question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>This question is motivated by <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/98067/does-natural-unit-of-information-and-entropy-nat-play-special-role-in-the-free">this one</a>.</p> <p>Suppose $l$ is the minimum measurable unit of length. What is entropy of a spinless particle contained in this interval?</p> <p>We know that entropy of a two-level system depends on the probabilities of the respective levels, if the probability of the state 0 is $p_0$, then the entropy (in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nat_%28information%29" rel="nofollow">natural units</a>) is:</p> <p>$$S= -\sum_{i=0}^1 p_i \ln p_i = -p_0 \ln p_0 - (1 - p_0) \ln (1 - p_0)$$</p> <p>So if $p_0=1/2$ then $S=\ln 2\: \mathrm{nat}$, equal to $1\: \mathrm{bit}$. A particle which has the maximum in the middle has entropy of $1\: \mathrm{bit}$ (it is equally likely to be measured to the right and to the left of the middle).</p> <p>Since we cannot measure intervals smaller than $l$, we cannot make guesses about where the maximum of the probability for the particle is located. As such, if we assume that the particle is equally likely have the maximum of the probability in any point on the interval $x\in[0,l]$, the total entropy becomes $$S=\int_0^l \frac{-(1-\frac xl) \ln (1- \frac xl)-\frac xl \ln (\frac xl)}{l} \, dx=\int_0^1 -(1-x) \ln (1-x)-x \ln (x) \, dx=\frac12$$</p> <p>An entropy of a similar particle contained in a square area with side $l$ will be twice more, that is $1\: \mathrm{nat}$.</p> <p>Now if we assume that $l=2l_p$ where $l_p$ is the Planck length, we arrive that such spinless particle has entropy of $1\: \mathrm{nat}$ per 4 square Planck length or $1/4\: \mathrm{nat}$ for one square Planck length.</p> <p>Thus from the only assumption that double Planck length is the minimum measurable interval, and double Planck length squared is expected to contain 1 particle on average we arrive at the standard value of the Black Hole entropy in nats:</p> <p>$$S=\frac{A}{4l_p^2}=\frac14 A_p$$</p> <p>Where $A_p$ is the area in Planck units.</p> <p>Sometimes I encountered a claim that the fundamental unit of information is 1 bit. From the above considerations it follows that possibly the fundamental unit is 1/2 (or 1 or 1/4) nat.</p> <p><strong>UPDATE</strong></p> <p>Note that the distance of $2l_p$ between two particles is natural if we assume that the particles are <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_particle" rel="nofollow">planckons</a>, whose radius is Planck length $l_p$. Thus densely packed planckons will have average distance exactly $2l_p$.As such, the Black Hole can be viewed as a spherical shell consisting of one layer of planckons.</p>
g6565
[ -0.011858668178319931, -0.0014222076861187816, -0.0028681261464953423, -0.04275841638445854, -0.003935459069907665, 0.02606487274169922, -0.016299856826663017, 0.008725139312446117, -0.038787197321653366, -0.0040414100512862206, -0.002452622167766094, 0.013704751618206501, -0.0103661073371768, -0.05522371828556061, -0.03265705704689026, 0.025138545781373978, 0.03518754243850708, -0.00945589691400528, 0.04735264182090759, 0.007192669436335564, -0.018213722854852676, -0.00334173534065485, 0.0026201556902378798, -0.06582849472761154, -0.0434139110147953, -0.04816526919603348, 0.04864729940891266, 0.013881961815059185, -0.10194630175828934, -0.0027941609732806683, 0.014686131849884987, -0.027985313907265663, 0.04526232182979584, -0.06703536957502365, -0.09296846389770508, -0.011958976276218891, 0.01951402612030506, 0.03841664269566536, 0.010345221497118473, 0.015293908305466175, 0.0294228196144104, -0.07276539504528046, -0.03650683909654617, -0.04164859652519226, 0.006060644052922726, 0.058359287679195404, 0.03910638019442558, 0.046082232147455215, 0.04508737102150917, -0.030442673712968826, -0.014710544608533382, 0.04707849770784378, 0.03306059539318085, 0.05969756096601486, 0.04373937100172043, 0.07807303965091705, -0.0002037632220890373, -0.009639575146138668, 0.03532995656132698, 0.06090272217988968, 0.057194922119379044, 0.0015069935470819473, -0.016264930367469788, -0.010293823666870594, 0.02605968527495861, 0.06829704344272614, -0.018438559025526047, 0.021077267825603485, -0.050529297441244125, -0.013740459457039833, -0.018256034702062607, -0.04117431119084358, -0.023786943405866623, -0.02518763393163681, 0.026058819144964218, 0.05157959833741188, 0.026380440220236778, 0.06575015932321548, -0.0007793005206622183, 0.030395468696951866, -0.022885886952280998, 0.0068789091892540455, 0.03344487398862839, -0.004398750606924295, 0.011459867469966412, 0.03935881331562996, -0.024477114900946617, -0.07230806350708008, -0.008055314421653748, 0.1130194291472435, -0.023416059091687202, -0.027357010170817375, 0.046060338616371155, -0.013577102683484554, 0.022899838164448738, 0.03928167000412941, -0.006123116705566645, -0.027940990403294563, -0.036425888538360596, 0.04852830618619919, -0.037371039390563965, 0.016637898981571198, 0.020205961540341377, -0.005800474435091019, 0.006803634576499462, -0.04128248617053032, -0.016078626736998558, -0.0016929993871599436, -0.0033522541634738445, -0.008540884591639042, 0.031292591243982315, -0.006244249176234007, 0.00939192809164524, 0.018876265734434128, -0.025561954826116562, 0.04630356281995773, 0.09806008636951447, -0.010785105638206005, -0.026793746277689934, 0.044923946261405945, -0.016682930290699005, 0.013801192864775658, 0.05657515302300453, 0.03911972418427467, 0.009605852887034416, -0.0128095131367445, 0.0030675700400024652, 0.009341158904135227, -0.01770937629044056, -0.01778976432979107, -0.005578458309173584, -0.0064979963935911655, -0.07187063246965408, 0.029295623302459717, -0.08616185933351517, 0.06264159083366394, -0.02359975315630436, 0.023268606513738632, -0.006414102390408516, -0.03268524259328842, -0.09929715096950531, -0.028603777289390564, 0.008090279065072536, -0.017660092562437057, 0.01597593165934086, 0.003141143824905157, 0.02369781583547592, -0.06922277063131332, -0.014998511411249638, -0.005200703162699938, -0.043954506516456604, 0.0658428743481636, 0.0019412634428590536, 0.0032602425199002028, -0.01815389283001423, 0.007565522566437721, 0.03955067694187164, 0.04296700656414032, -0.008688663132488728, 0.022485116496682167, 0.020517772063612938, -0.0027599330060184, 0.03913901373744011, 0.021381739526987076, -0.05268188193440437, 0.02904214896261692, 0.00924746785312891, -0.08217833936214447, 0.008642347529530525, -0.06192900985479355, 0.004712130408734083, -0.00031088016112335026, -0.025212302803993225, 0.04126311093568802, -0.04771164432168007, -0.025427859276533127, 0.004104644525796175, 0.03717970848083496, 0.013431292958557606, 0.006670188624411821, -0.027392162010073662, 0.018950950354337692, 0.060688409954309464, -0.009029447101056576, -0.026090282946825027, -0.018397610634565353, 0.014097540639340878, 0.05440215766429901, 0.007898946292698383, -0.016138916835188866, -0.04307026043534279, -0.004535543732345104, 0.0020997896790504456, 0.07634086906909943, 0.026279401034116745, 0.008278550580143929, -0.008293595165014267, -0.082283154129982, 0.0010019518667832017, -0.033110298216342926, 0.0005877829389646649, -0.013115971349179745, 0.02683858573436737, -0.021096179261803627, 0.05142426863312721, 0.007585369981825352, 0.012648534961044788, 0.023415911942720413, -0.0115473298355937, 0.023425687104463577, 0.028545532375574112, -0.052609678357839584, -0.023330802097916603, 0.03357481211423874, 0.014618116430938244, -0.05923113599419594, -0.030739396810531616, 0.00188696407712996, 0.020537573844194412, -0.05734798684716225, -0.012902704067528248, 0.01294776052236557, 0.04068166762590408, -0.05306531861424446, 0.021786946803331375, 0.006703777238726616, -0.005418781656771898, -0.025692179799079895, -0.026980435475707054, 0.0838041752576828, -0.07997819781303406, -0.0054773292504251, -0.003922746516764164, 0.02871236391365528, 0.0059804669581353664, 0.09632179141044617, -0.004060904961079359, -0.006629770155996084, 0.03166813775897026, -0.020927421748638153, 0.05399823188781738, -0.005062735173851252, -0.06315925717353821, 0.027911853045225143, -0.02095547877252102, -0.01311118621379137, -0.04974130541086197, -0.022983184084296227, -0.035411641001701355, 0.03851597383618355, -0.029949843883514404, -0.010562059469521046, 0.026231395080685616, -0.0022154455073177814, 0.02703595720231533, 0.010300857946276665, 0.03604473918676376, -0.0022348451893776655, -0.06707386672496796, -0.04480336606502533, 0.027246788144111633, -0.007275603245943785, -0.00456221541389823, 0.02510124444961548, -0.001376084634102881, -0.006296003703027964, -0.081956647336483, 0.06888855248689651, 0.008973555639386177, 0.04092627763748169, 0.06832544505596161, 0.07416900992393494, -0.025011330842971802, -0.005778636317700148, 0.05327889323234558, 0.04722107574343681, 0.023153213784098625, 0.03328639641404152, 0.003690491896122694, -0.028714120388031006, -0.03795921057462692, 0.04153755307197571, -0.049417462199926376, 0.009960254654288292, 0.05534054711461067, -0.0612611249089241, 0.012529222294688225, 0.03405183181166649, 0.023806855082511902, 0.04126688838005066, 0.005034979898482561, 0.027097104117274284, 0.043531857430934906, 0.03158773481845856, 0.031500525772571564, 0.006110654678195715, 0.00934686977416277, -0.0031717075034976006, 0.02288566343486309, 0.008429980836808681, -0.034796807914972305, -0.02824118360877037, -0.0205227080732584, -0.04046808183193207, 0.0031330811325460672, 0.0005987787735648453, -0.06081083416938782, -0.012451929040253162, -0.001593979075551033, 0.008658180944621563, -0.0018640446942299604, 0.06883527338504791, 0.04616697132587433, 0.013120457530021667, -0.046236325055360794, 0.00042236148146912456, -0.004536725580692291, 0.020241694524884224, -0.024189677089452744, -0.022226419299840927, 0.07389941066503525, -0.043126869946718216, 0.012251167558133602, -0.0003568998072296381, 0.02041204273700714, -0.05573341250419617, -0.04445192217826843, -0.008946914225816727, -0.08893009275197983, 0.026384981349110603, 0.028522146865725517, -0.07121642678976059, 0.019485756754875183, 0.011176343075931072, -0.041849009692668915, -0.06729700416326523, -0.03262168541550636, -0.007135828025639057, 0.02312019281089306, 0.01171866711229086, 0.04389715939760208, -0.014002731069922447, -0.06025322899222374, 0.00029411897412501276, -0.033744312822818756, 0.004825463984161615, -0.030409662052989006, -0.05950203537940979, -0.017407342791557312, 0.003039150033146143, 0.01713440753519535, 0.01838439330458641, 0.010051227174699306, -0.035409070551395416, 0.019740818068385124, 0.023136749863624573, 0.03336469456553459, 0.0003833149094134569, 0.056873153895139694, -0.02134694717824459, 0.02730228193104267, -0.054347991943359375, 0.03318333625793457, -0.04147109016776085, -0.04619598388671875, -0.02057727612555027, 0.020605018362402916, -0.004718819633126259, 0.0646333396434784, -0.009193725883960724, -0.047947466373443604, -0.044939860701560974, 0.0018187311943620443, 0.010182752273976803, -0.020763486623764038, -0.02614372968673706, -0.013173405081033707, 0.026957383379340172, -0.06965377181768417, 0.005428624805063009, -0.004572340287268162, -0.034850042313337326, -0.0066488939337432384, -0.01869058795273304, 0.024832557886838913, -0.013426225632429123, -0.022752180695533752, -0.02801818959414959, 0.003443499095737934, -0.05085885897278786, -0.03273897245526314, -0.009195287711918354, -0.020175524055957794, 0.01528182066977024, -0.015373039059340954, -0.027150385081768036, 0.0743941217660904, 0.012688015587627888, 0.038241997361183167, 0.04933120310306549, 0.041765280067920685, -0.02400200068950653, -0.004276009742170572, -0.023998672142624855, 0.008828701451420784, -0.05303068459033966, -0.009433025494217873, -0.014325018972158432, 0.0025312199722975492, 0.0033925045281648636, 0.00767078110948205, 0.03403586149215698, 0.034055713564157486, -0.019484588876366615, -0.004417638760060072, 0.01404076348990202, -0.05163261294364929, -0.05713082104921341, -0.0028001489117741585, 0.023562263697385788, -0.006279383320361376, -0.01862100139260292, 0.03640659525990486, -0.004718286916613579, -0.07190325111150742, -0.03351288661360741, 0.0623859241604805, 0.048748794943094254, -0.03595514968037605, -0.011432983912527561, 0.03136969357728958, 0.02855500392615795, 0.015504168346524239, 0.056420426815748215, -0.040832847356796265, 0.05171717703342438, -0.047285690903663635, 0.0015629385598003864, -0.021793285384774208, 0.011810222640633583, 0.01888442598283291, -0.006919222883880138, 0.005941588897258043, -0.02933209203183651, 0.013620859012007713, -0.008961980231106281, 0.03450607508420944, 0.0006655663019046187, -0.009236695244908333, -0.016783546656370163, 0.07191547751426697, -0.014773346483707428, -0.008050914853811264, -0.08410331606864929, 0.031021542847156525, 0.0041891722939908504, -0.05826304107904434, 0.06337659806013107, 0.02505607157945633, -0.011984258890151978, -0.008367902599275112, 0.02353844605386257, -0.020079972222447395, 0.019048746675252914, -0.015202442184090614, -0.06324344873428345, -0.09114973992109299, 0.03041655756533146, -0.026802003383636475, -0.010379606857895851, 0.0409385971724987, -0.002878789324313402, 0.025996487587690353, 0.00937292817980051, 0.00802966021001339, 0.029130304232239723, -0.027382193133234978, -0.018921544775366783, -0.04357144981622696, 0.0036287622060626745, -0.030766645446419716, -0.025423331186175346, -0.004950425121933222, 0.05609649792313576, 0.028275737538933754, 0.021851086989045143, -0.013142186217010021, 0.011069719679653645, 0.018659083172678947, 0.013699712231755257, 0.02478046528995037, -0.008860534988343716, 0.07541979104280472, 0.015327566303312778, -0.062108322978019714, -0.051382604986429214, 0.0022463351488113403, -0.046599652618169785, 0.05256780982017517, 0.012567860074341297, -0.07074207812547684, 0.03617525100708008, 0.04954718053340912, 0.040459733456373215, -0.03994916379451752, -0.01727192848920822, -0.016238370910286903, 0.024399390444159508, -0.038262706249952316, 0.03845643624663353, 0.0533330924808979, -0.011003549210727215, -0.04392634332180023, -0.03010956197977066, -0.025842277333140373, -0.05135975033044815, 0.05257172882556915, 0.03981932997703552, -0.03574632480740547, 0.00124175357632339, 0.0020814130548387766, -0.01713935099542141, 0.07305597513914108, -0.03327358886599541, 0.06028631702065468, -0.021071286872029305, -0.06489615142345428, -0.003541037905961275, 0.017977431416511536, 0.04757220298051834, 0.00000863529112393735, 0.0024938685819506645, -0.012734230607748032, -0.016085278242826462, 0.0037449286319315434, -0.0018208591500297189, -0.004471481777727604, 0.01624923199415207, 0.054840248078107834, -0.02376575581729412, 0.0041801659390330315, -0.10316065698862076, -0.018609749153256416, 0.04733826965093613, -0.022233132272958755, -0.03217475861310959, -0.03781387582421303, -0.017738500609993935, -0.000319356273394078, 0.00480313366279006, 0.016451874747872353, -0.008422750048339367, -0.009540288709104061, -0.021094240248203278, 0.01516502071171999, -0.02483137883245945, 0.023563917726278305, 0.03312384709715843, -0.0036999424919486046, 0.0019762986339628696, -0.00512703275308013, -0.00943891890347004, 0.010909494943916798, 0.09553182125091553, 0.010355539619922638, -0.03429582715034485, -0.00411548838019371, -0.05451171100139618, 0.02716781012713909, 0.0649794340133667, -0.05441029369831085, 0.0443757101893425, -0.011948484927415848, 0.012226374819874763, 0.047670137137174606, -0.016093267127871513, -0.005568249151110649, -0.04461686685681343, -0.04000527039170265, -0.0012842795113101602, -0.05674025043845177, -0.00876103900372982, 0.002419519703835249, -0.029436083510518074, 0.005831521935760975, 0.05919766053557396, 0.00681036151945591, 0.006632767617702484, -0.02272629365324974, 0.028875743970274925, -0.0030262276995927095, -0.034148335456848145, -0.01668969914317131, 0.0025909419637173414, -0.0006133628776296973, -0.04441693425178528, -0.01525577437132597, -0.12133537232875824, -0.012097170576453209, 0.010302537120878696, -0.055584315210580826, -0.03780830651521683, 0.021136190742254257, -0.026292361319065094, 0.0003525822830852121, 0.07689078897237778, -0.05881835147738457, 0.02897033840417862, -0.0005710230907425284, 0.06334683299064636, -0.013571702875196934, 0.011105185374617577, -0.031018568202853203, 0.009042423218488693, -0.03027765452861786, -0.03218860924243927, -0.021918704733252525, -0.03537939116358757, -0.04566404968500137, 0.045187029987573624, 0.03703200817108154, 0.05244065076112747, -0.05465736240148544, -0.07436849921941757, 0.02196367084980011, 0.05238987132906914, 0.027149902656674385, 0.02780393324792385, 0.034562744200229645, 0.04875054210424423, 0.04122721403837204, 0.038423892110586166, -0.004215418826788664, 0.07933186739683151, 0.0005685377400368452, -0.015699025243520737, -0.048747722059488297, 0.016100311651825905, 0.03826144337654114, 0.04718773812055588, 0.022611483931541443, -0.06707990914583206, 0.035845011472702026, 0.043486036360263824, -0.013014407828450203, -0.01861993782222271, 0.060275282710790634, 0.07189495861530304, -0.050075337290763855, 0.03170715644955635, 0.0015755569329485297, 0.0033572607208043337, 0.018025292083621025, -0.020814675837755203, -0.023801391944289207, 0.022332051768898964, 0.01432125922292471, 0.012192814610898495, 0.02838299423456192, 0.0006884678150527179, 0.008444092236459255, -0.062499821186065674, 0.015364366583526134, -0.013744755648076534, -0.003450754564255476, 0.04239944368600845, 0.028754184022545815, -0.035240188241004944, 0.001299117924645543, -0.11406167596578598, 0.0024344732519239187, -0.03435933589935303, -0.02040942758321762, -0.0011022157268598676, -0.03674808144569397, -0.0129244988784194, -0.001483555999584496, 0.03880936652421951, -0.01402655802667141, 0.001355677959509194, 0.06424587219953537, 0.017906518653035164, 0.021538199856877327, -0.04980235546827316, -0.04638631269335747, 0.057917892932891846, -0.07046423852443695, 0.03780409321188927, 0.07152534276247025, 0.006026605609804392, 0.01153072901070118, 0.0161600299179554, 0.024679729714989662, -0.014437411911785603, -0.062009863555431366, 0.016340527683496475, 0.05510659143328667, 0.0495266355574131, 0.033602531999349594, -0.07048390060663223, 0.018663454800844193, -0.034437019377946854, -0.039197541773319244, -0.03383539617061615, 0.0487167164683342, 0.042398788034915924, 0.0362812876701355, 0.0217746552079916, -0.04045707359910011, -0.0025085394736379385, 0.014310565777122974, -0.018450845032930374, 0.011498533189296722, 0.022397682070732117, -0.025639716535806656, -0.0039162361063063145, 0.02568363957107067, 0.03600830212235451, -0.003215576522052288, -0.022862644866108894, -0.019550936296582222, -0.040379978716373444, -0.07485463470220566, -0.010716989636421204, -0.018073532730340958, -0.04453106224536896, 0.00010039014887297526, 0.00314456969499588, -0.010084313340485096, 0.012804213911294937, 0.03517606854438782, -0.027502533048391342, -0.027442896738648415, -0.02856305055320263, -0.034497860819101334, 0.0278177373111248, 0.006788068450987339, 0.06075335666537285, -0.018217001110315323, 0.01855297200381756, -0.006047092378139496, -0.033451687544584274, 0.05459240823984146, -0.029517341405153275, -0.05658860504627228, -0.028248364105820656, -0.04302415996789932, 0.04829858988523483, 0.02031630091369152, -0.038872841745615005, -0.03500497713685036, -0.029005147516727448, 0.04190312325954437, 0.051222652196884155, 0.04250243306159973, -0.05504221096634865, 0.013799615204334259, -0.018919698894023895, -0.022662773728370667, 0.029698872938752174, 0.002849409356713295, -0.012306595221161842, 0.036472927778959274, 0.035609010607004166, 0.04533863067626953, 0.007321142591536045, 0.04130443185567856, 0.054543398320674896 ]
<p>Let's say you are in the air 500 meters above flat land and you have no parachute. Which pose - forming a sphere or spreading all extremities to make yourself as wide as possible or other - is the most appropriate to cause the highest likelihood of survival?</p> <ol> <li>in the air</li> <li>right before impact</li> </ol> <p>In other words: which body position causes the least amount of negative acceleration in this context?</p> <p>PS: As a side-question: Which body position enables you to control the direction of flight to control your angle of impact and make it as flat as possible?</p> <p>My take: In the air make yourself as wide as possible and control direction by weight displacement. Right before impact, form a sphere when having a flat angle of impact and let rolling take care of the change of kinetic energy into heat and potential energy.</p>
g6566
[ 0.0497555173933506, -0.0018036181572824717, 0.01416975911706686, 0.07240008562803268, -0.02619618922472, 0.10251514613628387, 0.05637890100479126, 0.030891869217157364, -0.007037334144115448, -0.026965707540512085, 0.046179529279470444, -0.08559069782495499, 0.007867990992963314, 0.004873002879321575, 0.014859163202345371, 0.02048773132264614, 0.05022422596812248, -0.07712813466787338, 0.026353955268859863, -0.011842545121908188, -0.01879754103720188, -0.08314163982868195, -0.05102413520216942, 0.012978178448975086, -0.03553874045610428, -0.01499680895358324, -0.015996068716049194, 0.0116707319393754, -0.05667022243142128, -0.0102401003241539, 0.06458411365747452, 0.03121383860707283, 0.02819884940981865, -0.02353961206972599, -0.036071039736270905, -0.04116901382803917, -0.00463457964360714, 0.04854073002934456, -0.04006224498152733, -0.05281394347548485, -0.022511381655931473, -0.07866515219211578, -0.013567001558840275, 0.031027117744088173, -0.019734608009457588, -0.00955598708242178, 0.021545622497797012, 0.007974423468112946, 0.0200418122112751, -0.027454650029540062, -0.014804370701313019, 0.005832915659993887, -0.037711285054683685, -0.08273112028837204, 0.04754967242479324, 0.02066756971180439, 0.01980455033481121, -0.021458689123392105, -0.031249037012457848, -0.026382312178611755, -0.03160214424133301, 0.0025340321008116007, -0.05457454174757004, -0.0016749161295592785, 0.04965348541736603, 0.004855522885918617, -0.08180177211761475, 0.024648290127515793, 0.024758797138929367, -0.02081371657550335, 0.039338838309049606, -0.03936779499053955, -0.07708004862070084, -0.010130831971764565, -0.024778539314866066, 0.01716822199523449, -0.030261943116784096, 0.003519985591992736, 0.05603263899683952, 0.008894788101315498, 0.005429134238511324, 0.02188737690448761, 0.030645495280623436, -0.057559046894311905, 0.07511170953512192, -0.013407249934971333, 0.016325538977980614, -0.042733434587717056, 0.006320504005998373, 0.025755304843187332, 0.07122421264648438, 0.049600787460803986, 0.06730025261640549, 0.01938120648264885, -0.05862103030085564, 0.06589538604021072, -0.005883593577891588, 0.08707049489021301, -0.012139949016273022, 0.02363751269876957, 0.003223268548026681, -0.024173587560653687, -0.026454372331500053, 0.012336667627096176, -0.02371259778738022, -0.011033237911760807, 0.047536760568618774, -0.05279838666319847, 0.04775596410036087, -0.025681478902697563, -0.024823034182190895, 0.026289278641343117, -0.06525079160928726, -0.028635133057832718, -0.0608515702188015, -0.0534968301653862, 0.03925898298621178, 0.017552601173520088, 0.007482349872589111, 0.07733135670423508, -0.04316744580864906, 0.036454953253269196, 0.031853508204221725, 0.01823415420949459, -0.03849301487207413, -0.037784330546855927, -0.04469578340649605, 0.011076529510319233, 0.03324378281831741, -0.0043521481566131115, -0.010267007164657116, -0.015101022087037563, -0.08081478625535965, 0.008503710851073265, -0.03287177532911301, 0.04178466647863388, -0.058411385864019394, -0.0019499931950122118, 0.025414060801267624, -0.007339110132306814, 0.0032534198835492134, 0.015068951062858105, 0.03433430567383766, -0.051824480295181274, -0.030307533219456673, 0.009798090904951096, 0.022861281409859657, 0.01311176735907793, -0.016329053789377213, 0.06807571649551392, -0.007847004570066929, 0.021217070519924164, -0.011904717423021793, -0.060799822211265564, 0.012830480933189392, 0.023394348099827766, -0.0009300698875449598, 0.03374503180384636, 0.027099426835775375, -0.0071009378880262375, 0.06935392320156097, 0.00986646767705679, -0.016193941235542297, 0.018602728843688965, -0.03154849261045456, -0.012936060316860676, -0.052490897476673126, -0.048979662358760834, -0.0016678994288668036, -0.0029323820490390062, -0.06020757183432579, -0.08913038671016693, 0.02864409051835537, 0.02001042291522026, 0.006173871457576752, -0.01313643716275692, 0.016893256455659866, -0.06592638790607452, 0.011442870832979679, 0.00995752215385437, 0.04166325181722641, -0.010966497473418713, 0.013322198763489723, 0.019624020904302597, -0.003991350531578064, -0.029433341696858406, 0.06624647974967957, 0.06250591576099396, -0.08646345883607864, -0.023694217205047607, 0.013360850512981415, -0.04504769295454025, -0.03290442004799843, -0.038247641175985336, -0.060084667056798935, -0.02421826869249344, 0.11414328962564468, 0.01861577294766903, -0.059236329048871994, 0.05357429012656212, 0.022987043485045433, 0.024969059973955154, 0.020434390753507614, -0.009053121320903301, -0.07360437512397766, 0.0473954975605011, 0.049995556473731995, -0.008703419007360935, 0.03790508210659027, -0.009262384846806526, 0.05441468209028244, -0.008801141753792763, 0.04245665296912193, -0.019774217158555984, 0.04189961403608322, 0.06354058533906937, -0.025106878951191902, -0.0041849189437925816, -0.018612664192914963, -0.026754125952720642, -0.003467220114544034, 0.02770380675792694, -0.025089653208851814, -0.030174585059285164, -0.02745445817708969, 0.03901992738246918, -0.023589633405208588, -0.04524599015712738, 0.047769784927368164, -0.05262349545955658, -0.0562048964202404, 0.017870478332042694, 0.024540521204471588, -0.03827456384897232, 0.023973889648914337, 0.014331940561532974, 0.03963720425963402, 0.0874953344464302, 0.013666260056197643, -0.017438651993870735, 0.021950991824269295, -0.0006787439342588186, -0.03738872706890106, -0.02374553307890892, 0.04103376343846321, -0.006830888334661722, -0.013889681547880173, -0.005461995955556631, -0.0032346865627914667, 0.03950680047273636, -0.012188615277409554, 0.014165750704705715, -0.061438098549842834, -0.06578077375888824, -0.0038610331248492002, 0.00000804746650828747, -0.06581953912973404, 0.034606631845235825, -0.0364118367433548, -0.005603226367384195, 0.012950804084539413, -0.007464236579835415, -0.005029425956308842, -0.014018040150403976, -0.10557308793067932, 0.06591266393661499, -0.06481259316205978, 0.013801285065710545, -0.001569755026139319, 0.033434052020311356, -0.018724914640188217, 0.009264783933758736, -0.0751831978559494, 0.07262774556875229, -0.015538291074335575, -0.042824048548936844, -0.03390584886074066, 0.0015976266004145145, -0.04630206152796745, 0.00685438746586442, 0.032467070966959, -0.005610711872577667, 0.0026453298050910234, 0.03580135852098465, 0.07639278471469879, 0.016823992133140564, 0.009850540198385715, 0.014205120503902435, -0.03831211104989052, 0.02191382460296154, -0.002261499175801873, -0.022201556712388992, 0.052689362317323685, 0.00853849295526743, 0.015811733901500702, 0.04905523359775543, 0.017082005739212036, -0.033761877566576004, -0.03477559611201286, -0.019474918022751808, -0.01715073361992836, -0.009179641492664814, 0.030863875523209572, 0.013783392496407032, 0.01516159251332283, 0.04969862103462219, -0.000472394865937531, -0.03699646517634392, 0.03445184603333473, -0.032564349472522736, -0.037327904254198074, 0.04794105887413025, -0.03697612136602402, 0.04988742247223854, -0.0543743260204792, 0.0069892518222332, -0.06266210228204727, -0.02625194564461708, -0.010938312858343124, -0.05744641274213791, 0.01586359553039074, -0.027936888858675957, -0.00006412260700017214, 0.015578767284750938, 0.019271450117230415, 0.053604502230882645, -0.0005084263975732028, 0.05177387595176697, 0.03149263560771942, -0.055297378450632095, 0.030337480828166008, 0.051251184195280075, -0.005923244170844555, -0.0033794818446040154, -0.023682940751314163, -0.04519261419773102, -0.011939379386603832, 0.006356572266668081, 0.033727604895830154, 0.028634360060095787, -0.004738355055451393, -0.011431192979216576, -0.014730623923242092, -0.029796652495861053, 0.0466645322740078, -0.004391322378069162, 0.034047383815050125, 0.009646713733673096, 0.004968360066413879, 0.012603608891367912, 0.04092804342508316, -0.020659437403082848, -0.0392388217151165, -0.02959747053682804, 0.03297223895788193, 0.017751473933458328, -0.011923471465706825, 0.033999841660261154, -0.02627008780837059, 0.005288342013955116, -0.04864876717329025, -0.02645963616669178, -0.01096956804394722, -0.011946422979235649, 0.018166042864322662, -0.021904954686760902, -0.061918433755636215, 0.00665875943377614, -0.0429893434047699, 0.056626856327056885, 0.011515781283378601, -0.031022047623991966, -0.009542997926473618, -0.04445508122444153, 0.06165606528520584, 0.028980428352952003, 0.02369060553610325, -0.010557967238128185, -0.022595664486289024, -0.011859696358442307, 0.05222320929169655, 0.0075411684811115265, -0.011463498696684837, 0.015048238448798656, -0.014903769828379154, 0.03268193453550339, -0.036529168486595154, -0.054284002631902695, 0.021900584921240807, -0.0027484321035444736, -0.028109116479754448, -0.09532409906387329, -0.007938504219055176, 0.014501462690532207, 0.051912058144807816, 0.055865559726953506, -0.009335861541330814, -0.002335631288588047, -0.022570407018065453, 0.06843292713165283, 0.03398289158940315, 0.02645665965974331, -0.0273892879486084, 0.03792779892683029, 0.0118833864107728, 0.02263486757874489, 0.029020877555012703, -0.0011634078109636903, -0.04154953360557556, -0.016794215887784958, 0.12636558711528778, 0.07089893519878387, -0.07819104194641113, -0.0703837051987648, 0.031059397384524345, -0.03312051668763161, 0.0027898577973246574, 0.018408460542559624, 0.04555051773786545, 0.05757305026054382, 0.03793545439839363, 0.030657704919576645, 0.0011599266435950994, -0.03633803874254227, 0.043503958731889725, 0.007941825315356255, 0.046969857066869736, -0.025905588641762733, -0.016382094472646713, 0.045547932386398315, -0.02791162207722664, 0.02032863162457943, 0.027555139735341072, -0.01945766806602478, -0.031090250238776207, 0.006295764818787575, 0.015843290835618973, -0.0014961689012125134, 0.062394674867391586, 0.020084938034415245, 0.029557975009083748, -0.0012835427187383175, -0.00818448793143034, -0.02719801291823387, 0.012978366576135159, 0.047676146030426025, -0.006489206105470657, -0.042372480034828186, 0.033226702362298965, -0.025579269975423813, -0.010459855198860168, -0.0282388087362051, 0.07040190696716309, -0.028142733499407768, -0.08270979672670364, -0.01728961057960987, -0.031901683658361435, -0.02291431836783886, 0.008392659947276115, -0.011723607778549194, 0.020980987697839737, 0.010021926835179329, -0.014642092399299145, 0.0020107016898691654, 0.018401790410280228, 0.04716944694519043, -0.06314685940742493, -0.017757542431354523, -0.03044763021171093, 0.005448079667985439, -0.032886307686567307, 0.023116087540984154, 0.04056005924940109, 0.02999473363161087, -0.019092170521616936, 0.05819534510374069, 0.0013183667324483395, -0.015941038727760315, 0.015426499769091606, 0.015471012331545353, 0.011990266852080822, 0.006365017965435982, -0.03994673863053322, -0.0556500218808651, 0.02598312310874462, 0.022775741294026375, 0.009513110853731632, -0.02945847436785698, 0.0849001333117485, -0.00633499538525939, 0.04220401123166084, -0.01635548286139965, -0.04631790891289711, -0.019669268280267715, -0.03511616960167885, 0.032231107354164124, 0.011143060401082039, -0.0062594665214419365, 0.015357177704572678, 0.0035127277951687574, -0.056887030601501465, -0.031880903989076614, 0.05178460478782654, -0.021056869998574257, -0.07448320090770721, -0.04262133687734604, 0.05893661081790924, 0.002821783535182476, 0.037042710930109024, 0.014765306375920773, -0.05292825400829315, 0.03348582237958908, -0.013666260987520218, -0.011384449899196625, -0.01312472578138113, -0.012812872417271137, -0.01256791315972805, 0.03229324519634247, -0.025710515677928925, 0.007646930869668722, 0.04976706951856613, -0.03893076628446579, 0.029674703255295753, 0.023003071546554565, 0.07833162695169449, -0.022680005058646202, -0.011423608288168907, -0.014248576015233994, -0.003919420298188925, -0.005294543690979481, 0.021686693653464317, 0.016612984240055084, -0.0008830731967464089, -0.021632125601172447, -0.04920700192451477, -0.038883570581674576, -0.025081925094127655, 0.042500026524066925, 0.011622206307947636, -0.04146106168627739, -0.05638968199491501, -0.010934622026979923, -0.0006258853827603161, 0.07524778693914413, -0.0666854977607727, 0.0039630769751966, -0.09620301425457001, 0.02433944307267666, -0.009872917085886002, -0.02255753055214882, -0.002830059267580509, 0.050022903829813004, -0.004822711925953627, -0.005415199790149927, 0.018890060484409332, 0.011473697610199451, -0.03921780735254288, 0.03234250470995903, -0.006445617880672216, -0.06222547963261604, -0.010412653908133507, 0.007751794066280127, 0.047794561833143234, 0.04193281754851341, 0.018004806712269783, -0.026224521920084953, -0.009235826320946217, -0.0437566302716732, 0.016774721443653107, 0.0300400722771883, 0.011696730740368366, -0.06273724883794785, 0.06214920058846474, 0.06523896008729935, 0.01875246688723564, -0.016785746440291405, 0.039240770041942596, -0.00451439106836915, -0.03490697592496872, 0.04935983568429947, -0.040138788521289825, -0.02339617721736431, 0.03820774704217911, -0.05941757559776306, -0.020927589386701584, 0.02657376043498516, -0.02569534257054329, 0.023739686235785484, -0.019233331084251404, -0.04601823166012764, -0.0032659873832017183, 0.004148463718593121, -0.013534518890082836, 0.03035159781575203, -0.06337036192417145, -0.04614681750535965, -0.026151614263653755, -0.004655772354453802, -0.06981692463159561, 0.012493983842432499, 0.02599053457379341, -0.014719988219439983, 0.04017876833677292, 0.021526340395212173, 0.02076851762831211, 0.049010951071977615, 0.02707529440522194, 0.017398826777935028, 0.011199641041457653, -0.02834368869662285, -0.02725624106824398, 0.0508401021361351, 0.022461116313934326, 0.012338778004050255, -0.024150267243385315, 0.016550827771425247, 0.014274394139647484, -0.012407476082444191, 0.018881645053625107, -0.025422286242246628, -0.05089377984404564, -0.02529272250831127, 0.0023896852508187294, -0.003309190971776843, -0.03181038796901703, -0.03381909430027008, -0.015826161950826645, 0.036844607442617416, -0.03815505653619766, 0.03569662943482399, 0.010640828870236874, 0.035329148173332214, -0.03640207648277283, 0.08702614903450012, -0.024436337873339653, 0.02518729493021965, 0.013672985136508942, 0.0169568732380867, 0.038723599165678024, 0.02439759112894535, 0.004264723509550095, 0.03842185065150261, -0.03858485445380211, 0.02861488237977028, -0.039695654064416885, 0.01071926299482584, 0.012357918545603752, -0.036303307861089706, 0.013326781801879406, -0.001642924384213984, -0.0017054418567568064, -0.03095283731818199, -0.016901925206184387, -0.03128804266452789, 0.02913830056786537, 0.03062969073653221, 0.027561243623495102, 0.001139824278652668, -0.013480732217431068, -0.047572970390319824, -0.016345690935850143, 0.0050473324954509735, 0.0019252606434747577, 0.004020992666482925, -0.0506579615175724, 0.0015840455889701843, 0.023263420909643173, 0.013958025723695755, -0.054387565702199936, 0.02678721956908703, -0.009922180324792862, -0.006909860298037529, -0.056386351585388184, -0.052147574722766876, -0.00173956120852381, -0.0026769523974508047, 0.014715556986629963, -0.02307259663939476, -0.007453380152583122, 0.034942418336868286, -0.00000526266330780345, 0.013469577766954899, -0.03348352015018463, -0.006881410256028175, -0.018781354650855064, -0.01167876273393631, 0.009180127643048763, 0.02188868261873722, 0.0012178556062281132, -0.0610269270837307, -0.048541806638240814, 0.05284379422664642, -0.0042076073586940765, 0.021894173696637154, -0.04698847606778145, 0.02533811517059803, 0.03731342405080795, 0.06575693935155869, 0.0007762388559058309, 0.015098054893314838, -0.004288969561457634, -0.017821865156292915, 0.01214139349758625, 0.02755899168550968, 0.0299240630120039, 0.01264766976237297, 0.054955728352069855, 0.03029780089855194, -0.008998829871416092, 0.023205213248729706, 0.0731206089258194, 0.021618904545903206, 0.037704091519117355, 0.03985300287604332, -0.03435944765806198, 0.05336590111255646, -0.016088295727968216, 0.03679000586271286, 0.04813642054796219, 0.04799468442797661, 0.025242604315280914, 0.005017457064241171, -0.025556331500411034, -0.03532963618636131, -0.024488011375069618, -0.0662267729640007, -0.034318577498197556, 0.004763685632497072, 0.04222561791539192, -0.029661621898412704, -0.005673334002494812, -0.04073755815625191, -0.028519531711935997, 0.04566376656293869, 0.006036774720996618, -0.0235440731048584, -0.034035034477710724, 0.022699447348713875, -0.06899145245552063, 0.028835980221629143, -0.04896191507577896, 0.02396239899098873, -0.02566787227988243, -0.012461480684578419, -0.016068266704678535, -0.025316409766674042, 0.057749032974243164, 0.051959019154310226, 0.03763191029429436, 0.0018766530556604266, -0.013978669419884682, -0.039383795112371445, -0.0515136644244194, 0.0591123029589653, -0.01019927766174078, 0.028973327949643135, 0.008493153378367424, 0.015637481585144997, 0.022065460681915283, 0.036233119666576385, -0.03548150882124901, -0.023248225450515747, 0.06556595116853714, -0.059157419949769974, -0.03555990010499954, 0.005945480894297361, 0.014429100789129734, 0.021117478609085083 ]
<p>What is the formula we use to calculate average speed?</p>
g225
[ 0.013383958488702774, 0.02394086867570877, 0.0081877326592803, 0.0004150773456785828, 0.011494922451674938, -0.061225321143865585, 0.03784753009676933, 0.02163785696029663, -0.05675650015473366, 0.021979661658406258, 0.05486404895782471, 0.050048694014549255, 0.026717903092503548, 0.05141367390751839, -0.016534505411982536, 0.0047875456511974335, 0.021847136318683624, -0.01200187299400568, 0.025947922840714455, 0.05239279568195343, 0.004056544508785009, -0.01690637320280075, 0.02331233210861683, -0.04931186884641647, 0.0064070033840835094, -0.03968777880072594, -0.07005057483911514, -0.04855119809508324, -0.11007522791624069, 0.04001921787858009, 0.023093368858098984, -0.024322573095560074, -0.0018429899355396628, -0.03568665683269501, -0.03267042711377144, 0.010450809262692928, -0.0041023315861821175, -0.006172678433358669, 0.05358237028121948, -0.018456164747476578, 0.0017063752748072147, -0.048843976110219955, -0.00097432523034513, 0.027795391157269478, 0.0003401024150662124, -0.037250448018312454, -0.015538719482719898, -0.03375259414315224, -0.050073496997356415, 0.010927430354058743, -0.027244342491030693, 0.026313701644539833, 0.0379096195101738, -0.02077699638903141, -0.03778805583715439, 0.02677334100008011, 0.020457107573747635, -0.04352853074669838, -0.043600741773843765, 0.02740149013698101, -0.02344386838376522, -0.0591697134077549, 0.054825834929943085, 0.026853442192077637, 0.04542479291558266, -0.008656993508338928, 0.03121246211230755, -0.020285028964281082, 0.005683570634573698, -0.046749670058488846, -0.01355897355824709, -0.01711667887866497, 0.02539520151913166, -0.08406299352645874, -0.08562904596328735, -0.03918176889419556, 0.024010663852095604, -0.031875260174274445, 0.03262058645486832, 0.04526832327246666, 0.059836529195308685, -0.008101481013000011, -0.018450895324349403, 0.004375628661364317, -0.013391551561653614, -0.04027547314763069, -0.013154170475900173, 0.013238256797194481, 0.0007460188353434205, 0.00950547680258751, -0.000582973996642977, -0.029061926528811455, 0.033487237989902496, -0.011758904904127121, 0.0484653040766716, -0.05100934952497482, -0.026186572387814522, 0.0030326307751238346, -0.024094121530652046, 0.047914788126945496, -0.005103901959955692, 0.003445080714300275, 0.029398545622825623, -0.029144158586859703, 0.0052840388379991055, 0.012160147540271282, -0.027451403439044952, -0.013360932469367981, -0.036072541028261185, -0.05819833651185036, 0.014335586689412594, -0.022295242175459862, 0.011268455535173416, 0.007756796199828386, -0.006204981356859207, -0.08189599215984344, -0.012957116588950157, -0.019547488540410995, 0.014298714697360992, 0.00907090213149786, 0.04527098685503006, -0.005138660315424204, -0.05645567551255226, 0.03804602846503258, 0.022477177903056145, 0.01613950915634632, -0.016945049166679382, -0.042557504028081894, 0.026707302778959274, -0.012438267469406128, 0.01756337471306324, -0.019146107137203217, 0.016404524445533752, 0.04624135419726372, -0.05094704404473305, 0.040167711675167084, 0.0021071305964142084, 0.030290957540273666, 0.005670694634318352, 0.021368129178881645, -0.046599894762039185, -0.07784169912338257, 0.029321128502488136, 0.0003001310396939516, -0.035095855593681335, 0.037153616547584534, -0.05093363672494888, -0.04822239279747009, 0.010459997691214085, -0.0010315318359062076, 0.05522285774350166, 0.03498334437608719, 0.029887735843658447, 0.03424522653222084, -0.04549955949187279, -0.022941766306757927, -0.012754547409713268, 0.08009764552116394, 0.008066334761679173, 0.1025889441370964, 0.05819245055317879, -0.008274916559457779, -0.0389106422662735, 0.03101705200970173, -0.06947018951177597, 0.013712812215089798, 0.02544333040714264, -0.02151036635041237, -0.028122100979089737, -0.039145611226558685, 0.01460432168096304, 0.003434473183006048, 0.0012218471383675933, -0.002422741148620844, 0.005825178697705269, -0.015985876321792603, 0.05619943141937256, -0.013717351481318474, -0.00602327473461628, 0.03715191408991814, 0.026593133807182312, -0.004125933162868023, 0.06815329194068909, -0.06659522652626038, -0.06142869219183922, 0.012179169803857803, -0.02638465352356434, -0.052981678396463394, -0.08251743018627167, 0.014669899828732014, -0.004839309491217136, 0.015047448687255383, 0.02084164135158062, 0.03820808604359627, -0.012491635978221893, 0.010430998168885708, 0.051768507808446884, -0.02238016575574875, -0.006224325392395258, -0.006909339223057032, 0.037640128284692764, 0.03384259715676308, -0.000024982879040180705, -0.035343803465366364, 0.019309457391500473, -0.019437866285443306, -0.00966962892562151, 0.06565335392951965, 0.029078615829348564, 0.03834200277924538, 0.06464380025863647, 0.023379793390631676, -0.012910924851894379, 0.09363473951816559, 0.010988206602633, -0.007122314069420099, -0.010159320197999477, -0.018353795632719994, -0.022464852780103683, 0.01072603464126587, 0.018291335552930832, -0.01986943930387497, -0.04349201172590256, 0.0220631193369627, -0.04999315366148949, 0.006393044721335173, 0.0010217053350061178, 0.003758569248020649, 0.03839444741606712, 0.07968980073928833, 0.03192472830414772, -0.055822085589170456, -0.08271481841802597, 0.0015252565499395132, -0.06047537177801132, 0.0438556931912899, -0.007350774481892586, 0.029621321707963943, 0.014307740144431591, 0.06280237436294556, 0.057426102459430695, -0.024832624942064285, 0.009209845215082169, -0.0074062771163880825, -0.031568076461553574, -0.023274540901184082, 0.017083249986171722, -0.043679408729076385, -0.00007783532055327669, 0.0729622021317482, 0.011811337433755398, -0.019884241744875908, 0.009697988629341125, -0.0415998175740242, 0.017520109191536903, -0.028363121673464775, -0.023840727284550667, 0.012298977933824062, -0.04350138455629349, -0.036396414041519165, -0.02576827071607113, 0.09129169583320618, -0.005545640364289284, -0.04291567951440811, -0.018703756853938103, -0.04106771573424339, -0.006825402844697237, -0.010255216620862484, 0.007448718883097172, 0.02894064038991928, -0.011225789785385132, 0.02321462891995907, 0.003069587517529726, -0.0039075687527656555, 0.013895063661038876, -0.03900044038891792, 0.06152373179793358, -0.06819472461938858, 0.006466931663453579, 0.0034823990426957607, -0.028354445472359657, -0.011123674921691418, -0.021826425567269325, 0.024722397327423096, -0.020168228074908257, -0.08337585628032684, 0.09262565523386002, 0.04856390133500099, -0.0025372931268066168, 0.04733363911509514, -0.013726688921451569, -0.005038089584559202, -0.016836531460285187, 0.02733842097222805, 0.03684353828430176, 0.12670719623565674, 0.12831923365592957, -0.05413144454360008, 0.014151771552860737, -0.03979329392313957, 0.053827155381441116, -0.047473181039094925, -0.015199628658592701, -0.002706063212826848, -0.051315248012542725, 0.026966406032443047, 0.02317226305603981, -0.03202660754323006, 0.005444459617137909, 0.009477010928094387, -0.004579378291964531, 0.043495673686265945, 0.0063074384815990925, -0.012542449869215488, -0.05448399484157562, 0.01635020785033703, 0.024289023131132126, -0.010153361596167088, 0.02991846390068531, -0.00047810663818381727, 0.015438265167176723, -0.09136443585157394, -0.021177729591727257, -0.009460086934268475, -0.04349244385957718, 0.028238805010914803, 0.005461906082928181, 0.017633425071835518, 0.02391173504292965, -0.005895324982702732, 0.018570665270090103, 0.03229617327451706, -0.001707959221675992, 0.02610238641500473, -0.009414716623723507, -0.02890215441584587, 0.09723814576864243, 0.05271889269351959, 0.0008658930892124772, 0.025164375081658363, 0.005337974522262812, -0.00023768075334373862, -0.05678943544626236, -0.030084628611803055, -0.04118278622627258, -0.03177393600344658, 0.022267233580350876, -0.00923166237771511, -0.0383392870426178, 0.0057729980908334255, 0.012818563729524612, 0.011760288849473, -0.06052606552839279, -0.06910025328397751, 0.003091973252594471, 0.017549708485603333, -0.0023703579790890217, -0.04291282221674919, 0.005261035170406103, 0.033635012805461884, 0.024337485432624817, -0.0011010151356458664, 0.02387406677007675, 0.04835396632552147, -0.01723502017557621, -0.013538709841668606, -0.02259240113198757, 0.0834847167134285, -0.033044423907995224, -0.06489215046167374, -0.012406913563609123, -0.0001211741182487458, 0.0330241359770298, -0.0058664134703576565, -0.02523639053106308, -0.0007137671927921474, -0.027696825563907623, -0.01608540117740631, -0.027730340138077736, 0.008582736365497112, 0.051527239382267, 0.011284276843070984, -0.010020445100963116, -0.03229020908474922, -0.025113938376307487, -0.0220309030264616, -0.016098881140351295, -0.029077356681227684, 0.013387233018875122, -0.026903705671429634, 0.025857191532850266, -0.018869638442993164, 0.0033107143826782703, -0.0014028804143890738, -0.002738351235166192, -0.04279328137636185, 0.0007162563852034509, 0.030632518231868744, -0.03789064288139343, 0.046729352325201035, -0.006116969510912895, 0.01619994267821312, -0.001034203334711492, 0.0072799972258508205, 0.004378733690828085, -0.018054230138659477, 0.010762949474155903, -0.049707263708114624, 0.053196512162685394, 0.008214594796299934, -0.08661631494760513, 0.029144074767827988, 0.0438951812684536, 0.012504031881690025, 0.028681699186563492, 0.03091440163552761, 0.03819885849952698, -0.04746512323617935, -0.012090448290109634, -0.02300071343779564, -0.004674369934946299, 0.017963601276278496, 0.0365888886153698, -0.017927637323737144, -0.039661306887865067, -0.017757227644324303, 0.08037368953227997, 0.011958545073866844, -0.028511926531791687, 0.014241667464375496, 0.04861867055296898, 0.033650100231170654, -0.02127704955637455, 0.06499998271465302, -0.015330263413488865, 0.02797851338982582, 0.028285764157772064, 0.07516729086637497, 0.06825177371501923, -0.0176029521971941, -0.03238365799188614, -0.0182783342897892, 0.05167119577527046, 0.027040764689445496, -0.04220104217529297, 0.06141422688961029, -0.00830119103193283, -0.05105496570467949, -0.053455471992492676, -0.03917967155575752, 0.0644286721944809, 0.02251259982585907, 0.0013951155124232173, -0.0002520674024708569, -0.015304733999073505, 0.030704140663146973, -0.05678083002567291, -0.002430308610200882, 0.057178981602191925, 0.032923609018325806, -0.07440835237503052, -0.0018432720098644495, 0.01680757850408554, -0.03264350816607475, -0.030559999868273735, 0.028101196512579918, 0.010551185347139835, 0.013602393679320812, 0.013277520425617695, 0.00038195474189706147, 0.014392239972949028, -0.0556054562330246, -0.03149130940437317, -0.00091694196453318, -0.0012660971842706203, 0.02205786667764187, -0.007196450140327215, 0.016500119119882584, -0.05252065137028694, -0.002195616252720356, -0.0339675098657608, 0.002479289658367634, 0.005130671430379152, -0.012628564611077309, -0.024143921211361885, 0.03913261368870735, -0.05222195014357567, 0.013742883689701557, -0.06639352440834045, -0.06807541847229004, -0.03969230130314827, 0.038213539868593216, 0.022261982783675194, -0.04707270488142967, -0.069912850856781, -0.02974909543991089, -0.018409347161650658, 0.014652179554104805, -0.013521180488169193, 0.002040452789515257, -0.05930790305137634, 0.07128220051527023, -0.043171994388103485, -0.01918026991188526, 0.05319786071777344, 0.04076574742794037, 0.003071538871154189, 0.014708596281707287, -0.00378552102483809, 0.018345890566706657, 0.1096469834446907, 0.030739393085241318, 0.05177169293165207, -0.05493282899260521, -0.03915682062506676, 0.00009334956848761067, 0.0052064042538404465, -0.02828392945230007, -0.0015032694209367037, -0.03731634467840195, 0.05389795079827309, 0.04600919783115387, 0.04501733556389809, 0.005942398216575384, 0.02947136014699936, 0.01562205795198679, -0.08783470839262009, -0.00661835353821516, 0.030697956681251526, -0.06892434507608414, 0.0015113125555217266, -0.013850439339876175, -0.01954212784767151, -0.08030106872320175, -0.016807569190859795, 0.020562445744872093, -0.01104260329157114, -0.056239571422338486, 0.04402713105082512, -0.02229604870080948, -0.07167279720306396, 0.048695966601371765, -0.006097234319895506, 0.04337981715798378, 0.0334586426615715, 0.015308074653148651, -0.04179731756448746, -0.018282081931829453, -0.018791940063238144, -0.03389870002865791, 0.02855929359793663, 0.015013243071734905, 0.028855979442596436, -0.04380842670798302, -0.006213624961674213, 0.01494337897747755, -0.013580402359366417, 0.004513212945312262, 0.004180025774985552, -0.012181056663393974, 0.022545520216226578, 0.03681815788149834, 0.06594758480787277, 0.023906322196125984, -0.011035001836717129, -0.0544070303440094, 0.027836984023451805, 0.03946612402796745, -0.006393967196345329, -0.04319937899708748, -0.02234504744410515, -0.0029095113277435303, -0.011205325834453106, -0.0053875078447163105, 0.05907980352640152, 0.05129235237836838, 0.007672341540455818, -0.041698358952999115, -0.01878422684967518, -0.02821086347103119, 0.011122873052954674, -0.008952297270298004, -0.04202640429139137, -0.007974924519658089, -0.06919367611408234, -0.03836986795067787, -0.0038807298988103867, 0.01025150716304779, 0.007246251683682203, -0.023066101595759392, 0.039565131068229675, 0.030165569856762886, -0.02395673841238022, -0.0618165098130703, 0.02870631217956543, 0.0006917410064488649, -0.02407040260732174, -0.013326531276106834, 0.002310127718374133, -0.0010197967058047652, -0.006459190510213375, 0.014118202030658722, 0.05315211042761803, -0.020592637360095978, 0.015112300403416157, 0.013929834589362144, 0.03881308063864708, -0.02355811558663845, -0.051121409982442856, 0.0041378336027264595, -0.0035575497895479202, 0.02756873331964016, 0.03346817567944527, 0.038053013384342194, -0.04678448662161827, 0.03660288825631142, 0.011558406054973602, 0.016711317002773285, 0.03300199657678604, 0.002547171199694276, 0.025132881477475166, -0.021735962480306625, -0.0023913318291306496, -0.008886109106242657, 0.08103082329034805, 0.014165051281452179, -0.016877852380275726, -0.032676126807928085, -0.007423607632517815, -0.057546041905879974, 0.05461772531270981, 0.009519405663013458, -0.0073838550597429276, -0.0023831664584577084, -0.017070699483156204, 0.02238345332443714, -0.00894272979348898, 0.06835495680570602, -0.0007967910496518016, 0.03262273222208023, 0.07144327461719513, 0.01964694634079933, -0.048413168638944626, 0.022387908771634102, -0.07227110862731934, -0.009246873669326305, 0.015104579739272594, 0.009489098563790321, -0.0727250948548317, -0.015596446581184864, 0.0045323362573981285, -0.011526322923600674, -0.045546554028987885, 0.03235641494393349, -0.015901468694210052, -0.013211536221206188, 0.03889871761202812, 0.01735992357134819, 0.007947024889290333, 0.000628325913567096, 0.02037595584988594, -0.03427581489086151, 0.04299722984433174, 0.0107674989849329, 0.0033582844771444798, 0.008176836185157299, -0.017356490716338158, -0.0278229471296072, -0.024862395599484444, -0.03987301141023636, -0.01148177683353424, 0.0027244591619819403, -0.039888154715299606, 0.023166198283433914, 0.021879898384213448, 0.05420719459652901, -0.01194352563470602, -0.015518108382821083, -0.055577926337718964, -0.005174046382308006, 0.00034394627436995506, 0.030080262571573257, -0.011986196041107178, -0.023424867540597916, 0.04721260443329811, 0.07820258289575577, 0.01007909793406725, -0.04586892947554588, 0.014101131819188595, 0.0014074528589844704, -0.019280146807432175, -0.0015501993475481868, 0.04139772430062294, -0.047566480934619904, -0.020209848880767822, 0.018216896802186966, -0.0551474466919899, 0.04687679931521416, 0.004939602222293615, 0.06008359417319298, 0.009943767450749874, 0.014737579971551895, 0.04215279221534729, 0.08118827641010284, -0.05299108475446701, -0.006039116531610489, -0.03376639634370804, 0.013773986138403416, -0.015482071787118912, -0.02786131575703621, -0.013737152330577374, 0.02395598776638508, 0.04562722519040108, 0.012194203212857246, -0.02024735137820244, -0.030521929264068604, 0.021921437233686447, -0.0773252472281456, -0.05170891806483269, 0.009818640537559986, 0.05932500958442688, -0.0005884722340852022, 0.05236304923892021, -0.024568727239966393, 0.011673931032419205, -0.029710844159126282, 0.029634976759552956, 0.002708951709792018, -0.01195584051311016, -0.007959051057696342, -0.03167594596743584, 0.0238477885723114, -0.01630329340696335, 0.06765347719192505, -0.049606092274188995, 0.023461228236556053, 0.05210268869996071, 0.012661953456699848, -0.06541171669960022, 0.11426513642072678, -0.03518958389759064, 0.02205200120806694, -0.017910221591591835, 0.047355975955724716, 0.01989399828016758, 0.030473193153738976, 0.019717730581760406, 0.0347931794822216, 0.038396332412958145, -0.05176585167646408, 0.04034624621272087, 0.03463207557797432, -0.03588194400072098, 0.042873140424489975, 0.012820434756577015, -0.044626712799072266, -0.011598496697843075, 0.010906247422099113, -0.07492166757583618, -0.029027393087744713, -0.009927337057888508, -0.05125600844621658, -0.014371342957019806, 0.03939255326986313, 0.033947188407182693, -0.014644577167928219, -0.06950193643569946, -0.016745030879974365 ]
<p>In multi-electron atoms, the electronic state of the optically active "subshell" is often expressed in "term symbols" notation. I.e. $^{2S+1}L_J$. This presumes that the system of electrons has definite $L^2$, $S^2$ and $\mathbf{J}$ eigenstates.</p> <p>In order to determine all the possible electronic states compatible with the Pauli's exclusion principle, the technique is to assign to each electron its $m_s$ and $m_l$ and to see what states can be found in terms of eigenvalues of $L^2$, $S^2$, $J^2$ and $J_z$.</p> <p>What justifies this procedure? In other words, the assumption so far was: </p> <ul> <li>heavy nucleus -> the Hamiltonian is spherically symmetric -> total $\mathbf{J}$ is conserved</li> <li>spin-orbit is negligible to some extent -> total $S^2$ and $L^2$ are conserved</li> </ul> <p>What justifies, apart from intuitiveness, returning to the single electron picture (assigning to every electron its spin and angular momentum) to find what states are allowed or not according to the requirement that the total wavefunction should be antisymmetric? And could be there exceptions?</p>
g6567
[ -0.012413164600729942, 0.019566446542739868, -0.004702460952103138, 0.00019988766871392727, -0.021918602287769318, -0.03029952570796013, 0.050393734127283096, 0.030706729739904404, 0.06742270290851593, 0.020123731344938278, 0.003237923141568899, 0.00989967305213213, 0.0576484315097332, 0.04162652790546417, -0.015748372301459312, -0.036789800971746445, 0.06546627730131149, 0.03135247901082039, 0.043299317359924316, 0.00817850325256586, -0.005531569477170706, 0.027337754145264626, -0.03048328496515751, 0.0002787166158668697, 0.029987910762429237, 0.043160416185855865, -0.016283169388771057, -0.04061300307512283, 0.009168049320578575, 0.03026629239320755, 0.01692909561097622, -0.07485552877187729, 0.05003881826996803, -0.06155473738908768, 0.005152648780494928, 0.016931619495153427, 0.06640204787254333, 0.031894877552986145, -0.03072129748761654, 0.0341225266456604, -0.03018938936293125, -0.031554169952869415, -0.003078949637711048, -0.01729423739016056, 0.05148156359791756, -0.006981147453188896, -0.007922589778900146, 0.014361991547048092, -0.021964790299534798, -0.03580981120467186, 0.037506379187107086, 0.041559189558029175, 0.04425378888845444, -0.0028582224622368813, 0.023799197748303413, 0.008282525464892387, -0.08413054794073105, 0.014301714487373829, 0.04315713420510292, 0.010428059846162796, 0.039819445461034775, 0.008863231167197227, -0.015191322192549706, 0.01994975470006466, 0.06012288108468056, 0.02552037686109543, -0.048680923879146576, 0.007975230924785137, 0.010013995692133904, -0.002756696892902255, -0.007408331613987684, -0.02793668396770954, -0.0006734283524565399, -0.01795022375881672, 0.011783045716583729, -0.009526815265417099, -0.04784518852829933, 0.004418468102812767, 0.06640502065420151, 0.05599469318985939, -0.05584678426384926, -0.0445343554019928, 0.03162422776222229, -0.006840493064373732, 0.007122992072254419, 0.024526668712496758, 0.004862966015934944, -0.026737140491604805, -0.019153254106640816, 0.039571359753608704, 0.026811150833964348, -0.010812987573444843, 0.05019393563270569, 0.003317741909995675, 0.006874911952763796, 0.013493495993316174, 0.0005643731565214694, 0.02751806192100048, -0.06103425472974777, -0.027379024773836136, 0.020447203889489174, -0.009055067785084248, -0.00454020407050848, -0.009775251150131226, 0.011191995814442635, 0.04011033475399017, -0.04175291955471039, -0.002742739859968424, 0.024729620665311813, 0.04038744792342186, -0.006621163338422775, 0.011817924678325653, 0.007381926290690899, -0.03306112438440323, -0.10186251252889633, 0.021166274324059486, 0.030386587604880333, -0.04992477968335152, -0.04653282091021538, 0.040986720472574234, -0.009850231930613518, 0.02934304066002369, 0.05948551371693611, 0.06878189742565155, -0.0014100164407864213, 0.001450681360438466, -0.05966871976852417, -0.024020493030548096, 0.03490246832370758, -0.032866690307855606, -0.03785349801182747, 0.004898708313703537, 0.0023488395381718874, 0.04953668266534805, 0.016801083460450172, -0.06836449354887009, -0.020011281594634056, 0.003837895579636097, -0.03347243741154671, -0.06607135385274887, 0.018698440864682198, -0.02365252934396267, -0.04972310736775398, -0.033319562673568726, -0.0002866218565031886, -0.06683461368083954, -0.02378065697848797, 0.0016262581339105964, 0.012025860138237476, 0.03743114694952965, 0.019389035180211067, 0.03492290526628494, 0.0358085073530674, -0.01841925084590912, -0.004053183831274509, -0.04431527480483055, 0.08007615804672241, -0.04672513157129288, -0.02833327278494835, 0.07094281911849976, 0.013675822876393795, -0.03848971053957939, -0.01620429754257202, 0.039397504180669785, -0.040716417133808136, -0.015330706723034382, -0.029371000826358795, -0.04125717282295227, 0.021089956164360046, -0.03317013010382652, -0.06406232714653015, -0.021501393988728523, 0.02279803156852722, 0.03352385014295578, 0.03991639241576195, 0.011077756993472576, -0.02300410531461239, -0.06853966414928436, 0.06876693665981293, 0.06641783565282822, -0.00962816085666418, 0.024929244071245193, -0.010981063358485699, 0.06259859353303909, 0.016023196280002594, -0.011155033484101295, -0.0203397199511528, 0.039344821125268936, -0.04082673415541649, 0.04433855786919594, 0.09345627576112747, 0.06533724069595337, 0.020493483170866966, -0.015471321530640125, -0.00734071247279644, -0.002407636260613799, 0.0047880555503070354, -0.04851385951042175, -0.052765969187021255, -0.021397946402430534, -0.0025734647642821074, 0.026623953133821487, -0.016243180260062218, 0.004821304697543383, 0.016914531588554382, -0.021486813202500343, -0.005149555392563343, 0.03905562683939934, -0.0032779956236481667, -0.010457492433488369, 0.00684753805398941, -0.03975694254040718, -0.014058972708880901, 0.0037890183739364147, 0.015871644020080566, 0.009759713895618916, 0.01533741969615221, 0.019334403797984123, -0.004276779945939779, 0.022890113294124603, -0.01831202767789364, -0.005520615726709366, -0.028179533779621124, 0.04562273621559143, 0.03195633739233017, 0.03693721070885658, -0.03848259523510933, 0.010212394408881664, -0.037441350519657135, 0.03326762840151787, -0.0673314705491066, -0.023049410432577133, -0.013186306692659855, -0.07702802866697311, -0.022390181198716164, 0.02286217361688614, -0.013692038133740425, 0.009649687446653843, 0.00000828328211355256, 0.03631680831313133, 0.01428457722067833, 0.005136791616678238, 0.00315281399525702, 0.060383833944797516, 0.02801373414695263, -0.017399029806256294, 0.011180846020579338, 0.028139661997556686, -0.042581185698509216, 0.028242943808436394, -0.0874740481376648, 0.010839284397661686, -0.06675892323255539, 0.041665513068437576, -0.008475072681903839, -0.032566193491220474, -0.004437358118593693, 0.005269531160593033, -0.04441065341234207, 0.026323508471250534, -0.0035772172268480062, 0.0038982578553259373, -0.010778077878057957, 0.018352171406149864, 0.02249489538371563, -0.013622022233903408, 0.01601823791861534, -0.03707233816385269, -0.021254612132906914, 0.009310531429946423, -0.0566910058259964, 0.09177617728710175, -0.03849443420767784, 0.04527563229203224, 0.015030957758426666, 0.013986064121127129, -0.026597756892442703, 0.03693576157093048, 0.019517596811056137, 0.0340646393597126, -0.03803720325231552, -0.007164182607084513, -0.03433395177125931, 0.029421882703900337, 0.015676051378250122, -0.04171929135918617, 0.026953743770718575, 0.04213123023509979, 0.006969895213842392, -0.034522633999586105, -0.037693340331315994, 0.03748584911227226, 0.016786590218544006, 0.02729913219809532, -0.0451587438583374, -0.041826434433460236, 0.015264937654137611, -0.05453163757920265, -0.013677683658897877, 0.08023591339588165, -0.018385479226708412, 0.0649842843413353, 0.04409656301140785, -0.02509492076933384, 0.06347447633743286, 0.026743466034531593, -0.028017939999699593, -0.02121729776263237, -0.02245347760617733, -0.036132726818323135, -0.02537587471306324, 0.05891568213701248, 0.008589007891714573, -0.03632097691297531, -0.038022730499506, -0.0117775434628129, 0.01928163506090641, 0.00586710823699832, 0.04179554432630539, -0.0281303059309721, -0.03674774244427681, 0.07915756106376648, 0.008909267373383045, 0.0020407543051987886, 0.024156060069799423, 0.011110986582934856, -0.0950351133942604, -0.03847186267375946, -0.04999812692403793, -0.031150544062256813, 0.022265778854489326, 0.01624036207795143, 0.027107728645205498, 0.004464942496269941, -0.023465381935238838, 0.00622692471370101, -0.00011244529014220461, -0.024385781958699226, 0.05908217653632164, 0.017910990864038467, -0.019623873755335808, -0.025907522067427635, -0.026311257854104042, -0.0236139465123415, -0.007733305916190147, -0.027345407754182816, -0.10221249610185623, 0.014022449031472206, -0.024134105071425438, -0.030766300857067108, -0.061399780213832855, 0.055129826068878174, -0.026845060288906097, -0.0009467697236686945, 0.024509910494089127, 0.01622614823281765, 0.003621411509811878, 0.06442053616046906, 0.0561479814350605, 0.009145105257630348, -0.013259555213153362, -0.03225889801979065, -0.014322072267532349, -0.05616750568151474, 0.03875218331813812, -0.011581623926758766, -0.0005166347837075591, -0.03559845685958862, 0.0827452689409256, -0.028520137071609497, -0.01920432038605213, -0.02544255182147026, 0.0003495163982734084, -0.042683131992816925, 0.026414910331368446, -0.03640889376401901, -0.03751827031373978, -0.010309714823961258, -0.0812678411602974, 0.008002283051609993, -0.026703137904405594, 0.00827849842607975, 0.03636297583580017, 0.04597436264157295, 0.03440452739596367, 0.03866760432720184, -0.0358022004365921, 0.048980437219142914, -0.01649133861064911, 0.020544685423374176, 0.03667804226279259, -0.05515856295824051, -0.057846564799547195, -0.03287794068455696, 0.02603662759065628, -0.0027430786285549402, 0.07182334363460541, -0.10811646282672882, 0.03969070687890053, 0.02981613390147686, -0.017611674964427948, -0.02908637560904026, 0.024854252114892006, -0.06742793321609497, 0.035386502742767334, 0.01980338804423809, 0.02176804468035698, 0.008794968947768211, 0.029020316898822784, -0.01705315336585045, -0.015525409020483494, -0.01504511758685112, 0.02504829503595829, 0.03908495977520943, -0.04954218119382858, -0.02037888765335083, 0.008901149034500122, -0.048158008605241776, 0.0008756181341595948, -0.004733856301754713, 0.017109589651226997, 0.07147807627916336, -0.025569353252649307, -0.004749098792672157, -0.03183593600988388, 0.03637157380580902, 0.006961614824831486, -0.010673274286091328, 0.016370806843042374, -0.014070875942707062, 0.01358267106115818, 0.0052804299630224705, 0.023934559896588326, -0.027253199368715286, -0.12124721705913544, -0.021678753197193146, -0.03623748943209648, 0.018021712079644203, -0.0028696770314127207, 0.060285069048404694, 0.05663381144404411, -0.029519489035010338, -0.007770481053739786, 0.019330767914652824, -0.021409783512353897, -0.002843467053025961, -0.04578579217195511, -0.048940036445856094, -0.0025988235138356686, -0.04094795510172844, -0.012686747126281261, -0.03366777300834656, -0.042631059885025024, 0.018558179959654808, -0.022105911746621132, -0.017580818384885788, -0.043387673795223236, 0.040202200412750244, 0.0628763735294342, 0.00281257345341146, -0.03267540782690048, -0.01760287955403328, -0.05982226878404617, 0.041227713227272034, 0.023662330582737923, 0.009843903593719006, -0.028739504516124725, 0.033788662403821945, -0.0314040333032608, -0.0001698031701380387, 0.05972164869308472, 0.019499991089105606, 0.0817008838057518, -0.053549304604530334, 0.010465593077242374, -0.08052419126033783, -0.0018651586724445224, -0.0005992451915517449, -0.0051642293110489845, 0.03381526470184326, -0.0351390577852726, 0.00042572751408442855, 0.03784312307834625, 0.018812958151102066, -0.021106474101543427, -0.002125419909134507, 0.02134903520345688, -0.00009002409933600575, -0.08340390771627426, 0.0006197735783644021, -0.006594125647097826, 0.03236480429768562, 0.0035784952342510223, -0.015156876295804977, 0.04968030005693436, 0.031921662390232086, 0.020229872316122055, 0.01532982662320137, -0.02620854601264, 0.03621552884578705, -0.03397343307733536, -0.003862446639686823, -0.024051068350672722, 0.02844383753836155, -0.015977224335074425, -0.0026958677917718887, 0.12879513204097748, -0.04983724653720856, -0.007207841146737337, -0.09897394478321075, -0.007436392363160849, -0.04110275208950043, -0.004350803792476654, -0.06333918869495392, -0.002946821041405201, -0.07727651298046112, 0.0010279755806550384, 0.0719197690486908, -0.006709056906402111, -0.05148611217737198, -0.024951450526714325, 0.01015245821326971, 0.035819657146930695, -0.033533547073602676, -0.00948043167591095, 0.007766118738800287, -0.004813191946595907, 0.0031072483398020267, 0.02856251783668995, 0.04440300539135933, 0.01737421751022339, -0.015625713393092155, 0.00221317820250988, 0.02512425370514393, 0.07356687635183334, -0.08052036911249161, -0.04150077700614929, 0.003638993948698044, 0.0057760500349104404, 0.018064934760332108, 0.007600633893162012, -0.050779685378074646, -0.024861136451363564, 0.039508938789367676, -0.03237304836511612, 0.0009080258896574378, 0.020014766603708267, -0.0017336799064651132, -0.03578510507941246, -0.03793986886739731, -0.023958252742886543, 0.09155139327049255, -0.034172531217336655, -0.011205889284610748, 0.029745154082775116, 0.049696072936058044, 0.003748858580365777, 0.025480376556515694, 0.014284995384514332, 0.0321427620947361, 0.04719908908009529, 0.02445109561085701, -0.0023534749634563923, 0.03570748120546341, 0.03080133907496929, 0.011430276557803154, -0.031670667231082916, -0.015840677544474602, 0.019785398617386818, 0.020320812240242958, -0.038606058806180954, 0.011754167266190052, 0.01899818517267704, 0.009622410871088505, 0.028671132400631905, 0.02113884873688221, -0.03339387848973274, 0.022375881671905518, -0.008543189615011215, -0.004267449956387281, -0.023221725597977638, 0.06520122289657593, 0.015248439274728298, 0.0003907692153006792, -0.018796565011143684, 0.020896458998322487, -0.009364999830722809, -0.004495262634009123, 0.018229536712169647, -0.03717217966914177, -0.0013062501093372703, 0.002756651723757386, 0.00996241346001625, 0.023807143792510033, -0.0017970692133530974, 0.03511665388941765, -0.009576003067195415, -0.015795202925801277, -0.014410500414669514, 0.02052822709083557, 0.08592736721038818, -0.014166580513119698, 0.010314310900866985, 0.015872139483690262, 0.05544324591755867, 0.0689426138997078, -0.060155317187309265, -0.0034349788911640644, 0.009314254857599735, -0.041922230273485184, -0.035335421562194824, -0.013570453971624374, 0.028264999389648438, 0.004087997134774923, -0.013233267702162266, -0.032456837594509125, -0.003278128569945693, 0.04491439089179039, -0.06883419305086136, 0.04405330866575241, 0.052600741386413574, 0.02420695871114731, -0.06116285175085068, -0.008160951547324657, 0.08888398110866547, 0.0414525531232357, -0.05644853413105011, -0.03395611047744751, 0.06585420668125153, 0.008335371501743793, -0.0022176438942551613, 0.024601232260465622, 0.07115208357572556, 0.008552656508982182, 0.014179768040776253, 0.04518420994281769, -0.022441690787672997, 0.012925422750413418, 0.05841854587197304, 0.041245222091674805, -0.04092269390821457, 0.039583541452884674, 0.13019028306007385, 0.026879018172621727, -0.060441337525844574, 0.0118595315143466, 0.04570689797401428, -0.03263118490576744, -0.013396025635302067, -0.008391241542994976, 0.012248034588992596, -0.01135617308318615, -0.039735082536935806, 0.0012826846214011312, -0.01065851841121912, -0.009065312333405018, -0.007676706649363041, -0.024233942851424217, 0.010262398980557919, -0.03704920411109924, -0.01822669990360737, -0.025118928402662277, -0.01492649782449007, -0.05509450286626816, -0.041209883987903595, 0.022983171045780182, 0.0029836134053766727, -0.06378202885389328, -0.023346005007624626, -0.018656231462955475, -0.015385616570711136, -0.04486079514026642, -0.07028059661388397, 0.09442953020334244, -0.032865509390830994, -0.037415601313114166, -0.0026786865200847387, -0.016023755073547363, -0.02649463154375553, -0.04134945943951607, -0.0730431005358696, 0.044948309659957886, 0.018008986487984657, 0.03280860558152199, -0.0514911413192749, -0.018561607226729393, -0.016451334580779076, 0.02669895812869072, -0.019833792001008987, 0.027563344687223434, 0.03234143927693367, -0.0028173201717436314, 0.03447882458567619, -0.023364543914794922, -0.007207588758319616, -0.008729372173547745, -0.025422269478440285, 0.04742978885769844, 0.04315967112779617, -0.00999740231782198, -0.014463559724390507, 0.030084554105997086, 0.01039077527821064, 0.044493403285741806, 0.044064510613679886, 0.0034077607560902834, -0.0062059927731752396, -0.019889142364263535, -0.04529714956879616, -0.013963310979306698, 0.011464020237326622, 0.008579179644584656, -0.0034305285662412643, 0.00918319821357727, 0.026469949632883072, -0.03908626735210419, -0.015594919212162495, 0.015110624022781849, 0.017805451527237892, 0.006794260814785957, 0.06576491892337799, 0.02705560438334942, -0.037454649806022644, 0.014258130453526974, 0.025435926392674446, -0.03686673566699028, 0.005975788459181786, 0.013370185159146786, 0.025942692533135414, -0.0077009061351418495, -0.028338663280010223, 0.04609426110982895, -0.043087031692266464, -0.017216265201568604, -0.04302549362182617, 0.019604740664362907, -0.027314424514770508, -0.06887504458427429, -0.007830518297851086, 0.05265431106090546, -0.015400685369968414, 0.0001431388227501884, -0.0007119430229067802, -0.027865920215845108, -0.047127366065979004, 0.022848831489682198, -0.04275750741362572, -0.04688733443617821, 0.07155712693929672, 0.00643845833837986, -0.0363425686955452, -0.0011495979269966483, -0.029355734586715698, 0.029261235147714615, 0.041148606687784195, -0.021063346415758133, 0.03527715802192688, -0.07766056805849075, 0.041997797787189484, 0.043457258492708206, -0.03272097930312157, 0.018594367429614067, 0.010715906508266926, 0.02464233711361885, 0.0031796430703252554, -0.10478030890226364, -0.02071281149983406, -0.01030667219310999 ]
<p>In an assignment I am given a random car with a random suspension system, and told that it is sufficient to test the safety of the car with regards to the suspension on three different sinusoidal roads.</p> <p>The first road has an amplitude of 5 centimeters and a period of 20 meters, the second road has an amplitude of 2.5 centimeters and a period of 2 meters and the third road has an amplitude of 1 centimeter and a period of 20 centimeters.</p> <p>I can't figure out why a test on these three roads would be sufficient to conclude that the car can handle any random other road, and I am given no other information.</p> <p>Could anyone please tell me why it is sufficient to test the suspension on only these three roads?</p>
g6568
[ 0.023438220843672752, -0.012163924053311348, 0.0035237364936619997, -0.012373296543955803, 0.029207564890384674, 0.011089217849075794, -0.003832547925412655, 0.00450459960848093, -0.0009996985318139195, -0.007900259457528591, -0.009101956151425838, -0.013517206534743309, -0.019472524523735046, -0.014508160762488842, -0.04049130529165268, -0.01682373508810997, 0.0368490032851696, 0.027589119970798492, -0.007657089736312628, 0.0002899311948567629, -0.006010350771248341, 0.008470279164612293, -0.037877216935157776, -0.012261773459613323, 0.05162942036986351, -0.016104331240057945, -0.03851993381977081, -0.04073531553149223, -0.06842448562383652, -0.009400189854204655, 0.0036245952360332012, 0.011704372242093086, -0.008230824954807758, -0.04709380865097046, -0.08550921082496643, 0.010334105230867863, 0.0036066893953830004, 0.000402678590035066, 0.01219392754137516, -0.021183455362915993, -0.020075233653187752, 0.03817523643374443, 0.05258317291736603, 0.0010114379692822695, -0.00897213350981474, -0.024917930364608765, -0.05210477486252785, 0.05900659039616585, 0.011354406364262104, -0.029550127685070038, -0.003866892773658037, -0.044489726424217224, 0.04300224781036377, 0.019032958894968033, -0.019450809806585312, -0.029178436845541, 0.03157500922679901, -0.004672198090702295, -0.028699912130832672, -0.014220645651221275, -0.021017130464315414, -0.00785956159234047, -0.049583759158849716, -0.029323311522603035, 0.02511058934032917, -0.02489824965596199, 0.028843076899647713, 0.011211110278964043, 0.04145249351859093, 0.06171485036611557, 0.049889251589775085, 0.0031411272939294577, -0.02555970288813114, -0.09038543701171875, -0.06325367093086243, -0.014621438458561897, 0.005317860748618841, 0.03416406363248825, 0.051970530301332474, 0.03922376036643982, 0.019495796412229538, 0.025575997307896614, -0.05960257723927498, 0.024493010714650154, 0.05438341572880745, 0.04849991574883461, 0.025022093206644058, -0.02779344655573368, -0.025960532948374748, -0.014865359291434288, 0.05447545647621155, -0.025658296421170235, 0.04713164642453194, 0.1006736159324646, -0.01670846901834011, -0.028008898720145226, -0.059469420462846756, 0.12173694372177124, 0.014967119321227074, 0.04207964614033699, -0.011158297769725323, -0.014766897074878216, 0.044735513627529144, -0.016958750784397125, -0.012760059908032417, 0.02505333162844181, 0.0010034285951405764, 0.00685188127681613, 0.02874002791941166, -0.07598838210105896, -0.035044167190790176, 0.0032538287341594696, -0.0388091541826725, -0.0008522348944097757, 0.012633666396141052, -0.010901384986937046, 0.044637538492679596, 0.003365518758073449, 0.04042215272784233, -0.0045740725472569466, -0.009755951352417469, -0.02417600527405739, -0.0516388975083828, 0.028837276622653008, -0.0724177211523056, 0.036637380719184875, 0.014644819311797619, 0.046750035136938095, 0.04558432847261429, 0.02509796805679798, -0.039405327290296555, 0.04017798975110054, 0.010430525057017803, -0.02316218428313732, -0.03751299902796745, 0.04549025371670723, 0.0645022764801979, -0.01574864238500595, -0.03187902644276619, 0.05801060423254967, 0.04193444177508354, 0.027498366311192513, -0.009571083821356297, -0.010978465899825096, -0.015209457837045193, 0.021702401340007782, -0.03558680787682533, -0.028624622151255608, 0.01680625230073929, -0.009563110768795013, -0.002196843968704343, 0.017336398363113403, 0.00469210185110569, 0.020928021520376205, -0.00008634253026684746, 0.011250132694840431, -0.002840863075107336, 0.0035140637774020433, -0.020676735788583755, 0.00673649599775672, 0.040551550686359406, -0.02727636508643627, 0.009691892191767693, 0.008837809786200523, -0.06932148337364197, 0.016629572957754135, -0.01115996204316616, -0.01787339709699154, 0.02309487573802471, -0.005780291743576527, -0.016008008271455765, -0.018329612910747528, 0.051424019038677216, 0.025501331314444542, 0.025923997163772583, 0.014861403033137321, 0.07108688354492188, -0.03829606622457504, 0.07541199773550034, -0.031003009527921677, -0.020888466387987137, -0.007062000222504139, -0.022548027336597443, -0.014674662612378597, -0.006210770923644304, 0.0074135069735348225, 0.027031991630792618, 0.04567746818065643, -0.08456891775131226, 0.016534995287656784, 0.05729222297668457, -0.0446314811706543, -0.0002865309070330113, -0.04068463668227196, 0.010946414433419704, -0.044473059475421906, 0.008163073100149632, 0.030337370932102203, 0.011417154222726822, -0.0000230627538257977, 0.08765128254890442, 0.020444322377443314, -0.023863602429628372, -0.004803232848644257, 0.009830369614064693, -0.016141895204782486, -0.02389586716890335, 0.014832894317805767, 0.011697923764586449, 0.0032034062314778566, 0.049463845789432526, -0.009628566913306713, 0.022106217220425606, 0.03535441681742668, 0.017640039324760437, -0.08026380091905594, 0.0585256926715374, -0.02666878141462803, 0.022429270669817924, 0.034837864339351654, 0.07297708839178085, -0.06777555495500565, 0.03691926971077919, -0.05618009716272354, -0.05895215645432472, 0.05393066629767418, -0.04809858277440071, -0.03206151723861694, 0.07087598741054535, 0.018957536667585373, -0.015269758179783821, -0.06451360136270523, 0.019884025678038597, 0.008280253037810326, -0.013320938684046268, 0.06006990373134613, 0.06041407957673073, -0.08117309957742691, 0.0066640242002904415, 0.011332777328789234, -0.0006507021025754511, 0.011323499493300915, 0.025860192254185677, -0.04018465429544449, 0.027038756757974625, -0.011713237501680851, 0.0067230165004730225, -0.01742442324757576, 0.03055816888809204, 0.02417844906449318, -0.01112006139010191, 0.0183438491076231, -0.03903541341423988, -0.01014508493244648, 0.006807531695812941, -0.03409966453909874, 0.02953837439417839, -0.002512900857254863, -0.02727331779897213, -0.012424930930137634, -0.03610480576753616, -0.02151728980243206, 0.01313172746449709, 0.017547650262713432, -0.05957421287894249, 0.0037917292211204767, -0.0006800027331337333, -0.012389319948852062, -0.018963418900966644, -0.021914945915341377, 0.03538809344172478, 0.03087705746293068, 0.05830937251448631, 0.09697233140468597, -0.02540862374007702, 0.008672562427818775, -0.03301257640123367, 0.0087087107822299, -0.020985350012779236, 0.03556825593113899, -0.022679707035422325, -0.03406323865056038, -0.010496360249817371, -0.0078034899197518826, 0.0053347195498645306, -0.031741898506879807, 0.05052595213055611, -0.0032365384977310896, -0.04737015813589096, 0.05134700983762741, -0.05836349353194237, 0.01839667744934559, 0.05973105877637863, 0.01586439646780491, 0.009585860185325146, 0.046107176691293716, -0.05549049749970436, -0.013922330923378468, 0.006693973205983639, 0.03414082154631615, -0.03139390051364899, -0.017460322007536888, 0.016354426741600037, 0.007572532631456852, 0.00870600063353777, 0.031344398856163025, -0.0026686463970690966, -0.016281848773360252, 0.03882724791765213, 0.04380633682012558, -0.05448715016245842, 0.059796009212732315, -0.029423633590340614, -0.02248096466064453, -0.05487292259931564, 0.020886393263936043, -0.012590042315423489, 0.03231706842780113, -0.0011867424473166466, 0.06327219307422638, -0.028763337060809135, -0.020515581592917442, -0.0116273183375597, -0.021114742383360863, 0.023538118228316307, 0.03444366157054901, -0.007136196829378605, 0.03118634968996048, -0.044081948697566986, -0.05542197450995445, 0.047054391354322433, 0.03546072170138359, -0.002452599350363016, -0.06960075348615646, 0.02230563759803772, -0.07341630011796951, 0.03296696022152901, 0.004143367521464825, 0.010279926471412182, -0.022669265046715736, 0.03625987470149994, -0.06297893822193146, -0.03146691620349884, -0.06485868245363235, -0.010614856146275997, 0.05724183842539787, 0.05521921068429947, 0.012582892552018166, 0.03526350483298302, -0.026850169524550438, -0.015239644795656204, -0.030982695519924164, -0.04373016580939293, -0.023353667929768562, 0.002880070125684142, 0.0429256334900856, -0.05708081275224686, 0.00787604134529829, -0.026449108496308327, 0.024645576253533363, -0.00956374779343605, -0.06658836454153061, -0.001182679319754243, 0.003662645583972335, 0.04995555430650711, 0.002398346085101366, -0.02239323779940605, 0.0685354545712471, -0.014878958463668823, 0.011835486628115177, -0.0020404017996042967, -0.02005501091480255, -0.011630058288574219, 0.0190893542021513, 0.08037558943033218, 0.009343051351606846, 0.02127944678068161, 0.03314583748579025, -0.06714050471782684, 0.029855582863092422, 0.027429768815636635, -0.04671400785446167, 0.007370856124907732, -0.012126438319683075, -0.005985885858535767, 0.014037109911441803, -0.02229299396276474, 0.025338703766465187, -0.02114519104361534, -0.04936888813972473, 0.014342359267175198, -0.09680798649787903, -0.038066864013671875, -0.018490560352802277, 0.09205380082130432, -0.03188551962375641, 0.01811598241329193, -0.006556481588631868, 0.030579542741179466, 0.030942797660827637, 0.026705065742135048, -0.0200902558863163, -0.00003726888098753989, 0.008210928179323673, -0.058911681175231934, 0.030948393046855927, -0.0009532980620861053, 0.01476317085325718, -0.048429764807224274, 0.015691889449954033, 0.011682250536978245, -0.017107531428337097, -0.009591441601514816, -0.06634889543056488, 0.01890423335134983, 0.03708023950457573, -0.003834000090137124, -0.0005771465366706252, 0.0015325330896303058, 0.06353065371513367, 0.008925551548600197, 0.004197848029434681, 0.016867363825440407, -0.05156839266419411, 0.021023986861109734, 0.013070526532828808, 0.032792828977108, 0.0011200587032362819, -0.030050083994865417, 0.010452990420162678, 0.02966098114848137, 0.0018063567113131285, -0.04459988325834274, 0.03466496616601944, -0.05931621044874191, 0.014334961771965027, -0.016872458159923553, 0.0645148977637291, -0.011414424516260624, -0.008319977670907974, -0.045804064720869064, 0.02358029969036579, -0.01661214977502823, -0.014680825173854828, -0.029722148552536964, -0.018810538575053215, -0.02116634137928486, -0.05659704655408859, -0.0173236895352602, 0.03573661297559738, -0.01674085110425949, -0.0030259699560701847, 0.013534809462726116, -0.030128968879580498, 0.010252625681459904, -0.005317772272974253, 0.002964949468150735, 0.01695900596678257, 0.028897756710648537, 0.045735329389572144, -0.021032849326729774, -0.012312310747802258, 0.025089770555496216, 0.042839862406253815, -0.019260285422205925, -0.006773791741579771, -0.002170907100662589, -0.020479707047343254, 0.0002650087990332395, -0.01849290542304516, -0.018565744161605835, -0.0403573103249073, 0.04589100182056427, -0.005318159237504005, -0.016867078840732574, -0.026665804907679558, 0.026925332844257355, 0.04070743918418884, -0.03209788352251053, -0.01752655953168869, 0.015200880356132984, -0.05389532074332237, -0.00124835385940969, 0.02248658798635006, 0.03223457187414169, -0.003572891466319561, 0.024542443454265594, -0.04665495082736015, 0.04473835602402687, 0.016745280474424362, 0.02641575038433075, 0.038734372705221176, 0.012871935963630676, 0.016130436211824417, 0.014795779250562191, -0.07943140715360641, 0.025597356259822845, -0.04595581814646721, -0.09335815161466599, -0.08193018287420273, -0.05261368304491043, 0.0037614803295582533, 0.052836839109659195, 0.01419773604720831, -0.0718793123960495, -0.001996503444388509, 0.06845318526029587, -0.08293513208627701, -0.043214961886405945, 0.07896407693624496, 0.0017464306438341737, 0.0024326287675648928, 0.0735035240650177, 0.0006210546707734466, -0.04764507710933685, 0.006612853612750769, -0.03489522263407707, 0.030375586822628975, -0.013244282454252243, -0.01508945133537054, 0.025670653209090233, 0.0028000890742987394, 0.015306863002479076, -0.07010096311569214, -0.052403662353754044, -0.02324841357767582, -0.007787630893290043, -0.07682547718286514, 0.014492194168269634, -0.04698333516716957, 0.02613442949950695, 0.03498649597167969, -0.016393957659602165, -0.003988018725067377, -0.011609384790062904, -0.05514250323176384, -0.011069218628108501, 0.029736872762441635, -0.03937757387757301, -0.03667638450860977, -0.0541921891272068, -0.01724208891391754, 0.03799806162714958, 0.07299905270338058, -0.012654478661715984, -0.028518397361040115, -0.01568957418203354, -0.04958772286772728, 0.02180277556180954, -0.10230516642332077, -0.017277777194976807, 0.06363936513662338, -0.06841500848531723, 0.025377916172146797, -0.028007688000798225, 0.0657537505030632, -0.013409595005214214, -0.00407666340470314, -0.038719210773706436, -0.045318908989429474, 0.05920136719942093, -0.039528943598270416, 0.005192157346755266, 0.034984178841114044, -0.021439079195261, -0.015137530863285065, -0.07166390120983124, 0.0544247180223465, 0.03809786215424538, 0.0841502994298935, 0.031816206872463226, -0.013425461947917938, 0.023284612223505974, 0.06130404397845268, 0.055920351296663284, 0.0022819754667580128, -0.030230941250920296, 0.03579891100525856, 0.03676474466919899, -0.0003487145877443254, -0.01360544003546238, -0.0053533450700342655, 0.0819956362247467, -0.019530709832906723, 0.00003328627281007357, 0.022410923615098, -0.024772288277745247, -0.03331835940480232, -0.0057357302866876125, -0.06421694159507751, -0.050377484411001205, -0.012921947985887527, 0.019152823835611343, -0.056756533682346344, 0.016268989071249962, -0.05121582746505737, -0.02797596901655197, 0.04283009469509125, -0.01377957221120596, 0.052395034581422806, 0.025090346112847328, -0.021752897650003433, 0.04634303227066994, -0.02682468481361866, -0.03975287824869156, 0.046176403760910034, 0.05085325986146927, -0.027455169707536697, -0.022648749873042107, -0.04435070604085922, 0.004665103275328875, 0.07583677768707275, 0.019863186404109, 0.06867839395999908, -0.06015189737081528, 0.026552237570285797, -0.05758526921272278, -0.039468914270401, -0.0016275022644549608, -0.04226420447230339, 0.05147561803460121, 0.07264448702335358, 0.023572245612740517, -0.004356497433036566, -0.030798308551311493, 0.008494354784488678, -0.025887586176395416, -0.039783068001270294, 0.032541804015636444, 0.018499230965971947, 0.0034578940831124783, 0.007395591586828232, 0.011839783750474453, 0.0352621003985405, -0.07481110095977783, 0.05098453164100647, -0.04261591657996178, 0.028330123052001, 0.07988397032022476, 0.0015584098873659968, 0.017044946551322937, 0.035889092832803726, -0.02288241684436798, 0.008277778513729572, 0.045540712773799896, -0.025184156373143196, 0.05780210718512535, 0.05592651292681694, 0.01655416563153267, 0.03893636539578438, -0.01897512376308441, -0.031205369159579277, 0.003035220317542553, 0.020973823964595795, -0.006435881834477186, -0.02833876945078373, 0.02992810681462288, 0.03711910545825958, 0.031695302575826645, -0.06472014635801315, -0.009238671511411667, 0.02121848240494728, -0.015300802886486053, -0.02007276937365532, 0.005136366002261639, 0.037140727043151855, -0.0012520650634542108, -0.07519017159938812, -0.007003500126302242, -0.0030838095117360353, 0.03815969079732895, -0.021083854138851166, -0.03529893979430199, 0.0026695383712649345, 0.046106018126010895, -0.03158444166183472, 0.019628779962658882, 0.06354747712612152, 0.03254212439060211, 0.030299661681056023, 0.04342612251639366, -0.02883199229836464, 0.015468847937881947, -0.02564670331776142, 0.032231055200099945, 0.00943584181368351, 0.051983319222927094, -0.02956179343163967, 0.021900108084082603, -0.05359555780887604, 0.011279860511422157, -0.008591839112341404, 0.01121910847723484, -0.04811371490359306, -0.0036736978217959404, -0.010382497683167458, 0.013673428446054459, 0.032156817615032196, -0.009493584744632244, -0.026995597407221794, 0.006516920868307352, 0.02537436969578266, 0.0806364119052887, 0.059104982763528824, 0.03125740960240364, -0.04103934392333031, 0.017901942133903503, -0.014414179138839245, -0.05482035130262375, 0.005537064746022224, -0.019481783732771873, -0.01392716821283102, -0.020149290561676025, 0.06048443913459778, -0.07870051264762878, -0.015541192144155502, 0.044504314661026, 0.013177724555134773, -0.01604313775897026, -0.00926461722701788, -0.005763491149991751, -0.018121950328350067, 0.05043414235115051, -0.051224760711193085, -0.00644946051761508, -0.03673572838306427, 0.0275176502764225, 0.009074431844055653, 0.06477104127407074, -0.047497257590293884, -0.03264482691884041, 0.032815657556056976, -0.031984128057956696, -0.009976457804441452, -0.026002487167716026, 0.05441876873373985, -0.012275608256459236, 0.031155196949839592, -0.020993547514081, 0.004451128654181957, 0.01076949667185545, 0.013166623190045357, 0.03910611569881439, -0.024679673835635185, 0.006950167007744312, -0.03408220410346985, -0.007178972940891981, 0.042979370802640915, 0.02789105474948883, -0.09604252129793167, -0.024373440071940422, 0.002343422034755349, -0.010502421297132969, 0.028833504766225815, -0.011224653571844101, -0.01435071136802435, -0.022592952474951744, -0.05444156751036644, 0.03815348818898201, -0.009362446144223213, 0.01033091451972723, 0.025001203641295433, -0.027760455384850502, -0.03116687759757042, -0.031373053789138794, -0.08708056807518005, -0.02171645127236843, 0.019812798127532005 ]
<p>Say there was some situation where you have a lot of subatomic particles interacting with each other and decided to draw (say, by joining Feynmann diagrams) those interactions- so that you got some sort of (?directed) graph... what kind of network would you obtain? Would it be scale-free? Would it be a complex network similar to a social network? What properties would it have?</p>
g6569
[ 0.02969035506248474, 0.04982119798660278, 0.009786328300833702, -0.006358083803206682, 0.0316331572830677, -0.021228333935141563, -0.032109931111335754, -0.01976359263062477, 0.017715992406010628, -0.07028331607580185, -0.03515097126364708, -0.0006400957936421037, 0.028444718569517136, -0.012860927730798721, -0.036379922181367874, 0.0224596057087183, -0.03842819482088089, -0.0057470486499369144, -0.03945701941847801, 0.027152813971042633, -0.033460911363363266, -0.004399317782372236, 0.04762564226984978, 0.0071921623311936855, 0.00438748300075531, -0.04125721752643585, 0.024927394464612007, -0.033054761588573456, -0.08058673143386841, -0.02778194099664688, -0.010267367586493492, 0.004853860940784216, 0.018853381276130676, -0.002148962579667568, -0.07452169805765152, -0.019444918259978294, -0.004288159776479006, -0.003410921199247241, 0.021170800551772118, 0.024297425523400307, -0.0062628332525491714, 0.014144696295261383, -0.05432172492146492, -0.05981040000915527, 0.016369745135307312, 0.032314151525497437, 0.004170180764049292, 0.012772906571626663, 0.01519610732793808, -0.0067805633880198, -0.018376590684056282, 0.03572748601436615, -0.0418611541390419, 0.00590594531968236, 0.04178513586521149, 0.03740887716412544, 0.04459337145090103, -0.022874346002936363, 0.08022750169038773, -0.0061287228018045425, -0.0013879064936190844, 0.028794733807444572, 0.013189352117478848, 0.02114207297563553, 0.00927624199539423, -0.0005636424757540226, -0.04529261216521263, 0.02169969491660595, 0.04498347267508507, -0.001990425633266568, -0.02558276616036892, -0.02928442694246769, 0.029026314616203308, 0.005839634221047163, 0.012289067730307579, 0.0957384929060936, -0.04678531736135483, 0.01389317400753498, 0.05576309189200401, 0.003170617623254657, -0.0728176087141037, -0.0661589577794075, 0.010541828349232674, -0.053208883851766586, 0.08879387378692627, -0.03609253093600273, -0.030938617885112762, -0.07355161011219025, -0.01794935017824173, 0.044652149081230164, 0.029140006750822067, -0.0176534503698349, 0.004525542259216309, -0.043772775679826736, 0.0047423336654901505, -0.023261241614818573, -0.0019087506225332618, -0.008921023458242416, -0.03781111538410187, -0.033483535051345825, -0.0031411596573889256, -0.04007092863321304, 0.010951090604066849, 0.0014491553883999586, -0.05472494661808014, -0.021167397499084473, -0.013498782180249691, -0.0051437984220683575, 0.057553283870220184, 0.02961985021829605, -0.01863054931163788, -0.06553268432617188, -0.01006556861102581, 0.04198969900608063, 0.046340636909008026, -0.053394243121147156, 0.007724445778876543, -0.014601116068661213, 0.040158793330192566, 0.05316254869103432, 0.028528261929750443, -0.06273971498012543, 0.02082126960158348, -0.03772474452853203, -0.0321480818092823, 0.04124665632843971, 0.02044462040066719, 0.043159618973731995, -0.05257760360836983, -0.0655963122844696, 0.03864806890487671, -0.049824308604002, -0.043909523636102676, 0.0633111521601677, -0.06879076361656189, 0.02355099469423294, -0.06772365421056747, -0.07096344977617264, -0.019020307809114456, -0.07393700629472733, 0.019459368661046028, -0.025060992687940598, -0.0679885596036911, -0.014325950294733047, -0.0075776828452944756, -0.05123463273048401, -0.00011296235607005656, -0.029234305024147034, 0.023570777848362923, 0.01975219137966633, -0.00895534548908472, 0.02333763800561428, -0.038142550736665726, -0.044616151601076126, 0.02533400058746338, -0.010416368022561073, 0.05638314411044121, -0.011786905117332935, 0.023519521579146385, -0.04696166142821312, 0.007754728198051453, -0.021564988419413567, 0.0010702447034418583, -0.004480043426156044, -0.03532704338431358, -0.03922557085752487, 0.06688801199197769, -0.03789447247982025, 0.005048059858381748, 0.015812944620847702, -0.04243079945445061, 0.0054666101932525635, -0.027305148541927338, 0.04598834738135338, -0.004224847536534071, 0.020739290863275528, -0.047653768211603165, 0.043325286358594894, 0.08724453300237656, 0.03549070283770561, 0.04230243340134621, 0.005520396865904331, 0.01952669769525528, -0.04784952476620674, 0.0030165258795022964, 0.012605921365320683, -0.0351499505341053, -0.0022491414565593004, 0.03482716903090477, -0.021022377535700798, -0.008793543092906475, -0.021851759403944016, -0.0060089100152254105, -0.02013608254492283, 0.029919035732746124, -0.03975733369588852, 0.026624327525496483, -0.06292221695184708, 0.06317489594221115, -0.017713263630867004, -0.008562516421079636, 0.02767295390367508, -0.009677140973508358, 0.02523629739880562, 0.037727538496255875, 0.028254061937332153, -0.05491023138165474, 0.018720557913184166, 0.037451185286045074, 0.014576178044080734, 0.05304818972945213, -0.025605084374547005, 0.024556664749979973, 0.0014531641500070691, -0.05210110917687416, -0.05128176882863045, -0.03318227082490921, 0.002148216590285301, 0.020911993458867073, 0.03227061778306961, 0.02057383581995964, -0.046785496175289154, -0.011197790503501892, -0.015849504619836807, 0.0687074214220047, -0.023417940363287926, -0.030037492513656616, 0.013277456164360046, -0.03840019926428795, 0.03396010026335716, -0.011387021280825138, 0.022303782403469086, -0.0039078486151993275, -0.05293148756027222, -0.023352256044745445, 0.013660254888236523, -0.0013905494706705213, -0.008142653852701187, -0.031372200697660446, 0.01763303205370903, 0.008364636451005936, -0.055011164397001266, 0.0025733003858476877, -0.024117646738886833, 0.00960988737642765, -0.011417718604207039, 0.02716776542365551, 0.059314921498298645, -0.025852292776107788, 0.01711377687752247, 0.08030281960964203, -0.009689935483038425, -0.003526306012645364, 0.011663916520774364, 0.006377680692821741, 0.048111140727996826, 0.01100864913314581, 0.051899176090955734, -0.032240789383649826, -0.020626869052648544, -0.027375590056180954, -0.055350396782159805, -0.029279449954628944, -0.005959453992545605, 0.010713057592511177, -0.03801656886935234, 0.047950707376003265, -0.03683727607131004, -0.042306553572416306, 0.001794734736904502, -0.04839747026562691, 0.008748323656618595, 0.015836019068956375, -0.017438329756259918, 0.03922213613986969, 0.08315488696098328, 0.03280383720993996, 0.021389897912740707, 0.01616097427904606, 0.01855836994946003, 0.021828748285770416, 0.039198171347379684, -0.014086293056607246, 0.07336512207984924, 0.029846802353858948, -0.037957482039928436, 0.03416081890463829, 0.00759406853467226, -0.039168503135442734, 0.017760545015335083, -0.00999822374433279, -0.03363485261797905, -0.003391875885426998, 0.007136175874620676, 0.015407437458634377, -0.02264765463769436, 0.029663274064660072, -0.01354192104190588, -0.030202701687812805, -0.014540627598762512, -0.02478671446442604, 0.014379002153873444, 0.07742851972579956, 0.018535666167736053, -0.023701516911387444, -0.050443023443222046, -0.1024903878569603, 0.010994172655045986, 0.006011987570673227, -0.02277872897684574, -0.02412208914756775, 0.056809648871421814, 0.01073782704770565, 0.06305301189422607, 0.03281719982624054, 0.0039467886090278625, 0.06018794700503349, 0.06090601161122322, 0.0074394200928509235, -0.07044532150030136, 0.027690786868333817, 0.023818111047148705, 0.0542038157582283, -0.04276398569345474, -0.01558183878660202, 0.03547496721148491, -0.010271388106048107, -0.0216253362596035, -0.021831462159752846, -0.007732539437711239, -0.04613494873046875, -0.053360067307949066, 0.044911906123161316, 0.010893912054598331, -0.06689337641000748, -0.05124164745211601, -0.031101463362574577, -0.0044503784738481045, 0.04183965176343918, 0.01917162910103798, -0.008491387590765953, -0.03435509651899338, -0.07825358957052231, -0.050392378121614456, -0.001810822170227766, 0.005152760539203882, 0.013946428894996643, -0.034475989639759064, 0.04031635820865631, -0.05974333733320236, -0.014576821587979794, -0.024368634447455406, -0.019597945734858513, -0.04565832391381264, 0.056406326591968536, -0.018818864598870277, 0.0008225374040193856, 0.02058253064751625, 0.001986426068469882, 0.006796190049499273, 0.002562212757766247, 0.012978125363588333, -0.08190401643514633, -0.016730062663555145, -0.013729983009397984, 0.013985197059810162, -0.026444941759109497, 0.006432024296373129, 0.06358083337545395, 0.0071865953505039215, 0.020346205681562424, -0.0131344273686409, -0.020276691764593124, 0.031995370984077454, -0.02739100530743599, 0.02509297803044319, -0.02434675768017769, -0.0176121536642313, 0.019623009487986565, -0.001298298710025847, -0.030792029574513435, 0.041210658848285675, -0.0016353745013475418, 0.025427917018532753, 0.03615756705403328, 0.031520482152700424, -0.04061507806181908, 0.003453219309449196, -0.0574159175157547, 0.07426098734140396, -0.02656649611890316, -0.01664581336081028, 0.02383553422987461, -0.00912350695580244, 0.02666461654007435, -0.020675519481301308, 0.04623600095510483, -0.025350144132971764, 0.021644432097673416, 0.021868864074349403, 0.016781941056251526, -0.02364841103553772, 0.013944262638688087, -0.06788572669029236, 0.04886964336037636, -0.097396619617939, -0.03450081869959831, -0.009797466918826103, 0.0231170617043972, -0.015850868076086044, -0.00781707651913166, -0.01414670143276453, 0.05775681883096695, -0.004483019933104515, -0.015129486098885536, -0.00838763453066349, 0.0012975961435586214, -0.04152952879667282, -0.011254847049713135, 0.023064324632287025, -0.023060530424118042, 0.039212170988321304, 0.006138708908110857, 0.042875535786151886, -0.024302886798977852, -0.020776882767677307, -0.024928545579314232, -0.010217363946139812, -0.0498444028198719, 0.01331998873502016, 0.004487201105803251, 0.01780928298830986, -0.026652971282601357, -0.026114175096154213, -0.05307236313819885, -0.007520867511630058, -0.020795810967683792, -0.015573468990623951, 0.014567023143172264, 0.038684237748384476, 0.019139397889375687, 0.03173244744539261, 0.05132335424423218, -0.051382094621658325, 0.03358488902449608, 0.050694629549980164, -0.034320391714572906, -0.03236687183380127, -0.09945414960384369, 0.016712576150894165, -0.01473546214401722, 0.008091912604868412, -0.07834096252918243, -0.029249219223856926, -0.04251188412308693, -0.02768237516283989, 0.0049718571826815605, 0.045503780245780945, 0.03174775093793869, -0.02552218735218048, -0.10245601087808609, 0.026566792279481888, 0.0059571294113993645, 0.011689314618706703, 0.018444299697875977, -0.04203954339027405, -0.0030092778615653515, -0.006383346393704414, -0.035947538912296295, -0.03519831970334053, 0.0033870080951601267, 0.023738998919725418, 0.07088322192430496, 0.05479169264435768, -0.043587565422058105, -0.02901328168809414, -0.019334867596626282, 0.03580671176314354, 0.00008944646833697334, -0.049116410315036774, 0.027645602822303772, 0.04760603979229927, 0.006796494126319885, -0.013435771688818932, -0.005376358982175589, 0.01838611252605915, -0.02075457200407982, 0.028007930144667625, -0.03402025252580643, -0.002662262413650751, 0.0012655967148020864, -0.01361445989459753, -0.02272096276283264, 0.03591984882950783, -0.0515279658138752, -0.08156370371580124, -0.027060577645897865, -0.0020604324527084827, 0.10727006942033768, 0.023818261921405792, 0.00884543638676405, 0.06996213644742966, -0.05190012976527214, -0.05131594091653824, -0.015650879591703415, 0.03406229987740517, 0.06896116584539413, -0.0688435286283493, -0.007289917673915625, 0.009518636390566826, -0.020133916288614273, -0.010887481272220612, -0.02963429130613804, 0.02526218257844448, -0.005178574472665787, 0.030157718807458878, -0.021136494353413582, -0.04342789947986603, -0.040610939264297485, 0.027680711820721626, 0.03276703506708145, -0.01770893484354019, 0.018522292375564575, -0.05829915776848793, -0.03786323592066765, 0.03813653439283371, -0.0971423089504242, 0.0347781702876091, 0.0014141469728201628, 0.08736533671617508, 0.03484395518898964, -0.0041330005042254925, -0.04110819473862648, 0.035848237574100494, 0.018680542707443237, 0.00043530575931072235, 0.019876163452863693, 0.05357348546385765, 0.06952835619449615, 0.013995871879160404, 0.05772017687559128, -0.02022586762905121, -0.009124625474214554, 0.03270183876156807, -0.01182458084076643, -0.05183958634734154, 0.04230153560638428, 0.0519607774913311, 0.033873606473207474, 0.03229137137532234, -0.033403024077415466, -0.03870571404695511, 0.004501551855355501, 0.02186592109501362, -0.04105350002646446, 0.008142668753862381, -0.012420975603163242, 0.030733764171600342, 0.017553122714161873, 0.06060023605823517, 0.03494172915816307, 0.0027754337061196566, 0.0049491217359900475, -0.045989640057086945, -0.030967118218541145, 0.007528490386903286, -0.08591446280479431, 0.005083282478153706, 0.04240081459283829, 0.054734837263822556, 0.012557242065668106, -0.047439396381378174, 0.024090241640806198, 0.0014036813518032432, -0.014540920965373516, -0.02037687599658966, 0.04391874000430107, 0.01921207830309868, -0.003152022836729884, 0.011148049496114254, -0.018709085881710052, -0.013078317046165466, 0.03452443704009056, -0.02342987433075905, -0.005521257873624563, 0.050020381808280945, 0.0005363739328458905, 0.011993655934929848, 0.007344376761466265, 0.017107531428337097, -0.027086863294243813, -0.0029117166996002197, -0.06880144774913788, -0.042371299117803574, 0.009978278540074825, -0.011388421058654785, 0.02533685974776745, -0.01349837239831686, -0.02346723899245262, 0.09362547099590302, -0.008469093590974808, 0.03395852446556091, -0.006931688170880079, 0.028168024495244026, 0.03107733465731144, 0.08679816126823425, 0.04157477244734764, 0.05919038876891136, -0.01368128415197134, -0.04090544953942299, -0.01583193987607956, 0.048456352204084396, 0.005629997234791517, 0.001080846879631281, 0.091163270175457, -0.04595815762877464, 0.026565980166196823, -0.051473211497068405, -0.029140232130885124, -0.06098966673016548, 0.0020456735510379076, -0.04854537174105644, 0.013052462600171566, -0.02035132795572281, 0.015320966951549053, 0.018714824691414833, -0.02158430777490139, 0.03234440088272095, 0.04891917109489441, 0.004919060505926609, 0.01515328511595726, 0.051890015602111816, 0.06287578493356705, 0.01747131161391735, -0.014589107595384121, 0.031581487506628036, -0.03729923442006111, 0.01837894879281521, 0.07851143181324005, 0.019544975832104683, -0.012167045846581459, 0.02971849963068962, 0.04705655574798584, 0.006587176583707333, 0.019170138984918594, -0.023263955488801003, 0.007593370042741299, 0.0373089499771595, -0.025665033608675003, 0.024905670434236526, 0.02338440716266632, -0.02032858319580555, -0.04433785378932953, 0.0036425194703042507, -0.009432842954993248, -0.07820300757884979, -0.046745967119932175, 0.04004824534058571, 0.0169199388474226, -0.04243004694581032, -0.08811687678098679, 0.024314220994710922, 0.009402884170413017, -0.004222244024276733, 0.021461207419633865, 0.04536094143986702, 0.009396795183420181, 0.013847032561898232, -0.045085374265909195, -0.009100033901631832, -0.039743244647979736, -0.0335901714861393, -0.02979285456240177, 0.05763379484415054, -0.005777232814580202, -0.04684546962380409, 0.02526143752038479, 0.0039047624450176954, 0.012760404497385025, 0.0062467739917337894, 0.01578621380031109, 0.02566005103290081, 0.04790323227643967, -0.00020377534383442253, -0.0071968683041632175, 0.04484818875789642, -0.009210631251335144, 0.0027281413786113262, -0.00014826850383542478, -0.06449902802705765, -0.0027568682562559843, 0.04020769149065018, -0.018966350704431534, -0.009068764746189117, 0.0053655714727938175, 0.014421059750020504, 0.008064717054367065, 0.04020882025361061, 0.04620911926031113, 0.07751858234405518, 0.04454893618822098, 0.03916657716035843, -0.022572513669729233, -0.005470298230648041, 0.03756635636091232, 0.030085237696766853, 0.004248512908816338, -0.03714984282851219, -0.006270348560065031, -0.06591132283210754, -0.015682943165302277, 0.08383675664663315, 0.04995174705982208, 0.08665087074041367, -0.012909023091197014, 0.027001183480024338, 0.0013494928134605289, -0.019397761672735214, 0.007154139690101147, 0.060700923204422, -0.032950837165117264, 0.02391050197184086, -0.011775730177760124, -0.025003336369991302, -0.0007386091747321188, -0.008709081448614597, -0.03522301837801933, -0.05324818938970566, -0.007882189005613327, 0.03318146988749504, 0.03470442816615105, 0.0011283529456704855, -0.03883541002869606, 0.053276512771844864, -0.015823934227228165, -0.061505451798439026, -0.0030602733604609966, 0.008158648386597633, -0.0161494929343462, -0.029681218788027763, 0.0031151073053479195, -0.013197533786296844, 0.008635975420475006, -0.010500233620405197, 0.059072017669677734, -0.018793394789099693, -0.02813107706606388, -0.021227093413472176, 0.05579402297735214, 0.005061394069343805, -0.035133007913827896, -0.02111017517745495, 0.053059786558151245, -0.022499023005366325, 0.05219433084130287, 0.0007158211665228009, 0.008721851743757725, 0.034090861678123474, 0.0030242688953876495, 0.013613516464829445, -0.0053849839605391026, 0.023319322615861893, -0.057525716722011566, 0.0774330347776413, -0.06393903493881226, 0.044707462191581726, 0.0039019424002617598, 0.038173872977495193 ]
<p>Imagine a bar </p> <p>spinning like a helicopter propeller,</p> <p>At $\omega$ rad/s because the extremes of the bar goes at speed</p> <p>$$V = \omega * r$$</p> <p>then we can reach near $c$ (speed of light) applying some <strong>finite</strong> amount of energy just doing </p> <p>$$\omega = V / r$$</p> <p>The bar should be long, low density, strong to minimize the amount of energy needed</p> <p>For example a $2000\,\mathrm{m}$ bar</p> <p>$$\omega = 300 000 \frac{\mathrm{rad}}{\mathrm{s}} = 2864789\,\mathrm{rpm}$$</p> <p>(a dental drill can commonly rotate at $400000\,\mathrm{rpm}$)</p> <p>$V$ (with dental drill) = 14% of speed of light.</p> <p>Then I say this experiment can be really made and bar extremes could approach $c$.</p> <p>What do you say? </p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>:</p> <p>Our planet is orbiting at sun and it's orbiting milky way, and who knows what else, then any Earth point have a speed of 500 km/s or more agains CMB.</p> <p>I wonder if we are orbiting something at that speed then there would be detectable relativist effect in different direction of measurements, simply extending a long bar or any directional mass in different galactic directions we should measure mass change due to relativity, simply because $V = \omega * r$</p> <p>What do you think?</p>
g121
[ 0.0002992994268424809, 0.028541600331664085, 0.0007578777731396258, -0.0041016265749931335, 0.07042388617992401, 0.020075399428606033, 0.03450152650475502, 0.04424915090203285, -0.03991790860891342, -0.03205393627285957, 0.0659453496336937, 0.01647229865193367, -0.01534285955131054, 0.0057978699915111065, 0.02775840274989605, -0.039894621819257736, 0.02189434878528118, -0.06931838393211365, 0.04411516338586807, 0.0723002478480339, 0.0008472837507724762, -0.040633101016283035, -0.0037133125588297844, -0.0031012401450425386, -0.01307513564825058, 0.001955146435648203, 0.03199896588921547, -0.015100889839231968, -0.0705094188451767, 0.04347509518265724, -0.03881236910820007, -0.07555165141820908, -0.0033294076565653086, -0.013973730616271496, -0.014558791182935238, -0.0988464504480362, 0.0003928857622668147, 0.05261551961302757, 0.0013661159900948405, -0.01100179087370634, -0.045899536460638046, 0.01231261808425188, 0.030240699648857117, -0.030752547085285187, 0.039765723049640656, 0.00553659163415432, 0.05794022977352142, 0.00534867262467742, 0.03231725096702576, -0.05647400766611099, -0.0653587281703949, -0.002243253169581294, 0.04107782989740372, 0.03535529226064682, 0.009995024651288986, 0.050946805626153946, -0.005044497083872557, -0.017443105578422546, 0.057843033224344254, -0.005921129137277603, -0.01355162262916565, -0.036900535225868225, 0.028571726754307747, 0.004168007988482714, -0.005949509795755148, 0.027358097955584526, -0.012007330544292927, -0.0007909281412139535, 0.011951749213039875, -0.011688023805618286, 0.032921914011240005, -0.03033122979104519, -0.026062069460749626, -0.015689797699451447, -0.06324440240859985, 0.012647831812500954, -0.00027650941046886146, -0.009211837314069271, -0.0009875994874164462, -0.006177206989377737, -0.029228709638118744, -0.03261449933052063, -0.03465747833251953, -0.01683845929801464, 0.05205874145030975, -0.024293938651680946, 0.015191926620900631, -0.020623769611120224, 0.01650167629122734, 0.0011035919887945056, 0.09858249127864838, -0.07572652399539948, 0.08737324923276901, 0.021135587245225906, -0.014040360227227211, -0.06456554681062698, 0.01653764210641384, 0.06960024684667587, -0.06104309856891632, -0.0014675197890028358, 0.0017436760244891047, 0.022506875917315483, -0.01729414612054825, 0.05565608665347099, -0.024627994745969772, -0.02504199557006359, 0.016541337594389915, 0.012905786745250225, 0.0012203669175505638, -0.04245106875896454, 0.0012120018946006894, -0.05175641551613808, 0.013586342334747314, -0.03641800954937935, -0.043076060712337494, -0.018478771671652794, 0.09018352627754211, -0.016422787681221962, -0.007023911457508802, 0.061715930700302124, 0.10009138286113739, 0.020889626815915108, -0.026491738855838776, 0.08114492148160934, -0.01705395244061947, 0.013162089511752129, 0.01408146321773529, -0.0027976869605481625, 0.01787242479622364, -0.01686706207692623, -0.03690730035305023, 0.01518484391272068, -0.011690070852637291, -0.0015139690367504954, -0.019834177568554878, 0.012944867834448814, -0.05402743071317673, 0.020176243036985397, -0.007094257511198521, -0.00043036480201408267, -0.001935489010065794, -0.02062220312654972, 0.0078102946281433105, 0.0017760891932994127, -0.02951357699930668, 0.025904064998030663, -0.03238477185368538, 0.0671287477016449, 0.0719514712691307, 0.023468922823667526, 0.010227885097265244, 0.053008247166872025, 0.009868750348687172, 0.0020361703354865313, 0.012901172041893005, 0.02609942853450775, 0.02278246358036995, 0.02685609459877014, 0.021614501252770424, 0.06034237891435623, 0.019549792632460594, 0.009095821529626846, 0.003941519185900688, -0.04365845024585724, -0.06793203204870224, 0.026045726612210274, -0.005100992973893881, 0.006538847927004099, 0.012987582944333553, -0.008966140449047089, -0.10802336037158966, -0.02966384030878544, 0.02607836201786995, 0.006759576499462128, 0.03255942091345787, 0.023303302004933357, 0.01078443881124258, -0.008551589213311672, -0.021838145330548286, 0.0488961823284626, 0.002601673360913992, -0.03933728113770485, 0.02848653309047222, -0.031090622767806053, 0.014440045692026615, 0.032866138964891434, 0.03569864109158516, -0.02068150043487549, -0.033566996455192566, -0.034495968371629715, -0.0029629687778651714, -0.006802330259233713, -0.014646019786596298, 0.0074775926768779755, -0.023781249299645424, 0.05359119549393654, 0.040912263095378876, -0.050710201263427734, -0.04310661181807518, 0.06888409703969955, -0.022014833986759186, 0.052819475531578064, 0.0392954982817173, 0.020079148933291435, -0.0033351543825119734, -0.052316244691610336, 0.0019440988544374704, -0.013976461254060268, 0.019064990803599358, 0.027225429192185402, 0.1351460963487625, 0.011252771131694317, -0.030967434868216515, 0.030871855095028877, 0.010845774784684181, 0.00619771471247077, 0.018160762265324593, 0.028527431190013885, 0.027533169835805893, 0.02996770478785038, 0.017992187291383743, 0.00009110421524383128, 0.020590031519532204, 0.005347845144569874, -0.01917342282831669, -0.04581904783844948, -0.058058854192495346, -0.027352644130587578, 0.049000080674886703, 0.005571604240685701, 0.005893345922231674, 0.06829095631837845, 0.061226192861795425, 0.018141349777579308, 0.05391762778162956, 0.0005185852060094476, -0.0017052387120202184, 0.007406826596707106, -0.03707977011799812, 0.006376804783940315, 0.045603375881910324, -0.04330041632056236, -0.057014092803001404, -0.031158005818724632, 0.0012550265528261662, -0.06830891966819763, 0.002345590153709054, 0.03624289855360985, 0.015531770884990692, 0.023353103548288345, 0.05319053679704666, 0.016023680567741394, -0.03288937360048294, 0.014077947475016117, 0.014793282374739647, -0.018429651856422424, -0.027774285525083542, 0.0683235451579094, -0.0849895104765892, -0.036421969532966614, -0.04322524741292, 0.02646471932530403, 0.002700354205444455, -0.011377821676433086, -0.025994641706347466, -0.006367656867951155, -0.04010181874036789, -0.0037415619008243084, -0.026100153103470802, -0.005275551695376635, -0.041492730379104614, -0.013478069566190243, 0.039674606174230576, 0.02725064754486084, 0.00006551970000145957, 0.016010291874408722, 0.012750626541674137, -0.028103496879339218, 0.01679306849837303, 0.004294015001505613, -0.010289368219673634, 0.03579523041844368, -0.06612462550401688, 0.009778606705367565, -0.020896630361676216, -0.01483162585645914, -0.0019520382629707456, -0.001390931662172079, -0.05612002685666084, 0.024164985865354538, 0.026255924254655838, 0.011483142152428627, 0.0357716828584671, 0.0061824265867471695, 0.056016191840171814, 0.058906059712171555, 0.07177631556987762, 0.01861124485731125, 0.008867292664945126, 0.0031223874539136887, 0.020624009892344475, -0.03348119929432869, -0.03593062236905098, 0.04109000787138939, -0.04794461652636528, 0.008887328207492828, -0.03436914458870888, -0.02723105065524578, 0.019302986562252045, -0.0047141555696725845, 0.030800430104136467, 0.0704769715666771, 0.02452852763235569, 0.018580658361315727, -0.06508670747280121, 0.005331291351467371, -0.035745732486248016, -0.005204963032156229, 0.010667462833225727, -0.044708892703056335, 0.052077457308769226, -0.06698215752840042, -0.03176213428378105, -0.04211971163749695, 0.03493289276957512, 0.02102208137512207, -0.0339462049305439, -0.036936186254024506, -0.07721304893493652, -0.011237331666052341, 0.052708931267261505, 0.07982850074768066, -0.007337877061218023, 0.02862791158258915, -0.06772603839635849, -0.016999557614326477, 0.012463272549211979, 0.05100226402282715, 0.06581282615661621, 0.06661307066679001, -0.026762695983052254, -0.025748198851943016, -0.017955908551812172, 0.004059091676026583, 0.002799655543640256, 0.06913003325462341, -0.0024615481961518526, 0.01079302653670311, -0.023531323298811913, -0.022009020671248436, 0.022626278921961784, -0.04010860621929169, -0.021522000432014465, -0.03346201032400131, 0.06884205341339111, 0.02485618367791176, 0.05603225529193878, 0.04763428494334221, 0.06270162016153336, -0.060418568551540375, 0.0017585947643965483, 0.03810816630721092, 0.006516410503536463, -0.009358738549053669, -0.031991224735975266, 0.038185153156518936, -0.01309483777731657, 0.021191729232668877, -0.05064387992024422, 0.008522072806954384, 0.012362692505121231, -0.03829047456383705, -0.0054149869829416275, -0.008238394744694233, 0.020795775577425957, -0.024952640756964684, 0.01732008531689644, 0.027883470058441162, 0.006593378260731697, 0.03884375840425491, 0.025655442848801613, -0.002583123743534088, -0.009712609462440014, -0.03989417850971222, -0.061982277780771255, 0.02224596217274666, -0.024165015667676926, -0.044273409992456436, -0.022461825981736183, -0.012178987264633179, -0.0013318895362317562, -0.03170844539999962, 0.04035612568259239, 0.022319357842206955, -0.010704009793698788, -0.030030632391572, 0.058003585785627365, -0.06999482959508896, -0.06783581525087357, 0.022173358127474785, -0.03763915225863457, 0.015868112444877625, 0.014920924790203571, 0.007877834141254425, -0.08768266439437866, -0.08039690554141998, 0.034670256078243256, -0.02031782828271389, -0.032277967780828476, -0.0034746380988508463, 0.02223079837858677, -0.06422857195138931, 0.002241650829091668, -0.0755530372262001, 0.030408009886741638, 0.031378377228975296, -0.015710564330220222, -0.011551854200661182, 0.04679064825177193, 0.04921776056289673, -0.020896868780255318, 0.07326066493988037, 0.008011672645807266, -0.011737629771232605, 0.012803700752556324, 0.06346053630113602, -0.003575066337361932, -0.00744610046967864, 0.048071373254060745, -0.00833978597074747, 0.035674821585416794, -0.011867167428135872, -0.0340767428278923, 0.007228825706988573, -0.009401503019034863, 0.05637926608324051, -0.007183460518717766, 0.017834920436143875, 0.005723467096686363, 0.0022857473231852055, -0.017042353749275208, 0.002095677424222231, 0.024219369515776634, -0.019204633310437202, -0.03233543410897255, 0.07914264500141144, -0.039841584861278534, -0.04538724943995476, -0.010548129677772522, -0.01164034940302372, -0.0740981251001358, -0.003080120775848627, 0.005208468530327082, 0.035423923283815384, 0.03911937028169632, -0.03922354429960251, -0.014386658556759357, 0.05794944241642952, 0.037812378257513046, 0.07596118748188019, -0.06876068562269211, -0.003924235701560974, 0.04718368127942085, -0.005374398082494736, 0.010561130940914154, -0.011468390002846718, -0.036284469068050385, -0.07714367657899857, -0.03899126872420311, -0.013572687283158302, -0.06536322832107544, -0.0008113232324831188, 0.02082691714167595, 0.061660055071115494, -0.035558927804231644, 0.008065969683229923, 0.01759413816034794, -0.02900305949151516, -0.03192973881959915, -0.08066631108522415, -0.07649468630552292, -0.0008990535861812532, 0.02730601094663143, -0.05491974949836731, -0.02651957981288433, -0.00018440881103742868, -0.13195191323757172, -0.0071314130909740925, -0.0312368031591177, -0.02157871052622795, 0.006891798228025436, 0.04001326858997345, -0.039977654814720154, -0.06444956362247467, 0.01322374027222395, 0.01814231462776661, -0.03615803271532059, -0.055893536657094955, -0.029769157990813255, -0.02786080539226532, -0.034045081585645676, 0.06944797188043594, -0.0294894278049469, -0.0017625143518671393, -0.07079005241394043, 0.04621215537190437, 0.023346461355686188, 0.023058127611875534, -0.04100719094276428, 0.05114399269223213, -0.05736716836690903, 0.025559036061167717, 0.03058028593659401, -0.017167771235108376, -0.02064727619290352, -0.017996633425354958, 0.053797151893377304, 0.047934696078300476, 0.0376291498541832, -0.08512528240680695, -0.009966994635760784, -0.020739642903208733, 0.05371775105595589, -0.006984005216509104, 0.003298515686765313, 0.005868976470082998, -0.026369864121079445, 0.020827507600188255, 0.020748067647218704, -0.02671387605369091, 0.027620848268270493, -0.02245977334678173, 0.04382087290287018, -0.027686510235071182, -0.039684269577264786, -0.006205274257808924, 0.0612478032708168, 0.009825249202549458, -0.021283704787492752, -0.07094036787748337, -0.009264971129596233, -0.016935333609580994, 0.05159727483987808, 0.06549414992332458, 0.07341060787439346, -0.005799423437565565, -0.06902074068784714, -0.010095205157995224, 0.04384704306721687, -0.0063590994104743, 0.00661240192130208, -0.011604436673223972, -0.027181077748537064, 0.005909981671720743, 0.0028860196471214294, 0.018681585788726807, 0.00739454198628664, -0.08534352481365204, -0.038621366024017334, -0.0347316712141037, 0.016211848706007004, 0.021008174866437912, 0.03683413192629814, 0.0386626273393631, -0.0024894087109714746, -0.06440093368291855, 0.04145136848092079, -0.04665485769510269, 0.054162248969078064, 0.05419488996267319, -0.048239246010780334, 0.0039020408876240253, -0.03846229612827301, -0.0014847646234557033, 0.06886273622512817, -0.000841817120090127, 0.03315965086221695, 0.008581328205764294, -0.0070029920898377895, -0.023931866511702538, -0.0028756738174706697, -0.009346887469291687, 0.015682360157370567, 0.016413329169154167, 0.014272517524659634, -0.006390996277332306, -0.0007311075460165739, 0.022717289626598358, 0.019276434555649757, -0.0904567688703537, -0.00585465831682086, -0.017200812697410583, 0.00391924474388361, -0.06314809620380402, -0.07350613921880722, -0.022604867815971375, 0.01853089965879917, -0.08493909239768982, -0.03004981391131878, 0.001389473327435553, -0.023702112957835197, -0.02075088955461979, 0.02283303439617157, 0.019613657146692276, 0.010051356628537178, -0.025664987042546272, -0.012658655643463135, -0.005998016335070133, 0.054460927844047546, -0.0029567398596554995, -0.021360671147704124, 0.051523737609386444, 0.020334260538220406, -0.012736907228827477, -0.02839871309697628, 0.011768200434744358, 0.0376216396689415, -0.014376289211213589, 0.044565796852111816, 0.02692941203713417, 0.028603380545973778, -0.004199714865535498, 0.0040852767415344715, -0.05071217194199562, 0.0022940081544220448, 0.03665362671017647, -0.03861382603645325, 0.002777277957648039, 0.012265107594430447, 0.02510955184698105, 0.031104030087590218, 0.004160190932452679, -0.0005421385867521167, 0.05192144960165024, -0.0029659124556928873, 0.05667721480131149, -0.0356663279235363, 0.03914313390851021, 0.031241662800312042, 0.015917649492621422, 0.04095236584544182, -0.030562642961740494, -0.018598543480038643, 0.03414812684059143, -0.015609491616487503, 0.026798779144883156, 0.033235739916563034, 0.007710004225373268, 0.0022934461012482643, -0.011673377826809883, 0.002615920966491103, -0.07029582560062408, -0.02599225379526615, -0.007239774335175753, -0.021130379289388657, 0.02800823748111725, 0.046858638525009155, -0.007783082779496908, -0.0061241937801241875, -0.0718531385064125, -0.014874027110636234, -0.010960056446492672, 0.012753564864397049, -0.024069031700491905, -0.03510412201285362, 0.027065150439739227, -0.049733966588974, -0.02020302414894104, -0.042843110859394073, -0.015560219995677471, 0.004305270966142416, -0.04757003113627434, -0.03410516306757927, -0.02671317756175995, -0.008422354236245155, 0.01589563861489296, 0.011893673799932003, -0.015818437561392784, -0.029221132397651672, 0.011831012554466724, 0.0028131038416177034, 0.06501752138137817, -0.03570093587040901, 0.029057595878839493, -0.009599900804460049, 0.03815096989274025, -0.057753756642341614, -0.022197987884283066, -0.00868821982294321, -0.019900599494576454, -0.03920108824968338, 0.06404951959848404, -0.01979856938123703, -0.016119014471769333, 0.0038343851920217276, 0.015245995484292507, 0.004279971122741699, 0.04524807259440422, -0.015005511231720448, 0.011081493459641933, -0.028925934806466103, 0.005519603844732046, 0.04183589294552803, 0.006312580779194832, 0.006536285392940044, 0.06162337586283684, -0.012154911644756794, -0.003293307265266776, -0.021028924733400345, 0.013376599177718163, 0.0335390567779541, 0.08079438656568527, 0.0021784764248877764, 0.004925994668155909, -0.004130844492465258, 0.058144401758909225, -0.014205551706254482, -0.005208136513829231, 0.02839469723403454, -0.047750167548656464, -0.028923939913511276, 0.025173531845211983, -0.013312974944710732, -0.028752008453011513, -0.009772959165275097, -0.027591003105044365, -0.005494334269315004, -0.037709444761276245, -0.0060155559331178665, -0.0322905071079731, 0.05929827317595482, -0.010204309597611427, -0.07391010224819183, 0.016764366999268532, -0.057738855481147766, 0.009018098004162312, -0.010798635892570019, 0.03666264936327934, -0.01663106679916382, 0.05497629940509796, 0.0026831994764506817, -0.031629811972379684, -0.017924731597304344, -0.01612408272922039, 0.04548553377389908, -0.0030286095570772886, 0.006328917574137449, 0.028022149577736855, 0.036382533609867096, 0.007048426195979118, -0.016948165372014046, 0.06202095001935959, -0.015613996423780918, 0.035968564450740814, 0.0006882637972012162, -0.04638595134019852, 0.02613341063261032, -0.029338497668504715, -0.002815962303429842, -0.01798449456691742, 0.026411905884742737, -0.008287535980343819, -0.006716058123856783, -0.037020906805992126, 0.025881994515657425, -0.04726119339466095, 0.004592185374349356, 0.01693265326321125 ]
<p>Assume we have a conveyor scales. Which consists of scales, and motor with conveyor belt placed above, so that the boxes can be measured (weight) while moving above. What I want is to create the model of the oscillations of that scale. The equation of the oscillations of the spring is well known for everybody. How to include the influence of the motor, conveyor and other important effects to the system? Is there any papers (articles) about this thema? I think that the influence of the motor in simle case can be modelled as the force: $F(t) = A sin(\Omega t)$ Where $A$ is a constant and $\Omega$ is the parameter which depends on the motor (frequency), which is also constant (depending on the speed of the motor). How to add the ocsillations created by conveyor belt and may be some other oscillations such as box moving above can create additional vibrations?</p> <p>EDIT 1: I want to crate the model. I have created one for a scales, but without conveyor and motor. It seems that they do not match. The data of the model and the real data of the conveyor with scales. So there sems to be a big influence of a motor, conveyor belt etc. And what I want is to identify what has a big influence and include it inside the system. So that my model will match the real system. I don't care of some influences which do not make big difference. It is difficult to identify what makes a big influence. And It is more difficult to model for example the moving of the conveyor with or without a box above. How to do it?</p>
g226
[ 0.013434459455311298, 0.04803710803389549, -0.01951802708208561, -0.025821417570114136, 0.04877888038754463, -0.000011699728929670528, 0.01948205940425396, 0.017736254259943962, -0.046659328043460846, -0.0300455205142498, -0.05407201871275902, -0.02337820455431938, 0.09697231650352478, 0.04673376306891441, 0.0063874488696455956, 0.01821398176252842, 0.04747135564684868, -0.011425474658608437, 0.023905055597424507, 0.02371770143508911, 0.06625814735889435, 0.02862754464149475, -0.01164040993899107, -0.05446821078658104, 0.0076401736587285995, 0.05370175838470459, 0.0002882292028516531, 0.005051749758422375, 0.024474384263157845, 0.027419155463576317, -0.05753457546234131, 0.0011081876000389457, 0.01273224875330925, -0.027829105034470558, -0.07177712768316269, -0.03400807827711105, 0.03511100262403488, 0.0071712383069098, -0.006774932611733675, 0.012352382764220238, 0.015938548371195793, -0.016050605103373528, -0.011905874125659466, 0.008865460753440857, -0.028274191543459892, -0.03943418711423874, 0.01741681806743145, -0.07167254388332367, -0.0035568480379879475, 0.06593779474496841, -0.0253280121833086, -0.03689100593328476, -0.01238104235380888, 0.029333019629120827, 0.0072699617594480515, -0.02855309471487999, 0.04854650795459747, -0.012132961302995682, 0.05182139202952385, 0.004598659463226795, -0.02760847844183445, 0.0019466442754492164, 0.005795123986899853, 0.03101821430027485, 0.0356023944914341, 0.012190202251076698, 0.0189713966101408, -0.023321688175201416, -0.012291869148612022, -0.018399164080619812, 0.03584522753953934, 0.053309157490730286, -0.033770881593227386, -0.04211724177002907, -0.02342352829873562, 0.07165779918432236, 0.00560389831662178, 0.002608490874990821, 0.01600066013634205, 0.01463763602077961, -0.010691634379327297, 0.03313538432121277, 0.0471620112657547, 0.00898869801312685, 0.04193677380681038, -0.0007181106484495103, -0.05861242488026619, 0.01710180565714836, 0.03485323488712311, -0.015190416015684605, -0.023123260587453842, -0.056194208562374115, 0.008764919824898243, 0.021084878593683243, -0.008606838062405586, -0.042856764048337936, -0.019299954175949097, 0.08699849992990494, 0.00808300543576479, 0.022184062749147415, 0.004969313740730286, 0.003230439266189933, -0.05465347692370415, -0.024714548140764236, -0.0647839680314064, -0.0378996767103672, 0.05746999755501747, -0.052549343556165695, 0.027118019759655, -0.019901419058442116, -0.026028228923678398, -0.060074977576732635, -0.034183867275714874, 0.012489157728850842, -0.024815663695335388, -0.10692588239908218, 0.0720323994755745, 0.021339301019906998, -0.04102785140275955, -0.010526749305427074, 0.020249031484127045, -0.05677980184555054, -0.03179236128926277, 0.024173520505428314, 0.006248703692108393, -0.031834255903959274, -0.003549744375050068, 0.01615802012383938, -0.034085363149642944, -0.052745115011930466, 0.05120290070772171, -0.009865070693194866, 0.01882971078157425, 0.029269810765981674, 0.0434320792555809, 0.0788264349102974, -0.0033521850127726793, 0.014612993225455284, 0.0014507832238450646, 0.01788058876991272, 0.0336868092417717, 0.046536192297935486, -0.02664949931204319, 0.009414485655725002, 0.02113363705575466, 0.0543467216193676, 0.03403104096651077, -0.013580217957496643, 0.025727326050400734, -0.042913973331451416, 0.032792940735816956, 0.1138821616768837, -0.08116276562213898, -0.02991747297346592, -0.024950796738266945, 0.002461077179759741, -0.02044081501662731, 0.013652744702994823, -0.021523522213101387, -0.029932063072919846, 0.04535916820168495, -0.03249412029981613, 0.07354287058115005, -0.013068502768874168, -0.03556601330637932, -0.00070177111774683, 0.0013556889025494456, 0.0061754886992275715, -0.002400075551122427, 0.043297480791807175, -0.08318080753087997, -0.028945911675691605, 0.03248574957251549, 0.004634391516447067, 0.020504888147115707, 0.03899352252483368, 0.039143625646829605, -0.01514430157840252, 0.10841237753629684, 0.005369642283767462, -0.007731283083558083, -0.032891932874917984, -0.002749269362539053, -0.014536628499627113, -0.06268323212862015, 0.01885266788303852, 0.056845057755708694, 0.0318174883723259, -0.03644881024956703, 0.024096060544252396, -0.009979658760130405, 0.002922273240983486, 0.043080687522888184, -0.0005034629139117897, -0.0361100435256958, 0.012072605080902576, 0.036578740924596786, -0.047881465405225754, -0.042008426040410995, -0.03953888267278671, -0.00017615326214581728, 0.02483503147959709, 0.028366457670927048, 0.023921266198158264, 0.00243886630050838, -0.004630975890904665, -0.02415737695991993, -0.01018444262444973, -0.05641007795929909, 0.02678297646343708, -0.029485361650586128, -0.024117834866046906, -0.01538077276200056, 0.03846586123108864, 0.004723086953163147, 0.0031875777058303356, 0.03153296560049057, 0.006964126601815224, 0.02285092882812023, 0.04529185965657234, -0.02055729739367962, -0.024312438443303108, 0.07818520069122314, 0.006888386327773333, -0.03734288737177849, -0.018932301551103592, 0.004665964748710394, -0.005242344923317432, -0.021130520850419998, 0.03525373712182045, -0.012382693588733673, -0.033223994076251984, 0.049518004059791565, -0.044665127992630005, -0.006473151966929436, -0.024352187290787697, 0.002880165819078684, -0.019363058730959892, 0.010760754346847534, 0.015522127039730549, 0.0751725286245346, -0.028334127739071846, 0.025627408176660538, -0.09768117964267731, -0.015546003356575966, -0.009709234349429607, 0.02495047077536583, 0.03818569704890251, -0.0057184998877346516, 0.02231273613870144, -0.01153661124408245, 0.014297764748334885, 0.009884358383715153, -0.027893804013729095, 0.04431592673063278, 0.013541627675294876, -0.017193954437971115, 0.01035831868648529, -0.01661231741309166, -0.01239774003624916, -0.0034743815194815397, -0.00698263943195343, 0.015375897288322449, 0.08398527652025223, -0.011130188591778278, -0.05660655349493027, 0.028590282425284386, -0.062400929629802704, -0.03820442408323288, -0.007519796025007963, -0.009496418759226799, -0.006714990362524986, -0.0854601338505745, -0.024515826255083084, 0.02528289705514908, 0.0062763886526227, 0.011473388411104679, -0.052984610199928284, -0.012633373960852623, -0.007826854474842548, 0.03511831536889076, -0.035534705966711044, 0.03190174326300621, -0.026825085282325745, 0.03519807010889053, 0.008741083554923534, 0.03387074172496796, -0.023741938173770905, 0.0236891508102417, -0.007253178395330906, -0.025582704693078995, 0.029217101633548737, -0.012373500503599644, -0.014161573722958565, -0.05846673250198364, 0.09460830688476562, 0.022294476628303528, -0.03854380175471306, -0.0012883188901469111, 0.057515859603881836, 0.028628185391426086, -0.04442385584115982, 0.03150906786322594, 0.0031194626353681087, -0.010072973556816578, 0.012773726135492325, -0.009737785905599594, 0.02848471887409687, 0.04755912348628044, 0.03138432279229164, -0.06718140095472336, -0.020068848505616188, 0.015116303227841854, 0.004510643891990185, -0.08348531275987625, 0.014376284554600716, -0.022128703072667122, -0.018062110990285873, 0.005177139770239592, -0.052538514137268066, 0.013878650031983852, -0.09041205793619156, 0.060202740132808685, -0.06658782809972763, -0.015490585006773472, 0.04082173481583595, -0.0131594929844141, 0.044509053230285645, -0.015586293302476406, -0.013819152489304543, 0.005254453048110008, 0.014755397103726864, 0.017970310524106026, -0.030033092945814133, -0.048554450273513794, -0.057722751051187515, -0.025728359818458557, -0.045102789998054504, -0.006264146417379379, 0.043159227818250656, 0.0056836348958313465, 0.01968224160373211, 0.01420801505446434, -0.019022531807422638, -0.06656065583229065, -0.0018546001520007849, -0.04154686629772186, 0.0037048719823360443, 0.03574845567345619, -0.08566927909851074, 0.05269751697778702, 0.011937043629586697, -0.005349012557417154, -0.015682397410273552, 0.011499329470098019, -0.017814503982663155, 0.0697064995765686, 0.03587448596954346, -0.05207101255655289, -0.004805699922144413, 0.02278839983046055, -0.026199687272310257, -0.010830892249941826, 0.05838998407125473, 0.04846847429871559, -0.0037216758355498314, -0.011944865807890892, 0.05930471792817116, -0.02979748509824276, -0.01461192686110735, -0.003815804608166218, -0.02133760415017605, 0.019456224516034126, -0.010266979224979877, 0.074479840695858, 0.0106118842959404, 0.0879555270075798, 0.04683711752295494, -0.034701231867074966, 0.04066312313079834, -0.0008950908086262643, 0.03692102059721947, -0.011429416947066784, -0.0777733102440834, 0.06189664453268051, -0.0321626216173172, 0.030531615018844604, 0.010591466911137104, 0.010059421882033348, 0.015544397756457329, 0.01747983507812023, -0.07437438517808914, -0.049432072788476944, 0.009712315164506435, 0.08200966566801071, -0.009283754043281078, -0.002984208520501852, -0.041967231780290604, -0.020991157740354538, -0.016450101509690285, 0.0016505439998582006, 0.0013197254156693816, 0.004123111721128225, 0.06141003221273422, 0.002088327892124653, -0.010876982472836971, 0.05187281593680382, -0.04201919957995415, 0.02706913836300373, 0.04077264666557312, -0.0622028224170208, -0.03865012526512146, 0.010733568109571934, -0.03335336595773697, -0.021093472838401794, 0.02934947796165943, 0.07435634732246399, 0.019036412239074707, 0.008626990020275116, 0.007890770211815834, 0.013561796396970749, 0.10671577602624893, -0.019494423642754555, -0.008939719758927822, -0.046565767377614975, 0.028943859040737152, 0.02412673830986023, -0.0661705806851387, -0.022539524361491203, -0.05181148275732994, -0.05933055281639099, 0.05722282454371452, 0.005164617206901312, 0.062356848269701004, -0.038180649280548096, 0.056098707020282745, -0.01302141323685646, -0.009926718659698963, -0.03327370434999466, -0.013342170044779778, 0.0047217486426234245, 0.02870260551571846, -0.011303463950753212, 0.01734975166618824, -0.0614924319088459, 0.04416259750723839, -0.042009640485048294, -0.0023565611336380243, -0.018919354304671288, 0.013203008100390434, -0.01869865506887436, 0.02813216671347618, -0.03218992054462433, 0.0031717855017632246, 0.02331455424427986, 0.02113192528486252, 0.019178632646799088, -0.053562138229608536, 0.025408228859305382, -0.04895811900496483, -0.02121208794414997, -0.032706089317798615, -0.05676114931702614, -0.0026057041250169277, -0.031368594616651535, -0.05936913192272186, -0.037673868238925934, -0.004315405618399382, 0.002261210698634386, -0.020010290667414665, 0.05362243577837944, -0.024593411013484, 0.019642844796180725, 0.06656758487224579, 0.00592674408107996, 0.010759279131889343, -0.03611200302839279, -0.022236881777644157, 0.002785977441817522, 0.027663517743349075, -0.005843526218086481, -0.012223605066537857, 0.034768689423799515, -0.052777718752622604, -0.03175966814160347, -0.04949698969721794, 0.004312017001211643, 0.02575915865600109, 0.03159092366695404, 0.008396987803280354, 0.04702945053577423, 0.08355142921209335, -0.017524464055895805, -0.0037042247131466866, -0.012024400755763054, 0.021029137074947357, 0.0002868907176889479, -0.005664879456162453, 0.04014920815825462, -0.03132639825344086, -0.00934942252933979, 0.05216766893863678, -0.003994010388851166, 0.020476028323173523, -0.03972044587135315, -0.02456211857497692, 0.023134766146540642, 0.004166718106716871, -0.008543970994651318, 0.014475459232926369, -0.02924646995961666, 0.08598687499761581, -0.027757035568356514, 0.02066059224307537, -0.0258057601749897, -0.008831959217786789, 0.014599652960896492, 0.007027490064501762, -0.023017704486846924, -0.01072858925908804, 0.035453833639621735, -0.05557192862033844, 0.07551339268684387, -0.040231429040431976, -0.012640737928450108, 0.0037827682681381702, -0.03406520187854767, -0.026331715285778046, 0.02623952180147171, 0.008020355366170406, 0.04152533411979675, 0.011049240827560425, -0.011686979793012142, 0.02445119433104992, 0.03809855505824089, -0.026683982461690903, 0.045507874339818954, 0.05634268373250961, -0.016706641763448715, -0.046019427478313446, -0.0032577626407146454, -0.025569168850779533, 0.04268653318285942, 0.0022351103834807873, 0.03362544625997543, -0.04655516520142555, 0.004068159963935614, -0.005758270155638456, 0.030348924919962883, 0.020533375442028046, 0.0034880347084254026, 0.03534119948744774, 0.019870664924383163, 0.04662982374429703, -0.0750972256064415, 0.024945033714175224, -0.02416139654815197, -0.056837163865566254, 0.009985178709030151, 0.0441402830183506, 0.047789257019758224, 0.04693014547228813, 0.04637395218014717, -0.023006107658147812, -0.025326207280158997, 0.058924973011016846, -0.013490238226950169, -0.0019140439108014107, 0.07512304186820984, 0.0850561186671257, -0.010703875683248043, -0.0034461012110114098, 0.03843936324119568, 0.036391835659742355, -0.010060679167509079, 0.008580626919865608, -0.02600298821926117, -0.051415715366601944, -0.028053009882569313, 0.03399328887462616, -0.03584897145628929, 0.01032119058072567, 0.011170830577611923, -0.004917961545288563, -0.03553199768066406, -0.013053258880972862, -0.058329369872808456, -0.02808373235166073, -0.019367484375834465, 0.0020250161178410053, 0.018229130655527115, -0.05185270681977272, -0.03323832526803017, -0.010446016676723957, 0.017726842314004898, -0.01915101893246174, -0.037504058331251144, 0.0052345190197229385, 0.06258541345596313, 0.03349814563989639, 0.0064764912240207195, -0.00977262295782566, 0.018383437767624855, 0.003269069129601121, 0.010164963081479073, 0.007087879814207554, -0.059989772737026215, -0.007535744924098253, 0.018228894099593163, 0.04690595716238022, 0.007722995709627867, 0.0397072471678257, 0.014617341570556164, 0.039590347558259964, 0.05690326169133186, -0.003267005318775773, 0.006362693849951029, -0.0020545595325529575, 0.01142682321369648, -0.024393534287810326, -0.010725441388785839, -0.030814407393336296, 0.03956897184252739, -0.03614581748843193, 0.02463957667350769, -0.010670662857592106, -0.0714835599064827, 0.04270782694220543, 0.007663855794817209, -0.030133312568068504, -0.03289595991373062, 0.021719425916671753, 0.0018340408569201827, -0.013182695023715496, -0.034946247935295105, 0.07679888606071472, -0.012693334370851517, 0.03245265409350395, 0.01659025065600872, 0.08885859698057175, 0.00907699391245842, 0.05635546147823334, 0.0006677821511402726, 0.02482839673757553, -0.02594674751162529, -0.037546321749687195, 0.049046069383621216, -0.002180988434702158, 0.0017687676008790731, 0.01349368505179882, -0.020003369078040123, -0.024915475398302078, 0.01245492696762085, 0.013643533922731876, 0.030029172077775, -0.020498864352703094, 0.025035466998815536, 0.035837847739458084, 0.04561447352170944, 0.001999771688133478, -0.05173802003264427, -0.12541928887367249, 0.02489112690091133, 0.02249518781900406, 0.009711825288832188, 0.0619303397834301, -0.03183335065841675, -0.019900772720575333, 0.013483756221830845, 0.03754551336169243, -0.02910936251282692, -0.07000409811735153, 0.010791218839585781, 0.028405096381902695, -0.024084394797682762, -0.05011541768908501, -0.021186349913477898, 0.039381224662065506, 0.019697142764925957, -0.0596904382109642, 0.02366819605231285, -0.033941756933927536, -0.01772298291325569, 0.016453832387924194, -0.004981496371328831, 0.021645216271281242, 0.017263446003198624, -0.03553106635808945, -0.03554524481296539, -0.04702625423669815, -0.007138701621443033, -0.004331487230956554, -0.025550736114382744, -0.03127568960189819, -0.06194179132580757, 0.01222231239080429, -0.07727260887622833, 0.026266416534781456, -0.01755281537771225, 0.002891864627599716, 0.07424767315387726, 0.02656489983201027, -0.013691076077520847, 0.030458275228738785, -0.024590685963630676, 0.005710768513381481, -0.019146347418427467, -0.06705258786678314, -0.011549828574061394, 0.007349734660238028, -0.06356707215309143, 0.05532441288232803, 0.016981055960059166, -0.022822411730885506, -0.0829603374004364, 0.08471857011318207, -0.010616900399327278, 0.0003987882228102535, -0.0557066909968853, 0.05928917974233627, -0.027067838236689568, 0.04089696705341339, -0.038911156356334686, -0.05816544592380524, 0.021016810089349747, -0.05280260741710663, -0.02131720632314682, -0.011238175444304943, 0.00827724952250719, 0.022627227008342743, -0.020420661196112633, -0.012209132313728333, -0.060677025467157364, 0.038746677339076996, -0.026601355522871017, 0.029811222106218338, 0.012471277266740799, -0.019252382218837738, -0.08051397651433945, 0.022807691246271133, 0.007572094444185495, -0.07720381021499634, -0.005429581739008427, 0.058524057269096375, -0.0006003028829582036, -0.022496692836284637, -0.06116379424929619, 0.03433510661125183, 0.005446906201541424, 0.006228020414710045, -0.0023323961067944765, -0.022412551566958427, -0.0003044743207283318, -0.04276607558131218, -0.03464294224977493, -0.04361557215452194, -0.035461436957120895, 0.012437529861927032, -0.01184580847620964, -0.003641526447609067, -0.004149962682276964, 0.03344329819083214, 0.005549479275941849, 0.01592201739549637, -0.03626599162817001, -0.02873530238866806, 0.02411777712404728, -0.01684790663421154 ]
<p>I'm reading an article about bi layered membranes which state that for the free energy function<br> $f(\theta) = \theta \ln \theta + (1-\theta)\ln(1-\theta) + \chi \theta (1-\theta)$</p> <p>Where $\phi_i$ is the mole fraction of certain types of lipids in layer $i$ and $\chi$ is the energy of interaction between two lipids molecules composing the layer. The article states that a critical point exist at $\chi=2$ and $\theta=0.5$. Reading in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_point_%28thermodynamics%29">wikipedia</a>, I concluded that removing the layers interaction part, I simply need to take the second and third derivative of the free energy of the membrane. How do I do this with the interactions? Where can I read about this?</p>
g6570
[ 0.05051669478416443, 0.020089831203222275, -0.005519141908735037, 0.03585002198815346, 0.07117774337530136, 0.005830860696732998, -0.019832106307148933, -0.010800818912684917, -0.07817307114601135, 0.017209960147738457, -0.020771611481904984, 0.0006396261742338538, 0.017395498231053352, -0.030565127730369568, 0.024748919531702995, -0.05435558035969734, 0.05868852883577347, 0.01411363948136568, 0.036913011223077774, 0.021220378577709198, -0.0841921791434288, 0.016028743237257004, -0.0253224428743124, -0.020973285660147667, 0.02045266702771187, 0.004740121308714151, 0.01312745176255703, -0.008795388042926788, -0.09229057282209396, -0.013545714318752289, -0.0059816353023052216, 0.011482693254947662, 0.060173630714416504, -0.02791460044682026, -0.04198772460222244, -0.015653051435947418, 0.11042039096355438, 0.016202960163354874, -0.055404625833034515, 0.02478097192943096, 0.04005766659975052, 0.03982021287083626, 0.024582937359809875, -0.03091035969555378, 0.01591196469962597, -0.0016615410568192601, -0.06703870743513107, -0.021152313798666, -0.00734979473054409, -0.012945274822413921, 0.04947693273425102, 0.11089855432510376, 0.03320539370179176, -0.030911564826965332, -0.03521541878581047, 0.050566013902425766, -0.0032686844933778048, -0.028068453073501587, -0.030785921961069107, -0.013311685062944889, -0.005335773341357708, -0.06618387252092361, 0.01696411892771721, -0.009983398951590061, 0.047971226274967194, -0.0011901521356776357, -0.051172878593206406, -0.02356155775487423, -0.07557811588048935, -0.03264980390667915, 0.020462168380618095, -0.011425388045608997, -0.027141163125634193, -0.0008271026308648288, -0.02009466104209423, -0.029834236949682236, -0.013698805123567581, -0.020030340179800987, 0.002221212489530444, 0.005051566753536463, -0.05995359644293785, -0.007610314525663853, 0.036364901810884476, -0.03194304183125496, 0.04172400385141373, 0.001312006264925003, -0.020691070705652237, -0.011462635360658169, -0.030478620901703835, 0.06071452423930168, -0.0012112336698919535, -0.018972452729940414, 0.046398866921663284, -0.037708353251218796, 0.041859425604343414, 0.006585265044122934, 0.003127293661236763, -0.006338649429380894, -0.0039491415955126286, -0.004068303387612104, -0.02062741480767727, 0.025904593989253044, 0.034057144075632095, -0.0376339815557003, -0.011027619242668152, 0.0024736097548156977, 0.04062887281179428, -0.004191658925265074, 0.0020184072200208902, 0.011981935240328312, -0.005338227842003107, -0.04475071653723717, -0.019743967801332474, -0.011977939866483212, 0.08564841747283936, -0.044735539704561234, 0.032564498484134674, -0.027657903730869293, -0.000963998434599489, 0.008925888687372208, -0.03209157660603523, -0.03806119039654732, 0.027957752346992493, 0.04104815423488617, -0.021778246387839317, 0.011562498286366463, -0.03007768839597702, 0.021058928221464157, 0.07088790833950043, -0.0077305627055466175, 0.0563306100666523, -0.023307224735617638, 0.012500566430389881, 0.020504159852862358, 0.0108175128698349, 0.03989936038851738, -0.004764289129525423, -0.03184546157717705, 0.035576578229665756, -0.048599112778902054, -0.020762907341122627, -0.001007068669423461, -0.0017999911215156317, 0.002997556235641241, 0.0058424584567546844, -0.028072208166122437, 0.05089829862117767, -0.03761684149503708, 0.03818899765610695, -0.0051766568794846535, 0.008523168042302132, 0.07891620695590973, -0.01105267833918333, -0.018160639330744743, -0.007753636222332716, 0.0316021554172039, 0.038725413382053375, 0.01234128326177597, -0.02306945249438286, -0.0042337095364928246, 0.03135500103235245, -0.021613415330648422, 0.05081460624933243, -0.009570959955453873, -0.0013097251066938043, 0.037941064685583115, 0.009049719199538231, -0.12488972395658493, 0.01192002184689045, 0.016652176156640053, -0.07977300137281418, 0.02804691344499588, -0.006973405834287405, 0.07205740362405777, 0.012504260055720806, 0.057420115917921066, -0.07220183312892914, -0.016389044001698494, 0.028011437505483627, 0.03418752923607826, -0.0070069027133286, -0.021085016429424286, 0.06389357149600983, -0.04603249579668045, 0.023811640217900276, 0.03347114101052284, -0.0014045698335394263, 0.035737693309783936, -0.02638208493590355, 0.022654296830296516, -0.04332462698221207, 0.018166614696383476, 0.034034326672554016, -0.05894274264574051, -0.029348311945796013, 0.10243728011846542, 0.09027567505836487, -0.06638635694980621, 0.02480264939367771, -0.051377855241298676, -0.05415625870227814, -0.019166769459843636, 0.0065926071256399155, 0.04146616533398628, -0.022404424846172333, 0.020845947787165642, -0.0042525362223386765, 0.00570555729791522, -0.060970548540353775, -0.048972513526678085, -0.028838522732257843, -0.029152201488614082, -0.022319061681628227, 0.00852457620203495, 0.04083497077226639, -0.04495806246995926, -0.012179626151919365, -0.016362793743610382, 0.001796314725652337, -0.01580064371228218, -0.025254618376493454, 0.028226014226675034, 0.08526043593883514, -0.011137273162603378, -0.002681405982002616, 0.01762944646179676, -0.004897211212664843, -0.0017039338126778603, -0.023083290085196495, 0.03066159039735794, -0.04632093384861946, -0.02154902182519436, 0.0007920269854366779, -0.013168077915906906, -0.02323816902935505, 0.05777735263109207, 0.01821436919271946, 0.00979080144315958, -0.021984126418828964, 0.07193302363157272, -0.02226186729967594, 0.02183118835091591, -0.0328826978802681, 0.06666232645511627, -0.0662311241030693, 0.007344621699303389, 0.0007407551747746766, 0.014093661680817604, -0.022866949439048767, -0.01843823492527008, 0.033168673515319824, 0.005993199069052935, 0.012021456845104694, 0.06163368001580238, -0.005416012369096279, 0.036639899015426636, 0.0011514470679685473, 0.039483264088630676, -0.022973034530878067, -0.008171934634447098, 0.034621890634298325, 0.0037649550940841436, 0.033273015171289444, 0.046805985271930695, -0.016306046396493912, -0.04096055403351784, -0.006189555861055851, -0.04464823380112648, 0.02498958446085453, 0.027393175289034843, 0.026830555871129036, 0.08727381378412247, 0.01768440753221512, 0.07117537409067154, 0.034221719950437546, -0.04193461313843727, 0.04756699874997139, -0.052776116877794266, 0.011041354387998581, -0.027387335896492004, -0.005126920994371176, -0.003239445388317108, -0.0008255737484432757, 0.00033754322794266045, 0.06775015592575073, -0.001374706975184381, -0.001304360805079341, 0.07357331365346909, 0.011272655799984932, -0.0159321129322052, 0.034513041377067566, 0.030917741358280182, -0.07571575045585632, 0.0168239064514637, 0.01674543507397175, -0.010166381485760212, 0.0714111253619194, -0.06345783174037933, -0.058657556772232056, 0.01873696967959404, -0.02000025287270546, -0.004955913405865431, 0.01411798782646656, 0.062461450695991516, 0.030967392027378082, -0.011637474410235882, 0.009821299463510513, -0.01816066913306713, 0.03051810711622238, 0.004657762590795755, -0.02349294349551201, -0.03199002519249916, 0.017122548073530197, -0.025031613186001778, 0.035121191293001175, 0.017162473872303963, 0.004814584273844957, -0.01133586186915636, 0.010981643572449684, 0.0460924431681633, -0.06207257881760597, 0.0030119773000478745, 0.041270505636930466, 0.00832596980035305, -0.008768109604716301, 0.014827465638518333, -0.06319304555654526, -0.0022090962156653404, -0.07049745321273804, 0.0009555259603075683, 0.016642704606056213, 0.01939397305250168, 0.060701366513967514, -0.03643123060464859, -0.04611585661768913, -0.04566872492432594, 0.0028742942959070206, -0.004983952268958092, 0.06701146811246872, -0.0056746904738247395, -0.02960432879626751, 0.03409939259290695, 0.0027730464935302734, -0.03371337056159973, -0.019231943413615227, -0.04500018060207367, -0.049085088074207306, 0.0516696535050869, -0.026304645463824272, -0.05824827775359154, 0.0009277068311348557, 0.010775587521493435, -0.00870429165661335, -0.03835858777165413, 0.04512789472937584, 0.0015603230567649007, -0.00046444148756563663, 0.01111896988004446, -0.001763784559443593, 0.033729247748851776, -0.004670693539083004, -0.08545346558094025, 0.02305976115167141, 0.04413846880197525, -0.0061319381929934025, -0.03052111156284809, -0.03907664865255356, 0.04624335095286369, 0.003340639639645815, -0.02473672665655613, 0.034007489681243896, -0.02099960297346115, 0.039675649255514145, 0.011622177436947823, -0.030445700511336327, -0.008088509552180767, -0.01868932694196701, 0.007638785056769848, 0.009918435476720333, 0.016213517636060715, -0.014634132385253906, -0.06989327818155289, 0.0018752001924440265, -0.019394004717469215, 0.09927482903003693, 0.008660825900733471, -0.06309294700622559, -0.011349436827003956, 0.016105031594634056, 0.03706742823123932, 0.011746023781597614, 0.01062626764178276, 0.0017942471895366907, -0.004956821445375681, -0.041658494621515274, -0.02057504467666149, 0.024115612730383873, 0.030992336571216583, -0.05257680267095566, 0.058076370507478714, 0.0049268449656665325, -0.010541887022554874, -0.05804096907377243, -0.005688723176717758, 0.02266056090593338, -0.0048221563920378685, 0.027500491589307785, -0.025318430736660957, 0.02592531591653824, 0.0172493327409029, 0.019574133679270744, -0.018459390848875046, -0.02396758645772934, 0.016742413863539696, -0.05456877499818802, -0.00989841390401125, 0.00597712816670537, -0.055321697145700455, 0.010854406282305717, 0.004777311813086271, -0.05375152453780174, -0.04358348995447159, -0.05846932902932167, -0.027975820004940033, -0.05283419042825699, 0.06450065970420837, 0.0673956423997879, -0.04169332981109619, -0.004007885232567787, -0.05884763225913048, 0.018911829218268394, 0.011683530174195766, -0.06232482194900513, 0.0029690961819142103, -0.030793698504567146, 0.011553685180842876, -0.04830237850546837, -0.004239011090248823, -0.010157424956560135, 0.05357006937265396, 0.0691780373454094, -0.032552532851696014, -0.0792064219713211, -0.0035184163134545088, 0.008475317619740963, 0.04231597110629082, -0.04783747345209122, -0.07155153155326843, 0.024503855034708977, -0.04888878017663956, 0.009860388934612274, -0.025311410427093506, 0.02576158195734024, 0.02116505056619644, 0.0006493875989690423, 0.007221502717584372, -0.029690319672226906, 0.012862886302173138, -0.00009392105130245909, -0.0047617750242352486, 0.028062501922249794, 0.005536696873605251, 0.0013680271804332733, -0.031876444816589355, 0.019610291346907616, -0.003151847515255213, 0.0009734997292980552, 0.025246480479836464, -0.02105770632624626, -0.030567742884159088, 0.0440051294863224, 0.044572390615940094, 0.045264020562171936, -0.030666932463645935, -0.023485740646719933, -0.047871071845293045, 0.004806673154234886, -0.04674213007092476, -0.021948255598545074, -0.06269887089729309, 0.0033208441454917192, -0.002964848419651389, 0.024942776188254356, 0.01036891434341669, 0.010618418455123901, -0.005344818811863661, -0.009291710332036018, -0.002331678057089448, 0.023980770260095596, -0.0038580861873924732, 0.02035745419561863, 0.036186400800943375, 0.013732326216995716, 0.005601467099040747, -0.01642792485654354, 0.011318977922201157, 0.08173906803131104, -0.05849519371986389, 0.004211796913295984, 0.006511607673019171, 0.0059442282654345036, 0.02445819042623043, -0.023409700021147728, 0.004361570347100496, -0.06494738161563873, 0.029077596962451935, 0.027143357321619987, 0.007324080914258957, 0.0035891211591660976, 0.03277380019426346, -0.022888202220201492, -0.03894961625337601, 0.02477114461362362, 0.03231128677725792, 0.002664342988282442, 0.008926989510655403, -0.01955362968146801, 0.014960072003304958, -0.03805164247751236, -0.0225202739238739, 0.028895143419504166, -0.019333556294441223, -0.03722313791513443, 0.0002478326787240803, -0.007510316092520952, -0.05252378433942795, -0.08310168236494064, 0.0024009293410927057, 0.027414528653025627, 0.01322675496339798, -0.033168964087963104, -0.014526558108627796, 0.00866638496518135, 0.035555362701416016, -0.007394739892333746, -0.020456355065107346, 0.025734970346093178, 0.00657047051936388, 0.042405031621456146, 0.04387599229812622, 0.003143446985632181, 0.036339107900857925, -0.004810308571904898, 0.060446131974458694, 0.007521501276642084, 0.016553277149796486, -0.016003286466002464, 0.021149301901459694, 0.00007923152588773519, 0.029889248311519623, -0.008794573135674, -0.039797719568014145, 0.05075398087501526, 0.008851775899529457, 0.015994738787412643, -0.00917279813438654, 0.029501399025321007, -0.029283432289958, -0.013407655991613865, 0.02744084596633911, 0.01766005903482437, -0.08462345600128174, 0.05899907648563385, 0.024137243628501892, 0.053290605545043945, -0.04851395636796951, -0.04977856203913689, 0.0458298958837986, -0.01059754192829132, 0.002014561789110303, 0.011178023181855679, 0.028379423543810844, -0.063223697245121, -0.016081444919109344, 0.029995394870638847, 0.05512906610965729, -0.023393230512738228, 0.05386200174689293, -0.036015357822179794, -0.020996740087866783, 0.003150923876091838, 0.03290212154388428, -0.06569091230630875, -0.07303263247013092, -0.03683742135763168, 0.0160222165286541, 0.005786137655377388, -0.08345326036214828, -0.0013762257294729352, 0.012761084362864494, 0.009161775931715965, -0.027923762798309326, -0.03742217645049095, -0.001423132955096662, 0.0640600249171257, -0.08142798393964767, -0.018933165818452835, 0.00270907673984766, 0.014821763150393963, 0.07857734709978104, -0.012028614990413189, -0.09181991964578629, -0.012084604240953922, -0.08813231438398361, 0.021932777017354965, 0.01947050727903843, 0.009105860255658627, 0.033238623291254044, -0.043235018849372864, 0.03335920721292496, -0.05276546999812126, -0.019442832097411156, -0.022277947515249252, -0.008333628997206688, 0.007294355425983667, -0.03443749621510506, -0.031095048412680626, 0.03170420601963997, -0.02425539307296276, 0.030117617920041084, 0.022960616275668144, 0.017503395676612854, 0.045951616019010544, -0.08335895091295242, 0.03913024812936783, 0.024951322004199028, -0.031023968011140823, 0.020907344296574593, 0.02068442292511463, 0.01822344958782196, 0.014337451197206974, 0.037777189165353775, -0.024984823539853096, 0.08155712485313416, -0.041895851492881775, -0.0011377246119081974, -0.05682477355003357, -0.03955201059579849, -0.031492434442043304, 0.02635384164750576, -0.008038169704377651, 0.0762326642870903, 0.07881256192922592, 0.05210389196872711, -0.006683995481580496, -0.019124669954180717, 0.02337075024843216, -0.036585595458745956, -0.007029227912425995, 0.08710303157567978, 0.020219234749674797, -0.03120519407093525, 0.0008571798680350184, 0.011006539687514305, -0.014554186724126339, 0.017226535826921463, -0.030063770711421967, -0.03920995816588402, -0.0004258455301169306, 0.03692902252078056, -0.03712554648518562, -0.07010964304208755, 0.03308115527033806, 0.018927128985524178, -0.0008983596926555037, 0.03466242924332619, 0.04492262005805969, 0.00528449472039938, 0.05520899221301079, -0.02522731013596058, -0.052585355937480927, -0.06902854144573212, -0.05305848643183708, 0.06494107097387314, 0.0005283015198074281, -0.025490766391158104, 0.04400346055626869, 0.007708023302257061, 0.002368926303461194, -0.005625192541629076, 0.022738277912139893, -0.02907579019665718, 0.01944308914244175, -0.0598750039935112, -0.023424532264471054, 0.04828445240855217, 0.04359894245862961, 0.04397990182042122, 0.03354969248175621, 0.051325682550668716, -0.010362828150391579, 0.007592993322759867, -0.02275221422314644, -0.025276795029640198, 0.006884975358843803, -0.01125276554375887, 0.07531452924013138, 0.06501331180334091, 0.07291269302368164, 0.0156722292304039, 0.02253808081150055, -0.050685763359069824, -0.07346709817647934, -0.002625284483656287, -0.06165188178420067, 0.05384232476353645, -0.02726844698190689, -0.0713016539812088, 0.02166133187711239, -0.01450895145535469, 0.01111105177551508, -0.014970499090850353, 0.007811803370714188, -0.019914045929908752, 0.01736077107489109, -0.007676968351006508, -0.02571156620979309, 0.0539020411670208, -0.0008931212360039353, 0.0057455627247691154, 0.015729503706097603, 0.019805189222097397, -0.049650292843580246, -0.04356873035430908, -0.04275383800268173, -0.0317903608083725, -0.05817346274852753, 0.02774500846862793, 0.014690070413053036, 0.04463775083422661, -0.008748557418584824, -0.037415213882923126, -0.018113935366272926, 0.02532004378736019, 0.0029471025336533785, 0.0019154422916471958, 0.014165140688419342, -0.006882614456117153, 0.032999224960803986, -0.036403000354766846, -0.0027161072939634323, -0.03852219879627228, 0.03197230026125908, -0.005088191945105791, -0.0285810474306345, 0.01971534825861454, -0.030526340007781982, 0.0432957261800766, 0.03429621458053589, 0.06218736246228218, -0.05466799810528755, 0.01994028314948082, -0.015149836428463459, -0.018399015069007874, 0.0310023482888937, -0.07211039215326309, -0.057172395288944244, -0.033352918922901154, -0.006703896913677454, -0.01637096330523491, 0.0033951394725590944, -0.029846325516700745, 0.007668276783078909, 0.04039231315255165, 0.03239843621850014, -0.010036250576376915, 0.024996617808938026, 0.02573036216199398 ]
<p>Argument: Buckling is an engineering concept that can only be applied to <strong>thin columns</strong> with <strong>compressive</strong> loading.</p> <p>(Is it possible to) Prove the above sentence right or wrong with mathematical formulation. Emphasis on cellular and solid materials that have no concept of "thin". </p> <p>Also, why can you use buckling to describe crack growth experiments in thin sheets: out-of-plane deformation of sheets = buckling? => deformation in perpendicular direction respect to force is buckling? => 3D solids can experience buckling ? => example of this kind of material is...</p> <p>Good references, rigorous treatment and mathematical approach are more than welcome.</p> <p><strong>edit:</strong> In other words, what is the mathematical definition for buckling?</p> <p><strong>edit2:</strong> So, buckling is the bifurcation of static equilibrium (see annav's comment below). And thus:</p> <blockquote> <p>More technically, consider the continuous dynamical system described by the ODE</p> <p>$\dot x=f(x,\lambda)\quad &gt; f:\mathbb{R}^n\times\mathbb{R}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}^n.$</p> <p>A local bifurcation occurs at $(x0,λ0)$ if the Jacobian matrix $\textrm{d}f_{x_0,\lambda_0}$ has an eigenvalue with zero real part.</p> </blockquote> <p>This also happens to coincide with ASTM E-9 standard, section 3.2.1 that says: </p> <blockquote> <p>bucklig -- (3) a local instability, either elastic or inelastic, over a small portion of the gage length</p> </blockquote>
g6571
[ 0.09006167948246002, 0.029595721513032913, 0.007846135646104813, -0.003586195409297943, 0.018649013713002205, -0.02125529572367668, -0.01733989454805851, -0.0373685359954834, -0.02874850668013096, -0.015928246080875397, 0.010246890597045422, -0.013335769064724445, 0.04162163287401199, -0.026139624416828156, -0.01568739116191864, 0.02097567357122898, 0.06748486310243607, 0.000402721983846277, 0.026927383616566658, 0.07966773211956024, -0.08557967096567154, 0.003925126511603594, 0.03016643226146698, -0.013890921138226986, -0.022656457498669624, 0.09343893080949783, 0.01165943406522274, -0.009302069433033466, -0.02106785587966442, 0.02094537764787674, 0.0330163836479187, -0.04665033891797066, 0.011659041978418827, -0.03677072003483772, -0.0423133559525013, -0.05502932146191597, 0.0032794957514852285, 0.01746300421655178, 0.04599646478891373, -0.006955099757760763, 0.009893779642879963, -0.006946830544620752, 0.04113495349884033, -0.012183927930891514, -0.005567200016230345, 0.018922103568911552, -0.04995707795023918, 0.016087118536233902, -0.026813799515366554, 0.016533469781279564, -0.02301173284649849, -0.020671267062425613, 0.014610487036406994, -0.03254313766956329, -0.02848070114850998, 0.0040389723144471645, 0.0016150830779224634, 0.02412150800228119, -0.0062093427404761314, -0.040018320083618164, -0.022657515481114388, 0.0036569051444530487, 0.020410750061273575, -0.025668714195489883, 0.05324612185359001, 0.008608122356235981, -0.07784003019332886, -0.034246619790792465, 0.030969152227044106, 0.03873702138662338, 0.004797772504389286, -0.07170242071151733, -0.04020163416862488, -0.01817033812403679, -0.026360852643847466, 0.02331848070025444, 0.007927614264190197, -0.023303808644413948, 0.0010457973694428802, 0.028208313509821892, -0.05283142253756523, 0.049353957176208496, -0.032323215156793594, 0.0027766944840550423, 0.04233613982796669, 0.006438424810767174, 0.003438996383920312, 0.006752041168510914, -0.05743866413831711, -0.0019537077751010656, -0.01628877967596054, 0.04333164170384407, -0.031210867688059807, -0.003261853940784931, -0.03233020380139351, -0.0035081878304481506, 0.009905497543513775, -0.013611414469778538, -0.012698042206466198, 0.008374543860554695, -0.010739565826952457, -0.008186534978449345, -0.07107289135456085, -0.030175313353538513, -0.03919209912419319, 0.033379364758729935, 0.027535149827599525, 0.016498131677508354, -0.025797422975301743, -0.054676882922649384, 0.0007739372085779905, 0.03969874978065491, -0.04668871685862541, -0.022975550964474678, -0.008049090392887592, 0.014198506250977516, 0.07225292921066284, 0.012449253350496292, 0.03080103173851967, 0.046712327748537064, 0.06626608222723007, 0.02462754026055336, 0.07986404746770859, 0.07202745974063873, 0.01344294659793377, -0.012050282210111618, 0.0013192424084991217, 0.045989517122507095, -0.008953627198934555, -0.034079063683748245, 0.020375633612275124, 0.00022291566710919142, -0.058669157326221466, -0.05045899748802185, 0.0697968527674675, 0.04399097338318825, -0.044814035296440125, -0.03474769741296768, -0.018965518102049828, 0.011047341860830784, -0.08732988685369492, 0.04005847126245499, 0.007462004665285349, 0.03963656723499298, 0.04325004667043686, -0.014043929055333138, 0.022955236956477165, 0.04296557977795601, 0.05585572496056557, 0.034335907548666, -0.03232013061642647, 0.08901078253984451, -0.02078625187277794, -0.06447925418615341, 0.022104522213339806, 0.050221849232912064, 0.04805998504161835, 0.024698739871382713, 0.019517607986927032, 0.024612827226519585, 0.03113749995827675, -0.030650164932012558, -0.08778131753206253, 0.022146016359329224, -0.0636085793375969, 0.026096753776073456, -0.05537129566073418, 0.045990340411663055, -0.005915550515055656, -0.008868111297488213, -0.0722324401140213, 0.015854867175221443, 0.04665099456906319, -0.008321834728121758, 0.020608408376574516, 0.004789191298186779, 0.0274192001670599, -0.07790857553482056, 0.011236274614930153, -0.0814133733510971, -0.05916009098291397, 0.02956255152821541, -0.00656057707965374, 0.022294210270047188, -0.015579178929328918, 0.020067257806658745, 0.018556736409664154, -0.022328974679112434, -0.04376577213406563, 0.004692459478974342, -0.03523581847548485, 0.03196464106440544, -0.008140873163938522, 0.07039320468902588, -0.06728336215019226, -0.07270985096693039, 0.030296163633465767, -0.02169656939804554, 0.05828636512160301, -0.048757441341876984, 0.04536847025156021, 0.010196128860116005, 0.043588124215602875, 0.009173767641186714, -0.04990822821855545, -0.012968008406460285, -0.04707582667469978, -0.026009734719991684, -0.05641395226120949, -0.0020334478467702866, 0.025201596319675446, -0.03386584296822548, -0.03141750767827034, 0.08399853110313416, 0.05016057565808296, -0.047738637775182724, 0.04253910854458809, -0.02475777640938759, -0.004588230047374964, -0.015211212448775768, 0.03057693876326084, -0.03658777475357056, -0.07325000315904617, -0.012090550735592842, 0.021713657304644585, -0.08861644566059113, -0.028607599437236786, 0.030034787952899933, 0.07379968464374542, -0.045998651534318924, -0.10816490650177002, -0.007578771561384201, -0.0207515936344862, -0.0038735661655664444, 0.04797656834125519, 0.0614752322435379, -0.02266640216112137, 0.034875597804784775, 0.02112979255616665, 0.05206650495529175, 0.009671715088188648, -0.04760707542300224, -0.06485056132078171, -0.043392982333898544, -0.0016837635776028037, -0.04469790309667587, 0.03136899322271347, -0.05378865823149681, 0.060348521918058395, -0.003453016048297286, 0.041882917284965515, 0.0011597692500799894, -0.0035510442685335875, 0.041014887392520905, -0.00575975188985467, -0.1000688374042511, 0.01411119382828474, 0.02943808026611805, -0.006375114433467388, 0.015042691491544247, 0.017229698598384857, 0.031649235635995865, 0.020948121324181557, -0.013853399083018303, -0.029980702325701714, 0.004736434202641249, -0.05591317266225815, -0.0007372472900897264, -0.033382728695869446, 0.014124041423201561, -0.027460068464279175, 0.027780376374721527, 0.006307507865130901, 0.03854713216423988, -0.011771759949624538, -0.03960788622498512, -0.0293284859508276, 0.004423163831233978, 0.0016676790546625853, -0.02174498699605465, 0.03536113351583481, 0.00772827910259366, 0.009384009055793285, 0.018185772001743317, 0.0057589709758758545, 0.01738658733665943, 0.013384477235376835, -0.020373422652482986, -0.010048405267298222, 0.039266131818294525, -0.031528305262327194, 0.019994042813777924, -0.025825152173638344, -0.04634625092148781, -0.021535828709602356, 0.04489722102880478, -0.010520781390368938, -0.05586480349302292, -0.050311874598264694, 0.028233980759978294, -0.012684418819844723, -0.03060333989560604, 0.0060221953317523, -0.045801617205142975, 0.06581699848175049, 0.03492734953761101, -0.0005924152210354805, -0.04938807338476181, -0.006323610432446003, 0.012240410782396793, 0.006362610962241888, -0.010633653961122036, 0.02065328136086464, 0.026727372780442238, -0.054597917944192886, -0.01615672931075096, 0.005481787957251072, -0.023888057097792625, -0.020059308037161827, -0.08905484527349472, -0.019651005044579506, -0.028733111917972565, -0.014453992247581482, -0.0031596289481967688, -0.002692698035389185, 0.012009979225695133, -0.037284720689058304, 0.017172709107398987, -0.043589700013399124, 0.00046847425983287394, -0.011366813443601131, -0.05173371732234955, 0.0508933886885643, -0.054281629621982574, -0.02427799254655838, -0.06879433244466782, -0.0383157953619957, -0.037312112748622894, 0.04747316241264343, -0.004463305696845055, -0.02085810713469982, -0.0027462285943329334, 0.018330927938222885, -0.010428288951516151, -0.04040033742785454, -0.001835308619774878, 0.006731320638209581, 0.015476562082767487, -0.0038649586495012045, 0.005157671868801117, 0.016851911321282387, 0.024944018572568893, 0.02220275066792965, -0.055161233991384506, -0.019125424325466156, -0.018413526937365532, 0.015623992308974266, 0.01611156016588211, -0.002804376883432269, 0.016992824152112007, 0.012305028736591339, 0.005852467380464077, 0.00644118944182992, -0.034857116639614105, -0.03638157993555069, 0.07644578814506531, 0.026517895981669426, 0.06769217550754547, 0.02178957685828209, -0.04169240966439247, 0.0229826457798481, -0.008575852029025555, -0.000059575824707280844, -0.010025198571383953, 0.0531439334154129, -0.04660044610500336, 0.014042890630662441, -0.008848726749420166, 0.020243311300873756, 0.035982366651296616, 0.037170473486185074, 0.024521050974726677, 0.06240633502602577, 0.05468503013253212, -0.02575332671403885, -0.012797446921467781, -0.015878677368164062, 0.00036601649480871856, -0.03614591062068939, 0.010125267319381237, 0.0188637375831604, -0.009184412658214569, 0.008450737223029137, 0.04125083610415459, -0.00689326599240303, 0.026216760277748108, -0.015229561366140842, 0.02091190591454506, -0.0522596538066864, -0.024602429941296577, 0.01927892118692398, 0.004976904019713402, 0.00978156365454197, 0.008922496810555458, 0.034069936722517014, -0.021125299856066704, -0.029742509126663208, -0.022015796974301338, -0.02605176903307438, -0.029855065047740936, 0.022093890234827995, -0.042262911796569824, -0.003819890320301056, -0.046325113624334335, 0.05567408725619316, 0.009129464626312256, 0.050905171781778336, 0.01123499684035778, 0.012558531947433949, -0.0479448139667511, 0.03347382694482803, 0.016050342470407486, -0.08495263755321503, 0.07368595153093338, 0.03811490535736084, 0.06256791204214096, -0.0037387493066489697, -0.00808453094214201, 0.03826270252466202, -0.04336391016840935, -0.031850289553403854, -0.0003513327974360436, 0.00037764135049656034, 0.018920499831438065, -0.010368085466325283, -0.0160811934620142, -0.016956225037574768, 0.04991491511464119, -0.012889647856354713, 0.06088823825120926, 0.007194452919065952, 0.009776855818927288, 0.06174195185303688, 0.027604995295405388, 0.00549941323697567, 0.01617557927966118, -0.007248309440910816, -0.015173596329987049, -0.03337903320789337, -0.03698023036122322, -0.03251506760716438, 0.02469923533499241, 0.04130588099360466, -0.018140718340873718, 0.03172903507947922, -0.026456398889422417, -0.010604385286569595, 0.040664780884981155, 0.0254985261708498, 0.04415528103709221, 0.07411710917949677, -0.02878609672188759, 0.059765614569187164, -0.037432242184877396, 0.01749832183122635, 0.015302474610507488, 0.022625427693128586, -0.02311701513826847, 0.02074344828724861, 0.022838063538074493, -0.06467252224683762, -0.006254655309021473, -0.023466847836971283, 0.0016658386448398232, -0.006567826494574547, -0.006806531921029091, -0.002309518400579691, 0.037888530641794205, 0.027254972606897354, -0.019214453175663948, 0.03650212660431862, 0.004312892910093069, -0.010118595324456692, -0.025097619742155075, 0.04221345856785774, -0.00175258528906852, -0.018306467682123184, 0.021665459498763084, -0.02392706274986267, -0.0558699294924736, 0.028247186914086342, -0.07074327766895294, -0.019464777782559395, 0.04866287112236023, -0.020422620698809624, -0.022035811096429825, 0.021076926961541176, 0.0019105775281786919, -0.07315465062856674, -0.03124925121665001, -0.03421648219227791, 0.04368971288204193, 0.0003319217066746205, 0.012901526875793934, 0.044189173728227615, -0.01760721206665039, 0.06794121116399765, 0.007975664921104908, 0.01660974882543087, 0.01563064381480217, 0.020555883646011353, 0.01145944930613041, 0.024381939321756363, 0.03743284195661545, 0.04862619936466217, -0.015047072432935238, -0.030320320278406143, 0.008113500662147999, -0.0318463072180748, -0.0713793933391571, 0.026234135031700134, -0.01478341594338417, -0.0509190708398819, -0.0642646849155426, 0.005468578543514013, 0.002000272972509265, -0.07751423120498657, 0.00414951192215085, -0.004208797588944435, 0.01582648791372776, -0.007982924580574036, -0.014973328448832035, 0.043980710208415985, -0.01670120283961296, -0.07602810859680176, 0.041926734149456024, 0.007954609580338001, -0.0171236339956522, -0.032288745045661926, -0.013698535971343517, -0.012380889616906643, -0.058850690722465515, 0.03494356572628021, 0.061124589294195175, 0.015448831021785736, 0.026183409616351128, -0.06040528044104576, -0.022774826735258102, 0.08745313435792923, -0.011058798059821129, -0.02594088204205036, 0.035684991627931595, -0.015957355499267578, 0.02002321183681488, -0.00937441922724247, -0.004489421378821135, 0.00036495944368653, -0.038610536605119705, -0.011371945962309837, -0.03007889725267887, -0.05107768625020981, 0.04641388729214668, -0.023607343435287476, 0.013860655948519707, 0.0346585251390934, 0.05078200623393059, -0.04156472161412239, 0.004594780970364809, 0.0022292551584541798, 0.033989451825618744, 0.0019502145005390048, 0.033722393214702606, 0.07305490225553513, 0.0700758546590805, -0.03344012796878815, 0.029603131115436554, -0.022659242153167725, 0.009451530873775482, -0.010484355501830578, -0.03811420500278473, -0.026847368106245995, -0.014931600540876389, 0.03919801488518715, 0.036344293504953384, -0.004496022593230009, 0.027291852980852127, 0.016070576384663582, -0.034734923392534256, 0.016347579658031464, -0.0703003853559494, 0.02894650027155876, 0.02240198664367199, -0.0007819041493348777, 0.0671011283993721, -0.021136993542313576, 0.015966763719916344, 0.015265467576682568, 0.04257408156991005, 0.0176747664809227, 0.0011524915462359786, 0.0006015414255671203, 0.10169943422079086, 0.017141245305538177, -0.028118563815951347, -0.029950760304927826, 0.004679379519075155, 0.01648048497736454, 0.010969304479658604, 0.0022100305650383234, 0.01715751178562641, -0.005586148239672184, 0.03180898725986481, 0.002055997960269451, -0.02610507793724537, 0.02342064306139946, -0.08709239214658737, 0.019979232922196388, -0.04838966578245163, 0.033796243369579315, -0.03305898606777191, 0.01683514006435871, -0.026313889771699905, 0.015100200660526752, -0.037760522216558456, 0.03979480639100075, 0.03314151614904404, -0.06428402662277222, 0.023722337558865547, 0.08461742103099823, -0.004074188880622387, -0.006774734705686569, -0.020247498527169228, -0.05490685626864433, 0.05013361573219299, -0.025095466524362564, 0.03602921590209007, -0.02489999681711197, 0.03388350084424019, 0.09827479720115662, -0.009084586054086685, -0.041623394936323166, 0.029085326939821243, 0.007760871667414904, -0.003764933440834284, -0.03630385547876358, 0.011860929429531097, 0.01816960796713829, -0.003053422784432769, -0.029234804213047028, 0.02975730411708355, 0.06471778452396393, 0.002651428570970893, -0.0851776972413063, -0.048527684062719345, -0.057384081184864044, 0.028690798208117485, 0.01399245299398899, -0.03747046738862991, 0.037385858595371246, -0.005994066130369902, -0.026133019477128983, 0.029818011447787285, 0.03334144130349159, -0.059773508459329605, 0.0048473249189555645, 0.04749695584177971, 0.009042318910360336, -0.0005391029408201575, -0.07218094915151596, 0.005956146866083145, 0.06543352454900742, -0.00017348438268527389, 0.01980145089328289, 0.029075413942337036, -0.004350031726062298, -0.0063201431185007095, 0.008891931734979153, 0.00826702918857336, 0.06660722196102142, -0.026620473712682724, 0.09923776239156723, 0.03203915059566498, 0.025899749249219894, 0.020346052944660187, 0.012030367739498615, -0.009164768271148205, 0.0008268831297755241, 0.011063924059271812, 0.021689726039767265, -0.018584661185741425, 0.021506698802113533, -0.00035798302269540727, -0.03915565833449364, -0.001765647903084755, -0.028057033196091652, -0.007842516526579857, 0.04007963463664055, 0.010604757815599442, 0.0008232088875956833, -0.025724681094288826, -0.0394972488284111, -0.019599221646785736, -0.048165518790483475, -0.016524294391274452, -0.00939274113625288, 0.020791996270418167, -0.023189226165413857, -0.06755329668521881, -0.06937237828969955, -0.021276047453284264, 0.012242448516190052, 0.024434616789221764, -0.008235936053097248, -0.0361379012465477, 0.07636544853448868, 0.007169906049966812, 0.02447720430791378, -0.028936238959431648, -0.0051871794275939465, 0.010922406800091267, -0.036868348717689514, -0.027875931933522224, -0.022521324455738068, -0.056334421038627625, -0.006143075414001942, 0.05298560857772827, 0.031207319349050522, -0.05352594330906868, -0.06728214025497437, 0.05910840630531311, -0.038345206528902054, -0.02046877145767212, 0.011870386078953743, 0.02499786764383316, -0.04076485335826874, 0.015037769451737404, 0.032776083797216415, 0.006516317371279001, -0.052984513342380524, 0.041798438876867294, 0.014834749512374401, 0.027440594509243965, -0.10232598334550858, -0.01707090251147747, 0.03657448664307594, 0.006091282702982426, -0.024017488583922386, 0.10648252069950104, 0.019771652296185493, 0.005144563969224691, 0.0019966228865087032, 0.057083092629909515, 0.024291951209306717, 0.035431552678346634, -0.004303460009396076, 0.026759056374430656, 0.009580668993294239, -0.056198086589574814, 0.00039652801933698356, -0.015049558132886887, 0.015152201056480408, 0.0394413098692894, 0.009962179698050022, -0.07425892353057861, -0.025506800040602684, -0.006996172945946455, 0.007564646191895008, 0.022455740720033646 ]
<p>When Einstein started to think about gravitation, he completely created a new theory that no experiment supported. He based his reasoning, as he explained it later, on small thought experiments (Gedankenexperiment) that led him to formulate the equivalence principle. From this equivalence principle, he used the principles of physics and understood that a new space-time geometry was necessary and after years of effort he obtained the Einstein's equation. It is only when he used this equation to compute the anomalous perihelion advance of the planet Mercury that he knew his theory had something to do with the real world (but one could not call this a prediction). Since then, many predictions of General Relativity have been successfully checked experimentally.</p> <p><strong>Edited question</strong></p> <p>A thought experiment is an experiment that has not been realized, but that was imagined. The results of such experiment are based on well established physical principles but have never been observed physically. A second example of a thought experiment considers a frictionless movement of a vehicle on a road (see Einstein and Infeld, <em><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Evolution_of_Physics" rel="nofollow">The Evolution of Physics: The Growth of Ideas From Early Concepts to Relativity and Quanta</a></em>, chapter 1 on the Galilean relativity). Another example in particle physcis is described in <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/93839/are-there-correct-physical-predictions-made-only-from-thought-experiments-other?noredirect=1#comment192225_93839">one of the above comments</a>. Thought experiments only draw conclusions from physical considerations, not from mathematical derivations, and can therefore be used as illustrations destined to non-physicists.</p> <p>Does anyone think of other thought experiments which results have been proved relevant later by physical experiments, either because the thought experiment has been realized or because its results had physically testable consequences ?</p>
g6572
[ 0.026950174942612648, 0.04419548809528351, 0.020184464752674103, -0.016858655959367752, 0.05156389996409416, 0.034882284700870514, 0.023654844611883163, -0.0038652990479022264, -0.015229510143399239, -0.040455903857946396, 0.010602855123579502, -0.04278085008263588, 0.014478391967713833, 0.02897852472960949, 0.006953712087124586, 0.027669565752148628, 0.09396309405565262, -0.03960799798369408, 0.015428130514919758, 0.015770098194479942, 0.047706522047519684, 0.03145967423915863, -0.019251838326454163, -0.03949899971485138, -0.022214500233530998, -0.028656786307692528, -0.011590427719056606, 0.004752908367663622, -0.04587848111987114, 0.022514089941978455, 0.025937562808394432, -0.06331978738307953, 0.027671294286847115, -0.04157821461558342, -0.038078512996435165, -0.06338152289390564, 0.0286547988653183, 0.021983740851283073, 0.01656249538064003, -0.042171280831098557, 0.008805414661765099, -0.01789514347910881, -0.03920700028538704, 0.01030648685991764, 0.06297057121992111, -0.010928047820925713, 0.016837116330862045, -0.005316533613950014, 0.0659509152173996, 0.019291801378130913, -0.016107218340039253, 0.07985436171293259, 0.0799141675233841, 0.01075772475451231, 0.012616814114153385, 0.04468298703432083, 0.05533021315932274, -0.03489098697900772, 0.04399457201361656, -0.007170704193413258, -0.024205338209867477, 0.020948171615600586, 0.06281556189060211, 0.0019532558508217335, 0.0030801782850176096, -0.016449373215436935, -0.04334346950054169, 0.013867486268281937, 0.0366896353662014, 0.015125127509236336, 0.057578638195991516, -0.042555585503578186, -0.01957392878830433, 0.022264374420046806, 0.008287073113024235, 0.03007517009973526, 0.02900274656713009, -0.005564785562455654, 0.05238024890422821, 0.027740396559238434, -0.02160874754190445, -0.04763154685497284, -0.046794384717941284, -0.013383815996348858, 0.06276446580886841, -0.05353305861353874, -0.000671661866363138, 0.025814490392804146, 0.02414948306977749, 0.03769214078783989, 0.005343342665582895, -0.016623064875602722, 0.037789829075336456, 0.009570637717843056, -0.06136653572320938, -0.017258532345294952, 0.006754120346158743, 0.06520942598581314, 0.029577787965536118, 0.0320066399872303, -0.05646289512515068, -0.004914718680083752, 0.019763128831982613, 0.013589155860245228, 0.04889610409736633, -0.05104855075478554, 0.03059304691851139, 0.054069600999355316, -0.004799556918442249, 0.014167383313179016, -0.01468503475189209, -0.013926548883318901, -0.019382953643798828, -0.05129791796207428, -0.018162650987505913, -0.05403996631503105, 0.01588529720902443, -0.007311275694519281, 0.05879039689898491, 0.021093500778079033, 0.015534089878201485, 0.05713783949613571, -0.014975789934396744, 0.024181747809052467, -0.030121169984340668, -0.002775617642328143, -0.005377931986004114, -0.008497537113726139, -0.02377491258084774, -0.055252913385629654, -0.020684555172920227, 0.03002765029668808, 0.026164116337895393, 0.053347762674093246, -0.019342942163348198, 0.024381985887885094, 0.03130711615085602, -0.029357392340898514, 0.007854052819311619, -0.009569298475980759, 0.032018907368183136, 0.014679639600217342, -0.013582748360931873, 0.02816912531852722, 0.02235102467238903, -0.021762914955615997, -0.008637715131044388, 0.006648258771747351, -0.004275094252079725, 0.05621038004755974, -0.06110948696732521, 0.03296016901731491, 0.016823099926114082, -0.045053575187921524, -0.0033068282064050436, 0.0066811442375183105, -0.02901710383594036, -0.002621142193675041, 0.016494952142238617, 0.011443023569881916, -0.0006743648555129766, -0.030253322795033455, 0.010639662854373455, 0.009715517051517963, -0.046131111681461334, 0.024495311081409454, 0.012401679530739784, -0.0446244478225708, 0.05480792000889778, -0.026192456483840942, -0.06627225130796432, -0.050269149243831635, 0.014124253764748573, 0.062208618968725204, -0.002455807290971279, 0.013924003578722477, 0.04986812546849251, -0.04287657141685486, -0.036224886775016785, 0.011617254465818405, -0.0183545108884573, -0.05577898770570755, -0.013600400649011135, -0.02298225276172161, -0.060359690338373184, -0.009402750059962273, 0.0004238057299517095, -0.025675136595964432, -0.08142611384391785, -0.0050626457668840885, -0.020412232726812363, 0.0026938815135508776, -0.02380385249853134, -0.007266039494425058, -0.027838559821248055, 0.01869114302098751, 0.0050244806334376335, -0.057341933250427246, 0.0024679088965058327, 0.07139270752668381, 0.0035232773516327143, 0.09313111007213593, -0.015981247648596764, 0.005585000850260258, 0.0029757157899439335, -0.017226815223693848, -0.008536674082279205, -0.04252907261252403, 0.03006865829229355, 0.005993886385113001, 0.09627198427915573, 0.04494147747755051, 0.010433266870677471, 0.010089673101902008, -0.03910595923662186, 0.019616596400737762, -0.006165114231407642, -0.01905670389533043, 0.022976242005825043, 0.0324685238301754, 0.04409131407737732, -0.00834602676331997, 0.004946459084749222, -0.00029993581119924784, -0.0016330546932294965, -0.019426817074418068, -0.03499121218919754, -0.038794759660959244, -0.043583061546087265, -0.010793522000312805, -0.004633517470210791, 0.006089816335588694, -0.016932133585214615, -0.010205410420894623, 0.042480405420064926, -0.009127955883741379, -0.03912772610783577, -0.02886330895125866, 0.07468575239181519, 0.05697781220078468, 0.012551278807222843, 0.014351408928632736, -0.04451579973101616, -0.012147440575063229, -0.014110444113612175, -0.12109851837158203, -0.013011603616178036, -0.0313444547355175, 0.02885720133781433, 0.03576317057013512, 0.027624167501926422, 0.024332614615559578, 0.005673192907124758, -0.005994471721351147, 0.00046396811376325786, 0.05900430306792259, 0.0010735314572229981, 0.029596280306577682, -0.023987453430891037, -0.0767044648528099, -0.02270142175257206, -0.023068010807037354, 0.01827785186469555, 0.05315348133444786, -0.018512070178985596, -0.0038525033742189407, -0.07690182328224182, 0.00684903422370553, -0.016329487785696983, -0.0072357309982180595, -0.03372611105442047, 0.01779487542808056, -0.08026355504989624, 0.012161992490291595, -0.03663955628871918, 0.03419486805796623, 0.00576937897130847, -0.010548108257353306, 0.04653395712375641, 0.02831524796783924, 0.0027329125441610813, 0.017227528616786003, -0.07761819660663605, 0.03636913374066353, 0.029650863260030746, -0.058595433831214905, 0.0685005933046341, 0.010874742642045021, 0.007913758978247643, -0.0356326550245285, -0.022765101864933968, 0.014398055151104927, 0.10471633076667786, 0.0039302571676671505, -0.02111101523041725, 0.06784522533416748, -0.0202791765332222, -0.01888161711394787, -0.009226884692907333, -0.026263214647769928, 0.0075012557208538055, -0.01570802368223667, 0.008248437196016312, 0.06977467983961105, 0.026160920038819313, 0.005848484113812447, -0.024637987837195396, -0.04602024704217911, -0.006168600171804428, -0.046271927654743195, 0.004904943984001875, 0.07258552312850952, 0.014645473100244999, 0.004988654516637325, -0.07906395941972733, -0.011653978377580643, -0.007531526032835245, 0.024859998375177383, 0.03474295884370804, 0.0037895238492637873, 0.059614744037389755, -0.03200807422399521, -0.00845089927315712, -0.0373753197491169, 0.07222606241703033, 0.03691273182630539, -0.0008035717764869332, 0.003325382247567177, 0.05088840797543526, -0.023187175393104553, -0.0169830285012722, 0.0652962252497673, -0.04667969048023224, -0.013238095678389072, -0.008236457593739033, -0.08354955166578293, -0.023853382095694542, 0.03058694861829281, 0.008689001202583313, 0.03442750871181488, 0.010297819040715694, -0.032564472407102585, -0.027550019323825836, 0.011181269772350788, -0.017838796600699425, 0.010784420184791088, 0.05268114432692528, 0.012418614700436592, -0.0033807121217250824, 0.04235880449414253, 0.05101119726896286, 0.0025084340013563633, -0.006954395677894354, -0.013147610239684582, -0.001867939135991037, 0.009551565162837505, 0.04631373658776283, 0.06508862972259521, 0.052183039486408234, -0.01070516649633646, 0.012787330895662308, 0.06193600222468376, 0.008175215683877468, -0.010959621518850327, 0.052485011518001556, -0.011285156011581421, -0.0078089237213134766, -0.042603008449077606, 0.03990963473916054, -0.026166461408138275, -0.00042855142964981496, 0.003335464047268033, 0.03256284445524216, 0.007535910699516535, 0.06684665381908417, 0.0051168352365493774, 0.07203724980354309, 0.022163866087794304, -0.023027818650007248, 0.00038242500158958137, 0.05701213330030441, 0.02877589873969555, -0.0016735513927415013, 0.001368736382573843, 0.03327357769012451, -0.030014662072062492, -0.041677720844745636, 0.009686620905995369, 0.007482679560780525, 0.02401389554142952, -0.011162093840539455, 0.04677166789770126, -0.014507448300719261, -0.017146870493888855, -0.015635481104254723, 0.03164598345756531, 0.005367659963667393, -0.06309835612773895, 0.05133533850312233, -0.025738274678587914, -0.0010845344513654709, 0.021850209683179855, 0.014092961326241493, 0.044140011072158813, -0.0718126893043518, -0.06612107157707214, 0.034866999834775925, -0.03878233581781387, -0.04221640154719353, -0.011942800134420395, 0.025669202208518982, 0.013962408527731895, -0.06552011519670486, -0.09662697464227676, -0.018690118566155434, 0.009005237370729446, -0.03433060273528099, -0.02944543957710266, -0.0035082364920526743, 0.045058391988277435, 0.016905194148421288, 0.05026743933558464, 0.004753964487463236, 0.012169485911726952, 0.03559623286128044, 0.023931404575705528, 0.00006084247797844, -0.00810088962316513, -0.013073445297777653, -0.06585052609443665, 0.028392750769853592, -0.0728306844830513, -0.02580622211098671, 0.009936423972249031, -0.045372750610113144, 0.026832588016986847, -0.0033260693307965994, 0.07117903977632523, -0.029193896800279617, -0.02368207462131977, 0.06615278869867325, 0.051124680787324905, 0.03059336543083191, 0.0043037827126681805, 0.02623007632791996, 0.04573670029640198, 0.010835529305040836, 0.004866550676524639, -0.005076881498098373, -0.01383029855787754, -0.04722397029399872, -0.012100079096853733, -0.015205875039100647, 0.0356236957013607, -0.00741803040727973, -0.02852252684533596, -0.05408415570855141, -0.010267166420817375, -0.021361859515309334, 0.07159947603940964, -0.03602144122123718, -0.02176217921078205, 0.027030998840928078, 0.0898403748869896, -0.0075602163560688496, -0.0009246909758076072, -0.06853381544351578, -0.08285042643547058, -0.04253961145877838, -0.04017822444438934, -0.0918385311961174, 0.014568298123776913, 0.06228514015674591, -0.04792993515729904, -0.04012017324566841, -0.01749015785753727, -0.014235823415219784, 0.0039654881693422794, 0.022263145074248314, -0.0002135753456968814, -0.04905589297413826, -0.01380863692611456, 0.03745598718523979, -0.039071232080459595, 0.018793726339936256, -0.008958247490227222, -0.0756685882806778, 0.030186600983142853, -0.020960820838809013, -0.07659769803285599, 0.010103992186486721, -0.04392078146338463, -0.0009148617973551154, -0.032827556133270264, -0.0233760979026556, -0.01983686164021492, -0.058339376002550125, -0.02152004837989807, -0.017173532396554947, -0.012066496536135674, -0.017248693853616714, 0.06067588925361633, 0.041794367134571075, -0.004125470295548439, 0.051797542721033096, -0.026234392076730728, -0.03400363400578499, -0.047378357499837875, -0.04859887808561325, 0.021351104602217674, 0.003220686223357916, 0.022928446531295776, -0.044830113649368286, 0.012386597692966461, 0.013368690386414528, 0.0614817813038826, 0.014804600737988949, -0.03158017247915268, 0.04404253512620926, -0.05240526795387268, -0.0032242964953184128, -0.01456521637737751, 0.025106048211455345, 0.01213478296995163, 0.0388878770172596, 0.01766916923224926, 0.0022710824850946665, -0.0015896279364824295, 0.025972994044423103, 0.037806231528520584, 0.007724449969828129, -0.0208926759660244, 0.07009655982255936, 0.017143558710813522, -0.026172325015068054, -0.020997118204832077, 0.0024401978589594364, 0.008999696001410484, 0.04109863564372063, -0.057329654693603516, -0.06603144854307175, 0.011658516712486744, 0.04225577786564827, 0.04150107502937317, -0.0326712392270565, 0.043228231370449066, -0.08875805139541626, 0.036925747990608215, 0.078678198158741, -0.08930879831314087, -0.08739204704761505, -0.009468487463891506, -0.056898318231105804, 0.054238539189100266, -0.012133413925766945, 0.0356031097471714, -0.06756357103586197, -0.0825028195977211, 0.008455067873001099, 0.009193360805511475, 0.0480843260884285, 0.01666259951889515, 0.02828473597764969, 0.009719552472233772, -0.04381236433982849, -0.05934663861989975, 0.028552645817399025, -0.0357392244040966, 0.02809012308716774, 0.03129751235246658, 0.006366440560668707, 0.018995001912117004, 0.005061908159404993, -0.0009071712847799063, 0.007508223410695791, -0.07564090937376022, 0.013449274934828281, 0.01197322178632021, -0.03156815096735954, 0.004716922994703054, -0.002042626030743122, 0.010836053639650345, 0.08337370306253433, -0.04267244040966034, -0.07229085266590118, 0.025023307651281357, -0.023913588374853134, -0.021214256063103676, 0.03278638795018196, -0.04659032076597214, -0.02328890934586525, -0.0037871727254241705, -0.05570468306541443, -0.06518732756376266, -0.015830934047698975, -0.055366937071084976, 0.04767175018787384, -0.018402740359306335, -0.06123947352170944, 0.032047394663095474, -0.04851287975907326, -0.039961960166692734, 0.04378284141421318, 0.05528867989778519, -0.016868513077497482, 0.01220239419490099, -0.07205351442098618, 0.0009028373751789331, 0.013933701440691948, -0.03259367123246193, -0.006732569541782141, 0.04220949485898018, 0.014578314498066902, 0.016870485618710518, -0.038048312067985535, -0.004576726816594601, 0.058210670948028564, -0.018102552741765976, 0.03163626790046692, -0.051784418523311615, 0.028317028656601906, 0.005471627693623304, 0.045311134308576584, -0.041852548718452454, -0.028340892866253853, 0.030823051929473877, -0.005209535825997591, -0.012965190224349499, 0.08729749917984009, 0.012812788598239422, -0.05382310971617699, -0.014928426593542099, 0.011670826934278011, 0.01699446514248848, -0.0249584149569273, -0.015479876659810543, 0.02496226504445076, 0.004146326333284378, 0.06277381628751755, -0.03839666023850441, -0.05839630216360092, -0.03457994759082794, 0.0006951337563805282, -0.013181701302528381, -0.03772277757525444, 0.014642673544585705, 0.007028114981949329, 0.035951919853687286, -0.0189813319593668, 0.0013592365430667996, 0.006024416536092758, -0.0481409952044487, 0.011224930174648762, -0.01792071759700775, -0.01068960689008236, 0.0332522876560688, 0.001861683209426701, 0.041361719369888306, 0.03758816793560982, -0.047909028828144073, -0.02625439316034317, 0.012006466276943684, -0.03925231471657753, 0.01709604635834694, -0.054154641926288605, 0.030946336686611176, 0.03723163530230522, -0.06194406747817993, -0.032142411917448044, 0.02506262995302677, 0.04410499334335327, 0.0033291580621153116, -0.02712676115334034, 0.015734445303678513, -0.014288670383393764, -0.023379074409604073, -0.012069860473275185, -0.03003867156803608, 0.011736821383237839, -0.028930671513080597, -0.039836227893829346, 0.07924462109804153, 0.030425995588302612, 0.06048615649342537, -0.01607895828783512, 0.011776753701269627, 0.016677655279636383, 0.01561934594064951, -0.08594194054603577, -0.02488849125802517, -0.013690021820366383, -0.0039721038192510605, 0.031248340383172035, -0.016438400372862816, 0.030649682506918907, -0.0010934742167592049, 0.024450203403830528, 0.03481404110789299, 0.02455933392047882, -0.03847662732005119, -0.02254350483417511, 0.021054290235042572, -0.017251959070563316, -0.008973286487162113, -0.021089108660817146, 0.001546447747386992, 0.012760807760059834, 0.002947325585409999, -0.08347446471452713, 0.023504020646214485, 0.0032071885652840137, 0.0048187836073338985, 0.05080258473753929, 0.0689782127737999, -0.0243010725826025, -0.00351891596801579, -0.01260900218039751, -0.020779449492692947, 0.03408943861722946, 0.004772915504872799, -0.009302081540226936, -0.0018691254081204534, -0.033183880150318146, -0.07378020137548447, -0.03779562935233116, 0.02663460373878479, 0.007259268779307604, -0.009021610021591187, 0.03351834416389465, -0.0520978644490242, 0.01129246037453413, -0.017862126231193542, -0.023036684840917587, 0.042381033301353455, -0.01612195000052452, 0.014674023725092411, 0.02753343991935253, -0.04644634574651718, -0.014571765437722206, -0.0001173433629446663, 0.0018582979682832956, 0.011422947980463505, 0.056396156549453735, 0.001483882311731577, -0.009810845367610455, -0.03583173453807831, -0.019388264045119286, 0.07754217088222504, 0.008185542188584805, -0.03604476526379585, -0.02977432683110237, 0.029316511005163193, 0.002553895115852356, 0.045821525156497955, 0.028050974011421204, -0.028456462547183037, -0.029673896729946136, 0.021374668926000595, 0.04162367433309555, 0.010942933149635792, -0.0014294888824224472, -0.023042619228363037, 0.019195526838302612, -0.02945557050406933, -0.025110097602009773, -0.018948525190353394, 0.05423297360539436, -0.001348225399851799 ]
<p>In the literature (<a href="http://openlibrary.org/books/OL6927036M/Vorlesungen_u%CC%88ber_mechanik" rel="nofollow">Kirchhoff G. - Mechanic (1897), Lecture 18</a> or Lamb, H. - Hydrodynamics (1879)) one can find the following analytical closed form expression for the gravitational potential of homogeneous ellipsoid of unit density, whose surface is given by \begin{equation} \frac{x^2}{a^2}+\frac{y^2}{b^2}+\frac{z^2}{c^2}=1 \;. \end{equation} Gravitational point for internal points is \begin{equation} \Omega=\pi abc\int_0^\infty\left(1-\frac{x^2}{a^2+\lambda}-\frac{y^2}{b^2+\lambda}-\frac{z^2}{c^2+\lambda}\right)\frac{d\lambda}{\Delta} \end{equation} and for external points \begin{equation} \Omega=\pi abc\int_u^\infty\left(1-\frac{x^2}{a^2+\lambda}-\frac{y^2}{b^2+\lambda}-\frac{z^2}{c^2+\lambda}\right)\frac{d\lambda}{\Delta} \;, \end{equation} where \begin{equation} \Delta=\sqrt{(a^2+\lambda)(b^2+\lambda)(c^2+\lambda)} \end{equation} and $u$ is the positive root of equation \begin{equation} \frac{x^2}{a^2+u}+\frac{y^2}{b^2+u}+\frac{z^2}{c^2+u}=1 \;. \end{equation}</p> <p>The expressions in these formulas appear similar to <a href="http://mathworld.wolfram.com/ConfocalEllipsoidalCoordinates.html" rel="nofollow">confocal ellipsoidal coordinates</a>.</p> <p>How can these formulas be derived? (perhaps something more readable than the <a href="http://openlibrary.org/books/OL6952302M/Ueber_die_anziehung_homogener_ellipsoide." rel="nofollow">original papers</a>) Can they be derived in terms of <a href="http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LaplaceEquationConfocalEllipsoidalCoordinates.html" rel="nofollow">ellipsoidal harmonics</a>?</p>
g6573
[ 0.042557038366794586, 0.035522349178791046, -0.015028037130832672, -0.024253742769360542, 0.03452381491661072, 0.037793781608343124, 0.022845236584544182, -0.061416301876306534, -0.05327397957444191, 0.021560458466410637, 0.018584594130516052, 0.03260326385498047, 0.07134950160980225, 0.015038974583148956, 0.025553356856107712, -0.015484994277358055, 0.05801551789045334, 0.030769139528274536, 0.03843650966882706, -0.040471069514751434, -0.003473428310826421, 0.023090805858373642, -0.006921695079654455, -0.020139455795288086, -0.03953097388148308, 0.018421147018671036, 0.04851767048239708, -0.024481812492012978, -0.07841941714286804, -0.013157976791262627, -0.005350418854504824, 0.02186237834393978, 0.06761769205331802, 0.02500317618250847, -0.006178947165608406, 0.03153872489929199, -0.005606548860669136, 0.020918425172567368, -0.02903793565928936, 0.012455587275326252, 0.03543452173471451, -0.05133315175771713, 0.015237321145832539, 0.005466166418045759, 0.02714652381837368, -0.048697330057621, -0.03107236698269844, 0.004243185743689537, 0.01919490098953247, -0.015419846400618553, 0.059131424874067307, 0.09518702328205109, 0.061236169189214706, -0.08122656494379044, -0.022022275254130363, 0.05289580672979355, 0.05772167444229126, -0.02537604421377182, 0.01240737084299326, 0.03173885866999626, -0.016161086037755013, -0.03557167947292328, -0.03443094342947006, -0.009768303483724594, 0.05239449068903923, -0.04402394965291023, -0.008435402996838093, -0.011465365998446941, -0.05147682875394821, 0.011275745928287506, -0.008609791286289692, -0.0343589149415493, 0.029189234599471092, -0.03964218124747276, -0.07451644539833069, 0.02031407132744789, 0.01640385203063488, 0.023683488368988037, 0.03405166417360306, -0.021262014284729958, -0.003701700596138835, -0.003286602906882763, 0.017334887757897377, -0.0062261042185127735, 0.01018788293004036, -0.034063518047332764, 0.025233877822756767, -0.0003864778554998338, -0.01157678198069334, -0.008732583373785019, -0.007062449119985104, 0.0332508310675621, -0.006227915640920401, -0.013399974443018436, -0.03273775056004524, -0.007914459332823753, 0.014375276863574982, 0.025787316262722015, -0.02196933701634407, -0.03432220220565796, 0.017117559909820557, 0.024100402370095253, 0.0034603646490722895, 0.014615206979215145, 0.06414902955293655, -0.015285343863070011, 0.005565348081290722, 0.00936006847769022, -0.034808121621608734, 0.0013042677892372012, 0.002303309040144086, -0.014328432269394398, 0.04469791799783707, -0.0352032370865345, -0.037456754595041275, -0.012846048921346664, 0.048951201140880585, -0.03833615034818649, -0.0020941016264259815, 0.05601631477475166, -0.03418170288205147, 0.01095541100949049, 0.02773878537118435, 0.040762413293123245, -0.004367210902273655, 0.01961192861199379, -0.0161968432366848, 0.02005278505384922, 0.01679353415966034, 0.008512228727340698, 0.03158750757575035, 0.01910896599292755, 0.002008315408602357, 0.02474481426179409, 0.014138730242848396, -0.04385687783360481, -0.012956787832081318, 0.023638496175408363, -0.0038518542423844337, 0.0315605066716671, 0.021938001736998558, -0.04279514029622078, -0.02758212946355343, -0.054225288331508636, -0.03408753499388695, 0.034959930926561356, -0.022733597084879875, -0.028936421498656273, 0.01980273239314556, -0.030228234827518463, -0.02690754644572735, 0.06221930682659149, 0.017743295058608055, -0.013508875854313374, -0.05524333566427231, 0.011255907826125622, -0.03585340827703476, 0.04512405022978783, 0.0015913051320239902, 0.05671766772866249, 0.037381239235401154, 0.02259579487144947, 0.017001910135149956, 0.010346907190978527, 0.0006419421988539398, 0.07968421280384064, -0.05136539041996002, -0.07818837463855743, 0.04096650704741478, 0.002214419422671199, -0.035275571048259735, 0.007226529065519571, -0.016203707084059715, 0.061345841735601425, 0.038854509592056274, 0.011972618289291859, 0.03271155059337616, -0.03684232756495476, 0.01200651004910469, 0.012025158852338791, -0.04101531207561493, -0.003861948847770691, 0.025307873263955116, 0.01716911420226097, 0.013743268325924873, -0.005313829518854618, 0.047861188650131226, -0.00039856377406977117, -0.02268644981086254, 0.033501457422971725, -0.016819093376398087, 0.016082560643553734, -0.021554039791226387, 0.02312304824590683, 0.029224922880530357, 0.08751252293586731, 0.10650873929262161, -0.054225292056798935, -0.036318544298410416, 0.022140292450785637, 0.008607222698628902, 0.04389220103621483, 0.07284847646951675, 0.0013274706434458494, 0.006081757135689259, -0.014186029322445393, 0.003902987577021122, 0.0005754039739258587, -0.01378896925598383, -0.00638212775811553, -0.062158625572919846, -0.03151775151491165, 0.031076909974217415, 0.015679648146033287, 0.023040171712636948, -0.03130696341395378, -0.04962123557925224, 0.0005265483632683754, -0.018706096336245537, 0.02293206937611103, -0.046141367405653, 0.02320367656648159, 0.027285438030958176, 0.006429221481084824, 0.024996161460876465, 0.005440897773951292, 0.016607314348220825, -0.005701630376279354, 0.033608391880989075, 0.023297283798456192, -0.0014939616667106748, -0.02684733271598816, 0.06876366585493088, -0.021168125793337822, -0.026218654587864876, -0.033215612173080444, -0.05220286548137665, -0.0031217620708048344, -0.00709177553653717, 0.07178286463022232, 0.008339574560523033, -0.034953102469444275, -0.01275426521897316, -0.03333291783928871, 0.00517745316028595, -0.011072156019508839, 0.058484602719545364, -0.02270805463194847, 0.05903610959649086, 0.03132228925824165, 0.06047193333506584, -0.035491712391376495, -0.019325552508234978, -0.0003190095885656774, 0.029764549806714058, -0.0052624912932515144, -0.015892354771494865, 0.024656614288687706, -0.03616245836019516, -0.02928698994219303, -0.0315043181180954, 0.012823488563299179, 0.008373627439141273, 0.009768039919435978, -0.03983977437019348, 0.004009349271655083, -0.011571182869374752, -0.05531525984406471, 0.08249099552631378, 0.04023535177111626, 0.03776354342699051, 0.06539640575647354, 0.02462593838572502, 0.09712561964988708, -0.05910702422261238, 0.027171403169631958, -0.04678971320390701, -0.002752843778580427, 0.03945017233490944, -0.0070110284723341465, 0.03692523017525673, -0.02263045683503151, 0.017116989940404892, 0.09825066477060318, 0.017661958932876587, -0.05202069878578186, -0.02744963765144348, 0.0544222816824913, -0.006067551672458649, -0.01680339127779007, 0.024936674162745476, 0.038720715790987015, -0.011495479382574558, 0.036319565027952194, -0.004112835507839918, 0.01755496859550476, -0.03086676076054573, -0.04201135411858559, -0.0009951877873390913, 0.024307332932949066, -0.007456671912223101, 0.012188843451440334, 0.0016590867890045047, 0.03464221581816673, -0.06236379221081734, 0.047488100826740265, -0.0222503449767828, -0.09867455065250397, -0.009949634782969952, -0.0008177110576070845, 0.009853813797235489, 0.007997829467058182, 0.037518758326768875, -0.029087422415614128, -0.04307204857468605, 0.031957563012838364, 0.011709545738995075, -0.024128703400492668, -0.004009965807199478, 0.013648513704538345, -0.01126839779317379, -0.022514741867780685, -0.04473760724067688, -0.00045290644629858434, 0.020497633144259453, 0.05622844398021698, -0.07558711618185043, 0.020771468058228493, -0.02530517615377903, -0.08525948971509933, -0.012406804598867893, -0.0032368870452046394, 0.025678323581814766, 0.03829718753695488, -0.008696937002241611, -0.056972723454236984, -0.017235418781638145, -0.038024142384529114, 0.11012901365756989, 0.003596837632358074, -0.042133934795856476, -0.03034878522157669, -0.03247824311256409, 0.003128340467810631, -0.08773637562990189, -0.023956935852766037, -0.006424643099308014, 0.03518807142972946, -0.03590601682662964, -0.009460918605327606, -0.02385544776916504, -0.026744011789560318, 0.062385957688093185, -0.02910003811120987, 0.03630106896162033, -0.0271262489259243, 0.033507756888866425, 0.024604570120573044, 0.009766749106347561, 0.03537527099251747, -0.02847641333937645, -0.05532517284154892, -0.0022607017308473587, 0.00796367134898901, 0.04719232767820358, -0.04524439945816994, -0.0024688332341611385, 0.05765926092863083, -0.0642499253153801, -0.04159150272607803, 0.026896532624959946, -0.014011593535542488, 0.06287617981433868, 0.04135917127132416, 0.019804714247584343, -0.06640004366636276, -0.015587523579597473, -0.01021390501409769, -0.038506682962179184, 0.0028501173947006464, 0.03444881737232208, -0.004874701611697674, -0.007676585577428341, 0.02581433765590191, 0.01808331534266472, -0.009529286995530128, 0.006717979907989502, -0.011193984188139439, 0.09670637547969818, -0.051897428929805756, 0.0457271933555603, -0.05667967349290848, 0.0015942053869366646, -0.07350461184978485, 0.0014039510861039162, 0.00017313691205345094, 0.007568967062979937, 0.0005241600447334349, -0.02430001087486744, 0.03701173886656761, 0.026463506743311882, 0.003487205831333995, -0.0342070572078228, 0.044393643736839294, -0.020266037434339523, -0.0707952007651329, 0.0011154352687299252, -0.061781641095876694, 0.07603266835212708, -0.006143977399915457, 0.08800448477268219, -0.08187315613031387, 0.07280265539884567, -0.004149580840021372, 0.01909693330526352, -0.03620462864637375, 0.01350974477827549, -0.04628918692469597, -0.028758985921740532, 0.019809311255812645, 0.0070358868688344955, 0.03905660659074783, 0.001956566469743848, -0.050560176372528076, -0.021779514849185944, 0.02119160257279873, 0.08612824976444244, 0.0016194655327126384, -0.03515496850013733, 0.023900138214230537, -0.006404037121683359, 0.02261575683951378, 0.007335019763559103, 0.0013824617490172386, -0.08793468028306961, 0.020834892988204956, -0.042105380445718765, 0.01962912082672119, 0.024271508678793907, -0.012725342996418476, -0.0308252964168787, 0.0176957119256258, -0.023473113775253296, -0.027544667944312096, 0.023689571768045425, 0.08367470651865005, 0.006721155717968941, -0.102203868329525, 0.0056195990182459354, -0.04210818186402321, -0.038609445095062256, -0.036818064749240875, 0.05284292995929718, -0.01153101772069931, -0.02454329840838909, 0.004975898191332817, 0.013365644961595535, 0.007421882823109627, -0.005966047756373882, -0.013125530444085598, 0.00937120895832777, -0.029289525002241135, 0.006429802160710096, -0.011947916820645332, 0.05888557806611061, -0.03631674870848656, -0.06567125767469406, -0.0004794802807737142, -0.010134917683899403, -0.06081179529428482, -0.011264286004006863, 0.05964532122015953, 0.07919491082429886, -0.021859843283891678, -0.016326572746038437, 0.03101619891822338, 0.03083769977092743, -0.008991003036499023, -0.05212940648198128, -0.02447644993662834, -0.04516783356666565, -0.021965501829981804, -0.015964161604642868, 0.030007384717464447, -0.0033163283951580524, 0.018709935247898102, -0.03822929039597511, 0.027073245495557785, -0.03020540624856949, 0.08320252597332001, 0.025587737560272217, -0.04549175873398781, 0.02656388096511364, 0.009095334447920322, 0.010528180748224258, -0.038545623421669006, 0.006776050664484501, -0.08308762311935425, -0.0014267772203311324, 0.0035875802859663963, -0.022704128175973892, 0.034722354263067245, -0.03560568019747734, 0.0262464452534914, 0.026896527037024498, 0.046574272215366364, 0.05861768499016762, 0.015245126560330391, 0.057481799274683, 0.07206528633832932, 0.01336903590708971, -0.015719566494226456, 0.02482740208506584, 0.009152435697615147, 0.02171524241566658, -0.01655469834804535, -0.03476041927933693, 0.0383724682033062, -0.038412243127822876, -0.05059150978922844, 0.08121972531080246, 0.031746357679367065, -0.03204121068120003, -0.01758907362818718, 0.041783589869737625, 0.026087505742907524, -0.048713602125644684, -0.029975516721606255, 0.022132793441414833, 0.02286713942885399, -0.0700317770242691, 0.01956687495112419, -0.006632818374782801, -0.04850315302610397, 0.037174757570028305, -0.03424800559878349, -0.016712909564375877, -0.006031332537531853, 0.0036465704906731844, -0.049237728118896484, -0.03693253919482231, -0.014068212360143661, -0.04772296920418739, 0.03598306328058243, -0.07466618716716766, 0.009349916130304337, 0.0039125122129917145, -0.015223291702568531, 0.018063796684145927, -0.059082161635160446, 0.024657057598233223, -0.017643846571445465, 0.023888563737273216, 0.02367020584642887, -0.10013128072023392, 0.02590135671198368, 0.03468445688486099, -0.013285776600241661, -0.06617914140224457, -0.05769432336091995, 0.002791515551507473, -0.014502977021038532, 0.01228337362408638, 0.00797687005251646, -0.012463872320950031, -0.055698782205581665, -0.02649306133389473, -0.01901007443666458, 0.06718247383832932, 0.0052510411478579044, -0.011713709682226181, 0.0289307851344347, 0.015285608358681202, -0.003114393213763833, 0.016678765416145325, 0.052505768835544586, -0.022286225110292435, -0.020335298031568527, -0.023304414004087448, 0.019071005284786224, -0.05491122603416443, -0.006857677828520536, 0.030424755066633224, 0.02083093300461769, -0.08323235809803009, 0.006735426839441061, -0.03432682901620865, -0.0076843067072331905, -0.00803086906671524, -0.01915847696363926, 0.022566406056284904, 0.0013414955465123057, -0.013630762696266174, -0.0008022502297535539, -0.025938354432582855, 0.029981983825564384, 0.009864553809165955, 0.04605339840054512, 0.01342396903783083, -0.027892546728253365, -0.02430075593292713, 0.0096576027572155, 0.0263298898935318, 0.030323123559355736, 0.04187972843647003, -0.025449322536587715, 0.010950370691716671, -0.02847403660416603, -0.047886673361063004, -0.05416380241513252, -0.03375253081321716, 0.052262842655181885, -0.005743547808378935, -0.07557924836874008, 0.006191322114318609, -0.022642625495791435, 0.005017886403948069, 0.046670712530612946, -0.029036449268460274, -0.030136656016111374, 0.026062652468681335, 0.031837522983551025, -0.0020359402988106012, -0.035948414355516434, -0.02121994085609913, -0.009029198437929153, -0.06449110060930252, 0.005106502678245306, 0.05505462735891342, 0.00523093668743968, 0.04021459445357323, 0.016331229358911514, -0.020410189405083656, 0.00859772227704525, -0.043909016996622086, 0.013298294506967068, -0.03166032209992409, 0.04073479399085045, 0.04925457015633583, 0.027308324351906776, 0.02319939248263836, 0.038222841918468475, 0.011593655683100224, 0.02973596379160881, -0.08697421103715897, -0.004295167047530413, 0.011870496906340122, -0.0022476124577224255, -0.09969388693571091, 0.01912088878452778, 0.0315682478249073, -0.07929705828428268, -0.011081523261964321, 0.06718264520168304, -0.013998396694660187, 0.034446414560079575, 0.009367965161800385, 0.0291513092815876, 0.009058979339897633, -0.047964662313461304, -0.008401299826800823, 0.031505145132541656, 0.06912077218294144, 0.015914762392640114, -0.08166918158531189, 0.02260546386241913, 0.016221076250076294, 0.004206295590847731, -0.02164752222597599, 0.008116694167256355, 0.026119420304894447, 0.04073775187134743, -0.04896889999508858, -0.0028692870400846004, -0.009782940149307251, 0.010059910826385021, 0.054559387266635895, -0.017262520268559456, 0.011533813551068306, -0.005273547023534775, -0.0022742722649127245, 0.0012367900926619768, -0.050093211233615875, -0.01237014215439558, -0.03354455158114433, -0.0307332593947649, -0.03167986497282982, -0.06359613686800003, 0.022430557757616043, 0.0908908024430275, -0.028657162562012672, 0.0669635757803917, -0.05898388847708702, -0.0033380610402673483, -0.04614504799246788, -0.021705610677599907, 0.0006812464562244713, 0.05171733349561691, 0.013179360888898373, -0.02270471304655075, 0.019754603505134583, -0.026490911841392517, 0.011123874224722385, -0.009396479465067387, -0.029700294137001038, -0.026721591129899025, -0.00914725661277771, 0.01045162696391344, 0.005605868995189667, 0.05386153236031532, 0.024924226105213165, -0.0034083849750459194, -0.02564767375588417, -0.0032136342488229275, 0.03772735968232155, 0.004135371185839176, -0.015971586108207703, 0.017014121636748314, -0.0330268032848835, -0.018874401226639748, 0.01830758899450302, -0.029264995828270912, 0.028994139283895493, -0.038399871438741684, -0.05340220034122467, -0.010607065632939339, 0.003305416088551283, -0.03102855756878853, 0.02212494984269142, -0.028463779017329216, -0.029929643496870995, 0.02380797453224659, 0.05582175776362419, -0.03934267535805702, -0.005755474790930748, -0.03849878907203674, -0.06410443782806396, -0.038284510374069214, 0.006374233402311802, -0.004095894284546375, -0.011490244418382645, -0.08378524333238602, 0.06586502492427826, -0.008622712455689907, 0.013917187228798866, 0.0067073586396873, -0.05844888091087341, 0.0737089216709137, 0.03580080345273018, 0.0444539338350296, 0.008316787891089916, 0.009007885120809078, -0.0010020711924880743, 0.014718472957611084, 0.02586212009191513, -0.08594806492328644, 0.017451878637075424, 0.02079496532678604, -0.017936116084456444, -0.0008590372744947672, -0.03213103115558624, -0.016469256952404976, -0.004126711282879114, 0.0035876540932804346, 0.005383525975048542, -0.028034312650561333, 0.0074552991427481174, 0.017515255138278008 ]
<p>I am reading a physiology book chapter (<a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0387983813" rel="nofollow">Mathematical Physiology, by Keener</a> --Respiration chapter) about the gas exchange between capillaries and alveoli. It seems that this gas exchange can be modeled after some simple physical relationships. Since I am not usually studying physics, I do not fully understand some concepts that the author uses to derive a conservation law and I would appreciate any help. </p> <p>I do admit, however, that this question may be off-topic since it could be a mathematical lapsus rather than a physics question. </p> <p><strong>Preliminaries</strong></p> <p>First, the author indicates that if a gas with partial pressure $P_g$ is in contact with a liquid, the steady-state concentration $U$ of gas is given by: $$ U = \sigma P_s $$</p> <p>where $\sigma$ is the solubility of the gas in the liquid. I assume that this is a particular version of Henry's Law.</p> <p>Then, it explains if there is a difference between the partial pressure of the gas ($P_g$) and the partial pressure on the fluid ($\frac{U}{\sigma}$), then there should be some flux between the gas and the fluid and the simplest model would be to assume that this flux is linearly proportional to the pressure difference: $$ q = D_s \left(P_g - \frac{U}{\sigma}\right) $$</p> <p><strong>Problem</strong></p> <p>The author then considers a segment of a capillary (a cylindrical tube) of length $L$, constant cross-sectional area $A$ and perimeter $p$, that is in contact with a gas with partial pressure $P_g$. The fluid moves through the tube with a velocity $v(x)$. Finally, they say that since mass is conserved: $$ \frac{d}{dt} \left( A \int_{0}^{L} U(x,t) dt \right) = v(0)AU(0,t) - v(L)AU(L,t) + p \int_{0}^{L} q(x,t) dx $$</p> <p><strong>Question</strong></p> <p>How is the relationship below derived? </p> <p>I understand that $A \int_{0}^{L} U(x,t) dt$ is in fact the total amount of the dissolved gas in the tube at a given time. I also understand how $\int_{0}^{L} q(x,t) dx$ represents the total flux of gas across the whole capillary wall. However, I fail to see what the two first elements of the right-hand represent and why is the left-side derived with respect to $t$.</p>
g6574
[ 0.031538382172584534, -0.03473477438092232, -0.026905618607997894, 0.01767124980688095, 0.026747042313218117, 0.04392443969845772, 0.032073404639959335, -0.007909945212304592, -0.02337176539003849, -0.022864244878292084, -0.01170521043241024, -0.037634897977113724, 0.031534016132354736, -0.004945085849612951, 0.04637526348233223, 0.041776515543460846, 0.08866894245147705, -0.02790941298007965, -0.026275739073753357, 0.040856096893548965, -0.05117519572377205, 0.008718014694750309, -0.04089599847793579, -0.03583965077996254, -0.028093229979276657, -0.0361478254199028, 0.021860944107174873, 0.021847432479262352, -0.04872841015458107, -0.008143520914018154, 0.00845571979880333, -0.0007797349244356155, 0.00813263189047575, 0.007284419611096382, 0.0030500260181725025, -0.02279844880104065, 0.0006410925416275859, -0.03405510634183884, 0.01150581892579794, -0.010540158487856388, 0.08210521191358566, 0.04591146484017372, 0.022523118183016777, 0.05680358037352562, 0.007705196272581816, -0.032670166343450546, -0.07627484202384949, -0.08798757195472717, -0.031115639954805374, -0.009121750481426716, 0.027601152658462524, 0.03968126326799393, -0.039477329701185226, 0.007527273613959551, 0.0054757255129516125, 0.021763205528259277, 0.048566170036792755, -0.019992846995592117, 0.03650369867682457, 0.016483750194311142, 0.053008146584033966, 0.006816757842898369, -0.0009161695488728583, 0.008689134381711483, 0.013636481948196888, -0.00815454963594675, -0.01896531693637371, -0.018219808116555214, 0.03153345733880997, 0.03726882115006447, -0.008041433990001678, -0.04081328958272934, 0.04629940167069435, 0.009634474292397499, -0.01571040228009224, 0.005484872963279486, -0.025751782581210136, -0.02692534029483795, 0.05117008090019226, -0.059027113020420074, -0.06882871687412262, 0.0020898582879453897, 0.014298921450972557, 0.0022207258734852076, -0.0011241293977946043, 0.012937945313751698, -0.06391517072916031, -0.026367420330643654, -0.0421878919005394, 0.03476996347308159, -0.011703051626682281, -0.0032757422886788845, 0.10279589891433716, 0.00923913437873125, 0.008755997754633427, -0.024368949234485626, -0.002087398897856474, 0.03476627916097641, -0.016794417053461075, -0.02145547792315483, -0.02339962311089039, 0.0072219474241137505, -0.01709282584488392, 0.05192367359995842, 0.014904535375535488, 0.01213326770812273, 0.016416028141975403, 0.0697578638792038, -0.05315117910504341, 0.026605285704135895, 0.020171621814370155, 0.02287389151751995, -0.05130920931696892, 0.028982631862163544, 0.024159099906682968, -0.048182472586631775, 0.04522974416613579, 0.04532323777675629, 0.053811557590961456, 0.04227659851312637, 0.010416427627205849, 0.03270058333873749, 0.038536448031663895, -0.003725349670276046, -0.0185126680880785, -0.0005088060279376805, 0.03347228094935417, -0.025416439399123192, 0.034277934581041336, 0.06331606954336166, 0.024627894163131714, -0.03702721744775772, -0.044099073857069016, 0.021926579996943474, 0.04565594717860222, -0.06599116325378418, -0.03105333261191845, 0.05074993893504143, -0.012285522185266018, -0.02198735810816288, 0.013527036644518375, -0.0032416190952062607, -0.009726757183670998, 0.05847498029470444, -0.01669059880077839, 0.011069945991039276, -0.04132890701293945, -0.0587218813598156, 0.03946755453944206, -0.04070384427905083, -0.007299968972802162, 0.0872240886092186, -0.010387439280748367, -0.007225238252431154, 0.03147851303219795, -0.024955814704298973, 0.0343804769217968, -0.027433929964900017, -0.004414298105984926, 0.019983261823654175, 0.03796563670039177, -0.026489879935979843, 0.049209706485271454, -0.017248554155230522, -0.051436204463243484, -0.0005239172605797648, 0.021831106394529343, -0.06903977692127228, 0.04974980279803276, -0.030644703656435013, -0.013336348347365856, -0.03367931768298149, -0.0019016540609300137, 0.050202518701553345, 0.004425038583576679, 0.06827910989522934, 0.04764468967914581, 0.01691446825861931, -0.02487139403820038, -0.05569411441683769, 0.022591743618249893, -0.02530663087964058, -0.0061450013890862465, -0.024968216195702553, 0.03168254345655441, 0.047267984598875046, 0.02376352809369564, -0.024933552369475365, -0.09835193306207657, -0.04888265207409859, -0.02135295979678631, 0.0010792278917506337, 0.019441382959485054, 0.032269399613142014, -0.01007307879626751, 0.05482998862862587, 0.02748505026102066, -0.10851673781871796, -0.0422249436378479, 0.058610208332538605, -0.032885145395994186, -0.0043283808045089245, 0.04977298155426979, 0.05899260938167572, 0.025311030447483063, 0.024108057841658592, -0.015180977061390877, 0.02348167821764946, -0.03811204433441162, 0.017281483858823776, -0.020516930148005486, -0.02655602991580963, -0.001559731550514698, -0.010807426646351814, -0.03101038560271263, -0.05729532986879349, 0.0012698157224804163, 0.09609415382146835, -0.0015209652483463287, 0.009784235619008541, -0.006693142931908369, -0.034160301089286804, -0.06539081782102585, 0.0020795250311493874, -0.01651274971663952, -0.02369195781648159, 0.0335894338786602, 0.032830238342285156, -0.07424686849117279, 0.04140323027968407, -0.030803585425019264, 0.022798504680395126, 0.0005345228710211813, -0.007016555406153202, 0.018147818744182587, -0.001149367424659431, -0.002617995487526059, 0.019740987569093704, -0.015763534232974052, 0.019180821254849434, 0.012492619454860687, -0.0439918227493763, -0.037901632487773895, 0.030053624883294106, 0.01786772720515728, 0.06577979773283005, 0.01864134706556797, -0.04083793982863426, 0.0039435201324522495, 0.007640042807906866, -0.004619338549673557, -0.0016900378977879882, 0.048464108258485794, -0.013731387443840504, 0.01912432350218296, -0.018046218901872635, -0.019268354400992393, 0.013630906119942665, -0.00905346404761076, -0.039815641939640045, -0.013220430351793766, -0.026994019746780396, 0.0072180163115262985, 0.042297590523958206, -0.05756200850009918, 0.001523266197182238, -0.0037950787227600813, 0.06591258198022842, 0.030947821214795113, -0.03512877598404884, -0.01201965007930994, 0.04948430880904198, -0.016391145065426826, 0.03974707052111626, 0.060505229979753494, 0.014142281375825405, 0.057581283152103424, -0.059291742742061615, -0.019699491560459137, -0.013804316520690918, 0.025688763707876205, 0.017493804916739464, -0.022433804348111153, 0.03600035235285759, 0.05774049833416939, -0.052608273923397064, 0.06294148415327072, 0.022631961852312088, 0.021245509386062622, 0.04262600466609001, -0.015877196565270424, 0.0003648875863291323, -0.04425550624728203, 0.021019885316491127, 0.048202816396951675, 0.07627926766872406, 0.02153731696307659, -0.03590850159525871, -0.011225945316255093, -0.011994016356766224, 0.0076703839004039764, 0.023304276168346405, -0.04245857521891594, -0.010275417938828468, 0.05548392981290817, 0.021718207746744156, -0.05462133139371872, -0.07135415822267532, 0.020173950120806694, 0.010622464120388031, -0.016469085589051247, 0.00018536460993345827, -0.0054133255034685135, -0.048305682837963104, -0.008445678278803825, 0.015757838264107704, 0.007450162433087826, -0.05650408938527107, -0.012576553039252758, -0.007092200219631195, -0.0023072813637554646, -0.061496756970882416, -0.008100039325654507, -0.02487361617386341, -0.022279612720012665, -0.029578404501080513, -0.09593810886144638, -0.026200179010629654, -0.027766143903136253, -0.004688483662903309, -0.020624961704015732, 0.04434870928525925, 0.011347657069563866, -0.03290681168437004, -0.01857398822903633, 0.0014303779462352395, -0.03202709183096886, 0.04900296404957771, 0.054448727518320084, -0.021892903372645378, -0.014564023353159428, -0.04298827424645424, -0.029850486665964127, -0.026311788707971573, -0.01033800933510065, -0.03093905746936798, 0.023448793217539787, 0.05486535280942917, 0.023226242512464523, -0.014486047439277172, 0.06272639334201813, 0.02243000641465187, 0.039001401513814926, -0.02170737087726593, -0.030780086293816566, 0.005608965177088976, 0.03049303963780403, 0.034786392003297806, 0.027433348819613457, 0.004434157162904739, 0.04199106991291046, -0.05056564882397652, -0.050044894218444824, 0.043190788477659225, -0.009194454178214073, -0.02263428084552288, 0.022297734394669533, 0.01458706334233284, 0.020159870386123657, -0.05708235129714012, -0.019377680495381355, -0.027914701029658318, -0.04570090025663376, 0.03100305050611496, 0.0028727527242153883, -0.07202014327049255, -0.02262764424085617, -0.028408074751496315, -0.03654814139008522, 0.05925993248820305, 0.04806125909090042, 0.03793150186538696, -0.006212908774614334, 0.027405058965086937, 0.03757771849632263, -0.010955232195556164, -0.022281063720583916, 0.06148912012577057, -0.0001772452815202996, -0.018529975786805153, -0.010742833837866783, -0.02594411000609398, -0.03438572585582733, -0.05741129443049431, 0.055829260498285294, 0.011409763246774673, 0.027973709627985954, 0.01344357617199421, -0.056236933916807175, 0.0004957172786816955, -0.01698186993598938, -0.018944844603538513, 0.013057133182883263, 0.01830989494919777, -0.018664009869098663, 0.011350701563060284, 0.01287422887980938, -0.05809086561203003, -0.009296591393649578, -0.00832806620746851, 0.021814627572894096, -0.01821785233914852, -0.030800415202975273, -0.03221065178513527, -0.003968206699937582, 0.026811283081769943, -0.04765578731894493, -0.004418055061250925, 0.038250140845775604, -0.002679763827472925, 0.03168487176299095, -0.023642396554350853, -0.051935672760009766, 0.009691022336483002, 0.015018676407635212, 0.03001890890300274, 0.04750742390751839, -0.019602470099925995, -0.008927970193326473, -0.07725460827350616, -0.007722207345068455, 0.019244413822889328, -0.003555840579792857, 0.028295297175645828, -0.08768238127231598, 0.051557280123233795, -0.11451470106840134, -0.02613764815032482, 0.0028398658614605665, 0.06627701967954636, 0.07636670023202896, -0.011664588935673237, 0.02072356827557087, -0.009603126905858517, 0.010050581768155098, 0.004601768217980862, 0.012132402509450912, -0.023710135370492935, 0.014909793622791767, -0.05326300859451294, -0.03604598715901375, 0.0402592197060585, -0.02748052217066288, -0.046973153948783875, -0.027217062190175056, 0.01788908988237381, -0.011604896746575832, 0.006486954633146524, 0.009434129111468792, 0.030376140028238297, -0.030514584854245186, 0.09067673981189728, 0.05384700000286102, -0.002405930310487747, 0.0032744240015745163, -0.06460519134998322, -0.03945066034793854, 0.03265862539410591, -0.023502210155129433, -0.03631288558244705, 0.008789192885160446, 0.009637159295380116, 0.018203379586338997, -0.00746064493432641, 0.02773429825901985, 0.01823386736214161, -0.02149365469813347, 0.020841699093580246, -0.005932179279625416, -0.07033468782901764, 0.001336956862360239, 0.07290443778038025, 0.011949848383665085, 0.05941108241677284, -0.01325205061584711, -0.016953444108366966, -0.03710675239562988, -0.026683997362852097, -0.04302014037966728, 0.03672894462943077, -0.050442226231098175, 0.03205793723464012, 0.037597913295030594, 0.027038123458623886, -0.006966376211494207, -0.08625459671020508, 0.0716649740934372, -0.01983542926609516, -0.006661387626081705, -0.010395081713795662, -0.08040348440408707, -0.009950941428542137, -0.02329900860786438, 0.007005347404628992, -0.009957476519048214, 0.039656512439250946, 0.027496227994561195, -0.005943520460277796, -0.006717389449477196, 0.013461577706038952, 0.02536764368414879, -0.01855594851076603, -0.030200913548469543, 0.01170048862695694, 0.0019673677161335945, 0.03997673839330673, -0.0195926483720541, 0.02804482914507389, 0.0025099674239754677, 0.010969490744173527, 0.07813534140586853, 0.02621486783027649, 0.043544869869947433, 0.029067624360322952, -0.05512554198503494, 0.010937805287539959, -0.020108124241232872, -0.01440866943448782, -0.008499770425260067, 0.0023957283701747656, -0.012935399077832699, -0.006108046043664217, -0.04039427265524864, 0.044919922947883606, -0.08193952590227127, -0.017867088317871094, -0.04340539127588272, 0.029046058654785156, 0.06320608407258987, -0.020098725333809853, -0.0476456917822361, -0.022649407386779785, 0.004815629217773676, 0.06901554763317108, 0.04590146243572235, 0.005096133798360825, -0.007077929098159075, 0.003079736605286598, -0.00796765647828579, 0.041970450431108475, -0.013207499869167805, -0.05539441108703613, -0.015993472188711166, 0.0077723171561956406, 0.06288227438926697, -0.07423693686723709, 0.05705695599317551, -0.04465482011437416, 0.02827916294336319, -0.01988554745912552, 0.020641516894102097, 0.05803722143173218, 0.008634177036583424, 0.024217460304498672, -0.018086591735482216, -0.044857919216156006, -0.06466761231422424, -0.008114947006106377, 0.07573812454938889, 0.020754337310791016, 0.04198296368122101, -0.01803544908761978, -0.010958579368889332, -0.008610200136899948, -0.02872498147189617, 0.015213722363114357, -0.07918228209018707, 0.0013257171958684921, -0.03562719747424126, 0.05721157789230347, -0.015376562252640724, -0.05188268423080444, -0.0263733621686697, -0.03554104268550873, -0.015963032841682434, -0.002229256322607398, 0.023791471496224403, -0.019512230530381203, 0.07601544260978699, 0.03284601494669914, 0.026722708716988564, -0.021515149623155594, -0.010866221971809864, -0.07781405746936798, 0.003577356692403555, -0.04936410114169121, 0.040299613028764725, -0.027632979676127434, 0.0061674402095377445, 0.022777801379561424, -0.01432175561785698, 0.05219244211912155, -0.039629414677619934, -0.06693252921104431, 0.04119951277971268, -0.04020658880472183, 0.014990351162850857, 0.010848220437765121, -0.029264530166983604, 0.01261059008538723, 0.005666145123541355, 0.004178863484412432, -0.004637617617845535, -0.04401462897658348, -0.006135294679552317, -0.0766671821475029, -0.0011842453386634588, 0.055312175303697586, -0.012988242320716381, 0.009128852747380733, 0.002995977643877268, 0.021534034982323647, 0.024240748956799507, 0.009582791477441788, 0.054903898388147354, 0.029337747022509575, -0.053807832300662994, 0.02816285938024521, 0.03783372417092323, 0.01743912696838379, 0.010023079812526703, 0.024572711437940598, -0.007262185215950012, -0.01171056553721428, 0.0011442219838500023, 0.024736616760492325, -0.05693832039833069, -0.014799734577536583, 0.06457622349262238, 0.0667419359087944, 0.022577939555048943, -0.01584157533943653, 0.030415942892432213, 0.03752629831433296, -0.012432990595698357, -0.025761688128113747, 0.04352346435189247, 0.017948433756828308, -0.0644386038184166, 0.01825844496488571, -0.03160453587770462, -0.02484748698771, -0.08503897488117218, -0.012789889238774776, 0.004624335560947657, 0.02221091277897358, -0.00921938568353653, -0.002367408247664571, 0.016632109880447388, -0.07803727686405182, -0.029322240501642227, -0.030707692727446556, 0.008860084228217602, 0.022945381700992584, 0.026547059416770935, 0.06521084904670715, 0.035883840173482895, -0.03493354097008705, 0.0501968190073967, -0.06973342597484589, -0.0017758420435711741, -0.011798759922385216, -0.03519747406244278, 0.028056945651769638, 0.014364054426550865, 0.014302943833172321, 0.04661043360829353, 0.013471043668687344, -0.038107067346572876, 0.0009744542767293751, -0.0350586473941803, 0.0061145019717514515, 0.015045366249978542, -0.048033375293016434, -0.046393100172281265, -0.010225724428892136, 0.030745191499590874, -0.01229157019406557, 0.0023398015182465315, 0.04310702905058861, -0.018321257084608078, 0.0073589240200817585, 0.057849105447530746, 0.04620242863893509, -0.03533530235290527, 0.02306024357676506, 0.020678315311670303, 0.041305843740701675, -0.021253198385238647, 0.02643398754298687, 0.05862737074494362, -0.015261487103998661, -0.060040269047021866, 0.04158475622534752, 0.021631237119436264, -0.018280651420354843, -0.02666211687028408, -0.025533566251397133, -0.02651044726371765, -0.027690982446074486, 0.03500273451209068, -0.030636638402938843, 0.04170703515410423, 0.036706361919641495, 0.06482850015163422, -0.019713085144758224, -0.021911129355430603, 0.042009081691503525, -0.006418786942958832, -0.010167524218559265, -0.009135210886597633, -0.09151039272546768, -0.030162600800395012, -0.0998106524348259, -0.058922573924064636, -0.008944498375058174, 0.011931369081139565, -0.0029341315384954214, -0.06940818578004837, 0.019769975915551186, -0.022503945976495743, 0.013108866289258003, -0.00964468065649271, -0.0017974844668060541, 0.048935454338788986, 0.001048786798492074, 0.07651029527187347, -0.020854325965046883, 0.010846887715160847, -0.001916264882311225, -0.008969509974122047, -0.06924761086702347, 0.04123400151729584, -0.03554986044764519, -0.018282614648342133, -0.016030875965952873, 0.02369537577033043, 0.04724150523543358, 0.031108278781175613, -0.031987834721803665, 0.06247568503022194, 0.023312261328101158, 0.06202958896756172, 0.020470311865210533, -0.017100702971220016, -0.08406957983970642, 0.003737777005881071, 0.053265687078237534, -0.00881640799343586, -0.002476373454555869, -0.04153349995613098, -0.0015339611563831568, -0.019789444282650948, -0.01608593948185444, 0.046250272542238235, -0.01994568295776844, -0.03798219561576843, -0.013197867199778557 ]
<p>Or would it be acceleration voltage? Acceleration sounds like it makes more sense, but my paper says accelerating.</p> <p>What are possible ways you could go about calculating it?</p>
g6575
[ 0.08312352001667023, 0.07586808502674103, 0.003520793514326215, 0.018161654472351074, 0.04966525733470917, -0.02562534809112549, -0.00884028896689415, 0.04868462681770325, -0.04427643120288849, -0.022103141993284225, -0.014603449031710625, 0.03883613273501396, 0.025874964892864227, 0.045944590121507645, 0.02504066377878189, -0.020035864785313606, 0.05197307839989662, -0.04386107996106148, 0.022333770990371704, 0.020611319690942764, 0.011283754371106625, -0.030745036900043488, -0.036214109510183334, -0.046131428331136703, -0.04430576041340828, 0.017629817128181458, -0.07736609131097794, 0.03398270905017853, -0.0609356127679348, -0.020885879173874855, 0.0331958644092083, -0.056317511945962906, 0.0247451551258564, -0.004236434120684862, -0.051705170422792435, 0.022365324199199677, 0.01114683784544468, 0.061053093522787094, 0.03072216920554638, 0.012462745420634747, 0.007796390913426876, -0.04538142308592796, 0.012042010203003883, 0.01859598606824875, 0.007914526388049126, -0.007204902358353138, 0.006837520748376846, -0.0345076359808445, -0.027407215908169746, -0.07310790568590164, -0.05503880977630615, 0.0047226278111338615, 0.020131122320890427, 0.039281755685806274, 0.006597784347832203, 0.0352359302341938, -0.01570502296090126, -0.01386663131415844, 0.041809502989053726, 0.02714565210044384, -0.0341222770512104, -0.007141744717955589, 0.0713164433836937, -0.015099719166755676, 0.04806673526763916, 0.005028239917010069, -0.03154435008764267, -0.010866648517549038, 0.02178400196135044, -0.01092199981212616, 0.041439592838287354, -0.0664236843585968, -0.0379791259765625, -0.028038235381245613, -0.021477244794368744, -0.00016237549425568432, -0.022856855764985085, 0.023658260703086853, 0.04906119406223297, 0.03463392332196236, 0.005164827685803175, 0.0098949009552598, 0.012122954241931438, -0.024340493604540825, 0.06299091875553131, -0.0008857258362695575, 0.020083259791135788, 0.0393117256462574, 0.011463146656751633, -0.012959221377968788, 0.03361315280199051, 0.03625912219285965, 0.07507487386465073, -0.03844369202852249, -0.022316675633192062, -0.041471317410469055, -0.0009991422994062304, 0.06752986460924149, 0.03868381306529045, 0.004391206428408623, -0.024462426081299782, -0.03840528428554535, 0.019594553858041763, -0.036434710025787354, -0.005493507720530033, 0.01840486191213131, 0.015449589118361473, -0.08549649268388748, 0.0021345734130591154, -0.05912619084119797, -0.021719738841056824, -0.08673683553934097, 0.006417754106223583, -0.049709826707839966, -0.008271901868283749, -0.01631115935742855, 0.09639058262109756, 0.030418824404478073, -0.023183723911643028, 0.04597758874297142, -0.0011725217336788774, 0.04486526921391487, -0.06309153884649277, 0.06536660343408585, 0.0029976472724229097, 0.026353823021054268, 0.0018340586684644222, -0.02757728099822998, -0.0726034939289093, 0.026309316977858543, 0.03907742723822594, -0.013730425387620926, 0.014536052010953426, -0.021555878221988678, 0.02061929926276207, 0.05697578936815262, -0.02757989801466465, -0.03214557468891144, -0.03260311111807823, -0.002951467875391245, 0.013930260203778744, -0.04995105043053627, -0.02542201802134514, 0.002593432320281863, -0.002225978299975395, 0.02255822904407978, -0.05721055343747139, 0.02365647815167904, 0.029642030596733093, 0.04565419629216194, 0.03295271098613739, 0.042715877294540405, 0.011705070734024048, -0.06213047727942467, 0.07305353134870529, -0.03979937732219696, 0.02284446731209755, 0.008850077167153358, -0.022124743089079857, 0.05581885948777199, 0.044581931084394455, -0.04230217635631561, -0.0053471908904612064, -0.017253560945391655, -0.04896944761276245, -0.038710396736860275, 0.01694977656006813, 0.00940730981528759, -0.0111912302672863, -0.020043883472681046, 0.0010281672002747655, -0.020282356068491936, 0.052500780671834946, 0.005769724026322365, 0.03394772857427597, 0.07741506397724152, 0.04200877994298935, -0.017216864973306656, 0.012671815231442451, 0.042930666357278824, 0.04610591009259224, -0.018891459330916405, 0.04879295080900192, -0.038590386509895325, -0.017031662166118622, -0.06195122003555298, -0.008606916293501854, -0.004574233200401068, -0.04164888337254524, 0.03499467670917511, -0.05053282901644707, -0.03876442462205887, 0.02143014781177044, 0.006910448893904686, -0.08297678083181381, -0.033692918717861176, 0.010512237437069416, -0.02860347554087639, -0.027264272794127464, 0.02442937158048153, 0.030985957011580467, 0.061951570212841034, -0.021997176110744476, 0.024021010845899582, 0.0449247881770134, 0.01317611988633871, -0.05864064767956734, -0.015418730676174164, 0.049710728228092194, -0.001535050687380135, 0.04444735869765282, 0.062280308455228806, 0.025797851383686066, 0.07503051310777664, -0.0011622171150520444, 0.021388648077845573, -0.018059322610497475, -0.022670766338706017, -0.01384411659091711, 0.02194673754274845, -0.03036726824939251, -0.006596057675778866, 0.018278667703270912, 0.06427882611751556, -0.07487871497869492, 0.0021678698249161243, 0.014018547721207142, -0.040411874651908875, -0.00012940255692228675, -0.02893451787531376, -0.06844020634889603, -0.014718789607286453, -0.06313464790582657, -0.04066174104809761, 0.05835074931383133, 0.05505993217229843, -0.02884839102625847, 0.04106606915593147, 0.008488403633236885, 0.024920610710978508, 0.07480603456497192, -0.03388404846191406, 0.04540006443858147, -0.008463808335363865, -0.059115614742040634, -0.015051404014229774, 0.059035804122686386, -0.0068791769444942474, -0.016984669491648674, -0.017458822578191757, -0.0010117135243490338, -0.019554542377591133, 0.004524937830865383, 0.003022510791197419, -0.016484778374433517, -0.014852216467261314, -0.04267209768295288, 0.016588497906923294, -0.024444229900836945, 0.022886302322149277, 0.03095126710832119, 0.025654545053839684, 0.016374044120311737, -0.0221685990691185, -0.036426689475774765, -0.0031535436864942312, -0.00890342891216278, -0.036048829555511475, -0.017941923812031746, 0.01468741986900568, -0.023075029253959656, 0.05538554862141609, -0.05742647126317024, -0.03668023645877838, 0.009006783366203308, -0.01599934883415699, 0.03800357133150101, -0.03359355032444, 0.06405218690633774, -0.023083878681063652, -0.028569204732775688, -0.03980293869972229, -0.022058118134737015, 0.04472650960087776, -0.02768443338572979, -0.05944301187992096, 0.06591864675283432, -0.014695868827402592, -0.0075406236574053764, -0.018675466999411583, -0.04143723472952843, -0.035906970500946045, 0.00010380589083069935, -0.022754989564418793, 0.02628600224852562, 0.07840969413518906, 0.06573318690061569, -0.023580176755785942, 0.04165540635585785, 0.004474836867302656, 0.02944384515285492, -0.037970442324876785, 0.01217510923743248, -0.019070535898208618, -0.03267363831400871, 0.013789801858365536, 0.005275433417409658, 0.0008633994730189443, 0.02857280522584915, -0.0004528953577391803, -0.055786147713661194, -0.023192204535007477, 0.035288337618112564, 0.015720536932349205, -0.054670609533786774, -0.05427590757608414, 0.029452906921505928, 0.010832513682544231, 0.050086647272109985, 0.009267196990549564, -0.03609525412321091, -0.1072101816534996, 0.01504883635789156, 0.033330533653497696, -0.027886107563972473, 0.03147008270025253, 0.01366005465388298, 0.04568743705749512, 0.010616575367748737, -0.06394858658313751, 0.003797959303483367, 0.02893810160458088, -0.05925142019987106, 0.009381106123328209, 0.004078459460288286, -0.06468340754508972, 0.009515990503132343, 0.04473486915230751, 0.028578339144587517, 0.06717280298471451, -0.0247934702783823, -0.012211591005325317, -0.018739541992545128, -0.01784070022404194, -0.03451225161552429, -0.025166338309645653, 0.020015673711895943, -0.029460780322551727, 0.04441942274570465, -0.05118095874786377, 0.04727949574589729, -0.04243141785264015, -0.04760821536183357, 0.0076490226201713085, -0.0357002429664135, 0.0028930041007697582, -0.0025440091267228127, 0.016659000888466835, -0.06319781392812729, 0.06861173361539841, -0.027426423504948616, -0.00463671050965786, 0.021100953221321106, 0.027369176968932152, -0.008813831023871899, 0.005615539848804474, -0.05583709850907326, 0.10277027636766434, -0.058850664645433426, -0.03644724562764168, -0.023266062140464783, -0.0030498241540044546, 0.005312875844538212, 0.028147518634796143, 0.014754759147763252, -0.013160457834601402, -0.028360456228256226, -0.023561229929327965, -0.02747553028166294, 0.04643372818827629, 0.040173474699258804, 0.018415695056319237, -0.01658269576728344, -0.04029523953795433, -0.036964450031518936, -0.05881480500102043, -0.07273874431848526, -0.0024975696578621864, 0.021152786910533905, -0.061939988285303116, 0.014039142988622189, 0.033108144998550415, -0.06140226125717163, -0.0010457250755280256, -0.0180658008903265, -0.04375716298818588, 0.018241818994283676, -0.005200703162699938, 0.017620280385017395, 0.036044660955667496, 0.020259397104382515, 0.005499522667378187, 0.04999352991580963, 0.04077931120991707, 0.001606610370799899, 0.01384669542312622, 0.07441424578428268, -0.0281885527074337, 0.03128376603126526, 0.021784014999866486, -0.009966625832021236, 0.020818933844566345, 0.03704157471656799, -0.019396524876356125, -0.005620097275823355, 0.01067596860229969, 0.048823028802871704, 0.011016073636710644, -0.022425781935453415, 0.051034074276685715, 0.02657560631632805, -0.04891494661569595, 0.005563313141465187, -0.009058145806193352, -0.018491804599761963, 0.02396627888083458, 0.04451605677604675, -0.00992532353848219, -0.009556401520967484, -0.01236709300428629, 0.007804341148585081, 0.01625685952603817, -0.019473085179924965, 0.037160180509090424, -0.02462361380457878, 0.06818358600139618, 0.023803023621439934, 0.09866756945848465, 0.035164251923561096, 0.03757981210947037, 0.0556168258190155, 0.02400130033493042, 0.011896164156496525, -0.0033617489971220493, -0.006270457990467548, 0.08158902823925018, -0.011497248895466328, -0.01511712558567524, -0.005449100397527218, -0.0021284918766468763, -0.05293022841215134, 0.011216485872864723, -0.025851253420114517, 0.003288229228928685, 0.04293932765722275, 0.010577648878097534, -0.038306817412376404, -0.00965980626642704, 0.017143327742815018, 0.02546955831348896, -0.08689998835325241, -0.014117423444986343, -0.002708221785724163, -0.0037732829805463552, 0.018766120076179504, -0.01100658718496561, -0.012621069326996803, -0.04646407067775726, -0.046097174286842346, -0.0010208318708464503, -0.020558323711156845, -0.03797663003206253, -0.01978059485554695, 0.043706949800252914, 0.052417442202568054, 0.01431905385106802, -0.01054714247584343, 0.01575600542128086, -0.01806538924574852, -0.04948204383254051, -0.06975040584802628, 0.01009384635835886, 0.0033764089457690716, -0.06419317424297333, -0.03697214648127556, 0.027106601744890213, -0.04100007191300392, 0.03128467872738838, 0.0103920204564929, -0.06275017559528351, -0.016387108713388443, 0.09185057878494263, -0.02325679548084736, -0.03654802218079567, -0.026119079440832138, 0.0233360156416893, 0.017887912690639496, -0.029732992872595787, -0.015321335755288601, 0.004257090389728546, -0.07005613297224045, 0.008166374638676643, -0.00855030957609415, -0.028119483962655067, 0.022199947386980057, 0.04474245384335518, 0.050711825489997864, -0.0071438951417803764, 0.03181428834795952, 0.036624111235141754, 0.03928328678011894, 0.04719002917408943, 0.047406647354364395, 0.02474052831530571, 0.01814875192940235, -0.015577769838273525, -0.024848490953445435, 0.00839330442249775, -0.053386036306619644, -0.03173264488577843, 0.07063647359609604, -0.04998335242271423, 0.03741277754306793, 0.013904373161494732, -0.013726507313549519, 0.03848773241043091, -0.02462049573659897, -0.05136298015713692, 0.03216679021716118, -0.04848584905266762, -0.005221216939389706, -0.014505031518638134, -0.02011864259839058, -0.03931504115462303, -0.011191192083060741, 0.0014736105222254992, 0.02114374190568924, 0.01849663443863392, 0.015469267033040524, -0.0045997328124940395, -0.11129798740148544, 0.03011167421936989, 0.01099663507193327, 0.0651155337691307, 0.011907592415809631, -0.03982016071677208, -0.05677480250597, 0.04965100437402725, 0.01584993116557598, -0.10350517183542252, -0.014274763874709606, 0.009494234807789326, 0.0460883267223835, 0.0005685591022484004, 0.020395828410983086, 0.020122753456234932, 0.05923420935869217, -0.001716346014291048, -0.022055979818105698, -0.0039519318379461765, 0.017244568094611168, 0.012330417521297932, 0.03479117527604103, -0.01760290190577507, 0.008204145357012749, -0.00862148404121399, 0.01753261126577854, 0.0045440602116286755, 0.01609700918197632, -0.009040364995598793, 0.012482874095439911, -0.02650354616343975, 0.009857218712568283, -0.007549420464783907, 0.009282306768000126, -0.000880672421772033, 0.02888191118836403, 0.029963839799165726, -0.012258621864020824, -0.026243245229125023, -0.04959086701273918, 0.02175678126513958, 0.023133767768740654, -0.009701701812446117, -0.0024483243469148874, -0.012019481509923935, -0.038609396666288376, 0.025456087663769722, 0.030773911625146866, -0.010829395614564419, -0.012482719495892525, 0.004989843815565109, 0.009685619734227657, -0.05738387256860733, -0.06038364768028259, -0.002440653508529067, -0.007104741409420967, 0.018788928166031837, 0.0001927912817336619, -0.006755605805665255, 0.045967407524585724, 0.03342851251363754, -0.01345669012516737, -0.014963576570153236, 0.07969596982002258, -0.03205021470785141, -0.004210816230624914, 0.01837988756597042, -0.04741857200860977, -0.08858553320169449, -0.07916107028722763, -0.010376034304499626, 0.016681058332324028, -0.0035998851526528597, -0.0170135535299778, 0.026335490867495537, -0.009865961968898773, 0.0004121095989830792, 0.07069811224937439, 0.040603309869766235, 0.019191015511751175, -0.005712856072932482, 0.009244708344340324, -0.025878973305225372, 0.03795064613223076, 0.04305991157889366, -0.011369305662810802, -0.005034351721405983, 0.02510623261332512, -0.07532735168933868, -0.020947884768247604, 0.02042127214372158, 0.04933040216565132, 0.03831695020198822, 0.05596239119768143, 0.0564911924302578, 0.04037243872880936, -0.011675081215798855, -0.022033430635929108, 0.00844177883118391, 0.060244474560022354, 0.030881093814969063, -0.03511856496334076, 0.0212364811450243, -0.03792097792029381, 0.030002549290657043, -0.01367929670959711, -0.004968306981027126, 0.016275741159915924, -0.025650305673480034, 0.025944367051124573, -0.03214862570166588, -0.04161607474088669, 0.023236600682139397, -0.019442787393927574, 0.037562720477581024, 0.03526366129517555, 0.020990785211324692, 0.01285583432763815, -0.012850304134190083, 0.0002654818817973137, -0.05020242556929588, 0.05342990159988403, 0.01516477670520544, 0.002197759225964546, -0.006647124886512756, -0.04159862920641899, -0.031192675232887268, 0.007548993919044733, -0.0014291692059487104, -0.012943018227815628, -0.0636194571852684, -0.024454033002257347, -0.018635785207152367, 0.012609932571649551, -0.024047287181019783, -0.059831973165273666, -0.021259548142552376, -0.03980114310979843, 0.017800524830818176, -0.05783030018210411, 0.0429890938103199, -0.02544987201690674, -0.007374364882707596, -0.018163228407502174, 0.023418905213475227, -0.052133459597826004, 0.03418974578380585, 0.0030445908196270466, -0.0022352717351168394, -0.035772573202848434, -0.0037698259111493826, 0.03271213546395302, -0.02558060549199581, -0.006723483558744192, 0.023940423503518105, -0.06190699338912964, 0.014602044597268105, 0.0012083109468221664, 0.018185120075941086, 0.027839070186018944, 0.034569498151540756, 0.06227676197886467, 0.011515537276864052, -0.040283359587192535, 0.014918091706931591, -0.009409038349986076, -0.013867455534636974, -0.0373428538441658, 0.01593494787812233, 0.027564629912376404, 0.015165411867201328, 0.026007231324911118, 0.040416695177555084, -0.006887386552989483, 0.051854927092790604, 0.014206266961991787, -0.01576300896704197, -0.030279753729701042, 0.06229158490896225, -0.014635463245213032, 0.03056304156780243, 0.044074419885873795, -0.0293947234749794, 0.0653848797082901, -0.05269275978207588, -0.028678564354777336, 0.029417311772704124, -0.0042121228761971, 0.00015353957132901996, -0.019871627911925316, -0.03697923943400383, 0.06371676176786423, 0.07423168420791626, -0.05890284851193428, 0.0075377607718110085, 0.012185480445623398, 0.024512605741620064, 0.01321076788008213, 0.0577094629406929, -0.019278429448604584, -0.016754809767007828, -0.05355650559067726, -0.032284483313560486, 0.003780402708798647, -0.031651224941015244, -0.017188800498843193, 0.06353773921728134, 0.09110760688781738, -0.04316724091768265, 0.0164344385266304, -0.019045332446694374, -0.06847719103097916, -0.027053024619817734, 0.017995420843362808, -0.02410256303846836, -0.06927314400672913, 0.015356834977865219, -0.030840519815683365, 0.02481798268854618, -0.0035855239257216454, 0.008678426034748554, -0.014409729279577732, -0.02189043164253235, 0.029060950502753258, -0.07467590272426605, -0.04969805106520653, -0.0753168985247612 ]
<p>My question is vague, so I'm hoping the answers will help me ask more concrete questions and maybe produce some interesting discussion.</p> <p>In mean field theory, say for the Ising model, we treat the magnetization $m$ as a parameter and derive the equation $$ \langle\sigma_i\rangle = \tanh (\beta J dm), $$ where $J$ is the neighbor coupling, $\beta$ is the inverse temperature, and $d$ is the spatial dimension. Self-consistency requires $$ \langle\sigma_i \rangle = m, $$ from which can be derived all the ordinary mean field theory conclusions.</p> <p>However, we don't have to impose this equation by hand if instead we minimize the mean field free energy with respect to $m$.</p> <p>In string theory something superficially similar happens. Consistency conditions on the world-sheet theory are equivalent to equations of motion of the target-space theory. I have always wondered why this is the case, and it would be interesting to see a correspondence like mean field consistency $\simeq$ world-sheet consistency, mean field equilibrium for liberated $m$ $\simeq$ target-space vacuum.</p> <p>An observation: mean field theory maps a physical system with site-to-site interactions to a single site problem, where the other sites are treated as creating the background magnetization $m$.</p> <p>An analogous observation for the string: to derive Einstein's equations, we consider a string propagating in a background metric (which would be emergent from a sea of strings) and show that the background metric gets renormalized according to the Einstein-Hilbert action.</p> <p>${}{}$</p>
g6576
[ 0.010173088870942593, 0.034907229244709015, -0.02265014685690403, -0.05047597363591194, 0.04073931276798248, 0.03360029309988022, -0.0021636986639350653, -0.019708767533302307, -0.0015539274318143725, 0.010498413816094398, -0.025381052866578102, 0.04127069190144539, -0.011450055055320263, 0.007409428246319294, -0.019006825983524323, -0.006518706679344177, 0.058108508586883545, -0.04679601639509201, 0.006528032943606377, -0.04538968205451965, -0.003033860120922327, -0.011875473894178867, 0.0677657350897789, -0.039792656898498535, 0.0166776105761528, 0.05398952588438988, 0.04043315351009369, -0.03875606134533882, -0.00513051450252533, -0.001622181385755539, 0.002967291511595249, 0.034433335065841675, 0.05575960502028465, -0.05671403557062149, -0.054382145404815674, -0.015208160504698753, 0.015799565240740776, 0.0013299769489094615, 0.026669740676879883, -0.017702709883451462, 0.034220658242702484, -0.04702475666999817, 0.07668010145425797, 0.00951131246984005, 0.016300257295370102, -0.029141690582036972, -0.06223279610276222, -0.009973580949008465, 0.03682117536664009, 0.021022632718086243, -0.021760832518339157, 0.05345587059855461, 0.05176422372460365, 0.04597502201795578, 0.018675820901989937, 0.0207669660449028, 0.016595885157585144, -0.020954420790076256, 0.0371454581618309, 0.03031911887228489, -0.0017862694803625345, 0.022461652755737305, -0.03795742988586426, 0.05179723724722862, 0.022368470206856728, 0.022772183641791344, -0.09496141970157623, 0.02742248959839344, 0.02504635788500309, -0.012518513947725296, 0.04160188511013985, 0.03173620253801346, -0.04014037549495697, 0.002067986875772476, -0.06871763616800308, 0.011128995567560196, 0.03662164881825447, -0.01204666867852211, -0.04106765612959862, 0.03555968776345253, -0.05846378579735756, -0.05571003630757332, 0.0077639068476855755, -0.03450184687972069, 0.08352441340684891, -0.0753985345363617, 0.027852270752191544, 0.021023903042078018, -0.06760833412408829, -0.015575150959193707, 0.031095949932932854, 0.034067265689373016, 0.032479289919137955, -0.030603215098381042, 0.044331107288599014, -0.027340887114405632, 0.002546862931922078, 0.0616036057472229, -0.013332153670489788, -0.011413058266043663, -0.026367997750639915, -0.019695736467838287, 0.0018878686241805553, 0.048664506524801254, -0.025663210079073906, 0.017379945144057274, 0.056422628462314606, 0.06440010666847229, 0.034664321690797806, 0.01999969221651554, -0.05041025951504707, -0.02328147366642952, -0.050235144793987274, -0.012937883846461773, -0.05990558862686157, -0.06107816472649574, 0.020797723904252052, 0.030409622937440872, 0.006094298325479031, 0.04382672533392906, -0.01805407926440239, -0.024990618228912354, -0.010462393052875996, 0.0228461641818285, -0.018810193985700607, -0.029140116646885872, -0.021460115909576416, -0.02563682198524475, 0.01270729023963213, -0.021367983892560005, 0.01973516121506691, -0.05100386589765549, -0.017513060942292213, 0.042158160358667374, -0.026612896472215652, -0.0020972394850105047, -0.0529632493853569, 0.0318533293902874, 0.004903474822640419, 0.018108971416950226, -0.04376526549458504, -0.041829224675893784, -0.026493171229958534, -0.024596111848950386, 0.01673927903175354, 0.01506061851978302, 0.048771932721138, -0.054982054978609085, 0.030412254855036736, 0.06897170096635818, 0.031233686953783035, 0.08317515254020691, -0.00280958553776145, -0.004830458667129278, -0.030590355396270752, 0.02102215215563774, -0.006104433909058571, -0.05409161001443863, 0.015281214378774166, -0.05454960837960243, 0.08063941448926926, -0.04161151126027107, 0.06067148596048355, 0.01638975366950035, -0.010001718997955322, -0.008839568123221397, 0.03499490022659302, 0.021893780678510666, -0.0380975604057312, -0.060579415410757065, -0.043530452996492386, 0.02065606229007244, 0.05112998187541962, 0.0691923126578331, -0.07081004232168198, 0.039797622710466385, -0.0243911761790514, -0.006232003215700388, -0.0021215130109339952, 0.06290163844823837, 0.019304446876049042, -0.030226565897464752, 0.05100451409816742, -0.08113761246204376, 0.029064809903502464, -0.015549244359135628, -0.05991438031196594, -0.003555067116394639, -0.04117352142930031, -0.021584678441286087, -0.005535989534109831, 0.01834297366440296, -0.03213271498680115, 0.07068291306495667, 0.0037885101046413183, -0.010910050012171268, 0.008107814937829971, -0.05019168555736542, 0.00281452271156013, -0.027586864307522774, 0.005282917059957981, 0.03805416822433472, 0.016039889305830002, -0.015325489453971386, -0.05718521028757095, 0.028285814449191093, 0.001194977667182684, -0.0050125024281442165, 0.054834429174661636, 0.0012629620032384992, 0.00026575845549814403, -0.032856784760951996, -0.06875239312648773, 0.02761387638747692, -0.022479671984910965, 0.012337823398411274, 0.014546833001077175, 0.01718094013631344, -0.03742649406194687, 0.06991404294967651, -0.006943055894225836, -0.03457888960838318, 0.05910732224583626, 0.007931728847324848, -0.015151286497712135, 0.01959924027323723, -0.046287622302770615, 0.038452956825494766, 0.031395237892866135, 0.022413158789277077, -0.0958942174911499, -0.006068274844437838, 0.026368027552962303, 0.009341459721326828, 0.07053247839212418, 0.034336306154727936, 0.031872350722551346, -0.0347767136991024, 0.05971227586269379, 0.03830961510539055, -0.005137916654348373, 0.004095211625099182, -0.06603618711233139, 0.07927487045526505, 0.026241160929203033, 0.0638636127114296, 0.026165729388594627, 0.013233615085482597, 0.0033600616734474897, 0.030799292027950287, -0.010475254617631435, -0.012834385968744755, -0.010510919615626335, -0.04087469354271889, -0.013639691285789013, -0.012487733736634254, 0.013326497748494148, 0.03239813074469566, -0.02539222314953804, -0.03127158805727959, -0.026725081726908684, -0.054672278463840485, 0.053407955914735794, 0.02152198553085327, -0.003383311443030834, -0.0005185516201891005, 0.026082530617713928, 0.0016504416707903147, -0.037983763962984085, -0.009962807409465313, 0.01437303051352501, 0.03710893541574478, -0.02467290684580803, 0.06740867346525192, 0.014158249832689762, 0.01699615828692913, 0.003252448746934533, 0.03391145169734955, 0.03262191265821457, 0.003393335733562708, -0.015122411772608757, -0.02188807539641857, -0.044371347874403, -0.06373230367898941, -0.003966116812080145, -0.028191465884447098, 0.007216553669422865, -0.04265029355883598, -0.006777294911444187, 0.02274082414805889, 0.02294543944299221, 0.00489850714802742, 0.014062532223761082, 0.009777329862117767, 0.004537660162895918, 0.09660505503416061, 0.03136540204286575, -0.05430562049150467, 0.033799268305301666, 0.06755190342664719, -0.013898246921598911, 0.004822871182113886, -0.0340944342315197, -0.006741393357515335, -0.0008867821888998151, -0.014877832494676113, -0.05187244340777397, -0.08133575320243835, -0.0004855665611103177, -0.026200352236628532, 0.004685362800955772, 0.004559529013931751, 0.050350483506917953, -0.014134066179394722, -0.02389434166252613, 0.0565154105424881, -0.022109944373369217, -0.013496029190719128, 0.0426798090338707, -0.04955441504716873, -0.030160874128341675, -0.010604471899569035, 0.04329974949359894, -0.030760018154978752, 0.00026789927505888045, -0.0004188329912722111, -0.05359567701816559, 0.0014827405102550983, -0.024227380752563477, 0.05873044952750206, 0.031642526388168335, 0.018700899556279182, 0.05279020220041275, -0.00344640645198524, -0.01750830188393593, -0.07283902168273926, -0.037285733968019485, 0.037013884633779526, 0.017557388171553612, 0.032047901302576065, -0.034831129014492035, -0.030783386901021004, 0.023513032123446465, -0.006612321361899376, 0.002600275445729494, 0.07524054497480392, 0.013911006040871143, 0.020777186378836632, 0.029306450858712196, -0.02079007588326931, 0.004254303406924009, 0.002833411330357194, 0.0324910506606102, 0.010742684826254845, -0.026773763820528984, 0.06393744796514511, 0.06514947861433029, 0.04530856013298035, 0.016323700547218323, -0.03234678879380226, 0.021744944155216217, -0.007577267475426197, -0.08361810445785522, -0.04225383698940277, -0.012247140519320965, -0.040773943066596985, -0.05166604742407799, 0.009613045491278172, -0.012813812121748924, -0.03678835928440094, 0.013457055203616619, 0.032927725464105606, 0.001728429109789431, 0.005088122561573982, 0.06361209601163864, -0.009188092313706875, -0.00854340847581625, 0.022796137258410454, -0.02338981069624424, 0.011214671656489372, 0.0452309213578701, -0.029105691239237785, -0.06352244317531586, 0.006363939959555864, 0.006325829774141312, -0.017594577744603157, -0.05099725350737572, 0.02232428453862667, -0.05209843069314957, 0.012438423000276089, -0.02287493832409382, -0.03395980969071388, 0.03166668489575386, -0.03391420096158981, 0.05603098124265671, 0.05577509105205536, 0.02600555121898651, 0.03225245699286461, 0.06226612254977226, 0.016405874863266945, 0.03552626818418503, 0.01953967660665512, 0.03114723414182663, -0.013319652527570724, -0.04865414649248123, -0.03704284504055977, -0.007943777367472649, -0.041323453187942505, -0.01896740309894085, -0.030263351276516914, 0.02335219271481037, 0.00732451630756259, -0.04160790145397186, -0.04806169494986534, 0.060508303344249725, -0.05849551409482956, 0.02556261233985424, 0.007187924347817898, -0.015097180381417274, -0.029889365658164024, 0.008402674458920956, 0.023036999627947807, 0.014746959321200848, -0.07765234261751175, -0.028834905475378036, 0.057610783725976944, -0.01133554708212614, 0.03739500045776367, -0.004120917525142431, -0.061547160148620605, 0.03578316420316696, -0.006320647429674864, -0.002918641082942486, 0.003546625142917037, -0.1030815988779068, 0.0171516090631485, -0.0438305027782917, 0.009759708307683468, -0.0003427494375500828, 0.026547525078058243, 0.013651436194777489, 0.002021417487412691, 0.0436810702085495, -0.00015820603584870696, -0.07023508101701736, 0.04411546140909195, -0.07391444593667984, -0.02772458642721176, -0.0324549600481987, -0.023509345948696136, -0.06081419065594673, 0.003079945920035243, 0.002532703336328268, -0.026135429739952087, 0.029120134189724922, -0.04090554639697075, -0.0006987857050262392, 0.11916670203208923, 0.03883691132068634, -0.012626565992832184, 0.009753577411174774, 0.007549398113042116, 0.04025714844465256, 0.08282248675823212, -0.03643788397312164, -0.04584791511297226, 0.0009083243203349411, 0.009881829842925072, -0.02407318912446499, 0.06717793643474579, 0.045291151851415634, 0.03707873076200485, 0.021120188757777214, -0.05422739312052727, -0.032425545156002045, 0.047662124037742615, -0.042889658361673355, -0.027471765875816345, -0.0033222862984985113, -0.0617554672062397, -0.041117437183856964, 0.00727068493142724, 0.04866723343729973, 0.05531351640820503, 0.01082220021635294, 0.033865123987197876, 0.0022948840633034706, 0.0018405186710879207, -0.017138030380010605, -0.010222804732620716, -0.04005028307437897, -0.026731841266155243, -0.01008270587772131, -0.018686454743146896, -0.02763303741812706, -0.0012079993030056357, -0.01826571114361286, -0.0044809021055698395, -0.024706970900297165, -0.016798846423625946, -0.010912950150668621, -0.0034951220732182264, 0.06098653003573418, 0.049409154802560806, -0.050084732472896576, 0.051839251071214676, 0.022412816062569618, 0.006662821397185326, 0.008015258237719536, 0.04538780823349953, -0.030533017590641975, 0.05207419395446777, 0.020032119005918503, 0.02608432248234749, 0.035424306988716125, -0.04090399295091629, 0.012111629359424114, 0.01492692157626152, 0.02353927679359913, -0.03292921558022499, 0.001239575445652008, 0.008752121590077877, 0.09062977880239487, 0.02250230871140957, -0.005483532790094614, 0.03126869723200798, -0.012641707435250282, -0.03597995266318321, 0.049048762768507004, 0.020270511507987976, -0.015503079630434513, -0.001806997461244464, 0.027050349861383438, 0.014430869370698929, 0.021684957668185234, -0.04015275090932846, 0.0072276354767382145, 0.03812248632311821, 0.020092718303203583, -0.013961805030703545, 0.023792069405317307, -0.0416470430791378, 0.038621265441179276, 0.01463458314538002, 0.010001109912991524, 0.011259431950747967, 0.007539375219494104, -0.01901005022227764, 0.04657546803355217, -0.05063037574291229, -0.08901481330394745, -0.050691816955804825, -0.04497167840600014, -0.0028827576898038387, -0.02298501506447792, 0.013829934410750866, -0.022624753415584564, -0.01738562062382698, -0.02621503546833992, -0.0462784618139267, 0.0383455827832222, 0.013162887655198574, -0.007249750662595034, 0.028172006830573082, -0.0030258619226515293, -0.014811648055911064, 0.027290375903248787, -0.045381199568510056, 0.04583239182829857, 0.012595795094966888, 0.009099955670535564, 0.04610641673207283, 0.013474171981215477, 0.012844111770391464, -0.034695837646722794, -0.04161439090967178, 0.014218381606042385, -0.0518222339451313, -0.022226056084036827, -0.007124772761017084, 0.02432994917035103, -0.000808246317319572, 0.034928400069475174, -0.06798706948757172, -0.014359109103679657, -0.017032528296113014, -0.03758041188120842, -0.016831764951348305, 0.06806767731904984, -0.003470849012956023, -0.012162244878709316, 0.010232582688331604, 0.027837883681058884, -0.016796845942735672, -0.019444644451141357, -0.015066082589328289, -0.030226804316043854, -0.0442354716360569, -0.05555247887969017, 0.0023483806289732456, 0.012585646472871304, 0.015609031543135643, 0.044927459210157394, -0.03245256096124649, 0.024940140545368195, 0.06819736212491989, -0.016761500388383865, -0.004758759401738644, -0.03493933379650116, 0.036514490842819214, -0.01467833761125803, 0.04943036288022995, -0.037869494408369064, 0.08691226691007614, -0.0013345280895009637, -0.025824440643191338, 0.0347621776163578, 0.06803935766220093, -0.020068829879164696, 0.005949892103672028, 0.007909958250820637, -0.013681214302778244, 0.04380553588271141, -0.04053469002246857, -0.005098335910588503, 0.01428101398050785, 0.005628674756735563, 0.005213357042521238, 0.042861469089984894, 0.00020094432693440467, -0.057409849017858505, 0.04948711767792702, -0.05880684405565262, 0.042073093354701996, -0.054760608822107315, 0.044856809079647064, 0.007641986012458801, -0.03717256709933281, -0.06831793487071991, 0.050018325448036194, -0.03348036855459213, 0.05494704470038414, 0.05441766232252121, -0.006014949642121792, -0.05775890499353409, 0.038055263459682465, 0.07069939374923706, -0.0036519828718155622, -0.07709964364767075, 0.04182852432131767, 0.0047773392871022224, 0.023986902087926865, 0.003401273163035512, -0.04085054621100426, -0.03622141852974892, -0.010353189893066883, -0.050843801349401474, -0.023337997496128082, 0.014046943746507168, -0.034223005175590515, -0.09494291245937347, 0.0062322416342794895, -0.03231261670589447, -0.03358587622642517, 0.006134706549346447, 0.007159034255892038, 0.02088400535285473, -0.0146658169105649, 0.016165003180503845, -0.009740590117871761, 0.0073189083486795425, -0.014830158092081547, -0.005299555137753487, 0.0302005372941494, -0.011459394358098507, -0.022011058405041695, -0.004261312540620565, 0.04121537506580353, -0.06297926604747772, -0.017113616690039635, 0.04068534076213837, -0.010431595146656036, 0.02808176912367344, -0.0019840553868561983, -0.020011339336633682, 0.027480661869049072, 0.01647963374853134, 0.015575251542031765, -0.030713196843862534, 0.043298833072185516, 0.002725944621488452, 0.02608606219291687, 0.030695786699652672, -0.014662778936326504, 0.049699507653713226, 0.010829535312950611, -0.01290857046842575, 0.03286752477288246, 0.04815151169896126, 0.00775713799521327, 0.011741326190531254, -0.00572493951767683, 0.00009474121179664508, -0.02621370367705822, 0.0538175068795681, -0.04449103772640228, -0.023293238133192062, 0.0016917428001761436, -0.07880297303199768, -0.052712082862854004, -0.03888145461678505, -0.025107095018029213, -0.007222750224173069, 0.05166289582848549, 0.00913704838603735, -0.036610569804906845, -0.08694478869438171, -0.02392367646098137, 0.03898659348487854, 0.01805708557367325, -0.020049020648002625, 0.0351986400783062, -0.018117139115929604, -0.022375833243131638, 0.004225337877869606, -0.032867077738046646, -0.01886594481766224, -0.07743814587593079, 0.04981503635644913, -0.01686459220945835, -0.045071423053741455, -0.03406182676553726, -0.0022357774432748556, 0.0492430180311203, -0.009398353286087513, 0.04336366802453995, -0.019160736352205276, -0.037829384207725525, 0.037511423230171204, -0.05566791072487831, 0.030545786023139954, -0.04996839910745621, 0.025114933028817177, -0.03150911256670952, -0.026274895295500755, 0.03494274243712425, 0.00253501208499074, 0.019229257479310036, 0.013924185186624527, -0.005541750229895115, 0.017240002751350403, 0.01053714845329523, -0.03496697172522545, 0.014792349189519882, -0.011426453478634357, -0.030913271009922028, 0.0016258612740784883, 0.05062325671315193, 0.04253171384334564, 0.027565250173211098, -0.03410595655441284, -0.09572281688451767, -0.0366562083363533, 0.024396661669015884, -0.015432585962116718, -0.01621687225997448, -0.029749102890491486, 0.043535299599170685 ]
<p>If you "disobey" the constraints of the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kramers%E2%80%93Kronig_relations" rel="nofollow">Kramers-Kronig relations</a>, what happens? Do you get non-physical results?</p> <p>I am simulating reflection and transmission off/through a slab of material. I specify the complex index of refraction $n = n_r + i n_i$ of the material, assume it has vacuum on either side, and then use the transfer-matrix method to find the reflection and transmission for some given wavelength range.</p> <p>As I was messing around, adjusting $n_r$ and $n_i$ to see what happens, I found that with certain combinations of $n_r$ and $n_i$ I could get seemingly impossible results -- e.g., reflection going above 1 (which represents more power coming reflecting off of the material than went into it!).</p> <p>But I was pretty arbitrarily choosing my $n$'s, and I realized that in real life one of $n_r$ or $n_i$ determines the other, from the Kramers-Kronig relations. So was I getting these bizarre results as a result of (probably) "disobeying" the K-K relations, is it more likely my simulation is broken?</p>
g6577
[ -0.015696024522185326, 0.01552160270512104, 0.0064264689572155476, -0.007655658759176731, 0.004401165526360273, -0.015921222046017647, -0.009882722981274128, -0.021137775853276253, -0.0009819457773119211, 0.02800900861620903, 0.001570848049595952, -0.006115473806858063, -0.016164829954504967, 0.04882459342479706, -0.0398201048374176, -0.004358558915555477, 0.0810391753911972, 0.020815817639231682, 0.012354793958365917, 0.01265977043658495, -0.04479345306754112, -0.005012670997530222, -0.05090869590640068, -0.061765752732753754, 0.029536813497543335, -0.02337535470724106, 0.00022098032059147954, -0.039279792457818985, -0.06573116034269333, 0.020929455757141113, 0.027832841500639915, -0.016728932037949562, 0.06111372634768486, -0.045212578028440475, -0.039562273770570755, 0.02012316696345806, 0.05564476177096367, 0.015095576643943787, 0.021860195323824883, -0.016255544498562813, -0.03327571600675583, 0.014090158976614475, -0.022037245333194733, 0.0525050088763237, -0.04634673893451691, -0.020686592906713486, 0.010551978833973408, 0.04367828741669655, 0.01188150979578495, -0.03408573195338249, -0.017202233895659447, 0.02731173112988472, 0.036351919174194336, 0.05869909003376961, 0.0011752513237297535, -0.0011396154295653105, 0.01679246313869953, 0.01311586145311594, 0.10236044973134995, -0.014156010933220387, 0.009164267219603062, 0.01617841050028801, -0.00922069326043129, 0.06184417009353638, 0.06175192445516586, 0.02915904112160206, -0.04120476916432381, 0.04614284634590149, -0.029673609882593155, -0.05331934988498688, -0.016023222357034683, 0.00619139289483428, -0.008873945102095604, -0.0431048758327961, -0.025858283042907715, 0.020571323111653328, 0.025039199739694595, -0.006745143793523312, 0.015281518921256065, 0.038938239216804504, -0.010182345286011696, -0.015454531647264957, -0.006768539547920227, 0.010802377946674824, 0.032611921429634094, 0.05224141478538513, 0.015971628949046135, 0.02506948634982109, 0.012420200742781162, 0.026025203987956047, 0.019379815086722374, -0.011377369984984398, 0.015103340148925781, 0.01862165704369545, 0.04513391852378845, 0.043354395776987076, -0.031864043325185776, 0.03323330730199814, 0.007702548988163471, 0.000007123489922378212, -0.007485812995582819, 0.07259875535964966, 0.03080027736723423, -0.03343070670962334, -0.06776545196771622, 0.004786740988492966, 0.08741740882396698, 0.005954217631369829, -0.0005982012953609228, -0.003316677175462246, -0.055190447717905045, -0.04025960713624954, -0.07216980308294296, -0.0870320126414299, 0.0016918940236791968, -0.040934935212135315, -0.01139912661164999, 0.019190488383173943, 0.03366556018590927, 0.009835740551352501, 0.0021588511299341917, -0.0459582544863224, 0.0298834927380085, 0.07658294588327408, -0.054495878517627716, 0.0062682898715138435, 0.02789456956088543, 0.013177050277590752, 0.09071490168571472, -0.0058160205371677876, -0.050255320966243744, -0.025910409167408943, -0.031821779906749725, 0.07490414381027222, 0.025073735043406487, -0.030696576461195946, 0.04141295328736305, 0.04540017619729042, 0.005577871110290289, -0.0290281493216753, -0.010354510508477688, -0.04138471931219101, -0.06259491294622421, -0.07157852500677109, -0.05660814046859741, -0.02715274505317211, -0.003937785979360342, -0.01158884633332491, 0.05356413498520851, -0.06056287884712219, -0.003638551337644458, 0.024659907445311546, -0.028245480731129646, -0.025846706703305244, -0.012285999953746796, -0.005093881860375404, 0.022987598553299904, -0.05276012793183327, -0.005417116917669773, -0.058957748115062714, 0.030648162588477135, -0.01348450593650341, -0.005521183367818594, -0.00543221877887845, 0.020532798022031784, -0.06106505170464516, 0.011441051959991455, -0.02343887835741043, 0.028323115780949593, -0.07481665164232254, -0.07274738699197769, 0.0028449823148548603, -0.024930315092206, 0.01468656025826931, 0.033586543053388596, 0.11164442449808121, 0.0372641496360302, 0.02603471651673317, -0.009426706470549107, 0.04065932705998421, -0.02226904220879078, -0.0006473507964983582, -0.019227150827646255, -0.030376141890883446, 0.0007034321315586567, -0.02858932688832283, 0.022726375609636307, -0.006519107148051262, -0.03931957110762596, -0.01453795749694109, -0.04059087112545967, -0.018584247678518295, -0.0248020701110363, -0.04456012696027756, -0.00607258640229702, -0.008350912481546402, 0.0007862875354476273, 0.028660066425800323, -0.01542751770466566, 0.049355894327163696, 0.014143268577754498, 0.07774677127599716, 0.07081638276576996, -0.0013041142374277115, 0.008726773783564568, 0.014782106503844261, -0.038888826966285706, -0.015940062701702118, 0.006043786648660898, -0.04806314408779144, 0.00863572582602501, 0.028119230642914772, 0.03941628709435463, -0.040841035544872284, 0.008228522725403309, -0.03875771164894104, -0.009150811471045017, -0.0060887085273861885, 0.012034831568598747, 0.02776232734322548, -0.01728527992963791, -0.015467224642634392, 0.05515698343515396, 0.011798383668065071, -0.027200981974601746, -0.0231382604688406, 0.017029769718647003, -0.025033319368958473, -0.023389024659991264, -0.022313592955470085, -0.04359200969338417, -0.060919713228940964, -0.001789547735825181, -0.027055907994508743, 0.021343978121876717, 0.012979439459741116, -0.02597193978726864, -0.010156791657209396, 0.02135809138417244, 0.00950607843697071, 0.024967018514871597, -0.048609256744384766, -0.08789677172899246, 0.04154261574149132, -0.012672921642661095, 0.004056576639413834, 0.06312555819749832, -0.0009549760725349188, -0.02561694011092186, -0.007481640670448542, -0.008431264199316502, 0.029784800484776497, -0.01293590385466814, -0.004660158883780241, -0.01772811822593212, -0.007382503245025873, -0.03986537083983421, 0.028841108083724976, -0.01825825124979019, -0.0004178847884759307, 0.015984365716576576, -0.041116319596767426, 0.02736126258969307, 0.042878128588199615, -0.05189010500907898, 0.005786094814538956, 0.0011848877184092999, 0.05950473994016647, 0.03262120112776756, 0.03621845692396164, -0.038045331835746765, 0.05687418580055237, 0.0591319240629673, 0.035826317965984344, 0.016787713393568993, 0.02313576079905033, 0.0019619751255959272, -0.09405592828989029, 0.019718296825885773, -0.0022158429492264986, -0.08622550964355469, 0.012445461004972458, -0.007910959422588348, 0.0008755928720347583, 0.011018648743629456, -0.06649117171764374, -0.038506485521793365, 0.014184903353452682, -0.00598240876570344, 0.006122750695794821, -0.07375641167163849, 0.012350056320428848, -0.0011106951860710979, 0.011246833950281143, -0.04485892876982689, 0.014531121589243412, -0.000031024261261336505, -0.04331095889210701, 0.05283269286155701, 0.05766410380601883, 0.06462465226650238, -0.01158076524734497, -0.050871457904577255, 0.01600344106554985, -0.04112381860613823, 0.01736965775489807, -0.032816026359796524, -0.05252045765519142, 0.030484884977340698, 0.009769673459231853, 0.014243727549910545, 0.019678223878145218, 0.03644941747188568, 0.0029721709433943033, 0.05283532291650772, 0.01992490515112877, 0.011358886025846004, 0.004236854612827301, 0.007652051746845245, 0.011889678426086903, -0.03731248900294304, 0.018917664885520935, -0.001209814683534205, -0.01842326670885086, 0.009775633923709393, 0.0431019626557827, -0.08948913216590881, 0.026415841653943062, 0.005188366398215294, 0.02549688145518303, 0.0012001052964478731, -0.009918482042849064, 0.03391525521874428, -0.02569000795483589, -0.07052718102931976, -0.02278873324394226, -0.0545150488615036, 0.02126263827085495, 0.006447277497500181, -0.0009944657795131207, -0.02116943895816803, -0.020601360127329826, -0.0268112700432539, 0.01842733472585678, 0.030985910445451736, 0.05145270377397537, -0.008566740900278091, 0.0218210406601429, -0.020351437851786613, 0.023144157603383064, 0.003324603894725442, 0.04657144844532013, 0.07145155966281891, -0.01773216389119625, -0.02667670138180256, 0.013021543622016907, -0.01050442922860384, 0.06102953106164932, 0.00345044769346714, 0.001376091269776225, -0.0035223416052758694, 0.031212694942951202, -0.01068421732634306, -0.06200419366359711, 0.021215898916125298, 0.018650276586413383, 0.06721410900354385, 0.07131814956665039, 0.004968529101461172, -0.006559787318110466, -0.014011741615831852, -0.015489163808524609, 0.01687527447938919, 0.006358254700899124, 0.011322644539177418, 0.0031856365967541933, -0.03987729549407959, -0.027794308960437775, 0.022414935752749443, 0.06727477163076401, 0.009235083125531673, 0.05092184245586395, 0.04203731566667557, 0.002618037164211273, 0.0003588491235859692, 0.02307855896651745, 0.011858365498483181, -0.005110225640237331, -0.07381759583950043, -0.039242275059223175, -0.011683431454002857, -0.011181283742189407, -0.03364211320877075, 0.004346136935055256, 0.022552642971277237, -0.05260429158806801, -0.015528866089880466, -0.015602398663759232, -0.016740601509809494, 0.003460012376308441, 0.05879056826233864, 0.04276061803102493, -0.04731304571032524, 0.0025418910663574934, 0.019783426076173782, -0.014094183221459389, 0.011134862899780273, 0.06435791403055191, -0.016948077827692032, 0.00638591917231679, -0.05613255128264427, -0.038003481924533844, -0.04832424223423004, -0.1531052142381668, 0.007493241224437952, -0.012483678758144379, -0.0378463938832283, 0.017601005733013153, -0.008928965777158737, 0.011620710603892803, -0.02039322443306446, 0.015019009821116924, 0.0005887102452106774, 0.001862254342995584, 0.04520094022154808, -0.026610931381583214, 0.009967929683625698, -0.034368403255939484, -0.03188629820942879, -0.03635545074939728, -0.008270585909485817, 0.004192478489130735, -0.01332056149840355, 0.011977393180131912, 0.01701866090297699, 0.03258409723639488, -0.015044420957565308, -0.01875450648367405, 0.030921027064323425, 0.06193634122610092, 0.025609508156776428, -0.020901627838611603, 0.05509326979517937, -0.0457393042743206, 0.028861455619335175, 0.054562199860811234, -0.07611187547445297, -0.0026699528098106384, -0.0210937038064003, -0.014278889633715153, -0.06554675102233887, -0.027247561141848564, -0.0052248090505599976, -0.042726896703243256, -0.008284118957817554, -0.07022131234407425, -0.0018531865207478404, 0.03203968703746796, 0.055179037153720856, 0.02203674055635929, -0.033165086060762405, -0.0010881911730393767, -0.010385447181761265, -0.031088801100850105, 0.024240532889962196, 0.01668507792055607, -0.020772850140929222, 0.018355896696448326, -0.03694663941860199, -0.014121098443865776, 0.023021353408694267, 0.03351863846182823, 0.04465930536389351, 0.02038026787340641, 0.051936496049165726, 0.008239729329943657, -0.05440690740942955, 0.04950135946273804, -0.0991920605301857, -0.005668092984706163, 0.01865692436695099, 0.04529336467385292, 0.0781116634607315, 0.0017209949437528849, -0.0394071601331234, 0.034008972346782684, -0.030028708279132843, 0.006777280941605568, 0.030390113592147827, 0.027233991771936417, 0.05975586920976639, -0.0996265560388565, -0.019870050251483917, -0.021431926637887955, -0.032457541674375534, 0.05280613526701927, 0.04637398198246956, -0.0034515431616455317, -0.013450747355818748, 0.006242303643375635, -0.020890535786747932, 0.01964268647134304, 0.054233256727457047, -0.008310372941195965, -0.016625896096229553, -0.019004955887794495, 0.093548983335495, -0.010265134274959564, 0.018755435943603516, 0.0189205352216959, 0.04746882617473602, 0.022082572802901268, 0.021505756303668022, -0.03164822980761528, 0.0014255965361371636, -0.010993588715791702, -0.1044652983546257, -0.038067858666181564, -0.09059060364961624, -0.06808421015739441, 0.023092731833457947, 0.020660074427723885, 0.006777756381779909, -0.03651467710733414, -0.034567732363939285, 0.01035014446824789, -0.003329691244289279, -0.046028003096580505, -0.018940627574920654, 0.0044112359173595905, 0.027281764894723892, 0.04008139297366142, -0.006387550383806229, 0.01613840088248253, 0.016450321301817894, -0.035286370664834976, 0.032736457884311676, -0.015964914113283157, 0.01175468135625124, -0.029781989753246307, -0.007615883368998766, 0.031015513464808464, 0.04519803449511528, 0.04380015283823013, -0.009625179693102837, -0.004837778862565756, 0.026277555152773857, 0.025500616058707237, 0.07605350017547607, 0.031954213976860046, -0.03314538300037384, -0.02430502325296402, 0.00038656333344988525, 0.009409029968082905, 0.06559757888317108, -0.011089172214269638, -0.04865139722824097, -0.01540480274707079, -0.04796447604894638, 0.02621070295572281, 0.027910158038139343, 0.04033636301755905, 0.025584755465388298, -0.0262944046407938, -0.005338301882147789, -0.022270159795880318, -0.06020384281873703, 0.02240125648677349, -0.003968897741287947, 0.02064157836139202, 0.010970943607389927, 0.004641290754079819, -0.012745627202093601, -0.007215610705316067, -0.02748410776257515, 0.04765268787741661, -0.0777248963713646, -0.00926687940955162, 0.00816656555980444, 0.0030287669505923986, -0.014489846304059029, -0.011974407359957695, 0.003922305069863796, 0.013997540809214115, -0.04636315256357193, 0.010100656189024448, -0.03258964419364929, 0.02121458388864994, 0.033703237771987915, -0.012671257369220257, -0.07394133508205414, -0.05763683840632439, 0.022591607645154, -0.008034856989979744, 0.00827581062912941, -0.04669126123189926, 0.06527083367109299, 0.019468359649181366, -0.07840809971094131, 0.060801081359386444, 0.04099594056606293, -0.014271978288888931, 0.05474872514605522, -0.05763353407382965, -0.03605321794748306, 0.0032981305848807096, -0.02776396833360195, 0.05186520516872406, -0.0037003145553171635, 0.04324818029999733, -0.002161042531952262, 0.03860645741224289, 0.004494958091527224, 0.07888525724411011, 0.02438405156135559, -0.03559683635830879, 0.048551853746175766, 0.004523520823568106, -0.030156167224049568, -0.07542648911476135, 0.004545248579233885, -0.018992388620972633, 0.02031593769788742, -0.0012218509800732136, -0.025290435180068016, 0.021854732185602188, -0.03419529274106026, -0.03113805316388607, 0.03697784245014191, 0.0679866150021553, 0.03307359293103218, -0.004797845613211393, -0.0036650330293923616, 0.007697194814682007, 0.04692227393388748, 0.03947928175330162, -0.07128588110208511, 0.060056932270526886, 0.04111180081963539, 0.06437631696462631, 0.026505379006266594, -0.029058918356895447, -0.00471285218372941, -0.022337203845381737, -0.02112491987645626, -0.0030001113191246986, -0.006363665219396353, 0.03273678943514824, -0.101420097053051, 0.01764546148478985, 0.04476818069815636, 0.01692206785082817, -0.07017658650875092, 0.031151970848441124, -0.034402377903461456, -0.009576728567481041, 0.008298911154270172, 0.04661678522825241, 0.042866308242082596, -0.03194563835859299, -0.039681658148765564, -0.05254419147968292, -0.06181006506085396, -0.021104419603943825, -0.032518163323402405, 0.05635500326752663, 0.001207655412144959, -0.0029299636371433735, 0.016688281670212746, -0.012652367353439331, -0.01680893637239933, -0.050253551453351974, 0.009784120135009289, 0.003300287527963519, -0.007867974229156971, -0.03132157027721405, 0.007545876316726208, -0.003989256918430328, -0.0031851676758378744, 0.04631773382425308, -0.019677216187119484, 0.04338742792606354, 0.10339906811714172, 0.009313974529504776, 0.002042449079453945, -0.006187102757394314, -0.05636012554168701, -0.01368620339781046, -0.0524333156645298, -0.010377734899520874, 0.028685079887509346, 0.0161648727953434, 0.02898762933909893, 0.037348248064517975, -0.0049566118977963924, 0.01863144151866436, 0.0015928245848044753, 0.05252440273761749, 0.06967169791460037, 0.02656722441315651, 0.03193136304616928, 0.01396562997251749, -0.039828523993492126, 0.019807113334536552, -0.0011160579742863774, -0.008377013728022575, -0.0050507509149611, -0.0609278567135334, 0.03865654394030571, 0.005418757908046246, 0.009256059303879738, -0.029347075149416924, -0.04369135946035385, 0.05194719880819321, -0.007675164379179478, 0.014748210087418556, -0.013711130246520042, 0.022157752886414528, 0.004630960989743471, -0.0002945796004496515, -0.017927175387740135, -0.010721219703555107, 0.025658462196588516, -0.04428306221961975, -0.006110028363764286, -0.03701403737068176, -0.01377097237855196, -0.0065255905501544476, -0.031209168955683708, 0.07975748926401138, -0.010462390258908272, -0.005989184603095055, -0.09205880016088486, -0.007529995404183865, 0.02661370299756527, -0.0026419535279273987, 0.000946665822993964, 0.003063560463488102, 0.017192894592881203, -0.014253204688429832, -0.03615299239754677, 0.006974040996283293, 0.01512689609080553, 0.032761432230472565, -0.02873833291232586, -0.03150000423192978, -0.011703256517648697, -0.01596466451883316, -0.004824760835617781, 0.038565706461668015, -0.11183497309684753, 0.04007527604699135, 0.025560587644577026, -0.008240739814937115, 0.049753714352846146, -0.0630267933011055, -0.0221550352871418, -0.005001187790185213, 0.08072056621313095, 0.0006163498037494719, -0.008478773757815361, -0.031135106459259987, -0.08896517008543015, 0.025058286264538765, -0.008804705925285816, -0.03240872547030449, 0.0034361511934548616, 0.015237122774124146 ]
<p>My question is mainly an engineering question. Assume I have a turbine in which I adiabatically expand compressed air. The air cools down and does work to its surroundings, which is captured by the blades of the turbine and then is transformed into rotational energy/electricity. </p> <p>When instead I let the compressed air flow through a nozzle into open space (no vacuum) and it expands adiabatically, it also cools down. But where is the internal energy of the air going? It does work to its surroundings, but where does this work end up? Does the surrounding heat up? Does it produce wind, i.e. kinetic energy in the surrounding air?</p> <p>Feel free to replace adiabatic with polytropic. Whenever the gas cools down, I ask: Where does the energy end up, when I do not capture it with a turbine?</p>
g6578
[ 0.061623621731996536, -0.010412434116005898, 0.004794434178620577, 0.011611656285822392, -0.017456531524658203, 0.02256583236157894, 0.04380417987704277, 0.0749259814620018, -0.06594952940940857, -0.03118615224957466, 0.005461734253913164, 0.019661976024508476, -0.00646259356290102, -0.03355398774147034, -0.0067309243604540825, -0.010884417220950127, 0.02070443332195282, -0.0102454898878932, 0.0649595782160759, -0.018877245485782623, -0.027082189917564392, -0.025945603847503662, 0.034371353685855865, -0.018064098432660103, -0.028272895142436028, -0.03777746483683586, 0.060531336814165115, 0.007552393712103367, -0.04690364748239517, -0.05365980789065361, 0.01964251510798931, 0.03745640814304352, 0.016380082815885544, -0.00269304309040308, 0.0034854609984904528, 0.007644281722605228, 0.08655400574207306, 0.010121005587279797, 0.007335303351283073, -0.0229914803057909, 0.0289164986461401, -0.01025356538593769, -0.041758447885513306, 0.0028881921898573637, -0.0006639094790443778, 0.04813988879323006, -0.0565338097512722, -0.03127510845661163, -0.030444899573922157, -0.018409838899970055, -0.0017911643953993917, 0.030559008941054344, -0.01512439176440239, -0.04497339576482773, 0.08183950185775757, 0.005057789850980043, -0.004551198799163103, -0.04800425469875336, 0.06175011768937111, 0.009725513868033886, 0.026439303532242775, 0.018340907990932465, 0.02648922987282276, 0.013266810216009617, 0.03062756359577179, -0.04209362715482712, -0.04236844554543495, -0.042600445449352264, -0.006884442642331123, -0.0523647703230381, -0.017464440315961838, -0.03443487361073494, 0.020623762160539627, -0.04180346056818962, 0.013964328914880753, -0.0035377084277570248, -0.012373902834951878, -0.05691228061914444, 0.01252166647464037, 0.013777771033346653, -0.02900833822786808, 0.026568682864308357, 0.045809246599674225, -0.06399929523468018, 0.09649206697940826, 0.015564663335680962, -0.0034890351817011833, 0.017733493819832802, -0.017913365736603737, 0.00045503859291784465, 0.05119337514042854, 0.020284151658415794, 0.06641972064971924, 0.00043877778807654977, -0.06373763829469681, 0.009858539327979088, -0.015495478175580502, 0.0636143609881401, -0.02033267542719841, -0.03320019692182541, -0.010955382138490677, -0.027746587991714478, -0.019481953233480453, -0.020559778437018394, 0.0308699831366539, -0.010833573527634144, 0.0008002262911759317, -0.039462070912122726, -0.02351466938853264, 0.03194951266050339, -0.0019741072319447994, -0.0337817445397377, -0.03826117888092995, -0.013885931111872196, -0.035054344683885574, -0.0191290695220232, 0.022911574691534042, -0.009870599955320358, 0.011566290631890297, 0.06932432949542999, 0.042708870023489, 0.09352006763219833, -0.019933650270104408, -0.052282534539699554, -0.0029114224016666412, 0.0307115837931633, -0.008748305030167103, -0.006065690889954567, -0.007412731181830168, 0.0008897251100279391, 0.019283916801214218, -0.02926507033407688, -0.018296506255865097, 0.04080692678689957, -0.01280851662158966, -0.0075319730676710606, -0.052207741886377335, -0.022197769954800606, 0.02160477824509144, 0.052915431559085846, -0.001024887664243579, -0.046215832233428955, 0.005343100521713495, 0.020528854802250862, 0.00426856055855751, -0.03391297161579132, -0.007202452979981899, -0.04762694984674454, 0.02753201685845852, 0.009065191261470318, 0.028370041400194168, 0.051168959587812424, 0.03394528850913048, -0.07754643261432648, 0.09087719768285751, 0.017581529915332794, 0.0438418909907341, -0.014243231154978275, 0.04051830619573593, 0.0024353312328457832, 0.037484101951122284, -0.04975549131631851, 0.09299786388874054, -0.0003990176192019135, -0.1041039526462555, -0.030496792867779732, -0.017022965475916862, -0.024963321164250374, 0.05338295176625252, -0.019884862005710602, -0.027596471831202507, -0.0452633872628212, -0.008375375531613827, -0.06154103949666023, 0.017760328948497772, 0.06918667256832123, 0.059388428926467896, 0.03664514049887657, 0.007681766990572214, -0.06926796585321426, -0.015377034433186054, 0.02468317374587059, 0.03896511346101761, -0.060447171330451965, 0.02468195930123329, 0.07208514213562012, -0.04480654373764992, 0.009008508175611496, -0.031527675688266754, -0.018752165138721466, 0.042694661766290665, -0.010515800677239895, -0.0039532482624053955, 0.022822674363851547, -0.0449100024998188, 0.0025984670501202345, -0.009124896489083767, -0.08843231201171875, -0.03795600309967995, -0.020660217851400375, 0.04475770518183708, -0.0006339658284559846, 0.04282941669225693, -0.011401503346860409, 0.06175002455711365, 0.006129124667495489, -0.0006767931045033038, 0.03712383657693863, 0.03181977942585945, -0.011944065801799297, 0.019160175696015358, -0.019306227564811707, -0.0059601906687021255, 0.020145343616604805, 0.01377046201378107, 0.006599002052098513, -0.03873562067747116, 0.0019142975797876716, -0.0025154869072139263, 0.0052889673970639706, 0.00842262338846922, 0.0007585504208691418, -0.0049287197180092335, 0.008010494522750378, -0.03521527349948883, -0.009002694860100746, -0.027054494246840477, -0.04304680973291397, -0.049553874880075455, 0.07939734309911728, -0.07294832915067673, 0.02350161410868168, -0.002691142028197646, -0.04953515902161598, 0.054771970957517624, 0.024548407644033432, -0.035595204681158066, 0.082123763859272, 0.030129898339509964, -0.04495370760560036, -0.0390535332262516, -0.02055629901587963, -0.03551905229687691, 0.03621405363082886, -0.0059510208666324615, 0.0404183603823185, 0.012175141833722591, -0.030020548030734062, 0.007778569590300322, -0.004110404755920172, 0.03435502201318741, 0.028523487970232964, 0.00525198457762599, 0.03318867087364197, -0.03799370676279068, -0.03833429515361786, -0.011698437854647636, 0.008608781732618809, -0.00852054450660944, -0.07851248234510422, -0.007766427472233772, 0.028250543400645256, -0.026340806856751442, 0.003316075075417757, -0.07346194982528687, 0.0717601552605629, 0.0037820509169250727, -0.03849433735013008, -0.0007177958614192903, -0.0006029534270055592, -0.011464809067547321, 0.05101713910698891, 0.03415921702980995, 0.010629972442984581, 0.011387807317078114, -0.056227345019578934, 0.021377524361014366, 0.04155903682112694, 0.0009862225269898772, -0.054797928780317307, 0.029620826244354248, -0.004435217007994652, -0.02030193619430065, 0.03216259926557541, 0.00021116543211974204, -0.05401916056871414, -0.046416040509939194, 0.017790447920560837, -0.02168472483754158, -0.049094151705503464, 0.002101314254105091, -0.026665285229682922, 0.028033550828695297, 0.014575961045920849, -0.002721106167882681, 0.013109209947288036, 0.029797730967402458, 0.003912588581442833, 0.020675521343946457, 0.060007244348526, -0.0371931791305542, -0.060437291860580444, -0.014531725086271763, 0.046161822974681854, 0.027282504364848137, 0.037805311381816864, -0.08079570531845093, -0.03213692083954811, -0.014183697290718555, 0.04904686659574509, -0.02130873128771782, -0.014272388070821762, 0.0023735954891890287, -0.002538080094382167, -0.07254377007484436, -0.042642224580049515, -0.028173059225082397, -0.06672494858503342, 0.025214774534106255, -0.005255452822893858, -0.0005251484108157456, -0.0009263076935894787, 0.029426569119095802, -0.004840816371142864, -0.02997254580259323, -0.002885912312194705, 0.02037387527525425, 0.017184102907776833, 0.037333399057388306, -0.09146004170179367, -0.07438597083091736, -0.013545859605073929, 0.007979330606758595, -0.04896704480051994, -0.033790457993745804, -0.05431516095995903, -0.03934961557388306, 0.013718552887439728, 0.03834338113665581, 0.023722464218735695, 0.0256902314722538, 0.005321042612195015, 0.010587798431515694, -0.020331019535660744, -0.027529750019311905, 0.008602412417531013, -0.02895236946642399, 0.010331066325306892, -0.01604718156158924, 0.016214804723858833, 0.029059862717986107, -0.000996702816337347, -0.03927187994122505, -0.0008066085283644497, -0.024491164833307266, -0.007947765290737152, 0.007269664201885462, 0.01945476420223713, -0.018229087814688683, 0.023623980581760406, 0.022935915738344193, -0.04365238919854164, -0.03765002638101578, -0.01604464277625084, -0.05481305345892906, 0.006226459518074989, -0.019395584240555763, -0.020755412057042122, -0.020546065643429756, 0.014150429517030716, 0.047119125723838806, -0.017835335806012154, -0.01723785512149334, 0.0373883992433548, 0.020749015733599663, -0.00767970085144043, 0.06943177431821823, 0.04724988713860512, -0.0016235532239079475, -0.00453165965154767, 0.02523169480264187, 0.013106225989758968, 0.004961308091878891, -0.011336457915604115, -0.0026624056044965982, 0.06331410259008408, -0.04447890445590019, 0.04944716393947601, -0.016889329999685287, 0.0017486168071627617, -0.0018385413568466902, -0.004305812995880842, -0.009079615585505962, -0.0017583172302693129, -0.03133952245116234, -0.006044727750122547, 0.012435614131391048, -0.025523411110043526, -0.035372018814086914, 0.031697239726781845, 0.026515046134591103, 0.048402998596429825, -0.027622083202004433, -0.020072927698493004, 0.01941123977303505, -0.009133235551416874, 0.06274145096540451, 0.003527237568050623, 0.02333349920809269, -0.03442025184631348, 0.019285431131720543, -0.021655874326825142, -0.021240022033452988, -0.06096572428941727, 0.05698959901928902, -0.07441934198141098, -0.012122705578804016, -0.05567023903131485, 0.018632248044013977, 0.024928301572799683, -0.004715499002486467, 0.0032178775873035192, -0.015147424302995205, 0.07524435222148895, -0.026905344799160957, 0.09241020679473877, 0.016855603083968163, -0.06121935695409775, -0.04697265848517418, 0.008356884121894836, -0.01655997708439827, -0.029387883841991425, 0.031045911833643913, -0.040493715554475784, -0.019317811354994774, 0.003944756463170052, -0.02829737775027752, 0.030892329290509224, 0.024833418428897858, 0.07351791113615036, 0.05542437732219696, -0.003149476135149598, -0.023947065696120262, -0.042050715535879135, 0.009590637870132923, 0.07785166054964066, -0.00339504424482584, 0.01963069848716259, 0.01858297921717167, -0.03556743636727333, -0.10058072209358215, 0.016512632369995117, -0.021529333665966988, -0.015908975154161453, 0.012722598388791084, 0.030098704621195793, -0.055751919746398926, -0.012700967490673065, -0.001959883840754628, -0.02988000027835369, -0.023494716733694077, -0.022431930527091026, -0.04377507045865059, 0.010203163139522076, -0.01696978323161602, -0.031354717910289764, -0.013060892932116985, 0.02158297225832939, -0.013252097181975842, -0.032185543328523636, 0.040739238262176514, 0.05813039094209671, -0.038311585783958435, 0.06285865604877472, 0.025558726862072945, 0.05995184928178787, 0.05080212280154228, -0.05682158097624779, 0.06306636333465576, 0.005108429118990898, 0.04132000356912613, 0.026728136464953423, 0.02398662269115448, 0.05298834294080734, 0.027197854593396187, 0.02225862443447113, -0.046640794724226, 0.0062825605273246765, 0.0448065809905529, 0.0073064467869699, 0.01552899181842804, 0.07031179964542389, 0.00290070497430861, -0.024774041026830673, -0.04179194197058678, 0.036620501428842545, -0.02015877701342106, -0.0621672198176384, -0.038946352899074554, -0.024641379714012146, -0.006973712705075741, 0.009272444061934948, -0.010588761419057846, 0.050603531301021576, 0.011231598444283009, 0.05795593187212944, 0.051097121089696884, -0.007894513197243214, -0.014796852134168148, 0.03208315744996071, 0.0021149511449038982, 0.02631375938653946, -0.08006516844034195, 0.03861305117607117, 0.048944950103759766, -0.018312763422727585, -0.002865443006157875, -0.009116999804973602, -0.039050932973623276, -0.04620780423283577, 0.009430448524653912, 0.021466614678502083, 0.013900676742196083, -0.010860253125429153, 0.03638673946261406, 0.06302720308303833, -0.03763625770807266, 0.0011885914718732238, 0.022872474044561386, 0.05805147439241409, -0.014397300779819489, 0.02320065163075924, 0.03348832577466965, -0.007254436612129211, 0.0018102674512192607, 0.03369094058871269, -0.04336404427886009, 0.00004101670492673293, 0.0694664716720581, 0.005703895818442106, 0.025325370952486992, -0.01817086525261402, -0.04324699565768242, -0.037199705839157104, 0.008976278826594353, 0.02103857882320881, -0.024039139971137047, 0.01896224543452263, 0.06259587407112122, -0.024335147812962532, 0.00165007752366364, -0.008840956725180149, 0.035713329911231995, -0.022159863263368607, 0.009002314880490303, -0.04225857928395271, 0.03805537894368172, 0.009829061105847359, -0.015446278266608715, -0.051574643701314926, 0.028061673045158386, 0.021650003269314766, 0.025460410863161087, 0.004606453701853752, 0.049742624163627625, -0.021750161424279213, 0.016040291637182236, -0.003633447689935565, 0.04030429199337959, 0.012541820295155048, 0.052241384983062744, -0.019235720857977867, 0.04024500399827957, -0.024563567712903023, 0.044803738594055176, 0.02494139038026333, -0.030900437384843826, -0.016104716807603836, -0.013699733652174473, -0.011728369630873203, 0.025902245193719864, 0.0016821569297462702, 0.07840292155742645, -0.009402369149029255, 0.05585789307951927, 0.03228876367211342, -0.015845179557800293, -0.00009007899643620476, 0.0203426294028759, 0.032530222088098526, 0.00023980916012078524, -0.04345325753092766, -0.012916356325149536, 0.020347246900200844, -0.04468525946140289, -0.012083305045962334, 0.007951066829264164, -0.015667514875531197, 0.029166873544454575, -0.007281908765435219, -0.0009884422179311514, 0.04742284119129181, 0.09725520014762878, -0.08414620161056519, 0.026820166036486626, 0.0027105165645480156, 0.015471279621124268, 0.032422635704278946, -0.011517036706209183, 0.006747863255441189, -0.06709864735603333, 0.013241380453109741, 0.08209264278411865, -0.05705152824521065, 0.01621122844517231, 0.03399164229631424, 0.017712855711579323, -0.014814099296927452, 0.02765948884189129, -0.029106872156262398, 0.022603396326303482, -0.03456268087029457, 0.041722141206264496, -0.06017359346151352, 0.04657687991857529, -0.0094713494181633, -0.06345528364181519, 0.03760775551199913, 0.03718877583742142, 0.01944436877965927, 0.007096685003489256, 0.07951223850250244, -0.05053330212831497, 0.0555572509765625, -0.004782584495842457, 0.00570676289498806, 0.03306936100125313, 0.037424035370349884, 0.12643325328826904, 0.025382300838828087, -0.047994814813137054, 0.07170765846967697, -0.04077250137925148, 0.031055361032485962, -0.04899534210562706, -0.015477231703698635, 0.017880888655781746, -0.03578261658549309, -0.02789725735783577, -0.0568537637591362, -0.06535666435956955, -0.07468870282173157, -0.025820646435022354, -0.02385745942592621, -0.031850337982177734, 0.045197129249572754, -0.026874518021941185, -0.04908398911356926, 0.012202574871480465, -0.05617673322558403, 0.021119818091392517, -0.038110073655843735, -0.01786116324365139, 0.06352998316287994, 0.00008523005089955404, 0.06343652307987213, 0.03669746220111847, 0.03266722708940506, 0.0024842810817062855, -0.05827626585960388, -0.024882325902581215, -0.03874925896525383, -0.09845282882452011, 0.012700066901743412, -0.04815790429711342, -0.019051259383559227, 0.018820617347955704, 0.05451745167374611, 0.009487008675932884, -0.06332070380449295, 0.01233984250575304, -0.024531038478016853, -0.015482209622859955, -0.02299511805176735, -0.007555734366178513, 0.04497746750712395, -0.038744814693927765, 0.0018448042683303356, 0.0008875495987012982, -0.041664596647024155, -0.043525584042072296, 0.041803181171417236, 0.059202294796705246, -0.05479775369167328, -0.04778023809194565, -0.000028234609999344684, 0.0674644187092781, -0.0028831560630351305, -0.05210726335644722, -0.01001149695366621, 0.025845075026154518, 0.006429537199437618, 0.0366542674601078, 0.0031580361537635326, 0.015549368225038052, 0.024107690900564194, 0.021294642239809036, -0.021904276683926582, -0.020219553261995316, 0.022670526057481766, -0.006349681410938501, -0.020640287548303604, 0.012554855085909367, -0.01671730913221836, 0.02929452806711197, -0.04108230024576187, -0.0353938527405262, -0.005694572348147631, 0.005081715993583202, -0.00035952465259470046, -0.007237532641738653, 0.013852463103830814, -0.05627519264817238, -0.02009008452296257, -0.008400814607739449, -0.006841882597655058, -0.009182993322610855, 0.023896871134638786, -0.008947350084781647, -0.05631539970636368, -0.04890647530555725, 0.04455868527293205, 0.03543831780552864, 0.01040992047637701, -0.003838442964479327, -0.03527214750647545, 0.08242682367563248, -0.03264651447534561, 0.01841486245393753, -0.013135822489857674, -0.005162617191672325, -0.010514858178794384, 0.04557517543435097, -0.019024141132831573, -0.03943385183811188, -0.046581897884607315, 0.01637694612145424, 0.033544961363077164, 0.06873361021280289, -0.0488564558327198, 0.033388569951057434, -0.021969804540276527, 0.0033493584487587214, -0.019862517714500427, 0.04571396857500076, -0.01893359050154686, -0.000436562520917505, 0.03549524024128914, 0.016526462510228157, 0.013262614607810974, -0.021533189341425896, -0.019266122952103615, -0.07820186018943787, -0.02234053611755371, -0.019480695948004723, -0.04377078637480736, 0.0026855976320803165, 0.03775258734822273 ]
<p>We know about some events that happen very quickly. For example, the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dielectric" rel="nofollow">dielectric</a> relaxation time is about $10^{-14}\, \mathrm{seconds}$. </p> <p>I'm interested in other processes that switch extremely fast or or could be use as a very short tick in a clock.</p>
g446
[ 0.08531714975833893, 0.11450067162513733, -0.01223441120237112, 0.02276592329144478, 0.030333567410707474, -0.0856628492474556, 0.04256599396467209, -0.0014258509036153555, 0.011310376226902008, -0.010883700102567673, -0.03831776976585388, 0.04154496267437935, 0.012255126610398293, -0.02639545127749443, -0.010765668004751205, -0.03853035718202591, 0.08984121680259705, 0.04736895486712456, 0.01222744956612587, 0.050907202064991, 0.04222724586725235, 0.004503138363361359, -0.009277822449803352, -0.0358438715338707, -0.011664189398288727, 0.04412750154733658, 0.008913656696677208, -0.019586531445384026, -0.018440209329128265, -0.021479949355125427, -0.0577966570854187, -0.07821834087371826, 0.014793520793318748, 0.023034369572997093, 0.0003536113945301622, -0.04630029574036598, 0.023059871047735214, 0.001755294855684042, 0.017093362286686897, 0.04761206731200218, -0.019369572401046753, -0.01991846226155758, 0.05854921042919159, -0.045577485114336014, 0.03083389438688755, 0.019125232473015785, 0.0002716532035265118, 0.047879960387945175, -0.020844893530011177, -0.0972490906715393, 0.0165880024433136, -0.012978387996554375, 0.01759333722293377, 0.048387058079242706, -0.01676914282143116, -0.016869455575942993, 0.012621378526091576, 0.03566285967826843, 0.047750119119882584, -0.0037650037556886673, -0.028336942195892334, -0.02128918282687664, 0.03061506524682045, -0.022917214781045914, 0.029426973313093185, 0.056260716170072556, 0.005294932052493095, -0.033142250031232834, 0.07718367874622345, 0.043436966836452484, -0.018645919859409332, 0.01674220710992813, -0.09394068270921707, -0.04502641037106514, 0.016896026208996773, 0.015788156539201736, 0.0037529405672103167, -0.07620880752801895, 0.013674120418727398, 0.017626117914915085, -0.10637305676937103, -0.03190544992685318, -0.014790824614465237, -0.00022448629897553474, -0.020871836692094803, 0.0202696081250906, 0.015493441373109818, 0.020349718630313873, 0.023521745577454567, -0.018777115270495415, 0.025087354704737663, -0.034441493451595306, -0.0053357696160674095, -0.01902124658226967, -0.08417557179927826, 0.06355457752943039, 0.025025377050042152, 0.06346531957387924, 0.03728659451007843, -0.0051352097652852535, -0.03008500300347805, -0.014724752865731716, -0.03362765908241272, -0.030148055404424667, -0.010302646085619926, -0.041729044169187546, -0.017806226387619972, -0.02538369596004486, -0.01795101724565029, 0.013942747376859188, 0.009318932890892029, -0.03370894864201546, -0.02365785650908947, 0.041268590837717056, 0.01971859112381935, 0.02510673925280571, -0.06612648069858551, -0.013046725653111935, -0.03039190173149109, 0.001339695299975574, 0.04326274245977402, -0.014045637100934982, -0.008762108162045479, 0.0026963178534060717, 0.005084407981485128, 0.010447611100971699, 0.011099312454462051, 0.026468615978956223, -0.015476525761187077, 0.012395470403134823, 0.010637607425451279, 0.012400698848068714, -0.02735385298728943, 0.018055779859423637, -0.05732666328549385, 0.011984465643763542, 0.05965184047818184, -0.027203034609556198, 0.004682060331106186, -0.009684722870588303, 0.035263970494270325, -0.039621323347091675, 0.0022674829233437777, 0.012525662779808044, -0.04230593889951706, 0.029778247699141502, -0.014314291067421436, 0.06469611078500748, 0.004563762340694666, 0.024097196757793427, -0.014619091525673866, -0.017054585739970207, 0.04473661258816719, -0.007645230740308762, 0.018310459330677986, 0.019456731155514717, 0.02676706202328205, -0.004677358083426952, -0.004359246231615543, 0.04989789426326752, 0.04423701763153076, -0.022676590830087662, -0.050534892827272415, 0.036383647471666336, -0.012724039144814014, -0.021113449707627296, 0.04017610102891922, 0.044472597539424896, 0.009695095010101795, -0.010790206491947174, -0.047698214650154114, -0.03550664708018303, -0.010561060160398483, 0.04760206863284111, -0.006673354189842939, -0.017298543825745583, 0.03925999253988266, -0.036589786410331726, -0.0515623465180397, -0.05162402614951134, -0.011169960722327232, -0.058746904134750366, -0.039112918078899384, -0.043721769005060196, 0.05185360088944435, 0.027298131957650185, 0.03810109198093414, 0.0051887063309550285, -0.0819086953997612, 0.028658898547291756, -0.05647192522883415, -0.05271218344569206, 0.009679696522653103, 0.06971586495637894, -0.045358385890722275, -0.03567182272672653, 0.01355158630758524, -0.012673440389335155, -0.025047248229384422, -0.01653359830379486, -0.013956387527287006, 0.008043861947953701, 0.025317111983895302, 0.0502525195479393, 0.05537185072898865, 0.018060391768813133, 0.0020526284351944923, -0.029948022216558456, -0.018470872193574905, -0.018007148057222366, 0.0995471253991127, 0.062183741480112076, -0.013661164790391922, -0.018335672095417976, -0.01486970204859972, 0.00011056770745199174, -0.026563135907053947, -0.035067152231931686, 0.06761600077152252, 0.023336561396718025, 0.03936083987355232, -0.005092599429190159, 0.057838618755340576, -0.024452121928334236, 0.04758709296584129, -0.03453952446579933, 0.017980651929974556, 0.015332183800637722, 0.04484574869275093, 0.03544393181800842, -0.059713754802942276, 0.07918217778205872, -0.05443930998444557, -0.011700214818120003, -0.04282725602388382, 0.024291282519698143, 0.025939946994185448, -0.0038444786332547665, 0.05259772390127182, 0.032318051904439926, 0.014909323304891586, 0.004003805108368397, -0.009758836589753628, 0.0442030131816864, -0.1061808317899704, -0.09725172072649002, 0.03651959076523781, -0.014822723343968391, 0.031622715294361115, 0.009102987125515938, 0.004083867184817791, -0.062287233769893646, -0.022965876385569572, -0.01719062402844429, -0.007448424119502306, -0.03567184880375862, 0.020645514130592346, 0.06576014310121536, -0.03020966798067093, -0.0012093795230612159, -0.018473103642463684, 0.04364164546132088, 0.042916785925626755, -0.016735753044486046, 0.059811487793922424, -0.053549349308013916, 0.013486579060554504, 0.0030879578553140163, -0.07140132039785385, 0.009171445854008198, -0.04554268345236778, -0.02499288320541382, -0.04127030447125435, 0.020532675087451935, -0.02458605170249939, -0.030546020716428757, 0.05456358566880226, -0.031391825526952744, 0.022090774029493332, 0.007852278649806976, 0.0022167041897773743, -0.06491045653820038, -0.021594176068902016, -0.01023748517036438, -0.012541541829705238, -0.03527623042464256, 0.010524359531700611, 0.07655834406614304, -0.055173151195049286, 0.028715098276734352, -0.04851473867893219, 0.0227933619171381, 0.03600768744945526, 0.005266750697046518, -0.022228403016924858, 0.03445101156830788, 0.014252612367272377, -0.05499676614999771, -0.0010572790633887053, 0.028138555586338043, 0.05259772390127182, -0.039823371917009354, -0.017640024423599243, 0.03609409183263779, 0.017384136095643044, -0.01444191299378872, -0.024829501286149025, 0.0004950236179865897, 0.0510588176548481, 0.0019713793881237507, 0.06421273946762085, 0.05650806799530983, -0.02187248319387436, -0.0126735744997859, -0.10113579779863358, -0.05308052524924278, 0.010036657564342022, 0.05833790823817253, 0.042426954954862595, -0.07359541952610016, 0.030430397018790245, -0.039051227271556854, 0.018250735476613045, -0.052050210535526276, 0.03311493620276451, 0.027054313570261, 0.00887592975050211, -0.030605599284172058, -0.07365044951438904, 0.023593850433826447, -0.028453320264816284, 0.004380454774945974, -0.057939562946558, -0.008388551883399487, -0.07837652415037155, -0.03602044656872749, 0.004889106377959251, 0.04504648968577385, 0.025146545842289925, -0.0012848960468545556, -0.03161842003464699, 0.009761413559317589, -0.06317918747663498, 0.018629206344485283, 0.0417557992041111, -0.009137449786067009, 0.04602901637554169, -0.0449245423078537, 0.028622668236494064, -0.022931387647986412, 0.010860886424779892, -0.012996232137084007, 0.0006718204822391272, -0.057333361357450485, 0.006063619628548622, 0.006114196497946978, 0.013079129159450531, 0.027288461104035378, 0.02654164656996727, -0.037372130900621414, -0.008629762567579746, 0.006266619544476271, -0.007133049424737692, 0.006564771756529808, -0.035312455147504807, 0.014136639423668385, -0.03391815721988678, 0.06536012142896652, 0.023744111880660057, -0.033518239855766296, 0.004368824418634176, 0.05029630661010742, 0.01873105764389038, -0.0030131489038467407, 0.037286028265953064, 0.029287060722708702, 0.0003748646704480052, 0.04444904252886772, -0.005914631765335798, 0.011289644986391068, -0.0691886693239212, -0.003890435677021742, 0.05094846338033676, -0.04524426534771919, -0.0066618421114981174, -0.025276441127061844, -0.038123082369565964, -0.05747741088271141, -0.05204825475811958, -0.060120511800050735, 0.028410617262125015, 0.02211242914199829, 0.004116309806704521, -0.01817028596997261, -0.05126805603504181, -0.06038030609488487, 0.05645499750971794, -0.04046859219670296, 0.045823678374290466, -0.01211391668766737, -0.03392823040485382, -0.05148295685648918, -0.027378803119063377, 0.014294996857643127, 0.030089106410741806, 0.07288791984319687, -0.03654789552092552, -0.025793569162487984, -0.014211238361895084, -0.013202146627008915, -0.0288158617913723, -0.024087030440568924, -0.029988979920744896, 0.01965123414993286, 0.03132723644375801, 0.00020558277901727706, 0.011837726458907127, -0.00863326620310545, 0.006162825506180525, -0.010863453149795532, 0.004826245363801718, 0.056008946150541306, -0.017302362248301506, 0.016672467812895775, 0.028114458546042442, -0.02370651438832283, 0.00936331506818533, 0.02373742125928402, 0.017087846994400024, -0.014178927056491375, 0.03150596097111702, 0.004677711986005306, -0.01782594993710518, -0.019320335239171982, 0.020392322912812233, 0.013958669267594814, 0.02700851857662201, 0.026941834017634392, -0.013693428598344326, 0.05732415243983269, 0.043892115354537964, 0.009591205976903439, 0.0009711651946417987, 0.03814958408474922, -0.002568187890574336, 0.0697198361158371, -0.009516437537968159, -0.057174202054739, -0.03087964653968811, -0.06413447111845016, -0.014773400500416756, 0.07461004704236984, -0.05052197352051735, -0.02168937399983406, 0.06615940481424332, -0.03827968239784241, -0.007954219356179237, 0.0844862163066864, 0.00463843671604991, 0.03804289922118187, -0.04977121576666832, -0.009029681794345379, 0.03538992628455162, 0.0065717133693397045, -0.02975638210773468, 0.023623842746019363, -0.011348334141075611, -0.020019682124257088, -0.030526814982295036, -0.016521355137228966, -0.04400939121842384, 0.003464161418378353, 0.014598031528294086, 0.05737990885972977, 0.00007987180288182572, 0.01554278563708067, 0.008443883620202541, 0.020812679082155228, 0.004453857429325581, -0.016788823530077934, -0.008036864921450615, 0.003468351671472192, 0.006802343763411045, 0.055170003324747086, -0.010422047227621078, -0.006041122134774923, -0.06186359003186226, -0.00713277468457818, 0.028226371854543686, -0.06418769806623459, 0.021709993481636047, 0.05425911024212837, 0.04541122913360596, 0.024455539882183075, 0.028220953419804573, -0.033567409962415695, 0.03891303762793541, 0.00995061919093132, -0.05314178764820099, -0.018651988357305527, -0.04464280977845192, -0.036500561982393265, -0.05682489648461342, -0.032621972262859344, -0.02395722083747387, 0.026305411010980606, -0.03088042326271534, -0.004678364377468824, -0.0060307420790195465, 0.05164346471428871, -0.06764821708202362, 0.02327709086239338, -0.005793333053588867, -0.015184889547526836, -0.010751527734100819, -0.014670838601887226, 0.0010931615252047777, -0.04526204988360405, -0.013137424364686012, -0.03275910019874573, 0.04109515994787216, -0.048593468964099884, 0.03906726837158203, 0.030618268996477127, -0.004889687988907099, -0.008433288894593716, -0.017296791076660156, 0.020212050527334213, -0.011568740010261536, 0.014431378804147243, 0.04453390836715698, -0.07622021436691284, -0.038197197020053864, 0.010686831548810005, -0.014841063879430294, 0.04603715240955353, 0.043088413774967194, 0.021606944501399994, -0.03698762133717537, 0.011195655912160873, -0.04248516261577606, 0.027445709332823753, -0.001886896905489266, 0.029527688398957253, -0.04075887054204941, -0.047854192554950714, 0.04753607511520386, 0.02844763547182083, 0.011191110126674175, 0.012721633538603783, 0.003446308895945549, -0.012226561084389687, 0.09820115566253662, -0.027395449578762054, 0.013038372620940208, 0.027482187375426292, 0.031190726906061172, 0.019844409078359604, 0.0036791865713894367, -0.013385873287916183, 0.03908613696694374, 0.04858611524105072, 0.045657072216272354, -0.046427611261606216, 0.0018012885702773929, -0.08156874030828476, -0.02041066810488701, 0.01649278774857521, 0.04852902516722679, 0.009556757286190987, 0.053076643496751785, -0.021912207826972008, -0.045457687228918076, -0.020650478079915047, -0.005070019979029894, -0.014589780941605568, 0.02765362150967121, -0.0011186763877049088, -0.027833038941025734, -0.0057098958641290665, -0.09483447670936584, 0.007762421388179064, 0.015667840838432312, 0.0204391498118639, -0.013781684450805187, 0.0045722550712525845, 0.005752136930823326, 0.03644672781229019, 0.007585691288113594, 0.008997784927487373, 0.006527959369122982, -0.025004863739013672, -0.03501095622777939, -0.05759362876415253, 0.04246202111244202, -0.05216048285365105, -0.05744481459259987, -0.025983477011322975, -0.006302226800471544, 0.02857566624879837, -0.033398717641830444, 0.014277481473982334, 0.015355060808360577, -0.007515694014728069, -0.03304494917392731, 0.04806109145283699, -0.03784450516104698, 0.03847724571824074, 0.026669787243008614, 0.03566841408610344, 0.032392747700214386, -0.01763482205569744, -0.014325650408864021, -0.0242022555321455, -0.09520366042852402, -0.04265958443284035, 0.03484393283724785, -0.01782369613647461, 0.02351124957203865, -0.011694026179611683, 0.03156809136271477, -0.014856262132525444, 0.04739024490118027, 0.017957115545868874, -0.05815804377198219, 0.01669500768184662, -0.02692844159901142, 0.0010372960241511464, 0.00826603639870882, -0.03524315729737282, 0.06513199210166931, -0.012973612174391747, -0.05322369560599327, 0.04962769150733948, 0.020461969077587128, -0.0029310043901205063, -0.06164860352873802, -0.00628711236640811, 0.010315482504665852, -0.0036417909432202578, 0.03476228937506676, 0.038137808442115784, -0.003291175002232194, 0.051557984203100204, 0.06114324554800987, 0.03099464252591133, 0.018729589879512787, 0.02966918610036373, 0.03102293238043785, 0.004355794750154018, -0.0066996426321566105, 0.010388446040451527, -0.05731569230556488, 0.01803695783019066, 0.002319538267329335, -0.029820268973708153, 0.017870934680104256, 0.012101373635232449, 0.016572609543800354, -0.017620468512177467, 0.03153970465064049, 0.02008572593331337, -0.024314405396580696, -0.020892944186925888, 0.05275391414761543, 0.04481392726302147, -0.023781850934028625, -0.061986979097127914, 0.015505781397223473, -0.02848917990922928, 0.017673742026090622, 0.02025686390697956, -0.010108957067131996, -0.03018888644874096, -0.0018842470599338412, 0.03706720098853111, 0.008135582320392132, -0.004136796575039625, 0.03333442658185959, -0.009185482747852802, -0.02254917100071907, 0.004685916472226381, -0.021923797205090523, -0.029268821701407433, -0.011681273579597473, 0.08878051489591599, -0.03248351067304611, 0.0539642870426178, 0.02721530944108963, 0.027848517522215843, -0.002064825501292944, 0.06338030844926834, -0.0015184372896328568, 0.0000245088212977862, 0.03819460794329643, -0.02139320783317089, -0.03225696086883545, -0.0613752119243145, 0.031184924766421318, -0.009044822305440903, -0.0021521649323403835, 0.01596393622457981, 0.009765098802745342, 0.02782313898205757, 0.006811357103288174, 0.02199053391814232, -0.028417205438017845, -0.10883498936891556, 0.00977280456572771, 0.02777389995753765, 0.035615161061286926, 0.08320752531290054, -0.01267116330564022, -0.05147752910852432, 0.048496078699827194, -0.017976999282836914, -0.02667645737528801, -0.0667266994714737, 0.03001600131392479, 0.04764473810791969, -0.006267293822020292, -0.02977943606674671, -0.03737910836935043, -0.0017482878174632788, 0.029209323227405548, 0.002934244927018881, -0.007349549327045679, -0.03170383721590042, 0.03418511524796486, -0.007654885295778513, 0.004247074946761131, -0.03432595729827881, 0.038593992590904236, 0.02109498716890812, -0.053473737090826035, -0.013262786902487278, -0.0027114313561469316, 0.055319011211395264, -0.04885030910372734, 0.02746504172682762, 0.027260305359959602, -0.05450353026390076, -0.05601036548614502, -0.001075198408216238, 0.01403652224689722, -0.034170962870121, 0.018971681594848633, 0.016130821779370308, 0.0024856855161488056, -0.02130265347659588, -0.044839855283498764, 0.0174087006598711, -0.09248214215040207, 0.019147630780935287, -0.010152310132980347, 0.07288636267185211, 0.05699336528778076, 0.006413599941879511, 0.018001623451709747, -0.05404350534081459, -0.03199239820241928, 0.0008909534080885351, -0.007917935028672218, 0.014234335161745548, -0.006553058046847582, -0.007701497990638018, 0.035014793276786804, 0.024450793862342834 ]
<p>Immediately prior to becoming a supernova the core of some types of stars may suffer gravitational collapse. </p> <ul> <li><p>What happens to any planets in orbit around the star at the instant the mass is fully collapsed? </p></li> <li><p>Assuming this sudden change would cause some perturbation ; how large/distant would a planet in the system have to be to be relatively immune to such perturbation?</p></li> <li><p>Could unexplained perturbation serve as an indicator of a historic supernova in the vicinity?</p></li> </ul>
g6579
[ -0.005586423445492983, 0.02392144314944744, -0.002572149969637394, -0.062489643692970276, -0.020998874679207802, 0.06475048512220383, -0.044010698795318604, 0.03420893847942352, 0.02239595539867878, -0.03535595163702965, -0.02618591859936714, 0.06529921293258667, 0.03914172202348709, 0.014199009165167809, 0.054807886481285095, -0.011270553804934025, 0.04922419786453247, -0.0076565914787352085, 0.04555821791291237, -0.0008554566302336752, -0.06340406835079193, 0.014809953980147839, -0.022867148742079735, 0.03910839185118675, -0.06480348855257034, 0.014310097321867943, 0.05528847500681877, -0.020691579207777977, 0.013072989881038666, 0.008134129457175732, 0.008095284923911095, -0.005798127967864275, 0.024949420243501663, -0.09617521613836288, -0.005010969936847687, -0.002657234435901046, 0.028840357437729836, -0.018487459048628807, 0.026957742869853973, -0.033537380397319794, -0.01140940748155117, -0.030901754274964333, 0.04212716594338417, -0.02522788941860199, 0.009092788212001324, 0.01017378456890583, -0.008770765736699104, -0.03454887494444847, -0.0002788531419355422, 0.016787448897957802, -0.03417378291487694, 0.008961054496467113, 0.015415675938129425, -0.025982176885008812, -0.04426874965429306, 0.04078185185790062, 0.04872584342956543, -0.024541279301047325, 0.015626737847924232, 0.0004990178858861327, -0.014993730932474136, -0.0376252606511116, 0.02468132972717285, -0.07661996781826019, 0.01350801158696413, -0.04978100582957268, -0.03365541994571686, 0.06707163155078888, 0.033248286694288254, -0.01668827049434185, -0.024467524141073227, 0.025431623682379723, -0.05887865275144577, -0.0518459789454937, -0.05166803300380707, 0.06602192670106888, -0.04937615245580673, 0.020993059501051903, -0.0518011674284935, 0.07580756396055222, -0.011375287547707558, -0.012374188750982285, 0.023862887173891068, 0.03311456739902496, 0.04085099697113037, -0.0244117621332407, -0.042798060923814774, 0.023473192006349564, -0.010857421904802322, 0.04011405631899834, 0.03562740236520767, 0.0032369785476475954, -0.002340930514037609, -0.060802362859249115, 0.017215309664607048, -0.0006634413148276508, -0.018729886040091515, 0.004873010795563459, -0.02291710302233696, -0.013643303886055946, 0.012010060250759125, -0.0005057426169514656, -0.035840947180986404, -0.04722623899579048, 0.017882058396935463, -0.003790547838434577, 0.06675659120082855, 0.02083919569849968, 0.05229936167597771, -0.040057674050331116, 0.013068096712231636, -0.014111682772636414, 0.05635342001914978, -0.021569373086094856, -0.0436827577650547, -0.03782579302787781, 0.0873049646615982, -0.023300593718886375, 0.04324658587574959, 0.08145508170127869, -0.03146618232131004, 0.010941630229353905, -0.03820732980966568, 0.0027761326637119055, -0.04903465509414673, -0.019894011318683624, -0.00886070542037487, 0.044596925377845764, 0.06568650901317596, 0.034555286169052124, -0.010765576735138893, 0.00945889949798584, -0.07992509752511978, 0.0029010141734033823, 0.053188830614089966, 0.045207541435956955, -0.026320768520236015, 0.01706179603934288, -0.05231478810310364, -0.030884113162755966, 0.049419376999139786, 0.007489361334592104, 0.05052296072244644, 0.031782038509845734, -0.022137336432933807, -0.004515503998845816, 0.019368896260857582, 0.037265971302986145, -0.00889609381556511, 0.005146272014826536, -0.043871212750673294, -0.016847994178533554, 0.04199784994125366, -0.08586513996124268, 0.0031637728679925203, 0.018147213384509087, -0.042497094720602036, -0.005707982461899519, -0.030890870839357376, -0.025688381865620613, -0.007331362925469875, -0.023783141747117043, 0.04019975662231445, -0.0010999083751812577, -0.05608357861638069, 0.04434635862708092, -0.01613769307732582, -0.018633294850587845, 0.025814561173319817, 0.05269557982683182, -0.008129783906042576, -0.016511771827936172, 0.0042179846204817295, 0.06541488319635391, 0.0156811885535717, -0.015955770388245583, 0.043573688715696335, -0.06460150331258774, 0.05909840762615204, 0.01335031259804964, 0.06583527475595474, -0.017429564148187637, -0.020569398999214172, -0.02230479009449482, 0.01623440720140934, -0.05588868632912636, -0.017878280952572823, 0.024486789479851723, -0.016329549252986908, 0.011259111575782299, -0.04773489385843277, -0.03515486791729927, 0.051077138632535934, 0.015485509298741817, -0.009415335021913052, -0.020788149908185005, 0.0073258844204247, 0.0080774687230587, -0.0343877449631691, 0.03051071986556053, -0.025008494034409523, 0.00024126139760483056, -0.006238862406462431, 0.0022243966814130545, -0.042146988213062286, 0.014699084684252739, -0.04465911537408829, 0.07700672000646591, 0.006107192952185869, -0.028170714154839516, -0.002610619179904461, -0.020269643515348434, 0.02352229505777359, -0.04781219735741615, -0.0658346638083458, 0.057037174701690674, -0.04288458079099655, 0.05811592936515808, 0.007206331472843885, 0.053150009363889694, 0.013936040922999382, 0.018607616424560547, 0.02462943084537983, -0.035609468817710876, 0.01333602610975504, -0.017754297703504562, 0.006903411820530891, 0.010164856910705566, 0.05379926785826683, 0.003243481507524848, -0.04509600251913071, -0.03307414427399635, 0.020193930715322495, 0.020383726805448532, -0.01355964969843626, -0.0067687202244997025, 0.023374972864985466, -0.06227043271064758, -0.0030524032190442085, -0.015591811388731003, 0.01736345887184143, -0.005083179101347923, -0.011375194415450096, -0.01458190567791462, 0.04713161662220955, -0.04973798617720604, 0.010033316910266876, -0.01682543009519577, -0.04048168659210205, -0.025906801223754883, 0.003943447954952717, 0.020891573280096054, -0.041843440383672714, -0.011244041845202446, -0.00979316234588623, -0.02265302650630474, 0.008209689520299435, 0.05308333784341812, -0.0585901215672493, -0.00008237109432229772, 0.05961417034268379, 0.0025879405438899994, 0.03423378989100456, -0.0017123532015830278, 0.03250138461589813, 0.022743619978427887, 0.029816193506121635, -0.021679818630218506, -0.005560975521802902, 0.0023195601534098387, -0.002833685837686062, -0.007126105483621359, 0.0057717603631317616, 0.05916045606136322, -0.0054339137859642506, 0.03438960388302803, -0.05597047135233879, 0.0001227568427566439, -0.023227965459227562, -0.04335398226976395, 0.006368870381265879, 0.005735617130994797, -0.06962136179208755, 0.0057584443129599094, 0.006396409124135971, -0.056339070200920105, 0.034580111503601074, 0.0371856726706028, 0.053478457033634186, -0.03673795238137245, 0.03373505547642708, 0.011601405218243599, 0.0020848007407039404, 0.07748132199048996, -0.03385721892118454, 0.027211174368858337, 0.017305750399827957, 0.07880078256130219, 0.012455574236810207, 0.02398686856031418, 0.07530488818883896, -0.0612216480076313, 0.00013401880278252065, 0.02087230421602726, 0.01528436504304409, 0.020399654284119606, -0.05607662349939346, 0.019166823476552963, -0.01773025654256344, -0.020679766312241554, -0.041666384786367416, 0.021153831854462624, 0.015590311028063297, 0.031900182366371155, -0.043217387050390244, 0.03297388181090355, 0.01685311645269394, -0.028514716774225235, -0.0006557847955264151, 0.016825992614030838, -0.02769431285560131, -0.022391097620129585, -0.020003408193588257, -0.020062513649463654, -0.0001311901432927698, -0.026053672656416893, 0.011605207808315754, 0.035420943051576614, -0.02301119454205036, -0.014474268071353436, -0.024035420268774033, -0.04804569482803345, 0.00019229169993195683, -0.013422740623354912, -0.033198099583387375, 0.05704909563064575, -0.022246740758419037, 0.03353824093937874, 0.032405052334070206, 0.0843908041715622, 0.021718012169003487, 0.011479372158646584, -0.001997201004996896, -0.010901045985519886, 0.018270162865519524, 0.027445577085018158, 0.006483693607151508, -0.06821632385253906, 0.02113283984363079, -0.0844784751534462, 0.0440627746284008, -0.04299374297261238, 0.053526561707258224, -0.012799456715583801, 0.014339915476739407, 0.03347943350672722, 0.0011771975550800562, -0.0040126461535692215, -0.008657712489366531, 0.02464277297258377, -0.009153158403933048, -0.08160442858934402, 0.01556939072906971, 0.03178298473358154, 0.03485636040568352, 0.03874567151069641, -0.007615853566676378, -0.04652322083711624, 0.041068971157073975, 0.016917143017053604, 0.028577154502272606, -0.002276557730510831, -0.02553117647767067, -0.026456428691744804, 0.07577801495790482, -0.008940696716308594, 0.06301935762166977, 0.026834117248654366, -0.058325767517089844, 0.049313805997371674, 0.061625588685274124, -0.0031529392581433058, 0.019760409370064735, -0.021594038233160973, 0.021731259301304817, -0.016830937936902046, 0.024863023310899734, -0.05721615254878998, 0.015529908239841461, -0.01267373375594616, 0.010772807523608208, -0.11610253900289536, 0.02631286159157753, -0.017705721780657768, 0.03082490712404251, -0.004263490904122591, 0.021024061366915703, 0.0065133520402014256, 0.0709131732583046, 0.041073933243751526, -0.013752499595284462, 0.03445878252387047, 0.012018260546028614, -0.02337862364947796, 0.0340372659265995, -0.021449461579322815, -0.011831790208816528, -0.016356848180294037, -0.029482537880539894, -0.023416806012392044, 0.06370589882135391, 0.024303007870912552, -0.011504911817610264, -0.013910630717873573, 0.009297076612710953, -0.02250085212290287, 0.04977786913514137, 0.014626847580075264, 0.015449938364326954, 0.011010554619133472, -0.04995069280266762, 0.03519473597407341, 0.006418060977011919, 0.0176805779337883, 0.006282609887421131, -0.011686666868627071, 0.037594616413116455, -0.07312779873609543, -0.0026485382113605738, 0.037955570966005325, 0.04595795273780823, 0.060239341109991074, 0.03859521448612213, 0.002807595767080784, -0.01747819036245346, 0.0029092589393258095, -0.05678093060851097, 0.035323936492204666, -0.024312803521752357, 0.048290081322193146, -0.0011262207990512252, -0.023389000445604324, -0.014928659424185753, 0.03697705268859863, -0.013764054514467716, 0.04571625217795372, 0.003892205422744155, 0.0013289999915286899, 0.029893523082137108, -0.040970578789711, -0.02979971654713154, -0.018944354727864265, 0.009939438663423061, 0.01206583995372057, -0.07364542037248611, -0.022313611581921577, 0.017615295946598053, 0.03308727592229843, -0.01942664198577404, 0.013052788563072681, 0.03035418502986431, -0.011509710922837257, -0.008642969653010368, 0.026408633217215538, 0.042846791446208954, -0.031156647950410843, -0.011157270520925522, -0.03546960651874542, -0.04768881946802139, -0.0048016998916864395, -0.03927511349320412, 0.019493423402309418, 0.03616722673177719, -0.012667592614889145, -0.021913858130574226, 0.026671554893255234, 0.0011391291627660394, -0.0372375026345253, 0.0770794078707695, -0.03734959289431572, 0.002985157771036029, 0.010035205632448196, 0.012950032949447632, -0.017024721950292587, 0.02452346310019493, 0.03992068022489548, 0.012428459711372852, 0.003045338671654463, 0.01435043103992939, 0.005609280429780483, -0.06318376213312149, -0.04074345529079437, 0.0388464480638504, 0.027821453288197517, 0.03138795867562294, -0.04320158064365387, -0.00167303835041821, -0.026006020605564117, -0.011595753021538258, 0.017682578414678574, -0.059984926134347916, 0.029733141884207726, 0.037945568561553955, 0.039404384791851044, -0.0021969787776470184, 0.016148952767252922, -0.009680473245680332, -0.04244383051991463, 0.08313698321580887, -0.035437971353530884, -0.06014833226799965, 0.08857110887765884, 0.02156440168619156, 0.015739675611257553, -0.02984802797436714, -0.038856714963912964, -0.031789593398571014, 0.025375816971063614, 0.00048053296632133424, -0.006037972401827574, -0.08904964476823807, -0.037571173161268234, -0.01713567227125168, 0.018244652077555656, 0.06776849925518036, 0.03052649274468422, 0.01086705457419157, -0.004383925814181566, -0.018110383301973343, 0.01798287220299244, 0.015817051753401756, -0.05324006453156471, 0.00002713135108933784, -0.06765585392713547, -0.012192144058644772, 0.018602382391691208, -0.011976214125752449, 0.018625104799866676, 0.025325950235128403, -0.005584512371569872, -0.0564328208565712, -0.0005556983524002135, -0.026423783972859383, -0.007900934666395187, -0.02068292163312435, -0.02303742617368698, -0.031112032011151314, 0.07278741896152496, 0.00968257337808609, -0.073561891913414, 0.016405612230300903, 0.047738268971443176, 0.014203299768269062, 0.019907524809241295, -0.010133324190974236, 0.050203390419483185, 0.06365440040826797, 0.0018572048284113407, 0.012019838206470013, -0.06036890298128128, -0.029472975060343742, -0.03153258189558983, 0.029831979423761368, 0.031360942870378494, 0.023348884657025337, -0.005570085719227791, -0.030232183635234833, -0.05321407690644264, 0.07535547763109207, 0.031128084287047386, 0.03480365127325058, -0.021861791610717773, -0.0017479535890743136, -0.035899825394153595, 0.03067304939031601, -0.023713983595371246, -0.031762681901454926, 0.003859153715893626, 0.029982034116983414, -0.03581880405545235, 0.008246771059930325, -0.0635589137673378, 0.021856945008039474, -0.01617855578660965, -0.03813076391816139, -0.024023331701755524, 0.024073341861367226, 0.03781425207853317, 0.03320188820362091, -0.035319600254297256, -0.003824115265160799, -0.04134654998779297, 0.02245859056711197, 0.01827944628894329, -0.02300330065190792, 0.06305055320262909, -0.07955478876829147, 0.008618790656328201, -0.04310857877135277, 0.021486753597855568, 0.00258435751311481, 0.019663579761981964, 0.06896845996379852, -0.00738554960116744, -0.011213165707886219, -0.01371072232723236, -0.03051607497036457, 0.025185376405715942, 0.03888043016195297, 0.017664464190602303, 0.0670352652668953, 0.029974542558193207, 0.06767528504133224, -0.008347115479409695, -0.039960190653800964, -0.07585731893777847, -0.01222789566963911, 0.01690208911895752, -0.0610346794128418, 0.017815766856074333, -0.002577724400907755, -0.043794117867946625, -0.00827301386743784, -0.034777525812387466, -0.039448872208595276, 0.0048840767703950405, 0.017309382557868958, -0.019796423614025116, 0.028724808245897293, 0.035359013825654984, 0.006371597293764353, -0.006614660378545523, -0.006578484084457159, 0.010384893976151943, 0.01970617100596428, 0.0402848981320858, -0.014543372206389904, -0.008541380055248737, 0.05360814929008484, -0.03577805683016777, 0.05972171574831009, -0.05247323960065842, -0.033778853714466095, -0.018111594021320343, -0.00812971405684948, 0.044078726321458817, 0.008768060244619846, 0.005361384246498346, 0.003699489636346698, 0.004081502556800842, -0.019335176795721054, -0.054180510342121124, 0.042176902294158936, -0.017312252894043922, -0.046044789254665375, 0.030479205772280693, -0.020411944016814232, 0.018385326489806175, -0.044485025107860565, -0.09666328132152557, -0.02178988978266716, -0.01758101023733616, -0.003208023961633444, -0.04470747709274292, 0.016847878694534302, 0.03737820312380791, 0.08769294619560242, -0.086935855448246, -0.020545924082398415, 0.016186032444238663, 0.025506913661956787, 0.02009548619389534, -0.026909302920103073, -0.03159782290458679, 0.005506154615432024, 0.00008277992310468107, -0.024168670177459717, -0.0646461471915245, 0.08087585866451263, 0.0023666219785809517, -0.004220024682581425, 0.02180037461221218, -0.015434532426297665, -0.02202111855149269, 0.00900763738900423, 0.028504109010100365, -0.017267981544137, 0.03456209972500801, 0.007022926118224859, 0.011666664853692055, -0.023421533405780792, 0.05189821124076843, 0.0004838530730921775, -0.04550694301724434, 0.04040408134460449, -0.031483761966228485, -0.00358560960739851, 0.03769347071647644, 0.030115028843283653, -0.09570276737213135, -0.06353241205215454, 0.04680998995900154, 0.009828920476138592, -0.08945102244615555, 0.013302451930940151, 0.05758418142795563, -0.051843274384737015, 0.003150927135720849, -0.08196520060300827, 0.046152353286743164, 0.09574131667613983, 0.045642610639333725, 0.0034562726505100727, -0.05599097162485123, 0.019663184881210327, 0.005300425924360752, 0.018693963065743446, -0.027036193758249283, -0.03147196024656296, 0.02984173223376274, -0.048251740634441376, -0.012774022296071053, 0.01826355792582035, -0.058414410799741745, 0.02189134992659092, -0.022373801097273827, -0.008265956304967403, 0.04387936368584633, -0.02255559153854847, -0.05999750643968582, -0.005797962192445993, -0.0031891369726508856, -0.012946025468409061, -0.019779011607170105, -0.050116851925849915, -0.04530811682343483, -0.03040500357747078, -0.022602766752243042, -0.06352026015520096, -0.013211056590080261, -0.0761125311255455, -0.06879501044750214, 0.016437459737062454, 0.021650774404406548, 0.021899042651057243, 0.020199432969093323, 0.014767864719033241, 0.00522764353081584, -0.018520276993513107, -0.032664161175489426, -0.01617259532213211, 0.027326025068759918, -0.000446371384896338, 0.057703517377376556, -0.010074523277580738, 0.05730099231004715, -0.11287732422351837, -0.0390237495303154, -0.08532599359750748, -0.004534638021141291, 0.03347840532660484, 0.05148380249738693, 0.042360857129096985, -0.017769837751984596, 0.048200253397226334, -0.008618162013590336, 0.0006775012006983161, 0.0297402236610651 ]
<p><strong>(1)</strong> As we know, we have theories of second quantization for both bosons and fermions. That is, let $W_N$ be the $N$ identical particle Hilbert space of bosons or fermions, then the "many particle" Hilbert space $V$ would be $V=W_0\oplus W_1\oplus W_2\oplus W_3\oplus...$ , and further we can define creation and annihilation operators which satisfy commutation(anticommutation) relations for bonsons(fermions).</p> <p>So my first question is, do we also have a "second quantization theory" for anyons like bosons and fermions?</p> <p><strong>(2)</strong> Generally speaking, anyons can only happen in 2D. Is this conclusion based on the assumption that the particles are <strong>point-like</strong>? </p> <p>In <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9707021" rel="nofollow">Kitaev's toric code model</a>, the quasiparticles are <strong>point-like</strong> due to the <strong>local operators</strong> in the Hamiltonian. My question is, in 3D case, whether there exists a simple model whose Hamiltonian contains <strong>local operators</strong> and <strong>spatially extended operators</strong>, so that it has both poit-like quasiparticles(say, $\mathbf{e}$) and knot-like quasiparticles(say, $\mathbf{m}$), then the $\mathbf{e}$ and $\mathbf{m}$ particles have nontrivial mutual statistics in 3D? </p>
g6580
[ 0.0528068020939827, -0.0502823106944561, -0.0018710375297814608, -0.02767742983996868, 0.09196498990058899, 0.0014383132802322507, -0.005766712594777346, 0.014326744712889194, -0.019564326852560043, 0.04161969572305679, -0.04980182647705078, 0.024954406544566154, -0.004539568442851305, 0.015290427021682262, -0.05032730475068092, 0.06862588226795197, 0.005869294982403517, 0.05258601903915405, 0.046018559485673904, -0.049430180341005325, -0.0018886232282966375, 0.029895542189478874, 0.038124069571495056, -0.05414668098092079, 0.011111175641417503, 0.006838109809905291, 0.03209102898836136, -0.0353972464799881, -0.02244722470641136, -0.00277273659594357, 0.03766664117574692, -0.021782856434583664, 0.040729038417339325, -0.07907447963953018, 0.004594548139721155, -0.05759483203291893, 0.05606662109494209, -0.01132145244628191, -0.03620946407318115, -0.0020729701500386, 0.0043871658854186535, -0.026431595906615257, 0.0386711023747921, -0.017819149419665337, -0.05918026342988014, 0.006826526951044798, -0.030090337619185448, 0.05397110432386398, -0.02203632891178131, -0.012883752584457397, 0.009668594226241112, 0.027200879529118538, 0.04543488472700119, -0.008381915278732777, 0.03164944797754288, 0.06980995088815689, -0.012881629168987274, -0.047632355242967606, 0.057129427790641785, 0.04893006011843681, -0.06454724818468094, 0.05423124507069588, 0.026645345613360405, 0.01627219095826149, 0.03604944795370102, 0.03247877582907677, -0.04284649342298508, 0.015998367220163345, -0.011706497520208359, -0.021282335743308067, 0.03599083051085472, -0.04832154139876366, -0.025350192561745644, -0.02723662368953228, 0.044367026537656784, 0.015352390706539154, -0.05566725507378578, -0.008942910470068455, -0.0010661593405529857, -0.011858334764838219, -0.09337622672319412, -0.03234463930130005, -0.05217637121677399, -0.004154758062213659, 0.027314525097608566, -0.06543169170618057, 0.026986828073859215, 0.0006897829589433968, -0.00886615552008152, 0.06039923056960106, -0.012293596751987934, 0.021593784913420677, 0.032873429358005524, 0.07218960672616959, -0.02094271034002304, -0.022280028089880943, 0.015972478315234184, 0.059348106384277344, -0.05329916998744011, 0.003179145511239767, -0.039344560354948044, -0.02152267098426819, 0.008375106379389763, 0.000812324695289135, 0.005816531367599964, -0.010516745038330555, 0.08602479100227356, -0.027908146381378174, 0.02768883854150772, 0.0371275320649147, -0.03354199603199959, 0.0232804324477911, -0.015895342454314232, 0.018105648458003998, -0.030254153534770012, 0.0009267835994251072, 0.021692322567105293, -0.04915696009993553, 0.005857250653207302, 0.039716292172670364, 0.048900969326496124, -0.028395984321832657, 0.013130910694599152, 0.03728809580206871, 0.026988042518496513, 0.020894216373562813, -0.03338715806603432, 0.05763835087418556, 0.0029486690182238817, 0.034234121441841125, 0.003999633248895407, -0.031490158289670944, 0.01839623972773552, 0.05332595854997635, -0.030012622475624084, 0.03901778906583786, -0.023027092218399048, 0.035089366137981415, 0.03631686046719551, 0.015371190384030342, -0.04276855289936066, -0.042707331478595734, -0.002303903689607978, 0.035440512001514435, -0.04577719420194626, -0.0179179385304451, 0.0734415054321289, -0.06376157701015472, -0.023363959044218063, 0.05355063080787659, 0.02757817879319191, 0.025717727839946747, 0.06699047237634659, 0.016158945858478546, -0.0427795834839344, 0.041620977222919464, -0.02665424905717373, 0.0408596433699131, 0.03357294946908951, -0.011214430443942547, 0.03003094159066677, -0.0029867354314774275, 0.004041335545480251, 0.012302111834287643, 0.011657842434942722, -0.00475567439571023, 0.03844987973570824, -0.029589107260107994, -0.016836632043123245, 0.0034116851165890694, -0.031968750059604645, 0.03159255161881447, -0.018909407779574394, -0.0255553238093853, 0.009203118272125721, -0.025952642783522606, -0.10405376553535461, -0.025357253849506378, 0.008094225078821182, 0.02241324447095394, -0.016707533970475197, 0.018654711544513702, -0.015166682191193104, -0.023280339315533638, -0.006974908523261547, 0.046556130051612854, -0.037647999823093414, 0.05289299413561821, 0.04549162834882736, -0.004721580073237419, -0.010261249728500843, -0.05147667974233627, -0.008640809915959835, 0.022560318931937218, -0.04219776391983032, 0.009142219088971615, 0.07260344922542572, -0.045137736946344376, -0.003910883795469999, -0.04043043777346611, 0.014207988977432251, 0.04707111418247223, 0.024610809981822968, -0.004090983886271715, 0.042485155165195465, -0.007810595445334911, 0.001910748309455812, 0.01761069893836975, -0.020356692373752594, 0.0350005105137825, 0.007642305921763182, -0.018199920654296875, 0.029142383486032486, 0.03917965665459633, -0.019245073199272156, -0.030153660103678703, -0.036712877452373505, 0.01223313994705677, -0.01303203497081995, -0.048342540860176086, -0.02692681923508644, -0.05042438954114914, 0.05150075629353523, -0.05582362040877342, -0.01708565279841423, -0.002916263649240136, 0.004744963254779577, -0.010661023668944836, -0.006114338990300894, 0.04770383983850479, -0.006165248341858387, -0.03436208888888359, -0.03373955190181732, -0.08501887321472168, 0.026719313114881516, 0.054358962923288345, -0.06811916083097458, 0.0018535535782575607, 0.05352901294827461, 0.01594904623925686, 0.0507732592523098, -0.04105474427342415, -0.017235923558473587, -0.014236507937312126, 0.07085279375314713, 0.01117442175745964, 0.030060477554798126, 0.04446626082062721, 0.003951619379222393, 0.023435527458786964, -0.01913696527481079, -0.00650747399777174, -0.07105281203985214, -0.03003557398915291, 0.056428488343954086, 0.0017346178647130728, 0.07362471520900726, 0.02913324162364006, -0.055407699197530746, -0.08423791825771332, 0.03470413759350777, -0.012723465450108051, -0.005239300429821014, 0.039311379194259644, -0.008381490595638752, 0.03232976049184799, -0.007424998562783003, 0.02963836118578911, -0.03384556248784065, 0.01605299673974514, -0.06097769737243652, 0.03568962588906288, -0.00422561913728714, 0.036009397357702255, -0.010803939774632454, 0.0013548779534175992, -0.039811424911022186, -0.008606908842921257, 0.0005226177163422108, -0.05572188273072243, -0.045016027987003326, 0.0858834981918335, -0.011855518445372581, 0.03553394228219986, 0.04323199391365051, -0.0144947599619627, -0.016578778624534607, 0.00126233184710145, -0.007115177810192108, 0.010979892686009407, 0.03537899628281593, 0.014474027790129185, 0.020342005416750908, 0.07350799441337585, -0.0354975163936615, 0.012441621161997318, -0.07120673358440399, -0.005086539778858423, 0.009001091122627258, 0.09549959748983383, 0.03083779476583004, -0.017666680738329887, -0.005360154435038567, 0.04329733923077583, 0.09906166046857834, -0.03697646036744118, -0.07303962856531143, -0.006127683911472559, -0.02409345470368862, 0.004376789089292288, -0.0026395125314593315, 0.07928616553544998, -0.01802751049399376, -0.012022935785353184, 0.024670369923114777, 0.023313134908676147, -0.03388192132115364, -0.00575476698577404, 0.005891406908631325, -0.05629400163888931, -0.04481199383735657, -0.02351294457912445, 0.03220504894852638, -0.04090510308742523, 0.0619596503674984, 0.05399744585156441, -0.060291729867458344, -0.002842833986505866, -0.045850902795791626, -0.009121468290686607, -0.06029640510678291, -0.008451634086668491, 0.02456900104880333, 0.00734728155657649, -0.082762710750103, -0.06172408163547516, -0.04041662812232971, -0.02665962278842926, 0.0467216894030571, -0.009724834002554417, 0.04072397202253342, -0.002213822677731514, -0.026054343208670616, -0.0035706418566405773, -0.03462125360965729, 0.019209349527955055, 0.022676846012473106, 0.005319913383573294, 0.03704327344894409, -0.030927404761314392, 0.040453121066093445, -0.023778684437274933, 0.06547758728265762, 0.0036531828809529543, 0.00159541517496109, -0.01943110302090645, 0.0526619628071785, 0.011027294211089611, 0.014960735104978085, -0.06869592517614365, 0.025372400879859924, -0.02644363045692444, 0.05101696774363518, 0.039383526891469955, -0.03398017957806587, -0.006682130042463541, 0.03564294055104256, -0.05078911781311035, 0.025950370356440544, -0.01613619737327099, 0.036714281886816025, 0.01510525681078434, 0.00242284475825727, -0.014278599061071873, 0.04223966598510742, 0.027944929897785187, 0.03130671754479408, -0.022566750645637512, -0.02914530411362648, 0.00032163705327548087, 0.029722733423113823, 0.025153985247015953, 0.013992682099342346, 0.0283205546438694, 0.01957094669342041, 0.024779409170150757, 0.010669419541954994, -0.0059255738742649555, -0.04263798147439957, -0.09480219334363937, 0.008584752678871155, -0.033521510660648346, -0.009954027831554413, -0.054470181465148926, 0.04208681359887123, -0.04516755789518356, 0.030603528022766113, -0.057870324701070786, -0.006081853061914444, 0.07844351977109909, -0.09553972631692886, -0.025566279888153076, -0.005469188559800386, -0.09071867167949677, -0.01801937073469162, -0.038086846470832825, -0.01295663882046938, 0.03432416170835495, -0.014979242347180843, -0.005739630199968815, -0.0037993756122887135, -0.011140751652419567, 0.041567232459783554, -0.06784628331661224, -0.012856101617217064, -0.03672480210661888, -0.03169915825128555, 0.008541163988411427, -0.03638797998428345, -0.06685846298933029, 0.012271355837583542, 0.06181276589632034, 0.04299052432179451, 0.010334833525121212, 0.018148895353078842, 0.0121536273509264, 0.026181243360042572, -0.002654451411217451, -0.024730943143367767, -0.0028123159427195787, 0.013653802685439587, -0.025760382413864136, 0.05728624388575554, 0.035192862153053284, -0.04192452132701874, -0.019613491371273994, -0.02373712696135044, 0.04866097867488861, 0.016607701778411865, -0.014123224653303623, 0.04115784168243408, 0.0017724602948874235, 0.014490297064185143, -0.01879454404115677, 0.06722474098205566, 0.006713820621371269, -0.028867879882454872, 0.007065534591674805, -0.020354025065898895, -0.007445822935551405, 0.0023962168488651514, 0.0805596336722374, -0.010947898961603642, 0.007497512269765139, -0.0007362193427979946, 0.011391565203666687, -0.0032351503614336252, -0.006259342189878225, -0.007605934049934149, -0.02683192677795887, -0.055003587156534195, 0.0016461279010400176, 0.01864040456712246, 0.021455436944961548, -0.013499340042471886, 0.009547163732349873, -0.09545852243900299, 0.015755292028188705, 0.0004428368993103504, -0.02196689136326313, -0.017285970970988274, 0.007654609624296427, 0.00805321242660284, -0.048235878348350525, 0.021878743544220924, 0.011001348495483398, 0.07306796312332153, -0.06110590323805809, 0.03683369606733322, -0.02655351534485817, 0.012777375057339668, -0.030484192073345184, 0.05829994007945061, -0.01021953672170639, 0.02125636115670204, 0.01833302155137062, 0.01568176969885826, 0.009885133244097233, -0.04693594574928284, 0.025149665772914886, -0.025245551019906998, -0.030087580904364586, -0.017763826996088028, 0.013668734580278397, 0.018636735156178474, -0.0020862221717834473, 0.01982978545129299, -0.0428142324090004, -0.0005320098134689033, 0.018172144889831543, -0.016162235289812088, -0.04904031381011009, 0.04950100556015968, 0.01582503505051136, -0.006155699025839567, 0.025442304089665413, 0.06973063200712204, -0.030804399400949478, -0.002245450159534812, -0.01316223107278347, -0.017808761447668076, -0.01471426710486412, -0.055557731539011, -0.02223396673798561, -0.00808016862720251, 0.05937010422348976, -0.021700944751501083, 0.04530685022473335, -0.04454478621482849, -0.06166614592075348, 0.007389379199594259, -0.020404893904924393, 0.03316577896475792, -0.02143370546400547, 0.0265154130756855, 0.027563678100705147, -0.04402906075119972, -0.042980875819921494, 0.06730704009532928, 0.06375683844089508, -0.033761028200387955, 0.007889718748629093, -0.05313611030578613, 0.022329261526465416, -0.020850755274295807, -0.009751185774803162, -0.013719722628593445, 0.03505644574761391, 0.018687231466174126, 0.03571734577417374, 0.020801428705453873, -0.007883032783865929, -0.007359296549111605, 0.02224412001669407, -0.059893928468227386, -0.013898788020014763, -0.057734500616788864, -0.026844169944524765, 0.027095559984445572, -0.025552082806825638, -0.03604893013834953, -0.04088333249092102, -0.024149084463715553, -0.018573397770524025, 0.022677641361951828, -0.0007680606795474887, -0.04163332283496857, -0.0009937190916389227, 0.03228442370891571, 0.001151547534391284, -0.04466498643159866, -0.006330200005322695, 0.04251499101519585, -0.027683980762958527, 0.024179620668292046, -0.004355873912572861, 0.0266374833881855, 0.03428186476230621, -0.0029326293151825666, 0.08575577288866043, 0.03849506005644798, 0.0693599134683609, 0.04043559357523918, 0.009490713477134705, 0.013621876016259193, -0.025587016716599464, 0.001084522227756679, -0.025507552549242973, -0.04428090527653694, -0.016117190942168236, -0.004430512432008982, 0.07745683938264847, -0.01973721943795681, -0.022592933848500252, -0.03860074281692505, 0.053874656558036804, 0.06061503291130066, -0.046866193413734436, -0.0038888822309672832, 0.040532056242227554, -0.037797681987285614, 0.016869906336069107, -0.06268555670976639, -0.059196606278419495, -0.005219012498855591, 0.04585372284054756, 0.015407618135213852, -0.05768216773867607, -0.020369043573737144, 0.05230638384819031, 0.007888128980994225, -0.00737781124189496, -0.0005272867274470627, 0.01954078860580921, -0.019488265737891197, 0.06762650609016418, -0.04254058003425598, 0.0031061593908816576, -0.03401857614517212, 0.02825629524886608, 0.01151486486196518, -0.030405715107917786, -0.00845465436577797, 0.039658237248659134, 0.030624207109212875, -0.06486841291189194, -0.004252720158547163, -0.03670703247189522, -0.03500554338097572, -0.03865961730480194, 0.043199166655540466, -0.01225090678781271, -0.031183188781142235, -0.04105258360505104, 0.023194357752799988, 0.03362499922513962, 0.01402206439524889, -0.029205312952399254, 0.054284948855638504, 0.03229086846113205, -0.031056595966219902, -0.004800854716449976, 0.014662906527519226, 0.04442109912633896, -0.06511277705430984, -0.011837984435260296, -0.05560068041086197, -0.03904149681329727, -0.008653373457491398, -0.008411509916186333, -0.04313550516963005, 0.018242210149765015, 0.021998198702931404, -0.019868042320013046, -0.04380311071872711, 0.008801739662885666, 0.017278719693422318, 0.005135833285748959, -0.026506787165999413, 0.041922662407159805, 0.02803752012550831, 0.024028820917010307, -0.012895511463284492, -0.01783101260662079, 0.02528850920498371, 0.013340701349079609, 0.05929693952202797, 0.03990591689944267, -0.015618531033396721, -0.02048923447728157, -0.05870413780212402, 0.013436910696327686, -0.03306446224451065, -0.04957133159041405, 0.04038819298148155, 0.044254958629608154, 0.015438609756529331, -0.023897213861346245, -0.061620891094207764, 0.0015102154575288296, -0.005588478874415159, -0.02487059310078621, -0.07272160798311234, -0.019695498049259186, -0.013506448827683926, 0.00230098026804626, 0.003664798103272915, 0.07460509240627289, -0.003223059233278036, -0.05036509409546852, 0.07332243770360947, 0.024877876043319702, 0.03736631199717522, -0.003395270323380828, 0.00018763002299237996, 0.05367874354124069, 0.02591828629374504, -0.011899196542799473, -0.040438782423734665, 0.03125672787427902, 0.06306740641593933, -0.048659827560186386, 0.011942584998905659, -0.02943238988518715, -0.030397724360227585, 0.032119400799274445, -0.0078529492020607, 0.01692529208958149, 0.04527390003204346, 0.040825095027685165, 0.02266487292945385, -0.03340144827961922, -0.09649140387773514, -0.026880817487835884, -0.00045403692638501525, -0.04842853173613548, 0.015661442652344704, -0.010040104389190674, -0.03975632041692734, -0.008557675406336784, 0.04974065348505974, 0.0008498408715240657, 0.03665170818567276, 0.041150741279125214, 0.015832284465432167, -0.026121219620108604, -0.011173347942531109, -0.008868779987096786, 0.015440770424902439, -0.045091841369867325, -0.024043874815106392, -0.047716591507196426, -0.08195144683122635, 0.006750635337084532, 0.04068927466869354, -0.020792772993445396, 0.021787766367197037, 0.0027822228148579597, 0.02494320273399353, 0.02096117101609707, 0.0035364776849746704, 0.020063018426299095, -0.02818186767399311, 0.038364093750715256, -0.04664254188537598, 0.00004855584484175779, 0.000026930580133921467, 0.003631108207628131, -0.01321004144847393, -0.05447506532073021, -0.01405660156160593, -0.010995603166520596, 0.06096608191728592, 0.005236882716417313, -0.006222437135875225, 0.06452939659357071, -0.023737970739603043, -0.007150312419980764, -0.015995033085346222, -0.056864261627197266, 0.01145636010915041, 0.01366292592138052, 0.03760270029306412, 0.006471589207649231, 0.04111926630139351, -0.02953076921403408, 0.04611169546842575, 0.009059176780283451, -0.014006827026605606, -0.036529961973428726, -0.058615148067474365, 0.01306310947984457, -0.01359749585390091, -0.0385100357234478, 0.03818687051534653, -0.034235529601573944, -0.024503644555807114, 0.1008099690079689 ]
<p>I read some where that there are three types of UV and infrared rays namely UV-A, UV-B, UV-C and near infrared, mid infrared and far infrared. Which is the most abundant among the the three in Ultraviolet and infrared radiation from sun? I mean there is a total of 1000 W per unit area illumination by sun among which more than 500 watts is infrared, around 450 watts in visible and the rest part is ultraviolet so in the infrared rays which are the most abundant means which contribute to most of the 500 watts? Also, what are the sources of infrared at night and what is the power density of infrared rays at night!.</p>
g6581
[ 0.028891783207654953, 0.003967556171119213, 0.0021887419279664755, 0.04500006139278412, -0.0014976972015574574, -0.009781653061509132, 0.023109134286642075, -0.006072668358683586, 0.006931287236511707, 0.020038118585944176, 0.04662308841943741, -0.008350252173841, -0.035702768713235855, 0.03152136132121086, 0.012281632982194424, -0.02152952179312706, 0.020958617329597473, -0.01698433980345726, 0.04396593198180199, 0.07505825161933899, -0.04842761531472206, -0.06972357630729675, 0.030799657106399536, -0.006567468401044607, -0.057936813682317734, 0.01693783514201641, 0.0011839563958346844, 0.006294427439570427, 0.020992698147892952, -0.05789243429899216, 0.08930163085460663, -0.014080245979130268, 0.07031665742397308, 0.0032849072013050318, 0.016809815540909767, -0.010224059224128723, 0.020256230607628822, 0.00086393509991467, -0.02119310572743416, 0.04853815585374832, 0.0036122368182986975, 0.057437390089035034, 0.09714752435684204, 0.026020528748631477, -0.0021980253513902426, 0.011563373729586601, -0.0505225732922554, 0.003051827661693096, 0.006998872384428978, -0.03763238713145256, 0.008908971212804317, -0.020902149379253387, 0.020064083859324455, 0.023891819640994072, 0.06298930197954178, -0.01984519511461258, 0.010203723795711994, -0.040521297603845596, 0.018709806725382805, 0.039624977856874466, 0.060750532895326614, 0.007303065620362759, -0.06153760105371475, 0.012347204610705376, 0.013035465031862259, -0.01879323087632656, -0.016264697536826134, 0.023915698751807213, 0.00759910698980093, 0.008223211392760277, 0.005404338240623474, -0.04501350224018097, -0.005607289262115955, -0.024109970778226852, -0.01755368709564209, -0.06264527142047882, 0.022993996739387512, -0.013783507980406284, -0.03825550898909569, 0.08730047196149826, 0.040539927780628204, -0.0565233938395977, 0.006360616069287062, -0.01414358802139759, 0.025249015539884567, -0.034210242331027985, -0.032380856573581696, 0.008024247363209724, -0.013448696583509445, -0.00876326858997345, 0.036666616797447205, 0.04978323355317116, 0.08080065995454788, -0.0021582962945103645, -0.004460417199879885, 0.06587006896734238, 0.04084803909063339, 0.05276545509696007, 0.008440268225967884, -0.0116217490285635, -0.005560798570513725, -0.049349162727594376, 0.051072850823402405, -0.02524595893919468, 0.015555677935481071, 0.01796294003725052, -0.06463269144296646, -0.05811981484293938, -0.05429358407855034, 0.06945338100194931, -0.09604004770517349, -0.02572539448738098, 0.001670177443884313, -0.00945077370852232, -0.04168607294559479, -0.0311651099473238, 0.02384740486741066, 0.014312757179141045, 0.06457668542861938, 0.06602460145950317, 0.009577910415828228, 0.05844642221927643, -0.035988207906484604, -0.026211077347397804, 0.0031733724754303694, -0.02469734475016594, 0.009830544702708721, -0.014394067227840424, -0.049931589514017105, -0.022260956466197968, 0.04016035795211792, 0.0063290526159107685, -0.008740602992475033, 0.00827329233288765, 0.07331523299217224, 0.0020803455263376236, 0.019789662212133408, 0.026479285210371017, 0.05714835971593857, 0.0426117368042469, 0.017444586381316185, -0.011716398410499096, 0.014507546089589596, -0.052260857075452805, -0.05082903057336807, 0.0450759157538414, -0.05148711055517197, -0.008482703007757664, -0.027632124722003937, -0.021007327362895012, 0.05929876118898392, 0.029698660597205162, 0.02499781921505928, -0.08660714328289032, -0.03614182025194168, -0.04844851419329643, -0.026904884725809097, -0.02914714440703392, -0.015676377341151237, 0.00556125957518816, -0.021626312285661697, -0.04060238599777222, 0.014557857066392899, -0.0141390860080719, 0.007196180988103151, -0.07162538170814514, -0.031019598245620728, -0.06895367056131363, -0.005304066929966211, 0.012774428352713585, -0.009827664121985435, -0.02889048121869564, -0.003983114380389452, -0.02417862042784691, 0.022967146709561348, 0.005912026856094599, 0.10574644804000854, -0.03212481737136841, -0.0020853218156844378, 0.03975362330675125, -0.031193992123007774, -0.026806188747286797, -0.0382392555475235, -0.0513923317193985, 0.01876229979097843, 0.018828783184289932, -0.001986418617889285, -0.041146036237478256, -0.002637645462527871, 0.04920833930373192, -0.03081025741994381, -0.05418672040104866, 0.045363083481788635, -0.029379921033978462, -0.02799365669488907, 0.025339201092720032, 0.02326769381761551, 0.004115338437259197, 0.004348006099462509, 0.0254324022680521, 0.04489276930689812, -0.030671613290905952, -0.05451390892267227, -0.011573264375329018, 0.001145035377703607, 0.09546029567718506, -0.020744556561112404, 0.01991851069033146, -0.025803927332162857, 0.028989415615797043, 0.012009687721729279, -0.05968927592039108, 0.03816543519496918, 0.02152005024254322, -0.022202765569090843, -0.001991105265915394, -0.09728366136550903, 0.0007770433439873159, 0.023416614159941673, -0.02971290983259678, -0.021586524322628975, 0.06112151965498924, 0.05986279994249344, 0.04217394068837166, -0.008132608607411385, 0.08930568397045135, -0.009809937328100204, -0.0216762013733387, 0.06145511567592621, 0.052385684102773666, -0.06671664863824844, -0.037177857011556625, 0.017539961263537407, 0.007138374727219343, -0.01506110280752182, 0.005884545389562845, -0.002860970562323928, -0.01110292598605156, 0.03726089000701904, -0.02926841378211975, 0.01357960794121027, 0.01181902177631855, 0.037574704736471176, -0.005118224769830704, 0.0009521216270513833, 0.028101224452257156, -0.05294415354728699, -0.03969668596982956, 0.04455392435193062, 0.009649597108364105, -0.012494265101850033, 0.02300289459526539, 0.029136380180716515, 0.005091829691082239, -0.03246660158038139, -0.02524959109723568, -0.030765902251005173, 0.027892153710126877, -0.020977463573217392, -0.019887294620275497, -0.015057902783155441, -0.08552476018667221, -0.0019713877700269222, 0.013719961047172546, 0.00756352161988616, 0.06587395071983337, 0.002331503899767995, -0.019641714170575142, 0.014566087163984776, 0.009822841733694077, -0.02755439281463623, 0.027508869767189026, -0.020327679812908173, 0.012402014806866646, 0.053150273859500885, -0.00807050708681345, -0.02296685427427292, -0.015473665669560432, -0.017014222219586372, -0.058400873094797134, 0.01071256771683693, 0.041344333440065384, 0.0035570913460105658, 0.009085958823561668, 0.030995037406682968, -0.0314081571996212, 0.0058379871770739555, -0.024379488080739975, 0.019439272582530975, -0.019821153953671455, -0.0175736453384161, -0.0371355377137661, 0.04792671278119087, 0.003669996978715062, -0.08723133057355881, 0.0034192504826933146, 0.030883129686117172, 0.007318161893635988, -0.019511085003614426, 0.0173451267182827, 0.03564607724547386, -0.03218653053045273, -0.0036620122846215963, 0.00836970005184412, 0.0046699875965714455, 0.01405410561710596, -0.054208166897296906, -0.05954475700855255, 0.007173449266701937, 0.029106134548783302, -0.043490804731845856, -0.029849620535969734, -0.012676018290221691, 0.010064046829938889, 0.007366410456597805, -0.025694912299513817, 0.006065101828426123, -0.0333876870572567, -0.0013976522022858262, -0.016144737601280212, -0.049893300980329514, 0.009490897879004478, 0.02206805720925331, -0.0015785638242959976, -0.01074032112956047, 0.067805215716362, 0.020244311541318893, -0.00977670680731535, 0.03557681664824486, -0.022878559306263924, -0.06114928051829338, 0.03451898321509361, -0.01726246066391468, -0.015144458040595055, -0.02622477151453495, 0.012289253994822502, -0.05360812693834305, 0.02080647088587284, 0.036958225071430206, 0.009459459222853184, 0.07029641419649124, 0.0427965484559536, -0.0330970399081707, -0.030118504539132118, 0.027276579290628433, 0.01902010478079319, -0.03334454447031021, -0.06740313768386841, -0.053545933216810226, 0.051599372178316116, 0.00674652773886919, -0.04366801679134369, -0.01390642486512661, -0.037657756358385086, -0.044758960604667664, 0.04610135033726692, -0.053976934403181076, 0.025510618463158607, 0.04829537495970726, -0.06366289407014847, -0.004268038552254438, -0.03157102316617966, 0.08668147772550583, -0.00991761963814497, -0.0440426804125309, -0.008047726936638355, 0.048790689557790756, -0.008473854511976242, 0.03784625977277756, 0.02824402041733265, 0.012441765516996384, -0.05611405149102211, -0.0182938314974308, -0.07477676868438721, -0.009435949847102165, 0.00130229361820966, 0.0032333997078239918, -0.01162632741034031, 0.01535496674478054, 0.08652549982070923, 0.03626858443021774, 0.0117697948589921, 0.06747094541788101, 0.023248644545674324, 0.022531632333993912, 0.0798342376947403, -0.03221922740340233, -0.02274513617157936, 0.009521696716547012, -0.050310175865888596, 0.0353647917509079, -0.07142500579357147, -0.07043295353651047, 0.010062461718916893, -0.006676340475678444, -0.037977445870637894, 0.04687226936221123, 0.013939907774329185, 0.03243718296289444, 0.03609731048345566, 0.056622374802827835, 0.02131587453186512, -0.00566117512062192, -0.017125219106674194, 0.0013068313710391521, 0.06970098614692688, 0.02899998612701893, -0.04146292805671692, 0.04239808768033981, -0.011167958378791809, 0.0019295410020276904, 0.0072970520704984665, 0.033437520265579224, -0.05499225854873657, 0.009692042134702206, 0.006785614416003227, -0.008958457037806511, -0.07296605408191681, 0.029394373297691345, 0.061281777918338776, -0.0057698325254023075, -0.039005834609270096, -0.07627086341381073, -0.03216635808348656, 0.021467359736561775, 0.024123981595039368, 0.08993301540613174, -0.009396863169968128, -0.02225586026906967, 0.02773129940032959, -0.005215417128056288, -0.0002371437003603205, 0.026983004063367844, 0.02027306891977787, 0.03272489085793495, 0.006416491232812405, 0.010314815677702427, -0.022688990458846092, -0.002187626203522086, 0.01743181049823761, 0.05853550508618355, 0.011599181219935417, 0.005239877384155989, 0.0037384245079010725, -0.005802284926176071, 0.05743725970387459, 0.019416794180870056, -0.021361395716667175, -0.016760535538196564, -0.002445598365738988, 0.02179396152496338, 0.028384016826748848, -0.06588060408830643, -0.03377524018287659, 0.024058358743786812, 0.03086034581065178, -0.07423330843448639, -0.017791522666811943, 0.030703186988830566, 0.0006557962042279541, -0.028404464945197105, -0.002729842672124505, 0.02335580252110958, 0.008435637690126896, 0.06481096148490906, -0.06927284598350525, -0.06977306306362152, 0.03484366834163666, -0.04396071657538414, -0.053316038101911545, 0.019236864522099495, 0.03988940641283989, 0.05592542886734009, 0.005933335050940514, 0.013334057293832302, -0.043035078793764114, -0.006532604340463877, -0.027605973184108734, -0.027375858277082443, 0.031581807881593704, -0.019290737807750702, -0.0027584980707615614, -0.021664584055542946, 0.09842534363269806, -0.040859196335077286, -0.009703725576400757, 0.04426521435379982, -0.010588012635707855, -0.013180040754377842, -0.011216673068702221, -0.039629556238651276, 0.033184632658958435, 0.026638837531208992, 0.033569417893886566, 0.006156009156256914, 0.026416463777422905, 0.0005453931516967714, -0.05356783792376518, 0.007388490252196789, 0.028106754645705223, 0.0314304381608963, -0.00857177097350359, -0.038279131054878235, -0.039921700954437256, 0.004481506999582052, 0.013267025351524353, 0.05337280035018921, -0.024138033390045166, 0.04251304641366005, 0.058392543345689774, -0.023505304008722305, -0.05261276289820671, -0.028524044901132584, 0.019952712580561638, 0.03667039796710014, -0.027410931885242462, -0.007806121371686459, 0.05125710740685463, 0.02060038596391678, 0.0032124132849276066, 0.05420798808336258, 0.013611135073006153, 0.029569078236818314, 0.061262860894203186, 0.0777137354016304, -0.01947302743792534, 0.00909974705427885, 0.012501087971031666, 0.07165166735649109, -0.04120771586894989, -0.0209331251680851, 0.050149668008089066, -0.023022880777716637, -0.05284975841641426, -0.0030244970694184303, -0.010055704042315483, 0.0335027351975441, 0.02890598215162754, 0.003160636406391859, 0.034000881016254425, -0.02211686782538891, -0.005678575485944748, 0.009373165667057037, 0.037402357906103134, 0.055422600358724594, -0.0396871492266655, -0.01396102737635374, -0.00913776271045208, -0.00254680123180151, 0.08967345207929611, 0.024379797279834747, 0.018257806077599525, 0.02556290104985237, -0.034812796860933304, -0.027359794825315475, -0.05769027769565582, -0.013891370967030525, 0.058285921812057495, 0.023659957572817802, -0.0001873015280580148, 0.0051072994247078896, 0.01714491657912731, -0.00026380084455013275, -0.029801703989505768, -0.003774876007810235, -0.04322991147637367, -0.02504865825176239, -0.04837068170309067, 0.013902021571993828, 0.017078742384910583, 0.028540756553411484, 0.02855609357357025, 0.036356523633003235, 0.007265803869813681, 0.08091868460178375, 0.003844183636829257, 0.05000922083854675, -0.015562159940600395, -0.048937682062387466, -0.018120432272553444, 0.046792320907115936, -0.02116113156080246, -0.04176465794444084, 0.029985329136252403, -0.031434040516614914, 0.028613422065973282, 0.034011971205472946, -0.017330193892121315, -0.05354594439268112, -0.0485294945538044, 0.007670056074857712, -0.029281655326485634, -0.014927461743354797, -0.007108445279300213, -0.08869369328022003, -0.010756198316812515, 0.005113560706377029, -0.02539980039000511, -0.010716189630329609, -0.041876036673784256, -0.021224848926067352, 0.008000336587429047, 0.027605053037405014, -0.01308869943022728, 0.0326649434864521, -0.028566505759954453, 0.02387366071343422, -0.029652411118149757, -0.017977962270379066, 0.01768648624420166, -0.023091351613402367, 0.009543215855956078, -0.05768486484885216, 0.016683226451277733, -0.02683672122657299, 0.003975837957113981, -0.0917849987745285, -0.03961410000920296, 0.011055815033614635, -0.05159001424908638, 0.01466258056461811, -0.05711763724684715, 0.024625802412629128, -0.03794386237859726, 0.05096502974629402, 0.06462489068508148, -0.005874257069081068, 0.02525760978460312, 0.0679461881518364, -0.006165405735373497, 0.020202914252877235, -0.04044165089726448, 0.005773183424025774, 0.04222673177719116, 0.016305075958371162, 0.009099258109927177, -0.02230083756148815, -0.004340708255767822, 0.004849930759519339, 0.018063686788082123, -0.032064829021692276, -0.030755367130041122, 0.016665443778038025, 0.023584820330142975, 0.02537505514919758, -0.032140351831912994, -0.03709150478243828, -0.07990811765193939, -0.00032707321224734187, -0.004287940450012684, -0.04104763641953468, -0.010939284227788448, 0.0302871260792017, -0.030731841921806335, 0.007143238093703985, 0.07969261705875397, -0.011039718985557556, 0.029180858284235, 0.011741884052753448, -0.08158031105995178, 0.005235849879682064, 0.03736167028546333, 0.028891224414110184, 0.0683562308549881, 0.00393274798989296, 0.0737856924533844, -0.019828401505947113, 0.002949075773358345, -0.08436475694179535, 0.009300075471401215, -0.001919066533446312, 0.022991018369793892, -0.03828166052699089, -0.050967488437891006, -0.027760177850723267, 0.015685394406318665, -0.03424542024731636, 0.0038379637990146875, 0.00991041399538517, -0.058170076459646225, -0.03513167425990105, 0.007746147457510233, -0.005935216322541237, -0.009341328404843807, 0.059407129883766174, -0.01079520769417286, -0.007319224998354912, -0.07930337637662888, 0.051565635949373245, -0.03757309913635254, -0.07281100749969482, 0.01403468381613493, 0.02563760243356228, -0.07079549133777618, 0.0053105829283595085, -0.022548697888851166, -0.05780736356973648, -0.023280492052435875, 0.009922536090016365, 0.021132728084921837, 0.023130465298891068, 0.001240454032085836, 0.06400161981582642, -0.023867303505539894, -0.033040281385183334, 0.015547716058790684, 0.014220635406672955, 0.05414758250117302, -0.004956705030053854, -0.005525466986000538, 0.024455847218632698, -0.005966633092612028, 0.043816082179546356, 0.040478892624378204, 0.00866164080798626, -0.02294664829969406, -0.06942200660705566, 0.02779434248805046, -0.07701233774423599, 0.020113859325647354, 0.008697619661688805, 0.010462021455168724, 0.02519640326499939, -0.005950466264039278, -0.01934252679347992, -0.041305091232061386, 0.02043369971215725, -0.03365641087293625, 0.018352588638663292, 0.011464051902294159, -0.02900252677500248, -0.036584705114364624, -0.031111514195799828, -0.028798971325159073, -0.030788876116275787, 0.027569295838475227, -0.0040842462331056595, 0.0022873871494084597, 0.010788668878376484, -0.010562011040747166, 0.0008668160880915821, -0.004696596413850784, 0.003974294289946556, -0.0324297659099102, -0.03288232907652855, -0.034471042454242706, -0.027614735066890717, 0.03199081867933273, 0.0378604419529438, 0.0067084054462611675, -0.04592977836728096, 0.05729741230607033, 0.032858338207006454, 0.012048216536641121, 0.041929204016923904, -0.018764693289995193, 0.03362242132425308, 0.006413248833268881, -0.04614710435271263, 0.018802877515554428, 0.005358763039112091, -0.02956034615635872, -0.03489246219396591, -0.00991032924503088, -0.004729528445750475, -0.010270433500409126, 0.01497382577508688, -0.07982191443443298 ]
<p>In spherical coordinates the flat space-time metric takes:</p> <p>$$ds^2=-c^2dt^2+dr^2+r^2d\Omega^2$$</p> <p>where $r^2d\Omega^2$ come from when the signature of metric $g_{\mu\nu}$ is (-,+,+,+)?</p> <p>what is signature of spherical metric?</p> <hr> <p>this is signature of spherical coordinates: $(1,r^2,r^2\sin^2\theta$)</p> <hr> <p>let me ask in this way, Isn't it metric of spherical coordinates?</p> <p>$$g_{\mu\nu}= (-1,+1,+r^2,+r^2\sin^2\theta)$$</p>
g6582
[ -0.012167312204837799, -0.045424334704875946, -0.0347411185503006, -0.04430847987532616, 0.025127438828349113, 0.03492085263133049, 0.05373704433441162, -0.01595453917980194, -0.0446530282497406, 0.0015015468234196305, 0.007105104625225067, 0.03329943120479584, 0.06101603806018829, -0.052665844559669495, 0.012060528621077538, -0.07026774436235428, 0.040906332433223724, -0.021199412643909454, -0.023665066808462143, 0.009996558539569378, 0.03380053490400314, -0.0207451730966568, 0.057811517268419266, -0.018481392413377762, 0.013154418207705021, -0.01242462731897831, 0.09322681277990341, -0.01767260953783989, -0.030334003269672394, 0.00521545996889472, 0.0498577319085598, -0.01584804616868496, 0.06447311490774155, -0.007731106597930193, -0.01149113941937685, 0.02558699995279312, 0.0350334495306015, 0.005024509970098734, 0.04609830677509308, 0.004889247473329306, 0.004405197221785784, 0.0044886283576488495, 0.04922294616699219, 0.07271233946084976, -0.01671934872865677, -0.01631840132176876, -0.008977862074971199, 0.08670233935117722, -0.015655869618058205, -0.005433632060885429, -0.014160321094095707, 0.04120345786213875, 0.005419918801635504, -0.03755376487970352, -0.026448369026184082, 0.05074281245470047, 0.061998721212148666, -0.038423001766204834, 0.02526193857192993, 0.07139629870653152, -0.00938293244689703, -0.02667543850839138, -0.011371536180377007, 0.02853451669216156, 0.033364612609148026, -0.010202920064330101, -0.025120999664068222, 0.008658728562295437, 0.021987570449709892, -0.006449831183999777, 0.04804782569408417, -0.03524995595216751, 0.00768832815811038, -0.019573872908949852, -0.028916971758008003, 0.026205074042081833, 0.050917863845825195, 0.0005501075647771358, 0.0074672456830739975, -0.05382511392235756, 0.01459322776645422, 0.010928120464086533, 0.052359819412231445, 0.029613004997372627, 0.04916641116142273, 0.004569311626255512, -0.0037415693514049053, -0.012289502657949924, -0.05385644733905792, 0.035123735666275024, 0.05568055063486099, -0.031898900866508484, 0.010650763288140297, -0.03444793075323105, -0.036622025072574615, 0.007548109162598848, 0.02493566833436489, 0.0026966375298798084, -0.026163192465901375, -0.03066595084965229, -0.005609840154647827, -0.009852172806859016, 0.03284090384840965, 0.02139478363096714, 0.020991187542676926, 0.018118631094694138, 0.00316826393827796, 0.04925540089607239, 0.03779299184679985, -0.02367166243493557, -0.015546618029475212, 0.030835511162877083, -0.006860376801341772, 0.002970899688079953, -0.04126807302236557, -0.04353605955839157, 0.002877400955185294, -0.0508246049284935, 0.0023880042135715485, 0.07114318758249283, -0.02222629450261593, 0.0003260797820985317, 0.005840909201651812, 0.05879437178373337, -0.019837496802210808, -0.018627995625138283, -0.015189806930720806, 0.019400587305426598, 0.06466022878885269, 0.00783709716051817, 0.0610683374106884, 0.05593820661306381, -0.01671677641570568, 0.02332093007862568, -0.08061189204454422, 0.045807525515556335, -0.02771739847958088, -0.03700273111462593, -0.04025774449110031, -0.04400012269616127, -0.08919144421815872, 0.005280603654682636, 0.049857284873723984, -0.030169546604156494, -0.012275930494070053, 0.035740066319704056, 0.04043881595134735, -0.023123249411582947, 0.003186275949701667, 0.02792365290224552, 0.04205481708049774, 0.0786171704530716, 0.010860508307814598, 0.027723316103219986, -0.001409780466929078, 0.0049919066950678825, -0.028408875688910484, -0.037304870784282684, 0.0044404021464288235, 0.03658190369606018, 0.0694720521569252, 0.0203082375228405, 0.024988709017634392, 0.002535163890570402, -0.020047882571816444, 0.04109622538089752, -0.022833028808236122, 0.008488564752042294, -0.03842775523662567, -0.06223207712173462, -0.022905269637703896, 0.03287327289581299, 0.003932851832360029, 0.011351343244314194, -0.027075836434960365, -0.03310026600956917, -0.06517081707715988, 0.018630437552928925, 0.05066739022731781, 0.02242462895810604, -0.004110876936465502, -0.07158815860748291, 0.004178662318736315, -0.012516611255705357, 0.0023204113822430372, 0.014056740328669548, 0.05436650291085243, -0.04455438628792763, -0.014899848029017448, 0.07029033452272415, 0.01311887800693512, -0.017632266506552696, 0.020064054057002068, 0.11242315173149109, 0.05589814856648445, 0.05911383777856827, 0.045924942940473557, -0.009587723761796951, -0.018309947103261948, 0.11499421298503876, -0.023964090272784233, -0.0009540461469441652, 0.022731073200702667, 0.01783519610762596, -0.03972483426332474, -0.000968019652646035, 0.022288497537374496, -0.017808083444833755, 0.02417898364365101, 0.016516810283064842, 0.004499125760048628, -0.028000639751553535, -0.005561384372413158, -0.04966185986995697, -0.05543957278132439, -0.0012620709603652358, -0.030994614586234093, -0.005110634490847588, -0.03401642665266991, -0.015231413766741753, -0.03731813654303551, 0.009675192646682262, 0.03297002613544464, 0.008397798053920269, 0.01656309701502323, 0.026478547602891922, -0.060784220695495605, 0.0013009549584239721, 0.0387175977230072, -0.01834626868367195, -0.021051539108157158, -0.029615670442581177, 0.04673974961042404, -0.0018661852227523923, 0.03747225180268288, 0.02489333599805832, -0.017159802839159966, -0.0344422422349453, 0.022444937378168106, 0.0032363433856517076, -0.009544415399432182, -0.018308034166693687, 0.015035037882626057, -0.00013046838284935802, 0.028479427099227905, -0.03470330312848091, 0.08586503565311432, 0.057768888771533966, 0.013612275943160057, -0.022812997922301292, 0.019794490188360214, -0.021856257691979408, 0.004841468762606382, -0.05802103504538536, 0.03705942630767822, 0.008235428482294083, -0.037596695125103, 0.014377587474882603, -0.10649331659078598, -0.020259728655219078, -0.0073617552407085896, -0.05618711933493614, -0.00614597974345088, -0.009054954163730145, -0.015023448504507542, -0.003167307935655117, -0.011985656805336475, 0.07267768681049347, 0.025695394724607468, -0.02307758294045925, -0.006663811858743429, 0.02868458814918995, -0.008420374244451523, 0.041274260729551315, -0.06049063056707382, -0.03429848700761795, -0.004250767175108194, -0.020012248307466507, -0.011328711174428463, 0.02574535831809044, -0.005930417217314243, 0.0019994108006358147, -0.04723420739173889, -0.0006049263756722212, -0.006664992310106754, -0.05342370271682739, -0.038019079715013504, 0.0719425231218338, -0.041572585701942444, 0.019637756049633026, 0.025311900302767754, 0.002840132685378194, -0.018530555069446564, -0.06691917032003403, 0.03457268700003624, 0.0530090406537056, -0.00425896979868412, 0.016007382422685623, 0.002518033841624856, 0.038561660796403885, 0.014213637448847294, -0.030018368735909462, -0.005607211031019688, -0.016283869743347168, 0.03708991780877113, -0.03988421708345413, -0.021845363080501556, -0.046762678772211075, -0.037215299904346466, 0.0007853148854337633, 0.06479938328266144, 0.040834277868270874, 0.006762644741684198, 0.0019902714993804693, 0.0021056761033833027, -0.004370332229882479, -0.04027393460273743, -0.024000057950615883, -0.05858416482806206, 0.017597313970327377, -0.04514928162097931, -0.03423736244440079, -0.03649994730949402, 0.0035151084885001183, 0.024734685197472572, 0.016086827963590622, -0.029561610892415047, -0.02677314169704914, -0.010424138978123665, -0.03270387277007103, 0.009789608418941498, -0.015710508450865746, -0.04178996384143829, 0.03701817989349365, -0.0797220766544342, -0.005623235367238522, 0.006772554945200682, 0.06523112952709198, 0.049110930413007736, 0.05262713134288788, 0.0060319239273667336, 0.0037797903642058372, 0.019951017573475838, 0.004684880375862122, 0.016106057912111282, 0.0094031086191535, 0.034395549446344376, 0.001209935755468905, 0.00003941056638723239, -0.019166184589266777, -0.01731231063604355, -0.036319468170404434, 0.016366468742489815, -0.023077212274074554, 0.0020169727504253387, 0.07168084383010864, 0.04898548126220703, 0.042303666472435, 0.003268265165388584, -0.05633840337395668, 0.01734456606209278, 0.014861078932881355, -0.0004597792576532811, -0.02644539438188076, 0.033032115548849106, -0.06675540655851364, 0.04766907915472984, -0.0215065386146307, -0.02627323567867279, -0.040156301110982895, 0.07871343940496445, 0.01177684124559164, 0.020871145650744438, 0.06503360718488693, 0.07168681174516678, -0.026377132162451744, -0.05370750650763512, -0.0004720472206827253, 0.02767430990934372, 0.02314605377614498, 0.018691979348659515, -0.03061254322528839, -0.012734153307974339, 0.025920173153281212, 0.0020645102486014366, -0.0026095034554600716, -0.044012799859046936, 0.001082223141565919, 0.0192987322807312, -0.041017111390829086, -0.01575533114373684, -0.02126844972372055, 0.011112230829894543, -0.05880586430430412, -0.001439798972569406, -0.06743735820055008, 0.03380109369754791, 0.05337516590952873, 0.016074372455477715, 0.028763869777321815, -0.0417022779583931, 0.020344316959381104, 0.04288741201162338, -0.02509048953652382, -0.02780120261013508, 0.016182636842131615, -0.015190299600362778, -0.003709604265168309, 0.015156276524066925, 0.009270030073821545, 0.013269643299281597, 0.0020580990239977837, 0.07549794763326645, -0.06015334278345108, 0.05197127163410187, 0.022182336077094078, 0.006476698908954859, -0.006762336939573288, -0.04179174825549126, 0.010642160661518574, -0.06171856448054314, 0.07693617790937424, 0.0685276985168457, -0.00031824701000005007, 0.02060624025762081, -0.01563580334186554, 0.11955160647630692, 0.031119080260396004, -0.0372774638235569, -0.011809805408120155, 0.04457145184278488, -0.027867766097187996, 0.018366100266575813, 0.025379963219165802, -0.10574495792388916, 0.02514270506799221, 0.02186410129070282, -0.007490312680602074, -0.04212513566017151, -0.010000539012253284, 0.04475865140557289, -0.005564325023442507, 0.04121779277920723, -0.014595436863601208, -0.03532715141773224, -0.00014720481703989208, -0.0003364482254255563, -0.060778453946113586, -0.03021899424493313, 0.03449182212352753, -0.038589611649513245, -0.00034886522917076945, 0.06998257339000702, -0.05943448841571808, 0.016870707273483276, 0.027546031400561333, -0.040611643344163895, 0.03658450022339821, -0.03869721293449402, 0.004512218292802572, -0.039418675005435944, 0.009626250714063644, -0.0002562451409175992, 0.00857622642070055, 0.06751293689012527, -0.008721180260181427, -0.08322588354349136, 0.009170225821435452, -0.008893647231161594, 0.008161251433193684, -0.024573130533099174, 0.08423888683319092, -0.009913007728755474, -0.01963868737220764, -0.017955338582396507, 0.06472539156675339, -0.03312668949365616, -0.04353856295347214, 0.011797454208135605, -0.05755553022027016, -0.019943488761782646, 0.015227168798446655, -0.015986206009984016, 0.00046477679279632866, -0.009886176325380802, 0.015334966592490673, 0.010483196005225182, -0.008355656638741493, 0.06103594973683357, 0.03843044117093086, 0.02078826166689396, -0.021844707429409027, -0.01613408513367176, 0.02082470804452896, 0.01510979887098074, 0.06828081607818604, 0.0032777516171336174, -0.07917602360248566, -0.02522468753159046, -0.031765494495630264, -0.08236068487167358, 0.017963098362088203, 0.04377854987978935, 0.009542305022478104, -0.003935448359698057, 0.02071741595864296, 0.07190876454114914, 0.01299829687923193, 0.025202052667737007, 0.023134872317314148, -0.00398127268999815, 0.023843564093112946, -0.006039397791028023, -0.004053386393934488, 0.0027946506161242723, -0.04423588886857033, -0.019143102690577507, -0.014522404409945011, -0.0061340960673987865, 0.022589927539229393, 0.021787744015455246, -0.012818614952266216, 0.016032177954912186, -0.019356276839971542, 0.05430404096841812, 0.03979693353176117, -0.01823994144797325, -0.027010321617126465, 0.0923917293548584, 0.014383182860910892, 0.019117245450615883, -0.07661660760641098, -0.03170445188879967, -0.0034909809473901987, 0.06161697953939438, -0.049057815223932266, -0.009710568003356457, 0.016755161806941032, 0.04846487194299698, -0.0276927687227726, -0.036348093301057816, -0.04668540135025978, 0.019197901710867882, 0.037854548543691635, -0.06311293691396713, -0.018804408609867096, 0.020849592983722687, 0.0026704242918640375, -0.03697237744927406, -0.0009375950321555138, -0.05607413500547409, -0.006537226028740406, -0.01665845327079296, -0.018183346837759018, -0.033031266182661057, 0.008073488250374794, 0.04933329299092293, -0.0006291537429206073, -0.05784890800714493, -0.015020608901977539, 0.0017565523739904165, -0.004321312066167593, -0.00965783279389143, 0.025699090212583542, 0.024554358795285225, -0.07306495308876038, -0.03595384955406189, -0.023528024554252625, 0.06933020800352097, -0.013748765923082829, -0.026179896667599678, 0.012179948389530182, 0.034927111119031906, -0.02651131898164749, 0.03443251922726631, 0.0483664907515049, 0.04117974266409874, 0.050061412155628204, -0.023253707215189934, -0.012920055538415909, 0.00408955616876483, 0.04637804254889488, 0.012930824421346188, -0.06564486771821976, -0.014064432121813297, 0.007399255875498056, -0.007008225191384554, -0.010307015851140022, -0.00777836749330163, 0.004871999379247427, 0.023544086143374443, 0.005721554160118103, -0.0305216945707798, 0.014592486433684826, -0.041112374514341354, -0.02917477674782276, 0.0018466809997335076, 0.059681251645088196, -0.020477846264839172, -0.043720781803131104, -0.0025248646270483732, 0.02091181091964245, 0.06352987140417099, -0.019054003059864044, -0.01644759438931942, -0.046843841671943665, -0.06421268731355667, -0.03429989889264107, -0.0013643933925777674, 0.008660067804157734, 0.0015493989922106266, 0.06387845426797867, -0.028094276785850525, 0.04701569303870201, -0.01748736947774887, -0.0759870782494545, -0.005911803338676691, 0.022517168894410133, -0.053395625203847885, -0.06257403641939163, 0.05202415958046913, 0.053961243480443954, -0.026593152433633804, -0.03192802891135216, 0.015381982550024986, -0.04336396977305412, 0.002227026503533125, 0.022885538637638092, -0.023686213418841362, -0.013445853255689144, -0.01395901758223772, 0.0018729210132732987, -0.04072012007236481, -0.0064112721011042595, -0.018023882061243057, -0.03086833842098713, 0.007311539258807898, 0.040893785655498505, 0.004013238474726677, 0.0223478265106678, 0.028591956943273544, 0.006786329671740532, 0.06112497299909592, -0.04849390685558319, -0.05168827250599861, -0.010996183380484581, 0.04362430423498154, 0.017689689993858337, -0.07722826302051544, 0.05357758700847626, 0.02589554339647293, -0.07209151238203049, 0.008869225159287453, 0.06752994656562805, -0.0477571003139019, -0.01487258356064558, -0.014484983868896961, 0.01720578595995903, -0.033432118594646454, -0.044388871639966965, -0.012086771428585052, -0.023943621665239334, -0.015298890881240368, 0.023968612775206566, -0.05315176397562027, -0.0041564879938960075, 0.026905503123998642, -0.08653125166893005, 0.04999830573797226, -0.043329767882823944, 0.00599466310814023, 0.030071474611759186, 0.015013720840215683, -0.006655002478510141, -0.00756326038390398, 0.028936391696333885, -0.022319592535495758, 0.015022458508610725, -0.031341928988695145, -0.01517731137573719, 0.03412187099456787, 0.0017922719707712531, -0.050077784806489944, 0.004609694238752127, -0.044823020696640015, 0.02253510057926178, 0.01777646131813526, -0.045047007501125336, -0.021610738709568977, 0.00782767217606306, -0.0410001277923584, 0.02967134676873684, -0.0713215321302414, 0.0186845101416111, 0.047316163778305054, -0.011132634244859219, 0.062293194234371185, 0.0354730486869812, -0.02520439587533474, -0.030535535886883736, -0.00007710303907515481, -0.042006056755781174, -0.027986805886030197, 0.02863726019859314, -0.007208629976958036, 0.0010910766432061791, 0.02368469536304474, -0.010345847345888615, 0.03224176540970802, 0.009865186177194118, 0.055286943912506104, -0.05869944021105766, -0.014669010415673256, -0.005290613509714603, -0.02768174558877945, -0.00034702804987318814, -0.05051688849925995, 0.02198018878698349, 0.009012707509100437, -0.060371607542037964, -0.06495349109172821, -0.0204685777425766, 0.018593452870845795, -0.0542900413274765, 0.0028293493669480085, 0.002898227656260133, -0.0194113589823246, -0.025032633915543556, 0.05189719796180725, -0.005490683019161224, -0.019117342308163643, -0.010329247452318668, -0.0363796167075634, 0.04436488449573517, -0.018294643610715866, 0.02823208086192608, -0.05689064785838127, -0.01581244170665741, 0.008276265114545822, -0.0514582060277462, 0.017667297273874283, -0.06754432618618011, 0.004514387343078852, -0.024239003658294678, -0.03937076777219772, -0.07567689567804337, -0.021026011556386948, 0.024745333939790726, 0.06402725726366043, -0.02717428468167782, 0.06332855671644211, 0.06992585211992264, 0.016259435564279556, -0.014341460540890694, -0.04378647357225418, -0.091269850730896, 0.03901039436459541, -0.015145154669880867, 0.048747844994068146, -0.03266278654336929, 0.03167383000254631, -0.020327527076005936, -0.026730572804808617, 0.035166021436452866, 0.023764200508594513, -0.033708807080984116, -0.00802330207079649, 0.05645553767681122 ]
<p>If light is passed through two polarizing filters before arriving at a target, and both of the filters are oriented at 90° to each other, then no light will be received at the target. If a third filter is added between the first two, oriented at a 45° angle (as shown below), light will reach the target.</p> <p>Why is this the case? As I understand it, a polarized filter does nothing except filter out light--it does not alter the light passing through in any way. If two filters exist that will eliminate all of the light, why does the presence of a third, which should serve only to filter out additional light, actually act to allow light through?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/OogSm.png" alt="Image of three polarizers, target is at the right"></p>
g6583
[ -0.03202067315578461, -0.0010736524127423763, 0.017778214067220688, 0.017590653151273727, 0.08807948976755142, -0.0017391013680025935, -0.009568680077791214, 0.03222019970417023, -0.04093464836478233, -0.015689998865127563, -0.008096510544419289, -0.007033980451524258, -0.013344691134989262, -0.017484959214925766, -0.019092261791229248, 0.03245333209633827, 0.09441471844911575, 0.01879155822098255, 0.01685846596956253, 0.017545942217111588, -0.032408397644758224, 0.008160709403455257, -0.016858192160725594, -0.089814692735672, 0.0015027563786134124, 0.011003736406564713, 0.0015781255206093192, -0.05717150866985321, -0.005594028625637293, 0.022664563730359077, 0.024598486721515656, 0.022130297496914864, -0.027544785290956497, -0.046324945986270905, -0.02058248408138752, -0.025088531896471977, 0.06308111548423767, 0.032543182373046875, -0.022790098562836647, -0.011876503936946392, -0.00456807017326355, 0.07594312727451324, 0.02878395840525627, -0.07524330914020538, 0.013554173521697521, -0.039532776921987534, -0.019697468727827072, 0.029966268688440323, 0.024488013237714767, 0.01400682982057333, 0.00046317846863530576, -0.005078107118606567, -0.002606568858027458, 0.01920880563557148, 0.04837658256292343, 0.03710043430328369, -0.003773421049118042, -0.009051920846104622, 0.02912413328886032, 0.07353520393371582, 0.001624877448193729, 0.010181061923503876, 0.00036726819234900177, 0.023042939603328705, -0.026727192103862762, -0.028735000640153885, -0.012425433844327927, -0.04034608229994774, 0.05593123286962509, 0.08203516155481339, -0.018396509811282158, 0.013710048981010914, -0.0027985135093331337, -0.08341055363416672, 0.01110432855784893, 0.0040235500782728195, -0.0034545946400612593, 0.018720466643571854, 0.00425856513902545, 0.026388395577669144, 0.043051641434431076, -0.010700222104787827, -0.020954987034201622, 0.010161780752241611, -0.0008090741466730833, 0.04051695391535759, 0.027305487543344498, -0.037231821566820145, -0.035859014838933945, -0.06813759356737137, 0.003655478125438094, 0.04553093761205673, 0.06831619888544083, 0.006382593419402838, -0.06833876669406891, 0.016098398715257645, -0.012275326997041702, 0.032835837453603745, -0.0014367433032020926, 0.08812680095434189, 0.009035248309373856, 0.04069966822862625, 0.019374655559659004, 0.04691991209983826, 0.01685268059372902, -0.027328915894031525, 0.07295721769332886, 0.06755488365888596, -0.025117116048932076, -0.011438644491136074, -0.12888412177562714, -0.05964692682027817, -0.034134671092033386, -0.06674425303936005, -0.01609882153570652, -0.021392444148659706, 0.0759972408413887, -0.01313976850360632, 0.047374527901411057, 0.026069222018122673, 0.04552105814218521, 0.03264695778489113, -0.025838594883680344, 0.05491048842668533, -0.014884404838085175, 0.042485032230615616, 0.006510129664093256, 0.03500930592417717, 0.020394861698150635, -0.04575642943382263, 0.024883706122636795, 0.0033824427518993616, 0.02018149569630623, 0.006110809743404388, -0.0005908161401748657, -0.016486214473843575, 0.029485531151294708, -0.002951580099761486, 0.018675215542316437, 0.008977443911135197, -0.0188438780605793, -0.03979356586933136, 0.020473452284932137, -0.017285026609897614, -0.006548983510583639, -0.022500021383166313, -0.033699098974466324, 0.01233657356351614, 0.04156794026494026, -0.012279174290597439, 0.010668763890862465, 0.04661067575216293, 0.025499707087874413, 0.03747869282960892, -0.01889972947537899, -0.03329962491989136, 0.010374765843153, -0.06266535073518753, -0.024741115048527718, 0.026297608390450478, 0.036245621740818024, 0.007058354094624519, -0.017886629328131676, -0.0025807868223637342, -0.04005569964647293, 0.028877006843686104, 0.02886176109313965, -0.10511956363916397, -0.07813961803913116, -0.03362162783741951, -0.055761225521564484, 0.022827187553048134, 0.007836145348846912, 0.02886858955025673, 0.026322398334741592, 0.09786497056484222, 0.07427051663398743, 0.03929579257965088, 0.03066994808614254, 0.02407342940568924, -0.10460884869098663, 0.0025635017082095146, -0.029595838859677315, 0.0047342199832201, -0.04730673134326935, -0.04410131648182869, 0.02119598537683487, 0.040819328278303146, -0.10131464153528214, 0.03074253909289837, 0.03225603699684143, -0.008898735046386719, -0.004071117378771305, -0.025166047737002373, -0.06060073524713516, -0.01671488955616951, -0.03516687452793121, 0.009441091679036617, 0.0036812967155128717, 0.017341306433081627, -0.02079438418149948, 0.004135375376790762, 0.003026006743311882, -0.005150658078491688, 0.010452084243297577, 0.012404045090079308, -0.0043199323117733, -0.005108298268169165, 0.005326586775481701, -0.017483768984675407, -0.054819975048303604, -0.020160051062703133, 0.01573871076107025, -0.013743235729634762, -0.018643036484718323, 0.005715053994208574, 0.01807309500873089, 0.07111147791147232, -0.006504247896373272, 0.01669352315366268, -0.009616188704967499, -0.009622708894312382, -0.037657514214515686, -0.02358412742614746, -0.04729562625288963, 0.0025972339790314436, -0.10868419706821442, -0.013526177033782005, -0.007969801314175129, 0.05258709564805031, -0.027423016726970673, -0.03808823227882385, 0.06281120330095291, 0.01031265314668417, 0.01796269789338112, 0.03542167320847511, -0.028230316936969757, -0.01135723665356636, 0.036077167838811874, 0.04210929200053215, -0.022746330127120018, 0.02678575925529003, 0.008314736187458038, 0.011076080612838268, 0.10952479392290115, -0.02737601101398468, 0.002247368451207876, -0.012316202744841576, -0.026647189632058144, 0.04274040460586548, 0.009504285641014576, 0.04151419177651405, -0.01067599467933178, -0.006140417885035276, -0.022499702870845795, -0.025881126523017883, 0.018629761412739754, -0.01202907133847475, -0.027015693485736847, -0.007185790687799454, -0.008036229759454727, -0.03996742144227028, 0.04521820694208145, -0.025173768401145935, -0.03585169464349747, -0.00805110763758421, 0.024213101714849472, 0.0047830319963395596, 0.028776124119758606, -0.021893998607993126, -0.06676089018583298, 0.058623261749744415, 0.09097515791654587, 0.016125572845339775, -0.003153839847072959, 0.0192821454256773, -0.058085035532712936, 0.0046019055880606174, -0.0256936214864254, 0.04766148701310158, -0.029027795419096947, 0.07794138044118881, -0.023677712306380272, -0.03477051481604576, 0.03716906160116196, -0.023550011217594147, 0.06293033808469772, 0.02263837866485119, -0.008676688186824322, 0.0031866307836025953, -0.0603913851082325, 0.027212055400013924, 0.014780297875404358, -0.04335935413837433, 0.029019670560956, -0.02106723003089428, -0.0030911772046238184, -0.07574585825204849, -0.033379435539245605, 0.04600749537348747, -0.03874976933002472, 0.0669005736708641, 0.02738007716834545, -0.0766172781586647, 0.04731295257806778, -0.031574368476867676, -0.02850533276796341, -0.03130071237683296, -0.02588716335594654, 0.052694570273160934, 0.007579620461910963, 0.02677055448293686, -0.05595669522881508, 0.036631010472774506, 0.06489913910627365, -0.022168194875121117, -0.0524454191327095, -0.011802375316619873, -0.01709534227848053, 0.06676021963357925, 0.02976178005337715, 0.06895116716623306, -0.0405004546046257, -0.0037878609728068113, 0.04643300175666809, -0.029273543506860733, 0.0035450970754027367, 0.03922618553042412, 0.0008633218239992857, 0.000030079101634328254, 0.04893273860216141, -0.01828519068658352, -0.0052499230951070786, -0.003998869098722935, -0.01878809742629528, 0.021220125257968903, -0.017662011086940765, 0.044498004019260406, 0.026390932500362396, -0.04079693928360939, 0.03266468271613121, 0.02353418804705143, -0.08058568090200424, -0.027251802384853363, -0.015730304643511772, -0.014648281037807465, 0.012137805111706257, -0.016208622604608536, -0.012244662269949913, -0.012940682470798492, 0.012790591455996037, -0.0008427775464951992, 0.007796700112521648, 0.012787094339728355, -0.07455999404191971, -0.0030262910295277834, -0.03611773997545242, 0.05519925057888031, 0.02567135915160179, 0.013708369806408882, -0.00909832026809454, 0.013014396652579308, -0.027073821052908897, -0.0301798265427351, -0.0024440379347652197, 0.03081323206424713, -0.0074468450620770454, -0.044403284788131714, -0.017248978838324547, 0.0007631256012246013, 0.03625231236219406, -0.0431511364877224, -0.021458959206938744, -0.024979954585433006, 0.03097505494952202, -0.0449836365878582, 0.030619055032730103, 0.06414392590522766, -0.0732269138097763, 0.027577005326747894, 0.033137720078229904, -0.0009195134625770152, 0.02506467141211033, 0.005113024264574051, 0.042026761919260025, 0.018306035548448563, -0.026074828580021858, -0.025724364444613457, -0.03879544138908386, -0.01725197024643421, -0.06479725241661072, 0.04662354663014412, -0.012254052795469761, 0.018231788650155067, 0.027237365022301674, -0.020540930330753326, 0.00017144769662991166, -0.09285492449998856, 0.02171834371984005, 0.013262302614748478, 0.038917675614356995, 0.005625923629850149, -0.0375852957367897, -0.014133147895336151, -0.03435933217406273, -0.01624627225100994, 0.01347880344837904, 0.03573628515005112, -0.003950466401875019, 0.02763945981860161, -0.025344787165522575, 0.029828164726495743, -0.021638276055455208, -0.03024166449904442, 0.04880741611123085, -0.014521608129143715, -0.021484142169356346, 0.0270891971886158, 0.00508761964738369, -0.015577390789985657, 0.03501678258180618, 0.009847724810242653, 0.00343122985213995, 0.009966486133635044, -0.01617642305791378, 0.04808942601084709, 0.018802395090460777, -0.06437516957521439, 0.021036293357610703, -0.01522828172892332, 0.0012274787295609713, -0.0038658634293824434, 0.001645055366680026, 0.04956641420722008, 0.02104853466153145, -0.0133796576410532, -0.07437959313392639, 0.04617821052670479, 0.008428406901657581, 0.058131635189056396, 0.009202282875776291, 0.007584648206830025, -0.05016111955046654, -0.04205423966050148, 0.013683075085282326, -0.03588670864701271, 0.020547427237033844, 0.02276655286550522, 0.021582579240202904, -0.013581421226263046, -0.00859206635504961, -0.027389897033572197, -0.0625913217663765, 0.0035783243365585804, -0.08374475687742233, 0.025107301771640778, 0.006987367756664753, 0.038244180381298065, 0.011394551955163479, 0.04147128760814667, -0.050773441791534424, -0.008192368783056736, -0.0541035458445549, -0.050695061683654785, 0.036325789988040924, 0.0037809412460774183, 0.033203113824129105, -0.03050416335463524, -0.05783737078309059, 0.052271559834480286, -0.015692727640271187, 0.041800107806921005, -0.035410717129707336, 0.10179702937602997, -0.021122848615050316, -0.003326397156342864, -0.013058739714324474, -0.00978909619152546, -0.008739463984966278, -0.0329003781080246, 0.0036254138685762882, -0.08234874904155731, 0.024468209594488144, -0.021787257865071297, -0.02081567607820034, -0.0009451598743908107, 0.0022027373779565096, 0.054538749158382416, -0.02878035046160221, -0.0260469950735569, 0.03897792100906372, 0.0069771017879247665, -0.05408599600195885, -0.01565662771463394, 0.0009214418823830783, 0.07393443584442139, 0.0521780289709568, 0.025340542197227478, 0.03900112584233284, -0.03086494840681553, -0.032116908580064774, 0.0009706640266813338, -0.016676755622029305, -0.036511585116386414, -0.011494298465549946, 0.006581638008356094, 0.032312795519828796, -0.07289359718561172, 0.01860528066754341, 0.038837533444166183, 0.007095443084836006, -0.07693009078502655, 0.00922754779458046, 0.041812341660261154, 0.004967654123902321, -0.007485082373023033, 0.0009540639584884048, -0.00502515584230423, -0.0030909166671335697, 0.020335352048277855, -0.0219432283192873, -0.01727948896586895, -0.06556545197963715, -0.019142035394906998, 0.030855907127261162, 0.010814446024596691, -0.05810016766190529, -0.003726388094946742, 0.029958514496684074, 0.019158661365509033, -0.024665629491209984, 0.019915824756026268, 0.045243557542562485, 0.025702983140945435, 0.03872260823845863, -0.06133303418755531, 0.02116984874010086, -0.003280806588009, 0.0407274030148983, 0.016234060749411583, -0.03658850118517876, -0.04101845249533653, 0.023073920980095863, 0.11750004440546036, -0.0010273945517838001, -0.0012793850619345903, 0.010468901135027409, -0.015105259604752064, 0.0020794998854398727, -0.01726572960615158, -0.006796419154852629, 0.016075175255537033, -0.05081366002559662, -0.007926898077130318, 0.028778310865163803, 0.02330077812075615, -0.02435361221432686, -0.013948989100754261, 0.025262154638767242, -0.0964018926024437, 0.013592571020126343, 0.00525549054145813, -0.01865537278354168, -0.007895291782915592, -0.006917324382811785, -0.007723918650299311, -0.04404442012310028, 0.048771705478429794, -0.00328428135253489, 0.019297588616609573, -0.007441623602062464, -0.07672692835330963, -0.002235199324786663, 0.07994353771209717, 0.04799140617251396, 0.040322646498680115, -0.03775038942694664, -0.02859368547797203, -0.01761782169342041, 0.029521482065320015, 0.043326485902071, 0.003154108300805092, 0.015280956402420998, -0.03090638481080532, 0.033761538565158844, 0.027519335970282555, -0.0694003701210022, -0.0064330995082855225, 0.06754039973020554, -0.056322015821933746, -0.03485669568181038, -0.030305545777082443, -0.03375235199928284, -0.05035412684082985, -0.01443751435726881, -0.05235118791460991, 0.030890677124261856, 0.083740234375, -0.019475718960165977, -0.020018165931105614, 0.028848355636000633, -0.02246670238673687, 0.08820945769548416, -0.041429873555898666, 0.015572085976600647, 0.0320608913898468, -0.0337502546608448, -0.07164692133665085, 0.029167452827095985, -0.009849650785326958, 0.00759643642231822, 0.031635843217372894, -0.04319683089852333, 0.04132001847028732, -0.019977521151304245, -0.023341916501522064, -0.0914246067404747, -0.038865357637405396, 0.009362264536321163, 0.014681205153465271, -0.013286317698657513, -0.020718542858958244, -0.019054453819990158, -0.05346974730491638, -0.026980258524417877, 0.013034126721322536, 0.016215255483984947, -0.014134182594716549, 0.005649021826684475, 0.120200514793396, -0.005246151238679886, -0.022284507751464844, 0.030526455491781235, -0.008127888664603233, 0.03368135541677475, -0.03769414871931076, -0.023683026432991028, 0.00007162900146795437, 0.050118789076805115, 0.07752304524183273, 0.009750042110681534, 0.024503760039806366, 0.012175064533948898, 0.0404454804956913, 0.006774649024009705, 0.04114411771297455, 0.008522739633917809, -0.055423300713300705, -0.04941935837268829, -0.0028586327098309994, -0.044968657195568085, -0.02889472432434559, 0.024166682735085487, 0.03743675351142883, -0.022475924342870712, 0.010448027402162552, 0.0086162518709898, -0.0046869744546711445, 0.0022485924419015646, -0.0024679882917553186, -0.029131503775715828, -0.049967266619205475, -0.05507904291152954, 0.004818239714950323, -0.011035428382456303, 0.023584552109241486, 0.037767443805933, -0.03689638152718544, -0.0023017856292426586, -0.013763200491666794, -0.05282408744096756, -0.015313232317566872, 0.0442197322845459, 0.02030845358967781, -0.019877981394529343, -0.006427417974919081, 0.007070643827319145, -0.004146489314734936, 0.027449050918221474, -0.008389889262616634, 0.013608194887638092, 0.03561357036232948, 0.00948470737785101, -0.07560398429632187, -0.03839613124728203, -0.0015680656069889665, 0.027424613013863564, -0.023917822167277336, -0.02792816422879696, -0.009688870050013065, 0.008593020029366016, 0.024902474135160446, 0.009743094444274902, -0.022736040875315666, -0.018080895766615868, 0.04098622128367424, 0.02758045494556427, 0.017312079668045044, 0.004470366053283215, 0.015125890262424946, -0.0026106408331543207, -0.025358740240335464, -0.0006476356065832078, -0.06623109430074692, 0.09063615649938583, 0.016564397141337395, 0.028358280658721924, -0.005786707624793053, 0.031758200377225876, 0.009872794151306152, -0.02839970961213112, 0.02025659941136837, 0.00449306471273303, 0.02101605013012886, -0.04830249771475792, -0.014259838499128819, -0.02136390469968319, 0.012398716993629932, -0.03204081580042839, -0.059533629566431046, 0.014154651202261448, 0.052150968462228775, -0.029107704758644104, -0.014405970461666584, -0.003318456467241049, 0.03752496838569641, 0.039066132158041, 0.0013008808018639684, 0.04084799438714981, 0.020401325076818466, 0.03004729188978672, 0.011265840381383896, -0.05979152023792267, 0.034459326416254044, -0.02642683871090412, 0.0344865657389164, -0.001436946913599968, -0.02744612656533718, 0.027870582416653633, -0.002313298173248768, 0.04269513115286827, 0.01666162721812725, 0.003759864019230008, -0.04846983402967453, 0.0437048077583313, 0.007052361499518156, 0.010207908228039742, -0.0055846781469881535, 0.025910470634698868, -0.020820695906877518, 0.0016390822129324079, 0.06198393926024437, -0.009729060344398022, 0.027907559648156166, 0.03297897055745125, -0.06350208073854446, -0.009582752361893654, -0.04392353445291519, 0.018580876290798187, -0.033521875739097595, -0.0015034552197903395, -0.052412454038858414, -0.04209546744823456, -0.05359162017703056, -0.006185754202306271, 0.006869847886264324, -0.0560750812292099, 0.015081445686519146 ]
<p>New question: In string theory and QFT, do particles travel back in time? Not related to antimatter: Do they travel back and forth in time in reality or are these just interpretations of mathematical formulas used to make sense of calculations?</p> <p>This is a different question (<a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/58101">from this one</a>) as it concerns strings and not antimatter...</p>
g6584
[ 0.03232550248503685, 0.018125416710972786, 0.016499638557434082, -0.028390252962708473, 0.06159447506070137, -0.0010901890927925706, 0.01088036224246025, -0.016569875180721283, -0.061708223074674606, 0.015111149288713932, -0.031813450157642365, 0.07800659537315369, 0.000313769793137908, -0.031871993094682693, -0.09399478882551193, -0.010130876675248146, 0.04834650456905365, 0.07438062131404877, 0.00968827772885561, 0.002380777383223176, 0.042696792632341385, 0.043025095015764236, -0.01685248129069805, -0.03532063215970993, -0.0017409124411642551, 0.0025259831454604864, -0.022133756428956985, -0.020217543467879295, -0.04395756497979164, -0.03788205236196518, 0.08084375411272049, -0.011205049231648445, 0.02488800883293152, -0.08593685925006866, -0.004879650194197893, -0.0776553526520729, 0.02154652029275894, -0.020153488963842392, 0.04209912195801735, 0.0214996375143528, 0.022957446053624153, -0.015512321144342422, 0.01041177473962307, 0.0331227071583271, 0.03925139829516411, 0.06381373107433319, -0.03336697444319725, -0.004326525144279003, -0.04847900569438934, -0.03251517936587334, -0.04637710005044937, 0.016904130578041077, 0.025743573904037476, 0.04937836900353432, -0.050344645977020264, -0.004889822565019131, 0.055293720215559006, -0.04443893954157829, 0.10833708941936493, 0.04683145508170128, -0.05183190852403641, 0.025160223245620728, -0.007201285567134619, -0.0016532668378204107, 0.04763864725828171, -0.02065367065370083, -0.042524971067905426, -0.009764374233782291, -0.018490782007575035, 0.021939804777503014, 0.06531179696321487, -0.023859767243266106, -0.032770898193120956, -0.0016323502641171217, 0.002695264294743538, 0.0712980106472969, 0.018343856558203697, -0.02931852638721466, -0.006846440490335226, 0.011277146637439728, -0.045563437044620514, -0.032067690044641495, -0.0081308763474226, 0.035106390714645386, 0.05961991101503372, -0.07729015499353409, -0.0007465613889507949, 0.04637933149933815, 0.01134431641548872, 0.008915397338569164, -0.04589015245437622, -0.03228899836540222, 0.042000364512205124, 0.007079167291522026, 0.002646791748702526, -0.03218691051006317, -0.016765553504228592, 0.013029307126998901, -0.03917495906352997, 0.0037329557817429304, -0.035092953592538834, 0.0454256646335125, 0.012326422147452831, 0.03387042507529259, 0.0269948560744524, -0.04425881430506706, 0.08073204755783081, -0.02688690461218357, 0.016698792576789856, 0.03421584144234657, -0.053378090262413025, 0.005015412345528603, -0.01619771681725979, -0.0028479639440774918, -0.06223239377140999, 0.02146480232477188, 0.004838034976273775, -0.033613622188568115, -0.004943307489156723, 0.04150589555501938, -0.001955469837412238, -0.00443502701818943, 0.053135477006435394, -0.00359880062751472, -0.037092722952365875, 0.0029029008001089096, -0.04758213460445404, -0.021034888923168182, -0.03574804961681366, 0.008798415772616863, -0.041618239134550095, 0.00800230260938406, 0.024396883323788643, 0.06095755472779274, -0.022953666746616364, 0.0324675589799881, 0.009161673486232758, -0.007155550643801689, -0.009541441686451435, 0.0027067784685641527, 0.05526379495859146, -0.06461121886968613, -0.015607181005179882, -0.04355017468333244, -0.05300241336226463, 0.02046443149447441, -0.020776713266968727, -0.040520742535591125, -0.01830214448273182, 0.06185508146882057, 0.035687413066625595, 0.07780791074037552, -0.016487352550029755, 0.018030576407909393, 0.07207409292459488, 0.002767964033409953, 0.00369880348443985, 0.009572216309607029, -0.04037339240312576, -0.011126545257866383, 0.06012320891022682, 0.015554476529359818, 0.004653473384678364, -0.011306868866086006, -0.01471518911421299, 0.006225180812180042, -0.010009914636611938, -0.054112497717142105, 0.02668723836541176, -0.08399256318807602, -0.03155079483985901, 0.011215227656066418, 0.020798737183213234, 0.018999837338924408, -0.003747506532818079, 0.004274776671081781, -0.015168128535151482, -0.010744315572082996, -0.05860263481736183, -0.0626324936747551, -0.017556585371494293, 0.027912890538573265, 0.008414579555392265, -0.014562513679265976, -0.03592728450894356, 0.0067555406130850315, -0.041876453906297684, 0.007333222310990095, -0.05538373813033104, -0.004262452945113182, -0.0169571153819561, 0.008285598829388618, -0.023642031475901604, -0.0028707184828817844, 0.02476818673312664, -0.058200158178806305, -0.028533831238746643, 0.01564967818558216, -0.009083042852580547, 0.029974669218063354, 0.04774293303489685, 0.039037615060806274, 0.05656060948967934, -0.062680684030056, 0.0944567397236824, 0.004882461857050657, -0.02069181017577648, -0.04315652698278427, 0.03765251487493515, -0.04218214377760887, 0.0352090559899807, 0.06618255376815796, 0.021345172077417374, 0.0414634570479393, -0.059311773627996445, -0.02075325697660446, -0.017624307423830032, -0.012667698785662651, 0.009150892496109009, 0.031716130673885345, -0.011448201723396778, -0.014877397567033768, 0.07485964894294739, -0.03462522104382515, -0.03500733897089958, 0.01262167189270258, -0.01945316232740879, -0.03794889524579048, -0.05004607513546944, 0.024659786373376846, -0.0835610181093216, 0.009022909216582775, -0.07484923303127289, -0.030971288681030273, 0.06317997723817825, -0.018436497077345848, -0.015179549343883991, -0.0320354662835598, 0.10344698280096054, 0.023172251880168915, 0.013377571478486061, 0.02827501855790615, -0.043590594083070755, 0.015894228592514992, 0.05470583215355873, -0.05143172666430473, 0.012631281279027462, 0.014519707299768925, -0.025549722835421562, 0.03453551232814789, 0.057091400027275085, -0.024609943851828575, -0.06642945855855942, 0.04659538343548775, 0.0030259164050221443, -0.02036353014409542, 0.024141700938344002, 0.0009422620059922338, -0.06681139767169952, -0.02831445448100567, 0.013896043412387371, 0.007632025517523289, -0.008202475495636463, -0.017731573432683945, -0.009173099882900715, -0.023905325680971146, -0.019211841747164726, 0.030561214312911034, -0.025437450036406517, -0.009579450823366642, -0.05264133960008621, 0.016184240579605103, 0.08582786470651627, -0.00711653009057045, 0.018705707043409348, -0.002737760543823242, 0.018313193693757057, 0.011521325446665287, 0.01987796276807785, -0.013545658439397812, -0.0218159519135952, -0.034213948994874954, -0.021031208336353302, -0.022938279435038567, -0.024039631709456444, -0.07457900047302246, 0.02577180415391922, -0.027078360319137573, -0.012934621423482895, 0.011399712413549423, 0.004763553384691477, -0.0019393105758354068, 0.04057300463318825, 0.016317907720804214, -0.033758580684661865, 0.09187429398298264, 0.06582800298929214, -0.04984511435031891, -0.00529449200257659, 0.06260417401790619, -0.043664950877428055, -0.0026863468810915947, 0.020923813804984093, 0.01801038347184658, 0.05488079786300659, 0.03051762655377388, -0.0644611194729805, -0.040865518152713776, -0.027240412309765816, -0.026744194328784943, -0.012683108448982239, 0.07432693243026733, 0.005911257583647966, 0.022342924028635025, 0.018995223566889763, 0.02246589958667755, -0.026855096220970154, 0.03577449172735214, 0.03452933207154274, -0.007600064855068922, -0.04058035835623741, -0.025815390050411224, 0.026233430951833725, -0.023904332891106606, 0.006052239332348108, -0.028100168332457542, -0.03927147760987282, 0.007085402030497789, -0.07768891006708145, -0.06321434676647186, -0.022083571180701256, -0.051935747265815735, 0.012300034984946251, -0.019596407189965248, -0.03557204827666283, -0.016577066853642464, 0.025897441431879997, 0.02906757965683937, -0.032641030848026276, 0.03323689475655556, -0.034946903586387634, -0.0302407406270504, 0.05352426692843437, 0.0340367816388607, 0.031024154275655746, 0.0659521222114563, 0.023747704923152924, 0.04549597576260567, 0.02592972107231617, 0.025932548567652702, 0.013462251052260399, 0.049977850168943405, 0.037733294069767, 0.052184395492076874, -0.009108527563512325, 0.02432766556739807, 0.007348527666181326, 0.05807816982269287, 0.052203137427568436, -0.02295246347784996, -0.030349571257829666, 0.0016815396957099438, -0.013173308223485947, 0.02350199595093727, 0.014917825348675251, -0.03778557851910591, 0.03718053922057152, 0.00697097834199667, 0.05007900297641754, -0.017340868711471558, 0.04461243748664856, 0.031288694590330124, -0.012750416062772274, 0.038908541202545166, -0.01381445862352848, 0.000246381969191134, 0.03974620997905731, 0.0017636765260249376, -0.019137367606163025, 0.008064817637205124, 0.04116182401776314, 0.044066257774829865, 0.030649492517113686, -0.008001811802387238, 0.04441126435995102, 0.019350165501236916, -0.050172194838523865, -0.034855931997299194, -0.04065237194299698, -0.025243759155273438, -0.00036127661587670445, 0.03433024138212204, -0.010444367304444313, -0.06081990897655487, -0.019964663311839104, -0.013052061200141907, 0.01497588586062193, -0.031681716442108154, 0.011715472675859928, -0.044489942491054535, 0.016059666872024536, 0.0437246598303318, -0.054570939391851425, -0.019144607707858086, -0.02924489974975586, 0.003822166472673416, 0.03410536050796509, -0.091905377805233, -0.011365171521902084, -0.017676690593361855, -0.05147438123822212, -0.02779368869960308, -0.027002127841114998, -0.04084360599517822, 0.020332850515842438, 0.0030583341140300035, -0.0008235645364038646, 0.0072411224246025085, -0.02385244145989418, -0.02860374189913273, 0.03877278044819832, -0.005111176986247301, 0.02030286192893982, -0.005259215831756592, -0.04006824642419815, 0.042959436774253845, 0.02875468321144581, -0.011409019120037556, -0.03172827512025833, -0.027816995978355408, 0.017234530299901962, 0.028002025559544563, -0.00023332001001108438, 0.01891382597386837, -0.03664378449320793, 0.04718629643321037, 0.004131538327783346, 0.04764394834637642, 0.09190391004085541, -0.04643063619732857, 0.059025608003139496, 0.018069138750433922, 0.03180953860282898, -0.034143611788749695, -0.060104597359895706, 0.027380140498280525, -0.0669708102941513, -0.02703959308564663, -0.005355767905712128, -0.021011337637901306, -0.05996573343873024, 0.06709816306829453, -0.032842013984918594, 0.005699990317225456, -0.0383792370557785, -0.015061002224683762, 0.008147945627570152, -0.03865651413798332, 0.02438521757721901, 0.03795117512345314, -0.07076562196016312, 0.009744148701429367, 0.04275577515363693, 0.03373191878199577, -0.03563600778579712, -0.014217069372534752, -0.01362567488104105, -0.010960518382489681, -0.030055364593863487, 0.028996312990784645, -0.03302304074168205, 0.024279115721583366, 0.004602787550538778, -0.03875213861465454, -0.012973520904779434, -0.05740069970488548, 0.019686704501509666, 0.014161596074700356, -0.021290022879838943, -0.024405086413025856, -0.011691352352499962, 0.018060453236103058, 0.03996714577078819, -0.024671262130141258, -0.02262779138982296, 0.07292650640010834, -0.018876569345593452, 0.05071742460131645, -0.003617999842390418, -0.053965747356414795, -0.017642883583903313, -0.04960327968001366, 0.04801426827907562, -0.025304557755589485, -0.006653327960520983, -0.017305493354797363, 0.006305979564785957, 0.03348150849342346, -0.05142996087670326, -0.02194107137620449, 0.007178933825343847, 0.014173083007335663, 0.0044848499819636345, 0.027142930775880814, -0.003809899790212512, 0.060365431010723114, 0.01808318682014942, -0.004993983078747988, -0.05980550870299339, -0.04320771247148514, 0.08596935123205185, 0.03019486926496029, -0.07478242367506027, 0.005034642294049263, 0.04780273139476776, 0.025054361671209335, -0.014134403318166733, 0.012118443846702576, 0.04875437542796135, -0.02477641962468624, -0.05998751521110535, 0.08321073651313782, 0.03464927524328232, -0.029125597327947617, 0.013521343469619751, 0.0010365619091317058, -0.047725629061460495, -0.03172783926129341, -0.005133185535669327, 0.03455251827836037, -0.009698480367660522, -0.010863934643566608, 0.0413636639714241, -0.0021250310819596052, -0.01386045478284359, 0.014127437956631184, -0.008160443976521492, -0.039918649941682816, 0.030916182324290276, 0.013309984467923641, -0.06728676706552505, 0.03152167424559593, -0.0063920048996806145, 0.058074090629816055, -0.0496797040104866, 0.0042479862459003925, 0.007258185185492039, -0.01625203527510166, 0.0901484340429306, -0.07602567970752716, -0.004014444537460804, 0.03893623873591423, -0.045430149883031845, -0.020391590893268585, 0.017504844814538956, 0.05104372650384903, -0.004357509780675173, -0.02099669724702835, -0.003432691562920809, 0.012327861040830612, -0.02206871472299099, 0.004284500144422054, 0.029087817296385765, 0.012518943287432194, 0.004784118849784136, -0.049113284796476364, 0.01430068351328373, -0.03997717425227165, 0.048755161464214325, -0.0017709247767925262, 0.07426875084638596, 0.0021046698093414307, -0.02026510052382946, 0.006611540447920561, 0.023657970130443573, 0.004997038748115301, -0.03356567770242691, -0.11226103454828262, -0.05192827805876732, -0.033454880118370056, 0.024435151368379593, 0.028780415654182434, 0.0183233805000782, -0.007692779880017042, -0.03144630417227745, 0.028742456808686256, -0.04428728669881821, 0.010543645359575748, 0.04284549877047539, -0.0071279797703027725, -0.04604529216885567, -0.021920382976531982, -0.05899947136640549, -0.007639020681381226, -0.04040544107556343, 0.0233190655708313, -0.0009542744373902678, 0.01670968346297741, -0.04641501605510712, 0.003927720710635185, 0.00811306107789278, 0.017543036490678787, 0.05482454225420952, -0.004193010739982128, 0.04438190162181854, 0.026474222540855408, 0.037377916276454926, 0.043125398457050323, 0.010253079235553741, -0.02071889489889145, 0.04277632012963295, -0.00953148864209652, 0.023282092064619064, 0.07861621677875519, 0.004755530506372452, 0.00007554960757261142, -0.022008728235960007, 0.030465340241789818, -0.03641090914607048, 0.008486158214509487, 0.038467828184366226, -0.029205026105046272, -0.027087567374110222, -0.03863700479269028, 0.01727239042520523, 0.04201420396566391, -0.00523833092302084, 0.07188203930854797, 0.03868177533149719, -0.015880778431892395, -0.0036842881236225367, 0.012039946392178535, 0.008056564256548882, 0.01711130701005459, -0.0030772630125284195, -0.03316401317715645, -0.024245573207736015, 0.01392071321606636, -0.10772956162691116, 0.06583203375339508, -0.0312657356262207, 0.011379888281226158, 0.013287961483001709, -0.012824641540646553, -0.04734192043542862, -0.0031827103812247515, 0.08533012121915817, -0.018932541832327843, -0.01875750906765461, -0.009816843084990978, 0.056383807212114334, -0.030077839270234108, -0.061844728887081146, 0.017715804278850555, -0.003914537839591503, -0.05374681577086449, -0.01439586840569973, 0.07993202656507492, 0.040406234562397, -0.034251999109983444, -0.043335165828466415, -0.026793472468852997, -0.03387352079153061, 0.030658196657896042, 0.011695384979248047, 0.015085576102137566, 0.03617268055677414, -0.051702823489904404, 0.032151319086551666, 0.006550149526447058, -0.018502259626984596, 0.007591296918690205, 0.005012595560401678, -0.0006566442316398025, 0.0035936045460402966, -0.026509564369916916, -0.024783268570899963, 0.041328754276037216, -0.007247419562190771, 0.07015857100486755, 0.0645742192864418, 0.00017230572120752186, 0.009864318184554577, 0.012297584675252438, 0.0016854205168783665, 0.05902687460184097, -0.040029700845479965, -0.00542595935985446, -0.03494489565491676, -0.009191387332975864, 0.05208232253789902, 0.006297444924712181, -0.007332090754061937, -0.014980358071625233, 0.03570808470249176, 0.0042333160527050495, 0.06991709768772125, 0.023899821564555168, 0.0467386357486248, -0.01956842839717865, -0.03794366866350174, 0.011387629434466362, 0.025463350117206573, -0.00374310789629817, 0.03364250808954239, -0.06179841235280037, 0.02247067540884018, -0.009466414339840412, -0.10433345288038254, -0.0004427618405316025, -0.05143946781754494, 0.04837079718708992, 0.035796258598566055, 0.052209705114364624, 0.053261611610651016, 0.008442521095275879, 0.007746166083961725, -0.013337569311261177, 0.0017458279617130756, -0.029649905860424042, -0.001289824489504099, 0.004906284622848034, -0.02638496272265911, -0.021272476762533188, -0.03307964280247688, -0.02977137453854084, -0.008780624717473984, -0.03477668762207031, 0.017520546913146973, -0.012387154623866081, 0.007684207521378994, 0.011765697039663792, -0.07401508837938309, 0.0349087193608284, -0.011603530496358871, 0.030045967549085617, -0.017328040674328804, -0.030363032594323158, -0.011571964249014854, -0.002162604359909892, 0.034825604408979416, -0.023282095789909363, 0.004764963407069445, -0.0008865197887644172, -0.06632903963327408, -0.0408199280500412, -0.037170302122831345, 0.010156027041375637, 0.019828785210847855, -0.0232185497879982, 0.04021086171269417, 0.02473880909383297, -0.007294406183063984, 0.057278361171483994, 0.041665468364953995, -0.017392799258232117, 0.0077545843087136745, 0.025928597897291183, -0.0021011261269450188, -0.0015503756003454328, -0.0052724299021065235, -0.04098298028111458, 0.01795957237482071, 0.0023067607544362545, -0.0023280559107661247, 0.013331451453268528, -0.03174000605940819, 0.01489815954118967 ]
<p>The first <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chern_class" rel="nofollow">Chern number</a> $\cal C$ is known to be related to various physical objects.</p> <ol> <li><p>Gauge fields are known as connections of some principle bundles. In particular, principle $U(1)$ bundle is said to be classified by first Chern number. In terms of electromagnetic field, ${\cal C} \neq 0$ is equivalent to the existence of monopoles. </p></li> <li><p>In the case of integer quantum Hall states, Chern number is simply the Hall conductance up to a constant.</p></li> </ol> <p>In both physical problems, Chern number is related to vorticity -- a quantized value (first case, Dirac's string argument and second, vortices in magnetic Brillouin zone).</p> <p>Then my questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>What was the "physical" picture in Chern's mind when he originally "dreamed up" the theory? (Maybe knots, but how?)</p></li> <li><p>If I want to learn how Chern classified $U(1)$ bundles using integers (first Chern number), which books or papers should I refer to?</p></li> </ol> <p>Notes: </p> <p>My point is that mathematical theorems are not God-given but arose from concrete problems. I was asking what was <em>the original problem</em> that Chern solved, from which he codified the general theorems? And Chern number seems related to vorticity and then what are the corresponding vortices in his problem?</p>
g6585
[ 0.05678887665271759, 0.013434289954602718, -0.0025749702472239733, -0.019769055768847466, 0.07207512855529785, -0.004494502674788237, 0.08271199464797974, 0.004560495261102915, -0.023972725495696068, 0.004535512533038855, -0.07762087136507034, 0.01647045463323593, -0.021957064047455788, 0.03285503759980202, 0.050452426075935364, -0.05986406281590462, -0.025011809542775154, -0.01584644615650177, 0.011693336069583893, -0.1005064994096756, 0.009723718278110027, 0.04690247401595116, 0.019838847219944, -0.053260933607816696, 0.025313004851341248, 0.0005347535479813814, 0.011699646711349487, 0.002815099898725748, 0.005251309368759394, -0.08031211793422699, 0.03130040690302849, -0.036885689944028854, 0.07454397529363632, -0.030455240979790688, 0.001933006220497191, -0.00041817306191660464, -0.03929329290986061, 0.04006937891244888, 0.026524346321821213, 0.008033168502151966, 0.06348554790019989, -0.03615283593535423, 0.026801293715834618, -0.017102224752306938, -0.0712657943367958, 0.07771449536085129, -0.05252835899591446, -0.007261856459081173, 0.0022691229823976755, 0.0752742737531662, 0.038719791918992996, 0.03285714611411095, 0.08277377486228943, -0.005899546667933464, 0.009658641181886196, -0.026496822014451027, 0.0257741566747427, -0.06288721412420273, 0.08191855996847153, 0.031664274632930756, 0.042184632271528244, 0.05799539387226105, 0.014934564009308815, 0.01952183060348034, 0.036375727504491806, 0.04091813042759895, 0.0003858518903143704, 0.013045091181993484, 0.014879693277180195, 0.0261407271027565, -0.049672242254018784, -0.063619464635849, 0.009002613835036755, 0.03154880926012993, -0.022034484893083572, 0.004806593991816044, 0.06393857300281525, -0.023148350417613983, 0.042207982391119, 0.01077025756239891, -0.008324901573359966, 0.006828338373452425, -0.04501199349761009, -0.047703638672828674, 0.10725627839565277, 0.011768141761422157, -0.031957171857357025, -0.04556867107748985, -0.0010224998695775867, 0.015423876233398914, -0.001152081647887826, -0.007739644031971693, -0.012678813189268112, 0.026983780786395073, 0.037337325513362885, 0.007642632350325584, 0.030878134071826935, 0.020501872524619102, -0.044154513627290726, 0.014955303631722927, -0.0042307451367378235, -0.054697733372449875, 0.025976572185754776, -0.023488929495215416, -0.025888321921229362, 0.020907439291477203, 0.016210703179240227, -0.01920202001929283, 0.03627517446875572, 0.060127176344394684, -0.09962646663188934, 0.03172704204916954, -0.040330931544303894, -0.011854037642478943, -0.010983272455632687, 0.03341292962431908, 0.055998798459768295, 0.0007551646558567882, -0.023630820214748383, 0.022063111886382103, 0.008264929987490177, -0.010991298593580723, 0.050318535417318344, 0.017556514590978622, -0.0034122453071177006, 0.001353909494355321, -0.03869209811091423, -0.01438671350479126, 0.03080434538424015, -0.03414541855454445, 0.037548862397670746, -0.029898017644882202, 0.04547969996929169, -0.008899211883544922, -0.04556771367788315, 0.02354544959962368, -0.04128424823284149, -0.007612321991473436, 0.04012675583362579, 0.04769667983055115, -0.02027294412255287, -0.09315798431634903, -0.021730909124016762, 0.009625027887523174, -0.006085988134145737, 0.03433915972709656, -0.012602212838828564, -0.03848181292414665, 0.03632301837205887, 0.023270118981599808, 0.005376399029046297, 0.07800135016441345, 0.009356998838484287, -0.040093738585710526, -0.01507426705211401, 0.01404061820358038, 0.038776665925979614, 0.007118513807654381, -0.013540071435272694, 0.01315738633275032, 0.029567517340183258, -0.015250761061906815, 0.023838603869080544, 0.015736643224954605, -0.02564876154065132, -0.06592091172933578, -0.017453204840421677, -0.00520097091794014, 0.008827411569654942, -0.047126512974500656, -0.032203901559114456, 0.07704329490661621, 0.022375456988811493, 0.043833039700984955, 0.04267825186252594, -0.004599407780915499, -0.02392691560089588, 0.003501317696645856, -0.009716354310512543, 0.008447323925793171, -0.06007402762770653, -0.04655671492218971, 0.03299179673194885, -0.012342861853539944, -0.022460812702775, 0.040377065539360046, -0.018804850056767464, 0.029191887006163597, 0.005252989940345287, -0.04536106809973717, -0.024611538276076317, -0.04262511059641838, -0.028199659660458565, 0.07885829359292984, -0.032880932092666626, 0.005916595458984375, 0.0076262629590928555, -0.02294185385107994, -0.04433280602097511, 0.01499977707862854, 0.0055218590423464775, 0.04742561653256416, 0.0375942587852478, -0.007111117243766785, 0.017933644354343414, 0.038625914603471756, -0.02830244041979313, -0.03550047054886818, 0.02801128849387169, -0.04064387455582619, 0.054504938423633575, -0.045774538069963455, 0.006801493000239134, 0.0066374521702528, -0.08829917758703232, -0.05701187252998352, 0.00738948117941618, -0.03078894130885601, -0.02946224808692932, -0.02910366840660572, -0.015548628754913807, -0.017815470695495605, 0.11860191076993942, 0.0582779161632061, -0.008800891228020191, 0.016608688980340958, -0.03993624821305275, -0.0011722227791324258, -0.007850398309528828, -0.023528456687927246, -0.02096276730298996, 0.01070212759077549, 0.05202800780534744, -0.01724664866924286, 0.028838561847805977, 0.007771058939397335, -0.06484339386224747, -0.004983628634363413, -0.016247626394033432, 0.04421703517436981, 0.013544603250920773, -0.0102405846118927, 0.02961733192205429, -0.017792189493775368, 0.025749605149030685, -0.016719097271561623, 0.00506016006693244, -0.03378716856241226, -0.03914450854063034, 0.05122274160385132, 0.009107221849262714, 0.003142676781862974, -0.011812310665845871, 0.09450362622737885, -0.005761115346103907, 0.03402726724743843, 0.020592335611581802, -0.013557828962802887, 0.03139545023441315, -0.02513989619910717, 0.0171932615339756, -0.06480664014816284, 0.005295435898005962, -0.0060010747984051704, -0.08887121826410294, 0.001982102170586586, -0.037223462015390396, 0.05360418185591698, -0.028975283727049828, -0.015311118215322495, 0.0008645085617899895, 0.03512270748615265, 0.015533702448010445, -0.07844940572977066, 0.02617645636200905, -0.05389022082090378, 0.01572307199239731, 0.044818948954343796, -0.04776773974299431, -0.049822572618722916, -0.014386800117790699, 0.017267100512981415, -0.010119989514350891, 0.014260980300605297, -0.0003406688047107309, -0.020995480939745903, -0.00978225376456976, 0.012245962396264076, 0.009926515631377697, 0.028718017041683197, 0.020983600988984108, -0.01699857786297798, 0.03857004642486572, 0.02692556194961071, -0.004075948614627123, -0.04069091007113457, 0.034664586186409, 0.02330344170331955, -0.0362466461956501, 0.01911154016852379, 0.07798337191343307, -0.02283686213195324, -0.03296838700771332, 0.06564062833786011, 0.021102281287312508, -0.0018448729533702135, -0.03927623853087425, -0.00016586680430918932, -0.04230561852455139, -0.017521407455205917, -0.010531401261687279, 0.012955998070538044, 0.04005124047398567, -0.03667355701327324, -0.013913407921791077, 0.046635568141937256, 0.024455150589346886, 0.02391001209616661, 0.04703744128346443, -0.008310183882713318, -0.040990449488162994, -0.011625927872955799, 0.05013260245323181, -0.04952249675989151, 0.07134516537189484, 0.039866749197244644, 0.015217028558254242, 0.04669269919395447, 0.0028536468744277954, -0.060843851417303085, -0.010808774270117283, -0.02720586583018303, -0.020981868728995323, -0.025234023109078407, -0.05054900050163269, -0.06227520853281021, -0.04373480752110481, -0.045720282942056656, 0.05431205779314041, 0.01114435400813818, -0.00497267534956336, 0.01500646211206913, -0.053750425577163696, -0.04502397030591965, 0.01228480227291584, 0.03518044948577881, -0.010352320969104767, 0.012383819557726383, -0.03290770202875137, 0.009812301956117153, -0.0038135030772536993, -0.02311115153133869, 0.003731862176209688, 0.06686427444219589, -0.016646625474095345, 0.044485904276371, 0.0098198177292943, 0.02234625443816185, 0.004865927621722221, 0.001998532796278596, -0.0017604263266548514, 0.030130578204989433, 0.0035299919545650482, 0.010640190914273262, -0.0004965760745108128, -0.05496225878596306, -0.01258775219321251, 0.01301647536456585, 0.034721001982688904, 0.03398988023400307, -0.036495331674814224, 0.005196418147534132, 0.014785699546337128, -0.0030671514105051756, 0.007587578147649765, -0.012076118029654026, -0.03244810178875923, -0.007025144528597593, -0.03745640441775322, -0.012751122936606407, 0.03406551480293274, -0.00926847755908966, 0.07196266204118729, 0.05661461502313614, -0.037721820175647736, 0.02868000790476799, -0.016681984066963196, 0.025025513023138046, 0.029066070914268494, -0.0527203232049942, 0.020818213000893593, -0.025465399026870728, -0.0334063358604908, -0.031247667968273163, -0.0024918154813349247, 0.028485920280218124, 0.0030288128182291985, 0.016609735786914825, -0.002101879334077239, 0.005581494886428118, 0.00539338868111372, -0.07805664837360382, 0.004825810436159372, 0.0013935355236753821, -0.0262829028069973, 0.03686594218015671, 0.058849040418863297, -0.013495845720171928, 0.020740967243909836, -0.045147888362407684, 0.01534830592572689, -0.021708279848098755, 0.01446141954511404, -0.12135735154151917, 0.019350187852978706, -0.042488303035497665, -0.007311221212148666, -0.04480089992284775, 0.03992000222206116, -0.006124116014689207, -0.009777328930795193, 0.0340302512049675, 0.02262009121477604, -0.028422093018889427, -0.05104715749621391, 0.0424310527741909, 0.058279380202293396, -0.013993040658533573, -0.06322470307350159, -0.005696263629943132, -0.02391923777759075, 0.010112577117979527, 0.006117671728134155, 0.02211078256368637, -0.013355477713048458, 0.00807153433561325, 0.020138880237936974, -0.015566186979413033, -0.032511185854673386, 0.020536532625555992, 0.049329936504364014, -0.022349338978528976, 0.005688941106200218, -0.012762967497110367, 0.007036953698843718, -0.03524832800030708, -0.08876627683639526, -0.007561299949884415, -0.020735453814268112, 0.001914060558192432, 0.02655315399169922, -0.008773584850132465, -0.02438504993915558, -0.04609574005007744, 0.009919164702296257, -0.05161236599087715, 0.031578145921230316, -0.03888389840722084, 0.032011013478040695, 0.012279183603823185, -0.01741643436253071, 0.013426669873297215, -0.04088500887155533, -0.06425518542528152, 0.05736035481095314, 0.027150163426995277, -0.009410037659108639, -0.023240327835083008, -0.0749594047665596, -0.01022657286375761, -0.004088382702320814, -0.014458730816841125, 0.020351191982626915, -0.029325995594263077, 0.04058384522795677, -0.024219684302806854, 0.06288672983646393, -0.023733248934149742, 0.002999118994921446, -0.031584516167640686, 0.010879524052143097, -0.009977308101952076, -0.01839473471045494, 0.022906925529241562, -0.016335874795913696, -0.08321511000394821, -0.03346332535147667, 0.016339696943759918, -0.07190342992544174, 0.029697235673666, -0.02092178352177143, -0.04112682864069939, 0.023353807628154755, 0.02097027190029621, -0.006882896181195974, -0.07102503627538681, -0.035150665789842606, -0.014257856644690037, -0.014710103161633015, 0.021939216181635857, 0.0026918768417090178, -0.016443783417344093, -0.04122445732355118, 0.021236933767795563, -0.006303663365542889, -0.042944446206092834, 0.015496551990509033, -0.04741528257727623, -0.0011722907656803727, -0.0029701769817620516, -0.021075014024972916, 0.019374938681721687, -0.0225786492228508, 0.0010179773671552539, 0.009685707278549671, 0.01079775020480156, -0.0626625344157219, -0.006638344377279282, 0.03469451144337654, -0.013300803489983082, 0.0006440069410018623, 0.018736079335212708, 0.06342088431119919, -0.0014060616958886385, -0.07281524688005447, -0.0004607343871612102, -0.044694382697343826, -0.07096952199935913, 0.03786972910165787, 0.05114373564720154, -0.00410221004858613, -0.02068929560482502, 0.020505236461758614, -0.011658051051199436, -0.04858782887458801, 0.054524023085832596, 0.011727104894816875, -0.07037080824375153, 0.021321430802345276, 0.024871474131941795, -0.03662750869989395, -0.006139500066637993, -0.004773684311658144, -0.044881872832775116, 0.005218599457293749, -0.020884960889816284, -0.007748846895992756, 0.01595824956893921, 0.042565230280160904, -0.021399326622486115, -0.02596556767821312, -0.016790946945548058, 0.01776609569787979, -0.019649915397167206, -0.023790720850229263, -0.00846931803971529, 0.010533971711993217, -0.01264224573969841, -0.01092891301959753, 0.020431242883205414, 0.05780407041311264, -0.019884949550032616, -0.03396999090909958, 0.012075339443981647, -0.00324167194776237, 0.04870638996362686, 0.023538757115602493, -0.014274584129452705, 0.06086260452866554, 0.07003383338451385, -0.026186460629105568, 0.02866525948047638, 0.00004756341513711959, 0.016555285081267357, 0.04748331010341644, 0.007796330843120813, -0.036125801503658295, -0.1389123946428299, -0.019686106592416763, -0.028898071497678757, -0.0029351150151342154, 0.07264793664216995, 0.05646555498242378, -0.0776028111577034, -0.02136511355638504, 0.028997913002967834, -0.03693744167685509, -0.017430076375603676, 0.009864959865808487, -0.013973996043205261, -0.006826858967542648, 0.06627143919467926, -0.00952181313186884, -0.033394500613212585, -0.02914498746395111, 0.029559528455138206, 0.07391074299812317, -0.038468021899461746, -0.0803777277469635, -0.019000336527824402, 0.03995385393500328, 0.008267111144959927, -0.014612207189202309, 0.007296867202967405, -0.010899410583078861, 0.0037128841504454613, 0.019757894799113274, -0.0612671859562397, 0.057930756360292435, 0.02233961783349514, 0.01876026578247547, -0.007839564234018326, -0.03229020535945892, 0.014705779030919075, -0.0038343549240380526, -0.043554771691560745, 0.02816813252866268, -0.0226972047239542, 0.02303791232407093, -0.020409876480698586, 0.04800277575850487, -0.00043936551082879305, 0.040112271904945374, 0.028038864955306053, 0.06064959987998009, 0.05263422057032585, -0.004728393163532019, -0.009048223495483398, 0.06500830501317978, -0.0018266375409439206, -0.05376606434583664, 0.0227361973375082, 0.03613417595624924, 0.024429339915513992, 0.018528979271650314, -0.004562056623399258, -0.019455481320619583, -0.011389256455004215, 0.07921535521745682, 0.023135626688599586, -0.022592181339859962, 0.024296090006828308, 0.05372907593846321, 0.0054270317777991295, 0.0528605654835701, -0.07500145584344864, -0.002957899821922183, -0.01215155515819788, -0.01832432486116886, 0.001192177296616137, -0.030604559928178787, 0.00950841885060072, 0.032395802438259125, -0.021119773387908936, -0.031717509031295776, -0.020000912249088287, 0.015076684765517712, -0.002161179669201374, 0.0009473928948864341, 0.01971357688307762, -0.038383953273296356, 0.047553807497024536, 0.009476256556808949, -0.0032140780240297318, -0.03634747862815857, 0.05437376722693443, -0.0013687311438843608, -0.04039328545331955, 0.03728840872645378, -0.07284248620271683, 0.03283826634287834, -0.006762397941201925, -0.05418936535716057, -0.0064582242630422115, -0.025790715590119362, -0.007222886197268963, -0.022185105830430984, 0.015184154734015465, 0.020527642220258713, 0.008345097303390503, -0.025122638791799545, 0.08139774948358536, 0.048123735934495926, -0.030377138406038284, -0.014253669418394566, 0.007452758029103279, -0.05967054143548012, 0.03992687538266182, 0.03447844460606575, -0.03522754833102226, 0.05919535085558891, -0.09420664608478546, 0.04842760041356087, -0.025893332436680794, -0.010785805061459541, -0.07577142864465714, -0.005315009038895369, 0.0003420890716370195, 0.02320965565741062, -0.011395629495382309, 0.05606817826628685, 0.0275543462485075, -0.021938784047961235, -0.016149643808603287, 0.010423165746033192, -0.018854966387152672, -0.022318286821246147, 0.0032901111990213394, -0.0524868369102478, 0.06438837200403214, 0.0007947597769089043, 0.012846332043409348, 0.03753582388162613, 0.049722012132406235, 0.004229605197906494, 0.04845305532217026, 0.01965063251554966, -0.011280979961156845, -0.03943689540028572, 0.033101074397563934, 0.01102572400122881, 0.005104450974613428, -0.00595824932679534, 0.04849783331155777, -0.006997233256697655, 0.022518770769238472, 0.021102972328662872, 0.049220211803913116, -0.08302246034145355, 0.060565825551748276, 0.02715364284813404, -0.03278141841292381, -0.014025909826159477, 0.008043764159083366, -0.04496011510491371, 0.03209143877029419, -0.014719770289957523, 0.022091306746006012, 0.07762710005044937, -0.0424642451107502, -0.023306388407945633, 0.014728553593158722, 0.034456636756658554, 0.010713843628764153, -0.04006141796708107, -0.018569063395261765, -0.07841546833515167, 0.07379075884819031, -0.012394480407238007, 0.005136347375810146, -0.03723221644759178, 0.018732070922851562, 0.020166220143437386, 0.0017136590322479606, -0.0005519799306057394, -0.026862112805247307, 0.037435248494148254, 0.02586153708398342, 0.072880819439888, -0.009952676482498646, 0.006000293884426355, -0.05828598886728287, 0.05840599909424782, 0.04390842095017433, -0.012226912193000317, -0.003153088968247175, 0.005382114555686712, -0.0034195499029010534 ]
<p>In the special relativistic action for a massive point particle, </p> <p>$$\int_{t_i}^{t_f}\mathcal {L}dt,$$</p> <p>why is the Lagrangian </p> <p>$$\mathcal {L}=-E_o\gamma^{-1}$$</p> <p>a negative number?</p>
g924
[ 0.046468187123537064, 0.004954833071678877, -0.00999225303530693, -0.010082785971462727, 0.08119145035743713, 0.03897746652364731, 0.05002502351999283, 0.08178254961967468, -0.0625106617808342, 0.016274048015475273, 0.010088116861879826, 0.09472397714853287, 0.07463593035936356, 0.019569775089621544, -0.007284273859113455, -0.03202680125832558, 0.06143118813633919, -0.010031064040958881, -0.007108647376298904, -0.0024669438134878874, -0.012059717439115047, 0.02886885032057762, 0.034822653979063034, -0.01650572381913662, 0.08970247209072113, 0.017507662996649742, 0.03951188921928406, -0.01850476674735546, -0.025987181812524796, -0.020503826439380646, 0.05584414303302765, -0.010365508496761322, -0.011813472956418991, -0.012685640715062618, -0.00481451116502285, -0.019967136904597282, 0.0484808012843132, 0.057195622473955154, 0.02614033967256546, 0.008144914172589779, -0.028807831928133965, 0.009193104691803455, 0.04336455464363098, -0.018378864973783493, 0.005892622750252485, -0.003278665244579315, -0.001273885602131486, 0.014024841599166393, -0.038984984159469604, 0.02147219143807888, 0.014188370667397976, -0.004946411587297916, -0.02821868471801281, -0.04661225527524948, 0.037763047963380814, 0.01627577841281891, -0.088103286921978, -0.015914244577288628, -0.0083674481138587, 0.06174740567803383, 0.014175817370414734, -0.08042359352111816, 0.03224971517920494, 0.021480463445186615, 0.0707118809223175, 0.004277451429516077, -0.04082164540886879, -0.0025525721721351147, -0.011728867888450623, 0.0019776765257120132, -0.01148829236626625, -0.04169883951544762, 0.03816895931959152, -0.03496880456805229, -0.009514173492789268, 0.02914021536707878, -0.04379966855049133, 0.041289426386356354, -0.04499760642647743, -0.03114735148847103, -0.054645292460918427, -0.0506473109126091, 0.037044961005449295, -0.01972222328186035, 0.06074604392051697, -0.01386341918259859, 0.04997061938047409, 0.0018521830206736922, -0.015537112019956112, -0.004441019147634506, 0.05950629338622093, 0.0003137093153782189, 0.0598357692360878, 0.019178949296474457, -0.008109827525913715, -0.003711472963914275, 0.019400199875235558, 0.04374226927757263, -0.0711730420589447, -0.0007197092054411769, 0.05969276279211044, 0.05225256830453873, -0.03250415623188019, 0.018930256366729736, -0.028461625799536705, 0.023196442052721977, -0.007000997196882963, -0.004313994664698839, 0.022071871906518936, -0.002285528229549527, 0.012857083231210709, -0.025759505107998848, 0.0288515817373991, -0.07584653794765472, -0.041883938014507294, 0.05330805107951164, 0.012710703536868095, -0.07020498812198639, -0.03905992582440376, 0.06256852298974991, 0.027030980214476585, -0.003615399356931448, -0.03887647017836571, 0.08342340588569641, -0.02255685068666935, -0.03561577573418617, 0.018888967111706734, 0.03279945254325867, -0.0025798450224101543, 0.015240466222167015, -0.027581816539168358, 0.04934476688504219, -0.05133955180644989, -0.011782822199165821, 0.005203134845942259, 0.0338902473449707, 0.014168581925332546, 0.0037720552645623684, 0.015682030469179153, -0.027112731710076332, -0.012974551878869534, -0.00591657031327486, 0.052508749067783356, -0.05430132523179054, -0.036187924444675446, -0.001629104372113943, 0.013031542301177979, -0.03282495215535164, 0.013312743045389652, 0.008666562847793102, 0.008336572907865047, 0.01655616983771324, 0.04093093425035477, 0.003105851821601391, 0.055974286049604416, -0.009248553775250912, 0.035056259483098984, 0.052547477185726166, -0.062293555587530136, -0.0007020107004791498, 0.03783326968550682, 0.008998909965157509, -0.006056061014533043, 0.014675967395305634, -0.018363477662205696, 0.04102044552564621, -0.017261609435081482, -0.039833612740039825, -0.02254456840455532, -0.033615175634622574, -0.05807854235172272, -0.005134407430887222, 0.03015976957976818, -0.029948916286230087, -0.002515227533876896, 0.0046981158666312695, -0.0451401025056839, -0.03679141774773598, -0.0040960353799164295, 0.019952256232500076, -0.040057241916656494, -0.09582854062318802, -0.012676743790507317, -0.021416913717985153, -0.014329936355352402, -0.030234910547733307, -0.03022611513733864, 0.07697559148073196, -0.023758942261338234, 0.02138322778046131, 0.011969813145697117, 0.030288629233837128, -0.013151987455785275, 0.0004837496380787343, -0.00851515308022499, 0.022365424782037735, 0.0036355452612042427, -0.06406227499246597, -0.047382425516843796, 0.004942307248711586, -0.008769659325480461, 0.029061919078230858, 0.045335542410612106, 0.006612266413867474, -0.021052192896604538, -0.08746486157178879, -0.038911689072847366, 0.02573486790060997, 0.013805347494781017, 0.03476175665855408, 0.045497726649045944, -0.05183227360248566, 0.016378527507185936, -0.036834586411714554, -0.013202269561588764, -0.07233009487390518, 0.00025187883875332773, 0.030260799452662468, -0.024568134918808937, 0.031222522258758545, -0.09568153321743011, 0.024407053366303444, 0.0641804188489914, -0.012302078306674957, 0.022221963852643967, 0.018583869561553, -0.022545896470546722, -0.05913770943880081, 0.03511864319443703, -0.015202331356704235, -0.07476110011339188, 0.029324855655431747, -0.03428027778863907, 0.02178545668721199, 0.01782606728374958, -0.026774372905492783, -0.02554558776319027, -0.02071371115744114, 0.01763441227376461, 0.016325633972883224, 0.023825479671359062, -0.05425351485610008, -0.01944665051996708, -0.015321392565965652, 0.01920759305357933, 0.037990156561136246, 0.00227244570851326, 0.016576426103711128, -0.07296890020370483, -0.009208548814058304, -0.025710338726639748, -0.04267805442214012, 0.004227522294968367, 0.039177026599645615, 0.050922807306051254, -0.017545729875564575, -0.01560160331428051, -0.013778147287666798, -0.010874171741306782, 0.013991598971188068, -0.01338632870465517, 0.0008224121993407607, -0.017499417066574097, 0.039110247045755386, -0.007700162939727306, 0.02179144136607647, -0.03787917271256447, 0.008622881956398487, 0.04239848628640175, -0.024787841364741325, 0.033308133482933044, 0.07146790623664856, 0.04562096670269966, 0.03798641636967659, -0.03223466873168945, -0.013539387844502926, -0.04527553543448448, -0.020175715908408165, 0.0497698076069355, -0.04237285628914833, -0.006365381181240082, 0.038937412202358246, -0.0016767926281318069, -0.010746504180133343, 0.03167222440242767, -0.07878625392913818, -0.029950110241770744, -0.027126440778374672, -0.07186941057443619, -0.028073403984308243, 0.049252700060606, 0.015585961751639843, -0.018080607056617737, -0.05521908402442932, 0.06686478853225708, -0.00564027251675725, -0.04963589087128639, -0.04980166256427765, -0.013522605411708355, 0.04941965639591217, 0.02515660785138607, -0.02298431470990181, -0.05760752409696579, -0.03502891585230827, -0.03799842298030853, 0.0002020534739131108, 0.018333619460463524, -0.013608538545668125, -0.06367602199316025, 0.006221472285687923, -0.00005766237518400885, 0.06964660435914993, 0.031958285719156265, -0.03835468739271164, -0.013234560377895832, 0.027167947962880135, -0.024815913289785385, -0.024271825328469276, 0.03899705410003662, 0.007162135560065508, -0.03722488135099411, -0.02906252071261406, -0.009671386331319809, 0.031931813806295395, 0.03847803920507431, 0.03082849085330963, -0.035086214542388916, 0.020751409232616425, 0.005736039485782385, 0.0048965164460241795, -0.015229655429720879, -0.061204466968774796, 0.01904241554439068, 0.05397353693842888, 0.0002434759953757748, 0.04565637931227684, -0.032946567982435226, -0.010096017271280289, 0.06891672313213348, 0.004361840896308422, -0.07684553414583206, -0.0318014919757843, -0.03942802920937538, 0.052173737436532974, 0.056956563144922256, -0.035146839916706085, 0.035688165575265884, 0.018418896943330765, 0.06472845375537872, 0.05105159431695938, -0.035542234778404236, -0.041241392493247986, 0.009882723912596703, -0.014827689155936241, 0.003342370269820094, -0.04034290462732315, -0.004712849855422974, 0.03625516965985298, -0.0007914568413980305, -0.0016812487738206983, -0.01137989666312933, 0.0057737757451832294, -0.0454353429377079, 0.06568595767021179, 0.013547186739742756, 0.06430669128894806, -0.07005412876605988, -0.046787139028310776, 0.012213281355798244, -0.003607789985835552, 0.03827112913131714, -0.01227217260748148, 0.01741013117134571, 0.01799091510474682, 0.00950087234377861, -0.006157125346362591, -0.03159452602267265, -0.041476644575595856, -0.027673983946442604, -0.01866704411804676, 0.06697266548871994, -0.04338999092578888, -0.0502176508307457, -0.0031042650807648897, 0.0495903454720974, 0.019655883312225342, -0.03516727313399315, -0.01328116562217474, 0.0026409043930470943, -0.083128921687603, 0.0077676912769675255, -0.03017103485763073, -0.016045669093728065, -0.020237909629940987, 0.06996641308069229, 0.01454926561564207, 0.02756614238023758, 0.0026108117308467627, 0.01664823107421398, 0.010832186788320541, -0.019400781020522118, 0.05334259942173958, 0.06054170802235603, -0.006605428643524647, 0.014027637429535389, -0.003964525647461414, 0.04674398899078369, 0.02667953260242939, 0.03240378573536873, -0.047842785716056824, -0.023228999227285385, -0.027836909517645836, -0.02287636511027813, -0.0539250448346138, 0.014512256719172001, -0.05793292820453644, 0.007439110893756151, -0.01994205266237259, 0.0030586959328502417, -0.01927359215915203, 0.050679925829172134, 0.008455678820610046, 0.057869378477334976, -0.01711444742977619, 0.03274614363908768, 0.06544094532728195, 0.012282542884349823, 0.05938666686415672, -0.06680236011743546, -0.03664682060480118, -0.00760111678391695, 0.02253473736345768, 0.02878810465335846, 0.004993750713765621, -0.025194676592946053, 0.08789379894733429, -0.036932364106178284, 0.0659312903881073, 0.08770614862442017, 0.08502525836229324, 0.01896306872367859, -0.03278527036309242, -0.0000573372672079131, -0.03958052024245262, 0.059661779552698135, 0.010510549880564213, -0.026408344507217407, -0.034738924354314804, -0.05437927320599556, -0.0173827912658453, 0.03585698828101158, -0.005362912081182003, -0.053539641201496124, -0.021121330559253693, 0.060172684490680695, 0.019661208614706993, -0.01595928519964218, 0.03747010976076126, -0.024849239736795425, 0.0351824089884758, -0.06657847762107849, -0.04446142911911011, 0.02400350570678711, 0.05051524564623833, 0.039182212203741074, -0.001453834818676114, -0.035443615168333054, 0.024534311145544052, -0.057040028274059296, -0.01640056073665619, -0.03379043564200401, -0.008410348556935787, 0.04037413373589516, 0.001794622396118939, -0.050883565098047256, -0.007518924307078123, -0.047715768218040466, -0.004772009328007698, -0.040443580597639084, -0.010501495562493801, 0.01915684901177883, -0.04294269531965256, 0.009666290134191513, -0.016448592767119408, -0.010946789756417274, 0.033491648733615875, -0.051159631460905075, -0.0005047821905463934, 0.022281382232904434, 0.0016363827744498849, 0.01022567879408598, -0.04930809885263443, 0.014541937969624996, 0.0567314513027668, 0.027426334097981453, -0.015232186764478683, -0.012702085077762604, 0.024399030953645706, 0.008426915854215622, -0.0005004220292903483, -0.07648120075464249, -0.0212390199303627, -0.025118490681052208, -0.012014668434858322, 0.008499755524098873, 0.03359675779938698, 0.04047222062945366, -0.017694413661956787, -0.005714032333344221, -0.017033850774168968, -0.006153667811304331, -0.01089944876730442, 0.06078687682747841, -0.02065088227391243, 0.02214094251394272, -0.02733801305294037, 0.03323535993695259, -0.015497070737183094, -0.0030142900068312883, -0.020754743367433548, -0.002632983261719346, 0.0008039687527343631, -0.01925673335790634, -0.04963560774922371, -0.03976992145180702, -0.021366653963923454, -0.03723924234509468, -0.022956684231758118, -0.009610663168132305, 0.0016986698610708117, 0.0035233167000114918, 0.0024693834129720926, 0.04562832787632942, 0.008364011533558369, -0.033289842307567596, 0.007244229782372713, 0.013826362788677216, -0.025056151673197746, 0.015335863456130028, -0.0119162043556571, 0.07098786532878876, -0.05293610319495201, -0.02305018901824951, 0.03219708800315857, -0.012905510142445564, 0.03463884815573692, -0.028972934931516647, -0.003997943829745054, -0.029973994940519333, -0.06095794588327408, -0.009187808260321617, 0.024934325367212296, 0.007668003905564547, -0.030283231288194656, -0.019531162455677986, -0.038817133754491806, 0.02473967708647251, 0.029574960470199585, 0.019531480967998505, -0.027389707043766975, -0.03280113264918327, -0.04289734736084938, 0.052992768585681915, 0.02439582534134388, 0.03472818806767464, -0.028455164283514023, 0.01361755933612585, -0.05733013153076172, 0.003950695041567087, -0.03554881364107132, -0.032789941877126694, 0.08067486435174942, -0.029053278267383575, 0.02013815939426422, 0.061339668929576874, 0.0207725390791893, -0.01232538465410471, 0.006772496737539768, -0.050488509237766266, 0.01845477893948555, -0.011431321501731873, 0.06188800558447838, 0.04603232815861702, -0.08650919049978256, 0.004646850284188986, -0.03219367563724518, -0.031495265662670135, -0.011038639582693577, -0.02406294085085392, 0.09829758107662201, 0.05410382151603699, -0.011310167610645294, -0.07333683967590332, -0.0012394055956974626, -0.014245540834963322, 0.03144649416208267, -0.03038044087588787, -0.05056501924991608, -0.015625251457095146, -0.028488878160715103, 0.06284738332033157, 0.07103342562913895, -0.009290416724979877, -0.0020092756021767855, -0.010473256930708885, -0.01773298718035221, -0.03971739113330841, 0.01758350245654583, 0.00975062046200037, 0.033204175531864166, 0.04899553954601288, 0.017063047736883163, -0.02877083420753479, 0.0034763189032673836, 0.047002799808979034, -0.039055224508047104, 0.040839783847332, 0.06042828410863876, -0.037241172045469284, -0.009268458001315594, 0.03441265597939491, -0.02933138608932495, -0.02131805755198002, 0.01171466987580061, 0.021742239594459534, 0.012305183336138725, -0.05509074404835701, 0.027859259396791458, -0.044128235429525375, 0.01087180059403181, 0.008579535409808159, 0.024534370750188828, -0.04104965180158615, 0.047116994857788086, 0.02056266926229, -0.0028512815479189157, -0.06687182933092117, 0.031041467562317848, 0.03317917138338089, 0.014082865789532661, -0.030698109418153763, 0.046844806522130966, 0.015657784417271614, -0.08748294413089752, -0.08154579252004623, 0.0744851678609848, -0.024802858009934425, -0.006676732562482357, -0.05752980336546898, -0.00515405461192131, -0.004547080956399441, 0.021633459255099297, -0.032938361167907715, -0.00828213058412075, -0.013122105039656162, -0.05305684357881546, 0.01993580162525177, 0.0152584882453084, -0.011192132718861103, -0.005204800050705671, -0.02981720305979252, 0.0016953758895397186, 0.02940700389444828, 0.0007234264630824327, 0.04828167334198952, 0.02905617095530033, 0.0018750748131424189, -0.022416621446609497, 0.04358404502272606, -0.007010217290371656, -0.005954534746706486, 0.010213596746325493, -0.08316381275653839, 0.01160676870495081, -0.007635663729161024, 0.010162550956010818, 0.03999403491616249, 0.01884741336107254, -0.06585212796926498, 0.024080902338027954, 0.0067297047935426235, 0.04755116626620293, 0.0034427312202751637, -0.028156772255897522, -0.058055274188518524, -0.023274380713701248, -0.01034490205347538, 0.0018936077831313014, -0.03499898687005043, 0.02391636371612549, 0.007160719484090805, 0.04266347736120224, 0.021856067702174187, 0.04798951372504234, 0.029071157798171043, -0.009233402088284492, -0.0077202110551297665, 0.03849255293607712, -0.006751930341124535, 0.02715756744146347, 0.023037048056721687, -0.03291377052664757, -0.05896869674324989, 0.016341406852006912, 0.03273316100239754, 0.050575271248817444, 0.032439690083265305, -0.029964309185743332, 0.004382514860481024, 0.045349251478910446, -0.020513301715254784, -0.003888673847541213, -0.020372623577713966, 0.028197254985570908, 0.053564369678497314, 0.016729604452848434, -0.005715752951800823, -0.009567190892994404, 0.05487639456987381, -0.08053798973560333, 0.03779499977827072, 0.010674028657376766, -0.024294275790452957, -0.10080166906118393, -0.00550226541236043, -0.07200811803340912, 0.017253244295716286, 0.0078110406175255775, 0.05604548752307892, 0.03505973145365715, -0.04808203876018524, 0.0191426370292902, -0.06922154873609543, 0.06487781554460526, -0.020583199337124825, -0.004810502752661705, -0.011272542178630829, -0.042605362832546234, 0.025298278778791428, 0.027006488293409348, -0.01421018224209547, -0.04028366133570671, 0.034882768988609314, 0.06614560633897781, -0.006803236436098814, -0.026282068341970444, 0.008886681869626045, 0.012981181964278221, 0.025561967864632607, 0.0013333054957911372, 0.022690091282129288, 0.007775927893817425, -0.02564620040357113, 0.07204524427652359, 0.04037339612841606, -0.022533193230628967, 0.02718091942369938, -0.05316254496574402, 0.015931427478790283, -0.011503005400300026, 0.010480719618499279, -0.019475147128105164, 0.01817593351006508, -0.015218866057693958, -0.0011303339852020144, -0.03157426789402962, -0.018906254321336746, -0.0046256594359874725 ]
<p>The question concerns <a href="http://www.theepochtimes.com/n3/739183-former-nasa-physicist-disputes-einsteins-relativity-theory/?photo=2" rel="nofollow">this video</a>: </p> <p>It says that the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_lens" rel="nofollow">Gravitational Lens</a> effect is an illusion, meaning it's not caused by gravity but by change in density of a plasma atmosphere. It claims further that this gravitational lens effect is not present with other massive objects that aren't made of, or surrounded by, plasma. </p> <p>Does this mean general relativity is invalid, somewhat invalid, or still luckily valid? What is the merit of claim that bending could be caused by plasma and not by gravity? </p>
g6586
[ 0.05109719932079315, 0.05374550819396973, -0.006303379312157631, 0.025435419753193855, 0.03775712847709656, 0.08981435745954514, 0.021699924021959305, 0.042428139597177505, -0.03802398964762688, 0.006056707352399826, 0.11071151494979858, 0.014029637910425663, 0.01794295758008957, 0.006350921932607889, -0.03797084838151932, 0.008942478336393833, 0.07670196145772934, -0.04681920260190964, -0.045551687479019165, 0.0534210242331028, 0.0036104086320847273, -0.042979370802640915, -0.010363724082708359, -0.040465347468853, -0.005067428108304739, 0.006098110694438219, 0.004264557734131813, 0.005572807975113392, 3.3740306548679655e-7, -0.04957106336951256, 0.0031226284336298704, 0.0002164506004191935, -0.012668532319366932, -0.058407094329595566, -0.017748981714248657, -0.03355727717280388, 0.0030053574591875076, 0.04124743118882179, 0.047840602695941925, -0.035044871270656586, -0.08002911508083344, -0.034289587289094925, 0.019226398319005966, -0.006528572179377079, 0.018273891881108284, 0.031787388026714325, 0.005695946980267763, 0.025888707488775253, 0.03145148605108261, -0.02630171924829483, -0.025366313755512238, 0.03267326205968857, -0.01942729763686657, 0.0103065837174654, -0.031432028859853745, 0.0329597070813179, -0.01751767098903656, 0.05791749060153961, 0.05863439291715622, -0.043463729321956635, 0.02615080587565899, 0.05156498774886131, 0.06018202751874924, 0.020761026069521904, -0.02679581195116043, -0.018304578959941864, -0.07556326687335968, -0.0371856652200222, 0.04146096110343933, -0.024759631603956223, 0.03293266519904137, -0.0034413887187838554, -0.05054464936256409, 0.009877519682049751, -0.027581915259361267, 0.08727717399597168, -0.03386550396680832, 0.04906164109706879, 0.004764451179653406, 0.0017256621504202485, -0.001973050180822611, 0.04643521457910538, -0.010119129903614521, 0.006430738605558872, 0.07953034341335297, 0.005038639530539513, 0.00858076848089695, -0.005144604481756687, 0.012610943987965584, 0.05325046926736832, 0.010910801589488983, -0.02494608238339424, 0.01634805276989937, 0.02835514210164547, 0.010559567250311375, -0.00831087026745081, -0.05689338594675064, 0.08884195238351822, -0.025331348180770874, 0.0443570651113987, -0.08747386187314987, 0.03216022625565529, -0.007371979765594006, 0.018591666594147682, 0.02731952629983425, -0.00011357830953784287, 0.0070240795612335205, 0.03204500302672386, 0.03756445273756981, -0.04511414095759392, -0.027350516989827156, 0.007121516391634941, 0.03940621018409729, -0.03259087726473808, -0.057316701859235764, -0.08317141979932785, 0.02861977554857731, 0.008245138451457024, 0.00036993317189626396, 0.02951817959547043, -0.036857739090919495, 0.05830778554081917, 0.021127309650182724, 0.09486696124076843, -0.034877125173807144, -0.07374906539916992, 0.05689289793372154, -0.023816067725419998, 0.004578570369631052, -0.056214358657598495, 0.010994506999850273, -0.04828150197863579, 0.0138876186683774, -0.0011924655409529805, 0.02687462419271469, 0.019205242395401, 0.036836087703704834, -0.003206339431926608, -0.06791898608207703, 0.032877255231142044, 0.01997993141412735, 0.014157332479953766, 0.06791707128286362, -0.027140352874994278, -0.02232675440609455, 0.03044426627457142, -0.022922664880752563, 0.03904583305120468, 0.08288951218128204, 0.0054028709419071674, -0.02081882394850254, 0.05208313837647438, 0.0036813600454479456, -0.05018451437354088, -0.03403155505657196, -0.004993955139070749, -0.03901759535074234, -0.012773948721587658, 0.015908395871520042, 0.011188275180757046, 0.048267364501953125, -0.04028305783867836, 0.007232171017676592, -0.008455443195998669, -0.0263719130307436, 0.014466739259660244, -0.0033034931402653456, 0.010411220602691174, -0.02118789590895176, -0.08278748393058777, -0.04998045414686203, -0.005368180572986603, 0.032899510115385056, 0.029427744448184967, 0.006286915857344866, 0.03540416806936264, 0.001305512385442853, -0.022879421710968018, -0.009012958034873009, -0.018840214237570763, -0.027188243344426155, -0.02617044188082218, -0.043782033026218414, -0.033974941819906235, -0.0011326073436066508, -0.032352689653635025, 0.017517615109682083, 0.007676182314753532, -0.02028295211493969, 0.03755369037389755, -0.02807316742837429, -0.020138463005423546, 0.021085703745484352, -0.013564192689955235, 0.00309967459179461, -0.01916029118001461, 0.051595401018857956, -0.013411012478172779, -0.009923925623297691, 0.061503030359745026, -0.047190021723508835, 0.014392107725143433, 0.003732130164280534, -0.03812985494732857, 0.033995162695646286, -0.002833713311702013, -0.010566080920398235, -0.05517652630805969, 0.021373501047492027, 0.0027566913049668074, 0.027333129197359085, -0.028239373117685318, 0.05484064668416977, -0.022509630769491196, -0.014269682578742504, 0.039298027753829956, -0.02955908514559269, 0.06277335435152054, -0.003319470677524805, 0.00010986928100464866, -0.02679448574781418, 0.06160538271069527, 0.0005698034656234086, 0.0026621390134096146, 0.022308552637696266, -0.03749886155128479, 0.005053118336945772, -0.013197467662394047, -0.012600709684193134, -0.04599059000611305, -0.02072044461965561, 0.003117810469120741, -0.06580547243356705, -0.04061855375766754, 0.06110777705907822, 0.02034156769514084, -0.01064672414213419, -0.0022790555376559496, 0.028533661738038063, 0.012863507494330406, -0.008270928636193275, -0.04435261711478233, -0.04451543092727661, -0.09685344249010086, 0.03892437368631363, -0.042737528681755066, 0.01820494793355465, -0.032394956797361374, 0.015731986612081528, 0.014010298997163773, -0.0033772194292396307, -0.021296454593539238, -0.00878901407122612, 0.009623564779758453, 0.037152212113142014, 0.03218486160039902, -0.025292810052633286, 0.04368830844759941, -0.05949721112847328, 0.029456747695803642, 0.043765779584646225, -0.04516075924038887, -0.006874363403767347, -0.02312353439629078, -0.11414387822151184, 0.00030132074607536197, -0.03305056318640709, 0.01579768769443035, -0.002322218846529722, 0.0664956122636795, 0.007963521406054497, 0.0015108886873349547, -0.04406973719596863, 0.035482507199048996, 0.014078152365982533, 0.05643121525645256, -0.0193665511906147, 0.009536408819258213, 0.01394833717495203, -0.00592922605574131, -0.013451635837554932, 0.007905449718236923, -0.05219311639666557, 0.02270904742181301, 0.03288192301988602, -0.009449396282434464, -0.0563543327152729, -0.007307770662009716, 0.05489911139011383, 0.03424687311053276, 0.02568303421139717, 0.05321120098233223, -0.00035968341398984194, 0.030836325138807297, -0.057051654905080795, 0.04937516525387764, -0.021903494372963905, 0.0112984050065279, -0.07058673352003098, -0.03787614777684212, -0.013822361826896667, -0.005877099931240082, -0.012990441173315048, 0.019392071291804314, 0.015078304335474968, 0.01893981359899044, -0.04602859914302826, -0.03847721591591835, 0.005254718475043774, -0.03563506156206131, -0.002642436185851693, 0.03206782042980194, 0.021481305360794067, 0.06194703280925751, -0.0014601777074858546, 0.003424190217629075, -0.05015392601490021, -0.007018817588686943, -0.029842032119631767, -0.0012856352841481566, 0.0021971482783555984, -0.04665188118815422, -0.03612159565091133, -0.07274463027715683, 0.028642402961850166, 0.00777642335742712, 0.01530439779162407, -0.03199372440576553, 0.0342586413025856, 0.01904672011733055, 0.03244100883603096, -0.04674827307462692, -0.02052456885576248, -0.023337705060839653, -0.011714405380189419, -0.02727038972079754, 0.018146507441997528, 0.02848881110548973, 0.07854443043470383, 0.05336827412247658, -0.01737445779144764, -0.025425080209970474, -0.04900701716542244, -0.0027317178901284933, -0.011874699033796787, 0.056154247373342514, -0.0005674256826750934, -0.011303871870040894, -0.0042403643019497395, 0.018785113468766212, 0.052186042070388794, 0.03232540562748909, 0.01044592633843422, -0.011485239490866661, -0.0035995144862681627, -0.035569678992033005, 0.030139604583382607, 0.015341523103415966, 0.020589543506503105, -0.04724125191569328, 0.05802909657359123, -0.04685916006565094, -0.005969110876321793, -0.022851966321468353, 0.006927612237632275, 0.0007601648103445768, -0.008559033274650574, -0.009997921995818615, 0.01781197264790535, -0.03720828890800476, -0.027035096660256386, -0.024395283311605453, -0.023599592968821526, 0.05453203245997429, 0.058906182646751404, 0.01811417192220688, 0.0757240280508995, 0.04669559374451637, -0.034489527344703674, 0.02882687747478485, 0.06132030859589577, 0.07484006881713867, 0.048012133687734604, 0.03370434045791626, 0.010301340371370316, -0.06281029433012009, -0.03473654389381409, -0.015981078147888184, 0.029080970212817192, -0.07391957938671112, -0.026710789650678635, 0.0045709991827607155, -0.0019814951810985804, -0.016161026433110237, 0.018099555745720863, -0.010054265148937702, 0.007889586500823498, -0.012635807506740093, 0.02391061559319496, -0.002107033971697092, 0.05771755427122116, 0.05438685417175293, 0.04597112536430359, 0.004358366131782532, 0.01031374093145132, -0.04046730697154999, 0.030554696917533875, 0.027159687131643295, -0.04549012333154678, 0.0038247264456003904, 0.013250963762402534, 0.030280327424407005, -0.052204351872205734, -0.07101819664239883, 0.0699755996465683, 0.040441058576107025, -0.013305003754794598, 0.024709267541766167, 0.05064617469906807, -0.007905601523816586, -0.010424329899251461, 0.06525391340255737, -0.0004937824560329318, -0.022056270390748978, -0.02139388397336006, 0.06932852417230606, 0.029241960495710373, -0.013325683772563934, 0.0005870108725503087, -0.008739611133933067, 0.034476812928915024, 0.007439879700541496, -0.03822655230760574, -0.010503475554287434, -0.030851436778903008, 0.048633042722940445, -0.06870122998952866, 0.09204099327325821, 0.012288101948797703, 0.027335451915860176, 0.03550463914871216, -0.012661157175898552, 0.04554987698793411, -0.016367701813578606, 0.011895934119820595, 0.028991490602493286, -0.052971649914979935, -0.016420254483819008, -0.03907957300543785, 0.015366937965154648, -0.06902828812599182, -0.03964094817638397, 0.039184290915727615, 0.00433386443182826, -0.017096633091568947, 0.009171588346362114, -0.01111749280244112, 0.020261183381080627, -0.0033145546913146973, 0.019842028617858887, -0.03436773270368576, 0.005550254136323929, 0.04890366643667221, 0.05207354202866554, 0.06198178976774216, -0.038080260157585144, -0.00048452839837409556, -0.03905105963349342, -0.012310420162975788, -0.05579875409603119, -0.037636034190654755, 0.017842121422290802, -0.003796911332756281, 0.015933267772197723, 0.024620652198791504, -0.008405040018260479, -0.022109171375632286, -0.001964071299880743, -0.006827606353908777, -0.03539403900504112, -0.0031697305385023355, 0.00683778990060091, 0.08449158817529678, -0.05323546752333641, 0.053688593208789825, 0.06649290770292282, -0.02747734636068344, 0.027921538800001144, -0.001990617485716939, -0.02786753512918949, 0.02772459387779236, -0.05713605508208275, -0.018736543133854866, -0.02023281902074814, 0.0001998642401304096, -0.017926933243870735, -0.04026210308074951, -0.011663248762488365, 0.02873757854104042, 0.0028389585204422474, 0.0010862211929634213, 0.04233625903725624, 0.03840359300374985, -0.04448150470852852, -0.022717135027050972, 0.013049089349806309, 0.0092237563803792, -0.019739581272006035, -0.013636262156069279, 0.05249052867293358, -0.031331632286310196, -0.0531708262860775, -0.007527328096330166, 0.018289750441908836, 0.03860502690076828, -0.015506639145314693, -0.05951879546046257, -0.007662098854780197, 0.024931741878390312, -0.020700762048363686, 0.03193829581141472, -0.05537435784935951, 0.038736555725336075, 0.00788290798664093, 0.026145294308662415, -0.005658573471009731, 0.04125012829899788, -0.0004998506628908217, 0.02502700872719288, 0.03940562903881073, -0.002708313288167119, -0.019165895879268646, 0.07220330089330673, 0.023014165461063385, 0.035124167799949646, -0.016259677708148956, -0.009327350184321404, 0.025711167603731155, 0.01942369155585766, -0.0357515774667263, 0.009393572807312012, 0.01597471348941326, 0.04792502149939537, 0.0336708165705204, -0.059816379100084305, 0.04253033921122551, -0.03930797427892685, 0.014347170479595661, 0.06211704760789871, -0.06831031292676926, 0.005989694967865944, 0.02100924402475357, 0.010437056422233582, 0.012400384061038494, 0.05775134265422821, -0.012780227698385715, -0.023338207975029945, -0.07447603344917297, 0.023255130276083946, -0.0409211739897728, 0.024753695353865623, -0.009068076498806477, -0.008129854686558247, -0.03854329511523247, 0.017244650050997734, -0.017064062878489494, -0.02833283692598343, -0.017605304718017578, 0.0688529834151268, -0.000837702420540154, -0.03878027945756912, 0.03096989542245865, -0.07429008185863495, -0.018789280205965042, 0.014074623584747314, -0.008427909575402737, -0.003375788452103734, 0.012298651039600372, -0.05654645711183548, 0.022169409319758415, 0.021651681512594223, -0.02837255969643593, 0.031305477023124695, -0.06290381401777267, -0.06196040287613869, -0.044859156012535095, -0.05409945547580719, 0.008495970629155636, 0.0663597583770752, -0.009482086636126041, -0.030452562496066093, -0.06421446055173874, -0.045098982751369476, -0.030378324910998344, -0.08126496523618698, -0.08353953808546066, -0.0011134058004245162, -0.015772156417369843, -0.012319773435592651, 0.032946065068244934, -0.01334356889128685, 0.02264709211885929, -0.02033611200749874, 0.04679544270038605, 0.016663067042827606, -0.051606640219688416, -0.041780438274145126, 0.01755773462355137, 0.017408831045031548, 0.006735354661941528, 0.005637560971081257, 0.035147614777088165, 0.008723518811166286, -0.030292028561234474, 0.002286694711074233, -0.04669128730893135, -0.06497014313936234, -0.008926469832658768, -0.03030877746641636, -0.04289156198501587, -0.01263093389570713, -0.048577211797237396, 0.03016774170100689, 0.032725073397159576, 0.012429475784301758, 0.01682185009121895, -0.029728181660175323, -0.004741219338029623, 0.046319447457790375, 0.0293128602206707, -0.05031147226691246, -0.02828684076666832, -0.03766762092709541, 0.006644985172897577, 0.04423316568136215, 0.047845788300037384, -0.002155663911253214, 0.017058173194527626, 0.046875134110450745, -0.010239298455417156, -0.03270033001899719, -0.07302167266607285, 0.06358447670936584, -0.028843270614743233, -0.07717935740947723, -0.01953037641942501, -0.013401820324361324, -0.011272643692791462, -0.07538039982318878, -0.02596745267510414, -0.05005784332752228, -0.02700292319059372, 0.014284641481935978, 0.03217776119709015, -0.030335601419210434, 0.04334395378828049, -0.032510075718164444, -0.005717157851904631, 0.03209870308637619, -0.06362743675708771, -0.026240544393658638, -0.03198375180363655, 0.05023134872317314, 0.027315637096762657, -0.005478191189467907, 0.018796497955918312, 0.002375070471316576, -0.059436436742544174, -0.04418575018644333, 0.07699413597583771, 0.015359025448560715, 0.005209146533161402, 0.02893848717212677, 0.01625099591910839, 0.02606535702943802, -0.020352136343717575, -0.019324054941534996, -0.03534863889217377, 0.033762190490961075, 0.023538287729024887, -0.0003173074219375849, 0.0858716294169426, 0.07612770050764084, 0.040706343948841095, -0.09869807213544846, -0.011278173886239529, 0.03008023463189602, 0.04668937623500824, -0.03862325847148895, -0.04835142567753792, 0.00645364448428154, 0.042081013321876526, -0.02292102575302124, 0.01580825448036194, -0.025718890130519867, 0.007702885661274195, 0.023743843659758568, 0.020998116582632065, 0.01204688474535942, -0.005006643012166023, -0.03575905039906502, -0.02011300064623356, -0.06495970487594604, -0.02579401433467865, 0.061887819319963455, 0.07144569605588913, -0.04040933772921562, -0.0026244528125971556, -0.001839194679632783, -0.024401241913437843, 0.07676707953214645, -0.043748144060373306, 0.02151934616267681, 0.016633406281471252, 0.0039029577746987343, -0.053857408463954926, 0.018513191491365433, -0.00801768433302641, -0.015146031975746155, -0.04926697537302971, -0.038685284554958344, -0.012647240422666073, 0.006150440312922001, -0.057075537741184235, -0.014305016957223415, 0.03541182726621628, 0.03587302565574646, -0.05840679258108139, -0.01866711862385273, -0.029496965929865837, -0.03251603990793228, 0.030412260442972183, -0.01374126598238945, -0.04137662425637245, 0.00010691873467294499, 0.018982021138072014, 0.03248301520943642, -0.08119885623455048, 0.00831284373998642, 0.0009359270334243774, 0.015296345576643944, 0.01179675292223692, 0.0008467300212942064, -0.015229244716465473, 0.028906388208270073, 0.012508399784564972, -0.013595866039395332, 0.015265936963260174, 0.01173819974064827, -0.002904215594753623, 0.004220382776111364, 0.03841106593608856, 0.01996086910367012, 0.010583868250250816, 0.05251654237508774, 0.0028214631602168083, -0.0269475057721138, 0.014053630642592907, -0.007374660577625036, -0.005314664915204048, -0.016952963545918465, -0.024330759420990944, 0.0813649594783783, -0.050502926111221313, -0.02711564488708973, 0.009296668693423271, 0.00039482078864239156, -0.0009950976818799973 ]
<p>I have a ball of metal about an inch in diameter and a concave disc of another metal (which is magnetic) around the ring of the disc (about $12 {\rm mm}$ in diameter). I don't know which metals they are. The ball is not magnetic on its own. That is <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paramagnetism" rel="nofollow">paramagnetism</a>, right?</p> <p>The magnetic ring is strongly attracted to the surface of the ball, '<em>sticking</em>' to it. However, I can stick a paperclip on the opposite side of the ball as if it has become magnetic itself, until I remove the magnetic ring from the ball.</p> <p>When I wave the paperclip the same distance from only the ring itself, I feel no force at that distance.</p> <p>Has the strong magnetic field of the ring caused a temporary magnetic alignment through the metal of the ball, allowing the paperclip to be attracted to it while the ring remains?</p>
g6587
[ 0.03692144155502319, 0.025103392079472542, 0.0011465313145890832, -0.03461776301264763, 0.030818326398730278, 0.04548158496618271, 0.00299593573436141, 0.0029520464595407248, -0.024123430252075195, 0.02813657559454441, -0.034041665494441986, 0.019061582162976265, -0.03590889275074005, -0.05560741946101189, 0.04262659326195717, 0.0639176294207573, 0.0507766492664814, -0.00012502142635639757, 0.058033622801303864, 0.020216476172208786, -0.0007755852420814335, 0.011775842867791653, -0.0005243950290605426, -0.01688043586909771, -0.009879075922071934, -0.018457552418112755, 0.03371284902095795, -0.05948369577527046, 0.0020810554269701242, -0.026145093142986298, -0.04178245738148689, 0.0012336965883150697, 0.03518061339855194, -0.02385829947888851, -0.012193763628602028, -0.032968904823064804, 0.03410285711288452, 0.008698280900716782, -0.033141300082206726, 0.008888554759323597, -0.012591938488185406, 0.03551386296749115, 0.022843271493911743, -0.022882090881466866, 0.05387376621365547, -0.014530861750245094, -0.03424769639968872, 0.027308164164423943, -0.0007185937138274312, -0.026203207671642303, -0.05846618115901947, -0.013181873597204685, 0.012229823507368565, 0.007935593836009502, -0.006030015181750059, 0.054594364017248154, 0.03674490377306938, -0.0005537964752875268, 0.08420507609844208, 0.0410238653421402, -0.034638650715351105, 0.033084768801927567, 0.0017546742456033826, -0.013036728836596012, -0.0010199033422395587, -0.03425829857587814, -0.035782281309366226, 0.005786255467683077, -0.023196976631879807, 0.0007560916128568351, 0.00028485379880294204, 0.013556791469454765, 0.00013277989637572318, -0.028195083141326904, -0.004646096844226122, 0.025320233777165413, 0.018052199855446815, -0.05486784502863884, -0.0023743899073451757, -0.03500426560640335, -0.01799905113875866, 0.00901147723197937, -0.011051388457417488, 0.025706252083182335, 0.03218957036733627, 0.003978334367275238, -0.035036008805036545, -0.05026581510901451, -0.04063836485147476, 0.01047312468290329, 0.04149326682090759, 0.02062976360321045, 0.04343418404459953, 0.05923895165324211, -0.016177043318748474, -0.025810612365603447, -0.013897031545639038, 0.0930207297205925, -0.036753345280885696, 0.01848713867366314, -0.016610389575362206, -0.0009953394765034318, 0.029374057427048683, 0.02861584909260273, -0.003025333397090435, 0.0242906641215086, 0.004671940580010414, 0.009786639362573624, 0.026445403695106506, 0.03109508752822876, -0.031694065779447556, -0.021257856860756874, -0.03512644022703171, -0.006076105870306492, 0.018229562789201736, 0.027441008016467094, 0.003883386729285121, -0.021514873951673508, -0.043220389634370804, 0.05709866061806679, 0.03055078536272049, -0.035089362412691116, -0.018678242340683937, 0.08794524520635605, -0.051624130457639694, -0.031284768134355545, 0.026121782138943672, -0.011665640398859978, 0.011753063648939133, 0.014222131110727787, 0.01146454643458128, 0.002837307518348098, 0.07349233329296112, 0.002231878461316228, -0.010801161639392376, -0.015455895103514194, 0.027286415919661522, -0.0035513904877007008, -0.03329949826002121, -0.010779025964438915, 0.026346828788518906, -0.06202111393213272, 0.025618689134716988, -0.0302745271474123, -0.05131993442773819, 0.0631553903222084, -0.03499811887741089, 0.022630520164966583, 0.042068298906087875, 0.0549568310379982, 0.03758380934596062, 0.018152955919504166, -0.04654017090797424, -0.09213663637638092, 0.01049137208610773, 0.017499012872576714, 0.030545314773917198, -0.006862793583422899, 0.028802301734685898, -0.05607645958662033, 0.08147686719894409, -0.027279721572995186, 0.05117415636777878, -0.02032218873500824, -0.06751325726509094, 0.03483233228325844, 0.0571514330804348, 0.017106838524341583, -0.05487266555428505, 0.020774129778146744, -0.021733814850449562, -0.003199539612978697, 0.009717699140310287, 0.019056418910622597, 0.017855500802397728, -0.009596371091902256, 0.04113825783133507, -0.043507643043994904, 0.047796353697776794, -0.01568719558417797, 0.028581924736499786, -0.007060387171804905, 0.039311185479164124, 0.0057241846807301044, 0.004052747040987015, -0.02706262655556202, -0.02420920319855213, 0.06732890009880066, -0.04413596913218498, -0.026946542784571648, -0.027871238067746162, -0.032758887857198715, -0.05605781823396683, 0.05759276822209358, 0.0019017403246834874, -0.04976608604192734, -0.0023562083952128887, -0.006083856802433729, -0.0307136420160532, -0.06736612319946289, -0.014781276695430279, 0.00410078139975667, -0.02538030408322811, 0.0029359287582337856, -0.04635471850633621, -0.04162023589015007, 0.027124473825097084, 0.014278692193329334, 0.04986806958913803, 0.04417511448264122, 0.022689376026391983, 0.04674554243683815, -0.03224649280309677, -0.02783304639160633, -0.026294942945241928, 0.036074962466955185, 0.017778394743800163, 0.043316442519426346, -0.044529989361763, 0.04893854260444641, -0.005217030178755522, 0.05740271508693695, 0.030680730938911438, 0.0069482596591115, -0.04446377977728844, -0.01210738904774189, -0.01909492537379265, 0.05012313276529312, -0.03396596759557724, 0.02823585271835327, -0.027514902874827385, -0.014928160235285759, 0.011341020464897156, 0.0159600917249918, 0.037992212921381, 0.060517214238643646, 0.01896398514509201, -0.021284397691488266, -0.005329051520675421, -0.05478363484144211, 0.009348873980343342, -0.04405529424548149, -0.031393278390169144, 0.008012971840798855, -0.01774398423731327, -0.06146939843893051, 0.08240298181772232, -0.0030453710351139307, 0.01679251343011856, 0.018710976466536522, 0.08140454441308975, -0.06802093982696533, -0.03160296380519867, 0.04824614152312279, -0.01751134730875492, -0.008877313695847988, -0.07000323385000229, 0.02636561542749405, -0.07217497378587723, -0.023295249789953232, -0.01899554207921028, -0.05051940307021141, 0.047360144555568695, 0.028622416779398918, -0.038804635405540466, -0.0168932992964983, -0.04711253196001053, 0.023993544280529022, -0.0018162393243983388, 0.004121345467865467, -0.02359597012400627, 0.022588007152080536, 0.024941440671682358, 0.01707569696009159, -0.010059261694550514, 0.027145523577928543, 0.007205306086689234, -0.01654120348393917, 0.01780278980731964, 0.007463124115020037, 0.026546664535999298, 0.06838411837816238, -0.05625529959797859, -0.04750009998679161, 0.0019289868650957942, -0.04297777637839317, -0.03305933624505997, -0.011196671053767204, 0.011954241432249546, -0.016156839206814766, -0.0045044333674013615, 0.03248467296361923, 0.07268765568733215, -0.0038740357849746943, 0.012708194553852081, 0.06342573463916779, -0.017267026007175446, 0.056126341223716736, -0.008852707222104073, 0.03115733154118061, 0.04008333012461662, 0.0026347592938691378, -0.05932259187102318, -0.016140228137373924, 0.011346024461090565, 0.03698473051190376, -0.0247616246342659, -0.048449065536260605, 0.024542871862649918, 0.008244228549301624, 0.015919292345643044, 0.07218638062477112, 0.04003328084945679, -0.015081828460097313, -0.026638254523277283, -0.006482255179435015, -0.0028440358582884073, 0.057503875344991684, -0.022088421508669853, 0.040806882083415985, -0.021757962182164192, -0.032481346279382706, 0.0008360220235772431, -0.06029884144663811, 0.07875537127256393, -0.015663672238588333, -0.022673550993204117, -0.0448203943669796, -0.007296077441424131, -0.05002112314105034, -0.005179882515221834, -0.02415790967643261, -0.026394004002213478, -0.019895188510417938, -0.08993441611528397, -0.01581450365483761, 0.017317213118076324, 0.06266158819198608, -0.003902384778484702, 0.032910704612731934, 0.04744825139641762, -0.025902211666107178, -0.045619651675224304, -0.052084870636463165, 0.0012659651692956686, 0.13035134971141815, 0.020264092832803726, -0.018924390897154808, 0.008725553750991821, 0.03673544153571129, 0.037493620067834854, -0.0131293386220932, 0.026174260303378105, -0.014579796232283115, 0.0385521724820137, 0.023140860721468925, 0.012142695486545563, -0.0033648579847067595, -0.020018933340907097, -0.028788762167096138, -0.05602153763175011, 0.00303275347687304, 0.010804105550050735, -0.03142159432172775, -0.0018514130497351289, 0.07790662348270416, -0.020695021376013756, -0.021792760118842125, -0.0030329502187669277, 0.0073209828697144985, -0.02008109912276268, -0.037213146686553955, -0.024631017819046974, 0.02788158878684044, 0.030773142352700233, 0.006698577664792538, 0.03792586177587509, 0.00998701248317957, -0.04545975849032402, 0.0007414089632220566, -0.012142634019255638, 0.07701746374368668, -0.0041181957349181175, 0.08548260480165482, 0.0044907438568770885, 0.015705440193414688, -0.029839955270290375, -0.028783757239580154, 0.015625756233930588, -0.02771672047674656, -0.011385416612029076, 0.04375739395618439, 0.022647248581051826, 0.011556282639503479, -0.020760448649525642, 0.0054674213752150536, -0.024955660104751587, 0.002199916634708643, 0.06242235004901886, -0.0250912643969059, 0.031809739768505096, -0.02190621942281723, -0.04307467117905617, -0.010373548604547977, 0.009316092357039452, -0.012566745281219482, 0.008151350542902946, -0.009691053070127964, -0.03176431357860565, -0.04406863823533058, 0.021786915138363838, -0.0347265750169754, -0.07544134557247162, -0.02022973634302616, 0.006847619544714689, -0.025527264922857285, 0.013883458450436592, 0.09313055127859116, -0.03148309886455536, -0.049001529812812805, -0.028018005192279816, 0.05572604387998581, 0.06595567613840103, -0.011922233738005161, -0.030632086098194122, 0.04487212002277374, 0.008858982473611832, 0.014394540339708328, 0.030053628608584404, 0.0028023580089211464, -0.003093858016654849, 0.05828898400068283, -0.014440711587667465, -0.01074123289436102, -0.039112139493227005, 0.0338410846889019, -0.06007308512926102, 0.018285445868968964, 0.06401824206113815, 0.02609724923968315, 0.034089431166648865, -0.003962664864957333, 0.028209567070007324, -0.0165163055062294, -0.047245923429727554, 0.025312941521406174, -0.0490708127617836, 0.020908912643790245, -0.06948694586753845, -0.07367121428251266, -0.04115037992596626, 0.007206680253148079, -0.013146133162081242, -0.014222783036530018, -0.026544621214270592, -0.04476900026202202, -0.041455939412117004, -0.012503430247306824, -0.024037925526499748, -0.02165050059556961, 0.0019108694978058338, -0.004597934428602457, -0.019909143447875977, -0.004297045525163412, -0.0024270506110042334, -0.03096582368016243, 0.021920597180724144, -0.08160953223705292, -0.011727133765816689, -0.01981988362967968, 0.03921334818005562, 0.0501200295984745, 0.016607780009508133, 0.0504494309425354, 0.06551085412502289, 0.0056473431177437305, 0.03176547959446907, -0.008186962455511093, 0.048999492079019547, -0.08071821928024292, -0.025914251804351807, 0.06005005165934563, 0.038499586284160614, -0.01869136095046997, 0.01967395469546318, 0.0009556571021676064, 0.0020599872805178165, 0.05572545900940895, 0.016844259575009346, 0.018309764564037323, 0.02491423860192299, -0.05519270524382591, 0.010385067202150822, -0.01764829456806183, -0.024292806163430214, -0.053787678480148315, -0.002778131514787674, 0.008064168505370617, -0.012967171147465706, -0.047909125685691833, -0.026660311967134476, -0.018361808732151985, 0.050554659217596054, 0.05389280617237091, -0.042675647884607315, 0.01792929694056511, -0.039866797626018524, 0.01239620428532362, 0.05264142155647278, 0.06441754847764969, -0.06176646053791046, 0.03415495902299881, 0.055114198476076126, 0.019098496064543724, -0.015715479850769043, 0.04401364177465439, -0.003963907714933157, 0.032667338848114014, 0.0020122244022786617, 0.026530781760811806, -0.004480946343392134, -0.0024841148406267166, 0.01036131288856268, -0.06725350767374039, -0.0024914254900068045, -0.014726036228239536, -0.061933208256959915, 0.0005406903219409287, 0.033411409705877304, 0.06416438519954681, 0.010387484915554523, 0.0010864785872399807, 0.06848261505365372, 0.025941992178559303, 0.0013584726257249713, -0.09418772161006927, 0.05985833704471588, -0.05447366088628769, -0.024462958797812462, 0.028559856116771698, 0.0482398122549057, -0.07807941734790802, 0.06303681433200836, 0.03902518376708031, -0.01377834565937519, -0.02317437343299389, -0.0015652661677449942, -0.014067670330405235, 0.06051948666572571, -0.054251957684755325, 0.031989045441150665, 0.0306496974080801, -0.0122990682721138, 0.0536583811044693, 0.029505152255296707, 0.044970933347940445, -0.02728482522070408, -0.025189721956849098, 0.033403173089027405, -0.046103883534669876, 0.08911502361297607, -0.03709835186600685, -0.04201849177479744, 0.05006725713610649, -0.01009353157132864, 0.03305501118302345, -0.032437145709991455, -0.03308236226439476, 0.025483878329396248, -0.041670847684144974, 0.01544458419084549, -0.011033573187887669, -0.011639268137514591, 0.02530369721353054, 0.009904708713293076, 0.048855025321245193, -0.05956908315420151, -0.008270522579550743, -0.02633809670805931, 0.020054703578352928, 0.03682927414774895, 0.019379625096917152, 0.02676919661462307, -0.0562637597322464, 0.02274448052048683, -0.03156491741538048, -0.06742110103368759, 0.013779500499367714, 0.04360686242580414, -0.09621560573577881, -0.08568891137838364, -0.0006961653125472367, -0.025284240022301674, -0.024950018152594566, -0.03915154188871384, 0.04608386754989624, -0.061449334025382996, 0.01697038672864437, -0.048713624477386475, 0.07888789474964142, -0.007510421331971884, -0.042287636548280716, 0.04929894581437111, 0.01817444898188114, 0.006312188226729631, 0.008607493713498116, -0.017531635239720345, -0.003946642857044935, 0.012043580412864685, 0.005722071509808302, -0.042285069823265076, 0.024826252833008766, -0.016363495960831642, 0.016662759706377983, -0.02878587134182453, 0.0019488285761326551, 0.029673688113689423, 0.008597059175372124, -0.035495925694704056, -0.07174772024154663, -0.06848156452178955, -0.016232388094067574, -0.03401826694607735, -0.01707763411104679, -0.05528450757265091, -0.03843478485941887, -0.056939709931612015, -0.02427617274224758, -0.037993479520082474, 0.022993169724941254, -0.00623592734336853, 0.05675707384943962, -0.025169167667627335, 0.016746671870350838, -0.04525865614414215, 0.0316523052752018, 0.04100074991583824, -0.01184061449021101, 0.028575818985700607, -0.006686044856905937, -0.011938600800931454, 0.03304572403430939, -0.007553990930318832, 0.0028076092712581158, 0.021165527403354645, -0.006958220154047012, -0.00834857951849699, 0.008466922678053379, -0.03263549879193306, 0.029558954760432243, -0.010126409120857716, 0.012635152786970139, -0.049524251371622086, 0.031086640432476997, -0.029865264892578125, 0.06883622705936432, -0.03918161615729332, -0.007619543932378292, -0.011232568882405758, 0.029487883672118187, -0.028759071603417397, -0.03111204132437706, -0.0482669435441494, -0.08020544052124023, -0.009663550183176994, 0.019628215581178665, 0.01227578241378069, -0.06294813007116318, -0.027337532490491867, -0.046865276992321014, 0.03418926149606705, -0.051158055663108826, 0.029600581154227257, 0.026612311601638794, -0.0003009685024153441, 0.03008207306265831, 0.012648154981434345, -0.015813278034329414, 0.046829815953969955, 0.01647244021296501, -0.062248747795820236, 0.0406726635992527, 0.0010552876628935337, -0.021368199959397316, -0.029822053387761116, 0.016201982274651527, -0.018210727721452713, 0.06315738707780838, 0.03018942102789879, -0.014915470033884048, 0.02562570571899414, 0.00813624169677496, 0.05187491327524185, 0.08545195311307907, -0.005583273712545633, -0.009384174831211567, 0.03753073513507843, 0.021463682875037193, 0.04259888455271721, -0.009618350304663181, -0.004703226033598185, 0.04776636138558388, 0.007624538615345955, -0.027979237958788872, 0.05730896443128586, 0.033214736729860306, -0.062385547906160355, 0.04052329063415527, -0.035934653133153915, 0.016149289906024933, 0.008094711229205132, 0.03800322115421295, 0.00540993083268404, -0.027365580201148987, -0.010988363064825535, 0.040156081318855286, -0.02720165066421032, -0.00885473657399416, 0.02517656609416008, -0.020448539406061172, -0.03439514711499214, 0.038619644939899445, -0.009916462004184723, -0.07105923444032669, -0.01112326793372631, -0.048422638326883316, 0.0058197928592562675, -0.010103910230100155, 0.029188914224505424, 0.045719780027866364, 0.003667447017505765, -0.05856750160455704, -0.0633266493678093, -0.04676501452922821, -0.030574919655919075, -0.04299839958548546, -0.00956995040178299, 0.010925550945103168, 0.025312993675470352, -0.02242811769247055, -0.0026298542506992817, -0.045168187469244, -0.017427176237106323, -0.015067809261381626, -0.005702604539692402, 0.006428082473576069, -0.05465012043714523, 0.07953248918056488, 0.003330900566652417, 0.0023938787635415792, -0.012245086953043938, -0.012947923503816128, -0.045550744980573654, 0.034826721996068954, 0.028130266815423965, -0.0396198034286499, -0.050771184265613556, 0.02644849568605423, 0.04527800530195236, -0.01630144752562046, -0.03051183931529522, -0.051081784069538116, 0.006501575466245413, -0.012944387272000313, 0.06284426152706146, 0.045925382524728775, -0.043198153376579285, 0.01911282166838646 ]
<p>If we are travelling with the speed of light, can we see whats behind us(like if we are moving away from earth can we able see the earth)? And how we see the things that we are approaching with speed of light? Does the things look like fast forwarding because we are moving and the source also sending photons with the same light speed.</p>
g6588
[ -0.012285040691494942, 0.04067358002066612, 0.029355963692069054, 0.031156688928604126, -0.0017793932929635048, -0.027856187894940376, 0.023242518305778503, -0.019602537155151367, -0.03855299949645996, -0.04179483652114868, 0.08516459912061691, 0.05295531079173088, 0.0786375030875206, 0.02897612750530243, -0.010602188296616077, -0.04554101079702377, 0.07140840590000153, -0.04288717359304428, -0.013964757323265076, 0.007041282951831818, 0.03536636754870415, 0.059680961072444916, -0.00863899476826191, -0.012018438428640366, -0.05584866926074028, 0.015687022358179092, -0.001767896581441164, -0.03887966647744179, -0.006441799458116293, -0.028078902512788773, 0.06012842804193497, -0.05652111396193504, 0.005963693372905254, -0.010414081625640392, 0.04831840470433235, -0.010070300661027431, 0.039161890745162964, 0.016433099284768105, -0.012905195355415344, -0.013245471753180027, -0.015031064860522747, -0.031825412064790726, 0.014948002994060516, -0.02176687680184841, 0.05819685012102127, 0.016652746126055717, 0.0291554294526577, -0.027995986863970757, 0.0012728993315249681, 0.022642605006694794, -0.06197275593876839, 0.007225325331091881, -0.0674145519733429, 0.01991814747452736, 0.038637205958366394, -0.01241739746183157, 0.008417101576924324, -0.04849022626876831, 0.1303674727678299, -0.007259661797434092, -0.03553728386759758, 0.011148101650178432, 0.053765907883644104, 0.004601227585226297, 0.07297828793525696, -0.02952631749212742, -0.04831709712743759, -0.022428762167692184, -0.006338817998766899, -0.032097477465867996, 0.04992257058620453, 0.017656248062849045, -0.09946601837873459, -0.04526375234127045, 0.03560436889529228, 0.004425080493092537, 0.08426359295845032, -0.016360990703105927, 0.0027237723115831614, 0.05421783775091171, -0.03184293210506439, -0.05287795141339302, -0.027351537719368935, -0.02740531601011753, 0.0047792838886380196, 0.017761731520295143, -0.0046697803772985935, 0.027945782989263535, -0.009143326431512833, -0.0031356588006019592, 0.02320760488510132, -0.025460444390773773, 0.07144983857870102, 0.07396145910024643, -0.01996760629117489, 0.008889994584023952, -0.027136685326695442, 0.03453851863741875, 0.009564907290041447, -0.012410181574523449, -0.031823981553316116, 0.02197258174419403, 0.031071862205863, 0.04980718716979027, 0.015431070700287819, -0.013241381384432316, -0.009244147688150406, -0.02057424560189247, -0.020545605570077896, -0.02304702438414097, -0.024533463642001152, -0.09491664171218872, -0.011664101853966713, 0.013270615600049496, -0.054788194596767426, -0.05443701520562172, 0.04893052205443382, 0.03935234248638153, 0.032393112778663635, 0.07135750353336334, 0.045718833804130554, 0.033260688185691833, -0.006264411378651857, -0.015865091234445572, 0.01248987764120102, 0.0015102742472663522, -0.01776111125946045, -0.031193574890494347, -0.010175452567636967, 0.0089912423864007, -0.0035911868326365948, 0.04728803038597107, -0.007132594473659992, 0.06651359051465988, -0.02482665702700615, -0.016568053513765335, 0.03329624608159065, 0.022359531372785568, 0.017237527295947075, 0.04762709513306618, 0.05030104145407677, -0.04733458161354065, 0.0030493757221847773, -0.012064739130437374, -0.023623518645763397, -0.015635935589671135, 0.006591421086341143, 0.022346507757902145, -0.009090017527341843, 0.02685554139316082, -0.007854419760406017, 0.05251915752887726, 0.036171428859233856, 0.021273745223879814, 0.012536856345832348, -0.04586155340075493, 0.001411834149621427, 0.004937308374792337, -0.04315274581313133, -0.010521998628973961, 0.030519889667630196, -0.013247201219201088, -0.0014411439187824726, -0.017148597165942192, -0.022807307541370392, 0.0018496281700208783, 0.006081173662096262, -0.010365014895796776, 0.01810392737388611, 0.03366706147789955, -0.0016712922370061278, 0.04746844246983528, 0.041825685650110245, 0.03151679411530495, 0.028654729947447777, -0.03455433249473572, 0.03427693620324135, -0.017038777470588684, -0.07021289318799973, 0.026696182787418365, -0.03458913043141365, -0.03309257701039314, -0.023483218625187874, -0.017371580004692078, -0.026705820113420486, -0.03257083520293236, -0.04798080027103424, -0.0019200325477868319, -0.028779612854123116, -0.002793902298435569, 0.02531610243022442, -0.0735231339931488, -0.04628543183207512, 0.04072962701320648, 0.004450054373592138, -0.06129210442304611, 0.008980697952210903, -0.003992633894085884, 0.02518785558640957, -0.02701638452708721, -0.022879712283611298, 0.08193893730640411, -0.005117734428495169, -0.006240833085030317, 0.013749190606176853, -0.022058574482798576, 0.028717225417494774, 0.018483884632587433, 0.01216850895434618, -0.026055369526147842, 0.08576103299856186, -0.033303793519735336, 0.047091465443372726, 0.027790671214461327, 0.005275862757116556, 0.006043160334229469, -0.044016387313604355, 0.007271622773259878, 0.0003956771979574114, 0.011117535643279552, -0.00507009495049715, -0.018400663509964943, -0.03132976219058037, -0.06009695306420326, -0.0521194227039814, -0.0030604039784520864, -0.052111320197582245, -0.017092833295464516, 0.05007033050060272, 0.09123250842094421, -0.002294837264344096, 0.012292914092540741, 0.02928834967315197, 0.005725450348109007, 0.022282637655735016, -0.017931414768099785, -0.0328756682574749, 0.015036288648843765, 0.003526190761476755, 0.0007774839177727699, 0.006480307783931494, -0.038552526384592056, -0.056821558624506, -0.003450824413448572, 0.02456493116915226, -0.02904278039932251, 0.03129177540540695, 0.0005270089022815228, 0.009745562449097633, 0.038729384541511536, 0.041852034628391266, -0.004738413263112307, -0.031906336545944214, 0.06808366626501083, 0.0036961750593036413, -0.0335061252117157, -0.01925780437886715, 0.052529796957969666, -0.056476518511772156, -0.038647208362817764, -0.04061693325638771, 0.010545175522565842, -0.07240945845842361, 0.013628785498440266, -0.01035362295806408, -0.006654858123511076, 0.022368017584085464, 0.020986326038837433, -0.03571388125419617, 0.000410825276048854, -0.02747369557619095, 0.003161634784191847, 0.013419361785054207, -0.017760751768946648, -0.021538304165005684, 0.012554951943457127, 0.04667016491293907, -0.006343667861074209, -0.02127741277217865, 0.001717985956929624, -0.018774772062897682, -0.01841661147773266, -0.027126068249344826, -0.02479317970573902, -0.005150859244167805, -0.06366457790136337, 0.01906689815223217, 0.005437843967229128, 0.003929647151380777, 0.008639970794320107, -0.056658945977687836, 0.0032934544142335653, 0.07707080245018005, -0.01708160527050495, -0.020669834688305855, 0.03794189915060997, 0.06994213908910751, -0.030835436657071114, -0.006522257346659899, -0.016278861090540886, 0.04017498344182968, -0.02920745126903057, -0.029509849846363068, -0.010372117161750793, 0.023092785850167274, 0.0037664971314370632, -0.08065153658390045, -0.005342874210327864, 0.02900576964020729, -0.04371245577931404, 0.03121849335730076, 0.0430995337665081, -0.04818115383386612, 0.010302691720426083, 0.041368186473846436, -0.01408932451158762, 0.008177360519766808, 0.03035467490553856, -0.007905964739620686, 0.043557751923799515, 0.03370962664484978, -0.0032194643281400204, -0.03607671707868576, -0.02019345387816429, 0.018149491399526596, 0.02652653679251671, 0.019761912524700165, -0.014758937060832977, -0.06425957381725311, -0.023751629516482353, 0.03807096928358078, -0.01935851387679577, -0.05342184752225876, 0.021458759903907776, -0.03931109979748726, 0.021341722458600998, 0.02830173447728157, 0.028050197288393974, 0.06733126193284988, -0.011214902624487877, 0.06547737866640091, -0.00032687425846233964, -0.06816688925027847, 0.034258026629686356, 0.007087079808115959, -0.015222005546092987, -0.027716081589460373, 0.0009914010297507048, -0.05805884301662445, 0.00526256812736392, 0.05674009770154953, 0.016525860875844955, -0.03600076213479042, -0.05736859515309334, 0.014610526151955128, 0.050255708396434784, 0.0026194588281214237, 0.006060214713215828, 0.04840279370546341, -0.057529017329216, -0.05356854945421219, -0.004546351730823517, 0.07025640457868576, 0.0032054136972874403, 0.00531936576589942, -0.03610546514391899, -0.0048678722232580185, -0.004117776174098253, 0.02939561940729618, 0.02092379331588745, 0.0003982564085163176, -0.008073625154793262, -0.0544930025935173, 0.02881624363362789, -0.013995240442454815, -0.025488050654530525, 0.018011249601840973, -0.029726166278123856, -0.04475896432995796, 0.012176153250038624, 0.014733826741576195, 0.032027438282966614, 0.053600478917360306, -0.015799539163708687, 0.023613426834344864, 0.025053951889276505, 0.012371263466775417, -0.09106585383415222, -0.0018866588361561298, -0.010120929218828678, 0.02683156728744507, -0.05891024321317673, 0.019710272550582886, -0.027038438245654106, -0.02499150112271309, 0.03093571960926056, 0.03441610187292099, 0.020931299775838852, -0.02789740450680256, 0.023945624008774757, 0.004357184749096632, 0.04286065697669983, 0.005109160207211971, 0.019726285710930824, -0.04169850051403046, -0.029624955728650093, -0.026241393759846687, -0.05710857734084129, -0.014690914191305637, -0.01087888889014721, -0.05518596991896629, -0.011978456750512123, -0.05077749863266945, 0.017005708068609238, -0.018483934924006462, 0.047153666615486145, 0.006534029729664326, -0.011031586676836014, 0.039975348860025406, -0.0046016378328204155, -0.0041807303205132484, 0.0473051518201828, 0.034966208040714264, -0.019025351852178574, -0.07518620789051056, 0.07647128403186798, 0.11721419543027878, -0.05454917997121811, -0.09123428165912628, 0.02028415910899639, -0.00848984532058239, -0.0034050841350108385, 0.03441484272480011, 0.0805530846118927, 0.013623770326375961, 0.041838452219963074, -0.002585437847301364, -0.0062179905362427235, 0.0381755493581295, -0.001275973510928452, 0.027915898710489273, 0.036604996770620346, 0.05656077340245247, 0.005693537648767233, -0.04756706953048706, 0.06765095144510269, 0.005459097679704428, -0.009681252762675285, -0.0023973770439624786, -0.028232432901859283, -0.029244186356663704, 0.018872149288654327, -0.0551571361720562, -0.013616696000099182, -0.0008265720680356026, 0.03375519439578056, -0.05369437485933304, -0.003876336384564638, 0.006674467585980892, -0.009247205220162868, 0.01817507855594158, 0.03295516595244408, 0.08870721608400345, -0.014233045279979706, -0.03382306173443794, 0.015520645305514336, -0.07248193025588989, -0.010486937128007412, -0.02801709808409214, 0.024082111194729805, -0.03402046859264374, -0.004226159304380417, -0.02121591381728649, 0.006333599332720041, -0.015195953659713268, -0.00911630131304264, -0.05192386358976364, 0.016701029613614082, -0.036420345306396484, -0.016208922490477562, 0.014972888864576817, 0.012002835050225258, 0.02448786050081253, -0.06437740474939346, -0.047492533922195435, 0.0008402220555581152, -0.011645056307315826, 0.04428471624851227, -0.02250005304813385, -0.06586232036352158, -0.022639410570263863, -0.020095737650990486, 0.004475120455026627, -0.024826541543006897, -0.0815131664276123, 0.051656849682331085, 0.05438646674156189, 0.04323386773467064, -0.028406359255313873, 0.017340730875730515, -0.008957906626164913, 0.0028310560155659914, 0.007378982845693827, 0.010452077724039555, 0.047330040484666824, 0.03658280521631241, 0.06088459864258766, -0.034195464104413986, -0.02282072976231575, 0.06956484913825989, -0.048783078789711, 0.03628457710146904, -0.05428819730877876, -0.03951997682452202, -0.03175745904445648, -0.0692441388964653, -0.021529357880353928, -0.000857968523632735, 0.038296494632959366, -0.0326862633228302, -0.020073311403393745, 0.015736306086182594, 0.05531809851527214, -0.004638642072677612, 0.0386575311422348, -0.04655630141496658, -0.046282727271318436, 0.030127841979265213, 0.015741335228085518, 0.03448997437953949, 0.025774966925382614, 0.03514646366238594, 0.048396941274404526, -0.015329889953136444, 0.0014323493232950568, -0.002278665080666542, 0.056854456663131714, -0.03293124586343765, 0.05846940726041794, 0.018430141732096672, -0.03578818589448929, -0.049282256513834, -0.01755456253886223, 0.11150939762592316, 0.06701788306236267, -0.010393110103905201, 0.01145014725625515, 0.040003444999456406, 0.0049598850309848785, -0.00963100790977478, 0.009078187867999077, 0.030284453183412552, -0.06541819870471954, 0.026086119934916496, -0.053407084196805954, 0.046160388737916946, -0.015952181071043015, -0.010184647515416145, 0.029758905991911888, -0.022112932056188583, 0.07509081065654755, 0.03226284310221672, -0.014557542279362679, -0.02675897441804409, 0.0019749486818909645, -0.04053213447332382, 0.04204796627163887, 0.010416451841592789, 0.004353253170847893, 0.012951959855854511, 0.006196352653205395, -0.037892892956733704, -0.07929538935422897, 0.005423767492175102, -0.007316926494240761, -0.05920364707708359, 0.031791575253009796, -0.005086127202957869, -0.04890992119908333, -0.020614221692085266, -0.0007076209876686335, 0.03208574280142784, 0.017296943813562393, -0.032649725675582886, 0.039395030587911606, 0.0013839148450642824, -0.04456045478582382, 0.04753312095999718, 0.04017646238207817, -0.027507435530424118, -0.01711255870759487, 0.023551171645522118, -0.01992644928395748, -0.0875166654586792, -0.006006163079291582, -0.04531973600387573, -0.028738288208842278, 0.03188757225871086, -0.018962044268846512, 0.0896364226937294, 0.005443571601063013, -0.030798736959695816, 0.018919382244348526, -0.03849086910486221, 0.032741729170084, 0.033160626888275146, 0.009582209400832653, -0.007947751320898533, 0.05322524905204773, -0.022388946264982224, 0.027160365134477615, -0.030792614445090294, 0.003936026245355606, -0.019312776625156403, -0.018316740170121193, -0.05266759172081947, -0.04370886832475662, -0.038559965789318085, 0.0650390163064003, -0.012572248466312885, 0.03206226974725723, -0.022027743980288506, 0.004960769321769476, 0.022356940433382988, -0.010506706312298775, 0.028446724638342857, 0.0003585795930121094, 0.04229481518268585, -0.02352386899292469, 0.019009647890925407, 0.05436857044696808, 0.03077583760023117, -0.00809005182236433, 0.011403585784137249, 0.049648918211460114, 0.004311806056648493, 0.015703916549682617, 0.031824953854084015, -0.00769465696066618, 0.015399607829749584, 0.05734589323401451, -0.024415047839283943, -0.052056118845939636, 0.0009134754654951394, -0.0037847179919481277, 0.012618173845112324, 0.018653227016329765, -0.05145527422428131, -0.00934400875121355, -0.01075008139014244, -0.02313767746090889, -0.0298378374427557, 0.00860891118645668, 0.024404501542448997, 0.0241836030036211, -0.00011285533400950953, 0.011155766434967518, 0.0573880560696125, -0.05637693777680397, -0.06938745081424713, -0.014332865364849567, -0.02756698615849018, -0.08095795661211014, -0.020865540951490402, -0.0017364909872412682, 0.04709503427147865, 0.025550274178385735, -0.048111893236637115, -0.07513324171304703, 0.025762805715203285, 0.016445182263851166, -0.0443105585873127, -0.025891108438372612, 0.011417543515563011, -0.01956045813858509, 0.031752120703458786, -0.04256579652428627, 0.024248367175459862, 0.00554411206394434, -0.020425990223884583, 0.03469522297382355, 0.0766686499118805, 0.015993690118193626, 0.08460530638694763, -0.010430512018501759, 0.044400595128536224, 0.020730149000883102, -0.0749545469880104, -0.01979687251150608, -0.07397475838661194, 0.041028622537851334, -0.03673885762691498, -0.041271667927503586, -0.040132589638233185, -0.0009545269422233105, -0.05163881927728653, -0.004494749009609222, -0.00003479627048363909, -0.029308246448636055, 0.004090501926839352, -0.03645210340619087, 0.02996785379946232, 0.05644042789936066, -0.0029760529287159443, -0.012866753153502941, -0.0519971139729023, 0.02518421597778797, -0.002063415478914976, -0.01082608476281166, 0.020865175873041153, 0.03351890668272972, 0.04194242134690285, -0.05263390392065048, 0.045192163437604904, -0.027595676481723785, 0.025422481819987297, 0.02225865237414837, 0.029118617996573448, -0.0004823433409910649, -0.005423855967819691, -0.060140788555145264, 0.019138233736157417, -0.04737627133727074, -0.016137229278683662, -0.02890915796160698, 0.04790123179554939, 0.07112587243318558, 0.028345255181193352, -0.0514029897749424, -0.02584460750222206, 0.03703102469444275, 0.050478216260671616, -0.03285612910985947, -0.004812208004295826, -0.053361259400844574, 0.04163794219493866, 0.00875002145767212, -0.05754515528678894, 0.008716141805052757, 0.0062765153124928474, -0.008081015199422836, -0.04155287519097328, 0.012829973362386227, -0.022235393524169922, 0.00883356761187315, -0.01819583959877491, 0.06750054657459259, -0.00560802360996604, -0.0032211083453148603, -0.004994101822376251, 0.014831430278718472, 0.050957534462213516, -0.04342106729745865, 0.0607757642865181, 0.02087508887052536, 0.006225146818906069, -0.0162355937063694, -0.04060759022831917, -0.05469762906432152, 0.002214177278801799, 0.013174035586416721, -0.05147543549537659, -0.021921692416071892, -0.036308448761701584, 0.032129738479852676, -0.03503020107746124, -0.05333622172474861, -0.019689219072461128 ]
<p>Pioneer <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_10">10</a> &amp; <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_11">11</a> are robotic space probes launched by the NASA in the early 1970's. After leaving our solar system, an <strong>unusual deceleration</strong> of both spacecrafts has been measured to be approximately $$\ddot{r}_p = -(8.74&#177;1.33)&#215;10^{−10} \frac{m}{s^2}$$ with respect to our solar system.</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_anomaly#Proposed_explanations">Several attempts</a> were made to <strong>explain this tiny effect</strong>, called the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_anomaly">Pioneer anomaly</a>, but none was fully accepted in the scientific community so far.</p> <p>Two months ago, <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1103.5222v1">Frederico Francisco et al</a> have proposed another solution to the problem. They assume, roughly speaking, that the <strong>thermal radiation</strong> of the spacecraft caused by plutonium on board along with the actual structure of the probes is responsible for this mystery of modern physics.</p> <p>Here an image of Pioneer 10 taken from Wikipedia along with a sketch of the <strong>radiation model</strong> employed in the paper: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Ukwcx.png" alt="Pioneer 10 and heat model"></p> <p>Hence my question:</p> <blockquote> <h3>Is the Pioneer anomaly finally explained?</h3> </blockquote> <p>Sincerely</p>
g6589
[ 0.04467477276921272, 0.03822809085249901, -0.006741278804838657, 0.010660102590918541, 0.031068574637174606, 0.06099915876984596, 0.021337486803531647, 0.03757094964385033, -0.013800038956105709, -0.03655068576335907, 0.04675523564219475, 0.04366208240389824, 0.0107832420617342, 0.003176160389557481, 0.041707903146743774, -0.0005685732467100024, 0.1149914488196373, -0.028405535966157913, 0.03095848485827446, 0.051292624324560165, 0.0016949304845184088, -0.012015328742563725, -0.021197181195020676, -0.04363378509879112, -0.014237308874726295, -0.017275772988796234, 0.0016009206883609295, -0.00036394078051671386, 0.028646867722272873, -0.018187379464507103, 0.026902280747890472, -0.029980000108480453, 0.04543839767575264, -0.050265032798051834, -0.02513173781335354, -0.04183175042271614, 0.003204566426575184, 0.019825320690870285, -0.016337554901838303, -0.01837889663875103, -0.010127132758498192, -0.03550155833363533, -0.015410416759550571, 0.035770248621702194, -0.013790409080684185, 0.0015924766194075346, -0.014391599223017693, -0.006592751946300268, 0.010162007063627243, 0.01896176114678383, -0.008265921846032143, -0.0067578330636024475, 0.043189603835344315, 0.013667126186192036, -0.009884919039905071, -0.013806089758872986, 0.010470835492014885, -0.007520495913922787, 0.08125483989715576, -0.0034592892043292522, 0.007515565492212772, 0.04175497964024544, 0.0277733001857996, -0.020364809781312943, 0.013804304413497448, -0.029172856360673904, 0.043210871517658234, 0.038860876113176346, 0.0023302689660340548, -0.05786912515759468, 0.045359134674072266, -0.02977462112903595, -0.07949670404195786, 0.02683880366384983, -0.03245819732546806, 0.024695225059986115, -0.013595047406852245, 0.003263480495661497, 0.027416156604886055, -0.013667350634932518, -0.029268953949213028, 0.03815058618783951, -0.032360199838876724, 0.02461862564086914, 0.05016491562128067, -0.025229569524526596, -0.040148116648197174, 0.0613635890185833, -0.009542637504637241, -0.04200351983308792, 0.002264154376462102, -0.021267149597406387, 0.015002747997641563, -0.022208694368600845, 0.015554710291326046, 0.021535301581025124, -0.010450977832078934, 0.032060761004686356, -0.04477090761065483, -0.022286782041192055, 0.008473112247884274, 0.03957822546362877, -0.0073185754008591175, 0.04226372018456459, 0.018123526126146317, -0.007839679718017578, 0.04191482812166214, 0.050051528960466385, -0.006003027781844139, -0.027758734300732613, -0.0023295702412724495, -0.024925801903009415, -0.0032922071404755116, -0.030729323625564575, 0.04687431454658508, -0.03898920863866806, 0.04593045637011528, -0.03332816809415817, -0.022681402042508125, 0.012036807835102081, -0.015354366041719913, 0.0009667720878496766, -0.05214032530784607, 0.1287270337343216, -0.07263890653848648, 0.02526354044675827, 0.014503571204841137, -0.07424923032522202, 0.0100754639133811, 0.03140825405716896, -0.017708254978060722, 0.07117627561092377, -0.02725127711892128, 0.04656938463449478, 0.06590433418750763, -0.0062889703549444675, -0.02730628103017807, 0.034153781831264496, 0.015186455100774765, 0.00435596564784646, -0.009718560613691807, -0.019699102267622948, 0.009092976339161396, -0.0030413768254220486, -0.03917532414197922, -0.01172536052763462, -0.055276162922382355, 0.06760801374912262, 0.036036472767591476, 0.058779578655958176, 0.04846939072012901, 0.0590861514210701, -0.03760877624154091, -0.05106798931956291, -0.04953734576702118, 0.012392477132380009, -0.030336571857333183, 0.04000452533364296, -0.03157515451312065, 0.009046096354722977, 0.04352610930800438, 0.02957826852798462, 0.010565636679530144, 0.034812089055776596, -0.055859457701444626, 0.04107538238167763, -0.01896081678569317, -0.09138715267181396, -0.009280601516366005, -0.016530726104974747, -0.051825471222400665, -0.02809717506170273, 0.01633230596780777, 0.0571211613714695, -0.030881624668836594, 0.030158663168549538, 0.05973758548498154, -0.06117677316069603, 0.026016484946012497, -0.013525057584047318, -0.029202697798609734, -0.009838400408625603, 0.026897627860307693, -0.009948167949914932, -0.002117140917107463, -0.022059712558984756, 0.04299111291766167, 0.0002904379216488451, -0.03391503542661667, -0.023490682244300842, -0.008903245441615582, -0.0022439302410930395, 0.011350132524967194, -0.050411660224199295, 0.036859165877103806, -0.0547117181122303, -0.0367155522108078, -0.011417812667787075, -0.060043442994356155, 0.06293685734272003, 0.012931426987051964, 0.002486970741301775, -0.0008974633528850973, -0.003364148549735546, 0.013419325463473797, -0.04248031601309776, -0.022371310740709305, -0.009361154399812222, 0.040386561304330826, -0.03878762573003769, -0.002629198832437396, -0.03235762193799019, -0.01384944561868906, 0.020625052973628044, -0.03403745964169502, -0.03160259872674942, 0.001419686945155263, -0.014749608933925629, 0.02458549290895462, -0.050104040652513504, -0.04496603459119797, 0.020050644874572754, -0.0002521157148294151, 0.021521510556340218, 0.0028163676615804434, 0.024234047159552574, 0.0024931312073022127, -0.07214297354221344, -0.07974006235599518, -0.002395347459241748, -0.05837910249829292, 0.03176932409405708, -0.055082377046346664, 0.004989129025489092, 0.07915613800287247, -0.0017645321786403656, -0.002705375896766782, -0.027359161525964737, -0.04678206890821457, 0.01753423735499382, -0.010191832669079304, -0.0012257221387699246, -0.08491714298725128, 0.017237624153494835, 0.04563876986503601, -0.08580716699361801, 0.02770817093551159, -0.0011220488231629133, -0.024619504809379578, -0.07423501461744308, 0.03882065787911415, -0.02739223651587963, -0.03428034856915474, -0.00688380841165781, 0.003084181807935238, 0.016725091263651848, -0.030548658221960068, 0.11084581166505814, -0.07534772902727127, -0.0637068971991539, 0.0004512182786129415, 0.013752717524766922, 0.0056925383396446705, 0.04507024586200714, -0.0031678678933531046, -0.001730473362840712, -0.029804401099681854, -0.03946845605969429, -0.06090002506971359, -0.04930412024259567, -0.011189567856490612, 0.05134693533182144, 0.03633740544319153, 0.05050532519817352, -0.014187050983309746, 0.06237952038645744, 0.0032660174183547497, -0.013835594989359379, 0.05458005145192146, -0.0214068666100502, -0.016530949622392654, 0.025700725615024567, -0.03328057751059532, -0.022856857627630234, -0.019718537107110023, -0.006051003001630306, -0.05984698235988617, 0.025421610102057457, 0.014603899791836739, -0.006309355143457651, 0.027186112478375435, -0.05975564569234848, 0.07324787229299545, -0.02227829396724701, 0.006579773500561714, 0.016560573130846024, 0.05616099014878273, 0.03427625447511673, -0.03630279004573822, -0.0036327929701656103, 0.14396175742149353, -0.06418770551681519, 0.009281319566071033, 0.007890294305980206, -0.028372520580887794, -0.0027649474795907736, -0.010142115876078606, -0.012988636270165443, -0.061053723096847534, -0.008153234608471394, -0.000450570514658466, 0.005828408524394035, -0.04957917705178261, 0.060651931911706924, 0.0017023467225953937, 0.007327771745622158, -0.08725100010633469, 0.01650347374379635, 0.011389090679585934, 0.04202466830611229, -0.039981529116630554, -0.06382973492145538, -0.0524136945605278, -0.01714632287621498, 0.06649723649024963, 0.025339968502521515, -0.020671363919973373, -0.04299895465373993, -0.04173393175005913, -0.0033451735507696867, 0.016639279201626778, -0.029646549373865128, -0.0444822832942009, -0.041451383382081985, -0.04706163331866264, 0.009026695042848587, -0.037334371358156204, 0.13037265837192535, 0.03608493134379387, 0.05627095699310303, -0.04114430770277977, 0.018352201208472252, -0.00956082995980978, -0.04123459756374359, 0.0343233123421669, 0.04403409734368324, 0.009050973691046238, -0.02765241637825966, -0.0429697148501873, 0.03353928029537201, 0.06697044521570206, 0.04423646628856659, -0.014387106522917747, -0.023799527436494827, -0.020930247381329536, 0.04408249258995056, -0.04338209703564644, -0.033620819449424744, 0.005831332877278328, -0.006108261179178953, -0.021725375205278397, 0.009648906998336315, 0.0074976845644414425, -0.004178995732218027, 0.03370196372270584, 0.01561951544135809, 0.025698954239487648, 0.07585613429546356, 0.0018268678104504943, -0.0632731169462204, -0.0522194504737854, 0.005371200852096081, -0.05111362412571907, -0.05171767249703407, 0.06637467443943024, -0.05286816507577896, 0.0477992482483387, -0.0009352501947432756, -0.04818720743060112, 0.08854671567678452, 0.012739741243422031, 0.008737107738852501, 0.03674367815256119, 0.01306641660630703, 0.08286638557910919, 0.014295476488769054, -0.01224333606660366, -0.03196367248892784, -0.013448868878185749, -0.07777844369411469, -0.05064082518219948, -0.0027455405797809362, -0.01696030981838703, 0.0054077403619885445, -0.005792719312012196, -0.03288224712014198, 0.02401665784418583, 0.022609643638134003, -0.005464139860123396, 0.007020073942840099, 0.040556617081165314, 0.028356177732348442, 0.014115473255515099, 0.008791796863079071, -0.016237657517194748, -0.023398103192448616, -0.019025396555662155, 0.004894690588116646, -0.041552044451236725, 0.02126564458012581, -0.0024622189812362194, 0.03689255565404892, -0.03240400552749634, -0.07582506537437439, 0.01602686010301113, 0.002609929069876671, 0.02290245145559311, 0.03609829768538475, 0.03724599629640579, 0.027157146483659744, -0.04035870358347893, 0.058650314807891846, -0.010419242084026337, 0.00729345390573144, 0.0742197334766388, 0.08135762810707092, -0.026135733351111412, 0.023660095408558846, 0.04980163648724556, -0.05330018699169159, 0.007628762628883123, 0.002934535499662161, -0.06549650430679321, 0.00892788264900446, 0.001699336338788271, 0.03414135426282883, 0.005366784054785967, 0.043582115322351456, -0.0385989286005497, 0.08298205584287643, 0.02317485213279724, -0.01048363372683525, 0.007664084900170565, 0.061077892780303955, 0.014112777076661587, 0.07938569784164429, 0.04288563132286072, -0.04794080927968025, 0.006966016720980406, -0.022717371582984924, -0.05491907149553299, -0.05007736757397652, 0.02294609695672989, 0.050605371594429016, -0.032577913254499435, -0.0019100378267467022, 0.033976390957832336, -0.028349921107292175, 0.0010350275551900268, 0.029664386063814163, -0.04542529210448265, 0.000632766867056489, 0.013487935066223145, 0.016559304669499397, 0.06736715883016586, -0.025848450139164925, -0.0649803876876831, -0.035186827182769775, -0.015857331454753876, -0.04744787886738777, -0.03844078630208969, -0.014326377771794796, 0.016827117651700974, 0.028351452201604843, -0.03151506930589676, 0.012737547047436237, 0.003431545803323388, -0.04083043336868286, 0.04737650975584984, 0.021860776469111443, 0.01580232009291649, 0.017533382400870323, -0.0009759516105987132, -0.011613588780164719, -0.011515372432768345, -0.016670869663357735, -0.08795545995235443, 0.03488455340266228, 0.04924863204360008, -0.039658792316913605, -0.013431561179459095, -0.029621699824929237, 0.016370898112654686, -0.038563307374715805, -0.001583582954481244, 0.007650061510503292, 0.004791914019733667, 0.024747787043452263, 0.0017163037555292249, 0.004937126301229, 0.02602192386984825, -0.0031111263670027256, 0.002316811354830861, 0.007120154798030853, 0.0004948535934090614, -0.013847715221345425, 0.049505386501550674, 0.024474959820508957, 0.03626023977994919, -0.03328273072838783, -0.06466308981180191, 0.08430163562297821, 0.02737765945494175, -0.02178339846432209, 0.01595202647149563, -0.018322058022022247, 0.016988787800073624, -0.02959807775914669, -0.013409052044153214, -0.052330534905195236, -0.01245749182999134, -0.06170196831226349, 0.05200094357132912, 0.018615558743476868, 0.0037611655425280333, 0.01885635033249855, -0.019992884248495102, 0.024966832250356674, 0.023955373093485832, 0.07362727075815201, -0.011366859078407288, 0.03510059043765068, 0.06391757726669312, 0.053864844143390656, -0.0007227638852782547, -0.015295553021132946, 0.03481706604361534, 0.018694749101996422, 0.02622709609568119, -0.04989676550030708, -0.02076706476509571, 0.034722745418548584, 0.0494181253015995, 0.026894686743617058, 0.010353172197937965, 0.03318752720952034, -0.00546224694699049, -0.007015787530690432, 0.04560986906290054, -0.05166131630539894, -0.01978037878870964, -0.009424016810953617, 0.02306295745074749, 0.034087199717760086, -0.01899082399904728, -0.012477309443056583, 0.002333076437935233, -0.03412895277142525, -0.09360809624195099, -0.07359456270933151, -0.019035344943404198, 0.004145079292356968, 0.05499870702624321, 0.01195363700389862, 0.046330541372299194, 0.022972585633397102, -0.011912324465811253, -0.07857000082731247, 0.027616873383522034, -0.04979385435581207, 0.013536886312067509, 0.0004221491690259427, 0.026249989867210388, 0.04179058596491814, 0.04341121390461922, 0.0050831944681704044, -0.026099350303411484, 0.03847047686576843, -0.0494048111140728, 0.0060886540450155735, -0.016254588961601257, 0.01204146258533001, 0.04929083213210106, -0.0053923907689750195, -0.03166890889406204, 0.010851801373064518, -0.07223497331142426, 0.042555589228868484, 0.055384814739227295, 0.0024286131374537945, -0.006575684063136578, -0.025086089968681335, -0.02610926888883114, 0.0018082682508975267, -0.06451234966516495, -0.01656956970691681, -0.0030165580101311207, 0.006746067199856043, -0.06250043213367462, 0.03188200667500496, -0.0179317407310009, 0.0036361890379339457, 0.08474859595298767, 0.0527835413813591, 0.049531057476997375, -0.02563786320388317, 0.0375385619699955, 0.029833456501364708, 0.039266493171453476, 0.025168973952531815, -0.023674989119172096, 0.03653091564774513, 0.010461068712174892, -0.019156642258167267, 0.003054145025089383, -0.028635764494538307, 0.004431078210473061, 0.009941104799509048, -0.024736452847719193, 0.04522118717432022, -0.0049680545926094055, 0.00663678627461195, -0.05085664615035057, -0.04017174243927002, -0.03756006434559822, 0.008757427334785461, 0.001997791463509202, -0.018695874139666557, 0.04390568658709526, 0.017016064375638962, -0.015371285378932953, 0.019157569855451584, 0.04439177364110947, 0.002383744576945901, -0.002669582376256585, -0.02543620578944683, 0.025694098323583603, 0.03733421117067337, -0.0070540872402489185, -0.013612029142677784, -0.003911205101758242, -0.031383540481328964, -0.042493440210819244, -0.02738087996840477, -0.0255419984459877, 0.04766193777322769, -0.008844261057674885, 0.04678463935852051, -0.02655521221458912, -0.01678466983139515, 0.021788237616419792, -0.049951229244470596, 0.029340701177716255, 0.004976864904165268, 0.041003815829753876, 0.011859075166285038, -0.013550754636526108, 0.02846408262848854, 0.031590815633535385, -0.049148477613925934, 0.04954100772738457, -0.033173929899930954, -0.0028603796381503344, 0.028537895530462265, -0.004639578051865101, 0.025204479694366455, -0.02157391980290413, -0.03416113182902336, -0.007163711823523045, -0.04305250197649002, 0.009004318155348301, -0.027191806584596634, -0.05558498576283455, -0.030217070132493973, -0.017329471185803413, 0.0003955381107516587, 0.044280149042606354, -0.08883191645145416, 0.045550718903541565, 0.0403391569852829, 0.033377375453710556, 0.030645029619336128, -0.009741870686411858, 0.007810833863914013, 0.011212361045181751, -0.02351253665983677, -0.04864173382520676, -0.03259638696908951, 0.0030789526645094156, 0.02843182347714901, -0.03831249475479126, 0.07983686774969101, 0.005820383317768574, 0.0286076832562685, 0.007517938502132893, 0.0077714333310723305, -0.04968574270606041, 0.018611261621117592, 0.007629890460520983, -0.026095733046531677, 0.00009497747669229284, 0.005466827191412449, 0.001018086331896484, 0.01545793004333973, -0.01982320286333561, 0.02472909912467003, 0.004938162863254547, -0.034428250044584274, -0.047696229070425034, -0.035338375717401505, -0.00017851525626610965, 0.000024857554308255203, 0.04048008471727371, -0.0122058792039752, -0.013491296209394932, -0.012947656214237213, -0.04389705881476402, -0.0028248934540897608, -0.017632586881518364, -0.07148458063602448, 0.009671145118772984, -0.024718977510929108, -0.01026144064962864, -0.017672181129455566, -0.002674684626981616, -0.04587386175990105, -0.009216527454555035, -0.049506593495607376, 0.08147114515304565, -0.017426444217562675, 0.063985675573349, 0.004926247056573629, -0.04822354391217232, -0.05802629515528679, -0.008267905563116074, 0.0032906709238886833, 0.009491545148193836, 0.01722658984363079, -0.008804243057966232, 0.006271899212151766, -0.004161179531365633, 0.013648295775055885, 0.01698707789182663, -0.0015380835393443704, -0.011837652884423733, -0.039441999047994614, -0.03018021211028099, 0.008483230136334896, -0.005736296996474266, -0.05492902174592018, 0.028886687010526657, -0.008795088157057762, -0.018181417137384415, -0.014177033677697182, 0.03787938877940178, 0.011544245295226574, -0.008267516270279884, 0.00616971030831337, -0.03351529315114021, -0.034537456929683685, -0.006074877921491861, -0.04199138656258583, -0.036580972373485565, -0.0113069461658597, 0.03468097746372223, -0.005812950897961855, 0.034606918692588806, -0.007165140938013792 ]
<p>In all the literature I've seen the turbulent energy spectrum described as $E(k)$ instead of $E(L)$, i.e. as a function of a wave number not eddy size. The connection via $k=2\pi/\lambda$ is clear, but exactly what wave process is meant here. Is the idea that turbulent flow can be viewed as a superposition of waves? Waves of what? Or is this just a common notation used for energy spectra? </p>
g6590
[ 0.03238056227564812, 0.010899857617914677, -0.021482186391949654, -0.07465516030788422, 0.0642060860991478, 0.001849031075835228, 0.026266565546393394, 0.03290135785937309, -0.049710340797901154, -0.05582597106695175, 0.0011052655754610896, 0.0029009422287344933, 0.06168070062994957, 0.02789091132581234, -0.03263407200574875, -0.06724507361650467, 0.045572105795145035, 0.023664768785238266, 0.002383053069934249, -0.012587243691086769, -0.04157876595854759, -0.019635921344161034, 0.015421269461512566, 0.009710684418678284, 0.020291442051529884, 0.01164928823709488, 0.0004475924069993198, -0.06359931826591492, -0.006876041181385517, -0.09089388698339462, 0.030004026368260384, 0.01339141745120287, 0.06252789497375488, -0.014606423676013947, -0.057617466896772385, 0.013091315515339375, 0.031191499903798103, 0.028346389532089233, 0.05762388929724693, -0.033015064895153046, 0.025327473878860474, 0.046156931668519974, -0.012427463196218014, -0.02388056181371212, -0.03355002403259277, 0.022130748257040977, -0.014219972304999828, 0.025488723069429398, -0.05224502831697464, -0.0005980503046885133, 0.027346234768629074, 0.013733350671827793, 0.034456394612789154, 0.03368910402059555, -0.0041748839430511, 0.04264319688081741, 0.008598832413554192, -0.015734681859612465, 0.06507930159568787, 0.06077918782830238, 0.04873872920870781, -0.033559102565050125, -0.025393541902303696, 0.014993644319474697, 0.07795043289661407, 0.03569083288311958, -0.0006570327095687389, -0.014448782429099083, 0.011105936020612717, -0.010310330428183079, 0.0372086800634861, -0.05778002738952637, 0.01305108331143856, -0.0528779961168766, -0.03184572979807854, -0.018276220187544823, 0.001514639938250184, -0.02441444806754589, 0.005853371229022741, 0.037089891731739044, 0.0300027746707201, -0.028387682512402534, -0.006233301945030689, 0.007951396517455578, 0.04258578270673752, 0.03729492798447609, -0.0021552590187639, 0.03414056450128555, -0.03218212351202965, -0.013634804636240005, 0.010146104730665684, -0.03758378326892853, 0.027483955025672913, 0.01008957251906395, 0.0027961761225014925, -0.008590265177190304, -0.022794876247644424, 0.02744905836880207, -0.018872173503041267, -0.004645128268748522, -0.036612268537282944, -0.003908858168870211, -0.021228281781077385, -0.031090129166841507, 0.01500796526670456, -0.0031616257037967443, -0.023494591936469078, -0.017794650048017502, 0.04090099409222603, -0.05782347172498703, -0.032206859439611435, 0.04386426508426666, -0.012708812020719051, 0.021177086979150772, -0.04623705521225929, -0.021675074473023415, 0.05202888324856758, -0.0017241941532120109, -0.0077407872304320335, 0.016124321147799492, 0.08612853288650513, -0.005285619292408228, 0.05053624510765076, 0.0524657778441906, 0.04701429605484009, 0.05335255712270737, 0.0014245754573494196, 0.001437856932170689, 0.04443035274744034, -0.018949048593640327, 0.08446085453033447, -0.030615847557783127, 0.007055081892758608, -0.027474287897348404, 0.06193482503294945, 0.043596863746643066, -0.018246466293931007, 0.015379219315946102, -0.03180426359176636, -0.014197265729308128, 0.024150392040610313, -0.042775657027959824, 0.021792039275169373, -0.0780111774802208, -0.04414668306708336, 0.003941608592867851, -0.0017733763670548797, -0.054844729602336884, 0.008480066433548927, 0.015678461641073227, -0.007610830012708902, 0.0181365255266428, -0.036748263984918594, -0.02648354135453701, 0.004320213105529547, 0.04067401587963104, 0.04486844316124916, -0.010732868686318398, 0.005013422109186649, 0.06094706803560257, 0.044552985578775406, 0.05361035838723183, 0.04175122454762459, -0.0033549948129802942, -0.05958952009677887, -0.01190652884542942, 0.028509659692645073, -0.005940414499491453, -0.015453144907951355, 0.0022367555648088455, 0.017960140481591225, -0.0033808471634984016, -0.010811546817421913, 0.012863623909652233, 0.02394629642367363, 0.06011735275387764, 0.06022229790687561, -0.028178608044981956, 0.027458421885967255, 0.0014713824493810534, -0.023813461884856224, 0.02285304293036461, 0.02479320950806141, -0.0418759286403656, 0.03484348952770233, 0.022776499390602112, -0.026241974905133247, 0.005029050167649984, 0.012106179259717464, 0.003805700223892927, 0.042211104184389114, -0.011532154865562916, 0.004739836789667606, 0.023594755679368973, -0.012682387605309486, 0.01992294192314148, -0.06345012784004211, -0.03336789831519127, -0.07893934100866318, -0.008941666223108768, 0.04086219519376755, 0.03028860315680504, 0.030629457905888557, 0.005266000051051378, 0.0530729778110981, 0.08921550959348679, -0.03326396644115448, -0.018761642277240753, -0.04236539825797081, 0.026320436969399452, -0.009998484514653683, -0.03308471664786339, -0.05800324305891991, -0.025634832680225372, 0.010132716037333012, -0.016356203705072403, 0.0012284638360142708, -0.007143043912947178, 0.0037902905605733395, 0.016574760898947716, -0.10074502974748611, -0.043213069438934326, 0.026145314797759056, 0.00831602979451418, 0.010986545123159885, 0.06370040029287338, -0.036042969673871994, -0.025496939197182655, 0.030827121809124947, -0.04133192449808121, -0.07361428439617157, 0.018776603043079376, -0.002015262609347701, -0.017013316974043846, -0.022808199748396873, 0.007625809404999018, 0.03448978066444397, 0.035039253532886505, -0.011752638034522533, 0.003931306768208742, 0.01693066395819187, 0.0026002556551247835, -0.01148796733468771, 0.028795016929507256, 0.027683183550834656, 0.031232925131917, 0.044039834290742874, 0.022906150668859482, -0.044446252286434174, -0.014740705490112305, -0.0020808163098990917, -0.08030498027801514, -0.011587067507207394, 0.031215714290738106, 0.0038851804565638304, -0.032242316752672195, 0.03605534881353378, 0.0928601399064064, -0.007151533383876085, 0.06442943960428238, 0.02234363555908203, 0.08614064007997513, -0.0096599031239748, -0.040116772055625916, -0.029717888683080673, -0.030399205163121223, 0.0063009317964315414, 0.058601390570402145, -0.024408288300037384, -0.04914039000868797, -0.01893213763833046, 0.04402470961213112, 0.02966003492474556, -0.023749981075525284, 0.013114863075315952, -0.08934071660041809, -0.019580118358135223, -0.042753178626298904, 0.05076117068529129, -0.023612169548869133, -0.002429133513942361, -0.0551106296479702, 0.001647536177188158, 0.03619001805782318, -0.019203217700123787, -0.10159607231616974, 0.0402352437376976, 0.07133793830871582, 0.04234479367733002, 0.010717657394707203, 0.03551674634218216, -0.01690262369811535, -0.04264359921216965, -0.0018633484141901135, -0.010774174705147743, 0.018221823498606682, 0.04789027199149132, -0.0033000160474330187, 0.010182141326367855, -0.02294432371854782, 0.009913516230881214, -0.013585301116108894, 0.0020113149657845497, -0.025941360741853714, 0.021554891020059586, 0.02547190897166729, -0.07181473076343536, -0.04461615905165672, -0.06978510320186615, -0.04459354281425476, -0.017269570380449295, 0.038053516298532486, -0.005157188978046179, 0.08534635603427887, -0.04363783076405525, 0.0408170148730278, -0.05932280048727989, -0.015911925584077835, -0.028496112674474716, 0.0015681536169722676, -0.06681860238313675, -0.04358678683638573, 0.07198918610811234, -0.027305949479341507, -0.003627309575676918, -0.012648563832044601, -0.018277032300829887, -0.03405731916427612, -0.019022513180971146, -0.011808712035417557, -0.03910953551530838, -0.007295097224414349, -0.008603820577263832, -0.002924505388364196, 0.0037011553067713976, 0.009053271263837814, -0.05449230968952179, -0.05675683170557022, -0.00003900512456311844, 0.06766274571418762, -0.02423730492591858, 0.011508227325975895, 0.003770829178392887, 0.00040933815762400627, 0.009745500981807709, 0.02989303134381771, -0.06373842060565948, -0.011362342163920403, -0.006998477037996054, -0.04022343084216118, -0.02284148894250393, 0.034949418157339096, 0.025782525539398193, -0.030159367248415947, 0.013910427689552307, -0.0004492116568144411, 0.002402079291641712, -0.015631597489118576, 0.010072100907564163, 0.02111697942018509, 0.04095911234617233, -0.020025528967380524, -0.00153327826410532, -0.05348922312259674, -0.006794368382543325, -0.028057172894477844, 0.01606765016913414, -0.013435843400657177, -0.013205927796661854, -0.019266707822680473, 0.0025704647414386272, -0.04072211682796478, 0.012297545559704304, -0.049820467829704285, 0.035297494381666183, -0.015073481947183609, 0.029692742973566055, 0.06553857028484344, 0.04517515376210213, 0.03029550425708294, 0.03581543639302254, -0.030913617461919785, 0.0003103629860561341, 0.0014783047372475266, -0.014480949379503727, -0.020141921937465668, -0.03878668323159218, 0.0697011724114418, -0.027286818251013756, -0.022050537168979645, 0.02467302791774273, -0.0552506148815155, -0.015190016478300095, -0.0006664275424554944, -0.008094307035207748, 0.020280862227082253, 0.05156874284148216, 0.004631091374903917, -0.05200580134987831, 0.09611905366182327, 0.023606088012456894, 0.0037313071079552174, -0.049433182924985886, 0.003826807253062725, -0.006903561297804117, 0.07245337218046188, 0.10026922821998596, -0.026767147704958916, 0.008226540870964527, -0.03237507492303848, 0.041799381375312805, 0.02572524920105934, -0.0026249580550938845, -0.07509100437164307, -0.025212349370121956, -0.003754626726731658, -0.0021561940666288137, -0.06238026171922684, 0.0028727243188768625, 0.05859587341547012, 0.03170308843255043, -0.012599656358361244, 0.012816774658858776, 0.034596461802721024, -0.014160407707095146, 0.05392925813794136, 0.057805050164461136, 0.04683560132980347, -0.05717672407627106, -0.03179767727851868, 0.014104647561907768, 0.016365397721529007, -0.0330190472304821, 0.009237709455192089, -0.05535687506198883, -0.017396366223692894, 0.03820229694247246, 0.008396207354962826, -0.03209308162331581, 0.04283241182565689, -0.02183702029287815, -0.007634578738361597, -0.006579239387065172, 0.03685050830245018, 0.04630570858716965, 0.008061015978455544, 0.01614106073975563, -0.039134733378887177, -0.07447054982185364, -0.012835709378123283, -0.0248730406165123, 0.03658114746212959, -0.012765821069478989, 0.03296402096748352, 0.005613344721496105, -0.03392259404063225, -0.01279398426413536, 0.013060765340924263, 0.008173766545951366, -0.021627355366945267, -0.031604792922735214, -0.00457055913284421, 0.005153751000761986, 0.015333755873143673, 0.037128549069166183, -0.005546177737414837, -0.04177282005548477, 0.010372134856879711, -0.043220240622758865, 0.008588007651269436, 0.05593160539865494, -0.02395637333393097, -0.024330472573637962, -0.033663831651210785, 0.027078619226813316, 0.0017011970048770308, -0.001029417384415865, -0.004756213165819645, 0.02063479647040367, -0.04116623476147652, 0.05103002116084099, -0.009532567113637924, -0.009995323605835438, -0.015458510257303715, -0.0014705018838867545, 0.028605980798602104, -0.011485552415251732, -0.005892092362046242, 0.003608781611546874, 0.040632884949445724, -0.005236157216131687, 0.030443474650382996, -0.025622989982366562, 0.012330672703683376, 0.06278979778289795, 0.0158621184527874, 0.05328725278377533, -0.07625216245651245, 0.010363411158323288, -0.0067604039795696735, 0.009300552308559418, -0.0367051362991333, -0.0223544929176569, 0.006033889017999172, 0.031141329556703568, 0.022043170407414436, 0.09999532997608185, 0.00996062345802784, -0.018360061571002007, 0.024753618985414505, -0.03766322508454323, -0.028614310547709465, -0.05406660586595535, 0.021773342043161392, -0.02769429050385952, -0.03230108693242073, -0.028663119301199913, -0.0011506957234814763, 0.020003652200102806, 0.05119581148028374, 0.022935887798666954, 0.028810661286115646, -0.05105871334671974, 0.00036684845690615475, -0.021517569199204445, 0.00562741793692112, -0.04930693283677101, 0.014882453717291355, 0.029441144317388535, 0.00718957232311368, -0.008870325982570648, 0.0005229124799370766, 0.024766813963651657, 0.031302858144044876, 0.035352922976017, -0.013329978100955486, -0.012165883556008339, 0.02110757865011692, 0.0070887235924601555, 0.08894039690494537, 0.0256876852363348, -0.011929620988667011, -0.05445703864097595, 0.03622222691774368, -0.012058015912771225, 0.058853160589933395, 0.05335189774632454, 0.05832403898239136, 0.007659986615180969, -0.061349838972091675, 0.024715041741728783, -0.017118215560913086, 0.05350010097026825, -0.0216688085347414, -0.038014039397239685, 0.030312100425362587, 0.07533294707536697, -0.055288683623075485, -0.033231209963560104, 0.006736378185451031, -0.004600585903972387, 0.03815418854355812, -0.010388991795480251, -0.03388197347521782, 0.05447046831250191, -0.03883439302444458, -0.0033784459810703993, -0.0353863388299942, -0.027239760383963585, 0.07361675798892975, -0.03841729089617729, -0.04083092883229256, 0.004048763308674097, -0.020126767456531525, 0.007499843370169401, -0.04893280938267708, 0.04910324513912201, -0.010650784708559513, -0.037714023143053055, -0.05174323916435242, -0.016501300036907196, 0.004322633612900972, 0.021435948088765144, -0.006178976967930794, -0.02920941263437271, 0.0035375047009438276, -0.026894763112068176, -0.02969697117805481, 0.013317473232746124, 0.09823352098464966, -0.05507037416100502, -0.02839406207203865, -0.05019513890147209, 0.03793894127011299, -0.004667174071073532, 0.0021955559495836496, -0.044568099081516266, 0.009752485901117325, -0.005726858042180538, 0.030030515044927597, -0.01644434593617916, -0.005827899556607008, 0.00910852663218975, -0.04434556886553764, -0.03899846598505974, -0.009692265652120113, -0.010677757672965527, 0.011350424028933048, -0.09738675504922867, 0.06222911179065704, 0.008980498649179935, -0.0410614013671875, 0.050776999443769455, -0.03991391509771347, -0.018035950139164925, -0.0032219775021076202, -0.03501972556114197, 0.0103067671880126, 0.025297371670603752, -0.02040587179362774, 0.060715336352586746, -0.09190087765455246, 0.021254975348711014, -0.005515276920050383, 0.027529872953891754, 0.022078702226281166, -0.03389057144522667, 0.006613498087972403, 0.036287419497966766, 0.0375661738216877, 0.018958481028676033, -0.023019710555672646, -0.015131721273064613, 0.08917304128408432, -0.06045408919453621, -0.042374808341264725, -0.072117879986763, 0.006378886289894581, 0.04614591225981712, 0.06241916865110397, -0.016843272373080254, 0.0722222849726677, -0.00040671046008355916, 0.016632627695798874, -0.03073466196656227, -0.007945533841848373, -0.002909601666033268, -0.0168886911123991, -0.0939290001988411, -0.06259950250387192, -0.05388255789875984, -0.016712570562958717, -0.039627157151699066, -0.01453428529202938, -0.032849691808223724, -0.0018122972687706351, -0.019962307065725327, 0.004419853910803795, 0.02682790532708168, -0.04204852133989334, 0.05262867361307144, 0.04283875226974487, -0.046848151832818985, -0.0011596539989113808, 0.00582239031791687, 0.03745613619685173, 0.04738198593258858, -0.0318470261991024, 0.014192719012498856, -0.027623847126960754, 0.02875443361699581, -0.03422679752111435, -0.025345327332615852, -0.02702196128666401, -0.0783182829618454, 0.013118548318743706, -0.04134448245167732, -0.031493596732616425, 0.001455236691981554, -0.011545930989086628, -0.03255990147590637, 0.048774830996990204, 0.06699298322200775, -0.02032516710460186, 0.001180444029159844, 0.05180588737130165, -0.0689137876033783, -0.010506372898817062, -0.04085899516940117, -0.03788688778877258, -0.024628277868032455, 0.06992509216070175, 0.028910253196954727, -0.038840629160404205, -0.02709045633673668, 0.01280828658491373, 0.010063611902296543, -0.0171981081366539, -0.006609957665205002, 0.08608782291412354, 0.07895243167877197, -0.010883253999054432, -0.032987579703330994, 0.003054662374779582, -0.010644768364727497, 0.0057115196250379086, 0.033529218286275864, -0.041448891162872314, -0.02258848212659359, -0.024034937843680382, -0.01328308880329132, -0.020765356719493866, 0.007967617362737656, 0.014868906699120998, -0.006706956773996353, 0.006477889139205217, 0.02002861350774765, 0.010950176976621151, -0.06894790381193161, 0.01219885516911745, 0.041942380368709564, 0.043807461857795715, -0.003389347344636917, -0.030177682638168335, 0.036853305995464325, 0.017304029315710068, 0.008845822885632515, 0.02583261765539646, -0.018146498128771782, -0.017403898760676384, -0.06965664774179459, 0.019458899274468422, -0.03190182149410248, -0.01770656183362007, -0.03231046721339226, -0.024559833109378815, 0.026371261104941368, 0.011159011162817478, 0.05655292049050331, -0.025109564885497093, 0.02743157185614109, -0.0016753999516367912, -0.004561095964163542, 0.009533054195344448, -0.014581744559109211, -0.07058613747358322, -0.037132952362298965, -0.045159343630075455, -0.03222426399588585, -0.029798895120620728, 0.012375496327877045, 0.0937652513384819, 0.03536777198314667, 0.0648854523897171, 0.07193063199520111, -0.031828902661800385, 0.027234068140387535, 0.025412501767277718, -0.02532496489584446, -0.005101833026856184, -0.019559772685170174, 0.02538994699716568, -0.006432163063436747, -0.008421595208346844, -0.0428907684981823, -0.03943416476249695, 0.03532668203115463, 0.06902986019849777 ]
<p>I've seen many science popularisation documentaries and read few books (obviously not being scientist myself). I am able to <em>process and understand</em> basic ideas behind most of these. However for general relativity there is this one illustration, which is being used over and over (image from Wikipedia):</p> <p><img src="http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/22/Spacetime_curvature.png" alt="Spacetime curvature (from Wikipedia)"></p> <p>I always thought that general relativity gives another way how you can describe gravity. However for this illustration to work, there needs to be another force, pulling the object down (referring to a direction in the attached image). If I put two non-moving objects in the image, what force will pull them together?</p> <p>So where is my understanding incorrect? Or is general relativity not about explaining gravity and just describes how heavy objects bends spacetime (in that case the analogy is being used not correctly in my opinion)?</p> <hr> <p><strong>UPDATE</strong> Thank you for the answers and comments. Namely the XKCD comics is a spot on. I understand that the analogy with bent sheet of fabric pretty bad, but it seems that it can be fixed if you don't bent the fabric, but just distort the drawn grid. </p> <p>Would you be so kind and answer the second part of the question as well - whether general relativity is explaining gravitational force. To me it seems that it is not (bending of spacetime simply can not affect two non-moving objects). However most of the time it is being presented that it does.</p>
g6591
[ -0.0013714126544073224, 0.04203972965478897, -0.006108108442276716, -0.035402197390794754, 0.05835016071796417, 0.055400069802999496, 0.023938069120049477, 0.03278118371963501, -0.04997308924794197, -0.04558849707245827, 0.06654645502567291, -0.04016200825572014, 0.02848927490413189, 0.007631178945302963, 0.011557251214981079, 0.03000451996922493, 0.05538209527730942, -0.03417014330625534, 0.05739828571677208, 0.03362196311354637, -0.005935992579907179, 0.01820109598338604, 0.03790230304002762, -0.037690553814172745, -0.09768330305814743, -0.025568939745426178, 0.01215091161429882, -0.015005337074398994, -0.07977322489023209, -0.027171725407242775, 0.042491041123867035, 0.023709522560238838, 0.009864523075520992, -0.0936572402715683, -0.009221384301781654, -0.020321927964687347, 0.016554392874240875, -0.0047256615944206715, 0.004829114302992821, 0.04231639578938484, -0.05081091821193695, 0.02670496702194214, 0.007175246253609657, -0.02149515226483345, 0.02326935902237892, -0.024495046585798264, -0.037628207355737686, -0.012001658789813519, 0.053722865879535675, -0.062357667833566666, 0.0027006797026842833, 0.060473088175058365, 0.054606202989816666, 0.00016934171435423195, 0.022612743079662323, -0.014508817344903946, 0.02022925205528736, 0.0017744738142937422, 0.09756752103567123, -0.0006749521708115935, -0.03163984790444374, 0.03982889652252197, 0.051193393766880035, -0.0025387019850313663, 0.016918214038014412, 0.036212753504514694, -0.02368265576660633, -0.032565563917160034, 0.04364977777004242, -0.007912012748420238, 0.020895374938845634, 0.00836536567658186, 0.010230359621345997, -0.016726532950997353, -0.052051663398742676, 0.02600260265171528, -0.0031233348418027163, -0.00019453854474704713, -0.0021932567469775677, 0.004028958734124899, -0.0022340151481330395, 0.029400497674942017, 0.021035615354776382, 0.05712456256151199, 0.12837262451648712, -0.010568302124738693, -0.04764656722545624, 0.019460899755358696, 0.019433805719017982, 0.03288619592785835, 0.04103581979870796, -0.027491845190525055, 0.029014529660344124, 0.05245751142501831, -0.02424478903412819, -0.03631909191608429, -0.03301330655813217, 0.05211319029331207, -0.00945034809410572, 0.03263475000858307, -0.04378027841448784, -0.013518721796572208, 0.006748302839696407, 0.022043952718377113, -0.019872920587658882, 0.03545636311173439, 0.023957088589668274, 0.059362176805734634, 0.01643696241080761, -0.056814588606357574, -0.09060391783714294, -0.005935553926974535, 0.009412314742803574, -0.03400832414627075, 0.005838474724441767, -0.04728156700730324, 0.07909274846315384, -0.02748933620750904, -0.0004432254354469478, 0.00651837233453989, -0.0205093827098608, 0.05728312209248543, 0.027681227773427963, 0.05459143593907356, -0.026058310642838478, -0.06103525310754776, 0.03333663195371628, -0.009431895799934864, -0.012610949575901031, -0.027143210172653198, 0.022140424698591232, -0.029104266315698624, 0.09377864748239517, 0.01621861197054386, -0.01610550656914711, 0.033807478845119476, -0.0016315019456669688, -0.02569710835814476, -0.03019420988857746, 0.020018495619297028, 0.01047398429363966, -0.044636402279138565, 0.032190367579460144, -0.030630039051175117, 0.006109080743044615, 0.023585733026266098, -0.03291090205311775, 0.038399625569581985, 0.04491722211241722, -0.006971017457544804, 0.01679827645421028, 0.09449280053377151, 0.0005112834624014795, -0.08651123195886612, 0.05640575662255287, -0.006150154862552881, 0.009782345965504646, 0.007215464953333139, 0.04996167868375778, 0.03151295706629753, 0.07766395807266235, -0.0165127944201231, -0.03757091984152794, 0.005207208916544914, -0.03953249379992485, 0.031152695417404175, -0.020938411355018616, -0.047349948436021805, 0.0051259673200547695, -0.022548632696270943, -0.054962169378995895, -0.025815965607762337, 0.013125689700245857, 0.04441973939538002, -0.022063642740249634, 0.026976242661476135, 0.03940301388502121, -0.04955127462744713, -0.024856112897396088, -0.019504424184560776, -0.013904400169849396, -0.05075123906135559, 0.0014373688027262688, -0.04176754876971245, -0.017587043344974518, -0.02114252559840679, -0.02610079012811184, 0.044966667890548706, -0.012327715754508972, 0.04140409082174301, -0.03230055794119835, -0.02189958468079567, 0.006951907183974981, 0.011975256726145744, -0.03721485286951065, 0.0034433691762387753, 0.03152594715356827, -0.01112257968634367, -0.010579322464764118, 0.03321400657296181, 0.010592318139970303, -0.022727129980921745, 0.026486678048968315, 0.011164953000843525, 0.02734263800084591, 0.027646157890558243, -0.0773925930261612, 0.013710280880331993, 0.05744519457221031, -0.029439281672239304, 0.05869726464152336, -0.034964483231306076, 0.04157854616641998, -0.0397205613553524, -0.034106913954019547, 0.005391085520386696, -0.028116052970290184, 0.005856386385858059, -0.07478906959295273, 0.02518322877585888, 0.002508427482098341, -0.015841461718082428, 0.047302402555942535, -0.02451738528907299, 0.010398544371128082, 0.009062395431101322, -0.006262979470193386, -0.043765198439359665, 0.01055071596056223, -0.012115697376430035, -0.07208926230669022, -0.025987902656197548, -0.0185543242841959, 0.0033500988502055407, 0.05027076601982117, -0.00011391934822313488, 0.011963450349867344, 0.00653028255328536, 0.006761581636965275, -0.01192293781787157, 0.014305510558187962, -0.0242319293320179, 0.002759090391919017, -0.040074847638607025, 0.034783508628606796, -0.0009436547989025712, 0.03824354335665703, -0.07177522778511047, 0.03477449715137482, 0.05494282767176628, 0.028239676728844643, -0.050133924931287766, -0.06481423228979111, 0.010324389673769474, 0.036964014172554016, 0.006093522533774376, -0.004727625288069248, 0.051895368844270706, -0.10824386030435562, -0.015215196646749973, 0.04476133733987808, -0.06069966405630112, -0.010877726599574089, 0.04269018769264221, -0.09310977160930634, -0.026295993477106094, 0.011148640885949135, -0.000014391909644473344, -0.0031101806089282036, 0.019624236971139908, -0.04567587748169899, 0.014281011186540127, -0.03937060758471489, -0.04010637104511261, -0.04476715996861458, 0.021224496886134148, -0.029313543811440468, -0.011631857603788376, -0.059308044612407684, -0.045705635100603104, 0.02514311857521534, -0.004857910796999931, -0.036261770874261856, -0.04165465384721756, 0.05590938404202461, -0.010885666124522686, -0.05209878832101822, -0.024882258847355843, 0.02860523760318756, 0.03803865984082222, -0.010481790639460087, 0.03695716708898544, 0.016679657623171806, -0.042756058275699615, -0.037710417062044144, 0.004898746497929096, -0.018193764612078667, 0.02249377965927124, -0.02755124680697918, -0.012365230359137058, -0.010589266195893288, 0.020764127373695374, 0.052692245692014694, 0.047071002423763275, -0.0008561841677874327, -0.031503960490226746, -0.003774663433432579, -0.08377397805452347, -0.018023351207375526, -0.037237800657749176, 0.012021545320749283, 0.013413730077445507, 0.023573031648993492, 0.04501769691705704, -0.012606765143573284, -0.02541940100491047, 0.004721478093415499, 0.002338364953175187, 0.001981790643185377, 0.016281235963106155, 0.02318362146615982, 0.010840246453881264, 0.00046559583279304206, -0.002436634385958314, -0.028234755620360374, 0.031148051843047142, -0.003915541339665651, -0.024550046771764755, 0.0017784514930099249, -0.017131300643086433, 0.03626324608922005, -0.03637063503265381, -0.022245323285460472, -0.015122965909540653, -0.05652960389852524, 0.02864951640367508, 0.020208995789289474, -0.043158259242773056, 0.047798626124858856, -0.011799132451415062, 0.028308497741818428, -0.05385415628552437, -0.06292290985584259, 0.018583746626973152, 0.021536463871598244, 0.03959503024816513, 0.02930956706404686, 0.010655113495886326, -0.042995162308216095, -0.017577655613422394, 0.018815219402313232, -0.025268882513046265, 0.0009640646167099476, -0.01679879054427147, -0.01793310046195984, -0.0010067842667922378, 0.0018662252696231008, 0.010985169559717178, -0.031210357323288918, -0.035918839275836945, 0.03247386962175369, 0.0022928775288164616, -0.029715469107031822, 0.03713798150420189, -0.00666958000510931, 0.011794941499829292, 0.030115025117993355, 0.0008982883882708848, -0.028223687782883644, -0.008920402266085148, 0.0422656312584877, 0.0029277605935931206, -0.02507011592388153, 0.004627312067896128, 0.05714207515120506, -0.0360071063041687, 0.06194378808140755, 0.014355646446347237, -0.03102528676390648, 0.035434894263744354, 0.06271526962518692, 0.04108421504497528, 0.02310749888420105, 0.028679724782705307, 0.057432305067777634, -0.015776360407471657, -0.032523225992918015, -0.0011330818524584174, 0.017179634422063828, -0.021974436938762665, -0.01852395012974739, 0.002093240153044462, -0.017873290926218033, -0.02717244252562523, -0.0196518674492836, -0.010623489506542683, 0.02116706408560276, 0.06123194098472595, 0.016154548153281212, -0.004234398249536753, -0.03557037189602852, 0.036722827702760696, -0.011743729934096336, 0.014388902112841606, -0.033626489341259, -0.0031771643552929163, 0.029613640159368515, -0.05229893699288368, -0.02419177256524563, -0.042553700506687164, 0.036657389253377914, 0.05638866499066353, -0.013543600216507912, -0.07442457228899002, 0.07089309394359589, -0.011023523285984993, 0.013626959174871445, 0.03125912696123123, 0.0030970140360295773, 0.03375724330544472, 0.013981607742607594, 0.08147779852151871, -0.02829822525382042, -0.018903808668255806, -0.017338449135422707, 0.12241879105567932, -0.0034772781655192375, -0.002075537573546171, 0.04963389411568642, -0.03138578310608864, -0.0007160084205679595, 0.003566908184438944, 0.016172192990779877, 0.014350274577736855, -0.05919702723622322, 0.0721946656703949, 0.017646070569753647, 0.08459599316120148, 0.01739196479320526, -0.0016557929338887334, 0.08842184394598007, 0.026365945115685463, 0.0216655470430851, -0.005015740171074867, -0.01886332966387272, 0.02031417191028595, -0.04016847535967827, -0.005673930048942566, -0.02755492925643921, -0.024300720542669296, -0.06402313709259033, 0.012624640017747879, 0.011164073832333088, -0.012782271951436996, -0.00928895641118288, 0.02916758321225643, 0.025591937825083733, -0.0026827254332602024, -0.04053883999586105, 0.003555733012035489, -0.05242815241217613, -0.004245483782142401, 0.02156616374850273, 0.004130193963646889, 0.013335301540791988, -0.021053584292531013, -0.06983698904514313, -0.03660183399915695, -0.015486433170735836, 0.015558741986751556, -0.030851585790514946, -0.023514561355113983, -0.039966341108083725, 0.0075649358332157135, 0.04606589674949646, 0.05081389099359512, -0.023472484201192856, 0.021793808788061142, -0.008918448351323605, -0.0401916429400444, -0.01870923861861229, -0.022804664447903633, 0.04586510732769966, -0.07466089725494385, 0.03730341047048569, -0.030225833877921104, 0.026651857420802116, 0.044550348073244095, 0.04852162301540375, -0.008637896738946438, 0.013458678498864174, -0.06099095195531845, -0.029254766181111336, -0.007427804172039032, -0.02612530253827572, 0.028235817328095436, 0.014181209728121758, -0.008391055278480053, 0.0015079195145517588, -0.04376951605081558, 0.013223768211901188, 0.07600430399179459, 0.018875865265727043, -0.019549543038010597, -0.02288670465350151, 0.03341077268123627, 0.053842127323150635, -0.0651361271739006, -0.020662184804677963, 0.13946011662483215, -0.020338328555226326, -0.004731704946607351, -0.014104652218520641, 0.019446536898612976, 0.06712343543767929, -0.01576213724911213, 0.026965485885739326, 0.014642898924648762, 0.05497186258435249, -0.02163773775100708, 0.02843368612229824, 0.02060122601687908, 0.004333102609962225, -0.039924997836351395, 0.012756016105413437, -0.017494160681962967, -0.03449182212352753, 0.04250889644026756, 0.047288332134485245, 0.04942190274596214, 0.009311329573392868, 0.02239813655614853, 0.04675109684467316, 0.032060544937849045, 0.008512676693499088, -0.01963835395872593, 0.038632117211818695, 0.009207447059452534, 0.05429573729634285, -0.04235612973570824, -0.026632897555828094, 0.026949848979711533, -0.016257567331194878, 0.060512740164995193, -0.04209038242697716, 0.01520788948982954, -0.022807294502854347, -0.04165026918053627, 0.052276868373155594, -0.01704096421599388, -0.019236134365200996, -0.024614594876766205, 0.03661078214645386, 0.053092870861291885, 0.023782679811120033, 0.016138922423124313, 0.019384566694498062, -0.1122748926281929, 0.05918969213962555, -0.009131267666816711, 0.021881498396396637, -0.019477492198348045, -0.00941876694560051, -0.011897897347807884, 0.035579655319452286, 0.005025964695960283, 0.02569899894297123, -0.020627206191420555, 0.0684601366519928, 0.037476036697626114, -0.03418729081749916, -0.002457710914313793, 0.0368269719183445, 0.009854163974523544, -0.026082690805196762, 0.003580824239179492, -0.00854029692709446, -0.016001978889107704, -0.06651628017425537, -0.0045190248638391495, 0.00642057042568922, -0.02409629337489605, 0.012044709175825119, -0.06095598638057709, -0.07690167427062988, 0.038656365126371384, -0.06870532035827637, -0.0173804834485054, 0.01583246886730194, -0.02320421300828457, -0.022182326763868332, 0.0025230119936168194, 0.01747826673090458, -0.03048705868422985, -0.04670337960124016, -0.028782330453395844, 0.023686280474066734, 0.010753883048892021, -0.014758842065930367, -0.0019828344229608774, -0.06648369878530502, 0.023948246613144875, 0.01722114160656929, 0.017581192776560783, 0.03104531019926071, -0.01220212783664465, -0.02870986983180046, -0.020575828850269318, 0.03315671160817146, -0.03728009760379791, -0.06135222688317299, 0.02158760093152523, -0.009749425575137138, 0.032672587782144547, -0.010831682942807674, -0.04784129932522774, -0.032016728073358536, -0.008173485286533833, 0.0108613520860672, -0.04749177396297455, -0.012601288966834545, 0.006891594734042883, 0.05077109485864639, 0.007725810166448355, 0.01924699731171131, 0.023547999560832977, -0.05314926430583, 0.031294457614421844, 0.020243456587195396, 0.013427932746708393, -0.05624040216207504, -0.0343073345720768, -0.023529592901468277, 0.011321654543280602, 0.004544752184301615, 0.08630490303039551, -0.023559747263789177, 0.05107930675148964, 0.039429280906915665, 0.03677217289805412, -0.050034575164318085, -0.025759803131222725, 0.028557121753692627, -0.02025335468351841, -0.021027792245149612, -0.0394350104033947, 0.00190089107491076, 0.018404880538582802, -0.06622442603111267, 0.008376999758183956, 0.0035311563406139612, -0.05038808658719063, -0.03727766126394272, 0.05754871293902397, -0.06955661624670029, 0.0537978932261467, -0.04085041210055351, -0.029312219470739365, 0.03442807123064995, -0.0782160684466362, -0.03462231904268265, -0.06495174020528793, -0.00964075792580843, 0.025443563237786293, -0.07834853231906891, 0.06216299161314964, 0.007647899445146322, 0.0030271040741354227, -0.03369494527578354, 0.04755546525120735, -0.017508849501609802, -0.036198582500219345, 0.02879444882273674, -0.011186014860868454, 0.004386442247778177, -0.05652263015508652, -0.027721388265490532, -0.027699511498212814, 0.025304442271590233, -0.029708806425333023, -0.0003705692943185568, 0.04530810937285423, 0.07548598945140839, 0.032129913568496704, -0.0855739489197731, 0.03217308595776558, 0.0490909218788147, 0.046016354113817215, -0.030792236328125, -0.011477455496788025, 0.01579505391418934, 0.019303087145090103, -0.043218791484832764, 0.05426618456840515, 0.017999904230237007, 0.008729091845452785, -0.015715816989541054, 0.03559226542711258, 0.004683414474129677, -0.005627559032291174, -0.007577045354992151, 0.010255248285830021, -0.09708943963050842, -0.0225451048463583, 0.028135456144809723, 0.02100159414112568, -0.041661009192466736, -0.04721987619996071, -0.0012412536889314651, -0.06829575449228287, 0.024364639073610306, -0.0019871126860380173, 0.011968866921961308, -0.02085880935192108, 0.01691335439682007, 0.008844506926834583, -0.010199743323028088, 0.009159054607152939, 0.0021446587052196264, -0.008069436997175217, 0.007757487241178751, 0.010300930589437485, -0.0031261707190424204, -0.07355687767267227, -0.011528853327035904, 0.03058384731411934, 0.017030833289027214, -0.04037737846374512, -0.0548495315015316, 0.01902814209461212, -0.04827040806412697, 0.004285420756787062, -0.01970960572361946, 0.035660166293382645, 0.012463611550629139, 0.07029269635677338, 0.009952671825885773, -0.060792285948991776, -0.002168310107663274, 0.0029911426827311516, -0.017221059650182724, -0.001773921656422317, -0.01045915950089693, 0.02359909750521183, 0.010151972062885761, -0.012482190504670143, -0.017963282763957977, 0.016429640352725983, 0.02989022061228752, 0.008016573265194893, 0.008763590827584267, 0.038083259016275406, -0.011093423701822758, -0.025941526517271996, 0.06908733397722244, -0.0657690241932869, -0.04501817747950554, -0.002109968103468418, 0.0205158069729805, -0.013672241941094398, -0.027563052251935005, -0.003589056432247162, -0.010797983035445213, -0.03960710018873215, 0.010291323997080326, -0.0031569297425448895, -0.05941060557961464, 0.03053232841193676 ]
<p>On a quantum scale the smallest unit is the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_scale">Planck scale</a>, which is a discrete measure.</p> <p>There several question that come to mind:</p> <ol> <li>Does that mean that particles can only live in a discrete grid-like structure, i.e. have to "magically" jump from one pocket to the next? But where are they in between? Does that even give rise to the old paradox that movement as such is impossible (e.g. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeno%27s_paradoxes">Zeno's paradox</a>)?</li> <li>Does the same hold true for time (i.e. that it is discrete) - with all the ensuing paradoxes?</li> <li>Mathematically does it mean that you have to use difference equations instead of differential equations? (And sums instead of integrals?)</li> <li>From the point of view of the space metric do you have to use a discrete metric (e.g. the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_metric">Manhattan metric</a>) instead of good old Pythagoras?</li> </ol> <p>Thank you for giving me some answers and/or references where I can turn to.</p> <p><strong>Update:</strong> I just saw this call for papers - it seems to be quite a topic after all: <em>Is Reality Digital or Analog?</em> FQXi Essay Contest, 2011. <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20110504051348/http://www.fqxi.org/community/essay">Call for papers (at Wayback Machine)</a>, <a href="http://www.fqxi.org/community/forum/category/31417">All essays</a>, <a href="http://www.fqxi.org/community/essay/winners/2011.1">Winners</a>. One can find some pretty amazing papers over there.</p>
g114
[ -0.021113045513629913, 0.05783569812774658, -0.03293889760971069, -0.04252725467085838, 0.029836516827344894, -0.019628873094916344, -0.017933689057826996, -0.03056729957461357, -0.030221864581108093, -0.05608903244137764, -0.01311683189123869, -0.02301853708922863, 0.04420856013894081, -0.050379566848278046, -0.03058904968202114, -0.014333384111523628, 0.036595698446035385, -0.028214989230036736, 0.021284697577357292, 0.006704210769385099, 0.0073579587042331696, 0.021992510184645653, 0.04205647110939026, -0.047380976378917694, 0.0027047989424318075, -0.007487150840461254, 0.021833227947354317, -0.05190129950642586, -0.05748995020985603, 0.015445858240127563, 0.017793864011764526, -0.017714355140924454, 0.05608263239264488, -0.049605898559093475, -0.03239826485514641, 0.02608911320567131, 0.031253814697265625, 0.020230820402503014, 0.017661703750491142, 0.03109726868569851, 0.03231106325984001, -0.05574716627597809, -0.02259954996407032, -0.04128847271203995, 0.021990425884723663, 0.013665485195815563, -0.018024099990725517, -0.006298081949353218, 0.06052042171359062, 0.021853948011994362, -0.02317408286035061, 0.046354979276657104, 0.037430644035339355, 0.05099979043006897, -0.0040925052016973495, 0.03481274098157883, 0.03764259070158005, 0.019960502162575722, 0.07915555685758591, 0.03047674521803856, 0.011334378272294998, -0.0014112613862380385, -0.011733708903193474, -0.005724471062421799, 0.04946675896644592, 0.020340217277407646, -0.03335995227098465, 0.0014946602750569582, -0.014464088715612888, -0.0020476849749684334, -0.02596367336809635, -0.09204470366239548, 0.012364200316369534, -0.03210679441690445, -0.008130662143230438, 0.0580856017768383, 0.01619337871670723, -0.0036284560337662697, 0.019430335611104965, -0.016236700117588043, -0.057270266115665436, 0.002274345140904188, 0.06770068407058716, -0.025115681812167168, 0.05546381697058678, 0.019465824589133263, -0.02336157113313675, -0.0323144868016243, -0.0019863254856318235, 0.053821660578250885, -0.0264095701277256, -0.032116346061229706, 0.029029902070760727, -0.01295134425163269, -0.021378835663199425, -0.01525262650102377, 0.0032372171990573406, 0.058510828763246536, -0.030128294602036476, 0.004288858734071255, -0.01792292483150959, 0.03034001961350441, -0.01706286333501339, -0.011963761411607265, -0.0030297618359327316, -0.004434634931385517, -0.009158546105027199, 0.021555522456765175, 0.046328410506248474, -0.0222783200442791, -0.0347665399312973, -0.030709179118275642, -0.045543648302555084, -0.018944894894957542, -0.009006193839013577, 0.022588687017560005, 0.04088369756937027, -0.03594322130084038, 0.019963592290878296, 0.009141186252236366, 0.015976784750819206, 0.0016307382611557841, 0.03447731211781502, 0.04645892605185509, -0.0548158623278141, 0.0066582560539245605, 0.032810043543577194, -0.0006936104036867619, -0.003735274076461792, -0.0251489095389843, 0.08611159771680832, 0.05837657302618027, -0.1266648918390274, 0.0073494501411914825, -0.005920860450714827, 0.016577303409576416, 0.012547865509986877, -0.002094508847221732, -0.011281139217317104, 0.024245796725153923, 0.009031448513269424, -0.014474159106612206, -0.008349878713488579, -0.021616609767079353, 0.0046793739311397076, -0.05620001628994942, -0.04357200115919113, -0.03809523582458496, -0.015580354258418083, -0.015110773034393787, 0.01074674166738987, 0.07581451535224915, 0.005787139758467674, 0.006155964452773333, -0.017387155443429947, 0.0037920998875051737, 0.04613516479730606, 0.08327771723270416, -0.028717156499624252, -0.07930057495832443, 0.028105467557907104, -0.019750701263546944, 0.005407852120697498, 0.03550292178988457, -0.004933449439704418, 0.007537674158811569, 0.02929556556046009, -0.0021905661560595036, 0.017472494393587112, -0.07148914039134979, -0.015788909047842026, -0.04457521811127663, 0.004730308428406715, 0.06324609369039536, 0.004893437027931213, 0.0823102742433548, 0.00407790020108223, 0.0058997017331421375, -0.05263336002826691, -0.06886432319879532, 0.022079892456531525, -0.015724483877420425, 0.021766886115074158, -0.07589229196310043, -0.00240722787566483, -0.01974872499704361, -0.010332458652555943, 0.016296997666358948, 0.0212232768535614, -0.020461419597268105, -0.012057819403707981, -0.013811353594064713, 0.03336530551314354, -0.00807074923068285, -0.008586050942540169, -0.0354686863720417, 0.0033225619699805975, -0.05039522796869278, -0.012953071855008602, -0.061669740825891495, 0.03727814927697182, 0.03895178437232971, 0.04269963875412941, -0.025276560336351395, 0.0440659262239933, 0.004641581326723099, -0.025169573724269867, -0.01102154515683651, -0.0012878800043836236, -0.03117361105978489, 0.044923335313797, -0.050357356667518616, -0.06343047320842743, -0.0017011644085869193, -0.07347372174263, -0.00042693899013102055, 0.0452047623693943, -0.01871407963335514, 0.03456622734665871, 0.005772132892161608, -0.01461631990969181, -0.052412211894989014, 0.01416336465626955, 0.0030630528926849365, 0.010325891897082329, -0.014423687011003494, 0.011335897259414196, -0.017293881624937057, 0.027480699121952057, 0.09296128898859024, -0.10042156279087067, -0.024069329723715782, 0.03545572981238365, -0.037676770240068436, 0.02932312712073326, 0.060882363468408585, -0.031709618866443634, 0.006808754056692123, 0.04934021830558777, 0.02369317226111889, 0.09524029493331909, -0.030410628765821457, -0.06555736064910889, 0.03138143569231033, 0.0488252155482769, -0.028711935505270958, -0.008178988471627235, 0.029605761170387268, -0.023268382996320724, -0.013173110783100128, 0.02352004311978817, -0.07206793129444122, -0.008996336720883846, -0.027384338900446892, 0.014345240779221058, 0.02592521160840988, 0.03562714159488678, -0.009395239874720573, -0.0796516165137291, 0.01964503899216652, 0.03508720546960831, 0.0061069088988006115, -0.018869874998927116, 0.017196865752339363, 0.012822747230529785, -0.053791988641023636, -0.01184232346713543, 0.01788174733519554, -0.020770469680428505, -0.04111410304903984, 0.028224695473909378, 0.05723598599433899, -0.006591208279132843, 0.04820384085178375, -0.00015004570013843477, -0.012052974663674831, 0.023618066683411598, -0.036787163466215134, 0.07135031372308731, -0.015768706798553467, -0.023749511688947678, -0.014871814288198948, -0.07417083531618118, -0.023045703768730164, 0.047594111412763596, -0.07632362097501755, 0.006240821443498135, -0.014027854427695274, -0.05405097454786301, 0.06205077841877937, -0.05231766402721405, 0.0066029466688632965, 0.006251027807593346, 0.013273532502353191, -0.06696658581495285, 0.06907927244901657, -0.03969482704997063, -0.08103674650192261, -0.009184815920889378, -0.020147211849689484, 0.023121410980820656, -0.02914074994623661, -0.005885285325348377, 0.01210821233689785, 0.05991242453455925, 0.030537156388163567, -0.0363042876124382, -0.0030737982597202063, -0.0015151238767430186, -0.02800092287361622, 0.023030655458569527, 0.06199873983860016, -0.018160812556743622, -0.0015144773060455918, 0.013316217809915543, -0.052872657775878906, 0.0046772221103310585, 0.0666351392865181, 0.022180944681167603, -0.021246155723929405, 0.05692048370838165, -0.066700279712677, -0.019269615411758423, -0.049699146300554276, 0.04014292731881142, -0.002022203989326954, -0.07009910047054291, 0.009435981512069702, 0.042572446167469025, 0.05181014537811279, 0.032357193529605865, -0.01005614548921585, 0.03955696523189545, 0.005106070078909397, -0.060222920030355453, -0.06436877697706223, -0.06900139153003693, 0.02049669250845909, 0.0309771541506052, -0.026795674115419388, -0.09293236583471298, -0.023074427619576454, -0.07843407988548279, 0.021540408954024315, 0.023567093536257744, 0.01705927960574627, 0.06883560866117477, 0.012870276346802711, 0.002271730452775955, 0.006647209171205759, -0.004663792904466391, -0.036571647971868515, -0.016419721767306328, -0.023254672065377235, 0.0013114848406985402, 0.008294404484331608, 0.03861217200756073, 0.027798805385828018, 0.04817112907767296, -0.013854799792170525, -0.013091146014630795, -0.04748545587062836, 0.04728398844599724, -0.023362236097455025, 0.00457774056121707, 0.005147410556674004, -0.04019201919436455, 0.05811179801821709, -0.00009944922203430906, -0.008244194090366364, -0.0569739043712616, 0.04942336305975914, -0.011661220341920853, 0.059934746474027634, 0.03056037425994873, -0.06272444128990173, -0.0038102935068309307, -0.004266858566552401, -0.01217786967754364, -0.0022311904467642307, -0.022932130843400955, 0.05155980587005615, 0.03804156929254532, -0.03249098360538483, 0.047928765416145325, -0.009108217433094978, -0.06993475556373596, -0.06270750612020493, -0.025768114253878593, -0.025519290938973427, -0.036000948399305344, -0.005167943891137838, -0.04412340745329857, 0.01840483769774437, 0.00007815023127477616, 0.011421432718634605, 0.02756619080901146, 0.00670229597017169, 0.00153428188059479, 0.05961557850241661, 0.017068857327103615, 0.005941160023212433, -0.039910443127155304, 0.013240842148661613, 0.030741561204195023, -0.018756529316306114, 0.0023157603573054075, 0.029724983498454094, -0.02925924025475979, -0.022679494693875313, 0.028175055980682373, 0.0467570461332798, -0.0014146714238449931, -0.07014010101556778, 0.01104028895497322, 0.012814879417419434, -0.010983120650053024, -0.04186372831463814, 0.0016745913308113813, 0.04263424500823021, -0.011212408542633057, 0.04197269678115845, -0.022421684116125107, 0.016955828294157982, -0.06682819128036499, 0.034253790974617004, 0.030505092814564705, 0.06317532807588577, -0.04973902553319931, -0.005845985375344753, 0.01902167685329914, 0.05134420096874237, 0.023351747542619705, 0.07947880774736404, 0.022197403013706207, 0.02174600213766098, -0.02213873900473118, 0.028251852840185165, -0.01757943630218506, -0.037579361349344254, 0.09366156905889511, 0.0251337718218565, 0.02730187401175499, 0.015582563355565071, -0.011140605434775352, 0.04358807951211929, -0.06409953534603119, -0.016838891431689262, -0.02934155985713005, 0.017906764522194862, 0.06090903654694557, 0.05174194276332855, -0.018482059240341187, -0.0851905420422554, -0.00410812720656395, -0.036461472511291504, -0.015307503752410412, 0.0417531318962574, 0.0394725576043129, 0.021516991779208183, -0.05737268924713135, -0.02569904737174511, -0.03305448964238167, 0.0624794103205204, 0.009956504218280315, -0.003947888035327196, -0.07777784019708633, 0.03872030973434448, -0.07712741941213608, -0.06788236647844315, 0.04205229505896568, 0.0313347689807415, -0.014835448004305363, 0.03820497542619705, -0.0133860157802701, -0.0015847340691834688, -0.011659976094961166, 0.053118105977773666, -0.02630995400249958, -0.03263939544558525, -0.030330315232276917, 0.0056077707558870316, 0.0228680782020092, 0.025532709434628487, -0.0028478242456912994, 0.0073586441576480865, -0.018860027194023132, -0.03736364096403122, -0.0030913595110177994, 0.02357790432870388, 0.009816291742026806, -0.011586627922952175, 0.04548513516783714, 0.008709684014320374, -0.017414255067706108, -0.005144156981259584, -0.0008506266749463975, -0.006879482883960009, -0.000906929955817759, -0.006277817767113447, -0.03735596314072609, 0.05876779556274414, 0.005626121070235968, -0.045309919863939285, 0.0203507412225008, 0.028568312525749207, 0.06272930651903152, 0.011404024437069893, 0.014662348665297031, -0.003922945354133844, 0.006712069734930992, -0.002014382276684046, -0.03503958880901337, 0.013858169317245483, 0.0013655547518283129, -0.05234552174806595, -0.024631522595882416, -0.017245126888155937, 0.012386039830744267, -0.0062626018188893795, -0.00913599319756031, -0.025649486109614372, 0.04711200296878815, -0.02479998767375946, -0.005972364451736212, 0.00907896552234888, -0.07167749851942062, -0.02687181904911995, 0.01078897062689066, 0.06748814880847931, 0.04374523460865021, 0.031095100566744804, 0.0015441944124177098, 0.03514213114976883, -0.04009681195020676, 0.04296620190143585, 0.018720930442214012, 0.0727330818772316, 0.03639136999845505, 0.012936851009726524, -0.05466447398066521, -0.05585193261504173, 0.03460685536265373, 0.04494671896100044, 0.008860362693667412, -0.016860662028193474, 0.01052530761808157, 0.03980754315853119, 0.03650574013590813, -0.012505083344876766, -0.028647636994719505, 0.031122203916311264, -0.004587452858686447, 0.02443588525056839, -0.05979794263839722, -0.022278498858213425, 0.02545068971812725, -0.029583202674984932, -0.029472067952156067, -0.003339156974107027, 0.056229718029499054, 0.012535354122519493, 0.026601087301969528, -0.0476175881922245, 0.015669111162424088, -0.0629369392991066, 0.015995318070054054, 0.025629451498389244, 0.04376114904880524, 0.010824006050825119, 0.018437689170241356, 0.01486106775701046, 0.06891633570194244, 0.024919504299759865, -0.030826259404420853, -0.02075168676674366, -0.011513995006680489, -0.019498975947499275, -0.09652230888605118, -0.002021797001361847, 0.006013771519064903, 0.06560904532670975, -0.00324985827319324, -0.003932297229766846, -0.012510203756392002, 0.08181431889533997, -0.020594576373696327, -0.0011355846654623747, -0.010289584286510944, 0.007040291093289852, 0.009622901678085327, -0.021335087716579437, -0.010675748810172081, -0.025404522195458412, -0.0666084811091423, -0.022901320829987526, 0.03635339438915253, -0.03728485852479935, -0.062449969351291656, 0.026387440040707588, -0.012881564907729626, -0.05156715214252472, -0.019411396235227585, -0.043134164065122604, -0.021194813773036003, 0.03462300822138786, -0.049445778131484985, 0.023407526314258575, -0.007295394781976938, 0.04430433735251427, -0.009764962829649448, 0.0482364185154438, 0.047622960060834885, 0.010668785311281681, -0.0011584748281165957, -0.04618224501609802, 0.010504207573831081, -0.00566817307844758, -0.03819042816758156, 0.023121148347854614, 0.01093333587050438, -0.024373870342969894, 0.0007293378002941608, -0.02166740968823433, -0.0032254441175609827, 0.023462004959583282, 0.003426349489018321, 0.03430412709712982, 0.023097367957234383, 0.031166648492217064, -0.02781020477414131, -0.011149419471621513, 0.03734854981303215, 0.0719885379076004, -0.036945097148418427, 0.004049388226121664, -0.038481444120407104, -0.012046081945300102, 0.05751020461320877, -0.018581829965114594, 0.06967899948358536, -0.005668574012815952, 0.044429533183574677, -0.02847525291144848, -0.004820193164050579, 0.03336312994360924, 0.02166653238236904, 0.06589151173830032, -0.037033289670944214, -0.012231276370584965, 0.05708542838692665, -0.014942435547709465, -0.03368464484810829, -0.0052869608625769615, -0.02094407193362713, 0.04088549315929413, -0.004974795505404472, -0.0018963725306093693, 0.035033442080020905, -0.070368193089962, -0.012302028946578503, -0.05827614292502403, 0.05114607512950897, -0.010170998051762581, 0.011106613092124462, 0.05986184999346733, 0.01453208178281784, -0.004624950233846903, 0.015356281772255898, -0.0471891388297081, 0.0050420877523720264, -0.03169967979192734, -0.020753197371959686, 0.024812869727611542, 0.0697166919708252, -0.03556056693196297, -0.020395897328853607, 0.05745338648557663, 0.014457453973591328, -0.015135404653847218, 0.08398118615150452, -0.0010426427470520139, -0.0035682751331478357, -0.07499948143959045, -0.06330257654190063, 0.022719355300068855, -0.03625526651740074, 0.012324963696300983, 0.03527236357331276, -0.06229615956544876, 0.011918038129806519, -0.024381855502724648, 0.048828091472387314, 0.02183344028890133, -0.04601620137691498, 0.023441456258296967, 0.03304865211248398, 0.04687659814953804, 0.012379568070173264, -0.023797187954187393, 0.01007272582501173, -0.005905137863010168, -0.040092721581459045, -0.016428930684924126, 0.03779705613851547, 0.0247286856174469, 0.01922684721648693, -0.02647837996482849, -0.0557115413248539, -0.03888905420899391, -0.030642755329608917, 0.014208982698619366, 0.0063581448048353195, -0.02593996934592724, 0.05533442273736, -0.012945613823831081, -0.016485445201396942, -0.012436078861355782, 0.04645712673664093, -0.01888926699757576, 0.0327799916267395, -0.03380201384425163, -0.02089816704392433, -0.044411033391952515, -0.00230580591596663, -0.05121176317334175, 0.003073351690545678, -0.04364446923136711, 0.014238913543522358, -0.007057052105665207, -0.02356744557619095, -0.009826664812862873, -0.027600273489952087, -0.008785133250057697, -0.03166496381163597, 0.06069674715399742, 0.026162849739193916, 0.008582258597016335, 0.056595973670482635, -0.023752018809318542, -0.020776040852069855, -0.0033655830193310976, 0.0479043647646904, 0.06189798191189766, -0.024021806195378304, -0.028976762667298317, -0.05597704276442528, 0.029613545164465904, 0.03473828732967377, 0.008826171047985554, -0.010944955982267857, 0.032392144203186035, -0.04124996066093445, 0.016284417361021042, 0.03605448827147484, -0.05387106165289879, 0.04033023118972778, 0.029118964448571205, 0.009531068615615368, -0.031972505152225494, 0.02408929541707039, -0.016568100079894066, 0.009069704450666904, 0.042695123702287674, -0.09182360023260117, -0.0408053882420063, 0.0030628438107669353, 0.015633419156074524 ]
<p>If a vibrating atom can produce light why can't an alternating current of electrons do the same?</p> <p>EDIT: When I use the term "light" I mean all EMR</p>
g6592
[ 0.0034606794361025095, 0.04430529475212097, -0.020377254113554955, -0.004711575340479612, 0.04867260903120041, 0.02484283037483692, -0.009254640899598598, -0.017696639522910118, 0.03445707634091377, -0.018714040517807007, 0.013359001837670803, 0.010703656822443008, -0.01641271635890007, 0.04086234048008919, -0.03531922399997711, 0.006238244473934174, 0.01041880901902914, -0.00860905647277832, 0.0314834900200367, 0.03927377983927727, 0.02838473580777645, 0.007051759399473667, -0.005882509518414736, -0.06896575540304184, 0.021423783153295517, 0.0442538820207119, 0.006059881299734116, -0.07540085166692734, -0.052815668284893036, 0.0118508730083704, 0.009197523817420006, -0.01210889220237732, 0.031971536576747894, 0.030296318233013153, -0.005493782460689545, -0.0889723151922226, -0.00858596246689558, 0.03752966970205307, 0.032469578087329865, 0.01954011060297489, -0.007769724354147911, 0.046001136302948, 0.004946845583617687, 0.02507718652486801, 0.023205721750855446, -0.03363058716058731, 0.031242741271853447, 0.04875510185956955, -0.05017823353409767, -0.03568852320313454, 0.018708059564232826, -0.014034471474587917, 0.0394185446202755, -0.012888114899396896, 0.07365334033966064, -0.039987608790397644, -0.06805887818336487, -0.008147361688315868, 0.04441451653838158, 0.028176797553896904, -0.026884453371167183, -0.024775054305791855, 0.008411203511059284, 0.07355333864688873, 0.028942536562681198, -0.04009687155485153, -0.021232526749372482, -0.0464041605591774, 0.07892384380102158, 0.039300426840782166, 0.03629833087325096, -0.046582844108343124, -0.04271789640188217, -0.0005671380204148591, 0.027127781882882118, 0.01308590266853571, 0.0048628877848386765, 0.02277078665792942, 0.03734898194670677, -0.004311039112508297, -0.05073340982198715, -0.012569126673042774, -0.011599966324865818, -0.017485758289694786, 0.07609105855226517, -0.03101233020424843, -0.016584297642111778, -0.055324189364910126, 0.025853216648101807, 0.011570494621992111, 0.053433191031217575, -0.07247567176818848, 0.09278363734483719, -0.005662302020937204, -0.01671767793595791, -0.060132887214422226, -0.0011836568592116237, 0.019962521269917488, 0.004641325678676367, -0.023141512647271156, -0.04346567764878273, -0.01044752448797226, 0.014277935959398746, -0.006201899144798517, 0.005843273364007473, -0.012372826226055622, -0.010862656868994236, -0.04683437570929527, 0.0055486420169472694, -0.0036570345982909203, 0.027181284502148628, -0.02626550942659378, -0.00881007220596075, -0.02651461958885193, -0.028270898386836052, -0.03774948790669441, 0.06324908137321472, 0.00628167949616909, -0.0326242633163929, 0.06445395201444626, 0.04510544613003731, -0.005407263990491629, -0.015454537235200405, -0.012306353077292442, -0.06486162543296814, 0.006590683478862047, 0.027364294975996017, 0.036866217851638794, 0.04257998615503311, -0.010591207072138786, -0.006032716482877731, 0.002831703517585993, -0.01913994550704956, 0.025256870314478874, 0.04964650049805641, 0.019081218168139458, 0.019890381023287773, -0.054905518889427185, 0.01487743854522705, 0.006581077817827463, 0.019760655239224434, 0.004833758808672428, -0.00521070696413517, -0.05012214928865433, -0.0370652973651886, 0.06533120572566986, -0.03166627883911133, 0.009865139611065388, 0.06657417863607407, 0.0774998813867569, -0.007759366650134325, 0.06347203999757767, 0.028533432632684708, -0.021272679790854454, 0.01237223856151104, -0.04148384928703308, 0.08853504061698914, 0.00017616500554140657, -0.058748211711645126, 0.024083660915493965, 0.03646405041217804, 0.021054985001683235, -0.014599976129829884, -0.016897905617952347, 0.021191515028476715, 0.02929154969751835, 0.0005276998854242265, -0.00559118902310729, -0.0020340988412499428, -0.04087882488965988, -0.06293386220932007, 0.025471186265349388, 0.01741519756615162, 0.06566011160612106, 0.07728048413991928, 0.06680025905370712, 0.027888210490345955, -0.034654777497053146, 0.030995696783065796, -0.01688356325030327, -0.061544474214315414, -0.022443080320954323, 0.014513005502521992, -0.02172563597559929, -0.030769232660531998, 0.013422672636806965, -0.0314721018075943, -0.0114925941452384, -0.04604853689670563, -0.007716867607086897, 0.0034686883445829153, -0.006350671872496605, -0.03390709310770035, 0.02364478074014187, -0.03826502338051796, -0.05966203659772873, -0.02429346553981304, -0.019241267815232277, 0.010956265963613987, 0.0004960533697158098, 0.022962119430303574, 0.053439293056726456, 0.02191925421357155, -0.026209834963083267, 0.03208170086145401, 0.0061239684000611305, -0.07352600246667862, -0.039741531014442444, 0.06698223203420639, 0.00268610124476254, 0.0638648197054863, 0.025173719972372055, 0.024446262046694756, 0.039992913603782654, -0.030344009399414062, -0.05942365527153015, 0.0019074816955253482, -0.0218514371663332, -0.03335711732506752, 0.015052501112222672, 0.0017150462372228503, -0.0293436199426651, -0.01902439445257187, -0.011801849119365215, -0.047499023377895355, 0.008940275758504868, -0.04394186660647392, -0.004847244825214148, -0.012564443051815033, -0.025383520871400833, -0.026785636320710182, 0.03476087376475334, 0.0030854165088385344, 0.012539823539555073, 0.007277538999915123, 0.037249352782964706, 0.023923030123114586, 0.018896836787462234, -0.036181170493364334, -0.01966704986989498, -0.008184169419109821, 0.00233672303147614, 0.007598775904625654, -0.004695674870163202, -0.01935633458197117, 0.00845867395401001, 0.013009504415094852, 0.03395363315939903, 0.0033289180137217045, -0.01468556746840477, 0.06524157524108887, -0.0022572814486920834, -0.04850362613797188, 0.02611248940229416, -0.003022415330633521, -0.0949372872710228, 0.04696227237582207, 0.06378597766160965, -0.003804869018495083, -0.010763661935925484, -0.02135160192847252, -0.027641436085104942, 0.020583562552928925, 0.00010269979975419119, -0.026325415819883347, -0.010713430121541023, 0.024027371779084206, -0.03505970910191536, -0.00015433640510309488, 0.01924361102283001, -0.08558066934347153, 0.055925190448760986, -0.03617381677031517, 0.014263476245105267, -0.03121844492852688, -0.0015780928079038858, 0.015363934449851513, -0.013297487050294876, 0.05104482173919678, -0.05179613456130028, -0.00571436807513237, 0.018593385815620422, -0.01086153369396925, -0.043730609118938446, 0.01951824314892292, -0.03394196182489395, 0.009374299086630344, -0.00810438022017479, -0.004916445817798376, 0.015089524909853935, -0.01914910599589348, -0.008474466390907764, 0.03213552385568619, 0.00252866861410439, -0.07241133600473404, 0.010141081176698208, 0.01578083075582981, -0.004070318304002285, -0.07502812147140503, 0.09501701593399048, 0.022343123331665993, -0.0021983433980494738, 0.03230070695281029, 0.07007528096437454, -0.012133474461734295, -0.01631326600909233, 0.011800527572631836, -0.029548030346632004, 0.02030366286635399, 0.05860774219036102, -0.0015153844142332673, 0.05939728394150734, 0.0073850094340741634, -0.0011675201822072268, -0.04867413267493248, 0.033507440239191055, 0.0041960435919463634, -0.009384616278111935, 0.03895636275410652, -0.02679266408085823, -0.023104675114154816, -0.01729707419872284, 0.025109071284532547, -0.03838636726140976, -0.01715712808072567, 0.0069393590092659, -0.007158808410167694, 0.027228694409132004, -0.03201443701982498, -0.009376849047839642, 0.013196459040045738, 0.0033961336594074965, 0.01947428658604622, 0.009393817745149136, -0.012218992225825787, -0.05857846513390541, -0.011978867463767529, 0.057294972240924835, -0.0024041475262492895, 0.006174761801958084, -0.005615624599158764, 0.01638917252421379, -0.09115473926067352, 0.019430849701166153, -0.0110397320240736, 0.06977634876966476, -0.07928857952356339, -0.03814361244440079, 0.0010318689746782184, -0.04275265708565712, 0.02508227340877056, 0.023830516263842583, 0.009903492406010628, 0.02003704197704792, -0.044526223093271255, 0.007660157512873411, 0.04041947051882744, 0.03508981689810753, 0.00417603412643075, -0.017229024320840836, -0.006455893162637949, -0.059506624937057495, 0.04892905801534653, -0.03168861195445061, -0.039593588560819626, 0.01564975269138813, -0.014217756688594818, 0.041115887463092804, 0.00946786254644394, -0.013962912373244762, 0.023945624008774757, -0.045033734291791916, -0.015003480948507786, -0.03707362338900566, 0.03488056734204292, -0.07146524637937546, 0.024348760023713112, 0.017263295128941536, -0.06477494537830353, 0.021828066557645798, 0.013548789545893669, -0.0014579173875972629, 0.025160333141684532, 0.013270705007016659, 0.009150492958724499, 0.016298530623316765, -0.03689754009246826, 0.03951810672879219, -0.07632187008857727, -0.05217325687408447, -0.0027494037058204412, 0.0005113171064294875, -0.03098718449473381, 0.005565295461565256, -0.020941883325576782, -0.03293931111693382, 0.04256478697061539, -0.10163447260856628, 0.05390800163149834, 0.03081156127154827, 0.03886311501264572, 0.0025710691697895527, 0.017934564501047134, 0.0032667971681803465, -0.006435342598706484, -0.005117734428495169, 0.03908652439713478, -0.04438208416104317, 0.02560240961611271, 0.008344910107553005, -0.026424888521432877, 0.01332338061183691, -0.009444908238947392, 0.00785171240568161, -0.02060130052268505, -0.0011926854494959116, 0.029786041006445885, 0.016713570803403854, 0.06359703093767166, 0.027081945911049843, -0.008915182203054428, 0.038747385144233704, 0.02560983970761299, 0.005526973865926266, 0.05059202015399933, 0.07123691588640213, -0.01024133712053299, -0.03254549577832222, -0.017322154715657234, -0.05917879566550255, 0.003713989397510886, -0.015721069648861885, -0.047836340963840485, -0.04547514393925667, -0.04885328933596611, 0.06233709305524826, -0.019803328439593315, 0.05457310751080513, 0.07520481944084167, 0.06653058528900146, 0.100031279027462, -0.0401359461247921, 0.025672102347016335, 0.03461337462067604, 0.010679468512535095, 0.07820526510477066, -0.03397960588335991, -0.030512522906064987, -0.004720412660390139, 0.004463749006390572, 0.015156801789999008, -0.017680682241916656, -0.05267292633652687, -0.013416040688753128, -0.008765315636992455, -0.028563790023326874, -0.04389866441488266, 0.00754741532728076, 0.018809227272868156, 0.04679330810904503, -0.012693973258137703, -0.011273451149463654, 0.03380914777517319, -0.009766694158315659, 0.02628551796078682, 0.048988427966833115, -0.005573946516960859, -0.015933552756905556, -0.11546216160058975, -0.06374641507863998, 0.012593665160238743, 0.03617051988840103, -0.015074740163981915, 0.05568891391158104, 0.04581482708454132, -0.023988373577594757, 0.02328023873269558, -0.05430476367473602, -0.04332774505019188, -0.04847252741456032, -0.041432417929172516, -0.046739112585783005, -0.04380195587873459, 0.013765440322458744, 0.0029750270769000053, -0.017178812995553017, -0.05044015124440193, 0.0674230083823204, -0.018218928948044777, -0.07403309643268585, 0.008853951469063759, 0.052378084510564804, -0.05276074633002281, -0.08610941469669342, 0.026089606806635857, 0.013036674819886684, -0.009684275835752487, 0.034023966640233994, -0.014072509482502937, 0.036880847066640854, -0.05432910472154617, -0.03368308022618294, -0.022721046581864357, -0.03932516276836395, -0.03275827318429947, -0.02204068936407566, -0.01940704509615898, 0.021738411858677864, -0.05261971056461334, -0.0016429133247584105, -0.02183889038860798, -0.04673122987151146, 0.006748710758984089, 0.07355595380067825, 0.03830756992101669, 0.03599151223897934, -0.05655992403626442, 0.008378386497497559, -0.07057461887598038, -0.013863539323210716, 0.01453386526554823, -0.022679097950458527, 0.04803509637713432, -0.06698447465896606, -0.011584712192416191, 0.024126991629600525, -0.0333188995718956, -0.004197061527520418, 0.05477401241660118, 0.05476647987961769, 0.03953850269317627, 0.015121099539101124, 0.037210434675216675, -0.0346766859292984, 0.046683188527822495, -0.05088111758232117, 0.040487293154001236, -0.00489776162430644, -0.0860009640455246, 0.04104473441839218, 0.005518800113350153, -0.02280084788799286, 0.028768673539161682, 0.04130374267697334, 0.066428042948246, -0.009297795593738556, 0.00803056824952364, -0.01796363666653633, 0.0026955779176205397, 0.0051063052378594875, -0.0058434042148292065, 0.05447846278548241, -0.026141932234168053, 0.04501276835799217, 0.00554608553647995, 0.04353060573339462, 0.0006991307018324733, -0.021032048389315605, -0.0288859773427248, -0.013005321845412254, 0.04112539440393448, 0.029181433841586113, 0.03392128273844719, -0.023785512894392014, 0.06498988717794418, -0.0022605988197028637, -0.008800229988992214, 0.02447662688791752, -0.011728741228580475, 0.05675509199500084, -0.017366081476211548, 0.03043225221335888, 0.026904461905360222, 0.005402981303632259, 0.03286616876721382, 0.013997795060276985, -0.019454222172498703, -0.05948634445667267, -0.07252778112888336, -0.0184823926538229, 0.01761826127767563, -0.015377223491668701, -0.011565200984477997, -0.013360349461436272, 0.05053960159420967, -0.013445990160107613, -0.008795621804893017, 0.0004816224391106516, 0.08427420258522034, -0.043952226638793945, -0.05330239236354828, -0.008982600644230843, -0.016445342451334, 0.009129757061600685, -0.03662720322608948, -0.011955443769693375, 0.004656441044062376, -0.0586673766374588, 0.007441935129463673, 0.03236095979809761, 0.09914354979991913, -0.01401364617049694, 0.03736290708184242, 0.021276870742440224, 0.022332409396767616, 0.0093002300709486, -0.06569088250398636, -0.0033863303251564503, 0.003593232249841094, 0.02471166104078293, -0.09530775994062424, -0.02081092819571495, -0.021785981953144073, -0.0328621007502079, -0.03300723060965538, -0.03466823697090149, -0.02499626763164997, -0.0016827686922624707, 0.03753138333559036, 0.04688112810254097, -0.04007348418235779, 0.01956264115869999, -0.013978327624499798, -0.029498757794499397, 0.022482778877019882, 0.03869667649269104, -0.07616148144006729, 0.06522808969020844, 0.05235237628221512, 0.012601533904671669, -0.00017830375873018056, 0.04032214730978012, -0.02231569029390812, 0.06720168143510818, 0.007995732128620148, 0.03095324896275997, -0.007900193333625793, -0.07300455868244171, 0.04085707291960716, -0.02093294821679592, -0.031401798129081726, 0.08147943764925003, 0.03281267359852791, 0.05200411379337311, -0.04244106262922287, -0.008578506298363209, 0.07089908421039581, -0.03621688485145569, -0.026226110756397247, 0.01955845206975937, -0.01703789457678795, -0.04083618149161339, -0.020479004830121994, 0.05103173479437828, -0.010213389992713928, -0.004453375469893217, 0.01608777791261673, 0.006906341761350632, 0.014111718162894249, -0.013613319024443626, -0.04171207174658775, -0.007856795564293861, 0.006337231025099754, 0.00034200234222225845, 0.04003732278943062, -0.011890954338014126, -0.05294911935925484, -0.10914871841669083, 0.03653401508927345, 0.0023909287992864847, -0.02063887193799019, -0.07098235189914703, 0.03401980549097061, -0.0004455775488168001, 0.005880441050976515, -0.008680339902639389, -0.021910076960921288, 0.02027755416929722, 0.016650181263685226, -0.014685183763504028, -0.04822608828544617, 0.0059904553927481174, 0.04215230047702789, -0.039391495287418365, -0.008613336831331253, 0.006294596940279007, -0.06826300173997879, -0.014915753155946732, 0.03193673491477966, -0.039694126695394516, -0.021558508276939392, -0.006460162345319986, -0.009764512069523335, -0.02216605469584465, -0.016013525426387787, 0.04551878944039345, -0.021055443212389946, 0.011254477314651012, 0.030843619257211685, -0.04020179435610771, -0.024734530597925186, -0.023526273667812347, 0.0075972541235387325, 0.00567294005304575, 0.027068788185715675, 0.0009848895715549588, 0.03620575740933418, 0.0007859176839701831, -0.015588963404297829, 0.013927371241152287, -0.0037476085126399994, 0.041682031005620956, -0.008718997240066528, 0.03893578052520752, 0.016781428828835487, 0.056490812450647354, 0.01705065742135048, 0.014463599771261215, 0.04061386361718178, 0.02771606668829918, 0.02350482903420925, -0.004022237379103899, -0.024999136105179787, -0.011026393622159958, 0.026720218360424042, -0.04861059412360191, 0.0583159439265728, -0.020002102479338646, 0.03865937516093254, -0.020420223474502563, 0.052179500460624695, 0.0352819487452507, 0.029240980744361877, -0.03906041383743286, -0.06561895459890366, 0.048307422548532486, 0.0016931791324168444, 0.031487837433815, 0.0031836729031056166, 0.005341113545000553, -0.006674635224044323, 0.00950763002038002, 0.004335587844252586, -0.023033244535326958, 0.007353007793426514, -0.013693551532924175, -0.05092192441225052, -0.015160365961492062, 0.04079488292336464, -0.0012278934009373188, -0.06925854831933975, -0.004463041666895151, -0.046872179955244064, -0.006327600684016943, 0.06658226251602173, -0.043577246367931366, 0.025458291172981262, 0.03458566591143608, -0.002898301463574171, 0.03148265182971954, -0.0647214725613594, 0.04926391690969467, 0.005669213365763426, -0.059883370995521545, -0.005818923935294151, -0.02672475576400757, -0.05877029150724411, -0.013888323679566383 ]
<p>consider object A with mass $m_{A}$ and positional vector $\overrightarrow{r_{A}}$</p> <p>object B with mass $m_{B}$ and positional vector $\overrightarrow{r_{B}}$</p> <p>object C with mass $m_{C}$ and positional vector $\overrightarrow{r_{C}}$</p> <p>since reference frame is inertial (assumed) so</p> <p>$m_{A}\frac{d^{2}}{dt^{2}}\overrightarrow{r_{A}}=\overrightarrow{F}{}_{AB}+\overrightarrow{F}{}_{AC}$</p> <p>$\Rightarrow$$m_{A}\frac{d^{2}}{dt^{2}}\overrightarrow{r_{A}}=G\frac{m_{A}m_{B}}{\left|\overrightarrow{r_{B}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}}\right|^{3}}(\overrightarrow{r_{B}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}})+G\frac{m_{A}m_{C}}{\left|\overrightarrow{r_{C}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}}\right|^{3}}(\overrightarrow{r_{C}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}})$ ....[1]</p> <p>for potential energy equation is to be integrated with a positional vector and i am trying hard to figure out what that vector could be, but still no success. please help</p> <hr> <p>Potential energy of a object due to another object $m_{A}\frac{d^{2}}{dt^{2}}\overrightarrow{r_{A}}=\overrightarrow{F_{A}}=G\frac{m_{A}m_{B}}{\left|\overrightarrow{r_{A}}-\overrightarrow{r_{B}}\right|^{3}}(\overrightarrow{r_{B}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}})$</p> <p>assuming $\overrightarrow{r_{0}}=\overrightarrow{r_{B}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}}$</p> <p>$\Rightarrow m_{A}\frac{d^{2}}{dt^{2}}\overrightarrow{r_{0}}=-(1+\frac{m_{A}}{m_{B}})(G\frac{m_{A}m_{B}}{r_{0}^{2}}\hat{r_{0}})$</p> <p>$\Rightarrow\intop_{\overrightarrow{r_{0i}}}^{\overrightarrow{r_{0f}}}\left(m_{A}\frac{d^{2}}{dt^{2}}\overrightarrow{r_{0}}\right).d\overrightarrow{r_{0}}=-\intop_{\overrightarrow{r_{0i}}}^{\overrightarrow{r_{0f}}}\left((1+\frac{m_{A}}{m_{B}})(G\frac{m_{A}m_{B}}{r_{0}^{2}}\hat{r_{0}})\right).d\overrightarrow{r_{0}}$</p> <p>$\Rightarrow\left.\frac{1}{2}m_{A}v_{0}^{2}\right|_{v_{0}(\overrightarrow{r_{0i}})}^{v_{0}(\overrightarrow{r_{0f}})}=\left.G\frac{m_{A}(m_{A}+m_{B})}{r_{0}}\right|_{\overrightarrow{r_{0i}}}^{\overrightarrow{r_{0f}}}$</p> <p>So What positional vector should be integrated with equ [1] ? How it is decided ? (i mean what kind of property(s) that vector should possess ?)</p> <p>EDIT 1</p> <p>$\int_{\overrightarrow{r_{i}}}^{\overrightarrow{r_{f}}}\left(m_{A}\frac{d^{2}}{dt^{2}}\overrightarrow{r_{A}}\right).d\overrightarrow{r}=\int_{\overrightarrow{r_{i}}}^{\overrightarrow{r_{f}}}\left(G\frac{m_{A}m_{B}}{\left|\overrightarrow{r_{B}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}}\right|^{3}}(\overrightarrow{r_{B}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}})+G\frac{m_{A}m_{C}}{\left|\overrightarrow{r_{C}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}}\right|^{3}}(\overrightarrow{r_{C}}-\overrightarrow{r_{A}})\right).d\overrightarrow{r}$ .....[2]</p> <p>questions </p> <p>a) what is $\overrightarrow{r}$ in terms of $\overrightarrow{r_{A}}$,$\overrightarrow{r_{B}}$or $\overrightarrow{r_{C}}$ ?</p> <p>b) solve equ [2].</p>
g6593
[ 0.048440635204315186, -0.01753488928079605, -0.007684042211622, -0.0016347687924280763, 0.03202364593744278, -0.013481494039297104, 0.09146972000598907, 0.010207955725491047, -0.11196908354759216, 0.00776643306016922, 0.0034349511843174696, 0.003391081700101495, -0.022955041378736496, -0.03760243207216263, 0.041264306753873825, 0.0001544644037494436, 0.05964552238583565, -0.0020044627599418163, 0.006808644626289606, 0.01462635025382042, 0.011875077150762081, 0.012950753793120384, 0.01313219964504242, 0.014054146595299244, -0.023874670267105103, -0.03324531391263008, 0.07319588959217072, -0.012065798044204712, -0.05782988667488098, -0.007183806039392948, 0.01739976555109024, 0.036544084548950195, 0.004671164322644472, -0.06879162788391113, -0.025510141626000404, 0.024633577093482018, 0.06005913019180298, 0.00028179812943562865, 0.006882462650537491, 0.017973363399505615, -0.022504808381199837, -0.03562052920460701, 0.03667382895946503, 0.003756680293008685, 0.027800174430012703, -0.020473316311836243, 0.02681582234799862, 0.02055036835372448, -0.012307408265769482, -0.02471885457634926, 0.0009722517570480704, 0.06405115872621536, 0.04932146519422531, -0.05854877457022667, 0.004984439350664616, 0.05317123979330063, 0.028368474915623665, -0.02996613271534443, 0.01873902790248394, 0.07857111096382141, -0.008180300705134869, -0.0005111411446705461, -0.055852245539426804, 0.03517060726881027, 0.05947548523545265, -0.033291999250650406, -0.05704835429787636, -0.015086935833096504, -0.03534567356109619, -0.06186438351869583, 0.026986941695213318, -0.010260708630084991, 0.006046928931027651, -0.04509555175900459, -0.032550401985645294, -0.019836967810988426, 0.0241989828646183, -0.010235182009637356, 0.03819149360060692, -0.03275931999087334, 0.02110833115875721, 0.039409905672073364, 0.015348750166594982, 0.02536626346409321, 0.0691569447517395, 0.012523127719759941, 0.04341914877295494, 0.06520950794219971, -0.04268278181552887, -0.03702366352081299, 0.028755081817507744, -0.030803723260760307, 0.02298308163881302, -0.02444751188158989, 0.008450686000287533, 0.03917447105050087, -0.029970450326800346, 0.03774533048272133, -0.06470589339733124, -0.04053362086415291, -0.002235362073406577, 0.020014824345707893, 0.020281430333852768, -0.008288934826850891, 0.04079638421535492, -0.012666016817092896, 0.04238562658429146, 0.0361853688955307, -0.015860017389059067, -0.012927589006721973, -0.006545098498463631, 0.018604978919029236, -0.010920294560492039, -0.03705653175711632, -0.07263345271348953, -0.06432898342609406, 0.0925641655921936, 0.007946508005261421, -0.029208462685346603, 0.03419744595885277, -0.0012445064494386315, 0.02794536016881466, 0.006707201711833477, 0.10213996469974518, -0.022682782262563705, 0.018483739346265793, -0.04051297530531883, -0.03868922218680382, 0.043202925473451614, -0.026315147057175636, 0.01803230680525303, -0.06075694411993027, 0.03927895799279213, -0.019100815057754517, 0.010076279751956463, 0.039017435163259506, 0.008738705888390541, -0.00015177245950326324, 0.024132005870342255, 0.03375115245580673, 0.023317215964198112, -0.02671724557876587, 0.005336581263691187, 0.012927843257784843, -0.03687388822436333, 0.09571625292301178, -0.004830976016819477, -0.051538001745939255, 0.0382813885807991, -0.0038784232456237078, -0.00818661693483591, 0.08125780522823334, -0.06004383787512779, 0.00915906485170126, 0.10650359839200974, 0.004302249755710363, -0.029744740575551987, -0.04074978083372116, 0.005891043692827225, -0.021878361701965332, 0.03896038234233856, -0.000006119085810496472, -0.013427100144326687, -0.014079833403229713, -0.004869382828474045, -0.0317106656730175, 0.022640015929937363, -0.03884667903184891, 0.002523587318137288, -0.07311355322599411, -0.009081974625587463, 0.030697384849190712, 0.05283592268824577, 0.02513325773179531, 0.009607232175767422, 0.06530208885669708, -0.02890145406126976, -0.03855832293629646, 0.07630746811628342, 0.0044382670894265175, 0.006689518690109253, 0.00676172599196434, 0.04385966807603836, -0.015755509957671165, -0.02277301624417305, 0.02102062664926052, 0.04206816479563713, 0.08874346315860748, -0.017910722643136978, 0.04113025963306427, -0.03276137262582779, 0.03487288951873779, 0.03891361877322197, 0.05034210532903671, -0.01004467997699976, 0.07270146906375885, 0.07699954509735107, -0.047888532280921936, -0.051167089492082596, -0.012746636755764484, -0.01202215626835823, -0.006983260624110699, 0.039213575422763824, 0.05311637744307518, 0.04546264931559563, 0.007615297567099333, 0.04534723982214928, 0.026525292545557022, 0.01379426196217537, 0.027422651648521423, -0.041750937700271606, -0.009770779870450497, -0.008833307772874832, 0.029554208740592003, -0.015244940295815468, -0.0454714260995388, 0.002917938632890582, -0.02656969614326954, -0.07323027402162552, -0.027043035253882408, -0.04433685541152954, -0.022110873833298683, 0.0035389161203056574, 0.023357290774583817, -0.07342763245105743, 0.04619895666837692, -0.020568525418639183, -0.012669493444263935, 0.027067048475146294, -0.004212371073663235, -0.0031760255806148052, 0.02708660438656807, 0.029337866231799126, -0.020040716975927353, 0.05473698303103447, -0.027619654312729836, -0.017820199951529503, -0.006852931808680296, -0.014169305562973022, -0.02288808301091194, 0.041395481675863266, 0.03407161682844162, 0.022800154983997345, -0.05463072657585144, 0.052510183304548264, 0.03692613169550896, 0.05885516107082367, 0.028132231906056404, 0.03095940873026848, 0.05126551166176796, -0.04457364231348038, 0.00940152257680893, -0.00499179121106863, -0.022568020969629288, -0.0013879277976229787, 0.03433137387037277, -0.10535881668329239, 0.020070688799023628, -0.026891745626926422, -0.03603174537420273, -0.05145981162786484, -0.020852262154221535, -0.01747041381895542, 0.011656722985208035, -0.08786099404096603, 0.009595859795808792, -0.03331376612186432, -0.017110386863350868, 0.0365535132586956, 0.013108428567647934, 0.029752440750598907, 0.06473307311534882, 0.017746569588780403, 0.041120465844869614, -0.0013454287545755506, 0.00009043317550094798, -0.023613303899765015, -0.07112209498882294, 0.058039065450429916, 0.01862950623035431, -0.006528759840875864, -0.03892507031559944, -0.039463479071855545, 0.054739080369472504, 0.013635575771331787, -0.027137059718370438, -0.05965175852179527, 0.07844197005033493, 0.006151942536234856, -0.046523988246917725, -0.03666960820555687, 0.034809812903404236, 0.02428394742310047, -0.02893044613301754, -0.00491226464509964, -0.01811561919748783, 0.025933055207133293, -0.05204165726900101, 0.020371589809656143, 0.018591459840536118, -0.010645073838531971, 0.022207077592611313, -0.018197735771536827, -0.025882884860038757, 0.03406378626823425, -0.052195992320775986, -0.0329405814409256, -0.058436259627342224, 0.03482550010085106, 0.013252549804747105, -0.019809570163488388, -0.008856227621436119, -0.012987500987946987, -0.035573069006204605, -0.044221676886081696, -0.01206156611442566, -0.04723142087459564, -0.031260982155799866, -0.0074574328027665615, -0.07838843017816544, -0.013020787388086319, 0.009461412206292152, 0.04382597655057907, 0.022125929594039917, 0.004318038001656532, 0.04582324996590614, -0.030572984367609024, 0.0009712464525364339, -0.040802113711833954, -0.003151229815557599, -0.002058004727587104, 0.05344424396753311, 0.05164676159620285, 0.02478620409965515, -0.02506774477660656, 0.015206806361675262, 0.00022088625701144338, 0.02551531419157982, 0.06776797026395798, -0.010399620980024338, -0.0005538127734325826, -0.004548919387161732, -0.0010027404641732574, 0.012661350890994072, 0.006614516489207745, 0.00919976457953453, 0.020316539332270622, 0.028111008927226067, 0.037090737372636795, 0.00849824771285057, 0.0006991047412157059, -0.012026685290038586, 0.019144989550113678, -0.012464920058846474, 0.0032151127234101295, -0.00029367720708251, 0.011663621291518211, 0.0339743010699749, -0.053867995738983154, 0.018937520682811737, -0.009985703974962234, -0.02576955035328865, 0.030872268602252007, -0.014046920463442802, 0.0494084358215332, 0.00003762872802326456, -0.06284843385219574, -0.02112434245646, -0.015759043395519257, -0.03483578562736511, 0.02891785278916359, -0.0513298362493515, -0.07038790732622147, -0.013992952182888985, 0.006383523810654879, -0.06827744841575623, -0.009451122023165226, -0.037806689739227295, -0.033848896622657776, 0.013012604787945747, -0.0007458290201611817, 0.0036743837408721447, 0.0033254779409617186, -0.000744983262848109, 0.016910362988710403, 0.05670240521430969, -0.012524682097136974, -0.011823846958577633, 0.05057360231876373, -0.008607665076851845, -0.03170052915811539, -0.01848648115992546, -0.06791269779205322, -0.008951752446591854, 0.007700581103563309, 0.02780924364924431, -0.011669408529996872, 0.007672570645809174, -0.010010047815740108, 0.009304864332079887, -0.035148985683918, 0.018534818664193153, 0.007776929065585136, -0.05065857619047165, -0.042965929955244064, 0.012231157161295414, 0.026613688096404076, -0.0050443317741155624, 0.0012531415559351444, -0.006448978558182716, -0.0046485536731779575, 0.01629110425710678, -0.039617422968149185, -0.06171184033155441, -0.0023853222373872995, 0.014856400899589062, 0.01231677457690239, -0.011634459719061852, -0.017722612246870995, 0.007445852737873793, 0.012537865899503231, 0.009795487858355045, 0.031470887362957, -0.03271183371543884, 0.007614417467266321, 0.04802551865577698, 0.04786902666091919, -0.03458113595843315, -0.013909011147916317, 0.03954209014773369, 0.022404305636882782, 0.059830233454704285, 0.008574786596000195, 0.006863463204354048, -0.027522526681423187, 0.022981375455856323, -0.026556573808193207, -0.012084298767149448, 0.0048176925629377365, 0.018366828560829163, 0.011348342522978783, 0.00749643798917532, -0.009455012157559395, -0.04504518583416939, 0.006096420809626579, 0.017010552808642387, -0.019906895235180855, -0.05426787585020065, 0.01857680082321167, -0.007451838813722134, 0.06442129611968994, 0.027989527210593224, -0.005821600556373596, -0.022318977862596512, -0.017266610637307167, 0.010672204196453094, -0.060046326369047165, -0.00005417898137238808, -0.00517728365957737, -0.040802888572216034, 0.007579145487397909, -0.0562589168548584, -0.07611171156167984, -0.03922279551625252, 0.06199268624186516, -0.03994210809469223, -0.020954139530658722, 0.039500657469034195, 0.0029213791713118553, -0.009154376573860645, 0.026832448318600655, -0.02096857875585556, 0.011309098452329636, 0.02517325058579445, 0.0030469121411442757, 0.021201973780989647, -0.028677422553300858, -0.020403139293193817, 0.03804365545511246, -0.013203191570937634, -0.06533265113830566, 0.05646190792322159, 0.03325190395116806, 0.03829270228743553, -0.0023529022000730038, 0.0005566392792388797, -0.04379613697528839, 0.010824746452271938, 0.010645242407917976, 0.05215206742286682, 0.03486257418990135, 0.03655177354812622, -0.02849668264389038, -0.029950788244605064, 0.009843581356108189, 0.04660860449075699, -0.0059326631017029285, -0.01841995306313038, 0.019238494336605072, -0.006170949432998896, -0.033665359020233154, 0.0019546865951269865, -0.03620738908648491, 0.0010839136084541678, 0.027607997879385948, 0.05061323195695877, 0.10400064289569855, -0.0228524599224329, -0.04988584294915199, 0.017443444579839706, 0.012121938169002533, 0.02026822790503502, 0.009815006516873837, 0.02643579989671707, -0.04764970764517784, -0.039418336004018784, 0.0004707317566499114, 0.0007361046737059951, -0.03774126619100571, -0.06510619074106216, 0.06352855265140533, -0.03079737164080143, 0.030263230204582214, -0.017257506027817726, 0.05644075945019722, -0.002468589460477233, 0.010878950357437134, -0.04533512890338898, -0.019184397533535957, 0.03336622938513756, -0.06613849103450775, -0.01542472280561924, -0.01590258628129959, -0.013392770662903786, -0.01321589108556509, -0.04535200819373131, -0.008629696443676949, 0.003500562161207199, 0.05816083028912544, 0.003653331659734249, -0.008375815115869045, -0.08048080652952194, 0.003469359828159213, 0.04122708737850189, -0.09385047852993011, 0.017583593726158142, 0.0030977479182183743, -0.015532318502664566, -0.010969163849949837, -0.04304111376404762, -0.005264796782284975, 0.01349607016891241, -0.01939491741359234, -0.030324682593345642, 0.02324877306818962, -0.02983103320002556, 0.00409654900431633, -0.0056227645836770535, -0.024314720183610916, -0.012730876915156841, 0.026358062401413918, -0.04556400701403618, 0.03808050602674484, -0.010582170449197292, 0.027594076469540596, -0.00037707702722400427, 0.013970297761261463, -0.02897672727704048, 0.038096290081739426, -0.036703165620565414, -0.03960559517145157, 0.01043744757771492, -0.012691976502537727, 0.016807567328214645, 0.07415974885225296, 0.029686961323022842, -0.028183184564113617, 0.009225098416209221, -0.006720270961523056, -0.023915909230709076, -0.005354858003556728, 0.033412713557481766, 0.04248794540762901, -0.008201435208320618, -0.029757503420114517, 0.060450684279203415, -0.05609830468893051, -0.06500479578971863, -0.0038306256756186485, -0.038213688880205154, -0.012546377256512642, -0.011832555755972862, -0.02986169047653675, -0.03835416957736015, -0.033115603029727936, 0.026749974116683006, -0.014839543029665947, -0.047773830592632294, 0.015214254148304462, 0.043671999126672745, 0.037746530026197433, 0.019447453320026398, 0.02608335390686989, -0.002468968043103814, 0.019825944676995277, 0.004875865764915943, -0.08474339544773102, -0.05770530551671982, -0.0505671501159668, 0.0031632971949875355, 0.004557264968752861, 0.029012851417064667, 0.028143996372818947, 0.012206305749714375, 0.024555763229727745, 0.026200462132692337, -0.009477350860834122, 0.05222783237695694, 0.03157762810587883, -0.009143865667283535, 0.012690359726548195, -0.015075751580297947, 0.016346311196684837, -0.05178401991724968, 0.013207247480750084, -0.006217144429683685, -0.05413131043314934, 0.04871125891804695, 0.07399304211139679, 0.01368874404579401, 0.07576106488704681, -0.03912772610783577, -0.009743588976562023, 0.031856413930654526, -0.03286467492580414, 0.004151889123022556, -0.052734147757291794, 0.055786456912755966, -0.003225825261324644, 0.051898978650569916, 0.01360473595559597, 0.060301609337329865, -0.043358564376831055, -0.016772940754890442, -0.012482987716794014, -0.03610539063811302, 0.047488193958997726, -0.03858086094260216, -0.05118778347969055, -0.03495299443602562, -0.017253680154681206, 0.015115532092750072, -0.04158089682459831, 0.01469366904348135, -0.07035937160253525, -0.022662699222564697, 0.006216634996235371, 0.033188194036483765, 0.07568012923002243, -0.05992810055613518, 0.0174875371158123, -0.02896844409406185, -0.030056390911340714, 0.036385659128427505, 0.00950490590184927, 0.06770604848861694, 0.005505161359906197, -0.04393239691853523, -0.0280787143856287, -0.0424639992415905, -0.04713543504476547, 0.00967700220644474, -0.03164775297045708, 0.061000190675258636, -0.0069793942384421825, 0.04445556923747063, 0.053584128618240356, 0.03487716615200043, -0.017813777551054955, -0.023398781195282936, 0.008274344727396965, 0.02048911526799202, -0.02388431318104267, 0.028116801753640175, -0.05836164951324463, 0.03697669133543968, 0.036807842552661896, 0.02334572933614254, -0.05925777181982994, 0.02492200769484043, -0.018430931493639946, 0.0660349503159523, 0.0686333104968071, -0.0004778399888891727, -0.04987427592277527, -0.035896945744752884, -0.04924657940864563, 0.04063626378774643, 0.04204520210623741, 0.014620156958699226, 0.028376281261444092, -0.107726089656353, 0.01016045268625021, 0.00021456240210682154, 0.008703784085810184, -0.03685455024242401, 0.0024593924172222614, -0.01637871563434601, 0.02436351403594017, 0.034305352717638016, 0.031247660517692566, -0.006985091604292393, 0.023554448038339615, -0.0028269027825444937, -0.0041372766718268394, 0.028774401172995567, -0.057764749974012375, 0.07336444407701492, 0.003520530415698886, -0.005672503728419542, -0.027574824169278145, 0.018377143889665604, -0.03356020897626877, -0.0708872452378273, -0.0037518092431128025, -0.012752797454595566, -0.032704953104257584, -0.05420533940196037, 0.03819684684276581, -0.05952455848455429, -0.04925072565674782, -0.033581703901290894, -0.052238721400499344, 0.07967893779277802, -0.01458423025906086, 0.011824091896414757, 0.029697079211473465, -0.06985611468553543, -0.0014342335052788258, -0.01642208732664585, 0.004785149358212948, -0.11153394728899002, -0.05387839302420616, 0.01679929345846176, 0.009363432414829731, -0.05551452562212944, -0.028104476630687714, 0.02461203932762146, 0.06857222318649292, -0.018973056226968765, 0.036113690584897995, 0.02668578363955021, -0.056232750415802, 0.00660060066729784, 0.08694589138031006, -0.03584329038858414, 0.034931764006614685, 0.03910677507519722, -0.010686865076422691, 0.03785610944032669, 0.011594229377806187, -0.03284219279885292, -0.0382736474275589, 0.019149893894791603, -0.0035747999791055918, -0.019781621173024178, -0.02333822473883629, 0.01766461506485939 ]
<p>I am looking at the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poincare_sphere" rel="nofollow">Poincaré sphere</a> and I am trying to compute a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jones_calculus" rel="nofollow">Jones matrix</a> for a particular rotation. Specifically, I would like it to perform the following maps:</p> <p>$O :|H \rangle \rightarrow |R \rangle$</p> <p>$O :|V \rangle \rightarrow |L \rangle$</p> <p>$O :|L \rangle \rightarrow |H \rangle$</p> <p>$O :|R \rangle \rightarrow |V \rangle$</p> <p>where $|R \rangle$, $|L \rangle$ are right circular and left circular light. Is this possible? I should mention that I would also accept the same equations with L,R replaced by linearly polarized light $|D \rangle$, $|A \rangle$. If it is possible, what would be common plates that could do it?</p>
g6594
[ -0.0172869935631752, -0.03923187404870987, -0.033427540212869644, -0.04052900895476341, 0.0328955240547657, -0.05959262698888779, 0.02570733241736889, -0.04236603528261185, 0.020247487351298332, 0.03928463160991669, 0.023309189826250076, 0.03284256532788277, 0.008973267860710621, -0.011335303075611591, -0.004695700481534004, 0.007298095617443323, 0.07168760895729065, 0.036271460354328156, 0.022828159853816032, -0.01142446231096983, 0.0033023206051439047, 0.011046087369322777, 0.048038020730018616, -0.06775002181529999, 0.040711645036935806, 0.0061075701378285885, -0.007403808645904064, 0.007465163711458445, -0.06002764776349068, 0.01726974919438362, -0.008141102269291878, -0.026888178661465645, 0.03417724370956421, -0.06675446033477783, 0.02105536498129368, 0.013652635738253593, 0.06494960188865662, 0.009886238723993301, 0.07269434630870819, 0.012543564662337303, 0.021161893382668495, 0.017580976709723473, 0.056800663471221924, 0.028907891362905502, 0.05702150613069534, -0.05153395235538483, 0.004544421099126339, 0.037183795124292374, -0.022430576384067535, 0.019978798925876617, -0.03301215544342995, 0.03284844011068344, 0.029757874086499214, -0.04709584638476372, -0.03686407580971718, 0.0411277711391449, -0.013403434306383133, -0.022110555320978165, 0.050402749329805374, 0.06295847147703171, -0.052601467818021774, -0.04421372339129448, -0.020717093721032143, 0.03134353458881378, -0.010301913134753704, 0.0045580933801829815, -0.01151890680193901, -0.05121447518467903, -0.04248291254043579, 0.03043191134929657, 0.01222018152475357, -0.04284784570336342, 0.04071887210011482, -0.03652123734354973, -0.04852984473109245, -0.015225067734718323, 0.03486735001206398, -0.01085295993834734, 0.03821536898612976, 0.0008450356544926763, -0.052268657833337784, 0.049324411898851395, 0.021565688773989677, -0.02463698945939541, 0.030163301154971123, 0.04532104358077049, 0.053671933710575104, 0.010474625043570995, -0.022888686507940292, -0.004418520722538233, 0.05393296107649803, -0.009468307718634605, 0.03341192752122879, 0.021619372069835663, -0.012788769789040089, -0.0007905730744823813, -0.027575528249144554, -0.011054075323045254, -0.02269122004508972, -0.015862008556723595, -0.04235774651169777, 0.005613136570900679, -0.03558563068509102, -0.019602136686444283, 0.02722337283194065, -0.024079935625195503, 0.047581613063812256, -0.013138895854353905, -0.0321049764752388, -0.017261819913983345, -0.04109952598810196, -0.029884593561291695, -0.052657559514045715, -0.03243899345397949, -0.02372862584888935, -0.08007486164569855, 0.09485846012830734, 0.011160354129970074, 0.007803717162460089, 0.07338099926710129, 0.05508428066968918, 0.018625184893608093, 0.023591574281454086, 0.10448609292507172, 0.03868235647678375, 0.08900002390146255, 0.009571559727191925, 0.002854568650946021, 0.08959262073040009, -0.01763305999338627, 0.00032969407038763165, -0.005506566260010004, 0.04533259943127632, 0.028094997629523277, -0.0081477090716362, 0.0002299377229064703, -0.025958482176065445, 0.02476038783788681, 0.001671169069595635, -0.039867278188467026, 0.008274097926914692, -0.053927771747112274, -0.005551743321120739, 0.014975707046687603, 0.012959991581737995, 0.015409840270876884, -0.009156238287687302, -0.07267431169748306, 0.06087252125144005, 0.07978963851928711, -0.010240050032734871, 0.08500926196575165, 0.0027061644941568375, 0.021828457713127136, 0.010531136766076088, 0.04571753740310669, 0.0078979367390275, -0.06962900608778, 0.002170682419091463, -0.02436671033501625, 0.032287582755088806, 0.006871670018881559, 0.0021940264850854874, -0.017968803644180298, -0.051102414727211, -0.012626090086996555, -0.019664062187075615, 0.013124961405992508, -0.04462243989109993, -0.0856320858001709, -0.02188735641539097, -0.0014960499247536063, 0.037799280136823654, 0.00541292317211628, 0.01837790571153164, 0.04859036207199097, -0.05738798528909683, -0.024668419733643532, 0.05313432961702347, -0.00006177099567139521, -0.031177613884210587, -0.0023467419669032097, 0.017200222238898277, -0.026395272463560104, 0.027284665033221245, -0.0020385736133903265, -0.020106922835111618, -0.0005259484169073403, -0.10649111121892929, -0.010506187565624714, 0.04342610388994217, 0.04605577141046524, 0.024150511249899864, 0.0037942861672490835, -0.035336535423994064, 0.007626127451658249, 0.0013441926566883922, -0.009090800769627094, -0.047319650650024414, 0.08494344353675842, 0.02430848404765129, 0.0027135678101330996, 0.05111624673008919, 0.02737526409327984, 0.006157777272164822, -0.023242225870490074, 0.004150428809225559, -0.02142190933227539, 0.022090455517172813, 0.022920534014701843, 0.024790648370981216, 0.01412222906947136, -0.005097163375467062, 0.0028214978519827127, -0.04255511611700058, -0.014124284498393536, -0.007524763233959675, 0.019832829013466835, -0.016367921605706215, 0.030073394998908043, -0.043542053550481796, 0.020387420430779457, -0.022737735882401466, 0.021890243515372276, -0.024704966694116592, 0.02422594279050827, -0.01733851432800293, -0.016756050288677216, -0.01628837361931801, 0.033656731247901917, -0.03321973606944084, -0.013845718465745449, 0.06119757890701294, -0.0038789331447333097, 0.034168146550655365, -0.008336658589541912, -0.01993229240179062, 0.019823778420686722, -0.01145227812230587, 0.056378502398729324, -0.008573872968554497, 0.01813872903585434, 0.02202923782169819, -0.01144544966518879, -0.014602801762521267, -0.017552871257066727, 0.04444103315472603, 0.006019267253577709, 0.04088359326124191, 0.08429557830095291, 0.0021340292878448963, -0.015016308054327965, -0.029216472059488297, 0.0017259134911000729, -0.018303226679563522, 0.007703026290982962, -0.04123156517744064, -0.014786407351493835, -0.026004014536738396, -0.022092444822192192, -0.031481657177209854, 0.0014307079836726189, -0.044432953000068665, 0.006519770715385675, -0.030717024579644203, 0.01612495630979538, -0.002433744026347995, -0.008679416961967945, 0.03241856023669243, 0.03004888817667961, -0.04060390219092369, 0.06464163959026337, 0.09839925915002823, 0.027970410883426666, -0.036366213113069534, -0.06415984779596329, -0.02691642940044403, 0.03389563784003258, -0.04144798219203949, 0.01731906272470951, 0.01511881873011589, -0.055345162749290466, -0.01353750005364418, 0.05295708030462265, -0.002899461891502142, -0.05100110545754433, -0.033843837678432465, 0.08063656091690063, -0.033997517079114914, 0.043090153485536575, -0.09323004633188248, 0.01447876263409853, 0.03204992786049843, -0.030047737061977386, 0.00548513000831008, -0.02578328736126423, 0.05145867541432381, -0.038277894258499146, 0.019248098134994507, 0.0947282686829567, 0.028120601549744606, -0.009762730449438095, 0.0046394397504627705, 0.0494270846247673, 0.05955155938863754, -0.002171905478462577, -0.02158202975988388, -0.034140825271606445, 0.020942507311701775, 0.0656297579407692, 0.024101916700601578, -0.0026416343171149492, -0.07502120733261108, -0.003215501783415675, 0.0020155496895313263, -0.0268094502389431, -0.03008350357413292, -0.05786186829209328, 0.03484078124165535, 0.007801136001944542, -0.05235162377357483, -0.026493119075894356, -0.043695565313100815, -0.007503056898713112, 0.03037663921713829, 0.044244956225156784, -0.035513874143362045, -0.005723266862332821, -0.017617229372262955, -0.03244709596037865, 0.04533040151000023, 0.002911938587203622, 0.02135293558239937, 0.0005878473166376352, -0.06705032289028168, -0.025576673448085785, -0.02272513136267662, 0.024152722209692, 0.053573139011859894, -0.06401032954454422, -0.041691310703754425, -0.08141063153743744, -0.03407278656959534, -0.03229203075170517, 0.014809023588895798, -0.0051718177273869514, -0.006943970452994108, 0.0006713566835969687, 0.023938948288559914, -0.02276776172220707, -0.028390787541866302, -0.039178650826215744, 0.055041905492544174, -0.013785390183329582, 0.05750594660639763, 0.03501508757472038, 0.02958785556256771, 0.0927593782544136, 0.03642888739705086, 0.006546913646161556, -0.02337425947189331, -0.02972722239792347, -0.019290871918201447, -0.014207988046109676, 0.048787232488393784, 0.04449052736163139, 0.03804883360862732, 0.03591649979352951, -0.022745715454220772, 0.009018690325319767, 0.03426757827401161, 0.03710661455988884, 0.007242310326546431, -0.042473696172237396, -0.012051839381456375, -0.03442864492535591, -0.00813936535269022, 0.023068683221936226, -0.015352163463830948, 0.0011268701637163758, -0.09305494278669357, -0.003278787015005946, 0.04599983990192413, 0.06497867405414581, -0.00691559910774231, 0.032509755343198776, -0.0030606971122324467, 0.0262112058699131, -0.0026177617255598307, 0.037433940917253494, -0.014057538472115993, -0.048723574727773666, -0.021736161783337593, -0.004548182245343924, 0.033968981355428696, -0.03055463172495365, -0.007095783948898315, -0.0834561213850975, -0.11813949793577194, 0.01346143800765276, 0.04716205596923828, -0.026934172958135605, 0.024183468893170357, 0.0029717020224779844, -0.03670279309153557, -0.058336976915597916, 0.014950140379369259, 0.04557358846068382, 0.02722191996872425, -0.008943099528551102, -0.04769674316048622, -0.04148232191801071, 0.04402963072061539, -0.05563049763441086, 0.038924653083086014, 0.05745267495512962, 0.012798148207366467, -0.00043902764446102083, -0.003657254623249173, 0.018853219226002693, -0.010251672007143497, 0.05511080101132393, -0.0006236709887161851, -0.0026235822588205338, 0.02841438166797161, 0.03320488706231117, 0.0566679984331131, -0.05709262564778328, 0.04640670865774155, -0.04742185398936272, 0.03296651691198349, -0.005060412455350161, -0.021299729123711586, -0.032087624073028564, -0.01405284833163023, -0.07762525230646133, -0.07001127302646637, 0.0378609336912632, 0.024305326864123344, -0.016528304666280746, -0.021446306258440018, -0.00491828890517354, 0.03274234011769295, -0.031937915831804276, 0.0017970665358006954, 0.02002079039812088, -0.0008121757418848574, -0.02550974115729332, 0.006989501882344484, -0.013256239704787731, 0.0006883720052428544, -0.007484181318432093, 0.021735405549407005, -0.012498120777308941, -0.013893870636820793, 0.01975277066230774, -0.029074911028146744, 0.04113525524735451, 0.004808826372027397, 0.029423555359244347, 0.010655407793819904, -0.0419374480843544, -0.020067820325493813, -0.06848803162574768, 0.04834406077861786, 0.012370269745588303, -0.08188005536794662, 0.07107431441545486, -0.05028915032744408, -0.036545462906360626, 0.005593622103333473, 0.012145230546593666, 0.011255617253482342, 0.004356587305665016, -0.08285707235336304, -0.01907251589000225, -0.05426345020532608, -0.042860765010118484, -0.0038577010855078697, -0.0541033074259758, -0.03986801952123642, 0.0032288762740790844, 0.014176007360219955, 0.004861645400524139, -0.00385196297429502, -0.007344874553382397, -0.0274529866874218, -0.030585695058107376, -0.020713189616799355, 0.015064220875501633, -0.020137619227170944, 0.01570044830441475, -0.02856695093214512, -0.012680752202868462, 0.029525641351938248, 0.016062049195170403, 0.010461515747010708, -0.059825148433446884, -0.064470574259758, 0.01633823662996292, -0.010914602316915989, 0.0038472614251077175, 0.007290317676961422, -0.04066687822341919, -0.010374619625508785, -0.009396331384778023, 0.04573947563767433, 0.0495821088552475, 0.021772239357233047, 0.03643450513482094, 0.005570066627115011, -0.05668375641107559, 0.021737217903137207, 0.01965528540313244, -0.03852070868015289, -0.024236368015408516, -0.07017114758491516, -0.007585298735648394, -0.02959025278687477, -0.055333517491817474, 0.013516961596906185, -0.0452093780040741, 0.007364185526967049, 0.014499434269964695, 0.039931103587150574, 0.021715950220823288, -0.0314905047416687, 0.0030734543688595295, 0.03508736565709114, 0.015530938282608986, -0.020561838522553444, -0.06693550944328308, 0.025517424568533897, 0.005175312981009483, 0.007250119931995869, -0.04952091723680496, 0.028313761577010155, 0.002782056573778391, 0.04466147720813751, -0.014954362995922565, -0.02805481106042862, -0.055333126336336136, 0.07443226873874664, 0.04681135341525078, -0.00940465647727251, -0.0019270398188382387, 0.03731599450111389, -0.010424328036606312, -0.020516647025942802, -0.018787814304232597, -0.0574256032705307, 0.04088189825415611, 0.014870810322463512, -0.043019816279411316, -0.005474223755300045, 0.00991752091795206, -0.025844698771834373, -0.04107384383678436, -0.005973870866000652, 0.016790466383099556, 0.08793526142835617, -0.07200722396373749, -0.00851472932845354, -0.044704798609018326, -0.012813475914299488, 0.0006069567170925438, -0.002299162093549967, 0.012447607703506947, 0.03467289358377457, 0.08846591413021088, -0.027414953336119652, -0.04954831674695015, -0.039889879524707794, 0.06862043589353561, 0.06314881891012192, 0.02182171680033207, -0.006355399265885353, 0.020282620564103127, -0.013736629858613014, 0.02848823554813862, -0.006477997172623873, 0.028687410056591034, 0.011414559558033943, 0.007664796430617571, -0.004493552725762129, 0.002588978735730052, -0.03276070952415466, 0.04932722821831703, 0.02907421812415123, -0.049025148153305054, -0.00779959000647068, -0.022555658593773842, -0.06009658798575401, -0.01792936399579048, -0.01704428158700466, -0.009118660353124142, -0.02390768565237522, 0.05125606432557106, 0.025466540828347206, -0.011792014352977276, 0.02062571793794632, -0.02748621068894863, 0.028757445514202118, -0.01134329754859209, 0.013642675243318081, -0.022424260154366493, -0.09900180250406265, -0.03937637805938721, 0.022465405985713005, 0.029784642159938812, -0.0010391224641352892, 0.02056235820055008, 0.020751696079969406, 0.04005050286650658, -0.033293526619672775, -0.012259217910468578, -0.04534465819597244, 0.018931806087493896, 0.02938253805041313, -0.016690673306584358, 0.026868531480431557, -0.044104281812906265, -0.04473637416958809, -0.04301893338561058, 0.029294341802597046, 0.0017370512941852212, -0.016095854341983795, 0.02366846427321434, 0.056723810732364655, 0.07909092307090759, 0.042061615735292435, -0.008726336061954498, -0.023198263719677925, -0.010447373613715172, 0.05367652326822281, 0.0064465622417628765, -0.08667917549610138, 0.033603355288505554, 0.048090752214193344, 0.03782997652888298, 0.004534753039479256, 0.057968590408563614, 0.027063993737101555, 0.030061904340982437, -0.00017174531240016222, -0.024978064000606537, -0.012016315944492817, -0.017297115176916122, -0.040613945573568344, 0.07336927950382233, 0.07348380982875824, 0.03447423875331879, -0.01008154172450304, 0.027833648025989532, -0.0367841012775898, -0.005742955487221479, 0.037695009261369705, 0.0029992905911058187, 0.020550215616822243, -0.009087612852454185, -0.0062064859084784985, -0.014512740075588226, -0.01924842596054077, -0.04842599853873253, -0.022569401189684868, -0.018361162394285202, -0.028928518295288086, 0.03158422186970711, 0.013851886615157127, -0.0169130377471447, -0.021848367527127266, 0.02136402390897274, -0.027086080983281136, 0.04988650977611542, 0.0012769006425514817, 0.02465670369565487, -0.005392932798713446, 0.009035322815179825, -0.0021786238066852093, -0.0015180400805547833, 0.03203757479786873, -0.023796137422323227, -0.027226174250245094, 0.04076336324214935, 0.03487154841423035, 0.0005200332961976528, 0.020544307306408882, -0.014088073745369911, 0.030595162883400917, -0.011910824105143547, -0.011304154992103577, 0.02768896520137787, 0.00857853889465332, 0.04049072042107582, -0.012921633198857307, -0.021601708605885506, -0.012956084683537483, 0.019505659118294716, -0.05155500769615173, -0.017653116956353188, -0.01577652432024479, -0.0025992118753492832, -0.01828925684094429, -0.05368618667125702, -0.01388601679354906, -0.04105121269822121, -0.04218124970793724, -0.007756254635751247, 0.02517259493470192, 0.018932925537228584, 0.0059929401613771915, 0.06404329091310501, -0.08002833276987076, 0.022862473502755165, 0.0034623295068740845, -0.02618437260389328, 0.0070948186330497265, 0.047166381031274796, 0.007589614484459162, 0.019197886809706688, -0.04689444229006767, 0.0011552706127986312, 0.0008206263883039355, -0.017512980848550797, 0.02879217080771923, -0.024532968178391457, -0.02312052622437477, 0.03183136135339737, 0.03182957321405411, 0.00270868930965662, 0.039915040135383606, 0.021488284692168236, -0.05063110589981079, 0.007924034260213375, 0.02567683532834053, 0.007469770032912493, -0.09878913313150406, -0.0418744832277298, 0.039669640362262726, 0.02989790216088295, 0.012661561369895935, -0.0623168908059597, 0.04498031362891197, -0.04259975627064705, -0.006158336065709591, 0.011548293754458427, -0.02270166203379631, 0.013021525926887989, 0.031001050025224686, -0.05280749127268791, -0.047519195824861526, 0.07447737455368042, 0.01756073534488678, -0.026033945381641388, 0.04762466251850128, -0.0423317514359951, -0.012803100980818272, 0.011362497694790363, 0.06558609753847122, -0.03414522483944893, 0.005082802847027779, -0.01677311770617962, -0.0413515530526638, 0.039676912128925323, 0.021924201399087906, -0.09482236951589584, -0.031518299132585526, 0.043711207807064056 ]
<p>How are the external magnetic field intensity H, magnetisation M and the entropy related to each other? i.e. if I change the magnetic field intensity by dH what will be the change in entropy dS in terms of M. </p>
g6595
[ -0.02490917779505253, -0.010762154124677181, -0.006234962027519941, -0.06791726499795914, 0.01801198534667492, -0.018600493669509888, -0.020957693457603455, 0.05904553458094597, -0.06863655149936676, 0.0010673931101337075, -0.05751891806721687, 0.01947496086359024, 0.055071815848350525, -0.019470777362585068, 0.030559463426470757, 0.06446710973978043, -0.030452627688646317, 0.0140162268653512, 0.00876266323029995, 0.002611073898151517, -0.05647386983036995, 0.008402982726693153, 0.00880889780819416, -0.06134602054953575, -0.02433401718735695, -0.012363621033728123, 0.05879070982336998, -0.03404480963945389, -0.004310490097850561, -0.006772888358682394, 0.010201697237789631, 0.056189779192209244, 0.023888511583209038, -0.05032562464475632, -0.039705559611320496, 0.01787056028842926, 0.03997034579515457, 0.07412026077508926, 0.019840577617287636, 0.01802222430706024, 0.015526998788118362, -0.02874995768070221, 0.024099910631775856, -0.06697297096252441, -0.04934483766555786, 0.004011719021946192, -0.019887983798980713, -0.013743515126407146, -0.0104100052267313, 0.013311157003045082, -0.041321367025375366, 0.002106179716065526, 0.05956120043992996, 0.015732672065496445, 0.03655843436717987, 0.046255555003881454, 0.008312989957630634, -0.06609391421079636, 0.07745519280433655, 0.022407598793506622, 0.005360024515539408, -0.043353334069252014, -0.07132767885923386, 0.031041843816637993, -0.020500853657722473, -0.019630812108516693, 0.008902309462428093, -0.03796836733818054, -0.016627119854092598, 0.022234024479985237, -0.057237282395362854, -0.04186442121863365, -0.023501502349972725, -0.015514099970459938, 0.010806151665747166, 0.060402531176805496, 0.09186191856861115, -0.042298898100852966, 0.04992185905575752, -0.008432609960436821, -0.07471659779548645, -0.03910357877612114, 0.042901862412691116, -0.021125702187418938, 0.05545593798160553, 0.021159693598747253, 0.03164709359407425, 0.006236406974494457, 0.02553589455783367, -0.0041459305211901665, -0.02216511033475399, -0.03322531655430794, -0.008312786929309368, -0.02390776202082634, -0.03158974647521973, 0.07666417956352234, 0.028100579977035522, 0.040345121175050735, 0.012745517306029797, 0.00922498106956482, -0.022376950830221176, -0.04525327682495117, 0.04160987585783005, -0.016583649441599846, -0.03737214580178261, 0.021150454878807068, 0.015049898996949196, -0.023370960727334023, -0.03484847769141197, 0.062424298375844955, -0.013569542206823826, -0.023402323946356773, -0.06475914269685745, -0.004233321640640497, -0.026133134961128235, -0.03883854299783707, 0.06771411746740341, -0.061599504202604294, -0.020840050652623177, 0.00529239047318697, 0.054028239101171494, 0.005598232615739107, -0.003006367478519678, 0.046795330941677094, 0.009205601178109646, 0.0032788256648927927, 0.0006540807080455124, 0.017199937254190445, 0.04808850586414337, -0.08034391701221466, 0.027833690866827965, -0.039412595331668854, 0.040781501680612564, 0.0035422968212515116, 0.018497584387660027, 0.008570290170609951, 0.027442051097750664, 0.010344869457185268, -0.0044721998274326324, 0.030684819445014, -0.011194082908332348, -0.03539649397134781, 0.01361320074647665, -0.04302085191011429, 0.003696838626638055, 0.045564960688352585, -0.0023388650733977556, -0.06089954078197479, 0.003451284021139145, -0.011527356691658497, 0.060658425092697144, -0.023750483989715576, -0.004488751292228699, 0.029214784502983093, -0.019155623391270638, -0.008421206846833229, 0.013783251866698265, 0.06054707616567612, -0.02062060311436653, 0.004514271859079599, 0.011199972592294216, -0.04197557643055916, 0.05357843637466431, 0.01911957375705242, -0.001066095195710659, 0.021565979346632957, 0.12057105451822281, -0.027822021394968033, -0.006175353657454252, -0.005740239284932613, -0.01605568639934063, 0.011023562401533127, 0.013725591823458672, -0.0032380030024796724, 0.00854295864701271, 0.07648911327123642, -0.00604406138882041, -0.01932779885828495, 0.044703178107738495, 0.03725457936525345, 0.004632552154362202, 0.059173062443733215, 0.06058615818619728, -0.052273672074079514, 0.016461923718452454, 0.01760871894657612, 0.010958712548017502, 0.006454050540924072, -0.06902029365301132, -0.001506460946984589, -0.010916412808001041, -0.009664329700171947, -0.018048154190182686, 0.018020611256361008, 0.030428551137447357, -0.01797705516219139, -0.03872038051486015, 0.02996605820953846, -0.02171529270708561, -0.005801761522889137, 0.000810174155049026, 0.0487084686756134, 0.0499422587454319, -0.01088765449821949, 0.013035813346505165, 0.05161453038454056, 0.041023124009370804, 0.02786274626851082, 0.0594031922519207, -0.0060889278538525105, 0.00017680175369605422, -0.05015213415026665, -0.01036488264799118, 0.005205599591135979, 0.017108626663684845, -0.016997890546917915, 0.014577727764844894, 0.026454269886016846, -0.023321060463786125, -0.0009986677905544639, -0.010140450671315193, 0.00482543557882309, 0.04604673013091087, 0.031003693118691444, -0.08693148195743561, -0.01897757314145565, -0.008351297117769718, 0.04984097182750702, -0.004624802153557539, -0.015755362808704376, 0.012246784754097462, 0.030736083164811134, 0.011800839565694332, 0.009553877636790276, -0.03829643130302429, 0.04426495358347893, 0.023036640137434006, -0.002892172895371914, 0.01852295733988285, 0.027015885338187218, -0.002937008859589696, 0.043761271983385086, -0.005916548892855644, 0.024022212252020836, 0.0013738127890974283, -0.03390226140618324, 0.06584049761295319, 0.017334554344415665, -0.050112590193748474, 0.04210558906197548, 0.02215508557856083, 0.0015688104322180152, -0.0010041353525593877, 0.028317304328083992, -0.018418824300169945, 0.005145195405930281, -0.05579891800880432, -0.004178984090685844, -0.04767335206270218, -0.004459851887077093, -0.00787353329360485, -0.007590522523969412, 0.02461835741996765, 0.04869457706809044, -0.03962504491209984, -0.01587320677936077, 0.0011788633419200778, -0.022528300061821938, 0.001632483908906579, -0.03768270090222359, -0.006947062909603119, 0.0906025692820549, 0.013903922401368618, 0.023881591856479645, 0.021759910508990288, 0.030875010415911674, 0.004389047622680664, 0.003028523176908493, -0.003156080609187484, -0.08262749761343002, 0.0028049603570252657, 0.02653897926211357, -0.06756821274757385, -0.006225711200386286, -0.00834314338862896, -0.025739748030900955, 0.01762285642325878, -0.024096187204122543, -0.023173203691840172, 0.03150632977485657, -0.005901811644434929, 0.0320509634912014, 0.03182457014918327, 0.000326974899508059, 0.01333870179951191, -0.0023793026339262724, 0.030298098921775818, -0.030181802809238434, 0.01797725446522236, 0.058048635721206665, 0.023035665974020958, 0.014180849306285381, -0.03619660437107086, -0.007251677103340626, 0.02065729722380638, 0.038461506366729736, -0.09864555299282074, -0.058142825961112976, 0.021730167791247368, 0.010291497223079205, -0.0661853775382042, -0.0474635548889637, 0.02531435713171959, -0.006616774946451187, 0.02839650586247444, 0.014319594949483871, 0.03148147463798523, -0.0007543861865997314, 0.01466740109026432, 0.010115992277860641, 0.0029829563573002815, -0.06324102729558945, -0.0012534352717921138, -0.059350188821554184, 0.016094747930765152, -0.0016262856079265475, 0.010370769537985325, -0.05461001768708229, -0.034139130264520645, -0.001079629990272224, 0.031393714249134064, -0.01612294651567936, 0.029011942446231842, -0.025291983038187027, -0.14780659973621368, 0.032610535621643066, -0.026293806731700897, -0.07717112451791763, -0.03193661943078041, 0.047167323529720306, 0.03906488046050072, -0.029069125652313232, -0.08276821672916412, 0.0053392923437058926, -0.024659665301442146, 0.0402517095208168, -0.03732168674468994, -0.04087534919381142, 0.0011860063532367349, 0.018930699676275253, -0.015646647661924362, 0.0049056196585297585, 0.04670131206512451, 0.03221631795167923, -0.0025541535578668118, -0.037044815719127655, 0.03477882593870163, -0.03293255716562271, -0.03414567932486534, 0.01482013426721096, -0.03994940593838692, -0.05071365460753441, -0.022138716652989388, -0.023989172652363777, -0.0530906580388546, 0.07960408180952072, -0.02119513973593712, 0.021252531558275223, -0.058304522186517715, -0.015263054519891739, 0.002279639942571521, -0.023348910734057426, -0.06049366295337677, 0.014280369505286217, 0.008733022026717663, -0.05283096432685852, 0.05846733972430229, -0.024773288518190384, -0.04407672584056854, 0.02790187858045101, 0.0032099029049277306, 0.03226000815629959, -0.0027642708737403154, 0.0182019155472517, 0.053268853574991226, -0.01342826709151268, -0.014367693103849888, 0.06112859398126602, 0.0074203661642968655, -0.055323608219623566, -0.010512959212064743, 0.004993366543203592, 0.014317736960947514, -0.0032428286504000425, 0.021754972636699677, 0.008133018389344215, 0.014571635983884335, 0.008155577816069126, -0.012878760695457458, 0.014092502184212208, 0.008629607036709785, 0.005596514325588942, -0.01266349758952856, 0.0421585775911808, -0.004071332979947329, -0.06234807148575783, -0.0087994784116745, 0.006738944444805384, 0.041173674166202545, -0.04624791815876961, 0.00636011827737093, -0.03802206367254257, 0.0052290079183876514, -0.032641202211380005, 0.014800380915403366, 0.016317078843712807, 0.04248394817113876, -0.03200710564851761, 0.005884499289095402, -0.011577781289815903, 0.046681031584739685, 0.013596104457974434, -0.0164844561368227, 0.007009419146925211, -0.0634055957198143, 0.054246559739112854, 0.06504794210195541, -0.008119983598589897, 0.018346533179283142, -0.03760714828968048, -0.023910576477646828, 0.030020534992218018, -0.0017156933899968863, 0.06611958891153336, -0.04329586401581764, 0.07087480276823044, -0.03157171607017517, 0.007500004023313522, -0.026992714032530785, -0.045977506786584854, 0.04253605753183365, 0.04605930671095848, -0.016011472791433334, -0.03602428734302521, -0.038808420300483704, 0.03830049932003021, -0.05712645873427391, -0.007021363824605942, 0.0037979059852659702, -0.046324700117111206, -0.05909962207078934, 0.022025151178240776, -0.013032699935138226, -0.02978266403079033, 0.04624008387327194, 0.041123006492853165, -0.02925514057278633, 0.014071165584027767, -0.014003866352140903, -0.05675516650080681, -0.06866591423749924, 0.0352703332901001, -0.04575439542531967, -0.009496273472905159, -0.052147235721349716, -0.02325332909822464, -0.04417926073074341, 0.002373156603425741, -0.056306708604097366, 0.038520559668540955, 0.1118742823600769, 0.0053482335060834885, 0.013424361124634743, -0.029808763414621353, 0.07440046966075897, 0.0635654479265213, -0.0003507981891743839, -0.04457342252135277, 0.00284782238304615, -0.0589769072830677, -0.007558744866400957, 0.0029671478550881147, 0.06560766696929932, 0.05045145004987717, -0.026453720405697823, -0.016687562689185143, 0.022516947239637375, -0.0022074501030147076, 0.026711978018283844, -0.028977394104003906, -0.005096239037811756, 0.05953919142484665, 0.06090454384684563, 0.01537864375859499, -0.03512544184923172, 0.003440834814682603, -0.06133658066391945, -0.04661920666694641, -0.04237888380885124, 0.0017677515279501677, -0.05408751219511032, 0.06228259578347206, -0.03511878475546837, 0.009380530565977097, -0.0066190748475492, 0.06968101114034653, 0.0729793980717659, -0.06574343889951706, 0.039720650762319565, 0.05420353636145592, -0.03338305652141571, 0.047361116856336594, 0.001894377637654543, 0.019291546195745468, 0.03159844130277634, 0.010597233660519123, 0.00571824423968792, 0.031711380928754807, 0.03092264011502266, -0.06416136771440506, 0.06129811704158783, 0.00013972462329547852, 0.04845282435417175, -0.060149844735860825, -0.0794127881526947, 0.04753788933157921, -0.03851178288459778, -0.005384679883718491, 0.01657327450811863, 0.04344962164759636, -0.007368953432887793, 0.08346813917160034, 0.010393507778644562, 0.0062704128213226795, -0.0015590771799907088, -0.08017189800739288, 0.02760271169245243, 0.02027897723019123, -0.030679643154144287, 0.06958846002817154, -0.0020761005580425262, -0.027148300781846046, -0.022059854120016098, 0.012384451925754547, -0.005531241651624441, -0.016687165945768356, -0.0017053178744390607, -0.056481484323740005, -0.006482125259935856, -0.001981921959668398, -0.048649657517671585, -0.012190941721200943, 0.03127104789018631, -0.02234334498643875, -0.05696025863289833, -0.0070625958032906055, 0.06790313124656677, -0.006558750756084919, 0.04514402523636818, 0.03130180388689041, 0.03885820508003235, -0.004830216523259878, -0.043621692806482315, 0.005491893272846937, -0.0030795831698924303, -0.039142657071352005, 0.056175097823143005, 0.02194112353026867, 0.05016729235649109, 0.07789406925439835, -0.013895170763134956, 0.05475122481584549, -0.027878403663635254, -0.031855031847953796, 0.0269081462174654, 0.006778495851904154, -0.019524209201335907, -0.05299883708357811, -0.039763227105140686, -0.033608052879571915, -0.03200245648622513, 0.024721721187233925, 0.047093410044908524, -0.017221810296177864, -0.021825328469276428, 0.026888767257332802, -0.03369743749499321, -0.004979812074452639, 0.02374264970421791, -0.0008365468820556998, -0.0391109474003315, 0.030299551784992218, 0.011981664225459099, 0.0022273364011198282, -0.02168346382677555, 0.0035025663673877716, -0.043176472187042236, -0.004166341386735439, -0.006356297992169857, 0.0059967609122395515, -0.04223136976361275, -0.050084929913282394, -0.009586009196937084, -0.038161471486091614, 0.012740924023091793, 0.028555238619446754, -0.02322324924170971, 0.006907507311552763, -0.07270964980125427, 0.009451249614357948, 0.013546866364777088, -0.03710847720503807, 0.00770967174321413, 0.016696706414222717, 0.03315814957022667, 0.00699276477098465, -0.028042646124958992, 0.03399565443396568, 0.033657561987638474, 0.02670758217573166, -0.03025979734957218, -0.053088873624801636, 0.029383815824985504, -0.05641339346766472, 0.0005788997514173388, 0.0575728565454483, -0.009483731351792812, -0.035673588514328, -0.05922015756368637, 0.010743086226284504, -0.02116771601140499, 0.013216709718108177, 0.02878546714782715, 0.06264948099851608, 0.024051537737250328, 0.009087339043617249, 0.017141055315732956, -0.008810336701571941, 0.01894461363554001, 0.0674382746219635, 0.04339759424328804, -0.0005832695751450956, -0.018344607204198837, -0.04421444982290268, 0.0027717642951756716, -0.04944053664803505, 0.006431469228118658, -0.0325743593275547, -0.0394684262573719, 0.017721934244036674, -0.00574118597432971, -0.0062489258125424385, 0.01011764258146286, 0.013230525888502598, -0.018883254379034042, 0.08206693828105927, -0.012838131748139858, 0.05971800535917282, 0.026342589408159256, -0.006167392246425152, 0.011637642979621887, 0.004434054717421532, -0.02093425765633583, -0.0024050285574048758, 0.055643461644649506, 0.03591596335172653, 0.036024801433086395, -0.0005034139612689614, 0.010666828602552414, -0.0035817588213831186, -0.013125963509082794, -0.034197017550468445, -0.06249286234378815, 0.009447313845157623, -0.017616646364331245, -0.01919189840555191, -0.0019323609303683043, -0.0041887108236551285, 0.01298234611749649, 0.009504633955657482, -0.023819919675588608, -0.0347563810646534, 0.006865601520985365, -0.02456783689558506, -0.025416933000087738, 0.057793084532022476, -0.08708391338586807, 0.006297592539340258, 0.09878174960613251, 0.03148447349667549, -0.01303150225430727, -0.04817502945661545, 0.026933103799819946, -0.02581625245511532, -0.058873631060123444, 0.01879124529659748, 0.01404203474521637, 0.04304623231291771, 0.038513511419296265, -0.068028524518013, 0.049160558730363846, 0.004765900317579508, 0.024417590349912643, 0.0030607059597969055, 0.046781737357378006, 0.022929882630705833, -0.013575652614235878, 0.00917770341038704, 0.011877371929585934, 0.041118793189525604, 0.03726253658533096, 0.0116995545104146, 0.019386865198612213, -0.03304577246308327, -0.021400636062026024, 0.001878612325526774, -0.08685143291950226, -0.03223845362663269, 0.007959055714309216, 0.020405884832143784, -0.010314499959349632, 0.006367061752825975, -0.05513804405927658, -0.004132363013923168, -0.04013608396053314, -0.00011969134357059374, 0.014813079498708248, 0.005873522721230984, 0.04641834273934364, -0.010196806862950325, -0.001090772682800889, -0.011693420819938183, -0.04239349439740181, -0.03794041648507118, -0.06930096447467804, 0.01055392250418663, 0.03286238759756088, -0.03444157913327217, 0.04610719904303551, -0.024340780451893806, 0.003945698495954275, -0.040033210068941116, 0.04664521664381027, -0.001228143461048603, 0.0007275743409991264, -0.016484105959534645, -0.0549432672560215, 0.048328448086977005, 0.021032141521573067, 0.007827450521290302, 0.017800575122237206, -0.06671510636806488, -0.05303967371582985, -0.03596600517630577, 0.03535659983754158, -0.04650783911347389, -0.05478357896208763, 0.034592244774103165, 0.015545970760285854, -0.004628709517419338, 0.04645160958170891, -0.04283883795142174, -0.056335512548685074, 0.04534575715661049, -0.017959071323275566, 0.036324966698884964, 0.002096872078254819, 0.020972440019249916 ]
<p>An isolated system $A$ has entropy $S_a&gt;0$.</p> <p>Next, the isolation of $A$ is temporarily violated, and it has entropy reduced $$S_b ~=~ S_a - S,\space\space\space S\leq S_a.$$</p> <p>Is it true to say: <strong>the process of lowering entropy of a system requires work and energy?</strong></p> <p>I am not sure if energy of the system must be changed when entropy is reduced. However, energy certainly is required – changing entropy is work and uses energy?</p>
g6596
[ -0.011030582711100578, -0.018241597339510918, -0.00700860982760787, 0.001014787470921874, -0.030988316982984543, -0.039470523595809937, -0.023872070014476776, 0.04552027955651283, -0.022543029859662056, 0.01824622042477131, -0.07167244702577591, 0.026290182024240494, -0.016512876376509666, 0.0015668855048716068, -0.044047001749277115, 0.04908245429396629, 0.055720869451761246, -0.02217678911983967, -0.003859678516164422, 0.03450828418135643, -0.051544636487960815, -0.0020957577507942915, 0.019389402121305466, -0.033441558480262756, 0.05748981982469559, -0.048540566116571426, 0.07072635740041733, -0.03469721972942352, -0.03520456328988075, 0.01174684427678585, 0.02646426297724247, -0.00397665286436677, 0.07428935170173645, -0.07169755548238754, -0.03488438203930855, -0.014250749722123146, 0.12439098209142685, 0.04749506339430809, 0.020665345713496208, -0.03812618926167488, -0.02520771324634552, -0.008320351131260395, -0.006752932444214821, -0.022333785891532898, 0.0035966860596090555, -0.02725515328347683, 0.014392798766493797, -0.001529269153252244, -0.014132026582956314, -0.022544942796230316, 0.040483422577381134, 0.04241032153367996, -0.00378752825781703, -0.011837788857519627, 0.025166409090161324, 0.013794726692140102, -0.0032353198621422052, -0.013302027247846127, 0.029698241502046585, -0.00608249893411994, 0.011559275910258293, -0.012824423611164093, 0.017002016305923462, 0.012157319113612175, -0.0012830375926569104, -0.01644100621342659, 0.028259340673685074, -0.041147682815790176, 0.007895637303590775, 0.00876842811703682, -0.010804866440594196, 0.011653166264295578, -0.027976185083389282, -0.027063583955168724, 0.07827119529247284, 0.0010453475406393409, 0.06013503298163414, -0.03499908000230789, -0.06033266335725784, 0.032417453825473785, 0.008779138326644897, -0.0283040851354599, 0.029287973418831825, 0.012756303884088993, 0.013195101171731949, 0.01383979618549347, 0.013196810148656368, -0.02878967486321926, 0.03208282217383385, 0.054173510521650314, 0.0028486009687185287, -0.030161935836076736, 0.07301415503025055, -0.00592467375099659, -0.0010512863518670201, 0.03564705327153206, 0.002016606042161584, 0.026231015101075172, 0.023464318364858627, 0.007067080587148666, -0.021436557173728943, -0.10906117409467697, -0.020733781158924103, -0.07426844537258148, -0.015533944591879845, -0.005087336990982294, 0.015312213450670242, -0.024238329380750656, 0.00676521472632885, 0.03317161649465561, 0.031008267775177956, 0.00789624359458685, -0.04343608766794205, -0.046866901218891144, 0.022160714492201805, -0.009086019359529018, 0.09760892391204834, -0.059895314276218414, 0.0011782386573031545, 0.021308770403265953, -0.0406811460852623, -0.007445590570569038, 0.004964787978678942, 0.08300333470106125, -0.023202968761324883, 0.03823799639940262, 0.013861519284546375, 0.051247987896203995, 0.04705298691987991, -0.011829319410026073, -0.016643250361084938, 0.017342306673526764, 0.00270721479319036, 0.029584620147943497, 0.007999757304787636, 0.02103555016219616, -0.018879439681768417, -0.001517802127636969, 0.01304697897285223, -0.023390693590044975, -0.00016250192129518837, 0.0394321046769619, -0.02283845841884613, 0.0016014935681596398, -0.029950348660349846, -0.030027000233530998, -0.012858182191848755, 0.02732575312256813, 0.012680231593549252, -0.017171192914247513, -0.019263586029410362, 0.032650433480739594, -0.03349485248327255, -0.03809577599167824, 0.018436502665281296, -0.015120603144168854, 0.038292307406663895, 0.055160973221063614, 0.05151791125535965, -0.012651502154767513, 0.0656433254480362, -0.028872227296233177, 0.0831085816025734, 0.010550711303949356, -0.0602886825799942, 0.055145613849163055, -0.004491688217967749, -0.02255137450993061, 0.030352458357810974, -0.030465038493275642, -0.08538027852773666, -0.05013900250196457, -0.012456484138965607, 0.02909921668469906, -0.012879917398095131, 0.05462443828582764, 0.06230565533041954, -0.013039489276707172, 0.02085333876311779, -0.02960118278861046, -0.048102401196956635, 0.04362472891807556, 0.05141361802816391, -0.03511703386902809, 0.04445505514740944, 0.038966093212366104, -0.027317259460687637, 0.012466536834836006, -0.08241292089223862, 0.0009199542691931129, -0.039530251175165176, 0.013082736171782017, 0.00008865175914252177, 0.005742603447288275, 0.019500426948070526, 0.008103850297629833, -0.039996854960918427, -0.026477618142962456, -0.054854996502399445, 0.01597920060157776, 0.003120782785117626, 0.015418333932757378, 0.015592612326145172, -0.011019004508852959, 0.031237710267305374, 0.04958542063832283, -0.0700514018535614, 0.0005314715090207756, -0.0026795449666678905, -0.004438475705683231, 0.043912116438150406, -0.01806364208459854, -0.03306581825017929, -0.013508890755474567, -0.019131816923618317, -0.023700745776295662, 0.014618612825870514, 0.03210780769586563, -0.01803646981716156, 0.02689806930720806, -0.0448889434337616, 0.03766092658042908, 0.012972776778042316, 0.035542067140340805, -0.017718438059091568, 0.0006304781418293715, -0.08071764558553696, -0.025541646406054497, 0.012996042147278786, 0.022894781082868576, 0.009419632144272327, 0.038984816521406174, 0.009457982145249844, -0.01825682632625103, -0.025208301842212677, 0.04399074241518974, 0.025878317654132843, 0.024578500539064407, 0.05623878911137581, 0.008486603386700153, 0.000009357890121464152, -0.05886302515864372, -0.012130683287978172, 0.0017614415846765041, 0.04824152961373329, 0.019900890067219734, 0.005494656506925821, -0.024384574964642525, -0.04563162848353386, -0.029448602348566055, 0.013002771884202957, -0.01274073962122202, -0.008760635741055012, 0.011006071232259274, -0.010676112025976181, 0.017934784293174744, 0.022478768602013588, 0.03802269697189331, 0.0036476890090852976, -0.012796430848538876, 0.037770241498947144, -0.027000505477190018, 0.016119597479701042, 0.03464014455676079, -0.0036420125979930162, -0.012601303867995739, -0.032998550683259964, -0.02798335812985897, 0.07233979552984238, -0.02546512708067894, -0.010029977187514305, 0.032305408269166946, -0.012035503052175045, 0.004855664446949959, 0.02704937383532524, 0.002992458175867796, -0.003504555905237794, -0.04071709141135216, 0.014201728627085686, 0.016752704977989197, 0.010889098979532719, 0.017945919185876846, -0.08227085322141647, 0.046852272003889084, 0.016265634447336197, -0.02375894971191883, -0.01777864433825016, -0.03606077656149864, -0.02651454135775566, -0.02639162726700306, -0.002090500434860587, 0.015323055908083916, 0.049745041877031326, -0.0268817450851202, -0.028889836743474007, 0.05303066596388817, -0.003235690062865615, -0.06369700282812119, -0.028484100475907326, 0.018858639523386955, -0.002316158963367343, 0.018514851108193398, -0.007376343943178654, 0.04546056687831879, 0.07239479571580887, 0.0864388644695282, -0.06318343430757523, -0.045472390949726105, -0.047084737569093704, 0.012078053317964077, -0.007914076559245586, -0.0062317089177668095, 0.02697029523551464, 0.007534630596637726, -0.02404015138745308, 0.01477795373648405, -0.06109238043427467, -0.053059205412864685, -0.00348958233371377, -0.02978823147714138, -0.020434074103832245, -0.013359365053474903, 0.005791518371552229, -0.03172794729471207, 0.001742368214763701, 0.023022213950753212, -0.016929956153035164, -0.02077026478946209, -0.059244368225336075, -0.020612725988030434, 0.00032749888487160206, -0.02711227722465992, 0.009370180778205395, -0.03673255071043968, -0.08762340247631073, 0.01398450043052435, -0.013077625073492527, -0.04392024129629135, 0.03886299952864647, 0.027917198836803436, 0.04443517327308655, 0.04144183546304703, -0.011402325704693794, 0.025224804878234863, 0.011235903948545456, 0.07479137182235718, -0.024730274453759193, -0.058467354625463486, 0.03206927701830864, -0.0026861107908189297, 0.048058271408081055, -0.0031611716840416193, 0.01220739632844925, -0.014624448493123055, -0.02788344956934452, -0.03509436175227165, -0.0021537693683058023, -0.019815940409898758, -0.02048027515411377, -0.03899187222123146, -0.006192104425281286, -0.057201117277145386, 0.04398857429623604, 0.05005773901939392, -0.04975688457489014, 0.01861836016178131, 0.02913345955312252, -0.011536559090018272, -0.00749804126098752, -0.0005981244030408561, 0.033481501042842865, -0.04293669015169144, -0.022237971425056458, -0.009172369726002216, 0.009884705767035484, -0.016243528574705124, 0.036340225487947464, 0.03963970020413399, -0.04531220346689224, 0.015026637353003025, 0.0668550506234169, -0.040540438145399094, -0.02119196020066738, 0.03408833593130112, 0.05384182557463646, 0.017377305775880814, 0.0038032932206988335, 0.026979411020874977, -0.05765809863805771, -0.02144211158156395, -0.012809094041585922, 0.02196226827800274, 0.0012527755461633205, -0.00930392649024725, 0.006158805452287197, 0.03430432453751564, 0.07600045204162598, 0.004107209388166666, 0.0225351732224226, 0.047479383647441864, -0.021545615047216415, -0.013196445070207119, 0.013201850466430187, 0.023612193763256073, 0.0076200286857783794, -0.06721540540456772, -0.015310386195778847, -0.01871846243739128, -0.03253762051463127, 0.012024992145597935, 0.013649530708789825, -0.1420065462589264, -0.040627412497997284, -0.04521135985851288, -0.047655705362558365, -0.04689789190888405, 0.0021116507705301046, -0.03468085080385208, 0.005868931300938129, 0.04038010165095329, 0.03430695831775665, 0.041234228760004044, -0.014302879571914673, 0.026716746389865875, -0.024466389790177345, 0.11851883679628372, 0.0034445140045136213, 0.04297230765223503, 0.022479338571429253, -0.06368982046842575, 0.0008616555714979768, 0.048190969973802567, -0.030299197882413864, 0.011800101958215237, 0.014859750866889954, 0.046377912163734436, -0.015858402475714684, -0.015020717866718769, -0.01116058137267828, 0.03249272704124451, 0.01785176247358322, 0.007970201782882214, -0.010206944309175014, -0.03629102557897568, 0.046041302382946014, 0.0173780657351017, -0.0034044282510876656, -0.0031442337203770876, -0.00834440067410469, -0.07706049829721451, -0.04617036506533623, 0.041239891201257706, 0.0322321280837059, -0.031040769070386887, 0.03595593199133873, 0.004943113308399916, -0.04609299078583717, 0.0020179091952741146, -0.03480633720755577, 0.05255559831857681, -0.045228078961372375, -0.06323996186256409, 0.05586165934801102, 0.03632315248250961, 0.005574224982410669, 0.03415293991565704, -0.06174315884709358, 0.027844907715916634, -0.05681085214018822, -0.02643534541130066, 0.02701578103005886, 0.010217465460300446, -0.020129570737481117, 0.0347801148891449, -0.03280524164438248, -0.021135341376066208, -0.01346189621835947, -0.01225089281797409, 0.061597444117069244, 0.033496253192424774, 0.03355831280350685, -0.03762039914727211, -0.002178339520469308, -0.0018716715276241302, 0.019156770780682564, 0.017623500898480415, -0.03734368830919266, -0.02800479158759117, 0.03382054716348648, 0.02261980250477791, 0.013059661723673344, 0.1079716607928276, 0.06097622588276863, 0.08550502359867096, -0.024406973272562027, -0.014558733440935612, -0.009258587844669819, -0.044425636529922485, -0.0012770273024216294, 0.04674581065773964, -0.05885685980319977, -0.01394062489271164, 0.03567075356841087, 0.014443223364651203, -0.04478474333882332, 0.0039301118813455105, 0.009391024708747864, -0.002568522235378623, -0.023997753858566284, 0.025759361684322357, -0.03864533454179764, 0.040705129504203796, 0.03525643050670624, 0.012561636045575142, -0.00590974697843194, -0.02062184177339077, 0.0017280953470617533, 0.0018035134999081492, -0.0397380106151104, -0.07609187811613083, 0.042282599955797195, -0.0001250063069164753, 0.03309341147542, -0.04694982245564461, 0.0018344965064898133, 0.036133501678705215, -0.09263142943382263, 0.034083664417266846, -0.00009332373883808032, 0.028924057260155678, -0.01191591564565897, 0.03831847757101059, -0.05905858427286148, 0.024154160171747208, 0.034162044525146484, -0.0406850166618824, -0.0010833824053406715, 0.04011860489845276, -0.02905994839966297, 0.02633294276893139, -0.03616984933614731, -0.07538590580224991, -0.01999347284436226, 0.023037215694785118, -0.04880918189883232, -0.06974723190069199, -0.023984156548976898, -0.08699513971805573, -0.013277590274810791, -0.06332026422023773, -0.05869678035378456, -0.012333412654697895, -0.015842938795685768, 0.014481334015727043, -0.013217969797551632, 0.01995396800339222, 0.012479348108172417, -0.017472553998231888, 0.02355150692164898, -0.01999630406498909, 0.0477629229426384, -0.02583606354892254, -0.0451309010386467, -0.012592281214892864, 0.0752839595079422, -0.11455200612545013, 0.04927200824022293, 0.03809447959065437, 0.015289241448044777, 0.07012370973825455, -0.0015536091523244977, 0.03767756000161171, 0.00400671036913991, -0.010220354422926903, 0.023065928369760513, 0.00872162077575922, -0.060740504413843155, -0.011407852172851562, -0.05019387975335121, 0.00933013390749693, -0.0354762077331543, -0.04524260014295578, 0.013233854435384274, -0.04573215916752815, -0.025498349219560623, 0.06155842915177345, -0.026299240067601204, 0.033934786915779114, 0.0839768648147583, 0.044732604175806046, 0.010899556800723076, -0.05124285817146301, -0.02909902110695839, 0.06385783106088638, -0.01212623342871666, 0.07099486142396927, -0.055375900119543076, -0.012888510711491108, -0.02326197922229767, 0.04065423458814621, -0.01453968696296215, -0.07043591141700745, 0.03318342566490173, -0.07813108712434769, -0.041482117027044296, 0.0672077089548111, 0.020536279305815697, 0.05945573374629021, -0.0018786241998896003, 0.012782841920852661, -0.029051506891846657, 0.009953147731721401, 0.06270212680101395, 0.006185169331729412, 0.008308841846883297, -0.012705888599157333, -0.042209845036268234, 0.027875442057847977, -0.06369028985500336, -0.024573007598519325, 0.00012431763752829283, -0.0038264140021055937, 0.031162379309535027, 0.002312034135684371, -0.01949452981352806, 0.09308090060949326, -0.0147537337616086, -0.012829948216676712, 0.01820775493979454, 0.030583659186959267, -0.03166293352842331, 0.056565556675195694, -0.041105274111032486, 0.008270283229649067, -0.05576730892062187, -0.03768981993198395, -0.04290714114904404, 0.05722681060433388, 0.05142301321029663, -0.009698850102722645, 0.016122890636324883, 0.016298823058605194, -0.010205652564764023, 0.0437447652220726, -0.029729390516877174, -0.005285885650664568, 0.03716568648815155, -0.034981463104486465, -0.00392930256202817, -0.014050296507775784, -0.022765491157770157, -0.007484332658350468, -0.06949035078287125, -0.04162226617336273, 0.00938495434820652, 0.0735277384519577, -0.07456263154745102, 0.02396218292415142, -0.002012534998357296, -0.00639402074739337, 0.049049679189920425, -0.018733201548457146, 0.016251401975750923, 0.05642259865999222, 0.031042611226439476, 0.07320839911699295, 0.03911749646067619, -0.05926459655165672, -0.012352190911769867, -0.012278018519282341, -0.008929447270929813, -0.027183562517166138, -0.024876609444618225, -0.023717178031802177, -0.03400610014796257, 0.014261399395763874, 0.03690967708826065, -0.020517515018582344, 0.026154858991503716, 0.014172318391501904, -0.00861013401299715, -0.010008147917687893, -0.021099507808685303, -0.03654583543539047, 0.00813776720315218, 0.07471663504838943, -0.042730171233415604, 0.05112213268876076, 0.015820959582924843, -0.023068256676197052, -0.0531265027821064, 0.010223486460745335, -0.002835928462445736, 0.03431306406855583, -0.0022415330167859793, -0.023066984489560127, 0.046172767877578735, 0.032180316746234894, 0.017984483391046524, -0.08006880432367325, -0.010991438291966915, 0.026187725365161896, -0.012548591941595078, 0.04793258011341095, -0.022255340591073036, 0.03301085904240608, 0.01054319180548191, -0.06175362318754196, 0.00030796215287409723, 0.019896375015378, -0.03044310212135315, 0.019947776570916176, 0.025300735607743263, -0.04707135632634163, 0.021724827587604523, -0.024686407297849655, -0.016392936930060387, -0.0011300782207399607, 0.01390824280679226, -0.0385214239358902, 0.00007913702575024217, 0.011119326576590538, -0.04895595461130142, -0.027806010097265244, -0.004441105294972658, 0.025819456204771996, 0.06754063814878464, -0.03575826436281204, 0.039972346276044846, -0.0252949558198452, -0.019965974614024162, -0.03829921782016754, -0.0006160814664326608, 0.02162312902510166, -0.0328148752450943, 0.004728307016193867, -0.0021900353021919727, -0.013829371891915798, 0.0010015923762694001, 0.03425073251128197, -0.043390754610300064, -0.0193471759557724, 0.006348470691591501, 0.024582603946328163, 0.025273317471146584, -0.02005033940076828, 0.021792232990264893, -0.025032659992575645, 0.057230256497859955, -0.011480513028800488, 0.0035812114365398884, -0.05627692490816116, -0.014757342636585236, -0.029912574216723442, 0.001478079124353826, -0.025165429338812828, -0.016287904232740402, -0.009497856721282005, 0.004902041517198086, 0.03788866102695465, -0.021609604358673096, 0.02999686449766159, -0.015911400318145752, 0.03024350479245186, 0.03522047773003578, -0.035008132457733154, 0.06651414930820465, 0.044064514338970184 ]
<p>In <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metric_expansion_of_space#Understanding_the_expansion_of_Universe" rel="nofollow">this wikipedia article</a> it is described how a beam of light, with its locally constant speed, can travel "faster than light". That is to say it travels a distance, which, from a special relativistic point of view, is surprisingly big. </p> <p>I wonder if a gravitational wave on such a curved spacetime (of which the wave is actually part of) behaves equally. </p> <blockquote> <p>Does a gravitational wave also ride on expanding spacetime, just as light does? Do the nonlinearities of gravitation-gravitation interaction influence the propagation of a wave (like e.g. a plasma) such that light and gravity are effectively not equally fast?</p> <p>If I want to send a fast signal in this expanding universe scenario, in what fashion do I decide to I send it?</p> </blockquote>
g6597
[ 0.027797801420092583, 0.10333189368247986, 0.01805698685348034, 0.03287738934159279, 0.006374250166118145, -0.008999456651508808, -0.033392876386642456, -0.034305013716220856, -0.03587166965007782, -0.02201020158827305, 0.0527842678129673, 0.009071364998817444, 0.03693956881761551, 0.03609883785247803, -0.016454823315143585, -0.03092706948518753, 0.038445331156253815, -0.048014186322689056, 0.05819973722100258, 0.023961473256349564, -0.009265054948627949, 0.014649192802608013, 0.02001280151307583, -0.023106055334210396, -0.013204613700509071, 0.015073657967150211, 0.04022395610809326, -0.06324218958616257, -0.014598319306969643, -0.044144827872514725, -0.00819022860378027, -0.012113369069993496, 0.00002037606100202538, -0.0436830148100853, -0.041271716356277466, 0.0440681092441082, -0.02716347575187683, -0.038434069603681564, 0.03680368512868881, 0.0011854944750666618, -0.032004464417696, -0.0005566768231801689, -0.026808135211467743, 0.027859900146722794, 0.08666373789310455, -0.04390449821949005, -0.015491497702896595, 0.027291228994727135, 0.04800068959593773, -0.025439292192459106, -0.04244360700249672, 0.0175214521586895, 0.0002811709709931165, 0.023311229422688484, 0.05375342816114426, 0.04463154822587967, -0.0460418239235878, -0.0014868290163576603, 0.07596494257450104, 0.02233307622373104, -0.038616765290498734, -0.014497434720396996, 0.09503043442964554, -0.0331292599439621, 0.009918522089719772, 0.021870432421565056, -0.002920372411608696, -0.06801608949899673, -0.0045244270004332066, -0.04254041239619255, 0.058686550706624985, -0.06663313508033752, -0.03698097914457321, -0.09528840333223343, -0.015779558569192886, 0.04469390586018562, 0.02620481327176094, 0.015179039910435677, -0.028685053810477257, 0.01238612923771143, -0.019816594198346138, -0.02392887882888317, -0.015919335186481476, 0.008473383262753487, -0.03934160992503166, -0.024158699437975883, 0.015102391131222248, -0.0169962290674448, -0.0009540377650409937, -0.008419690653681755, 0.016046902164816856, -0.02619241178035736, 0.04089973121881485, 0.04965381696820259, -0.053898490965366364, 0.0019238500390201807, -0.05600457265973091, 0.06294278800487518, -0.004923139698803425, 0.016976231709122658, -0.05431850254535675, -0.007000850047916174, 0.010091437958180904, 0.013716825284063816, 0.020742356777191162, -0.04079211875796318, -0.015975724905729294, -0.022439882159233093, 0.00617231335490942, -0.01804623194038868, -0.010977707803249359, -0.07757594436407089, 0.03006451390683651, -0.07261344790458679, -0.09362628310918808, -0.0313897542655468, 0.012831883504986763, 0.054202038794755936, 0.0032657801639288664, 0.012985432520508766, -0.013870478607714176, 0.06281042098999023, -0.038199249655008316, 0.018401311710476875, 0.009173610247671604, -0.0041022347286343575, -0.028907515108585358, -0.004934650845825672, 0.0051608337089419365, -0.005516733508557081, -0.020725851878523827, 0.028465518727898598, -0.03353920951485634, 0.03803505748510361, -0.021191978827118874, -0.0038496104534715414, 0.02062200754880905, -0.022132061421871185, -0.04183734208345413, 0.019878292456269264, -0.03621054068207741, -0.06867709010839462, 0.023743342608213425, -0.029505625367164612, -0.042822953313589096, 0.017397498711943626, 0.025344030931591988, 0.0013489387929439545, 0.05073395371437073, -0.03413613513112068, 0.003954035695642233, 0.10477470606565475, -0.024976953864097595, -0.0471513494849205, -0.012773988768458366, 0.03503361716866493, 0.03161092847585678, -0.01123366691172123, -0.027632372453808784, 0.02599162608385086, 0.04905160516500473, -0.020600611343979836, -0.012370549142360687, -0.0034956675954163074, 0.008503152057528496, 0.07312782853841782, 0.0359257310628891, -0.07371008396148682, 0.013083253987133503, -0.019215503707528114, -0.059123698621988297, -0.015612782910466194, 0.0308387354016304, 0.049218785017728806, 0.04762599989771843, 0.016543567180633545, 0.00991911068558693, -0.028399141505360603, -0.07784318923950195, -0.014357849955558777, -0.08062741160392761, -0.08007622510194778, -0.04357752576470375, -0.05100414529442787, -0.019103022292256355, -0.026533056050539017, -0.021055134013295174, -0.03834157437086105, -0.03682355582714081, -0.04096067696809769, -0.018267948180437088, -0.05455193296074867, 0.00483736302703619, 0.05552582070231438, -0.009895521216094494, -0.002689491491764784, 0.021054066717624664, 0.01722402684390545, -0.016146225854754448, 0.015975352376699448, -0.014005467295646667, 0.09187491983175278, 0.04641835018992424, -0.017198221758008003, 0.0528937503695488, 0.029304251074790955, -0.01543093379586935, 0.011264080181717873, 0.034390680491924286, 0.005401838105171919, 0.08427950739860535, -0.03617280349135399, 0.04437343031167984, 0.0469643659889698, 0.0019228713354095817, 0.028364913538098335, -0.02790079638361931, 0.03989311307668686, 0.0012396764941513538, 0.029967786744236946, 0.004444046877324581, 0.0923687070608139, 0.003337679896503687, -0.041377030313014984, -0.005104015115648508, -0.06842759251594543, -0.01582258567214012, -0.02259507030248642, 0.025451403111219406, 0.027371343225240707, -0.007270173169672489, -0.004418381489813328, 0.010547243990004063, -0.027921807020902634, 0.06798477470874786, -0.012356912717223167, -0.036259036511182785, 0.023249482735991478, -0.034911613911390305, -0.017163477838039398, 0.015690457075834274, -0.002237387001514435, 0.002243436174467206, 0.01625998690724373, -0.007739336229860783, -0.08968903869390488, 0.008687993511557579, -0.07942777127027512, -0.05088482424616814, 0.008518397808074951, 0.05265885591506958, -0.01669256202876568, -0.011031183414161205, 0.030798694118857384, -0.002486229408532381, -0.02184954471886158, -0.01642109639942646, 0.0550856776535511, -0.12486658245325089, -0.008681071922183037, 0.008099425584077835, 0.028635140508413315, 0.01695905812084675, -0.018647046759724617, -0.01751430332660675, -0.010634158737957478, 0.019952934235334396, 0.03743236884474754, -0.04577478766441345, 0.030813558027148247, -0.024438567459583282, 0.01485175546258688, -0.022677907720208168, -0.009323269128799438, 0.004912571515887976, -0.0007544675027020276, 0.0073337978683412075, -0.03473857417702675, -0.0034427877981215715, -0.038459502160549164, -0.007284978404641151, -0.05706304311752319, -0.07997411489486694, 0.0017892109462991357, 0.008319482207298279, -0.09092516452074051, 0.02330363541841507, 0.04671734943985939, -0.008491535671055317, -0.0020080944523215294, -0.007040390279144049, 0.0537201426923275, -0.02119271457195282, 0.05383676663041115, -0.03352556750178337, 0.059135209769010544, -0.008378881961107254, 0.01269253809005022, 0.005616911221295595, 0.012110101990401745, -0.03113158605992794, -0.10040027648210526, 0.0380028635263443, -0.02052205801010132, -0.04311993718147278, 0.012143822386860847, -0.07080049067735672, -0.007862738333642483, -0.017678631469607353, 0.03199751302599907, 0.03190555050969124, 0.0291401669383049, 0.012617697939276695, 0.028788920491933823, -0.010425538755953312, -0.033460672944784164, -0.015381818637251854, -0.01811860129237175, 0.0021405909210443497, 0.021702757105231285, 0.04511570557951927, -0.010954250581562519, -0.06072976812720299, 0.015778454020619392, 0.002789662452414632, 0.006940390449017286, 0.020284732803702354, 0.02564588002860546, -0.033969130367040634, 0.02993559092283249, 0.012125765904784203, -0.0011656449642032385, -0.006909415125846863, 0.01262236014008522, -0.00198871036991477, -0.03260676935315132, 0.017465826123952866, 0.04198889061808586, 0.07210612297058105, 0.055226024240255356, -0.024604149162769318, 0.021940642967820168, -0.05114568769931793, 0.038371432572603226, -0.003898952854797244, 0.02930450439453125, 0.03941144049167633, 0.007303161546587944, -0.043695081025362015, -0.038394179195165634, 0.01588761992752552, -0.004155478440225124, -0.0008557578548789024, -0.025633040815591812, 0.0005178181454539299, -0.015486817806959152, -0.0058836303651332855, -0.009810342453420162, -0.021267037838697433, -0.053532712161540985, 0.003405991941690445, -0.014726808294653893, -0.003317621536552906, 0.02585608884692192, -0.017519265413284302, 0.00278283073566854, 0.02964758314192295, -0.028289807960391045, -0.0422891266644001, -0.0015741686802357435, 0.0821816697716713, -0.06440717726945877, 0.013099762611091137, 0.056368544697761536, 0.021271370351314545, -0.030675986781716347, 0.027113452553749084, -0.038158826529979706, 0.010629654861986637, 0.009869914501905441, 0.05422098562121391, 0.07945168018341064, 0.05013583227992058, -0.010564037598669529, 0.014300736598670483, 0.029578523710370064, -0.03501035273075104, -0.029561586678028107, 0.05153066664934158, -0.0398610457777977, 0.03738237917423248, -0.05799847096204758, 0.010770807042717934, 0.008954523131251335, -0.010514560155570507, -0.017112746834754944, -0.0068727112375199795, -0.00485059292986989, -0.004629067610949278, 0.039198264479637146, -0.004804486408829689, 0.06162261962890625, -0.0041756159625947475, -0.01887207105755806, -0.0588722750544548, -0.0361984483897686, 0.03486546874046326, -0.015424244105815887, -0.0075316959992051125, 0.02755354344844818, -0.024853892624378204, 0.037066500633955, -0.032567333430051804, -0.09436638653278351, 0.04299959912896156, 0.04015670716762543, 0.05238370597362518, -0.06530115008354187, -0.006797654088586569, 0.02383020706474781, 0.0002829880395438522, 0.009110722690820694, 0.038984380662441254, 0.004662693478167057, -0.023480970412492752, 0.050431329756975174, 0.03308482840657234, -0.06367585062980652, -0.012536708265542984, 0.008246933110058308, -0.0030623862985521555, 0.02204480767250061, 0.0017018106300383806, 0.04629185050725937, 0.003961092326790094, 0.052164167165756226, 0.0016621866961941123, 0.05356808006763458, 0.0408293642103672, 0.013065037317574024, 0.049522675573825836, 0.0048609646037220955, -0.016141967847943306, -0.008663836866617203, 0.019932864233851433, 0.0484168715775013, -0.05471973121166229, -0.025100257247686386, 0.006614204030483961, -0.018087290227413177, -0.05937835946679115, 0.006708793342113495, 0.04757272079586983, -0.03351907804608345, 0.009585544466972351, 0.04812752082943916, -0.011532590724527836, -0.028870606794953346, 0.07715281844139099, -0.01033970806747675, -0.036347512155771255, 0.04542553797364235, 0.02448095753788948, 0.0005152879748493433, -0.013653750531375408, 0.011786098591983318, -0.03006589226424694, -0.04543168097734451, -0.06860329210758209, -0.004319676663726568, -0.01984953135251999, -0.03070957399904728, 0.02310793660581112, 0.03307441249489784, 0.0029418650083243847, 0.024744566529989243, -0.012008988298475742, 0.015884872525930405, -0.02299235202372074, -0.03457644581794739, -0.04050774127244949, -0.057534925639629364, 0.07231137156486511, -0.006796649657189846, -0.013223698362708092, 0.008010690100491047, 0.01896131969988346, 0.08158282935619354, 0.0030314745381474495, -0.037905387580394745, 0.04407469928264618, -0.021368995308876038, -0.053181253373622894, 0.02512452006340027, 0.006630904972553253, 0.00008243598858825862, 0.006716051604598761, -0.039757076650857925, 0.00993166584521532, -0.02603743225336075, -0.015367936342954636, 0.03860330209136009, -0.0012906776973977685, -0.018509522080421448, -0.0314740426838398, 0.0978192389011383, -0.009403797797858715, 0.03326483815908432, -0.0967235192656517, 0.0733792781829834, -0.015018019825220108, 0.0032740915194153786, -0.03161870315670967, 0.008394830860197544, 0.060118041932582855, -0.09051543474197388, -0.017621507868170738, 0.022787485271692276, -0.03391961380839348, -0.02134682983160019, -0.019858989864587784, -0.022768300026655197, -0.008580069988965988, -0.03594440966844559, 0.041529469192028046, 0.031017648056149483, -0.007606829516589642, -0.004781357944011688, 0.021335970610380173, -0.016090281307697296, 0.07721199095249176, 0.012072775512933731, 0.024498166516423225, -0.005763125605881214, 0.006739715114235878, -0.022553684189915657, 0.04572310298681259, 0.014276132918894291, 0.011156724765896797, -0.007582645397633314, -0.03121534362435341, -0.012384513393044472, -0.012026306241750717, 0.09505227208137512, -0.0034997800830751657, 0.05715091526508331, -0.027919841930270195, 0.010220786556601524, 0.0627906322479248, -0.026255574077367783, -0.04520256072282791, -0.025646300986409187, 0.011768101714551449, 0.035002291202545166, 0.0183822363615036, 0.03831752762198448, 0.03069896623492241, 0.009599442593753338, -0.030326563864946365, -0.05475220829248428, 0.021938461810350418, 0.04267878830432892, 0.016464918851852417, -0.08347187936306, -0.008126568049192429, -0.040645770728588104, -0.011924432590603828, -0.09767598658800125, 0.08577997237443924, -0.0033590798266232014, -0.05744335427880287, 0.002031291602179408, -0.029721103608608246, -0.015423126518726349, 0.017811452969908714, -0.05498170852661133, 0.04054337739944458, -0.022454379126429558, -0.03798901289701462, -0.011224191635847092, -0.052411776036024094, -0.0025070367846637964, 0.05790957063436508, 0.027414700016379356, -0.009756777435541153, 0.01719929464161396, -0.013264941982924938, 0.03182269260287285, 0.034165315330028534, -0.044020798057317734, -0.011117675341665745, -0.04473740607500076, -0.01811547391116619, -0.022515028715133667, -0.017924509942531586, -0.03595384955406189, -0.033104173839092255, 0.02867322973906994, -0.04463114216923714, 0.02723005600273609, -0.018970854580402374, 0.033427100628614426, 0.07271590083837509, 0.03515000641345978, 0.008633256889879704, -0.00579168600961566, -0.05117481201887131, 0.016512418165802956, 0.04495804384350777, -0.008351866155862808, 0.043098561465740204, 0.030265918001532555, 0.018346965312957764, -0.010401029139757156, 0.01780533418059349, -0.05768322944641113, -0.013621341437101364, -0.04073013365268707, 0.038196008652448654, 0.05173211917281151, 0.04332466796040535, -0.013040833175182343, 0.031164728105068207, -0.0001744323380989954, -0.028997745364904404, -0.013371523469686508, -0.016061192378401756, -0.011577056720852852, 0.013274355791509151, -0.02245982177555561, 0.017879320308566093, 0.028341136872768402, -0.03743261471390724, 0.04871150478720665, 0.05154948681592941, 0.013380059972405434, -0.020280756056308746, 0.03370724618434906, -0.004281041212379932, -0.0043683648109436035, 0.028344979509711266, 0.04169999435544014, 0.005613698158413172, 0.034000322222709656, -0.0401221327483654, 0.011178302578628063, 0.020009730011224747, -0.04598888009786606, 0.05255328491330147, 0.024393975734710693, -0.006296004634350538, -0.01666189916431904, -0.02772633731365204, -0.012649445794522762, -0.03809738531708717, 0.005012190900743008, -0.03506409749388695, 0.047879915684461594, -0.011982260271906853, -0.013215779326856136, -0.004660752601921558, -0.05371925234794617, -0.0012222656514495611, 0.03255277872085571, 0.009420851245522499, 0.04936915636062622, -0.013999185524880886, 0.013890947215259075, -0.00022092853032518178, 0.03118227608501911, 0.01590038277208805, 0.014982511289417744, 0.043803051114082336, 0.03253595158457756, 0.0561697892844677, -0.021764148026704788, -0.11166650801897049, -0.01515901181846857, 0.015207006596028805, 0.005837500095367432, 0.015451708808541298, 0.038121242076158524, 0.017501424998044968, 0.08711181581020355, -0.009114633314311504, 0.0036218222230672836, -0.03739264979958534, 0.025672998279333115, -0.005960215348750353, -0.04777652770280838, -0.012139854952692986, 0.01409770455211401, -0.018455203622579575, 0.0061696371994912624, 0.04503203555941582, 0.009864703752100468, -0.034263066947460175, 0.042040981352329254, -0.007622923702001572, -0.014650185592472553, -0.09348487108945847, 0.02496144361793995, -0.03662260249257088, -0.005138084292411804, 0.05591660365462303, 0.0034369744826108217, -0.015451472252607346, -0.05567624792456627, 0.0037316938396543264, -0.011305581778287888, 0.027166247367858887, 0.04028145223855972, -0.06933977454900742, -0.0035465494729578495, -0.015423959121108055, 0.009725620970129967, 0.047337114810943604, 0.0007197191007435322, 0.030122404918074608, -0.015905585139989853, -0.03982958197593689, 0.016852883622050285, 0.007678220979869366, -0.04858199879527092, 0.030176633968949318, 0.003840517718344927, -0.012636370956897736, -0.018434325233101845, -0.037188995629549026, -0.021841855719685555, 0.018716394901275635, -0.03905893862247467, -0.049756087362766266, -0.011687664315104485, -0.06378571689128876, 0.05750918388366699, -0.038904819637537, -0.0067438893020153046, 0.022546270862221718, 0.05099720135331154, 0.003135510254651308, -0.04008426144719124, -0.00924169085919857, 0.037355031818151474, 0.005145061295479536, 0.042743537575006485, -0.0001829099201131612, -0.032312024384737015, 0.06237882375717163, -0.026634488254785538, 0.018529657274484634, 0.06360960006713867, 0.004806123208254576, 0.03741583973169327, 0.029197312891483307, -0.01835523545742035, -0.03268832340836525, -0.021400211378932, 0.023639362305402756, -0.034001484513282776, 0.04979948699474335, -0.008983452804386616, 0.011907447129487991, -0.039504118263721466, -0.0017447833670303226, 0.0026791056152433157, 0.0002467650338076055, 0.021724460646510124 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/759/does-quantum-physics-really-suggests-this-universe-as-a-computer-simulation">Does Quantum Physics really suggests this universe as a computer simulation?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>I know the title sounds far-fetched, but the idea was first brought to my attention by a comment by Prof. Jim Gates of the University of Maryland during the <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYeN66CSQhg" rel="nofollow">2011 Issac Asimov Memorial Debate</a>.</p> <p>Google lead me to <a href="http://www.bottomlayer.com/bottom/argument/Argument4.html" rel="nofollow">this essay</a> which seems to argue that the universe/reality shares many analogues to how a modern Turing machine (a computer) does what we perceive it to do. It doesn't come out and state that <em>The Matrix</em> ought to be reclassified as a documentary, but it leaves that possibility open.</p> <p>Not being a physicist, I'm wondering just how much water these ideas might hold. Is this an avenue that we really ought to explore or are these scientists abusing an (apparently uncanny) analogy?</p>
g227
[ -0.013364648446440697, 0.06615246087312698, 0.01315534021705389, -0.011626778170466423, 0.03655771166086197, -0.004406256601214409, -0.00708294752985239, 0.02186841331422329, 0.04621616378426552, 0.01304337102919817, 0.05528358370065689, 0.02304122969508171, 0.0323367603123188, 0.057629913091659546, -0.0343773290514946, -0.0026459081564098597, -0.014687267132103443, -0.017946939915418625, 0.05225294828414917, 0.00653004739433527, 0.022438183426856995, 0.009927473030984402, 0.012086594477295876, -0.025084590539336205, -0.08653254061937332, -0.042834311723709106, 0.002375394105911255, -0.08107814937829971, -0.005296212621033192, 0.020031394436955452, 0.027959981933236122, -0.005874857306480408, 0.040885988622903824, -0.05276964232325554, -0.03307808190584183, -0.022480763494968414, 0.003536550560966134, 0.012543200515210629, 0.03856895491480827, -0.013833323493599892, -0.031299736350774765, -0.0031218561343848705, -0.0791596993803978, 0.00230682035908103, 0.011030249297618866, 0.03284948691725731, 0.012740431353449821, 0.0018689678981900215, 0.09465014189481735, -0.04412129521369934, -0.0020557416137307882, -0.02124686725437641, 0.050257910043001175, 0.060402799397706985, 0.08277150988578796, 0.010751181282103062, -0.009972226805984974, 0.04700562357902527, 0.09727934747934341, -0.009668882004916668, 0.04215140640735626, 0.028265515342354774, 0.04924299567937851, 0.023252271115779877, 0.005339786410331726, 0.05870361998677254, -0.01266565453261137, 0.06028556451201439, -0.033468883484601974, -0.013941901735961437, 0.01626773551106453, -0.035596542060375214, -0.03616248071193695, 0.050141166895627975, 0.048437025398015976, 0.02558954618871212, -0.021387245506048203, -0.035598162561655045, 0.035159870982170105, 0.030913058668375015, 0.004101254511624575, -0.022088168188929558, -0.02158837392926216, 0.004975663963705301, 0.0054623279720544815, -0.0170412827283144, -0.056690458208322525, 0.0035832219291478395, 0.040310341864824295, 0.06827368587255478, -0.005530419759452343, -0.010311626829206944, 0.07239913940429688, 0.0196077823638916, -0.01747039705514908, -0.03388497605919838, -0.019766483455896378, 0.02890639193356037, -0.022943969815969467, 0.043793756514787674, -0.06010999158024788, 0.017908284440636635, 0.06299489736557007, -0.04740414768457413, -0.004976749885827303, 0.044730305671691895, 0.002020113402977586, -0.018652448430657387, -0.0387692004442215, 0.016535121947526932, 0.007331817876547575, -0.006473388057202101, -0.08025894314050674, -0.03221125155687332, -0.057990074157714844, -0.0016072830185294151, 0.0628262534737587, -0.055871762335300446, -0.016217147931456566, 0.028888670727610588, -0.015018457546830177, 0.022889379411935806, -0.005119533743709326, 0.029661361128091812, 0.004806250799447298, 0.019925836473703384, 0.029114142060279846, -0.011636183597147465, -0.0004612540069501847, -0.0235595665872097, -0.01858401857316494, -0.01934412680566311, -0.010711483657360077, 0.04237385094165802, 0.025097964331507683, 0.014218753203749657, -0.039810240268707275, -0.04482783377170563, -0.02809825912117958, 0.030716603621840477, -0.015563985332846642, -0.027905141934752464, -0.03656385466456413, -0.0006270226440392435, -0.015404517762362957, 0.03606615960597992, -0.05883878096938133, 0.05816483497619629, 0.002062377519905567, -0.002691072877496481, 0.05101973935961723, 0.0693235918879509, -0.025143805891275406, -0.07480241358280182, 0.001835322706028819, 0.025387367233633995, 0.03052138164639473, -0.029083846136927605, -0.00040243015973828733, 0.011346246115863323, 0.06340853869915009, -0.02351485751569271, 0.013579362072050571, 0.0006866423063911498, -0.030945319682359695, 0.006551351863890886, 0.04382949694991112, -0.06496501713991165, 0.0396810844540596, -0.021908579394221306, -0.02248762920498848, -0.03017042949795723, -0.03538208454847336, 0.03141436353325844, 0.0027406299486756325, -0.018166188150644302, -0.02964850515127182, -0.04765791445970535, -0.0009670690633356571, -0.007691313978284597, -0.03580313175916672, -0.000430035317549482, -0.01340087316930294, 0.011096468195319176, -0.014086778275668621, -0.0242634154856205, -0.027005964890122414, 0.07117516547441483, -0.01803642138838768, -0.017233915627002716, -0.08240598440170288, -0.03232165053486824, -0.002408063504844904, 0.003928912803530693, 0.016487902030348778, -0.022523008286952972, 0.008197374641895294, 0.017279813066124916, 0.013239433988928795, -0.03983449935913086, 0.03727603331208229, 0.025874214246869087, -0.021222220733761787, 0.013953004032373428, -0.007604946382343769, 0.034220535308122635, -0.009366502985358238, -0.011585536412894726, -0.04782663658261299, -0.024080753326416016, 0.10803059488534927, 0.04741225019097328, 0.03144842013716698, 0.029770836234092712, -0.013649491593241692, 0.003104293253272772, -0.006780320778489113, -0.050204500555992126, -0.036047354340553284, 0.06756686419248581, 0.017249571159482002, -0.05868569016456604, 0.038440167903900146, 0.005372491665184498, 0.020911836996674538, -0.004999547265470028, -0.07335972040891647, -0.028633669018745422, -0.029900599271059036, 0.039060212671756744, 0.02221178263425827, 0.0010188048472627997, 0.005397603381425142, -0.005423319526016712, 0.035184696316719055, 0.020511852577328682, -0.008856263011693954, 0.05625448748469353, 0.03347369655966759, -0.004204313736408949, 0.005245367530733347, -0.059585340321063995, -0.09293141961097717, 0.03856119140982628, 0.05625751242041588, -0.07037389278411865, 0.03401024639606476, -0.011321940459311008, -0.012258556671440601, -0.03157179802656174, 0.028484350070357323, -0.06521328538656235, -0.0328659750521183, -0.007443597074598074, 0.04137994721531868, 0.005273814778774977, 0.05282454192638397, 0.052057623863220215, -0.007287149783223867, -0.0006802004645578563, 0.06278800964355469, -0.053642258048057556, 0.006156791467219591, -0.003048619953915477, 0.034181732684373856, 0.03251225873827934, -0.0350191630423069, -0.028599945828318596, -0.02732120081782341, -0.004834665451198816, 0.006972192786633968, 0.012173770926892757, 0.0036415690556168556, -0.008295570500195026, 0.005889574531465769, 0.017999397590756416, -0.014599460177123547, 0.023837557062506676, 0.033522434532642365, -0.03305589780211449, -0.029067665338516235, 0.03496095538139343, -0.043814826756715775, 0.004841433838009834, 0.06074882671236992, -0.08115853369235992, -0.03930066153407097, -0.05312056094408035, -0.03180820494890213, -0.02909744344651699, 0.013658685609698296, -0.01589292846620083, -0.03302830457687378, 0.0315060093998909, -0.0671287477016449, -0.008008554577827454, -0.01628910005092621, 0.016872836276888847, -0.0038844801019877195, 0.052924744784832, 0.008925789035856724, -0.0009043398895300925, 0.01212333608418703, 0.06818868964910507, 0.006201563403010368, 0.03445974737405777, -0.06652788072824478, -0.021368546411395073, -0.028501922264695168, -0.0750717744231224, -0.006193873472511768, 0.06666363775730133, -0.02244928479194641, 0.028907060623168945, 0.01691727712750435, 0.046206917613744736, -0.023636972531676292, 0.05021645501255989, 0.001542851678095758, -0.0052162460051476955, -0.0008030654862523079, 0.005580533761531115, -0.033719465136528015, 0.014123724773526192, 0.06958873569965363, 0.07810630649328232, -0.005020315293222666, -0.03724324703216553, -0.03284195438027382, -0.06179679557681084, 0.05646725744009018, -0.08245495706796646, -0.007604967337101698, -0.0031111077405512333, -0.08957754075527191, -0.07881899178028107, -0.00016925351519603282, 0.006607895251363516, 0.03775988519191742, -0.031299617141485214, -0.004331854172050953, 0.01860630139708519, 0.02561594545841217, 0.030347442254424095, 0.04409482330083847, 0.0653594583272934, 0.008333349600434303, 0.06366557627916336, 0.017359109595417976, -0.050942469388246536, 0.020763175562024117, 0.022293565794825554, 0.032190725207328796, 0.013316445052623749, -0.002972027752548456, 0.019208760932087898, 0.025248520076274872, 0.024482108652591705, 0.0472223199903965, -0.012344718910753727, -0.05834460258483887, -0.025257442146539688, 0.007974199019372463, -0.028611108660697937, 0.009150620549917221, 0.011071162298321724, -0.03833824396133423, 0.04297969117760658, -0.011311489157378674, 0.007626171689480543, 0.0028859677258878946, -0.006544904783368111, -0.012038715183734894, -0.03120536357164383, 0.06917375326156616, -0.00695806322619319, 0.03228161111474037, -0.0027332594618201256, 0.037403758615255356, -0.014086945913732052, -0.01870797760784626, 0.03277972340583801, 0.03761720284819603, -0.028699975460767746, 0.035056233406066895, 0.0013483650982379913, -0.00967421941459179, -0.021813414990901947, -0.023409483954310417, -0.0027522859163582325, 0.018679581582546234, -0.0014829463325440884, -0.03208804503083229, -0.007577964104712009, -0.001390380202792585, 0.0015357743250206113, -0.03551905229687691, -0.05021650716662407, -0.03504379466176033, -0.00912125501781702, 0.025849344208836555, -0.026812994852662086, 0.013746754266321659, 0.06168673187494278, -0.015099688433110714, -0.0399041585624218, -0.005233199801295996, -0.04251376911997795, -0.007661084178835154, -0.04372464865446091, 0.02368081733584404, 0.02553427405655384, -0.013343782164156437, -0.04489127919077873, 0.0031325004529207945, 0.026339679956436157, -0.04212050512433052, -0.006536182016134262, 0.013276158832013607, 0.03598427399992943, 0.028624920174479485, 0.05022696033120155, 0.002314680954441428, 0.04650713875889778, -0.006868888158351183, 0.002721999306231737, -0.0021076579578220844, 0.022203927859663963, -0.014945005998015404, -0.026738351210951805, 0.03898469731211662, 0.025763709098100662, 0.025851497426629066, 0.047142453491687775, 0.04067034274339676, 0.035160426050424576, -0.0000893937103683129, 0.024465961381793022, 0.02431267686188221, 0.007831382565200329, 0.04781950265169144, -0.003942249342799187, 0.02066130004823208, -0.0017465912969782948, -0.012634317390620708, 0.028488267213106155, -0.05230057239532471, 0.060778599232435226, -0.08886778354644775, -0.03910084068775177, -0.03924128785729408, 0.054213810712099075, 0.020877275615930557, -0.019734714180231094, 0.01101360097527504, -0.024523044005036354, 0.008874297142028809, 0.0020357321482151747, -0.0240427628159523, 0.035364676266908646, -0.05877531319856644, 0.018345464020967484, 0.00008546934986952692, 0.059753067791461945, 0.008954161778092384, 0.04225733503699303, -0.10132113099098206, -0.028056368231773376, -0.03229539841413498, -0.05336382985115051, 0.02143976092338562, -0.00859026238322258, -0.006430149078369141, 0.019516512751579285, 0.03155847266316414, -0.04848578944802284, -0.05933573096990585, -0.02019716426730156, -0.008495197631418705, 0.041494857519865036, -0.03585241734981537, 0.023845793679356575, 0.06902576982975006, -0.037968311458826065, 0.03251147270202637, 0.03558309003710747, -0.062187906354665756, 0.028089549392461777, -0.05392855405807495, -0.02308354340493679, 0.026404952630400658, -0.022270018234848976, 0.0022388631477952003, -0.046870265156030655, -0.004086448345333338, 0.004305561073124409, -0.01895790547132492, -0.016631465405225754, -0.01278686337172985, 0.05339960381388664, -0.014862874522805214, 0.01329398900270462, 0.004584077745676041, -0.019604193046689034, -0.016300588846206665, 0.036858197301626205, 0.023985834792256355, 0.002167819067835808, -0.023468302562832832, 0.013888985849916935, -0.011407746002078056, 0.005156779196113348, -0.043531060218811035, -0.0015937946736812592, 0.045511603355407715, -0.007083178032189608, -0.015689415857195854, -0.03322392702102661, -0.026911474764347076, -0.07147377729415894, 0.0423397496342659, 0.029011430218815804, 0.05233406648039818, -0.0059036738239228725, -0.0197883490473032, -0.03008047305047512, -0.0077194469049572945, -0.012987615540623665, 0.01754729449748993, 0.019454337656497955, 0.05016535520553589, 0.05144784227013588, -0.0009759434615261853, 0.006295049097388983, -0.018515238538384438, 0.025576235726475716, 0.01701963320374489, 0.010406904853880405, 0.024985946714878082, 0.01812051609158516, -0.02792942523956299, 0.0010976941557601094, 0.027281055226922035, 0.07325372099876404, 0.035886723548173904, -0.0013687979662790895, -0.005475097335875034, 0.010604253970086575, 0.05768344923853874, -0.07715429365634918, -0.06360035389661789, -0.03208195045590401, -0.04115039482712746, 0.05319220572710037, 0.06100176274776459, 0.009330123662948608, 0.00855889730155468, -0.06467548757791519, 0.008359563536942005, -0.01292889192700386, -0.059258781373500824, 0.07825513184070587, 0.00225034705363214, -0.014291837811470032, -0.03756968677043915, 0.05504097789525986, 0.0027583432383835316, -0.02984943985939026, 0.03141399100422859, 0.052929043769836426, 0.014558564871549606, -0.06369157135486603, -0.03496489301323891, -0.05382668972015381, -0.025839315727353096, -0.052995748817920685, 0.021541617810726166, -0.04804997518658638, -0.02376343309879303, -0.07375649362802505, 0.03525255620479584, -0.06931270658969879, 0.05243895947933197, -0.026199504733085632, 0.037597253918647766, 0.009960955940186977, -0.07860975712537766, 0.05326931178569794, -0.010472110472619534, 0.02306154929101467, -0.04534907266497612, -0.003997392486780882, -0.0257446076720953, -0.011409422382712364, -0.023471714928746223, -0.018359916284680367, 0.026359334588050842, -0.02645624801516533, -0.06560296565294266, 0.0541377067565918, -0.03452345356345177, -0.010832112282514572, 0.012510123662650585, 0.006875335238873959, 0.006179658230394125, 0.04321841523051262, -0.03167075663805008, 0.025228027254343033, 0.04325559362769127, -0.019812051206827164, -0.04470723122358322, 0.028528384864330292, -0.006242759060114622, 0.007056241389364004, -0.0017580966232344508, -0.03179826959967613, 0.010540258139371872, -0.06898920238018036, -0.03746160864830017, 0.001558273914270103, 0.017257314175367355, 0.005027112551033497, 0.04300137236714363, -0.016901206225156784, -0.007806465961039066, 0.07109244167804718, -0.04022767022252083, 0.08059960603713989, 0.09698084741830826, 0.033930808305740356, -0.0675218477845192, -0.02631337009370327, 0.07543738186359406, 0.04637516289949417, 0.004693684633821249, 0.04316822066903114, -0.05093125253915787, -0.048536740243434906, 0.002891340758651495, -0.01459878496825695, -0.008965766988694668, -0.07064149528741837, -0.010923841968178749, 0.0001602653501322493, -0.02270766906440258, 0.002759671537205577, 0.03759190812706947, 0.04675573110580444, -0.018315404653549194, -0.0023863737005740404, 0.033588703721761703, -0.0031876773573458195, -0.0673111230134964, 0.0017292688135057688, -0.05987626686692238, 0.052833192050457, 0.007591985631734133, 0.004102533217519522, 0.019461167976260185, -0.12082785367965698, -0.02091227099299431, -0.04792725294828415, -0.03962969779968262, -0.0699692964553833, -0.04674355685710907, 0.04068921506404877, -0.0028031161054968834, -0.024185480549931526, -0.028957990929484367, -0.008674352429807186, -0.041730012744665146, -0.07132605463266373, -0.005892342422157526, -0.028796806931495667, -0.010537853464484215, -0.08111267536878586, 0.03978080302476883, 0.04258989915251732, -0.047560133039951324, 0.005627715028822422, 0.003543685656040907, 0.03510870411992073, 0.06527327746152878, 0.014936723746359348, -0.012436535209417343, 0.030585067346692085, 0.022002367302775383, -0.03533197566866875, -0.0659361407160759, -0.034209202975034714, 0.02985292114317417, -0.0347709022462368, -0.026829028502106667, -0.011723008938133717, 0.019884245470166206, 0.05576014518737793, 0.029695866629481316, 0.02578163892030716, 0.0373513326048851, 0.0186983160674572, -0.04215274751186371, 0.05787190794944763, -0.04397459328174591, 0.024861477315425873, 0.023162277415394783, 0.00554579496383667, 0.004709604661911726, 0.0364004485309124, -0.0176108255982399, 0.0016361242160201073, 0.012356673367321491, 0.030576782301068306, 0.004766477271914482, 0.029422756284475327, 0.029341554269194603, -0.006308628711849451, 0.03881959989666939, -0.019331801682710648, 0.024039050564169884, -0.026766609400510788, 0.015262394212186337, 0.008086868561804295, -0.037356898188591, 0.021727126091718674, -0.014094763435423374, 0.02701856568455696, 0.012692241929471493, -0.03620307147502899, -0.050354499369859695, -0.007659938186407089, 0.025475990027189255, -0.023260854184627533, 0.024222632870078087, 0.0057763950899243355, -0.036986224353313446, -0.011583821848034859, -0.04105854779481888, 0.03377309814095497, -0.02879456616938114, -0.033979833126068115, 0.011362599208950996, -0.016409074887633324, 0.018892524763941765, -0.015151580795645714, 0.042758598923683167, -0.0787099301815033, -0.049592338502407074, -0.0007166045252233744, 0.03962692245841026, -0.023827308788895607, -0.004304123111069202, -0.047873370349407196, -0.002784575102850795, 0.044772956520318985, 0.06616098433732986, -0.03230663016438484, 0.027238382026553154, 0.029591994360089302, 0.0417194701731205, -0.0018890239298343658, -0.008727160282433033, -0.05161318555474281, -0.009123774245381355, -0.014869986101984978, -0.03858498856425285, -0.027508080005645752, 0.004065836779773235, 0.029689880087971687 ]
<p>Say we have an expression of the form: $$ \left&lt;0\right|:\phi(x)^2: : \phi(y)^2:\left|0\right&gt;, $$ where $\phi$ is some scalar field. I have heard the claim several times, that in evaluating this expression using Wick contractions, one only has to contract terms between groups of normal ordered terms. In this example this would mean we only have to contract $\phi(x)$ with $\phi(y)$ but not $\phi(x)$ with $\phi(x)$. I have no clue how to derive this. Has anyone got an idea?</p> <p>EDIT: And say we consider anticommuting operators, would we have: $$ \left&lt;:\Psi^{\dagger}(x)\Psi(x)::\Psi^{\dagger}(0)\Psi(0):\right&gt; = (-1)^3\left&lt;\Psi^{\dagger}(x)\Psi(0)\right&gt;\left&lt;\Psi^{\dagger}(x)\Psi(0)\right&gt;, $$ or with a plus sign?</p>
g6598
[ -0.008683375082910061, 0.006940849125385284, -0.022770076990127563, 0.005770787131041288, 0.042161863297224045, -0.07214701920747757, 0.03689519688487053, 0.013714363798499107, 0.0033291017170995474, 0.000045621298340847716, -0.0524253286421299, 0.05245552957057953, -0.04028220474720001, 0.011641704477369785, -0.02122470922768116, 0.0425356887280941, 0.0007421808550134301, 0.009247501380741596, 0.029935715720057487, 0.009112897329032421, -0.09118454158306122, 0.01879810355603695, 0.0005493787466548383, -0.0060035111382603645, 0.05397689715027809, -0.054796867072582245, 0.0010503854136914015, -0.006627020426094532, -0.06040605902671814, -0.06441919505596161, 0.03542027994990349, 0.05183527246117592, 0.0225225780159235, -0.06125691905617714, -0.0384543351829052, 0.014199890196323395, 0.040192168205976486, 0.020718902349472046, 0.0243571437895298, 0.01159332413226366, -0.013768665492534637, 0.017586855217814445, 0.04081610217690468, -0.01431540958583355, 0.009651889093220234, -0.0288400761783123, -0.004078164231032133, 0.055245205760002136, -0.012947832234203815, -0.029467923566699028, -0.009575958363711834, 0.029643947258591652, 0.023528601974248886, -0.04130260646343231, -0.02498084306716919, 0.05175037682056427, 0.04994385316967964, -0.04304192587733269, 0.028109734877943993, 0.03214219957590103, -0.0542592853307724, -0.037739019840955734, 0.05781180411577225, -0.03827841952443123, 0.03736672177910805, -0.026286588981747627, 0.016375485807657242, 0.01903710700571537, -0.009885961189866066, -0.028046799823641777, 0.00019666737352963537, -0.031601909548044205, 0.047588035464286804, -0.020749475806951523, -0.01771746389567852, 0.004768807906657457, -0.012058969587087631, -0.08292493224143982, 0.05693308264017105, 0.017221948131918907, -0.022058159112930298, -0.07249464094638824, 0.029083723202347755, 0.06539956480264664, 0.02579759992659092, -0.013435760512948036, 0.03505993261933327, -0.024319607764482498, -0.0028352902736514807, 0.06170166656374931, 0.02464643493294716, -0.02311481349170208, -0.001823084894567728, 0.03522660210728645, 0.008793672546744347, 0.019791383296251297, -0.0036943405866622925, 0.02159796841442585, -0.003123442642390728, -0.025291476398706436, 0.0073635694570839405, 0.041738562285900116, -0.008079896681010723, -0.000269462849246338, -0.020135516300797462, 0.01571287401020527, 0.02363753505051136, 0.018060021102428436, 0.00036965575418435037, -0.01847492903470993, -0.013055730611085892, 0.028191931545734406, -0.04217970371246338, -0.06312274187803268, 0.048502419143915176, -0.0320717878639698, 0.015654325485229492, 0.02290876768529415, -0.011723794974386692, 0.030412325635552406, -0.00216154707595706, -0.022200368344783783, 0.01246741134673357, 0.038289789110422134, 0.013018738478422165, -0.023979781195521355, 0.01813102513551712, 0.042500898241996765, -0.010665269568562508, -0.01755543053150177, 0.06756242364645004, -0.004932739306241274, 0.05508586764335632, 0.0883398950099945, 0.006621917709708214, 0.016913706436753273, -0.04416254907846451, 0.01607361249625683, 0.012203359976410866, -0.08580788969993591, -0.035106681287288666, 0.0034111510030925274, -0.021134184673428535, 0.003502926556393504, -0.011363119818270206, -0.03380467742681503, 0.04710114002227783, -0.06548719853162766, 0.01595793105661869, 0.06923738867044449, -0.029846783727407455, 0.0428561195731163, -0.004351416602730751, 0.009216390550136566, -0.02051541581749916, 0.0025205782148987055, 0.035384856164455414, 0.006977839861065149, -0.04968244582414627, 0.00955173559486866, 0.009575355798006058, 0.03458451107144356, 0.009739510715007782, 0.023002441972494125, -0.04912728816270828, -0.043748222291469574, 0.026541782543063164, -0.007292882539331913, -0.04435453936457634, -0.07045315951108932, 0.02128741703927517, 0.04402478039264679, 0.012978733517229557, -0.03509124368429184, 0.023129945620894432, 0.07021643966436386, -0.03378785029053688, 0.0041013979353010654, 0.01217783335596323, 0.027919281274080276, -0.06307248771190643, 0.011988040991127491, 0.009077632799744606, -0.020478732883930206, -0.022205935791134834, -0.039566412568092346, -0.06377905607223511, -0.00682164216414094, -0.02012326754629612, -0.010081455111503601, 0.020525634288787842, 0.02444986067712307, 0.021674413233995438, 0.0072996472008526325, -0.01761249080300331, -0.01767442561686039, -0.029937468469142914, -0.06715069711208344, 0.013575118966400623, -0.016979819163680077, -0.00824545044451952, -0.021470656618475914, -0.041902657598257065, -0.04088762775063515, -0.009929892607033253, -0.0034015493001788855, -0.020381897687911987, 0.020946595817804337, 0.035412877798080444, -0.016620859503746033, 0.013479745015501976, -0.09564534574747086, 0.03991072252392769, 0.028647154569625854, -0.017303790897130966, -0.05724814161658287, 0.006287981290370226, -0.000821361318230629, -0.0341525673866272, -0.012423279695212841, -0.016251347959041595, -0.027364153414964676, 0.017328526824712753, -0.0035811651032418013, 0.011077246628701687, 0.02235715091228485, 0.05072086676955223, 0.05831227824091911, 0.03378928080201149, 0.026884321123361588, -0.09968774020671844, 0.013532670214772224, -0.04330815002322197, -0.06489303708076477, -0.027492821216583252, 0.008285369724035263, -0.034179992973804474, 0.055199459195137024, 0.011415734887123108, 0.06123138964176178, -0.001124658272601664, 0.01801963709294796, -0.025932246819138527, 0.030627097934484482, 0.026781843975186348, -0.0042853872291743755, 0.03232596069574356, 0.022868888452649117, -0.03320031613111496, 0.0511467270553112, -0.02592909336090088, 0.004775163251906633, -0.020084192976355553, -0.021024171262979507, -0.03560253605246544, -0.04917016625404358, -0.0034453868865966797, -0.03889773041009903, -0.0309413094073534, -0.010033158585429192, -0.016656722873449326, 0.0698876902461052, 0.03760896623134613, 0.023793190717697144, -0.0409390926361084, -0.02730332501232624, 0.005655887071043253, 0.035706955939531326, 0.03894959017634392, 0.008666696958243847, -0.029740385711193085, -0.007160705514252186, -0.008302557282149792, -0.005567880813032389, -0.03211748227477074, -0.06454598158597946, -0.022022100165486336, -0.030379099771380424, 0.021110927686095238, 0.04311058297753334, 0.04356799274682999, -0.0002427185681881383, 0.005837135948240757, 0.0438874252140522, -0.0012254409957677126, -0.03541293367743492, -0.0022692966740578413, 0.036940693855285645, -0.00875131506472826, 0.01331039797514677, -0.007989390753209591, 0.023962581530213356, 0.009870409965515137, -0.04110700264573097, 0.002007042523473501, -0.009316307492554188, 0.017389658838510513, -0.00972513947635889, 0.033153995871543884, 0.03978307172656059, -0.006649005692452192, 0.01833486557006836, 0.021839963272213936, 0.03486702963709831, 0.004713691771030426, -0.022370781749486923, -0.017904823645949364, -0.07289029657840729, -0.029784321784973145, -0.010620190761983395, -0.006179633550345898, 0.020566727966070175, -0.024945087730884552, 0.0057106949388980865, -0.05250444635748863, -0.031976357102394104, 0.007285239174962044, 0.01444126758724451, -0.00483803590759635, -0.04960102215409279, -0.00803618784993887, -0.05999407172203064, 0.06199837848544121, 0.014155130833387375, -0.02458271011710167, -0.0036111194640398026, -0.06593789905309677, 0.04386739060282707, -0.05785032734274864, -0.06549480557441711, 0.014071624726057053, -0.004415589384734631, 0.03908853232860565, 0.004375236574560404, -0.04175364226102829, -0.06567889451980591, -0.004644317086786032, 0.017462916672229767, -0.010897909291088581, 0.007172957994043827, 0.0357925221323967, -0.02160377986729145, -0.048962801694869995, 0.0011230732779949903, -0.020908161997795105, -0.059118155390024185, -0.032776545733213425, 0.06992384791374207, 0.044379014521837234, -0.01545693352818489, -0.03875555098056793, -0.04935607314109802, 0.026193639263510704, -0.05057363957166672, -0.00891305971890688, 0.016301151365041733, 0.03384455665946007, -0.023286595940589905, 0.0048728203400969505, 0.015911875292658806, 0.015190073288977146, 0.02399165742099285, -0.018115980550646782, 0.015696337446570396, 0.01665438711643219, 0.041612476110458374, 0.04571260139346123, 0.08438390493392944, 0.015846749767661095, -0.0047690668143332005, 0.00048114077071659267, 0.007195489481091499, 0.034094009548425674, 0.02107894793152809, -0.058071717619895935, -0.008989316411316395, 0.028791263699531555, -0.014902645722031593, 0.06355591863393784, -0.013965317979454994, -0.05030420050024986, 0.0576932467520237, 0.03611749783158302, -0.03290672227740288, -0.056171055883169174, -0.016211066395044327, -0.013951919041574001, 0.037365686148405075, -0.070856012403965, 0.011279345490038395, -0.001362788607366383, -0.0277694184333086, -0.022394180297851562, 0.033189840614795685, 0.027183501049876213, -0.035662636160850525, 0.02548261359333992, 0.021139230579137802, -0.015631239861249924, -0.053098127245903015, 0.0030788835138082504, -0.03181786090135574, 0.04218921810388565, -0.03450477868318558, -0.01380985602736473, -0.041709575802087784, 0.03812215104699135, 0.02085135132074356, 0.04819512367248535, -0.06144965440034866, -0.004700652789324522, -0.04338402301073074, 0.00140066584572196, 0.040251120924949646, 0.01007484458386898, -0.015508443117141724, 0.023991582915186882, -0.008759449236094952, -0.07118917256593704, 0.01652618683874607, 0.011614229530096054, 0.0156562477350235, 0.004245346412062645, -0.0024363980628550053, 0.029604341834783554, 0.11509232968091965, 0.03640376776456833, 0.00548667972907424, 0.02382575161755085, -0.005791782401502132, -0.03747973591089249, 0.11102423071861267, -0.016569074243307114, 0.031322773545980453, -0.014226735569536686, -0.010172151029109955, -0.07297965884208679, 0.034844525158405304, 0.038080766797065735, -0.007696504704654217, -0.018022283911705017, 0.0016585917910560966, -0.03591113165020943, -0.05523828789591789, 0.0006443556630983949, -0.019199978560209274, -0.05183786153793335, -0.04207243770360947, 0.007954324595630169, -0.019926998764276505, -0.04207240045070648, 0.05033859610557556, 0.021130435168743134, -0.0863756462931633, 0.07017220556735992, -0.015123828314244747, 0.0006558610475622118, 0.002995937829837203, -0.027748532593250275, -0.020503152161836624, -0.01893303543329239, -0.08008129149675369, -0.000996079994365573, -0.00890872161835432, 0.028075043112039566, -0.003516435855999589, -0.0943155363202095, 0.03171733021736145, -0.10352399945259094, 0.03293208032846451, 0.04109774902462959, 0.05707739666104317, 0.02838762104511261, -0.05936604365706444, -0.02541375905275345, -0.011645099148154259, 0.028421230614185333, 0.03360293060541153, -0.051433272659778595, -0.012427866458892822, 0.017578361555933952, -0.04103896766901016, -0.04917878285050392, -0.0031062231864780188, 0.04891052469611168, 0.04610768333077431, -0.0060535576194524765, -0.018687894567847252, 0.025771884247660637, -0.03785143792629242, 0.03209499269723892, 0.05015556886792183, -0.007176603656262159, -0.03557506576180458, -0.07006745785474777, -0.016496790573000908, 0.02319418638944626, -0.013437294401228428, 0.02777963876724243, -0.01588228903710842, -0.03366997465491295, -0.0016745703760534525, -0.041363444179296494, 0.013525985181331635, -0.010675672441720963, 0.06715703755617142, 0.007903724908828735, 0.03605516999959946, 0.015152105130255222, 0.03194968402385712, 0.013660396449267864, -0.021791212260723114, 0.11699803173542023, -0.005516068544238806, -0.005858323071151972, -0.0008477825904265046, -0.014145726338028908, -0.038991253823041916, 0.023958561941981316, -0.06205907464027405, 0.07909557968378067, 0.030939213931560516, -0.00873776338994503, -0.012434417381882668, 0.06167701259255409, 0.05355384573340416, -0.013358737342059612, -0.060642313212156296, -0.029078403487801552, -0.015512467361986637, 0.008564094081521034, 0.036779094487428665, 0.005973847582936287, -0.00990261510014534, 0.05955316126346588, -0.06445658951997757, -0.02562238648533821, 0.07071349769830704, 0.00925454217940569, 0.006425938569009304, -0.0750170424580574, -0.014185418374836445, -0.018275456503033638, 0.0231497623026371, -0.028712183237075806, 0.01984608732163906, 0.006424381863325834, -0.030700433999300003, -0.018996097147464752, -0.03917362168431282, 0.01929834671318531, -0.030811524018645287, -0.03201392665505409, -0.05692523345351219, 0.03223082795739174, 0.020029529929161072, -0.019491324201226234, -0.013020330108702183, -0.009017915464937687, -0.017290648072957993, 0.02440977469086647, -0.013880319893360138, 0.03415345400571823, 0.03204786777496338, 0.018788082525134087, -0.008714141324162483, 0.0050519416108727455, 0.03632862865924835, -0.024120710790157318, 0.005257092881947756, 0.038049422204494476, 0.04699869826436043, 0.027595924213528633, 0.05886856094002724, 0.06447585672140121, 0.018841195851564407, 0.0007930745487101376, 0.025574488565325737, -0.00045521120773628354, 0.015074447728693485, 0.004184954799711704, -0.04135172814130783, 0.009876510128378868, -0.059517741203308105, -0.0668681338429451, 0.031155752018094063, 0.03804308921098709, -0.01356141921132803, 0.05024903267621994, 0.04140685871243477, -0.009784729219973087, -0.0022814865224063396, 0.0035534529015421867, 0.03716026991605759, -0.0024443070869892836, 0.05201473459601402, 0.046592820435762405, 0.04927459731698036, 0.022730102762579918, 0.007961836643517017, 0.0475940927863121, 0.054238371551036835, 0.04313089698553085, -0.08733758330345154, 0.03861776366829872, 0.023531045764684677, -0.043803535401821136, 0.058637555688619614, -0.03420419245958328, -0.020801208913326263, -0.01456349529325962, -0.023434074595570564, 0.011247929185628891, 0.011807537637650967, -0.007976427674293518, -0.015218059532344341, 0.016914552077651024, 0.09565503895282745, -0.014102528803050518, -0.01478409580886364, 0.03568382188677788, 0.023662764579057693, -0.0337495282292366, -0.01576332561671734, 0.033363357186317444, 0.03197222203016281, 0.009586869738996029, -0.049495939165353775, 0.02987552434206009, 0.04898707941174507, 0.027911650016903877, 0.0045123049058020115, -0.03286692500114441, 0.012092288583517075, -0.008108843117952347, 0.0271469559520483, -0.07226239889860153, 0.09066996723413467, 0.01579207181930542, 0.07635283470153809, 0.016423005610704422, 0.018707403913140297, 0.040562164038419724, -0.05450283735990524, -0.042295366525650024, 0.02710098773241043, -0.009179319255053997, -0.03645686060190201, -0.047352246940135956, -0.02690647542476654, -0.007303909864276648, 0.004458791576325893, -0.03606502339243889, 0.03459199145436287, -0.023898961022496223, 0.030317677184939384, 0.039084360003471375, 0.06935964524745941, -0.07890167832374573, -0.05937068536877632, 0.03486493602395058, 0.014136438257992268, 0.021952098235487938, 0.07533625513315201, -0.006262792274355888, 0.010905812494456768, -0.004885610193014145, 0.04214812442660332, 0.038281917572021484, 0.009250017814338207, -0.04730965197086334, -0.023303477093577385, -0.037810567766427994, -0.004822698887437582, 0.008667804300785065, -0.04894736409187317, 0.08007694780826569, 0.020292621105909348, 0.02283698506653309, 0.008715188130736351, -0.024894487112760544, -0.02299761213362217, -0.012330187484622002, -0.02861841581761837, -0.02205895632505417, 0.09335702657699585, 0.04907328635454178, -0.02481677755713463, -0.022472672164440155, 0.031106367707252502, 0.05005089193582535, -0.03084101714193821, -0.022566506639122963, -0.003479722421616316, 0.026982495561242104, -0.023174798116087914, 0.009713699109852314, 0.09714967757463455, -0.01931741274893284, 0.04289883375167847, 0.05720826983451843, 0.009816001169383526, -0.048595622181892395, -0.004173812922090292, -0.004534013103693724, 0.0016579002840444446, -0.019219661131501198, -0.01550920307636261, -0.024522975087165833, -0.09375027567148209, 0.009534844197332859, 0.008575529791414738, -0.04622757062315941, 0.0013329057255759835, -0.014645581133663654, -0.011700445786118507, 0.0069361599162220955, 0.009826645255088806, 0.0403306744992733, -0.031468089669942856, 0.00527118518948555, 0.021971896290779114, -0.014408268965780735, -0.0636637881398201, 0.0008529140031896532, -0.03170209378004074, -0.06372170150279999, 0.024514392018318176, -0.0052105276845395565, 0.05929572880268097, 0.002298185834661126, -0.07413278520107269, -0.03321462124586105, 0.08510705083608627, -0.026759594678878784, 0.02746427059173584, -0.03691716492176056, -0.06287894397974014, 0.012277026660740376, -0.029132425785064697, -0.051777396351099014, -0.013635649345815182, -0.03292069211602211, -0.013923515565693378, 0.04424427077174187, -0.00871158204972744, 0.001920081558637321, 0.018340878188610077, 0.03470192477107048, -0.009721779264509678, -0.03505229949951172, 0.04871173948049545, -0.02416575327515602, 0.06456688791513443, 0.03358432278037071, -0.027281610295176506, 0.010063217021524906, 0.005233618430793285, 0.015852531418204308, 0.03799201920628548, -0.026995470747351646, -0.03485475108027458, -0.06200212985277176, 0.003707433585077524, -0.028537752106785774, -0.03733773157000542, 0.014251073822379112, 0.004510627128183842 ]
<p>I am trying to make sense of <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0210005" rel="nofollow">arXiv:physics/0210005</a>. I am confused with the concept of information bearing degrees of freedom of a system mentioned at the very beginning. To verify the arguments of the paper, I would like to start with a 1-D quantum simple harmonic oscillator. We know that it has two degrees of freedom, momentum and position. You can also use generalized degrees of freedom if you want. My question is which of these are the information bearing degrees of freedom?</p>
g6599
[ 0.04107074812054634, 0.0008589160861447453, 0.0005711746052838862, -0.010933621786534786, 0.06342893838882446, 0.019851457327604294, 0.06691402196884155, -0.03913012146949768, -0.012217836454510689, -0.03963780775666237, -0.027963396161794662, 0.004797876346856356, -0.019706567749381065, -0.016184240579605103, -0.010739874094724655, -0.049710437655448914, 0.05174809694290161, 0.07369206845760345, 0.04923509433865547, -0.028906410560011864, 0.028935370966792107, 0.026723524555563927, -0.10036846250295639, -0.019372571259737015, -0.010074660181999207, 0.0045426879078149796, 0.004797816276550293, -0.08477681130170822, -0.01670778915286064, -0.021056078374385834, -0.07648012787103653, -0.03165837749838829, 0.06637759506702423, -0.0020911102183163166, 0.008482621051371098, -0.02245909534394741, 0.03200451284646988, -0.023199748247861862, 0.018234949558973312, 0.022975511848926544, -0.049244996160268784, -0.020571859553456306, -0.003554019844159484, -0.019606968387961388, 0.03441723808646202, 0.05205722898244858, 0.02977537363767624, -0.011473199352622032, -0.0281122587621212, -0.020722322165966034, 0.006336433347314596, 0.02075505256652832, 0.032868023961782455, 0.06086178869009018, 0.008995294570922852, 0.0458805188536644, 0.013514801859855652, -0.056709468364715576, 0.010558126494288445, 0.00044509072904475033, 0.014343529008328915, 0.039049554616212845, -0.015560860745608807, -0.015380223281681538, 0.023994045332074165, -0.006599646992981434, -0.0570853017270565, -0.06195182725787163, -0.039837297052145004, -0.011115998961031437, 0.02213132567703724, -0.029574038460850716, -0.024372277781367302, -0.017409460619091988, 0.01613754592835903, -0.037875063717365265, 0.013728695921599865, -0.051151104271411896, 0.0473763570189476, -0.006671268027275801, -0.029680540785193443, -0.08498110622167587, 0.06974448263645172, -0.006056411191821098, 0.09584962576627731, 0.020353153347969055, -0.0186642874032259, 0.024999428540468216, -0.0010765653569251299, 0.06651104986667633, 0.040779393166303635, -0.02311772294342518, 0.025808868929743767, 0.0187305249273777, -0.0016023799544200301, -0.003977173939347267, -0.06910693645477295, 0.018458079546689987, 0.018260546028614044, 0.06596130132675171, -0.028780711814761162, 0.0004032497527077794, 0.0025067597161978483, -0.024088658392429352, 0.016287051141262054, -0.04333476349711418, -0.01958184503018856, -0.04525446146726608, -0.012150539085268974, 0.012470996007323265, -0.04923655092716217, 0.017674315720796585, 0.014656628482043743, -0.06810969859361649, -0.04758754372596741, -0.02356557548046112, 0.10243452340364456, -0.005840647500008345, -0.00985982920974493, -0.0071950736455619335, -0.012918807566165924, 0.03721213340759277, 0.043540533632040024, 0.08844054490327835, -0.01608852669596672, -0.00902439747005701, 0.0031734684016555548, -0.021672602742910385, 0.025592422112822533, -0.03399300575256348, -0.009734364226460457, -0.018445344641804695, -0.01784876547753811, 0.02236158400774002, -0.025236139073967934, 0.0054177152924239635, 0.06375470757484436, -0.007952549494802952, 0.008099541068077087, 0.007238483987748623, 0.04274491220712662, -0.033928338438272476, 0.002150388201698661, -0.07212301343679428, 0.030447019264101982, 0.0026511664036661386, 0.030268648639321327, -0.022670656442642212, 0.060347095131874084, 0.012720725499093533, 0.012998729944229126, 0.014546727761626244, 0.0035690527874976397, -0.0398855097591877, -0.0003773291246034205, -0.011065519414842129, 0.019385065883398056, 0.01841067150235176, 0.02784094028174877, 0.03512310981750488, 0.026409616693854332, 0.015157556161284447, 0.06351584941148758, -0.02331857569515705, -0.02410936914384365, -0.00730983866378665, -0.0032577018719166517, -0.043986666947603226, -0.005676425993442535, -0.04770931601524353, -0.01716420240700245, -0.03953108191490173, -0.03933277726173401, 0.035138364881277084, -0.020313454791903496, 0.02159845270216465, 0.01344876829534769, 0.027188993990421295, 0.08757387846708298, 0.03317752107977867, 0.02050177752971649, -0.00290933926589787, -0.004503021016716957, 0.00397765077650547, -0.026523107662796974, 0.026324691250920296, 0.0730489119887352, 0.012523902580142021, -0.07304701209068298, 0.025220884010195732, -0.0009958137525245547, -0.038110166788101196, -0.04356447979807854, -0.006515032611787319, -0.03986286371946335, -0.01472749374806881, 0.02681809663772583, -0.018046336248517036, -0.038495734333992004, 0.0332554467022419, -0.01771821454167366, 0.029353320598602295, 0.015073582530021667, 0.014134465716779232, 0.049055516719818115, 0.005833685398101807, 0.01460224762558937, 0.038334667682647705, 0.0011261127656325698, 0.004562817979604006, 0.0222003236413002, -0.014445362612605095, 0.0007762510213069618, 0.031916793435811996, 0.024919137358665466, -0.0657191202044487, 0.042832087725400925, -0.020673613995313644, 0.014045333489775658, -0.052490234375, -0.00392840476706624, 0.02974826656281948, 0.06263188272714615, -0.013905978761613369, -0.024534817785024643, 0.05354577675461769, -0.051289379596710205, -0.04797779768705368, -0.045241862535476685, 0.06864422559738159, -0.06165344640612602, -0.019571051001548767, -0.007356191985309124, -0.012543064542114735, 0.03010113537311554, 0.03957124426960945, -0.014259048737585545, -0.027812229469418526, 0.0516614131629467, 0.03830511495471001, 0.018190519884228706, 0.031479042023420334, -0.03089674562215805, -0.06508464366197586, -0.018408790230751038, 0.028364261612296104, 0.04765506461262703, -0.02632364258170128, -0.037640444934368134, 0.003491588868200779, -0.02211880125105381, -0.06309682130813599, 0.037504907697439194, -0.0076007298193871975, 0.005082482937723398, 0.009648626670241356, -0.0007130596786737442, -0.03846650570631027, -0.027439787983894348, -0.025715000927448273, -0.02141367830336094, -0.10638252645730972, 0.008263190276920795, 0.039085738360881805, -0.04013214260339737, 0.001977285835891962, 0.009348009712994099, -0.02890332043170929, 0.0037221082020550966, -0.024167455732822418, -0.0061951554380357265, 0.07912025600671768, -0.03500485420227051, 0.07107099890708923, -0.047123122960329056, -0.017234330996870995, 0.01087899785488844, -0.015399684198200703, -0.06665041297674179, 0.0012627794640138745, -0.01483965665102005, 0.01576375402510166, -0.003659073496237397, 0.009236413054168224, 0.06721947342157364, -0.049781426787376404, -0.012755069881677628, 0.04323616996407509, -0.004245956894010305, 0.02558271586894989, -0.060718268156051636, 0.02758541703224182, 0.03158937767148018, 0.03646852821111679, -0.040025826543569565, 0.07911942899227142, 0.04202998802065849, -0.004677527118474245, -0.03744730353355408, 0.07191213220357895, 0.013612388633191586, 0.028676485642790794, -0.011836186982691288, 0.05273136496543884, -0.010305024683475494, 0.00731344148516655, -0.02220483496785164, 0.0032890629954636097, 0.016292793676257133, 0.005737054627388716, -0.05334347113966942, -0.022493576630949974, 0.046300116926431656, -0.0002752933942247182, -0.005719044245779514, -0.0015080436132848263, -0.05943071097135544, 0.0017955198418349028, -0.03519770875573158, -0.02185348980128765, -0.0501001700758934, -0.06602483987808228, 0.0033928826451301575, -0.04036587104201317, 0.12836503982543945, 0.09131886810064316, -0.041123777627944946, 0.0007338568684644997, -0.06271959841251373, -0.09612902998924255, 0.028008639812469482, -0.0054965270683169365, -0.0073160696774721146, -0.02939663827419281, -0.009760403074324131, -0.034589994698762894, -0.015479007735848427, 0.0028448079247027636, -0.0025213644839823246, 0.021425919607281685, 0.02462012693285942, 0.011143398471176624, 0.011377585120499134, 0.022735146805644035, -0.0005599242285825312, -0.013201610185205936, -0.01356351189315319, 0.011727187782526016, -0.009263004176318645, -0.00014908789307810366, -0.010871986858546734, 0.03607925772666931, -0.02287919446825981, 0.016436858102679253, 0.0056215329095721245, 0.07924339175224304, 0.00573092931881547, 0.056755151599645615, 0.02523655630648136, -0.01713946834206581, -0.007048197090625763, -0.017642013728618622, 0.02088375762104988, 0.0641661211848259, 0.008057814091444016, -0.03359299153089523, -0.03533557802438736, -0.0005968806799501181, 0.025224698707461357, -0.00518212141469121, -0.03497679904103279, -0.09213576465845108, 0.04352077096700668, 0.00008413539035245776, 0.062108464539051056, 0.026852762326598167, 0.012687303125858307, -0.024594932794570923, -0.05356542766094208, 0.022177213802933693, 0.025664331391453743, 0.003951667807996273, 0.04503285884857178, 0.012650563381612301, 0.06763820350170135, 0.004480564966797829, 0.017517535015940666, 0.03891536965966225, -0.02746128849685192, -0.03723302483558655, 0.06714513897895813, -0.059945814311504364, -0.011740943416953087, 0.010977399535477161, 0.020189886912703514, 0.01999831013381481, -0.016383569687604904, 0.005467304028570652, -0.03674323856830597, 0.05138426646590233, 0.013661864213645458, -0.022352103143930435, -0.001617982517927885, 0.00332475733011961, 0.01597304455935955, 0.06116004288196564, 0.01312066800892353, -0.022316444665193558, 0.014382684603333473, -0.00982020515948534, -0.043891388922929764, 0.003616266418248415, 0.01947890780866146, -0.03951086103916168, 0.0010735706891864538, 0.09108193963766098, 0.005332698114216328, -0.08038859069347382, 0.008489750325679779, 0.01692637801170349, -0.03470020741224289, 0.06709686666727066, 0.02550947107374668, -0.011964610777795315, -0.05866082012653351, 0.00251580448821187, 0.06120818108320236, 0.0048298100009560585, 0.003322622971609235, -0.011943865567445755, 0.012957898899912834, -0.04952201992273331, 0.06419198215007782, -0.0054067461751401424, -0.06650589406490326, 0.033479414880275726, -0.010681727901101112, 0.0038169012404978275, -0.00657674903050065, 0.03317073732614517, 0.07458491623401642, 0.012184553779661655, -0.026444492861628532, -0.04506182298064232, 0.026242034509778023, 0.03136669844388962, -0.01259202603250742, 0.015253538265824318, 0.024927327409386635, -0.03233460336923599, 0.036758601665496826, 0.04613000154495239, -0.061105936765670776, -0.07838581502437592, 0.031552139669656754, 0.028480710461735725, -0.06764592975378036, 0.004200696479529142, 0.00027931781369261444, -0.0072687044739723206, 0.018017560243606567, -0.017337266355752945, -0.008113844320178032, -0.02169082686305046, 0.024165261536836624, -0.004877801053225994, -0.039147645235061646, 0.011088673025369644, -0.06983254849910736, -0.01303123589605093, 0.05067004635930061, -0.04581143334507942, 0.006586889270693064, 0.032911404967308044, 0.033474620431661606, -0.0211167149245739, 0.02015136368572712, -0.049734145402908325, 0.01878543198108673, -0.048387736082077026, 0.02564813382923603, -0.027599237859249115, 0.021308191120624542, 0.06319320201873779, 0.023471713066101074, -0.05134733393788338, 0.01798298954963684, -0.031978510320186615, -0.008539793081581593, -0.007763785310089588, 0.03855513408780098, 0.027896663174033165, 0.0034592917654663324, -0.031489573419094086, -0.010594197548925877, -0.030477814376354218, -0.02281070500612259, 0.008601575158536434, -0.01086493395268917, -0.017642658203840256, -0.09733845293521881, 0.036919303238391876, 0.02835109457373619, 0.0306804571300745, -0.038290999829769135, 0.03195143863558769, 0.01750892959535122, -0.062091194093227386, -0.011739340610802174, 0.0010632188059389591, -0.03175760433077812, -0.011651089414954185, -0.009955037385225296, 0.0002300220658071339, 0.046735771000385284, -0.06666668504476547, -0.02100735902786255, 0.015184176154434681, 0.0034966059029102325, 0.04647460952401161, -0.010919513180851936, 0.0340595617890358, 0.024185361340641975, -0.05007867142558098, -0.006541973911225796, 0.010604184120893478, -0.06224648281931877, -0.03716469556093216, 0.0366348959505558, 0.09305791556835175, 0.03127961978316307, 0.03709603101015091, 0.07849418371915817, -0.023146405816078186, -0.02139822021126747, 0.003415197366848588, -0.027334343641996384, -0.0588766485452652, 0.009969995357096195, 0.04166514798998833, -0.05584628880023956, -0.002182245720177889, -0.0043523283675313, 0.059881649911403656, -0.021295178681612015, -0.060193635523319244, 0.022984571754932404, -0.0017324598738923669, -0.00046973853022791445, 0.030409786850214005, -0.012401157990098, 0.02908877097070217, -0.007702635135501623, 0.0005876514478586614, -0.010110302828252316, -0.009890771470963955, 0.02134726755321026, 0.012496493756771088, 0.015623887069523335, 0.021047523245215416, 0.041834499686956406, 0.028790604323148727, 0.058740999549627304, 0.023679278790950775, 0.02850295789539814, 0.03952596336603165, -0.00006180649506859481, -0.032422225922346115, 0.04917147383093834, 0.0989367812871933, -0.04889127239584923, 0.031483184546232224, -0.03335824981331825, -0.022368937730789185, 0.036670245230197906, 0.018290752544999123, -0.056861016899347305, -0.08012737333774567, -0.06205931678414345, 0.0072951349429786205, -0.03364504501223564, 0.052048660814762115, 0.04141182824969292, -0.013418257236480713, -0.004760971758514643, 0.00720980204641819, -0.03442881628870964, -0.005929851438850164, 0.012299198657274246, 0.03760310634970665, -0.032493334263563156, 0.014369623735547066, -0.03762958571314812, -0.03461503982543945, -0.05572453886270523, 0.0016170855378732085, 0.009872321039438248, -0.004773976281285286, -0.025820231065154076, 0.01903355121612549, 0.02923867106437683, -0.055122602730989456, 0.05443954840302467, -0.018254587426781654, -0.022752484306693077, 0.08841679245233536, -0.028526315465569496, 0.003478625789284706, 0.005628935527056456, -0.0002726186066865921, -0.06311709433794022, -0.0004995427443645895, 0.007257391698658466, 0.00833535473793745, 0.04756814241409302, -0.013319849036633968, 0.006764761172235012, -0.04281199350953102, 0.01335806306451559, -0.019475750625133514, 0.07809341698884964, -0.014768031425774097, 0.011277424171566963, 0.027756990864872932, -0.0002570438664406538, 0.05173981934785843, -0.03154400363564491, 0.02388826198875904, 0.0673905536532402, 0.032432641834020615, 0.0225888192653656, -0.005017295014113188, 0.0640004575252533, 0.025616485625505447, 0.002573471050709486, -0.027594758197665215, -0.009576758369803429, 0.03992532938718796, 0.038713399320840836, 0.053686778992414474, -0.03838525339961052, -0.006344323046505451, 0.053001902997493744, 0.00505003472790122, -0.02850515954196453, 0.0003820065758191049, 0.02424299716949463, -0.0135544678196311, -0.07436720281839371, -0.002772972919046879, -0.04238273948431015, 0.019840974360704422, -0.023293597623705864, 0.045620620250701904, -0.016279436647892, -0.02191965840756893, 0.036084581166505814, 0.003752463962882757, -0.03429199382662773, -0.03007604368031025, -0.046704307198524475, -0.02509292960166931, -0.0010613566264510155, -0.017886314541101456, -0.08049309998750687, 0.03895054757595062, 0.008742261677980423, -0.04642431437969208, -0.0008440802339464426, -0.00384811544790864, -0.00954096857458353, -0.00016911413695197552, 0.02063635177910328, -0.021330367773771286, 0.0007547484710812569, 0.01615775004029274, -0.015507126227021217, -0.0007087343255989254, -0.043136097490787506, 0.017729829996824265, -0.010774258524179459, 0.048953671008348465, 0.04856295511126518, -0.03402175381779671, -0.02586415968835354, -0.007145688869059086, -0.035580042749643326, 0.007583445869386196, 0.048019811511039734, -0.0714975968003273, -0.011011909693479538, -0.010977939702570438, -0.03818678483366966, -0.025887148454785347, -0.10384667664766312, 0.052255019545555115, 0.013177836313843727, 0.05253826454281807, -0.023662833496928215, 0.011447290889918804, 0.027263950556516647, -0.09538581967353821, -0.035444583743810654, 0.07529164850711823, 0.01553995069116354, -0.04458737000823021, 0.012961762957274914, -0.033484894782304764, -0.012639445252716541, 0.0014445841079577804, 0.04024139791727066, -0.05930809676647186, 0.01138297002762556, -0.009665451943874359, -0.03526827320456505, 0.05353089049458504, -0.03792145475745201, 0.058685366064310074, 0.021439531818032265, -0.03239003196358681, -0.0058823092840611935, -0.0016566398553550243, -0.020012103021144867, -0.014991501346230507, -0.055928103625774384, -0.0027977798599749804, 0.011150304228067398, -0.021887533366680145, 0.0018684674287214875, -0.020333413034677505, 0.011379976756870747, -0.011690356768667698, -0.01877155527472496, 0.019866999238729477, -0.022426141425967216, 0.02350284345448017, 0.002733658766373992, -0.01429116539657116, -0.013797353021800518, 0.02992033213376999, 0.009645875543355942, -0.005468872841447592, -0.015376233495771885, -0.02799731306731701, -0.029355987906455994, -0.05849306657910347, -0.033586759120225906, 0.05562863498926163, 0.012449068017303944, -0.10283102095127106, 0.010930115357041359, 0.0027950983494520187, 0.009238030761480331, -0.03141630068421364, 0.037097617983818054, -0.01984550803899765, -0.028004838153719902, 0.0198681578040123, 0.038923732936382294, 0.01790391281247139, 0.023361284285783768, 0.029494676738977432, 0.01053853053599596, 0.018133407458662987, -0.019722916185855865, -0.027291765436530113, -0.017911052331328392, 0.044155750423669815 ]
<p>Google has not been very useful in this regard. It seems no one has clearly defined terms and Kittel has too little on this. </p>
g6600
[ 0.014386100694537163, 0.0834764689207077, 0.0063358452171087265, -0.011292628012597561, 0.004009667783975601, -0.010120381601154804, -0.02789306454360485, -0.001429345109499991, -0.012647275812923908, -0.053677499294281006, -0.05507182702422142, -0.020685382187366486, 0.05409455671906471, 0.05732707306742668, 0.013704484328627586, -0.02820206619799137, 0.036050520837306976, 0.02210616134107113, 0.046516042202711105, 0.0457996241748333, 0.011139066889882088, 0.046967145055532455, -0.07095924764871597, -0.023197680711746216, -0.07458373159170151, -0.08823981881141663, 0.01908872090280056, 0.016757186502218246, -0.08040867745876312, -0.008548470214009285, -0.004045644775032997, -0.04208999127149582, -0.0019418520387262106, -0.038105908781290054, -0.07409247010946274, -0.008526151068508625, 0.02696957252919674, 0.02356201596558094, -0.0219903364777565, -0.030519111081957817, 0.05083361640572548, 0.008760858327150345, 0.057896167039871216, 0.05436284840106964, -0.016136668622493744, -0.012166121043264866, -0.0385950542986393, -0.019784774631261826, 0.05371834710240364, -0.037593089044094086, 0.0031543567311018705, -0.022774752229452133, 0.016983753070235252, 0.003467724658548832, 0.06167882680892944, -0.015998562797904015, 0.04675569385290146, 0.014888261444866657, 0.0004157833172939718, -0.02435251511633396, 0.008040214888751507, -0.022937925532460213, 0.004602500237524509, 0.04856747388839722, 0.020411845296621323, 0.0508718304336071, 0.024316541850566864, -0.0007085904944688082, 0.07145106047391891, -0.044216904789209366, 0.013891752809286118, -0.03430119529366493, 0.0029866108670830727, 0.006469940301030874, -0.02659914456307888, 0.005200408864766359, -0.04397495836019516, 0.0041543603874742985, 0.02547767572104931, 0.051185719668865204, 0.0019217360531911254, 0.0030211943667382, -0.05311046168208122, -0.020751530304551125, 0.05763299763202667, 0.022188208997249603, 0.012526108883321285, 0.002360397018492222, 0.0391000472009182, -0.002231006510555744, 0.05756121501326561, 0.012824675999581814, 0.031944744288921356, 0.008466693572700024, -0.012442117556929588, 0.00872985552996397, 0.001476982026360929, -0.01769784837961197, 0.07047554850578308, -0.05192689970135689, -0.06930834800004959, 0.0219187643378973, 0.0006974206771701574, -0.026473667472600937, -0.05886351317167282, 0.059730447828769684, 0.052366871386766434, -0.024023810401558876, 0.05629696324467659, -0.021900026127696037, -0.0026651902589946985, 0.013314089737832546, -0.051801614463329315, 0.03174779564142227, 0.016436155885457993, -0.04345172643661499, 0.04077630490064621, -0.006782379932701588, 0.00971873477101326, 0.001665809890255332, 0.02694462239742279, -0.04172967001795769, 0.04232264682650566, 0.006836343090981245, -0.02617802284657955, 0.015108173713088036, -0.018827341496944427, 0.017415905371308327, -0.03865104168653488, -0.017813773825764656, -0.01974525675177574, -0.02896696701645851, 0.06036096438765526, -0.029236026108264923, -0.013583436608314514, -0.0013363639591261744, 0.008350235410034657, -0.056144580245018005, -0.04078718274831772, 0.013648404739797115, 0.028321994468569756, 0.004169875290244818, -0.035109419375658035, 0.024825407192111015, 0.06592254340648651, -0.015327708795666695, 0.011144124902784824, 0.035391028970479965, 0.013055232353508472, -0.009973062202334404, 0.02519974112510681, -0.002365740481764078, -0.04644184187054634, -0.0035574212670326233, 0.023115189746022224, -0.028448108583688736, -0.031130526214838028, 0.06108725070953369, 0.04949643835425377, 0.01740768365561962, 0.0007404868374578655, -0.021374430507421494, -0.029719743877649307, -0.011021528393030167, -0.07626620680093765, -0.03507440909743309, -0.023020507767796516, 0.048896241933107376, -0.05820321664214134, -0.005444676615297794, 0.027838172391057014, -0.003226693719625473, 0.02036658488214016, 0.06202549859881401, 0.07988280057907104, 0.0517241507768631, 0.020043879747390747, 0.008227898739278316, 0.001634070766158402, -0.010330506600439548, -0.0426471084356308, -0.05060083046555519, -0.010124950669705868, 0.052005063742399216, -0.03922882303595543, -0.01468292623758316, 0.016741277649998665, -0.04169538989663124, -0.021417856216430664, 0.0001461554493289441, -0.006445132661610842, -0.09133557230234146, 0.05459199845790863, -0.02252276986837387, -0.02204819768667221, -0.00804080069065094, 0.005771977826952934, -0.012788493186235428, 0.0011789893032982945, -0.07324063777923584, 0.03366989642381668, -0.030688468366861343, -0.04327474907040596, -0.005176053382456303, -0.05666700378060341, -0.005126187577843666, 0.005822007078677416, 0.02524019218981266, 0.05333907902240753, -0.006329340860247612, 0.031283311545848846, -0.05465264245867729, -0.007988423109054565, 0.033677082508802414, -0.010852486826479435, -0.059907130897045135, -0.02400672435760498, 0.06220513582229614, -0.005038381088525057, -0.04558302089571953, -0.03532889485359192, -0.01283561997115612, -0.004145234357565641, -0.034787122160196304, -0.012797312811017036, -0.058007363229990005, 0.07152829319238663, 0.01603017933666706, -0.018915578722953796, 0.0450604148209095, -0.059640415012836456, -0.030221236869692802, -0.03634060546755791, -0.04032079875469208, 0.011282982304692268, 0.10959530621767044, 0.09692081063985825, -0.0001477995829191059, -0.021556220948696136, 0.033260926604270935, -0.022480906918644905, 0.0020451496820896864, -0.03449518606066704, 0.03283167630434036, -0.07339005917310715, 0.04114087298512459, 0.06141321733593941, 0.01926221325993538, 0.0022113421000540257, 0.030918719246983528, -0.032743413001298904, 0.04305736720561981, 0.015258615836501122, -0.03495372086763382, -0.004434545058757067, -0.011725641787052155, 0.007147261407226324, 0.04310820251703262, -0.04862973839044571, 0.056279078125953674, 0.021169906482100487, -0.0822107344865799, 0.03857024759054184, 0.010617474094033241, 0.023290256038308144, -0.05790448561310768, -0.011726529337465763, 0.00022649265883956105, 0.0614623986184597, 0.014002280309796333, -0.03694866597652435, 0.05401594191789627, 0.03696621209383011, -0.033087100833654404, 0.013909564353525639, -0.042775142937898636, -0.04335698112845421, -0.0492553673684597, 0.0006112369592301548, -0.03262034058570862, 0.036860622465610504, -0.04509161040186882, 0.006573561578989029, 0.027349961921572685, -0.03410680964589119, 0.036763373762369156, 0.05541612580418587, 0.08824066072702408, -0.039989542216062546, 0.01135167945176363, -0.038379549980163574, -0.018458882346749306, 0.027447903528809547, -0.006396259646862745, -0.0065793488174676895, -0.01833988167345524, 0.013779825530946255, 0.04375359043478966, 0.06421131640672684, -0.007826169021427631, 0.08254668861627579, -0.046265967190265656, -0.011666083708405495, -0.036715395748615265, 0.024564597755670547, 0.002988974330946803, 0.012492097914218903, -0.07871628552675247, 0.04955407977104187, -0.018850404769182205, -0.025156386196613312, 0.007285526022315025, -0.009352883324027061, 0.020940590649843216, -0.0475681908428669, 0.05814443901181221, 0.027203528210520744, 0.002088929759338498, -0.010042019188404083, 0.04906650260090828, -0.011194632388651371, -0.005919417832046747, 0.001652050414122641, 0.03222281485795975, 0.033580441027879715, 0.09860970824956894, -0.018977737054228783, 0.030557138845324516, 0.0381229929625988, 0.003889314364641905, -0.02030404470860958, 0.044780973345041275, 0.020362308248877525, -0.047614868730306625, -0.02907295897603035, 0.008878770284354687, -0.05857216939330101, 0.004292621742933989, 0.006774163339287043, -0.006840735208243132, 0.020312918350100517, 0.02290084771811962, 0.012290578335523605, -0.023766687139868736, -0.0382857471704483, 0.033151403069496155, -0.011828739196062088, -0.006691679824143648, 0.026913989335298538, -0.04125945270061493, -0.022027138620615005, -0.02631460130214691, 0.045654140412807465, -0.022565506398677826, -0.05291649326682091, 0.028532540425658226, -0.0063703288324177265, -0.02903791330754757, 0.009021006524562836, 0.04908027499914169, 0.021776575595140457, 0.03544295206665993, -0.003760738531127572, -0.013346179388463497, 0.06346779316663742, 0.033652763813734055, 0.049541231244802475, 0.04912842810153961, -0.07848647236824036, -0.014273937791585922, 0.002244561677798629, 0.0801086351275444, -0.001271805725991726, 0.03240443766117096, 0.054136283695697784, 0.04395464062690735, -0.038024768233299255, -0.02180374786257744, -0.051814403384923935, 0.03518136590719223, 0.012945826165378094, 0.013441978953778744, 0.026460042223334312, 0.011865787208080292, -0.0010278631234541535, -0.0356299914419651, -0.04431312531232834, 0.00005871427492820658, 0.013272236101329327, 0.04224758222699165, -0.0069331335835158825, -0.0458902008831501, -0.04713102802634239, -0.016048215329647064, 0.009568046778440475, -0.02988489344716072, -0.005377049092203379, -0.00019542814698070288, 0.023651935160160065, 0.03209921345114708, 0.02357766404747963, 0.018317166715860367, 0.04372604563832283, 0.015159353613853455, -0.027734657749533653, -0.011718250811100006, 0.018114620819687843, -0.007921122014522552, -0.001823939266614616, -0.030883098021149635, -0.03520738333463669, 0.017384402453899384, 0.002219089539721608, -0.009898809716105461, 0.04909471422433853, 0.043638717383146286, 0.025861084461212158, -0.030885791406035423, 0.05033095180988312, 0.024548102170228958, -0.005202658008784056, -0.001797789940610528, -0.02128640003502369, -0.04110805317759514, 0.023205310106277466, 0.04650482162833214, 0.06035929173231125, 0.03151985630393028, 0.0055868057534098625, -0.06324182450771332, 0.008261437527835369, -0.061208534985780716, -0.008388351649045944, 0.06424040347337723, -0.023547634482383728, 0.00904998742043972, -0.016354097053408623, 0.012974359095096588, -0.05492076277732849, -0.0005791457952000201, 0.025709785521030426, -0.048861805349588394, -0.030388034880161285, 0.007082683499902487, 0.026909224689006805, 0.07384195178747177, 0.06211856007575989, -0.022396065294742584, -0.011304538697004318, 0.039455611258745193, -0.056638095527887344, 0.015536687336862087, -0.02346091717481613, 0.01303156279027462, 0.022129369899630547, 0.0072421482764184475, 0.009337576106190681, -0.06640326231718063, 0.018376335501670837, -0.038935769349336624, -0.04538295790553093, -0.03894827887415886, 0.026919061318039894, 0.01869533769786358, 0.0012339394306764007, 0.005943813361227512, -0.03389821946620941, -0.02319498173892498, 0.003017525188624859, 0.07070532441139221, 0.011493915691971779, 0.019424045458436012, 0.011157597415149212, 0.02111033909022808, -0.03284168988466263, 0.022122031077742577, 0.021378079429268837, -0.02026919648051262, -0.06248288229107857, -0.038105618208646774, -0.015311571769416332, -0.020962083712220192, -0.037589676678180695, -0.001169552095234394, -0.016433753073215485, 0.017664669081568718, 0.0651806890964508, -0.026261674240231514, 0.018705695867538452, -0.04595768824219704, 0.060427308082580566, 0.03439275920391083, 0.02430347353219986, 0.008522299118340015, -0.03708983212709427, 0.0071292053908109665, -0.0106660770252347, 0.0916987955570221, 0.02496395632624626, 0.061618685722351074, 0.018724020570516586, -0.023403367027640343, -0.008581634610891342, 0.06520349532365799, 0.03704080730676651, 0.0354544073343277, 0.006940022576600313, 0.004879910498857498, -0.034822236746549606, 0.028910856693983078, -0.004365263041108847, -0.026743358001112938, -0.06250407546758652, 0.0005441468092612922, -0.0024587896186858416, 0.001698023290373385, -0.002568183932453394, 0.02088368870317936, -0.019995540380477905, -0.010437609627842903, -0.0034365709871053696, -0.024040881544351578, -0.030253639444708824, 0.07660570740699768, -0.021777676418423653, -0.052424948662519455, -0.03605189174413681, -0.06330090761184692, 0.04570939019322395, -0.09039467573165894, 0.046226564794778824, 0.03554762154817581, 0.04196615144610405, -0.020014610141515732, 0.02820625901222229, 0.004139295779168606, -0.02571973204612732, 0.03114708699285984, -0.0016134480247274041, -0.02899341471493244, -0.06813443452119827, -0.003019989002496004, -0.013653473928570747, 0.007362789940088987, -0.008846914395689964, -0.05220424383878708, 0.039455607533454895, 0.03118973784148693, -0.014173741452395916, -0.04918069392442703, 0.0018578567542135715, -0.07727500051259995, 0.024499228224158287, -0.036946117877960205, 0.012836646288633347, -0.04606116935610771, 0.0005569892236962914, 0.003293218556791544, -0.05021313205361366, -0.004692356567829847, -0.018782690167427063, 0.03970479965209961, 0.06428667902946472, 0.058279071003198624, 0.022984914481639862, -0.0191904716193676, -0.038566574454307556, -0.008843304589390755, -0.006074466276913881, -0.022366302087903023, -0.025183705613017082, -0.002608055714517832, -0.024762775748968124, -0.021527037024497986, -0.053887709975242615, -0.009510883130133152, -0.01130493450909853, 0.02187383733689785, 0.025982219725847244, 0.06947427988052368, -0.011858820915222168, -0.02981499582529068, -0.00013806586503051221, -0.00498075969517231, -0.07413668185472488, -0.023331915959715843, 0.060207776725292206, 0.052297066897153854, -0.008689753711223602, 0.01186971366405487, 0.03281219303607941, 0.015500635839998722, -0.034191492944955826, -0.03335542231798172, 0.037165071815252304, 0.06616219133138657, -0.04651957377791405, 0.0842001736164093, 0.04292105510830879, -0.008774465881288052, -0.02838313579559326, 0.033428702503442764, -0.0034639197401702404, -0.0229170098900795, 0.025157302618026733, 0.07621654123067856, 0.02464362606406212, 0.05260208249092102, 0.02579563856124878, 0.008004993200302124, -0.00876525416970253, 0.038396961987018585, -0.026625581085681915, -0.017747724428772926, -0.013712041079998016, -0.025731127709150314, -0.08157360553741455, -0.03524982929229736, -0.02127327397465706, -0.01137800607830286, 0.01486685685813427, -0.0394064225256443, 0.05502358078956604, 0.07643366605043411, -0.049936793744564056, 0.04912428557872772, -0.0080678416416049, -0.020093441009521484, -0.018189992755651474, -0.003938308916985989, -0.014765731990337372, 0.0312659852206707, -0.05686112120747566, -0.03604903072118759, -0.029280779883265495, 0.036305226385593414, -0.040317993611097336, -0.02481922321021557, 0.0018450487405061722, 0.004985431209206581, 0.01796114630997181, 0.0313863642513752, -0.02768600545823574, 0.05359766259789467, 0.05544764921069145, -0.006362064275890589, 0.029750024899840355, -0.04512456804513931, 0.07029103487730026, -0.014795491471886635, -0.021835515275597572, -0.0758742019534111, -0.048982858657836914, -0.01528704073280096, -0.0003700941160786897, -0.04277390241622925, 0.004653655458241701, 0.018740564584732056, -0.020678235217928886, -0.06002608314156532, 0.004627498798072338, 0.04333505779504776, -0.0026756953448057175, -0.004524642135947943, -0.04098575934767723, -0.016988281160593033, 0.007342025637626648, -0.04785522073507309, -0.0352642796933651, -0.0010162327671423554, 0.009339334443211555, 0.007335354574024677, 0.021461233496665955, 0.00031034694984555244, 0.003967607393860817, -0.037613194435834885, -0.0020126886665821075, 0.007983154617249966, -0.013557115569710732, -0.004051525611430407, 0.02520369179546833, 0.0004914514720439911, 0.02602897584438324, -0.0465162955224514, 0.0434110164642334, -0.006294732913374901, 0.027365656569600105, -0.028099384158849716, 0.09110130369663239, -0.016430703923106194, -0.01261513028293848, 0.032101329416036606, -0.0012188449036329985, -0.010385196655988693, 0.011896603740751743, -0.018420575186610222, -0.02506282553076744, -0.0023326741065829992, -0.020855003967881203, 0.006375032942742109, 0.006234381813555956, 0.044669341295957565, -0.01774457097053528, 0.011871379800140858, 0.026765190064907074, -0.027096396312117577, 0.01847940869629383, 0.006039964035153389, -0.05776175856590271, -0.002236774889752269, 0.007671996019780636, -0.030787723138928413, 0.02374890446662903, 0.08211808651685715, -0.05511161684989929, -0.015875406563282013, -0.010319766588509083, 0.03161371499300003, 0.04107113927602768, -0.009795435704290867, 0.04481619596481323, -0.06879962235689163, 0.0421522818505764, -0.02569730579853058, -0.05131024494767189, 0.005260738078504801, -0.004265971947461367, -0.02925581857562065, -0.018713166937232018, -0.04395250603556633, -0.0587150901556015, 0.010953412391245365, 0.007593235466629267, 0.051817700266838074, -0.07109871506690979, 0.022582968696951866, -0.022836431860923767, -0.040332477539777756, -0.030486522242426872, 0.05996248498558998, -0.051558345556259155, -0.03419870883226395, 0.0062101781368255615, -0.038974303752183914, 0.003482196945697069, 0.0156314168125391, 0.027569333091378212, 0.009921866469085217, 0.016658339649438858, -0.02686295099556446, 0.048967037349939346, 0.04050404205918312, -0.008098919875919819, 0.01828150264918804, 0.012054034508764744, 0.050287775695323944, -0.06843475252389908, 0.012800357304513454, -0.04688771814107895, -0.01790771074593067, -0.07087713479995728, -0.025736812502145767, -0.06826524436473846, -0.06616243720054626, 0.056230299174785614, -0.00558741670101881, -0.01114957220852375, -0.03477242961525917 ]
<p>Hey guys I really need help on this problem.</p> <blockquote> <p>A ceramic slab of dimentions 5cm x 10 cm x .25 cm has to be heated to $177\,^{\circ}{\rm C}$. The ceramic slab travels on a conveyor belt traveling at $.1 \frac{m}{s}$. The slab is initially at a temperature of $18\,^{\circ}{\rm C}$ when it enters a radiant heater on the conveyor belt. The heater surrounds the whole slab and emits heat as a black body at $1000\,^{\circ}{\rm C}$. Since the heat surrounds the slab, all the energy that leaves the heater is absorbed by the slab. The slab has an emissivity of .85. Find the amount of time it takes to heat the slab to $177\,^{\circ}{\rm C}$. The slab has properties $c_{p}=1500\frac{J}{Kg K}$ and $\rho=900\frac{kg}{m^{3}}$ and $k=1 \frac{W}{mK}$</p> </blockquote> <p>I started off by creating an energy balance on the slab as it's in the heater. I assumed convection that is caused by the conveyor belt traveling at such a slow speed to be insignificant to all calculations. $$\dot{E}_{in}- \dot{E}_{out}+\dot{E}_{g}=\dot{E}_{st}$$ $$A\alpha\sigma T^{4}_{heater}-A\epsilon\sigma T^{4}=\rho c_{p}V\frac{dT}{dt}$$ $$A\sigma(T^{4}_{heater}-\epsilon T^{4})=\rho c_{p}V \frac{dT}{dt}$$</p> <p>I then plugged in the values and got: $$44.185-1.428x10^{-11} T^{4}=\frac{dT}{dt}$$</p> <p>I realized that this comes out to be a VERY nasty integral so I tried to use matlab and numerically integrate it using Euler's method. My graph for that came out to be linear which I knew was not right and I came here straight away to figure out what I was doing wrong</p>
g6601
[ 0.06010657921433449, 0.07616796344518661, 0.012125416658818722, -0.023468080908060074, 0.03863311558961868, -0.0428815558552742, 0.052857644855976105, 0.012194096110761166, -0.07930802553892136, 0.04063906520605087, -0.06900890916585922, 0.07920035719871521, 0.025654027238488197, 0.03397586941719055, 0.045781273394823074, -0.016108714044094086, 0.05261962115764618, 0.019328705966472626, 0.008174278773367405, 0.07413025200366974, 0.015904612839221954, 0.00003503758125589229, -0.002641805913299322, -0.08483567833900452, 0.03319503739476204, -0.007100317161530256, 0.0025389923248440027, 0.018170978873968124, -0.006490885280072689, 0.019359618425369263, -0.02332391031086445, 0.04980025812983513, 0.010338926687836647, -0.01013621874153614, -0.07520212978124619, -0.00612495094537735, 0.024137722328305244, 0.004300800152122974, 0.005369042512029409, -0.03290293365716934, -0.02049826830625534, -0.033015668392181396, 0.02330872043967247, 0.06386607885360718, 0.037837352603673935, 0.024194350466132164, -0.02185162715613842, 0.006089686881750822, -0.04629804939031601, 0.027001122012734413, -0.02873692288994789, -0.013868758454918861, 0.07995093613862991, -0.01042797788977623, -0.027557045221328735, 0.04234999418258667, -0.03171120584011078, -0.05176800116896629, 0.017857594415545464, 0.032804884016513824, -0.008613839745521545, -0.026372285559773445, -0.0325886607170105, -0.03797148913145065, 0.011147445067763329, -0.003288229228928685, -0.029262447729706764, -0.007933376356959343, 0.028537653386592865, -0.004587825387716293, 0.03674958646297455, 0.008891196921467781, 0.03753677010536194, -0.03388933464884758, -0.04466618597507477, -0.01222281251102686, -0.008230465464293957, -0.03315451368689537, 0.039034824818372726, -0.005680319387465715, -0.07573831081390381, 0.00644470751285553, -0.005843851715326309, 0.06568184494972229, -0.028038686141371727, 0.009218894876539707, -0.03443961217999458, -0.014637516811490059, -0.08169831335544586, -0.03801361098885536, -0.005371733568608761, -0.039943501353263855, -0.013156875036656857, 0.04129460081458092, 0.027407269924879074, 0.008295352570712566, -0.060392607003450394, 0.05253987014293671, -0.01467812992632389, -0.0536554716527462, 0.054645851254463196, 0.001129397191107273, -0.00526511762291193, 0.001140673877671361, -0.03425661101937294, 0.017776668071746826, 0.005792075768113136, -0.009878488257527351, -0.0058017512783408165, 0.012284721247851849, 0.06471680849790573, -0.11676796525716782, -0.044456589967012405, -0.09428912401199341, 0.004359637852758169, 0.018823515623807907, 0.007735783234238625, -0.032891299575567245, -0.010403771884739399, 0.024624982848763466, 0.005246342159807682, 0.047275714576244354, 0.03305418789386749, -0.0118438471108675, 0.02716263383626938, -0.02350347489118576, 0.027832694351673126, -0.01771194115281105, 0.03466292843222618, -0.004258938133716583, -0.01728985086083412, 0.014630855061113834, 0.01987195387482643, 0.04083127900958061, -0.0222440417855978, 0.057245537638664246, -0.02367100492119789, 0.04950716346502304, -0.01696051098406315, -0.001368233934044838, 0.009499671868979931, -0.0634298175573349, 0.029592188075184822, -0.002441499847918749, -0.017209526151418686, 0.05949355661869049, -0.06693275272846222, -0.07188335806131363, 0.0847918912768364, -0.04031083360314369, -0.002227499382570386, 0.08944538235664368, -0.008879401721060276, 0.01255644578486681, 0.026749474927783012, 0.02742936462163925, 0.06426388770341873, 0.00868984404951334, 0.02626180835068226, -0.052071407437324524, 0.0354364737868309, 0.045328665524721146, 0.036695387214422226, -0.02297668345272541, -0.031585827469825745, 0.022745080292224884, -0.01473737321794033, -0.051362045109272, 0.017042377963662148, -0.031785748898983, -0.006888692267239094, -0.05726495385169983, 0.019800201058387756, 0.022104008123278618, -0.04056878387928009, 0.01971380226314068, 0.06494247168302536, 0.0498470813035965, 0.020456887781620026, 0.004655321594327688, 0.052618835121393204, -0.019624430686235428, 0.024573925882577896, -0.007065369747579098, 0.022330954670906067, -0.005145907402038574, 0.01546237338334322, 0.011560735292732716, -0.01026518177241087, -0.020938215777277946, 0.010417585261166096, 0.0019863934721797705, 0.011480099521577358, 0.06977059692144394, -0.01611221954226494, -0.02822166681289673, 0.03288847580552101, -0.047010548412799835, -0.06945224851369858, -0.09253976494073868, 0.07335710525512695, 0.03783884271979332, 0.10661879926919937, 0.03416777774691582, 0.039830274879932404, -0.03919961676001549, -0.00487464340403676, -0.00022665690630674362, -0.01679513044655323, 0.036846693605184555, -0.01471039280295372, -0.026298845186829567, -0.031186405569314957, 0.050790902227163315, 0.0374370813369751, -0.016608187928795815, -0.015773015096783638, 0.01816701702773571, 0.024276647716760635, -0.0064898026175796986, -0.021079519763588905, 0.010091191157698631, 0.019989896565675735, -0.01637425646185875, -0.028154602274298668, -0.00008517793321516365, -0.024163302034139633, -0.035925380885601044, -0.03381611406803131, 0.014177362434566021, -0.08412584662437439, 0.04020432382822037, 0.02774707041680813, -0.05515958368778229, 0.03122456558048725, -0.048937540501356125, -0.014282789081335068, 0.023062990978360176, -0.007673040498048067, 0.01740996539592743, 0.01473408006131649, 0.01623520255088806, -0.027197351679205894, -0.07265141606330872, 0.0043304357677698135, -0.005694493651390076, 0.049552954733371735, 0.0076341209933161736, 0.01569126546382904, -0.013414888642728329, -0.012367142364382744, -0.020012425258755684, -0.047552019357681274, 0.007780320011079311, 0.028922542929649353, 0.005419174209237099, -0.05422687530517578, -0.01554570160806179, 0.000001275825979973888, -0.007750357501208782, -0.04557851701974869, -0.05531084164977074, 0.011909067630767822, -0.007807809393852949, -0.04151077941060066, 0.02899736724793911, -0.04825340211391449, -0.05962926149368286, 0.013114606030285358, 0.012679863721132278, 0.0301213301718235, 0.027265548706054688, 0.053515076637268066, 0.013490592129528522, 0.041215937584638596, 0.026963988319039345, 0.04450196772813797, -0.018802324309945107, -0.04710124805569649, -0.0093311732634902, 0.0535820871591568, -0.04368334263563156, -0.025662291795015335, -0.029024789109826088, 0.014871662482619286, -0.055793389678001404, -0.005869852378964424, 0.012651520781219006, -0.01724705658853054, -0.02512022852897644, -0.006393431685864925, -0.018228106200695038, -0.024247193709015846, 0.041561227291822433, 0.0006480849115177989, 0.022473178803920746, 0.06045880168676376, -0.02925722301006317, -0.004678879864513874, -0.028713691979646683, 0.05236959084868431, -0.025090446695685387, -0.06047746539115906, -0.01242807973176241, -0.042169298976659775, -0.005350994411855936, 0.004528595134615898, -0.08760412782430649, 0.02076965756714344, -0.003217324148863554, 0.026903145015239716, -0.03071833960711956, -0.01952829770743847, -0.045850805938243866, -0.00880521535873413, 0.002830595476552844, -0.013681466691195965, 0.007752136792987585, 0.038918182253837585, 0.003270896151661873, 0.0145052345469594, -0.009830431081354618, -0.008367088623344898, -0.0291628185659647, -0.016005394980311394, -0.003926924895495176, 0.012152566574513912, -0.020122742280364037, -0.017096037045121193, -0.02313569374382496, -0.06337238103151321, 0.010792192071676254, 0.013802943751215935, -0.04542681947350502, -0.07052582502365112, -0.04399118199944496, -0.03479352220892906, 0.03543704375624657, 0.014355739578604698, 0.043282244354486465, -0.08980834484100342, -0.03527085855603218, -0.031896594911813736, -0.011666135862469673, 0.026476260274648666, -0.014910165220499039, -0.018501870334148407, -0.016125474125146866, -0.0030746161937713623, 0.02815374918282032, 0.0603519082069397, 0.011710246093571186, -0.0050878445617854595, -0.01738494262099266, -0.009654298424720764, 0.03261744976043701, 0.04191698506474495, 0.05038034915924072, 0.015438804402947426, -0.005613239016383886, 0.004215870518237352, 0.03031770884990692, 0.05090169236063957, 0.003936318214982748, 0.001737439539283514, 0.022531120106577873, -0.030020590871572495, 0.021113399416208267, 0.015006677247583866, 0.03900214284658432, -0.024449214339256287, -0.030504951253533363, -0.028553972020745277, 0.03327621519565582, 0.03250477463006973, -0.005568316671997309, -0.026876457035541534, 0.02563684619963169, 0.0012128803646191955, 0.02600293979048729, -0.05079721659421921, 0.0025124105159193277, -0.02166999690234661, -0.02270301803946495, 0.021506574004888535, 0.07749118655920029, 0.022606922313570976, 0.0009878871496766806, 0.024539822712540627, -0.06264519691467285, 0.0640818178653717, -0.026510639116168022, -0.04456513375043869, -0.013856791891157627, 0.04110468551516533, -0.0359809473156929, 0.05836549773812294, 0.032787468284368515, -0.025827575474977493, 0.016419721767306328, 0.058311887085437775, -0.020353946834802628, 0.050158388912677765, 0.012255185283720493, -0.059992432594299316, -0.02609987184405327, 0.0291764996945858, -0.013014387339353561, 0.06627418845891953, -0.0031335295643657446, -0.07869850099086761, -0.027572117745876312, 0.007587766740471125, -0.031062396243214607, 0.09606894850730896, -0.05399702861905098, 0.019581913948059082, 0.009718136861920357, 0.01722368225455284, -0.029923202469944954, -0.054573122411966324, 0.02961188554763794, -0.05595625191926956, -0.006781386211514473, 0.050519295036792755, 0.01328093558549881, 0.05288218334317207, -0.033682819455862045, -0.004284883849322796, 0.037936531007289886, -0.039478376507759094, 0.0054704840295016766, -0.06425777822732925, 0.041086722165346146, -0.059961624443531036, 0.05003206431865692, 0.02895577996969223, -0.014978391118347645, 0.01451610866934061, 0.07272685319185257, -0.03551759570837021, -0.06211724132299423, -0.03148644044995308, -0.0008093048818409443, 0.028469307348132133, 0.016110319644212723, -0.05302850157022476, -0.13897539675235748, -0.0006571693229489028, 0.0038351230323314667, 0.052834633737802505, 0.007535383105278015, -0.019102632999420166, 0.02018354833126068, 0.005967221222817898, 0.012996695935726166, -0.029874609783291817, 0.016560811549425125, 0.10379137098789215, 0.04263785853981972, 0.03497622534632683, 0.055351704359054565, -0.01703159138560295, -0.00694021163508296, -0.030444178730249405, -0.04089374840259552, 0.014452017843723297, 0.10109559446573257, 0.02436675876379013, -0.02286895550787449, 0.004014627542346716, 0.026665573939681053, -0.0029248162172734737, 0.04162674769759178, -0.011414877139031887, -0.012811725027859211, -0.012378615327179432, -0.0053816381841897964, 0.02607535757124424, -0.019796481356024742, -0.0023564505390822887, -0.0003398476110305637, 0.041315708309412, 0.050626564770936966, 0.031101083382964134, 0.017825014889240265, -0.04562040790915489, 0.03103698045015335, 0.04241166263818741, -0.00030276618781499565, 0.006860402412712574, 0.009444786235690117, -0.03989341855049133, -0.04969511926174164, -0.016933005303144455, -0.0071488660760223866, 0.04020779952406883, -0.010870018042623997, -0.013347525149583817, 0.014085466973483562, 0.00048225861974060535, 0.022447913885116577, -0.04327870532870293, 0.008339998312294483, -0.008435217663645744, 0.03699179366230965, 0.06565133482217789, 0.04797070100903511, -0.0005496796220541, 0.0509282723069191, -0.04083333909511566, 0.04141415283083916, 0.045707572251558304, -0.08181807398796082, -0.04431336000561714, -0.055222369730472565, 0.01065238006412983, -0.06541656702756882, -0.02333918958902359, -0.04283616319298744, 0.025647182017564774, 0.030467398464679718, -0.006861700210720301, 0.007028429303318262, 0.05570462718605995, -0.004598561674356461, -0.04640758037567139, -0.035116057842969894, -0.012503506615757942, 0.015325367450714111, 0.0031886163633316755, -0.03206123411655426, -0.07160414755344391, 0.020082717761397362, -0.04339005798101425, 0.02331705391407013, -0.006478681694716215, -0.015079574659466743, 0.025997508317232132, -0.050701405853033066, 0.024438362568616867, -0.04520406946539879, -0.010817783884704113, 0.0011227732757106423, -0.01296162698417902, -0.026809921488165855, -0.030079500749707222, -0.008303362876176834, 0.025600941851735115, 0.010019523091614246, 0.03815116733312607, 0.0033241529017686844, 0.02790883742272854, -0.020540790632367134, 0.04529671370983124, 0.003830777248367667, 0.013680115342140198, -0.00775781087577343, -0.00855598971247673, -0.009382032789289951, 0.030147477984428406, 0.013216729275882244, -0.012388166040182114, 0.0026768003590404987, -0.0033635743893682957, -0.006679078098386526, -0.042315587401390076, -0.013517441228032112, 0.023643553256988525, -0.010910764336585999, 0.043895117938518524, -0.02960147149860859, 0.0035470356233417988, 0.020903974771499634, 0.048554595559835434, 0.07291904836893082, -0.03374132141470909, -0.025523176416754723, -0.034734323620796204, 0.018838869407773018, -0.0021596974693238735, 0.03904671221971512, -0.013650137931108475, 0.04870087280869484, 0.019186604768037796, -0.007327658124268055, -0.06378535181283951, 0.00658572930842638, -0.04470103234052658, 0.010888497345149517, -0.026944763958454132, 0.03740797936916351, -0.03194153681397438, 0.021947944536805153, -0.023883787915110588, -0.0411301851272583, -0.0817171260714531, -0.004782755393534899, 0.005389946047216654, 0.03741302713751793, -0.02212676592171192, -0.022085966542363167, -0.028551828116178513, -0.022933505475521088, 0.006913560908287764, -0.03942865505814552, -0.01059374213218689, 0.01054013054817915, 0.0007314824615605175, 0.039954934269189835, 0.0566832534968853, 0.05918791890144348, 0.06406251341104507, -0.010264230892062187, 0.005683470517396927, 0.00103034358471632, 0.05101839825510979, 0.058068644255399704, 0.03443742170929909, -0.07291071116924286, 0.04072192311286926, 0.03881964087486267, -0.0004919696366414428, -0.040102388709783554, 0.051003701984882355, -0.011818901635706425, -0.08163797855377197, 0.0067862775176763535, 0.07761267572641373, 0.005418762564659119, 0.024738667532801628, -0.04118293151259422, 0.009583734907209873, -0.039675820618867874, 0.04077276960015297, -0.005793704651296139, -0.04083707928657532, 0.014656910672783852, -0.03073500283062458, 0.056435685604810715, -0.03223298862576485, -0.006860540248453617, -0.006467857863754034, 0.01976630836725235, -0.037437111139297485, 0.03658817335963249, 0.008541624993085861, 0.010726174339652061, -0.03307536616921425, -0.0025428161025047302, 0.030711451545357704, 0.0260926466435194, -0.022043367847800255, 0.009192134253680706, -0.05145353078842163, -0.06227893754839897, 0.04778679832816124, -0.009485521353781223, 0.0038563418202102184, 0.0068739959970116615, 0.012538731098175049, -0.08684571087360382, -0.02008218504488468, 0.027111314237117767, 0.04455850273370743, 0.03473212942481041, 0.01574304699897766, -0.0236371960490942, 0.011193218640983105, -0.08441516757011414, -0.0403747521340847, -0.015502702444791794, -0.055149637162685394, 0.035232800990343094, -0.002010645344853401, -0.010488765314221382, 0.042530614882707596, 0.005913637112826109, -0.005533332005143166, -0.017269257456064224, -0.052725907415151596, -0.009725382551550865, -0.005179110448807478, 0.024795176461338997, 0.056217506527900696, 0.008732030168175697, -0.01607116125524044, -0.07523947209119797, 0.040584102272987366, 0.043355148285627365, -0.006021806504577398, 0.041948165744543076, 0.02431071363389492, -0.03844552859663963, 0.02828982286155224, 0.03447885811328888, -0.04703529551625252, -0.02034224011003971, 0.014531455002725124, -0.007849594578146935, 0.004774956963956356, 0.004372659604996443, 0.039713870733976364, 0.0030794646590948105, -0.025353506207466125, 0.02267349697649479, 0.013013106770813465, 0.017471803352236748, -0.002777062589302659, 0.016145486384630203, 0.045860473066568375, 0.012333015911281109, -0.027181297540664673, -0.002294400008395314, 0.003134685568511486, 0.015019954182207584, -0.04875006526708603, 0.013548069633543491, 0.03125922381877899, -0.01763538457453251, -0.028246968984603882, 0.012377155013382435, -0.027491571381688118, -0.07346998900175095, 0.04918042942881584, -0.035338420420885086, -0.05442246049642563, -0.01295615453273058, 0.04022330790758133, 0.03500847890973091, 0.013895070180296898, 0.050166722387075424, -0.03686915338039398, -0.011630689725279808, -0.025147704407572746, 0.030880166217684746, 0.03807539865374565, -0.01342590618878603, 0.07045239210128784, 0.02967114932835102, 0.011764814145863056, -0.028971964493393898, -0.03248732537031174, 0.03616628795862198, -0.02965291403234005, -0.013830003328621387, -0.08324073255062103, 0.01000283844769001, 0.024542242288589478, -0.010640890337526798, 0.029286624863743782, -0.03683382272720337, -0.06479010730981827, -0.04742765426635742, -0.014787280932068825, -0.004818664398044348, -0.021553080528974533, -0.020098969340324402, 0.01907321624457836, -0.0074054161086678505, -0.013545648194849491, -0.02075311355292797, -0.02931777387857437, 0.017939886078238487, 0.08131315559148788, 0.019606923684477806, 0.048628054559230804, -0.06517548114061356 ]
<p>Reading about plasmonic nanoparticles I faced the term "localised light".</p> <p>How can one localise light? What are applications of it?</p>
g6602
[ 0.0552387461066246, -0.011279604397714138, 0.0009552729316055775, -0.049712494015693665, 0.017715727910399437, 0.035821910947561264, 0.010698208585381508, 0.013055150397121906, 0.024102086201310158, -0.011028088629245758, 0.024361371994018555, 0.002297478262335062, 0.03018847480416298, -0.00637641828507185, -0.07577428966760635, 0.004803491290658712, 0.09695557504892349, 0.05611910670995712, 0.05681316554546356, 0.0006242684903554618, -0.005736179184168577, -0.007063813973218203, 0.021566860377788544, -0.03299339488148689, -0.062184982001781464, 0.022999053820967674, -0.02761959098279476, -0.016970882192254066, -0.003301285207271576, -0.03363441303372383, 0.04650292545557022, -0.08251640945672989, 0.022325729951262474, -0.05054958909749985, 0.03836739435791969, -0.034573666751384735, -0.01978708617389202, 0.013673857785761356, -0.03028721548616886, 0.06132517382502556, 0.00887375045567751, 0.017408113926649094, -0.0037039197050035, 0.000056624248827574775, -0.0026856500189751387, 0.019662603735923767, -0.011914994567632675, -0.0368194542825222, -0.014363930560648441, -0.07123853266239166, 0.03315215930342674, -0.010255546309053898, 0.047983285039663315, 0.02973397821187973, 0.11551813036203384, -0.03120080940425396, 0.017365923151373863, -0.032696761190891266, 0.08062387257814407, -0.0007661252748221159, 0.08554769307374954, 0.026084868237376213, 0.016745731234550476, 0.030854040756821632, -0.0010985697153955698, -0.06316683441400528, 0.00010938546620309353, 0.010907698422670364, 0.03985285386443138, -0.038927119225263596, 0.006656347308307886, -0.029022997245192528, 0.007085732650011778, -0.01941836252808571, -0.03265393152832985, -0.030664604157209396, -0.005669090896844864, 0.03623506799340248, -0.030482841655611992, 0.002199000446125865, -0.0035737312864512205, -0.01815073750913143, -0.03094562143087387, -0.03129647299647331, 0.03138142079114914, 0.010493953712284565, -0.04706104099750519, -0.04636865854263306, 0.01940036006271839, -0.031331416219472885, 0.05306296795606613, 0.04515784606337547, 0.05734524875879288, -0.0028285402804613113, -0.01909351348876953, -0.03601120039820671, 0.04305190220475197, -0.018484361469745636, -0.026531053707003593, -0.01931760646402836, -0.05133576691150665, 0.0006257024360820651, -0.030469294637441635, 0.0191657692193985, 0.007591043133288622, 0.03628108650445938, 0.024944525212049484, 0.0008991278009489179, 0.007027999963611364, -0.012842901982367039, 0.01694095879793167, -0.061999425292015076, -0.04743830859661102, -0.03164564073085785, -0.0707152783870697, -0.005437618121504784, 0.07137398421764374, -0.020725684240460396, 0.022178729996085167, 0.046300556510686874, 0.06597785651683807, 0.06643452495336533, 0.05286285653710365, 0.026391014456748962, 0.009517168626189232, -0.03028913401067257, -0.016512632369995117, -0.020586185157299042, -0.04069496691226959, -0.05781705304980278, 0.01958787441253662, -0.0002146062470274046, -0.04887216165661812, -0.023004349321126938, -0.028638390824198723, 0.05184779316186905, 0.0560617633163929, -0.05749601870775223, 0.02122475765645504, 0.030587101355195045, 0.027755029499530792, -0.04458046704530716, 0.02024400606751442, -0.0073359874077141285, -0.014169889502227306, -0.001692329184152186, -0.035050828009843826, 0.029236719012260437, 0.009216686710715294, 0.031906433403491974, 0.021497558802366257, 0.0521591454744339, -0.0004820187168661505, -0.08306001871824265, 0.04878859221935272, -0.03228039667010307, 0.06485164165496826, -0.0044627259485423565, -0.009015644900500774, 0.016383890062570572, 0.03988988324999809, -0.018179049715399742, -0.04234853759407997, 0.003914593253284693, -0.04309249669313431, 0.0031657216604799032, 0.03547956421971321, -0.06798020750284195, 0.002096418756991625, -0.09016851335763931, 0.01708921231329441, 0.02397504448890686, -0.07264388352632523, 0.009970363229513168, 0.012397321872413158, 0.04048359766602516, 0.0016769551439210773, -0.03928326815366745, -0.044266000390052795, -0.007959879003465176, 0.0027231338899582624, -0.08531318604946136, -0.015990063548088074, 0.011776929721236229, -0.039936941117048264, 0.011086168698966503, -0.005563055630773306, -0.042655784636735916, 0.053140003234148026, 0.02300138585269451, -0.08283314108848572, 0.020348496735095978, 0.04547728970646858, -0.012549239210784435, -0.027074817568063736, -0.04118071869015694, -0.026138154789805412, -0.0741565153002739, -0.009003465063869953, 0.05099048838019371, -0.036203257739543915, 0.04862580820918083, 0.006086430512368679, 0.028016844764351845, 0.09024115651845932, -0.04599165916442871, -0.019287051633000374, -0.04795585200190544, 0.0280682984739542, 0.02937059849500656, 0.05456213653087616, -0.031393539160490036, 0.041314538568258286, 0.01425275020301342, -0.022446950897574425, 0.014461832121014595, -0.014223896898329258, -0.00521007040515542, 0.031779274344444275, -0.01654193177819252, -0.0003365726734045893, 0.04391651973128319, 0.00015763765259180218, -0.006189997773617506, 0.004883367568254471, 0.05807633325457573, -0.044525615870952606, 0.04206621274352074, 0.02414042130112648, 0.042326074093580246, -0.040730785578489304, -0.07109847664833069, 0.0025478582829236984, -0.013033073395490646, 0.04625313729047775, 0.008701765909790993, -0.04845152050256729, -0.025942163541913033, -0.036845430731773376, 0.06971874833106995, 0.01775011420249939, 0.005897079594433308, 0.02011917345225811, -0.004528334829956293, -0.0400761179625988, 0.0012940731830894947, 0.05516476556658745, -0.03244705870747566, -0.05454631894826889, 0.0737975463271141, 0.05851981043815613, -0.033019058406353, 0.06424428522586823, -0.005419921595603228, 0.02627726085484028, -0.025251593440771103, 0.0014046545838937163, 0.07448049634695053, 0.022554127499461174, 0.007494345773011446, 0.03893599286675453, -0.004603667184710503, -0.04586899280548096, -0.012907705269753933, 0.029823170974850655, 0.0061009544879198074, -0.006739395204931498, 0.04854962229728699, 0.0009173998259939253, 0.006153724156320095, -0.0034880463499575853, 0.029407180845737457, -0.0025692435447126627, -0.03739519417285919, 0.055758826434612274, 0.006066861562430859, 0.01819552481174469, 0.029208816587924957, 0.04830819368362427, 0.006452468689531088, 0.04525398835539818, 0.051515355706214905, -0.058696992695331573, -0.08271421492099762, 0.016937335953116417, -0.04476768150925636, -0.01573253981769085, 0.020099906250834465, 0.046896565705537796, -0.08426142483949661, -0.003508199704810977, -0.044073671102523804, 0.02729247882962227, -0.038196317851543427, 0.016235526651144028, -0.025248559191823006, 0.04773249104619026, 0.03176487982273102, 0.03697836771607399, 0.06183497980237007, 0.01973290927708149, -0.00014128508337307721, 0.025370720773935318, -0.0015699604991823435, 0.026872985064983368, 0.02789444290101528, -0.03055253066122532, -0.008699370548129082, 0.0075835054740309715, 0.008325193077325821, 0.04906557500362396, 0.029795901849865913, -0.0060905106365680695, 0.022666100412607193, -0.001719595747999847, 0.0016214223578572273, 0.014945358969271183, 0.01507885567843914, 0.05994759872555733, 0.012272215448319912, 0.017194686457514763, -0.031235547736287117, 0.017179176211357117, -0.01304787490516901, 0.055554214864969254, -0.04012564942240715, 0.02348228171467781, 0.0009616676834411919, -0.002137821866199374, -0.009685236029326916, 0.007316600531339645, -0.005455577280372381, -0.04841219633817673, -0.06222079321742058, -0.025440016761422157, -0.07516247779130936, -0.01701284572482109, 0.05593924969434738, 0.037599168717861176, -0.023675335571169853, 0.039836518466472626, -0.007425953634083271, -0.03473842144012451, -0.0030086322221904993, 0.02715217135846615, 0.0031963454093784094, -0.03411852568387985, 0.00485950568690896, -0.02264864556491375, 0.01892692781984806, -0.0035159538965672255, 0.04010508954524994, -0.018721401691436768, -0.04951228201389313, 0.0014552605571225286, 0.002688594162464142, 0.015495959669351578, 0.036851685494184494, 0.08079609274864197, -0.0626540258526802, -0.00825986173003912, -0.0036888804752379656, 0.03499865531921387, -0.03641698881983757, -0.020117059350013733, -0.020529311150312424, 0.05495026335120201, -0.000755766814108938, -0.015625936910510063, -0.03190646693110466, -0.018198465928435326, -0.026571108028292656, -0.03478879854083061, -0.02427123486995697, -0.01856152154505253, -0.012451800517737865, -0.061384957283735275, -0.04185747355222702, -0.05040723457932472, -0.005664040334522724, -0.09332402795553207, 0.03255348652601242, 0.026130329817533493, 0.0032813793513923883, 0.01965855248272419, 0.034354839473962784, -0.0019266682211309671, -0.012421236373484135, 0.016151875257492065, -0.019349168986082077, -0.02826368808746338, -0.028450103476643562, -0.010058406740427017, -0.04906684532761574, -0.052363086491823196, -0.016544010490179062, -0.01669461652636528, 0.025599028915166855, 0.036295417696237564, 0.017687367275357246, -0.010787950828671455, -0.046992409974336624, 0.02255457080900669, -0.030205976217985153, -0.01775514706969261, -0.06422966718673706, 0.01640934683382511, -0.02509656362235546, 0.013997805304825306, -0.005026561673730612, 0.019246770069003105, 0.023032646626234055, 0.06921415776014328, -0.011406050063669682, 0.04916229844093323, 0.013215168379247189, 0.029727542772889137, -0.04032257944345474, -0.05115823820233345, 0.037416037172079086, -0.008064504712820053, 0.06223822385072708, 0.0031845038756728172, -0.0021794906351715326, -0.03366968035697937, 0.0725645199418068, -0.030338682234287262, 0.036378346383571625, 0.04391355440020561, -0.018583165481686592, -0.01845642179250717, -0.007457824423909187, 0.06810353696346283, 0.02946668677031994, -0.018757261335849762, -0.03088855743408203, 0.058174923062324524, -0.04405491054058075, 0.03189420700073242, 0.024688979610800743, 0.031632401049137115, 0.025316912680864334, -0.0312114916741848, 0.029449015855789185, -0.012664973735809326, 0.05484412983059883, -0.028659237548708916, 0.05641033872961998, 0.006375467404723167, 0.009743282571434975, 0.02428363636136055, -0.0387125127017498, -0.047270625829696655, -0.020967574790120125, 0.04594608023762703, -0.018317997455596924, -0.021725185215473175, 0.002815914573147893, 0.04564841836690903, -0.04179465398192406, -0.0569271445274353, -0.012830921448767185, -0.03622652590274811, -0.014997215010225773, 0.05600982531905174, 0.03570842370390892, -0.0352945439517498, -0.0035858331248164177, 0.0011383112287148833, -0.09990435093641281, -0.0517338402569294, -0.027801085263490677, 0.0296725332736969, -0.01850617118179798, 0.03119250014424324, 0.005744481459259987, 0.048826735466718674, -0.01892959140241146, 0.027857812121510506, -0.02744802087545395, 0.01666182652115822, 0.023316431790590286, 0.02622881904244423, -0.09261330217123032, -0.07420890033245087, -0.02944646216928959, -0.0037029015365988016, 0.023166928440332413, -0.0015709946164861321, -0.07076700776815414, -0.014938637614250183, -0.051628414541482925, -0.01787436753511429, -0.004049775190651417, -0.01267411932349205, -0.006381932646036148, 0.0023026037961244583, 0.06002005562186241, 0.010006564669311047, 0.012117047794163227, 0.007258584722876549, 0.021523386240005493, -0.030797403305768967, 0.015158011578023434, 0.015207844786345959, -0.0030655208975076675, 0.040114425122737885, -0.043469540774822235, -0.0003526774817146361, 0.01116699818521738, 0.02844468131661415, -0.0035022327210754156, -0.062191691249608994, 0.055970169603824615, -0.0254945307970047, -0.022929592058062553, -0.020771952345967293, 0.05479690060019493, -0.014450587332248688, -0.01484000589698553, -0.09506212919950485, -0.010852910578250885, -0.0023998827673494816, -0.009072587825357914, -0.0008046019938774407, 0.005196072161197662, -0.04060978814959526, 0.005472536198794842, 0.03706226125359535, -0.057209987193346024, -0.02045280858874321, 0.017645858228206635, 0.033338762819767, -0.0562567412853241, -0.021295737475156784, -0.005241486243903637, -0.013848301023244858, 0.02120017632842064, 0.012441112659871578, 0.024412598460912704, -0.030269624665379524, -0.07619417458772659, -0.022579606622457504, 0.013461672700941563, 0.018888400867581367, -0.008104407228529453, 0.018223710358142853, 0.028041861951351166, 0.03743387758731842, -0.013493319042026997, 0.052877772599458694, -0.00037823247839696705, 0.029369177296757698, -0.0043779113329946995, 0.011274476535618305, 0.010814305394887924, -0.03997040167450905, -0.030545955523848534, 0.0013500534696504474, -0.0019941667560487986, 0.057634737342596054, 0.06748443841934204, -0.028837069869041443, -0.049783382564783096, 0.033954013139009476, -0.0027237660251557827, 0.0074758329428732395, 0.02313617430627346, 0.04971041902899742, 0.06416445225477219, -0.04639757052063942, 0.009813717566430569, 0.028036611154675484, 0.011758933775126934, 0.04183650761842728, 0.007930610328912735, 0.04112734645605087, 0.04204083979129791, -0.08209489285945892, 0.019301647320389748, -0.0005222109030000865, 0.05293431133031845, 0.006399441044777632, -0.0007365208002738655, -0.05102603882551193, 0.004237147513777018, 0.0019208723679184914, -0.0478130467236042, 0.05749675631523132, -0.06546387821435928, 0.03967107832431793, 0.0053848158568143845, -0.03066103346645832, 0.0179947130382061, -0.04901601001620293, -0.06843242794275284, 0.010050644166767597, 0.06020694598555565, -0.02891596220433712, 0.05739545449614525, -0.06038970500230789, -0.042576905339956284, 0.03925095126032829, 0.0324995219707489, 0.03990098834037781, 0.023083550855517387, 0.0003460881707724184, 0.008853873237967491, 0.056193992495536804, -0.015248897485435009, -0.01295006275177002, 0.0033622505143284798, -0.05671515315771103, -0.008668984286487103, -0.01320517435669899, -0.050043463706970215, -0.05425696074962616, -0.046263113617897034, 0.038363419473171234, -0.04659908264875412, -0.0254571121186018, 0.01059548556804657, -0.022570397704839706, 0.0036799958907067776, -0.03563770651817322, 0.046163372695446014, -0.0421859435737133, 0.039092909544706345, -0.03189771622419357, 0.03256617486476898, -0.01684611290693283, 0.014234126545488834, 0.005289182532578707, 0.027753446251153946, 0.014166236855089664, 0.012333963997662067, 0.014504768885672092, -0.03390417620539665, 0.035750072449445724, -0.04950103163719177, -0.05869452655315399, 0.01955822855234146, 0.009668557904660702, 0.0030660824850201607, 0.0177740678191185, 0.050466958433389664, 0.003974206745624542, 0.06184903159737587, 0.027328327298164368, -0.02034274861216545, 0.006346080452203751, -0.03393065929412842, -0.04160844534635544, 0.03246036544442177, 0.006832414772361517, 0.0447099506855011, -0.04664942994713783, -0.02393975481390953, -0.011972806416451931, -0.02933492511510849, -0.027420826256275177, 0.019084841012954712, -0.030629314482212067, -0.015173511579632759, -0.005999977700412273, 0.04448605328798294, -0.016421446576714516, -0.02857016585767269, -0.049750782549381256, -0.03439023345708847, 0.013480021618306637, -0.030404042452573776, -0.04134016111493111, -0.06669285893440247, -0.0386262908577919, 0.06887832283973694, -0.01636412926018238, 0.08407628536224365, -0.03324359282851219, -0.028320124372839928, -0.006734509486705065, -0.010764814913272858, -0.012742249295115471, -0.05686355382204056, -0.018426701426506042, -0.025487497448921204, -0.041300445795059204, -0.020290952175855637, 0.04939332976937294, -0.0572967529296875, 0.010111038573086262, -0.0008486421429552138, 0.017045535147190094, -0.06411595642566681, 0.0570681206882, -0.031037069857120514, 0.05908321216702461, 0.03845783695578575, 0.006480436306446791, 0.0063773575238883495, -0.0018159240717068315, -0.023722531273961067, 0.027867324650287628, 0.011272601783275604, 0.00134326855186373, -0.030479123815894127, 0.0017000050283968449, 0.04317793250083923, -0.05234593152999878, 0.003208084963262081, 0.05881461501121521, 0.05896918103098869, -0.0013731825165450573, 0.09812936931848526, 0.0447368249297142, 0.04693245515227318, 0.018858427181839943, 0.0408807098865509, -0.0097851837053895, 0.04284762963652611, 0.024939386174082756, 0.0077630034647881985, 0.01759793795645237, -0.03850724548101425, -0.0067512826062738895, -0.0005797294434159994, 0.06480693072080612, 0.011000819504261017, -0.006571141071617603, -0.020356083288788795, 0.014613403007388115, 0.055490847676992416, -0.050331197679042816, -0.003768367925658822, -0.07500121742486954, 0.01427818089723587, 0.007607366424053907, -0.04517446830868721, -0.02749144285917282, -0.0012054945109412074, -0.0049958135932683945, -0.027466390281915665, 0.025807935744524002, 0.014485885389149189, 0.028582969680428505, -0.012165513820946217, -0.00030460761627182364, -0.03408745676279068, -0.03218298405408859, -0.027504295110702515, 0.02761685848236084, 0.0543847382068634, -0.03420660272240639, -0.002210376551374793, 0.04101358726620674, -0.07894734293222427, 0.049753107130527496, 0.013091448694467545, 0.0016975003527477384, 0.0012785475701093674, -0.02196471020579338, 0.02740633673965931, 0.012403225526213646, 0.016461487859487534, -0.02387860044836998, 0.010954983532428741, -0.03731689602136612, 0.012533011846244335 ]
<p>How to calculate the area / volume of a black hole? Is there a corresponding mathematical function such as rotating $1/x$ around the $x$-axis or likewise to find the volume? </p>
g6603
[ -0.0027690010610967875, -0.0106113376095891, -0.0029842876829206944, -0.01864062249660492, -0.029319697991013527, -0.031604256480932236, 0.06194841489195824, -0.023337071761488914, -0.016354765743017197, -0.005006841383874416, 0.02925335057079792, 0.03388339653611183, 0.06495536118745804, 0.015130365267395973, 0.0627870112657547, -0.037460602819919586, -0.05986568331718445, 0.007211575284600258, -0.03029240295290947, -0.023565765470266342, 0.035965438932180405, -0.035527754575014114, 0.03620479255914688, -0.016517503187060356, -0.026008710265159607, 0.000720761832781136, 0.027889784425497055, 0.026142967864871025, -0.04234333708882332, 0.02972497045993805, 0.004832753911614418, 0.03496340662240982, -0.011864736676216125, 0.005312392488121986, -0.015521727502346039, -0.00046679546358063817, -0.03818078339099884, -0.016155509278178215, 0.04469688609242439, 0.03811013698577881, 0.021070100367069244, -0.0793161615729332, -0.0059960451908409595, -0.0017283093184232712, -0.007084621582180262, -0.0010578400688245893, -0.011438930407166481, 0.026752091944217682, 0.004917576909065247, -0.019921543076634407, 0.008380701765418053, 0.011923420242965221, 0.12552018463611603, -0.0051875547505915165, 0.004296445287764072, 0.04793883115053177, 0.035304754972457886, -0.012742376886308193, -0.03810825198888779, 0.04568930342793465, -0.034673988819122314, -0.015135610476136208, -0.007960297167301178, -0.014181959442794323, 0.0746176615357399, -0.015851203352212906, -0.032674871385097504, -0.008960193954408169, -0.0725289061665535, 0.0164018701761961, 0.028859935700893402, 0.01978621631860733, 0.07237810641527176, 0.011218818835914135, -0.056998178362846375, 0.042376063764095306, 0.04057395085692406, 0.03720344603061676, 0.005386879201978445, -0.03319096565246582, -0.033419691026210785, -0.02826959267258644, 0.08154000341892242, -0.053549326956272125, 0.06569570302963257, -0.00501199159771204, 0.036311469972133636, -0.03251069411635399, -0.027724450454115868, 0.042662061750888824, -0.01361666340380907, 0.040048856288194656, 0.04949229583144188, 0.01061898935586214, 0.019186463207006454, 0.018372125923633575, -0.000877783284522593, 0.031226299703121185, -0.001508033717982471, 0.05365416407585144, -0.008044969290494919, 0.023168668150901794, -0.003619944676756859, -0.01635507307946682, 0.02291657216846943, 0.028414152562618256, -0.05844910070300102, 0.03095015324652195, -0.027795707806944847, 0.007323544938117266, -0.0378323569893837, -0.08550108224153519, 0.015019236132502556, -0.02479635551571846, -0.019883329048752785, -0.02438887394964695, 0.06628187745809555, -0.006519948597997427, 0.028188707306981087, 0.09279865026473999, -0.030991753563284874, 0.014947427436709404, 0.03649349883198738, -0.007212942931801081, 0.03347800672054291, -0.00800764374434948, -0.018880140036344528, -0.009140009060502052, -0.003665186231955886, 0.03319960832595825, 0.010015754960477352, -0.002638960024341941, -0.0009055165573954582, 0.03791744261980057, 0.005783595144748688, 0.03605923801660538, 0.014896746724843979, 0.002513130195438862, -0.03583725914359093, 0.006135210394859314, -0.019029200077056885, -0.03111177869141102, -0.0039040790870785713, 0.05891202390193939, 0.012229369953274727, 0.017512628808617592, -0.04787924140691757, -0.08217906206846237, -0.024413438513875008, -0.011783733032643795, -0.011846747249364853, 0.12079207599163055, -0.012539426796138287, -0.039498720318078995, 0.01771838590502739, -0.018382862210273743, 0.06411119550466537, 0.0573369562625885, -0.015757055953145027, -0.011311789974570274, 0.04419733211398125, 0.019250398501753807, -0.014590426348149776, 0.029455581679940224, -0.018715152516961098, -0.03199956566095352, -0.044759415090084076, -0.02170555479824543, -0.03375794738531113, -0.031622499227523804, 0.006760882679373026, 0.009357785806059837, -0.0006767807644791901, -0.007186384871602058, 0.02936924621462822, 0.018790585920214653, -0.01634671352803707, 0.03531825169920921, 0.008320379070937634, 0.03132886812090874, 0.06955546885728836, 0.0223233662545681, 0.027916835620999336, 0.03775014728307724, 0.020949028432369232, 0.003103055292740464, 0.014580913819372654, -0.012127405032515526, -0.014490059576928616, 0.012043159455060959, -0.013325156643986702, 0.029130922630429268, 0.07180359214544296, 0.014209010638296604, -0.008987221866846085, 0.07259850203990936, 0.04534480348229408, -0.04303006827831268, -0.029960867017507553, 0.05932731181383133, -0.027749383822083473, -0.017387332394719124, 0.07652803510427475, 0.031393855810165405, 0.032602451741695404, -0.005952021107077599, -0.0233253613114357, 0.035198770463466644, 0.04725568741559982, 0.049773260951042175, 0.014112875796854496, -0.03935355320572853, 0.01668149046599865, -0.01864708587527275, -0.0245067086070776, 0.043213434517383575, -0.06398042291402817, 0.015500213950872421, -0.017740299925208092, 0.0067364792339503765, 0.0035464817192405462, -0.007215128745883703, -0.029213543981313705, -0.0030238700564950705, -0.028355317190289497, 0.032497428357601166, 0.03302793949842453, -0.035568904131650925, -0.009409231133759022, 0.02506270632147789, -0.10052686184644699, -0.00897608045488596, 0.015870723873376846, 0.02977885492146015, 0.0166181493550539, 0.004169842693954706, -0.01215599849820137, 0.06322431564331055, 0.014493677765130997, 0.03262120485305786, 0.047267038375139236, 0.062008339911699295, -0.011412096209824085, 0.031367797404527664, 0.041427820920944214, 0.04118160158395767, 0.0053468425758183, 0.011854542419314384, 0.006894453428685665, -0.014161650091409683, -0.022758908569812775, -0.028110748156905174, -0.02932213619351387, -0.00012283782416488975, -0.00662414263933897, -0.012101350352168083, -0.024836065247654915, -0.01864566281437874, -0.011133415624499321, -0.03427906706929207, 0.029993174597620964, 0.034006014466285706, 0.03729751706123352, 0.013626827858388424, -0.031639907509088516, -0.00822853296995163, -0.09560314565896988, -0.005885463673621416, 0.032832223922014236, 0.06824003905057907, 0.018620112910866737, -0.0005831142188981175, 0.06845301389694214, 0.03627926483750343, 0.021616417914628983, -0.06309634447097778, -0.0397215336561203, 0.030236762017011642, 0.05521957948803902, -0.02599329501390457, 0.01778739131987095, -0.008572150953114033, -0.06118983030319214, 0.03078448213636875, -0.006810352206230164, -0.024457640945911407, 0.050158072263002396, 0.012890887446701527, -0.05713870748877525, -0.05668613314628601, 0.028746360912919044, -0.002926297951489687, -0.04551473632454872, 0.03714079409837723, 0.02207927033305168, 0.03210186958312988, 0.04996231943368912, 0.008615173399448395, 0.046034522354602814, 0.014502860605716705, 0.025556454434990883, -0.041123826056718826, -0.001006013830192387, -0.039773520082235336, -0.04323754459619522, 0.04297145828604698, -0.0017284833593294024, -0.05560210719704628, -0.02243642322719097, 0.026836073026061058, 0.008305296301841736, -0.013584454543888569, 0.012156039476394653, -0.03286081179976463, -0.012238391675055027, -0.023830575868487358, 0.002148199826478958, -0.03325321897864342, -0.006439280696213245, 0.017252527177333832, -0.06547576189041138, -0.021809745579957962, -0.014952667988836765, 0.006553166545927525, 0.016811978071928024, -0.006793603301048279, -0.06424794346094131, -0.008330758661031723, 0.00006200459756655619, -0.007848440669476986, -0.04758378118276596, 0.012116318568587303, -0.0315215140581131, 0.03598172962665558, -0.018520815297961235, -0.002823450369760394, 0.000404631340643391, -0.03152298554778099, 0.04156879708170891, -0.006547155324369669, 0.011463858187198639, -0.05242979899048805, 0.017936553806066513, 0.010082394815981388, -0.012814652174711227, -0.026050088927149773, -0.07429549098014832, -0.023393161594867706, 0.036666471511125565, 0.005891159176826477, -0.03384840115904808, -0.07316886633634567, 0.04984993115067482, -0.037435587495565414, 0.09782934188842773, -0.005486118141561747, 0.03874659910798073, -0.008609860204160213, -0.039334867149591446, 0.003786821383982897, -0.020776310935616493, -0.08672762662172318, -0.029041115194559097, 0.0010819582967087626, -0.02314121462404728, -0.039127517491579056, 0.05739804729819298, -0.00878943968564272, -0.0903923362493515, -0.021658429875969887, 0.01579689234495163, -0.007119154091924429, 0.04338960722088814, -0.0028421541210263968, -0.030495954677462578, -0.08789857476949692, 0.007203199435025454, -0.03313199803233147, -0.022871214896440506, -0.01624414138495922, 0.016642296686768532, -0.0401691272854805, 0.020526554435491562, -0.019007986411452293, -0.09194586426019669, 0.023851851001381874, -0.03972237557172775, -0.04302049055695534, 0.06816793233156204, -0.04790147393941879, 0.01107533648610115, -0.009763524867594242, -0.02540576085448265, -0.07741127908229828, 0.052892137318849564, -0.005033145193010569, -0.02699853852391243, -0.023534320294857025, -0.06781797111034393, -0.02032812125980854, 0.04151085019111633, -0.020607827231287956, 0.022117555141448975, 0.013314456678926945, 0.04714585468173027, 0.015720287337899208, 0.053882189095020294, -0.0033966018818318844, 0.006371135823428631, 0.025502027943730354, 0.04428553208708763, -0.01735888235270977, 0.023782234638929367, -0.012267310172319412, 0.05386078357696533, -0.028204403817653656, -0.005829818081110716, -0.012088547460734844, 0.029394129291176796, -0.03760989382863045, 0.0026798867620527744, -0.06230385601520538, -0.015630295500159264, 0.014203867875039577, -0.08858350664377213, -0.033331699669361115, 0.016482576727867126, 0.0061096316203475, 0.008824307471513748, 0.0012576015433296561, 0.024841176345944405, 0.04235222935676575, 0.005009880289435387, 0.01242916565388441, -0.05461800470948219, -0.003043057629838586, 0.008601305074989796, 0.018193406984210014, 0.012640239670872688, 0.00026701821479946375, -0.01214352436363697, 0.022996995598077774, -0.0658368393778801, -0.03495036065578461, -0.03997363522648811, 0.012662981636822224, 0.03393300995230675, -0.024147655814886093, -0.04756259545683861, -0.02650185115635395, -0.03784311190247536, -0.011374016292393208, -0.023457510396838188, -0.0690213143825531, -0.011865803971886635, 0.00705892825499177, -0.032563716173172, 0.04770650342106819, 0.057077210396528244, 0.00934265460819006, -0.03705989196896553, -0.0350557342171669, -0.06389148533344269, 0.052705276757478714, -0.01850675232708454, -0.01944717764854431, -0.05447106808423996, -0.009384498931467533, 0.00211198884062469, 0.012359087355434895, -0.030866075307130814, 0.03810390830039978, -0.018379658460617065, 0.017580879852175713, -0.04878722503781319, 0.07525163888931274, -0.004276928957551718, -0.012268904596567154, -0.03514929488301277, -0.04041994735598564, -0.01729581318795681, -0.01571805402636528, 0.039274487644433975, 0.029308820143342018, 0.03935077786445618, 0.03709206357598305, -0.01606408692896366, -0.004962206818163395, 0.02303619496524334, 0.047666244208812714, 0.003117666346952319, 0.017356179654598236, 0.08522927761077881, -0.0466046966612339, -0.008834975771605968, -0.08448023349046707, -0.029150599613785744, -0.08769973367452621, 0.0321846567094326, 0.08712584525346756, 0.013432782143354416, 0.034348029643297195, 0.026006683707237244, -0.015867944806814194, -0.01596156135201454, 0.003285628277808428, -0.015831945464015007, 0.047330956906080246, -0.009491953067481518, 0.053739503026008606, 0.047572750598192215, -0.006443863734602928, 0.019419223070144653, 0.041450124233961105, 0.022020358592271805, -0.07689663767814636, 0.004598054103553295, 0.047622330486774445, -0.0038751557003706694, 0.0384223647415638, 0.029485251754522324, 0.004987293854355812, 0.024158190935850143, 0.024814547970891, 0.008228342980146408, -0.000758941809181124, -0.06099358946084976, -0.033635132014751434, 0.01810009777545929, 0.021357838064432144, -0.03043282963335514, -0.041921086609363556, -0.024328559637069702, -0.005500180646777153, -0.0334608219563961, 0.005924216005951166, -0.023008624091744423, -0.01703152433037758, 0.10099461674690247, -0.029030831530690193, 0.02670038491487503, 0.007932224310934544, -0.010734864510595798, 0.007234241813421249, -0.006646085996180773, 0.008214508183300495, -0.053410887718200684, -0.004648277070373297, 0.031692638993263245, -0.027921821922063828, -0.01289308164268732, 0.017935823649168015, -0.001305767334997654, -0.03385902941226959, -0.018764588981866837, 0.0038775287102907896, -0.027219008654356003, -0.060211144387722015, -0.01579313538968563, -0.001067941077053547, 0.03597807139158249, -0.06308663636445999, 0.004218770191073418, -0.00801660306751728, -0.03761373087763786, 0.015320190228521824, 0.029744723811745644, -0.03258978947997093, -0.01570191979408264, 0.015959689393639565, -0.07582391053438187, -0.01867733895778656, -0.01983276568353176, -0.01949767768383026, 0.0336131788790226, 0.05802258476614952, -0.006282604765146971, -0.006192707922309637, -0.004953788127750158, -0.00021192015265114605, 0.009696466848254204, -0.006220351904630661, 0.05011976510286331, -0.036024291068315506, -0.006521755829453468, -0.006338127888739109, 0.017273763194680214, 0.019166046753525734, -0.01441904902458191, -0.01110891904681921, -0.02544528618454933, -0.006296742707490921, 0.008242092095315456, -0.059752751141786575, -0.045828402042388916, -0.005358085967600346, -0.015494200401008129, 0.007977882400155067, 0.05619603022933006, -0.05673613399267197, -0.012783853337168694, 0.048443298786878586, -0.02086135558784008, -0.01268833689391613, -0.0010702137369662523, -0.05853412300348282, -0.07472232729196548, -0.027051052078604698, 0.0008389879949390888, -0.03638254478573799, 0.009754800237715244, 0.03263934329152107, 0.009020566008985043, 0.029255423694849014, 0.011105033569037914, 0.005640619434416294, 0.029478667303919792, 0.0058974833227694035, 0.06493103504180908, -0.04794640094041824, 0.015483847819268703, 0.01936735399067402, -0.04394064098596573, -0.04573405161499977, 0.04503604397177696, 0.012830602005124092, -0.028769822791218758, 0.010706769302487373, 0.036826808005571365, -0.013192735612392426, 0.09624162316322327, 0.0768899917602539, -0.0217316634953022, 0.04306881129741669, 0.01750156469643116, 0.00995761901140213, -0.06079612299799919, 0.03084346279501915, 0.0021217053290456533, 0.035430967807769775, -0.04550893232226372, -0.03691655397415161, 0.0439017228782177, 0.021153807640075684, -0.058772049844264984, -0.047914277762174606, -0.05435916781425476, 0.028188269585371017, -0.026219939813017845, 0.07159166783094406, 0.04326089844107628, -0.06637674570083618, -0.023611463606357574, 0.006718060467392206, -0.07093743234872818, -0.04152701795101166, 0.025628777220845222, -0.06694167852401733, 0.002584553323686123, -0.034761060029268265, 0.002746570622548461, -0.05080639198422432, -0.03698446974158287, 0.026914559304714203, 0.014960026368498802, 0.04827263206243515, 0.03820072486996651, 0.06908480077981949, 0.06587835401296616, -0.050494808703660965, -0.010752653703093529, -0.0038458050694316626, -0.07497572153806686, 0.03797908499836922, -0.1078469455242157, -0.016584264114499092, 0.0033832176122814417, 0.02400399185717106, -0.030539875850081444, 0.040138378739356995, 0.006283591501414776, 0.037032149732112885, -0.07007744163274765, 0.032560113817453384, -0.014075776562094688, -0.0384499691426754, -0.04414932802319527, 0.00020574154041241854, 0.04013613983988762, 0.1047961637377739, -0.008035385049879551, -0.026763416826725006, -0.02544235624372959, -0.018932275474071503, -0.027365390211343765, 0.005176491104066372, 0.02831406705081463, 0.022601528093218803, 0.0008159297285601497, 0.016549287363886833, 0.022810662165284157, -0.03822696954011917, 0.034456148743629456, -0.036597948521375656, 0.047583337873220444, -0.007138925138860941, 0.005536078009754419, 0.029803600162267685, -0.029479222372174263, 0.012506765313446522, 0.07383572310209274, 0.012415420264005661, -0.00865956861525774, -0.02634148672223091, -0.008218671195209026, 0.0135641572996974, 0.01715611107647419, -0.003457688959315419, 0.004912730306386948, -0.07003522664308548, -0.04400504752993584, 0.02930312417447567, 0.022866107523441315, -0.07272984832525253, 0.011867687106132507, -0.030084019526839256, -0.0265236496925354, -0.018646836280822754, -0.007475436199456453, 0.026071272790431976, -0.02423958107829094, 0.042335912585258484, -0.026389624923467636, 0.03042927011847496, 0.015717383474111557, -0.011320782825350761, 0.012992758303880692, -0.008996857330203056, 0.034442123025655746, 0.07252511382102966, 0.019790062680840492, -0.06533984839916229, 0.026127679273486137, 0.006070585921406746, 0.026377787813544273, 0.01656912826001644, 0.023757368326187134, 0.06029062718153, 0.03870680555701256, -0.042734574526548386, -0.02927759476006031, 0.04924511909484863, -0.0039300802163779736, 0.00810453575104475, 0.026858489960432053, -0.044749461114406586, 0.008619497530162334, -0.04716133698821068, -0.0734710544347763, -0.000828991353046149, 0.01751384697854519, 0.030554499477148056, 0.035117145627737045, -0.010988579131662846, 0.020356763154268265, -0.02923249639570713, 0.03319743648171425, 0.034902408719062805 ]
<p>For a simulation, I want to compute the path that light follows near a black hole.</p> <p>Non-relativistically, a massive point particle in a central newtonian gravitational field follows either an ellipse, a parabola, or a hyperbola. Is the same true relativistically for light around a black hole? A problem I see with this, is that while particles gain velocity when approaching a black hole, a photon gains energy instead. So do photons behave differently?</p>
g6604
[ 0.009113886393606663, 0.009012333117425442, 0.015452327206730843, 0.02883477509021759, 0.035764411091804504, 0.004021177999675274, 0.04054071381688118, 0.004817625042051077, -0.03367689624428749, 0.004515461623668671, 0.032021623104810715, 0.016764087602496147, 0.03957255557179451, -0.019474465399980545, -0.03748718276619911, -0.026948802173137665, 0.07946861535310745, 0.006925342138856649, 0.040814101696014404, -0.009422973729670048, -0.02263258583843708, 0.019669605419039726, 0.028589559718966484, -0.029635459184646606, -0.02352641150355339, 0.018387578427791595, 0.061572156846523285, -0.03963903710246086, -0.07922931760549545, -0.007213506381958723, 0.06205523759126663, -0.04508287087082863, 0.0656595528125763, -0.026366278529167175, 0.023559695109725, 0.019732851535081863, 0.024096578359603882, 0.01271666307002306, -0.016319040209054947, -0.000039610971725778654, 0.03656682372093201, -0.034631047397851944, -0.007929881103336811, -0.009494985453784466, 0.020713066682219505, -0.05994020402431488, 0.043072693049907684, -0.0016413844423368573, 0.016101451590657234, 0.0017794531304389238, -0.0017989681800827384, 0.0024251791182905436, -0.01735732890665531, 0.012644797563552856, 0.024046452715992928, 0.07361577451229095, 0.007450757082551718, -0.002926895394921303, 0.040591590106487274, 0.05712733417749405, -0.009008309803903103, -0.015046444721519947, -0.00353030301630497, -0.01576215960085392, -0.00153378548566252, 0.014651212841272354, -0.03465479612350464, -0.027941932901740074, -0.10464229434728622, 0.0009143980569206178, 0.006029724143445492, 0.007407227531075478, -0.024436885491013527, -0.06368780881166458, -0.01580685004591942, 0.02317025512456894, -0.04333443194627762, 0.019686194136738777, -0.01482333056628704, 0.004055427853018045, 0.007243347819894552, 0.020226264372467995, 0.04465356841683388, -0.014078804291784763, 0.07317358255386353, -0.008518975228071213, -0.024857966229319572, -0.01869610883295536, -0.036806732416152954, 0.004392507951706648, 0.05839007720351219, 0.02532147616147995, 0.07966569811105728, 0.03727184608578682, -0.040420643985271454, 0.009728767909109592, -0.04777555540204048, 0.04470397159457207, 0.03856330364942551, 0.010384959168732166, -0.015958910807967186, 0.005859507247805595, 0.005126905627548695, 0.03193208575248718, 0.018784036859869957, -0.0033046065364032984, -0.004997176118195057, 0.05271688848733902, -0.003761403961107135, 0.0265958309173584, -0.02839820086956024, -0.11043848842382431, -0.003010118380188942, -0.09825655817985535, -0.0878218337893486, 0.008550310507416725, 0.08430793881416321, -0.04346168786287308, 0.027353515848517418, 0.12364405393600464, 0.019197413697838783, 0.011096959933638573, 0.031118858605623245, 0.10861803591251373, 0.018457069993019104, 0.018093155696988106, -0.008864928968250751, 0.021093541756272316, 0.027539275586605072, 0.028276024386286736, 0.01740189827978611, -0.019515102729201317, -0.05332230404019356, 0.05273967608809471, -0.03530789911746979, -0.005421461071819067, 0.04310620576143265, 0.003506304929032922, -0.042588572949171066, -0.009683012031018734, -0.0029461835511028767, -0.04320499673485756, -0.003948119468986988, -0.03126906231045723, -0.04872426390647888, 0.00993743259459734, 0.004428140819072723, -0.023037148639559746, 0.03906863182783127, 0.008094629272818565, 0.027675002813339233, 0.11380635201931, -0.00530534703284502, 0.007531875744462013, -0.01069923210889101, 0.029864728450775146, 0.0214283037930727, 0.017654607072472572, -0.06524956226348877, -0.00909157283604145, 0.026642819866538048, 0.004896821454167366, 0.06494967639446259, 0.004203803837299347, 0.004410985391587019, -0.0031417105346918106, 0.03630642220377922, -0.047713395208120346, 0.03834913671016693, -0.024506712332367897, -0.02083870954811573, -0.0033658910542726517, -0.00923396460711956, 0.06263882666826248, -0.0018300729570910335, 0.025296257808804512, 0.016270453110337257, -0.00620436342433095, -0.02168525941669941, -0.015507584437727928, -0.0064698196947574615, -0.006458378862589598, 0.037043843418359756, 0.028339309617877007, -0.001847420702688396, 0.0017857380444183946, -0.01529688574373722, 0.0007643664721399546, -0.052764423191547394, -0.010002481751143932, -0.045060619711875916, -0.018652772530913353, 0.00834567192941904, 0.01535127591341734, -0.004686689469963312, 0.05032409355044365, 0.013480023480951786, -0.023126037791371346, -0.01814397983253002, 0.06423114985227585, -0.004855367820709944, 0.03608197346329689, -0.04243838042020798, 0.026247724890708923, 0.031085263937711716, -0.01965518295764923, -0.037631090730428696, -0.011685450561344624, -0.018961744382977486, 0.02022632211446762, 0.03361295163631439, 0.0114476028829813, 0.05165993049740791, 0.00535618094727397, -0.04608967527747154, 0.022730927914381027, -0.10119873285293579, 0.010306614451110363, 0.008893544785678387, 0.05984864756464958, -0.028618570417165756, -0.051149021834135056, 0.013017871417105198, -0.04819820448756218, 0.010855195112526417, 0.003025750396773219, -0.0679679736495018, -0.039301563054323196, 0.020023547112941742, 0.03507526218891144, -0.06236927583813667, 0.029177991673350334, -0.0026090554893016815, -0.01442798599600792, 0.08863137662410736, -0.04628211259841919, -0.038330256938934326, -0.0001910443970700726, 0.049420978873968124, -0.013291174545884132, 0.003661447437480092, -0.010802955366671085, -0.02297528274357319, -0.004340578801929951, 0.01550467312335968, -0.009568637236952782, 0.037894412875175476, 0.005725827068090439, -0.06277064979076385, 0.0018102115718647838, 0.05115083232522011, -0.02198152430355549, 0.005032876040786505, 0.034241579473018646, 0.02303338795900345, -0.0039982870221138, -0.017147943377494812, 0.0140693886205554, -0.06973434239625931, -0.01362193375825882, -0.02049224078655243, -0.01573469676077366, -0.03136421740055084, 0.00318464869633317, -0.013782412745058537, 0.025893162935972214, 0.005807959008961916, -0.017383480444550514, 0.027310030534863472, 0.03927001357078552, -0.032002732157707214, 0.038307636976242065, 0.06611184030771255, 0.022299474105238914, -0.002145954640582204, -0.0023496549110859632, -0.011205805465579033, 0.014706740155816078, 0.01504895742982626, -0.0032881656661629677, 0.007392896339297295, -0.04622979462146759, -0.020242324098944664, 0.028762830421328545, 0.03918364271521568, -0.11003150045871735, 0.007568312343209982, -0.019209690392017365, -0.06102166697382927, -0.04630747437477112, 0.017950110137462616, 0.04552781581878662, -0.00194668082986027, 0.06961642950773239, 0.01145952194929123, -0.010796461254358292, 0.03319232910871506, -0.014421077445149422, -0.02004249207675457, 0.029685506597161293, -0.031936995685100555, -0.022423261776566505, -0.030629092827439308, 0.011173175647854805, -0.0018874111119657755, 0.035985711961984634, -0.05948884040117264, -0.06844137609004974, 0.05531331151723862, 0.016530239954590797, 0.01791701838374138, 0.03365263342857361, -0.018011150881648064, 0.04221966490149498, 0.02443535067141056, -0.016279559582471848, 0.008058549836277962, 0.03718046844005585, 0.014338801614940166, 0.05795999988913536, 0.002202268224209547, 0.016725415363907814, -0.050869088619947433, 0.015491664409637451, 0.05533605441451073, 0.044397879391908646, 0.012278718873858452, 0.0019174396293237805, -0.01416144147515297, -0.0325903594493866, 0.010423922911286354, -0.04095986858010292, -0.01877034641802311, 0.06432376801967621, 0.035646095871925354, -0.031928326934576035, 0.016094787046313286, -0.028112350031733513, 0.0840969905257225, -0.03663713485002518, 0.029096052050590515, -0.04269558936357498, 0.010306647047400475, 0.0026975260116159916, -0.012671548873186111, -0.030024919658899307, 0.0395759642124176, -0.013074223883450031, -0.014357045292854309, -0.024367885664105415, 0.011109191924333572, -0.08569832891225815, -0.013638114556670189, -0.02816731110215187, -0.00021487391495611519, -0.00963673647493124, -0.00732786487787962, 0.0003342202689964324, 0.026145823299884796, 0.018504075706005096, -0.06405998021364212, -0.031046276912093163, -0.014947360381484032, 0.03373550996184349, -0.007853299379348755, -0.000987174455076456, 0.05381280183792114, -0.03436479717493057, 0.0018042424926534295, -0.016998644918203354, -0.013714968226850033, 0.009858189150691032, 0.014087263494729996, -0.004843450617045164, 0.0016036267625167966, -0.0156463123857975, 0.0361156240105629, -0.05227796733379364, 0.0036522201262414455, -0.025745676830410957, -0.0011629716027528048, 0.02066061832010746, 0.0016320523573085666, -0.002030330477282405, 0.0020784351509064436, 0.05576813593506813, -0.026730850338935852, -0.04086786508560181, 0.0565948411822319, -0.007327912840992212, 0.013848393224179745, -0.06758628785610199, -0.023121338337659836, -0.048838645219802856, 0.01004072930663824, -0.023868700489401817, -0.013652483932673931, 0.004768596962094307, 0.013238130137324333, -0.03138430044054985, 0.07672711461782455, 0.02321271412074566, 0.013841059058904648, 0.06632794439792633, 0.02619694359600544, -0.03876321762800217, 0.010446104221045971, -0.04608415439724922, -0.04496857523918152, 0.00025436535361222923, 0.07127274572849274, -0.02794327773153782, 0.015542126260697842, -0.07929708063602448, 0.011599983088672161, -0.03320945054292679, 0.018296534195542336, 0.0192363653331995, -0.016728365793824196, 0.01059685181826353, 0.014975662343204021, 0.004252662416547537, 0.030761094763875008, -0.025303589180111885, -0.02631296217441559, 0.06623943150043488, 0.034036390483379364, -0.012336505576968193, -0.01939709670841694, 0.011995349079370499, 0.010579608380794525, 0.036734797060489655, 0.011978373862802982, 0.0034895772114396095, -0.05569014698266983, 0.043751638382673264, -0.012775328010320663, -0.001461439998820424, 0.07180565595626831, -0.024451827630400658, 0.0066873482428491116, 0.05465595796704292, 0.025323130190372467, -0.07661077380180359, 0.018880145624279976, 0.0444847010076046, -0.02244017831981182, 0.014272228814661503, -0.05043096840381622, -0.012256632559001446, 0.02633323334157467, 0.0188274048268795, -0.04471590742468834, -0.01853696070611477, -0.014985576272010803, -0.016264084726572037, -0.014809513464570045, 0.04650457948446274, -0.007385086268186569, -0.007295542396605015, -0.050380807369947433, -0.014486793428659439, 0.043980248272418976, 0.009626484476029873, -0.009202716872096062, -0.02726517617702484, -0.10117734968662262, -0.018413808196783066, -0.020525500178337097, 0.01283229049295187, -0.07010499387979507, 0.01874653622508049, 0.003915649373084307, 0.014590849168598652, -0.014550291001796722, -0.012493611313402653, -0.030313599854707718, 0.010451476089656353, 0.0019621325191110373, -0.041824549436569214, -0.012739147059619427, -0.03070809319615364, 0.029243193566799164, 0.016272995620965958, -0.0057172817178070545, 0.034997813403606415, -0.0366416797041893, 0.04593104496598244, -0.001410208409652114, -0.007828841917216778, 0.0013640867546200752, -0.0758664533495903, -0.0277104489505291, -0.04322989657521248, 0.003780738916248083, -0.031157111749053, 0.014450805261731148, 0.015095748007297516, 0.045862384140491486, -0.012487035244703293, -0.0958697572350502, 0.03869660198688507, 0.02945483662188053, -0.006449722684919834, -0.014114568009972572, 0.05334240198135376, 0.06099452078342438, 0.00926736555993557, -0.04532410949468613, 0.0451803095638752, -0.035863254219293594, -0.002579831052571535, -0.010273969732224941, 0.0008276486187241971, -0.00211000326089561, -0.013819706626236439, 0.012345436029136181, 0.021172702312469482, -0.037674836814403534, -0.03112235851585865, 0.034627992659807205, 0.018544869497418404, 0.013526479713618755, 0.0218124371021986, 0.08822153508663177, -0.005858711898326874, -0.0025599421933293343, -0.00863885972648859, 0.03558547794818878, -0.013358836062252522, 0.027699559926986694, -0.025353290140628815, 0.05525849014520645, 0.02200254797935486, -0.04122936725616455, -0.06474009901285172, 0.022625472396612167, -0.016603393480181694, 0.05688345059752464, -0.035678278654813766, -0.006404274143278599, -0.0005870094173587859, 0.011712226085364819, 0.04468783736228943, -0.01636666990816593, 0.041576873511075974, -0.017030412331223488, 0.04601167142391205, 0.005938342772424221, -0.06936806440353394, -0.0028968516271561384, 0.00854058563709259, 0.031534671783447266, 0.015671169385313988, -0.03324901685118675, 0.023877033963799477, -0.007885785773396492, -0.045043814927339554, -0.013480402529239655, -0.036125004291534424, 0.006353674456477165, -0.08347316831350327, 0.027770645916461945, -0.03525911271572113, -0.003416344290599227, -0.05506886914372444, -0.054125163704156876, -0.06869803369045258, 0.04458007588982582, 0.032217636704444885, -0.021782150492072105, -0.016469042748212814, -0.02448585070669651, 0.059713561087846756, 0.0049089896492660046, 0.02585124783217907, 0.00600785855203867, -0.012327345088124275, -0.03312817960977554, -0.028452739119529724, 0.0021688633132725954, 0.017960961908102036, 0.04240676760673523, -0.037563540041446686, 0.002579072490334511, -0.003147043054923415, 0.008485356345772743, 0.11415465921163559, 0.022362159565091133, 0.015683908015489578, -0.020482279360294342, -0.03582434728741646, 0.018271885812282562, -0.04779750853776932, -0.08171799778938293, -0.012670082040131092, 0.014799182303249836, -0.01176487561315298, 0.00656163552775979, -0.00254261726513505, -0.038024842739105225, 0.045067764818668365, 0.017207160592079163, -0.05497252568602562, 0.012328499928116798, 0.02109777368605137, -0.06362079828977585, -0.038321226835250854, 0.058276645839214325, -0.03764772787690163, 0.06500118970870972, 0.043926600366830826, -0.011360091157257557, 0.03074321337044239, -0.021394146606326103, -0.01870414800941944, -0.019000018015503883, 0.01847587525844574, 0.07497982680797577, -0.03144686669111252, -0.007661622017621994, -0.02719077654182911, -0.0308796726167202, -0.038599029183387756, 0.05331419035792351, 0.03445962443947792, -0.07195938378572464, 0.08734362572431564, 0.025167861953377724, 0.0075052231550216675, 0.0464298352599144, -0.0015761905815452337, -0.04442266374826431, 0.05676655098795891, 0.06877395510673523, 0.0009219066123478115, -0.06520483642816544, 0.03985438868403435, 0.0036835139617323875, 0.03496613726019859, 0.04056992381811142, -0.048866890370845795, 0.022008821368217468, 0.02104794979095459, -0.06387685984373093, 0.006003649439662695, -0.013727745972573757, 0.028055984526872635, -0.018252424895763397, 0.025983408093452454, -0.0268547385931015, -0.05575808510184288, -0.02498863823711872, 0.012355729006230831, -0.01754850335419178, -0.017533747479319572, -0.053754039108753204, 0.01390045415610075, -0.0312928669154644, -0.08367793262004852, -0.021459579467773438, -0.01846286468207836, -0.061576999723911285, -0.02804451249539852, 0.026965251192450523, -0.00004079730570083484, 0.003057391382753849, 0.032380398362874985, -0.06517238914966583, 0.016492703929543495, -0.009485175833106041, -0.04259650781750679, -0.05953802913427353, 0.10448689013719559, -0.0442388691008091, -0.06331238150596619, -0.048036713153123856, 0.05103089287877083, -0.04425628483295441, -0.005681407172232866, 0.07485293596982956, 0.05801260471343994, 0.0031741573475301266, 0.03312622383236885, 0.003591058077290654, -0.014248853549361229, -0.07133599370718002, -0.010897469706833363, -0.023968109861016273, -0.00837504118680954, -0.037665996700525284, 0.027720361948013306, -0.01946692354977131, -0.0553106963634491, 0.01890823245048523, 0.02680603228509426, 0.06087441369891167, 0.02104400284588337, 0.015220340341329575, -0.01892819069325924, -0.032215047627687454, 0.005579649470746517, -0.017065158113837242, -0.033087342977523804, 0.0005651854444295168, 0.012794858776032925, -0.025300541892647743, -0.01817171461880207, -0.036403506994247437, 0.06717663258314133, 0.05192074924707413, 0.03537076339125633, -0.02465083636343479, -0.00568052614107728, -0.0014650261728093028, -0.006636802572757006, 0.017451418563723564, 0.04287589341402054, -0.015012655407190323, -0.039755694568157196, -0.02970232255756855, 0.014180942438542843, -0.054325371980667114, -0.005447284318506718, 0.0022131726145744324, -0.049297209829092026, 0.007935903035104275, 0.01583855226635933, -0.021932095289230347, -0.07307311147451401, -0.020336806774139404, 0.021171029657125473, -0.04018072038888931, 0.0030645050574094057, 0.0015937117859721184, 0.02177722565829754, -0.06084504723548889, -0.0006521473405882716, 0.02898186445236206, -0.017436593770980835, 0.012899859808385372, -0.13287127017974854, 0.06483864784240723, -0.011540606617927551, 0.02592368982732296, 0.01449317205697298, 0.04535087198019028, 0.003350114682689309, 0.05498407781124115, 0.0316295325756073, 0.013021205551922321, 0.058931589126586914, -0.015032644383609295, 0.051283881068229675, 0.027351684868335724, -0.04167041555047035, 0.024124234914779663, -0.04919687658548355, -0.0244149137288332, -0.029150471091270447, 0.000044533378968480974, -0.024810858070850372, 0.004474131856113672, -0.019093375653028488, 0.011225951835513115, 0.00260770320892334, -0.016203783452510834, 0.04580770060420036 ]
<p>I know there may be missing information, but my question is really simple and yet I haven't found an answer to it. To make things easy, let's assume we have a $40×40×40$ cm oven that we want to keep its temperature at $200$ degrees Celsius using natural gas. How much energy per second is consumed to achieve this?</p>
g6605
[ 0.059209421277046204, 0.034295178949832916, 0.035851459950208664, 0.0478171706199646, -0.06676128506660461, -0.1051853746175766, 0.016286058351397514, 0.06241915002465248, -0.07580402493476868, 0.017218466848134995, -0.02768127992749214, 0.03237996622920036, -0.021829793229699135, 0.023408856242895126, 0.013414724729955196, 0.001742515480145812, 0.005199011880904436, -0.0017402124358341098, 0.08141680806875229, 0.0844925045967102, -0.04440900310873985, -0.07348020374774933, 0.0073357135988771915, -0.04775280877947807, -0.04920065775513649, -0.017532039433717728, 0.000453010608907789, 0.010382069274783134, -0.053569450974464417, -0.004383379593491554, -0.04200301319360733, 0.05148419737815857, -0.01091942097991705, -0.029928656294941902, -0.07164088636636734, -0.04102204740047455, 0.018819715827703476, -0.011139943264424801, 0.01122993417084217, -0.05303319916129112, -0.010275091044604778, 0.017153840512037277, 0.00937908235937357, 0.019470371305942535, 0.03197271376848221, 0.05834859609603882, 0.021872172132134438, -0.01809602417051792, -0.012700927443802357, -0.039493121206760406, -0.028700053691864014, 0.006777903530746698, 0.013664080761373043, -0.04045729339122772, -0.02171829529106617, -0.049223393201828, -0.03091379813849926, 0.00034603587118908763, 0.04160212352871895, 0.036646269261837006, 0.021420614793896675, -0.06344577670097351, 0.0046867444179952145, -0.009533530101180077, -0.012106760405004025, -0.012268696911633015, -0.027056047692894936, 0.007486357353627682, 0.06990517675876617, 0.04425537958741188, -0.015801098197698593, 0.014780848287045956, -0.04038352519273758, -0.04871482402086258, -0.018876710906624794, -0.039444196969270706, -0.001834746217355132, -0.059167325496673584, -0.012518215924501419, 0.0410614013671875, -0.044458650052547455, -0.03090856224298477, -0.0015219127526506782, 0.00004589470336213708, -0.03879324719309807, -0.03775008022785187, -0.005143657326698303, 0.027111709117889404, -0.05928456410765648, 0.03937169909477234, 0.026638830080628395, -0.008813493885099888, 0.10273509472608566, 0.0006714132032357156, 0.0481254868209362, -0.014803478494286537, -0.03970740735530853, 0.038335464894771576, 0.033387817442417145, 0.016425257548689842, -0.005441186483949423, -0.07520386576652527, 0.01618519425392151, -0.05230465903878212, -0.025388451293110847, 0.013707765378057957, 0.005609100218862295, 0.03136322647333145, -0.042010944336652756, 0.0040514711290597916, 0.05409583821892738, -0.03980129584670067, -0.027862543240189552, -0.008176296018064022, -0.04992412030696869, -0.018464986234903336, 0.04044842720031738, 0.0054931845515966415, 0.042066790163517, 0.03766932711005211, 0.014420670457184315, 0.07326903939247131, -0.03980035334825516, -0.0051725166849792, -0.07783831655979156, -0.008759663440287113, -0.01607818715274334, 0.007604639977216721, 0.027838008478283882, 0.007911862805485725, -0.06749401241540909, 0.013985793106257915, -0.0025426747743040323, 0.018718816339969635, 0.025945967063307762, 0.01585577428340912, -0.03769368678331375, 0.017013689503073692, -0.027311231940984726, -0.0032989669125527143, -0.0034692473709583282, 0.013162483461201191, 0.041225917637348175, -0.00438607856631279, -0.027874285355210304, 0.037213560193777084, -0.05287997052073479, 0.017613576725125313, 0.028293069452047348, 0.04172559827566147, 0.02146647684276104, 0.0010747136548161507, 0.049169350415468216, -0.040029529482126236, 0.03608112409710884, -0.03025958500802517, -0.0198355745524168, 0.00741425110027194, 0.06093287840485573, 0.025656230747699738, 0.06683844327926636, -0.0057374839670956135, 0.08390530943870544, -0.014462697319686413, -0.08885503560304642, 0.005759594962000847, 0.046691350638866425, -0.018987298011779785, 0.01647961512207985, -0.021981414407491684, -0.043157223612070084, -0.019421033561229706, -0.028663484379649162, 0.0523395836353302, -0.0553162656724453, -0.00019287019676994532, 0.052471358329057693, 0.01572471484541893, -0.01634455844759941, 0.0094304159283638, -0.007938835769891739, 0.006276222411543131, 0.04729920253157616, -0.025637054815888405, -0.022376857697963715, 0.06910078227519989, 0.00991285964846611, -0.028754843398928642, -0.00901731476187706, 0.0025389669463038445, 0.01617581583559513, 0.026529598981142044, 0.003974508959800005, -0.004368146415799856, 0.0017055569915100932, 0.025236403569579124, 0.01608501933515072, -0.043197229504585266, -0.052374888211488724, -0.013110579922795296, 0.03511356934905052, -0.023677105084061623, 0.0315638929605484, 0.02348487079143524, 0.022740574553608894, 0.023083357140421867, -0.002825346775352955, 0.021383047103881836, -0.013788683339953423, -0.002309145638719201, -0.012523307465016842, 0.03916407749056816, 0.002243981696665287, 0.0339631512761116, 0.07697849720716476, 0.03583335503935814, -0.01799282431602478, 0.0008024142007343471, -0.0067813280038535595, 0.0035536305513232946, 0.003937416709959507, 0.02187373675405979, 0.05468707159161568, -0.010716846212744713, -0.014701338484883308, -0.07987701147794724, -0.0018890087958425283, -0.026435839012265205, 0.004227183759212494, 0.047140732407569885, -0.01826033554971218, 0.029257597401738167, -0.0020488854497671127, -0.04721451178193092, 0.024564020335674286, 0.059430867433547974, -0.01647949032485485, 0.05187731981277466, 0.009160343557596207, 0.0022733095102012157, 0.00993767473846674, -0.019955338910222054, 0.019968288019299507, 0.05930592119693756, -0.03378794342279434, 0.004985671956092119, 0.050937097519636154, -0.024355625733733177, -0.0016373669495806098, -0.008860998786985874, -0.00839765090495348, -0.009697029367089272, -0.032235972583293915, 0.013344533741474152, -0.009986142627894878, -0.010341983288526535, -0.05813088268041611, 0.025868171826004982, -0.005203541833907366, -0.047984134405851364, -0.015232987701892853, -0.07471243292093277, 0.04932243004441261, 0.0016512596048414707, 0.04961393028497696, -0.07856181263923645, -0.017377464100718498, -0.047668155282735825, 0.016587087884545326, 0.019055569544434547, 0.014507070183753967, 0.033450379967689514, -0.030883368104696274, 0.018459588289260864, 0.001448635826818645, -0.04358045384287834, 0.07730220258235931, -0.04429280012845993, 0.04475756362080574, 0.00323595036752522, 0.017042217776179314, -0.03577422350645065, -0.06588934361934662, 0.0633450448513031, 0.0011428478173911572, -0.0598301887512207, -0.015949366614222527, 0.04795752838253975, 0.0044408636167645454, -0.039258867502212524, -0.020140355452895164, 0.027504919096827507, -0.02730976603925228, -0.008380657061934471, -0.024248814210295677, 0.014021444134414196, 0.032029978930950165, 0.00505567342042923, 0.013310843147337437, -0.03579743206501007, 0.017344743013381958, -0.04776079207658768, -0.04615702107548714, 0.045360267162323, -0.07548671215772629, -0.04267910495400429, -0.10942032188177109, -0.027135441079735756, 0.026569344103336334, -0.04829736426472664, -0.010547380894422531, 0.020994270220398903, -0.04377548396587372, 0.05783933401107788, -0.06532919406890869, -0.05248195677995682, -0.01638394221663475, 0.0075441147200763226, 0.037368010729551315, -0.0046943058259785175, -0.015975918620824814, -0.05670461803674698, 0.021769804880023003, -0.0116758793592453, 0.005088698118925095, 0.010747895576059818, -0.012413379736244678, -0.06187780573964119, 0.016541318967938423, -0.03295298293232918, -0.006080468650907278, 0.011571980081498623, -0.07371022552251816, -0.016044018790125847, 0.02497924119234085, 0.00008028766751522198, 0.013371954672038555, -0.04759091138839722, -0.011972058564424515, 0.06929154694080353, -0.022552939131855965, -0.024686286225914955, -0.01637825183570385, -0.011233128607273102, 0.0607064813375473, -0.0026795112062245607, -0.009861938655376434, -0.022276876494288445, -0.032566189765930176, 0.0003031066444236785, 0.07139961421489716, -0.05885816738009453, 0.016655322164297104, -0.026841972023248672, -0.035345304757356644, 0.02321431040763855, -0.0075529166497290134, 0.016968047246336937, -0.045069269835948944, 0.004351125098764896, -0.007475307211279869, -0.0008845214615575969, 0.015168432146310806, 0.05768159031867981, -0.014718363992869854, -0.025120358914136887, -0.05990974232554436, 0.005763978231698275, 0.017538513988256454, 0.01209384948015213, -0.048039618879556656, 0.004473020322620869, -0.0344427190721035, 0.009149108082056046, 0.06160682439804077, 0.04421072453260422, 0.03343009203672409, 0.025127409026026726, 0.010174108669161797, 0.04517760127782822, -0.01661352440714836, -0.015110941603779793, -0.008220570161938667, 0.0007686577155254781, -0.05889936536550522, -0.019344979897141457, -0.030779559165239334, 0.04577483981847763, 0.044536102563142776, -0.06701789051294327, -0.01674736477434635, -0.043040383607149124, -0.01284193154424429, 0.0023050156887620687, 0.01895315945148468, -0.055834975093603134, 0.029181160032749176, -0.044445816427469254, -0.03955543041229248, 0.027897482737898827, 0.03713380545377731, 0.014705303125083447, 0.02499285154044628, -0.048614926636219025, -0.014747136272490025, 0.026608383283019066, 0.059984371066093445, -0.015641113743185997, -0.005212981719523668, 0.009089005179703236, -0.008783726021647453, 0.03213951364159584, -0.010498096235096455, 0.001036701025441289, 0.0885281190276146, -0.05465276166796684, -0.02159341238439083, 0.015576799400150776, 0.04717309772968292, -0.03202507272362709, -0.07953453063964844, 0.006545874290168285, -0.027586570009589195, -0.02927066572010517, 0.046553321182727814, 0.04733803868293762, 0.004154026508331299, 0.01668601669371128, -0.006526466459035873, -0.030068431049585342, 0.03412104770541191, -0.016941262409090996, -0.04305678978562355, 0.031462956219911575, 0.027974141761660576, 0.008996181190013885, 0.016653090715408325, -0.014119970612227917, 0.05537520721554756, 0.0493563637137413, 0.006262620911002159, -0.0026334149297326803, 0.06832264363765717, 0.0010089449351653457, -0.012280136346817017, -0.02192838490009308, -0.017190642654895782, -0.01035297755151987, -0.009459618479013443, -0.048296090215444565, 0.04778427258133888, 0.012906934134662151, -0.024876927956938744, -0.01640729047358036, -0.02298020012676716, 0.0235732551664114, 0.030411621555685997, 0.008377437479794025, 0.03714818134903908, 0.08043024688959122, -0.05803976580500603, -0.005663057789206505, 0.029585883021354675, 0.0438440702855587, -0.007787496317178011, 0.009791096672415733, 0.02984916791319847, -0.003881375305354595, -0.0015805780421942472, 0.02581796422600746, 0.026798082515597343, -0.0179470032453537, -0.004002880305051804, 0.04168161377310753, 0.015466051176190376, -0.006427186541259289, 0.021216876804828644, -0.0023406047839671373, 0.06427530199289322, 0.007585405837744474, -0.04045531898736954, 0.009078078903257847, 0.034753113985061646, 0.03786584734916687, 0.03637560084462166, -0.05511687695980072, -0.06082337349653244, -0.038613464683294296, 0.04771285504102707, -0.011336488649249077, -0.06119733676314354, 0.0549476332962513, 0.019162574782967567, -0.004596341866999865, 0.008432439528405666, 0.007183136884123087, 0.0684126764535904, -0.03995063900947571, 0.010613134130835533, -0.004086293280124664, -0.012139925733208656, 0.027425581589341164, -0.04395824298262596, -0.025947364047169685, -0.023413656279444695, 0.03880327567458153, 0.036153364926576614, 0.04021010175347328, -0.02786029689013958, 0.04466650262475014, 0.028772486373782158, 0.03784748911857605, 0.020888425409793854, -0.08365172147750854, 0.022305235266685486, -0.07036847621202469, -0.019411703571677208, -0.03025582805275917, -0.03384160250425339, 0.01066386979073286, 0.04234463348984718, -0.020540712401270866, 0.04136347770690918, -0.01410937961190939, 0.002386491745710373, 0.008933180943131447, -0.09606465697288513, 0.016558606177568436, 0.036399632692337036, 0.04058818146586418, 0.03691132739186287, -0.009447859600186348, -0.03304753452539444, -0.04678383469581604, -0.020261511206626892, 0.022622019052505493, 0.028581926599144936, -0.01571822166442871, 0.03837896138429642, -0.0010478933108970523, -0.029169756919145584, 0.05341508612036705, 0.04877791926264763, 0.036486346274614334, 0.017448710277676582, -0.053871139883995056, 0.013135092332959175, 0.02290262095630169, 0.008181481622159481, 0.013338335789740086, 0.003966260701417923, -0.005357763729989529, 0.08029905706644058, -0.0310857854783535, 0.09143298119306564, 0.03965381905436516, 0.06539556384086609, 0.010663146153092384, 0.03392237424850464, -0.03818940743803978, 0.015886716544628143, -0.010674804449081421, 0.06309287995100021, 0.037683382630348206, 0.04002128913998604, -0.052462976425886154, -0.033846378326416016, -0.01798485778272152, 0.011904665268957615, 0.06999986618757248, 0.07986272871494293, -0.04069457948207855, -0.008015655912458897, -0.0352686382830143, 0.02019503526389599, 0.023997632786631584, -0.04889310523867607, -0.021412866190075874, -0.026584699749946594, -0.0407903715968132, 0.02603830210864544, -0.05601571500301361, -0.002470294013619423, -0.011716167442500591, 0.057475022971630096, 0.06578592211008072, 0.01841365359723568, 0.03126552328467369, -0.03946324437856674, -0.0007485253736376762, 0.04142485186457634, -0.03465856611728668, -0.012817424722015858, 0.007335174363106489, 0.03697590157389641, -0.073379747569561, -0.058213405311107635, -0.03053409978747368, -0.0331149585545063, 0.04119085147976875, 0.009146401658654213, 0.019736336544156075, -0.024487469345331192, -0.047432154417037964, 0.014725014567375183, 0.044351883232593536, 0.011209866032004356, 0.04481370374560356, -0.007616123184561729, -0.027164673432707787, -0.0670870989561081, 0.011140049435198307, 0.08440171927213669, -0.017314918339252472, 0.01384002435952425, -0.020187310874462128, -0.006830309517681599, 0.018223613500595093, 0.059728194028139114, 0.028528187423944473, 0.008985460735857487, -0.03487318381667137, 0.024148616939783096, -0.0019303119042888284, 0.07011348009109497, 0.005420409142971039, -0.01974717155098915, 0.07361611723899841, 0.07574857026338577, -0.047744881361722946, -0.01510477066040039, 0.01646706834435463, -0.01958320289850235, 0.008361672051250935, 0.02077510394155979, 0.0032638171687722206, -0.09507138282060623, -0.022117430344223976, -0.02913064695894718, 0.04013962298631668, -0.0062935734167695045, -0.017487898468971252, 0.008484240621328354, 0.03450969234108925, -0.028669744729995728, 0.016556669026613235, -0.005663228686898947, -0.049211740493774414, 0.010144339874386787, -0.003360435599461198, -0.05932796373963356, -0.037494707852602005, -0.04565806686878204, 0.010594232939183712, -0.031188450753688812, 0.0005006772698834538, -0.00903510581701994, 0.018190795555710793, 0.015491139143705368, -0.03585164621472359, 0.022287802770733833, -0.05646837130188942, 0.02562817744910717, 0.018291154876351357, 0.04147431626915932, -0.002937434706836939, 0.001125793787650764, -0.0017105662263929844, 0.03235899657011032, -0.07878565043210983, -0.03870663419365883, -0.04205808788537979, -0.06810116767883301, -0.029104918241500854, -0.049257371574640274, -0.024071913212537766, -0.003964140545576811, -0.012327614240348339, 0.043252427130937576, -0.02159428410232067, 0.034787617623806, -0.029670853167772293, -0.007529648020863533, -0.009374317713081837, 0.027362830936908722, 0.006534605752676725, 0.005847204010933638, 0.025532489642500877, 0.017706476151943207, -0.0033832727931439877, -0.0031364543829113245, 0.007260843180119991, 0.053225427865982056, 0.007694551721215248, -0.023441316559910774, 0.05157218500971794, 0.011867170222103596, -0.054637305438518524, 0.0281123835593462, -0.0288857314735651, 0.005412171594798565, 0.04017484188079834, 0.010049332864582539, 0.024461112916469574, 0.01742679253220558, 0.03764285892248154, 0.00615757517516613, -0.04769006371498108, -0.03506851568818092, 0.02637016773223877, 0.0020983335562050343, -0.004835141357034445, 0.04964005574584007, 0.027266765013337135, 0.09394184499979019, 0.015331241302192211, -0.054083481431007385, -0.021747000515460968, 0.03057565540075302, 0.03197188675403595, 0.003549374407157302, -0.005140580236911774, -0.0033683963119983673, 0.033244937658309937, -0.03918670862913132, -0.0013482521753758192, -0.023068420588970184, -0.05670269578695297, 0.03379940986633301, -0.022939305752515793, 0.015513928607106209, 0.07909494638442993, -0.00996033102273941, 0.02745911478996277, 0.03173890337347984, -0.0053481487557291985, 0.03385695815086365, 0.020382845774292946, 0.028027087450027466, 0.029609236866235733, 0.012891083024442196, 0.022546421736478806, -0.0007530333823524415, -0.024166004732251167, 0.012981105595827103, -0.03411015495657921, -0.06561361253261566, 0.02268698439002037, 0.051442742347717285, 0.018892910331487656, 0.005314364563673735, -0.10790091753005981, -0.023462461307644844, -0.04166402295231819, -0.011956221424043179, -0.05230621621012688, -0.007823257707059383, 0.014471200294792652, -0.04892311990261078, 0.0034586333204060793, -0.014580314978957176, 0.039792269468307495, -0.001018369453959167, -0.051894400268793106, 0.019514046609401703, -0.06671443581581116, 0.010646023787558079, -0.05480226129293442 ]
<p>Imagine two laser beams A and B are released at the same moment to bounce between two mirrors, A was moving and B was at rest, doing the calculations I found that for a person at rest B would reach the upper mirror before A because in his frame of reference A travels less distance. but for another person in the same reference frame of A, A would reach the upper mirror first. Is that OK in relativity!<img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/MJn2B.jpg" alt="the upper is moving and the lower is constant"></p>
g6606
[ 0.02181377075612545, -0.008677463047206402, 0.010266163386404514, 0.008814582601189613, -0.03161649778485298, 0.056360673159360886, 0.0572727806866169, 0.042063698172569275, -0.031769949942827225, -0.013141375035047531, 0.008496562018990517, 0.028236132115125656, 0.004069095943123102, -0.04608527198433876, 0.018477313220500946, -0.0020821592770516872, 0.09428688883781433, -0.04494059830904007, -0.002780314302071929, 0.01534752082079649, -0.047847457230091095, 0.020766397938132286, -0.03239988908171654, -0.043135955929756165, -0.005175401922315359, -0.0007985663251020014, 0.01693662814795971, 0.00024163037596736103, -0.059140533208847046, -0.01137241069227457, 0.05678736791014671, -0.0076811243779957294, 0.010683608241379261, -0.09360738843679428, 0.006623584311455488, -0.04431542754173279, 0.023976357653737068, 0.03172128275036812, -0.005398005712777376, 0.005874555092304945, 0.05628166347742081, 0.019414477050304413, -0.02649555169045925, -0.018750272691249847, 0.06498976796865463, 0.01293919701129198, 0.037682775408029556, -0.02350383624434471, -0.012641623616218567, -0.005550159141421318, -0.029512567445635796, 0.06696081161499023, -0.034643229097127914, 0.0008103158324956894, 0.06689818203449249, 0.026310663670301437, -0.021854950115084648, -0.02547963336110115, 0.04681461676955223, 0.0070455786772072315, 0.03682207316160202, -0.04385102167725563, 0.006385899614542723, 0.0016405335627496243, 0.06448892503976822, 0.06065867468714714, -0.06670117378234863, -0.0169768538326025, 0.015658175572752953, -0.0566207692027092, -0.019998058676719666, -0.01562649942934513, -0.058626700192689896, -0.0024704081006348133, -0.06472308188676834, 0.023825570940971375, 0.059484656900167465, -0.03162846714258194, -0.034812986850738525, 0.03529461845755577, -0.0841890275478363, -0.012647448107600212, 0.05453457683324814, 0.03790152072906494, 0.06072789803147316, 0.01727883704006672, -0.0326572060585022, 0.08927204459905624, -0.00423812959343195, 0.0020354371517896652, 0.030738554894924164, -0.015123634599149227, 0.10305193811655045, 0.06057514250278473, -0.0548861064016819, -0.003904887707903981, -0.04227079823613167, 0.021425681188702583, 0.02905256114900112, 0.008397894911468029, -0.08796728402376175, 0.03366962820291519, 0.0040648328140378, 0.03393486142158508, 0.021264348179101944, -0.04308755695819855, 0.024419832974672318, 0.0015441963914781809, -0.08145095407962799, -0.03481573611497879, -0.03202517703175545, -0.07491826266050339, -0.0029035680927336216, 0.014193789102137089, -0.07714670896530151, -0.03762780874967575, 0.11020828038454056, -0.0251707024872303, -0.019042519852519035, -0.012095537036657333, 0.04154841974377632, -0.021930351853370667, -0.006706383544951677, 0.07767355442047119, -0.026233762502670288, 0.02382637932896614, -0.025019539520144463, -0.01982863061130047, 0.027916481718420982, 0.04290411248803139, -0.033738717436790466, 0.030914895236492157, 0.031183885410428047, 0.040424227714538574, -0.01132199540734291, 0.0031211739405989647, 0.059808600693941116, -0.03906262293457985, 0.00476166233420372, 0.0236856359988451, 0.03359511122107506, 0.0009437004919163883, 0.005120088346302509, -0.0724022164940834, -0.048002663999795914, 0.03181567043066025, -0.021121375262737274, 0.015194736421108246, 0.02754397504031658, 0.06264420598745346, 0.0010934940073639154, 0.05675709620118141, -0.022710446268320084, -0.018673000857234, 0.025506772100925446, -0.031247559934854507, 0.045235734432935715, 0.008326769806444645, 0.007393528241664171, 0.020977579057216644, 0.06973934173583984, -0.03489615023136139, -0.004258485045284033, -0.028955936431884766, -0.05235305801033974, 0.025213435292243958, 0.018670588731765747, -0.05800776183605194, 0.021163206547498703, -0.027332210913300514, -0.053965695202350616, -0.028944173827767372, -0.00772760808467865, -0.00403461791574955, 0.04791627824306488, 0.04442866891622543, 0.015517991967499256, -0.029176894575357437, -0.013897234573960304, 0.024214863777160645, -0.03879847377538681, -0.045555438846349716, -0.027755631133913994, -0.017744187265634537, -0.00724882772192359, -0.004262432921677828, -0.020969456061720848, -0.04212607815861702, -0.06896759569644928, 0.008034461177885532, -0.013837695121765137, -0.04213897883892059, -0.01323208399116993, -0.006295326631516218, -0.06760820001363754, -0.0052808611653745174, 0.046618878841400146, 0.018997399136424065, -0.06159811466932297, 0.08922872692346573, -0.02625151164829731, 0.031252436339855194, 0.017240559682250023, -0.014102970249950886, -0.0020459219813346863, 0.08143656700849533, 0.021188639104366302, 0.0099727101624012, -0.013925782404839993, -0.025619378313422203, -0.019158296287059784, 0.003318697912618518, 0.04737954959273338, 0.006572169717401266, 0.031685326248407364, 0.0036211805418133736, -0.008393018506467342, -0.0010689902119338512, -0.04433337226510048, 0.056450121104717255, -0.014001172967255116, 0.029407726600766182, 0.03290557116270065, -0.03894232586026192, 0.027349138632416725, -0.037597931921482086, -0.041695691645145416, -0.024074725806713104, -0.0027310028672218323, 0.016975514590740204, -0.02772659622132778, 0.040307383984327316, -0.015522447414696217, -0.004456300754100084, 0.05127904564142227, -0.002687969012185931, 0.03553406894207001, 0.03993964567780495, 0.0373397022485733, 0.046665262430906296, 0.023569392040371895, -0.01371785718947649, -0.01577373407781124, 0.02083343267440796, -0.00404736353084445, 0.0004972800379619002, -0.007849584333598614, -0.02300775609910488, -0.02172231115400791, 0.0028700544498860836, 0.019508980214595795, -0.03874699026346207, -0.0552491657435894, -0.05234554409980774, -0.04360080882906914, -0.0060917893424630165, -0.023768866434693336, 0.0003739234816748649, -0.08312732726335526, -0.0662693977355957, 0.019817613065242767, -0.048212628811597824, 0.024496670812368393, -0.05690820887684822, -0.05844806134700775, -0.004807634279131889, 0.007494771853089333, 0.029542645439505577, -0.007074529770761728, -0.019949723035097122, 0.00031591817969456315, 0.08429691195487976, 0.032135237008333206, 0.02136888913810253, -0.023983687162399292, -0.005751236341893673, -0.0005929329781793058, -0.05002012848854065, -0.032008297741413116, 0.024001803249120712, -0.0631147250533104, 0.05697039142251015, -0.03270244598388672, -0.035522401332855225, 0.036567170172929764, -0.04493067041039467, -0.0012459747958928347, 0.005537078250199556, 0.00008047866867855191, 0.020995646715164185, -0.029357297345995903, 0.06463959068059921, 0.05578826740384102, 0.05172181501984596, 0.013363848440349102, 0.06826107949018478, 0.051253341138362885, -0.033616360276937485, -0.024853244423866272, 0.04568498954176903, -0.024338489398360252, -0.06572453677654266, 0.023243200033903122, -0.030773937702178955, -0.0018482718151062727, -0.026660006493330002, -0.02314477041363716, -0.0134429344907403, 0.01347238291054964, 0.019008830189704895, -0.0023306410294026136, 0.06912443041801453, 0.019519580528140068, -0.00156108767259866, -0.04222794622182846, -0.010608496144413948, 0.018486132845282555, -0.013674207963049412, 0.002570793265476823, 0.031471364200115204, -0.010100431740283966, 0.0001350604579783976, -0.057182494550943375, -0.039541926234960556, 0.03846578672528267, 0.05048849433660507, -0.009100127033889294, 0.02037808857858181, -0.031756553798913956, 0.018666859716176987, 0.01160957757383585, 0.017057884484529495, 0.007801587227731943, -0.010131323710083961, 0.024861352518200874, -0.013946618884801865, -0.03627253696322441, 0.01283384207636118, 0.03761261701583862, 0.015117506496608257, 0.0059297229163348675, 0.047599032521247864, -0.03275572136044502, 0.00004106889900867827, 0.05450383946299553, 0.03232625871896744, 0.01025003008544445, 0.015726033598184586, -0.030839018523693085, -0.011377966962754726, -0.026845457032322884, -0.04041716083884239, -0.003005107631906867, -0.007133759092539549, -0.04836229979991913, 0.026353731751441956, 0.01681435853242874, 0.042989056557416916, -0.021159933879971504, -0.011242100968956947, 0.008393977768719196, -0.0003220939834136516, 0.01391385868191719, 0.015579549595713615, -0.02071012556552887, -0.04718790948390961, -0.06019578129053116, 0.03297628462314606, 0.02152865380048752, 0.028366198763251305, 0.011497152037918568, -0.06198754534125328, -0.01525974553078413, -0.05798831954598427, 0.034994833171367645, -0.005476226564496756, 0.13211797177791595, -0.021626237779855728, -0.054047755897045135, 0.025469768792390823, 0.031560949981212616, 0.03559829294681549, 0.012459473684430122, 0.01710169017314911, 0.026089468970894814, 0.030744250863790512, -0.01891861855983734, -0.03549103066325188, 0.01990010216832161, -0.03758814558386803, 0.02817225456237793, -0.02570437639951706, -0.0016040815971791744, -0.00475357286632061, 0.04118887335062027, 0.04798172041773796, 0.032180044800043106, 0.01809646002948284, 0.016992200165987015, -0.016965487971901894, 0.010192397981882095, 0.051256000995635986, -0.039064373821020126, -0.006159854121506214, -0.06860390305519104, 0.009422571398317814, 0.04629474878311157, 0.03579239919781685, 0.014626824297010899, 0.03557272255420685, -0.045887358486652374, 0.013333845883607864, -0.01790424808859825, -0.05862122029066086, 0.03522650524973869, 0.03819194808602333, -0.004506939090788364, -0.013983878307044506, 0.007711810525506735, 0.04914885014295578, 0.012218410149216652, 0.0982360690832138, 0.10249657928943634, 0.003021474229171872, 0.04583907872438431, 0.06821015477180481, 0.04724908992648125, -0.017702346667647362, 0.009594699367880821, -0.049264561384916306, 0.031598906964063644, 0.075993113219738, -0.0028463981579989195, 0.028015462681651115, -0.041525937616825104, 0.04372454062104225, 0.03574681282043457, 0.015363838523626328, 0.023637782782316208, 0.038726553320884705, 0.037439629435539246, -0.000958409917075187, 0.00613064831122756, -0.026465006172657013, -0.033386632800102234, 0.07297930121421814, -0.04498552531003952, -0.09606672823429108, 0.02704962156713009, -0.06610442698001862, -0.041987452656030655, 0.01982741244137287, -0.011678939685225487, -0.01052871160209179, -0.01903260499238968, -0.03237897902727127, 0.013359606266021729, 0.025421304628252983, 0.019969578832387924, 0.004102564416825771, 0.019455373287200928, 0.03953434154391289, 0.006690225098282099, -0.06368689239025116, 0.026872633025050163, -0.025307556614279747, -0.035455748438835144, -0.0374341756105423, -0.0668628066778183, 0.027970116585493088, 0.01749078929424286, 0.019310705363750458, -0.008037066087126732, 0.033897899091243744, -0.02301030047237873, 0.007428184151649475, 0.03010513074696064, 0.01229016575962305, 0.010929289273917675, -0.005845107138156891, -0.03258273005485535, 0.021640300750732422, 0.05023902654647827, -0.027058951556682587, 0.0041935327462852, 0.009299558587372303, -0.005818681791424751, -0.017713692039251328, 0.02872968278825283, -0.01602618396282196, -0.00783506128937006, -0.049164384603500366, -0.00699643837288022, -0.00008050046017160639, -0.028000418096780777, 0.04959503933787346, -0.035464655607938766, -0.029112068936228752, -0.03197639063000679, -0.00292701437138021, -0.03983859345316887, 0.06225060671567917, 0.02903597429394722, -0.03629697114229202, -0.03551485389471054, 0.023602981120347977, -0.005712601821869612, 0.014748930931091309, -0.027466610074043274, 0.018186673521995544, 0.021325064823031425, 0.015574071556329727, -0.03152632713317871, 0.03512578830122948, -0.0033917019609361887, -0.02822236716747284, 0.06396639347076416, 0.032488737255334854, -0.010524788871407509, -0.0109639847651124, 0.037762172520160675, 0.0292124692350626, 0.016395023092627525, -0.00023246217460837215, -0.03925412520766258, 0.023894188925623894, -0.012063666246831417, 0.015078126452863216, -0.037878602743148804, 0.03438907489180565, 0.0007116292254067957, -0.024772511795163155, 0.03061600774526596, -0.02214929834008217, 0.04478670284152031, -0.027541089802980423, -0.017094384878873825, -0.008497706614434719, 0.011701938696205616, -0.03867417946457863, -0.0614040270447731, 0.004530836828052998, 0.019686024636030197, 0.07462510466575623, 0.01797659508883953, -0.04117465391755104, -0.030742254108190536, -0.017327578738331795, 0.09724417328834534, -0.04505627229809761, -0.007976007647812366, 0.03581830486655235, -0.00586207490414381, 0.052682001143693924, -0.007446323521435261, 0.04546009749174118, 0.0070517477579414845, 0.005035187117755413, 0.01941385306417942, 0.008110066875815392, 0.03058476373553276, -0.01675543002784252, 0.04796670004725456, -0.02272510714828968, -0.028857555240392685, -0.06157904490828514, -0.006726976018399, 0.02260322868824005, 0.02185213565826416, -0.01396831963211298, 0.014349906705319881, -0.007588260807096958, -0.05294567719101906, 0.020710261538624763, 0.00015184222138486803, 0.06536366045475006, -0.07778856158256531, -0.04154336452484131, -0.05273077264428139, 0.02644972689449787, -0.007920010946691036, -0.016531219705939293, 0.004315667320042849, -0.003993540536612272, -0.04335765913128853, 0.01601855456829071, -0.031283967196941376, -0.023378072306513786, 0.01715892367064953, -0.048301033675670624, -0.06339164078235626, -0.05207895115017891, 0.0029650740325450897, -0.011520870961248875, -0.05020708218216896, -0.023522265255451202, 0.002908297348767519, -0.013274493627250195, -0.07406437397003174, 0.07851310074329376, 0.025232970714569092, 0.002079193713143468, 0.08077608048915863, 0.025883866474032402, -0.0502021498978138, 0.04817942529916763, -0.042724449187517166, 0.003009106032550335, 0.038167569786310196, 0.035718657076358795, 0.03929750621318817, 0.012055566534399986, 0.03379032015800476, 0.036248691380023956, -0.028678376227617264, -0.0024509464856237173, -0.038609277456998825, 0.007858618162572384, -0.020632479339838028, 0.0020114537328481674, 0.014340749010443687, -0.06412648409605026, -0.009585625492036343, -0.03269054368138313, 0.004146462306380272, 0.015029476024210453, -0.04356955364346504, 0.009953970089554787, -0.0001170045870821923, 0.059642475098371506, -0.0022262255661189556, -0.043679606169462204, -0.03647830709815025, 0.046372219920158386, 0.018914910033345222, 0.036587778478860855, -0.08933326601982117, 0.04543044790625572, 0.006441000383347273, -0.0020160486456006765, 0.018185235559940338, -0.005710096098482609, -0.007545731030404568, 0.03411238268017769, -0.011274583637714386, -0.01454856712371111, 0.04285532608628273, -0.005935228429734707, -0.08257271349430084, 0.031585801392793655, -0.007493044249713421, -0.03766849264502525, -0.02124159224331379, 0.021535776555538177, -0.0601051039993763, -0.0073528410866856575, -0.012847136706113815, 0.019054211676120758, -0.023997295647859573, -0.0411018431186676, 0.010205594822764397, -0.005246298853307962, -0.015988340601325035, 0.0182502381503582, -0.06381908059120178, -0.042172063142061234, -0.00987941212952137, -0.034556325525045395, 0.0037729383911937475, -0.01959831267595291, 0.003024202771484852, -0.04073294624686241, -0.05357404053211212, 0.002069717040285468, -0.019856998696923256, 0.04895295575261116, -0.028100397437810898, -0.03888050466775894, -0.016412392258644104, -0.013801670633256435, -0.006742184050381184, -0.005672668572515249, 0.01600521057844162, -0.00019454544235486537, -0.08705968409776688, 0.09542074799537659, 0.005742858164012432, -0.034003984183073044, 0.019580073654651642, -0.04895922541618347, -0.049665145576000214, 0.02379167079925537, 0.010288376361131668, -0.03241026774048805, -0.03321180120110512, 0.018174609169363976, 0.03931330516934395, 0.03311935067176819, 0.0055965520441532135, -0.04227786138653755, -0.039140485227108, 0.005873819347470999, 0.03478474169969559, 0.03218284621834755, -0.01353976409882307, 0.0481937974691391, -0.00869505200535059, -0.020362919196486473, 0.02242967113852501, -0.040680892765522, 0.02545098587870598, 0.05314791947603226, 0.024103200063109398, 0.03174711391329765, -0.042271532118320465, -0.00990668497979641, 0.009622614830732346, 0.019641317427158356, 0.017842058092355728, -0.021537788212299347, 0.017480874434113503, 0.003612843342125416, -0.004871048498898745, -0.08180078119039536, -0.04199718311429024, 0.01460601482540369, 0.016172412782907486, -0.03451170399785042, -0.06528837978839874, -0.036065977066755295, 0.0011269082315266132, 0.0011176187545061111, -0.08812418580055237, 0.03853735327720642, 0.008471977896988392, 0.06209815666079521, -0.03894931450486183, -0.02193104662001133, -0.005780258681625128, 0.016585569828748703, -0.013184159062802792, -0.06037730351090431, 0.024584053084254265, -0.020405901595950127, 0.005198670085519552, -0.004729005973786116, 0.043102141469717026, 0.01844559796154499, 0.0018542094621807337, -0.03197738528251648, -0.03386147320270538, 0.045675624161958694, -0.006592568475753069, 0.048784397542476654, 0.10663634538650513, -0.03922325000166893, -0.007330814376473427, -0.015523852780461311, 0.0090021388605237, 0.004471734166145325, -0.03446412831544876, -0.009717978537082672, -0.000782203336711973, -0.012912895530462265, -0.00673486664891243, -0.0050708153285086155, -0.026739465072751045, 0.016896696761250496 ]
<p>The <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vis-viva_equation" rel="nofollow">proof</a> of the vis-viva equation of orbital mechanics found on wikipedia looks, in my opinion, somewhat convoluted and unenlightening. Considering the simplicity and importance of the vis-viva equation, is there a shorter or more insightful derivation?</p> <p>The vis-viva equation states that for a Kepler orbit of a mass around a central mass $M$, the magnitude of the velocity at any distance $r$ from the center obeys $v^2 = GM(\frac{2}{r}-\frac{1}{a})$, where $a$ is the semi-major axis of the orbit. It is equivalent to saying that the energy of a Kepler orbit with semi-major axis $a$ is $-\frac{GM}{2a}$. This is a very natural generalization of the 'circular' case where the total energy is $-\frac{GM}{2r}$.</p> <p>Because of the simplicity of the result, I guessed that there could be a relatively straightforward derivation. The derivation on wikipedia involves quite some algebra and, importantly, only holds for elliptical orbits.</p>
g6607
[ 0.038941722363233566, 0.01838459074497223, 0.002125899773091078, -0.012153361923992634, -0.05247882753610611, -0.019359009340405464, 0.06597879528999329, 0.003965941723436117, 0.011935451067984104, 0.05609515681862831, 0.01275421492755413, 0.03829992935061455, -0.01738055981695652, 0.011486245319247246, 0.05149572342634201, -0.06569625437259674, 0.00848233513534069, -0.0032405778765678406, 0.03571346774697304, 0.09726692736148834, 0.015079930424690247, -0.037167251110076904, -0.013032974675297737, 0.0103989839553833, 0.05274723842740059, 0.014804903417825699, 0.012970414943993092, 0.035259731113910675, -0.012590872123837471, 0.01141798123717308, 0.06292089074850082, -0.02857433818280697, 0.11102863401174545, -0.0615924708545208, 0.002062288811430335, 0.09770193696022034, -0.01769448257982731, -0.02251076139509678, -0.009394912049174309, 0.003511040238663554, -0.033754900097846985, -0.018037846311926842, 0.006828096229583025, 0.03529111295938492, 0.006721221376210451, -0.012063327245414257, -0.03889885172247887, 0.0022804788313806057, -0.042348939925432205, -0.028100987896323204, -0.007868698798120022, 0.05192827060818672, 0.09352105110883713, 0.0036703080404549837, -0.05624677613377571, 0.030685914680361748, 0.07177563011646271, -0.04681405797600746, -0.006399785168468952, 0.06579310446977615, 0.05376110598444939, -0.020284634083509445, -0.028473446145653725, 0.01608116552233696, 0.007037770468741655, -0.02071414329111576, -0.030800873413681984, 0.04139900580048561, 0.004105474334210157, 0.01835046149790287, 0.026559321209788322, 0.0033821784891188145, -0.03101866878569126, -0.042013198137283325, -0.03589148446917534, -0.007161060348153114, 0.021084362640976906, -0.01690840534865856, 0.04579722881317139, -0.0307757705450058, 0.013947311788797379, 0.011883229948580265, 0.02406240813434124, 0.015209956094622612, 0.08241488039493561, -0.07185916602611542, 0.026692697778344154, 0.008928202092647552, -0.030063612386584282, -0.007448282092809677, 0.013286692090332508, -0.004660292528569698, 0.06588225811719894, -0.024263961240649223, -0.031649742275476456, -0.038843441754579544, -0.03102349117398262, 0.053929418325424194, -0.04223600775003433, 0.026778694242239, 0.022627398371696472, 0.0077025615610182285, -0.0003494984994176775, -0.03561234846711159, 0.051532965153455734, -0.00011645806807791814, 0.0032615435775369406, 0.04424702003598213, 0.01102416217327118, -0.006637714337557554, -0.014004289172589779, -0.07044949382543564, -0.020141316577792168, -0.0033614165149629116, -0.05042567476630211, -0.03423222154378891, 0.0701456367969513, -0.030746852979063988, -0.02689715474843979, 0.03535488247871399, -0.007536780089139938, 0.044441770762205124, -0.01382117997854948, 0.09954139590263367, 0.004114989656955004, 0.0017532632919028401, -0.0008860991219989955, -0.013651391491293907, 0.008478295989334583, 0.024664251133799553, 0.0068956962786614895, -0.04406056925654411, 0.024227727204561234, -0.01194673404097557, 0.029471654444932938, 0.024686340242624283, -0.05193158984184265, 0.010832034982740879, -0.07083892077207565, -0.02369779348373413, 0.01653868518769741, -0.03922446444630623, 0.013392782770097256, -0.017756657674908638, -0.07067467272281647, 0.052744559943675995, -0.031303439289331436, 0.010149156674742699, 0.09262716770172119, -0.014541110023856163, -0.01861872896552086, 0.03640669211745262, 0.026561811566352844, -0.07723090797662735, 0.008896763436496258, -0.0377764068543911, -0.020096305757761, -0.013047019019722939, -0.04008681699633598, 0.006745037157088518, 0.055475156754255295, -0.0018387557938694954, 0.06895485520362854, -0.02511262707412243, -0.05244945362210274, 0.061056457459926605, 0.002040153369307518, -0.046220771968364716, 0.00606138538569212, -0.018155904486775398, -0.03251498192548752, -0.027935707941651344, 0.02902047336101532, -0.020176032558083534, -0.07499141991138458, 0.01585419476032257, 0.015108398161828518, -0.01871166005730629, -0.008824777789413929, 0.03614140301942825, 0.008222666569054127, 0.024673011153936386, 0.0159753430634737, -0.05995113030076027, 0.026117147877812386, -0.00710410438477993, 0.03702264279127121, 0.05272413417696953, -0.03999455273151398, 0.014483895152807236, 0.01646607741713524, -0.0325574167072773, 0.04902011528611183, 0.06628492474555969, -0.011189587414264679, 0.0019031284609809518, -0.003902818774804473, -0.0670308917760849, -0.05118698999285698, 0.04008413851261139, 0.010781274177134037, -0.03339657187461853, 0.002483821241185069, 0.013682638294994831, 0.031195683404803276, 0.008487657643854618, -0.012341623194515705, -0.0009780260734260082, 0.07774030417203903, -0.007384194992482662, -0.01044622901827097, -0.04102049022912979, -0.0035265563055872917, 0.0157957561314106, -0.017218492925167084, -0.017174504697322845, 0.015689721331000328, 0.020882200449705124, -0.03245476633310318, 0.049128878861665726, 0.02751990593969822, -0.04782935976982117, 0.00954501610249281, 0.0035617605317384005, 0.007245154585689306, 0.019573047757148743, -0.03204984962940216, -0.02094048075377941, -0.02158728428184986, 0.012248012237250805, -0.0383327379822731, -0.012248185463249683, -0.01575106754899025, 0.0498996339738369, 0.048760510981082916, 0.03167099878191948, -0.01905633509159088, 0.006364582106471062, 0.029600661247968674, 0.017590876668691635, 0.03557958826422691, -0.03332773223519325, -0.010857361368834972, -0.041553888469934464, 0.03486919030547142, -0.04309948906302452, 0.0667281225323677, 0.030011940747499466, 0.05123816803097725, -0.025536291301250458, -0.03584159165620804, -0.06416404992341995, -0.028624841943383217, -0.03347380831837654, 0.0409267321228981, -0.009593917988240719, -0.05006151646375656, 0.03611238673329353, -0.045617230236530304, 0.02182743325829506, -0.015383505262434483, -0.021872112527489662, 0.03300223499536514, 0.04399183765053749, 0.001033422420732677, -0.0037134855519980192, -0.0015231679426506162, -0.008360123261809349, -0.025167223066091537, 0.012586936354637146, -0.006501947063952684, 0.07928704470396042, -0.03442861884832382, 0.03869331628084183, -0.04764751344919205, -0.044493094086647034, -0.03750476986169815, -0.010963023640215397, 0.033741794526576996, 0.003827219596132636, -0.03186338022351265, -0.05040917545557022, 0.0043834904208779335, 0.03652850538492203, 0.030091822147369385, -0.027680063620209694, 0.006616729777306318, 0.06321161240339279, 0.035625748336315155, -0.058552149683237076, 0.046841222792863846, 0.04993578791618347, -0.016311584040522575, 0.0008269732934422791, -0.02353682555258274, 0.0498349703848362, 0.05313679203391075, -0.01595275290310383, 0.02642831951379776, -0.003113617654889822, -0.014970619231462479, -0.04220009595155716, -0.029092110693454742, 0.021746132522821426, -0.047239091247320175, 0.0219427477568388, 0.03383909538388252, -0.06213736906647682, 0.01250634528696537, -0.012148420326411724, 0.03554653003811836, -0.036973368376493454, 0.005234839394688606, -0.010038482025265694, -0.009691230021417141, 0.02207256108522415, 0.007923540659248829, 0.0018291572341695428, 0.01434445008635521, 0.02550429478287697, -0.08653795719146729, -0.03076547384262085, 0.0034029283560812473, 0.03517701476812363, 0.03377244248986244, -0.041571326553821564, -0.029834548011422157, -0.03215987607836723, 0.0037230257876217365, -0.02073250338435173, 0.005915654823184013, 0.02592051401734352, -0.0398898608982563, 0.021739859133958817, 0.008883452974259853, -0.03298942744731903, 0.01065059844404459, 0.041103098541498184, 0.028735121712088585, 0.014055422507226467, -0.007972877472639084, -0.02480951137840748, -0.041419535875320435, 0.03949093818664551, -0.011596303433179855, -0.0007299222052097321, -0.05293526127934456, 0.019820231944322586, 0.030390482395887375, -0.056077174842357635, 0.004012518096715212, -0.01838037371635437, 0.026253648102283478, -0.01986350491642952, -0.03138533979654312, 0.05825736001133919, 0.034594789147377014, -0.013067618012428284, 0.01989963836967945, 0.023400263860821724, -0.0005966089083813131, -0.019130805507302284, 0.008150717243552208, 0.020794162526726723, 0.046989087015390396, -0.017819538712501526, -0.03874213621020317, 0.01381071750074625, -0.0027045549359172583, -0.04427072033286095, -0.0175506342202425, -0.07494231313467026, 0.05847030505537987, -0.033911097794771194, 0.05405205115675926, -0.018999453634023666, 0.004236545413732529, 0.03132975846529007, -0.044520098716020584, 0.0016274044755846262, 0.0767340213060379, -0.021949054673314095, 0.04513942077755928, 0.07926027476787567, -0.0035570317413657904, -0.022355372086167336, -0.08476186543703079, 0.03432691469788551, 0.06178480014204979, -0.03473320230841637, 0.0300961434841156, 0.004265843890607357, 0.04372585564851761, 0.0051255603320896626, 0.07380643486976624, -0.02277541160583496, 0.0024866857565939426, -0.022002289071679115, -0.0413626991212368, 0.04195080325007439, 0.02138330414891243, -0.025595540180802345, -0.005448548123240471, 0.045578472316265106, 0.006955574732273817, 0.04465648531913757, -0.011082516983151436, -0.010566268116235733, -0.02507052570581436, -0.02950921095907688, 0.031393058598041534, -0.022818421944975853, 0.07024948298931122, -0.016289304941892624, 0.00644313357770443, 0.012005426920950413, -0.02257402427494526, -0.020508233457803726, 0.06955858319997787, 0.05885099619626999, -0.0311701949685812, 0.03425320237874985, 0.023300262168049812, -0.0542767196893692, 0.016159484162926674, 0.0706627145409584, 0.024160616099834442, -0.018895134329795837, 0.0035121417604386806, -0.012296538800001144, 0.02976163662970066, 0.026258694007992744, 0.005478931590914726, 0.05343632027506828, -0.04612717032432556, 0.033620890229940414, -0.023578280583024025, 0.051714152097702026, 0.026788709685206413, -0.03495962172746658, -0.0028942818753421307, 0.03975344076752663, -0.006575725506991148, 0.02550734579563141, -0.05924340337514877, -0.0044885980896651745, 0.05039669945836067, -0.023547763004899025, -0.02817418798804283, -0.06722278892993927, -0.032368406653404236, 0.020774440839886665, 0.015673255547881126, 0.013394249603152275, -0.002067810855805874, -0.03801378607749939, -0.03657803684473038, 0.019251251593232155, 0.0037442364264279604, -0.054399922490119934, -0.05547710135579109, -0.023688895627856255, 0.03176001086831093, 0.0541948527097702, 0.14071568846702576, -0.01519734412431717, -0.0021940707229077816, 0.025102758780121803, -0.021351508796215057, 0.005406406242400408, -0.010438334196805954, -0.0018307807622477412, -0.01624380424618721, -0.04034499078989029, -0.0024466689210385084, 0.00585966557264328, -0.003826685016974807, -0.03585748001933098, -0.01909921132028103, -0.04359016194939613, -0.0447547547519207, 0.03392234817147255, 0.022833827883005142, 0.030218053609132767, 0.035598620772361755, 0.0543987937271595, -0.033300358802080154, -0.0207967609167099, 0.002391982590779662, 0.02353236824274063, 0.01653898134827614, 0.008070316165685654, -0.04255761206150055, -0.026752127334475517, 0.05910511314868927, 0.005946107674390078, 0.011918219737708569, -0.06819160282611847, 0.03260422125458717, -0.018908720463514328, -0.09325604140758514, 0.03582380712032318, -0.0407821349799633, -0.02138606645166874, -0.026777442544698715, -0.011903056874871254, 0.0224942397326231, -0.008495111018419266, -0.05360369011759758, 0.03008679673075676, -0.004710859153419733, -0.07251951843500137, -0.03850860148668289, 0.02414310723543167, 0.0084266671910882, -0.036320846527814865, 0.02426835149526596, 0.03503976762294769, 0.03324558958411217, -0.025996102020144463, 0.04936929792165756, -0.002378293080255389, 0.04728023335337639, -0.015411960892379284, 0.019169650971889496, 0.005461095832288265, -0.03591901436448097, -0.062185585498809814, 0.007864084094762802, 0.015113088302314281, -0.056931670755147934, -0.04862634092569351, -0.017121993005275726, -0.004321529064327478, -0.04561441391706467, -0.004523854237049818, -0.05274060368537903, 0.03211776912212372, 0.01837138459086418, -0.01865626871585846, 0.0019701963756233454, -0.013350390829145908, 0.001188906840980053, 0.05188847333192825, -0.03480589762330055, 0.019276177510619164, -0.0416528657078743, -0.03462119400501251, 0.04376187548041344, -0.04957278445363045, -0.05812806263566017, -0.01402609795331955, -0.000927580171264708, -0.004703938495367765, -0.005698123015463352, 0.04915544018149376, -0.01504303514957428, -0.002480175578966737, -0.02919439785182476, -0.012149101123213768, 0.04300890490412712, -0.02041669376194477, 0.02689875289797783, 0.05914635211229324, -0.007394320331513882, -0.03812979534268379, 0.010241426527500153, -0.03841124475002289, 0.06562665849924088, 0.023399559780955315, -0.03170783817768097, 0.03442956879734993, -0.013558450154960155, -0.001246064086444676, 0.06132505461573601, 0.022152990102767944, 0.02193806692957878, -0.0735754519701004, -0.06180880218744278, -0.025014538317918777, 0.003054517088457942, -0.060249026864767075, 0.010668731294572353, 0.010637243278324604, -0.012303918600082397, 0.02786221168935299, -0.04785570129752159, -0.009159225970506668, -0.06337323784828186, -0.03787213936448097, 0.012094386853277683, 0.006330845411866903, -0.05793996527791023, -0.032870400696992874, 0.003971974831074476, -0.027210725471377373, 0.03024279698729515, 0.010371094569563866, 0.0000644691608613357, 0.032839491963386536, -0.009798594750463963, 0.009538456797599792, -0.005577061325311661, -0.0180986151099205, 0.06174984201788902, 0.003814038820564747, 0.012819555588066578, -0.004958644974976778, -0.011035075411200523, -0.009443053044378757, -0.0024465618189424276, 0.07915544509887695, 0.03162291273474693, 0.027727989479899406, 0.009633307345211506, 0.021298592910170555, -0.007437389809638262, 0.0504777655005455, 0.06862016022205353, -0.012949135154485703, -0.03102429024875164, 0.008101454004645348, 0.015215489082038403, 0.001450863666832447, 0.050766367465257645, 0.0064869532361626625, -0.04130478948354721, 0.009602338075637817, 0.09865174442529678, 0.0030468411277979612, 0.017981451004743576, -0.049493953585624695, -0.04810504615306854, 0.024542024359107018, 0.054605502635240555, 0.03203359991312027, -0.06551876664161682, -0.0009098703158088028, 0.000651579990517348, -0.0003465477202553302, -0.029676703736186028, -0.04606943577528, 0.008731053210794926, -0.01854865625500679, -0.04744713753461838, -0.05298592522740364, 0.006763538345694542, 0.027565883472561836, -0.04909462109208107, -0.011897656135261059, 0.031169835478067398, -0.018042705953121185, -0.023236893117427826, -0.0019054566510021687, -0.03559449687600136, -0.02957168035209179, -0.028276152908802032, -0.023697348311543465, 0.0533595010638237, -0.03319700434803963, 0.005942516960203648, 0.024201225489377975, 0.0005011619068682194, -0.008806006982922554, 0.008720087818801403, 0.004025101661682129, -0.0042771827429533005, -0.048365313559770584, 0.004419660661369562, -0.05841078236699104, 0.017401104792952538, 0.017625337466597557, -0.030526112765073776, -0.034668974578380585, -0.056286539882421494, 0.030677318572998047, -0.020620839670300484, -0.037543412297964096, -0.033525314182043076, 0.01768043078482151, -0.04588638246059418, -0.005228483583778143, 0.04188057407736778, 0.03389784321188927, -0.042525362223386765, -0.012443098239600658, -0.006574075669050217, -0.014313901774585247, -0.008253023028373718, 0.028808269649744034, -0.0018288283608853817, 0.031760137528181076, 0.054699160158634186, -0.01616273634135723, -0.015021908096969128, 0.016723619773983955, 0.029340730980038643, 0.07475216686725616, 0.037736956030130386, 0.007014730013906956, 0.04013520106673241, -0.006302980240434408, 0.017311355099081993, 0.03269673511385918, 0.05321675166487694, 0.07952257990837097, 0.024175496771931648, 0.011475817300379276, -0.05386384204030037, -0.03801373764872551, 0.017171060666441917, -0.01469434518367052, -0.011992285959422588, -0.029088234528899193, 0.008468931540846825, -0.00897893961519003, -0.018036969006061554, 0.08273446559906006, -0.029691198840737343, -0.021796060726046562, -0.004884897265583277, -0.04618826508522034, 0.006617517676204443, -0.08106596767902374, 0.027923347428441048, 0.017052896320819855, 0.016882581636309624, -0.10426678508520126, 0.023902274668216705, -0.08024588227272034, -0.010331539437174797, -0.015171335078775883, -0.013760500587522984, 0.05203478783369064, -0.039620351046323776, -0.008915109559893608, 0.009630040265619755, -0.061035383492708206, 0.01463035587221384, -0.006267774384468794, -0.018671128898859024, -0.11382389068603516, 0.015110911801457405, -0.04419751092791557, -0.02444666251540184, 0.023337477818131447, -0.00814367737621069, 0.024965886026620865, 0.021392781287431717, -0.062362004071474075, 0.06097016856074333, -0.002012416487559676, -0.045569006353616714, -0.01999186910688877, 0.06847801804542542, -0.03687548637390137, -0.003005693666636944, -0.06401179730892181, -0.020932737737894058, 0.043393924832344055, -0.04982161894440651, -0.0028472135309129953, 0.01575830578804016, -0.003052885178476572, 0.006861743051558733, -0.08875461667776108, -0.01756044290959835, 0.06308021396398544 ]
<p>Lately I'm reading about surface enhanced fluorescence. In many articles I can see that <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluorophore" rel="nofollow">fluorophores</a> are called "dipoles". Is it because that they can be modelled by a vibrating electric dipole? Or maybe they are all chemical dipoles?</p>
g6608
[ 0.0037829559296369553, 0.02598509006202221, -0.007738992106169462, 0.020215744152665138, 0.06331121921539307, -0.011963516473770142, 0.0008764528320170939, -0.011904960498213768, 0.014948609285056591, -0.03508121892809868, -0.056798774749040604, -0.03256211057305336, 0.0397040955722332, -0.019805176183581352, -0.010645387694239616, -0.016907919198274612, 0.012018628418445587, -0.00032082773395814, 0.05356653779745102, 0.010426240973174572, 0.02569308504462242, -0.004828457720577717, -0.056632254272699356, -0.0313890315592289, -0.04476405680179596, 0.025432292371988297, -0.029433881863951683, -0.026064738631248474, -0.015332072041928768, -0.039689190685749054, -0.03629516065120697, -0.043870456516742706, 0.03179222345352173, 0.04309578984975815, 0.0764356479048729, -0.05748404562473297, -0.04305548220872879, 0.04690719023346901, 0.01247324701398611, 0.026573047041893005, 0.03077169694006443, 0.05075247958302498, 0.029482360929250717, -0.007691843435168266, -0.00845859944820404, -0.02659459225833416, -0.005342901684343815, -0.03601430356502533, 0.01858619600534439, 0.006989220157265663, 0.031048009172081947, 0.0006537188892252743, 0.010445174761116505, 0.006944046355783939, 0.04009237512946129, -0.028796859085559845, 0.018453804776072502, 0.0335145927965641, 0.0019529364071786404, 0.040434081107378006, -0.038246557116508484, 0.07159047573804855, 0.009470995515584946, 0.005471772514283657, 0.029153166338801384, -0.022205309942364693, -0.010080913081765175, -0.09402220696210861, 0.05957767739892006, -0.024008404463529587, -0.007964449003338814, 0.04147884622216225, -0.07592739909887314, -0.010995902121067047, -0.007123319432139397, 0.06552191823720932, -0.03192480280995369, 0.002434111898764968, 0.0214379969984293, -0.022240279242396355, -0.018307341262698174, 0.0015784390270709991, -0.03260029852390289, -0.007576585281640291, 0.08055420219898224, 0.026120688766241074, -0.08443485200405121, 0.003042179625481367, 0.02359081618487835, -0.03396470099687576, 0.01135147362947464, -0.03270889073610306, 0.04752974584698677, -0.023680003359913826, -0.05968688055872917, -0.020842408761382103, -0.008776812814176083, 0.041666340082883835, -0.012783577665686607, -0.05677146092057228, -0.06561891734600067, 0.017488732933998108, 0.06753380596637726, -0.016886724159121513, 0.011320865713059902, 0.011504756286740303, 0.0022124843671917915, -0.07127002626657486, 0.00911136344075203, 0.034833647310733795, -0.02782084047794342, 0.016834694892168045, -0.00796311441808939, -0.004775636363774538, 0.00970317143946886, -0.02102907933294773, 0.03689424693584442, -0.011921346187591553, -0.006647386122494936, 0.05702348053455353, 0.03342919424176216, 0.03243290260434151, 0.001886174432002008, 0.0003610800486057997, -0.023515839129686356, 0.04900343343615532, 0.05856892839074135, 0.016236646100878716, 0.02267523668706417, -0.05074182152748108, 0.02910510264337063, -0.007203199435025454, -0.04587126895785332, 0.005435553845018148, 0.06412064284086227, 0.010009423829615116, 0.014084454625844955, -0.04232362285256386, -0.018834611400961876, 0.04290667921304703, 0.06193167343735695, -0.02118007466197014, 0.02192540280520916, -0.04093077778816223, -0.0039451839402318, -0.006787542253732681, -0.026952018961310387, 0.031164109706878662, 0.0657576248049736, 0.020932065322995186, -0.013642226345837116, 0.07417027652263641, 0.04315004497766495, -0.07897309213876724, -0.012786146253347397, -0.07334434986114502, 0.03372601047158241, 0.02589436061680317, 0.006360890809446573, 0.017598042264580727, 0.017111701890826225, -0.027582291513681412, -0.024286171421408653, -0.025288211181759834, -0.05493833124637604, -0.035565316677093506, 0.03178972005844116, -0.06747990846633911, -0.040189243853092194, -0.015314080752432346, -0.01492090243846178, 0.031022831797599792, 0.026709437370300293, 0.026434263214468956, 0.02061302401125431, 0.02110270969569683, -0.04229030758142471, -0.010835884138941765, -0.006747619714587927, 0.014399048872292042, -0.07681164890527725, 0.004522486589848995, -0.006127760745584965, 0.015798553824424744, 0.020366180688142776, 0.017993902787566185, -0.03546448051929474, -0.03847465291619301, -0.041539981961250305, 0.04167333245277405, -0.023316092789173126, -0.010656949132680893, 0.07488391548395157, -0.02575528435409069, -0.015843601897358894, 0.002605603775009513, -0.015425672754645348, -0.052069466561079025, 0.01222250983119011, 0.0009439805871807039, 0.003921348601579666, 0.003113384358584881, 0.010728511959314346, -0.018217364326119423, -0.028834398835897446, 0.011977650225162506, 0.0006812714273110032, -0.04102350398898125, 0.024300511926412582, -0.0059322514571249485, 0.033704690635204315, -0.01899036578834057, -0.012283234857022762, 0.01834929920732975, -0.019185282289981842, -0.02450086735188961, -0.03383563086390495, 0.0204648207873106, -0.002087334170937538, 0.008424554951488972, -0.011307699605822563, -0.015087448991835117, 0.06170212849974632, 0.05306928977370262, 0.022557292133569717, 0.00601983442902565, 0.011201679706573486, 0.00868633296340704, 0.010848663747310638, 0.060461197048425674, -0.0458526648581028, -0.07128388434648514, 0.01024243887513876, -0.010531594976782799, 0.028373321518301964, 0.017925914376974106, -0.05298979952931404, 0.02249147929251194, -0.06703683733940125, 0.006993025541305542, 0.0332980640232563, -0.028475457802414894, 0.011287009343504906, 0.024480126798152924, -0.0703425258398056, -0.004946645349264145, -0.013076256029307842, 0.016598496586084366, 0.014306719414889812, 0.0441349633038044, 0.07373179495334625, -0.03535613790154457, 0.021446766331791878, 0.06314847618341446, -0.00223681447096169, 0.007726711221039295, -0.011482523754239082, 0.0344175286591053, -0.004921811632812023, -0.002518868073821068, 0.0033259261399507523, 0.0010134016629308462, -0.0011841986561194062, -0.0010621591936796904, -0.017648939043283463, 0.017314080148935318, -0.015685569494962692, 0.01070950273424387, -0.047251611948013306, 0.03537905588746071, -0.040298428386449814, 0.03241821005940437, -0.029520457610487938, -0.06688033044338226, 0.010633078403770924, 0.0213017575442791, 0.0409446656703949, 0.054733436554670334, 0.04325152933597565, -0.0070978798903524876, 0.056444041430950165, 0.022258227691054344, -0.008881612680852413, -0.02009088546037674, -0.046255722641944885, -0.000630101072601974, 0.03620022162795067, -0.01975305937230587, -0.047828879207372665, -0.06356541812419891, -0.007827318273484707, -0.04055800661444664, 0.027300212532281876, -0.03567645698785782, -0.09055210649967194, 0.009639390744268894, 0.025422725826501846, -0.01252452377229929, -0.028473129495978355, 0.1257845014333725, 0.03394605591893196, 0.02314901165664196, -0.005967267788946629, 0.028248416259884834, 0.00260357279330492, 0.0500992089509964, -0.001144600915722549, -0.04035768285393715, -0.012977082282304764, 0.018994182348251343, -0.0019066083477810025, 0.06856545060873032, -0.005248982924968004, 0.06281740218400955, -0.009780092164874077, -0.0035869551356881857, -0.027647262439131737, -0.020472699776291847, 0.06893914937973022, -0.010850601829588413, -0.04239974543452263, -0.0028277658857405186, -0.060535166412591934, -0.00036714482121169567, 0.06012154743075371, 0.002993715228512883, -0.044345930218696594, -0.002955222735181451, -0.034523848444223404, -0.06962230056524277, 0.056739259511232376, -0.0069539411924779415, -0.0811815857887268, -0.05325606092810631, 0.010131056420505047, -0.08010400086641312, -0.057462502270936966, 0.0680830180644989, 0.02872401848435402, -0.012022227048873901, 0.027837051078677177, 0.005220192484557629, -0.03284977376461029, -0.026555834338068962, -0.04771541804075241, 0.0814656987786293, -0.035535696893930435, 0.0026412452571094036, -0.00044095134944655, -0.05016377195715904, 0.03338487073779106, 0.07843155413866043, 0.020196327939629555, 0.026975423097610474, -0.011504295282065868, -0.06982266157865524, 0.0419650599360466, -0.0323861762881279, 0.0019183249678462744, -0.02187490090727806, 0.07520180940628052, 0.03854461386799812, 0.022009072825312614, -0.01734628714621067, -0.002652037190273404, -0.0339137464761734, -0.010029521770775318, 0.05649262294173241, 0.0018702332163229585, -0.07907173037528992, -0.02014726772904396, 0.03506524860858917, -0.03214442729949951, -0.009770398028194904, 0.013143370859324932, 0.021423855796456337, -0.010994039475917816, -0.01784597896039486, -0.09829778969287872, -0.017290230840444565, -0.007612144108861685, 0.0589645579457283, 0.05236022546887398, 0.03210895135998726, 0.009839149191975594, -0.013228127732872963, -0.028966130688786507, 0.017744189128279686, 0.010063864290714264, -0.016889629885554314, -0.012268801219761372, 0.01255671214312315, 0.03277793899178505, -0.033450573682785034, -0.007100328803062439, -0.06315878033638, 0.026446308940649033, -0.06662031263113022, 0.025830453261733055, 0.04341943562030792, 0.059821419417858124, -0.023156525567173958, 0.011860690079629421, 0.0007847115630283952, 0.030196404084563255, -0.004811235703527927, -0.0007799836457706988, -0.03770378977060318, -0.009451061487197876, -0.005839311517775059, -0.06130434572696686, 0.029150325804948807, 0.003634409513324499, -0.009613689966499805, -0.0027110627852380276, 0.08355136960744858, -0.003304488258436322, -0.06328567117452621, -0.0367928072810173, 0.02548707090318203, 0.006410600617527962, 0.04479411616921425, 0.019106358289718628, 0.003198920050635934, 0.009853359311819077, 0.002694726223126054, 0.007910773158073425, 0.02492992766201496, -0.024568965658545494, -0.08690007030963898, -0.01824728585779667, -0.037051789462566376, 0.020208677276968956, 0.0003745074209291488, -0.04893814027309418, 0.015109796077013016, -0.030206333845853806, 0.008882974274456501, 0.04807552322745323, 0.08046533167362213, 0.06844130158424377, 0.0074942344799637794, 0.001275204005651176, 0.02804916352033615, 0.034992434084415436, 0.04356915503740311, -0.02235015295445919, -0.004256764426827431, -0.04041149467229843, 0.008771823719143867, -0.09415490180253983, 0.02234267070889473, -0.07402694225311279, -0.022291896864771843, 0.029224781319499016, -0.03183802589774132, -0.06341421604156494, -0.025534290820360184, -0.009043829515576363, 0.02943282760679722, -0.015138785354793072, -0.011029081419110298, 0.015949012711644173, -0.0561598502099514, 0.02768334560096264, 0.02525273896753788, -0.0017559746047481894, -0.06845401227474213, -0.08124591410160065, -0.055319320410490036, -0.050196025520563126, 0.010145191103219986, 0.03127146139740944, 0.027430368587374687, 0.026260625571012497, -0.029403099790215492, 0.05890382453799248, -0.001639183727093041, -0.017540017142891884, -0.07901574671268463, 0.015194532461464405, -0.003899817820638418, 0.045296233147382736, -0.007493554148823023, 0.026994381099939346, -0.011590249836444855, 0.02856249175965786, 0.03284591808915138, -0.04383400082588196, 0.0018561023753136396, -0.00019807732314802706, -0.02745869569480419, -0.044264908879995346, -0.02428758144378662, -0.031906720250844955, -0.043425120413303375, -0.020790789276361465, 0.01356783602386713, 0.02248760312795639, 0.0010891662677749991, -0.03355376422405243, 0.017241746187210083, 0.033553265035152435, 0.013732727617025375, 0.036685772240161896, 0.04819582775235176, 0.017274007201194763, -0.07798558473587036, 0.02365703135728836, 0.011679047718644142, -0.02429514192044735, -0.041900474578142166, -0.013357170857489109, 0.040112875401973724, 0.028639961034059525, -0.017038023099303246, -0.01816965825855732, 0.06428580731153488, -0.03642326965928078, 0.010640685446560383, -0.0015991086838766932, -0.06872197985649109, -0.001962082926183939, -0.028815748170018196, -0.016877038404345512, 0.00021562115580309182, -0.01555752195417881, -0.0003570617700461298, 0.08822029829025269, 0.060817163437604904, 0.032375674694776535, 0.031078524887561798, 0.020663436502218246, 0.06956914067268372, 0.037760015577077866, -0.03148934990167618, 0.02014303393661976, 0.012225369922816753, -0.0013366873608902097, 0.0519464910030365, -0.01716582104563713, 0.025741565972566605, 0.049651145935058594, 0.039554156363010406, 0.03362356498837471, -0.0005344655364751816, 0.07132332026958466, -0.0025518008042126894, 0.011844576336443424, 0.015561860054731369, -0.01543337944895029, -0.011211633682250977, 0.03542187437415123, 0.020370040088891983, 0.0036167690996080637, 0.0035001998767256737, 0.0015646808315068483, 0.002254984574392438, 0.028054680675268173, -0.08142866939306259, -0.005374821834266186, 0.05297021195292473, 0.013184040784835815, -0.017465734854340553, 0.02161264419555664, 0.021392762660980225, -0.03261023759841919, 0.006876888684928417, 0.010242351330816746, 0.009356589987874031, -0.02051462046802044, -0.01873200573027134, -0.038203686475753784, 0.02208358235657215, -0.037143055349588394, -0.014351685531437397, 0.032498035579919815, 0.008298522792756557, -0.043347541242837906, 0.04449706897139549, -0.012983324006199837, -0.04086383059620857, -0.012497102841734886, -0.04883098974823952, 0.005508639384061098, -0.005535533186048269, -0.026079855859279633, -0.008616868406534195, 0.04030106961727142, -0.028644397854804993, -0.023098058998584747, -0.04601171985268593, -0.04530492424964905, -0.03263173624873161, -0.01786007359623909, -0.0341777466237545, -0.034329045563936234, 0.03511140123009682, 0.026506397873163223, 0.05426992103457451, 0.0378408282995224, -0.010456726886332035, -0.0029403797816485167, -0.005846838001161814, 0.0772305503487587, -0.003880404867231846, 0.01143404096364975, 0.03344034403562546, 0.005943709053099155, -0.044508520513772964, 0.009849381633102894, 0.012376982718706131, -0.04706040397286415, -0.07043670117855072, -0.01960906572639942, -0.07372285425662994, -0.06404602527618408, -0.02526162564754486, 0.00919809378683567, 0.019561534747481346, -0.0461495965719223, -0.06200781837105751, 0.03626413270831108, 0.001626819372177124, -0.014697303995490074, 0.024151982739567757, -0.0539933405816555, 0.05647161975502968, 0.025437379255890846, 0.010172929614782333, 0.01601131446659565, 0.05479227006435394, 0.01409195177257061, 0.05050121620297432, 0.020832275971770287, 0.02065780572593212, -0.04910412058234215, -0.0018547708168625832, 0.04111278057098389, 0.019902890548110008, -0.04789227992296219, 0.03905809670686722, 0.07285533100366592, 0.05505950376391411, 0.024890845641493797, 0.018114883452653885, -0.017329847440123558, -0.009280539117753506, 0.03882382810115814, 0.011411377228796482, -0.010269710794091225, -0.0791577398777008, -0.05864189565181732, 0.0857151597738266, 0.004591172095388174, 0.030217088758945465, 0.028617870062589645, -0.0021241039503365755, -0.006632505916059017, 0.04333878308534622, -0.04459051415324211, -0.05650896579027176, 0.012187642976641655, -0.06586775928735733, 0.0491417795419693, 0.060940325260162354, 0.015121720731258392, -0.011798548512160778, -0.024000106379389763, 0.02143160253763199, -0.003970046993345022, -0.018579084426164627, 0.03176366165280342, -0.05929349362850189, -0.017759134992957115, 0.03434505686163902, -0.024325747042894363, 0.031130574643611908, 0.02689124271273613, -0.05524720624089241, -0.005952191539108753, 0.028279148042201996, 0.06695795059204102, -0.08701980859041214, -0.057605162262916565, -0.02095065265893936, -0.009787227027118206, 0.02098138816654682, 0.0022922521457076073, -0.04470687359571457, 0.03653504326939583, -0.003501236904412508, -0.060387395322322845, 0.02198662795126438, -0.01758919656276703, -0.031620681285858154, -0.00023970774782355875, 0.001199629856273532, 0.03618301823735237, -0.03792358189821243, -0.016174903139472008, -0.0066135902889072895, -0.008350993506610394, 0.011166197247803211, -0.009461767971515656, -0.03111433982849121, -0.029163595288991928, -0.014557743445038795, 0.0028609491419047117, 0.0332033596932888, -0.030636413022875786, 0.05482158809900284, 0.019286727532744408, 0.036967769265174866, -0.004510136786848307, 0.015361901372671127, -0.011922172270715237, 0.029165053740143776, -0.058513712137937546, -0.013601607643067837, 0.014866742305457592, 0.008109736256301403, -0.01695656031370163, 0.014336920343339443, -0.0025659119710326195, 0.042160484939813614, 0.014725559391081333, 0.023413371294736862, 0.04208769649267197, 0.01233291532844305, -0.017318248748779297, -0.00006399888661690056, -0.026160024106502533, 0.04729336500167847, -0.07680180668830872, 0.04689192399382591, 0.07858417183160782, 0.012950530275702477, -0.046455852687358856, 0.033353593200445175, 0.02569090574979782, -0.0565585121512413, 0.04534019157290459, -0.01283628772944212, -0.05116413161158562, -0.008758717216551304, -0.011103831231594086, -0.0045568253844976425, -0.0037110347766429186, 0.06380753219127655, -0.05821426957845688, 0.014099855907261372, 0.04392939433455467, 0.012252794578671455, 0.03648272529244423, -0.027405904605984688, -0.01160606648772955, 0.06571294367313385, 0.04731735959649086, -0.008942020125687122, -0.05209203064441681, 0.04850073531270027, 0.028537482023239136, -0.0015764404088258743, -0.03664879873394966, -0.024288905784487724, -0.025015514343976974, 0.021928761154413223 ]
<p>I saw the following way of derivation of Maxwell equations: author starts from Lorentz transformations for the 3-vector of force, then he applies them for the Coulomb law, after that gets the Lorentz force law with expressions for $\mathbf E $ and for $\mathbf B$ fields, then he takes curl and divergence and, finally, he derives the Maxwell equation for the field of charge moving with constant speed. </p> <p>After that he uses a few axioms: superposition principle and independence of equations on acceleration, and generalizes equations on all electrodynamical processes.</p> <p>But I have some doubts about this method. The most problematic question is followIng: there are EM fields of electric and magnetic type. For the first one $\mathbf E^{2} - \mathbf B^{2} &gt; 0$, for the second one - $\mathbf E^{2} - \mathbf B^{2} &lt; 0$. But the author have started from the electric type, so he can't generalize final result on all EM processes. </p> <p>The question: can we violate this argument against this methot of derivation by introducing some other argument?</p>
g6609
[ 0.06578338891267776, 0.02566925808787346, -0.007657061330974102, 0.028762424364686012, 0.09093473106622696, 0.02829000912606716, 0.09306734055280685, 0.002412329660728574, -0.014346102252602577, 0.03227051720023155, -0.018437154591083527, -0.01167666632682085, -0.007936883717775345, 0.024675505235791206, -0.030839456245303154, -0.05840473994612694, 0.06294789165258408, -0.04967629909515381, 0.008120379410684109, 0.031734514981508255, 0.010684658773243427, 0.04736777022480965, -0.018263233825564384, -0.055500905960798264, 0.002790718572214246, -0.04812713339924812, 0.058570269495248795, -0.05668342486023903, -0.021668419241905212, -0.06956863403320312, -0.006175206042826176, 0.01773579977452755, 0.039132010191679, -0.06731420010328293, 0.0014256596332415938, -0.04355385899543762, 0.042122598737478256, 0.0018208222463726997, 0.005367593374103308, 0.027275357395410538, 0.030552491545677185, -0.012652777135372162, 0.04310234263539314, 0.005827305372804403, 0.015901442617177963, -0.03161832317709923, -0.022345175966620445, -0.0006422497099265456, -0.05819873511791229, -0.014533178880810738, 0.0064178393222391605, 0.008268141187727451, 0.06421488523483276, -0.06045851856470108, -0.03235138580203056, 0.029888756573200226, 0.03557325154542923, -0.035107892006635666, 0.008737755008041859, 0.008860676549375057, -0.04427552968263626, -0.06384968757629395, 0.053859103471040726, 0.03398386389017105, 0.022220440208911896, 0.000964659615419805, -0.030656585469841957, 0.0031702578999102116, 0.00388951413333416, 0.02094622328877449, 0.022257447242736816, -0.057651422917842865, 0.012150092981755733, -0.018552593886852264, -0.04525759443640709, -0.018472595140337944, 0.024967696517705917, -0.01682935282588005, 0.011266140267252922, -0.009895090945065022, -0.03703703358769417, 0.04109107330441475, 0.016051707789301872, 0.0026451179292052984, 0.05903451889753342, 0.008004896342754364, 0.022951442748308182, 0.0181158185005188, 0.03371764346957207, -0.02224547415971756, -0.019847499206662178, -0.031058190390467644, 0.046698134392499924, 0.040684085339307785, -0.03698917105793953, -0.011908648535609245, 0.004810050129890442, 0.05635027959942818, 0.02189844287931919, -0.060117222368717194, -0.031077271327376366, 0.013506042771041393, -0.011853931471705437, 0.010470916517078876, 0.009767758660018444, -0.02785332500934601, -0.025164572522044182, 0.04296015575528145, 0.01697925291955471, -0.00806920975446701, -0.04635144770145416, -0.022720862179994583, -0.03731311112642288, 0.014217649586498737, -0.04578321799635887, -0.026818780228495598, -0.0046620131470263, 0.015168868936598301, -0.015971792861819267, 0.05294742435216904, 0.04785711690783501, -0.001574288704432547, -0.0009581746417097747, 0.022708507254719734, -0.03834937512874603, -0.03052610717713833, -0.05829374119639397, -0.0007810810930095613, 0.019698815420269966, -0.034884706139564514, 0.024477027356624603, -0.012559640221297741, 0.09070250391960144, 0.009663610719144344, -0.02192578837275505, 0.042739201337099075, -0.01906372234225273, -0.000059354453696869314, -0.032859865576028824, -0.04346933215856552, 0.04397391900420189, -0.059491727501153946, 0.04643696919083595, -0.02898879162967205, -0.04277702793478966, 0.04716629907488823, -0.012387748807668686, -0.013281640596687794, 0.055762674659490585, 0.07289983332157135, -0.009828498587012291, 0.06638812273740768, -0.006272472906857729, 0.01166943833231926, 0.05134843662381172, 0.02365889959037304, 0.012295417487621307, -0.012189664877951145, -0.011338970623910427, 0.0395001657307148, 0.04966358467936516, -0.05305495858192444, 0.029446916654706, 0.03759089857339859, 0.006797286681830883, 0.013948985375463963, -0.016582775861024857, -0.02140691876411438, -0.024426233023405075, -0.06313659250736237, -0.03806259110569954, 0.0059395139105618, 0.026005884632468224, -0.007603244855999947, -0.0015820334665477276, 0.01774597354233265, -0.013791289180517197, -0.05602962151169777, -0.04018392413854599, -0.025564629584550858, -0.09747034311294556, 0.0035840924829244614, 0.0273554939776659, -0.0013528808485716581, 0.013536026701331139, 0.0003038315335288644, -0.02816300094127655, 0.05376961827278137, -0.03369831293821335, -0.003753348020836711, -0.012509340420365334, 0.03175538033246994, -0.048632796853780746, 0.048879917711019516, -0.03840499371290207, 0.041285548359155655, 0.014974556863307953, -0.0223374180495739, 0.02441023662686348, 0.0330190509557724, 0.011467553675174713, 0.10731226205825806, 0.015572297386825085, -0.0114158159121871, 0.016450949013233185, -0.003899983363226056, -0.028829505667090416, -0.018412215635180473, 0.01787259429693222, 0.010289479047060013, 0.05973992124199867, -0.0007841480546630919, -0.0324694998562336, 0.0019216669024899602, -0.010233079083263874, -0.048081912100315094, -0.011532352305948734, 0.009127872064709663, -0.05682693421840668, 0.029759811237454414, -0.09852287173271179, -0.04847671836614609, 0.02748231776058674, 0.013587282970547676, -0.04621446505188942, -0.008801286108791828, -0.0012293189065530896, -0.03725928068161011, 0.0022680971305817366, -0.014251119457185268, -0.05519138276576996, 0.004447458311915398, -0.027942828834056854, -0.05200740322470665, 0.07516756653785706, 0.01815262995660305, -0.00198067887686193, 0.014265051111578941, 0.03722050413489342, 0.046925682574510574, 0.03412641957402229, 0.0043509602546691895, 0.07861807942390442, -0.04690191522240639, -0.005199220031499863, -0.07716897875070572, 0.10695294290781021, -0.018111862242221832, 0.021902715787291527, -0.03776697814464569, 0.01760018616914749, -0.05165902525186539, 0.01719268597662449, 0.016838911920785904, 0.011618208140134811, -0.02910124510526657, -0.007226251065731049, 0.06229514256119728, -0.002502841642126441, 0.03138403594493866, 0.002459739102050662, 0.025393323972821236, 0.024566615000367165, 0.0709308460354805, -0.06506925821304321, 0.0034890100359916687, -0.052426788955926895, 0.02038564719259739, 0.005889125168323517, -0.0014945943839848042, -0.09442585706710815, 0.041281357407569885, -0.056023284792900085, 0.030481845140457153, -0.02301529049873352, -0.03347494825720787, 0.01003951020538807, -0.05197976902127266, 0.06436195969581604, 0.007538718171417713, -0.044118449091911316, -0.05156440660357475, 0.009885400533676147, 0.013661563396453857, 0.02984495833516121, -0.02415987104177475, -0.04817494750022888, -0.04800627380609512, -0.023917343467473984, 0.006690491922199726, -0.02421249821782112, -0.017939060926437378, 0.03805918246507645, -0.04690372571349144, -0.03399128466844559, 0.03154267370700836, -0.009448178112506866, -0.10889871418476105, -0.02404208667576313, 0.0013883166247978806, 0.02008768543601036, -0.0011472278274595737, 0.013563660904765129, 0.007908089086413383, 0.07957777380943298, 0.053478192538022995, -0.05410115048289299, -0.05297352373600006, 0.059248458594083786, -0.010552183724939823, -0.022154588252305984, 0.004883396439254284, 0.02540968917310238, 0.030742255970835686, -0.009800786152482033, 0.0061531332321465015, 0.031392309814691544, -0.03637039661407471, 0.072353295981884, 0.0159431342035532, -0.08653577417135239, -0.06311659514904022, 0.030946392565965652, -0.02085341140627861, 0.04050496593117714, 0.018604233860969543, -0.01321800984442234, 0.01170816645026207, -0.003598095616325736, 0.014890365302562714, 0.002732943743467331, 0.03420078381896019, 0.019573908299207687, 0.016292760148644447, -0.00537201389670372, -0.003943572286516428, -0.006844197865575552, 0.058595407754182816, 0.014334974810481071, -0.05651050806045532, 0.019700465723872185, -0.06382544338703156, -0.0854506641626358, 0.017747962847352028, -0.037458695471286774, 0.015265116468071938, -0.013561531901359558, -0.03553237393498421, 0.0407799556851387, -0.008254249580204487, 0.0043633971363306046, -0.03481560945510864, 0.03148884326219559, 0.04447543993592262, -0.05257623642683029, -0.007893561385571957, 0.016059085726737976, 0.02440846897661686, 0.010843043215572834, 0.02975825034081936, 0.023310178890824318, 0.00030116495327092707, 0.015574432909488678, 0.010357819497585297, -0.01258711889386177, 0.012693505734205246, -0.018669046461582184, 0.08007942140102386, -0.038328371942043304, -0.03872879222035408, -0.00041546791908331215, -0.07069722563028336, 0.014652034267783165, -0.017338931560516357, 0.026300717145204544, -0.03485662490129471, 0.03847602754831314, 0.06371860206127167, -0.04550093412399292, 0.016411390155553818, 0.061650510877370834, 0.0692148432135582, 0.006218515336513519, 0.06324826925992966, 0.007864166051149368, 0.04965660721063614, -0.0012965155765414238, 0.056177109479904175, -0.0021622919011861086, -0.009524557739496231, 0.0461614690721035, 0.015316636301577091, -0.006255395710468292, 0.010760693810880184, -0.01386096142232418, -0.039321206510066986, -0.0020727580413222313, -0.030195027589797974, 0.03188897296786308, 0.005311230663210154, -0.004548683762550354, -0.017704375088214874, 0.013761185109615326, 0.02503732219338417, -0.062048085033893585, 0.001537369447760284, 0.04127361252903938, -0.0404423289000988, 0.06670556217432022, -0.0025549631100147963, 0.0058798762038350105, -0.03836950659751892, 0.030204912647604942, -0.015765614807605743, 0.04672093689441681, -0.021293433383107185, 0.016464963555336, -0.003221869235858321, -0.01711087115108967, -0.010314743965864182, 0.05542914569377899, 0.010301749221980572, 0.022030241787433624, -0.05301368236541748, -0.0010716901160776615, 0.07590167969465256, 0.07652120292186737, -0.005667827557772398, -0.006504126358777285, 0.005021215416491032, -0.016321102157235146, 0.007646727841347456, -0.0193523857742548, 0.03226056322455406, -0.07070281356573105, -0.0024673868902027607, -0.03689867630600929, 0.07175905257463455, 0.024106575176119804, 0.07553043961524963, 0.08626776933670044, 0.02759900875389576, 0.06136222183704376, -0.024780580773949623, 0.025752555578947067, 0.05892443656921387, -0.025056077167391777, -0.04067884385585785, 0.017345139756798744, -0.021108495071530342, -0.016482386738061905, 0.050552014261484146, -0.0379374660551548, 0.045828063040971756, -0.02884983830153942, 0.012414788827300072, -0.008150167763233185, -0.009160812012851238, 0.006909539923071861, 0.043661799281835556, -0.008816559799015522, 0.0043883901089429855, 0.00622308487072587, 0.025129634886980057, 0.09834016859531403, 0.028949270024895668, -0.05896003916859627, -0.0016003455966711044, -0.05476745590567589, -0.020643597468733788, 0.03407352417707443, 0.01075640320777893, -0.009206347167491913, -0.05135282501578331, -0.0019065720262005925, 0.0034829177893698215, -0.033138908445835114, 0.013858258724212646, -0.09261003136634827, 0.010824328288435936, -0.03303772583603859, -0.07003985345363617, 0.013862746767699718, -0.02006097137928009, -0.027935396879911423, 0.038388196378946304, 0.0005693744751624763, 0.03386745601892471, -0.03533228114247322, -0.014527147635817528, -0.003965475130826235, 0.03350352123379707, 0.004339015576988459, -0.02538718283176422, -0.00909479707479477, 0.05966542288661003, 0.015040485188364983, -0.029485667124390602, -0.03382714092731476, -0.0029949983581900597, -0.10388492792844772, -0.019862988963723183, -0.045838866382837296, 0.009898648597300053, 0.01131818164139986, 0.04054221510887146, 0.05670096352696419, 0.056263457983732224, -0.03706977143883705, -0.05081090331077576, 0.002450618427246809, 0.006275632884353399, 0.010349711403250694, -0.002885964000597596, 0.01087295450270176, 0.01322902087122202, -0.010927332565188408, 0.03166749328374863, 0.029003361240029335, -0.03986078128218651, 0.05498230829834938, 0.0408845990896225, 0.08299039304256439, -0.06681141257286072, -0.02176698110997677, 0.05374325066804886, -0.05085618048906326, -0.010386602021753788, 0.023332536220550537, 0.0016335169784724712, -0.02731216512620449, 0.0017733739223331213, 0.03336680680513382, -0.02006634511053562, 0.026923982426524162, -0.08577365428209305, 0.040517598390579224, -0.01859891414642334, -0.02315337583422661, -0.02748228795826435, -0.012820987030863762, -0.05399693548679352, 0.03114205040037632, 0.016386447474360466, -0.0660722553730011, 0.04249919205904007, -0.023863699287176132, 0.016987107694149017, 0.07370488345623016, -0.05958028882741928, -0.017942242324352264, -0.018255403265357018, -0.003253050846979022, -0.014438939280807972, -0.03614862263202667, 0.04550745710730553, -0.06533470004796982, -0.010687929578125477, -0.059339702129364014, 0.03252626210451126, -0.002714683534577489, -0.018697578459978104, 0.005429047625511885, 0.00008685448119649664, -0.0026050719898194075, -0.0379481241106987, 0.023157978430390358, 0.026233503594994545, 0.000424140045652166, 0.053704604506492615, 0.002877064049243927, 0.0628482848405838, -0.0494573600590229, -0.010094101540744305, -0.00341258873231709, -0.0344185009598732, 0.04773755371570587, -0.022641899064183235, -0.05898614600300789, 0.020611876621842384, 0.015967179089784622, 0.0037665609270334244, 0.00890699028968811, -0.03451749309897423, -0.026471199467778206, 0.01741277426481247, -0.05604223534464836, 0.024117309600114822, 0.03862135112285614, -0.05258050188422203, 0.004493046551942825, -0.021893931552767754, 0.008300550282001495, -0.01871470734477043, -0.004304622765630484, -0.02516491338610649, 0.018589792773127556, -0.03810317441821098, 0.0429220050573349, 0.03999445587396622, 0.034924764186143875, -0.028494013473391533, -0.026509754359722137, -0.04838201776146889, 0.04255043715238571, -0.006803740747272968, -0.08831335604190826, 0.01146148145198822, 0.007641342934221029, -0.055790603160858154, -0.02183975651860237, -0.039495281875133514, -0.08093520253896713, -0.021817756816744804, 0.025387724861502647, 0.021944595500826836, -0.041637249290943146, 0.011042223311960697, 0.0275247935205698, -0.004980898462235928, 0.026552913710474968, -0.008105813525617123, 0.008728892542421818, 0.04348638281226158, -0.009954048320651054, 0.05959620699286461, -0.010437344200909138, 0.06031026318669319, 0.04314342141151428, 0.0049279797822237015, 0.03333515301346779, -0.031104251742362976, -0.04026976600289345, 0.013277550227940083, -0.008997485041618347, 0.03113933652639389, 0.06209208443760872, 0.011428502388298512, -0.014577111229300499, 0.03446006402373314, -0.05050325766205788, 0.03593607619404793, 0.06481865793466568, -0.011249922215938568, -0.027516160160303116, -0.006147540174424648, 0.019387871026992798, 0.01629207655787468, -0.06484688073396683, 0.009912657551467419, -0.014853991568088531, -0.024004902690649033, -0.02176414430141449, 0.01958882436156273, -0.009005631320178509, 0.014518597163259983, -0.008536339737474918, 0.02076127752661705, -0.021292397752404213, -0.04974355921149254, 0.004013076424598694, -0.03689737617969513, -0.001591086620464921, -0.026744533330202103, 0.006008998490869999, 0.008354372344911098, -0.0031070506665855646, -0.04362349957227707, 0.03212275728583336, 0.019029635936021805, -0.017324818298220634, -0.06374572962522507, 0.02254888415336609, 0.028342776000499725, -0.021856164559721947, -0.04018622636795044, -0.004421355668455362, 0.035185981541872025, -0.05268532410264015, -0.01598006673157215, -0.06996830552816391, 0.03642994910478592, 0.0002498731773812324, 0.002338172635063529, -0.03333055227994919, 0.022008933126926422, -0.008589562959969044, -0.0018333435291424394, 0.02041301690042019, -0.029350196942687035, -0.002180010313168168, -0.009845065884292126, 0.048755452036857605, 0.005277167074382305, -0.02691689506173134, 0.006408801767975092, 0.0012999196769669652, 0.03217595815658569, 0.022745084017515182, 0.02508586458861828, 0.002732098801061511, -0.018088066950440407, -0.037568382918834686, 0.017127342522144318, -0.029690749943256378, 0.045934047549963, -0.04194331169128418, -0.007237471640110016, -0.005976868327707052, -0.009097515605390072, 0.011757195927202702, 0.0033731884323060513, -0.011112557724118233, 0.024803612381219864, 0.03935302421450615, 0.04875267669558525, 0.009649613872170448, 0.026716364547610283, -0.0015766556607559323, 0.010837625712156296, 0.0013556344201788306, 0.03486457094550133, -0.010423450730741024, -0.07526114583015442, 0.03497225046157837, -0.017610201612114906, -0.02637820690870285, -0.011714351363480091, -0.04885885864496231, -0.043491192162036896, -0.0009485912160016596, -0.033087458461523056, -0.026150235906243324, 0.04452734440565109, 0.004996117204427719, 0.0027859786059707403, 0.0035607663448899984, -0.035318102687597275, 0.03227610141038895, -0.03603774681687355, 0.012586602941155434, -0.019656239077448845, -0.034417107701301575, -0.01671876199543476, -0.018319912254810333, 0.007185665424913168, -0.037232182919979095, 0.01636648178100586, -0.02221163734793663, 0.005806352011859417, 0.010186363942921162, 0.02646167390048504, -0.06661535799503326, 0.06302600353956223, 0.030665889382362366, -0.04975108429789543, -0.0021766212303191423, -0.012333803810179234, 0.08137957006692886, 0.08206816017627716, -0.0226135291159153, -0.03996846079826355, 0.03746366500854492, -0.030448371544480324, -0.017328305169939995, -0.029889089986681938, -0.012987017631530762, 0.0599968321621418 ]
<p>I am studying the Fujikawa method of determining the chiral anomalies in a $U(1)$ theory. As we know the basis vectors selected are the eigenstates of the Dirac operator. One of the reasons given is that the eigenstates diagonalize the action which is needed for determining an exact quantity such as Ward-Takahashi identities. Anyone care to explain? I am referring to <em>Path Integrals and Quantum Anomalies</em> by Kazuo Fujikawa and Hiroshi Suzuki.</p>
g6610
[ 0.033072322607040405, 0.021744657307863235, 0.00612630695104599, 0.02247125282883644, 0.05636140704154968, 0.0028397648129612207, 0.0820031389594078, 0.05183812230825424, 0.012046800926327705, -0.022517014294862747, -0.04837975651025772, -0.058777108788490295, 0.024110134690999985, 0.04471646994352341, -0.008722378872334957, -0.005554711911827326, -0.022476742044091225, 0.011448940262198448, 0.03031260333955288, -0.045286960899829865, -0.029743917286396027, 0.029239753261208534, 0.01705755479633808, -0.00863805040717125, 0.09884883463382721, -0.05968816950917244, 0.0395282581448555, 0.025763479992747307, -0.044052500277757645, -0.0038600610569119453, 0.004482980351895094, 0.0033895389642566442, 0.055233169347047806, 0.003942975774407387, -0.05608152225613594, 0.00028965031378902495, 0.10444309562444687, 0.03734423592686653, 0.03243027999997139, -0.02450699731707573, 0.005553933791816235, -0.043586112558841705, -0.01515783742070198, -0.030621515586972237, -0.03117149882018566, -0.035931166261434555, -0.013126647099852562, -0.005409160163253546, -0.008183041587471962, 0.0645100325345993, -0.017347924411296844, 0.013602503575384617, 0.05700157955288887, -0.023325296118855476, -0.019336538389325142, 0.05393156036734581, 0.0008302730857394636, -0.03856699913740158, 0.04483411833643913, 0.039689790457487106, 0.016588112339377403, -0.02677149698138237, 0.07295885682106018, -0.011823456734418869, 0.06053142249584198, -0.029617086052894592, -0.009053892455995083, 0.005048895254731178, -0.05939405411481857, -0.04202335327863693, -0.03175509721040726, -0.027247674763202667, 0.023274576291441917, -0.003750333795323968, 0.027268266305327415, -0.018548445776104927, 0.012381378561258316, 0.014230819419026375, 0.003412374760955572, -0.021957198157906532, -0.030801156535744667, -0.08752410113811493, 0.04305705055594444, -0.003007770050317049, 0.04790636524558067, 0.023326287046074867, 0.04563622921705246, 0.0075262379832565784, 0.01623496599495411, -0.00290321814827621, -0.05068443343043327, 0.002578690880909562, 0.02323741279542446, 0.0012950693489983678, -0.020435987040400505, 0.00316240475513041, -0.029526207596063614, 0.05249142646789551, 0.024532390758395195, -0.004751675296574831, -0.01857445389032364, 0.0661652684211731, -0.005788583308458328, -0.017311442643404007, -0.033467039465904236, -0.012436940334737301, 0.011634941212832928, -0.018035316839814186, 0.03865437209606171, 0.027423450723290443, -0.03166113793849945, 0.027347536757588387, -0.028193561360239983, -0.004215691238641739, 0.011102097108960152, 0.036044515669345856, 0.04510580003261566, -0.025080019608139992, -0.020607778802514076, 0.018006568774580956, 0.02029256522655487, 0.027384450659155846, -0.015268501825630665, 0.013261290267109871, 0.053060226142406464, 0.03459735959768295, -0.02861965075135231, 0.042373403906822205, 0.0027279367204755545, 0.00016718407277949154, 0.05827545374631882, 0.011860298924148083, 0.02923678047955036, 0.06227923184633255, 0.022382713854312897, -0.05350635573267937, 0.04885571822524071, 0.09275735169649124, -0.0073903524316847324, -0.015823282301425934, 0.0002951927308458835, -0.01526856143027544, -0.019379783421754837, 0.022593583911657333, 0.0203536506742239, -0.026414206251502037, 0.01999523676931858, -0.027216458693146706, 0.013230116106569767, -0.016124479472637177, 0.030132077634334564, 0.026899276301264763, 0.003542969236150384, -0.006398003548383713, 0.01356441993266344, -0.002867513569071889, -0.01984645240008831, -0.04738520830869675, -0.06051016226410866, -0.029922116547822952, 0.056964874267578125, 0.03086566925048828, 0.021949203684926033, 0.03219471871852875, -0.03999054431915283, 0.006684555672109127, 0.09291212260723114, -0.03881793096661568, 0.03143139183521271, -0.021168602630496025, -0.01874270848929882, 0.0360838919878006, -0.009418715722858906, 0.043427541851997375, 0.022099705412983894, 0.06537923216819763, -0.08535923063755035, -0.03041294403374195, 0.04984903708100319, -0.03822537511587143, -0.00883508287370205, 0.016689101234078407, 0.006657728925347328, 0.0009657554910518229, -0.0624866783618927, -0.05044003576040268, 0.012349224649369717, -0.011865867301821709, -0.02040184661746025, 0.015490232035517693, 0.06175677850842476, -0.06892803311347961, 0.004586144350469112, -0.01178425457328558, 0.030301343649625778, -0.03056759014725685, 0.002742024604231119, -0.03404322266578674, -0.06770150363445282, 0.020934268832206726, -0.01167456153780222, -0.021123874932527542, -0.0353291891515255, -0.026552246883511543, -0.012211172841489315, -0.004831488244235516, 0.050472766160964966, -0.06371351331472397, 0.0028219770174473524, -0.04977961257100105, -0.03872448205947876, -0.03793781250715256, 0.03474834933876991, 0.05939600244164467, 0.032139141112565994, -0.012700056657195091, 0.05852418392896652, -0.07585496455430984, 0.0011520397383719683, -0.04307336360216141, -0.02373793162405491, -0.01910858415067196, 0.06472575664520264, 0.04569298028945923, 0.025081414729356766, 0.06251995265483856, -0.03407637029886246, 0.026413962244987488, 0.0011820782674476504, -0.020311156287789345, -0.06315590441226959, 0.025400180369615555, 0.015725674107670784, -0.026047280058264732, 0.033788956701755524, -0.002311397809535265, -0.05486230179667473, -0.0008172595407813787, 0.04220806062221527, 0.043733324855566025, -0.014148388057947159, -0.0028425275813788176, -0.09560687094926834, 0.03538990020751953, -0.011814639903604984, 0.04413633421063423, 0.03396777808666229, 0.019292667508125305, -0.04936150088906288, 0.04338078573346138, -0.00793930422514677, 0.007371638901531696, -0.01699286885559559, 0.01159752532839775, -0.003408299293369055, -0.023478979244828224, 0.0009672889718785882, 0.029202906414866447, -0.04129882529377937, -0.050291117280721664, 0.04394698515534401, -0.010264681652188301, -0.0030375223141163588, 0.01676560752093792, -0.044280458241701126, 0.029639296233654022, 0.006897323299199343, -0.017252609133720398, -0.04169198498129845, -0.031609270721673965, -0.01577390357851982, 0.051888611167669296, -0.029978232458233833, 0.04209042713046074, -0.0005079781985841691, -0.029615657404065132, -0.004729837644845247, -0.011821082793176174, 0.04004285857081413, 0.005967873148620129, -0.027490073814988136, 0.004116499796509743, -0.030518973246216774, 0.03247195854783058, 0.0407685711979866, 0.0061998749151825905, 0.015926076099276543, 0.019412169232964516, -0.010480963625013828, -0.0556907020509243, 0.018277207389473915, -0.02138405852019787, 0.028746383264660835, 0.011990890838205814, 0.012059936299920082, -0.030062299221754074, 0.03715498372912407, -0.03771983087062836, 0.013332771137356758, 0.06262694299221039, 0.0175949614495039, 0.010365116409957409, -0.02465672604739666, -0.028477150946855545, 0.010523298755288124, 0.019584177061915398, 0.002036817604675889, -0.041106998920440674, -0.02304467372596264, 0.0020469939336180687, -0.03583020716905594, 0.006511421874165535, -0.012592424638569355, 0.0017628888599574566, 0.03974076360464096, -0.008316603489220142, -0.03052811324596405, -0.0014385824324563146, -0.025593606755137444, 0.019813410937786102, -0.04813115671277046, -0.02532382309436798, 0.026313645765185356, 0.031759195029735565, 0.049409374594688416, 0.018026133999228477, -0.07018294930458069, 0.03343562036752701, -0.010324330069124699, -0.09725893288850784, -0.019533095881342888, -0.048020049929618835, 0.0020567532628774643, 0.015859408304095268, -0.05158744752407074, -0.05039864778518677, -0.045723896473646164, -0.030014052987098694, 0.0008366756374016404, -0.007373461499810219, -0.0654461532831192, -0.053650710731744766, 0.006948358379304409, -0.005932897794991732, 0.00792551226913929, -0.011453126557171345, 0.003941600676625967, 0.02991575002670288, 0.006370265502482653, 0.07230987399816513, -0.030915552750229836, 0.013836168684065342, 0.00031523380312137306, 0.011804846115410328, -0.005961035843938589, -0.055606041103601456, 0.03628832846879959, 0.05141614004969597, 0.048379480838775635, 0.022737795487046242, 0.020424971356987953, 0.020431265234947205, 0.0021260587964206934, -0.02843451499938965, -0.0023790367413312197, -0.029274657368659973, -0.04497644677758217, -0.0029922358226031065, 0.07407991588115692, 0.03316269442439079, 0.028264667838811874, -0.02557951956987381, 0.0022081949282437563, -0.03237870708107948, -0.03275182843208313, -0.03461841493844986, 0.03871871158480644, 0.010483388788998127, 0.01635126769542694, 0.002845627022907138, 0.013054745271801949, 0.05562916398048401, 0.02434159442782402, 0.010067849420011044, -0.0116445766761899, 0.011664963327348232, -0.04641382396221161, -0.02555013634264469, 0.004860568325966597, -0.06759195029735565, -0.006829594261944294, -0.05954276770353317, -0.004268934950232506, -0.004635772202163935, 0.012806045822799206, -0.03010149858891964, -0.028502020984888077, 0.007976477034389973, -0.016454322263598442, 0.04316529259085655, -0.01856183260679245, -0.03742507845163345, -0.05248221009969711, 0.02145676501095295, -0.009346048347651958, 0.03130410611629486, 0.0026282190810889006, -0.05635477229952812, 0.06135429069399834, 0.021029647439718246, 0.0060287960804998875, 0.010973403230309486, 0.03143111243844032, -0.04563639685511589, 0.030755801126360893, 0.023778224363923073, 0.002539979526773095, -0.049119606614112854, 0.0017786453245207667, -0.033470652997493744, 0.059578198939561844, 0.019222954288125038, -0.025618350133299828, -0.005350491963326931, -0.02049139142036438, 0.07447247952222824, 0.013270700350403786, 0.0103165153414011, 0.018087539821863174, -0.01266422402113676, -0.018434740602970123, 0.05122145265340805, -0.06697149574756622, 0.023741481825709343, -0.05661419406533241, 0.06376666575670242, -0.02878132462501526, 0.03499548137187958, 0.0027248160913586617, 0.04638451710343361, 0.04128091782331467, 0.07258809357881546, -0.11949921399354935, 0.0024373542983084917, -0.013834577985107899, -0.011212943121790886, -0.02926516719162464, -0.047220807522535324, -0.005767075810581446, -0.02977578155696392, 0.0019651700276881456, 0.022799545899033546, -0.010691741481423378, -0.07229187339544296, 0.0338529571890831, -0.055947549641132355, -0.06941332668066025, 0.0351155623793602, 0.016183873638510704, 0.053310226649045944, -0.048933517187833786, -0.1024002730846405, 0.002697017975151539, 0.05615362152457237, -0.0055742450058460236, -0.06776149570941925, -0.03066553920507431, 0.054361727088689804, -0.07689667493104935, -0.015721917152404785, 0.03262333199381828, -0.0015725045232102275, 0.011963693425059319, -0.05706601217389107, -0.020981591194868088, -0.036117516458034515, -0.027206171303987503, -0.010871903039515018, -0.03167687729001045, -0.00513721676543355, -0.035995002835989, -0.012550024315714836, 0.032543860375881195, 0.033587295562028885, 0.01766819693148136, -0.004757852293550968, 0.009928802959620953, -0.0016087834956124425, 0.016722099855542183, 0.025840383023023605, 0.037140142172575, 0.0281946063041687, 0.05002585053443909, -0.02518778294324875, 0.030249198898673058, 0.021992692723870277, -0.016761185601353645, 0.04832242429256439, -0.034482989460229874, -0.03388739749789238, 0.020089996978640556, 0.024837477132678032, -0.005620175041258335, -0.008047865703701973, 0.030613407492637634, -0.007827120833098888, 0.11225805431604385, 0.01420082338154316, 0.006329680792987347, -0.10953536629676819, -0.033165283501148224, -0.0011601001024246216, 0.0137445367872715, 0.026810992509126663, 0.0018945689080283046, 0.005391101818531752, -0.0163726806640625, 0.004120721016079187, -0.020160473883152008, 0.0026031082961708307, -0.01949002407491207, 0.018355894833803177, -0.02508724480867386, -0.04944100230932236, 0.016611535102128983, -0.024376796558499336, -0.04216637834906578, -0.02104676328599453, 0.02017674222588539, 0.015342403203248978, -0.004633627831935883, 0.013767078518867493, 0.00667150504887104, 0.022662874311208725, 0.06583355367183685, -0.01926708221435547, 0.02038525976240635, -0.00706039322540164, 0.02787483111023903, -0.004620008636265993, 0.014833568595349789, -0.012932389043271542, 0.00016426396905444562, -0.02205815352499485, -0.07258781790733337, -0.02135600335896015, -0.006682730279862881, -0.012305290438234806, 0.006290691439062357, -0.09197074919939041, -0.0748143196105957, 0.04796532541513443, -0.03568052873015404, -0.05147537216544151, -0.030014779418706894, 0.016021011397242546, -0.028400558978319168, 0.026514802128076553, 0.007352902553975582, 0.00634742621332407, 0.018584460020065308, 0.017043031752109528, 0.040896136313676834, -0.017501436173915863, 0.0010110738221555948, -0.0006549643585458398, -0.02222757413983345, -0.03986131772398949, 0.0006421239813789725, -0.03243042528629303, -0.026135820895433426, 0.013230431824922562, -0.026819530874490738, 0.011264597997069359, -0.018261803314089775, 0.015164894983172417, 0.00854969210922718, -0.02188037522137165, -0.0372016504406929, -0.0278642438352108, 0.013864497654139996, 0.025826748460531235, 0.023650025948882103, -0.023301655426621437, -0.008845685049891472, 0.020087357610464096, -0.09687475115060806, -0.01414560992270708, 0.034437768161296844, 0.07371299713850021, -0.07535962760448456, 0.025980820879340172, -0.08236070722341537, 0.038203995674848557, -0.026730583980679512, 0.008405416272580624, -0.029633278027176857, 0.006281341891735792, 0.013363128527998924, 0.023418003693223, 0.05601257085800171, 0.02034376561641693, 0.054740458726882935, 0.04545734077692032, -0.011177055537700653, 0.014238120056688786, 0.006592942401766777, -0.0011048418236896396, -0.015783488750457764, -0.005589333828538656, 0.0633682906627655, -0.0034659358207136393, -0.03541551157832146, -0.006385717540979385, -0.027478354051709175, -0.09192859381437302, -0.009122848510742188, 0.004592988174408674, 0.017001809552311897, 0.04082692787051201, 0.05808382108807564, -0.004371694289147854, 0.004275412764400244, -0.011780528351664543, 0.004807879216969013, 0.04156280308961868, -0.033141858875751495, -0.05106910690665245, 0.037991590797901154, 0.03437701612710953, 0.022437166422605515, -0.025296619161963463, 0.02373562939465046, 0.0249614417552948, -0.03544800728559494, 0.050879865884780884, -0.039229683578014374, 0.06581353396177292, -0.011820968240499496, 0.020424844697117805, -0.020352080464363098, 0.012699740007519722, 0.07269848138093948, -0.050844572484493256, -0.007704585790634155, 0.018950508907437325, 0.03480001166462898, 0.03398405387997627, -0.0759657472372055, -0.037906598299741745, 0.07069458812475204, 0.051579851657152176, -0.010029993019998074, -0.023592384532094002, 0.017719771713018417, -0.047991614788770676, 0.015044464729726315, 0.0107466671615839, -0.020395103842020035, -0.0305186677724123, 0.016040895134210587, 0.007971706800162792, -0.015154724009335041, -0.002961347810924053, 0.04161154106259346, 0.03797878697514534, 0.03844181075692177, -0.05666430667042732, 0.02465103380382061, 0.05428072065114975, -0.04159056022763252, 0.013923929072916508, -0.008585215546190739, -0.016373559832572937, 0.031070472672581673, -0.021077342331409454, 0.0065059601329267025, 0.05569641664624214, -0.05452544614672661, 0.02613854967057705, 0.020356567576527596, 0.021354537457227707, -0.001368459314107895, -0.0908752977848053, -0.026309648528695107, 0.056157540529966354, 0.013903218321502209, -0.034204307943582535, -0.08219842612743378, 0.015711143612861633, 0.046692393720149994, 0.005864412989467382, -0.043982334434986115, -0.023824982345104218, 0.0037945397198200226, -0.016082415357232094, -0.021712636575102806, 0.0496353842318058, 0.052232351154088974, -0.02239163964986801, 0.04012047499418259, -0.04266886040568352, 0.012905953451991081, 0.03402639552950859, 0.0009239668142981827, -0.09035144001245499, -0.0018803199054673314, -0.006646218243986368, 0.022993657737970352, 0.05429605394601822, 0.022734059020876884, -0.0008943978464230895, 0.04614294692873955, 0.0318211130797863, -0.019003698602318764, 0.003882824443280697, -0.01467239111661911, 0.04158882051706314, 0.017227653414011, -0.004623967222869396, -0.00936497189104557, 0.011499293148517609, -0.036831166595220566, 0.022154539823532104, -0.07225880771875381, -0.0637332871556282, -0.011867654509842396, 0.04399394616484642, 0.06078227609395981, 0.0036259235348552465, 0.012235904112458229, 0.007478814106434584, -0.0725921243429184, 0.03545761480927467, -0.08824307471513748, 0.024022895842790604, -0.04861278086900711, -0.09493714570999146, 0.016197700053453445, -0.02292797528207302, 0.04007531329989433, -0.04393376410007477, 0.03473936393857002, -0.02839517965912819, -0.02781398966908455, -0.03125930577516556, -0.0010453573195263743, -0.01981368474662304, 0.06636419892311096, -0.01123715192079544, -0.047441914677619934, 0.018950005993247032, -0.016244711354374886, 0.08633885532617569, 0.03723839297890663, 0.08660484850406647, 0.0062652165070176125, -0.03671615943312645, -0.015538704581558704, 0.06401246041059494, -0.0005725811934098601, 0.01013103500008583, 0.007480582222342491, -0.0005618841387331486, 0.038334015756845474, -0.020910460501909256, 0.00957976933568716, -0.04038906469941139 ]
<p>Through what I learned from school, frequency $f=\frac1T$ while $T$ is the period. However, things get harder in college where there are non-periodic signal. That means they have no period or their period is extended to infinity but they still have frequency. How can they have frequencies even there is no period to apply the formula $f=\frac1T$? Is there any definition of frequency in those cases.</p>
g6611
[ 0.0014978033723309636, -0.00024680880596861243, 0.005094306077808142, -0.014777975156903267, 0.04830949380993843, 0.007183881010860205, 0.03737125173211098, 0.005510326474905014, -0.0315508134663105, -0.04072253033518791, -0.019440947100520134, 0.003949363715946674, 0.0387267991900444, 0.045817781239748, -0.051832061260938644, 0.05544814467430115, 0.008566325530409813, 0.07129903137683868, 0.0011137075489386916, 0.032900068908929825, -0.016275126487016678, 0.03765992447733879, -0.0393042229115963, -0.022699499502778053, -0.02833307348191738, 0.0188287403434515, 0.025390243157744408, 0.011966879479587078, -0.05040121078491211, -0.04623604938387871, 0.03251825273036957, -0.015886787325143814, 0.03915321081876755, 0.01832112856209278, 0.05340396985411644, -0.03256118670105934, -0.04294893890619278, -0.008720768615603447, 0.00855210330337286, 0.007303058635443449, -0.013349677436053753, 0.017828747630119324, -0.01592126674950123, -0.02799193188548088, -0.09391213953495026, 0.018256237730383873, -0.05000170320272446, -0.022655922919511795, -0.026893479749560356, -0.02180449478328228, 0.01892639324069023, -0.02271837741136551, 0.05713207647204399, -0.007394574582576752, -0.01333249919116497, 0.03904702141880989, 0.008167028427124023, 0.04434197023510933, 0.047697097063064575, 0.05533186346292496, 0.02764245867729187, -0.005827412940561771, -0.008157407864928246, 0.03432636708021164, 0.013346669264137745, 0.008659605868160725, 0.06420809030532837, -0.02315293624997139, -0.015877990052103996, -0.014228531159460545, -0.023046696558594704, -0.012171505950391293, -0.02294064499437809, 0.00567020196467638, -0.014976606704294682, 0.029866259545087814, 0.003756525693461299, -0.03736726939678192, 0.012041178531944752, 0.00910020712763071, -0.013298680074512959, 0.048573050647974014, 0.02169692888855934, 0.01480849925428629, 0.052710793912410736, 0.04609246551990509, 0.00799648743122816, 0.01075950637459755, 0.061978671699762344, 0.06064995750784874, -0.012976291589438915, -0.037966206669807434, 0.016959937289357185, -0.04333140328526497, 0.01792590506374836, -0.010193977504968643, -0.006729658227413893, 0.06486248224973679, -0.042525213211774826, 0.0022854474373161793, 0.015612141229212284, 0.03889160603284836, 0.04256734251976013, 0.01232131477445364, -0.006535184103995562, -0.02354431338608265, 0.033537957817316055, -0.04185947775840759, -0.024639645591378212, -0.004375755786895752, -0.027180887758731842, 0.032018568366765976, -0.029702387750148773, -0.06690526008605957, 0.030856125056743622, 0.0291904266923666, 0.024781180545687675, 0.003942658193409443, 0.019851455464959145, 0.016060784459114075, 0.03274669870734215, -0.024665260687470436, 0.0113211739808321, 0.08182334154844284, -0.08387336134910583, 0.04937663674354553, 0.08057676255702972, 0.04565627872943878, 0.0323384627699852, -0.031405478715896606, -0.035177264362573624, 0.004845189396291971, 0.043639134615659714, -0.009420761838555336, 0.021765220910310745, 0.08437502384185791, 0.02612846903502941, -0.023533713072538376, 0.004314308054745197, 0.05480705201625824, -0.0023360943887382746, -0.06851877272129059, 0.029365118592977524, -0.06859384477138519, -0.04842553660273552, 0.04972675070166588, -0.07965376228094101, -0.07163900882005692, 0.016081390902400017, 0.031816039234399796, 0.03442474082112312, 0.09497711807489395, 0.028281336650252342, -0.05676920339465141, 0.010785842314362526, -0.0008698623860254884, 0.0363713875412941, 0.024149123579263687, -0.04227922111749649, 0.026292383670806885, 0.03924856707453728, 0.0113188112154603, 0.009582484140992165, 0.029297593981027603, -0.0747920498251915, 0.016023164615035057, -0.08495271950960159, -0.01729194074869156, -0.026804326102137566, -0.014314454980194569, -0.06050603464245796, 0.03160596266388893, 0.02775174006819725, 0.028609061613678932, 0.027022289112210274, 0.03914879262447357, 0.010753415524959564, -0.010885569266974926, 0.057989150285720825, -0.008995052427053452, -0.03536541387438774, -0.026351237669587135, -0.021713338792324066, -0.017342563718557358, 0.007289852946996689, 0.023359987884759903, -0.01574518531560898, 0.02006557025015354, -0.07167010009288788, 0.040810901671648026, -0.014117438346147537, -0.032386548817157745, -0.009940960444509983, 0.020068790763616562, -0.07402240484952927, -0.00828239694237709, -0.06475894153118134, -0.021390734240412712, -0.0023640329018235207, 0.020739926025271416, 0.01858745887875557, -0.03476157411932945, 0.01882600411772728, -0.011242740787565708, 0.044682011008262634, 0.003170834155753255, -0.01844928227365017, -0.04759050905704498, -0.020660944283008575, 0.013968118466436863, -0.05573061853647232, -0.06802517175674438, -0.032765861600637436, 0.0626324713230133, -0.01608274318277836, -0.02361871674656868, -0.03859470412135124, -0.004343210719525814, 0.005624481476843357, 0.05223996937274933, 0.01949554681777954, -0.0016668644966557622, 0.018866287544369698, -0.010488301515579224, -0.022070474922657013, -0.013199491426348686, 0.01952841691672802, -0.010045060887932777, -0.044510096311569214, 0.03280000016093254, -0.0021356316283345222, -0.013145931996405125, -0.038178831338882446, -0.02618551254272461, 0.01597643457353115, 0.05113533139228821, 0.0063956561498343945, 0.003649380523711443, 0.003257214557379484, 0.0031861423049122095, -0.038125306367874146, -0.023916101083159447, 0.020046349614858627, -0.030514398589730263, -0.019187506288290024, -0.04540470987558365, -0.0002712027635425329, -0.005323885008692741, 0.025940600782632828, 0.002114182570949197, 0.0334513783454895, -0.00981680117547512, 0.0027758467476814985, 0.03179736062884331, -0.015103351324796677, 0.009625264443457127, 0.014925741590559483, -0.007426518946886063, -0.07754049450159073, -0.06107787787914276, 0.06004994735121727, -0.006093153264373541, 0.06103792041540146, 0.02177737094461918, -0.03683815896511078, -0.013779493048787117, -0.011968834325671196, 0.051461778581142426, -0.06220059469342232, 0.012159212492406368, 0.002510306891053915, 0.02075284719467163, 0.08647190034389496, 0.006220124661922455, -0.02865542843937874, -0.012693246826529503, -0.007222296204417944, -0.012502244673669338, -0.015162386931478977, 0.010795659385621548, 0.005358306225389242, -0.01694083772599697, 0.007565631065517664, 0.005995083134621382, -0.010960138402879238, -0.04409712553024292, 0.08723592013120651, 0.06702514737844467, -0.05442202836275101, 0.015450905077159405, -0.04025258496403694, -0.06261106580495834, 0.023426054045557976, 0.012598286382853985, -0.010170100256800652, 0.049090247601270676, 0.05656599625945091, -0.022961169481277466, 0.03692864626646042, 0.06215088441967964, 0.06180310249328613, 0.038461752235889435, 0.000469025457277894, -0.01830180175602436, -0.01654406450688839, -0.033021051436662674, -0.0020947568118572235, -0.060635071247816086, -0.04665397107601166, -0.014126394875347614, 0.010313027538359165, 0.02341691218316555, 0.06214407458901405, 0.0034909015521407127, -0.024771997705101967, 0.05344117060303688, 0.004227864556014538, 0.018774161115288734, 0.007012930698692799, 0.023021310567855835, 0.001225467654876411, -0.012870479375123978, 0.0464865081012249, -0.04317409172654152, 0.010707530193030834, 0.010755816474556923, -0.00803079828619957, -0.017679007723927498, -0.05902816727757454, -0.025712203234434128, 0.028796419501304626, -0.02930588833987713, -0.02536730095744133, -0.06419580429792404, 0.016879472881555557, -0.03716229274868965, 0.012122801505029202, 0.0706995353102684, 0.040114764124155045, 0.03479383885860443, -0.004090244881808758, 0.009474653750658035, 0.0007642214186489582, -0.017513316124677658, -0.03010038658976555, 0.013710279017686844, -0.01834963820874691, 0.04327834025025368, 0.0052339923568069935, -0.017863618209958076, 0.014627260155975819, -0.027868103235960007, -0.0339166484773159, -0.01076818723231554, 0.01252788957208395, 0.029764793813228607, 0.0555960014462471, 0.04734126105904579, -0.012884275056421757, 0.0030167957302182913, 0.03231391683220863, -0.03853267431259155, 0.04594377800822258, 0.09419775009155273, -0.013628266751766205, 0.016135362908244133, 0.03572250157594681, 0.1406002640724182, 0.02465962991118431, 0.00924233254045248, 0.0018051326042041183, -0.010548497550189495, 0.06855536997318268, 0.03658025711774826, -0.009443752467632294, -0.023963939398527145, -0.03944956138730049, -0.016756294295191765, -0.03081427328288555, 0.037934157997369766, -0.01988954283297062, -0.061515241861343384, 0.01111728884279728, -0.05808556452393532, 0.003671457292512059, -0.0011841908562928438, 0.010089386254549026, 0.010401630774140358, 0.0010566076962277293, -0.02976076677441597, 0.03780323639512062, -0.031624890863895416, -0.005835790187120438, 0.05041906610131264, 0.04110115021467209, -0.0664503276348114, 0.011220893822610378, -0.008752130903303623, 0.017345547676086426, 0.016237277537584305, 0.03819010406732559, 0.003586637321859598, -0.06974867731332779, 0.030185086652636528, -0.030187703669071198, 0.09898687899112701, 0.008732553571462631, -0.04889165610074997, -0.025524385273456573, -0.03403085097670555, -0.05062803253531456, -0.027837397530674934, -0.01622987538576126, -0.05676427111029625, -0.0012180022895336151, 0.033236391842365265, 0.10962076485157013, -0.0199353639036417, 0.03417443856596947, 0.025565708056092262, -0.042885199189186096, 0.009236965328454971, 0.023286450654268265, 0.011136705055832863, 0.016367269679903984, 0.0177492443472147, 0.0018569001695141196, -0.011784622445702553, -0.030760152265429497, -0.0018167878733947873, -0.02463398687541485, -0.01791626773774624, 0.0038728739600628614, -0.02863418497145176, 0.0023645302280783653, 0.01624586619436741, -0.05109933018684387, 0.04184257611632347, 0.026288287714123726, -0.0007819116581231356, 0.006678372621536255, -0.015143446624279022, -0.05957282334566116, 0.001693215686827898, -0.002833488630130887, 0.04362517595291138, -0.04327674210071564, -0.02609746716916561, 0.025777967646718025, 0.01855316013097763, -0.03271661698818207, 0.07738031446933746, -0.04784470424056053, -0.01836196705698967, 0.0035849432460963726, -0.039597101509571075, -0.04038695991039276, 0.0030452825594693422, -0.007371161598712206, 0.017114276066422462, -0.028259778395295143, 0.006513878703117371, -0.002716341521590948, -0.02839597873389721, -0.006115827243775129, 0.03827011585235596, 0.048516422510147095, -0.09380441159009933, -0.014571580104529858, -0.005311673507094383, 0.006109780166298151, -0.029858281835913658, 0.06050097197294235, 0.03665103018283844, 0.03713122755289078, -0.028290588408708572, 0.036703839898109436, -0.012681822292506695, -0.01703663170337677, -0.05484364926815033, 0.04148653522133827, -0.06436757743358612, 0.03842921182513237, 0.0021005377639085054, -0.02539324015378952, 0.038115035742521286, 0.005263787228614092, 0.016649622470140457, 0.023726386949419975, -0.03479509428143501, 0.01293173898011446, 0.028230709955096245, 0.0028853677213191986, 0.009511992335319519, 0.004248008597642183, -0.06943859905004501, 0.06055241823196411, 0.0057909018360078335, 0.03228660300374031, -0.10459374636411667, -0.04070189595222473, 0.04898299649357796, -0.038813669234514236, 0.04529283940792084, 0.012636466883122921, 0.06874668598175049, 0.0074042389169335365, -0.03805955499410629, -0.04411930963397026, 0.050434600561857224, 0.004586046561598778, 0.006235502194613218, 0.01943996176123619, 0.03807090222835541, 0.031272754073143005, -0.0060775550082325935, -0.07294508069753647, -0.053869783878326416, -0.047754138708114624, -0.008343611843883991, -0.00620125001296401, 0.04396414756774902, 0.03627379983663559, 0.000654884148389101, 0.02364514209330082, -0.034350618720054626, -0.038349878042936325, -0.11691900342702866, 0.001721331151202321, -0.0027545022312551737, 0.009420117363333702, 0.01094113290309906, -0.016419004648923874, 0.006694089155644178, 0.01972632110118866, 0.015550834126770496, 0.006313418969511986, -0.029322046786546707, -0.012596995569765568, 0.026067130267620087, -0.01786022074520588, 0.02149241231381893, 0.023728158324956894, -0.013015186414122581, -0.012342923320829868, -0.012025617994368076, -0.010964864864945412, -0.00991749856621027, -0.0004717437259387225, -0.024530986323952675, -0.03172561526298523, 0.015996230766177177, 0.01185679156333208, -0.01853092387318611, 0.00318133388645947, 0.04807212948799133, -0.0023512032348662615, -0.03006497025489807, -0.046958647668361664, -0.021288244053721428, -0.02869783155620098, 0.01832498610019684, 0.027990473434329033, 0.00877709686756134, 0.018766801804304123, -0.008622444234788418, 0.03224174678325653, 0.021872548386454582, 0.050179608166217804, 0.019551532343029976, 0.017689060419797897, 0.024491267278790474, -0.01034622360020876, -0.013600670732557774, 0.011233705095946789, 0.013622545637190342, 0.011338971555233002, -0.040832456201314926, 0.03644382953643799, -0.058521270751953125, -0.018318211659789085, 0.003275818657130003, 0.011425620876252651, 0.017355628311634064, -0.019460076466202736, -0.011272656731307507, 0.036185529083013535, -0.040698692202568054, 0.04525265842676163, 0.0016085132956504822, -0.026933208107948303, -0.039851829409599304, -0.0036335166078060865, 0.06650158017873764, -0.005696870386600494, -0.005060577765107155, -0.03642599657177925, 0.046622104942798615, 0.024632155895233154, -0.039601389318704605, -0.0076032765209674835, 0.036888349801301956, 0.03787485882639885, 0.017869219183921814, -0.02059975266456604, 0.029764704406261444, 0.02386338636279106, -0.021323222666978836, -0.013403336517512798, 0.03290056809782982, -0.04860827326774597, 0.09080995619297028, 0.042446333914995193, -0.00036744173849001527, -0.06425192952156067, -0.05483761057257652, -0.05150563269853592, 0.030367039144039154, 0.0008689243695698678, 0.0053124804981052876, 0.06340370327234268, -0.06754014641046524, 0.01634136214852333, -0.04482901096343994, 0.019451498985290527, 0.0654122605919838, -0.03913431614637375, 0.024153433740139008, 0.04218548536300659, -0.04930141940712929, 0.01930788904428482, -0.03069913201034069, -0.02876734733581543, 0.009548161178827286, -0.039010751992464066, 0.04864228144288063, -0.08367741852998734, 0.039283860474824905, 0.055122293531894684, -0.01598254404962063, 0.004292318597435951, 0.024472882971167564, 0.04009409621357918, -0.012630926445126534, -0.010098719038069248, 0.029565399512648582, 0.027974803000688553, -0.020576344802975655, -0.03525755554437637, -0.005444200709462166, 0.030276281759142876, -0.06952033936977386, -0.0007957331836223602, 0.05740498751401901, 0.003869552630931139, -0.004528749268501997, 0.012127770110964775, -0.024895360693335533, 0.003227542620152235, -0.012878073379397392, -0.01602092944085598, -0.017752522602677345, 0.020988833159208298, 0.047309547662734985, 0.014281165786087513, 0.04542310908436775, 0.06521911919116974, -0.040066909044981, -0.02501976117491722, -0.07303648442029953, 0.023484447970986366, -0.044083841145038605, -0.025405235588550568, -0.013793508522212505, 0.008459885604679585, -0.009361142292618752, -0.04761643335223198, 0.03689006343483925, -0.034354500472545624, -0.042519498616456985, -0.03697032853960991, -0.03190094605088234, 0.0032785197254270315, -0.03110053762793541, 0.01200204249471426, 0.07550143450498581, -0.05243042856454849, 0.0073562911711633205, 0.03840462863445282, 0.0022112708538770676, 0.010312328115105629, 0.02171831764280796, 0.02191394753754139, -0.012256389483809471, 0.014575635083019733, -0.08355779200792313, 0.011880327947437763, -0.011346901766955853, -0.01643238216638565, -0.013012498617172241, 0.058712493628263474, -0.019314808771014214, -0.03404586389660835, -0.002810913138091564, 0.03704888001084328, 0.02586481347680092, -0.05199051275849342, -0.008450386114418507, 0.01186741515994072, -0.033370763063430786, 0.004267702344805002, 0.038269270211458206, 0.01099683903157711, 0.009113564155995846, -0.013814116828143597, -0.010131911374628544, -0.04611007124185562, -0.012092006392776966, -0.0403592474758625, -0.030808592215180397, -0.05009692907333374, -0.1308450996875763, -0.033156074583530426, -0.07669033110141754, -0.03310224786400795, 0.023860860615968704, -0.03995903953909874, -0.0689476951956749, -0.015317372046411037, -0.057368285953998566, -0.04365267604589462, 0.0039065927267074585, 0.004666301887482405, 0.028745537623763084, -0.0652637779712677, 0.027029823511838913, 0.05027374252676964, 0.03103598766028881, -0.009172460064291954, 0.028900466859340668, -0.01921437680721283, 0.04763396829366684, 0.004594672005623579, -0.0015978120500221848, 0.017273318022489548, 0.049651216715574265, -0.06390241533517838, -0.012868733145296574, 0.05701540410518646, -0.03382069244980812, -0.10516511648893356, 0.058455199003219604, -0.043558720499277115, 0.019460756331682205, 0.06913959980010986, -0.04632427915930748, 0.0008055853541009128, -0.005493290722370148, 0.047525804489851, -0.022997012361884117, -0.025519195944070816, 0.026754111051559448, -0.013005456887185574, 0.029335660859942436, 0.019974878057837486, -0.0576203316450119, 0.014630709774792194, 0.002812754362821579 ]
<p>This theory has bugged me ever since my first physics class on the subject. If this (<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_theory" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_theory</a>) is true, it leads me to a few weird conclusions.</p> <p>Opening the rear window in a pickup truck at 10 m/s doesn't empty the cabin of all its air. This means that gas molecules can catch up with us from behind so we can conclude that gases move much faster than 10 m/s at normal temperatures.</p> <p>Then, shouldn't gases mix almost instantaneously? For example, shouldn't a fart's smell reach us faster than a car on an highway and then dissapear almost immediately into such a large area that the concentration is too low for our noses to detect?</p>
g6612
[ 0.04210115969181061, -0.0035742949694395065, -0.0035182947758585215, 0.010045425035059452, 0.0030576889403164387, -0.0031717955134809017, 0.04566245526075363, 0.037174854427576065, -0.062278784811496735, -0.02022245153784752, 0.061140190809965134, -0.013193272985517979, 0.020633749663829803, 0.015471111983060837, -0.020299917086958885, -0.02249298244714737, 0.06489922106266022, -0.034680500626564026, 0.006693627219647169, 0.058639176189899445, -0.02530289813876152, -0.013090119697153568, 0.00019667850574478507, -0.07438591867685318, -0.0659516230225563, 0.029575474560260773, 0.022434134036302567, -0.0032778484746813774, -0.017423633486032486, -0.0250172708183527, 0.03927090764045715, 0.0007897003670223057, -0.07338128238916397, -0.07286533713340759, -0.058829206973314285, -0.05787133798003197, 0.012191208079457283, -0.033306099474430084, -0.02873927168548107, -0.03538252040743828, 0.0024505499750375748, -0.04391227290034294, 0.047043364495038986, -0.006046996917575598, -0.046408478170633316, 0.0577835850417614, 0.013442178256809711, 0.021155547350645065, 0.016115795820951462, -0.0005416455096565187, -0.05234396085143089, 0.0022919976618140936, -0.042754460126161575, 0.01723855547606945, 0.024616671726107597, 0.02770148776471615, 0.037601809948682785, -0.014673549681901932, 0.01763535663485527, -0.03354713320732117, 0.00047710337094031274, 0.03305833041667938, 0.04206589609384537, 0.03947947919368744, 0.03935542330145836, -0.03493481129407883, -0.04877032712101936, 0.048728421330451965, 0.025334347039461136, -0.04335219785571098, 0.023231809958815575, -0.03703608736395836, -0.047140609472990036, -0.020951474085450172, 0.024250557646155357, 0.03764757141470909, -0.018936166539788246, -0.008573638275265694, 0.05690358579158783, 0.002127281855791807, -0.02013377659022808, 0.0025296586100012064, -0.04493843764066696, -0.0053863017819821835, 0.0033278712071478367, -0.01218667533248663, -0.0361565537750721, 0.005440264940261841, -0.0002820505469571799, 0.005044890101999044, 0.02641814760863781, -0.03062320314347744, 0.05432553216814995, 0.029178455471992493, -0.026709910482168198, 0.0014949002070352435, -0.010387376882135868, 0.0545320063829422, -0.04345899820327759, -0.046233270317316055, -0.0829547867178917, -0.012804463505744934, 0.008560243993997574, 0.02751789428293705, 0.00337718753144145, 0.01048976555466652, -0.029840199276804924, 0.013820048421621323, -0.01923021487891674, -0.0101695004850626, -0.04598680138587952, 0.006456781644374132, -0.038326896727085114, -0.03608647361397743, -0.005375329405069351, 0.009493336081504822, 0.019695259630680084, -0.019795939326286316, 0.03627170994877815, -0.003998768050223589, -0.006966765969991684, 0.08111469447612762, -0.03987538069486618, -0.01771508902311325, -0.024620400741696358, -0.02670750394463539, -0.022949164733290672, -0.021010739728808403, -0.033530544489622116, -0.012697392143309116, -0.005691117141395807, 0.00023855238396208733, -0.01658894680440426, 0.07361509650945663, 0.00040058305603452027, 0.0023986580781638622, -0.02626155875623226, 0.02833729051053524, 0.007977953180670738, 0.04946719855070114, -0.010515774600207806, 0.03982970118522644, 0.03021259605884552, -0.01738300919532776, -0.059605326503515244, 0.002281756838783622, -0.04740550369024277, 0.02808500826358795, -0.02035566046833992, -0.02262105420231819, -0.0359000563621521, -0.015749994665384293, 0.029738958925008774, 0.038384851068258286, -0.004945558961480856, -0.011701731011271477, 0.039200473576784134, 0.027582351118326187, 0.026414476335048676, 0.002858412219211459, 0.05252841114997864, -0.004512200132012367, 0.0013583592372015119, 0.009778442792594433, -0.10346435010433197, -0.011892912909388542, -0.024616925045847893, -0.008873780257999897, 0.028821038082242012, 0.003918022848665714, -0.10455876588821411, 0.024383695796132088, -0.004106038250029087, 0.027563923969864845, -0.049453601241111755, 0.05162582919001579, 0.05963629111647606, -0.007973683066666126, -0.07549186050891876, -0.034014832228422165, 0.011339600197970867, -0.03133677691221237, -0.02233811840415001, -0.08005517721176147, 0.0214677844196558, -0.03127651289105415, -0.02836710214614868, 0.056609559804201126, -0.11248217523097992, -0.022352855652570724, 0.02506568282842636, -0.02638382278382778, 0.00016054141451604664, 0.02494146302342415, -0.05986962467432022, -0.006009632255882025, -0.011896017007529736, -0.016306810081005096, -0.00017995394591707736, -0.01832074671983719, -0.06213965266942978, 0.008286266587674618, 0.018472475931048393, -0.017886778339743614, 0.014648105949163437, -0.012980087660253048, -0.030870260670781136, -0.0015109266387298703, 0.036098841577768326, 0.010139490477740765, 0.007453458849340677, 0.0170910507440567, 0.02738644927740097, 0.022848717868328094, 0.018330061808228493, 0.012617978267371655, -0.028243903070688248, 0.004040404222905636, 0.003429906675592065, 0.012612995691597462, 0.0225725919008255, 0.0010994928888976574, -0.014004486612975597, -0.04380005598068237, 0.007358862552791834, -0.06967736780643463, -0.004154058173298836, -0.09615100175142288, -0.01349245011806488, 0.05598263069987297, 0.03466349467635155, 0.03550950437784195, -0.039230119436979294, 0.01422597374767065, 0.0384298600256443, 0.029842237010598183, 0.019255228340625763, 0.015211429446935654, 0.03825795277953148, 0.02173783630132675, 0.024507004767656326, -0.04738275334239006, -0.08954250067472458, 0.07131196558475494, -0.013539128005504608, -0.045434676110744476, -0.017253445461392403, -0.045052941888570786, -0.015342273749411106, 0.03728637844324112, -0.02930019237101078, 0.03955062851309776, -0.011937455274164677, -0.02410697378218174, -0.000533316982910037, -0.008200119249522686, -0.01597643457353115, 0.014409441500902176, -0.026724128052592278, -0.0978427454829216, -0.029694560915231705, -0.0020952741615474224, 0.02751277945935726, -0.06229936331510544, -0.06284858286380768, -0.0316273458302021, -0.04288198798894882, 0.04517234489321709, -0.014827204868197441, -0.06427837163209915, 0.010848524048924446, 0.03528861328959465, 0.00802201684564352, 0.0032683033496141434, 0.0004994962946511805, 0.05856647714972496, 0.029921570792794228, -0.03178563714027405, 0.0634196475148201, -0.021851839497685432, -0.08701404929161072, 0.015563267283141613, -0.02385793626308441, -0.027310175821185112, 0.04571622982621193, -0.028961556032299995, 0.01930691860616207, 0.08479286730289459, 0.05975063145160675, -0.016545254737138748, 0.061159539967775345, 0.019092421978712082, 0.050969984382390976, 0.09591837972402573, 0.006065107882022858, 0.06950746476650238, 0.047602392733097076, -0.06612294912338257, -0.005698681343346834, -0.05403229221701622, 0.04710763692855835, -0.04034337401390076, 0.013469270430505276, -0.011811119504272938, -0.03400224819779396, 0.0075844028033316135, -0.05855429172515869, -0.05468025058507919, -0.005331859923899174, -0.011471717618405819, 0.06842855364084244, 0.028870098292827606, -0.02693459764122963, 0.044459983706474304, -0.0293880645185709, 0.00992555171251297, -0.0077746049501001835, 0.008897615596652031, 0.06483054906129837, 0.02790665812790394, 0.029626822099089622, -0.019495591521263123, -0.0786181092262268, -0.025742903351783752, 0.0323038212954998, -0.018135635182261467, 0.02393433451652527, -0.04364442080259323, -0.041114840656518936, 0.0075947605073452, 0.04243107885122299, 0.011256872676312923, -0.010056661441922188, -0.019405007362365723, -0.025189854204654694, -0.029677361249923706, -0.00875483825802803, 0.07910396158695221, 0.019064243882894516, -0.005199610721319914, 0.013622529804706573, 0.001069138408638537, -0.012278420850634575, -0.00877421349287033, -0.008301391266286373, 0.02624920941889286, 0.03350228816270828, 0.05108538642525673, -0.025914324447512627, -0.03608741611242294, 0.053196754306554794, 0.04994598776102066, -0.024351803585886955, -0.04268147423863411, -0.06282931566238403, 0.03965398296713829, 0.03917375206947327, -0.016216009855270386, 0.012341012246906757, 0.009250173345208168, 0.00792080257087946, 0.028603021055459976, 0.016283255070447922, 0.05678781494498253, -0.009140091016888618, -0.009964721277356148, -0.05709696188569069, 0.07127423584461212, 0.10585024952888489, 0.006363545544445515, -0.08563166111707687, 0.0031137950718402863, -0.06885191798210144, 0.06682086735963821, 0.10127244889736176, -0.016335131600499153, 0.0966549664735794, 0.025131646543741226, -0.015210354700684547, 0.03931491822004318, 0.03619048371911049, 0.03959369286894798, -0.034346550703048706, 0.009845263324677944, 0.03177713230252266, -0.031251296401023865, -0.05620122328400612, -0.01395378541201353, -0.00833224505186081, -0.004704372491687536, -0.024365991353988647, 0.020498136058449745, -0.019093478098511696, -0.060315996408462524, -0.0011582744773477316, -0.014116810634732246, 0.029881222173571587, 0.009664822369813919, 0.009325218386948109, 0.033315278589725494, 0.04372773319482803, 0.02098853513598442, -0.01279766857624054, -0.006875861901789904, 0.008569831028580666, 0.007705364841967821, 0.010571427643299103, -0.004311710130423307, 0.0017559746047481894, -0.06416380405426025, -0.03275164216756821, 0.00174437474925071, -0.04356946051120758, -0.029116123914718628, 0.04021725058555603, 0.06270261108875275, -0.016436029225587845, 0.0182656142860651, -0.002883761888369918, 0.03030041977763176, -0.013660330325365067, 0.0658024325966835, -0.006557900458574295, -0.005943313241004944, -0.0020078010857105255, 0.02063324861228466, 0.05637776106595993, 0.04254445433616638, -0.00981612503528595, -0.026401827111840248, -0.006445758976042271, -0.023586859926581383, -0.024792160838842392, 0.032124727964401245, -0.017936211079359055, 0.047145649790763855, -0.02110270969569683, 0.07227024435997009, 0.05125775188207626, 0.08955741673707962, 0.017360351979732513, 0.029614154249429703, -0.00048738770419731736, 0.017056908458471298, -0.02210661582648754, 0.009329422377049923, 0.017081398516893387, -0.02548053115606308, 0.027229519560933113, -0.027752477675676346, -0.030807940289378166, 0.07581515610218048, -0.017647145316004753, 0.03427018225193024, -0.03180209919810295, 0.00047232856741175056, -0.04901780188083649, 0.03614659234881401, 0.012123394757509232, -0.0005100444541312754, -0.024488277733325958, 0.0943073034286499, 0.046942517161369324, 0.02061728574335575, 0.014309372752904892, -0.00884617492556572, 0.02339359186589718, 0.007354523055255413, -0.034719645977020264, -0.016367938369512558, -0.028514521196484566, 0.03261188045144081, 0.010781905613839626, 0.06012320891022682, 0.024908000603318214, 0.023891370743513107, 0.038117289543151855, 0.007880544289946556, 0.016028573736548424, -0.054259803146123886, 0.026573628187179565, 0.039764877408742905, 0.021493103355169296, 0.03353752940893173, 0.03741968050599098, 0.005156242288649082, -0.0734630823135376, 0.022318685427308083, -0.03396201133728027, -0.07257180660963058, 0.04539799690246582, 0.04307711869478226, -0.05053362995386124, 0.002236147178336978, -0.013874075375497341, 0.005319269839674234, 0.047907065600156784, -0.03674371540546417, -0.05044949799776077, -0.028363045305013657, -0.08898665755987167, -0.0003637027111835778, -0.038397010415792465, -0.004866014700382948, 0.03688078746199608, 0.021335037425160408, 0.03497050702571869, -0.015612557530403137, -0.01906319335103035, 0.03956031799316406, 0.03346873074769974, 0.08261355012655258, -0.0233109463006258, 0.015612580813467503, 0.009784541092813015, -0.03743375465273857, -0.014972330071032047, -0.06257567554712296, -0.016462821513414383, -0.022130170837044716, 0.0266061220318079, 0.0001765829074429348, 0.01294526644051075, -0.0018929354846477509, -0.042788028717041016, 0.02773437090218067, -0.025683118030428886, -0.0076314727775752544, -0.02848592959344387, 0.047836728394031525, -0.00802625622600317, -0.05217903479933739, 0.05668241158127785, 0.023514365777373314, 0.0326249934732914, 0.034635450690984726, 0.019325323402881622, -0.0023957029916346073, 0.04517518728971481, 0.004180261865258217, 0.0006305408314801753, 0.010728023014962673, -0.04350646957755089, 0.058126624673604965, 0.03677845746278763, 0.015625931322574615, -0.02778267301619053, 0.014043872244656086, 0.06676531583070755, -0.011624273844063282, 0.04359070211648941, 0.022747425362467766, -0.05799909308552742, -0.027126556262373924, -0.00927803386002779, 0.011187100782990456, 0.018334485590457916, 0.030398191884160042, -0.044572144746780396, -0.026578111574053764, 0.05766695737838745, 0.05783207714557648, 0.09806621819734573, 0.004011469427496195, 0.05824817344546318, -0.01677718199789524, -0.004987320862710476, 0.0777575820684433, 0.04809023067355156, 0.002008673269301653, 0.03981819376349449, 0.003504483262076974, 0.03829112648963928, -0.019887354224920273, 0.009653172455728054, -0.029070883989334106, 0.02111227624118328, -0.020633652806282043, 0.00919845700263977, -0.01885959319770336, 0.024139637127518654, -0.05648934096097946, -0.00029323683702386916, -0.019128456711769104, -0.02102862298488617, -0.010806749574840069, 0.0032427904661744833, 0.0019582086242735386, 0.05160309746861458, 0.030603814870119095, -0.011563858017325401, -0.046319130808115005, -0.04502643272280693, -0.05220794677734375, -0.03280234709382057, -0.1216534823179245, -0.0055169169791042805, -0.010194262489676476, -0.004772499203681946, 0.06344101577997208, 0.0142816212028265, 0.014556564390659332, 0.007287222426384687, -0.020318957045674324, -0.040437135845422745, 0.014076112769544125, 0.035080183297395706, 0.02691945806145668, -0.03537894785404205, 0.015731384977698326, -0.003095431951805949, 0.02120991051197052, 0.04184550791978836, 0.009376890026032925, -0.011866878718137741, -0.0519038625061512, -0.00818074680864811, 0.02774580754339695, 0.017982251942157745, 0.0020651016384363174, -0.01687329262495041, 0.025944653898477554, 0.04523460566997528, -0.020069457590579987, 0.04255388677120209, -0.009685266762971878, -0.035322822630405426, -0.046077754348516464, 0.05411229282617569, 0.027596257627010345, 0.052212752401828766, -0.05771063640713692, 0.004537364933639765, -0.0021353275515139103, -0.022141272202134132, -0.05763963982462883, -0.008148480206727982, -0.007898302748799324, 0.02714042365550995, 0.005572120193392038, -0.01795163005590439, -0.051306985318660736, -0.0013595422497019172, 0.03164088726043701, 0.008719922974705696, -0.03229854255914688, -0.00863516516983509, 0.023011336103081703, -0.01602337136864662, -0.055205006152391434, -0.030195124447345734, -0.05461271107196808, -0.01630856841802597, 0.03523184359073639, -0.0403623953461647, -0.00422604801133275, -0.010913750156760216, 0.03506745770573616, 0.034828174859285355, -0.051582273095846176, -0.031451888382434845, -0.003135029226541519, 0.02620784565806389, 0.0456438809633255, -0.012952165678143501, 0.025860676541924477, -0.0038599453400820494, -0.07145514339208603, -0.0045423381961882114, -0.041002582758665085, 0.02564355544745922, -0.031399812549352646, -0.025821363553404808, -0.02795645035803318, -0.009509180672466755, 0.05170291289687157, -0.029392747208476067, -0.012814179994165897, 0.0215940922498703, 0.0042722467333078384, 0.020812582224607468, -0.0076858485117554665, 0.011210360564291477, -0.004989870358258486, -0.05034444481134415, 0.0521567240357399, -0.012467274442315102, -0.001923013012856245, -0.017212288454174995, -0.030331414192914963, 0.03011561743915081, -0.00005233778938418254, 0.04267085716128349, 0.027949463576078415, -0.027153272181749344, -0.02922615222632885, 0.06423045694828033, -0.04889332130551338, -0.02275938354432583, 0.0043768067844212055, -0.01483824010938406, -0.006008805241435766, -0.006812079343944788, 0.002227461664006114, 0.0158089529722929, 0.011792651377618313, 0.060113102197647095, -0.019736867398023605, -0.05655761808156967, 0.04995866119861603, 0.0005040405667386949, 0.06892690807580948, 0.004847124684602022, 0.07439656555652618, -0.0029491265304386616, -0.08461418002843857, -0.0006977266748435795, -0.052817054092884064, 0.02577969804406166, 0.0034099812619388103, -0.023392297327518463, -0.011412468738853931, 0.032969389110803604, -0.012666798196732998, -0.028014857321977615, 0.015697689726948738, 0.005504258908331394, 0.012761734426021576, -0.0072941854596138, -0.02095257304608822, 0.024863459169864655, 0.011337979696691036, 0.0022653795313090086, -0.05230904743075371, -0.02809816412627697, -0.00252898340113461, 0.006854221690446138, -0.024265902116894722, -0.006309424061328173, 0.006862746085971594, -0.012166228145360947, -0.035537563264369965, 0.03870679438114166, -0.015645772218704224, 0.008309274911880493, -0.09448084980249405, -0.0043839095160365105, 0.03384840860962868, 0.042731355875730515, -0.008218377828598022, 0.031027989462018013, -0.04790240153670311, -0.04759381711483002, 0.014712671749293804, 0.024531353265047073, -0.013128824532032013, 0.024276714771986008, 0.04517597705125809, -0.014154837466776371, -0.023588141426444054, -0.005821529310196638, -0.002195044420659542, -0.035488877445459366, -0.06305989623069763, 0.025121456012129784, -0.02086067758500576, -0.010376968421041965, -0.044824521988630295 ]
<p><strong>If any equations are there ,for split the light particle, means that i have a 1m length of light just consider that in that who can i split the light particle into 1/2 m length Pls tell</strong> </p>
g6613
[ 0.008809944614768028, 0.03234610706567764, -0.0029986160807311535, -0.0063290074467659, 0.02388668805360794, -0.02975541353225708, -0.024128692224621773, 0.0009605145896784961, 0.03501228615641594, -0.014410842210054398, -0.00423715403303504, 0.003804980544373393, -0.06017950177192688, -0.007503341417759657, 0.00369343557395041, -0.02305402047932148, 0.07883558422327042, -0.05278795212507248, 0.020986242219805717, 0.03372323885560036, -0.04858950525522232, 0.0025874332059174776, 0.0002503292926121503, -0.0842568427324295, 0.0037049369420856237, -0.036696985363960266, 0.037036631256341934, 0.006394180003553629, -0.06678061187267303, 0.03254837915301323, 0.04405594617128372, -0.01401430368423462, 0.0448453351855278, -0.03026210330426693, -0.04140055924654007, -0.052273672074079514, 0.05438855662941933, -0.02407883107662201, 0.014745170250535011, 0.026653572916984558, 0.02487361803650856, -0.02395697310566902, 0.023667415603995323, -0.04288431629538536, 0.031688813120126724, -0.001383457682095468, -0.004456010647118092, 0.02863325923681259, -0.01250483188778162, -0.09137865155935287, -0.008347772061824799, 0.007623753510415554, -0.02600673772394657, 0.013512801378965378, 0.018600542098283768, 0.03660503774881363, -0.00308660208247602, -0.05573815479874611, 0.06231939420104027, 0.02114729955792427, 0.008064983412623405, -0.05999273061752319, 0.017637819051742554, 0.020201776176691055, 0.03805660828948021, 0.0036557589191943407, -0.024181900545954704, -0.07502482086420059, -0.01866927556693554, 0.0030758981592953205, 0.025814665481448174, -0.020162880420684814, 0.030070703476667404, -0.05009875074028969, -0.030719870701432228, -0.0488470084965229, 0.0033312449231743813, 0.05793379247188568, -0.0024775592610239983, 0.03688483685255051, 0.0074156043119728565, -0.020771563053131104, -0.022604892030358315, 0.022289790213108063, 0.0010073371231555939, 0.006252852734178305, 0.03251635655760765, -0.030130799859762192, -0.009309157729148865, 0.00693102739751339, -0.020490873605012894, -0.06220194324851036, 0.03247750923037529, -0.0026268784422427416, -0.006292527541518211, -0.014429336413741112, 0.03903280571103096, 0.03371473774313927, -0.029813092201948166, -0.002271966775879264, -0.0259584691375494, 0.01321231760084629, -0.024490518495440483, -0.00035110715543851256, 0.0378926582634449, 0.011799517087638378, 0.015030158683657646, 0.002726802369579673, 0.008989563211798668, -0.00348004512488842, 0.012397252023220062, -0.04492213577032089, -0.08688739687204361, 0.009636472910642624, -0.01173205766826868, -0.05368747562170029, 0.08708995580673218, -0.05895749107003212, -0.020010925829410553, 0.026211990043520927, 0.0314534455537796, -0.04839286953210831, 0.03919234499335289, 0.04688343033194542, -0.010207561776041985, -0.009568209759891033, 0.05094973370432854, 0.045831773430109024, 0.014292886480689049, -0.029204120859503746, 0.016704149544239044, -0.01337892934679985, 0.016109274700284004, 0.03257995843887329, -0.05733034387230873, 0.06457240134477615, 0.07384926080703735, -0.0032652902882546186, 0.008602926507592201, 0.007413126528263092, -0.02684623934328556, -0.01914733275771141, 0.01848687417805195, 0.007486459333449602, -0.037060681730508804, 0.02230430208146572, 0.012472327798604965, 0.005100110545754433, -0.019960980862379074, 0.0541682094335556, -0.0007095457403920591, 0.055298540741205215, -0.037231527268886566, 0.024899648502469063, -0.015316436998546124, -0.04782348498702049, -0.009528973139822483, -0.013482972979545593, -0.027644570916891098, -0.01304816547781229, 0.030135322362184525, 0.0653034895658493, -0.05721953138709068, -0.013591596856713295, -0.1287352591753006, 0.03244408592581749, -0.028903720900416374, -0.043800950050354004, -0.0111243249848485, -0.0963967889547348, -0.05687791481614113, 0.06623336672782898, 0.07460248470306396, -0.027215519919991493, 0.029895147308707237, 0.018619436770677567, -0.03182835504412651, 0.017834404483437538, -0.012310046702623367, 0.06084132194519043, -0.02937040477991104, 0.021757299080491066, 0.034349165856838226, -0.02449236623942852, -0.024678312242031097, -0.032058436423540115, -0.040687043219804764, -0.03152688220143318, -0.014921868219971657, -0.029856521636247635, 0.005663187708705664, 0.04706630855798721, -0.0009028769563883543, 0.021631108596920967, -0.007927223108708858, -0.032683584839105606, 0.007961422204971313, 0.015051268972456455, -0.038374073803424835, 0.019368911162018776, 0.024801313877105713, 0.06585898250341415, 0.0073029357008636, 0.03655674681067467, 0.05668584257364273, -0.05787672474980354, -0.0018312743632122874, -0.003180445171892643, 0.024473516270518303, 0.006084311753511429, 0.0468270368874073, -0.024798288941383362, 0.01379158440977335, 0.008734040893614292, -0.05155494809150696, -0.0647689551115036, -0.006995198782533407, -0.000239901986788027, 0.011781774461269379, -0.020507151260972023, 0.010370273143053055, 0.043355755507946014, 0.06223919987678528, -0.025007760152220726, 0.0013551710871979594, 0.019682815298438072, -0.003304692218080163, -0.015087290666997433, 0.026729928329586983, 0.029789090156555176, -0.03377583622932434, 0.026899952441453934, 0.018519723787903786, -0.006837294436991215, 0.042895086109638214, 0.0010660119587555528, -0.07389196753501892, 0.025002693757414818, -0.00714271143078804, 0.00850710179656744, 0.008855056948959827, -0.022106757387518883, -0.003845229046419263, 0.006676706485450268, -0.008267122320830822, 0.026599163189530373, 0.012522506527602673, -0.025671809911727905, -0.04649633541703224, -0.03498663753271103, 0.005782025866210461, -0.007448095362633467, -0.031413108110427856, 0.029468141496181488, -0.03820512816309929, -0.07871027290821075, -0.017316563054919243, 0.060507066547870636, -0.10341386497020721, -0.031539447605609894, -0.0019453266868367791, 0.030589720234274864, 0.0005787981790490448, -0.0007927383994683623, -0.05539685860276222, -0.02403545193374157, -0.0017468467121943831, 0.04119015857577324, 0.04225142300128937, -0.0019182795658707619, -0.011920711025595665, 0.04288443922996521, 0.017305517569184303, 0.01056792214512825, -0.05184146761894226, 0.00878725852817297, -0.014536400325596333, -0.032873477786779404, 0.029835281893610954, -0.026548102498054504, 0.00007279690908035263, 0.006087622605264187, -0.05059771239757538, 0.017293494194746017, 0.046187885105609894, -0.07103496044874191, -0.012390600517392159, -0.008261640556156635, -0.02890390157699585, 0.026610177010297775, -0.037923648953437805, 0.007307861000299454, 0.04252133145928383, -0.03395973518490791, -0.012813159264624119, -0.009955658577382565, 0.019041916355490685, 0.01196043100208044, -0.019245600327849388, -0.05051551014184952, 0.0037234663031995296, -0.0023308603558689356, -0.010685528628528118, 0.03819470480084419, 0.049198735505342484, 0.0356488898396492, 0.011347471736371517, -0.004786030855029821, 0.05316240340471268, 0.0014531955821439624, 0.017241835594177246, 0.07562679052352905, 0.08942326158285141, -0.026657061651349068, -0.04489721730351448, -0.042880717664957047, -0.06190551817417145, -0.03205212578177452, -0.030093681067228317, -0.0050192940980196, 0.040271539241075516, -0.07228580862283707, -0.020760223269462585, -0.027980631217360497, -0.030859149992465973, -0.06250375509262085, 0.005677917506545782, -0.005641002673655748, -0.03813894838094711, 0.03298509120941162, -0.05817165970802307, -0.05057211592793465, -0.005645722150802612, -0.004937125835567713, -0.0003900952578987926, -0.021365264430642128, 0.021045871078968048, -0.03416670113801956, 0.04232776165008545, -0.07159032672643661, -0.024011077359318733, 0.00338254333473742, -0.08270703256130219, 0.057289257645606995, -0.013283705338835716, -0.011342054232954979, -0.0214524082839489, 0.03026120737195015, 0.06556125730276108, -0.030042069032788277, -0.0018297376809641719, 0.025198061019182205, -0.023402119055390358, -0.07748272269964218, 0.0210577305406332, -0.004543299321085215, 0.05429304018616676, 0.07119667530059814, 0.019056906923651695, -0.012869144789874554, 0.03067578375339508, 0.022850871086120605, 0.05296020582318306, 0.023218734189867973, -0.03532986715435982, 0.022592181339859962, -0.0006532445549964905, 0.04937402904033661, -0.004919958300888538, 0.007280793506652117, 0.026885146275162697, -0.033151961863040924, 0.012719382531940937, 0.04814878851175308, -0.017071478068828583, -0.001261006691493094, 0.04249780625104904, -0.02929338440299034, 0.03393450379371643, 0.01269487850368023, 0.0338040329515934, 0.04415447264909744, 0.01679288037121296, 0.04962576553225517, -0.0016258730320259929, 0.001008909777738154, -0.026566676795482635, -0.011969302780926228, -0.0019380308222025633, -0.00622697826474905, 0.06893216073513031, -0.09157753735780716, -0.04928918927907944, 0.009771664626896381, -0.023248877376317978, 0.004569647368043661, -0.03200275078415871, 0.00953864585608244, -0.06905490905046463, -0.00720540527254343, -0.04256201162934303, 0.003132687881588936, 0.011065494269132614, -0.02567286789417267, -0.007816562429070473, 0.016272038221359253, -0.026978421956300735, -0.06594433635473251, 0.012272818014025688, 0.03602002561092377, 0.03156478703022003, -0.005806359462440014, -0.012951940298080444, -0.058864906430244446, -0.028501367196440697, -0.02511822059750557, -0.023899201303720474, 0.009113956242799759, 0.020068097859621048, 0.0034614086616784334, -0.0002493645588401705, 0.008168242871761322, -0.02374342642724514, 0.017552262172102928, -0.08182206004858017, 0.021695714443922043, 0.03357849270105362, 0.033669933676719666, 0.006505705416202545, -0.02843031845986843, -0.016303174197673798, -0.02385588176548481, -0.01333770714700222, -0.058052267879247665, 0.0030303436797112226, 0.053867559880018234, -0.00473722955211997, -0.004155071452260017, -0.03339114785194397, 0.03646857291460037, 0.0333516001701355, -0.005901569966226816, 0.06169331446290016, 0.003015098161995411, 0.06008625403046608, -0.04367293417453766, 0.0006483405013568699, -0.03477868810296059, -0.04443066939711571, -0.03313305974006653, 0.01342792995274067, 0.012111752294003963, -0.05347906053066254, -0.043531496077775955, -0.01153169572353363, 0.00770283117890358, -0.02502436935901642, -0.009499900974333286, 0.007227947004139423, 0.045124221593141556, -0.01684695854783058, -0.0425526462495327, 0.09439355134963989, -0.028690608218312263, -0.006439195945858955, -0.0003028804494533688, -0.08826802670955658, 0.027415135875344276, 0.009879772551357746, 0.011554940603673458, -0.05909915268421173, -0.0009399459231644869, -0.01040488202124834, -0.039086490869522095, -0.008680474013090134, -0.04174618795514107, -0.06112522631883621, -0.002738261828199029, -0.013483863323926926, 0.001023232121951878, 0.013776049017906189, -0.011456689797341824, -0.010112036019563675, -0.00602469639852643, 0.07497608661651611, 0.04025426134467125, 0.010445808991789818, 0.02482953853905201, -0.003171484684571624, -0.11327113956212997, -0.009342964738607407, 0.06220490485429764, -0.03576270863413811, -0.006043475586920977, -0.03403123840689659, 0.015569034032523632, 0.009947344660758972, -0.04224727302789688, 0.03682701662182808, 0.04951101914048195, 0.001757943071424961, -0.02559387870132923, 0.04366089031100273, 0.008360018022358418, -0.03834552690386772, 0.012726033106446266, -0.009186474606394768, 0.0062504480592906475, -0.049136679619550705, 0.034462638199329376, 0.11904092133045197, -0.042954664677381516, 0.06575385481119156, 0.021113432943820953, -0.00007211721822386608, -0.021057240664958954, 0.020342400297522545, 0.10513238608837128, 0.004824652802199125, 0.005091846454888582, -0.0034934321884065866, -0.053035080432891846, 0.08523021638393402, -0.01400342583656311, 0.011539699509739876, -0.05344250053167343, -0.09836689382791519, -0.01316033024340868, 0.04979986324906349, 0.0313439667224884, 0.021508662030100822, 0.03148868680000305, -0.033809974789619446, 0.0066449581645429134, 0.01170854177325964, -0.0636182650923729, 0.042294543236494064, -0.015308920294046402, -0.02072487771511078, -0.049471303820610046, 0.0012474539689719677, -0.013816985301673412, -0.005867575760930777, 0.054496828466653824, -0.01653168350458145, -0.011027932167053223, -0.03395526483654976, -0.003324101446196437, 0.023445438593626022, -0.029019832611083984, 0.07841723412275314, 0.01759609766304493, 0.003593775676563382, -0.008127925917506218, 0.05489683896303177, 0.0257075484842062, -0.021384643390774727, -0.015408176928758621, -0.001549220411106944, 0.035685282200574875, -0.01966971904039383, -0.015474542044103146, 0.028307948261499405, -0.04782382771372795, -0.02814732864499092, -0.01880398578941822, -0.0016417086590081453, -0.05470661818981171, -0.0006724241538904607, 0.04828551784157753, 0.021367469802498817, 0.011075091548264027, 0.012377593666315079, -0.0005619129515253007, 0.019491884857416153, -0.026401076465845108, 0.029789280146360397, -0.02105504274368286, -0.06368303298950195, -0.013838517479598522, -0.006431150250136852, 0.04882539436221123, 0.01267852634191513, -0.016767382621765137, -0.04678783938288689, 0.06878524273633957, -0.020014839246869087, 0.026736542582511902, 0.05029233545064926, -0.011451203376054764, 0.029438553377985954, -0.026368020102381706, -0.045650675892829895, -0.062272120267152786, -0.04275594651699066, -0.016771715134382248, 0.03761174529790878, -0.022752031683921814, 0.0183868445456028, 0.019691217690706253, 0.028954021632671356, 0.06656372547149658, -0.025911826640367508, 0.012531975284218788, 0.03746237978339195, -0.0018808591412380338, -0.03874680772423744, 0.017238132655620575, 0.06466095894575119, 0.014330095611512661, -0.005424927920103073, 0.016806792467832565, -0.008983067236840725, 0.0018141631735488772, -0.032664839178323746, -0.03397364541888237, 0.00336338859051466, -0.004910860676318407, 0.03289514780044556, -0.007674399297684431, -0.022680429741740227, -0.031811751425266266, -0.023584647104144096, -0.06454755365848541, 0.05162922292947769, 0.11789047718048096, -0.005401500966399908, 0.035893771797418594, 0.012370560318231583, 0.014494520612061024, 0.06689674407243729, 0.010502117685973644, 0.011648912914097309, 0.0037303308490663767, 0.029550207778811455, 0.03108813986182213, -0.00966672319918871, 0.0029749118257313967, -0.0058914716355502605, 0.11326602846384048, 0.046323634684085846, 0.03327799588441849, 0.03109363093972206, 0.020341554656624794, -0.03667953237891197, 0.01536957360804081, 0.02412586100399494, 0.047991763800382614, 0.004868173506110907, -0.028433717787265778, -0.04464463144540787, 0.048846643418073654, -0.04067124053835869, 0.03637075051665306, 0.030172379687428474, -0.03339936584234238, -0.03471149504184723, -0.024739792570471764, 0.026487581431865692, -0.04413105174899101, 0.003681376576423645, -0.02755182422697544, 0.03681075572967529, -0.07089850306510925, 0.0008492720080539584, 0.028887489810585976, 0.007095435634255409, -0.02043348178267479, -0.02196473255753517, -0.02758052945137024, -0.01601419970393181, -0.0485554076731205, -0.022738218307495117, 0.023759067058563232, -0.03102591447532177, 0.01980181783437729, -0.0015889956848695874, 0.040314026176929474, 0.02170741930603981, -0.04733505845069885, 0.07167581468820572, 0.03687050938606262, -0.031198957934975624, -0.0008673352422192693, 0.014895268715918064, -0.02440294623374939, 0.009425537660717964, -0.031955163925886154, 0.07018774002790451, 0.01920800656080246, -0.01608465611934662, 0.01849229820072651, -0.00309633812867105, -0.004067319445312023, -0.0443129800260067, -0.02585662715137005, -0.00010805845522554591, 0.07922209054231644, 0.07257860153913498, 0.022539734840393066, -0.01155238039791584, -0.010515358299016953, 0.03586605191230774, 0.026121584698557854, -0.01114126481115818, -0.005635568872094154, -0.01773533597588539, 0.010607769712805748, 0.0006506494246423244, -0.03806658834218979, -0.011728774756193161, 0.04193919897079468, -0.015079171396791935, 0.035309694707393646, 0.01734633557498455, 0.012616113759577274, 0.013106072321534157, 0.049687910825014114, 0.09433571249246597, 0.006561491172760725, 0.008026588708162308, -0.061730850487947464, -0.019528469070792198, -0.01704452373087406, -0.007075236178934574, -0.007928548380732536, 0.04393325373530388, 0.001123911584727466, -0.014639308676123619, 0.03168296813964844, 0.09543102979660034, 0.02058178186416626, -0.0032597738318145275, -0.03077189438045025, -0.01938355714082718, 0.0021368816960603, -0.017791444435715675, 0.027106430381536484, 0.00401823315769434, 0.048134706914424896, -0.009803405031561852, -0.0774914100766182, -0.04984922334551811, -0.006241677328944206, 0.011742337606847286, -0.024700528010725975, -0.06254570186138153, 0.026401350274682045, 0.05432320386171341, 0.012573645450174809, 0.004302150569856167, 0.03583182021975517, 0.002072704490274191, 0.06326421350240707, 0.04976995661854744, -0.0973975732922554, 0.01006518118083477, 0.01629512570798397, -0.042399343103170395, -0.00914961937814951, 0.003213695017620921, -0.019727760925889015, 0.05491822212934494, 0.05054822564125061, 0.044897742569446564, 0.03339701518416405, -0.005860649514943361, -0.004111462272703648 ]
<p>While watching a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schlieren_photography" rel="nofollow">Schlieren</a> video of a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CR22kpG3ig" rel="nofollow">hand clapping</a>, I noted a very distinct difference between a sound wave and a puff of air, which were both created by a hand clapping. What is the difference between a puff of air and a sound wave regarding creation and propagation?</p> <p>In the video, it appears that some of the energy goes into the sound wave and some of the energy goes into the puff. Is there a principle that governs the distribution of impact energy between oscillation (sound) and pushing (puff?) </p>
g6614
[ 0.08384833484888077, 0.073977991938591, -0.006369912065565586, 0.013381336815655231, -0.010485394857823849, 0.07869991660118103, 0.04811746999621391, 0.08355558663606644, 0.0005751876742579043, -0.06131456419825554, -0.016468416899442673, -0.019904348999261856, -0.013665001839399338, 0.0450914092361927, 0.08835349977016449, -0.02511064149439335, 0.06035479158163071, -0.04272361844778061, 0.010289349593222141, 0.07585598528385162, -0.018350351601839066, -0.004585402086377144, -0.045863520354032516, -0.06827966123819351, 0.010753914713859558, -0.023226451128721237, -0.012861919589340687, -0.0600050650537014, -0.03184530511498451, -0.07790631800889969, 0.009901560842990875, 0.04771178588271141, 0.07913520932197571, -0.008925927802920341, -0.037034906446933746, 0.011387346312403679, 0.0339181050658226, -0.06403252482414246, -0.004839964676648378, 0.006077186204493046, 0.0013869075337424874, -0.02260078676044941, 0.015699751675128937, -0.02733941189944744, -0.008936001919209957, 0.027850143611431122, -0.016840560361742973, 0.03049486130475998, 0.012159446254372597, -0.027688145637512207, -0.012177192606031895, -0.04954086244106293, -0.035333894193172455, 0.014535259455442429, 0.02335837110877037, -0.01234493125230074, 0.038640379905700684, -0.02585803158581257, 0.0656011700630188, -0.008867952041327953, -0.03838595002889633, 0.05811396241188049, 0.02134229987859726, 0.02088073082268238, 0.027282094582915306, -0.010969760827720165, -0.027611229568719864, -0.018879162147641182, 0.061674561351537704, 0.015467624180018902, 0.04736122488975525, -0.04553814232349396, 0.00561571167781949, 0.02233475260436535, 0.007937743328511715, 0.012846535071730614, 0.010421019978821278, -0.020194299519062042, -0.007050875574350357, 0.04742363095283508, 0.043649058789014816, 0.01540882047265768, 0.059397537261247635, -0.011513526551425457, 0.08638425916433334, -0.01893373765051365, -0.02682610973715782, 0.017765291035175323, -0.019748913124203682, 0.01537372823804617, -0.01256510429084301, -0.014408084563910961, 0.0925910472869873, 0.0367000587284565, -0.05326593667268753, -0.036991480737924576, -0.051514238119125366, 0.10645856708288193, 0.04241056740283966, -0.00282437726855278, -0.013972864486277103, -0.02032341994345188, 0.025682510808110237, 0.0027834626380354166, -0.025981426239013672, -0.01999458111822605, -0.01701486110687256, -0.027333373203873634, -0.02215416356921196, -0.029757047072052956, -0.026009606197476387, -0.03720858693122864, 0.01901589147746563, 0.015005160123109818, 0.005615530535578728, -0.023676998913288116, -0.00513291172683239, 0.0482960045337677, -0.003296816721558571, 0.05303812399506569, 0.029919642955064774, -0.04620921239256859, -0.04744157940149307, 0.016684824600815773, -0.007077193818986416, -0.003033439861610532, -0.0025457649026066065, -0.06107762083411217, -0.002812459832057357, 0.029569296166300774, 0.03009008802473545, -0.008371514268219471, 0.022456806153059006, -0.03829387575387955, 0.039563123136758804, -0.02007485367357731, 0.010590349324047565, -0.004324091598391533, 0.03413708508014679, -0.009349600411951542, 0.061727650463581085, -0.019943904131650925, 0.025219950824975967, -0.0404522642493248, -0.028568310663104057, 0.013039302080869675, 0.017248768359422684, 0.011383640579879284, 0.02637370489537716, 0.02923007868230343, -0.01405855268239975, 0.03717466816306114, -0.04275260120630264, -0.01933782920241356, 0.022469040006399155, 0.017153723165392876, -0.023521803319454193, 0.031179610639810562, -0.01351141557097435, 0.028465477749705315, 0.013449195772409439, -0.04195312783122063, 0.054383523762226105, -0.008223573677241802, -0.005671943537890911, 0.003706826362758875, 0.012328645214438438, -0.055622730404138565, 0.006657175254076719, 0.03941228985786438, -0.038489144295454025, -0.027874428778886795, -0.045996859669685364, 0.025827178731560707, -0.021723223850131035, 0.060944247990846634, 0.05860523134469986, -0.03248254582285881, 0.04202664643526077, -0.0516357384622097, -0.036050304770469666, -0.06076280400156975, -0.044749315828084946, -0.037579506635665894, 0.05372995138168335, 0.022623801603913307, 0.03096761368215084, -0.04877403751015663, -0.05408762767910957, 0.0029479253571480513, -0.052537452429533005, -0.04641705006361008, -0.018454745411872864, 0.024051904678344727, -0.052076686173677444, 0.01915387250483036, 0.032780058681964874, -0.03680836036801338, -0.03930423781275749, 0.02749246172606945, -0.015990622341632843, -0.014358592219650745, 0.055765338242053986, -0.040737226605415344, -0.019063811749219894, 0.09302707761526108, -0.0028128258418291807, 0.021140804514288902, 0.004656090866774321, -0.02754145860671997, -0.034601591527462006, -0.012051675468683243, 0.037571799010038376, 0.0033958510030061007, 0.028801461681723595, 0.041794389486312866, 0.014586969278752804, -0.02899756468832493, -0.0348815992474556, -0.015555167570710182, 0.01848219893872738, 0.03012125752866268, 0.05926733464002609, -0.052400875836610794, 0.02004721574485302, -0.03312944620847702, -0.0059404801577329636, -0.03038218803703785, -0.055997658520936966, 0.031538840383291245, -0.03131323307752609, -0.02430458553135395, -0.020976461470127106, 0.014281155541539192, 0.004103609826415777, 0.01434223260730505, -0.001139226951636374, 0.001576690236106515, 0.002203154843300581, -0.03493284061551094, -0.020699091255664825, -0.07951148599386215, 0.012630196288228035, -0.012256472371518612, 0.00960597675293684, -0.04868682846426964, 0.02813594602048397, -0.021053485572338104, 0.006562119349837303, 0.002197884488850832, 0.021615060046315193, -0.005627811886370182, -0.01401451788842678, -0.014833169989287853, 0.008711667731404305, -0.011799231171607971, -0.01978415809571743, 0.006634152960032225, -0.011684421449899673, 0.0015878260601311922, -0.012794229201972485, -0.017958560958504677, 0.010031272657215595, 0.03144363686442375, -0.05668574199080467, 0.00691373972222209, 0.009584013372659683, 0.032321035861968994, -0.0485045425593853, -0.03754917159676552, -0.03511255607008934, 0.05921198055148125, -0.04051951318979263, -0.006435925606638193, -0.03882419317960739, -0.009899893775582314, 0.041045427322387695, 0.011518442071974277, 0.010296178981661797, -0.010854020714759827, 0.02251424826681614, -0.008214768022298813, -0.0141378128901124, 0.015326405875384808, 0.04106829687952995, -0.07958751171827316, -0.0001726553018670529, -0.008361311629414558, 0.007881324738264084, 0.020883167162537575, -0.008565954864025116, 0.01558519434183836, -0.033387862145900726, 0.04109114035964012, -0.037633348256349564, 0.05644175037741661, -0.002435702597722411, -0.045562565326690674, -0.04602905362844467, -0.007242216728627682, -0.0035051291342824697, -0.03522436320781708, 0.0037062542978674173, 0.004906851798295975, -0.0012094768462702632, 0.04810883104801178, -0.021013472229242325, -0.04152160510420799, -0.01482956949621439, -0.003422816749662161, 0.010147321969270706, 0.03139404579997063, -0.01659378781914711, 0.023425985127687454, -0.011797788552939892, -0.07666178047657013, -0.0075177354738116264, 0.006812987383455038, 0.022645113989710808, 0.012735101394355297, -0.05329670011997223, -0.04257113113999367, 0.006953629199415445, 0.011285376735031605, 0.04558686912059784, 0.007518148981034756, -0.0012838257243856788, 0.030378930270671844, -0.025866933166980743, -0.054183073341846466, -0.045705996453762054, -0.007386409677565098, -0.06711982190608978, -0.04769400879740715, 0.01254427433013916, -0.047426700592041016, -0.042388666421175, 0.008880937471985817, 0.03152596950531006, 0.08358874917030334, 0.06898816674947739, 0.06966989487409592, 0.01352511253207922, -0.024449005722999573, -0.01989389955997467, 0.01996249333024025, 0.006479065865278244, 0.008059551008045673, 0.036567967385053635, -0.09055033326148987, 0.06507272273302078, 0.008433863520622253, 0.0013848489616066217, -0.003631048835813999, -0.0019256504019722342, -0.027416447177529335, 0.027205727994441986, 0.008110343478620052, 0.01650388538837433, -0.012684717774391174, -0.004082908388227224, 0.005690267309546471, -0.0022628356236964464, -0.011083169840276241, 0.010023537091910839, -0.05756698548793793, 0.018030589446425438, 0.001756363664753735, -0.010210709646344185, 0.0009247525595128536, -0.026632236316800117, -0.03767881169915199, -0.021176941692829132, 0.021108051761984825, 0.03665202111005783, -0.05891125276684761, 0.006242608185857534, 0.01015913300216198, -0.004896423779428005, 0.044035930186510086, 0.007783227134495974, 0.009012638591229916, 0.02050895430147648, -0.037364259362220764, 0.057323772460222244, -0.021956320852041245, 0.0022445914801210165, 0.0022633655462414026, 0.026036754250526428, -0.0631653293967247, -0.036556001752614975, -0.0814824178814888, -0.03352920711040497, 0.022064248099923134, 0.034596025943756104, 0.003321345429867506, -0.030566522851586342, 0.018144546076655388, 0.0019324923632666469, 0.10287855565547943, 0.025513263419270515, -0.0012941688764840364, -0.007438212167471647, -0.05764837563037872, 0.022081462666392326, 0.04112861678004265, 0.057402174919843674, -0.03777052462100983, -0.0076088751666247845, -0.047704026103019714, 0.0304248183965683, -0.010413055308163166, -0.02495875582098961, -0.08373972028493881, 0.016327429562807083, -0.0315493680536747, 0.07024655491113663, -0.010070140473544598, 0.03504340350627899, 0.05015227198600769, 0.004067030735313892, 0.041767802089452744, 0.03493673726916313, 0.0262486282736063, -0.0010963005479425192, 0.08694955706596375, 0.04407254233956337, -0.010696356184780598, -0.03365880623459816, -0.03444463014602661, -0.011952759698033333, -0.01035620179027319, 0.043922021985054016, 0.006544408854097128, -0.027364924550056458, 0.039554279297590256, -0.041953667998313904, -0.02111782878637314, 0.052311550825834274, 0.0034742355346679688, 0.1241784393787384, -0.002615207340568304, -0.06415656954050064, 0.027512334287166595, 0.061054255813360214, 0.027569040656089783, 0.013029024004936218, -0.05209629237651825, -0.045950453728437424, -0.008240440860390663, -0.07182437181472778, 0.013235863298177719, 0.0282417181879282, -0.04548398405313492, 0.010708863846957684, 0.0314345508813858, -0.018514450639486313, -0.05465303361415863, -0.03488157317042351, -0.014689482748508453, -0.005584534257650375, -0.0010650248732417822, 0.05486435815691948, -0.037817128002643585, 0.08414716273546219, -0.029126258566975594, -0.02854260988533497, -0.057026635855436325, -0.01859148219227791, 0.013047050684690475, 0.0495610237121582, 0.0021564802154898643, -0.047001298516988754, 0.04812879115343094, 0.017617253586649895, -0.03636360168457031, -0.04347806051373482, 0.0005957354442216456, 0.05408162623643875, -0.07100892812013626, 0.05257340148091316, -0.03779405355453491, -0.0008579888963140547, 0.034356240183115005, 0.013990470208227634, 0.03223944827914238, -0.018930500373244286, 0.058281801640987396, 0.031012237071990967, 0.02540724165737629, 0.07086306810379028, 0.01605067029595375, 0.0025269249454140663, -0.03307246044278145, -0.04089972749352455, -0.006909458432346582, 0.052892085164785385, 0.0032525670249015093, -0.007135722320526838, -0.018780680373311043, -0.026653971523046494, -0.00784239824861288, -0.028731873258948326, -0.01284824963659048, -0.020773734897375107, 0.009820165112614632, 0.05311452969908714, -0.010015340521931648, -0.008058443665504456, 0.04378250241279602, -0.013957662507891655, -0.010854355059564114, -0.0329887755215168, 0.019272999837994576, 0.013817149214446545, 0.020308079198002815, -0.026678478345274925, 0.012730683200061321, -0.017538199201226234, -0.02655957080423832, 0.03919454663991928, -0.028741003945469856, 0.023365451022982597, -0.01831425540149212, 0.01587717793881893, -0.026518693193793297, -0.0392090305685997, -0.04386306554079056, 0.054003290832042694, 0.0632624700665474, -0.009230200201272964, -0.007116042077541351, 0.059338804334402084, 0.005176869686692953, 0.028616786003112793, -0.03804038465023041, 0.03558489307761192, 0.06501331180334091, 0.008039462380111217, -0.018474292010068893, -0.026577508077025414, -0.01826193556189537, -0.02226310968399048, 0.07194140553474426, 0.022214245051145554, 0.03282909095287323, -0.008448432199656963, 0.05936991795897484, 0.0028175986371934414, 0.012219146825373173, -0.032039713114500046, 0.03151853382587433, 0.061905309557914734, 0.06194230914115906, 0.014719570055603981, -0.004275747109204531, 0.009379136376082897, -0.05657663941383362, -0.02290840819478035, -0.034949056804180145, 0.04330058768391609, 0.0642893984913826, 0.024521097540855408, -0.03534463793039322, 0.03220117464661598, -0.023747285827994347, -0.005641566589474678, -0.055609770119190216, 0.04338708519935608, 0.04759029299020767, 0.0015739307273179293, 0.0284310020506382, 0.029761960729956627, -0.022540388628840446, -0.013241891749203205, 0.030220679938793182, -0.010309685952961445, -0.06081931293010712, -0.02622200921177864, 0.012456412427127361, 0.01060551404953003, 0.018569279462099075, 0.05578719079494476, -0.020304106175899506, 0.0056455680169165134, -0.00538884149864316, -0.011555164121091366, -0.00656386511400342, 0.078624427318573, 0.025769643485546112, 0.034286245703697205, -0.06729013472795486, 0.0014456628123298287, -0.0624544695019722, -0.005110317375510931, -0.0574125237762928, -0.011975414119660854, -0.01087929867208004, -0.004086502827703953, 0.0026448906864970922, 0.02980981208384037, 0.03129051998257637, 0.022896872833371162, -0.009619687683880329, -0.016344521194696426, 0.028061959892511368, 0.01584019884467125, -0.01612487994134426, 0.01750355027616024, 0.012384540401399136, -0.08363326638936996, 0.054552819579839706, 0.006825636141002178, -0.03328132629394531, 0.028087031096220016, -0.0182198379188776, -0.03774665296077728, -0.044188469648361206, 0.04640116170048714, -0.007042976561933756, 0.00532380398362875, -0.011142617091536522, 0.03433354198932648, -0.0012750298483297229, 0.0414559468626976, -0.014125922694802284, -0.04936409369111061, 0.013272267766296864, -0.0022303638979792595, -0.035852059721946716, -0.004266188479959965, -0.01859046332538128, -0.029250456020236015, 0.11653934419155121, -0.04471305012702942, 0.02928108163177967, -0.010765005834400654, -0.001144228270277381, -0.02456912025809288, -0.023989038541913033, -0.003286405699327588, 0.042749736458063126, 0.08690250664949417, 0.08036265522241592, -0.03823476657271385, 0.015738731250166893, 0.0004504066309891641, -0.011827844195067883, -0.00437921704724431, -0.06041434034705162, -0.1229189932346344, -0.03827083855867386, -0.024441001936793327, -0.014249080792069435, -0.046621356159448624, 0.04900388419628143, -0.021395429968833923, 0.003316617337986827, 0.012325221672654152, -0.05291358381509781, -0.043677918612957, -0.09004135429859161, -0.027638500556349754, 0.06150897592306137, -0.009730669669806957, 0.031195301562547684, 0.017807940021157265, 0.010124375112354755, 0.01743893325328827, 0.01161176711320877, 0.07569380104541779, -0.04791189357638359, -0.02681262046098709, -0.0328504741191864, -0.019470680505037308, -0.015335474163293839, 0.008610685355961323, 0.01992914453148842, 0.0158793106675148, -0.06521837413311005, 0.02276606298983097, -0.010302161797881126, -0.01735963672399521, -0.004304416477680206, 0.02370503358542919, -0.01747613213956356, -0.029607215896248817, 0.02914639189839363, 0.0016642825212329626, -0.03489365056157112, -0.001917422516271472, 0.0248983446508646, 0.005760928150266409, 0.0008241648320108652, 0.021180884912610054, 0.011773758567869663, 0.06177571043372154, 0.026429815217852592, -0.0819801390171051, 0.027149569243192673, 0.01128390058875084, 0.015271667391061783, 0.03210771828889847, -0.002888612449169159, -0.009323963895440102, 0.030268454924225807, 0.013662737794220448, -0.04874289408326149, -0.043656185269355774, -0.07052828371524811, 0.001493061543442309, -0.04286181181669235, -0.000452790962299332, 0.0000015380910554085858, -0.049761828035116196, 0.06278067082166672, -0.04299866035580635, 0.06295298039913177, 0.04412325844168663, 0.006785929668694735, 0.033711474388837814, 0.014514573849737644, -0.016648003831505775, -0.06131872907280922, 0.009025217033922672, 0.004316325299441814, 0.0604211688041687, -0.011064641177654266, -0.01161390170454979, -0.0012741204118356109, -0.040159814059734344, -0.044808823615312576, 0.051826294511556625, -0.023645732551813126, -0.051193732768297195, -0.012545171193778515, 0.03978027030825615, 0.025807438418269157, 0.0010945132235065103, -0.057896409183740616, 0.06579017639160156, -0.04418103024363518, -0.020398365333676338, 0.011880872771143913, -0.014286934398114681, -0.06523474305868149, -0.005983311682939529, 0.0735662505030632, 0.02229195274412632, -0.03418070822954178, 0.02202046848833561, -0.014757182449102402, 0.00959797389805317, 0.02352900803089142, 0.006692662835121155, -0.03219721466302872, -0.0059334211982786655, 0.025196924805641174, 0.02039468102157116, -0.07367032021284103, -0.014063666574656963, 0.006765598896890879, 0.0011613743845373392, -0.03129918873310089, -0.05523250997066498, 0.047217659652233124, 0.030393190681934357, -0.0399845615029335 ]
<p>I am reading the original paper by Bondi, van der Berg and Metzner (<a href="http://rspa.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/269/1336/21" rel="nofollow">link</a>) regarding gravitational waves in asymptotically flat axisymmetric spacetimes. In the introduction, he makes the following comment - </p> <blockquote> <p>The conservation of mass effectively prohibits purely spherically symmetric waves and similarly, conservation of momentum prohibits waves of dipole symmetry. </p> </blockquote> <p>I know that Birkhoff's theorem tells us that spherically symmetric asymptotically flat solution to GR is necessarily static, and therefore contains a timelike Killing vector, which implies conservation of mass (energy). Bondi et. al. seem to be stating the converse of this theorem, whose validity I do not immediately see. How do we show this?</p> <p>Also, what is the corresponding proof of the second statement made above?</p>
g6615
[ 0.031237509101629257, -0.01979711279273033, 0.013877383433282375, -0.00714497733861208, 0.056920867413282394, 0.01911979727447033, 0.025356004014611244, -0.053620077669620514, -0.07053400576114655, 0.022506577894091606, 0.004153742920607328, -0.03331497311592102, 0.009635702706873417, 0.04200145602226257, 0.02247348427772522, -0.05253342539072037, 0.0648723766207695, 0.0023704790510237217, -0.05923978239297867, 0.031903523951768875, 0.010369056835770607, -0.009779966436326504, 0.015371857210993767, 0.004221090115606785, 0.04151081293821335, 0.03665030375123024, 0.059383172541856766, -0.008753265254199505, -0.027178417891263962, -0.03762452304363251, 0.06949781626462936, 0.045082319527864456, 0.014430810697376728, -0.06739901006221771, -0.005042156670242548, 0.0025222678668797016, 0.014998947270214558, 0.022267894819378853, 0.04455180838704109, 0.002814817475154996, -0.005841264501214027, -0.020358093082904816, -0.03514397516846657, 0.020596353337168694, 0.0054839057847857475, 0.00645302701741457, -0.062465302646160126, -0.013984455727040768, -0.023210469633340836, -0.01816597953438759, 0.06000468134880066, 0.07668714225292206, 0.08330917358398438, -0.06440743803977966, -0.03323320299386978, -0.02690097503364086, 0.006275222636759281, -0.005192608572542667, -0.030674079433083534, 0.03719751164317131, -0.01986834779381752, 0.044860877096652985, 0.025737185031175613, 0.025807198137044907, 0.022868501022458076, -0.03653870150446892, -0.0409649983048439, -0.027628030627965927, -0.010044156573712826, 0.029642269015312195, 0.04696985334157944, 0.014396625570952892, 0.025491412729024887, -0.08163022994995117, -0.002357043558731675, 0.09273950010538101, 0.026619696989655495, 0.03397199138998985, 0.013657214120030403, -0.03611262887716293, -0.10177053511142731, 0.008943582884967327, -0.003922844305634499, 0.058850228786468506, 0.08660943061113358, -0.0328647717833519, -0.047681257128715515, -0.07845055311918259, -0.010025178082287312, 0.023361295461654663, 0.012314309366047382, -0.009562242776155472, 0.0336056724190712, 0.011236930266022682, -0.004301193170249462, 0.028825754299759865, -0.010452651418745518, 0.029396574944257736, 0.0009614977752789855, 0.009917499497532845, -0.007903466001152992, -0.0034616899210959673, 0.0076601458713412285, 0.011557785794138908, 0.07190775126218796, -0.01947297714650631, 0.002178527181968093, 0.007856881245970726, -0.02022438496351242, 0.0021003815345466137, 0.05671259015798569, -0.06090928614139557, -0.0296922717243433, 0.014235331676900387, -0.07355421036481857, -0.02801324613392353, 0.04524290934205055, -0.05455867201089859, 0.01097559928894043, 0.06680652499198914, -0.02706645429134369, 0.045392315834760666, -0.00882713869214058, 0.06809438765048981, 0.038401443511247635, -0.015037303790450096, -0.018125442788004875, -0.003979948814958334, 0.05119379982352257, 0.012928114272654057, -0.02477186918258667, -0.0021751257590949535, 0.002423371421173215, 0.018262455239892006, -0.02121550589799881, 0.008395208977162838, -0.0033052393700927496, -0.0002287898096255958, -0.022739669308066368, -0.02826336771249771, -0.08114814758300781, -0.018635470420122147, 0.04650755971670151, -0.0021953152026981115, 0.00913990754634142, 0.023924000561237335, 0.0007248620968312025, 0.0067733111791312695, 0.08453527092933655, -0.01630992256104946, -0.025389276444911957, 0.1014040857553482, -0.0028331847861409187, 0.016233135014772415, 0.008404924534261227, -0.008529636077582836, -0.032035697251558304, -0.01716017723083496, 0.02028362825512886, 0.02864350564777851, 0.06599836051464081, 0.006789727136492729, -0.047564662992954254, 0.01986006088554859, 0.0006220114883035421, 0.021706558763980865, -0.00016263945144601166, -0.10041569173336029, -0.00975874438881874, -0.02922675386071205, -0.059876326471567154, 0.022219467908143997, 0.009590787813067436, 0.10580137372016907, -0.010433193296194077, -0.014953801408410072, -0.08056481927633286, -0.04467303305864334, -0.04000379145145416, -0.03853333741426468, -0.01978919841349125, -0.06530478596687317, 0.012140889652073383, -0.0015351253096014261, 0.014548011124134064, 0.0505763441324234, -0.009160864166915417, 0.004185117781162262, -0.08261720091104507, -0.010545439086854458, -0.009126793593168259, 0.046451136469841, -0.000724641780834645, 0.09217506647109985, 0.04286634176969528, 0.055352918803691864, 0.06972856819629669, -0.025033310055732727, -0.039596907794475555, 0.06170271709561348, -0.03603597730398178, -0.013910144567489624, 0.0031011428218334913, 0.009043940342962742, 0.022091014310717583, 0.019410137087106705, 0.013379614800214767, 0.010637455619871616, 0.02944478765130043, -0.028027892112731934, -0.00012384458386804909, 0.01385254692286253, 0.020532209426164627, -0.002746803453192115, 0.027157025411725044, 0.005642320029437542, -0.04319591447710991, 0.06014930084347725, -0.03440403565764427, -0.028852250427007675, -0.02989075891673565, 0.016729554161429405, -0.0031472088303416967, 0.037055522203445435, 0.01248567271977663, -0.027413103729486465, -0.043882373720407486, -0.03462964668869972, -0.0025630949530750513, -0.05099707841873169, 0.03333975374698639, -0.0017281199106946588, 0.057171303778886795, -0.03584284707903862, 0.09648153185844421, -0.005499133840203285, 0.003463882952928543, 0.022733284160494804, 0.03941692039370537, 0.03174757957458496, 0.0073946756310760975, 0.022337760776281357, -0.030604543164372444, -0.039811111986637115, 0.03125862032175064, 0.013673988170921803, 0.04295174404978752, 0.0008266416843980551, 0.024057844653725624, 0.012243717908859253, 0.01953803189098835, -0.02026669681072235, -0.021548498421907425, -0.015625273808836937, 0.02822960540652275, -0.00568025466054678, -0.0183227751404047, 0.029185974970459938, -0.03215726464986801, 0.015118942596018314, 0.0035594068467617035, -0.02043701894581318, 0.030409617349505424, -0.026487277820706367, -0.0561075396835804, -0.008560288697481155, 0.006843199487775564, 0.019506679847836494, -0.02393982745707035, 0.00725758820772171, -0.021951919421553612, 0.06533323228359222, -0.0024889004416763783, 0.14081938564777374, -0.038845743983983994, -0.003132973099127412, 0.03770997002720833, -0.02023128606379032, -0.03491585701704025, 0.005680204834789038, -0.05073889344930649, 0.01106962189078331, -0.034488286823034286, 0.012108861468732357, 0.022988211363554, -0.011648821644484997, -0.0029476513154804707, 0.007014173083007336, 0.015124120749533176, 0.009159481152892113, -0.034874748438596725, 0.04303450882434845, 0.021422432735562325, 0.01738971844315529, -0.00884352345019579, 0.07604242861270905, -0.022610940039157867, -0.08399824798107147, 0.005151629913598299, -0.000369474058970809, 0.018625257536768913, -0.015907466411590576, -0.004752709064632654, 0.02919110469520092, 0.021240191534161568, 0.037522632628679276, -0.05295306816697121, -0.03497478738427162, -0.03175823390483856, 0.0006204982637427747, 0.05345278978347778, 0.03436112776398659, -0.013652446679770947, -0.018105434253811836, -0.02634633332490921, -0.009059927426278591, -0.034170445054769516, -0.054258011281490326, -0.015923384577035904, -0.03405078500509262, -0.05516078695654869, 0.03396822139620781, 0.00023175994283519685, 0.027978790923953056, 0.000640290614683181, -0.003491723444312811, -0.038398344069719315, 0.03538970276713371, -0.05254639312624931, -0.003954531159251928, -0.021877992898225784, -0.010572251863777637, 0.03569768741726875, -0.022320957854390144, -0.033436600118875504, -0.0833396315574646, 0.04981112852692604, 0.017778025940060616, 0.0037808858323842287, 0.057635348290205, 0.0430942066013813, -0.005956562235951424, -0.044003427028656006, -0.01652694121003151, -0.04899704456329346, 0.02677534893155098, -0.047322407364845276, -0.014568339101970196, -0.024864252656698227, 0.03729761764407158, -0.001555957947857678, 0.0211026631295681, 0.01304690446704626, -0.036963921040296555, -0.0311251413077116, 0.018616097047924995, 0.027668679133057594, 0.038648299872875214, -0.004723954014480114, -0.011028946377336979, 0.010178475640714169, -0.000659405835904181, 0.08061175793409348, -0.002591080963611603, 0.027594996616244316, -0.018774036318063736, -0.014580138958990574, -0.04431435838341713, -0.015025005675852299, -0.039888449013233185, 0.04595065861940384, -0.04941385239362717, -0.016346214339137077, 0.018031729385256767, 0.04952773079276085, -0.0603783018887043, 0.018934041261672974, 0.015026789158582687, -0.04608828201889992, -0.015886837616562843, 0.017368465662002563, -0.036573562771081924, 0.021077368408441544, 0.02062639407813549, -0.01720350608229637, 0.014416511170566082, -0.0653509646654129, 0.028159067034721375, 0.013864153996109962, -0.030733177438378334, 0.02477956935763359, -0.008833800442516804, 0.03547472506761551, -0.0389733649790287, -0.008832830004394054, -0.019398843869566917, 0.01700589433312416, -0.017147278413176537, -0.010122344829142094, 0.06171353906393051, 0.02023358829319477, 0.015856025740504265, -0.030175702646374702, -0.03442114219069481, 0.05497537553310394, 0.023236919194459915, -0.006623351946473122, -0.006031005643308163, -0.022889044135808945, -0.0018660826608538628, 0.03964647278189659, 0.022924557328224182, 0.02742127701640129, -0.04741598665714264, 0.07026226073503494, -0.0035712863318622112, -0.023652900010347366, -0.048596519976854324, 0.06097540259361267, 0.01873732917010784, -0.0021198317408561707, 0.02330414019525051, -0.05305236205458641, -0.017131594941020012, -0.013410589657723904, 0.05331927537918091, 0.07711003720760345, -0.02727149985730648, -0.048281390219926834, -0.0018613964784890413, 0.027300527319312096, -0.018921906128525734, 0.019341468811035156, 0.03842395916581154, -0.04181806370615959, 0.010090570896863937, -0.05444229766726494, 0.03128325566649437, 0.020440783351659775, 0.0005492432392202318, 0.0815383791923523, 0.008634133264422417, 0.01763448305428028, 0.0019017751328647137, 0.01850690133869648, 0.03747889772057533, 0.02644811011850834, -0.0454583615064621, 0.014353014528751373, -0.013537285849452019, -0.020651156082749367, 0.011060025542974472, 0.03906174749135971, -0.05218224599957466, -0.03410912677645683, 0.03076157346367836, -0.018755769357085228, 0.05387982353568077, 0.06557394564151764, 0.008470824919641018, -0.03867819160223007, -0.03608943149447441, 0.07521060109138489, -0.00379965896718204, 0.06477660685777664, 0.025275075808167458, 0.0027685160748660564, -0.006260235793888569, -0.040666013956069946, -0.06202317774295807, 0.002138508716598153, 0.03339738771319389, -0.018728161230683327, -0.025821730494499207, -0.07022988796234131, 0.04629213735461235, 0.006618625950068235, -0.017694734036922455, 0.03785819560289383, -0.014013184234499931, -0.05242748185992241, -0.019751334562897682, 0.05707581713795662, 0.03494827449321747, 0.054241400212049484, 0.05352691560983658, -0.02349216490983963, 0.04270582273602486, -0.0020805050153285265, -0.08743554353713989, 0.015241163782775402, -0.029925324022769928, -0.022415967658162117, 0.07199861109256744, 0.010693221352994442, 0.05701243132352829, 0.015132905915379524, -0.06745470315217972, -0.042361781001091, -0.0026584630832076073, -0.05262840911746025, -0.04716603085398674, 0.022785192355513573, -0.0196994636207819, -0.017462437972426414, 0.05672673135995865, 0.05636737123131752, 0.03431839123368263, -0.023688044399023056, 0.055367011576890945, -0.02895406074821949, -0.007463290821760893, 0.02668253518640995, 0.021441694349050522, 0.03326251730322838, -0.05576615408062935, -0.029275281354784966, 0.034907229244709015, -0.03590969368815422, 0.02603626251220703, 0.004535319283604622, 0.012416547164320946, 0.030317110940814018, -0.002478399546816945, 0.036531418561935425, 0.02729824185371399, -0.0831853598356247, -0.025764821097254753, -0.039580244570970535, 0.027667108923196793, -0.022032754495739937, -0.030288798734545708, 0.04350021108984947, -0.01652766577899456, 0.044595617800951004, -0.03208216279745102, 0.03152049332857132, 0.05628259479999542, 0.025079457089304924, 0.00012602627975866199, -0.05198859050869942, 0.008872900158166885, 0.02001367136836052, 0.021494105458259583, 0.0007494205492548645, 0.029583953320980072, -0.03500334918498993, -0.028859248384833336, 0.010934303514659405, -0.08649992197751999, -0.04591915383934975, -0.015485999174416065, -0.06566575914621353, -0.04433123767375946, 0.008265113458037376, -0.009651224128901958, -0.021371252834796906, -0.019464001059532166, -0.04551621526479721, -0.021674219518899918, -0.022263387218117714, 0.01590871438384056, -0.018311770632863045, -0.042456503957509995, 0.023589186370372772, -0.03628451004624367, -0.05673399940133095, -0.04275249317288399, 0.02905779331922531, -0.008612273260951042, -0.06957497447729111, 0.018216390162706375, -0.03682222589850426, 0.04977823793888092, 0.010347680188715458, -0.02931121736764908, 0.009137438610196114, -0.049491457641124725, -0.04261563718318939, -0.021391533315181732, -0.071823850274086, -0.050396036356687546, 0.0388542078435421, -0.09042424708604813, -0.03463995084166527, -0.014798919670283794, -0.03225446119904518, 0.020702872425317764, 0.0070524816401302814, -0.0070425281301140785, -0.03925342112779617, -0.012991644442081451, -0.032522767782211304, 0.000667352054733783, -0.01483495719730854, 0.026134122163057327, 0.012032066471874714, 0.013715512119233608, -0.08987940102815628, -0.028217565268278122, -0.009234650060534477, -0.000050795053539332, 0.03130084276199341, 0.020362474024295807, 0.02769222855567932, 0.018962299451231956, -0.00024193325953092426, 0.008834617212414742, 0.009543444029986858, -0.015800731256604195, -0.03683352470397949, 0.023145904764533043, 0.007149792741984129, -0.01687663234770298, 0.0024778253864496946, -0.0416579395532608, 0.0011259648017585278, -0.013135412707924843, 0.016271434724330902, -0.047751426696777344, 0.020762426778674126, -0.01179247535765171, 0.010796191170811653, -0.009745080024003983, 0.08438889682292938, -0.009478368796408176, -0.02488795854151249, -0.014259285293519497, 0.004779220558702946, 0.028127485886216164, -0.01589946262538433, 0.051703501492738724, -0.034825440496206284, 0.00350671517662704, 0.03837165981531143, 0.009341041557490826, 0.0118781803175807, -0.012782693840563297, 0.05884426459670067, -0.03462856635451317, -0.043530818074941635, 0.07314925640821457, 0.038691941648721695, 0.017044877633452415, -0.12212124466896057, 0.03950684890151024, 0.0564558319747448, -0.024886509403586388, -0.02281826362013817, 0.019628390669822693, 0.036688029766082764, -0.046775832772254944, -0.015143261291086674, -0.02017972618341446, -0.03801519423723221, -0.017171362414956093, -0.03308321163058281, -0.01108506042510271, 0.0521453320980072, -0.056689705699682236, 0.03454003483057022, -0.020174337550997734, 0.033234596252441406, -0.011477172374725342, -0.03173017129302025, 0.011465657502412796, 0.0030099027790129185, 0.02066224068403244, 0.06174197047948837, -0.011147900484502316, -0.019864941015839577, 0.01111646555364132, -0.006792977452278137, -0.04657179117202759, -0.004052533768117428, 0.013704334385693073, -0.027486613020300865, 0.0185310710221529, 0.014102891087532043, 0.010457216762006283, -0.004566999152302742, 0.036816783249378204, -0.056481584906578064, 0.04206803813576698, 0.011090314015746117, -0.024724207818508148, -0.046514078974723816, -0.0017599613638594747, -0.030560310930013657, 0.034811872988939285, -0.017078766599297523, 0.03668210655450821, 0.0008833226747810841, -0.015111531130969524, 0.03793306276202202, -0.041050080209970474, 0.03728662058711052, 0.0853082612156868, -0.02325415052473545, -0.0022548912093043327, -0.01656133122742176, 0.011443126015365124, -0.007478462066501379, 0.03275156766176224, 0.03722197562456131, -0.01192890852689743, 0.008411621674895287, -0.06006389483809471, 0.027826933190226555, 0.03863914683461189, 0.00014309689868241549, -0.0008173368987627327, -0.05476713180541992, -0.01812911592423916, 0.060670483857393265, 0.009038279764354229, -0.02809922769665718, -0.03102053515613079, 0.014655801467597485, -0.05037989839911461, 0.01475953683257103, -0.0023975244257599115, -0.014538517221808434, -0.07976637780666351, -0.01703815720975399, -0.0006025678012520075, 0.03239411860704422, -0.010713672265410423, 0.03136543929576874, 0.002933985088020563, -0.03463129326701164, -0.04691033065319061, -0.01720939762890339, 0.061764612793922424, 0.06797350943088531, 0.01917824149131775, 0.020144658163189888, -0.03177377209067345, 0.00806893315166235, -0.008810746483504772, 0.010965012013912201, -0.04997987672686577, 0.012114403769373894, -0.021045347675681114, -0.02801155112683773, 0.02803967334330082, -0.012682116590440273, 0.017347605898976326, -0.004950283095240593, -0.019350530579686165, 0.01653234474360943, 0.01786041632294655, -0.06280136108398438, 0.004887855611741543, 0.002906262408941984, -0.04318469762802124, 0.08417278528213501, -0.05579250678420067, 0.06971831619739532, -0.018679821863770485, -0.002089804271236062, 0.012661454267799854, -0.007531123701483011, 0.021925250068306923, -0.01772019825875759, -0.033681031316518784, 0.02447541244328022, -0.019350755959749222 ]
<p>Suppose we have a material point. If it is moving from position $X_0$ with initial velocity $V_0$ and constant acceleration $A$, then from elementary physics course I remember that its movement is described by the equation</p> <p>$$X(t) = X_0 + V_0t + At^2/2.$$</p> <p>Now, my question is, what is the equation of the movement of the material point if its acceleration is an arbitrary function of $t$: $A(t)$. Is it simply:</p> <p>$$X(t) = X_0 + V_0t + A(t)t^2/2,$$</p> <p>or is it more complicated than that? From the looks of $At^2/2$ I have a suspicion that integrals may be involved. </p>
g228
[ 0.05854259431362152, 0.008873787708580494, -0.021314270794391632, 0.03423384949564934, 0.03970173001289368, 0.0007781264139339328, 0.01260349154472351, -0.01704808697104454, -0.06813469529151917, 0.007730579935014248, -0.04339650273323059, 0.027913128957152367, 0.057830560952425, -0.01906886324286461, -0.004787621088325977, -0.059139568358659744, 0.025953521952033043, -0.006015252787619829, -0.012157159857451916, 0.021553149446845055, 0.056974753737449646, 0.036448683589696884, 0.028829989954829216, -0.0393502451479435, 0.04565475881099701, 0.0018538587028160691, 0.006397627294063568, -0.020541153848171234, -0.05942421779036522, -0.011190522462129593, 0.03905859217047691, -0.017198210582137108, 0.029021579772233963, -0.02705356478691101, -0.027490967884659767, -0.060606371611356735, 0.06201764941215515, 0.0055984691716730595, 0.04638484865427017, -0.013585712760686874, -0.02122415415942669, -0.04767899587750435, 0.001016866648569703, 0.03241648152470589, 0.05291875824332237, 0.021992458030581474, -0.03318192437291145, -0.046816978603601456, -0.06236075982451439, 0.03398176655173302, -0.05803048238158226, 0.03772592172026634, 0.0009832317009568214, -0.0033814478665590286, -0.03517702594399452, 0.026850873604416847, 0.023827221244573593, -0.04681863263249397, 0.06672674417495728, 0.04539014399051666, 0.003054398577660322, -0.008867538534104824, 0.034684836864471436, -0.05602560192346573, 0.09829329699277878, -0.04804935306310654, -0.037077371031045914, 0.00506331492215395, -0.0018606034573167562, 0.011559669859707355, 0.054744575172662735, -0.03382499888539314, -0.014059755019843578, -0.0780331939458847, -0.051053766161203384, -0.010457316413521767, 0.01559631247073412, -0.028913423418998718, -0.0018764202250167727, 0.02248121239244938, -0.06514270603656769, 0.05112466961145401, 0.061474088579416275, -0.006812938954681158, 0.005109828896820545, -0.024576429277658463, 0.0446007065474987, 0.04163091257214546, -0.06266343593597412, 0.023419784381985664, 0.006356322672218084, 0.03933553025126457, 0.011377213522791862, -0.03284651041030884, -0.019880881533026695, -0.049648988991975784, -0.045006006956100464, 0.061502695083618164, -0.012384481728076935, 0.017523450776934624, -0.02735084295272827, -0.027363473549485207, 0.04430200532078743, 0.01031425315886736, 0.06862745434045792, -0.043424684554338455, 0.04018179699778557, -0.013642317615449429, 0.006075256038457155, -0.01404075138270855, 0.0640270784497261, -0.01915123127400875, -0.007101112976670265, -0.0476234033703804, -0.04995119571685791, -0.007341527380049229, -0.025173740461468697, 0.020898234099149704, 0.02372492104768753, 0.06695070117712021, -0.0006959376041777432, 0.013992560096085072, 0.005728035233914852, 0.06494388729333878, 0.013221072033047676, -0.017526879906654358, -0.017316149547696114, -0.01751161739230156, -0.02212625741958618, -0.0019239233806729317, 0.03311704471707344, -0.01288523431867361, 0.05337189882993698, -0.029721131548285484, -0.010979789309203625, 0.02831900306046009, -0.0007807222427800298, 0.037412986159324646, 0.013529336079955101, 0.039924051612615585, -0.01502794586122036, -0.04516949877142906, -0.04387228563427925, -0.016785554587841034, -0.07290206104516983, 0.05008630454540253, 0.017853502184152603, -0.061361245810985565, 0.014855618588626385, -0.0039501492865383625, -0.006273596081882715, 0.08846314996480942, -0.02341306023299694, -0.016074521467089653, 0.0419558510184288, -0.031072011217474937, 0.03664625063538551, 0.012109044007956982, 0.02004186064004898, -0.023641102015972137, 0.062162525951862335, -0.010740455240011215, 0.03265420347452164, 0.02517949789762497, -0.0746019259095192, 0.014186255633831024, -0.014727737754583359, -0.016005156561732292, 0.004962661769241095, -0.005011840723454952, 0.01405294518917799, 0.025266334414482117, 0.0307694673538208, 0.07152200490236282, -0.03491481766104698, -0.016922859475016594, 0.04217065870761871, -0.024060754105448723, 0.015979180112481117, -0.02539878711104393, 0.00934230349957943, -0.053492944687604904, 0.020593173801898956, -0.037166863679885864, -0.043974701315164566, 0.022313272580504417, -0.02272128313779831, 0.058506280183792114, -0.058561962097883224, -0.0022506671957671642, 0.010492527857422829, -0.024920761585235596, -0.012356378138065338, 0.02954792231321335, -0.07426971942186356, 0.008408219553530216, -0.006159869953989983, 0.008906778879463673, 0.013446204364299774, -0.02883727103471756, 0.07656741887331009, 0.07664860785007477, 0.046914782375097275, -0.0016577214701101184, 0.06708283722400665, -0.019990038126707077, -0.021378744393587112, -0.005461707711219788, -0.016842857003211975, 0.05010724812746048, 0.035844676196575165, 0.01419746596366167, -0.007219066843390465, 0.08831825107336044, -0.012766650877892971, -0.059545475989580154, 0.005392255261540413, -0.021447448059916496, -0.004420071374624968, -0.02198040299117565, -0.08531137555837631, -0.026409901678562164, -0.022685062140226364, 0.08226609975099564, -0.049126505851745605, -0.010742872022092342, 0.03552542254328728, -0.04503607004880905, 0.013675428926944733, -0.0003771954798139632, -0.02440783567726612, 0.03472786024212837, 0.015051957219839096, -0.05081724002957344, 0.046270858496427536, -0.0063985539600253105, -0.06234383583068848, 0.024178029969334602, 0.04667731374502182, 0.02939547598361969, 0.0063325827941298485, 0.018091337755322456, 0.011232082732021809, -0.05752689018845558, 0.0011063688434660435, -0.08623484522104263, 0.07425860315561295, -0.015792734920978546, 0.012353789061307907, -0.00870291143655777, 0.01366997417062521, -0.04966234788298607, -0.030882790684700012, 0.010246628895401955, 0.029840311035513878, 0.00931531097739935, -0.0135441729798913, 0.011418006382882595, -0.028706228360533714, -0.012344707734882832, -0.00417699059471488, -0.004217471461743116, 0.029475945979356766, -0.004526800941675901, -0.04887210577726364, 0.032593585550785065, -0.04130358248949051, 0.0008008585427887738, 0.012794284150004387, -0.006219983100891113, 0.013576637022197247, 0.05756526067852974, -0.01739671640098095, 0.03792779892683029, 0.011417413130402565, -0.06794606894254684, 0.0175753366202116, -0.043321892619132996, 0.008766368962824345, 0.004426393657922745, -0.007308647967875004, -0.04725957661867142, -0.05149869993329048, 0.004670209717005491, 0.001301199896261096, -0.008694588206708431, 0.05207386612892151, 0.036776117980480194, -0.03182237967848778, -0.03108314611017704, -0.0009928704239428043, 0.017544995993375778, 0.02087095007300377, -0.031115960329771042, -0.005985327996313572, 0.05988512188196182, 0.0047133550979197025, -0.025418568402528763, -0.0006177655886858702, 0.06289269030094147, -0.010645195841789246, -0.03758011758327484, -0.022942401468753815, -0.0038287858478724957, 0.030942806974053383, 0.015502152033150196, -0.0009156183805316687, -0.07739918678998947, 0.02023211307823658, 0.021200889721512794, 0.01796928606927395, 0.06442244350910187, 0.009054259397089481, 0.01219787448644638, -0.010950765572488308, -0.00677536753937602, 0.008590101264417171, -0.011924752034246922, 0.03200245648622513, 0.022751260548830032, -0.02887267991900444, -0.09467700123786926, -0.02003033459186554, 0.012410485185682774, 0.0509672574698925, -0.009421817027032375, 0.0048602609895169735, 0.007872527465224266, -0.03442837670445442, -0.040438275784254074, 0.0027867525350302458, 0.0066777849569916725, -0.014380349777638912, -0.011169195175170898, -0.009184220805764198, -0.05381616950035095, -0.016938921064138412, 0.026900315657258034, 0.06499668210744858, -0.0072682262398302555, 0.020185686647892, -0.000628257286734879, -0.06817744672298431, 0.03219278156757355, 0.005300997756421566, -0.05644842982292175, 0.05287093296647072, 0.020695123821496964, 0.021526210010051727, -0.0059189521707594395, 0.059577953070402145, -0.01882989890873432, 0.0011328001273795962, -0.011339301243424416, -0.039856843650341034, 0.019656354561448097, 0.07897049933671951, 0.004881601780653, -0.03438892588019371, -0.00697682099416852, -0.023804159834980965, -0.057165034115314484, 0.0056421770714223385, 0.021473510190844536, 0.026601683348417282, -0.0523734986782074, -0.018861953169107437, 0.035201482474803925, -0.01996724307537079, -0.017690012231469154, 0.021180616691708565, -0.0651332437992096, 0.008599120192229748, -0.008199194446206093, -0.0029469402506947517, -0.022965218871831894, -0.007579871919006109, -0.002473440021276474, -0.07828628271818161, 0.06402995437383652, 0.04303815960884094, 0.016835717484354973, 0.0350373238325119, 0.04961511865258217, -0.020940160378813744, 0.022452132776379585, -0.07708120346069336, -0.017886899411678314, 0.06260852515697479, -0.05053079500794411, 0.06731598824262619, -0.024541592225432396, -0.037069957703351974, -0.025525817647576332, 0.03890132158994675, -0.03366978093981743, -0.020892709493637085, 0.006379462778568268, -0.018761107698082924, 0.014269868843257427, 0.0036463045980781317, -0.015822771936655045, -0.001430604257620871, -0.017332768067717552, -0.012170878238976002, 0.06570275872945786, 0.061097558587789536, -0.024376798421144485, 0.048677679151296616, -0.027262387797236443, 0.009663992561399937, -0.03939832001924515, -0.008411694318056107, 0.001503191888332367, 0.0006607907707802951, -0.023449581116437912, 0.008660824038088322, 0.01269627921283245, -0.04544336721301079, -0.035614315420389175, 0.01163497008383274, 0.04200730845332146, 0.05418045446276665, 0.016432851552963257, -0.025503667071461678, 0.057125914841890335, 0.07451068609952927, 0.04349319636821747, 0.0016449274262413383, -0.017281528562307358, -0.06881450116634369, 0.036922335624694824, 0.046982474625110626, 0.08221156895160675, 0.00841632392257452, 0.09256430715322495, 0.02388678677380085, 0.07364284992218018, 0.023266298696398735, 0.009682944044470787, 0.05502147972583771, 0.01666414365172386, 0.007679673843085766, 0.0055311634205281734, -0.0038070804439485073, 0.017752662301063538, -0.0015162170166149735, -0.00604666443541646, -0.008251967839896679, -0.022677818313241005, -0.006644608452916145, 0.03434700146317482, -0.020586853846907616, -0.020550377666950226, -0.021255802363157272, 0.04679049551486969, -0.02289610169827938, -0.0296055655926466, 0.030170828104019165, 0.005505020264536142, 0.002849102718755603, -0.029586996883153915, -0.014463139697909355, 0.00013728783233091235, 0.0207062978297472, -0.02901574969291687, -0.03865223005414009, 0.017524151131510735, -0.04318152740597725, 0.030698703601956367, 0.04760698974132538, -0.001147706527262926, 0.014040102250874043, 0.013422773219645023, -0.008594045415520668, 0.005441225599497557, -0.03288261219859123, 0.023563936352729797, -0.015968598425388336, -0.06756039708852768, 0.0017286252696067095, 0.0066225589253008366, 0.021948648616671562, -0.06869914382696152, -0.011576870456337929, -0.015157083980739117, -0.09500984847545624, -0.004621271509677172, 0.010370027273893356, 0.006190807092934847, 0.052988603711128235, -0.03025696612894535, -0.009487711824476719, -0.03540201112627983, -0.02960074692964554, -0.05714894086122513, -0.03621220216155052, -0.013366316445171833, 0.011041802354156971, 0.017726128920912743, -0.07403706014156342, 0.012255033478140831, -0.010734017938375473, 0.03317622095346451, 0.005733982659876347, 0.047070831060409546, 0.009809243492782116, 0.002957392716780305, -0.00010742265294538811, 0.032925333827733994, 0.11123449355363846, 0.0876716896891594, 0.01138615794479847, -0.05246511101722717, -0.05933782085776329, 0.031071625649929047, -0.03622822090983391, -0.06658615171909332, -0.05695483833551407, 0.011117961257696152, 0.04103126749396324, 0.03301691636443138, 0.00187852350063622, -0.02120121195912361, 0.07203315943479538, 0.017337920144200325, -0.05622286722064018, 0.015437759459018707, -0.02935553900897503, 0.06984995305538177, -0.009079680778086185, -0.04330551624298096, 0.046110328286886215, -0.027642395347356796, -0.009705482982099056, 0.033190108835697174, 0.026308191940188408, -0.04128727316856384, 0.04286239296197891, 0.0011224846821278334, -0.08704902976751328, 0.014267575927078724, -0.0074121770448982716, 0.052268169820308685, -0.008547656238079071, 0.05985228344798088, -0.06459558010101318, 0.03177166357636452, 0.042161278426647186, -0.10536719113588333, -0.022451801225543022, 0.01925978995859623, 0.02101907506585121, -0.049660585820674896, -0.02443533018231392, 0.01574130170047283, -0.023210205137729645, -0.00491274893283844, -0.024111781269311905, -0.04432779923081398, 0.010853687301278114, -0.03110920824110508, 0.06779123842716217, -0.027440475299954414, 0.00771247548982501, -0.0784720703959465, 0.07399170100688934, -0.0228585097938776, 0.032732971012592316, 0.0034261432010680437, -0.02059163711965084, 0.0238984115421772, -0.014041837304830551, 0.03247958421707153, -0.01489790715277195, 0.017564596608281136, -0.06378750503063202, -0.008676165714859962, -0.09006846696138382, 0.016025414690375328, -0.023069387301802635, 0.02458682470023632, -0.02857663482427597, -0.06097226217389107, -0.052160970866680145, 0.0011199829168617725, -0.050334710627794266, -0.07834910601377487, 0.06001897156238556, -0.013356322422623634, -0.015486530028283596, 0.015790002420544624, -0.047967687249183655, -0.02485165372490883, -0.015523108653724194, -0.016361266374588013, 0.020937344059348106, -0.053399547934532166, 0.01127245370298624, 0.054368313401937485, 0.05381465330719948, 0.022655528038740158, -0.013336105272173882, -0.016821857541799545, 0.028906002640724182, -0.05568770691752434, 0.0053764465264976025, 0.022961780428886414, 0.018762290477752686, -0.03517843410372734, -0.020462624728679657, 0.04010046645998955, -0.0017269502859562635, 0.024798423051834106, 0.0301809124648571, 0.008082510903477669, -0.03124348819255829, 0.029536345973610878, 0.018101003021001816, -0.07483533769845963, 0.01225398387759924, 0.0035219022538512945, -0.004326743073761463, 0.003897135378792882, 0.04060959815979004, -0.04120778664946556, -0.023399414494633675, 0.06233404576778412, 0.026581209152936935, -0.05716539919376373, -0.003296758746728301, -0.019311748445034027, -0.006759967189282179, 0.05590682104229927, -0.011229168623685837, 0.0407387837767601, -0.012032969854772091, 0.03499816358089447, -0.020007941871881485, 0.05027775466442108, -0.01912088692188263, 0.00020329969993326813, 0.01829092763364315, 0.024037117138504982, -0.07856118679046631, -0.006880452390760183, -0.041194427758455276, -0.023953190073370934, -0.0725722387433052, 0.0034565352834761143, -0.028620662167668343, -0.020679907873272896, -0.029213234782218933, 0.014156457968056202, -0.052932582795619965, 0.012481121346354485, 0.012705369852483273, 0.018417323008179665, 0.0134323975071311, 0.00718279043212533, -0.0541076734662056, -0.04249387979507446, -0.002431978937238455, -0.010474009439349174, 0.028287602588534355, 0.057860977947711945, 0.044254984706640244, -0.045922014862298965, -0.024746524170041084, -0.005754956975579262, 0.039045561105012894, 0.003589075291529298, -0.01306533720344305, 0.07182849943637848, 0.03660864010453224, 0.03941526636481285, -0.03597576171159744, -0.015389014035463333, -0.005664191674441099, -0.0006763956625945866, 0.028652753680944443, 0.03114602528512478, -0.003394711297005415, -0.0031641433015465736, -0.026028454303741455, 0.060748059302568436, -0.005555777810513973, 0.03983141481876373, -0.0206336360424757, -0.018360940739512444, -0.022750020027160645, -0.002671380527317524, 0.05313870683312416, -0.04766788333654404, 0.03998564928770065, 0.008091813884675503, -0.020746687427163124, 0.012368753552436829, -0.03067704476416111, 0.04219634458422661, 0.04089513421058655, -0.04840964078903198, -0.009066129103302956, 0.018565664067864418, -0.024924511089920998, 0.0056296298280358315, 0.034617096185684204, -0.04255272075533867, -0.013145980425179005, 0.009147979319095612, 0.010330740362405777, 0.02917889505624771, 0.05682305246591568, 0.021801941096782684, -0.03520623967051506, 0.03061032108962536, -0.01904965564608574, -0.021641116589307785, 0.04152476787567139, -0.00726598734036088, -0.030905790627002716, 0.019414514303207397, -0.018872538581490517, -0.05627254769206047, 0.033957015722990036, -0.0041604433208703995, -0.0476059690117836, -0.048764754086732864, 0.0082936342805624, -0.03367028757929802, 0.0037989788688719273, 0.005788995418697596, 0.035602882504463196, 0.04857460781931877, -0.018113376572728157, -0.004273429978638887, 0.03875185176730156, -0.04747811332345009, 0.00046352011850103736, 0.0056561012752354145, -0.04876664653420448, -0.04685754328966141, -0.03576698526740074, 0.06082432344555855, -0.016548071056604385, -0.004068493843078613, 0.008493137545883656, 0.029540225863456726, 0.048800885677337646, -0.01986944116652012, 0.0565360002219677, 0.019861873239278793, -0.022567322477698326, 0.03954239934682846, -0.011661192402243614, -0.05580228194594383, -0.015068289823830128, 0.02441217750310898, -0.033244553953409195, 0.011437874287366867, -0.03439567983150482, 0.01581816002726555, 0.0026984792202711105, 0.014250579290091991, 0.023416878655552864, -0.040961429476737976, -0.0373862124979496, 0.01681041345000267 ]
<p>The light traveling a 3 lake km/sec, but Pls tell me how can a control the speed of light, means can limit the speed like 2 lake km/sec are 1 lake km/sec </p> <p>Pls tell me equation</p>
g6616
[ -0.023947851732373238, 0.07588467001914978, 0.0010728135239332914, 0.03361589461565018, 0.030097637325525284, -0.00021793255291413516, 0.05735895037651062, -0.0008189197396859527, -0.043109603226184845, -0.02087804488837719, -0.0051181139424443245, 0.015998762100934982, 0.06382087618112564, 0.04361213371157646, -0.03277197480201721, 0.03893209993839264, 0.06217596307396889, -0.005041681230068207, 0.02412690967321396, 0.010465177707374096, -0.0006847767508588731, 0.018552478402853012, -0.027254648506641388, -0.035806696861982346, -0.00680710282176733, 0.012107819318771362, 0.01942155510187149, -0.06378119438886642, -0.02407352440059185, 0.02037012204527855, -0.012920104898512363, -0.04742938652634621, 0.0065308427438139915, -0.020556168630719185, -0.013909803703427315, -0.03435947000980377, 0.06737008690834045, -0.012098059989511967, -0.051317472010850906, 0.0647846981883049, 0.008537993766367435, -0.01895921491086483, -0.007555181626230478, 0.023362912237644196, 0.017018625512719154, -0.006372318137437105, 0.007784551475197077, -0.008754797279834747, -0.07912829518318176, -0.020917240530252457, -0.02893114648759365, 0.03188116475939751, -0.05786998197436333, -0.01648801565170288, -0.0057232617400586605, 0.02916991524398327, -0.016661882400512695, -0.06373957544565201, 0.008338753134012222, 0.02472798340022564, -0.045756030827760696, -0.0725727304816246, 0.025741027668118477, -0.005590524990111589, 0.034251656383275986, -0.020282940939068794, -0.024206161499023438, -0.03391091153025627, 0.027816584333777428, 0.05118301883339882, 0.0038685339968651533, 0.006768548861145973, -0.04900515824556351, -0.07258212566375732, -0.010448764078319073, -0.029790200293064117, 0.030431732535362244, 0.019383301958441734, 0.004152921959757805, 0.029081951826810837, 0.0048224846832454205, 0.00695571955293417, -0.048421815037727356, -0.03545704111456871, -0.07188431918621063, 0.025314193218946457, 0.01627153344452381, 0.0021760694216936827, -0.02658640407025814, -0.03750665858387947, -0.05043347552418709, -0.02515139989554882, 0.07758022844791412, 0.012577125802636147, -0.00801056157797575, -0.0025926753878593445, 0.03256109356880188, 0.015942594036459923, 0.014103086665272713, 0.007864926941692829, -0.052427444607019424, -0.0124711524695158, 0.03335883095860481, 0.009544916450977325, 0.02006247453391552, -0.03211472928524017, -0.028554009273648262, -0.0027995489072054625, 0.04731995612382889, -0.05066139996051788, 0.009144606068730354, -0.10219365358352661, -0.030731363222002983, -0.04997790977358818, -0.037064291536808014, -0.05683204531669617, 0.05898180976510048, 0.04367734491825104, -0.01928705908358097, -0.03984846919775009, 0.03954328969120979, -0.0182627085596323, -0.028347400948405266, 0.04001874476671219, 0.022776450961828232, 0.022559350356459618, -0.0002488335594534874, 0.02728274278342724, -0.012055615894496441, 0.004568547010421753, -0.01842261478304863, -0.008966232649981976, -0.022202957421541214, 0.03043980710208416, -0.06303015351295471, -0.01947910524904728, 0.0032035314943641424, 0.03916475921869278, 0.031700681895017624, -0.031768567860126495, -0.027257919311523438, -0.03028719685971737, 0.02652353048324585, -0.021676961332559586, -0.04132751375436783, 0.032853372395038605, 0.012796895578503609, 0.004169734660536051, 0.03426923602819443, -0.05310216173529625, 0.05180396884679794, 0.07144010066986084, -0.02949001081287861, 0.01491006463766098, 0.021482083946466446, -0.007480548694729805, 0.04281289130449295, 0.022619731724262238, -0.039365001022815704, -0.032875653356313705, 0.024595756083726883, 0.05998328700661659, -0.01654697209596634, 0.021930450573563576, -0.10051680356264114, 0.07958443462848663, 0.05440406873822212, 0.07685332745313644, -0.05960814282298088, -0.06363365054130554, -0.060505516827106476, -0.0002433099434711039, -0.031500887125730515, 0.016734836623072624, 0.00005945808516116813, 0.015423225238919258, -0.00008156151307048276, -0.017516551539301872, -0.03816213831305504, 0.03171535208821297, -0.09030980616807938, -0.00007331507367780432, -0.03077724762260914, -0.02390286885201931, 0.006369678303599358, 0.014424425549805164, -0.04372025653719902, -0.017422538250684738, -0.0833219364285469, 0.00045771527220495045, 0.026814637705683708, -0.005787617061287165, -0.0022921855561435223, -0.023729978129267693, -0.026707474142313004, 0.001222142018377781, 0.016007140278816223, -0.047787025570869446, 0.02192038856446743, 0.003519820747897029, 0.0033600458409637213, 0.035972170531749725, -0.013073013164103031, -0.03063540905714035, 0.05836436524987221, -0.03475317358970642, 0.026315458118915558, -0.00018819229444488883, 0.022710898891091347, 0.028699494898319244, 0.01029801182448864, 0.010467559099197388, -0.015213975682854652, 0.04468700662255287, -0.020697511732578278, 0.013888457790017128, 0.013758650049567223, 0.012026824988424778, 0.03908180817961693, -0.0363895557820797, -0.022330746054649353, 0.030969763174653053, 0.036029066890478134, -0.023342793807387352, -0.10708873718976974, -0.03083851747214794, -0.013324359431862831, -0.019236238673329353, 0.06315106153488159, 0.07302052527666092, 0.016482925042510033, -0.008144949562847614, -0.04036042094230652, 0.007285956759005785, 0.04836377128958702, 0.06303075700998306, -0.01431762520223856, 0.0536365881562233, -0.004087756387889385, 0.0034553934819996357, -0.00423518056049943, 0.03892311453819275, 0.019876452162861824, -0.004186712671071291, -0.026409124955534935, -0.008716076612472534, 0.010369769297540188, -0.030688799917697906, -0.027078600600361824, 0.05076085403561592, 0.032813265919685364, 0.019549624994397163, -0.012067622505128384, 0.011335314251482487, -0.006617691833525896, -0.069981150329113, -0.014246480539441109, 0.06629730761051178, -0.09374748170375824, 0.006250995676964521, -0.009502165019512177, 0.0147945461794734, -0.0006244305404834449, -0.06611927598714828, -0.01442879531532526, -0.04260176792740822, -0.0226485263556242, -0.011148273944854736, 0.041234567761421204, 0.04178173467516899, -0.021372836083173752, -0.002783052157610655, 0.01390292402356863, 0.024925386533141136, -0.044162567704916, -0.05651206895709038, 0.017324594780802727, 0.0021652819123119116, 0.037890102714300156, 0.0004340698360465467, -0.020819300785660744, -0.040637943893671036, -0.0085611492395401, 0.0046744500286877155, 0.055633559823036194, -0.05318080633878708, 0.09081701934337616, 0.06146401911973953, -0.025800133123993874, 0.015674682334065437, -0.0523756742477417, 0.02732764557003975, 0.022954363375902176, 0.03655300661921501, 0.013314391486346722, 0.033475253731012344, 0.0261082760989666, -0.016411760821938515, -0.007265138905495405, 0.04196614399552345, 0.06396351009607315, 0.012007523328065872, -0.019272299483418465, 0.03710231930017471, 0.00021296968043316156, 0.04392797872424126, -0.015487255528569221, 0.031108256429433823, 0.060154471546411514, -0.009137898683547974, -0.005649377126246691, -0.020351547747850418, -0.015114457346498966, -0.006830520462244749, -0.06081350892782211, 0.03411217778921127, -0.001114161335863173, -0.015831047669053078, -0.0018440077546983957, -0.011877945624291897, 0.03810500726103783, -0.02977904863655567, -0.013177602551877499, 0.02232038415968418, -0.052972212433815, 0.026652591302990913, 0.012677161023020744, -0.012968519702553749, -0.03544251248240471, 0.020097699016332626, -0.00016804455663077533, 0.04377836361527443, -0.052855610847473145, -0.02810629829764366, -0.009311129339039326, -0.008696729317307472, 0.049732644110918045, 0.060787491500377655, 0.0133181381970644, -0.016724297776818275, -0.021160053089261055, 0.003937446046620607, -0.1065850481390953, 0.04828881472349167, -0.013267450965940952, -0.0016472558490931988, -0.07090231031179428, -0.018607784062623978, -0.015241365879774094, -0.009958868846297264, 0.015672847628593445, 0.04781220480799675, -0.044055622071027756, -0.07587765157222748, 0.019051797688007355, 0.04799441248178482, -0.011853184551000595, 0.07514773309230804, 0.048656072467565536, -0.018989939242601395, -0.02321317419409752, 0.0171465165913105, -0.022075900807976723, 0.04792153462767601, -0.0174420028924942, 0.039693862199783325, -0.0016776425763964653, 0.0603131465613842, -0.06286083161830902, 0.0354088619351387, -0.01665445975959301, 0.011670171283185482, 0.01292746514081955, 0.01664910465478897, 0.009787744842469692, 0.0000881068772287108, 0.0473412349820137, 0.044044945389032364, -0.04478999972343445, 0.04438751935958862, 0.030390702188014984, 0.03234979882836342, 0.040864091366529465, -0.032916340976953506, -0.011003883555531502, 0.040708497166633606, -0.01894262433052063, -0.06824567914009094, -0.01116868294775486, -0.005536925047636032, -0.0012191056739538908, -0.07401134818792343, -0.054451704025268555, -0.04721381142735481, -0.001937192166224122, 0.03707496076822281, 0.014678355306386948, 0.005817806348204613, -0.07389316707849503, -0.022940270602703094, 0.012460767291486263, 0.04326692223548889, -0.025075457990169525, 0.016899384558200836, -0.05325908213853836, 0.015913866460323334, 0.02306198887526989, -0.003672598162665963, 0.04330875352025032, 0.0010995427146553993, -0.04317077621817589, 0.02814842388033867, -0.0031028324738144875, -0.044174667447805405, -0.0455022007226944, 0.012064121663570404, 0.018545012921094894, -0.012108281254768372, -0.0020638229325413704, 0.04743063449859619, 0.015277709811925888, -0.00633211899548769, 0.010966944508254528, 0.007813218981027603, -0.029831230640411377, 0.038066644221544266, 0.0025275626685470343, -0.032609689980745316, -0.0430515818297863, -0.03271779045462608, 0.009255161508917809, -0.013165823183953762, 0.03350769355893135, 0.02208090014755726, 0.0035250531509518623, 0.03075065091252327, 0.013221980072557926, 0.018094472587108612, -0.037859268486499786, 0.01012191642075777, 0.024324100464582443, 0.013414901681244373, 0.002750771353021264, 0.021870700642466545, -0.01920768991112709, 0.05107015743851662, -0.02155940979719162, -0.006978924851864576, 0.019408605992794037, -0.043949030339717865, -0.017614440992474556, 0.026532283052802086, -0.049937792122364044, -0.02644716389477253, -0.0006040417356416583, 0.025922860950231552, -0.05828021839261055, 0.06371040642261505, 0.033991508185863495, 0.021837996318936348, -0.016235191375017166, 0.04851921647787094, 0.0015531486133113503, -0.016013124957680702, 0.04459076747298241, -0.004005813971161842, 0.0005215227720327675, -0.020740216597914696, -0.030153613537549973, -0.021389083936810493, 0.03598642349243164, 0.019051898270845413, 0.002202301286160946, 0.058226078748703, -0.008225958794355392, -0.039591651409864426, -0.025465674698352814, 0.036690592765808105, -0.034225814044475555, 0.0021927852649241686, 0.014914278872311115, 0.00026260444428771734, -0.02012346126139164, 0.0008882136316969991, 0.026813136413693428, 0.022222258150577545, -0.03032200038433075, 0.025263076648116112, -0.011972520500421524, -0.07769936323165894, -0.0032674912363290787, 0.02776327170431614, 0.003437593812122941, 0.01743025705218315, -0.011539076454937458, -0.0014160876162350178, 0.024895519018173218, 0.03449808061122894, 0.05005225911736488, 0.007863044738769531, 0.00020966603187844157, -0.03792732208967209, -0.02980729751288891, 0.010088255628943443, -0.025843573734164238, 0.04607400670647621, 0.008806147612631321, 0.010622850619256496, -0.010798378847539425, 0.022666851058602333, 0.04442065954208374, 0.0150468023493886, 0.04603312909603119, 0.02107223868370056, 0.025051353499293327, -0.07732295989990234, -0.004883262328803539, 0.057921119034290314, 0.05854098126292229, -0.011670208536088467, 0.05578296259045601, -0.04975153133273125, 0.01979413814842701, 0.00019389925000723451, -0.027066553011536598, -0.04767831787467003, -0.08596845716238022, -0.0040845712646842, 0.04616957902908325, -0.0259576216340065, -0.03341246768832207, -0.02523866668343544, -0.02145938202738762, -0.060293473303318024, -0.009919336065649986, -0.03134584054350853, 0.10366363078355789, -0.04340067133307457, 0.014392118901014328, 0.008383109234273434, -0.006248405668884516, -0.022764921188354492, 0.015906700864434242, 0.08697887510061264, 0.07356465607881546, -0.02492971159517765, -0.007465098053216934, -0.015380318276584148, 0.0016487789107486606, -0.03614683076739311, 0.03593588247895241, -0.010712255723774433, 0.022340791299939156, 0.0020998793188482523, 0.03839559853076935, 0.00534633407369256, -0.014602101407945156, -0.00985681265592575, -0.05052337050437927, -0.015946028754115105, 0.02916192263364792, 0.010341905057430267, 0.02471163123846054, -0.026145288720726967, 0.040162939578294754, -0.08460089564323425, -0.004921737592667341, 0.02216499112546444, 0.033777445554733276, 0.040029387921094894, 0.05867341160774231, -0.02275759167969227, -0.01753472164273262, -0.02522219344973564, 0.030185014009475708, 0.023630820214748383, 0.02725958451628685, -0.05364983156323433, -0.041437458246946335, -0.0342436321079731, -0.02536601759493351, 0.0075613767839968204, -0.017115775495767593, -0.09295692294836044, -0.045430801808834076, -0.004331791307777166, -0.004705351311713457, 0.04040302708745003, 0.01671930029988289, -0.07381926476955414, -0.006697516422718763, 0.03850797563791275, -0.012338952161371708, -0.016305342316627502, 0.03051820397377014, -0.0612882524728775, -0.0223177969455719, 0.029661906883120537, 0.005215964745730162, 0.015409466810524464, -0.00510432431474328, 0.0018417882965877652, 0.039628490805625916, 0.0001931335573317483, 0.012807163409888744, 0.03200782090425491, -0.01766495406627655, -0.023078888654708862, 0.017439723014831543, 0.03586334362626076, 0.003657223889604211, -0.00915435515344143, 0.0829748660326004, 0.03892543539404869, -0.1028926745057106, 0.021794931963086128, -0.03534763678908348, -0.015365240164101124, 0.0015771174803376198, -0.01609366200864315, 0.027272500097751617, -0.04830538481473923, 0.020733626559376717, -0.015916066244244576, 0.03834627941250801, 0.08246994018554688, 0.015568899922072887, -0.013662606477737427, -0.001323947450146079, 0.019682416692376137, 0.07205604761838913, -0.013758786953985691, -0.002156879287213087, 0.04326961562037468, 0.02033866196870804, 0.029606712982058525, -0.018875667825341225, 0.037506647408008575, 0.07142385840415955, 0.034193117171525955, 0.036091022193431854, 0.04758945479989052, 0.019845884293317795, 0.04683545231819153, -0.04333861172199249, -0.017694367095828056, -0.003766752779483795, -0.07921335846185684, -0.034129008650779724, -0.022409340366721153, -0.009774724021553993, 0.0071512977592647076, -0.04929894953966141, 0.04779721796512604, 0.043399322777986526, -0.029286859557032585, 0.0039002445992082357, 0.02687941864132881, 0.02910715341567993, -0.06189718097448349, -0.044974371790885925, 0.007973995991051197, 0.025447504594922066, -0.02773476205766201, 0.014280767180025578, 0.09614640474319458, -0.03462216258049011, -0.05440238118171692, -0.02635589987039566, -0.027373451739549637, -0.010683015920221806, -0.0371757447719574, 0.025120409205555916, -0.009062668308615685, -0.04279756918549538, 0.04639328643679619, -0.003795836353674531, 0.08820106089115143, 0.021824585273861885, -0.013556702062487602, 0.03339600935578346, 0.017989637330174446, -0.03406891971826553, -0.05154770240187645, -0.01744382455945015, 0.003778725629672408, -0.015127364546060562, -0.017323287203907967, 0.05320059135556221, -0.0019912533462047577, 0.0023521475959569216, 0.038316886872053146, 0.008669476956129074, -0.036003537476062775, 0.04242270812392235, -0.0012680584331974387, -0.011625723913311958, 0.025572730228304863, 0.02073242887854576, -0.009641795419156551, -0.020340634509921074, -0.05672479793429375, 0.02939421497285366, 0.057022012770175934, -0.0196538046002388, -0.008329610340297222, -0.029805509373545647, -0.003561938414350152, -0.012239671312272549, -0.05273350328207016, -0.09873290359973907, 0.02883181720972061, -0.07458183914422989, 0.022538891062140465, 0.02286589704453945, -0.00780436722561717, 0.03559491038322449, 0.018988709896802902, -0.03141545131802559, -0.013063524849712849, -0.02333943545818329, -0.027975060045719147, -0.04417150840163231, -0.05999736115336418, -0.0036194822750985622, -0.0357748419046402, 0.059415366500616074, -0.027227073907852173, -0.021506283432245255, -0.024307435378432274, 0.008333100005984306, -0.002216978231444955, -0.06642395257949829, -0.03230450674891472, -0.06647388637065887, 0.07117842882871628, -0.0282669048756361, 0.005959309637546539, -0.0054974607191979885, 0.09695050120353699, -0.03856273368000984, 0.01386930700391531, -0.01174147892743349, 0.01938166283071041, 0.028143875300884247, -0.018043672665953636, 0.03715112805366516, 0.01764075830578804, 0.03897275775671005, -0.017729539424180984, 0.07956487685441971, 0.059363096952438354, -0.029279660433530807, 0.002867079107090831, 0.10248970985412598, -0.024756746366620064, -0.03888693451881409, -0.03828059881925583, -0.035122521221637726, 0.005279623903334141, -0.005686683114618063, -0.04193175211548805, 0.038505759090185165, 0.06599659472703934, -0.007990550249814987, -0.03637811169028282, -0.029659785330295563, -0.014767221175134182 ]
<p>Given a black hole of some size, say $10^8$ solar masses, how can the size of its sphere of influence of light be calculated?</p> <p>To clarify, ultimately I'd like to be able to calculate the apparent angle of a black hole's lensing effects, as viewed from some distance.</p> <p>(I'm no physicist, so I might be making incorrect assumptions about gravitational lensing. If this is the case, sorry!)</p>
g6617
[ -0.01054143812507391, -0.003455492202192545, 0.023651335388422012, -0.029962437227368355, -0.01377317775040865, -0.03639413043856621, 0.023269711062312126, 0.02167997695505619, 0.005832352209836245, 0.02075636386871338, 0.027408402413129807, 0.0432344526052475, 0.09395970404148102, 0.026186106726527214, 0.05784865468740463, 0.029734529554843903, 0.033895093947649, -0.050531208515167236, 0.03476359695196152, 0.00015045030158944428, 0.048416439443826675, -0.04228592291474342, -0.016170721501111984, -0.03896605595946312, -0.04482833668589592, 0.07001835852861404, 0.03630242869257927, 0.04770009219646454, -0.03755084425210953, 0.024487223476171494, -0.056589651852846146, -0.002333898562937975, 0.008436488918960094, -0.006737059447914362, -0.011582165025174618, 0.013076984323561192, 0.048879511654376984, 0.017726955935359, 0.03490371257066727, -0.025454485788941383, -0.0016880760667845607, -0.056935641914606094, 0.01307631004601717, 0.04069938510656357, -0.02088765799999237, -0.023410256952047348, 0.03817199915647507, 0.05260780453681946, 0.03209739178419113, -0.016061609610915184, 0.004919554106891155, 0.07145888358354568, 0.0636475533246994, 0.009891819208860397, -0.026617711409926414, 0.06909795850515366, -0.00803355686366558, -0.021928058937191963, 0.03804190084338188, 0.06343004107475281, -0.01964234560728073, -0.009564178064465523, -0.04764783754944801, 0.02053213305771351, 0.02536552958190441, -0.020319420844316483, -0.0901489183306694, -0.03990095108747482, -0.04837014898657799, 0.021398842334747314, -0.010634460486471653, 0.0001772350660758093, -0.003755891928449273, -0.03902224823832512, -0.06247276812791824, 0.015076062642037868, -0.025664402171969414, 0.04971479997038841, 0.0018970239907503128, 0.021379902958869934, 0.004731458146125078, -0.043990734964609146, 0.03637062385678291, -0.029387393966317177, 0.06952251493930817, 0.006309450604021549, 0.03514289855957031, -0.020892446860671043, -0.04389882832765579, 0.0012857613619416952, 0.03793926164507866, 0.009510103613138199, 0.037287637591362, 0.055044613778591156, 0.04104665294289589, 0.02384079620242119, 0.0069050355814397335, 0.01170874759554863, -0.004324923735111952, 0.037834398448467255, -0.04517378285527229, 0.053731173276901245, -0.029266543686389923, 0.01730825938284397, 0.020430099219083786, 0.003652602434158325, -0.02629898302257061, 0.029127022251486778, 0.04267048463225365, 0.006424439139664173, -0.051193878054618835, -0.12005355209112167, -0.022931639105081558, -0.02859400399029255, -0.11582955718040466, -0.07041763514280319, 0.025788163766264915, 0.019093794748187065, 0.02513308636844158, 0.06050543859601021, 0.007751579396426678, 0.0219762921333313, 0.021087348461151123, 0.03326178714632988, 0.01299580279737711, -0.04618310555815697, -0.0462757907807827, 0.020991893485188484, 0.030508358031511307, -0.02824423462152481, 0.000647478736937046, -0.04452003538608551, -0.012820283882319927, 0.01649966649711132, 0.013516911305487156, 0.09881202131509781, -0.004585748538374901, -0.041792307049036026, -0.06753190606832504, 0.01354208029806614, -0.01629934087395668, 0.022528279572725296, 0.034898415207862854, 0.008477123454213142, -0.030759768560528755, 0.01551581546664238, -0.010802848264575005, -0.054671164602041245, 0.0473383404314518, 0.022887982428073883, 0.023698126897215843, 0.0807037428021431, 0.02823667600750923, -0.002813989296555519, -0.03205634281039238, 0.03401600569486618, -0.01583161950111389, 0.010635544545948505, -0.04311331734061241, 0.022110603749752045, 0.056623149663209915, -0.04867773875594139, -0.005381604190915823, 0.04162175953388214, -0.058165788650512695, 0.028179865330457687, 0.016740301623940468, -0.03288791701197624, -0.02848186157643795, -0.06693540513515472, -0.02899581752717495, 0.02098783478140831, 0.05366604030132294, -0.0037079784087836742, -0.0062330844812095165, 0.025956381112337112, 0.02032947540283203, -0.01281506847590208, 0.02687808871269226, 0.11202576011419296, 0.003181175095960498, -0.030090613290667534, -0.033474843949079514, -0.0007089763530530035, -0.021433431655168533, -0.055201947689056396, 0.04521108418703079, 0.0045886836014688015, 0.04215874895453453, 0.047452714294195175, -0.048251859843730927, 0.02820313349366188, 0.035390324890613556, -0.013888251036405563, 0.014754879288375378, 0.0042953332886099815, 0.0634903684258461, -0.02530769631266594, 0.00730746379122138, 0.07687896490097046, -0.08663862198591232, 0.04679301381111145, 0.009707019664347172, 0.05545674264431, 0.06413185596466064, 0.010444866493344307, 0.044515833258628845, 0.009479725733399391, -0.008830291219055653, -0.005106670781970024, 0.023059718310832977, -0.0585806779563427, -0.017049606889486313, -0.003391657490283251, -0.03525620698928833, 0.10546219348907471, -0.07964561134576797, 0.017680875957012177, 0.021888457238674164, 0.0028299279510974884, -0.03947960212826729, 0.02975173108279705, 0.01301403995603323, -0.0226120688021183, -0.02381955273449421, 0.04699787497520447, -0.04556800425052643, 0.0006005641771480441, 0.03295263275504112, 0.014312315732240677, -0.09286922961473465, -0.0037766462191939354, -0.002256654901430011, 0.023626768961548805, -0.01619410328567028, 0.0001608465245226398, -0.03632953017950058, -0.011270838789641857, -0.0029790548142045736, 0.07305226475000381, 0.056093767285346985, -0.00439319247379899, -0.015801189467310905, -0.03894706070423126, -0.0004698116681538522, 0.0025546858087182045, 0.011265653185546398, 0.019298937171697617, -0.031942784786224365, 0.014305880293250084, 0.00935124047100544, 0.03720533475279808, 0.043729018419981, 0.020231638103723526, -0.004389993380755186, 0.015677301213145256, -0.03650200739502907, 0.03452764078974724, -0.07381564378738403, 0.025356682017445564, -0.041122715920209885, -0.011972388252615929, 0.03595716878771782, 0.01663777604699135, -0.02540358155965805, -0.04091596230864525, -0.0407564640045166, -0.011558561585843563, 0.0363912396132946, 0.04733670502901077, 0.0028133888263255358, 0.02649296261370182, 0.05276810750365257, -0.0024584289640188217, 0.02160634472966194, -0.019153660163283348, -0.03382924571633339, -0.008049552328884602, 0.03291088342666626, 0.010048260912299156, -0.0018534036353230476, 0.02262037992477417, -0.06997977942228317, 0.06828700751066208, 0.04477424919605255, -0.05646570771932602, 0.038063790649175644, 0.024207886308431625, -0.0005740758497267962, -0.027902301400899887, -0.016118060797452927, 0.05328487977385521, -0.007685082498937845, 0.03175913169980049, 0.01055216696113348, 0.02375832013785839, 0.03678813949227333, 0.06578535586595535, -0.026717206463217735, 0.007941847667098045, 0.011419972404837608, -0.0018696858314797282, -0.03173749893903732, -0.026541339233517647, -0.006617093924432993, 0.034951284527778625, -0.04619988054037094, -0.05137261748313904, 0.057893306016922, -0.04199604690074921, -0.025584109127521515, 0.0040385243482887745, -0.0037157563492655754, 0.03524285927414894, -0.07934049516916275, -0.024825220927596092, 0.018387505784630775, -0.0037657874636352062, -0.0664893239736557, 0.0140862837433815, 0.01800426095724106, -0.021429048851132393, -0.02484123408794403, 0.002699580043554306, 0.019125832244753838, 0.008179700933396816, 0.007093657273799181, -0.049140848219394684, -0.01244356483221054, -0.017405200749635696, 0.00945190992206335, -0.005013155750930309, -0.07179202884435654, -0.010774586349725723, -0.020261237397789955, -0.03117147833108902, -0.021994397044181824, -0.017924858257174492, 0.039932992309331894, -0.0062165642157197, 0.031890902668237686, -0.03526251018047333, -0.052123915404081345, 0.00785101018846035, -0.03116001933813095, 0.00561655405908823, -0.017034990713000298, -0.1118156835436821, -0.008274995721876621, -0.03971448540687561, 0.031050128862261772, -0.02084050513803959, 0.007696361746639013, -0.035014357417821884, 0.10353963077068329, 0.018244311213493347, -0.0011926147853955626, 0.04400515556335449, 0.03322892636060715, -0.022960733622312546, 0.0193488672375679, -0.020959416404366493, -0.017402315512299538, -0.014392780140042305, 0.014841048046946526, -0.04883768409490585, 0.0358431302011013, 0.0026909795124083757, 0.011913917027413845, -0.010758236050605774, -0.01568576693534851, 0.032873839139938354, -0.0414324514567852, -0.006797417998313904, -0.03015708364546299, 0.020618900656700134, 0.042286910116672516, 0.0435447096824646, -0.0017189551144838333, 0.015067470259964466, 0.03898419812321663, 0.04059847816824913, 0.00993994902819395, -0.02134835161268711, -0.01763211190700531, -0.034422241151332855, -0.02842748910188675, -0.046844933182001114, 0.03039906732738018, -0.04762896150350571, -0.009788969531655312, -0.0942394882440567, 0.005105928517878056, -0.0828385204076767, 0.023863110691308975, 0.004594639874994755, 0.03425384312868118, -0.02286350540816784, 0.058486130088567734, -0.02754782885313034, 0.060435108840465546, 0.022991105914115906, 0.06370101869106293, 0.01276226807385683, 0.019725868478417397, 0.02197261154651642, 0.03105221502482891, 0.012481640093028545, -0.0038134006317704916, -0.0037418778520077467, 0.030849363654851913, -0.020799841731786728, 0.0023848945274949074, -0.046671684831380844, 0.004143877886235714, 0.016661962494254112, 0.0014444231055676937, -0.027346929535269737, 0.0038834973238408566, -0.018995126709342003, -0.03633703663945198, -0.05603259429335594, -0.010789184831082821, 0.007426572032272816, -0.027025273069739342, 0.029958637431263924, 0.012036039493978024, -0.044484466314315796, 0.004514805972576141, 0.0139859514310956, 0.006121098063886166, 0.012772159650921822, -0.043253153562545776, 0.016739970073103905, -0.06595508009195328, 0.050957486033439636, 0.013522975146770477, 0.06654129177331924, -0.01847255975008011, 0.00028286047745496035, 0.023827919736504555, 0.028546670451760292, -0.018958227708935738, -0.03426198288798332, 0.02698523923754692, -0.019999299198389053, 0.011602588929235935, 0.028870467096567154, 0.021467730402946472, -0.013712766580283642, -0.04640552029013634, -0.08497787266969681, -0.01738411746919155, -0.05630554258823395, -0.03510274738073349, 0.019122431054711342, -0.054050151258707047, 0.04458106309175491, 0.05624287575483322, -0.01693134754896164, -0.02699625864624977, -0.020060479640960693, -0.010106886737048626, 0.05335727334022522, 0.0061872368678450584, -0.018608560785651207, -0.028449155390262604, -0.028335554525256157, -0.024183088913559914, 0.02175949700176716, -0.0897991955280304, 0.04206349700689316, 0.014431128278374672, -0.031176717951893806, -0.07090675085783005, -0.01832534931600094, -0.061826106160879135, -0.05335600674152374, 0.02007133699953556, -0.006928289774805307, -0.006365387234836817, 0.01023721694946289, 0.03742067888379097, 0.007927803322672844, 0.000905452820006758, 0.05242006108164787, -0.003263085149228573, 0.03850856423377991, 0.03684814274311066, 0.04773080721497536, -0.02527339942753315, -0.011394510045647621, -0.0145907923579216, -0.023074666038155556, -0.018697144463658333, 0.0005366393597796559, 0.02580489031970501, 0.01699085161089897, 0.06253524869680405, 0.052131060510873795, 0.011860599741339684, 0.013768146745860577, 0.043071307241916656, -0.005686446093022823, -0.007273436523973942, 0.012678014114499092, 0.04398117959499359, -0.022343911230564117, 0.0523468479514122, 0.057503554970026016, -0.012522331438958645, 0.04525759816169739, 0.013215212151408195, 0.06954748183488846, 0.037503212690353394, -0.060883618891239166, -0.034248583018779755, 0.02507687732577324, 0.02219473570585251, 0.04273984208703041, 0.04249858111143112, -0.07144784182310104, 0.010653862729668617, 0.007927932776510715, 0.0438380129635334, -0.009748570621013641, -0.03786368668079376, -0.0308797936886549, 0.0020152670331299305, -0.025337520986795425, -0.025333957746624947, -0.016304651275277138, -0.02481907792389393, -0.01174583937972784, 0.03324883058667183, -0.008053621277213097, -0.01921173371374607, -0.022729262709617615, 0.045600078999996185, -0.04621698707342148, -0.011255084536969662, -0.011576858349144459, 0.02745421789586544, 0.010351826436817646, 0.03365302085876465, -0.015332327224314213, 0.0158995334059, 0.02054796926677227, 0.017860276624560356, 0.029998116195201874, -0.004951042588800192, 0.05657963827252388, 0.009106295183300972, -0.0032747741788625717, 0.0067047541961073875, 0.016738951206207275, 0.0026529778260737658, -0.050831254571676254, 0.008632613345980644, -0.059124767780303955, 0.042461294680833817, -0.032040826976299286, -0.005774203222244978, -0.03171056881546974, -0.04763014614582062, -0.05390944704413414, 0.0013839357998222113, -0.024315593764185905, 0.04519902169704437, 0.029890315607190132, -0.077660471200943, 0.007372272200882435, -0.020339559763669968, -0.04951004311442375, 0.04058333858847618, 0.019387556239962578, 0.0419326052069664, 0.023120619356632233, -0.016808059066534042, -0.020460832864046097, 0.005278443451970816, 0.03196348249912262, 0.05448402836918831, -0.0665745735168457, 0.01095322985202074, 0.0028781017754226923, -0.059508439153432846, 0.04145524650812149, 0.02173493057489395, -0.0358477346599102, -0.015723489224910736, 0.006444013677537441, 0.00032247655326500535, -0.036497753113508224, -0.04615642502903938, -0.08454381674528122, -0.03967853635549545, 0.03510504961013794, 0.012241637334227562, 0.012878959067165852, 0.024676000699400902, 0.06689932197332382, -0.0031638205982744694, 0.010039268992841244, -0.011983129195868969, -0.012211778201162815, -0.07591775059700012, -0.0030785519629716873, 0.08197220414876938, -0.004012578632682562, 0.004027833230793476, 0.05069075524806976, 0.011835182085633278, 0.030209418386220932, -0.013612395152449608, -0.019439540803432465, -0.04783683642745018, -0.08237430453300476, -0.014541213400661945, -0.07533629238605499, -0.0013687440659850836, -0.04624409228563309, -0.022358078509569168, -0.01981181465089321, 0.033552221953868866, 0.051009029150009155, -0.044655706733465195, 0.01538380142301321, -0.002959431614726782, 0.04039944335818291, 0.018572930246591568, 0.0009377249516546726, 0.011854151263833046, 0.05546940490603447, 0.06275591999292374, 0.06278621405363083, -0.0643937885761261, 0.05404970049858093, -0.018918754532933235, 0.03539539873600006, -0.03761148452758789, -0.037494052201509476, -0.013732852414250374, 0.042219750583171844, -0.04005272313952446, -0.01335725374519825, -0.013827326707541943, 0.03939863294363022, -0.06436054408550262, 0.025134572759270668, 0.018442414700984955, -0.03739578276872635, -0.004481764044612646, -0.01948278583586216, -0.02813875488936901, 0.0017625748878344893, -0.059563953429460526, 0.009269475005567074, -0.018557706847786903, -0.06238492950797081, 0.004058456514030695, -0.003708898089826107, -0.013060194440186024, -0.01377293560653925, 0.010675301775336266, 0.025159111246466637, 0.016548210754990578, -0.0060121892020106316, 0.007366718724370003, 0.02160242758691311, -0.03881854563951492, -0.028310319408774376, -0.04509694501757622, 0.04086151719093323, -0.04478181153535843, -0.07651828974485397, -0.003041408024728298, 0.02859742008149624, -0.013574969954788685, 0.07125832140445709, 0.044420141726732254, 0.05377393588423729, -0.01306264940649271, 0.007787585724145174, -0.03204911947250366, -0.02868219092488289, -0.034472111612558365, 0.007324608508497477, -0.0015518481377512217, -0.008478804491460323, -0.04481809586286545, -0.016334015876054764, -0.06128744035959244, 0.0173479076474905, 0.000490702164825052, 0.03934556990861893, 0.049908414483070374, 0.026908140629529953, 0.0012328127631917596, 0.0003781735140364617, -0.05057426542043686, -0.03105488047003746, 0.005704282782971859, -0.06991855800151825, 0.04224874824285507, 0.0070978254079818726, -0.046704381704330444, -0.009211533702909946, 0.01343235932290554, -0.012244787067174911, 0.03487451747059822, -0.015883661806583405, -0.00898904912173748, 0.019708994776010513, 0.01250999141484499, -0.04156949743628502, 0.0249281395226717, 0.004843653179705143, -0.040679413825273514, -0.024093888700008392, -0.04852406308054924, 0.017733359709382057, 0.04083491861820221, -0.05515768751502037, -0.009122258052229881, -0.060691215097904205, 0.009405344724655151, 0.01799057237803936, -0.0225877333432436, -0.013128476217389107, -0.011730660684406757, -0.013441101647913456, -0.034178540110588074, -0.001943637733347714, -0.008881931193172932, 0.014230320230126381, -0.000700569071341306, -0.04356936365365982, -0.01724255457520485, 0.04475775361061096, -0.0015800298424437642, -0.030700117349624634, 0.02284136600792408, -0.0300994161516428, 0.030570700764656067, 0.032586853951215744, -0.021565845236182213, 0.030649593099951744, 0.057398442178964615, 0.005800114944577217, -0.0057374462485313416, 0.03233274072408676, 0.06230037286877632, -0.002702029189094901, 0.012906334362924099, -0.004811383318156004, -0.07078039646148682, -0.0465279147028923, -0.06590548157691956, -0.039833229035139084, -0.023446353152394295, 0.02126304619014263, 0.03508551046252251, 0.002856201957911253, 0.0501101128757, -0.0522647500038147, -0.007603331934660673, 0.008608299307525158 ]
<p>How would I figure the needed pressure differential to freeze water inside a cooler using ambient air? I am assuming that the combined gas law would apply here and that the formula P1•V1/T1=P2•V2/T2 would provide the answer. My understanding is that by lowering the pressure I could effectively lower the temp as well. By this calculation I would need to reduce the air pressure from 1 bar to 313 milibar. Does this seem right on the math side? In an open system lowering the pressure should also lower the volume and therefore keep the temperature from dropping. Is this correct as well.</p> <p>I would assume an ambient temp of 100 F. </p>
g6618
[ 0.024300366640090942, -0.0397052988409996, 0.006112232804298401, 0.06720508635044098, -0.028005165979266167, 0.06269122660160065, 0.05632159486413002, 0.03461526334285736, -0.09401577711105347, 0.026701245456933975, 0.01083712000399828, -0.00016187909932341427, -0.009563564322888851, 0.006263320334255695, -0.0030579320155084133, 0.02447943389415741, -0.01840571127831936, -0.007473621051758528, 0.005629273131489754, -0.0014509836910292506, -0.021917536854743958, -0.012768552638590336, 0.01857731305062771, -0.031156225129961967, -0.003602022770792246, -0.0271766297519207, 0.039338331669569016, 0.02173917554318905, -0.09678877145051956, 0.0002527498872950673, 0.015459295362234116, 0.06437496840953827, -0.0354556068778038, -0.0008384421817027032, -0.008879183791577816, -0.02882014960050583, 0.06299727410078049, 0.06139162555336952, -0.07057549804449081, -0.05000653117895126, 0.009157058782875538, 0.03259396553039551, 0.02509332448244095, -0.012056620791554451, 0.0005268402164801955, -0.027429644018411636, -0.01736985333263874, -0.058413952589035034, -0.08791647106409073, -0.006257022265344858, 0.040770404040813446, 0.008187898434698582, -0.03131192922592163, -0.030054189264774323, -0.026711732149124146, -0.023682937026023865, -0.0225352942943573, -0.028060464188456535, 0.023750513792037964, 0.015200696885585785, 0.003951666411012411, 0.00027430380578152835, 0.006865457631647587, 0.001918550580739975, 0.028178930282592773, 0.010809794999659061, -0.0113042201846838, -0.05690303072333336, 0.04484252631664276, 0.01938694529235363, 0.014686571434140205, -0.05928318202495575, -0.03260425850749016, -0.06278849393129349, 0.018758228048682213, -0.01725645549595356, -0.004730908665806055, -0.05592814087867737, 0.0904126688838005, -0.010354804806411266, 0.002635137876495719, -0.03795947879552841, 0.07260194420814514, 0.0032499292865395546, -0.007979417219758034, -0.03417850658297539, -0.0828830748796463, -0.02657453715801239, -0.033173490315675735, 0.007710421923547983, -0.021268384531140327, -0.005301667843014002, 0.05915622040629387, -0.01742391102015972, 0.06538472324609756, 0.019558746367692947, 0.0033283201046288013, 0.017498688772320747, 0.004552504979074001, 0.06072714552283287, 0.0012478892458602786, -0.08756549656391144, 0.015919428318738937, -0.03752131760120392, -0.04184339568018913, 0.021812601014971733, 0.04190941900014877, -0.014290993101894855, -0.046519529074430466, 0.05674416571855545, 0.020879773423075676, -0.0736004188656807, -0.05420413240790367, 0.0010506493272259831, -0.03775500878691673, -0.026612190529704094, 0.03141037002205849, -0.004633051343262196, 0.011194977909326553, 0.04844937101006508, 0.05027032271027565, 0.048331569880247116, 0.00033907892066054046, 0.01781599037349224, 0.037016987800598145, 0.010931940749287605, -0.03431067615747452, -0.0073451632633805275, 0.027432702481746674, -0.03425264358520508, 0.030485063791275024, 0.028804684057831764, -0.03695077821612358, 0.0025859966408461332, -0.045441046357154846, 0.024022547528147697, -0.005279647186398506, 0.00978690106421709, -0.03717915341258049, -0.011120217852294445, 0.0495961494743824, 0.026337986811995506, -0.014350679703056812, 0.044083092361688614, -0.040500301867723465, 0.0015631136484444141, -0.06627055257558823, 0.020251614972949028, -0.0036250038538128138, -0.007247421890497208, 0.02759074792265892, 0.03430074825882912, 0.05004841461777687, 0.03690889850258827, 0.03009103797376156, -0.06434515863656998, 0.008078290149569511, -0.04491877928376198, 0.04115558788180351, 0.02423659712076187, 0.016091452911496162, 0.011710288003087044, 0.0012667069677263498, 0.06252313405275345, -0.08337574452161789, 0.022837040945887566, -0.009199273772537708, 0.06682668626308441, 0.015258518047630787, -0.04584868252277374, -0.02280152402818203, 0.03872237727046013, -0.06516540050506592, -0.002525270450860262, 0.04415940120816231, 0.010154463350772858, 0.09586802870035172, 0.01137600652873516, -0.04182356595993042, 0.019440269097685814, 0.019185345619916916, 0.05782634764909744, 0.029973210766911507, -0.04732209071516991, 0.0029667688068002462, 0.08187349140644073, 0.0017353735165670514, -0.03862825408577919, 0.006031128577888012, 0.0001961797388503328, 0.039548616856336594, 0.0171428881585598, 0.051405735313892365, 0.02442191168665886, 0.00017618756101001054, -0.008668015711009502, 0.016172604635357857, 0.014634489081799984, -0.032249920070171356, 0.08501280099153519, -0.012927321717143059, -0.01021837629377842, 0.04478789493441582, 0.025396812707185745, 0.04889838770031929, 0.05708015710115433, -0.02378903143107891, -0.004900907166302204, 0.028780579566955566, 0.02132786251604557, -0.04948195070028305, 0.017383087426424026, 0.042803917080163956, -0.011632092297077179, 0.012988755479454994, 0.05898291990160942, 0.012465894222259521, -0.020054401829838753, -0.042556628584861755, 0.009407739154994488, 0.018436046317219734, 0.06387428939342499, -0.07118498533964157, 0.02634543552994728, -0.054119452834129333, -0.03176052123308182, -0.02045520767569542, -0.013688638806343079, -0.018226366490125656, -0.019282270222902298, 0.014545966871082783, 0.04396001249551773, -0.0309425238519907, -0.014558184891939163, -0.00004646371598937549, 0.06720298528671265, -0.02967972122132778, 0.0426698662340641, 0.074715256690979, 0.041436661034822464, -0.046250443905591965, 0.02182377502322197, -0.021393844857811928, 0.03779609501361847, -0.018279805779457092, -0.0006966544315218925, -0.03722662106156349, 0.03454189747571945, 0.01826910302042961, -0.03874024748802185, -0.011408316902816296, 0.03979168459773064, -0.0288093164563179, -0.007226600311696529, -0.045338571071624756, 0.01237295102328062, -0.07784433662891388, -0.011728961020708084, 0.048361364752054214, -0.0580521859228611, -0.009599138982594013, -0.013428538106381893, -0.014865884557366371, 0.01834867149591446, -0.03240089491009712, -0.027369271963834763, -0.03160959109663963, 0.011868133209645748, 0.12314892560243607, 0.04154020547866821, 0.01984715461730957, 0.005244184751063585, -0.06169579178094864, -0.03553851321339607, -0.012277834117412567, -0.03223623335361481, 0.012889273464679718, 0.005777844227850437, 0.012745852582156658, 0.024043038487434387, 0.0005033315974287689, -0.036310914903879166, -0.0606074221432209, 0.0031761000864207745, 0.054383784532547, -0.019994394853711128, 0.027411429211497307, 0.053820930421352386, -0.00616066250950098, -0.017224237322807312, 0.04985697567462921, 0.030893784016370773, 0.01300401147454977, 0.03657171502709389, 0.02815413847565651, 0.04279518127441406, -0.02419411391019821, 0.036502592265605927, 0.039074286818504333, 0.010798769071698189, -0.009700260125100613, -0.04856133088469505, 0.0023320673499256372, -0.0011628216598182917, 0.008651256561279297, 0.03238135948777199, -0.03711104393005371, -0.010271512903273106, -0.028437407687306404, 0.017851170152425766, -0.05570818856358528, 0.01639493554830551, -0.005043804179877043, -0.037525951862335205, -0.01849380135536194, -0.004943949170410633, -0.005553075578063726, 0.0009958158480003476, -0.031304288655519485, 0.017300110310316086, -0.019485212862491608, -0.008110953494906425, 0.011384380981326103, 0.027667995542287827, 0.0040415008552372456, 0.038359347730875015, -0.04255923256278038, 0.017200954258441925, 0.0016126390546560287, -0.01452180277556181, -0.020296508446335793, 0.004507148638367653, -0.014752891846001148, 0.004946691449731588, -0.06395817548036575, -0.015222098678350449, 0.047885049134492874, -0.01388438418507576, 0.00020540098194032907, -0.021902458742260933, -0.002826703479513526, -0.053915154188871384, 0.002066582441329956, -0.02283940650522709, -0.01528043020516634, -0.0041391728445887566, 0.009982495568692684, 0.02232644148170948, -0.03121897764503956, 0.028432026505470276, 0.04722260311245918, -0.015954796224832535, 0.01917322538793087, 0.004133674316108227, -0.02526002563536167, -0.001539571792818606, 0.026495104655623436, 0.016347713768482208, -0.028553884476423264, 0.01223746407777071, 0.04855366423726082, -0.031165704131126404, -0.011225511319935322, 0.07495343685150146, -0.014563332311809063, -0.015000088140368462, 0.0005954108783043921, -0.01962146908044815, -0.05602462589740753, -0.056525349617004395, 0.019802333787083626, 0.02323201298713684, -0.024297349154949188, -0.028058182448148727, 0.042214520275592804, -0.04035290330648422, 0.00032448358251713216, 0.008784517645835876, -0.02847965992987156, 0.049465615302324295, 0.052898138761520386, -0.013312295079231262, -0.01633278653025627, 0.003072436200454831, 0.02179454080760479, 0.004812705796211958, 0.00570467347279191, 0.0255529023706913, 0.039444539695978165, -0.013418142683804035, -0.04597146064043045, 0.009848203510046005, 0.007992145605385303, 0.05767201632261276, 0.01733366958796978, -0.009829355403780937, -0.012222441844642162, 0.07266691327095032, -0.07193691283464432, -0.008922156877815723, -0.013091783039271832, 0.001787777291610837, 0.07220540940761566, -0.039415061473846436, -0.021704165264964104, -0.06106812134385109, 0.014648469164967537, -0.025468727573752403, 0.04603693261742592, -0.011272680014371872, 0.06466741114854813, 0.009162901900708675, -0.03252153843641281, 0.01510675810277462, 0.009088574908673763, -0.02601337432861328, 0.0231039859354496, -0.00867537036538124, 0.03743628412485123, 0.03506817668676376, -0.005816998891532421, -0.036246638745069504, -0.07211290299892426, -0.03265073150396347, -0.04621144384145737, 0.05362223461270332, 0.002170473337173462, -0.012738915160298347, -0.0017082234844565392, -0.022184595465660095, 0.004925466142594814, 0.02247411012649536, -0.06666649132966995, 0.00040562328649684787, 0.06171010062098503, 0.052820462733507156, 0.004217685200273991, -0.030841505154967308, 0.05763174593448639, 0.0009512444958090782, -0.01646050438284874, 0.003979520872235298, -0.030651159584522247, 0.06393328309059143, -0.02676681987941265, 0.05905614793300629, -0.0014212368987500668, -0.005428442731499672, 0.05150417611002922, -0.030829140916466713, -0.01322184968739748, 0.023156573995947838, -0.04278682917356491, 0.02068076841533184, -0.004907870665192604, 0.08088375627994537, -0.029072975739836693, 0.05434940382838249, -0.03801853209733963, 0.01665319874882698, 0.01660062000155449, -0.029540162533521652, -0.005812550894916058, -0.0032771932892501354, 0.027769038453698158, -0.01616925746202469, 0.006450190674513578, 0.01827101781964302, -0.008050214499235153, 0.019349638372659683, 0.002898178994655609, 0.036030132323503494, -0.02439556084573269, 0.055285170674324036, -0.02023569494485855, 0.0637935996055603, 0.015856925398111343, -0.03313629701733589, 0.04317422956228256, -0.016760362312197685, -0.009035547263920307, 0.04637826234102249, 0.0066799563355743885, 0.032515645027160645, -0.011335461400449276, -0.04285635054111481, -0.054148364812135696, 0.0013140158262103796, 0.000963305588811636, 0.01314593106508255, -0.01217662449926138, 0.07257518172264099, 0.044326990842819214, -0.00522370170801878, -0.04760083183646202, -0.04058538004755974, -0.0194398146122694, -0.06836201250553131, 0.008608492091298103, -0.015263205394148827, -0.08589902520179749, -0.030062835663557053, 0.01554960198700428, -0.04029237851500511, 0.02181803062558174, -0.00003112612466793507, -0.004577459301799536, 0.0035355007275938988, 0.0037357285618782043, 0.04252452030777931, 0.03201332315802574, 0.02075156755745411, 0.02084748074412346, 0.048350073397159576, 0.07803279161453247, -0.048831500113010406, -0.05653534457087517, -0.01322984043508768, -0.023444004356861115, -0.03235482797026634, 0.05762650817632675, -0.012760994024574757, 0.027670040726661682, -0.0031900755129754543, -0.1150372326374054, -0.018070749938488007, -0.07417333871126175, 0.04053936526179314, -0.024685421958565712, -0.062267906963825226, -0.034562841057777405, -0.011240976862609386, 0.011837201192975044, -0.0223526731133461, 0.009210314601659775, -0.010954029858112335, -0.015452373772859573, 0.027081409469246864, 0.06388898193836212, -0.001985041191801429, 0.020651323720812798, 0.04244621843099594, -0.025577852502465248, 0.018396316096186638, 0.04268237203359604, -0.025131411850452423, -0.035385169088840485, -0.022493820637464523, 0.049144551157951355, -0.018898623064160347, -0.011941352859139442, 0.0013259591069072485, -0.04012693464756012, -0.05283786728978157, 0.03089572675526142, -0.0173996239900589, 0.029616588726639748, -0.008460690267384052, 0.01297762431204319, 0.03284540772438049, 0.013492844067513943, -0.02187546156346798, -0.014777157455682755, 0.01849060133099556, 0.03220633417367935, -0.03630036488175392, -0.042295653373003006, 0.05245354771614075, 0.02120257169008255, 0.012697231955826283, 0.057767271995544434, -0.03209982439875603, 0.004044042434543371, -0.04144594818353653, 0.01219449657946825, 0.04804578796029091, -0.00047117911162786186, 0.03854912891983986, 0.02166702225804329, 0.010266171768307686, 0.04810190945863724, 0.003941676113754511, -0.029600266367197037, -0.043231647461652756, 0.009194614365696907, 0.011866495944559574, -0.060241684317588806, -0.021256159991025925, -0.025076501071453094, -0.025074902921915054, 0.0650775209069252, -0.023485321551561356, -0.044137436896562576, -0.024866944178938866, 0.02575324848294258, -0.020187437534332275, 0.05021519586443901, 0.04536987841129303, 0.0022310949862003326, -0.03008151240646839, -0.012523489072918892, 0.028298893943428993, -0.011611171066761017, -0.0678081139922142, -0.016886897385120392, 0.03874978795647621, -0.024088332429528236, 0.05588275566697121, 0.013021550141274929, 0.04514429345726967, -0.03493725508451462, 0.012225315906107426, 0.1134348213672638, -0.053238533437252045, 0.04098544642329216, -0.020300112664699554, -0.019503802061080933, 0.03409087285399437, -0.02373724989593029, 0.00613999180495739, -0.009684146381914616, -0.02743856981396675, 0.01808198355138302, -0.017948919907212257, 0.04427630081772804, -0.01908169873058796, -0.04561062529683113, 0.01490973774343729, 0.03908542916178703, -0.004148548003286123, 0.006439205724745989, -0.02042401023209095, -0.02133428305387497, -0.04155931621789932, 0.00003124481736449525, 0.02534063160419464, 0.0012205408420413733, 0.04398204758763313, 0.009276442229747772, 0.01589670218527317, 0.021464355289936066, -0.0161861814558506, -0.004126086365431547, 0.07001692801713943, -0.012300722301006317, 0.010224025696516037, -0.0033432303462177515, -0.06220996379852295, -0.031485415995121, -0.0018464147578924894, -0.025627896189689636, -0.12200367450714111, -0.047874338924884796, 0.05130714923143387, -0.04275886341929436, 0.05165163800120354, -0.0022325576283037663, -0.05110698193311691, 0.0013232241617515683, -0.001976510975509882, 0.019281573593616486, -0.02549075335264206, 0.026505419984459877, 0.05720088630914688, 0.02735152654349804, 0.06032634526491165, 0.012582923285663128, -0.02884114347398281, 0.056092169135808945, -0.08114464581012726, -0.054290659725666046, -0.013916725292801857, -0.03875307738780975, -0.004326511174440384, 0.026271849870681763, 0.03728446736931801, 0.011556674726307392, -0.02874385006725788, 0.002765259938314557, -0.014683681540191174, -0.011559510603547096, -0.0017788432305678725, -0.07604048401117325, -0.05050713196396828, 0.004247840028256178, 0.05602720379829407, -0.009655565954744816, -0.004156356677412987, 0.013769056648015976, -0.03547796607017517, -0.036588773131370544, -0.009988994337618351, -0.0002665086940396577, -0.004099773708730936, -0.04675739258527756, 0.02861592546105385, 0.057260069996118546, 0.00028331473004072905, -0.029418256133794785, -0.04831987991929054, 0.07359551638364792, -0.02768034301698208, 0.014314219355583191, 0.04072323068976402, -0.019019903615117073, -0.01442768145352602, 0.0045390380546450615, 0.021384980529546738, 0.05435590445995331, 0.007137272506952286, 0.008294395171105862, 0.01855078712105751, 0.004563296213746071, -0.05991891771554947, 0.05052805319428444, -0.039025016129016876, -0.05963846296072006, -0.03637993708252907, -0.007631294429302216, -0.005643489770591259, -0.024292871356010437, -0.0008388521964661777, 0.03034183941781521, -0.048624325543642044, -0.0005629821680486202, -0.006023538298904896, 0.004702696576714516, 0.008809092454612255, -0.03148898109793663, -0.08042050153017044, -0.05495753139257431, 0.06388115882873535, -0.020020194351673126, 0.0054332842119038105, 0.004026493057608604, -0.016147561371326447, -0.0037577501498162746, -0.016940996050834656, 0.027596116065979004, 0.05687931180000305, 0.023443739861249924, 0.06134076416492462, -0.020884402096271515, -0.08953934162855148, 0.047036878764629364, -0.06478946655988693, -0.03944620490074158, 0.027996573597192764, 0.05014295130968094, -0.012355289421975613, -0.0330628976225853, -0.060907911509275436, -0.06084360182285309, -0.011038396507501602, 0.036649685353040695, -0.05829223245382309, -0.027756521478295326, 0.04516449198126793, -0.07826119661331177, -0.038521431386470795, -0.019994892179965973, 0.0274452343583107, 0.022273844107985497, 0.049220241606235504, 0.015037189237773418, 0.003582300152629614, -0.05398271977901459, -0.054073743522167206 ]
<p>I have measured the total activity from a radioactive sample during an experiment by counting the number of decays happening in 3 seconds intervals. I got data as:</p> <p>Time bin: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... <br> Count number: 307 294 257 246 250 216 186 169 ...</p> <p>Now I want to curve fit an exponential $ae^{bt}$ to the data to determine $b$ as the decay constant. But since I have measured during intervals of 3 seconds, how should I convert/scale this data to get a proper estimate of the decay constant that has units s$^{-1}$?</p>
g6619
[ 0.024356111884117126, -0.025211531668901443, 0.004960579331964254, -0.039468489587306976, 0.053775086998939514, 0.03241823986172676, 0.022666359320282936, 0.05027302727103233, -0.01449769176542759, 0.04557497426867485, -0.006968919187784195, 0.057757847011089325, 0.012796344235539436, 0.001647113123908639, 0.024789603427052498, 0.0049638161435723305, 0.06811407208442688, -0.06639798730611801, 0.016015952453017235, -0.0062109180726110935, 0.04759499430656433, -0.03503825142979622, -0.026615368202328682, -0.0335225872695446, 0.03173236921429634, -0.06058010831475258, 0.05111986771225929, 0.07345782965421677, -0.021846067160367966, -0.018087880685925484, -0.019674213603138924, 0.025227798148989677, 0.03533797711133957, 0.04704004153609276, 0.03422142565250397, -0.009321533143520355, -0.043099261820316315, 0.05070352554321289, 0.0466543547809124, 0.021560095250606537, 0.01054008211940527, -0.033398352563381195, 0.006352230440825224, 0.09125860780477524, 0.014275970868766308, -0.012389065697789192, -0.023930111899971962, -0.012882714159786701, 0.04803881421685219, 0.015596693381667137, -0.013917301781475544, 0.024225324392318726, -0.012469151988625526, 0.014364754781126976, -0.04095437377691269, 0.06340238451957703, -0.014094281010329723, -0.004471426829695702, -0.009365636855363846, 0.023951539769768715, 0.03963916003704071, -0.07538080215454102, -0.007931189611554146, -0.02916850335896015, 0.06589436531066895, 0.07757139205932617, 0.026854857802391052, -0.014158422127366066, 0.00921300332993269, -0.012558240443468094, -0.03087891824543476, 0.010056795552372932, 0.022800862789154053, -0.011665414087474346, -0.06459077447652817, -0.008443296886980534, 0.008159562945365906, -0.04283978417515755, -0.005182553548365831, 0.04974818229675293, -0.07110533118247986, 0.012053452432155609, 0.05319204926490784, 0.01781501993536949, -0.005383663345128298, 0.002550408011302352, -0.046506792306900024, -0.02880222350358963, -0.012196202762424946, -0.033383551985025406, -0.008279809728264809, -0.03496333584189415, 0.04335170239210129, 0.0048074256628751755, 0.008927456103265285, -0.06938067078590393, -0.04048038646578789, 0.07144208997488022, 0.008789021521806717, 0.06267005205154419, 0.0021573808044195175, -0.009751093573868275, -0.026011371985077858, -0.010960318148136139, -0.06708420068025589, -0.0608006976544857, -0.007307914085686207, -0.02119467966258526, 0.03176329657435417, 0.002490568207576871, 0.005815189331769943, -0.04130604490637779, 0.009870666079223156, -0.05606693774461746, -0.0033589631784707308, -0.0014400563668459654, -0.006639425177127123, -0.05550289899110794, -0.03157370164990425, -0.012425795197486877, 0.021280309185385704, -0.09331795573234558, 0.02180624194443226, 0.025181543081998825, -0.030544361099600792, -0.014071960933506489, -0.021386481821537018, 0.07529135793447495, -0.023212825879454613, 0.00630771042779088, -0.0015133346896618605, 0.004066885448992252, -0.009715757332742214, 0.037571508437395096, 0.022037100046873093, 0.05626567453145981, 0.0052427505142986774, -0.0032939082011580467, -0.04268413037061691, 0.032641805708408356, -0.021091409027576447, -0.01460762694478035, 0.049039196223020554, -0.004107223823666573, -0.05463752895593643, 0.06533174216747284, -0.029716458171606064, -0.020556079223752022, 0.016002051532268524, 0.02134218066930771, -0.01711530052125454, 0.03816722333431244, -0.009528616443276405, -0.0020793969742953777, -0.051959630101919174, -0.046197257936000824, 0.03288678452372551, -0.0033318966161459684, -0.059289999306201935, -0.009658406488597393, 0.04778007045388222, -0.021829314529895782, -0.0459183044731617, 0.01949913240969181, -0.005351061467081308, 0.0042678420431911945, 0.002589689800515771, -0.05498725548386574, -0.019059808924794197, -0.016561323776841164, -0.04262521117925644, 0.010112377814948559, -0.015464148484170437, -0.022144697606563568, -0.031793706119060516, 0.06929337978363037, 0.04127530753612518, 0.0453505702316761, 0.05168690159916878, -0.0023270363453775644, 0.06429640203714371, 0.053948789834976196, 0.06646230816841125, -0.009702549315989017, 0.016863608732819557, -0.028360987082123756, 0.01135931070894003, -0.0009084664634428918, -0.006521150935441256, -0.00086433399701491, 0.014211846515536308, -0.042678263038396835, 0.0002013757621170953, -0.018792692571878433, -0.043763525784015656, 0.0017366460524499416, 0.005740567110478878, -0.09588199853897095, 0.033764876425266266, -0.02091068960726261, -0.005888475105166435, 0.008486621081829071, 0.019768748432397842, -0.028257720172405243, 0.044873353093862534, -0.009763315320014954, -0.05643788352608681, 0.013456880114972591, -0.028089206665754318, 0.00679885596036911, 0.04440084844827652, 0.019153330475091934, -0.025218287482857704, 0.0010081829968839884, -0.04983889311552048, 0.011669883504509926, -0.015244144946336746, 0.030706753954291344, 0.027089785784482956, 0.06268902868032455, -0.020370181649923325, -0.007873381488025188, 0.04036083072423935, -0.02912565879523754, -0.002963721053674817, -0.02346375584602356, 0.0017879342194646597, 0.03568887710571289, 0.02982494980096817, -0.023098472505807877, -0.07930149883031845, 0.04693792015314102, -0.05278155580163002, -0.01739894039928913, 0.011578190140426159, 0.028343331068754196, -0.019614452496170998, 0.03449444845318794, 0.01838473044335842, 0.011891132220625877, -0.009562305174767971, -0.010934321209788322, -0.033358894288539886, -0.015600265935063362, 0.02832985296845436, -0.023108193650841713, -0.04452062398195267, 0.02139473706483841, -0.012749570421874523, 0.012849445454776287, -0.020223107188940048, 0.017297623679041862, -0.0009442638256587088, -0.008889943361282349, 0.001992475241422653, -0.008199644275009632, 0.03221229463815689, 0.013041432946920395, -0.012323732487857342, -0.00971033051609993, 0.0026888574939221144, -0.03922119364142418, 0.02781587280333042, 0.028349680826067924, 0.016059210523962975, -0.1017187237739563, -0.0375305600464344, -0.056350383907556534, 0.015767613425850868, 0.0056696669198572636, 0.03543689101934433, 0.007768471725285053, -0.017982538789510727, 0.030712764710187912, 0.0026350270491093397, -0.01491275429725647, 0.05646360293030739, -0.05801848694682121, 0.01164317224174738, -0.04315844178199768, -0.0014983428409323096, -0.0026150888297706842, -0.04538826644420624, 0.04160404950380325, 0.043218281120061874, 0.0011460947571322322, -0.0013727691257372499, -0.026104938238859177, -0.0007447139360010624, 0.015106662176549435, -0.04954272136092186, -0.04407047852873802, -0.019876157864928246, 0.01701321080327034, 0.004455280490219593, 0.013496840372681618, 0.07586309313774109, -0.03039541095495224, 0.0816953256726265, 0.053429435938596725, -0.036131277680397034, -0.06422780454158783, -0.04039213806390762, -0.037608690559864044, -0.021360324695706367, -0.0012679853243753314, -0.013403639197349548, -0.00011700393952196464, -0.007432357873767614, 0.01700570434331894, -0.03414156660437584, -0.04833362251520157, 0.03309312090277672, -0.04286251589655876, -0.008176906034350395, -0.057574182748794556, 0.030484050512313843, -0.00024756373022682965, 0.010561075992882252, 0.007590363267809153, 0.0572313629090786, -0.0720122903585434, 0.02685071900486946, 0.03220098093152046, -0.02069023624062538, -0.015908537432551384, -0.005154930520802736, -0.008147581480443478, -0.08540290594100952, -0.015555809251964092, -0.01609179936349392, -0.008496575988829136, 0.018227582797408104, -0.004734122194349766, -0.0007643261342309415, -0.00908712949603796, 0.0009727313881739974, 0.019349021837115288, -0.0662311241030693, -0.022381098940968513, -0.06922604143619537, 0.03659357875585556, -0.029163431376218796, 0.031356148421764374, 0.02873878926038742, -0.022261375561356544, -0.005865498911589384, 0.016248580068349838, -0.017710058018565178, -0.006381960120052099, -0.003839417127892375, 0.015918154269456863, -0.02606869675219059, -0.018348265439271927, 0.00829825084656477, 0.03001318871974945, -0.01182754896581173, 0.022677060216665268, 0.02236318401992321, -0.06738243252038956, 0.011180231347680092, -0.06907031685113907, -0.013304058462381363, 0.0654289573431015, -0.04894779995083809, -0.03707389906048775, -0.02525237761437893, 0.10240080207586288, 0.07863716036081314, 0.008251567371189594, -0.0013121854281052947, 0.024651439860463142, 0.12056140601634979, -0.003667161101475358, 0.0033898791298270226, -0.03716893494129181, 0.018351629376411438, 0.023021843284368515, -0.03615228459239006, 0.09074584394693375, -0.007705229800194502, 0.02542874403297901, 0.008138401433825493, -0.03778686374425888, -0.020428137853741646, -0.029791058972477913, 0.014030110090970993, -0.023918163031339645, -0.006091317627578974, -0.08092479407787323, 0.017837796360254288, -0.05322746932506561, -0.006444654893130064, -0.013457111082971096, 0.006035014986991882, -0.11247983574867249, 0.052978165447711945, 0.04765157401561737, -0.005386723205447197, 0.03060697391629219, -0.020823759958148003, 0.009263564832508564, 0.008572223596274853, 0.04514463618397713, -0.012268341146409512, -0.02016201615333557, 0.020914986729621887, -0.020022055134177208, 0.023637834936380386, 0.017147235572338104, -0.04173414781689644, -0.017026452347636223, 0.03872687742114067, -0.03342586010694504, -0.032339148223400116, 0.02365446463227272, 0.0432097353041172, -0.01440043468028307, 0.028093580156564713, 0.023417159914970398, 0.0036857007071375847, 0.0029933254700154066, -0.006832996848970652, -0.044935427606105804, -0.06691767275333405, 0.08755798637866974, -0.00856525357812643, -0.0004226206801831722, 0.009114669635891914, -0.0029895431362092495, 0.003186834277585149, 0.04403284192085266, 0.02518143504858017, 0.04763346537947655, -0.034721825271844864, 0.007538695819675922, 0.02713947743177414, 0.027690451592206955, 0.022889770567417145, -0.0044663394801318645, -0.018586788326501846, -0.0002865018614102155, -0.04603048413991928, -0.01904563046991825, -0.009824293665587902, 0.046755097806453705, -0.04995490610599518, -0.0830676481127739, 0.0739985778927803, 0.061418648809194565, -0.019461901858448982, 0.03785833343863487, -0.05130137503147125, 0.019474199041724205, -0.0012434393865987659, -0.047274962067604065, 0.00872049480676651, 0.04834122583270073, 0.015214363113045692, 0.045292794704437256, -0.06666821241378784, -0.01160832867026329, -0.016559280455112457, -0.01478651538491249, 0.015584384091198444, -0.066605344414711, -0.03660407289862633, -0.03381161019206047, 0.01295184064656496, -0.013589928857982159, 0.011692319996654987, -0.02598894014954567, 0.05372356250882149, -0.032068926841020584, 0.005612436216324568, 0.01609491929411888, -0.06409069895744324, 0.04206749424338341, -0.005000659730285406, 0.01745796948671341, 0.028931595385074615, 0.009252777323126793, -0.020863302052021027, 0.018876761198043823, -0.041681863367557526, 0.020415661856532097, -0.041155919432640076, -0.030862772837281227, 0.028102751821279526, 0.01617867313325405, -0.019998544827103615, 0.054945867508649826, 0.1097743958234787, -0.010850601829588413, -0.0009724542615003884, -0.05471325293183327, 0.040932923555374146, 0.019732201471924782, -0.00669116759672761, 0.03295816853642464, -0.02918875217437744, 0.029737427830696106, -0.0322112962603569, 0.037778839468955994, -0.017892107367515564, 0.06291335821151733, -0.009679730050265789, 0.06736470758914948, -0.011034305207431316, 0.06379248946905136, -0.0015676585026085377, -0.02406066097319126, 0.05431147664785385, 0.021145714446902275, -0.013026709668338299, 0.02942962571978569, 0.049660973250865936, 0.0607435517013073, -0.021849878132343292, -0.05629158765077591, 0.030053921043872833, 0.01970827765762806, 0.03368566185235977, -0.035503797233104706, 0.014216400682926178, -0.059414222836494446, -0.036413561552762985, 0.012875706888735294, 0.029656831175088882, -0.01970445178449154, 0.041645072400569916, -0.0282154381275177, -0.07196391373872757, -0.005882403813302517, 0.025552496314048767, 0.037124864757061005, -0.0071674552746117115, -0.004707287531346083, -0.025671206414699554, -0.005472993478178978, -0.0574125237762928, 0.021231798455119133, 0.041343387216329575, -0.029509160667657852, -0.028790419921278954, -0.005619559902697802, -0.02685423567891121, -0.03405936062335968, 0.008088545873761177, -0.010743777267634869, 0.024965830147266388, 0.005232158116996288, 0.01668156497180462, -0.06040479615330696, -0.026491429656744003, 0.040968626737594604, 0.02682419866323471, 0.05626939237117767, 0.021137787029147148, 0.009501897729933262, -0.03085886873304844, 0.01083478331565857, 0.010497009381651878, 0.04085558280348778, -0.013654997572302818, -0.08217964321374893, 0.020319746807217598, 0.03217559680342674, -0.04046391323208809, -0.006907807197421789, 0.022305777296423912, -0.06480499356985092, 0.038112491369247437, 0.013617848046123981, -0.02786412090063095, 0.045736923813819885, -0.01085297204554081, -0.028472356498241425, 0.012892315164208412, 0.006123493425548077, -0.026143904775381088, -0.0025209130253642797, -0.024971172213554382, -0.0000045706028686254285, -0.06013437733054161, 0.025341007858514786, -0.003991635050624609, 0.0012002693256363273, 0.000017423770259483717, -0.03952302783727646, -0.01572633907198906, 0.009475327096879482, -0.030512483790516853, -0.02402942255139351, -0.02397312968969345, -0.044175177812576294, -0.02592262253165245, -0.050687890499830246, 0.020509183406829834, 0.01778682880103588, -0.03267034515738487, 0.020906826481223106, 0.019206760451197624, -0.03135044127702713, 0.04063519462943077, -0.003489595139399171, 0.008253821171820164, 0.00848537590354681, 0.062179986387491226, -0.038926128298044205, 0.017069431021809578, 0.008082023821771145, 0.00699821300804615, 0.03671189770102501, 0.00042378815123811364, -0.03918454796075821, 0.06260271370410919, 0.056779369711875916, -0.06796637177467346, 0.02104514092206955, 0.019632957875728607, 0.00021261654910631478, -0.008487649261951447, -0.003655344480648637, 0.025868305936455727, 0.039984412491321564, 0.021755164489150047, 0.02847934700548649, -0.010702717117965221, -0.08063998073339462, -0.046998534351587296, 0.026682360097765923, -0.027771100401878357, 0.00897076353430748, -0.0029841663781553507, 0.0744980201125145, 0.005434299819171429, 0.060910359025001526, -0.013044878840446472, 0.05140891298651695, 0.014121376909315586, 0.0017751000123098493, 0.008691033348441124, 0.029404176399111748, -0.07318286597728729, 0.002735929563641548, 0.023112518712878227, 0.0389077328145504, 0.009654312394559383, 0.039535317569971085, 0.053722016513347626, -0.06293132156133652, 0.01830204948782921, 0.0011522320564836264, 0.04201267287135124, -0.0020435303449630737, 0.021755171939730644, 0.02161102555692196, 0.0353667251765728, 0.0017866280395537615, 0.001330071478150785, -0.09843584895133972, 0.03196752816438675, -0.03762989491224289, 0.03751884400844574, 0.011026107706129551, 0.0052732182666659355, -0.04085351899266243, 0.032282281666994095, -0.12965264916419983, -0.03347614407539368, -0.04962893947958946, 0.019825292751193047, 0.029667964205145836, 0.02779778279364109, 0.031136417761445045, 0.0014193156966939569, 0.001262965495698154, -0.008590142242610455, -0.035190995782613754, -0.004567198920994997, -0.05599171295762062, 0.007249298971146345, -0.02575830928981304, -0.02677913010120392, 0.07296313345432281, -0.05222739279270172, -0.011020475067198277, 0.09344863891601562, -0.003473052056506276, -0.05659405514597893, 0.03342346101999283, 0.04148062318563461, -0.014433002099394798, 0.006771576125174761, -0.014221228659152985, -0.0032157511450350285, -0.06372253596782684, 0.0263166856020689, 0.022511783987283707, 0.05431875213980675, -0.01857774145901203, 0.04625964164733887, -0.03293817862868309, 0.012034272775053978, 0.029708387330174446, -0.0016889260150492191, -0.08149885386228561, 0.006738151889294386, -0.022346172481775284, -0.037323981523513794, 0.0030809352174401283, -0.0056976377964019775, -0.005402443930506706, 0.04533878713846207, 0.031227974221110344, -0.06062117964029312, -0.040444642305374146, 0.03211100772023201, -0.020365770906209946, -0.07499775290489197, -0.026593688875436783, -0.010549585334956646, -0.004260065965354443, 0.02562383934855461, -0.04550107941031456, -0.05508320778608322, 0.0055562411434948444, 0.034798648208379745, 0.015174412168562412, -0.03018243983387947, -0.02043571136891842, -0.03224055469036102, 0.024621479213237762, -0.0030330787412822247, 0.024481741711497307, 0.04656215012073517, 0.03225548192858696, -0.08969190716743469, 0.035120271146297455, 0.014559797011315823, 0.040878280997276306, 0.02400696650147438, 0.07216914743185043, 0.014958246611058712, -0.05248855799436569, -0.01907159760594368, 0.043372828513383865, 0.05082223564386368, -0.030346037819981575, -0.019561903551220894, -0.003896490903571248, 0.03702038899064064, 0.050206512212753296, -0.00795063842087984, 0.008364237844944, 0.019912585616111755, 0.007694924715906382, 0.023828336969017982, 0.00665742252022028, -0.0896347388625145, 0.0010444681392982602, -0.0404353104531765, 0.06001795455813408, -0.028584839776158333, -0.030556030571460724, 0.0286155566573143, 0.017385335639119148 ]
<p>I'm trying to calculate the initial velocity $v_0$ and angle $\theta$ for a given destination $(x, y)$ with a launch height of $y_0$. Obviously there will be a set of pairs of velocity and angle that will pass through the destination point. This set is given by $$ \left\{(v_0,\theta) \middle|y = - \frac{g}{2 v_0^2 \cdot \cos^2(\theta)} \cdot x^2 + \tan(\theta) \cdot x +y_0 \right\} \ .$$</p> <p>I have already looked at this questions:</p> <p><a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/27992/solving-for-initial-velocity-required-to-launch-a-projectile-to-a-given-destinat">Solving for initial velocity required to launch a projectile to a given destination at a different height</a></p> <p><a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/56265/how-to-get-the-angle-needed-for-a-projectile-to-pass-through-a-given-point-for-t">How to get the angle needed for a projectile to pass through a given point for trajectory plotting</a></p> <p>So for example I could rewrite the set to $$\left\{ (v_0,\theta) \middle| v_0 = \frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}\sqrt{\frac{\frac{1}{2} g x^2}{x \tan(\theta)+y_0}} \right\}\ .$$</p> <p>Is there an easy way to compute this set for one given destination without iterating over all possible velocities or angles?</p>
g6620
[ -0.02116360329091549, 0.00827487837523222, -0.022109905257821083, 0.02299271710216999, 0.018664248287677765, -0.031545817852020264, 0.03359300643205643, -0.011329835280776024, -0.07263092696666718, 0.014436503872275352, -0.01982305943965912, 0.0762348622083664, 0.06241230294108391, -0.0180913545191288, 0.006024669390171766, -0.009330406785011292, 0.040321942418813705, 0.00396285904571414, 0.05683472007513046, 0.04279344901442528, 0.03189149871468544, -0.059557121247053146, 0.003964546136558056, -0.02129237912595272, 0.013382203876972198, -0.03800201788544655, -0.012535623274743557, 0.013560083694756031, -0.09101595729589462, 0.06366444379091263, 0.004258205648511648, -0.010723238810896873, 0.04272521659731865, -0.040812842547893524, -0.02045067586004734, -0.01635267771780491, -0.016382351517677307, 0.002431007567793131, -0.04875792935490608, -0.0784745067358017, -0.002621161285787821, -0.06909341365098953, 0.041170891374349594, 0.008594794198870659, 0.001978522166609764, -0.0084706861525774, -0.01606266386806965, -0.017815761268138885, -0.05745471268892288, -0.02244322933256626, -0.012427311390638351, 0.02774043381214142, -0.011005764827132225, -0.06950990110635757, -0.06474590301513672, 0.04943028464913368, 0.004409248009324074, -0.06442848592996597, 0.02678336203098297, 0.022448953241109848, 0.008293354883790016, -0.018507909029722214, -0.016469435766339302, -0.00563026824966073, 0.024153124541044235, -0.011400184594094753, -0.004230073653161526, -0.011258970014750957, -0.006876675877720118, -0.022909387946128845, -0.010486100800335407, -0.025710873305797577, -0.0083943922072649, -0.04371266812086105, -0.0927928164601326, 0.019789930433034897, 0.025208977982401848, -0.017745675519108772, -0.034488122910261154, 0.007118788082152605, -0.025833429768681526, -0.020957667380571365, 0.01683119311928749, -0.06922657042741776, -0.021088896319270134, -0.011569519527256489, 0.08039186149835587, 0.03064390830695629, -0.020982889458537102, -0.030251076444983482, 0.018857227638363838, 0.033616237342357635, 0.005371036473661661, 0.02669558860361576, -0.009092051535844803, 0.022234199568629265, -0.08103618025779724, 0.022611601278185844, 0.06302721053361893, 0.020874539390206337, 0.00789796095341444, 0.022616231814026833, 0.03704031929373741, -0.042379509657621384, 0.010745474137365818, -0.048487983644008636, 0.06949567794799805, 0.00039184759953059256, 0.023420993238687515, -0.03068476729094982, -0.022968478500843048, -0.08221516013145447, -0.028368888422846794, -0.04556536674499512, -0.022202687337994576, -0.03203997761011124, 0.015292094089090824, 0.055769920349121094, -0.026517240330576897, 0.02001596800982952, -0.01607164554297924, 0.016318097710609436, -0.01994885504245758, 0.029882848262786865, -0.008386937901377678, -0.001597182359546423, -0.09503734111785889, -0.05712563171982765, 0.013667547143995762, -0.0026490739546716213, -0.029134783893823624, -0.02997024543583393, 0.04552839696407318, 0.04650023579597473, -0.0036081215366721153, -0.0006471475353464484, 0.020991791039705276, -0.0031831127125769854, 0.015747196972370148, 0.016596876084804535, -0.021369080990552902, -0.010128508321940899, -0.03442603349685669, 0.0025598981883376837, -0.043672140687704086, 0.029192037880420685, -0.00565457995980978, -0.03017239272594452, 0.012932874262332916, -0.0320676751434803, 0.003416879801079631, 0.06774073094129562, -0.0028812908567488194, 0.05832400545477867, -0.008771934546530247, -0.05715155228972435, 0.024622729048132896, 0.01692657731473446, 0.017017241567373276, -0.041430141776800156, 0.04887441173195839, -0.0038906740956008434, 0.05875277519226074, 0.006047184579074383, -0.04596969857811928, 0.021496769040822983, -0.020548230037093163, -0.0023761186748743057, -0.06203238666057587, -0.048219937831163406, -0.009408287703990936, 0.01860005222260952, 0.05363909900188446, 0.032783392816782, -0.011516747996211052, -0.0054834154434502125, -0.0022717625834047794, 0.011960815638303757, -0.01718340814113617, -0.003429278964176774, 0.013551546260714531, -0.057459600269794464, 0.02634824626147747, 0.007058071903884411, 0.019567465409636497, -0.013707789592444897, 0.003756557824090123, 0.008027028292417526, 0.00004050639472552575, -0.009497502818703651, 0.050660692155361176, 0.004264888819307089, -0.02114010602235794, -0.02310159243643284, -0.021798787638545036, -0.018239403143525124, 0.056675415486097336, 0.01825377158820629, -0.004353425465524197, 0.05514294281601906, 0.010607348755002022, 0.032336290925741196, 0.030493859201669693, 0.02163410186767578, -0.04722650349140167, 0.04139043390750885, 0.035410650074481964, -0.010894794017076492, -0.013914515264332294, 0.06554678827524185, -0.018620768561959267, -0.053117360919713974, -0.011023075319826603, 0.01849043183028698, 0.00861690565943718, 0.004369008354842663, 0.02836856059730053, -0.006779915653169155, -0.013025802560150623, 0.009067488834261894, -0.027566539123654366, 0.0017687560757622123, -0.013726175762712955, -0.02290394902229309, -0.01326177641749382, 0.05488862097263336, 0.008134179748594761, -0.02485964633524418, 0.02143343724310398, -0.015486180782318115, 0.037358541041612625, 0.04508017376065254, -0.01790347509086132, -0.05205367133021355, 0.0860774889588356, -0.008513787761330605, -0.004737963899970055, -0.04229610413312912, 0.059064123779535294, 0.04056648537516594, 0.025974968448281288, -0.05382673069834709, 0.030134277418255806, -0.003790054004639387, 0.0657457560300827, -0.06055612489581108, -0.01772759109735489, 0.016863074153661728, -0.011767768301069736, -0.033730052411556244, -0.04180889204144478, 0.009836947545409203, -0.0627492368221283, 0.030419792979955673, -0.03702107444405556, -0.015184924006462097, -0.033895280212163925, 0.009041553363204002, -0.03296835348010063, -0.052344754338264465, -0.08095266669988632, -0.014445050619542599, -0.03440142795443535, -0.010068400762975216, -0.019973309710621834, 0.05537791550159454, 0.018244188278913498, -0.05247507989406586, -0.004346149042248726, -0.03681183606386185, -0.09723933786153793, -0.010081898421049118, 0.07649429142475128, 0.030067363753914833, -0.005199147388339043, -0.04027214273810387, 0.003860853146761656, 0.012504462152719498, -0.0386480949819088, 0.07679298520088196, 0.006398245692253113, -0.04880955442786217, -0.0025872287806123495, 0.0962316170334816, 0.03663673251867294, -0.03172683343291283, 0.0709947943687439, 0.08892876654863358, 0.02486904338002205, -0.04279201477766037, 0.036541081964969635, 0.033904071897268295, 0.031075984239578247, -0.00903982575982809, 0.025949232280254364, 0.022626277059316635, 0.02744177356362343, -0.007047588471323252, 0.01727334037423134, -0.037686556577682495, -0.030019044876098633, -0.006107484456151724, -0.021490223705768585, -0.03437354043126106, 0.01497973408550024, -0.01023014448583126, 0.021587751805782318, -0.026166992262005806, -0.008028380572795868, -0.0019046204397454858, 0.059117596596479416, 0.0384182333946228, -0.03252039849758148, 0.010468377731740475, -0.01166960597038269, -0.03498348221182823, 0.015638792887330055, 0.0022875620052218437, -0.015965959057211876, 0.07126501947641373, -0.013874398544430733, -0.03032575361430645, 0.033907920122146606, 0.04154285043478012, 0.009543188847601414, 0.01738891936838627, 0.002275227103382349, 0.020201845094561577, -0.017111700028181076, -0.027823906391859055, 0.06058787927031517, 0.09413377940654755, 0.0437200590968132, -0.006634347140789032, -0.001360347610898316, -0.06156236305832863, 0.007120721973478794, 0.027607720345258713, 0.060000497847795486, 0.006551850587129593, -0.02300582267343998, -0.00648996839299798, -0.049906175583601, -0.004743689671158791, 0.02069815620779991, -0.03009330853819847, 0.03615039587020874, 0.020234614610671997, 0.017156977206468582, -0.1075344830751419, -0.008630813099443913, -0.030327506363391876, 0.008209047839045525, 0.028350485488772392, -0.025566691532731056, 0.05159278213977814, 0.07565362006425858, -0.023828983306884766, 0.007102243136614561, 0.046423494815826416, -0.012697141617536545, 0.015099719166755676, -0.02197975292801857, 0.06103565916419029, 0.020755350589752197, -0.043343715369701385, -0.06917747110128403, 0.018512004986405373, 0.0075774784199893475, 0.0013544977409765124, 0.031107675284147263, -0.0790005475282669, 0.02572724223136902, -0.03958839550614357, -0.025197694078087807, 0.0009476381819695234, 0.02633577212691307, 0.012248889543116093, -0.03206638619303703, 0.06780955195426941, 0.0838688537478447, 0.006543691270053387, -0.008424806408584118, 0.007100746035575867, -0.010316666215658188, 0.06959541141986847, -0.05277121439576149, 0.008261347189545631, 0.05546098202466965, -0.004112886730581522, -0.026263367384672165, -0.028021616861224174, -0.011772748082876205, 0.02113807201385498, 0.031377602368593216, -0.007507281377911568, 0.01987863890826702, 0.00937692727893591, -0.03159775212407112, 0.025224391371011734, -0.03691459447145462, -0.04476730152964592, 0.0016171075403690338, -0.032577402889728546, -0.0414646677672863, -0.00901598110795021, -0.018470725044608116, 0.014561411924660206, -0.011777789331972599, 0.0005649371305480599, -0.036676354706287384, -0.03985465690493584, 0.03308430686593056, 0.0021943249739706516, -0.01957179605960846, -0.016295911744236946, -0.02583649940788746, -0.026022637262940407, -0.04883045703172684, -0.03380563110113144, -0.0038570549804717302, 0.03628336265683174, 0.06326226145029068, -0.07599160820245743, 0.07679466903209686, 0.0031628194265067577, 0.03918701410293579, -0.019080758094787598, 0.055754031985998154, 0.0377754382789135, 0.0059362598694860935, 0.04363482818007469, -0.013613421469926834, 0.019352898001670837, -0.009553826414048672, 0.03362557291984558, 0.022908804938197136, -0.008891758508980274, 0.03069736808538437, -0.0250498466193676, -0.010636639781296253, 0.0022230627946555614, -0.025134773924946785, -0.017054013907909393, 0.011889583431184292, 0.04690442606806755, -0.013161041773855686, 0.016886811703443527, 0.024114197120070457, -0.0029374794103205204, 0.0009871108923107386, 0.02513166517019272, 0.017292222008109093, -0.004194101318717003, -0.059466686099767685, -0.04270010069012642, 0.006496243644505739, 0.00908885058015585, -0.012536460533738136, 0.019801964983344078, 0.021699337288737297, 0.02572665549814701, -0.02915126271545887, -0.03414957970380783, 0.03260579705238342, 0.020848579704761505, -0.00031561023206450045, 0.003936450462788343, 0.006836647167801857, -0.021077953279018402, 0.00519930012524128, 0.01607532426714897, 0.0077714258804917336, -0.007407782599329948, -0.0489409975707531, -0.02091645635664463, 0.0036385427229106426, 0.053274188190698624, 0.002592755714431405, -0.02053896337747574, -0.02484630048274994, -0.030806371942162514, -0.012543315067887306, 0.031807009130716324, 0.022170115262269974, 0.00005237826917436905, -0.014820422977209091, -0.06512658298015594, 0.014948728494346142, -0.019755080342292786, -0.04300794377923012, -0.042556364089250565, -0.02462012879550457, 0.049239013344049454, 0.008320322260260582, -0.04537208378314972, 0.024580512195825577, -0.01900908537209034, 0.011704972945153713, -0.02030280977487564, -0.037384454160928726, -0.01373352576047182, 0.026644568890333176, 0.017394009977579117, 0.0036876723170280457, 0.003016845555976033, 0.04995248466730118, 0.01574091985821724, -0.04926863685250282, 0.03271815553307533, 0.01976795867085457, 0.030842995271086693, 0.04681092128157616, -0.005685518030077219, 0.01781311072409153, 0.0006600155611522496, 0.012448585592210293, 0.009650316089391708, -0.012608152814209461, -0.04333864897489548, 0.08098584413528442, -0.054691389203071594, -0.005024487618356943, 0.02383972331881523, 0.05272569879889488, 0.03477349877357483, -0.06590753048658371, -0.05474287271499634, -0.064033642411232, 0.045099757611751556, -0.04459003731608391, -0.05197767913341522, -0.08052914589643478, -0.009614364244043827, -0.0182971078902483, -0.040019359439611435, -0.06900805979967117, -0.06894048303365707, 0.001222150633111596, -0.038190651684999466, -0.10367124527692795, 0.0003414618840906769, 0.008799797855317593, 0.03483610600233078, -0.01927773840725422, 0.03528263047337532, -0.052988164126873016, -0.02813275158405304, -0.0045651947148144245, 0.00009901825251290575, -0.06421272456645966, 0.03726000338792801, 0.03362254053354263, -0.09641032665967941, -0.03922061622142792, 0.038098301738500595, -0.051326584070920944, 0.06739839166402817, -0.0032553940545767546, -0.006937048863619566, 0.07833916693925858, -0.05387531965970993, 0.042892035096883774, 0.11329922825098038, -0.011232595890760422, 0.04549124836921692, 0.006400986108928919, 0.033607758581638336, 0.03234017640352249, -0.04562082514166832, 0.003033928805962205, 0.01818924769759178, -0.07651492208242416, 0.0031190726440399885, 0.04635332152247429, 0.06503302603960037, -0.01692078448832035, -0.044099897146224976, -0.007765027694404125, 0.014072820544242859, -0.0197829008102417, 0.054754145443439484, 0.025744706392288208, 0.01114258635789156, -0.03571556508541107, 0.021007973700761795, -0.0874917060136795, -0.025237353518605232, 0.0014162086881697178, -0.06523571908473969, -0.001169639639556408, 0.035216402262449265, -0.030066149309277534, -0.059549059718847275, -0.052770741283893585, -0.03849794715642929, 0.022183477878570557, 0.034956324845552444, -0.007025800179690123, 0.07316534221172333, 0.03464377671480179, 0.01644977740943432, -0.018628710880875587, -0.0012775035575032234, 0.009052565321326256, 0.03298645094037056, 0.03851545229554176, -0.02289273589849472, 0.06300882250070572, -0.052490703761577606, 0.019635867327451706, 0.07062888145446777, 0.059575460851192474, 0.0841016173362732, -0.027730531990528107, 0.02722943387925625, -0.038683537393808365, -0.02960936166346073, 0.0242394357919693, -0.015197284519672394, 0.06513772904872894, -0.025622345507144928, -0.03543510288000107, 0.038054730743169785, 0.021774770691990852, 0.0245782732963562, 0.06314022094011307, 0.030280333012342453, 0.021667052060365677, 0.01314206887036562, 0.04561552777886391, 0.0008396325865760446, -0.022493427619338036, 0.006147066596895456, 0.016589200124144554, 0.009169216267764568, 0.026557229459285736, 0.08614631742238998, -0.012673957273364067, -0.002550416858866811, 0.060391709208488464, 0.018021659925580025, -0.006417944096028805, 0.017193997278809547, -0.017187878489494324, 0.004445655737072229, -0.008294072933495045, -0.04735220596194267, -0.036062393337488174, -0.010183693841099739, 0.0167767982929945, -0.04899804666638374, -0.02282804623246193, 0.029879525303840637, -0.0026414135936647654, -0.03750089183449745, -0.02321746200323105, 0.03414032608270645, -0.05589786916971207, 0.07394876331090927, -0.007032678462564945, 0.00406158622354269, 0.027365801855921745, 0.012579850852489471, 0.015428495593369007, 0.03518291562795639, 0.007006193045526743, 0.014565086923539639, 0.005318598821759224, -0.061804305762052536, -0.04373788833618164, 0.0013226561713963747, -0.03877139836549759, 0.03972756862640381, -0.047355491667985916, 0.013912287540733814, 0.008647892624139786, 0.029639482498168945, -0.010948234237730503, -0.03995170444250107, 0.01679840125143528, 0.002620707731693983, -0.03071717359125614, -0.015788022428750992, 0.029077114537358284, -0.005432455334812403, 0.013638772070407867, -0.02580106072127819, -0.011683857999742031, -0.0003011315711773932, -0.015396817587316036, -0.030145009979605675, 0.030388280749320984, 0.030901869758963585, 0.02170700579881668, -0.028067519888281822, 0.03533929958939552, 0.060466356575489044, 0.0362321212887764, 0.02326080948114395, 0.01700902171432972, -0.012414554134011269, 0.060912732034921646, 0.026708504185080528, -0.015082428231835365, -0.018611852079629898, 0.017158348113298416, 0.019162990152835846, -0.013509700074791908, -0.0038675006944686174, 0.0009532316471450031, 0.05782828852534294, -0.03165850043296814, 0.040423907339572906, -0.02645917981863022, 0.02433653548359871, -0.07117915898561478, 0.07916660606861115, -0.006391060072928667, -0.01710115745663643, -0.022384921088814735, -0.02548711746931076, 0.07041152566671371, -0.03372741490602493, 0.02276589907705784, -0.02401622384786606, -0.01809948869049549, 0.012699807062745094, -0.009526247158646584, -0.02331223152577877, 0.015901925042271614, -0.039879243820905685, -0.030182434245944023, 0.08955778181552887, -0.06288622319698334, 0.030998636037111282, -0.02119145728647709, -0.06356745213270187, 0.010085498914122581, 0.01573885604739189, 0.004264046438038349, 0.026104526594281197, -0.03883981704711914, -0.03860688954591751, -0.0182508435100317, 0.043926969170570374, 0.03989819809794426, 0.03164482116699219, 0.028994936496019363, -0.04674544185400009, 0.0847640410065651, 0.04663752764463425, -0.029783135280013084, 0.0313984714448452, -0.03854374960064888, -0.029642462730407715, 0.009830916300415993, 0.03355328366160393, 0.024308379739522934, -0.04009125381708145, -0.049106959253549576, -0.01513732224702835, -0.009204273112118244, -0.006760796066373587, 0.015258949249982834, -0.02351279929280281, -0.019303636625409126, 0.0031732029747217894 ]
<p>I was laying on my bed, reading a book when the sun shone through the windows on my left. I happened to look at the wall on my right and noticed this very strange effect. The shadow of my elbow, when near the pages of the book, joined up with the shadow of the book even though I wasn't physically touching it. </p> <p>I have posted a video of the event <a href="http://tinypic.com/player.php?v=6xw7tc%3E&amp;s=5#.UtqZmbRFCM8">here</a>. <em>(Note: the video seems to be wrong way up but you still get the idea of what is happening)</em></p> <p>What is causing this? Some sort of optical illusion where the light get's bent? Coincidentally, I have been wondering about a similar effect recently where if you focus your eye on a nearby object, say, your finger, objects behind it in the distance seem to get curved/distorted around the edge of your finger. It seems awfully related...</p> <p><em><strong>EDIT:</em></strong> I could see the bulge with my bare eyes to the same extent as in the video! The room was well light and the wall was indeed quite bright.</p>
g6621
[ 0.028798775747418404, -0.02142799273133278, -0.006769026163965464, 0.012815400026738644, 0.006930546835064888, 0.0719638466835022, 0.023629089817404747, 0.07300284504890442, 0.01830402947962284, -0.00958679523319006, 0.03857193887233734, 0.02995794266462326, 0.002190748928114772, 0.01871146447956562, 0.04694871976971626, 0.009966009296476841, 0.06429547816514969, -0.022696174681186676, 0.007622253615409136, 0.0144930649548769, -0.02459486573934555, 0.05235854908823967, -0.044060636311769485, -0.0017926858272403479, -0.055001307278871536, 0.03537537157535553, -0.02139204926788807, -0.007977786473929882, -0.023661239072680473, -0.01861213892698288, 0.018482333049178123, 0.008012055419385433, 0.025538261979818344, 0.035437747836112976, -0.005043335258960724, -0.014682895503938198, 0.022838743403553963, -0.008636043407022953, 0.030150212347507477, 0.01976723037660122, -0.011997043155133724, 0.024676242843270302, 0.03107801079750061, 0.00859113223850727, 0.014306005090475082, 0.01730716973543167, 0.018990498036146164, 0.047856271266937256, 0.03856616094708443, -0.020955011248588562, -0.009980875998735428, -0.04465305060148239, 0.007241477258503437, 0.00220281514339149, 0.07120134681463242, 0.013406259939074516, -0.023195238783955574, -0.007334747351706028, 0.05094245448708534, 0.04081285372376442, 0.04598236829042435, 0.0346904918551445, 0.05830686166882515, 0.013022588565945625, 0.027368666604161263, 0.021477803587913513, -0.02913982793688774, 0.021507596597075462, 0.03270397335290909, -0.048594050109386444, -0.0017376068281009793, 0.023363398388028145, -0.025014938786625862, -0.020781217142939568, -0.020992381498217583, -0.02161041647195816, 0.02928905189037323, -0.01018523145467043, -0.013179445639252663, 0.05724480375647545, -0.03881164640188217, -0.044703785330057144, -0.06364127993583679, 0.04648797586560249, 0.04479992389678955, -0.024693699553608894, -0.0024413035716861486, -0.00679597957059741, -0.03132690489292145, -0.006053124088793993, 0.05349674075841904, -0.014192547649145126, 0.027855398133397102, -0.0011207772186025977, -0.02259773574769497, -0.021223159506917, 0.033877089619636536, 0.055784642696380615, 0.005186085123568773, -0.01170111633837223, -0.0938243418931961, -0.019230591133236885, -0.000041229137423215434, 0.02720956690609455, -0.012875128537416458, 0.06957687437534332, -0.01620892994105816, 0.007043821737170219, -0.05178801715373993, 0.01281929574906826, -0.057529937475919724, -0.03153648227453232, 0.0010541371302679181, -0.05165580287575722, 0.020098106935620308, -0.05856953561306, 0.008151600137352943, 0.03718237951397896, 0.015065079554915428, 0.02511114440858364, 0.041933368891477585, 0.03334140405058861, 0.011793863028287888, 0.0364513136446476, -0.011226354166865349, -0.038082368671894073, 0.007956210523843765, -0.06316616386175156, 0.009807691909372807, -0.03110930137336254, 0.06140667945146561, -0.00020810595015063882, -0.027043743059039116, 0.0325872078537941, 0.010893648490309715, 0.007058112882077694, 0.030330205336213112, -0.024807538837194443, 0.002756974659860134, 0.01186253223568201, 0.014159401878714561, -0.023323671892285347, 0.027613017708063126, -0.04863661900162697, -0.0037576432805508375, -0.00040663176332600415, -0.027580352500081062, 0.010233053006231785, 0.042996011674404144, -0.05454311892390251, -0.04679684340953827, -0.010376260615885258, -0.03522103279829025, -0.04908093437552452, 0.00900443084537983, 0.015972405672073364, 0.010777657851576805, -0.041817326098680496, -0.011938223615288734, 0.002370147965848446, 0.06840401142835617, -0.029279675334692, -0.025389034301042557, -0.03497209772467613, -0.01825963892042637, -0.009467009454965591, 0.0007523405947722495, -0.027729719877243042, 0.009776693768799305, -0.04592007398605347, -0.055724162608385086, -0.006068455055356026, -0.020202279090881348, -0.036584626883268356, -0.03087342157959938, 0.051435764878988266, 0.055608540773391724, -0.027849966660141945, 0.05859905853867531, 0.00987690594047308, -0.03794319927692413, -0.0274598840624094, -0.024313418194651604, -0.04104432836174965, 0.021491946652531624, -0.042130306363105774, 0.01782231405377388, 0.02332138642668724, -0.021961843594908714, 0.011845894157886505, -0.042878877371549606, -0.06718698143959045, -0.0074401539750397205, 0.0209119264036417, -0.008798379451036453, -0.010051365941762924, 0.0965471863746643, -0.001469272654503584, -0.037498973309993744, 0.0183020681142807, -0.015400608070194721, 0.004654198419302702, 0.027758538722991943, -0.010802811942994595, -0.026008617132902145, 0.08073128759860992, 0.008039364591240883, -0.006556476000696421, -0.02455908991396427, -0.008403515443205833, -0.010801254771649837, 0.00827726162970066, 0.014898641966283321, -0.027456894516944885, -0.02297462522983551, 0.030717484652996063, 0.004026183858513832, 0.050106681883335114, -0.06084715574979782, 0.060167890042066574, 0.07232633233070374, 0.07676766067743301, 0.027957966551184654, -0.02923605404794216, 0.0402621254324913, -0.008392227813601494, -0.03137684985995293, -0.014276172965765, -0.004151610191911459, 0.0008226957870647311, -0.09813694655895233, -0.015072827227413654, 0.05161002278327942, 0.061305686831474304, 0.00607079453766346, -0.029116634279489517, -0.0030700890347361565, 0.010764580219984055, -0.01123466994613409, -0.039037641137838364, 0.048367977142333984, -0.010220742784440517, -0.04264669120311737, -0.10473848134279251, 0.014723130501806736, 0.05577455088496208, -0.006500603165477514, 0.02034035697579384, 0.01970088668167591, -0.004959980491548777, 0.04761851951479912, -0.0030222039204090834, 0.004759019240736961, 0.00993131473660469, 0.022922703996300697, 0.007082274649292231, -0.05604051426053047, 0.013693198561668396, -0.05016732215881348, 0.004631680436432362, -0.04346417635679245, -0.030536359176039696, 0.0149840684607625, -0.005195403005927801, -0.0143223712220788, 0.02498738281428814, 0.028103027492761612, 0.002588399685919285, 0.03385595977306366, -0.004893885925412178, -0.0017678870353847742, 0.06590356677770615, -0.01814199611544609, 0.01711386814713478, 0.03210563212633133, 0.025689808651804924, -0.02626774273812771, -0.013669184409081936, -0.0023254062980413437, -0.004138332325965166, -0.03403427451848984, 0.06352526694536209, -0.025301093235611916, 0.04659649357199669, 0.014152965508401394, -0.04498006030917168, -0.07297048717737198, 0.009558508172631264, 0.0354488231241703, -0.0059501430951058865, -0.020604819059371948, -0.003179173218086362, -0.01563386432826519, 0.022481843829154968, 0.05579669401049614, 0.0635450929403305, 0.009418107569217682, 0.06434887647628784, -0.0758705586194992, 0.0008491250919178128, -0.04186666011810303, -0.02385779842734337, -0.011179829016327858, 0.06655748188495636, -0.014603630639612675, -0.03929596394300461, 0.009094059467315674, -0.07285427302122116, 0.021818969398736954, 0.019901983439922333, -0.024073075503110886, -0.03162318468093872, 0.038011930882930756, 0.050568822771310806, -0.004349544178694487, 0.019335048273205757, -0.00102050241548568, -0.012066727504134178, -0.009066633880138397, 0.01860971748828888, 0.04102790355682373, 0.03260500356554985, 0.0066113220527768135, 0.012742310762405396, 0.05577448382973671, -0.03967306390404701, -0.000018029953935183585, 0.023416979238390923, 0.015636611729860306, -0.010980004444718361, -0.029169388115406036, -0.04823891445994377, -0.041243523359298706, -0.016865134239196777, -0.010718337260186672, 0.0254829078912735, -0.05315125733613968, 0.01056104525923729, 0.046965859830379486, -0.017492344602942467, 0.013273139484226704, 0.018414007499814034, 0.00904306024312973, -0.05990075692534447, 0.06196923181414604, 0.016174854710698128, -0.011180819012224674, -0.042706962674856186, 0.004557441454380751, 0.020007044076919556, 0.06800568848848343, 0.004984654486179352, -0.04073121398687363, -0.09141095727682114, 0.014045444317162037, 0.05524909123778343, -0.0317685529589653, 0.02646547555923462, 0.007715457584708929, -0.07688354700803757, 0.008055002428591251, -0.023484645411372185, -0.008379749022424221, -0.08316873759031296, -0.06310902535915375, 0.011829862371087074, 0.015646863728761673, 0.033888719975948334, 0.0037887103389948606, 0.03947380557656288, -0.04821157827973366, -0.06822923570871353, -0.03059564344584942, -0.02619164064526558, 0.009084513410925865, -0.04116048663854599, 0.05207797512412071, 0.0006038871360942721, -0.017746400088071823, 0.02475654147565365, 0.011347975581884384, 0.01706053502857685, 0.03187790885567665, 0.04899601638317108, 0.037612129002809525, -0.0007201418629847467, -0.022116973996162415, -0.02182035520672798, 0.07314261794090271, -0.04253799095749855, -0.021452128887176514, -0.001119266264140606, -0.006943417713046074, -0.01909308135509491, 0.029904644936323166, 0.014130123890936375, -0.020150423049926758, 0.014096824452280998, -0.05697929486632347, 0.01219878625124693, 0.02188101038336754, -0.0070714582689106464, 0.01994515024125576, 0.02560197375714779, -0.07964693754911423, 0.005585600156337023, 0.02709333412349224, 0.03045502118766308, -0.03308085724711418, -0.01656918413937092, 0.03264400735497475, 0.020408660173416138, -0.047358572483062744, -0.06509855389595032, 0.011719243600964546, 0.0635276585817337, 0.0833057090640068, 0.059895023703575134, -0.013515274971723557, -0.0031259427778422832, -0.02215142548084259, 0.07125311344861984, -0.07071275264024734, 0.021898692473769188, -0.03852018341422081, 0.044750895351171494, 0.0004290546348784119, -0.035950686782598495, 0.0012268502032384276, -0.0038313516415655613, 0.011595685966312885, 0.029472939670085907, -0.06029362604022026, -0.00127376988530159, -0.014931837096810341, 0.035686034709215164, -0.033045295625925064, 0.0394778810441494, 0.024018270894885063, 0.07154527306556702, 0.04220178350806236, 0.0070794071070849895, 0.05806374549865723, -0.005407978314906359, 0.005194969475269318, 0.04758205637335777, -0.052077628672122955, -0.020876681432127953, -0.021844644099473953, -0.001548386295326054, -0.06839986890554428, 0.00002972471156681422, 0.020552391186356544, -0.0015257522463798523, 0.038619689643383026, -0.04428872466087341, -0.04545894265174866, 0.020779268816113472, 0.010064522735774517, -0.02994714491069317, -0.004382213111966848, 0.012915268540382385, -0.0025215372443199158, -0.009834816679358482, 0.017916999757289886, -0.03666997700929642, -0.054726745933294296, -0.007210553158074617, -0.01714906468987465, 0.011933304369449615, -0.032507799565792084, 0.0471280962228775, -0.018064778298139572, -0.02322867140173912, 0.05863688141107559, 0.06692104786634445, -0.06497291475534439, 0.03869560360908508, -0.057693999260663986, -0.05859072133898735, -0.03558963164687157, 0.018391549587249756, 0.04860744625329971, -0.0633799135684967, 0.002387135988101363, -0.014243993908166885, 0.02645646221935749, 0.0849670022726059, 0.014187530614435673, -0.0054662954062223434, 0.014756912365555763, -0.039149027317762375, -0.038326412439346313, -0.006702804937958717, -0.01448804885149002, 0.02224809303879738, 0.05405730381608009, 0.07122300565242767, 0.04122041165828705, -0.009122571907937527, -0.03224346786737442, 0.03843938931822777, 0.033092088997364044, -0.024741416797041893, 0.0019721847493201494, -0.01662999950349331, -0.038587555289268494, -0.02524527907371521, 0.06445992738008499, 0.06488484889268875, -0.03509664908051491, -0.027977950870990753, -0.021576298400759697, -0.017105191946029663, 0.026559390127658844, -0.02957877330482006, -0.033610325306653976, 0.01070267055183649, 0.015051783062517643, -0.02170385979115963, 0.03344772756099701, -0.025772036984562874, -0.014220268465578556, 0.016377992928028107, 0.07085775583982468, 0.02416391856968403, 0.05303800106048584, 0.03570995107293129, -0.019948383793234825, 0.03951277956366539, -0.03145717829465866, 0.005072333849966526, 0.08658982813358307, 0.007723222486674786, -0.004693131428211927, -0.03130560368299484, 0.011138377711176872, 0.0015759438974782825, 0.010804074816405773, 0.02330068126320839, -0.005379435606300831, -0.029255656525492668, 0.016349785029888153, 0.04809200391173363, -0.048128630965948105, -0.014482101425528526, -0.00195313966833055, 0.03142407536506653, 0.03269422426819801, 0.02904571406543255, 0.0682682916522026, 0.05304912477731705, -0.05177599564194679, 0.08378392457962036, 0.024242127314209938, -0.013338036835193634, -0.002490004990249872, -0.09929871559143066, 0.02525329403579235, -0.06443813443183899, 0.06626325845718384, 0.0004218288231641054, 0.021716663613915443, -0.02717471495270729, 0.026218319311738014, 0.005937209818512201, 0.01567760668694973, -0.030268557369709015, 0.004959449637681246, -0.007646711077541113, 0.03806433081626892, -0.03958725556731224, 0.041030384600162506, -0.010656640864908695, -0.0004921292420476675, 0.02693249098956585, 0.008340959437191486, -0.00189109961502254, -0.01834290660917759, 0.0022435004357248545, 0.0016034082509577274, 0.010851164348423481, 0.020503297448158264, -0.05584050342440605, -0.018406342715024948, -0.06309553980827332, -0.007577354554086924, 0.0386962965130806, 0.10087287425994873, -0.07084360718727112, -0.08724437654018402, 0.008593952283263206, -0.04271959513425827, -0.02423287183046341, -0.0009156459709629416, -0.03215920180082321, 0.015553373843431473, 0.050739556550979614, -0.09031432121992111, 0.002325560664758086, -0.052525755017995834, -0.029556384310126305, 0.04494414106011391, 0.006940584629774094, 0.0177780594676733, -0.0193365216255188, -0.022838395088911057, -0.008380747400224209, 0.0036055089440196753, 0.0034428262151777744, 0.005566439125686884, 0.04805940389633179, -0.010100145824253559, -0.001632755040191114, -0.05157233774662018, -0.044836901128292084, -0.033993519842624664, -0.07569052278995514, -0.047415778040885925, -0.04746348038315773, -0.007829035632312298, 0.0326961912214756, 0.017066072672605515, -0.05149047449231148, 0.01497240737080574, -0.004965002648532391, -0.062151554971933365, -0.04760228469967842, -0.031536076217889786, 0.020650556311011314, -0.050284817814826965, -0.003551542293280363, 0.002032908843830228, 0.0437149703502655, 0.01263087335973978, -0.0014326152158901095, 0.018464993685483932, 0.03713591396808624, 0.0080529460683465, -0.0009652407607063651, 0.01646221987903118, -0.07214681059122086, 0.0009024688042700291, -0.050230685621500015, -0.055030014365911484, -0.04821506142616272, -0.013138565234839916, 0.00731106149032712, -0.0531613789498806, -0.06106115132570267, 0.016482481732964516, 0.02142048068344593, -0.0047564031556248665, -0.030053140595555305, -0.002765576122328639, 0.008427063934504986, 0.013177796266973019, -0.037805262953042984, 0.005043934565037489, -0.08316753059625626, -0.09362240880727768, -0.023307709023356438, -0.02128102444112301, 0.01967567577958107, -0.012320393696427345, 0.018398184329271317, 0.00499927019700408, -0.01035438384860754, -0.06517884880304337, 0.025798747316002846, -0.00417066877707839, -0.0012686372501775622, 0.00875002145767212, -0.02795424871146679, 0.07602787762880325, 0.030406653881072998, 0.028615742921829224, 0.04859064519405365, -0.011885055340826511, -0.03673239424824715, -0.04502302408218384, 0.04915913566946983, 0.047545526176691055, -0.018341081216931343, -0.06996512413024902, 0.0015969815431162715, 0.0280779916793108, 0.052689988166093826, -0.03920198604464531, -0.05765406787395477, 0.0032599312253296375, 0.004242787137627602, -0.039000462740659714, -0.005543089006096125, 0.07727649062871933, -0.021940642967820168, 0.023761747404932976, 0.046995047479867935, -0.006357893813401461, 0.022708792239427567, -0.058231938630342484, -0.016629308462142944, -0.04706110060214996, -0.018010495230555534, 0.03528657555580139, 0.0017858907813206315, -0.06083594262599945, 0.03919163718819618, 0.02435966767370701, -0.00036340116639621556, 0.09502886235713959, -0.019899604842066765, 0.06989406049251556, 0.013221963308751583, 0.03725337237119675, 0.020984668284654617, -0.011964973993599415, 0.04189811274409294, -0.03758542239665985, 0.03749377653002739, -0.02639049105346203, -0.03538738936185837, -0.028175566345453262, -0.032391369342803955, 0.016197245568037033, -0.04142604395747185, 0.03178427740931511, 0.011328925378620625, 0.020403064787387848, 0.028037631884217262, 0.02578469179570675, -0.015370743349194527, 0.01295327115803957, -0.06886845827102661, -0.008516301400959492, 0.028994245454669, -0.0008904133574105799, -0.01046371553093195, 0.05675804987549782, -0.06451315432786942, 0.05460533872246742, -0.0016806377097964287, 0.0037839177530258894, -0.01927793398499489, 0.03860064968466759, -0.03454769402742386, -0.0008278790046460927, -0.005879395641386509, -0.02894221618771553, -0.00329654011875391, -0.031451914459466934, 0.013188989832997322, 0.0001657791726756841, 0.014763123355805874, 0.07647224515676498, 0.015233691781759262, -0.053120359778404236, -0.03907058387994766, 0.0006264609983190894, 0.008037995547056198, -0.06550369411706924, -0.08286185562610626, 0.02104080840945244, -0.04859650135040283, -0.0028651743195950985, -0.009170514531433582, -0.015834102407097816, 0.047315411269664764 ]
<p>I am trying to prove that the momentum $p_x$ operator is Hermitian, my approach is the following</p> <p>$$&lt;p_x&gt;~=~\int \Psi^*(\vec{r},t)[-ih\frac{\partial}{\partial x}]\Psi(\vec{r},t)\, d^3r.$$</p> <p>I try to do integration by parts but I cannot resolve the differential, as the integration is in respect to $\vec{r}$ and the partial is in respect to $x$.</p>
g6622
[ 0.06699459999799728, -0.013071822002530098, -0.0351250097155571, -0.0022750049829483032, 0.05474591255187988, -0.0005893492489121854, 0.04709932208061218, -0.009711296297609806, -0.04237671196460724, 0.03180669620633125, -0.014266664162278175, -0.011868033558130264, -0.09416745603084564, 0.01109224185347557, 0.031256940215826035, -0.04922707751393318, 0.008557969704270363, -0.010868998244404793, 0.0069131022319197655, -0.019162898883223534, -0.04236603155732155, 0.005907239392399788, 0.033185116946697235, -0.02251283824443817, 0.04886982589960098, -0.0411393828690052, -0.014042087830603123, -0.013882514089345932, -0.007364213466644287, 0.003311365842819214, 0.010794291272759438, 0.007268256042152643, 0.022612448781728745, 0.025732623413205147, -0.014659020118415356, 0.015010353177785873, 0.07983950525522232, 0.019422877579927444, 0.033904846757650375, -0.02735799178481102, 0.010775207541882992, -0.07044803351163864, -0.017099924385547638, 0.0013056317111477256, -0.004261136054992676, -0.02725825272500515, -0.0034180902875959873, 0.010217418894171715, -0.04675322771072388, 0.07024995237588882, -0.001097185304388404, 0.024611178785562515, 0.029748564586043358, -0.021684926003217697, -0.025482887402176857, 0.01909051649272442, 0.024341467767953873, -0.023803306743502617, 0.03236572444438934, 0.009996846318244934, 0.016467144712805748, -0.0723111480474472, 0.046162914484739304, 0.03738808259367943, 0.025312909856438637, -0.012942458502948284, -0.011424019932746887, -0.019956480711698532, 0.03060251846909523, -0.0449485220015049, 0.04310080409049988, -0.02298840507864952, 0.07847800850868225, 0.044986095279455185, -0.038009196519851685, -0.021771637722849846, 0.00217609410174191, -0.06581685692071915, 0.004303503315895796, -0.01719023287296295, 0.033441636711359024, -0.029229581356048584, 0.039744749665260315, -0.021554309874773026, -0.018860096111893654, -0.05442852899432182, 0.007494943216443062, -0.04315505549311638, -0.06314465403556824, 0.033474065363407135, 0.003129031974822283, 0.03941773623228073, 0.015456056222319603, 0.024490341544151306, -0.006081694271415472, -0.05224601924419403, -0.07362334430217743, 0.05853139981627464, -0.014279620721936226, -0.0016014258144423366, 0.002200876362621784, 0.03251635655760765, 0.007179049775004387, -0.034410711377859116, 0.009990465827286243, -0.009465841576457024, -0.014299863949418068, -0.0005892813787795603, 0.029301302507519722, -0.03449944406747818, 0.012020893394947052, 0.007884836755692959, -0.0204288512468338, -0.015590904280543327, 0.02851409651339054, -0.012490748427808285, -0.0009400026756338775, -0.035077184438705444, -0.06938651204109192, 0.06674076616764069, 0.012888086959719658, 0.02450338751077652, 0.03866412863135338, 0.04595230892300606, 0.007994411513209343, 0.028533780947327614, -0.0759376659989357, 0.01096777431666851, 0.07199369370937347, -0.0026716510765254498, 0.02288801223039627, 0.03184737265110016, -0.023483552038669586, 0.016281740739941597, -0.005802453495562077, -0.0018553296104073524, -0.08321335911750793, 0.0021777120418846607, -0.027621490880846977, 0.018035875633358955, 0.009211651980876923, 0.02135375142097473, 0.011579036712646484, 0.05008325353264809, -0.02081095613539219, -0.03542334958910942, -0.03262445330619812, -0.03294888883829117, -0.03375814110040665, 0.024456443265080452, 0.03378778696060181, 0.08277022838592529, 0.0303016509860754, 0.02724630944430828, 0.012306378223001957, 0.018963156268000603, 0.04858236014842987, -0.014578614383935928, 0.030007503926753998, 0.009975492022931576, 0.010252349078655243, 0.07514280080795288, 0.0216742604970932, -0.000268058676738292, 0.025449758395552635, -0.03323652222752571, -0.001681806636042893, -0.06148437038064003, -0.033547233790159225, -0.04202937334775925, 0.01447993516921997, 0.042275335639715195, -0.014154248870909214, 0.002035961952060461, 0.017372649163007736, 0.03218253329396248, -0.06022931635379791, -0.0034772150684148073, -0.00631676847115159, 0.08752721548080444, 0.01973816752433777, -0.0265756044536829, 0.015645936131477356, -0.08750392496585846, 0.041218966245651245, 0.0056244018487632275, 0.04201348498463631, -0.0012737840879708529, -0.0663267970085144, -0.06439381837844849, 0.04189598560333252, 0.025336429476737976, -0.0351981520652771, 0.02493920736014843, 0.015282999724149704, -0.013806844130158424, 0.015462948009371758, -0.06859755516052246, 0.0023249215446412563, 0.01766309328377247, -0.02189442329108715, 0.019759882241487503, 0.08380778878927231, 0.045062173157930374, 0.050422608852386475, 0.018800033256411552, 0.03297753259539604, -0.024117683991789818, 0.012866613455116749, 0.05168415233492851, 0.01943233609199524, -0.08008365333080292, 0.007465670816600323, 0.038392528891563416, -0.01197246927767992, -0.04126432538032532, 0.057910870760679245, 0.021577803418040276, -0.003522656625136733, -0.025032682344317436, -0.04559341073036194, -0.006709032226353884, -0.060030050575733185, -0.002398787997663021, -0.051788389682769775, 0.08641331642866135, -0.028565699234604836, 0.04690403863787651, -0.049375008791685104, -0.008310390636324883, 0.007351793814450502, 0.018992533907294273, -0.01874169148504734, 0.01288085151463747, 0.02970731072127819, 0.02987961657345295, 0.014856093563139439, -0.015351245179772377, -0.00022055320732761174, 0.04365646466612816, 0.02549760974943638, 0.0045639644376933575, 0.016298405826091766, -0.03700452297925949, 0.057407446205616, 0.03754863515496254, 0.018137631937861443, 0.040383026003837585, -0.032245781272649765, -0.06408166140317917, -0.010747411288321018, 0.055012837052345276, -0.011389221996068954, -0.02414540760219097, -0.02675751969218254, -0.006873232778161764, 0.004415880888700485, 0.030256569385528564, 0.011778493411839008, -0.013788333162665367, -0.03280039504170418, -0.004044154193252325, -0.03472296893596649, 0.0242503322660923, -0.09228724241256714, 0.006165150087326765, -0.006153718568384647, 0.003999273758381605, 0.034338075667619705, -0.010523932985961437, 0.01012466661632061, 0.08197081834077835, -0.00292127369903028, 0.02762593887746334, -0.007646837271749973, -0.0481887087225914, 0.04590011015534401, -0.03287891671061516, 0.0024999340530484915, -0.041199278086423874, -0.010588577017188072, 0.033799897879362106, -0.03855147957801819, -0.003251046407967806, 0.04262382537126541, -0.05401007458567619, -0.003569431370124221, 0.029183221980929375, 0.01214088685810566, 0.016696717590093613, 0.030957194045186043, -0.007154264021664858, 0.028218358755111694, -0.00042841877439059317, 0.004376284312456846, -0.012271794490516186, 0.06409241259098053, -0.05611686035990715, 0.01452796719968319, -0.01613244228065014, 0.03683116286993027, 0.03339524194598198, -0.005054425448179245, -0.0213395394384861, 0.03354108706116676, -0.06724203377962112, -0.02018889971077442, 0.04394053295254707, -0.015946263447403908, 0.01087193377315998, 0.018616240471601486, -0.016122067347168922, -0.009109631180763245, -0.011323720216751099, -0.025961462408304214, 0.00444053765386343, -0.044257987290620804, -0.0256248340010643, -0.02323412150144577, 0.0334618017077446, -0.02846888266503811, -0.012213352136313915, 0.05872612074017525, 0.02928009256720543, 0.03482717648148537, 0.015442482195794582, -0.06099279224872589, 0.06652960181236267, -0.0416904017329216, -0.009097483940422535, 0.011669914238154888, -0.006174331996589899, 0.028940901160240173, 0.015643678605556488, -0.04666085168719292, -0.011468417942523956, -0.004406481981277466, 0.024109788239002228, 0.022005179896950722, -0.038672976195812225, 0.0006966618821024895, 0.009669238701462746, -0.0552372932434082, 0.00555967353284359, -0.05813250318169594, -0.06333811581134796, 0.002302769338712096, 0.06980430334806442, 0.023556802421808243, 0.013328890316188335, -0.0386647954583168, 0.01596478931605816, 0.056494563817977905, -0.014965486712753773, -0.03527486324310303, -0.0027023209258913994, 0.05696483701467514, 0.05429647117853165, -0.0013683006400242448, -0.02301030233502388, 0.008950034156441689, -0.016941960901021957, 0.013719507493078709, -0.023751448839902878, 0.010802163742482662, -0.022888796404004097, 0.021787559613585472, 0.0219559483230114, -0.016959842294454575, 0.00699534360319376, -0.001750494004227221, -0.024582119658589363, 0.02832539938390255, 0.04645586386322975, -0.02184280939400196, -0.0865052193403244, -0.013838627375662327, -0.015039373189210892, 0.01693323440849781, 0.05810565873980522, 0.0013371598906815052, -0.002521590096876025, -0.019180241972208023, 0.028983376920223236, 0.030691295862197876, 0.04481086507439613, 0.00381285697221756, 0.06621989607810974, 0.08087041974067688, 0.008568398654460907, 0.024851063266396523, -0.03792152181267738, -0.036867059767246246, 0.03739235922694206, 0.012358305044472218, -0.032541003078222275, 0.011457085609436035, -0.020480236038565636, -0.05128776282072067, 0.018718445673584938, -0.04323626682162285, 0.005426371935755014, 0.05922513082623482, -0.01212488953024149, 0.023289578035473824, 0.054973747581243515, -0.009659006260335445, -0.022764867171645164, -0.014340045861899853, -0.009879866614937782, -0.006006049923598766, 0.011701163835823536, 0.01694549433887005, -0.0316394679248333, -0.04042789340019226, 0.0003746037546079606, 0.00015894387615844607, -0.062843918800354, -0.018945857882499695, 0.02570069395005703, 0.015820704400539398, 0.011519979685544968, 0.05628165230154991, -0.005844715517014265, 0.04462533816695213, 0.057953834533691406, 0.03327341005206108, -0.01462563592940569, -0.04438347369432449, -0.00673644058406353, -0.034887589514255524, -0.02188303880393505, -0.007534074131399393, 0.00841981079429388, 0.004727166146039963, -0.027482159435749054, -0.015943605452775955, -0.03022279217839241, -0.09429997205734253, 0.050683893263339996, 0.030339879915118217, 0.02975151687860489, 0.002114849165081978, -0.02292811870574951, -0.01695067808032036, 0.03259695693850517, 0.028991607949137688, -0.04616415500640869, 0.04411252960562706, 0.007971830666065216, -0.019323600456118584, 0.012441521510481834, -0.015085671097040176, -0.025271715596318245, 0.004116837400943041, 0.0397135354578495, -0.059379205107688904, 0.022479141131043434, -0.06803424656391144, -0.04923582077026367, -0.011312934570014477, -0.0017174945678561926, -0.00006523298361571506, -0.0071792080998420715, 0.057881634682416916, -0.030858207494020462, -0.09133478999137878, 0.06546797603368759, -0.0179463941603899, -0.07270660251379013, 0.047142017632722855, -0.05410508066415787, -0.03393232449889183, 0.009686285629868507, -0.015492892824113369, 0.012794802896678448, 0.03073343262076378, 0.018347840756177902, 0.005693802610039711, -0.03290461003780365, 0.016510142013430595, 0.00950546469539404, -0.03297146409749985, 0.023097291588783264, -0.02889070473611355, 0.031320974230766296, -0.05794232338666916, -0.025290826335549355, -0.0519934706389904, -0.022369002923369408, -0.02680366113781929, 0.09318171441555023, 0.04013210907578468, -0.000261789740761742, -0.014942768029868603, 0.05574723333120346, 0.0244273841381073, -0.026337316259741783, -0.015222195535898209, 0.027285393327474594, -0.06055327504873276, -0.04674334451556206, 0.008946524001657963, -0.015416709706187248, 0.059003375470638275, 0.0043059466406702995, 0.05743502080440521, -0.011068921536207199, 0.005906799342483282, 0.0578751303255558, 0.02707865461707115, 0.009507938288152218, 0.01853260211646557, -0.03881508484482765, -0.005192324053496122, 0.009557225741446018, 0.012015968561172485, -0.015106565319001675, -0.01764834299683571, -0.10428678244352341, 0.09800323098897934, -0.026840224862098694, 0.06108453869819641, -0.04835859686136246, 0.006049658637493849, 0.02983037941157818, -0.04557514935731888, -0.07153941690921783, -0.06325622648000717, 0.03254087641835213, 0.008609039708971977, -0.06975296884775162, 0.04386566951870918, -0.021777719259262085, -0.05408422648906708, -0.02441416308283806, 0.005545333493500948, 0.03550572693347931, 0.045833852142095566, -0.02691100910305977, -0.015597742982208729, -0.05504431948065758, -0.053573768585920334, 0.01922210492193699, -0.06801013648509979, 0.01121978834271431, 0.04241087660193443, -0.014837157912552357, 0.041837215423583984, -0.06545247882604599, -0.024912917986512184, 0.03686264902353287, -0.11081434041261673, -0.0417192205786705, 0.04322060942649841, -0.0492982342839241, 0.02991010807454586, -0.023213012143969536, 0.0016826910432428122, 0.017234448343515396, 0.043810028582811356, -0.050944868475198746, -0.0057141100987792015, -0.00672163674607873, 0.009539955295622349, 0.0008480777614749968, 0.005751028191298246, -0.0069823358207941055, -0.03178657218813896, 0.024228708818554878, -0.02629268355667591, 0.018743980675935745, -0.0016452404670417309, 0.02045408822596073, 0.00817471370100975, 0.03611796349287033, 0.0008630467928014696, -0.04582902416586876, 0.009593191556632519, -0.01380881853401661, -0.009485341608524323, -0.008035661652684212, 0.010369883850216866, -0.0016221447149291635, 0.00006487577047664672, -0.01189463585615158, -0.045235875993967056, -0.04643416032195091, 0.05183575674891472, 0.09561172127723694, -0.048966530710458755, 0.05926614999771118, -0.0647098571062088, -0.01102362759411335, 0.01736748032271862, 0.029394585639238358, 0.02864912711083889, -0.012646717950701714, 0.022700097411870956, 0.042227279394865036, 0.006190019194036722, -0.0196303129196167, 0.036264143884181976, -0.01917143352329731, -0.03809267655014992, 0.039047565311193466, -0.0212058387696743, -0.023717498406767845, -0.02089209109544754, 0.07055789232254028, -0.020876863971352577, 0.035074397921562195, 0.014217158779501915, 0.006049554329365492, 0.0246945358812809, -0.0368194580078125, -0.0031636084895581007, 0.07079334557056427, 0.01956506446003914, -0.023253923282027245, 0.06870806217193604, 0.015666577965021133, 0.011930102482438087, -0.009380446746945381, 0.017407460138201714, -0.01637241430580616, -0.008222285658121109, 0.02942332625389099, -0.00283407187089324, 0.007110103033483028, 0.03247126191854477, -0.012422436848282814, -0.023617791011929512, -0.04247207194566727, -0.027537092566490173, 0.034626998007297516, -0.03359239175915718, 0.05949736014008522, 0.04515894502401352, 0.03796663135290146, 0.033582959324121475, 0.03540866822004318, -0.00430624233558774, -0.018444709479808807, -0.0642242580652237, 0.007900786586105824, 0.0013422737829387188, -0.020260578021407127, -0.10572244971990585, 0.01836303435266018, 0.08055725693702698, 0.04739462211728096, 0.027743281796574593, 0.005714585073292255, -0.05080864951014519, -0.001827529165893793, 0.035678062587976456, -0.0010354063706472516, 0.010408075526356697, -0.046167269349098206, 0.002626819768920541, 0.00947689637541771, -0.017279639840126038, -0.004728719592094421, 0.009950325824320316, 0.017788881435990334, -0.03406423330307007, -0.03931744396686554, -0.0018882917938753963, -0.03640463948249817, -0.0029002518858760595, -0.004249265417456627, -0.07543422281742096, 0.0022104016970843077, -0.05459616333246231, 0.011151579208672047, 0.03919240087270737, 0.03818534314632416, -0.04976414889097214, 0.027147430926561356, -0.008396944031119347, 0.06509178876876831, -0.055631738156080246, 0.01624288409948349, -0.017407353967428207, -0.043418072164058685, -0.032183729112148285, -0.036500558257102966, -0.013402407988905907, 0.08178646862506866, -0.02786332555115223, 0.06379202753305435, 0.028278730809688568, 0.012624763883650303, -0.03878263384103775, 0.0038284920156002045, 0.058867741376161575, 0.03966803103685379, -0.0404512993991375, 0.028605369850993156, 0.026205047965049744, -0.06124105304479599, 0.05842195823788643, 0.010941894724965096, 0.020531171932816505, -0.013723696582019329, -0.025385700166225433, -0.004634670447558165, 0.012483596801757812, 0.011960482224822044, 0.06055415794253349, -0.028521373867988586, -0.029002616181969643, -0.020039837807416916, 0.0345953106880188, -0.019117916002869606, -0.06378605216741562, 0.005981940310448408, 0.008728493936359882, -0.06777481734752655, 0.027589404955506325, 0.01401566993445158, -0.04680858179926872, -0.07955128699541092, -0.000515580817591399, -0.018630312755703926, -0.05645236745476723, 0.004405119456350803, 0.020237542688846588, 0.04399231821298599, -0.011944427154958248, -0.0006712759495712817, -0.04895878955721855, 0.01607678085565567, -0.018374230712652206, 0.0022060831543058157, 0.027195775881409645, -0.03929315507411957, 0.0662505254149437, 0.017107129096984863, -0.0014304162468761206, -0.09694641083478928, 0.005769406445324421, 0.061021264642477036, 0.05930596590042114, -0.04794006794691086, -0.0016169490991160274, 0.06619922816753387, 0.0009240835788659751, 0.010042977519333363, -0.02919067069888115, 0.059330862015485764, -0.056756388396024704, 0.011978663504123688, -0.03866958245635033, -0.03246429190039635, -0.020601220428943634, 0.0490792877972126, -0.02498725615441799, 0.033895742148160934, -0.02300841361284256, -0.022410528734326363, -0.037901248782873154, -0.015900030732154846, -0.02134430781006813, -0.04731348156929016, -0.016460848972201347, -0.00736326863989234 ]
<p>Please bear with this experimentalist trying to understand the subtleties of TIs in what may well be imprecise language. I appreciate that one can deduce the topological trivial or non-trivial nature of a filled band for particular crystalline structures by virtue of $(-1)^{\nu_0} = \Pi \delta_i$ taken over the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-symmetry" rel="nofollow">TR</a> symmetry points of the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brillouin_zone" rel="nofollow">BZ</a>. I also appreciate that the gap must close at the interface between topologically distinct insulating phases. In my naive understanding, I would expect that the surface state must "fix" the overall parity difference between the valence bands of the TI and trivial insulator and believe that $N_k = \Delta \nu$ mod 2, where $N_k$ is the number of Kramers pair edge modes implies this fix. I would have expected however that their would be some implication about the parity of the edge mode itself (i.e. that is must be odd). Why is there no statement about the edge modes parity? </p>
g6623
[ 0.002431306056678295, 0.031243646517395973, -0.016096986830234528, 0.0008301578927785158, 0.050820425152778625, 0.0054179769940674305, 0.04552817344665527, 0.06865342706441879, 0.003656350541859865, -0.014109076000750065, -0.002667797962203622, -0.01799767091870308, 0.02842351794242859, -0.061627086251974106, 0.00042077433317899704, -0.012003210373222828, 0.010226028971374035, 0.07001902163028717, 0.04548073932528496, -0.03369760140776634, -0.026931850239634514, 0.00904738437384367, -0.015750065445899963, -0.03903067857027054, 0.00854360219091177, 0.023666005581617355, 0.00976751558482647, -0.0491730272769928, 0.02411673776805401, -0.04333343356847763, 0.0570843368768692, 0.004927944391965866, 0.05229099094867706, -0.028689872473478317, -0.04749564081430435, 0.015773484483361244, 0.040900133550167084, 0.005847444757819176, 0.03533954918384552, -0.022404149174690247, 0.01368402037769556, -0.0013642265694215894, -0.02105940692126751, -0.01007663644850254, -0.008105004206299782, -0.03930000588297844, -0.02330283261835575, 0.0039964597672224045, -0.037815503776073456, -0.015553567558526993, -0.012533319182693958, 0.04044389724731445, 0.07914097607135773, 0.021275898441672325, -0.022766010835766792, 0.005163058638572693, -0.013930144719779491, 0.01208267081528902, 0.07798752933740616, 0.07514756172895432, -0.011697737500071526, -0.0008947772439569235, 0.03278284892439842, 0.021690690889954567, 0.04951953515410423, -0.004195813089609146, 0.006649576593190432, 0.010268653742969036, 0.04851744323968887, -0.02281687594950199, -0.005733747035264969, -0.011429029516875744, 0.01369918417185545, -0.03323690965771675, -0.03428362309932709, 0.07867122441530228, -0.0009789151372388005, -0.0288856104016304, -0.06283991038799286, 0.018556887283921242, 0.014242683537304401, -0.043756887316703796, -0.03376036509871483, 0.026953792199492455, 0.04351957142353058, -0.027894407510757446, -0.030055193230509758, 0.0008162495796568692, -0.02559097297489643, 0.06668483465909958, 0.050131380558013916, -0.016833262518048286, 0.05130178853869438, -0.030645880848169327, -0.0005717570311389863, -0.019579697400331497, 0.016337649896740913, 0.02348039112985134, 0.01815045066177845, -0.02253851853311062, 0.01300104521214962, 0.038953423500061035, 0.01086280308663845, -0.031434252858161926, 0.019154293462634087, 0.0441337525844574, -0.05248231813311577, -0.007341050077229738, -0.008638721890747547, 0.04467414692044258, 0.0033047052565962076, -0.002124392194673419, 0.01312305685132742, -0.023439055308699608, -0.011000687256455421, 0.03916405886411667, 0.01929790899157524, -0.02575107105076313, -0.049825217574834824, -0.006524040829390287, 0.026012182235717773, -0.012878830544650555, -0.015641210600733757, 0.04811063036322594, -0.0008523925207555294, -0.018856298178434372, -0.008523681201040745, -0.035747841000556946, 0.03569725155830383, -0.004353546537458897, -0.05359282344579697, -0.005029542837291956, -0.0016231294721364975, 0.015909135341644287, 0.035878993570804596, -0.04183758795261383, -0.020018769428133965, -0.05452851951122284, 0.031696636229753494, -0.03234761953353882, -0.05831298232078552, -0.01000469084829092, -0.07687661796808243, -0.05486680194735527, 0.01905086636543274, -0.004467996768653393, -0.08154497295618057, -0.058727867901325226, 0.022615812718868256, 0.011591466143727303, 0.021933818235993385, 0.061660170555114746, 0.006174270063638687, -0.044784240424633026, -0.03809630125761032, -0.009206228889524937, 0.12344636768102646, 0.00222056545317173, 0.03308877721428871, 0.008763845078647137, -0.005866775754839182, -0.020058980211615562, 0.014986083842813969, 0.05760794132947922, -0.054681356996297836, -0.03734751045703888, 0.043768785893917084, -0.06313610076904297, -0.006614642217755318, -0.03873589634895325, -0.031728487461805344, 0.02164159156382084, -0.02800915203988552, 0.037627212703228, -0.015335076488554478, 0.07422616332769394, -0.05408626049757004, -0.011230106465518475, 0.09197922796010971, 0.0036074984818696976, 0.007072282489389181, 0.016976824030280113, -0.03005836345255375, 0.020384393632411957, -0.01047390978783369, -0.03675946220755577, 0.020060040056705475, -0.0446329303085804, -0.00035204397863708436, 0.08659777790307999, 0.03674476593732834, 0.003549169050529599, 0.018320009112358093, 0.015062949620187283, 0.044953085482120514, 0.00397393386811018, 0.06597401946783066, -0.01390029862523079, -0.07958772033452988, 0.005189287476241589, -0.0764889195561409, 0.006736918352544308, -0.011368876323103905, -0.00961391907185316, -0.046440720558166504, 0.014053620398044586, 0.021479802206158638, 0.012942515313625336, 0.030954837799072266, 0.0038712541572749615, -0.044329650700092316, 0.02864489145576954, -0.037490759044885635, -0.001810701796784997, -0.00010484526865184307, 0.00619493518024683, 0.04472322389483452, -0.03274059668183327, -0.00924028642475605, -0.010478920303285122, -0.08097567409276962, -0.008599216118454933, 0.06976770609617233, -0.002237572567537427, -0.04121533781290054, -0.022425850853323936, 0.027623331174254417, 0.0048097711987793446, -0.061485450714826584, 0.05263330042362213, -0.054393187165260315, -0.011459482833743095, -0.009614529088139534, 0.03748951107263565, 0.009680698625743389, 0.004550199024379253, 0.02695397473871708, -0.0252907145768404, 0.03362101688981056, -0.04702509194612503, -0.0031619444489479065, -0.005354427266865969, -0.07742727547883987, 0.04155677556991577, 0.024053925648331642, 0.020792081952095032, 0.005156087223440409, -0.024327393621206284, -0.027300726622343063, 0.025458257645368576, 0.023604480549693108, -0.021975068375468254, -0.022584477439522743, -0.001417877385392785, 0.023477628827095032, -0.06863277405500412, 0.028286777436733246, -0.025397516787052155, 0.036303095519542694, -0.031119780614972115, -0.01786566525697708, -0.005482408218085766, 0.04770583659410477, 0.009743327274918556, -0.03558160737156868, 0.0025715979281812906, 0.003129652002826333, 0.019443942233920097, 0.01301862858235836, 0.004640279803425074, 0.01455027423799038, 0.07887016981840134, 0.022754184901714325, 0.01246124878525734, 0.0024725906550884247, -0.036668360233306885, 0.00803240854293108, 0.036323439329862595, -0.0764138326048851, -0.0567411445081234, -0.02579890564084053, 0.03845996782183647, -0.04236213117837906, 0.020919619128108025, 0.06031021103262901, -0.08208514004945755, 0.03781504184007645, 0.008826988749206066, -0.051404230296611786, 0.06040794774889946, -0.010101905092597008, 0.0033325916156172752, 0.06160161271691322, 0.07388599216938019, 0.02251153439283371, -0.044825345277786255, -0.030361980199813843, 0.015982991084456444, -0.05934314429759979, 0.08755488693714142, -0.03619991987943649, 0.03982551395893097, -0.0255599282681942, 0.035796813666820526, -0.021706489846110344, 0.009004001505672932, -0.0242608655244112, -0.021817298606038094, -0.013856662437319756, -0.07047081738710403, 0.013268931768834591, 0.03428889065980911, 0.007907146587967873, -0.033179622143507004, 0.017953956499695778, 0.0834687203168869, -0.04599709436297417, 0.016077697277069092, -0.0016274566296488047, 0.0412604957818985, -0.0268885288387537, 0.08158507198095322, 0.03143811225891113, 0.046076949685811996, -0.008064462803304195, 0.006595272570848465, -0.08675301820039749, 0.0276804082095623, -0.04626382514834404, 0.022716542705893517, 0.0351162888109684, -0.0057136439718306065, 0.019369786605238914, -0.031079493463039398, -0.013073530979454517, -0.04221409186720848, -0.0023435361217707396, 0.07801714539527893, 0.07368496805429459, -0.006002162117511034, -0.08476754277944565, -0.04304753243923187, -0.008741224184632301, 0.042689450085163116, 0.028341401368379593, -0.013548859395086765, -0.07475455105304718, -0.00241136085242033, -0.018343811854720116, -0.00968091655522585, 0.04919234290719032, 0.03831200674176216, 0.01776624470949173, -0.007830454036593437, -0.038696013391017914, 0.05858197063207626, 0.023729756474494934, 0.03553982824087143, 0.021221667528152466, 0.018950030207633972, 0.07413887977600098, -0.07731135189533234, -0.009768730029463768, -0.08619953691959381, -0.05262726545333862, -0.004989649169147015, 0.00626435736194253, 0.032986026257276535, 0.027637183666229248, -0.02227783016860485, -0.029173433780670166, -0.029635265469551086, -0.0030888558831065893, 0.04198814556002617, 0.03336698189377785, -0.027522113174200058, -0.045770276337862015, 0.009013221599161625, 0.04430696368217468, 0.056333135813474655, 0.03266655653715134, -0.0226215198636055, 0.03983541950583458, -0.03287755325436592, 0.019600143656134605, 0.005852553527802229, -0.0024737899657338858, 0.05820352956652641, -0.015208670869469643, -0.014246460050344467, 0.02178245596587658, -0.020193476229906082, 0.02136617712676525, -0.0038319905288517475, -0.024131355807185173, -0.04728935658931732, -0.009517697617411613, -0.011145083233714104, -0.013262192718684673, -0.005914743524044752, 0.028260884806513786, -0.06325051188468933, -0.016252774745225906, -0.014488077722489834, -0.012853975407779217, 0.004397462122142315, 0.03498794138431549, 0.039795514196157455, 0.014793626964092255, -0.04058881476521492, 0.001137500279583037, 0.03408396989107132, 0.06776438653469086, -0.031154492869973183, 0.033704690635204315, 0.03034937009215355, 0.01898382045328617, -0.004136689472943544, 0.052901189774274826, -0.046905338764190674, -0.005999329965561628, -0.004861182067543268, 0.00845250766724348, -0.04168488457798958, -0.0034020552411675453, 0.08816097676753998, 0.013534333556890488, -0.04471756890416145, -0.020870232954621315, -0.038749467581510544, -0.033562857657670975, -0.031236398965120316, -0.0253683403134346, 0.03476273640990257, -0.03956236690282822, -0.013299759477376938, -0.08892083913087845, 0.04757734388113022, -0.03958722576498985, 0.01931443065404892, 0.04380178451538086, -0.029190247878432274, -0.023290349170565605, -0.048568740487098694, -0.013612344861030579, -0.03947969153523445, -0.06395744532346725, -0.01954011246562004, -0.016407674178481102, -0.01009372342377901, -0.021655187010765076, -0.003235073760151863, 0.0028686339501291513, -0.023782772943377495, -0.0018123987829312682, -0.08257629722356796, 0.012089300900697708, 0.03352345526218414, -0.01894097961485386, 0.020914187654852867, -0.021399369463324547, -0.02857704646885395, -0.034732505679130554, -0.0029307983350008726, 0.10356330126523972, 0.03845159336924553, -0.021947676315903664, 0.010104629211127758, -0.08110491931438446, -0.009753754362463951, 0.04387030377984047, 0.04122700169682503, 0.04239024221897125, 0.01896696537733078, 0.011703959666192532, -0.0076757012866437435, -0.0096048004925251, -0.008208922110497952, -0.01396600715816021, -0.02088969014585018, -0.01350690983235836, 0.02732747793197632, 0.013190636411309242, 0.0757157951593399, -0.023332420736551285, 0.024121342226862907, -0.0968080535531044, -0.029054371640086174, -0.06561227887868881, -0.01006130501627922, 0.07442066073417664, 0.033430445939302444, 0.048100795596838, 0.005708303768187761, -0.03378933295607567, -0.061165664345026016, 0.07032138109207153, 0.017681550234556198, 0.00436610309407115, 0.005293483380228281, -0.028339918702840805, -0.010129091329872608, 0.02929053083062172, 0.0306316539645195, 0.017603697255253792, 0.04284801334142685, 0.04805034026503563, -0.03391110524535179, 0.04168834909796715, 0.001677977154031396, 0.018001966178417206, 0.022263431921601295, -0.04077567532658577, 0.008443735539913177, 0.01220760028809309, 0.0038539329543709755, -0.0016480126651003957, 0.011299408040940762, 0.009306316263973713, -0.0112220523878932, -0.027517516165971756, 0.03512532636523247, -0.054077353328466415, -0.01603844203054905, -0.0025908690877258778, 0.005512093659490347, -0.01914556697010994, -0.07532978057861328, 0.0028960569761693478, 0.007613934576511383, 0.006669661030173302, 0.03826608881354332, 0.01662764884531498, -0.00960406381636858, 0.03139349818229675, 0.029981477186083794, -0.0025033005513250828, -0.005410617683082819, -0.011004157364368439, 0.041263360530138016, 0.01716144196689129, 0.002637638943269849, 0.034233931452035904, 0.03762612119317055, 0.06778029352426529, -0.038101449608802795, 0.0056623429991304874, 0.055577535182237625, 0.020449206233024597, -0.02581464871764183, -0.04298284649848938, -0.015810029581189156, -0.01730768382549286, -0.03493634983897209, -0.0005865711136721075, 0.0011142591247335076, -0.021938547492027283, -0.0065168775618076324, -0.04272156208753586, -0.03965456783771515, 0.07057289034128189, -0.012480012141168118, -0.014522031880915165, 0.01104220561683178, 0.07501155138015747, -0.03277139365673065, -0.04113710671663284, -0.007138761691749096, 0.02915278449654579, -0.03082098253071308, 0.026494042947888374, -0.01744314841926098, 0.03873256593942642, 0.004240887239575386, -0.0326397567987442, 0.031126530840992928, -0.010527932085096836, 0.016262104734778404, -0.05029348284006119, -0.05714165046811104, 0.01375157292932272, -0.02855711057782173, 0.021518699824810028, 0.011383503675460815, 0.018100697547197342, 0.028654491528868675, -0.0013838730519637465, -0.08552257716655731, 0.03984181210398674, 0.04800475388765335, -0.03527161478996277, -0.07074175775051117, -0.013012469746172428, 0.038970790803432465, 0.017680685967206955, 0.050314709544181824, -0.029337966814637184, 0.00983221922069788, -0.069563128054142, 0.045101914554834366, 0.04689130559563637, -0.023695582523941994, 0.00561806233599782, 0.030165858566761017, 0.007642343640327454, 0.029877180233597755, 0.013595622032880783, 0.018308503553271294, -0.09952107816934586, 0.015472285449504852, -0.005693172570317984, 0.07901929318904877, -0.03215450793504715, -0.030604908242821693, 0.013969124294817448, 0.0154415313154459, -0.03144218027591705, -0.024791480973362923, -0.024197259917855263, 0.01724299043416977, 0.02291116490960121, -0.04099775105714798, -0.01848587393760681, 0.00601746141910553, 0.051083337515592575, -0.028042007237672806, 0.007553363684564829, 0.013148183934390545, 0.005167674273252487, 0.010316694155335426, -0.011214652098715305, 0.010045703500509262, 0.005866320803761482, 0.034249503165483475, -0.03608039394021034, 0.015248301438987255, 0.02198457345366478, -0.03260837122797966, -0.015544287860393524, 0.028517551720142365, -0.026134410873055458, 0.03263411298394203, 0.08133324235677719, -0.011442402377724648, 0.026671458035707474, 0.03410374000668526, -0.05341576784849167, 0.0070680552162230015, -0.007124981377273798, -0.0233173631131649, 0.00932341255247593, 0.02821563556790352, 0.013406796380877495, -0.004277059808373451, 0.025559453293681145, -0.053446006029844284, -0.012084629386663437, -0.03565789386630058, 0.00793799851089716, 0.060304611921310425, -0.07594514638185501, 0.014180399477481842, 0.03165721148252487, -0.0010146736167371273, 0.022793034091591835, 0.03204895555973053, 0.006946846377104521, -0.019630175083875656, 0.013445374555885792, -0.04787500947713852, 0.001541400095447898, -0.052703857421875, -0.015457677654922009, 0.003574909409508109, -0.047653477638959885, 0.02597750723361969, -0.021285122260451317, 0.002623440930619836, -0.029407843947410583, 0.015004847198724747, -0.028395559638738632, 0.04905898869037628, 0.03133499622344971, 0.022488342598080635, 0.033091794699430466, 0.029461704194545746, 0.022141821682453156, -0.01778138242661953, -0.0274033322930336, 0.012703346088528633, 0.021179208531975746, 0.018579505383968353, 0.005600958596915007, 0.028725260868668556, 0.028500963002443314, 0.03441111370921135, 0.03812718391418457, 0.030064348131418228, -0.016419265419244766, 0.01920628920197487, -0.03747514635324478, -0.014530457556247711, -0.010587763041257858, -0.07957568019628525, 0.06719458848237991, 0.01709890179336071, 0.02859104983508587, -0.036380570381879807, -0.019596142694354057, 0.02665705978870392, -0.005465393420308828, -0.011384334415197372, -0.0015640530036762357, 0.0029453644528985023, 0.04684336856007576, -0.10423289239406586, -0.09287294000387192, -0.021009815856814384, 0.005925922654569149, -0.01446583028882742, -0.03853241726756096, -0.06473823636770248, 0.014882879331707954, -0.006830071099102497, -0.04864509031176567, -0.02168119326233864, 0.03438222408294678, 0.006378998979926109, 0.03266467899084091, 0.0582907609641552, -0.047392338514328, -0.0007560633239336312, 0.013070151209831238, -0.009025678038597107, -0.06057283282279968, 0.08382052928209305, 0.0769587978720665, -0.001226771273650229, -0.002513093641027808, 0.01688127964735031, -0.0044410862028598785, -0.0231820996850729, 0.0633993074297905, -0.023031828925013542, -0.03912542015314102, 0.07838531583547592, -0.008566509000957012, -0.014591341838240623, -0.032673195004463196, -0.011554674245417118, -0.021117258816957474, -0.029682975262403488, -0.028192363679409027, -0.028832174837589264, 0.002866649068892002, -0.019842665642499924, -0.031550467014312744, -0.02355991303920746, 0.06562032550573349, -0.015341825783252716, -0.03292734548449516, 0.013083774596452713, -0.05023837834596634, -0.01471619587391615, -0.025980399921536446, -0.02257312461733818, -0.01613517664372921, -0.04600420594215393 ]
<p>I want to know how a ceramic transparency is mostly affected by the pores, grain boundary, second phases etc. present inside of it, but the major contribution is due to the pores. </p> <p>Let's consider the glass slab with an air gap between them. It is still transparent.</p> <p>Hence: how can simple pores make ceramics opaque? I am after a theoretical description.</p>
g6624
[ 0.05431431159377098, 0.06147262826561928, 0.006259788293391466, 0.04846401512622833, 0.020054683089256287, 0.029747191816568375, 0.05911935865879059, 0.016285929828882217, -0.007453508209437132, -0.017756745219230652, 0.028195727616548538, 0.04039694741368294, 0.06278017908334732, 0.01745203137397766, 0.005561561789363623, 0.017332233488559723, 0.041292235255241394, -0.033303212374448776, 0.007827852852642536, 0.036018356680870056, -0.007362961303442717, -0.041213005781173706, 0.023124825209379196, -0.04080884903669357, -0.10789860785007477, 0.03553295508027077, 0.017393019050359726, -0.011428681202232838, 0.0536002479493618, -0.019646545872092247, 0.04970107600092888, -0.013837084174156189, 0.011032987385988235, -0.013341393321752548, 0.009165726602077484, 0.0342300646007061, -0.002566481474786997, 0.04582720622420311, 0.03115968592464924, -0.03666184842586517, 0.005466397851705551, 0.0075353761203587055, -0.003437475999817252, 0.007095338776707649, -0.05507482588291168, -0.016409171745181084, -0.02972172573208809, -0.011476846411824226, -0.01372107770293951, -0.0706162303686142, -0.02027088962495327, -0.00801403820514679, 0.004758514929562807, 0.013453037478029728, -0.045729219913482666, -0.021388232707977295, 0.019257673993706703, -0.018237462267279625, 0.0731353908777237, 0.01294973585754633, -0.029070593416690826, -0.03397168219089508, -0.004828090313822031, 0.06188053637742996, 0.02111344039440155, -0.05443518981337547, -0.08692684024572372, 0.02939716726541519, 0.06229732558131218, -0.009525311179459095, -0.0013797944411635399, 0.06951373815536499, 0.00018222037761006504, -0.0726289302110672, -0.07357747107744217, 0.0016740703722462058, -0.008476579561829567, 0.025375457480549812, 0.08163198828697205, -0.004343664739280939, 0.01976468227803707, -0.005112071521580219, -0.008715121075510979, 0.005551967304199934, 0.019296061247587204, -0.011169222183525562, 0.06171809136867523, -0.05705472081899643, -0.05227218195796013, -0.018331313505768776, -0.010746215470135212, -0.04514818638563156, -0.003137137508019805, 0.06895309686660767, 0.011826055124402046, 0.05259944126009941, -0.01810176484286785, 0.03517868369817734, -0.01936967857182026, 0.03051540069282055, 0.04863618686795235, -0.05298735201358795, 0.07389161735773087, -0.01012257020920515, -0.010269112884998322, 0.07333972305059433, 0.03765539079904556, 0.020136259496212006, -0.023656493052840233, 0.05800359696149826, -0.0022039897739887238, 0.01872345246374607, -0.053651921451091766, -0.027548357844352722, 0.03045954369008541, -0.0032148438040167093, 0.08663484454154968, -0.0026656314730644226, 0.03860241174697876, 0.01420698780566454, 0.0408683717250824, 0.0491693839430809, 0.03248602896928787, -0.04128175228834152, 0.0037009010557085276, -0.003430683398619294, 0.02335990034043789, -0.027058042585849762, 0.02884003520011902, -0.04780466854572296, 0.041291095316410065, 0.05817294865846634, 0.020194802433252335, 0.0016869611572474241, 0.03317124396562576, -0.004550715908408165, -0.012817056849598885, 0.0008257293375208974, 0.0016564639518037438, -0.05090821534395218, -0.05483752861618996, 0.007021928671747446, -0.01211707852780819, 0.012424035929143429, 0.00735974358394742, -0.0005901428521610796, 0.02076449804008007, -0.014181891456246376, 0.018964305520057678, -0.04511906951665878, 0.012163310311734676, 0.027259035035967827, 0.01328685600310564, 0.03755180537700653, 0.06820724159479141, -0.025757890194654465, 0.0515388548374176, -0.032829079777002335, 0.013771292753517628, -0.008946879766881466, 0.06216643005609512, 0.013025009073317051, -0.004694190341979265, -0.0007212578784674406, -0.11193370074033737, -0.06218552961945534, 0.012184389866888523, -0.04720151424407959, 0.006799245253205299, -0.038818079978227615, 0.020482627674937248, -0.008408579975366592, 0.06325584650039673, 0.08918330818414688, 0.0004632736381608993, 0.05481056123971939, 0.07895532995462418, 0.02686855010688305, 0.07847233861684799, 0.0497823990881443, 0.026669872924685478, -0.004141092766076326, -0.06178981438279152, -0.04114599525928497, 0.043031979352235794, -0.04179207608103752, 0.030194109305739403, -0.028219833970069885, -0.06267097592353821, 0.08136080205440521, -0.012675318866968155, -0.06540492922067642, -0.010429183021187782, 0.001325444784015417, -0.002630318282172084, -0.026683606207370758, 0.08037696033716202, -0.002356452401727438, -0.024001261219382286, -0.004115555435419083, -0.026545729488134384, 0.010606479831039906, 0.029583631083369255, 0.02963116392493248, 0.05522654950618744, 0.01371744554489851, -0.037732917815446854, 0.070072241127491, -0.037994492799043655, 0.041211020201444626, -0.07871237397193909, 0.0042859152890741825, 0.0452166311442852, 0.02171853557229042, 0.0039025458972901106, 0.02399003691971302, -0.029334133490920067, -0.002154128858819604, -0.03168824315071106, -0.05273626372218132, 0.02193949930369854, -0.023872463032603264, -0.04165618494153023, 0.00920017994940281, -0.03461509197950363, -0.022219624370336533, 0.03030397929251194, 0.04691816493868828, 0.003381092334166169, 0.050830598920583725, -0.09369730949401855, -0.02717597410082817, -0.023550070822238922, -0.025077953934669495, -0.00341858621686697, 0.01741337776184082, -0.050442807376384735, 0.014637655578553677, 0.012772401794791222, -0.02276451885700226, -0.001706314506009221, -0.08294220268726349, -0.03951273858547211, -0.005509267095476389, -0.01732262596487999, -0.046076469123363495, 0.0028362059965729713, 0.016373274847865105, -0.0033511498477309942, 0.015268007293343544, -0.01999732293188572, 0.04492427036166191, -0.02314012311398983, -0.006583344656974077, -0.04524746164679527, -0.057575877755880356, -0.03400979936122894, 0.010839915834367275, 0.003740218235179782, -0.00977799016982317, -0.01676795817911625, -0.02949978969991207, -0.003122730879113078, -0.029556771740317345, 0.016468791291117668, 0.014881056733429432, -0.009048204869031906, 0.028043944388628006, -0.02742784284055233, -0.03754528611898422, 0.023335272446274757, 0.08060035854578018, 0.056075569242239, 0.005627770442515612, 0.02607322484254837, 0.03474843502044678, 0.01454880926758051, -0.07090894877910614, -0.010970322415232658, -0.04725524038076401, -0.041350334882736206, -0.012312488630414009, -0.07425930351018906, 0.019992860034108162, 0.007703391835093498, -0.052473269402980804, 0.03873832896351814, 0.02141583524644375, 0.012340656481683254, 0.03625987470149994, -0.0032840524800121784, 0.012493814341723919, 0.010156105272471905, 0.01827443577349186, 0.00030153727857396007, -0.03410720080137253, 0.03496819734573364, -0.03698216751217842, -0.05447584018111229, 0.020688381046056747, -0.011384626850485802, -0.009307264350354671, -0.038143035024404526, 0.014178359881043434, 0.01669532246887684, 0.023259535431861877, 0.021149449050426483, -0.07868675887584686, -0.055154819041490555, -0.008317268453538418, 0.008842876181006432, -0.014003540389239788, -0.01054319366812706, 0.008705192245543003, -0.06675508618354797, 0.05820072814822197, -0.01926770620048046, 0.02270374819636345, -0.018404148519039154, 0.04458019882440567, -0.034008145332336426, 0.02783842198550701, 0.0436372309923172, -0.01699029467999935, -0.028913402929902077, -0.03102283552289009, 0.013396311551332474, -0.042410023510456085, -0.04302740469574928, -0.0008238228620029986, 0.028043121099472046, 0.020759614184498787, -0.02619142085313797, -0.051282208412885666, -0.0447206050157547, 0.011648694053292274, -0.05115007981657982, 0.004725849721580744, 0.004890096373856068, -0.02292337454855442, 0.03346451744437218, -0.029590589925646782, -0.03385147079825401, 0.012194477021694183, -0.00308606238104403, -0.03151906654238701, 0.022158917039632797, -0.014628903940320015, -0.001963152550160885, -0.020475171506404877, 0.05347280576825142, 0.010052253492176533, 0.003999111242592335, -0.054042279720306396, -0.01422575581818819, 0.047067463397979736, 0.04350324347615242, 0.03450164198875427, 0.024611657485365868, -0.013004190288484097, 0.04742289334535599, -0.03680925816297531, 0.04408465698361397, -0.052256014198064804, -0.015817051753401756, -0.0051979077979922295, 0.05286747217178345, -0.009445622563362122, 0.02288799360394478, 0.029835423454642296, -0.02688584104180336, 0.026388337835669518, -0.017559347674250603, 0.09071337431669235, 0.009789476171135902, -0.02242305874824524, -0.035770170390605927, 0.04361801967024803, 0.01684643141925335, 0.017870986834168434, 0.0007431191625073552, -0.028928332030773163, 0.023011241108179092, -0.03111918643116951, -0.003877960378304124, 0.03895217552781105, -0.004229764454066753, 0.005658586509525776, -0.048673100769519806, -0.04689447954297066, 0.01346476748585701, -0.023037418723106384, -0.05023784190416336, -0.040851328521966934, -0.001093385391868651, -0.08578712493181229, -0.03407313674688339, 0.020935973152518272, 0.002514549531042576, 0.02154732495546341, 0.016192691400647163, 0.03415890783071518, -0.025389641523361206, -0.004960514605045319, 0.024620603770017624, -0.00860469788312912, 0.008800451643764973, -0.035606395453214645, 0.020394545048475266, -0.011257682926952839, -0.010274500586092472, -0.002639945363625884, -0.005103027913719416, -0.01973043568432331, 0.053341273218393326, -0.01977473683655262, -0.010256010107696056, 0.0020533171482384205, 0.006770798936486244, 0.008767301216721535, -0.030442435294389725, 0.009593113325536251, -0.07390998303890228, 0.015220322646200657, 0.07720569521188736, 0.029179558157920837, 0.04204658418893814, -0.07977063208818436, 0.01251841988414526, 0.003042754251509905, 0.007889355532824993, 0.038228828459978104, 0.0014937204541638494, -0.006428062450140715, -0.04149151220917702, -0.008425683714449406, -0.042734190821647644, 0.00450602313503623, -0.0375724621117115, -0.014344804920256138, 0.005794416181743145, -0.025474248453974724, -0.013433624058961868, -0.0705583468079567, 0.008584124967455864, -0.0355815626680851, -0.02791747823357582, 0.006238299887627363, 0.01896769553422928, -0.0264888908714056, -0.023640576750040054, 0.009800272062420845, -0.05466284230351448, -0.018509436398744583, -0.027098050341010094, -0.0013444069772958755, -0.009607077576220036, -0.0067760394886136055, 0.0033081297297030687, -0.029043374583125114, -0.03456632047891617, 0.005658618174493313, 0.00810594204813242, 0.00883286353200674, 0.03102792240679264, -0.0328095443546772, 0.02156100980937481, 0.027965668588876724, -0.019584380090236664, -0.007666795514523983, 0.036081988364458084, 0.06389445811510086, -0.006028290838003159, 0.062368642538785934, 0.023944636806845665, -0.024935686960816383, -0.057056255638599396, 0.057691652327775955, 0.03813088312745094, 0.00441026920452714, 0.0009328193846158683, 0.04280742257833481, 0.14174410700798035, 0.030099859461188316, -0.03185899928212166, 0.04219212010502815, 0.0021288625430315733, 0.007875310257077217, -0.052577193826436996, -0.03588765114545822, 0.01112352591007948, 0.0241991076618433, -0.04424813762307167, 0.011374121531844139, -0.027154946699738503, -0.03723185881972313, 0.12394251674413681, 0.056249234825372696, -0.03166899085044861, 0.027128875255584717, -0.009215892292559147, -0.05397499352693558, 0.03400568664073944, 0.03084261529147625, 0.038356173783540726, 0.05971058830618858, 0.052628692239522934, -0.047070566564798355, 0.06119290739297867, 0.00457312585785985, -0.013192282989621162, -0.009198722429573536, -0.07195808738470078, 0.004661632236093283, 0.03498892858624458, 0.001370078301988542, -0.06537031382322311, -0.04750126600265503, 0.0025065280497074127, -0.02140994742512703, -0.0041406420059502125, 0.0023468341678380966, 0.005169485695660114, -0.012072846293449402, -0.03337743878364563, 0.017679452896118164, -0.014238073490560055, -0.055750537663698196, 0.029446255415678024, -0.038223136216402054, -0.047787148505449295, 0.014632187783718109, -0.02093888446688652, 0.00515341479331255, -0.0012779298704117537, -0.05253713205456734, -0.01139734499156475, 0.005811321549117565, 0.028511330485343933, -0.011753629893064499, -0.00923445075750351, 0.058927491307258606, 0.007362165953963995, 0.0835188627243042, 0.05714229494333267, -0.04972732812166214, 0.015734899789094925, 0.01671374775469303, 0.05152766406536102, -0.01602315343916416, 0.04354986548423767, -0.007521731313318014, 0.008846781216561794, -0.0046213543973863125, -0.00013520150969270617, 0.03882521390914917, 0.0077295247465372086, -0.03916768729686737, 0.03400947153568268, -0.028417468070983887, 0.08296194672584534, 0.051085248589515686, -0.049106892198324203, -0.022234966978430748, -0.0056241219863295555, -0.040413133800029755, 0.005331357475370169, 0.012423343025147915, 0.024164030328392982, -0.002160043455660343, 0.01756155863404274, -0.03669602796435356, -0.005777424201369286, -0.009003463201224804, -0.056393101811409, 0.07829561829566956, -0.05852202698588371, 0.013797047547996044, -0.008674840442836285, 0.011920200660824776, 0.006537472363561392, 0.027542755007743835, 0.017277231439948082, 0.07065507024526596, -0.01964263990521431, 0.02824229747056961, -0.015042698010802269, -0.02542242594063282, -0.010452658869326115, 0.028240561485290527, -0.034021344035863876, -0.041015420109033585, 0.023157186806201935, -0.06897067278623581, 0.038215089589357376, -0.0014401976950466633, -0.05008602514863014, -0.007182959001511335, 0.010218612849712372, 0.06122340261936188, -0.01665542460978031, 0.04020294174551964, -0.009076436050236225, 0.012736978009343147, -0.01978195831179619, 0.020744813606142998, 0.05151853710412979, -0.02712610922753811, 0.00025840275338850915, 0.029889976605772972, -0.016262806951999664, 0.0355105847120285, 0.003975508268922567, -0.025037679821252823, -0.0075438194908201694, -0.051762904971838, -0.05598028004169464, 0.005966904107481241, -0.008432474918663502, -0.03644110634922981, 0.017574338242411613, -0.009761163033545017, -0.0020538377575576305, -0.02298239804804325, 0.06184348464012146, -0.042092159390449524, -0.026015469804406166, 0.01327014621347189, 0.024149633944034576, 0.0006519441958516836, -0.02186417393386364, -0.04888412728905678, 0.03273337334394455, -0.044344086199998856, 0.014895247295498848, 0.03279289975762367, -0.043480489403009415, -0.017061425372958183, -0.008266797289252281, -0.08091586083173752, 0.05693547800183296, 0.006038888357579708, 0.05369805917143822, 0.11766236275434494, 0.02345575951039791, -0.03331276774406433, -0.03772642835974693, -0.018486464396119118, -0.037491898983716965, 0.009830296039581299, 0.000049066493374994025, -0.003177097300067544, -0.03626124933362007, -0.023714635521173477, -0.04313941299915314, 0.05641525983810425, -0.055186521261930466, 0.012249604798853397, 0.04534732922911644, -0.05468516796827316, 0.019477853551506996, 0.04910789802670479, -0.009520422667264938, 0.045872658491134644, 0.005473144352436066, 0.044024787843227386, 0.08785846829414368, -0.04485272988677025, 0.01604907214641571, -0.018508877605199814, 0.0240703746676445, -0.032068535685539246, -0.004000527318567038, 0.014095203951001167, -0.002241488080471754, -0.01154090091586113, -0.031915124505758286, 0.03940223902463913, 0.012226282618939877, 0.01567799039185047, -0.001412339974194765, 0.041462674736976624, 0.041080866008996964, -0.022277453914284706, 0.007934323512017727, 0.02480657771229744, 0.016859697178006172, -0.012114085257053375, -0.04066344350576401, -0.014084894210100174, -0.01446468010544777, -0.061967745423316956, 0.0017879990627989173, 0.004979781806468964, -0.03968419134616852, -0.02720469795167446, 0.04504147171974182, 0.02309824526309967, 0.01574118807911873, 0.01290860679000616, -0.022833416238427162, -0.019741902127861977, -0.019176216796040535, -0.026134369894862175, 0.03562338277697563, -0.02781253308057785, -0.02708432264626026, 0.0005584299797192216, -0.03251116722822189, -0.04422438144683838, 0.048801522701978683, 0.020967533811926842, 0.048606470227241516, -0.045274898409843445, 0.017866121605038643, -0.03366710618138313, -0.04577963054180145, -0.017661908641457558, -0.03720082715153694, 0.027696019038558006, -0.03219955414533615, -0.05586066469550133, 0.007031307555735111, -0.013566882349550724, -0.013279268518090248, 0.03739095479249954, -0.01490594632923603, -0.049446579068899155, -0.027717387303709984, 0.03961275517940521, 0.017036376520991325, 0.033558979630470276, 0.028858140110969543, 0.027056485414505005, -0.05356636643409729, 0.012233128771185875, 0.07894845306873322, -0.030063951388001442, 0.04139401763677597, 0.01982337422668934, 0.021122245118021965, -0.013269646093249321, -0.024763189256191254, -0.009332883171737194, 0.036752138286828995, 0.04073045775294304, -0.05301446467638016, -0.027413038536906242, -0.022317565977573395, 0.03517048433423042, -0.03861342743039131, -0.03574255853891373, 0.022180970758199692, -0.030783260241150856, 0.015105483122169971, -0.0695294737815857, -0.048697520047426224, 0.034174781292676926, -0.015566865913569927, -0.056338656693696976, -0.045789722353219986, 0.010229397565126419, -0.0196969173848629, 0.04952917620539665, -0.03431571647524834, -0.004645399283617735, -0.018755780532956123, -0.03824421390891075 ]
<p><strong>Edit 26/Sept/13: Fixed Typo in potential</strong></p> <p>I'm solving the following (seemingly simple) quantum-mechanical problem in <em>four spatial dimensions</em>. In natural units ($\hbar^2/2m=1$), the Schrödinger equation reads:</p> <p>$$ \Big[-\nabla^2-\frac{24 R^2}{(\mathbf{x}^2+R^2)^2}\Big]\psi(\mathbf{x})=E\,\psi(\mathbf{x})\,, $$</p> <p>where $R&gt;0$ is a parameter simultaneously characterizing the depth and range of the potential. The potential depends only on the distance away from the origin, so I can separate variables $\psi=R_{nl}(r)\,Y_l(\vec{\theta})$ and the radial equation then reads:</p> <p>$$ \Big[-\frac{\partial^2}{\partial r^2}-\frac{3}{r}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}+\frac{l(l+2)}{r^2}-\frac{24 R^2}{(r^2+R^2)^2}\Big]\,R_{nl}(r)=E_{nl}\,R_{nl}(r)\,. $$</p> <p><strong>Problem:</strong> I seem to have found an <em>s</em>-wave ($l=0$) non-scattering state with zero energy $E_{nl}=0$ that appears to be localized:</p> <p>$$R_{n,l=0}(r)=\mathcal{N}\frac{r^2-R^2}{(r^2+R^2)^2}\qquad E_{nl}=0.$$</p> <p>But, I am unable to normalize this "bound" state since the integral $\int_0^\infty dr\, r^3 |R(r)|^2$ does not converge. What is the nature of this state? Or am I just totally screwing something up?</p>
g6625
[ -0.010752318426966667, 0.017514124512672424, -0.03402714058756828, -0.020601855590939522, -0.011233652010560036, 0.06333472579717636, 0.02623194456100464, 0.0050721121951937675, -0.039858128875494, -0.03831643611192703, 0.018401460722088814, 0.0010496595641598105, -0.013125096447765827, 0.003922988194972277, -0.015229962766170502, -0.010003281757235527, 0.060626156628131866, -0.028705434873700142, 0.01517521869391203, -0.01140756905078888, -0.061378758400678635, 0.03504842147231102, -0.018805187195539474, -0.03048577532172203, 0.0006947810179553926, -0.006676953751593828, 0.027309458702802658, -0.023647909983992577, -0.012449711561203003, -0.02569158934056759, -0.015884241089224815, -0.004592359997332096, 0.05242190882563591, -0.07077359408140182, -0.000027115444027003832, 0.04468836262822151, 0.054073844105005264, 0.012133248150348663, -0.010115740820765495, -0.013754796236753464, -0.005449559073895216, -0.07144426554441452, -0.020635874941945076, -0.039132148027420044, 0.0034432760439813137, 0.016757512465119362, 0.05389706790447235, 0.023498937487602234, 0.0516587533056736, -0.0330943688750267, 0.008134516887366772, 0.041278161108493805, 0.030558515340089798, -0.039581991732120514, 0.04166247323155403, 0.0316440649330616, -0.03516533598303795, 0.035652704536914825, 0.05741479620337486, 0.016513116657733917, 0.06583718210458755, -0.0197678841650486, 0.035250354558229446, 0.04479556903243065, 0.05305052921175957, 0.016602370887994766, -0.051952093839645386, 0.01941678859293461, -0.031092505902051926, -0.03096667118370533, 0.006122729275375605, -0.07284725457429886, -0.026686344295740128, -0.03306596726179123, -0.0751240998506546, 0.016073428094387054, -0.022820724174380302, 0.02924591489136219, -0.008175584487617016, 0.01952909491956234, -0.039751578122377396, -0.020632313564419746, -0.0004093546012882143, -0.0336826927959919, 0.025178853422403336, 0.024394098669290543, 0.018979543820023537, 0.00935865007340908, 0.012065227143466473, 0.052475377917289734, -0.0030837245285511017, 0.01617743819952011, 0.039461616426706314, -0.026663556694984436, 0.07673466950654984, 0.013468904420733452, -0.02425585314631462, 0.08245770633220673, -0.005492246709764004, -0.017507974058389664, -0.026460621505975723, -0.005615462549030781, 0.044964779168367386, 0.011811108328402042, 0.021285362541675568, 0.0012178990291431546, 0.023873155936598778, 0.023506484925746918, 0.034776750952005386, -0.018402433022856712, 0.008104505017399788, -0.009663420729339123, -0.020538415759801865, -0.07089120149612427, -0.0729091539978981, 0.04022252932190895, 0.009854890406131744, -0.001419035135768354, -0.05032464116811752, 0.059060096740722656, 0.043036945164203644, 0.04284318536520004, 0.08114957809448242, 0.08707181364297867, -0.013227461837232113, 0.03811585158109665, -0.006510413717478514, 0.017690984532237053, 0.06863049417734146, 0.028895728290081024, -0.050880368798971176, 0.003958902787417173, 0.005280597135424614, -0.02171257883310318, -0.025502296164631844, 0.04140753298997879, -0.008557469584047794, -0.05642053857445717, -0.006846842356026173, 0.022913483902812004, -0.06628848612308502, -0.054973289370536804, 0.015352307818830013, 0.010087057948112488, -0.06723518669605255, -0.011617813259363174, 0.020750319585204124, -0.06787259131669998, -0.01305493526160717, -0.016717035323381424, 0.002376542892307043, 0.02098825015127659, -0.042038917541503906, -0.02119959518313408, -0.01286568958312273, 0.014783871360123158, 0.04185158386826515, 0.0031090734992176294, 0.04326638579368591, 0.009205544367432594, 0.019080638885498047, 0.050420839339494705, -0.014567142352461815, 0.0007061751093715429, -0.013314450159668922, 0.04690634459257126, 0.03419991955161095, -0.03274957835674286, 0.019051343202590942, -0.03320024907588959, 0.0008070493931882083, -0.031007466837763786, -0.006405537016689777, -0.02080036699771881, -0.05490618571639061, 0.07347480952739716, 0.02566186524927616, -0.04443875700235367, 0.008343461900949478, 0.015570355579257011, -0.04012094438076019, -0.06360626220703125, 0.016500024124979973, -0.046015236526727676, 0.011204118840396404, 0.01666419208049774, 0.0021645044907927513, 0.020481189712882042, 0.011803559958934784, -0.08791917562484741, -0.04422405734658241, 0.04977975785732269, 0.04544473811984062, -0.003575998591259122, -0.014806483872234821, 0.016800394281744957, 0.041998185217380524, -0.07623245567083359, -0.013337275944650173, 0.004829995799809694, -0.017784297466278076, 0.08319158107042313, 0.0332302488386631, 0.029336530715227127, 0.051291778683662415, -0.0033116338308900595, 0.01953194849193096, 0.02196153812110424, -0.02007989212870598, 0.01499804388731718, -0.033432140946388245, -0.05067397654056549, -0.03448385372757912, 0.0023596251849085093, 0.02952873520553112, -0.07211627066135406, 0.0225138571113348, 0.009742007590830326, -0.04307657480239868, 0.07547201961278915, -0.05731829255819321, -0.009535672143101692, 0.04625537246465683, 0.017719630151987076, 0.05742782726883888, 0.008636058308184147, -0.03133852407336235, 0.03879017010331154, -0.00313724298030138, 0.019655026495456696, -0.06114739552140236, 0.02350040338933468, 0.04096776992082596, 0.01543927751481533, 0.050232432782649994, 0.04937407001852989, -0.03022848255932331, -0.031029414385557175, -0.03094174712896347, -0.036296822130680084, 0.032746247947216034, -0.02537541091442108, -0.046700332313776016, 0.023927053436636925, 0.060418013483285904, 0.024912362918257713, -0.015727033838629723, -0.014844098128378391, -0.03229465335607529, 0.049644019454717636, 0.03826744481921196, 0.001720224041491747, -0.012078886851668358, 0.04291774705052376, -0.04313747584819794, -0.020934177562594414, 0.0018933541141450405, 0.001027901773341, -0.010668144561350346, -0.04153885319828987, -0.07589368522167206, 0.052666570991277695, 0.0564286969602108, 0.013933972455561161, -0.03598649054765701, 0.034416209906339645, -0.02247440628707409, 0.057032614946365356, -0.011162555776536465, -0.019993996247649193, 0.013205756433308125, 0.05837139114737511, 0.002668514149263501, 0.02526620775461197, 0.014521556906402111, -0.014008675701916218, -0.04410393908619881, 0.0014410382136702538, 0.05340782180428505, 0.016915909945964813, -0.03830713406205177, 0.001318586291745305, 0.03810278698801994, 0.03302935138344765, 0.014427468180656433, -0.07487960904836655, 0.035544898360967636, 0.05716049298644066, 0.006914662662893534, 0.010978295467793941, 0.017755646258592606, 0.00656924769282341, 0.028668498620390892, 0.03422147035598755, -0.029017284512519836, 0.02160067670047283, -0.005473525729030371, -0.04232477769255638, 0.04056810587644577, 0.045300211757421494, -0.004743751138448715, -0.010931145399808884, -0.02944023907184601, -0.03116772696375847, 0.002946366323158145, -0.02735547535121441, -0.0359208881855011, 0.02508178912103176, -0.017160724848508835, -0.016365785151720047, 0.02347731962800026, 0.03580653294920921, 0.010214421898126602, -0.013434232212603092, 0.003907374572008848, 0.034029170870780945, 0.002520227339118719, 0.010253850370645523, -0.028675450012087822, -0.011503375135362148, 0.0011517354287207127, -0.0618370845913887, 0.015302739106118679, 0.031018612906336784, 0.0011962641729041934, 0.029062215238809586, -0.04748281463980675, 0.005889832973480225, -0.038372837007045746, 0.014471911825239658, 0.01681753806769848, 0.006288065109401941, 0.021573850885033607, -0.03272651880979538, -0.07060965895652771, -0.058596085757017136, -0.014643783681094646, 0.007438138592988253, 0.09113272279500961, -0.00815632939338684, -0.012032605707645416, -0.07613220065832138, 0.017768707126379013, 0.005845008883625269, 0.035576120018959045, -0.008444397710263729, -0.08743482083082199, 0.054069533944129944, -0.011879142373800278, 0.056550998240709305, -0.02086765132844448, 0.009516830556094646, -0.009869086556136608, -0.007058193441480398, -0.0594063475728035, 0.07719168812036514, -0.013742544688284397, -0.0017471995670348406, -0.013995714485645294, 0.0037767565809190273, 0.015105288475751877, -0.044843483716249466, -0.0065453993156552315, -0.010800011456012726, 0.012326731346547604, 0.008845466189086437, 0.042635902762413025, 0.004679120145738125, 0.019737644121050835, -0.04272548109292984, 0.018737731501460075, -0.021200397983193398, 0.01006851065903902, 0.04994409158825874, 0.018979357555508614, -0.005025824997574091, -0.04082159325480461, -0.021048331633210182, -0.0602586604654789, 0.03654008358716965, 0.02165685035288334, 0.01091054454445839, -0.00447214487940073, 0.0026443018577992916, 0.039789021015167236, 0.028119320049881935, -0.02280104160308838, -0.03392999246716499, 0.002309688599780202, 0.024653326719999313, -0.036229707300662994, -0.045669883489608765, -0.023501060903072357, 0.07076137512922287, -0.020695360377430916, 0.014522206969559193, 0.036069147288799286, -0.044840261340141296, -0.07837893813848495, 0.06928733736276627, -0.014768957160413265, 0.005372001323848963, 0.01809021830558777, -0.03918635845184326, -0.06051388382911682, -0.07137555629014969, 0.03615555539727211, 0.04416661709547043, -0.05014093220233917, -0.00434987572953105, 0.01022059004753828, 0.00023257176508195698, -0.03283271566033363, -0.10031010955572128, 0.01922224462032318, -0.06220404803752899, 0.027409672737121582, -0.01739005371928215, -0.0657130554318428, 0.027496805414557457, 0.02916780114173889, 0.046742603182792664, 0.02279307320713997, 0.009076756425201893, 0.03846738860011101, 0.002963475650176406, -0.01348817441612482, 0.05539707839488983, 0.001229565590620041, 0.015187577344477177, -0.004249327350407839, 0.02400679513812065, -0.0070526874624192715, 0.07075345516204834, -0.02745974250137806, 0.015619209967553616, -0.08344841003417969, -0.021652832627296448, 0.007911629043519497, 0.034454625099897385, 0.0020303374622017145, 0.021419404074549675, -0.010996448807418346, 0.021581405773758888, 0.004420635290443897, 0.04507285729050636, -0.0029351150151342154, -0.010082906112074852, 0.01140751875936985, -0.01442714687436819, -0.028128404170274734, -0.0008147372282110155, 0.02895953692495823, -0.04912189021706581, 0.031854353845119476, -0.02389691397547722, -0.046171724796295166, 0.039729293435811996, 0.06902623921632767, -0.028213147073984146, 0.03130672499537468, -0.02788204699754715, -0.0528283528983593, -0.004476241301745176, 0.027735380455851555, -0.05656147748231888, -0.044521596282720566, 0.017042234539985657, -0.06492672860622406, -0.03407757356762886, 0.020699841901659966, 0.01840561255812645, 0.0597180612385273, 0.009990507736802101, -0.02861320599913597, 0.03189953789114952, -0.03882073611021042, 0.0011896839132532477, -0.0008655350538901985, -0.02216559648513794, 0.026477381587028503, -0.04946030676364899, -0.0030040929559618235, 0.0489797405898571, 0.018177039921283722, 0.07875770330429077, -0.03724316880106926, 0.005304092075675726, -0.020930083468556404, -0.003818897530436516, 0.028760546818375587, -0.011973872780799866, -0.024806447327136993, 0.003759326646104455, 0.01983586885035038, 0.011027970351278782, 0.01843985728919506, -0.015215789899230003, 0.00030872164643369615, 0.01842481642961502, -0.04909209907054901, 0.01354034524410963, 0.02724062092602253, 0.026503371074795723, -0.018918650224804878, 0.0692719966173172, 0.08434803783893585, 0.013806766830384731, 0.03190421313047409, 0.04902825877070427, -0.028473986312747, -0.03496824577450752, 0.00658848462626338, -0.04204327613115311, 0.028062548488378525, -0.08772637695074081, -0.06116364151239395, 0.07007815688848495, -0.05350847169756889, -0.010823894292116165, 0.027742084115743637, -0.014101176522672176, 0.026106109842658043, -0.03529270738363266, 0.0192143265157938, 0.008252765983343124, 0.007987537421286106, -0.019021285697817802, -0.01897546835243702, 0.03371467813849449, -0.003719168249517679, 0.009559130296111107, 0.013994570821523666, 0.008883961476385593, 0.04078829661011696, -0.014266310259699821, 0.010262800380587578, -0.01183213759213686, -0.02652612328529358, -0.017864268273115158, 0.03767872601747513, -0.0581323467195034, -0.04396890103816986, 0.042385172098875046, -0.07372228056192398, -0.014016778208315372, -0.017399534583091736, -0.059645283967256546, 0.030732491984963417, 0.011638314463198185, -0.01572229526937008, -0.05905721336603165, -0.08345210552215576, 0.007749957498162985, 0.03333975002169609, -0.02377372421324253, 0.01029106043279171, 0.0023860728833824396, -0.08212674409151077, -0.04186246171593666, 0.05504109710454941, -0.050277650356292725, 0.02333046868443489, 0.03245198354125023, 0.011759250424802303, -0.05494251102209091, -0.028381530195474625, -0.004221596289426088, 0.03612794354557991, 0.0037833251990377903, -0.05458104982972145, 0.022629033774137497, 0.006261182948946953, -0.01192803867161274, 0.03599844500422478, -0.009174658916890621, -0.02593528851866722, -0.024823036044836044, 0.01045428216457367, -0.0025992037262767553, -0.04897093400359154, 0.026069926097989082, 0.062187083065509796, -0.05130903422832489, 0.029304269701242447, 0.06409002840518951, -0.02104371041059494, -0.05712025985121727, 0.04736044257879257, 0.025071198120713234, -0.024110501632094383, 0.02747015468776226, -0.013019601814448833, 0.005935554392635822, -0.0006345315487124026, -0.060150206089019775, 0.05406038090586662, -0.018241113051772118, -0.1189364567399025, 0.009835940785706043, 0.032223351299762726, -0.01126112136989832, 0.011512056924402714, 0.016294635832309723, 0.0036375431809574366, 0.03596009314060211, -0.045351292937994, -0.020648648962378502, -0.01655391976237297, 0.06847495585680008, -0.025099806487560272, 0.023691451177001, 0.012127150781452656, 0.0038714043330401182, 0.010122867301106453, -0.08256738632917404, 0.08075519651174545, 0.025341838598251343, -0.021496573463082314, -0.0007569759036414325, 0.05826380103826523, 0.008761897683143616, 0.00395393930375576, 0.027918187901377678, 0.04612802714109421, -0.0037227740976959467, -0.05668127164244652, -0.026011254638433456, 0.05317949131131172, -0.005559240467846394, 0.020092379301786423, 0.0034151102881878614, -0.043485116213560104, 0.05782227963209152, -0.052327703684568405, -0.004898651037365198, -0.0525989830493927, 0.004854270257055759, 0.05255923420190811, -0.038206446915864944, -0.0454486645758152, -0.01869611255824566, 0.03725259751081467, -0.0588718056678772, -0.017430445179343224, -0.01677030324935913, 0.018672630190849304, 0.0014806858962401748, -0.06353630870580673, 0.042178843170404434, 0.050685349851846695, 0.021810589358210564, -0.02038159780204296, 0.017364341765642166, -0.02215171605348587, -0.003025510348379612, -0.05180077254772186, 0.01804167404770851, -0.02852855622768402, -0.04084311053156853, -0.012178709730505943, -0.03528590500354767, -0.051372770220041275, 0.012625981122255325, -0.005844384431838989, 0.056691426783800125, -0.010549123398959637, -0.07506146281957626, -0.03811006620526314, -0.06665374338626862, 0.02933003380894661, -0.0366707369685173, -0.013286557979881763, -0.002660637255758047, 0.014956473372876644, 0.024574870243668556, 0.050658777356147766, 0.022484473884105682, -0.00014967925380915403, -0.038985736668109894, 0.05714463070034981, 0.041710302233695984, -0.022933300584554672, 0.04916640743613243, -0.031309302896261215, -0.005210586823523045, -0.030700474977493286, 0.007477717939764261, 0.025982271879911423, 0.04810779541730881, 0.008497731760144234, 0.03795171156525612, -0.021238472312688828, 0.01119003165513277, 0.013356813229620457, -0.0083919707685709, 0.05061045289039612, 0.029747093096375465, 0.03670547530055046, -0.022730471566319466, -0.02671281062066555, -0.028990130871534348, 0.010412433184683323, 0.011337327770888805, 0.025857383385300636, -0.036384910345077515, -0.00832592137157917, -0.056636564433574677, 0.00683970469981432, 0.009068167768418789, -0.0007584519917145371, 0.03888930007815361, -0.0029351075645536184, 0.008581004105508327, 0.054095737636089325, 0.057533446699380875, -0.010272372514009476, 0.05776612088084221, 0.04543337970972061, -0.051698703318834305, -0.04893561080098152, 0.0359322614967823, 0.01027158834040165, -0.033133868128061295, -0.0509771965444088, -0.009078187867999077, 0.014281198382377625, -0.007832138799130917, 0.025326626375317574, 0.02567865699529648, -0.04943462088704109, -0.02269596792757511, -0.05103309452533722, -0.01408536359667778, 0.00962898787111044, -0.012035395950078964, -0.04755409434437752, 0.026779696345329285, 0.05231664702296257, -0.022457020357251167, -0.030537419021129608, -0.07716195285320282, 0.03321149945259094, -0.021772876381874084, 0.017350638285279274, -0.021406851708889008, -0.013395926915109158, 0.04722396656870842, 0.03311943635344505, -0.053381383419036865, 0.00982983224093914, -0.04038922116160393, -0.05124640837311745, 0.0601072683930397, 0.04818989709019661, -0.06580661982297897, 0.04011267423629761, -0.0214640274643898, 0.05247091129422188, 0.02334168553352356, 0.03500417619943619, -0.0468648262321949, -0.016636386513710022, 0.008378510363399982, 0.026959659531712532, -0.06510543823242188, -0.01421719416975975, 0.015840865671634674 ]
<p>I want to solve the TISE of a particle of charge $q$ and mass $m$ in a one dimensional triangular potential, with an infinitely high potential wall at $x = 0$, i.e.</p> <p>$$\hat{H}=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial x^2}+V(x),$$ with</p> <p>$$V\left(x\right)=\begin{cases}qEx&amp;{\rm if}\,x&gt;0 \\ \infty &amp;{\rm if}\,x\leq0\end{cases}$$</p> <p>For $x&gt;0$, this gives the TISE $$-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{\partial^2\Psi_n}{\partial x^2}+qEx\cdot\Psi_n = E_n\Psi_n.$$ I know that the solutions of $$\frac{d^2y}{dx^2} - xy = 0$$ are given by the Airy functions, however I don't know how I can transform the TISE to this form. I know it's possible, because I have the solution to the problem, but I don't know how I can myself come up with this, I don't see the aim which has to be reached in order for a substitution to be successful. Also, I don't know how the differential will transform under a substitution including $x$. Any help?</p> <p>The substitution used in the solution is $$u=\left(\frac{2mqE}{\hbar^2}\right)^\frac{1}{3}\left(x-\frac{E_n}{qE}\right).$$</p>
g6626
[ 0.032329119741916656, -0.016392681747674942, -0.019404783844947815, -0.028264285996556282, 0.07538879662752151, 0.02304951287806034, 0.03561263903975487, 0.01274141389876604, -0.03287163004279137, -0.018415100872516632, -0.03451380133628845, 0.019914360716938972, 0.008008955046534538, -0.007357101887464523, 0.043240007013082504, 0.009920146316289902, 0.0913306251168251, 0.049757570028305054, -0.005513088312000036, -0.008151336573064327, -0.015189502388238907, 0.005243031308054924, 0.043236926198005676, -0.03513412922620773, -0.03737379238009453, -0.0716644749045372, -0.013514426536858082, 0.05745982751250267, -0.016470035538077354, 0.03730328381061554, -0.007879475131630898, 0.008703748695552349, -0.013885864987969398, 0.04055078327655792, 0.018097708001732826, 0.023608362302184105, 0.08086781948804855, 0.005506827030330896, 0.016812553629279137, -0.007293074391782284, -0.008774037472903728, -0.051402464509010315, 0.051308773458004, 0.017834827303886414, -0.016087863594293594, -0.007137447129935026, -0.0021896513644605875, 0.024615738540887833, -0.04282355681061745, -0.0013368150684982538, 0.04412652179598808, 0.04181874915957451, 0.0016709028277546167, -0.03879484906792641, -0.019321899861097336, 0.010329230688512325, 0.0038399281911551952, -0.03522546589374542, 0.024696556851267815, 0.08183786273002625, -0.023627035319805145, -0.05539770796895027, 0.007839023135602474, 0.016411593183875084, 0.053346846252679825, -0.0027783315163105726, -0.049119673669338226, 0.027605988085269928, -0.020225895568728447, -0.034330252557992935, 0.06080348417162895, -0.03692607209086418, 0.04198165237903595, -0.010633598081767559, -0.0035486873239278793, -0.019329000264406204, 0.011707206256687641, -0.05047066509723663, 0.00037855171831324697, -0.014954516664147377, -0.032625049352645874, -0.0014785524690523744, 0.031210454180836678, -0.05061030387878418, 0.012802214361727238, -0.06554736942052841, 0.04077932983636856, -0.011784614063799381, -0.004569659475237131, -0.010872053913772106, -0.03285631164908409, 0.003346157493069768, 0.06258808076381683, 0.014446905814111233, -0.014901037327945232, -0.025739477947354317, 0.009479164145886898, 0.020206261426210403, 0.01980574242770672, -0.04181508347392082, -0.016886992380023003, -0.04030439630150795, 0.016484349966049194, 0.016835367307066917, -0.03190073370933533, 0.00842488743364811, 0.020838575437664986, -0.0012335542123764753, 0.03503437340259552, -0.013423255644738674, -0.032116226851940155, -0.015610452741384506, -0.004102468956261873, -0.05425240099430084, -0.011946510523557663, 0.014990244060754776, -0.009853151626884937, 0.020226066932082176, -0.05184409022331238, 0.06887906044721603, 0.020243769511580467, 0.006567444186657667, 0.0024269018322229385, 0.07433898001909256, 0.03405531123280525, -0.03196297585964203, -0.04929165542125702, 0.04079785197973251, 0.0014059903332963586, -0.038455430418252945, -0.01915784738957882, 0.03319542855024338, 0.030992239713668823, -0.03608253225684166, -0.010025108233094215, 0.02660336345434189, -0.02895967848598957, -0.018999813124537468, -0.011394326575100422, 0.02157149650156498, -0.02985829859972, -0.019898878410458565, 0.009686087258160114, 0.07171116024255753, -0.05123812332749367, 0.028551718220114708, -0.007299437187612057, -0.02439754456281662, -0.0639348030090332, -0.01160820759832859, -0.04420943930745125, 0.042010221630334854, 0.053903911262750626, 0.05082324147224426, 0.058803144842386246, -0.024774212390184402, 0.060646142810583115, -0.0026697907596826553, 0.05681968480348587, -0.03002479486167431, 0.0008788751438260078, -0.0013999990187585354, -0.0353325754404068, -0.019862409681081772, -0.02346237190067768, 0.0335424467921257, 0.019651338458061218, 0.012011156417429447, -0.02623416855931282, -0.09154747426509857, -0.01365608163177967, -0.008709847927093506, 0.025509925559163094, 0.054276976734399796, 0.01844853349030018, 0.020663805305957794, -0.0719204694032669, -0.02962682954967022, 0.019833270460367203, 0.024783577769994736, -0.007158542051911354, 0.009792317636311054, 0.01554166804999113, -0.014434318989515305, 0.008589377626776695, 0.016937123611569405, 0.029974717646837234, 0.055513665080070496, -0.04704571142792702, 0.020724672824144363, 0.017827948555350304, 0.006335678044706583, 0.013457860797643661, 0.020940667018294334, 0.020681561902165413, 0.02762717567384243, 0.08211354166269302, -0.0933331623673439, -0.03394797444343567, -0.01587555930018425, -0.048944924026727676, 0.0722743347287178, 0.06865521520376205, 0.013173463754355907, 0.06019913777709007, -0.007063894998282194, -0.0071909744292497635, -0.02914198860526085, -0.014390948228538036, 0.00007455365266650915, 0.006504303775727749, -0.02858126536011696, -0.01293121837079525, 0.04710717499256134, -0.009806407615542412, -0.034983184188604355, -0.043256208300590515, 0.04183927923440933, -0.00743759423494339, -0.01669882796704769, -0.01760566420853138, 0.011920939199626446, -0.021642711013555527, 0.016738375648856163, -0.014001892879605293, 0.018470939248800278, 0.027154158800840378, -0.008777297101914883, -0.03749656677246094, -0.01604524627327919, 0.011465856805443764, 0.015929579734802246, 0.02230556309223175, -0.036461155861616135, 0.022326195612549782, -0.007223712746053934, -0.038034550845623016, -0.0027817501686513424, 0.029396358877420425, -0.00833605881780386, 0.011177548207342625, -0.006630661431699991, -0.010067432187497616, -0.023102208971977234, 0.060909390449523926, 0.05282030254602432, -0.02074653096497059, 0.03255259245634079, 0.045480724424123764, 0.005820655729621649, -0.0040960488840937614, -0.04330648109316826, -0.06016049161553383, -0.02335391193628311, -0.04421733692288399, -0.03886665031313896, -0.014042140915989876, -0.017790712416172028, 0.052414990961551666, -0.04905815050005913, -0.08315169811248779, -0.002433094894513488, -0.03825846686959267, 0.011822228319942951, -0.09277967363595963, 0.02037145383656025, -0.034456875175237656, 0.033910784870386124, 0.03916701301932335, -0.005211766809225082, 0.0430128239095211, 0.04382462799549103, 0.028038617223501205, 0.024524947628378868, -0.02126537263393402, -0.06415163725614548, -0.005754910409450531, 0.028242630884051323, 0.016787555068731308, -0.021353455260396004, 0.035810425877571106, 0.018590914085507393, -0.0011555771343410015, 0.07524678856134415, 0.01861041598021984, -0.026016006246209145, 0.025661887601017952, 0.019436027854681015, 0.00850733369588852, 0.011530079878866673, -0.05619043856859207, -0.031533822417259216, 0.08158191293478012, 0.013053004629909992, -0.015114622190594673, -0.01278998889029026, 0.0009341079276055098, -0.01799634099006653, 0.0057808817364275455, -0.022895438596606255, -0.07140441983938217, 0.03256082907319069, -0.0009549235110171139, 0.03779701516032219, 0.05908266454935074, -0.02225182205438614, -0.03012934699654579, -0.03366324305534363, 0.05187540128827095, 0.029630146920681, 0.03455381467938423, 0.013512331061065197, -0.0023149859625846148, 0.02769060805439949, -0.018036823719739914, 0.029382450506091118, -0.029555518180131912, -0.039648912847042084, 0.009567737579345703, -0.00431823031976819, 0.006762154866009951, -0.008142860606312752, 0.020018136128783226, 0.018100325018167496, 0.035002149641513824, 0.006921977736055851, -0.027007706463336945, 0.03278334066271782, -0.07015024870634079, -0.007033409550786018, 0.026127811521291733, 0.03440089896321297, 0.055088385939598083, -0.05803515017032623, -0.0112153934314847, -0.0013964163372293115, 0.01698657125234604, 0.023481613025069237, 0.04264546185731888, -0.03308385610580444, -0.049295369535684586, 0.012047667987644672, -0.08268330991268158, 0.038458019495010376, -0.005478156730532646, -0.1037735790014267, -0.01780608482658863, 0.029616400599479675, 0.010080025531351566, -0.031235236674547195, -0.01773008145391941, 0.0036515069659799337, 0.004442240111529827, 0.04455898329615593, 0.015960780903697014, 0.019037675112485886, 0.0506587028503418, 0.0434880368411541, -0.03092781826853752, 0.0509367473423481, 0.0606875978410244, -0.10823449492454529, -0.017811324447393417, 0.04747893661260605, -0.007014395669102669, -0.003939816262573004, 0.003781914943829179, -0.03324520215392113, -0.011360131204128265, -0.005186757538467646, -0.015304503962397575, 0.009773483499884605, 0.009504854679107666, 0.06013474613428116, -0.004304004833102226, -0.062108878046274185, -0.04249420762062073, -0.01853792928159237, -0.006549987010657787, 0.021119866520166397, -0.00305566587485373, -0.006183025427162647, 0.005772939417511225, -0.029368244111537933, 0.08657281845808029, 0.011469087563455105, -0.04449877887964249, -0.014552636072039604, 0.017412792891263962, 0.0021631179843097925, -0.00780884176492691, -0.02455911785364151, -0.00851205550134182, 0.03247782215476036, 0.014391118660569191, -0.05990267172455788, 0.018194396048784256, -0.038843605667352676, -0.08803386241197586, -0.016611862927675247, -0.031721267849206924, -0.037685807794332504, -0.0037892155814915895, -0.033129919320344925, -0.03062357008457184, -0.016984324902296066, 0.04159132391214371, -0.06681031733751297, 0.022444672882556915, -0.035640373826026917, 0.0037930416874587536, -0.0066328346729278564, 0.04150128737092018, -0.011094366200268269, -0.053572628647089005, -0.015934087336063385, 0.02800118550658226, -0.025942794978618622, -0.017577067017555237, 0.013819209299981594, 0.003094133222475648, 0.003969772253185511, -0.04094843566417694, 0.037705279886722565, 0.044591255486011505, 0.042172424495220184, 0.05226024612784386, -0.04242745786905289, 0.016378024592995644, -0.004489087034016848, -0.0247564148157835, 0.03749103099107742, -0.012548611499369144, 0.013380835764110088, -0.016878485679626465, 0.008731584995985031, -0.034061506390571594, -0.0929676741361618, -0.004142803139984608, 0.02742840349674225, 0.05820289999246597, 0.028690902516245842, -0.03646164759993553, -0.023264912888407707, 0.012167399749159813, 0.03722177445888519, -0.012892941012978554, -0.05186938866972923, 0.05562905967235565, 0.019883334636688232, 0.0020536212250590324, 0.00132667925208807, 0.019848568364977837, -0.011823492124676704, 0.0027197329327464104, -0.008835649117827415, -0.016790274530649185, 0.004736439790576696, -0.04068990424275398, -0.04019181802868843, 0.006625399924814701, 0.00899572018533945, -0.03811732307076454, 0.0005868582520633936, 0.0421169139444828, 0.006126619875431061, -0.07538297772407532, 0.050313808023929596, -0.01885954663157463, -0.12184233218431473, -0.013577023521065712, -0.0034563406370580196, 0.01587875559926033, 0.009222469292581081, 0.031150085851550102, -0.05683625116944313, -0.024944452568888664, -0.058198679238557816, -0.011119471862912178, -0.025256814435124397, -0.01126837357878685, 0.01343838032335043, -0.015599903650581837, 0.03285088762640953, -0.025117941200733185, 0.008000095374882221, -0.04211696982383728, 0.028431493788957596, -0.025004534050822258, 0.030386080965399742, 0.0002862806722987443, 0.0820106565952301, -0.01246268954128027, -0.046321697533130646, 0.041267529129981995, 0.0021949014626443386, 0.043721165508031845, -0.003182938089594245, 0.022470081225037575, 0.05889607220888138, -0.03917204588651657, -0.06420136243104935, 0.0037226176355034113, 0.008616393432021141, 0.042277902364730835, 0.07830344140529633, 0.02102021314203739, 0.007445747498422861, -0.023654820397496223, 0.027200942859053612, -0.01793721131980419, -0.05686477571725845, 0.06670050323009491, -0.012383339926600456, 0.016740286722779274, 0.06046706438064575, -0.04199155420064926, 0.007977528497576714, -0.019950704649090767, 0.0008778165210969746, 0.08771421015262604, -0.007161399815231562, 0.026655850932002068, -0.022690296173095703, 0.04081282764673233, 0.013051468878984451, -0.014966383576393127, -0.07507006078958511, -0.07495564222335815, 0.012129900977015495, -0.019797515124082565, -0.07658258825540543, -0.04982396587729454, 0.005001815501600504, -0.032130613923072815, -0.04224161431193352, -0.015850242227315903, 0.026144105941057205, 0.0243129413574934, -0.03910191357135773, 0.027689160779118538, -0.036656349897384644, 0.023131094872951508, -0.030704297125339508, -0.06987040489912033, 0.026665709912776947, -0.06261055171489716, 0.061732176691293716, -0.012923991307616234, 0.05393250286579132, -0.013183455914258957, -0.017193343490362167, -0.044794853776693344, -0.02228633314371109, 0.08634982258081436, -0.01278337650001049, 0.03078017197549343, -0.028426378965377808, -0.007084606681019068, -0.003979780711233616, 0.05802736058831215, -0.04219900444149971, 0.05195410177111626, -0.008970499970018864, -0.06278499960899353, -0.041944652795791626, -0.010404638014733791, 0.04340621083974838, 0.05637982487678528, 0.01762956939637661, -0.012868712656199932, -0.02436210960149765, 0.048485781997442245, -0.05469406396150589, 0.035967227071523666, -0.01068444550037384, 0.0033818837255239487, -0.05356720834970474, 0.0019760497380048037, 0.024389246478676796, -0.0273195318877697, 0.04520086571574211, 0.006218673195689917, -0.024166811257600784, -0.024708615615963936, -0.00006854134699096903, 0.003085063537582755, -0.08877629786729813, -0.0015944625483825803, -0.009834486991167068, -0.025049926713109016, 0.005449036601930857, -0.028148602694272995, -0.027189848944544792, 0.028711339458823204, -0.004036999307572842, 0.04487793520092964, -0.005077909678220749, 0.0002265923540107906, 0.0784057229757309, 0.0613628588616848, -0.020658669993281364, -0.018463682383298874, 0.0623258575797081, 0.02459060400724411, -0.03234390541911125, -0.040556665509939194, 0.009272083640098572, -0.04352360591292381, 0.003041189629584551, 0.04221804812550545, -0.0043167234398424625, -0.0258809681981802, -0.07595209777355194, 0.00009513198165223002, -0.035335637629032135, 0.008420290425419807, 0.06602222472429276, 0.00914858840405941, -0.03209839016199112, 0.04607614502310753, 0.00750315934419632, 0.019828541204333305, -0.04604162275791168, 0.0669010654091835, -0.0411967970430851, 0.03747321292757988, 0.06671000272035599, 0.023680156096816063, -0.026510179042816162, 0.05677644535899162, -0.00766735477373004, -0.029093662276864052, -0.017444154247641563, -0.042737942188978195, 0.04509493336081505, 0.026238255202770233, 0.010526783764362335, 0.03544491529464722, 0.041290294378995895, -0.041295476257801056, 0.04693305119872093, -0.01624019630253315, -0.020336490124464035, -0.03949273005127907, -0.03908270224928856, 0.0009839197155088186, 0.015362673439085484, -0.06285469979047775, 0.05551193282008171, 0.06225445494055748, 0.010394570417702198, -0.048367105424404144, 0.028885547071695328, -0.03874935582280159, -0.018170258030295372, -0.012842785567045212, 0.0024990979582071304, -0.01974697783589363, -0.03780781850218773, -0.043537817895412445, -0.0034987989347428083, 0.01909123919904232, 0.01979243941605091, -0.015180881135165691, 0.08111737668514252, -0.002028184477239847, -0.037680912762880325, 0.017358342185616493, -0.07063905149698257, 0.023107530549168587, -0.00022581653320230544, -0.029558435082435608, 0.033849723637104034, 0.009026414714753628, 0.03368820622563362, 0.04316822066903114, 0.09134731441736221, -0.051554638892412186, 0.001345709664747119, 0.010260281153023243, -0.01890754885971546, -0.024926021695137024, 0.0014216238632798195, 0.007205127738416195, -0.0366823635995388, 0.003255631076171994, 0.04241438955068588, 0.015441671013832092, 0.08648991584777832, -0.04859883710741997, -0.029145462438464165, -0.006660642102360725, 0.03994132950901985, -0.013827556744217873, 0.02011445164680481, -0.0065733217634260654, 0.01582418568432331, -0.010219191201031208, 0.026494886726140976, 0.04274692386388779, -0.03165023401379585, 0.023305360227823257, -0.03453152999281883, -0.07556767016649246, -0.0176977701485157, -0.03141706809401512, 0.0011557677062228322, 0.03646905720233917, 0.012788655236363411, 0.06874721497297287, 0.05652109533548355, 0.00022321731375996023, -0.020358676090836525, 0.08300872147083282, 0.04049384966492653, -0.021739540621638298, 0.08090554177761078, 0.017589325085282326, -0.007791262120008469, -0.038474779576063156, 0.01412123627960682, -0.058234408497810364, -0.044608455151319504, 0.03379892557859421, -0.04025087133049965, -0.054076265543699265, 0.0476544164121151, -0.036170199513435364, 0.011171669699251652, -0.046829063445329666, 0.05771619826555252, 0.0055787512101233006, 0.017726436257362366, -0.005981029476970434, -0.03230870142579079, -0.019037391990423203, -0.04263892024755478, -0.02241198718547821, 0.03140052407979965, 0.010585902258753777, -0.025979699566960335, -0.003134089522063732, -0.05507499724626541, 0.002583370078355074, 0.03550391271710396, -0.00982310064136982, 0.017069639638066292, 0.01274384930729866, -0.028323203325271606, 0.012553158216178417, -0.03580830246210098, -0.0273207426071167, 0.04822733253240585, 0.021236654371023178, -0.047274377197027206, 0.020855773240327835, 0.07391592115163803, -0.007192013319581747, -0.0013153451727703214, 0.01705922558903694, -0.033099930733442307, -0.047918900847435, 0.05447753146290779, 0.004185870289802551, -0.05122022703289986, -0.005651545710861683, 0.06478749215602875 ]
<p>What I want: I have a rubber rope which is $5m$ in length when not stressed and is able to stretch about $100\%$ (to $10m$ long). I want to accelerate a constant mass horizontally, which has negligible friction. I'd like to have a function that tells me the velocity of the mass dependent on time, so for instance velocity $1 s$ after releasing it.</p> <p>What I did:​ I've done some measurements of forces of the rope when pulling it to different lengths. Of course, when pulling $0cm$ (total length $5m$) I got a force of $0N$. Here is a graph of my results.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Mok8k.png" alt="http://i.imgur.com/vtEnACQ.png"></p> <p>$x-axis$: displacement of one end of the rope</p> <p>$y-axis$: measured force</p> <p>I was also able to do a regression and found a function which describes how much force I get after I pull a given length. I name this function $F(s)$ for Force dependent on displacement. From this, it's easy to get the acceleration function, which is $a(s) = F(s)/m$ with $m = mass$ of the object I want to accelerate. But now I'm stuck. I somehow need to get $a(t)$ instead of $a(s)$, thus the acceleration by time, not by length, so I can then integrate that to get $v(t)$.</p> <p>How do I convert the dependency of the function?</p>
g6627
[ 0.07304295152425766, -0.02553195133805275, 0.004574873019009829, -0.04652923345565796, 0.00923844426870346, -0.017690487205982208, 0.04584794119000435, -0.03234972059726715, -0.043015770614147186, -0.008220959454774857, -0.021014388650655746, -0.046052832156419754, 0.024760322645306587, -0.015962211415171623, 0.05574975535273552, 0.006594739388674498, 0.07677333056926727, -0.012188301421701908, 0.00041019011405296624, -0.012721379287540913, 0.007019017823040485, -0.007741084787994623, -0.02386130765080452, -0.038159679621458054, 0.0863710343837738, -0.027119778096675873, 0.04803772643208504, 0.006032972130924463, -0.05726107954978943, 0.03000340797007084, 0.005442796740680933, -0.000011748632459784858, 0.01945149153470993, -0.01115634385496378, -0.0013649014290422201, -0.005309425760060549, 0.026987237855792046, -0.05758237838745117, 0.03725152835249901, 0.031157830730080605, -0.02160670980811119, 0.005399853456765413, 0.03033767268061638, 0.0723762959241867, 0.04375186190009117, -0.06999243795871735, -0.005132394842803478, 0.014996935613453388, -0.010982783511281013, -0.00880272127687931, -0.01607012003660202, 0.051201291382312775, -0.02407538704574108, -0.026492906734347343, -0.007788999937474728, 0.0455840565264225, 0.04268554970622063, 0.04107923060655594, -0.02205796353518963, 0.04589148983359337, -0.02247922495007515, -0.0872533768415451, 0.02845713309943676, -0.04613819718360901, 0.0642690658569336, -0.02526859939098358, -0.0061368620954453945, -0.027090447023510933, -0.04823208227753639, 0.03792978823184967, -0.006723359692841768, -0.006299167405813932, 0.03938012570142746, 0.018074525520205498, -0.040884267538785934, -0.017646487802267075, 0.025896070525050163, -0.04037756472826004, -0.04451884329319, 0.026223106309771538, 0.00515311025083065, 0.09048271924257278, 0.025330999866127968, 0.018091753125190735, -0.015847641974687576, -0.04502763971686363, -0.012336324900388718, 0.0014804970705881715, -0.006270225625485182, 0.0015656669856980443, 0.03110392577946186, 0.015145995654165745, 0.05974533036351204, 0.07315318286418915, 0.016402041539549828, -0.06909140944480896, -0.03216170519590378, 0.06485698372125626, 0.06700944155454636, 0.014748086221516132, -0.030398519709706306, -0.004771335516124964, -0.0007098644855432212, -0.02694791741669178, 0.029018856585025787, -0.012538455426692963, 0.01884285733103752, -0.0006880268338136375, -0.05144435167312622, -0.06750410795211792, 0.016125954687595367, 0.013553451746702194, -0.04704487696290016, -0.06469231098890305, -0.038513630628585815, -0.1016964465379715, -0.002599150175228715, 0.024534914642572403, -0.03794369846582413, 0.004937843419611454, -0.015425032004714012, -0.0634051114320755, 0.022651419043540955, 0.05160826817154884, -0.03882642090320587, -0.06407946348190308, -0.01623721979558468, 0.05231590196490288, 0.012697195634245872, -0.032761916518211365, 0.0453326590359211, -0.03535928949713707, 0.04328914359211922, 0.03656875342130661, -0.03468003123998642, 0.05527346208691597, -0.044016387313604355, 0.014550170861184597, -0.01583130657672882, 0.07554282993078232, -0.038990892469882965, -0.02600414678454399, -0.026251357048749924, 0.03169378265738487, -0.04118841886520386, 0.0324271135032177, -0.05008731782436371, 0.0006861492292955518, 0.02853287011384964, 0.007240195292979479, 0.017639035359025, 0.043025434017181396, -0.07150793820619583, 0.014919635839760303, 0.03238101676106453, -0.03420776128768921, 0.05368385463953018, -0.010966891422867775, -0.007597692776471376, -0.017136646434664726, 0.025328056886792183, -0.0010329346405342221, 0.009823407977819443, -0.011333567090332508, -0.06885386258363724, 0.03598242998123169, -0.007150676101446152, -0.030341070145368576, -0.004222046118229628, 0.003775753080844879, -0.01500585488975048, 0.014775899238884449, 0.03818865492939949, -0.0397406667470932, -0.025666585192084312, 0.0022532206494361162, 0.028284670785069466, 0.0030481850262731314, 0.007651893887668848, -0.0051155961118638515, 0.03449162840843201, -0.009528120048344135, 0.026324428617954254, -0.025517288595438004, -0.012945085763931274, 0.015216576866805553, 0.037154585123062134, 0.04468947649002075, -0.06861874461174011, -0.010728735476732254, 0.012024875730276108, 0.007088809739798307, -0.0255444198846817, -0.01371266320347786, -0.07413199543952942, -0.003018365940079093, -0.0031348918564617634, -0.07932116091251373, 0.027586814016103745, 0.02852623350918293, 0.011254362761974335, 0.05180716887116432, 0.03308088332414627, 0.04425148293375969, 0.04339984804391861, -0.07611559331417084, 0.01291630044579506, -0.04155445098876953, -0.00005649979357258417, -0.000018250246284878813, 0.05160576477646828, 0.03662751615047455, -0.030814075842499733, -0.015884369611740112, 0.014517570845782757, -0.03753400593996048, -0.011219128035008907, 0.05111793801188469, 0.011408847756683826, -0.005828931927680969, -0.004377031698822975, 0.01606180891394615, 0.07170127332210541, 0.014300276525318623, -0.022678274661302567, -0.027841717004776, 0.029402410611510277, -0.025677263736724854, -0.013099810108542442, -0.029977573081851006, -0.009578712284564972, 0.028839392587542534, -0.036822862923145294, 0.025716988369822502, 0.04806290566921234, 0.016625212505459785, 0.00352111435495317, 0.021929800510406494, 0.011802867986261845, 0.03510081768035889, 0.020404502749443054, -0.010178003460168839, 0.008236080408096313, -0.06808168441057205, 0.002481152070686221, -0.08769826591014862, 0.027322813868522644, 0.030735518783330917, 0.038506194949150085, -0.01247238740324974, -0.04357273876667023, 0.03595798835158348, -0.01554696075618267, 0.01016922201961279, 0.021318411454558372, -0.0015848323237150908, -0.062471903860569, 0.001288460218347609, -0.013282212428748608, -0.05003252997994423, -0.004455881658941507, 0.02336590550839901, 0.03701568767428398, 0.08046847581863403, -0.03529050573706627, 0.014806274324655533, -0.044811878353357315, -0.05807413160800934, 0.024380294606089592, -0.007893471047282219, -0.018676288425922394, 0.010060392320156097, -0.007562877144664526, -0.009259017184376717, -0.004740792326629162, -0.036276206374168396, 0.0002326253306819126, -0.002283821813762188, 0.029575685039162636, 0.00453233951702714, 0.03422186151146889, -0.004468005150556564, -0.019557679072022438, 0.05841181427240372, -0.00221074977889657, -0.02862783893942833, 0.015189369209110737, 0.012089446187019348, -0.01708398386836052, 0.003217714373022318, -0.02423446998000145, 0.05498092994093895, -0.026471422985196114, 0.00029502061079256237, 0.017590831965208054, 0.03874180093407631, -0.023130076006054878, -0.011610381305217743, 0.009628567844629288, -0.0032254871912300587, -0.04592417925596237, -0.04616524279117584, 0.016853515058755875, 0.06257139891386032, -0.020249703899025917, -0.03170613572001457, -0.02572384849190712, -0.06400774419307709, 0.024207837879657745, 0.00904412753880024, -0.016429465264081955, 0.0235276035964489, 0.04566217213869095, -0.005868222564458847, -0.045338861644268036, -0.04653758928179741, 0.03408512845635414, -0.01708635315299034, 0.0092410733923316, 0.010337921790778637, -0.02209531143307686, -0.18120454251766205, -0.00815011840313673, 0.015245199203491211, -0.02142365463078022, 0.0005802235100418329, 0.0024561549071222544, -0.019947292283177376, 0.0064318422228097916, -0.014166067354381084, -0.0035289835650473833, 0.0005903352866880596, 0.03716256842017174, -0.038280390202999115, -0.05037670210003853, -0.012720827013254166, 0.0035793969873338938, -0.0016144796973094344, -0.03824485093355179, -0.003106234362348914, -0.05919446051120758, -0.01148636918514967, -0.05102682486176491, 0.0694996640086174, -0.02606227435171604, 0.0201107170432806, -0.021021220833063126, 0.0121286790817976, 0.07093489170074463, -0.03231097757816315, -0.013313248753547668, -0.018621956929564476, 0.011105089448392391, 0.00011091689520981163, 0.03970915824174881, 0.03379131853580475, 0.09595916420221329, 0.002525798510760069, -0.06398915499448776, 0.011823857203125954, -0.000654948060400784, -0.05080647021532059, -0.009725414216518402, 0.02608778141438961, 0.0165073461830616, 0.005093742161989212, 0.026437899097800255, 0.06632232666015625, -0.01776832900941372, -0.006124850362539291, 0.003915122710168362, -0.06655704975128174, 0.033290278166532516, -0.030115406960248947, -0.019808566197752953, -0.05524759739637375, 0.05826708674430847, 0.025859326124191284, 0.0029407425317913294, 0.05770197883248329, 0.05335497483611107, 0.010830661281943321, -0.08695577085018158, 0.07510076463222504, 0.020006921142339706, 0.003651822218671441, -0.02831723727285862, 0.02580132707953453, 0.0306194219738245, 0.004997330717742443, 0.04221516475081444, -0.02980855666100979, -0.007888936437666416, -0.008288711309432983, 0.03392301872372627, -0.030800221487879753, 0.041281551122665405, 0.010060861706733704, -0.030955104157328606, 0.01444244384765625, -0.02989310584962368, 0.01316324807703495, 0.009203093126416206, 0.03450540080666542, -0.051983047276735306, 0.0339277945458889, 0.02740064077079296, -0.025389330461621284, -0.015873393043875694, 0.00924859382212162, 0.0004941425868310034, -0.051353901624679565, 0.02782421186566353, -0.008743096143007278, -0.019489720463752747, 0.00735779432579875, 0.062044087797403336, -0.024117568507790565, -0.04692412540316582, -0.030082380399107933, 0.018747078254818916, 0.03360820189118385, -0.020000508055090904, -0.012035021558403969, -0.006825741846114397, 0.03806658834218979, 0.03960192948579788, 0.013138624839484692, 0.04616531729698181, -0.005835146643221378, 0.005801078397780657, 0.0738300085067749, 0.017126398161053658, -0.018063867464661598, -0.00916585698723793, 0.03182528540492058, 0.03271208330988884, -0.017164036631584167, 0.05438057333230972, 0.03563409671187401, 0.007989028468728065, 0.06446432322263718, -0.014483463950455189, 0.040436841547489166, -0.038160745054483414, 0.023508084937930107, -0.02198963053524494, -0.04332737997174263, -0.012463408522307873, 0.0233596321195364, -0.07089401036500931, 0.0022918651811778545, -0.020902900025248528, -0.05190558359026909, 0.01944621279835701, 0.01251272577792406, -0.005493997596204281, -0.0007494104793295264, 0.031361278146505356, -0.035066790878772736, -0.04631447419524193, -0.003833262948319316, -0.07399445027112961, -0.014355186372995377, -0.00861557200551033, -0.003447751048952341, -0.022215858101844788, 0.0712525025010109, 0.03272618353366852, 0.03949391096830368, 0.021860478445887566, -0.006350172217935324, -0.007253069430589676, -0.025119634345173836, 0.02278965711593628, 0.03168781101703644, 0.011750316247344017, -0.006724115461111069, 0.06708546727895737, -0.010148100554943085, 0.01959819346666336, -0.014009447768330574, 0.004041192587465048, -0.07176952809095383, 0.010759655386209488, 0.00034968997351825237, 0.026707356795668602, -0.02159605547785759, 0.03618569299578667, 0.002200599294155836, 0.02699553593993187, 0.024577118456363678, -0.025183243677020073, -0.037850651890039444, 0.014826025813817978, 0.004322956316173077, 0.01301922369748354, -0.044202715158462524, 0.051334448158741, 0.03300022333860397, -0.06550045311450958, 0.008557385765016079, -0.012169444933533669, 0.03945619985461235, -0.029841555282473564, 0.031755801290273666, 0.04459843784570694, 0.037552230060100555, -0.03719417005777359, 0.04752971604466438, 0.02056935429573059, 0.06032847613096237, -0.006070647854357958, -0.021167347207665443, -0.051837850362062454, 0.029061920940876007, 0.019927816465497017, 0.02780098281800747, 0.003787905676290393, 0.03370320424437523, 0.053832024335861206, -0.009994208812713623, 0.053172968327999115, 0.003782837651669979, 0.04578740894794464, 0.03473087400197983, -0.00693410774692893, 0.0027288924902677536, -0.05461537837982178, -0.013258259743452072, -0.056586381047964096, -0.056631311774253845, 0.05051513388752937, -0.044157419353723526, -0.007580899633467197, -0.01431252807378769, 0.0496736578643322, -0.0004915018216706812, -0.01479413639754057, -0.06311967223882675, -0.013891800306737423, -0.026707323268055916, 0.021794667467474937, -0.026010582223534584, -0.0692233145236969, 0.03635093942284584, 0.014902947470545769, -0.01589827984571457, 0.0011434719199314713, -0.035203807055950165, -0.014827102422714233, 0.015931494534015656, 0.0048559014685451984, -0.04644598811864853, -0.040539707988500595, 0.03529100492596626, 0.014354594983160496, 0.0004449401458259672, -0.01983964443206787, 0.027038630098104477, 0.016503334045410156, -0.041191089898347855, 0.025280745700001717, 0.01670149713754654, -0.01823035441339016, -0.05117879807949066, 0.049808599054813385, 0.026425974443554878, 0.009801646694540977, 0.00016678286192473024, -0.01833239570260048, 0.012161321938037872, -0.022248703986406326, 0.015428291633725166, -0.008324963971972466, 0.017400091513991356, -0.02220672369003296, -0.03855372965335846, -0.01040674652904272, 0.022034920752048492, -0.029508057981729507, -0.0800616592168808, -0.00975821539759636, -0.022631647065281868, -0.057479195296764374, -0.03111334703862667, -0.00016046359087340534, -0.06072745472192764, -0.014379085041582584, -0.0033685103990137577, -0.06629116833209991, 0.020793665200471878, -0.02458280883729458, -0.029252737760543823, -0.014201203361153603, -0.056346382945775986, -0.010537593625485897, -0.03299686312675476, 0.03468696400523186, 0.03158973902463913, 0.028748681768774986, 0.007847229018807411, 0.08330533653497696, -0.052516646683216095, -0.005978004541248083, -0.033565688878297806, -0.01755889505147934, -0.009341168217360973, 0.05791003629565239, -0.0644046738743782, -0.058429304510354996, -0.015738673508167267, 0.01736629754304886, 0.015936624258756638, 0.007587846834212542, 0.03951718658208847, 0.0034833902027457952, 0.001414537662640214, 0.02199893817305565, -0.015807662159204483, -0.006134609691798687, 0.02765814960002899, -0.0070632766000926495, -0.019463324919342995, 0.03165537863969803, -0.0022799929138273, -0.035076893866062164, 0.010865160264074802, 0.04182397574186325, -0.07767410576343536, 0.0018954755505546927, 0.03272193297743797, -0.036200739443302155, 0.011732551269233227, -0.025835607200860977, 0.11670134961605072, 0.0183760654181242, 0.07267610728740692, 0.044644806534051895, 0.04420635476708412, 0.0005232789553701878, 0.0011057087685912848, -0.03878815099596977, 0.06295769661664963, -0.06552045047283173, -0.0315164215862751, 0.024491045624017715, 0.019218718633055687, -0.04982609674334526, 0.07765673846006393, 0.024096375331282616, -0.03450430557131767, -0.016534434631466866, 0.009716803207993507, -0.013132728636264801, 0.031089870259165764, 0.04016954079270363, 0.008232214488089085, 0.061373092234134674, 0.0029471702873706818, -0.057090405374765396, -0.08863063156604767, 0.01009880006313324, 0.036049652844667435, -0.0021604590583592653, 0.05853942781686783, 0.00007153861952247098, -0.02192828617990017, 0.042785100638866425, -0.025557780638337135, 0.017037011682987213, -0.012271489016711712, 0.0033884288277477026, 0.06397343426942825, 0.006829855497926474, 0.021229587495326996, -0.018569480627775192, -0.014796009287238121, -0.05694829300045967, 0.05199476331472397, -0.05959063023328781, 0.028547771275043488, 0.01897222362458706, -0.025213496759533882, -0.03276917338371277, 0.010598248802125454, -0.017510835081338882, -0.003816624404862523, 0.05582636594772339, -0.018559858202934265, -0.13898234069347382, 0.06483061611652374, 0.052533116191625595, -0.012134760618209839, 0.023001356050372124, -0.03732212260365486, 0.0036449905019253492, 0.007880471646785736, 0.025014681741595268, 0.017814606428146362, 0.047455668449401855, -0.034224655479192734, -0.010131261311471462, -0.02829601615667343, -0.034450713545084, 0.03692126274108887, -0.06613854318857193, -0.0336402952671051, 0.0021922090090811253, 0.019456781446933746, -0.02803025208413601, 0.02054472267627716, -0.05690578743815422, -0.02868514508008957, 0.029762910678982735, 0.038966815918684006, -0.009705323725938797, 0.008251244202256203, 0.026780782267451286, -0.041985832154750824, -0.011943813413381577, -0.0007360469899140298, 0.02098659612238407, -0.058380790054798126, 0.020969687029719353, -0.034434184432029724, -0.05935797467827797, -0.03655117005109787, -0.0528879351913929, -0.028621407225728035, 0.015943635255098343, -0.002407096093520522, 0.03805992379784584, -0.0005419908557087183, 0.022281119599938393, -0.01630932278931141, 0.004099026322364807, 0.060508452355861664, -0.04687601327896118, 0.04235398396849632, -0.052753422409296036, -0.01746995933353901, -0.08805818855762482, 0.05929436534643173, 0.05177148059010506, -0.01698070950806141, -0.013970466330647469, 0.07549627125263214, 0.03940229490399361, -0.010000371374189854, 0.05266435444355011, -0.004268244374543428, -0.04260031878948212, 0.020285215228796005, -0.021976668387651443, -0.034068260341882706, -0.041085872799158096, 0.05041198432445526, 0.0204205010086298, 0.0099317766726017, -0.011921991594135761, 0.03785916045308113, -0.048849917948246, 0.009138405323028564, -0.0027911837678402662, -0.025393541902303696, 0.002537332009524107, 0.05846516788005829 ]
<p>In light-front QFT, in the Minkowski space, we define a hypersurface, $\Sigma_+ : x^3+ x^0 = 0 $. How can I write its parametric equations? </p>
g6628
[ 0.00806262344121933, -0.01589895412325859, -0.02936309389770031, -0.030348332598805428, 0.024173492565751076, -0.020021839067339897, 0.06079036369919777, -0.009500006213784218, 0.008456787094473839, -0.07309563457965851, -0.043167151510715485, 0.004318608902394772, 0.020661378279328346, 0.006655420642346144, -0.045737430453300476, 0.014691151678562164, 0.07948463410139084, 0.0031997046899050474, 0.0386078841984272, -0.029024695977568626, 0.0011926452862098813, -0.0030711041763424873, 0.04027474299073219, -0.0020001279190182686, 0.048532307147979736, 0.006398413795977831, 0.0118158720433712, -0.032848816365003586, 0.013695350848138332, -0.023154059424996376, 0.038001567125320435, 0.06302759051322937, -0.024068307131528854, 0.024502675980329514, 0.05934722721576691, -0.01943671517074108, 0.02321837842464447, -0.0019219688838347793, 0.02393033728003502, -0.032672490924596786, -0.006953781004995108, -0.018024535849690437, 0.03333752974867821, 0.019043752923607826, 0.05358131602406502, -0.030519772320985794, -0.026251984760165215, 0.04068991541862488, 0.006165241822600365, 0.011151614598929882, 0.0668507069349289, 0.0993892028927803, 0.034483663737773895, -0.05089612677693367, -0.0011110245250165462, 0.04039155691862106, 0.048680998384952545, -0.06601276248693466, 0.06782619655132294, 0.026148362085223198, -0.05079007148742676, -0.0689716637134552, -0.00898022297769785, -0.0025673636700958014, 0.07114971429109573, 0.001299165771342814, 0.0006181494682095945, -0.04017869383096695, -0.07337283343076706, 0.04194657504558563, -0.00717553123831749, 0.046746306121349335, 0.03325660899281502, -0.019779585301876068, -0.052860718220472336, 0.009340247139334679, 0.0027338259387761354, 0.03419894725084305, 0.03122968040406704, -0.005509879440069199, -0.029420940205454826, 0.01557855773717165, 0.018361445516347885, 0.0031526689417660236, -0.006730864755809307, -0.020274246111512184, 0.042637232691049576, -0.025495586916804314, -0.0015897653065621853, -0.0561913326382637, 0.0011188380885869265, 0.05609511956572533, -0.011068519204854965, -0.021943220868706703, -0.00111811060924083, -0.011206884868443012, 0.03091346099972725, 0.00515708839520812, -0.07402531057596207, -0.026354679837822914, -0.020222632214426994, 0.027059778571128845, 0.027805961668491364, -0.0302924532443285, -0.017917290329933167, -0.032339729368686676, 0.022984791547060013, 0.06580476462841034, 0.02841864712536335, -0.01001499779522419, -0.04264688119292259, 0.03520844876766205, -0.02591703087091446, -0.04694078117609024, -0.005939477123320103, -0.010808492079377174, 0.004607573617249727, -0.039608657360076904, 0.005630129482597113, 0.07409808784723282, -0.030628537759184837, -0.006794993299990892, 0.026746591553092003, 0.05269154533743858, 0.00030146545032039285, 0.020031694322824478, -0.03505752235651016, 0.04200844466686249, 0.05033478885889053, 0.03320372477173805, 0.08539722859859467, -0.030230209231376648, 0.0032124014105647802, 0.022939695045351982, -0.015433700755238533, 0.06330537796020508, -0.029175495728850365, -0.010499680414795876, -0.004220239352434874, 0.0502864308655262, -0.0339764766395092, -0.02265150286257267, -0.0006554558640345931, -0.01516543235629797, 0.031456541270017624, -0.05521775782108307, 0.0153169771656394, -0.049042485654354095, -0.013294062577188015, 0.003161570057272911, -0.006178415846079588, 0.09688982367515564, -0.0007205678266473114, 0.03633493930101395, -0.015037083998322487, -0.036150459200143814, 0.027846919372677803, -0.024191049858927727, -0.058692000806331635, -0.047221533954143524, 0.05273684486746788, 0.046116773039102554, 0.011902534402906895, -0.010462755337357521, -0.04320274293422699, -0.03628654405474663, -0.03399696201086044, -0.016774194315075874, 0.007819379679858685, -0.07688174396753311, -0.0372958667576313, 0.024024270474910736, 0.04560646787285805, 0.031028099358081818, -0.017513079568743706, 0.04412788525223732, -0.0013790070079267025, 0.019772984087467194, 0.011651943437755108, 0.042629435658454895, -0.05107331648468971, -0.03699761629104614, 0.04042118415236473, -0.031105026602745056, -0.03678940609097481, 0.006827035918831825, -0.016612863168120384, 0.031460732221603394, -0.07205729931592941, 0.037556182593107224, 0.010273397900164127, 0.05472761020064354, 0.04842299222946167, -0.0163620263338089, 0.05145099014043808, 0.04723072797060013, 0.009931040927767754, -0.05767953768372536, 0.047633152455091476, 0.03304436430335045, -0.05622035637497902, 0.032801736146211624, 0.0361456498503685, -0.004346822388470173, 0.024139070883393288, 0.0020840081851929426, -0.009282559156417847, 0.010068976320326328, 0.015771053731441498, 0.020652536302804947, -0.029898228123784065, -0.04098731651902199, -0.012884312309324741, -0.0036437103990465403, -0.04284775257110596, -0.004397585988044739, -0.006729993969202042, -0.03162249177694321, -0.04013967514038086, 0.0602714829146862, -0.02720719203352928, -0.01661154069006443, 0.015561162494122982, -0.0081136804074049, -0.017287665978074074, -0.0017818959895521402, -0.006264058873057365, -0.007128152996301651, 0.04889870434999466, 0.016238732263445854, -0.04898614436388016, -0.055017270147800446, 0.015828294679522514, 0.05375489965081215, 0.010071353055536747, -0.0385872982442379, -0.00019011822587344795, 0.022996576502919197, 0.03854161873459816, 0.08746128529310226, 0.01606840081512928, 0.03173767775297165, -0.00311835203319788, 0.020512692630290985, -0.03911826014518738, -0.020553333684802055, -0.047533467411994934, -0.012087422423064709, -0.016138100996613503, 0.03020372800529003, 0.05033965781331062, -0.0368727445602417, 0.023911070078611374, -0.001439619460143149, -0.012907280586659908, -0.0471634604036808, -0.004510433878749609, -0.036011721938848495, -0.106822669506073, -0.021044597029685974, 0.03003869578242302, 0.057186271995306015, -0.057535938918590546, -0.05108899623155594, -0.027748582884669304, 0.009894625283777714, 0.007485512178391218, 0.004479957744479179, -0.0031808356288820505, 0.06426872313022614, 0.026900803670287132, 0.04264814034104347, 0.013794055208563805, 0.06030117720365524, -0.03224354609847069, -0.04297482594847679, 0.005124712362885475, -0.037002917379140854, 0.012895029038190842, -0.007590718101710081, 0.0076059759594500065, -0.03722278028726578, -0.02998124249279499, 0.013274392113089561, 0.018087996169924736, -0.07428694516420364, 0.033012691885232925, 0.06204952299594879, 0.037922680377960205, -0.012861199676990509, 0.005928080528974533, 0.06220832094550133, 0.0039038704708218575, 0.01087124366313219, -0.058608584105968475, 0.015532056801021099, -0.01519683189690113, -0.043299611657857895, 0.017510103061795235, 0.05395817384123802, -0.0022228574380278587, -0.0043482608161866665, 0.04516826570034027, -0.0006505396449938416, -0.04029753804206848, -0.04203571006655693, -0.0158891249448061, -0.06964155286550522, 0.025409040972590446, 0.052162982523441315, -0.026094874367117882, -0.0029853263404220343, -0.04256206005811691, -0.017164601013064384, 0.00034186741686426103, 0.02393966354429722, 0.022397596389055252, -0.057724595069885254, 0.010777747258543968, -0.02874191850423813, -0.04078512638807297, -0.04123924672603607, -0.009047252126038074, 0.006386909168213606, -0.007424251642078161, -0.021137019619345665, 0.027217227965593338, 0.05568096041679382, -0.003947297111153603, 0.017021600157022476, 0.040126603096723557, 0.02639150433242321, 0.015421302057802677, -0.015624462626874447, 0.07398080080747604, 0.08446262776851654, 0.022484809160232544, 0.025712642818689346, 0.018531832844018936, -0.05044462904334068, -0.017860224470496178, -0.017316732555627823, -0.06487409770488739, -0.0035511262249201536, -0.020890789106488228, -0.06642251461744308, 0.03413153439760208, 0.017514867708086967, 0.0012077316641807556, 0.028453636914491653, -0.0455826111137867, 0.03184328228235245, -0.018624693155288696, -0.05830657109618187, 0.025912510231137276, 0.02822628803551197, 0.00973169319331646, 0.009220000356435776, 0.05993134155869484, -0.029812095686793327, 0.005788230337202549, -0.06842014938592911, -0.01255231723189354, 0.005180467385798693, 0.01784248650074005, -0.05795075371861458, 0.016668379306793213, 0.005238477140665054, -0.04895058646798134, 0.02324651926755905, 0.07519596070051193, 0.0007103159441612661, 0.054793622344732285, 0.03176112100481987, -0.06208363547921181, -0.10811875760555267, -0.03050816059112549, -0.082688108086586, -0.03446933627128601, -0.004321087151765823, 0.0516677126288414, 0.03459634259343147, 0.00894508883357048, -0.0016778492135927081, 0.024341801181435585, 0.058132488280534744, -0.06465666741132736, -0.04394398629665375, 0.08305880427360535, 0.034508176147937775, -0.022077323868870735, 0.03484170883893967, -0.07032587379217148, -0.04388072341680527, -0.027091780677437782, -0.017093785107135773, 0.052057813853025436, -0.06902702897787094, -0.06232745200395584, 0.03277188912034035, 0.022679785266518593, 0.038976479321718216, 0.07077671587467194, 0.015529602766036987, -0.039297327399253845, -0.0949254184961319, -0.03882676735520363, -0.04924767091870308, -0.008844807744026184, 0.0015468396013602614, 0.05232110619544983, -0.011418106965720654, 0.03446699678897858, -0.03298176825046539, 0.03439752012491226, 0.019791841506958008, 0.021398140117526054, -0.024414245039224625, -0.011043279431760311, -0.049960099160671234, 0.03421904519200325, 0.02437702566385269, -0.0055367592722177505, -0.017105506733059883, 0.05634644627571106, 0.006928696762770414, 0.07485820353031158, -0.043233152478933334, -0.0021116079296916723, -0.014685030095279217, 0.008747304789721966, 0.020483290776610374, 0.027869289740920067, 0.09709015488624573, 0.012460571713745594, -0.014924773015081882, -0.07439552247524261, -0.020293351262807846, -0.008396477438509464, 0.022676818072795868, 0.0007785050547681749, 0.026122132316231728, 0.02914770320057869, -0.06061593070626259, -0.017112119123339653, 0.02715013548731804, 0.02844097651541233, -0.04931142181158066, 0.016334302723407745, -0.011460569687187672, -0.00016392483667004853, 0.012385661713778973, -0.03852067515254021, -0.0015886790351942182, -0.014693853445351124, 0.0477270632982254, -0.07230746746063232, -0.013251163065433502, 0.08181741833686829, -0.020762771368026733, 0.00032428017584607005, -0.06717357039451599, 0.07215180993080139, 0.005648770369589329, 0.04552750289440155, 0.006471122149378061, -0.11215119808912277, 0.02858976274728775, -0.01983823999762535, 0.004071212839335203, 0.04790692776441574, 0.018769660964608192, -0.0026270542293787003, -0.03660590946674347, -0.08040619641542435, 0.042157020419836044, 0.01368745043873787, -0.0022340393625199795, -0.04735832288861275, -0.022293314337730408, 0.03229924291372299, 0.044713012874126434, -0.011935173533856869, -0.03339782729744911, -0.0007500117644667625, -0.00922383926808834, -0.009140641428530216, -0.017704756930470467, -0.0045621455647051334, -0.04372905567288399, -0.0354391373693943, 0.04839135706424713, -0.017088379710912704, 0.02762329764664173, -0.018033131957054138, 0.03417111933231354, 0.0368986576795578, 0.014124879613518715, 0.021799927577376366, 0.019639519974589348, -0.03079627826809883, 0.034054696559906006, 0.08064405620098114, -0.014686175622045994, 0.012135614641010761, 0.020156370475888252, -0.002985498635098338, 0.010116745717823505, 0.014774217270314693, 0.05660475417971611, 0.045823488384485245, -0.009617315605282784, 0.012255295179784298, -0.001364204566925764, 0.012951396405696869, 0.022952266037464142, -0.002577138366177678, -0.026153117418289185, -0.015621255151927471, -0.026064597070217133, 0.049362678080797195, -0.0034159848000854254, -0.018553411588072777, 0.016343824565410614, 0.05359730124473572, 0.04230199009180069, -0.057639818638563156, -0.10262582451105118, -0.0030440993141382933, 0.02047639526426792, -0.037909675389528275, 0.02506462298333645, 0.037437766790390015, -0.018147233873605728, 0.06411635130643845, -0.0006734902272000909, 0.03281662240624428, 0.037634529173374176, -0.004829321522265673, 0.0008913038764148951, -0.06163204088807106, -0.034215107560157776, 0.006138464901596308, 0.0635472983121872, -0.0011027350556105375, 0.005834190174937248, -0.023364229127764702, 0.06372560560703278, -0.004473322536796331, -0.04828547313809395, 0.014750339090824127, 0.0132112642750144, -0.00789481122046709, 0.004959161393344402, 0.012712976895272732, 0.0045594885013997555, -0.026577632874250412, -0.06654960662126541, -0.018391968682408333, -0.06260069459676743, 0.00911040510982275, -0.06939514726400375, 0.016750013455748558, -0.046062957495450974, -0.036523547023534775, -0.04509812593460083, -0.014548278413712978, -0.0239349864423275, 0.01512649655342102, -0.05731578916311264, -0.037504978477954865, -0.006830642465502024, -0.016841068863868713, 0.014054808765649796, -0.004416583105921745, 0.04511597380042076, 0.033790212124586105, -0.015655599534511566, -0.02261558175086975, 0.028815442696213722, -0.04735390841960907, 0.04510548338294029, -0.04243464395403862, -0.044385623186826706, -0.021885734051465988, 0.02222190797328949, 0.014112328179180622, -0.001803751103579998, 0.016811290755867958, -0.005719625391066074, -0.009101798757910728, 0.016366569325327873, -0.05055714398622513, -0.010622922331094742, 0.03275328874588013, 0.04188816249370575, 0.04206434637308121, 0.05113593116402626, -0.026534579694271088, -0.04234962910413742, -0.027021462097764015, -0.0038567266892641783, -0.02466275542974472, -0.026969315484166145, 0.07231344282627106, -0.020501427352428436, -0.01947505958378315, 0.005354136694222689, 0.02615002542734146, -0.03622324392199516, -0.003590924432501197, 0.020705796778202057, -0.017784956842660904, 0.03483276441693306, -0.010434995405375957, -0.01602366752922535, 0.03291471302509308, 0.03834180161356926, 0.017385907471179962, -0.050104059278964996, 0.024137435480952263, -0.01719793677330017, 0.029045619070529938, -0.023002667352557182, 0.01625124365091324, 0.022875389084219933, -0.008599812164902687, 0.022876325994729996, -0.017435206100344658, 0.0026742529589682817, 0.04494982212781906, -0.02709389291703701, -0.05207474157214165, -0.015047550201416016, -0.00039461199776269495, -0.02376856468617916, -0.005625483114272356, -0.00802688393741846, -0.004111570306122303, 0.04766480252146721, 0.01876787282526493, 0.07267875969409943, 0.030244130641222, -0.06801387667655945, -0.013623080216348171, -0.03579016402363777, 0.011812962591648102, -0.01416870392858982, -0.04538107290863991, -0.001515703508630395, 0.03688156232237816, -0.017969926819205284, -0.012914026156067848, 0.00824452843517065, -0.00034235461498610675, 0.044266022741794586, -0.01624496467411518, -0.023347128182649612, -0.025752156972885132, -0.05377866327762604, 0.021798748522996902, 0.019450560212135315, 0.006885741371661425, -0.0060426052659749985, -0.011363758705556393, 0.019353609532117844, 0.03215555474162102, 0.006342180538922548, 0.017063939943909645, 0.02446931041777134, -0.04874884709715843, -0.03478488698601723, 0.00036086104228161275, 0.07340483367443085, -0.015626920387148857, 0.006779080722481012, -0.02110418863594532, 0.12604370713233948, 0.010613544844090939, -0.021915411576628685, 0.012002915143966675, 0.005309866741299629, -0.0641796737909317, -0.0625917837023735, 0.01708034798502922, -0.03174728900194168, 0.010457595810294151, -0.0011871680617332458, 0.016584821045398712, 0.027912957593798637, 0.01675304025411606, 0.0008522638236172497, -0.017303774133324623, -0.038657572120428085, -0.0014485581777989864, 0.03141096234321594, -0.023439927026629448, 0.03798118606209755, -0.009545991197228432, -0.0026233443059027195, -0.017515283077955246, -0.033412788063287735, -0.0008679099264554679, -0.006509173195809126, 0.0008466439903713763, -0.022518273442983627, -0.02137473039329052, -0.0195666141808033, -0.043199725449085236, 0.001563415164127946, 0.03483377769589424, 0.02746577374637127, -0.010976514779031277, 0.00568312918767333, 0.07382592558860779, -0.025876732543110847, -0.038281455636024475, 0.01961815170943737, -0.0039046392776072025, -0.037789035588502884, 0.00491344602778554, 0.024111319333314896, -0.03171321004629135, -0.09588494896888733, -0.006275085732340813, -0.00923324003815651, -0.03550112247467041, -0.03758476674556732, 0.02642347663640976, 0.050402261316776276, 0.011863292194902897, -0.009312854148447514, -0.021202532574534416, 0.043560322374105453, 0.01084089931100607, 0.033272385597229004, -0.055263400077819824, -0.019571008160710335, 0.06991551071405411, 0.04008406400680542, -0.04610472917556763, -0.0740351602435112, -0.002301363041624427, -0.0200545284897089, 0.07050713896751404, -0.017465269193053246, 0.03496449813246727, -0.008421591483056545, 0.021887673065066338, -0.024516796693205833, 0.02150237001478672, 0.016567254438996315, -0.02716444805264473, 0.03223973512649536, -0.011734655126929283, -0.0027674150187522173, 0.01715359091758728, -0.018810534849762917, 0.017510881647467613, -0.05338887497782707, -0.016475925222039223, -0.03966163471341133, 0.01956961862742901, 0.027716293931007385, -0.042539916932582855, -0.05246580019593239, -0.00860625971108675, -0.002647851826623082 ]
<p>How much energy is derived from the full process from hydrogen-1 fused into helium-4? Including all the sub-reactions (H1 into Deuterium, etc).</p>
g6629
[ 0.017369426786899567, 0.008456752635538578, 0.0036709634587168694, 0.009727937169373035, -0.04710770398378372, -0.02370184287428856, 0.00773618184030056, 0.14033234119415283, -0.036421287804841995, -0.05493008717894554, -0.0384180061519146, -0.013021741062402725, -0.03697224706411362, 0.02762019634246826, 0.01074194721877575, -0.019634034484624863, 0.007877997122704983, -0.03886905685067177, -0.045973461121320724, 0.040199942886829376, -0.04473291337490082, -0.023908067494630814, -0.046432774513959885, -0.01972433738410473, 0.018827591091394424, -0.040309131145477295, 0.006742250174283981, -0.044869937002658844, -0.0689464583992958, -0.042667634785175323, -0.029804032295942307, 0.012057559564709663, 0.0901976227760315, -0.02868657559156418, -0.05352618917822838, 0.035619866102933884, 0.038095466792583466, -0.05362798273563385, 0.04391331225633621, -0.03173883259296417, -0.028500871732831, 0.014974774792790413, -0.02173120528459549, 0.03202071413397789, -0.019211435690522194, 0.013781149871647358, 0.03359666466712952, -0.015162854455411434, -0.0007408857927657664, 0.019093558192253113, 0.025941910222172737, 0.057703256607055664, -0.01965772733092308, 0.007418008986860514, 0.02452908828854561, 0.03395663946866989, -0.012611497193574905, -0.0133829889819026, 0.04876689985394478, 0.04328031837940216, 0.02240077219903469, -0.026738345623016357, 0.031550467014312744, 0.02838079072535038, 0.07798407226800919, -0.0056827133521437645, 0.026206351816654205, 0.0003050594823434949, 0.03206838667392731, 0.031750425696372986, 0.002287744777277112, -0.004848142620176077, 0.013952058739960194, 0.07647121697664261, -0.05455414205789566, -0.031950950622558594, 0.06041957065463066, -0.015614709816873074, -0.02214186079800129, 0.005847469437867403, 0.017570096999406815, 0.0067055136896669865, 0.021408744156360626, 0.011028781533241272, 0.05204027146100998, -0.021804388612508774, -0.0342618003487587, 0.0007740061264485121, -0.08993788808584213, 0.0006905037444084883, 0.015317501500248909, 0.05438302084803581, -0.002919647376984358, -0.051861826330423355, -0.02691354788839817, 0.002227444900199771, -0.025166189298033714, 0.01811269298195839, 0.010870244354009628, -0.05931098386645317, 0.015999330207705498, -0.03042360208928585, 0.035920124500989914, -0.0677461177110672, 0.021492788568139076, 0.022508280351758003, -0.00911009032279253, -0.054656170308589935, 0.023119846358895302, 0.026084866374731064, 0.022168627008795738, 0.006111700087785721, -0.06006647273898125, -0.00563359959051013, 0.00019248233002144843, 0.01274261437356472, 0.01587195321917534, -0.0009887446649372578, -0.032491087913513184, 0.02312290482223034, 0.0718354880809784, 0.031249912455677986, 0.009075077250599861, -0.01055523008108139, -0.049087490886449814, -0.020867057144641876, -0.08773493021726608, 0.05890003964304924, -0.02322487346827984, -0.021286850795149803, -0.009863856248557568, -0.06637495011091232, 0.020883655175566673, -0.021643536165356636, 0.05156448483467102, 0.02049037627875805, 0.005864802747964859, 0.02091362327337265, -0.01942252740263939, -0.01822672411799431, 0.020332837477326393, -0.0009154019644483924, -0.007810573559254408, -0.02930467016994953, -0.03218616545200348, 0.010332486592233181, -0.02056238241493702, 0.005742474924772978, -0.028609195724129677, 0.03862978518009186, -0.022863775491714478, -0.0380646251142025, 0.053889766335487366, -0.012744511477649212, -0.0012940367450937629, 0.015215456485748291, 0.04514559730887413, -0.05421283096075058, -0.013975010253489017, 0.0663989931344986, -0.006403232924640179, 0.004404224921017885, 0.04407934471964836, -0.03297307714819908, 0.02660330943763256, -0.0033855868969112635, 0.002660186728462577, -0.04899593070149422, 0.01775524951517582, -0.028321539983153343, 0.005876678973436356, -0.027394209057092667, 0.03665606677532196, -0.017799029126763344, -0.05635921284556389, 0.024709494784474373, 0.07453672587871552, -0.041617754846811295, -0.043421708047389984, 0.029058480635285378, 0.06906270235776901, -0.025663169100880623, 0.04580581560730934, 0.006098111625760794, 0.032948195934295654, 0.01672511361539364, 0.008417429402470589, -0.011644423007965088, -0.028440624475479126, 0.013078773394227028, 0.009924737736582756, 0.023078439757227898, 0.0061279600486159325, -0.033602502197027206, 0.015326841734349728, -0.012032154947519302, -0.007975299842655659, -0.028538933023810387, -0.01924070715904236, 0.004584530834108591, -0.017083358019590378, 0.0006345512811094522, 0.018000712618231773, 0.008648157119750977, 0.0734730139374733, 0.014996838755905628, 0.03473776951432228, 0.013494743034243584, 0.01865307427942753, -0.002527476055547595, -0.06328122317790985, 0.024159740656614304, -0.004950712434947491, -0.023698927834630013, 0.024280168116092682, -0.011072231456637383, 0.01854821667075157, 0.011819504201412201, 0.02193645015358925, 0.01718277670443058, -0.03893711045384407, 0.08017538487911224, -0.01976003125309944, -0.007877099327743053, 0.013182902708649635, 0.018887478858232498, 0.025209922343492508, -0.01620110124349594, -0.02859385311603546, -0.03970595821738243, 0.006647969130426645, 0.07600270956754684, -0.04172021523118019, -0.033662211149930954, -0.010062179528176785, 0.05545184761285782, -0.010328018106520176, -0.0384640209376812, -0.006950729992240667, 0.0070006451569497585, -0.008897879160940647, -0.03404960036277771, 0.0054767015390098095, -0.03676208481192589, 0.024291807785630226, -0.09184147417545319, 0.024793153628706932, -0.0009707014542073011, -0.03203548118472099, -0.048657841980457306, -0.0008663049666211009, 0.005812378600239754, -0.0020026525016874075, 0.028394505381584167, -0.008777141571044922, -0.01383030042052269, -0.05000052973628044, 0.04149497300386429, -0.005732596851885319, -0.017904575914144516, -0.0022690962068736553, -0.06804414093494415, 0.0022510578855872154, 0.010283207520842552, -0.0601138100028038, -0.06369427591562271, 0.0008445233106613159, -0.06671132147312164, 0.05003323778510094, -0.0320778451859951, -0.0674482211470604, 0.08594046533107758, -0.015917547047138214, 0.040037982165813446, -0.03432409092783928, -0.021949756890535355, 0.02650400996208191, -0.019003313034772873, 0.026061829179525375, 0.006374737713485956, -0.005144455470144749, 0.010113908909261227, -0.040341854095458984, 0.024499693885445595, -0.012774988077580929, -0.03461253643035889, -0.016174614429473877, 0.02417539432644844, 0.009111572057008743, 0.03793610259890556, -0.041685350239276886, -0.061835892498493195, 0.019027872011065483, -0.036242447793483734, 0.039579227566719055, 0.000566762057133019, 0.07654857635498047, 0.007664057891815901, 0.009010392241179943, -0.045817725360393524, -0.030308786779642105, -0.03549377992749214, -0.03589329496026039, 0.03066420927643776, 0.010000807233154774, -0.018106941133737564, -0.03139225021004677, -0.05843496695160866, 0.004733541049063206, -0.01385023444890976, 0.008124793879687786, -0.004783398937433958, 0.07101468741893768, 0.04038012772798538, -0.013363059610128403, -0.04707818478345871, 0.05193457379937172, 0.012526948004961014, 0.059126269072294235, -0.06390859186649323, -0.013010633178055286, -0.03026374988257885, -0.029710158705711365, -0.05323207005858421, 0.018623560667037964, -0.003236817428842187, 0.026202013716101646, -0.04030434414744377, 0.02253824658691883, 0.016793332993984222, 0.004460773430764675, -0.014111427590250969, -0.027938593178987503, 0.044593118131160736, 0.008216110058128834, -0.050405967980623245, -0.02472376637160778, -0.04473981261253357, 0.04629073292016983, 0.043739207088947296, -0.021467404440045357, -0.006958942394703627, 0.05630524456501007, 0.0029230043292045593, 0.0996842160820961, -0.06049886345863342, -0.053786538541316986, 0.019888300448656082, -0.009770819917321205, 0.0016903566429391503, 0.04146965593099594, -0.015973500907421112, -0.009621740318834782, 0.022912228479981422, 0.05164559185504913, 0.07036188244819641, 0.025377120822668076, 0.06040025129914284, -0.016032328829169273, 0.039218414574861526, -0.02065228298306465, -0.04864460229873657, 0.031780343502759933, -0.003469181712716818, -0.05043798312544823, -0.047229766845703125, -0.03429437056183815, 0.0475601851940155, -0.014876291155815125, -0.005744043737649918, -0.04820583015680313, -0.0280899740755558, 0.034862156957387924, -0.002120138378813863, -0.046231865882873535, 0.024849507957696915, 0.007728101219981909, 0.005317118484526873, -0.013771596364676952, 0.03758438304066658, 0.07351216673851013, 0.026912637054920197, -0.011468681506812572, 0.03496706485748291, -0.01635400578379631, -0.03693670406937599, -0.03611963987350464, 0.01734425500035286, 0.007251218426972628, -0.026819081977009773, 0.025684090331196785, -0.01319020614027977, 0.01491723395884037, 0.03388523310422897, -0.04018843173980713, -0.02797647938132286, 0.04820137098431587, -0.05648166313767433, -0.020424995571374893, 0.0015866924077272415, -0.008901234716176987, -0.04714740067720413, 0.04213637113571167, -0.010428523644804955, 0.049536701291799545, 0.03690235689282417, -0.013709789142012596, -0.041202113032341, 0.06981759518384933, 0.008773978799581528, 0.07538390159606934, 0.042430054396390915, -0.0018406682647764683, 0.028971843421459198, 0.03572172299027443, -0.03908197209239006, -0.00023853752645663917, -0.03008202277123928, 0.03802623227238655, -0.03300728648900986, 0.013219520449638367, 0.01631033606827259, 0.0223002377897501, 0.04946056380867958, -0.009926523081958294, -0.0022066812962293625, 0.04569929838180542, 0.001299712690524757, -0.002400672994554043, 0.007749574258923531, 0.030379902571439743, -0.011949634179472923, 0.03801727667450905, -0.029607342556118965, -0.05568888410925865, 0.040267761796712875, 0.07040323317050934, 0.060630131512880325, -0.013936029747128487, 0.013525094836950302, 0.06867051124572754, 0.06792571395635605, 0.004336499609053135, 0.029087398201227188, 0.018453439697623253, -0.02067878097295761, -0.018903417512774467, -0.06885246932506561, -0.04074840992689133, -0.0895945280790329, -0.05797388032078743, -0.004513447172939777, -0.05368105694651604, 0.001795572112314403, 0.028214169666171074, 0.018729640170931816, -0.049155041575431824, 0.027229053899645805, -0.002256406005471945, 0.029152218252420425, -0.04498511180281639, -0.020012307912111282, 0.02561928704380989, 0.023874511942267418, 0.07659418135881424, -0.015801891684532166, -0.04254386946558952, -0.0022464690264314413, -0.005771744530647993, 0.09394626319408417, 0.032035741955041885, -0.013131660409271717, -0.018924124538898468, -0.044120464473962784, -0.022413451224565506, 0.05109803378582001, -0.0307189729064703, -0.01895930804312229, 0.019624490290880203, -0.013188453391194344, 0.029109714552760124, 0.031507156789302826, -0.011953240260481834, 0.0012585649965330958, -0.02209801971912384, 0.052371036261320114, -0.028557268902659416, -0.039798617362976074, -0.002470859559252858, 0.025093423202633858, -0.08048497140407562, 0.03175079822540283, 0.03115164116024971, -0.036887090653181076, -0.002672400791198015, 0.04236971586942673, 0.008990439586341381, -0.04721204563975334, -0.013922099955379963, 0.08127512782812119, -0.025483477860689163, 0.0031441275496035814, -0.08392602205276489, -0.024055734276771545, 0.0019792011007666588, 0.01989397592842579, 0.0379730723798275, 0.01392672024667263, -0.010450351051986217, -0.03452198952436447, 0.0134871331974864, 0.029910778626799583, -0.026550646871328354, 0.0399300679564476, 0.0015520498855039477, -0.011543593369424343, -0.018089737743139267, 0.06185058504343033, 0.013839245773851871, -0.004026231821626425, 0.06332888454198837, -0.001711751101538539, 0.09491895884275436, -0.019207924604415894, 0.007707878481596708, 0.009338990785181522, -0.05180282145738602, 0.004153670743107796, 0.00011660849850159138, 0.036430198699235916, 0.06402336806058884, 0.008409354835748672, 0.006268423516303301, 0.0291594285517931, 0.012576252222061157, 0.03435315936803818, -0.052705153822898865, -0.01963319070637226, 0.036721937358379364, 0.01402098685503006, 0.016599079594016075, 0.026895079761743546, -0.018964121118187904, 0.07667595893144608, -0.08107013255357742, -0.0033673064317554235, -0.019127236679196358, 0.026582222431898117, -0.04764534905552864, 0.001253961818292737, 0.022839557379484177, -0.05717115104198456, 0.025552546605467796, -0.04153142124414444, 0.0005642236210405827, 0.0504903681576252, 0.030559223145246506, -0.0397331602871418, -0.010224240832030773, 0.02301502600312233, -0.0002982054720632732, -0.02552109956741333, 0.003371104132384062, 0.07071436196565628, 0.01421944797039032, -0.02709650993347168, 0.024543005973100662, -0.09488722681999207, -0.028189200907945633, 0.057573918253183365, 0.033036570996046066, -0.06355959177017212, -0.04056553542613983, -0.06527568399906158, -0.007888294756412506, -0.025402268394827843, 0.05678217113018036, -0.003372112289071083, -0.059022098779678345, 0.005919961258769035, 0.023775683715939522, -0.07797104865312576, 0.0260014608502388, -0.005430278833955526, -0.0360952727496624, 0.03415790572762489, 0.006031269673258066, 0.02344268187880516, -0.03147100657224655, 0.03213037922978401, -0.013573229312896729, 0.05230360105633736, -0.013198236003518105, -0.01118736807256937, 0.01742992363870144, 0.0008232223335653543, 0.02381463721394539, -0.027747182175517082, -0.05095912516117096, -0.014078568667173386, -0.025149259716272354, -0.046958521008491516, 0.0051813796162605286, -0.05032075569033623, 0.01790660433471203, -0.019786255434155464, 0.02334975078701973, 0.01949816197156906, -0.03621520847082138, -0.006950067356228828, 0.020219916477799416, -0.024286406114697456, -0.028424080461263657, -0.01275878306478262, -0.040309637784957886, -0.05606311559677124, 0.04499039426445961, -0.016917474567890167, 0.04751044884324074, -0.01111327763646841, 0.01757659763097763, -0.06528868526220322, 0.05989859998226166, -0.006353079341351986, 0.06256841123104095, -0.0014092394849285483, -0.0445978008210659, 0.04266249015927315, 0.02702517621219158, 0.02103092148900032, -0.00824828166514635, -0.022810354828834534, -0.0038839727640151978, 0.0748218297958374, 0.015233046375215054, 0.03265035152435303, 0.004748528357595205, -0.027941618114709854, -0.029734397307038307, 0.039583008736371994, 0.016144679859280586, -0.013288959860801697, 0.03473078832030296, 0.007188618648797274, -0.042525097727775574, -0.013445165008306503, -0.009469729848206043, -0.04321423918008804, -0.016303610056638718, -0.016450973227620125, -0.06657276302576065, -0.009525535628199577, -0.009022128768265247, 0.01837410032749176, -0.06810658425092697, 0.05339282006025314, -0.0651063397526741, 0.019215404987335205, -0.005198545753955841, 0.000012056798368575983, 0.04472614824771881, 0.00442133005708456, -0.021158643066883087, -0.017119279131293297, 0.034019507467746735, -0.01550687849521637, 0.005682983435690403, 0.01243226695805788, 0.04431625455617905, -0.03926114737987518, 0.02963990718126297, 0.021152369678020477, -0.043082691729068756, -0.00858462043106556, -0.020806942135095596, -0.0067704650573432446, 0.05744698643684387, -0.001251278561539948, 0.0008118125260807574, -0.028559666126966476, -0.11021675914525986, 0.06355080008506775, 0.008036470040678978, 0.02918080985546112, -0.036509234458208084, -0.025843564420938492, -0.045178864151239395, -0.028523899614810944, 0.0350462906062603, 0.05648304149508476, -0.04944106936454773, 0.020741509273648262, 0.03846634179353714, -0.014171126298606396, -0.0005952041829004884, 0.04315200820565224, 0.06170864403247833, -0.04902103543281555, -0.021583445370197296, 0.03224242478609085, 0.030939511954784393, 0.04885300248861313, 0.0013183996779844165, -0.004001106135547161, 0.022998198866844177, 0.043333519250154495, 0.0534023642539978, -0.00005900579708395526, 0.036878734827041626, 0.002463016426190734, 0.059217583388090134, 0.07397560030221939, -0.029822710901498795, -0.04582321271300316, 0.019649872556328773, 0.0008428452420048416, -0.05177071690559387, -0.034522030502557755, 0.047514062374830246, 0.043176084756851196, 0.07541880011558533, -0.0079251229763031, -0.03372678905725479, -0.026103250682353973, -0.009034295566380024, -0.0016686591552570462, -0.0008900851244106889, -0.0456836111843586, 0.0018973553087562323, -0.01087196171283722, -0.01893959753215313, -0.01171594113111496, 0.021434592083096504, -0.018152233213186264, -0.0031290159095078707, -0.06677266210317612, 0.053425684571266174, -0.03820287808775902, 0.014617614448070526, -0.009256557561457157, -0.04940987750887871, -0.056623753160238266, 0.029482567682862282, -0.016965016722679138, 0.013886176981031895, -0.002803258830681443, -0.037565283477306366, 0.06795292347669601, 0.0737515389919281, -0.009162889793515205, 0.0148843452334404, -0.036137718707323074, 0.04401939734816551, -0.02568872831761837, 0.03910829871892929, -0.08897001296281815, -0.07460061460733414, -0.0033034502994269133, 0.011717146262526512, 0.004045776091516018, -0.0015534745762124658, 0.015091726556420326, -0.005061287898570299, -0.01826067827641964, -0.024400047957897186, -0.0012084243353456259, 0.00021599579486064613, 0.004269985016435385 ]
<p>In a typical photon experiment the photon is depicted as moving across the page, say from right to left. Suppose we were actually able to witness such an experiment, from the side (to position of reader to a page). If the photon is actually moving from left to right can I, standing at 90 degrees to the motion, see the photon? </p>
g6630
[ -0.025103526189923286, 0.05731744319200516, 0.024611851200461388, -0.00684794457629323, 0.02247682400047779, 0.0006682834937237203, 0.04745958000421524, 0.06501740217208862, 0.012828840874135494, 0.018441077321767807, 0.03980053588747978, 0.016896028071641922, 0.01887531951069832, 0.008291839621961117, 0.0024194070138037205, -0.06016342714428902, 0.09007089585065842, -0.03772246465086937, -0.029828345403075218, 0.010039674118161201, -0.03469851240515709, 0.061223383992910385, -0.05810665339231491, 0.018530230969190598, -0.024157004430890083, -0.006590722594410181, -0.04310169443488121, -0.039232030510902405, -0.05987995117902756, -0.006956515833735466, -0.019416680559515953, -0.023534409701824188, 0.0029440713115036488, 0.026009652763605118, 0.013703815639019012, -0.020612062886357307, 0.03148501366376877, -0.0022467069793492556, -0.0025618874933570623, 0.011368917301297188, -0.016856081783771515, 0.0031930427066981792, -0.011595233343541622, -0.030109180137515068, 0.04450438171625137, 0.0393035002052784, 0.043659426271915436, 0.0347638800740242, 0.02269011177122593, -0.025043785572052002, -0.03219608590006828, -0.014393344521522522, -0.019252916797995567, 0.047592416405677795, 0.06417740136384964, 0.010661760345101357, 0.0042674909345805645, -0.000893728865776211, 0.09710915386676788, 0.019477928057312965, -0.0003373789368197322, 0.0004922744701616466, -0.007663094438612461, -0.05318044498562813, 0.057565271854400635, 0.01380984764546156, -0.07901941239833832, 0.0030295327305793762, -0.04482610151171684, -0.015085212886333466, 0.02181030996143818, 0.06456352025270462, -0.0561557412147522, 0.023086855188012123, 0.039347197860479355, -0.010763694532215595, 0.0095731932669878, -0.04771875962615013, -0.016803303733468056, 0.039402883499860764, -0.011763723567128181, -0.0557950921356678, -0.00205306732095778, 0.019745998084545135, 0.12131547182798386, 0.006146652158349752, -0.029192950576543808, -0.005924188997596502, -0.02153564989566803, -0.0013960166834294796, 0.05850335955619812, -0.010780510492622852, 0.08791124075651169, 0.08214373886585236, -0.0030472418293356895, -0.035893455147743225, -0.03426940739154816, 0.05897831916809082, -0.012777958996593952, 0.006871515419334173, -0.04964671656489372, 0.03718854486942291, -0.004681704565882683, 0.044735655188560486, -0.036784276366233826, 0.011449321173131466, 0.024365868419408798, -0.042654506862163544, -0.007465126924216747, -0.0733032375574112, -0.029882512986660004, -0.04091477021574974, -0.05508052930235863, -0.03655559569597244, -0.043236568570137024, -0.03381282091140747, 0.06146315112709999, 0.03830813243985176, 0.012011563405394554, 0.07524317502975464, 0.04553935304284096, 0.06472744047641754, -0.030331920832395554, 0.08786063641309738, -0.01456771045923233, 0.02139095589518547, -0.07033798098564148, 0.01737501285970211, 0.008512457832694054, 0.03430260717868805, 0.026078201830387115, 0.07918939739465714, -0.04985743388533592, 0.04920164495706558, 0.024592028930783272, 0.018042638897895813, 0.045329730957746506, 0.03817489370703697, 0.009741989895701408, 0.016769705340266228, 0.048600949347019196, -0.021188650280237198, -0.025349419564008713, 0.0270485058426857, -0.0039069764316082, -0.0016174087068066, 0.0282205231487751, 0.03295617178082466, 0.005379287991672754, 0.04822423681616783, -0.017577314749360085, 0.03703315183520317, -0.0005550358910113573, -0.022188328206539154, 0.06668049097061157, -0.08556897193193436, 0.04366240277886391, 0.0021363974083215, -0.016125934198498726, 0.04171114042401314, 0.04436064139008522, 0.010591698810458183, -0.027000680565834045, -0.04330172389745712, -0.05135611817240715, -0.03257054090499878, -0.055075835436582565, -0.009483828209340572, -0.003433037782087922, -0.06797771900892258, -0.014758031815290451, 0.000054697371524525806, -0.0011672533582895994, 0.009392503648996353, -0.06963826715946198, 0.03995118662714958, -0.02342979423701763, 0.008993564173579216, 0.02444034442305565, 0.022661102935671806, -0.05496615543961525, 0.0239043477922678, 0.008242332376539707, -0.07671687006950378, 0.010754100047051907, -0.01951911672949791, -0.03492176905274391, 0.037677980959415436, -0.06696031987667084, 0.0007691275095567107, -0.01830899901688099, -0.07560829818248749, -0.00593178067356348, 0.02986103482544422, -0.06079023703932762, -0.09375345706939697, 0.0024311039596796036, -0.014689815230667591, -0.01135410089045763, 0.0020555320661514997, -0.015729669481515884, 0.047689780592918396, -0.011526289395987988, 0.00866555143147707, -0.02260054275393486, -0.01957312971353531, 0.051021117717027664, -0.022305546328425407, -0.0009625715319998562, -0.045547716319561005, 0.023652920499444008, 0.019080357626080513, 0.003706125309690833, 0.01586761698126793, 0.010228362865746021, 0.018489832058548927, -0.01705627515912056, -0.021487126126885414, -0.007782681845128536, 0.040783196687698364, 0.00045418148511089385, -0.03651275113224983, 0.001205124775879085, -0.027071386575698853, -0.022159727290272713, 0.007921218872070312, -0.10855355113744736, -0.05473651736974716, 0.0048031616024672985, 0.09709405153989792, -0.06335451453924179, 0.02916872128844261, 0.04178730398416519, 0.02692641317844391, 0.020038077607750893, 0.03081771731376648, -0.043941058218479156, 0.0485428050160408, 0.07034970819950104, -0.05068432539701462, -0.020409096032381058, -0.031494736671447754, -0.05954752862453461, -0.0016613060142844915, 0.05476408451795578, -0.00007011919660726562, 0.04582860320806503, 0.05965520441532135, -0.009844725020229816, 0.031132908537983894, 0.06537405401468277, -0.024742010980844498, 0.016367729753255844, 0.02874004654586315, -0.022895868867635727, 0.03008611872792244, -0.03388991951942444, -0.0050864736549556255, -0.01961875520646572, -0.0008251877152360976, -0.04818059131503105, -0.08420766890048981, -0.015316602773964405, -0.000016357462300220504, 0.015384715981781483, 0.004279912915080786, -0.006801912561058998, 0.007050907704979181, 0.009802456945180893, 0.01760362647473812, 0.03544946759939194, 0.024630500003695488, 0.08348429203033447, 0.024537568911910057, -0.028182899579405785, 0.009122989140450954, 0.052825845777988434, -0.0500761978328228, -0.0451936200261116, -0.0402287133038044, -0.004095536656677723, 0.035814981907606125, 0.005835589487105608, 0.010515649802982807, 0.03255585953593254, -0.03247095271945, -0.0010547061683610082, -0.038134362548589706, -0.018039293587207794, -0.03542548790574074, -0.059985339641571045, -0.015373741276562214, 0.023844735696911812, 0.03668029233813286, -0.029720842838287354, 0.01694246008992195, 0.04000740125775337, -0.0648445412516594, -0.019908221438527107, 0.007766599301248789, -0.0019111650763079524, -0.0016246566083282232, -0.03693397343158722, 0.035650305449962616, 0.036062657833099365, 0.036348018795251846, -0.04299738258123398, -0.028268679976463318, 0.04267854243516922, -0.004859980195760727, -0.04992932453751564, 0.03262781351804733, -0.026198167353868484, -0.031216315925121307, 0.002082517836242914, -0.04685747250914574, -0.03297162055969238, 0.03803705424070358, -0.03421805426478386, 0.06788576394319534, 0.018777266144752502, 0.04140637442469597, -0.03793617710471153, -0.0030095549300312996, 0.1027747094631195, 0.0021814601495862007, -0.020113473758101463, 0.006572364829480648, -0.08978927880525589, -0.01590423658490181, 0.018223026767373085, 0.027668656781315804, -0.007845962420105934, -0.014635455794632435, 0.06427973508834839, 0.03790070116519928, 0.013996995985507965, 0.011245757341384888, 0.019752489402890205, -0.035120803862810135, 0.07256796211004257, -0.028731832280755043, -0.03493344783782959, 0.02521090768277645, 0.07258356362581253, -0.025686129927635193, -0.04306626319885254, -0.009751247242093086, 0.010773234069347382, -0.03978893160820007, 0.019434701651334763, -0.016861477866768837, -0.0331948958337307, -0.069667749106884, -0.014243297278881073, 0.029542025178670883, 0.01486755721271038, 0.023308780044317245, -0.01511109434068203, -0.018650570884346962, -0.03793539106845856, 0.015069675631821156, 0.03872174024581909, -0.06262753158807755, -0.02164173685014248, 0.03886258229613304, -0.049792658537626266, 0.053856655955314636, 0.0373123437166214, 0.010683784261345863, -0.07344521582126617, -0.08045733720064163, -0.03118683211505413, -0.02230510301887989, -0.008867424912750721, -0.020464489236474037, 0.004023105837404728, -0.001617736998014152, -0.013610035181045532, 0.037074778228998184, -0.042296163737773895, 0.005256508477032185, 0.028718745335936546, -0.0049827815964818, 0.04978419467806816, 0.052194830030202866, -0.01943741738796234, -0.018159780651330948, 0.03951152786612511, 0.016570502892136574, 0.06572660058736801, -0.03771298751235008, -0.012461329810321331, -0.032842643558979034, -0.022726139053702354, 0.03521004319190979, 0.0067161316983401775, -0.04476100951433182, 0.0029677473939955235, -0.037452634423971176, 0.05116445571184158, 0.01839362271130085, 0.009850197471678257, 0.029504744336009026, -0.05206605792045593, 0.022372636944055557, 0.01959553360939026, 0.006961570121347904, -0.05903676897287369, 0.01878109946846962, -0.024273525923490524, -0.024503784254193306, -0.024699652567505836, -0.019992731511592865, 0.025902658700942993, 0.054066479206085205, -0.01120923925191164, 0.02815803326666355, -0.015983005985617638, 0.013494262471795082, -0.018794648349285126, 0.05142533406615257, 0.036910880357027054, -0.012137875892221928, -0.05012357607483864, 0.11768396943807602, 0.03094211407005787, -0.006472837645560503, -0.008004470728337765, -0.008908817544579506, 0.03991379961371422, 0.010238302871584892, -0.018857913091778755, 0.026158638298511505, -0.0371730700135231, 0.027935298159718513, 0.003269053529947996, 0.028464147821068764, 0.06596095860004425, 0.06082873046398163, 0.03434930369257927, 0.013156075030565262, 0.030886465683579445, -0.011667103506624699, -0.035558801144361496, 0.07064628601074219, 0.022723518311977386, -0.03164905682206154, -0.03993745148181915, -0.02745317481458187, -0.049081332981586456, -0.044864263385534286, -0.07405833154916763, 0.0145349046215415, 0.009721087291836739, -0.04038161784410477, -0.0284144077450037, 0.018081024289131165, -0.01584174484014511, 0.02451738715171814, 0.003057110123336315, -0.04158558323979378, 0.03347539156675339, 0.004240481182932854, 0.03822759911417961, 0.03371284902095795, -0.05064241960644722, -0.015484885312616825, -0.07449530065059662, 0.002979352604597807, 0.0025977501645684242, 0.016498617827892303, 0.01610313169658184, 0.03049122728407383, -0.0271931029856205, -0.010036887601017952, -0.0295309666544199, 0.04831302538514137, -0.000499040586873889, -0.05198657140135765, -0.035105057060718536, 0.01943369396030903, 0.05220938101410866, -0.05371947959065437, 0.011312924325466156, -0.03313824534416199, -0.07146089524030685, 0.03805245831608772, -0.006646582391113043, -0.002797132357954979, -0.004198997747153044, -0.036698803305625916, -0.001630825805477798, -0.03448139503598213, -0.0026825591921806335, -0.012920812703669071, 0.005482284817844629, -0.007624277379363775, 0.05893415957689285, 0.031476039439439774, 0.021565238013863564, -0.0016534548485651612, 0.048339832574129105, -0.0330476351082325, -0.025312891229987144, 0.006942461710423231, -0.016047624871134758, -0.019984856247901917, -0.02307891473174095, 0.02151385322213173, -0.04924073442816734, 0.028361797332763672, -0.06017352268099785, -0.006409873254597187, 0.02719840034842491, -0.03161359205842018, -0.019335806369781494, -0.004041698295623064, 0.00042505015153437853, 0.01703529804944992, 0.009719726629555225, 0.024403082206845284, 0.05475180596113205, -0.03013480454683304, 0.0205344520509243, -0.05239955708384514, -0.07432620972394943, 0.03666873648762703, 0.02228025160729885, -0.005338939838111401, 0.04340219125151634, 0.023409489542245865, 0.039209216833114624, 0.020478224381804466, -0.016996245831251144, -0.059079721570014954, 0.0360206700861454, -0.037576284259557724, 0.041865184903144836, 0.0035505560226738453, -0.07373598963022232, -0.022092949599027634, 0.06605856120586395, 0.0662035122513771, 0.05760717764496803, 0.02180224284529686, -0.011303763836622238, -0.02499416284263134, 0.030371742323040962, -0.013800961896777153, 0.004718750715255737, 0.05721093714237213, -0.033693958073854446, 0.0051044742576777935, -0.02441369742155075, -0.020208820700645447, -0.014719096943736076, 0.0008191345841623843, -0.009881467558443546, -0.011284729465842247, 0.08351708203554153, 0.013113866560161114, 0.0549197643995285, 0.005459317471832037, -0.02299472503364086, 0.007791259326040745, -0.0016295640962198377, -0.03337915614247322, 0.016262678429484367, 0.0029241705778986216, 0.009004933759570122, -0.012556234374642372, -0.01160459965467453, 0.020473463460803032, -0.004209264647215605, -0.0001860731717897579, 0.011568430811166763, 0.031499240547418594, -0.046650875359773636, -0.011491145007312298, -0.03069048933684826, 0.03694669157266617, 0.004579692613333464, -0.021438518539071083, 0.014857642352581024, 0.003643831005319953, -0.09751774370670319, 0.053373731672763824, -0.007507015019655228, -0.0024176512379199266, -0.07877476513385773, -0.019342603161931038, -0.05305836349725723, -0.02524506114423275, -0.029614688828587532, -0.03810019791126251, -0.012519625015556812, 0.007510295137763023, -0.03612324595451355, 0.08155422657728195, 0.027143068611621857, -0.060407042503356934, 0.011292804032564163, -0.05138128995895386, -0.00046632287558168173, -0.0008584921015426517, -0.02657480351626873, 0.03128241002559662, 0.04782741889357567, 0.00837805587798357, -0.018902437761425972, -0.01563407853245735, 0.023514751344919205, -0.03088943473994732, -0.016314661130309105, -0.04897623509168625, -0.002928344067186117, -0.02844824455678463, 0.00508134625852108, -0.035956237465143204, -0.03238717094063759, -0.0008843985851854086, 0.028581244871020317, 0.012700718827545643, 0.008594220504164696, 0.06521348655223846, -0.04765719175338745, 0.07389935851097107, 0.04110473766922951, 0.06501860916614532, -0.030463172122836113, 0.02805762179195881, 0.012842277996242046, 0.029586514458060265, 0.0656830221414566, -0.012276781722903252, -0.06840282678604126, -0.008811173029243946, -0.005632209125906229, 0.04520487040281296, 0.018210474401712418, 0.02557278610765934, 0.02504166215658188, -0.08256519585847855, -0.005391761194914579, 0.037676747888326645, 0.001996708335354924, 0.007225734647363424, -0.026759754866361618, 0.00461304048076272, 0.00493988860398531, -0.008244195021688938, -0.03377223759889603, 0.04273909330368042, 0.008976152166724205, 0.028569666668772697, -0.0065996055491268635, -0.011018695309758186, -0.009483217261731625, -0.057239364832639694, -0.010272986255586147, -0.07201938331127167, -0.016818732023239136, -0.02494380623102188, -0.016829010099172592, 0.0039711506105959415, 0.022242678329348564, -0.021505942568182945, -0.0464521199464798, -0.007159417495131493, 0.013473873026669025, -0.04427611827850342, -0.03254231810569763, -0.005578814074397087, -0.040544744580984116, -0.012424701824784279, 0.022609826177358627, 0.04245421290397644, -0.0484667532145977, -0.025638017803430557, -0.021838726475834846, 0.027405664324760437, 0.04035637900233269, 0.02978276088833809, -0.04731934890151024, -0.008659475483000278, -0.024427147582173347, -0.07071332633495331, -0.003394674276933074, -0.02398882433772087, 0.025192851200699806, -0.025662805885076523, 0.021151134744286537, -0.017284994944930077, -0.015342107973992825, -0.0004711211659014225, 0.05137074738740921, 0.0026047853752970695, -0.009058116935193539, 0.0456995964050293, 0.010848977603018284, -0.0007294787210412323, -0.0260788444429636, 0.016579458490014076, 0.02025691233575344, -0.014291108585894108, -0.011983765289187431, -0.019770320504903793, -0.048368774354457855, -0.061327386647462845, 0.049642715603113174, 0.05214167386293411, -0.011886699125170708, 0.03693145141005516, 0.02427344210445881, 0.010587957687675953, -0.03983468934893608, 0.039484698325395584, 0.07348929345607758, 0.006962263956665993, -0.03528149425983429, 0.01979306899011135, -0.05252595990896225, 0.008663258515298367, -0.01659224182367325, 0.008455919101834297, 0.04083635285496712, 0.015543151646852493, 0.02407500520348549, -0.00461924122646451, 0.04703756421804428, 0.025894997641444206, -0.031280629336833954, -0.006100178696215153, -0.0071402378380298615, 0.0025845374912023544, 0.015654591843485832, -0.05910424888134003, -0.004091763403266668, -0.013969890773296356, 0.011783121153712273, -0.05597333982586861, 0.0194854736328125, -0.008866841904819012, 0.0007151112076826394, -0.0594601184129715, 0.02560635469853878, -0.020024562254548073, -0.00012778340897057205, -0.000919485290069133, 0.019248662516474724, 0.056862179189920425, -0.006956667173653841, 0.017770536243915558, 0.011513922363519669, 0.03687146306037903, -0.0017555394442752004, -0.02961263246834278, -0.01428675651550293, 0.03316032886505127, -0.0015125740319490433, -0.03629373386502266, -0.00862115528434515, -0.051410872489213943, -0.01399408932775259, -0.006037629209458828, 0.0009615227463655174, 0.03505246713757515 ]
<p>What are the quantum mechanisms behind the emission and absorption of thermal radiation at and below room temperature? If the relevant quantum state transitions are molecular (stretching, flexing and spin changes) how come the thermal spectrum is continuous? What about substances (such as noble gases) which don't form molecules, how do they emit or absorb thermal radiation? Is there a semi-classical mechanism (with the EM field treated classically) and also a deeper explanation using the full apparatus of QFT?</p>
g6631
[ 0.01562088169157505, -0.031026309356093407, 0.0019135111942887306, 0.02514065057039261, 0.0006137081072665751, 0.040670253336429596, 0.010169210843741894, 0.07362619042396545, 0.00616545882076025, -0.04619579762220383, -0.02421957440674305, 0.019829679280519485, 0.03367368131875992, -0.0020804395899176598, -0.010490473359823227, -0.020776690915226936, 0.02065737172961235, 0.017072634771466255, 0.057691074907779694, 0.030423535034060478, -0.09420481324195862, -0.013554245233535767, -0.010339666157960892, -0.08123882114887238, -0.08789441734552383, 0.01715783029794693, -0.00119486334733665, 0.04866588115692139, 0.08422072976827621, -0.049623940140008926, -0.007617536932229996, 0.038707904517650604, 0.022789571434259415, -0.010791691951453686, 0.08178853243589401, -0.010681414976716042, 0.047786153852939606, -0.005318383686244488, -0.04549986869096756, -0.03531975299119949, -0.03324270248413086, -0.03924020007252693, 0.02580728754401207, 0.018995601683855057, 0.03379139304161072, 0.05386532098054886, -0.04610922560095787, 0.001364995609037578, 0.0006443258025683463, 0.04039207100868225, 0.003290865570306778, -0.011240212246775627, 0.02202354557812214, 0.02117801643908024, 0.04382564127445221, -0.0389304980635643, -0.044578440487384796, 0.02539004571735859, 0.06662992388010025, -0.05620381981134415, 0.04436379671096802, 0.008103931322693825, 0.009231941774487495, -0.018722763285040855, 0.07793735712766647, -0.026986435055732727, -0.029117288067936897, 0.00887554232031107, -0.024408642202615738, 0.004210931248962879, 0.006685568019747734, -0.01909886673092842, -0.07174025475978851, 0.0028623316902667284, 0.010750841349363327, -0.01625533401966095, -0.009724687784910202, -0.012784244492650032, -0.027848314493894577, 0.010240044444799423, -0.03402411565184593, -0.03540416061878204, 0.0036357783246785402, -0.009760303422808647, 0.024403460323810577, 0.011561637744307518, -0.011849273927509785, 0.03165779635310173, 0.0057740593329072, 0.0225993525236845, 0.016438089311122894, 0.012217352166771889, 0.06875859200954437, 0.013334285467863083, 0.013653899542987347, -0.002355912933126092, 0.012156421318650246, 0.06137286499142647, -0.004210442770272493, -0.017705345526337624, 0.015200844965875149, -0.01729651726782322, 0.016900034621357918, 0.010125957429409027, 0.01925421692430973, -0.013537362217903137, -0.010597825981676579, 0.008363056927919388, -0.009952876716852188, 0.05649557709693909, -0.06506114453077316, 0.00038690396468155086, -0.0020342825446277857, 0.005186049733310938, -0.01308613270521164, 0.019685138016939163, 0.0359024778008461, -0.002495274180546403, 0.05015115812420845, 0.08295440673828125, 0.01679467223584652, 0.06681246310472488, 0.05935182049870491, -0.01794765144586563, -0.011403780430555344, -0.044482603669166565, -0.011088407598435879, -0.01455506682395935, -0.007488485425710678, 0.004875493235886097, 0.06482021510601044, 0.07448910176753998, -0.0911421850323677, 0.05693819001317024, 0.023920617997646332, 0.04003004729747772, -0.0026249291840940714, -0.007787996903061867, 0.024968430399894714, -0.005386741831898689, 0.0130881667137146, -0.0066866204142570496, -0.016754642128944397, -0.035700298845767975, -0.018277009949088097, 0.0035507928114384413, -0.026195934042334557, -0.019513219594955444, -0.004376927390694618, -0.00248732534237206, 0.0567450225353241, 0.04713863879442215, 0.06416439265012741, -0.029090387746691704, 0.0488116629421711, -0.04504157975316048, 0.022545434534549713, -0.03477850928902626, 0.02574731595814228, 0.06666097044944763, 0.018569353967905045, -0.010065728798508644, -0.0696553960442543, 0.016385391354560852, -0.034096233546733856, -0.0010262159630656242, -0.024126283824443817, -0.05542540177702904, 0.04886803776025772, -0.044171370565891266, -0.047297846525907516, 0.016110070049762726, -0.03937598690390587, 0.039021268486976624, -0.049978941679000854, 0.054486922919750214, 0.050366438925266266, -0.016170699149370193, -0.0014453936601057649, -0.03619864583015442, -0.014347244054079056, 0.004710724111646414, 0.004541068337857723, -0.035999562591314316, 0.01775062456727028, 0.03944150358438492, -0.021898075938224792, 0.019136516377329826, -0.07665466517210007, 0.018816448748111725, -0.04463327303528786, -0.07092776149511337, 0.021508129313588142, 0.002121805213391781, -0.009923723526299, -0.00411326065659523, 0.00786132737994194, -0.03811837360262871, -0.0472089983522892, 0.014362283051013947, 0.002570929704234004, -0.00402282178401947, -0.03175768628716469, 0.00865205843001604, 0.07479364424943924, 0.05645798146724701, -0.005938869435340166, -0.01026987750083208, 0.008953887037932873, -0.05599229782819748, -0.011148884892463684, -0.007070932537317276, 0.03892577812075615, -0.0028553418815135956, -0.003921002149581909, 0.07438477873802185, 0.0006744781276211143, -0.0374738946557045, 0.018351897597312927, 0.019914522767066956, 0.022119270637631416, 0.02527979388833046, 0.04240056872367859, 0.043673451989889145, -0.01835005171597004, -0.008627907373011112, -0.08502598106861115, 0.018193652853369713, -0.000990311847999692, 0.04428793117403984, -0.1303817629814148, 0.045928049832582474, 0.009185784496366978, 0.0016390102682635188, 0.03900507092475891, 0.028297118842601776, -0.030426662415266037, -0.05445193126797676, 0.059444572776556015, -0.016075406223535538, -0.014612390659749508, -0.01664847880601883, -0.038791216909885406, -0.006096449214965105, -0.005137715954333544, -0.02393771894276142, -0.026458529755473137, -0.0464872308075428, 0.007946801371872425, -0.01859479583799839, 0.033141687512397766, -0.013507700525224209, -0.006369545590132475, -0.008626852184534073, -0.09209419786930084, -0.0026665220502763987, -0.07433272898197174, 0.05869356542825699, -0.03445858880877495, -0.07773643732070923, -0.008964253589510918, 0.016868149861693382, -0.03829490765929222, 0.013936459086835384, 0.01867217943072319, 0.008362327702343464, -0.028569625690579414, 0.042251914739608765, -0.05247243866324425, -0.015180440619587898, -0.02874828316271305, 0.07415933161973953, -0.05925743654370308, 0.04127191752195358, 0.024550557136535645, -0.00018707853450905532, 0.007752178702503443, 0.017383532598614693, 0.024189453572034836, -0.03849494084715843, -0.006086364388465881, -0.02708611823618412, -0.04484115540981293, -0.01179394032806158, 0.035405974835157394, -0.015161611139774323, -0.011933068744838238, 0.0028275588992983103, 0.0026192357763648033, -0.04711136221885681, 0.02416849508881569, 0.013993954285979271, 0.002183582866564393, 0.024379875510931015, -0.1085968017578125, 0.0032087513245642185, 0.028352143242955208, -0.022428365424275398, -0.019723840057849884, 0.068998783826828, 0.03846321627497673, -0.053347598761320114, 0.04056544974446297, 0.03177342936396599, -0.0061370027251541615, -0.020034311339259148, -0.0345812663435936, -0.060296740382909775, 0.014013233594596386, 0.028134658932685852, -0.0257280170917511, -0.022176643833518028, -0.04658643901348114, 0.08082039654254913, -0.011361805722117424, -0.048917364329099655, -0.03303998336195946, 0.017098497599363327, 0.06253726035356522, -0.031077731400728226, 0.012422711588442326, -0.028821535408496857, 0.003660846035927534, -0.06343270093202591, 0.04988930746912956, -0.009499958716332912, 0.01624459959566593, -0.05504780262708664, -0.016856292262673378, -0.04869219288229942, 0.005681601352989674, -0.007776487618684769, -0.0025721334386616945, -0.015810079872608185, 0.01085725985467434, 0.005335633642971516, -0.09088923782110214, 0.007670914754271507, 0.0015552523545920849, -0.016285080462694168, 0.05165552347898483, -0.022001242265105247, -0.03644122928380966, 0.03575839847326279, 0.03966888040304184, -0.014653886668384075, -0.013271257281303406, -0.06159409135580063, -0.0002634350676089525, -0.003189890645444393, -0.011013134382665157, 0.012491868808865547, -0.019028212875127792, 0.018954936414957047, -0.026303434744477272, 0.039829425513744354, 0.0014076679944992065, 0.08608090877532959, 0.050789251923561096, 0.006523543037474155, -0.03176824003458023, -0.051345840096473694, 0.07254081964492798, 0.03107837215065956, -0.024701828137040138, 0.026395028457045555, 0.048601184040308, 0.02276180498301983, 0.07362842559814453, 0.03745444864034653, -0.016426028683781624, -0.0052126082591712475, -0.05709930509328842, -0.028755590319633484, -0.017814388498663902, 0.053080763667821884, 0.043644823133945465, 0.004724327474832535, -0.09388135373592377, 0.012513682246208191, 0.002701584715396166, 0.01396774873137474, -0.010630397126078606, 0.03489994630217552, 0.04956183210015297, 0.04637869819998741, -0.054866597056388855, 0.001969757955521345, -0.038177378475666046, -0.024866655468940735, 0.007013349793851376, -0.06280326843261719, -0.00331865600310266, -0.027683144435286522, 0.030647587031126022, -0.02082776091992855, 0.052988018840551376, -0.013312365859746933, 0.0001840455224737525, 0.005643089767545462, 0.023253684863448143, 0.037028975784778595, -0.04341530054807663, -0.06585809588432312, 0.020289653912186623, 0.05999460443854332, -0.02113702893257141, -0.022482862696051598, 0.002351393224671483, -0.014185723848640919, 0.020864233374595642, 0.06773670017719269, -0.05315268412232399, -0.022466516122221947, 0.005678071640431881, 0.001998109742999077, 0.015864599496126175, -0.03354589641094208, -0.04352070391178131, -0.03878664970397949, -0.0067152404226362705, -0.002630068687722087, -0.003958965186029673, 0.07134347409009933, -0.004824730567634106, 0.05103546753525734, 0.04151756316423416, -0.0030525478068739176, 0.016214920207858086, -0.0034869126975536346, -0.017024651169776917, 0.011441955342888832, -0.0067537082359194756, -0.002858435967937112, -0.020061446353793144, 0.008611216209828854, -0.0458061620593071, -0.005858930293470621, -0.0127600422129035, 0.002065334003418684, 0.15141676366329193, -0.012129141949117184, 0.0013991734012961388, 0.025856366381049156, -0.0330955944955349, 0.0034715256188064814, -0.0175502710044384, -0.017532717436552048, -0.004503178410232067, -0.05150976404547691, -0.04277645796537399, -0.005428812000900507, -0.06103453412652016, -0.007754739839583635, -0.026437651365995407, -0.04562199488282204, -0.04931337758898735, 0.028839251026511192, 0.033277738839387894, 0.012104282155632973, -0.07502884417772293, 0.0004310241201892495, -0.020179573446512222, -0.019946765154600143, -0.012332791462540627, -0.0038925844710320234, -0.08007057011127472, 0.013047615066170692, -0.030272124335169792, 0.013835560530424118, 0.006830114871263504, 0.017828339710831642, 0.03688409551978111, 0.019180903211236, 0.05227506905794144, -0.0293867290019989, 0.02913898602128029, -0.01721019670367241, 0.025380784645676613, -0.06071767210960388, 0.06234416365623474, 0.02527938410639763, 0.0436614528298378, 0.01111249253153801, 0.00007496245962101966, -0.003405240597203374, -0.023814747110009193, 0.020089274272322655, -0.004046483896672726, -0.041722171008586884, 0.03204090893268585, 0.02934357337653637, 0.010246079415082932, -0.00022624648408964276, 0.0009825777960941195, 0.02066449075937271, 0.0027558717411011457, 0.023313643410801888, 0.02525472082197666, -0.023938195779919624, -0.020508335903286934, -0.02777733840048313, -0.01899772696197033, 0.02923058159649372, 0.03499791771173477, 0.010341718792915344, 0.029526038095355034, -0.0058133830316364765, 0.008942422457039356, 0.04640408977866173, -0.04507700726389885, 0.010215387679636478, -0.03493310511112213, -0.013115956448018551, 0.044997699558734894, -0.016842052340507507, -0.022381553426384926, -0.08109452575445175, -0.029761910438537598, -0.002137815812602639, -0.06912412494421005, -0.007135970052331686, 0.018013564869761467, 0.01333149429410696, 0.04430682957172394, 0.060077570378780365, -0.009982053190469742, 0.04260045662522316, 0.021673740819096565, 0.046073731034994125, 0.016493387520313263, 0.013137034140527248, 0.00432739220559597, 0.04911445826292038, 0.0230901800096035, 0.031597305089235306, -0.03694868087768555, -0.033173568546772, -0.0249063428491354, 0.09582037478685379, -0.007960222661495209, -0.051393162459135056, 0.010728491470217705, 0.033429134637117386, 0.05072677135467529, -0.026583338156342506, 0.006107955705374479, 0.03698885813355446, 0.01619766652584076, 0.014063547365367413, 0.0386466309428215, 0.024318568408489227, 0.051848072558641434, -0.0341896116733551, 0.02059035934507847, -0.0026469682343304157, -0.0062182885594666, -0.028697572648525238, 0.02726532518863678, 0.015102881006896496, 0.0418015792965889, 0.029011812061071396, 0.06312800943851471, -0.05001513287425041, 0.05393536388874054, 0.019296685233712196, 0.011446550488471985, -0.03021244704723358, 0.06353449821472168, 0.01953226700425148, 0.0043597836047410965, 0.000921411148738116, 0.006003824528306723, -0.04716344550251961, -0.02237146534025669, 0.011878730729222298, -0.002666550688445568, -0.036449965089559555, -0.05901237949728966, -0.0189505685120821, 0.040513988584280014, 0.018185153603553772, 0.004911137744784355, -0.03129757195711136, -0.043559636920690536, 0.04197781905531883, -0.002676913281902671, -0.014194916002452374, 0.035084113478660583, 0.027554433792829514, -0.04412737116217613, -0.0462845154106617, -0.04625996947288513, 0.014778721146285534, 0.008557443507015705, 0.002644856460392475, -0.010967528447508812, -0.04045348986983299, -0.048852432519197464, -0.04228167235851288, -0.017606260254979134, 0.04023294150829315, 0.023166589438915253, -0.0548148937523365, 0.061274848878383636, -0.0107034370303154, 0.0022368920035660267, -0.009722833521664143, -0.00631807092577219, 0.03605848178267479, -0.007107028737664223, -0.030973423272371292, -0.030989427119493484, -0.009209089912474155, -0.03452339395880699, -0.018724314868450165, -0.03217862546443939, 0.0662747323513031, -0.006187800783663988, -0.03644080460071564, -0.02941693365573883, -0.05763047933578491, 0.056629471480846405, -0.028773581609129906, 0.045827776193618774, 0.036348551511764526, -0.0682569071650505, 0.04596813768148422, 0.04072924703359604, 0.0076146842911839485, -0.002433663932606578, -0.01489591971039772, 0.01334279216825962, 0.002850121585652232, -0.013684161007404327, -0.02279752492904663, 0.015312179923057556, -0.008083966560661793, 0.013436412438750267, 0.04069821164011955, -0.01807655766606331, -0.027152612805366516, 0.05908270552754402, 0.0012457841075956821, -0.029802020639181137, -0.01108590792864561, -0.03785305097699165, -0.024327443912625313, -0.08398935943841934, 0.023454608395695686, 0.0011433286126703024, -0.063820019364357, -0.04834701865911484, -0.0015836774837225676, 0.06322693079710007, 0.06017273664474487, 0.030926257371902466, -0.012188343331217766, -0.03140858933329582, -0.06381037086248398, 0.006789681501686573, -0.012884438969194889, 0.020034736022353172, 0.05808545649051666, 0.01171402633190155, 0.06984145939350128, 0.030330605804920197, -0.035846561193466187, 0.019159767776727676, -0.03649379685521126, -0.01712005026638508, -0.00431099021807313, 0.02374347299337387, -0.039080556482076645, -0.026545729488134384, -0.021843789145350456, -0.010799371637403965, 0.09387148916721344, 0.006674222182482481, -0.04108015447854996, -0.06238798424601555, 0.06742661446332932, 0.03389234095811844, -0.0038097130600363016, 0.023408303037285805, 0.04170349985361099, 0.0047869374975562096, 0.05859674885869026, -0.01232250314205885, -0.034674741327762604, -0.03890814632177353, -0.043567266315221786, -0.022979596629738808, -0.012177671305835247, 0.04394715651869774, 0.012907166965305805, 0.013759179040789604, -0.0713919997215271, 0.013120844028890133, -0.030407048761844635, 0.01721876859664917, -0.00308453431352973, 0.03670578449964523, -0.008028878830373287, 0.03530643507838249, 0.015999892726540565, 0.02647916041314602, 0.014113586395978928, 0.0036634341813623905, 0.009891591966152191, 0.010965359397232533, 0.013635692186653614, 0.08018266409635544, 0.052590180188417435, 0.004999049939215183, -0.03599517047405243, -0.047325339168310165, -0.004442358389496803, 0.015186617150902748, -0.04334620386362076, -0.04054791107773781, 0.016924824565649033, -0.03205389529466629, 0.027679501101374626, -0.0004662721767090261, -0.03846389427781105, -0.034952178597450256, -0.02430419623851776, 0.03550191968679428, -0.021364331245422363, -0.012380409054458141, 0.07597381621599197, -0.003508823225274682, -0.046353988349437714, -0.039827391505241394, 0.05468396097421646, 0.01134488359093666, 0.0013616315554827452, 0.04964404180645943, 0.003305035410448909, -0.010824509896337986, 0.02078789286315441, 0.03227407857775688, -0.009238667786121368, -0.022401759400963783, -0.08994244039058685, -0.04025059565901756, -0.011311940848827362, 0.029336044564843178, 0.0075743491761386395, -0.040877100080251694, -0.03741765394806862, 0.003844070713967085, 0.0258590467274189, 0.031238604336977005, -0.06662260740995407, -0.0370103120803833, 0.07190964370965958, 0.02305147424340248, 0.004846783820539713, -0.06420116871595383, 0.0077580297365784645, -0.0410289466381073, -0.011235023848712444, -0.015548588708043098, 0.008395034819841385, -0.012960695661604404, -0.024138011038303375 ]
<p><em>[insert obligatory statement of my lack of knowledge in physics]</em></p> <p>Alright, so we have all seen the movies where someone gets blasted out of the airlock on their starship, or their suit decompresses while on a space walk. The poor schmoe usually either decompresses so violently that blood is oozing out of every orifice in their body, or they freeze instantly.</p> <p>From this I have two questions:</p> <ol> <li><strong>Would the decompression really be that violent?</strong> <ol> <li>Clearly the drastic difference in pressure from a normal "earth" like environment to space would be bad, but would it be <em>that</em> devastating.</li> <li>I vaguely remember that standard atmospheric pressure was something like 15 psi, which doesn't seem like enough to mess you up that bad.</li> </ol></li> <li><strong>Would you <em>actually</em> freeze instantly in space?</strong> <ol> <li>Heat, or lack thereof is a measure of internal energy, but in a vacuum there wouldn't be anything to have internal energy, so does space even have a temperature?</li> <li>Wouldn't some form of matter have to be present in order to cool off? If there were no matter besides yourself and a few stray particles here and there, it seems like it would take a very long time to cool off.</li> </ol></li> </ol>
g6632
[ 0.04329506680369377, 0.04124606400728226, -0.020321281626820564, 0.020844079554080963, 0.00785589125007391, 0.011136393994092941, -0.060063865035772324, 0.0771104246377945, -0.010187281295657158, -0.007832055911421776, -0.03691587597131729, 0.03741778805851936, -0.014840591698884964, -0.026998570188879967, 0.02023816667497158, -0.04736565053462982, 0.06395857781171799, -0.060085613280534744, 0.0011501050321385264, -0.045897193253040314, -0.03684987127780914, -0.0643610954284668, 0.020070888102054596, -0.022192154079675674, -0.03085111826658249, -0.015014143660664558, 0.03458600491285324, 0.0019713102374225855, -0.059965964406728745, 0.012344611808657646, -0.015617023222148418, 0.01495766919106245, -0.04182625934481621, -0.08949853479862213, -0.037296704947948456, -0.025494351983070374, 0.007744815666228533, 0.02171826735138893, -0.029239213094115257, -0.01984352618455887, 0.0031721077393740416, -0.10995258390903473, 0.04447129741311073, -0.024963924661278725, -0.022611023858189583, 0.07760798186063766, -0.042897894978523254, -0.067288339138031, -0.021740542724728584, -0.013614760711789131, -0.05324458330869675, -0.01309348177164793, 0.008298657834529877, 0.0045150876976549625, -0.00195335759781301, -0.033523738384246826, 0.030354037880897522, -0.023862004280090332, 0.029427802190184593, -0.041895195841789246, -0.051610298454761505, -0.012023470364511013, -0.0008498262614011765, -0.04094414785504341, -0.011445898562669754, 0.004766736179590225, -0.0489274226129055, 0.010479799471795559, 0.06458357721567154, -0.0008305946830660105, 0.06272772699594498, -0.04929829761385918, -0.0742875412106514, -0.06299154460430145, -0.025256333872675896, 0.04760884493589401, -0.024671265855431557, 0.014097817242145538, 0.044963859021663666, 0.04910717159509659, -0.04964366555213928, 0.014536120928823948, 0.015135113149881363, -0.023804789409041405, 0.024459175765514374, -0.032106153666973114, -0.03558407723903656, -0.048843275755643845, 0.020955506712198257, 0.051800861954689026, -0.020689379423856735, 0.039959926158189774, 0.044704537838697433, 0.012442473322153091, -0.02182709239423275, 0.028199993073940277, 0.01966949552297592, 0.08163957297801971, -0.008280492387712002, -0.028061863034963608, -0.019100842997431755, -0.04388312250375748, -0.022750485688447952, -0.010686635039746761, -0.02871505543589592, -0.039514295756816864, 0.03824126347899437, 0.013913977891206741, 0.0038590284530073404, -0.032725103199481964, 0.0011204828042536974, 0.015114199370145798, -0.048564862459897995, -0.01822698302567005, 0.03858401998877525, -0.009887966327369213, 0.04929294064640999, -0.06410502642393112, -0.011873424053192139, 0.03153418004512787, 0.019770290702581406, 0.04495267942547798, 0.0123817203566432, 0.00047079240903258324, 0.014761301688849926, -0.004280903842300177, 0.03190126270055771, 0.002346461871638894, 0.029241980984807014, -0.024691926315426826, -0.03981836885213852, 0.008466914296150208, -0.043364956974983215, -0.0324302576482296, -0.021091222763061523, 0.031187914311885834, -0.0803234726190567, 0.01999541185796261, -0.09903162717819214, -0.01400975976139307, 0.06249169632792473, 0.008153215982019901, 0.022722851485013962, 0.056204505264759064, -0.07467058300971985, -0.031851913779973984, -0.029115721583366394, 0.04987334832549095, 0.02285594493150711, 0.07134220749139786, -0.013178879395127296, 0.040032483637332916, 0.01110555324703455, -0.030100196599960327, 0.02932143211364746, 0.015199672430753708, 0.03350936248898506, 0.016672158613801003, 0.0501713752746582, -0.017603322863578796, 0.05251654237508774, 0.008882805705070496, 0.05591587722301483, 0.0486464723944664, -0.04789575934410095, 0.02701854333281517, -0.06429015100002289, 0.02053518034517765, 0.04913762956857681, 0.007542913779616356, -0.0490998774766922, -0.04182848334312439, 0.04718678072094917, 0.05121355876326561, 0.006927527021616697, 0.010982632637023926, 0.059845931828022, -0.014651413075625896, -0.018754471093416214, -0.05376414582133293, 0.030407438054680824, 0.050374630838632584, -0.0034090587869286537, -0.05767048895359039, 0.06345245987176895, 0.0049781156703829765, 0.010937903076410294, 0.019971046596765518, 0.000822357542347163, -0.014850517734885216, 0.029302962124347687, -0.041185490787029266, -0.02961508184671402, 0.004755739122629166, -0.003096126951277256, -0.03532145172357559, -0.02681386098265648, 0.0210852213203907, -0.07996692508459091, 0.00625983951613307, -0.005070607643574476, -0.0003203070955350995, 0.030105434358119965, 0.027194872498512268, 0.012949174270033836, 0.017438232898712158, -0.051979854702949524, 0.0006751759792678058, 0.000910692207980901, -0.029914062470197678, 0.09924669563770294, -0.012370985932648182, 0.03669458627700806, 0.02058192901313305, 0.011677801609039307, -0.008796515874564648, -0.048006948083639145, 0.016453875228762627, -0.02962200902402401, 0.0014147298643365502, 0.007356890011578798, 0.028530655428767204, 0.03554769977927208, -0.004234427586197853, 0.027319567278027534, -0.06556737422943115, -0.09965594857931137, -0.0312669463455677, 0.015525235794484615, -0.03651650622487068, -0.07052093744277954, 0.03352329879999161, 0.0008497840026393533, -0.05490700528025627, -0.028424041345715523, 0.0520210862159729, 0.04329841211438179, 0.02193104848265648, -0.00659993477165699, 0.03515215590596199, 0.029742559418082237, -0.014550220221281052, -0.04838952049612999, 0.0013781707966700196, 0.054008908569812775, -0.03925468772649765, -0.028257856145501137, -0.001362259965389967, 0.016490943729877472, -0.07694606482982635, -0.06116316840052605, 0.027333112433552742, -0.08731009066104889, -0.017872022464871407, -0.014028999954462051, -0.028392869979143143, -0.04256982356309891, 0.06926939636468887, -0.03256547078490257, 0.011866535991430283, -0.021996673196554184, 0.014470340684056282, -0.0672542005777359, -0.015539233572781086, -0.07020793855190277, 0.03322107344865799, 0.019448427483439445, 0.06669320166110992, 0.025479357689619064, 0.007492329925298691, 0.008228342048823833, 0.016033781692385674, -0.05831049382686615, 0.044344712048769, 0.030328765511512756, -0.003226472996175289, -0.019147271290421486, -0.020551221445202827, 0.01947784051299095, -0.05026732385158539, 0.010604463517665863, 0.02951771579682827, -0.09133940935134888, 0.015115350484848022, 0.019051244482398033, -0.04581524804234505, 0.01836365833878517, 0.051954761147499084, -0.01000336091965437, -0.049841638654470444, -0.019951816648244858, 0.021662667393684387, 0.016155142337083817, 0.03497277572751045, 0.016661349684000015, 0.04314250871539116, 0.004747267812490463, -0.017015503719449043, -0.02890964411199093, 0.006601175293326378, 0.04660841450095177, -0.0560254342854023, 0.016019651666283607, 0.05049401521682739, -0.005527422297745943, -0.010920303873717785, -0.069285087287426, 0.006993464194238186, -0.021928519010543823, -0.037376631051301956, 0.011605562642216682, 0.06868456304073334, 0.08521655946969986, 0.02184055745601654, -0.0013104366371408105, -0.009820238687098026, 0.024840014055371284, -0.046003036201000214, 0.00234140339307487, -0.02566627785563469, 0.017732495442032814, -0.013932691887021065, -0.00737413065508008, -0.03774699196219444, 0.05723707005381584, 0.01809246838092804, -0.01526030246168375, -0.037963587790727615, -0.05189938843250275, -0.019962843507528305, -0.026521099731326103, -0.0011360981734469533, 0.002409883076325059, -0.04423096030950546, -0.09263807535171509, 0.027202729135751724, -0.027577245607972145, -0.0019285879097878933, 0.017186131328344345, -0.0001856287708505988, 0.030906639993190765, -0.03876136615872383, 0.03261863812804222, 0.03308907151222229, 0.03893039748072624, 0.019619252532720566, 0.04604470357298851, -0.048195697367191315, -0.02639831230044365, -0.01173324603587389, 0.06923753768205643, -0.07588333636522293, 0.02011115290224552, -0.02606768161058426, -0.08235577493906021, -0.03767605498433113, 0.02175091952085495, 0.01111458707600832, -0.013344384729862213, 0.011323713697493076, -0.04174114763736725, 0.010370982810854912, -0.00541742192581296, -0.020283058285713196, -0.03412467613816261, 0.0012613151920959353, 0.015311368741095066, 0.02613736316561699, -0.03701711446046829, -0.03506995365023613, 0.03728213161230087, 0.03143542632460594, -0.09586893022060394, 0.01998484879732132, 0.07381837069988251, -0.01708264648914337, 0.024986648932099342, 0.001924957032315433, 0.008213935419917107, -0.007808342110365629, 0.08539979159832001, -0.00032161272247321904, 0.07520029693841934, -0.0018408632604405284, 0.011243332177400589, -0.015583752654492855, -0.009452000260353088, -0.0023427652195096016, -0.012128438800573349, -0.014406376518309116, 0.000562475819606334, -0.06474597752094269, 0.015018930658698082, 0.06188712641596794, 0.010190824046730995, 0.007554356940090656, 0.04435684159398079, 0.015805598348379135, -0.04412752762436867, -0.0028332725632935762, 0.04524131119251251, 0.049961261451244354, -0.009927400387823582, 0.006534956861287355, 0.014401200227439404, 0.002252132399007678, -0.01329949963837862, -0.018322933465242386, -0.044942039996385574, -0.006892087869346142, 0.04791030287742615, -0.003777345409616828, -0.021036744117736816, -0.06160638481378555, -0.015445181168615818, 0.00836738757789135, -0.005300581920892, 0.024176383391022682, 0.04066137224435806, 0.018339375033974648, -0.019989371299743652, 0.039119135588407516, -0.03279145807027817, -0.005198105238378048, -0.05288618430495262, 0.06137556582689285, 0.036605700850486755, -0.001659217057749629, 0.023972945287823677, -0.016459722071886063, 0.05418248102068901, -0.010469295084476471, -0.005564965773373842, 0.09577494114637375, 0.019258635118603706, 0.01649247668683529, 0.014284445904195309, -0.023541782051324844, -0.014929902739822865, 0.06729208678007126, 0.011770689859986305, -0.019092563539743423, 0.08117704093456268, 0.028362015262246132, 0.007770076859742403, 0.03693882003426552, -0.00936851091682911, -0.09110589325428009, -0.031698085367679596, 0.010124348104000092, -0.055818796157836914, 0.041966360062360764, 0.0009590588160790503, 0.010449327528476715, 0.02532212808728218, -0.020438723266124725, 0.007067896891385317, 0.050126105546951294, -0.038179825991392136, 0.04764263331890106, 0.004503421951085329, 0.03327147662639618, 0.018285268917679787, 0.023237600922584534, 0.014199434779584408, -0.007805954664945602, -0.003300912445411086, 0.002107333391904831, -0.011606133542954922, 0.035368382930755615, 0.017997296527028084, 0.027022136375308037, -0.0019127099076285958, 0.03544262424111366, -0.010741099715232849, 0.030405191704630852, -0.01613324135541916, -0.05850300192832947, -0.027124404907226562, -0.002160673961043358, 0.028631772845983505, 0.03780417889356613, 0.021871346980333328, 0.0012694699689745903, -0.012252085842192173, 0.006272332742810249, -0.07249152660369873, 0.03196132183074951, 0.009430586360394955, 0.02892107330262661, -0.038307517766952515, 0.06197534501552582, -0.02316354028880596, 0.046795353293418884, -0.02589985728263855, 0.0043328446336090565, -0.015152853913605213, -0.015811746940016747, -0.05734463408589363, 0.015267658978700638, -0.03658954054117203, -0.01537236850708723, 0.020461928099393845, -0.03623218834400177, -0.035954054445028305, -0.021970560774207115, 0.0038842863868921995, -0.012562872841954231, 0.034601666033267975, 0.026656456291675568, -0.019448747858405113, 0.06407155841588974, 0.03622102737426758, 0.018372489139437675, 0.05738861486315727, -0.03703329339623451, -0.03786810487508774, 0.009827835485339165, 0.029995763674378395, -0.023110628128051758, 0.015878671780228615, -0.0025023813359439373, 0.03016493283212185, 0.02064822055399418, -0.010910045355558395, 0.012246008031070232, -0.05698457732796669, 0.01024288684129715, -0.07305728644132614, 0.05037127807736397, -0.005237432662397623, -0.058963365852832794, -0.011042519472539425, -0.002914606826379895, -0.024923676624894142, -0.039660658687353134, -0.028403673321008682, 0.07619313895702362, 0.030863942578434944, 0.02297389693558216, -0.04312559589743614, -0.013050361536443233, -0.023042334243655205, 0.05525092035531998, -0.02734806202352047, 0.016394343227148056, -0.002751080086454749, 0.004286748357117176, 0.022493047639727592, 0.000957752054091543, -0.08047810196876526, -0.016271322965621948, 0.004388167057186365, -0.024054499343037605, 0.014902392402291298, 0.0075822994112968445, 0.01178324781358242, -0.001871985848993063, -0.016293426975607872, -0.012420479208230972, -0.0023792951833456755, -0.041664447635412216, 0.0729028731584549, 0.05501880124211311, 0.026311272755265236, -0.012368397787213326, -0.0005164614995010197, -0.044375743716955185, 0.04081520065665245, 0.048994217067956924, 0.016806865110993385, -0.023917600512504578, 0.002377372467890382, -0.05515294522047043, -0.02109716087579727, -0.03345019742846489, 0.006354409735649824, 0.04810282960534096, -0.010825098492205143, 0.018022146075963974, -0.005912971682846546, 0.027932599186897278, 0.046539828181266785, -0.052021950483322144, 0.003912143409252167, 0.052846163511276245, 0.010228795930743217, 0.03198407590389252, 0.054393112659454346, -0.015097204595804214, 0.027271434664726257, -0.017833057790994644, -0.032767631113529205, -0.021485263481736183, -0.046721700578927994, 0.003733907826244831, 0.03282005712389946, -0.028814898803830147, -0.013936271890997887, 0.055039189755916595, 0.04233606904745102, 0.04742901399731636, 0.013605223968625069, -0.0041665262542665005, -0.0007347279461100698, 0.03902224451303482, 0.0429612472653389, 0.06034732237458229, 0.03309774026274681, 0.02130705490708351, -0.03712666779756546, 0.01188481692224741, -0.011592810973525047, -0.010862275958061218, 0.032827265560626984, -0.003306033555418253, 0.019765814766287804, 0.003612245200201869, 0.01512824185192585, 0.014269156381487846, -0.009102586656808853, -0.049602556973695755, -0.008999460376799107, -0.0351942777633667, 0.047426488250494, 0.015635289251804352, 0.014538628049194813, 0.05727938190102577, 0.039400264620780945, -0.03466789424419403, 0.02956637553870678, -0.027598222717642784, 0.014653390273451805, 0.020854702219367027, -0.032048068940639496, 0.05543132871389389, 0.0022779081482440233, 0.0131455659866333, -0.0005747341201640666, 0.006704402156174183, 0.06322388350963593, -0.03381397947669029, -0.0024843087885528803, -0.03474947437644005, -0.048472195863723755, 0.04218732565641403, 0.04356846213340759, -0.009562632068991661, 0.03452686965465546, -0.042998384684324265, -0.05488934367895126, -0.04016260430216789, -0.02626076713204384, -0.0249846912920475, 0.015195564366877079, 0.06344719231128693, -0.029010798782110214, 0.0010872099082916975, -0.05334830284118652, -0.07639167457818985, 0.026064343750476837, -0.023748161271214485, -0.05165635421872139, 0.012512910179793835, 0.007559408899396658, 0.0538378581404686, 0.041510775685310364, -0.017658494412899017, 0.06880854070186615, -0.022935057058930397, 0.038989488035440445, 0.03976517170667648, -0.030426960438489914, 0.00868174433708191, -0.008118724450469017, 0.018206322565674782, 0.023898763582110405, -0.03892616182565689, 0.04291682317852974, 0.027872169390320778, -0.022403312847018242, -0.013455965556204319, -0.029622193425893784, 0.018986977636814117, -0.03603002801537514, 0.023903995752334595, 0.01189883891493082, 0.008623708039522171, 0.08063265681266785, -0.015108712948858738, -0.05164234712719917, 0.031137851998209953, -0.017073120921850204, -0.01256028562784195, -0.023718638345599174, 0.015252839773893356, 0.028825121000409126, 0.06857138872146606, 0.03678812086582184, -0.01987493224442005, -0.011011159047484398, 0.021145857870578766, -0.009268254041671753, -0.012708654627203941, -0.033322226256132126, 0.04453609511256218, 0.004200024995952845, -0.013728184625506401, -0.04361526668071747, 0.07229538261890411, 0.08150823414325714, 0.06237802281975746, -0.006679821293801069, -0.033647678792476654, 0.017567044124007225, -0.013334646821022034, 0.004588935058563948, -0.005342437420040369, 0.04431920126080513, 0.04852068051695824, -0.016067003831267357, -0.01088731549680233, 0.019542507827281952, -0.007877830415964127, 0.07611414045095444, 0.026474960148334503, 0.0320134274661541, -0.051197346299886703, 0.018126782029867172, -0.05227702483534813, -0.04693475365638733, -0.010418549180030823, 0.037946559488773346, -0.0009533556294627488, -0.03260425105690956, -0.0029679490253329277, 0.04761763662099838, -0.040419407188892365, -0.06346654891967773, 0.04511517658829689, -0.03523555025458336, 0.020473673939704895, -0.05229445919394493, -0.023468831554055214, 0.05685795843601227, 0.025514114648103714, -0.03916715830564499, 0.02097541280090809, -0.015866609290242195, -0.024270158261060715, 0.036383241415023804, -0.0013687564060091972, -0.025902768597006798, -0.015245483256876469, -0.024965092539787292, -0.041784316301345825, -0.058270931243896484, -0.038051407784223557, 0.02103508822619915, -0.027025295421481133, -0.0008308264659717679, -0.03377876430749893, -0.01077784039080143, -0.014119891449809074, -0.00161369435954839, -0.04501480981707573, 0.034578368067741394, -0.011356060393154621 ]
<p>Given some observable $\mathcal O \in \mathcal H$ it is simple to construct a CP (completely positive) map $\Phi:\mathcal{H}\mapsto \mathcal{H}$ that conserves this quantity. All one has to observe is that $$ \text{Tr}(\mathcal O \, \Phi[\rho]) = \text{Tr}(\Phi^*[\mathcal O] \rho).$$ Therefore, if we impose $\Phi^*[\mathcal O] = \mathcal O$, then $\text{Tr}(\mathcal O \, \Phi[\rho])=\text{Tr}(\mathcal O \rho), \; \forall \rho\in \mathcal H$. That amounts to impose that the Kraus operators of $\Phi^*$ should commute with $\mathcal O$.</p> <p>I'd like, however, to construct a trace-preserving CP map for which the expectation value of $\mathcal O$ does not increase for any $\rho \in \mathcal H$. More explicitly, given $\mathcal O\in \mathcal H$, I want to construct $\Gamma:\mathcal H \mapsto \mathcal H$ such that $$ \text{Tr}(\mathcal O\, \Gamma[\rho]) \le \text{Tr}(\mathcal O \rho), \; \forall \rho \in \mathcal H .$$</p> <p>How would you go about that? Any ideas?</p>
g6633
[ -0.0463545061647892, -0.03593610227108002, -0.020290065556764603, -0.014598428271710873, 0.05574283003807068, 0.015966499224305153, 0.016926463693380356, 0.020368536934256554, -0.03421960026025772, -0.01709112711250782, -0.0019916279707103968, -0.004809324163943529, 0.022051770240068436, 0.03994215279817581, -0.016707224771380424, 0.06118433550000191, -0.00996400136500597, 0.004400775767862797, -0.018874043598771095, 0.01460742112249136, -0.0390341691672802, -0.0013887598179280758, 0.04609113186597824, 0.001123229507356882, 0.05097733065485954, -0.006938100792467594, 0.04770527780056, 0.017901824787259102, 0.008458451367914677, -0.03131939843297005, 0.03209945559501648, -0.008550796657800674, 0.013706986792385578, -0.009789057075977325, -0.047551557421684265, 0.014326394535601139, 0.04184681177139282, 0.06947380304336548, 0.038248155266046524, 0.00786143820732832, 0.036343153566122055, -0.01957111433148384, 0.039472248405218124, 0.013774176128208637, -0.010197022929787636, -0.001497879857197404, -0.0012036326806992292, 0.03479819372296333, 0.027746735140681267, 0.001136053237132728, -0.015693126246333122, 0.027817843481898308, 0.01171023678034544, -0.012133433483541012, 0.002933499636128545, 0.02380778267979622, 0.0006361700361594558, -0.0645580068230629, -0.01212812028825283, -0.004313787445425987, -0.007635803893208504, -0.07837989181280136, 0.04923084378242493, 0.021446997299790382, 0.013745701871812344, 0.024579688906669617, -0.030619004741311073, 0.012639946304261684, -0.03742878884077072, 0.03036215342581272, -0.02176346816122532, 0.0600176639854908, 0.018777206540107727, -0.003199951956048608, -0.053452782332897186, 0.04349832981824875, -0.0023642675951123238, 0.01336135808378458, 0.04424944147467613, -0.009002205915749073, -0.03621259704232216, 0.009157177992165089, 0.07252877205610275, 0.05742306634783745, -0.005154259502887726, 0.05826954543590546, 0.03387479484081268, -0.02427259460091591, -0.03528936579823494, -0.005172667559236288, 0.009724079631268978, -0.053904902189970016, 0.035353075712919235, -0.0033914009109139442, 0.054818861186504364, 0.015548975206911564, -0.005576504860073328, 0.01147354207932949, 0.04147084429860115, -0.025375260040163994, 0.03658601641654968, -0.008594289422035217, 0.03161325678229332, -0.030957020819187164, -0.01111580803990364, -0.028010064736008644, 0.04523333162069321, -0.023782595992088318, -0.00492411432787776, 0.02187860943377018, 0.04365431144833565, -0.017885297536849976, -0.029241757467389107, -0.050366077572107315, -0.015881989151239395, 0.005228539928793907, 0.03992646560072899, 0.018942266702651978, -0.015072178095579147, 0.02102554962038994, -0.003242037957534194, -0.012096705846488476, 0.007805502973496914, 0.028882352635264397, 0.015968019142746925, 0.05554413050413132, -0.03852427005767822, -0.002003749832510948, 0.07082872837781906, -0.0016865675570443273, 0.00511731905862689, 0.026961499825119972, -0.0014995213132351637, 0.033026114106178284, -0.04168635234236717, -0.019935976713895798, -0.0475015826523304, 0.012821580283343792, 0.04515039548277855, -0.051789551973342896, -0.07666515558958054, -0.011723808944225311, -0.008259272202849388, 0.03604749217629433, 0.026323039084672928, -0.06579285115003586, 0.022439394146203995, -0.039510421454906464, 0.1023310124874115, -0.020825650542974472, -0.007064509205520153, 0.05701301991939545, -0.04297996684908867, 0.05435064435005188, 0.00891746673732996, 0.006077669095247984, 0.037851423025131226, -0.03003854490816593, -0.046927936375141144, 0.003491699695587158, -0.019534701481461525, 0.008758998475968838, 0.0031598203349858522, -0.0220248531550169, -0.02322029508650303, -0.059045251458883286, 0.053582340478897095, -0.06350147724151611, -0.03038584068417549, -0.014329330064356327, -0.024179868400096893, 0.05133359506726265, 0.053145881742239, -0.000627513334620744, -0.03413321077823639, -0.056143444031476974, -0.06285372376441956, 0.012107468210160732, 0.010481237433850765, 0.001894516171887517, -0.05413137748837471, -0.05172491818666458, -0.000343181483913213, 0.013330892659723759, 0.00036275730235502124, -0.02166293002665043, -0.07034824788570404, -0.012428953312337399, -0.07397769391536713, 0.015080547891557217, 0.01342836394906044, -0.009620456956326962, 0.0001473135343985632, 0.052587997168302536, -0.0008626988274045289, 0.0035921563394367695, -0.011397657915949821, -0.057240523397922516, -0.01977686583995819, 0.032131511718034744, 0.029809923842549324, -0.009360874071717262, 0.004656641744077206, 0.031093884259462357, 0.004295916296541691, -0.009501320309937, 0.00656133983284235, -0.05068756639957428, 0.020013729110360146, -0.003044161479920149, 0.015094207599759102, -0.08124859631061554, 0.0013459279434755445, -0.018740670755505562, 0.008062539622187614, -0.0603671669960022, -0.018940772861242294, 0.013656348921358585, 0.011080797761678696, -0.06714396178722382, -0.015752339735627174, -0.023172063753008842, 0.0966884195804596, 0.07044001668691635, -0.08460187911987305, 0.04334164410829544, 0.00819172989577055, 0.01312434021383524, -0.016768788918852806, -0.004832219798117876, -0.011413407512009144, 0.01949203573167324, -0.05879319831728935, -0.001992075936868787, 0.03919525071978569, 0.04473869875073433, -0.050846848636865616, 0.07383663952350616, -0.043523043394088745, 0.014703216962516308, 0.023806141689419746, 0.023533206433057785, 0.020886026322841644, 0.0363776795566082, 0.04545518755912781, -0.04149574413895607, 0.05206730216741562, 0.0775216594338417, -0.012034313753247261, 0.032517511397600174, -0.05456569418311119, 0.026497434824705124, 0.03252110630273819, -0.047596678137779236, 0.018249399960041046, -0.023288168013095856, 0.011623878963291645, -0.04498664662241936, -0.01383946556597948, 0.00366421602666378, -0.04156429320573807, -0.036462027579545975, -0.0195253174751997, -0.024731451645493507, -0.000705534010194242, -0.006437093485146761, -0.006282855290919542, 0.004453766625374556, -0.0019686652813106775, 0.03345761075615883, -0.02134772576391697, 0.01815136894583702, 0.022654030472040176, 0.08233091235160828, -0.042151354253292084, -0.05260506272315979, -0.021172860637307167, -0.0011935995426028967, 0.015379411168396473, -0.0027714385651052, 0.05509527027606964, -0.022723866626620293, 0.0007397879380732775, 0.012453729286789894, -0.018150290474295616, -0.07466291636228561, -0.005361414980143309, 0.0005592532688751817, 0.042457472532987595, 0.05709698796272278, -0.02615106664597988, 0.020464323461055756, 0.009849421679973602, 0.020152851939201355, 0.023866096511483192, 0.005290720146149397, -0.021836601197719574, 0.002288177842274308, 0.0638013556599617, -0.01789546199142933, -0.0117284394800663, 0.011885834857821465, 0.03281603008508682, 0.019670885056257248, 0.052418727427721024, 0.020418260246515274, -0.04900413379073143, -0.0187798123806715, 0.009880832396447659, 0.001431447104550898, 0.003275218652561307, -0.06570356339216232, -0.0645880326628685, -0.04967191815376282, 0.03134221211075783, -0.019468260928988457, -0.008752407506108284, -0.025229426100850105, -0.020470470190048218, -0.03936068341135979, 0.010065258480608463, -0.0417509526014328, 0.010788059793412685, -0.011502006091177464, 0.022983135655522346, 0.034178297966718674, -0.043672576546669006, 0.025938918814063072, 0.02293095365166664, -0.02890692465007305, 0.02864302136003971, 0.023092731833457947, 0.04208509251475334, -0.00458397576585412, -0.020217780023813248, -0.04346868395805359, 0.005243058316409588, -0.0015145811485126615, 0.014271574094891548, -0.03137408196926117, 0.003052202984690666, -0.034975770860910416, -0.054742760956287384, -0.004470130894333124, 0.005100706126540899, -0.036104317754507065, 0.011818013153970242, -0.011941758915781975, 0.08377699553966522, -0.06911769509315491, 0.003819570178166032, -0.041545845568180084, 0.08105555176734924, -0.02985934168100357, 0.012511814013123512, 0.030662978067994118, 0.01826043613255024, 0.03956916555762291, 0.043118298053741455, 0.007840480655431747, -0.011652426794171333, -0.03917673975229263, -0.04306310415267944, -0.002473750151693821, -0.04227469488978386, 0.011630123481154442, 0.059539951384067535, -0.01987098529934883, 0.015577636659145355, 0.023663882166147232, 0.030441300943493843, 0.02718193270266056, 0.008809366263449192, -0.009583634324371815, 0.013701457530260086, -0.054875850677490234, 0.02419397421181202, 0.0108128497377038, 0.000826752046123147, 0.0602370984852314, -0.06175814941525459, 0.04044107720255852, 0.04236900806427002, -0.02218429371714592, 0.029338721185922623, -0.029623450711369514, -0.00303148222155869, 0.002844860078766942, -0.008918729610741138, -0.02820710465312004, -0.005456812679767609, 0.008913609199225903, -0.0026162490248680115, 0.00017888452566694468, 0.04840478673577309, -0.03663121163845062, -0.00997205451130867, -0.020298583433032036, -0.007252700626850128, 0.031224332749843597, 0.00614508893340826, -0.01367779541760683, 0.013308091089129448, -0.04711700603365898, -0.05059339478611946, -0.06713451445102692, 0.10660809278488159, 0.07715961337089539, 0.001631382154300809, -0.011036568321287632, -0.03306591138243675, -0.052719417959451675, 0.04266795516014099, -0.01986994408071041, 0.049157049506902695, 0.024549361318349838, 0.005121659953147173, -0.01714382879436016, 0.013686549849808216, 0.01505955122411251, -0.05361536145210266, 0.018081214278936386, -0.014323243871331215, -0.018456749618053436, 0.026765547692775726, 0.04788434877991676, 0.007698428351432085, 0.01581702008843422, -0.003481360152363777, -0.004147957544773817, -0.0034443484619259834, 0.0333203449845314, 0.019053371623158455, 0.027203667908906937, -0.04812129959464073, -0.007099401205778122, -0.12401527911424637, 0.04427138715982437, -0.09202836453914642, 0.0020482486579567194, -0.019183587282896042, -0.002440796233713627, -0.04328560829162598, -0.00619394239038229, -0.03872097283601761, 0.020601851865649223, 0.0007026011007837951, -0.0218493789434433, -0.0213337279856205, 0.045988667756319046, -0.05485035851597786, 0.03687693923711777, 0.009717602282762527, 0.011437472887337208, 0.03264262154698372, -0.04081830754876137, -0.014810249209403992, -0.014985617250204086, 0.08615991473197937, 0.023258216679096222, -0.04010792076587677, -0.032666731625795364, 0.021272514015436172, -0.010629327967762947, 0.07569169998168945, 0.011908654123544693, -0.08984231948852539, 0.006639470811933279, -0.043489888310432434, -0.022534115239977837, -0.017512129619717598, 0.08837573230266571, 0.03904100880026817, -0.045012980699539185, -0.042563438415527344, 0.07507909089326859, -0.02190418913960457, 0.004045139066874981, 0.010065381415188313, 0.018327875062823296, -0.06743641942739487, 0.017870446667075157, 0.01995149627327919, 0.013934536837041378, 0.02870939113199711, 0.053810521960258484, -0.04051407426595688, -0.04947032034397125, -0.010647092945873737, -0.013043002225458622, 0.033216509968042374, 0.041704628616571426, 0.06540685892105103, 0.05335767939686775, -0.0023338235914707184, -0.041586749255657196, -0.011463794857263565, 0.009621698409318924, 0.004347218666225672, -0.008618002757430077, -0.04442044347524643, -0.040215082466602325, -0.032607946544885635, 0.009701544418931007, 0.01469505950808525, 0.026762016117572784, 0.03869253024458885, 0.04337453097105026, 0.011460237205028534, 0.011990280821919441, -0.011816856451332569, 0.025954563170671463, -0.010964767076075077, 0.006015580613166094, -0.0318937674164772, 0.04648042097687721, -0.04783187061548233, -0.0004727527848444879, -0.06481602787971497, -0.1000719740986824, 0.057590287178754807, -0.01678221859037876, 0.013019455596804619, 0.018024509772658348, 0.08008730411529541, 0.07195232063531876, -0.022798752412199974, -0.05956077575683594, 0.045122433453798294, -0.027592696249485016, 0.037283800542354584, -0.09335198253393173, -0.0325547531247139, -0.08022062480449677, -0.009134355001151562, -0.05628969520330429, -0.01227666437625885, 0.0479600764811039, 0.02392447553575039, 0.008407220244407654, -0.0490436926484108, 0.046924006193876266, 0.0165496114641428, 0.061356306076049805, 0.005941352806985378, -0.03994840383529663, -0.035092875361442566, -0.015141488052904606, -0.010547253303229809, 0.00628775916993618, 0.0014612057711929083, -0.012799943797290325, -0.0061596455052495, -0.00493572186678648, 0.06757661700248718, -0.001454037381336093, 0.017586370930075645, -0.0016242775600403547, -0.02167929708957672, -0.0066025517880916595, -0.014132853597402573, -0.014112691394984722, 0.028203487396240234, 0.060179829597473145, 0.03385234624147415, -0.009484559297561646, 0.001445333007723093, -0.028402602300047874, 0.0706300288438797, 0.04098593816161156, -0.013574767857789993, 0.025539297610521317, -0.0011959712719544768, 0.012311034835875034, -0.005235388409346342, 0.006970195099711418, -0.026470854878425598, -0.009294076822698116, 0.0458575077354908, -0.01441638357937336, 0.0026940484531223774, -0.034761857241392136, 0.0057588485069572926, -0.06892403215169907, -0.04675227403640747, 0.04154431074857712, 0.002651395509019494, -0.009994695894420147, 0.061831388622522354, 0.05277718976140022, 0.01461088564246893, 0.04445669427514076, -0.02438838593661785, 0.011902879923582077, 0.04464902728796005, -0.029161011800169945, -0.04663681611418724, -0.00843653455376625, -0.030782027170062065, -0.05193887650966644, 0.024438604712486267, 0.010806816630065441, 0.0834498405456543, -0.06838228553533554, -0.01159269642084837, 0.012047256343066692, -0.03618818148970604, 0.022251766175031662, 0.02278069593012333, -0.01961812749505043, -0.04198666289448738, 0.008932216092944145, -0.03837299719452858, -0.026384321972727776, -0.0042589339427649975, -0.02913593128323555, 0.04874042049050331, 0.06781435012817383, -0.022570235654711723, 0.03457564488053322, -0.040463417768478394, 0.01556306891143322, 0.0012410077033564448, 0.03211585804820061, -0.019241061061620712, -0.03284655138850212, 0.07555130869150162, -0.013772435486316681, 0.030924247577786446, 0.00730855343863368, -0.02323870174586773, 0.07031451165676117, -0.02315625362098217, -0.05657995492219925, 0.002012372948229313, 0.020621569827198982, -0.04177144914865494, 0.024315761402249336, 0.01427350752055645, 0.010764236561954021, 0.011618106625974178, 0.0037003078032284975, 0.04083547741174698, -0.030987540259957314, -0.026620836928486824, -0.04327531158924103, 0.03622567281126976, -0.007317093666642904, -0.06769106537103653, 0.010955573990941048, 0.08311440050601959, 0.02715974673628807, -0.010651023127138615, -0.0683659240603447, -0.02011885493993759, -0.003951107617467642, 0.058627888560295105, 0.041957370936870575, 0.05589045584201813, -0.0028214072808623314, 0.0243461225181818, -0.0795368030667305, 0.012928467243909836, 0.022078007459640503, 0.029024170711636543, -0.0015452451771125197, -0.057385869324207306, -0.0065911561250686646, 0.0215334240347147, -0.015709172934293747, 0.026425674557685852, 0.05302964895963669, -0.008159837685525417, 0.019550157710909843, 0.035333339124917984, -0.0005810914444737136, 0.03031572885811329, 0.054213106632232666, -0.04290332645177841, 0.010924607515335083, -0.03745512664318085, -0.024834901094436646, -0.002680027624592185, -0.03436729684472084, 0.02365047112107277, -0.01778990589082241, -0.0705542266368866, -0.02649286389350891, 0.00748396897688508, -0.001992651494219899, -0.01708958111703396, -0.028083404526114464, 0.036145586520433426, 0.0022698005195707083, 0.025498967617750168, 0.04267304390668869, -0.019956178963184357, 0.009894788265228271, 0.00450082216411829, 0.024601945653557777, 0.003148564137518406, -0.020057352259755135, 0.02568860724568367, -0.01750039868056774, 0.025119919329881668, -0.029786890372633934, -0.03200299292802811, -0.09690862894058228, -0.033951178193092346, -0.020482221618294716, -0.05577121302485466, 0.0013315394753590226, -0.019657038152217865, -0.011449357494711876, 0.09377753734588623, -0.03148087486624718, -0.011670957319438457, -0.023353977128863335, 0.0883929505944252, -0.04129461571574211, -0.007266497705131769, -0.03674152120947838, -0.0098413722589612, -0.03666268289089203, -0.016630135476589203, -0.05657817795872688, -0.023318715393543243, -0.011231360025703907, -0.0015245237154886127, 0.048317402601242065, -0.01111278124153614, -0.06771713495254517, -0.03558310493826866, 0.06254899501800537, -0.0007887142128311098, 0.043775975704193115, -0.01832784339785576, 0.009881734848022461, -0.0019430036190897226, -0.03635099157691002, -0.06291035562753677, -0.05589621886610985, -0.0002644727355800569, -0.021863697096705437, 0.0195908322930336, 0.05705060809850693, 0.02137768268585205, -0.03900140896439552, 0.06840755045413971, -0.05123795196413994, -0.015190492384135723, 0.03234424069523811, -0.014078565873205662, -0.0017322424100711942, -0.0015187151730060577, -0.02785644680261612, 0.03640495613217354, -0.030769865959882736, 0.037959273904561996, 0.020000265911221504, 0.05373430252075195, -0.017083799466490746, -0.052814073860645294, 0.0343858040869236, -0.061041444540023804, -0.037727925926446915, 0.07466711848974228, -0.04598654434084892 ]
<p>I need to find the possible values of energies and impulses of virtual photon emitted by real electron. I don't understand how to compute it (look to the text below). </p> <p>Let's introduce the free electron. Then let's use the frame in which it is at rest. </p> <p>So the laws of energy-momentum conservation take the form $$ E_{0} = E_{1} + E_{photon}, \quad 0 = p_{1} + p_{photon} . $$ According to this, electron after photon emission must be virtual. What to do after that? Formally I have only two equations for four unknown values. What to do next? To use energy-impulse relation $p_{\mu}p^{\mu} = m^2c^2$ for virtual particles?</p>
g6634
[ 0.022122198715806007, -0.03383617848157883, -0.010211775079369545, -0.00836323481053114, 0.005989873316138983, -0.018089473247528076, 0.0016359178116545081, 0.07748852670192719, -0.032876405864953995, 0.014132913202047348, -0.02462651953101158, 0.03675992414355278, 0.016582651063799858, 0.010322903282940388, -0.00043542051571421325, 0.007425595074892044, 0.12196551263332367, 0.020006537437438965, -0.0005244354251772165, 0.0037475954741239548, -0.006630841176956892, -0.019132662564516068, -0.023568926379084587, -0.05249559506773949, 0.005287772975862026, 0.013150759972631931, 0.009997650980949402, 0.03907677158713341, -0.029118746519088745, -0.028271827846765518, -0.010478530079126358, -0.011138688772916794, 0.061648525297641754, 0.005253027658909559, -0.0027356345672160387, -0.0007651867927052081, 0.08858942240476608, -0.004487655591219664, -0.001071658916771412, -0.01753827929496765, -0.023073792457580566, -0.04537775367498398, 0.018114637583494186, 0.012072905898094177, 0.01443287543952465, 0.024916471913456917, -0.0009631774155423045, -0.012848773039877415, 0.015559643507003784, -0.031601134687662125, 0.040197860449552536, 0.05772819370031357, -0.00022645328135695308, -0.0020817748736590147, 0.02925461158156395, 0.0015452464576810598, 0.024047406390309334, -0.0027796169742941856, 0.07016520202159882, 0.023578127846121788, 0.02431711181998253, -0.06051669269800186, 0.009405015036463737, 0.00921181496232748, 0.10335229337215424, -0.01651736907660961, -0.047420844435691833, 0.022216638550162315, -0.03362080082297325, -0.010935526341199875, 0.012560484930872917, -0.027386998757719994, -0.006631991360336542, -0.030912388116121292, 0.012368266470730305, -0.0399126298725605, -0.030598705634474754, -0.0430261492729187, -0.017492834478616714, 0.036355264484882355, -0.015319278463721275, 0.006939467042684555, 0.07503160089254379, -0.017941614612936974, 0.01570536382496357, -0.013109236024320126, -0.03526390716433525, -0.0009447582415305078, -0.01956949755549431, -0.06429688632488251, 0.04021007567644119, -0.025666631758213043, 0.07025327533483505, -0.01812121644616127, 0.021707884967327118, 0.0013436985900625587, -0.0577697828412056, 0.060469165444374084, 0.0187155120074749, -0.02695038728415966, 0.013178694061934948, -0.05687138810753822, 0.009307446889579296, -0.06233036890625954, 0.023788299411535263, -0.04305442422628403, -0.014794597402215004, 0.0021280318032950163, 0.031179916113615036, 0.0004017840838059783, -0.04085918143391609, -0.08970420062541962, -0.03200014680624008, -0.06790398061275482, -0.04105140268802643, -0.023944448679685593, 0.02661559171974659, -0.04602072015404701, -0.008306264877319336, 0.10242452472448349, 0.027981502935290337, -0.01523937750607729, 0.0209937933832407, 0.05843242630362511, 0.036887433379888535, -0.04089120030403137, -0.0066842203959822655, -0.007862482219934464, 0.01013996358960867, -0.005386958830058575, 0.00571067351847887, -0.032412897795438766, 0.009336075745522976, 0.040447745472192764, 0.018360339105129242, 0.010180076584219933, 0.045125238597393036, 0.016886482015252113, 0.027298806235194206, -0.04075542464852333, -0.005766131915152073, -0.018897606059908867, -0.010603716596961021, -0.043845679610967636, -0.07290560752153397, -0.026806460693478584, -0.012060901150107384, -0.050980325788259506, 0.025650113821029663, -0.006837224587798119, 0.05434832721948624, 0.06254949420690536, -0.019745778292417526, -0.02651044726371765, 0.03458642587065697, -0.05256756395101547, 0.012868926860392094, -0.025956472381949425, -0.08523797988891602, 0.01622842252254486, 0.030873602256178856, -0.022398239001631737, 0.019096486270427704, 0.0023652701638638973, 0.012854192405939102, 0.015535062178969383, 0.00129148259293288, -0.07520359009504318, -0.04213091358542442, -0.049781810492277145, -0.027146652340888977, -0.0173760037869215, 0.01609310880303383, 0.011634409427642822, -0.019830740988254547, 0.04284609481692314, -0.008325130678713322, -0.033773597329854965, 0.009469916112720966, 0.04091915115714073, -0.013308743946254253, -0.05480395257472992, 0.05018417537212372, 0.02797059156000614, 0.011223184876143932, 0.02372257597744465, 0.004983484745025635, 0.032655268907547, 0.0049177478067576885, -0.02124808356165886, -0.010665230453014374, 0.028895989060401917, 0.03300055116415024, -0.02129165083169937, -0.043154481798410416, 0.0016731125069782138, 0.009857461787760258, -0.03169352188706398, -0.037468671798706055, 0.027244633063673973, -0.027153175324201584, 0.07900657504796982, -0.016008738428354263, 0.01751951314508915, 0.004419159144163132, -0.0025374034885317087, 0.03776589781045914, -0.02458920143544674, -0.021415814757347107, -0.0031539828050881624, 0.047341488301754, -0.045499227941036224, 0.017913656309247017, 0.03500693663954735, 0.010951134376227856, -0.007988400757312775, -0.007951137609779835, -0.03280871361494064, -0.02758888155221939, 0.01341198105365038, -0.04202093929052353, 0.016777941957116127, 0.05260537937283516, -0.019619332626461983, -0.03174002841114998, 0.02072632499039173, -0.0404001846909523, -0.01779719814658165, 0.007833925075829029, 0.02046952210366726, -0.005457252264022827, 0.042270202189683914, -0.0041619762778282166, -0.027662523090839386, 0.05149947106838226, 0.07383083552122116, -0.048841726034879684, 0.034384287893772125, 0.030440164729952812, -0.00013187942386139184, 0.064463771879673, -0.015393955633044243, 0.06764468550682068, -0.020413782447576523, 0.004703492857515812, -0.03551322966814041, 0.07428158819675446, 0.02712482586503029, -0.021782973781228065, -0.022287385538220406, -0.054214075207710266, 0.011431146413087845, -0.007512653712183237, 0.08083619177341461, -0.05262785777449608, -0.029780542477965355, -0.012418362312018871, 0.02020685374736786, -0.09740503132343292, -0.01901370659470558, 0.006019935477524996, -0.029357170686125755, -0.06905485689640045, 0.06855855882167816, 0.00044012037687934935, 0.004826460033655167, 0.023068564012646675, 0.013709943741559982, -0.009485716931521893, -0.011159214191138744, -0.004094469361007214, 0.04153813421726227, -0.045856721699237823, -0.006727237720042467, 0.03274742513895035, -0.020475367084145546, 0.05581328645348549, 0.0020005875267088413, 0.002746171085163951, -0.04745887964963913, -0.02393130585551262, -0.029002051800489426, -0.008120657876133919, 0.0029109951574355364, 0.02270076796412468, -0.1414434164762497, 0.04441361501812935, 0.016356978565454483, -0.01587997004389763, -0.05404273420572281, -0.0613553412258625, 0.030662810429930687, -0.03514420613646507, 0.012903222814202309, -0.059919361025094986, 0.02405400760471821, 0.06777006387710571, 0.03110348992049694, -0.020081734284758568, 0.017453240230679512, 0.009793504141271114, -0.01747375912964344, -0.007763225585222244, -0.03282700479030609, 0.025458892807364464, 0.02676239237189293, -0.0704665556550026, 0.023354457691311836, 0.0338938944041729, 0.01812453381717205, -0.017775803804397583, 0.033288829028606415, 0.0024325610138475895, -0.06174618378281593, -0.006960228551179171, -0.008645097725093365, 0.031288374215364456, -0.01080159842967987, -0.04200907051563263, 0.0072546484880149364, -0.06585177034139633, -0.04280424863100052, 0.03294873237609863, 0.00043319573160260916, 0.03425245359539986, 0.042955122888088226, -0.052649714052677155, -0.011511360295116901, -0.0037053250707685947, 0.0310768261551857, 0.012852621264755726, 0.007015963550657034, 0.012924487702548504, 0.0026634689420461655, 0.029079614207148552, -0.04473303258419037, -0.01322813332080841, 0.02534538134932518, 0.036069173365831375, -0.06459987163543701, 0.0014529338805004954, 0.025769801810383797, -0.0633307620882988, 0.013444600626826286, 0.04849257692694664, -0.046667423099279404, -0.05370178073644638, 0.04089833050966263, -0.020577190443873405, -0.08770500123500824, 0.006923421286046505, -0.02570091001689434, 0.018922757357358932, 0.00914067029953003, -0.008344287984073162, 0.06426853686571121, 0.010169652290642262, 0.027693284675478935, 0.02972721867263317, -0.007872799411416054, -0.05826808512210846, -0.027809472754597664, 0.06691674888134003, -0.017610281705856323, -0.019208231940865517, -0.04096322879195213, -0.017687669023871422, 0.0032423639204353094, 0.01104048453271389, -0.007649527862668037, 0.05775536969304085, -0.02578035742044449, -0.017048094421625137, -0.0009636000031605363, -0.07916262000799179, -0.014741158112883568, 0.014300419948995113, 0.01495407149195671, -0.02893303707242012, 0.02507486566901207, 0.014297395944595337, 0.005063161253929138, 0.07016943395137787, 0.038176264613866806, 0.04254883527755737, 0.04779372736811638, -0.028941351920366287, 0.038363438099622726, 0.03392500802874565, 0.01937061734497547, 0.049759335815906525, -0.06039327755570412, -0.07005821913480759, -0.01525053195655346, -0.0036504450254142284, -0.02043747901916504, 0.04484423249959946, -0.07925871014595032, -0.03700751066207886, -0.0005255434662103653, -0.005267843138426542, 0.05717695131897926, 0.042194467037916183, 0.010961441323161125, 0.013865700922906399, 0.05812409520149231, 0.0302484892308712, 0.000008780425559962168, 0.018850326538085938, -0.019600413739681244, -0.03551063686609268, 0.016163649037480354, 0.030491504818201065, -0.04589458927512169, -0.04601823911070824, -0.028704017400741577, 0.002410290762782097, -0.04339488223195076, 0.04309919849038124, -0.012218519113957882, 0.018525371327996254, -0.016337133944034576, 0.04756191372871399, -0.061190370470285416, -0.021022174507379532, 0.08401834964752197, 0.07451707124710083, -0.03739793226122856, 0.00926977675408125, -0.011396539397537708, 0.0316353365778923, -0.01271421555429697, 0.010399945080280304, 0.026290226727724075, -0.04133103787899017, 0.027286460623145103, -0.061023078858852386, 0.02135051041841507, -0.023929456248879433, 0.07230032235383987, 0.10319318622350693, 0.019635813310742378, 0.07014203816652298, -0.008815169334411621, 0.01076155062764883, 0.051210369914770126, -0.04050462320446968, -0.03287394344806671, 0.032105568796396255, -0.011305173859000206, 0.0826469212770462, -0.03162309527397156, -0.003840067656710744, -0.036353982985019684, 0.014507207088172436, -0.032573141157627106, -0.019323932006955147, -0.006527455057948828, 0.0389048270881176, 0.03315482661128044, -0.019701343029737473, -0.003120949724689126, 0.014598691835999489, 0.006596371065825224, 0.048344653099775314, -0.003941453993320465, -0.08532139658927917, 0.022225935012102127, -0.027087388560175896, -0.03228403627872467, 0.06662864983081818, -0.006547538097947836, -0.016337836161255836, -0.04256009683012962, 0.004685089457780123, -0.019263435155153275, -0.05417339503765106, 0.010035140439867973, -0.0028468724340200424, 0.0008597444393672049, -0.007995509542524815, -0.0064463065937161446, 0.008246159180998802, 0.022759808227419853, -0.008172356523573399, -0.015398044139146805, -0.023131022229790688, 0.009233403950929642, -0.01525248121470213, -0.029590431600809097, -0.011470256373286247, 0.04106241092085838, -0.050389450043439865, -0.0014227384235709906, 0.07652069628238678, 0.021209752187132835, -0.005623131059110165, 0.03278637304902077, -0.0031307300087064505, 0.007356664165854454, -0.05092222988605499, -0.017317993566393852, -0.042690545320510864, -0.01812257617712021, 0.0216506514698267, 0.018627161160111427, 0.04365244135260582, -0.011853438802063465, -0.012016755528748035, -0.008339786902070045, 0.015553762204945087, -0.030590049922466278, 0.017848920077085495, -0.051048923283815384, 0.0021001624409109354, 0.0036177723668515682, 0.028344951570034027, -0.010294223204255104, -0.007198110222816467, -0.01157298218458891, 0.09555863589048386, 0.005231753457337618, 0.08690577000379562, -0.028655633330345154, 0.0036510443314909935, -0.016063997521996498, 0.0035975580103695393, -0.03705849498510361, 0.03493180125951767, 0.015240340493619442, -0.0076984139159321785, -0.05091528221964836, -0.06208285689353943, 0.012020199559628963, -0.027385447174310684, 0.019849015399813652, -0.026989521458745003, -0.01717614382505417, 0.005415512714534998, 0.011539104394614697, -0.011409563012421131, -0.008177953772246838, 0.00186153466347605, 0.027422942221164703, 0.01980910636484623, -0.01664331741631031, -0.0061873821541666985, -0.0029388475231826305, 0.027171852067112923, 0.015604016371071339, 0.0031739973928779364, -0.0030276011675596237, 0.020628033205866814, -0.05261344835162163, 0.022828781977295876, -0.008514335379004478, 0.04348661005496979, 0.020030273124575615, -0.03435507044196129, 0.014113877899944782, 0.019984178245067596, 0.02455255389213562, 0.011971909552812576, 0.05319579690694809, 0.011926471255719662, 0.0509309321641922, 0.010928978212177753, -0.06289467215538025, -0.0412554033100605, -0.028875205665826797, -0.013164978474378586, 0.004831546917557716, 0.0017011883901432157, -0.016832713037729263, 0.027423975989222527, 0.041908495128154755, 0.060999829322099686, -0.005730749107897282, -0.07698357105255127, -0.012114107608795166, 0.0037097963504493237, 0.053244415670633316, 0.027422316372394562, -0.0064612082205712795, -0.010119414888322353, 0.03838683292269707, -0.023987391963601112, -0.026369865983724594, 0.03045508824288845, -0.029905691742897034, 0.05742647126317024, 0.0014347319956868887, -0.0577361099421978, -0.020529979839920998, -0.0359966978430748, 0.019527530297636986, 0.048151981085538864, -0.07742299139499664, -0.04799971356987953, 0.039865072816610336, 0.05776330828666687, 0.04691087454557419, -0.03809129819273949, -0.016131190583109856, 0.023903945460915565, 0.021067796275019646, -0.01818791776895523, 0.03961601480841637, -0.031547658145427704, 0.01605779118835926, -0.050690799951553345, 0.009676385670900345, 0.01072672288864851, 0.002467980608344078, 0.002989367116242647, -0.02931886911392212, -0.007240956649184227, 0.0648496225476265, 0.014541545882821083, -0.005836845841258764, 0.023899365216493607, -0.049453891813755035, -0.0010401791660115123, 0.00520152784883976, 0.08350448310375214, 0.0039293463341891766, -0.02797766961157322, 0.029655858874320984, 0.09375264495611191, 0.004713563248515129, -0.002021568128839135, -0.03815663978457451, 0.02363838255405426, 0.058875031769275665, 0.03972085192799568, 0.05251492187380791, -0.03187170624732971, 0.06768340617418289, -0.020762739703059196, 0.04767397418618202, 0.009951883926987648, -0.021903827786445618, 0.03494732826948166, 0.019071558490395546, -0.056282807141542435, -0.00390959158539772, 0.0018274409230798483, -0.041560813784599304, -0.015043582767248154, 0.016152942553162575, -0.0019740008283406496, -0.0014215100090950727, 0.04695834219455719, 0.03828714042901993, -0.06222599744796753, -0.01565958373248577, -0.0020925540011376143, -0.011129346676170826, 0.022823425009846687, -0.04850809648633003, -0.013040848076343536, -0.08523614704608917, 0.0294962078332901, 0.001992426346987486, 0.053601861000061035, 0.00214563705958426, -0.008025139570236206, -0.054414331912994385, 0.011670942418277264, -0.03589944541454315, -0.017644770443439484, -0.043710436671972275, -0.07713209092617035, -0.01958596520125866, 0.0002466272853780538, 0.0058565144427120686, -0.012465585954487324, 0.09506049007177353, -0.07451269775629044, -0.004530498757958412, -0.04256764426827431, 0.059766415506601334, -0.06341991573572159, 0.0065464130602777, -0.005036324728280306, 0.026328951120376587, 0.017714276909828186, 0.017573213204741478, -0.010988876223564148, 0.027891743928194046, -0.026309572160243988, -0.003034924855455756, 0.04742198809981346, -0.06327397376298904, 0.005733674857765436, -0.007536624558269978, 0.011817220598459244, -0.03748319298028946, 0.03391876444220543, 0.0009314838680438697, 0.017011627554893494, -0.02793744206428528, 0.06356488913297653, 0.05004708468914032, -0.04316489025950432, 0.003798567457124591, 0.009878904558718204, -0.09253327548503876, -0.01787268929183483, 0.009455590508878231, -0.006024971138685942, -0.04898285120725632, 0.012724760919809341, 0.022472769021987915, 0.026993338018655777, -0.022994032129645348, -0.020350730046629906, 0.0981953963637352, 0.03204500675201416, 0.01815744675695896, -0.007527201436460018, -0.0169194545596838, -0.017903784289956093, -0.006488972343504429, 0.028176860883831978, -0.014090928249061108, -0.0021754915360361338, 0.01257337350398302, 0.0018434333615005016, -0.013011729344725609, -0.05150473862886429, -0.04574952274560928, -0.030467543751001358, 0.016802702099084854, 0.04262230545282364, 0.011226806789636612, 0.022655973210930824, 0.008982725441455841, 0.021477585658431053, 0.03554235398769379, 0.011161407455801964, -0.11395877599716187, -0.014727378264069557, -0.0156727135181427, -0.007375455927103758, -0.07532816380262375, -0.024877864867448807, -0.0011577816912904382, 0.057567447423934937, 0.007038157433271408, -0.00013102177763357759, -0.0027678452897816896, -0.02924031764268875, 0.046515125781297684, 0.07460620254278183, -0.08704342693090439, -0.009447403252124786, 0.008455140516161919, 0.03711044043302536, 0.030358850955963135, -0.018129484727978706, 0.01634235493838787, -0.005174737423658371, 0.01670655980706215, 0.008795049041509628, -0.08743573725223541, -0.012707139365375042, 0.010844703763723373 ]
<p>Quantization of gravity (general relativity) seems to be impossible for spacetime dimension D >= 4. Instead, quantum gravity is described by string theory which is something more than quantization (for example it introduces an infinite number of fields). More direct approaches to quantization of gravity have failed (my opinion; not everyone would agree on this).</p> <p>However, gravity in dimensions D &lt; 4 is special, because it is topological (carries no dynamic degrees of freedom locally). It is possible to quantize gravity coupled to other fields at D = 2: in fact perturbative string theory is exactly that! What about D = 3? Are there approaches to quantization of gravity (coupled to other fields) which have been more successful at D = 3 than at D = 4?</p>
g6635
[ 0.04836403578519821, 0.04639919474720955, 0.002237471519038081, -0.045342616736888885, -0.009300848469138145, 0.056013114750385284, 0.0226230937987566, -0.05022527649998665, -0.07669596374034882, -0.029176626354455948, 0.03936426341533661, -0.024657245725393295, 0.0127084506675601, -0.006568507757037878, -0.017967768013477325, 0.0024522251915186644, 0.014387024566531181, 0.0337430015206337, 0.04699862748384476, -0.0554727241396904, 0.023561138659715652, -0.020684152841567993, 0.05379810556769371, -0.041989438235759735, -0.025914782658219337, -0.030117211863398552, 0.026422036811709404, -0.024710552766919136, -0.008741949684917927, -0.010517604649066925, -0.030775997787714005, -0.0024742642417550087, 0.018249662593007088, 0.029595712199807167, -0.0007582546095363796, -0.04940947890281677, -0.002508187899366021, 0.027553893625736237, -0.008454433642327785, -0.06261114776134491, -0.006997406017035246, -0.0068379612639546394, -0.027873879298567772, 0.01841813698410988, -0.01774042285978794, 0.015560339204967022, -0.001455472782254219, 0.017233580350875854, 0.04485685005784035, -0.0008118526311591268, 0.0026890470180660486, 0.08606830984354019, 0.03803272172808647, -0.03413434699177742, 0.053416237235069275, 0.011270283721387386, 0.01873217150568962, 0.01609034277498722, 0.0299547016620636, 0.055006325244903564, -0.009914358146488667, 0.04159830883145332, 0.015922680497169495, 0.010345477610826492, 0.02644382230937481, 0.03530624136328697, -0.03721123933792114, -0.030498482286930084, 0.020470894873142242, -0.06324180215597153, 0.03728247433900833, -0.07129967212677002, 0.036200232803821564, 0.031836505979299545, 0.001225836924277246, 0.04383089765906334, -0.026308514177799225, 0.009705285541713238, -0.03943348303437233, -0.010745923034846783, -0.015660326927900314, -0.00495596369728446, -0.04356704279780388, -0.04707081988453865, 0.058833684772253036, -0.027537796646356583, 0.016729796305298805, 0.026305027306079865, 0.025944910943508148, 0.0399676077067852, -0.011506878770887852, 0.0053285760805010796, 0.04239027202129364, 0.05030059069395065, -0.03942158445715904, 0.0066440352238714695, 0.04797119274735451, 0.11686942726373672, -0.02322731539607048, -0.0419870987534523, -0.021254926919937134, 0.05166160687804222, 0.029643651098012924, 0.01527989748865366, 0.004024064168334007, -0.023939019069075584, 0.07554376125335693, 0.034865397959947586, 0.0624631904065609, 0.0016070569399744272, -0.047916147857904434, 0.04007141664624214, -0.012414978817105293, 0.00465846061706543, -0.0694197490811348, 0.0186457596719265, -0.007012238260358572, -0.037799954414367676, -0.05931691452860832, 0.02042289823293686, 0.011321833357214928, 0.041431013494729996, 0.022012151777744293, 0.027076682075858116, -0.026910869404673576, 0.03231291472911835, -0.06035465747117996, -0.010925035923719406, 0.040562693029642105, -0.00008734199946047738, -0.0045953551307320595, -0.03533416613936424, 0.0047022877261042595, 0.027536874637007713, -0.011918674223124981, 0.024662073701620102, -0.02260182425379753, -0.009773507714271545, -0.038744814693927765, 0.06310168653726578, -0.03640418499708176, -0.06201409548521042, -0.004094368312507868, 0.01973867416381836, -0.008810257539153099, 0.006732883397489786, 0.017075195908546448, 0.012496674433350563, -0.00787370279431343, 0.008727556094527245, 0.03944697231054306, 0.050529345870018005, 0.05550793185830116, -0.04822731018066406, 0.011749399825930595, 0.036555659025907516, -0.014577721245586872, 0.0028984295204281807, 0.011187508702278137, 0.006985981948673725, -0.00813011359423399, 0.032953664660453796, -0.031871307641267776, -0.06007647141814232, 0.04837606102228165, 0.0307049211114645, 0.06442267447710037, -0.028099671006202698, -0.012446374632418156, -0.034427460283041, -0.04319113492965698, -0.003806181252002716, 0.022268271073698997, 0.026322484016418457, -0.02956622838973999, 0.007519800215959549, -0.06811197847127914, 0.008481744676828384, -0.13300497829914093, 0.00830016192048788, 0.08824483305215836, -0.022639427334070206, -0.008753488771617413, -0.06220315769314766, 0.0032586748711764812, 0.04757803678512573, 0.028719646856188774, -0.026878399774432182, 0.01524004340171814, 0.018111905083060265, -0.05066680163145065, 0.019016647711396217, 0.06355845183134079, 0.00727224163711071, 0.007584556937217712, -0.013597645796835423, 0.0460960790514946, -0.01729961484670639, 0.005996303167194128, 0.002734281588345766, 0.007834019139409065, 0.04776680842041969, 0.06133396923542023, 0.0036737381014972925, 0.06702814996242523, 0.005417016334831715, -0.05373706296086311, 0.06373855471611023, 0.017138823866844177, 0.005724079441279173, 0.05142902210354805, -0.01720556803047657, 0.03361840918660164, -0.012781830504536629, -0.026004130020737648, 0.020514989271759987, 0.008200835436582565, 0.031176621094346046, -0.01748163066804409, 0.08077845722436905, 0.01591493748128414, -0.00022190903837326914, 0.09566591680049896, 0.06483975052833557, -0.039815183728933334, -0.013169498182833195, -0.05640658363699913, 0.01641264744102955, -0.0002709509280975908, -0.00022778984566684812, -0.041480548679828644, -0.03631583973765373, -0.022682132199406624, -0.02130313590168953, -0.0013383427867665887, 0.029131906107068062, -0.021118929609656334, -0.09128188341856003, 0.022192930802702904, 0.019802870228886604, 0.05017276108264923, 0.025188015773892403, -0.015594192780554295, -0.05119987204670906, 0.04697701334953308, -0.03589484468102455, -0.023966288194060326, 0.028451375663280487, -0.03008710965514183, 0.024183716624975204, -0.0062055764719843864, 0.003525611711665988, -0.02805478312075138, -0.009154282510280609, 0.03565264120697975, 0.04504095017910004, 0.06203000992536545, 0.029670774936676025, -0.05584334954619408, -0.016248252242803574, -0.0076897647231817245, -0.039547890424728394, 0.04748310521245003, 0.00779788987711072, -0.037685688585042953, -0.019171861931681633, -0.025904439389705658, 0.011330584064126015, -0.01607789658010006, 0.018668828532099724, -0.08431088924407959, 0.012529542669653893, -0.003421878907829523, 0.023386836051940918, 0.0015987860970199108, 0.019461067393422127, 0.016683857887983322, 0.028567349538207054, -0.014344636350870132, -0.02721187099814415, 0.003735005622729659, 0.009395408444106579, -0.023488739505410194, -0.020383434370160103, 0.03407180309295654, -0.028604883700609207, -0.02014555223286152, -0.02265860140323639, -0.006834285333752632, -0.001932348357513547, 0.04683854058384895, 0.005410900805145502, -0.04805775731801987, 0.03368240222334862, 0.005256797652691603, 0.033925194293260574, -0.06955987960100174, -0.002396135590970516, -0.006681548431515694, 0.013788643293082714, 0.022488972172141075, 0.004919647704809904, 0.021077895537018776, 0.02958398126065731, 0.038267869502305984, -0.0574081651866436, -0.059583019465208054, -0.039907459169626236, -0.023940425366163254, -0.03815114498138428, 0.00603870814666152, 0.007693212479352951, -0.007239201571792364, 0.017307814210653305, -0.019976109266281128, -0.00470660999417305, 0.06155332922935486, -0.022624189034104347, -0.011812363751232624, -0.04157750681042671, 0.035579975694417953, 0.009464513510465622, -0.0447382926940918, -0.048814643174409866, -0.011543993838131428, 0.07582435011863708, -0.02504129521548748, 0.00864299014210701, -0.032385580241680145, 0.03205617889761925, 0.03517080470919609, -0.0115505987778306, -0.0319301076233387, 0.024884629994630814, -0.0464446134865284, 0.0003386420721653849, -0.07559105008840561, -0.015418085269629955, 0.06740225106477737, -0.007336546201258898, -0.007720813155174255, -0.01501193642616272, -0.051071297377347946, -0.010469927452504635, -0.0006103772320784628, 0.08864415436983109, 0.01560937613248825, 0.026853883638978004, -0.002214273205026984, 0.029381200671195984, -0.0069809104315936565, -0.02208336628973484, 0.018905196338891983, 0.034939028322696686, -0.004453952424228191, 0.07719230651855469, 0.022090652957558632, 0.08237557858228683, -0.028936324641108513, -0.04624709486961365, 0.0071131023578345776, 0.028101133182644844, -0.006569047924131155, 0.012003447860479355, -0.004626106005162001, -0.03507830575108528, 0.04226578399538994, -0.0473695732653141, -0.0446859672665596, 0.015622524544596672, 0.048520948737859726, -0.011841489002108574, 0.0030558244325220585, -0.017096225172281265, 0.0858030840754509, -0.06637337058782578, -0.026272311806678772, -0.03239112347364426, -0.0030904822051525116, 0.0092649906873703, 0.0379142165184021, 0.0438753217458725, 0.02118692733347416, -0.011834375560283661, -0.014234015718102455, -0.011183120310306549, -0.036385755985975266, -0.014095176011323929, -0.05788775533437729, -0.0033060803543776274, -0.054671693593263626, -0.014366392977535725, -0.005108014214783907, -0.023448342457413673, -0.02180231176316738, 0.013844147324562073, 0.014095278456807137, 0.0021501651499420404, 0.008672746829688549, -0.025112098082900047, 0.007879331707954407, -0.010453070513904095, 0.010876152664422989, -0.015808694064617157, -0.054377324879169464, -0.006777015049010515, 0.022992251440882683, 0.018839821219444275, 0.07735233008861542, -0.004016509745270014, 0.023782728239893913, 0.021232984960079193, 0.015506835654377937, -0.07751748710870743, 0.025613127276301384, -0.0420391745865345, -0.034710273146629333, -0.03281150758266449, 0.016019346192479134, 0.03646044060587883, 0.03952416405081749, 0.08092017471790314, -0.006764307618141174, -0.01511557586491108, 0.035679012537002563, 0.07081708312034607, -0.011913706548511982, -0.004713319707661867, -0.06000414863228798, 0.07932600378990173, 0.09255284070968628, -0.026170333847403526, -0.0043710689060389996, 0.04806015267968178, -0.04573987051844597, 0.0076040239073336124, -0.001977949868887663, 0.05228206142783165, -0.02185879833996296, -0.00910400040447712, 0.0745624378323555, 0.05030867084860802, -0.014848818071186543, -0.014314933679997921, 0.002433424349874258, 0.03847838565707207, -0.03147738799452782, 0.011924095451831818, -0.01252427976578474, 0.040800612419843674, -0.006581588182598352, 0.010448092594742775, -0.05953669920563698, 0.004865245893597603, -0.02443629316985607, -0.003598666051402688, -0.03016490675508976, 0.036819543689489365, -0.022868044674396515, 0.036824531853199005, -0.11228334903717041, 0.008647514507174492, -0.010300660505890846, 0.03560301661491394, -0.023822572082281113, -0.03918085992336273, -0.07227419316768646, -0.01172096561640501, -0.0651736631989479, -0.0005979918059892952, 0.012448396533727646, 0.002453584223985672, -0.03403087705373764, -0.005138548091053963, -0.02837652899324894, 0.0360870286822319, -0.01375574804842472, -0.00451549282297492, 0.027839014306664467, -0.09080885350704193, 0.061587993055582047, -0.0569181852042675, 0.010919426567852497, 0.02875182032585144, 0.0009900325676426291, 0.023442968726158142, -0.03267832100391388, -0.013128183782100677, -0.063868448138237, -0.012911012396216393, -0.007653382141143084, -0.02790112979710102, 0.0018011975334957242, -0.009807989932596684, -0.0380382239818573, 0.020538443699479103, -0.02360907383263111, -0.0427175834774971, -0.02713601663708687, -0.025944149121642113, -0.024437207728624344, 0.00725619588047266, -0.010063385590910912, -0.05567038804292679, -0.045214276760816574, -0.024224961176514626, 0.06304527074098587, -0.026615366339683533, -0.049736738204956055, 0.0768083706498146, -0.04114445298910141, 0.03234817460179329, -0.07486644387245178, 0.016685888171195984, 0.05071977898478508, 0.010941797867417336, 0.03722849488258362, -0.0026808956172317266, 0.052457381039857864, -0.04327831044793129, -0.03323885798454285, -0.003873374778777361, -0.005233860109001398, -0.032483190298080444, 0.10666122287511826, 0.03941794112324715, -0.011097176931798458, 0.013437818735837936, 0.0033995804842561483, -0.01898261345922947, 0.05510516092181206, -0.019243530929088593, 0.026236511766910553, 0.011020494624972343, -0.031501032412052155, 0.014023425057530403, 0.04583987593650818, -0.028790315613150597, 0.0512656532227993, 0.027091067284345627, -0.050706662237644196, 0.014653056859970093, -0.036182429641485214, 0.06862188130617142, 0.01208219863474369, -0.03621258959174156, -0.02105174958705902, 0.010729730129241943, 0.0018608291866257787, -0.021314533427357674, -0.07543379068374634, -0.04272790253162384, -0.016104502603411674, 0.009739449247717857, -0.015775853767991066, -0.00892964843660593, -0.0152589688077569, -0.05259676277637482, -0.001450550276786089, -0.012224584817886353, -0.006450737826526165, 0.03772479668259621, 0.020066015422344208, -0.045504745095968246, -0.07252980768680573, -0.024182189255952835, 0.02341773733496666, -0.02521156519651413, 0.011632701382040977, 0.006282075308263302, -0.039193131029605865, 0.01104716770350933, 0.034452732652425766, 0.07391173392534256, 0.00790057796984911, -0.0573880597949028, 0.06631496548652649, -0.059960272163152695, -0.041665900498628616, -0.004687725566327572, -0.012122875079512596, 0.015541881322860718, 0.05241086333990097, -0.09190744906663895, -0.08356153219938278, 0.07731065154075623, -0.005561059340834618, -0.028821585699915886, -0.02841450832784176, 0.0009831805946305394, -0.026519782841205597, 0.020862789824604988, -0.036445021629333496, 0.015533220022916794, -0.014082626439630985, -0.02471105568110943, 0.042699605226516724, 0.00995643064379692, -0.08656121045351028, 0.04818606376647949, 0.019744478166103363, 0.0028136055916547775, 0.05479355901479721, -0.005442825146019459, -0.0020331935957074165, 0.08367189019918442, -0.05956456437706947, -0.06738080829381943, -0.005998768378049135, 0.03238710016012192, 0.058481670916080475, 0.0012877999106422067, 0.014078056439757347, 0.09884009510278702, 0.009140334092080593, -0.0532282330095768, 0.02043168991804123, -0.02146298997104168, 0.038746174424886703, 0.02417108602821827, 0.0380164235830307, -0.054040487855672836, 0.03358568996191025, -0.006259122397750616, 0.03253386169672012, 0.01911165378987789, 0.017885083332657814, 0.006415146868675947, 0.0057610091753304005, -0.03467610478401184, -0.03039572946727276, -0.03250226005911827, 0.026328762993216515, 0.0169229656457901, 0.007713028695434332, 0.002059048041701317, 0.003224869491532445, -0.02781645767390728, -0.017493506893515587, -0.0005683720810338855, -0.03590446710586548, -0.006196561735123396, 0.05269843339920044, -0.0021035217214375734, -0.0037561929784715176, -0.03804850950837135, 0.0491289384663105, 0.004985260311514139, -0.016084525734186172, 0.002639390993863344, 0.02867022342979908, 0.013665864244103432, 0.008845202624797821, -0.037537433207035065, -0.05373353511095047, 0.01069789007306099, -0.027285080403089523, 0.02622867189347744, 0.02777991071343422, -0.05329987034201622, -0.03869377821683884, 0.011037737131118774, -0.07862555980682373, -0.030330656096339226, -0.006574401166290045, 0.05117224529385567, 0.007628249004483223, 0.021415075287222862, -0.015479318797588348, -0.056820280849933624, 0.0011719631729647517, 0.022632773965597153, -0.01656287908554077, 0.017962589859962463, -0.008872153237462044, -0.03009444661438465, -0.018902605399489403, 0.07952806353569031, 0.03618668019771576, 0.007636458147317171, 0.008958698250353336, 0.03443975746631622, 0.009205475449562073, 0.0008280248730443418, -0.015413695015013218, 0.02960520051419735, 0.028467925265431404, -0.00770841259509325, -0.04727395996451378, 0.032859642058610916, 0.027114644646644592, -0.01284932903945446, -0.017440559342503548, -0.01798923872411251, 0.008112919516861439, 0.03801118955016136, 0.0030997171998023987, -0.03620922565460205, 0.024661235511302948, 0.04720376431941986, 0.006163580808788538, -0.0119670070707798, -0.016726624220609665, -0.041155438870191574, 0.024335848167538643, -0.01953079178929329, -0.007160933688282967, -0.030161617323756218, -0.053188592195510864, 0.04098151996731758, -0.00614937674254179, 0.0417325533926487, -0.03794407472014427, 0.006100452039390802, -0.0039745597168803215, -0.019144123420119286, -0.05561206489801407, -0.05198080092668533, -0.020615175366401672, -0.06651568412780762, -0.0020813122391700745, -0.016274597495794296, -0.005698295310139656, -0.03074839897453785, -0.02356870286166668, 0.009745943360030651, 0.015349059365689754, -0.07964567095041275, 0.04230543598532677, -0.039648059755563736, -0.025537334382534027, 0.009889106266200542, -0.0222892165184021, 0.01627493090927601, -0.06777457147836685, 0.09061665087938309, -0.05945218726992607, -0.016158124431967735, 0.01740163005888462, 0.001622162526473403, -0.02234409563243389, 0.04967690259218216, -0.030040012672543526, 0.0012355896178632975, 0.08167116343975067, 0.024961097165942192, -0.004386947024613619, 0.008467459119856358, 0.033497437834739685, -0.03150944039225578, 0.002584007801488042, 0.008068419061601162, 0.012204347178339958, -0.005253613460808992, 0.015802159905433655, -0.020593803375959396, -0.01073373295366764, -0.03363962098956108, 0.025580067187547684, -0.029180627316236496, -0.019211482256650925, 0.02249578945338726, 0.03535488620400429, -0.011091278865933418, -0.008459514006972313, -0.012032766826450825, 0.01666942611336708, 0.04564506933093071 ]
<p>Does the PV regulator breaks SUSY? </p> <p>Take for instance the 1-loop (top/stop loops) correction to the Higgs squared-mass parameter in the MSSM, and you'll get something like, </p> <p>$$\delta m^2_{h_u} = - 3Y_u^2/(4 \pi^2) m_{\tilde{t}}^2 ln (\frac{\Lambda_{PV}^2}{m_{\tilde{t}}^2})$$ </p> <p>Where, $\Lambda_{PV}$ is the PV regulator/cutoff, and $m_{\tilde{t}}$ is the stop-quark mass. </p> <p>In my mind, as the calculation is performed before ElectroWeak Symmetry Breaking (EWSB) (i.e. no mass for the top), but at the same time it's considering softly broken susy (i.e. there is mass for the stop-quark), therefore we don't get perfect cancelation. But I heard someone saying that there's no perfect cancelation because PV regulator breaks SUSY!</p> <p>I don't see where the PV breaking SUSY argument fits. Can anyone enlighten me?</p>
g6636
[ -0.010307038202881813, 0.02602449059486389, 0.007846838794648647, 0.009065692313015461, -0.00801057368516922, -0.004481748212128878, 0.010809224098920822, 0.05477768927812576, -0.04113864526152611, 0.06210522726178169, -0.018684428185224533, -0.002806193893775344, -0.02219037152826786, 0.05060511827468872, -0.01080423966050148, 0.06370768696069717, 0.03065173141658306, 0.025078853592276573, 0.049773745238780975, -0.011823075823485851, -0.08507389575242996, -0.05433235689997673, -0.03198616951704025, -0.0383683517575264, -0.029862070456147194, 0.00981774553656578, 0.018852796405553818, 0.04035573452711105, -0.0009763878188095987, 0.04189411923289299, 0.0608593188226223, 0.033843256533145905, 0.047095853835344315, -0.08255811035633087, -0.06209369748830795, -0.00868250709027052, 0.052571240812540054, 0.03915422409772873, 0.0009183078072965145, -0.014515146613121033, 0.025711091235280037, -0.06111517921090126, 0.0057326918467879295, -0.042084719985723495, -0.006120940204709768, -0.015753820538520813, -0.0008461858960799873, -0.027295496314764023, 0.0002554296515882015, 0.017848528921604156, 0.023545444011688232, 0.0027105750050395727, 0.02755758911371231, -0.025889132171869278, -0.022852305322885513, -0.0012471245136111975, -0.03756968304514885, 0.011478765867650509, 0.006098488345742226, 0.03748072683811188, -0.0073387762531638145, -0.029023079201579094, 0.03542258217930794, 0.029277266934514046, 0.03447958081960678, -0.009768703952431679, -0.07847245037555695, -0.026842255145311356, -0.0007032696157693863, 0.04964689910411835, 0.009792227298021317, -0.025966797024011612, -0.02529888227581978, -0.05431075766682625, 0.08025673776865005, 0.036181479692459106, -0.022802095860242844, -0.006725892424583435, -0.02217107079923153, -0.030921487137675285, 0.020085105672478676, -0.0411258228123188, -0.02056317776441574, 0.030275344848632812, 0.0245348047465086, -0.058548543602228165, -0.04525428265333176, 0.059216395020484924, -0.055560123175382614, 0.018489288166165352, -0.05437103286385536, -0.015773393213748932, -0.007042506244033575, -0.04481621831655502, 0.0005970348138362169, -0.008230207487940788, 0.04347033053636551, -0.0008012694888748229, -0.016026422381401062, -0.01133832335472107, -0.021991396322846413, 0.05720456689596176, -0.004504446405917406, 0.009062455967068672, -0.04577726870775223, 0.009073792956769466, 0.06535065919160843, -0.044533129781484604, -0.008282375521957874, -0.017460200935602188, 0.0024285721592605114, -0.015622193925082684, -0.011959993280470371, 0.03047347255051136, -0.06788399070501328, -0.017153432592749596, 0.10555167496204376, -0.013012496754527092, -0.0029622556176036596, -0.02200944721698761, -0.010313684120774269, 0.012064443901181221, 0.007029355503618717, 0.06366077810525894, -0.053259532898664474, -0.01638062298297882, 0.006447863765060902, 0.060159191489219666, -0.031593501567840576, 0.017155561596155167, 0.007607434876263142, -0.011892518028616905, -0.0226005706936121, 0.015070400200784206, 0.020968656986951828, -0.011875546537339687, 0.04976119473576546, -0.015058598481118679, 0.07559812068939209, -0.08787450939416885, -0.0658755749464035, 0.047956984490156174, -0.025692326948046684, -0.019985444843769073, -0.046126823872327805, -0.01507963240146637, -0.0052914004772901535, 0.010553928092122078, -0.022087575867772102, 0.00015373578935395926, 0.027644870802760124, 0.07716130465269089, -0.023185331374406815, -0.03181295841932297, -0.03613462671637535, -0.014502495527267456, 0.08092287182807922, 0.0457133986055851, 0.10409723967313766, -0.00018318953516427428, 0.020826702937483788, -0.0006972517003305256, 0.03644563630223274, -0.020304445177316666, -0.0872638151049614, -0.015348277054727077, -0.01449983473867178, -0.005567390006035566, -0.05302705988287926, -0.03086751513183117, -0.09680083394050598, 0.04597631096839905, -0.0027192949783056974, 0.031996648758649826, 0.02226526476442814, 0.027048878371715546, -0.009591317735612392, -0.013197979889810085, 0.004143764264881611, 0.035963837057352066, 0.024044636636972427, -0.008126482367515564, 0.016818255186080933, -0.024259723722934723, -0.003541802056133747, 0.018724314868450165, -0.02156301587820053, 0.0024064737372100353, 0.061091288924217224, 0.02298109419643879, -0.04286953806877136, 0.061782948672771454, -0.0449826754629612, -0.02206536941230297, -0.035659100860357285, 0.01128388475626707, -0.03520562872290611, -0.037416279315948486, -0.05269525200128555, -0.024530695751309395, -0.036795228719711304, 0.016015470027923584, 0.048654742538928986, -0.04913424700498581, -0.031735725700855255, -0.03740663081407547, -0.00016780402802396566, 0.029924316331744194, -0.05265302583575249, 0.03588169068098068, 0.047511640936136246, -0.03571557253599167, 0.024761423468589783, -0.007188527379184961, -0.0432768277823925, -0.01980968751013279, -0.008512897416949272, 0.037568576633930206, 0.01542892586439848, -0.026827242225408554, -0.06410057097673416, -0.010295890271663666, 0.02896992117166519, -0.04182843491435051, -0.028217831626534462, 0.021967163309454918, 0.007926120422780514, -0.03673874959349632, 0.012950499542057514, -0.025980116799473763, -0.03938458859920502, 0.013208786956965923, -0.05743611231446266, -0.03974162042140961, 0.016048412770032883, 0.028093263506889343, -0.025158042088150978, -0.007909776642918587, 0.0022701043635606766, -0.03258740156888962, 0.07582729309797287, 0.016621967777609825, 0.011760435998439789, 0.05684661120176315, 0.06868216395378113, 0.02282363921403885, 0.06841456890106201, 0.009523235261440277, -0.02440814860165119, -0.007322990335524082, 0.04215109720826149, 0.014406825415790081, -0.019258294254541397, 0.03954777866601944, -0.004318118095397949, -0.1039092019200325, -0.01375278178602457, 0.03148622065782547, -0.05790049582719803, 0.0168442539870739, 0.0481296069920063, 0.000638742174487561, 0.02126438543200493, -0.0015993255656212568, -0.011473406106233597, 0.03472557291388512, -0.006765933241695166, -0.013376283459365368, 0.04818671941757202, -0.021811021491885185, -0.004955630749464035, 0.020306354388594627, -0.01049282681196928, 0.018001209944486618, 0.007814099080860615, 0.013095689937472343, -0.01758936606347561, 0.02643194980919361, 0.06701656430959702, -0.053841616958379745, -0.039942823350429535, 0.05090498924255371, -0.006850156933069229, 0.000750253617297858, 0.05542762950062752, -0.01911124773323536, -0.03620951995253563, -0.034540798515081406, -0.023777876049280167, 0.03020169772207737, -0.05173225328326225, -0.1005089282989502, 0.007259363308548927, -0.0015948215732350945, -0.028965448960661888, 0.03668737784028053, 0.003128959098830819, 0.0043793595395982265, 0.0029637387488037348, 0.022210918366909027, -0.007469820324331522, 0.07723363488912582, -0.026208922266960144, 0.013682973571121693, -0.06193004921078682, 0.06874977797269821, -0.011297157034277916, 0.05952350050210953, 0.02707732655107975, -0.07005345076322556, 0.028373228386044502, 0.032095637172460556, 0.0388161726295948, 0.008165696635842323, 0.009958667680621147, 0.0017122639110311866, 0.01598432846367359, -0.028393270447850227, -0.04986147955060005, -0.018764058127999306, -0.11074908822774887, 0.06609096378087997, 0.035929955542087555, 0.008674194104969501, -0.03977226838469505, 0.05864608287811279, 0.018099358305335045, -0.020214857533574104, -0.01847248710691929, 0.0031899549067020416, -0.0008176215342245996, 0.035544253885746, 0.014131286181509495, 0.0728093609213829, -0.027313265949487686, -0.024102799594402313, -0.018874960020184517, 0.022967059165239334, 0.016503900289535522, -0.006319776643067598, -0.0564795657992363, 0.048230525106191635, 0.016123343259096146, 0.024327389895915985, 0.02095078118145466, 0.03314505144953728, 0.002402115613222122, -0.015261633321642876, 0.02477208711206913, -0.03374619781970978, 0.06394624710083008, 0.024683455005288124, -0.007965601980686188, -0.03522910550236702, 0.014355474151670933, 0.0009978602174669504, 0.01912861503660679, 0.05751630291342735, 0.017004141584038734, -0.03557832911610603, 0.05122532323002815, 0.02520315907895565, 0.0382104329764843, -0.020146729424595833, -0.04491868615150452, 0.01597500406205654, -0.0047205714508891106, 0.012814055196940899, -0.04891312122344971, -0.05941672623157501, 0.007096365559846163, -0.018311817198991776, 0.007375900633633137, -0.014818633906543255, -0.0380377396941185, -0.022261247038841248, 0.012392131611704826, 0.03559080883860588, 0.03975678235292435, 0.03081274963915348, 0.013082055374979973, 0.02305394411087036, 0.003875523107126355, -0.017958922311663628, 0.003946240060031414, 0.00966258067637682, -0.016438977792859077, -0.022332198917865753, -0.07254228740930557, -0.051605407148599625, 0.029808495193719864, -0.009034335613250732, -0.0017716488800942898, -0.004607726354151964, 0.02322702296078205, -0.008063453249633312, 0.012246964499354362, 0.015341157093644142, -0.055198609828948975, -0.015467831864953041, -0.021072961390018463, 0.04698989912867546, -0.0011704823700711131, -0.047581687569618225, 0.03797857463359833, -0.016143351793289185, 0.004599529784172773, 0.04181342571973801, 0.05528758466243744, 0.025364235043525696, -0.01516338437795639, 0.027907341718673706, -0.012736303731799126, -0.07901188731193542, -0.02928381785750389, -0.009940276853740215, -0.016946692019701004, 0.0014898123918101192, 0.05483848601579666, -0.030905432999134064, 0.0074563114903867245, -0.025774842128157616, -0.03132234513759613, -0.04912376403808594, 0.0018967732321470976, 0.009772738441824913, 0.024237528443336487, 0.004694943781942129, 0.030945077538490295, -0.018396852537989616, 0.06939432770013809, -0.0020667477510869503, -0.04853544011712074, 0.02397834323346615, -0.02242649532854557, -0.0003989229444414377, -0.0131171103566885, -0.0010418263264000416, -0.0619608573615551, 0.035839248448610306, 0.13108466565608978, -0.07689131051301956, -0.00436696782708168, 0.009748647920787334, -0.014215050265192986, -0.016050145030021667, 0.03806207329034805, -0.03885417431592941, 0.020273709669709206, 0.010776236653327942, -0.04716501757502556, -0.011118829250335693, 0.004071125295013189, -0.008725634776055813, -0.029222754761576653, -0.019586503505706787, -0.025377420708537102, 0.017588559538125992, 0.023767618462443352, 0.030648626387119293, -0.007625060621649027, -0.046485915780067444, 0.0018462943844497204, 0.04345007613301277, 0.06757039576768875, 0.002231146674603224, -0.06096304580569267, -0.03530074283480644, -0.005504177417606115, 0.036611177027225494, -0.009759216569364071, 0.0500299371778965, -0.008629794232547283, 0.07019126415252686, 0.064468152821064, -0.03549730032682419, -0.016153594478964806, -0.040484149008989334, 0.012465843930840492, -0.027302073314785957, 0.0318559966981411, 0.01039193756878376, 0.029196659103035927, -0.04139157012104988, 0.007376087363809347, -0.001978140790015459, -0.04699078947305679, -0.0783013328909874, 0.023746388033032417, 0.025356298312544823, -0.01684006303548813, 0.10060573369264603, 0.003152135293930769, -0.0920439213514328, 0.04000086337327957, 0.01748335361480713, 0.03680672124028206, -0.033938929438591, -0.05192235857248306, -0.0013185651041567326, -0.011105827987194061, -0.00016775753465481102, 0.021686071529984474, 0.026703132316470146, 0.005036246497184038, 0.05534029379487038, 0.011826976202428341, 0.0064589218236505985, 0.0309272650629282, -0.00871152151376009, 0.0172947458922863, -0.0008578108390793204, 0.02648412436246872, -0.0013173269107937813, -0.009937587194144726, -0.001919992733746767, -0.016521736979484558, 0.010647309944033623, -0.03516411781311035, -0.05031117796897888, 0.012165536172688007, -0.011783985421061516, -0.053766243159770966, -0.01197177916765213, 0.004838057328015566, 0.013279233127832413, -0.08742556720972061, -0.006335628218948841, 0.010898388922214508, 0.004913089796900749, 0.04226617515087128, -0.009400085546076298, 0.04493247717618942, 0.05217180773615837, 0.04892219230532646, -0.06621496379375458, 0.0012598700122907758, -0.005928881466388702, 0.003148303832858801, -0.004185448866337538, -0.015029997564852238, -0.018259387463331223, -0.0016443372005596757, -0.005978990346193314, -0.0033814257476478815, -0.0127011863514781, -0.009117143228650093, 0.015166081488132477, -0.01535720843821764, -0.0008127878536470234, -0.027716584503650665, -0.06118280440568924, 0.018589312210679054, 0.0009619251359254122, -0.03350285068154335, 0.03673485666513443, -0.011939048767089844, 0.03137514367699623, -0.04181993752717972, -0.020882144570350647, -0.051911354064941406, 0.04046223685145378, -0.012780332937836647, -0.0031623251270502806, 0.029979461804032326, 0.0023693640250712633, -0.05211784690618515, 0.036438923329114914, -0.016279254108667374, 0.006583354901522398, 0.05834490433335304, 0.023359494283795357, 0.04167989641427994, 0.03541107848286629, -0.023651599884033203, 0.03329605981707573, -0.053300172090530396, 0.0034232453908771276, -0.02242698334157467, -0.028084712103009224, 0.006184268277138472, -0.02219419740140438, -0.02716602385044098, -0.0772477388381958, 0.02147965133190155, -0.052698466926813126, -0.03311435133218765, -0.013877781108021736, 0.020320672541856766, 0.06136390194296837, 0.019127674400806427, -0.010582294315099716, -0.02452191896736622, 0.054854538291692734, 0.022128166630864143, 0.012431025505065918, 0.018681300804018974, -0.003905493998900056, -0.029595382511615753, 0.008121661841869354, 0.08179552108049393, -0.062048450112342834, -0.017916206270456314, -0.020649369806051254, 0.002680852310732007, 0.067515067756176, 0.019815819337964058, 0.06988369673490524, -0.06173134595155716, -0.03388794884085655, -0.038047391921281815, 0.04212334007024765, 0.021623611450195312, -0.035370003432035446, -0.006426890380680561, -0.03815479576587677, -0.05922141298651695, 0.05075877159833908, -0.0462518185377121, 0.004849836230278015, 0.004439953248947859, 0.0412655770778656, 0.01794523559510708, -0.06487896293401718, 0.03053715080022812, 0.0855032429099083, 0.11312980204820633, -0.013922530226409435, 0.04646331071853638, 0.009118534624576569, 0.0006746617727912962, -0.010371627286076546, 0.03798019140958786, 0.01234501600265503, 0.004363986663520336, 0.041941601783037186, -0.0209538321942091, 0.032768819481134415, -0.00441751116886735, 0.007004388142377138, 0.027108395472168922, 0.01764250546693802, 0.006168525665998459, 0.032061729580163956, -0.017815282568335533, 0.001118966843932867, 0.0520012304186821, 0.007460214197635651, -0.061728112399578094, 0.01184066291898489, 0.0025162266101688147, 0.006415938958525658, -0.02022661082446575, 0.005107307806611061, -0.025544149801135063, 0.02196681685745716, -0.013718884438276291, 0.02675464190542698, 0.03777298703789711, -0.04660111293196678, 0.0014489382738247514, 0.011891843751072884, 0.06177488714456558, 0.04533597081899643, 0.03624832257628441, 0.014446856454014778, -0.06835723668336868, -0.026394203305244446, 0.02803550846874714, -0.06899211555719376, -0.02758856676518917, -0.026925038546323776, -0.045350782573223114, -0.020083483308553696, 0.06166256591677666, -0.0014253623085096478, -0.04496040940284729, -0.010613078251481056, -0.010960419662296772, 0.016741786152124405, -0.002608366310596466, -0.012328114360570908, -0.032150592654943466, 0.001179142389446497, -0.02259487472474575, 0.03300493583083153, -0.04501207545399666, 0.018572207540273666, -0.007024039980024099, 0.07150162011384964, 0.018606876954436302, 0.05326937511563301, 0.05275706201791763, 0.01359283085912466, -0.057605985552072525, -0.04040929302573204, -0.006895594298839569, 0.025049669668078423, -0.012576254084706306, -0.017548151314258575, 0.015429403632879257, -0.022208817303180695, -0.004655752796679735, 0.008984039537608624, 0.0522615872323513, 0.0667816624045372, -0.05379173532128334, -0.010237942449748516, -0.058142293244600296, -0.0059007988311350346, 0.021226637065410614, -0.0027000673580914736, 0.008732574991881847, 0.0007524057873524725, 0.07966243475675583, -0.003808369394391775, -0.03938550502061844, 0.00336147821508348, 0.05998971685767174, -0.0045495787635445595, -0.04632166028022766, -0.0008099019178189337, -0.020603280514478683, -0.05981413647532463, 0.00797479972243309, -0.010727953165769577, 0.0030324470717459917, 0.03060874342918396, 0.004407891072332859, 0.02624981850385666, 0.05693173408508301, 0.010305365547537804, 0.02075403369963169, -0.05051316320896149, -0.03736452758312225, 0.013725103810429573, 0.01617719791829586, -0.002833282807841897, -0.022508103400468826, 0.053532835096120834, -0.04099030792713165, -0.07147543132305145, 0.028745198622345924, -0.03970867395401001, 0.020903419703245163, 0.01651395484805107, -0.0163208469748497, -0.027264611795544624, -0.009406025521457195, -0.08223024755716324, 0.03568645194172859, -0.0033827240113168955, -0.061705928295850754, 0.07271487265825272, 0.05764775723218918, 0.015102303586900234, -0.00661048386245966, -0.06734666973352432, -0.05653144046664238, 0.033225372433662415, 0.02864287979900837, -0.05269089713692665, -0.0024788102600723505, -0.011939394287765026, 0.01604042947292328, -0.023731067776679993, 0.02108393795788288, 0.008577029220759869 ]
<p>The traditional (not taking into account phasor addition or complex addition) application of Kirchoff Voltage law, i.e. $\Sigma\Delta V=0$ along a loop, does not work for AC circuits. We can sum the voltage drops to zero if we take into account their phase differences. But at some particular time, no matter what the phase differences in the general equation for the voltages across various components, there will be only one numeric value of $\Delta V$. </p> <blockquote> <p><strong>Why doesn't this sum to zero over the loop in case of AC circuits with non-zero <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_reactance" rel="nofollow">reactance</a>?</strong></p> </blockquote> <p>Is this because there is some contribution to the $\oint E.dl$ due to changing magnetic flux? If it is, even in absence of any inductance, the voltage drops still do not sum to zero. why? </p>
g6637
[ 0.0020187317859381437, 0.01135389693081379, 0.0023963828571140766, 0.01008893083781004, 0.07130923122167587, -0.03783607482910156, -0.0028097413014620543, 0.049306612461805344, -0.015402321703732014, -0.04419247433543205, -0.06526520848274231, 0.023357121273875237, 0.029253866523504257, 0.06790079176425934, -0.014012744650244713, 0.018055588006973267, 0.023622727021574974, 0.043595995754003525, 0.11065881699323654, 0.011905430816113949, -0.0387866236269474, -0.025111475959420204, -0.040258754044771194, -0.01770360767841339, -0.015258871018886566, -0.0003266554558649659, 0.03552383556962013, -0.06211213022470474, -0.0887312963604927, 0.013171074911952019, 0.01248752512037754, 0.019820155575871468, 0.003589390544220805, -0.0011090392945334315, 0.0013567556161433458, 0.0007638809038326144, 0.022990360856056213, 0.020561128854751587, 0.04270254075527191, -0.021217375993728638, 0.009596738032996655, 0.038448695093393326, 0.06719662249088287, 0.03128322586417198, -0.02853846363723278, -0.020654331892728806, -0.04438493028283119, 0.021060636267066002, -0.09046702086925507, 0.0053885383531451225, -0.028396673500537872, -0.0180507842451334, 0.028494514524936676, 0.011020183563232422, 0.0154540054500103, -0.0421893484890461, 0.011246317997574806, 0.014245662838220596, 0.014742913655936718, 0.07679041475057602, 0.006768837105482817, 0.024016330018639565, 0.04436451569199562, 0.00018544885097071528, 0.03907015547156334, -0.022986913099884987, -0.013320814818143845, -0.013784739188849926, 0.02369818277657032, 0.0802883431315422, -0.020574813708662987, -0.06640263646841049, -0.01515222992748022, -0.04229500889778137, 0.07646508514881134, 0.024179253727197647, 0.010056760162115097, -0.031049098819494247, 0.0623021274805069, -0.05836984142661095, -0.07615760713815689, -0.001152249169535935, 0.015199929475784302, 0.10757295787334442, 0.01658511534333229, 0.048431605100631714, 0.03843989968299866, 0.026069747284054756, 0.0011507124872878194, 0.027805399149656296, 0.0516568087041378, -0.030220061540603638, 0.042660556733608246, -0.035145003348588943, -0.01967138610780239, -0.05138854309916496, 0.019809840247035027, 0.05947525054216385, 0.0326695516705513, -0.013224787078797817, -0.048052359372377396, 0.050620999187231064, 0.015821462497115135, -0.05241755396127701, -0.03674456477165222, 0.017377479001879692, 0.004391881637275219, -0.012272635474801064, -0.00852134358137846, 0.014032602310180664, -0.0632118359208107, -0.06491735577583313, -0.050834428519010544, 0.0014537337701767683, 0.0067574940621852875, 0.029334641993045807, 0.025809111073613167, -0.009953848086297512, 0.015990925952792168, -0.002490864833816886, 0.026817981153726578, 0.015225585550069809, 0.03499709069728851, 0.038136109709739685, -0.016006601974368095, 0.010306021198630333, 0.04493407532572746, 0.07808548957109451, 0.04961489886045456, -0.05877915397286415, 0.017124902456998825, 0.01885245181620121, -0.04850255325436592, 0.024407360702753067, 0.043189357966184616, -0.03660961985588074, 0.02595023438334465, -0.05182074010372162, -0.007443288806825876, 0.0012378799729049206, 0.004834107588976622, 0.018614603206515312, -0.009042220190167427, -0.022087758406996727, -0.00018011595238931477, 0.043738991022109985, -0.053532350808382034, -0.006082497071474791, 0.022488730028271675, -0.027111953124403954, 0.017484888434410095, 0.02974255383014679, -0.03364875167608261, 0.011949880048632622, -0.0020053894259035587, -0.01446345541626215, 0.01228004228323698, -0.01213244441896677, -0.016903791576623917, -0.02534635178744793, -0.00670943409204483, 0.02055511251091957, -0.05589231103658676, -0.037983935326337814, -0.054194167256355286, -0.01862143725156784, 0.03580717369914055, 0.00214580399915576, -0.016680622473359108, -0.06610536575317383, -0.04294724017381668, -0.04707108810544014, -0.004658638499677181, 0.029042674228549004, 0.04531431570649147, 0.024774348363280296, 0.04676613584160805, 0.014384221285581589, 0.05758289992809296, -0.04646551236510277, -0.059902504086494446, 0.04240738973021507, 0.005832131020724773, 0.003444350091740489, 0.02517586201429367, 0.01961679384112358, -0.00625636475160718, 0.018782738596200943, -0.09929793328046799, -0.01624426618218422, -0.04160206392407417, 0.01856835186481476, 0.02515791542828083, 0.05844953656196594, -0.03794321417808533, 0.024728015065193176, -0.007679899223148823, -0.035083137452602386, -0.05879552662372589, 0.06352178752422333, 0.048805199563503265, -0.02341597154736519, 0.04617593064904213, 0.0028821344021707773, -0.0034953870344907045, 0.041684992611408234, 0.0015440726419910789, -0.026073217391967773, 0.030297791585326195, -0.06297963112592697, 0.015128293074667454, 0.014375848695635796, -0.04720913991332054, 0.03587603196501732, 0.017387568950653076, -0.04166218638420105, 0.0013623121194541454, -0.009279345162212849, 0.019368985667824745, 0.03997587040066719, -0.039718303829431534, -0.022849276661872864, 0.01715809665620327, 0.029164327308535576, -0.06714257597923279, -0.0036339450161904097, -0.025539707392454147, -0.0076641240157186985, -0.024176854640245438, -0.03348405286669731, -0.031853705644607544, 0.00527842016890645, -0.05422580987215042, -0.02424447424709797, 0.017714036628603935, 0.019259760156273842, 0.02551613748073578, 0.003852528054267168, 0.009602432139217854, 0.0412156879901886, 0.017644086852669716, -0.04221523553133011, 0.00461245235055685, 0.018805237486958504, -0.0213173758238554, -0.03299781307578087, 0.00037749181501567364, 0.03696587309241295, -0.033590834587812424, -0.04200959578156471, -0.022057989612221718, 0.00472545949742198, -0.010974924080073833, -0.016230307519435883, -0.04058615118265152, -0.003993099555373192, 0.02694428525865078, -0.0368632897734642, -0.005768533330410719, -0.03281199559569359, -0.012998491525650024, 0.0357070118188858, 0.0068885856308043, -0.0016125371912494302, -0.0465213768184185, 0.07287969440221786, -0.03484734520316124, 0.027873480692505836, 0.02154620923101902, 0.0008855066844262183, -0.06720110028982162, 0.07264865934848785, -0.02712702937424183, 0.003391571342945099, -0.027695296332240105, -0.0033064931631088257, 0.0291379876434803, 0.014012616127729416, 0.062178026884794235, 0.0355880931019783, -0.030540211126208305, -0.009371859021484852, -0.06490994989871979, -0.02714828960597515, 0.011205415241420269, -0.059280652552843094, 0.04691436514258385, 0.010090518742799759, -0.010369948111474514, 0.004069119691848755, -0.028185267001390457, 0.010035742074251175, -0.012457684613764286, 0.021369589492678642, 0.008909687399864197, 0.029576914384961128, 0.008289103396236897, -0.03688330948352814, -0.0373612605035305, 0.043293390423059464, 0.016509072855114937, 0.0009073446854017675, -0.00760593032464385, -0.011859267018735409, 0.022836958989501, 0.06675845384597778, 0.057357218116521835, -0.03790179267525673, -0.015001988038420677, 0.010377742350101471, 0.007243838626891375, 0.016285091638565063, 0.04627690836787224, -0.05874165520071983, -0.026041364297270775, 0.03303436562418938, -0.03427942097187042, 0.012759285047650337, -0.00623659323900938, -0.02599158138036728, -0.023236123844981194, -0.012453087605535984, -0.023606643080711365, 0.006823461037129164, -0.015552064403891563, 0.0033417080994695425, -0.04732513427734375, 0.06460705399513245, -0.03252221271395683, 0.020182138308882713, 0.005082500632852316, 0.0189371295273304, 0.05590880662202835, -0.03861330449581146, -0.023686608299613, -0.04434766247868538, -0.018831046298146248, 0.004182853735983372, -0.015362399630248547, 0.06282895058393478, -0.05886630341410637, 0.007202738430351019, -0.037089280784130096, 0.005089486949145794, 0.017860285937786102, 0.03181993216276169, 0.0004936392651870847, 0.01822974905371666, -0.04062998294830322, -0.011694530956447124, 0.054189588874578476, 0.03294346481561661, 0.029688198119401932, 0.019794151186943054, 0.015265381895005703, 0.003738947445526719, -0.005743436980992556, 0.027063004672527313, -0.005248197820037603, 0.021516922861337662, 0.03534991666674614, -0.003548810025677085, -0.016174623742699623, -0.0058389692567288876, 0.04844524711370468, 0.03931078314781189, 0.027060149237513542, 0.036725182086229324, -0.01925850287079811, -0.055607929825782776, 0.02815108560025692, 0.009248904883861542, -0.043038785457611084, 0.023251470178365707, 0.005311938468366861, -0.04692362993955612, -0.006217205431312323, 0.08138883858919144, -0.021135129034519196, 0.028579620644450188, 0.015360267832875252, 0.008581229485571384, 0.015349763445556164, -0.0014894417254254222, -0.002818265464156866, -0.04040190577507019, -0.019377103075385094, 0.0384131520986557, -0.03660339489579201, -0.033167436718940735, -0.0156601183116436, 0.03679654002189636, 0.05221511796116829, 0.036705005913972855, -0.006089941598474979, -0.02625907026231289, 0.029900364577770233, -0.020756032317876816, -0.0036693820729851723, 0.0016188659938052297, -0.000876737292855978, -0.004226795397698879, 0.021657830104231834, -0.05533112585544586, 0.04801017418503761, -0.02413531020283699, 0.05084342882037163, -0.026593666523694992, 0.054099082946777344, -0.04778946936130524, -0.008487486280500889, -0.04105551168322563, -0.019041011109948158, -0.07560412585735321, 0.03707338124513626, 0.022354423999786377, 0.03619380295276642, -0.003688517725095153, 0.012009823694825172, -0.06935174018144608, -0.009528923779726028, -0.018736062571406364, -0.013905429281294346, -0.014701761305332184, -0.024127963930368423, -0.007525190245360136, -0.03207364305853844, 0.032762229442596436, 0.0499427504837513, 0.013671431690454483, -0.052025340497493744, 0.03778371959924698, -0.05558202043175697, -0.011119399219751358, -0.07842860370874405, 0.09147516638040543, -0.028289873152971268, 0.020988916978240013, -0.017511652782559395, 0.05638887360692024, 0.08244638890028, 0.024656997993588448, 0.007735205814242363, 0.04979797452688217, -0.020780732855200768, 0.03752584382891655, -0.04793495312333107, -0.0396052822470665, -0.011539285071194172, -0.005985629744827747, -0.038734108209609985, 0.03887214511632919, 0.0022404605988413095, -0.0282440148293972, 0.002619443228468299, 0.007301618345081806, -0.0016968499403446913, -0.008463102392852306, 0.01587352715432644, 0.03777031973004341, -0.015834661200642586, -0.07608813792467117, -0.03259940817952156, -0.03331383690237999, 0.003732775105163455, -0.010868489742279053, 0.022662164643406868, -0.05115564540028572, -0.10262793302536011, -0.008301958441734314, -0.003996505867689848, 0.04679384455084801, -0.013021712191402912, 0.01769895851612091, 0.04934914782643318, -0.02533680386841297, 0.05070599168539047, -0.0044835759326815605, -0.035791657865047455, -0.047682877629995346, -0.05645424500107765, -0.04899858683347702, -0.011915737763047218, 0.08700183033943176, 0.04728596657514572, 0.02252095565199852, -0.054317545145750046, -0.03417862206697464, 0.012437195517122746, -0.07392751425504684, 0.05570847541093826, 0.08331232517957687, 0.0070660775527358055, -0.04871513321995735, 0.009202784858644009, 0.0402984619140625, -0.0377664752304554, 0.004013195168226957, -0.05057545751333237, -0.002280677203088999, -0.07692541182041168, 0.020339258015155792, -0.016338340938091278, -0.007044665049761534, -0.04441293329000473, 0.025496065616607666, 0.02477044239640236, -0.009067123755812645, 0.05105370655655861, 0.001002551638521254, 0.0015145346987992525, 0.0007875474402680993, 0.06364858150482178, 0.06435715407133102, 0.04384678602218628, 0.05781443044543266, -0.04589064046740532, -0.04973766207695007, -0.05696530267596245, -0.022937975823879242, 0.028261525556445122, 0.04489376023411751, -0.03597636893391609, 0.03760029748082161, 0.006648195441812277, -0.004343188367784023, -0.06869053840637207, -0.06639120727777481, 0.002345333807170391, 0.003680228954181075, 0.01683112047612667, 0.02048276551067829, 0.009448510594666004, -0.004957455210387707, -0.01953130029141903, -0.024635320529341698, -0.006404049228876829, 0.012506588362157345, -0.007014187518507242, 0.0642390325665474, 0.001960268709808588, 0.004530712496489286, 0.02182728238403797, 0.08885511755943298, 0.029861504212021828, -0.04711143672466278, -0.004880394320935011, -0.06155543774366379, 0.014128759503364563, -0.06026419624686241, -0.07734351605176926, 0.030453477054834366, -0.025145934894680977, 0.01017636526376009, 0.009455032646656036, 0.023566897958517075, 0.0018885649042204022, 0.019679199904203415, -0.042959414422512054, 0.012503829784691334, 0.025294937193393707, -0.005624231416732073, -0.02122933231294155, 0.01821025460958481, 0.03559068962931633, -0.0579107329249382, -0.026867061853408813, 0.039090219885110855, 0.05005190894007683, 0.04432521387934685, 0.015341104008257389, -0.026504941284656525, 0.010770373977720737, -0.028941337019205093, -0.008560823276638985, 0.021403446793556213, -0.012877046130597591, -0.07019615173339844, 0.01906088925898075, -0.020815853029489517, -0.032736919820308685, 0.01802084408700466, 0.04014318063855171, -0.03864321485161781, 0.031976062804460526, -0.06999564915895462, -0.003116447478532791, 0.023814724758267403, 0.07232718169689178, 0.10093113034963608, -0.03604019433259964, -0.029054267331957817, 0.03869681805372238, 0.011097815819084644, -0.0289783775806427, -0.019740654155611992, -0.00544716464355588, 0.023965565487742424, 0.028224749490618706, -0.017551802098751068, 0.03029320016503334, 0.01451421994715929, 0.02524747885763645, -0.011594472452998161, -0.018512262031435966, 0.019891992211341858, -0.04836612567305565, 0.01568026654422283, -0.04653439298272133, 0.005802767816931009, 0.05261179059743881, 0.013417289592325687, 0.001005769707262516, -0.0054509700275957584, 0.005401324480772018, -0.05698155239224434, -0.025563299655914307, 0.015708493068814278, -0.035048626363277435, 0.007569253444671631, -0.012836027890443802, -0.013480440713465214, -0.005742468871176243, -0.006645526271313429, 0.022285468876361847, 0.05670938268303871, -0.002117571420967579, 0.03398830443620682, 0.0647197738289833, 0.0638113021850586, 0.016512064263224602, 0.07614124566316605, -0.08241957426071167, 0.02100237086415291, 0.024994906038045883, 0.05217394605278969, -0.026841821148991585, -0.0044882893562316895, 0.020499419420957565, -0.008506039157509804, -0.007077164947986603, 0.03310959041118622, -0.008537359535694122, 0.033639054745435715, -0.0337715744972229, 0.036288633942604065, 0.022346392273902893, -0.025179220363497734, -0.053348835557699203, 0.0017411753069609404, 0.07871054112911224, 0.026278315111994743, 0.007590625435113907, 0.01074456050992012, -0.023322993889451027, -0.03866395354270935, 0.03335883468389511, 0.02413330040872097, 0.031405046582221985, -0.005852461326867342, -0.048318423330783844, -0.022096501663327217, 0.019715189933776855, 0.06692202389240265, 0.06690964102745056, 0.032840825617313385, -0.02259199135005474, -0.0473843477666378, 0.07106606662273407, -0.01985079236328602, 0.018796756863594055, -0.035647936165332794, -0.026852020993828773, 0.006732690613716841, 0.016738286241889, 0.0006640337524004281, 0.009298535995185375, -0.01719125173985958, -0.007191171403974295, 0.043047089129686356, 0.029563384130597115, -0.04898754507303238, -0.0020368178375065327, -0.06675133109092712, -0.048180993646383286, 0.022499872371554375, -0.03441474959254265, 0.030612105503678322, -0.03530263155698776, 0.008754659444093704, 0.04651566222310066, 0.01761169359087944, 0.02239413559436798, -0.029082706198096275, 0.011716768145561218, 0.049777694046497345, 0.033653125166893005, -0.036773089319467545, 0.010936262086033821, -0.05488014221191406, 0.10939367115497589, -0.06127379462122917, -0.03601165488362312, -0.005639213137328625, 0.025481512770056725, 0.01983979158103466, -0.003677751636132598, -0.06491488218307495, -0.00483417883515358, 0.06501079350709915, 0.026472115889191628, 0.050904303789138794, -0.02892552688717842, -0.006703634280711412, 0.014183895662426949, -0.002487451070919633, -0.006778663489967585, 0.012050548568367958, -0.013077964074909687, -0.0007749664946459234, -0.013189125806093216, -0.09128604829311371, 0.004492511041462421, -0.08063481003046036, -0.03284253180027008, -0.013172918930649757, 0.011756159365177155, -0.003593359375372529, 0.0227650236338377, 0.016943473368883133, 0.01239061914384365, -0.013230827637016773, -0.026474053040146828, -0.015012810006737709, -0.028210459277033806, 0.0398598313331604, -0.0027114658150821924, 0.03420417755842209, -0.008548406884074211, 0.0034794325474649668, 0.00005958178735454567, -0.0455198734998703, -0.025267915800213814, -0.0382879301905632, 0.00019450958643574268, -0.025391392409801483, -0.04235564172267914, 0.03576602414250374, 0.0005932694766670465, -0.019562089815735817, -0.04715045914053917, -0.008291758596897125, -0.08354301005601883, -0.023771919310092926, 0.04229108244180679, 0.021490786224603653, -0.012771756388247013, -0.032025597989559174, 0.010202974081039429, -0.028077727183699608, -0.062254898250103, -0.016354087740182877, -0.09081132709980011, -0.00388540280982852, 0.04745222255587578, -0.047946251928806305, 0.0019320037681609392, -0.05754983797669411 ]
<p>I hope this is the right forum to ask this question. Is there a material (preferably thin, like a membrane) that changes its local conductivity (by that I mean the permeability for an electric field; I hope it's the right term) upon excitation with light or heat? I have no idea where to start my search for something like that. </p> <p>Thanks a lot.</p>
g6638
[ 0.057145856320858, 0.026172442361712456, 0.017504161223769188, -0.012199973687529564, 0.005529317073523998, 0.0198214128613472, -0.06764878332614899, 0.01993352547287941, 0.005602739751338959, 0.03112521581351757, -0.010138694196939468, 0.03867963328957558, 0.002691093599423766, 0.020131850615143776, -0.042345479130744934, -0.0470895878970623, 0.04357112944126129, 0.012370269745588303, -0.0102439159527421, 0.036428507417440414, -0.04865635558962822, 0.0039767432026565075, 0.05188274011015892, -0.00939649622887373, 0.029792990535497665, 0.028632821515202522, 0.029245207086205482, -0.036402080208063126, 0.034145258367061615, -0.00448894128203392, -0.032944560050964355, -0.106554314494133, 0.02467857301235199, -0.049100276082754135, -0.040561240166425705, -0.033223576843738556, 0.011955373920500278, -0.010256379842758179, 0.0038577578961849213, 0.03825957328081131, 0.05944054573774338, 0.051758721470832825, 0.021317195147275925, 0.0007589203305542469, 0.07257629930973053, -0.04536083713173866, -0.021789375692605972, 0.017268052324652672, -0.05173827335238457, -0.007368532475084066, -0.026641452684998512, 0.0024117438588291407, 0.019265642389655113, 0.0005869597080163658, 0.006441919133067131, -0.04198284447193146, -0.02355816587805748, 0.01794874668121338, 0.04415936768054962, -0.003659419948235154, -0.046167340129613876, 0.043307114392519, 0.012631027027964592, -0.029546957463026047, -0.016493704169988632, 0.012441440485417843, -0.009709151461720467, 0.0019864330533891916, -0.02046433463692665, 0.003953854087740183, 0.00811843667179346, 0.04214681312441826, -0.05866448953747749, -0.0024853781796991825, 0.034315019845962524, 0.0505220852792263, 0.030202198773622513, 0.0022286176681518555, 0.0064467815682291985, -0.029505781829357147, -0.07436206936836243, -0.022148778662085533, -0.05520404502749443, -0.010112138465046883, 0.0337517149746418, -0.056241609156131744, 0.01434365101158619, 0.030437029898166656, 0.03437938541173935, -0.05621258541941643, -0.038367267698049545, 0.019309628754854202, 0.08926911652088165, -0.05725575238466263, -0.023321999236941338, 0.04831346496939659, 0.018049374222755432, 0.000047134075430221856, -0.0215535219758749, -0.062063176184892654, -0.005940424744039774, -0.031056609004735947, 0.057850588113069534, 0.00729774683713913, -0.050080105662345886, 0.02289307862520218, 0.021739456802606583, -0.07114227861166, -0.029394574463367462, -0.003530737478286028, 0.038503360003232956, -0.022596735507249832, -0.03481801226735115, -0.014925247058272362, -0.007180166430771351, 0.011287313885986805, 0.034850943833589554, -0.04267680272459984, 0.005529675632715225, 0.04077019914984703, 0.04731491208076477, 0.018125459551811218, -0.012731559574604034, 0.06636388599872589, -0.01115519180893898, 0.08980758488178253, 0.0044751898385584354, 0.03781907632946968, -0.021405259147286415, -0.004532081540673971, 0.026004236191511154, 0.01551496796309948, -0.025275209918618202, -0.007816750556230545, -0.006264772731810808, 0.007779334671795368, 0.03827838599681854, -0.00027023963048122823, 0.044961486011743546, -0.008708292618393898, 0.009474193677306175, -0.08349598944187164, -0.011812853626906872, 0.013863544911146164, 0.017808396369218826, -0.03291599452495575, 0.03501906245946884, -0.0018762140534818172, 0.07357866317033768, 0.012416724115610123, 0.04065994173288345, 0.017684828490018845, -0.019036466255784035, -0.040029410272836685, -0.016930921003222466, -0.022931842133402824, 0.021769007667899132, 0.01079921331256628, 0.0779927596449852, -0.06571868807077408, -0.006119832396507263, 0.027394013479351997, -0.010901326313614845, -0.005009475164115429, 0.007661794777959585, 0.014230753295123577, -0.02320794388651848, -0.0023643707390874624, -0.033539433032274246, -0.01970485970377922, -0.020158801227808, -0.016020188108086586, 0.018909361213445663, 0.10175150632858276, 0.008252413012087345, 0.03500957041978836, -0.0023501762188971043, -0.0535496287047863, -0.02383943274617195, -0.03943701460957527, -0.05141245201230049, -0.014499913901090622, 0.02352711744606495, -0.12402015179395676, -0.011559512466192245, 0.025647738948464394, -0.01142422016710043, 0.0075953747145831585, -0.07519946247339249, 0.003900793381035328, -0.05199515447020531, -0.0075654867105185986, 0.006270201876759529, -0.013146026991307735, 0.018802396953105927, 0.008871675468981266, 0.04968975484371185, -0.03515254706144333, -0.028409430757164955, -0.05985349789261818, 0.024494128301739693, 0.03125690296292305, 0.05104810744524002, 0.035263482481241226, 0.013215659186244011, 0.022542959079146385, -0.03525876998901367, -0.046539269387722015, 0.024529000744223595, 0.005617949180305004, 0.02177892066538334, -0.002070138929411769, 0.027712805196642876, 0.010308945551514626, 0.00034878196311183274, -0.02904624491930008, -0.04182504862546921, -0.011547851376235485, -0.014680140651762486, -0.06636008620262146, -0.014596077613532543, 0.046401362866163254, 0.015719499439001083, -0.021876627579331398, -0.05314389988780022, -0.035119060426950455, 0.03959282487630844, 0.03249771147966385, 0.012494176626205444, 0.03593311086297035, -0.07114768028259277, -0.04201198369264603, 0.054990168660879135, 0.010705760680139065, 0.05567753687500954, 0.01820768602192402, -0.07495398819446564, -0.041064076125621796, -0.03201251104474068, -0.08742716163396835, -0.015153340995311737, -0.019735651090741158, -0.06996350735425949, 0.007840408012270927, -0.001200387952849269, -0.02577725425362587, -0.0448211245238781, -0.007222009357064962, 0.05202150717377663, -0.010988093912601471, 0.06426156312227249, 0.0014490013709291816, -0.003618385409936309, 0.04842174053192139, 0.012383151799440384, -0.021940059959888458, 0.005487335845828056, 0.05886705592274666, -0.016190562397241592, -0.024836340919137, 0.030768640339374542, 0.008082079701125622, 0.012459595687687397, 0.02999107725918293, -0.01310588140040636, -0.013694550842046738, -0.025808289647102356, 0.03974269703030586, -0.007621873635798693, 0.05032650753855705, 0.025907209143042564, 0.05351627245545387, 0.022688372060656548, 0.0006875856197439134, 0.06526132673025131, -0.01418080274015665, 0.027742378413677216, -0.07033894211053848, 0.05704981088638306, -0.061086833477020264, 0.0353858508169651, -0.044866736978292465, -0.05090832710266113, -0.0012977863661944866, -0.00875114370137453, -0.056359779089689255, 0.03073575720191002, -0.0030926871113479137, 0.02454822137951851, -0.04561396688222885, -0.007501511834561825, -0.004672701470553875, -0.046738188713788986, 0.028281105682253838, -0.023995371535420418, 0.0010970053263008595, 0.057390544563531876, -0.008707741275429726, 0.02478650212287903, 0.027278879657387733, 0.012730118818581104, -0.04205392301082611, 0.003890596330165863, -0.004662184044718742, 0.05352802202105522, -0.0027885264717042446, -0.01536927092820406, -0.07870103418827057, 0.054595645517110825, -0.003820633515715599, -0.023828810080885887, -0.07407477498054504, 0.03338116407394409, 0.019276374951004982, -0.010120181366801262, 0.002480874303728342, -0.01291586086153984, 0.013059786520898342, 0.07062937319278717, -0.07867871969938278, 0.02685350365936756, 0.01869042031466961, 0.02300902269780636, -0.009113858453929424, 0.018570516258478165, -0.0120201101526618, -0.00808088667690754, -0.006930414587259293, -0.01759827323257923, -0.041524488478899, -0.002312413416802883, 0.01286004763096571, -0.02365703321993351, -0.060472384095191956, -0.04553207382559776, -0.0165970828384161, -0.053095366805791855, 0.029387036338448524, 0.005381991155445576, 0.04436440020799637, 0.028475316241383553, -0.03397485986351967, -0.027522621676325798, -0.009575514122843742, -0.0272214412689209, 0.03312501311302185, 0.01828821748495102, -0.05703303590416908, -0.01489756628870964, 0.0006566998781636357, 0.034362610429525375, 0.004702966194599867, 0.04394040256738663, -0.0014596657129004598, -0.06925221532583237, 0.009807445108890533, 0.09508073329925537, 0.007726216688752174, 0.01396086160093546, 0.012123921886086464, 0.0006067308131605387, -0.0972304418683052, 0.05770019069314003, -0.03545474633574486, -0.022376734763383865, 0.05743768811225891, 0.03746100887656212, -0.028810789808630943, -0.03996909782290459, 0.007436043117195368, 0.07066554576158524, -0.01703723706305027, -0.001865559839643538, 0.06954522430896759, -0.002428248291835189, -0.03430113568902016, -0.031728047877550125, -0.014519544318318367, -0.042594775557518005, -0.010872457176446915, 0.007969117723405361, 0.05711290240287781, 0.05900871753692627, 0.02560492977499962, 0.0319693498313427, 0.014229283668100834, 0.012291805818676949, -0.007084887940436602, -0.007935945875942707, -0.0022930994164198637, -0.06235671415925026, 0.017627259716391563, -0.004121463745832443, -0.013767112977802753, -0.00544740492478013, -0.024136461317539215, 0.0286802276968956, -0.02116752415895462, 0.03430088981986046, 0.004448145627975464, 0.07886143773794174, 0.022532925009727478, 0.036492105573415756, 0.009186369366943836, 0.022954918444156647, -0.0073645515367388725, 0.030510274693369865, 0.009863886050879955, -0.017453230917453766, -0.019171077758073807, -0.026986412703990936, -0.05469520762562752, -0.02999618649482727, -0.05397820845246315, -0.04163992032408714, 0.0005396261112764478, 0.03135306015610695, -0.036757487803697586, 0.06308188289403915, -0.008313626982271671, -0.011403697542846203, 0.008754896931350231, 0.007968368008732796, 0.008143024519085884, 0.04063359275460243, 0.07877400517463684, 0.07066366821527481, -0.006180056370794773, -0.01321761030703783, -0.04807530343532562, -0.02675931714475155, -0.0023055728524923325, -0.07460460066795349, 0.04521898180246353, 0.01333223283290863, 0.01940377801656723, -0.07720883935689926, -0.02153465710580349, 0.01570182479918003, 0.051966726779937744, 0.04461181163787842, -0.018922701478004456, 0.004122121725231409, -0.00939922221004963, 0.022830305621027946, 0.030213911086320877, -0.025071915239095688, 0.03231484442949295, -0.013693219050765038, -0.001385206705890596, -0.07361666858196259, 0.0025950679555535316, -0.0006529315724037588, -0.01081561204046011, -0.06476445496082306, -0.024324046447873116, -0.03706808015704155, -0.024917149916291237, 0.06243196129798889, 0.038988146930933, -0.01620597578585148, -0.03321095183491707, -0.043115127831697464, 0.0550357848405838, -0.0016945617971941829, -0.003097702283412218, -0.0017252721590921283, -0.007473296485841274, -0.005360414274036884, 0.002800233894959092, 0.03259257227182388, 0.06946618109941483, 0.013272399082779884, 0.039507247507572174, 0.027054140344262123, 0.014428946189582348, -0.04650295898318291, 0.003197886049747467, -0.06572463363409042, -0.06731794029474258, -0.008585115894675255, 0.02037971280515194, 0.04008480906486511, 0.014375098049640656, 0.0561247356235981, 0.023035703226923943, -0.048701442778110504, 0.09132888913154602, 0.009806875139474869, -0.09935358166694641, 0.00265158386901021, -0.00015745509881526232, 0.007581488229334354, 0.04604329541325569, -0.0296789463609457, 0.009841825813055038, 0.02520432323217392, 0.0030031127389520407, -0.013101899065077305, -0.0018654073355719447, 0.01866491138935089, 0.0462530218064785, -0.005812627263367176, -0.01672162115573883, 0.018442897126078606, 0.02359818108379841, -0.03417099267244339, 0.003946084063500166, 0.0056405821815133095, 0.023930944502353668, -0.05566143989562988, -0.010974764823913574, 0.0030828313902020454, -0.015469145029783249, -0.0023090397007763386, -0.0064926715567708015, -0.08362405002117157, 0.004625051282346249, -0.03910696133971214, -0.05272574722766876, -0.05955128371715546, -0.065943643450737, 0.011812200769782066, 0.0017188148340210319, 0.0027966529596596956, 0.03105780854821205, -0.029756968840956688, 0.015232571400702, 0.07021339982748032, 0.017267603427171707, 0.0583818145096302, 0.03327561169862747, -0.03526165708899498, -0.022731244564056396, -0.0058952029794454575, 0.03352260962128639, -0.0029182429425418377, 0.057222604751586914, -0.0033595850691199303, 0.06802034378051758, -0.016879161819815636, -0.05277445539832115, 0.05791938677430153, 0.003924168646335602, 0.09125161916017532, 0.043620072305202484, -0.02237544395029545, 0.009245127439498901, 0.024137109518051147, 0.014897583983838558, 0.03380622714757919, -0.004957822151482105, 0.006762724835425615, 0.0363004170358181, 0.00439173448830843, -0.03384888172149658, -0.0133312176913023, -0.011575555428862572, 0.012839997187256813, 0.029443856328725815, 0.06343533098697662, 0.003139093052595854, 0.03290928900241852, -0.09400908648967743, 0.01706209033727646, -0.04017113521695137, 0.006818066816776991, -0.006115361582487822, 0.07447434961795807, -0.01702040433883667, -0.02768567204475403, 0.027107402682304382, 0.03869413956999779, -0.0653252899646759, -0.054348863661289215, -0.02315661683678627, -0.015717225149273872, -0.05469389259815216, -0.022482775151729584, 0.0007100154762156308, -0.028096698224544525, 0.03277192264795303, -0.02154706045985222, -0.020562954246997833, -0.013912105932831764, 0.01538576278835535, 0.03592189773917198, -0.04671843349933624, 0.039349265396595, -0.05309378728270531, 0.0017453496111556888, -0.01059764251112938, -0.04612341150641441, 0.021944524720311165, 0.004032788332551718, 0.015399874188005924, -0.06821145862340927, 0.03738388791680336, 0.03506085276603699, 0.05013825744390488, 0.031783636659383774, -0.06905229389667511, 0.003976874053478241, -0.03553447872400284, 0.02585470862686634, 0.06690794974565506, 0.05638862028717995, 0.027463529258966446, 0.02977108582854271, -0.028202906250953674, -0.027489086613059044, -0.057138316333293915, -0.034815527498722076, -0.0270379725843668, -0.04205631837248802, -0.01040146965533495, -0.019411588087677956, -0.028231382369995117, 0.031673505902290344, -0.014868633821606636, -0.05559367686510086, -0.03204532340168953, 0.04938257485628128, -0.0019503958756104112, -0.03992342948913574, 0.028775623068213463, -0.02606547251343727, 0.03526897355914116, 0.026437126100063324, -0.014152402989566326, -0.00813293643295765, 0.01176435500383377, 0.0226366575807333, 0.05018480122089386, -0.016119539737701416, -0.03949274122714996, 0.013707142323255539, -0.061397913843393326, 0.02017258293926716, 0.002451792126521468, 0.0026669949293136597, 0.025181839242577553, 0.021765239536762238, 0.05173390731215477, 0.03264802321791649, -0.02587546594440937, -0.0165419839322567, 0.018685990944504738, 0.003312173066660762, 0.006400516256690025, 0.03128550574183464, 0.04214010387659073, -0.045956019312143326, -0.02843097411096096, -0.005971607286483049, 0.018173107877373695, -0.029190272092819214, 0.024911338463425636, 0.026575054973363876, -0.022504456341266632, -0.03588630259037018, -0.02335176058113575, -0.01202663779258728, -0.015457995235919952, 0.009266546927392483, 0.0371369943022728, -0.010496119037270546, -0.04890236631035805, -0.002220442984253168, -0.010432717390358448, 0.0351836122572422, -0.041976574808359146, 0.0068846228532493114, -0.021120015531778336, -0.027202041819691658, -0.03997236490249634, -0.009012113325297832, 0.10555774718523026, 0.022595174610614777, -0.03600209951400757, -0.000809424149338156, 0.010478992015123367, 0.06499651819467545, -0.034825582057237625, -0.004946602042764425, 0.005866880062967539, -0.036277901381254196, 0.05207475274801254, 0.037635497748851776, 0.058570995926856995, 0.03082774020731449, -0.007931920699775219, 0.03222660347819328, -0.01928767003118992, 0.03411431610584259, -0.033919356763362885, 0.027364518493413925, 0.0026111258193850517, 0.041554998606443405, -0.03204687312245369, -0.0486849844455719, -0.001995476195588708, -0.0007585271378047764, -0.058631595224142075, -0.0031902622431516647, -0.031208638101816177, -0.04151449352502823, -0.054808661341667175, -0.07875019311904907, 0.010824774391949177, 0.007742520421743393, 0.07857134193181992, 0.05226583406329155, 0.03509538993239403, -0.0016445049550384283, 0.007839350029826164, -0.037557195872068405, 0.07440702617168427, -0.02669556438922882, 0.021130843088030815, -0.05772015079855919, 0.00837499089539051, -0.009327870793640614, 0.0031701119150966406, -0.0006803765427321196, -0.002006776863709092, -0.01175603736191988, 0.018196623772382736, 0.06324836611747742, 0.02635577879846096, 0.0465359091758728, -0.03912952169775963, -0.005059929098933935, -0.03287133201956749, -0.07910352945327759, -0.02299361675977707, 0.05537853017449379, 0.0018757618963718414, 0.06635067611932755, -0.029430456459522247, 0.009787927381694317, -0.029608575627207756, -0.022352105006575584, -0.02132255584001541, 0.009303211234509945, 0.010725721716880798, 0.0018626933451741934, 0.008230060338973999, 0.07185547798871994, -0.040903523564338684, -0.0535246916115284, -0.004612677730619907, 0.00277357897721231, 0.010651208460330963, -0.032630421221256256, -0.0421128012239933, 0.007280729245394468, 0.003545660525560379, -0.02893746830523014, -0.039451729506254196, 0.010954039171338081, -0.026655146852135658, 0.005224320571869612, 0.05055830627679825, -0.005284145008772612, 0.010540231131017208, 0.057804930955171585, 0.011437805369496346 ]
<p>It seems as though I've come across a rather unusual conclusion that could either simply be a misinterpretation or a contradictory discovery. I seem to have found a way to utilize the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle (HUP) to our benefit to communicate faster than the speed of light (FTL). I am aware of many proposals that try to utilize entangled spin particles and try to communicate, but this schemes fail because the measurement outcome can NOT be controlled. Therefore, even if two people share an entangled pair of particles, and Alice measures spin up, although she knows Bob has a spin down particle, Bob didn't measure yet and has no way of knowing that Alice has measured her particle. Hence, FTL is impossible based on the reason that the measurement outcome can not be controlled.</p> <p>This leads to my proposal of using position and momentum entangled pairs. Consider <strong>Alice and Bob hold an ensemble of entangled particles in position and momenta</strong>, where each particle is trapped in a separate harmonic potential. At some specified time agreed upon in the future, Alice measures all of her particles' position to high precision. <strong>Alice and Bob have synchronized clocks</strong> and Bob measures all of his entangled particle's momentum to whatever accuracy he chooses. Alice can calculate the average value and also the standard deviation of position. The standard deviation of position would be extremely narrow, i.e, the spread of her measurements would be very small.</p> <p>From the entanglement relation, <strong>x1 = x2 and p1 = -p2</strong>, we know that when Bob measures his particle's momentum, the spread of momentum will be very large. This must be true because position and momentum cannot be measured to arbitrary accuracy at the same time. This is very similar to Einstein's proposal to violate the HUP, however I am exploiting HUP.</p> <p>What this all means is that the if Bob measures a very large momentum spread, it must mean that Alice has made her measurements. If Bob measures a relatively moderate momentum spread, then he knows Alice did not measure her particles. <strong>Since the position measurement can be made to arbitrary accuracy, we are "controlling the spread or the standard deviation as the means to communicate."</strong> (MAIN RATIONALE)</p> <p>Say Alice and Bob have multiple ensembles of entangled particles. Alice can relay a message by simultaneously measuring her first ensemble, meaning its a "1" and not touch her second ensemble meaning its a "0", and perhaps she chose to measure the third ensemble, "1", etc. Hence generating the series 101..., where <strong>each ensemble of entangled particles represents one bit of information.</strong></p> <p>What is flawed in this proposal? Entanglement in position and momenta is well established. We can also choose to measure the position of a particle to arbitrary precision. The HUP must hold for Bob and everyone involved.</p>
g6639
[ 0.004779121372848749, 0.04265236482024193, -0.012958673760294914, -0.03259092569351196, 0.04987020418047905, 0.005166764371097088, 0.059120528399944305, 0.010893522761762142, -0.014159430749714375, 0.030057404190301895, 0.022417157888412476, -0.02507779374718666, -0.02288222685456276, -0.01589748077094555, -0.012728484347462654, 0.043046724051237106, 0.152746319770813, 0.020034823566675186, 0.018975352868437767, 0.005745709873735905, 0.03471788018941879, 0.02483193948864937, -0.06484786421060562, -0.04281998798251152, -0.05725853890180588, -0.023038366809487343, -0.03273497521877289, -0.05976879224181175, -0.03145274147391319, 0.02071060985326767, -0.02935301512479782, -0.05768550559878349, 0.028627881780266762, -0.03636045381426811, 0.02490408718585968, -0.07996474206447601, -0.004063581582158804, -0.021999768912792206, -0.012450417503714561, 0.03738444671034813, -0.01035275124013424, 0.009142793715000153, -0.02531476877629757, -0.029119594022631645, 0.02798394486308098, 0.032488491386175156, 0.02225557528436184, -0.02272189036011696, 0.01714993454515934, -0.01838654838502407, 0.00914729107171297, 0.012815040536224842, 0.04716915637254715, 0.0464591421186924, 0.07440517842769623, 0.11519868671894073, 0.006426519248634577, -0.02013608068227768, 0.03069990500807762, 0.0017578961560502648, 0.015004105865955353, -0.006731315515935421, 0.014606039971113205, 0.04891534522175789, 0.02939065732061863, 0.06239274516701698, -0.080436572432518, 0.03379024192690849, -0.009359756484627724, -0.01873195171356201, -0.010373386554419994, -0.06189693510532379, -0.0008438630611635745, -0.01991022750735283, -0.03050685115158558, 0.057722050696611404, -0.011170131154358387, -0.04045189172029495, -0.0018482115119695663, 0.051930587738752365, -0.07705574482679367, -0.034822460263967514, 0.005928352475166321, -0.04900970682501793, 0.031647153198719025, -0.03278447315096855, -0.01864849030971527, 0.003102993592619896, -0.0038213287480175495, 0.020856942981481552, 0.018675824627280235, -0.05394745245575905, 0.05587230622768402, -0.009046167135238647, -0.04030471667647362, -0.01306154578924179, -0.039625994861125946, -0.0084480419754982, 0.002273646416142583, 0.05385895073413849, -0.06332559883594513, 0.05012954771518707, -0.026276927441358566, 0.026762424036860466, -0.022521143779158592, -0.03275497257709503, 0.004203500226140022, 0.015243136323988438, -0.007368106860667467, -0.008123916573822498, 0.02216101810336113, -0.021233852952718735, -0.04160407930612564, -0.05117132514715195, -0.06058989092707634, -0.0551108792424202, 0.07150977104902267, 0.014689148403704166, -0.06853868812322617, 0.0024827569723129272, 0.03540107235312462, 0.02636374719440937, 0.0226286631077528, 0.10550267994403839, -0.023943856358528137, 0.038081683218479156, -0.02524278126657009, 0.034564532339572906, 0.02925959788262844, 0.0011495407670736313, -0.049488987773656845, -0.009588832966983318, -0.03377099335193634, 0.05058857426047325, -0.045901212841272354, -0.024868423119187355, 0.03983837738633156, 0.03147747367620468, 0.03141435235738754, 0.008893760852515697, -0.013660457916557789, -0.01756587252020836, 0.02780146524310112, -0.05537261441349983, -0.012520751915872097, 0.02751922607421875, -0.004129862878471613, -0.027603454887866974, 0.03534764423966408, 0.03950340673327446, 0.00536614004522562, 0.09052444249391556, -0.014357996173202991, 0.050229962915182114, -0.011365961283445358, 0.02381565235555172, 0.04197172820568085, 0.031581904739141464, 0.024837227538228035, 0.04447036236524582, 0.06944151222705841, 0.003286791266873479, -0.008066919632256031, -0.06098233908414841, 0.015482679940760136, 0.0422510951757431, 0.04098377749323845, 0.008067445829510689, -0.040778011083602905, -0.03896193578839302, -0.08722589910030365, -0.0061394888907670975, -0.003055717796087265, 0.00688586849719286, 0.04219313710927963, 0.0648394301533699, -0.03499135375022888, -0.07065369933843613, -0.026221219450235367, 0.06155943125486374, -0.007201863918453455, 0.022614706307649612, -0.004486061632633209, -0.015496845357120037, -0.05531476438045502, 0.06764548271894455, 0.04355428367853165, 0.012911401689052582, -0.014594613574445248, -0.04934289678931236, -0.03173324093222618, -0.04159567877650261, -0.024516727775335312, 0.009663446806371212, -0.033061422407627106, 0.028891395777463913, 0.03302045539021492, -0.009153853170573711, -0.014415106736123562, 0.05986849591135979, 0.002616447862237692, 0.023702921345829964, -0.02097037434577942, -0.01432417519390583, 0.050366003066301346, 0.018053105100989342, 0.004144699312746525, -0.007955973967909813, 0.031694136559963226, -0.021568072959780693, 0.04651794210076332, -0.016864625737071037, -0.03385483846068382, 0.01262538693845272, 0.009547415189445019, -0.06619416922330856, 0.01080274861305952, -0.00936697144061327, 0.013658853247761726, 0.004486111458390951, -0.02387131191790104, -0.03157758340239525, 0.02791271172463894, -0.024062206968665123, -0.039376065135002136, 0.01203871425241232, -0.04023996368050575, -0.06689084321260452, -0.08305788785219193, 0.05567061901092529, -0.04696331545710564, -0.00828714668750763, -0.026707150042057037, 0.0069269523955881596, 0.06523717194795609, 0.02409319020807743, -0.001534775597974658, 0.04091973975300789, 0.01896156556904316, 0.0524076446890831, 0.032132092863321304, -0.062498655170202255, -0.09976481646299362, -0.012900127097964287, 0.0022180017549544573, 0.008330742828547955, 0.021053237840533257, -0.07061415910720825, 0.0054582045413553715, 0.016490228474140167, 0.03354872390627861, 0.03134777396917343, 0.038757357746362686, -0.09030821919441223, 0.001289257314056158, 0.001454461133107543, 0.012324754148721695, 0.04780503734946251, -0.0980544164776802, -0.04963948577642441, -0.011010188609361649, -0.012516850605607033, -0.01659446768462658, -0.0008462781552225351, 0.015908507630228996, -0.00020707576186396182, -0.025405608117580414, 0.04115176573395729, -0.010085068643093109, -0.0005944074946455657, -0.027775965631008148, -0.0021658821497112513, 0.009009843692183495, 0.009005164727568626, -0.04483997821807861, -0.060337238013744354, 0.006707294378429651, -0.02868782915174961, 0.04974610358476639, 0.039594054222106934, -0.07431914657354355, 0.05830354988574982, -0.06568408012390137, 0.012851541861891747, 0.01825278252363205, -0.0024520286824554205, -0.02139454148709774, 0.015288992784917355, 0.03978506103157997, 0.022018464282155037, 0.033153679221868515, 0.012609248049557209, 0.052820026874542236, 0.001235397532582283, -0.01351073943078518, 0.049437250941991806, 0.013728776015341282, -0.03633362054824829, -0.017480865120887756, 0.0018793079070746899, 0.006857965607196093, 0.06886749714612961, 0.00041531320312060416, 0.057823821902275085, 0.05907357111573219, 0.025676753371953964, -0.04696148261427879, 0.010524974204599857, -0.014635182917118073, -0.01998397894203663, -0.004739164840430021, 0.04935939982533455, -0.02038700319826603, -0.051163747906684875, 0.0004569707380142063, -0.0257037915289402, -0.0349898561835289, 0.02205931954085827, 0.014015043154358864, -0.023461557924747467, 0.031989071518182755, -0.017522409558296204, 0.0017613125964999199, -0.03638071194291115, 0.07232129573822021, 0.028516484424471855, -0.03373797982931137, 0.019091829657554626, -0.06214047968387604, -0.007760701701045036, 0.022327616810798645, 0.031978730112314224, 0.03529422730207443, -0.0014489964814856648, -0.014804038219153881, -0.09057291597127914, 0.030362188816070557, 0.06511971354484558, 0.05013559013605118, 0.026776399463415146, -0.035696983337402344, -0.06403770297765732, -0.055810391902923584, 0.05777498334646225, 0.003352018538862467, -0.0006481771124526858, -0.002866089344024658, 0.003769289469346404, 0.015079586766660213, 0.01683003641664982, 0.0034612189047038555, 0.06446844339370728, 0.022719746455550194, -0.021555062383413315, 0.00912427343428135, 0.0349210761487484, 0.04791548103094101, -0.013176994398236275, 0.004340306855738163, 0.00619897898286581, 0.03295177221298218, 0.014060446061193943, 0.029067493975162506, 0.002361259190365672, -0.008496510796248913, 0.012716841883957386, -0.033182740211486816, 0.01601896621286869, 0.0316094234585762, -0.0010973234893754125, -0.05525371804833412, 0.00024381848925258964, -0.028029218316078186, -0.0037301364354789257, 0.056720197200775146, -0.047567445784807205, 0.0666629821062088, -0.052475783973932266, -0.011047356761991978, -0.0075432173907756805, 0.016345413401722908, 0.07095932960510254, 0.002641953993588686, 0.020984264090657234, 0.021006081253290176, 0.0368303544819355, -0.03820743039250374, 0.01619868166744709, -0.04906313866376877, 0.0069487555883824825, -0.01888229511678219, -0.06881877034902573, -0.021141590550541878, -0.03950294479727745, 0.032357946038246155, -0.012418046593666077, 0.020282717421650887, -0.028062853962183, 0.03571053966879845, -0.038966357707977295, -0.0567285418510437, -0.04653690755367279, -0.02728225477039814, -0.012288459576666355, 0.021862423047423363, -0.003328048624098301, 0.013731472194194794, -0.048617321997880936, 0.01622159034013748, 0.03042907454073429, 0.02096407301723957, 0.03369252383708954, 0.006019157357513905, -0.01123371534049511, 0.03843269869685173, -0.00436827726662159, -0.02559443563222885, -0.048640355467796326, 0.030291639268398285, 0.017223553732037544, 0.03163111209869385, 0.049538422375917435, 0.05662048980593681, -0.021051691845059395, -0.04178148880600929, 0.024977829307317734, 0.0031301481649279594, 0.010583835653960705, 0.0008011923055164516, -0.042563918977975845, 0.02214142121374607, -0.003218348603695631, -0.017624331638216972, 0.0008658198057673872, 0.007443409878760576, -0.0282462015748024, 0.0393015593290329, -0.01407281868159771, 0.04871514067053795, 0.08273763209581375, 0.023336129263043404, -0.023066775873303413, -0.0018916117260232568, -0.056075289845466614, -0.00821780227124691, 0.08438292145729065, -0.05560291185975075, -0.004918853752315044, -0.006181965582072735, -0.013018024154007435, 0.02465103194117546, 0.021938607096672058, -0.05767049640417099, 0.016533898189663887, 0.009027802385389805, 0.02270021289587021, -0.03552563488483429, 0.03936445713043213, 0.08486942201852798, 0.006791363470256329, -0.03960801288485527, 0.050860609859228134, 0.009403889067471027, -0.009692894294857979, -0.003107419004663825, 0.058532457798719406, -0.07379002124071121, -0.0352507084608078, -0.056280869990587234, -0.03385220468044281, -0.01465301401913166, -0.02580452524125576, 0.06828397512435913, 0.0595989003777504, -0.03060568869113922, -0.0007591306348331273, 0.013244583271443844, 0.009769285097718239, -0.006723961792886257, -0.04062377288937569, -0.01632535085082054, 0.049991004168987274, 0.021977411583065987, 0.003492849413305521, -0.03454441949725151, 0.014729767106473446, -0.052801813930273056, -0.009827898815274239, 0.006761873606592417, -0.0007306173210963607, 0.049179185181856155, -0.02615332417190075, 0.018081484362483025, -0.009417245164513588, -0.011679773218929768, 0.0169351976364851, -0.006004213355481625, 0.01118193008005619, -0.02773759700357914, -0.027148278430104256, -0.021257318556308746, 0.014353646896779537, -0.009154336526989937, 0.02778494730591774, -0.02682488039135933, 0.04883767291903496, 0.08359555155038834, 0.03750363364815712, -0.03332072123885155, -0.006833231076598167, 0.020008329302072525, -0.0064933812245726585, -0.016432104632258415, -0.030730025842785835, -0.018658161163330078, -0.015580604784190655, -0.012082806788384914, -0.03874077647924423, -0.007793846540153027, 0.0075172120705246925, 0.0005481706466525793, 0.0143720218911767, 0.03422102704644203, -0.030673226341605186, -0.04229648783802986, -0.053861796855926514, -0.06232481822371483, 0.07222495228052139, -0.0019433344714343548, 0.040598638355731964, 0.05037675052881241, 0.012999975122511387, 0.03665538504719734, -0.0750679224729538, 0.004786699544638395, 0.011674177832901478, 0.042388953268527985, -0.04198465123772621, 0.008594093844294548, 0.02363632805645466, 0.0021447360049933195, -0.027406128123402596, 0.013083807192742825, 0.06137924641370773, -0.03334348648786545, 0.008851651102304459, -0.022171037271618843, -0.03487757220864296, 0.014595123007893562, -0.03663768619298935, 0.012851654551923275, -0.02750028669834137, -0.03985246643424034, -0.01077097188681364, -0.019172074273228645, 0.03595855087041855, -0.011989223770797253, -0.04691482335329056, -0.017846090719103813, 0.029392126947641373, 0.003665473312139511, -0.020592764019966125, 0.04367474094033241, -0.016495786607265472, -0.0032856299076229334, 0.0005741027416661382, 0.009561676532030106, 0.012427911162376404, -0.021301141008734703, 0.08075349032878876, -0.019255533814430237, 0.038774263113737106, -0.048580102622509, 0.0008679187740199268, -0.01951601170003414, 0.021483398973941803, -0.01269590761512518, -0.005493485368788242, -0.044175323098897934, -0.0694856122136116, -0.035782117396593094, 0.008550613187253475, -0.010930893942713737, -0.0012678271159529686, 0.01898283138871193, 0.008399357087910175, -0.04407411068677902, 0.04652991518378258, 0.0313003771007061, 0.0005578591953963041, -0.006413360591977835, 0.0013430260587483644, -0.06080801039934158, -0.054774876683950424, -0.05840088799595833, -0.04532443359494209, 0.010067641735076904, -0.07410270720720291, -0.07842089980840683, 0.0034117233008146286, -0.02403542771935463, -0.010202870704233646, 0.017219191417098045, 0.004964997060596943, -0.025346316397190094, 0.04934284836053848, 0.0018966876668855548, 0.01051794458180666, 0.02078593708574772, -0.022849498316645622, 0.010210556909441948, 0.02161294035613537, 0.030087294057011604, 0.01975889876484871, -0.0022596505004912615, 0.03026708774268627, 0.025360245257616043, -0.009823298081755638, -0.06749440729618073, 0.03256191685795784, 0.06839409470558167, 0.020881954580545425, 0.019148657098412514, -0.026819225400686264, 0.03216876462101936, 0.0319562666118145, 0.009478870779275894, 0.013398665003478527, 0.031141994521021843, 0.0567183755338192, 0.03979218751192093, -0.009050692431628704, 0.054844073951244354, 0.03566393256187439, -0.05175450071692467, -0.008116835728287697, -0.033971577882766724, 0.051619455218315125, 0.03914940357208252, 0.04447964206337929, 0.04653826728463173, 0.025391701608896255, 0.01874987594783306, 0.02783045917749405, -0.05829237028956413, 0.01573711633682251, 0.051088057458400726, 0.006573187652975321, -0.035181015729904175, 0.0000313522141368594, -0.03491703048348427, 0.00032369588734582067, -0.062078338116407394, 0.05526503175497055, 0.027617350220680237, -0.015655936673283577, -0.00639206962659955, -0.006669018417596817, 0.041473012417554855, -0.0555153489112854, -0.046617768704891205, -0.056888237595558167, -0.01097462885081768, -0.053101327270269394, -0.025961976498365402, -0.014941523782908916, -0.0031228004954755306, -0.0575777068734169, -0.07111261039972305, -0.02270139381289482, 0.04419761151075363, -0.043922509998083115, 0.0009047329076565802, -0.03712979331612587, 0.026369694620370865, -0.02180762030184269, -0.006893109530210495, 0.011859129182994366, -0.08524654060602188, 0.0489877425134182, -0.009631420485675335, 0.03184055536985397, -0.020235896110534668, 0.022970376536250114, -0.0030673311557620764, 0.05035153776407242, -0.047480497509241104, 0.022515075281262398, -0.01568513736128807, -0.058831315487623215, -0.010391270741820335, 0.0080783786252141, 0.007030968554317951, -0.016262851655483246, -0.02561306208372116, 0.04893223196268082, 0.04280366376042366, 0.030468996614217758, -0.016613729298114777, 0.017768865451216698, -0.048322632908821106, -0.07309231907129288, 0.004588620271533728, 0.012605114839971066, 0.03993770480155945, -0.02061154507100582, 0.024850893765687943, 0.010235308669507504, -0.015279539860785007, -0.03281840682029724, 0.014903889037668705, 0.03017125464975834, -0.005448373034596443, -0.02375692129135132, -0.04699486494064331, -0.017650026828050613, -0.004898794926702976, -0.02993084117770195, 0.019845599308609962, 0.007684247102588415, 0.029456807300448418, -0.023177646100521088, -0.02248290553689003, 0.01998625136911869, -0.026481546461582184, -0.04830159991979599, 0.04155363887548447, 0.058469079434871674, 0.011575441807508469, -0.037597399204969406, 0.03961856663227081, 0.02268189750611782, -0.03482494875788689, -0.03883841261267662, -0.01815180294215679, 0.05912128463387489, -0.016060568392276764, 0.05160500109195709, -0.034805525094270706, 0.01940714195370674, -0.03829692304134369, -0.052486274391412735, 0.02578877843916416, 0.015662437304854393, -0.0019782069139182568, -0.04270527511835098, -0.05450032651424408, 0.02959006279706955, -0.038161925971508026, -0.035433508455753326, -0.05301602929830551, 0.030524956062436104, -0.03565182164311409, 0.02444125898182392, 0.04240699112415314, -0.02010739967226982, 0.003755096811801195, 0.04177377372980118, 0.04121041297912598, -0.027499886229634285, -0.00017647798813413829, -0.01967471092939377, -0.026940271258354187, 0.02890414372086525, -0.04554121941328049, 0.0031372469384223223, 0.02286078780889511, 0.06293299794197083 ]
<p><a href="http://www.google.com/search?q=haldane+conjecture">Haldane's conjecture</a> states that the integer spin antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chains have a gap in the excitation spectrum. However, the dispersion relation of the antiferromagnetic spin wave is $\omega_k\sim k$ in the long wave length limit, meaning that the excitation energy could be zero. What is the matter?</p>
g6640
[ 0.008988665416836739, 0.026123663410544395, -0.012332845479249954, -0.02446824498474598, -0.014745712280273438, 0.03676227852702141, -0.005953488405793905, 0.07927799969911575, -0.022668754681944847, -0.05872632935643196, 0.03887391462922096, 0.005971021018922329, -0.023723939433693886, -0.00283521949313581, 0.041256919503211975, 0.04103526845574379, 0.010402169078588486, 0.045141663402318954, -0.005540994927287102, -0.010276680812239647, -0.04758009687066078, -0.006394585594534874, -0.044965341687202454, -0.04282381758093834, 0.011243129149079323, 0.024543633684515953, 0.009810669347643852, -0.08535408973693848, -0.017621882259845734, -0.013205201365053654, 0.0065393345430493355, -0.007598553784191608, 0.03311403468251228, -0.01342109777033329, 0.04885397106409073, 0.023508267477154732, 0.01663612760603428, -0.0019682757556438446, -0.05964941158890724, -0.02115231566131115, -0.03380758315324783, 0.023053845390677452, 0.029221463948488235, 0.009728283621370792, -0.012920176610350609, 0.017208607867360115, -0.007695105392485857, 0.05364353209733963, 0.010477033443748951, 0.012974470853805542, -0.01003821287304163, 0.009929332882165909, 0.05927783250808716, 0.006420664023607969, -0.017211226746439934, 0.07658354938030243, -0.03106570802628994, -0.03330368548631668, 0.006998388562351465, 0.050972986966371536, 0.017200207337737083, -0.0070125386118888855, -0.01661212556064129, 0.05138830840587616, 0.03123675473034382, -0.001082873553968966, -0.08054810762405396, 0.02862311340868473, -0.0008214203990064561, 0.007510536350309849, 0.0240474846214056, -0.02557423897087574, -0.01009217556566, -0.038284480571746826, -0.039851732552051544, 0.0007057494367472827, 0.05322962999343872, 0.01861400157213211, 0.02188965119421482, 0.038629092276096344, -0.052083518356084824, 0.04750807583332062, -0.011633709073066711, -0.05459893122315407, 0.046314630657434464, -0.015794113278388977, -0.03631037101149559, 0.025738419964909554, 0.02117050252854824, 0.10999977588653564, 0.00396436732262373, 0.01549815945327282, 0.021611783653497696, -0.035018615424633026, 0.0021359883248806, -0.03709564357995987, 0.0491001270711422, 0.034571029245853424, -0.02996114082634449, 0.016201607882976532, -0.02282807230949402, 0.046635981649160385, 0.0096511859446764, -0.01988528110086918, 0.034894634038209915, -0.006503894925117493, -0.0029645415488630533, -0.04925811290740967, 0.03249434754252434, 0.04266638308763504, -0.012709620408713818, 0.020761603489518166, -0.0703965499997139, -0.024566199630498886, -0.015140868723392487, 0.04106609895825386, 0.05863763019442558, -0.027561990544199944, -0.027740098536014557, 0.0075536794029176235, 0.016764283180236816, 0.013715834356844425, -0.043395034968853, 0.11787614971399307, 0.006190564949065447, 0.004636468831449747, 0.0012483419850468636, 0.021433712914586067, 0.030659230425953865, 0.002266393043100834, -0.006957231089472771, 0.007490926422178745, -0.00875757820904255, 0.0023098792880773544, 0.019789371639490128, 0.003997527528554201, 0.020733611658215523, 0.036465905606746674, -0.021127240732312202, 0.006392013281583786, -0.017305029556155205, -0.09187242388725281, 0.01902652531862259, -0.030171560123562813, -0.015729960054159164, 0.006672173738479614, 0.005228927358984947, -0.038471072912216187, 0.004734414163976908, 0.002824280643835664, 0.009917891584336758, 0.07562840729951859, -0.011828964576125145, -0.07021584361791611, 0.007974544540047646, 0.030099904164671898, 0.0672372430562973, 0.0020698425360023975, 0.005618113558739424, -0.000955990981310606, -0.0051719113253057, 0.01334460824728012, 0.03004959225654602, 0.051407523453235626, -0.06768914312124252, -0.07116352021694183, 0.06869318336248398, -0.015487066470086575, -0.016639351844787598, -0.02144235372543335, -0.06787300109863281, -0.0018255674513056874, -0.01088473666459322, -0.005423332564532757, 0.055319324135780334, 0.06547439098358154, -0.057644665241241455, -0.06082381308078766, 0.0027014226652681828, -0.00917880330234766, 0.021792404353618622, -0.011249951086938381, 0.015895159915089607, 0.018400510773062706, -0.04538191109895706, 0.08049190044403076, 0.09761740267276764, -0.04882765933871269, 0.026957442983984947, -0.03545830771327019, 0.032721586525440216, 0.028825808316469193, -0.03368685767054558, -0.017539862543344498, 0.04677863419055939, 0.025643257424235344, 0.003052146639674902, -0.047980133444070816, -0.014650513418018818, 0.011525379493832588, 0.0525512658059597, 0.01230445597320795, -0.04837701842188835, 0.006656534969806671, 0.02795041911303997, 0.012676510028541088, 0.007253770716488361, -0.02962702512741089, 0.025066088885068893, -0.06755302101373672, 0.020137500017881393, -0.0023422474041581154, -0.07284924387931824, 0.0056890700943768024, 0.01717577502131462, 0.01902809925377369, 0.010978790931403637, -0.01911074109375477, 0.02285647951066494, 0.04239882156252861, -0.0010627019219100475, 0.014385237358510494, 0.03631661832332611, 0.04760558530688286, -0.02228359691798687, -0.03136155381798744, -0.07719089835882187, -0.049126990139484406, -0.06938102841377258, 0.014555482193827629, -0.006737956311553717, -0.07393676042556763, 0.03689444437623024, 0.002957595745101571, 0.016806870698928833, -0.005005166865885258, -0.01249291468411684, -0.045960284769535065, 0.009288952685892582, -0.014751722104847431, -0.002096649492159486, 0.028253816068172455, -0.060192544013261795, 0.005894476547837257, 0.04838870093226433, -0.013731407932937145, -0.01758662424981594, -0.022642750293016434, -0.016943883150815964, -0.005722119938582182, 0.033466797322034836, 0.01669210009276867, -0.0015629797708243132, 0.03733741492033005, 0.006203237920999527, -0.039711326360702515, -0.02888074517250061, 0.06506580859422684, -0.02819347195327282, -0.0628056600689888, 0.06364796310663223, -0.0035954827908426523, 0.06834736466407776, 0.025437097996473312, -0.04801982268691063, -0.021975181996822357, -0.0018463960150256753, 0.05112891271710396, -0.041734881699085236, -0.0601465217769146, 0.002585954964160919, 0.08855094015598297, 0.0005243102787062526, 0.003629835555329919, -0.06007694825530052, -0.020363280549645424, -0.03102121688425541, 0.0020751217380166054, 0.012617039494216442, -0.01608330011367798, -0.04577767848968506, 0.03823074325919151, 0.011540837585926056, 0.0009301471873186529, -0.016242608428001404, -0.034030571579933167, -0.0011222410248592496, -0.0007375530549325049, 0.04130411148071289, -0.029525088146328926, -0.016039105132222176, -0.0023687793873250484, 0.074832484126091, 0.004724488593637943, -0.03550703078508377, 0.0666085034608841, 0.019854506477713585, -0.006335557904094458, 0.007774462457746267, 0.020200183615088463, -0.010661915875971317, 0.043408650904893875, -0.04011541232466698, 0.011093816719949245, 0.04256061092019081, 0.01198611781001091, -0.04213597998023033, -0.03386242315173149, -0.050428736954927444, -0.006150409113615751, -0.04018126428127289, 0.040844663977622986, 0.015131672844290733, 0.03539038076996803, 0.04141043499112129, 0.046444524079561234, 0.007128729484975338, 0.061651118099689484, -0.00015644477389287204, -0.027584202587604523, -0.015606672503054142, -0.03126826509833336, 0.014727940782904625, -0.014101367443799973, 0.02320886217057705, -0.019406281411647797, -0.029952429234981537, -0.0020337924361228943, -0.08683416992425919, 0.019397681578993797, -0.009082665666937828, -0.0870424211025238, -0.018065858632326126, 0.0010037687607109547, -0.05900880694389343, 0.006781840696930885, 0.01105632446706295, 0.03874412178993225, 0.012049158103764057, 0.09810028225183487, -0.09290911257266998, 0.01255156472325325, -0.04981722682714462, 0.024905750527977943, -0.006887497846037149, 0.06008697301149368, -0.035189904272556305, -0.007829990237951279, -0.047411222010850906, -0.017381390556693077, -0.08066631108522415, 0.004042902495712042, 0.0028145534452050924, -0.03994223475456238, -0.0487387478351593, 0.010840150527656078, 0.01136280782520771, 0.02428092248737812, 0.03365756943821907, -0.008385873399674892, 0.014023168943822384, -0.0027602699119597673, 0.07289538532495499, -0.02613990567624569, -0.025530101731419563, -0.020765462890267372, -0.041821062564849854, -0.01926497370004654, 0.05565757304430008, -0.042328499257564545, 0.014587953686714172, 0.014480200596153736, -0.001900744391605258, -0.005938983056694269, -0.006602533161640167, -0.06501149386167526, -0.031962085515260696, 0.01956229656934738, -0.009120630100369453, 0.033223241567611694, 0.023498674854636192, 0.025274693965911865, 0.020004695281386375, 0.0308492761105299, -0.008421882055699825, -0.0021449404302984476, -0.023938942700624466, 0.009423410519957542, -0.05516965314745903, -0.037652671337127686, -0.018701117485761642, -0.07948096841573715, 0.04645891860127449, 0.008452920243144035, -0.05617212504148483, -0.01900324411690235, -0.012610959820449352, -0.07548622786998749, 0.005263671278953552, 0.021500568836927414, 0.013456698507070541, 0.048164382576942444, -0.044673752039670944, -0.01621725596487522, 0.039196837693452835, 0.052158597856760025, 0.07390142232179642, -0.01821601577103138, 0.02411184273660183, 0.029360337182879448, -0.0084206722676754, 0.0009429972269572318, -0.018369130790233612, -0.05378128960728645, -0.013952900655567646, -0.014144676737487316, 0.027422301471233368, -0.02301470935344696, -0.010510256513953209, -0.021532557904720306, 0.030691392719745636, -0.0022719858679920435, -0.020062793046236038, 0.047758523374795914, -0.03890148177742958, -0.009698254987597466, 0.0067403800785541534, -0.008971184492111206, -0.02238440327346325, -0.017480041831731796, -0.07220768928527832, 0.008071820251643658, -0.008502677083015442, 0.027729187160730362, -0.06169389188289642, 0.015397131443023682, -0.008960784412920475, 0.0791233479976654, 0.037602949887514114, 0.027464071288704872, 0.016997192054986954, 0.03967660292983055, 0.07740828394889832, 0.03170739486813545, 0.03452720865607262, 0.04749979451298714, -0.04331127181649208, -0.021475303918123245, -0.016164543107151985, -0.031986989080905914, 0.04440038278698921, -0.012328152544796467, -0.050685714930295944, -0.09204172343015671, 0.049865640699863434, -0.028927091509103775, -0.062347110360860825, 0.0065690320916473866, 0.0586102157831192, 0.05058690533041954, -0.03224921226501465, -0.030675308778882027, -0.03823227062821388, -0.015188144519925117, 0.02376498281955719, 0.00009211893484462053, -0.03139512985944748, -0.06524056941270828, -0.08109112083911896, 0.036879442632198334, 0.042101699858903885, 0.00400701817125082, -0.040920455008745193, 0.004831282421946526, -0.027050048112869263, -0.014258341863751411, 0.04217357560992241, 0.01616360805928707, -0.047321002930402756, -0.04573743790388107, -0.008609018288552761, 0.012922714464366436, 0.0034858870785683393, -0.014435747638344765, 0.023504555225372314, 0.01735183410346508, -0.021014289930462837, -0.01112973690032959, -0.031016893684864044, -0.07619882375001907, 0.08673688024282455, 0.017080333083868027, -0.022674834355711937, -0.01880338415503502, 0.04723956435918808, -0.005738777108490467, 0.03022061102092266, 0.025935232639312744, -0.013136845082044601, 0.008164369501173496, 0.008772947825491428, -0.025329362601041794, -0.0023785880766808987, -0.01835084706544876, -0.02334655076265335, 0.08724439144134521, 0.05292793735861778, 0.041285570710897446, -0.009708854369819164, 0.006392957642674446, -0.03198684751987457, 0.01025352906435728, 0.026690028607845306, 0.030619867146015167, 0.06063820421695709, 0.013937987387180328, -0.028922714293003082, -0.08722301572561264, 0.06599672883749008, -0.002880824264138937, -0.029715409502387047, -0.04931727051734924, 0.009860469959676266, -0.02524174004793167, -0.009694445878267288, -0.05047112703323364, 0.022499166429042816, 0.032476041465997696, -0.015057219192385674, 0.0205918587744236, 0.04240939021110535, 0.02248242497444153, -0.047294020652770996, -0.03520768880844116, 0.02347453683614731, 0.024474887177348137, 0.017604079097509384, 0.03027847409248352, -0.04786039888858795, 0.06344940513372421, -0.022203700616955757, -0.07507355511188507, 0.02989007532596588, 0.031383905559778214, 0.060890037566423416, -0.019978439435362816, -0.012589224614202976, -0.03637968376278877, 0.016309427097439766, -0.06117696315050125, -0.040573377162218094, 0.0064558652229607105, -0.004870302975177765, -0.026248103007674217, 0.029695332050323486, 0.00015884972526691854, 0.012164964340627193, -0.025816958397626877, 0.028682075440883636, -0.03387802839279175, 0.011584257706999779, 0.03352629393339157, 0.010996950790286064, -0.0017385657411068678, 0.001372201251797378, 0.03852758929133415, -0.06911584734916687, -0.06347176432609558, -0.014171660877764225, -0.038482099771499634, -0.015246852301061153, 0.039245352149009705, -0.015054672956466675, 0.020960554480552673, 0.0512213371694088, 0.001220401143655181, 0.0385751947760582, -0.07848022878170013, -0.02808113396167755, -0.026002679020166397, -0.060481708496809006, 0.020395776256918907, 0.000581811647862196, 0.009513475000858307, 0.01850220374763012, -0.001418369123712182, -0.01142230723053217, -0.058500587940216064, 0.0678471252322197, 0.02710563689470291, -0.0301379207521677, -0.009529750794172287, -0.033340491354465485, -0.0032067354768514633, 0.030003253370523453, -0.01993951015174389, 0.016546577215194702, -0.023879501968622208, -0.07457566261291504, -0.04764356464147568, 0.010698425583541393, -0.03821273148059845, 0.01818188838660717, 0.052356868982315063, -0.07885242998600006, 0.00646683806553483, -0.0022391341626644135, -0.019464312121272087, -0.02126610465347767, 0.03822138532996178, -0.020326673984527588, -0.014665406197309494, 0.05175581946969032, 0.016677534207701683, 0.050459496676921844, -0.03318889066576958, 0.008350269868969917, -0.005373791325837374, 0.011534717865288258, 0.03616616874933243, 0.023336073383688927, -0.01706622540950775, -0.04666145145893097, -0.007181528490036726, 0.03377068042755127, 0.05004653334617615, 0.006022301968187094, 0.017194030806422234, -0.007932611741125584, -0.005190448369830847, -0.014113010838627815, 0.011293979361653328, -0.04050575569272041, 0.07047808170318604, -0.03838283196091652, 0.009427061304450035, -0.0581045001745224, -0.04726121202111244, 0.02262972667813301, 0.03167605772614479, -0.009628537110984325, 0.007179584354162216, 0.043236006051301956, 0.005990516394376755, -0.025876887142658234, -0.009636078961193562, 0.01464706938713789, -0.030047746375203133, 0.016893496736884117, -0.05399087443947792, 0.0009501728345640004, -0.017576921731233597, -0.05279893800616264, 0.06552647054195404, -0.018058976158499718, -0.06864867359399796, -0.031367573887109756, -0.04504597559571266, 0.039513200521469116, 0.0004267246404197067, -0.0069486419670283794, -0.011237633414566517, -0.006710892077535391, -0.0811440646648407, -0.03836999461054802, 0.022794976830482483, 0.020227180793881416, -0.0056466832756996155, -0.002794967032968998, 0.0367581844329834, 0.01502195280045271, -0.016115939244627953, -0.017302649095654488, -0.05611618235707283, 0.03235029801726341, 0.009532150812447071, -0.04109220579266548, -0.019321849569678307, -0.005455670412629843, 0.007715458981692791, 0.018162112683057785, 0.05556883662939072, -0.00026875498588196933, 0.0457945317029953, 0.011175047606229782, 0.038069985806941986, -0.040681444108486176, 0.02689751610159874, 0.017137160524725914, 0.004161499440670013, 0.009214073419570923, 0.011671452783048153, 0.04415854066610336, -0.011130592785775661, 0.03791000694036484, 0.03224407136440277, -0.005571354646235704, 0.023195646703243256, 0.005098997615277767, 0.03441563621163368, 0.0676751583814621, -0.005316723603755236, -0.02197539433836937, 0.06310410797595978, -0.010447494685649872, -0.010544943623244762, 0.04678644612431526, 0.031245455145835876, -0.03217603266239166, -0.037148259580135345, 0.050109077244997025, 0.011773635633289814, 0.0017337239114567637, -0.020990807563066483, 0.09329479932785034, 0.031001778319478035, -0.049444299191236496, 0.02715623937547207, 0.015845071524381638, -0.0452374704182148, 0.016881508752703667, -0.005173829384148121, 0.04301862418651581, 0.014164574444293976, -0.05670217424631119, -0.013570466078817844, 0.002751615596935153, 0.011759787797927856, 0.056974951177835464, 0.0328977108001709, -0.02528274618089199, 0.03036884404718876, -0.043090347200632095, -0.012025733478367329, -0.059199653565883636, -0.014113316312432289, -0.047882407903671265, 0.010414449498057365, 0.041329193860292435, -0.012810994870960712, -0.0053551881574094296, 0.07692456990480423, 0.036350708454847336, -0.03429562598466873, -0.009672056883573532, -0.009601716883480549, -0.0040334295481443405, -0.016608022153377533, 0.0012593342689797282, 0.015119798481464386, -0.10863955318927765, 0.020421389490365982, 0.038072213530540466, 0.031214600428938866, 0.04035287722945213, -0.04474731907248497, 0.01654350385069847, 0.05251893773674965, 0.03960367292165756, -0.0402584969997406, 0.004570513963699341, -0.03580386936664581, 0.00645240256562829, 0.0549180693924427, 0.0455084852874279, -0.04587450250983238, 0.02699854038655758, 0.017490997910499573 ]
<p>Relativity of Simultaneity seems to be about OBSERVING two events simultaneously (please correct me if I am wrong). </p> <p>However, as long as the two events are separated by a distance (any distance) then two observers (in the same frame) cannot agree that they happen simultaneously unless they are equidistant from the two events within the frame.</p> <p>Consider the example of A and B at rest with respect to another observer C. A and B are stationary in space but separated by 1 light second of distance.</p> <p>An event occurs simultaneously at A and B, the time should be the same since they are at rest with respect to each other. However, A will OBSERVE event at A and exactly after 1 second, the event at B. B will OBSERVE the event at B and exactly after 1 second, the event at A.</p> <p>C may observe A first, B first or A and B simultaneously (which is fine).</p> <p>My questions are:</p> <ol> <li>Are A and B in the same inertial frame? And if so, if simultaneity is about OBSERVING an event, then how do we account for the different observation times within the same frame? An event can never be simultaneous for A and B unless they are at the same location.</li> <li>If A and B are not in the same frame, then they are not in inertial frames as there is no motion with respect to each other.</li> <li>If simultaneity is not about OBSERVING two events, then how do we separate the visual aspect (time taken for light to travel) from the temporal aspects (time at which the two events actually occurred.</li> </ol>
g6641
[ 0.03388296067714691, 0.006326586008071899, 0.02906462363898754, -0.011673971079289913, 0.03441745042800903, -0.018794942647218704, 0.0435754656791687, 0.07606346160173416, -0.006865248084068298, -0.0012892299564555287, -0.014212274923920631, -0.061292991042137146, 0.0009346013539470732, 0.011108767241239548, 0.005564126651734114, -0.026310494169592857, 0.06987124681472778, -0.06114688888192177, -0.0163583867251873, 0.02120615914463997, 0.030230727046728134, 0.08368862420320511, 0.03399937227368355, -0.012883211486041546, -0.005324784200638533, -0.004471728578209877, 0.03631377965211868, -0.047134511172771454, -0.027273381128907204, -0.008548890240490437, -0.01146771665662527, -0.018849896267056465, -0.0025676204822957516, -0.03159503638744354, 0.05644938349723816, -0.020408743992447853, 0.011309762485325336, 0.026601487770676613, -0.036795731633901596, 0.018947076052427292, 0.030158597975969315, 0.02735055983066559, 0.028947819024324417, -0.08532299846410751, 0.07205749303102493, 0.022971024736762047, 0.006704101804643869, -0.0010280795395374298, 0.005503576714545488, -0.04281889274716377, -0.0009959707967936993, 0.07450348138809204, -0.018350711092352867, 0.012761479243636131, 0.021892298012971878, 0.059335507452487946, 0.01884412206709385, -0.015767866745591164, 0.07015015929937363, 0.024924132972955704, 0.054348353296518326, -0.03952199965715408, 0.0014993727672845125, 0.04124448075890541, 0.02897193469107151, -0.03580954670906067, -0.034981101751327515, 0.013025959953665733, 0.0183868408203125, -0.03850792720913887, -0.0004283323069103062, -0.016840077936649323, -0.0262016411870718, -0.034902069717645645, -0.04595634713768959, 0.013337739743292332, 0.05778347700834274, -0.0013532170560210943, 0.005877387244254351, 0.05036765709519386, -0.06302576512098312, -0.0241704098880291, 0.02581760659813881, -0.004789270926266909, 0.03500790521502495, -0.0319296158850193, 0.016201598569750786, -0.007492385804653168, -0.03691935911774635, 0.004764148034155369, 0.06055538356304169, -0.027801338583230972, 0.07056628912687302, 0.054042696952819824, -0.06458339840173721, -0.011636518873274326, -0.037839438766241074, 0.06679636985063553, 0.03361443057656288, 0.024286311119794846, -0.029534736648201942, 0.04825398698449135, -0.0091446153819561, 0.007555011659860611, 0.0361051969230175, -0.07792668044567108, -0.020153822377324104, 0.036628708243370056, -0.0642523542046547, -0.05313330888748169, -0.037124019116163254, -0.052673663944005966, -0.03400202840566635, -0.02628166973590851, -0.0729554295539856, -0.04040826857089996, 0.04571676626801491, -0.01950649730861187, -0.022944897413253784, -0.011489459313452244, -0.030955204740166664, 0.0445697158575058, -0.035286739468574524, 0.039972566068172455, -0.04752475768327713, 0.005810490343719721, -0.01187201775610447, 0.009911044500768185, 0.04213543236255646, 0.004901933949440718, 0.038764581084251404, 0.008626958355307579, 0.04989367723464966, 0.01225409284234047, -0.03617884963750839, -0.01986568421125412, 0.03620128706097603, -0.009604689665138721, 0.022576825693249702, 0.03278632089495659, 0.030060019344091415, -0.0057578072883188725, -0.02043754793703556, -0.00550341559574008, 0.01807275414466858, -0.008968481793999672, -0.0511343814432621, 0.017880836501717567, 0.018849637359380722, 0.042722124606370926, -0.05000612139701843, 0.06622689217329025, 0.005306701175868511, -0.028465019538998604, -0.012652786448597908, -0.010805141180753708, -0.03670898824930191, -0.03430015593767166, 0.02346119098365307, 0.0198433306068182, 0.07763145118951797, -0.02485453337430954, 0.005984045099467039, -0.0386095866560936, -0.02075861394405365, 0.01782158948481083, -0.0121479956433177, -0.039182692766189575, 0.025221101939678192, -0.10617423057556152, 0.0002573981473688036, -0.00726982019841671, 0.028822986409068108, 0.0018061435548588634, 0.02532973699271679, 0.03750285878777504, -0.0008191427914425731, 0.003553692251443863, -0.07362044602632523, -0.012921744957566261, -0.05266791954636574, -0.017788199707865715, -0.0410495363175869, -0.06777498126029968, -0.036141473799943924, -0.08360093832015991, 0.02201305516064167, -0.018589649349451065, -0.05170855298638344, 0.048020292073488235, -0.019897613674402237, -0.03685326129198074, -0.029728960245847702, 0.013083199970424175, -0.047226935625076294, -0.002272383775562048, 0.053470417857170105, 0.006742296740412712, -0.029371878132224083, 0.01898031122982502, -0.02888096496462822, -0.002802637405693531, -0.008298673667013645, 0.06447604298591614, 0.0065551032312214375, 0.027676472440361977, 0.006777560338377953, -0.022599752992391586, -0.008308645337820053, 0.0008324087248183787, 0.0035241972655057907, -0.06462917476892471, 0.015961987897753716, -0.031116735190153122, -0.015822913497686386, 0.05477846413850784, 0.02754906751215458, 0.008797060698270798, -0.026004042476415634, -0.018653562292456627, -0.027206744998693466, -0.018523866310715675, -0.006620908156037331, -0.04723664000630379, -0.05273567885160446, -0.01738787814974785, -0.02696159854531288, 0.05346043407917023, 0.061092402786016464, 0.03856130689382553, -0.045246295630931854, 0.059007249772548676, -0.042040836066007614, 0.0323326401412487, 0.015806077048182487, 0.03721421957015991, 0.008611060678958893, 0.02075337804853916, 0.02405664324760437, 0.004905065521597862, 0.04542671516537666, 0.011736923828721046, -0.014303558506071568, 0.010046439245343208, 0.03531371057033539, -0.02329128608107567, 0.09669937193393707, -0.02482164278626442, 0.005634802859276533, 0.01384365651756525, -0.03354572877287865, -0.05656767636537552, -0.05698340758681297, -0.015416824258863926, -0.031695228070020676, -0.0669528916478157, 0.009977847337722778, 0.010527409613132477, -0.10118340700864792, -0.008257483132183552, 0.017808089032769203, -0.045073945075273514, 0.0270280372351408, 0.0218916367739439, -0.027703164145350456, -0.02186018042266369, 0.009688426740467548, 0.016340211033821106, -0.043208200484514236, -0.014879644848406315, 0.006911073811352253, 0.006212130188941956, 0.018889833241701126, 0.06525057554244995, -0.00039717555046081543, 0.014913504011929035, -0.027536649256944656, -0.010353777557611465, 0.015583411790430546, 0.01057878602296114, -0.017802033573389053, 0.02531297691166401, -0.06007501855492592, -0.038623400032520294, 0.071605384349823, -0.0337580069899559, 0.009216878563165665, 0.002769813407212496, 0.0363897867500782, 0.01936625875532627, -0.06994406878948212, 0.04583305865526199, 0.010335937142372131, 0.01590903475880623, -0.03995414450764656, 0.05958981439471245, -0.06005379185080528, -0.025716843083500862, -0.023061972111463547, 0.025053061544895172, -0.01402619294822216, -0.010135194286704063, 0.029135687276721, 0.030029725283384323, 0.04990851506590843, 0.023440435528755188, -0.04199409484863281, -0.04643994942307472, 0.014377059414982796, -0.0345349982380867, -0.03881867602467537, 0.010255200788378716, -0.00993443001061678, -0.004739777185022831, 0.0011184263275936246, 0.05252673849463463, -0.013276146724820137, -0.018785709515213966, -0.052821170538663864, -0.005367261357605457, -0.0018322091782465577, 0.030412422493100166, -0.053205594420433044, 0.007221553940325975, 0.005840978119522333, -0.015309958718717098, 0.0284531619399786, -0.05657565966248512, -0.03294261917471886, 0.018417324870824814, -0.03633158653974533, 0.02865339256823063, 0.005616459995508194, -0.012024608440697193, 0.04164986312389374, 0.04126676172018051, -0.042557887732982635, 0.0016332784434780478, 0.05642135813832283, 0.03521174564957619, 0.045717496424913406, 0.04491610825061798, -0.06995395570993423, 0.013369509018957615, -0.01143606100231409, 0.031047770753502846, -0.0016060664784163237, 0.022418614476919174, 0.007476448081433773, -0.008371769450604916, 0.03813977912068367, 0.0033975783735513687, -0.003598501905798912, -0.05787452310323715, 0.007774203550070524, 0.04117437079548836, 0.03879807889461517, 0.02103741094470024, -0.003492828458547592, -0.009421356953680515, 0.028011033311486244, 0.020358329638838768, 0.0027984511107206345, 0.0061429524794220924, 0.01605834625661373, -0.03200807422399521, -0.005663529969751835, -0.01868988387286663, 0.06122366711497307, -0.00523749552667141, 0.013531887903809547, 0.05583905801177025, -0.03693617880344391, -0.05172518268227577, 0.07542143762111664, -0.028392305597662926, 0.05146227777004242, 0.05223218351602554, -0.005615410394966602, 0.026504019275307655, 0.02259971760213375, 0.00845902506262064, -0.010663911700248718, -0.004057640675455332, 0.09779737889766693, 0.0053375218994915485, 0.02815207839012146, 0.03010101057589054, -0.014427012763917446, -0.04088349640369415, 0.03317582234740257, -0.07017119973897934, -0.053227752447128296, -0.0850539281964302, 0.03358261659741402, 0.02945404127240181, 0.03935308754444122, 0.004163100849837065, 0.006162288133054972, 0.01802799105644226, 0.005816277582198381, 0.020118163898587227, 0.012395473197102547, -0.02926313504576683, -0.05235225707292557, 0.042616382241249084, 0.006737823598086834, -0.008807897567749023, -0.019995002076029778, 0.06143622100353241, 0.051799874752759933, 0.019727317616343498, -0.02938796952366829, -0.04609007388353348, 0.016370797529816628, 0.0015575765864923596, 0.0293988436460495, 0.02692853845655918, 0.06968527287244797, 0.02605242282152176, -0.010382731445133686, 0.04795876145362854, 0.037927914410829544, -0.024438980966806412, 0.032221049070358276, 0.08923342078924179, 0.009017513133585453, 0.010298298671841621, -0.049095191061496735, -0.02191300503909588, -0.017111780121922493, 0.004979285411536694, 0.02272825688123703, 0.02030179277062416, -0.03943570330739021, 0.04445672407746315, 0.030294612050056458, 0.061114124953746796, 0.04833552613854408, 0.010719917714595795, -0.004058322869241238, -0.014753609895706177, 0.010494478046894073, -0.029700811952352524, 0.004597689025104046, 0.032671187072992325, -0.06009252741932869, -0.06300429254770279, -0.029992971569299698, -0.04048699140548706, -0.014395270496606827, 0.05276235565543175, -0.031735021620988846, -0.020597007125616074, 0.009354962036013603, 0.0014485872816294432, -0.03965264558792114, 0.02687891758978367, -0.017374934628605843, -0.0009932961547747254, 0.021401461213827133, -0.023266570642590523, 0.027579965069890022, -0.02782224863767624, -0.018148839473724365, 0.015554160811007023, -0.04553866758942604, -0.014628312550485134, -0.04782146215438843, -0.006490305531769991, -0.030164800584316254, -0.01271179597824812, -0.016648564487695694, -0.009811848402023315, 0.04160548374056816, -0.03604671359062195, 0.0029845840763300657, -0.01621006429195404, -0.013476583175361156, -0.03861387073993683, -0.027225416153669357, -0.052616529166698456, -0.009329755790531635, -0.03257131949067116, 0.043071623891592026, -0.017572922632098198, 0.026990467682480812, -0.017110632732510567, 0.05890117585659027, 0.0012769402237609029, -0.005966118071228266, 0.04288201034069061, 0.01188600528985262, 0.00045806312118656933, -0.011150562204420567, 0.007559910416603088, 0.038539156317710876, 0.03053608536720276, -0.019666971638798714, -0.0043612257577478886, -0.05498943477869034, 0.036381326615810394, 0.0011559209087863564, -0.045149579644203186, -0.023703765124082565, 0.033919841051101685, 0.00000834296861285111, -0.025279657915234566, -0.059790242463350296, 0.04153009131550789, 0.00855250284075737, 0.051311805844306946, -0.07694827020168304, 0.047442156821489334, 0.004353978205472231, -0.07367399334907532, 0.09088007360696793, -0.039366111159324646, 0.001042350078932941, -0.05680171400308609, 0.00587817607447505, 0.02091943845152855, 0.00718538835644722, -0.041313961148262024, 0.005693493876606226, -0.04603029787540436, -0.05524367094039917, 0.0353546179831028, 0.02256760187447071, 0.010858148336410522, -0.003289995016530156, 0.010368689894676208, -0.012105783447623253, -0.02191983535885811, -0.00796521082520485, -0.0007647516904398799, 0.03481396660208702, -0.05107662081718445, 0.01842541992664337, 0.02853291481733322, -0.07713628560304642, -0.03335018828511238, -0.011320937424898148, 0.07653287053108215, -0.06112661957740784, -0.055983152240514755, 0.028360256925225258, 0.006894153542816639, 0.05164730176329613, -0.021304940804839134, -0.01452102791517973, 0.02592337504029274, 0.02946535125374794, 0.0277351476252079, -0.005177414510399103, 0.059181928634643555, -0.0019099069759249687, -0.0039743282832205296, -0.0039136228151619434, -0.0451430082321167, 0.02068292908370495, 0.008795961737632751, 0.015939444303512573, -0.035192735493183136, -0.0006156240706332028, -0.023163940757513046, 0.025207335129380226, -0.03327902406454086, 0.03368943929672241, -0.01614442467689514, 0.04161114990711212, -0.03197869658470154, -0.020608726888895035, -0.043228015303611755, -0.0024559476878494024, 0.0013326914049685001, -0.012380401603877544, 0.01764453575015068, -0.06759794056415558, 0.013288346119225025, -0.02098812907934189, -0.003206385299563408, 0.04675542563199997, -0.001911198953166604, -0.03295449540019035, 0.013241243548691273, -0.019418446347117424, -0.025843963027000427, -0.038261134177446365, -0.008137822151184082, 0.0048523773439228535, -0.029191171750426292, -0.060768384486436844, -0.0285209808498621, -0.049193281680345535, -0.042098671197891235, -0.006144129671156406, 0.02313801646232605, -0.018430177122354507, 0.089580237865448, -0.011466478928923607, -0.04586358368396759, 0.01581287756562233, -0.05847858637571335, -0.01890769600868225, 0.05067843571305275, -0.06109900772571564, 0.01649348996579647, 0.05260953679680824, -0.017695358023047447, -0.0024173292331397533, -0.008902433328330517, 0.0044997925870120525, 0.059354592114686966, -0.049746885895729065, -0.009790081530809402, -0.005844769533723593, -0.019960030913352966, -0.00813452247530222, -0.024140911176800728, 0.05938392132520676, -0.019380846992135048, 0.0001792604016372934, 0.017279889434576035, 0.012803052552044392, 0.056395430117845535, -0.0387636199593544, -0.020635029301047325, 0.0245364960283041, 0.07606461644172668, 0.018552547320723534, 0.002821022877469659, -0.052062056958675385, 0.059623897075653076, 0.021384848281741142, 0.038296494632959366, -0.027690807357430458, 0.02601328119635582, 0.004157920368015766, 0.01189005933701992, 0.05078572779893875, 0.044368427246809006, 0.03186798095703125, 0.038194891065359116, -0.01675080880522728, -0.051509372889995575, 0.03365205228328705, -0.0315479077398777, -0.03963371738791466, -0.009468882344663143, 0.0022928393445909023, -0.05703849345445633, 0.007748542353510857, 0.019306516274809837, -0.08242692053318024, -0.005234635900706053, 0.000823453301563859, -0.021659132093191147, 0.009474175982177258, -0.06885313987731934, -0.04333077371120453, 0.028359021991491318, -0.09355323761701584, -0.02582830749452114, -0.03428274020552635, 0.010635611601173878, -0.001531996880657971, -0.126581609249115, 0.0072199562564492226, -0.0014719688333570957, 0.020181166008114815, -0.015631064772605896, -0.021064244210720062, 0.0162812452763319, -0.04874606058001518, -0.0008122339495457709, -0.03208059072494507, 0.014027005061507225, 0.0037493386771529913, -0.0065202293917536736, -0.039457693696022034, 0.039383407682180405, 0.020794101059436798, 0.016597917303442955, -0.01931399293243885, 0.05030319467186928, 0.06934758275747299, -0.03927530720829964, -0.014434035867452621, -0.041175782680511475, -0.04059338569641113, 0.034874655306339264, 0.00023038405925035477, -0.016698893159627914, -0.01878659427165985, -0.016305014491081238, 0.07538865506649017, 0.018670611083507538, -0.027597377076745033, -0.0002900470863096416, -0.05147057771682739, -0.00681638577952981, 0.06475412100553513, -0.018253883346915245, 0.045599762350320816, -0.015441264025866985, 0.0008515233639627695, -0.012114128097891808, 0.04745055362582207, 0.05567330867052078, 0.028843477368354797, 0.04668433219194412, 0.024272926151752472, -0.0078179482370615, -0.026263097301125526, -0.08061132580041885, -0.031110819429159164, 0.02619086764752865, 0.048537012189626694, 0.015990274026989937, -0.005990341305732727, -0.0449797622859478, 0.0014957134844735265, -0.042935360223054886, 0.029149170964956284, 0.021830342710018158, 0.10918349772691727, -0.05776171758770943, -0.011514288373291492, -0.03343307226896286, 0.025217514485120773, 0.038598574697971344, -0.018911154940724373, 0.07157482951879501, -0.005480180028825998, 0.06693509966135025, 0.058943524956703186, -0.07577540725469589, -0.02199573814868927, 0.014020177535712719, 0.03369813412427902, -0.006325984839349985, -0.03650113195180893, 0.01113571971654892, 0.01744023710489273, 0.04156642407178879, 0.025672651827335358, 0.022390197962522507, 0.024366185069084167, 0.03572829067707062, -0.03382182493805885, 0.0949111208319664, -0.04876236617565155, 0.01775725930929184, 0.06209760159254074, 0.0068069640547037125, -0.03530165180563927, -0.010453673079609871, 0.03849480673670769, 0.010935179889202118, -0.028090395033359528, 0.014779924415051937, -0.012818980030715466, -0.019728755578398705, -0.021134350448846817, -0.024168772622942924, -0.022385871037840843, 0.06169311702251434 ]
<p>The water-gas phase transition is said to be similar to the ferromagnetic-paramagnetic phase transition (same set of critical exponents = same universality class). In the former case the order parameter is the difference in the densities, while in the latter it is the magnetization density.</p> <p>In the magnetic case the $O(N)$ symmetry is broken spontaneously - hence we talk about two distinct phases as suggested by Landau, i.e. the ferromagnetic phase (which has $O(N-1)$ symmetry) and the paramagnetic phase (which has the full $O(N)$ symmetry). Now for the water-gas case, what symmetry is spontaneously broken? Both liquid water and gaseous water have translational and rotational symmetry..</p> <p>Also, sometimes it is suggested that water and liquid should not be considered as distinct phases, since one can join the two phases by an excursion in the parameter space which does not encounter any singularities in the free energy. If so, then shouldn't we consider the paramagnetic and ferromagnetic phase to be just one phase as well?</p> <p>How do we reconcile the concept of phases being characterized by symmetry (and their breakings), or being characterized by excursions in the parameter space, since they seem to give contradictory results? Thanks.</p>
g6642
[ -0.03929635137319565, 0.04353421926498413, -0.0022248034365475178, 0.03304586187005043, 0.00421879580244422, 0.035443175584077835, -0.00025577237829566, 0.04661151394248009, -0.02173929288983345, 0.01659315824508667, -0.0062997955828905106, 0.012566604651510715, -0.03266053646802902, 0.006121492013335228, -0.032765597105026245, -0.011633066460490227, -0.019211042672395706, 0.03099551796913147, -0.009145240299403667, 0.021074259653687477, -0.02340450882911682, -0.002837836043909192, -0.0009371294872835279, -0.025341657921671867, 0.011638755910098553, -0.004449950065463781, 0.03698478266596794, -0.060062576085329056, -0.006662928033620119, -0.0020485708955675364, 0.024892527610063553, 0.052481509745121, -0.00860700011253357, -0.0690455213189125, -0.027875395491719246, -0.07489003986120224, 0.01615295745432377, -0.006878410931676626, 0.019966185092926025, -0.02706580050289631, 0.0020564221777021885, 0.07010339200496674, 0.015379493124783039, 0.004439039155840874, 0.0033209456596523523, 0.04755290970206261, -0.025358548387885094, -0.029749765992164612, -0.07438793778419495, 0.019440216943621635, 0.07780518382787704, 0.09541039168834686, 0.03997187316417694, 0.012952746823430061, -0.029220739379525185, 0.037215933203697205, -0.04018815606832504, 0.04069993272423744, 0.0881781205534935, 0.015418585389852524, -0.0006535890279337764, 0.057756975293159485, 0.0018913989188149571, -0.008111821487545967, 0.09171873331069946, -0.0504951998591423, -0.050627451390028, 0.01656430773437023, -0.0022594425827264786, -0.03543921932578087, -0.004592324141412973, -0.04883808270096779, 0.0038085526321083307, -0.020223567262291908, -0.019071165472269058, 0.009247773326933384, -0.0024507474154233932, -0.007501598447561264, 0.021729465574026108, -0.0677875429391861, -0.00345189543440938, 0.02414257638156414, 0.0015382798155769706, 0.0346074216067791, 0.005931300111114979, -0.026082325726747513, -0.0026446781121194363, -0.030584782361984253, 0.0067148590460419655, 0.0032574539072811604, -0.018187733367085457, -0.003691535908728838, -0.010285099036991596, 0.046822577714920044, 0.0074225859716534615, 0.007513910997658968, 0.042501550167798996, 0.04728015884757042, -0.020521705970168114, 0.015222717076539993, -0.04590931162238121, 0.006681577768176794, -0.003837008262053132, -0.0395817868411541, -0.006131459027528763, -0.008942069485783577, 0.02332931011915207, 0.03459256514906883, 0.03942638263106346, 0.014337214641273022, -0.017220189794898033, 0.03376356512308121, -0.06050315871834755, 0.060248833149671555, -0.023215536028146744, 0.024216987192630768, 0.09088419377803802, -0.05037132650613785, 0.008406003005802631, 0.0033096959814429283, -0.003764551132917404, -0.006940694525837898, 0.0332314670085907, 0.11535625904798508, -0.022617381066083908, 0.014780677855014801, 0.02494853176176548, -0.017792047932744026, -0.0009043518221005797, 0.0026266679633408785, -0.04104861244559288, -0.004240547306835651, -0.026524338871240616, 0.0353100411593914, 0.0028199381195008755, -0.027168309316039085, 0.03378830477595329, 0.08652424812316895, 0.009062392637133598, -0.06031697243452072, 0.026323555037379265, 0.019293857738375664, -0.044995471835136414, -0.029755348339676857, -0.04825149103999138, -0.0393303781747818, -0.009235134348273277, -0.006101325154304504, -0.00651959702372551, 0.04432806745171547, 0.04334696754813194, 0.010496364906430244, -0.029457954689860344, -0.008037630468606949, -0.01712600328028202, -0.002661369275301695, -0.02343299612402916, -0.04771312326192856, 0.051159173250198364, -0.006033333484083414, 0.020861441269516945, -0.012736155651509762, 0.037198878824710846, 0.05822999030351639, -0.07384043186903, -0.045413222163915634, 0.041504766792058945, 0.023388609290122986, 0.04486915469169617, -0.03163312003016472, 0.002031573560088873, -0.016849933192133904, -0.016160013154149055, 0.08572550117969513, 0.02825411781668663, 0.050095535814762115, 0.007908635772764683, -0.016703886911273003, -0.00660844286903739, 0.03028145246207714, 0.0013268173206597567, -0.016079092398285866, -0.04272571578621864, -0.033655401319265366, 0.004828437231481075, 0.022414574399590492, 0.010179354809224606, 0.01755227893590927, -0.06701194494962692, -0.03602911904454231, 0.009507082402706146, 0.03339361399412155, -0.022112801671028137, -0.008511449210345745, 0.03063911385834217, -0.03712448477745056, -0.028335949406027794, 0.05658815801143646, -0.07643920928239822, -0.03914782032370567, -0.006142742466181517, -0.005452085752040148, -0.035202205181121826, 0.025044480338692665, -0.007591188419610262, 0.027207311242818832, -0.011645245365798473, 0.00023027189308777452, 0.012404167093336582, 0.019556924700737, 0.011590961366891861, -0.01569913886487484, 0.006808388978242874, -0.025258611887693405, -0.015572689473628998, 0.06397393345832825, -0.01191404927521944, -0.0026941169053316116, 0.008084116503596306, 0.013683455996215343, 0.01589156873524189, 0.038400158286094666, 0.013162320479750633, 0.027986647561192513, 0.035102445632219315, 0.006882154382765293, 0.0006046537891961634, -0.006903345230966806, 0.02812790870666504, -0.06602813303470612, -0.007812981493771076, 0.0006042419699952006, -0.012292033061385155, -0.02228359691798687, 0.007896192371845245, 0.02608048915863037, -0.023586956784129143, -0.0451359823346138, 0.02154487743973732, -0.033320438116788864, -0.0046094609424471855, -0.02169395051896572, -0.02917121909558773, 0.041128646582365036, -0.0028789089992642403, -0.02017543837428093, 0.01421317644417286, -0.0032759823370724916, 0.05597136914730072, -0.003302905708551407, -0.010922849178314209, -0.06586114317178726, -0.046005137264728546, 0.00857063289731741, -0.025218641385436058, 0.013910094276070595, 0.050389885902404785, 0.09427943825721741, -0.0904657244682312, 0.03114939294755459, -0.006235170178115368, 0.01097885612398386, 0.01013590581715107, 0.011003452353179455, -0.060248780995607376, -0.0020416025072336197, -0.01909317634999752, 0.04521443322300911, 0.012015909887850285, -0.013733395375311375, 0.0011827804846689105, 0.049683138728141785, -0.004510337021201849, 0.036076322197914124, -0.030475139617919922, -0.010507686994969845, 0.002335907658562064, -0.024834858253598213, 0.06555670499801636, -0.02276875078678131, -0.0824851393699646, -0.047929950058460236, -0.05572587996721268, -0.027982043102383614, 0.04684942215681076, -0.0321776382625103, -0.01651717722415924, 0.04008902609348297, -0.011589284986257553, 0.059764962643384933, 0.02462591603398323, 0.03340347483754158, 0.0316942073404789, 0.012172555550932884, -0.0216414425522089, 0.0015368059976026416, -0.0352528840303421, 0.0006501677562482655, 0.0008270661346614361, -0.004499667324125767, 0.029439644888043404, -0.022192854434251785, 0.022289114072918892, 0.027703456580638885, 0.012862978503108025, -0.004501542076468468, -0.025246068835258484, -0.03481576591730118, -0.01613765023648739, -0.056898150593042374, -0.09696783125400543, 0.03620770573616028, -0.03099595010280609, -0.02117163874208927, 0.0029873994644731283, -0.0054328544065356255, -0.009553348645567894, 0.031526077538728714, 0.061237022280693054, -0.05423927307128906, -0.08982279896736145, -0.0028746044263243675, 0.022659635171294212, -0.05506375804543495, -0.035606712102890015, -0.01630229875445366, -0.04588869586586952, 0.002604371402412653, -0.018348848447203636, 0.013047476299107075, -0.04710903391242027, -0.04606194794178009, 0.017115164548158646, -0.08233314752578735, -0.05580313503742218, -0.0024881765712052584, 0.0032576206140220165, 0.011121760122478008, -0.012326990254223347, -0.0005146936164237559, -0.00008733629510970786, -0.02188410609960556, 0.03862611949443817, 0.031198490411043167, 0.010194937698543072, 0.0006293230107985437, 0.024398908019065857, -0.008703676052391529, 0.0030878218822181225, 0.030599549412727356, 0.045707494020462036, 0.01338530145585537, 0.013821844011545181, 0.01406139601022005, -0.07529785484075546, 0.018636412918567657, 0.04611135274171829, -0.032218143343925476, 0.017932549118995667, -0.0036639650352299213, 0.013513275422155857, -0.030832242220640182, 0.01928587444126606, 0.02825584076344967, -0.02733469195663929, 0.004041118081659079, -0.01754705049097538, 0.045995671302080154, 0.027472253888845444, -0.0797937884926796, 0.05038008838891983, -0.03665994107723236, 0.03834200277924538, -0.08827030658721924, 0.07434561103582382, -0.025265203788876534, -0.008157751522958279, -0.035075947642326355, -0.015293385833501816, 0.02642289362847805, 0.024507392197847366, -0.053669337183237076, 0.015390311367809772, 0.0202811136841774, 0.019641300663352013, 0.00815313309431076, -0.011385477147996426, -0.008123255334794521, -0.03680044785141945, -0.08237617462873459, 0.03277343884110451, 0.029140643775463104, -0.0004915853496640921, -0.019722357392311096, 0.029859164729714394, 0.04654240235686302, 0.0029679040890187025, 0.043146051466464996, -0.04396705701947212, 0.08905238658189774, -0.043171487748622894, -0.051026441156864166, -0.01662561297416687, -0.037187036126852036, 0.019916821271181107, -0.07040584087371826, 0.025471748784184456, -0.0344376415014267, -0.018282247707247734, 0.002277249237522483, 0.01683434657752514, -0.01749538443982601, -0.04407985135912895, -0.04031902924180031, 0.01754925586283207, 0.01383662223815918, -0.00166614493355155, -0.08051694184541702, 0.029471835121512413, -0.029208600521087646, -0.01440352015197277, 0.02625800296664238, -0.08726969361305237, -0.08075802773237228, -0.02190369926393032, 0.04951656237244606, 0.055942416191101074, -0.002623805543407798, -0.0052763065323233604, 0.0045708660036325455, -0.0038963868282735348, 0.016257507726550102, 0.005552720744162798, 0.006079715210944414, -0.007126465439796448, -0.025529352948069572, -0.03867199644446373, 0.04912784695625305, 0.005234813317656517, 0.040250468999147415, 0.05470229685306549, 0.057037290185689926, 0.018614692613482475, 0.036359116435050964, 0.06837698072195053, -0.021800540387630463, 0.06291566044092178, -0.006968997418880463, -0.022275259718298912, 0.017704088240861893, -0.060890428721904755, 0.028397873044013977, -0.01589084230363369, -0.024995187297463417, -0.03380889073014259, -0.03516523167490959, -0.04344955086708069, 0.03241635486483574, -0.003853460540995002, -0.00841586384922266, 0.010263447649776936, -0.041187092661857605, 0.0014906551223248243, 0.023472731932997704, -0.012987535446882248, 0.005696979351341724, -0.0205950029194355, -0.015002775005996227, 0.00953658577054739, -0.002008673269301653, 0.022417526692152023, 0.0668753907084465, 0.03638678789138794, 0.011866630986332893, 0.09432745724916458, 0.04357610642910004, 0.05541583523154259, -0.05493149906396866, 0.004111586604267359, -0.05794057250022888, -0.0028181306552141905, -0.008530299179255962, 0.0708039179444313, 0.005743103101849556, -0.06773606687784195, 0.004948718938976526, 0.008284803479909897, -0.014332722872495651, -0.018192151561379433, 0.02115662768483162, 0.01165247056633234, 0.06265857070684433, 0.0041822828352451324, -0.05589160695672035, 0.03364614397287369, -0.03451746329665184, 0.000043926280341111124, -0.015014796517789364, -0.03740249574184418, -0.04074477776885033, -0.025588935241103172, 0.0016634792555123568, 0.04191884770989418, 0.007101905532181263, 0.026130346581339836, 0.027314482256770134, 0.004855839069932699, 0.0023473254404962063, -0.043153904378414154, 0.013096222653985023, 0.05128553509712219, -0.058273300528526306, -0.05026020109653473, 0.024247445166110992, 0.028268514201045036, 0.004536905791610479, 0.02838767319917679, -0.010238377377390862, -0.049727387726306915, -0.06408064812421799, 0.012741915881633759, -0.0008121184655465186, 0.04855833947658539, -0.08333580940961838, -0.01350120548158884, -0.026910968124866486, -0.06563440710306168, -0.013992391526699066, 0.03552108630537987, 0.004133517853915691, 0.024945946410298347, -0.011035350151360035, 0.04187331721186638, -0.021991107612848282, 0.01975991576910019, -0.09048453718423843, -0.03865158185362816, 0.0047423336654901505, 0.0625176802277565, 0.03327416256070137, -0.030839206650853157, 0.0221411045640707, 0.06541009247303009, -0.038817111402750015, 0.017422372475266457, 0.013571745716035366, -0.03542865067720413, 0.005018823780119419, -0.040826216340065, -0.009832058101892471, -0.03282429277896881, -0.008261633105576038, -0.061171822249889374, -0.014700116589665413, 0.030150532722473145, 0.06809370219707489, -0.007306800689548254, -0.017984583973884583, -0.06566838920116425, 0.009607581421732903, 0.08442332595586777, -0.011696330271661282, 0.03011501207947731, -0.03897162526845932, 0.004401425831019878, 0.0032909137662500143, -0.01027184072881937, -0.034881919622421265, -0.040135882794857025, 0.035294484347105026, -0.007491920609027147, 0.05594703555107117, 0.02565586380660534, -0.051189132034778595, 0.04096995294094086, -0.016256388276815414, 0.004256132058799267, -0.0018954912666231394, 0.01476565282791853, 0.021873481571674347, -0.008661380037665367, -0.009794430807232857, 0.03314423933625221, 0.004488688427954912, -0.05254056677222252, 0.004460858181118965, -0.06911898404359818, -0.005061266478151083, -0.0004874480946455151, 0.022307781502604485, -0.04108797758817673, -0.005359030794352293, -0.046983636915683746, -0.0063359737396240234, 0.06767160445451736, 0.03836681321263313, -0.02380317822098732, -0.06737951189279556, -0.031691405922174454, 0.059391919523477554, -0.014156630262732506, 0.008325599133968353, 0.02303669974207878, 0.032853156328201294, -0.03153575584292412, 0.05392112955451012, -0.033484674990177155, 0.07500452548265457, -0.0007112363236956298, 0.0006044817855581641, 0.004530542064458132, 0.04230920225381851, -0.006003311835229397, 0.007528279442340136, -0.03748941421508789, -0.014437857083976269, -0.03313538432121277, 0.02087455615401268, -0.01688680239021778, 0.046862006187438965, -0.02447994239628315, -0.032435331493616104, -0.012303313240408897, -0.046311669051647186, 0.009520039893686771, 0.04796256497502327, -0.0183568112552166, -0.0008673844276927412, -0.01564432680606842, 0.009141550399363041, 0.030790340155363083, -0.030957862734794617, -0.013064329512417316, 0.004139618016779423, 0.027271108701825142, -0.03037319891154766, -0.07272840291261673, 0.0010327694471925497, 0.0641472339630127, 0.015580645762383938, 0.024170508608222008, -0.017016392201185226, 0.010267933830618858, -0.009025667794048786, -0.015065751038491726, 0.037361156195402145, 0.022292597219347954, -0.04212908446788788, -0.03517967835068703, 0.04045531898736954, 0.005602787248790264, -0.06476869434118271, -0.024172572419047356, -0.007165820803493261, -0.0330236554145813, 0.07231190800666809, 0.04399031400680542, 0.003998271655291319, 0.037431444972753525, 0.0177688617259264, -0.058282479643821716, 0.1151801347732544, 0.01952405832707882, -0.029373854398727417, -0.014961699955165386, -0.007748682051897049, -0.02940799482166767, 0.017460865899920464, -0.0034428141079843044, -0.029155902564525604, -0.029822854325175285, -0.011653388850390911, -0.057122860103845596, 0.0353337787091732, 0.0317334346473217, 0.027094583958387375, 0.007372424006462097, 0.06177681311964989, 0.04205043986439705, -0.034151703119277954, 0.004090241622179747, 0.0013710842467844486, -0.007735871244221926, -0.03809979930520058, -0.01202966645359993, 0.01421345490962267, -0.059316329658031464, 0.060001276433467865, 0.06319282203912735, -0.011128525249660015, 0.017904730513691902, 0.01683996245265007, 0.06885693222284317, -0.02135181613266468, 0.0027277444023638964, 0.027685197070240974, 0.03816138580441475, -0.0034030992537736893, 0.036319486796855927, 0.002462511183694005, 0.08677053451538086, 0.009615280665457249, -0.013678454793989658, 0.010816970840096474, 0.020308757200837135, -0.00046008749632164836, 0.05463755875825882, -0.05181412398815155, 0.018172500655055046, -0.05408182367682457, -0.09616190195083618, 0.09278815984725952, 0.009967966936528683, -0.020226186141371727, 0.04502757638692856, -0.04061119258403778, -0.04825141653418541, 0.010566598735749722, 0.04623913764953613, 0.04558219015598297, -0.041302844882011414, -0.03712790086865425, 0.011198523454368114, -0.05202706530690193, -0.031199609860777855, 0.014453493990004063, 0.013516911305487156, 0.0296577587723732, 0.03948531672358513, -0.012137243524193764, -0.06539084762334824, -0.023626063019037247, -0.012737277895212173, 0.0361480750143528, -0.006289168260991573, 0.017656950280070305, 0.005286083556711674, -0.025125019252300262, 0.03755444288253784, -0.043756674975156784, 0.026470709592103958, 0.06906065344810486, 0.06320412456989288, 0.002183754462748766, -0.022130191326141357, -0.04423623904585838, -0.013465968891978264, 0.032875221222639084, 0.024155110120773315, -0.0375613272190094, -0.018254630267620087, -0.05587818846106529, 0.03754615783691406, 0.0030038838740438223, -0.018110880628228188, -0.08315089344978333, 0.011510012671351433, 0.06203337386250496, 0.010045399889349937, -0.001097799395211041, -0.012773583643138409, 0.03025190159678459, -0.014111407101154327, 0.028236495330929756, -0.0700019896030426, 0.029222598299384117, -0.01610260270535946, 0.07248752564191818 ]
<p>According to <a href="http://www.ted.com/talks/jeremy_kasdin_the_flower_shaped_starshade_that_might_help_us_detect_earth_like_planets" rel="nofollow">this TED talk by Jeremy Kasdin,</a> Nasa is planning to spend $1bn on a "Starshade" project, where a giant flower shaped metal eclipser 20 meters wide is placed 50k kilometers in front of a space telescope, to fit the telescope diameter.</p> <p>The idea is to occlude a star and photograph it's exoplanets.</p> <p>The above solution is surreal. Why can't they control the diffraction of the light around the occlusion circle with a refractive material, to direct it outwards?</p> <p>I suggest that they can design a round black occluder with soft edges overlaid with a refractive material that deflects the light away from the centre, similar to a lense.</p> <p>Why do the angles and shapes at the edge of the flower shaped occluder have to be very precise in order to control diffraction?</p>
g6643
[ -0.013617859221994877, 0.06504971534013748, -0.012536461465060711, -0.012915550731122494, -0.05248399078845978, 0.028437206521630287, 0.003876978997141123, 0.028319744393229485, 0.006620426662266254, -0.041809625923633575, 0.08548030257225037, 0.03583647310733795, 0.09058975428342819, 0.004631610121577978, 0.07739116996526718, 0.06021399050951004, 0.02370862476527691, -0.001593244494870305, 0.04841611161828041, 0.05199500173330307, 0.021183010190725327, 0.0033180154860019684, -0.06228369474411011, -0.0027145962230861187, -0.04004766792058945, 0.027110056951642036, 0.032579295337200165, -0.022115860134363174, -0.02993900142610073, 0.0034268752206116915, 0.04743942990899086, -0.00951910950243473, 0.0357428677380085, -0.012003076262772083, 0.02394256182014942, 0.03545055165886879, -0.023632602766156197, -0.006631587166339159, -0.01033503096550703, -0.015516516752541065, -0.037868060171604156, 0.016147997230291367, -0.011280020698904991, -0.02233787253499031, 0.00500693591311574, -0.018311351537704468, -0.028314027935266495, 0.010679585859179497, 0.051066555082798004, -0.04884958639740944, 0.0040279715321958065, 0.03359517827630043, 0.004519645590335131, -0.026249244809150696, 0.02251688949763775, 0.013080665841698647, -0.02036866545677185, 0.0020591523498296738, 0.09994002431631088, -0.046856798231601715, -0.020229505375027657, 0.028955727815628052, -0.03617769479751587, 0.07514206320047379, 0.004543194081634283, -0.016908327117562294, 0.024981826543807983, 0.0020841388031840324, 0.06928860396146774, 0.013663168996572495, -0.0009693413157947361, 0.007456108462065458, 0.01016797311604023, -0.029554318636655807, -0.054706599563360214, 0.013836725614964962, -0.04091251641511917, 0.04179663211107254, -0.005481553729623556, 0.039823953062295914, 0.00864045973867178, -0.022367069497704506, -0.0535602867603302, -0.023331422358751297, 0.0753675103187561, 0.019991831853985786, -0.01632731221616268, -0.056875698268413544, 0.01634731888771057, 0.0184079110622406, 0.014073595404624939, -0.017309240996837616, 0.02428789995610714, -0.02469239942729473, 0.020530737936496735, -0.026668518781661987, -0.0010335850529372692, -0.016026318073272705, -0.05324018746614456, 0.016169164329767227, -0.02785957045853138, 0.005509371403604746, 0.0054730745032429695, 0.05398303642868996, 0.02696308307349682, -0.016265058889985085, 0.001620789640583098, 0.023119106888771057, 0.05289413034915924, 0.007073690649122, -0.034715961664915085, -0.042739029973745346, -0.013289786875247955, -0.03542289137840271, -0.012459708377718925, -0.018751565366983414, 0.06745974719524384, -0.013996188528835773, 0.04833260551095009, 0.0639440044760704, 0.030234094709157944, -0.043571580201387405, 0.024798747152090073, 0.07407771050930023, 0.009998149238526821, -0.02381659671664238, 0.024472683668136597, -0.02624194324016571, 0.041087325662374496, -0.05347304418683052, -0.05392530560493469, -0.000023457514544134028, -0.017174122855067253, -0.009801463223993778, 0.00991052109748125, 0.013636411167681217, -0.024056516587734222, -0.01331323105841875, -0.015009447000920773, -0.029830945655703545, -0.021704116836190224, 0.03733544796705246, -0.0005884810816496611, 0.012439983896911144, -0.09809788316488266, 0.007038874085992575, 0.0076822079718112946, 0.05193145573139191, -0.024851618334650993, -0.018349701538681984, 0.005255377385765314, 0.029202112928032875, 0.0164871234446764, 0.013856294564902782, -0.05415351688861847, -0.032541170716285706, 0.03883127123117447, 0.0426907017827034, -0.018354507163167, 0.014578278176486492, 0.05200706422328949, 0.05630050227046013, -0.05037618800997734, 0.0038446467369794846, -0.0028605719562619925, 0.008255007676780224, -0.009947977028787136, -0.07112215459346771, -0.05572135001420975, -0.03308922052383423, -0.019318154081702232, 0.028070086613297462, -0.007403065450489521, 0.011621128767728806, 0.037689391523599625, 0.05219467356801033, 0.05241219699382782, -0.04369749128818512, 0.025915447622537613, 0.0685616210103035, -0.004079217556864023, -0.04876038432121277, -0.001184142311103642, 0.004872980993241072, -0.013923383317887783, -0.024167150259017944, 0.034634657204151154, -0.038489602506160736, 0.01848823018372059, 0.008879365399479866, 0.06981157511472702, 0.004482008051127195, 0.007020897231996059, 0.009373076260089874, 0.007171047851443291, -0.006708608474582434, 0.06237579882144928, -0.027706580236554146, -0.03599468246102333, 0.060914333909749985, -0.02026396431028843, 0.046581584960222244, 0.010078683495521545, 0.030501844361424446, 0.006376826204359531, -0.02216850221157074, -0.043827515095472336, 0.06217458099126816, 0.0004414991126395762, 0.01470654271543026, 0.013841469772160053, -0.0011250147363170981, 0.0009089999366551638, 0.001950525213032961, 0.0011252430267632008, 0.021690934896469116, -0.016821684315800667, -0.01565217599272728, -0.028239434584975243, -0.012314185500144958, 0.03431243821978569, -0.0062828343361616135, 0.10138264298439026, -0.03609057143330574, -0.018245285376906395, 0.022562159225344658, -0.06633036583662033, -0.019394632428884506, 0.032960113137960434, -0.008947400376200676, 0.006261872127652168, -0.04461747780442238, 0.03429679200053215, -0.0034414257388561964, 0.07324754446744919, 0.005024785175919533, 0.0007045655511319637, 0.021152546629309654, -0.04785018041729927, 0.017501618713140488, 0.02840171754360199, -0.03818783536553383, -0.0346376895904541, -0.07167918235063553, -0.0013690697960555553, -0.006104141939431429, -0.03501679748296738, -0.006966308690607548, -0.07136465609073639, 0.0248089712113142, 0.04271438345313072, 0.026489244773983955, 0.015537161380052567, -0.029240282252430916, -0.05392345413565636, -0.02448171004652977, -0.05220445245504379, 0.023799221962690353, -0.033513393253088, -0.03235890716314316, -0.02418816275894642, -0.02007637359201908, 0.0019273237558081746, -0.006059938110411167, -0.03597330302000046, 0.021420029923319817, -0.017310282215476036, -0.0019880463369190693, 0.03876107186079025, 0.04136507958173752, 0.039565395563840866, 0.03881913796067238, 0.03453008458018303, 0.01123158261179924, -0.028537744656205177, 0.059938736259937286, -0.03878800570964813, 0.018618160858750343, 0.07708393037319183, 0.09401001036167145, -0.01129496656358242, 0.040095485746860504, -0.03224441036581993, 0.024496732279658318, 0.012736043892800808, 0.01161322370171547, -0.0286082923412323, 0.005136010702699423, 0.003088301280513406, -0.03541475161910057, -0.027454564347863197, 0.043815597891807556, -0.027204295620322227, -0.03825998306274414, 0.02146194502711296, 0.0010470559354871511, -0.00940679106861353, 0.07503567636013031, -0.025616297498345375, 0.03272014111280441, 0.0016729490598663688, 0.04643339663743973, 0.003218302270397544, 0.051226597279310226, -0.019953742623329163, 0.04225568845868111, 0.023669404909014702, -0.027018235996365547, 0.017549794167280197, 0.00886351615190506, 0.0758323147892952, -0.01804456301033497, 0.01930011250078678, 0.049361422657966614, 0.023637404665350914, -0.020144466310739517, -0.026560626924037933, 0.0025280937552452087, -0.024627279490232468, 0.05196129530668259, 0.043425530195236206, 0.0754554271697998, -0.045117322355508804, -0.02554761804640293, 0.012149471789598465, -0.005835383199155331, 0.011833012104034424, -0.03619874641299248, -0.031291041523218155, -0.00944216363132, 0.05283576622605324, 0.0706239715218544, -0.03669191151857376, -0.045214198529720306, -0.005651397164911032, 0.0649651288986206, 0.00765324616804719, 0.03575004264712334, 0.06794068962335587, 0.029277395457029343, -0.04182907193899155, 0.009985942393541336, -0.053529929369688034, -0.027768278494477272, 0.0518239326775074, 0.009718972258269787, 0.03070887178182602, -0.02487707883119583, 0.0025391329545527697, -0.027235759422183037, 0.05596188083291054, 0.01203830260783434, -0.004914677236229181, -0.055172961205244064, -0.027262182906270027, 0.03700465336441994, 0.04915301129221916, 0.002763223135843873, 0.028578732162714005, -0.04754209518432617, 0.02800815925002098, 0.041314058005809784, -0.01800207979977131, -0.0469716340303421, 0.019812988117337227, -0.00989922508597374, 0.060147177428007126, 0.051019709557294846, -0.02451295219361782, 0.05184405669569969, -0.018570391461253166, -0.03330789878964424, -0.04632384702563286, -0.026647228747606277, 0.009085227735340595, 0.010959528386592865, 0.035908475518226624, 0.03803442046046257, 0.016775064170360565, -0.0018773960182443261, 0.02232147566974163, 0.06343375891447067, 0.0012618873734027147, -0.017288029193878174, 0.011739259585738182, 0.004685307387262583, -0.00779078109189868, -0.09439807385206223, 0.0047062975354492664, -0.014236261136829853, -0.0035252326633781195, -0.06767845898866653, 0.06405004858970642, -0.05731907859444618, -0.00047702345182187855, 0.018364589661359787, 0.0012308413861319423, -0.053461816161870956, -0.05065587908029556, -0.05660086125135422, 0.08470060676336288, 0.00534299248829484, 0.0097831254824996, -0.009521585889160633, -0.03260787948966026, -0.08002380281686783, -0.006715382914990187, -0.052705343812704086, -0.04778201878070831, 0.018311403691768646, 0.05946088954806328, -0.005467362701892853, -0.017416037619113922, -0.014043264091014862, 0.0071590859442949295, 0.017092525959014893, 0.005817313212901354, 0.045709241181612015, 0.003038253867998719, -0.024714788421988487, -0.0036904553417116404, 0.09792165458202362, 0.0018745617708191276, 0.0030826914589852095, 0.051683761179447174, 0.0869104340672493, -0.02805444225668907, -0.05699117109179497, 0.03131953626871109, -0.01524039264768362, 0.04154082015156746, 0.00477008568122983, 0.010246170684695244, -0.010822802782058716, -0.02738182805478573, -0.013185781426727772, -0.0016136823687702417, -0.00777098536491394, -0.02177181839942932, -0.004167498089373112, 0.009748106822371483, -0.06524796783924103, -0.010713908821344376, -0.050669919699430466, 0.02203623577952385, 0.045179519802331924, -0.008858304470777512, 0.036030273884534836, -0.022761572152376175, 0.01664571836590767, -0.0038532742764800787, -0.048253659158945084, -0.023151064291596413, 0.004941555671393871, -0.01836777664721012, -0.03186739236116409, -0.09116719663143158, -0.008865813724696636, 0.007784713059663773, 0.037409503012895584, 0.0107108224183321, -0.020929360762238503, -0.0014839572831988335, -0.007825808599591255, 0.07169938832521439, 0.04270567744970322, -0.013056154362857342, -0.062249165028333664, 0.013191794976592064, -0.027391958981752396, -0.0351581834256649, 0.07609978318214417, 0.0075912270694971085, 0.08509255200624466, -0.0365334078669548, -0.024600306525826454, -0.03420913219451904, -0.05945605784654617, -0.02108573541045189, -0.033494025468826294, -0.021668605506420135, 0.012210103683173656, 0.0411062017083168, -0.03071664273738861, -0.011872736737132072, 0.018399160355329514, -0.028071526437997818, -0.035627078264951706, -0.07059044390916824, -0.014156599529087543, -0.017221415415406227, -0.0503963977098465, 0.003958116285502911, -0.00237076822668314, 0.029416752979159355, 0.0067269569262862206, 0.038399308919906616, 0.026912054046988487, 0.06779946386814117, -0.0071185799315571785, 0.0021071217488497496, -0.01386351604014635, -0.06694941967725754, -0.007298566401004791, -0.022581880912184715, -0.017292018979787827, 0.0195208340883255, -0.033042360097169876, 0.027411365881562233, 0.04434385150671005, -0.029063798487186432, -0.026517236605286598, 0.027108199894428253, 0.008118710480630398, 0.026852257549762726, -0.021968873217701912, -0.044305216521024704, -0.058007918298244476, -0.01668853498995304, -0.005207267124205828, 0.03594940900802612, 0.017881184816360474, -0.05372360348701477, -0.009276431053876877, 0.024748442694544792, 0.024864288046956062, -0.009675632230937481, 0.013075442984700203, -0.03433927521109581, -0.002972938120365143, -0.03402416780591011, 0.02581632137298584, -0.026467127725481987, -0.0372825488448143, -0.02190009318292141, 0.015968801453709602, 0.07608254253864288, 0.05533071979880333, 0.04010045900940895, -0.04374958202242851, -0.02743208035826683, 0.04311944916844368, 0.061287324875593185, 0.040760189294815063, 0.043913811445236206, -0.037830740213394165, 0.02273201197385788, 0.052845776081085205, 0.007209674455225468, -0.01848466694355011, -0.0012426100438460708, 0.03872132673859596, -0.0017911497270688415, 0.015921710059046745, 0.02331911027431488, -0.007593956775963306, -0.0804566815495491, -0.0716552659869194, -0.023916523903608322, -0.05939215421676636, 0.009647371247410774, -0.0009437656844966114, 0.01112072728574276, 0.02857079729437828, 0.002996566006913781, -0.002073801588267088, 0.008951330557465553, 0.02619003877043724, 0.031551577150821686, 0.011393922381103039, -0.0630178228020668, -0.07146542519330978, 0.012358295731246471, -0.013353347778320312, 0.0393490269780159, 0.0017399366479367018, -0.004476458765566349, -0.030567947775125504, -0.04264695569872856, 0.010091021656990051, 0.026542291045188904, 0.017753256484866142, -0.009461659938097, -0.04158217832446098, -0.00004663097934098914, 0.016012893989682198, -0.05343157798051834, 0.041078031063079834, 0.06016632169485092, -0.10604163259267807, 0.042194075882434845, -0.07015698403120041, 0.008677292615175247, 0.006808374542742968, -0.05965616926550865, -0.020415307953953743, 0.007983414456248283, 0.06439127773046494, -0.01596948131918907, 0.010905815288424492, -0.009362276643514633, -0.012371452525258064, 0.051248949021101, 0.04718444123864174, 0.000033306481782346964, -0.02487241104245186, -0.026555495336651802, -0.013689389452338219, 0.07710610330104828, -0.03154965490102768, 0.03376384079456329, 0.01290807593613863, 0.041881997138261795, 0.0008773807203397155, -0.04284805804491043, -0.015178854577243328, -0.03894748166203499, -0.0636725127696991, -0.007250905968248844, -0.026333484798669815, 0.011263707652688026, -0.0005462705157697201, -0.03830474987626076, 0.007907415740191936, -0.004813524894416332, 0.015497579239308834, -0.03170572593808174, -0.03649881109595299, 0.022829566150903702, 0.03875143080949783, -0.01093938760459423, -0.014871008694171906, 0.029677610844373703, 0.03290093317627907, -0.004652236122637987, 0.01803090050816536, -0.06222572177648544, 0.06975392252206802, 0.028837792575359344, 0.052598316222429276, -0.011703616939485073, -0.003920146729797125, 0.014119991101324558, 0.07077214866876602, -0.04159938544034958, 0.004271919373422861, 0.0077018048614263535, 0.003389563877135515, -0.058655090630054474, -0.010026907548308372, -0.002927359426394105, -0.04108297452330589, -0.0338309146463871, 0.0017499102978035808, 0.005433409474790096, 0.008893703110516071, -0.057816557586193085, -0.017170721665024757, -0.02465382032096386, -0.08591113984584808, -0.019667070358991623, -0.017259255051612854, -0.013018004596233368, -0.010488562285900116, -0.0024416858796030283, -0.041835471987724304, 0.03791112080216408, 0.004137574229389429, -0.09924019128084183, 0.0040775323286652565, -0.03038155660033226, -0.004534636624157429, -0.04491381719708443, -0.015066488645970821, 0.01458087470382452, -0.04832039028406143, 0.019610334187746048, 0.019341476261615753, -0.029220907017588615, 0.005702233873307705, 0.03867965564131737, 0.07746826857328415, 0.08191706240177155, -0.014314649626612663, -0.08983679115772247, -0.03464648872613907, -0.038237571716308594, 0.001091423095203936, 0.048847269266843796, -0.038778241723775864, -0.013269844464957714, 0.05769853666424751, -0.02554113045334816, 0.016256999224424362, 0.02984151802957058, 0.016269266605377197, 0.04188442602753639, 0.020198959857225418, -0.05082789435982704, -0.04688394069671631, -0.02292230911552906, -0.00380457891151309, 0.010338133201003075, 0.01116181630641222, 0.07043484598398209, 0.009739920496940613, -0.03886101394891739, 0.04156910255551338, 0.002033863216638565, 0.02232632040977478, 0.00992629211395979, -0.012774252332746983, -0.00845764484256506, 0.053155794739723206, -0.022276829928159714, 0.010360251180827618, -0.033465564250946045, 0.0162601750344038, -0.033616308122873306, 0.0033187330700457096, -0.047126684337854385, -0.053961046040058136, 0.035301338881254196, -0.062031492590904236, 0.014715726487338543, -0.029873423278331757, 0.02780064381659031, -0.030039342120289803, -0.0000858598286868073, -0.05169977992773056, 0.041972480714321136, 0.021361172199249268, 0.010704915970563889, -0.0005535816308110952, -0.02734965831041336, -0.052038200199604034, -0.03907021880149841, -0.09332729876041412, -0.047034718096256256, -0.0037940777838230133, 0.0003465965564828366, -0.07582402974367142, -0.020402271300554276, -0.05500943958759308, -0.006769181694835424, 0.023973921313881874, -0.022461600601673126, 0.0474882610142231, -0.019971953704953194, 0.011160358786582947, -0.025062790140509605, 0.0413038432598114, -0.035388555377721786, -0.0578877292573452, 0.05258140340447426, -0.009604526683688164, 0.03292706608772278, -0.027713727205991745, 0.02341209352016449, 0.022028174251317978, 0.047858644276857376, -0.025581877678632736, -0.05747022479772568, -0.009722065180540085, -0.0302390418946743, 0.01713927835226059, 0.0015304289991036057, 0.022287946194410324 ]
<p>I currently have a very limited knowledge of how radiation works etc, but while sat in class the other day, one question occurred to me that even my teacher could not answer.</p> <p>We have been learning about alpha, beta and gamma radiation. I know that alpha is positive and that makes perfect sense. However, when the neutron is broken down to form a β particle and this particle is then sent out of the nucleus, why is this negatively charged β particle not attracted (presumably by electromagnetic force) back into the overall positive nucleus of the atom? To me, at least, it does not make sense that it would not be attracted back the nucleus.</p> <p>Sorry if this is simple stuff but even after some furious googling I haven't been able to find an answer.</p>
g6644
[ 0.024008337408304214, 0.013104435987770557, 0.005203351844102144, -0.053528089076280594, 0.08220955729484558, 0.03225436434149742, 0.002178701339289546, 0.03713184967637062, -0.012504644691944122, -0.04860677197575569, 0.016384193673729897, 0.0390351377427578, -0.03740372881293297, -0.0007375533459708095, 0.025300676003098488, 0.022249735891819, 0.07992994040250778, 0.002636966062709689, 0.027181534096598625, 0.03376111388206482, 0.026229720562696457, 0.033722855150699615, -0.0015861892607063055, -0.08599025011062622, -0.023555783554911613, 0.01480264775454998, 0.01592269539833069, -0.044380225241184235, -0.009709008038043976, -0.047539930790662766, 0.013196096755564213, -0.01608046144247055, 0.029988043010234833, 0.004550194833427668, -0.010513652116060257, -0.045635975897312164, -0.027131684124469757, 0.006673981435596943, -0.031157152727246284, 0.012325192801654339, 0.007433324586600065, 0.004565738607198, 0.029932593926787376, -0.01218253094702959, 0.04475054889917374, 0.06658322364091873, 0.020105253905057907, -0.012505666352808475, 0.005861582234501839, 0.005941448267549276, -0.011953008361160755, -0.06801658123731613, -0.03921535983681679, 0.04591453820466995, 0.005113149993121624, -0.007570828776806593, 0.06823675334453583, -0.02857235260307789, 0.05823609605431557, 0.008677699603140354, -0.03213096037507057, 0.07262355089187622, -0.009177197702229023, -0.022545792162418365, -0.008519860915839672, -0.0534583255648613, -0.06749644130468369, 0.043606992810964584, 0.007827619090676308, 0.04087134078145027, -0.010678162798285484, -0.030108634382486343, -0.05518632009625435, -0.001300169969908893, 0.04124215617775917, -0.003973799757659435, 0.03128350153565407, -0.04472209885716438, -0.006164440885186195, 0.016752086579799652, -0.032463472336530685, -0.07300935685634613, 0.03710492327809334, -0.0020754374563694, 0.08252081274986267, 0.036959078162908554, -0.03593679890036583, -0.009389572776854038, -0.0032167346216738224, -0.025759033858776093, 0.029964759945869446, -0.04217880591750145, 0.04694414511322975, 0.028194459155201912, -0.010586078278720379, -0.06860880553722382, 0.006662388797849417, 0.03062525764107704, -0.0492803156375885, -0.003966463264077902, 0.038062237203121185, -0.03527618944644928, 0.003946647979319096, 0.04368068277835846, -0.02359722927212715, 0.005853528622537851, 0.0014246258651837707, -0.02469157613813877, 0.009922667406499386, 0.0010898654581978917, -0.06028526648879051, -0.021036701276898384, -0.0026932668406516314, -0.04716429114341736, 0.007237538229674101, 0.0018596445443108678, 0.066513791680336, -0.03881646692752838, 0.02417495846748352, 0.06706994771957397, -0.00979013554751873, 0.06605706363916397, -0.06457554548978806, -0.037656333297491074, -0.03637458756566048, -0.01154681108891964, 0.0028777618426829576, 0.041369203478097916, 0.036960892379283905, -0.010073859244585037, 0.03803354874253273, 0.004258362576365471, -0.04510539397597313, 0.038257040083408356, 0.024606380611658096, 0.03647425398230553, 0.05172261968255043, -0.03804304078221321, 0.03341378644108772, -0.04460824280977249, 0.03785775601863861, 0.023357493802905083, 0.022206038236618042, -0.011906581930816174, -0.03596967086195946, 0.054659027606248856, -0.02239908091723919, 0.012934240512549877, 0.026708686724305153, 0.05510854348540306, 0.010199070908129215, 0.023308873176574707, 0.05856743082404137, -0.04089329391717911, 0.05657301843166351, -0.05781913176178932, 0.0185447596013546, 0.0155800711363554, -0.011980175971984863, -0.014999225735664368, 0.11932379007339478, 0.012279496528208256, -0.02658260427415371, -0.04131532832980156, -0.047943610697984695, -0.0025827977806329727, -0.020395515486598015, -0.051687512546777725, -0.04137426242232323, -0.001620463328436017, -0.05270455405116081, 0.02059837244451046, 0.03280344605445862, -0.018964426591992378, -0.0198370348662138, 0.016743039712309837, 0.0025643259286880493, -0.021434329450130463, 0.012719676829874516, -0.024911116808652878, -0.08189425617456436, 0.02385142259299755, 0.05486496165394783, -0.004707769025117159, 0.026324240490794182, -0.04042007401585579, -0.04653218761086464, 0.06303077191114426, -0.022051485255360603, 0.0037054617423564196, 0.024924537166953087, -0.010785982012748718, -0.01581132411956787, -0.029201123863458633, 0.0014537564711645246, -0.06448669731616974, 0.007658961694687605, -0.043525807559490204, 0.040438584983348846, 0.029319047927856445, -0.06078903004527092, 0.009470688179135323, 0.011904066428542137, 0.009028492495417595, 0.06668001413345337, -0.056755006313323975, -0.00843418575823307, 0.07114797830581665, 0.06799673289060593, 0.003790526883676648, -0.020976901054382324, -0.03513554111123085, 0.012860799208283424, -0.03221127763390541, -0.01787118799984455, -0.017809651792049408, -0.03176768496632576, 0.043620169162750244, -0.04783922806382179, -0.028119711205363274, -0.08079154789447784, -0.00788796879351139, 0.01302406843751669, -0.05136760696768761, -0.03504627197980881, 0.05802728235721588, -0.027364028617739677, -0.01642524264752865, -0.0063940719701349735, 0.04393840581178665, -0.09648862481117249, 0.01505488995462656, -0.11146394908428192, -0.011369824409484863, 0.06223639100790024, 0.018214119598269463, -0.011680670082569122, 0.04000990092754364, -0.010215471498668194, -0.09903072565793991, -0.05565400794148445, -0.049058347940444946, -0.055002741515636444, 0.021006999537348747, -0.006696353200823069, -0.06416959315538406, 0.05198054015636444, -0.03198239207267761, -0.028649022802710533, -0.04506491497159004, 0.035971708595752716, 0.004323019180446863, -0.03720952570438385, 0.006356388330459595, -0.006352782249450684, -0.009832971729338169, -0.03438153117895126, 0.044866789132356644, -0.052710361778736115, -0.05159865692257881, -0.018079543486237526, -0.08522658050060272, -0.03591831028461456, -0.012781777419149876, -0.04791006073355675, 0.02743457816541195, -0.050350721925497055, -0.00892589520663023, 0.03640083596110344, 0.006439703982323408, -0.03745906800031662, 0.07495267689228058, 0.03358636423945427, -0.0009639313211664557, -0.02186143770813942, -0.0031380890868604183, -0.02278119884431362, 0.00757890148088336, 0.03568378835916519, -0.056130845099687576, 0.02270391955971718, 0.055499009788036346, -0.045622389763593674, -0.06692954897880554, -0.008722427301108837, -0.013788966462016106, -0.011098324321210384, -0.05174361169338226, 0.016592862084507942, -0.009133884683251381, -0.06819593906402588, -0.008883056230843067, 0.06418554484844208, -0.034488026052713394, 0.012146592140197754, 0.022192971780896187, 0.06602034717798233, -0.0028488973621279, -0.07565132528543472, 0.040926139801740646, -0.012958812527358532, -0.013746222481131554, 0.00017265736823901534, -0.05935890972614288, -0.006109361071139574, 0.02092129737138748, -0.0763331949710846, -0.015003949403762817, -0.034325942397117615, 0.040512267500162125, -0.10714663565158844, 0.04906326159834862, -0.010473434813320637, -0.0015837600221857429, 0.020766394212841988, -0.010837838053703308, -0.034884028136730194, 0.038063809275627136, 0.08016347885131836, 0.035176511853933334, -0.04476333037018776, -0.0076172081753611565, 0.034770406782627106, -0.023589778691530228, 0.04655473306775093, 0.048292968422174454, -0.007634319830685854, -0.009946691803634167, -0.02128951996564865, -0.02257121540606022, 0.03899078816175461, -0.04305754974484444, 0.012115230783820152, 0.04437435045838356, -0.03293107450008392, 0.010670213960111141, -0.05488073453307152, 0.018192918971180916, -0.008496078662574291, 0.0282120518386364, 0.08122716844081879, -0.03494789078831673, -0.03796069324016571, 0.01610582508146763, 0.03977423906326294, 0.01841888017952442, -0.02871103398501873, -0.03509612753987312, 0.011291349306702614, 0.015182922594249249, 0.009097039699554443, 0.03912065178155899, 0.008985728025436401, 0.031704384833574295, -0.043443866074085236, -0.015309975482523441, -0.005342015530914068, 0.02395355887711048, -0.012103231623768806, 0.023312628269195557, -0.00834363792091608, -0.02692270837724209, 0.03521772846579552, -0.0034732019994407892, -0.05823604390025139, 0.028340741991996765, -0.021489620208740234, 0.024618685245513916, -0.0044670067727565765, -0.015429383143782616, 0.015251915901899338, 0.005061228759586811, -0.007071575615555048, 0.009091213345527649, 0.036523446440696716, -0.021980328485369682, 0.040213800966739655, 0.05734353885054588, -0.017961299046874046, 0.006425293628126383, -0.011120130307972431, -0.022580290213227272, 0.024395272135734558, 0.05394676327705383, 0.028625858947634697, 0.03078303672373295, -0.007062160409986973, -0.010940102860331535, -0.05260468274354935, -0.027434740215539932, 0.010173683054745197, -0.007171657867729664, -0.020839078351855278, 0.019063780084252357, -0.002941218437626958, -0.03886469453573227, 0.03388813138008118, -0.013480727560818195, 0.017847903072834015, 0.015536894090473652, -0.034110892564058304, 0.06006808578968048, -0.012208400294184685, -0.08006241172552109, 0.05494699999690056, 0.07102359086275101, -0.014310114085674286, -0.018523214384913445, -0.022164588794112206, -0.05471891909837723, -0.0002275825827382505, 0.003947950899600983, -0.005269313231110573, -0.016433846205472946, 0.012335012666881084, -0.023191725835204124, 0.013714032247662544, 0.052245113998651505, 0.009120741859078407, 0.0067535401321947575, 0.014283024705946445, 0.04216058924794197, -0.007470922078937292, 0.0008636991842649877, 0.02203856222331524, 0.07448168843984604, 0.0763126015663147, 0.06240600347518921, 0.023898977786302567, -0.016858994960784912, 0.04384475201368332, 0.04850734770298004, 0.005719411186873913, 0.02165745384991169, -0.07026269286870956, 0.07082975655794144, -0.07349307835102081, 0.04674805328249931, 0.016082776710391045, 0.013982289470732212, 0.10259625315666199, -0.012123540975153446, 0.012167047709226608, -0.013107881881296635, 0.009341711178421974, 0.04630301520228386, -0.04454249143600464, -0.04089805856347084, -0.058856554329395294, -0.02537338063120842, -0.03447786346077919, 0.033479806035757065, -0.08221606910228729, -0.04454364255070686, -0.01103514339774847, 0.007808181457221508, -0.01317609939724207, 0.017782168462872505, -0.03134036436676979, 0.05094905197620392, -0.03574219346046448, 0.0016318553825840354, 0.08377016335725784, 0.030997753143310547, -0.006486591883003712, -0.016089705750346184, 0.023550264537334442, 0.014791514724493027, -0.029337847605347633, 0.002745134988799691, -0.009459028020501137, 0.057887446135282516, 0.02278796397149563, -0.03222283720970154, 0.018348217010498047, 0.010363280773162842, 0.01312261912971735, -0.0011226222850382328, 0.030299587175250053, -0.002959260018542409, -0.038406722247600555, -0.03393549844622612, -0.009494448080658913, -0.020868368446826935, -0.0217429231852293, 0.04468364641070366, 0.008715223520994186, 0.052366338670253754, 0.030535059049725533, -0.045611001551151276, 0.0406990572810173, -0.001848449232056737, 0.013389049097895622, -0.060892559587955475, 0.020607590675354004, -0.06770399212837219, -0.03020750731229782, 0.022914379835128784, -0.004981471691280603, -0.020884785801172256, -0.03436347469687462, -0.06888731569051743, -0.03229309991002083, 0.00017190611106343567, -0.016718696802854538, 0.04944879561662674, 0.05075613409280777, -0.05829655006527901, -0.03543149307370186, -0.0282397773116827, -0.032116807997226715, -0.0367506667971611, 0.016247626394033432, -0.004040278494358063, -0.0030471826903522015, 0.0008315090672113001, -0.044764306396245956, 0.03152347356081009, 0.03104388527572155, 0.014656055718660355, -0.03547373786568642, 0.04382555931806564, 0.028664221987128258, -0.05606174096465111, 0.022395355626940727, -0.009676077403128147, -0.07360689342021942, 0.06000053137540817, 0.07290121167898178, -0.013853057287633419, 0.04981537535786629, -0.0001593426859471947, 0.04299171641469002, 0.04299129173159599, -0.007558618206530809, -0.0564851313829422, -0.0011463494738563895, 0.0012836935929954052, 0.0352875292301178, 0.037040773779153824, 0.05171312764286995, -0.007939034141600132, 0.04345688223838806, 0.021366385743021965, -0.013018704019486904, 0.01684701442718506, 0.004993203561753035, 0.007241586688905954, -0.01796887069940567, 0.028490647673606873, -0.008965401910245419, 0.010696743614971638, 0.010824211873114109, 0.03404921293258667, -0.008658863604068756, 0.001809529261663556, 0.033766139298677444, -0.0047990866005420685, 0.011453681625425816, -0.06542462110519409, -0.01989665813744068, -0.007969456724822521, -0.02439797669649124, 0.0543917752802372, 0.03623871132731438, -0.024231472983956337, 0.04175820201635361, -0.024435047060251236, -0.012614801526069641, 0.03058621659874916, 0.028443042188882828, 0.04572557657957077, 0.05747642368078232, 0.025429973378777504, 0.026666970923542976, 0.00831251684576273, -0.02839074097573757, -0.021859971806406975, -0.021122515201568604, 0.018850259482860565, 0.06536190211772919, 0.04133354127407074, 0.030205778777599335, -0.0371679924428463, -0.026199568063020706, 0.023518217727541924, -0.0012881850125268102, -0.02529798448085785, -0.009075951762497425, -0.06786465644836426, 0.005253199953585863, -0.02894006296992302, 0.023044655099511147, -0.02098877727985382, -0.05322481691837311, -0.020359134301543236, 0.009265003725886345, -0.051492948085069656, -0.02446179836988449, -0.0058364262804389, 0.015399886295199394, 0.01699930615723133, -0.017300445586442947, -0.004936514887958765, 0.030858218669891357, -0.009822240099310875, 0.041700802743434906, 0.007526930887252092, 0.03474051505327225, 0.035487085580825806, -0.04786737635731697, 0.019451675936579704, -0.051232803612947464, -0.013639037497341633, -0.0021152286790311337, -0.04856562241911888, 0.007587404455989599, 0.039192844182252884, 0.006704396568238735, 0.011772490106523037, -0.003963933326303959, 0.012282779440283775, 0.04011773318052292, -0.006938769016414881, 0.07628504931926727, 0.02577836997807026, -0.008705666288733482, 0.015111436136066914, 0.03889397904276848, 0.06236952543258667, -0.03365257382392883, 0.02887517213821411, -0.03982142359018326, 0.012250701896846294, -0.018739255145192146, 0.008483322337269783, 0.03985096141695976, 0.013224761933088303, 0.02615310810506344, -0.006590492557734251, -0.02273404225707054, 0.0616505891084671, -0.007780627813190222, 0.014604340307414532, -0.03573332726955414, 0.049433059990406036, 0.016795936971902847, 0.015544612891972065, -0.09849315136671066, 0.02591557614505291, 0.039414841681718826, 0.0034325141459703445, 0.017308661714196205, 0.04206031933426857, -0.07511650025844574, 0.02534538321197033, 0.0035258790012449026, 0.03678567707538605, -0.00964437797665596, -0.04585350677371025, 0.005571971647441387, -0.02843708172440529, -0.04083005338907242, 0.008907526731491089, -0.006073298864066601, -0.010094336234033108, 0.033471304923295975, 0.020240163430571556, 0.009392048232257366, -0.015262461267411709, 0.005065002012997866, -0.01441741082817316, -0.024471184238791466, -0.018428107723593712, -0.012746669352054596, 0.002400614321231842, 0.020590174943208694, 0.01734563522040844, 0.01921400986611843, 0.0023156525567173958, -0.015993166714906693, -0.010305529460310936, 0.023030562326312065, 0.002401150530204177, -0.03943723812699318, 0.05668448656797409, -0.05250254273414612, 0.009500067681074142, 0.034136541187763214, 0.04918240010738373, -0.020600249990820885, 0.04334097355604172, 0.03907141834497452, -0.021889889612793922, -0.05636664107441902, 0.0061730737797915936, -0.011899064294993877, 0.07654765248298645, 0.024244900792837143, -0.047730669379234314, 0.0002900279650930315, -0.02891838736832142, 0.004623137414455414, -0.03071674145758152, 0.02190426178276539, 0.0037668601144105196, -0.02599795162677765, -0.00018964662740472704, -0.06231628358364105, -0.0655316486954689, -0.003818314289674163, -0.0042290715500712395, 0.038578346371650696, 0.010197813622653484, 0.006608373019844294, 0.01996975764632225, -0.04038846120238304, -0.003640318289399147, -0.026916582137346268, -0.030833667144179344, 0.03486448526382446, 0.01396010909229517, -0.04939447343349457, -0.03048538602888584, 0.03762148320674896, -0.04276926442980766, -0.02173345908522606, -0.049336157739162445, 0.03420514985918999, 0.027311544865369797, -0.02991143986582756, 0.028163917362689972, -0.01216072216629982, -0.03450652211904526, -0.016862543299794197, 0.005153050180524588, 0.051275163888931274, -0.042827315628528595, -0.01138138398528099, 0.008827990852296352, 0.03507039695978165, -0.020392438396811485, 0.017465874552726746, -0.029169298708438873, -0.01313522644340992, -0.052225589752197266, -0.04203731194138527, 0.05613362044095993, 0.00003253899558330886, -0.0028461602050811052, -0.008793225511908531, -0.001671862555667758, 0.008590484037995338, 0.08780514448881149, 0.0871891900897026, -0.03655454143881798, 0.0035551053006201982, 0.022410385310649872, -0.03909618407487869, -0.0000199421319848625, 0.004578769207000732, 0.032618723809719086, -0.0015884237363934517, -0.012376928701996803, -0.02862759865820408, -0.026135612279176712, -0.05739225819706917, 0.028470326215028763 ]
<p>If I knew the exact value of constant centripetal force and the <strong>average velocity</strong> of an object travelling around a circle for time $t$, would that be enough information to determine the final positon of an object? What I mean is what if I had another object, at the same initial position and with identical centripetal force applied to it, which would have a different velocity function $f(t)$, but identical average velocity - would it eventually be in the same place as the first object after time $t$? Deriving a formula answering this question was beyond my skills.</p>
g6645
[ 0.04353971779346466, -0.0266567412763834, 0.0009197763283737004, 0.0028293814975768328, 0.08210050314664841, -0.033833302557468414, 0.054894447326660156, -0.01454002782702446, -0.08535398542881012, 0.009339424781501293, -0.01195644959807396, -0.05001015588641167, -0.000647502311039716, -0.04055473580956459, 0.019740840420126915, -0.004924615379422903, 0.06514380872249603, -0.06769785284996033, 0.046202417463064194, 0.04458828270435333, 0.011171135120093822, 0.010548685677349567, 0.021569959819316864, -0.06584851443767548, -0.008940332569181919, -0.009721551090478897, -0.046193927526474, -0.03526166081428528, -0.0788915753364563, 0.005608078092336655, 0.02909708395600319, -0.012129191309213638, 0.03218824416399002, -0.08303665369749069, -0.03656738996505737, -0.0021200363989919424, 0.045674946159124374, 0.02928503416478634, -0.005845578853040934, 0.012348833493888378, 0.07309254258871078, -0.004425890743732452, 0.005948483943939209, 0.007406247314065695, 0.014988220296800137, -0.022067343816161156, -0.0040277475491166115, 0.007694547064602375, -0.004771776497364044, -0.006320117507129908, -0.045228321105241776, 0.042627934366464615, 0.041702184826135635, -0.01353511307388544, -0.02733514830470085, 0.08567172288894653, 0.1168610155582428, -0.08065695315599442, -0.05899495631456375, 0.0005857729120180011, -0.0127163240686059, 0.014278331771492958, -0.01564817503094673, -0.023488789796829224, 0.04613432660698891, -0.03308026120066643, -0.012365484610199928, 0.025632916018366814, -0.05768154561519623, -0.010481095872819424, -0.009632245637476444, -0.02657717652618885, 0.03313445672392845, -0.03677753731608391, -0.07965671271085739, 0.018116919323801994, 0.032421231269836426, -0.024295929819345474, 0.0529676154255867, -0.023306572809815407, 0.005290166940540075, 0.0497729554772377, 0.006117481272667646, 0.04749318212270737, 0.04336445778608322, -0.025699306279420853, -0.010821087285876274, -0.006104364525526762, 0.01822780817747116, -0.014185721054673195, 0.04593803361058235, -0.04687883332371712, 0.023288138210773468, 0.022422198206186295, 0.05946759879589081, -0.06190218776464462, -0.012161028571426868, 0.08891426026821136, 0.006302427034825087, 0.058539558202028275, -0.028547171503305435, -0.02077954076230526, -0.03210775926709175, 0.0003232562739867717, 0.021860383450984955, -0.028261760249733925, 0.059237655252218246, 0.001917438581585884, -0.0461307056248188, -0.013436878100037575, 0.0011948273750022054, -0.04944697767496109, -0.013777070678770542, 0.004577916581183672, -0.025302710011601448, -0.07917580008506775, 0.04613422229886055, -0.000028596299671335146, -0.016624823212623596, 0.0076682488434016705, -0.013285009190440178, 0.0033232388086616993, -0.017244745045900345, 0.10519175231456757, 0.003859111573547125, -0.02595204859972, 0.0015048653585836291, 0.036482539027929306, 0.02157771959900856, -0.025247057899832726, 0.024579249322414398, -0.01785595715045929, 0.06613966077566147, 0.060096625238657, -0.017658434808254242, 0.06251352280378342, -0.03299852833151817, 0.04148395359516144, -0.001741983462125063, 0.016322942450642586, -0.03248244524002075, -0.05234859511256218, 0.019726626574993134, -0.008430412970483303, -0.06463656574487686, 0.04871523380279541, -0.03650376573204994, -0.01957724802196026, 0.04920150339603424, -0.012955179437994957, 0.04573509469628334, 0.08640392869710922, -0.0020153201185166836, -0.016160912811756134, -0.05344155803322792, -0.07298559695482254, -0.0019332498777657747, -0.0023772181011736393, 0.015865905210375786, 0.0037851978559046984, 0.07242216169834137, -0.01598469354212284, 0.016612811014056206, -0.004568103235214949, -0.026700006797909737, 0.03276386111974716, -0.012230511754751205, -0.0218111053109169, 0.0038477247580885887, -0.032989926636219025, -0.06609262526035309, 0.016009768471121788, 0.04033169522881508, -0.011132367886602879, -0.019802842289209366, -0.045960359275341034, -0.014700503088533878, -0.037378620356321335, 0.02692185528576374, 0.036418043076992035, 0.012213722802698612, 0.029895514249801636, 0.048458222299814224, -0.003361618844792247, -0.014029942452907562, 0.040074244141578674, 0.00247055827639997, -0.0036704016383737326, -0.05102788284420967, 0.03102257288992405, -0.006265699863433838, -0.031634777784347534, -0.049735039472579956, 0.07359088957309723, -0.03331486135721207, 0.004981496836990118, 0.026651514694094658, -0.0044099013321101665, -0.10830803960561752, 0.03016674891114235, 0.008074557408690453, 0.05025073513388634, 0.028512263670563698, -0.014856936410069466, -0.035634152591228485, 0.0016791182570159435, 0.017473658546805382, -0.00770752876996994, 0.021607903763651848, 0.04116986691951752, 0.027997374534606934, 0.002565425354987383, -0.03679139167070389, 0.0894477590918541, -0.0713944211602211, -0.0331033393740654, 0.052885886281728745, 0.059215933084487915, -0.010715936310589314, 0.004318607971072197, -0.023931490257382393, -0.006696994416415691, 0.012987880036234856, 0.008809740655124187, -0.07067835330963135, -0.021108802407979965, 0.049234166741371155, -0.01092806551605463, -0.010623844340443611, 0.060013674199581146, -0.006449488922953606, 0.01589787006378174, 0.00863347202539444, 0.04738617688417435, 0.060877200216054916, 0.03237117826938629, 0.015624083578586578, -0.0018796502845361829, 0.039481405168771744, 0.022439010441303253, 0.015485040843486786, -0.03139863163232803, -0.01265066396445036, -0.033475082367658615, 0.014177347533404827, -0.05533915385603905, 0.0227633249014616, -0.014380773529410362, 0.08179289102554321, 0.021805906668305397, -0.01640700362622738, -0.032654523849487305, -0.039176419377326965, 0.026702074334025383, 0.016498515382409096, 0.008642693981528282, -0.04269491508603096, -0.00020915400818921626, -0.07267433404922485, -0.04947194829583168, -0.028774462640285492, 0.022633880376815796, 0.03247150033712387, 0.03147243708372116, -0.046758756041526794, -0.0444650836288929, -0.012744479812681675, 0.02499304711818695, -0.026148824021220207, 0.009689802303910255, -0.01403598953038454, 0.028782309964299202, 0.011899701319634914, 0.09095852822065353, 0.005737868137657642, -0.0385388620197773, 0.0041525294072926044, -0.018551655113697052, -0.04321648180484772, 0.04676470533013344, -0.04182302579283714, 0.004904879257082939, -0.06857480853796005, 0.04152282327413559, -0.045973870903253555, -0.055469412356615067, 0.05478757247328758, 0.043049078434705734, 0.008448154665529728, 0.03505093604326248, -0.0041018589399755, 0.06903377920389175, 0.029833072796463966, -0.006620712578296661, 0.028906825929880142, 0.037702735513448715, 0.04039401561021805, -0.028546923771500587, 0.05013590306043625, -0.019915562123060226, 0.008365722373127937, -0.05817157030105591, -0.017160633578896523, 0.023464763537049294, 0.015606231987476349, 0.011671800166368484, -0.002469174098223448, -0.02991882897913456, -0.003912950865924358, 0.05641259253025055, -0.01448810938745737, 0.07610836625099182, 0.008412133902311325, -0.01774751767516136, -0.026599518954753876, 0.007608960382640362, 0.027124173939228058, 0.025486480444669724, -0.0044585722498595715, 0.05358861759305, 0.028267089277505875, -0.05060262978076935, 0.016421914100646973, -0.004145995248109102, 0.08031170070171356, 0.028958642855286598, -0.0888034999370575, -0.00011600655125221238, -0.02167220413684845, 0.002302467357367277, -0.014184628613293171, 0.06083584576845169, -0.002082463353872299, 0.01568872295320034, -0.005282111931592226, -0.002969548339024186, 0.036793824285268784, -0.004623688291758299, 0.022846532985568047, 0.033306851983070374, 0.00386771559715271, -0.04294869303703308, -0.028760863468050957, 0.008598319254815578, 0.0241900235414505, -0.008974021300673485, 0.026620950549840927, -0.021769246086478233, 0.028569037094712257, 0.02645418979227543, 0.049466732889413834, -0.02912069484591484, -0.0004962672246620059, -0.031679168343544006, 0.015079321339726448, 0.004431623499840498, 0.054523494094610214, 0.012450278736650944, -0.05154172703623772, -0.004214044194668531, -0.0021256243344396353, -0.042966872453689575, 0.014952307567000389, 0.025530459359288216, 0.009005827829241753, 0.011900014244019985, -0.008030497469007969, 0.0636759102344513, -0.0071565257385373116, -0.011402352713048458, 0.02807270549237728, 0.006620288826525211, 0.00014989193005021662, -0.011717651970684528, 0.03777997940778732, -0.022367466241121292, 0.025658629834651947, -0.020039210096001625, -0.057364173233509064, 0.021308524534106255, 0.08599629998207092, 0.06401804834604263, -0.024336611852049828, 0.033316511660814285, -0.033742379397153854, 0.007646465674042702, -0.07934503257274628, -0.018456533551216125, 0.03835597634315491, -0.05070723965764046, 0.0017221750458702445, -0.006562143098562956, 0.0023093419149518013, -0.0016575391637161374, 0.058637335896492004, -0.029387054964900017, -0.0039346059784293175, -0.07323647290468216, -0.005791193805634975, -0.028235958889126778, -0.03822639584541321, 0.0277464147657156, -0.04521181434392929, 0.014742707833647728, 0.013424808159470558, 0.01335902139544487, 0.010665264911949635, -0.012454980053007603, -0.01719534583389759, -0.0184109378606081, -0.04823578521609306, 0.010531964711844921, 0.039651308208703995, -0.06332626938819885, 0.023610716685652733, 0.026486601680517197, 0.02110188454389572, -0.039427269250154495, 0.019131505861878395, -0.057884056121110916, 0.02501833066344261, 0.06233109533786774, 0.02016938105225563, -0.012840043753385544, -0.04207323491573334, 0.0089748939499259, 0.054100267589092255, 0.035178642719984055, -0.028449585661292076, -0.05752323195338249, -0.014776958152651787, 0.04996330291032791, 0.04082798585295677, 0.020175637677311897, -0.03928351774811745, 0.022354470565915108, 0.004802272189408541, 0.034499358385801315, 0.0241878479719162, 0.031572144478559494, -0.0325985886156559, 0.07456402480602264, 0.03830435499548912, -0.052612483501434326, -0.04640578851103783, 0.059460680931806564, -0.049869269132614136, -0.024189362302422523, -0.006875297985970974, -0.026709534227848053, -0.06313461065292358, -0.00456717424094677, -0.01089085265994072, -0.03351695463061333, -0.03287277743220329, 0.018557382747530937, -0.014347922056913376, 0.0018313664477318525, -0.006949422415345907, -0.007915099151432514, -0.04645540565252304, -0.007888195104897022, -0.023881809785962105, -0.025371471419930458, 0.04143191874027252, -0.002057966310530901, 0.005313408561050892, 0.043802596628665924, -0.02750062383711338, 0.02221202664077282, -0.006355695892125368, 0.0164552703499794, 0.05890979617834091, 0.02854984439909458, -0.05097438022494316, 0.008246892131865025, 0.025560462847352028, 0.009000035002827644, 0.04189364239573479, -0.010921983048319817, -0.04069259390234947, 0.015607777051627636, 0.024294927716255188, -0.058489326387643814, 0.01204756274819374, -0.035220637917518616, -0.03879919275641441, -0.011588993482291698, -0.0009468371281400323, -0.01009219978004694, 0.03386939689517021, -0.00969797745347023, 0.05182052403688431, -0.04085015133023262, -0.019628729671239853, -0.030477670952677727, -0.002807521028444171, -0.03740726038813591, -0.0008189553045667708, 0.0292629674077034, -0.08712983131408691, 0.021489253267645836, -0.02519087865948677, 0.035048458725214005, -0.03244360163807869, 0.029282694682478905, 0.02043808624148369, -0.019122719764709473, -0.023884255439043045, 0.053924817591905594, 0.012766746804118156, 0.041988421231508255, -0.019283294677734375, 0.010395447723567486, -0.05582490935921669, 0.028713567182421684, -0.0201618243008852, 0.053765200078487396, -0.01742606796324253, 0.002569229807704687, 0.06590594351291656, 0.10503962635993958, 0.04015880450606346, -0.017014184966683388, -0.02195023186504841, -0.01741959899663925, -0.005515672266483307, 0.047945309430360794, 0.02797725237905979, 0.021676724776625633, 0.027059340849518776, 0.028082968667149544, -0.033413562923669815, -0.03955802693963051, -0.02038361132144928, -0.03851611912250519, 0.017901232466101646, -0.026388905942440033, 0.05641571059823036, -0.020795321092009544, -0.02892177179455757, -0.0071141705848276615, 0.03626372292637825, 0.032568324357271194, -0.031832125037908554, 0.0008218034054152668, -0.031195268034934998, -0.03132477030158043, 0.03575952351093292, -0.03450005501508713, -0.014481117017567158, 0.07274752855300903, -0.0069069769233465195, -0.01782308705151081, -0.029558898881077766, 0.06023193523287773, -0.006602788344025612, -0.004468689672648907, 0.05839446559548378, -0.05438148230314255, 0.040878310799598694, -0.05505941063165665, 0.031122712418437004, 0.023215100169181824, -0.010033657774329185, -0.04473300650715828, -0.013980009593069553, 0.0005453746998682618, 0.059164077043533325, 0.039100874215364456, -0.004497114568948746, 0.018040750175714493, -0.02345416136085987, -0.03982875868678093, 0.039063453674316406, 0.017468249425292015, -0.04963494464755058, -0.005504811182618141, -0.04480650648474693, 0.04478532448410988, 0.02062370441854, -0.013159988448023796, 0.01638825424015522, 0.02737342193722725, -0.0064310356974601746, 0.037415213882923126, -0.05603202432394028, -0.029673557728528976, 0.018707487732172012, -0.0420290008187294, 0.011194782331585884, -0.0460505373775959, -0.038412779569625854, -0.0284382626414299, -0.03299683332443237, -0.026634061709046364, 0.00772356241941452, -0.019145585596561432, -0.012126099318265915, 0.06509941816329956, 0.00009672233136370778, -0.039441175758838654, 0.024670839309692383, -0.00909749511629343, 0.015926627442240715, -0.02053758129477501, 0.04497866332530975, -0.04081827402114868, 0.017754001542925835, -0.07038228213787079, 0.05383161082863808, 0.03441982343792915, -0.016910776495933533, 0.05651599168777466, -0.014073891565203667, 0.028065789490938187, 0.021669883280992508, -0.034993015229701996, -0.01457471214234829, -0.06524727493524551, 0.04841654375195503, 0.014539213851094246, 0.005055748391896486, 0.00843723677098751, 0.05214846134185791, 0.02989771217107773, -0.07107115536928177, 0.013277657330036163, 0.04065603390336037, 0.017636898905038834, 0.04207601398229599, 0.022176070138812065, 0.040241409093141556, 0.008017953485250473, -0.01109718531370163, 0.04737778380513191, -0.024201884865760803, 0.06546047329902649, 0.0002550850622355938, -0.0013745902106165886, 0.02856431156396866, 0.02322228252887726, 0.03585885092616081, -0.018088771030306816, -0.08347517251968384, -0.04618864879012108, 0.04819178953766823, 0.0031263113487511873, -0.05883755162358284, 0.02246885374188423, 0.017727263271808624, -0.04187296703457832, 0.005685168318450451, 0.012582900002598763, -0.01766210049390793, 0.02231445536017418, 0.010391149669885635, -0.0009390320628881454, -0.009023378603160381, -0.03425443172454834, -0.004126960877329111, -0.03473398834466934, -0.039392195641994476, -0.003773806383833289, -0.06382817775011063, 0.02617296762764454, -0.05345049127936363, -0.03830334171652794, -0.021403435617685318, -0.04577986150979996, 0.05285055562853813, 0.015336866490542889, -0.03224104270339012, 0.04035448282957077, 0.031038060784339905, 0.05733276158571243, -0.024843033403158188, -0.023470453917980194, 0.004109720233827829, 0.0008327236864715815, -0.050829511135816574, -0.03904261440038681, 0.0030629283282905817, -0.003224763786420226, -0.015202068723738194, 0.06581976264715195, -0.03426060453057289, -0.01871594972908497, -0.025816908106207848, -0.05332811921834946, -0.03136298060417175, 0.008475434966385365, 0.02723543532192707, -0.02834286540746689, -0.024849779903888702, -0.039094794541597366, 0.03524589166045189, 0.05395002290606499, 0.014221261255443096, 0.03050645813345909, 0.004838998429477215, -0.016323380172252655, -0.017303092405200005, 0.004208833444863558, -0.022127635776996613, 0.020714614540338516, -0.08040875941514969, 0.004270937293767929, -0.04236910864710808, 0.047603290528059006, 0.04145584627985954, 0.04509939253330231, -0.004822999704629183, -0.058982379734516144, -0.04544205218553543, 0.046258509159088135, -0.05778017267584801, -0.04017821326851845, -0.0003293571644462645, 0.008527185767889023, -0.05634346976876259, 0.007826164364814758, -0.019431930035352707, -0.08039932698011398, -0.04711131379008293, -0.010561845265328884, -0.06924860179424286, -0.06660446524620056, -0.03238408640027046, 0.02595462277531624, 0.017255054786801338, -0.01391313225030899, -0.04153492674231529, 0.024254055693745613, -0.04472942650318146, 0.041149117052555084, -0.008182859048247337, 0.008619243279099464, -0.039828523993492126, 0.011973167769610882, -0.021695543080568314, -0.0095602348446846, -0.013930272310972214, 0.027833281084895134, -0.02975505404174328, 0.013190541416406631, -0.01677774265408516, 0.04869060218334198, 0.02947351150214672, -0.0268220454454422, -0.012844801880419254, -0.005598758347332478, -0.050605855882167816, -0.022781280800700188, 0.013303562998771667, -0.04638449102640152, -0.030883364379405975, -0.013164830394089222, -0.047386977821588516, -0.004937140736728907, 0.009066871367394924, 0.024686580523848534, 0.0083415936678648, -0.0021794030908495188, -0.023833079263567924, -0.020908670499920845, -0.021144261583685875, 0.05659044161438942 ]
<p>My professor said that the $k_BT$ displacement in the energy levels of the band electrons is due to the space-thermal displacement of the potential of the ion host. I think that this displacement is due to the thermal fluctuations of the electromagnetic field coupled to the electron charge.</p> <p>Who is right?</p>
g6646
[ 0.03460930287837982, 0.047548532485961914, -0.01796858198940754, 0.023692185059189796, 0.03999689221382141, 0.07774480432271957, -0.03389572352170944, 0.03472660109400749, 0.02133367955684662, 0.039587490260601044, 0.013766037300229073, 0.05345182865858078, 0.0017046671127900481, -0.0012800573604181409, 0.011388961225748062, -0.0375053845345974, 0.048954810947179794, 0.06318743526935577, -0.031127318739891052, 0.034684114158153534, -0.02919880487024784, 0.01953607238829136, -0.06735359132289886, -0.07810233533382416, 0.03168107941746712, 0.000775331340264529, -0.006333683617413044, 0.010306078009307384, 0.007708210032433271, -0.0625397339463234, 0.015432697720825672, 0.0245395228266716, 0.0004630371113307774, -0.043039336800575256, -0.07025863230228424, -0.037846874445676804, 0.0689743384718895, 0.014751560054719448, -0.0035997903905808926, 0.0064277793280780315, -0.030645929276943207, -0.02250969409942627, -0.007500307634472847, 0.02657463774085045, 0.010252850130200386, -0.015048382803797722, -0.013809570111334324, 0.01186484657227993, -0.047370586544275284, -0.02522866055369377, -0.03650818392634392, 0.02487367019057274, 0.02082614041864872, 0.03937897831201553, 0.06417680531740189, -0.01913321204483509, -0.035044845193624496, 0.01409171987324953, 0.06601965427398682, 0.030117789283394814, 0.12835350632667542, -0.00027368118753656745, -0.013076297007501125, 0.012701566331088543, 0.03803957998752594, -0.023893747478723526, -0.05432488024234772, 0.041061196476221085, -0.0006448783096857369, -0.05603881925344467, 0.02629167027771473, 0.026897557079792023, -0.039866406470537186, 0.04496817663311958, -0.044270433485507965, -0.03253331780433655, -0.03610892593860626, 0.004522262141108513, 0.0163617804646492, 0.00636918842792511, -0.06843217462301254, -0.0005063213175162673, 0.02138701267540455, 0.014740088023245335, 0.04754723981022835, -0.028340037912130356, 0.005054083652794361, 0.11513296514749527, 0.018793659284710884, 0.03065483085811138, 0.0035938743967562914, -0.03963306546211243, 0.05256149172782898, 0.014318271540105343, 0.014527054503560066, -0.019185218960046768, -0.027348043397068977, 0.07108692824840546, -0.006134359166026115, -0.039233725517988205, -0.025876980274915695, -0.016024595126509666, -0.030709730461239815, 0.03193247318267822, -0.060515936464071274, 0.009489928372204304, -0.03267798200249672, -0.03638899326324463, 0.08246278017759323, 0.008633092977106571, -0.03680470213294029, -0.05399869754910469, 0.009149250574409962, 0.004893959499895573, -0.017115026712417603, -0.014389581978321075, -0.027210796251893044, -0.05251672863960266, -0.021882226690649986, 0.05719629302620888, -0.038222536444664, -0.04677128791809082, -0.019431615248322487, 0.02881510555744171, 0.019399341195821762, -0.011215435341000557, -0.03002765215933323, -0.021512653678655624, 0.03482203930616379, 0.018267914652824402, -0.030474474653601646, 0.022714106366038322, -0.030886828899383545, 0.006036215461790562, 0.05622722953557968, -0.03116004355251789, 0.014843433164060116, 0.002039730316027999, -0.06162184849381447, -0.014749862253665924, 0.016892269253730774, -0.023856330662965775, 0.020889952778816223, -0.07063499838113785, -0.006458251737058163, -0.011620745062828064, -0.06741529703140259, -0.025848813354969025, 0.03561482951045036, 0.030396167188882828, 0.03879428282380104, 0.017001619562506676, 0.005695968866348267, -0.09324999898672104, 0.02711022086441517, -0.05811365693807602, 0.06858289986848831, 0.03978115692734718, -0.0026239128783345222, 0.044076915830373764, 0.0022626908030360937, 0.0029163570143282413, 0.013460504822432995, 0.007959598675370216, 0.05967746675014496, -0.028285397216677666, -0.03299392759799957, -0.007494649849832058, 0.005675560794770718, 0.022586019709706306, -0.020495830103754997, -0.001650986378081143, 0.0022389679215848446, 0.02160254865884781, -0.06321392208337784, 0.09161154925823212, 0.007803629618138075, -0.03828783705830574, 0.057040128856897354, -0.0385131761431694, -0.01537037268280983, 0.014409205876290798, 0.05099198594689369, -0.04457069933414459, 0.05017529055476189, -0.024675220251083374, -0.06539325416088104, 0.04607657343149185, -0.016383809968829155, -0.05288517847657204, 0.02613462507724762, -0.036353498697280884, 0.026261407881975174, -0.030309977009892464, 0.012015330605208874, -0.005140268709510565, 0.03802276775240898, 0.005120570305734873, -0.014008392579853535, -0.005600152537226677, -0.001738077844493091, -0.013781430199742317, 0.019153229892253876, -0.03821322321891785, 0.07674244046211243, 0.005228622350841761, -0.06064101308584213, 0.00462711276486516, -0.0033092277590185404, -0.04723108187317848, -0.015513637103140354, -0.027133021503686905, -0.08138324320316315, 0.05216922238469124, 0.015176059678196907, -0.005338956601917744, -0.023763395845890045, -0.02255171537399292, 0.02760266698896885, 0.001123751513659954, -0.03911709040403366, -0.0041892207227647305, 0.0031671866308897734, 0.050156064331531525, -0.015025852248072624, -0.016032177954912186, -0.0009512268588878214, -0.044284798204898834, -0.07775495946407318, -0.02559652179479599, -0.06725482642650604, 0.05307833105325699, -0.01721886731684208, 0.009704502299427986, 0.06931191682815552, 0.09862516820430756, -0.0046795569360256195, -0.0007142131216824055, 0.0030204476788640022, -0.051434457302093506, -0.026164984330534935, -0.011782663874328136, -0.024851810187101364, 0.0059520769864320755, 0.016173765063285828, 0.030863218009471893, 0.016661599278450012, -0.02987688221037388, -0.05862674489617348, -0.055093877017498016, 0.044850170612335205, -0.05474163591861725, 0.024320287629961967, -0.024903446435928345, -0.0083766533061862, -0.00811618659645319, -0.00756290927529335, 0.0375283882021904, -0.0025750796776264906, -0.035273972898721695, 0.02099255658686161, -0.018974797800183296, 0.012104709632694721, -0.02234835736453533, -0.03113715723156929, -0.04869072511792183, 0.005327119491994381, -0.06070958450436592, 0.021018335595726967, -0.03513789176940918, 0.060097385197877884, 0.09756956249475479, -0.004438301548361778, 0.03927411884069443, 0.04263913631439209, -0.032391589134931564, 0.041448574513196945, -0.003337305970489979, 0.0062842159532010555, -0.062401965260505676, -0.05447668954730034, 0.033889494836330414, 0.00044595569488592446, -0.03985995054244995, -0.019563188776373863, 0.020289916545152664, -0.035534415394067764, 0.011483260430395603, -0.012785953469574451, 0.00781413447111845, -0.0027061232831329107, -0.04155273735523224, 0.03872820362448692, 0.017611438408493996, -0.052350208163261414, 0.03424913436174393, 0.06131976470351219, -0.07222039252519608, -0.044074781239032745, 0.06144101545214653, 0.02991194650530815, 0.015052549540996552, -0.02230137214064598, -0.001507361652329564, 0.01421307772397995, 0.019856994971632957, 0.010590873658657074, -0.019581953063607216, 0.02769588492810726, -0.023509105667471886, -0.008339671418070793, -0.016873536631464958, 0.015610210597515106, 0.02725042961537838, -0.027807652950286865, -0.01059703528881073, -0.07666803151369095, -0.008050207048654556, 0.08102953433990479, 0.019142091274261475, -0.017550133168697357, -0.021293768659234047, -0.015541971661150455, 0.0016248931642621756, 0.03596174716949463, -0.01921631023287773, 0.002158544957637787, -0.027702588587999344, -0.007171804551035166, 0.006073388736695051, -0.043445687741041183, -0.030261510983109474, 0.0014390544965863228, -0.02529050037264824, 0.011377234943211079, 0.015258101746439934, 0.0336117148399353, 0.050691891461610794, -0.033707212656736374, 0.02617291733622551, -0.02978881448507309, 0.007049274630844593, -0.038248300552368164, -0.029107926413416862, -0.008681501261889935, 0.023254437372088432, -0.019955193623900414, -0.06368767470121384, -0.03937498852610588, -0.005429940298199654, 0.02059348300099373, 0.02188509702682495, 0.011965828016400337, 0.004730653949081898, -0.059375517070293427, 0.019076770171523094, 0.019828835502266884, 0.0066789546981453896, -0.02964729815721512, -0.019468843936920166, 0.039985038340091705, -0.02038523741066456, 0.06794333457946777, -0.008056835271418095, -0.05585760623216629, 0.01582976058125496, 0.0019884409848600626, 0.06883123517036438, 0.018598316237330437, -0.034553367644548416, -0.07293552160263062, -0.05577455088496208, -0.033814139664173126, 0.0013509117998182774, 0.0663001537322998, -0.0295051671564579, 0.008916264399886131, 0.020230459049344063, -0.0030653986614197493, 0.01279172208160162, -0.002333048963919282, -0.026265041902661324, 0.03124990500509739, 0.02329016663134098, 0.051999643445014954, 0.0036709727719426155, -0.03788355365395546, 0.054051823914051056, -0.02080918289721012, -0.0517348051071167, -0.019535215571522713, 0.013108571991324425, 0.011838112026453018, -0.029025152325630188, 0.05498230829834938, -0.040109895169734955, 0.018023360520601273, -0.011206626892089844, 0.06219162791967392, 0.06220325827598572, 0.07247669249773026, -0.00969199649989605, -0.002748957835137844, -0.032612767070531845, -0.020916201174259186, 0.038345564156770706, 0.07985375821590424, -0.07418622821569443, -0.06331761926412582, -0.019507750868797302, -0.06051773577928543, 0.02617683634161949, 0.013137749396264553, -0.01959231309592724, -0.006464075762778521, -0.02119622752070427, -0.0026430313009768724, 0.05650939792394638, 0.0587259866297245, -0.009196655824780464, 0.006710915360599756, 0.01943144015967846, 0.01440845150500536, -0.00374624109826982, 0.03127438202500343, 0.06307879090309143, 0.028641054406762123, 0.0021953475661575794, 0.005080417264252901, 0.0052850800566375256, -0.02273689955472946, 0.016162453219294548, -0.009412380866706371, 0.0006007853080518544, -0.03510640934109688, 0.04106476157903671, 0.0025502177886664867, 0.02383374609053135, -0.02363557554781437, 0.06712771952152252, 0.054520122706890106, -0.032732971012592316, -0.011568657122552395, 0.010824568569660187, 0.005954512394964695, 0.022580072283744812, 0.020682353526353836, -0.0138260992243886, -0.02532484196126461, 0.007960687391459942, 0.019140096381306648, 0.020474817603826523, 0.004905482288450003, 0.028643865138292313, 0.05917060747742653, -0.03472605720162392, -0.031738825142383575, -0.007541889790445566, 0.02700759470462799, 0.016260264441370964, -0.018944386392831802, 0.02917107380926609, -0.020552702248096466, 0.03336592763662338, 0.04159305617213249, -0.009983118623495102, 0.02293882519006729, 0.01704045757651329, -0.04040051996707916, -0.023956317454576492, 0.047230903059244156, 0.016168680042028427, 0.01816873997449875, 0.01153455302119255, 0.08237109333276749, 0.02767837792634964, -0.01960301585495472, -0.012823468074202538, -0.030978895723819733, -0.05389378219842911, -0.02431502752006054, 0.007433013524860144, 0.028511526063084602, 0.02926289476454258, -0.06251653283834457, 0.01599576510488987, 0.01917039230465889, 0.02697387896478176, 0.009836188517510891, -0.029802056029438972, 0.061639826744794846, -0.00519126933068037, 0.00018307010759599507, -0.0003376675595063716, 0.0007467591785825789, 0.04864494130015373, 0.025258824229240417, 0.09129256755113602, 0.047403912991285324, 0.03787703812122345, 0.007026121485978365, -0.00353047763928771, 0.038034114986658096, 0.0014289451064541936, -0.008076532743871212, 0.00631379010155797, -0.032973989844322205, -0.021502867341041565, 0.003366178600117564, -0.02520127408206463, -0.027048330754041672, 0.07231318950653076, 0.034979067742824554, 0.010893560014665127, 0.032749470323324203, -0.048716604709625244, -0.030671512708067894, -0.021985944360494614, -0.04592634737491608, -0.03156738728284836, -0.00465557212010026, 0.007193485740572214, 0.03834811598062515, -0.01935669407248497, 0.0380275659263134, 0.06631465256214142, -0.006404994986951351, -0.014006432145833969, -0.01268637366592884, 0.00824923999607563, 0.005509025417268276, 0.039991021156311035, 0.02615775726735592, 0.030488381162285805, -0.026082457974553108, -0.016422834247350693, 0.05303814634680748, 0.020898018032312393, 0.00868554413318634, 0.018069561570882797, 0.04382321238517761, 0.03562904894351959, 0.007371301297098398, 0.03364647924900055, -0.00637924624606967, 0.0026370242703706026, -0.0435749813914299, 0.02511700429022312, 0.061318665742874146, -0.08533487468957901, -0.009212149307131767, 0.07313080877065659, -0.012643503956496716, -0.03190992400050163, 0.046127744019031525, -0.052558787167072296, 0.02019830048084259, -0.02546524815261364, -0.05086119845509529, -0.038640234619379044, 0.0037721614353358746, 0.07413173466920853, 0.03974973037838936, 0.016577549278736115, 0.06223538890480995, -0.022988779470324516, -0.01399378664791584, 0.011563453823328018, 0.06813229620456696, 0.010331668891012669, -0.04561908543109894, -0.024360505864024162, -0.023109659552574158, -0.04099331051111221, 0.007774297147989273, 0.04146431013941765, -0.0024272555019706488, -0.0032526555005460978, -0.062262337654829025, -0.04561515897512436, 0.003112140344455838, 0.005478855688124895, -0.040248364210128784, 0.0006691617309115827, -0.07952015101909637, 0.0014964727452024817, -0.008558188565075397, 0.015562540851533413, 0.12783828377723694, 0.0010167992440983653, -0.020815853029489517, -0.012846243567764759, 0.020366616547107697, 0.020640281960368156, -0.07329102605581284, -0.016333425417542458, -0.028490394353866577, -0.010122151114046574, -0.03170815855264664, 0.02536674402654171, 0.01192964892834425, -0.030665120109915733, -0.028955334797501564, -0.024734407663345337, 0.015681924298405647, -0.05846570432186127, -0.01997389830648899, 0.029946310445666313, -0.04944441840052605, 0.052839722484350204, -0.008192424662411213, -0.001687506097368896, 0.052609242498874664, -0.04593354091048241, -0.00765186594799161, -0.0049271476455032825, -0.01890779472887516, 0.06235095113515854, -0.05452603101730347, -0.0013353853719308972, 0.0006341035477817059, 0.018612803891301155, -0.05333983525633812, 0.0019038388272747397, 0.002522937720641494, 0.017817460000514984, 0.009492242708802223, 0.0062307086773216724, -0.012816289439797401, -0.05722356587648392, -0.0038818230386823416, 0.03965688869357109, -0.0000012329539913480403, -0.0011253093834966421, -0.006539076566696167, 0.007687485311180353, -0.007695392239838839, 0.01785784587264061, -0.03554791957139969, -0.016530334949493408, -0.02539924532175064, -0.03095374070107937, 0.06553617119789124, 0.01831338368356228, 0.022014470770955086, -0.013522293418645859, -0.018292849883437157, 0.0408112071454525, -0.04074360802769661, -0.038830723613500595, 0.007426835596561432, -0.03565611690282822, -0.0428837351500988, 0.005611916072666645, 0.03339622542262077, 0.0033018786925822496, 0.0028650867752730846, 0.009076130576431751, 0.059162240475416183, -0.03446376323699951, -0.07617288827896118, -0.06700148433446884, 0.004414185415953398, 0.024968372657895088, 0.03907542675733566, 0.054401565343141556, 0.017885230481624603, -0.03759991377592087, -0.015149232931435108, -0.034939173609018326, 0.0014270574320107698, -0.03541399911046028, 0.05854225158691406, 0.035922564566135406, -0.07603936642408371, 0.003419933607801795, -0.045411672443151474, 0.02924981899559498, -0.06298667937517166, -0.0024189024697989225, -0.03622573986649513, -0.0017337746685370803, 0.07610733062028885, -0.02939159795641899, -0.014543630182743073, -0.01511085219681263, -0.0423135980963707, 0.011141203343868256, 0.019288986921310425, 0.0067709521390497684, 0.0022574784234166145, 0.005881755147129297, -0.02555616945028305, 0.01856793835759163, 0.034429725259542465, 0.025415407493710518, -0.007174644153565168, -0.01552498247474432, 0.04533250257372856, 0.033545587211847305, 0.0028184056282043457, 0.01162804290652275, 0.0072598643600940704, -0.00008274303399957716, 0.0599667988717556, 0.007807470392435789, 0.03648647665977478, 0.015005247667431831, -0.052166957408189774, -0.05631861835718155, 0.05969904363155365, -0.03285617008805275, -0.01421412080526352, 0.026032404974102974, 0.06120571866631508, -0.031087974086403847, 0.005984306335449219, 0.0019019665196537971, -0.056561343371868134, -0.0235836710780859, 0.05226876214146614, -0.003613716224208474, 0.03682003170251846, -0.047303706407547, 0.0392644926905632, -0.052873607724905014, 0.021896645426750183, -0.03439214453101158, 0.029156621545553207, -0.004957652650773525, -0.034676581621170044, -0.004092361778020859, -0.058411795645952225, -0.08872569352388382, 0.0047865561209619045, 0.02295106276869774, -0.02498195692896843, 0.03578637167811394, 0.0570729523897171, -0.010220769792795181, -0.024299975484609604, -0.011513818055391312, 0.029160311445593834, 0.009174766018986702, -0.0793825089931488, -0.0005373951280489564, -0.06689851731061935, -0.05217713862657547, 0.07938551157712936, -0.00439412472769618, 0.01301709283143282, -0.05631306767463684, -0.08379704505205154, 0.03782051056623459, 0.021207449957728386, -0.028404798358678818, 0.005319562740623951, 0.013915247283875942, -0.006584205664694309, 0.04906393587589264, -0.025228939950466156, -0.03679696470499039, -0.016408000141382217, -0.005260862410068512, 0.02367708645761013, -0.010688061825931072, -0.008720108307898045, 0.01723296009004116 ]
<p>Is there any phenomenon where the 'wave description' of the electron's motion is not applicable?</p> <p>The reason for this question is to find out if there are any situations were quantum wave theories fail. If not, it seems that the Everett's multiworld analysis as described by Coleman, <a href="http://media.physics.harvard.edu/video/index.php?id=SidneyColeman_QMIYF.flv" rel="nofollow">http://media.physics.harvard.edu/video/index.php?id=SidneyColeman_QMIYF.flv</a> works.</p>
g6647
[ -0.0013621350517496467, 0.07000938802957535, 0.015017482452094555, -0.013214039616286755, 0.04966193065047264, 0.015259429812431335, -0.0015748055884614587, -0.009824639186263084, 0.018493788316845894, -0.04884197935461998, 0.02493792213499546, -0.023272398859262466, 0.01738852821290493, 0.04036519676446915, -0.06640604883432388, -0.06057244539260864, 0.044967494904994965, 0.008780800737440586, 0.044503990560770035, 0.03008451499044895, -0.024746593087911606, 0.0007296839030459523, 0.00032009329879656434, 0.026396483182907104, -0.00913142692297697, 0.0029808832332491875, -0.042813755571842194, -0.05626661702990532, 0.028176242485642433, -0.049088772386312485, 0.04707092046737671, 0.012492635287344456, 0.05527344346046448, -0.07726645469665527, -0.03408658877015114, 0.02166634239256382, 0.013694923371076584, 0.0354788713157177, -0.025789985433220863, 0.015551924705505371, -0.044109612703323364, 0.0011129964841529727, -0.029496662318706512, 0.01723405160009861, 0.021655773743987083, -0.01766136847436428, 0.04427702724933624, 0.0154911819845438, -0.04223114252090454, -0.005488433875143528, -0.01627531461417675, 0.044435951858758926, 0.04980489984154701, 0.010105771943926811, 0.06922467797994614, 0.03569777309894562, -0.003182807704433799, 0.04676533490419388, 0.08708616346120834, 0.005360639188438654, 0.01241656020283699, 0.020316408947110176, 0.024641267955303192, 0.02343756891787052, 0.04514094069600105, -0.00863596610724926, -0.04858306422829628, -0.013094492256641388, -0.008626675233244896, -0.025904737412929535, 0.04551054909825325, -0.09186400473117828, -0.07341589033603668, -0.006997805554419756, 0.026540113613009453, 0.07255496084690094, -0.036177199333906174, 0.0004506851837504655, 0.004251823760569096, 0.006682919338345528, -0.04640228673815727, -0.02185666374862194, 0.02373826690018177, 0.025347312912344933, 0.06446725875139236, -0.04943455010652542, 0.012081761844456196, 0.018070051446557045, 0.004279685206711292, -0.008529270067811012, 0.01148125808686018, 0.005213269963860512, 0.06577228009700775, 0.035351116210222244, -0.015468730591237545, -0.06970727443695068, -0.05154472589492798, 0.053379762917757034, -0.029707230627536774, 0.03898127004504204, -0.0743110403418541, 0.008718159049749374, -0.008050740696489811, 0.005245953798294067, 0.04158202186226845, -0.01363291684538126, -0.02254394069314003, -0.026605509221553802, 0.03768592327833176, 0.012874096632003784, -0.051732663065195084, -0.03939851000905037, -0.004473347682505846, -0.014490695670247078, -0.037620510905981064, -0.03141315281391144, 0.0444820299744606, -0.044871892780065536, -0.001967886695638299, 0.04829976335167885, 0.0019257866078987718, 0.0040015773847699165, 0.011360954493284225, 0.05916942283511162, -0.027120845392346382, 0.01589670404791832, -0.025342755019664764, -0.02482105791568756, 0.037816811352968216, 0.03256549313664436, 0.06489987671375275, 0.05070199817419052, 0.023389747366309166, 0.07492849230766296, 0.005533550400286913, 0.020581522956490517, 0.02104341611266136, 0.04267806559801102, -0.012208711355924606, 0.019321097061038017, 0.02649417705833912, -0.06469271332025528, -0.007708462420850992, -0.05340429022908211, -0.027149232104420662, -0.03852051869034767, 0.0002600049483589828, 0.006648136302828789, 0.03226562216877937, 0.026214612647891045, -0.01843060366809368, 0.04015115648508072, 0.018892617896199226, 0.03756916895508766, 0.023702984675765038, 0.001762037049047649, 0.07690735906362534, 0.039426788687705994, -0.02012604847550392, -0.01440003514289856, 0.01829744689166546, -0.0189859289675951, 0.01106201484799385, 0.042978737503290176, -0.004601727705448866, -0.027736978605389595, 0.037385664880275726, -0.0012115244753658772, 0.00899248756468296, -0.025560712441802025, -0.04082225635647774, -0.027786988765001297, 0.014905395917594433, 0.059625983238220215, 0.020411154255270958, 0.08447287976741791, -0.01428980939090252, -0.05512324348092079, -0.025735601782798767, -0.01020266953855753, -0.01637415960431099, 0.04008518159389496, -0.041158173233270645, -0.04450985789299011, 0.04382960870862007, -0.011299444362521172, 0.00683435145765543, 0.029018959030508995, -0.0213945209980011, -0.04373162239789963, -0.0245938953012228, -0.04716760665178299, 0.009426716715097427, 0.009228760376572609, -0.014366667717695236, -0.019323725253343582, 0.0003428374184295535, 0.0047318171709775925, -0.03803631290793419, -0.031023165211081505, 0.042274829000234604, 0.08181273192167282, 0.014989826828241348, -0.02418479137122631, 0.01735072210431099, -0.02949557639658451, -0.018165530636906624, -0.0020047293510288, 0.04315716773271561, -0.007921111769974232, 0.028842473402619362, 0.012579691596329212, -0.02193387784063816, 0.0590193048119545, -0.0658593699336052, -0.046331167221069336, -0.012084153480827808, 0.025985704734921455, -0.004953691270202398, -0.0056433710269629955, -0.06717287003993988, -0.0073949433863162994, 0.00024984730407595634, 0.003547836095094681, 0.018290704116225243, 0.013157902285456657, -0.0509883277118206, -0.05417074263095856, -0.03601595759391785, 0.01828160136938095, -0.0682612732052803, 0.01157111395150423, 0.0038303083274513483, -0.05292419344186783, 0.04600299894809723, 0.03486189618706703, -0.03956133872270584, -0.06590832769870758, 0.04787002131342888, 0.011614929884672165, 0.01688925363123417, -0.007013093680143356, -0.0892418697476387, -0.04569915309548378, 0.027776477858424187, -0.021489333361387253, 0.011843012645840645, 0.03210316598415375, 0.009422854520380497, 0.013485579751431942, -0.0009680688381195068, -0.030397342517971992, -0.06660091131925583, 0.007688258774578571, 0.038469430059194565, -0.008785140700638294, 0.013318556360900402, 0.0377187542617321, -0.053785666823387146, 0.022337771952152252, 0.008529509417712688, -0.03298204019665718, 0.019145911559462547, -0.013026649132370949, 0.0008231918909586966, -0.05128883942961693, 0.05251692235469818, 0.05938331037759781, -0.051021162420511246, -0.0423738956451416, -0.07582978159189224, 0.06453555077314377, -0.020739350467920303, 0.004197648726403713, -0.020819418132305145, 0.010998012498021126, -0.027247078716754913, 0.008761615492403507, 0.01737871766090393, -0.04450727254152298, -0.0636528804898262, -0.008311321027576923, -0.004641886800527573, 0.007307419553399086, 0.046978987753391266, -0.08166658878326416, -0.0032731813844293356, -0.0035451462026685476, 0.025051360949873924, 0.04481874406337738, -0.02105058915913105, -0.0048535605892539024, 0.026011601090431213, 0.0711006447672844, -0.07507525384426117, 0.056467462331056595, -0.006611973512917757, -0.01999269612133503, 0.0040517766028642654, 0.007182684261351824, -0.030121302232146263, -0.019215622916817665, -0.10480815917253494, 0.03601706400513649, 0.0697813332080841, 0.04875244200229645, -0.001948743243701756, -0.0283761415630579, -0.024248570203781128, -0.07525112479925156, 0.007024653255939484, 0.0825958177447319, -0.06678859889507294, -0.02595784328877926, -0.010943040251731873, 0.029267648234963417, 0.002605560002848506, 0.055567435920238495, 0.06623080372810364, 0.0014845422701910138, -0.06836842745542526, -0.023209132254123688, 0.03913704305887222, 0.013103092089295387, 0.05133461579680443, 0.07877534627914429, -0.008313283324241638, -0.0008214960689656436, -0.05236624553799629, 0.0001483952219132334, -0.01573600433766842, -0.05336512625217438, -0.0015239116037264466, -0.012718379497528076, 0.014035441912710667, -0.03529058024287224, 0.01540267001837492, 0.025437988340854645, 0.019934508949518204, 0.02088947966694832, -0.041206568479537964, -0.03677470609545708, -0.04453490674495697, 0.011185575276613235, -0.00505985738709569, 0.007432349491864443, -0.06695453822612762, 0.03782059997320175, 0.00821763463318348, -0.030366022139787674, 0.018734050914645195, 0.029080169275403023, -0.03131258860230446, 0.026814641430974007, -0.05624052882194519, 0.012846040539443493, 0.06069802865386009, 0.018564684316515923, 0.017667869105935097, 0.0023860358633100986, -0.04327226057648659, 0.024726906791329384, -0.003552098758518696, -0.043902527540922165, 0.0053265755996108055, 0.01443681214004755, -0.013576002791523933, 0.025745896622538567, 0.05517176166176796, -0.045422013849020004, -0.00809895247220993, -0.0076503269374370575, 0.028255002573132515, 0.02830343134701252, 0.03519440069794655, -0.048885952681303024, -0.023825395852327347, 0.0029849293641746044, -0.08580655604600906, 0.050617847591638565, 0.05254814401268959, 0.025318969041109085, 0.026061950251460075, 0.020087646320462227, 0.0020920992828905582, -0.012638612650334835, -0.06419062614440918, -0.0016477034660056233, -0.0622868575155735, 0.03626440465450287, -0.036485858261585236, -0.0020171068608760834, 0.004557735286653042, 0.03208605572581291, 0.025445111095905304, -0.03606528043746948, 0.04110177606344223, -0.09673523157835007, 0.004101267550140619, 0.040395013988018036, 0.021353675052523613, -0.022625457495450974, 0.01409773901104927, 0.009850895032286644, -0.012101965956389904, 0.04880295321345329, 0.047504618763923645, 0.003946335054934025, -0.016535473987460136, -0.04368302598595619, -0.03245019540190697, 0.0020950285252183676, -0.00029870233265683055, -0.04459727928042412, -0.010350191034376621, 0.01658375933766365, 0.02140365168452263, -0.013822990469634533, -0.02063499018549919, 0.050870466977357864, 0.025511108338832855, 0.09270618855953217, 0.011736253276467323, 0.0006113110575824976, -0.004083031322807074, 0.04369071498513222, -0.0006766283186152577, 0.020088545978069305, -0.014852814376354218, -0.034263186156749725, -0.0420982725918293, 0.0007514093886129558, -0.009999526664614677, 0.05036822333931923, -0.007708718068897724, 0.03570430725812912, -0.013781964778900146, 0.05624852329492569, 0.05068529397249222, -0.01884549856185913, 0.04493749514222145, 0.012397886253893375, 0.027021080255508423, 0.05164242908358574, -0.02690262719988823, 0.05769345536828041, -0.008884322829544544, -0.01889467053115368, -0.05543477088212967, -0.042582571506500244, -0.029994294047355652, -0.0009804156143218279, -0.06917886435985565, 0.03226910158991814, -0.006048185750842094, -0.01905536837875843, -0.01678970828652382, 0.0044984412379562855, -0.01625174470245838, 0.04331699758768082, -0.07797148078680038, -0.004620987921953201, 0.004765767138451338, 0.06777486950159073, 0.011739867739379406, -0.043110303580760956, -0.02511095441877842, 0.014624375849962234, -0.09836134314537048, -0.04035963490605354, 0.05360987037420273, 0.004812272265553474, 0.038704901933670044, 0.016422994434833527, 0.039303719997406006, -0.03407217934727669, -0.018831850960850716, 0.019502103328704834, -0.0482562817633152, -0.04881095513701439, 0.02227560430765152, -0.0690062940120697, 0.02573814056813717, 0.031918153166770935, -0.028418783098459244, -0.0017003050306811929, 0.022062942385673523, 0.06964170187711716, -0.023967385292053223, -0.008707020431756973, 0.044620219618082047, 0.0240367092192173, -0.01818910799920559, -0.07308637350797653, -0.02792356349527836, -0.005278596188873053, 0.05134952813386917, 0.025297068059444427, -0.019301360473036766, 0.025378184393048286, -0.05606121942400932, 0.009566917084157467, -0.015341520309448242, -0.04273655265569687, 0.012851525098085403, -0.008134735748171806, 0.06992929428815842, -0.027560792863368988, -0.027493838220834732, -0.017323462292551994, 0.02129887044429779, 0.00012128321395721287, -0.04008721187710762, -0.01580309495329857, 0.05393628031015396, -0.040200624614953995, -0.019460143521428108, -0.035213734954595566, 0.000004864543825533474, -0.03362007439136505, 0.033820923417806625, 0.011820985935628414, 0.00782421138137579, -0.03239954262971878, 0.037853118032217026, -0.006411231122910976, -0.057581011205911636, -0.025080587714910507, 0.01960703171789646, 0.06074553728103638, 0.05821697786450386, -0.01235116831958294, 0.05420771241188049, 0.04595578834414482, 0.023737598210573196, -0.036690112203359604, 0.03536740690469742, 0.0407181940972805, 0.012101331725716591, 0.014653678052127361, -0.021899567916989326, -0.007604105398058891, 0.0053381165489554405, 0.0491664744913578, 0.03665461018681526, 0.016899473965168, -0.03276988863945007, 0.032706573605537415, 0.04693489894270897, -0.01426965557038784, -0.03014177270233631, 0.024818038567900658, -0.055953823029994965, -0.025751303881406784, 0.0031778716947883368, 0.04850776121020317, -0.03440186753869057, -0.06062914803624153, -0.04353945329785347, -0.007753915153443813, 0.002272329991683364, 0.03442462533712387, 0.06625854969024658, 0.055762115865945816, 0.022087672725319862, 0.030401060357689857, -0.025269076228141785, 0.003165997564792633, 0.02706257253885269, 0.04207702726125717, -0.039500802755355835, 0.009389450773596764, 0.019090911373496056, 0.0019492305582389235, 0.014601231552660465, -0.05356207117438316, 0.059737883508205414, -0.038018714636564255, -0.06626366078853607, -0.0425979346036911, 0.0234806127846241, -0.004251433070749044, -0.026454197242856026, -0.013560998253524303, -0.0490713007748127, 0.03254944086074829, -0.05273659527301788, -0.005459349136799574, 0.04045800864696503, 0.029920728877186775, -0.06738957017660141, 0.044999442994594574, -0.003975720144808292, 0.001413852209225297, 0.0014210803201422095, -0.034304168075323105, -0.008799443021416664, -0.025975756347179413, -0.057728298008441925, 0.020443232730031013, 0.04214058071374893, -0.01195781771093607, -0.0012380055850371718, 0.05971033126115799, 0.05313916876912117, 0.08036191016435623, -0.010716882534325123, 0.023937471210956573, -0.04454779252409935, -0.019809536635875702, -0.0565624013543129, 0.052533455193042755, 0.06049513444304466, -0.019263649359345436, -0.036255497485399246, -0.06946209818124771, -0.007910673506557941, 0.006934745702892542, -0.04217333346605301, 0.023018117994070053, 0.034350402653217316, -0.05600305274128914, -0.016964003443717957, 0.03156307712197304, 0.002898275852203369, 0.0626974031329155, -0.051417455077171326, -0.031189413741230965, 0.05554933473467827, -0.035220447927713394, 0.03717447817325592, 0.009421469643712044, 0.01306093204766512, 0.043741267174482346, -0.015479647554457188, 0.07524172961711884, -0.028238413855433464, -0.0046809762716293335, 0.014389397576451302, 0.006824050564318895, -0.05450055003166199, 0.023809058591723442, 0.024949809536337852, -0.033705174922943115, -0.0608009435236454, 0.040921151638031006, 0.014437874779105186, 0.006346666254103184, -0.07703562825918198, -0.042768463492393494, 0.02910836599767208, 0.00047790436656214297, -0.02198145166039467, 0.004082647152245045, -0.009393740445375443, -0.024744991213083267, -0.013248834758996964, -0.015240282751619816, -0.01463159266859293, -0.022907616570591927, -0.015858659520745277, -0.024549538269639015, 0.016587091609835625, 0.014082260429859161, -0.012330309487879276, 0.01405903697013855, -0.05225837230682373, -0.06568673253059387, -0.008027665317058563, -0.02275742031633854, 0.037135180085897446, -0.011685251258313656, -0.02322130836546421, 0.011078685522079468, -0.0005208863294683397, -0.04588567465543747, -0.03699810057878494, 0.034412141889333725, -0.025960519909858704, 0.0015070806257426739, -0.014024892821907997, 0.028237612918019295, 0.029779132455587387, 0.024688031524419785, 0.0065991682931780815, -0.005583116784691811, -0.004330586176365614, -0.008636126294732094, -0.029057057574391365, -0.00989220105111599, 0.021521177142858505, -0.031162137165665627, 0.032120492309331894, -0.04927840456366539, 0.018201619386672974, 0.0414937287569046, -0.05210643261671066, 0.037678062915802, 0.01630202867090702, 0.01536223292350769, -0.0009229753632098436, 0.017976216971874237, -0.0045513431541621685, 0.0027577958535403013, 0.03409680724143982, -0.03738939017057419, 0.010983317159116268, -0.05102169141173363, -0.029830463230609894, 0.04364897310733795, 0.014774629846215248, 0.04449208453297615, 0.014999217353761196, -0.010687166824936867, 0.053584519773721695, -0.02412973903119564, 0.01479587983340025, 0.07727771252393723, 0.0318426676094532, 0.010045060887932777, -0.003608312690630555, 0.027997398748993874, -0.03784298524260521, -0.0024967670906335115, 0.008579361252486706, -0.01749097742140293, 0.025211051106452942, 0.002320587867870927, -0.0003891638189088553, -0.03311256319284439, -0.038879092782735825, 0.010647540912032127, -0.03082893043756485, -0.004321170970797539, -0.09687667340040207, 0.010794722475111485, -0.0164787657558918, -0.026188068091869354, 0.036685679107904434, 0.009644033387303352, 0.01537309866398573, 0.03355785086750984, 0.007180203218013048, -0.05100046843290329, -0.07712263613939285, -0.024850979447364807, 0.006228949408978224, -0.03188588097691536, 0.00995649490505457, -0.022448450326919556, -0.03543122857809067, 0.03629226237535477, -0.03887753561139107, 0.017145894467830658, 0.032903384417295456, 0.028056252747774124, 0.0015785150462761521, 0.006616910453885794, 0.10164371132850647, 0.019413545727729797, 0.0018538812873885036, -0.03338427469134331, 0.0316329300403595, -0.02680218406021595, -0.008160294964909554, -0.0800933837890625, -0.02723892591893673, -0.014123520813882351 ]
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/orT7X.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>In the left side example of cantilever brakes, how do I find the tension in strings DE and DC, in terms of T. According to me applying force balance equations, horizontal and vertical forces should be zero</p> <p>i.e. $T_{DE} \cos(45) + T_{DE} \cos(45) = T$...</p> <p>The answer given is $T/2$, which is against general understanding.</p> <p><strong>SOURCE:- Mechanics of Materials by JM Gere Ed2009- Problem 1.2.3</strong></p>
g6648
[ 0.04999784007668495, 0.004906171932816505, -0.01799197308719158, 0.014704706147313118, 0.07315494865179062, 0.03439902141690254, 0.05836116150021553, 0.0161586944013834, -0.04169495776295662, -0.028209730982780457, -0.07054080069065094, -0.036448393017053604, -0.03536612167954445, -0.008314262144267559, 0.08544694632291794, 0.06603771448135376, 0.008938221260905266, -0.02544245310127735, 0.03160812705755234, -0.004777961410582066, -0.01099968608468771, -0.009666850790381432, -0.026722939684987068, -0.047522448003292084, 0.061948541551828384, 0.03216458484530449, -0.04346851631999016, 0.004864024464040995, -0.03892233595252037, 0.0014197751879692078, -0.002199504990130663, 0.029145853593945503, 0.025599950924515724, -0.06331898272037506, -0.05778880417346954, -0.031250450760126114, 0.03319086879491806, 0.009540234692394733, -0.011224744841456413, -0.0009596096351742744, 0.012841925956308842, -0.01398816704750061, 0.03177434578537941, -0.02872365713119507, -0.021280862390995026, -0.07218897342681885, -0.06938895583152771, 0.013282451778650284, -0.03972756862640381, 0.0015415328089147806, 0.007749233394861221, -0.011558793485164642, 0.04689273238182068, -0.02488567866384983, -0.017482709139585495, 0.024988502264022827, 0.07748167961835861, -0.05510082095861435, -0.011329399421811104, 0.00562133127823472, -0.04998476058244705, 0.026523498818278313, 0.006493566557765007, 0.001796087482944131, -0.0159181896597147, -0.020315513014793396, 0.002195394830778241, 0.017840778455138206, 0.0753885805606842, 0.021213917061686516, -0.030200103297829628, -0.0040571726858615875, -0.006911570206284523, -0.05109798163175583, -0.06723172217607498, -0.030124759301543236, 0.019037824124097824, 0.0328846350312233, -0.0174910519272089, -0.02371012233197689, 0.003554112045094371, 0.05398225411772728, -0.0016166639979928732, 0.00883957464247942, 0.03744510933756828, -0.0004871421551797539, 0.009353317320346832, 0.031343523412942886, -0.0041782609187066555, 0.05787516385316849, 0.01477271318435669, 0.008148805238306522, 0.03966160863637924, 0.010530417785048485, 0.020034529268741608, -0.042554840445518494, 0.004391990602016449, 0.09025745093822479, 0.008359269239008427, -0.06678604334592819, -0.019949933513998985, -0.002763067139312625, -0.032697804272174835, -0.030979836359620094, -0.0059695676900446415, 0.010322760790586472, 0.05823188275098801, 0.012808435596525669, -0.033764198422431946, -0.057074081152677536, -0.054413408041000366, 0.01775233820080757, -0.041668739169836044, -0.05878879502415657, 0.01644289493560791, 0.03490334376692772, 0.032334599643945694, 0.001172711723484099, -0.009098942391574383, 0.028752047568559647, 0.031064681708812714, -0.026655975729227066, -0.005904292222112417, 0.06033826619386673, -0.006290811114013195, -0.02689533494412899, -0.020584672689437866, 0.04353711009025574, 0.022401386871933937, -0.0662844181060791, 0.002309543779119849, -0.004917277488857508, 0.07008297741413116, -0.03448961675167084, 0.022750673815608025, 0.07745806872844696, -0.024962561205029488, 0.00004365333734313026, 0.012627918273210526, -0.005809021648019552, 0.0043084449134767056, 0.011363000608980656, -0.006711848545819521, 0.04527558386325836, -0.009844654239714146, -0.010776173323392868, -0.041595280170440674, 0.039291445165872574, 0.02390526793897152, -0.059749625623226166, 0.028378400951623917, 0.03439520671963692, 0.005212290678173304, 0.004377945326268673, -0.024862922728061676, -0.0011260168394073844, 0.06561378389596939, -0.018289824947714806, -0.005368316546082497, 0.04848664626479149, 0.015047232620418072, -0.0005788501584902406, 0.03140246123075485, -0.03226516395807266, -0.06903141736984253, 0.025402026250958443, -0.009611261077225208, 0.035151999443769455, 0.043044328689575195, -0.0189723651856184, -0.09868234395980835, -0.01153076346963644, 0.02489691786468029, -0.013304636813700199, 0.03351207822561264, 0.026015715673565865, 0.010298354551196098, -0.05547920614480972, 0.0500749871134758, 0.006532460916787386, 0.04265446588397026, -0.04096426069736481, 0.062252018600702286, 0.03825319930911064, -0.015047676861286163, -0.004575981758534908, 0.03197145834565163, 0.019973156973719597, -0.04308971390128136, 0.012818398885428905, -0.030172284692525864, 0.026705775409936905, -0.03206660598516464, -0.0252083633095026, -0.05412137508392334, -0.01863716170191765, -0.02836044691503048, -0.0646359920501709, 0.02598670683801174, 0.05423939600586891, -0.00904853641986847, 0.04555780813097954, 0.020179925486445427, -0.0020587146282196045, -0.04053378105163574, -0.006828693673014641, 0.019360123202204704, -0.008782102726399899, 0.02387002296745777, -0.004132390953600407, -0.045307476073503494, -0.013222905807197094, 0.007104736287146807, 0.0007634610519744456, -0.05333137512207031, -0.06699207425117493, 0.024183275178074837, 0.04756913334131241, -0.04014844074845314, 0.0026083795819431543, -0.05971373990178108, -0.024492302909493446, -0.0036475281231105328, -0.00400205235928297, -0.0633445680141449, -0.03891604393720627, -0.008934647776186466, 0.027698233723640442, -0.022817309945821762, -0.004147959873080254, -0.020897842943668365, -0.027470914646983147, -0.039935555309057236, 0.03415288031101227, 0.07407563924789429, 0.059864312410354614, 0.027512501925230026, 0.020220013335347176, -0.004972646478563547, 0.033666882663965225, 0.03561791032552719, -0.0276041217148304, 0.034256067126989365, 0.007905524224042892, 0.04054718464612961, 0.03227551281452179, 0.0166550911962986, 0.049944259226322174, -0.0036138847935944796, 0.000169296283274889, 0.034429218620061874, -0.0700036808848381, 0.014944790862500668, 0.0775580033659935, 0.02499878592789173, -0.03840286284685135, -0.05826079100370407, -0.01677403599023819, -0.013148731552064419, -0.027785183861851692, -0.013973942957818508, 0.03906389698386192, 0.06154790148139, 0.0587177649140358, -0.08558700233697891, -0.03920060396194458, -0.04499201476573944, -0.12307928502559662, 0.06196334958076477, -0.006676510442048311, -0.0009049735381267965, 0.004503224045038223, -0.057500362396240234, 0.021848265081644058, -0.0052391537465155125, -0.11365540325641632, 0.023652315139770508, -0.008431198075413704, -0.041110169142484665, 0.006494633387774229, 0.041819360107183456, 0.016396140679717064, 0.05536745488643646, 0.028425369411706924, -0.002616016659885645, 0.021242182701826096, -0.025778716430068016, -0.018529772758483887, -0.006303057074546814, 0.02210625261068344, -0.046392206102609634, 0.07052052766084671, 0.05552826076745987, -0.016878413036465645, 0.022069547325372696, 0.054020803421735764, 0.001108188764192164, -0.037139348685741425, -0.04567250981926918, 0.014088531024754047, -0.039021339267492294, 0.007130054756999016, 0.0325716957449913, 0.008532574400305748, -0.00977868027985096, -0.056550558656454086, 0.0005556911928579211, 0.0014641981106251478, 0.06165879964828491, 0.020975010469555855, -0.004312146455049515, -0.0012384499423205853, 0.04954083636403084, -0.07626377046108246, -0.056042321026325226, 0.030139733105897903, 0.08071210980415344, -0.04842266067862511, -0.022238334640860558, -0.042457301169633865, -0.021026944741606712, -0.08115669339895248, 0.06617017835378647, 0.020896777510643005, -0.051681436598300934, 0.05882447957992554, -0.029510580003261566, 0.010440535843372345, -0.030494771897792816, -0.021568330004811287, 0.0216305423527956, -0.0024703452363610268, 0.05879690870642662, -0.05130184441804886, 0.008776490576565266, -0.03284502029418945, 0.024092799052596092, -0.01771598681807518, 0.04453738033771515, 0.039850879460573196, -0.03585470840334892, -0.024103598669171333, -0.011347954161465168, 0.01709434948861599, -0.0027945174369961023, -0.008468965999782085, 0.04570714011788368, 0.10769960284233093, 0.05663776025176048, -0.04770255088806152, 0.008093205280601978, -0.018652480095624924, -0.00043117860332131386, 0.008740696124732494, 0.016547923907637596, 0.02201845869421959, 0.03908831626176834, 0.007584292907267809, -0.04085593298077583, 0.01646718941628933, 0.023331530392169952, 0.0018610424594953656, -0.07596409320831299, 0.009587411768734455, 0.026299109682440758, -0.023933691903948784, 0.012197157368063927, 0.06244412809610367, -0.02348286844789982, -0.022517431527376175, 0.03372597321867943, 0.02396542578935623, 0.03938442841172218, -0.009178733453154564, 0.047047361731529236, -0.05259735509753227, 0.03849327936768532, -0.03956529498100281, 0.014933518134057522, 0.033098023384809494, 0.03845193609595299, 0.023681873455643654, 0.02684278041124344, 0.011330349370837212, 0.023107565939426422, -0.006336945574730635, 0.016694463789463043, 0.0347680039703846, -0.015943991020321846, -0.001906442572362721, -0.0004194672219455242, -0.021061621606349945, -0.03357500210404396, 0.01422104611992836, -0.02871564030647278, 0.014030646532773972, 0.039774052798748016, 0.03902466967701912, -0.06554755568504333, -0.020085198804736137, 0.012900195084512234, 0.02572455257177353, 0.002223030664026737, -0.007576439063996077, -0.011705405078828335, 0.05559831112623215, 0.003432230092585087, -0.01831240952014923, 0.03675597161054611, 0.02353942021727562, 0.07377860695123672, -0.08419721573591232, 0.0018554653506726027, -0.020720167085528374, 0.05030885338783264, 0.006805162876844406, 0.05777037516236305, 0.058862797915935516, 0.04656638950109482, -0.01506555825471878, 0.02792954631149769, 0.05817017704248428, -0.018825901672244072, -0.013234919868409634, -0.02791823446750641, 0.05178775265812874, -0.02193060703575611, 0.038312725722789764, 0.049811482429504395, -0.00806669145822525, -0.01704201102256775, -0.02096528373658657, 0.021245455369353294, 0.013116412796080112, -0.03556932881474495, 0.061763957142829895, 0.01117753703147173, 0.05372920632362366, -0.021796438843011856, 0.04384922981262207, 0.01794729009270668, 0.03370042145252228, 0.000485809869132936, -0.008286019787192345, -0.06100023165345192, 0.03561782091856003, -0.042060088366270065, -0.044172756373882294, 0.002328588394448161, -0.043923377990722656, -0.04644528403878212, -0.015996403992176056, -0.02703973650932312, -0.025469249114394188, -0.014765091240406036, -0.03842506557703018, -0.004789098631590605, 0.018461838364601135, -0.004033700097352266, -0.010234125889837742, 0.02608310617506504, -0.03478046879172325, 0.005294401198625565, -0.0013164080446586013, -0.0071031213738024235, 0.005769351962953806, 0.03675739839673042, 0.024328745901584625, -0.03759549558162689, 0.01634599268436432, -0.008319634012877941, 0.05348176509141922, 0.0078547652810812, 0.00400385819375515, -0.007292375434190035, -0.005435221362859011, 0.03996817767620087, -0.013998816721141338, 0.08126211911439896, -0.023156482726335526, -0.01077476516366005, 0.02107621170580387, -0.0238094050437212, -0.021985039114952087, 0.005510121583938599, -0.0532897487282753, -0.0021710346918553114, -0.03633880987763405, 0.009008696302771568, 0.0062871105037629604, -0.012136729434132576, 0.04673205316066742, -0.049207113683223724, -0.0567808523774147, -0.007851979695260525, -0.0240041371434927, -0.008331162855029106, -0.04551553353667259, -0.07201254367828369, -0.029293198138475418, -0.05978880077600479, -0.0019437676528468728, -0.0016801427118480206, 0.02909589558839798, -0.039849791675806046, 0.029921291396021843, 0.003903847187757492, 0.020337846130132675, 0.00784569326788187, -0.011058436706662178, -0.0202036090195179, 0.006049788556993008, 0.018459802493453026, 0.03783411905169487, -0.0017659926088526845, 0.011505521833896637, 0.05683065950870514, 0.007865151390433311, -0.032711006700992584, 0.01189052127301693, 0.05823943018913269, 0.013808023184537888, 0.045886676758527756, -0.024109812453389168, -0.01671571284532547, -0.03476395457983017, -0.0008236009743995965, -0.033301323652267456, -0.022232474759221077, -0.025997363030910492, -0.05444057285785675, -0.022982100024819374, -0.002416834933683276, -0.04852497577667236, -0.0020097827073186636, -0.02338540181517601, -0.002173907123506069, -0.0152857955545187, -0.0349641889333725, -0.013875449076294899, 0.01977667212486267, 0.006677404046058655, 0.008433595299720764, 0.03271499276161194, -0.02282826229929924, 0.012225535698235035, -0.03138110041618347, -0.04574720188975334, 0.031671296805143356, -0.01865757815539837, -0.02917693741619587, 0.030484279617667198, -0.045887771993875504, 0.007183191366493702, 0.005549621768295765, 0.029211871325969696, -0.0108371302485466, -0.06172119081020355, -0.03345685079693794, -0.0013005792861804366, 0.042671117931604385, 0.01608535833656788, 0.002455485286191106, 0.01684148982167244, 0.004729310050606728, 0.025359518826007843, -0.042812950909137726, 0.03464442491531372, 0.050337981432676315, 0.03985666483640671, 0.07178337126970291, 0.005192285403609276, 0.0013832624536007643, 0.07873506098985672, 0.03560376912355423, 0.0156891830265522, -0.06252804398536682, -0.030900875106453896, -0.04363445192575455, 0.026745958253741264, -0.04498806595802307, 0.044439490884542465, 0.006549648474901915, -0.0296440701931715, -0.014533279463648796, 0.05831470713019371, -0.036501433700323105, -0.11488877981901169, 0.0350959450006485, -0.03428255394101143, 0.020704109221696854, 0.010640619322657585, -0.02441979944705963, 0.018778346478939056, 0.023685164749622345, 0.011165427044034004, 0.047569334506988525, 0.05232573300600052, 0.027881991118192673, 0.048950787633657455, 0.05484602600336075, 0.05227166786789894, 0.032416243106126785, -0.00458566565066576, 0.052577905356884, -0.0691794827580452, 0.03168904781341553, 0.018855439499020576, -0.08784569799900055, -0.011041009798645973, 0.015448855236172676, -0.015600863844156265, -0.019613010808825493, 0.02068556472659111, 0.011450564488768578, 0.0076192826963961124, -0.0007305457256734371, 0.012143773026764393, 0.001108453026972711, -0.028848525136709213, -0.02750079147517681, -0.044368211179971695, 0.04058079048991203, 0.008053958415985107, 0.007397419773042202, -0.011108104139566422, -0.09773913770914078, 0.0022666689474135637, 0.021552573889493942, 0.002976813353598118, 0.018773240968585014, -0.005440154112875462, 0.0031196274794638157, 0.018120799213647842, 0.0027464109007269144, 0.10656715929508209, -0.03539907932281494, -0.021558934822678566, 0.04911345615983009, 0.04004532843828201, -0.0029237098060548306, -0.007861468009650707, 0.02496080845594406, -0.052630990743637085, 0.02058524452149868, 0.004815967287868261, 0.01726037636399269, -0.03852565959095955, -0.020888572558760643, 0.05784231051802635, 0.006167768035084009, 0.0045203473418951035, -0.018204933032393456, 0.01332128420472145, -0.019337566569447517, 0.003885352285578847, 0.01691298559308052, -0.05614442750811577, 0.04430687427520752, -0.03576179966330528, -0.035464394837617874, 0.029463835060596466, 0.05760597810149193, 0.005872953683137894, -0.006117471028119326, 0.056309718638658524, 0.011690719053149223, -0.005285147577524185, -0.006222874391824007, -0.000995161710307002, -0.003993268124759197, -0.03717305138707161, 0.007069431245326996, -0.021557491272687912, 0.0407923087477684, 0.04204433411359787, -0.035895127803087234, 0.01198728010058403, 0.028644373640418053, -0.028189275413751602, 0.004448122810572386, -0.0027789201121777296, -0.08677983283996582, 0.0022294095251709223, -0.04182993248105049, 0.05450769141316414, 0.011950727552175522, -0.0037925560027360916, -0.015420492738485336, 0.006068493705242872, 0.008148920722305775, 0.11653118580579758, -0.0074395607225596905, -0.028972255066037178, -0.022602509707212448, -0.040704768151044846, 0.03792557120323181, 0.06424904614686966, 0.008575881831347942, -0.0116495406255126, -0.00042464619036763906, -0.025738397613167763, -0.008151920512318611, 0.062061410397291183, -0.033121176064014435, -0.023159919306635857, -0.053293369710445404, -0.07709678262472153, -0.055516358464956284, -0.009105215780436993, 0.0001955949264811352, 0.0037521638441830873, -0.06301090866327286, 0.03570296987891197, 0.038759712129831314, -0.011435930617153645, -0.020119622349739075, -0.005401841830462217, 0.025801347568631172, 0.019627509638667107, -0.04224126413464546, -0.06297007203102112, 0.03860146924853325, -0.08018387854099274, -0.08190726488828659, -0.004114795476198196, -0.003732583485543728, -0.018484635278582573, -0.017258260399103165, 0.02186489850282669, 0.003193987999111414, 0.02041487768292427, 0.04821581766009331, -0.02077571675181389, -0.008029277436435223, 0.009390332736074924, -0.002095441333949566, -0.049708303064107895, -0.03357324004173279, -0.010408584028482437, 0.0034445011988282204, -0.06711210310459137, -0.03639889135956764, -0.006023835856467485, 0.04061504825949669, -0.018827252089977264, -0.06099850311875343, -0.00761778000742197, 0.021226173266768456, -0.039328690618276596, 0.04008995369076729, -0.048392537981271744, 0.02579939179122448, 0.006481945980340242, -0.05586060509085655, -0.06516627222299576, 0.01883358508348465, -0.024833152070641518, 0.011311338283121586, -0.0034621693193912506, -0.004262613132596016, 0.04450298100709915, -0.05082837492227554, -0.03380909934639931, 0.02852005884051323, -0.022753145545721054, -0.03569376468658447, 0.029612433165311813 ]
<p>As any light reflected or emitted from objects inside a black hole (if it is possible to be there) does not leave the event horizon and comes back inside, would it be like seeing yourself?</p> <p>What I mean is that would the light we might emit/reflect return to our eyes and make us sort of look at ourselves? </p>
g6649
[ -0.0239707138389349, 0.0032647543121129274, 0.04332872852683067, -0.001407713396474719, -0.015380152501165867, 0.01624464988708496, 0.004733889829367399, 0.040875520557165146, 0.0015321398386731744, -0.04215230792760849, 0.03587333485484123, 0.055541444569826126, 0.040914248675107956, -0.024084821343421936, -0.03684449940919876, -0.043770551681518555, 0.03763732686638832, -0.03876335546374321, -0.019576579332351685, -0.026350220665335655, 0.025998039171099663, -0.0062496718019247055, -0.00201324000954628, -0.03202072158455849, -0.07047664374113083, 0.03812223672866821, 0.014584087766706944, -0.02227378822863102, -0.017602451145648956, -0.011030798777937889, 0.04898766800761223, 0.001236693817190826, 0.004953450057655573, -0.019252123311161995, 0.03551958501338959, 0.0035574156790971756, 0.01786063425242901, 0.08790483325719833, -0.008694222196936607, 0.012230230495333672, -0.016597433015704155, -0.01795043610036373, -0.01729142852127552, -0.024705499410629272, 0.018026070669293404, 0.023659585043787956, 0.04579602926969528, 0.011107861064374447, 0.06702660024166107, -0.029739033430814743, 0.012898564338684082, -0.023244401440024376, 0.02380642481148243, 0.04909372329711914, 0.06878966838121414, 0.010447710752487183, -0.005074169021099806, -0.0004946187837049365, 0.04536668583750725, -0.019679494202136993, -0.023017166182398796, 0.012101591564714909, 0.04487869516015053, 0.04222865775227547, 0.016339875757694244, -0.014211219735443592, -0.08652663975954056, -0.00003978354288847186, -0.033817358314991, -0.0010558853391557932, 0.03602350503206253, 0.05303911119699478, -0.06337326765060425, -0.01234771404415369, 0.000023962649720488116, 0.04716923087835312, 0.018094653263688087, 0.02769232913851738, 0.0018091467209160328, -0.009371763095259666, -0.05105127766728401, -0.059090789407491684, -0.002388512948527932, 0.02170342393219471, 0.06469743698835373, 0.04163694009184837, -0.013061627745628357, -0.04579095169901848, -0.0012142941122874618, 0.014972837641835213, 0.0862002745270729, -0.03674960508942604, 0.028763528913259506, 0.03942003473639488, -0.02082190476357937, 0.01589619368314743, 0.032535430043935776, -0.006708693690598011, 0.001627687830477953, 0.06494680792093277, -0.06201326847076416, -0.009217885322868824, -0.03574658930301666, -0.01079491339623928, 0.01998264156281948, -0.0496390201151371, -0.02285890467464924, 0.011979966424405575, -0.04640374705195427, 0.030239490792155266, -0.02674916386604309, -0.10108241438865662, -0.03519180417060852, -0.00013807885989081115, -0.07060494273900986, -0.015461176633834839, 0.05793042853474617, -0.011858814395964146, -0.01798936538398266, 0.09754712134599686, 0.026641540229320526, -0.0001905107346829027, -0.00030018165125511587, 0.020164595916867256, 0.04905395209789276, 0.01328070368617773, -0.04003779590129852, -0.0418085977435112, 0.024734782055020332, -0.01977418176829815, -0.014147316105663776, 0.014333928003907204, -0.031603943556547165, 0.09328431636095047, 0.012136156670749187, -0.01159617304801941, 0.03760356456041336, -0.013308636844158173, 0.030961228534579277, 0.005101427435874939, 0.04354194551706314, -0.014863855205476284, -0.018141547217965126, 0.0026610626373440027, -0.0026229757349938154, -0.0008409183938056231, -0.0018288494320586324, -0.05628398433327675, 0.0008626916096545756, 0.05347742140293121, -0.022694576531648636, 0.06508025527000427, 0.022687094286084175, 0.0032462060917168856, -0.05441652610898018, -0.03807413950562477, 0.01110078115016222, 0.04144173488020897, -0.039757516235113144, 0.0073404270224273205, 0.08081933110952377, -0.04019719362258911, 0.0011418333742767572, 0.027721788734197617, -0.011401454918086529, -0.06484542787075043, -0.021960677579045296, -0.029131194576621056, 0.04086105525493622, -0.041500821709632874, 0.02073059231042862, 0.011548450216650963, -0.0187512319535017, 0.03527770936489105, 0.031716883182525635, -0.006181045435369015, -0.01736462116241455, 0.03858686238527298, -0.04349828511476517, 0.014643962495028973, 0.0021012581419199705, -0.02344619296491146, -0.06390256434679031, -0.05469866469502449, 0.012780317105352879, -0.05813799425959587, 0.02757805772125721, 0.04199376329779625, 0.04640983045101166, 0.014246570877730846, 0.011387228965759277, -0.014062728732824326, 0.031298357993364334, 0.010421646758913994, 0.030006995424628258, -0.03993695601820946, -0.00815910380333662, -0.011504272930324078, 0.05843228101730347, 0.0707998126745224, 0.041564375162124634, 0.019140416756272316, 0.014606551267206669, -0.007444484159350395, 0.0057399095967411995, -0.009851145558059216, 0.03326908499002457, -0.038018736988306046, -0.01741374097764492, -0.07915918529033661, 0.03416988626122475, -0.013710025697946548, 0.05228620395064354, -0.021648604422807693, -0.01788044162094593, 0.04736757650971413, -0.04428466409444809, 0.038520697504282, 0.009726867079734802, 0.04173891991376877, -0.02467615343630314, 0.026977742090821266, -0.005516801495105028, -0.03254934027791023, -0.029037119820713997, 0.05363955721259117, -0.08456685394048691, -0.01691638119518757, 0.007634854409843683, -0.0016870941035449505, -0.05324805900454521, -0.03190089017152786, -0.012885505333542824, 0.015643354505300522, 0.032115742564201355, -0.0011519237887114286, -0.04353085532784462, 0.027548005804419518, 0.017101531848311424, 0.007455251645296812, -0.008095575496554375, -0.03625955805182457, -0.06705880165100098, -0.037000373005867004, 0.03143961355090141, 0.009284377098083496, -0.01040107011795044, 0.04757583513855934, 0.048780884593725204, 0.018639253452420235, 0.018322838470339775, 0.008325062692165375, -0.02124939300119877, -0.04963197559118271, 0.009194828569889069, -0.009533282369375229, 0.01886913552880287, 0.048248495906591415, -0.04712880775332451, 0.0017456929199397564, -0.018060091882944107, -0.025749346241354942, -0.029090560972690582, 0.045860908925533295, -0.03358948603272438, 0.008116784505546093, -0.009604323655366898, -0.0029813593719154596, 0.013189288787543774, 0.06461294740438461, -0.02060682699084282, 0.02762784995138645, 0.02415764145553112, -0.005420529283583164, 0.02586408704519272, 0.010455065406858921, -0.04170728474855423, 0.004589115735143423, 0.051489561796188354, 0.007655960042029619, -0.0070896572433412075, -0.03509347140789032, -0.052128009498119354, -0.0182332806289196, -0.041511036455631256, -0.06229383870959282, 0.0071602133102715015, 0.003564838320016861, 0.03294477239251137, 0.0270377267152071, -0.018148714676499367, 0.02657158672809601, -0.03215327858924866, 0.03222065418958664, -0.012682048603892326, 0.01668095961213112, 0.03276851028203964, 0.03452331945300102, 0.003852325025945902, 0.02836637571454048, 0.009224984794855118, 0.0006652529700659215, -0.010678875260055065, 0.016508817672729492, -0.04261097311973572, -0.013942183926701546, -0.016815993934869766, 0.020264320075511932, 0.033474572002887726, -0.000880238541867584, -0.000448943639639765, 0.010342826135456562, 0.020861094817519188, 0.040096040815114975, 0.021285222843289375, -0.00010536659829085693, 0.005599826108664274, -0.004010195378214121, -0.00452469801530242, -0.03760111331939697, -0.007261150050908327, 0.05356670916080475, -0.005313768982887268, 0.006508509628474712, 0.03317932039499283, 0.022704821079969406, 0.006582960486412048, -0.030939696356654167, -0.054946914315223694, -0.030138013884425163, -0.027204889804124832, 0.027587469667196274, -0.012348681688308716, 0.012384694069623947, 0.027949251234531403, -0.02606513351202011, -0.04743750020861626, 0.003713093465194106, 0.033125314861536026, 0.0391613245010376, 0.08477388322353363, -0.0377812497317791, -0.013155411928892136, -0.02712298557162285, 0.03497333824634552, -0.009189257398247719, -0.03378636762499809, -0.0367516428232193, -0.018666474148631096, -0.014860434457659721, 0.03744499012827873, -0.014149541966617107, 0.023675573989748955, -0.044106971472501755, 0.02882068045437336, -0.037795159965753555, 0.0555194728076458, 0.04254120960831642, 0.03819999471306801, -0.015953829512000084, -0.017071688547730446, -0.06306301057338715, 0.04331200569868088, -0.08775829523801804, 0.017455117776989937, -0.06506059318780899, 0.019137322902679443, 0.02717450074851513, 0.02779320813715458, 0.03028448112308979, -0.009049288928508759, 0.01710972748696804, -0.02422679401934147, -0.01402701623737812, -0.051170121878385544, -0.06925322115421295, 0.04719525948166847, 0.0034469999372959137, -0.004949145019054413, -0.024945365265011787, 0.002180797280743718, -0.013448049314320087, 0.00992597360163927, 0.0034755023662000895, 0.01515701599419117, 0.020800497382879257, -0.004334277007728815, -0.07213687151670456, -0.0035199651028960943, -0.010646309703588486, -0.004438588861376047, 0.002244623377919197, 0.014590495266020298, -0.09825334697961807, -0.017736118286848068, 0.03520682454109192, -0.0012649840209633112, -0.044747259467840195, 0.01687721349298954, -0.04562455415725708, 0.009867136366665363, 0.0211839210242033, 0.04117213562130928, 0.06361565738916397, 0.03197325021028519, 0.006651428062468767, 0.03678309544920921, -0.03126157820224762, -0.030146516859531403, -0.048079054802656174, -0.03403700143098831, 0.01910402439534664, -0.03709689900279045, 0.015515363775193691, 0.00476679066196084, -0.004480347037315369, 0.041330091655254364, 0.00992168951779604, 0.05474972724914551, 0.013134332373738289, 0.028566043823957443, -0.02394186705350876, 0.0115354023873806, 0.07971753925085068, -0.014551489613950253, -0.011452481150627136, -0.013035549782216549, 0.024240948259830475, -0.04992343485355377, -0.005157948937267065, -0.0483776330947876, -0.026844540610909462, -0.015504928305745125, 0.017386993393301964, -0.026751220226287842, 0.05257038027048111, -0.04246596246957779, 0.004434899426996708, 0.016209889203310013, -0.010521158576011658, 0.02568315528333187, 0.009961257688701153, 0.03383008763194084, -0.0025231114123016596, 0.02149379625916481, 0.05473580211400986, 0.03357327729463577, 0.048047974705696106, 0.0358438603579998, -0.017176732420921326, -0.04718303680419922, 0.001099359360523522, 0.008411787450313568, -0.07901518046855927, -0.049897219985723495, -0.0011903384001925588, -0.0457737073302269, 0.0436798520386219, -0.028994055464863777, 0.00316813588142395, 0.028924020007252693, -0.03076784312725067, 0.04668217524886131, 0.03180750459432602, 0.010557224042713642, -0.005115966312587261, -0.07237789034843445, -0.023783689364790916, -0.016018729656934738, -0.021210193634033203, -0.08575363457202911, 0.05198289826512337, 0.008869706653058529, 0.011017690412700176, -0.0330694317817688, 0.028813842684030533, 0.02117922715842724, -0.0008556635002605617, -0.010974349454045296, -0.04644188657402992, -0.02652103081345558, -0.00023513143241871148, 0.04670273885130882, -0.054203614592552185, -0.028687505051493645, 0.04061764106154442, -0.05403026193380356, 0.04362800717353821, -0.04675044119358063, -0.014836695976555347, -0.029013285413384438, -0.07191145420074463, -0.027161937206983566, -0.04498365893959999, -0.04620438814163208, -0.03200322762131691, -0.010721931234002113, -0.0005437556537799537, 0.018915066495537758, 0.015733366832137108, -0.05611643195152283, -0.02980717085301876, -0.0012102389009669423, 0.006749883759766817, -0.03405550494790077, 0.0034096878953278065, -0.0026311606634408236, -0.02858513779938221, 0.028382722288370132, 0.07620732486248016, 0.02144596353173256, -0.023223653435707092, -0.07389124482870102, 0.03223560377955437, 0.03335056081414223, -0.04514742270112038, -0.043928809463977814, -0.004311276599764824, 0.04531830921769142, -0.017109891399741173, -0.04575334116816521, -0.007817615754902363, 0.026808617636561394, 0.015820734202861786, 0.04576531797647476, 0.043863724917173386, -0.03368600085377693, 0.02017023414373398, 0.04711698368191719, -0.01780950091779232, 0.05208838731050491, 0.03727451339364052, 0.04593293368816376, -0.028538094833493233, 0.04252297803759575, -0.029239067807793617, 0.013954604975879192, 0.02622004598379135, 0.05291074514389038, -0.01139377523213625, -0.027998510748147964, -0.00016365903138648719, -0.02585960179567337, 0.019859740510582924, 0.0631944090127945, -0.001051575061865151, -0.009525268338620663, 0.01852433755993843, -0.03709005191922188, -0.016033511608839035, -0.004427238833159208, 0.07134076207876205, -0.044932059943675995, 0.060748495161533356, 0.00840143021196127, 0.008355864323675632, 0.00691392133012414, 0.008904213085770607, -0.024635201320052147, -0.06757088005542755, 0.031386133283376694, -0.020021596923470497, -0.03510207310318947, -0.0751507431268692, 0.0022849170491099358, 0.003004113445058465, 0.039550259709358215, 0.03061133436858654, 0.010817205533385277, -0.01659402996301651, 0.04090389981865883, -0.047681812196969986, 0.02535712532699108, -0.030674036592245102, -0.036760132759809494, 0.03300650045275688, 0.05505189672112465, 0.006176677532494068, -0.019490668550133705, -0.045873917639255524, 0.028719047084450722, -0.014239383861422539, 0.07830810546875, -0.05277277156710625, -0.004231204278767109, -0.05227163806557655, -0.00020361706265248358, 0.08197930455207825, 0.0341964066028595, -0.0327436625957489, -0.02697352133691311, 0.004262660164386034, 0.024867430329322815, -0.07656098902225494, -0.022761434316635132, -0.03742307424545288, -0.041066378355026245, -0.041407261043787, -0.008290383964776993, -0.030735857784748077, -0.045823995023965836, 0.03774604573845863, -0.002952516544610262, 0.007998176850378513, 0.03404022380709648, 0.0568159818649292, -0.04843507334589958, 0.01850091852247715, 0.06325185298919678, 0.024525314569473267, 0.059624478220939636, -0.01584574021399021, -0.02271120622754097, 0.04749515280127525, -0.020570222288370132, 0.029424628242850304, -0.032687243074178696, -0.057670075446367264, 0.03648316115140915, -0.046297114342451096, -0.009200284257531166, 0.013613397255539894, 0.015952276065945625, -0.00448211096227169, -0.026249825954437256, 0.04066348448395729, -0.08746810257434845, 0.026533136144280434, 0.030915692448616028, 0.08450420945882797, 0.02894119918346405, -0.0057539925910532475, 0.018442092463374138, 0.05469096079468727, 0.047240544110536575, 0.03486327826976776, 0.023581309244036674, -0.028088226914405823, -0.058959949761629105, -0.07190636545419693, 0.007025860249996185, -0.008825143799185753, -0.004599285777658224, 0.012216475792229176, -0.08174740523099899, 0.07265741378068924, 0.025255758315324783, -0.029819997027516365, -0.05850615352392197, 0.01549422275274992, 0.014797864481806755, -0.013387015089392662, -0.011660978198051453, -0.03054412640631199, -0.03673529624938965, -0.05912412703037262, -0.03327217325568199, 0.054318636655807495, -0.043668318539857864, -0.07790165394544601, 0.0033454885706305504, 0.030505074188113213, -0.1048455685377121, -0.04455675929784775, -0.007979877293109894, 0.011450029909610748, 0.012308647856116295, -0.004852321930229664, 0.0012129426468163729, 0.059643831104040146, -0.00599076971411705, -0.0597536638379097, -0.04677543789148331, 0.008783182129263878, -0.06626202166080475, -0.04967067763209343, -0.018199484795331955, 0.1368422955274582, 0.022956399247050285, 0.04698098078370094, 0.01479820441454649, 0.017121488228440285, 0.006363051012158394, 0.07164762169122696, -0.04024006798863411, 0.03481069207191467, 0.03917217627167702, -0.042721670120954514, -0.005741593427956104, -0.007673954591155052, -0.0730995163321495, 0.03784520551562309, -0.017810095101594925, -0.07655611634254456, -0.011600266210734844, -0.01318176556378603, 0.029869096353650093, 0.021249454468488693, 0.009850245900452137, -0.008287206292152405, -0.022699078544974327, 0.061313483864068985, 0.06418021768331528, -0.04799606651067734, -0.0012098689330741763, -0.04683426395058632, -0.02927444688975811, -0.020919937640428543, -0.00986680667847395, -0.010459152981638908, 0.04589037969708443, 0.07343585789203644, -0.04067784547805786, 0.04317011311650276, -0.008988682180643082, -0.03676416352391243, -0.007551256101578474, 0.012146621011197567, 0.015226298943161964, -0.034540969878435135, -0.0018541284371167421, 0.032805997878313065, -0.018850285559892654, 0.05604725331068039, -0.008482161909341812, 0.023468894883990288, 0.005894903559237719, -0.03941617161035538, 0.014865955337882042, -0.03735315427184105, 0.05301298201084137, 0.06749029457569122, -0.03607923910021782, -0.021626342087984085, 0.023033656179904938, 0.011426803655922413, 0.009234733879566193, 0.02391386590898037, -0.01577405072748661, -0.027496393769979477, 0.007024792488664389, -0.0006773851346224546, 0.03136590123176575, -0.03312971815466881, 0.031216410920023918, -0.021853718906641006, 0.021458284929394722, -0.02917482703924179, -0.013636201620101929, 0.01589258946478367, 0.024110324680805206, -0.02367895096540451, -0.02741927281022072, 0.022064805030822754, 0.0778345987200737, -0.0063793533481657505, -0.0457349494099617, 0.03401578962802887, -0.0958515852689743, 0.018710745498538017, -0.0470479354262352, 0.01986398920416832, -0.04252918064594269, 0.009964946657419205, 0.04394473880529404, -0.054685596376657486, 0.052415698766708374, 0.027916230261325836 ]
<p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbulence" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a> states that </p> <blockquote> <p><em>Turbulent flow is chaotic. However, not all chaotic flows are turbulent.</em></p> </blockquote> <p>Someone give a picture for that?</p>
g6650
[ 0.027859004214406013, 0.07114582508802414, 0.016339782625436783, 0.02343682199716568, 0.07207565754652023, -0.03500496596097946, 0.04430226981639862, 0.0075719296000897884, 0.017306188121438026, -0.023703936487436295, 0.03248849883675575, 0.01715298555791378, 0.039821743965148926, 0.04089473560452461, -0.013095922768115997, 0.015026197768747807, -0.009124206379055977, -0.015626464039087296, 0.0612904392182827, 0.02110333740711212, -0.04953475296497345, 0.008368309587240219, 0.056147608906030655, 0.005035641603171825, -0.02897855080664158, 0.006865441799163818, -0.01325117889791727, -0.10482358932495117, -0.06547939777374268, 0.01193151529878378, 0.06014544889330864, 0.016729215160012245, 0.009707032702863216, -0.02872699685394764, -0.04197175055742264, 0.027664121240377426, -0.03108047880232334, -0.007650179322808981, 0.06328339129686356, 0.03367723897099495, 0.05531067028641701, 0.06620129942893982, -0.04531367868185043, -0.002170511521399021, -0.07920066267251968, 0.024431852623820305, -0.03599056228995323, 0.019683076068758965, -0.08435934782028198, 0.006926180794835091, 0.026087503880262375, 0.017727253958582878, 0.03456303849816322, 0.03505045548081398, 0.04098192974925041, 0.043951041996479034, 0.029658500105142593, 0.04415101930499077, 0.026018602773547173, -0.017297882586717606, 0.0019714159425348043, -0.018039926886558533, 0.023204006254673004, 0.024170080199837685, -0.01836741529405117, 0.023880554363131523, -0.01929759979248047, -0.07033424079418182, 0.07020339369773865, 0.0358496755361557, 0.01110452227294445, -0.02118084765970707, -0.010910114273428917, 0.01522983331233263, -0.06050983816385269, 0.03478795662522316, 0.0030884083826094866, -0.02802751213312149, 0.039391085505485535, 0.0020576179958879948, 0.018688788637518883, 0.0165676511824131, -0.019768916070461273, 0.03093177266418934, 0.09124356508255005, 0.03726280853152275, -0.02981109917163849, -0.05424007400870323, -0.019833168014883995, -0.04801178351044655, 0.03277209401130676, -0.029557453468441963, 0.015238556079566479, 0.02196572534739971, 0.0807529017329216, 0.02456175722181797, -0.05873243883252144, -0.00507791293784976, -0.03669391945004463, 0.027947911992669106, -0.057800501585006714, 0.021107442677021027, 0.03842946141958237, -0.007363724056631327, 0.012299840338528156, -0.0508306585252285, -0.005996244959533215, -0.03751713037490845, -0.033517997711896896, -0.03295193240046501, -0.025734199211001396, -0.02060089074075222, -0.012820875272154808, 0.05324399098753929, 0.04088669642806053, -0.014290557242929935, 0.07695279270410538, -0.005836241878569126, 0.004490263294428587, 0.006016289349645376, 0.025647634640336037, -0.054053083062171936, 0.021457351744174957, 0.018905026838183403, 0.0381617471575737, 0.04898502305150032, 0.045962922275066376, -0.041748665273189545, 0.04072941839694977, 0.0031306392047554255, 0.02866080217063427, 0.02329288050532341, -0.011563552543520927, 0.002056070137768984, 0.032871320843696594, 0.029254943132400513, 0.010090716183185577, -0.029818544164299965, -0.022056037560105324, 0.019248541444540024, 0.07885637134313583, -0.03933459520339966, 0.001824633334763348, -0.03804473206400871, -0.04343662038445473, -0.03697808459401131, 0.028649671003222466, 0.01564883254468441, 0.0032822219654917717, -0.014660566113889217, -0.048592459410429, 0.039689164608716965, -0.023349285125732422, 0.034930191934108734, -0.00884224008768797, 0.03669740632176399, 0.046319738030433655, 0.05445254221558571, -0.042474906891584396, 0.05317104607820511, -0.0407884456217289, 0.0354488380253315, 0.0553714893758297, -0.03984430804848671, -0.04979954659938812, -0.07694195955991745, -0.014677268452942371, -0.05663269758224487, -0.028862835839390755, -0.007442896720021963, -0.0007884556544013321, 0.006186733487993479, 0.007483945693820715, 0.011061514727771282, 0.04484202712774277, -0.011236576363444328, 0.03236429765820503, 0.03277541697025299, 0.02572018653154373, -0.03360769897699356, -0.003035500645637512, 0.023875737562775612, 0.07625254988670349, -0.1026107594370842, 0.01232729572802782, 0.03284035995602608, -0.0035684281028807163, 0.034607041627168655, -0.022619744762778282, -0.023472260683774948, 0.03457413986325264, -0.06842517107725143, -0.003460348816588521, 0.016208728775382042, 0.01894773170351982, -0.016106421127915382, -0.0567326545715332, -0.01548855286091566, -0.032053496688604355, -0.0030958112329244614, 0.048190392553806305, 0.021033260971307755, 0.04297330975532532, 0.004313704092055559, -0.06285326182842255, -0.0064221518114209175, -0.04104098305106163, 0.02084294706583023, -0.03053157962858677, -0.031664423644542694, 0.02514142356812954, -0.0653800368309021, 0.013995017856359482, 0.016023265197873116, 0.004564589820802212, 0.0021812596824020147, 0.035741183906793594, -0.049135856330394745, -0.007400549948215485, 0.006222862284630537, 0.005921903531998396, -0.032291848212480545, -0.03236250579357147, -0.021489527076482773, 0.039847493171691895, 0.025315286591649055, -0.007182449102401733, -0.06670847535133362, 0.01398080587387085, 0.00835868064314127, -0.005163013935089111, -0.030162019655108452, -0.028744002804160118, 0.011816335842013359, 0.00951203890144825, 0.02374928817152977, 0.04650082439184189, 0.0531388483941555, -0.05441131815314293, -0.021215250715613365, 0.013008831068873405, -0.03678277134895325, -0.008029146119952202, -0.02958783321082592, 0.02195373736321926, -0.03693301975727081, 0.008257114328444004, -0.037976328283548355, -0.015562132932245731, 0.018718361854553223, 0.05178198590874672, -0.11236078292131424, 0.004772764164954424, -0.01634244993329048, 0.024309933185577393, -0.01706526055932045, 0.02990272082388401, 0.01816677115857601, -0.01425292156636715, 0.056823886930942535, -0.011234537698328495, -0.015707744285464287, 0.0021840373519808054, -0.0012030648067593575, -0.0263510774821043, -0.015722738578915596, 0.011419166810810566, 0.026884494349360466, -0.025481397286057472, 0.0019343390595167875, -0.008368014357984066, -0.015936726704239845, 0.03442613035440445, -0.053909771144390106, -0.05381990224123001, -0.016614794731140137, -0.03207746148109436, 0.013714803382754326, -0.07937082648277283, -0.009070388972759247, 0.007695455104112625, 0.042205799371004105, -0.0014693750999867916, 0.00032227474730461836, -0.024447571486234665, -0.029013928025960922, -0.02181960642337799, 0.01974351331591606, -0.030211716890335083, -0.029628997668623924, -0.03891186788678169, -0.01528833992779255, -0.007542503532022238, 0.022457698360085487, -0.03515155240893364, 0.027066545560956, 0.039461683481931686, -0.003863263875246048, -0.028772130608558655, -0.0023442180827260017, -0.025390567258000374, -0.006242353469133377, 0.0661473497748375, 0.04932670667767525, 0.025162287056446075, 0.004576727282255888, 0.023829957470297813, -0.03471636027097702, 0.013571631163358688, -0.006987296510487795, 0.025983743369579315, 0.030071783810853958, -0.053196728229522705, 0.09041216224431992, 0.014765404164791107, 0.06101126968860626, -0.010965121909976006, 0.024834902957081795, 0.026167066767811775, 0.019739557057619095, -0.03021189756691456, -0.046750523149967194, 0.03263258934020996, 0.0036665061488747597, -0.0030949425417929888, -0.03145812824368477, -0.0049153659492731094, 0.00005290106128086336, -0.03359682485461235, -0.017830749973654747, -0.014477331191301346, -0.020621445029973984, 0.0010187618900090456, -0.01733710803091526, 0.0014983551809564233, -0.02963765524327755, 0.03802584111690521, 0.024088652804493904, 0.03967462107539177, 0.0031013835687190294, 0.06764749437570572, -0.02066522277891636, -0.04076569899916649, -0.016100412234663963, -0.005363245494663715, 0.05553140491247177, -0.009848909452557564, -0.06627839803695679, 0.045880287885665894, -0.04730425402522087, 0.015208776108920574, -0.0041312058456242085, 0.009427232667803764, -0.03455723077058792, 0.018592996522784233, -0.014434858225286007, 0.01890607737004757, -0.019061073660850525, 0.011885580606758595, 0.006684346590191126, -0.005631421227008104, -0.029990442097187042, -0.01637328416109085, -0.019494403153657913, -0.006002705078572035, 0.06743646413087845, 0.0332159548997879, 0.04987838864326477, -0.051753513514995575, 0.003822948085144162, -0.04020208492875099, -0.02577630989253521, -0.009560585021972656, -0.015666376799345016, 0.09206891804933548, 0.02391553670167923, 0.040172405540943146, 0.05217009410262108, 0.05814019590616226, 0.011140725575387478, -0.00988035462796688, -0.018640918657183647, -0.002113253576681018, -0.022377120330929756, 0.01204567588865757, -0.03876013681292534, -0.009167304262518883, 0.044937483966350555, -0.02797478251159191, -0.05455296114087105, 0.022218132391572, 0.01346875261515379, -0.03924395889043808, 0.03551251068711281, -0.026716817170381546, 0.02462633326649666, 0.06828620284795761, 0.014954489655792713, -0.02028685435652733, 0.04598996043205261, 0.03250693529844284, -0.022427430376410484, -0.08252732455730438, 0.03784042224287987, -0.00014732961426489055, 0.04412810504436493, 0.0011405987897887826, -0.05088046193122864, 0.01917371153831482, 0.03842001035809517, 0.05380070582032204, 0.02373906970024109, 0.015933938324451447, -0.020315121859312057, -0.0022294751834124327, 0.011027132160961628, 0.0008129854686558247, 0.008882284164428711, 0.0082778949290514, 0.014886678196489811, 0.03385470062494278, 0.02994062937796116, -0.008771544322371483, -0.004097565542906523, -0.012334853410720825, -0.0037784690503031015, 0.0025592471938580275, 0.029312457889318466, -0.021438850089907646, 0.05087171122431755, 0.01629268191754818, -0.022092891857028008, -0.08478477597236633, 0.014884797856211662, -0.027624184265732765, 0.0002731596177909523, 0.06337447464466095, 0.004229038022458553, 0.05153858661651611, 0.008429141715168953, -0.006974752526730299, -0.019557489082217216, 0.039802707731723785, -0.0015958414878696203, -0.023008069023489952, 0.01266511995345354, 0.08105983585119247, 0.02937019243836403, -0.03416489437222481, 0.059456389397382736, -0.02947554551064968, 0.00785953737795353, -0.017557667568325996, 0.0708574652671814, 0.008555748499929905, -0.04204903542995453, -0.01230843085795641, 0.0034860996529459953, -0.032990142703056335, 0.015614691190421581, -0.021028537303209305, -0.007241738028824329, 0.038805779069662094, 0.04133859649300575, -0.048633843660354614, -0.009222433902323246, -0.03760536387562752, -0.05187788978219032, 0.0023171924985945225, -0.01726364903151989, 0.01505843736231327, -0.010122155770659447, -0.04255657643079758, 0.026275936514139175, 0.02426164411008358, -0.014654864557087421, 0.040636587888002396, -0.04349411278963089, 0.05844860523939133, -0.02074149064719677, 0.06001149117946625, 0.0193799939006567, 0.026302598416805267, -0.0025972158182412386, 0.06819919496774673, 0.004396509844809771, -0.013061195611953735, 0.0511469841003418, 0.0380752868950367, 0.036838967353105545, -0.004383734427392483, 0.04649389535188675, -0.10949645191431046, -0.0424157939851284, -0.014072167687118053, -0.07667293399572372, 0.035264261066913605, -0.05752519145607948, 0.009181453846395016, -0.026128089055418968, -0.07273674011230469, -0.05752449110150337, -0.01418119203299284, 0.018235646188259125, -0.018530847504734993, 0.020374206826090813, -0.07048515230417252, -0.0007644129218533635, -0.02927418425679207, 0.07107311487197876, -0.03786903992295265, -0.09168969839811325, -0.07220610231161118, 0.013421889394521713, -0.0024750379379838705, -0.041818395256996155, -0.008208787068724632, -0.024483418092131615, 0.06489087641239166, -0.003082213457673788, 0.004218581132590771, -0.0023603986483067274, 0.01953056827187538, 0.003879155730828643, -0.022629667073488235, 0.017267737537622452, -0.004444533959031105, -0.03270861878991127, -0.006942568346858025, 0.010430664755403996, -0.036739882081747055, -0.017835021018981934, 0.048093829303979874, -0.004579734522849321, -0.010194110684096813, -0.011097093112766743, 0.058726511895656586, 0.018236640840768814, -0.01249244436621666, 0.057876329869031906, 0.0355258546769619, 0.046021122485399246, -0.03536165505647659, 0.002698845462873578, 0.016137901693582535, 0.03483333811163902, -0.00926624983549118, 0.01238342747092247, 0.030215119943022728, -0.029341837391257286, 0.04167141020298004, -0.034239135682582855, -0.0033768832217901945, -0.011666244827210903, -0.04453614354133606, -0.012286175042390823, 0.03503792732954025, -0.01957876794040203, -0.018282463774085045, 0.015505345538258553, -0.01808200590312481, -0.0077808392234146595, 0.01235367450863123, -0.03564581274986267, 0.02296455204486847, -0.03880895674228668, -0.03663652017712593, 0.06249475106596947, 0.006416612770408392, 0.07677489519119263, 0.003841473488137126, 0.007072026375681162, -0.010791006498038769, 0.01551817450672388, 0.049282755702733994, -0.07753202319145203, 0.005193809513002634, -0.03366565331816673, -0.008915111422538757, -0.015252522192895412, -0.05172179266810417, 0.0002969339257106185, 0.09880650788545609, -0.06314907968044281, -0.009396258741617203, -0.04299117252230644, 0.0022009043022990227, 0.05699918791651726, -0.05604531243443489, 0.10554231703281403, -0.06898388266563416, 0.01871330477297306, -0.031658828258514404, 0.016607247292995453, 0.0336114764213562, -0.00959803070873022, -0.05664265528321266, 0.05134883522987366, 0.0019068861147388816, 0.0161306019872427, -0.039712969213724136, -0.012787766754627228, 0.03901445120573044, -0.037645477801561356, -0.03639901429414749, 0.015253636986017227, 0.05273818597197533, -0.017956478521227837, -0.07782566547393799, 0.08308488875627518, 0.007087985053658485, 0.019215762615203857, 0.06954886019229889, -0.010341261513531208, -0.05685615912079811, -0.052166398614645004, -0.0022040398325771093, -0.005655866581946611, -0.011857379227876663, 0.01767028123140335, -0.0022915878798812628, -0.050352029502391815, 0.0346999391913414, -0.030702559277415276, -0.0026143311988562346, 0.047593969851732254, -0.052478887140750885, 0.03430873528122902, -0.007380962371826172, -0.03617379814386368, 0.0007854893337935209, 0.004149863496422768, -0.017918981611728668, 0.04105885326862335, -0.05938402935862541, -0.03527594357728958, -0.1067735031247139, -0.01784013770520687, 0.06022278591990471, 0.061029233038425446, 0.03180660679936409, 0.06340749561786652, 0.023831715807318687, 0.005448182579129934, -0.0012931199744343758, -0.011917890049517155, 0.014120914973318577, 0.02772126905620098, -0.02000139094889164, -0.004976593889296055, 0.019495565444231033, 0.01358808297663927, 0.018949497491121292, -0.017313798889517784, -0.045646920800209045, 0.036704156547784805, 0.013557225465774536, -0.004356517922133207, -0.024909021332859993, -0.06778304278850555, 0.026722174137830734, 0.02912464365363121, -0.011907362379133701, -0.017367271706461906, 0.0026611306238919497, 0.0011369772255420685, 0.024089708924293518, 0.0294755008071661, -0.0037491596303880215, -0.025467898696660995, 0.006273264996707439, -0.04015868157148361, 0.009402522817254066, 0.006749319843947887, -0.033781204372644424, -0.030044734477996826, -0.009928412735462189, -0.006388651207089424, 0.08113981038331985, -0.023113897070288658, 0.01630137488245964, -0.012186550535261631, 0.02743096649646759, -0.01109043974429369, -0.02323911152780056, 0.04500935971736908, -0.05218002572655678, -0.02295476756989956, -0.02795172482728958, -0.05356095731258392, -0.008304073475301266, 0.052684225142002106, -0.010218443349003792, -0.07493863254785538, -0.06566377729177475, 0.01652689091861248, 0.011932571418583393, -0.042405854910612106, -0.013765738345682621, -0.030269118025898933, 0.0077221631072461605, -0.0003022924647666514, -0.05549158900976181, -0.005055303685367107, 0.004601724911481142, -0.035433217883110046, 0.06262476742267609, 0.030162151902914047, -0.07007554918527603, -0.01826717145740986, 0.0015060289297252893, -0.0013297871919348836, -0.058114465326070786, -0.05689931660890579, -0.030193835496902466, 0.0048585389740765095, 0.04180833697319031, -0.005375262815505266, -0.02194703370332718, 0.01530943252146244, 0.015184485353529453, -0.023725131526589394, -0.09458635747432709, -0.06600029021501541, -0.010134241543710232, 0.0186853539198637, 0.02166038192808628, -0.011924592778086662, 0.008493640460073948, -0.03526679053902626, -0.03435661643743515, 0.006667339242994785, 0.02091514877974987, 0.028850281611084938, -0.012001512572169304, 0.027833860367536545, 0.021715112030506134, 0.038520101457834244, 0.04396650195121765, -0.05138975381851196, 0.05781325325369835, 0.04101787135004997, -0.034892600029706955, 0.0070027136243879795, 0.00857979990541935, -0.0636693611741066, -0.05812305584549904, -0.0328044630587101, -0.0382259301841259, -0.060969460755586624, 0.050083670765161514, 0.0718788281083107, 0.007644055876880884, -0.012050561606884003, 0.05575953423976898, -0.0008517641690559685, -0.05544539913535118, 0.048479024320840836, 0.0016656152438372374, -0.025220947340130806, 0.007296327035874128, -0.009808002039790154, 0.007291468791663647, -0.002006121212616563, -0.020076479762792587, -0.025006048381328583, -0.027938449755311012, -0.0026304994244128466 ]
<p>Assuming you have container with heat insulation (something like boiler).<br> You can store water at any temperature <strong>below 100°C</strong>. At these conditions, you can drill a hole into container and <strong>store water at air pressure</strong>.<br> But when you heat water to tempertature <strong>over 100°C</strong>, it starts to boil, increasing pressure in contailner. If you drill a hole, water will start to evaporate and that'll cause temperature drop. If you try to maintain constant temperature, after some time <strong>all water will evaporate</strong>.<br> <strong>Water with temperature over 100°C can be stored only at high pressure?</strong><br> If so, it'll reach some pressure (depending on temperature) and stop boiling?<br> Are there any other risks besides high pressure to be aware when trying to store water at these conditions?</p>
g6651
[ 0.02423362247645855, 0.02324635721743107, 0.009729226119816303, 0.05891000106930733, -0.0010378170991316438, -0.0013865010114386678, -0.010411796160042286, 0.015104986727237701, -0.03520512580871582, 0.00423286110162735, -0.038787584751844406, -0.0005913322675041854, 0.014410190284252167, 0.02858855202794075, -0.0007283001905307174, 0.0011263287160545588, 0.015595623292028904, -0.0020170039497315884, 0.014864008873701096, 0.0026148331817239523, -0.02794823795557022, -0.01232092920690775, 0.033080704510211945, 0.03366909921169281, -0.07431778311729431, -0.008004754781723022, -0.013173160143196583, 0.003598253009840846, -0.02733059599995613, 0.0020022413227707148, -0.036334600299596786, -0.0017973445355892181, -0.03530963882803917, 0.02936716005206108, -0.01866231858730316, -0.11302143335342407, 0.03132276609539986, 0.010711262933909893, -0.019433721899986267, -0.05769116431474686, 0.015445074997842312, -0.008472942747175694, 0.02025679126381874, -0.01427252683788538, -0.006950889714062214, 0.03835827112197876, -0.008191482163965702, -0.025061622262001038, -0.02155155874788761, 0.0251711905002594, 0.05304021015763283, -0.03263574093580246, -0.005780862644314766, -0.03776155412197113, -0.01416193787008524, -0.033280353993177414, -0.0828574001789093, 0.022520629689097404, 0.01691252551972866, -0.03346186503767967, 0.002045807195827365, -0.03251475840806961, 0.011678828857839108, -0.005370077211409807, 0.01593797281384468, 0.0465092733502388, -0.09401921927928925, 0.013604652136564255, 0.023670390248298645, 0.06491358578205109, 0.053680334240198135, 0.01400713250041008, -0.0725189745426178, -0.05314277857542038, -0.014860033988952637, 0.01814381219446659, -0.004129674285650253, 0.0074553778395056725, 0.04084894061088562, 0.03578980639576912, -0.009544127620756626, 0.038794003427028656, 0.043649815022945404, 0.012397020123898983, -0.015773270279169083, -0.008680579252541065, 0.008264428935945034, 0.01586207188665867, 0.04180959612131119, 0.031161390244960785, -0.051017407327890396, -0.04218578338623047, 0.0622207336127758, 0.08543483912944794, 0.07324203103780746, 0.05482322350144386, 0.04461539536714554, 0.009791496209800243, 0.003829371416941285, 0.009311361238360405, 0.06296242028474808, -0.0528346449136734, 0.00499120494350791, 0.017023460939526558, -0.08113093674182892, 0.011483482085168362, 0.06073052063584328, 0.007883085869252682, -0.00864349864423275, -0.03295101225376129, 0.05658535659313202, 0.011669730767607689, -0.11494637280702591, -0.04174436628818512, -0.03879847750067711, 0.057132184505462646, 0.015122207812964916, 0.011234745383262634, -0.002480450551956892, -0.01979338750243187, 0.043544501066207886, 0.0523868128657341, 0.01126070786267519, 0.05633767694234848, 0.027752939611673355, 0.015834301710128784, -0.03496994450688362, -0.006827474571764469, -0.021327638998627663, 0.02239006757736206, -0.03351129963994026, 0.02165757678449154, -0.07742089033126831, 0.0045288195833563805, -0.00016660305846016854, 0.010993724688887596, -0.017807113006711006, 0.03288140147924423, -0.012531943619251251, 0.008341692388057709, 0.039034437388181686, 0.03176208958029747, -0.010669588111341, 0.04508938267827034, 0.01101524755358696, -0.050984106957912445, -0.019328860566020012, 0.02616771310567856, 0.00014321260096039623, 0.007606051862239838, -0.06179118528962135, 0.025057924911379814, 0.009704405441880226, 0.03177662938833237, 0.03837475925683975, 0.012526953592896461, -0.005846142303198576, -0.02520284615457058, 0.09409233182668686, 0.0663084164261818, 0.03812934458255768, 0.04736337438225746, 0.031987596303224564, 0.05661936476826668, -0.07300593703985214, -0.0050787609070539474, -0.023164482787251472, 0.02874232642352581, -0.002604336477816105, -0.0361349992454052, -0.05759790167212486, 0.05575491860508919, -0.020818503573536873, 0.0025460764300078154, 0.022153647616505623, -0.05402183532714844, 0.06800876557826996, 0.011481989175081253, -0.0177301038056612, -0.02107926830649376, -0.03531821072101593, 0.030865630134940147, -0.036126453429460526, -0.03614521026611328, -0.02416081167757511, 0.05481741949915886, 0.05653068423271179, 0.017134789377450943, -0.03602168336510658, 0.010384623892605305, 0.003206714754924178, -0.03508780151605606, -0.009616010822355747, 0.058344461023807526, 0.043998561799526215, -0.050240445882081985, 0.00967312790453434, -0.022352144122123718, -0.08253917843103409, -0.02102609910070896, -0.007587699219584465, -0.036156196147203445, 0.010260422714054585, 0.034510206431150436, -0.008673618547618389, 0.022227441892027855, -0.0697162076830864, 0.01567300781607628, -0.020998168736696243, -0.04682547226548195, 0.02161075919866562, 0.005360657349228859, -0.012858357280492783, 0.023581111803650856, 0.027506526559591293, 0.03539162874221802, 0.005416559986770153, 0.009484604932367802, -0.027178671211004257, 0.014481281861662865, -0.0012714428594335914, 0.0031133696902543306, -0.035146500915288925, 0.009595888666808605, -0.07962958514690399, 0.022873256355524063, -0.0751391351222992, 0.012604652903974056, 0.007900986820459366, 0.007792606949806213, -0.003376032691448927, 0.02384515106678009, 0.027953816577792168, -0.015289600938558578, -0.051459237933158875, 0.024816472083330154, 0.02597125619649887, 0.007418523542582989, 0.018571672961115837, 0.02071050927042961, 0.010925404727458954, 0.003096206346526742, -0.04019380360841751, 0.00468492554500699, 0.01723875105381012, -0.03269543871283531, -0.007690201047807932, -0.03233209252357483, 0.09373416006565094, 0.008906221948564053, 0.009637361392378807, -0.012798897922039032, 0.007528143003582954, 0.01936963014304638, -0.043295469135046005, -0.010705813765525818, 0.003494181903079152, 0.018165946006774902, -0.04699220880866051, -0.05719245225191116, 0.03112008608877659, -0.011243334040045738, 0.01235434040427208, -0.006503434851765633, 0.038136135786771774, 0.028456123545765877, -0.03416992351412773, 0.028779450803995132, 0.010823538526892662, 0.06629893183708191, 0.051830992102622986, 0.00369862443767488, -0.05417128652334213, 0.06598731875419617, -0.007065140176564455, -0.0020096362568438053, -0.02659740298986435, 0.004586962517350912, 0.043462373316287994, -0.044048093259334564, 0.0011075244983658195, -0.05101059377193451, 0.0022322337608784437, -0.008152049034833908, 0.0006527910009026527, -0.028156934306025505, 0.019020352512598038, 0.05190959572792053, -0.00857371836900711, -0.054707929491996765, 0.01869637332856655, 0.012408420443534851, -0.02667885273694992, 0.03968745470046997, 0.0437062606215477, 0.009819401428103447, -0.07684595137834549, -0.009943450801074505, -0.004478934686630964, -0.03636300936341286, 0.0025242227129638195, -0.018606653437018394, -0.009260236285626888, 0.015080577693879604, 0.03924207389354706, 0.013175610452890396, -0.014625110663473606, 0.005416059400886297, 0.004758534952998161, -0.05985400453209877, -0.04470513015985489, -0.016360197216272354, -0.017186319455504417, 0.016360415145754814, -0.02611764892935753, 0.02428559586405754, -0.017825422808527946, 0.0008190869702957571, 0.07629316300153732, -0.09478097409009933, 0.009234289638698101, 0.002393563510850072, 0.0025042707566171885, 0.011674690991640091, 0.02959960699081421, 0.09165096282958984, -0.03485674038529396, 0.007859215140342712, -0.07847649604082108, -0.03187065199017525, 0.01970706321299076, -0.00775474077090621, -0.010791785083711147, 0.02517106756567955, 0.031194085255265236, -0.013378341682255268, 0.04623033478856087, -0.025191480293869972, -0.0025853607803583145, 0.0020641745068132877, 0.08343856036663055, -0.020445549860596657, 0.0028297794051468372, -0.01858530193567276, 0.017500806599855423, -0.01428636908531189, 0.03782273083925247, -0.0035298725124448538, 0.008258523419499397, 0.04417914152145386, 0.07022827863693237, -0.05909671634435654, 0.037376295775175095, -0.022943314164876938, -0.0490880087018013, 0.013054690323770046, 0.017374422401189804, 0.02299770712852478, -0.009009087458252907, 0.04530470073223114, -0.019648315384984016, 0.002313639037311077, 0.035202909260988235, -0.014660746790468693, -0.013742751441895962, 0.03545486181974411, 0.018306303769350052, 0.02950317971408367, -0.052289269864559174, -0.03006390482187271, -0.004784951917827129, -0.032355498522520065, -0.034007806330919266, 0.034573543816804886, 0.04068637266755104, -0.01500240433961153, 0.03679930046200752, -0.005245921667665243, -0.011200028471648693, 0.041749268770217896, 0.03173191845417023, -0.04130266234278679, -0.017744362354278564, -0.027657445520162582, -0.01777227781713009, -0.06150238588452339, 0.06465394794940948, 0.038483139127492905, 0.039972275495529175, -0.029956171289086342, 0.04788679629564285, -0.04064446687698364, 0.08589664101600647, 0.016625814139842987, 0.04333801567554474, 0.0017266510985791683, -0.014162225648760796, 0.04114086553454399, -0.02614136040210724, -0.06304382532835007, 0.013083040714263916, -0.0473259836435318, 0.06002877280116081, -0.012854122556746006, -0.030507197603583336, -0.04020986706018448, 0.03533456474542618, 0.03335355594754219, -0.02247072570025921, -0.07248460501432419, 0.05961114913225174, -0.0039723701775074005, -0.060524001717567444, 0.040935371071100235, -0.01453317329287529, -0.07944277673959732, 0.013729846104979515, 0.04082765057682991, 0.023484613746404648, -0.012837251648306847, -0.011052356101572514, 0.013667131774127483, -0.04956788197159767, 0.00024444778682664037, 0.06160994619131088, -0.028353475034236908, -0.0076449159532785416, -0.05015285313129425, 0.013316232711076736, 0.018980789929628372, -0.02787591703236103, 0.02919459529221058, -0.03548466041684151, -0.019178012385964394, 0.04107922688126564, 0.03551320359110832, -0.025530466809868813, -0.05023296922445297, -0.046830713748931885, -0.003841657191514969, 0.009558480232954025, 0.005742446053773165, 0.052077777683734894, 0.010631678625941277, -0.03456522896885872, 0.08215419948101044, 0.007859032601118088, -0.014306393451988697, 0.05264444649219513, -0.04216925799846649, -0.05027075484395027, 0.05660927668213844, 0.03802911937236786, -0.03255461901426315, -0.006701285019516945, -0.01149918045848608, 0.025581443682312965, 0.012923878617584705, -0.04465867206454277, 0.04844781383872032, 0.01703067123889923, -0.025685949251055717, -0.010782497934997082, 0.00278676045127213, 0.016652911901474, -0.050058163702487946, -0.016659045591950417, -0.07341264933347702, 0.0011061688419431448, -0.015218349173665047, 0.005254777614027262, 0.07894287258386612, 0.03507494926452637, 0.05596877261996269, 0.07451082020998001, 0.07007782906293869, -0.03751548379659653, -0.043021731078624725, -0.05114273354411125, -0.05112273246049881, -0.010543199256062508, 0.013465330004692078, -0.033521659672260284, 0.024874256923794746, 0.0073244948871433735, -0.04377048835158348, 0.013566277921199799, -0.0010783191537484527, 0.059041570872068405, 0.025240479037165642, 0.025717103853821754, -0.0024729901924729347, 0.036053456366062164, 0.06203406676650047, -0.004523129668086767, -0.030167194083333015, 0.012130034156143665, 0.017329713329672813, -0.0058727990835905075, 0.018593406304717064, 0.01320224441587925, -0.03039940632879734, -0.009526929818093777, -0.01124329399317503, -0.0014980070991441607, 0.008175423368811607, -0.015292230062186718, 0.016033360734581947, 0.007511019241064787, 0.03188275545835495, 0.02609223686158657, 0.050804320722818375, -0.028970956802368164, -0.021358318626880646, 0.1163688376545906, -0.010158935561776161, -0.05192221328616142, -0.007770488038659096, -0.04975324869155884, -0.026760444045066833, -0.013663462363183498, -0.005961814429610968, 0.0019171233288943768, -0.01896330527961254, -0.02396736666560173, -0.008126812055706978, -0.060634054243564606, -0.04328714683651924, 0.028926465660333633, 0.020755695179104805, 0.09650171548128128, 0.04657290130853653, 0.038129959255456924, -0.029444163665175438, 0.029110627248883247, -0.01333942636847496, -0.0650537833571434, 0.008074114099144936, 0.07012396305799484, 0.07327087223529816, 0.04332020506262779, -0.008721916936337948, -0.03629510477185249, 0.041518960148096085, -0.03358820080757141, -0.05030576139688492, -0.06484133750200272, -0.012758605182170868, 0.02366049215197563, 0.01645577698945999, -0.007390379905700684, 0.04298153147101402, -0.047033924609422684, -0.02904999442398548, 0.043881140649318695, -0.06747319549322128, 0.005111182574182749, -0.02658209763467312, -0.01483581867069006, -0.0033102096058428288, -0.01947249472141266, 0.02448560856282711, 0.027286464348435402, 0.01699952408671379, -0.0015296988422051072, -0.00802711583673954, -0.04568187892436981, -0.013553843833506107, 0.02179528772830963, 0.06232098862528801, 0.05249960720539093, 0.0017822764348238707, 0.026700805872678757, -0.07160778343677521, -0.04009602591395378, -0.022310109809041023, -0.06776005029678345, 0.037520892918109894, 0.04075060412287712, -0.009481850080192089, -0.05897558480501175, -0.019391320645809174, -0.06331311911344528, 0.021561186760663986, -0.03532979637384415, -0.007598415482789278, -0.00854698196053505, -0.010619071312248707, 0.031512558460235596, 0.01373361423611641, -0.016156325116753578, 0.01101644802838564, 0.013000491075217724, 0.016322314739227295, 0.10712974518537521, 0.0026973385829478502, -0.004847291391342878, 0.02269996702671051, -0.03899557143449783, -0.022010838612914085, 0.014930143021047115, 0.04306800290942192, 0.044108156114816666, 0.0135397519916296, -0.04761591553688049, 0.024448368698358536, 0.0228760726749897, 0.060977451503276825, 0.021585581824183464, 0.02549656108021736, 0.004629957024008036, -0.017761148512363434, 0.04343128949403763, -0.011145949363708496, -0.018093552440404892, -0.082340769469738, 0.02472950518131256, 0.021136581897735596, -0.02927350252866745, -0.018426423892378807, 0.0428885817527771, 0.008979376405477524, -0.020081644877791405, -0.02401064708828926, 0.0002805162512231618, 0.005922493524849415, -0.013029194436967373, 0.012407930567860603, 0.046457819640636444, -0.06104087829589844, 0.013418988324701786, -0.014537124894559383, -0.026983199641108513, -0.03462418541312218, -0.05781342834234238, -0.012265753000974655, -0.056823790073394775, 0.04540606588125229, 0.007111736107617617, 0.0607987642288208, 0.02319011464715004, -0.023580830544233322, -0.008783528581261635, 0.007123890332877636, -0.01931471936404705, 0.030833657830953598, -0.023267490789294243, -0.02614077366888523, -0.05968986451625824, -0.01617581956088543, -0.013813412748277187, -0.04370115324854851, -0.06746447831392288, -0.03147786483168602, -0.019744114950299263, 0.027130872011184692, 0.019511962309479713, -0.029545610770583153, -0.033299483358860016, 0.013600443489849567, 0.012978645041584969, 0.001443567336536944, 0.021823257207870483, 0.025230126455426216, -0.013979713432490826, 0.032662611454725266, 0.024282781407237053, -0.0810462012887001, 0.028635818511247635, -0.020069759339094162, 0.017398715019226074, -0.01286348793655634, 0.015192762948572636, -0.07788196951150894, 0.01894989050924778, -0.007432455196976662, 0.0502353310585022, 0.04999668151140213, -0.015624729916453362, 0.034096427261829376, -0.06814906001091003, -0.019546890631318092, 0.0025620583910495043, -0.015314942225813866, 0.024206874892115593, -0.006448097061365843, -0.024255940690636635, -0.02717779017984867, 0.044810980558395386, -0.05910325050354004, -0.04919305816292763, 0.00022146131959743798, 0.061564989387989044, -0.006977428216487169, -0.013480076566338539, -0.0018795933574438095, 0.045408859848976135, -0.020682021975517273, 0.0003057889989577234, -0.0358671173453331, -0.026484092697501183, 0.04125317186117172, 0.07566976547241211, -0.03178922459483147, 0.023849692195653915, 0.04831951856613159, -0.017592864111065865, 0.05159991234540939, -0.04145491495728493, 0.02786407805979252, 0.05097295716404915, 0.04117929935455322, 0.040968962013721466, -0.06837542355060577, -0.02600165829062462, -0.010173696093261242, -0.05658843740820885, -0.08737685531377792, -0.022567816078662872, -0.017578249797225, -0.05805679038167, -0.01958511397242546, -0.025485243648290634, 0.010524147190153599, 0.030466344207525253, 0.016267333179712296, 0.005552561488002539, -0.008456805720925331, -0.05648847296833992, -0.02441568858921528, -0.03551023453474045, -0.005899531301110983, -0.05051156133413315, 0.03048378974199295, 0.02858228236436844, -0.014314697124063969, 0.04905502125620842, 0.028985116630792618, -0.020586920902132988, 0.012112978845834732, 0.0067055197432637215, 0.054370928555727005, 0.006922802422195673, -0.013533871620893478, 0.021307969465851784, -0.026039930060505867, -0.011891062371432781, -0.015176810324192047, -0.013154062442481518, 0.002561017405241728, -0.03205830231308937, -0.02570350654423237, -0.03609636798501015, -0.013015108183026314, -0.022520901635289192, -0.05181402713060379, -0.025422193109989166, 0.011589739471673965, 0.015645548701286316, -0.06739791482686996, -0.006367370951920748, 0.03213251754641533, -0.038244593888521194, -0.036305177956819534, 0.046324290335178375, -0.009795185178518295, -0.03851763904094696, -0.05744398385286331 ]
<p>Need help in understanding the direction of magnetic force in the magnetic field!Totally confused by directions.</p> <p>Why is it that magnetic force is perpendicular to the direction of magnetic field and velocity of charged particle. Why is it(force) not in the same direction as the magnetuc field</p>
g6652
[ 0.014354052022099495, 0.027517113834619522, -0.013795237988233566, 0.006213229149580002, 0.089993417263031, 0.04479372873902321, 0.002825644798576832, 0.029730597510933876, -0.02601042203605175, -0.04362841695547104, 0.016507940366864204, 0.02655922621488571, -0.02573975920677185, -0.021102100610733032, 0.012599700130522251, 0.04445575550198555, 0.060521624982357025, 0.012430809438228607, 0.020264966413378716, 0.02329053170979023, -0.022990545257925987, 0.03774946555495262, -0.0007416162407025695, -0.007848531939089298, 0.034214086830616, -0.04321770742535591, -0.030814064666628838, -0.079442098736763, -0.004768475890159607, -0.03696679696440697, 0.06771087646484375, 0.00761566823348403, 0.05886493995785713, -0.08678814768791199, -0.024272236973047256, -0.03847610577940941, 0.04728361591696739, 0.056268975138664246, 0.02567506954073906, 0.008236750960350037, 0.0012219795025885105, 0.0015635995659977198, 0.043973058462142944, -0.01880493201315403, 0.0037385961040854454, 0.019832776859402657, -0.0729941576719284, -0.033984530717134476, -0.0584111250936985, -0.016245895996689796, -0.03333372622728348, -0.02200334705412388, 0.029481174424290657, 0.020008528605103493, -0.030589846894145012, 0.027200182899832726, 0.06914038956165314, -0.03566516935825348, 0.04227829724550247, 0.03193163499236107, 0.03650444746017456, 0.07958833128213882, -0.014404387213289738, 0.002132660709321499, -0.016347993165254593, -0.07061569392681122, -0.017352566123008728, 0.04501723870635033, -0.007830467075109482, 0.0019493559375405312, -0.0053832740522921085, -0.07604934275150299, 0.025307374075055122, -0.05498490855097771, -0.03632291778922081, -0.050936926156282425, 0.05868292599916458, -0.02671286277472973, 0.01948707364499569, -0.04482472315430641, 0.009741811081767082, -0.008672502823174, 0.02416257932782173, -0.006017701234668493, 0.08400260657072067, -0.07166695594787598, 0.010145356878638268, 0.03710753470659256, 0.03346696123480797, -0.044502489268779755, -0.04126150161027908, 0.010760234668850899, 0.048077795654535294, 0.05730670690536499, -0.018145019188523293, -0.06350113451480865, -0.01187067199498415, 0.0616510845720768, 0.006232374347746372, 0.04002503678202629, -0.005604507401585579, 0.013283169828355312, -0.0037472746334969997, 0.01605825498700142, 0.009753381833434105, -0.050261106342077255, 0.04110293835401535, 0.07211300730705261, -0.00012616554158739746, -0.03568795323371887, -0.0548093318939209, -0.005980517249554396, -0.002054881304502487, 0.023713165894150734, 0.027074452489614487, -0.029726002365350723, 0.02716253511607647, -0.0279995147138834, 0.023054398596286774, 0.029728081077337265, -0.01243661344051361, 0.0038220405112951994, 0.005436800420284271, -0.0032040816731750965, -0.027181340381503105, -0.052584223449230194, -0.022253038361668587, 0.024489156901836395, -0.023863237351179123, -0.07391621917486191, 0.04482570290565491, -0.02405206859111786, 0.019887374714016914, 0.025409147143363953, -0.02457876317203045, 0.003905927063897252, 0.005758898798376322, 0.057804469019174576, 0.04889264330267906, -0.02832738496363163, 0.022911829873919487, 0.006689269095659256, 0.04458368942141533, -0.013058346696197987, -0.05803750827908516, -0.013215100392699242, 0.011393586173653603, -0.06264085322618484, 0.09174059331417084, -0.024295510724186897, 0.046947088092565536, 0.037685707211494446, -0.03254853934049606, -0.0053520905785262585, 0.013829580508172512, -0.03955443948507309, 0.05318208038806915, 0.03297189250588417, 0.0031926834490150213, -0.022801440209150314, 0.0014953130157664418, 0.024647889658808708, -0.007834713906049728, 0.004747758619487286, -0.03140914440155029, -0.011560549959540367, 0.05855480581521988, -0.01629273220896721, 0.0028617680072784424, 0.01856350526213646, -0.030003657564520836, -0.004316007252782583, -0.003996949177235365, 0.06940304487943649, -0.0003812369250226766, 0.038720421493053436, -0.04540760815143585, -0.031109519302845, -0.014998607337474823, 0.03543398156762123, -0.003836067160591483, 0.010271945036947727, 0.05726490914821625, -0.025705227628350258, -0.02495921030640602, -0.031146060675382614, -0.025824714452028275, 0.07154371589422226, 0.0021775865461677313, 0.04564312845468521, -0.04261630401015282, 0.02314622513949871, -0.05214469134807587, 0.040526703000068665, 0.005372297018766403, -0.033463288098573685, -0.0014706089859828353, 0.010420102626085281, -0.014968665316700935, 0.0037372438237071037, -0.05714511126279831, -0.0033934793900698423, 0.05208945646882057, 0.04057193174958229, -0.000006320599823084194, -0.026523642241954803, 0.025996556505560875, 0.028459545224905014, 0.0549452006816864, 0.03120049461722374, 0.013114961795508862, -0.0021053061354905367, 0.026773586869239807, -0.01608300767838955, -0.01806253008544445, -0.002697078278288245, 0.01618053764104843, 0.0009564705542288721, -0.028995729982852936, -0.02454206347465515, -0.02652909606695175, -0.03908015415072441, 0.06281132251024246, -0.021761657670140266, -0.06098020449280739, -0.027482377365231514, -0.0034062517806887627, -0.018085621297359467, -0.00808879267424345, -0.016307638958096504, -0.03687076270580292, 0.012146491557359695, 0.009391008876264095, 0.02684234268963337, 0.06757504492998123, 0.027019398286938667, 0.0032783562783151865, 0.011678779497742653, -0.013634984381496906, -0.058477647602558136, -0.05697513744235039, 0.013305377215147018, 0.06082458421587944, -0.0314168818295002, -0.00009167360258288682, 0.005772556643933058, 0.0892781913280487, -0.027274886146187782, 0.01485030073672533, 0.0034051642287522554, 0.028451036661863327, -0.011535369791090488, -0.004532074090093374, 0.00391777791082859, 0.03739066421985626, 0.0034786334726959467, -0.06939589977264404, 0.01536629255861044, -0.07171370089054108, -0.0732511579990387, -0.03784027695655823, -0.045044783502817154, 0.06039689481258392, 0.08595868200063705, -0.03125806525349617, 0.015910722315311432, -0.012098596431314945, 0.05494332313537598, 0.09514274448156357, -0.039514027535915375, 0.006737083662301302, 0.06444954127073288, 0.01833207532763481, -0.021397821605205536, 0.025911033153533936, -0.03146159648895264, 0.007327658124268055, 0.004862890113145113, -0.005262627732008696, -0.03582567349076271, -0.0335598848760128, 0.03534817695617676, 0.015547562390565872, -0.0300966314971447, -0.01049825083464384, 0.008686551824212074, -0.0033186848741024733, -0.05367468670010567, -0.01157717127352953, -0.014474404975771904, -0.05615350604057312, -0.016258716583251953, 0.051589611917734146, -0.0681706964969635, -0.0004414677096065134, -0.007836882956326008, 0.046568818390369415, -0.0007413927232846618, -0.06979720294475555, 0.04260222241282463, 0.0054514664225280285, -0.0033622898627072573, -0.020424509420990944, 0.014546718448400497, 0.027120215818285942, -0.01010992843657732, -0.01753777451813221, -0.0852009728550911, -0.036718692630529404, 0.05906409025192261, -0.03481975570321083, 0.0519770085811615, -0.003449300304055214, 0.004123310092836618, -0.023550087586045265, -0.023925045505166054, -0.07092028856277466, 0.03711463883519173, -0.013082877732813358, 0.013921619392931461, -0.04746151342988014, -0.05987900123000145, -0.004615894518792629, 0.02973128668963909, 0.022484462708234787, 0.017688177525997162, -0.03623334690928459, -0.00795028917491436, -0.032015781849622726, -0.03269613906741142, 0.006972129922360182, 0.0009168102405965328, 0.038302160799503326, -0.003218994941562414, -0.08786480128765106, 0.021761104464530945, 0.004689205437898636, -0.02416829951107502, 0.012033239006996155, -0.000007504173026973149, 0.04563003033399582, -0.051693473011255264, -0.0346984937787056, 0.02584400214254856, -0.021943144500255585, 0.03498387709259987, 0.05666583776473999, -0.015333279967308044, 0.04485630616545677, 0.04161472246050835, 0.031958483159542084, 0.01050823274999857, 0.004506903700530529, 0.020907428115606308, -0.012938489206135273, -0.022036448121070862, 0.024317020550370216, 0.02906731702387333, -0.048393528908491135, 0.032680775970220566, 0.02031378448009491, 0.004737926181405783, -0.03759569302201271, 0.016992788761854172, -0.03813527524471283, 0.026120809838175774, 0.043740883469581604, -0.0041688913479447365, -0.05837727710604668, -0.019884632900357246, -0.005788406357169151, -0.055676452815532684, 0.00349604245275259, -0.02539706602692604, -0.04630381613969803, -0.05733140558004379, -0.0017634113319218159, -0.03827811777591705, 0.010069714859127998, -0.012233810499310493, 0.0014404802350327373, -0.00849908497184515, -0.0035520431119948626, 0.007644318044185638, -0.005648882128298283, 0.04150386154651642, -0.009090801700949669, 0.059418052434921265, 0.020733928307890892, 0.007716627325862646, -0.012739033438265324, -0.0056570968590676785, -0.029210172593593597, 0.02265140414237976, -0.00502495002001524, -0.02746857888996601, -0.04349402338266373, 0.015729349106550217, -0.06138831004500389, -0.030409902334213257, 0.012315886095166206, -0.03491050377488136, -0.034434571862220764, -0.014427559450268745, -0.01045203860849142, 0.0991392582654953, -0.0013220316031947732, -0.018277691677212715, 0.022553203627467155, -0.03262060508131981, 0.060177989304065704, -0.02660953626036644, -0.020724939182400703, -0.029683688655495644, 0.055716127157211304, -0.011534983292222023, -0.016959408298134804, 0.09003797918558121, 0.02053995430469513, -0.038504939526319504, 0.07886950671672821, 0.01963588036596775, 0.018996387720108032, -0.042131323367357254, 0.003403429174795747, 0.06078675016760826, 0.024619290605187416, -0.0008932098862715065, -0.011585798114538193, 0.008045135997235775, -0.016247084364295006, 0.056510016322135925, 0.025210421532392502, -0.009918482042849064, -0.05816708877682686, 0.042141277343034744, 0.009200330823659897, 0.038900963962078094, 0.02193952538073063, 0.035273514688014984, 0.012215553782880306, 0.07077722996473312, 0.055775754153728485, -0.04678205028176308, -0.06208847463130951, 0.011962422169744968, -0.02374396286904812, -0.014736495912075043, -0.01673746667802334, -0.031600549817085266, 0.0019143930403515697, 0.04182817414402962, -0.11629433929920197, -0.01109961699694395, -0.03151395171880722, -0.0032144682481884956, -0.00399125786498189, -0.040538255125284195, 0.0018635679734870791, 0.0011357334442436695, -0.03234296664595604, 0.004539181012660265, -0.011188148520886898, 0.011454838328063488, -0.032817427068948746, -0.006560957990586758, 0.008304321207106113, -0.01565883308649063, -0.04688739404082298, 0.06447318196296692, 0.005304322112351656, 0.017175469547510147, -0.0030355583876371384, -0.025175413116812706, 0.05446489155292511, 0.014246055856347084, 0.006293074693530798, -0.013214911334216595, 0.0004515083855949342, 0.007419583387672901, -0.0142684830352664, -0.03876885399222374, 0.069343701004982, -0.005021483171731234, -0.02477453090250492, -0.02436053566634655, 0.017184758558869362, 0.05139809474349022, 0.034654438495635986, -0.05120326206088066, -0.012209540233016014, 0.0427202545106411, -0.04883558303117752, -0.018877265974879265, 0.01838664337992668, -0.007103923242539167, -0.06942560523748398, 0.021759362891316414, 0.012901602312922478, -0.04216114059090614, -0.02723785489797592, -0.06552896648645401, -0.004427958745509386, 0.007719587069004774, -0.02504492923617363, 0.0542914979159832, 0.06374889612197876, -0.0076008946634829044, 0.00252058869227767, -0.012852064333856106, 0.00990210846066475, 0.020721346139907837, 0.06265252828598022, -0.04514317214488983, 0.003955371677875519, 0.008213396184146404, 0.036274127662181854, 0.061944760382175446, 0.052583277225494385, 0.008708965964615345, 0.030393052846193314, 0.026909688487648964, 0.007594936527311802, -0.030497970059514046, 0.011009312234818935, -0.03477730602025986, -0.028913529589772224, 0.042927682399749756, 0.05035622790455818, 0.012635333463549614, -0.02273300662636757, 0.02513492852449417, 0.05817147344350815, -0.012334064580500126, -0.05108063295483589, -0.07483576238155365, 0.07308407127857208, -0.09731883555650711, 0.015141691081225872, -0.012773394584655762, 0.00408434122800827, -0.024989807978272438, 0.017636330798268318, -0.0044372715055942535, -0.07432565838098526, 0.05285362899303436, -0.007000181823968887, -0.03097730129957199, 0.03823255002498627, -0.0790223702788353, -0.041304100304841995, 0.0337090827524662, -0.003651420818641782, -0.037234481424093246, 0.011540377512574196, -0.039037566632032394, -0.007695751264691353, -0.030491573736071587, 0.0033440550323575735, -0.014957226812839508, 0.060371872037649155, -0.06745550036430359, -0.016411131247878075, 0.012548045255243778, 0.024061139672994614, 0.008212228305637836, -0.01790076121687889, -0.013698765076696873, 0.05211891606450081, 0.02753746695816517, -0.025270264595746994, -0.02370707504451275, -0.05419037863612175, 0.06395018100738525, 0.09279163181781769, 0.045469433069229126, 0.014300057664513588, -0.019493279978632927, -0.0758560448884964, 0.034038033336400986, 0.07835206389427185, 0.021976163610816002, 0.004111345391720533, -0.013574027456343174, 0.001282283803448081, 0.07078805565834045, -0.0484396331012249, 0.047665636986494064, 0.06835397332906723, -0.054767463356256485, 0.001741182990372181, 0.010402399115264416, 0.014440384693443775, -0.004651047755032778, -0.07571949064731598, 0.011846291832625866, -0.005724411923438311, 0.02180420234799385, 0.0030687961261719465, 0.03170725330710411, -0.06042858958244324, -0.0013633152702823281, -0.09594954550266266, 0.018372809514403343, 0.0368560366332531, -0.00545220822095871, 0.01069777924567461, 0.016453124582767487, -0.05418914183974266, -0.014146139845252037, -0.025371870025992393, 0.00494268536567688, -0.04794231057167053, -0.007409923244267702, 0.03563105687499046, -0.004112219903618097, -0.02539394237101078, -0.04362916201353073, -0.023793574422597885, 0.02551109343767166, 0.0029372056014835835, -0.005496799014508724, -0.007175202015787363, -0.01575019583106041, 0.03564805909991264, 0.00709370244294405, -0.026972219347953796, 0.03762191906571388, 0.024931568652391434, -0.00339300069026649, 0.02513018622994423, -0.01684415712952614, 0.0019080584170296788, 0.027609942480921745, 0.06474968045949936, 0.0014532277127727866, 0.011964072473347187, 0.002757695969194174, 0.005186048336327076, 0.06457779556512833, -0.007442719303071499, 0.006673616357147694, -0.0038111500907689333, -0.03770165517926216, -0.021075958386063576, -0.0021343862172216177, -0.01370785292237997, 0.03922412917017937, -0.032996442168951035, 0.019553881138563156, -0.06936653703451157, 0.03143274039030075, 0.052944380789995193, -0.0025741129647940397, 0.00823222380131483, 0.027792630717158318, 0.03272673487663269, 0.004339282400906086, -0.004561918321996927, -0.0541827529668808, -0.029239626601338387, 0.02537132240831852, -0.03825732320547104, 0.004289598204195499, -0.02507402002811432, 0.02127332054078579, -0.03830147534608841, 0.02166222408413887, 0.03256857395172119, -0.055403709411621094, -0.013675183057785034, -0.012247749604284763, -0.01126887183636427, -0.02709922008216381, -0.034154195338487625, 0.023220879957079887, -0.04396677762269974, 0.05792829394340515, 0.002982750767841935, -0.025928771123290062, -0.02543981745839119, 0.05314578860998154, -0.0032205332536250353, -0.033254560083150864, 0.012512889690697193, -0.06408771872520447, 0.028789576143026352, -0.0019928414840251207, 0.007956248708069324, -0.017905045300722122, -0.00012723184772767127, 0.020915845409035683, 0.060193922370672226, -0.0014059528475627303, -0.01945733278989792, 0.004180495161563158, 0.0007463741931132972, 0.05721981078386307, 0.04447281360626221, 0.01532236859202385, -0.014449362643063068, -0.0427262969315052, 0.01664835773408413, 0.0008637438295409083, -0.007306645158678293, -0.006751710083335638, 0.008831602521240711, 0.06905947625637054, -0.049618493765592575, -0.02941828966140747, -0.025083184242248535, 0.0057310424745082855, 0.013272560201585293, -0.007251111324876547, 0.023763181641697884, 0.01151452399790287, -0.018496548756957054, 0.06814165413379669, -0.017399286851286888, -0.052516110241413116, 0.029226941987872124, -0.016648391261696815, 0.005340774077922106, -0.03519602119922638, -0.05726286768913269, -0.021182728931307793, -0.00367446755990386, 0.037974707782268524, 0.012754330411553383, -0.028511052951216698, 0.0165717676281929, 0.04455362260341644, -0.030884526669979095, -0.0488012433052063, -0.021805696189403534, 0.03807364031672478, 0.005575858056545258, -0.06010103225708008, 0.04598382115364075, -0.05205731838941574, 0.06128089874982834, -0.01944253034889698, -0.03384256362915039, -0.025286303833127022, -0.07186610996723175, -0.021443713456392288, -0.06430558115243912, 0.022464102134108543, 0.008393400348722935, 0.008518505841493607, 0.05317072942852974, 0.033114612102508545, 0.01817028969526291, 0.01490041520446539, 0.000327732355799526, -0.056595202535390854, 0.04637138172984123, 0.07495900988578796, 0.004395592957735062, -0.041448235511779785, -0.00904888566583395, 0.0017539623659104109, 0.03681841492652893, -0.0022588386200368404, 0.04388086870312691, 0.024660397320985794, -0.09416119009256363, -0.008829199708998203 ]
<p>I know that if two air bubbles which are formed inside a liquid are somehow joined using something (say a small tube), then, as the bubble with the larger radius has less pressure and the one with the smaller radius has more air pressure, air will flow to the larger bubble from the smaller bubble as the excess pressure inside the smaller bubble is greater.</p> <p>But will we be able to quantitatively calculate the time taken for this to happen?</p> <p>If so then what is the relation connecting time and every other variable?</p>
g6653
[ 0.05291192606091499, -0.00036051389179192483, -0.004223006311804056, 0.028457337990403175, -0.00848881620913744, 0.08019773662090302, 0.016047921031713486, 0.007433564402163029, -0.06299249827861786, -0.02475038915872574, -0.05014685168862343, -0.00043360484414733946, -0.028333498165011406, 0.001975847175344825, 0.004042487591505051, -0.02871454320847988, 0.039741162210702896, 0.010502811521291733, -0.04400395601987839, 0.00882717128843069, 0.014652810990810394, -0.005003285128623247, 0.018988775089383125, -0.03357740119099617, -0.07404188066720963, -0.05524028092622757, 0.011451161466538906, 0.013434560969471931, -0.05929978936910629, 0.01247584167867899, 0.014347121119499207, 0.044620972126722336, 0.03485693782567978, -0.05337826535105705, -0.017504030838608742, -0.03816020116209984, -0.04715506732463837, 0.01691974326968193, -0.0009700463269837201, -0.0007768390350975096, 0.027185361832380295, 0.05417827144265175, -0.009925245307385921, 0.01275279838591814, -0.050747163593769073, -0.004319646395742893, 0.008417281322181225, 0.040626410394907, 0.00539037212729454, -0.03429841250181198, -0.015884196385741234, 0.05176901817321777, -0.03647991642355919, 0.03917370364069939, 0.011641782708466053, 0.04193456470966339, 0.07291301339864731, -0.035985223948955536, 0.04132765159010887, 0.06262023001909256, -0.02622193470597267, -0.02680765464901924, -0.004013724159449339, 0.05321625992655754, 0.04612041264772415, 0.04374277591705322, -0.03684600070118904, -0.06277011334896088, 0.061663709580898285, 0.021949877962470055, -0.05630936846137047, -0.050824761390686035, 0.005072483327239752, -0.0634084939956665, -0.049993470311164856, 0.020548345521092415, 0.011788050644099712, -0.01382732018828392, -0.004754603374749422, 0.0007568751461803913, 0.04297995567321777, 0.008900856599211693, 0.002285178517922759, 0.056522950530052185, 0.05640510469675064, -0.013413089327514172, -0.007317651994526386, -0.02411572076380253, -0.03561163321137428, 0.025586742907762527, 0.019857486709952354, -0.03608536720275879, 0.06819616258144379, 0.0033035920932888985, -0.007471892982721329, -0.019818555563688278, -0.0417100191116333, 0.01710488833487034, -0.02906091883778572, -0.00627564312890172, -0.0007493874290958047, 0.005246223881840706, 0.009725560434162617, 0.007303421385586262, -0.08640200644731522, -0.002273903926834464, 0.01887211576104164, 0.002687020692974329, -0.03141370788216591, 0.004789118189364672, -0.039147987961769104, -0.010216085240244865, -0.04366229474544525, 0.047923799604177475, 0.007976521737873554, -0.0218502264469862, -0.020217567682266235, -0.04615982621908188, -0.01027186680585146, 0.01657205820083618, 0.007552814204245806, 0.02159951813519001, 0.004383330699056387, 0.028441255912184715, -0.0033253722358494997, -0.006559772416949272, -0.004978245589882135, 0.08840028196573257, 0.03183583915233612, 0.0420856811106205, 0.03520793095231056, -0.02722328156232834, 0.03129873797297478, -0.017847940325737, -0.04386548697948456, 0.024398498237133026, -0.052959755063056946, 0.0036115194670856, -0.02893056720495224, -0.004118236713111401, -0.024355405941605568, -0.024144405499100685, 0.007991272024810314, 0.01581559330224991, -0.0754871666431427, 0.03861352801322937, -0.013874168507754803, -0.004644016269594431, -0.02913922630250454, -0.0007533961324952543, -0.0056977239437401295, 0.0029428075067698956, 0.010078709572553635, -0.006157419178634882, 0.03086821548640728, 0.061692290008068085, -0.030103549361228943, -0.049083054065704346, 0.04055667668581009, 0.000564179674256593, 0.021070081740617752, -0.024711446836590767, 0.0466294139623642, -0.016305191442370415, -0.0733635276556015, 0.027755621820688248, 0.05359803885221481, -0.03202899545431137, 0.006104279309511185, -0.054502420127391815, -0.010767652653157711, -0.06953876465559006, -0.012538043782114983, 0.019345907494425774, 0.042314715683460236, 0.06419298052787781, 0.05274537578225136, -0.024503318592905998, -0.03144882991909981, 0.01602192409336567, 0.006645594257861376, 0.015855200588703156, 0.004099498502910137, -0.04447215050458908, -0.007932687178254128, 0.028756624087691307, 0.019905241206288338, -0.04509354382753372, -0.07256605476140976, -0.03165363147854805, -0.038987088948488235, -0.009144962765276432, 0.04123171046376228, 0.05202987790107727, -0.04088776931166649, 0.0020991256460547447, 0.06662849336862564, -0.029057303443551064, -0.06006753444671631, 0.03362308442592621, -0.04931197315454483, 0.04156521335244179, 0.04898867383599281, 0.000719048548489809, 0.063560351729393, 0.061029233038425446, -0.01423674263060093, 0.015578905120491982, 0.003316726768389344, 0.07172752916812897, 0.016574088484048843, 0.028264617547392845, 0.004064652603119612, 0.007521939929574728, -0.010019625537097454, -0.034046296030282974, -0.027278145775198936, -0.026946790516376495, 0.005927844438701868, 0.03292073309421539, -0.008960962295532227, 0.003585915779694915, 0.017319269478321075, -0.03957124054431915, 0.01865139603614807, -0.04343768209218979, 0.008498548530042171, -0.033410631120204926, -0.0065338509157299995, -0.025567159056663513, -0.03512134775519371, 0.03084622137248516, 0.010467111133038998, -0.026680536568164825, -0.0563727468252182, 0.07499255985021591, 0.04034668579697609, 0.06464377045631409, -0.016891740262508392, 0.027169641107320786, 0.03241357579827309, -0.04696245118975639, -0.03469756990671158, 0.09318994730710983, -0.001002162811346352, 0.03495194762945175, 0.02510266751050949, -0.04241470620036125, -0.030922474339604378, 0.08632483333349228, -0.053947269916534424, 0.04029277339577675, -0.0426359660923481, -0.01728234812617302, -0.017621764913201332, -0.004300146829336882, 0.029723182320594788, 0.040981877595186234, -0.038603924214839935, -0.03106553666293621, 0.0012650109129026532, -0.0019310333300381899, -0.0020008038263767958, -0.030442358925938606, -0.07289743423461914, 0.0012082192115485668, 0.016143284738063812, 0.009422323666512966, -0.01689690165221691, -0.00396526837721467, -0.012951971031725407, 0.010686121881008148, -0.027406666427850723, 0.003405851311981678, 0.029845552518963814, -0.04955010116100311, -0.0015942761674523354, -0.02839607372879982, -0.018264491111040115, -0.01625894196331501, -0.030861251056194305, -0.042757466435432434, -0.09976650774478912, 0.01053330022841692, 0.0035783604253083467, -0.05389266461133957, 0.03720076382160187, 0.07240357995033264, 0.02984800562262535, 0.0059867072850465775, 0.018884852528572083, 0.0036950912326574326, 0.00944356620311737, 0.013801591470837593, 0.05410172417759895, 0.08080510795116425, 0.059600524604320526, 0.028760045766830444, 0.0037755435332655907, -0.047234270721673965, -0.057231172919273376, -0.012426118366420269, 0.008350237272679806, 0.0170893594622612, 0.018616795539855957, -0.004844880662858486, -0.05547114834189415, -0.012035921216011047, -0.03281751275062561, -0.0021571002434939146, 0.04566212370991707, 0.03085457906126976, -0.00731866667047143, 0.002603760687634349, -0.022579066455364227, -0.03293626755475998, 0.010662935674190521, 0.060542091727256775, -0.0005727636744268239, 0.018589889630675316, -0.009299315512180328, -0.057369690388441086, -0.005841018632054329, -0.03071223385632038, 0.03735385462641716, -0.04719087854027748, -0.03786666318774223, 0.022497396916151047, -0.06736081093549728, 0.010694161988794804, -0.0317285880446434, -0.013176080770790577, -0.02086004614830017, -0.011357870884239674, -0.029028886929154396, 0.0029216224793344736, -0.003263175254687667, -0.006099015939980745, -0.0005612043896690011, 0.025116657838225365, 0.017513088881969452, -0.011408444494009018, -0.02302924357354641, 0.012519989162683487, 0.004323160741478205, 0.028570979833602905, 0.01142210140824318, 0.044224321842193604, 0.03430378809571266, -0.0014785077655687928, 0.025073189288377762, 0.002396530006080866, 0.004451428540050983, -0.06726394593715668, 0.014989051036536694, 0.03812194988131523, 0.032514650374650955, 0.012503212317824364, 0.028224991634488106, -0.066848024725914, 0.0220616664737463, -0.03010481223464012, 0.01074634213000536, 0.07800114899873734, -0.06565432995557785, -0.050638843327760696, 0.028527338057756424, 0.023975059390068054, -0.016455262899398804, -0.03481640666723251, -0.042136356234550476, 0.031018704175949097, -0.018824458122253418, -0.0006588195101357996, 0.035611849278211594, -0.04611861705780029, 0.061667315661907196, -0.040169838815927505, 0.011498413980007172, 0.030267488211393356, 0.05839269980788231, 0.05706923454999924, -0.006248271558433771, -0.0014113489305600524, 0.03606375306844711, -0.03480330482125282, -0.05228172615170479, 0.004131294321268797, 0.01256717462092638, -0.10749725997447968, -0.016952725127339363, -0.05030505731701851, -0.041391558945178986, -0.0032135110814124346, -0.00458489079028368, -0.009520306251943111, 0.014921926893293858, 0.028166579082608223, -0.00024283028324134648, -0.01839587651193142, -0.035625409334897995, -0.04637554660439491, -0.03982250764966011, 0.0347873717546463, -0.012195906601846218, 0.026266619563102722, 0.050554998219013214, -0.0017660033190622926, -0.028376998379826546, -0.008903414011001587, 0.017939891666173935, -0.04364514350891113, 0.04197853058576584, -0.04323486238718033, 0.018927985802292824, -0.02752373367547989, -0.013861196115612984, -0.027209172025322914, 0.0047356183640658855, 0.016375472769141197, 0.00752910366281867, -0.011424252763390541, 0.04667830467224121, -0.02103562280535698, 0.00635620066896081, 0.02686285972595215, 0.03784344345331192, 0.02083420567214489, -0.012268017046153545, -0.030559005215764046, -0.04421757906675339, 0.03914358839392662, -0.060297273099422455, 0.0054656872525811195, -0.023205868899822235, 0.009374505840241909, -0.011035491712391376, 0.05421553924679756, 0.04151077941060066, 0.003934135194867849, 0.028398094698786736, -0.011304153129458427, 0.01077120378613472, -0.004798769950866699, 0.059956036508083344, 0.056442759931087494, -0.014585692435503006, -0.050371259450912476, -0.026341766119003296, -0.06407288461923599, 0.005308622494339943, 0.04668896645307541, 0.02348426729440689, -0.02332659251987934, -0.02588888257741928, -0.0045839776284992695, 0.0015097821597009897, 0.039055462926626205, 0.009307147935032845, 0.014295181259512901, -0.057492636144161224, 0.05392804369330406, 0.02340591885149479, 0.03369664400815964, 0.011587720364332199, -0.09666363149881363, 0.014678205363452435, -0.034187451004981995, -0.07386516034603119, 0.05338180810213089, 0.004049889277666807, 0.03386237844824791, 0.01272420771420002, 0.09565966576337814, 0.028224727138876915, 0.0067940750159323215, -0.037326350808143616, 0.019672948867082596, 0.09427181631326675, -0.06575046479701996, -0.0017085239524021745, 0.014472674578428268, -0.009500941261649132, 0.009149639867246151, 0.036037199199199677, 0.002670848509296775, -0.0534246452152729, -0.007163798902183771, 0.044746410101652145, 0.021570054814219475, 0.012517809867858887, 0.015503674745559692, 0.05774068087339401, 0.024051159620285034, -0.06567935645580292, -0.015069611370563507, -0.023846542462706566, -0.020706290379166603, 0.017881980165839195, -0.01724795624613762, -0.026694752275943756, 0.06665702909231186, 0.0295161884278059, -0.0022436981089413166, 0.00048275766312144697, 0.0477072149515152, -0.015005411580204964, 0.029255883768200874, -0.04172927886247635, 0.07485909759998322, -0.019185425713658333, 0.016803592443466187, -0.031126726418733597, 0.012708602473139763, -0.02399872988462448, -0.01437817420810461, -0.030714120715856552, -0.016381725668907166, -0.029524900019168854, -0.03097769431769848, 0.07654251903295517, -0.0028932136483490467, 0.008651519194245338, -0.011594509705901146, -0.025693243369460106, -0.002082153921946883, -0.03817678615450859, 0.004271872341632843, 0.03528914228081703, -0.04520643875002861, -0.03297927603125572, -0.033959560096263885, -0.0012624847004190087, 0.021017318591475487, -0.00003271522291470319, -0.011097063310444355, 0.019271252676844597, -0.004670056980103254, 0.05356211960315704, -0.004371627699583769, -0.06040449067950249, 0.006159151438623667, -0.02181319147348404, 0.07403264194726944, 0.016643555834889412, -0.023120557889342308, -0.007221599575132132, 0.0338108204305172, 0.022667773067951202, 0.013251724652945995, 0.008165277540683746, -0.0381016843020916, -0.0053405496291816235, 0.05078813061118126, 0.020020002499222755, -0.007638188544660807, 0.03570707142353058, -0.013705894351005554, 0.0002841506211552769, 0.012080362997949123, 0.026484087109565735, -0.013860585168004036, 0.006516503635793924, 0.011561066843569279, -0.03746051713824272, -0.04127032682299614, -0.0019807976204901934, 0.0155174620449543, -0.003988747484982014, 0.05635847523808479, 0.030131468549370766, -0.09562540054321289, 0.036282528191804886, -0.04189145937561989, 0.03290772810578346, -0.003335186280310154, 0.03509877249598503, -0.012886155396699905, -0.0026059316005557775, 0.011868540197610855, 0.004972963128238916, -0.029930463060736656, -0.024982856586575508, -0.015851521864533424, -0.002554244827479124, 0.03309095650911331, -0.004232244566082954, 0.0005792572046630085, 0.006769038271158934, -0.0220344178378582, -0.041681934148073196, -0.026008347049355507, -0.06206429377198219, -0.041000381112098694, -0.014259968884289265, -0.003918585833162069, 0.025268372148275375, -0.007763662841171026, 0.0033724401146173477, 0.016726680099964142, -0.046376608312129974, 0.02670094184577465, 0.09090904146432877, -0.03289191797375679, -0.048456307500600815, -0.005252680741250515, -0.005577104166150093, 0.02049955353140831, 0.020486872643232346, 0.026068316772580147, -0.009548849426209927, 0.030784599483013153, 0.09103930741548538, 0.019589262083172798, 0.02213614247739315, -0.05148524418473244, 0.03127763420343399, -0.024081256240606308, 0.016464876011013985, -0.029842238873243332, 0.02741044946014881, -0.016614707186818123, 0.01928938925266266, -0.024621693417429924, 0.04500165581703186, 0.035185545682907104, -0.0538487434387207, -0.028490161523222923, -0.08591766655445099, -0.03331708535552025, 0.05042006075382233, -0.028147753328084946, -0.010494573041796684, -0.017435580492019653, 0.012458447366952896, 0.04316435754299164, -0.043863337486982346, 0.01647765375673771, 0.019107185304164886, 0.045826505869627, 0.030295170843601227, 0.03244924172759056, 0.02345644123852253, 0.08652559667825699, 0.015178157947957516, -0.025908833369612694, 0.08918513357639313, 0.005274937022477388, -0.07404632866382599, -0.03828173875808716, -0.029829736799001694, 0.009478605352342129, -0.029432186856865883, 0.05973059684038162, -0.07429526001214981, -0.019197607412934303, -0.038040369749069214, -0.004396253731101751, 0.010675126686692238, 0.011152835562825203, -0.02192549966275692, -0.006601386237889528, -0.028537556529045105, 0.0254436656832695, 0.020655978471040726, 0.037059370428323746, 0.026610875502228737, -0.0427800714969635, 0.02623678371310234, -0.055354248732328415, 0.04529095068573952, 0.020708654075860977, -0.007711335550993681, -0.05953394994139671, -0.0065315100364387035, 0.009974130429327488, 0.025910470634698868, 0.022177230566740036, 0.04956921562552452, 0.003310210071504116, -0.033835358917713165, 0.03780356049537659, -0.0338703878223896, 0.04747700318694115, -0.07073770463466644, 0.06444865465164185, -0.0011156578548252583, -0.03915438801050186, -0.016686158254742622, -0.02372715063393116, -0.029766470193862915, -0.0035368921235203743, 0.013705862686038017, 0.008820881135761738, 0.0008342951186932623, 0.024264633655548096, 0.07991877943277359, -0.008594613522291183, 0.013833768665790558, 0.041226599365472794, 0.02147963084280491, 0.02312205545604229, -0.027898326516151428, -0.06320178508758545, 0.027335723862051964, 0.011999672278761864, 0.0012207786785438657, -0.00028553063748404384, -0.048303667455911636, 0.008934415876865387, 0.058694664388895035, 0.0631880834698677, -0.009768969379365444, -0.024280663579702377, 0.01587783172726631, -0.07543819397687912, -0.05638543888926506, 0.039872244000434875, 0.02783402055501938, 0.04544797167181969, -0.030698416754603386, -0.08475412428379059, -0.027731433510780334, -0.05163290351629257, -0.011129898019134998, -0.016749773174524307, -0.01471636164933443, -0.013692766427993774, -0.05815006047487259, 0.0032426947727799416, -0.033588215708732605, -0.014626597054302692, 0.03278575465083122, 0.06137029454112053, 0.002596390899270773, -0.025523405522108078, 0.023069532588124275, 0.05378137528896332, -0.07066118717193604, 0.006965606007725, -0.04185185208916664, 0.007942047901451588, 0.04853424057364464, -0.019426528364419937, 0.011849706061184406, -0.0801534652709961, -0.0041917539201676846, 0.07157611101865768, 0.05816994607448578, -0.030936909839510918, -0.010255751200020313, 0.05002354830503464, 0.015910208225250244, 0.020752299576997757, 0.09233952313661575, -0.04123612865805626, -0.0877939909696579, 0.03188418224453926, -0.04702235013246536, -0.035081010311841965, -0.011390507221221924, 0.07689737528562546, -0.07437758147716522, -0.021234747022390366, 0.034132447093725204, 0.003588547697290778, -0.010001814924180508, 0.06761743128299713 ]
<p>I do not have much experience on this but if an atom has some electrons around nucleus and the atom itself it is moving at some speed does that affect the distribution of electrons around?</p> <p>I am presuming that the interaction between the nucleus and electrons has a constant speed $c$. Anything I found so far is a calculation for interactions that presume an infinite speed. </p> <p>As an argument I am thinking of relativistic Doppler effect that does not change proportional with $v/c$. So I am thinking that maybe the speed does affect the distribution and so that is why the difference in the emission energy.</p>
g6654
[ 0.048009179532527924, 0.03378889709711075, 0.018799996003508568, 0.027472540736198425, 0.04513786733150482, 0.006622040178626776, -0.008254799991846085, 0.07440896332263947, -0.028358913958072662, -0.0166776180267334, 0.030557435005903244, 0.02470303885638714, 0.00046062315232120454, 0.0304719265550375, -0.005039358511567116, 0.009942373260855675, 0.05099909380078316, -0.04009988531470299, 0.01498967781662941, 0.07433230429887772, 0.003033527173101902, -0.021755840629339218, -0.021616939455270767, -0.020085524767637253, 0.002711279783397913, 0.005989363417029381, 0.004110068082809448, -0.05460376292467117, -0.04474084824323654, 0.0011784539092332125, -0.004877518396824598, -0.0049287304282188416, 0.0046027665957808495, -0.013058740645647049, -0.04764952138066292, -0.05679307132959366, 0.03586357831954956, 0.027366647496819496, 0.03411474451422691, 0.0159311480820179, -0.016085254028439522, 0.020032141357660294, 0.0322849303483963, -0.02870219200849533, 0.0019386926433071494, 0.010790172964334488, 0.01369027141481638, 0.014385647140443325, -0.059447064995765686, 0.014841903932392597, -0.05801619589328766, -0.0051167188212275505, -0.021921096369624138, 0.05174285173416138, 0.020967813208699226, -0.016613861545920372, -0.004264076240360737, -0.007448376156389713, 0.03008997067809105, 0.02308681607246399, 0.01921420730650425, 0.003406043630093336, 0.020547280088067055, -0.014376518316566944, 0.04480884596705437, 0.0009760981774888933, -0.025806043297052383, 0.03371269255876541, 0.0230917539447546, 0.016171514987945557, -0.008733836933970451, -0.025597183033823967, -0.07729333639144897, -0.04106459021568298, 0.005354158580303192, -0.022684792056679726, 0.0027429957408457994, -0.08184424042701721, 0.009878196753561497, 0.026630720123648643, -0.07042267173528671, -0.03182927519083023, 0.05351515859365463, 0.0028401543386280537, 0.03508361056447029, 0.01040763221681118, 0.034690938889980316, -0.0024848810862749815, -0.0007144584669731557, -0.04512651637196541, 0.021782973781228065, -0.05847258120775223, -0.009164606221020222, -0.020860547199845314, -0.025692714378237724, -0.053045764565467834, -0.022279078140854836, 0.07850520312786102, -0.05592610314488411, -0.026156682521104813, -0.021480634808540344, 0.0017114531947299838, 0.015194764360785484, 0.010937646962702274, -0.04325491935014725, -0.027530914172530174, -0.05903639644384384, -0.01722422055900097, 0.019944975152611732, 0.0074263159185647964, -0.009303407743573189, -0.1515662670135498, 0.026774773374199867, -0.01249829400330782, -0.02023899555206299, -0.032100215554237366, 0.01129396352916956, -0.044779643416404724, -0.023209301754832268, 0.04702817276120186, -0.006572707090526819, 0.05132802203297615, -0.04102401062846184, 0.0186240803450346, -0.01570815034210682, 0.010453051887452602, -0.0116362189874053, -0.008331955410540104, 0.00038305038469843566, -0.02182937040925026, 0.02561161108314991, 0.005463102832436562, 0.013460418209433556, 0.04759541526436806, -0.03376040607690811, 0.0006361613632179797, 0.0018006647005677223, 0.020477939397096634, -0.04401961341500282, -0.02668776549398899, 0.06778732687234879, 0.02674449421465397, 0.05191199108958244, -0.018645519390702248, -0.02798163890838623, 0.015728680416941643, -0.010691840201616287, -0.015329299494624138, 0.018313782289624214, -0.06662831455469131, 0.017883913591504097, 0.006376019679009914, 0.0011332754511386156, -0.041001420468091965, -0.054091595113277435, 0.0179289560765028, -0.017528245225548744, 0.020510684698820114, -0.062477707862854004, 0.05526680499315262, 0.02207317017018795, -0.02434714138507843, -0.03663002699613571, -0.02459818683564663, -0.038643158972263336, 0.030620679259300232, 0.04555526748299599, 0.0076849861070513725, 0.03702050447463989, -0.04207734391093254, 0.019253864884376526, 0.032051973044872284, -0.027917008846998215, 0.02139611355960369, 0.00013979982759337872, -0.019255632534623146, 0.051913194358348846, 0.012924298644065857, 0.0017959533724933863, 0.010051875375211239, -0.01958898827433586, -0.009061465039849281, 0.03429873660206795, -0.024890322238206863, 0.03256038576364517, 0.009970652870833874, -0.025975605472922325, -0.0002281040360685438, -0.08038904517889023, -0.003540788544341922, -0.0011801562504842877, -0.046222563832998276, 0.0034935942385345697, -0.01251496747136116, -0.038714054971933365, 0.007092752493917942, 0.0064163594506680965, -0.020413387566804886, -0.005127776879817247, -0.04082126170396805, 0.010890720412135124, 0.029641127213835716, -0.014771691523492336, 0.01743404194712639, 0.1097811609506607, -0.02939332090318203, 0.00311743700876832, -0.00863890815526247, 0.038363102823495865, -0.010371586307883263, 0.06389803439378738, -0.006828645709902048, -0.06092936918139458, 0.07163424044847488, 0.06676054000854492, 0.025847529992461205, -0.04399087280035019, 0.007973936386406422, -0.009688974358141422, 0.04165186360478401, -0.03347396478056908, -0.036803219467401505, -0.023424062877893448, -0.030882354825735092, -0.03893638029694557, -0.05031266435980797, 0.012979745864868164, -0.04456314072012901, 0.014079216867685318, 0.08961878716945648, -0.03624188154935837, 0.05999042093753815, -0.043181437999010086, -0.0017810070421546698, -0.008584156632423401, 0.02865223027765751, -0.013349955901503563, -0.010608007200062275, -0.02903173677623272, 0.006213774438947439, 0.002066938439384103, -0.023647375404834747, -0.04925135150551796, -0.009738310240209103, 0.030660182237625122, -0.038193754851818085, 0.043212562799453735, -0.0402316115796566, 0.013595297001302242, -0.04964964836835861, 0.04295244812965393, -0.01718209683895111, -0.06943701207637787, -0.00685862684622407, 0.008913223631680012, -0.008073616772890091, -0.05157248675823212, 0.05227644369006157, -0.045531224459409714, -0.042146068066358566, -0.03774530813097954, -0.010425613261759281, -0.0001700754655757919, 0.030237438157200813, 0.0018888968043029308, -0.0045665958896279335, -0.00946616381406784, -0.0021009566262364388, -0.027022330090403557, 0.004412517417222261, -0.005779891274869442, 0.05179595574736595, -0.044502872973680496, 0.033230219036340714, -0.013549836352467537, -0.017820186913013458, 0.0009159618057310581, -0.04418756812810898, -0.024707837030291557, 0.008127374574542046, -0.013865579850971699, -0.04504001885652542, -0.02205144613981247, -0.03332291916012764, 0.05935799330472946, -0.03995605185627937, 0.01612289622426033, -0.03055521287024021, 0.016255071386694908, -0.03298313543200493, 0.013736770488321781, 0.02874629572033882, 0.01970364712178707, 0.005582625512033701, 0.028174199163913727, 0.054598722606897354, 0.09580107033252716, -0.044604238122701645, -0.03151104226708412, 0.05012963339686394, 0.012900427915155888, -0.050470318645238876, -0.0366055853664875, 0.03855862468481064, 0.023152342066168785, 0.005183980334550142, -0.07956677675247192, -0.016279255971312523, 0.008228998631238937, -0.005822184029966593, -0.024456879124045372, 0.01495390385389328, 0.011274286545813084, 0.004915801342576742, -0.025988170877099037, -0.004238571971654892, -0.016986843198537827, 0.026529312133789062, 0.022381383925676346, -0.004120506811887026, 0.04755350574851036, 0.01889554224908352, -0.02318638004362583, -0.0032986835576593876, 0.017297325655817986, 0.05601539462804794, 0.003423150861635804, 0.02393473871052265, -0.007278289645910263, -0.0008339608320966363, -0.009897963143885136, 0.013305590488016605, -0.0009785187430679798, -0.00905364565551281, -0.06916318088769913, -0.03225817531347275, 0.03633550554513931, 0.03914811089634895, 0.003598393639549613, 0.04248181730508804, 0.06787983328104019, -0.0011616110568866134, -0.0805734395980835, 0.029139943420886993, 0.003953315317630768, 0.008791749365627766, 0.007038187235593796, 0.010055836290121078, -0.06482386589050293, -0.013733835890889168, 0.061131369322538376, 0.007514940574765205, -0.029502324759960175, -0.030458837747573853, 0.022391173988580704, -0.01166046503931284, 0.0015815277583897114, -0.005986676085740328, -0.026818066835403442, 0.008242379873991013, -0.03998352214694023, -0.03651636466383934, 0.012918500229716301, 0.017285943031311035, -0.0636216253042221, 0.0034236283972859383, -0.03705830127000809, 0.019678179174661636, 0.06409274786710739, -0.006018731743097305, -0.06452446430921555, 0.03418266400694847, -0.013836086727678776, 0.01769532449543476, 0.014662003144621849, 0.016576839610934258, 0.03701023757457733, 0.055069297552108765, -0.05845554545521736, 0.019071875140070915, -0.017603300511837006, 0.022055942565202713, -0.00545019144192338, 0.026465637609362602, 0.007746540941298008, -0.035542599856853485, -0.03599679470062256, -0.030605528503656387, 0.005927532445639372, -0.045670442283153534, -0.01934673637151718, -0.015229769982397556, -0.010558721609413624, 0.03945538401603699, 0.015803314745426178, -0.00751987099647522, 0.031063389033079147, -0.004033308010548353, 0.05970858410000801, 0.034325599670410156, -0.029370969161391258, -0.026729414239525795, -0.01207639928907156, -0.04233746603131294, 0.031446099281311035, 0.014675432816147804, 0.03052341565489769, -0.022469887509942055, -0.04924628883600235, -0.035759277641773224, -0.05093199759721756, 0.04170622304081917, -0.052156366407871246, 0.026179485023021698, -0.024024005979299545, 0.02523011714220047, -0.014973893761634827, 0.03126411885023117, -0.02910776436328888, -0.007384985685348511, -0.04203274846076965, 0.05133649334311485, 0.06439100950956345, 0.030377373099327087, -0.016907019540667534, 0.06554247438907623, 0.07428470253944397, -0.004459386225789785, -0.005714762955904007, -0.018077727407217026, -0.0019825384952127934, 0.02841765619814396, 0.03566506877541542, 0.01360805332660675, -0.07739348709583282, 0.07828320562839508, -0.0251946859061718, 0.019115669652819633, 0.045403581112623215, -0.0016359704313799739, 0.06241225078701973, 0.036608096212148666, 0.04256755858659744, 0.04972637817263603, -0.046681832522153854, 0.09208911657333374, -0.08619894087314606, -0.048841606825590134, -0.07008206099271774, -0.04345402494072914, -0.0021741841919720173, 0.020274877548217773, -0.03159955143928528, -0.0019610710442066193, 0.023993022739887238, -0.01116917748004198, -0.08565085381269455, 0.0026983662974089384, 0.08251947909593582, 0.00605913856998086, -0.08828935027122498, 0.0419219471514225, 0.050027087330818176, 0.050516169518232346, -0.028824351727962494, -0.000987290171906352, -0.008811579085886478, -0.010612836107611656, -0.0826459750533104, -0.009264384396374226, 0.023793430998921394, -0.03428531065583229, 0.02486802078783512, 0.016871942207217216, 0.015455225482583046, -0.0356101393699646, 0.03954237699508667, -0.05563497915863991, -0.00015408893523272127, -0.03915669023990631, -0.04372518137097359, -0.0729018971323967, 0.03611311689019203, 0.027348270639777184, -0.0024035486858338118, 0.020608793944120407, -0.0325334332883358, 0.06469127535820007, 0.053730301558971405, -0.08977539837360382, 0.04600505530834198, 0.01022669579833746, -0.02566119097173214, -0.04317481070756912, 0.05072863772511482, 0.011807174421846867, 0.07004077732563019, -0.007034470792859793, -0.011877373792231083, 0.009441526606678963, -0.0368431881070137, 0.069581039249897, -0.03164716064929962, 0.0009595583542250097, -0.006793367676436901, 0.06108340993523598, 0.07582369446754456, -0.009983422234654427, -0.031343813985586166, 0.013744979165494442, -0.053853292018175125, 0.027259791269898415, 0.03243619576096535, 0.00539342500269413, -0.051050543785095215, 0.023668481037020683, -0.017294788733124733, -0.012570816092193127, -0.014410538598895073, -0.028004098683595657, 0.06351886689662933, 0.016332069411873817, 0.003639979287981987, -0.00880371406674385, 0.026397021487355232, -0.04478352889418602, -0.019939756020903587, 0.029609685763716698, 0.02561989426612854, 0.05774649605154991, 0.05928651615977287, 0.0013692877255380154, -0.0013291279319673777, 0.039839766919612885, -0.0034872356336563826, -0.013162430375814438, -0.004339046310633421, 0.000021748563085566275, 0.01786145195364952, 0.008765647187829018, 0.055099643766880035, -0.023816129192709923, 0.010276807472109795, 0.08202313631772995, -0.0362204909324646, -0.013847769238054752, -0.05929316580295563, -0.0035967768635600805, 0.018378524109721184, 0.005829867906868458, 0.03655394911766052, 0.04447128623723984, 0.0002767450059764087, 0.027014585211873055, 0.021000955253839493, 0.022876501083374023, 0.05056328698992729, -0.005102957133203745, 0.017109276726841927, -0.009277800098061562, 0.0313473604619503, 0.03491713106632233, 0.07433334738016129, 0.03657342493534088, 0.02460390143096447, -0.016980493441224098, -0.009864674881100655, -0.048555538058280945, 0.027207301929593086, 0.05078810080885887, 0.011671343818306923, 0.003578126896172762, -0.033813998103141785, -0.032838962972164154, 0.050571344792842865, 0.023448340594768524, -0.024043964222073555, -0.0403204970061779, -0.061180245131254196, 0.014288684353232384, 0.06740937381982803, 0.012346744537353516, -0.06054449453949928, -0.05988204479217529, 0.010946705937385559, -0.0325939804315567, 0.03938177973031998, 0.046616703271865845, 0.07673797011375427, -0.03229227289557457, 0.004622017033398151, -0.056901488453149796, 0.021427759900689125, -0.032456688582897186, -0.04836197942495346, -0.040734339505434036, -0.02532038278877735, -0.10167164355516434, -0.033350132405757904, 0.0724826231598854, 0.043091826140880585, -0.034133292734622955, 0.022134093567728996, 0.010881547816097736, 0.005714064463973045, -0.0017409243155270815, -0.028956597670912743, 0.033380087465047836, -0.0020875718910247087, 0.03822153061628342, -0.02786492556333542, 0.046672847121953964, 0.04025402292609215, -0.03255749121308327, -0.00514841778203845, -0.04140634089708328, -0.03072584606707096, 0.013235361315310001, 0.0354759506881237, -0.004145987797528505, 0.009434498846530914, -0.023696355521678925, -0.03222072497010231, -0.03155065327882767, 0.05759480968117714, 0.04961361363530159, -0.05022922903299332, 0.030274948105216026, 0.015323055908083916, -0.025954077020287514, 0.05843166634440422, 0.010666358284652233, -0.03394347056746483, 0.053358450531959534, 0.0012634850572794676, 0.055005840957164764, 0.0026889846194535494, -0.028161797672510147, 0.04015154018998146, 0.0347461923956871, 0.019221464172005653, -0.014860117807984352, 0.030486363917589188, 0.03229710832238197, -0.02585453912615776, -0.04174058139324188, 0.04504593089222908, 0.04113992303609848, -0.026984291151165962, -0.00982234999537468, -0.012872990220785141, -0.045725855976343155, -0.015673227608203888, 0.07689446955919266, -0.013925883919000626, -0.036686014384031296, -0.016993772238492966, -0.03567500412464142, -0.011523234657943249, -0.07060734182596207, -0.047445736825466156, -0.0683782771229744, -0.005533864721655846, -0.01021422166377306, 0.013919712975621223, 0.012613768689334393, 0.012788818217813969, -0.03889736533164978, -0.06629180163145065, 0.01320914551615715, -0.022641688585281372, -0.07688559591770172, -0.010700320824980736, 0.05398782715201378, 0.06701838970184326, 0.009621103294193745, -0.002064254367724061, -0.013276580721139908, -0.019314667209982872, -0.05530676990747452, 0.04827811196446419, 0.027027597650885582, 0.0010635207872837782, -0.00012250083091203123, -0.03890656679868698, 0.05453380569815636, -0.05661335587501526, -0.0318303257226944, -0.008877811953425407, -0.02668418549001217, 0.02053006738424301, -0.056858208030462265, -0.022513961419463158, -0.008722417987883091, -0.03356198966503143, 0.04109059274196625, -0.028588738292455673, 0.036048609763383865, -0.004626499488949776, 0.028852108865976334, -0.0038964594714343548, -0.034086719155311584, 0.05667196959257126, 0.037412796169519424, 0.05422502011060715, 0.019203033298254013, 0.029904978349804878, 0.048240624368190765, -0.008882707916200161, 0.02440185286104679, 0.06648987531661987, -0.04761407896876335, 0.10202106088399887, -0.02813401073217392, -0.036763131618499756, -0.04152948781847954, 0.0003026828053407371, 0.028078746050596237, 0.0123522337526083, 0.03339940682053566, -0.022685106843709946, -0.0050488547421991825, -0.008262081071734428, -0.024696901440620422, 0.010251500643789768, -0.037577565759420395, -0.007735682651400566, -0.0016999533399939537, 0.05014289170503616, 0.018141571432352066, -0.007356452289968729, 0.033973079174757004, -0.03868852183222771, -0.01547261606901884, -0.06674911826848984, -0.0009346549049951136, 0.06755805760622025, -0.04231848195195198, 0.0003698507498484105, 0.022689249366521835, -0.0044649140909314156, -0.060648199170827866, 0.041547320783138275, 0.045493148267269135, -0.024039505049586296, -0.06784824281930923, 0.01583082415163517, 0.004210211802273989, 0.008439244702458382, 0.03843230754137039, -0.012789457105100155, 0.005528615787625313, -0.06616277247667313, 0.06857732683420181, 0.03930037096142769, 0.020206891000270844, 0.0034682198893278837, 0.0061630988493561745, -0.02340654283761978, 0.01168078277260065, -0.007488748524338007, -0.027660099789500237, 0.021818777546286583, 0.005531261209398508, 0.028881283476948738, -0.027065645903348923, 0.004418287891894579, -0.028499579057097435 ]
<p>Is the classical doopler effect for light shift equal to $1-v/c$ exact or an approximation of a classical formula? I know that it is an approximation of the relativistic formula, but what was the corresponding classical formula? I ask this because in Einstein's On the Electrodynamics of moving bodies he derives $\sqrt\frac{1-v/c}{1+v/c}$ and notes that it is different from the classical case. I'm not exactly sure what formula he is comparing it to. </p>
g6655
[ -0.015626616775989532, 0.0022808092180639505, -0.007539005018770695, 0.009474537335336208, 0.030035270377993584, 0.012674909085035324, 0.07102043181657791, -0.030297495424747467, -0.019603868946433067, 0.010208811610937119, -0.029798241332173347, 0.030163664370775223, 0.009804647415876389, 0.03922615945339203, -0.03203315660357475, -0.004896062891930342, 0.04924827441573143, -0.012320649810135365, 0.054563652724027634, -0.04112367331981659, 0.018544843420386314, -0.0007734078099019825, -0.042225491255521774, -0.04969145730137825, 0.013236486352980137, -0.004405772779136896, 0.003295435104519129, 0.007431844249367714, -0.026263391599059105, 0.004034930374473333, 0.01237572357058525, 0.048737943172454834, 0.015388469211757183, 0.003258625278249383, 0.04773953929543495, -0.0552721805870533, 0.014677280560135841, 0.03127675876021385, 0.03525802120566368, 0.020283395424485207, -0.047052185982465744, 0.01494350004941225, 0.03741057217121124, 0.008789819665253162, 0.016547109931707382, -0.00263024284504354, -0.009046203456819057, 0.0006247534183785319, -0.035581644624471664, -0.02112078107893467, -0.045705750584602356, 0.022563567385077477, 0.029226865619421005, 0.04511604085564613, -0.03586534038186073, 0.005705224350094795, -0.006502749864012003, -0.04095792397856712, 0.04746130108833313, 0.04941757768392563, -0.007395220920443535, -0.02504023350775242, 0.018236201256513596, -0.02956170216202736, 0.028618425130844116, -0.01832663267850876, 0.0015051077352836728, -0.039960239082574844, 0.024861691519618034, -0.010721515864133835, -0.012205350212752819, -0.08157899975776672, -0.015629971399903297, -0.02573402412235737, -0.029183652251958847, -0.036240361630916595, -0.011397771537303925, -0.045265574008226395, 0.023892562836408615, -0.05848511680960655, 0.0028667456936091185, -0.04626946896314621, 0.03408926725387573, 0.050567030906677246, 0.06387095153331757, -0.0058167921379208565, 0.03758300840854645, 0.0640595555305481, 0.0038019195199012756, -0.030995363369584084, 0.02688005566596985, -0.051400016993284225, 0.010517685674130917, -0.022004704922437668, 0.006223409436643124, -0.05217021331191063, -0.008036830462515354, 0.04154123365879059, -0.024152882397174835, -0.0304148830473423, -0.03089084103703499, -0.04223811626434326, 0.009219804778695107, 0.0348246768116951, -0.020487219095230103, -0.030336519703269005, 0.037740543484687805, -0.019649337977170944, 0.005091092083603144, -0.013230605982244015, -0.09508559107780457, -0.1076526865363121, 0.03269099071621895, -0.07819537073373795, -0.051121897995471954, -0.03629574179649353, 0.0329289436340332, -0.04809502139687538, 0.024747449904680252, 0.024647939950227737, 0.021603913977742195, 0.03112826868891716, 0.04467129707336426, 0.06782110035419464, 0.025124935433268547, -0.027231406420469284, -0.013023891486227512, -0.004137316253036261, 0.014141076244413853, 0.026474758982658386, 0.011083764024078846, -0.009439130313694477, 0.004209313075989485, 0.008891772478818893, -0.04793648049235344, 0.05234391987323761, 0.09302625805139542, -0.00978008285164833, 0.06337954103946686, -0.012722951360046864, 0.06666149199008942, -0.0038419514894485474, -0.017826812341809273, -0.016857976093888283, -0.06985890120267868, 0.0340566411614418, -0.027905534952878952, -0.025008616968989372, 0.04976482689380646, -0.018511727452278137, 0.07176285982131958, 0.005504312925040722, 0.04865841194987297, -0.011446143500506878, -0.003526862245053053, 0.012205805629491806, 0.018454495817422867, 0.04598783701658249, -0.03881121426820755, 0.07151561975479126, 0.012118814513087273, -0.01684555597603321, -0.02046467736363411, -0.0066778818145394325, -0.006907177157700062, 0.002366642700508237, -0.005060720723122358, -0.030985001474618912, 0.005541848950088024, -0.10515926778316498, -0.02542768232524395, 0.018721062690019608, 0.027719693258404732, -0.00030471134232357144, 0.008632679469883442, 0.031161794438958168, 0.020176295191049576, 0.009312277659773827, -0.002344020875170827, 0.046129871159791946, -0.05783768370747566, -0.0353519506752491, -0.005316445603966713, 0.007379458285868168, -0.05115893855690956, -0.055345457047224045, -0.021099556237459183, -0.017292290925979614, -0.04047374054789543, -0.016653867438435555, -0.04754684120416641, -0.014983762055635452, 0.010354338213801384, 0.04111819714307785, -0.08141225576400757, 0.027015196159482002, -0.010668870061635971, -0.018969310447573662, -0.012633257545530796, 0.037622980773448944, 0.012382132932543755, 0.02703983150422573, 0.03174320235848427, -0.03697085753083229, 0.025385817512869835, 0.0028890520334243774, -0.01950933039188385, -0.048951681703329086, 0.10036483407020569, 0.006084609776735306, 0.06779082119464874, -0.022734008729457855, 0.040264662355184555, 0.05041706562042236, -0.029026154428720474, -0.029307281598448753, -0.055163074284791946, -0.009573707357048988, 0.002924968721345067, 0.04940386116504669, -0.04710753262042999, -0.007410296238958836, 0.011341225355863571, 0.04527369886636734, 0.017440075054764748, -0.008448266424238682, 0.006947332993149757, -0.01899847574532032, 0.08137574791908264, 0.023107513785362244, -0.050101254135370255, 0.043072815984487534, -0.05338551476597786, 0.04005055874586105, 0.02790774218738079, 0.05641718581318855, -0.06874087452888489, -0.015855712816119194, 0.04148370772600174, 0.024415897205471992, 0.04772373288869858, -0.03397157043218613, -0.03804673254489899, -0.0059316628612577915, -0.014936063438653946, 0.042898740619421005, 0.094915971159935, 0.00020554174261633307, -0.02473454736173153, -0.05280382186174393, -0.020658668130636215, 0.011992122046649456, -0.05368763953447342, 0.006123456638306379, 0.011323487386107445, -0.04445461556315422, -0.04662143439054489, 0.06510202586650848, -0.047876209020614624, -0.002176599809899926, -0.04586631804704666, -0.005412972066551447, 0.01855570822954178, -0.002545316470786929, -0.003963455557823181, 0.016087155789136887, 0.002404238563030958, 0.006637379061430693, 0.04338444769382477, -0.020456798374652863, 0.012441441416740417, 0.02292000874876976, -0.03806499019265175, 0.035834506154060364, -0.022951874881982803, -0.03193133696913719, 0.012574578635394573, -0.04865972325205803, 0.04260902479290962, -0.04143749177455902, -0.013979931361973286, -0.0027712553273886442, -0.03951055556535721, -0.01661692000925541, 0.021723952144384384, -0.07627490162849426, 0.003884869394823909, -0.024395490065217018, -0.03913476690649986, 0.014778858982026577, -0.06078990176320076, 0.02802429534494877, 0.0032421823125332594, 0.0030226081144064665, 0.022346362471580505, 0.052765313535928726, 0.058946575969457626, 0.03801332414150238, -0.03898930922150612, 0.09756898134946823, 0.016332000494003296, -0.018886437639594078, -0.03262617439031601, 0.004854556638747454, 0.009294582530856133, 0.008640208281576633, -0.01151889469474554, -0.07214029133319855, 0.09705831110477448, 0.07856032997369766, -0.011497316882014275, 0.07667440921068192, 0.007062940392643213, -0.0006276261992752552, -0.06594720482826233, -0.02045777626335621, 0.04454711824655533, -0.02084271050989628, 0.014364269562065601, -0.004900261294096708, 0.010066735558211803, -0.038288265466690063, -0.026109695434570312, 0.010406763292849064, 0.02943824976682663, 0.042947035282850266, -0.04812593758106232, 0.02701793983578682, -0.015660323202610016, -0.00572211341932416, 0.01894356682896614, -0.020556937903165817, -0.030508849769830704, -0.03905252739787102, -0.025189366191625595, -0.015741553157567978, -0.07082119584083557, 0.06515497714281082, 0.009838924743235111, 0.004668170586228371, -0.02552853897213936, 0.028366899117827415, -0.10148033499717712, 0.04323562607169151, 0.034413959830999374, 0.013575728982686996, 0.02951861545443535, 0.006408335641026497, -0.007977757602930069, 0.015253635123372078, 0.018942752853035927, -0.004249344114214182, -0.032558318227529526, 0.017951471731066704, -0.04749992862343788, -0.0014353051083162427, 0.011978461407124996, 0.039191655814647675, 0.03323153778910637, 0.009375940077006817, 0.01072264090180397, -0.0155080771073699, -0.050844334065914154, 0.03336426243185997, 0.018696404993534088, -0.04720146209001541, 0.0029437385965138674, 0.04877697676420212, -0.010813646949827671, -0.021348964422941208, -0.010826303623616695, -0.008962390013039112, 0.022931864485144615, 0.08162157982587814, -0.005061354022473097, -0.0325319766998291, 0.0007533460156992078, 0.04972895607352257, -0.06962757557630539, 0.016602886840701103, 0.035744909197092056, 0.04400409758090973, -0.03548337146639824, 0.022893939167261124, -0.028976839035749435, -0.06647871434688568, -0.045553576201200485, -0.041146643459796906, 0.04919159784913063, 0.004204663913697004, 0.024754159152507782, -0.050536442548036575, 0.003819243749603629, 0.02820623479783535, 0.029426436871290207, 0.002136226510629058, 0.008830014616250992, 0.00583312613889575, -0.07176202535629272, -0.0031052331905812025, 0.011581439524888992, 0.0069349342957139015, 0.057114869356155396, -0.011721285991370678, -0.021923402324318886, -0.02571006305515766, 0.02830454520881176, -0.06453336775302887, 0.006194959860295057, 0.034428875893354416, -0.02626839466392994, -0.019257700070738792, -0.05695696547627449, -0.03642994537949562, 0.04786420240998268, 0.015767060220241547, 0.05825083330273628, -0.036677442491054535, 0.03815830126404762, 0.009105360135436058, 0.010034369304776192, 0.009293703362345695, 0.002460115822032094, 0.0035917460918426514, -0.06273160129785538, 0.013338676653802395, 0.012574438005685806, 0.004859566688537598, 0.047566067427396774, -0.025465484708547592, 0.018446609377861023, 0.003943024668842554, -0.0035387431271374226, 0.07172109186649323, -0.006715315859764814, 0.07417071610689163, 0.01107680331915617, 0.08623112738132477, -0.04546743631362915, 0.003126532770693302, 0.036757439374923706, 0.016362229362130165, 0.06763394176959991, -0.02707991562783718, -0.02092711441218853, 0.06099701300263405, -0.03676356002688408, -0.04011526703834534, 0.027807287871837616, -0.02050931751728058, -0.0014000277733430266, 0.0684170350432396, 0.03900633379817009, 0.015644880011677742, 0.01135456096380949, -0.0020744893699884415, -0.017291098833084106, -0.00531914783641696, 0.008201230317354202, -0.0014385636895895004, -0.03000381961464882, 0.03465331718325615, 0.023365234956145287, -0.002566492883488536, 0.058455146849155426, 0.028538625687360764, -0.06394651532173157, -0.017931215465068817, -0.06988893449306488, -0.027244070544838905, -0.02676169015467167, -0.008402137085795403, -0.01055123284459114, -0.04663654416799545, 0.005270105320960283, -0.0028451804537326097, 0.03215590491890907, 0.0020091538317501545, -0.07336102426052094, -0.02698659338057041, -0.057601988315582275, -0.02610790729522705, -0.011300098150968552, -0.03282107785344124, -0.043751854449510574, 0.005459798965603113, 0.032104019075632095, 0.02686716429889202, -0.021191053092479706, -0.06243768706917763, 0.031349360942840576, 0.03599585220217705, -0.0037336796522140503, -0.036425601691007614, 0.03591296821832657, 0.01986830309033394, -0.00609580148011446, 0.034021709114313126, -0.027277139946818352, 0.07853256911039352, -0.07720806449651718, 0.0824228972196579, 0.017188958823680878, 0.031479764729738235, -0.008755944669246674, 0.05294700339436531, 0.0036186848301440477, -0.005677683744579554, -0.038797780871391296, 0.015076732262969017, 0.016532540321350098, 0.01622970961034298, -0.0009898539865389466, 0.07748502492904663, 0.027699388563632965, 0.010441453196108341, -0.019971774891018867, -0.02171284705400467, 0.00961487926542759, -0.042942389845848083, -0.017516572028398514, 0.003117222571745515, -0.014290520921349525, 0.05833560228347778, 0.014880925416946411, 0.0035297684371471405, -0.04266941174864769, -0.011790220625698566, 0.004214041400700808, -0.014135966077446938, 0.009850161150097847, 0.021275749430060387, 0.01067341398447752, -0.012137120589613914, -0.011481614783406258, 0.009479972533881664, 0.0057514021173119545, -0.009185045957565308, 0.012640983797609806, 0.004600127227604389, -0.04087897017598152, -0.014871044084429741, -0.0015429112827405334, 0.06009253114461899, 0.010262244381010532, 0.016174346208572388, -0.09303728491067886, 0.010477304458618164, 0.025740627199411392, -0.023459535092115402, -0.004124837461858988, -0.0005966501776129007, -0.004520396236330271, 0.044517580419778824, 0.050898563116788864, 0.002892149845138192, 0.01859208010137081, -0.06897764652967453, -0.0011580891441553831, 0.004937749356031418, 0.02813507616519928, -0.0010319227585569024, 0.026504328474402428, -0.05161742866039276, 0.012339308857917786, -0.04372883588075638, 0.06645925343036652, -0.027501247823238373, 0.07320711761713028, -0.010632924735546112, 0.0026305534411221743, -0.021408187225461006, -0.01597069576382637, -0.03302759677171707, 0.004167531616985798, 0.06359338760375977, -0.016009701415896416, -0.06523417681455612, -0.07064007222652435, 0.02655266597867012, 0.009465005248785019, 0.02137599140405655, 0.01708551123738289, -0.04553917050361633, -0.07873788475990295, 0.04130885750055313, -0.03820408508181572, 0.026558713987469673, 0.0340166911482811, 0.012492566369473934, -0.04130689799785614, 0.0228594820946455, -0.04997764900326729, -0.003944505006074905, -0.029934721067547798, -0.0031133743468672037, -0.003329283557832241, 0.021463066339492798, 0.015296103432774544, 0.04285714775323868, 0.004951562266796827, 0.020897405222058296, 0.043697092682123184, 0.007930864579975605, 0.025955021381378174, -0.003438614308834076, -0.06417842954397202, -0.005975633859634399, -0.0008421734673902392, 0.010603846982121468, 0.008464266546070576, 0.025620659813284874, -0.03556219860911369, -0.06698955595493317, -0.029066476970911026, -0.018258031457662582, -0.013044881634414196, 0.03210804983973503, 0.03557628393173218, -0.026030901819467545, -0.03393813222646713, -0.05263863131403923, 0.02794589474797249, -0.04576737433671951, -0.019091947004199028, 0.05524001270532608, -0.06610801815986633, -0.018890392035245895, -0.006899764761328697, 0.018585072830319405, 0.03921111300587654, -0.032207388430833817, -0.031461987644433975, 0.030029213055968285, 0.06735535711050034, 0.04772938787937164, -0.04009336978197098, 0.029116623103618622, -0.010189114138484001, 0.03770698606967926, -0.013574620708823204, 0.018147267401218414, 0.033765945583581924, -0.007037260569632053, -0.0837387815117836, -0.005320834461599588, 0.010267367586493492, 0.016824111342430115, -0.04671398922801018, 0.008827805519104004, 0.03416912630200386, -0.0593811497092247, 0.009797045961022377, 0.05140494555234909, -0.011768280528485775, -0.029418645426630974, 0.010709871537983418, 0.01784708723425865, -0.02610512264072895, -0.09213877469301224, -0.02046571858227253, -0.02285899594426155, 0.0053976671770215034, 0.030937401577830315, -0.007210811134427786, 0.020756326615810394, 0.026665711775422096, -0.07065630704164505, -0.0010129412403330207, 0.02402419224381447, 0.056509144604206085, -0.012525453232228756, -0.01971045508980751, 0.044858165085315704, 0.0281747505068779, -0.02849787473678589, -0.057304322719573975, 0.032855622470378876, -0.027163848280906677, -0.007499809376895428, -0.02845054306089878, 0.06104610487818718, -0.0004086627159267664, -0.011608988046646118, -0.058588869869709015, 0.041454996913671494, -0.03192389756441116, -0.050397202372550964, 0.01893266662955284, 0.03839770331978798, -0.0007107707788236439, -0.03210625424981117, -0.06660228967666626, -0.02709071710705757, 0.0065661207772791386, 0.006205464713275433, 0.057596661150455475, 0.06168632209300995, 0.05009671300649643, 0.01717039942741394, -0.03245553374290466, -0.060947928577661514, -0.014021310023963451, 0.009293453767895699, 0.018696378916502, 0.004826740827411413, -0.04259565472602844, -0.020933037623763084, -0.009268484078347683, 0.0008395957993343472, 0.08920136839151382, 0.03450383245944977, 0.08119707554578781, -0.022178947925567627, 0.03432142734527588, 0.035906124860048294, -0.014795270748436451, 0.009624593891203403, 0.02069329470396042, 0.04242818057537079, -0.013825672678649426, -0.03363534063100815, -0.021265313029289246, -0.04842601716518402, 0.000542005873285234, -0.018579840660095215, -0.014590886421501637, -0.04706433042883873, 0.05253973230719566, 0.001904331729747355, 0.0341363325715065, 0.009953576140105724, -0.01961648277938366, -0.03545680269598961, -0.057562489062547684, 0.01734689064323902, 0.002769030863419175, 0.03857601061463356, 0.05626445636153221, 0.03721921518445015, -0.050139378756284714, -0.04406126216053963, 0.026168638840317726, -0.010590104386210442, -0.002944723702967167, 0.012762363068759441, 0.00982585921883583, 0.0014273474225774407, 0.017718706279993057, -0.02387184277176857, -0.051290303468704224, 0.006343240849673748, -0.013504840433597565, -0.004696964751929045, 0.11327365040779114, -0.018637247383594513, -0.03712743893265724, -0.05246720835566521, -0.026918485760688782, 0.03131740540266037, -0.05646705999970436, -0.028548864647746086, 0.005231549963355064, 0.012288481928408146, -0.01055698562413454, 0.004353044088929892, -0.013215682469308376, 0.034717656672000885 ]
<p>It's easy for me to imagine that if we brake the front wheel then there is a chance that I'll flip.</p> <p>On the other hand if I brake the back wheel, there is no way it'll happen no matter how fast I brake.</p> <p>But whether I brake the front wheel or back wheel, the force I've added is a backward force at the bottom of the wheel.</p> <p>So why the different outcome?</p>
g6656
[ 0.006249392870813608, 0.04578869417309761, 0.019698109477758408, 0.0665786862373352, 0.05725788697600365, -0.009193730540573597, 0.07072439789772034, 0.02551305666565895, -0.05320252478122711, -0.10357079654932022, 0.04017137736082077, -0.015269159339368343, 0.007788257207721472, 0.028158649802207947, 0.04582811892032623, 0.04968714341521263, 0.024999039247632027, -0.0032704125624150038, -0.001301003503613174, -0.006236828397959471, -0.058584850281476974, 0.047348830848932266, -0.09193043410778046, 0.00174474879167974, -0.10415389388799667, -0.02771509438753128, 0.006404741667211056, -0.003977152984589338, 0.01854977197945118, 0.002255754778161645, 0.026272853836417198, 0.05842796713113785, 0.023106774315238, -0.017441097646951675, -0.004043392837047577, -0.032714083790779114, -0.012114823795855045, -0.00801118090748787, -0.004115517251193523, -0.03844441846013069, 0.018365727737545967, 0.02393362857401371, 0.011139752343297005, -0.004921303130686283, 0.02809964306652546, -0.016167091205716133, -0.022749805822968483, 0.018779801204800606, 0.036026109009981155, 0.039162538945674896, 0.009488997049629688, -0.02088679000735283, -0.0304420068860054, 0.015957526862621307, 0.0272416602820158, -0.004601547960191965, -0.009475051425397396, 0.039378419518470764, -0.03735976293683052, -0.016760800033807755, -0.10016632080078125, 0.029850902035832405, 0.01757770963013172, 0.024340862408280373, 0.011120728217065334, -0.017824923619627953, 0.0007328384672291577, 0.015240529552102089, 0.05362960696220398, 0.04220130667090416, -0.020032504573464394, 0.020060401409864426, 0.007830032147467136, -0.02699185349047184, -0.003241222584620118, 0.03224596381187439, 0.06354529410600662, 0.0003243524697609246, 0.007164319511502981, 0.006763744633644819, -0.027059733867645264, -0.01928689330816269, 0.006016076076775789, 0.04941802844405174, 0.05644097179174423, -0.0006088881054893136, -0.014569654129445553, 0.006455046124756336, -0.054235320538282394, 0.04190540686249733, 0.02197386510670185, -0.04712331295013428, 0.04009556397795677, 0.030686719343066216, -0.07370534539222717, -0.07510874420404434, -0.047586992383003235, 0.06050292029976845, -0.037873655557632446, 0.009776998311281204, -0.052612628787755966, 0.022224346175789833, 0.051175713539123535, 0.023151004686951637, -0.001559039345011115, -0.08518879115581512, 0.016767311841249466, -0.0008205152116715908, -0.021229760721325874, -0.058769818395376205, -0.015758905559778214, -0.006898854393512011, -0.02201312780380249, -0.02570517733693123, 0.003527988912537694, 0.006130249239504337, 0.004960750229656696, 0.024783195927739143, 0.041369225829839706, 0.0015191107522696257, 0.0032822692301124334, 0.014280377887189388, -0.06844247132539749, 0.03731098771095276, -0.018095847219228745, -0.0721009224653244, 0.01610707677900791, -0.018857011571526527, 0.07779748737812042, -0.007847968488931656, 0.029216116294264793, -0.013199973851442337, 0.020514942705631256, -0.002187053207308054, 0.06137198582291603, 0.05757027864456177, 0.017706165090203285, 0.05844223499298096, 0.049322739243507385, 0.024099912494421005, -0.017872711643576622, 0.047169893980026245, 0.05259665474295616, 0.0036680155899375677, -0.05023818463087082, 0.004118210636079311, -0.03982000797986984, 0.04848581552505493, -0.017171699553728104, 0.04017737880349159, -0.01097404956817627, 0.013193443417549133, -0.009885531850159168, -0.00917037669569254, 0.03460703417658806, 0.011217220686376095, 0.06441419571638107, 0.06739208847284317, -0.0009658081689849496, 0.015089566819369793, 0.08649777621030807, -0.039620738476514816, -0.04569481313228607, 0.04428288713097572, -0.0893024131655693, 0.0003987907839473337, -0.07077019661664963, -0.02912275865674019, -0.019339734688401222, 0.03531971573829651, -0.02871975302696228, 0.007009136024862528, 0.021250328049063683, 0.031063398346304893, 0.07791098207235336, 0.028995566070079803, -0.016537271440029144, 0.010783669538795948, 0.011450573801994324, 0.05424414575099945, 0.011157373897731304, 0.015778174623847008, -0.04506557434797287, 0.01168027799576521, 0.020442049950361252, -0.05675510689616203, -0.04884077608585358, 0.0625072792172432, -0.03580716997385025, 0.015891754999756813, 0.04454701766371727, -0.032590415328741074, -0.03777151182293892, 0.019367240369319916, -0.03657011315226555, -0.04579411447048187, -0.04590018838644028, 0.0016794884577393532, 0.026208218187093735, 0.02097329869866371, -0.0278493519872427, 0.025284353643655777, 0.03412807732820511, 0.014139831997454166, -0.07584617286920547, -0.02331850491464138, -0.026597240939736366, 0.028399139642715454, 0.030111899599432945, -0.08100082725286484, -0.04297226294875145, 0.05382636561989784, 0.01828310638666153, -0.0096138846129179, -0.044860489666461945, 0.026121972128748894, 0.006178174167871475, 0.03571513295173645, -0.0008289034012705088, 0.01775941252708435, 0.051369037479162216, -0.048809416592121124, 0.0012843901058658957, -0.026864193379878998, -0.03942064940929413, -0.01703117974102497, 0.0054001277312636375, 0.009655306115746498, 0.012876957654953003, 0.04498891532421112, 0.0023509436286985874, -0.02271745726466179, -0.01426638849079609, 0.011643514968454838, 0.032203949987888336, 0.02273416519165039, 0.06760138273239136, 0.002737967995926738, 0.038167983293533325, -0.008373004384338856, 0.0207507461309433, -0.030688451603055, -0.025676874443888664, 0.030032433569431305, 0.018933413550257683, -0.0398649238049984, 0.015865178778767586, -0.08515362441539764, 0.004696998745203018, 0.02735680527985096, 0.0029673930257558823, -0.008201994933187962, -0.023170843720436096, 0.015748748555779457, -0.02320345863699913, -0.02229980193078518, -0.04967706277966499, 0.010698411613702774, -0.0614234134554863, 0.007469042204320431, 0.005586240906268358, 0.020601151511073112, 0.006626702379435301, -0.008938368409872055, -0.06992070376873016, -0.02477562613785267, -0.010432487353682518, -0.0067176553420722485, -0.019018301740288734, 0.018355295062065125, -0.020328911021351814, 0.037335824221372604, -0.030012628063559532, -0.018953319638967514, 0.001040066359564662, 0.002244379837065935, -0.01016187109053135, -0.04003441333770752, -0.010658856481313705, -0.004250854253768921, -0.0352904386818409, 0.04574322700500488, 0.039495453238487244, 0.009707977995276451, -0.013502022251486778, 0.0012089986121281981, 0.003403270151466131, -0.038320377469062805, -0.022998543456196785, 0.00622107507660985, -0.11207671463489532, 0.04887150228023529, 0.10698498040437698, -0.026823945343494415, 0.06893368810415268, 0.06732557713985443, 0.03855128213763237, -0.02248445339500904, -0.061193883419036865, -0.0012224201345816255, -0.029373034834861755, -0.002392652677372098, -0.001487288624048233, -0.004464054945856333, -0.026769492775201797, 0.027606742456555367, -0.017459610477089882, -0.0038593634963035583, -0.030416959896683693, 0.014844376593828201, -0.031008290126919746, -0.009292514994740486, -0.04592099413275719, -0.0064620948396623135, -0.06332700699567795, -0.01863490231335163, -0.04669084772467613, 0.02031833492219448, -0.015468795783817768, -0.04386691376566887, -0.04523077234625816, -0.01636182889342308, -0.016968853771686554, -0.015510727651417255, -0.009394114837050438, 0.06468520313501358, -0.09760450571775436, -0.011593291535973549, 0.04742218554019928, -0.03953242674469948, 0.05276774242520332, 0.02511410601437092, -0.029268046841025352, -0.016709357500076294, -0.03728785365819931, 0.06063920632004738, 0.05685364827513695, 0.06517788767814636, 0.015052189119160175, 0.018308743834495544, 0.021113401278853416, -0.009636232629418373, -0.053478486835956573, -0.024167293682694435, 0.000047165500291157514, 0.052042700350284576, 0.022161206230521202, 0.0038120774552226067, 0.028114618733525276, -0.007214436307549477, -0.011865333653986454, -0.029711082577705383, 0.033595409244298935, -0.009169225580990314, 0.0502023920416832, 0.010049923323094845, -0.03203664720058441, -0.0012456623371690512, 0.03081698901951313, 0.015748130157589912, 0.048290252685546875, 0.04120558872818947, -0.044465694576501846, -0.007878700271248817, -0.011964811012148857, -0.005554727278649807, -0.08519787341356277, 0.008154772222042084, -0.05329758673906326, -0.0026019772049039602, 0.019415386021137238, 0.023577818647027016, 0.021013781428337097, 0.06031264364719391, 0.05650770291686058, -0.03288291022181511, 0.04382580146193504, -0.0024424311704933643, 0.0411112979054451, -0.05063599720597267, 0.07358796149492264, 0.09516022354364395, 0.073414146900177, -0.011866549029946327, -0.011695642955601215, 0.005172015633434057, -0.03338467329740524, -0.06815598160028458, 0.00468283798545599, 0.03386470675468445, -0.03603759780526161, 0.007269761525094509, 0.03843742981553078, -0.04161371663212776, 0.000041683488234411925, 0.04000331461429596, 0.0024145643692463636, -0.04546664282679558, 0.021533865481615067, 0.034594543278217316, -0.057344406843185425, 0.08140196651220322, -0.011954572051763535, 0.009296131320297718, -0.025256458669900894, -0.003047060687094927, 0.02805577963590622, 0.007584171835333109, -0.018284611403942108, 0.023468082770705223, 0.020300090312957764, 0.012996632605791092, -0.01336209662258625, -0.015749085694551468, 0.0624377615749836, -0.01668676733970642, 0.05059979483485222, 0.05875574052333832, 0.0335550382733345, -0.052335385233163834, 0.017142733559012413, 0.03369210287928581, -0.009545105509459972, -0.0053433883003890514, -0.029447028413414955, 0.04857867583632469, -0.02509983256459236, -0.038288362324237823, -0.022011198103427887, 0.01632172055542469, 0.010936791077256203, 0.025425050407648087, -0.024833351373672485, -0.030298026278614998, 0.005221288185566664, -0.020987985655665398, -0.0065958513878285885, 0.02845522202551365, 0.023681242018938065, 0.014938745647668839, 0.027895966544747353, 0.03248213604092598, -0.02668141759932041, -0.005759075749665499, -0.02310531958937645, -0.02532101422548294, -0.03569263592362404, -0.017448751255869865, 0.022443637251853943, -0.03246309608221054, -0.0537298284471035, 0.02934086136519909, -0.010675042867660522, -0.04542529955506325, 0.022178463637828827, -0.0199009720236063, -0.03165123611688614, -0.01829708181321621, -0.026836689561605453, 0.04960181936621666, -0.04854743555188179, -0.03798013925552368, 0.03462094068527222, 0.00671661039814353, -0.0398646742105484, 0.03178032487630844, 0.0201282761991024, -0.017263449728488922, -0.01363372802734375, 0.05366535484790802, -0.016152746975421906, -0.026299098506569862, -0.005478902719914913, 0.0763145461678505, 0.043424464762210846, 0.022597551345825195, 0.023820601403713226, 0.007659277878701687, 0.036386504769325256, -0.04088659584522247, -0.06494755297899246, 0.023138469085097313, 0.05134052783250809, -0.06640022248029709, -0.042454663664102554, 0.024128105491399765, -0.05724173039197922, -0.03031250648200512, 0.011743367649614811, -0.012229806743562222, 0.03878806158900261, 0.0629877820611, -0.007265590131282806, -0.051580388098955154, -0.014692540280520916, 0.04574273154139519, -0.007064292207360268, -0.0024736300110816956, -0.07442107796669006, 0.029257791116833687, -0.07565227895975113, 0.017814064398407936, 0.0150374174118042, -0.03331945464015007, 0.03095768392086029, 0.0928395688533783, 0.035385578870773315, -0.0505608506500721, -0.01232203096151352, 0.03349755331873894, -0.027137786149978638, -0.01488465629518032, -0.04788130894303322, 0.0515141636133194, 0.0042325956746935844, -0.00024575780844315886, -0.020956702530384064, -0.008083459921181202, 0.024609167128801346, -0.06695427745580673, -0.038865458220243454, -0.03347516059875488, -0.001611686428077519, -0.057524118572473526, -0.04704387113451958, -0.05567808449268341, -0.015212757512927055, -0.04011651873588562, -0.03646127134561539, -0.012612714432179928, -0.00410059466958046, 0.06440524756908417, 0.10478335618972778, 0.0561947263777256, -0.023122092708945274, -0.0321129634976387, 0.08901476114988327, -0.053247831761837006, 0.03751416876912117, -0.04063206538558006, 0.051600925624370575, 0.0460984893143177, -0.020668765529990196, 0.04560081660747528, -0.05705811083316803, -0.014870342798531055, -0.05730384215712547, 0.03603498637676239, -0.007346741855144501, -0.0412420891225338, 0.011361289769411087, 0.04193751513957977, -0.04020237550139427, -0.03582165017724037, -0.06318321079015732, 0.07320290803909302, -0.04838055372238159, -0.025837505236268044, -0.003296319395303726, -0.06909811496734619, -0.008671076036989689, -0.008800704032182693, 0.0065209041349589825, -0.0014036872889846563, 0.014444690197706223, -0.04589544236660004, -0.021192898973822594, -0.005127254407852888, 0.00918115209788084, -0.018506130203604698, 0.03779803588986397, 0.005449108313769102, -0.06401902437210083, 0.034792494028806686, -0.010757914744317532, 0.008807959966361523, 0.016542136669158936, -0.008932081051170826, -0.013271963223814964, -0.03115678019821644, -0.017492128536105156, -0.021374506875872612, 0.03344147279858589, 0.012636984698474407, -0.00035225696046836674, 0.0013738442212343216, -0.1025756448507309, -0.0057035828940570354, 0.028713783249258995, -0.052766188979148865, -0.006072354037314653, 0.00777187617495656, 0.04001171886920929, -0.00003224071770091541, -0.025865335017442703, -0.007209185976535082, 0.0006552883423864841, -0.00978511106222868, -0.04274201765656471, -0.03179516643285751, 0.02852185256779194, 0.04636048525571823, 0.07950783520936966, 0.005245145410299301, 0.04142790287733078, 0.020959140732884407, 0.027774153277277946, 0.004086748696863651, 0.05161790922284126, 0.044868990778923035, 0.02293296344578266, 0.017418337985873222, 0.015951821580529213, 0.03327307105064392, -0.0482809841632843, 0.03496347367763519, -0.015319611877202988, -0.02404852770268917, 0.011792383156716824, 0.01189067680388689, 0.010562053881585598, -0.009376810863614082, 0.023174451664090157, -0.0034901818726211786, 0.01724294014275074, 0.001068971469067037, -0.03725232928991318, 0.0362069234251976, 0.049483876675367355, 0.03366644307971001, 0.0447191447019577, -0.027544280514121056, -0.08024511486291885, 0.07655828446149826, -0.00757242739200592, 0.027254397049546242, -0.04097921401262283, -0.013972285203635693, -0.007229135371744633, 0.015239682979881763, -0.002140713855624199, 0.09165605157613754, 0.0013694713125005364, 0.01828007958829403, -0.03628532215952873, 0.013354028575122356, 0.007053551729768515, -0.01638953387737274, 0.018366526812314987, 0.0320945642888546, -0.02266610413789749, -0.0003134776488877833, -0.023453164845705032, -0.01759326457977295, -0.038950156420469284, 0.01390641275793314, 0.06257840991020203, 0.015066898427903652, 0.01520628947764635, 0.014371571131050587, 0.03753145784139633, -0.005392427556216717, -0.017539232969284058, 0.027183324098587036, -0.029316969215869904, -0.0007733228267170489, 0.01124764047563076, -0.023796673864126205, 0.03590350225567818, 0.02847174182534218, 0.017212046310305595, -0.043936945497989655, -0.05290614813566208, -0.01863698661327362, 0.026879174634814262, 0.008749880827963352, -0.026369597762823105, -0.035211801528930664, 0.051671382039785385, 0.024604137986898422, 0.051067762076854706, 0.010806690901517868, -0.011349612846970558, 0.052587322890758514, -0.01912868767976761, 0.04277690127491951, 0.01877721957862377, 0.05668744817376137, 0.010217361152172089, -0.037425532937049866, 0.039595115929841995, -0.02634856291115284, -0.0015876076649874449, 0.022392310202121735, -0.06284863501787186, -0.04402392357587814, -0.053981713950634, 0.005086091347038746, 0.0029133413918316364, -0.018488867208361626, -0.0044981385581195354, 0.01450517401099205, 0.03879006579518318, -0.010555491782724857, 0.006984459701925516, -0.023656722158193588, -0.034389838576316833, 0.024255098775029182, -0.028051408007740974, -0.051755014806985855, 0.04396471381187439, 0.02016463130712509, -0.019470954313874245, 0.009428104385733604, 0.006664067506790161, 0.013313173316419125, 0.027496181428432465, 0.012856798246502876, -0.01344930287450552, 0.007203623186796904, -0.01795397512614727, -0.03682642802596092, 0.0003299155505374074, -0.040155503898859024, -0.03036498837172985, -0.040343835949897766, 0.05580131337046623, -0.01485668309032917, -0.011470481753349304, 0.030643930658698082, -0.011641192249953747, -0.002528828103095293, 0.02184806391596794, -0.030647970736026764, -0.030931614339351654, 0.03424759954214096, -0.021743761375546455, -0.024526264518499374, -0.08058831840753555, -0.0051688337698578835, -0.04453444108366966, -0.013637821190059185, -0.009438755922019482, -0.036382053047418594, -0.026095477864146233, 0.013069521635770798, 0.010151245631277561, 0.018012760207057, 0.024664347991347313, 0.028272487223148346, -0.00842487346380949, -0.0459025613963604, -0.03589210286736488, 0.02397165261209011, 0.0456504188477993, 0.033721376210451126, -0.06429331749677658, -0.008422085084021091, 0.020799292251467705, -0.013327069580554962, -0.016211630776524544, -0.010396637953817844, -0.028774479404091835, -0.06007775664329529, 0.00005820317528559826, -0.020393088459968567, -0.060337699949741364, 0.015029017813503742 ]