question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>If a particle with mass $m$ collides with a wall at right angles, and the collision is perfectly elastic. The particle hits the wall at $v\ ms^{-1}$. There is no friction or gravity. So the particle will rebound at $-v\ ms^{-1}$?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Xp73i.png" alt="image description"></p> <p>What will the change in momentum be?</p> <p>I did:</p> <p>$$initial\ momentum = final\ momentum$$ $$mv = m(-v)$$ $$mv = -mv$$</p> <p>But this doesn't seem right because it's like saying $1=-1$?</p>
g7406
[ 0.09603229910135269, -0.004879232496023178, -0.007263381965458393, 0.015767637640237808, 0.10716293752193451, 0.02568107284605503, 0.0353144071996212, 0.010922931134700775, -0.07228119671344757, -0.01287125889211893, -0.013868110254406929, 0.03588195517659187, 0.008293003775179386, -0.020826170220971107, -0.019431162625551224, -0.0028781236615031958, 0.09468179941177368, -0.026533523574471474, 0.005721771623939276, 0.010954401455819607, -0.058311883360147476, -0.004043306224048138, -0.02204192988574505, -0.0350135900080204, 0.03417416661977768, -0.012801273725926876, -0.019224703311920166, 0.01986686885356903, -0.02887904830276966, 0.05809149891138077, 0.0394551157951355, -0.04864531755447388, 0.021304817870259285, -0.02988990768790245, -0.03773435950279236, -0.009045273065567017, 0.06042703241109848, -0.016528215259313583, 0.033500127494335175, -0.01447635143995285, 0.07535574585199356, -0.04770045727491379, 0.05557383969426155, -0.0084879444912076, 0.006660249084234238, 0.024861225858330727, 0.021864034235477448, 0.008836651220917702, -0.02304115518927574, 0.0398244746029377, -0.040962107479572296, 0.06621163338422775, -0.0031463606283068657, 0.00125306926202029, -0.039648495614528656, 0.024547995999455452, 0.0649116262793541, -0.00517886271700263, 0.04481590911746025, 0.07291366159915924, 0.0042788246646523476, -0.06139291077852249, 0.010526718571782112, -0.014244758524000645, 0.028481945395469666, -0.013864324428141117, -0.018334055319428444, 0.03357645496726036, -0.012172660790383816, -0.013394060544669628, 0.011478235013782978, 0.0020962234120815992, 0.03330276533961296, -0.02806469425559044, -0.04166682809591293, -0.005101929884403944, -0.03140667825937271, -0.04784131422638893, -0.03202487528324127, -0.010472162626683712, -0.05744580551981926, 0.06893833726644516, 0.02528965100646019, -0.07669242471456528, 0.01863947883248329, -0.015157167799770832, 0.024507004767656326, 0.004760403651744127, -0.05734677240252495, -0.025019044056534767, 0.048630163073539734, -0.047345977276563644, -0.010280315764248371, 0.016899146139621735, -0.01747003197669983, -0.04188716039061546, -0.08523308485746384, 0.019926607608795166, 0.01624162122607231, -0.0009797165403142571, -0.015448846854269505, -0.019222447648644447, 0.0013974563917145133, -0.05518847331404686, 0.001839960110373795, 0.00032408631523139775, 0.04239622503519058, 0.008513318374752998, 0.008067870512604713, -0.00466809282079339, -0.00379180652089417, -0.09832613170146942, -0.010333430953323841, -0.06484822183847427, -0.03612421825528145, -0.058719612658023834, 0.06908863037824631, 0.032945211976766586, 0.004120878875255585, 0.08965716511011124, -0.00107399036642164, -0.001345001277513802, 0.02538834884762764, 0.07861936837434769, -0.03518727794289589, -0.03516831994056702, 0.008869106881320477, 0.011686415411531925, -0.010755782015621662, 0.007427743170410395, 0.025506922975182533, 0.0029505009297281504, 0.0030600172467529774, 0.006946095731109381, -0.0025467872619628906, -0.00746622821316123, 0.006423762068152428, 0.019563935697078705, -0.007151636760681868, 0.009351246990263462, 0.004219937138259411, 0.05142085999250412, 0.04294823482632637, -0.031751956790685654, -0.07943268120288849, -0.058126941323280334, 0.007287757471203804, -0.018546821549534798, 0.028085486963391304, 0.021422576159238815, -0.027312910184264183, 0.03712619096040726, -0.010456562042236328, -0.009335215203464031, -0.005102891009300947, -0.019002769142389297, 0.055866338312625885, 0.02740355208516121, -0.011256122030317783, 0.0008806591504253447, 0.053101133555173874, -0.02889050543308258, 0.03935403376817703, 0.002789420308545232, -0.06723497062921524, 0.003107215277850628, 0.007152196019887924, -0.007204012479633093, -0.02122338116168976, -0.06424011290073395, -0.04820174351334572, -0.03826221078634262, -0.0097906943410635, 0.026092590764164925, -0.03305095061659813, 0.03588436171412468, -0.010507822968065739, -0.016958944499492645, 0.03919193148612976, 0.022361569106578827, 0.07179421186447144, -0.011700296774506569, 0.05569707974791527, -0.015625031664967537, 0.05431891605257988, -0.0006548944511450827, 0.02917124144732952, 0.11145875602960587, -0.0259690023958683, 0.02257527783513069, -0.01819009706377983, -0.01018424890935421, 0.0006635289755649865, 0.0021786997094750404, -0.021344680339097977, 0.016487877815961838, 0.018397409468889236, -0.06279906630516052, -0.03139845281839371, 0.024130666628479958, -0.03140115737915039, 0.04365909472107887, 0.05334528535604477, 0.0546778179705143, -0.048541635274887085, -0.01662551797926426, 0.010653479024767876, -0.013571851886808872, -0.019429828971624374, -0.010249011218547821, 0.06842076033353806, -0.0016149476869031787, -0.09113585948944092, 0.03346705436706543, -0.04393045976758003, -0.004314105026423931, -0.012063850648701191, 0.041593652218580246, -0.0006157901952974498, 0.0413980707526207, -0.0709972158074379, -0.015330597758293152, 0.0014618163695558906, -0.06323962658643723, 0.0022804790642112494, -0.019620629027485847, -0.0416082963347435, -0.009627061896026134, 0.02730177529156208, 0.020014770328998566, -0.0520675852894783, 0.05412675440311432, -0.007981509901583195, -0.0032014367170631886, 0.043356169015169144, 0.026205122470855713, 0.024281436577439308, 0.044800180941820145, 0.016478434205055237, 0.01575777493417263, 0.025214245542883873, -0.03992178291082382, -0.02578023448586464, -0.05642122030258179, 0.044489990919828415, -0.0077590798027813435, 0.03210313990712166, 0.03200661018490791, 0.025196868926286697, -0.01976695843040943, 0.03930535912513733, -0.008411998860538006, -0.01954241469502449, 0.013869144953787327, 0.026629911735653877, -0.024309255182743073, 0.013593397103250027, -0.009510830044746399, -0.020224763080477715, 0.023117849603295326, 0.012222480960190296, -0.04876687005162239, 0.02047383226454258, 0.059475693851709366, -0.04661712050437927, 0.018124092370271683, -0.029316730797290802, 0.05195724591612816, 0.006866366136819124, 0.005834993440657854, -0.017870735377073288, 0.04743267223238945, 0.001767261535860598, 0.10359904915094376, -0.024129942059516907, -0.043036650866270065, 0.007366898935288191, -0.03714418038725853, -0.014013700187206268, -0.026923706755042076, -0.03357599675655365, 0.07160768657922745, -0.009355618618428707, -0.03880081698298454, 0.0015767539152875543, -0.06455162912607193, -0.017194848507642746, 0.01885470189154148, -0.04555589333176613, 0.02184935100376606, 0.00007047352846711874, 0.017409011721611023, 0.0357368178665638, -0.011971699073910713, 0.06510359793901443, 0.0685889795422554, 0.018991129472851753, -0.019412821158766747, -0.013305612839758396, -0.012277285568416119, -0.07928694784641266, 0.007351054344326258, -0.11439387500286102, 0.012326044961810112, 0.02093365415930748, 0.05924847349524498, -0.006369410548359156, 0.02282523550093174, 0.006643056869506836, 0.008413108997046947, 0.00315866619348526, 0.074473075568676, 0.03608335554599762, 0.011548738926649094, -0.032662760466337204, 0.0003632289299275726, 0.06934867799282074, 0.005778271704912186, -0.024067066609859467, 0.04978054389357567, -0.07906000316143036, -0.048939306288957596, 0.07637376338243484, 0.005733448546379805, -0.007993889972567558, 0.03307057544589043, -0.08106480538845062, 0.02379828877747059, -0.023249860852956772, -0.008331422694027424, 0.02556646429002285, 0.06766416132450104, 0.01599954441189766, -0.0398140549659729, 0.0010526978876441717, -0.027546610683202744, 0.050491705536842346, -0.005037317052483559, 0.04017161205410957, 0.024446066468954086, -0.04069822281599045, 0.015147406607866287, 0.028010904788970947, 0.016909440979361534, 0.03697032108902931, 0.02388572320342064, 0.05997856706380844, 0.01726744882762432, 0.004742145072668791, -0.03172929584980011, 0.08757204562425613, -0.012151838280260563, 0.021138206124305725, 0.01706656441092491, -0.0018705938709899783, 0.06085430085659027, -0.01791631430387497, 0.04520802199840546, -0.007901405915617943, 0.023161593824625015, 0.001343240262940526, -0.061089519411325455, 0.010940787382423878, 0.022296255454421043, -0.014666667208075523, 0.00722795445472002, -0.08421976864337921, 0.04026960954070091, 0.004093374591320753, -0.015511760488152504, -0.013311834074556828, -0.07178788632154465, -0.011434920132160187, 0.02482379972934723, -0.044038962572813034, -0.026310866698622704, 0.010058670304715633, 0.008338763378560543, 0.01313960924744606, 0.01388100627809763, 0.04378528147935867, -0.030830439180135727, -0.06783552467823029, 0.025441467761993408, -0.017231490463018417, 0.05915229022502899, -0.04813855141401291, 0.002054719952866435, 0.05735522136092186, -0.004767329432070255, 0.05060127377510071, -0.003167001763358712, 0.02735055610537529, 0.03542172536253929, 0.05840836092829704, -0.025557782500982285, 0.010099995881319046, -0.031411658972501755, -0.07067858427762985, -0.008433994837105274, -0.013395634479820728, 0.0763043612241745, -0.016999974846839905, 0.009423768147826195, 0.05410182103514671, 0.0015725800767540932, 0.03233145549893379, 0.020711347460746765, -0.005762754939496517, -0.01759491115808487, 0.015707679092884064, -0.05210670083761215, -0.014378536492586136, -0.012301703914999962, -0.019226035103201866, -0.0002913936914410442, -0.0043848054483532906, 0.011570089496672153, -0.0000460356313851662, 0.01607581414282322, 0.02423936128616333, 0.029838383197784424, -0.0005196150741539896, -0.013136849738657475, -0.021722575649619102, -0.02158152498304844, 0.039213113486766815, 0.009408166632056236, -0.04283992946147919, -0.014861488714814186, 0.014321038499474525, 0.039198171347379684, 0.021542364731431007, -0.030837439000606537, -0.053045276552438736, 0.10926634818315506, 0.00963903870433569, -0.02585149183869362, 0.0013945772079750896, 0.054700955748558044, 0.02892017923295498, 0.022606873884797096, -0.0047788191586732864, -0.05002337321639061, 0.01837291568517685, 0.05048665776848793, -0.031173698604106903, -0.030564339831471443, 0.05801644176244736, -0.03983314335346222, -0.032353587448596954, -0.005014317575842142, -0.007403177674859762, -0.06240490823984146, -0.0057920231483876705, -0.034548770636320114, -0.028715087100863457, 0.08327358216047287, -0.0243828147649765, -0.007588230073451996, -0.025113895535469055, -0.0015187518438324332, 0.020309489220380783, -0.0047272443771362305, -0.012766381725668907, -0.016936123371124268, -0.010794191621243954, 0.015172253362834454, -0.05843047797679901, -0.01695428602397442, 0.019834836944937706, 0.020764514803886414, -0.04056620970368385, 0.037570804357528687, -0.012535873800516129, 0.027796410024166107, -0.003722277469933033, 0.02285986766219139, 0.05797514319419861, -0.06476793438196182, -0.00303938752040267, 0.004018418490886688, -0.0016615302301943302, -0.044373348355293274, 0.001798607176169753, 0.0038199301343411207, -0.04544586315751076, 0.007163850124925375, 0.04831463471055031, 0.044294003397226334, -0.0057993861846625805, -0.013725224882364273, -0.050674814730882645, -0.04956822842359543, 0.050371069461107254, 0.0066835940815508366, -0.04294899106025696, -0.02882259339094162, 0.00307374051772058, -0.011586606502532959, -0.05040648952126503, -0.03815146163105965, -0.0004786456120200455, -0.020369043573737144, -0.045756395906209946, 0.022742820903658867, 0.004246854223310947, -0.016228534281253815, 0.007932954467833042, 0.024573571979999542, -0.02387193776667118, -0.0070809428580105305, 0.06470101326704025, -0.02006051316857338, 0.03970719128847122, 0.0026678938884288073, 0.04489516094326973, -0.002246938645839691, -0.025451267138123512, 0.0127771170809865, 0.06227216497063637, -0.04881015792489052, 0.01503734476864338, 0.025942575186491013, -0.041214536875486374, -0.002702527679502964, -0.009066129103302956, -0.06098054721951485, -0.024590039625763893, 0.07847308367490768, 0.02900804579257965, -0.07829703390598297, 0.051764752715826035, 0.04010339826345444, -0.027587562799453735, -0.06443510949611664, 0.01598997600376606, 0.03670533001422882, 0.01703043095767498, -0.05972869694232941, -0.0553814135491848, 0.01930379867553711, 0.05764700099825859, 0.052845049649477005, -0.030374033376574516, 0.025464659556746483, -0.06354021281003952, 0.010542668402194977, -0.01313899364322424, -0.026366911828517914, -0.04058428108692169, 0.007983221672475338, -0.048823971301317215, 0.005516204982995987, 0.0024281807709485292, -0.02133582904934883, 0.06875661760568619, -0.01486852765083313, 0.037071723490953445, -0.03337185084819794, -0.006913131568580866, -0.08095850050449371, 0.019677545875310898, -0.027664877474308014, 0.009724157862365246, -0.009315559640526772, -0.016831913962960243, -0.015665628015995026, 0.019040962681174278, 0.004151510074734688, 0.001252461108379066, 0.03265184536576271, -0.01295650564134121, -0.0034855990670621395, 0.013835746794939041, 0.018155239522457123, -0.0352783203125, -0.04200955107808113, -0.0589505210518837, -0.020205870270729065, 0.057262588292360306, -0.006716136354953051, 0.016180966049432755, -0.029993325471878052, 0.003127466421574354, -0.020405707880854607, -0.027466924861073494, -0.05210346728563309, 0.052692532539367676, 0.03364845737814903, -0.06896324455738068, 0.016316600143909454, 0.024645959958434105, 0.007609130349010229, -0.030079592019319534, -0.03106042370200157, -0.018819039687514305, 0.00469126645475626, -0.029426969587802887, 0.029116174206137657, 0.03938702493906021, 0.07252208888530731, -0.011694615706801414, 0.002218009904026985, 0.006543824914842844, 0.01518180686980486, -0.006118223536759615, 0.025873983278870583, 0.010818748734891415, 0.04695121571421623, 0.0011990130878984928, 0.031763382256031036, 0.010561533272266388, 0.00987803004682064, 0.014348060823976994, 0.0009689977741800249, -0.03903355449438095, 0.02157161384820938, -0.017620323225855827, -0.05890790745615959, 0.004662774503231049, 0.007445236202329397, 0.012150101363658905, -0.044123198837041855, 0.07076892256736755, -0.0030415572691708803, -0.03741509094834328, 0.020950432866811752, 0.025783633813261986, -0.020115384832024574, -0.0441957488656044, -0.02917465940117836, -0.01664757914841175, 0.029886750504374504, -0.04506194218993187, 0.07758089154958725, -0.0025889829266816378, 0.022344406694173813, 0.019667871296405792, 0.04281814396381378, 0.03302330896258354, 0.00533437030389905, -0.001917272456921637, -0.014438923448324203, -0.03789420798420906, 0.005682321265339851, -0.018335362896323204, -0.03163839504122734, -0.034203171730041504, 0.014285768382251263, -0.036544233560562134, -0.014449362643063068, 0.02739875204861164, 0.04168020933866501, -0.012652548961341381, -0.017278898507356644, -0.0003396354441065341, -0.0031318990513682365, 0.019667504355311394, 0.0266108438372612, -0.06177555024623871, -0.055931076407432556, 0.0023055749479681253, -0.0294586643576622, 0.0017966075101867318, -0.010209708474576473, 0.005036447662860155, -0.0033204942010343075, 0.05608397349715233, -0.05368179455399513, 0.0010058833286166191, -0.038898587226867676, -0.050171587616205215, 0.014123938046395779, 0.032599639147520065, 0.020191827788949013, -0.0445723719894886, 0.017881091684103012, -0.038853954523801804, 0.004895568359643221, 0.022370394319295883, 0.054137106984853745, 0.012696570716798306, -0.03334726020693779, -0.005429581273347139, -0.01011931337416172, -0.02794063277542591, 0.07039202004671097, -0.008323604241013527, -0.02287326566874981, -0.016789132729172707, 0.02436760999262333, 0.010894321836531162, 0.00562034547328949, -0.04200407862663269, -0.008484677411615849, 0.03471510484814644, 0.05876917019486427, -0.005313495639711618, -0.004871539305895567, 0.0234675295650959, -0.034104153513908386, -0.02757137082517147, 0.031301964074373245, -0.03195870667695999, 0.013664796017110348, -0.0520903579890728, -0.051728442311286926, -0.03232526034116745, -0.018590664491057396, 0.00979060959070921, 0.013874280266463757, 0.027649084106087685, -0.02791690267622471, 0.0041507151909172535, -0.002613998018205166, -0.0019286706810817122, 0.038334090262651443, 0.014653882943093777, 0.01896435208618641, 0.010845844633877277, -0.012365457601845264, -0.009280487895011902, -0.06696809828281403, -0.01716158725321293, -0.009363393299281597, -0.0731818750500679, 0.08230811357498169, 0.03644530847668648, 0.04719657078385353, -0.07743975520133972, -0.04702399671077728, 0.0027058979030698538, 0.023289386183023453, 0.02100507728755474, -0.020841680467128754, 0.04201047867536545, -0.029868047684431076, -0.02523469179868698, -0.004747618455439806, -0.0722639262676239, -0.05543125420808792, 0.047594036906957626, 0.014122683554887772, 0.0225136149674654, 0.0005717141320928931, 0.03463417664170265, 0.088589608669281, -0.032199449837207794, -0.05982167273759842, 0.06544727832078934, -0.019608985632658005, -0.02197035774588585, 0.044565413147211075, -0.01744740456342697, -0.08230102807283401, -0.044429246336221695, -0.017285708338022232, -0.026430390775203705, -0.07152199745178223, 0.01836334355175495, -0.002884842688217759, -0.03291895613074303, -0.05348947271704674, 0.02082163281738758, -0.05329360440373421, -0.004561042413115501, 0.03701211139559746 ]
<p>My science teacher used to say a lot of weird stuff, but I'm just making sure on this one.</p>
g7407
[ 0.025868849828839302, 0.02814866229891777, 0.021345801651477814, -0.028779728338122368, 0.026753704994916916, -0.002800585003569722, -0.03794638067483902, -0.049650419503450394, 0.002971404930576682, -0.05132429674267769, 0.009742341935634613, 0.06258407980203629, -0.003278857097029686, 0.03027874417603016, -0.017257677391171455, -0.040575556457042694, 0.053796276450157166, -0.0732339546084404, -0.025835637003183365, 0.017370890825986862, -0.018781568855047226, -0.037848543375730515, 0.02028524875640869, -0.03914780914783478, 0.01385559979826212, -0.047854624688625336, -0.05485135316848755, 0.009832586161792278, 0.008638521656394005, -0.016225343570113182, 0.10438239574432373, -0.009499344043433666, -0.017177477478981018, 0.030911549925804138, -0.051392801105976105, 0.007205247413367033, -0.000005562753813137533, 0.016253169625997543, 0.07923516631126404, -0.00011688774247886613, 0.011790730990469456, 0.04524262249469757, 0.004267428070306778, -0.08335371315479279, 0.011658895760774612, 0.0246047992259264, -0.08325914293527603, -0.007211912423372269, -0.04770271107554436, -0.012175905518233776, -0.006210331805050373, -0.025333739817142487, 0.003987593110650778, 0.029239578172564507, -0.006574694998562336, 0.01043834537267685, -0.024816228076815605, -0.054090987890958786, 0.07446832954883575, 0.0066405851393938065, 0.007711237762123346, 0.05329504236578941, 0.012194623239338398, 0.00589754106476903, 0.010527146980166435, 0.004296202212572098, -0.06173345446586609, 0.02048586495220661, -0.04906260967254639, -0.004731899593025446, 0.06905252486467361, -0.04321267083287239, 0.014172805473208427, -0.00374264782294631, -0.0748465433716774, 0.028369856998324394, -0.02703048661351204, -0.021683532744646072, 0.013841322623193264, 0.07359086722135544, -0.07900790125131607, 0.007530553266406059, 0.0021968160290271044, 0.019314546138048172, 0.024560313671827316, 0.04175582528114319, 0.024841168895363808, 0.02970689721405506, -0.027766801416873932, 0.04630059003829956, -0.018705686554312706, -0.09151551872491837, 0.04940907657146454, 0.00300328666344285, 0.054151907563209534, -0.03522370755672455, -0.003241166239604354, -0.037623081356287, -0.021089157089591026, 0.010637802071869373, -0.10014735907316208, -0.03775827959179878, 0.054035916924476624, -0.03626025468111038, 0.005184083711355925, 0.0034751270432025194, 0.026826931163668633, -0.04411459341645241, 0.00885184295475483, -0.07449179887771606, 0.01667323149740696, 0.028828535228967667, -0.012137582525610924, -0.01348462887108326, -0.005597475450485945, 0.0435405895113945, -0.014373982325196266, -0.06658393144607544, 0.059792011976242065, 0.04367043823003769, 0.010009285993874073, -0.012278351001441479, -0.013756739906966686, 0.04103011637926102, 0.008404696360230446, 0.006976176518946886, -0.011334949173033237, 0.03491580858826637, -0.0022984351962804794, 0.008659117855131626, -0.030782882124185562, -0.00586735038086772, 0.012662588618695736, 0.023713039234280586, -0.0077257538214325905, 0.01890411786735058, 0.0061988988891243935, -0.0021233679726719856, -0.011555532924830914, -0.05219827964901924, 0.014158825390040874, 0.020863952115178108, -0.022971145808696747, -0.02128620073199272, 0.033879827708005905, -0.01915394887328148, -0.021273881196975708, 0.017909573391079903, 0.012780141085386276, -0.02518097497522831, 0.003905300982296467, 0.013428599573671818, -0.010927335359156132, -0.02998482994735241, 0.023675821721553802, -0.005212974734604359, -0.015419157221913338, 0.027473365887999535, 0.032750453799963, 0.011866609565913677, 0.07624443620443344, -0.005441473331302404, 0.022649578750133514, 0.02996158041059971, -0.07176116853952408, -0.0014520337572321296, -0.0002823140239343047, -0.016243193298578262, -0.02305516228079796, 0.06205336004495621, -0.06489039212465286, -0.013098522089421749, 0.06524289399385452, 0.024336090311408043, -0.06359449774026871, 0.008840643800795078, -0.04210611432790756, -0.06394800543785095, -0.0056747617200016975, 0.036694884300231934, 0.006514928303658962, 0.04285752400755882, 0.05871187150478363, -0.011013275012373924, 0.0018963984912261367, 0.005733849946409464, 0.00015669481945224106, 0.034344304352998734, -0.05794284865260124, 0.01603786274790764, -0.06488494575023651, -0.01770886220037937, 0.007901836186647415, -0.0344131737947464, -0.014294156804680824, -0.036056291311979294, -0.050775062292814255, 0.026639336720108986, -0.034197863191366196, 0.07447101175785065, -0.020007316023111343, 0.023875856772065163, -0.018526004627346992, 0.01070665568113327, -0.010799619369208813, -0.030557449907064438, 0.010932855308055878, 0.005630249157547951, 0.027161113917827606, 0.01579809933900833, 0.07029558718204498, -0.022900428622961044, -0.016072843223810196, 0.06791192293167114, -0.019881948828697205, -0.024155640974640846, -0.004351326730102301, -0.047451235353946686, -0.03828306496143341, 0.058198075741529465, -0.020770730450749397, -0.043607428669929504, 0.008766014128923416, -0.011834293603897095, 0.07959716022014618, 0.016891229897737503, -0.02602570503950119, -0.07566633075475693, -0.03889361768960953, 0.005363896023482084, -0.017248496413230896, -0.07354810833930969, 0.03554292023181915, -0.008945812471210957, 0.06130732223391533, 0.06164921820163727, 0.009726009331643581, -0.12565365433692932, 0.012981347739696503, 0.03981459513306618, 0.05143838748335838, -0.03665485978126526, -0.029284659773111343, -0.02874576300382614, 0.06123049929738045, -0.00573116447776556, 0.010374045930802822, -0.04236553609371185, 0.0035546778235584497, -0.0002766911929938942, 0.0252576544880867, 0.04628400877118111, -0.030520139262080193, 0.07459161430597305, 0.027730748057365417, 0.0019726718310266733, -0.03567282110452652, 0.037570975720882416, -0.01662108674645424, -0.03547248616814613, 0.07432767003774643, -0.08879715204238892, -0.0335954949259758, -0.019014280289411545, -0.04386818781495094, -0.046135518699884415, -0.056576281785964966, -0.004533217288553715, 0.0020063018891960382, 0.006099575664848089, 0.019123688340187073, 0.030340047553181648, 0.013727080076932907, 0.007487806025892496, -0.06709683686494827, -0.005755990277975798, -0.04977547004818916, 0.04601910337805748, 0.0994727686047554, -0.002230144338682294, -0.03369789943099022, 0.103126659989357, -0.004589878488332033, -0.00966966338455677, 0.03325194865465164, 0.06151815876364708, -0.008513023145496845, 0.011825750581920147, -0.01968991570174694, 0.004461127799004316, -0.04206428304314613, -0.02487957663834095, 0.07978074997663498, 0.037159644067287445, 0.008537986315786839, 0.03929530829191208, 0.03098645620048046, 0.011085067875683308, -0.01895783469080925, 0.03137248009443283, 0.047961510717868805, 0.01907314360141754, -0.0028063759673386812, -0.01646193489432335, 0.02900712564587593, 0.02113291248679161, -0.0071576680056750774, 0.005065354984253645, 0.08698045462369919, 0.007801090367138386, -0.03769896551966667, 0.021097151562571526, 0.06491628289222717, 0.020248398184776306, -0.027958739548921585, 0.06408485025167465, -0.013387725688517094, -0.01741114631295204, 0.051709793508052826, -0.017159441486001015, -0.0012793421046808362, -0.0012643329100683331, 0.054018206894397736, -0.045756950974464417, 0.008282064460217953, 0.028218699619174004, -0.018025895580649376, -0.04026125371456146, -0.05481080338358879, 0.014859248884022236, -0.001909567043185234, -0.02991519123315811, -0.023994816467165947, -0.07433295994997025, 0.013659062795341015, 0.06256013363599777, -0.02282087132334709, 0.03960338607430458, -0.0036116058472543955, 0.021267026662826538, 0.01951444335281849, -0.002653883770108223, 0.04210124909877777, 0.026233552023768425, 0.010039611719548702, 0.06886553764343262, 0.008957767859101295, -0.042284198105335236, 0.0035075650084763765, 0.02534511312842369, 0.00990304071456194, 0.04506384953856468, -0.025609135627746582, -0.008122275583446026, 0.02853873372077942, 0.007543677464127541, 0.012559641152620316, -0.017991535365581512, -0.02818022482097149, -0.002440345473587513, -0.017289116978645325, -0.05241477116942406, -0.012268288061022758, -0.03563253954052925, -0.056530408561229706, 0.008840883150696754, 0.01638580858707428, 0.07079172879457474, 0.014355857856571674, -0.035813093185424805, -0.05740229785442352, 0.01777653954923153, -0.03454439714550972, 0.013127986341714859, 0.06573580205440521, -0.04452618956565857, 0.025327671319246292, -0.00849292054772377, -0.053707726299762726, -0.002653932897374034, 0.041095536202192307, -0.005324664991348982, 0.017467109486460686, 0.0038505103439092636, 0.028872832655906677, 0.04733815789222717, -0.03023088537156582, 0.017203910276293755, 0.04400769621133804, -0.01906663365662098, -0.019743915647268295, -0.008326571434736252, -0.04396755248308182, -0.05705835297703743, -0.004631370306015015, 0.0008415572810918093, 0.00007437335443682969, 0.009677030146121979, -0.02682086080312729, 0.0028039910830557346, -0.06187653914093971, 0.024987967684864998, 0.025433188304305077, 0.0009204430389218032, -0.05528334155678749, 0.04880502447485924, 0.03608303517103195, -0.05383569747209549, 0.015792066231369972, -0.057832688093185425, 0.005626779515296221, -0.006517742294818163, -0.03222232311964035, -0.010966209694743156, -0.05967817083001137, 0.013108196668326855, -0.005870665889233351, 0.021899202838540077, -0.04289250820875168, -0.005609107669442892, 0.05223127827048302, 0.02101157233119011, -0.0654350072145462, -0.05741947889328003, 0.03494247421622276, 0.015887992456555367, 0.0019416490104049444, -0.0006931466050446033, -0.02315966598689556, -0.05993717163801193, -0.010540773160755634, -0.00024865803425200284, -0.0017103992868214846, 0.055216822773218155, 0.03784070909023285, 0.029615018516778946, -0.0719924345612526, 0.011457893066108227, 0.0055926088243722916, 0.052178509533405304, -0.005000805016607046, 0.0007461128989234567, -0.0014968765899538994, 0.0030234716832637787, 0.017468644306063652, -0.0673506036400795, 0.02849152311682701, 0.025500459596514702, -0.013259933330118656, 0.08569848537445068, -0.06295399367809296, 0.06957468390464783, -0.009131960570812225, 0.0166139155626297, 0.030622586607933044, -0.05870671197772026, -0.0016554583562538028, 0.019309645518660545, -0.030301108956336975, 0.05537751689553261, -0.0920262336730957, 0.00350237381644547, 0.03022434562444687, 0.004458094015717506, -0.00016316768596880138, 0.03235527127981186, -0.05429328978061676, -0.057669054716825485, 0.04486660659313202, -0.008883773349225521, 0.0000011581985290831653, -0.04098770394921303, 0.01865631900727749, 0.056870099157094955, -0.024657249450683594, -0.00877904612571001, -0.018718339502811432, -0.0034397286362946033, -0.06632475554943085, 0.06349235028028488, -0.04053843021392822, -0.0006068344227969646, 0.029595136642456055, -0.020131375640630722, 0.03076278604567051, 0.033740997314453125, 0.004718951415270567, 0.009496110491454601, 0.04093019291758537, -0.009494317695498466, 0.02472747676074505, -0.03406360000371933, 0.062482502311468124, -0.03328505530953407, -0.06125523895025253, -0.025812562555074692, 0.012725417502224445, -0.054997775703668594, 0.031459491699934006, 0.010891648940742016, -0.1083860844373703, 0.04849293828010559, 0.015958677977323532, -0.0016523433150723577, 0.0025570462457835674, -0.05713856965303421, 0.018471190705895424, -0.021359913051128387, -0.017390752211213112, 0.005875211209058762, 0.05241885036230087, 0.04622545838356018, 0.015742486342787743, 0.1148899644613266, 0.005273267161101103, -0.0297947209328413, -0.02831210009753704, 0.058078814297914505, 0.001785171334631741, 0.012742068618535995, -0.014558760449290276, -0.07423977553844452, 0.008290343917906284, 0.010729042813181877, -0.06405659765005112, 0.019234448671340942, -0.035018064081668854, -0.05173038691282272, 0.05101362615823746, 0.025412119925022125, 0.014050883240997791, 0.023128284141421318, -0.009350315667688847, -0.02008252777159214, 0.015020797960460186, -0.04384233430027962, -0.04006361961364746, 0.05396104231476784, 0.012545503675937653, -0.01992177963256836, -0.025313155725598335, 0.01000947318971157, -0.004481541458517313, -0.03409121185541153, -0.008235601708292961, 0.0031665172427892685, 0.012972164899110794, -0.051188915967941284, 0.015470835380256176, 0.004424070939421654, 0.01169214304536581, -0.0018462137086316943, -0.000384543469408527, 0.0009709494188427925, 0.05270341783761978, 0.0329025462269783, -0.037329334765672684, -0.031159836798906326, -0.0011467320146039128, 0.023905057460069656, -0.011251130141317844, -0.05082482099533081, -0.013871927745640278, -0.023216556757688522, 0.004812018945813179, -0.06652011722326279, -0.03304671496152878, -0.03908926993608475, -0.004800485447049141, -0.02303493022918701, 0.021805740892887115, 0.03618736192584038, -0.03656793013215065, -0.0012337417574599385, 0.0254292581230402, 0.013845890760421753, -0.011214541271328926, 0.07356790453195572, 0.013970826752483845, -0.03895308077335358, 0.010156380943953991, -0.04106241464614868, -0.015015735290944576, -0.0638812854886055, 0.03240291774272919, 0.002162138931453228, 0.001359801390208304, 0.005992237012833357, -0.018932843580842018, -0.07241873443126678, 0.006995683070272207, -0.0357481986284256, -0.05495557561516762, 0.05723518878221512, 0.023363223299384117, 0.0029831971041858196, -0.017723720520734787, -0.03348991647362709, -0.00919936690479517, 0.02004847675561905, 0.01448896899819374, -0.0002071554190479219, 0.06030058115720749, -0.031991519033908844, 0.021923406049609184, 0.04381578788161278, 0.012640547938644886, 0.08360190689563751, 0.0038197904359549284, -0.06101621687412262, -0.019962448626756668, 0.01186541561037302, -0.009829784743487835, 0.07210321724414825, 0.023919332772493362, -0.03208828344941139, 0.0003740739484783262, -0.011258398182690144, 0.001614857348613441, 0.06175314635038376, 0.05409964546561241, 0.031470950692892075, -0.004491167142987251, -0.08670881390571594, 0.027860397472977638, 0.06350624561309814, -0.01121046394109726, -0.04465462639927864, 0.06732360273599625, -0.03459033742547035, -0.06112481281161308, -0.0035511841997504234, 0.03954697027802467, 0.022963497787714005, 0.008249529637396336, 0.021888064220547676, 0.006029678042978048, 0.032051991671323776, -0.004867815878242254, 0.018909776583313942, 0.012178255245089531, -0.004322246182709932, -0.009966731071472168, 0.005585561040788889, -0.015197090804576874, 0.008240291848778725, 0.05028316751122475, 0.007428021635860205, -0.006801724899560213, -0.03890812397003174, 0.01817013882100582, -0.0028271868359297514, -0.010320160537958145, 0.0005791900330223143, 0.02117197774350643, -0.021704819053411484, 0.02860601805150509, 0.010940102860331535, 0.010365687310695648, -0.03174233064055443, 0.00011330563575029373, -0.01876750960946083, 0.007887864485383034, -0.007482608314603567, 0.005665315315127373, 0.0525081641972065, -0.013117584399878979, 0.01407074648886919, 0.00009226590918842703, 0.009302366524934769, 0.00261456286534667, -0.027716975659132004, -0.011533566750586033, 0.01677514798939228, 0.03624705597758293, 0.02054031379520893, -0.005610830150544643, 0.0030956093687564135, 0.026395544409751892, -0.030352437868714333, 0.006883484311401844, 0.044417399913072586, -0.009505842812359333, 0.0035718425642699003, -0.07195649296045303, -0.040887799113988876, -0.015002705156803131, -0.044515546411275864, -0.024489620700478554, 0.022507941350340843, -0.003991088829934597, 0.013367722742259502, 0.017034584656357765, 0.008034579455852509, 0.04781123995780945, -0.06027643382549286, 0.033608872443437576, 0.04875604435801506, 0.0096177002415061, -0.03587732091546059, 0.001985263777896762, 0.05606965720653534, -0.053267549723386765, 0.0428062379360199, 0.020656418055295944, 0.03263513371348381, 0.0089974794536829, -0.046114712953567505, -0.030289962887763977, -0.012104544788599014, -0.029424551874399185, 0.01382607314735651, 0.04693127050995827, 0.037621550261974335, 0.007691576145589352, 0.004700290039181709, 0.022504333406686783, -0.02625727467238903, -0.010047788731753826, 0.0003943582996726036, -0.08947811275720596, 0.043308719992637634, -0.08899161219596863, 0.01629253849387169, 0.019617605954408646, -0.0017668924992904067, 0.032062601298093796, 0.048759836703538895, 0.021204428747296333, 0.017786120995879173, -0.006614005193114281, -0.007677088025957346, -0.012619554065167904, -0.003174898447468877, 0.013501636683940887, 0.043884698301553726, -0.025493726134300232, -0.03641923516988754, -0.03159669414162636, -0.002572468714788556, 0.019526805728673935, 0.03641914203763008, 0.052377454936504364, 0.022497927770018578, -0.019388070330023766, -0.029039103537797928, -0.049961283802986145, 0.014395959675312042, -0.02729024365544319, -0.06919566541910172, -0.043616022914648056, -0.002345917047932744, -0.003960182424634695, 0.06285455077886581, -0.016310609877109528, -0.022390644997358322, 0.0029860674403607845, 0.07382646948099136, 0.04477125033736229, 0.021518878638744354, -0.012090389616787434, 0.02609502337872982, 0.015149341896176338, -0.01814441569149494, -0.005980690009891987, -0.02269156649708748, -0.018373630940914154, -0.03089197538793087 ]
<p>I know that half silvered mirrors are used in the production of laser emission. Can half silvered mirrors be used outside the instrument so the rays get reflected back on one side of the mirror and pass through the other side? </p> <p>What will be the result if a half silvered mirror is kept rotating and laser is made to pass through it?</p> <p>Similarly what will be the result if a prism is kept rotating and laser is made to pass through it? </p> <p>Series of prisms and mirrors are used in the instrument to produce laser but can we obtain more patterns (movement of laser in entertainment lasers) when we keep a rotating half silvered mirror and prism (different cases) and laser is made to pass through it?</p>
g7408
[ -0.010925110429525375, -0.01189100556075573, 0.024702738970518112, 0.022039487957954407, 0.025045903399586678, -0.005685439798980951, 0.07260236144065857, -0.0009963419288396835, 0.019171372056007385, -0.013835901394486427, -0.027969131246209145, 0.07330630719661713, 0.05400659888982773, -0.013657817617058754, 0.020048968493938446, -0.0036199812311679125, 0.02244093082845211, -0.02764294482767582, -0.002376964781433344, 0.089969202876091, -0.057648688554763794, 0.05447530001401901, -0.0449412502348423, -0.07074198871850967, -0.07523080706596375, 0.006176663562655449, 0.022025423124432564, -0.0052537210285663605, -0.03643888607621193, -0.01099231094121933, 0.01209595613181591, -0.027911003679037094, -0.003897752845659852, -0.014593824744224548, -0.006636889185756445, -0.040334977209568024, 0.07374981045722961, 0.06852641701698303, 0.003910432104021311, -0.011964756064116955, -0.0317121222615242, 0.016256282106041908, -0.0013678622199222445, -0.02435794100165367, 0.038426730781793594, 0.006332424469292164, 0.009551719762384892, -0.04229762405157089, 0.027255836874246597, -0.010237772949039936, -0.009110103361308575, 0.015936845913529396, 0.01444262731820345, -0.03195339813828468, 0.030360590666532516, 0.019338514655828476, -0.042321864515542984, 0.0016248819883912802, 0.054081033915281296, -0.06544958055019379, -0.02408001944422722, -0.04174267128109932, -0.051679231226444244, 0.046222586184740067, -0.006451811641454697, -0.031120754778385162, -0.02508961595594883, -0.00550376670435071, 0.00035060118534602225, 0.04515865445137024, 0.00001246964075107826, -0.021769773215055466, 0.027477171272039413, 0.0008151412475854158, -0.022702928632497787, 0.04642399400472641, 0.048881981521844864, 0.042415767908096313, 0.0016853726701810956, 0.03757631778717041, -0.1045437753200531, -0.0394795797765255, -0.04153061285614967, 0.014118521474301815, 0.10298270732164383, 0.08268383890390396, -0.05518636852502823, 0.023928971961140633, -0.005466729402542114, 0.03296298533678055, 0.05759513005614281, -0.00009342047269456089, 0.07092619687318802, 0.01891995035111904, 0.0030449272599071264, 0.045018188655376434, -0.030127109959721565, 0.02455928735435009, 0.002405861159786582, 0.0323132760822773, 0.008547468110918999, -0.0658358559012413, 0.044208724051713943, 0.0350932702422142, 0.03569081053137779, -0.018048161640763283, 0.02658037655055523, -0.018085405230522156, -0.08480379730463028, 0.004564534407109022, -0.020373428240418434, -0.04894404858350754, -0.055692460387945175, 0.044461335986852646, -0.05577823519706726, -0.0363493375480175, 0.0755787268280983, 0.013733739964663982, 0.029729744419455528, 0.06331796199083328, 0.0677340179681778, 0.01060190424323082, -0.051421474665403366, -0.003943773452192545, -0.0053024920634925365, 0.04275548458099365, 0.023549601435661316, -0.005345544312149286, 0.001163341454230249, 0.010502775199711323, -0.05568584054708481, 0.055510930716991425, 0.01958583854138851, 0.052130185067653656, 0.05651610717177391, 0.05481759458780289, 0.0236052218824625, 0.005523707717657089, 0.041921909898519516, -0.04650918394327164, 0.04907505586743355, -0.02514069899916649, -0.013812398537993431, -0.03239336982369423, -0.0034167126286774874, 0.04516657814383507, -0.023115677759051323, 0.007341567426919937, -0.009760099463164806, 0.051747117191553116, 0.006064985413104296, 0.034576285630464554, 0.05526501685380936, -0.03646589070558548, -0.0014733674470335245, -0.07501082122325897, -0.07158444076776505, -0.05333385244011879, 0.012569230049848557, -0.0272748451679945, 0.03276200219988823, -0.04521182179450989, 0.016229843720793724, 0.002809267956763506, -0.08808848261833191, 0.005774823483079672, -0.0006694138864986598, -0.06631333380937576, 0.001237724325619638, -0.03560255840420723, -0.03227124735713005, 0.00521610863506794, -0.006456376519054174, 0.022267205640673637, 0.06238937005400658, 0.0770641416311264, 0.029940666630864143, -0.011988713406026363, 0.02514420822262764, 0.017338912934064865, -0.02596941776573658, -0.03774791210889816, -0.045718174427747726, -0.06239909306168556, 0.008287704549729824, 0.06314735114574432, 0.025775203481316566, -0.09449688345193863, 0.014705044217407703, 0.03290681913495064, 0.025045596063137054, -0.005473430268466473, -0.03861815482378006, -0.009306839667260647, -0.05172966420650482, -0.018127605319023132, -0.012471004389226437, -0.03019966371357441, -0.027886956930160522, -0.003633819054812193, -0.011216595768928528, 0.030928533524274826, 0.0057472544722259045, -0.03302042931318283, -0.010780575685203075, 0.014421217143535614, -0.008213890716433525, -0.025348486378788948, -0.014149569906294346, 0.02300572767853737, 0.016421694308519363, 0.06232951208949089, 0.057781949639320374, 0.01978674717247486, -0.03648846596479416, 0.0359552726149559, -0.0013614257331937551, -0.0032514198683202267, 0.018687332049012184, 0.04060681536793709, -0.006169083993881941, 0.008122853003442287, -0.037758905440568924, -0.021105367690324783, -0.023057399317622185, 0.03230423107743263, -0.0174693800508976, 0.04143880307674408, -0.032209690660238266, 0.04775548353791237, -0.02481692284345627, -0.07572498172521591, 0.016944898292422295, -0.0568540021777153, 0.03794365003705025, -0.05821588262915611, -0.00011613987589953467, 0.059581954032182693, 0.036866363137960434, -0.05450774356722832, -0.006941395811736584, 0.006616880651563406, -0.05377882346510887, -0.03461458534002304, 0.03631400316953659, -0.03504891321063042, -0.010530488565564156, 0.03832700848579407, 0.016116051003336906, 0.034259095788002014, 0.013181202113628387, 0.005714981351047754, -0.011270529590547085, -0.016904698684811592, -0.005634564906358719, -0.013576249592006207, -0.048957303166389465, 0.017726998776197433, 0.012139135040342808, 0.014569844119250774, 0.0004830729158129543, 0.002088450361043215, -0.03569484502077103, -0.054844360798597336, -0.021401165053248405, -0.03188985586166382, -0.0549650676548481, -0.017945243045687675, 0.023048508912324905, 0.047557730227708817, -0.049001529812812805, 0.04716778174042702, 0.05740051716566086, 0.016084110364317894, -0.0008685167413204908, 0.007343206088989973, 0.015199706889688969, -0.06312199681997299, 0.0205489844083786, -0.022500785067677498, -0.0204504132270813, -0.05107511952519417, -0.08059056103229523, -0.010910993441939354, -0.00875393208116293, -0.012402210384607315, 0.03131313994526863, -0.007611616514623165, -0.030923297628760338, 0.06999284029006958, -0.07464650273323059, -0.04887758567929268, 0.0443580336868763, -0.02564319781959057, -0.03692108020186424, -0.00848387274891138, -0.01684671640396118, -0.00882874708622694, 0.02721429616212845, 0.005970006342977285, 0.00022928349790163338, -0.07142180949449539, -0.039108943194150925, -0.0014141459250822663, 0.0442010760307312, 0.025353016331791878, -0.052900128066539764, -0.013463528826832771, 0.0602341927587986, 0.011414398439228535, 0.005738607607781887, 0.020207775756716728, -0.014673315919935703, 0.020977133885025978, 0.01584894396364689, -0.015299929305911064, -0.03863675519824028, -0.01092060748487711, 0.03793852776288986, 0.04029092192649841, 0.0006053579272702336, 0.027748923748731613, 0.061946477741003036, -0.05951101332902908, 0.03499159216880798, -0.0015984795754775405, 0.020845500752329826, 0.00015210933634079993, -0.02544383518397808, -0.015316412784159184, 0.013127080164849758, 0.03490534797310829, -0.05320131406188011, 0.012369084171950817, 0.0028473439160734415, 0.03633629158139229, -0.0850362479686737, 0.006970165763050318, -0.0038170425686985254, 0.038979243487119675, 0.07089865207672119, -0.03354751318693161, -0.03099805675446987, -0.03717589005827904, -0.0009531193063594401, 0.002987306099385023, -0.03309085965156555, -0.014718666672706604, -0.0035091335885226727, 0.00320665305480361, 0.048863064497709274, -0.04145064949989319, 0.02831968665122986, 0.015514491125941277, -0.008920494467020035, 0.01911199651658535, 0.041453711688518524, 0.038607653230428696, 0.016589203849434853, -0.0224912092089653, 0.019438156858086586, -0.027658937498927116, 0.0161458607763052, -0.07733314484357834, 0.00923045352101326, 0.017895059660077095, 0.03985721990466118, -0.008066706359386444, 0.0171830877661705, 0.02236591838300228, 0.027481509372591972, 0.004926641471683979, -0.03345626965165138, -0.028489604592323303, -0.0352756604552269, 0.020461564883589745, 0.08082114905118942, 0.04092085734009743, -0.08458027988672256, 0.048839032649993896, 0.0027762483805418015, 0.0687432587146759, 0.02938036620616913, 0.015154081396758556, -0.005876585375517607, 0.04817967861890793, 0.006987429223954678, -0.0032155148219317198, -0.01158996857702732, -0.07395526766777039, 0.04787462577223778, -0.054655976593494415, -0.0279006976634264, -0.014812998473644257, 0.021349340677261353, -0.01837928406894207, 0.025907449424266815, -0.04739559441804886, 0.048477377742528915, -0.012404656037688255, 0.016770271584391594, 0.04872751981019974, 0.010177968069911003, -0.0374528169631958, -0.01025055069476366, 0.010672837495803833, -0.007966991513967514, -0.028739148750901222, -0.007355974521487951, 0.00007509459828725085, -0.07178546488285065, -0.009915069676935673, -0.014672831632196903, -0.02714429795742035, 0.037294644862413406, 0.040766146034002304, 0.013168693520128727, 0.038184378296136856, 0.0065206740982830524, 0.0009716569911688566, -0.040674012154340744, 0.06627556681632996, 0.06872566789388657, 0.047878239303827286, 0.02196153998374939, 0.022832371294498444, -0.0008438702207058668, -0.07026117295026779, -0.030645592138171196, -0.04792667180299759, 0.017123838886618614, -0.010992011986672878, 0.009516824036836624, -0.030532553791999817, -0.028030285611748695, 0.006887219380587339, 0.002862405264750123, -0.0013444507494568825, 0.011022192426025867, 0.034166254103183746, 0.0619230791926384, -0.01202290691435337, 0.02619824931025505, -0.02195732668042183, -0.011566698551177979, -0.008736046962440014, -0.03745054081082344, -0.0435045100748539, -0.00599877443164587, -0.05238617956638336, -0.05462762340903282, 0.02341536059975624, -0.06108493357896805, -0.021576790139079094, -0.04835831746459007, -0.013829118572175503, -0.017262905836105347, 0.0534093864262104, 0.05089472606778145, 0.015779409557580948, -0.04572339355945587, -0.010046863928437233, -0.014939122833311558, -0.01892867498099804, 0.02957836724817753, -0.021924521774053574, -0.04795796424150467, -0.05020512267947197, -0.04123835265636444, 0.004484988749027252, 0.01246936060488224, 0.03620579093694687, 0.040155600756406784, 0.10174492746591568, 0.014723684638738632, -0.059183526784181595, 0.0026087455917149782, -0.01259046234190464, 0.008687950670719147, -0.027013668790459633, -0.00031709944596514106, -0.01820041984319687, 0.05560406669974327, 0.0037941194605082273, -0.035322561860084534, -0.05383861064910889, -0.05085764080286026, -0.04202313348650932, 0.0033776643685996532, 0.008346132934093475, -0.01310967281460762, -0.025896817445755005, 0.037283025681972504, -0.02945624105632305, -0.034961652010679245, 0.02665131166577339, -0.009218930266797543, -0.05460883304476738, 0.014162649400532246, -0.023161467164754868, 0.007252372335642576, 0.01264753844588995, -0.01926240138709545, -0.02513509802520275, -0.003087040036916733, -0.027717867866158485, -0.021551011130213737, -0.045732468366622925, -0.01064626406878233, 0.06688987463712692, -0.024147171527147293, -0.042034946382045746, -0.0369439572095871, 0.002169604878872633, 0.03067912720143795, -0.037353549152612686, -0.012027792632579803, 0.060056593269109726, 0.013893394730985165, 0.009359541349112988, -0.028922218829393387, 0.0006183566292747855, 0.0073319352231919765, -0.03984741121530533, 0.038419101387262344, 0.01770596392452717, -0.03925381600856781, 0.022577764466404915, -0.0018782978877425194, -0.00930494163185358, 0.009622355923056602, 0.0517738051712513, 0.040295619517564774, -0.00983014702796936, -0.00801838282495737, -0.0667467713356018, -0.023386245593428612, 0.04208094999194145, 0.012744994834065437, 0.060121599584817886, 0.026628147810697556, 0.003034494584426284, 0.055963169783353806, 0.09538934379816055, 0.021199537441134453, 0.00042597888386808336, 0.005534624680876732, 0.04120567440986633, 0.013764512725174427, -0.01141408458352089, 0.033374860882759094, 0.08897437900304794, 0.021908732131123543, -0.03434203937649727, -0.03385203331708908, 0.032437074929475784, -0.015361246652901173, -0.027742790058255196, 0.04159491881728172, -0.04768397659063339, 0.014229685068130493, 0.04518947750329971, 0.020604228600859642, -0.02749462053179741, -0.021389666944742203, -0.0036105799954384565, 0.02126089110970497, -0.0029696731362491846, 0.026631489396095276, 0.04307975992560387, -0.017833895981311798, -0.0017549485201016068, -0.09530232101678848, 0.05294794961810112, 0.015181356109678745, 0.05662289261817932, -0.03220716863870621, -0.05748472362756729, -0.032277438789606094, 0.05083306506276131, 0.0014837465714663267, 0.04681150242686272, -0.02977338619530201, 0.05446070432662964, 0.017239809036254883, -0.013231804594397545, -0.005619633477181196, -0.027465278282761574, -0.05270297825336456, -0.05484083294868469, -0.06992579996585846, -0.02587025985121727, 0.03660111874341965, 0.028457915410399437, -0.01741187274456024, 0.007006075698882341, -0.011394904926419258, 0.05814260244369507, 0.025901447981595993, -0.002700064331293106, 0.02972053736448288, -0.008527376689016819, 0.033800121396780014, -0.03746575117111206, -0.03489631786942482, -0.019397618249058723, -0.04458899423480034, 0.0078611234202981, 0.03991096094250679, -0.05165526643395424, -0.03849241882562637, 0.005299333017319441, 0.018001602962613106, 0.037491172552108765, -0.03309069946408272, 0.02430444024503231, 0.0004958778736181557, -0.012694931589066982, -0.0010815243003889918, -0.030615832656621933, 0.011441890150308609, -0.07016166299581528, -0.01026905793696642, -0.02103235386312008, 0.0009404576849192381, 0.06266061961650848, -0.022426974028348923, 0.013106469996273518, 0.03202459588646889, 0.03320368006825447, -0.0047274865210056305, 0.006735320668667555, -0.025311868637800217, -0.02703845128417015, -0.008749841712415218, 0.050707098096609116, -0.06265432387590408, 0.02104019559919834, 0.046184275299310684, 0.0029255705885589123, -0.020696816965937614, 0.01630556583404541, 0.02241027168929577, 0.0307050421833992, 0.00893134530633688, 0.016671475023031235, -0.03597289323806763, -0.04410373792052269, -0.054281700402498245, -0.007116092834621668, -0.053511183708906174, -0.08298873156309128, -0.07765437662601471, 0.0466768816113472, -0.016421770676970482, 0.04833509400486946, 0.03574184700846672, 0.03906409814953804, -0.003958459012210369, -0.04669920355081558, -0.026891101151704788, 0.0017078133532777429, -0.02759290114045143, -0.017118435353040695, -0.02513648383319378, -0.021092131733894348, -0.007930593565106392, 0.038765158504247665, -0.0265054889023304, 0.019696226343512535, -0.016885120421648026, -0.020469456911087036, -0.03254091367125511, 0.020826857537031174, -0.019930724054574966, 0.013822462409734726, -0.02218087762594223, 0.02386213280260563, 0.01835302822291851, -0.01422079186886549, -0.044771116226911545, 0.009520197287201881, -0.005305150058120489, -0.01038409024477005, -0.06642567366361618, 0.011528520844876766, -0.03726069629192352, 0.030074860900640488, 0.050149403512477875, -0.12380190193653107, 0.021040454506874084, 0.024884195998311043, 0.04737555980682373, 0.03364850580692291, 0.003928090445697308, 0.003202255116775632, -0.010655133984982967, 0.03356349095702171, -0.0234717708081007, 0.015591460280120373, 0.023913562297821045, 0.057945024222135544, 0.025670167058706284, 0.00210526492446661, 0.008086321875452995, -0.009226907044649124, -0.03617685288190842, 0.027561618015170097, 0.04922361671924591, 0.03923150897026062, -0.02775791846215725, -0.0016048410907387733, 0.02757302112877369, 0.03927263244986534, -0.02411067485809326, 0.009606128558516502, 0.012065260671079159, -0.010019213892519474, -0.007471481338143349, 0.007692412007600069, 0.015755267813801765, 0.0544588565826416, 0.02270112931728363, -0.03333430737257004, 0.02700180560350418, -0.005607263185083866, 0.0019430279498919845, -0.0010430975817143917, -0.01895737461745739, 0.014561311341822147, 0.011474359780550003, 0.06959762424230576, -0.035191599279642105, 0.054102856665849686, -0.019194940105080605, -0.039358578622341156, 0.06961631029844284, -0.05684075132012367, -0.010350828059017658, 0.02194599248468876, 0.004781538620591164, -0.07052971422672272, 0.010312781669199467, -0.013588261790573597, -0.008510306477546692, -0.0214107446372509, -0.03433308005332947, -0.011095697060227394, -0.05896512046456337, -0.002287038369104266, -0.004725734703242779, 0.06537806242704391, -0.021931789815425873, 0.027353975921869278, 0.09029144048690796, -0.023410402238368988, 0.05551888421177864, 0.037688929587602615, 0.05915972217917442, 0.010925201699137688, -0.012241799384355545, 0.04326154664158821, 0.000452515872893855, 0.0015649694250896573, -0.048693858087062836, -0.04811800643801689, 0.0018892009975388646, -0.005421717185527086 ]
<p>Next semester, I am going to lecture about (the mathematics of) general relativity and I am still thinking hard how to organize and even more importantly how to motivate all the stuff.</p> <p>I am wondering what minimal assumptions I have to make about the objects and their relations to be able to interpret the formulae and their relation to classical Newtonian physics. I should explain further:</p> <p>I think the assumption that spacetime is modeled by a four-dimensional differentiable manifold M is fine and is easily to be motivated. I am also fine with assuming that we have an affine connection on the manifold because it can be measured by moving a (quantum) particle with spin along a closed loop and comparing spin direction (and relative position/phase for torsion) before and after going through the loop.</p> <p>Then we may assume that the holonomy of the affine connection lies inside the Poincaré group (because we measure no other holonomy). Using this, we can parallel transport a chosen Lorentz metric in one tangent space to each other tangent space, so we get a Lorentz manifold. (Usually texts on general relativity start with a Lorentzian manifold, but they do not explain where the measuring of lengthes and angles should come from — a rod is itself a complicated physical object).</p> <p>Now having such a manifold, we can write down the Riemannian curvature and the torsion tensor. For simplicity, let us assume that torsion vanishes for the moment. Given the Riemannian curvature, we can contract it and write down the Einstein tensor G. Now the Einstein field equations can be stated as a definition: "The Einstein tensor G is the stress-energy tensor", that is G tells us where we measure matter.</p> <p>Mathematically this is fine (and actually of no content). From the viewpoint of physics, however, we want to be able to interpret the so <em>defined</em> matter (or stress-energy tensor to be more precise) as what is usually consider to be matter (or mass density or pressure or stress). What other inputs do I need to achieve this?</p> <p>Do I have to add the geodesic equation for free-falling test particles, for example, or does this already follow from my definitions (that is the field equations) above (of course, one has to relate a test particle to the matter term)?</p> <p>I am aware of the geometric interpretation of the Einstein field equation which relates the trace of the stress-energy tensor to the second derivative of the change of the volume of a ball of free-falling test particles. In order to use this, one has to know the equations of motions for free-falling test particles first. Further, one has to compare with the change of volume in the Newtonian limit. But how would we then get the pressure dependent parts in the trace of the stress-energy tensor, because Newtonian gravity depends only on the mass (the 00-part)?</p>
g7409
[ 0.006826252676546574, -0.007653824519366026, -0.020171601325273514, 0.00031854366534389555, 0.008782022632658482, 0.04678935557603836, 0.04756952077150345, -0.008919253014028072, -0.053694382309913635, -0.008933580480515957, 0.03393477573990822, -0.021784350275993347, 0.05042006075382233, -0.04448109120130539, 0.014803499914705753, -0.008375958539545536, 0.057956818491220474, -0.01093808002769947, 0.01986652985215187, -0.020952071994543076, 0.07692736387252808, 0.0011098048416897655, 0.035456858575344086, -0.009602688252925873, -0.04692339524626732, 0.00254163914360106, -0.007501713000237942, 0.010768267326056957, -0.04595166817307472, 0.015183845534920692, 0.052308715879917145, -0.03182627633213997, 0.026100536808371544, -0.05933308228850365, -0.04736717790365219, -0.06278972327709198, 0.03648849576711655, 0.0623694472014904, -0.002540812361985445, 0.02620573155581951, -0.001008569379337132, -0.08161238580942154, -0.009852584451436996, 0.014825105667114258, -0.0019741288851946592, 0.0054561118595302105, -0.019874004647135735, -0.014217900112271309, 0.036844655871391296, -0.0022626847494393587, -0.020833950489759445, 0.06354586780071259, 0.03597342595458031, -0.017438329756259918, -0.008394548669457436, 0.010094898752868176, 0.018010249361395836, 0.010616485960781574, 0.09928062558174133, -0.002032548189163208, -0.035007596015930176, -0.0015392687637358904, -0.038794614374637604, 0.008471337147057056, 0.018173469230532646, 0.008397791534662247, -0.0591324120759964, -0.03626620024442673, -0.03578280285000801, 0.04118437319993973, 0.043674174696207047, -0.07501011341810226, 0.05132925510406494, -0.018894223496317863, -0.051157258450984955, 0.013944026082754135, 0.016520483419299126, 0.02065926603972912, -0.0015960814198479056, -0.05819700285792351, 0.03482471778988838, 0.020573453977704048, 0.054200220853090286, -0.031302694231271744, 0.1264275163412094, -0.02647894062101841, -0.009608657099306583, -0.009286636486649513, -0.02084491029381752, 0.059072062373161316, 0.062736377120018, 0.005880686454474926, 0.07054821401834488, 0.033166561275720596, 0.02454814501106739, 0.03790448233485222, -0.027019327506422997, 0.0307038314640522, 0.006284413859248161, -0.01650242693722248, -0.03760712221264839, -0.013018121011555195, 0.012019526213407516, -0.0549219511449337, 0.005185126326978207, -0.001907245023176074, 0.03128700330853462, 0.06856464594602585, -0.009050870314240456, -0.0223162192851305, -0.09348025172948837, 0.01782958209514618, -0.04269159585237503, -0.004992123693227768, -0.0684506967663765, -0.09757993370294571, 0.053189609199762344, -0.003792076837271452, 0.03011108562350273, 0.06597765535116196, -0.0360986702144146, 0.04196642339229584, 0.04256194829940796, 0.09051957726478577, -0.03931891918182373, -0.028409555554389954, -0.015648113563656807, -0.03263897821307182, 0.013727754354476929, -0.018268002197146416, 0.016154563054442406, -0.01559444423764944, -0.01982182264328003, 0.029144078493118286, -0.05012095347046852, 0.039527226239442825, -0.06924757361412048, -0.03700386732816696, 0.03035556524991989, -0.02732972614467144, -0.03810819983482361, -0.02692793868482113, -0.055285703390836716, -0.01915125735104084, -0.02774719148874283, 0.054412346333265305, 0.00905671902000904, -0.058590974658727646, 0.0036823907867074013, 0.0015238079940900207, 0.021258851513266563, 0.0940675213932991, -0.0020580182317644358, -0.003160596126690507, 0.0894765704870224, 0.00021031721553299576, -0.022958561778068542, -0.0443720705807209, 0.002922488609328866, -0.006408692337572575, 0.055268947035074234, -0.04670340195298195, 0.013214057311415672, 0.021764013916254044, -0.07600805908441544, 0.020692309364676476, -0.019658003002405167, -0.034568533301353455, 0.08896443992853165, -0.07768568396568298, -0.029988648369908333, -0.04304378107190132, -0.007271467708051205, -0.01505243219435215, -0.03771541267633438, 0.058846328407526016, -0.01052718423306942, -0.006276371888816357, 0.015096689574420452, 0.04091136157512665, 0.016013428568840027, -0.048203472048044205, 0.065268874168396, -0.002379811368882656, -0.047242600470781326, 0.02143530547618866, -0.008039422333240509, 0.01661890745162964, -0.026538481935858727, 0.014164259657263756, -0.041719384491443634, -0.020658930763602257, -0.013792775571346283, 0.03558594360947609, 0.009838790632784367, 0.01987573131918907, -0.005952369887381792, -0.01587515138089657, -0.005592833738774061, 0.07286962121725082, -0.0153345363214612, 0.01764729805290699, 0.019509023055434227, 0.042914897203445435, 0.03413277864456177, -0.013597697019577026, -0.03173483535647392, -0.005882548168301582, 0.01138975564390421, -0.01768314279615879, 0.12408516556024551, -0.05020029842853546, 0.06500154733657837, 0.015060195699334145, -0.03364073857665062, -0.027403179556131363, -0.003388108452782035, -0.014853239059448242, 0.021575354039669037, 0.02379639446735382, 0.0026716841384768486, -0.033290378749370575, 0.09273232519626617, -0.038537200540304184, -0.025824658572673798, 0.018236445263028145, -0.0037363984156399965, -0.04815896973013878, -0.007200770080089569, -0.04650450870394707, -0.06839907169342041, 0.04337429627776146, 0.019864240661263466, 0.017719008028507233, 0.04718396067619324, 0.009683068841695786, -0.00826694630086422, -0.002915189368650317, 0.03162849694490433, 0.02921231836080551, 0.03131303936243057, -0.003285646438598633, -0.02743765339255333, -0.04359026625752449, 0.04866238683462143, -0.012489421293139458, 0.04138025641441345, -0.012649444863200188, -0.025403980165719986, 0.017558887600898743, -0.017195070162415504, -0.03318684548139572, -0.06363371014595032, -0.00005883920312044211, 0.019213847815990448, -0.03254466876387596, -0.023465706035494804, 0.00707793515175581, -0.07600794732570648, -0.04627729579806328, 0.009710404090583324, -0.029597561806440353, -0.023618850857019424, 0.08841510862112045, -0.08545486629009247, -0.03713615983724594, -0.015534170903265476, 0.006620908156037331, -0.00044468033593147993, 0.0028084651567041874, 0.021785877645015717, 0.0322362519800663, 0.008071600459516048, 0.027812620624899864, -0.026667730882763863, -0.033482737839221954, -0.01823875866830349, 0.02616112306714058, -0.028057366609573364, 0.025940967723727226, -0.012490899302065372, -0.008908099494874477, -0.02903849445283413, -0.046458058059215546, 0.01524079218506813, -0.0729130282998085, 0.032693956047296524, 0.0460212267935276, 0.0009230009745806456, 0.010871273465454578, 0.001792916445992887, 0.07980268448591232, -0.011877480894327164, 0.0026644503232091665, -0.03930637240409851, 0.05362445116043091, -0.015894310548901558, -0.017815792933106422, -0.024605654180049896, 0.06393282860517502, -0.06209707632660866, 0.002470627659931779, 0.02741525135934353, 0.019613701850175858, -0.01828703097999096, -0.01229477021843195, -0.03431768715381622, -0.07085461914539337, 0.011300833895802498, -0.0324871763586998, -0.01334365364164114, -0.018938932567834854, 0.06232482194900513, -0.03658711537718773, -0.020924223586916924, 0.006709869485348463, -0.0009057827410288155, -0.02849973924458027, 0.01852140948176384, 0.005228775553405285, -0.009344294667243958, -0.006674322299659252, 0.046502016484737396, -0.040048934519290924, -0.015517688356339931, 0.05087462440133095, -0.07542610913515091, -0.026826905086636543, -0.04073726385831833, 0.011769834905862808, 0.05469407141208649, -0.020389113575220108, -0.003752020187675953, 0.01416708528995514, -0.031097687780857086, -0.03372769430279732, -0.02528103068470955, 0.007584193255752325, 0.04217202216386795, -0.027073580771684647, 0.011084109544754028, -0.03323668986558914, -0.016666069626808167, 0.03568503260612488, -0.01737789809703827, -0.037640102207660675, 0.019991736859083176, 0.021275833249092102, 0.019312333315610886, -0.06453265249729156, -0.01770571433007717, -0.05725197121500969, 0.009027635678648949, -0.034970905631780624, 0.010604768991470337, 0.03697311505675316, 0.04574080556631088, 0.06332893669605255, -0.003629320301115513, -0.01530234795063734, -0.024459974840283394, -0.023880213499069214, -0.024028025567531586, 0.05414595827460289, 0.022358978167176247, -0.018478278070688248, 0.012575875036418438, -0.003101128153502941, 0.006023384165018797, 0.000703372061252594, 0.046830371022224426, -0.00853628572076559, -0.051633164286613464, -0.014064181596040726, -0.0037882912438362837, -0.018413323909044266, 0.04081903025507927, 0.016741320490837097, -0.038756489753723145, 0.01501560304313898, -0.006037338171154261, 0.05319814011454582, 0.00492632482200861, 0.005329485051333904, 0.018661100417375565, 0.00814743246883154, -0.020093418657779694, 0.001546821091324091, 0.010016681626439095, 0.024703839793801308, 0.007441946770995855, -0.08277992159128189, -0.020504122599959373, -0.012710478156805038, 0.050768110901117325, -0.02038496732711792, 0.06956764310598373, 0.045214347541332245, -0.05486161261796951, 0.020422914996743202, -0.009266863577067852, 0.027088508009910583, 0.023761171847581863, 0.0006127178203314543, -0.0046737222000956535, 0.023423152044415474, 0.016300885006785393, -0.017929794266819954, 0.0028231553733348846, 0.0013155480846762657, 0.06246460974216461, -0.009452063590288162, 0.03204306960105896, -0.05761430785059929, 0.03900071233510971, -0.01622169464826584, 0.008111708797514439, -0.03759395331144333, -0.014521204866468906, 0.03935713693499565, 0.032656650990247726, 0.054350003600120544, 0.036370184272527695, -0.05901356041431427, -0.04702995717525482, 0.04668480530381203, 0.04712427407503128, -0.002418942516669631, -0.056765101850032806, 0.0022524562664330006, 0.014851180836558342, -0.01369495876133442, 0.02101261354982853, 0.00423672329634428, -0.042750127613544464, 0.032463960349559784, -0.07022882997989655, 0.05724852532148361, 0.01444825530052185, -0.01399066299200058, 0.060808900743722916, 0.05605566129088402, 0.002996057504788041, -0.03544428199529648, -0.04465092718601227, 0.05473250523209572, -0.03721492737531662, 0.01091458648443222, -0.043922603130340576, 0.000011539905244717374, -0.009643612429499626, 0.03541838005185127, 0.029575586318969727, -0.017462367191910744, 0.014854228124022484, 0.04012161120772362, -0.020890628919005394, -0.014385845512151718, 0.01270953007042408, -0.0034580829087644815, -0.03994596377015114, 0.020888714119791985, 0.04590119794011116, 0.023667417466640472, -0.0003662965027615428, -0.07451283931732178, -0.06612415611743927, 0.02788483165204525, -0.07568053156137466, -0.03347969427704811, -0.04264145344495773, -0.0186515711247921, 0.04887710139155388, -0.04054681211709976, 0.026852454990148544, 0.060116060078144073, -0.026969296857714653, -0.007707796059548855, -0.015966057777404785, 0.0012701129307970405, -0.015329599380493164, 0.02539655938744545, -0.0010929156560450792, 0.000987458392046392, -0.02559027634561062, 0.050490207970142365, 0.01774236187338829, -0.013117567636072636, -0.017023831605911255, 0.016079291701316833, 0.002030725125223398, -0.019718004390597343, 0.003744326764717698, 0.007766291964799166, -0.027294836938381195, -0.01270982250571251, 0.025139283388853073, -0.01799194887280464, -0.0111732492223382, -0.049943793565034866, -0.06096388399600983, 0.0625075250864029, 0.027879582718014717, 0.01810576394200325, -0.01611560583114624, -0.0034362839069217443, 0.037868235260248184, -0.028117336332798004, -0.03696442395448685, 0.07286263257265091, 0.0009448840864934027, 0.01303756982088089, -0.01709679886698723, 0.03751727566123009, -0.027157235890626907, 0.024918902665376663, -0.002909664995968342, 0.05140549689531326, -0.0362708680331707, 0.04071108624339104, -0.005827985238283873, 0.02697577513754368, 0.056828297674655914, -0.03101557120680809, 0.04410181939601898, 0.04268178716301918, -0.03323899954557419, -0.017955927178263664, 0.02586660534143448, 0.04336165636777878, -0.024009613320231438, 0.021296648308634758, 0.05170512571930885, 0.010371485725045204, -0.003731999546289444, -0.01502216886729002, 0.021677592769265175, 0.02691030316054821, 0.08639801293611526, -0.01506301574409008, -0.08253063261508942, -0.022989492863416672, 0.035330064594745636, 0.0360494889318943, 0.01460385974496603, 0.00726343784481287, -0.0436345636844635, 0.042487695813179016, 0.05443568527698517, -0.054349321871995926, -0.03906258940696716, 0.026107817888259888, 0.04281109571456909, -0.01168458629399538, -0.009648661129176617, 0.016291432082653046, 0.01882634311914444, -0.09328144788742065, 0.025062184780836105, 0.03444816917181015, 0.040730081498622894, -0.050464339554309845, -0.033542364835739136, 0.04096822813153267, -0.008402537554502487, 0.006994467228651047, -0.004419567994773388, -0.05903114378452301, 0.04825038090348244, -0.021686973050236702, -0.0328771248459816, -0.013403181917965412, 0.0007650064071640372, -0.027861863374710083, -0.027952546253800392, -0.021299978718161583, -0.036464009433984756, -0.05784578621387482, -0.011213354766368866, 0.047622378915548325, 0.0228265430778265, 0.04211471229791641, 0.031703218817710876, -0.051977138966321945, -0.036429163068532944, 0.018044771626591682, -0.04544886574149132, -0.017926283180713654, 0.0035286438651382923, 0.014698418788611889, -0.022433539852499962, 0.008906787261366844, 0.04097221419215202, 0.016158532351255417, 0.02705114334821701, 0.0016789763467386365, 0.02489793859422207, -0.05195050686597824, -0.02210354432463646, 0.05369226634502411, -0.0076009538024663925, 0.028317976742982864, 0.04285157844424248, -0.03855328634381294, 0.039423633366823196, 0.034406520426273346, -0.05446527898311615, -0.03184463083744049, -0.04058511182665825, -0.03740108758211136, -0.008280685171484947, 0.01879294030368328, -0.02187991887331009, 0.08103058487176895, 0.026463715359568596, 0.05898788943886757, -0.026629852131009102, -0.02711464837193489, 0.02126576378941536, -0.0671200379729271, 0.020035846158862114, 0.035106442868709564, 0.04065730422735214, -0.003265932435169816, 0.03916218504309654, 0.01695505902171135, -0.03234826400876045, 0.06124343350529671, -0.02525242045521736, -0.005167713388800621, -0.020071446895599365, 0.005964653100818396, -0.053259532898664474, 0.04051071032881737, 0.03199067339301109, 0.05899612605571747, -0.02285989560186863, 0.0010893945582211018, 0.022512441501021385, 0.06473951041698456, -0.0054208762012422085, -0.04729538783431053, 0.02236275188624859, 0.0014583885204046965, -0.0411151759326458, -0.064881332218647, -0.010107720270752907, 0.011602760292589664, -0.039340149611234665, 0.010046325623989105, 0.023850660771131516, -0.05235116928815842, -0.017679281532764435, 0.035539668053388596, -0.04417867213487625, 0.0130934938788414, -0.04054946079850197, -0.0009955990826711059, 0.07735875248908997, -0.055505041033029556, -0.042153555899858475, 0.007093849591910839, 0.004777464549988508, -0.03653828427195549, -0.06268905103206635, 0.06880699843168259, 0.01129081565886736, 0.005803941749036312, -0.009600253775715828, 0.03220916911959648, 0.014321785420179367, 0.00006383374420693144, -0.01973385363817215, 0.037616509944200516, -0.020250771194696426, -0.019513441249728203, -0.032491207122802734, 0.02392500452697277, -0.026270665228366852, 0.007558367680758238, -0.03231780603528023, 0.05589042603969574, 0.028739839792251587, 0.07119592279195786, -0.011694127693772316, 0.019932277500629425, -0.006185169797390699, 0.027455158531665802, -0.021615760400891304, 0.042630650103092194, 0.02656312845647335, -0.018025433644652367, 0.022334543988108635, -0.012713372707366943, 0.026542454957962036, -0.015505487099289894, 0.07248752564191818, 0.03441322594881058, 0.050792861729860306, -0.01750338077545166, 0.010651808232069016, -0.0004933232557959855, -0.0519685223698616, 0.00425634253770113, -0.025250183418393135, 0.0024170128162950277, 0.003295589005574584, -0.002345785964280367, -0.04995756968855858, 0.02189560979604721, 0.003781235544010997, 0.02534661442041397, -0.026780666783452034, 0.02395872212946415, 0.0086454963311553, 0.048340581357479095, -0.06438583135604858, 0.004234533291310072, 0.0015982668846845627, -0.035080958157777786, -0.0182136632502079, 0.00007372156687779352, -0.019366662949323654, -0.07029468566179276, -0.01452419813722372, -0.013188709504902363, 0.012223090045154095, -0.017384642735123634, -0.02812395989894867, 0.015859995037317276, -0.05363835394382477, -0.0361173190176487, -0.022895410656929016, 0.042635299265384674, -0.009532229043543339, 0.044712889939546585, 0.028005342930555344, -0.05028330907225609, -0.016519922763109207, 0.004520003218203783, -0.005575275979936123, -0.01777638867497444, -0.01098236907273531, -0.014916714280843735, -0.02462156116962433, -0.0338275283575058, -0.0006402833969332278, 0.05216674506664276, -0.0009414670057594776, -0.041312575340270996, -0.038416214287281036, 0.06378643959760666, 0.04262065887451172, 0.020620638504624367, 0.017571503296494484, -0.10334401577711105, -0.021793371066451073, -0.038910847157239914, 0.0538126677274704, 0.0037913990672677755, 0.02183803915977478, 0.01126097608357668, -0.030319036915898323, 0.012370559386909008, -0.035528793931007385, -0.0157840084284544, 0.02878161147236824, 0.02738076075911522 ]
<p>Yesterday my wife asked me that question, and I couldn't answer.</p> <p>Consider a car, in a sunny day, and that is consumes x gallons per mile. Considering that everything is equal, except that it's traveling in a rainy day, but at the same temperature as the sunny day so that air density is the same.</p> <p>Will the lower friction of the tires make it consume more or less fuel? And the fact that rain drops are falling over and in front of it ?</p> <p>I answered that it'll consume more fuel, since friction is what makes car move and that the rain will act against it... but I'm not sure ?</p>
g7410
[ 0.03209861367940903, 0.008422808721661568, 0.00939515233039856, 0.05294162407517433, -0.0020900052040815353, 0.02887861616909504, 0.02669428288936615, -0.03347194194793701, -0.036678239703178406, -0.040084559470415115, 0.03693592548370361, -0.08658241480588913, 0.016790170222520828, -0.0007173113990575075, 0.0019420715980231762, 0.042780980467796326, 0.019782710820436478, -0.007853378541767597, -0.012233203276991844, 0.029330844059586525, -0.005307637620717287, 0.0016859689494594932, -0.06580433249473572, -0.024695400148630142, -0.00815699901431799, -0.029123490676283836, -0.03434709832072258, -0.023135125637054443, -0.03184361755847931, 0.016309166327118874, 0.05951206386089325, 0.0024980695452541113, -0.035969819873571396, -0.05618273466825485, -0.0836438462138176, -0.012826058082282543, 0.056306906044483185, -0.00021150315296836197, 0.07073430716991425, -0.03903708979487419, 0.006346148904412985, 0.0150893684476614, 0.003231649985536933, 0.048629991710186005, -0.06344573944807053, -0.06497754156589508, -0.0028179509099572897, -0.0006445791805163026, -0.0040731108747422695, -0.006063532549887896, -0.027253039181232452, 0.0026384161319583654, -0.037290409207344055, 0.038023803383111954, -0.003036371199414134, -0.020968323573470116, 0.02219252660870552, -0.041409168392419815, 0.008067576214671135, 0.020844168961048126, -0.029168006032705307, -0.0036988521460443735, -0.02255762554705143, -0.012741625308990479, 0.07241548597812653, -0.05539345368742943, -0.007413872517645359, -0.0014490350149571896, 0.05212375894188881, 0.020444191992282867, 0.021132996305823326, 0.04328218102455139, -0.054439742118120193, -0.05729304254055023, 0.0218215174973011, -0.04709732532501221, -0.0018988281954079866, -0.006120404228568077, 0.0479426383972168, -0.0029421120416373014, -0.012193910777568817, -0.015933092683553696, 0.01558891125023365, 0.015602735802531242, 0.0878453180193901, -0.016292033717036247, 0.04236232861876488, 0.009903606958687305, 0.034744806587696075, 0.025099288672208786, 0.027514947578310966, -0.07025087624788284, 0.10175773501396179, -0.000890627212356776, -0.0077836462296545506, -0.01944947987794876, 0.0035090462770313025, -0.007044148165732622, 0.056537434458732605, 0.05607685446739197, -0.02834898792207241, -0.08606170862913132, 0.04161996766924858, -0.03987506404519081, 0.047103192657232285, -0.040649767965078354, -0.003541128011420369, -0.024937067180871964, -0.015048808418214321, -0.008229066617786884, 0.022791007533669472, -0.02627543732523918, -0.03886958211660385, -0.042154476046562195, -0.018529804423451424, -0.03102816827595234, 0.060514118522405624, -0.015075220726430416, 0.002783530857414007, -0.0002223118644906208, -0.03614987060427666, 0.07261719554662704, -0.01739019714295864, 0.060253553092479706, 0.02895781584084034, -0.029094509780406952, -0.0007610693573951721, 0.018181758001446724, -0.008338079787790775, 0.01957722008228302, -0.04095418006181717, 0.05970165506005287, 0.004945533815771341, -0.024174613878130913, -0.012948182411491871, -0.009863762184977531, -0.06790711730718613, 0.10811412334442139, -0.008127717301249504, -0.0030267382971942425, 0.06402547657489777, 0.0261322483420372, 0.031156647950410843, 0.03533322736620903, -0.07458330690860748, -0.002019992098212242, -0.07472717761993408, 0.03709825873374939, -0.044977959245443344, 0.02987886220216751, 0.0009817903628572822, -0.020292529836297035, 0.000493750732857734, -0.060210615396499634, 0.023396136239171028, 0.00743348291143775, 0.030312713235616684, -0.0006036002305336297, -0.038706399500370026, 0.025946179404854774, 0.012731242924928665, -0.011675503104925156, 0.058557767421007156, 0.01478839386254549, -0.04566666856408119, -0.007670477498322725, -0.030746139585971832, -0.01759437471628189, 0.032835815101861954, 0.008398745208978653, -0.02540319785475731, -0.03268042579293251, -0.09308019280433655, 0.010187606327235699, 0.023913739249110222, -0.004926459863781929, 0.06401863694190979, 0.024115968495607376, 0.018314193934202194, 0.031001318246126175, -0.003575411392375827, 0.006053641438484192, -0.014371058903634548, -0.0486702062189579, -0.0010306894546374679, 0.020288752391934395, -0.01327873021364212, -0.028277086094021797, -0.10353587567806244, 0.005961939692497253, 0.01987726427614689, -0.03970678150653839, 0.04010462760925293, -0.03408728912472725, -0.00037551362765952945, -0.005460189189761877, -0.03603171557188034, -0.02155551128089428, 0.0023310398682951927, -0.013322468847036362, -0.02084079198539257, 0.0034139801282435656, 0.021180635318160057, 0.012015447951853275, -0.0010997944045811892, 0.057572122663259506, -0.029473217204213142, 0.004185380879789591, 0.03931741043925285, -0.044921502470970154, -0.013785583898425102, 0.040898676961660385, 0.02529163472354412, 0.04069242253899574, 0.01656084880232811, -0.015082517638802528, -0.02231767773628235, 0.050429850816726685, 0.0012214184971526265, 0.012718046084046364, -0.0023306095972657204, -0.03618360683321953, -0.06454569846391678, 0.039351437240839005, -0.04920375347137451, 0.03600382059812546, -0.03967989608645439, -0.06260186433792114, 0.005205533932894468, 0.02768654190003872, 0.031101500615477562, -0.007843038998544216, 0.0020207713823765516, -0.03379632532596588, 0.014590427279472351, 0.008655778132379055, 0.06343496590852737, 0.028313741087913513, -0.002963610691949725, -0.03145798295736313, 0.014864029362797737, -0.018745182082057, 0.0028991135768592358, 0.026986973360180855, 0.05748501047492027, -0.041196610778570175, -0.055317237973213196, -0.013316228985786438, -0.007596190553158522, 0.021386586129665375, 0.043453190475702286, 0.045989345759153366, -0.04762362688779831, 0.023386219516396523, 0.023985058069229126, -0.027754750102758408, -0.043679129332304, -0.013389620929956436, 0.009217431768774986, -0.02997884340584278, 0.002357129007577896, 0.001546692568808794, 0.002230416750535369, 0.007263467647135258, 0.016674743965268135, 0.028899308294057846, -0.012868477031588554, -0.019532356411218643, 0.0178550872951746, -0.010493461973965168, 0.033978842198848724, 0.013036186806857586, -0.014592282474040985, 0.028066538274288177, -0.030529331415891647, -0.01638827659189701, -0.022928109392523766, 0.023684905841946602, -0.01279902271926403, -0.014406858943402767, 0.009868646040558815, -0.007455592043697834, 0.020522335544228554, 0.04597168043255806, 0.03782486170530319, -0.04236114025115967, 0.013477007858455181, 0.02586537040770054, 0.02756468951702118, -0.030775848776102066, 0.010074964724481106, 0.03827962279319763, -0.009088545106351376, 0.023298922926187515, 0.04018622264266014, 0.035838060081005096, 0.0356307253241539, -0.035621628165245056, -0.04861772060394287, -0.05025330185890198, -0.05253870412707329, 0.033706337213516235, 0.0070593347772955894, 0.038965389132499695, 0.009747400879859924, 0.07090484350919724, -0.08905886858701706, -0.05036890506744385, -0.05049075931310654, -0.019793935120105743, -0.014933588914573193, 0.051388487219810486, -0.01964065246284008, 0.039158500730991364, -0.07713397592306137, -0.005774458404630423, 0.019992489367723465, 0.013235839083790779, 0.0012949361698701978, 0.034593965858221054, -0.021108385175466537, -0.0012242854572832584, 0.027797240763902664, 0.0019846640061587095, -0.016735127195715904, 0.0896247997879982, -0.006410154979676008, 0.03081303834915161, 0.026540113613009453, -0.019155258312821388, 0.00639911787584424, 0.0298375952988863, -0.0451895073056221, -0.0020765275694429874, -0.031230583786964417, 0.045666877180337906, 0.032733090221881866, 0.07820776104927063, -0.018896691501140594, 0.04678211733698845, -0.02841859683394432, 0.01876996085047722, 0.03319408744573593, -0.02310575172305107, -0.007970516569912434, 0.03772331401705742, 0.01727537252008915, 0.02714533917605877, -0.014898414723575115, -0.0009163657668977976, 0.04603727534413338, -0.055647172033786774, 0.005214169155806303, -0.025338299572467804, -0.012507181614637375, -0.026814142242074013, -0.039316799491643906, 0.01849214918911457, 0.003835657611489296, 0.029036179184913635, -0.0016224079299718142, -0.021042313426733017, 0.029992448166012764, 0.017771059647202492, 0.007986383512616158, -0.05334669351577759, -0.05378019064664841, -0.03408294916152954, -0.03592249006032944, 0.03245733678340912, 0.06431390345096588, -0.014449983835220337, 0.0073537458665668964, 0.06400398910045624, 0.051891930401325226, -0.0037838276475667953, 0.08054032921791077, -0.0016898952890187502, 0.01814565248787403, 0.014881896786391735, 0.07807774841785431, 0.05288748815655708, -0.01961364783346653, 0.038890719413757324, -0.013532842509448528, -0.033630575984716415, -0.020207710564136505, 0.0095486119389534, 0.016846073791384697, 0.014491855166852474, -0.03832940012216568, -0.011747613549232483, 0.022046726197004318, -0.015309047885239124, 0.027411436662077904, -0.007057769689708948, 0.029797768220305443, 0.0011703576892614365, 0.006167590618133545, 0.03601013496518135, 0.030771104618906975, 0.047618743032217026, 0.024336956441402435, -0.011945041827857494, -0.006900179665535688, -0.014891753904521465, 0.03309145197272301, -0.0033921634312719107, -0.022657694295048714, -0.0651230737566948, 0.03470449894666672, -0.01942945457994938, -0.062435392290353775, 0.03702608495950699, -0.05429038405418396, 0.05146460235118866, -0.07099000364542007, 0.006260885391384363, 0.021773237735033035, 0.039711352437734604, -0.014287246391177177, 0.02902224473655224, -0.00766736501827836, 0.006570649333298206, 0.029554544016718864, 0.003643374890089035, 0.05285559594631195, 0.025470254942774773, -0.06402205675840378, -0.06774256378412247, 0.03744220361113548, -0.019313955679535866, 0.02252931334078312, 0.0025908052921295166, -0.0013870472321286798, 0.062156591564416885, 0.002523148898035288, -0.03012898750603199, 0.06084059551358223, -0.027742920443415642, -0.06489140540361404, 0.06388793140649796, 0.007381504867225885, 0.01448631938546896, -0.02940974198281765, 0.023072347044944763, 0.006419488228857517, -0.0021145078353583813, 0.0030435530934482813, -0.05520040914416313, -0.018116945400834084, 0.03047564998269081, 0.03186947479844093, 0.004402213729918003, -0.004485001787543297, 0.06283529102802277, -0.05785511061549187, -0.03437688201665878, -0.009082057513296604, 0.04941030219197273, -0.04243180900812149, 0.0406746044754982, 0.11922021210193634, 0.04835536703467369, 0.0020960671827197075, -0.0696578323841095, -0.009568075649440289, 0.031165553256869316, -0.022240690886974335, 0.0022204427514225245, -0.028397882357239723, -0.030392568558454514, 0.016342906281352043, 0.005073601845651865, 0.043395474553108215, -0.055670034140348434, 0.047209542244672775, 0.005113203544169664, 0.00011750327394111082, -0.001814661780372262, -0.04517850652337074, -0.004408143926411867, 0.055251993238925934, 0.032497063279151917, -0.0021885260939598083, -0.009565669111907482, 0.010855556465685368, -0.0020828733686357737, 0.05287720635533333, -0.027678892016410828, -0.030660901218652725, -0.005947490222752094, -0.01882633939385414, 0.013962067663669586, -0.0253550224006176, 0.022936534136533737, 0.04615132510662079, -0.014374484308063984, 0.003867898602038622, -0.04596404358744621, -0.019923916086554527, -0.0015963254263624549, 0.02739548124372959, -0.08657700568437576, 0.03476465865969658, 0.02125755324959755, 0.0857972726225853, -0.030913904309272766, -0.019115982577204704, 0.07430066168308258, -0.030036604031920433, 0.050582993775606155, -0.02181987278163433, -0.01347335521131754, -0.017471734434366226, -0.06474880129098892, -0.055815041065216064, 0.03981848806142807, 0.012448440305888653, 0.02644505724310875, 0.026330294087529182, -0.00799739919602871, -0.0007024896331131458, -0.0028437029104679823, 0.08379936963319778, -0.005444173235446215, -0.060459427535533905, -0.05701249837875366, -0.004576131235808134, -0.04306876286864281, 0.06526300311088562, 0.025819819420576096, 0.0544474720954895, 0.02143104560673237, -0.036414001137018204, 0.02995564043521881, 0.014054926112294197, 0.023301104083657265, 0.06207221746444702, -0.02405405417084694, -0.012756723910570145, -0.053387969732284546, 0.048849862068891525, 0.03888396546244621, 0.03606999292969704, -0.05314094200730324, -0.012657086364924908, 0.0031762528233230114, 0.009779363870620728, -0.06486459076404572, -0.02266377955675125, 0.07275979220867157, -0.08144006133079529, 0.013822844251990318, 0.02106468752026558, 0.01763787865638733, 0.027943946421146393, -0.01985008642077446, 0.0402778796851635, -0.057679370045661926, -0.03952682763338089, 0.03253095597028732, 0.04619228467345238, 0.01654927246272564, 0.04079393669962883, 0.0063674915581941605, -0.0270551610738039, -0.05059143528342247, 0.03348108381032944, 0.05688900500535965, 0.0559237040579319, -0.04912576451897621, 0.00007440632907673717, -0.05217381939291954, 0.021808480843901634, -0.006575870793312788, -0.015202841721475124, 0.0040199486538767815, -0.016627216711640358, -0.0007323396275751293, 0.044682033360004425, -0.09366125613451004, -0.022304831072688103, -0.01168406754732132, -0.026501337066292763, 0.024732308462262154, -0.016533492133021355, 0.05745156854391098, 0.02857048250734806, -0.019746651872992516, -0.03723742812871933, 0.021079663187265396, 0.014128281734883785, 0.029271235689520836, 0.006265086587518454, 0.005839994642883539, -0.05741340294480324, 0.021948600187897682, 0.0030957027338445187, 0.016228727996349335, 0.020817458629608154, 0.0241756122559309, 0.07152625173330307, -0.06427883356809616, -0.036424439400434494, -0.01957050897181034, 0.03942876681685448, 0.00353155261836946, 0.0025498298928141594, -0.023694993928074837, -0.0326504148542881, 0.023524709045886993, 0.016417259350419044, 0.041885435581207275, -0.004276110790669918, 0.026433909311890602, -0.06234992668032646, -0.0062097287736833096, 0.02543650008738041, -0.03984793648123741, -0.011470912024378777, 0.007383706979453564, -0.0153346573933959, -0.07475166767835617, -0.03168480098247528, 0.0041456641629338264, -0.03287488967180252, 0.02055167220532894, 0.07864474505186081, -0.03860854357481003, 0.042536646127700806, -0.014945924282073975, -0.051988594233989716, 0.05104248970746994, 0.0024619726464152336, 0.014588539488613605, -0.04836256057024002, 0.000642917410004884, -0.030423760414123535, -0.015422920696437359, 0.03108902834355831, -0.029145801439881325, -0.00654686288908124, -0.0154586061835289, -0.027376603335142136, -0.009685810655355453, -0.002294532721862197, -0.053707532584667206, 0.00027968923677690327, -0.026171475648880005, -0.05612371116876602, -0.041346583515405655, -0.04117024317383766, 0.022773277014493942, -0.025868430733680725, 0.014984394423663616, -0.0257501769810915, 0.07044973969459534, 0.03717322275042534, 0.020332178100943565, -0.012808387167751789, 0.006408508401364088, 0.012560141272842884, 0.04270938038825989, 0.018673639744520187, -0.005761616863310337, -0.004036140628159046, -0.005688146688044071, 0.0021714111790060997, 0.01637035235762596, -0.016815446317195892, -0.07374643534421921, -0.05284867435693741, -0.04043726250529289, 0.032844193279743195, 0.006207351107150316, -0.05111349746584892, -0.022789858281612396, -0.021176114678382874, 0.006952962838113308, 0.04382334649562836, -0.03299083560705185, 0.004651783499866724, 0.03148080036044121, -0.0035298506263643503, -0.06535522639751434, 0.005063799675554037, -0.041500672698020935, -0.027516068890690804, -0.07187871634960175, 0.01720210164785385, -0.0553411990404129, 0.007386115845292807, 0.025262318551540375, -0.06240767985582352, 0.008969220332801342, 0.05383765697479248, -0.03792233765125275, -0.05486087501049042, -0.029999716207385063, -0.016187766566872597, 0.012821989133954048, 0.020611995831131935, 0.011474325321614742, -0.017031759023666382, -0.009296548552811146, 0.0018808955792337656, 0.06183411926031113, -0.12196417897939682, -0.0009862148435786366, 0.023122336715459824, -0.02648273855447769, 0.015341646037995815, 0.038580529391765594, 0.06177813932299614, -0.023766353726387024, 0.062184035778045654, -0.03306156024336815, -0.05819521099328995, -0.0007409980753436685, -0.012961194850504398, -0.021335264667868614, 0.033595938235521317, -0.055432695895433426, -0.04522242769598961, -0.0270529817789793, -0.02140720561146736, -0.03232086822390556, 0.05302853137254715, 0.004245122894644737, 0.024780066683888435, 0.06073668971657753, 0.015117637813091278, -0.085573710501194, 0.030693916603922844, -0.02680153399705887, 0.039401307702064514, -0.031444162130355835, -0.010514012537896633, 0.013918821699917316, -0.04059947654604912, 0.015255304984748363, 0.03507426381111145, 0.00713586388155818, 0.013799996115267277, -0.06471076607704163, 0.033985428512096405, 0.07179252058267593, 0.04756534844636917, -0.006008599419146776, -0.014425394125282764, -0.01306859776377678, 0.002444466343149543, -0.008564924821257591, -0.016838211566209793, -0.0008692234405316412, -0.04790450260043144, -0.01625213772058487, -0.00035048945574089885, -0.04747727885842323, 0.026998387649655342, -0.0022093940060585737, 0.04244765266776085, -0.07652997225522995, -0.007893430069088936, -0.021710380911827087, 0.018408754840493202, -0.00015453599917236716 ]
<p>Since by definition we cannot observe black holes directly, how do astronomers determine the mass of a black hole?</p> <p>What observational techniques are there that would allow us to determine a black hole's mass?</p>
g7411
[ 0.0045523266308009624, -0.018470322713255882, 0.020279262214899063, -0.030523061752319336, 0.06992164254188538, -0.04093904048204422, 0.036377694457769394, 0.024674104526638985, -0.02572287805378437, -0.03402766212821007, 0.03106284886598587, -0.054389588534832, 0.05859614536166191, 0.02843879908323288, 0.00010393018601462245, -0.02085191011428833, 0.005320088472217321, -0.060855571180582047, 0.013901266269385815, 0.027547430247068405, 0.06408360600471497, -0.03995175659656525, 0.05730019509792328, 0.014340165071189404, -0.0651821419596672, 0.009848067536950111, -0.0033671571873128414, 0.03594803065061569, -0.02231942117214203, -0.004841962363570929, -0.011736184358596802, -0.0212095957249403, 0.048211757093667984, -0.002796825021505356, 0.051807548850774765, -0.025098007172346115, 0.005743793211877346, 0.02144109271466732, -0.02236252836883068, -0.002844505477696657, -0.017026860266923904, -0.026765739545226097, -0.008230910636484623, -0.008608473464846611, -0.0038430928252637386, -0.005505277309566736, 0.019119245931506157, -0.012397105805575848, 0.05487418919801712, -0.005515318363904953, 0.04800837114453316, 0.002632866380736232, 0.0908348560333252, 0.013918261043727398, -0.0025209628511220217, 0.056450482457876205, 0.026196815073490143, 0.010484721511602402, 0.09915035218000412, -0.04102804884314537, -0.03618071973323822, -0.004348194692283869, 0.03712603077292442, 0.01933343894779682, 0.04540504515171051, -0.056568440049886703, -0.05056774243712425, -0.018488625064492226, -0.004472957458347082, -0.010096580721437931, 0.039930351078510284, 0.021309982985258102, 0.015852469950914383, 0.003910704981535673, -0.06044260784983635, 0.0007888813270255923, -0.06415263563394547, 0.003207918955013156, 0.0014006668934598565, -0.012520940974354744, 0.03706847503781319, -0.03407410532236099, 0.006757163908332586, -0.0013148239813745022, 0.058889083564281464, -0.0025785895995795727, -0.05520884692668915, -0.03524800390005112, -0.0250055231153965, -0.005948007572442293, 0.025414811447262764, -0.0007678103866055608, 0.09441400319337845, 0.012361196801066399, 0.02422836236655712, -0.008467559702694416, -0.004788662306964397, 0.05052562430500984, 0.03324427455663681, -0.004387662746012211, -0.054831914603710175, 0.050238948315382004, -0.018944906070828438, -0.009062577970325947, 0.02819206193089485, 0.026316843926906586, -0.040609441697597504, 0.05579758808016777, 0.008952354080975056, 0.016023896634578705, -0.009382796473801136, -0.05462770164012909, 0.016602763906121254, 0.04008759185671806, -0.07963549345731735, -0.05159732699394226, 0.02944428101181984, 0.03938843309879303, 0.004712631925940514, 0.05333685502409935, -0.01622067019343376, 0.03937115520238876, -0.021981431171298027, -0.011930377222597599, -0.005683503579348326, -0.031699132174253464, 0.013999232091009617, -0.011474188417196274, 0.005200143903493881, 0.01700933463871479, 0.0156546663492918, 0.03359290584921837, -0.005480083171278238, 0.02791086956858635, -0.06151957809925079, 0.03106505423784256, 0.0010150535963475704, 0.0013874268624931574, -0.018259698525071144, -0.02033846266567707, 0.007260690908879042, 0.022182969376444817, -0.0016831348184496164, -0.0007744088652543724, 0.03870692104101181, 0.02970884181559086, -0.015910429880023003, -0.01771160215139389, 0.018436137586832047, 0.08050574362277985, -0.028505049645900726, 0.07167269289493561, 0.012802879326045513, 0.0015862510772421956, 0.05465263873338699, 0.009901013225317001, -0.010122425854206085, -0.021235156804323196, -0.0007114621694199741, 0.01675734668970108, 0.09758811444044113, -0.03597188740968704, -0.00598850566893816, 0.05066118761897087, -0.053290847688913345, -0.043854229152202606, -0.018572531640529633, 0.0002133126836270094, 0.03271447494626045, -0.045025333762168884, -0.01656636968255043, -0.016627591103315353, -0.007704178802669048, 0.0453992560505867, 0.03992798551917076, -0.005251842550933361, 0.005729906726628542, 0.024295581504702568, 0.04557739943265915, 0.048572830855846405, 0.06344279646873474, -0.03036046400666237, 0.029281824827194214, 0.001856194343417883, 0.0025524043012410402, -0.011899692937731743, 0.03441188111901283, -0.05011829361319542, 0.056780166923999786, 0.052865657955408096, -0.04159511998295784, -0.013434204272925854, 0.05907735973596573, 0.03294277563691139, 0.020264431834220886, 0.035510823130607605, 0.023773735389113426, -0.021182291209697723, 0.014708951115608215, 0.022510387003421783, 0.002178011927753687, -0.007347057107836008, -0.046451911330223083, 0.026731057092547417, -0.010381162166595459, -0.03338721767067909, 0.024071423336863518, 0.0048965103924274445, -0.017267759889364243, -0.006030452903360128, -0.007774034980684519, -0.008189551532268524, 0.006274369545280933, -0.01095607504248619, -0.07383850961923599, 0.08587905764579773, -0.04172171652317047, 0.03957955166697502, 0.012248655781149864, -0.009584374725818634, -0.0294206440448761, -0.02201657183468342, -0.033896543085575104, 0.015227735042572021, -0.026727916672825813, 0.06183180585503578, -0.025863345712423325, 0.015572839416563511, 0.03553842753171921, 0.018196584656834602, -0.02754424884915352, -0.02017769031226635, -0.00238882377743721, 0.0636720284819603, 0.06141963228583336, 0.0226239375770092, 0.017830997705459595, -0.005348977167159319, 0.0059036933816969395, 0.03002995438873768, 0.06982757151126862, -0.04411729425191879, -0.04033256322145462, -0.03980950638651848, -0.023579271510243416, -0.011951283551752567, 0.026903724297881126, 0.008858861401677132, 0.022729061543941498, 0.02092726156115532, 0.022143138572573662, 0.0073647224344313145, 0.010669898241758347, -0.058928217738866806, -0.0406656488776207, -0.0015884725144132972, 0.011561483144760132, 0.052744898945093155, -0.056233230978250504, 0.023033319041132927, -0.014594106934964657, -0.04390575736761093, 0.036261022090911865, -0.0003055223496630788, -0.05486088991165161, -0.09269120544195175, -0.10191971063613892, -0.0038654287345707417, -0.02015679143369198, 0.05080746114253998, -0.007333927322179079, 0.023147230967879295, 0.030552690848708153, -0.05299825593829155, -0.0037575699388980865, 0.0685415118932724, 0.010676133446395397, 0.025589151307940483, 0.06343504786491394, 0.01434196624904871, 0.048765987157821655, 0.023555681109428406, -0.07385025173425674, -0.007958048023283482, 0.04118076711893082, -0.028536701574921608, -0.007849089801311493, -0.013051839545369148, 0.0017966021550819278, -0.09156829863786697, 0.06365777552127838, -0.04683123156428337, -0.01182909682393074, 0.021346205845475197, 0.007326377555727959, 0.00929840374737978, -0.0173909030854702, 0.02862934023141861, 0.027268612757325172, -0.024688920006155968, 0.0008535785018466413, 0.010459257289767265, 0.0029766960069537163, -0.024899473413825035, 0.02952568419277668, 0.0296196099370718, -0.001697516068816185, -0.010454706847667694, 0.04571079462766647, -0.058880288153886795, 0.043304476886987686, -0.020448774099349976, 0.040385618805885315, 0.04431585222482681, -0.011016802862286568, 0.020668083801865578, -0.048354484140872955, 0.0149964839220047, -0.028568297624588013, -0.03756168484687805, -0.02170080691576004, 0.05702230706810951, -0.00029799004551023245, -0.012666735798120499, 0.03480858355760574, 0.002177253132686019, 0.039712607860565186, -0.07106263190507889, -0.08105722814798355, -0.04031657427549362, -0.016948727890849113, 0.012831615284085274, -0.05313500761985779, -0.012269128113985062, -0.0043505416251719, -0.014467940665781498, -0.03336922824382782, -0.047681014984846115, 0.04213442653417587, 0.008578657172620296, 0.0289887934923172, -0.038524314761161804, -0.04226772487163544, 0.0003956556029152125, -0.019453246146440506, -0.015147891826927662, -0.025006530806422234, -0.077104352414608, 0.03839349001646042, -0.05579063296318054, 0.02719046175479889, 0.004906877875328064, 0.020768415182828903, -0.048714105039834976, 0.018664272502064705, 0.033457353711128235, -0.0053741042502224445, 0.02404172159731388, 0.04172502085566521, -0.008903970941901207, 0.01689474657177925, 0.022123059257864952, 0.03400741145014763, -0.00018450689094606787, 0.036666132509708405, -0.03865533694624901, 0.07331766933202744, -0.046360328793525696, 0.04405486583709717, -0.02290024235844612, -0.03324318304657936, -0.0007474009180441499, 0.02286895178258419, -0.029516177251935005, 0.007999156601727009, -0.06993989646434784, 0.05299854278564453, 0.011042249388992786, 0.0173358041793108, 0.01968395709991455, -0.07188331335783005, -0.001500912243500352, -0.02023901417851448, -0.054046694189310074, 0.009062480181455612, 0.008964772336184978, -0.040822677314281464, -0.03386343643069267, 0.004554577637463808, -0.06808936595916748, 0.002143436810001731, -0.057414308190345764, 0.00045194706763140857, -0.08028946816921234, -0.016554290428757668, -0.018323343247175217, 0.016602322459220886, -0.016473473981022835, 0.05610456317663193, -0.021355047821998596, 0.037577904760837555, 0.056276511400938034, 0.04856843873858452, 0.027203068137168884, 0.021768394857645035, 0.0391080304980278, -0.03128178045153618, -0.013194904662668705, 0.011209179647266865, 0.013526725582778454, 0.03409648686647415, -0.01873735897243023, 0.003273620270192623, 0.0022662479896098375, -0.008456108160316944, 0.0028243265114724636, -0.023452676832675934, -0.010996561497449875, 0.013357279822230339, 0.01980549469590187, -0.01661514677107334, -0.06754013150930405, -0.04838366433978081, -0.00790275540202856, -0.041731931269168854, 0.055164944380521774, -0.014480364508926868, -0.0033065106254070997, -0.018028073012828827, 0.02727089449763298, 0.03910820558667183, -0.04841397702693939, 0.017911396920681, 0.0433243103325367, -0.04646840691566467, 0.035965241491794586, 0.03093809261918068, 0.017260564491152763, 0.03867177292704582, -0.01768689975142479, 0.04038090631365776, 0.020578589290380478, -0.08550440520048141, -0.024296000599861145, -0.013950761407613754, 0.028826599940657616, 0.014171441085636616, 0.019214250147342682, -0.059365954250097275, 0.021571198478341103, -0.02373501844704151, -0.05271482095122337, -0.053522739559412, -0.027529150247573853, -0.009607440792024136, 0.007646664511412382, -0.053859177976846695, 0.08948037028312683, 0.004546028096228838, 0.022103480994701385, -0.054455071687698364, -0.053785569965839386, 0.02548731304705143, 0.05244017019867897, 0.016980325803160667, -0.005441256798803806, -0.010745822452008724, -0.04469819739460945, -0.012734907679259777, 0.000043164352973690256, -0.09106281399726868, 0.04862853139638901, 0.04821702837944031, 0.008182781748473644, -0.034196194261312485, -0.039263561367988586, -0.07179799675941467, -0.036540448665618896, 0.02603941410779953, -0.04239427298307419, -0.0008832020685076714, 0.0038885092362761497, 0.027484992519021034, 0.007794888224452734, 0.011849833652377129, 0.029296139255166054, -0.03283802792429924, 0.0183392520993948, -0.036167655140161514, 0.014510607346892357, -0.031301386654376984, 0.054593220353126526, 0.011738418601453304, -0.0014043595874682069, -0.06375069171190262, -0.060063306242227554, 0.016964353621006012, 0.0013550432631745934, 0.06249237805604935, 0.015362588688731194, -0.023682359606027603, 0.02922486513853073, 0.0003544582868926227, 0.030947508290410042, 0.019877005368471146, 0.030339473858475685, 0.001495053875260055, -0.029377026483416557, 0.0019956021569669247, 0.04090546444058418, -0.03522142395377159, 0.03212904557585716, -0.01726747676730156, 0.04869558662176132, 0.0399666391313076, -0.01324787549674511, 0.038105737417936325, 0.019806180149316788, 0.0016654880018904805, 0.004057576879858971, -0.0439051017165184, -0.025532836094498634, 0.01654776930809021, 0.07662002742290497, 0.054249126464128494, -0.03173793479800224, -0.01882723718881607, 0.016033457592129707, 0.01789206452667713, -0.04414261132478714, -0.0013782369205728173, -0.058165036141872406, 0.03842310979962349, -0.05381802096962929, 0.011020692996680737, 0.0025880513712763786, 0.009475372731685638, -0.024953193962574005, 0.04196977615356445, 0.005628569051623344, -0.015258364379405975, 0.0029072179459035397, 0.02975396066904068, 0.05748767778277397, 0.07437808811664581, -0.02120276540517807, 0.0014364186208695173, 0.03964986279606819, 0.042924050241708755, -0.019562413915991783, -0.09443102031946182, 0.05756589025259018, -0.06400132924318314, 0.0395168736577034, -0.01309394184499979, 0.05601813644170761, -0.027999982237815857, -0.013300132006406784, -0.050785988569259644, -0.026760146021842957, -0.00406167795881629, -0.013048260472714901, 0.012884950265288353, -0.011022764258086681, 0.0066854218021035194, -0.02402682788670063, -0.00604452658444643, 0.0009342489065602422, 0.0006285530398599803, -0.033680010586977005, -0.08949746191501617, -0.018101949244737625, -0.04090135917067528, 0.0024531371891498566, 0.0008094696677289903, 0.0368272103369236, -0.007743815891444683, 0.08237005770206451, 0.01271159015595913, -0.02374092862010002, 0.033069759607315063, -0.0006657448830083013, 0.062289174646139145, -0.06426991522312164, 0.012601329945027828, 0.018184157088398933, 0.01962769776582718, 0.045501213520765305, -0.035176172852516174, 0.036927480250597, -0.002683932427316904, 0.021490372717380524, -0.006949663162231445, -0.04540659114718437, -0.06710649281740189, -0.03633838891983032, -0.048739198595285416, 0.02554706297814846, 0.025036441162228584, -0.019925257191061974, -0.013155834749341011, 0.002516745822504163, -0.023630382493138313, -0.013570782728493214, -0.004893158562481403, -0.013724669814109802, -0.034495070576667786, -0.03676940128207207, 0.0367058590054512, -0.07214699685573578, -0.06698451191186905, 0.02326798066496849, -0.011150826700031757, 0.00564061664044857, -0.03802219778299332, 0.04827115684747696, -0.056777678430080414, -0.01674439013004303, -0.010003921575844288, -0.04437432438135147, 0.01251479797065258, 0.029954232275485992, 0.011090545915067196, -0.032267455011606216, 0.06099655479192734, 0.025484902784228325, -0.02395971119403839, 0.01962345652282238, 0.07356389611959457, 0.004743659403175116, -0.004674158059060574, 0.03251151368021965, -0.007647331804037094, 0.0023457121569663286, 0.044400282204151154, 0.0364527553319931, 0.010215448215603828, 0.05029033124446869, 0.05037686228752136, -0.02339118719100952, -0.007926694117486477, -0.03975866362452507, -0.004292131867259741, 0.037521105259656906, -0.05920301377773285, -0.010412810370326042, -0.01795325241982937, 0.06748788803815842, -0.06306249648332596, -0.015607360750436783, -0.001990785589441657, -0.06208116188645363, -0.014513619244098663, -0.03643513470888138, -0.026098119094967842, 0.04060514271259308, -0.0019633604679256678, 0.022029293701052666, 0.06000218540430069, -0.05391009524464607, -0.025504611432552338, 0.021624507382512093, -0.028463007882237434, -0.015407461673021317, 0.038855139166116714, -0.03374435752630234, 0.004945631604641676, -0.017360690981149673, -0.0650184154510498, -0.002791214734315872, 0.02162620611488819, -0.021245252341032028, -0.060087352991104126, -0.008487130515277386, -0.00799467135220766, -0.08536337316036224, -0.028876882046461105, 0.013496902771294117, -0.022552812471985817, 0.002770061371847987, -0.0279279462993145, 0.018349546939134598, 0.0038336666766554117, 0.010436193086206913, 0.006348307244479656, 0.04344296455383301, -0.04070558026432991, 0.045299068093299866, 0.04152387008070946, -0.01659482903778553, -0.04027629643678665, 0.05303897336125374, 0.021211428567767143, -0.05719125270843506, -0.027188735082745552, -0.05006399005651474, 0.02346755936741829, -0.018874123692512512, -0.010585558600723743, -0.016791734844446182, -0.034761086106300354, -0.02842612750828266, 0.08943330496549606, -0.05287022516131401, -0.009847257286310196, -0.023944556713104248, -0.052783455699682236, 0.0037425209302455187, -0.024181518703699112, 0.061976056545972824, 0.03852125629782677, -0.008546019904315472, -0.04248004034161568, 0.0020716171711683273, -0.02491198293864727, -0.052089203149080276, -0.027252789586782455, 0.005312500987201929, -0.04512554034590721, -0.016333093866705894, -0.005448698531836271, 0.03688732534646988, 0.042446568608284, -0.06402607262134552, 0.00031760509591549635, -0.01605893298983574, 0.04713895916938782, 0.062246181070804596, -0.051520075649023056, -0.03704426810145378, -0.0003124353534076363, 0.040495216846466064, 0.01194150559604168, 0.024064647033810616, -0.05065157637000084, 0.022758549079298973, 0.0164688378572464, -0.016815168783068657, 0.003476035548374057, 0.016306890174746513, 0.03138362988829613, 0.00457133399322629, 0.00011398802598705515, -0.04205355793237686, 0.047998685389757156, -0.0383906364440918, -0.01067554671317339, 0.05602773651480675, 0.0487387478351593, 0.0434764064848423, -0.00019339624850545079, 0.06255532801151276, 0.02919837273657322, -0.0013919565826654434, -0.0769701674580574, -0.03902765363454819, -0.024923287332057953, -0.036335207521915436, -0.0770225077867508, 0.040832486003637314, 0.018283279612660408, 0.07622646540403366, 0.00895241741091013, 0.0072206468321383, -0.04766770824790001, -0.03435787186026573, 0.058626238256692886, -0.024908624589443207 ]
<p>How much of the Earth would a spoonful of the Sun scorch if held at ground level?</p> <p>I basically would like to conceptualize the heat of the Sun on a smaller scale, please.</p>
g7412
[ 0.02990271896123886, 0.06334774941205978, -0.014343011192977428, -0.013022642582654953, -0.048917483538389206, 0.02235909178853035, -0.019674908369779587, 0.02462814189493656, -0.008506106212735176, -0.010324790142476559, 0.02247540093958378, 0.02038894034922123, 0.0235756728798151, 0.015147599391639233, 0.0353928878903389, 0.021298671141266823, -0.01908143423497677, -0.03570456802845001, 0.03721681609749794, 0.03896043077111244, 0.003337592352181673, -0.057855069637298584, 0.018330922350287437, -0.04731941595673561, -0.08302547037601471, -0.009901626035571098, -0.02864394709467888, 0.005412115715444088, -0.044599149376153946, -0.035398054867982864, -0.0032210908830165863, 0.020429007709026337, -0.028080934658646584, -0.029758770018815994, -0.047791216522455215, -0.05399763956665993, 0.02476077526807785, 0.00978881772607565, -0.018352879211306572, -0.03360180929303169, 0.05424698814749718, -0.014796935021877289, 0.07975786179304123, 0.03872378543019295, 0.047384146600961685, -0.0026292335242033005, -0.013955146074295044, 0.049676910042762756, 0.017579268664121628, 0.010359033942222595, -0.005430151242762804, 0.018150096759200096, 0.0071789720095694065, -0.020828986540436745, -0.00930517166852951, -0.08957989513874054, 0.03462674468755722, -0.014429250732064247, 0.03740039840340614, 0.06280238926410675, 0.07003232091665268, -0.030617589130997658, -0.021908750757575035, -0.044827695935964584, -0.012640675529837608, 0.060167454183101654, -0.017570050433278084, -0.027060924097895622, -0.0025363739114254713, -0.030114393681287766, -0.0007124110707081854, -0.02027798630297184, -0.029206624254584312, -0.051164571195840836, -0.0647670328617096, -0.027085449546575546, -0.035726916044950485, 0.04640333354473114, 0.06831013411283493, 0.05622765049338341, -0.01800549402832985, 0.00477326475083828, 0.033593498170375824, -0.012734641321003437, 0.002474011853337288, -0.05554674565792084, -0.05154145509004593, 0.04365304484963417, -0.007174651604145765, 0.021049410104751587, 0.004442187957465649, 0.0050131287425756454, 0.1141904965043068, 0.004387145861983299, 0.029584595933556557, -0.02288287878036499, 0.023831244558095932, 0.05078888311982155, -0.03812963142991066, -0.003960595931857824, -0.025664642453193665, -0.016882767900824547, 0.0337383970618248, 0.006605277303606272, 0.022722264751791954, -0.005532807670533657, -0.04267016798257828, 0.0017400692449882627, 0.005238870624452829, -0.013968557119369507, 0.0417674295604229, -0.021529989317059517, -0.04330645129084587, -0.027582945302128792, 0.0066677359864115715, -0.027343137189745903, 0.018118996173143387, -0.006625766400247812, 0.05888242647051811, 0.004776220303028822, 0.04068051278591156, 0.025940977036952972, -0.022604871541261673, 0.07463957369327545, 0.031775154173374176, 0.014208045788109303, 0.028825320303440094, -0.05199423432350159, 0.016757911071181297, -0.017450004816055298, -0.0012073557591065764, 0.005107728764414787, -0.04705093055963516, 0.01215855311602354, 0.05959046259522438, 0.02433420717716217, -0.004435247275978327, 0.021585773676633835, -0.01949721947312355, -0.005598088726401329, 0.03265683725476265, 0.010489348322153091, 0.007600241806358099, -0.009303919039666653, -0.035664256662130356, 0.05869169160723686, -0.024020470678806305, 0.011231126263737679, 0.05085764080286026, -0.002953875344246626, 0.021457169204950333, 0.02693047560751438, 0.027378926053643227, -0.05560115724802017, 0.005504474975168705, -0.008092083968222141, 0.00889125932008028, -0.017244873568415642, 0.0022119649220257998, -0.002804892137646675, -0.011065764352679253, -0.053697291761636734, 0.05142540484666824, -0.029220622032880783, -0.034750159829854965, 0.011396455578505993, -0.06251678615808487, -0.0490574836730957, -0.07099976390600204, 0.002653564093634486, -0.023583482950925827, -0.008906945586204529, -0.038177426904439926, -0.0018041125731542706, -0.13328026235103607, 0.03377046063542366, 0.038975898176431656, 0.013913809321820736, 0.05745402351021767, 0.006671876180917025, 0.017784738913178444, -0.027979308739304543, 0.004225021693855524, 0.025406837463378906, 0.0629163384437561, 0.027789073064923286, 0.005869964603334665, -0.05814271792769432, 0.0563921257853508, 0.015512160025537014, -0.01252775825560093, -0.05012504383921623, 0.004989015869796276, 0.009375684894621372, 0.028569350019097328, -0.017270494252443314, -0.0033392789773643017, -0.006534572225064039, -0.0015753911575302482, -0.015064964070916176, 0.007599742617458105, 0.04302994906902313, -0.014679517596960068, 0.0032513802871108055, -0.01107738632708788, 0.0292669627815485, -0.01980508863925934, 0.006944386754184961, -0.02067025750875473, 0.008200913667678833, 0.032204873859882355, -0.03617292270064354, 0.04643861949443817, -0.008115896955132484, -0.037115924060344696, 0.046210356056690216, -0.014687848277390003, 0.01372001226991415, -0.02038172259926796, -0.0051451511681079865, 0.027410633862018585, 0.08967150747776031, 0.015270096249878407, -0.03071584552526474, 0.021206073462963104, 0.06163237616419792, -0.06317981332540512, 0.03823645040392876, 0.038916416466236115, 0.05467844381928444, -0.03139550983905792, -0.01326663326472044, -0.033222395926713943, -0.032728537917137146, -0.05247797816991806, 0.03377215191721916, 0.0213310569524765, -0.01824634149670601, -0.009599779732525349, 0.039738718420267105, -0.005047933664172888, 0.011559468694031239, -0.01047024130821228, 0.041987765580415726, -0.01600288599729538, -0.06904510408639908, 0.022679030895233154, 0.014154589734971523, 0.007965452037751675, 0.024649297818541527, 0.010524218901991844, -0.028179656714200974, 0.0073960102163255215, 0.04338657855987549, -0.009334246627986431, 0.013790411874651909, -0.033269092440605164, -0.008143953047692776, -0.047985684126615524, -0.042671989649534225, -0.0005468962481245399, -0.06492407619953156, 0.009512585587799549, -0.021150104701519012, -0.033506788313388824, -0.07556185126304626, -0.03373793512582779, 0.0062027983367443085, 0.043457064777612686, 0.031868550926446915, 0.02404082380235195, 0.043926868587732315, -0.016389794647693634, 0.04230249300599098, 0.007631856016814709, 0.019655881449580193, 0.0017257911385968328, -0.028882233425974846, 0.01875351555645466, -0.05333605781197548, 0.019622934982180595, 0.05423324927687645, -0.011500515043735504, 0.0697292760014534, 0.03934438154101372, -0.04789981618523598, -0.06235989183187485, 0.05830146372318268, -0.01544397883117199, 0.00044244411401450634, -0.010894074104726315, 0.01790275052189827, 0.025381457060575485, 0.011176832020282745, 0.007116951979696751, -0.00074994150782004, 0.03432371839880943, -0.040756985545158386, -0.023322168737649918, 0.04368043690919876, 0.04853068292140961, -0.06026177853345871, -0.007902476005256176, -0.0221188273280859, -0.0541703999042511, -0.0067426906898617744, -0.01864141970872879, -0.04752237722277641, 0.04404686018824577, -0.05952411890029907, -0.019667508080601692, -0.003942201845347881, 0.009358846582472324, -0.00628285575658083, -0.07175631076097488, -0.050960663706064224, -0.03288267180323601, 0.02758459374308586, 0.020023643970489502, 0.00023669291113037616, 0.00600805226713419, -0.0722397118806839, -0.03428015857934952, 0.009481890127062798, -0.049718208611011505, 0.09632161259651184, -0.049870364367961884, -0.08178207278251648, 0.010411224327981472, -0.02297178842127323, -0.014802039600908756, -0.0008251105318777263, -0.0725514218211174, -0.016181468963623047, 0.014660552144050598, 0.03257358446717262, -0.030434850603342056, -0.03903816640377045, 0.02222452685236931, 0.026035403832793236, -0.012714331969618797, -0.022921493276953697, -0.03979134559631348, -0.060699909925460815, 0.04795105755329132, 0.03702942281961441, -0.03296127915382385, -0.026407822966575623, -0.03241300955414772, -0.011538862250745296, 0.05006279796361923, -0.08867324143648148, -0.015901129692792892, -0.04201333969831467, -0.014733316376805305, 0.049249112606048584, -0.01604885794222355, 0.033079277724027634, -0.03004947490990162, 0.00661074835807085, 0.026120318099856377, 0.03291385993361473, 0.005531178321689367, -0.03752477467060089, 0.017663994804024696, 0.01023868378251791, -0.03956111893057823, 0.02095010317862034, 0.011121495626866817, 0.007567921187728643, -0.019123036414384842, 0.01531853899359703, -0.002673212205991149, 0.03916601464152336, 0.022546229884028435, -0.00025360166910104454, 0.07007763534784317, -0.023610906675457954, 0.01934240758419037, 0.044768452644348145, 0.009142507798969746, -0.007926790043711662, -0.002933504758402705, 0.035133857280015945, 0.01348934881389141, 0.0071317283436656, -0.0011584375752136111, -0.017983192577958107, -0.01992359198629856, 0.01580406352877617, 0.013557685539126396, -0.10670437663793564, 0.006042538210749626, 0.021179912611842155, 0.025336556136608124, 0.010032574646174908, 0.007091151550412178, 0.045796651393175125, -0.01954684592783451, 0.034671600908041, 0.06510305404663086, 0.032589688897132874, 0.11473263800144196, -0.04651052504777908, -0.0023210407234728336, 0.042841579765081406, 0.0419684536755085, -0.022356921806931496, -0.03188151493668556, 0.004918798804283142, 0.036717407405376434, 0.04224485158920288, -0.012606598436832428, 0.01367866713553667, 0.02747906558215618, -0.04117196798324585, 0.0005968488403595984, -0.022868448868393898, 0.05033621937036514, -0.006885263603180647, -0.08438216149806976, 0.018151940777897835, -0.009288976900279522, -0.015193171799182892, -0.025901542976498604, 0.027897600084543228, -0.013909795321524143, -0.01604888215661049, 0.003119295695796609, -0.008598480373620987, 0.04444384574890137, 0.024699058383703232, -0.02584061771631241, 0.026740966364741325, -0.05230219289660454, 0.03131458908319473, -0.016804484650492668, -0.04713064804673195, -0.09446290135383606, -0.007776869926601648, 0.018450330942869186, 0.028089508414268494, 0.013509525917470455, 0.045922305434942245, 0.035315386950969696, 0.011770054697990417, 0.00585373817011714, -0.06527161598205566, -0.023138955235481262, -0.01466688234359026, -0.03420552238821983, 0.0160883329808712, -0.031565625220537186, 0.009795882739126682, -0.05003198981285095, 0.04286901652812958, -0.06920497119426727, -0.012630254030227661, -0.02565186470746994, 0.058676574379205704, -0.05335962027311325, 0.007593355607241392, -0.013899385929107666, -0.004854902625083923, 0.020515842363238335, -0.08408360183238983, -0.023043572902679443, 0.05395655333995819, 0.01697486639022827, -0.007497754879295826, 0.02992515079677105, -0.03816962242126465, 0.02711724117398262, -0.004481852054595947, 0.02800506167113781, 0.052203744649887085, -0.012800216674804688, -0.018853306770324707, -0.002745863050222397, -0.004334121476858854, 0.008562065660953522, 0.06257089972496033, -0.0035544049460440874, 0.014158601872622967, -0.007366363890469074, 0.00996274035423994, -0.04494861513376236, 0.029793499037623405, -0.01823529414832592, 0.03440816327929497, -0.04167792946100235, -0.022824058309197426, -0.01596854254603386, 0.03743646666407585, -0.041649412363767624, -0.002518788445740938, -0.0071485284715890884, -0.0323440358042717, 0.06453671306371689, 0.044901907444000244, 0.0011837435886263847, 0.0740567073225975, 0.010999251157045364, -0.022701120004057884, 0.022228853777050972, -0.02613588236272335, 0.011822959408164024, -0.02516299858689308, 0.055943116545677185, 0.06555052101612091, 0.06677713245153427, 0.04329512640833855, -0.008887524716556072, -0.014776625670492649, 0.052192799746990204, -0.05814465880393982, 0.0011275826254859567, -0.011769882403314114, 0.028349487110972404, 0.01512494869530201, 0.010958723723888397, 0.01901184394955635, -0.01055094599723816, -0.003091663122177124, 0.040686823427677155, 0.015569002367556095, -0.0720716342329979, -0.02261369861662388, 0.0020712194964289665, -0.03384217619895935, 0.013346169143915176, 0.011965706013143063, -0.03591906279325485, -0.02744976617395878, -0.006109117064625025, -0.030984124168753624, 0.03134893253445625, 0.08396680653095245, 0.052834317088127136, -0.05106088146567345, -0.04383812099695206, 0.01709229126572609, 0.016302967444062233, 0.04424486681818962, 0.03394877538084984, -0.007749010808765888, -0.002629450522363186, 0.006360900588333607, 0.049716923385858536, 0.0652172714471817, -0.009149808436632156, 0.04819675534963608, 0.060270678251981735, 0.01862463727593422, -0.0013520768843591213, -0.0013476299354806542, 0.008370260708034039, -0.04159441217780113, 0.037348296493291855, -0.04619988054037094, 0.03563418239355087, 0.036772359162569046, 0.03113805316388607, 0.03267344832420349, 0.028421668335795403, -0.06426370143890381, -0.010003202594816685, -0.09552661329507828, 0.059312883764505386, 0.027374282479286194, -0.026566527783870697, -0.02880115434527397, 0.03146686777472496, -0.06090599298477173, -0.014263500459492207, -0.007197235245257616, -0.0008235467248596251, 0.03319206461310387, -0.02674993686378002, -0.05287465825676918, -0.0006607521208934486, 0.030871691182255745, -0.010779296047985554, -0.04115056246519089, -0.014789449982345104, 0.0355033352971077, -0.050556354224681854, 0.01595500484108925, 0.02248147502541542, -0.0040030707605183125, 0.019748466089367867, -0.004309629090130329, 0.01867496594786644, 0.06565482914447784, -0.033499497920274734, -0.029093250632286072, 0.018335595726966858, -0.025515766814351082, -0.0012627681717276573, 0.03337638080120087, 0.02661832422018051, 0.051437824964523315, 0.034490860998630524, -0.08041080832481384, 0.05887112393975258, 0.0435129776597023, 0.0488082617521286, -0.0006571474368683994, 0.0006037915591150522, -0.005387616343796253, 0.030352991074323654, 0.023663146421313286, 0.023790612816810608, -0.03153296560049057, 0.013742227107286453, -0.02234612964093685, -0.005937180947512388, -0.03531462326645851, 0.023885171860456467, -0.07401275634765625, -0.06750170886516571, -0.0040842765010893345, 0.01645040325820446, -0.016080910339951515, -0.00731844175606966, -0.014197653159499168, -0.03681466355919838, 0.07042057812213898, 0.01302840281277895, -0.07679496705532074, -0.003996450919657946, 0.01048565749078989, 0.04571425914764404, 0.049957793205976486, 0.0005770171992480755, -0.00011769462435040623, 0.02914736047387123, -0.032723747193813324, -0.12088355422019958, 0.01465205755084753, -0.012652773410081863, -0.06893029808998108, -0.013411176390945911, 0.009055925533175468, -0.04248940199613571, -0.02716822922229767, -0.078563392162323, -0.027649523690342903, -0.011990615166723728, -0.010125954635441303, 0.013031371869146824, -0.005246903747320175, -0.040229786187410355, -0.01750059798359871, -0.018868984654545784, 0.03491206094622612, -0.010264283046126366, 0.052167605608701706, 0.010936520993709564, -0.03359389677643776, -0.017710605636239052, 0.041699785739183426, 0.046427372843027115, -0.01826830394566059, -0.04574946314096451, 0.08368178457021713, 0.05650807172060013, -0.037972185760736465, -0.002745523815974593, -0.011929145082831383, -0.030711455270648003, 0.01674320548772812, -0.032987430691719055, 0.013554167933762074, -0.003744252026081085, -0.019452445209026337, 0.008248844183981419, 0.001274715643376112, -0.0026542225386947393, 0.023117201402783394, 0.014204169623553753, -0.021583793684840202, 0.06647132337093353, 0.014314730651676655, 0.06875023990869522, -0.020095890387892723, 0.027262022718787193, 0.022213466465473175, 0.05158735439181328, 0.026396367698907852, -0.0068379794247448444, 0.03165851905941963, -0.02493148297071457, -0.010779070667922497, 0.03606821969151497, 0.00011600874131545424, -0.017330162227153778, -0.04219376668334007, 0.030683962628245354, -0.016526926308870316, 0.025884833186864853, -0.03506837412714958, 0.023717425763607025, -0.04013432562351227, -0.044484153389930725, 0.0477721206843853, 0.023616034537553787, -0.000012653872545342892, -0.04445008933544159, -0.11015468090772629, 0.01685699261724949, 0.029149707406759262, 0.038129739463329315, 0.04916219040751457, 0.054177168756723404, 0.031727179884910583, -0.0393504835665226, -0.03541793301701546, 0.003071156097576022, -0.06246844679117203, 0.00022188360162544996, -0.017715752124786377, 0.08687728643417358, -0.006562219467014074, 0.041882097721099854, -0.0037949883844703436, 0.038512054830789566, -0.07945012301206589, 0.038843125104904175, -0.037618253380060196, 0.022482383996248245, 0.01747525855898857, 0.019725225865840912, -0.03918509557843208, -0.0016643478302285075, 0.024683581665158272, 0.004474384244531393, -0.02992621436715126, 0.02256055548787117, -0.0098404036834836, -0.044918302446603775, 0.02227729745209217, -0.031199079006910324, -0.02373901568353176, -0.019109461456537247, 0.01619458943605423, -0.07933895289897919, 0.02717074193060398, 0.055881399661302567, -0.03857630118727684, 0.028053568676114082, 0.01702950894832611, 0.00007285902393050492, -0.043648771941661835, -0.011563168838620186, 0.02592698112130165, -0.05108444392681122, -0.014023520052433014, 0.0014983745058998466, -0.04091332107782364, -0.008877193555235863, -0.05775138735771179, 0.05340481922030449, 0.003836122341454029, -0.0021393841598182917, -0.0265102069824934, 0.0014355543535202742, -0.08568622916936874 ]
<p>The viscosity of water creates drag on swimmer's body so its effect is to slow down the swimmer. However the viscosity seems to be essential for pushing the water backwards by the swimmer's arms and legs. Would a human be able to swim in water with much lower viscosity? What standard stroke (front crawl, breaststroke, butterfly) would work best/worst? How would a lower viscosity affect fish motion in water?</p>
g7413
[ 0.024883948266506195, 0.000021895479221711867, 0.0191244725137949, 0.032539740204811096, 0.011739907786250114, 0.030119307339191437, 0.04789913445711136, 0.06783447414636612, -0.008023332804441452, -0.042153649032115936, -0.018679369240999222, 0.03202870488166809, 0.020702660083770752, 0.007556384429335594, -0.05297737568616867, 0.03557009994983673, -0.07002777606248856, 0.0005465148133225739, -0.028336411342024803, 0.031205466017127037, 0.014166774228215218, 0.05425954610109329, -0.04248477518558502, 0.08420627564191818, -0.032763607800006866, -0.0037435113918036222, 0.015341181308031082, -0.05511012300848961, 0.004646594170480967, 0.003519068704918027, 0.03001592308282852, -0.005651375744491816, -0.017037514597177505, -0.14151546359062195, -0.02689516916871071, 0.03439904749393463, -0.02452932484447956, -0.0667041763663292, 0.013701869174838066, -0.009895948693156242, 0.0006087204092182219, 0.04504859447479248, 0.0071541927754879, -0.0026416361797600985, 0.028354378417134285, -0.005282491445541382, 0.029083624482154846, -0.018060805276036263, -0.06892504543066025, 0.023651275783777237, -0.023021917790174484, -0.015489849261939526, -0.05418049544095993, -0.03740650787949562, -0.006829210091382265, -0.021969623863697052, -0.033079005777835846, 0.005543126724660397, 0.007378107402473688, -0.0001791997201507911, -0.031247492879629135, -0.0713823139667511, 0.004571051802486181, -0.029896369203925133, 0.01586935482919216, -0.05414137989282608, -0.025164145976305008, -0.018191516399383545, 0.06550871580839157, 0.03710750862956047, 0.04717496410012245, -0.03922596201300621, -0.050074562430381775, -0.0394219271838665, -0.037045594304800034, -0.01774340681731701, -0.04450097680091858, -0.03504226356744766, 0.02293136902153492, -0.03489101305603981, -0.02545119822025299, -0.03241611644625664, 0.03569411486387253, 0.03076331689953804, 0.0814720094203949, -0.025100501254200935, -0.03227313607931137, -0.05091526731848717, 0.07110408693552017, 0.02430359646677971, -0.04953797906637192, -0.033094484359025955, 0.0471300408244133, 0.013991577550768852, 0.013501185923814774, -0.0352134145796299, -0.016798701137304306, 0.008328181691467762, -0.055701304227113724, -0.004775112494826317, 0.00692312465980649, -0.027346448972821236, 0.06998766958713531, 0.006265274714678526, -0.045858804136514664, -0.0202750563621521, 0.042879972606897354, 0.01792767457664013, -0.02828221768140793, -0.013066308572888374, 0.031114887446165085, -0.07120765000581741, 0.02783038653433323, 0.009989682585000992, -0.023682769387960434, -0.08152419328689575, 0.009176426567137241, 0.07266079634428024, 0.002442680299282074, 0.017033571377396584, -0.029362212866544724, 0.03476351872086525, -0.015223613008856773, 0.07161448150873184, -0.018752751871943474, -0.003650778904557228, -0.030012313276529312, 0.05151651054620743, 0.030524415895342827, 0.04750896245241165, 0.010210349224507809, 0.08692862093448639, -0.01513795554637909, -0.04016101360321045, -0.0030726068653166294, 0.03746408596634865, -0.03440549969673157, -0.009294159710407257, 0.011678353883326054, -0.03711844980716705, 0.08970087021589279, 0.020372554659843445, -0.04924416542053223, 0.043351005762815475, -0.03713114932179451, -0.040097761899232864, -0.043233901262283325, 0.020579244941473007, -0.03208822011947632, 0.02047482132911682, 0.05897195637226105, -0.011882148683071136, 0.07321006059646606, -0.006075901445001364, 0.03880387544631958, 0.011456591077148914, 0.05515526607632637, 0.01493548508733511, -0.0299515463411808, -0.011188526637852192, 0.04273049160838127, 0.019029369577765465, -0.0039410777390003204, 0.021808229386806488, -0.0313589982688427, 0.038268908858299255, -0.027565650641918182, -0.013961653225123882, 0.039425596594810486, -0.027926435694098473, -0.029467230662703514, -0.045647598803043365, -0.04282369837164879, 0.03652229160070419, 0.013597439043223858, -0.045266345143318176, 0.02487136609852314, -0.018238846212625504, -0.034858837723731995, -0.0587056428194046, -0.09196921437978745, 0.014470303431153297, -0.03424246236681938, -0.045985203236341476, -0.01321133691817522, -0.034471116960048676, -0.005130976904183626, -0.07014274597167969, -0.04550733417272568, -0.0312204509973526, 0.026440827175974846, -0.08008848875761032, -0.018323229625821114, -0.01428659912198782, -0.03433237224817276, -0.024482497945427895, 0.005933187436312437, -0.018285613507032394, -0.052976299077272415, 0.011225420981645584, 0.01800423115491867, -0.029675796627998352, 0.0306924469769001, -0.035338155925273895, 0.001195683260448277, -0.026042401790618896, -0.027249297127127647, -0.019650716334581375, 0.02085188962519169, -0.05878874659538269, 0.005880527198314667, 0.013317280448973179, 0.017352722585201263, 0.02656545676290989, -0.03039962612092495, 0.043293796479701996, -0.05327388644218445, -0.01449116226285696, -0.012438325211405754, 0.0016750911017879844, -0.005526960361748934, -0.050208721309900284, -0.07004886120557785, 0.022283349186182022, -0.024112261831760406, 0.00683501735329628, -0.03592851385474205, -0.005657036788761616, 0.033670734614133835, -0.024954643100500107, 0.02969076856970787, 0.05240912735462189, 0.021466989070177078, -0.012509769760072231, -0.015258099883794785, 0.019247040152549744, 0.03572129085659981, 0.052591994404792786, 0.017649821937084198, -0.06830472499132156, -0.027830887585878372, 0.0135191073641181, 0.020278368145227432, -0.037457119673490524, 0.015250061638653278, -0.003176288679242134, -0.03320658579468727, 0.007150797173380852, 0.024370193481445312, 0.06136646866798401, -0.002828434109687805, -0.0010463753715157509, 0.035736650228500366, 0.016935385763645172, 0.032623905688524246, -0.008883190341293812, -0.01733868010342121, 0.07548148930072784, -0.03707374632358551, 0.06873408704996109, 0.014283514581620693, 0.030938301235437393, -0.027093403041362762, -0.042103879153728485, -0.050537850707769394, -0.00568233011290431, -0.027544427663087845, 0.026049114763736725, 0.0510396808385849, 0.005249474197626114, 0.022204553708434105, -0.01774582266807556, -0.0819605365395546, 0.025470806285738945, -0.023841723799705505, -0.04436292126774788, -0.03095323219895363, -0.031106198206543922, -0.01881994493305683, 0.04394323378801346, 0.0035179839469492435, -0.023392759263515472, 0.02418956533074379, 0.022877531126141548, 0.07046117633581161, -0.009439055807888508, 0.018229138106107712, 0.0051000542007386684, -0.037167493253946304, 0.08562418818473816, -0.044254329055547714, 0.04594604671001434, 0.036695823073387146, -0.012710975483059883, 0.03237004205584526, -0.012710820883512497, 0.06118897721171379, -0.030418353155255318, -0.008971570059657097, 0.005809035152196884, 0.0260302871465683, -0.0054677315056324005, 0.005460389889776707, -0.005348210223019123, -0.027164679020643234, 0.025383369997143745, -0.023547999560832977, -0.00257403333671391, 0.01316823996603489, -0.017603352665901184, 0.00440215552225709, -0.0015227923868224025, -0.010409624315798283, 0.06388572603464127, -0.034814052283763885, -0.013591599650681019, -0.05648904666304588, 0.02581056021153927, -0.006823730189353228, 0.005511745810508728, 0.039005350321531296, -0.015110012143850327, -0.01548578217625618, -0.005869059357792139, 0.03264932706952095, 0.04640970379114151, 0.01019330509006977, 0.03024575300514698, -0.08234700560569763, 0.004058544058352709, 0.03283991292119026, 0.0022991786245256662, -0.018029414117336273, 0.03637770190834999, 0.005778181832283735, -0.00008679381426190957, 0.04804420471191406, 0.03834857791662216, -0.0011247156653553247, -0.029518306255340576, 0.026331378147006035, -0.054831020534038544, 0.011649665422737598, -0.0022662892006337643, 0.02067745104432106, -0.004719493445008993, 0.03942430019378662, 0.03606300428509712, -0.0003343258867971599, -0.0037254050839692354, -0.0269370898604393, -0.06253538280725479, -0.031686652451753616, -0.08037769049406052, -0.010457879863679409, -0.001380888163112104, 0.016624026000499725, 0.0710798054933548, 0.002820762572810054, 0.02105817198753357, -0.05122217535972595, -0.027920765802264214, -0.027081821113824844, 0.07453674077987671, -0.017024675384163857, 0.02417682483792305, -0.02566644549369812, 0.008916712366044521, -0.10056141018867493, 0.04734501242637634, -0.0023354182485491037, -0.04873957112431526, 0.017475618049502373, 0.02961338870227337, 0.006899484433233738, 0.04347015917301178, 0.04076237976551056, 0.06294303387403488, -0.011424818076193333, 0.016638120636343956, 0.06522548943758011, 0.031854454427957535, 0.0064392052590847015, 0.024765435606241226, 0.010454334318637848, -0.02084388956427574, -0.02064901776611805, -0.032295435667037964, 0.03137734532356262, 0.05765778571367264, 0.012067094445228577, -0.00019655469805002213, 0.0036238005850464106, 0.0023551760241389275, 0.030870916321873665, -0.00797637552022934, 0.026813913136720657, 0.03233189508318901, -0.049914781004190445, 0.010283291339874268, -0.040156278759241104, 0.019615255296230316, 0.04060208797454834, 0.08729318529367447, -0.04283171892166138, 0.024053078144788742, 0.010846848599612713, -0.04283007234334946, -0.05254276096820831, -0.00037608042475767434, 0.010826163925230503, -0.004851505625993013, -0.000751958810724318, -0.024507982656359673, -0.08419950306415558, 0.060567740350961685, 0.010399420745670795, -0.024150120094418526, 0.021678496152162552, 0.05280766636133194, 0.07051906734704971, 0.011898747645318508, 0.05823959782719612, -0.017777884379029274, -0.025195704773068428, 0.023058289662003517, 0.06880835443735123, -0.0017133788205683231, 0.04629497602581978, -0.03413734585046768, 0.019869884476065636, 0.03076964244246483, -0.009445766918361187, 0.0006010616780258715, 0.07357101887464523, 0.011400536634027958, 0.052432235330343246, -0.04474331811070442, 0.03469410538673401, 0.01808265969157219, -0.06221189349889755, 0.02405593730509281, 0.023495202884078026, 0.010903789661824703, -0.04034622758626938, 0.0365305058658123, 0.022157808765769005, -0.007030668668448925, -0.03730887174606323, 0.003715636907145381, -0.021213484928011894, 0.03534482419490814, 0.00341280410066247, -0.033798616379499435, -0.03342356160283089, 0.012266195379197598, -0.004354441538453102, -0.01114004198461771, -0.025800809264183044, -0.06843432039022446, 0.014502651989459991, 0.04087628051638603, -0.0029173779767006636, -0.00813900213688612, 0.0006735495990142226, -0.025067191570997238, 0.059779226779937744, 0.012221140787005424, -0.026144964620471, 0.03144187480211258, 0.001786443404853344, 0.01676478236913681, 0.008548074401915073, 0.05739395320415497, -0.0013220354449003935, 0.03192052245140076, -0.005910022184252739, -0.05373665690422058, 0.01914162188768387, 0.013176408596336842, -0.045970674604177475, -0.009935812093317509, -0.03496170789003372, -0.00229834602214396, -0.01760920137166977, -0.03502922132611275, -0.02661227248609066, 0.05848878249526024, 0.023796312510967255, -0.02711809240281582, -0.028973577544093132, -0.00030921032885089517, -0.020985256880521774, -0.018252026289701462, -0.017977407202124596, 0.024755047634243965, 0.029873568564653397, 0.06582195311784744, 0.009735753759741783, 0.015437704510986805, -0.06492997705936432, -0.05691630393266678, -0.021438680589199066, -0.06693331152200699, 0.02632479928433895, 0.0016822488978505135, 0.022381512448191643, -0.07791971415281296, -0.03396759554743767, 0.011117751710116863, -0.007487993687391281, 0.0071528903208673, -0.060176651924848557, -0.04520208016037941, -0.006247330456972122, -0.015268424525856972, -0.04809416085481644, -0.018773294985294342, 0.04826066270470619, -0.03160184994339943, 0.04315035045146942, 0.0034243972040712833, 0.000022573516616830602, 0.020618805661797523, 0.009871844202280045, 0.017571792006492615, -0.028900763019919395, 0.02902919426560402, -0.020687252283096313, -0.038235001266002655, 0.042545136064291, 0.032956112176179886, 0.04294562339782715, -0.00513665983453393, -0.015332153998315334, -0.04544626176357269, -0.013535958714783192, 0.014098087325692177, 0.00710615050047636, 0.04291209205985069, 0.0074588400311768055, 0.033649519085884094, 0.018556952476501465, 0.06450919061899185, 0.01611464098095894, -0.03952347859740257, -0.016734126955270767, -0.014792582020163536, -0.051348280161619186, -0.061233654618263245, -0.00986739993095398, 0.022868070751428604, -0.012602699920535088, 0.06996051222085953, -0.07249224185943604, -0.0025236294604837894, -0.01741519570350647, -0.006417444441467524, 0.02892121486365795, 0.003912018612027168, 0.040985964238643646, 0.016400599852204323, -0.01350043248385191, -0.0010347212664783, 0.06017223745584488, -0.0657961368560791, -0.014680668711662292, 0.025612475350499153, 0.06723939627408981, 0.03653084859251976, -0.05228094384074211, -0.02333707921206951, 0.05059443414211273, -0.018765272572636604, 0.00796473491936922, -0.027313435450196266, 0.022963423281908035, -0.027071107178926468, -0.008638356812298298, 0.04437543451786041, 0.026279058307409286, -0.021887416020035744, -0.025865744799375534, -0.037804558873176575, -0.021283557638525963, 0.025757407769560814, 0.006579223088920116, 0.009099921211600304, 0.027225201949477196, 0.0018845652230083942, 0.05479733273386955, 0.010499195195734501, 0.01876453496515751, -0.020673202350735664, 0.023799173533916473, 0.011578692123293877, 0.021239062771201134, 0.03974294662475586, -0.06634672731161118, 0.03240440785884857, 0.026852691546082497, 0.034530192613601685, 0.021800179034471512, 0.018716884776949883, 0.019727615639567375, 0.006949036382138729, 0.05533098429441452, 0.0009432976949028671, -0.007020850200206041, -0.0021536920685321093, -0.05787040293216705, 0.00789668783545494, -0.018019529059529305, -0.015402971766889095, -0.002496727043762803, 0.005770714022219181, 0.044521208852529526, -0.01275783684104681, -0.03701486438512802, 0.05967036262154579, -0.07669057697057724, -0.0811489000916481, 0.027151959016919136, 0.016655603423714638, 0.03212793543934822, -0.03394152596592903, -0.023239370435476303, 0.023710474371910095, -0.01906365528702736, 0.04372365027666092, 0.04119780287146568, -0.0684547945857048, 0.011484568938612938, 0.09686277061700821, -0.008226328529417515, -0.05476769432425499, -0.01850864477455616, 0.09867242723703384, 0.025856943801045418, 0.06468134373426437, 0.07121573388576508, 0.002055021235719323, -0.010689254850149155, 0.01302376203238964, -0.037306737154722214, 0.056198600679636, 0.027369791641831398, 0.015427246689796448, -0.015985626727342606, -0.0501648411154747, 0.036265525966882706, 0.009154777973890305, -0.0053508649580180645, 0.014132386073470116, -0.026462724432349205, 0.006171524524688721, -0.00660660769790411, 0.022945256903767586, 0.01522786170244217, 0.022214531898498535, 0.009879344142973423, 0.04025394469499588, 0.07131776213645935, 0.02986651100218296, -0.004251005593687296, 0.019612813368439674, 0.04715755209326744, 0.00227751350030303, 0.019113246351480484, 0.06854169815778732, 0.057295311242341995, -0.07510247826576233, -0.001042157062329352, 0.021894926205277443, 0.028083892539143562, -0.007227863650768995, -0.0016310442006215453, 0.012982289306819439, -0.036843039095401764, -0.018998712301254272, -0.0014079839456826448, -0.011466868221759796, 0.01202586479485035, 0.03150856867432594, -0.02068709209561348, -0.015206688083708286, 0.03331473097205162, -0.029411867260932922, 0.0385676734149456, -0.048410866409540176, -0.017728278413414955, 0.017084747552871704, -0.07218579947948456, -0.015569113194942474, -0.02916857600212097, 0.02560591511428356, -0.027293192222714424, 0.06669243425130844, 0.03411218151450157, -0.007834150455892086, -0.004631841089576483, -0.0008703244384378195, 0.034647200256586075, 0.09192784875631332, 0.016669215634465218, 0.009952972643077374, -0.05009540170431137, 0.0030995772685855627, -0.07204388082027435, -0.11497008055448532, -0.011408521793782711, 0.01374905463308096, 0.022982917726039886, 0.004818228539079428, 0.006565221585333347, -0.010302498936653137, 0.003214478027075529, 0.005430532619357109, 0.007633949164301157, -0.0057612331584095955, -0.024030376225709915, -0.031203025951981544, 0.003884929232299328, -0.024360932409763336, -0.015370838344097137, -0.03443065658211708, -0.048338714987039566, -0.022947760298848152, -0.04663508012890816, -0.06128423288464546, -0.07691899687051773, -0.07669577747583389, -0.039666272699832916, -0.01700710691511631, 0.00017002431559376419, 0.026052359491586685, -0.024583827704191208, 0.01666967384517193, 0.0013958238996565342, 0.010777595452964306, 0.03655887395143509, 0.08598095923662186, -0.033741217106580734, -0.01949620246887207, -0.001660670037381351, -0.054742734879255295, 0.05387435853481293, 0.049876052886247635, 0.032771941274404526, -0.0001823193597374484, 0.04489430785179138, -0.03879249095916748, -0.02705506607890129, 0.0025821910239756107, 0.039021238684654236, 0.015042503364384174, -0.012708436697721481, 0.021725531667470932, -0.02584891766309738, -0.030876128003001213, -0.015109658241271973, -0.02207190915942192, -0.006574018392711878, 0.043593425303697586, -0.04746422916650772, -0.04230464994907379, -0.029028376564383507, -0.034529026597738266 ]
<p>Water pressure is simply $pgh/2$ for a vertical wall parallel to the depth of the water at exactly the half the water's depth. Suppose the wall is tapered (angled) slightly at around 2 degrees from the y-axis (parallel to the wall). How would you measure the pressure at this point? Would it be the contributing pressure from both the vertical and horizontal pressure? As such: $pgh \sin (\theta) + 1/2pgh\cos(\theta)$.</p> <p>I'm assuming pressures can be summed as forces. This may be false.</p>
g7414
[ 0.07469101250171661, -0.024814078584313393, -0.024989405646920204, -0.0649702250957489, 0.060342829674482346, 0.0031794989481568336, 0.05025561526417732, -0.012709717266261578, -0.033634576946496964, 0.030898284167051315, -0.07308657467365265, 0.06422640383243561, -0.009977775625884533, 0.0018593359272927046, 0.020835906267166138, -0.021858081221580505, 0.01756201684474945, -0.03919657692313194, -0.014993542805314064, 0.003873125184327364, -0.0010287553304806352, -0.022694069892168045, 0.048507291823625565, -0.0046736691147089005, 0.010536613874137402, -0.010301591828465462, 0.056297000497579575, 0.021395588293671608, -0.03802577406167984, 0.029558399692177773, -0.035871852189302444, 0.03245829790830612, 0.027414841577410698, -0.01046324148774147, -0.012118857353925705, -0.04140117019414902, 0.02027341164648533, 0.03659019246697426, 0.05357619374990463, -0.04707496613264084, -0.02119317650794983, -0.0060646431520581245, 0.036784280091524124, 0.0007952387677505612, -0.011840693652629852, -0.04175790771842003, -0.06354271620512009, 0.01641256920993328, 0.014693737961351871, -0.00406284723430872, -0.03967193886637688, -0.005110467318445444, 0.014592526480555534, -0.02723313309252262, -0.06498359143733978, 0.029356522485613823, 0.035976339131593704, -0.017539648339152336, 0.021710075438022614, 0.017733866348862648, -0.03255131095647812, 0.00201563723385334, 0.05110005661845207, 0.027140634134411812, 0.008315024897456169, -0.003965505864471197, -0.015335115604102612, -0.004564883653074503, 0.014706442132592201, 0.04108475521206856, 0.018364429473876953, -0.02833402529358864, 0.012152696028351784, -0.020930975675582886, -0.08267557621002197, 0.024068081751465797, -0.0045798160135746, 0.00908681470900774, 0.010302985087037086, -0.04149956256151199, 0.032783493399620056, -0.010711745359003544, 0.057311829179525375, -0.004732308443635702, 0.011656370013952255, 0.002897463971748948, 0.02111857756972313, -0.014186649583280087, -0.03625873476266861, 0.03467518463730812, -0.022180497646331787, -0.021606652066111565, 0.033045537769794464, 0.002895908197388053, 0.026329299435019493, -0.05071986839175224, 0.019426533952355385, -0.0272299163043499, 0.04196648299694061, 0.0053059011697769165, -0.01570272445678711, 0.00853380560874939, -0.008489008992910385, 0.008899993263185024, -0.007195056416094303, 0.01812034286558628, 0.09762652963399887, 0.03814133629202843, 0.003049046266824007, -0.055940352380275726, 0.006512516178190708, -0.03825199604034424, 0.006426763255149126, -0.04386195167899132, 0.028838198632001877, -0.05777081102132797, 0.04048896208405495, -0.009171918034553528, 0.03259922191500664, 0.07207593321800232, -0.010379105806350708, 0.040813565254211426, 0.053800180554389954, 0.08859051018953323, -0.04117527976632118, 0.031479086726903915, -0.053216271102428436, 0.02720615454018116, -0.003468042006716132, 0.028478113934397697, 0.034429214894771576, 0.047510936856269836, -0.0757211223244667, 0.0071874093264341354, 0.04679441079497337, -0.008124503307044506, -0.06862843036651611, -0.010870745405554771, -0.030301533639431, 0.029558051377534866, -0.023343313485383987, 0.011861715465784073, 0.022878477349877357, 0.04778485372662544, 0.012868006713688374, -0.007397032342851162, -0.03737926855683327, 0.014297045767307281, 0.008747187443077564, -0.03485330566763878, -0.0015160883776843548, 0.04690191522240639, 0.04668022692203522, 0.0036460980772972107, 0.014510453678667545, -0.049346037209033966, -0.03670857101678848, -0.020803367719054222, 0.03847239911556244, 0.0648328885436058, 0.007303809281438589, 0.008414111100137234, 0.03576219826936722, 0.009027435444295406, -0.052781425416469574, 0.011455901898443699, -0.019896216690540314, 0.03526325523853302, 0.0036942551378160715, -0.006413642782717943, 0.04321030527353287, 0.03757140412926674, 0.024262696504592896, -0.061125077307224274, 0.03287525475025177, 0.004845913965255022, 0.03172812983393669, 0.006151051260530949, -0.0038180595729500055, 0.025707362219691277, 0.019902052357792854, 0.02792830392718315, 0.05213543400168419, -0.013131726533174515, 0.022654423490166664, -0.03390800952911377, 0.04238414764404297, -0.040842801332473755, -0.03750472515821457, 0.024614155292510986, 0.02994672767817974, 0.034105394035577774, -0.03511415794491768, 0.029614288359880447, 0.022890403866767883, -0.005155789665877819, 0.1057436615228653, -0.02236911654472351, 0.002221696777269244, 0.021728383377194405, -0.06765594333410263, 0.025957176461815834, 0.08065284788608551, 0.03202081844210625, -0.010982087813317776, 0.04837933927774429, 0.014780529774725437, -0.05582822486758232, 0.038413044065237045, -0.0042070047929883, -0.04636884480714798, 0.00908154807984829, -0.037531450390815735, 0.001028208527714014, -0.007782850880175829, 0.020456841215491295, -0.014391668140888214, 0.01963883452117443, -0.06585633009672165, -0.013242770917713642, -0.05460105463862419, 0.05033197999000549, 0.01927538774907589, 0.007715621497482061, -0.040266674011945724, 0.007101346738636494, -0.03693776577711105, 0.0673472136259079, -0.0053064459934830666, -0.0015540531603619456, 0.0030515873804688454, -0.035841770470142365, -0.03804975748062134, 0.050780802965164185, 0.04543408378958702, 0.06132952496409416, -0.007299416698515415, 0.05756921321153641, 0.0770709216594696, -0.014237572439014912, -0.01561259850859642, -0.03383594751358032, -0.006031560245901346, 0.005208312533795834, 0.009829630143940449, 0.0346955806016922, 0.02733541652560234, 0.05190936103463173, 0.038966771215200424, 0.03786865621805191, -0.03203999623656273, -0.055350981652736664, -0.010704541578888893, 0.06497776508331299, 0.0530923455953598, 0.0077652460895478725, 0.032543499022722244, 0.03164653480052948, -0.039796311408281326, -0.0405561700463295, -0.022094981744885445, -0.04528018832206726, 0.011873576790094376, 0.033364493399858475, -0.01939246989786625, 0.0058182911016047, -0.06442417949438095, 0.05602475255727768, 0.08746612071990967, -0.018083520233631134, 0.007950588129460812, 0.012921160086989403, -0.009885297156870365, 0.02872852049767971, -0.04847891628742218, -0.06276661902666092, 0.022159257903695107, -0.035431958734989166, -0.025602703914046288, 0.007606847677379847, -0.025777187198400497, -0.002918124897405505, 0.015549441799521446, 0.07903534173965454, 0.006812578998506069, 0.048102859407663345, 0.043619878590106964, 0.006999252364039421, -0.00468911649659276, 0.09579247981309891, 0.00823541171848774, -0.023774968460202217, 0.029300790280103683, -0.0313856266438961, 0.02288886345922947, 0.05646849051117897, 0.04104244336485863, 0.0009642178192734718, -0.03573879972100258, -0.012452681548893452, -0.039390161633491516, -0.006593630649149418, -0.03212311491370201, 0.02779773809015751, -0.00200317008420825, -0.024823732674121857, -0.006409809459000826, -0.00519957160577178, -0.029526926577091217, 0.0003172699944116175, -0.005307895131409168, -0.027395358309149742, 0.046885896474123, -0.04032585024833679, 0.002163873752579093, -0.04486465826630592, -0.0029795044101774693, -0.011621206067502499, -0.08547040820121765, 0.022653281688690186, -0.04166586697101593, -0.03070119582116604, 0.04391619190573692, 0.04457307979464531, -0.014439066872000694, 0.05746534466743469, -0.030208082869648933, 0.048943985253572464, -0.05032901465892792, -0.06248651072382927, 0.021513642743229866, -0.0022102228831499815, -0.019050778821110725, 0.025284240022301674, 0.019852370023727417, -0.022455137223005295, 0.015716932713985443, 0.004355763550847769, -0.013793575577437878, 0.04400376230478287, -0.052141666412353516, -0.04085041955113411, -0.07854095846414566, -0.010507638566195965, 0.027354279533028603, -0.03710852563381195, 0.02336869388818741, 0.029452785849571228, -0.01464063674211502, -0.001137239276431501, 0.017430249601602554, -0.03872020170092583, -0.006181048694998026, 0.021171651780605316, 0.07880470901727676, 0.018985603004693985, 0.035872649401426315, 0.0261808093637228, -0.08157021552324295, 0.020630192011594772, 0.03359316661953926, -0.023261800408363342, -0.015862539410591125, -0.013782104477286339, -0.0434420146048069, -0.033968936651945114, 0.04029298573732376, 0.047651469707489014, -0.05358333885669708, -0.05591606721282005, -0.004797450266778469, -0.02223300002515316, 0.022292835637927055, 0.0024932841770350933, -0.061143677681684494, -0.07873427867889404, 0.016113659366965294, -0.06784408539533615, -0.011230004951357841, 0.07171116769313812, 0.05762927606701851, 0.01820916123688221, 0.0002742722863331437, 0.05142812430858612, -0.010627281852066517, -0.018769195303320885, -0.05007750168442726, 0.058245912194252014, 0.06722493469715118, 0.014646883122622967, 0.03737114369869232, -0.04067396745085716, -0.031154785305261612, 0.04426724463701248, 0.02718338742852211, -0.06070169806480408, 0.03556981682777405, 0.08707471191883087, -0.05933229997754097, -0.008328384719789028, -0.011530717834830284, -0.03927288576960564, 0.055931393057107925, -0.01741468720138073, -0.014858904294669628, -0.014726872555911541, 0.05644656717777252, -0.008501873351633549, 0.0031635102350264788, 0.016075875610113144, 0.03311542421579361, -0.0161854550242424, -0.0007923568482510746, 0.019027015194296837, 0.01907035894691944, 0.014327243901789188, 0.0018598302267491817, 0.020389240235090256, 0.01044020801782608, 0.009649782441556454, -0.025437911972403526, 0.025243431329727173, -0.0338745042681694, -0.012260795570909977, -0.005237638484686613, 0.038122568279504776, -0.022530561313033104, 0.04473629221320152, 0.004774544388055801, -0.04223943501710892, 0.008407720364630222, 0.0026867964770644903, 0.050933144986629486, -0.005378501955419779, 0.017486492171883583, 0.01046197023242712, -0.04876990616321564, -0.04378461092710495, -0.0757257416844368, 0.024952806532382965, 0.007727454882115126, 0.04521575942635536, 0.020680466666817665, 0.025648830458521843, 0.0022738489788025618, 0.009854204021394253, -0.030401933938264847, -0.05525737628340721, 0.005835022311657667, 0.010618849657475948, -0.05609951913356781, 0.016237333416938782, 0.0023541245609521866, -0.02955266460776329, -0.013721202500164509, 0.0073455399833619595, -0.035368841141462326, 0.054746273905038834, -0.03069090098142624, -0.002808790188282728, -0.0008744302322156727, -0.03873218968510628, -0.061033789068460464, -0.010606421157717705, 0.0486845001578331, -0.02421247959136963, -0.04202451929450035, -0.04123283922672272, -0.013685842044651508, -0.02261667139828205, 0.007401703391224146, 0.050652798265218735, 0.03827929496765137, 0.034714918583631516, -0.031100139021873474, 0.01148310024291277, -0.04246038198471069, 0.006889571901410818, 0.023548098281025887, -0.06389118731021881, 0.0027246521785855293, 0.018522582948207855, -0.00443709222599864, -0.005220849998295307, 0.011582938022911549, -0.025353526696562767, -0.050498053431510925, -0.0034821301233023405, 0.002450281288474798, 0.02040182240307331, -0.037969864904880524, 0.03651410713791847, -0.015121969394385815, 0.02348625287413597, -0.04435340315103531, 0.004925285931676626, -0.02573576383292675, -0.02680845744907856, -0.016215218231081963, 0.07506932318210602, -0.061878323554992676, 0.06311073899269104, 0.014119627885520458, -0.012173106893897057, 0.003711465746164322, -0.01052238792181015, 0.02501785382628441, -0.037007659673690796, 0.01506629679352045, 0.08591096848249435, -0.0020110171753913164, -0.0011113033397123218, -0.017453035339713097, -0.041365377604961395, 0.07112295180559158, -0.02368803881108761, 0.033526383340358734, 0.019502751529216766, -0.050134409219026566, 0.03784573823213577, 0.08774173259735107, -0.02225569449365139, -0.030601866543293, -0.021463710814714432, 0.000261457113083452, -0.0007512964657507837, -0.07934241741895676, 0.017659513279795647, -0.007952668704092503, -0.032942406833171844, 0.02069525234401226, -0.0009780157124623656, -0.017844317480921745, -0.005728983785957098, 0.006681444123387337, -0.08679667860269547, 0.022611740976572037, -0.02253941260278225, 0.08470399677753448, -0.03138168156147003, -0.024107860401272774, 0.00669029401615262, 0.018825385719537735, 0.05718829855322838, -0.0035930636804550886, -0.010928048752248287, -0.03578644618391991, -0.035431891679763794, -0.021776581183075905, -0.005333709996193647, -0.06736847758293152, 0.04866351932287216, -0.05172576755285263, 0.04525262862443924, -0.026072435081005096, -0.033012691885232925, 0.04411517456173897, -0.033980805426836014, 0.04576774686574936, 0.001630142331123352, 0.03937746584415436, -0.01023348979651928, -0.03171604871749878, 0.006614314392209053, -0.01850656233727932, -0.03537372127175331, 0.013660304248332977, -0.007432607468217611, 0.016409998759627342, -0.004050367511808872, 0.0585988387465477, -0.0529908612370491, 0.011832928285002708, 0.04886864125728607, 0.0441480353474617, 0.030726104974746704, -0.02775253728032112, 0.03688938915729523, -0.03688642010092735, 0.032759130001068115, -0.050663288682699203, 0.040713172405958176, 0.005211029667407274, 0.0008949895272962749, 0.01309344731271267, 0.03879326581954956, -0.007638534065335989, -0.03764261677861214, 0.043182581663131714, 0.04490106180310249, -0.022185705602169037, -0.011714158579707146, -0.061816878616809845, 0.005799906328320503, 0.01820709928870201, 0.005631233099848032, 0.061734698712825775, 0.07038885354995728, -0.029291929677128792, 0.03742295503616333, 0.0199997890740633, 0.04222627356648445, 0.024886665865778923, -0.031118759885430336, 0.03090033121407032, -0.041234090924263, 0.002970735542476177, 0.02895113080739975, -0.04087448865175247, -0.010106656700372696, -0.02451089583337307, 0.029711412265896797, -0.0009371362393721938, -0.0245603509247303, 0.01202132273465395, 0.01510806567966938, 0.019634321331977844, -0.01816961169242859, -0.10030926764011383, 0.036734338849782944, 0.01255524717271328, -0.039538539946079254, -0.021836277097463608, -0.07155629247426987, 0.05015315115451813, -0.04364479333162308, -0.06056899577379227, -0.013332684524357319, 0.004988679196685553, 0.008945426903665066, 0.029157811775803566, -0.04161634296178818, 0.0330914705991745, -0.02181370183825493, -0.01644453965127468, 0.024204259738326073, -0.00957795325666666, 0.057098329067230225, 0.028771961107850075, 0.06574418395757675, 0.05005451664328575, 0.004542700946331024, -0.04365876317024231, 0.0029565279837697744, -0.0368700847029686, -0.004470599349588156, -0.04979050159454346, 0.001371364458464086, -0.045276664197444916, 0.004422363825142384, 0.026791155338287354, -0.0650666281580925, -0.03805150091648102, -0.02066204510629177, -0.08628257364034653, 0.06320372968912125, 0.06843411177396774, -0.037433184683322906, 0.024097248911857605, 0.009399628266692162, -0.03317227214574814, -0.01630091853439808, 0.03430202975869179, 0.011007496155798435, -0.051610734313726425, 0.0333159863948822, 0.0021765404380857944, -0.0627455934882164, -0.009358770214021206, -0.015479178167879581, -0.04081267863512039, -0.03956671431660652, -0.025510210543870926, -0.0016490627313032746, 0.001794513431377709, 0.054515354335308075, 0.0605120025575161, -0.03275620564818382, -0.04086827114224434, -0.00397490756586194, 0.0060150339268147945, 0.0011517859529703856, -0.03035961277782917, -0.040521491318941116, -0.043523166328668594, -0.0597279891371727, 0.001417239778675139, -0.07240648567676544, 0.021184338256716728, -0.01456186268478632, -0.02071259915828705, -0.0004675051604863256, 0.004865238908678293, -0.005264167208224535, 0.05548304319381714, 0.017677266150712967, 0.0294831283390522, 0.05466349422931671, 0.0014284844510257244, -0.0501246452331543, 0.013278328813612461, -0.019236741587519646, -0.020428210496902466, 0.007315835915505886, -0.033500123769044876, -0.06601507216691971, -0.013603415340185165, 0.010726241394877434, -0.004491149913519621, -0.08747201412916183, 0.0034051958937197924, 0.002572237513959408, -0.008063837885856628, -0.01136577408760786, 0.06136918440461159, 0.013337627984583378, -0.09448115527629852, -0.016980662941932678, 0.020143095403909683, -0.046306584030389786, -0.06686273962259293, -0.047918885946273804, 0.053976576775312424, -0.10164222866296768, 0.009812116622924805, 0.012229825370013714, -0.040221065282821655, -0.01507340744137764, 0.03126918897032738, 0.01768386736512184, -0.011881530284881592, -0.014032751321792603, 0.004248820710927248, 0.010711131617426872, -0.021322976797819138, 0.007812052499502897, 0.01380146387964487, 0.002415003953501582, 0.013380937278270721, 0.016628816723823547, -0.003744900692254305, -0.014039579778909683, -0.030582843348383904, -0.04304758086800575, 0.05779678374528885, -0.03356734290719032, -0.039598092436790466, 0.04293512925505638, 0.011840526945888996, 0.011016118340194225, 0.018355265259742737, 0.04075324907898903, 0.008722922764718533, 0.022116560488939285, 0.022705625742673874, -0.08610618859529495, -0.04605024307966232, -0.005345811136066914, -0.060960832983255386, -0.02243621274828911, -0.022168489173054695, -0.018262486904859543, 0.03834981843829155, -0.034116506576538086, 0.0011717062443494797, -0.017210671678185463, -0.04474421590566635, -0.013811862096190453 ]
<p>During a random reading through this site, I found this one: <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/7131/origin-of-elements-heavier-than-iron-fe">Origin of elements heavier than Iron (Fe)</a>...</p> <p>The answer was "The formation of many elements in earth was due to <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supernova_nucleosynthesis" rel="nofollow">Supernova nucleosynthesis</a>" as told by some guy. Here, A question crosses my mind:</p> <ul> <li>If the elements were formed due to the explosion of a supernova, then there should be a <strong>remnant</strong> like a black-hole or a neutron star nearby... Were there any nearby? Or, the <em>famous</em> <strong>Big Bang</strong> is responsible for this?</li> </ul> <p>(<em>Down-voters - leave comments</em>)</p>
g7415
[ 0.053790368139743805, 0.04661950096487999, 0.014627580530941486, -0.030491698533296585, 0.012354138307273388, 0.06512526422739029, -0.014291301369667053, 0.08090557157993317, 0.031684309244155884, -0.05238162353634834, -0.026835061609745026, 0.01955166831612587, 0.0748249813914299, 0.0029443937819451094, 0.023516155779361725, -0.015554260462522507, 0.07738722860813141, -0.017053792253136635, 0.03554433211684227, -0.006001153029501438, -0.03432715684175491, -0.012329142540693283, 0.01175374910235405, -0.008199957199394703, -0.027249639853835106, 0.010288937948644161, 0.02011435478925705, 0.007082760334014893, -0.0001589916500961408, -0.09408964961767197, 0.010435712523758411, -0.04958947002887726, 0.06134960055351257, -0.0325225368142128, 0.0005636547575704753, -0.03099263645708561, -0.02993861958384514, 0.03150396794080734, -0.0035384646616876125, -0.015811417251825333, 0.010712655261158943, -0.05896859988570213, -0.007102407049387693, -0.03778643533587456, -0.029410287737846375, -0.026474537327885628, 0.005740151274949312, 0.02136722207069397, 0.010486848652362823, -0.02604074776172638, -0.03223273158073425, -0.00827625673264265, 0.018651288002729416, 0.03576912358403206, 0.0022461016196757555, 0.039395999163389206, 0.031564682722091675, -0.041403140872716904, 0.03141126409173012, 0.019776739180088043, -0.029406294226646423, -0.001650351914577186, 0.01271218154579401, -0.011299626901745796, 0.05185495316982269, 0.020237943157553673, -0.06710076332092285, 0.04202334210276604, 0.06024649739265442, 0.04213894531130791, 0.005816415883600712, 0.0031261821277439594, -0.06386584788560867, 0.04238114878535271, 0.011692441999912262, 0.029479732736945152, -0.05059465393424034, 0.023746266961097717, -0.00958767719566822, 0.010754666291177273, -0.008279494009912014, -0.009219937957823277, 0.009806123562157154, 0.027793768793344498, 0.01217262726277113, 0.006019129417836666, -0.018978102132678032, 0.07615910470485687, 0.022648293524980545, 0.0021017601247876883, 0.06533154100179672, 0.04407651722431183, 0.00022262365382630378, -0.048201363533735275, -0.017797347158193588, -0.003765170695260167, 0.03748586028814316, 0.06349323689937592, -0.032287415117025375, -0.008205109275877476, -0.02687048353254795, 0.013373828493058681, -0.02098483219742775, -0.0053027658723294735, 0.08132065087556839, 0.019404953345656395, -0.03477682173252106, 0.025217052549123764, -0.043348703533411026, 0.0299643874168396, -0.011456264182925224, -0.035195328295230865, -0.012182209640741348, 0.005554088391363621, 0.014975206926465034, 0.021375946700572968, 0.04362805187702179, 0.004038029350340366, 0.03596213832497597, 0.04991156607866287, -0.011487003415822983, -0.0028268329333513975, -0.02742830477654934, 0.015148213133215904, -0.017665129154920578, -0.05140064284205437, 0.043362993746995926, 0.011630820110440254, -0.012085997499525547, -0.0297878235578537, -0.02655668370425701, 0.0026027446147054434, -0.024110643193125725, -0.03911559283733368, 0.02061801590025425, -0.01819055713713169, -0.048673611134290695, 0.04595286026597023, 0.03181157261133194, 0.016070056706666946, 0.004156087059527636, 0.044885728508234024, 0.02858637273311615, -0.07322988659143448, -0.007041970733553171, 0.054850369691848755, -0.03100907802581787, 0.031220758333802223, -0.03531824052333832, 0.01621520332992077, -0.028348222374916077, 0.0051226201467216015, -0.015262608416378498, -0.029637284576892853, -0.04696415737271309, 0.0013965243706479669, -0.035025641322135925, -0.06712798774242401, -0.013013734482228756, -0.06997424364089966, 0.042812515050172806, 0.0058494554832577705, 0.015430676750838757, -0.0038951109163463116, 0.02787831425666809, -0.005423683673143387, -0.01571369357407093, -0.02057088539004326, 0.006909537129104137, 0.04976939409971237, -0.027920380234718323, -0.028009913861751556, 0.02986990287899971, 0.02089659497141838, -0.015061689540743828, -0.009649219922721386, 0.10612098127603531, -0.08493174612522125, 0.02384047396481037, -0.031019581481814384, -0.023471014574170113, -0.03678634762763977, 0.02885991521179676, 0.017838506028056145, 0.0628380998969078, -0.05317707732319832, -0.008459358476102352, 0.07833778858184814, 0.01496333908289671, 0.04215117543935776, -0.04480314999818802, -0.01035325601696968, 0.02196403406560421, 0.06687038391828537, -0.0010418484453111887, -0.011359798721969128, -0.022461945191025734, -0.03316626697778702, -0.00019730809435714036, 0.06866336613893509, -0.016346178948879242, 0.010779899545013905, -0.0564902238547802, -0.013878735713660717, -0.011702820658683777, 0.008645628578960896, -0.061464469879865646, 0.027957826852798462, -0.006077740341424942, -0.013276924379169941, -0.026498325169086456, 0.01078030839562416, -0.024822760373353958, -0.024497389793395996, -0.04697573557496071, -0.00045300961937755346, -0.054910652339458466, 0.0015520746819674969, -0.008431516587734222, 0.048665013164281845, -0.05657254159450531, -0.02779616042971611, -0.015987403690814972, -0.038862358778715134, -0.044971056282520294, -0.015140908770263195, 0.043018605560064316, -0.04220280051231384, 0.0034556095488369465, -0.028646042570471764, -0.04631371796131134, -0.021399758756160736, 0.025745192542672157, -0.016071951016783714, 0.02794501557946205, 0.008703190833330154, 0.021462077274918556, -0.04225724935531616, -0.06080073490738869, 0.00146735948510468, -0.005004737991839647, -0.03653981164097786, 0.03608392924070358, -0.03283318504691124, 0.0716429054737091, -0.03880752995610237, 0.027480239048600197, -0.03370189666748047, 0.010448671877384186, -0.01728840172290802, -0.007306511048227549, -0.062146157026290894, -0.011501897126436234, -0.032431673258543015, -0.050101395696401596, -0.05170852690935135, 0.02189016155898571, 0.09890060126781464, -0.048074208199977875, -0.021155275404453278, 0.014232414774596691, 0.016707036644220352, 0.0336751826107502, -0.01151641458272934, -0.040946852415800095, 0.015767842531204224, -0.026409652084112167, -0.05475926771759987, 0.02186523750424385, -0.012776970863342285, -0.0574149452149868, -0.03968045860528946, 0.019421443343162537, 0.006072790361940861, -0.042970720678567886, -0.015413151122629642, -0.02352038212120533, 0.040502868592739105, 0.05531894043087959, 0.029366083443164825, 0.040225207805633545, 0.04926711320877075, -0.016368640586733818, -0.03331797569990158, -0.010112429037690163, 0.011588012799620628, -0.019523218274116516, -0.044822610914707184, 0.0554189495742321, -0.014379262924194336, 0.014338437467813492, -0.08723864704370499, 0.01676943711936474, 0.047650594264268875, 0.039014238864183426, -0.0003138317842967808, 0.04387702792882919, -0.017494792118668556, -0.07097999006509781, 0.01691855676472187, 0.03812747821211815, -0.05076945200562477, 0.02207537740468979, 0.01007079053670168, 0.031915728002786636, -0.013774337247014046, -0.0061242771334946156, 0.011462976224720478, 0.013266215100884438, -0.0287283007055521, -0.007523857522755861, 0.04547492414712906, 0.04618237912654877, 0.08194692432880402, -0.028110578656196594, 0.04962707310914993, 0.008578675799071789, 0.04204288497567177, 0.06138726323843002, -0.06239468976855278, -0.07243712991476059, -0.04134124144911766, 0.06577305495738983, -0.03276070952415466, 0.05303189903497696, 0.034617576748132706, -0.001435405807569623, -0.0004164269776083529, -0.013895276933908463, -0.062140777707099915, -0.02544219419360161, -0.006417673546820879, -0.051710184663534164, 0.06827463209629059, -0.10259994864463806, 0.011055274866521358, -0.05958637595176697, 0.03238958865404129, 0.08269936591386795, 0.05382644385099411, 0.017425986006855965, 0.031721532344818115, 0.05185359716415405, -0.016887512058019638, 0.03948808088898659, 0.033441901206970215, -0.013820595107972622, -0.033605802804231644, -0.0039765858091413975, 0.046957436949014664, 0.017129896208643913, 0.027052924036979675, 0.0680229514837265, 0.008534172549843788, 0.016789555549621582, -0.0457441508769989, 0.04613156616687775, -0.016360970214009285, 0.024301769211888313, -0.02852536551654339, -0.02208876609802246, -0.022575238719582558, 0.02480887621641159, -0.03790227323770523, -0.06889863312244415, 0.06359321624040604, 0.03214551508426666, -0.012193148024380207, 0.014774472452700138, 0.006625443231314421, 0.0038185936864465475, 0.0012331001926213503, -0.03244474157691002, 0.009224810637533665, 0.05443770810961723, 0.028392868116497993, 0.07752742618322372, 0.04971212148666382, -0.04926810786128044, -0.03711868077516556, 0.05011966824531555, 0.010112526826560497, 0.05965539813041687, 0.01574847102165222, 0.04175347834825516, -0.06166055426001549, -0.021485738456249237, -0.07439383864402771, -0.0756794735789299, -0.020895712077617645, 0.05677306279540062, -0.02288198098540306, -0.05517095699906349, -0.008774313144385815, 0.000497103319503367, -0.021214984357357025, -0.03556251898407936, 0.008202540688216686, 0.0038257965352386236, 0.056324202567338943, 0.005306762643158436, 0.01488597970455885, 0.03144443780183792, 0.017154371365904808, 0.017623132094740868, 0.0037441158201545477, -0.011090644635260105, -0.050093550235033035, -0.02931988053023815, -0.024857282638549805, 0.044122956693172455, 0.01648891344666481, -0.023113280534744263, -0.015000099316239357, -0.004668537061661482, -0.02645069546997547, 0.03071264550089836, 0.008671320043504238, -0.03227289766073227, -0.043748803436756134, 0.013109833002090454, 0.03382738307118416, 0.055130381137132645, 0.05382625758647919, 0.030283033847808838, 0.01815105974674225, -0.01530014630407095, -0.03545578196644783, 0.04018910601735115, 0.06274185329675674, 0.011343808844685555, 0.05854392796754837, 0.01964546926319599, 0.017070729285478592, -0.027275362983345985, 0.012379612773656845, -0.04183584079146385, 0.01056778896600008, -0.02649337612092495, 0.04697822406888008, 0.06169004738330841, -0.020322924479842186, 0.018099531531333923, 0.03422343358397484, 0.044244155287742615, 0.043366748839616776, -0.02278536930680275, 0.00481864670291543, -0.058297209441661835, -0.05127378925681114, 0.03899255394935608, -0.006378426216542721, 0.019863875582814217, -0.012973259203135967, -0.0009338802192360163, -0.004514841362833977, 0.015474019572138786, 0.014821315184235573, -0.018185066059231758, 0.05765385180711746, 0.006794739980250597, 0.006298927124589682, 0.01019310299307108, 0.07816752046346664, 0.03730865195393562, -0.06764613837003708, -0.034158699214458466, -0.02089521288871765, 0.021805398166179657, 0.013565151952207088, -0.01596800982952118, -0.01618468388915062, 0.05109309405088425, 0.008595234714448452, 0.013516639359295368, 0.003210641909390688, -0.009503512643277645, -0.05447395145893097, 0.024446509778499603, -0.018209116533398628, -0.0037862102035433054, 0.016269991174340248, -0.014327983371913433, 0.010793277993798256, 0.000753250322304666, 0.0162271186709404, -0.039994098246097565, 0.022584473714232445, -0.0103076733648777, -0.04549861699342728, -0.06973256170749664, -0.06920302659273148, 0.06556762009859085, -0.010608380660414696, 0.014383425004780293, -0.04955814778804779, 0.023120921105146408, -0.003926662728190422, -0.024363433942198753, 0.0024332862813025713, -0.047951165586709976, -0.028772085905075073, -0.0011839093640446663, 0.015417157672345638, 0.04274536296725273, -0.018172644078731537, 0.04271461069583893, 0.005158420652151108, 0.09180663526058197, -0.025061018764972687, -0.03098338283598423, 0.01525384746491909, 0.007869316264986992, 0.004569311160594225, 0.06050213426351547, 0.023772573098540306, 0.02752852626144886, 0.013688083738088608, 0.025316322222352028, 0.011865510605275631, -0.01473227608948946, -0.01111637707799673, 0.01607270911335945, 0.02416384406387806, 0.04897702857851982, 0.004989819135516882, -0.010461105965077877, -0.03252056613564491, 0.001277897972613573, 0.00024628618848510087, 0.020108502358198166, -0.026980360969901085, -0.00009342749399365857, 0.005841163918375969, 0.03682803362607956, 0.030487891286611557, 0.015613801777362823, -0.018234072253108025, 0.014902093447744846, -0.0005569913773797452, 0.03763438016176224, 0.00669791828840971, 0.02388160675764084, 0.046954430639743805, 0.010717052966356277, -0.003937863744795322, -0.023611199110746384, 0.022675778716802597, -0.004536909516900778, -0.041888970881700516, -0.008697674609720707, 0.05693519860506058, 0.011619361117482185, -0.013313652016222477, -0.027907583862543106, 0.01822890155017376, 0.015581544488668442, 0.009419268928468227, -0.05080490931868553, -0.08333927392959595, -0.010609341785311699, -0.0075566815212368965, -0.04429027810692787, 0.05529142916202545, -0.02975531853735447, -0.023084968328475952, -0.0071204002015292645, -0.01917489618062973, 0.00031101162312552333, 0.023965055122971535, 0.008873176760971546, 0.01760539412498474, -0.04380500689148903, 0.012300759553909302, 0.0054082260467112064, -0.023838235065340996, 0.011353841051459312, 0.006799350958317518, -0.026576543226838112, 0.00451291399076581, 0.06432004272937775, 0.0076477788388729095, 0.06691398471593857, -0.011600466445088387, -0.037511132657527924, -0.04191761836409569, 0.015822825953364372, 0.05675260350108147, -0.013698358088731766, -0.04416247829794884, 0.06868873536586761, 0.05228007212281227, 0.012769542634487152, 0.0026389756239950657, -0.08596039563417435, 0.00027764233527705073, -0.007195295300334692, -0.041949592530727386, -0.07144998759031296, 0.002694556023925543, 0.006980258971452713, 0.04457571357488632, 0.026588216423988342, 0.032004933804273605, 0.00038381697959266603, -0.04852008447051048, -0.014713705517351627, 0.006576430052518845, 0.0166737362742424, 0.002632226562127471, 0.05210091918706894, 0.027128396555781364, -0.026798438280820847, 0.028181668370962143, 0.0142319705337286, -0.07712473720312119, -0.01788046397268772, 0.006982181686908007, -0.025996003299951553, 0.06833658367395401, 0.02606586180627346, -0.015975024551153183, -0.04076721891760826, -0.01652934029698372, 0.019550617784261703, 0.06664164364337921, -0.033017221838235855, 0.05998588725924492, 0.015194849111139774, 0.05265042930841446, -0.017662251368165016, 0.01907789520919323, -0.01887499913573265, -0.004999424330890179, -0.012976248748600483, 0.04896490275859833, 0.06145811080932617, 0.01677786372601986, 0.02122443914413452, -0.017850592732429504, -0.04416545853018761, -0.06530126929283142, 0.002715528942644596, 0.007830538786947727, 0.009111741557717323, 0.04258449748158455, 0.016506483778357506, -0.02741951309144497, -0.06126575917005539, -0.018611079081892967, 0.005028683226555586, -0.027251936495304108, -0.0026131703052669764, -0.048351071774959564, -0.0205175019800663, -0.005597684532403946, 0.011825458146631718, -0.01187740545719862, -0.021498888731002808, -0.10075926780700684, -0.05290461704134941, 0.006647375877946615, 0.014489146880805492, -0.04328819736838341, 0.021253962069749832, 0.01106641348451376, 0.0017780981725081801, -0.06671155244112015, -0.0007364880875684321, 0.009492792189121246, 0.00005594865797320381, -0.0229782834649086, -0.01712929829955101, -0.08002263307571411, -0.0497010163962841, -0.018421219661831856, -0.0096859410405159, -0.016313452273607254, 0.05503826215863228, 0.022137034684419632, 0.041594114154577255, 0.07260533422231674, -0.05103985592722893, -0.04005651921033859, 0.000673223112244159, -0.019339902326464653, -0.061633821576833725, 0.01656099408864975, 0.007529799360781908, 0.04610585421323776, -0.06131986528635025, 0.05278477072715759, 0.014164827764034271, -0.006434424314647913, -0.017422862350940704, -0.04605577141046524, -0.005099013913422823, 0.014845187775790691, 0.04511573165655136, -0.05780120566487312, -0.04191943630576134, 0.004591541364789009, -0.018754249438643456, -0.04746371507644653, 0.06102640554308891, 0.047445669770240784, -0.04030120372772217, 0.033985164016485214, -0.04649977385997772, -0.03191400691866875, 0.07755300402641296, 0.03282054141163826, 0.02615409344434738, -0.00893430132418871, 0.08377254754304886, -0.00938440766185522, 0.04589518532156944, -0.029834391549229622, -0.009788377210497856, 0.012335499748587608, -0.04755552113056183, -0.03202555328607559, -0.023515574634075165, -0.05502792447805405, -0.007306602317839861, 0.04047597572207451, 0.03750383108854294, -0.009104672819375992, -0.028217950835824013, 0.008289724588394165, 0.008302082307636738, -0.02395905740559101, -0.009358197450637817, -0.043091174215078354, -0.02073850855231285, -0.08840169757604599, 0.015331094153225422, -0.00486998213455081, -0.013640196993947029, 0.01525080669671297, 0.008960406295955181, -0.07932467758655548, 0.0010561038507148623, -0.04966926574707031, -0.04867864400148392, -0.06831257045269012, -0.04630851000547409, 0.04129822179675102, -0.02990998513996601, -0.06102372333407402, 0.031153328716754913, 0.018224330618977547, -0.03199724480509758, 0.049759864807128906, 0.07008357346057892, 0.015820587053894997, -0.01752048172056675, 0.0381048247218132, -0.04978339746594429, -0.020458752289414406, -0.03985334560275078, 0.03723989799618721, 0.03620316460728645, -0.027372267097234726, 0.004115675576031208, -0.00634426437318325, -0.01914926804602146, 0.018125060945749283 ]
<p>consider me sitting on the top of a train which is travelling close to the speed of light, will I be able to see my image on a mirror which I'm holding in my hand??</p>
g248
[ -0.04287668317556381, 0.0804976299405098, 0.019139543175697327, 0.01877060905098915, 0.001298061921261251, 0.03828960284590721, 0.029716983437538147, 0.05481896549463272, -0.022941429167985916, -0.012706084176898003, 0.02703266218304634, 0.027614062651991844, 0.007493136916309595, -0.01819502003490925, -0.011703516356647015, 0.0034953264985233545, 0.0920545756816864, -0.02459990605711937, -0.012551947496831417, -0.024416256695985794, -0.024156983941793442, 0.006996509153395891, -0.034802794456481934, -0.003862986108288169, -0.06377438455820084, -0.0011210598750039935, -0.02773151732981205, -0.032615892589092255, -0.022083468735218048, -0.03714774176478386, 0.0015379210235551, -0.03954368084669113, -0.022892070934176445, -0.07944626361131668, 0.0004419275501277298, -0.0349106565117836, 0.06658949702978134, 0.0010738387936726213, 0.03418842330574989, -0.0021893216762691736, -0.011061944998800755, -0.005595879629254341, -0.01602870598435402, -0.04020647704601288, 0.06772454082965851, 0.03824484720826149, 0.04229920357465744, -0.01785692386329174, 0.0092477323487401, -0.02634357288479805, -0.02497764118015766, -0.010812115855515003, -0.010114005766808987, 0.00997652392834425, 0.004870718810707331, -0.058964379131793976, -0.039593156427145004, -0.01238661166280508, 0.05219828337430954, -0.013911648653447628, -0.017261575907468796, -0.060750238597393036, -0.005459929816424847, 0.017567023634910583, -0.01333689596503973, 0.06277401745319366, -0.08794953674077988, -0.04604555293917656, 0.03958117589354515, -0.035992447286844254, -0.011681623756885529, 0.04504776373505592, -0.03488672152161598, -0.052550915628671646, -0.002723900368437171, -0.014975947327911854, 0.10473155975341797, -0.018246440216898918, -0.010278557427227497, 0.02929540164768696, -0.008848669938743114, -0.018148303031921387, -0.025523100048303604, 0.022397583350539207, 0.018160458654165268, 0.02505853958427906, 0.005021954886615276, 0.03179682791233063, 0.04368095099925995, 0.05078987777233124, 0.035262033343315125, -0.024583978578448296, 0.05417430400848389, 0.06336329132318497, 0.02339812181890011, -0.03483901917934418, 0.022177167236804962, 0.053492043167352676, 0.024263596162199974, 0.02645069733262062, -0.06795596331357956, -0.01512425672262907, 0.008269168436527252, 0.046713221818208694, 0.019353453069925308, -0.018257925286889076, -0.03346370905637741, -0.02524321712553501, -0.027228178456425667, -0.06614568084478378, 0.0040543656796216965, -0.08644020557403564, -0.0060087693855166435, 0.026536673307418823, -0.029646508395671844, -0.043196212500333786, 0.05547424778342247, 0.0001338818547083065, -0.004617240279912949, 0.0172472782433033, 0.049316879361867905, 0.022819843143224716, -0.002742342883720994, 0.04443048685789108, -0.040537554770708084, -0.01873515546321869, -0.005744814407080412, -0.0354900136590004, -0.003993234597146511, -0.004510686732828617, -0.03912755474448204, 0.04638957604765892, -0.005958843510597944, 0.008130366913974285, -0.01668754778802395, 0.05074679106473923, -0.017685815691947937, -0.05959092453122139, 0.02588018588721752, -0.005359574221074581, 0.029177123680710793, -0.023663030937314034, -0.01071342546492815, -0.004459491930902004, 0.022130277007818222, -0.03824248164892197, -0.03403110057115555, 0.026952175423502922, 0.04392106086015701, 0.0051878937520086765, -0.07813658565282822, 0.04318881034851074, -0.011029119603335857, -0.05865207314491272, 0.0301253329962492, -0.03487135097384453, 0.02537982538342476, 0.01568758673965931, 0.047075677663087845, -0.053250402212142944, 0.08128493279218674, -0.01872389204800129, -0.02336539700627327, -0.031525835394859314, -0.028409898281097412, -0.06626678258180618, -0.010771212168037891, -0.054207708686590195, 0.0667603462934494, -0.03498305380344391, -0.03223246708512306, 0.0742209404706955, 0.04918443039059639, -0.003718240885064006, -0.0007223865250125527, -0.06760907918214798, -0.04331658408045769, -0.030523354187607765, 0.042588118463754654, 0.039325349032878876, 0.039000943303108215, -0.05716922879219055, -0.033284079283475876, -0.08578795194625854, -0.0194766353815794, -0.01531245931982994, -0.024285195395350456, -0.000022085545424488373, -0.04484418034553528, 0.058165352791547775, 0.04244505614042282, -0.04203997924923897, -0.02572033181786537, 0.04779938608407974, 0.004334786906838417, -0.055113717913627625, 0.04445897042751312, 0.0017407680861651897, -0.03580864891409874, -0.00432785227894783, 0.03576921299099922, 0.04866882041096687, 0.018668774515390396, -0.006783499848097563, -0.037245772778987885, -0.01567954197525978, 0.034264370799064636, -0.009429426863789558, -0.011788363568484783, -0.07489767670631409, 0.02629459649324417, 0.014050187543034554, 0.013149681501090527, -0.044713299721479416, 0.04875233396887779, 0.03326837718486786, 0.010916679166257381, -0.038100965321063995, -0.021198775619268417, 0.0371597483754158, 0.02705882117152214, 0.011389759369194508, 0.01398385874927044, -0.06682005524635315, -0.038518089801073074, -0.05153803527355194, -0.08214516937732697, -0.06964148581027985, 0.05190843716263771, 0.06233220547437668, 0.007489303592592478, -0.008386299945414066, 0.04611405357718468, 0.006129966117441654, 0.028590301051735878, 0.0022654756903648376, -0.030321961268782616, -0.017598731443285942, 0.0050788698717951775, -0.010419067926704884, 0.03676833584904671, -0.01239704992622137, 0.013433371670544147, -0.013147070072591305, -0.013859782367944717, 0.07165291160345078, 0.013322636485099792, -0.018471740186214447, 0.04212494194507599, 0.036565955728292465, 0.00010384569031884894, -0.0200527124106884, 0.01726650446653366, 0.00543322553858161, -0.019470127299427986, 0.012410484254360199, -0.030230987817049026, -0.005654426757246256, -0.02653896063566208, 0.03604033216834068, -0.010414240881800652, 0.01761879026889801, -0.05075656250119209, -0.013408389873802662, -0.0465790256857872, 0.0017042403342202306, 0.01821826584637165, 0.009864170104265213, 0.03311516344547272, 0.023831989616155624, -0.011846217326819897, 0.06750746071338654, -0.011641980148851871, 0.056073181331157684, -0.019446689635515213, 0.00037292216438800097, -0.02059689722955227, -0.09383655339479446, 0.026796208694577217, -0.029593512415885925, -0.009312903508543968, 0.024908563122153282, -0.012910455465316772, -0.022591261193156242, 0.017673999071121216, -0.05457083135843277, 0.00301870028488338, 0.03289039433002472, 0.05062542110681534, 0.002584535861387849, -0.054800380021333694, 0.04857635125517845, 0.025353195145726204, 0.02930777706205845, -0.01027971412986517, -0.01636492647230625, 0.03805144131183624, 0.0060428231954574585, -0.0016903053037822247, 0.022694984450936317, 0.03225904330611229, -0.053853362798690796, 0.020227141678333282, 0.014535725116729736, 0.00417105620726943, -0.01676131598651409, -0.05981232225894928, -0.012072931043803692, 0.07398807257413864, 0.012108711525797844, -0.021383309736847878, 0.011939161457121372, -0.009870125912129879, 0.033141374588012695, -0.00607302226126194, -0.03633486479520798, -0.01783125288784504, -0.030764752998948097, -0.006506067700684071, 0.032933857291936874, 0.05870361998677254, 0.017448537051677704, -0.06379536539316177, -0.01248200610280037, 0.05181615427136421, -0.06242750212550163, 0.05546114221215248, 0.019039317965507507, 0.02106146700680256, -0.007629572879523039, 0.003336158813908696, 0.04332784190773964, 0.001585870748385787, 0.012832804583013058, 0.007020663470029831, 0.02677805721759796, 0.027472861111164093, 0.03269750252366066, 0.05811508744955063, -0.02466123178601265, 0.00020830809080507606, 0.004353213123977184, -0.020207025110721588, -0.026865607127547264, 0.09296534210443497, -0.01255322527140379, -0.08610384911298752, -0.01715678907930851, -0.014225934632122517, -0.04720793664455414, 0.04985813796520233, -0.026418033987283707, 0.019054271280765533, -0.07552539557218552, 0.018361276015639305, 0.017249830067157745, -0.0012031387304887176, 0.03237440064549446, 0.019514132291078568, -0.053329501301050186, -0.013210956938564777, 0.012416544370353222, 0.04875274747610092, -0.02838209643959999, -0.01842437870800495, -0.06099487468600273, -0.04847797006368637, 0.04184193164110184, -0.009944933466613293, 0.01966133527457714, 0.0023348494432866573, -0.04819224402308464, -0.04424216225743294, 0.026823099702596664, -0.02138596400618553, -0.000992033863440156, 0.058866750448942184, -0.05570914223790169, -0.007807085290551186, 0.04246986284852028, 0.00849234126508236, 0.03493534028530121, 0.0014525840524584055, 0.039855338633060455, 0.01500554010272026, 0.004995254799723625, -0.0006213883170858026, -0.05499368533492088, 0.045033227652311325, -0.022358978167176247, 0.07709451019763947, -0.04047592356801033, 0.029306063428521156, -0.012476678006350994, -0.02291058748960495, -0.008463619276881218, 0.013963929377496243, -0.017805421724915504, 0.005361593794077635, -0.018482273444533348, 0.013893338851630688, 0.06180356442928314, -0.0361720509827137, 0.04289206862449646, -0.0879402682185173, -0.03499104455113411, -0.018968205899000168, 0.0029681615997105837, 0.021005818620324135, -0.01329466700553894, -0.045245636254549026, -0.018015751615166664, -0.012412605807185173, -0.014237582683563232, 0.013644461520016193, 0.08177558332681656, -0.00189316610340029, -0.006902129855006933, -0.0029351769480854273, 0.030687732622027397, -0.003518828423693776, 0.04436558112502098, 0.04831429198384285, -0.022976404055953026, -0.02199763059616089, 0.07890848070383072, 0.04468890279531479, -0.054913926869630814, -0.012948248535394669, -0.014150520786643028, 0.04655885696411133, -0.03415033966302872, 0.007169349119067192, 0.006919519975781441, -0.03669888153672218, 0.05161751061677933, 0.0238267183303833, -0.027324724942445755, 0.00778203783556819, -0.046183645725250244, 0.06792236119508743, 0.026015451177954674, 0.06693276017904282, 0.016033286228775978, -0.036382175981998444, 0.03846035897731781, -0.025770673528313637, -0.021811092272400856, -0.006398877594619989, -0.0025355294346809387, -0.048328131437301636, 0.017458787187933922, -0.03885183483362198, 0.011410071514546871, -0.03478146344423294, -0.027037328109145164, -0.05171332135796547, -0.03388894721865654, 0.017328813672065735, -0.019413473084568977, -0.02611510455608368, 0.05867487192153931, 0.009883229620754719, -0.00028488325187936425, -0.0032722202595323324, 0.004300570581108332, -0.06692393124103546, -0.01740226149559021, 0.019646940752863884, -0.05555562674999237, -0.03323691710829735, 0.020420385524630547, 0.04160641133785248, 0.043925318866968155, 0.0026071052998304367, -0.0017401722725480795, 0.024710170924663544, -0.0021371771581470966, -0.012059460394084454, 0.04856834188103676, -0.00024829874746501446, 0.02877325378358364, 0.023273076862096786, 0.010837998241186142, -0.03203148394823074, -0.0023812365252524614, -0.020036621019244194, 0.09248870611190796, -0.043121665716171265, -0.017239827662706375, -0.029190650209784508, -0.009781261906027794, -0.025007015094161034, 0.031642552465200424, -0.03120899200439453, 0.022040847688913345, 0.010969913564622402, 0.02630068175494671, -0.0014654711121693254, 0.04287678375840187, 0.015954285860061646, -0.02311171591281891, 0.036776892840862274, 0.019613998010754585, 0.02679961919784546, 0.013612139970064163, 0.0013670410262420774, -0.015489918179810047, 0.00913523230701685, 0.10980204492807388, 0.02113015577197075, -0.01523853000253439, -0.01543684583157301, -0.0029343985952436924, -0.018160484731197357, -0.07079265266656876, -0.03924502059817314, -0.0026737127918750048, -0.013203751295804977, -0.010379797779023647, 0.006826565135270357, -0.02810230478644371, 0.06664466112852097, 0.0013445919612422585, 0.0048753246665000916, 0.01996653899550438, -0.007230997085571289, 0.033226002007722855, 0.06382504850625992, -0.015458839945495129, 0.03162265941500664, 0.01663101278245449, 0.013022029772400856, -0.05849089473485947, -0.024350706487894058, -0.005291779525578022, 0.05651663616299629, -0.0025710398331284523, 0.009049548767507076, 0.07142336666584015, -0.027312522754073143, -0.05155836418271065, -0.02405555546283722, 0.06814923882484436, 0.06008618697524071, 0.0007363119511865079, 0.004903689958155155, 0.018182529136538506, 0.017024286091327667, 0.01888381503522396, 0.028277644887566566, 0.019082359969615936, -0.05721598491072655, 0.05236367508769035, -0.057594433426856995, 0.04585104063153267, 0.02382815070450306, -0.0006331457989290357, 0.052222173660993576, -0.027725225314497948, 0.09244877099990845, 0.05363480746746063, 0.014709552749991417, -0.032797981053590775, -0.005977282300591469, -0.020729735493659973, 0.000824429327622056, 0.040010638535022736, 0.015535694546997547, 0.003285060403868556, -0.026475202292203903, 0.027302587404847145, -0.016231244429945946, 0.0067749363370239735, -0.011405201628804207, -0.026905760169029236, -0.03879673033952713, 0.05103753134608269, -0.05616907775402069, 0.014224755577743053, -0.007831145077943802, -0.021142156794667244, -0.004461269360035658, 0.032398536801338196, 0.014291660860180855, -0.003031782805919647, -0.012781231664121151, -0.04320162162184715, 0.02429516613483429, -0.037119004875421524, -0.03677533566951752, -0.006729559041559696, 0.01393340528011322, -0.013623693957924843, 0.00541897164657712, -0.06305327266454697, -0.07391484081745148, 0.017992256209254265, -0.06727824360132217, 0.10354926437139511, 0.019346315413713455, -0.04839127138257027, 0.007922674529254436, 0.005462605506181717, 0.015973692759871483, 0.032977428287267685, -0.005174800753593445, -0.007419778499752283, 0.01576276496052742, -0.021780069917440414, 0.04027172923088074, 0.044390808790922165, 0.029124120250344276, 0.028893563896417618, -0.04564254358410835, -0.03803342208266258, 0.0026303145568817854, -0.05286981910467148, 0.01279190368950367, -0.028208760544657707, 0.033232178539037704, -0.0028019025921821594, -0.0016458366299048066, -0.028418395668268204, -0.023555418476462364, 0.006998024415224791, -0.012318799272179604, 0.04719296470284462, -0.0040394398383796215, 0.033414438366889954, 0.03167520835995674, -0.06470609456300735, -0.06286792457103729, 0.00436255382373929, 0.020052868872880936, 0.023814456537365913, 0.02332102134823799, -0.01594705879688263, 0.046933140605688095, 0.041819989681243896, -0.030169876292347908, 0.01982857659459114, -0.03311353921890259, -0.021242985501885414, -0.003117973916232586, 0.019441813230514526, 0.014706457033753395, -0.019428012892603874, -0.01163855753839016, -0.04070211574435234, 0.012539458461105824, 0.020219119265675545, -0.03504124656319618, 0.008580520749092102, 0.0021952867973595858, -0.0024282040540128946, -0.008275928907096386, 0.026467174291610718, -0.01861775852739811, -0.032906677573919296, -0.05292775481939316, -0.024477947503328323, -0.06823591142892838, -0.052897777408361435, -0.01564686931669712, 0.014079148881137371, -0.02361134998500347, -0.040906306356191635, -0.03278416395187378, 0.004356312565505505, -0.035645291209220886, -0.06003623083233833, -0.041710641235113144, 0.023908859118819237, 0.046958375722169876, 0.008111285977065563, -0.06465653330087662, 0.02203136868774891, 0.006899872794747353, 0.048205506056547165, -0.031629204750061035, 0.014377583749592304, 0.03607161343097687, 0.020583204925060272, -0.012705319561064243, 0.009947773069143295, 0.032487060874700546, -0.04858090355992317, 0.08164750039577484, -0.12470247596502304, -0.00961615052074194, -0.016928935423493385, 0.013407411053776741, -0.04256770759820938, -0.0015610111877322197, -0.06731535494327545, 0.007771012838929892, 0.0007868425454944372, 0.02989344857633114, 0.01527030672878027, -0.028461243957281113, 0.044849272817373276, -0.003171325195580721, 0.027832765132188797, -0.012914563529193401, -0.0046534305438399315, -0.015273862518370152, 0.036777276545763016, -0.0015167085221037269, 0.017543070018291473, 0.03963370993733406, 0.05369235947728157, 0.014540767297148705, 0.06257428228855133, 0.08935526013374329, -0.0064397878013551235, 0.019807113334536552, 0.016292324289679527, -0.00041154975770041347, 0.04126138240098953, 0.0026272297836840153, 0.045255597680807114, 0.0100431302562356, -0.03588021174073219, -0.04831487312912941, 0.024275029078125954, 0.043293297290802, 0.034242644906044006, -0.03483232110738754, -0.04826050624251366, 0.07240830361843109, 0.05294841155409813, -0.053345054388046265, -0.001516900840215385, -0.026086661964654922, 0.0426618717610836, 0.04056800529360771, -0.03330302983522415, -0.029172636568546295, -0.027487240731716156, -0.02848927304148674, -0.06788089871406555, 0.04074626415967941, 0.006025927606970072, 0.003683834569528699, 0.03606162220239639, 0.011796590872108936, -0.0825277641415596, -0.03928885608911514, -0.011676410213112831, -0.017590293660759926, 0.0593242384493351, 0.0310398917645216, 0.03495560586452484, 0.06540553271770477, -0.01247427612543106, 0.0015624315710738301, -0.0315047912299633, -0.009978783316910267, 0.03437286987900734, -0.04503800719976425, -0.07624616473913193, 0.04456399381160736, -0.028179863467812538, -0.028170909732580185, -0.05021347105503082, -0.03571585938334465, -0.010344392620027065 ]
<p>I'm reading some chemistry-related papers that employ concepts of droplet evaporation. Since I am no chemist, I am wondering:</p> <p>How can I estimate the actual size of a molecule, say <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Succinic_acid" rel="nofollow">succinic acid</a>?</p> <p>An order of magnitude would suffice. I'm aware of the fact that most molecules can not be approximated by simple assuming that they are spherical.</p> <p>Evidently, I don't want to do this bottom-up from quantum mechanics. A broad explanation or just a reference would suffice.</p>
g7416
[ 0.014689956791698933, 0.07646943628787994, 0.01395453978329897, -0.04735277220606804, -0.01398927066475153, 0.0047744945622980595, -0.036233656108379364, 0.05356217920780182, -0.054286859929561615, 0.025897162035107613, -0.02858121134340763, -0.04345342516899109, 0.09735774248838425, 0.0017676828429102898, 0.020617734640836716, -0.011107301339507103, -0.009068730287253857, -0.07176120579242706, 0.007044931873679161, -0.00433148629963398, 0.028941283002495766, -0.05205346271395683, -0.04169171303510666, -0.07676365226507187, -0.08064410090446472, 0.02711627632379532, 0.02244710735976696, 0.015208151191473007, -0.047450728714466095, 0.002254722872748971, -0.09421937167644501, -0.018208840861916542, -0.02765606716275215, -0.0026662941090762615, 0.004066772293299437, 0.04033521190285683, -0.009414436295628548, 0.04398558288812637, 0.03836767375469208, -0.05055557191371918, -0.013981211930513382, -0.05448642000555992, -0.01811029762029648, 0.029317058622837067, -0.01955207996070385, 0.015569259412586689, 0.006234032567590475, 0.04832492396235466, -0.004831806756556034, 0.019810916855931282, 0.03389658033847809, 0.08498679101467133, 0.015392954461276531, -0.00924979243427515, -0.07567021250724792, 0.05819090083241463, 0.05611459165811539, -0.02657584846019745, 0.07742626965045929, 0.029297081753611565, 0.015877973288297653, -0.06499144434928894, -0.020288579165935516, 0.03489810973405838, 0.07569804042577744, 0.008680741302669048, -0.06844942271709442, -0.018595490604639053, 0.004981763660907745, -0.07017122209072113, -0.01582762785255909, -0.021713096648454666, 0.00043205151450820267, -0.0007678040419705212, -0.07828705757856369, 0.003842785255983472, -0.057030852884054184, 0.06254512816667557, 0.04502028971910477, 0.00846894457936287, -0.0310165174305439, -0.05165015161037445, 0.010051599703729153, -0.014120214618742466, 0.026525117456912994, 0.009857309982180595, -0.017567062750458717, -0.0497654564678669, -0.020533960312604904, 0.032897256314754486, -0.014257249422371387, 0.006640136241912842, 0.03388402238488197, -0.01877775974571705, 0.033100441098213196, 0.019798563793301582, 0.029768679291009903, -0.021522268652915955, -0.0511600524187088, -0.007459737826138735, 0.048649534583091736, 0.06208927929401398, 0.02728462778031826, -0.0247991643846035, 0.04816259816288948, 0.021756498143076897, 0.012791034765541553, -0.013490372337400913, 0.05264255777001381, 0.006557297892868519, -0.029341883957386017, -0.017569251358509064, -0.04213361814618111, -0.017210232093930244, -0.031043995171785355, -0.020503992214798927, 0.012291546911001205, 0.011287667788565159, 0.0408494807779789, 0.043052926659584045, 0.00807072315365076, 0.06377314031124115, 0.0693306177854538, 0.04721681773662567, -0.012759394943714142, -0.022729869931936264, 0.012584124691784382, 0.058705542236566544, -0.017786864191293716, -0.018399884924292564, 0.06036902219057083, -0.024186251685023308, 0.013634580187499523, -0.008171502500772476, 0.02247672528028488, 0.03569049388170242, -0.02242688089609146, -0.0313885398209095, -0.01660124771296978, -0.035275012254714966, 0.0035706458147615194, 0.0004285263712517917, 0.05415693670511246, 0.012989005073904991, -0.05602175369858742, -0.004222509916871786, -0.053339410573244095, 0.05669248476624489, -0.014354865998029709, -0.02449488453567028, -0.03515748679637909, 0.01735510490834713, 0.05537722632288933, -0.031030232086777687, -0.009096018970012665, 0.015886245295405388, 0.010725945234298706, -0.014460914768278599, -0.03436119854450226, 0.03318681940436363, 0.025492103770375252, 0.018184922635555267, -0.006335696205496788, 0.041695475578308105, -0.06818219274282455, 0.013034487143158913, 0.032352495938539505, -0.07833771407604218, -0.03553443029522896, -0.07107380032539368, -0.013013067655265331, 0.010873719118535519, -0.007953961379826069, 0.0024362048134207726, -0.03884484991431236, 0.036724865436553955, 0.052999068051576614, 0.0037434841506183147, 0.01615140028297901, 0.01266082189977169, 0.07789374142885208, -0.005823618732392788, 0.03515934199094772, 0.0015512043610215187, 0.030627518892288208, 0.011549001559615135, 0.037605661898851395, 0.040822919458150864, -0.013759225606918335, -0.00520427618175745, -0.006023741792887449, -0.03562796488404274, 0.03335199132561684, -0.0406491793692112, 0.005829806439578533, 0.0364234521985054, 0.05548672750592232, -0.04491210728883743, 0.011629927903413773, 0.01546136848628521, -0.03152326121926308, 0.016623346135020256, -0.008725417777895927, 0.03493145480751991, 0.034974414855241776, -0.04501914232969284, -0.03162914514541626, 0.012341431342065334, -0.006663772743195295, -0.0007790673989802599, 0.010297979228198528, -0.039871834218502045, -0.015662027522921562, 0.004481060896068811, -0.007011577486991882, 0.028270753100514412, -0.018192503601312637, -0.01798206754028797, -0.004725325852632523, 0.031377796083688736, 0.014162697829306126, 0.031016774475574493, 0.009154715575277805, -0.010787790641188622, 0.04503876343369484, 0.0336499959230423, 0.05521600693464279, 0.01194742787629366, 0.026682954281568527, -0.010677948594093323, -0.08234991878271103, -0.006944126449525356, -0.046539630740880966, 0.010493692010641098, -0.0129676703363657, 0.05058566853404045, -0.06068939343094826, -0.006790159270167351, -0.0039202021434903145, 0.024002671241760254, 0.060668110847473145, 0.006169484928250313, -0.0350106842815876, 0.049942631274461746, 0.02884705550968647, -0.03980112820863724, 0.015000498853623867, -0.011797330342233181, -0.004397342447191477, -0.012867879122495651, -0.023282578215003014, 0.006899537984281778, 0.025904277339577675, -0.033477723598480225, -0.021458497270941734, 0.03315481171011925, -0.004632831085473299, 0.003090217709541321, 0.009764414280653, -0.05999681353569031, -0.0056671821512281895, -0.020512284711003304, 0.10074510425329208, 0.0392993688583374, -0.019908400252461433, -0.02952364645898342, -0.05760810151696205, 0.01972164772450924, 0.017661359161138535, 0.016469260677695274, -0.0045187328942120075, 0.031918130815029144, -0.008965895511209965, 0.003963623195886612, -0.012694181874394417, 0.02384101413190365, 0.014218761585652828, 0.008625142276287079, 0.014210555702447891, 0.038751449435949326, -0.04689974710345268, 0.030911464244127274, -0.018310056999325752, 0.10978496819734573, 0.023017317056655884, -0.061665959656238556, 0.018712608143687248, 0.039385419338941574, -0.022791331633925438, -0.04616551846265793, 0.01819058507680893, 0.019078372046351433, -0.03509024530649185, 0.03237741440534592, -0.038644883781671524, -0.0001598446979187429, 0.03510008379817009, -0.004112170077860355, -0.0111367367208004, 0.0020813331939280033, -0.00383725855499506, -0.01242752093821764, 0.0010082416702061892, 0.040592629462480545, -0.004540532827377319, 0.07469635456800461, -0.04283731058239937, -0.03550463169813156, -0.008256406523287296, -0.03072482906281948, -0.030189283192157745, 0.04444967210292816, -0.031020469963550568, 0.020304124802350998, -0.04032127931714058, -0.012768546119332314, 0.03972937911748886, 0.017220262438058853, -0.0039508044719696045, -0.002444092184305191, 0.04694579541683197, -0.08164703845977783, 0.02280695177614689, 0.042349573224782944, 0.011573482304811478, 0.024057064205408096, -0.06070884317159653, -0.029503611847758293, 0.036441389471292496, -0.056786540895700455, 0.004579965956509113, -0.0230119526386261, -0.038216475397348404, -0.02612156979739666, -0.030560599640011787, -0.044308874756097794, -0.00712191266939044, -0.020790288224816322, -0.0188595037907362, -0.024378880858421326, -0.016793157905340195, 0.0009700644877739251, -0.009185833856463432, -0.013197595253586769, 0.0027142036706209183, 0.025638006627559662, -0.0653429925441742, -0.00888658408075571, -0.02237951196730137, -0.10594669729471207, 0.0402691476047039, -0.008430922403931618, 0.04715404286980629, 0.010227169841527939, 0.07291797548532486, 0.04999713599681854, 0.007184768095612526, -0.0439334511756897, 0.06772660464048386, -0.019411038607358932, -0.0026087157893925905, -0.05122305080294609, 0.0965111255645752, 0.04328368231654167, 0.04930993914604187, -0.0704762265086174, -0.03806433826684952, 0.027471814304590225, -0.028473101556301117, 0.009185259230434895, -0.06458742916584015, 0.005729221273213625, 0.022666439414024353, 0.028307540342211723, 0.012381876818835735, -0.035390451550483704, 0.02093084156513214, 0.04292130097746849, -0.028728054836392403, -0.0332583524286747, 0.036066751927137375, 0.07322949171066284, -0.02828027494251728, -0.06719808280467987, -0.056229107081890106, -0.0317598320543766, -0.06802948564291, 0.019484063610434532, 0.013638390228152275, -0.04389943927526474, 0.02356167510151863, -0.08591528236865997, -0.02950730174779892, -0.05785144120454788, -0.013071363791823387, 0.039795320481061935, 0.05121653899550438, 0.0007425171206705272, -0.016256727278232574, 0.033874694257974625, 0.012957108207046986, -0.003758028382435441, -0.011546839028596878, -0.025735478848218918, 0.031107164919376373, 0.006981320679187775, 0.00125154631678015, 0.001785322674550116, -0.00901020411401987, -0.03211117535829544, 0.011130365543067455, 0.04656795412302017, 0.004651473369449377, -0.018612714484333992, -0.021250952035188675, -0.03632230684161186, -0.009390190243721008, -0.0472034253180027, -0.026307152584195137, 0.049468137323856354, -0.007020775228738785, -0.009090607985854149, -0.04346707835793495, -0.04716448113322258, -0.06756678968667984, 0.03375730291008949, 0.021034516394138336, 0.028607778251171112, 0.018600521609187126, -0.008010156452655792, 0.006926807574927807, -0.012530194595456123, 0.008340333588421345, 0.07337526977062225, -0.030006228014826775, -0.04479144886136055, 0.010275029577314854, 0.024029629305005074, 0.051790934056043625, 0.02404467947781086, 0.00542549230158329, 0.04629077762365341, -0.027066519483923912, 0.05449211969971657, 0.005207730922847986, 0.006639166735112667, 0.018276553601026535, 0.016971813514828682, -0.020229274407029152, -0.025302937254309654, -0.04605753719806671, 0.008017857559025288, -0.07498195022344589, 0.012580392882227898, -0.01668521948158741, 0.00505588436499238, -0.044457871466875076, 0.0021860955748707056, 0.026750758290290833, 0.0512271486222744, -0.05034720152616501, 0.03698841109871864, -0.010048642754554749, 0.02372048608958721, -0.005413339007645845, -0.04100215807557106, -0.042080238461494446, -0.03715189918875694, 0.014550097286701202, 0.033582303673028946, -0.05758308246731758, 0.02437758445739746, 0.026829300448298454, 0.03785001114010811, 0.0232078954577446, -0.06551653891801834, -0.00533201452344656, -0.0112436069175601, -0.012972552329301834, 0.007634417153894901, -0.02161577343940735, 0.012339218519628048, 0.012675088830292225, 0.03287651017308235, 0.023717662319540977, 0.037081632763147354, 0.02201250195503235, 0.02005877159535885, 0.03660517558455467, -0.001040296396240592, -0.013519171625375748, 0.00703390734270215, -0.04719381034374237, -0.017820309847593307, -0.013718272559344769, -0.05728547275066376, -0.019954083487391472, -0.04538614675402641, -0.00832515861839056, 0.028654979541897774, -0.08985113352537155, 0.025684868916869164, 0.03149884566664696, 0.012675908394157887, 0.007859106175601482, 0.03708428889513016, 0.03669516742229462, -0.010139115154743195, -0.004214824177324772, 0.039274659007787704, 0.0025744233280420303, -0.010081632062792778, -0.003190615912899375, 0.045741450041532516, -0.011447419412434101, 0.006690060719847679, -0.006916735786944628, 0.059126731008291245, -0.03879304602742195, 0.05335862562060356, 0.03776179999113083, 0.004038033075630665, -0.011352063156664371, 0.009382150135934353, -0.059277310967445374, 0.0006919114966876805, -0.061324432492256165, -0.0823339968919754, 0.01879151351749897, 0.020493555814027786, -0.007260466460138559, -0.004681812599301338, -0.057425856590270996, -0.0014840435469523072, 0.0034959246404469013, 0.01935853809118271, -0.020386656746268272, 0.011629845947027206, 0.020126910880208015, 0.039084166288375854, -0.01872936077415943, 0.01145106740295887, -0.0335497111082077, 0.0670933648943901, 0.02142191119492054, -0.04748233035206795, 0.04020552337169647, 0.01789463683962822, 0.06709631532430649, 0.061182305216789246, -0.035879697650671005, 0.015170655213296413, 0.018606320023536682, -0.018680719658732414, 0.03377711400389671, 0.008026315830647945, -0.0467134453356266, -0.0032244506292045116, 0.03828556835651398, -0.00918444711714983, -0.03555708006024361, 0.014575676061213017, 0.02522558905184269, 0.04081736505031586, -0.02648000419139862, 0.03949941322207451, -0.026600945740938187, -0.014518994837999344, 0.02303559146821499, 0.02214013785123825, -0.06740225106477737, -0.02192753739655018, -0.03748505935072899, -0.05559444800019264, -0.0009795931400731206, 0.002003269735723734, 0.07194648683071136, -0.05073253810405731, -0.03807806223630905, -0.00030132869142107666, -0.014424638822674751, 0.026211168617010117, -0.007041470147669315, -0.052143871784210205, -0.04161012917757034, 0.003176638390868902, -0.05324459448456764, 0.04135752469301224, 0.010646634735167027, 0.07591117918491364, 0.03260871767997742, -0.007533728610724211, -0.05940879136323929, -0.0560477189719677, -0.05287426710128784, -0.04654029756784439, -0.011560257524251938, 0.009998638182878494, -0.015818510204553604, 0.024415966123342514, 0.00004229267142363824, 0.04658682644367218, 0.007758528459817171, -0.03307607024908066, 0.04449381306767464, 0.03082657977938652, -0.02395113930106163, 0.06181524321436882, 0.0013427739031612873, -0.03999318182468414, -0.02902965247631073, 0.019535623490810394, 0.035062648355960846, -0.01484624668955803, 0.011964013800024986, -0.06841027736663818, 0.05035150796175003, 0.002575971418991685, -0.007291639689356089, -0.05084020644426346, -0.008966071531176567, -0.0502026192843914, 0.01652536541223526, 0.004658100660890341, -0.0021353906486183405, 0.03735695779323578, 0.024658171460032463, 0.02032654359936714, 0.05969001352787018, 0.014103139750659466, 0.009521635249257088, -0.014244181104004383, 0.04144247621297836, 0.053791437298059464, 0.020321600139141083, 0.07062789052724838, -0.0455600768327713, 0.0318521149456501, 0.0411328449845314, 0.04607703164219856, 0.004682354629039764, -0.04956788942217827, 0.0136235561221838, 0.08561151474714279, -0.07717276364564896, -0.00028662203112617135, 0.011875070631504059, 0.039949897676706314, 0.005710130091756582, -0.038479678332805634, 0.06562552601099014, -0.03615949675440788, -0.024024074897170067, -0.0021764689590781927, -0.05997737497091293, 0.04452107846736908, -0.007588106673210859, 0.0021782084368169308, -0.0012597159948199987, -0.047207124531269073, -0.02938542701303959, -0.015366249717772007, 0.09889787435531616, -0.0653008371591568, 0.03894629701972008, -0.007437584921717644, 0.022212963551282883, -0.008931871503591537, -0.00825386494398117, -0.06841135025024414, 0.004420625511556864, -0.011493125930428505, -0.061793092638254166, -0.02629362978041172, 0.019512366503477097, -0.006896215490996838, 0.06749881058931351, -0.03742082044482231, 0.0018701419467106462, -0.00893285870552063, -0.007871853187680244, 0.006075962912291288, 0.03902016952633858, -0.05627499148249626, -0.015913505107164383, 0.022803233936429024, -0.07071976363658905, -0.005096725188195705, 0.07746509462594986, 0.013027247972786427, 0.028836343437433243, -0.019722633063793182, -0.005127417854964733, -0.018524838611483574, -0.0038934932090342045, 0.015875328332185745, 0.03858978673815727, -0.035549409687519073, 0.024796465411782265, -0.028935646638274193, 0.0039061822462826967, -0.01407988928258419, 0.039844874292612076, -0.033086344599723816, 0.023342914879322052, 0.015564203262329102, -0.04648002237081528, 0.0660386011004448, -0.012426885776221752, -0.03079935535788536, 0.02123519591987133, -0.04005436226725578, 0.012421424500644207, 0.02423664927482605, 0.08060278743505478, -0.037390220910310745, -0.040528904646635056, -0.016325194388628006, -0.011027039028704166, -0.037470098584890366, -0.03854530304670334, -0.006530627142637968, 0.03122898004949093, -0.04611263424158096, -0.009761175140738487, -0.0343155711889267, -0.03727467358112335, 0.031991783529520035, 0.017511829733848572, 0.03246898204088211, 0.029057500883936882, 0.018835481256246567, 0.02818656899034977, -0.0015791123732924461, -0.03967594355344772, 0.005809204652905464, 0.035554274916648865, -0.03804698958992958, -0.03525059297680855, -0.01719200238585472, -0.023581670597195625, -0.00789736583828926, 0.05261759087443352, -0.05204857140779495, 0.04116494581103325, -0.015475365333259106, -0.055861230939626694, 0.01620844192802906, 0.05359594523906708, -0.05159419775009155, -0.0062934341840445995, 0.040660127997398376, -0.0050247181206941605, 0.05113481357693672, 0.05196758359670639, -0.08474031090736389, -0.004570935387164354, 0.06301429122686386, -0.002226986223831773, -0.029576648026704788, -0.02881450019776821, -0.00006317207589745522, 0.016225995495915413, 0.041980501264333725, 0.023790137842297554, -0.002622462110593915, -0.015412215143442154, 0.03657127544283867 ]
<p>I am rather a theoretician and looking for a formalism to represent biological clocks by Hermitian operators.</p> <p>The simplest thought model I am looking for is a formal representation of a clock (for instance 12 hours clock) by applying a Hermitian operator (e.g. Hamiltonian)?</p> <p><em>Note: a clock is a discrete modular representation</em></p> <p>As questions came up, let me try to explain: </p> <p>A clock has a modular arithmetic, that is a discrete oscillator, for instance: $$a \equiv b \pmod n$$</p> <p>Many biological clocks work like this, and our 12 hours clock is similar $\pmod {12}$.</p> <p>It is possible as Raskolnikov indicated to apply an inverse Fourier type of approach and express such clocks, as discrete as they are, in the form of a sum such as (example):</p> <p>$$\psi_q=\sum_{k=1}^q \frac{\omega_q}{4 \pi} \left( e^{-i(k-1)\;\omega_q x} + e^{i(k-1)\;\omega_q x}\right)$$</p> <p>Both are the representation of the same type of clock.</p> <p>My first question is <em>how does the parameters in the first equation relate to the second equation?</em></p> <p>My second question is <em>then what is the Hermitian operator of the second equation?</em></p> <p>My third question is <em>how can I find to a type of algorithm or general method to read the first equation directly into a Hermitian operator?</em></p> <p>The fact that I use this for biological clocks is marginal. The $\pmod n$ operation is independent of where we use it.</p> <p>I hope this helps, but if still questions, I am glad to explain.</p>
g7417
[ 0.04954051971435547, -0.011053885333240032, -0.020677030086517334, -0.040305767208337784, 0.015850432217121124, -0.0441245436668396, 0.04327812418341637, 0.03026697412133217, -0.03254410997033119, 0.007662793155759573, -0.010828813537955284, 0.04651884734630585, 0.013850447721779346, 0.028076844289898872, 0.01870853081345558, -0.018848273903131485, 0.033375084400177, 0.06372593343257904, 0.00738363666459918, 0.011569513007998466, -0.0006632523727603257, 0.0733211487531662, 0.03600737825036049, -0.010531476698815823, -0.025200586766004562, 0.001506136846728623, 0.017273863777518272, 0.023715732619166374, -0.041039030998945236, -0.021695060655474663, -0.050010036677122116, -0.025462429970502853, 0.04500151053071022, 0.01811741665005684, -0.03589467704296112, 0.017632562667131424, -0.007749809417873621, -0.022315865382552147, 0.0072826119139790535, 0.02966964617371559, 0.03745364025235176, 0.0036734461318701506, 0.018634667620062828, 0.004096937365829945, -0.030239930376410484, -0.0030823315028101206, -0.03361086547374725, 0.03723136708140373, -0.017336320132017136, 0.019126616418361664, 0.033919718116521835, -0.04048608988523483, 0.03732490539550781, -0.012360836379230022, 0.007594956085085869, -0.00039916025707498193, -0.011296061798930168, -0.03341742977499962, 0.061376653611660004, 0.06054197624325752, 0.028274431824684143, -0.035772450268268585, -0.0159109178930521, 0.009181734174489975, 0.02778780460357666, 0.02837526611983776, 0.025655556470155716, -0.002890487667173147, 0.06257615983486176, 0.0005140972789376974, 0.019432488828897476, -0.07628405839204788, 0.03934020549058914, -0.02513900026679039, 0.03480534628033638, 0.04753686860203743, 0.026167508214712143, -0.04494412988424301, -0.010971867479383945, 0.018009647727012634, -0.017188671976327896, -0.014408962801098824, 0.025348104536533356, 0.01892372965812683, 0.006165423430502415, -0.001240986748598516, -0.00498978653922677, 0.0005422835820354521, 0.02948463149368763, 0.02193426340818405, 0.015507176518440247, -0.023675205186009407, 0.011081970296800137, -0.016146890819072723, -0.0512174591422081, 0.008038397878408432, -0.09613589197397232, 0.03365115821361542, -0.03714565932750702, 0.020646346732974052, 0.024961154907941818, 0.016164299100637436, -0.009732277132570744, -0.07887473702430725, 0.004621625877916813, 0.0026771794073283672, 0.01685972698032856, -0.005998875014483929, -0.04447895660996437, -0.032508619129657745, -0.06505313515663147, -0.010615980252623558, -0.05328380689024925, 0.02125021256506443, -0.00347865535877645, -0.018238620832562447, 0.018890582025051117, -0.008685693144798279, -0.01888308860361576, 0.021737484261393547, 0.046940818428993225, -0.011054793372750282, 0.06971124559640884, 0.04986003786325455, 0.006118683610111475, 0.00539303058758378, -0.005771086551249027, 0.03459944948554039, -0.018258685246109962, -0.0020802055951207876, 0.04544516280293465, 0.0723353773355484, -0.028208905830979347, 0.06075809523463249, 0.014846045523881912, 0.007493177894502878, -0.06813772767782211, -0.008509872481226921, 0.0313885398209095, -0.012712414376437664, -0.01092867273837328, -0.022289834916591644, -0.012578176334500313, -0.00239981384947896, -0.04168679937720299, 0.04772689566016197, 0.01166002918034792, -0.08077993243932724, 0.007004843093454838, 0.012331429868936539, -0.03222644329071045, 0.06902704387903214, 0.04517088457942009, -0.015803838148713112, 0.0167508814483881, -0.039586763828992844, 0.03051295317709446, 0.03912554308772087, -0.0547221340239048, 0.024585623294115067, 0.06438512355089188, -0.0031357770785689354, 0.002667937893420458, -0.021347571164369583, -0.03717273101210594, -0.04016902297735214, -0.025898143649101257, -0.03584106266498566, -0.020258817821741104, -0.03042118437588215, 0.038781922310590744, 0.06781704723834991, -0.001298128510825336, 0.030817946419119835, 0.000737191119696945, 0.06423833966255188, -0.06475324183702469, -0.010053497739136219, -0.028149956837296486, 0.005251763854175806, -0.02632186748087406, -0.03268412500619888, -0.008295716717839241, -0.06575170904397964, -0.015408225357532501, -0.026512689888477325, 0.06007407233119011, 0.013229302130639553, -0.04730331152677536, -0.024114158004522324, -0.008088166825473309, 0.042573388665914536, 0.07038451731204987, 0.01295913103967905, -0.015886027365922928, 0.03202006220817566, -0.02739841118454933, -0.05405177175998688, 0.07812611758708954, 0.0024926909245550632, 0.06209097057580948, 0.006152589339762926, 0.052951496094465256, 0.0283778328448534, 0.053892895579338074, 0.0739808902144432, 0.00748402951285243, -0.031186658889055252, -0.006812569219619036, -0.054342206567525864, 0.009584535844624043, -0.027731744572520256, 0.015612496063113213, 0.024897638708353043, -0.013004744425415993, 0.01357383094727993, 0.04628387838602066, 0.012884940020740032, -0.02227930910885334, 0.014353776350617409, 0.03376308083534241, -0.05929746851325035, -0.020429451018571854, -0.033934012055397034, 0.006715739145874977, 0.0007054348825477064, -0.03146994486451149, -0.010539546608924866, 0.0065251789055764675, 0.029917944222688675, -0.04180718958377838, -0.013067333959043026, -0.02378522790968418, -0.008045755326747894, 0.019469227641820908, 0.030385755002498627, -0.010060538537800312, 0.017019307240843773, 0.00647001713514328, 0.025911040604114532, 0.013591236434876919, 0.014935504645109177, -0.0004932162119075656, -0.023701226338744164, -0.029339445754885674, -0.04433031007647514, 0.008340311236679554, 0.006461171433329582, -0.01960418000817299, 0.0031640599481761456, -0.009699848480522633, 0.0027346767019480467, -0.05575594678521156, -0.05708570405840874, -0.005596118047833443, -0.02675718255341053, 0.02960158698260784, 0.03709844872355461, -0.009076154790818691, 0.06220284849405289, 0.02704877033829689, -0.010612241923809052, -0.03662959486246109, 0.06326376646757126, 0.012634392827749252, -0.09000382572412491, -0.0022794415708631277, 0.05070463940501213, -0.033377137035131454, -0.012411436066031456, 0.007854131050407887, 0.038240548223257065, -0.025427401065826416, 0.0018678250489756465, -0.02971029095351696, -0.05756280571222305, 0.010785731486976147, -0.023316005244851112, 0.04161631688475609, -0.005790421739220619, -0.001288553699851036, -0.012636018916964531, -0.045018069446086884, 0.034025683999061584, 0.0027500931173563004, -0.06275152415037155, 0.0009441268048249185, 0.011169781908392906, 0.011790446937084198, -0.006417608354240656, 0.01841597445309162, 0.06455269455909729, -0.00840332917869091, 0.0003403097507543862, -0.08224478363990784, 0.034477341920137405, -0.014804141595959663, -0.031161390244960785, 0.02260207198560238, 0.07332141697406769, 0.028225596994161606, -0.02695121429860592, 0.022112810984253883, -0.003840228309854865, 0.02127397432923317, -0.038465846329927444, -0.042152710258960724, -0.04401338845491409, -0.025888485834002495, -0.014479799196124077, -0.01231903862208128, 0.020722301676869392, 0.02590210549533367, -0.025080645456910133, -0.01116991601884365, 0.022872038185596466, -0.07657855749130249, -0.04122118279337883, 0.0300587248057127, 0.04420504346489906, 0.011873611249029636, -0.011535286903381348, 0.0018583789933472872, -0.007999795489013195, 0.05966060236096382, -0.026320187374949455, -0.03039107844233513, 0.02535172551870346, -0.0414913147687912, 0.007675252854824066, 0.04930583015084267, -0.0048268442042171955, 0.007272451184689999, 0.036690860986709595, 0.0008183961035683751, -0.025700127705931664, -0.12438169121742249, -0.02104140631854534, -0.05190711468458176, -0.06459493190050125, -0.007470536045730114, -0.03563421592116356, -0.027639081701636314, -0.021081531420350075, 0.00984842050820589, -0.05235864967107773, 0.03964272886514664, -0.028205756098031998, -0.03449900075793266, -0.06775036454200745, -0.07680583745241165, -0.018530815839767456, 0.03781602159142494, 0.010443104431033134, 0.006370952818542719, 0.04738469421863556, 0.03285685554146767, 0.08689956367015839, -0.008053550496697426, 0.015303866006433964, -0.016571296378970146, -0.017108622938394547, -0.006128557026386261, 0.018861668184399605, 0.02973492257297039, -0.02674557827413082, -0.004497308749705553, 0.040769465267658234, 0.05024053901433945, -0.016665691509842873, 0.03628397732973099, 0.055889684706926346, 0.05096227675676346, -0.01781986840069294, 0.025901054963469505, -0.07365594804286957, -0.056044552475214005, 0.0008361677173525095, 0.046005960553884506, 0.0577862486243248, -0.07055139541625977, -0.06731627881526947, 0.018538394942879677, -0.016115723177790642, 0.09595657885074615, 0.03955014795064926, 0.056027598679065704, 0.03669888153672218, -0.024443408474326134, -0.019359931349754333, 0.022144433110952377, -0.056782763451337814, 0.007945675402879715, -0.03312000259757042, 0.04270174726843834, 0.016338912770152092, 0.008405142463743687, 0.0058557456359267235, -0.043401334434747696, -0.043619588017463684, 0.010882093571126461, -0.04365124925971031, 0.06373330950737, 0.01823645830154419, 0.003072703257203102, 0.06522060185670853, -0.020309902727603912, -0.056851476430892944, -0.006081447005271912, -0.0649435818195343, -0.032000333070755005, -0.011090822517871857, 0.0690721645951271, 0.019362779334187508, 0.011075610294938087, 0.05642843246459961, 0.07807757705450058, -0.07424741238355637, 0.0061288997530937195, 0.03793662413954735, -0.0017042799154296517, 0.04024786502122879, -0.014609554782509804, -0.022267259657382965, -0.026732221245765686, 0.0616021603345871, 0.03247595205903053, -0.005231770686805248, -0.002949791494756937, -0.05402856692671776, -0.02733394131064415, -0.00792927946895361, -0.002071535214781761, 0.09382764995098114, -0.036582957953214645, -0.018328268080949783, -0.006409383844584227, 0.045102789998054504, -0.026783617213368416, -0.0033832245972007513, 0.005519210360944271, -0.025346720591187477, 0.017733478918671608, 0.007032495923340321, -0.0020812139846384525, 0.02961529791355133, 0.005371115170419216, -0.07293127477169037, -0.030438991263508797, 0.003480457467958331, 0.04169372841715813, 0.08775842189788818, 0.010244442149996758, -0.054257165640592575, 0.03204939141869545, 0.037744082510471344, -0.011174311861395836, 0.03361345827579498, -0.006341609638184309, 0.013039251789450645, -0.07950560003519058, -0.00795512180775404, -0.02483823336660862, 0.021063877269625664, 0.015170294791460037, -0.032113444060087204, -0.05839305743575096, 0.024522455409169197, -0.004593914840370417, -0.022261761128902435, 0.010052804835140705, -0.06628207862377167, 0.013820190913975239, -0.0041014268063008785, -0.015622715465724468, 0.0013835246209055185, 0.016575047746300697, -0.016895197331905365, -0.038589660078287125, 0.02036580815911293, 0.017099464312195778, -0.003122316673398018, -0.057470615953207016, 0.06978896260261536, -0.03362127020955086, 0.015550465323030949, 0.05850812792778015, -0.018331626430153847, -0.013633668422698975, 0.00835786759853363, -0.011007179506123066, -0.028243372216820717, 0.06255772709846497, 0.010245613753795624, -0.0030243461951613426, 0.029778962954878807, 0.0113671300932765, 0.003667485434561968, 0.0338565967977047, -0.05871458351612091, -0.016453029587864876, 0.04452066123485565, -0.013116552494466305, 0.016460523009300232, 0.07091453671455383, 0.04179340973496437, 0.03174399957060814, 0.006343054119497538, -0.005752116907387972, 0.10573967546224594, 0.04033584147691727, -0.02694765105843544, -0.07726138830184937, -0.004591422621160746, 0.010910235345363617, -0.025767317041754723, -0.04224303737282753, -0.026439256966114044, -0.009624912403523922, -0.07461655884981155, -0.008449388667941093, -0.013849746435880661, 0.05794607475399971, -0.049814075231552124, -0.005013047717511654, -0.014610704965889454, -0.04116642102599144, -0.06925583630800247, -0.009035022929310799, -0.0020090800244361162, -0.001644146628677845, 0.019679637625813484, -0.0026345355436205864, -0.015400749631226063, -0.030117327347397804, 0.019812751561403275, 0.015391115099191666, 0.04204307124018669, 0.029596049338579178, -0.012267565354704857, 0.010307705029845238, -0.030159983783960342, 0.04915933310985565, 0.0322873555123806, 0.0019612396135926247, -0.006346599198877811, 0.022408144548535347, -0.003236006712540984, -0.030139906331896782, 0.02828974835574627, -0.021047217771410942, 0.03820158168673515, -0.028413953259587288, -0.004550570156425238, 0.009300818666815758, 0.014582493342459202, -0.0001978952350327745, -0.03276670724153519, -0.0006506741628982127, 0.05606069415807724, 0.02835167944431305, 0.02501356601715088, 0.0027792679611593485, -0.015687033534049988, 0.02343682572245598, -0.005083979573100805, 0.021447649225592613, 0.0061078001745045185, 0.04686640575528145, 0.061482954770326614, 0.07159440219402313, -0.02211252599954605, 0.017066262662410736, 0.011356538161635399, -0.017031362280249596, -0.03509088233113289, 0.01349422987550497, -0.06279582530260086, -0.04479243606328964, 0.02591913938522339, -0.0205609742552042, 0.007109495811164379, -0.06916340440511703, 0.009963152930140495, 0.004715822171419859, 0.006559876725077629, -0.006501419004052877, 0.00014455524797085673, -0.03292996808886528, 0.012820110656321049, 0.011151821352541447, 0.0528060607612133, -0.05230480805039406, -0.07790965586900711, 0.05863460898399353, 0.005212902091443539, 0.04586762562394142, 0.003972894977778196, 0.05324395373463631, 0.01700953021645546, -0.012642033398151398, -0.07591818273067474, 0.0010774274123832583, -0.007925120182335377, -0.004497438669204712, 0.0810958594083786, -0.10386916249990463, -0.004021401982754469, 0.041263073682785034, 0.011238710023462772, 0.0008207408245652914, 0.0007508643320761621, -0.015463035553693771, 0.026217453181743622, -0.032905302941799164, -0.036604899913072586, -0.03098803013563156, 0.03348246589303017, -0.008794093504548073, 0.030379708856344223, 0.06566475331783295, 0.016487322747707367, 0.030091121792793274, -0.028895407915115356, 0.014059137552976608, 0.026497486978769302, 0.02454817295074463, 0.009656785987317562, -0.01362758781760931, -0.023200329393148422, -0.009161241352558136, -0.052244074642658234, -0.04599257931113243, 0.04602506756782532, 0.03271385282278061, 0.008660009130835533, -0.09312838315963745, 0.05961575731635094, -0.07243901491165161, -0.012630101293325424, 0.024287555366754532, -0.0007086945697665215, 0.08436605334281921, 0.0038470097351819277, -0.0755859836935997, -0.003049056977033615, 0.04317699745297432, 0.051458731293678284, -0.03375576063990593, 0.03034006990492344, 0.07055112719535828, -0.0019312044605612755, -0.06437945365905762, 0.058464113622903824, -0.04959766939282417, -0.033101554960012436, 0.026543188840150833, -0.029663121327757835, 0.031545475125312805, -0.024479681625962257, -0.020487891510128975, -0.02433810941874981, -0.027126390486955643, -0.0050165848806500435, 0.018243739381432533, 0.06131479889154434, -0.041127368807792664, 0.012547625228762627, 0.013886031694710255, -0.02588399313390255, -0.009671666659414768, -0.019195130094885826, 0.0047526489943265915, 0.013493211939930916, -0.0012173829600214958, -0.0001103226313716732, -0.013006447814404964, -0.010150203481316566, -0.09220302850008011, -0.06369001418352127, 0.014663830399513245, 0.005349910818040371, -0.049797430634498596, -0.0018666243413463235, 0.011791727505624294, 0.05006706714630127, 0.05415115877985954, 0.05184091255068779, -0.017665531486272812, -0.02694695256650448, 0.018748018890619278, 0.05822223424911499, 0.034223489463329315, -0.039357177913188934, -0.019181542098522186, 0.021617025136947632, 0.032783493399620056, 0.049700744450092316, -0.01633058860898018, 0.00325415818952024, 0.06779132783412933, -0.032748594880104065, 0.03904324024915695, 0.00987499300390482, 0.008183790370821953, -0.004939164035022259, -0.037776049226522446, -0.056099217385053635, -0.057663265615701675, -0.012975623831152916, 0.0006901546148583293, -0.004892959725111723, 0.03662849962711334, 0.027586480602622032, 0.03554206341505051, -0.04772482439875603, -0.015679093077778816, 0.012455218471586704, 0.023976987227797508, -0.03717254474759102, -0.031235435977578163, -0.05133330821990967, -0.054751116782426834, -0.047257836908102036, 0.031735990196466446, -0.008765791542828083, -0.04565951228141785, 0.05434846505522728, -0.024018777534365654, -0.023101896047592163, 0.06532997637987137, -0.05268910154700279, -0.012173625640571117, 0.07275307178497314, 0.022828416898846626, 0.007881457917392254, -0.04763467609882355, -0.02595505863428116, 0.01873510517179966, -0.053315311670303345, 0.03397567942738533, -0.07426505535840988, -0.0010015201987698674, 0.012793892994523048, 0.02698116935789585, -0.024816980585455894, -0.06557856500148773, -0.009922589175403118, -0.006339023821055889, 0.013479681685566902, -0.0197638887912035, 0.05473364517092705, -0.03962177783250809, -0.007559880148619413, 0.02238825336098671, -0.017391642555594444, 0.04208610951900482, 0.005407304503023624, -0.009302270598709583, -0.03396651893854141, -0.017986899241805077, -0.02624543197453022, -0.009864293038845062, 0.0218395683914423, -0.08839385956525803, -0.014879092574119568, -0.0011301639024168253, 0.015017162077128887 ]
<p>What is going on here <a href="http://youtu.be/LQFmKPA-iAg" rel="nofollow">http://youtu.be/LQFmKPA-iAg</a></p> <p>Is ethanol leaving the liquid? If so, why?</p> <p>Does the pressure add energy to the ethanol molecules causing them to gasify and move rapidly near border of gas/liquid and rapid depressurization allows it to escape the liquid and turn back liquid, this time as mist/vapor?</p> <p>Is the added pressure needed? Would same thing happen if we'd rapidly depressurize it regardless what is starting pressure?</p>
g7418
[ 0.028679151087999344, 0.01362085435539484, -0.021753458306193352, 0.03482535481452942, 0.04468889161944389, -0.03645465523004532, 0.02208671346306801, 0.06393856555223465, -0.08306608349084854, -0.011369187384843826, -0.0075413319282233715, -0.03753047436475754, 0.0018934397958219051, -0.02111181430518627, 0.03272082656621933, -0.004670016933232546, 0.07292855530977249, -0.0705350860953331, -0.002043897984549403, 0.009643199853599072, -0.04324943944811821, 0.01449847687035799, -0.010287991724908352, -0.13889722526073456, -0.04988357052206993, -0.07890412211418152, 0.012937573716044426, -0.03165673092007637, 0.010993624106049538, 0.001489313319325447, 0.0007748648640699685, 0.01119961403310299, 0.010943581350147724, -0.038984473794698715, -0.02045154757797718, -0.015412549488246441, 0.021362731233239174, 0.029089728370308876, -0.004420233424752951, -0.07472191005945206, -0.024491703137755394, -0.03890375792980194, 0.012350006960332394, -0.008588203229010105, -0.06873060017824173, 0.024817610159516335, -0.031590428203344345, -0.026861023157835007, -0.027076970785856247, 0.042130813002586365, 0.039511535316705704, 0.009511427022516727, -0.02648848667740822, 0.019762838259339333, -0.042681608349084854, 0.07774671912193298, -0.006536376196891069, 0.004324130713939667, 0.06367569416761398, 0.006009334698319435, -0.015516222454607487, -0.028562674298882484, 0.0316341333091259, 0.03197672963142395, -0.016071397811174393, -0.040087636560201645, -0.015622483566403389, 0.0248603243380785, 0.058256346732378006, 0.04179159551858902, 0.01599886640906334, -0.023850567638874054, -0.01942174881696701, 0.00918376911431551, -0.03740657493472099, 0.03385212644934654, 0.03719284012913704, -0.025567222386598587, 0.010051223449409008, -0.02316788025200367, -0.0018842275021597743, -0.030155573040246964, 0.009249342605471611, -0.03065146878361702, 0.009858330711722374, 0.015666361898183823, -0.036573827266693115, -0.013291843235492706, -0.030604157596826553, -0.01914568804204464, 0.03996775299310684, -0.03983866423368454, 0.055800728499889374, 0.00036167679354548454, -0.01980252005159855, 0.005215083248913288, 0.03191352263092995, 0.05165353789925575, 0.0022229687310755253, -0.0029193873051553965, 0.03990447521209717, -0.035910654813051224, 0.05063817277550697, 0.008695824071764946, -0.031853243708610535, -0.031230555847287178, -0.038623105734586716, -0.0021216333843767643, 0.012643970549106598, 0.01981610618531704, -0.0031485771760344505, 0.042125217616558075, -0.04763931781053543, 0.023127811029553413, -0.008666865527629852, 0.00034983851946890354, 0.014559007249772549, 0.03747566416859627, -0.005856493022292852, 0.005140478257089853, 0.018877048045396805, 0.04440873861312866, 0.007136556785553694, 0.016195783391594887, 0.014036032371222973, -0.03368280082941055, 0.06501917541027069, -0.009139105677604675, 0.014804106205701828, -0.01609492301940918, 0.03437584638595581, 0.05431143566966057, -0.04681936278939247, 0.025489503517746925, 0.12154717743396759, -0.01517433300614357, -0.006670457776635885, 0.035465825349092484, -0.014799755066633224, 0.04981645196676254, 0.05211707577109337, 0.0776844471693039, 0.01683569885790348, -0.016163205727934837, -0.06216254085302353, -0.0004004538059234619, 0.012440533377230167, 0.03572091832756996, 0.030574766919016838, -0.010369735769927502, -0.018303008750081062, 0.01964874565601349, 0.07063200324773788, -0.00040297629311680794, 0.019093003123998642, -0.00289008766412735, 0.03128748759627342, -0.0002602535823825747, 0.02608329989016056, 0.019809434190392494, 0.08002116531133652, -0.06369234621524811, 0.008960321545600891, 0.06688307225704193, -0.04236039146780968, 0.04531518369913101, 0.0012112513650208712, -0.01884452998638153, 0.008793951943516731, -0.027057988569140434, -0.08684821426868439, 0.005594713147729635, -0.02532598376274109, 0.020678391680121422, 0.05704207718372345, 0.005974303465336561, 0.06277672946453094, -0.027345329523086548, -0.003389956895262003, -0.051570914685726166, 0.02532246522605419, 0.0013244349975138903, 0.024110129103064537, -0.04455310478806496, 0.03730121627449989, -0.009960928931832314, -0.026805372908711433, 0.002282884204760194, -0.05622534081339836, 0.002212163992226124, 0.046288568526506424, -0.00014014508633408695, -0.011222075670957565, 0.013930953107774258, -0.052994098514318466, -0.01100930292159319, 0.020328572019934654, -0.05197791010141373, -0.07839184254407883, 0.00637033861130476, -0.056857816874980927, -0.002895912854000926, 0.00960518792271614, -0.002279092790558934, -0.014137704856693745, -0.007076662499457598, 0.043599579483270645, 0.04944619908928871, 0.032525110989809036, 0.017772207036614418, -0.040459517389535904, -0.010312343016266823, -0.011308947578072548, 0.009720548056066036, -0.024021651595830917, 0.03227120637893677, -0.004708095919340849, 0.0015120231546461582, 0.05981156602501869, 0.025723055005073547, -0.03402493894100189, 0.03358574956655502, -0.03726600110530853, -0.0013746335171163082, -0.08694853633642197, -0.03846077248454094, -0.02221859246492386, 0.015425696969032288, -0.04619985818862915, 0.012160299345850945, 0.03435049578547478, 0.009875286370515823, -0.016597842797636986, -0.010452625341713428, 0.04037218168377876, -0.0007378626032732427, -0.04857804253697395, 0.08682568371295929, -0.017329175025224686, -0.0052000731229782104, 0.00981519278138876, -0.09340272098779678, -0.053623098880052567, 0.03635070472955704, 0.02529987134039402, -0.010606309399008751, -0.0026032663881778717, -0.052210237830877304, 0.026567768305540085, 0.020475829020142555, 0.006727759260684252, -0.030586527660489082, -0.0017142659053206444, 0.015091978013515472, -0.020088914781808853, -0.03451938554644585, 0.006055961828678846, 0.021586211398243904, -0.007131196558475494, 0.010771595872938633, 0.02184443734586239, 0.0068048276007175446, -0.033053115010261536, -0.03616754710674286, -0.06029995158314705, 0.015699589625000954, -0.03932030498981476, 0.047211065888404846, 0.04176148772239685, -0.017241450026631355, 0.002456030109897256, 0.04006056487560272, 0.007802272215485573, -0.0005195395206101239, 0.03473946824669838, -0.03369152918457985, -0.01062509324401617, -0.00039662321796640754, 0.005002288613468409, -0.018378697335720062, -0.028874188661575317, -0.05155148729681969, -0.023030679672956467, -0.00553622841835022, 0.005483588203787804, -0.041630819439888, 0.015000431798398495, 0.03349285572767258, -0.059141576290130615, -0.04745245724916458, 0.019370215013623238, 0.005756793078035116, 0.037403419613838196, 0.04262126609683037, 0.027769358828663826, 0.026073889806866646, 0.0003634899330791086, 0.038413360714912415, -0.024529695510864258, -0.010455514304339886, -0.0027462863363325596, -0.07773852348327637, -0.053373079746961594, 0.03410109505057335, -0.018864892423152924, 0.07892048358917236, -0.05258636176586151, 0.02781529165804386, -0.03179921582341194, 0.019680391997098923, -0.004054058808833361, 0.016290107741951942, -0.05440011993050575, 0.055880893021821976, -0.03653080388903618, 0.022086607292294502, 0.000803111121058464, -0.008363073691725731, 0.005976732820272446, 0.01851814240217209, -0.05118940770626068, -0.051952850073575974, 0.016250208020210266, 0.00026137387612834573, 0.016494352370500565, 0.09222538024187088, -0.010066860355436802, -0.03069990873336792, -0.032932233065366745, -0.0164782851934433, 0.07099080085754395, -0.018772872164845467, -0.029935453087091446, -0.06371010839939117, -0.03029569424688816, -0.02778010442852974, -0.034604135900735855, 0.01659228652715683, 0.02001461759209633, 0.03625154495239258, 0.014185857027769089, 0.013473531231284142, -0.004023886751383543, -0.000060349644627422094, -0.03388025239109993, -0.03259401395916939, 0.041672028601169586, 0.014995438978075981, -0.014537736773490906, -0.00901299063116312, 0.03632749244570732, 0.0027238803450018167, -0.02097979001700878, 0.0012999089667573571, -0.025673046708106995, -0.0004884788650088012, 0.023566214367747307, -0.03206441551446915, 0.01674220897257328, -0.006856253370642662, -0.022068405523896217, -0.039632897824048996, 0.03828785941004753, 0.05981827899813652, -0.045195724815130234, -0.0019907858222723007, -0.013954207301139832, -0.0037710315082222223, -0.0823708176612854, 0.008507349528372288, 0.009400761686265469, 0.02800384722650051, -0.04942558333277702, 0.028524044901132584, 0.015740985050797462, -0.052189938724040985, 0.03676444664597511, 0.019810790196061134, -0.05102026090025902, 0.02070234902203083, 0.0473167784512043, 0.019261473789811134, 0.017866112291812897, 0.008555094711482525, 0.00020905263954773545, 0.0005289773107506335, -0.06002982705831528, 0.015925133600831032, 0.031089618802070618, -0.04028679430484772, -0.030066201463341713, -0.01654788851737976, -0.006563179660588503, 0.0063496846705675125, -0.040403492748737335, 0.05763822793960571, 0.05348775535821915, -0.01942051202058792, 0.007681115996092558, 0.011569352820515633, -0.013257576152682304, -0.009046263061463833, -0.05414697527885437, 0.01912013068795204, 0.017008254304528236, 0.00399138405919075, 0.020337123423814774, -0.014965949580073357, 0.020496223121881485, -0.004219742026180029, 0.02213616855442524, -0.031871747225522995, -0.04263873025774956, 0.029653601348400116, 0.013220131397247314, -0.018109651282429695, 0.026394153013825417, 0.028261229395866394, 0.05593607574701309, 0.019015774130821228, -0.040025494992733, 0.018250657245516777, 0.04470622166991234, 0.025717202574014664, -0.04689287766814232, 0.01877507194876671, 0.0652199238538742, -0.011012779548764229, 0.008473815396428108, -0.03254047781229019, -0.003922881092876196, -0.018273934721946716, 0.004050224553793669, -0.037062469869852066, 0.03177507221698761, 0.040665384382009506, 0.0012068740325048566, 0.0045000649988651276, 0.032676812261343, 0.06881693005561829, 0.04167404770851135, 0.03916383907198906, 0.010270140133798122, 0.03658076748251915, 0.0064455256797373295, 0.012970623560249805, 0.033145029097795486, -0.01772146113216877, 0.0169385876506567, -0.07462891191244125, -0.017420265823602676, 0.07244086265563965, 0.0038627830799669027, -0.006690357346087694, -0.03139275684952736, -0.014591801911592484, -0.026296088472008705, 0.08680621534585953, -0.03229309618473053, 0.06345045566558838, -0.06423698365688324, 0.0333523154258728, 0.0336868017911911, 0.06443806737661362, -0.008305251598358154, -0.011107678525149822, -0.03814462944865227, -0.04005157947540283, 0.024606788530945778, -0.011058102361857891, -0.030818898230791092, 0.0010599838569760323, 0.00835544615983963, 0.05314105749130249, 0.00998802948743105, -0.0024118975270539522, 0.03962497040629387, 0.027717553079128265, 0.08967042714357376, -0.04587071016430855, 0.04017738997936249, 0.07407289743423462, 0.0660497173666954, 0.027064120396971703, 0.06304923444986343, -0.017940664663910866, -0.03411277011036873, -0.017488254234194756, -0.006020757369697094, -0.02037896402180195, 0.014746417291462421, 0.06433498859405518, -0.042339082807302475, -0.049429550766944885, 0.004223870579153299, -0.005106993019580841, 0.03219650685787201, 0.016709867864847183, -0.013347169384360313, -0.0015545333735644817, -0.032195016741752625, -0.03316807374358177, -0.009210227057337761, -0.021240223199129105, 0.005632105283439159, 0.007465035654604435, 0.002562546404078603, 0.0016352384118363261, 0.01261765044182539, 0.0451359748840332, -0.033411502838134766, -0.041674885898828506, -0.003400108078494668, -0.02026226930320263, 0.058059271425008774, -0.0579582154750824, -0.010236410424113274, -0.051502775400877, 0.04261230677366257, -0.054438501596450806, 0.011299128644168377, -0.03235827013850212, 0.028428034856915474, 0.010207203216850758, -0.021143456920981407, 0.03181546553969383, -0.024678921326994896, -0.005712016485631466, -0.04462993144989014, 0.03284861147403717, -0.04604105278849602, -0.005341562908142805, 0.06135592237114906, 0.026786722242832184, -0.0379314050078392, -0.014349971897900105, -0.025230512022972107, 0.011257092468440533, 0.0881391167640686, 0.015440928749740124, 0.0035356171429157257, -0.061208147555589676, -0.06714306771755219, 0.09577875584363937, 0.038810741156339645, 0.05133027583360672, -0.00008424044062849134, 0.024274902418255806, -0.046258725225925446, -0.020403247326612473, -0.004150645341724157, 0.03427707403898239, -0.0006280071684159338, 0.007575409021228552, -0.050330013036727905, -0.014546114951372147, 0.041830699890851974, -0.02341574616730213, -0.0016461004270240664, -0.05084843188524246, -0.0231405608355999, 0.04790962487459183, 0.015050656162202358, 0.00705478060990572, 0.034625839442014694, -0.003978348802775145, -0.004307693801820278, -0.009680407121777534, -0.00010295508400304243, 0.00317663443274796, 0.05137310177087784, -0.018721899017691612, 0.035492248833179474, -0.016642142087221146, 0.036760393530130386, -0.0024785820860415697, 0.003364643780514598, 0.05062760412693024, -0.051539111882448196, -0.04125092178583145, -0.02742106467485428, 0.016821447759866714, 0.0390557162463665, -0.05782627314329147, 0.0460285060107708, -0.056652579456567764, -0.034258779138326645, 0.02987823076546192, 0.03992197662591934, 0.0018027023179456592, -0.012680266052484512, 0.003341580741107464, -0.004086064174771309, -0.06797414273023605, -0.020373698323965073, -0.06414715200662613, 0.005873350892215967, -0.01313349511474371, 0.01771761104464531, -0.021514827385544777, 0.0018399398541077971, 0.040491096675395966, -0.017484918236732483, -0.04888976365327835, -0.016252901405096054, -0.009135875850915909, 0.023185769096016884, 0.015614368952810764, -0.03174223750829697, 0.03364771977066994, -0.042674243450164795, -0.05459071323275566, 0.03720921650528908, -0.04451015219092369, -0.03093389980494976, -0.028610756620764732, -0.014996522106230259, 0.048549946397542953, 0.005925638601183891, -0.007741848006844521, -0.031187525019049644, -0.024309316650032997, 0.08575174957513809, -0.07314492762088776, 0.03458922356367111, 0.011153221130371094, -0.06906484812498093, 0.005367801524698734, 0.0014316567685455084, 0.04802781343460083, 0.04328504949808121, -0.05603431165218353, -0.06891340017318726, 0.01568240113556385, -0.04675300046801567, -0.010076419450342655, -0.06418450176715851, 0.030926629900932312, 0.05940963700413704, 0.014001122675836086, 0.0019622978288680315, -0.025010064244270325, -0.01373744010925293, 0.04066416993737221, 0.01691955327987671, 0.03183048218488693, -0.004636433906853199, -0.04898667335510254, -0.018268907442688942, -0.012012135237455368, -0.039310600608587265, -0.02606232464313507, -0.03126843646168709, 0.08622513711452484, -0.05357009172439575, 0.05477664992213249, -0.002441528020426631, 0.010950456373393536, -0.07466774433851242, -0.03121005930006504, -0.005807970184832811, -0.020490612834692, -0.03245944529771805, 0.023248739540576935, 0.0025327554903924465, 0.044533275067806244, 0.09891165792942047, -0.06344114989042282, 0.048272453248500824, -0.027799593284726143, 0.04492802545428276, -0.018522959202528, -0.04495622217655182, -0.03191844001412392, -0.03479389846324921, 0.03854452446103096, 0.037980884313583374, 0.0004991900641471148, 0.055630315095186234, -0.033529192209243774, 0.012298773974180222, -0.004901649430394173, 0.008666406385600567, -0.02895788475871086, -0.05609731748700142, 0.029860496520996094, 0.03269775211811066, 0.07260550558567047, -0.06566774100065231, 0.01183531153947115, 0.050921183079481125, 0.0404072105884552, 0.027559611946344376, 0.07234134525060654, -0.035823289304971695, -0.013241024687886238, 0.010642427019774914, -0.01465423870831728, 0.00126617809291929, 0.038284264504909515, -0.030574172735214233, -0.024781784042716026, 0.012836108915507793, -0.0414607897400856, -0.02630728855729103, 0.0036447534803301096, 0.05460534989833832, 0.005517508368939161, -0.01699158176779747, 0.02322850562632084, 0.008662351407110691, -0.03773248568177223, -0.04835154488682747, -0.03758269175887108, 0.01841113157570362, -0.02514849789440632, -0.022845348343253136, -0.023866955190896988, -0.02838294208049774, 0.021960915997624397, -0.01784580945968628, -0.017169475555419922, -0.036879751831293106, 0.030471304431557655, -0.012840588577091694, 0.07641302794218063, -0.0025030721444636583, -0.04316691681742668, -0.04249100014567375, -0.021986104547977448, -0.05795112997293472, 0.019559374079108238, 0.03853670135140419, -0.033674586564302444, -0.04461927339434624, -0.027114443480968475, 0.06775692105293274, -0.023810118436813354, 0.007509688381105661, 0.022610565647482872, -0.015325212851166725, -0.03028140775859356, 0.04899836704134941, -0.006141687743365765, 0.04267886281013489, -0.07960484176874161, -0.0227917842566967, 0.03304914012551308, 0.06676674634218216, -0.018196918070316315, 0.03855881839990616, -0.023735051974654198, 0.06156054139137268, 0.006347497925162315, -0.014885571785271168, -0.00679207406938076, -0.05838607996702194, 0.0773363932967186, 0.003996298648416996, -0.07148716598749161, -0.06756563484668732, 0.03828050568699837, 0.028176739811897278, -0.07602432370185852, 0.0294845849275589, 0.0009778094245120883, 0.008753428235650063, 0.033739034086465836 ]
<p>Consider a big commercial airliner, like a 727, 747, or a 787. </p> <p>At cruising altitude, under standard conditions, how much of the lift of the aircraft comes from the wings, and how much from the rest of the airframe -- the tube that holds all the people? </p> <p>My general impression from watching airplanes in flight is that the velocity vector of the centre of mass of the airplane tends <em>not</em> to be pointing in the same direction as the nose of the aircraft. They're usually a little off, moreso during take-off and landing but it seems like they're almost always a little off. </p> <p>When I look at a side-view of a 747, I see that the angle of attack of the airfoil doesn't quite match the line of the tube part of the hull. Moreover, the tube has a pretty large surface area relative to the wing area. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/gg06c.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>My suspicion is that there's maybe stability reasons why you'd want the tube to not be flat in steady-state flight. And perhaps that's part of the reason why the bottom of the tube is more flat towards the front Is something like this what's going on? </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/BOqVu.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
g7419
[ -0.026379941031336784, 0.023349618539214134, -0.014493231661617756, 0.031939320266246796, 0.020800763741135597, 0.022750068455934525, 0.06778120994567871, -0.0017702700570225716, -0.04943427816033363, -0.06313970685005188, 0.05739318206906319, 0.0037590644787997007, 0.022745909169316292, 0.04476562887430191, 0.045129429548978806, 0.0008774556335993111, -0.045457176864147186, -0.036843232810497284, 0.016941698268055916, 0.020859943702816963, 0.01082653272897005, -0.036268703639507294, 0.004506305791437626, -0.013909447006881237, -0.033495236188173294, -0.006623206194490194, -0.015299961902201176, -0.022271903231739998, -0.049461133778095245, 0.027507437393069267, -0.002324793254956603, 0.015224302187561989, 0.05673373490571976, -0.05219225957989693, -0.049606308341026306, -0.008460141718387604, 0.028409725055098534, 0.02981066145002842, 0.03173099085688591, -0.032707490026950836, -0.0020350858103483915, -0.04996958374977112, -0.04026790335774422, 0.03911798819899559, -0.020419437438249588, 0.00869233813136816, -0.05442626401782036, 0.009293501265347004, -0.04051240161061287, -0.006388456095010042, 0.026166358962655067, 0.08133354038000107, -0.025391025468707085, -0.050554532557725906, 0.012761889956891537, 0.03299740329384804, 0.01879693567752838, 0.0549805723130703, -0.040526870638132095, 0.006877024192363024, -0.04121612384915352, 0.018889760598540306, -0.04459257796406746, 0.09008488804101944, 0.009664053097367287, -0.04973810911178589, -0.0037783451844006777, -0.015291154384613037, -0.01798451878130436, 0.04317354038357735, -0.011324071325361729, -0.10053406655788422, -0.023648381233215332, -0.047481074929237366, -0.1260576844215393, -0.003975771367549896, -0.0511375367641449, -0.0034734755754470825, 0.0071519240736961365, -0.039041925221681595, 0.03470080345869064, 0.02357698231935501, 0.010116588324308395, 0.012730996124446392, 0.055245619267225266, -0.006046953145414591, 0.01629035919904709, -0.05516437813639641, 0.0015600267797708511, -0.010664045810699463, 0.043806273490190506, 0.018175117671489716, 0.07299315929412842, 0.04575596749782562, -0.01771768555045128, -0.06878872215747833, -0.005390404723584652, 0.05281270295381546, -0.061152275651693344, -0.022860178723931313, -0.031157542020082474, 0.024946754798293114, -0.012900497764348984, 0.05598693713545799, -0.03134634345769882, -0.060037169605493546, 0.06098195165395737, 0.06019037961959839, -0.007805271074175835, -0.05107562243938446, -0.03628576919436455, -0.016664136201143265, -0.0010470924898982048, 0.047201815992593765, -0.02078147977590561, -0.026792345568537712, 0.007497364655137062, -0.005940448958426714, -0.003000707132741809, 0.006507754325866699, 0.026469556614756584, -0.03865181282162666, 0.0014068507589399815, 0.031910981982946396, 0.04865126311779022, -0.010801578871905804, -0.04839923605322838, -0.020516229793429375, -0.01081752683967352, 0.049234647303819656, -0.0022875142749398947, -0.0033046361058950424, -0.05835602805018425, -0.027238687500357628, 0.023151107132434845, 0.031278785318136215, -0.06679167598485947, -0.015384330414235592, -0.0030632284469902515, 0.032313402742147446, 0.031920287758111954, 0.010074869729578495, 0.04409574344754219, 0.0020408874843269587, -0.040582623332738876, 0.01596197858452797, -0.041976314038038254, 0.06904071569442749, 0.05449189245700836, 0.037902284413576126, -0.07498802989721298, 0.05669626221060753, 0.016016537323594093, -0.013943455182015896, -0.03813527151942253, 0.01682203635573387, -0.003126126481220126, -0.034936800599098206, 0.013808712363243103, 0.039205148816108704, 0.0215422585606575, -0.04764270409941673, 0.04867982864379883, -0.018893200904130936, -0.07345901429653168, -0.0065972874872386456, 0.0006335890502668917, -0.03438528999686241, 0.029671547934412956, 0.02411637455224991, -0.025807367637753487, -0.027953028678894043, 0.01952417939901352, 0.05014118552207947, 0.024939019232988358, 0.009548086673021317, 0.06503915786743164, 0.028030406683683395, 0.10236351937055588, -0.022138096392154694, 0.017492810264229774, 0.042723674327135086, -0.036878328770399094, -0.07525309175252914, -0.003856207709759474, -0.036484673619270325, 0.02844225987792015, -0.009982394054532051, -0.04743089899420738, 0.011784540489315987, 0.03611169010400772, -0.015551564283668995, -0.030403796583414078, 0.06535036861896515, -0.054680075496435165, -0.04625951871275902, 0.035256002098321915, -0.03984052315354347, -0.03962085396051407, 0.03732164204120636, -0.025795118883252144, -0.07095275819301605, 0.06414744257926941, 0.03666398301720619, -0.033533975481987, -0.0067019155248999596, 0.001447119633667171, 0.006991298403590918, -0.0033522830344736576, -0.015794305130839348, 0.019215598702430725, 0.02352341078221798, 0.023484904319047928, 0.06575251370668411, 0.025664906948804855, 0.01026440504938364, 0.00332619808614254, 0.007575088180601597, 0.03276355564594269, 0.018117660656571388, 0.07735145837068558, -0.03220593184232712, 0.013386676087975502, 0.006206134799867868, 0.0011684771161526442, -0.06083088740706444, 0.0005778400227427483, -0.03984791412949562, -0.004498012829571962, 0.002845242153853178, -0.016350096091628075, 0.006990598514676094, 0.016706734895706177, 0.00011139192065456882, 0.024276670068502426, -0.055191438645124435, 0.08803842216730118, 0.02766602672636509, -0.008695430122315884, 0.013860807754099369, 0.016732780262827873, 0.01823088712990284, -0.042363960295915604, -0.024502785876393318, -0.027264337986707687, -0.010990881361067295, 0.029010748490691185, 0.023098912090063095, -0.03463031351566315, 0.006201145239174366, -0.02463327720761299, 0.013178834691643715, -0.029945969581604004, 0.025864804163575172, -0.015395479276776314, -0.050969477742910385, -0.08228755742311478, -0.007882785983383656, 0.0074166529811918736, -0.0020610063802450895, -0.06155632063746452, -0.05881524458527565, -0.005677595268934965, 0.03163939714431763, -0.03872006759047508, 0.061132315546274185, -0.00974892359226942, -0.009316882118582726, -0.00284207658842206, 0.04803365096449852, -0.03317584469914436, 0.09083579480648041, 0.005234761629253626, 0.04761167988181114, 0.012006033211946487, -0.019589468836784363, -0.02532503940165043, 0.00245596282184124, -0.09312240034341812, 0.0343407467007637, 0.004509869497269392, 0.05092567205429077, -0.04878900572657585, 0.029474472627043724, 0.01193922944366932, 0.0342535525560379, -0.02817162685096264, 0.0066187744960188866, -0.006835469510406256, 0.01771528087556362, -0.009104243479669094, 0.0009109380771405995, 0.021579841151833534, -0.046038441359996796, 0.0767364576458931, -0.037238094955682755, 0.06763904541730881, -0.0010408073430880904, -0.04649313911795616, -0.011176656000316143, -0.0418359711766243, 0.03151938319206238, 0.01731984317302704, -0.011022323742508888, -0.008306358009576797, 0.035815607756376266, -0.03401824086904526, -0.0716676414012909, -0.004268314689397812, -0.0025395199190825224, 0.003690707264468074, 0.012338134460151196, -0.024220336228609085, 0.00763404555618763, 0.004265720956027508, -0.014044292271137238, -0.04982047528028488, -0.010134966112673283, -0.027629056945443153, 0.01940050907433033, -0.0446586087346077, -0.017148690298199654, -0.01603361964225769, 0.030020399019122124, 0.006937850266695023, 0.006407931447029114, 0.03445902094244957, 0.03890082612633705, -0.022654082626104355, 0.00459976214915514, 0.07087518274784088, -0.011393924243748188, -0.029424509033560753, 0.03926396369934082, 0.015682043507695198, 0.031223921105265617, 0.06140811741352081, 0.04106352478265762, 0.05199706554412842, -0.00225899089127779, -0.0070562646724283695, 0.016192669048905373, 0.02851511724293232, -0.03531240299344063, 0.03919476643204689, -0.016135629266500473, -0.03338158130645752, -0.006115463562309742, 0.05549043044447899, -0.019826464354991913, 0.06149682775139809, -0.036095019429922104, -0.01703297533094883, -0.02888614498078823, -0.0033082808367908, 0.009616282768547535, -0.013872921466827393, 0.023043615743517876, -0.025331737473607063, 0.07979662716388702, 0.01698223687708378, 0.004644820000976324, -0.03710484504699707, 0.014758679084479809, -0.05022474005818367, -0.08538331091403961, -0.06069805473089218, 0.07880470901727676, -0.010768339969217777, -0.025625094771385193, -0.026673628017306328, -0.024785256013274193, -0.055254656821489334, 0.015771325677633286, -0.035332757979631424, -0.022744499146938324, 0.012625430710613728, 0.015641946345567703, 0.03855385631322861, 0.014084153808653355, 0.059156037867069244, 0.00937946792691946, -0.029811156913638115, 0.0005654295673593879, -0.02884679101407528, 0.0429125651717186, -0.04970204830169678, -0.00843743421137333, 0.030648507177829742, -0.00382670434191823, -0.031257763504981995, -0.04753706976771355, 0.014150675386190414, -0.008578247390687466, 0.00518636591732502, -0.005726280622184277, -0.008137613534927368, 0.009337428025901318, -0.039854295551776886, 0.056465864181518555, 0.040321167558431625, 0.025911735370755196, -0.024243218824267387, -0.022105153650045395, -0.015830179676413536, 0.0542728491127491, -0.021506529301404953, 0.026453763246536255, -0.02920280024409294, -0.022490959614515305, 0.05623553693294525, 0.008955834433436394, 0.0016542535740882158, -0.10197515785694122, 0.020013200119137764, 0.047044143080711365, -0.02703094109892845, 0.0400787778198719, 0.06711972504854202, 0.007995537482202053, 0.028788620606064796, 0.052608851343393326, 0.04944068193435669, -0.02775276079773903, 0.034932851791381836, 0.04386923834681511, -0.0053208391182124615, -0.03667300567030907, -0.025172850117087364, -0.011379732750356197, 0.035962216556072235, 0.0009020320139825344, 0.0254813339561224, 0.03646480664610863, -0.03565317764878273, 0.0425441637635231, 0.02105705253779888, 0.0235632061958313, 0.0001740495499689132, -0.014489256776869297, 0.03418393060564995, 0.0279349684715271, -0.06754371523857117, -0.043816737830638885, -0.0262411180883646, -0.0010956482728943229, 0.0039023817516863346, -0.0075195832177996635, 0.004310240503400564, 0.049083054065704346, -0.04745514690876007, -0.015648722648620605, 0.004539962857961655, -0.0067572807893157005, -0.013139263726770878, -0.0386999137699604, 0.023710336536169052, -0.03237128257751465, 0.020479559898376465, -0.007359815761446953, -0.024024350568652153, -0.04357661306858063, -0.04802091792225838, -0.007565387990325689, -0.004280967637896538, -0.013479629531502724, 0.0034779736306518316, -0.03387850522994995, -0.021006092429161072, -0.03419289365410805, -0.035069819539785385, 0.03222079575061798, 0.02521456964313984, 0.050816573202610016, -0.008323206566274166, 0.040302202105522156, -0.012601619586348534, -0.017758198082447052, -0.04002580791711807, -0.01716560684144497, 0.006115871015936136, -0.01465977355837822, 0.05409758910536766, 0.017406191676855087, 0.015105478465557098, -0.02264421433210373, -0.002047992777079344, 0.007743010763078928, 0.035816241055727005, -0.003432529279962182, 0.05023114010691643, 0.005591732449829578, -0.050728946924209595, -0.03553423285484314, -0.04194362834095955, -0.013320235535502434, 0.019546693190932274, -0.03675909340381622, 0.03907311335206032, 0.02569788135588169, -0.05772750452160835, 0.0636526569724083, 0.04904695972800255, -0.01588454842567444, -0.02409842237830162, 0.038589004427194595, 0.05018084868788719, -0.07651418447494507, -0.06126720458269119, 0.050768330693244934, -0.0571536086499691, 0.02044336125254631, 0.005975593812763691, -0.0393172912299633, -0.017690882086753845, -0.03485887125134468, -0.022039184346795082, 0.0365896001458168, 0.015976255759596825, 0.052765559405088425, 0.025466686114668846, -0.024601837620139122, -0.018784020096063614, -0.016411885619163513, -0.0573403462767601, 0.03211577236652374, -0.0064887311309576035, -0.04002714902162552, 0.008802127093076706, -0.030526958405971527, -0.041931018233299255, 0.00565734738484025, 0.07594647258520126, 0.012458579614758492, -0.044243425130844116, -0.010038251988589764, 0.014275780878961086, 0.023948784917593002, 0.039907582104206085, -0.061320941895246506, -0.002324111992493272, 0.03968168422579765, -0.047432687133550644, 0.14682523906230927, 0.020127911120653152, -0.0163271501660347, -0.013004577718675137, 0.00042616904829628766, 0.028730478137731552, 0.017644569277763367, -0.018218552693724632, 0.07325482368469238, -0.07685200124979019, 0.004572056699544191, -0.04208273068070412, 0.00034303413121961057, -0.004345398396253586, 0.007098267320543528, -0.009260403923690319, -0.05344830080866814, 0.057795483618974686, -0.010629956610500813, 0.08416890352964401, 0.0015064942417666316, 0.02104833722114563, 0.03584173321723938, -0.07922212779521942, 0.022065654397010803, 0.028821730986237526, -0.02021954022347927, 0.004742602352052927, -0.047064561396837234, -0.030566874891519547, -0.0380595400929451, 0.0026875745970755816, 0.015743283554911613, -0.07864758372306824, 0.016235485672950745, -0.02358159050345421, 0.04994397610425949, -0.007707181852310896, -0.03229769319295883, -0.002609154675155878, -0.04593721777200699, -0.03061981312930584, 0.010824835859239101, -0.008386054076254368, -0.028967343270778656, 0.021207483485341072, 0.04541271552443504, -0.052279192954301834, 0.035668257623910904, 0.016739532351493835, 0.027205266058444977, -0.0239105224609375, -0.0622762069106102, -0.007784857414662838, 0.01660657301545143, -0.02922610007226467, 0.015046724118292332, 0.01330971997231245, 0.08295804262161255, 0.046191681176424026, -0.014601304195821285, 0.04387747496366501, 0.036047160625457764, 0.08525563776493073, 0.05729446932673454, -0.02399393543601036, -0.014938198029994965, 0.053312793374061584, 0.042621910572052, 0.06860430538654327, -0.00612016674131155, -0.004040115512907505, -0.0687221810221672, 0.008714417926967144, -0.03137920796871185, 0.021220874041318893, -0.008439192548394203, 0.006368849892169237, -0.0018689525313675404, -0.04400017112493515, 0.009828264825046062, 0.05206385999917984, 0.013278593309223652, -0.0734410211443901, -0.015179220587015152, -0.0018549333326518536, -0.03480640798807144, 0.032043274492025375, -0.01957842707633972, -0.03387036919593811, 0.01785421371459961, -0.017969850450754166, 0.017512133345007896, -0.024454668164253235, 0.03468248248100281, 0.02982170879840851, 0.0018511887174099684, -0.004327652044594288, 0.06153960898518562, 0.009825972840189934, -0.017748994752764702, -0.06658975034952164, 0.0015370235778391361, 0.004233131185173988, 0.05374433472752571, 0.03333354741334915, -0.03964504972100258, -0.029136067256331444, -0.06033802404999733, -0.00972331315279007, -0.0013240977423265576, -0.03344636410474777, -0.007172551937401295, -0.011700383387506008, -0.027348177507519722, 0.0844738557934761, -0.06487210839986801, 0.022562973201274872, -0.0013482834910973907, -0.024676021188497543, 0.028792422264814377, -0.01579109951853752, 0.0315096415579319, 0.020445091649889946, -0.032798126339912415, -0.016371307894587517, -0.00975299347192049, 0.006550888996571302, -0.004933780990540981, 0.00014952973288018256, 0.02072497271001339, 0.02160440757870674, -0.009257704950869083, -0.04689107835292816, -0.04613910987973213, 0.0006212079897522926, 0.030310336500406265, 0.05589308589696884, 0.02677430398762226, 0.03354359790682793, 0.049739327281713486, -0.012635487131774426, -0.02968536876142025, -0.011868946254253387, -0.032410699874162674, 0.005961890332400799, -0.055979110300540924, -0.02342727780342102, 0.015006136149168015, -0.0005078976973891258, 0.025284694507718086, -0.047793325036764145, 0.0138320317491889, 0.017017345875501633, 0.0398070365190506, -0.010334767401218414, 0.030493929982185364, 0.04595770686864853, 0.0007407665252685547, 0.03268393501639366, -0.006307621952146292, 0.06739822775125504, -0.02269265241920948, 0.020438091829419136, -0.006896575912833214, 0.0075962538830935955, 0.03621065989136696, 0.01900387741625309, -0.04432569071650505, 0.02616763859987259, 0.04084964096546173, -0.044413432478904724, -0.027504924684762955, 0.008949373848736286, -0.042054109275341034, -0.031653642654418945, 0.03836238384246826, -0.051204901188611984, -0.048072364181280136, 0.024328086525201797, -0.0016890218248590827, 0.02837502770125866, -0.019386643543839455, -0.010257495567202568, 0.026690684258937836, -0.0005098035908304155, 0.003451324300840497, -0.025909336283802986, 0.028767233714461327, -0.014572934247553349, 0.049042943865060806, 0.030669357627630234, -0.028281444683670998, 0.04009256139397621, 0.009055345319211483, 0.002702338621020317, -0.05667075887322426, 0.021042590960860252, 0.027455845847725868, 0.0009385373559780419, -0.03410311043262482, -0.003691008547320962, 0.03973362594842911, 0.037799153476953506, 0.03600363805890083, 0.018574506044387817, -0.035586167126894, 0.06523271650075912, 0.018619531765580177, 0.011529654264450073, -0.002167630009353161, 0.0060104066506028175, 0.007848980836570263, 0.02040102705359459, -0.05618443340063095, -0.04121021553874016, -0.05120914801955223, 0.009876499883830547, -0.016101300716400146, 0.03418496623635292, -0.06281694024801254, -0.04936440661549568, -0.013701085932552814, -0.08183274418115616, 0.0027763857506215572 ]
<p>One way how to look at refraction by a dielectric medium like water or glass is that (phase) velocity of light decreases because it is the wavelength rather than the frequency of the light which changes.</p> <p>I have read somewhere (but can't recall where) that the frequency must remain the same because otherwise principle of causality would be broken. Is that true?</p>
g7420
[ 0.07093241065740585, 0.016507260501384735, 0.018007174134254456, -0.015620434656739235, 0.00994042120873928, -0.043576646596193314, 0.04852759465575218, 0.00026777153834700584, -0.011238567531108856, -0.041281335055828094, 0.0561850480735302, 0.009490189142525196, 0.007837316021323204, 0.02603415958583355, -0.02721976488828659, 0.01364383939653635, 0.00917594414204359, -0.0075158835388720036, 0.011793010868132114, 0.055034931749105453, -0.02181132137775421, 0.00984006468206644, -0.036353375762701035, -0.04736511781811714, -0.03864531219005585, -0.002364527899771929, 0.0396881178021431, -0.047976721078157425, -0.007426102180033922, -0.01809004135429859, 0.08796817064285278, -0.03339492529630661, 0.04981255903840065, -0.06711454689502716, 0.03022816590964794, -0.041089143604040146, 0.04378325119614601, 0.019697565585374832, 0.011823220178484917, 0.02455570548772812, 0.045705340802669525, 0.05977930128574371, -0.021018562838435173, 0.00007185425783973187, 0.0309006180614233, -0.027223758399486542, -0.03746912628412247, -0.01744670793414116, -0.022024456411600113, -0.021558502689003944, -0.02767711505293846, 0.025850102305412292, 0.0028460805770009756, 0.022425929084420204, 0.00004258063927409239, 0.008071199990808964, -0.05129389837384224, 0.028314538300037384, 0.039993178099393845, -0.002220789436250925, -0.006184534635394812, 0.023650189861655235, -0.0141376918181777, 0.020418744534254074, 0.030615735799074173, -0.08356044441461563, -0.06137857958674431, -0.018567241728305817, 0.04646291956305504, -0.022166384384036064, -0.04476693645119667, -0.02849983423948288, -0.07256144285202026, -0.024352390319108963, -0.020226342603564262, -0.016630439087748528, -0.009085913188755512, 0.006478543393313885, -0.03226446732878685, -0.009236405603587627, -0.0038096255157142878, -0.013880913145840168, 0.0016543928068131208, 0.038758426904678345, 0.0036592399701476097, -0.029728742316365242, 0.02327214740216732, 0.017714601010084152, -0.00018881203141063452, -0.0025361948646605015, 0.02487063966691494, -0.01825024001300335, 0.07636259496212006, 0.04900135099887848, 0.04438886418938637, -0.04192948713898659, -0.019688304513692856, 0.06012297421693802, 0.043895166367292404, -0.017451172694563866, -0.04721385985612869, 0.02379416488111019, 0.04414599388837814, 0.03880546614527702, -0.024110695347189903, 0.020915266126394272, 0.04667974263429642, 0.023206956684589386, -0.03738196939229965, -0.00044054907630197704, 0.023501140996813774, -0.06840642541646957, -0.05614517629146576, -0.0063598668202757835, -0.008729410357773304, -0.030614428222179413, 0.0388399101793766, -0.013991382904350758, 0.0484817810356617, 0.04464329406619072, 0.0192278865724802, -0.010719440877437592, 0.039697252213954926, 0.08704059571027756, -0.02969423681497574, 0.03123163804411888, 0.00666532339528203, 0.03346475958824158, 0.04007790610194206, 0.019815536215901375, -0.009302627295255661, -0.008343305438756943, -0.02929028682410717, 0.015194719657301903, -0.0107417032122612, 0.03963726386427879, 0.07139777392148972, -0.025080598890781403, 0.006595319136977196, 0.029307035729289055, 0.030986374244093895, 0.017457572743296623, 0.032918818295001984, 0.008782045915722847, -0.040081776678562164, 0.00604240270331502, 0.0239926278591156, 0.008744494989514351, 0.061498552560806274, -0.02166951820254326, -0.02534578926861286, 0.07166671007871628, 0.021960528567433357, -0.0009387696627527475, 0.006049626506865025, -0.019563741981983185, 0.04501429572701454, -0.0031327642500400543, -0.004333747550845146, -0.012904912233352661, 0.02189982682466507, -0.024184608832001686, 0.007623732555657625, 0.05106240138411522, -0.04542609676718712, -0.005908224266022444, -0.028247132897377014, 0.01658179797232151, -0.010400928556919098, -0.08047953993082047, -0.053443655371665955, 0.019609227776527405, -0.054175712168216705, 0.09617670625448227, 0.007944787852466106, 0.05385100096464157, 0.005977201741188765, -0.00947609357535839, -0.049824606627225876, 0.004896683152765036, -0.06062870845198631, -0.01976076327264309, -0.022332871332764626, -0.10143683850765228, 0.03490303084254265, 0.02683446928858757, 0.03319390490651131, 0.010287581011652946, -0.051625896245241165, 0.0037171230651438236, -0.034544438123703, -0.03062427043914795, -0.04140337556600571, 0.03895415738224983, 0.0022498113103210926, -0.005841260775923729, -0.005071923136711121, 0.023862233385443687, -0.019254619255661964, 0.047147344797849655, -0.004097319208085537, 0.04863747954368591, 0.020778577774763107, 0.017526987940073013, -0.02146337367594242, -0.00666405912488699, -0.05723472684621811, 0.011901160702109337, -0.028293287381529808, 0.02273128181695938, 0.008772684261202812, 0.0380440317094326, -0.007011135574430227, -0.03370216116309166, -0.036696676164865494, 0.032857440412044525, 0.004518897272646427, -0.0007260690908879042, 0.0013915160670876503, 0.048676151782274246, -0.046231985092163086, 0.05409809201955795, -0.012358441017568111, 0.012275616638362408, -0.04591119661927223, -0.06919687241315842, -0.02770446240901947, 0.002441499847918749, 0.024067990481853485, -0.01663079857826233, -0.006874122656881809, -0.025785647332668304, -0.06896072626113892, 0.014649088494479656, 0.020527007058262825, 0.04871649667620659, -0.058377865701913834, -0.041120726615190506, 0.0412595197558403, 0.0177488774061203, 0.013778576627373695, -0.015145649202167988, -0.03921942040324211, 0.019283609464764595, -0.04901426285505295, -0.023925775662064552, 0.0045294566079974174, -0.0664772316813469, 0.0343133807182312, 0.05777060240507126, 0.02521626651287079, -0.008351468481123447, 0.003360809525474906, 0.015026073902845383, -0.02668977528810501, 0.031013235449790955, -0.03990612179040909, 0.0924125462770462, -0.057549674063920975, -0.036101844161748886, -0.006865473929792643, 0.011341429315507412, 0.023503532633185387, -0.02879149466753006, 0.00114294677041471, 0.0008671439718455076, 0.023041892796754837, 0.1244911178946495, -0.024175874888896942, 0.03618782386183739, 0.012069669552147388, 0.0389430895447731, 0.046875663101673126, 0.005148181691765785, 0.008991245180368423, 0.03713717311620712, 0.0181982833892107, -0.07841654866933823, 0.053087033331394196, 0.020578449591994286, -0.035941801965236664, -0.029063599184155464, -0.10621963441371918, -0.014694863930344582, 0.014285414479672909, -0.056436166167259216, 0.04557455703616142, 0.031754020601511, -0.057096417993307114, 0.015735875815153122, -0.02339475229382515, 0.05771425738930702, 0.021952878683805466, -0.014906780794262886, 0.012448268011212349, 0.034736182540655136, 0.077390156686306, -0.025585399940609932, -0.03577539324760437, 0.039617639034986496, -0.004729749169200659, -0.00034013157710433006, 0.009888431057333946, 0.018262548372149467, 0.04689602181315422, 0.06389729678630829, -0.07519802451133728, -0.027369249612092972, 0.07687592506408691, -0.008253565058112144, 0.005629231687635183, 0.052290286868810654, -0.00585206551477313, 0.039396192878484726, -0.03865864500403404, 0.06037856638431549, 0.0035214645322412252, 0.04184051230549812, -0.001075547537766397, 0.025090409442782402, -0.026550792157649994, -0.010344043374061584, -0.010421146638691425, -0.004618053790181875, 0.00608244352042675, -0.031142452731728554, 0.005750193260610104, 0.04005889967083931, -0.05685766413807869, 0.037990812212228775, 0.002939992817118764, -0.02396501414477825, -0.04410649091005325, -0.040794532746076584, -0.012878361158072948, 0.008138773031532764, -0.006131609436124563, -0.008139596320688725, 0.07195911556482315, 0.047681212425231934, 0.034575726836919785, 0.009684034623205662, -0.016902418807148933, 0.0013489549746736884, 0.0015313135227188468, 0.01327262632548809, 0.006932484917342663, -0.005560608580708504, 0.01620609685778618, 0.028264837339520454, 0.05806548520922661, -0.019073765724897385, 0.013202664442360401, -0.04937346279621124, -0.07553635537624359, 0.013843432068824768, 0.004855055827647448, 0.05463601276278496, 0.06780563294887543, -0.048258714377880096, 0.026345638558268547, -0.0687900260090828, 0.00589807378128171, -0.022840231657028198, -0.05114300921559334, -0.0007323925965465605, 0.029028261080384254, 0.10068127512931824, -0.048516057431697845, 0.006142979953438044, -0.026211004704236984, -0.04148977994918823, -0.03184729814529419, 0.03900742158293724, -0.0019168828148394823, 0.025203222408890724, -0.008230015635490417, -0.006982037331908941, -0.025546597316861153, 0.05921449884772301, 0.0355408750474453, 0.0067083272151649, 0.04223586991429329, 0.0022889450192451477, -0.006265019997954369, -0.02478913590312004, -0.006266097072511911, -0.019164199009537697, -0.012115558609366417, -0.04088059812784195, 0.003288251580670476, -0.004169754683971405, 0.017785826697945595, 0.006497730500996113, 0.003913882188498974, 0.005372186191380024, -0.01354236714541912, 0.014261938631534576, 0.019033614546060562, 0.01080259494483471, -0.02736346796154976, -0.016470616683363914, -0.020860670134425163, 0.027545887976884842, -0.002167083788663149, 0.022012853994965553, 0.04602231830358505, -0.00777820311486721, -0.014139344915747643, -0.021244019269943237, -0.013113490305840969, -0.019125299528241158, -0.07360847294330597, -0.10168290883302689, 0.028949474915862083, 0.03185862675309181, 0.06258930265903473, -0.021604662761092186, 0.07672905176877975, 0.01699058525264263, 0.008064420893788338, 0.018356431275606155, -0.035467278212308884, -0.046297017484903336, 0.014111201278865337, 0.06063452735543251, 0.043436478823423386, -0.033758483827114105, -0.042438119649887085, -0.06329487264156342, -0.0358370803296566, 0.0031409712973982096, -0.060613907873630524, -0.007644099649041891, 0.018990298733115196, -0.021893402561545372, 0.011098372749984264, 0.0030883285216987133, 0.0006835804088041186, 0.03963770717382431, 0.04027857258915901, -0.006531680002808571, 0.03494827076792717, -0.04412940517067909, -0.013645350001752377, 0.09971239417791367, -0.011847814545035362, -0.022562537342309952, -0.0378449521958828, -0.03953751549124718, -0.051063016057014465, 0.04145940765738487, -0.01202950719743967, 0.015813851729035378, -0.06206939369440079, -0.019176557660102844, -0.07774751633405685, 0.03213948383927345, -0.018498988822102547, 0.002117522293701768, -0.04393622651696205, 0.020078303292393684, 0.016838712617754936, 0.0021427988540381193, -0.02496519312262535, 0.015838177874684334, 0.02523122727870941, -0.05853187292814255, -0.042764827609062195, 0.010216220282018185, -0.04810630530118942, -0.016263365745544434, 0.017990771681070328, 0.015204708091914654, 0.07909585535526276, -0.028518596664071083, -0.0463474802672863, -0.014852534048259258, -0.008731941692531109, -0.020521769300103188, -0.004490010440349579, -0.02137477695941925, 0.07833027839660645, -0.008103489875793457, -0.014019658789038658, -0.008267492987215519, -0.04046286642551422, 0.06416278332471848, -0.00398217560723424, -0.041350629180669785, 0.004888433963060379, -0.0471983328461647, 0.019695943221449852, 0.013591677881777287, -0.04966111481189728, 0.0053408220410346985, 0.048849791288375854, -0.011809287592768669, -0.024319609627127647, 0.01713748648762703, -0.07163503766059875, -0.02736263908445835, 0.029904570430517197, -0.01898801326751709, -0.00019087031250819564, 0.015932967886328697, 0.050740811973810196, 0.024129141122102737, -0.02485995553433895, 0.03141668066382408, 0.016365090385079384, -0.014471928589046001, 0.007468215189874172, 0.02683250606060028, 0.06599614769220352, -0.04687409847974777, -0.0588531419634819, 0.013567633926868439, -0.005157776176929474, -0.022553998976945877, 0.00803801603615284, -0.015985028818249702, -0.011265055276453495, -0.028219521045684814, -0.03831645846366882, 0.006385489832609892, -0.027856597676873207, -0.04613951966166496, 0.016686515882611275, -0.03738373890519142, 0.00807210709899664, 0.039097633212804794, 0.009070056490600109, -0.027758799493312836, -0.02276911400258541, -0.02386173978447914, 0.0049255709163844585, -0.020263250917196274, -0.01956423744559288, 0.04110933095216751, -0.08217547088861465, 0.039100244641304016, 0.04550962895154953, 0.05618029460310936, -0.029529638588428497, 0.01602325029671192, -0.022293321788311005, 0.004029497969895601, 0.03511346876621246, 0.007897311821579933, -0.035720933228731155, -0.009252266958355904, 0.014909463003277779, 0.01879243738949299, -0.012984780594706535, 0.013418047688901424, -0.013985932804644108, 0.006025916431099176, -0.02611929550766945, -0.03791596740484238, 0.07631333917379379, -0.001807183725759387, 0.003907348494976759, -0.004967203829437494, 0.06115764006972313, -0.1045108512043953, -0.0011833349708467722, 0.019934771582484245, 0.042975883930921555, 0.027974307537078857, -0.04459582641720772, 0.010264293290674686, -0.08865263313055038, -0.0185310747474432, -0.04232551530003548, 0.016041742637753487, -0.024438878521323204, -0.024027029052376747, 0.00455083092674613, -0.007729817647486925, 0.016152488067746162, -0.011315003037452698, 0.005355257075279951, -0.0053994320333004, -0.05704755336046219, -0.017891712486743927, -0.012295642867684364, 0.02478131465613842, 0.06488977372646332, -0.010816101916134357, 0.010732351802289486, -0.008466771803796291, -0.04154409095644951, 0.0013652920024469495, -0.023327546194195747, -0.04908769950270653, 0.031033508479595184, 0.015999337658286095, -0.03217293694615364, 0.019453812390565872, 0.03848762437701225, -0.014758525416254997, 0.05463067814707756, -0.07157422602176666, -0.01697516441345215, 0.009556839242577553, 0.021530257537961006, -0.034635208547115326, 0.08038102835416794, -0.019601350650191307, -0.016797026619315147, 0.007706200238317251, 0.04080875217914581, -0.0016059618210420012, -0.057350706309080124, -0.0781259834766388, -0.050525128841400146, 0.03343754634261131, -0.007896853610873222, -0.015012766234576702, 0.054574575275182724, -0.05617208778858185, 0.01917063631117344, -0.008432207629084587, 0.02013247273862362, 0.07751809805631638, -0.029990078881382942, 0.004345403052866459, 0.019222809001803398, 0.013929462991654873, 0.031155984848737717, 0.0048733423464000225, -0.045385152101516724, -0.011018314398825169, 0.014920735731720924, -0.0019523885566741228, -0.05399177968502045, -0.009879755787551403, 0.01769852824509144, -0.0007496224134229124, 0.06551402062177658, 0.03127327933907509, 0.016104010865092278, 0.05593077093362808, -0.0316595695912838, 0.03489881008863449, 0.0713135227560997, -0.06747327744960785, -0.022690700367093086, -0.014569852501153946, 0.025299372151494026, -0.05404769629240036, -0.01859554834663868, 0.061677854508161545, -0.009800076484680176, 0.04574793204665184, -0.011945600621402264, 0.04765938222408295, 0.03519969433546066, -0.047361455857753754, -0.050101157277822495, -0.006827084347605705, 0.022697564214468002, 0.004759202711284161, -0.02844373881816864, 0.03965909779071808, 0.02437692880630493, -0.050967972725629807, 0.0288696251809597, -0.002427296247333288, 0.032865747809410095, -0.012679275125265121, 0.014432672411203384, -0.014402562752366066, 0.007475817110389471, 0.013639002107083797, -0.0002528913610149175, 0.012956888414919376, 0.04418055713176727, 0.004496579058468342, 0.03726806491613388, 0.05539095029234886, 0.04452782869338989, -0.05153394863009453, 0.021739792078733444, 0.044152870774269104, -0.08590434491634369, 0.00256179622374475, 0.056749626994132996, -0.039299264550209045, -0.015063071623444557, -0.04262886196374893, 0.04246556758880615, 0.01182110421359539, 0.021197794005274773, -0.0714477151632309, 0.08860428631305695, 0.009986333549022675, -0.016179528087377548, -0.06709332764148712, -0.06279464066028595, -0.06718749552965164, -0.030907215550541878, 0.003455482190474868, -0.019007349386811256, 0.0008444220875389874, -0.06537045538425446, -0.04348549246788025, -0.01958998665213585, -0.041740793734788895, 0.015520335175096989, 0.0006996719748713076, 0.010877199470996857, 0.006891203578561544, -0.01239706575870514, -0.026043787598609924, -0.014231445267796516, -0.01226560678333044, -0.0017961121629923582, -0.007372323423624039, -0.00291040469892323, -0.0715436190366745, 0.032462604343891144, -0.06904719769954681, -0.028689349070191383, 0.0005364265525713563, 0.05536634474992752, -0.04862843453884125, -0.03100169077515602, 0.03903818875551224, -0.007766196969896555, 0.033498022705316544, -0.026488952338695526, -0.037644241005182266, 0.04146871715784073, 0.03563818708062172, 0.005547394510358572, 0.024999909102916718, -0.02638293243944645, 0.02900640293955803, 0.01905612088739872, 0.052955906838178635, -0.021149389445781708, 0.013517476618289948, -0.025562593713402748, 0.0034250037278980017, 0.027206098660826683, 0.036388032138347626, 0.06129584461450577, -0.05026022717356682, -0.034736186265945435, 0.007552635855972767, -0.024460040032863617, 0.0134687265381217, 0.02239091508090496, -0.08135763555765152, 0.00016290594066958874, -0.00039328314596787095, 0.03227142244577408, -0.06270090490579605, 0.024567099288105965, -0.005654799751937389, 0.010150051675736904, -0.0064333234913647175, -0.05039709806442261, 0.00017858030332718045, 0.023354802280664444, 0.032940980046987534 ]
<p>So I have faced a problem dealing with transient conduction and I need a little help with the problem solving concepts. I need to determine how long it would take to reach the final temperature but I need to know the convection coefficient for that.</p> <p>I have done steady state and calculation of Reynolds'/Nusselt's Numbers and everything but that was when the film temperature, $\frac{T_{s}+T_{\infty}}{2}$ was constant throughout the process. In a transient problem, the surface temperature is constantly changing, causing the film temperature to constantly change and also the Reynolds'/Nusselt numbers to both constantly change with time because the film properties are changing. </p> <p>How can I combat all of these changes? I could either:</p> <ol> <li><p>Calculate the convection coefficient using either the initial temperature or the final temperature when calculating the film temperature</p></li> <li><p>Average the two temperatures in the beginning and then calculate the convection coefficient for that averaged temperature</p></li> <li><p>Calculate the convection coefficients at the initial and final temperatures and then just average those numbers</p></li> <li><p>Make a spreadsheet of the properties in the back of the book and then somehow write code on MATLAB that would continuously calculate the coefficient between different boundaries and then just add up the heat transfer, I would have to do that on MATLAB and it would take a long time to do.</p></li> </ol> <p>I am very open to any suggestions. I am having a lot of trouble on this because we did not do this in my class and my professor did not really give me an answer when I talked to him</p>
g7421
[ 0.02696850895881653, -0.045670285820961, 0.02547273598611355, 0.012903263792395592, 0.025469813495874405, -0.05332079902291298, 0.062005553394556046, 0.05244859680533409, -0.08074209839105606, 0.038315411657094955, -0.07201855629682541, 0.07532103359699249, 0.026411717757582664, 0.04051687568426132, 0.018713241443037987, -0.025558102875947952, 0.034546345472335815, -0.035889409482479095, -0.015077317133545876, 0.05618643760681152, 0.01669074408710003, 0.04904215410351753, 0.03945552930235863, -0.027952300384640694, -0.09069240838289261, 0.018235599622130394, -0.058309122920036316, 0.0755004733800888, -0.05532582476735115, 0.0037740108091384172, -0.03495220094919205, 0.01899290643632412, 0.00211274903267622, -0.033641647547483444, 0.016358355060219765, -0.009385357610881329, -0.02184271812438965, -0.007885313592851162, -0.010507706552743912, -0.009228268638253212, 0.03137480095028877, -0.018869683146476746, -0.008212658576667309, 0.03102860599756241, 0.040206361562013626, 0.0017200843431055546, -0.06120450794696808, -0.03348429873585701, -0.030514132231473923, -0.004689336288720369, 0.0019123948877677321, 0.03110639937222004, 0.02278127521276474, -0.04688338562846184, -0.05491108074784279, 0.03487154096364975, -0.038044221699237823, -0.011668248102068901, 0.0317862406373024, -0.023032765835523605, 0.0035693778190761805, 0.013566314242780209, -0.024394391104578972, -0.06625445187091827, 0.012967941351234913, -0.008053981699049473, 0.017498351633548737, -0.02246006391942501, -0.01319428812712431, 0.0166852418333292, -0.01741354912519455, -0.015271886251866817, 0.018480168655514717, -0.02897774614393711, -0.055032361298799515, 0.010120758786797523, 0.012771354988217354, -0.017414528876543045, -0.006895471829921007, 0.006365974899381399, -0.037422798573970795, -0.0052472385577857494, -0.020722979679703712, 0.044905539602041245, 0.008983295410871506, -0.005247154738754034, 0.010297582484781742, 0.03867187350988388, -0.015022248029708862, -0.036216914653778076, -0.06341191381216049, 0.06675475090742111, 0.08690950274467468, 0.017910875380039215, 0.045751940459012985, 0.02607741951942444, -0.032650627195835114, 0.008444731123745441, -0.0072455210611224174, -0.008197390474379063, 0.016641829162836075, -0.021507641300559044, 0.018068403005599976, 0.045893486589193344, -0.04144459217786789, -0.003554561408236623, 0.004779004026204348, -0.0027365111745893955, -0.03975706920027733, -0.022265134379267693, 0.010552513413131237, -0.0000134136662381934, -0.06378181278705597, -0.033597432076931, 0.01576380804181099, 0.0012813200009986758, 0.007375222630798817, 0.013094362802803516, -0.030064657330513, -0.03019316866993904, -0.04494677111506462, 0.013386239297688007, -0.006870580837130547, -0.022275295108556747, 0.06894846260547638, 0.002330812392756343, 0.02980518527328968, 0.036974918097257614, 0.021099166944622993, 0.0642637312412262, -0.006041211541742086, -0.017177529633045197, -0.024426357820630074, 0.036969322711229324, -0.018362559378147125, 0.02114238403737545, -0.020972562953829765, 0.052020590752363205, -0.06370076537132263, 0.039587851613759995, 0.05145948380231857, -0.04567108675837517, -0.018779253587126732, 0.0003169166448060423, -0.046040501445531845, 0.05359126627445221, -0.09086742997169495, -0.03211503103375435, 0.04328327625989914, -0.07260969281196594, 0.04319441318511963, 0.06678179651498795, -0.008947871625423431, 0.00708386767655611, -0.011336740106344223, 0.0223983321338892, -0.010291936807334423, -0.00920036993920803, 0.05472741648554802, -0.02891680970788002, 0.04028959572315216, -0.01436301413923502, 0.002176886424422264, -0.03899421542882919, -0.05036453902721405, 0.06521721929311752, -0.06940632313489914, 0.013569270260632038, -0.07124167680740356, -0.013397494331002235, -0.04073493927717209, -0.03837422654032707, -0.02495153248310089, 0.036229513585567474, -0.005275983363389969, 0.05104592815041542, 0.05864381790161133, -0.004619968123733997, 0.010655814781785011, -0.0007001283229328692, -0.010034115985035896, 0.03525089472532272, 0.038376808166503906, -0.07476311922073364, 0.001015823450870812, 0.02873927168548107, -0.027074897661805153, -0.05696377158164978, -0.11242754012346268, -0.013267447240650654, -0.011357138864696026, 0.011301551014184952, 0.007285004481673241, -0.0035862403456121683, -0.02843371592462063, -0.038405198603868484, 0.0463256910443306, -0.014106329530477524, -0.07605285942554474, -0.1379753202199936, -0.044584352523088455, 0.023228412494063377, 0.05362556874752045, 0.03029235452413559, -0.05355572700500488, 0.004500323906540871, -0.012080985121428967, -0.004946798551827669, -0.01072706002742052, -0.007488023955374956, 0.028282038867473602, -0.03519948199391365, -0.029999248683452606, 0.037037622183561325, 0.0022383821196854115, -0.0008533751242794096, 0.014246453531086445, -0.03832903504371643, -0.0203953068703413, 0.006906167604029179, 0.021267235279083252, 0.05764323100447655, -0.014688028953969479, -0.025834474712610245, -0.0607774555683136, -0.012973069213330746, 0.04990316182374954, 0.02573418989777565, -0.006069515366107225, 0.045431047677993774, -0.04820534586906433, 0.03041313961148262, -0.025260111317038536, 0.016645250841975212, 0.031294938176870346, 0.010410849004983902, -0.04376651719212532, 0.014708802103996277, -0.011300992220640182, 0.027978233993053436, -0.00039289373671635985, 0.004109915345907211, 0.0016923206858336926, -0.013106152415275574, 0.005319886840879917, -0.0008019336382858455, 0.0001672241633059457, -0.010889805853366852, 0.05099410563707352, -0.006605379283428192, 0.038615092635154724, -0.06794211268424988, 0.004295444581657648, 0.051611099392175674, -0.03184928372502327, -0.05705976486206055, 0.0006538121378980577, 0.027960114181041718, 0.012856447137892246, -0.04382924735546112, -0.03041844628751278, 0.0009339841781184077, 0.055659469217061996, 0.03661162406206131, -0.08558423072099686, -0.03153139725327492, -0.07892236858606339, 0.013406503014266491, -0.013726435601711273, 0.003540011588484049, 0.022493014112114906, -0.0037064682692289352, 0.03432226553559303, 0.02804768644273281, 0.007377154193818569, -0.01534994412213564, 0.05646422505378723, -0.011979406699538231, 0.0035111727192997932, 0.006919377483427525, 0.013195063918828964, -0.08341119438409805, -0.03486174717545509, 0.07634825259447098, 0.06205514445900917, -0.05706566572189331, 0.01598259061574936, 0.05559895187616348, 0.010238248854875565, -0.03202534839510918, 0.03343326970934868, 0.030003895983099937, -0.05662057176232338, 0.0259654950350523, 0.021272988989949226, -0.008025766350328922, 0.03231519088149071, -0.018122214823961258, -0.011867462657392025, -0.05701776221394539, -0.00048468864406459033, 0.02647552639245987, -0.010196099989116192, -0.04910716041922569, -0.00513206422328949, -0.013551594689488411, -0.026690052822232246, -0.003383887931704521, 0.045887790620326996, -0.01917824149131775, 0.020436739549040794, -0.023245660588145256, -0.010194126516580582, 0.021789858117699623, 0.04931352287530899, 0.04631012678146362, 0.004200016148388386, -0.027389343827962875, 0.0493418388068676, 0.012989223934710026, 0.013869807124137878, -0.011479908600449562, 0.03374875336885452, -0.04578967019915581, -0.008238343521952629, 0.03770245239138603, -0.016769206151366234, -0.002457995666190982, -0.028809010982513428, 0.0049248808063566685, 0.0009455051622353494, 0.03711618110537529, -0.006724995095282793, -0.05296178162097931, 0.05410483479499817, -0.0342288613319397, 0.028772154822945595, -0.031395189464092255, 0.015381417237222195, -0.0043914164416491985, -0.006042065564543009, -0.0577116422355175, -0.0618894025683403, 0.016073256731033325, -0.039169520139694214, -0.016743561252951622, 0.024449709802865982, 0.016578571870923042, -0.01688368245959282, 0.030928440392017365, 0.07156802713871002, 0.010191316716372967, 0.013547012582421303, 0.0007566013373434544, -0.057343244552612305, 0.004643441177904606, 0.015016548335552216, 0.06401850283145905, -0.014950052835047245, 0.06605558097362518, 0.005845447536557913, -0.04614463448524475, -0.0074073937721550465, 0.05843580141663551, 0.04509161040186882, 0.011330225504934788, 0.019014885649085045, 0.07840056717395782, 0.021756257861852646, -0.024675318971276283, 0.024440092965960503, 0.05129919573664665, -0.021388409659266472, -0.01387832872569561, 0.018060462549328804, 0.007686455734074116, -0.02637545019388199, 0.004607026930898428, 0.007172747980803251, 0.0743514820933342, 0.024493489414453506, 0.022463692352175713, -0.002451360458508134, -0.02257377654314041, 0.012014049105346203, 0.008737578988075256, 0.0027234130539000034, 0.01210472360253334, 0.007607047911733389, -0.09196558594703674, 0.02520335465669632, -0.008145097643136978, 0.016723360866308212, 0.0019424338825047016, 0.010686451569199562, -0.08137529343366623, 0.029707733541727066, 0.03855433315038681, 0.010626004077494144, -0.0630212053656578, 0.043303534388542175, -0.015139074064791203, 0.01743018813431263, 0.02662980929017067, -0.03325611352920532, 0.022796204313635826, 0.05250537395477295, -0.027856213971972466, -0.02975987084209919, -0.027517253533005714, -0.05250599607825279, -0.0194656141102314, -0.056158505380153656, -0.03328515961766243, -0.02538616955280304, -0.023789651691913605, 0.02743838168680668, -0.01586581952869892, 0.010749341920018196, -0.01133150327950716, 0.005017831455916166, 0.04180299863219261, -0.03964856639504433, -0.014847359620034695, 0.016093336045742035, 0.015317156910896301, 0.041065871715545654, 0.0096972044557333, -0.0072726658545434475, -0.041029151529073715, -0.00956357829272747, 0.014471432194113731, -0.028845587745308876, 0.09705499559640884, -0.023406701162457466, 0.0808052346110344, -0.012955782935023308, 0.020836761221289635, -0.029443301260471344, -0.027558637782931328, 0.020397480577230453, -0.03685631975531578, -0.02529624104499817, -0.018614614382386208, -0.028897233307361603, 0.0443970151245594, -0.02904580347239971, -0.09033744782209396, 0.008727865293622017, 0.013400011695921421, -0.019139649346470833, 0.0431491881608963, -0.02570461481809616, 0.06100175529718399, -0.03563898429274559, 0.008766070008277893, 0.0006633862503804266, -0.020046377554535866, 0.014553943648934364, 0.02457941509783268, -0.03713594004511833, 0.02463308535516262, -0.04230724275112152, 0.005382244940847158, -0.0013672111090272665, -0.037237830460071564, 0.09431688487529755, -0.008232397958636284, 0.017111951485276222, -0.020608672872185707, 0.01580735109746456, 0.008477872237563133, 0.05916853994131088, 0.0801977664232254, -0.013110273517668247, -0.024515049532055855, -0.02654554508626461, 0.026475634425878525, 0.011799857951700687, 0.0077757700346410275, -0.0075758774764835835, 0.04919712245464325, 0.02476394921541214, 0.017464622855186462, 0.04356386139988899, -0.030464377254247665, -0.06339123100042343, 0.0026546092703938484, 0.029702547937631607, -0.015390382148325443, 0.018338633701205254, 0.015359402634203434, 0.03776802122592926, 0.0035277584102004766, -0.011670825071632862, -0.05660045146942139, 0.021160107105970383, 0.009652952663600445, 0.014809483662247658, -0.007925084792077541, 0.03807702660560608, 0.03340566158294678, -0.03581986948847771, 0.04671188071370125, 0.023397838696837425, 0.04202664643526077, -0.012931487523019314, 0.05605590343475342, 0.030794180929660797, 0.07967657595872879, -0.030890831723809242, 0.02970052696764469, 0.03789149224758148, -0.05547872185707092, -0.05621619150042534, -0.019290439784526825, 0.027187228202819824, -0.06091412901878357, -0.02708020806312561, -0.062241990119218826, 0.0572177991271019, 0.01898312009871006, 0.030247358605265617, 0.003242005594074726, 0.013494640588760376, 0.0024055074900388718, -0.047068823128938675, -0.04738672077655792, 0.009775267913937569, -0.005975876469165087, -0.02443315088748932, 0.02523002214729786, -0.0808761864900589, -0.007772093638777733, -0.027458099648356438, 0.01804104447364807, -0.011591466143727303, -0.031642332673072815, -0.03409464657306671, 0.026410531252622604, -0.02514297142624855, 0.015911513939499855, -0.0010268399491906166, 0.013068909756839275, 0.0060308086685836315, -0.054235316812992096, 0.020527174696326256, 0.011424644850194454, 0.054848987609148026, 0.008097244426608086, 0.021610643714666367, 0.028989039361476898, 0.013500305823981762, -0.04044627398252487, 0.003349743550643325, -0.00585621502250433, 0.013968393206596375, -0.032924834638834, -0.0036642623599618673, 0.062016360461711884, 0.010047146119177341, -0.04268185794353485, 0.010020510293543339, 0.015627944841980934, 0.020214732736349106, -0.02653321996331215, -0.0352076031267643, 0.03658964857459068, 0.04478742927312851, -0.0035013931337743998, 0.013960951007902622, -0.04808880761265755, 0.044973745942115784, -0.08906412124633789, -0.001523647690191865, 0.062389202415943146, -0.04821903258562088, 0.009195005521178246, -0.007189156021922827, -0.029914697632193565, -0.019424060359597206, 0.018421579152345657, -0.012637387961149216, -0.016155853867530823, -0.023635704070329666, 0.014766523614525795, -0.03358151763677597, -0.048741016536951065, 0.03977181017398834, -0.01810397021472454, -0.04163595288991928, -0.05261800438165665, 0.02307666279375553, -0.006279306020587683, 0.037260398268699646, 0.0077101923525333405, -0.05028024688363075, -0.000013146730452717748, 0.043692950159311295, 0.04437665641307831, -0.02542201429605484, -0.00771842198446393, -0.021126357838511467, -0.0635485127568245, -0.01756986975669861, -0.01688375696539879, 0.0532233901321888, 0.038404617458581924, 0.05109267309308052, 0.0029155586380511522, 0.03581611439585686, 0.0049248551949858665, 0.017395613715052605, 0.016997994855046272, -0.02267499454319477, 0.00864423904567957, -0.004295083694159985, 0.09420104324817657, 0.020981315523386, -0.04014180228114128, 0.043469373136758804, -0.021042123436927795, 0.01927325502038002, -0.022773489356040955, 0.04829311743378639, 0.07754040509462357, -0.07276410609483719, 0.009968097321689129, 0.023249860852956772, -0.011011024005711079, 0.01819615438580513, -0.0298497062176466, 0.0025365680921822786, 0.034460704773664474, 0.0022577305790036917, 0.01183935534209013, -0.022426743060350418, 0.01180315762758255, -0.0168596301227808, 0.07486668229103088, 0.02258479781448841, -0.013333830051124096, -0.009846145287156105, 0.004143893253058195, -0.029383225366473198, 0.010452521033585072, -0.007651919964700937, -0.019849929958581924, -0.10751675814390182, 0.022228840738534927, 0.05112721771001816, 0.038367774337530136, 0.002406905172392726, 0.04456924647092819, 0.0470522865653038, 0.05706087872385979, 0.012156907469034195, -0.056018099188804626, -0.0030189692042768, 0.037495288997888565, 0.003455482190474868, -0.045068033039569855, 0.0005523868021555245, -0.025053180754184723, 0.011352636851370335, 0.10964963585138321, 0.027851669117808342, -0.044502899050712585, 0.034709613770246506, -0.06569355726242065, 0.012170625850558281, 0.0040488168597221375, 0.009126216173171997, 0.04865065962076187, 0.010779096744954586, 0.031540244817733765, 0.008505819365382195, 0.032769061625003815, -0.005424858536571264, -0.0013041622005403042, -0.05335468426346779, -0.05655220150947571, -0.019713575020432472, -0.018249448388814926, 0.028397023677825928, 0.02263866364955902, -0.050234969705343246, 0.018293723464012146, 0.062199667096138, 0.013103509321808815, 0.0058401538990437984, 0.04777064919471741, -0.032866377383470535, -0.07075304538011551, 0.018497498705983162, 0.008352472446858883, -0.03254270181059837, 0.009073835797607899, 0.06491325795650482, -0.004333860240876675, 0.053689032793045044, 0.011328766122460365, -0.0003517364675644785, -0.030499085783958435, -0.03214753419160843, 0.05325306951999664, -0.03210718184709549, -0.005213859025388956, 0.022405175492167473, 0.02777259610593319, 0.003741395892575383, 0.00439358688890934, 0.0038817606400698423, 0.005105902906507254, -0.10483203828334808, 0.006996746640652418, -0.04736347496509552, -0.07199136167764664, -0.04770279303193092, 0.014702503569424152, -0.04402913153171539, -0.07983522117137909, -0.029300877824425697, -0.042010996490716934, 0.025879282504320145, -0.05099930614233017, -0.05203045904636383, -0.03933387249708176, -0.01514444313943386, 0.0002413224574411288, 0.022247659042477608, 0.017426645383238792, -0.04391985014081001, -0.014596236869692802, -0.02725507877767086, 0.03294968232512474, 0.08082739263772964, -0.019862307235598564, 0.018265336751937866, -0.028547251597046852, 0.009326908737421036, -0.0063577876426279545, -0.003782702377066016, -0.027932602912187576, 0.03586043789982796, 0.0008532135398127139, -0.01956239342689514, 0.0806213989853859, 0.050361644476652145, 0.015342924743890762, 0.012723028659820557, 0.0013488413533195853, -0.022888842970132828, -0.03936002776026726, 0.0007441852358169854, -0.02328074909746647, -0.02471393346786499, -0.0033108205534517765, 0.015372680500149727, 0.02644256316125393, -0.06280384212732315, 0.022941064089536667, -0.052623722702264786, -0.013627743348479271, 0.05333307757973671, 0.0026128387544304132, -0.010141557082533836, -0.02125466987490654 ]
<p>Why is the number of molecules in a standard volume of gas at a standard temperature and pressure a constant, regardless of the molecule's composition or weight? Let's say I have a closed box full of a heavy gas, one meter on a side. It has a certain number of molecules inside. I want to be able to add a lighter gas to the box without changing its internal pressure (or temperature), so I connect a cylinder to the side of the box, which holds a frictionless piston for expansion (the piston has a constant force applied to it, to maintain a constant pressure inside the box and allow the volume of the gas to grow as new gas is introduced into the box). Now I add Helium to the box. The piston moves back to maintain constant pressure, but why does the number of molecules in the box proper stay constant? My mental image of this is that it would be like adding water to a bucket of marbles, and that, evidently, is wrong, but why is it wrong?</p>
g7422
[ 0.017931152135133743, -0.01501584891229868, 0.017157860100269318, -0.028753265738487244, 0.02297987788915634, -0.021255332976579666, 0.0010725101456046104, 0.07242612540721893, -0.10053273290395737, -0.05291737988591194, -0.008061368949711323, -0.05576056241989136, 0.01586710475385189, 0.021291784942150116, 0.014899933710694313, 0.033866625279188156, -0.008364163339138031, -0.057452891021966934, 0.020343760028481483, -0.016951780766248703, -0.04093575477600098, 0.0016412334516644478, -0.002471605781465769, -0.05830679461359978, -0.02201741747558117, 0.009753977879881859, 0.08776887506246567, 0.009204493835568428, 0.011501691304147243, -0.053025808185338974, 0.005597061477601528, -0.0024110027588903904, 0.004136483184993267, -0.013672531582415104, 0.02893073856830597, -0.040751710534095764, 0.05258456990122795, -0.022984879091382027, 0.06212316453456879, -0.03499601036310196, 0.04094654321670532, -0.04091092199087143, -0.0048836166970431805, 0.02008765935897827, -0.02996492199599743, 0.0688953623175621, -0.03161952644586563, -0.023271190002560616, 0.030373994261026382, -0.006016353145241737, -0.010440600104629993, -0.001846458064392209, -0.11442442983388901, 0.013178801164031029, 0.03935851901769638, 0.05391109362244606, -0.051724713295698166, -0.02222462184727192, -0.02260647900402546, 0.029714761301875114, 0.01733931340277195, -0.061309706419706345, 0.03052292950451374, -0.008654583245515823, 0.02637569047510624, -0.01112749706953764, -0.05006648972630501, 0.02687673084437847, -0.017445804551243782, 0.04341166466474533, -0.017634036019444466, -0.06616893410682678, 0.04802577942609787, 0.04184042289853096, -0.02297322452068329, -0.027266323566436768, 0.006149184424430132, 0.023303072899580002, -0.007318785879760981, -0.0440622977912426, 0.0006033562240190804, 0.012561253271996975, 0.05767977982759476, 0.007665211800485849, 0.025014013051986694, -0.052597761154174805, 0.006415158044546843, -0.009279034100472927, -0.05500585213303566, 0.04434770345687866, -0.058818019926548004, -0.006284631323069334, 0.09084565937519073, 0.039108894765377045, 0.008231361396610737, -0.03190259262919426, 0.0007899079355411232, 0.0460253581404686, 0.010924211703240871, 0.007504540495574474, 0.04016539826989174, 0.00415342953056097, 0.031051399186253548, 0.025839373469352722, -0.03281581029295921, 0.007820669561624527, -0.013381904922425747, 0.041486307978630066, -0.00208663335070014, -0.05703781917691231, -0.04054446145892143, 0.01019966322928667, -0.07602179050445557, -0.06042112037539482, -0.0469212681055069, -0.02903287671506405, 0.04897260665893555, 0.06750784069299698, -0.0069473786279559135, 0.0019681090489029884, -0.018589545041322708, 0.01876581646502018, -0.01176049467176199, -0.01363217830657959, -0.041351597756147385, -0.04327907785773277, 0.023001372814178467, 0.013067756779491901, -0.024723265320062637, -0.04377772659063339, -0.009696695022284985, 0.008945430628955364, -0.020061733201146126, 0.03783383220434189, 0.0651245266199112, -0.012835253030061722, -0.048863306641578674, 0.012289244681596756, 0.02117026038467884, 0.03689882531762123, -0.00960165448486805, 0.029612669721245766, -0.0402250811457634, -0.039465490728616714, -0.03241598606109619, 0.005519624333828688, -0.0006878716521896422, 0.004361115396022797, 0.040987443178892136, -0.007362244185060263, 0.018259171396493912, 0.058196090161800385, 0.023861205205321312, -0.023523753508925438, 0.006337018217891455, -0.01054924912750721, 0.0238987784832716, 0.019727259874343872, 0.024813588708639145, 0.03703005239367485, 0.041513051837682724, 0.017012543976306915, -0.013720305636525154, -0.026255425065755844, -0.09886819124221802, 0.05944550782442093, -0.07908321917057037, -0.03429985046386719, -0.0036622730549424887, 0.014058028347790241, -0.06009761989116669, 0.042600683867931366, -0.029960980638861656, 0.06368986517190933, -0.004682454746216536, 0.006062236614525318, 0.13979193568229675, 0.020361457020044327, 0.02296799048781395, -0.052610427141189575, -0.020708851516246796, 0.024878308176994324, -0.0028910210821777582, -0.09102549403905869, -0.08682432025671005, 0.07488191872835159, -0.011663503013551235, -0.009708133526146412, -0.07493354380130768, 0.00532926619052887, 0.013642800971865654, 0.03240232542157173, 0.0516124852001667, 0.021807651966810226, -0.03393539786338806, 0.013716821558773518, -0.025091642513871193, -0.04228286072611809, -0.06976375728845596, -0.025115827098488808, -0.09680742025375366, 0.01262609101831913, 0.02079704776406288, 0.014292923733592033, 0.00845342967659235, 0.0033817202784121037, -0.010064364410936832, 0.035235822200775146, 0.011830066330730915, 0.009004902094602585, -0.006466913968324661, 0.05294584110379219, -0.002245306270197034, 0.00974993221461773, 0.04208885505795479, -0.00027189002139493823, 0.03457724303007126, -0.012594100087881088, 0.03582796826958656, 0.015557236038148403, -0.0357406847178936, 0.03721880912780762, 0.015772193670272827, 0.01011242438107729, -0.027526183053851128, -0.050446767359972, 0.013562187552452087, -0.03175690025091171, -0.035985130816698074, 0.034359995275735855, -0.0393257737159729, 0.02294212579727173, 0.028301585465669632, 0.04227399453520775, -0.0014936766820028424, 0.016884498298168182, -0.05465804412961006, 0.04403434693813324, 0.03092489391565323, 0.03433956578373909, 0.05487102270126343, -0.04727032035589218, -0.0669458881020546, 0.017729882150888443, -0.0032181611750274897, -0.053635187447071075, -0.032136447727680206, -0.0606486052274704, 0.007684861775487661, 0.06841062009334564, -0.10469962656497955, -0.00034830093500204384, 0.015159038826823235, -0.006049979478120804, -0.006666533183306456, 0.056504055857658386, -0.06327415257692337, -0.004688848275691271, -0.028272002935409546, -0.025841109454631805, 0.023914696648716927, -0.016311051324009895, 0.037816137075424194, 0.003924223128706217, -0.08001245558261871, -0.007322070188820362, -0.0409044586122036, 0.04211766645312309, 0.024271242320537567, 0.02866378240287304, 0.03261813893914223, 0.022359097376465797, 0.026991568505764008, 0.0757700577378273, -0.015001628547906876, 0.03146549314260483, 0.00501719955354929, -0.010899393819272518, 0.025058850646018982, -0.01298103854060173, -0.008397038094699383, -0.022962193936109543, -0.06070195510983467, 0.027416542172431946, 0.03732142969965935, 0.0034609881695359945, 0.0059045604430139065, -0.010729226283729076, -0.020263196900486946, -0.01081826537847519, 0.04406839981675148, 0.08545677363872528, -0.021627359092235565, 0.030623285099864006, 0.053060293197631836, 0.047869786620140076, 0.030940579250454903, -0.05282088369131088, 0.004684438928961754, 0.05106888711452484, -0.05377281457185745, -0.015728972852230072, 0.017845463007688522, -0.021699292585253716, -0.06258425116539001, 0.007824936881661415, -0.05714349448680878, -0.007704596035182476, -0.04656515270471573, 0.03762168809771538, 0.022097855806350708, -0.0000515194442414213, -0.022616004571318626, 0.012367368675768375, -0.07515093684196472, -0.022455424070358276, 0.02688649483025074, -0.005322677083313465, 0.0007664256263524294, -0.03692269325256348, -0.03218812122941017, -0.02044830285012722, 0.030801858752965927, -0.06628352403640747, 0.052159834653139114, 0.026798155158758163, -0.02003132365643978, -0.002765858545899391, -0.04289443418383598, -0.03289630264043808, 0.029976001009345055, 0.007732287980616093, -0.03863716870546341, -0.0005540383863262832, -0.007656401954591274, -0.0008451392641291022, -0.02986830100417137, -0.023602120578289032, 0.02081623300909996, 0.03457760438323021, -0.03289930894970894, -0.0014029863523319364, -0.021852616220712662, -0.03335130587220192, -0.004795487504452467, -0.015706589445471764, -0.004652767907828093, 0.02173321321606636, 0.013147064484655857, -0.02048245631158352, 0.05200514942407608, 0.002878385130316019, 0.023072779178619385, 0.0035293535329401493, 0.0069473786279559135, -0.010517405346035957, -0.01573058031499386, 0.028601109981536865, -0.03892035037279129, -0.023739488795399666, -0.000008419187906838488, -0.022887278348207474, 0.0069086262956261635, 0.0613962821662426, 0.01618843525648117, -0.008524909615516663, 0.007245855871587992, 0.03822895139455795, 0.04924285411834717, -0.04403138533234596, -0.007067370694130659, -0.047121841460466385, -0.03910446539521217, -0.007242376916110516, 0.05572234094142914, -0.01414287555962801, 0.012883898802101612, 0.023612145334482193, -0.046825140714645386, 0.048258643597364426, 0.07008063793182373, -0.000735440815333277, -0.056240759789943695, -0.030466485768556595, 0.012036057189106941, -0.017725612968206406, -0.026536976918578148, 0.03554808720946312, 0.05488784611225128, 0.007450587581843138, 0.041522540152072906, -0.012549443170428276, 0.003386156866326928, 0.011248546652495861, -0.013128271326422691, 0.037754688411951065, -0.003354527521878481, -0.059792857617139816, -0.03237386792898178, -0.023349380120635033, 0.05666394904255867, -0.009352706372737885, -0.029365403577685356, -0.01656433753669262, -0.020037785172462463, 0.02810615859925747, 0.07266644388437271, 0.0048361835069954395, 0.04967276751995087, -0.042316984385252, 0.05370935797691345, 0.056386105716228485, -0.012353487312793732, 0.005021602381020784, 0.03485432267189026, 0.01857026107609272, 0.003843914018943906, -0.003427213989198208, -0.021210627630352974, -0.006602228619158268, 0.005857087671756744, 0.06640763580799103, -0.02116565592586994, -0.0018054756801575422, 0.008293130435049534, 0.011656094342470169, 0.01400009822100401, 0.015044895932078362, -0.001327875885181129, -0.0700337141752243, -0.0016426810761913657, 0.01163171324878931, 0.022050006315112114, 0.017574070021510124, 0.030965764075517654, 0.01710752584040165, -0.020035574212670326, 0.021035287529230118, -0.03216090425848961, 0.03702656924724579, 0.047353073954582214, 0.07822854071855545, -0.008107732981443405, -0.006762129720300436, -0.01058398187160492, 0.02817344292998314, -0.0804644525051117, 0.018009928986430168, -0.001582909026183188, -0.006601863540709019, -0.021322721615433693, 0.039555203169584274, -0.0003275726339779794, -0.04101947322487831, -0.03747861832380295, -0.0016071934951469302, -0.03976132720708847, 0.020646438002586365, -0.008462482132017612, 0.0240556001663208, -0.06430194526910782, 0.010830157436430454, -0.07038599997758865, 0.03896253556013107, -0.026950370520353317, 0.0031497010495513678, -0.036936286836862564, -0.008138294331729412, -0.0041032214649021626, 0.0067351930774748325, 0.05725564435124397, 0.010880544781684875, -0.01693721115589142, 0.06458084285259247, 0.05784593150019646, -0.010863657109439373, 0.01393178291618824, -0.0442223846912384, 0.014781711623072624, -0.06785400956869125, 0.039948370307683945, 0.015116392634809017, 0.07092837244272232, 0.05899263545870781, 0.02365649677813053, 0.03731473162770271, 0.0018918904243037105, 0.00034532631980255246, -0.008814577013254166, 0.006169804837554693, 0.04886501654982567, -0.017980163916945457, 0.06143183261156082, 0.006713953334838152, -0.028075020760297775, -0.027611181139945984, 0.04390460625290871, -0.04400943964719772, 0.024234523996710777, 0.01631493680179119, -0.006958105601370335, 0.052664615213871, 0.005545810330659151, -0.021730508655309677, 0.017208188772201538, -0.012059398926794529, -0.0344206839799881, -0.00017649166693445295, 0.019078394398093224, 0.04075023531913757, 0.054496344178915024, -0.020964473485946655, 0.03869323059916496, 0.07886536419391632, -0.0314323864877224, -0.007648366503417492, 0.01014400739222765, -0.07080285251140594, -0.03306308388710022, -0.017116611823439598, 0.011301208287477493, -0.02833624742925167, 0.01461916882544756, 0.0042115021497011185, -0.04791588708758354, 0.05620598793029785, -0.006910075433552265, -0.043453648686409, -0.03372889757156372, 0.07645060122013092, -0.009726015850901604, -0.003845002269372344, 0.06765621155500412, -0.028560303151607513, -0.06451524794101715, 0.011298451572656631, -0.009945089928805828, 0.029431037604808807, 0.06660536676645279, 0.018744617700576782, 0.04381871968507767, -0.026491789147257805, -0.030142832547426224, 0.09800934791564941, 0.013074380345642567, 0.01324202585965395, -0.02831827476620674, 0.018337512388825417, 0.014104291796684265, 0.0062668523751199245, -0.007632811088114977, 0.043748319149017334, 0.009809214621782303, -0.016027407720685005, 0.007984858937561512, -0.004342476837337017, -0.019811753183603287, 0.023591164499521255, -0.03285571560263634, 0.022648289799690247, -0.005092144478112459, 0.048927322030067444, 0.0036726905964314938, 0.01342686079442501, 0.026111168786883354, -0.0626310408115387, 0.0062143635004758835, -0.017973994836211205, -0.02412973716855049, 0.06624726206064224, -0.030918844044208527, 0.023666681721806526, 0.014681470580399036, -0.04163983836770058, 0.05097072571516037, 0.005312882363796234, -0.07926622778177261, -0.03430439159274101, -0.028775686398148537, 0.012592395767569542, 0.002135948510840535, -0.0036063913721591234, -0.005462962202727795, -0.07263907045125961, 0.016554953530430794, -0.0729227289557457, -0.028640665113925934, -0.030143264681100845, 0.011516356840729713, -0.00694575160741806, -0.012977826409041882, -0.01446349173784256, -0.05059488117694855, 0.021409589797258377, -0.0137430215254426, 0.011323295533657074, -0.04850626736879349, 0.027078939601778984, 0.039725471287965775, -0.017488747835159302, 0.04264184087514877, 0.04691934585571289, 0.09004024416208267, -0.03888024389743805, -0.026331055909395218, -0.00011508438183227554, -0.021360570564866066, 0.007695028558373451, -0.021473681554198265, 0.0307599063962698, -0.034518081694841385, -0.02988591603934765, -0.014472492970526218, -0.03525422513484955, 0.025887275114655495, -0.05096663534641266, 0.01693042367696762, 0.011438559740781784, -0.0341639444231987, -0.0037569324485957623, 0.0016189075540751219, -0.01039084978401661, 0.07581467181444168, -0.024595975875854492, 0.0782223492860794, -0.034627024084329605, -0.06643309444189072, 0.048080239444971085, 0.06394768506288528, -0.028209321200847626, 0.0166358333081007, 0.00653502345085144, -0.03669515624642372, 0.015066727064549923, -0.034715473651885986, 0.005999082233756781, -0.07159002125263214, 0.03643219545483589, 0.05474693328142166, -0.00048038127715699375, 0.0038383700884878635, -0.01324812788516283, 0.03969854116439819, 0.02251064032316208, -0.0030517138075083494, -0.015792518854141235, 0.05331522971391678, -0.013813641853630543, -0.04978182166814804, 0.01935102790594101, -0.024833010509610176, -0.028328577056527138, -0.03751837834715843, 0.02436726912856102, 0.005636220332235098, 0.029694393277168274, 0.019635263830423355, -0.04641479253768921, 0.02294253557920456, -0.04054318368434906, -0.021437058225274086, 0.021973874419927597, -0.0038569013122469187, 0.0020518640521913767, -0.014592649415135384, 0.028747303411364555, -0.0140610933303833, -0.015660971403121948, 0.05087139084935188, -0.02917332388460636, 0.023485349491238594, 0.02497577853500843, -0.015157420188188553, 0.014957664534449577, 0.008160773664712906, 0.04538764804601669, 0.02316703088581562, 0.0287716593593359, 0.040116820484399796, -0.04935245215892792, 0.008527178317308426, 0.0070095970295369625, -0.021266384050250053, -0.00028665096033364534, -0.031841546297073364, 0.010415719822049141, 0.01822611317038536, -0.01741839200258255, 0.020568111911416054, -0.032304778695106506, 0.07406429201364517, 0.010112191550433636, 0.04895090311765671, 0.01755422353744507, -0.021641481667757034, 0.05266619473695755, 0.010023459792137146, -0.02918010577559471, 0.011889290995895863, -0.02996971271932125, 0.04257252439856529, -0.05056161805987358, -0.01351836510002613, 0.00911971926689148, 0.0059332652017474174, 0.04273753985762596, -0.007474195212125778, 0.051355794072151184, -0.01635087840259075, -0.02934550866484642, -0.01358749158680439, 0.021202631294727325, 0.05216600373387337, 0.0091622369363904, 0.003599117510020733, -0.03397485613822937, -0.066841721534729, -0.0597313717007637, -0.003955571446567774, -0.08187030255794525, -0.05750527232885361, -0.018666202202439308, 0.010951567441225052, -0.017105668783187866, -0.012416324578225613, -0.04024262726306915, -0.04372665286064148, -0.03847631812095642, -0.004158077295869589, 0.0417291559278965, -0.02095475047826767, 0.016358068212866783, -0.01646052673459053, 0.018497755751013756, -0.02149129845201969, -0.004123987164348364, 0.06318558752536774, -0.010793295688927174, -0.05423924699425697, 0.038706254214048386, -0.030612217262387276, -0.005165317095816135, 0.04289603233337402, 0.038818296045064926, 0.00889519415795803, -0.07594038546085358, -0.07685254514217377, 0.05200272053480148, 0.06645973026752472, -0.025212537497282028, -0.008751440793275833, -0.0707952231168747, 0.010637857019901276, -0.0153496153652668, 0.018939638510346413, -0.08318659663200378, 0.028243163600564003, 0.05023921653628349, -0.01066358108073473, -0.0238325372338295, -0.03187258541584015, 0.06274836510419846, -0.00590918306261301, -0.01625395193696022, -0.017252907156944275, 0.0065212068147957325, 0.0006929128430783749, -0.004783735144883394 ]
<p>In popular science books and articles, I keep running into the claim that the total energy of the Universe is zero, "because the positive energy of matter is cancelled out by the negative energy of the gravitational field".</p> <p>But I can't find anything concrete to substantiate this claim. As a first check, I did a calculation to compute the gravitational potential energy of a sphere of uniform density of radius $R$ using Newton's Laws and threw in $E=mc^2$ for energy of the sphere, and it was by no means obvious that the answer is zero!</p> <p>So, my questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>What is the basis for the claim - does one require General Relativity, or can one get it from Newtonian gravity?</p></li> <li><p>What conditions do you require in the model, in order for this to work?</p></li> <li><p>Could someone please refer me to a good paper about this?</p></li> </ol>
g27
[ 0.06793524324893951, 0.035647980868816376, 0.0005690274992957711, -0.00797688215970993, -0.02119353599846363, 0.02889244630932808, 0.00524044968187809, 0.06276841461658478, -0.03903532773256302, 0.020703205838799477, 0.05110253393650055, -0.06694743782281876, 0.024898124858736992, -0.012818807736039162, -0.023839488625526428, 0.010214093141257763, 0.018278861418366432, 0.002625431166961789, 0.01459213625639677, 0.034964632242918015, -0.050383035093545914, -0.07718698680400848, 0.009281390346586704, -0.07774754613637924, -0.057884544134140015, -0.004138110671192408, 0.00013907051470596343, 0.006240797229111195, -0.036837536841630936, -0.0195468720048666, 0.032325346022844315, -0.01981281489133835, 0.037659186869859695, -0.059016741812229156, -0.04126790538430214, 0.05650331452488899, 0.022507885470986366, 0.020267944782972336, 0.023219190537929535, -0.03471139073371887, 0.008630023337900639, -0.01312804315239191, -0.01406362745910883, 0.001492203795351088, 0.006268528755754232, 0.01654949225485325, 0.014243287034332752, 0.0400535874068737, 0.02817433513700962, -0.038205329328775406, -0.00006670586299151182, 0.01759214513003826, 0.06226205453276634, -0.02936943992972374, -0.050707463175058365, 0.03556525707244873, -0.035504814237356186, -0.0233437679708004, 0.018863312900066376, -0.009525720961391926, 0.007635396905243397, -0.0061872536316514015, -0.01928081549704075, 0.01408571470528841, 0.035709548741579056, 0.008839144371449947, -0.08057506382465363, -0.04243675619363785, 0.035267360508441925, 0.014259038493037224, 0.021480431780219078, -0.025646120309829712, -0.035990070551633835, -0.0350596122443676, -0.0638311430811882, 0.03633805364370346, 0.010036458261311054, 0.019893420860171318, -0.004747180733829737, -0.020588912069797516, -0.012872439809143543, -0.023227358236908913, 0.0347273163497448, 0.015014680102467537, 0.02038663811981678, -0.052114471793174744, -0.006279969122260809, 0.007560861762613058, -0.008673345670104027, 0.08911091089248657, 0.05370046943426132, 0.06027141213417053, 0.11128781735897064, -0.03320937603712082, 0.042980942875146866, 0.045422207564115524, -0.01354928594082594, 0.0392792783677578, -0.03731353208422661, 0.007847627624869347, -0.024646511301398277, -0.014348423108458519, 0.03432522714138031, -0.03772269934415817, 0.04150678589940071, -0.021657776087522507, -0.02997550368309021, -0.001218945486471057, 0.046399250626564026, 0.02843785472214222, -0.019477959722280502, 0.0016538704512640834, -0.030596906319260597, -0.027300631627440453, -0.05217526853084564, -0.05414466932415962, 0.13956351578235626, -0.03122156485915184, -0.045766185969114304, 0.05362312123179436, -0.06550740450620651, 0.10610723495483398, 0.007027376443147659, 0.03021346963942051, -0.0726814717054367, -0.05056341364979744, 0.005275445990264416, -0.032908543944358826, -0.005244166124612093, -0.03915892168879509, 0.04572839289903641, -0.016508333384990692, -0.08285776525735855, -0.03347495570778847, 0.0038861907087266445, 0.01355944573879242, 0.00987450871616602, -0.0008917987579479814, -0.004433974623680115, 0.0020361465867608786, -0.01736481860280037, -0.023343471810221672, 0.025792118161916733, -0.018891844898462296, 0.0007961917435750365, 0.018138375133275986, -0.018412642180919647, 0.04439764469861984, 0.01829667203128338, 0.04384378716349602, -0.007767256814986467, 0.07332327216863632, 0.012939102947711945, -0.09844976663589478, 0.018098589032888412, -0.03414445370435715, -0.006221122574061155, -0.04160751402378082, 0.009435796178877354, 0.0002128325868397951, 0.08776890486478806, -0.003106968244537711, 0.055921781808137894, 0.02839053049683571, -0.008107519708573818, 0.048312388360500336, -0.02948766015470028, -0.02688135951757431, 0.03243759274482727, -0.03537660464644432, -0.03186752647161484, 0.017909061163663864, 0.00677778385579586, 0.023249471560120583, -0.026212183758616447, 0.006335007958114147, -0.008242866024374962, 0.01626994088292122, -0.030576761811971664, 0.012693953700363636, 0.01144601684063673, -0.055220432579517365, 0.04390942305326462, 0.009493590332567692, 0.03915979713201523, -0.015264199115335941, 0.034022845327854156, 0.049317777156829834, -0.014984219335019588, 0.024584216997027397, -0.004806370008736849, 0.029108693823218346, 0.019979460164904594, -0.026006372645497322, 0.03225145488977432, 0.03993720933794975, 0.030729474499821663, -0.024543272331357002, -0.007289181463420391, 0.010965805500745773, -0.014296969398856163, 0.043871525675058365, 0.002758067799732089, 0.020070809870958328, 0.04013698548078537, -0.03534519672393799, 0.012052743695676327, 0.008887683972716331, 0.04891320690512657, 0.024522006511688232, 0.00616238871589303, -0.06021573022007942, 0.026575149968266487, -0.019827213138341904, -0.002660181373357773, 0.022502470761537552, -0.06657743453979492, 0.03215298801660538, -0.05922531709074974, 0.021990859881043434, -0.04918539524078369, 0.05842439457774162, -0.0024156998842954636, 0.019704794511198997, 0.02801993303000927, 0.03962231054902077, -0.0485871247947216, -0.0020915158092975616, -0.028715919703245163, -0.0002907449670601636, -0.054149091243743896, -0.028091203421354294, -0.00430679926648736, -0.03055214323103428, 0.07151012122631073, 0.0255717933177948, 0.012140180915594101, -0.005396271124482155, -0.02086249366402626, 0.026405094191432, -0.04972139000892639, 0.016410065814852715, -0.051329080015420914, -0.00436527980491519, 0.065372034907341, -0.07021396607160568, 0.05269715189933777, -0.06833547353744507, -0.0006561202462762594, -0.005641930270940065, 0.03731158375740051, 0.00274584605358541, -0.03641475737094879, 0.017304541543126106, -0.013306154869496822, -0.00328794214874506, -0.001038790913298726, 0.04751497507095337, -0.03610018640756607, -0.026345938444137573, 0.0098789744079113, -0.04477231204509735, 0.036074448376894, 0.056534845381975174, -0.06149918586015701, -0.0206597987562418, -0.10635847598314285, -0.030193854123353958, -0.01249365508556366, 0.019906390458345413, 0.02821364253759384, 0.05779057741165161, -0.029427941888570786, 0.005344038363546133, 0.018055280670523643, -0.021582340821623802, -0.01598270982503891, 0.024879982694983482, 0.04677668586373329, -0.03226495534181595, 0.012272654101252556, 0.026903845369815826, 0.013963001780211926, 0.028419112786650658, 0.018253907561302185, -0.09348206967115402, -0.018232760950922966, -0.007559724617749453, 0.04942147433757782, -0.048092618584632874, 0.05108639597892761, 0.06036520376801491, 0.03130653128027916, 0.02228374034166336, -0.035609323531389236, 0.04993945360183716, 0.003766117850318551, -0.015130258165299892, -0.05792933329939842, -0.032054681330919266, -0.04014528542757034, 0.004820675123482943, -0.026515448465943336, -0.031202945858240128, -0.04994966834783554, -0.01286841370165348, -0.03387366980314255, -0.026696179062128067, -0.006286758463829756, -0.05213814973831177, -0.0345236174762249, 0.055627964437007904, 0.030721701681613922, 0.018252549692988396, 0.007350688334554434, 0.07736913114786148, -0.026107963174581528, -0.03732365369796753, -0.0035509546287357807, 0.010326244868338108, 0.018162837252020836, 0.03931383788585663, 0.005865663755685091, -0.006894139107316732, -0.0004414747527334839, 0.02814282849431038, -0.011193830519914627, -0.054853878915309906, -0.02959362044930458, 0.020078187808394432, 0.023076526820659637, -0.009618809446692467, 0.003229511436074972, 0.06207987293601036, -0.031493932008743286, -0.011956965550780296, -0.04531862586736679, -0.027843153104186058, 0.07753872871398926, 0.042588941752910614, -0.013646411709487438, 0.032987080514431, -0.042415063828229904, 0.034152548760175705, -0.05354485288262367, 0.08883986622095108, -0.06461316347122192, -0.009793806821107864, -0.009344627149403095, -0.011930960230529308, 0.04076387733221054, -0.012472248636186123, 0.05347268283367157, -0.039002738893032074, -0.013001385144889355, 0.017699867486953735, -0.026205623522400856, 0.04545173421502113, 0.03386138752102852, 0.0040707881562411785, 0.0077623301185667515, -0.012972150929272175, 0.043552860617637634, 0.02086881920695305, 0.02331550605595112, 0.002723341342061758, -0.010881639085710049, -0.0752166137099266, -0.045607924461364746, -0.021633295342326164, 0.027425507083535194, -0.01454929355531931, -0.043541792780160904, -0.023324687033891678, 0.06604870408773422, -0.021857786923646927, -0.008382595144212246, 0.012783964164555073, 0.02295638807117939, 0.04214455187320709, 0.051034484058618546, 0.006582892499864101, -0.017773563042283058, 0.05620703101158142, -0.017933916300535202, 0.003998284228146076, -0.07993382960557938, -0.05774294584989548, 0.021712783724069595, -0.04440072178840637, -0.01172381266951561, -0.04470779746770859, 0.008093914948403835, 0.005150867160409689, 0.018029266968369484, -0.008731440640985966, 0.022364336997270584, -0.006909169256687164, 0.007904035039246082, 0.041362911462783813, 0.03269277885556221, 0.012734983116388321, 0.04102674871683121, -0.021588508039712906, 0.06527252495288849, 0.019163530319929123, 0.027260418981313705, -0.04077237844467163, -0.002016982529312372, -0.011038518510758877, 0.053151074796915054, 0.031647611409425735, -0.017572671175003052, -0.0736657902598381, 0.03672129288315773, -0.03342236578464508, 0.007227100897580385, -0.02094617672264576, 0.018200507387518883, -0.005013634916394949, 0.059275247156620026, 0.030390635132789612, -0.024219145998358727, -0.046645231544971466, -0.002628857037052512, 0.07604769617319107, 0.01185791939496994, -0.006075688172131777, -0.05625992268323898, 0.0029763125348836184, 0.05351392179727554, 0.010304133407771587, 0.028391269966959953, 0.06728457659482956, -0.09300252050161362, 0.05261024460196495, -0.006725640967488289, 0.08122867345809937, -0.020792540162801743, -0.00591266481205821, 0.06288750469684601, -0.038245078176259995, 0.004286654759198427, -0.010546664707362652, -0.03880703076720238, 0.05336299538612366, -0.020560383796691895, -0.03261982649564743, -0.0205395445227623, -0.0030377914663404226, -0.0036014376673847437, -0.020582102239131927, 0.011319597251713276, -0.03222721815109253, -0.020494531840085983, 0.03588269278407097, -0.05671827867627144, 0.06255065649747849, 0.0006278548971749842, 0.031798407435417175, -0.03776266798377037, 0.002610714640468359, 0.06769736111164093, 0.08102066814899445, 0.02668001316487789, -0.033974867314100266, -0.032965950667858124, 0.018913324922323227, -0.011033326387405396, -0.021019062027335167, -0.030582284554839134, 0.030074475333094597, 0.038804791867733, 0.041426029056310654, -0.030475856736302376, -0.00030867900932207704, -0.02886303886771202, -0.03989766538143158, 0.004423175472766161, 0.012556440196931362, -0.04070596396923065, 0.03369242697954178, 0.020243791863322258, -0.019651880487799644, 0.03055237978696823, 0.08260587602853775, -0.01877729594707489, 0.030838647857308388, 0.010733912698924541, -0.00920319277793169, 0.0037775300443172455, 0.005905148107558489, 0.010353338904678822, -0.047091372311115265, 0.023531483486294746, 0.05478259176015854, 0.014772096648812294, -0.017231572419404984, -0.044476110488176346, 0.0005244407802820206, -0.0366920530796051, -0.0037857433781027794, -0.021289030089974403, -0.0014479361707344651, -0.01902926340699196, 0.006341244094073772, 0.02092340961098671, 0.020644962787628174, 0.004754757042974234, 0.03426143899559975, -0.029407057911157608, -0.030419176444411278, 0.04288211837410927, 0.0657409057021141, 0.01985892467200756, -0.06642398238182068, -0.02802870236337185, -0.013930481858551502, -0.05993148311972618, -0.009630626998841763, -0.035251494497060776, -0.0056498609483242035, 0.04601449891924858, -0.023937631398439407, 0.05863476172089577, 0.03336542844772339, -0.02217671275138855, -0.0053786179050803185, 0.0674746111035347, 0.005973258521407843, 0.00624870415776968, -0.016924098134040833, -0.001565544051118195, 0.017068440094590187, 0.004512911196798086, 0.008292113430798054, -0.032858796417713165, -0.0003566945088095963, 0.019085697829723358, -0.005222531966865063, 0.012507631443440914, -0.0339043065905571, 0.03907354921102524, -0.03483011573553085, -0.07110214233398438, 0.019422199577093124, -0.057863347232341766, 0.026310037821531296, 0.008013632148504257, -0.07692263275384903, -0.029853953048586845, 0.01176831778138876, 0.026388347148895264, 0.02075926773250103, -0.009763085283339024, 0.000949195004068315, 0.019055750221014023, -0.047546304762363434, -0.02284521423280239, -0.023554306477308273, -0.026019370183348656, -0.010636620223522186, -0.028373166918754578, -0.02098793163895607, 0.023968523368239403, -0.007325408048927784, -0.002795191016048193, -0.06772080063819885, -0.0026756974402815104, 0.001322397030889988, -0.026435820385813713, 0.02871902473270893, 0.03229142725467682, -0.038531623780727386, 0.015951205044984818, -0.006712849251925945, 0.011296010576188564, -0.018692506477236748, -0.04339880123734474, -0.01753869839012623, 0.04942760989069939, -0.0019637723453342915, 0.033958982676267624, -0.08367537707090378, 0.01920248009264469, 0.02751106210052967, -0.030523989349603653, -0.02926631085574627, 0.01683489978313446, -0.03734865039587021, 0.014085236936807632, 0.012173758819699287, -0.002944199601188302, -0.041338782757520676, -0.042223453521728516, -0.05609378591179848, -0.002180923940613866, -0.02020205557346344, -0.037926286458969116, -0.02430451288819313, -0.05187148228287697, -0.013322697952389717, 0.040463659912347794, -0.04715186357498169, 0.08193869143724442, -0.02837246283888817, -0.051908448338508606, -0.037605736404657364, 0.010445703752338886, 0.004883894696831703, -0.03207101300358772, 0.04340803623199463, 0.016259217634797096, -0.011698867194354534, -0.005936161614954472, -0.030400151386857033, 0.015883812680840492, 0.012817933224141598, 0.004568556323647499, 0.007870771922171116, 0.002820968395099044, 0.012516084127128124, 0.03702720254659653, -0.03064069151878357, 0.04572424292564392, 0.03175356984138489, -0.03654097393155098, 0.05492010712623596, 0.028654223307967186, -0.0005774687160737813, -0.033214520663022995, 0.05293470621109009, -0.0163558479398489, 0.05910224840044975, -0.014963570050895214, 0.042177096009254456, -0.027029290795326233, 0.005733238533139229, 0.030775267630815506, -0.025622202083468437, -0.009880809113383293, 0.0199108999222517, 0.020780447870492935, -0.010659384541213512, -0.023274200037121773, 0.038252491503953934, -0.014399683102965355, -0.01910499855875969, -0.024138234555721283, -0.02024471014738083, -0.012272199615836143, -0.03695015236735344, 0.03375804424285889, -0.02155064046382904, -0.05800502747297287, 0.019797055050730705, -0.05907000973820686, -0.00012060163135174662, 0.01646455191075802, -0.08094798028469086, 0.033652547746896744, -0.004093206953257322, -0.010863949544727802, 0.037281736731529236, -0.06267735362052917, 0.034935012459754944, 0.007725055795162916, -0.022528648376464844, 0.00757866445928812, -0.03455497324466705, 0.045778777450323105, 0.0051797982305288315, -0.10222218185663223, 0.03306033834815025, -0.026891399174928665, -0.005542800761759281, -0.04941599443554878, 0.0050969780422747135, 0.07890556752681732, -0.010046900250017643, -0.0289179515093565, 0.044436194002628326, -0.04408552870154381, 0.0200489554554224, -0.03726264834403992, 0.027829132974147797, 0.012951955199241638, 0.03878023475408554, -0.0010886291274800897, 0.05949392914772034, -0.01184004545211792, 0.02933645248413086, 0.023261984810233116, -0.0006206578109413385, 0.008071118965744972, 0.0005888217128813267, 0.0371105819940567, 0.041714511811733246, 0.03468796983361244, -0.030195167288184166, 0.014803796075284481, -0.03143858537077904, -0.07921009510755539, 0.00562895555049181, -0.002984854159876704, 0.029489394277334213, -0.006640934851020575, 0.029106533154845238, -0.06541574746370316, 0.04143918678164482, 0.07111427187919617, -0.007845434360206127, -0.04348677769303322, -0.01168507058173418, 0.032347626984119415, 0.025599384680390358, -0.09113743901252747, 0.04713623598217964, -0.022377392277121544, -0.045402009040117264, -0.004805932752788067, 0.015065042302012444, 0.03200256824493408, -0.041322946548461914, -0.0422733873128891, 0.022907469421625137, -0.04187595471739769, 0.014125779271125793, 0.005067845340818167, 0.01648891717195511, -0.02262239158153534, -0.0035322089679539204, -0.0060777305625379086, 0.010380229912698269, -0.024705596268177032, 0.027345282956957817, -0.019539501518011093, -0.019810086116194725, -0.0023338203318417072, 0.020215239375829697, 0.0031737240497022867, -0.029670948162674904, 0.014217524789273739, -0.04743300750851631, 0.016328589990735054, -0.05920623615384102, -0.05871796980500221, 0.0795297622680664, 0.08584251999855042, -0.0027384033892303705, -0.01735607162117958, 0.013682476244866848, -0.018740421161055565, 0.06259032338857651, 0.047865789383649826, -0.06590690463781357, 0.008891254663467407, -0.030455509200692177, 0.0013912251451984048, -0.009552533738315105, 0.020655229687690735, -0.04482080414891243, 0.022104796022176743, -0.009049595333635807, -0.009965477511286736, -0.007208898663520813, 0.031930238008499146, 0.07985936105251312 ]
<p>Take an initial state and its environment, $E$, as follows, $$ |\psi\rangle_i = |0\rangle |E\rangle + \sqrt{2}|1\rangle |E\rangle. $$ Suppose that I've written it already in the basis in which the state de-coheres, such that after de-coherence, the wave-function is $$ |\psi\rangle_f = |0\rangle |E_0\rangle + \sqrt{2}|1\rangle |E_1\rangle. $$ where the environment states are orthogonal. In the many-worlds interpretation, if an observer has equal chance to be in each branch, he won't see a Born rule; each outcome is equiprobable.</p> <p>But suppose that when the state decoheres, it decoheres such that, $$ |\psi\rangle_f = |0\rangle |E_0\rangle + |1\rangle |E_2\rangle + |1\rangle |E_3\rangle. $$ This can be obtained with a unitary transformation, $$ U = 1 \otimes \left[\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}|E_2\rangle + |E_3\rangle\right)\langle E_1| + |E_0\rangle\langle E_0|\right] $$</p> <p>If the wave-function decoheres in the second way, as usual each branch is equi-probable, but this time it results in a Born rule! </p> <p>What are the problems with positing that the wave-function always decoheres and branches in such a way that, if you assign equal probabilites to each branch, the results are what you would have got from the Born rule?</p>
g7423
[ -0.018721971660852432, 0.009750036522746086, -0.007687930483371019, -0.0518154576420784, 0.03705717995762825, -0.007714249659329653, 0.03463297709822655, 0.06507312506437302, 0.028393706306815147, -0.006004829425364733, -0.03895142301917076, -0.024756718426942825, -0.001324948389083147, 0.04474266618490219, -0.008965963497757912, 0.015646688640117645, 0.04936298727989197, 0.00014832666784059256, 0.04541546106338501, 0.019043779000639915, -0.02673962526023388, 0.03445298597216606, 0.022307822480797768, 0.04264276102185249, 0.011845189146697521, -0.05691593512892723, -0.0017457015346735716, -0.033315401524305344, -0.04853428527712822, 0.027604060247540474, 0.0177806057035923, 0.028891844674944878, 0.05485206097364426, -0.04568326100707054, -0.013719877228140831, 0.044269245117902756, 0.030408838763833046, 0.011664225719869137, 0.016573501750826836, 0.02330670692026615, 0.03112604469060898, 0.020413724705576897, -0.0045213839039206505, 0.0022082095965743065, -0.018537702038884163, -0.0335075818002224, 0.02868044376373291, 0.0173150934278965, -0.01918320171535015, -0.09138591587543488, -0.020418616011738777, -0.013005711138248444, 0.1078895851969719, 0.04713520407676697, -0.008878619410097599, 0.05116290599107742, 0.011728662997484207, 0.0067890663631260395, 0.004147754982113838, -0.009749424643814564, 0.006162545643746853, -0.06931767612695694, -0.0005734168225899339, -0.009634934365749359, 0.015526684001088142, 0.02602999471127987, -0.028730763122439384, 0.014447064138948917, 0.0383637361228466, 0.0010804444318637252, 0.008652792312204838, -0.07008137553930283, -0.017240304499864578, -0.005620443727821112, 0.02075076475739479, -0.03306671604514122, -0.051216088235378265, 0.025493456050753593, 0.0028025961946696043, 0.06326820701360703, -0.038186050951480865, 0.005438322201371193, 0.02070881985127926, 0.0367141030728817, -0.019479800015687943, -0.0010369265219196677, 0.041555315256118774, -0.04128342866897583, 0.007649225182831287, 0.08186417073011398, -0.02772620879113674, -0.03392469510436058, 0.05380462110042572, 0.000659935234580189, 0.004338333383202553, 0.00973785575479269, -0.05740848928689957, 0.032514214515686035, 0.003719890723004937, -0.02241155132651329, -0.037005867809057236, -0.015597878955304623, 0.014247803948819637, -0.03368837386369705, -0.03020814061164856, 0.014961685985326767, -0.026278721168637276, -0.010933051817119122, -0.09245537966489792, -0.024385234341025352, -0.05143744871020317, -0.026336777955293655, -0.0284722950309515, 0.005349916871637106, -0.08003179728984833, -0.012070266529917717, 0.02181931398808956, -0.024521764367818832, -0.019347302615642548, 0.03313282132148743, -0.014264840632677078, 0.0006946417852304876, 0.017037034034729004, 0.027413437142968178, 0.02134329453110695, -0.0011722184717655182, -0.019708631560206413, 0.0027848605532199144, 0.056053441017866135, 0.00978432223200798, 0.024449773132801056, 0.02331337332725525, -0.006991630885750055, 0.01476682536303997, 0.0227874256670475, -0.01995205134153366, 0.039262689650058746, 0.03737858310341835, 0.023999808356165886, 0.01344319898635149, -0.010258687660098076, -0.05982648953795433, 0.009881221689283848, -0.023963328450918198, -0.026702437549829483, -0.025176631286740303, 0.044988229870796204, -0.045018117874860764, 0.028794128447771072, 0.0286366306245327, -0.052095621824264526, 0.024912508204579353, -0.02560236118733883, -0.030644616112113, 0.007300063502043486, 0.013809100724756718, 0.021968899294734, -0.017501933500170708, 0.010476747527718544, -0.041278641670942307, 0.054096098989248276, 0.013665657490491867, 0.007372900377959013, 0.022850578650832176, -0.016825543716549873, -0.020838676020503044, -0.010105889290571213, -0.07354294508695602, -0.013340665027499199, -0.0511799119412899, 0.008224424906075, 0.010630321688950062, 0.019321812316775322, 0.02964884601533413, -0.017156947404146194, 0.05235247686505318, -0.014935027807950974, -0.06448143720626831, 0.005432358011603355, 0.07010367512702942, -0.03159935027360916, 0.04433094337582588, -0.010890188626945019, 0.010877097956836224, 0.04456951841711998, -0.0673203319311142, -0.01720571331679821, 0.029710734263062477, 0.015109880827367306, -0.007381315343081951, -0.024363163858652115, 0.01825927011668682, -0.046120695769786835, 0.014603445306420326, 0.008048868738114834, -0.028653930872678757, -0.00917513482272625, -0.060551442205905914, -0.0471942275762558, -0.0008005190175026655, 0.0015579230384901166, 0.06963900476694107, 0.012383450753986835, -0.021075818687677383, 0.028698334470391273, -0.03320729732513428, -0.005323380697518587, 0.07212488353252411, -0.03837747871875763, -0.02785813994705677, 0.04706255719065666, -0.09497810900211334, -0.06467657536268234, 0.030610188841819763, -0.030689498409628868, -0.02577834203839302, 0.017822230234742165, -0.0018360678805038333, -0.02150336280465126, -0.0335652157664299, -0.017177069559693336, -0.012336011976003647, 0.058918390423059464, 0.01259953249245882, 0.03995272517204285, 0.021146832033991814, -0.06155554577708244, 0.004467995837330818, 0.004685568157583475, 0.07121232151985168, -0.02880324050784111, -0.05542771518230438, 0.019904863089323044, -0.05271206796169281, 0.012412415817379951, -0.003942463081330061, -0.00614815903827548, -0.0281244907528162, 0.034572772681713104, -0.005603116936981678, 0.02910984680056572, 0.01439940370619297, -0.0317809171974659, 0.030678465962409973, 0.09540584683418274, -0.04367880895733833, 0.00970088504254818, -0.01565391942858696, 0.025666767731308937, 0.05443238839507103, -0.02274193800985813, -0.00047615953371860087, -0.03998134657740593, 0.044103626161813736, -0.043753497302532196, -0.028047572821378708, 0.007793673314154148, 0.019665958359837532, 0.019146868959069252, -0.053985901176929474, 0.02898816205561161, -0.005983992479741573, 0.0006235839100554585, 0.026059390977025032, -0.020406082272529602, 0.03235258534550667, 0.007940788753330708, -0.0021218641195446253, -0.058680493384599686, -0.039272937923669815, 0.005685538984835148, 0.05271890386939049, 0.0038353768177330494, 0.0775388851761818, -0.00704153859987855, 0.03473927453160286, -0.036514244973659515, 0.0042444863356649876, -0.05325343832373619, 0.026944106444716454, -0.03898320347070694, -0.008749752305448055, -0.025709617882966995, 0.04814295843243599, 0.013887682929635048, -0.0892978087067604, 0.013301732018589973, 0.05129943788051605, 0.004112532828003168, 0.03550336882472038, -0.05839811637997627, 0.04253312572836876, 0.08450118452310562, 0.039605580270290375, -0.042885661125183105, -0.015548082068562508, -0.031620267778635025, -0.05759279802441597, -0.0189070887863636, 0.0374489389359951, 0.00491374684497714, -0.003998294938355684, 0.00851479358971119, 0.007668548729270697, 0.002749466570094228, 0.000657697906717658, 0.008287216536700726, 0.04740779474377632, -0.008302485570311546, -0.018780900165438652, -0.015098865143954754, 0.044318389147520065, -0.05827094614505768, -0.08182656764984131, 0.016939304769039154, -0.020388133823871613, -0.04066706821322441, -0.0023055619094520807, 0.06235021725296974, -0.010994710959494114, -0.06607044488191605, -0.0010603447444736958, 0.025988411158323288, 0.05742645636200905, 0.02940136194229126, 0.007964418269693851, -0.10718028247356415, 0.04417772591114044, 0.000042047089664265513, -0.01845182292163372, 0.03281834349036217, 0.029312143102288246, 0.03534659370779991, 0.05046601966023445, -0.03409650921821594, -0.03531208261847496, -0.03677253797650337, 0.008166207931935787, 0.0072272359393537045, -0.010005217045545578, 0.008719139732420444, -0.04166354984045029, 0.02045542187988758, 0.03702547028660774, 0.04430561140179634, 0.015045499429106712, 0.012446451000869274, -0.005079546943306923, 0.0043700989335775375, -0.0129158403724432, -0.030943766236305237, -0.04277227818965912, -0.008940665982663631, 0.03682970255613327, 0.0017550126649439335, 0.041423287242650986, 0.049099259078502655, 0.0369272418320179, 0.04697996750473976, -0.017046259716153145, -0.015793874859809875, -0.01814868301153183, -0.0020291407126933336, 0.014175087213516235, 0.012512443587183952, 0.001466937130317092, -0.00010136124183190987, 0.06310714036226273, 0.029836226254701614, -0.0001817243464756757, 0.04190421104431152, -0.04109201207756996, -0.04933810234069824, -0.009291231632232666, -0.051356326788663864, -0.06577900797128677, 0.03752182424068451, 0.026982566341757774, -0.024731697514653206, 0.014794442802667618, 0.06819301843643188, 0.031897496432065964, -0.012799665331840515, -0.008438048884272575, 0.026502901688218117, 0.027268189936876297, -0.030092468485236168, -0.03598197177052498, 0.027865039184689522, 0.02259869873523712, -0.003141068620607257, -0.007987041026353836, -0.020365966483950615, 0.005751262418925762, 0.06169465556740761, -0.00041494445758871734, 0.007642387878149748, -0.05037562921643257, -0.08921543508768082, 0.05248532071709633, -0.02018868364393711, -0.0433678962290287, -0.010733232833445072, 0.004700526129454374, -0.02574710175395012, -0.028804970905184746, 0.00854138657450676, -0.016085246577858925, -0.060375284403562546, -0.04422634094953537, 0.012006794102489948, 0.05502476915717125, 0.03840343654155731, -0.05916837975382805, -0.013573434203863144, -0.036858126521110535, 0.0850401371717453, -0.048461273312568665, 0.03189444541931152, 0.04231556877493858, -0.0030626151710748672, 0.022572671994566917, 0.00021083721367176622, -0.02064010314643383, 0.014615222811698914, -0.015953976660966873, 0.04605470597743988, -0.04486589878797531, 0.006043620873242617, -0.023099198937416077, 0.01622978411614895, 0.010381325148046017, 0.019830476492643356, 0.009326941333711147, -0.050505295395851135, -0.039378970861434937, -0.023654146119952202, 0.0823553055524826, -0.014656291343271732, 0.033535514026880264, 0.02917858585715294, -0.03701232746243477, -0.0033987259957939386, 0.03556652367115021, 0.024377159774303436, 0.020946044474840164, 0.061424270272254944, -0.03404220566153526, 0.0801476314663887, -0.03284734487533569, -0.009667890146374702, 0.07319555431604385, 0.04563743621110916, -0.09095583111047745, 0.04658329114317894, -0.06068244203925133, -0.04250062257051468, 0.04068945720791817, -0.0056797838769853115, 0.0008710473775863647, 0.05199827253818512, -0.05037888512015343, -0.006673267111182213, 0.007355147041380405, 0.005298882722854614, -0.04000867158174515, -0.11216007173061371, 0.08442004770040512, 0.006176164373755455, 0.012429854832589626, 0.025200476869940758, 0.0020619623828679323, 0.04242907837033272, 0.02156122401356697, -0.029120001941919327, 0.007319814991205931, -0.035788461565971375, -0.008544581942260265, -0.0010099310893565416, -0.029658736661076546, 0.008885200135409832, 0.0006578766624443233, 0.006244671996682882, 0.019562462344765663, -0.007539600599557161, 0.011160238645970821, 0.02742667682468891, -0.04563843458890915, -0.012207751162350178, -0.029984479770064354, 0.029772596433758736, 0.006430189125239849, -0.007169652264565229, -0.011930939741432667, 0.04801062494516373, -0.032308097928762436, -0.017877696081995964, -0.027940774336457253, -0.022655459120869637, -0.0006380265695042908, -0.13501666486263275, -0.0015427910257130861, 0.008602321147918701, 0.03515317291021347, 0.006155768875032663, 0.033744845539331436, 0.08972661942243576, -0.004844825714826584, -0.0321032889187336, -0.013402839191257954, 0.0005038056988269091, -0.03798068314790726, 0.006205087061971426, 0.011745566502213478, 0.03789814934134483, -0.039385393261909485, -0.09797307103872299, 0.03354956582188606, -0.016964435577392578, -0.03919326886534691, 0.028754953294992447, 0.05977493152022362, -0.024864433333277702, -0.011617057956755161, 0.017241956666111946, -0.00652721244841814, 0.002074034418910742, -0.04921334236860275, -0.03400985524058342, 0.08379974216222763, 0.07104477286338806, 0.031233269721269608, -0.013085875660181046, 0.06295541673898697, 0.09891732782125473, -0.04128759354352951, -0.03824502229690552, 0.012454121373593807, 0.03791866451501846, 0.020951993763446808, 0.024572087451815605, -0.029754091054201126, 0.05312742665410042, -0.001613540225662291, -0.037387117743492126, 0.03741943836212158, -0.034118156880140305, -0.007660215254873037, 0.020932737737894058, 0.013709540478885174, -0.0383552648127079, -0.017853260040283203, -0.041499026119709015, -0.03335794061422348, -0.017946382984519005, 0.016890211030840874, 0.03093086928129196, 0.010774608701467514, 0.02232440374791622, 0.0018000687705352902, 0.016498545184731483, 0.02169954590499401, 0.032415539026260376, 0.014773913659155369, 0.02972455881536007, -0.009581572376191616, -0.01856624148786068, 0.0074824620969593525, -0.02422686107456684, 0.04243067279458046, -0.003503920044749975, -0.040879689157009125, 0.02282077446579933, -0.01616825722157955, -0.022811366245150566, 0.04332587495446205, -0.02838357351720333, -0.05987787991762161, 0.03083597496151924, 0.0011426445562392473, -0.03719288110733032, -0.0028315966483205557, 0.04862241446971893, -0.019724564626812935, -0.07180655002593994, 0.0698966383934021, 0.00040366954635828733, -0.06168869510293007, 0.06259708106517792, 0.044261518865823746, -0.038086339831352234, -0.0011275190627202392, -0.0011039189994335175, -0.028012551367282867, 0.010564140044152737, -0.025465823709964752, 0.02325788512825966, 0.0032300776802003384, -0.06204897165298462, -0.014095311984419823, -0.010704589076340199, -0.05246330425143242, 0.03227892890572548, -0.02039489336311817, 0.015870606526732445, 0.05639959126710892, -0.025168530642986298, 0.03445320203900337, 0.025933749973773956, 0.04671423137187958, -0.004276613239198923, -0.03344881534576416, -0.015342174097895622, -0.01469726674258709, -0.011006679385900497, -0.036715585738420486, -0.012464523315429688, 0.011711075901985168, -0.031069856137037277, 0.040829356759786606, 0.051906656473875046, 0.0285634808242321, 0.03207581117749214, -0.028396645560860634, 0.03311518579721451, 0.0409652441740036, 0.03401242196559906, -0.06019505113363266, 0.021730566397309303, 0.06522436439990997, 0.02409951388835907, -0.05617203935980797, 0.002847915980964899, -0.0033227582462131977, -0.05358577147126198, 0.04551483318209648, -0.06452799588441849, 0.045596614480018616, 0.00858069397509098, -0.023002106696367264, -0.006291194353252649, 0.09169788658618927, 0.02539239265024662, -0.02372332103550434, -0.04145452007651329, 0.012969634495675564, 0.0882173404097557, -0.02153952606022358, -0.0588344968855381, 0.01948399841785431, 0.03576527535915375, 0.03510202094912529, -0.01910710334777832, -0.006106768734753132, -0.033277727663517, 0.026017898693680763, 0.08384718000888824, 0.0020060143433511257, -0.044339679181575775, -0.024591533467173576, 0.002291393233463168, -0.011625207029283047, -0.01904585212469101, 0.036243095993995667, -0.011198362335562706, 0.03563901036977768, 0.021046830341219902, -0.05424414947628975, -0.021745167672634125, -0.016042659059166908, -0.03465137258172035, -0.025038210675120354, -0.07278097420930862, -0.003233489114791155, 0.027778923511505127, 0.010532328858971596, 0.006912554148584604, 0.06928564608097076, 0.016809172928333282, 0.010615385137498379, -0.001629237667657435, 0.04446181654930115, 0.0025668491143733263, 0.014721473678946495, 0.01424802839756012, -0.01701420359313488, -0.033892903476953506, -0.008582393638789654, -0.06853195279836655, -0.013873807154595852, -0.04347093030810356, 0.02946791611611843, 0.007359734270721674, -0.03359977528452873, -0.06069774180650711, -0.05869865044951439, 0.04256566986441612, 0.04586587846279144, 0.07561007142066956, -0.013599533587694168, -0.03165328875184059, 0.020919280126690865, -0.018577715381979942, -0.013879516161978245, 0.011874602176249027, -0.06220186501741409, 0.01422905270010233, -0.01892901211977005, -0.009069690480828285, -0.023819494992494583, -0.006875348277390003, 0.025266699492931366, -0.04338553547859192, -0.02706175483763218, 0.0008195830159820616, -0.02774927020072937, -0.06369999051094055, 0.03928085416555405, 0.014112487435340881, 0.04467103257775307, -0.002407764783129096, 0.016568094491958618, -0.05014954134821892, 0.028302818536758423, 0.04357490688562393, -0.008176072500646114, 0.04118165001273155, 0.004490519408136606, -0.003939289599657059, 0.008205173537135124, -0.05458354949951172, -0.004481061361730099, -0.03932072967290878, 0.04553027078509331, -0.025240210816264153, 0.023927412927150726, -0.0029347152449190617, -0.004684747196733952, -0.044154614210128784, -0.03342326357960701, 0.011944015510380268, -0.05353466421365738, 0.02312261238694191, -0.02282797358930111, -0.020730726420879364, -0.0058690221048891544, -0.006298755295574665, -0.01994900032877922, 0.01082113478332758, -0.058508291840553284, -0.024793051183223724, -0.019226187840104103, 0.012649516575038433, 0.03180032968521118, 0.048188552260398865, -0.01815790869295597, 0.045675717294216156, -0.0013589445734396577, 0.04935767501592636, -0.01040011178702116, 0.010831317864358425, -0.05866212025284767, -0.06416276097297668, -0.06749878078699112, -0.041902024298906326, -0.031968697905540466, 0.005087703466415405, 0.06491683423519135 ]
<p>If we observe light that originates X light years away, but it passes between black holes X/2 light years away, will it be normal or red shifted or blue shifted? What if the black holes were X/4 or 3X/4 light years away?</p> <p>I have always wondered if the apparent red shift of distant galaxies must be due to relative velocity with us.</p>
g7424
[ 0.002835397142916918, 0.020074235275387764, 0.027639858424663544, 0.004467272199690342, 0.02053816057741642, 0.042153630405664444, -0.02329765073955059, 0.015049106441438198, 0.0016535408794879913, 0.006547180004417896, 0.03014288656413555, 0.07616714388132095, 0.008222202770411968, -0.0060206870548427105, 0.00705493800342083, -0.02619711309671402, 0.03675272315740585, -0.024964820593595505, 0.025704845786094666, -0.016200656071305275, -0.04771821200847626, -0.005311903078109026, 0.007157731801271439, -0.0802861824631691, -0.013346204534173012, -0.016199616715312004, -0.004142965190112591, -0.03413073718547821, -0.022726567462086678, -0.02530641481280327, 0.07057841867208481, -0.01865725964307785, 0.021865123882889748, 0.00257330690510571, 0.013994785957038403, 0.009982810355722904, 0.023068079724907875, -0.011392802000045776, 0.029979608952999115, 0.019545048475265503, 0.023376721888780594, 0.03731080889701843, -0.06290487200021744, 0.004558755084872246, 0.0602564662694931, 0.01892753317952156, 0.03347005695104599, 0.03841336444020271, 0.023360813036561012, -0.00971734244376421, -0.025027677416801453, 0.03510101139545441, -0.007073517888784409, 0.07959047704935074, -0.029017429798841476, 0.04601743817329407, 0.015738340094685555, -0.03414936736226082, 0.014374307356774807, 0.025029385462403297, -0.03343028202652931, -0.018850820139050484, 0.024795377627015114, -0.010041655972599983, 0.0027954147662967443, -0.023906851187348366, -0.02858152985572815, 0.01749100349843502, -0.029978694394230843, 0.05185667797923088, -0.014249961823225021, 0.03457915410399437, -0.029399139806628227, 0.047102633863687515, -0.03898046538233757, 0.0014428480062633753, -0.04119337722659111, -0.01075182855129242, -0.03280995041131973, 0.02792374975979328, -0.0319037027657032, -0.046801503747701645, 0.006853604223579168, 0.03375665098428726, 0.0808504968881607, 0.023325851187109947, 0.0005535046802833676, 0.03936213254928589, 0.009633120149374008, -0.013467843644320965, 0.04711611941456795, -0.027919629588723183, 0.049199603497982025, -0.0155132245272398, -0.0012117160949856043, 0.016339436173439026, -0.04295048490166664, 0.057860102504491806, -0.032090362161397934, 0.005836871452629566, -0.11228121817111969, 0.03429967537522316, 0.03075817972421646, -0.014127358794212341, 0.032114699482917786, -0.040331121534109116, 0.01380317471921444, 0.04758390039205551, 0.018427912145853043, -0.02969430759549141, -0.009193584322929382, -0.09274864196777344, 0.0363321378827095, 0.0035013617016375065, -0.014018449932336807, -0.03575317561626434, -0.00818875152617693, 0.008970493450760841, 0.04687969386577606, 0.048179227858781815, 0.04054639860987663, 0.025338225066661835, 0.031787335872650146, 0.011083372868597507, 0.047594986855983734, -0.0462045818567276, -0.025056155398488045, -0.01757761649787426, 0.046837590634822845, 0.009228280745446682, -0.022619109600782394, 0.031305283308029175, -0.007745495066046715, 0.043895065784454346, -0.05233899503946304, -0.03985484316945076, 0.0890386626124382, 0.015237223356962204, -0.04318150877952576, 0.020901739597320557, 0.0649792030453682, -0.0798327699303627, 0.039310432970523834, -0.048323195427656174, -0.019653620198369026, 0.01810205727815628, -0.028154881671071053, -0.06861915439367294, 0.042654357850551605, 0.022058967500925064, -0.009471608325839043, 0.001671473728492856, -0.05619229003787041, 0.04270729422569275, -0.03648843243718147, -0.005788816604763269, -0.020389413461089134, -0.016855299472808838, -0.027485987171530724, 0.0018020195420831442, 0.07255706191062927, -0.05162426084280014, 0.020716851577162743, 0.044258374720811844, -0.013503756374120712, -0.020908553153276443, 0.01223539188504219, -0.009396941401064396, 0.04673454165458679, -0.036649253219366074, -0.010181231424212456, 0.015315992757678032, -0.002428464125841856, 0.013370811939239502, 0.009102826938033104, 0.01355631835758686, 0.04486672952771187, 0.02735947072505951, -0.037233032286167145, 0.05958305671811104, -0.05839599296450615, -0.04987515136599541, -0.0359501875936985, -0.013060084544122219, 0.013942933641374111, -0.01622970774769783, -0.04730890691280365, -0.08324535936117172, 0.0016999334329739213, 0.03401949256658554, -0.04523704573512077, 0.011165743693709373, 0.03443070873618126, 0.023406589403748512, -0.0197176244109869, -0.051292505115270615, -0.04977218434214592, 0.012631356716156006, 0.016418656334280968, 0.07843903452157974, 0.041391316801309586, 0.028267398476600647, -0.010611703619360924, 0.001882002572529018, 0.05169955641031265, 0.028615830466151237, -0.009180957451462746, -0.026508880779147148, 0.00506330793723464, 0.005230550654232502, -0.0008353333105333149, -0.017127010971307755, 0.030597811564803123, 0.027538379654288292, -0.04549604654312134, 0.060208242386579514, -0.010823206044733524, 0.03380724787712097, -0.006787934806197882, 0.020062344148755074, 0.012733523733913898, 0.027314167469739914, 0.02498241327702999, -0.03803998976945877, -0.008656700141727924, -0.029194504022598267, -0.050613973289728165, 0.004307742230594158, 0.017290504649281502, 0.05373086780309677, -0.03959088772535324, 0.00964065920561552, 0.04469608515501022, 0.024100445210933685, 0.0455130860209465, 0.01565065048635006, -0.038758497685194016, -0.016892263665795326, 0.02769838273525238, 0.004672131966799498, 0.049726665019989014, -0.04666457325220108, -0.0569559708237648, 0.07003124058246613, 0.006358238402754068, 0.03637142479419708, 0.0561845563352108, -0.045014794915914536, -0.04021915793418884, -0.026025796309113503, 0.0570589154958725, 0.0018384247086942196, 0.015169554390013218, -0.03847747668623924, -0.050528403371572495, -0.05311361327767372, -0.01152853574603796, 0.08270522207021713, -0.08472059667110443, -0.016810908913612366, -0.034739043563604355, -0.01017804630100727, 0.036174580454826355, -0.01664416864514351, -0.0414167121052742, 0.045040663331747055, -0.008216768503189087, 0.0012812733184546232, -0.039219826459884644, -0.004279062617570162, 0.037187956273555756, -0.02461354248225689, 0.05232321843504906, 0.03498465195298195, 0.015520190820097923, 0.03724100440740585, -0.028353678062558174, -0.03862227499485016, 0.006329302676022053, 0.0507417693734169, -0.027906155213713646, 0.02773752622306347, -0.09345027804374695, -0.004679778590798378, -0.006774952169507742, -0.05959613248705864, -0.017454063519835472, 0.029922831803560257, -0.0005807180423289537, -0.01021311804652214, -0.03979114815592766, 0.011100203730165958, 0.05250431224703789, 0.043216004967689514, 0.04222610592842102, 0.027117284014821053, 0.032787587493658066, 0.04172476381063461, -0.040764469653367996, -0.001990403514355421, 0.042838580906391144, -0.05082613229751587, -0.03994855284690857, 0.0386795811355114, 0.04036934673786163, -0.024365238845348358, -0.03020014800131321, -0.012839714996516705, 0.00918219331651926, -0.011957180686295033, 0.01647639088332653, -0.014181108213961124, 0.02534104883670807, 0.0770268589258194, -0.03456014767289162, -0.00006200072675710544, -0.022414933890104294, 0.017680829390883446, -0.049673620611429214, 0.02221675217151642, 0.03283160552382469, -0.01439021248370409, -0.05511735752224922, -0.030188268050551414, 0.05040906369686127, -0.004980612080544233, 0.03806515783071518, -0.043608035892248154, -0.0953562930226326, 0.012449820525944233, -0.021124092862010002, 0.0018262501107528806, -0.06590349227190018, -0.027648460119962692, -0.017915114760398865, -0.001863405224867165, -0.0083802854642272, -0.004664025269448757, 0.00712472153827548, 0.00474941311404109, 0.07198258489370346, -0.04421411454677582, -0.06501179933547974, -0.011868560686707497, 0.015289576724171638, 0.005754433572292328, 0.026876794174313545, -0.03387976065278053, -0.007135950028896332, -0.016626477241516113, 0.008135179057717323, -0.050869740545749664, 0.04360363259911537, -0.036990415304899216, 0.012180710211396217, -0.026629216969013214, -0.01683679223060608, 0.008749566972255707, 0.04783196002244949, -0.021246159449219704, 0.0226694718003273, 0.005280212499201298, -0.02306932397186756, -0.017401251941919327, -0.007952343672513962, -0.005389068275690079, -0.023886051028966904, -0.010087593458592892, 0.030497396364808083, 0.010453615337610245, -0.023357389494776726, 0.010072469711303711, -0.02784871868789196, 0.008486486971378326, 0.022193077951669693, -0.009780623018741608, 0.05098280310630798, 0.03664127364754677, -0.03268472105264664, 0.05129105970263481, -0.011908472515642643, 0.023991797119379044, 0.016490627080202103, 0.010408472269773483, -0.00956020224839449, 0.006952522322535515, -0.024080775678157806, -0.050032276660203934, -0.027025854215025902, -0.0433448925614357, -0.04385492205619812, -0.01961594820022583, -0.018595177680253983, -0.05808168649673462, 0.010470801964402199, -0.027155470103025436, -0.0017559529514983296, 0.003922144882380962, 0.06266573816537857, 0.02622777782380581, -0.007830695249140263, 0.00562947615981102, -0.01392060425132513, 0.05222989246249199, -0.020287202671170235, 0.002078193938359618, 0.013312178663909435, -0.021034294739365578, -0.0187383983284235, 0.033405862748622894, -0.024737529456615448, -0.017551256343722343, 0.021635597571730614, -0.024609550833702087, 0.03820211812853813, -0.014768942259252071, 0.04087286442518234, 0.02082206681370735, -0.0195268876850605, 0.00648810900747776, 0.05446634441614151, 0.0054571120999753475, 0.040267907083034515, 0.008279526606202126, -0.00984241720288992, 0.044262368232011795, 0.056024812161922455, -0.019703762605786324, -0.022055041044950485, 0.013841294683516026, 0.0010330091463401914, 0.024657022207975388, -0.005800630431622267, 0.05522988364100456, -0.05443330109119415, 0.027173735201358795, -0.029830697923898697, 0.025897148996591568, 0.03336765989661217, 0.004237406421452761, 0.02980886772274971, 0.007112144026905298, 0.0032990137115120888, -0.020339354872703552, -0.0014723400818184018, 0.06379422545433044, -0.04852848872542381, 0.0034223946277052164, 0.03890674561262131, -0.018776576966047287, 0.009112323634326458, -0.0004846891388297081, -0.01221486646682024, -0.013627571985125542, -0.028868282213807106, 0.008390461094677448, -0.023734547197818756, -0.015892840921878815, 0.008592107333242893, 0.009686555713415146, -0.030823398381471634, -0.004917189013212919, 0.013238457031548023, 0.005833732895553112, -0.022979028522968292, -0.03241245821118355, -0.032373856753110886, -0.043376702815294266, -0.01022464781999588, 0.04560849443078041, -0.07002787292003632, -0.0015054821269586682, -0.0009058042196556926, 0.03603898361325264, -0.024870872497558594, 0.04531507194042206, -0.04015493392944336, -0.010145764797925949, 0.03269001096487045, -0.04182955622673035, -0.027942191809415817, -0.029712503775954247, 0.0872553363442421, -0.08198302239179611, -0.017886675894260406, 0.04299445450305939, -0.01659814454615116, 0.04993947967886925, -0.004602419678121805, -0.004904971458017826, 0.009344175457954407, -0.07141619920730591, -0.005978288594633341, 0.012849997729063034, -0.05590240657329559, 0.017556698992848396, -0.03413907811045647, 0.02085435576736927, -0.0059997099451720715, 0.010969092138111591, -0.04250098019838333, 0.10312829911708832, 0.0705466940999031, -0.009684774093329906, -0.022129349410533905, 0.06427951902151108, 0.027448588982224464, -0.037668995559215546, -0.015159540809690952, 0.07114230841398239, -0.06280944496393204, -0.00032318898593075573, 0.016215428709983826, 0.02761310152709484, 0.05363907665014267, -0.059601079672575, -0.025801533833146095, 0.0012251569423824549, 0.04635658487677574, -0.005489007104188204, -0.04416092112660408, -0.027183422818779945, 0.01189175620675087, 0.02603822574019432, 0.06071034073829651, 0.026453718543052673, -0.015119251795113087, 0.048829086124897, -0.028811730444431305, -0.06188110262155533, 0.035423263907432556, 0.018690306693315506, 0.04502143710851669, -0.025248011574149132, 0.0012900358997285366, 0.0024435408413410187, 0.011230210773646832, -0.014473985880613327, -0.0016962365480139852, -0.023736564442515373, -0.025221357122063637, -0.02935173176229, 0.011124351061880589, 0.04897092282772064, -0.0006573980790562928, 0.02050190046429634, -0.022781947627663612, -0.025157472118735313, 0.004078712314367294, -0.07567442208528519, -0.02484951540827751, 0.028513649478554726, 0.0019721854478120804, 0.06037888675928116, -0.01300585363060236, 0.03024910017848015, 0.036525510251522064, -0.08521204441785812, -0.056456826627254486, -0.05271916836500168, 0.0426904521882534, -0.03727320209145546, -0.03496759384870529, -0.019707579165697098, 0.03462715074419975, -0.06888236105442047, 0.003710971912369132, -0.08184495568275452, 0.0435471273958683, 0.04521883651614189, -0.022772369906306267, -0.06776874512434006, 0.03311266005039215, -0.02816150151193142, 0.03289929777383804, 0.03185387700796127, -0.0012428018962964416, -0.002742693992331624, -0.05059131234884262, -0.02574729360640049, 0.018956191837787628, -0.009355925023555756, 0.05329017713665962, -0.05619261786341667, -0.059624917805194855, 0.033537011593580246, 0.01798393204808235, 0.06386878341436386, 0.03481545299291611, -0.04153501242399216, -0.007604630663990974, -0.021638717502355576, -0.024212220683693886, -0.07498209923505783, -0.0474434569478035, -0.005833426956087351, -0.03156459704041481, 0.03075854294002056, -0.0026026470586657524, -0.025964904576539993, -0.004501768853515387, 0.003489145077764988, 0.02907383069396019, -0.0005166042828932405, 0.024132929742336273, 0.006942825857549906, -0.06471695750951767, 0.016358593478798866, 0.05222213640809059, 0.03083871304988861, 0.08847308158874512, 0.004785358440130949, 0.023988861590623856, 0.025812530890107155, -0.018267644569277763, -0.0016387887299060822, -0.045212022960186005, -0.044204067438840866, 0.012788950465619564, -0.011535722762346268, 0.04416320100426674, 0.0010990449227392673, -0.04363589361310005, 0.005067299585789442, 0.014764000661671162, 0.08700715750455856, -0.051144227385520935, 0.0056433286517858505, -0.010345960967242718, 0.059386249631643295, 0.019672667607665062, 0.04056401550769806, -0.0038667682092636824, -0.006573227234184742, 0.04837222397327423, -0.03206934407353401, -0.07130668312311172, 0.00912553258240223, -0.009191452525556087, 0.003146292408928275, 0.06267166137695312, -0.0327707976102829, 0.013472365215420723, -0.02187522128224373, 0.026487790048122406, 0.004840418696403503, -0.010586963035166264, 0.0011948253959417343, -0.08860825002193451, -0.01184836309403181, -0.014867428690195084, -0.06742867082357407, -0.012617623433470726, -0.03588304668664932, -0.006441750563681126, 0.003557804273441434, 0.014958903193473816, 0.04047920182347298, -0.004170679487287998, -0.07745915651321411, -0.0486055426299572, -0.0019624880515038967, -0.10759237408638, -0.003321954980492592, -0.01377843413501978, 0.04921477660536766, 0.013253278099000454, -0.07862134277820587, -0.038676898926496506, 0.03694897145032883, 0.011836106888949871, -0.0478537417948246, 0.0058549013920128345, 0.01502503827214241, -0.019286878407001495, -0.051087141036987305, -0.049770597368478775, 0.047524675726890564, 0.06930474936962128, 0.05509767308831215, 0.04223053529858589, 0.05227186158299446, 0.010886856354773045, 0.05630486086010933, -0.03403378278017044, 0.06107521429657936, 0.0031533464789390564, 0.002991592511534691, -0.043110545724630356, -0.02721063420176506, -0.05186847597360611, 0.007548708003014326, -0.06460043787956238, -0.05656462535262108, 0.0371074415743351, -0.018318068236112595, 0.06731405109167099, -0.012501131743192673, 0.033148810267448425, 0.011368934996426105, -0.002667029155418277, 0.021174198016524315, 0.021098317578434944, -0.0027276179753243923, 0.015891598537564278, -0.008574092760682106, -0.04644818976521492, 0.009125843644142151, -0.022106939926743507, 0.014347902499139309, 0.07136135548353195, 0.04049861431121826, 0.07070736587047577, 0.0013678550021722913, -0.008827337995171547, -0.02674824930727482, 0.05200038477778435, 0.009288512170314789, -0.02388594299554825, 0.013726851902902126, -0.018953721970319748, -0.011703291907906532, 0.022909382358193398, -0.019283438101410866, -0.0065980651415884495, -0.049059148877859116, 0.04339413717389107, -0.018958374857902527, -0.04117768630385399, -0.01604277826845646, -0.02008798159658909, 0.02986305020749569, -0.014116999693214893, 0.01189302746206522, -0.059470418840646744, 0.043771892786026, -0.009802272543311119, 0.050968434661626816, 0.0069558219984173775, -0.004736656788736582, -0.017831379547715187, -0.003308228449895978, 0.028669679537415504, 0.03053228370845318, 0.03647203370928764, -0.015306039713323116, 0.04910506308078766, 0.006079529877752066, 0.018955666571855545, -0.01888730190694332, 0.007929052226245403, 0.06847842782735825, 0.029238859191536903, 0.02990632690489292, 0.018237272277474403, -0.056714605540037155, -0.08373402804136276, -0.05214981362223625, -0.11378498375415802, -0.019459618255496025, -0.06418731063604355, -0.017242923378944397, -0.009165065363049507, 0.008378318510949612, -0.054546114057302475, -0.017669474706053734, -0.025093160569667816, 0.06319619715213776 ]
<p>There are 2 balls in a vacuum, next to each other but not touch. They are on the edge of a surface they will both leave the table at exactly the same time. One gets pushed harder than the other. The earth is completely flat. Apparently both balls will hit the floor at exactly the same time and even further be at the same vertical height from the floor at any point in time. How is this possible?</p> <p>If you push the one ball much much much harder than the first so that it is going at a considerable speed 100m/s compared to 1m/s say. The balls can't possible hit the floor at the same time, right?</p> <p>Now the earth is round. You hit the one ball so hard it goes into orbit the other ball just falls of the table straight down like before. As the one ball has gone into orbit it will never reach the ground. However the slow ball will reach the ground much faster. How can a rule be different? If it doesn't work at the extreme then it shouldnt work at all. </p>
g7425
[ 0.0582873709499836, 0.05451922491192818, -0.004223949275910854, -0.0017982841236516833, 0.07014384865760803, 0.07095424085855484, -0.013260230422019958, 0.0020487706642597914, -0.056845858693122864, -0.02599027007818222, -0.013517210260033607, -0.01759982667863369, 0.011029276065528393, -0.009663786739110947, 0.015464878641068935, 0.02589266560971737, 0.05820174142718315, -0.033873602747917175, -0.027096234261989594, 0.025000883266329765, 0.03809936344623566, 0.0069076018407940865, 0.005441559478640556, -0.03454373776912689, -0.07709704339504242, -0.013505823910236359, -0.02227010205388069, -0.02622322179377079, -0.02863471955060959, -0.0019807538483291864, 0.007209984585642815, -0.011890207417309284, 0.011577264405786991, -0.06658931076526642, -0.027192257344722748, -0.006467856932431459, 0.012566103599965572, -0.04416247829794884, -0.055321138352155685, 0.006766762584447861, 0.019985321909189224, -0.02738090790808201, -0.00022300862474367023, -0.020778005942702293, 0.010760638862848282, -0.0013746597105637193, -0.025870218873023987, 0.03473523631691933, -0.005672421306371689, -0.029258664697408676, -0.010634101927280426, -0.008062068372964859, -0.017561381682753563, -0.008670760318636894, -0.030865870416164398, 0.023783428594470024, 0.018816007301211357, -0.014522532001137733, 0.09325237572193146, 0.0042509958148002625, -0.046772297471761703, -0.04484075680375099, 0.06451702117919922, 0.034398142248392105, 0.05203957110643387, 0.027296101674437523, -0.03364349529147148, -0.0029091136530041695, 0.00802337285131216, -0.024637466296553612, 0.03757407143712044, -0.024771319702267647, -0.017068441957235336, -0.04548950865864754, -0.058844055980443954, -0.0035547646693885326, 0.05752972885966301, -0.018630225211381912, 0.041590847074985504, 0.010342288762331009, -0.024075275287032127, 0.033528368920087814, -0.002884187735617161, 0.02639700286090374, 0.03618040308356285, -0.04481631889939308, -0.005444876849651337, -0.054995547980070114, -0.027468672022223473, -0.00460011325776577, 0.021262651309370995, -0.03917326033115387, 0.040400952100753784, 0.04450448602437973, -0.05584710091352463, -0.0007667395984753966, 0.01766534522175789, 0.08202622085809708, -0.030169574543833733, -0.012883051298558712, -0.0016053413273766637, 0.02855352871119976, 0.05061604827642441, -0.0005263662314973772, -0.007601860910654068, -0.0059858886525034904, 0.02736036106944084, 0.05143968015909195, 0.02442091517150402, -0.05740367993712425, 0.006064295303076506, -0.052439577877521515, -0.02925119921565056, -0.0712255984544754, 0.018449582159519196, -0.03119945153594017, 0.07143043726682663, 0.02906745672225952, -0.00693451426923275, 0.0561712272465229, 0.07157757133245468, 0.051586031913757324, -0.011806548573076725, 0.0018386252922937274, -0.03327580913901329, -0.0008590432116761804, 0.03165660426020622, -0.029660195112228394, 0.025947073474526405, -0.01323761511594057, -0.054832492023706436, 0.019765028730034828, -0.0012396043166518211, 0.007315702270716429, -0.05474388226866722, -0.021142156794667244, 0.028119059279561043, 0.000911287555936724, 0.0008898983360268176, -0.04321236535906792, -0.022126229479908943, 0.001610507257282734, -0.044942669570446014, -0.003943259362131357, -0.03219250589609146, 0.03762971982359886, 0.05150424316525459, 0.01568489521741867, -0.0198501106351614, -0.005195873323827982, 0.041161321103572845, 0.0650913268327713, 0.008527416735887527, 0.02749582752585411, 0.014361037872731686, 0.014004644006490707, 0.033439330756664276, 0.056634508073329926, 0.014642479829490185, -0.0012761070393025875, 0.05932464078068733, 0.03863260895013809, -0.016468923538923264, -0.016651956364512444, -0.058263570070266724, 0.0904175266623497, -0.030599147081375122, -0.014663570560514927, -0.030541347339749336, -0.034790683537721634, -0.09797794371843338, -0.04761200770735741, 0.047485072165727615, 0.08482033759355545, -0.008823824115097523, 0.013450924307107925, 0.012859906069934368, -0.024006260558962822, -0.02630961686372757, -0.0021519844885915518, 0.02227935940027237, -0.041976116597652435, -0.011466749012470245, 0.03257184848189354, 0.02592751756310463, -0.006292190868407488, 0.011548101902008057, 0.03184647485613823, -0.07956675440073013, -0.03665779531002045, -0.03462693840265274, -0.06009045988321304, 0.007335038390010595, 0.030853383243083954, 0.022599341347813606, 0.014917876571416855, 0.08970008045434952, 0.0007447528187185526, -0.04345840588212013, 0.0023159869015216827, -0.00829313974827528, 0.037119705229997635, 0.04755255952477455, 0.020655319094657898, -0.0005028113955631852, -0.015630140900611877, -0.0048193554393947124, 0.004706169944256544, 0.04783066734671593, 0.0014471156755462289, 0.021214716136455536, 0.019217604771256447, 0.03050757572054863, 0.026072757318615913, 0.004025872331112623, 0.02424098551273346, -0.036556437611579895, 0.0020496316719800234, -0.037354305386543274, -0.007680958602577448, 0.021840358152985573, 0.004349405411630869, 0.06456270813941956, -0.03839573636651039, 0.01985679380595684, -0.07771661132574081, -0.03350333124399185, 0.022418253123760223, -0.003238152014091611, 0.0466628260910511, 0.000048372894525527954, -0.022655613720417023, -0.00015963327314238995, 0.0008421634556725621, 0.031696103513240814, 0.014651727862656116, 0.01625613123178482, 0.014170760288834572, -0.007338071241974831, 0.045086417347192764, 0.010167298838496208, -0.07411947846412659, -0.04717091843485832, -0.025899112224578857, 0.028476916253566742, -0.0802718922495842, 0.038241758942604065, -0.018362130969762802, 0.024503188207745552, 0.06601636111736298, -0.0025996582116931677, -0.0030490034259855747, -0.1045001819729805, 0.010691247880458832, -0.024667304009199142, -0.02472063899040222, -0.027971584349870682, 0.028860334306955338, -0.06573496758937836, -0.03556279093027115, 0.0363943986594677, -0.007025612518191338, 0.018285952508449554, 0.03857129067182541, -0.060759447515010834, -0.01969773694872856, -0.037122830748558044, 0.04297638684511185, -0.027704255655407906, 0.004297573585063219, -0.03593113645911217, 0.03832198306918144, 0.017633557319641113, 0.04251856356859207, -0.007758505176752806, 0.02075318805873394, 0.005066873040050268, -0.03684017434716225, 0.04348963126540184, 0.01424723956733942, -0.05333167687058449, 0.0018034455133602023, -0.0059789568185806274, -0.04600436985492706, 0.04337383806705475, -0.046597592532634735, -0.005953880492597818, 0.036876946687698364, -0.055937670171260834, 0.03456339240074158, -0.0063997963443398476, 0.0005560563295148313, 0.07083634287118912, 0.023670554161071777, 0.00012219489144627005, 0.09889769554138184, 0.0016660075634717941, -0.03370668739080429, -0.051249876618385315, 0.04099215939640999, 0.036819227039813995, -0.06611278653144836, -0.02223241701722145, 0.05897650122642517, 0.017832502722740173, -0.0084697799757123, 0.037894729524850845, -0.04378889128565788, -0.02006254717707634, -0.04370153322815895, 0.06252379715442657, 0.06835443526506424, -0.007770025637000799, -0.046434931457042694, -0.026460828259587288, 0.0292954221367836, 0.014038903638720512, 0.025207078084349632, 0.03108728863298893, 0.04550151154398918, -0.023449329659342766, -0.012289238162338734, -0.02551374025642872, -0.004810806829482317, 0.016466964036226273, 0.01761292666196823, -0.08233319967985153, -0.03534819930791855, -0.04423389583826065, 0.013701091520488262, 0.036772843450307846, 0.06983382999897003, -0.04469195753335953, -0.04432341828942299, -0.058533646166324615, -0.0020320273470133543, 0.04163452610373497, 0.005403479095548391, 0.030487025156617165, 0.0770549401640892, -0.06958005577325821, 0.0026123446878045797, -0.06615738570690155, 0.005588064901530743, -0.005279206205159426, 0.07170993089675903, 0.01638505421578884, 0.01719215139746666, -0.03992892801761627, 0.008120345883071423, 0.07546675950288773, -0.016757449135184288, 0.05237796530127525, -0.014304309152066708, 0.024783136323094368, 0.027263551950454712, 0.003230350324884057, 0.04758714511990547, -0.024191871285438538, -0.03736498951911926, 0.017827244475483894, 0.04402751475572586, -0.00865379348397255, -0.026171453297138214, 0.006269827485084534, 0.0061734747141599655, -0.02047535590827465, 0.003445846028625965, -0.0029939187224954367, 0.04501594603061676, -0.027242930606007576, -0.00896709505468607, 0.015912987291812897, 0.021620990708470345, 0.0625758245587349, -0.02108081802725792, 0.05281255021691322, -0.01837802492082119, -0.029898308217525482, 0.025121890008449554, 0.07600356638431549, 0.012042390182614326, -0.0150680523365736, -0.014654777944087982, 0.051353100687265396, 0.04842141643166542, -0.03307627886533737, -0.03565821051597595, 0.03744351491332054, -0.03097560815513134, 0.07120783627033234, -0.005145039409399033, -0.00563152926042676, 0.011834274977445602, 0.03277392312884331, 0.020404646173119545, 0.004061920568346977, -0.014111689291894436, 0.0054901824332773685, 0.007158438675105572, 0.006847746204584837, 0.019614974036812782, -0.10021428018808365, -0.029733965173363686, -0.05540518835186958, -0.03103245608508587, 0.007826666347682476, -0.003652443876489997, -0.0014705407666042447, 0.016793789342045784, 0.01489939633756876, 0.019512532278895378, -0.04982020705938339, -0.06171693652868271, 0.027000414207577705, 0.026686133816838264, 0.0458684004843235, 0.10015852749347687, 0.005466036032885313, -0.0217721126973629, -0.02219497784972191, 0.04390990361571312, 0.005721899680793285, -0.03712966665625572, 0.013956615701317787, -0.014484862796962261, 0.0015662471996620297, 0.025940606370568275, 0.012392616830766201, -0.015679307281970978, 0.004501220770180225, 0.02386617101728916, -0.01117902621626854, 0.04944591224193573, -0.04395643621683121, 0.03326309099793434, 0.004100783262401819, 0.02505585364997387, 0.035807911306619644, 0.050962913781404495, 0.05036259442567825, -0.03159045800566673, -0.013390014879405499, 0.03629761561751366, 0.02125413529574871, 0.10874970257282257, -0.00932410266250372, -0.07738173753023148, -0.05014980956912041, -0.028042133897542953, -0.03892828896641731, -0.014647001400589943, -0.0015722174430266023, -0.003704733680933714, -0.022151295095682144, -0.049035876989364624, 0.004653738811612129, 0.06868860125541687, -0.03443151339888573, -0.02063649892807007, -0.036899227648973465, -0.0010496428003534675, 0.01259948592633009, 0.0024037635885179043, 0.007253320887684822, -0.004466424696147442, -0.04665593057870865, -0.011749754659831524, -0.07335066050291061, 0.014006173238158226, 0.0008417993085458875, 0.016252920031547546, -0.024883130565285683, 0.09904026240110397, 0.0065420339815318584, 0.0010096565820276737, 0.03149983286857605, -0.024998845532536507, 0.07839150726795197, -0.0674668475985527, -0.04038460552692413, -0.065177321434021, 0.008111708797514439, -0.028612136840820312, -0.02603430487215519, 0.013698052614927292, -0.018516046926379204, 0.01700105145573616, 0.06786748766899109, -0.001074672443792224, 0.036407265812158585, -0.020308170467615128, -0.0717749074101448, -0.013280892744660378, -0.05530204251408577, -0.01889721117913723, 0.02474929764866829, 0.0026229661889374256, -0.04409793019294739, 0.0032067361753433943, -0.07233487814664841, -0.009257006458938122, 0.013444704934954643, 0.0059095509350299835, -0.05469278246164322, 0.0007144567207433283, 0.007712113205343485, -0.024811891838908195, 0.01864871010184288, -0.014857344329357147, -0.038949549198150635, -0.004452064633369446, 0.04089801013469696, -0.006527591496706009, -0.002521110000088811, 0.006766782142221928, 0.053328972309827805, -0.02145654894411564, 0.012358888983726501, -0.021916549652814865, 0.052099909633398056, -0.021927673369646072, 0.009481523185968399, -0.0031445734202861786, -0.02980344183743, -0.01171774510294199, -0.08188045024871826, 0.008385097607970238, -0.009817195124924183, 0.09564801305532455, -0.0022070067934691906, -0.04869439825415611, -0.038713376969099045, -0.02815242111682892, -0.0404539629817009, -0.016300661489367485, 0.04828188568353653, -0.04704682528972626, 0.07198655605316162, -0.06760833412408829, -0.006204505451023579, -0.05775616317987442, -0.0122115733101964, 0.0691179558634758, -0.02151520736515522, -0.005527794826775789, -0.08712971210479736, -0.016594266518950462, 0.08975125849246979, 0.011198282241821289, -0.020365867763757706, 0.03819869086146355, -0.026013189926743507, 0.03573994338512421, -0.03577191382646561, 0.016030877828598022, 0.005487124435603619, 0.007182384841144085, -0.005571608431637287, 0.004628404509276152, 0.03022734634578228, -0.003905473044142127, 0.028997624292969704, -0.005288972053676844, -0.05304770544171333, -0.03211631253361702, -0.015516464598476887, -0.003723671892657876, 0.03955896571278572, -0.004499237053096294, 0.0026192590594291687, 0.003973916172981262, 0.005764367990195751, 0.010985661298036575, 0.021531635895371437, -0.05151134729385376, -0.013220172375440598, 0.022682666778564453, -0.04081610590219498, -0.008477676659822464, 0.022418662905693054, -0.006772354245185852, 0.00031925650546327233, -0.021185066550970078, 0.028727034106850624, 0.02817922830581665, -0.06950045377016068, -0.03639964014291763, 0.035922035574913025, -0.03978917375206947, -0.026677561923861504, -0.023516401648521423, -0.008075054734945297, -0.03258698806166649, -0.07227133214473724, -0.023944800719618797, -0.04729335755109787, 0.0005549716879613698, -0.04978122189640999, 0.05067263916134834, -0.01640482060611248, -0.05284377187490463, 0.03686053678393364, 0.03747960180044174, 0.02887539379298687, 0.03101632371544838, -0.03340218588709831, -0.0477420799434185, 0.03423900157213211, 0.03631860017776489, -0.06805913150310516, 0.023953767493367195, -0.019390594214200974, 0.016832221299409866, -0.044085536152124405, -0.038822583854198456, 0.02213214337825775, -0.04275305196642876, 0.013036973774433136, -0.03815890848636627, 0.005957541987299919, 0.0032811379060149193, -0.049777545034885406, -0.04397101700305939, 0.0013730906648561358, -0.05577142536640167, -0.030095327645540237, 0.024760615080595016, 0.04757406935095787, 0.014696943573653698, 0.06463814526796341, -0.055842407047748566, -0.014307389967143536, 0.012480943463742733, -0.0023973474744707346, 0.06600863486528397, -0.012758740223944187, 0.03718738257884979, -0.02705518901348114, 0.01993890106678009, 0.0453021302819252, 0.04612526670098305, -0.01641482673585415, 0.08784548938274384, 0.028348417952656746, 0.019302157685160637, 0.01396140642464161, -0.018739398568868637, 0.015258685685694218, 0.03147301450371742, 0.011552568525075912, -0.03895074129104614, -0.07948783785104752, 0.0343015156686306, 0.00012738839723169804, -0.015296583995223045, -0.026445481926202774, -0.021513359621167183, -0.0200973954051733, -0.005262940190732479, 0.005186047870665789, -0.015790678560733795, -0.007049637380987406, 0.026044659316539764, -0.039598945528268814, 0.04094897583127022, -0.003405050141736865, -0.03129212185740471, 0.008878427557647228, -0.04355015605688095, 0.0374758243560791, -0.05076129361987114, -0.03373026102781296, 0.017519880086183548, 0.044652219861745834, 0.024896977469325066, -0.01375386118888855, 0.030323876067996025, -0.007271867245435715, -0.013495041988790035, 0.021076641976833344, 0.00881127268075943, -0.006949367932975292, -0.009855525568127632, 0.01965291239321232, 0.054962772876024246, -0.013097157701849937, 0.04389892518520355, 0.017274124547839165, -0.024780960753560066, 0.05452873557806015, 0.026353033259510994, -0.0005911759799346328, 0.03644328936934471, -0.01641320250928402, -0.0008556359680369496, -0.020132234320044518, 0.046751055866479874, -0.002002524212002754, -0.025737088173627853, -0.00337229878641665, 0.010159264318645, 0.014523857273161411, -0.016718171536922455, 0.030126536265015602, 0.011878508143126965, -0.00628364784643054, 0.04980115965008736, -0.004879193380475044, -0.01288741547614336, 0.005057904869318008, 0.06526616960763931, -0.02214992791414261, -0.03150950372219086, -0.00215316703543067, 0.05555930361151695, -0.01373964548110962, 0.004953381605446339, 0.046619266271591187, -0.018014417961239815, -0.03357846289873123, 0.016140196472406387, 0.011940980330109596, -0.08433256298303604, -0.005699025932699442, 0.027222415432333946, 0.02930552139878273, -0.07056047022342682, 0.015373066067695618, -0.03852393478155136, 0.02843080833554268, -0.040724072605371475, -0.005802864208817482, 0.025800218805670738, -0.044351134449243546, 0.04975168779492378, -0.016397925093770027, 0.03928685933351517, -0.07682335376739502, 0.0035775224678218365, -0.045080192387104034, -0.052477508783340454, -0.03762247785925865, -0.0024508382193744183, 0.01659850962460041, 0.0035184714943170547, -0.030505577102303505, 0.022196684032678604, -0.002094320487231016, 0.000990652246400714, 0.017951175570487976, -0.024975763633847237, -0.08119746297597885, 0.07512815296649933, 0.04944772645831108, -0.030390847474336624, -0.013522787019610405, 0.015810009092092514, 0.017009686678647995, -0.02176556922495365, -0.04194767028093338, 0.01962267979979515, 0.03553740307688713, -0.013782442547380924, 0.019909482449293137, -0.015483083203434944, -0.021987413987517357, 0.020434128120541573 ]
<p>I connected a bulb to a battery positive terminals with positive and negative terminals with negative . It glows as it should but when i connect the positive terminal of the same bulb to the positive terminal of one battery and negative terminal of the same bulb to the negative terminal of another battery. The bulb does not glow. What I want to ask here is that electric potential difference is being maintained then why does the bulb does not glow. NOTE : Batteries are not connected with each other. Both batteries are separately placed.</p>
g7426
[ 0.031266119331121445, -0.02246982976794243, 0.013587591238319874, 0.01781126670539379, 0.07567919790744781, 0.009923724457621574, 0.012267222627997398, 0.03287233039736748, -0.019276946783065796, -0.011823947541415691, -0.0013653853675350547, -0.001130979391746223, -0.021736884489655495, 0.04986879602074623, 0.00148844497743994, -0.01659051701426506, 0.04283199831843376, -0.007218983490020037, 0.0347304567694664, 0.035735759884119034, -0.02862352505326271, 0.03442229703068733, -0.025814158841967583, 0.01242346316576004, -0.028961073607206345, -0.015963902696967125, -0.010465051047503948, 0.000413750356528908, -0.016935810446739197, -0.0474148690700531, -0.008019540458917618, 0.011261417530477047, 0.055666446685791016, 0.035465631633996964, -0.04634416475892067, -0.02288007363677025, 0.0386507622897625, 0.02285752259194851, -0.028153831139206886, 0.0753948986530304, 0.05192774161696434, 0.05307219177484512, 0.027504874393343925, -0.011426842771470547, -0.00627756305038929, -0.04990274831652641, 0.048435602337121964, 0.012692298740148544, 0.011258442886173725, -0.03877030685544014, 0.0026854306925088167, 0.006595767103135586, -0.02005838230252266, -0.012292423285543919, 0.057133909314870834, -0.020380908623337746, 0.037212908267974854, -0.05036936327815056, -0.013014529831707478, 0.03846767544746399, 0.007912556640803814, 0.03136066719889641, 0.02841399796307087, 0.04467983916401863, 0.02512870915234089, -0.030106741935014725, 0.016889426857233047, -0.02919231541454792, 0.0150266382843256, -0.008736390620470047, -0.03283635899424553, 0.022933941334486008, -0.03681455925107002, 0.034099552780389786, 0.020120175555348396, 0.007379163056612015, 0.05078470706939697, -0.040408335626125336, -0.014123577624559402, 0.04790961369872093, 0.0002159111900255084, -0.05182845890522003, 0.04205448180437088, 0.07635136693716049, 0.03025742620229721, 0.008789571933448315, 0.02832709066569805, -0.04537512734532356, -0.08262528479099274, -0.02503548562526703, 0.059588395059108734, -0.020676223561167717, 0.09760046005249023, 0.013965795747935772, -0.04227729141712189, 0.019596464931964874, 0.008661494590342045, 0.045222487300634384, 0.007951021194458008, -0.024904275313019753, 0.03446516767144203, -0.011333812028169632, -0.009830472990870476, -0.028706956654787064, -0.057872362434864044, -0.02091703750193119, -0.018385890871286392, 0.01033864263445139, -0.040748871862888336, 0.002698896685615182, -0.02627764269709587, -0.10306937992572784, -0.014330125413835049, -0.04134770855307579, -0.01554777566343546, 0.023669825866818428, 0.06313162297010422, -0.10017801076173782, -0.0034874766133725643, -0.06828112155199051, 0.02040054090321064, 0.009387575089931488, 0.018647927790880203, -0.004919097758829594, 0.01848423294723034, 0.008452512323856354, 0.01636229082942009, -0.013921125791966915, 0.017938220873475075, 0.03387080132961273, 0.009821626357734203, -0.011069408617913723, -0.011165146715939045, 0.017172647640109062, 0.011959255672991276, 0.003706415882334113, 0.07416240125894547, -0.015215500257909298, 0.03652312234044075, 0.000645180931314826, 0.017010992392897606, 0.0006141108460724354, -0.005318114068359137, 0.014652193523943424, -0.03462010622024536, 0.029563037678599358, 0.0038638992700725794, 0.0025615538470447063, 0.0747193843126297, 0.04241044074296951, 0.05722442641854286, -0.005686393938958645, 0.0014195083640515804, -0.06620217859745026, 0.018043361604213715, -0.04269148409366608, -0.0029345527291297913, -0.012603849172592163, -0.043752845376729965, 0.005570327863097191, 0.002806328469887376, -0.012531904503703117, -0.0022432496771216393, -0.04613867402076721, -0.013034692034125328, -0.009481783956289291, 0.027978859841823578, -0.019946463406085968, 0.010557561181485653, -0.0023455515038222075, -0.010668656788766384, 0.009803597815334797, -0.024164767935872078, 0.07130375504493713, 0.11462057381868362, 0.04475509747862816, 0.0012635835446417332, 0.017704008147120476, 0.01801392063498497, 0.015477591194212437, -0.04654642194509506, 0.00808741245418787, 0.005828322842717171, -0.08535244315862656, -0.02997523732483387, 0.005232867784798145, -0.044091224670410156, -0.046756669878959656, -0.11273835599422455, -0.014926821924746037, -0.012327367439866066, 0.0068767559714615345, -0.033087003976106644, -0.006789790000766516, -0.020405780524015427, -0.04182422161102295, -0.0036975499242544174, -0.011389807797968388, -0.012926391325891018, 0.002723527606576681, -0.07015608996152878, 0.030957167968153954, 0.020516373217105865, 0.03773600235581398, 0.02446923218667507, -0.06479156762361526, -0.011239907704293728, -0.01513318158686161, 0.06444041430950165, -0.018062448129057884, -0.054794371128082275, 0.011088816449046135, 0.00963373202830553, -0.013843783177435398, -0.002094181952998042, -0.06306923180818558, 0.003229790134355426, 0.04515676572918892, -0.057529956102371216, -0.06911888718605042, -0.02896055392920971, 0.015018989332020283, 0.02499578148126602, -0.029935024678707123, -0.008458181284368038, -0.025405501946806908, 0.0140985157340765, -0.024105114862322807, -0.042710933834314346, 0.04650462418794632, -0.040177904069423676, 0.01350715383887291, -0.023259904235601425, -0.0037771202623844147, -0.0578623041510582, 0.001051444443874061, 0.0062729897908866405, -0.007575318217277527, 0.0009541760082356632, 0.004472857806831598, 0.0053848824463784695, -0.037712544202804565, 0.008860776200890541, 0.0929299145936966, -0.010465915314853191, -0.028292851522564888, 0.054660238325595856, 0.04281902313232422, 0.008135500364005566, 0.07053923606872559, -0.0032382654026150703, 0.023459943011403084, -0.03603499010205269, 0.025854740291833878, -0.014073245227336884, -0.04359477758407593, -0.0031007914803922176, 0.0226718932390213, -0.017672110348939896, -0.008489254862070084, -0.005279914475977421, -0.10481337457895279, 0.009496447630226612, 0.04943067952990532, -0.024589503183960915, -0.012098245322704315, 0.008271180093288422, -0.025484558194875717, -0.00789635069668293, -0.06888512521982193, 0.013212942518293858, 0.024366097524762154, -0.03874443098902702, -0.021927930414676666, 0.0025401650927960873, 0.04109565168619156, 0.0024870256893336773, -0.01208703126758337, 0.037960391491651535, -0.009423612616956234, 0.031631950289011, 0.001070102909579873, -0.055368926376104355, -0.02751271426677704, 0.02399512752890587, -0.030250689014792442, 0.034144699573516846, 0.017338616773486137, 0.003822724334895611, 0.019813168793916702, -0.00977505836635828, -0.014680339954793453, 0.07119321078062057, -0.013153072446584702, 0.008002628572285175, -0.005765440408140421, 0.023992586880922318, -0.05481889471411705, -0.05017174780368805, -0.02551867999136448, 0.027735598385334015, 0.052342165261507034, -0.0017583416774868965, 0.03588040545582771, 0.07977277785539627, 0.026309970766305923, -0.06426072865724564, 0.0008083086577244103, 0.05586090311408043, 0.0647551491856575, -0.03241398185491562, -0.022625993937253952, 0.028644565492868423, -0.06692639738321304, -0.007417865097522736, -0.010366018861532211, -0.022319436073303223, 0.05037756264209747, -0.0044762264005839825, -0.012847461737692356, -0.06294620037078857, 0.0025222022086381912, -0.03589567169547081, 0.03666117042303085, 0.03084486350417137, -0.00959210004657507, -0.007299912162125111, -0.002753508510068059, -0.038659777492284775, 0.020003383979201317, -0.06589973717927933, 0.021707989275455475, -0.037276849150657654, -0.03266733139753342, 0.023157352581620216, 0.0009063666802830994, 0.02369760163128376, -0.021810203790664673, -0.05295846238732338, 0.03332052007317543, 0.03680327907204628, -0.015490841120481491, -0.03200853243470192, -0.03442935273051262, -0.021485507488250732, -0.012738495133817196, -0.003128781681880355, 0.03165392205119133, 0.001493188552558422, -0.002569511067122221, 0.06404822319746017, 0.006769818719476461, 0.029384808614850044, 0.016403304412961006, -0.050081416964530945, -0.008650677278637886, -0.021662060171365738, -0.0017261393368244171, -0.05325044319033623, 0.04792742431163788, -0.013865822926163673, 0.03546444699168205, -0.004601337481290102, 0.006386136636137962, -0.021922452375292778, -0.005808813031762838, 0.009598009288311005, 0.02986701764166355, 0.023327190428972244, -0.014808706007897854, 0.0023317718878388405, -0.015958141535520554, -0.04772878810763359, -0.043666739016771317, 0.04297611117362976, -0.04320751503109932, 0.04995901137590408, 0.02521916665136814, -0.027787640690803528, 0.10575740784406662, -0.008504911325871944, 0.012901445850729942, -0.018180768936872482, -0.011915329843759537, 0.05009033530950546, 0.019991055130958557, 0.05807752162218094, 0.05344324931502342, 0.01662445440888405, -0.04431761056184769, -0.023916933685541153, 0.03677455708384514, -0.04587981477379799, -0.014764641411602497, 0.03514247015118599, 0.023046057671308517, 0.03092654049396515, 0.021596942096948624, 0.02467169612646103, 0.02910965122282505, -0.0021512992680072784, -0.04116959497332573, 0.019850190728902817, -0.051938243210315704, -0.04715787246823311, 0.00885572750121355, 0.02495238184928894, -0.004759124480187893, 0.02221738174557686, 0.0055274623446166515, 0.004160631913691759, 0.041848160326480865, 0.026889441534876823, -0.020141633227467537, -0.003564592683687806, -0.012562733143568039, 0.04949202388525009, 0.03459897264838219, 0.06604425609111786, 0.04655344784259796, -0.01342211477458477, 0.02467644028365612, -0.002461182652041316, -0.0431339330971241, 0.06647095829248428, 0.05649863928556442, 0.044156692922115326, -0.000594808894675225, -0.0010740729048848152, 0.0034794826060533524, -0.04892439395189285, 0.056366533041000366, -0.04799367114901543, -0.005592367611825466, -0.03766869008541107, 0.07571182399988174, 0.014268969185650349, 0.07227548211812973, 0.05969243496656418, 0.0928659737110138, 0.0876811072230339, 0.02371896617114544, -0.04839123785495758, -0.007538006640970707, 0.010904623195528984, 0.061284057796001434, -0.07333921641111374, 0.001820275792852044, -0.006320449523627758, -0.03478390350937843, -0.0040600658394396305, 0.02545369602739811, -0.03491877764463425, -0.09632457792758942, -0.05205635353922844, -0.018658127635717392, 0.03980468586087227, -0.011143624782562256, 0.017741970717906952, 0.003176366677507758, -0.0035927658900618553, -0.00869592186063528, 0.029576679691672325, -0.04608459398150444, 0.06866487860679626, -0.046538468450307846, -0.014261296018958092, 0.0319061279296875, -0.053489889949560165, 0.007999388501048088, -0.021811559796333313, 0.03049044869840145, -0.029201079159975052, 0.055300306528806686, 0.033519111573696136, -0.09148917347192764, 0.04041844606399536, 0.000012366363080218434, -0.03695772588253021, -0.03662602975964546, 0.005189410876482725, -0.009748930111527443, 0.015023555606603622, 0.009156148880720139, 0.02033929154276848, 0.01568794809281826, -0.046408962458372116, 0.03032061830163002, 0.015346205793321133, -0.01860862784087658, 0.03502481430768967, 0.042115915566682816, 0.03841421380639076, -0.010336082428693771, 0.027011999860405922, -0.05123768746852875, -0.01133634801954031, 0.07456962019205093, -0.027055716142058372, -0.017479751259088516, -0.06151949614286423, 0.028613615781068802, 0.0021623570937663317, 0.015937363728880882, 0.023282475769519806, 0.05963795259594917, -0.01577235572040081, -0.044001057744026184, 0.03177017718553543, -0.0003607391263358295, -0.04934362322092056, -0.04189152643084526, -0.020397454500198364, 0.03366977348923683, -0.010574066080152988, 0.008228901773691177, -0.02419712021946907, -0.027841923758387566, -0.03258826211094856, -0.018902553245425224, 0.016147421672940254, -0.007360260467976332, 0.020109394565224648, -0.07463908940553665, 0.02408471331000328, -0.010106933303177357, -0.048828668892383575, 0.011395538225769997, 0.037071287631988525, 0.013052675873041153, 0.017759958282113075, 0.056387756019830704, 0.030359258875250816, -0.013163735158741474, -0.0050664604641497135, -0.06685938686132431, 0.015809252858161926, -0.060651227831840515, 0.011279935017228127, 0.02432011440396309, 0.033929456025362015, -0.004191027954220772, 0.04911710321903229, 0.0702580139040947, -0.03474768251180649, -0.02192535251379013, -0.05486006289720535, -0.060784704983234406, -0.02519257180392742, 0.04218954220414162, 0.008903452195227146, 0.06976589560508728, -0.026783226057887077, 0.03845997527241707, 0.05746333673596382, -0.009442111477255821, 0.01674165204167366, 0.01794770359992981, 0.03397307172417641, -0.06382053345441818, 0.04096658527851105, -0.03314788639545441, 0.042311277240514755, 0.0022747560869902372, 0.06747199594974518, -0.020194070413708687, -0.03772057220339775, -0.020944638177752495, -0.016171010211110115, 0.038578473031520844, 0.018365683034062386, -0.018517516553401947, 0.025557877495884895, -0.04653910920023918, 0.010992392897605896, 0.047483235597610474, -0.02936532534658909, -0.05161739140748978, -0.005049735773354769, -0.0007244280423037708, 0.016406873241066933, 0.03224491328001022, 0.04158978909254074, -0.0627383217215538, -0.017534587532281876, 0.05713982507586479, -0.01608295552432537, -0.03829159215092659, 0.0037577319890260696, -0.02930997498333454, -0.03872491046786308, -0.026798559352755547, -0.02828226611018181, 0.00837724655866623, -0.0017170957289636135, -0.0067451996728777885, -0.031198611482977867, -0.004921471234411001, 0.02386462315917015, -0.02144361101090908, 0.01463569700717926, -0.0018917074194177985, 0.043340593576431274, -0.011681369505822659, 0.005067721474915743, 0.0555976927280426, 0.02683328650891781, 0.04854574427008629, 0.01627553626894951, 0.013154622167348862, 0.037666719406843185, 0.057663366198539734, -0.005356185603886843, -0.06258868426084518, 0.012145315296947956, -0.032726261764764786, -0.017319800332188606, 0.06308962404727936, -0.01617841236293316, 0.04519762471318245, -0.032466597855091095, -0.030620064586400986, 0.057076212018728256, 0.047754090279340744, 0.06254316121339798, 0.04689701274037361, -0.040870632976293564, -0.010566489771008492, -0.04830911010503769, -0.0061546205542981625, -0.028930051252245903, -0.007475422695279121, -0.06552071124315262, -0.005035653710365295, 0.008429709821939468, -0.012394469231367111, -0.044006191194057465, 0.039474327117204666, 0.04893376678228378, -0.03685339167714119, -0.03467576950788498, 0.031538624316453934, -0.008714986965060234, 0.04169353097677231, -0.0025044167414307594, 0.006982543505728245, 0.01937076449394226, -0.010321763344109058, -0.010045114904642105, 0.002201315714046359, -0.03213487192988396, -0.017287947237491608, -0.00021931769151706249, 0.007972427643835545, 0.004143697675317526, 0.011470875702798367, -0.024706648662686348, -0.031748756766319275, 0.031844958662986755, 0.004932285752147436, -0.024898599833250046, -0.03820965439081192, -0.06290165334939957, 0.035535428673028946, 0.01611086167395115, 0.06416795402765274, 0.0024417301174253225, -0.029361113905906677, -0.030663810670375824, 0.015306072309613228, -0.01636631041765213, -0.038394760340452194, 0.016985047608613968, -0.025545621290802956, -0.029268572106957436, 0.024066725745797157, 0.0228711050003767, 0.03009425289928913, 0.017379172146320343, -0.06178918108344078, -0.042618125677108765, -0.0295601524412632, -0.02934221178293228, -0.01829301379621029, -0.023698274046182632, 0.01162736676633358, -0.029824664816260338, -0.02254856750369072, 0.03842650726437569, -0.012442091479897499, -0.006700776517391205, 0.0051803006790578365, -0.0048242430202662945, -0.004466296639293432, -0.005143245682120323, 0.03116697072982788, 0.0535401776432991, -0.01753794401884079, 0.02188119664788246, 0.04228447005152702, 0.04802064970135689, -0.05735301971435547, 0.031046394258737564, 0.012839802540838718, 0.0015448115300387144, -0.02187071181833744, -0.02368263527750969, 0.010144364088773727, -0.046298008412122726, -0.03922075405716896, 0.05804147571325302, 0.0419088713824749, 0.050534605979919434, -0.03645135462284088, -0.013501763343811035, -0.023942183703184128, -0.02499370090663433, 0.013714227825403214, 0.01473382767289877, 0.017753681167960167, -0.019713573157787323, 0.007797576487064362, -0.0466410331428051, -0.04324214905500412, -0.04273422434926033, -0.04155588895082474, 0.018543165177106857, -0.019563114270567894, 0.06149643287062645, -0.006783701479434967, -0.027032842859625816, 0.037675533443689346, -0.03461425378918648, -0.022603698074817657, -0.04803317412734032, 0.008619430474936962, 0.032762669026851654, 0.048060979694128036, 0.010683905333280563, -0.00917014665901661, -0.020137200132012367, -0.15023694932460785, 0.01975007727742195, -0.022116409614682198, 0.0378977470099926, -0.06231090798974037, -0.01836240105330944, 0.02943430282175541, 0.09971056133508682, -0.03622626140713692, -0.06913592666387558, -0.06609384715557098, -0.08970417827367783, 0.03131870552897453, 0.05641483888030052, -0.05317189171910286, -0.02455267682671547, 0.008476008661091328, -0.05416939780116081, -0.02686491049826145, -0.05547333136200905, -0.011515382677316666, -0.042578231543302536, -0.04154433682560921, 0.0002375124313402921, 0.013991775922477245, -0.009589741006493568, 0.020851751789450645 ]
<p>I'm confused about the relation between the velocity expansion of a scattering cross section and the angular momentum (partial wave) expansion. For example, for dark matter annihilation, we write </p> <p>$\sigma v = \sigma_s + \sigma_p v^2 + \cdots$, </p> <p>where $v$ is the velocity and $\sigma_s$ corresponds to $s$-wave scattering (orbital angular momentum $\ell =0$) and $\sigma_p$ is the $p$-wave scattering ($\ell =1$). </p> <p><strong>Question:</strong>: why does the $v^{2\ell}$ term correspond to initial states in an $\ell$-wave configuration?</p> <hr> <p>I understand that in these calculations we treat the scattering states as plane waves, and that these can be expanded as a series of partial waves ($\ell$ eigenstates). And I can see that $\langle \mathbf x | E,\ell,m\rangle \sim j_\ell(kr) \sim k^\ell$. Is there more to this story?</p>
g7427
[ 0.06469184160232544, 0.030179869383573532, 0.005804192740470171, -0.013370740227401257, 0.04600720480084419, 0.0437176413834095, 0.01161456760019064, 0.027549201622605324, 0.008597965352237225, 0.02785305865108967, 0.014080774039030075, -0.03388773649930954, 0.01015466544777155, -0.007311589550226927, 0.0191730298101902, -0.040976185351610184, 0.03146374970674515, 0.002533314283937216, 0.03434517979621887, -0.0023520472459495068, -0.028552984818816185, 0.01236265804618597, -0.02323227748274803, -0.043238431215286255, 0.041419096291065216, -0.024913247674703598, -0.03438194841146469, -0.042614974081516266, -0.004368432331830263, -0.005718886852264404, 0.05783872306346893, 0.0010478352196514606, 0.050077009946107864, -0.010365985333919525, -0.03954041004180908, 0.038278356194496155, 0.03567748889327049, -0.023635122925043106, 0.005056013818830252, -0.011470459401607513, 0.03189209848642349, -0.07016849517822266, -0.008512722328305244, 0.012474884279072285, 0.011326697655022144, -0.00816722959280014, -0.06685537844896317, 0.013240141794085503, -0.023807784542441368, -0.03102685511112213, -0.05148463323712349, 0.03510606288909912, 0.074617400765419, 0.007055496796965599, 0.037677641957998276, 0.0623757466673851, -0.0278166513890028, -0.0009191969293169677, 0.03746650367975235, 0.01651419699192047, 0.07451754063367844, 0.0022542597725987434, 0.03985249251127243, -0.064168281853199, 0.037165045738220215, -0.049692701548337936, 0.01471522357314825, -0.008269422687590122, -0.017329823225736618, 0.0239663515239954, 0.010195954702794552, -0.05227111652493477, -0.031148120760917664, -0.05500930920243263, 0.0011510279728099704, 0.01202196441590786, -0.03425714746117592, -0.03765907883644104, 0.020207006484270096, -0.005436215084046125, -0.045414336025714874, -0.053316980600357056, -0.003012006636708975, -0.017708219587802887, 0.027129625901579857, -0.005483434069901705, 0.005974981468170881, 0.047567468136548996, -0.02560613863170147, 0.022867431864142418, -0.016407525166869164, -0.07828203588724136, 0.037576258182525635, -0.01222622487694025, -0.021279575303196907, -0.02149379998445511, -0.06406757980585098, 0.08463786542415619, 0.042486466467380524, 0.007933855056762695, 0.0011156299151480198, 0.011162486858665943, -0.003762149019166827, -0.001394318649545312, 0.06172012910246849, 0.060853276401758194, -0.03517386317253113, -0.027400566264986992, 0.011814980767667294, 0.014999200589954853, -0.08929558098316193, -0.023097766563296318, 0.018436511978507042, -0.04815077409148216, -0.05640573427081108, -0.016479916870594025, 0.013783060014247894, 0.027344251051545143, 0.029305605217814445, 0.0805899053812027, 0.03452455252408981, 0.0218167956918478, 0.029940465465188026, 0.08130801469087601, 0.0003833624650724232, -0.017479393631219864, -0.016106892377138138, 0.005826090462505817, 0.07396794110536575, -0.0005902911652810872, 0.0136100547388196, -0.03071395866572857, -0.0040324414148926735, 0.07872059941291809, 0.03626427426934242, -0.011129063554108143, -0.0031646499410271645, 0.0021090067457407713, -0.03997933492064476, -0.005681413691490889, -0.02106858231127262, -0.004652287345379591, -0.029599687084555626, 0.025643128901720047, -0.0008113292278721929, 0.0029774291906505823, -0.002798330970108509, -0.08857402205467224, 0.0020075952634215355, -0.015767039731144905, 0.009055894799530506, 0.02348911017179489, -0.009044735692441463, -0.03023386560380459, -0.017771048471331596, -0.007781460881233215, 0.10971613973379135, -0.04890470579266548, 0.015920989215373993, 0.017577853053808212, 0.0405438207089901, 0.013752434402704239, -0.0583275742828846, 0.031573086977005005, -0.04470907896757126, -0.0021818678360432386, 0.03121844306588173, -0.06155046075582504, -0.016964543610811234, -0.0502757802605629, 0.010841025970876217, 0.017800504341721535, 0.016820218414068222, 0.028246711939573288, -0.011527886614203453, 0.023695966228842735, 0.02660686895251274, -0.01698213256895542, 0.006250498350709677, -0.012330048717558384, -0.05085211619734764, 0.018601195886731148, -0.011486522853374481, 0.04966649413108826, 0.051039207726716995, -0.02818257361650467, 0.012778948992490768, 0.017497600987553596, -0.04857305437326431, -0.012537563219666481, 0.015658898279070854, -0.01193050853908062, 0.01540245208889246, 0.043276041746139526, 0.029427094385027885, -0.009012375958263874, 0.01952490396797657, -0.02058064565062523, -0.08625189960002899, 0.05840945988893509, -0.02388869598507881, 0.04501805827021599, -0.019102917984128, 0.028457093983888626, 0.04438546299934387, 0.04482824355363846, 0.007451713550835848, -0.01211091410368681, 0.046572115272283554, 0.05900707468390465, 0.010181751102209091, -0.013552555814385414, -0.007033147383481264, 0.002341540064662695, -0.03597284480929375, 0.029925646260380745, 0.007427597884088755, 0.03731226921081543, -0.037375494837760925, 0.044479306787252426, -0.06971196830272675, -0.05051206052303314, -0.05585060641169548, 0.021610552445054054, 0.006484754383563995, 0.07380016893148422, -0.013773096725344658, 0.01344861276447773, 0.004303950350731611, 0.0068855262361466885, -0.06076333671808243, 0.06334258615970612, -0.012838427908718586, 0.0032357522286474705, 0.02265133522450924, -0.016246281564235687, 0.010951357893645763, -0.013562636449933052, -0.026324721053242683, 0.0451439805328846, 0.022068463265895844, -0.01831510104238987, -0.01259696576744318, -0.030631758272647858, 0.07034707814455032, -0.0014317076420411468, 0.060515325516462326, -0.0052680750377476215, -0.04823165386915207, 0.017581956461071968, -0.04051216319203377, -0.03754813224077225, -0.025272808969020844, -0.007684336509555578, -0.0071996059268713, -0.024116359651088715, -0.07441646605730057, 0.061973687261343, -0.09132730215787888, 0.010311245918273926, -0.02412082999944687, 0.07878265529870987, -0.01717628724873066, 0.0015321007231250405, -0.06243328005075455, 0.021290026605129242, -0.019669463858008385, 0.02538287825882435, 0.04169268533587456, -0.025121692568063736, -0.04165582358837128, 0.05608775466680527, 0.0020713992416858673, 0.01711239479482174, 0.0023058338556438684, -0.03811439499258995, 0.020448368042707443, -0.036311715841293335, -0.022010687738656998, -0.0323919840157032, -0.04108060523867607, 0.02834470383822918, -0.04871897026896477, 0.013204637914896011, 0.04903169721364975, -0.09574563801288605, 0.07264769077301025, 0.0772457867860794, -0.061654336750507355, 0.0166595671325922, 0.005609384272247553, 0.04036705940961838, -0.0007909119594842196, 0.03188782185316086, 0.031805843114852905, 0.03719472512602806, 0.010516014881432056, -0.0742717981338501, 0.017229968681931496, 0.021653149276971817, -0.028942156583070755, -0.05703967809677124, -0.03319748863577843, 0.010242285206913948, 0.034111205488443375, 0.05066482722759247, -0.02901165373623371, 0.0030452637001872063, -0.03689415007829666, 0.04680361598730087, -0.00710431020706892, 0.034744907170534134, -0.004533936735242605, -0.02527162991464138, -0.03926446661353111, -0.010223268531262875, -0.012043142691254616, 0.007777125108987093, -0.039440449327230453, 0.02323923446238041, -0.016608407720923424, -0.05586434528231621, 0.02784433774650097, -0.01047638151794672, 0.05408734455704689, 0.002355828182771802, -0.07369332015514374, -0.0035710977390408516, -0.02165185660123825, -0.011739016510546207, -0.012438852339982986, 0.0006465911865234375, 0.026775987818837166, -0.001443037181161344, -0.01929211989045143, -0.02542727254331112, -0.03292293846607208, 0.05305100232362747, 0.017482060939073563, 0.005064170807600021, -0.001967820106074214, -0.02851264923810959, -0.07489920407533646, 0.0471748411655426, -0.004959979560226202, 0.007275954354554415, 0.0006956552970223129, 0.00839236844331026, -0.007670221850275993, -0.04079864174127579, -0.034171536564826965, 0.0994357168674469, 0.0007157635409384966, 0.014925173483788967, -0.02138826996088028, 0.012104694731533527, 0.04256582260131836, 0.015291967429220676, 0.026919245719909668, 0.015057099051773548, 0.017598554491996765, -0.02961367554962635, -0.012584932148456573, -0.003798591671511531, -0.007513497490435839, 0.013352709822356701, 0.007172964513301849, 0.006583481095731258, 0.018359297886490822, -0.007208045106381178, 0.014894461259245872, -0.0720481276512146, 0.00007278277189470828, 0.019277945160865784, -0.042415909469127655, -0.03685146942734718, -0.04258342459797859, 0.06513044238090515, -0.05649363622069359, 0.02954631857573986, 0.07799968868494034, 0.03711465373635292, 0.0005724795046262443, 0.10075456649065018, -0.027549978345632553, -0.016179783269762993, -0.08782036602497101, 0.0647878423333168, 0.018864717334508896, -0.020604752004146576, 0.07772520184516907, -0.04172641783952713, -0.040322888642549515, 0.008172736503183842, 0.08959703147411346, -0.05122137814760208, 0.022345172241330147, -0.041209299117326736, -0.039286211133003235, 0.041357267647981644, -0.04965151846408844, 0.012944216839969158, 0.0025276560336351395, -0.0016528370324522257, 0.009435835294425488, 0.05987333878874779, -0.025516178458929062, -0.03348758816719055, -0.00011151649232488126, -0.005660898983478546, -0.025103002786636353, 0.03912520036101341, -0.03635697439312935, -0.05037004500627518, -0.008282652124762535, 0.05519931763410568, 0.017488596960902214, -0.06462143361568451, -0.0627969354391098, 0.012290112674236298, 0.032222215086221695, 0.028933461755514145, 0.02468929998576641, 0.015464105643332005, -0.02047445811331272, 0.035473767668008804, 0.06896579265594482, -0.04071405157446861, 0.007873967289924622, -0.04794543609023094, 0.0036816373467445374, -0.0030154611449688673, 0.00413307873532176, 0.04288371279835701, -0.09438502788543701, 0.05141937732696533, -0.07262628525495529, 0.03899329900741577, 0.006187106017023325, 0.06289379298686981, 0.05547310784459114, -0.008868907578289509, -0.010695917531847954, 0.002209852449595928, 0.031573519110679626, -0.008190454915165901, -0.023319624364376068, -0.05620088800787926, 0.012460988014936447, -0.05252758413553238, -0.09955623000860214, 0.005506050307303667, 0.04624718055129051, -0.06820937991142273, -0.004624452907592058, 0.026467910036444664, -0.013135978020727634, 0.022180428728461266, -0.005091595463454723, 0.002574314596131444, -0.055276673287153244, 0.06696823239326477, 0.01529456302523613, -0.020191028714179993, 0.047397200018167496, -0.015012233518064022, 0.003461566986516118, -0.0017149591585621238, -0.09193798154592514, 0.0019413826521486044, 0.033125679939985275, -0.04249323159456253, 0.010555186308920383, -0.06366683542728424, 0.029425427317619324, 0.022597352042794228, -0.004725498612970114, -0.0011816533515229821, -0.0392029695212841, -0.05535171553492546, 0.0077957273460924625, -0.043564364314079285, 0.012368464842438698, -0.0077296034432947636, -0.008675891906023026, 0.03621137887239456, -0.005529133137315512, -0.02388034388422966, -0.021040543913841248, 0.016006197780370712, -0.00921614095568657, -0.02918361686170101, -0.07166613638401031, 0.014058684930205345, 0.03274638205766678, 0.059993017464876175, 0.030977200716733932, -0.05802072957158089, 0.0078087844885885715, 0.016292056068778038, -0.05271428823471069, -0.05156044289469719, 0.004805483855307102, 0.013293766416609287, -0.03516656905412674, 0.08315293490886688, 0.06438423693180084, -0.030991435050964355, 0.031546998769044876, -0.01267816498875618, 0.0662626177072525, 0.015167402103543282, -0.01918797940015793, -0.01472166646271944, -0.016525540500879288, -0.05446656793355942, -0.0018693441525101662, 0.03995955362915993, -0.03458740934729576, -0.007848619483411312, 0.0060388147830963135, 0.023587096482515335, 0.01988169550895691, 0.0012797811068594456, -0.011022387072443962, 0.004256740212440491, -0.03133389726281166, -0.025384072214365005, 0.02507234364748001, 0.06651664525270462, 0.030267909169197083, -0.009889650158584118, 0.04585113748908043, -0.002357437973842025, -0.023203587159514427, -0.08592832088470459, -0.056766632944345474, 0.0016335267573595047, 0.023204006254673004, -0.01632324606180191, -0.044415950775146484, -0.02035112865269184, -0.01249996293336153, 0.08283200860023499, -0.07736067473888397, 0.03607885167002678, 0.02514614164829254, -0.01866854354739189, -0.0045310938730835915, 0.005076783709228039, -0.07047498971223831, -0.04147336632013321, -0.028352344408631325, -0.02942010946571827, 0.007963393814861774, 0.025383470579981804, 0.005675822030752897, -0.016441473737359047, -0.04513692855834961, -0.039034176617860794, 0.01618381217122078, 0.02157684601843357, 0.03438402712345123, -0.023094724863767624, 0.024757061153650284, -0.02673535980284214, 0.0086041996255517, 0.017963116988539696, 0.009263160638511181, -0.006053222343325615, -0.03642360866069794, 0.03562059998512268, -0.02346234768629074, -0.04212699830532074, -0.011033397167921066, 0.031505733728408813, 0.04443834349513054, -0.03293050825595856, -0.021779054775834084, -0.004477900918573141, -0.00042241287883371115, 0.013026482425630093, 0.007104657590389252, 0.0414755642414093, -0.020745988935232162, -0.024500524625182152, -0.006569770164787769, -0.027900533750653267, 0.02944852225482464, 0.026725053787231445, -0.0696011334657669, 0.024483146145939827, 0.00415706867352128, 0.04190069064497948, -0.061836834996938705, 0.03505035489797592, 0.019084608182311058, 0.004955426789820194, -0.0007084807148203254, -0.006953619420528412, 0.10465151816606522, 0.04472111538052559, 0.040124718099832535, 0.04314910247921944, 0.05315874144434929, 0.030388500541448593, -0.017081495374441147, -0.022776151075959206, 0.008185873739421368, 0.0691482201218605, 0.013139892369508743, 0.01902824267745018, -0.009029222652316093, 0.016315018758177757, 0.009101076051592827, -0.004235762171447277, -0.03280964866280556, -0.0010786220664158463, 0.013904369436204433, -0.007015088573098183, 0.024036770686507225, -0.01151499804109335, 0.01902172714471817, 0.013873014599084854, 0.06391748040914536, 0.03638943284749985, -0.02160470373928547, -0.01574883423745632, 0.027226436883211136, -0.012690294533967972, 0.0444883368909359, 0.019750775769352913, 0.01266098115593195, 0.023142186924815178, -0.017497040331363678, 0.011913388967514038, -0.03224586695432663, 0.020696133375167847, 0.03648319095373154, 0.02161911129951477, 0.02869635447859764, 0.026393046602606773, -0.0056361248716712, -0.019673382863402367, -0.08121608942747116, -0.028882818296551704, 0.032590094953775406, -0.06835122406482697, -0.10031865537166595, -0.02786323055624962, -0.002058518584817648, -0.04152745380997658, -0.033972401171922684, -0.012992310337722301, -0.020027413964271545, -0.018416080623865128, -0.001466518733650446, -0.004724432714283466, -0.053159236907958984, 0.027267975732684135, -0.00851115956902504, -0.0066451458260416985, -0.03178303316235542, 0.008011294528841972, -0.0027817224618047476, -0.006262103095650673, 0.018925044685602188, -0.011814279481768608, 0.04752267152070999, -0.015341022983193398, 0.0032247488852590322, 0.02949015609920025, -0.05637302249670029, -0.011666807346045971, 0.037534620612859726, 0.01951388455927372, -0.022314386442303658, -0.03611568361520767, 0.002481405157595873, 0.005343387834727764, -0.019797982648015022, 0.041366901248693466, 0.004459624644368887, 0.04651371017098427, -0.023647358641028404, 0.0272520761936903, -0.021978847682476044, 0.04325731843709946, 0.01960057206451893, 0.014804485253989697, 0.027052272111177444, 0.016063684597611427, 0.0022466464433819056, 0.015002948231995106, 0.023293251171708107, 0.008546094410121441, 0.034670326858758926, 0.04553408548235893, -0.017473965883255005, -0.00212840735912323, 0.017901787534356117, -0.029403891414403915, 0.006250313483178616, 0.047369327396154404, 0.05239477381110191, -0.022764887660741806, 0.002072917763143778, -0.04050058498978615, -0.011035622097551823, -0.04217890277504921, -0.017209989950060844, -0.04037268087267876, 0.04507152736186981, -0.037580203264951706, -0.061522599309682846, 0.013996277004480362, 0.0767681896686554, 0.0049201068468391895, -0.01848522201180458, 0.030118783935904503, 0.016017107293009758, -0.0385238379240036, -0.006005506496876478, 0.006833550054579973, 0.029009679332375526, -0.012371500954031944, 0.018398283049464226, 0.03650876507163048, 0.03100285679101944, 0.03588481619954109, -0.018524741753935814, -0.008578958921134472, -0.016304858028888702, 0.02556094340980053, 0.002495501423254609, -0.005706125404685736, -0.007333814632147551, -0.08212673664093018, 0.01894468441605568, 0.04227679595351219, -0.05526430532336235, -0.07408322393894196, 0.009744221344590187, -0.03261791542172432, -0.0510028712451458, -0.05492030829191208, 0.027499765157699585, 0.014901561662554741, 0.04497652128338814, -0.012968817725777626, 0.013668357394635677, -0.0005684535135515034, 0.015116352587938309, 0.06361774355173111, -0.02432943508028984, -0.004565661773085594, 0.010253612883388996, 0.0015302386600524187, 0.002511255443096161, 0.009376246482133865, 0.01270210836082697, 0.03308750316500664, 0.005179821979254484, -0.033318813890218735, 0.022667912766337395, -0.08988910168409348, -0.07095737010240555, -0.026321865618228912 ]
<p>The system is as follows -</p> <p><img src="http://i.imgur.com/9hwHHIh.png" alt=""></p> <p>Friction exists only between the 2 blocks.</p> <p>I am trying to find out the accelerations of $m_1$ and $m_2$.</p> <p>Let $a_2$ be acceleration of $m_2$, and $a_x$ and $a_y$ be the accelerations of $m_1$ in the respective directions. Let $R$ be the normal reaction between the 2 blocks, and $N$ be the normal reaction between $m_2$ and floor. Balancing components across the axes, I get the following equations - $$N = m_2g + R\cos\theta \tag{1}$$ $$m_2a_2 = R\sin\theta \tag{2}$$ $$a_x = R(\sin\theta + \mu_s\cos\theta) \tag{3}$$ $$a_y = R(\cos\theta + \mu_s\sin\theta) – m_1g \tag{4}$$</p> <p>I don’t think $(1)$ is necessary, since friction is not involved between the blocks and the ground. Leaving that aside, I have 3 equations in 4 variables: $a_x, a_y, a_2, R$.</p> <p>Is there are any way I could perhaps get a 4th equation so that the system of equations could be solved? I can get $|a_1|$ in terms of $R$ from the expressions for $a_x$ and $a_y$, but I don’t think that would help.</p>
g7428
[ 0.07170950621366501, 0.06019952893257141, -0.01986577734351158, 0.02550746127963066, 0.024644317105412483, -0.012421521358191967, 0.07803631573915482, -0.0001099401488318108, -0.011594295501708984, -0.018190477043390274, -0.018750185146927834, 0.014278006739914417, -0.04827621579170227, 0.06112963333725929, 0.024343233555555344, 0.02143535017967224, 0.03610768914222717, -0.021492158994078636, -0.01943393424153328, 0.011183599941432476, -0.007008024957031012, -0.01978905312716961, -0.04364514350891113, -0.008709417656064034, 0.047540467232465744, -0.008106243796646595, -0.05184417590498924, -0.02481682412326336, -0.05434705689549446, 0.010230270214378834, -0.016969161108136177, 0.006069229915738106, -0.011596203781664371, -0.046398576349020004, -0.03185945376753807, 0.007721224799752235, 0.044698525220155716, 0.0015159378526732326, -0.015371936373412609, -0.012620546855032444, -0.009320606477558613, -0.0645366907119751, 0.011905387975275517, 0.004263703711330891, -0.001344831078313291, -0.021188989281654358, -0.017306992784142494, 0.012206176295876503, -0.04397188872098923, 0.04937402904033661, -0.02426104061305523, 0.02655685693025589, 0.03689185902476311, 0.012718472629785538, -0.05787816271185875, 0.03713829070329666, 0.06515587866306305, -0.045511700212955475, 0.006115705706179142, 0.050026148557662964, -0.04865148290991783, -0.08241227269172668, 0.02874676138162613, -0.06033405289053917, 0.09142155200242996, -0.004709069617092609, -0.006023806519806385, 0.0297053474932909, 0.03377530723810196, -0.020803648978471756, 0.03673991188406944, -0.00854345504194498, 0.0418587364256382, 0.030923286452889442, -0.04837821424007416, -0.015170839615166187, 0.04689183831214905, 0.017187120392918587, 0.008135446347296238, 0.047118183225393295, -0.011403009295463562, 0.08239324390888214, 0.015674129128456116, 0.014458846300840378, 0.022429751232266426, 0.022854631766676903, 0.05638826638460159, 0.028075238689780235, -0.09287843853235245, -0.019324230030179024, 0.03125707805156708, 0.018764114007353783, 0.0471000149846077, 0.012000784277915955, -0.022123828530311584, 0.016207082197070122, -0.0319899320602417, 0.05188685283064842, 0.02166772447526455, 0.024276692420244217, -0.0182146355509758, 0.02606121078133583, 0.004946478642523289, -0.007329857908189297, 0.06674796342849731, -0.06227882206439972, 0.04787649214267731, 0.013919117860496044, 0.020070340484380722, -0.01745380274951458, -0.001995025435462594, -0.03868594765663147, -0.033012498170137405, -0.05021488294005394, 0.04514443129301071, -0.051258210092782974, 0.03165031224489212, 0.0597291961312294, -0.006895073223859072, 0.038019996136426926, -0.023052504286170006, 0.04605838656425476, -0.04732063412666321, 0.03272609785199165, 0.010808946564793587, -0.017596257850527763, 0.020964985713362694, -0.01717267744243145, 0.023762235417962074, 0.015600910410284996, 0.00819692574441433, 0.01437112595885992, 0.07544276863336563, -0.01197975967079401, -0.011461020447313786, 0.040198054164648056, -0.008424308151006699, 0.04053318500518799, -0.03377698361873627, -0.009388514794409275, -0.01553255319595337, -0.012212364003062248, -0.015389468520879745, 0.011671336367726326, -0.058049872517585754, 0.01451026275753975, 0.01793384924530983, -0.0026608326006680727, 0.030897794291377068, 0.003290457185357809, -0.016412779688835144, 0.08871589601039886, -0.013056703843176365, 0.01415246818214655, 0.04541056230664253, 0.02170950174331665, -0.046551622450351715, -0.032220665365457535, -0.013817088678479195, 0.004014230333268642, 0.015924159437417984, -0.056320421397686005, 0.02735121361911297, -0.026122352108359337, -0.06724796444177628, -0.018121378496289253, -0.01271099504083395, -0.0008686826913617551, 0.03618471324443817, -0.019348813220858574, -0.0462731197476387, -0.019367389380931854, 0.009813252836465836, 0.037821657955646515, -0.031466588377952576, 0.035248953849077225, 0.03020784631371498, -0.021730519831180573, -0.005815594457089901, -0.0010368232615292072, 0.03070186823606491, -0.03008124604821205, 0.04315248876810074, 0.049435533583164215, 0.03286142274737358, -0.03267255425453186, 0.05387071520090103, 0.08480709791183472, -0.07424589991569519, -0.0020043670665472746, -0.004812633153051138, -0.013720872811973095, 0.011593323200941086, -0.00495156878605485, -0.03962768241763115, 0.04665640741586685, -0.0008001045789569616, -0.02173522673547268, 0.010657289065420628, 0.040231168270111084, -0.014699115417897701, 0.03316522762179375, 0.00317937764339149, -0.031560927629470825, 0.05335274711251259, 0.024360446259379387, 0.0029539738316088915, -0.02993812784552574, -0.009738938882946968, -0.018650392070412636, -0.03874846547842026, 0.008178481832146645, -0.043267253786325455, 0.0380830243229866, 0.0035440055653452873, -0.09121664613485336, 0.05166350305080414, -0.018717002123594284, 0.005093665327876806, 0.009698095731437206, -0.010594162158668041, -0.051232222467660904, -0.016497449949383736, -0.0420481339097023, -0.03615278750658035, -0.016397902742028236, 0.021833710372447968, -0.040343496948480606, -0.030383970588445663, 0.0022052598651498556, -0.05312502384185791, -0.015344038605690002, 0.011491727083921432, -0.037816815078258514, 0.00786325428634882, 0.012442917563021183, -0.022538673132658005, 0.005695871077477932, 0.02921144664287567, 0.06891047209501266, 0.008608301170170307, 0.017046019434928894, 0.006819481495767832, -0.011614480055868626, 0.06289460510015488, -0.026153139770030975, 0.09472810477018356, 0.039872828871011734, -0.0051866089925169945, 0.014925201423466206, -0.017524851486086845, -0.006212977226823568, -0.06498727947473526, -0.06470854580402374, -0.012364605441689491, -0.013556370511651039, -0.037552639842033386, -0.022632097825407982, 0.05192742124199867, -0.05787166953086853, -0.03688748925924301, 0.017015840858221054, -0.008478928357362747, 0.07587996870279312, -0.06939908117055893, -0.011618034914135933, -0.024085693061351776, -0.10563582181930542, -0.008797572925686836, 0.03761807829141617, -0.06705548614263535, -0.03737206012010574, -0.025137869641184807, 0.08765606582164764, -0.05055074021220207, -0.03170279413461685, 0.031048715114593506, -0.056942299008369446, -0.02319098450243473, 0.04781174659729004, 0.014321197755634785, -0.012289687059819698, 0.06033392623066902, -0.00890247244387865, 0.01481130812317133, 0.007956014946103096, 0.014303820207715034, 0.026397421956062317, -0.009268643334507942, 0.0477185919880867, -0.05024394765496254, 0.0019111055880784988, 0.06467224657535553, -0.014875917695462704, 0.002311862539499998, 0.04993290454149246, -0.021785061806440353, -0.0665731430053711, -0.023210622370243073, 0.044808823615312576, 0.02653452381491661, -0.05570359528064728, 0.001627205521799624, 0.03956686705350876, -0.04436361789703369, -0.04946679621934891, -0.031204720959067345, -0.019252099096775055, 0.04453933238983154, 0.008184708654880524, -0.009768443182110786, -0.037187572568655014, 0.032738372683525085, -0.02878458984196186, -0.03756491467356682, -0.020782344043254852, 0.030829142779111862, -0.0073105692863464355, 0.05158909037709236, 0.0011400794610381126, -0.09530144184827805, -0.0697343647480011, 0.012888910248875618, 0.02174081839621067, -0.008062954060733318, -0.004138610325753689, -0.050725340843200684, 0.02019570767879486, -0.06997603923082352, -0.017369579523801804, 0.009514277800917625, 0.02446191944181919, 0.010195312090218067, -0.0017263642512261868, -0.014637415297329426, -0.07343462109565735, 0.00662277452647686, -0.015259246341884136, 0.020453285425901413, -0.02282082848250866, -0.03134835138916969, -0.038056667894124985, -0.027104796841740608, -0.05144999548792839, -0.017193911597132683, -0.006306258495897055, -0.01170111633837223, 0.07483948767185211, -0.004924795124679804, -0.044264018535614014, 0.06323719024658203, -0.028792548924684525, 0.04947575554251671, 0.00005965816308162175, -0.0042507038451731205, 0.04207716882228851, -0.01281709410250187, 0.025516396388411522, -0.04462723433971405, 0.02073497138917446, -0.022913292050361633, -0.025930678471922874, -0.03506982699036598, 0.017152173444628716, 0.03340490534901619, 0.020178861916065216, -0.039431020617485046, 0.04834027588367462, -0.03458178788423538, -0.05594258010387421, 0.041448164731264114, -0.022889913991093636, 0.022863831371068954, -0.09335142374038696, 0.04572983458638191, -0.06419894099235535, -0.02082877606153488, 0.007503112778067589, -0.039065275341272354, 0.05216920003294945, 0.02166787162423134, -0.002344967797398567, -0.009207235649228096, 0.024308787658810616, 0.0186271034181118, 0.03216955438256264, -0.004681087564677, 0.0405765026807785, -0.03181726485490799, -0.019665740430355072, 0.037909671664237976, 0.0037822292651981115, -0.07089291512966156, 0.009374781511723995, 0.02192092314362526, -0.07456260174512863, 0.016959164291620255, 0.006571374833583832, -0.07989523559808731, 0.020086999982595444, -0.029393218457698822, 0.014928987249732018, -0.01753961108624935, 0.007422368507832289, -0.05588151887059212, -0.007662140764296055, -0.00010668662434909493, 0.017966732382774353, 0.03485799953341484, 0.053117282688617706, -0.0024526233319193125, -0.030782276764512062, 0.01773667335510254, -0.003438831539824605, 0.01357423048466444, -0.01406764890998602, 0.0023774346336722374, 0.0028725811280310154, -0.0031234354246407747, -0.04945029318332672, 0.008766691200435162, 0.05482848733663559, 0.0026379339396953583, -0.02224203571677208, 0.04001621529459953, -0.0049151210114359856, 0.009858458302915096, 0.042084239423274994, 0.016406340524554253, 0.0058031026273965836, -0.027773872017860413, 0.005820658523589373, -0.0438292920589447, 0.007501319516450167, -0.05384860187768936, 0.03964954614639282, -0.07114677876234055, 0.010125898756086826, 0.009142824448645115, 0.031873010098934174, 0.00436639878898859, 0.04346732050180435, 0.01278320886194706, -0.007807380985468626, -0.0055643003433942795, 0.05797968804836273, 0.03606240451335907, -0.0032665703911334276, -0.014233171939849854, -0.04449142515659332, -0.019853178411722183, -0.017944442108273506, 0.011174286715686321, -0.019024480134248734, 0.01368179451674223, 0.010400360450148582, 0.033838462084531784, 0.010949643328785896, 0.016503579914569855, 0.06862872838973999, 0.04352986440062523, -0.024976486340165138, 0.000553774880245328, -0.018786553293466568, -0.0024217632599174976, -0.01940387859940529, -0.04395730048418045, 0.0543370246887207, -0.05651329085230827, -0.021085375919938087, 0.04206158593297005, -0.023774603381752968, -0.039160698652267456, 0.01235179603099823, 0.021554937586188316, 0.04025610163807869, -0.014799006283283234, 0.052827972918748856, 0.026834627613425255, 0.024135205894708633, -0.003436520928516984, -0.0017003575339913368, -0.014386998489499092, 0.015152983367443085, 0.015231912955641747, -0.002906887559220195, -0.018473898991942406, -0.0458645261824131, 0.04500426724553108, 0.019355392083525658, -0.012220149859786034, 0.02770521119236946, -0.038973238319158554, -0.04328564926981926, -0.0035212829243391752, 0.03125550225377083, -0.028126219287514687, -0.0956788882613182, -0.022038288414478302, 0.015516489744186401, -0.04517801105976105, 0.012698972597718239, -0.003391655394807458, 0.025652827695012093, 0.001993837533518672, 0.012704224325716496, 0.024910487234592438, -0.016573093831539154, 0.01864495314657688, 0.07724876701831818, -0.0012810451444238424, 0.011133532971143723, 0.10055644065141678, 0.045199256390333176, -0.04133337363600731, 0.016805019229650497, 0.03517753258347511, 0.026653245091438293, -0.026115376502275467, -0.08602766692638397, 0.025348415598273277, -0.035221002995967865, 0.0330745093524456, -0.03351748362183571, 0.020555727183818817, 0.057505618780851364, -0.02295168675482273, -0.024422112852334976, -0.0022488366812467575, 0.00530201056972146, -0.02811116725206375, -0.04717661812901497, -0.03024643287062645, -0.012334415689110756, 0.016113879159092903, -0.046411532908678055, -0.013599775731563568, -0.03303682059049606, 0.010426121763885021, -0.04975887015461922, -0.09506679326295853, -0.048574019223451614, 0.03174695745110512, 0.022947683930397034, -0.018293147906661034, 0.012043452821671963, -0.0814465656876564, -0.006727660074830055, 0.0455811582505703, -0.010926196351647377, -0.027162477374076843, -0.0032188394106924534, 0.0158743467181921, -0.003831644542515278, -0.02026933990418911, 0.03733276203274727, -0.03174441307783127, 0.012383708730340004, 0.0017284327186644077, -0.01078200526535511, 0.04859885200858116, -0.041345879435539246, 0.05324914678931236, 0.03724135085940361, -0.06762896478176117, 0.0175599567592144, -0.025949791073799133, 0.021191010251641273, 0.036642443388700485, -0.003429155331104994, 0.04274053871631622, 0.006440078839659691, -0.024567943066358566, 0.06628593802452087, 0.0931314006447792, 0.015599432401359081, -0.022521626204252243, -0.0014974521473050117, -0.031143320724368095, 0.08675066381692886, -0.03654418885707855, 0.00731847295537591, -0.04736234247684479, -0.009375493042171001, -0.021523579955101013, -0.04062030464410782, -0.008605443872511387, -0.027530523017048836, 0.02098810486495495, -0.10288974642753601, -0.03141523897647858, 0.006107522174715996, -0.03598708659410477, 0.00011345675011398271, -0.004117556847631931, -0.037602026015520096, -0.02311541698873043, 0.044363297522068024, -0.006079411134123802, 0.018255915492773056, 0.06462372094392776, -0.017432400956749916, 0.06240684539079666, -0.007952135056257248, 0.03031208924949169, -0.030353549867868423, -0.050160542130470276, -0.00321313738822937, -0.014563682489097118, 0.01107573602348566, 0.002371015725657344, 0.05061060190200806, 0.01581689529120922, 0.06863882392644882, 0.02130299247801304, -0.004906217101961374, 0.01204343419522047, -0.0045048934407532215, 0.006136039737612009, -0.024537455290555954, 0.045648977160453796, -0.008422181941568851, -0.04049456864595413, -0.045294031500816345, 0.00007677858957322314, -0.04940212517976761, -0.02012835629284382, -0.012909947894513607, 0.01428801380097866, 0.033032920211553574, 0.04845503717660904, -0.0043257055804133415, -0.03510671108961105, -0.02886621095240116, 0.05947525426745415, 0.04057730361819267, -0.040431614965200424, 0.007219305727630854, -0.02118213288486004, 0.043495096266269684, 0.007786957081407309, 0.03399081900715828, -0.015340588986873627, 0.04934479296207428, -0.011115912348031998, -0.003061980241909623, 0.0417073592543602, 0.015320134349167347, -0.028221964836120605, 0.010269301012158394, 0.039284732192754745, -0.0030643704812973738, 0.0066867549903690815, 0.028649693354964256, -0.028073403984308243, -0.010839177295565605, 0.01578846015036106, 0.04334942251443863, 0.034139834344387054, 0.026033692061901093, -0.020367899909615517, -0.053124550729990005, 0.026703640818595886, 0.05734700337052345, -0.0017832599114626646, 0.04821086674928665, 0.002631797455251217, 0.06001812592148781, 0.0401141531765461, 0.014783558435738087, -0.013545791618525982, -0.01809796877205372, -0.028642021119594574, 0.07720021158456802, -0.016909373924136162, 0.048693958669900894, 0.08714742958545685, -0.01052003912627697, 0.04116912931203842, -0.021311482414603233, 0.0008908988093025982, -0.012052517384290695, -0.06361569464206696, 0.018234405666589737, 0.014971735887229443, 0.03473111242055893, 0.04388761892914772, 0.003962421324104071, -0.005482624750584364, 0.025291206315159798, -0.02734493650496006, 0.062749944627285, 0.023959705606102943, -0.022412557154893875, -0.006295820232480764, 0.059798095375299454, -0.005153318401426077, 0.040130339562892914, -0.04387420415878296, -0.05090084671974182, 0.00608314061537385, -0.0356416292488575, 0.02375749684870243, 0.020957760512828827, -0.015926960855722427, -0.02585742063820362, 0.009853930212557316, -0.018389664590358734, -0.008551722392439842, -0.012688368558883667, -0.00791637971997261, 0.05394091457128525, -0.020215725526213646, -0.013939100317656994, 0.009019069373607635, 0.050542816519737244, -0.005906062666326761, 0.01415630429983139, 0.02944144606590271, 0.009114455431699753, -0.07969100773334503, -0.03481888398528099, -0.022070903331041336, -0.08950264006853104, 0.017606250941753387, -0.07176573574542999, -0.019215978682041168, -0.049460720270872116, 0.020740896463394165, 0.0050580441020429134, 0.02214241400361061, -0.038963433355093, 0.011022605001926422, 0.044642653316259384, 0.01860090345144272, -0.019775699824094772, -0.00808250904083252, -0.09114796668291092, -0.03833998739719391, 0.02990276925265789, -0.056629281491041183, -0.07553071528673172, -0.017912160605192184, 0.02676345780491829, 0.012934300117194653, 0.0167011097073555, 0.013366862200200558, 0.08864940702915192, 0.040775272995233536, -0.029424753040075302, 0.049859870225191116, 0.034732885658741, -0.04168563336133957, 0.02948530949652195, 0.01769794151186943, -0.019529135897755623, -0.024606864899396896, 0.03508877754211426, -0.03724237158894539, 0.012784300372004509, -0.01593666337430477, 0.04826982319355011, -0.05827557295560837, -0.05827464163303375, -0.002605672460049391, -0.059374887496232986, -0.03498897701501846, 0.002594373421743512 ]
<p>Given an alcohol solution and a mass of ice in whatever shape you like, is shaping it into a sphere the worst possible way to cool your drink without diluting it?</p> <p>If the ice starts off at a sub-zero temperature, it is able to cool the drink without diluting it by first warming to 0 °C. After the periphery of the ice hits the melting point, it then waters down the drink in order to absorb more heat. However, if the conduction isn't perfect within the ice, melting could occur before the whole ice cube hits 0 °C, which seems sub-optimal.</p> <p>I don't know if because it's not just water that's being cooled the thermo changes, or if there's some other important effect I'm neglecting</p> <p>More important factors are probably the insulating properties of the container and ice, but all things equal, are all <a href="http://www.thewhiskeyball.com/" rel="nofollow">those</a> <a href="http://www.iceballmaker.com/" rel="nofollow">ice-ball</a> <a href="http://www.cirrusproducts.com/collections/ice-ball/products/2-75-cirrus-press" rel="nofollow">claims</a> categorically wrong?</p>
g7429
[ 0.028182152658700943, 0.009531555697321892, 0.02513183280825615, 0.04289262369275093, 0.02590426616370678, -0.0269602183252573, 0.04597296565771103, 0.043854985386133194, -0.029231620952486992, -0.00031802779994904995, -0.021117551252245903, 0.012563432566821575, 0.051643166691064835, 0.019737515598535538, -0.02325243502855301, -0.005705490708351135, -0.019608240574598312, -0.060807328671216965, 0.013327369466423988, 0.09664458781480789, -0.0024699801579117775, -0.0749097466468811, 0.06320922821760178, -0.008501807227730751, -0.077395960688591, -0.04741310700774193, 0.009404339827597141, 0.02925897017121315, -0.05769023671746254, 0.021406562998890877, 0.004092365503311157, 0.03733302280306816, -0.03197077289223671, 0.025086184963583946, 0.012616663239896297, 0.014003019779920578, 0.02354401722550392, 0.038319747895002365, -0.05227414518594742, -0.07979792356491089, -0.020432986319065094, 0.009496147744357586, 0.05829894542694092, 0.005751807242631912, 0.01545027643442154, 0.043691281229257584, 0.05444199964404106, 0.07324725389480591, -0.08308690041303635, 0.019133461639285088, 0.04173703491687775, -0.014199521392583847, 0.004643332213163376, -0.0005993795930407941, -0.03568552806973457, 0.038893286138772964, 0.0012987492373213172, 0.018245141953229904, -0.03421751782298088, -0.011112377978861332, 0.023403063416481018, -0.03246215358376503, -0.05827193707227707, 0.018899617716670036, 0.025389064103364944, -0.011650371365249157, -0.06367538869380951, 0.016003159806132317, 0.039136581122875214, 0.051649484783411026, 0.022164028137922287, -0.014835942536592484, -0.025271868333220482, -0.05875033140182495, -0.05002012103796005, 0.008464418351650238, 0.006056820508092642, -0.024463849142193794, 0.07441484183073044, -0.004433649592101574, -0.01601598784327507, -0.001006374484859407, 0.031934529542922974, -0.029733357951045036, 0.08857841789722443, 0.006618584971874952, -0.00042743212543427944, -0.03824213147163391, 0.006132971495389938, 0.052963897585868835, -0.04407766833901405, -0.0009306352585554123, 0.06746451556682587, -0.01580163836479187, -0.006265861447900534, -0.0008028849842958152, 0.01740344613790512, 0.00071898871101439, -0.01976902037858963, 0.060729045420885086, -0.007566859479993582, 0.004068595357239246, 0.0050877793692052364, 0.028484106063842773, -0.057892393320798874, 0.01222251821309328, 0.04327467083930969, 0.008975588716566563, 0.021298382431268692, -0.020012719556689262, -0.038444191217422485, -0.028128357604146004, -0.01962275430560112, 0.009661528281867504, -0.05687398090958595, 0.014410130679607391, 0.02286161668598652, 0.10003914684057236, -0.016675041988492012, 0.018137678503990173, 0.046483445912599564, 0.05717438459396362, -0.006837477441877127, 0.0667085275053978, -0.0059714410454034805, 0.054442696273326874, 0.007631584070622921, 0.05116335302591324, -0.029304875060915947, -0.059781644493341446, -0.041319720447063446, 0.04825148358941078, -0.04920834302902222, -0.06184013932943344, -0.02916712686419487, 0.09789672493934631, -0.05325274541974068, 0.012067080475389957, -0.01866063103079796, -0.013568704947829247, 0.016121620312333107, 0.026104029268026352, 0.03045349381864071, -0.03696165606379509, -0.03071438893675804, 0.010931724682450294, -0.019081654027104378, -0.05173150822520256, 0.017485735937952995, 0.025441132485866547, -0.053471025079488754, -0.011779747903347015, 0.10633517056703568, -0.03727651387453079, -0.0030532923992723227, 0.04604506865143776, 0.03435343876481056, -0.07009134441614151, 0.06487932056188583, 0.004271029029041529, 0.021848373115062714, -0.042820535600185394, 0.009936506859958172, -0.009473958984017372, -0.0679011270403862, 0.021705640479922295, -0.019538598135113716, 0.012693054042756557, -0.02116173878312111, -0.03240752965211868, -0.07518409192562103, 0.01667599193751812, -0.005375796463340521, 0.07830576598644257, 0.05360076203942299, -0.0006395853124558926, 0.05295165628194809, -0.021438181400299072, -0.04029318690299988, 0.003342938842251897, -0.02409227006137371, 0.03452124074101448, -0.07199982553720474, -0.05541184917092323, 0.00243171863257885, -0.023188145831227303, 0.06561964750289917, 0.0323532372713089, 0.010551925748586655, 0.01658620499074459, 0.03769061714410782, -0.05376087874174118, -0.03713164106011391, 0.010948405601084232, 0.002702240599319339, 0.016924096271395683, 0.06238683685660362, 0.00009003140439745039, -0.058833975344896317, 0.047127772122621536, -0.011328956112265587, -0.025169821456074715, -0.014936016872525215, 0.0274434182792902, -0.04966999217867851, 0.022398941218852997, -0.010251698084175587, 0.022061198949813843, 0.009467286989092827, 0.01665385626256466, 0.052013956010341644, 0.029409922659397125, 0.000606958637945354, -0.016403844580054283, -0.013005225919187069, 0.026507124304771423, 0.00997562799602747, 0.01811203360557556, -0.04376077279448509, 0.05884353816509247, -0.026759186759591103, 0.03735429793596268, -0.049267131835222244, -0.012468407861888409, -0.04064984992146492, -0.048043135553598404, -0.045599617063999176, 0.02775205671787262, -0.014155331067740917, -0.0020800840575248003, -0.039215728640556335, -0.07269647717475891, 0.04982161521911621, -0.051628343760967255, 0.010532795451581478, 0.02151089534163475, -0.021494658663868904, 0.006252626422792673, 0.029357170686125755, -0.0026358417235314846, -0.015075975097715855, -0.007525769528001547, -0.055229995399713516, -0.031294796615839005, 0.02861473709344864, -0.05567549169063568, -0.023967120796442032, -0.022314373403787613, 0.025447720661759377, 0.008307324722409248, 0.018885448575019836, 0.03690129891037941, -0.028135228902101517, -0.03578566387295723, 0.012730054557323456, -0.0336526483297348, -0.023622190579771996, 0.0463971346616745, -0.016374528408050537, -0.00043758918764069676, -0.0077088139951229095, -0.06152021139860153, -0.024494441226124763, -0.02906298078596592, -0.027402382344007492, -0.04065754637122154, -0.08757580816745758, -0.01774338260293007, 0.048314355313777924, 0.07351716607809067, -0.05749998614192009, 0.04311405494809151, 0.0021190594416111708, 0.07286497205495834, 0.0004396073054522276, -0.009451417252421379, -0.04534913972020149, 0.02727680280804634, 0.03374776244163513, -0.021902384236454964, 0.05346851423382759, 0.01208541076630354, -0.09859806299209595, -0.03405419737100601, 0.020604416728019714, -0.003784333588555455, -0.054352156817913055, 0.02599647082388401, -0.03163071349263191, -0.08231788128614426, 0.00020836861222051084, 0.05009022355079651, 0.07219644635915756, -0.022639315575361252, 0.03605223074555397, 0.0209234356880188, 0.022553959861397743, 0.0016157275531440973, -0.012955483980476856, 0.011107116937637329, -0.011881598271429539, 0.059764016419649124, -0.054906535893678665, 0.020272228866815567, 0.035660065710544586, 0.0461224801838398, -0.05451749637722969, -0.04347866773605347, 0.007271152455359697, 0.01849297247827053, 0.022785097360610962, 0.018415290862321854, -0.018117528408765793, 0.043230459094047546, -0.0029680689331144094, -0.017147911712527275, -0.021758094429969788, 0.03154641389846802, 0.07600519061088562, -0.04249997064471245, -0.019153257831931114, 0.04283155873417854, 0.00859200581908226, 0.020689861848950386, 0.033290982246398926, 0.047712042927742004, 0.05206167325377464, -0.007690952159464359, -0.0307405237108469, 0.03798083961009979, 0.01627884991466999, 0.0034237599465996027, -0.049451664090156555, -0.051513589918613434, -0.02468227595090866, -0.03465302661061287, -0.022541893646121025, 0.0002565620234236121, 0.04323280602693558, 0.05369456112384796, 0.005962824448943138, -0.07045167684555054, 0.0058760796673595905, 0.022809652611613274, -0.013028789311647415, -0.007884734310209751, -0.04787218198180199, -0.0206233449280262, 0.0014369346899911761, 0.007287630345672369, 0.04458273947238922, -0.008007694967091084, -0.06555597484111786, 0.023849206045269966, -0.019847337156534195, 0.015470607206225395, -0.00791923888027668, 0.05207955092191696, -0.029961680993437767, 0.031119899824261665, 0.010900215245783329, 0.013839896768331528, 0.04422052577137947, 0.0023118050303310156, 0.007968945428729057, 0.06690288335084915, -0.00393980136141181, -0.03287384659051895, -0.054168641567230225, 0.054918285459280014, -0.010897173546254635, -0.039765581488609314, -0.03850880265235901, -0.013017009012401104, 0.04225226864218712, 0.042914971709251404, -0.012549933046102524, 0.07873524725437164, -0.06396374851465225, -0.006934886798262596, 0.00836669560521841, -0.01873297616839409, 0.003276352072134614, -0.005692676175385714, -0.048469703644514084, 0.04451889917254448, -0.015218228101730347, -0.07303248345851898, 0.0037140301428735256, 0.013337149284780025, -0.07309538871049881, 0.05109032243490219, 0.0604982003569603, 0.04961976408958435, -0.00249785790219903, 0.04219445958733559, -0.005060915369540453, -0.05818864330649376, -0.06229838356375694, 0.011966105550527573, 0.02757391892373562, 0.0156321432441473, 0.015122044831514359, -0.03777414187788963, 0.026288188993930817, -0.06548670679330826, -0.011756934225559235, -0.03307760879397392, -0.05282764509320259, -0.07684216648340225, 0.03803369030356407, -0.006377464160323143, -0.02520124427974224, 0.000053406281949719414, 0.027291635051369667, -0.016590533778071404, -0.031292982399463654, -0.004422091878950596, 0.0071943337097764015, -0.015335394069552422, 0.014362315647304058, -0.0016106762923300266, -0.08277817070484161, 0.028851449489593506, -0.028819117695093155, 0.011671239510178566, -0.04220530763268471, -0.01384874526411295, -0.0015957815339788795, -0.018204202875494957, 0.03441203758120537, -0.0018187512177973986, -0.02226267009973526, -0.007852327078580856, 0.0018567375373095274, -0.019468890503048897, -0.037657685577869415, 0.01806511916220188, 0.01716344989836216, -0.007686280179768801, -0.02913391962647438, 0.00686615239828825, 0.005461866967380047, -0.001129258656874299, 0.00458502396941185, 0.033046476542949677, -0.008231351152062416, -0.01558614056557417, -0.011231668293476105, -0.028663771227002144, 0.01313614472746849, 0.061817437410354614, -0.009596145711839199, 0.002482606330886483, -0.052559882402420044, 0.021253511309623718, 0.055283691734075546, 0.07645878940820694, -0.01522963959723711, 0.0423261895775795, -0.009595845825970173, -0.031190022826194763, -0.023230189457535744, 0.02407379448413849, -0.0030085560865700245, -0.031785499304533005, 0.032868240028619766, -0.018429340794682503, -0.032635562121868134, 0.015437141992151737, 0.008726122789084911, 0.09658121317625046, 0.01245145220309496, 0.025840362533926964, 0.015800170600414276, 0.011966890655457973, -0.002830288838595152, 0.014302486553788185, 0.02893119864165783, 0.0026185759343206882, -0.02232152782380581, 0.03705376014113426, 0.020510004833340645, -0.0080425925552845, 0.038366805762052536, 0.05536803975701332, -0.054272446781396866, -0.004952460061758757, 0.009929424151778221, 0.007141792215406895, 0.020719781517982483, 0.04919913411140442, -0.030820069834589958, -0.022906921803951263, 0.008747940883040428, -0.008087730035185814, -0.0010459211189299822, -0.027065234258770943, 0.06503830850124359, 0.011523528955876827, -0.006434792652726173, -0.0022139495704323053, 0.009185123257339, -0.03542812168598175, 0.025649694725871086, -0.03276011720299721, 0.004774016328155994, -0.014297226443886757, 0.0744309276342392, 0.016049375757575035, 0.0010700811399146914, 0.005719122011214495, 0.04815569519996643, 0.009449319913983345, 0.015860680490732193, -0.06691767275333405, -0.02120831049978733, -0.03751587122678757, 0.012029961682856083, -0.010041991248726845, -0.03083718754351139, -0.017237335443496704, -0.030027396976947784, 0.02730308473110199, -0.05009305104613304, 0.048605334013700485, -0.07232942432165146, -0.03407011553645134, 0.05551677569746971, 0.011956173926591873, 0.020991595461964607, 0.04873380810022354, 0.01871967315673828, 0.03144673630595207, -0.047651611268520355, 0.017973382025957108, -0.09108497202396393, 0.04375900328159332, 0.018851561471819878, 0.05482365936040878, -0.002047757850959897, -0.02870815433561802, 0.006308060605078936, 0.05465776100754738, 0.01184015441685915, -0.012891861610114574, -0.05528876930475235, 0.033783625811338425, 0.039044857025146484, -0.023889703676104546, -0.03221054747700691, -0.0037345662713050842, -0.039189837872982025, 0.014587611891329288, 0.06676328927278519, 0.00527902040630579, -0.03890049457550049, 0.005594529677182436, -0.0007150894380174577, -0.013676612637937069, -0.010019402951002121, 0.011298740282654762, 0.0006367777241393924, 0.03961138427257538, -0.04264654591679573, -0.06181086227297783, -0.02999427542090416, -0.009301908314228058, 0.001073623774573207, 0.03575630113482475, -0.01758337765932083, -0.019737709313631058, 0.03878409042954445, -0.0701010525226593, 0.0041805775836110115, -0.02736472897231579, -0.004978179465979338, 0.022324275225400925, 0.018202470615506172, 0.04742325842380524, -0.0212098378688097, 0.006165924947708845, -0.04289728030562401, 0.009285436011850834, 0.06398692727088928, 0.036545466631650925, -0.07030949741601944, 0.030588282272219658, -0.028036203235387802, -0.029963435605168343, -0.0351976677775383, -0.039884746074676514, 0.05044414475560188, -0.04105512052774429, 0.027935273945331573, -0.029664872214198112, -0.02069447748363018, 0.021325577050447464, -0.070689857006073, 0.01111011952161789, 0.016086190938949585, 0.022297432646155357, 0.01099975872784853, 0.025571759790182114, -0.033581867814064026, 0.008592143654823303, 0.026361234486103058, 0.06250125169754028, 0.0656554326415062, -0.010328873991966248, -0.024518262594938278, 0.04045078158378601, 0.03255796059966087, -0.03696553781628609, -0.02511920966207981, -0.011898350901901722, -0.023494498804211617, -0.01542456354945898, 0.005525499116629362, -0.054293856024742126, -0.0024177890736609697, 0.03940825164318085, -0.0006136628799140453, -0.05349331721663475, -0.04340991750359535, 0.06881717592477798, 0.004437201656401157, 0.04030108079314232, -0.010421385988593102, 0.0364154689013958, 0.08084234595298767, -0.0009774081408977509, -0.01942504197359085, 0.055432796478271484, 0.009678683243691921, 0.045055218040943146, -0.026654265820980072, 0.03557388111948967, 0.05109535530209541, 0.0312049463391304, -0.03908400610089302, 0.015064307488501072, -0.0018234022427350283, 0.07632742822170258, -0.062368351966142654, 0.015496078878641129, -0.04318782687187195, 0.0368870347738266, -0.022385265678167343, 0.005901944357901812, -0.02668839693069458, -0.045477110892534256, -0.03416828066110611, -0.03204077482223511, -0.008371814154088497, 0.005887297913432121, 0.024527261033654213, 0.01914280094206333, -0.032462090253829956, -0.05058545246720314, -0.0036879212129861116, 0.01462608203291893, -0.0041951388120651245, -0.0010622398694977164, 0.007151368539780378, 0.019528640434145927, 0.03221557289361954, 0.0007528592832386494, 0.02560412511229515, -0.03637436404824257, 0.029519377276301384, 0.009090832434594631, -0.05118746683001518, -0.05425337329506874, 0.02256625145673752, 0.016174858435988426, 0.030522093176841736, -0.02187924273312092, 0.03905002027750015, 0.03905809670686722, 0.010388514958322048, -0.027517497539520264, 0.014899699948728085, -0.020987888798117638, -0.046169161796569824, -0.01311356108635664, -0.04575427621603012, 0.016217760741710663, 0.019299685955047607, -0.00036498624831438065, -0.029816677793860435, 0.06065869331359863, -0.003674567211419344, 0.06801468133926392, -0.0289028137922287, 0.036630481481552124, -0.009497394785284996, 0.026800906285643578, -0.018054325133562088, 0.0153263621032238, -0.014864299446344376, -0.011865551583468914, 0.03250615671277046, -0.019430415704846382, 0.014122729189693928, 0.021128926426172256, 0.02380775846540928, 0.05065055191516876, -0.0009161174530163407, 0.011977284215390682, 0.017723193392157555, 0.02455834671854973, -0.03021041862666607, -0.06143215671181679, -0.004943006671965122, 0.026030974462628365, -0.03343811258673668, -0.03782365843653679, -0.026411375030875206, -0.013422299176454544, -0.10593166202306747, 0.02172064408659935, 0.052146509289741516, -0.05442637950181961, -0.0339750275015831, -0.032416895031929016, -0.01907194033265114, -0.0027279683854430914, -0.0366157628595829, -0.030442122370004654, -0.03171844780445099, 0.029904121533036232, -0.0016147340647876263, -0.007001582533121109, -0.006007013376802206, -0.0032908159773796797, 0.012717435136437416, -0.01762261800467968, -0.0029164243023842573, 0.00609569763764739, -0.023137198761105537, 0.02475537545979023, -0.03600733354687691, -0.07979446649551392, 0.02597345970571041, -0.04396667331457138, 0.041836608201265335, 0.04693452641367912, 0.025895163416862488, -0.036743469536304474, -0.053822267800569534, 0.029039496555924416, 0.0026927900034934282, -0.033932626247406006, -0.01681380160152912, -0.010625178925693035, -0.016651807352900505, 0.03730473294854164, -0.057065412402153015, -0.007816311903297901, -0.06989942491054535, -0.04082425311207771, 0.02081551030278206, 0.03492569550871849, 0.003131862496957183, 0.028021832928061485, 0.04642700031399727, 0.002171867061406374 ]
<p>Thinking about the concept of symmetry breaking led me to the following question: Let's say that I have a theory described by a Lorentz invariant Lagrangian, and the true vacuum of the theory is not invariant under Lorentz transformation, will there be massless Goldstone bosons (or fermions) similar to the breaking of a gauge symmetry? How would it be different from this kind of symmetry breaking? What would be some phenomenological consequences? Or would it be stupid (for some reasons) to look at this kind of vacuum from the beginning?</p> <p>Thanks. </p>
g7430
[ 0.022670656442642212, 0.0070016272366046906, 0.02390027604997158, -0.046598274260759354, 0.0026207268238067627, 0.06685544550418854, -0.005979004316031933, 0.06250389665365219, -0.003303512232378125, -0.01318295393139124, -0.04492956027388573, 0.010109144262969494, 0.02453414350748062, 0.03892199322581291, -0.0028658586088567972, 0.01299203746020794, 0.06206953525543213, 0.008010786958038807, 0.029428385198116302, -0.08324333280324936, 0.018290195614099503, 0.02272227592766285, -0.00826289039105177, -0.04267144575715065, -0.006147255189716816, -0.0454484261572361, 0.03327001631259918, 0.07925081998109818, 0.0005550810601562262, 0.012549136765301228, 0.07150965183973312, 0.043939009308815, -0.004624553490430117, -0.002965695457533002, -0.01776350475847721, -0.048702117055654526, 0.06622077524662018, 0.07384707778692245, 0.042318303138017654, -0.0408744253218174, 0.02138742431998253, -0.008308721706271172, -0.02904893085360527, -0.027265677228569984, -0.006776547059416771, 0.00159282551612705, 0.018124228343367577, -0.02403382770717144, -0.02486695535480976, 0.006865162402391434, 0.0818924531340599, -0.006820254027843475, 0.03819240257143974, -0.04298568144440651, -0.0607626810669899, 0.025829864665865898, 0.0455453135073185, -0.01920507661998272, 0.052066605538129807, 0.01932758092880249, -0.03435704857110977, 0.002492371713742614, 0.011232143267989159, -0.006072391290217638, 0.03945903107523918, 0.010103954933583736, -0.041635774075984955, 0.0007602750556543469, -0.0031531518325209618, -0.0005652015097439289, -0.03316180780529976, 0.008092327043414116, -0.034076809883117676, -0.014487441629171371, -0.0029443055391311646, 0.0620647594332695, -0.023348374292254448, 0.02067907713353634, -0.003823320148512721, -0.0587846077978611, -0.004263514652848244, -0.04307769238948822, 0.006334833335131407, 0.00007771676609991118, 0.12270548939704895, -0.09256953001022339, -0.018317699432373047, -0.02199026755988598, 0.030623478814959526, 0.032966453582048416, -0.0038863641675561666, -0.06999021023511887, 0.004302161745727062, 0.028555111959576607, -0.013788879849016666, 0.0015127280494198203, 0.01957527920603752, 0.08390741795301437, -0.0777367353439331, -0.050623077899217606, 0.008132951334118843, 0.009325563907623291, 0.04171328246593475, -0.017300013452768326, -0.015466366894543171, -0.0759008601307869, 0.07091622054576874, -0.02527693472802639, 0.04195147752761841, -0.010386066511273384, -0.004901451524347067, 0.011405198834836483, -0.009711015969514847, 0.0024140123277902603, -0.08628486841917038, 0.009725147858262062, 0.07630453258752823, -0.020262129604816437, 0.027476510033011436, 0.015297720208764076, 0.05061771720647812, 0.01773642562329769, -0.034788794815540314, -0.03800657019019127, -0.022222593426704407, 0.012107929214835167, -0.029042020440101624, 0.022426782175898552, 0.03304753825068474, -0.045731592923402786, 0.0007633505738340318, 0.004709158092737198, -0.009538080543279648, 0.048430923372507095, -0.0014625057810917497, 0.05811476334929466, 0.024330725893378258, 0.012835546396672726, 0.04206077381968498, -0.04601345583796501, -0.00017810041026677936, 0.006580085959285498, -0.05589885264635086, 0.03027350828051567, 0.050332583487033844, -0.03984859213232994, -0.005667855963110924, -0.025634640827775, 0.017057374119758606, 0.06142866611480713, 0.005128959193825722, 0.04829116538167, 0.02551453933119774, -0.0033820157404989004, 0.016597788780927658, -0.005664967466145754, -0.010000087320804596, -0.0023537238594144583, 0.02798796445131302, -0.014129258692264557, 0.05614778771996498, -0.044233378022909164, 0.054527830332517624, -0.018654145300388336, -0.08156878501176834, -0.03225114941596985, -0.010213294997811317, -0.02956770732998848, 0.01567338965833187, -0.027876336127519608, -0.03719298914074898, 0.044144365936517715, 0.007961813360452652, 0.07250804454088211, -0.012205113656818867, 0.09231571853160858, -0.06577092409133911, 0.02688685432076454, 0.015200082212686539, 0.03799212723970413, -0.030988888815045357, -0.03588492050766945, 0.03359701484441757, -0.03289293497800827, -0.01267441175878048, 0.03739166632294655, 0.024684198200702667, -0.014035012573003769, -0.0009028513450175524, 0.01921805925667286, -0.001533678499981761, -0.017191288992762566, -0.01567738875746727, 0.05672556906938553, -0.01995578035712242, -0.015862872824072838, -0.018955834209918976, 0.009351258166134357, -0.04311705380678177, -0.005198814440518618, -0.011304349638521671, 0.0923667848110199, -0.0030888081528246403, -0.011361587792634964, -0.018941516056656837, -0.0511234886944294, -0.044165149331092834, -0.027456173673272133, 0.015056672506034374, -0.000613209034781903, 0.0519137866795063, 0.01969548873603344, 0.03298646956682205, -0.019820908084511757, -0.01889611780643463, 0.031899649649858475, 0.0036089583300054073, 0.044242508709430695, -0.04700133576989174, 0.061541199684143066, 0.007970686070621014, -0.015154506079852581, 0.05648167058825493, 0.020319685339927673, 0.013140145689249039, -0.04666077718138695, -0.01727411150932312, -0.07466502487659454, 0.027708061039447784, -0.021468183025717735, -0.0054238359443843365, 0.01955736242234707, 0.012201815843582153, -0.02747504413127899, -0.0015752074541524053, 0.0247779693454504, -0.0014169756323099136, 0.002114073606207967, 0.0660550445318222, -0.05317028611898422, 0.018212633207440376, -0.0044615804217755795, -0.07191809266805649, -0.006346272304654121, 0.06233711913228035, -0.020721033215522766, 0.029171930626034737, 0.018653003498911858, -0.011414894834160805, -0.01198149286210537, -0.004005778580904007, 0.0031993621960282326, -0.007099221460521221, -0.022915367037057877, 0.0005351404543034732, 0.013381008058786392, 0.09751754999160767, 0.02997962012887001, -0.03731970861554146, 0.0031155692413449287, 0.04370506852865219, -0.07732405513525009, -0.011440645903348923, 0.02934292145073414, -0.035122402012348175, 0.02998458966612816, 0.050483498722314835, 0.040384940803050995, -0.028852634131908417, 0.019933950155973434, -0.01948343589901924, 0.04434043541550636, 0.03290976583957672, 0.03610303997993469, 0.027118541300296783, -0.005161365028470755, 0.0009146087104454637, -0.032563138753175735, -0.007653245236724615, -0.13905565440654755, -0.029596669599413872, 0.01846553012728691, -0.03908675163984299, 0.0041856602765619755, 0.03635212406516075, -0.06041895970702171, -0.054364100098609924, -0.051026590168476105, -0.04110710695385933, 0.03357058763504028, -0.015477605164051056, 0.0014348903205245733, 0.0710761770606041, 0.0008574520470574498, -0.036112114787101746, 0.007869175635278225, -0.024349907413125038, 0.002168511739000678, -0.0499425083398819, 0.034120090305805206, -0.006477960851043463, -0.026113076135516167, 0.005433643702417612, 0.017779670655727386, -0.06621813029050827, -0.017308415845036507, -0.06408636271953583, -0.015116747468709946, -0.041483305394649506, -0.07350459694862366, -0.04351922869682312, 0.02061792090535164, 0.04394063726067543, 0.021089138463139534, 0.0051801674999296665, -0.005730281118303537, -0.046922873705625534, 0.0016243094578385353, 0.03189951926469803, -0.0112519646063447, -0.09294132143259048, -0.012871142476797104, 0.01657850109040737, -0.020788056775927544, 0.04326537624001503, -0.002429576590657234, 0.02333316020667553, 0.04325960576534271, -0.02732663042843342, -0.00798084493726492, -0.03867347165942192, -0.029902368783950806, -0.025380132719874382, 0.026930369436740875, -0.01357895415276289, 0.021475668996572495, -0.04320713132619858, -0.02163020521402359, 0.003766358597204089, -0.029493708163499832, -0.014067561365664005, -0.030148698017001152, -0.06480808556079865, 0.011837217956781387, 0.03065308928489685, 0.003425921779125929, 0.012251420877873898, -0.04777996242046356, 0.008417523466050625, 0.041140418499708176, 0.021274780854582787, -0.003467421978712082, 0.02783343195915222, -0.01955033466219902, 0.002066119108349085, -0.049823861569166183, 0.06479031592607498, 0.022493582218885422, 0.03732365369796753, -0.020423518493771553, 0.022900931537151337, -0.025072813034057617, -0.003623700700700283, -0.06291698664426804, -0.02606428787112236, 0.032142333686351776, -0.03268076479434967, -0.05582955852150917, 0.04427449032664299, 0.013535212725400925, 0.01800929382443428, -0.04895210266113281, -0.001725436537526548, 0.008546531200408936, -0.0018164593493565917, -0.013088996522128582, 0.0419907346367836, -0.021380998194217682, -0.028329862281680107, -0.02147907391190529, 0.01801786758005619, 0.03304518386721611, 0.04395078495144844, -0.011632988229393959, 0.036681488156318665, 0.01669618859887123, -0.02252746745944023, 0.028468795120716095, -0.029031850397586823, -0.05091400071978569, 0.018107326701283455, 0.030688898637890816, -0.03281054273247719, -0.0028944178484380245, 0.03087015263736248, -0.015179909765720367, 0.0052209580317139626, 0.0017547144088894129, 0.0321192592382431, 0.03556385263800621, 0.01935250498354435, 0.041169676929712296, -0.0012364716967567801, -0.030895454809069633, 0.033797528594732285, -0.010477133095264435, 0.04721378907561302, -0.031056266278028488, -0.02854776941239834, -0.015308135189116001, -0.01268040668219328, -0.01936950907111168, 0.009846694767475128, -0.03872011974453926, 0.044870443642139435, -0.017338169738650322, -0.029271243140101433, -0.01932782121002674, 0.02122526615858078, -0.026318680495023727, 0.02489941380918026, -0.02004590630531311, 0.01823342964053154, 0.030730431899428368, -0.007248770445585251, 0.014794891700148582, 0.047151681035757065, 0.004598823841661215, -0.014331803657114506, -0.039477329701185226, 0.01076964195817709, 0.022887716069817543, -0.030803242698311806, 0.01788349449634552, 0.005530437454581261, -0.006454095710068941, -0.09501749277114868, -0.013270006515085697, -0.0421445295214653, 0.05500835180282593, 0.0861009880900383, 0.02646569348871708, 0.04541174694895744, 0.01050282921642065, -0.007788927759975195, 0.03796902298927307, 0.0495658777654171, -0.08681702613830566, 0.017887504771351814, -0.00351228890940547, -0.040526580065488815, 0.006275503430515528, -0.047618791460990906, 0.01128489151597023, -0.012803089804947376, -0.03132806345820427, -0.01831253618001938, 0.030627340078353882, 0.01786787062883377, 0.0030367737635970116, -0.02115103229880333, -0.04137183353304863, 0.057001568377017975, 0.004393852781504393, 0.03217785805463791, -0.01934630051255226, -0.09913327544927597, 0.01520591787993908, -0.07473915070295334, -0.01665307953953743, 0.02660769782960415, -0.009390879422426224, -0.005139417480677366, -0.022508665919303894, 0.055903904139995575, 0.0285645704716444, -0.025540821254253387, -0.030240587890148163, -0.00976185780018568, -0.01598982699215412, 0.015349212102591991, -0.0057349978014826775, 0.07516274601221085, -0.09765425324440002, -0.013436516746878624, 0.012872633524239063, -0.0018159535247832537, 0.025439530611038208, -0.06156851723790169, -0.04621535912156105, -0.03445359319448471, 0.005431389901787043, 0.04102405160665512, -0.008560634218156338, -0.029750624671578407, 0.056372687220573425, -0.02016446925699711, 0.006133889779448509, -0.04282642528414726, 0.006510480307042599, -0.010828210972249508, 0.020405525341629982, 0.12494638562202454, 0.012075078673660755, 0.0034495166037231684, 0.039460647851228714, 0.052152812480926514, 0.00829075276851654, -0.00373264541849494, 0.013498258776962757, 0.028183767572045326, 0.008192277513444424, -0.019160715863108635, 0.017459779977798462, 0.008210361003875732, 0.023815860971808434, -0.04912356659770012, -0.004558753687888384, -0.017627671360969543, -0.03951619192957878, -0.0725562646985054, 0.034780483692884445, 0.01084818784147501, -0.030433600768446922, 0.020738083869218826, 0.04517795145511627, -0.026053769513964653, 0.01201878022402525, -0.033409588038921356, -0.0006194394663907588, 0.04772496595978737, -0.017983756959438324, 0.10144639015197754, -0.016522059217095375, 0.08491262793540955, -0.03189455345273018, 0.00981178693473339, 0.01485674548894167, -0.01089379284530878, 0.033425137400627136, -0.024183018133044243, -0.030768705531954765, 0.03102281503379345, -0.03127926215529442, -0.03256289288401604, 0.020824408158659935, -0.06241569295525551, 0.037130385637283325, 0.005155717954039574, -0.020589057356119156, -0.09244736284017563, 0.00023712649999652058, -0.012208474799990654, 0.013087568804621696, -0.042151737958192825, 0.04525100812315941, -0.01328449696302414, -0.010388276539742947, -0.06372138112783432, -0.01569966971874237, 0.04412435367703438, 0.031969763338565826, 0.013022664934396744, 0.0028431119862943888, -0.016024695709347725, 0.042552608996629715, 0.016983775421977043, -0.05723593384027481, 0.05563243851065636, -0.008540489710867405, -0.024944180622696877, 0.08541239798069, -0.015113085508346558, -0.0012448827037587762, 0.0027330713346600533, -0.008171431720256805, -0.027307894080877304, -0.018546121194958687, 0.04429604113101959, 0.01970909908413887, 0.009569091722369194, 0.004221816081553698, 0.013429922051727772, -0.07707195729017258, 0.001192036783322692, 0.015067193657159805, -0.028619375079870224, 0.0022052647545933723, 0.032422300428152084, 0.05703672394156456, -0.06074318289756775, -0.0450151190161705, -0.020649509504437447, 0.030474495142698288, 0.02397213689982891, 0.052992403507232666, -0.012222331948578358, -0.0649382621049881, 0.001363867544569075, 0.02431338094174862, 0.0643976628780365, 0.013204083777964115, -0.010982834734022617, 0.014824063517153263, 0.014016651548445225, 0.05693711340427399, -0.026876147836446762, 0.037091340869665146, 0.046782612800598145, -0.001084769843146205, 0.006767808925360441, 0.00800376944243908, -0.017300603911280632, -0.01908210664987564, 0.025382714346051216, -0.01797652803361416, 0.0007064423407427967, -0.018409887328743935, -0.0468362420797348, 0.05087023600935936, -0.03826446086168289, -0.03016437031328678, -0.013356509618461132, 0.03509538248181343, 0.02900109812617302, 0.08970310539007187, -0.046796806156635284, 0.041591525077819824, 0.04736136645078659, 0.017109496518969536, -0.02318885736167431, -0.030476797372102737, 0.03187131881713867, 0.009585580788552761, -0.012488027103245258, -0.017710968852043152, -0.015717478469014168, -0.00010476732131792232, 0.06872037798166275, 0.005156733561307192, -0.04082396999001503, -0.006689045578241348, 0.04767061397433281, -0.02585478499531746, -0.056886907666921616, 0.05198067054152489, 0.011704958975315094, 0.008671094663441181, -0.056434132158756256, -0.03997661918401718, -0.04835845157504082, -0.0006868498749099672, -0.008297757245600224, -0.018107473850250244, -0.021288588643074036, -0.02514011599123478, 0.017192082479596138, 0.013058370910584927, 0.011067770421504974, -0.07499480992555618, -0.0002278018946526572, 0.005781184416264296, 0.019236117601394653, -0.04229151830077171, 0.04944787546992302, 0.06487808376550674, -0.04115809500217438, -0.021801970899105072, 0.036656830459833145, 0.008357945829629898, -0.041175760328769684, -0.055913545191287994, 0.004847372882068157, 0.03220316767692566, 0.017306705936789513, -0.02131916582584381, -0.03494435176253319, 0.05836332589387894, -0.06389755755662918, -0.01950269751250744, -0.03554772585630417, 0.0274126585572958, 0.004756918642669916, 0.01752467080950737, -0.06389205902814865, -0.00008459980745101348, -0.002063190331682563, 0.05732685700058937, -0.03265587240457535, -0.016038205474615097, -0.008660857565701008, -0.035773929208517075, 0.07174459099769592, -0.012303758412599564, -0.06521204113960266, -0.025670677423477173, 0.01596224308013916, 0.043247733265161514, 0.02949933148920536, -0.04419546201825142, -0.010653597302734852, 0.025275791063904762, -0.004305426497012377, -0.03160760924220085, 0.06591664999723434, -0.01613474078476429, -0.021343953907489777, -0.05640144646167755, -0.041660357266664505, 0.06875740736722946, -0.004773163236677647, 0.08435215801000595, 0.03068489208817482, 0.022094450891017914, 0.04066253453493118, -0.04857044667005539, -0.05288667231798172, 0.04882713779807091, 0.06300772726535797, 0.01518202293664217, -0.026534361764788628, -0.029503485187888145, 0.008164585568010807, -0.033119671046733856, -0.019000675529241562, -0.0180674996227026, 0.010374744422733784, -0.021341415122151375, -0.02779466100037098, 0.006240424700081348, -0.017405996099114418, 0.017738955095410347, -0.02071036584675312, 0.046974603086709976, -0.021547121927142143, -0.002562802517786622, -0.002212776802480221, -0.02431444264948368, -0.015150085091590881, -0.04695062339305878, -0.030200473964214325, -0.036754004657268524, 0.016672467812895775, 0.0070937275886535645, -0.0011767162941396236, 0.045932549983263016, -0.008669555187225342, -0.052581626921892166, 0.01517337653785944, 0.01362511608749628, -0.013412891887128353, -0.014878214336931705, 0.0422438383102417, 0.04363587498664856, 0.01381742674857378, -0.011814022436738014, -0.009075449779629707, 0.009292973205447197, -0.004242960829287767, -0.004567018710076809, 0.017858382314443588, 0.035368286073207855, -0.010377676226198673, 0.04360974580049515, -0.07134250551462173, -0.030649663880467415, 0.004919462837278843, 0.06054524704813957 ]
<p>I am reading a paper on quantum gravity (written circa 1988 but I don't think it's relevant to give a more precise reference) where I read the following statement: "universe loops will in general induce nonlocality, just as field theory loops induce nonlocality in relativistic-particle path integrals, and string loops induce nonlocality on the world-sheet". And to be honest, it's really unclear, I can't argue about the string theory case as I barely know anything about it, but regarding QFT, if those loops are the quantum corrections (appearing in an $\hbar$ expansion for example) I don't see how it is nonlocal, although it could be Wilson loops, then I'd like to know if the "path integrals" mentioned in the quote/article are the path ordered integral of the Wilson loops or the path integral of the partition function (or any correlation function). I hope that my question is clearer than my mind right now.</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
g7431
[ 0.024029212072491646, 0.033034373074769974, 0.01572127267718315, -0.033848706632852554, 0.047866810113191605, 0.026655906811356544, -0.014739039354026318, 0.041232895106077194, -0.003044867655262351, 0.01622895896434784, -0.03802638500928879, 0.0067942775785923, -0.04109243303537369, 0.03798025846481323, -0.025494981557130814, -0.008939951658248901, -0.017105303704738617, 0.026251688599586487, 0.01765195094048977, -0.0837782472372055, -0.01240579504519701, 0.010616611689329147, -0.0004884591326117516, 0.0016848653322085738, -0.02828606404364109, 0.04940314218401909, 0.028074216097593307, -0.08088405430316925, -0.022601626813411713, -0.010235042311251163, 0.014256338588893414, 0.002047792775556445, 0.013589943759143353, -0.03841212019324303, -0.031852610409259796, -0.006377093493938446, 0.055131010711193085, -0.026659317314624786, 0.021019164472818375, -0.009740504436194897, -0.0502711683511734, 0.040541909635066986, 0.0010864075738936663, -0.032895512878894806, 0.0007586870924569666, -0.013475234620273113, 0.0065103680826723576, 0.026791203767061234, 0.07822747528553009, -0.0014343931106850505, -0.07473382353782654, 0.04719933494925499, 0.01603962481021881, 0.007344739977270365, 0.01499396562576294, 0.10270510613918304, 0.04152047634124756, -0.0015025739558041096, 0.06737353652715683, 0.015672089532017708, 0.015001220628619194, -0.022258730605244637, 0.07565850019454956, -0.03771086782217026, 0.013474167324602604, 0.020235856994986534, -0.007782353088259697, 0.02432255819439888, -0.08756694197654724, 0.009194518439471722, 0.04284891486167908, -0.002578659914433956, -0.04416726157069206, 0.024607161059975624, 0.0390007384121418, 0.08833003044128418, 0.010624608024954796, -0.011655109003186226, 0.028101691976189613, 0.011821907944977283, -0.07564913481473923, 0.007321943528950214, -0.006980401463806629, 0.06944208592176437, 0.0053672585636377335, -0.05778342857956886, 0.012068980373442173, -0.014835108071565628, -0.07027773559093475, 0.016353389248251915, -0.01944391056895256, -0.016430817544460297, 0.038209810853004456, 0.04294637218117714, -0.024059124290943146, 0.039713095873594284, 0.008305573835968971, 0.05377263203263283, -0.0114182373508811, 0.0038899648934602737, -0.06277520209550858, 0.012067994102835655, 0.05601688101887703, 0.016224615275859833, 0.0015646991087123752, -0.03936867415904999, 0.013490097597241402, -0.005144417751580477, 0.01868198812007904, 0.021066032350063324, -0.00908663123846054, 0.0058972472324967384, -0.010728738270699978, -0.020712314173579216, -0.055747587233781815, 0.009740256704390049, 0.0615483820438385, -0.06892137974500656, 0.006269867531955242, 0.06856405735015869, 0.05842126905918121, 0.033849287778139114, -0.004254191182553768, 0.04003516584634781, 0.011834968812763691, -0.010989506728947163, -0.003231412498280406, 0.000542556750588119, 0.009177377447485924, 0.008346391841769218, 0.0524570569396019, -0.046352189034223557, 0.016416946426033974, 0.07326018810272217, -0.037301283329725266, -0.015454067848622799, 0.04845082014799118, -0.048931851983070374, -0.02308533899486065, -0.004242034163326025, -0.014760796912014484, -0.044254280626773834, -0.04257845878601074, 0.004953770898282528, -0.02677326835691929, -0.047786787152290344, 0.03312891721725464, -0.012247239239513874, -0.0226869098842144, 0.007427671924233437, 0.04425691440701485, 0.027846088632941246, -0.05952027067542076, -0.054088443517684937, 0.00005113948282087222, 0.04136734455823898, 0.03576457500457764, -0.006114704068750143, 0.06703981757164001, -0.025484532117843628, 0.023988397791981697, 0.04321809485554695, 0.08024437725543976, -0.021070899441838264, -0.03437299281358719, 0.0175486970692873, 0.05978007614612579, -0.03200594335794449, 0.010976010002195835, -0.024763407185673714, -0.015395177528262138, -0.006391072645783424, 0.037635307759046555, 0.036009531468153, -0.013913058675825596, 0.05791265517473221, -0.02871495857834816, 0.003965345211327076, -0.04482881724834442, -0.015913816168904305, 0.02150135301053524, 0.026168394833803177, -0.041162654757499695, -0.015651391819119453, -0.003344862489029765, 0.008231397718191147, -0.06639565527439117, -0.018215332180261612, -0.040073033422231674, -0.02540750429034233, -0.0329761728644371, -0.006681385915726423, 0.017261819913983345, 0.009211204014718533, -0.021030325442552567, 0.011030662804841995, -0.026447465643286705, -0.04930882900953293, -0.03991219028830528, -0.04991509020328522, 0.006732331123203039, 0.012913588434457779, 0.030768660828471184, -0.07980181276798248, 0.019982414320111275, -0.023852374404668808, 0.00022478157188743353, -0.025611869990825653, -0.0007357825525105, -0.03516416251659393, 0.04452703520655632, -0.021368885412812233, 0.03336334601044655, 0.056067902594804764, -0.02748872898519039, -0.0008783397497609258, -0.04526244103908539, 0.0014251121319830418, 0.023641107603907585, -0.05831603705883026, 0.0020365379750728607, 0.07302151620388031, 0.044494226574897766, -0.016996944323182106, 0.03490094467997551, 0.01013508252799511, 0.016020724549889565, -0.026687415316700935, 0.0004328665672801435, -0.0002628528163768351, -0.07323595136404037, 0.007401660550385714, -0.039538122713565826, -0.02278592810034752, 0.052320197224617004, -0.007149389944970608, 0.024410901591181755, -0.011683454737067223, 0.037509236484766006, 0.01640683226287365, 0.003685304196551442, 0.004449454601854086, -0.02592632547020912, 0.018598975613713264, 0.04610501229763031, -0.053156860172748566, 0.049658410251140594, 0.024646209552884102, -0.08053980022668839, 0.021318327635526657, 0.027963556349277496, -0.05040031671524048, 0.029876617714762688, 0.06996466219425201, -0.0013138875365257263, 0.011008714325726032, 0.035035911947488785, 0.018895456567406654, -0.03298551216721535, -0.03821827843785286, 0.008736002258956432, 0.023316463455557823, 0.02250036783516407, 0.028265878558158875, -0.03105922043323517, -0.009010380133986473, 0.00566090689972043, -0.051693983376026154, -0.01830151118338108, -0.020695248618721962, -0.00952801201492548, -0.018674561753869057, -0.036381080746650696, -0.018509244546294212, 0.05799233168363571, 0.025563513860106468, -0.013434073887765408, 0.053008366376161575, -0.015761710703372955, 0.0060812244191765785, 0.005955428350716829, -0.03719422593712807, -0.04400775209069252, 0.04555448517203331, -0.03459114208817482, -0.0006246522534638643, 0.015471326187252998, -0.025556817650794983, 0.02368583343923092, -0.017551468685269356, 0.03206643462181091, 0.027853399515151978, 0.052189700305461884, 0.06609249114990234, 0.012235147878527641, 0.017456281930208206, 0.023253073915839195, -0.031181763857603073, -0.001521855010651052, 0.02987896278500557, 0.01023795921355486, -0.026544103398919106, 0.033325932919979095, -0.0048617227002978325, 0.00854217167943716, 0.01879064552485943, -0.027638232335448265, -0.02039799839258194, 0.02320866286754608, -0.045196838676929474, -0.012960266321897507, 0.01015662495046854, -0.01148493867367506, 0.009706549346446991, 0.05215710029006004, 0.10348682105541229, -0.030518842861056328, 0.06826428323984146, 0.04843756929039955, -0.08272591233253479, -0.041615743190050125, -0.0632876604795456, -0.0034765037707984447, 0.01637393794953823, 0.054092563688755035, 0.04970449581742287, 0.04251907765865326, -0.028164934366941452, 0.05191665142774582, -0.03519352152943611, 0.02018568478524685, -0.0509055070579052, 0.003974529914557934, -0.010194881819188595, -0.06127272546291351, -0.09828462451696396, -0.03580430522561073, -0.030939536169171333, 0.009191867895424366, 0.027967657893896103, -0.018355173990130424, -0.0162945669144392, 0.06811461597681046, 0.009421681985259056, -0.021171649917960167, 0.07144419848918915, 0.030136432498693466, 0.050595723092556, 0.004398224409669638, 0.051140230149030685, 0.04421938583254814, -0.06339845806360245, -0.015766490250825882, -0.014721261337399483, 0.00010894485603785142, 0.037643853574991226, 0.012693122029304504, 0.029872432351112366, 0.06121399626135826, -0.01380067877471447, -0.038037143647670746, -0.0698772743344307, -0.02512541599571705, 0.019880196079611778, 0.022482311353087425, -0.008993266150355339, 0.008881508372724056, -0.03806950896978378, -0.004080175422132015, -0.04785455763339996, 0.021890485659241676, 0.06873705983161926, -0.029261944815516472, 0.005175403319299221, 0.01457338035106659, 0.009214268997311592, 0.057689864188432693, 0.0316394679248333, -0.007103560492396355, 0.015289226546883583, 0.01579919643700123, 0.06495486199855804, 0.009685933589935303, 0.05324457958340645, 0.026320600882172585, -0.0016458624741062522, -0.06167253851890564, -0.024124864488840103, 0.0005373069434426725, -0.00018596638983581215, -0.022079089656472206, -0.057903412729501724, -0.013418231159448624, -0.02098884992301464, 0.010549254715442657, -0.008926983922719955, -0.0017819346394389868, -0.022724218666553497, 0.04244068264961243, 0.02789304591715336, 0.05301803722977638, -0.04445513337850571, 0.03375396504998207, 0.0207088440656662, 0.0024819904938340187, -0.02311202883720398, -0.002120544435456395, -0.016869833692908287, -0.01399274542927742, -0.028873171657323837, 0.0708482563495636, -0.025865476578474045, 0.010983055457472801, -0.05226901173591614, 0.033094216138124466, -0.015512185171246529, 0.010955417528748512, -0.06823606789112091, -0.020750410854816437, -0.007846021093428135, 0.0031689885072410107, 0.01320470217615366, 0.04730210825800896, -0.021341174840927124, -0.02113400585949421, 0.08374418318271637, -0.03631730377674103, -0.0033494331873953342, 0.0009351069456897676, -0.028996426612138748, -0.0017378005431964993, 0.03966202959418297, 0.0587974451482296, 0.01006843987852335, -0.049331456422805786, 0.030705293640494347, -0.01965671218931675, 0.0392080619931221, -0.02156183309853077, -0.02533707208931446, 0.06269127130508423, 0.026383569464087486, -0.02514795958995819, 0.03975476697087288, 0.017537597566843033, 0.02304866537451744, -0.046744462102651596, 0.04710223525762558, -0.07995150983333588, -0.06722687929868698, -0.04534554481506348, 0.049583274871110916, -0.012696530669927597, -0.024525729939341545, 0.029616190120577812, -0.014328740537166595, 0.011608683504164219, 0.014427493326365948, 0.03082173876464367, -0.03954576328396797, -0.0704711452126503, -0.013800975866615772, 0.005547738634049892, 0.054399192333221436, 0.0022026896476745605, 0.007563611026853323, -0.06229957193136215, 0.015822166576981544, -0.08609268069267273, -0.005404920782893896, 0.005020411219447851, -0.02069227397441864, 0.018593456596136093, -0.04698880761861801, 0.025286342948675156, -0.0250899326056242, -0.013922329992055893, -0.06370624154806137, -0.01828458160161972, -0.04384515434503555, -0.025333784520626068, 0.019764617085456848, 0.06247999891638756, -0.01867959275841713, 0.005174089223146439, 0.0012999845203012228, -0.06546711176633835, -0.006468476261943579, -0.0068170917220413685, 0.04320075362920761, 0.05527960881590843, -0.014530111104249954, 0.05963423475623131, -0.0224742591381073, -0.006251056678593159, -0.014612111262977123, -0.00018624687800183892, -0.03146655485033989, 0.02008584327995777, -0.03987181559205055, 0.021249521523714066, 0.0387512668967247, 0.05383602902293205, 0.016596253961324692, -0.03094375878572464, 0.06670857965946198, 0.0005606739432550967, 0.04356525465846062, 0.02548609860241413, -0.010016503743827343, 0.022810691967606544, -0.01017032004892826, -0.04207417368888855, 0.009071721695363522, 0.047834087163209915, -0.009475462138652802, -0.0676354393362999, -0.061620473861694336, 0.011958980932831764, -0.05540749430656433, 0.024833474308252335, 0.04671715572476387, -0.014925397001206875, 0.0054197595454752445, 0.06414249539375305, 0.003849620930850506, -0.01953239180147648, -0.05340659245848656, 0.014827684499323368, 0.023226521909236908, -0.00046588375698775053, -0.011394849047064781, 0.06355263292789459, 0.07849463820457458, 0.021673407405614853, -0.045956384390592575, 0.043448787182569504, 0.034654222428798676, 0.04036172106862068, 0.04907621443271637, -0.001623342977836728, 0.010814916342496872, -0.019678575918078423, -0.0052564735524356365, -0.05547107383608818, -0.0018985421629622579, -0.038315169513225555, -0.0393698625266552, 0.039595890790224075, -0.06348845362663269, -0.09692356735467911, -0.011192808859050274, 0.01160051766782999, 0.026983093470335007, -0.03108094446361065, 0.052205998450517654, -0.0073473346419632435, -0.009073802269995213, -0.00943685695528984, -0.016531452536582947, 0.04784803465008736, 0.0022511843126267195, 0.035249918699264526, -0.06310442835092545, 0.023165512830018997, -0.015162205323576927, 0.02059394307434559, -0.05086754262447357, 0.03201122209429741, 0.0214519239962101, -0.007920061238110065, -0.003484854009002447, -0.1093357503414154, 0.028447270393371582, -0.036870844662189484, 0.007360519375652075, -0.009219174273312092, -0.05787207558751106, -0.01096893660724163, -0.024622835218906403, -0.04686969518661499, 0.019640734419226646, -0.00648022536188364, -0.049055956304073334, -0.03123619593679905, 0.008371775969862938, -0.0507158525288105, -0.01683386042714119, 0.05929146334528923, 0.025410998612642288, -0.08202216029167175, 0.031216491013765335, -0.016714414581656456, -0.0040294998325407505, -0.031308893114328384, 0.024724116548895836, 0.010342476889491081, 0.02019503526389599, -0.006992465816438198, -0.02615142986178398, 0.02176837809383869, 0.024423999711871147, 0.10026103258132935, -0.0605580136179924, 0.04744117707014084, 0.04812795668840408, 0.004026834387332201, 0.0013160585658624768, 0.03807796165347099, -0.014100484549999237, 0.043733298778533936, 0.0004859376640524715, 0.019199242815375328, -0.012568779289722443, -0.02004605159163475, -0.05854957550764084, -0.04018929973244667, 0.006549668498337269, -0.01922444999217987, -0.017309151589870453, 0.03079863451421261, -0.02261940948665142, -0.03537916764616966, 0.051070842891931534, 0.0185458455234766, 0.08081884682178497, -0.014410729520022869, 0.028225209563970566, 0.02088175341486931, -0.021227214485406876, -0.0607873797416687, 0.019311323761940002, -0.018770135939121246, 0.028427060693502426, -0.04246402904391289, 0.02659093402326107, -0.0769333690404892, -0.04905993491411209, -0.011522906832396984, -0.022829048335552216, -0.04662168025970459, -0.019966159015893936, 0.018099110573530197, -0.05989999324083328, -0.04278945177793503, -0.03941403329372406, 0.03744170814752579, 0.011888859793543816, -0.05167124420404434, 0.033053018152713776, 0.020099163055419922, 0.03696823865175247, -0.03753877803683281, 0.03509430214762688, 0.004514230415225029, 0.012731794267892838, -0.03144010901451111, 0.04507914558053017, -0.02168247662484646, -0.004969966597855091, -0.03830007463693619, -0.039218660444021225, -0.08018996566534042, 0.03320969641208649, 0.05409330129623413, 0.00606234697625041, 0.05605999380350113, 0.00963329803198576, -0.07946162670850754, 0.04473479092121124, -0.033079762011766434, -0.038627058267593384, 0.0027883255388587713, 0.012338935397565365, -0.013469916768372059, -0.07969088107347488, -0.049208611249923706, -0.011625300161540508, 0.0005159033462405205, 0.04399972781538963, -0.0012424883898347616, 0.051688194274902344, -0.00293012079782784, 0.010963600128889084, -0.02920219860970974, -0.04047863930463791, 0.0024482409935444593, -0.04616088420152664, -0.03325086832046509, 0.010170272551476955, -0.0018723412649706006, 0.0326586477458477, -0.013315821997821331, -0.05660400539636612, 0.01671958714723587, 0.05846354737877846, 0.06754517555236816, -0.02031152881681919, 0.03517792373895645, 0.0025328388437628746, 0.0422794483602047, -0.058840833604335785, -0.04242520034313202, -0.010889427736401558, 0.05830814316868782, -0.044917184859514236, -0.003551534144207835, -0.021316420286893845, -0.05009505897760391, 0.009804164990782738, 0.004391578957438469, 0.012310568243265152, -0.010556765832006931, 0.031216729432344437, 0.009710229001939297, -0.00018497237761039287, 0.010383371263742447, 0.013156764209270477, -0.02066478133201599, 0.018329059705138206, 0.01421143114566803, 0.04331432282924652, -0.03635077178478241, -0.005524176638573408, -0.020366383716464043, 0.007996714673936367, 0.0004355312848929316, 0.012201189994812012, 0.007083581760525703, -0.007868602871894836, 0.002439318224787712, -0.005862279329448938, -0.035734813660383224, 0.04201917350292206, -0.02566510997712612, 0.015582847408950329, -0.0846920982003212, -0.05054722726345062, -0.015092376619577408, -0.004294217098504305, -0.000457854475826025, -0.06247060373425484, 0.018031349405646324, -0.013859743252396584, -0.01666244864463806, -0.04544903710484505, 0.022603115066885948, -0.027049869298934937, 0.010806004516780376, 0.005641347728669643, 0.02680642530322075, -0.005794995930045843, -0.012593305669724941, 0.0628514215350151, 0.012083983980119228, -0.03532489761710167, -0.06441423296928406, -0.0038793885614722967, 0.0006656927871517837, 0.05873189866542816, 0.025998525321483612, -0.01691296696662903, 0.03301692008972168, -0.011227005161345005, 0.004477541893720627, -0.015848129987716675, -0.0004925277316942811, 0.009339245036244392 ]
<p>I know that light does not interact with other light, but can interfere it, at least its amplitude. With that said, lights frequency can be changed via bouncing off matter, where matter might absorb some of that photons energy changing the frequency.. Does this imply that a high energy beam of light that intersects an <strike>non-</strike>visible beam of light, might be enough to bounce the light around at the intersection of the two laser beams to emit visible light? By changing its frequency? Could that also be controlled by the energy output of the other laser?</p>
g7432
[ 0.0305962972342968, 0.009243959560990334, 0.00501656997948885, 0.03774213045835495, -0.023733530193567276, 0.010316521860659122, -0.023253243416547775, 0.0302939023822546, -0.004696218762546778, -0.028002258390188217, 0.004189284052699804, -0.014016102999448776, 0.049139246344566345, -0.024831414222717285, -0.03280944749712944, 0.06187637150287628, 0.1024874821305275, 0.012767034582793713, 0.02140679769217968, 0.06260643154382706, -0.06778816133737564, 0.03620612993836403, -0.039338789880275726, -0.10633692890405655, -0.05569577217102051, -0.026238085702061653, 0.0295336302369833, -0.06840331107378006, -0.03304000198841095, -0.005520273931324482, -0.006409225054085255, -0.01774050109088421, 0.0296668391674757, -0.05127694085240364, -0.05908995121717453, -0.009424596093595028, 0.006507237441837788, -0.012765436433255672, -0.028054935857653618, 0.02482660487294197, 0.0023972599301487207, 0.05528674274682999, -0.017423953860998154, -0.005671794526278973, 0.020624643191695213, -0.02156350202858448, 0.042659416794776917, -0.0010136713972315192, -0.006276996806263924, -0.022459618747234344, -0.012950729578733444, -0.001139597618021071, -0.025522736832499504, 0.02800648659467697, 0.02042512409389019, 0.02669798769056797, 0.0047394344583153725, -0.008910141885280609, 0.08568403869867325, 0.014082113280892372, 0.01526500191539526, -0.05276433005928993, 0.0022812350653111935, 0.01322957780212164, 0.01110971998423338, -0.06391514092683792, -0.016995452344417572, -0.08578256517648697, 0.0037652133032679558, -0.033583369106054306, -0.020391225814819336, -0.02126477286219597, -0.03300889953970909, -0.018362412229180336, 0.010031264275312424, -0.021580534055829048, 0.02526589296758175, -0.006723372265696526, -0.06402825564146042, 0.015140744857490063, -0.03688863664865494, 0.01076248288154602, 0.007170604541897774, -0.03589257970452309, 0.05442141741514206, -0.05260509252548218, -0.03300553932785988, -0.04357952997088432, -0.004036230500787497, -0.04056483879685402, 0.08417457342147827, 0.011339068412780762, 0.02236315794289112, -0.00864868052303791, -0.07650487124919891, -0.010408430360257626, 0.02082868479192257, 0.020481891930103302, 0.021435417234897614, -0.004760820418596268, -0.03789028152823448, -0.016635136678814888, 0.007866038009524345, -0.006598927080631256, 0.00683502946048975, -0.07295340299606323, 0.005756116006523371, -0.04321429505944252, -0.0409083217382431, 0.0029083392582833767, -0.003863302757963538, -0.11071071773767471, 0.011429174803197384, -0.04120815545320511, -0.04620024189352989, -0.04497085139155388, 0.08994416892528534, 0.0017379893688485026, -0.024035397917032242, 0.07346832007169724, 0.09152916073799133, -0.022036433219909668, 0.0027534186374396086, 0.04005403444170952, 0.003077883506193757, 0.023820916190743446, 0.03432444855570793, 0.006994279101490974, 0.0007886689272709191, -0.07687854766845703, -0.008530725724995136, 0.015604150481522083, 0.008541392162442207, 0.030040498822927475, 0.03302628919482231, -0.01672615110874176, 0.09329453110694885, -0.015530379489064217, 0.012742872349917889, 0.004613905213773251, 0.03556111082434654, 0.01731949858367443, -0.029727375134825706, -0.032650452107191086, 0.01699649728834629, 0.06773263961076736, -0.01860920526087284, -0.027386801317334175, -0.005008745938539505, 0.040894802659749985, 0.03435418754816055, 0.04396233335137367, 0.0021569966338574886, -0.04156748950481415, -0.031957849860191345, 0.020889906212687492, 0.03957486152648926, 0.024448392912745476, -0.019869962707161903, 0.017727060243487358, 0.02690759301185608, -0.025445744395256042, -0.01141059398651123, -0.0013261492131277919, 0.0020299700554460287, 0.024591520428657532, 0.035693295300006866, -0.024927398189902306, 0.008215159177780151, -0.022481350228190422, -0.02138764224946499, 0.018757302314043045, -0.02973158471286297, 0.010228559374809265, 0.044229257851839066, 0.017574815079569817, 0.021218514069914818, -0.020199870690703392, -0.005279603414237499, 0.013933796435594559, -0.06069735810160637, -0.058203406631946564, -0.035560090094804764, -0.011718487367033958, 0.021535450592637062, 0.04172487556934357, -0.01980566419661045, -0.012690876610577106, -0.03654720261693001, 0.02388136275112629, -0.06647472083568573, -0.013416285626590252, 0.005263383500277996, -0.02786734700202942, 0.02969917468726635, -0.018320640549063683, -0.013570002280175686, 0.02628522738814354, -0.018735097721219063, 0.014152017422020435, -0.012842979282140732, 0.05900981277227402, -0.0342879593372345, -0.002747216960415244, 0.06353840976953506, 0.06047864630818367, -0.0163640808314085, 0.0014613867970183492, -0.03943860903382301, 0.0056601171381771564, 0.026717757806181908, -0.01221065316349268, 0.04244648292660713, 0.05480493977665901, 0.005030000116676092, 0.019858088344335556, -0.050126757472753525, 0.0011065027210861444, 0.013030842877924442, -0.008244939148426056, 0.00773105351254344, 0.041024405509233475, 0.030675603076815605, -0.0208071768283844, -0.016376344487071037, 0.02799084596335888, -0.02669946849346161, 0.009242361411452293, -0.01636439748108387, 0.02198808267712593, -0.012911858037114143, 0.0053762453608214855, -0.022113429382443428, -0.022073306143283844, 0.017469065263867378, 0.006479439791291952, 0.005998053587973118, 0.02644476667046547, 0.0009082041797228158, 0.00811860803514719, 0.056177329272031784, -0.0813799723982811, -0.01181252021342516, 0.02236868627369404, -0.0013404408236965537, -0.017817527055740356, -0.013384533114731312, 0.007612853776663542, -0.028707163408398628, -0.018952185288071632, 0.06357040256261826, 0.019573425874114037, -0.03358091413974762, -0.035883378237485886, -0.058988768607378006, -0.0340527668595314, 0.02259877696633339, 0.026466859504580498, -0.10841754078865051, -0.041502054780721664, -0.044423047453165054, -0.023001620545983315, 0.011428623460233212, 0.02303834818303585, -0.011741464957594872, -0.0014250612584874034, 0.026004930958151817, 0.009899290278553963, -0.10130733251571655, -0.01700512506067753, -0.04021650552749634, -0.011697792448103428, 0.035414472222328186, -0.010020536370575428, 0.00743443239480257, 0.040002379566431046, -0.006687904242426157, -0.015718191862106323, 0.03229223191738129, -0.011909661814570427, -0.03858916833996773, 0.04911123216152191, -0.043219681829214096, -0.03659405559301376, 0.04036255180835724, -0.04303739592432976, 0.03679540008306503, -0.036247048527002335, -0.005912355147302151, -0.003385246731340885, 0.014826541766524315, -0.013062959536910057, -0.019988788291811943, -0.004235405474901199, -0.08692838251590729, 0.0006394859519787133, 0.007805697154253721, 0.0747472420334816, -0.019992779940366745, 0.04095697030425072, 0.025292403995990753, -0.013662436045706272, -0.038739945739507675, 0.014746403321623802, 0.01663115620613098, -0.00121387280523777, -0.048492591828107834, 0.01556266937404871, 0.022798601537942886, 0.005306903272867203, -0.0175797026604414, 0.07567636668682098, -0.00867287814617157, 0.045211151242256165, -0.05019153282046318, -0.010991683229804039, 0.04968848079442978, 0.013509252108633518, -0.0008265298092737794, 0.038514308631420135, 0.03434661775827408, 0.031167883425951004, 0.0018804616993293166, -0.07642870396375656, -0.030257975682616234, -0.017023226246237755, 0.02523595280945301, -0.017871521413326263, 0.018917372450232506, 0.020911583676934242, 0.03731188550591469, 0.04894383251667023, -0.06861244887113571, -0.024306273087859154, 0.011885391548275948, -0.016944672912359238, 0.06443295627832413, 0.04389455169439316, 0.07557351887226105, 0.06005363166332245, 0.012319210916757584, 0.0008612956735305488, -0.015265030786395073, -0.03706235811114311, -0.010996252298355103, 0.022400109097361565, -0.021022874861955643, -0.03966112807393074, -0.005701074842363596, -0.022908108308911324, 0.08565075695514679, -0.01277998462319374, -0.010691423900425434, 0.019813649356365204, 0.04524119198322296, 0.03882589936256409, 0.02732955291867256, 0.02827155403792858, -0.02473791316151619, -0.03532400354743004, -0.00931540410965681, -0.041392721235752106, 0.06535933166742325, -0.03141891211271286, -0.046628259122371674, -0.0003434372483752668, -0.05350286141037941, 0.02277720347046852, -0.0022460680920630693, 0.035952772945165634, 0.03515945374965668, -0.06854800879955292, 0.0049459058791399, 0.02425045520067215, 0.027976229786872864, 0.026387281715869904, 0.08023025095462799, -0.0020230042282491922, -0.02678494155406952, 0.02671225555241108, -0.016041994094848633, 0.026278162375092506, 0.011590171605348587, -0.009046141989529133, 0.038791295140981674, 0.019623886793851852, 0.021895848214626312, 0.004912313539534807, 0.020663220435380936, 0.010784989222884178, -0.029099082574248314, -0.04853074997663498, -0.008152411319315434, 0.018658043816685677, 0.021382933482527733, 0.0292019285261631, -0.005879504140466452, -0.0003511844261083752, 0.010483006946742535, 0.010465429164469242, 0.0691741481423378, 0.02479986473917961, -0.032257433980703354, -0.10808685421943665, 0.02406683750450611, 0.03913426026701927, 0.03292490169405937, -0.008131123147904873, 0.005283887032419443, 0.017338020727038383, -0.0006899549043737352, -0.025025395676493645, -0.01756005734205246, -0.041617557406425476, -0.03418051451444626, -0.009491920471191406, 0.03878761827945709, 0.029540691524744034, 0.04929143562912941, 0.047313421964645386, 0.01863456889986992, 0.00021453230874612927, -0.003216569544747472, 0.02152339182794094, 0.039647623896598816, 0.04716634750366211, 0.00653491448611021, -0.040028661489486694, -0.033738892525434494, -0.031971275806427, 0.0307290218770504, 0.0327555350959301, -0.0058536590076982975, -0.02437892183661461, -0.019985100254416466, 0.02239249087870121, -0.009312874637544155, 0.00961354561150074, 0.05272422730922699, 0.03598806634545326, 0.0346125066280365, -0.05059513822197914, -0.027664843946695328, -0.028584815561771393, 0.013404886238276958, 0.08476029336452484, -0.061982639133930206, -0.0331081859767437, -0.002178180031478405, -0.05011136084794998, -0.08490744233131409, -0.06047654524445534, -0.017146430909633636, 0.02150430530309677, -0.014891636557877064, -0.0012073004618287086, -0.04828739911317825, 0.05887683108448982, 0.021011443808674812, 0.02671615593135357, 0.015392611734569073, -0.021622946485877037, 0.021732773631811142, -0.04132893681526184, 0.05112719535827637, 0.004610684234648943, -0.05869115889072418, -0.036226555705070496, -0.05979149043560028, 0.017715558409690857, 0.010862145572900772, 0.003029014216735959, 0.030311839655041695, 0.12240764498710632, 0.013969145715236664, -0.08579126000404358, -0.01385768037289381, -0.036780860275030136, 0.016774706542491913, -0.03447934240102768, 0.030576061457395554, -0.01609099842607975, 0.0372956246137619, -0.028080061078071594, 0.003526760032400489, -0.0026411304716020823, 0.03944159671664238, 0.025591375306248665, 0.039646849036216736, -0.00950960535556078, -0.03460047394037247, 0.03654031455516815, -0.05424441397190094, 0.006678193807601929, 0.019262302666902542, 0.05322343483567238, -0.02523421123623848, 0.021046629175543785, -0.027196532115340233, -0.0004768588114529848, 0.02132679894566536, -0.02160773053765297, -0.018647026270627975, -0.029415298253297806, -0.05680142715573311, 0.03763002157211304, 0.018155476078391075, -0.012533013708889484, -0.04745825007557869, 0.03409226983785629, -0.0372074730694294, -0.02166854776442051, 0.011283772997558117, 0.10064906626939774, -0.009887630119919777, -0.05180812627077103, 0.020915711298584938, 0.018248379230499268, -0.034744542092084885, -0.0412130244076252, -0.008986362256109715, -0.0378761887550354, -0.03851309046149254, 0.0356210358440876, 0.03534647822380066, -0.020428786054253578, 0.02748413011431694, 0.011312547139823437, -0.00025177429779432714, 0.049276165664196014, 0.008817887865006924, 0.0167464017868042, -0.03203163668513298, -0.032227467745542526, 0.0066493796184659, -0.030139019712805748, 0.024498451501131058, 0.02418062463402748, -0.05644192174077034, -0.013946943916380405, 0.01817801222205162, -0.017741983756422997, 0.0547681525349617, 0.04239032417535782, 0.010164743289351463, -0.029493674635887146, -0.021078038960695267, -0.02746500074863434, -0.0010813476983457804, -0.04291791468858719, 0.019302912056446075, 0.04678111523389816, -0.01170811615884304, 0.02002651058137417, 0.023955078795552254, -0.0063207452185451984, -0.004551297519356012, 0.021445730701088905, 0.05511859059333801, -0.03459559753537178, 0.08662734180688858, 0.008747391402721405, -0.03230469673871994, -0.037422604858875275, 0.04482465237379074, 0.012610305100679398, -0.009636429138481617, -0.019422665238380432, 0.0021658320911228657, 0.012993848882615566, 0.003796075005084276, 0.01985054649412632, -0.05999772623181343, -0.02704051323235035, 0.018420809879899025, 0.011986065655946732, -0.028060734272003174, -0.016000987961888313, -0.042438019067049026, -0.04077504575252533, 0.043010544031858444, -0.0046233064495027065, 0.020996397361159325, -0.04108612239360809, 0.021653877571225166, -0.007989863865077496, -0.010031899437308311, 0.0225601214915514, 0.000001949745183082996, -0.057312026619911194, -0.01568666286766529, -0.04832544922828674, 0.0011244788765907288, -0.01750195398926735, -0.04811420664191246, -0.007504056207835674, -0.053144752979278564, 0.040363628417253494, -0.0032101725228130817, 0.04204357787966728, 0.028420621529221535, -0.008757168427109718, 0.01832214742898941, 0.06654079258441925, -0.016945021227002144, 0.07038550078868866, -0.02125820703804493, -0.043771903961896896, 0.051875337958335876, -0.00869467481970787, -0.0614459291100502, 0.0592857263982296, 0.017160294577479362, 0.009748168289661407, -0.07562115043401718, -0.02672800049185753, -0.053911589086055756, -0.06148981302976608, 0.009889902547001839, 0.010260348208248615, -0.010852020233869553, -0.09219619631767273, 0.03298978880047798, -0.037857379764318466, -0.0321141853928566, 0.041378144174814224, -0.007121023256331682, -0.005983739625662565, 0.03492702171206474, 0.07624363154172897, -0.0002545758325140923, -0.012506542727351189, 0.018634505569934845, 0.0044431197457015514, 0.032287534326314926, 0.06367097795009613, -0.03935019299387932, -0.000939035729970783, 0.003167718881741166, -0.036898422986269, -0.012412307783961296, 0.038615595549345016, 0.016631044447422028, 0.06126078590750694, 0.04849163442850113, 0.008668891154229641, -0.02007371559739113, -0.06922639161348343, 0.008742370642721653, 0.10119161009788513, -0.016277018934488297, -0.04445555806159973, -0.06901935487985611, -0.008613638579845428, -0.012066831812262535, 0.036685746163129807, -0.051942504942417145, 0.03905656561255455, -0.008096332661807537, -0.07597228139638901, -0.024663720279932022, -0.005392346531152725, 0.002445766469463706, 0.023742424324154854, 0.03403233736753464, 0.018285896629095078, -0.015306374989449978, 0.0009637004695832729, -0.006796474102884531, 0.029518194496631622, 0.02818339876830578, -0.08506941050291061, -0.06627026200294495, 0.020497702062129974, -0.045972324907779694, 0.02001805417239666, -0.028437096625566483, 0.0584397166967392, 0.0656980574131012, 0.0028540329076349735, 0.054718077182769775, 0.05524531751871109, -0.011262240819633007, 0.03892256319522858, 0.0069959755055606365, 0.04901121184229851, 0.010163901373744011, 0.05976514890789986, -0.02854768931865692, -0.025860456749796867, -0.04608235880732536, -0.002602450782433152, 0.01341165229678154, 0.0064549921080470085, -0.04374203458428383, -0.03193191438913345, 0.05798802524805069, 0.03564198315143585, -0.026012184098362923, 0.029276607558131218, -0.024394135922193527, -0.000632044393569231, 0.019240276888012886, -0.049949761480093, -0.011068145744502544, 0.05396142974495888, 0.044636379927396774, -0.033000122755765915, -0.020872320979833603, -0.045496098697185516, -0.02283254638314247, 0.0827329009771347, 0.015124072320759296, 0.034591641277074814, -0.006259586662054062, 0.009772298857569695, 0.021686535328626633, 0.054941531270742416, -0.0037755605299025774, 0.01860203966498375, 0.009093287400901318, 0.005261701997369528, -0.054207708686590195, -0.014899973757565022, -0.01751663349568844, 0.003984002862125635, 0.05959047004580498, 0.011082026176154613, -0.003384531242772937, 0.03624451905488968, -0.024242188781499863, 0.030270438641309738, -0.011507868766784668, -0.009181431494653225, -0.025439929217100143, 0.018773294985294342, 0.011914023198187351, 0.01969372108578682, 0.013354136608541012, -0.0025408221408724785, 0.00797577016055584, -0.04342631250619888, -0.0161255095154047, 0.014256504364311695, 0.03671278432011604, -0.007204424124211073, 0.028508588671684265, -0.0048481738194823265, 0.03117571771144867, 0.009035579860210419, 0.001641774782910943, 0.049227941781282425, -0.08266864717006683, -0.0029227565973997116, 0.10723959654569626, -0.07150708884000778, -0.07873940467834473, 0.016743043437600136, 0.022036075592041016, -0.06540481746196747, 0.0040504527278244495, -0.011980374343693256, -0.04176892340183258, 0.025288939476013184, -0.05905162915587425, -0.00006279064837144688, -0.009551418013870716, 0.03703373298048973 ]
<p>Is there an easy way to understand and/or visualize the reciprocal lattice of a two or three dimensional solid-state lattice? What is the significance of the reciprocal lattice, and why do solid state physicists express things in terms of the reciprocal lattice rather than the real-space lattice?</p>
g7433
[ 0.014120073989033699, 0.06578277796506882, -0.0003309871244709939, -0.032087355852127075, -0.0067313918843865395, -0.025988956913352013, -0.0012751697795465589, 0.03563274070620537, 0.015990538522601128, -0.015749655663967133, -0.021854231134057045, 0.017464129254221916, 0.019300121814012527, -0.035245705395936966, 0.012849808670580387, -0.00603469368070364, 0.034284815192222595, 0.00960947759449482, 0.025041064247488976, 0.022243347018957138, -0.018391737714409828, 0.019620101898908615, 0.02067788876593113, -0.035468220710754395, -0.04346117749810219, 0.05250044912099838, 0.01170824933797121, -0.06596903502941132, 0.03788027912378311, -0.019679373130202293, 0.04806059971451759, -0.0605524480342865, 0.031072450801730156, -0.02724781259894371, -0.01716994307935238, -0.003536013187840581, -0.02195402793586254, 0.0774693414568901, -0.02736969105899334, -0.024158654734492302, 0.016639847308397293, -0.03175831958651543, 0.011092940345406532, -0.011818385683000088, 0.006515225861221552, -0.04172959923744202, -0.039949964731931686, -0.01514962688088417, 0.001242393278516829, -0.001922972034662962, 0.015142158605158329, 0.0648486539721489, 0.04539972171187401, 0.039844200015068054, 0.06292375177145004, -0.032368168234825134, -0.005605033133178949, -0.01670556515455246, 0.06835747510194778, -0.022149059921503067, 0.03173329681158066, 0.04361289367079735, 0.012994296848773956, -0.025265954434871674, 0.097608283162117, 0.0536496527493, -0.04299144819378853, 0.02977367304265499, 0.02977592684328556, 0.0021222028881311417, -0.026510974392294884, -0.0003351334307808429, 0.007733526173979044, -0.012758707627654076, -0.03095959685742855, -0.010523317381739616, 0.02492816187441349, -0.01013795007020235, 0.00041861881618387997, 0.016355635598301888, -0.04408036917448044, -0.06343921273946762, 0.02170172892510891, 0.007711878512054682, 0.0075035979971289635, 0.05018993839621544, 0.012393093667924404, 0.0007129247533157468, -0.04845651611685753, -0.016024066135287285, -0.006866054609417915, 0.04580416530370712, 0.061657145619392395, -0.004217390902340412, -0.08834712952375412, -0.004783380310982466, 0.0184780303388834, 0.03357170522212982, -0.029979102313518524, 0.08282004296779633, -0.03688691183924675, -0.014478503726422787, 0.03524987772107124, 0.03507980331778526, -0.039344657212495804, -0.013808351941406727, 0.010259699076414108, 0.018871478736400604, -0.009875735267996788, 0.05153878405690193, -0.0330875925719738, 0.0313911996781826, -0.012771176174283028, 0.0070892865769565105, 0.02756597474217415, 0.03958960250020027, 0.03867637738585472, -0.07729502022266388, -0.0021079175639897585, 0.03181319683790207, 0.08556258678436279, 0.01133304089307785, 0.014345472678542137, 0.0012675587786361575, -0.040879011154174805, -0.006136862561106682, 0.022386377677321434, 0.01637432724237442, 0.02543308399617672, 0.03134598955512047, 0.020877443253993988, 0.021019523963332176, -0.02553541027009487, -0.01178379263728857, -0.03605340048670769, 0.030476631596684456, -0.04280745983123779, -0.0038599104154855013, -0.015208451077342033, -0.008650233037769794, -0.019844669848680496, -0.0068775624968111515, -0.0698789656162262, -0.03159553185105324, 0.013663018122315407, -0.014375627040863037, -0.03468257188796997, -0.036505259573459625, 0.008593762293457985, 0.04877801612019539, -0.008501010946929455, 0.03746200352907181, -0.009548457339406013, -0.025810595601797104, 0.012459338642656803, -0.024628562852740288, 0.04636657238006592, -0.04763191565871239, 0.052596185356378555, 0.03589160740375519, 0.023948656395077705, 0.0005636662244796753, -0.07520509511232376, 0.028458062559366226, 0.04695955663919449, -0.05701970309019089, 0.011025573126971722, -0.06336180865764618, 0.0188803318887949, 0.0208284892141819, -0.01752527430653572, -0.006705909967422485, -0.012513600289821625, 0.09077388048171997, -0.026946498081088066, 0.03576011210680008, -0.02050694264471531, 0.03448924422264099, 0.07483484596014023, 0.007024189457297325, -0.02942521497607231, 0.007266152650117874, -0.0048562269657850266, 0.010718482546508312, 0.008538306690752506, 0.02377983182668686, 0.017066676169633865, 0.0526498407125473, -0.04028722271323204, 0.013140830211341381, -0.019927602261304855, -0.017471440136432648, -0.012892509810626507, 0.01108576264232397, 0.0031704511493444443, -0.05087459832429886, -0.030536871403455734, 0.07079911231994629, -0.012273183092474937, -0.032039690762758255, -0.04465347155928612, -0.0041849371045827866, 0.03196883201599121, 0.014885819517076015, -0.0006363457068800926, 0.022524148225784302, -0.050328806042671204, -0.03519637510180473, -0.0036816822830587626, 0.014956837520003319, -0.05593179911375046, -0.004223424941301346, 0.050827234983444214, 0.003344269236549735, 0.0662214457988739, -0.0003045217599719763, -0.04204176738858223, -0.05918395519256592, 0.0012133111013099551, -0.004742756020277739, -0.023136528208851814, -0.05566372722387314, -0.002779359696432948, 0.0053404257632792, -0.03305330500006676, -0.03216717764735222, 0.0005823558894917369, 0.051728505641222, 0.019417840987443924, 0.004528861027210951, -0.09549441188573837, -0.011094647459685802, -0.017279963940382004, -0.012498297728598118, 0.00535817863419652, -0.008820421993732452, -0.05936139449477196, 0.012667990289628506, 0.017485463991761208, 0.0044374470598995686, 0.019879693165421486, -0.037262968719005585, -0.00664597749710083, 0.03088190034031868, 0.04737696796655655, -0.013556293211877346, 0.07872547209262848, -0.011373537592589855, -0.005060313269495964, -0.010536730289459229, 0.034300729632377625, -0.003693065606057644, -0.05525306239724159, -0.05771487578749657, 0.002208536025136709, -0.009029189124703407, -0.013976167887449265, -0.009466459974646568, 0.016148997470736504, -0.018498437479138374, 0.03034590743482113, -0.07702071964740753, 0.012066841125488281, 0.03165186941623688, 0.008628047071397305, -0.03697627782821655, 0.03095371462404728, 0.04642510041594505, -0.020969348028302193, -0.015839936211705208, 0.024088295176625252, 0.055470239371061325, 0.012245572172105312, -0.035824451595544815, -0.032610416412353516, 0.021236397325992584, 0.03167102858424187, -0.058367397636175156, -0.0002802005037665367, -0.06796703487634659, -0.0035407652612775564, 0.046420276165008545, -0.019335029646754265, 0.03732290863990784, -0.013025938533246517, -0.019377682358026505, -0.03197990730404854, 0.0238551814109087, 0.030687376856803894, 0.005350108258426189, -0.006939377635717392, -0.004246940836310387, -0.049786172807216644, 0.003015971276909113, -0.04083605483174324, -0.044497326016426086, 0.007337369956076145, -0.03915465250611305, -0.011482156813144684, 0.05874170362949371, -0.000711088243406266, -0.008909342810511589, 0.048541001975536346, -0.0005735171143896878, 0.0013149388832971454, 0.007161461748182774, 0.003642961848527193, -0.020976265892386436, -0.057505685836076736, -0.026773158460855484, -0.03833208605647087, 0.03178993985056877, 0.010174187831580639, 0.015376714989542961, -0.05790334939956665, 0.053796082735061646, -0.004119093529880047, 0.01757320761680603, -0.004679602105170488, -0.015858342871069908, -0.03148207440972328, 0.0026211957447230816, 0.04514873027801514, -0.0320574976503849, -0.03118632361292839, 0.06277628988027573, -0.010828889906406403, -0.03440433740615845, -0.03789271041750908, -0.023881150409579277, -0.03397538512945175, -0.026198716834187508, -0.043338578194379807, -0.05973650515079498, -0.08309074491262436, -0.017329782247543335, -0.07059831917285919, -0.01295668538659811, 0.06213979423046112, -0.011532177217304707, -0.018285779282450676, -0.00456713791936636, -0.009840425103902817, -0.03244137763977051, 0.055652160197496414, -0.01883699558675289, -0.05070917680859566, -0.024274658411741257, 0.059627022594213486, -0.08159293979406357, 0.04505181685090065, 0.00898326002061367, 0.05417812988162041, -0.029191598296165466, -0.07536546885967255, 0.06716408580541611, -0.001673363265581429, 0.0218389593064785, -0.029900511726737022, -0.024459410458803177, -0.018359197303652763, -0.04875325411558151, 0.009806875139474869, 0.01596921868622303, -0.026465298607945442, 0.007857084274291992, 0.0014886845601722598, 0.0051658074371516705, -0.019520778208971024, 0.0005421127425506711, -0.025328250601887703, -0.03838234394788742, -0.013374238274991512, 0.0023844288662075996, 0.03578876331448555, -0.024929294362664223, -0.09891612082719803, 0.0008515198132954538, 0.003952088765799999, 0.01729142852127552, -0.024100521579384804, 0.047603413462638855, 0.047562435269355774, 0.0012540564639493823, 0.0007566670537926257, -0.0057795168831944466, -0.04237847030162811, 0.021798260509967804, -0.054733362048864365, -0.0028996525797992945, -0.01037568412721157, 0.03482721000909805, -0.09870921820402145, 0.014508646912872791, 0.022195814177393913, -0.013293656520545483, -0.015905248001217842, -0.010595753788948059, 0.014203188009560108, 0.021847814321517944, -0.04994318261742592, -0.021475359797477722, -0.02346818335354328, 0.00026723172049969435, -0.02204384282231331, -0.020058896392583847, 0.07431741803884506, -0.029364848509430885, -0.004093036986887455, 0.01597716473042965, -0.07057907432317734, 0.029039401561021805, 0.05619581788778305, -0.07126159220933914, 0.020914826542139053, 0.018857091665267944, -0.0344875305891037, 0.003831414273008704, 0.060634028166532516, 0.003380349138751626, 0.02533268742263317, 0.06329098343849182, 0.05701947584748268, -0.013329830951988697, 0.054900940507650375, 0.03796841949224472, 0.024082478135824203, -0.00261006155051291, -0.04627374932169914, 0.01152211893349886, 0.03903112933039665, 0.044674038887023926, 0.02852075733244419, -0.012295019812881947, -0.0707569494843483, -0.06084293872117996, -0.05050861835479736, 0.044085778295993805, -0.0632755309343338, 0.09041758626699448, 0.005588921252638102, -0.0071609774604439735, -0.02789301797747612, 0.03087429702281952, -0.038850557059049606, -0.02691778913140297, -0.05929006636142731, 0.05128728225827217, -0.012623238377273083, -0.019930124282836914, 0.009958552196621895, 0.01505714189261198, -0.0106407655403018, -0.03860771656036377, 0.0011635343544185162, -0.0028786479961127043, -0.00696890614926815, 0.014018233865499496, 0.01014880184084177, 0.055421601980924606, -0.007654245477169752, 0.00748899532482028, -0.025865310803055763, 0.01607106253504753, -0.011086184531450272, 0.024994296953082085, -0.055807020515203476, 0.015156134963035583, 0.020457850769162178, -0.005542290396988392, -0.007338964380323887, -0.023625295609235764, -0.014691418036818504, 0.017782066017389297, 0.042547788470983505, -0.02026086300611496, -0.03369167447090149, -0.02847503311932087, 0.04766852408647537, 0.036610934883356094, 0.015097959898412228, 0.015928681939840317, 0.09091714024543762, -0.0355607233941555, -0.0006531307590194046, 0.006341935601085424, -0.01804065890610218, 0.04137149080634117, -0.044573698192834854, 0.007380961906164885, 0.020170586183667183, -0.04927331954240799, 0.04019540548324585, 0.05096866562962532, -0.07989564538002014, -0.021440597251057625, 0.013747397810220718, 0.004861877299845219, 0.005782600492238998, 0.04191859811544418, -0.01459289900958538, 0.01144132949411869, 0.046936556696891785, 0.028172383084893227, -0.021951163187623024, -0.0065326448529958725, 0.04937228932976723, -0.0933510884642601, -0.026535792276263237, -0.06206987798213959, 0.002236476866528392, -0.010158264078199863, -0.033750422298908234, -0.015026522800326347, 0.07413887232542038, -0.03947640210390091, 0.03661512956023216, 0.020020686089992523, -0.020534463226795197, -0.008447669446468353, -0.0707651674747467, 0.0035325780045241117, -0.0017529287142679095, -0.07240761816501617, -0.06433241814374924, 0.019246038049459457, 0.011694238521158695, 0.016359131783246994, 0.017278116196393967, 0.05222088843584061, -0.015852252021431923, 0.007913676090538502, -0.048685748130083084, 0.021587062627077103, -0.016643226146697998, 0.014172922819852829, 0.026434164494276047, 0.01636800728738308, -0.02021668292582035, 0.02406064234673977, 0.005487592425197363, 0.008822763338685036, -0.04212653636932373, 0.06293569505214691, 0.013200749643146992, -0.03654896840453148, 0.031361088156700134, -0.013342294842004776, 0.0787874236702919, 0.02056666649878025, -0.048673663288354874, -0.016483867540955544, -0.02271384187042713, -0.009140605106949806, 0.04392525181174278, 0.01346281822770834, -0.01277804933488369, -0.0029027804266661406, 0.011883297003805637, 0.004762119147926569, 0.009680356830358505, 0.09030909091234207, -0.017770791426301003, -0.007557535544037819, 0.046451836824417114, -0.028430098667740822, -0.011799370869994164, -0.006764075718820095, 0.04518013820052147, 0.00033885709126479924, -0.03017457015812397, -0.028527550399303436, 0.0008510307525284588, 0.006656034849584103, 0.0393257662653923, 0.030893148854374886, -0.051409170031547546, -0.0430200919508934, 0.02392357401549816, 0.032657939940690994, 0.01113364938646555, 0.05077125504612923, 0.035856347531080246, 0.08703720569610596, -0.004037807695567608, 0.044929031282663345, -0.012584338895976543, 0.0027197804301977158, -0.06016527861356735, -0.011077706702053547, -0.05426289513707161, 0.024949299171566963, -0.05392247810959816, -0.03868791460990906, -0.01023995690047741, -0.02294258587062359, -0.027578145265579224, 0.09427132457494736, -0.04547855257987976, 0.07645731419324875, 0.03839848190546036, 0.06237780302762985, -0.003046188037842512, -0.018293090164661407, 0.010941511020064354, 0.01383163221180439, 0.0036441832780838013, -0.004298217128962278, -0.020331144332885742, 0.009291119873523712, -0.0037883780896663666, 0.0526668056845665, -0.004834044259041548, 0.03244298696517944, 0.08795463293790817, -0.07019297778606415, 0.004245375748723745, -0.0029301398899406195, -0.03501840680837631, -0.07412801682949066, 0.03776242583990097, -0.032964181154966354, 0.013815855607390404, 0.0476415753364563, 0.04323110729455948, 0.04765191674232483, -0.06656733900308609, 0.04453776776790619, 0.033264465630054474, -0.004518338944762945, 0.016695208847522736, -0.0039200070314109325, 0.009603451006114483, 0.07043185830116272, 0.08357714861631393, -0.0031631398014724255, -0.023960303515195847, 0.004397449549287558, 0.02884112484753132, 0.0424257256090641, -0.05663144215941429, 0.015019052661955357, 0.04286140948534012, -0.029125824570655823, -0.005275098606944084, -0.0500720776617527, -0.0023303283378481865, -0.013045880943536758, -0.0337497740983963, 0.028420891612768173, 0.03895815834403038, -0.017886396497488022, -0.03341982513666153, -0.0027850684709846973, 0.004493795335292816, 0.02092655561864376, 0.025200743228197098, 0.044530853629112244, -0.00852393452078104, -0.061075810343027115, -0.10239075869321823, 0.01029282622039318, -0.015598058700561523, -0.036417193710803986, -0.02957100421190262, -0.01585559733211994, 0.03568979352712631, -0.04285849630832672, -0.02732858620584011, 0.0012185419909656048, -0.010284660384058952, -0.06681861728429794, 0.041335102170705795, 0.03534925356507301, -0.023705247789621353, -0.0063966503366827965, -0.01578815095126629, -0.0033802008256316185, 0.019454391673207283, -0.05345935747027397, 0.035434968769550323, 0.0951237678527832, 0.0427316352725029, 0.027743631973862648, -0.018193518742918968, 0.041769858449697495, 0.030222440138459206, 0.04139414802193642, -0.10117179900407791, -0.044069353491067886, 0.025723423808813095, -0.02190416119992733, -0.036253657191991806, 0.01818098872900009, 0.025469988584518433, -0.005726347211748362, 0.006965323351323605, 0.029748830944299698, -0.01872551254928112, 0.005093035753816366, -0.005579184275120497, -0.009454312734305859, -0.0047491127625107765, 0.00241900235414505, 0.03769160434603691, -0.05109274759888649, 0.043596051633358, -0.0025112824514508247, 0.0012166853994131088, -0.04183158278465271, 0.005027866456657648, 0.0547386035323143, 0.028983619064092636, -0.004967718850821257, 0.006902224384248257, 0.025816453620791435, -0.017267344519495964, -0.014353474602103233, 0.0031055842991918325, 0.010581833310425282, -0.03792322799563408, 0.04161684215068817, -0.023395320400595665, -0.014687445014715195, -0.03879709169268608, 0.02876381203532219, -0.005714010447263718, -0.016560958698391914, 0.032940275967121124, 0.12022122740745544, 0.03648504987359047, 0.08379589766263962, 0.0340801365673542, 0.03413747251033783, -0.007456445600837469, 0.07619806379079819, -0.004430071450769901, -0.00508295651525259, 0.001152187236584723, 0.02298668399453163, -0.017587948590517044, 0.021768325939774513, -0.010227253660559654, -0.042574442923069, 0.005597634240984917, -0.056335803121328354, -0.04694407060742378, 0.03440472483634949, 0.0657774955034256, -0.06390059739351273, -0.04983019828796387, 0.030965248122811317, -0.026135481894016266, -0.04445936903357506, 0.0313275121152401, 0.017601069062948227, 0.0014495475916191936, 0.014901289716362953, -0.011814034543931484, -0.01308358833193779, -0.013888519257307053, 0.05173039436340332, -0.003007750492542982, -0.007660037837922573, -0.06500007957220078, -0.021302223205566406, -0.06954418867826462, 0.021943392232060432 ]
<p>For two different chemical substances there are two open valves with <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_rate" rel="nofollow">flow rates</a> $$Q_1=a\frac{m^3}{h}\ \text{ and }\ \ Q_2=b\frac{m^3}{h},$$ leading into seperate cables. </p> <p>Next, the cables join, the substances mix perfectly and they flow along together. </p> <p>Then during the route, there is an observational volume $V$ (e.g. a cylinder or length $d$ and cross section $A$).</p> <blockquote> <p>How long is the residence time $\Delta t$ of a particle of the mixture inside the volume?</p> </blockquote>
g7434
[ 0.050979066640138626, 0.03166309744119644, -0.00824605394154787, -0.02915782667696476, 0.058857254683971405, -0.020215798169374466, 0.043369777500629425, 0.027624638751149178, -0.03811850771307945, -0.02867846190929413, -0.006196410395205021, 0.042469512671232224, 0.02161302976310253, 0.0025104405358433723, 0.02459852397441864, 0.008513761684298515, 0.05753772333264351, -0.01824057847261429, 0.025841621682047844, 0.021659381687641144, -0.04263632744550705, -0.0074884626083076, 0.018154079094529152, -0.04978492110967636, 0.025389647111296654, -0.057532794773578644, 0.00799872912466526, -0.03258994221687317, -0.0907648503780365, -0.04046149179339409, 0.006367774214595556, 0.021310383453965187, 0.013195868581533432, 0.012333526276051998, -0.034719180315732956, -0.038696352392435074, -0.02734954282641411, -0.023500196635723114, -0.018878644332289696, -0.016732288524508476, 0.0548224039375782, -0.05067486688494682, 0.040855444967746735, -0.055309198796749115, -0.012782083824276924, 0.0032186766620725393, -0.027975821867585182, -0.034963347017765045, -0.00043687433935701847, -0.019750965759158134, -0.004375551827251911, 0.07622503489255905, -0.057354554533958435, 0.012835009954869747, -0.03593684360384941, 0.03524032607674599, 0.027023784816265106, -0.042481258511543274, 0.012306803837418556, 0.02247992530465126, -0.007826525717973709, -0.037681713700294495, 0.03218352794647217, 0.022174006327986717, 0.09290853887796402, 0.0435350202023983, -0.024459319189190865, 0.0034649153240025043, 0.09664202481508255, 0.06495917588472366, -0.016026640310883522, -0.05083708092570305, 0.03490807116031647, -0.022251877933740616, -0.0009069371153600514, -0.04695660620927811, -0.020575081929564476, -0.004608933813869953, 0.04320143908262253, -0.008607728406786919, -0.045237746089696884, 0.07154003530740738, 0.013695472851395607, -0.001751063042320311, 0.04886532947421074, 0.04809543862938881, 0.02942320890724659, -0.04088672250509262, -0.04411710053682327, 0.00991206243634224, -0.002095242263749242, -0.061874598264694214, 0.011523373425006866, 0.011664971709251404, -0.016429943963885307, -0.04443685710430145, -0.07964491099119186, 0.053332291543483734, 0.00718650734052062, 0.0500909797847271, 0.000415408838307485, 0.035788990557193756, -0.04176284745335579, 0.011332018300890923, -0.03584887459874153, -0.00793201569467783, -0.015021787956357002, 0.023736245930194855, -0.072505883872509, -0.04446052014827728, -0.052380871027708054, -0.020788373425602913, -0.06354627013206482, 0.03556148707866669, 0.024814864620566368, -0.008309178054332733, -0.041085436940193176, 0.039008527994155884, -0.07909812778234482, -0.014989153482019901, 0.02320186235010624, 0.04155018553137779, -0.00161234219558537, -0.04287392273545265, 0.00894286297261715, 0.03503501042723656, -0.00019943961524404585, 0.04238622263073921, 0.05237497389316559, 0.03653649240732193, 0.02311163768172264, -0.010225823149085045, 0.006569696590304375, -0.0014907442964613438, -0.030368924140930176, -0.015551581978797913, 0.04925044998526573, -0.0027516218833625317, -0.000928858236875385, 0.050989001989364624, 0.0071302540600299835, -0.06013257056474686, 0.008457009680569172, 0.01553688757121563, -0.03563055396080017, 0.02197536639869213, 0.048716429620981216, -0.01631172001361847, -0.017946340143680573, -0.027426324784755707, -0.006001755129545927, 0.07818850874900818, 0.005443224683403969, 0.0037428231444209814, -0.0020183452870696783, 0.04241885617375374, 0.015517213381826878, 0.01638365350663662, 0.05206885561347008, -0.03147239610552788, 0.019605480134487152, -0.014057441614568233, 0.031787846237421036, -0.03892476484179497, -0.09016428887844086, -0.01754184439778328, 0.011170858517289162, -0.0823102667927742, 0.05090615153312683, -0.03443720564246178, -0.016443772241473198, -0.015605127438902855, -0.05939072370529175, 0.05783490836620331, -0.023805320262908936, -0.030589992180466652, 0.02814074419438839, -0.054537754505872726, -0.001072267652489245, 0.032220467925071716, 0.04794217273592949, -0.009779323823750019, -0.00992904044687748, -0.07477909326553345, 0.02059161849319935, 0.021850358694791794, 0.01135645154863596, -0.008905832655727863, -0.10976850241422653, -0.01749311573803425, -0.027836043387651443, -0.025564810261130333, -0.014124431647360325, 0.056051917374134064, -0.012463281862437725, -0.005677338689565659, 0.024346668273210526, -0.047121383249759674, -0.018407437950372696, -0.01042198296636343, -0.017796305939555168, -0.014438682235777378, 0.046838827431201935, 0.032125819474458694, 0.01845656894147396, -0.0014493308262899518, -0.02287166379392147, 0.021897349506616592, -0.022502917796373367, 0.06428074091672897, 0.009862666018307209, 0.0620872937142849, -0.007017465773969889, 0.009191764518618584, -0.03258948028087616, -0.08581284433603287, 0.0648326426744461, 0.018168175593018532, 0.050412677228450775, -0.04439014196395874, 0.0036909428890794516, -0.004304397851228714, 0.042193930596113205, -0.07568535953760147, 0.05377963185310364, -0.015689847990870476, 0.017107592895627022, -0.05027921125292778, -0.06684020161628723, -0.008174845017492771, -0.038261253386735916, 0.005469906143844128, -0.017598172649741173, -0.03513135761022568, 0.014145721681416035, 0.0020470689050853252, 0.013391674496233463, -0.009022817015647888, 0.029280677437782288, -0.015074978582561016, 0.03303242474794388, 0.015907252207398415, -0.07692210376262665, 0.06934857368469238, -0.007209768984466791, -0.0518573522567749, 0.021787993609905243, 0.021023394539952278, 0.011299636214971542, 0.03506768122315407, -0.0025113397277891636, -0.025521866977214813, 0.03748941048979759, -0.018139466643333435, -0.028113506734371185, -0.004408540669828653, -0.026041489094495773, 0.03346904739737511, -0.030494840815663338, -0.05383981391787529, -0.06288604438304901, 0.010098179802298546, 0.09153743088245392, -0.029331382364034653, -0.07016965001821518, 0.01028523314744234, 0.009279634803533554, 0.014519774354994297, 0.03253985941410065, 0.035965871065855026, 0.0009590825065970421, -0.03804326429963112, 0.056760694831609726, 0.014208761975169182, -0.022639330476522446, 0.021552283316850662, -0.016346346586942673, -0.03879799693822861, -0.045661259442567825, 0.024527953937649727, -0.004491035360842943, -0.024545766413211823, -0.033602531999349594, 0.045702844858169556, 0.01868935488164425, -0.025509215891361237, 0.026527760550379753, 0.04208415374159813, 0.006030168384313583, -0.02660951390862465, -0.015785805881023407, 0.03954274579882622, 0.025670193135738373, 0.06992556899785995, 0.06745216995477676, 0.028158359229564667, 0.05722874030470848, -0.018698981031775475, 0.017556441947817802, 0.01567711867392063, -0.015845265239477158, 0.006531890481710434, 0.017782161012291908, 0.024416526779532433, 0.0025854508858174086, -0.016151322051882744, -0.03440725430846214, -0.024129774421453476, -0.004655902739614248, 0.007019859738647938, 0.06977608799934387, -0.004212195053696632, 0.008131268434226513, -0.05844244733452797, 0.017235085368156433, -0.03642198443412781, -0.017619071528315544, 0.05806301161646843, -0.011478368192911148, -0.0201127752661705, -0.013635708950459957, -0.04538395255804062, 0.027051394805312157, -0.021160636097192764, 0.03594953194260597, -0.04860564321279526, -0.0036074393428862095, 0.0037858395371586084, -0.010346923023462296, 0.011626112274825573, 0.010979478247463703, -0.008527938276529312, 0.021566059440374374, -0.019090870395302773, 0.04800206795334816, -0.06849146634340286, -0.003209111513569951, 0.01922299899160862, -0.005434941500425339, -0.016734382137656212, -0.041237011551856995, -0.01790940761566162, -0.018263665959239006, 0.021841855719685555, 0.0029722985345870256, -0.04227925091981888, -0.004708587657660246, 0.05898280814290047, 0.006687040440738201, 0.03826325386762619, 0.023723747581243515, 0.010921172797679901, -0.002129027619957924, -0.017774542793631554, 0.022346507757902145, 0.008216528221964836, 0.03092089295387268, -0.010470719076693058, 0.004326045513153076, -0.04184868186712265, 0.030062532052397728, -0.050915077328681946, 0.0025615408085286617, 0.03748888522386551, -0.04811949282884598, -0.022512011229991913, 0.027953563258051872, 0.07806293666362762, 0.031174134463071823, 0.005194891709834337, -0.08177830278873444, -0.041703227907419205, -0.07788696140050888, 0.0472247488796711, 0.05872246250510216, -0.062028076499700546, -0.0045737698674201965, 0.0014852889580652118, -0.01877489872276783, 0.03696252405643463, 0.002281160093843937, 0.0015386486193165183, -0.044372063130140305, -0.04848939925432205, -0.04296284168958664, -0.01054640393704176, -0.034856777638196945, -0.015357446856796741, 0.015765398740768433, -0.07265166193246841, 0.046156588941812515, -0.02325451374053955, -0.03901726007461548, -0.03452826291322708, -0.02161775901913643, 0.04784683883190155, 0.02795311063528061, 0.03881312534213066, -0.0035198593977838755, -0.0069506410509347916, -0.043016765266656876, -0.005520863924175501, -0.049223318696022034, -0.0024600501637905836, 0.038689374923706055, 0.052288178354501724, -0.002246990567073226, 0.016598934307694435, 0.0124818105250597, 0.025376228615641594, -0.028720403090119362, -0.04675746336579323, -0.004125176928937435, -0.024098791182041168, 0.01774877868592739, -0.015140789560973644, 0.01179905328899622, -0.017628207802772522, -0.017071636393666267, -0.011523707769811153, 0.013742838986217976, -0.005413012579083443, 0.00008324407826876268, -0.036689985543489456, -0.0212250966578722, -0.004807622171938419, 0.009348186664283276, 0.03223955258727074, -0.016755975782871246, -0.022733189165592194, -0.0163333248347044, 0.006421898026019335, -0.08264712989330292, 0.012743838131427765, -0.020532017573714256, 0.02993473783135414, 0.051150284707546234, -0.006362734828144312, 0.01647314429283142, 0.050093017518520355, 0.029162714257836342, -0.015278412960469723, -0.020787710323929787, 0.031926918774843216, 0.029086831957101822, 0.07925023138523102, 0.019388727843761444, -0.07926236838102341, 0.0313398651778698, -0.03991246968507767, 0.08241608738899231, 0.07115525752305984, -0.012792035937309265, -0.0064070760272443295, -0.0000997973038465716, 0.014008475467562675, 0.0037584658712148666, 0.015647854655981064, 0.05590398237109184, 0.013740395195782185, -0.025832293555140495, 0.03174129128456116, -0.015543250367045403, -0.0309463981539011, -0.06838430464267731, -0.04909771308302879, 0.004767196718603373, 0.01148111280053854, -0.032746296375989914, 0.01180729828774929, -0.0027273704763501883, -0.010739414021372795, 0.031140681356191635, 0.01632935367524624, 0.03635711222887039, -0.03259817510843277, -0.000596372177824378, 0.06466580182313919, 0.043620236217975616, -0.034378793090581894, -0.011756843887269497, 0.034743960946798325, -0.018616808578372, 0.04387510567903519, 0.04251622036099434, -0.021625300869345665, -0.06908486038446426, -0.04495791345834732, 0.03239553049206734, -0.00456306291744113, 0.03709316626191139, 0.03823315352201462, 0.06053122878074646, 0.022998815402388573, -0.017617788165807724, -0.047714751213788986, 0.009086178615689278, -0.06554147601127625, 0.024805719032883644, -0.03280605003237724, -0.016145411878824234, -0.046551309525966644, 0.00572564173489809, -0.053606219589710236, 0.03011646494269371, 0.07968509942293167, -0.02751213312149048, -0.014209266752004623, 0.014755615033209324, 0.023687807843089104, 0.029091982170939445, 0.007458624430000782, -0.001997229177504778, 0.06447609513998032, -0.0031383202876895666, -0.029901575297117233, -0.06081603839993477, -0.003045308170840144, -0.027598818764090538, -0.03183157369494438, 0.023703180253505707, 0.007520705461502075, -0.01654277928173542, 0.06618703156709671, -0.03189603239297867, -0.0140053890645504, -0.07974614202976227, 0.03066885471343994, 0.054205697029829025, -0.0024124381598085165, -0.02589721977710724, 0.020183468237519264, -0.013675465248525143, 0.019898055121302605, -0.023639190942049026, -0.04821693152189255, -0.011192134581506252, -0.00775346951559186, 0.03842150792479515, 0.019656801596283913, -0.04722379893064499, -0.002340958919376135, -0.024845056235790253, 0.04905125871300697, -0.0008459871169179678, 0.008238187059760094, 0.030260883271694183, -0.005658212583512068, 0.0269447173923254, 0.05336092785000801, -0.014993897639214993, -0.03906380385160446, 0.028744997456669807, -0.006514227017760277, 0.05509344860911369, 0.011530419811606407, -0.0004027821705676615, 0.032736994326114655, -0.016418462619185448, 0.01325549278408289, 0.07097363471984863, -0.015030505135655403, -0.007240247912704945, 0.011969366110861301, 0.01732640154659748, -0.06228630617260933, -0.031194068491458893, 0.06544363498687744, -0.034101784229278564, 0.05014028772711754, 0.012338678352534771, -0.08763497322797775, 0.033005814999341965, -0.04075712710618973, 0.05515597388148308, 0.028236543759703636, -0.04566321521997452, -0.046697910875082016, -0.014620423316955566, -0.022925907745957375, -0.045315321534872055, 0.0225247610360384, 0.011026537045836449, 0.001905096578411758, 0.0267194751650095, 0.04673192277550697, 0.035593338310718536, -0.0391947478055954, -0.0067229666747152805, 0.014606257900595665, 0.011527291499078274, -0.042983729392290115, -0.04498518630862236, -0.016094891354441643, 0.022295275703072548, 0.0020954341161996126, -0.01746252179145813, 0.0069879693910479546, 0.034585561603307724, 0.010533250868320465, -0.06675833463668823, 0.05241984501481056, 0.028706109151244164, -0.043048467487096786, 0.0021795874927192926, -0.04587846249341965, -0.04898257181048393, 0.010143512859940529, -0.04916919022798538, 0.02053927071392536, 0.02058529667556286, 0.022319847717881203, 0.023844363167881966, 0.01502980012446642, -0.0011044825660064816, -0.0313977412879467, 0.005056991707533598, 0.006286301650106907, 0.0735095739364624, 0.001707949209958315, 0.008887906558811665, 0.021056905388832092, 0.013692958280444145, -0.03256192430853844, 0.05474081635475159, 0.044395238161087036, -0.028001386672258377, -0.04509701207280159, 0.05657196417450905, 0.01221198309212923, 0.0676976889371872, -0.06552896648645401, -0.010976806282997131, -0.039003223180770874, -0.01645585708320141, -0.019492201507091522, -0.030377035960555077, -0.008549420163035393, 0.04815078154206276, 0.10184764117002487, 0.05407077819108963, 0.0585687980055809, 0.03700553998351097, 0.021217143163084984, 0.049019064754247665, -0.03284968063235283, 0.05707288533449173, 0.02556547522544861, -0.03546176105737686, -0.01899266242980957, -0.013052662834525108, 0.010478874668478966, 0.02355583943426609, 0.04325301945209503, -0.00886823795735836, -0.024535896256566048, 0.0012971918331459165, -0.01115573849529028, 0.06206345930695534, -0.011780091561377048, -0.00499662384390831, -0.022526849061250687, -0.04973585531115532, 0.01633055880665779, 0.0627119392156601, 0.049550142139196396, -0.025665447115898132, -0.00765669159591198, 0.020555155351758003, -0.06405457854270935, -0.05091981962323189, 0.028702737763524055, -0.027979282662272453, 0.04541401192545891, 0.010638668201863766, -0.0317300520837307, 0.06633155047893524, 0.04234923794865608, 0.0526360385119915, -0.03239559009671211, 0.046755366027355194, 0.0033531810622662306, 0.007168356794863939, -0.020672818645834923, -0.02295556105673313, -0.010955989360809326, -0.042215779423713684, -0.07744965702295303, 0.020935628563165665, -0.023462750017642975, 0.07160913944244385, 0.062341634184122086, 0.027224991470575333, 0.007481752894818783, -0.026608005166053772, 0.04813578352332115, 0.04101147502660751, -0.020941846072673798, 0.011558977887034416, 0.022984609007835388, 0.03850246220827103, 0.03200550749897957, 0.009381439536809921, -0.004733620211482048, -0.007268174551427364, -0.0436682291328907, -0.016575882211327553, -0.01531909592449665, -0.02153918147087097, -0.026948150247335434, -0.007236015982925892, 0.044011276215314865, -0.017722969874739647, 0.023661913350224495, -0.011555613949894905, -0.07901164144277573, -0.0800025537610054, -0.00030232546851038933, 0.06593049317598343, -0.0033442312851548195, -0.027875453233718872, -0.036120299249887466, -0.012333149090409279, -0.06712868809700012, -0.024031303822994232, -0.07042454183101654, 0.009316232986748219, -0.005411927122622728, -0.02725864201784134, 0.028587298467755318, 0.011106214486062527, -0.038815584033727646, 0.04065879061818123, 0.028343740850687027, 0.015218082815408707, -0.019752059131860733, 0.055374208837747574, 0.0009050836088135839, -0.07107488065958023, 0.018490124493837357, -0.003909463528543711, -0.036583974957466125, -0.008683891966938972, 0.020810948684811592, 0.01342540979385376, -0.0007676722016185522, -0.03818756714463234, 0.02287357859313488, 0.03335518389940262, -0.08957380056381226, 0.07295870780944824, 0.0023323020432144403, -0.021053439006209373, -0.009396208450198174, 0.04657604545354843, -0.021166088059544563, 0.011011870577931404, 0.027932170778512955, -0.038332901895046234, -0.02203810214996338, -0.013881339691579342, -0.02810102142393589, -0.04096035286784172, 0.017597397789359093, 0.019686296582221985, -0.008216607384383678, 0.026756085455417633, 0.01321618165820837 ]
<p>I recently found <a href="http://www.mnn.com/food/beverages/stories/why-is-it-so-hard-to-walk-and-not-spill-your-coffee-physicists-have-the-answe" rel="nofollow">this article</a>, which describes how...</p> <blockquote> <p>It just so happens that the human stride has almost exactly the right frequency to drive the natural oscillations of coffee, when the fluid is in a typically sized coffee mug.</p> </blockquote> <p><em>Judging by appearance</em>, coffee and water's fluid dynamics seem rather similar. Unfortunately,they do not site a source, but they mention that the study was done by "a pair of fluid physicists at the University of California at Santa Barbara (UCSB)".</p> <p>My question is <strong>how different are the properties of water and coffee? Is this difference significant enough to cause a dramatic change in how either fluid behaves in a mug (while walking)?</strong></p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>: <a href="http://pre.aps.org/pdf/PRE/v85/i4/e046117" rel="nofollow">Here</a> is the actual published article. </p>
g7435
[ 0.016720155254006386, 0.06066158786416054, 0.0030444173607975245, 0.002451022155582905, 0.024869386106729507, 0.010744021274149418, 0.0441189780831337, 0.01012367382645607, -0.07670702785253525, -0.03054066002368927, 0.07050812989473343, -0.06028791517019272, 0.0384272001683712, 0.008965220302343369, -0.006344141438603401, -0.017431603744626045, -0.018778910860419273, -0.018345920369029045, -0.015064186416566372, -0.015058666467666626, 0.020456388592720032, 0.01828899420797825, 0.007846266031265259, -0.028120500966906548, -0.041759274899959564, -0.06350049376487732, -0.032200779765844345, -0.04497095197439194, -0.025102781131863594, -0.033043891191482544, 0.033462513238191605, -0.024015773087739944, 0.01803160086274147, -0.014759046025574207, -0.08326432853937149, 0.040288496762514114, -0.0017963651334866881, -0.03338877856731415, -0.024982893839478493, 0.022945493459701538, 0.014028249308466911, 0.014885313808918, -0.030891109257936478, 0.01349598728120327, 0.011274246498942375, 0.023165876045823097, 0.02356681041419506, 0.009353255853056908, -0.008003365248441696, -0.009799325838685036, -0.020629432052373886, -0.015361098572611809, -0.03206763416528702, 0.05162016302347183, -0.010622168891131878, 0.03112061321735382, 0.08549873530864716, 0.02627045288681984, 0.022324463352560997, -0.002631235169246793, 0.0018701786175370216, -0.027077551931142807, 0.0004220427945256233, 0.03055492416024208, -0.0014530257321894169, -0.02433571219444275, -0.01388787105679512, -0.023052966222167015, -0.0015731012681499124, -0.025268901139497757, -0.019522299990057945, -0.037549808621406555, -0.02265195921063423, 0.009451586753129959, 0.03326376527547836, 0.06936334073543549, 0.01723197102546692, -0.0024631910491734743, 0.055653635412454605, -0.014017784968018532, -0.039427097886800766, 0.06931914389133453, 0.01521285530179739, 0.03883380815386772, 0.10253413766622543, 0.0002743772929534316, -0.014240222983062267, 0.018280750140547752, 0.06729035079479218, 0.03292371332645416, -0.03963372856378555, -0.08118022978305817, 0.07782700657844543, 0.03738825023174286, -0.03200390189886093, -0.05680697411298752, -0.004598781932145357, 0.013103350065648556, -0.004645433742552996, 0.03624791279435158, 0.004084212705492973, -0.01358397863805294, 0.0028848254587501287, 0.019752830266952515, 0.006118404679000378, -0.03084390237927437, -0.0133689995855093, 0.03090289980173111, -0.026224981993436813, -0.05596927925944328, 0.022734565660357475, -0.031925249844789505, -0.009454041719436646, -0.0037950677797198296, -0.06257893890142441, -0.04259846359491348, 0.012627486139535904, 0.03219715133309364, 0.00330469966866076, 0.009161315858364105, -0.015949737280607224, 0.012781155295670033, -0.0104327742010355, 0.036737214773893356, 0.0383150577545166, 0.0012885211035609245, 0.04647834971547127, -0.025181077420711517, 0.028151055797934532, 0.04704516753554344, 0.0076214964501559734, 0.04022742062807083, -0.019105304032564163, -0.06390179693698883, 0.017810164019465446, 0.02065047062933445, 0.02558748610317707, 0.06834404170513153, 0.0010089408606290817, -0.0339721143245697, 0.09583289176225662, -0.006291290279477835, 0.05085703730583191, -0.01774098351597786, -0.03445141762495041, 0.008462350815534592, -0.005160417873412371, -0.05250539258122444, 0.03686148300766945, -0.0014938610838726163, 0.004406367428600788, -0.005353578366339207, -0.023951532319188118, 0.011732054874300957, -0.0076737976633012295, -0.013044423423707485, -0.0015846091555431485, 0.031817175447940826, -0.013226809911429882, 0.023950140923261642, 0.020038744434714317, -0.05071057751774788, 0.053008683025836945, 0.010795977897942066, -0.005158332176506519, 0.004951549228280783, -0.019092155620455742, -0.019778400659561157, 0.0042189015075564384, -0.018779948353767395, -0.002970365108922124, 0.00296759232878685, -0.05217912420630455, 0.06217529997229576, 0.014224556274712086, 0.010112116113305092, 0.044201821088790894, -0.10367009788751602, -0.01403418742120266, -0.05853396654129028, -0.046636730432510376, -0.0037867301143705845, -0.0856013149023056, -0.03981633111834526, 0.010293954983353615, 0.03863643854856491, 0.058322153985500336, 0.028361964970827103, -0.04501795768737793, -0.0155849764123559, -0.04937462881207466, -0.05561843886971474, 0.006534402258694172, 0.008056802675127983, 0.04793015867471695, -0.02191135473549366, -0.06169506907463074, 0.06456230580806732, -0.02300948277115822, 0.004061153624206781, -0.0012166148517280817, -0.006921315565705299, 0.010762475430965424, -0.015492334961891174, -0.038473453372716904, 0.0322808101773262, 0.012793155387043953, 0.011479169130325317, 0.026653915643692017, -0.052409578114748, 0.03505910560488701, 0.02037832699716091, -0.010210514068603516, -0.0022509824484586716, -0.009676081128418446, 0.0705927386879921, 0.03059684857726097, -0.0004435495939105749, -0.03520771861076355, 0.05437779054045677, 0.02056816965341568, 0.005154140293598175, -0.04588877782225609, -0.009243445470929146, -0.0007293074741028249, -0.05798984691500664, -0.06577157974243164, -0.0195351280272007, -0.022414620965719223, 0.03606165200471878, 0.016894575208425522, 0.05295207351446152, 0.034535374492406845, -0.018826337531208992, 0.03811405226588249, -0.006682270672172308, 0.024511558935046196, 0.043725576251745224, 0.036253396421670914, -0.043101657181978226, 0.06816667318344116, -0.0012216053437441587, -0.04690265282988548, 0.016564171761274338, 0.04992073401808739, -0.03551537171006203, -0.02198747918009758, -0.057990945875644684, 0.06308009475469589, 0.0190597977489233, 0.08309311419725418, -0.03971755877137184, -0.020565733313560486, 0.026662079617381096, 0.0008083722786977887, 0.05144732818007469, -0.017705244943499565, 0.03025856986641884, -0.10464898496866226, -0.04470036178827286, -0.0356108583509922, -0.07442665100097656, -0.005646893754601479, 0.045958612114191055, 0.07911030948162079, 0.013461609371006489, -0.012914310209453106, 0.06454537808895111, -0.041685543954372406, 0.032292380928993225, 0.04344953969120979, 0.00820356048643589, 0.01755397766828537, 0.02576543390750885, -0.06027112901210785, -0.05690852925181389, 0.006149684078991413, -0.06004035472869873, -0.029917743057012558, -0.01432398334145546, 0.016825631260871887, -0.04767536744475365, -0.036701761186122894, 0.03605080023407936, 0.025927288457751274, -0.04080236330628395, -0.0051136440597474575, -0.016544198617339134, 0.04889300838112831, 0.008353693410754204, 0.015179010108113289, 0.06717639416456223, -0.009868230670690536, 0.052195560187101364, -0.000697335519362241, 0.03092477098107338, -0.0009475152473896742, -0.04031508043408394, -0.06120973080396652, -0.009469308890402317, 0.05609229952096939, -0.0004947701818309724, 0.020453516393899918, 0.019447600468993187, -0.015125363133847713, 0.024534234777092934, -0.03185229003429413, -0.034105945378541946, -0.007252777926623821, -0.01291680708527565, 0.02337593398988247, 0.05801049992442131, -0.062488507479429245, 0.02598387748003006, -0.00834154523909092, -0.017604298889636993, -0.04929511994123459, 0.04710923507809639, 0.011269417591392994, 0.004577402025461197, -0.021329157054424286, -0.05343840271234512, -0.037544552236795425, 0.01161876693367958, 0.04696577042341232, 0.017512362450361252, -0.025860408321022987, 0.019183358177542686, -0.01750134862959385, -0.02811821736395359, 0.05007384717464447, -0.000512937898747623, -0.05588359758257866, -0.054488860070705414, -0.018140604719519615, -0.019036738201975822, 0.031615760177373886, 0.048175979405641556, 0.034025564789772034, -0.01366695761680603, 0.03488742187619209, -0.014465701766312122, -0.06243041157722473, -0.051498569548130035, -0.03927154093980789, 0.03359465301036835, 0.0037313031498342752, -0.0012301874812692404, -0.027365142479538918, -0.05265648663043976, 0.07051289081573486, -0.030942711979150772, -0.03535196930170059, -0.0323319137096405, -0.007833993062376976, -0.05366930738091469, 0.05192231014370918, 0.011223607696592808, 0.006169943604618311, 0.059480417519807816, -0.011776036582887173, -0.05145848169922829, 0.03320315480232239, -0.008625851944088936, -0.017002716660499573, -0.013592260889708996, -0.06963498145341873, 0.07170043885707855, -0.09386958181858063, 0.01169014722108841, -0.0014472987968474627, -0.04660142958164215, -0.02049674279987812, 0.06498812884092331, 0.02004712074995041, -0.015227525494992733, 0.01479488518089056, 0.03152082860469818, -0.025151856243610382, 0.003550194436684251, -0.0012461775913834572, 0.020080752670764923, 0.02306755818426609, -0.03037835843861103, 0.019897617399692535, -0.07398038357496262, -0.034586697816848755, -0.055838581174612045, 0.0781468003988266, -0.06349024176597595, -0.02284216694533825, 0.008462469093501568, 0.003458186751231551, 0.02910836599767208, 0.0393342599272728, -0.0035508074797689915, -0.05618951842188835, 0.03098410740494728, -0.018744071945548058, 0.08227270096540451, -0.0026744736824184656, -0.021655185148119926, -0.002458566799759865, 0.03505251184105873, 0.0002719451440498233, -0.021434523165225983, 0.0173579603433609, -0.005723568145185709, -0.05414970591664314, -0.023261748254299164, 0.006199053954333067, 0.015504113398492336, -0.054713934659957886, -0.0689997673034668, -0.03184526413679123, 0.06021410971879959, -0.01419876143336296, -0.03090023808181286, 0.036409396678209305, -0.0008501607808284461, 0.058293163776397705, 0.00685621565207839, 0.022112296894192696, 0.06300492584705353, 0.010561542585492134, 0.03815906122326851, 0.049313414841890335, 0.0011371573200449347, -0.05401027202606201, -0.0260284673422575, 0.006948943715542555, -0.0043400987051427364, 0.038408312946558, 0.04574420675635338, 0.007507714908570051, 0.023947695270180702, 0.049619533121585846, -0.043781477957963943, -0.0031782451551407576, -0.025289930403232574, -0.05537508428096771, 0.013060581870377064, 0.04237646609544754, -0.019033918157219887, 0.03181915730237961, 0.06527069956064224, -0.005694854073226452, -0.010999036021530628, -0.004244264680892229, -0.016956385225057602, 0.02542967163026333, 0.05888659507036209, 0.035870399326086044, 0.006069024093449116, -0.034727904945611954, 0.05028065666556358, 0.004192124120891094, -0.011665260419249535, -0.036973342299461365, -0.0028778885025531054, -0.047330502420663834, 0.012510324828326702, 0.01395805086940527, 0.030758053064346313, -0.0547870397567749, -0.037512145936489105, 0.004966269247233868, -0.06098897010087967, -0.030433623120188713, -0.026573438197374344, 0.04259528964757919, -0.03558461740612984, 0.015642806887626648, 0.04584234580397606, 0.0372282974421978, 0.0057950871996581554, 0.01108552422374487, 0.026237742975354195, -0.0035914324689656496, -0.04943392425775528, -0.005170597229152918, 0.006711989175528288, 0.06270214170217514, 0.015295466408133507, -0.003249275963753462, 0.029059097170829773, -0.008378501050174236, 0.021057212725281715, 0.00116926827467978, 0.013009770773351192, 0.04683077335357666, 0.001434038276784122, 0.007930341176688671, -0.04030155763030052, -0.010605914518237114, 0.021029748022556305, 0.03535889834165573, 0.021956583485007286, 0.04129941761493683, -0.023709900677204132, -0.0348307266831398, 0.04828281328082085, -0.02379142865538597, -0.06769819557666779, -0.010162127204239368, -0.015036504715681076, 0.020535005256533623, -0.01848745346069336, -0.04708954691886902, 0.06479199230670929, -0.0005730754928663373, -0.016766928136348724, 0.0037495929282158613, 0.04234323650598526, 0.03980296850204468, -0.017400164157152176, 0.010030988603830338, -0.041990965604782104, 0.04301437735557556, -0.04451223462820053, 0.029385868459939957, -0.05517398566007614, -0.0029615473467856646, 0.03514530509710312, -0.004197041969746351, -0.03439651057124138, -0.02575591951608658, -0.03316280618309975, 0.04994598403573036, 0.01401509903371334, 0.04540657997131348, 0.04157958924770355, 0.051033057272434235, 0.062491513788700104, -0.0015800092369318008, -0.002661279868334532, 0.0034070960246026516, -0.02561769261956215, -0.017451394349336624, 0.05035177990794182, -0.04308897629380226, -0.01350937969982624, 0.0034749589394778013, 0.0709192156791687, 0.011747402139008045, -0.007196971680969, 0.025350280106067657, -0.01193041168153286, 0.04032954201102257, -0.0038060802035033703, -0.05447429046034813, 0.04076093062758446, 0.05026724934577942, 0.03586972877383232, 0.01739305816590786, 0.002079237485304475, 0.03772183880209923, -0.08031892776489258, -0.013556720688939095, -0.029687149450182915, 0.03684858977794647, 0.056337762624025345, 0.03028181567788124, -0.012929918244481087, -0.005165723152458668, -0.030121274292469025, 0.0031234833877533674, -0.003192412666976452, 0.040952764451503754, 0.08097130060195923, 0.003307358594611287, 0.008338281884789467, 0.05190408229827881, -0.027644403278827667, -0.051154594868421555, 0.03671504184603691, -0.044203244149684906, 0.009951287880539894, -0.0451841726899147, 0.009190285578370094, 0.02598903886973858, -0.02838192693889141, -0.03540954738855362, 0.009330781176686287, 0.010083350352942944, -0.004875458776950836, -0.051951516419649124, 0.11601492017507553, 0.06333671510219574, 0.020699607208371162, -0.014078877866268158, -0.010878716595470905, -0.0008018655353225768, -0.01749560795724392, 0.03179073706269264, -0.06776707619428635, -0.011679340153932571, -0.04177278280258179, -0.05961175635457039, 0.07231549173593521, -0.026991859078407288, 0.05004257336258888, -0.014739569276571274, 0.03413516655564308, -0.02104283683001995, 0.0028475329745560884, -0.003165349829941988, 0.00487425085157156, -0.03721253201365471, 0.024228010326623917, -0.06541799008846283, 0.036302413791418076, 0.06933469325304031, -0.06111631914973259, -0.027407292276620865, -0.0619676411151886, 0.028679722920060158, -0.046456824988126755, -0.015395477414131165, -0.011461746878921986, -0.010219546966254711, -0.04820339381694794, -0.0008349837735295296, -0.06702277064323425, -0.01234003808349371, 0.004708379041403532, -0.016142375767230988, 0.041015204042196274, 0.030069565400481224, -0.015044414438307285, 0.016906535252928734, -0.01243663765490055, 0.053158409893512726, 0.05427098646759987, -0.026967912912368774, 0.003769380273297429, -0.08237610757350922, -0.018615178763866425, 0.021788401529192924, -0.00791098177433014, 0.006669740192592144, -0.008509211242198944, 0.04279692471027374, 0.007352910470217466, -0.015485689975321293, 0.033692967146635056, 0.0321771502494812, -0.03249286115169525, -0.030431143939495087, -0.016003955155611038, 0.03051597997546196, -0.03373343124985695, 0.021159201860427856, 0.03169417008757591, -0.03555850312113762, 0.03961622342467308, -0.04709022119641304, 0.023424910381436348, -0.009558414109051228, -0.045268937945365906, -0.02539742738008499, -0.013550843112170696, 0.01627952605485916, 0.0037377094849944115, -0.03152349218726158, -0.008306101895868778, 0.008785848505795002, -0.04119827225804329, 0.0063080252148211, 0.04925918951630592, 0.04809672012925148, -0.027935463935136795, -0.04424716532230377, 0.021830707788467407, 0.06294187158346176, -0.06313511729240417, -0.008068056777119637, 0.008006042800843716, 0.018947038799524307, -0.03870849683880806, 0.02963336743414402, -0.04045163467526436, 0.041899099946022034, 0.03458821028470993, -0.061262521892786026, 0.02105558291077614, -0.054409727454185486, 0.0037678105290979147, -0.011979364790022373, -0.0136204669252038, -0.0003047653299290687, -0.015466639772057533, -0.0007455583545379341, 0.006376322358846664, -0.048330605030059814, -0.0038226579781621695, 0.03841877356171608, 0.008288128301501274, 0.013551631942391396, 0.00016933634469751269, -0.023622967302799225, 0.020450763404369354, -0.004511138424277306, -0.00009885212784865871, 0.03106113150715828, -0.02674039453268051, 0.007501597981899977, -0.06003052368760109, -0.025389615446329117, -0.03594973310828209, -0.034748952835798264, -0.018250254914164543, 0.05154833570122719, -0.02646021358668804, 0.07716063410043716, 0.0007161254179663956, -0.01694915071129799, -0.026924490928649902, -0.012774803675711155, 0.005005949176847935, -0.060906898230314255, -0.04773437976837158, -0.001977877924218774, -0.0324653722345829, -0.0356682650744915, 0.008381267078220844, -0.014143676497042179, -0.03209063410758972, -0.03347281366586685, -0.01525850873440504, -0.039301685988903046, -0.04500341787934303, 0.015731198713183403, -0.031055958941578865, -0.022456927224993706, 0.02971610613167286, 0.056542158126831055, 0.06412913650274277, -0.026713043451309204, -0.024405281990766525, 0.05089373141527176, 0.06322316825389862, 0.009491806849837303, 0.010223204270005226, 0.002107548527419567, -0.08585520833730698, -0.0029363783542066813, 0.06499624997377396, -0.018959805369377136, -0.0612192377448082, 0.039661113172769547, 0.046912118792533875, 0.007864962331950665, -0.011557341553270817, -0.043321553617715836, -0.045512471348047256, -0.037646740674972534, 0.014144704677164555, 0.05229916796088219, -0.02191155031323433, 0.0026782285422086716, 0.04745693877339363, 0.04841381683945656, -0.0022065734956413507, -0.00867810845375061, 0.0409030020236969, -0.028448063880205154, 0.04182804003357887 ]
<p>Let us assume that there are two astronauts A and B who are floating in space. A sees B passing by and vice versa. A sends signals to B every minute. According to A since B is moving his clock will be slower. So B will receive the signals prior to the appointed minute. The same argument can be applied for B who will conclude A's clock is running slow. Who is right?</p>
g7436
[ 0.03369446471333504, 0.051625803112983704, 0.011754540726542473, -0.03485933318734169, -0.009792692959308624, 0.03382479399442673, 0.05324956029653549, -0.06375665962696075, -0.018988097086548805, -0.006823374889791012, -0.005679744761437178, 0.0640406459569931, -0.003153699915856123, 0.029497167095541954, -0.008834511041641235, -0.02099805697798729, 0.11029345542192459, -0.015143249183893204, -0.015890002250671387, 0.004223898518830538, 0.03750285878777504, 0.0837593749165535, -0.03254902735352516, -0.037470776587724686, -0.046365804970264435, -0.04585880786180496, -0.005271437112241983, -0.010194831527769566, -0.041544053703546524, -0.007655617780983448, 0.030299320816993713, 0.01821654662489891, -0.01061850693076849, -0.05665607005357742, -0.04674622416496277, -0.030042050406336784, -0.007406942080706358, -0.0038762888871133327, -0.09198049455881119, 0.06360741704702377, -0.0036935792304575443, -0.019356904551386833, -0.021952824667096138, -0.021898407489061356, 0.018008219078183174, 0.015564218163490295, 0.019348876550793648, 0.021332457661628723, 0.027838774025440216, -0.00840646680444479, -0.030048582702875137, 0.0029995478689670563, -0.03728916868567467, 0.011484911665320396, 0.015545892529189587, 0.04528442397713661, 0.006621546112000942, -0.01848364993929863, 0.04726000875234604, 0.04432923346757889, 0.02855624444782734, -0.0053059677593410015, 0.01769343577325344, 0.036938928067684174, 0.08978613466024399, 0.02133815363049507, 0.03140084818005562, -0.005530018359422684, 0.0445028617978096, -0.030300850048661232, 0.006319585721939802, -0.01998807117342949, -0.011239069513976574, 0.009495607577264309, -0.03746594116091728, 0.08813469111919403, 0.03571803867816925, 0.008507460355758667, -0.0242087971419096, 0.054572805762290955, -0.038583818823099136, -0.0374717153608799, 0.023353762924671173, 0.03149019926786423, 0.022944273427128792, 0.03944859653711319, 0.022408053278923035, -0.01947133056819439, 0.007742099463939667, 0.06799987703561783, -0.0196254700422287, -0.06591837853193283, 0.06979867070913315, -0.004655767697840929, -0.058373961597681046, 0.020818151533603668, 0.01912950910627842, -0.0033173467963933945, -0.036986205726861954, 0.027057714760303497, -0.0633014589548111, 0.011730924248695374, -0.049443319439888, -0.005932302679866552, 0.012367765419185162, -0.059096116572618484, 0.009548879228532314, -0.009135980159044266, -0.06595178693532944, -0.03845873102545738, 0.030007319524884224, -0.0867953673005104, 0.01785409078001976, -0.008880986832082272, -0.00767860934138298, -0.05328067019581795, 0.06217131018638611, 0.007079895585775375, -0.041759803891181946, 0.018033131957054138, -0.010377508588135242, -0.04375171661376953, -0.027273980900645256, 0.027140509337186813, 0.014435222372412682, 0.05622725933790207, -0.004488857928663492, 0.01523084007203579, 0.01724768988788128, 0.05517641827464104, -0.00494415033608675, 0.05051472783088684, 0.0189758762717247, 0.009346826002001762, -0.06259943544864655, -0.018797609955072403, 0.03258330002427101, -0.010800668969750404, 0.004229946527630091, -0.03332719951868057, 0.009631533175706863, -0.011712773703038692, 0.010740088298916817, -0.06814005970954895, -0.028800325468182564, 0.038144301623106, 0.028554106131196022, -0.003918661270290613, 0.004961288534104824, 0.047283273190259933, -0.021872594952583313, 0.08554685115814209, 0.007082368712872267, 0.018815454095602036, 0.012769768945872784, -0.011111171916127205, -0.003068088786676526, 0.008510562591254711, 0.0016718507977202535, -0.000180180708412081, 0.0691942349076271, -0.025260161608457565, -0.01626294106245041, 0.03363116458058357, -0.04651336371898651, 0.03038952313363552, 0.005357838701456785, -0.024206414818763733, -0.03160899505019188, -0.05753006786108017, -0.006451860070228577, -0.017143594101071358, 0.016496535390615463, 0.058883219957351685, 0.052857059985399246, 0.054676346480846405, 0.014163671061396599, -0.00760919414460659, -0.015937643125653267, 0.00770188495516777, -0.04009654000401497, -0.02944468893110752, -0.020204707980155945, -0.006562899798154831, -0.007421657908707857, -0.047412335872650146, -0.033220186829566956, -0.007666024379432201, -0.123122937977314, -0.026177600026130676, -0.033588822931051254, -0.04393472895026207, -0.011386480182409286, 0.010642949491739273, -0.027654897421598434, 0.00020984900766052306, 0.02078625001013279, 0.035840097814798355, 0.015765907242894173, 0.06640853732824326, 0.015499119646847248, -0.013633723370730877, 0.06817913055419922, 0.007683590520173311, 0.017659736797213554, -0.0009883424500003457, -0.00970100611448288, -0.0035111187025904655, 0.03421217203140259, -0.048761315643787384, 0.021083388477563858, 0.029130464419722557, 0.04407224804162979, -0.003436981001868844, -0.02796332538127899, 0.018726574257016182, -0.004897541832178831, 0.030544698238372803, -0.000021775598725071177, -0.01888214983046055, -0.021716445684432983, -0.02069309912621975, 0.016389992088079453, -0.05608314275741577, 0.0035029936116188765, -0.06488923728466034, -0.0365007109940052, -0.05508474260568619, -0.016632262617349625, 0.047014106065034866, 0.019464053213596344, -0.009330241940915585, 0.002976000774651766, 0.038607869297266006, 0.014489121735095978, 0.024765482172369957, 0.05756708234548569, 0.055265821516513824, 0.07674210518598557, 0.0449298731982708, -0.007278614677488804, 0.030525268986821175, -0.0028321987483650446, 0.011609294451773167, -0.013696092180907726, -0.0068239010870456696, 0.017622023820877075, -0.007261596620082855, -0.012153389863669872, 0.05451365187764168, -0.016384422779083252, 0.008812113665044308, -0.06485580652952194, -0.029515964910387993, -0.007998825050890446, -0.006870295386761427, -0.016289643943309784, 0.03935632482171059, -0.07789018005132675, -0.016049882397055626, 0.025721536949276924, -0.02937517873942852, 0.022650014609098434, 0.008234923705458641, 0.02832331322133541, -0.04503545165061951, -0.040146756917238235, 0.09767019748687744, -0.005538441240787506, -0.03437820076942444, -0.02740664966404438, 0.017902836203575134, 0.06208169460296631, 0.0425892248749733, -0.0010414462303742766, -0.004136369563639164, 0.011570893228054047, -0.08617722243070602, 0.0061282082460820675, 0.02255464717745781, -0.029648074880242348, -0.028522348031401634, -0.023662133142352104, 0.0228496752679348, 0.03301963582634926, -0.028626980260014534, 0.022058719769120216, 0.05517509952187538, -0.012947400100529194, 0.034444596618413925, -0.01757495291531086, 0.06641499698162079, 0.038468893617391586, 0.06418776512145996, -0.03880832716822624, 0.05813116952776909, 0.04013752564787865, -0.033844999969005585, 0.02376415580511093, 0.004327106289565563, 0.0701160579919815, -0.03824258968234062, 0.009472101926803589, 0.04073491320014, 0.07148049026727676, 0.006086299661546946, -0.04336138442158699, -0.042130593210458755, 0.00796003732830286, -0.03769645839929581, 0.053260497748851776, 0.039561960846185684, 0.008164739236235619, -0.04773746803402901, 0.007032722234725952, 0.01880459487438202, -0.05133730545639992, 0.023108085617423058, -0.011756493709981441, 0.027712933719158173, 0.02862357720732689, 0.0018489754293113947, -0.05406343936920166, -0.05926781892776489, 0.038590915501117706, 0.0033322537783533335, 0.017856432124972343, 0.01660121977329254, -0.0642099380493164, 0.04150983691215515, -0.018212905153632164, -0.0025741092395037413, -0.00955301895737648, -0.003108522156253457, -0.029967203736305237, -0.046565160155296326, 0.0011280670296400785, 0.06432098895311356, -0.050851885229349136, 0.08356426656246185, -0.02945171482861042, 0.024304453283548355, -0.03337114304304123, 0.0463886521756649, 0.03277850151062012, -0.015664776787161827, 0.04807106778025627, 0.057146985083818436, -0.02487681619822979, -0.065764881670475, -0.008604348637163639, 0.010329236276447773, 0.018273090943694115, 0.008578273467719555, -0.018048910424113274, 0.03396742790937424, -0.000702214369084686, -0.003993345890194178, -0.03541705012321472, -0.029045719653367996, 0.006195137742906809, 0.03284730389714241, -0.011712332256138325, 0.09972038120031357, 0.03121437318623066, -0.006596365477889776, -0.017977548763155937, 0.06874595582485199, 0.008082308806478977, -0.0228115264326334, 0.032682061195373535, 0.059542879462242126, -0.0008783062221482396, -0.007930520921945572, 0.11096186935901642, -0.06187443807721138, 0.02867361716926098, -0.060556333512067795, -0.0038772448897361755, 0.023826856166124344, 0.0003893169923685491, 0.020125634968280792, -0.03216662257909775, -0.06289948523044586, 0.07655584067106247, -0.010433856397867203, -0.01320284977555275, -0.02432727999985218, -0.0005293011199682951, -0.06346748024225235, 0.0195832047611475, -0.042696308344602585, -0.03611438721418381, -0.0026405174285173416, -0.001957432832568884, 0.023704227060079575, 0.018417447805404663, -0.005741890985518694, 0.0484275184571743, -0.035631876438856125, -0.008339637890458107, 0.057194434106349945, -0.016087602823972702, 0.002355252392590046, -0.021999439224600792, 0.020492438226938248, -0.0177511777728796, -0.02782330848276615, -0.009532103314995766, 0.041768647730350494, -0.03256149962544441, 0.015808813273906708, -0.04367910698056221, -0.06392360478639603, -0.0075953262858092785, 0.04918369650840759, 0.012652380391955376, -0.001831117202527821, 0.04643688350915909, 0.0734952762722969, -0.016673143953084946, 0.04817889630794525, 0.0612398162484169, -0.06168535724282265, -0.027896355837583542, 0.0297984816133976, 0.086890310049057, 0.060340575873851776, 0.0025099616032093763, -0.06586994230747223, 0.007189149968326092, 0.03324481099843979, -0.02802651934325695, 0.0703127533197403, -0.03480372950434685, 0.01787639781832695, 0.006064810790121555, 0.026246091350913048, 0.029239756986498833, 0.10221049189567566, -0.03167860954999924, -0.033655960112810135, -0.022763242945075035, 0.0004215671797282994, -0.0032870792783796787, 0.108457550406456, -0.020853854715824127, -0.06998147815465927, 0.025304727256298065, -0.07142078876495361, 0.019149141386151314, 0.05704032629728317, 0.008100522682070732, -0.018943877890706062, -0.006744476035237312, -0.0066141695715487, 0.010794021189212799, 0.02527136355638504, 0.03197307884693146, -0.02214629016816616, 0.026473117992281914, 0.012703985907137394, -0.012727524153888226, -0.032115597277879715, -0.026055142283439636, 0.04097910225391388, -0.001632918487302959, -0.027638593688607216, 0.03359926864504814, 0.029445422813296318, 0.01125984638929367, -0.00786271970719099, 0.00797441229224205, 0.05801244080066681, -0.025799356400966644, -0.0012824792647734284, -0.0024645719677209854, 0.03497680276632309, 0.011916005983948708, 0.019500112161040306, -0.031838301569223404, 0.020388247445225716, -0.001317786518484354, -0.0016446877270936966, -0.011898115277290344, 0.05263013020157814, -0.004474744666367769, -0.026584502309560776, 0.01878281682729721, -0.011539223603904247, 0.024477645754814148, -0.014374477788805962, -0.0019795047119259834, -0.014619157649576664, -0.001942116767168045, -0.03194732591509819, -0.004261994734406471, 0.03762103617191315, 0.0234818197786808, -0.019194917753338814, -0.06453274935483932, 0.009398089721798897, -0.0026441041845828295, -0.02324354648590088, -0.004275956191122532, 0.016680879518389702, -0.04657694697380066, -0.030778661370277405, -0.019546782597899437, 0.02311028353869915, -0.0600292794406414, 0.016574811190366745, -0.030601609498262405, 0.002943947445601225, 0.0014711531111970544, -0.03865835815668106, -0.012522394768893719, -0.05875770002603531, -0.004893038887530565, 0.04252404719591141, 0.02334437146782875, 0.006677324417978525, 0.04229363054037094, 0.0325457863509655, -0.01172474306076765, -0.05776355415582657, -0.0441860593855381, -0.00470290333032608, -0.03202652558684349, 0.005871521309018135, 0.06552968174219131, 0.026658285409212112, -0.031778719276189804, -0.013705568388104439, 0.043353624641895294, -0.025839678943157196, 0.07041779160499573, -0.015008366666734219, 0.010566205717623234, -0.01875605434179306, -0.06655878573656082, -0.0028203781694173813, 0.04358641803264618, 0.0587773360311985, -0.02447730302810669, -0.021868808194994926, -0.05463384836912155, 0.008698872290551662, -0.011356811039149761, -0.023936931043863297, -0.051033470779657364, -0.0027764132246375084, -0.005057474598288536, 0.047822579741477966, 0.03622805327177048, 0.02149234525859356, -0.023713532835245132, 0.036855150014162064, 0.018824579194188118, 0.012024365365505219, -0.008215626701712608, 0.01868545450270176, 0.05368165299296379, -0.005909040104597807, 0.029884055256843567, -0.05215287581086159, 0.013099105097353458, 0.030355725437402725, 0.03125021234154701, 0.02585001289844513, 0.009182166308164597, -0.04323400929570198, -0.04351186752319336, 0.01042311079800129, -0.01997264288365841, 0.016495002433657646, -0.006488836370408535, -0.07411167025566101, -0.07505703717470169, 0.006921354215592146, -0.010004221461713314, -0.012837429530918598, -0.008386046625673771, -0.03784527629613876, -0.0007892826688475907, 0.0793614611029625, -0.03254286199808121, 0.01654263213276863, -0.0012418318074196577, -0.017698075622320175, -0.008318472653627396, -0.0345628522336483, -0.029732367023825645, -0.039799053221940994, -0.03542826697230339, 0.0006980434409342706, -0.019650466740131378, -0.017891360446810722, -0.03416740521788597, 0.06466693431138992, -0.005058118142187595, -0.0314054936170578, 0.06891684234142303, 0.011351803317666054, -0.0095230583101511, 0.025038300082087517, -0.08805312216281891, 0.002023703185841441, 0.03495364263653755, -0.035478875041007996, 0.001808286877349019, -0.024823395535349846, 0.03491613268852234, -0.004008967895060778, 0.0012666926486417651, 0.018511757254600525, 0.012455472722649574, 0.007173312362283468, -0.02931070141494274, 0.02455694042146206, 0.09684760123491287, -0.03158079832792282, -0.0015691588632762432, -0.025723807513713837, 0.021642182022333145, -0.0068429638631641865, -0.0004869213153142482, -0.03318944573402405, 0.01791565679013729, 0.02365896664559841, 0.030679399147629738, -0.06547344475984573, -0.04677116125822067, 0.0013329944340512156, 0.05912429094314575, -0.020414438098669052, -0.021799731999635696, 0.028307219967246056, -0.04378559812903404, 0.06114496290683746, 0.04047004133462906, 0.06077079847455025, -0.04908032342791557, 0.030528806149959564, -0.02145383134484291, -0.05898437276482582, 0.04390290006995201, 0.002140259137377143, 0.03483002260327339, -0.011305216699838638, -0.02438727580010891, -0.04455209895968437, 0.0072754668071866035, 0.0194243174046278, -0.03757898509502411, -0.03753316402435303, 0.011519202962517738, 0.004978773184120655, 0.05069413408637047, -0.036256421357393265, 0.01415819488465786, -0.029628442600369453, -0.08728238940238953, 0.05864455923438072, -0.016850866377353668, -0.022865664213895798, -0.0043055335991084576, -0.05530942603945732, 0.0022875932045280933, -0.02386375702917576, 0.000050953927711816505, -0.015116054564714432, -0.006571796722710133, -0.021040862426161766, -0.007095063105225563, 0.015574057586491108, -0.02699790522456169, -0.07709348201751709, -0.03373069316148758, -0.021777693182229996, 0.014980429783463478, -0.07578499615192413, -0.02998904138803482, 0.01745695061981678, -0.012047434225678444, 0.08884565532207489, 0.00177335599437356, -0.06623844057321548, -0.010286123491823673, -0.05965978652238846, -0.001987159252166748, 0.03149895742535591, -0.031377553939819336, -0.01846623234450817, -0.01851755939424038, 0.009281019680202007, -0.003939742688089609, 0.022249797359108925, -0.05070780590176582, -0.016582001000642776, -0.019040483981370926, 0.02009265497326851, 0.03736673668026924, 0.05881859362125397, 0.0092938132584095, -0.016186263412237167, 0.010894989594817162, -0.0210562814027071, -0.057266347110271454, -0.024225763976573944, 0.01681881956756115, 0.012851804494857788, 0.02368977479636669, -0.04123586788773537, -0.03555714339017868, -0.005260128993541002, -0.05470799282193184, -0.006302082445472479, 0.0347277857363224, 0.01663902960717678, 0.03887643665075302, -0.025583481416106224, -0.051853716373443604, -0.07211088389158249, 0.004394625313580036, -0.019117532297968864, 0.017235200852155685, -0.01370417233556509, -0.02139955572783947, -0.07390867173671722, 0.022884754464030266, 0.011555597186088562, -0.022035181522369385, -0.003281898330897093, -0.04632984846830368, -0.011198403313755989, -0.015064628794789314, -0.014099476858973503, -0.04293092340230942, 0.025608064606785774, -0.06804132461547852, -0.016658784821629524, 0.004641139879822731, -0.0014876164495944977, 0.05021577328443527, -0.014732163399457932, -0.016390718519687653, -0.028692085295915604, 0.06460399925708771, -0.06120552495121956, -0.006219071801751852, 0.022009581327438354, -0.06269912421703339, -0.013100584037601948, 0.036359935998916626, 0.014725797809660435, 0.006770782172679901, 0.005483924876898527, -0.028444534167647362, -0.03979947790503502, -0.07705532014369965, 0.012298977933824062, 0.005166158080101013, -0.0008354624733328819, -0.032684776932001114, 0.011690554209053516, 0.02536480687558651, 0.021067382767796516 ]
<p>I came across this proportionality statement in my quantum mechanics notebook: $\psi(x,t)$ is proportional to </p> <p>$$ \begin{align} \cos(kx - wt) &amp;= \exp(i(kx-wt)) + \exp(-i(kx-wt)) \\ &amp;= \exp (i(kx-wt)) \end{align} $$ I looked through most commonly used textbooks for quantum mechanics and I couldn't find this in them. Can you help me figure this out? Thanks.</p>
g7437
[ 0.04269774258136749, 0.0038767221849411726, 0.003111852565780282, -0.07294417172670364, 0.02694264054298401, 0.04057595133781433, -0.02478654496371746, -0.001290851621888578, -0.045248620212078094, 0.05252640321850777, 0.01938970386981964, 0.011200865730643272, 0.005713881459087133, -0.025768226012587547, -0.02351214736700058, 0.01808425411581993, 0.0679612085223198, 0.026349060237407684, 0.039404116570949554, 0.04712599143385887, -0.053274501115083694, -0.030345706269145012, -0.01658344827592373, -0.07056360691785812, 0.07596294581890106, -0.007750973105430603, -0.010483033955097198, -0.046423524618148804, -0.006171044427901506, -0.004520752467215061, 0.03542701154947281, -0.012876107357442379, 0.06812413781881332, -0.05941015109419823, -0.04063626378774643, -0.009043705649673939, 0.08383417874574661, 0.029497671872377396, 0.015418242663145065, -0.011650285683572292, 0.01838063634932041, -0.03579527139663696, 0.012462520971894264, -0.05891584977507591, -0.00003819474659394473, -0.02611997351050377, 0.0014008971629664302, 0.08510961383581161, -0.03336524963378906, 0.018335016444325447, -0.02393348701298237, 0.05462120473384857, -0.0015869485214352608, -0.020417843014001846, -0.00763022480532527, 0.0353003591299057, 0.01699202135205269, -0.08465134352445602, 0.06824522465467453, 0.04091809317469597, 0.03612503036856651, -0.026740169152617455, 0.05105698108673096, 0.03222766891121864, 0.09656345099210739, -0.05327619984745979, -0.013517430983483791, 0.015931786969304085, 0.01761263981461525, 0.005092311650514603, -0.02668394334614277, -0.018455272540450096, 0.017445523291826248, 0.022616950795054436, -0.008904142305254936, 0.0032270471565425396, 0.02408873289823532, -0.01085910014808178, 0.029146257787942886, 0.007903690449893475, -0.04526748135685921, -0.02376740612089634, 0.05819078907370567, 0.01795821264386177, 0.01382659375667572, -0.05789831280708313, 0.030732467770576477, -0.039879053831100464, -0.061663977801799774, 0.009943499229848385, -0.04185076430439949, 0.015294348821043968, 0.07775239646434784, 0.01790541596710682, -0.006034842226654291, -0.07110226154327393, 0.01106216013431549, 0.03002302534878254, -0.0017011073650792241, -0.012123113498091698, -0.013052165508270264, 0.00747552840039134, 0.02901678904891014, -0.03284270688891411, -0.0531090684235096, -0.022877026349306107, 0.020480958744883537, -0.011024774983525276, -0.013940566219389439, -0.028899963945150375, -0.013479461893439293, 0.024079374969005585, 0.001246045925654471, -0.045852988958358765, -0.02022142894566059, 0.031133228912949562, 0.014340050518512726, -0.08478058874607086, -0.019712116569280624, 0.026408551260828972, 0.0401693694293499, 0.007607941050082445, 0.008251048624515533, 0.04805562645196915, -0.051463037729263306, -0.019525526091456413, -0.010257403366267681, -0.02746122144162655, 0.006037076469510794, -0.01074542198330164, 0.08933369070291519, -0.005833123344928026, 0.010656542144715786, 0.0034729682374745607, -0.026917003095149994, 0.027733223512768745, -0.006019847933202982, 0.0009709408041089773, 0.016071690246462822, 0.0013582484098151326, -0.04887929558753967, -0.015349570661783218, -0.010806001722812653, -0.0016069483244791627, 0.017155464738607407, -0.020448388531804085, -0.02932465262711048, -0.014790154062211514, 0.056393615901470184, 0.03256408870220184, 0.035899531096220016, -0.034373555332422256, -0.013414631597697735, -0.04788294434547424, -0.010584590025246143, -0.038728803396224976, 0.0020281062461435795, -0.03931887075304985, -0.008599613793194294, -0.0188949815928936, 0.03937244415283203, 0.030112436041235924, -0.003368100617080927, 0.027441004291176796, -0.05597658455371857, -0.014880338683724403, 0.008672046475112438, -0.008384080603718758, 0.0033256197348237038, -0.03636109083890915, 0.00419848645105958, -0.031599294394254684, 0.02249210886657238, -0.04993404448032379, -0.0716858059167862, 0.05821399763226509, 0.018362905830144882, -0.02567206509411335, 0.031078355386853218, -0.002898039761930704, 0.028853880241513252, -0.013105190359055996, 0.07806797325611115, 0.008112837560474873, -0.02457861229777336, -0.015347382053732872, 0.020367659628391266, 0.04500358924269676, -0.025479819625616074, -0.0032415387686342, 0.04651966691017151, 0.018224002793431282, -0.012005853466689587, -0.018489478155970573, -0.03834335505962372, -0.08500951528549194, 0.041279442608356476, -0.055367473512887955, -0.010871727019548416, -0.027653949335217476, 0.0552506223320961, 0.060901109129190445, -0.010692405514419079, 0.003145409282296896, 0.05688240006566048, 0.010264799930155277, 0.03902839869260788, 0.0059066107496619225, 0.046606551855802536, 0.03091553784906864, -0.043787673115730286, 0.04955683648586273, 0.015437211841344833, 0.004369854927062988, -0.034432221204042435, -0.02319614589214325, 0.05459502339363098, -0.0023383700754493475, -0.03681974112987518, 0.02581620030105114, -0.008477352559566498, -0.034587420523166656, 0.025555526837706566, -0.005002864170819521, 0.002119357930496335, -0.009934243746101856, -0.05291486531496048, -0.0019543252419680357, -0.04926244914531708, 0.02588646672666073, -0.07230336964130402, 0.015083619393408298, -0.01727937161922455, 0.038998451083898544, 0.051069874316453934, 0.0726613849401474, 0.006165753118693829, -0.006847196724265814, 0.01793435961008072, 0.03673814982175827, 0.007218978833407164, -0.04990683123469353, 0.036797624081373215, 0.03707350417971611, 0.012391430325806141, 0.04316308721899986, 0.05546077340841293, -0.008468075655400753, -0.02732168324291706, 0.06365878880023956, -0.015095441602170467, -0.06256654858589172, -0.015070701017975807, -0.0003897710412275046, 0.018623128533363342, -0.001364552997983992, -0.015816431492567062, -0.005061728414148092, -0.022538289427757263, -0.026308123022317886, 0.014023263938724995, -0.03689708933234215, 0.0009493647376075387, 0.006858044303953648, -0.002725776517763734, -0.04298362135887146, 0.004869203548878431, -0.03785752132534981, 0.045828692615032196, -0.026691682636737823, 0.010892687365412712, 0.11909380555152893, -0.023516202345490456, 0.014526832848787308, 0.0064897784031927586, -0.023777179419994354, -0.01740802451968193, -0.04755250737071037, -0.04316641017794609, -0.01055195089429617, 0.002456765389069915, 0.027297211810946465, -0.006450207903981209, 0.027902649715542793, 0.019114917144179344, -0.03842151165008545, 0.07537132501602173, -0.0017468446167185903, 0.02285950258374214, 0.008707172237336636, 0.009592774324119091, -0.024279316887259483, -0.026300372555851936, 0.012356715276837349, 0.024477582424879074, -0.015816889703273773, 0.06817305833101273, -0.0022040698677301407, -0.008361472748219967, 0.02791883796453476, -0.0072068930603563786, 0.0028238696977496147, 0.028630783781409264, 0.018824921920895576, 0.04055163264274597, 0.03809957206249237, 0.02234121412038803, -0.008630934171378613, -0.004037084989249706, 0.01679956540465355, -0.03320404887199402, -0.028221655637025833, 0.024622652679681778, 0.03367206081748009, -0.039306554943323135, 0.04978242516517639, -0.01893739216029644, -0.01228383183479309, -0.01710069738328457, 0.021998347714543343, -0.021327991038560867, -0.031174341216683388, 0.04589151591062546, 0.013995194807648659, 0.023325076326727867, -0.02437743730843067, -0.02016500197350979, -0.021790511906147003, 0.014575375244021416, 0.006181284785270691, 0.011324262246489525, -0.02235855907201767, 0.05194191262125969, 0.033371344208717346, -0.04138427600264549, -0.03520919010043144, 0.004620055202394724, -0.01743406243622303, 0.033105798065662384, 0.06283791363239288, -0.017848340794444084, -0.04360009729862213, 0.0052506993524730206, -0.0013378652511164546, -0.03971315175294876, -0.039459314197301865, 0.03490590676665306, 0.04823261871933937, 0.07444096356630325, 0.017937814816832542, -0.056753963232040405, -0.02906722202897072, -0.0006238175556063652, -0.03068094700574875, 0.03815767168998718, 0.03291233628988266, 0.05261871963739395, 0.01783689856529236, 0.024483798071742058, -0.02916957065463066, 0.037090107798576355, -0.01922180876135826, -0.009227211587131023, -0.0320921465754509, 0.0136888911947608, -0.01658794842660427, 0.02287103980779648, 0.02436106838285923, -0.028715793043375015, 0.011040771380066872, -0.0006189008126966655, 0.0075965519063174725, 0.0030262761283665895, 0.011389927007257938, -0.028277957811951637, -0.08716998994350433, -0.002955425763502717, -0.004632751457393169, -0.005681674461811781, -0.01288651768118143, -0.025429710745811462, -0.0061476160772144794, -0.019124729558825493, 0.028582243248820305, 0.04022626951336861, 0.025037279352545738, -0.028316719457507133, 0.005732133984565735, 0.025827419012784958, 0.04339492321014404, -0.024231404066085815, -0.05785520374774933, -0.08504846692085266, 0.03382029011845589, -0.047231655567884445, 0.05460551753640175, 0.06190399453043938, 0.02280368283390999, -0.02067214623093605, 0.0012428737245500088, -0.07618200033903122, 0.01814230903983116, 0.02082735486328602, 0.030376452952623367, 0.021022235974669456, 0.02440500073134899, 0.028272002935409546, -0.002634102711454034, -0.01701689511537552, -0.0355917327105999, -0.018485600128769875, 0.010358208790421486, 0.03788100183010101, 0.013262049295008183, 0.0026588335167616606, 0.025083940476179123, 0.01074612233787775, -0.02287937141954899, 0.05211697146296501, -0.02896491065621376, 0.009336770512163639, -0.012468980625271797, 0.07688164710998535, -0.02462746761739254, 0.09530962258577347, 0.04659606143832207, 0.02906942367553711, 0.061049140989780426, 0.01037169061601162, -0.0248259250074625, -0.037846602499485016, -0.004998303018510342, 0.05356864258646965, 0.010542444884777069, -0.026823176071047783, -0.010133642703294754, -0.05055227503180504, 0.0036919161211699247, -0.014367309398949146, 0.006815340835601091, 0.040922511368989944, 0.03096776455640793, -0.00021450458734761924, -0.05122009664773941, -0.027021311223506927, 0.013256102800369263, 0.006892757024616003, -0.07720310986042023, -0.007478407584130764, -0.06795003265142441, 0.008315151557326317, -0.0010677927639335394, -0.013154804706573486, -0.017174657434225082, -0.029560940340161324, -0.07709798216819763, -0.0010523569071665406, 0.036206599324941635, 0.019123252481222153, 0.03509031981229782, -0.0633559301495552, -0.012604783289134502, 0.02289213053882122, -0.06070820614695549, 0.024250999093055725, 0.038398198783397675, -0.046670231968164444, 0.03674257546663284, -0.0007555610500276089, -0.005072793457657099, 0.04703968018293381, -0.05239712446928024, 0.016983089968562126, 0.005076421890407801, -0.00581817701458931, -0.019200902432203293, -0.010969838127493858, -0.039810966700315475, -0.009262905456125736, -0.024589423090219498, 0.0018322884570807219, -0.04280694201588631, 0.02568267285823822, 0.020836280658841133, 0.043211840093135834, 0.025371573865413666, 0.007943338714540005, -0.04819360375404358, 0.006525389850139618, -0.037534814327955246, 0.016003917902708054, 0.0882907509803772, 0.02558743581175804, 0.01862769015133381, 0.026874301955103874, 0.021114401519298553, 0.03913585841655731, 0.0030520542059093714, 0.055124931037425995, 0.010118854232132435, -0.013621576130390167, 0.06568565964698792, -0.019384179264307022, 0.027236035093665123, -0.06071539223194122, 0.00995542947202921, 0.06922536343336105, -0.004524249117821455, -0.007303628139197826, 0.03460371121764183, 0.002365256194025278, -0.014287219382822514, -0.010133999399840832, -0.010197781957685947, -0.018204951658844948, -0.027417708188295364, -0.004273806698620319, -0.000014697468941449188, -0.034878410398960114, -0.03922386094927788, 0.09781008213758469, 0.012904435396194458, -0.054668135941028595, -0.03465220332145691, 0.014422666281461716, 0.0014221256133168936, -0.031086472794413567, -0.04903978481888771, 0.004511217586696148, 0.011880903504788876, -0.038030534982681274, 0.011507718823850155, -0.04507521912455559, 0.04662888124585152, 0.0021153679117560387, -0.03239065408706665, -0.04630747437477112, 0.03658074885606766, 0.03491038829088211, 0.02033654786646366, -0.06016135215759277, 0.0198472011834383, 0.012018830515444279, 0.05650697275996208, -0.011473528109490871, 0.008800211362540722, -0.047721561044454575, -0.007431878708302975, 0.01209045760333538, -0.0008567004697397351, -0.025975847616791725, 0.051040168851614, -0.0422808974981308, -0.018894553184509277, 0.00594533234834671, 0.011433434672653675, 0.007537004072219133, -0.03113517351448536, -0.0007923780358396471, 0.017540372908115387, 0.042853400111198425, -0.025526221841573715, 0.03330546244978905, -0.019601570442318916, 0.0016134482575580478, -0.01153431087732315, -0.07791133224964142, -0.016030894592404366, -0.010181039571762085, -0.008814603090286255, 0.0007257797988131642, -0.019879763945937157, -0.00775882275775075, 0.008349760435521603, 0.04888802394270897, 0.09827157855033875, -0.056675273925065994, -0.041606560349464417, 0.011292696930468082, -0.02872210554778576, -0.022965043783187866, -0.00818438921123743, -0.05387743562459946, -0.08869428187608719, -0.059278883039951324, 0.04011809080839157, -0.03465360030531883, -0.03458770737051964, 0.047482915222644806, 0.05116969719529152, -0.05868376046419144, -0.046273939311504364, -0.06868965923786163, 0.009334756061434746, 0.019009152427315712, -0.021483924239873886, 0.04079609736800194, 0.05784837156534195, -0.021783366799354553, -0.01823107898235321, 0.02591385692358017, -0.03235437348484993, -0.015253917314112186, -0.04914027824997902, 0.022684253752231598, 0.03897656872868538, -0.03984483331441879, -0.00856372993439436, -0.03170567750930786, 0.01581551879644394, -0.017576612532138824, 0.027338793501257896, -0.01800266094505787, 0.00698142359033227, 0.011003240942955017, -0.0562983974814415, 0.05100611597299576, 0.05430151894688606, -0.03448503091931343, 0.009186208248138428, 0.05019616708159447, 0.008462071418762207, -0.025966135784983635, -0.0043533057905733585, 0.07799799740314484, 0.026031410321593285, -0.025035765022039413, -0.02641589380800724, 0.007568359375, 0.0016961527289822698, -0.038603272289037704, -0.0420854277908802, -0.05627378448843956, 0.011688061989843845, -0.0633903443813324, 0.046884242445230484, -0.03787049278616905, -0.027855295687913895, 0.03880409151315689, 0.054750774055719376, -0.05817621946334839, -0.00734160328283906, 0.028550853952765465, -0.000525572570040822, -0.08797706663608551, 0.043396998196840286, -0.05126501992344856, -0.007218722254037857, -0.11784566938877106, -0.016715118661522865, 0.06167058274149895, 0.05046809837222099, -0.02799442782998085, 0.06207089126110077, -0.05112065002322197, 0.01687818579375744, 0.04153105616569519, -0.03965107724070549, 0.045535650104284286, -0.07785384356975555, -0.03114583157002926, -0.04651913791894913, 0.03177563473582268, 0.03186824545264244, -0.02110537514090538, 0.05953090637922287, 0.06488721072673798, 0.0011853472096845508, 0.0036758671049028635, -0.036992575973272324, -0.014863159507513046, -0.004149070009589195, -0.07741297781467438, -0.008371226489543915, 0.012664031237363815, 0.035313189029693604, 0.0127027602866292, 0.02837224118411541, -0.021255681291222572, 0.008862015791237354, -0.040907904505729675, 0.024065731093287468, 0.0265353973954916, -0.02470417506992817, -0.061403509229421616, -0.03277991712093353, 0.02826637588441372, -0.011298613622784615, -0.010072876699268818, 0.08542899042367935, -0.05953521654009819, -0.051736731082201004, 0.05823637172579765, 0.015537274070084095, 0.016605157405138016, 0.0028784549795091152, 0.07733110338449478, -0.020502278581261635, 0.010531522333621979, 0.05712718516588211, 0.08020950108766556, -0.024264371022582054, 0.007812547497451305, -0.0011239377781748772, 0.01669139973819256, 0.02187889814376831, -0.005366927944123745, 0.005557559430599213, -0.015071523375809193, -0.046444911509752274, 0.009511142037808895, -0.03177424147725105, 0.04014167934656143, 0.04178403317928314, 0.06057315692305565, -0.031520992517471313, -0.07505890727043152, 0.027563847601413727, 0.05169609934091568, -0.053073860704898834, -0.023463860154151917, -0.00941106490790844, -0.001315184636041522, -0.08680699020624161, -0.020349523052573204, -0.07448840886354446, -0.006416970863938332, 0.0055818213149905205, -0.014669607393443584, 0.02671877294778824, -0.0003949604870285839, 0.003399463137611747, -0.015617265366017818, 0.08133074641227722, 0.019389590248465538, 0.017105169594287872, -0.0076722209341824055, -0.04911947250366211, 0.0407688282430172, 0.03583098575472832, 0.009293386712670326, -0.047132883220911026, 0.0008866788703016937, -0.02107049897313118, -0.014426963403820992, -0.05977877601981163, 0.02180664613842964, 0.030262930318713188, 0.013544647954404354, -0.037027306854724884, -0.03009294718503952, 0.02052442729473114, 0.005055788438767195, 0.043979089707136154, 0.05524495616555214, -0.0648379921913147, 0.03880561515688896, 0.021685095503926277, -0.01949024572968483, 0.015169495716691017, -0.048874299973249435, -0.04356275498867035, 0.04079484939575195, 0.011058313772082329, 0.05793997645378113, -0.03351794555783272, -0.038455575704574585, -0.03366338834166527 ]
<p>if a lightbeam is fired from space to earth is it blueshifted? I heard this happens with special relativity but not sure if it happens with genreal relativity</p>
g7438
[ 0.0258579533547163, -0.003263481892645359, 0.009408297948539257, 0.00076767971040681, -0.0005826714914292097, 0.030027899891138077, -0.005559535697102547, 0.048092182725667953, -0.012526998296380043, -0.047123897820711136, -0.015454540960490704, 0.05127955973148346, 0.028839999809861183, -0.012261497788131237, 0.01707140915095806, -0.05644243583083153, 0.04356048256158829, 0.008907356299459934, 0.03368331864476204, 0.024541227146983147, -0.004722527228295803, 0.04171155393123627, 0.018966158851981163, -0.06277944892644882, -0.023543793708086014, -0.0026759288739413023, 0.04340546578168869, -0.017144402489066124, -0.0640983060002327, -0.07225877046585083, -0.0029091425240039825, 0.010767349973320961, 0.011427861638367176, -0.015944454818964005, -0.00021241499052848667, -0.021349798887968063, -0.002281318884342909, 0.0224932748824358, 0.008498119190335274, 0.0479309968650341, 0.04628356173634529, -0.005727220792323351, -0.022955209016799927, -0.01209868025034666, 0.06769511848688126, -0.02150915376842022, -0.02328689955174923, 0.044030893594026566, -0.024286309257149696, -0.023195473477244377, -0.012690340168774128, -0.010676257312297821, 0.033814046531915665, -0.05488769710063934, 0.05581694841384888, -0.0036693578585982323, -0.07020819187164307, -0.04448488727211952, 0.019568385556340218, 0.031260810792446136, -0.024416092783212662, -0.002603518543764949, 0.05882297828793526, -0.015935959294438362, 0.008481006138026714, -0.0017840059008449316, -0.027441153302788734, -0.044048864394426346, -0.008770528249442577, -0.0672854334115982, 0.03408503532409668, -0.00788278691470623, -0.051418405026197433, -0.012730144895613194, -0.015737812966108322, -0.004264321643859148, -0.029765771701931953, 0.054113686084747314, -0.06085626780986786, 0.09373325854539871, -0.06461276859045029, -0.05064285546541214, -0.03818559646606445, -0.013229204341769218, 0.034861449152231216, 0.014163576997816563, 0.027170633897185326, 0.024546990171074867, 0.0029923722613602877, -0.011374111287295818, 0.030030149966478348, -0.06683659553527832, 0.06620712578296661, 0.061092887073755264, -0.06732774525880814, 0.006957448553293943, -0.01755749061703682, 0.007417815271764994, -0.037027861922979355, -0.014767630025744438, -0.10264826565980911, 0.02813083492219448, 0.004722895100712776, 0.0030962072778493166, 0.041500914841890335, -0.025460684671998024, -0.002683260478079319, -0.008281621150672436, -0.023305043578147888, -0.05368397757411003, -0.014446900226175785, -0.06189735233783722, -0.06265772879123688, -0.00501383887603879, -0.07585887610912323, -0.002034006407484412, 0.06678419560194016, -0.05548752471804619, -0.025927584618330002, 0.030213531106710434, 0.023774992674589157, -0.057833243161439896, 0.0351833775639534, 0.06377669423818588, -0.012954141944646835, 0.031080760061740875, 0.013182518072426319, 0.007229420822113752, 0.007251535076647997, -0.012318653054535389, -0.07807981967926025, -0.0028165201656520367, 0.048828594386577606, 0.00882822647690773, -0.03891409933567047, 0.004160343203693628, 0.05924274027347565, -0.013528337702155113, -0.052205320447683334, 0.0519450306892395, 0.03927910327911377, -0.06535184383392334, 0.0391731932759285, -0.0196443572640419, 0.0009353163768537343, 0.020902352407574654, 0.014604335650801659, -0.00022568316489923745, 0.07396502792835236, 0.0576455183327198, -0.06252571195363998, 0.06741253286600113, 0.019376570358872414, -0.031337592750787735, 0.015910284593701363, -0.014957070350646973, 0.03874713182449341, -0.014553750865161419, -0.01320915948599577, -0.05659187585115433, 0.03523687273263931, -0.006160168908536434, 0.02077430859208107, 0.011064044199883938, -0.0014908363809809089, 0.01934063993394375, 0.00784371979534626, -0.06522513926029205, 0.022889332845807076, 0.0028348006308078766, -0.01441571582108736, -0.04457539692521095, 0.023217234760522842, 0.028905818238854408, -0.0011509822215884924, 0.03972669318318367, 0.031717248260974884, 0.02587788738310337, -0.031310852617025375, 0.018672173842787743, -0.043210435658693314, -0.025650504976511, -0.03426043689250946, -0.061907850205898285, 0.009816561825573444, -0.03683636710047722, -0.02010873146355152, -0.06054659187793732, -0.025168729946017265, 0.04468865692615509, -0.04716300219297409, -0.056895576417446136, -0.002625904744490981, 0.012446492910385132, -0.00010558088979450986, -0.04156086966395378, -0.020306238904595375, -0.01311514526605606, 0.03974510356783867, 0.03492065891623497, 0.0279686376452446, 0.05582346022129059, 0.028965208679437637, -0.018333610147237778, 0.0053995223715901375, 0.030290380120277405, 0.012808609753847122, 0.03080080635845661, -0.012004128657281399, -0.02219645492732525, 0.04588037356734276, 0.011772640980780125, 0.04232579469680786, -0.0099940812215209, -0.02434653230011463, 0.00554874399676919, -0.013073832727968693, 0.02095426805317402, -0.02642056904733181, 0.029265880584716797, 0.0024599735625088215, 0.044086579233407974, 0.01869576796889305, 0.00704535935074091, -0.00667927972972393, 0.018790345638990402, -0.03372832015156746, -0.0011646512430161238, 0.07299219816923141, -0.006444850470870733, -0.032513685524463654, 0.04028744623064995, 0.013178376480937004, 0.0031202647369354963, 0.0812550038099289, -0.02546214684844017, 0.01852109469473362, -0.06337463855743408, -0.01563812792301178, -0.0054459101520478725, -0.0342971533536911, -0.06418035179376602, 0.001205009175464511, 0.005497389007359743, 0.023693975061178207, -0.035430680960416794, -0.019599677994847298, -0.000044515127228805795, -0.03530508279800415, -0.022274242714047432, 0.04335607960820198, -0.01793210580945015, -0.037411753088235855, 0.04706510528922081, -0.009522891603410244, -0.02920156717300415, -0.02930096723139286, 0.012505906634032726, -0.09477600455284119, 0.0019215800566598773, -0.035997174680233, -0.022543534636497498, 0.01078005600720644, -0.022308509796857834, -0.011871101334691048, 0.028508508577942848, -0.008554666303098202, 0.016485050320625305, -0.003998314030468464, -0.02922097034752369, -0.008614804595708847, 0.03681047260761261, 0.04459725320339203, 0.012924497947096825, 0.018749630078673363, 0.050611626356840134, -0.022777529433369637, -0.01714850403368473, 0.014619427733123302, -0.023239271715283394, -0.041377801448106766, 0.022116489708423615, -0.040004365146160126, -0.007920593023300171, 0.033872928470373154, 0.0036849593743681908, 0.023997370153665543, 0.03763261437416077, -0.016123881563544273, -0.005061676725745201, -0.052934885025024414, 0.018350711092352867, 0.0435168519616127, 0.06449025124311447, -0.014060494489967823, 0.020545126870274544, 0.03792216256260872, -0.011330065317451954, -0.04363168403506279, 0.050071731209754944, 0.016531148925423622, -0.052561111748218536, 0.0021059121936559677, 0.0115584135055542, -0.05177483707666397, -0.019261559471488, -0.02104988507926464, -0.01342726405709982, 0.034967388957738876, 0.03085489571094513, 0.00458033662289381, 0.036778293550014496, 0.03579676151275635, 0.029389765113592148, -0.046708136796951294, -0.02783547155559063, 0.02270364761352539, -0.048890821635723114, 0.013612024486064911, 0.013608768582344055, -0.010661575943231583, 0.015564595349133015, -0.051158323884010315, -0.006906456779688597, 0.040647946298122406, -0.0204391498118639, 0.06875065714120865, -0.00043917703442275524, -0.08881430327892303, 0.008947781287133694, -0.032152656465768814, 0.01692854054272175, -0.027584508061408997, -0.0016561970114707947, -0.007489094976335764, 0.040390390902757645, -0.04506853222846985, 0.01630932092666626, 0.0077300225384533405, 0.05257808044552803, 0.018803279846906662, -0.01607656665146351, 0.03180147707462311, -0.027452833950519562, -0.0011273082345724106, 0.05964178219437599, 0.04991327226161957, 0.008035508915781975, -0.03439369425177574, -0.04405483603477478, 0.04080915078520775, -0.03656948730349541, 0.036688242107629776, -0.04024958238005638, -0.04194508492946625, 0.039275020360946655, 0.010587644763290882, 0.026046214625239372, 0.06579107791185379, -0.03143985569477081, -0.022327085956931114, -0.03387482836842537, 0.030740713700652122, -0.005125855561345816, -0.03634941205382347, 0.0025672048795968294, -0.020243894308805466, -0.006288704928010702, -0.008587177842855453, 0.042514119297266006, 0.011841914616525173, -0.016012584790587425, -0.0462714284658432, 0.04268893226981163, 0.028122520074248314, -0.028333399444818497, 0.05689545348286629, -0.061800483614206314, -0.024428727105259895, 0.020217834040522575, 0.03825090453028679, 0.08654714375734329, 0.07006601244211197, 0.0057402136735618114, 0.019850127398967743, 0.005200651008635759, 0.003365160198882222, -0.015800973400473595, -0.014407088980078697, -0.01819750666618347, -0.015632878988981247, -0.01163653377443552, -0.0038256612606346607, -0.015262272208929062, 0.0025073823053389788, -0.0231679268181324, -0.0023395181633532047, 0.036834679543972015, 0.0050473990850150585, 0.028379039838910103, 0.04136180132627487, 0.0037821379955857992, 0.04309684783220291, -0.01231693010777235, -0.031221965327858925, -0.03730905428528786, 0.04650579392910004, -0.008346331305801868, -0.03752385452389717, 0.013334810733795166, 0.05797693505883217, -0.026998251676559448, -0.03517591208219528, -0.05306795611977577, 0.024717705324292183, 0.034901682287454605, 0.04426765814423561, 0.04482205957174301, -0.02669612318277359, 0.022138815373182297, 0.012679588049650192, 0.009464994072914124, 0.039686452597379684, -0.026724452152848244, 0.03626478835940361, 0.06518027186393738, 0.03918713703751564, -0.06235668063163757, 0.02949603833258152, 0.04166229069232941, 0.010641016066074371, -0.020057054236531258, 0.0163358673453331, 0.048786357045173645, -0.017809994518756866, 0.0576358363032341, -0.004550198558717966, 0.06484287977218628, 0.024806281551718712, 0.052462387830019, 0.06432965397834778, -0.0025104540400207043, 0.01391017995774746, -0.04705533757805824, 0.02642710879445076, 0.05387919768691063, -0.010335177183151245, -0.027012528851628304, 0.02821938507258892, -0.0644664540886879, 0.010268846526741982, -0.0107992272824049, -0.00618053087964654, 0.002560204593464732, 0.002192971995100379, 0.021814696490764618, -0.02252274379134178, -0.0045525687746703625, -0.005947676487267017, 0.050310615450143814, 0.016276437789201736, -0.078846774995327, 0.028746912255883217, 0.0007771361852064729, -0.005373208783566952, 0.012961188331246376, -0.036246057599782944, -0.020864194259047508, -0.07510458678007126, -0.007920442149043083, -0.006368497386574745, -0.013889375142753124, -0.03733175992965698, 0.0459105409681797, -0.008424762636423111, 0.005589994601905346, -0.055334966629743576, -0.0218054112046957, -0.0084684444591403, -0.02449321188032627, -0.026802226901054382, -0.046390507370233536, 0.016503747552633286, -0.029676344245672226, 0.003371489467099309, 0.03314508497714996, 0.006216760724782944, 0.0034977407194674015, 0.029931988567113876, -0.07853703945875168, 0.0085061676800251, -0.008477949537336826, -0.014089957810938358, -0.020868932828307152, -0.07510587573051453, 0.0349515937268734, -0.019752129912376404, -0.019273823127150536, 0.008622881956398487, 0.0036623203195631504, -0.027528639882802963, 0.02081533521413803, 0.05274200439453125, -0.003283153986558318, -0.03906863182783127, 0.03416965901851654, 0.0015501895686611533, 0.061067845672369, -0.0488799624145031, 0.07836639881134033, -0.0007266778266057372, 0.017879946157336235, 0.0025947988033294678, 0.005285157822072506, 0.10291105508804321, -0.08387970179319382, 0.004552746191620827, 0.05598881468176842, 0.011750041507184505, -0.026550887152552605, -0.06460250914096832, -0.02306993678212166, 0.02166646532714367, -0.010049927979707718, 0.05353580787777901, 0.038977380841970444, -0.0483953058719635, 0.00294689042493701, -0.014568728394806385, 0.08267276734113693, -0.02461831271648407, 0.016828328371047974, 0.06563965976238251, 0.004661433398723602, 0.09036994725465775, -0.029298000037670135, 0.06354746222496033, 0.013901516795158386, -0.032834406942129135, 0.005529507528990507, -0.052252884954214096, -0.0022157931234687567, -0.020752260461449623, 0.0051018898375332355, -0.004680038429796696, 0.0004985398845747113, -0.06621387600898743, 0.0045821163803339005, 0.07575488090515137, -0.034053172916173935, -0.05040352791547775, 0.03301152214407921, -0.04984113201498985, 0.010912343859672546, 0.022534547373652458, 0.02298877015709877, -0.029639853164553642, -0.028374964371323586, -0.045418497174978256, -0.03582240268588066, 0.016822153702378273, 0.005560164339840412, 0.0714021697640419, -0.06393717229366302, 0.07701925933361053, -0.03873971849679947, 0.018660863861441612, -0.015324597246944904, 0.06104670837521553, -0.006600822322070599, -0.003059870097786188, 0.0022186394780874252, -0.04013119637966156, -0.015622642822563648, -0.03502914309501648, -0.044341791421175, 0.030275318771600723, -0.04616936296224594, -0.04065943881869316, 0.015147549100220203, 0.014159338548779488, 0.028531374409794807, 0.05956215783953667, 0.002603109460324049, -0.022698696702718735, -0.008684106171131134, 0.012617815285921097, 0.040527042001485825, -0.0025024726055562496, -0.07165854424238205, -0.05782540887594223, -0.01297079399228096, -0.03352746739983559, 0.032945260405540466, -0.07109526544809341, 0.04171843081712723, 0.013700098730623722, 0.06351657956838608, -0.015485567040741444, 0.03254363313317299, 0.010179772973060608, 0.008046356029808521, 0.060349125415086746, 0.033583659678697586, 0.05609775707125664, 0.02102372795343399, -0.05011628940701485, -0.031597428023815155, 0.0526883527636528, 0.05358573794364929, 0.007362020201981068, -0.012695137411355972, 0.014060195535421371, 0.042657408863306046, -0.02002698741853237, -0.04356369748711586, -0.0018795023206621408, -0.0419272743165493, 0.011988377198576927, -0.01977546699345112, 0.06350620836019516, -0.040670283138751984, 0.016801422461867332, 0.008172179572284222, 0.02801031619310379, 0.07833345234394073, -0.014299833215773106, -0.05398774892091751, -0.030904926359653473, -0.03203901648521423, -0.039202265441417694, 0.026491213589906693, -0.016018128022551537, 0.009260520339012146, 0.05386927351355553, 0.034669943153858185, -0.031679365783929825, 0.02876441366970539, -0.01281893253326416, -0.026641706004738808, 0.01579892635345459, 0.05705636739730835, 0.02478519268333912, 0.01856350712478161, -0.04741661995649338, 0.020808396860957146, 0.003966690041124821, -0.07579240202903748, -0.03371390700340271, -0.019849713891744614, 0.03845158591866493, -0.030294345691800117, -0.02068297564983368, -0.029807208105921745, -0.02645772136747837, 0.02440231293439865, -0.026076875627040863, 0.036219894886016846, -0.03471625968813896, -0.08891765773296356, -0.03039393573999405, -0.03619983419775963, -0.08403938263654709, -0.0024975603446364403, 0.028782252222299576, 0.05015379190444946, -0.004760599695146084, -0.04803993180394173, 0.004228790756314993, 0.035256527364254, -0.08117097616195679, 0.009133148938417435, 0.0018893858650699258, 0.007438899017870426, 0.01689983159303665, -0.029045643284916878, -0.05389103665947914, 0.05448181554675102, 0.03499353304505348, 0.014016334898769855, 0.03353142738342285, 0.032673049718141556, -0.07581756263971329, 0.03195817396044731, -0.02419167011976242, 0.016656408086419106, 0.006752528715878725, -0.011715958826243877, 0.014399154111742973, -0.0720590278506279, -0.04775116220116615, -0.02432086504995823, -0.04891672357916832, 0.004369344096630812, 0.030667448416352272, -0.05123766139149666, 0.03721649572253227, 0.036750052124261856, 0.010831700637936592, 0.0035245767794549465, -0.0775502622127533, 0.04914455860853195, -0.03495592251420021, 0.04698241502046585, 0.015857288613915443, -0.019090432673692703, -0.015645306557416916, -0.030136562883853912, -0.013848369009792805, -0.034085728228092194, 0.03613327443599701, 0.08512461185455322, 0.03907586261630058, 0.010450615547597408, -0.0176844522356987, 0.05655744671821594, 0.007493134122341871, 0.018885653465986252, 0.025534136220812798, -0.0019744241144508123, -0.00354344816878438, -0.021843159571290016, -0.023210905492305756, 0.019187532365322113, 0.02810760587453842, -0.010891910642385483, 0.02201954461634159, -0.07334188371896744, -0.012311520986258984, -0.07358591258525848, 0.05787883326411247, -0.013193906284868717, -0.030694561079144478, 0.021483294665813446, 0.011361607350409031, -0.021254587918519974, 0.009816785342991352, -0.023758161813020706, -0.0149995731189847, 0.04113947972655296, -0.02200203388929367, -0.006718302611261606, -0.01148490235209465, 0.011033604852855206, 0.0692623183131218, 0.06655345112085342, 0.022842349484562874, -0.04644589498639107, 0.047600626945495605, -0.02918325364589691, -0.002638113684952259, 0.028452763333916664, -0.0038457864429801702, 0.006036609411239624, 0.05166228488087654, -0.000023236420020111836, -0.03106006607413292, -0.02020593360066414, -0.020873989909887314, -0.026540711522102356, -0.009436864405870438, -0.0442100465297699, 0.004271502140909433, -0.03644004091620445, -0.06006764993071556, -0.04038715735077858, -0.024979257956147194, 0.055554673075675964 ]
<p>QFT says that an unlimited number of bosons can occupy the same "state" (what I mean by that is that the whole system's wavefunction is composed of a product of many identical wavefunctions).</p> <p>However, gravity increases monotonically with energy density. It seems that at some point, one additional boson would create a high enough energy density to create a black hole. Is this true? Could I calculate the number of bosons necessary to cause this?</p>
g7439
[ -0.01667061075568199, 0.07019736617803574, 0.01636970229446888, -0.04950123652815819, 0.04239749535918236, -0.013778727501630783, -0.0022891697008162737, 0.04655097797513008, -0.006563606671988964, -0.002811683574691415, -0.0530201680958271, -0.027403080835938454, 0.00894723180681467, -0.011733594350516796, -0.037403374910354614, 0.03677726164460182, 0.007316019386053085, 0.0017912087496370077, 0.015133315697312355, -0.06272491812705994, -0.023562917485833168, -0.013792254962027073, 0.05035412684082985, -0.038616858422756195, -0.011322560720145702, 0.032865796238183975, 0.00857110507786274, 0.027744321152567863, -0.060517944395542145, 0.011444571428000927, -0.004498952068388462, 0.06496843695640564, -0.012893898412585258, 0.010350903496146202, -0.004146270453929901, -0.049733828753232956, 0.02231922373175621, -0.0297259334474802, -0.017718741670250893, -0.022237399592995644, -0.007126744370907545, -0.05577610805630684, -0.027063516899943352, -0.0366210862994194, -0.06422185152769089, -0.01267140544950962, 0.06666471809148788, 0.025880077853798866, 0.012704573571681976, -0.044659096747636795, -0.02906787022948265, -0.02388470247387886, 0.023407936096191406, 0.009985709562897682, 0.009695909917354584, 0.04968013986945152, -0.026052352041006088, -0.05158715322613716, -0.0035754286218434572, 0.06560055166482925, -0.02742653340101242, -0.005153371021151543, 0.009319715201854706, 0.011945449747145176, 0.043402109295129776, 0.02719312347471714, -0.0294010192155838, 0.019125744700431824, -0.010367254726588726, -0.03155338019132614, 0.02945750579237938, -0.011343028396368027, -0.03182331845164299, 0.048639602959156036, 0.015471357852220535, 0.08163198083639145, -0.024330584332346916, 0.057744793593883514, -0.021077187731862068, -0.005386227276176214, -0.0139393899589777, -0.019676927477121353, 0.04802893102169037, -0.028271730989217758, 0.033334750682115555, -0.04890360310673714, 0.04143190756440163, 0.009558165445923805, 0.006188941188156605, 0.03852236270904541, 0.036378223448991776, -0.001594629604369402, 0.07107257097959518, 0.019325708970427513, -0.03108847886323929, -0.010549811646342278, 0.04033421352505684, 0.07731550186872482, -0.05043421685695648, -0.006054599303752184, -0.0402970127761364, 0.019790850579738617, -0.009812718257308006, -0.07296980917453766, 0.009716080501675606, -0.03407609835267067, 0.01319151557981968, 0.04334935173392296, 0.025091664865612984, 0.010018795728683472, -0.04642106592655182, -0.008584310300648212, 0.030155692249536514, -0.02606499381363392, -0.06526221334934235, 0.014069314114749432, 0.01945134438574314, -0.034246187657117844, -0.02815435267984867, 0.07006337493658066, -0.04866583272814751, 0.02629774622619152, 0.017597820609807968, -0.01951112411916256, -0.009682332165539265, -0.06315615773200989, -0.04138008505105972, 0.014851786196231842, 0.015608592890202999, 0.008462161757051945, 0.03857303783297539, -0.011469325982034206, -0.014033001847565174, 0.011145996861159801, -0.016722965985536575, 0.0008646181668154895, -0.013370383530855179, 0.03017445094883442, -0.006056834477931261, 0.03839922696352005, -0.023203186690807343, -0.053237657994031906, -0.0028247241862118244, 0.004149917978793383, 0.02274439111351967, -0.02833990566432476, -0.0054900930263102055, -0.034274253994226456, -0.056751713156700134, 0.03548420965671539, 0.02694566547870636, 0.07218971103429794, -0.023495685309171677, -0.05732891336083412, 0.04750111699104309, 0.05496097356081009, 0.041903138160705566, 0.022547638043761253, -0.032974015921354294, -0.010547791607677937, 0.10501281172037125, 0.01022370159626007, 0.026672568172216415, 0.027199622243642807, -0.032153937965631485, 0.032791152596473694, 0.06120842322707176, -0.04945509508252144, 0.012292321771383286, 0.014041599817574024, -0.008350187912583351, -0.02689223363995552, -0.028866799548268318, 0.06018655002117157, 0.061076972633600235, 0.023947270587086678, 0.01131510827690363, -0.028421340510249138, 0.04520728066563606, 0.028866074979305267, 0.010287903249263763, 0.0005359307979233563, 0.03360559791326523, 0.007490574847906828, -0.004134146496653557, 0.015852777287364006, -0.020520783960819244, -0.03002854250371456, -0.0071320985443890095, 0.1293211430311203, -0.05088778957724571, 0.03445572033524513, 0.011646570637822151, 0.007594706024974585, 0.007807543966919184, 0.02294178307056427, 0.0451277494430542, -0.028190303593873978, -0.01761300303041935, -0.01675647683441639, -0.01346546970307827, 0.04653868079185486, 0.02425311505794525, -0.02795593999326229, 0.05107903853058815, 0.004923446569591761, -0.031433578580617905, -0.01174764335155487, 0.03258763253688812, -0.05175448954105377, 0.0001448336406610906, -0.045740626752376556, -0.049099866300821304, 0.08951129019260406, 0.020273299887776375, 0.031205054372549057, -0.025081723928451538, 0.022179771214723587, 0.0020772910211235285, 0.013645047321915627, -0.0765252560377121, 0.016856029629707336, 0.061216261237859726, 0.03143690153956413, -0.048980820924043655, 0.0020312790293246508, -0.05162391439080238, -0.09448932856321335, 0.005288290791213512, 0.035408128052949905, -0.03789710998535156, 0.01202236209064722, 0.012718354351818562, -0.05634535849094391, 0.013292133808135986, 0.08250419050455093, -0.024089625105261803, -0.022017160430550575, 0.021180802956223488, 0.05577108636498451, 0.036927830427885056, 0.0071175009943544865, -0.024476205930113792, 0.03146571293473244, 0.05428222566843033, -0.02781554125249386, -0.033311907202005386, -0.012567197903990746, 0.02676468901336193, 0.024179650470614433, 0.024344071745872498, -0.056134600192308426, -0.041766457259655, 0.012449905276298523, 0.0023759084288030863, 0.02341325581073761, 0.017758790403604507, 0.039560988545417786, -0.03945232927799225, -0.08848882466554642, 0.03569755330681801, -0.038705773651599884, 0.0014494769275188446, -0.03150954842567444, -0.08398132026195526, -0.0019415259594097733, -0.04397961497306824, -0.06589168310165405, -0.05098176375031471, 0.040492113679647446, -0.026676099747419357, 0.03900619223713875, 0.01596866175532341, 0.03452084958553314, 0.0013711131177842617, 0.023003000766038895, -0.06004183739423752, 0.018202824518084526, 0.027943439781665802, -0.033734116703271866, -0.03367772325873375, -0.028387736529111862, -0.09053958207368851, 0.012624313123524189, 0.041377607733011246, -0.005494773853570223, 0.022883472964167595, 0.0010583794210106134, -0.029153810814023018, -0.04571587219834328, 0.041577477008104324, 0.04881683737039566, 0.02520746923983097, 0.07767002284526825, -0.025706173852086067, 0.06379881501197815, -0.043516505509614944, -0.061080753803253174, -0.03919871151447296, 0.058918245136737823, -0.0405590757727623, -0.009933402761816978, 0.0638032779097557, 0.00949725229293108, -0.008767146617174149, 0.005734719336032867, -0.06958364695310593, 0.016663141548633575, -0.06513246148824692, -0.024779435247182846, -0.0360155813395977, 0.030386891216039658, -0.03882961720228195, 0.0364309623837471, -0.007763328030705452, 0.024648748338222504, 0.04418587684631348, -0.005251829978078604, 0.039475928992033005, -0.05694655328989029, -0.012591545470058918, -0.010350951924920082, 0.0030965504702180624, -0.015888778492808342, 0.06998801976442337, 0.049693018198013306, -0.030975278466939926, -0.02081034518778324, -0.04867975041270256, 0.028460372239351273, 0.03994552791118622, -0.037016235291957855, -0.03657053783535957, 0.059114716947078705, -0.017307471483945847, -0.03384142369031906, -0.010916578583419323, -0.07478830963373184, 0.04896116256713867, 0.07839693874120712, -0.026043836027383804, 0.000085635190771427, -0.00436759926378727, -0.004450629465281963, -0.01611991412937641, 0.01666257157921791, 0.009685375727713108, 0.036382559686899185, 0.006172562949359417, -0.012417740188539028, -0.02666630409657955, -0.06837934255599976, 0.029313240200281143, 0.025288840755820274, 0.016818644478917122, 0.014886024408042431, 0.03331028297543526, 0.008582722395658493, 0.05058599263429642, -0.012190255336463451, 0.018080199137330055, -0.09522302448749542, 0.07265783101320267, 0.04327991604804993, -0.012591728940606117, -0.025358418002724648, -0.012480936013162136, -0.039405398070812225, -0.03374223783612251, 0.008753753267228603, 0.002513896208256483, -0.02632487379014492, 0.001258224481716752, 0.00004823142080567777, 0.05900801718235016, -0.07471360266208649, 0.058806147426366806, -0.043613895773887634, 0.033016737550497055, -0.0180903859436512, 0.0651518702507019, 0.033278487622737885, 0.041997868567705154, -0.003153582802042365, 0.03798787668347359, 0.02689662203192711, -0.05709684640169144, -0.07392897456884384, 0.06052854657173157, -0.02201719954609871, -0.04018879309296608, -0.06169521063566208, 0.014483844861388206, -0.028882397338747978, 0.017973793670535088, 0.007536132354289293, -0.010914801619946957, -0.020782869309186935, 0.05233512818813324, 0.06786288321018219, 0.027466846629977226, -0.03236040472984314, -0.03278639167547226, -0.02368004061281681, 0.0024712434969842434, -0.01902058720588684, 0.07710190117359161, 0.0016536539187654853, -0.001353967236354947, -0.06509891152381897, 0.02846650406718254, 0.03879864886403084, 0.027142858132719994, -0.02436003088951111, 0.012548889964818954, -0.013589419424533844, 0.049163978546857834, -0.031157352030277252, -0.012130331248044968, 0.009585937485098839, 0.04754507169127464, -0.01893814280629158, -0.011781604960560799, 0.012185430154204369, -0.004031085409224033, 0.012203296646475792, 0.0014010932063683867, -0.014580169692635536, -0.03566630929708481, -0.005457879509776831, 0.03671290725469589, 0.03754756599664688, 0.004629495088011026, 0.018705593422055244, -0.06027456000447273, 0.043442726135253906, -0.01615782640874386, -0.01690913923084736, 0.008148574270308018, 0.059198834002017975, -0.0020428893622010946, -0.02437606267631054, -0.018032409250736237, -0.009498273022472858, 0.04657536745071411, 0.0565926730632782, -0.04075542464852333, -0.030414817854762077, -0.045565471053123474, -0.02367209643125534, 0.04084344953298569, -0.03766710311174393, -0.004928518086671829, -0.03605981171131134, -0.017046546563506126, -0.03461601212620735, -0.04862416163086891, 0.012672350741922855, 0.010204967111349106, 0.027223259210586548, -0.069783054292202, -0.012395791709423065, 0.005398864392191172, 0.010728124529123306, 0.012088913470506668, -0.0002618436119519174, -0.052802298218011856, 0.015306223183870316, -0.018258847296237946, -0.030482714995741844, 0.014468361623585224, -0.01924843341112137, 0.047771111130714417, 0.028161071240901947, -0.024980004876852036, 0.021688926964998245, -0.036641646176576614, -0.04327494278550148, 0.01954292692244053, -0.05451598018407822, 0.025804555043578148, -0.024908103048801422, 0.04708102345466614, -0.008110453374683857, 0.017867745831608772, -0.0269533209502697, -0.03866884484887123, 0.042604539543390274, -0.0022912267595529556, -0.020828261971473694, 0.004038418643176556, 0.007752835750579834, 0.02725374698638916, 0.021259263157844543, -0.009961930103600025, -0.005973052233457565, -0.0188347939401865, -0.07101357728242874, -0.007528997492045164, 0.04237533360719681, -0.027034388855099678, 0.016379661858081818, 0.03270532935857773, -0.02308858558535576, 0.012463068589568138, 0.05803637579083443, -0.0007727345218881965, 0.023762352764606476, 0.02569570578634739, 0.045355625450611115, -0.08932465314865112, 0.04481123015284538, 0.00011939227260882035, 0.013946278020739555, 0.08721468597650528, -0.039321642369031906, 0.000021948004359728657, -0.013587640598416328, -0.02723710425198078, -0.01744464971125126, 0.05928177759051323, -0.021622411906719208, -0.03295660391449928, 0.008540846407413483, -0.024870675057172775, 0.04228533059358597, -0.05169760808348656, -0.01769779622554779, 0.001141721149906516, 0.03662381321191788, 0.0701214000582695, 0.003806566121056676, 0.026705889031291008, -0.025921253487467766, -0.005575258284807205, 0.010209323838353157, 0.02565724216401577, 0.00012766936561092734, 0.04381512477993965, 0.04888871684670448, 0.02713286131620407, -0.0036646977532655, -0.005611953791230917, -0.0035452176816761494, -0.008956429548561573, -0.015517341904342175, -0.05491721257567406, -0.022718803957104683, 0.018779171630740166, -0.09232228994369507, -0.04889476299285889, 0.01904771663248539, -0.0025816811248660088, -0.011688646860420704, 0.032874125987291336, 0.06349030882120132, -0.0010892129503190517, 0.003970719408243895, -0.019252602010965347, -0.04441319406032562, -0.01791788451373577, -0.0008214665576815605, 0.014046766795217991, -0.030960267409682274, 0.03714435175061226, -0.02098642662167549, 0.0030630631372332573, -0.027086351066827774, 0.03787674754858017, -0.008252051658928394, -0.005990517791360617, 0.02255040965974331, 0.020395899191498756, -0.008641758933663368, 0.023340566083788872, 0.012135643512010574, -0.011890891939401627, 0.0051142810843884945, -0.0337739922106266, -0.015299404971301556, -0.016881760209798813, 0.004285385366529226, 0.019781451672315598, -0.06317201256752014, 0.003710513934493065, 0.06975840777158737, 0.02989947237074375, 0.0027256589382886887, 0.030113138258457184, 0.0054665845818817616, -0.023452507331967354, 0.004175390582531691, -0.002555565442889929, -0.020551862195134163, -0.019294096156954765, 0.0121260154992342, -0.007680374197661877, -0.04456521198153496, -0.03094698302447796, -0.09117954969406128, 0.04552959278225899, 0.03937786445021629, 0.009221061132848263, -0.01151034515351057, -0.042527083307504654, 0.01897185854613781, -0.06621889770030975, -0.03384106606245041, -0.019259026274085045, 0.02275271527469158, -0.01599173992872238, -0.03471708670258522, -0.011945926584303379, -0.021762454882264137, 0.017023008316755295, -0.042586661875247955, 0.05254153162240982, 0.058834515511989594, -0.02034575305879116, 0.056088823825120926, 0.057248156517744064, -0.04104363173246384, 0.009718635119497776, -0.05884028226137161, 0.05784209817647934, 0.07691706717014313, -0.002059968188405037, 0.028595218434929848, 0.054074935615062714, -0.018900830298662186, 0.007072962820529938, 0.035189978778362274, -0.0464082732796669, 0.02609189972281456, -0.02886315807700157, 0.060634009540081024, -0.03371681272983551, -0.014766539447009563, -0.010212244465947151, -0.01508898101747036, -0.05401976406574249, -0.04699062183499336, 0.05372551828622818, 0.026932671666145325, -0.03010316751897335, 0.01842261478304863, 0.014906632713973522, 0.0020047673024237156, -0.07352157682180405, 0.012824535369873047, 0.012042025104165077, -0.02347095124423504, -0.01288721151649952, 0.010267423465847969, -0.022365251556038857, -0.003574700327590108, 0.00555603951215744, -0.04700898751616478, 0.06195501610636711, -0.008915267884731293, 0.015614439733326435, 0.02050069533288479, -0.054318077862262726, -0.0018095464911311865, 0.025901034474372864, 0.039606787264347076, 0.05177190154790878, 0.014601599425077438, 0.016656095162034035, -0.0423135869204998, 0.001493309740908444, -0.005769008304923773, -0.051335398107767105, 0.00030790833989158273, -0.06349202990531921, -0.03622296079993248, -0.025008607655763626, 0.07072875648736954, 0.004279524553567171, 0.011788496747612953, 0.005737276282161474, -0.005694934166967869, -0.027978071942925453, 0.02390477992594242, -0.020348288118839264, 0.01521574892103672, 0.003715364495292306, 0.03141729161143303, -0.006467530969530344, 0.03813411295413971, -0.035791222006082535, 0.015137008391320705, -0.00802422035485506, -0.03635362908244133, -0.012289096601307392, 0.07227495312690735, 0.013445527292788029, 0.0017318131867796183, 0.05754269286990166, 0.026186959818005562, -0.0021622914355248213, 0.0004481218056753278, -0.053436003625392914, -0.08306577056646347, 0.03416098281741142, -0.001808482687920332, 0.01848333142697811, -0.06832095980644226, -0.0274247657507658, -0.004428312182426453, 0.0978899672627449, -0.007614782080054283, 0.010835994966328144, 0.012876201421022415, 0.03168146684765816, -0.05697193369269371, -0.014673395082354546, 0.016341397538781166, -0.020266273990273476, -0.028468767181038857, -0.021824972704052925, 0.04674408212304115, -0.03375227376818657, -0.014812109060585499, -0.044096849858760834, -0.0489654541015625, -0.009616219438612461, 0.009519238956272602, -0.037638645619153976, 0.01340735424309969, -0.05969196557998657, -0.048645660281181335, -0.041405025869607925, -0.01789356768131256, -0.003507055575028062, -0.016600167378783226, -0.022513970732688904, 0.008072455413639545, 0.03249566629528999, 0.0455288365483284, -0.029437802731990814, -0.03125455603003502, 0.04442368075251579, -0.03516129031777382, 0.04880724847316742, -0.021390767768025398, -0.002277669031172991, -0.011701665818691254, 0.11013596504926682, 0.027070339769124985, 0.00012500408047344536, 0.009844202548265457, 0.02309594117105007, 0.02885533683001995, -0.00008192266977857798, -0.03677394241094589, 0.013324269093573093, 0.009225433692336082, -0.011415544897317886, 0.01055966503918171, -0.021825168281793594, 0.006978305522352457, 0.04983930289745331, -0.05684405192732811, -0.0671350434422493, -0.024452321231365204, 0.04324530437588692, 0.0013723595766350627 ]
<p>This question is closely related to <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/28834/7670"><em>Event horizons without singularities</em></a> from about a year ago (May 2012), which <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/users/1325/john-rennie">John Rennie</a> answered nicely and persuasively.</p> <p>My variant of the question is this: Given an <em>existing</em> large-scale black hole and associated event horizon, how does matter manage to fall through the event horizon?</p> <p>Here's the reference thought experiment I'm using:</p> <p>Assume two clocks communicating in both directions via radio or laser, with the observer clock kept distant from the black hole, and the falling clock heading towards the event horizon of the black hole.</p> <p>Each clock "sees" the time units (call them seconds) of the other clock through the radio link, and can express the size of those time units in terms of its own units of time. The observer clock watches the time units of the falling clock grow quickly in length, until at the event horizon the seconds of the falling clock become infinite in length. To the observer clock, it looks as though the falling clock has become suspended in time at the event horizon, since a clock with infinitely long seconds requires an infinite time to do anything.</p> <p>Now the standard interpretation is that since the falling clock has its own time standard, it sees nothing amiss at the event horizon. In that interpretation, the apparent "freezing" of the falling clock is more-or-less an illusion caused by the falling clock red-shifting out of communication with the rest of the universe. By that interpretation, the observer clock is viewing what amounts to a massively slowed-down recording of the moments right up to the falling clock leaving the visible universe. The remaining, um, "singular" fate of the falling clock is simply hidden from view. It is an appealing scenario, one that "feels right" for interpreting the oddities of infinite time dilation.</p> <p>My problem is with what the falling clock sees.</p> <p>As best I can understand it -- and my question is what I'm seeing wrongly -- the falling clock will not see the event horizon as a "no big deal" event. Instead, it will see the time flow of the observer region accelerate very quickly, so that the falling clock can observe <em>and in principle exchange data with</em> events in the very distant future of the observer universe.</p> <p>A second rather noticeable effect will be that unless the external universe stays very dark indeed, the falling clock will be incinerated by blue shifted radiation before hitting the event horizon proper. Why that is so is not hard to see: If at some point the falling clock measures the observer clock as having seconds that are one billionth the length of its own falling clock seconds, then the frequency of any electromagnetic radiation sent to it from the observer region will also be multiplied in frequency by a billion times. Or from the observer clock perspective, the falling clock has slowed down so severely in time that it begins accumulating energy over very long periods of time.</p> <p>My biggest problem is that if the falling clock can <em>interact</em> with the future universe, no matter how painfully, its time dilation is necessarily real and observable, and not simply a left-over recording of the last moments of its fall out of this universe. So, if the falling clock is still available to interact with an observer clock a billion years from now, then it is not truly "in the black" yet, just very, very cold and slow -- and still perched very close to, but <em>still</em> not all the way through, the event horizon.</p> <p>This would mean that regardless of how the black hole formed -- which is a separate question, and one that John Rennie addressed nicely last time -- then once it has formed, <em>external matter and light cannot penetrate its event horizon.</em></p> <p>So what is the deal here? Is there something fundamentally wrong with my thought experiment? How exactly does a falling clock move through a region where the seconds are infinite in length? (And one more thought in passing: Does the observer clock also appear to become more distant in space? That might help... maybe?)</p> <p><strong>Addendum 2013-10-27</strong></p> <p>Here's the most succinct version of the question I can come up with:</p> <blockquote> <p>What is the mathematical procedure for calculating the last distant-clock time tag that the falling clock sees as it approaches the event horizon?</p> </blockquote> <p>The above version keeps the calculation firmly embedded in the time system of the falling clock, avoiding the dangers in statements such as "time flows normally for the falling clock." That assertion is patently true, but since it does not calculate the last time tag seen, it does not answer the question.</p> <p><a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/users/3099/twistor59">@twistor95</a> left a nice, highly relevant reference to an <a href="http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/BlackHoles/fall_in.html">online article by John Baez</a> on why most physicists now think that a clock falling into a black hole will <em>not</em> see the end of the universe. <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/users/2451/qmechanic">@Qmechanic</a> noted an <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/21319/2451">an earlier Physics SE question</a> that to be honest I think is the same as mine. (I really did look, but Qmechanic is a lot better at such searches.) What's worrisome is that the answer to that question was the older physics view that the falling clock <em>would</em> see the end of the universe!</p> <p>I must 'fess up that I exchanged a few emails with John Baez on this topic years before he wrote that piece. What left me baffled at that time was a subtle switch in whose time standard was used. So, in my current variant of this question, I tried as carefully as I could to ask the question in terms of predicting the last time stamp the falling clock would receive. This phrasing shifts focus from "Will he see the end of the universe?" (Baez: no) to what the math predicts. Prediction is, after all, the very essence of what good scientific theory is all about.</p> <p>The old answer was that the cutoff occurs at infinity, that is, at the end of the external universe. If you accept that cutoff for a clock that is merely <em>approaching</em> the event horizon and has not yet fallen through it, then the idea that you can fall through an event horizon becomes very problematic indeed. See for example <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/users/1186/anixx">@Anixx</a>'s <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/21357/7670">accepted "collapsar" answer</a> for the older version of this question.</p> <p>So, since the current answer is that the falling clock does <em>not</em> see the end of the universe, the visibility cutoff must necessarily occur for a tag that is well short of the end of the external universe. You cannot assert the one ("no end seen") without implying the other ("some tag will be the last one seen").</p> <p>So again: If "no end is seen" is the answer, how is the implied final tag calculated?</p> <p>I will be blunt on one point: As someone with an information technologies background, I see no strong reason to view either the old or the new answer as more persuasive. Untestable code, whether mathematical or programmatic, is always in danger of errors.</p> <p><strong>Addendum 2013-10-30</strong></p> <p>My question has been very nicely answered (no end-of-universe is seen!) in this new (2013-10-29) question asked by <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/users/1325/john-rennie">John Rennie</a>:</p> <blockquote> <p><a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/82678/7670">Does someone falling into a black hole see the end of the universe?</a></p> </blockquote> <p><a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/users/17320/michael-brown">Michael Brown</a> provided the answer, and John Rennie then iced the cake by providing an additional diagram that shows the actual intersection of the outside time stamp with the falling clock. Beautiful and elegant stuff!</p> <p>Alas, though, it also means I don't have an answer to check here. @MichaelBrown, if you happen see this and don't mind adding in a link to your other answer as an answer here, I'd be happy to flag your link to close out this question.</p>
g7440
[ 0.02632426656782627, 0.008783899247646332, 0.03565720468759537, -0.04762138053774834, 0.015141351148486137, 0.05963706970214844, 0.035979416221380234, 0.018602939322590828, -0.009481759741902351, -0.04718071594834328, 0.00822390615940094, -0.0020083412528038025, 0.011525090783834457, 0.03280435502529144, -0.011731586419045925, 0.018399914726614952, 0.13208022713661194, -0.029711488634347916, -0.00970555655658245, -0.01449664868414402, -0.017906665802001953, 0.02683081477880478, -0.0007666017045266926, -0.032580114901065826, -0.09588948637247086, -0.023246105760335922, 0.023435620591044426, 0.047987278550863266, -0.0442078560590744, -0.021344980224967003, 0.06112930551171303, -0.023726969957351685, -0.024468908086419106, 0.014609670266509056, 0.04376598820090294, -0.05649549514055252, -0.007496042177081108, 0.016581887379288673, -0.035700492560863495, 0.06294762343168259, 0.01406619418412447, -0.024768492206931114, -0.036647483706474304, -0.014737274497747421, 0.005284969694912434, 0.020806416869163513, 0.0012551776599138975, 0.026290878653526306, 0.0848967581987381, -0.07654360681772232, 0.005096884910017252, 0.020175401121377945, 0.07617097347974777, 0.013539252802729607, 0.05104775354266167, 0.04830799996852875, 0.01618063636124134, 0.022782301530241966, 0.02569964900612831, 0.03198106214404106, 0.02759929932653904, -0.030486229807138443, 0.013091502711176872, -0.0314086489379406, 0.019525768235325813, 0.03828234225511551, -0.093958280980587, -0.019833777099847794, -0.04518377408385277, 0.005406302399933338, -0.02520565688610077, 0.00901377759873867, -0.054221414029598236, -0.005714414641261101, 0.008991549722850323, 0.05754518136382103, -0.009922463446855545, -0.03957990184426308, 0.008783015422523022, 0.013254961930215359, -0.07720373570919037, -0.0016122878296300769, -0.009894405491650105, 0.018372533842921257, 0.06977973133325577, 0.04065012186765671, 0.019181834533810616, 0.035764336585998535, -0.016242269426584244, 0.04804940149188042, -0.009002224542200565, -0.047127652913331985, 0.06267936527729034, -0.01817072369158268, 0.01802261359989643, 0.043242499232292175, 0.011685994453728199, 0.06169643625617027, 0.07165076583623886, 0.07067181915044785, -0.05175171419978142, 0.03133591264486313, -0.012730280868709087, -0.010220143012702465, 0.007556471042335033, -0.02866196259856224, -0.03454797342419624, 0.040364500135183334, -0.04882858321070671, -0.0067628431133925915, -0.052699267864227295, -0.0850621685385704, -0.010311415418982506, -0.036897554993629456, -0.04894546791911125, -0.033824410289525986, 0.044178642332553864, 0.011714870110154152, 0.011073124594986439, 0.05707363411784172, -0.00598475756123662, 0.02210172265768051, 0.04999133199453354, 0.024654751643538475, 0.009907335974276066, -0.002436166862025857, 0.015225823037326336, 0.0016315336106345057, -0.023633936420083046, -0.018629778176546097, -0.03871208429336548, 0.06650970876216888, 0.031657204031944275, 0.057712286710739136, -0.05637594312429428, 0.029034314677119255, 0.039138246327638626, -0.025731507688760757, -0.016384826973080635, 0.00580977089703083, 0.009150367230176926, -0.06724607944488525, -0.02491580881178379, -0.024117184802889824, -0.005118156783282757, 0.04937735199928284, -0.021141620352864265, -0.016878750175237656, 0.02718527801334858, -0.039943668991327286, -0.04754780977964401, 0.07393281906843185, -0.038800910115242004, -0.05095028877258301, -0.02551972307264805, 0.04291655123233795, 0.0123802050948143, -0.03204604983329773, -0.0120719438418746, 0.05721776559948921, 0.07434896379709244, -0.034450970590114594, -0.027073118835687637, 0.026901474222540855, -0.04267848655581474, 0.009545648470520973, 0.02478577196598053, -0.07485448569059372, 0.04264642670750618, -0.050397761166095734, -0.08612813800573349, -0.022879060357809067, 0.022012853994965553, 0.03350076079368591, 0.01489590760320425, 0.04147282987833023, 0.07462792098522186, 0.017125166952610016, -0.029339611530303955, -0.024749282747507095, -0.025890888646245003, -0.05571760609745979, -0.034085921943187714, -0.014957607723772526, -0.007870656438171864, -0.04704746603965759, 0.04425204545259476, 0.04486541077494621, 0.023255351930856705, -0.012016678228974342, -0.039251234382390976, -0.0663997083902359, 0.01574043743312359, 0.0348924845457077, -0.047424767166376114, 0.0028141045477241278, 0.007433511782437563, -0.025946935638785362, -0.010872206650674343, 0.02699972316622734, 0.0443078838288784, -0.027196357026696205, 0.0032926585990935564, 0.046036288142204285, 0.08308417350053787, 0.0171817597001791, -0.0032107208389788866, -0.02004597708582878, -0.018696246668696404, -0.0341748483479023, 0.011984720826148987, -0.01579556055366993, -0.03491026535630226, 0.005908193066716194, -0.036751888692379, 0.0011847397545352578, -0.04150056838989258, 0.03601229190826416, -0.007055383641272783, 0.06145911663770676, -0.028056442737579346, -0.013982406817376614, 0.0719134658575058, -0.04930240660905838, -0.009039980359375477, -0.004479125142097473, -0.06979614496231079, -0.05877184122800827, -0.005721885245293379, 0.03389422968029976, -0.0692516416311264, 0.03896206617355347, -0.023176787421107292, 0.03193525969982147, 0.018046200275421143, -0.0064873830415308475, -0.0015581755433231592, -0.010387329384684563, 0.021621577441692352, 0.013236836530268192, 0.0008701775805093348, -0.025633368641138077, -0.09156674146652222, -0.020832734182476997, 0.02846311591565609, -0.015540547668933868, 0.03010641597211361, -0.0029895410407334566, 0.007696263957768679, 0.03489873185753822, 0.057399049401283264, -0.037513621151447296, -0.031756844371557236, -0.037270303815603256, -0.013793926686048508, -0.06388799846172333, 0.0032829956617206335, 0.038436297327280045, -0.06315240263938904, 0.008335637860000134, 0.018067283555865288, -0.03695409372448921, 0.018714861944317818, 0.06771339476108551, -0.07599999010562897, -0.014749244786798954, -0.07939309626817703, 0.05168404057621956, -0.023838644847273827, 0.03721342980861664, -0.017270050942897797, -0.027775777503848076, 0.0338173434138298, 0.05142468586564064, 0.01605033688247204, 0.021866565570235252, -0.06304354965686798, -0.02741832286119461, 0.0980917364358902, -0.003845474449917674, -0.03847875818610191, 0.014691329561173916, -0.07781212776899338, 0.01842297427356243, 0.02183871902525425, -0.014650003053247929, -0.0013174538034945726, 0.0020101338159292936, 0.0000987163366517052, 0.020502230152487755, -0.012843429110944271, 0.06126122549176216, 0.01625968888401985, 0.06197630241513252, -0.013525065034627914, 0.0356324128806591, -0.04234654828906059, -0.026092253625392914, -0.05724367871880531, -0.03164315223693848, 0.035232171416282654, -0.05204883962869644, -0.02473515272140503, 0.07852763682603836, 0.045374684035778046, 0.01646306738257408, -0.03946000337600708, -0.032158125191926956, 0.020528476685285568, -0.03875860199332237, -0.015757303684949875, 0.02150697447359562, 0.04955257102847099, -0.031716056168079376, 0.0024327447172254324, 0.024547766894102097, 0.020089223980903625, 0.0494106151163578, -0.02176777273416519, 0.03175506740808487, 0.032415930181741714, 0.022691473364830017, -0.03829343244433403, -0.020646238699555397, 0.05906900018453598, -0.02692250721156597, 0.015661804005503654, -0.026039637625217438, -0.032136399298906326, 0.007083019241690636, -0.021621908992528915, -0.047955915331840515, -0.014444610103964806, -0.0370316207408905, -0.024580316618084908, -0.013265438377857208, -0.0033198336604982615, 0.003119562054052949, 0.03779046982526779, -0.0010869622929021716, 0.0474088117480278, -0.011702691204845905, 0.007561786100268364, 0.026103578507900238, 0.058410029858350754, -0.020848756656050682, -0.02130802534520626, -0.02436148189008236, -0.018003839999437332, -0.02673870325088501, 0.02316911146044731, -0.020741915330290794, 0.0055799176916480064, -0.002872027922421694, 0.016290638595819473, -0.02174106426537037, -0.014843709766864777, 0.02758979983627796, 0.042995575815439224, -0.03058856725692749, 0.02852639928460121, -0.006244270596653223, 0.036549799144268036, -0.012193446978926659, 0.0005086649907752872, -0.037376563996076584, -0.002121004043146968, 0.014407032169401646, 0.022127659991383553, -0.031889237463474274, 0.04109887406229973, 0.05635945871472359, -0.0023947160225361586, 0.004060412757098675, -0.005676875822246075, -0.08636762946844101, 0.01282784529030323, 0.04218035563826561, -0.007260709069669247, 0.04381047189235687, 0.025102324783802032, 0.01421397551894188, -0.01155493501573801, -0.003783790860325098, 0.07109863311052322, 0.03985235095024109, 0.002562877256423235, -0.07183844596147537, -0.048166465014219284, -0.024838365614414215, 0.018918650224804878, -0.0414365716278553, 0.018961193040013313, -0.04423554986715317, 0.004753145854920149, -0.01248177420347929, -0.008862501010298729, -0.014112874865531921, 0.03308035433292389, -0.0025122370570898056, 0.02635800652205944, 0.04061485826969147, -0.0012539471499621868, 0.021129317581653595, 0.03519692271947861, 0.018995648249983788, -0.007770239375531673, -0.014485782943665981, 0.0023340999614447355, -0.007975065149366856, 0.027225324884057045, 0.03315000981092453, -0.05457691103219986, -0.050092123448848724, 0.03737188130617142, -0.06812474131584167, 0.04825235530734062, -0.008215409703552723, -0.01158918533474207, -0.01974504627287388, 0.019088925793766975, -0.0056978678330779076, -0.03966079652309418, -0.002408895641565323, -0.027373630553483963, 0.001239547971636057, 0.003742097644135356, 0.023739119991660118, -0.043900907039642334, 0.0381619930267334, 0.010029199533164501, -0.007273597177118063, 0.023144187405705452, 0.07305750995874405, -0.03903966024518013, 0.08051097393035889, 0.015551320277154446, 0.05320223420858383, 0.04160496965050697, 0.058039456605911255, 0.05158166587352753, -0.045581478625535965, -0.054383374750614166, 0.007428816054016352, -0.049266792833805084, 0.0534781888127327, -0.055766161531209946, -0.011282443068921566, 0.006670841947197914, -0.0029207065235823393, -0.022324953228235245, 0.0011417270870879292, 0.021993441507220268, -0.025454819202423096, -0.013442193157970905, -0.009296920150518417, -0.02820148691534996, 0.0647289901971817, -0.00431220605969429, -0.011614820919930935, -0.06900420784950256, -0.030644459649920464, -0.04680284485220909, 0.038522958755493164, 0.01709732599556446, -0.003133513266220689, -0.016484061256051064, -0.04544069990515709, -0.031431376934051514, -0.0014051551697775722, -0.1113211065530777, -0.0005721934139728546, 0.014630903489887714, -0.014436026103794575, -0.004380880855023861, 0.03400164097547531, -0.007605194579809904, -0.051865074783563614, 0.06460754573345184, -0.004278633743524551, -0.019266678020358086, -0.01650320366024971, 0.04157159850001335, 0.02660103142261505, -0.02133629471063614, 0.0573103204369545, -0.027424123138189316, 0.012563413009047508, 0.03191405162215233, 0.008409091271460056, 0.033491525799036026, -0.0899842232465744, -0.006576206535100937, -0.027349146082997322, -0.047136757522821426, -0.02898172289133072, 0.05939200893044472, -0.0062625412829220295, 0.03533071652054787, -0.040574997663497925, -0.027960821986198425, 0.04789752513170242, 0.01838728040456772, 0.0001055405373335816, -0.0021359107922762632, 0.007402278948575258, 0.0408552847802639, 0.02115103416144848, 0.049283113330602646, 0.07133743166923523, -0.0165655966848135, 0.012007678858935833, -0.007168647833168507, 0.030292101204395294, 0.022285811603069305, -0.029271239414811134, 0.046794138848781586, -0.033304985612630844, 0.0037033148109912872, -0.007228710688650608, -0.03759932890534401, 0.021526264026761055, 0.019410647451877594, 0.014173268340528011, 0.045118849724531174, -0.07690348476171494, -0.03430575132369995, -0.02159099467098713, -0.033193547278642654, -0.013891206122934818, 0.022979872301220894, 0.03974805772304535, 0.02596675604581833, 0.013265913352370262, 0.007981323637068272, 0.04924841225147247, 0.023155560716986656, -0.020034149289131165, 0.02151517942547798, -0.03928922489285469, -0.008292182348668575, -0.000827547162771225, 0.039560236036777496, 0.07277652621269226, 0.04632825776934624, -0.012061646208167076, -0.020347027108073235, 0.03968260437250137, 0.041455358266830444, -0.03368605673313141, -0.01384884212166071, 0.03194093331694603, -0.01292463205754757, 0.08505739271640778, 0.011977717280387878, 0.008562169037759304, 0.07090812176465988, -0.07255448400974274, -0.05876832455396652, -0.03931398689746857, -0.020853860303759575, -0.043173015117645264, -0.019940458238124847, -0.011862527579069138, 0.0086686285212636, -0.05518548935651779, -0.018885409459471703, -0.02300027757883072, 0.019826171919703484, 0.05071059986948967, -0.0031542249489575624, 0.005900464486330748, 0.012364376336336136, -0.011897996999323368, -0.014052151702344418, 0.03147182986140251, -0.03145676478743553, -0.05659548565745354, -0.03664407134056091, -0.04505790024995804, -0.028177659958600998, -0.04368419945240021, 0.06638958305120468, -0.039287008345127106, 0.02182309702038765, -0.003953187260776758, -0.07451453804969788, -0.00515387300401926, -0.025735342875123024, -0.00495194224640727, -0.04396923631429672, -0.00823601521551609, 0.06460307538509369, -0.04619472846388817, -0.07541076838970184, -0.020569829270243645, -0.03763775900006294, -0.05111166834831238, -0.0336744450032711, 0.008799309842288494, -0.03538050502538681, -0.04144890233874321, 0.03152438625693321, -0.011815792880952358, 0.02453499101102352, 0.01647532917559147, -0.04031775891780853, 0.0020854417234659195, 0.07952079176902771, -0.000430700252763927, 0.009468326345086098, 0.04860617592930794, -0.01155063882470131, 0.060503989458084106, -0.03183695673942566, 0.00750356912612915, -0.007430452853441238, -0.02510826662182808, -0.022475790232419968, -0.013605781830847263, 0.034321464598178864, -0.01420466136187315, 0.009283097460865974, -0.02197430655360222, -0.017315413802862167, 0.0641467496752739, -0.028069455176591873, 0.018054595217108727, 0.016952404752373695, 0.03838656097650528, 0.028741447255015373, 0.014251919463276863, -0.025487229228019714, -0.005358820781111717, 0.029750993475317955, 0.06302036345005035, 0.012431533075869083, -0.010647064074873924, 0.02151755802333355, -0.03751080855727196, 0.02109760046005249, 0.000722814176697284, -0.00800132006406784, 0.014805863611400127, -0.04867368936538696, -0.024403655901551247, 0.02090485207736492, 0.0603061318397522, -0.07561114430427551, 0.013042458333075047, 0.02601618692278862, -0.037414636462926865, -0.06008797511458397, 0.02443535439670086, 0.03394137695431709, -0.020336035639047623, 0.008415183052420616, 0.02343229576945305, 0.03453778475522995, -0.0574411116540432, 0.01943720318377018, -0.02769365720450878, -0.05297156050801277, -0.007087454199790955, 0.000772420666180551, 0.039913710206747055, -0.03692327439785004, -0.06568000465631485, 0.008726611733436584, -0.011817327700555325, 0.02268793061375618, -0.037587713450193405, -0.04239712655544281, -0.041509877890348434, -0.000563359004445374, -0.08628006279468536, -0.026182327419519424, 0.036757685244083405, -0.022008391097187996, 0.0327594168484211, 0.05638111010193825, 0.04155517742037773, -0.01873154379427433, 0.005254534073174, 0.018081504851579666, 0.026749785989522934, -0.031858377158641815, 0.028030626475811005, -0.04323049262166023, 0.008045109920203686, -0.0008553480729460716, 0.04872582480311394, -0.058793310075998306, 0.012722082436084747, -0.005702883005142212, 0.004180483054369688, 0.08311548829078674, -0.016101934015750885, 0.023333946242928505, -0.017749499529600143, 0.002128778723999858, 0.04369276389479637, 0.004732068162411451, 0.051230136305093765, 0.018007153645157814, 0.04292193427681923, -0.011653347872197628, -0.026535164564847946, -0.013794554397463799, 0.0028799253050237894, 0.03147850185632706, 0.04502180963754654, -0.014185740612447262, -0.012309727258980274, 0.004895051009953022, -0.016646942123770714, 0.018912702798843384, -0.0010287349577993155, 0.009120983071625233, -0.026490285992622375, -0.051519811153411865, 0.03257651999592781, -0.03644648566842079, -0.04105392470955849, -0.030766909942030907, -0.0022727791219949722, 0.05700209364295006, 0.014902359806001186, -0.054829876869916916, -0.03748701885342598, -0.004982335027307272, 0.012454187497496605, -0.03652137145400047, 0.03032190166413784, -0.033683378249406815, -0.03318248689174652, 0.011000020429491997, -0.0017841143999248743, -0.02358844503760338, 0.01896875910460949, -0.00744465971365571, -0.08762571215629578, 0.013499133288860321, -0.0018942211754620075, 0.013867105357348919, -0.026240959763526917, -0.0005103019066154957, 0.02548997476696968, 0.02499074675142765, -0.02707492560148239, 0.006485207937657833, 0.048299625515937805, 0.012162292376160622, -0.002030477160587907, 0.04920873045921326, -0.01892254315316677, -0.004955210257321596, 0.006499751005321741, -0.0195363350212574, -0.00896345917135477, -0.013976593501865864, -0.016766898334026337, -0.0032035161275416613, -0.02458077110350132, 0.03520165756344795, -0.0017895500641316175, 0.061134129762649536, 0.0023769214749336243 ]
<p>I understand that in general if we're adding more planes of atoms (increasing thickness of sample) then the intensity would increase because we have more constructive interference. But isn't there a breaking point for this? Shouldn't there be a finite thickness past which the intensity decreases? </p>
g7441
[ 0.013452324084937572, 0.03354044631123543, 0.012926010414958, -0.04010075330734253, 0.024893376976251602, 0.021436870098114014, -0.0006431848159991205, 0.05299345403909683, -0.0738288015127182, -0.04997217655181885, -0.006648015696555376, -0.0007565722335129976, -0.01809464395046234, 0.017520949244499207, 0.031142085790634155, -0.017760364338755608, -0.031886931508779526, -0.03539684787392616, 0.022798307240009308, 0.04849470406770706, -0.055862076580524445, -0.03197455778717995, 0.014228088781237602, -0.062375880777835846, -0.04413649067282677, 0.028127290308475494, 0.03034985437989235, -0.032378487288951874, -0.00207906449213624, 0.04217880591750145, 0.05132800713181496, -0.02926798164844513, 0.01451193168759346, 0.003413763362914324, -0.010921095497906208, 0.0023710113018751144, 0.025351187214255333, 0.03988796845078468, 0.05321769043803215, -0.029052479192614555, 0.02730589732527733, -0.05123898759484291, -0.0061073810793459415, -0.026119565591216087, -0.08162231743335724, -0.017624475061893463, 0.01632869988679886, -0.0009892089292407036, 0.008485631085932255, -0.05075056478381157, -0.048626162111759186, 0.0028922096826136112, 0.01382718700915575, 0.04611027613282204, 0.0217735692858696, 0.06926482170820236, -0.08881888538599014, -0.10315436869859695, 0.04003407806158066, 0.06218515709042549, -0.025040896609425545, -0.0071755023673176765, -0.020578503608703613, 0.02276282198727131, 0.028919992968440056, -0.028816020116209984, -0.048794183880090714, 0.007878182455897331, 0.01530346181243658, 0.02545084059238434, -0.013460996560752392, -0.07084966450929642, -0.05349145084619522, -0.026689492166042328, -0.014510905370116234, 0.01749533601105213, 0.016178838908672333, 0.02608347497880459, -0.02876974083483219, 0.03338536247611046, -0.01941700279712677, -0.036942008882761, 0.02630728669464588, -0.07322953641414642, 0.0418345145881176, 0.012962463311851025, 0.03344740718603134, -0.050625406205654144, -0.014167574234306812, 0.014137959107756615, 0.040369533002376556, -0.016486389562487602, 0.02865663543343544, -0.012583709321916103, -0.01786983758211136, -0.02591545321047306, 0.03093969076871872, 0.01044507510960102, -0.03645515814423561, 0.008791718631982803, -0.005495223682373762, -0.00683036120608449, 0.07503586262464523, -0.027311576530337334, -0.030603177845478058, 0.004506184719502926, -0.0483168363571167, -0.037124697118997574, -0.028851598501205444, 0.016886770725250244, -0.04731843248009682, -0.028215304017066956, -0.058717552572488785, -0.00397188076749444, 0.011945084668695927, 0.03354137763381004, 0.04447680711746216, 0.011918751522898674, 0.02175910770893097, 0.06559246778488159, 0.027214838191866875, -0.004717977251857519, 0.039903637021780014, -0.007059823255985975, -0.017939992249011993, 0.03580938279628754, 0.03533225879073143, 0.0378989614546299, 0.027780191972851753, -0.0781414806842804, 0.03392966464161873, 0.041643619537353516, -0.024545306339859962, 0.011066809296607971, 0.051171235740184784, 0.009982410818338394, -0.030024196952581406, -0.037575170397758484, 0.005200937390327454, 0.059288252145051956, -0.026071064174175262, 0.001069938763976097, 0.009284960106015205, -0.04418172687292099, -0.02574683167040348, -0.012611263431608677, 0.00851974543184042, 0.03233466297388077, 0.02415858954191208, -0.0022903091739863157, 0.019692104309797287, 0.02734125405550003, 0.06071658059954643, -0.061662014573812485, -0.0024839446414262056, 0.015931840986013412, 0.04400360584259033, -0.03320722281932831, 0.042715515941381454, -0.009331019595265388, 0.04710470885038376, 0.0155273312702775, -0.04991234466433525, 0.015187574550509453, -0.045060135424137115, 0.0808798149228096, 0.004232608247548342, -0.06113360449671745, -0.00602769386023283, 0.0266188383102417, 0.02407051995396614, 0.024689385667443275, 0.0019953385926783085, -0.005457361228764057, 0.022885961458086967, 0.1126120463013649, 0.0968238115310669, -0.040469761937856674, 0.043186385184526443, 0.03303179144859314, -0.0535583458840847, 0.03961384296417236, -0.01771501451730728, -0.1039358451962471, 0.041719913482666016, -0.04126923531293869, -0.01733234152197838, -0.06846465915441513, -0.07054144889116287, 0.020680641755461693, 0.00807809829711914, -0.04059828072786331, -0.030746936798095703, 0.043442364782094955, -0.034138865768909454, 0.017526624724268913, 0.02824399620294571, -0.03992917388677597, -0.018575888127088547, -0.006185623817145824, -0.04744371026754379, 0.0506686232984066, 0.050848085433244705, 0.06887274980545044, -0.0011915285140275955, 0.04069124162197113, -0.05486316233873367, 0.039247944951057434, -0.01038676779717207, 0.03126821666955948, -0.03095254860818386, 0.05761636048555374, 0.009139148518443108, 0.02606409601867199, 0.003635761793702841, -0.0013691398780792952, 0.01047520898282528, 0.02178269810974598, 0.030566243454813957, 0.026754284277558327, -0.004440842662006617, -0.008126570843160152, 0.06069377064704895, 0.018497126176953316, -0.03258587792515755, -0.08185630291700363, 0.013109169900417328, 0.0035102348774671555, -0.014440719038248062, 0.03920983150601387, -0.057457711547613144, -0.006288828328251839, -0.04083390533924103, -0.029211686924099922, -0.012983310036361217, -0.01042797602713108, -0.01848071627318859, 0.011946624144911766, -0.041031140834093094, -0.01614242047071457, 0.014027565717697144, -0.01671745628118515, -0.06435813754796982, 0.002664351835846901, 0.0007279387791641057, -0.05775035172700882, -0.05650712549686432, -0.039842069149017334, -0.014825423248112202, 0.014184647239744663, 0.036552637815475464, -0.007848810404539108, -0.0345768965780735, 0.04900773987174034, -0.03224777430295944, -0.0024676769971847534, -0.04200182482600212, 0.07680243998765945, -0.020512059330940247, -0.033340319991111755, 0.004634295590221882, -0.060970697551965714, 0.03959095478057861, -0.00036216506850905716, -0.028445439413189888, 0.01126124244183302, -0.0027478402480483055, -0.012829111889004707, -0.0006676859338767827, 0.007282383739948273, -0.030663684010505676, 0.07863865792751312, 0.017839962616562843, 0.0428362600505352, 0.020810363814234734, 0.07733318954706192, 0.025703230872750282, -0.017416151240468025, 0.05695623531937599, -0.052032116800546646, -0.04763513430953026, 0.036648139357566833, -0.0556027814745903, 0.01655152440071106, 0.020558185875415802, -0.025541670620441437, 0.08010371029376984, 0.03804755210876465, -0.05480678007006645, -0.03388780727982521, -0.017090395092964172, -0.008356851525604725, 0.05818818509578705, -0.002847010036930442, -0.012667402625083923, 0.007727061863988638, 0.049097705632448196, -0.03468973562121391, -0.003195492783561349, 0.05965256318449974, -0.06487587094306946, 0.04959970712661743, -0.0035748726222664118, -0.054989010095596313, 0.007730021607130766, 0.03339172899723053, 0.0006785159930586815, -0.02663891576230526, -0.03726162016391754, 0.005472889170050621, -0.003597875125706196, -0.03574890270829201, -0.006102314218878746, 0.04336071386933327, -0.00861430261284113, -0.0032017510384321213, 0.011838575825095177, 0.08130741864442825, -0.024621285498142242, 0.0014119917759671807, -0.031226390972733498, 0.007575064431875944, -0.018870802596211433, -0.051338084042072296, -0.022057155147194862, -0.0005448617157526314, 0.017655683681368828, -0.09307793527841568, -0.03477706387639046, 0.035840313881635666, 0.04788763448596001, -0.020196963101625443, 0.002138618379831314, 0.02471042610704899, -0.05922365561127663, -0.039318181574344635, -0.010837454348802567, -0.009026186540722847, 0.048650577664375305, 0.08030132204294205, -0.031964901834726334, 0.01179104670882225, 0.007690712343901396, -0.041182685643434525, 0.01915036328136921, 0.02892185188829899, -0.029472725465893745, 0.014326201751828194, -0.018950490280985832, 0.011886503547430038, 0.06946577876806259, 0.0628080889582634, -0.007396259345114231, -0.04845491796731949, -0.04652039706707001, -0.013083229772746563, 0.023763157427310944, 0.061525847762823105, -0.026390358805656433, -0.057712823152542114, 0.0254274420440197, -0.03855364769697189, 0.004535110667347908, -0.02602606825530529, -0.09029704332351685, 0.048097554594278336, -0.01955801248550415, 0.07240075618028641, 0.007349471095949411, 0.014761436730623245, -0.056906942278146744, -0.025023920461535454, -0.02234378457069397, 0.01597677730023861, 0.0012029013596475124, -0.010822657495737076, 0.053934432566165924, 0.015176624990999699, 0.024895433336496353, 0.018444962799549103, 0.02627287432551384, 0.024830438196659088, -0.018504809588193893, -0.029469875618815422, -0.011566350236535072, 0.040390677750110626, -0.04565146192908287, -0.03220943361520767, 0.000294889701763168, -0.03694070875644684, 0.012917869724333286, -0.00891669187694788, -0.030410747975111008, 0.012543474324047565, 0.018226806074380875, -0.04994462430477142, -0.03849031776189804, -0.009839782491326332, -0.02528592385351658, 0.02866634726524353, 0.036496423184871674, 0.028431398794054985, -0.024599887430667877, 0.046525467187166214, -0.007316135335713625, -0.01261982973664999, 0.06979034096002579, 0.03723251074552536, -0.008033997379243374, 0.009221541695296764, 0.02765217237174511, -0.07209928333759308, -0.04088815301656723, -0.06997019052505493, -0.0004257885739207268, -0.003523528575897217, 0.03806792199611664, 0.049236781895160675, 0.028439830988645554, 0.003571999492123723, -0.04581614211201668, 0.0272669680416584, -0.02813531644642353, 0.022691955789923668, 0.014130394905805588, 0.03909895941615105, -0.05517129600048065, -0.004512207582592964, 0.004903980530798435, -0.04475630074739456, -0.04237597435712814, 0.025648875162005424, 0.0018138894811272621, -0.0396006777882576, -0.03526011481881142, 0.019314520061016083, -0.013105529360473156, 0.08059339225292206, 0.0029874721076339483, 0.005304247140884399, 0.04648546129465103, 0.004076680168509483, 0.004606195259839296, 0.013788513839244843, 0.052231475710868835, 0.02485581673681736, -0.08073989301919937, -0.021140066906809807, 0.019435223191976547, 0.011710278689861298, -0.061259377747774124, 0.0018075795378535986, 0.016060849651694298, -0.01986442506313324, 0.0007855891599319875, -0.03434024751186371, -0.07614923268556595, 0.043039459735155106, 0.017371030524373055, 0.031095268204808235, -0.018396148458123207, 0.07688114047050476, -0.04690704494714737, -0.020899051800370216, -0.04433438926935196, -0.00773964449763298, -0.04410775750875473, -0.0036523023154586554, -0.08118292689323425, 0.0499795638024807, -0.013417829759418964, 0.044051364064216614, 0.025169113650918007, 0.07286299020051956, 0.00618040282279253, -0.007205292582511902, -0.024051984772086143, -0.00895636435598135, -0.01769738458096981, -0.070456363260746, 0.012892737984657288, -0.04864569008350372, 0.06569166481494904, 0.0002040566032519564, 0.000056325672630919144, 0.03868325799703598, -0.08227378129959106, 0.013071597553789616, 0.03535816818475723, -0.05950312688946724, 0.03949922323226929, 0.01837530918419361, 0.013567496091127396, 0.03637872263789177, -0.06647869199514389, -0.008081824518740177, 0.042965926229953766, -0.0337090939283371, -0.0345047190785408, 0.03418634831905365, -0.011705243960022926, -0.0006283944239839911, 0.0066158645786345005, -0.005491993855684996, -0.007681781426072121, 0.05071401223540306, 0.09515603631734848, -0.06438446044921875, 0.05794830992817879, 0.04415212944149971, -0.043779123574495316, -0.03658156841993332, 0.04027964547276497, -0.03520555794239044, 0.026737704873085022, 0.013645307160913944, -0.019812356680631638, 0.05423266068100929, -0.07586389780044556, -0.06125742569565773, 0.012903260067105293, -0.010670813731849194, -0.0154829490929842, -0.027493057772517204, -0.009203941561281681, 0.029942605644464493, -0.0017297002486884594, -0.030778439715504646, 0.014381065964698792, 0.018749959766864777, 0.06369993090629578, 0.02709326520562172, -0.014430435374379158, 0.029847402125597, 0.05952799320220947, 0.032412122935056686, 0.024171218276023865, -0.0027275793254375458, -0.0547550804913044, -0.0003508054360281676, 0.012248787097632885, 0.030529553070664406, -0.01022515818476677, 0.08679108321666718, 0.03855482488870621, -0.0278976671397686, 0.021568505093455315, -0.006432102061808109, 0.0716577097773552, -0.022477738559246063, -0.02816206030547619, -0.016140766441822052, 0.011889850720763206, -0.021418944001197815, -0.024525927379727364, 0.06541755050420761, 0.01519868802279234, 0.026834972202777863, 0.008697457611560822, 0.006014696322381496, 0.019168009981513023, -0.014727411791682243, -0.01794211007654667, 0.024752147495746613, 0.07242819666862488, -0.029583796858787537, -0.04729107394814491, -0.0016876792069524527, 0.01925896294414997, 0.04439549520611763, -0.025210367515683174, 0.03594202548265457, 0.030421147122979164, 0.004244186449795961, 0.015606475062668324, 0.05145087093114853, -0.029626740142703056, -0.01929960772395134, 0.0028843977488577366, -0.022250335663557053, -0.04554320499300957, 0.043989378958940506, 0.01911459118127823, 0.0006043758476153016, 0.059119053184986115, 0.0126613425090909, -0.04392425715923309, 0.00516908336430788, 0.06506308168172836, -0.06876485049724579, -0.017186956480145454, -0.035952966660261154, 0.08490287512540817, -0.02843177318572998, 0.010358667932450771, -0.027904177084565163, -0.01811055839061737, -0.001674210885539651, 0.008024890907108784, 0.010867609642446041, 0.05131756141781807, -0.014065556228160858, 0.02400379255414009, 0.004232620820403099, 0.009829378686845303, -0.008031480014324188, 0.039771098643541336, -0.018466467037796974, -0.011799894273281097, 0.015875037759542465, 0.0006807876052334905, 0.013064887374639511, 0.0339176170527935, -0.00580937834456563, 0.016763459891080856, -0.04784586653113365, 0.01957041025161743, -0.016304466873407364, -0.007472106721252203, -0.020452627912163734, 0.025203555822372437, -0.0320412702858448, 0.01967778615653515, -0.0275284256786108, 0.02250254899263382, 0.007359432987868786, -0.01126281637698412, 0.01642506569623947, 0.03298993781208992, -0.00531521812081337, 0.017130795866250992, 0.027801042422652245, 0.015864117071032524, 0.08874444663524628, -0.03829341009259224, 0.02119053341448307, -0.03261807933449745, 0.0006935616838745773, -0.027028724551200867, 0.06421608477830887, -0.02593851089477539, 0.02170655131340027, 0.01460722554475069, 0.008922074921429157, 0.0017656852724030614, -0.017813831567764282, 0.057465776801109314, -0.019234146922826767, -0.051488302648067474, 0.025764448568224907, -0.00037370945210568607, -0.01506448071449995, -0.028396978974342346, 0.00028587706037797034, -0.028245285153388977, -0.0050573511980473995, -0.01751711405813694, 0.01290260162204504, 0.045587994158267975, -0.005829805973917246, -0.03534958139061928, -0.028534362092614174, -0.04976627975702286, -0.019392434507608414, -0.0030014084186404943, 0.046540115028619766, 0.06367108225822449, -0.010008472949266434, -0.03206843510270119, -0.013016927056014538, -0.006131333764642477, -0.0506899431347847, -0.001810897490940988, 0.01274492684751749, 0.03756536543369293, -0.0317206010222435, -0.009007205255329609, 0.0028250289615243673, 0.02779512107372284, -0.009962168522179127, 0.03341633826494217, 0.032188378274440765, 0.042556025087833405, 0.008668346330523491, -0.01119428314268589, -0.022456983104348183, -0.058752138167619705, -0.03099338337779045, -0.02671842649579048, -0.02235768921673298, 0.0020689538214355707, -0.0026615264359861612, 0.00875162798911333, 0.058489907532930374, -0.03991785645484924, 0.008866623044013977, -0.03321133926510811, 0.045850276947021484, -0.010907623916864395, -0.03523372486233711, -0.04626784473657608, -0.07730640470981598, -0.01822035200893879, -0.041164759546518326, 0.008908947929739952, 0.008056598715484142, 0.01919209025800228, -0.008181699551641941, 0.043822355568408966, -0.07296565920114517, -0.024788590148091316, 0.013722993433475494, 0.042711008340120316, 0.026804670691490173, -0.007087568752467632, -0.020302360877394676, -0.05108842998743057, -0.031786054372787476, 0.03605944290757179, 0.04540187120437622, -0.019868427887558937, 0.0031672038603574038, -0.03936920315027237, 0.006710618734359741, -0.031876806169748306, 0.023531077429652214, 0.06333918124437332, -0.027539849281311035, 0.022938812151551247, 0.03525494784116745, 0.0016843442572280765, 0.019295208156108856, -0.0503227561712265, -0.052874404937028885, -0.02157810889184475, -0.02949054352939129, 0.06313761323690414, -0.02424502931535244, -0.014788920059800148, 0.015383001416921616, 0.026733076199889183, -0.008249166421592236, -0.005632220767438412, -0.0496712327003479, 0.005765599198639393, -0.002409114968031645, -0.02113286778330803, 0.015038480050861835, 0.057939313352108, -0.008917436003684998, -0.03136385977268219, -0.01639646291732788, 0.0021266143303364515, 0.025951679795980453, 0.05144462734460831, -0.02867942489683628, 0.003626341000199318, -0.008039831183850765, 0.003561344463378191, -0.06587928533554077, 0.0658968836069107, 0.0110541433095932, 0.00242311367765069, -0.012355352751910686, -0.04395012930035591, -0.006221592891961336, 0.00411792378872633, -0.03927476704120636 ]
<p>In the usual covariant approach to the development of surface charges of an asymptotic symmetry group, one works with the linearized theory as this ensures that the charges are integrable.</p> <p>I also read </p> <blockquote> <p>In the full interacting theory with prescribed asymptotics, the expressions are one-forms on solution space indexed by asymptotic symmetries and one has to face the question whether these one-forms are integrable, i.e. whether one can construct suitable "Hamiltonians" for them.</p> </blockquote> <p>What is the meaning of integrable here? </p>
g7442
[ 0.03534174710512161, 0.017869295552372932, -0.02917673997581005, -0.019528264179825783, 0.06619278341531754, -0.003530228743329644, 0.067349374294281, -0.018667250871658325, 0.01743602380156517, -0.030035467818379402, -0.024568211287260056, -0.03494032099843025, -0.0047321016900241375, 0.05616564676165581, -0.019348351284861565, 0.011062754318118095, 0.07462193816900253, 0.03327417001128197, 0.012737145647406578, -0.02497035823762417, -0.026993129402399063, -0.03081999532878399, 0.02055034227669239, 0.021010911092162132, 0.016764964908361435, -0.026175692677497864, 0.043954893946647644, -0.007959212176501751, -0.005764197092503309, 0.013608777895569801, 0.017604036256670952, 0.053463272750377655, 0.02380330115556717, -0.03208416700363159, -0.029550207778811455, -0.04726428911089897, 0.05340857431292534, 0.01689748838543892, 0.039043501019477844, -0.026169855147600174, 0.06599879264831543, -0.035316966474056244, 0.018511205911636353, 0.009897612035274506, -0.025313066318631172, -0.011089619249105453, -0.022565115243196487, 0.05640309676527977, 0.02309655398130417, 0.010436901822686195, 0.09769531339406967, 0.04692479968070984, 0.0658653974533081, -0.043916113674640656, 0.015156523324549198, 0.01966410130262375, 0.03569871932268143, -0.01973387412726879, -0.019025884568691254, 0.05214942246675491, 0.015605926513671875, 0.02760915271937847, -0.00994899682700634, 0.04885369911789894, 0.09776619076728821, 0.0307723768055439, -0.042438119649887085, -0.030155517160892487, 0.034906864166259766, 0.0023078962694853544, 0.050769414752721786, -0.060411326587200165, 0.07307994365692139, -0.005783800967037678, -0.020734772086143494, 0.02167460322380066, 0.02059655264019966, -0.06086353585124016, 0.012022756040096283, -0.0016534115420654416, -0.02679409645497799, -0.07763060927391052, -0.018717287108302116, -0.03150869533419609, 0.07661060243844986, -0.054087139666080475, 0.03249134495854378, -0.035732366144657135, -0.024102751165628433, -0.010882530361413956, 0.006889731157571077, 0.021066788583993912, -0.0497196763753891, -0.013340665958821774, 0.023336850106716156, 0.018946994096040726, 0.006058807484805584, -0.004343632608652115, -0.06939329206943512, 0.002366148866713047, -0.061471134424209595, 0.07149257510900497, 0.030907142907381058, 0.005292373709380627, 0.043664734810590744, 0.0039163194596767426, -0.018785955384373665, -0.06098281592130661, -0.01766667142510414, -0.03377941623330116, -0.007922791875898838, 0.0007910946733318269, -0.035910964012145996, 0.029432762414216995, -0.017941828817129135, -0.004655205179005861, -0.0018022269941866398, -0.05849621817469597, 0.00928494706749916, -0.00006635108729824424, 0.018270136788487434, -0.00904543325304985, 0.030370328575372696, 0.025767577812075615, 0.06117837876081467, 0.04783552139997482, 0.00003257488788221963, -0.02551877498626709, 0.037558916956186295, -0.022961024194955826, -0.04630712419748306, 0.0481470488011837, -0.009917574003338814, -0.017800265923142433, 0.013714898377656937, 0.040712252259254456, -0.0010762898018583655, -0.017444182187318802, 0.039873357862234116, -0.018891073763370514, -0.015162240713834763, -0.032158464193344116, -0.03133785352110863, 0.04145524278283119, 0.022447798401117325, -0.0057992818765342236, 0.02801891788840294, -0.056498024612665176, 0.014213821850717068, 0.004620715044438839, -0.003898072987794876, 0.08584364503622055, 0.022770969197154045, -0.037828538566827774, 0.02448931336402893, 0.018888982012867928, 0.007045840844511986, -0.025633785873651505, 0.0811932384967804, -0.013416578061878681, 0.08201488107442856, -0.011754530481994152, -0.015359294600784779, 0.013023927807807922, -0.05501145124435425, -0.02502838708460331, 0.004079548642039299, -0.07127115875482559, -0.007595105562359095, -0.03155592083930969, -0.008015073835849762, 0.004435711540281773, -0.02728806808590889, 0.060830939561128616, 0.06724990904331207, 0.038594115525484085, -0.03742722049355507, -0.03729555383324623, 0.00974372960627079, -0.020718682557344437, -0.04113828390836716, -0.04581471532583237, 0.018512815237045288, 0.02534431591629982, 0.013581808656454086, 0.027930526062846184, -0.008928930386900902, 0.012955548241734505, -0.050534967333078384, 0.004290455486625433, 0.008184267207980156, 0.0420069545507431, -0.0037942607887089252, 0.09204144775867462, -0.0002714314905460924, 0.052303433418273926, 0.07809015363454819, -0.05351419374346733, -0.07891211658716202, -0.06345785409212112, -0.0030928717460483313, 0.05422765016555786, -0.023107372224330902, -0.029289914295077324, 0.019940072670578957, 0.003998125437647104, -0.010145013220608234, -0.032426584511995316, 0.02684146724641323, 0.012631201185286045, 0.04305198788642883, -0.06802701950073242, 0.0037931837141513824, 0.049804750829935074, -0.005493479780852795, -0.040967635810375214, 0.022541608661413193, -0.009795893914997578, -0.018236806616187096, -0.006008961237967014, 0.007141273468732834, -0.02519947476685047, -0.011254891753196716, 0.05886460840702057, 0.02379567362368107, -0.010910333134233952, -0.006364226806908846, 0.029633106663823128, -0.0021732968743890524, -0.02548014000058174, -0.04417648911476135, -0.028464725241065025, -0.019955087453126907, -0.03408146649599075, -0.039775606244802475, 0.061131466180086136, -0.07014888525009155, -0.048495858907699585, 0.021797509863972664, 0.03744596615433693, 0.002736837137490511, -0.0027659835759550333, 0.014536608941853046, 0.004120622295886278, 0.003395990002900362, 0.030097050592303276, 0.034972865134477615, 0.03535720333456993, -0.05693970248103142, 0.05224733054637909, 0.013887394219636917, 0.01383602898567915, -0.018359318375587463, -0.08370091021060944, 0.01937422715127468, -0.02724909409880638, 0.029155520722270012, 0.017270412296056747, 0.02090390771627426, -0.06984953582286835, 0.02486344985663891, -0.025872301310300827, -0.020055407658219337, -0.025979654863476753, -0.041843853890895844, -0.017271772027015686, 0.03900953754782677, 0.011286932043731213, 0.05566887930035591, -0.010931522585451603, -0.015214713290333748, 0.05834805965423584, 0.026989437639713287, 0.03910304233431816, -0.008160339668393135, -0.002661739243194461, -0.06965719908475876, -0.03566397354006767, 0.02240011841058731, -0.043999962508678436, -0.03249621391296387, -0.006363737862557173, -0.024159129709005356, -0.049376197159290314, 0.016403747722506523, -0.018832333385944366, 0.05882764607667923, -0.0043207695707678795, 0.015874305739998817, 0.04101022332906723, -0.04924459755420685, -0.03712645545601845, 0.027454707771539688, 0.009576371870934963, 0.002008922630921006, 0.005200851708650589, 0.008834966458380222, -0.036458298563957214, -0.04897042736411095, 0.07960540056228638, 0.006508163176476955, -0.0056455908343195915, 0.0009196471655741334, -0.030809123069047928, 0.05393833667039871, 0.027378955855965614, -0.05139143019914627, -0.017078246921300888, 0.016728723421692848, -0.04989239573478699, -0.07110947370529175, 0.04966152086853981, 0.005789629649370909, -0.0387120358645916, -0.040826573967933655, -0.013192251324653625, 0.012757791206240654, 0.016909165307879448, -0.0011626299237832427, -0.07533344626426697, -0.02709195949137211, 0.05717146024107933, 0.07434843480587006, 0.03578709810972214, -0.01149138156324625, -0.011023134924471378, -0.06238439306616783, -0.039937786757946014, 0.02579212747514248, -0.03943226858973503, -0.0011515324003994465, -0.00933668203651905, 0.09122976660728455, -0.01692510023713112, -0.02454826608300209, -0.03846205398440361, -0.042737334966659546, 0.028610283508896828, 0.006713826674968004, 0.038952555507421494, -0.003880901262164116, -0.06715252250432968, -0.01806548982858658, 0.020394109189510345, -0.01970210112631321, -0.04452360048890114, -0.07722149789333344, -0.01534454058855772, -0.08011696487665176, 0.028063341975212097, -0.022248707711696625, 0.03140712529420853, -0.009574420750141144, -0.026064353063702583, -0.023279396817088127, 0.020285295322537422, 0.052950382232666016, 0.03210495412349701, -0.07975342869758606, 0.009573656134307384, -0.012196896597743034, 0.006045951973646879, -0.004726444836705923, 0.06998778879642487, 0.0010520946234464645, 0.048318617045879364, -0.0373004712164402, 0.023559117689728737, -0.026995548978447914, -0.012621096335351467, 0.01748252473771572, -0.021905284374952316, 0.0563364177942276, 0.005166086833924055, 0.02662748657166958, 0.004809911362826824, -0.05152348056435585, -0.011190390214323997, -0.006106857676059008, -0.06968763470649719, 0.012303072959184647, -0.02952117659151554, 0.03142481669783592, 0.011031550355255604, 0.028106804937124252, 0.05619711056351662, -0.03454629331827164, 0.02822939120233059, -0.009447875432670116, -0.011701822280883789, 0.010506236925721169, -0.031888384371995926, 0.03845876082777977, -0.0003661664086394012, 0.03103462979197502, -0.04348515719175339, 0.013357155956327915, 0.017369963228702545, 0.03484949469566345, 0.0023116653319448233, -0.0009516449645161629, -0.04417966306209564, -0.009877502918243408, -0.01359747163951397, 0.06342076510190964, 0.032364338636398315, 0.0395844466984272, -0.02524450607597828, -0.017332816496491432, -0.06842409819364548, -0.023343365639448166, -0.018541766330599785, 0.02259092777967453, -0.03157172352075577, -0.000894107564818114, 0.01339801773428917, 0.011366644874215126, -0.06922391057014465, 0.0229546707123518, 0.00607324531301856, 0.005324225872755051, 0.04563179612159729, 0.022166267037391663, 0.01546196173876524, 0.015094638802111149, -0.013226417824625969, 0.04526228830218315, -0.011697857640683651, -0.02868318371474743, -0.03712697699666023, -0.004595076199620962, 0.05411418527364731, -0.034798551350831985, -0.010994171723723412, -0.10780934989452362, -0.004084861371666193, -0.010674103163182735, 0.01576017215847969, -0.002595911268144846, 0.03197344020009041, 0.05913098156452179, 0.03197474032640457, -0.0019984026439487934, -0.004046950954943895, 0.010969442315399647, 0.056987714022397995, 0.010953105054795742, -0.037091318517923355, 0.016618438065052032, -0.04985085129737854, -0.06032387167215347, 0.031665604561567307, 0.01680883578956127, -0.023336445912718773, 0.01568426750600338, -0.046950966119766235, -0.018069937825202942, 0.044668179005384445, 0.030826931819319725, 0.04456128180027008, 0.020385248586535454, -0.037869665771722794, -0.014528647065162659, -0.052607081830501556, 0.007959007285535336, -0.06552351266145706, -0.008343751542270184, -0.010121691040694714, -0.04487394168972969, -0.05773580074310303, 0.05313323438167572, 0.012008928693830967, 0.01670725829899311, -0.0240611769258976, 0.015914544463157654, -0.02126946486532688, 0.06197090446949005, -0.003406669246032834, -0.024738585576415062, 0.029478471726179123, -0.065822072327137, -0.007599576376378536, -0.0016412014374509454, 0.01791314221918583, -0.02442927472293377, 0.021307358518242836, 0.030078750103712082, 0.010520496405661106, -0.03718594089150429, 0.011987630277872086, 0.023775285109877586, 0.013268845155835152, 0.024353837594389915, 0.09275760501623154, -0.009915492497384548, 0.08999332040548325, -0.022033439949154854, -0.028164269402623177, 0.014497569762170315, -0.03410693630576134, -0.019162101671099663, -0.02769162505865097, 0.00040306535083800554, -0.006338220089673996, 0.01570122316479683, 0.07549966126680374, 0.03156881406903267, -0.01949930563569069, 0.019473055377602577, -0.019782647490501404, -0.0038398043252527714, 0.009148229844868183, 0.038673486560583115, 0.01622752845287323, 0.006816720589995384, 0.06114688143134117, -0.08507368713617325, 0.05736107379198074, -0.012447868473827839, -0.004163787700235844, 0.04271676391363144, -0.02080121636390686, -0.036068327724933624, -0.04241707921028137, 0.017417585477232933, 0.0367354154586792, -0.009358438663184643, -0.0816439539194107, 0.0405840203166008, 0.0374317467212677, 0.0123123275116086, 0.035311102867126465, -0.005282196216285229, -0.06448481976985931, 0.01757819764316082, -0.05851021781563759, -0.013080335222184658, 0.04366736486554146, 0.03783436119556427, 0.038551658391952515, -0.046338003128767014, -0.008646835573017597, -0.0060248044319450855, 0.029074998572468758, 0.03819149732589722, 0.014437904581427574, -0.05948984622955322, 0.046230047941207886, -0.010170618072152138, -0.04219021275639534, -0.03895760700106621, -0.03867577016353607, -0.02760479599237442, -0.02847418189048767, -0.008078978396952152, 0.002010742435231805, -0.0022761505097150803, -0.00966267753392458, 0.006164239719510078, 0.02933541312813759, 0.027529599145054817, -0.03243183344602585, -0.007728854194283485, -0.045899633318185806, -0.020827386528253555, -0.029970962554216385, 0.014272664673626423, -0.060704655945301056, 0.029667947441339493, -0.01827262155711651, -0.00023349805269390345, 0.01597720757126808, 0.05762484669685364, -0.03246741741895676, -0.026956258341670036, -0.03159577399492264, -0.0034148201812058687, -0.053715694695711136, -0.022537393495440483, 0.01307478453963995, -0.018299013376235962, -0.04546554014086723, 0.018187055364251137, -0.033798858523368835, 0.035421572625637054, 0.013939689844846725, -0.041889533400535583, -0.06793877482414246, 0.01641622558236122, 0.013450869359076023, -0.028368698433041573, 0.027048464864492416, 0.0035526584833860397, 0.026011409237980843, 0.017733728513121605, -0.0018183267675340176, 0.015313167124986649, 0.046971503645181656, -0.027391111478209496, -0.03274625167250633, -0.025539573282003403, -0.006748658139258623, 0.07465706020593643, 0.027379734441637993, 0.036630187183618546, 0.041563551872968674, -0.027077076956629753, -0.03189122676849365, -0.003910352475941181, 0.04307841509580612, -0.027892066165804863, 0.0076515269465744495, -0.011387242935597897, 0.005712759681046009, 0.04927099868655205, -0.013157104142010212, 0.0006485785124823451, -0.014621643349528313, 0.0029684840701520443, 0.012161454185843468, 0.04622212052345276, 0.01818881370127201, -0.016427161172032356, -0.011992350220680237, -0.005879531614482403, -0.006880759261548519, 0.003942213021218777, -0.046766772866249084, 0.017565468326210976, 0.027296433225274086, -0.01817508041858673, -0.005984897259622812, 0.01531231589615345, 0.00025257281959056854, 0.02051582932472229, 0.046154145151376724, -0.0056837499141693115, -0.010300753638148308, 0.03336765989661217, 0.01919330470263958, -0.03267033025622368, 0.07164368033409119, 0.019430208951234818, 0.05691874772310257, -0.023136518895626068, -0.009914309717714787, 0.017589915543794632, -0.006558331660926342, -0.06087105721235275, -0.04363511875271797, 0.04974837973713875, -0.020506709814071655, -0.045611001551151276, 0.011132840067148209, 0.009514081291854382, -0.07364055514335632, 0.027431312948465347, 0.005679109133780003, -0.015593083575367928, 0.017312578856945038, -0.054895732551813126, 0.025641920045018196, -0.025914395228028297, -0.055006641894578934, 0.012331881560385227, 0.017063243314623833, 0.01770462840795517, 0.003387292381376028, 0.034371450543403625, -0.015660585835576057, -0.00867425836622715, -0.03236725926399231, 0.02336299605667591, 0.026452260091900826, 0.017658567056059837, -0.014193672686815262, 0.00508120795711875, 0.04198654741048813, -0.009245096705853939, -0.022653572261333466, -0.024985039606690407, 0.019732676446437836, 0.03672134876251221, 0.06186559796333313, 0.0039498889818787575, -0.035360511392354965, -0.030506180599331856, 0.017117440700531006, -0.08504600077867508, 0.04476704075932503, 0.06191490590572357, -0.040648188441991806, -0.032622888684272766, 0.05188845470547676, -0.055206235498189926, 0.012270675972104073, 0.022326616570353508, 0.07543743401765823, -0.029085388407111168, 0.009678233414888382, -0.012650399468839169, -0.03322179242968559, -0.02937295287847519, -0.03924831002950668, 0.058113887906074524, -0.011444886215031147, -0.0010221011471003294, -0.021177534013986588, -0.028138678520917892, -0.026461215689778328, -0.11021101474761963, 0.06223133206367493, 0.05808413028717041, 0.008243182674050331, 0.056139763444662094, 0.03417586535215378, -0.026332976296544075, -0.0013506204122677445, 0.011950122192502022, 0.015089902095496655, 0.008962729945778847, -0.01482957974076271, 0.013741699978709221, -0.06613684445619583, -0.011391251347959042, -0.042044930160045624, 0.028283599764108658, 0.029056960716843605, 0.043874554336071014, 0.0286633912473917, -0.08869487792253494, -0.0011207526549696922, -0.022719325497746468, 0.05758845433592796, -0.043560098856687546, 0.024906190112233162, 0.023652251809835434, -0.08439859747886658, -0.007557443808764219, -0.03332015499472618, 0.0048256427980959415, -0.10094545036554337, 0.0482126846909523, -0.03804320469498634, -0.011334003880620003, 0.059530001133680344, -0.013033515773713589, -0.027034925296902657, 0.015790186822414398, 0.027914974838495255, 0.03900527209043503, 0.03463652729988098, -0.005225675646215677, 0.03923815116286278, 0.06590070575475693, -0.006114820949733257, -0.03055444359779358, 0.002275286242365837, 0.04919959232211113, 0.026042092591524124, 0.0023175785318017006, 0.0031886249780654907, -0.0661996528506279, 0.03606746345758438, -0.047079898416996, -0.07059168815612793, -0.00031720404513180256, -0.03163144364953041 ]
<p>This question is motivated by <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/71947/does-a-charged-particle-revolving-around-another-charged-particle-radiate-energy">similar one.</a> If an accelerated point charge $q$ radiates with power $W$ then I assume the same particle with charge $-q$ will radiate with the same rate $W$. Now what if we make a dipole with these two charges and accelerate it with the same acceleration? What will be the radiation power? </p>
g7443
[ 0.03696592524647713, 0.03348707780241966, 0.018454644829034805, 0.03594815731048584, 0.04641573503613472, -0.019073793664574623, -0.03029807098209858, -0.026609499007463455, -0.027272872626781464, -0.01666339300572872, 0.02175794541835785, 0.10866732895374298, -0.006932160351425409, -0.03226453810930252, 0.008945303969085217, -0.00888853520154953, 0.038975946605205536, -0.02623905800282955, -0.002369810128584504, 0.04566164314746857, 0.0018679526401683688, -0.03774852678179741, -0.02130196988582611, -0.050156719982624054, -0.027310848236083984, 0.004313367884606123, -0.045601680874824524, -0.03835389018058777, -0.047780800610780716, -0.053760357201099396, 0.06398717314004898, -0.03438881039619446, 0.03758055716753006, 0.011419489979743958, 0.01200846116989851, -0.06584468483924866, 0.022706469520926476, -0.01721009984612465, -0.024277901276946068, -0.0018106581410393119, 0.008465939201414585, 0.008948405273258686, 0.04009043425321579, 0.007951305247843266, 0.039180938154459, -0.04395417869091034, 0.03392398729920387, 0.04154803231358528, -0.01012510247528553, 0.030671680346131325, -0.03936992213129997, -0.003250421956181526, 0.00937795452773571, -0.042949460446834564, 0.026091188192367554, 0.037706535309553146, 0.01220585498958826, -0.0587092861533165, 0.052560366690158844, 0.05056820809841156, -0.06983339041471481, 0.021577296778559685, 0.0290488563477993, 0.008631513454020023, 0.029961606487631798, -0.03413602337241173, 0.020607737824320793, -0.003039491595700383, -0.006090386305004358, -0.02384232170879841, 0.021482117474079132, -0.030713384971022606, -0.052252572029829025, -0.04513166472315788, 0.05793696641921997, -0.008158821612596512, 0.02273399569094181, -0.02331048622727394, -0.006040673237293959, 0.03492027893662453, -0.05252078175544739, -0.016126561909914017, 0.01930244080722332, 0.008388152346014977, 0.04589390754699707, -0.012958893552422523, 0.0035110448952764273, 0.034195754677057266, -0.03554503247141838, -0.025558792054653168, 0.02664768695831299, -0.016477225348353386, 0.014909920282661915, -0.0017567046452313662, -0.023588428273797035, -0.06043527275323868, 0.038832586258649826, 0.03488216921687126, -0.024677414447069168, -0.012554648332297802, -0.017422260716557503, 0.03099648840725422, 0.04103963077068329, 0.06073983386158943, 0.05331840738654137, -0.0369773730635643, -0.0140371760353446, -0.053423188626766205, -0.0011531627969816327, 0.024981267750263214, -0.003917534835636616, -0.09129772335290909, 0.016312677413225174, -0.03797869384288788, -0.060692694038152695, -0.05582943931221962, 0.08064169436693192, -0.021295685321092606, 0.004950824659317732, 0.09890848398208618, 0.023258307948708534, 0.01239707414060831, -0.03704461082816124, 0.055527009069919586, -0.012316158041357994, 0.006090340204536915, 0.03785216063261032, 0.006589400116354227, 0.01477099023759365, 0.017682263627648354, 0.009068897925317287, -0.011786326766014099, 0.023162387311458588, 0.06371787190437317, -0.015954261645674706, 0.01461139414459467, -0.00213157432153821, 0.013847408816218376, 0.0018635832238942385, -0.00865985732525587, -0.0033837142400443554, -0.039129339158535004, 0.04560134559869766, 0.00956067442893982, -0.047435302287340164, 0.03819628804922104, -0.038914915174245834, -0.04960922524333, 0.04692801833152771, 0.07055513560771942, 0.0030484525486826897, 0.05091983824968338, 0.011513172648847103, -0.01580606773495674, 0.05562853440642357, 0.012827527709305286, -0.0005589515203610063, 0.009941079653799534, -0.0028360318392515182, 0.010767646133899689, 0.053717151284217834, -0.003996707499027252, 0.0031526810489594936, -0.013927053660154343, 0.004115451592952013, -0.044404271990060806, 0.0652938038110733, -0.04237229377031326, -0.028482677415013313, -0.0025172473397105932, 0.007639260496944189, -0.025143086910247803, 0.01680569350719452, -0.032416339963674545, -0.01834000274538994, 0.010610386729240417, -0.045379359275102615, -0.009439230896532536, -0.009797327220439911, 0.030250607058405876, -0.04302949085831642, -0.009327592328190804, -0.01970154605805874, -0.010016889311373234, 0.006008163094520569, 0.00905130710452795, -0.04655618593096733, -0.0024493655655533075, -0.012013382278382778, -0.009728326462209225, -0.002027816604822874, -0.06670397520065308, -0.010343064554035664, 0.05266055464744568, -0.044128671288490295, 0.011780238710343838, 0.020921658724546432, -0.005036347080022097, 0.04515755921602249, -0.011936996132135391, 0.010856637731194496, 0.05036250129342079, 0.03029542788863182, -0.017525581642985344, 0.06331943720579147, 0.027808744460344315, -0.00873581599444151, -0.02433398738503456, 0.06188293546438217, 0.028568793088197708, 0.06510525196790695, 0.021962817758321762, -0.004327671602368355, 0.055810194462537766, -0.031391024589538574, -0.001511373557150364, -0.042030829936265945, 0.05880032479763031, -0.02055647224187851, -0.013682562857866287, -0.06572821736335754, 0.0011244197376072407, 0.036292754113674164, -0.03466009721159935, -0.03196500241756439, -0.03225357457995415, -0.05763877555727959, -0.027621030807495117, 0.013212117366492748, 0.034555453807115555, -0.028174540027976036, 0.004138016141951084, -0.039916470646858215, -0.041232749819755554, 0.06661199778318405, -0.015988484025001526, -0.055281415581703186, 0.059350453317165375, 0.024013010784983635, -0.037075504660606384, -0.03918173536658287, 0.023492665961384773, 0.014187530614435673, 0.01730266399681568, 0.017763398587703705, 0.0022006204817444086, 0.055252037942409515, -0.015363295562565327, -0.01652601547539234, 0.009443862363696098, 0.043465010821819305, -0.0058721513487398624, 0.022262752056121826, 0.04168877750635147, -0.027003897354006767, -0.011899532750248909, -0.033981241285800934, 0.0382530614733696, -0.039829008281230927, -0.035805270075798035, 0.059286151081323624, 0.04224438592791557, -0.002246932126581669, -0.03342430293560028, -0.01988389901816845, 0.04095705598592758, 0.019468247890472412, 0.0279658455401659, 0.01973542757332325, -0.002272431505843997, -0.018806299194693565, 0.10523654520511627, 0.013588299974799156, 0.02861350029706955, -0.03492698073387146, -0.007169773802161217, 0.02545982226729393, -0.08121062815189362, 0.004534428007900715, -0.038503386080265045, -0.00141322601120919, -0.0204416923224926, -0.02952093817293644, 0.02131219580769539, 0.0014052323531359434, -0.07304771989583969, -0.015686996281147003, 0.02386319264769554, -0.041546985507011414, -0.020868372172117233, -0.05238325521349907, 0.03741147369146347, 0.12292366474866867, -0.02788436785340309, 0.0373259000480175, 0.03226581960916519, 0.0697745531797409, 0.020122596994042397, 0.0020538894459605217, 0.05226627737283707, 0.012494158931076527, -0.07688291370868683, -0.062188465148210526, 0.04029558226466179, 0.05431312695145607, 0.05346418544650078, -0.07450070232152939, -0.07012385129928589, 0.016476888209581375, 0.034925948828458786, -0.027633817866444588, 0.040344368666410446, -0.04041846841573715, 0.025306381285190582, 0.0545099675655365, -0.0758632943034172, -0.00014627663767896593, -0.025271840393543243, 0.022628547623753548, 0.01967347413301468, -0.03935111686587334, 0.0010969589930027723, 0.03762466832995415, -0.009065900929272175, -0.018374424427747726, 0.09202158451080322, -0.028487185016274452, 0.025663917884230614, -0.03488592803478241, -0.0354691781103611, -0.01033500861376524, 0.018807271495461464, -0.013182328082621098, 0.001248437911272049, 0.02482202835381031, -0.05234064161777496, 0.006103102583438158, 0.014846548438072205, 0.02867819555103779, 0.03251614794135094, 0.012715611606836319, 0.005167180206626654, -0.03706483915448189, 0.007186301052570343, 0.0011867729481309652, 0.002911582589149475, 0.05734151601791382, 0.0015645428793504834, -0.003682173555716872, 0.017762236297130585, 0.026357218623161316, -0.027201339602470398, 0.030841322615742683, 0.010354277677834034, -0.0449654757976532, -0.010864831507205963, 0.009153271093964577, -0.000529155193362385, -0.007764838170260191, -0.0341721847653389, 0.017413530498743057, -0.04032009467482567, 0.04832896217703819, -0.039993345737457275, -0.014061122201383114, 0.0023489431478083134, -0.0461353175342083, -0.01673727296292782, -0.03869831562042236, -0.017662255093455315, -0.014470080845057964, -0.026130760088562965, -0.011531751602888107, -0.06244514510035515, 0.032020051032304764, -0.006606674753129482, -0.002387747634202242, -0.02196207270026207, -0.07001154869794846, 0.01637420803308487, -0.0044355737045407295, 0.04883263632655144, -0.004395810421556234, -0.007307449821382761, -0.026908935979008675, 0.059934746474027634, -0.056522343307733536, -0.01856296695768833, 0.031031940132379532, -0.0712084025144577, 0.02285432629287243, -0.030599400401115417, -0.007736972998827696, -0.029398571699857712, 0.04399039223790169, -0.05884639918804169, 0.024283457547426224, -0.06335294246673584, 0.027081165462732315, 0.025291118770837784, 0.004401409067213535, 0.0488319918513298, 0.03563942760229111, -0.05681001767516136, 0.035684071481227875, -0.0571860745549202, 0.036450374871492386, -0.001143458066508174, -0.04948636516928673, 0.007293320260941982, -0.0004111681191716343, -0.019018549472093582, 0.02326313406229019, -0.03547670319676399, -0.032133474946022034, -0.00409742770716548, 0.0012050573714077473, -0.02235402725636959, -0.02967172861099243, 0.03642149269580841, -0.00708633242174983, 0.018141835927963257, 0.047316864132881165, -0.01913195289671421, -0.0010185636347159743, 0.01691306382417679, 0.0684543028473854, -0.014441361650824547, -0.03214843571186066, -0.03170233964920044, 0.023437228053808212, 0.01282186433672905, 0.0008676990400999784, -0.03922031819820404, 0.00739981047809124, -0.024231113493442535, -0.027833836153149605, 0.039491914212703705, 0.05569345876574516, 0.03286207839846611, 0.041569214314222336, -0.0031548473052680492, 0.0973803699016571, -0.034649692475795746, 0.024666909128427505, 0.09468495100736618, -0.04931696876883507, -0.0016778417630121112, 0.013423770666122437, -0.01717747375369072, -0.011789584532380104, -0.0065278057008981705, -0.08721645921468735, -0.0652129203081131, 0.031833961606025696, -0.004948881920427084, -0.029747532680630684, -0.007500824518501759, 0.04967130720615387, 0.05489777401089668, -0.0675089955329895, 0.043525923043489456, 0.06044745445251465, -0.04943379759788513, 0.023680170997977257, -0.044343311339616776, -0.05340143293142319, -0.044125210493803024, -0.09176664054393768, -0.03311905264854431, -0.018437862396240234, -0.003356106113642454, -0.002414341550320387, -0.02913053147494793, 0.014357076957821846, -0.04523911699652672, 0.0012147390516474843, 0.003812963142991066, 0.010857656598091125, 0.028789633885025978, -0.05456133931875229, -0.037952691316604614, -0.008991616778075695, -0.03746682405471802, -0.008104913868010044, 0.022442078217864037, -0.05331243947148323, 0.04764321818947792, 0.011976869776844978, -0.036869198083877563, -0.040425609797239304, -0.049719199538230896, 0.02874184213578701, -0.03690911456942558, 0.04025101661682129, 0.08137857913970947, -0.00888596661388874, 0.030651219189167023, -0.001233695074915886, 0.02570301666855812, 0.01287692878395319, -0.057252608239650726, -0.05350501462817192, 0.012651082128286362, 0.05148020759224892, 0.11021827906370163, 0.06734420359134674, -0.005347530357539654, 0.011290465481579304, 0.04604796692728996, -0.04397503286600113, 0.039354994893074036, 0.027122879400849342, 0.006595154758542776, 0.018565494567155838, 0.04381926730275154, -0.07884697616100311, 0.004103191662579775, 0.004699651151895523, -0.06320585310459137, 0.08662814646959305, 0.003267405554652214, -0.027383316308259964, 0.008572897873818874, 0.02966167777776718, 0.006344088818877935, -0.0228431336581707, 0.03504745662212372, 0.040419820696115494, 0.0347517728805542, 0.05226537585258484, -0.0031755189411342144, -0.02902933396399021, -0.02940751239657402, 0.026814162731170654, -0.025317758321762085, 0.030019935220479965, 0.012373998761177063, 0.018674304708838463, 0.025743335485458374, -0.028775909915566444, 0.012326393276453018, 0.08782777190208435, 0.04428308457136154, -0.025369036942720413, 0.009296288713812828, -0.08555786311626434, 0.0008580500143580139, -0.02048746682703495, -0.04976475238800049, -0.023636888712644577, -0.04332742840051651, 0.05360860377550125, 0.02036573924124241, 0.00864340178668499, 0.029244931414723396, 0.04685872420668602, -0.011529188603162766, 0.015469638630747795, -0.038311246782541275, -0.0020685186609625816, -0.05029480904340744, 0.04593444615602493, 0.006471370812505484, 0.043524011969566345, -0.029521137475967407, 0.03258616849780083, -0.08847517520189285, 0.026833614334464073, -0.017165357246994972, 0.029770122841000557, 0.03941773250699043, -0.02249099686741829, -0.032413728535175323, 0.029555583372712135, -0.03440910205245018, 0.00411645881831646, 0.04525450989603996, -0.011221421882510185, -0.019462112337350845, 0.04857618734240532, 0.02934018149971962, 0.030359359458088875, -0.008613601326942444, 0.028031043708324432, 0.017637072131037712, 0.0019068351248279214, 0.011467195115983486, 0.08146145939826965, 0.0012808004394173622, -0.07314199954271317, -0.06897725909948349, -0.025535082444548607, -0.03761345148086548, -0.07778733223676682, 0.0035522649995982647, 0.022287985309958458, -0.02319193258881569, -0.029083045199513435, 0.02307123690843582, 0.029489737004041672, -0.020230276510119438, -0.007762521505355835, -0.030855635181069374, 0.024054042994976044, -0.04019222408533096, 0.0024191616103053093, -0.04746866598725319, 0.018539579585194588, -0.045947447419166565, -0.050705451518297195, -0.010532520711421967, 0.01574530638754368, -0.002254816237837076, 0.01977343112230301, -0.001839416683651507, 0.012766280211508274, 0.011759018525481224, -0.00885562039911747, 0.013013814575970173, 0.034177690744400024, -0.03485197573900223, -0.04495858773589134, -0.04302528128027916, -0.008741610683500767, 0.02550974301993847, -0.014812028035521507, 0.06640632450580597, 0.04700322821736336, -0.020771561190485954, -0.01833292841911316, 0.015317349694669247, -0.015979306772351265, 0.04199954494833946, 0.052489448338747025, 0.033767469227313995, 0.008265870623290539, 0.026634128764271736, -0.04523533582687378, -0.013577505946159363, 0.007933879271149635, 0.03680523857474327, 0.01805112138390541, 0.009661847725510597, -0.045467205345630646, -0.02033453993499279, 0.025086767971515656, -0.059012893587350845, 0.02102150395512581, 0.013705296441912651, -0.006994594819843769, -0.07088743895292282, -0.04468837007880211, 0.011392350308597088, 0.01269840169698, -0.002235466381534934, 0.03589009866118431, 0.05333787575364113, 0.004061346873641014, -0.04639822244644165, 0.019088098779320717, -0.00024204165674746037, -0.007123986724764109, 0.004155617207288742, -0.003811559174209833, 0.005532308481633663, -0.0028048984240740538, -0.006925803143531084, -0.03411112353205681, 0.01328159961849451, -0.013578508049249649, 0.0015452075749635696, -0.03587230667471886, -0.01662098430097103, 0.02567431516945362, 0.0248186644166708, -0.04720683768391609, 0.009246286004781723, 0.023031145334243774, 0.019502414390444756, 0.015521885827183723, -0.0004664719454012811, 0.002872156910598278, 0.0017288671806454659, 0.011612472124397755, 0.02596529945731163, -0.053971439599990845, 0.011906895786523819, -0.023420263081789017, -0.06428022682666779, -0.03653373196721077, -0.013352833688259125, 0.07765278965234756, -0.011234177276492119, 0.009457272477447987, 0.041878752410411835, -0.012359607964754105, 0.0019535745959728956, -0.010537107475101948, 0.0339072123169899, -0.008453357964754105, 0.010456274263560772, 0.051546163856983185, -0.00019171638996340334, -0.018923424184322357, -0.010745496489107609, 0.022676343098282814, -0.03930889070034027, -0.02926107868552208, -0.012130946852266788, -0.0021884609013795853, -0.04430723190307617, 0.0381622277200222, 0.014056755229830742, 0.001219304627738893, -0.008967094123363495, -0.05196575075387955, 0.06472492963075638, 0.02208002656698227, -0.006959257181733847, -0.011522078886628151, 0.004161803517490625, -0.013365611433982849, -0.06862789392471313, 0.058512214571237564, -0.05042602866888046, -0.032192885875701904, 0.012289201840758324, -0.00887297373265028, 0.006458960473537445, -0.00664437236264348, 0.027378583326935768, -0.003985011018812656, 0.04849482327699661, -0.0035576755180954933, -0.009190243668854237, 0.012914460152387619, 0.009264979511499405, -0.005452134646475315, 0.018586330115795135, 0.006121877580881119, -0.0434584878385067, 0.007310079410672188, 0.031472351402044296, -0.023659462109208107, -0.006623309571295977, 0.021615130826830864, 0.0471896231174469, 0.07588118314743042, -0.0419817790389061, -0.02930602617561817, -0.009884759783744812, -0.08780498057603836, 0.023696623742580414, 0.09623075276613235, -0.04470304399728775, -0.051672764122486115, 0.056979939341545105, -0.023102955892682076, -0.028679020702838898, 0.00669892830774188, -0.007481736596673727, -0.05955403298139572, -0.06590739637613297, 0.043090954422950745, -0.028873084113001823, -0.06061170995235443, -0.005320052150636911 ]
<p>Well I imagine that there is a very fast rocket moving alongside the Earth and I know that people in the Earth regard the events on the rocket as happening more slowly as it is moving and time expands, and the same for people in the rocket as they could consider themselves at rest and the Earth moving so they would regard events in Earth as happening more slowly, my question arises in the moment they stop moving with respect to each other.</p> <p>Lets say there were two identical twins, one on the rocket and one on Earth, for the twin in the rocket he would experience as if he was getting older quicker than his brother on earth as he regards the events there as happening more slowly and the same for the other twin, at the moment they stop moving, which one would be older? If no one, how is this time difference compensated just by stoping abruptly. I mean one clearly experienced how was he getting older quicker than his relative moving sibling, if we kept this motion long enough one could get to old age while seeing his brother stay younger, what happens <em>after</em> we stop this motion?</p>
g249
[ 0.07318304479122162, -0.006311022210866213, 0.013350159861147404, -0.026253804564476013, -0.01795022003352642, 0.06394137442111969, 0.059792134910821915, 0.05007331818342209, -0.048158563673496246, -0.03111533634364605, -0.0025582790840417147, -0.02746332623064518, 0.014613829553127289, 0.03220679238438606, 0.05444473400712013, -0.04014477878808975, 0.08025101572275162, -0.059597447514534, -0.046109698712825775, 0.029242586344480515, 0.005220077931880951, 0.07998933643102646, -0.0506192184984684, 0.00682098651304841, -0.049314726144075394, -0.03296725079417229, -0.033241841942071915, -0.054084647446870804, -0.008519231341779232, 0.014330996200442314, 0.04050782695412636, -0.03372349962592125, 0.027224361896514893, -0.016606882214546204, 0.013891350477933884, -0.020171647891402245, 0.031121285632252693, 0.002444012789055705, 0.02807079255580902, -0.005122476257383823, 0.04719347879290581, -0.03830195963382721, -0.015414366498589516, -0.011968584731221199, 0.02055860310792923, -0.003963001072406769, -0.023605527356266975, -0.012246989645063877, 0.0754147320985794, -0.00982353463768959, -0.08148185908794403, 0.003705025417730212, -0.01855122670531273, 0.07948500663042068, 0.03798946365714073, 0.021617917343974113, 0.009418731555342674, 0.002177164191380143, 0.0501522459089756, 0.0023834742605686188, -0.026579612866044044, -0.016989456489682198, 0.020778950303792953, -0.005237006116658449, 0.06678411364555359, 0.025312522426247597, -0.023666908964514732, 0.003043484641239047, 0.10190711170434952, 0.009799142368137836, 0.020026370882987976, 0.002072145463898778, -0.09011323004961014, -0.005408682394772768, -0.04183878377079964, 0.04566952586174011, 0.01339674275368452, 0.009384597651660442, -0.008075484074652195, 0.025130122900009155, -0.032506562769412994, 0.07661351561546326, 0.014823692850768566, 0.003514784388244152, 0.035760119557380676, -0.014868280850350857, 0.010713327676057816, 0.021135909482836723, -0.025227509438991547, 0.017006248235702515, 0.03377772867679596, -0.047585178166627884, 0.029606375843286514, -0.012175152078270912, -0.06233630329370499, -0.012073401361703873, -0.011801877059042454, 0.05223218351602554, 0.015870999544858932, 0.012560088187456131, -0.04246591404080391, 0.004819988273084164, 0.009112905710935593, -0.011980761773884296, 0.0206272155046463, -0.0316820964217186, -0.007098978850990534, 0.0114276222884655, -0.040352173149585724, -0.04828740656375885, -0.01323453988879919, -0.10196668654680252, -0.007074630353599787, 0.009495407342910767, 0.03092016465961933, -0.026144735515117645, 0.004027463961392641, 0.011051300913095474, -0.040735796093940735, -0.005551521200686693, 0.011548146605491638, 0.03485802188515663, -0.06862527877092361, 0.061049360781908035, 0.017639223486185074, 0.016480324789881706, -0.02149795927107334, -0.008890027180314064, -0.030780574306845665, 0.046790678054094315, 0.009708966128528118, 0.0269167423248291, 0.057572141289711, 0.03280536085367203, -0.03463086858391762, -0.045260556042194366, -0.0032382879871875048, 0.012241117656230927, 0.04537878558039665, -0.014143531210720539, 0.0458696223795414, 0.020498262718319893, -0.006831263191998005, -0.011710427701473236, -0.0033717730548232794, 0.04028880223631859, 0.006953520234674215, 0.020538758486509323, 0.010385307483375072, -0.0027337013743817806, 0.006331810727715492, 0.07794533669948578, -0.0005067707970738411, -0.01068390253931284, 0.024856744334101677, 0.03701469674706459, 0.0018515310948714614, 0.04111900180578232, -0.014050455763936043, 0.013996458612382412, 0.012987417168915272, 0.0009804553119465709, 0.025278786197304726, 0.03393816947937012, -0.061774563044309616, 0.08014239370822906, 0.02338874340057373, -0.06542055308818817, -0.0022514674346894026, -0.04801547899842262, -0.04982312023639679, -0.009567614644765854, 0.026770275086164474, -0.0008746196399442852, 0.04859108850359917, 0.013784009963274002, 0.08705031871795654, -0.023423796519637108, -0.031161826103925705, 0.00003958879460697062, -0.08976202458143234, -0.026567798107862473, -0.057382453233003616, -0.024026954546570778, 0.018549837172031403, -0.0283292755484581, 0.0008337674662470818, 0.022214774042367935, -0.08229298144578934, -0.05246777832508087, -0.01976907067000866, -0.0668819397687912, 0.011546476744115353, 0.003793088486418128, -0.02312421053647995, -0.04054761677980423, 0.0077073960565030575, 0.0022202490363270044, -0.04658601060509682, 0.0025147106498479843, -0.016890913248062134, 0.009115767665207386, 0.04052962735295296, 0.01701301522552967, 0.015520247630774975, 0.014801062643527985, -0.03170011565089226, -0.0017464724369347095, 0.022869469597935677, -0.04994143173098564, 0.0614125058054924, 0.055253464728593826, -0.023505931720137596, -0.016146667301654816, -0.05091816186904907, 0.04743624106049538, 0.011913207359611988, 0.036217838525772095, -0.017998406663537025, -0.006913287565112114, 0.022511059418320656, -0.03345217928290367, 0.03451254963874817, 0.002931256080046296, 0.012391439639031887, -0.058339159935712814, 0.017275763675570488, -0.017517974600195885, 0.02988075092434883, 0.052136216312646866, -0.060714926570653915, 0.04085154831409454, 0.0019206926226615906, -0.007794903591275215, 0.015187755227088928, 0.04588919132947922, -0.01391172967851162, 0.04904276505112648, -0.008878634311258793, 0.017060723155736923, 0.00565342977643013, 0.013419917784631252, -0.05043649300932884, 0.027802275493741035, 0.016087181866168976, -0.0591091625392437, 0.06716915965080261, -0.028496986255049706, 0.00650204299017787, 0.027030421420931816, 0.0019737491384148598, -0.024821536615490913, -0.10147534310817719, -0.039497844874858856, 0.0269548911601305, -0.0026346626691520214, -0.04018084704875946, 0.06274554133415222, -0.06728760898113251, 0.023114383220672607, -0.05882129818201065, 0.007716977037489414, 0.047467660158872604, -0.025513242930173874, -0.028085356578230858, -0.014565277844667435, -0.005403697956353426, 0.0330226868391037, -0.020134247839450836, 0.0045258235186338425, -0.05167263001203537, 0.01566600799560547, -0.028753455728292465, 0.07230379432439804, -0.041547611355781555, 0.01012603472918272, 0.03358817845582962, -0.02816704288125038, 0.006215945817530155, 0.01440033596009016, -0.02674499712884426, 0.019887806847691536, -0.008560951799154282, 0.016282344236969948, 0.047373950481414795, -0.04785969480872154, 0.024697918444871902, 0.025655245408415794, -0.021985480561852455, 0.025823572650551796, -0.04251397028565407, 0.015624611638486385, 0.07369980961084366, 0.03251243382692337, -0.017777469009160995, 0.07044994086027145, -0.015274951234459877, -0.055290739983320236, -0.06891124695539474, -0.053017813712358475, 0.057227201759815216, -0.09425627440214157, 0.03437276557087898, 0.0675937607884407, 0.040023598819971085, -0.011081529781222343, -0.0431034117937088, -0.01927296631038189, -0.03683163598179817, -0.04363919794559479, 0.05773898586630821, -0.005434285383671522, -0.043127112090587616, 0.000206257333047688, -0.013515468686819077, -0.0071732718497514725, -0.019574090838432312, 0.029023820534348488, 0.040378835052251816, -0.003508011344820261, -0.022840846329927444, -0.053459443151950836, -0.007161624263972044, 0.0502278171479702, -0.024364836513996124, 0.021873682737350464, -0.038830772042274475, 0.005447110626846552, -0.018268214538693428, 0.008043455891311169, -0.082009457051754, 0.01585305482149124, 0.005830057896673679, -0.00843814853578806, -0.06998403370380402, 0.02761917933821678, -0.023185718804597855, 0.025623563677072525, 0.030048757791519165, 0.04839077219367027, 0.011364168487489223, 0.04703652486205101, -0.004184367135167122, -0.0009031978552229702, -0.0037515703588724136, 0.04083865508437157, 0.011014286428689957, 0.01613716408610344, -0.011156254447996616, 0.009683343581855297, 0.05554598569869995, -0.032321833074092865, 0.002618312370032072, -0.01839836686849594, -0.05308665335178375, 0.036509957164525986, 0.017990583553910255, -0.022649331018328667, -0.007714893668889999, -0.05804745480418205, -0.004530978389084339, 0.01920822635293007, -0.033959850668907166, 0.04438459500670433, -0.02476862259209156, -0.021744556725025177, -0.05011571943759918, 0.022019462659955025, 0.02942795306444168, -0.010331779718399048, 0.022547543048858643, 0.038014721125364304, -0.07771524041891098, -0.026470858603715897, 0.04461497440934181, -0.037404824048280716, 0.05898232012987137, -0.03791441395878792, 0.008189814165234566, -0.009054874069988728, 0.020541483536362648, 0.005843241233378649, -0.0005456602666527033, -0.022534143179655075, 0.03997650370001793, 0.026824720203876495, -0.009177987463772297, -0.044541288167238235, -0.027799531817436218, -0.03476978465914726, 0.09392835944890976, -0.036324240267276764, -0.033535949885845184, -0.00871317833662033, 0.04498656094074249, -0.003476281650364399, 0.00012440994032658637, -0.002384652616456151, -0.0023673218674957752, 0.003745735390111804, -0.03689471632242203, 0.045301396399736404, -0.029249047860503197, 0.03120885230600834, -0.04566299170255661, 0.05538621172308922, -0.006104201544076204, -0.03252553939819336, 0.024208731949329376, -0.0037043532356619835, -0.025036625564098358, 0.0194285549223423, -0.07224413007497787, -0.040227554738521576, 0.005347325932234526, -0.007640707306563854, 0.034035127609968185, 0.022224992513656616, 0.03722093626856804, 0.017965616658329964, 0.03981277346611023, 0.04042148217558861, -0.028368493542075157, 0.00831624586135149, 0.02909884601831436, 0.02423664554953575, 0.041953280568122864, 0.026357004418969154, 0.014209257438778877, 0.008386264555156231, 0.040919072926044464, 0.03726349025964737, -0.014556309208273888, 0.06168883666396141, -0.027879972010850906, 0.030248472467064857, 0.013269306160509586, 0.05226306617259979, 0.021661270409822464, 0.06006571650505066, 0.021770523861050606, 0.004216763190925121, 0.04063824564218521, 0.02713007666170597, -0.05374018847942352, 0.08411036431789398, -0.070517398416996, -0.06269686669111252, 0.020208796486258507, -0.02285122312605381, -0.06509191542863846, 0.07664622366428375, 0.0037350801285356283, -0.012719252146780491, 0.006323840003460646, -0.025936337187886238, -0.06603191047906876, -0.012571251019835472, 0.014259818941354752, 0.002593916142359376, -0.029588863253593445, -0.01309224497526884, 0.031355854123830795, -0.021234381943941116, -0.0181448832154274, -0.02894708141684532, -0.05569707229733467, -0.029721245169639587, 0.01127178966999054, 0.03521794453263283, -0.015143889002501965, -0.021366948261857033, -0.03286494314670563, 0.06027640774846077, -0.05449710786342621, -0.04136224091053009, 0.02727237530052662, -0.014531583525240421, 0.07137713581323624, -0.029973145574331284, -0.03562645986676216, 0.00977726187556982, 0.03666171431541443, -0.04396757483482361, 0.01814940571784973, -0.005696066189557314, -0.0064481147564947605, -0.04110299423336983, 0.06631133705377579, 0.00027299573412165046, 0.039469536393880844, -0.012710744515061378, -0.01987808384001255, 0.027469439432024956, -0.03536945581436157, -0.06082623079419136, -0.012331286445260048, 0.009818686172366142, -0.005172888282686472, 0.006158666685223579, -0.023042842745780945, 0.02643887884914875, -0.011424817144870758, -0.017729517072439194, -0.03116093948483467, 0.053267985582351685, 0.023621778935194016, -0.03368606045842171, -0.029058976098895073, 0.07049962133169174, -0.01643524132668972, 0.05795647203922272, -0.014094646088778973, -0.025610562413930893, -0.010074836201965809, -0.0027978583239018917, 0.01111107598990202, -0.016915859654545784, 0.021991930902004242, -0.04025239497423172, 0.01671362854540348, 0.024079512804746628, 0.020171314477920532, 0.03495333343744278, 0.07559330016374588, -0.03417016565799713, -0.05553518608212471, 0.036204755306243896, -0.02590787038207054, 0.07568036764860153, 0.009532060474157333, -0.02391921542584896, 0.012174435891211033, -0.037396080791950226, 0.006446478422731161, 0.0012953917030245066, 0.029855836182832718, -0.037617333233356476, 0.06247321888804436, -0.025974133983254433, -0.08249451220035553, -0.025338662788271904, 0.00019876786973327398, 0.08854356408119202, -0.04278931766748428, 0.0255043413490057, -0.06917861849069595, 0.015855686739087105, 0.0350516177713871, 0.02142118290066719, -0.07616234570741653, -0.053158633410930634, 0.0154109550639987, 0.0419170968234539, -0.007863716222345829, 0.08595991134643555, 0.031305644661188126, 0.018183104693889618, -0.013645447790622711, 0.013479475863277912, -0.003875765250995755, -0.00436709588393569, 0.02744792401790619, -0.05350411683320999, -0.022715451195836067, -0.025775766000151634, 0.01853286102414131, 0.002602496650069952, 0.00668191397562623, -0.04401896521449089, 0.05428371578454971, -0.005346390418708324, 0.030376004055142403, 0.023109009489417076, 0.009918060153722763, 0.0166850034147501, -0.021832311525940895, -0.0020395994652062654, -0.10365503281354904, 0.01565076783299446, -0.01832381822168827, -0.017867716029286385, 0.04235701262950897, 0.017427615821361542, -0.007539462298154831, 0.07613761723041534, -0.009057397954165936, -0.019739817827939987, 0.011866385117173195, 0.02817622199654579, 0.0012127412483096123, 0.007627884391695261, -0.06345519423484802, -0.009205309674143791, -0.049010127782821655, 0.023931754752993584, -0.03508938476443291, -0.020077936351299286, -0.03364001587033272, 0.0591435581445694, 0.008370419032871723, -0.05930604413151741, 0.0791010931134224, 0.0013262013671919703, 0.04134783521294594, 0.010908610187470913, 0.012196261435747147, -0.026118729263544083, 0.03142986074090004, -0.06582913547754288, 0.02821418084204197, 0.0000462596035504248, 0.01765328273177147, 0.03455806523561478, -0.008809671737253666, 0.049474455416202545, 0.011871470138430595, 0.008097711019217968, -0.0030327823478728533, 0.01213446632027626, 0.029070060700178146, -0.027997829020023346, -0.004329263232648373, -0.02145269326865673, -0.0158834345638752, 0.014838463626801968, -0.029299456626176834, 0.003985462710261345, -0.021478058770298958, 0.024538768455386162, 0.035909391939640045, -0.008770151995122433, -0.004861210938543081, 0.034242600202560425, 0.06645505130290985, 0.03536706417798996, -0.012198658660054207, 0.03594103828072548, -0.049442943185567856, -0.001639478956349194, 0.04202426224946976, 0.02503187023103237, 0.004572618752717972, 0.04206818714737892, -0.005127684213221073, -0.0357712097465992, 0.02208305522799492, -0.024810969829559326, -0.05706198513507843, -0.07233454287052155, -0.053075917065143585, 0.008483956567943096, -0.0010094948811456561, 0.040613990277051926, 0.01119996327906847, -0.0064714569598436356, -0.01843053475022316, 0.008562435396015644, 0.04835984855890274, -0.003715349128469825, -0.04717375710606575, 0.001339449780061841, -0.018293291330337524, 0.03280683979392052, -0.05612814053893089, 0.029383836314082146, 0.012020532973110676, -0.08221784979104996, 0.0016314011299982667, 0.0017935815267264843, -0.02897222898900509, -0.009223232045769691, 0.0379931814968586, 0.020757881924510002, -0.020390113815665245, -0.010314715094864368, 0.008071303367614746, -0.050563398748636246, -0.000247540941927582, 0.015300524421036243, -0.020605139434337616, -0.016358252614736557, 0.014942793175578117, 0.026479830965399742, -0.029226751998066902, 0.06769472360610962, -0.02128780633211136, -0.04051283746957779, -0.01587323285639286, -0.07036706805229187, -0.027354368939995766, 0.050326354801654816, -0.010213365778326988, 0.006499728187918663, 0.014636952430009842, -0.0207620058208704, -0.0012276439229026437, 0.012694304808974266, -0.023081490769982338, 0.002814430743455887, -0.02489290200173855, 0.018167728558182716, 0.02278800867497921, -0.017320608720183372, 0.02456394024193287, 0.0007847155211493373, -0.01662967912852764, -0.033934615552425385, -0.05324091389775276, 0.005135882645845413, -0.004938209895044565, 0.08099135011434555, 0.011093350127339363, -0.01910613663494587, 0.004329343792051077, -0.06094371899962425, -0.01929343305528164, -0.03483866900205612, 0.06505318731069565, 0.017850905656814575, 0.01251610554754734, -0.04174959659576416, 0.01366166677325964, -0.06614163517951965, -0.004651801660656929, 0.026175176724791527, -0.01527395099401474, -0.08226986229419708, -0.0008522130665369332, -0.019531795755028725, 0.0030650258995592594, 0.023389512673020363, 0.017057709395885468, 0.02261429838836193, -0.06036485731601715, 0.06771589815616608, 0.004620932973921299, -0.011073905974626541, -0.05304910987615585, 0.000040199582144850865, -0.059872597455978394, 0.0015428004553541541, -0.010640219785273075, 0.07424134761095047, -0.00510408217087388, 0.006925813853740692, 0.03843989968299866, 0.04495454579591751, 0.004042475484311581, -0.01858443394303322, 0.04381279647350311, -0.01887103170156479, -0.08059586584568024, 0.006744670681655407, 0.013471306301653385, 0.047179512679576874, -0.04765921086072922, -0.04332052171230316, -0.041960958391427994, -0.04768470674753189, -0.027327774092555046, 0.036749016493558884, -0.032137181609869, -0.07239492982625961, -0.03827838599681854, -0.017947472631931305, -0.019997894763946533, 0.02248144894838333 ]
<p>I'm trying to get Ward-Takahashi identities using the approach used in <a href="http://books.google.com.br/books?id=nnuW_kVJ500C&amp;pg=PA264&amp;lpg=PA264&amp;dq=%22leads%20to%20a%20differential%20equation%20for%20Z%22&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=vpxudGVM4Y&amp;sig=b9ByfCjLwU9oT9wMXIInGj7z8vk&amp;hl=pt-BR#v=onepage&amp;q=%22leads%20to%20a%20differential%20equation%20for%20Z%22&amp;f=false" rel="nofollow">Ryder's book (pages 263-266)</a>. I like that he starts from demanding gauge invariance of Z in a explicit way and them explores the consequences of that to functional generators of vertex functions. But the actual calculation is bugging me out. </p> <p>The author seems oblivious to the fact that the fermionic fields and sources ($\psi$ and $\eta$) are Grassmann variables and keeps commuting them out with no regard for my sanity. For instance, equation (7.102) has a term:</p> <p>$$i e (\bar{\eta}\psi-\bar{\psi}\eta) $$</p> <p>that promply becomes (exchanging the fields by ${1\over i}$ times the derivatives on the sources, acting on Z to the right):</p> <p>$$ e (\bar{\eta}{\delta \over \delta \bar{\eta} }-\eta{\delta \over \delta \eta }) $$</p> <p>In my opinion that should be:</p> <p>$$ e (\bar{\eta}{\delta \over \delta \bar{\eta} }+\eta{\delta \over \delta \eta }) $$</p> <p>This one has no consequences because he commutes them again right after. But when I try to calculate it being careful with the Grassmann variables, I can never get the right signs in (7.111). I'm specially troubled by the derivatives below (this is what I'm getting, but one of them should have a different sign in order to get the right WT identities):</p> <p>$${\delta \over \delta \bar{\psi}(x_1) } {\delta \over \delta \psi(y_1) } \left[{\delta \Gamma \over \delta \psi(x) }\psi(x)\right]_{\psi=\bar{\psi}=0}=-\delta^4(x-y_1){\delta^2 \Gamma \over \delta \bar{\psi}(x_1) \delta\psi(x) }$$</p> <p>$${\delta \over \delta \bar{\psi}(x_1) } {\delta \over \delta \psi(y_1) } \left[\bar{\psi}(x) {\delta \Gamma \over \delta \bar{\psi}(x) } \right]_{\psi=\bar{\psi}=0} =\\=-\delta^4(x-x_1){\delta^2 \Gamma \over \delta \psi(y_1) \delta\bar{\psi}(x) } = \delta^4(x-x_1){\delta^2 \Gamma \over \delta \bar{\psi}(x) \delta\psi(y_1) }$$</p> <p>Does anybody ever did this calculation in detail and has some pointers? Are there any other references that follow this same approach?</p> <p>EDIT: Just a shameless bump: I still looking for some light on this. Any reference on where this is done in detail would help.</p>
g7444
[ -0.0070366207510232925, -0.0156510379165411, -0.01939488761126995, -0.017704807221889496, 0.052843671292066574, -0.03759441524744034, 0.05938642844557762, 0.013298367150127888, -0.039563942700624466, 0.0049999733455479145, -0.02223476581275463, -0.02752903662621975, 0.03911617025732994, 0.0022626593708992004, -0.013703016564249992, 0.003630808787420392, 0.007862092927098274, 0.05180017650127411, 0.012254456989467144, -0.05337696895003319, -0.06288246810436249, 0.03427649289369583, 0.0029475647024810314, -0.022230252623558044, -0.01718474179506302, -0.061054788529872894, -0.015146825462579727, 0.017593374475836754, -0.04852506145834923, -0.01046790275722742, 0.036722637712955475, 0.05675043910741806, 0.06929247826337814, -0.036821551620960236, -0.060705460608005524, 0.06335501372814178, 0.10721726715564728, 0.05222338065505028, 0.03088759072124958, 0.02992781065404415, 0.0006789396284148097, -0.00782980676740408, 0.04484044387936592, 0.05732264742255211, -0.042720288038253784, 0.04738573357462883, 0.01316047552973032, 0.024071907624602318, -0.04559871181845665, -0.01328743901103735, -0.0044075497426092625, 0.028748759999871254, 0.05443450063467026, -0.023144084960222244, -0.027936989441514015, 0.03851677477359772, 0.04945051297545433, -0.03393666073679924, 0.029421526938676834, 0.04034177586436272, -0.02348335087299347, -0.049631517380476, -0.027734847739338875, 0.017042146995663643, 0.06752189248800278, -0.030864128842949867, -0.015301138162612915, -0.02508709579706192, -0.02390209399163723, -0.023053953424096107, 0.002611095318570733, -0.008279177360236645, 0.031714603304862976, 0.025985004380345345, -0.0052378796972334385, 0.05371471866965294, 0.013394935056567192, 0.005000736564397812, -0.011222452856600285, -0.04992292821407318, 0.029504088684916496, -0.01675911247730255, -0.002717869356274605, 0.027585608884692192, 0.10953731834888458, -0.026164932176470757, 0.009315991774201393, 0.019751863554120064, -0.011361404322087765, -0.02735932171344757, 0.011449967510998249, 0.012170256115496159, 0.023946721106767654, -0.04015408828854561, -0.0403011292219162, 0.031159913167357445, -0.020280420780181885, 0.023899152874946594, 0.032877109944820404, -0.03382079675793648, -0.013990134000778198, 0.06309378147125244, 0.04067457467317581, 0.008140867576003075, -0.03140281140804291, 0.003957679960876703, 0.03802960366010666, -0.012656833045184612, -0.010663283057510853, 0.00797118991613388, -0.05360662192106247, 0.03166471794247627, -0.01626535877585411, 0.007357543800026178, -0.05472468212246895, -0.020611323416233063, -0.026495635509490967, 0.0036895587109029293, -0.022601166740059853, 0.003336861962452531, -0.015508502721786499, -0.03597404435276985, 0.05942193418741226, -0.036277882754802704, -0.018240872770547867, -0.03951616212725639, -0.05423439294099808, 0.011936591006815434, 0.046166710555553436, -0.005025391932576895, 0.024499990046024323, -0.05821473151445389, -0.025227347388863564, 0.06652546674013138, -0.015066110529005527, 0.03685566782951355, -0.04906674847006798, 0.07667887210845947, -0.001319651142694056, -0.00510042579844594, -0.0018224853556603193, -0.046217501163482666, 0.00794291589409113, -0.025823112577199936, 0.0115400655195117, 0.02173086628317833, 0.0020632296800613403, -0.10730350762605667, 0.07152359932661057, -0.010479209013283253, 0.0554228238761425, 0.061085671186447144, -0.020469635725021362, 0.03234081715345383, 0.01440497487783432, -0.0037673974875360727, 0.015904953703284264, -0.057599056512117386, -0.010297837667167187, -0.034227848052978516, 0.018784133717417717, -0.027429912239313126, 0.007033586967736483, -0.0020356050226837397, 0.0389617383480072, -0.018014216795563698, 0.09002387523651123, -0.050658609718084335, -0.08902628719806671, -0.067157082259655, -0.041028667241334915, 0.011717922985553741, 0.03387576341629028, -0.029320452362298965, -0.0010867342352867126, 0.065274678170681, -0.04492730647325516, -0.034567397087812424, -0.011058593168854713, 0.008400405757129192, -0.0006009758799336851, -0.028795167803764343, 0.02045627124607563, -0.0529879629611969, 0.012378943152725697, -0.024029068648815155, -0.02001185342669487, -0.010181045159697533, -0.051002975553274155, -0.011135864071547985, -0.0000025993160761572653, 0.05855986103415489, 0.06368188560009003, 0.06592177599668503, 0.00481835100799799, 0.033192019909620285, 0.02485228143632412, -0.05466534197330475, -0.013363190926611423, 0.03269558399915695, -0.04112941026687622, 0.028596628457307816, 0.028610799461603165, 0.03043687902390957, 0.02810557745397091, 0.0674629658460617, 0.0011796691687777638, -0.010412698611617088, -0.016070503741502762, -0.05092396214604378, -0.024044184014201164, -0.07185564935207367, 0.031050415709614754, 0.028990628197789192, 0.01831766590476036, -0.04419628903269768, -0.034315187484025955, -0.032701727002859116, -0.028240283951163292, -0.019094472751021385, 0.029785793274641037, -0.05495896190404892, 0.04715387150645256, 0.04429080709815025, -0.06727086007595062, 0.05118737369775772, 0.00992506742477417, -0.011526674963533878, -0.014869283884763718, -0.018038161098957062, -0.02526872605085373, 0.005141883157193661, -0.04913366213440895, -0.04012252017855644, -0.04408623278141022, -0.019376425072550774, -0.002510801190510392, -0.01776937022805214, 0.07244868576526642, -0.004642855376005173, 0.0002780069480650127, -0.022696122527122498, -0.01877576857805252, 0.04891829565167427, 0.05843469128012657, 0.030418885871767998, 0.06954816728830338, 0.011736507527530193, -0.050179194658994675, 0.004114184062927961, 0.0015077164862304926, -0.013383462093770504, -0.06689295172691345, 0.01898355968296528, -0.000999623560346663, -0.033216457813978195, -0.010472148656845093, -0.010998114943504333, 0.0044739339500665665, 0.031481459736824036, -0.006304733920842409, -0.056810613721609116, -0.01284345518797636, 0.03409337252378464, 0.053255632519721985, -0.03796323016285896, 0.026190975680947304, -0.016030067577958107, -0.028399717062711716, -0.006358151324093342, -0.029224585741758347, 0.01715046726167202, 0.04849398881196976, 0.0031797403935343027, 0.015362401492893696, -0.022813981398940086, -0.006606692913919687, 0.011175393126904964, 0.03475995734333992, 0.007873548194766045, -0.01765158399939537, -0.0004828559176530689, -0.04511842504143715, 0.011900936253368855, 0.061124593019485474, -0.06249091029167175, 0.019539499655365944, 0.004425304010510445, -0.00432983785867691, 0.0070778788067400455, 0.04033096507191658, 0.03076215460896492, 0.04397519305348396, 0.02231963723897934, -0.02862168475985527, -0.04672333598136902, -0.007071799598634243, -0.03275832161307335, -0.015159497037529945, 0.044830795377492905, 0.04521878436207771, -0.022583892568945885, -0.018899589776992798, 0.018086552619934082, 0.08226058632135391, -0.04208444803953171, -0.04861081391572952, 0.04573768377304077, 0.04291548952460289, 0.001050839084200561, -0.0030108867213129997, -0.005285609979182482, -0.020950181409716606, -0.005648741964250803, -0.008737543597817421, 0.03150510415434837, -0.009228616021573544, -0.05364636331796646, 0.0007858311291784048, -0.0015714867040514946, -0.023264799267053604, 0.01791883260011673, 0.025661304593086243, 0.03217416629195213, 0.025866728276014328, 0.03931441530585289, -0.05007248371839523, -0.004677408374845982, -0.005808543413877487, -0.000730570696759969, 0.030858881771564484, -0.035698093473911285, 0.0370260551571846, -0.011327051557600498, -0.05446824058890343, -0.058756161481142044, -0.026540173217654228, 0.04607268050312996, -0.04290975257754326, -0.048747897148132324, -0.05286804959177971, -0.04605063050985336, -0.014272383414208889, 0.01510031707584858, 0.005825247149914503, -0.0281554963439703, 0.0033563508186489344, 0.019922802224755287, 0.0006394019001163542, 0.051494352519512177, -0.010393313132226467, -0.02293446846306324, 0.04367741942405701, -0.0009460040600970387, 0.04788492992520332, -0.007052663713693619, 0.029292885214090347, 0.003136971965432167, 0.02687772922217846, 0.025422288104891777, -0.03412184864282608, -0.009738361462950706, -0.027736281976103783, -0.026476506143808365, 0.020930662751197815, 0.052270568907260895, 0.0070328726433217525, 0.03479018807411194, 0.018127409741282463, -0.04445754736661911, 0.05621771141886711, 0.01213555596768856, 0.03696948289871216, 0.017874306067824364, -0.08433835208415985, -0.047723542898893356, -0.010066558606922626, 0.05743042007088661, -0.06714620441198349, 0.002950877184048295, -0.015022593550384045, 0.010499171912670135, 0.05008852854371071, 0.012251300737261772, 0.02869872935116291, 0.002465835539624095, -0.036038994789123535, 0.014975843951106071, -0.007682763505727053, 0.011434909887611866, 0.025983022525906563, 0.016948876902461052, -0.051913339644670486, 0.055606793612241745, 0.016996022313833237, -0.032609499990940094, -0.0020188598427921534, 0.031645484268665314, -0.051353342831134796, 0.02020397037267685, -0.018934492021799088, -0.02590942196547985, 0.014007573015987873, 0.0007306587649509311, -0.056424692273139954, -0.001211991417221725, 0.021594831719994545, -0.017131134867668152, 0.06726506352424622, -0.02083132602274418, -0.0199714507907629, 0.05530012398958206, 0.019855143502354622, -0.047526851296424866, 0.049219053238630295, 0.008157354779541492, -0.001033677370287478, -0.0630635917186737, 0.003968097735196352, -0.010382910259068012, 0.010831432417035103, -0.02039789967238903, 0.021582575514912605, 0.03634340316057205, 0.04417949914932251, 0.07707428932189941, 0.050771575421094894, 0.003322419710457325, -0.0065415953285992146, -0.02003166638314724, -0.0425957515835762, 0.11181081831455231, -0.026877623051404953, 0.018508944660425186, -0.019586969166994095, 0.02071431279182434, -0.04243113473057747, 0.023398421704769135, -0.030842112377285957, 0.03117758221924305, 0.06712670624256134, 0.012112583965063095, -0.03133947402238846, -0.04182791709899902, -0.034401729702949524, -0.006753741763532162, -0.10347923636436462, -0.07530184835195541, 0.05505633354187012, -0.014560317620635033, -0.029567869380116463, 0.020616935566067696, 0.04355413094162941, -0.029884211719036102, 0.05841565132141113, -0.015883587300777435, -0.010518104769289494, 0.03146427497267723, -0.0008598091080784798, 0.016539838165044785, -0.028524106368422508, -0.062436096370220184, -0.03889797255396843, 0.01416094321757555, 0.03210683912038803, 0.03110676445066929, -0.10765815526247025, 0.039480213075876236, 0.0056811170652508736, -0.03907817602157593, -0.003762362524867058, -0.035154517740011215, -0.01670144498348236, -0.06619197130203247, 0.028180567547678947, -0.00018006983736995608, -0.025237122550606728, 0.002260037465021014, 0.003586368402466178, -0.03983193263411522, -0.046634189784526825, -0.0028229679446667433, 0.01288954820483923, 0.07379762828350067, -0.026950687170028687, 0.01094997301697731, 0.013646730221807957, -0.045657847076654434, 0.036336079239845276, -0.03357037901878357, 0.045961834490299225, 0.0011509379837661982, 0.02186436951160431, -0.016385376453399658, -0.03764830157160759, -0.014517982490360737, 0.08234947919845581, -0.026097234338521957, -0.016255736351013184, 0.03631186857819557, -0.07538999617099762, 0.021262168884277344, -0.01857721246778965, -0.07227127254009247, 0.047849204391241074, 0.02382814884185791, 0.1157464012503624, 0.04245263710618019, 0.020925702527165413, -0.032999392598867416, 0.04115200787782669, -0.03502386808395386, 0.035446904599666595, -0.021254820749163628, 0.02105054445564747, 0.025064697489142418, -0.04039265587925911, -0.011307942681014538, -0.04422343894839287, -0.05787929892539978, 0.057810116559267044, 0.0742221549153328, -0.010514166206121445, -0.04647722467780113, -0.016934020444750786, 0.03259272128343582, 0.0025593857280910015, -0.11121505498886108, -0.024630002677440643, -0.019282303750514984, -0.01811969093978405, -0.031394124031066895, -0.03974856436252594, 0.01636485941708088, 0.02766604535281658, 0.007457592990249395, -0.002492132131010294, -0.02937502972781658, 0.01485726609826088, 0.00463257497176528, 0.01961214654147625, 0.013828253373503685, 0.005185011774301529, -0.0051444401033222675, -0.060674261301755905, -0.007027877494692802, -0.017119117081165314, 0.005145628470927477, -0.027307523414492607, -0.020725637674331665, -0.034240253269672394, 0.012810807675123215, -0.00035865651443600655, -0.05938870459794998, 0.019852284342050552, 0.018368421122431755, 0.0482773557305336, -0.007514547556638718, -0.004381576552987099, 0.023775028064846992, 0.044433604925870895, 0.01762300170958042, -0.02115502767264843, 0.013397037982940674, -0.02783694677054882, 0.053216759115457535, -0.04341535642743111, -0.018103932961821556, -0.00834154337644577, 0.043835315853357315, 0.05130966752767563, 0.0033644731156527996, 0.014070902019739151, -0.0019337852718308568, -0.0019275039667263627, 0.0394630990922451, 0.005767093040049076, -0.0520298071205616, 0.04614831134676933, 0.016315197572112083, -0.01993403770029545, -0.007205795496702194, -0.016651824116706848, -0.04273471608757973, -0.01668556034564972, 0.04804043471813202, -0.08128933608531952, -0.026192057877779007, -0.027013448998332024, -0.0047600846737623215, -0.019963571801781654, -0.017223002389073372, 0.035339877009391785, 0.02766783908009529, -0.0003863006131723523, -0.013669480569660664, 0.02579270862042904, 0.04080187529325485, -0.012763499282300472, -0.011557414196431637, -0.006850119214504957, 0.020932858809828758, 0.05181484296917915, 0.008608832024037838, 0.023050347343087196, -0.020648935809731483, -0.04055538401007652, 0.03437237814068794, -0.03495673090219498, -0.028364453464746475, 0.00631996663287282, -0.009080727584660053, 0.012419218197464943, 0.01350659504532814, 0.00014120493142399937, -0.09462431073188782, 0.05072516202926636, 0.08301778882741928, -0.021902261301875114, -0.015958251431584358, 0.045895323157310486, -0.007718303240835667, 0.019003774970769882, -0.0013958046911284328, 0.0009918431751430035, 0.06303983181715012, 0.016537705436348915, -0.00845655333250761, 0.040384989231824875, -0.03922197222709656, 0.03489670157432556, 0.049652572721242905, -0.02548598125576973, 0.04673689976334572, -0.06063058599829674, 0.030617324635386467, -0.027545174583792686, 0.010269580408930779, 0.019061196595430374, 0.10038523375988007, -0.04621860012412071, 0.04932713136076927, 0.02223244309425354, -0.028077643364667892, -0.001708216848783195, 0.010825401172041893, 0.0045778099447488785, -0.00029063617694191635, -0.0880277007818222, 0.04278235137462616, 0.048186689615249634, -0.00811698753386736, 0.014924631454050541, 0.017116261646151543, 0.013951648026704788, -0.006399548612535, 0.014220839366316795, 0.03662285581231117, -0.024104313924908638, -0.011602221056818962, 0.031275056302547455, -0.037442516535520554, 0.008363154716789722, 0.0017603527521714568, -0.01300868857651949, 0.007368474267423153, 0.06701847165822983, -0.032344285398721695, 0.04784925654530525, 0.032754234969615936, -0.027607208117842674, -0.055426258593797684, -0.01757965050637722, -0.006130245979875326, -0.001571102300658822, -0.015830203890800476, 0.0274045392870903, 0.0850638672709465, -0.029351741075515747, -0.03432215005159378, -0.02204572595655918, 0.01592220738530159, -0.030579177662730217, -0.03095369040966034, -0.025777235627174377, 0.010613865219056606, 0.03243137151002884, -0.025240639224648476, -0.00023398570192512125, 0.04412924125790596, -0.054113466292619705, 0.01715959422290325, 0.01563054323196411, -0.007668718229979277, -0.024949118494987488, 0.018665429204702377, -0.00030598536250181496, 0.02967541292309761, 0.037162039428949356, 0.04644850641489029, 0.04137773439288139, -0.04883956536650658, -0.061074148863554, 0.023257452994585037, 0.025580931454896927, -0.004659000784158707, -0.02423250488936901, -0.008041290566325188, 0.030289223417639732, 0.019218560308218002, 0.012434056960046291, -0.027066657319664955, -0.06166117265820503, 0.042257096618413925, 0.008023656904697418, 0.02032650262117386, -0.018008284270763397, -0.027016853913664818, 0.02205861546099186, 0.0322275348007679, -0.014246233738958836, 0.00632320623844862, -0.0014225166523829103, -0.033277060836553574, -0.04179175943136215, -0.054374851286411285, -0.041308220475912094, -0.0224292054772377, 0.022020185366272926, 0.044563956558704376, -0.06555337458848953, -0.02306884527206421, -0.0734298974275589, 0.03697841614484787, -0.03552332893013954, -0.04851379990577698, -0.03353850916028023, -0.06644051522016525, 0.02494904026389122, -0.038158975541591644, 0.013406846672296524, -0.05836844816803932, 0.004884297493845224, -0.04010429233312607, -0.03459852933883667, -0.023243393748998642, 0.0032605736050754786, 0.03281426429748535, 0.024811403825879097, -0.02589811012148857, 0.016718588769435883, -0.007374401204288006, 0.0121121471747756, 0.02253861166536808, 0.023842571303248405, -0.039863284677267075, 0.03982030972838402, -0.002410041866824031, 0.0589946024119854, 0.011346952058374882, -0.029643382877111435, 0.008207299746572971, -0.020076772198081017, 0.103641577064991, -0.013055453076958656, -0.009486764669418335, -0.002546097384765744, 0.024764560163021088 ]
<p>I guess that these questions were being asked by many people on the Northern Hemisphere during this summer (and other summers) and someone may give a nice, coherent answer. The general question is how many times more slowly one is getting suntan or damages his skin in the evening, relatively to the noon?</p> <p>The Sun altitude (solar elevation angle) $\alpha_s$ apparently makes the ozone layer etc. look $1/\sin\alpha_s$ times thicker than when the Sun is directly above our head. Clearly, this makes the solar UV radiation weaker if we're further from the noon. So</p> <ul> <li>is that right that a particular spectral line gets weakened by the factor of $\exp(-C_\lambda/ \sin\alpha_s)$?</li> <li>is that true that the changes to the UV-B radiation are the most important ones because UV-A is almost completely transmitted and UV-C is almost completely blocked?</li> <li>because 98% of the UV radiation is said to be absorbed by the atmosphere, one would expect that the exponential reduction above will be dramatic. However, sources suggest that the "total amount" of UV radiation is only suppressed by a power law, probably by $1/\sin^2\alpha_s$ (10% thicker atmosphere implies 20% less radiation). Where does it come from? Is it from some integration of the exponentially suppressed function over frequencies? What is the approximate integrand and how does the decreasing exponential become a power law?</li> <li>is it OK to assume that all transmitted UV rays cause suntan and potential diseases at the same rate, I mean that the ratio of "suntan vs harm" obtained by a photon is constant, or is it true that softer UV rays are giving us suntan with less harm to the skin? That would imply that it's healthier to get suntan in the evening</li> <li>above, it was assumed that the solar photons travel straight from the Sun. But does Rayleigh scattering matter here? UV photons could go via the shortest path through the atmosphere (velocity orthogonal to the ozone layer) and then reflect to our skin via Rayleigh scattering – in this way, they would effectively see the minimally thin ozone layer. Rayleigh scattering is probably substantial for UV radiation, isn't it? In this way, one could explain why the Sun seems more powerful in the evening than the exponentially decreasing formula suggests. In the evening, one could still be getting suntanned from "all directions" of the sky (all places where it's "blue").</li> </ul> <p>Sorry for this mixture of facts, questions, and half-baked hypotheses. Please fix the claims that are incorrect. There seem to be many related questions above but I would really like to get some usable "rate of getting suntan" as a function of the Sun altitude.</p>
g7445
[ 0.025903645902872086, -0.040995631366968155, -0.01382768526673317, 0.054198604077100754, -0.008294775150716305, 0.05370091646909714, 0.06559163331985474, -0.009749515913426876, 0.03143240138888359, -0.037630435079336166, 0.0426129586994648, -0.00233055604621768, 0.04458514228463173, 0.021065501496195793, 0.02708941511809826, 0.0061599197797477245, 0.061309125274419785, -0.011438016779720783, 0.0666981115937233, -0.020210010930895805, -0.047385308891534805, -0.023773841559886932, -0.00740252947434783, -0.04376356303691864, -0.04927282780408859, -0.00046982645289972425, -0.024922654032707214, -0.00886568520218134, -0.03271493315696716, -0.03455834463238716, 0.09289083629846573, -0.01926851086318493, 0.021819625049829483, -0.0026901978999376297, 0.01631183549761772, 0.0003629158018156886, 0.021078774705529213, 0.010898427106440067, -0.03765024244785309, 0.027120638638734818, 0.060519151389598846, 0.030946830287575722, 0.06527122855186462, 0.08297069370746613, -0.02243727818131447, -0.025114689022302628, -0.020754434168338776, 0.030677376314997673, 0.007788138464093208, -0.05984918400645256, -0.06618314236402512, -0.04428130015730858, -0.004397949203848839, 0.026324836537241936, 0.04006033390760422, 0.005985624622553587, 0.03527971729636192, -0.022484468296170235, -0.0012102077016606927, 0.06842531263828278, 0.0555785708129406, -0.036660853773355484, 0.005468172021210194, -0.046972762793302536, 0.05136806145310402, -0.0202192310243845, 0.04607103765010834, -0.02730930596590042, 0.022930070757865906, 0.01871345192193985, 0.011109041050076485, -0.022479714825749397, -0.07133594900369644, -0.05544449761509895, 0.055083103477954865, -0.01522249635308981, 0.017421657219529152, -0.036131251603364944, 0.030015941709280014, 0.07724526524543762, -0.0021791004110127687, 0.006176567170768976, -0.010416117496788502, 0.023832283914089203, -0.019470730796456337, -0.03137541189789772, 0.01766323857009411, 0.003618264338001609, 0.01572122797369957, 0.016484638676047325, 0.04059311002492905, -0.013761745765805244, 0.06978955864906311, -0.029763732105493546, -0.018671944737434387, -0.033521752804517746, 0.03684096783399582, 0.018433017656207085, -0.0451243594288826, -0.05327237397432327, -0.0589236244559288, -0.011051760986447334, 0.028956018388271332, 0.06406428664922714, 0.004158706404268742, 0.04311640188097954, 0.05706002190709114, -0.044568583369255066, -0.06668061017990112, 0.04865725710988045, -0.02425316721200943, -0.014573677442967892, -0.057537827640771866, -0.03668636456131935, -0.04043364152312279, -0.06520136445760727, -0.0012817536480724812, 0.011940279975533485, 0.07815953344106674, 0.05802043154835701, -0.007308974862098694, 0.07668428122997284, -0.011712300591170788, 0.024630321189761162, -0.005951938685029745, 0.041973814368247986, -0.033566299825906754, 0.003980353008955717, 0.02443683333694935, 0.027339881286025047, -0.0016370186349377036, 0.013621128164231777, -0.03476886823773384, 0.03890308365225792, 0.013436894863843918, 0.00017174173262901604, 0.020798660814762115, 0.042454153299331665, 0.001180140650831163, -0.0183511171489954, 0.017266543582081795, 0.020539231598377228, 0.01335163228213787, -0.051329948008060455, -0.08553190529346466, 0.06877423822879791, -0.05199785158038139, -0.030217811465263367, 0.028064340353012085, -0.017664318904280663, 0.028552982956171036, 0.012996361590921879, 0.0025139397475868464, -0.022410418838262558, -0.039585378021001816, -0.022870497778058052, 0.00786533858627081, 0.00913332775235176, 0.006986732594668865, 0.05367796868085861, 0.022335538640618324, -0.0010342809837311506, 0.007372547872364521, -0.03767312318086624, -0.03547995164990425, 0.007534419186413288, -0.05433579534292221, -0.008433304727077484, -0.022310752421617508, 0.02098052203655243, -0.014750964008271694, 0.008139419369399548, 0.010027862153947353, -0.020822197198867798, -0.0067270235158503056, 0.034453898668289185, 0.12292875349521637, -0.030032943934202194, -0.04327850043773651, 0.01017748937010765, -0.0378216914832592, -0.0028242007829248905, -0.023653669282794, -0.06818268448114395, 0.048593297600746155, -0.005101701244711876, -0.014872760511934757, -0.05789560079574585, -0.03145897760987282, 0.024685952812433243, -0.00727952690795064, -0.07109305262565613, 0.014683404006063938, -0.06583312898874283, 0.013150099664926529, 0.017404882237315178, 0.015781350433826447, 0.01693948172032833, -0.0557171069085598, 0.058546800166368484, -0.026893658563494682, 0.021362608298659325, 0.003335025627166033, -0.03668292239308357, 0.006730455905199051, 0.09691261500120163, -0.03171609714627266, 0.023462487384676933, 0.020082678645849228, -0.0634002611041069, 0.005863682832568884, -0.038078539073467255, 0.03351195156574249, 0.014546931721270084, 0.021104678511619568, 0.04899746924638748, -0.05359278619289398, 0.009796320460736752, 0.02084984816610813, -0.002631925279274583, -0.008044635877013206, 0.01257072202861309, 0.02337583899497986, 0.02013569511473179, -0.02170933224260807, 0.0351245142519474, -0.05927876755595207, -0.04082881659269333, 0.05544918030500412, 0.03102058731019497, -0.01662309281527996, -0.01882512867450714, -0.030090272426605225, 0.007708488032221794, -0.06562068313360214, -0.0006217018817551434, 0.048209816217422485, -0.010576815344393253, 0.03125881403684616, -0.02864116244018078, 0.05988356098532677, 0.0035756223369389772, -0.03270592913031578, -0.0021715215407311916, 0.022807788103818893, 0.0070325578562915325, -0.04015950858592987, 0.0020064967684447765, -0.033086273819208145, -0.0005978074041195214, -0.007407601922750473, 0.03205915167927742, 0.028278294950723648, -0.02012234926223755, 0.0006417797994799912, -0.014166849665343761, -0.024566326290369034, 0.01258351095020771, -0.051480937749147415, -0.023703303188085556, -0.040068838745355606, -0.014210118912160397, 0.01447370182722807, -0.06524918973445892, -0.07189945876598358, 0.07336121052503586, -0.04355967417359352, 0.033629678189754486, -0.00821734219789505, -0.03445802256464958, 0.003691241377964616, 0.10479923337697983, 0.005934632383286953, 0.038029592484235764, 0.03750884532928467, -0.009373528882861137, -0.024466831237077713, -0.06197778135538101, 0.00813036784529686, -0.003047562437132001, -0.015147162601351738, -0.0019432998960837722, -0.034829284995794296, -0.032217659056186676, 0.0416395477950573, 0.00903384666889906, 0.016402889043092728, 0.059781625866889954, 0.003534510266035795, -0.0022204758133739233, 0.004754811059683561, -0.0068308343179523945, 0.07822801172733307, 0.05270294100046158, -0.03125091269612312, 0.011556223966181278, 0.07031235843896866, -0.023769987747073174, -0.02851160243153572, -0.048393502831459045, 0.0022720785345882177, 0.031915370374917984, 0.0045968154445290565, 0.01152883842587471, 0.02469051070511341, 0.021328993141651154, -0.07293310761451721, -0.06818129867315292, 0.025069067254662514, -0.02891341596841812, -0.016932491213083267, 0.02114499919116497, -0.012397481128573418, 0.04115987941622734, 0.03494775667786598, -0.0188202653080225, -0.01575476862490177, -0.016609562560915947, 0.023743411526083946, 0.007206649985164404, -0.019957346841692924, -0.02615063078701496, -0.030258331447839737, 0.013659588992595673, -0.006115152966231108, 0.0009263901156373322, -0.022314779460430145, 0.025552591308951378, -0.016954030841588974, -0.004353441763669252, 0.02030356414616108, 0.04203559085726738, -0.035235997289419174, -0.012825592420995235, -0.06379527598619461, 0.0463094487786293, -0.002546821953728795, 0.0026326996739953756, 0.015057741664350033, 0.025664806365966797, -0.046472180634737015, -0.0375952422618866, -0.020047582685947418, -0.019357791170477867, 0.023994725197553635, -0.024761276319622993, -0.048842206597328186, -0.022750845178961754, -0.06792593002319336, 0.018967216834425926, 0.07264744490385056, 0.010345988906919956, -0.04409879073500633, 0.0023189671337604523, 0.008685518987476826, 0.04365943372249603, 0.0025774529203772545, 0.04375555366277695, 0.016242152079939842, -0.06339673697948456, 0.04451453685760498, -0.03688626363873482, 0.029377788305282593, 0.014421806670725346, -0.036283668130636215, 0.016612743958830833, 0.02840472385287285, 0.11845102161169052, 0.009597787633538246, 0.040112655609846115, -0.003369783516973257, -0.004596144892275333, -0.03899089992046356, -0.018051890656352043, -0.03990153595805168, 0.007958250120282173, 0.026191746816039085, 0.025251120328903198, 0.02102220244705677, 0.09117919951677322, 0.049804531037807465, 0.02106374502182007, 0.04141513630747795, -0.003620752366259694, 0.03250676766037941, 0.012772438116371632, -0.056688837707042694, -0.04342908412218094, -0.0016463604988530278, -0.07116304337978363, 0.00459302170202136, -0.029215794056653976, 0.026079924777150154, 0.013074723072350025, 0.0584305077791214, -0.061397358775138855, 0.0287306047976017, -0.01746744103729725, -0.04528284817934036, 0.03200622648000717, 0.07749152928590775, 0.005530921276658773, 0.022231198847293854, 0.0504523329436779, -0.026640357449650764, 0.017309514805674553, 0.0312921442091465, -0.009213694371283054, 0.012457391247153282, 0.0017029951559379697, 0.02671639434993267, -0.016517644748091698, -0.03654443472623825, -0.0893826112151146, 0.010633069090545177, 0.0649198591709137, -0.022699255496263504, -0.08242937922477722, -0.001739814062602818, 0.002771250670775771, -0.016143208369612694, -0.000804252689704299, -0.021469419822096825, -0.03560985252261162, -0.035530854016542435, 0.05825560912489891, 0.04644082486629486, -0.018875088542699814, 0.016081606969237328, -0.008407210931181908, 0.04268815740942955, -0.005924453493207693, -0.021617138758301735, -0.011364432983100414, -0.030779695138335228, 0.013963574543595314, -0.008082286454737186, -0.0020645270124077797, 0.00017212230886798352, -0.02934003621339798, 0.02789168432354927, 0.046652454882860184, 0.04104216396808624, -0.004521538969129324, -0.02420004829764366, 0.043420858681201935, -0.011602493934333324, -0.019302409142255783, -0.01130992267280817, 0.006075418554246426, -0.05782968923449516, 0.039885733276605606, 0.04459605738520622, -0.01792381890118122, -0.03040054813027382, -0.007181158289313316, -0.01210156362503767, 0.010902976617217064, 0.04092147946357727, 0.03290854021906853, -0.07020686566829681, 0.014835448004305363, 0.04550575837492943, -0.02086399309337139, 0.03954422101378441, -0.031791552901268005, -0.030093351379036903, 0.06630834192037582, -0.04884449392557144, -0.00625832611694932, -0.03366102650761604, 0.003704347414895892, 0.00343002425506711, -0.0343448743224144, -0.028382252901792526, 0.0013165052514523268, -0.051127973943948746, 0.02165985479950905, -0.020105954259634018, -0.048295531421899796, 0.04355857893824577, 0.02368137240409851, -0.007529839873313904, -0.011700941249728203, -0.09148448705673218, 0.0033229535911232233, -0.03645333647727966, -0.029469337314367294, -0.04169277846813202, -0.018640948459506035, -0.0220786202698946, -0.039253827184438705, 0.00023796090681571513, -0.009710746817290783, -0.013728338293731213, 0.0174354687333107, 0.015027929097414017, 0.03214327245950699, 0.013664250262081623, -0.03114248253405094, -0.03922756761312485, 0.052867572754621506, 0.0005104359588585794, -0.07243964821100235, 0.02356414683163166, -0.022083381190896034, 0.054856207221746445, -0.04836580157279968, 0.04271918907761574, 0.06090495362877846, -0.014034793712198734, -0.002820430090650916, -0.006963537074625492, -0.008064807392656803, -0.036025792360305786, -0.05342672020196915, -0.08718579262495041, 0.036034662276506424, 0.046275366097688675, -0.04871689900755882, 0.09044744819402695, 0.029596777632832527, -0.014719626866281033, 0.03690803796052933, 0.0633319765329361, -0.02388455532491207, -0.006918519269675016, 0.012623653747141361, -0.025523189455270767, -0.04856926202774048, -0.032222993671894073, 0.062220294028520584, -0.07548998296260834, -0.03292166814208031, 0.048515480011701584, -0.010939575731754303, 0.04865698143839836, 0.016766976565122604, 0.024665264412760735, 0.017516721040010452, -0.05868369713425636, -0.04247121512889862, -0.009248968213796616, 0.053882237523794174, 0.02205592207610607, 0.00025151047157123685, -0.006190457846969366, -0.012064293958246708, 0.003885301761329174, -0.0010658524697646499, 0.010839954949915409, -0.010224211029708385, 0.035787228494882584, 0.06631909310817719, -0.03381198272109032, 0.007774382829666138, 0.005277174524962902, 0.01080075092613697, 0.03230305016040802, 0.00694719422608614, 0.035955820232629776, 0.020053336396813393, 0.019217118620872498, -0.01573999971151352, 0.03186310455203056, -0.04776468873023987, 0.037275850772857666, -0.0322420708835125, 0.027584845200181007, 0.07655904442071915, 0.012079787440598011, -0.002715890994295478, 0.04200489819049835, 0.004052259027957916, 0.025698479264974594, 0.003501336555927992, 0.018143726512789726, -0.027904361486434937, -0.01689104363322258, -0.03782915323972702, -0.008800618350505829, -0.040899090468883514, 0.009471852332353592, -0.02219594083726406, 0.015251537784934044, -0.02499040775001049, -0.03006022982299328, -0.009390868246555328, 0.10303165763616562, 0.016361486166715622, 0.013971688225865364, -0.018311021849513054, -0.034647077322006226, 0.007769033312797546, -0.06327802687883377, -0.07137604057788849, 0.04475199058651924, -0.03157790005207062, -0.036885347217321396, -0.0021381720434874296, 0.025287609547376633, -0.04999467730522156, 0.07389435172080994, -0.08224441856145859, 0.03935348615050316, 0.05202597752213478, 0.04787895828485489, -0.016097677871584892, 0.03150654956698418, -0.032738856971263885, -0.025689098984003067, -0.00840404350310564, -0.02825540117919445, 0.016954615712165833, -0.012985597364604473, -0.011834734119474888, -0.030538829043507576, 0.022231869399547577, -0.001529727946035564, 0.01079885009676218, -0.015934795141220093, 0.0018590489635244012, 0.0159678403288126, 0.013263959437608719, 0.01741383969783783, 0.02734464965760708, 0.0054350346326828, -0.03607278689742088, 0.0017069731839001179, -0.014026682823896408, 0.04093305394053459, -0.0189741812646389, 0.019613191485404968, 0.05184459313750267, 0.0020359137561172247, 0.016614822670817375, 0.0037859384901821613, 0.021811990067362785, -0.036174479871988297, 0.029877619817852974, -0.0005645562196150422, 0.017646610736846924, -0.015400100499391556, 0.05973494052886963, 0.01289562787860632, -0.008624215610325336, -0.0019876400474458933, -0.01092980895191431, -0.03629225492477417, 0.05071280896663666, 0.04996833577752113, -0.03094862587749958, -0.017870446667075157, -0.03427943214774132, 0.0748155489563942, 0.051867447793483734, -0.052266497164964676, 0.05354403331875801, 0.03283797204494476, -0.10798609256744385, -0.01626565121114254, -0.04204583540558815, -0.021998651325702667, 0.014245813712477684, -0.02603278122842312, -0.014633840881288052, 0.020301198586821556, -0.041984643787145615, -0.003234484000131488, -0.005675354972481728, -0.015534890815615654, 0.003903383854776621, -0.008243805728852749, -0.038306817412376404, 0.013053566217422485, 0.028494955971837044, -0.032447971403598785, -0.04125039279460907, -0.02459586225450039, 0.04125966876745224, 0.033514123409986496, 0.017767179757356644, 0.016843654215335846, -0.020741412416100502, 0.031029580160975456, -0.042560797184705734, -0.08633647114038467, 0.0004476924950722605, 0.023422813042998314, -0.019352396950125694, -0.020367931574583054, -0.004242327064275742, -0.10936722159385681, -0.00586084695532918, 0.028562229126691818, -0.04242672026157379, -0.026276620104908943, 0.002004090929403901, -0.0071295457892119884, -0.03791866451501846, 0.009817497804760933, -0.00038439189665950835, 0.05519716069102287, -0.010175216943025589, 0.026992617174983025, 0.036122698336839676, 0.02554423362016678, -0.012111539021134377, -0.012841549701988697, -0.0009493305115029216, 0.07882634550333023, -0.014034704305231571, 0.04493442177772522, 0.02635631337761879, 0.039468564093112946, -0.026134992018342018, -0.022155936807394028, -0.002522669965401292, -0.028490737080574036, 0.005141564179211855, -0.04324192926287651, -0.014931716024875641, 0.04227053001523018, -0.030139373615384102, -0.00831186305731535, 0.0228089801967144, 0.04951608180999756, -0.031164376065135002, 0.0631868839263916, -0.0436059832572937, 0.008679189719259739, -0.016272112727165222, 0.008495520800352097, -0.10701311379671097, 0.031793124973773956, 0.004457179456949234, 0.040874749422073364, -0.021243521943688393, -0.01438454445451498, 0.007264098152518272, -0.07017359882593155, -0.0009909635409712791, -0.016193317249417305, -0.0050994837656617165, -0.04025966674089432, 0.0007940974901430309, -0.01669159345328808, -0.014774111099541187, -0.02217159979045391, -0.01250790897756815, -0.007343184668570757, 0.04488053545355797, 0.005513855721801519, 0.00910635944455862, -0.012884090654551983, -0.017932351678609848, 0.05632048845291138, -0.07921460270881653, 0.02842862531542778, -0.015260574407875538, -0.024757634848356247, -0.015514057129621506, -0.021066563203930855, -0.010989224538207054, 0.006493204738944769, -0.03233286365866661, 0.02917524427175522, -0.04046589136123657 ]
<p>A very rough approximation from first principles, from the elementary charge and hbar, would suffice. But is there such an approximation at all? </p> <p>(Alternatively, if water is too difficult: is there any other material or gas for which such a calculation is possible?)</p>
g7446
[ 0.03361818939447403, 0.03990868479013443, -0.007663384545594454, -0.010823259130120277, -0.014160389080643654, 0.02925998531281948, -0.07138904929161072, 0.00925456453114748, -0.04642113298177719, 0.011463792063295841, 0.04352287948131561, -0.031193623319268227, -0.03448880463838577, -0.005260028876364231, -0.029661770910024643, 0.003969074692577124, 0.03989887237548828, -0.013600647449493408, 0.016689246520400047, 0.009060222655534744, -0.034554220736026764, -0.052144452929496765, -0.02657034993171692, -0.013961589895188808, -0.06095948442816734, -0.03708449751138687, -0.0014897880610078573, 0.002571698511019349, -0.0018367459997534752, -0.033472172915935516, -0.04297702759504318, 0.01813299022614956, -0.026812369003891945, -0.06728637218475342, -0.02189006842672825, 0.0018841224955394864, 0.014082200825214386, 0.033992476761341095, 0.01733773574233055, -0.008929070085287094, -0.006060396786779165, -0.02738068252801895, 0.025611378252506256, 0.011858544312417507, -0.016234803944826126, -0.02104531228542328, 0.02144971862435341, -0.009244193322956562, -0.034586962312459946, -0.009162481874227524, -0.026101401075720787, 0.06288059800863266, 0.036424554884433746, -0.008223311975598335, -0.00859125517308712, 0.020977601408958435, -0.0073607866652309895, -0.03655669093132019, 0.025352641940116882, 0.033743537962436676, 0.008905132301151752, 0.0021769527811557055, -0.04434618353843689, 0.0026324456557631493, 0.0358157716691494, 0.007934966124594212, -0.06486483663320541, -0.0014540988486260176, 0.0404052697122097, 0.004958220291882753, 0.05457865074276924, -0.046358413994312286, -0.053587011992931366, -0.005239334888756275, -0.02890746481716633, 0.0016535057220607996, -0.05181000381708145, 0.016377370804548264, 0.07573024928569794, -0.04055769369006157, -0.0028366832993924618, -0.025494324043393135, 0.04650615155696869, 0.0011968421749770641, 0.0013817561557516456, -0.05906733125448227, -0.009771524928510189, 0.04450700432062149, 0.027364004403352737, -0.03707404062151909, -0.055011555552482605, 0.024838265031576157, 0.004143620375543833, -0.05673101544380188, 0.0621323436498642, -0.029398420825600624, 0.004127337131649256, 0.011021992191672325, 0.006847698707133532, -0.003803747706115246, 0.005450941622257233, -0.0023370615672320127, 0.03422047570347786, 0.009718590416014194, -0.02685217745602131, 0.006270759738981724, 0.02715580351650715, 0.0006152047426439822, -0.002756195142865181, -0.03971431031823158, -0.01661919802427292, 0.018817560747265816, -0.007614320144057274, -0.029609158635139465, 0.009596413001418114, -0.01414387859404087, 0.05683381110429764, -0.04816909506917, -0.0040329559706151485, 0.03328324854373932, 0.0168649610131979, 0.051128000020980835, 0.038105398416519165, 0.11458338797092438, 0.011790967546403408, -0.013016235083341599, -0.04103983938694, 0.017637157812714577, 0.007012200076133013, -0.026307852938771248, -0.006062268279492855, 0.0031957412138581276, 0.021100856363773346, -0.03027172200381756, -0.0020914901979267597, 0.027000268921256065, -0.030979100614786148, -0.03427530452609062, -0.00933169201016426, 0.0004347418143879622, 0.018836813047528267, 0.005228910129517317, -0.034688226878643036, 0.06139587238430977, -0.054485224187374115, -0.0075193969532847404, -0.0708145946264267, -0.007264759857207537, 0.010661975480616093, -0.019800512120127678, 0.033251699060201645, 0.03139609098434448, 0.10045315325260162, 0.03288710117340088, 0.06529997289180756, -0.023665104061365128, 0.05926036462187767, -0.05269867181777954, -0.0033211088739335537, -0.003540013451129198, -0.01935870200395584, 0.0058509879745543, 0.01632288657128811, -0.019754929468035698, 0.008281984366476536, -0.008235860615968704, 0.017631344497203827, 0.01381797157227993, 0.026919405907392502, -0.05898406729102135, 0.02762007713317871, -0.041279491037130356, -0.059103116393089294, 0.06710486114025116, 0.0005903495475649834, 0.033921461552381516, -0.003257746808230877, -0.032968729734420776, 0.012125513516366482, 0.0693395808339119, 0.03688585385680199, 0.03451848402619362, 0.03428160771727562, 0.010336908511817455, -0.01890493370592594, 0.052735332399606705, -0.018289735540747643, 0.007247516885399818, 0.0014424312394112349, -0.0007704442250542343, -0.040289510041475296, 0.038447316735982895, 0.028353644534945488, -0.017339495941996574, 0.020952792838215828, -0.018493330106139183, 0.08910752087831497, 0.007551862392574549, -0.025705348700284958, 0.022160176187753677, -0.04126240313053131, 0.049957625567913055, -0.011592564173042774, 0.04952707886695862, 0.08132339268922806, 0.003341096919029951, -0.019208595156669617, -0.022677037864923477, 0.03683168813586235, -0.007952452637255192, -0.019284898415207863, 0.011111149564385414, 0.03000831976532936, 0.034656066447496414, -0.02429414540529251, 0.01096088532358408, -0.07368702441453934, 0.006119394674897194, -0.018887510523200035, 0.027147267013788223, -0.0834735631942749, 0.02335115522146225, -0.013707687146961689, 0.07120101898908615, 0.006688655354082584, 0.001118390471674502, 0.021463001146912575, 0.023900333791971207, 0.021404141560196877, -0.027146652340888977, -0.00019447175145614892, -0.012933122925460339, -0.01380710955709219, 0.027016742154955864, 0.018990550190210342, 0.08334041386842728, -0.05238156020641327, -0.034426674246788025, -0.0016939864726737142, 0.009457713924348354, 0.07059429585933685, 0.012308240868151188, -0.0048526800237596035, 0.053834669291973114, -0.002944721607491374, 0.027524325996637344, 0.01702641323208809, -0.009547651745378971, 0.037660203874111176, 0.03161854296922684, -0.029412589967250824, 0.006189902778714895, -0.013036235235631466, 0.0120414262637496, -0.002950395457446575, 0.044594161212444305, -0.008071918971836567, 0.01786518283188343, -0.030036086216568947, -0.05118897557258606, 0.002377857221290469, -0.03565443679690361, -0.008282162249088287, -0.030653145164251328, -0.06700845062732697, -0.01701143942773342, -0.04905787110328674, 0.002114395145326853, 0.06157415360212326, -0.012409918941557407, -0.0061244359239935875, 0.026393627747893333, 0.005528798792511225, 0.05364471301436424, -0.03931257501244545, -0.011295177973806858, 0.03214645758271217, -0.040852293372154236, 0.02179061621427536, -0.02524808794260025, 0.02709481306374073, -0.024822207167744637, -0.06682147085666656, 0.05678676813840866, -0.016992712393403053, 0.004931821022182703, 0.06560618430376053, 0.006113729905337095, 0.03250282257795334, 0.006481034215539694, 0.025253072381019592, 0.011977710761129856, -0.017079999670386314, 0.07029746472835541, -0.002456790069118142, -0.004456117749214172, 0.09138203412294388, -0.0073865363374352455, -0.006160616409033537, 0.08916331082582474, 0.03128955885767937, -0.07462607324123383, 0.054879337549209595, 0.061837099492549896, -0.013215254060924053, 0.05828694999217987, -0.04502122476696968, -0.045746102929115295, 0.06762147694826126, -0.0015492546372115612, -0.04706059396266937, 0.02369067259132862, 0.00250199344009161, 0.022834541276097298, -0.040895454585552216, -0.06202946603298187, 0.03390997648239136, -0.0027781142853200436, 0.033778633922338486, -0.02860628254711628, -0.003313906956464052, -0.024570250883698463, 0.035931725054979324, -0.002527374541386962, -0.02467004582285881, 0.030626434832811356, -0.10020597279071808, -0.046350836753845215, -0.06218734011054039, -0.03323261812329292, -0.004344046115875244, 0.005984408315271139, 0.030054520815610886, 0.030040699988603592, -0.08060327917337418, -0.06349962204694748, 0.05686909332871437, 0.020339999347925186, 0.022173462435603142, 0.055848147720098495, -0.030970925465226173, -0.06523728370666504, -0.04135655239224434, -0.015167140401899815, -0.0009675811743363738, -0.03048088774085045, -0.021094677969813347, -0.02000582218170166, -0.005511642433702946, -0.01813472993671894, 0.030280673876404762, -0.02862332947552204, -0.008890973404049873, 0.01946040615439415, 0.029943523928523064, 0.04511227086186409, 0.035778336226940155, 0.04575743153691292, 0.005892052780836821, 0.0006217900663614273, 0.016160419210791588, -0.06739017367362976, 0.07371934503316879, -0.017287591472268105, 0.006978779565542936, -0.03021801821887493, -0.026565147563815117, 0.06212666630744934, -0.016351256519556046, -0.025934584438800812, 0.008579319342970848, -0.00947912223637104, 0.050141237676143646, 0.027481133118271828, 0.030534928664565086, -0.02486369013786316, 0.024703210219740868, -0.06569736450910568, -0.06048602610826492, 0.012430732138454914, 0.06601820141077042, 0.0521186925470829, 0.02285732328891754, 0.015219041146337986, -0.033782247453927994, -0.048835836350917816, -0.05315485596656799, -0.016798103228211403, 0.028921552002429962, -0.004694253671914339, -0.05771295353770256, -0.0194585919380188, -0.04441964626312256, 0.0052606831304728985, 0.0028113285079598427, -0.06381314247846603, 0.024613307788968086, -0.01325289811939001, -0.08033068478107452, 0.006606451701372862, 0.02339063584804535, 0.01753738708794117, 0.0089208222925663, -0.003340848721563816, 0.0033730173017829657, -0.0053946757689118385, 0.06442155689001083, -0.07996849715709686, -0.02779768593609333, -0.03718143701553345, 0.009188237600028515, -0.004741128999739885, 0.0013452982529997826, 0.020786037668585777, 0.01563466340303421, -0.057603731751441956, -0.03339239954948425, 0.011206284165382385, 0.006996128708124161, 0.056988444179296494, -0.004672730341553688, -0.019209275022149086, -0.02369105815887451, -0.012043632566928864, -0.03441188111901283, 0.04077732935547829, 0.025339988991618156, -0.021575486287474632, 0.021038424223661423, -0.05978701636195183, 0.032837189733982086, 0.026989614591002464, -0.00856583658605814, 0.06717699766159058, 0.0002905424335040152, 0.01078064739704132, -0.011503083631396294, 0.010856090113520622, 0.0026148012839257717, 0.05180031806230545, 0.04728366434574127, 0.07565654069185257, 0.023353347554802895, -0.0013094962341710925, 0.01889840140938759, 0.04004916921257973, -0.008496281690895557, -0.011492124758660793, 0.008908235467970371, -0.04270821809768677, -0.04370005056262016, -0.03558788821101189, 0.015559505671262741, 0.034192074090242386, -0.03824391961097717, 0.0011765006929636002, -0.0637006014585495, 0.03234165161848068, -0.00831681303679943, 0.08363156765699387, -0.03844854608178139, -0.00969137903302908, -0.0035141005646437407, 0.029207531362771988, -0.02657949924468994, -0.01871132105588913, -0.008671705611050129, -0.0021041766740381718, -0.007174244150519371, -0.007583724334836006, 0.047866638749837875, 0.013372745364904404, 0.04361025616526604, 0.0034455659333616495, 0.01505103800445795, -0.04810110479593277, 0.017877250909805298, -0.04664396494626999, -0.011299602687358856, -0.010389083065092564, -0.06366699188947678, 0.025582924485206604, -0.037868354469537735, 0.07822243124246597, -0.009791694581508636, 0.06522949784994125, -0.061780642718076706, 0.03658762574195862, -0.01723335310816765, -0.03732976317405701, -0.04823658987879753, 0.022811811417341232, 0.0011282211635261774, -0.010856088250875473, 0.00800839252769947, 0.025690872222185135, -0.008487729355692863, -0.018049180507659912, -0.03318954259157181, 0.10465234518051147, -0.05137353390455246, 0.01920764148235321, -0.03905153274536133, 0.02829468995332718, 0.05268818512558937, 0.06876092404127121, 0.016682187095284462, 0.003983287140727043, 0.014191134832799435, 0.05097971484065056, 0.017374351620674133, 0.007078212220221758, -0.031351037323474884, 0.04908226057887077, 0.0542038232088089, 0.05090605467557907, -0.04355020448565483, 0.03257901221513748, -0.07359085232019424, -0.03278878703713417, 0.06482100486755371, -0.04498794302344322, 0.01945912092924118, 0.014757704921066761, -0.032989416271448135, -0.00650677690282464, -0.035094745457172394, -0.04528594762086868, -0.025554530322551727, -0.018052320927381516, 0.05303988605737686, -0.031133810058236122, -0.027621259912848473, -0.04245513677597046, 0.022988950833678246, 0.014677747152745724, -0.02235993556678295, -0.0011848800349980593, 0.05120116472244263, 0.021831894293427467, 0.00810660794377327, 0.03214924782514572, 0.03552715480327606, 0.06853921711444855, 0.07304245978593826, 0.01050956454128027, -0.05459361523389816, 0.008569653145968914, 0.006190706975758076, -0.04826333746314049, -0.002443531062453985, -0.01662684977054596, 0.004049806389957666, -0.025186795741319656, 0.03592972084879875, -0.010594586841762066, 0.025944041088223457, -0.043665025383234024, 0.009929089806973934, 0.026424970477819443, 0.06658467650413513, -0.004258557688444853, -0.0016079997876659036, -0.0019183881813660264, -0.005774942226707935, -0.03175351396203041, -0.002804089803248644, -0.02888553775846958, 0.05173608288168907, -0.016284767538309097, -0.056358929723501205, -0.0275209229439497, 0.02166951261460781, -0.0668773278594017, 0.022039173170924187, -0.001883268472738564, 0.010500955395400524, -0.006917537190020084, -0.007644697558134794, -0.01871313340961933, 0.006149775814265013, -0.010693559423089027, -0.009217318147420883, 0.03559993952512741, -0.024620378389954567, 0.007542842999100685, -0.027890078723430634, -0.012741196900606155, -0.005479744635522366, -0.013410973362624645, 0.0328376330435276, 0.028022950515151024, -0.02338629588484764, -0.050362665206193924, 0.006742375437170267, -0.01878848299384117, 0.03247259557247162, -0.023944329470396042, -0.01326038222759962, 0.06446603685617447, 0.066120445728302, 0.02609344571828842, -0.006636782083660364, 0.04667810723185539, 0.05113603174686432, -0.006043650675565004, 0.008851563557982445, 0.023401424288749695, -0.0739719420671463, -0.0057404483668506145, -0.07978478819131851, 0.011674178764224052, 0.010221878066658974, -0.03532344102859497, 0.00925873126834631, -0.08250539004802704, 0.015196152962744236, 0.026898065581917763, 0.024279816076159477, 0.048232655972242355, 0.030302729457616806, -0.05155588686466217, 0.023786989971995354, -0.0013614415656775236, 0.028164805844426155, 0.02502325549721718, 0.002291537821292877, 0.06509552150964737, 0.0152476467192173, -0.01817149482667446, 0.04293699562549591, -0.03061220981180668, 0.038171641528606415, 0.030018573626875877, 0.028511153534054756, 0.058032020926475525, -0.0345965176820755, -0.02236204594373703, -0.020494289696216583, 0.06326580792665482, -0.04067125543951988, -0.05096982792019844, 0.041415173560380936, 0.04244418814778328, -0.10055475682020187, -0.006974867545068264, 0.029037348926067352, -0.06695950031280518, -0.05456063151359558, -0.023343268781900406, 0.03740294277667999, -0.0703280046582222, 0.002497241832315922, -0.01635036990046501, -0.059630297124385834, 0.0030749968718737364, 0.015661993995308876, -0.009485471993684769, 0.05129566043615341, -0.009918755851686, -0.015437176451086998, 0.02086925320327282, 0.051586367189884186, -0.06298227608203888, 0.018945714458823204, 0.06938564032316208, 0.011030114255845547, -0.09792091697454453, -0.006434900686144829, -0.0402396060526371, 0.018323417752981186, -0.02834629826247692, 0.005115055013448, 0.004451046697795391, -0.011006924323737621, -0.013020530343055725, 0.016557440161705017, 0.04270735755562782, 0.020597444847226143, 0.02956452965736389, -0.009950604289770126, 0.037309352308511734, -0.010413127951323986, 0.025928758084774017, 0.019053349271416664, 0.014495452865958214, -0.022097455337643623, 0.023160457611083984, 0.010784017853438854, 0.01049249991774559, 0.011721515096724033, 0.005261529702693224, 0.009849123656749725, -0.056773874908685684, 0.0015939982840791345, 0.04309022054076195, 0.00526511762291193, -0.05464567616581917, 0.03601402789354324, -0.06423493474721909, -0.04897059500217438, -0.0423077829182148, -0.02316439338028431, -0.07240535318851471, 0.008545401506125927, -0.01675466075539589, -0.008264444768428802, -0.0038616731762886047, -0.011536460369825363, -0.07578019052743912, 0.05125533789396286, 0.08845963329076767, -0.025384491309523582, -0.03483765199780464, 0.06554511189460754, -0.036046143621206284, -0.07098173350095749, -0.01626771315932274, 0.014879013411700726, 0.015691721811890602, -0.025104578584432602, -0.0035881095100194216, 0.006679683458060026, -0.019696520641446114, 0.02421797253191471, -0.012233248911798, -0.016241542994976044, -0.012814078480005264, 0.0033220944460481405, 0.03406411409378052, -0.015233677811920643, -0.025704514235258102, 0.02144399657845497, -0.0032321696635335684, 0.002128270920366049, 0.012410681694746017, 0.002813603263348341, -0.022523358464241028, 0.037420518696308136, -0.010279467329382896, -0.014234273694455624, -0.008111475966870785, -0.016683584079146385, -0.09417952597141266, 0.00019783717289101332, -0.05783481150865555, -0.06616787612438202, -0.006771453190594912, 0.07325266301631927, -0.03603002056479454, -0.006609112489968538, -0.004861403722316027, 0.008992585353553295, -0.010842821560800076, 0.05286126211285591, -0.04935783892869949, -0.052186209708452225, 0.07071664929389954, -0.015653854236006737, 0.015091769397258759, -0.006420537363737822, -0.028522564098238945, 0.004721456207334995, 0.023760423064231873, 0.061424192041158676, -0.06050029769539833, -0.04936658963561058, -0.0457259900867939 ]
<p>I have asked the question <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/q/188313/28724">in math.stackexchange</a>, but perhaps it should be more relevant here. Hence I am re-posting it with necessary reediting.</p> <p>Let $\mathcal{H}=\mathbb{C}^n$ be a Hilbert space. A state $\rho\in\mathcal{B(H)}$ is a positive semi-definite operator with unit trace. $\rho\in \mathcal{B(H)}$, where $\mathcal{H}=\mathcal{H}_1\otimes\mathcal{H}_2=\mathbb{C}^{n_1}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{n_2}$, is called entangled, if it can not be written as convex sum of one dimensional projections - like $P_x\otimes P_y$, where $|x\rangle\in\mathcal{H}_1$ and $|y\rangle\in\mathcal{H}_2$.</p> <p>In a similar spirit can we define entanglement in the symmetric space $\mathcal{H}\bigvee\mathcal{H}$ and antisymmetric space $\mathcal{H}\bigwedge\mathcal{H}$? </p> <p>As you have already understood, I am looking for entanglement in the indistinguishable particles. Hence the above definition for the entanglement of distinguishable particles does not work. A quick googling gave me a few papers, which refer to different definitions (for multipartite systems, and some are based on certain entropic conditions). Hence I want to know whether there is mathematical definitions for entanglement in such systems which is closest to the spirit of the definition mentioned above (for distinguishable particle). Advanced thanks for any help in this direction.</p>
g7447
[ -0.00673108734190464, -0.004545273259282112, -0.02652820572257042, -0.005443993490189314, 0.013286520726978779, -0.015547499060630798, 0.01218936312943697, 0.022946098819375038, -0.02327406033873558, 0.014573386870324612, 0.007223216351121664, 0.06783834099769592, -0.03665187209844589, -0.029326794669032097, 0.0026053732726722956, 0.010383817367255688, 0.06618446856737137, 0.010254154913127422, 0.019502811133861542, -0.04388659819960594, -0.049257948994636536, 0.02760426141321659, -0.015001300722360611, -0.01566646248102188, 0.025984112173318863, -0.031829431653022766, 0.049813415855169296, -0.06274338066577911, -0.0001652217033552006, 0.004083857871592045, 0.001876855967566371, -0.044537175446748734, 0.03768393024802208, -0.05656026676297188, -0.012080405838787556, 0.0015548525843769312, 0.03929238021373749, -0.02910866029560566, 0.023297956213355064, 0.0029326938092708588, 0.03354154899716377, -0.0010041261557489634, -0.019852127879858017, -0.06657939404249191, -0.0039223721250891685, 0.0165807344019413, -0.012046021409332752, 0.05908522382378578, 0.029035545885562897, -0.0298018716275692, 0.03105265460908413, 0.017932500690221786, 0.042505476623773575, 0.04607195407152176, 0.013191299512982368, -0.0016759525751695037, 0.022059407085180283, -0.0454782098531723, 0.02181987650692463, -0.0026185906026512384, 0.02807031199336052, 0.034209657460451126, -0.0013780520530417562, 0.05856462940573692, 0.005510568153113127, -0.02705279365181923, -0.06350777298212051, -0.017225708812475204, -0.04526330158114433, -0.034598030149936676, 0.007366005331277847, -0.03552300110459328, 0.0477963462471962, -0.028136301785707474, -0.026148971170186996, -0.03282885625958443, -0.0137961246073246, -0.009583953768014908, 0.06484104692935944, 0.03940415382385254, -0.06054384261369705, -0.05503853037953377, 0.04275764152407646, 0.03163427859544754, 0.07814265787601471, 0.023855648934841156, -0.011678077280521393, -0.0674276351928711, -0.05339973047375679, -0.0026039578951895237, 0.01901385933160782, -0.020193001255393028, 0.025725040584802628, 0.07863910496234894, -0.011027388274669647, -0.03157070279121399, -0.013123206794261932, 0.019301796332001686, -0.0338616743683815, 0.03527693450450897, 0.0013150179293006659, -0.018076246604323387, 0.06096750870347023, -0.006839698646217585, 0.06177550181746483, -0.0052911206148564816, 0.02977214753627777, -0.007691630162298679, -0.008540980517864227, 0.013116061687469482, 0.0130604924634099, -0.005875146947801113, -0.054252419620752335, -0.02535117417573929, -0.06198052689433098, 0.045475833117961884, 0.05681370571255684, -0.06827376782894135, -0.05373051017522812, 0.03535977378487587, 0.006302849389612675, -0.007906004786491394, 0.0429525263607502, 0.05682627484202385, -0.009743127040565014, 0.06833942234516144, -0.012175871059298515, -0.005582964047789574, 0.03093332052230835, -0.023842843249440193, 0.060285910964012146, -0.004884738475084305, 0.010198126547038555, -0.005502925720065832, -0.055518440902233124, 0.026903729885816574, 0.029748154804110527, -0.0585215799510479, 0.007562743034213781, -0.005688211880624294, -0.027481934055685997, 0.027141258120536804, -0.03701992332935333, -0.00964796170592308, -0.0015590648399665952, -0.03339269757270813, 0.02496420219540596, -0.032061558216810226, 0.027593445032835007, 0.04777742549777031, 0.03262731060385704, 0.08844183385372162, 0.003351355902850628, 0.003118953900411725, -0.05039206147193909, 0.05924811586737633, 0.045297011733055115, 0.03089018724858761, -0.0025772955268621445, -0.0008846147102303803, -0.024410199373960495, 0.018740007653832436, -0.018062030896544456, -0.02539028413593769, 0.0229328703135252, 0.00006914572441019118, -0.02885650284588337, -0.08955544978380203, 0.04602515697479248, -0.09900470077991486, -0.0421556793153286, 0.02658815309405327, -0.025383872911334038, 0.020236946642398834, 0.04054923355579376, -0.016622938215732574, -0.041052527725696564, -0.04266060143709183, 0.017046747729182243, 0.02104363590478897, -0.06970266252756119, 0.014871224761009216, 0.01778351701796055, 0.030463354662060738, -0.0710001289844513, 0.042529284954071045, -0.024446940049529076, -0.054050326347351074, -0.05717930942773819, -0.017958765849471092, -0.045711301267147064, -0.006050995551049709, -0.028710151091217995, -0.047636281698942184, 0.06371103227138519, 0.029994463548064232, 0.023142827674746513, -0.03396531194448471, 0.00880342349410057, -0.058923717588186264, 0.01640566624701023, 0.04037642106413841, 0.04602591320872307, 0.019005663692951202, 0.05802964046597481, 0.028154021129012108, -0.0192814189940691, -0.027777334675192833, -0.02842990681529045, 0.03430661931633949, 0.0162334181368351, -0.05430759862065315, -0.024274371564388275, -0.024643728509545326, -0.017120352014899254, -0.0298867579549551, -0.02302543632686138, 0.07100611180067062, 0.003049525199458003, -0.021947691217064857, 0.00031638663494959474, -0.04031858593225479, 0.035477787256240845, 0.012733840383589268, -0.026110222563147545, 0.05196003243327141, -0.04792410135269165, -0.0007259497651830316, 0.007978880777955055, 0.04990268871188164, -0.06254956871271133, 0.0022803598549216986, 0.05267389118671417, -0.10284256935119629, 0.04110037162899971, 0.03150627017021179, -0.006418189965188503, 0.04249994084239006, 0.005803575739264488, 0.030252741649746895, 0.029084058478474617, 0.002929622307419777, -0.05260854959487915, -0.004430744331330061, 0.04476859048008919, 0.02464401349425316, 0.015239885076880455, -0.013188695535063744, -0.014522301033139229, -0.009063495323061943, -0.04275175929069519, 0.031281959265470505, 0.008980225771665573, -0.0047269100323319435, 0.007530405186116695, 0.0006199781782925129, 0.01468376163393259, 0.007851039059460163, -0.016495337709784508, -0.02100772224366665, -0.004612830001860857, -0.03859341889619827, -0.02968362346291542, 0.043512746691703796, 0.02748526632785797, 0.019400183111429214, 0.01598227024078369, 0.0021039946004748344, -0.0037831247318536043, 0.035797297954559326, 0.023862536996603012, 0.05194561928510666, -0.02013065107166767, 0.03307611122727394, -0.02079545333981514, 0.0213590357452631, -0.03320922702550888, -0.03284520283341408, 0.02319818176329136, 0.007265178486704826, -0.012566212564706802, 0.04920924827456474, -0.0057608587667346, 0.0561470128595829, 0.04230286553502083, -0.07681602984666824, -0.015827659517526627, -0.01755029521882534, 0.03881654143333435, 0.02431170456111431, 0.017121104523539543, 0.0050571998581290245, 0.018244542181491852, 0.016769178211688995, -0.04127238690853119, 0.0050065587274730206, -0.04686849191784859, 0.008845007978379726, 0.04875729978084564, 0.008633555844426155, -0.06272511184215546, -0.01925837993621826, 0.03172130137681961, 0.05129988119006157, 0.03076845221221447, 0.006901754532009363, -0.0989760085940361, 0.013314064592123032, -0.033165089786052704, 0.00004759471630677581, -0.06887512654066086, -0.004722656216472387, 0.0177084282040596, -0.06977018713951111, 0.010974920354783535, -0.07250093668699265, 0.012478676624596119, 0.004725840408354998, 0.008015710860490799, -0.05436595156788826, 0.001795305055566132, -0.03834402561187744, 0.036748990416526794, 0.00229236320592463, 0.03903461992740631, -0.00824466347694397, -0.02187173441052437, 0.036691270768642426, -0.10301952809095383, -0.06354951858520508, -0.009590894915163517, -0.0630435049533844, 0.05707332119345665, 0.02508874610066414, -0.07510729134082794, -0.10418464243412018, -0.025081686675548553, -0.0789131373167038, 0.03004247508943081, -0.017760559916496277, 0.02935982123017311, -0.023228809237480164, 0.01269063912332058, 0.008640419691801071, -0.05390862748026848, 0.026414379477500916, 0.034522078931331635, 0.011160762049257755, 0.08274378627538681, 0.03615541011095047, 0.03332408890128136, 0.04115735739469528, 0.06950165331363678, -0.040339112281799316, -0.025029553100466728, -0.05017678439617157, 0.03383242338895798, -0.02876865491271019, 0.039390988647937775, -0.023424826562404633, -0.0030896668322384357, -0.018703417852520943, 0.011456228792667389, 0.08204502612352371, -0.026461223140358925, -0.04749603942036629, 0.05268978700041771, 0.004144796635955572, 0.0212380513548851, -0.008708793669939041, -0.017134912312030792, 0.011513987556099892, -0.012172644957900047, 0.002474042121320963, 0.030447881668806076, -0.0229156706482172, 0.025271611288189888, -0.053214941173791885, 0.024672236293554306, -0.03474556282162666, -0.03557530418038368, 0.008148384280502796, 0.03868351876735687, 0.04356285557150841, 0.05014156177639961, -0.004125096369534731, 0.04744581878185272, 0.03876330703496933, 0.020315352827310562, -0.02580869197845459, 0.06427136063575745, -0.02045518159866333, -0.015114560723304749, -0.04598236083984375, 0.053580913692712784, 0.028975006192922592, 0.027716893702745438, -0.010836516506969929, -0.023804090917110443, -0.006004059221595526, -0.03458843752741814, -0.044700220227241516, 0.030272753909230232, -0.006579526234418154, 0.058148324489593506, -0.07133762538433075, 0.02504800073802471, -0.013587203808128834, -0.018232598900794983, -0.052954092621803284, 0.005729289259761572, -0.0035163164138793945, 0.022452518343925476, -0.028265289962291718, -0.0203168373554945, 0.002315423684194684, 0.01315705943852663, -0.023258686065673828, 0.016793059185147285, 0.00232728966511786, -0.00156160828191787, 0.102183498442173, -0.026264557614922523, 0.027028555050492287, 0.03154446929693222, -0.022626398131251335, 0.009332968853414059, 0.013962081633508205, -0.05426623672246933, -0.061950139701366425, 0.020650923252105713, 0.004704780410975218, 0.015523668378591537, 0.06251223385334015, -0.09854650497436523, -0.04116668179631233, -0.10216071456670761, 0.004861015360802412, 0.04362691566348076, -0.043875910341739655, 0.064800925552845, 0.04259900003671646, 0.007283712737262249, -0.013937505893409252, 0.03096182458102703, 0.011516477912664413, 0.001807448803447187, -0.001997323241084814, -0.07480891793966293, 0.026319468393921852, 0.006720659323036671, 0.03575752303004265, 0.013245852664113045, -0.034785717725753784, -0.045670803636312485, 0.029553856700658798, -0.01598827913403511, 0.002996573457494378, -0.014264312572777271, 0.015621673315763474, -0.020177114754915237, -0.04552800580859184, -0.005956019274890423, -0.003542548045516014, -0.0008097448153421283, -0.011400671675801277, -0.08634792268276215, 0.04439280927181244, 0.007164106238633394, -0.016084330156445503, -0.0003921908210031688, 0.05846691131591797, 0.038884758949279785, -0.0002833994512911886, 0.016820132732391357, -0.007001983001828194, -0.01540750078856945, -0.02024327591061592, -0.04737188294529915, 0.030819253996014595, -0.015429015271365643, -0.03870034217834473, -0.010080505162477493, 0.05648202821612358, 0.05773216485977173, 0.08853905647993088, 0.0020261015743017197, 0.02159196138381958, -0.04235532507300377, -0.032508399337530136, 0.02897433564066887, 0.00940387137234211, -0.023210838437080383, 0.01722717471420765, 0.040205832570791245, -0.06532454490661621, -0.00781197939068079, -0.03287746012210846, -0.048172205686569214, 0.05893949046730995, 0.0023078357335180044, -0.034890949726104736, 0.05855892226099968, 0.03613562509417534, 0.0035517539363354445, 0.05701838806271553, 0.0830443948507309, 0.01842392422258854, -0.01585846208035946, -0.0027829143218696117, 0.026501625776290894, -0.020979415625333786, -0.01140931062400341, 0.008491813205182552, 0.004629094153642654, 0.03862597420811653, -0.08523456752300262, 0.03751498460769653, 0.010447005741298199, -0.03389296680688858, 0.022196659818291664, -0.012549865990877151, 0.02984457276761532, -0.007360071409493685, 0.032569579780101776, 0.02524920552968979, -0.07777485251426697, 0.008650834672152996, -0.02132938615977764, 0.06165255233645439, 0.06585881859064102, 0.02131321094930172, 0.0174416471272707, -0.039620544761419296, -0.0046120379120111465, -0.02361140586435795, -0.013016748242080212, 0.027133798226714134, 0.07328896969556808, 0.009774629026651382, -0.034100715070962906, 0.0009673428721725941, -0.02491690404713154, 0.04859616979956627, 0.010046788491308689, 0.015057837590575218, -0.05221380293369293, -0.056656111031770706, 0.017294064164161682, -0.0007116070482879877, -0.034461185336112976, 0.05263717845082283, -0.0014490429311990738, -0.05873003229498863, 0.025346530601382256, 0.052980903536081314, -0.00420894380658865, 0.01955956406891346, 0.003592919325456023, 0.033844441175460815, -0.006887206807732582, -0.035951197147369385, 0.004021257162094116, -0.028619620949029922, -0.03886041045188904, -0.022015633061528206, -0.01636405661702156, 0.016609083861112595, 0.01523421611636877, 0.05114559084177017, -0.018183978274464607, 0.013835652731359005, 0.025583265349268913, -0.00803148839622736, 0.06120985373854637, -0.03932010382413864, -0.014416990801692009, -0.031463149935007095, -0.022963134571909904, 0.03897294029593468, 0.01391998678445816, -0.0028619151562452316, -0.0003064673801418394, -0.034934062510728836, -0.057790208607912064, 0.006275732070207596, -0.0523466020822525, -0.00708395428955555, 0.014805839397013187, 0.025073787197470665, 0.0015009158523753285, -0.03799271583557129, -0.054818615317344666, -0.017313862219452858, -0.013433740474283695, 0.0013482997892424464, -0.02656700275838375, 0.03121868334710598, -0.01275482028722763, 0.021631555631756783, -0.00524633564054966, -0.011509018018841743, -0.010732924565672874, -0.008252725936472416, -0.043766122311353683, 0.0645008385181427, -0.04223557189106941, -0.03218351677060127, 0.029183780774474144, -0.012337619438767433, 0.009428746066987514, -0.053465645760297775, -0.01304769515991211, -0.01511557400226593, -0.0016100660432130098, -0.06341389566659927, -0.010011247359216213, 0.008636136539280415, -0.003825915278866887, -0.029116995632648468, -0.01153935119509697, 0.02074342593550682, -0.02342083677649498, 0.050724148750305176, 0.06738512217998505, 0.06932178139686584, -0.012893473729491234, 0.007017068564891815, 0.023048441857099533, 0.016144271939992905, 0.08226508647203445, -0.0543062686920166, 0.04766092076897621, 0.021360229700803757, 0.007024191785603762, -0.014642727561295033, -0.0488467738032341, 0.025763867422938347, 0.03553079441189766, 0.023137176409363747, -0.03632168099284172, 0.04815910384058952, 0.041973426938056946, -0.04381946101784706, -0.00025486768572591245, 0.012131830677390099, 0.024464093148708344, 0.00779247609898448, -0.04106704890727997, 0.017040066421031952, 0.0044051287695765495, 0.007298917043954134, -0.017521319910883904, 0.007207741495221853, -0.02651575580239296, 0.004835581872612238, 0.021953433752059937, 0.011072281748056412, 0.015257535502314568, -0.058349236845970154, -0.009484575130045414, -0.023351630195975304, -0.01143595390021801, 0.03350065276026726, -0.056395404040813446, 0.03044428490102291, 0.007710426114499569, 0.025972634553909302, -0.018676580861210823, -0.009365053847432137, -0.02816721610724926, 0.0009252949384972453, -0.009200133383274078, 0.06115032359957695, -0.016977086663246155, -0.0690983310341835, 0.01173772569745779, 0.068974070250988, 0.0023627078626304865, -0.021079406142234802, 0.04385470971465111, 0.016205020248889923, -0.0011805318063125014, 0.02559139020740986, 0.028797147795557976, 0.019897934049367905, 0.003870701650157571, 0.023936524987220764, 0.004630473908036947, -0.0425521582365036, 0.00856468454003334, -0.027210764586925507, 0.0013099291827529669, -0.011962493881583214, -0.036247871816158295, 0.05773602053523064, 0.08059605956077576, 0.09718557447195053, 0.0028505660593509674, -0.04114426672458649, -0.008933492004871368, 0.031998902559280396, -0.027127845212817192, 0.029246363788843155, -0.022969350218772888, -0.03250092267990112, -0.051730766892433167, 0.01134737953543663, 0.02217676118016243, 0.01156686432659626, -0.03528997674584389, 0.053551990538835526, -0.017869027331471443, -0.034155722707509995, -0.0002807285636663437, -0.05799204483628273, -0.028282593935728073, -0.01765945553779602, 0.05434149131178856, -0.047713909298181534, 0.028629155829548836, 0.04609651491045952, -0.015631064772605896, -0.01550628338009119, -0.013816865161061287, -0.06711918860673904, -0.031525567173957825, -0.023277156054973602, -0.004401406738907099, -0.026456091552972794, 0.009388316422700882, 0.023083023726940155, 0.016878971830010414, 0.057802800089120865, -0.017912238836288452, 0.03648873791098595, 0.008787877857685089, 0.0151832802221179, 0.026700260117650032, -0.015227490104734898, -0.025526199489831924, -0.06160600483417511, 0.03846306726336479, -0.05868493393063545, -0.015659740194678307, 0.039862506091594696, -0.05895821005105972, 0.01435653492808342, -0.009608077816665173, -0.024322878569364548, -0.054123859852552414, 0.011730855330824852, -0.0258424524217844, 0.08062942326068878, 0.05970996245741844, -0.015424896031618118, 0.046940188854932785, 0.044928066432476044, 0.004970348905771971, 0.003910080995410681, 0.0017859537620097399, -0.04178430885076523, -0.04102689027786255, -0.018219349905848503, -0.026656776666641235, 0.003314075991511345, 0.009041748940944672, -0.01654844731092453 ]
<p>On page 92, my still favorite supersymmetry <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0071636412">book</a> says, by making the global infinitisimal parameter of a SUSY tranformation spacetitime dependent (gauging) it forces one to introduce a new gauge field which turns out to have the properties of a graviton and one obtains supergravity. This is analogue to obtaining electromagnetism from gauging the global $U(1)$ symmetry of the Dirac Lagrangian.</p> <p>This approach seems to me a nice way to learn more about supergravity, but unfortunately it was only mentioned as an aside comment in that book without explaining it any further. So can somebody explain (or outline) in a bit more detail how this works?</p>
g7448
[ 0.034286946058273315, 0.08369673788547516, -0.03340177610516548, 0.002154580084607005, 0.01120351068675518, 0.07867726683616638, 0.07655408978462219, 0.039451923221349716, -0.030483702197670937, 0.0011652985122054815, -0.03090137429535389, -0.036023132503032684, 0.04304737225174904, 0.013312292285263538, 0.07039433717727661, -0.03148045390844345, 0.06760097295045853, -0.007770986296236515, 0.05947951227426529, -0.0588720478117466, 0.05142956227064133, -0.006419196259230375, 0.02787267416715622, -0.03548990935087204, -0.00752216437831521, 0.0010174775961786509, 0.07777079194784164, -0.0060708969831466675, 0.028658755123615265, -0.04267604276537895, 0.024324921891093254, -0.017062697559595108, -0.038404323160648346, -0.0075316098518669605, 0.00005412223617895506, -0.026509614661335945, 0.024450113996863365, 0.043154068291187286, -0.0041255224496126175, 0.01084674522280693, -0.04850643500685692, -0.03412856534123421, 0.015568222850561142, -0.02913745306432247, -0.048863206058740616, 0.011531798169016838, 0.015643354505300522, 0.0069556934759020805, 0.0009326161234639585, -0.03375226631760597, -0.003218357916921377, 0.05630006641149521, 0.005953626241534948, -0.04218567535281181, -0.011056840419769287, 0.0051789782010018826, 0.01946331188082695, 0.0037148965056985617, 0.047978419810533524, -0.011234480887651443, 0.003705608192831278, -0.0517101064324379, -0.006065101828426123, 0.01474426407366991, 0.013986874371767044, 0.010127176530659199, -0.048042844980955124, -0.03667984530329704, -0.06116294860839844, 0.014724861830472946, -0.04602767899632454, -0.06902261078357697, 0.028320234268903732, -0.03426641598343849, -0.003127083647996187, 0.05164653807878494, 0.03737179562449455, -0.004974432289600372, -0.021582623943686485, 0.0323849655687809, -0.010424206033349037, -0.014825782738626003, 0.015648650005459785, -0.008962222374975681, 0.05148136243224144, -0.05555066838860512, -0.007957388646900654, -0.00010231416672468185, 0.006690322887152433, -0.033753588795661926, 0.016926495358347893, -0.06408373266458511, -0.012676388025283813, 0.025251304730772972, -0.04677321016788483, 0.0012791596818715334, 0.012244588695466518, 0.05541522428393364, 0.013878065161406994, -0.054946500808000565, -0.01905263215303421, 0.023995589464902878, 0.009016746655106544, 0.004562607035040855, 0.004033063538372517, -0.0003303769917692989, 0.06690827757120132, -0.036096733063459396, 0.062454480677843094, -0.03720945492386818, -0.04441896826028824, 0.018595682457089424, 0.011669454164803028, 0.029661232605576515, -0.0951656922698021, -0.03445988520979881, 0.03356311842799187, 0.002163997618481517, 0.018369274213910103, -0.02565940096974373, -0.024325108155608177, 0.015453599393367767, -0.07366187125444412, 0.035567134618759155, -0.07301001250743866, 0.04167231544852257, -0.046506501734256744, 0.01533140055835247, 0.029433391988277435, 0.013361042365431786, 0.01556064561009407, -0.014024602249264717, -0.008361698128283024, 0.005864414852112532, 0.02446841634809971, 0.02497749775648117, 0.02252861112356186, -0.0059725274331867695, -0.04620133340358734, -0.015355940908193588, -0.07711023837327957, -0.04654576629400253, -0.016827458515763283, -0.011812340468168259, 0.051445141434669495, 0.029981017112731934, -0.001539332908578217, 0.030929798260331154, 0.016614381223917007, -0.06302700936794281, -0.0008703636704012752, 0.06694072484970093, 0.024583512917160988, 0.003079858608543873, 0.036552105098962784, -0.04128219187259674, 0.040436435490846634, -0.0206132959574461, 0.05961877480149269, -0.046698037534952164, 0.07777754962444305, -0.03186551854014397, 0.029896488413214684, 0.04099573940038681, -0.04717731475830078, 0.050199829041957855, 0.03823032230138779, -0.037313058972358704, -0.014533162117004395, -0.06190440058708191, -0.07790960371494293, 0.017434630542993546, -0.005767622962594032, 0.022671597078442574, 0.030891409143805504, 0.0473126657307148, -0.005904123652726412, -0.04074990376830101, -0.008253109641373158, -0.015722882002592087, -0.050189852714538574, -0.053929176181554794, -0.004108464810997248, -0.05069133639335632, -0.03163611888885498, 0.01387870404869318, -0.02270817570388317, 0.044693175703287125, 0.013911119662225246, -0.009164873510599136, -0.029727308079600334, 0.007971446961164474, -0.017651991918683052, 0.044298429042100906, -0.01845000497996807, 0.06972331553697586, 0.06910105049610138, -0.05606485903263092, -0.009970207698643208, 0.032424796372652054, -0.007004546467214823, 0.03843218833208084, 0.020526697859168053, -0.036024268716573715, -0.015087912790477276, -0.03878654167056084, -0.03720324859023094, 0.016651058569550514, 0.03901344910264015, 0.006018397863954306, 0.05679517239332199, 0.0025860806927084923, 0.02343839406967163, -0.010758637450635433, -0.0017028909642249346, -0.030139483511447906, 0.0009356091031804681, 0.008930150419473648, 0.05801644176244736, 0.03322590887546539, 0.03181735426187515, 0.008690128102898598, 0.10744792222976685, 0.051130861043930054, -0.010442649014294147, -0.00290853064507246, -0.039112646132707596, -0.05065961554646492, 0.0496206171810627, -0.05458829179406166, -0.06196536868810654, 0.017540840432047844, -0.018007522448897362, -0.07191047072410583, 0.023150423541665077, 0.053934838622808456, -0.004092541057616472, 0.02806776948273182, -0.012474115006625652, -0.0002352804585825652, 0.011127669364213943, -0.032906003296375275, 0.02429015189409256, -0.002480709459632635, -0.014288974925875664, -0.03496607393026352, 0.021328866481781006, 0.028821300715208054, -0.038529716432094574, -0.0246743094176054, -0.02502630278468132, 0.022876176983118057, -0.02624349109828472, -0.035244014114141464, -0.034492772072553635, -0.026162059977650642, -0.01514099258929491, 0.06546475738286972, -0.044498011469841, 0.0009327565785497427, 0.04113853722810745, -0.049331266433000565, 0.038974910974502563, 0.038052454590797424, -0.027807854115962982, 0.025044815614819527, 0.019519900903105736, -0.005343323107808828, -0.01743357442319393, -0.006656323093920946, -0.020425816997885704, 0.027628641575574875, 0.022896818816661835, -0.007489325944334269, -0.024901006370782852, -0.03713097423315048, -0.005726914387196302, 0.02185051329433918, 0.061472948640584946, -0.07510074973106384, -0.03872716799378395, -0.06431850790977478, -0.0024193236604332924, -0.010535887442529202, 0.045409876853227615, -0.0091968709602952, 0.010233604349195957, 0.007270576898008585, -0.03841337934136391, -0.03747069835662842, 0.03593016043305397, -0.007457176223397255, 0.010200266726315022, -0.017462603747844696, -0.016522150486707687, 0.03666534647345543, 0.020132295787334442, -0.003478724043816328, -0.0126485675573349, -0.0022763663437217474, -0.026453062891960144, -0.0158150102943182, 0.004814015701413155, 0.0386609323322773, 0.0006638626218773425, -0.03135489299893379, -0.04126504808664322, -0.08486916124820709, -0.013237513601779938, -0.047471147030591965, -0.013327999040484428, 0.0016399746527895331, 0.04711158946156502, -0.023354200646281242, 0.03529378026723862, -0.015910757705569267, -0.01146525889635086, -0.0172252394258976, 0.005779499188065529, -0.006598381325602531, -0.019498467445373535, -0.043207570910453796, 0.06157534569501877, 0.01112382486462593, 0.02152292989194393, 0.0351150780916214, -0.02219446562230587, -0.003938241861760616, -0.08103712648153305, -0.01780148595571518, -0.016136255115270615, 0.010103096254169941, -0.020535217598080635, -0.03498213365674019, -0.030883697792887688, -0.011356580071151257, -0.037717271596193314, 0.010752181522548199, 0.028555897995829582, 0.013719071634113789, -0.05621165409684181, -0.08315057307481766, -0.04958755522966385, 0.043254654854536057, 0.00637501385062933, 0.04629385098814964, -0.022184425964951515, -0.008848837576806545, 0.04582171514630318, 0.037763409316539764, -0.009192543104290962, 0.03439164534211159, 0.0026559645775705576, -0.023497728630900383, -0.049669139087200165, 0.04699922353029251, 0.017354348674416542, 0.02276698499917984, -0.025853341445326805, -0.0028245244175195694, 0.06330909579992294, -0.04195399954915047, 0.0015114698326215148, 0.02093403972685337, 0.00651641795411706, 0.034668851643800735, -0.008181639015674591, -0.023390796035528183, -0.03887038677930832, 0.03385221213102341, 0.02217756025493145, -0.0728999599814415, 0.004914611112326384, -0.04647872969508171, 0.038969893008470535, -0.09989167749881744, -0.002660838421434164, 0.001326561439782381, 0.010066586546599865, -0.014107412658631802, 0.0009940735762938857, 0.006092903204262257, 0.05279406160116196, -0.0028049182146787643, 0.037737321108579636, 0.06837119162082672, -0.007094261236488819, 0.016935961320996284, -0.03226621448993683, -0.050725534558296204, -0.000042032690544147044, -0.036824680864810944, 0.006811083760112524, -0.03867717832326889, -0.001589792431332171, 0.012954131700098515, 0.0011108405888080597, -0.013719715178012848, 0.024542011320590973, 0.02103406935930252, -0.009489976800978184, 0.03509559854865074, 0.010573958046734333, 0.002021661028265953, -0.07277750968933105, -0.04767153784632683, 0.03969409316778183, -0.036936428397893906, 0.06112126633524895, -0.02423981763422489, 0.0006398977711796761, 0.03791697695851326, 0.023836422711610794, -0.0741761326789856, 0.06347665190696716, -0.007444461341947317, 0.008368571288883686, -0.06917113810777664, 0.01647833175957203, -0.024820201098918915, 0.014413625933229923, 0.054358866065740585, 0.08309536427259445, -0.046640291810035706, -0.011619504541158676, 0.05753932520747185, 0.039109889417886734, 0.016476191580295563, 0.010788054205477238, -0.010640772990882397, 0.009021342732012272, -0.006128370761871338, -0.005902198143303394, 0.0483999103307724, -0.07679963111877441, 0.05269445478916168, -0.053038474172353745, -0.01421919371932745, -0.0406307615339756, 0.023704184219241142, 0.12213224172592163, -0.010996527969837189, 0.00296550034545362, -0.012749668210744858, 0.04508023336529732, -0.012602020055055618, -0.0464562252163887, -0.02915113791823387, -0.0009236393962055445, 0.014371586963534355, -0.059691622853279114, -0.01759004220366478, -0.007247298955917358, 0.006410884205251932, -0.012712796218693256, -0.024704709649086, 0.02398318238556385, 0.02946709468960762, 0.0413362979888916, -0.02987099625170231, -0.03583259880542755, -0.049852896481752396, -0.017282065004110336, 0.03545442596077919, 0.05167938396334648, 0.01922396570444107, -0.05104324221611023, -0.008789385668933392, -0.06210380792617798, -0.0504065677523613, -0.016101734712719917, -0.006814772728830576, 0.03734985366463661, -0.0145775331184268, 0.0454874187707901, 0.05067569017410278, 0.01758103258907795, -0.006994405761361122, -0.005511879455298185, 0.0038328953087329865, -0.039681050926446915, 0.013130060397088528, 0.0646318569779396, -0.0410018153488636, -0.012424088083207607, -0.04200218990445137, -0.018383581191301346, -0.0039610713720321655, -0.07625225931406021, -0.034604378044605255, -0.034748371690511703, -0.021609842777252197, 0.0566277801990509, -0.019116198644042015, 0.004739030264317989, 0.03468907251954079, 0.034258656203746796, -0.014333878643810749, -0.005888612940907478, -0.044993944466114044, -0.0023425789549946785, 0.050234898924827576, -0.009888865984976292, 0.011508447118103504, -0.02292199246585369, 0.028803028166294098, 0.09559007734060287, 0.04517863318324089, -0.04715043678879738, 0.03838397562503815, 0.004564834758639336, 0.003309581894427538, -0.03349676355719566, 0.04525165259838104, 0.04981106519699097, 0.011734993197023869, -0.0118232611566782, 0.027124134823679924, 0.006910835392773151, -0.019118264317512512, 0.016746440902352333, 0.013001189567148685, -0.008783041499555111, -0.033931929618120193, 0.029339604079723358, 0.05019815266132355, -0.09554557502269745, 0.014148454181849957, 0.09876146167516708, -0.06399203091859818, 0.04466378316283226, -0.011798333376646042, 0.06430104374885559, -0.01729891635477543, 0.07411302626132965, -0.01904289424419403, -0.014804334379732609, -0.0015028545167297125, -0.044576749205589294, -0.015968309715390205, 0.005703330505639315, -0.03350137919187546, 0.010774259455502033, 0.0014244692865759134, 0.034448470920324326, -0.04795387014746666, -0.01922108232975006, -0.020307384431362152, -0.0013248297618702054, -0.03544111177325249, -0.09708412736654282, 0.011942693963646889, 0.05110577121376991, 0.009974007494747639, -0.006298791151493788, 0.022319816052913666, -0.05084334313869476, -0.05643276125192642, -0.0755072608590126, 0.01231935154646635, 0.03381893411278725, 0.011877340264618397, 0.052306167781353, -0.0013679331168532372, -0.03770901635289192, -0.01876598596572876, 0.02790052443742752, -0.03488210588693619, 0.04614308103919029, 0.016404658555984497, -0.028773391619324684, 0.056515879929065704, 0.033610034734010696, -0.00011061391705879942, -0.05093052238225937, 0.0011531049385666847, 0.04273534193634987, -0.02584809437394142, 0.010488932952284813, -0.01324451807886362, 0.02486136555671692, -0.009875734336674213, 0.08157986402511597, -0.037516605108976364, -0.03317635878920555, 0.0402534119784832, -0.010285798460245132, 0.05243915691971779, 0.025730719789862633, 0.012887589633464813, -0.004907993134111166, -0.014893364161252975, 0.001816670293919742, 0.029932720586657524, -0.0013499448541551828, 0.02822725847363472, -0.0454140342772007, -0.007829844951629639, 0.01870531588792801, -0.004153297748416662, 0.02906162291765213, 0.011745945550501347, 0.03904241696000099, -0.022081566974520683, 0.030989648774266243, 0.037293341010808945, -0.047727733850479126, -0.001020305440761149, 0.06311788409948349, 0.01135309413075447, 0.016630994156003, -0.031995899975299835, 0.022858573123812675, 0.0026992231141775846, 0.048821818083524704, 0.0020191925577819347, -0.01605370081961155, -0.004456722643226385, 0.0053911758586764336, 0.003192648058757186, 0.017845677211880684, 0.0011768649565055966, 0.013553643599152565, -0.03402417153120041, 0.0065430691465735435, 0.05794620141386986, 0.015504994429647923, -0.013924997299909592, -0.0037495424039661884, -0.008996590040624142, -0.06108846887946129, 0.06205418333411217, 0.003979840315878391, 0.014163102023303509, -0.002366582863032818, 0.09100104868412018, 0.03898001089692116, 0.045690909028053284, 0.04508911818265915, -0.017718620598316193, -0.011314627714455128, -0.009353682398796082, -0.024460138753056526, -0.03485369309782982, 0.004842874128371477, 0.010402118787169456, -0.022171540185809135, 0.00342852296307683, -0.04265395551919937, 0.03295494616031647, 0.04124777764081955, -0.029505530372262, -0.005592430476099253, 0.053721971809864044, -0.0170757956802845, 0.02673984505236149, -0.028368894010782242, -0.020722562447190285, 0.04582107812166214, -0.058769967406988144, -0.061684492975473404, -0.011081929318606853, 0.012128003872931004, 0.04307028278708458, 0.028207069262862206, 0.08002974092960358, -0.07993075996637344, -0.0193472933024168, 0.070085309445858, -0.015276235528290272, -0.07831736654043198, -0.026033176109194756, 0.018060220405459404, 0.035378601402044296, -0.020127631723880768, -0.06007016450166702, -0.030059123411774635, 0.04921587184071541, -0.0497530996799469, -0.00255115726031363, 0.05079665407538414, 0.045130494982004166, 0.027272973209619522, -0.020671075209975243, -0.0690436139702797, 0.019173625856637955, -0.002017273334786296, -0.013574681244790554, -0.046626463532447815, -0.040187712758779526, -0.036316558718681335, -0.03758035972714424, 0.031007075682282448, 0.04266349971294403, 0.02560778707265854, -0.05296367034316063, 0.040747299790382385, 0.041752856224775314, 0.0272256750613451, 0.0003993308055214584, 0.014247714541852474, -0.011832425370812416, -0.02683418244123459, -0.020142976194620132, 0.050060566514730453, -0.00192634342238307, -0.04205663129687309, -0.04568856954574585, -0.0028191518504172564, 0.013836984522640705, -0.01577913761138916, -0.019821666181087494, 0.021334875375032425, 0.054744936525821686, 0.02706051617860794, 0.03310709074139595, 0.017661098390817642, 0.01195643749088049, 0.0009807106107473373, -0.0018342043040320277, -0.012506114318966866, -0.0059410762041807175, 0.055269353091716766, -0.02851928025484085, -0.058395128697156906, 0.014466622844338417, -0.018114514648914337, -0.03622576966881752, 0.02239813469350338, -0.03386110067367554, -0.02508026361465454, 0.0401054210960865, -0.008542667143046856, -0.0018508099019527435, -0.049154650419950485, -0.010336651466786861, 0.027831193059682846, -0.10304106771945953, 0.03928884118795395, 0.04510233923792839, 0.027315275743603706, -0.025360718369483948, 0.02421899139881134, -0.0392756424844265, -0.04067998006939888, 0.06027233973145485, -0.049250297248363495, 0.02519354410469532, 0.0072225118055939674, -0.02602510340511799, 0.011940297670662403, 0.03918454051017761, -0.0113723399117589, -0.020712820813059807, 0.020796550437808037, -0.0005492050549946725, -0.03338216617703438, -0.02629423327744007, 0.05502884089946747, 0.03704215586185455, 0.0036255395971238613, 0.011172877624630928, 0.021686473861336708, 0.022455470636487007, -0.04168631136417389, -0.0019559343345463276, 0.009436092339456081, 0.05334675312042236 ]
<p>I would like to understand better a phenomenon of a quantum heat bath. </p> <p>Below I present one example, which seems quite clear to me. It would be great to see some less-discrete models, and more specific open quantum systems (with a given concrete Hilbert space). </p> <p>(Discrete Picture)</p> <p>Let $S$ be an open quantum system (e.g. an atom), $\mathcal{H}_{S}$ be a Hilbert space of $S$ and $\mathrm{H}_S$ be a Hamiltonian of $S$. Let $\bigotimes_{k \geq 0} \mathbb{C}^{N}$ of copies of $\mathbb{C}^{N}$, where $N\geq 2$ is a fixed integer be the state space for the reservoir, that is a heat bath (e.g., radiation). Let $\{e_i\}_{i = 0}^{N}$ be an orthonormal basis of $\mathbb{C}^{N}$ such that the countable tensor product is taken with respect to the ground state $e_0$. Single $\mathbb{C}^{N}$ is a state space for single photon, let $\mathrm{H}_{p}$ stands for a Hamiltonian of a single photon. When the system and a photon are interacting, we consider the state space $\mathcal{H}_{S} \otimes\mathbb{C}^{N} $ with a interaction Hamiltonian $\mathrm{H}_{I}$. </p> <p>First question how can we determine the interaction Hamiltonian? How can we describe this interaction?</p> <p>Now, consider the state of each photon to be given by a density matrix $\rho_{\beta}$ which is a function of $\mathrm{H}_{p}$, e.g., a Gibbs state at inverse temperature $\beta= \frac{1}{T}$: $$ \rho_{\beta}= \frac{1}{\mathrm{Tr}(e^{-\beta\mathrm{H}_{p}})}e^{-\beta\mathrm{H}_{p}}.$$ Denote the Total Hamiltonain by $\mathrm{H}_{T}$, that is, $\mathrm{H}_{T}(n)=\mathrm{H}_{S} \otimes I_{\mathbb{C}^{N}} + I_{\mathcal{H}_S} \otimes \mathrm{H}_{p} + \mathrm{H}_{I}(n) $.</p> <p>The system $S$ is first in contact with the first photon only and they interact together according to the above Hamiltonian $\mathrm{H}_{T}$. This lasts for a time length $n$ . The system $S$ then stops interacting with the first photon and starts interacting with the second photon only. This second interaction is directed by the same Hamiltonian $\mathrm{H}_{T}$ on the corresponding spaces and it lasts for the same duration $n$ , and so on...</p> <p>So we can see how the quantum system $S$ interacts with a heat bath. References - Attal and Joye (2007, <em>J. Funct. Anal.</em> <strong>247</strong>, 253--288).<a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/math-ph/0612055v1.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/pdf/math-ph/0612055v1.pdf</a></p> <p>Informally speaking, $S$ is a `small' system and as we will go with time to $+\infty$ we should obtain a 'large' system after the interaction with a heat bath.</p> <p>Some quantum noises should appear as well, if they were be `squeezed' how would we interpret it ? I meant by this that the driving noises form Araki-Woods representations of CCR in a squeezed (quasifree) state. I would like to know more about the physical interpretations of this phenomenon. I would be also grateful if someone could show me some proper pictures presenting that or similar situation.</p> <p>Thank you very much for any remarks and answers. </p>
g7449
[ 0.019188741222023964, 0.035434540361166, -0.026246536523103714, -0.02796890027821064, 0.008183760568499565, 0.023671520873904228, 0.07134576141834259, 0.007568345870822668, 0.014433343894779682, 0.010668518021702766, -0.03742176666855812, 0.033210813999176025, 0.02838415466248989, 0.029404601082205772, 0.00034568001865409315, 0.027707582339644432, 0.06877834349870682, 0.030345991253852844, -0.04312533885240555, 0.0032499399967491627, -0.046722523868083954, 0.021535543724894524, 0.006902309600263834, -0.04050019010901451, -0.022170554846525192, -0.00848206877708435, 0.04888516664505005, 0.010600331239402294, 0.012468848377466202, -0.0473729632794857, -0.039867933839559555, -0.0422377809882164, 0.018100589513778687, -0.0428134985268116, -0.051866479218006134, 0.011724607087671757, 0.0514097735285759, -0.034021515399217606, -0.01714150607585907, -0.020420320332050323, 0.036238446831703186, -0.03810044378042221, 0.04753737151622772, -0.008209488354623318, 0.03862139582633972, 0.008203359320759773, -0.03950827941298485, 0.05572332441806793, -0.008127357810735703, 0.08230073750019073, 0.037953637540340424, 0.052989017218351364, 0.032471224665641785, 0.00017301522893831134, 0.056791532784700394, -0.012991673313081264, -0.00013495603343471885, 0.03683086484670639, 0.04730934649705887, 0.033435478806495667, -0.00007359167648246512, -0.01545767392963171, -0.009207409806549549, 0.00882727187126875, 0.07718437165021896, -0.004659662023186684, -0.04370121657848358, -0.019498499110341072, 0.015377102419734001, -0.011960134841501713, -0.008633099496364594, -0.07830053567886353, -0.04674655571579933, -0.02989162504673004, 0.026250503957271576, -0.03378120809793472, -0.0014514814829453826, -0.013956904411315918, 0.018448058515787125, 0.032332465052604675, -0.07228120416402817, -0.07679480314254761, 0.016164056956768036, -0.059946026653051376, 0.04605138301849365, 0.026271285489201546, -0.026839327067136765, 0.0020375836174935102, 0.004720705561339855, 0.0060631101951003075, -0.015262032859027386, 0.02158110961318016, 0.09140116721391678, 0.029943207278847694, -0.0021519558504223824, 0.023236624896526337, -0.019586976617574692, 0.020901963114738464, -0.046681568026542664, 0.010955961421132088, 0.023063143715262413, -0.030951738357543945, -0.01013026013970375, -0.07667049765586853, -0.029430463910102844, 0.029678620398044586, -0.05035918951034546, 0.00019925831293221563, -0.014134603552520275, 0.05389862507581711, -0.06062737852334976, 0.019974233582615852, -0.02022312581539154, -0.03969195485115051, -0.008254076354205608, -0.0231944490224123, -0.004369053058326244, 0.013728843070566654, -0.019250312820076942, 0.05006910860538483, 0.03224126994609833, 0.05167265608906746, -0.03488263115286827, 0.05896950513124466, 0.014026379212737083, 0.02229686826467514, 0.0034987383987754583, -0.007377599831670523, -0.005343083292245865, -0.03627209737896919, -0.05139065533876419, 0.037333667278289795, -0.0015630640555173159, 0.015244711190462112, -0.004860945977270603, 0.013345717452466488, 0.022322308272123337, -0.03446052595973015, 0.04626500979065895, -0.035470735281705856, 0.02828083746135235, -0.039492879062891006, -0.050291020423173904, -0.03115754947066307, 0.03873266279697418, -0.03024149499833584, -0.016436342149972916, -0.052531804889440536, 0.03305730223655701, -0.007689446210861206, 0.04407768324017525, 0.05653813108801842, -0.0016422863118350506, 0.015778252854943275, 0.00615661172196269, 0.03991798311471939, 0.033661793917417526, 0.004083611536771059, -0.007658486720174551, 0.019503528252243996, 0.03903227671980858, -0.037590693682432175, 0.03257056698203087, 0.0264769047498703, -0.06091535836458206, -0.008690770715475082, 0.031628817319869995, -0.11105170845985413, 0.0459478497505188, -0.05715932697057724, -0.05486200004816055, 0.03188389912247658, -0.07838474214076996, 0.034856706857681274, -0.03815215826034546, -0.004055917263031006, -0.003779054619371891, -0.02542198821902275, 0.026575174182653427, -0.02678363025188446, -0.028292955830693245, 0.003271515481173992, 0.04574105143547058, -0.018442610278725624, -0.014640109613537788, 0.08411210030317307, -0.0074350591748952866, 0.0022342216689139605, -0.04992293938994408, -0.037911757826805115, -0.058093808591365814, -0.056545376777648926, 0.014115240424871445, -0.022092079743742943, 0.024671638384461403, 0.00378700764849782, 0.006180472671985626, -0.057512205094099045, 0.011716846376657486, -0.03809583932161331, -0.04253231734037399, 0.02440364472568035, 0.014889944344758987, 0.003212376032024622, 0.0003600491618271917, 0.05497081205248833, -0.005152205470949411, 0.03506956622004509, -0.04792744293808937, -0.021099677309393883, 0.04376988112926483, -0.08050008118152618, -0.023699358105659485, 0.03383766487240791, -0.031723376363515854, -0.02977067418396473, -0.00411204295232892, 0.025653325021266937, -0.013287948444485664, -0.026289571076631546, 0.03142194449901581, 0.04325588420033455, -0.013360992074012756, -0.009039415046572685, -0.003466586349532008, -0.013495373539626598, -0.0661044716835022, -0.014123263768851757, -0.06056306138634682, 0.10442449897527695, -0.09651260823011398, -0.006109517067670822, 0.010611120611429214, -0.047218091785907745, -0.002604842884466052, 0.04417852684855461, 0.006445832084864378, -0.02147635631263256, 0.011155948042869568, 0.05409609153866768, 0.019475087523460388, 0.017276326194405556, -0.07575942575931549, 0.0037162352818995714, -0.026733074337244034, 0.006988414563238621, -0.03743992745876312, 0.05592365935444832, -0.018239183351397514, 0.01424164418131113, -0.019828548654913902, 0.01365920715034008, -0.028304006904363632, -0.03805871307849884, -0.011655175127089024, -0.010617418214678764, 0.0003802614228334278, -0.003064668970182538, -0.026447756215929985, -0.07628219574689865, -0.02218649722635746, 0.0137782022356987, -0.00746986223384738, 0.007288116030395031, 0.022203300148248672, -0.03794578090310097, -0.003953007515519857, -0.020494617521762848, -0.02204550988972187, -0.034839481115341187, 0.011503641493618488, 0.09304986894130707, 0.03763427585363388, -0.01136238593608141, 0.03437848389148712, 0.006298872176557779, -0.04117364436388016, -0.021372975781559944, 0.036291733384132385, -0.04691864177584648, -0.07202040404081345, -0.006251116283237934, -0.015114226378500462, -0.007502143736928701, 0.03697836771607399, -0.10541453212499619, 0.010819998569786549, 0.017659440636634827, -0.010424776002764702, -0.008918103761970997, 0.047930482774972916, 0.07565132528543472, 0.006760816089808941, 0.04247613996267319, -0.0643266886472702, 0.050313640385866165, 0.018350109457969666, -0.008739760145545006, 0.03268356993794441, 0.10273966193199158, 0.05163484811782837, -0.0668477788567543, 0.004050191026180983, -0.0016481508500874043, -0.008014717139303684, -0.022960906848311424, -0.08962382376194, -0.04016214236617088, -0.03184140846133232, 0.018202107399702072, -0.019089441746473312, 0.02232387848198414, 0.011942985467612743, -0.02693529799580574, -0.0387209877371788, 0.005639894399791956, -0.028150396421551704, -0.03790910914540291, 0.07556714862585068, -0.022286953404545784, -0.0023589935153722763, 0.024244943633675575, 0.005326433107256889, -0.02125258930027485, 0.06401540338993073, 0.007952709682285786, -0.060747645795345306, -0.03192128241062164, -0.02015969343483448, -0.06998372077941895, -0.01094566285610199, -0.04994966834783554, 0.049278296530246735, -0.027690289542078972, -0.06556978076696396, -0.025216128677129745, -0.04243321344256401, -0.01559135876595974, 0.03274890407919884, -0.03061419539153576, -0.021681107580661774, -0.039053644984960556, 0.014063343405723572, 0.031444452702999115, 0.006183633580803871, 0.012320809997618198, 0.038467053323984146, 0.011488131247460842, 0.002208423102274537, -0.020983755588531494, 0.001688644872047007, -0.03883936256170273, 0.03347129002213478, -0.004791343584656715, -0.03805647790431976, 0.06196429580450058, -0.004429235123097897, 0.03732927516102791, 0.05173250287771225, -0.016452794894576073, -0.021275701001286507, -0.03392458334565163, 0.016749540343880653, -0.03468451648950577, -0.014679133892059326, -0.03659044951200485, 0.0004101231461390853, 0.005412715952843428, 0.03508127108216286, -0.012210013344883919, -0.03358881175518036, 0.04453415423631668, -0.02009429782629013, 0.01221560314297676, 0.09103138744831085, 0.01621197536587715, 0.047722913324832916, -0.02785593457520008, -0.039585042744874954, 0.00531740440055728, -0.06054546311497688, -0.00033675803570076823, 0.03615952655673027, 0.06107315793633461, 0.07498345524072647, 0.0031733938958495855, 0.04538343846797943, 0.016337255015969276, -0.050239644944667816, -0.0425000824034214, 0.04678724333643913, -0.04762386158108711, 0.042896077036857605, 0.05935549736022949, 0.024812905117869377, 0.017571600154042244, 0.04811070114374161, -0.017497630789875984, -0.04016142338514328, 0.0267021581530571, -0.032672226428985596, -0.01325575727969408, -0.0046450067311525345, -0.03369128331542015, -0.020040035247802734, -0.02560846507549286, 0.06769941002130508, -0.003983387257903814, -0.06838955730199814, -0.06480420380830765, -0.011867879889905453, -0.004857569467276335, -0.006133274640887976, -0.013125143013894558, -0.01716943457722664, -0.008146215230226517, 0.08834738284349442, -0.0072601353749632835, 0.023274891078472137, -0.016647944226861, -0.03261258825659752, 0.027713708579540253, 0.02682659961283207, 0.06150316447019577, 0.013535596430301666, -0.01525917463004589, 0.024328114464879036, 0.0026546202134341, 0.006160852499306202, -0.10340053588151932, 0.011185859329998493, -0.016928846016526222, 0.013997623696923256, 0.01980603113770485, -0.035091057419776917, 0.05860833823680878, -0.058160450309515, 0.036016322672367096, -0.008059044368565083, 0.01788385771214962, 0.06556331366300583, -0.009384515695273876, -0.005052650347352028, 0.017665252089500427, 0.04999366030097008, 0.011310819536447525, 0.027864350005984306, -0.06547217816114426, -0.058033403009176254, -0.05387185513973236, 0.018340356647968292, 0.031358253210783005, -0.028295453637838364, -0.00769404461607337, 0.05482945591211319, 0.03987570106983185, -0.023786768317222595, 0.02696860022842884, -0.00016281208081636578, 0.02069792151451111, -0.029642704874277115, -0.043586645275354385, -0.016103675588965416, 0.02349795028567314, -0.01745765097439289, -0.06521143019199371, -0.020511262118816376, 0.02869267761707306, -0.07080058008432388, -0.022938672453165054, 0.02887442335486412, 0.06770449876785278, 0.04020584374666214, 0.013081411831080914, -0.0026434690225869417, -0.03946857899427414, 0.005983756389468908, -0.024811215698719025, 0.014274433255195618, -0.018550056964159012, 0.023743072524666786, 0.04376399144530296, 0.011156024411320686, 0.06445421278476715, -0.017159467563033104, 0.014547675848007202, 0.0022190227173268795, 0.022304635494947433, -0.05054854229092598, 0.004039097111672163, -0.014910158701241016, -0.014514652080833912, 0.030651066452264786, 0.030482284724712372, -0.00738027598708868, -0.03894808515906334, -0.007620965130627155, -0.03322838991880417, 0.023815706372261047, 0.02961737848818302, -0.04894222691655159, 0.02865852415561676, -0.0030891178175807, 0.04481324180960655, -0.0016962551744654775, 0.0069574229419231415, 0.036616381257772446, 0.033323295414447784, 0.02584903873503208, 0.05159739404916763, 0.013772004283964634, 0.030850019305944443, 0.018713854253292084, 0.011690110899508, -0.009052622132003307, -0.015029770322144032, 0.01434557419270277, -0.011105562560260296, -0.05744892731308937, -0.002161630429327488, -0.007897650822997093, -0.019477300345897675, 0.013221555389463902, -0.0450284518301487, 0.04124477505683899, 0.018381675705313683, -0.01398098561912775, -0.029473068192601204, 0.031234662979841232, 0.029049111530184746, 0.023820040747523308, 0.0731804296374321, 0.000932750350330025, 0.03197086974978447, -0.03457863628864288, -0.019347866997122765, -0.01720024086534977, 0.0323219895362854, 0.034885745495557785, 0.000704086443874985, -0.03022260218858719, -0.031253185123205185, -0.006291805766522884, 0.03951257839798927, 0.021872373297810555, 0.015022838488221169, -0.03241322934627533, -0.024997983127832413, 0.021852431818842888, 0.07899117469787598, -0.044739723205566406, -0.013337436132133007, -0.03726838156580925, 0.017139356583356857, 0.05891682952642441, -0.02080114558339119, 0.038725029677152634, 0.002737277653068304, 0.012790150009095669, 0.060636553913354874, 0.03438225015997887, 0.04438963904976845, 0.05662776902318001, -0.008550685830414295, 0.04690125957131386, 0.013750635087490082, -0.00814221054315567, -0.03560778126120567, 0.014221696183085442, 0.02740221656858921, 0.017707016319036484, 0.02722388133406639, 0.07354988902807236, -0.03951289504766464, 0.03725552558898926, 0.03523782640695572, -0.028398647904396057, -0.06328631937503815, -0.07937148213386536, -0.012789342552423477, -0.014300786890089512, 0.01564605161547661, -0.0010086718248203397, -0.017863262444734573, 0.029617810621857643, 0.013654939830303192, -0.019739750772714615, -0.052328500896692276, 0.04106567054986954, 0.006686783861368895, -0.011453305371105671, -0.026050956919789314, -0.026223445311188698, -0.03745318576693535, 0.03676895052194595, -0.008148029446601868, -0.0026383621152490377, 0.006554863415658474, -0.06178966537117958, 0.0003030253283213824, -0.014312800019979477, -0.058475375175476074, 0.0058123026974499226, -0.008569732308387756, -0.05493806675076485, 0.029042452573776245, -0.03307342529296875, -0.05122491717338562, 0.010616007260978222, 0.02007206715643406, -0.04029810056090355, 0.02371133305132389, 0.003979802597314119, 0.010851116850972176, -0.012364557012915611, -0.10968371480703354, 0.010679877363145351, 0.03242792934179306, 0.03562739118933678, -0.008989926427602768, -0.007252302952110767, -0.05212801694869995, 0.02801452949643135, -0.08898603916168213, 0.05871453881263733, 0.021625757217407227, -0.04226357117295265, -0.008006220683455467, 0.016508027911186218, -0.0005972296348772943, -0.008065418340265751, -0.03305979073047638, -0.03312470391392708, 0.0594894103705883, -0.036556851118803024, -0.005921734031289816, -0.062069524079561234, 0.021018901839852333, -0.010843844152987003, -0.046140823513269424, 0.0840357169508934, 0.051763661205768585, 0.04644382372498512, 0.05203387513756752, -0.029530327767133713, 0.03200284764170647, 0.010814383625984192, 0.006715324241667986, -0.07221527397632599, 0.041140954941511154, 0.01853780820965767, 0.015809955075383186, -0.09272374957799911, -0.024734681472182274, 0.015644028782844543, 0.021270936354994774, -0.011529884301126003, 0.00031950516859069467, -0.00451570563018322, -0.0044643087312579155, -0.005142328329384327, -0.04249897599220276, -0.027926130220294, 0.04871996119618416, 0.03881823271512985, 0.04235636070370674, 0.026511987671256065, 0.003516684751957655, 0.024431919679045677, 0.021181726828217506, -0.004423617850989103, -0.08537507057189941, -0.02181360498070717, 0.016570517793297768, 0.027297595515847206, -0.028000229969620705, 0.026991557329893112, 0.09432069212198257, 0.0015212075086310506, -0.04532516002655029, -0.022408802062273026, 0.012522179633378983, 0.040413595736026764, -0.014275954104959965, 0.004697381518781185, 0.012561386451125145, 0.008961673825979233, 0.03198099136352539, -0.004601626191288233, 0.002349456772208214, 0.0006970662507228553, -0.03228225186467171, -0.05197075381875038, 0.01727956347167492, -0.009496486745774746, 0.04404238238930702, 0.08586262911558151, 0.014437248930335045, -0.0245866309851408, 0.006322815082967281, -0.02353602647781372, 0.01479015126824379, 0.006190084852278233, -0.011324100196361542, -0.005089810583740473, 0.03821491077542305, 0.030095331370830536, -0.025425080209970474, -0.014887853525578976, -0.00981647614389658, 0.026366861537098885, -0.010982455685734749, 0.029536569491028786, 0.048258714377880096, -0.016424842178821564, -0.01682453788816929, -0.031861577183008194, 0.025403551757335663, 0.04366229102015495, -0.05929185822606087, -0.022226713597774506, 0.0009255592012777925, -0.044934578239917755, 0.02030288614332676, 0.04060972109436989, -0.05963684991002083, -0.02895520254969597, 0.00712830014526844, -0.00305745261721313, 0.03047347068786621, -0.017215019091963768, -0.06789028644561768, -0.010711229406297207, -0.015120797790586948, -0.021886803209781647, 0.040727272629737854, -0.008964276872575283, 0.009831804782152176, 0.07490575313568115, 0.02264072187244892, -0.0033037462271749973, -0.07245896756649017, 0.04738335311412811, -0.028960710391402245, 0.013867132365703583, -0.0007806937210261822, -0.06205341964960098, 0.021538008004426956, 0.02395162172615528, 0.02003752812743187, 0.03278514742851257, 0.010109186172485352, -0.012356474064290524, 0.0370388925075531, 0.06059078127145767, -0.019423076882958412, -0.003785267472267151, 0.0409027524292469, 0.002816167427226901, -0.007160567212849855, -0.0004530041478574276, -0.024713341146707535, -0.043113406747579575, 0.006270298734307289, -0.008350980468094349, -0.022071003913879395, 0.03744661435484886, 0.009273087605834007 ]
<p>We've got two long straight wires carrying current of 5A and placed along x and y axis respectively current flows in direction of positive axes we have to find magnetic field at a) (1 m,1 m) b) (-1 m,1 m) c) (-1 m,-1 m) d) (1 m,-1 m) now using ampere's law $$ \oint_{}^{}B.dl=\mu_oi $$ i found magnetic field for infinite wire be $$ B=\frac{\mu_oi}{2\pi r}$$ where r is distance from the wire but for evaluating the magnetic field we need to know direction of it and thus add it like vector but finding direction of magnetic feild at these point is confusing me , how do i find proper direction of magnetic field ?</p>
g7450
[ -0.0040140775963664055, 0.004364608787000179, -0.020591866225004196, -0.05933788791298866, 0.041212908923625946, -0.011250416748225689, 0.051642607897520065, -0.018476663157343864, -0.06700033694505692, -0.0007412025006487966, -0.01136216800659895, 0.03905262425541878, -0.03248513117432594, -0.008970322087407112, 0.05759797617793083, -0.044553909450769424, 0.034829478710889816, 0.011118371970951557, 0.07994657009840012, -0.040571704506874084, 0.024475105106830597, 0.012969124130904675, 0.006699730176478624, 0.05108930170536041, 0.003505556145682931, -0.07589782029390335, -0.029925765469670296, 0.034876372665166855, -0.031066013500094414, -0.03201279789209366, 0.01139143481850624, 0.02240549586713314, 0.08641328662633896, -0.0221236702054739, 0.003959851339459419, -0.03712335228919983, 0.007410776801407337, 0.05620672553777695, 0.06950598955154419, -0.034951671957969666, 0.014008197002112865, -0.011862225830554962, 0.041166890412569046, 0.005671766586601734, -0.011679752729833126, -0.014192629605531693, -0.08858988434076309, -0.04279397428035736, 0.006620579399168491, -0.02107793278992176, -0.0020482619293034077, 0.02298761159181595, 0.07202131301164627, -0.017641885206103325, -0.03211389482021332, 0.05375347286462784, 0.001540152239613235, -0.0807073712348938, -0.025192808359861374, 0.015591719187796116, 0.01706068217754364, 0.015990840271115303, -0.007812729105353355, 0.007431408856064081, -0.013194302096962929, -0.009875915944576263, -0.039798565208911896, -0.0034848281648010015, -0.03326065093278885, 0.04062405973672867, 0.002052099909633398, -0.10585271567106247, 0.05615602433681488, -0.028965026140213013, -0.05274181067943573, -0.011563893407583237, 0.020685605704784393, -0.01392407901585102, 0.023805959150195122, -0.031866636127233505, -0.04102420061826706, 0.0005652495310641825, 0.018946927040815353, 0.01027442142367363, 0.0024786610156297684, 0.02818571776151657, 0.015763919800519943, 0.017213860526680946, 0.021930495277047157, -0.033056680113077164, -0.012091916985809803, -0.010918678715825081, 0.035752423107624054, 0.057693298906087875, 0.03222455084323883, -0.05124383419752121, -0.01886996254324913, 0.031482234597206116, -0.04703504592180252, 0.0032042379025369883, -0.01795261725783348, 0.017970247194170952, -0.010243045166134834, 0.03775372728705406, -0.03898772597312927, 0.05065082386136055, 0.026246190071105957, 0.04982580617070198, -0.019615517929196358, -0.023556970059871674, -0.04591832309961319, -0.034808963537216187, -0.03662767633795738, 0.027113277465105057, 0.021414823830127716, 0.027960313484072685, 0.03996986150741577, -0.013418675400316715, 0.016997814178466797, 0.042411815375089645, -0.004118171986192465, -0.023575153201818466, 0.045055195689201355, 0.04263794422149658, 0.04904182627797127, -0.0030351721215993166, -0.08375783264636993, 0.03846972808241844, 0.048995744436979294, -0.0014249825617298484, -0.0016224549617618322, -0.06712698191404343, 0.07749222964048386, -0.02499740570783615, -0.014446571469306946, -0.022746926173567772, -0.019286349415779114, 0.026174992322921753, -0.012565983459353447, -0.0019538088236004114, -0.00375916576012969, -0.06303855031728745, 0.028228478506207466, -0.05116752162575722, -0.02884605899453163, 0.04070308431982994, 0.027154788374900818, -0.024628151208162308, 0.0479043573141098, -0.012828916311264038, 0.020731959491968155, 0.10953379422426224, -0.04690990597009659, 0.055856555700302124, -0.033921390771865845, 0.007995559833943844, 0.028335126116871834, -0.0024488524068146944, 0.030973531305789948, -0.05780508741736412, -0.024867042899131775, 0.005336301401257515, 0.06132395192980766, 0.001889145583845675, -0.044584691524505615, 0.0020717980805784464, 0.031025582924485207, -0.03350387141108513, 0.021987024694681168, 0.026905950158834457, -0.03144031763076782, -0.027506817132234573, 0.07164301723241806, 0.002980442252010107, 0.023015465587377548, 0.037527650594711304, -0.01100254151970148, 0.01230152789503336, 0.04899882152676582, -0.01895836554467678, 0.00005133534432388842, -0.02833937481045723, 0.05899224057793617, 0.028382861986756325, -0.0727023109793663, 0.01289378385990858, -0.034741148352622986, 0.00896548479795456, -0.04683772101998329, -0.031933531165122986, -0.024373792111873627, 0.0301267858594656, -0.042399074882268906, 0.04879453778266907, -0.00024428038159385324, -0.001698354841209948, -0.025207996368408203, -0.06333650648593903, -0.06388271600008011, 0.009201908484101295, -0.011306478641927242, 0.02774849347770214, 0.05924612283706665, 0.04021245986223221, -0.04201943054795265, -0.008204065263271332, 0.0007168893935158849, -0.007228067610412836, 0.09012610465288162, -0.013405379839241505, -0.018622783944010735, -0.0005434923223219812, -0.048869598656892776, 0.02168196439743042, 0.014380880631506443, -0.030218694359064102, -0.009411721490323544, 0.017451835796236992, -0.05759840086102486, -0.04214578494429588, 0.01200980693101883, -0.027796510607004166, 0.09588906913995743, 0.014817668125033379, -0.029457438737154007, 0.011895820498466492, -0.017682280391454697, -0.024433521553874016, -0.0031517082825303078, -0.040310755372047424, -0.03793678432703018, -0.007502500433474779, 0.026829564943909645, -0.013138607144355774, 0.06437662988901138, -0.011048213578760624, 0.011693472974002361, 0.014913525432348251, -0.01345880702137947, -0.003735171863809228, -0.015400617383420467, 0.03557809442281723, 0.030304059386253357, 0.003266775282099843, 0.01761205680668354, 0.01824413426220417, 0.07614883035421371, 0.04319177195429802, 0.005498714279383421, 0.013264288194477558, 0.05902400612831116, -0.005017308983951807, -0.020049842074513435, 0.07024833559989929, -0.002256296342238784, 0.03488602861762047, -0.009236892685294151, 0.05357132852077484, -0.004141397774219513, -0.04305030032992363, -0.06679842621088028, -0.026623059064149857, 0.027062835171818733, 0.05497109889984131, -0.011696535162627697, 0.045869529247283936, -0.06851732730865479, -0.022565731778740883, 0.03125237673521042, -0.026562262326478958, -0.033303577452898026, -0.013229694217443466, 0.02504570223391056, -0.03330496326088905, 0.024000992998480797, -0.03542497009038925, 0.019659440964460373, 0.04872715845704079, -0.025173526257276535, 0.048485707491636276, 0.017158543691039085, 0.015233289450407028, 0.01892166957259178, -0.018458032980561256, 0.0057150814682245255, -0.0117496307939291, -0.030967075377702713, -0.016417302191257477, 0.03060108982026577, -0.0054676407016813755, -0.028366200625896454, -0.00018888157501351088, 0.03725547716021538, -0.05398223549127579, 0.019943105056881905, 0.0072483886033296585, 0.019034327939152718, -0.0164299625903368, 0.0013002511113882065, 0.03917482867836952, -0.02697034552693367, 0.021783340722322464, 0.008758647367358208, -0.014291512779891491, 0.018559981137514114, -0.024164855480194092, 0.0043888697400689125, -0.07917730510234833, 0.0005362765514291823, 0.019289085641503334, 0.006671528797596693, -0.0028088740073144436, 0.024671636521816254, -0.11221370846033096, 0.02259175106883049, 0.0140183474868536, -0.004290428012609482, 0.008031751960515976, 0.06046655401587486, 0.03231533244252205, 0.004795282147824764, -0.05278920754790306, 0.02070828154683113, 0.014531281776726246, 0.039949484169483185, -0.007579314522445202, 0.0015979313757270575, 0.08409259468317032, -0.04782668501138687, -0.00864518340677023, -0.029351308941841125, -0.0003500512393657118, -0.019744982942938805, -0.007033884059637785, -0.005802322179079056, -0.014784209430217743, 0.053260236978530884, 0.038190219551324844, 0.011960122734308243, 0.04594887048006058, -0.054730840027332306, -0.012349409982562065, -0.07397040724754333, -0.02751108445227146, 0.0016822147881612182, -0.023467522114515305, -0.01273731142282486, 0.096622996032238, 0.06748954206705093, -0.02798677608370781, 0.023816239088773727, -0.009956162422895432, -0.01101534441113472, 0.003185657085850835, -0.01759040728211403, -0.0018456772668287158, 0.04523138329386711, 0.026826312765479088, -0.025758448988199234, -0.0018995227292180061, -0.011611701920628548, -0.00644890870898962, -0.03787219524383545, 0.007075675297528505, 0.03296227753162384, 0.002978333504870534, 0.0199936144053936, 0.059179678559303284, -0.015984268859028816, -0.06693613529205322, 0.03002556413412094, -0.062493741512298584, -0.00844747293740511, -0.0035824032966047525, -0.02835453674197197, -0.04720029979944229, -0.007642295211553574, 0.00861306767910719, -0.03150716423988342, 0.051167044788599014, -0.010783645324409008, 0.06194721534848213, -0.05281064286828041, 0.029978768900036812, -0.01789872534573078, -0.007983317598700523, 0.02557441033422947, 0.022336401045322418, -0.013216061517596245, -0.0027318797074258327, 0.041124336421489716, -0.04895912483334541, -0.006566400174051523, 0.02791396714746952, -0.03767022863030434, -0.05665746331214905, -0.03985530883073807, 0.018453583121299744, -0.0424693338572979, -0.014736698940396309, 0.03968827426433563, 0.012836241163313389, 0.034630484879016876, 0.009213494136929512, -0.030025428161025047, -0.01384439505636692, -0.0038690720684826374, 0.010790515691041946, 0.09029495716094971, 0.01824311912059784, -0.010259498842060566, 0.003525025211274624, -0.022163912653923035, -0.03336598351597786, 0.07775607705116272, -0.002633987460285425, 0.020358461886644363, -0.01738269068300724, 0.04302313178777695, -0.027738984674215317, 0.05766373500227928, -0.017910894006490707, 0.013535701669752598, -0.10739543288946152, -0.05474065616726875, 0.04688414931297302, 0.03237773850560188, -0.06576461344957352, 0.07308490574359894, -0.04686548560857773, -0.04658038169145584, 0.059553444385528564, -0.05952659994363785, 0.018051303923130035, -0.10896777361631393, 0.06361443549394608, -0.008267364464700222, 0.02654392085969448, 0.01132466085255146, 0.052953824400901794, 0.008400874212384224, 0.012382784858345985, 0.030957041308283806, -0.004645729437470436, -0.045201919972896576, 0.010967530310153961, -0.07789004594087601, -0.05103662610054016, 0.011425661854445934, -0.04016485437750816, 0.005732485558837652, 0.024308955296874046, -0.00598004600033164, 0.03379170969128609, 0.020547807216644287, 0.005195364821702242, -0.03470103070139885, 0.025421183556318283, 0.04050438851118088, 0.014334808103740215, -0.03551819920539856, 0.007866510190069675, -0.03180589899420738, 0.006557788699865341, -0.01080322451889515, 0.020633213222026825, 0.01406384538859129, -0.07131675630807877, -0.03263968229293823, 0.009572457522153854, 0.017438706010580063, 0.07159508019685745, 0.008218507282435894, -0.07878249138593674, 0.012167231179773808, 0.013124736957252026, -0.025123964995145798, -0.03738837316632271, -0.0409153588116169, -0.018053138628602028, -0.07859627902507782, -0.02101551927626133, 0.020750954747200012, 0.030545638874173164, 0.014110859483480453, -0.02880867011845112, 0.02044128067791462, 0.02357228845357895, 0.03654537349939346, -0.04904782027006149, 0.023113325238227844, 0.056558024138212204, 0.009743494912981987, -0.03573942929506302, -0.03677932545542717, -0.03653096780180931, -0.06012002006173134, -0.005384089425206184, -0.05555291473865509, -0.030962185934185982, -0.03492259234189987, -0.0435028001666069, -0.030542293563485146, -0.0003375429951120168, -0.019883491098880768, 0.06494781374931335, 0.02690785937011242, -0.0063217380084097385, -0.029469002038240433, -0.03179057314991951, 0.0005013954942114651, -0.006430899258702993, 0.020244762301445007, -0.016839027404785156, 0.05998413637280464, 0.02657017856836319, -0.009194969199597836, 0.05361771583557129, 0.01958979293704033, 0.026872698217630386, 0.07501918077468872, 0.02077321521937847, -0.0370439849793911, -0.047568511217832565, -0.004102788399904966, 0.01957620680332184, -0.05880341678857803, -0.018411140888929367, 0.010298661887645721, -0.009275129064917564, 0.01620785892009735, 0.01742067188024521, 0.004317181650549173, 0.013667265884578228, 0.007969529367983341, -0.005581911187618971, 0.05386216193437576, -0.059705182909965515, -0.015123903751373291, 0.025449510663747787, -0.015902729704976082, -0.028613300994038582, 0.0019634508062154055, 0.020738612860441208, -0.01821833848953247, 0.001701936824247241, 0.0328451432287693, -0.033291347324848175, 0.034990642219781876, -0.030147822573781013, -0.062316328287124634, -0.0008880276582203805, 0.012812390923500061, -0.010855644010007381, -0.0042148372158408165, -0.005956316366791725, -0.018201760947704315, 0.002037529833614826, -0.03455217927694321, 0.03778473287820816, 0.019980384036898613, -0.06485111266374588, -0.016843825578689575, -0.007762654684484005, -0.01994362100958824, 0.014842365868389606, -0.041920654475688934, 0.014135291799902916, 0.06773331761360168, 0.05629811808466911, -0.04052990674972534, -0.0363619364798069, -0.03564527630805969, 0.03547816351056099, 0.11621169745922089, 0.06645750254392624, -0.023558450862765312, 0.01986839435994625, -0.017895057797431946, 0.0401124469935894, 0.035938311368227005, 0.040425945073366165, 0.014478963799774647, -0.031910352408885956, 0.02627858705818653, 0.04214976727962494, -0.027226833626627922, -0.026877829805016518, 0.07807441055774689, -0.02210901491343975, 0.007023169193416834, 0.03499201685190201, 0.00894413236528635, -0.03343995660543442, -0.009330561384558678, -0.004253613296896219, -0.006385728716850281, -0.005435963626950979, -0.003526134416460991, 0.05787640064954758, -0.001403926988132298, -0.002044234424829483, -0.0390569344162941, 0.016745971515774727, 0.039448607712984085, 0.006398445926606655, -0.009487788192927837, 0.02123088203370571, -0.03246751427650452, -0.032376039773225784, 0.0675627738237381, -0.03303110599517822, -0.08093545585870743, 0.016241202130913734, 0.012615850195288658, 0.058997992426157, -0.03265788033604622, 0.015970000997185707, -0.021869689226150513, 0.035122137516736984, -0.008216149173676968, 0.005814219359308481, -0.08635292947292328, -0.014565072022378445, 0.024263184517621994, 0.020616136491298676, -0.05424708127975464, -0.024400195106863976, -0.004870382137596607, 0.024542661383748055, 0.027366923168301582, -0.011250234209001064, -0.056351058185100555, -0.025369049981236458, 0.058274045586586, -0.019746029749512672, 0.03481532260775566, 0.007497915532439947, 0.051269255578517914, 0.127052903175354, -0.02955414354801178, 0.04716169461607933, -0.009128192439675331, 0.004362632520496845, 0.011506268754601479, -0.08046124875545502, -0.020386526361107826, 0.054321832954883575, -0.037226296961307526, 0.01466399896889925, 0.016121793538331985, -0.004131910391151905, 0.02979983761906624, -0.001691819867119193, -0.01394463051110506, -0.026227766647934914, 0.06366557627916336, -0.023601800203323364, -0.003734043100848794, -0.01900547556579113, 0.011617032811045647, -0.06573212891817093, -0.01332371961325407, 0.0036808087024837732, -0.0018488974310457706, -0.01087799109518528, -0.04714766517281532, 0.0053649903275072575, 0.024881800636649132, -0.012059338390827179, -0.033875834196805954, -0.030003922060132027, 0.010744461789727211, 0.03013308160007, -0.027132824063301086, -0.014752821996808052, 0.01908268965780735, 0.0207444466650486, -0.012819920666515827, -0.05726660415530205, -0.031384214758872986, 0.019899873062968254, -0.02353654056787491, -0.06849965453147888, -0.02123764529824257, -0.012850671075284481, 0.032236792147159576, 0.003308143699541688, -0.03623473644256592, 0.00007777928840368986, -0.004536244086921215, 0.01271652802824974, 0.004962940700352192, -0.07131679356098175, 0.0038357425946742296, 0.042447250336408615, 0.04540640115737915, 0.04925708845257759, 0.02956060878932476, 0.0007332426612265408, 0.030006801709532738, -0.027999067679047585, -0.01969159208238125, 0.05621252581477165, -0.04538504406809807, 0.008746648207306862, 0.02966597117483616, 0.03436814248561859, -0.007495335303246975, -0.011526188813149929, -0.03915400803089142, 0.04563109204173088, -0.01618855446577072, 0.012048579752445221, 0.0370977446436882, 0.02829030342400074, -0.045263372361660004, 0.04077845811843872, 0.03593970462679863, -0.02938668243587017, -0.05016753450036049, -0.01633896492421627, -0.015892352908849716, -0.027906978502869606, -0.027157466858625412, 0.02267793007194996, -0.031518690288066864, 0.044467631727457047, 0.002479931805282831, -0.028836505487561226, -0.01923726126551628, -0.045291535556316376, -0.02569919265806675, 0.0016464689979329705, -0.06097862124443054, -0.009547923691570759, -0.026010766625404358, -0.07815516740083694, 0.020938411355018616, 0.011545752175152302, 0.05544070899486542, -0.05350136756896973, -0.02727590501308441, -0.009905287995934486, 0.011183333583176136, 0.015095341950654984, -0.021672893315553665, 0.06620872020721436, 0.01863854005932808, -0.02909625507891178, 0.0353262796998024, -0.00034596610930748284, -0.01839006319642067, -0.01183836255222559, 0.023073937743902206, 0.03716938570141792, 0.042196620255708694, -0.0001435346348444, 0.015833500772714615, 0.030669353902339935, -0.043743714690208435, -0.047692567110061646, -0.033561281859874725, 0.07468624413013458, 0.04756084084510803, -0.001197019126266241, -0.030590737238526344, -0.01940883696079254 ]
<ol> <li><p>If you were to draw a person on a Minkowski diagram, that was unmoving (though time was still passing) what would that look like? (As a light cone and ignore the observer.) <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/3y46m.jpg" alt="Minkowski diagram"></p></li> <li><p>Also what would it look like if you drew a person looking into a black hole (at a safe distance) but NOT accelerating away? (also as a light cone)</p></li> </ol>
g7451
[ -0.0044387332163751125, 0.026784950867295265, 0.016534876078367233, -0.07779641449451447, -0.007283274549990892, 0.05164336785674095, 0.02609279192984104, 0.009611234068870544, 0.0033722282387316227, -0.020487122237682343, 0.031112130731344223, -0.04702175036072731, 0.0572577565908432, -0.02916213497519493, -0.0054868548177182674, 0.01093710120767355, 0.076261505484581, -0.08358142524957657, 0.016451748088002205, -0.057930611073970795, 0.06234084442257881, 0.010476130060851574, 0.009150130674242973, -0.03761311247944832, 0.0025654875207692385, -0.07754382491111755, 0.054935432970523834, -0.03130511939525604, -0.08533766865730286, -0.030395951122045517, 0.05854782089591026, 0.02360004186630249, -0.028441283851861954, -0.024429459124803543, 0.002281845547258854, -0.02591073140501976, 0.025430461391806602, 0.04054085165262222, 0.03583947569131851, 0.05688214674592018, 0.0021753928158432245, -0.00020374606538098305, -0.021091803908348083, -0.04423778876662254, 0.005874039139598608, -0.018851973116397858, 0.006163076963275671, 0.03132861852645874, 0.008943467400968075, 0.05980779603123665, -0.042468924075365067, 0.010056404396891594, 0.020070059224963188, 0.007272862363606691, 0.030665727332234383, 0.055929034948349, 0.022159432992339134, -0.057042162865400314, 0.05975663289427757, 0.01753096841275692, -0.05122959613800049, -0.027279667556285858, 0.024258961901068687, 0.00643431069329381, 0.02287650853395462, -0.025320259854197502, -0.05542870983481407, -0.0070527540519833565, -0.017872165888547897, -0.012742594815790653, 0.013389596715569496, 0.02035117708146572, -0.03400597348809242, -0.007925891317427158, -0.022488169372081757, 0.06029793992638588, -0.05496213957667351, -0.022547544911503792, 0.049479927867650986, 0.04184560850262642, -0.07866270840167999, -0.016595888882875443, -0.0326550118625164, -0.00013409422535914928, 0.15028740465641022, 0.0025144151877611876, 0.007066207472234964, -0.03216218575835228, -0.06405889987945557, 0.016908807680010796, 0.048661425709724426, -0.024538492783904076, 0.10054682940244675, -0.009814972057938576, 0.0036551267839968204, -0.013258170336484909, -0.02458285726606846, 0.001926247961819172, -0.01949606090784073, 0.034964580088853836, -0.047653283923864365, -0.04089692234992981, -0.02070665918290615, 0.04041631892323494, 0.05338272824883461, -0.03348737582564354, 0.017490115016698837, -0.0022655781358480453, 0.011525955982506275, -0.006774140056222677, -0.0278070867061615, -0.0938786044716835, -0.006192905828356743, -0.03542400896549225, -0.004651638679206371, -0.08685143291950226, 0.025426696985960007, 0.002844685222953558, 0.020675724372267723, 0.038984186947345734, 0.05098410323262215, 0.01954898238182068, 0.02869059331715107, 0.00944388099014759, 0.01999753527343273, 0.034075308591127396, -0.03302078694105148, -0.04625653848052025, -0.010130186565220356, -0.01359954010695219, 0.028576843440532684, 0.022708863019943237, 0.008138376288115978, 0.09612441807985306, -0.08651028573513031, 0.04711264744400978, -0.009955394081771374, 0.03090781532227993, -0.0027011395432054996, 0.012196261435747147, 0.07344605773687363, -0.07421089708805084, -0.051354363560676575, 0.002688691718503833, -0.016780316829681396, -0.0544762946665287, -0.005456868093460798, -0.018117092549800873, 0.026683522388339043, 0.015954120084643364, -0.048522692173719406, 0.03395235165953636, 0.03374352678656578, -0.002076616743579507, 0.027189143002033234, -0.00036762034869752824, 0.04691609740257263, 0.0531778559088707, -0.031260643154382706, -0.021356718614697456, 0.0537441112101078, -0.0018670528661459684, 0.027837662026286125, 0.03328441455960274, -0.07593968510627747, -0.035789549350738525, 0.005926379002630711, -0.0560745932161808, 0.06960742920637131, -0.08684483915567398, -0.011554506607353687, -0.03971804678440094, 0.010478674434125423, 0.006175493821501732, -0.0013845765497535467, -0.019460037350654602, 0.017474345862865448, 0.0058943103067576885, 0.017796607688069344, 0.02822759933769703, 0.012885634787380695, -0.05166642740368843, 0.0074768392369151115, -0.03725602850317955, -0.008444726467132568, -0.0969569981098175, -0.053468044847249985, 0.029424212872982025, -0.032480038702487946, 0.02532804012298584, 0.015702174976468086, -0.053453367203474045, -0.023442432284355164, 0.0526810847222805, -0.007759138476103544, -0.01996038854122162, 0.07066424936056137, 0.019449174404144287, 0.01827280968427658, 0.033154431730508804, -0.01063563209027052, -0.020985061302781105, 0.02893301099538803, 0.008405395783483982, -0.023395581170916557, 0.01913762278854847, -0.027073271572589874, 0.01539838220924139, -0.010723366402089596, -0.04650888964533806, 0.019493944942951202, 0.011150439269840717, 0.03227483108639717, -0.04968004301190376, -0.11610502749681473, 0.05318472534418106, -0.015027455054223537, 0.01877768337726593, -0.014917136169970036, 0.049377188086509705, 0.01729660853743553, -0.026291443035006523, -0.018779272213578224, -0.0141395078971982, 0.009355488233268261, -0.037305839359760284, -0.060816440731287, -0.08464135974645615, 0.011645128019154072, 0.005500560160726309, -0.07217264920473099, -0.03421025723218918, 0.010964754037559032, 0.04741525650024414, 0.011085812933743, 0.017598021775484085, -0.0028157243505120277, 0.05329848453402519, 0.039127327501773834, -0.017542453482747078, -0.003602626034989953, 0.02631809376180172, -0.005099527537822723, -0.051334090530872345, 0.011895484291017056, -0.01984337717294693, 0.012148460373282433, -0.0072197443805634975, -0.048465874046087265, 0.07029636949300766, -0.027979537844657898, -0.001242969068698585, -0.004019394051283598, 0.025959432125091553, 0.020530670881271362, 0.036885447800159454, -0.02745279110968113, 0.027307849377393723, -0.11375142633914948, -0.010941632091999054, 0.0184331052005291, -0.023855160921812057, -0.08647038042545319, -0.013322325423359871, -0.01884392648935318, 0.016687937080860138, 0.022396771237254143, 0.017321160063147545, 0.03274175524711609, 0.023842860013246536, -0.01541062444448471, 0.004014845471829176, -0.013984679244458675, 0.034731313586235046, -0.01810947246849537, 0.014383595436811447, -0.01201839093118906, -0.010803761892020702, -0.04352455958724022, 0.02699281834065914, 0.026418108493089676, 0.021935908123850822, -0.06542867422103882, 0.04402650520205498, 0.04111843556165695, -0.06283172965049744, 0.04783669859170914, 0.03571847453713417, -0.023705413565039635, 0.03384049981832504, -0.06464030593633652, 0.05906488373875618, 0.05548834055662155, 0.024029245600104332, -0.04776332899928093, 0.008946897462010384, 0.0033479745034128428, 0.0006097368896007538, -0.0018079541623592377, 0.012946322560310364, 0.0062810201197862625, -0.04132213070988655, -0.008720185607671738, 0.03480678051710129, 0.003573305904865265, -0.06622014939785004, -0.014705732464790344, -0.0713648572564125, 0.055431388318538666, -0.004924087319523096, 0.025586241856217384, 0.011666650883853436, -0.019959595054388046, 0.04695027694106102, 0.015887439250946045, 0.00804049801081419, -0.03134432062506676, 0.0424240417778492, 0.018866833299398422, -0.018438275903463364, 0.04220261052250862, 0.035715118050575256, 0.018863022327423096, 0.044133130460977554, 0.026925906538963318, 0.008082387037575245, 0.06681863963603973, 0.010542805306613445, -0.037461891770362854, 0.03917580470442772, -0.005133355967700481, -0.041901521384716034, -0.009582468308508396, -0.0030944612808525562, 0.017214857041835785, 0.020579682663083076, -0.05495604872703552, -0.010446238331496716, 0.026053309440612793, -0.03779139742255211, 0.03859430551528931, -0.04537048935890198, -0.042463477700948715, -0.00986887514591217, 0.05256420001387596, -0.03177927806973457, 0.005087693687528372, -0.03827480971813202, 0.03726993501186371, -0.036975931376218796, 0.038080763071775436, -0.04849594831466675, 0.015206750482320786, -0.04299498349428177, 0.05440052971243858, -0.04767573997378349, -0.021831976249814034, 0.009445341303944588, 0.013219206593930721, -0.013136228546500206, -0.036558397114276886, 0.04252086579799652, 0.0000600684761593584, -0.003364413045346737, 0.05051249638199806, 0.007997287437319756, -0.011412681080400944, 0.04695607349276543, 0.04808509349822998, -0.005652454681694508, 0.03935704007744789, 0.03212549164891243, -0.02610771171748638, 0.013009578920900822, -0.010230330750346184, -0.019509809091687202, 0.018626898527145386, 0.02356150932610035, -0.00037814147071912885, 0.07031543552875519, -0.00035113285412080586, -0.028532972559332848, -0.011579399928450584, -0.03469453006982803, 0.014023445546627045, 0.04181654378771782, 0.0018015875248238444, -0.0563250407576561, -0.00565165001899004, -0.0188914705067873, -0.005038856528699398, -0.05858023837208748, 0.003145023249089718, -0.032100167125463486, 0.0061702909879386425, -0.01928872987627983, 0.013981547206640244, -0.02129940502345562, 0.012745299376547337, -0.012962614186108112, 0.017019152641296387, 0.0343887098133564, 0.03618505969643593, 0.03393946588039398, 0.0058820899575948715, -0.0004339572333265096, -0.05011577159166336, -0.004379546269774437, 0.038605690002441406, -0.026187673211097717, 0.003854075213894248, 0.0018370315665379167, -0.025939667597413063, -0.059233158826828, -0.011660163290798664, 0.0076913125813007355, 0.0590185783803463, 0.029382314532995224, -0.051926251500844955, 0.054271161556243896, 0.0026454352773725986, 0.049918558448553085, -0.00416926434263587, 0.020560890436172485, -0.011068868450820446, 0.04747062921524048, 0.02425328828394413, -0.036311350762844086, -0.06225037947297096, -0.034733422100543976, 0.03546199947595596, 0.03196226805448532, -0.0667693018913269, 0.01374325342476368, -0.00575472554191947, 0.034639641642570496, 0.03186221420764923, 0.022163137793540955, 0.02812381647527218, 0.03509058430790901, 0.015275429002940655, -0.015006017871201038, 0.0668066143989563, -0.060458697378635406, -0.039345934987068176, 0.023607345297932625, 0.0022725812159478664, -0.020196253433823586, 0.03191269189119339, 0.017015187069773674, -0.0389704704284668, 0.010122528299689293, -0.03568555414676666, -0.0028105650562793016, -0.011491099372506142, -0.007843242958188057, 0.013482274487614632, -0.012698493897914886, -0.02703034318983555, -0.0020400427747517824, -0.029285140335559845, -0.027398115023970604, 0.025267846882343292, -0.035586051642894745, -0.010346404276788235, -0.00009754967322805896, -0.05910283699631691, -0.010201132856309414, -0.010878481902182102, -0.02455986849963665, -0.050453219562768936, 0.011935287155210972, 0.04957569018006325, -0.007894942536950111, -0.04640759155154228, 0.057023897767066956, -0.03221890330314636, 0.05012084171175957, 0.005342177115380764, 0.00048221086035482585, -0.0008403927786275744, 0.035672347992658615, 0.043219178915023804, -0.07508692145347595, 0.02297092229127884, 0.011453649029135704, -0.024964816868305206, 0.05280474200844765, 0.0015820221742615104, 0.03213367983698845, 0.04129580408334732, -0.008671925403177738, 0.006418555974960327, 0.0036381722893565893, -0.01282456610351801, 0.013318434357643127, 0.02583470195531845, 0.04583481326699257, 0.03127365931868553, 0.025462578982114792, -0.08180387318134308, -0.011253338307142258, 0.033597465604543686, -0.06993064284324646, -0.02524474263191223, 0.039260897785425186, 0.02699129283428192, -0.043004587292671204, 0.057344481348991394, 0.12610341608524323, -0.03373413532972336, 0.04669167846441269, 0.009270346723496914, 0.00390983372926712, -0.018384968861937523, -0.03872504085302353, -0.06837578862905502, -0.004567713011056185, -0.009977437555789948, -0.0505586676299572, 0.02564975805580616, 0.009415609762072563, 0.040338627994060516, 0.027010628953576088, 0.07910347729921341, 0.048211149871349335, 0.0006971443071961403, -0.018191881477832794, 0.03069998137652874, 0.009157025255262852, 0.019603202119469643, -0.009478511288762093, 0.025760909542441368, -0.03335922583937645, 0.014923186041414738, -0.0034417256247252226, 0.051983609795570374, 0.0038058366626501083, 0.07597492635250092, -0.011351332999765873, -0.04116753488779068, 0.026355164125561714, -0.01321800984442234, 0.07858897745609283, 0.0009246469708159566, -0.027492858469486237, -0.006509615108370781, 0.04889701306819916, 0.024854321032762527, -0.044099222868680954, -0.05159526318311691, 0.022845525294542313, -0.013503849506378174, 0.09165139496326447, -0.012034623883664608, -0.0000224771247303579, -0.012182123959064484, -0.012028253637254238, -0.05066675320267677, -0.005593685898929834, 0.05339369550347328, -0.04152075573801994, 0.015406074933707714, 0.030821645632386208, -0.003798849880695343, -0.06654007732868195, 0.021757107228040695, 0.02333616465330124, 0.057322755455970764, 0.01206369511783123, 0.020107386633753777, -0.07507123053073883, 0.01628527231514454, 0.0051977732218801975, -0.02591145969927311, 0.034177057445049286, 0.00767646636813879, 0.021917741745710373, -0.037947170436382294, 0.03582540154457092, -0.05039285868406296, 0.01974461041390896, 0.037568505853414536, -0.041063204407691956, -0.06025215983390808, 0.03776171803474426, 0.006444726139307022, 0.028013925999403, 0.03739922121167183, 0.007827360183000565, -0.014859815128147602, -0.005737298633903265, 0.03031185455620289, -0.016590025275945663, -0.056289561092853546, 0.01550650130957365, -0.044013384729623795, -0.03558063879609108, -0.07730328291654587, 0.020560963079333305, -0.03645682334899902, 0.015878107398748398, -0.03744872659444809, 0.03525206074118614, 0.05116008222103119, 0.06175069883465767, -0.06299585849046707, 0.004823422059416771, -0.0026904400438070297, -0.046341877430677414, -0.013410291634500027, 0.053947772830724716, 0.004519148264080286, 0.028097286820411682, -0.003360702656209469, 0.03596626594662666, -0.028905827552080154, -0.015420768409967422, -0.05329103395342827, -0.03985297679901123, 0.06876741349697113, -0.007587640546262264, 0.0012218245537951589, 0.028766678646206856, -0.057769641280174255, 0.0234761331230402, -0.05166233330965042, 0.0034692115150392056, 0.008694828487932682, 0.015402409248054028, 0.026386752724647522, -0.041862279176712036, 0.016928577795624733, 0.054423801600933075, 0.06797371059656143, 0.015027284622192383, -0.032452166080474854, 0.03760893642902374, 0.03081219457089901, 0.010510848835110664, 0.012470174580812454, 0.03815148025751114, 0.028666673228144646, -0.0402398556470871, -0.010225851088762283, -0.04269417002797127, 0.006950657814741135, 0.042271677404642105, -0.04115748032927513, -0.044062115252017975, -0.013641124591231346, -0.02954818867146969, -0.03216882795095444, 0.012207531370222569, -0.011042692698538303, -0.006422737147659063, -0.010851697064936161, 0.024084296077489853, -0.002204990480095148, -0.05394890531897545, -0.022647233679890633, 0.02925296314060688, -0.0495506189763546, -0.04877232015132904, -0.0070185353979468346, 0.008041494525969028, -0.0008892659679986537, -0.02497672848403454, -0.08659136295318604, 0.018371904268860817, -0.0436406135559082, -0.05606997013092041, -0.04952993243932724, 0.03754769265651703, -0.03083920106291771, -0.020340418443083763, -0.062341902405023575, 0.05991197004914284, -0.009240158833563328, 0.007567220833152533, 0.034020788967609406, 0.038749128580093384, -0.01442644838243723, 0.037546735256910324, -0.014822198078036308, 0.04330853000283241, 0.008670217357575893, -0.028585046529769897, -0.029457343742251396, 0.0071397386491298676, 0.015557881444692612, 0.06063206493854523, -0.03470795974135399, -0.04377037659287453, 0.027076078578829765, -0.008581922389566898, -0.0015317818615585566, 0.01727871783077717, -0.0030249650590121746, -0.03561658412218094, -0.0010496684117242694, 0.014857313595712185, 0.0005004431586712599, -0.012509767897427082, -0.0026392999570816755, -0.0171179361641407, -0.023777633905410767, -0.027506129816174507, -0.020659834146499634, -0.005317268893122673, 0.01931625045835972, 0.04676923155784607, 0.018625326454639435, -0.024569354951381683, -0.03110741265118122, 0.014255835674703121, -0.02447240613400936, 0.033460527658462524, -0.015189859084784985, 0.01814992167055607, -0.00390853313729167, 0.013172834180295467, -0.015902968123555183, -0.046241797506809235, 0.011827175505459309, -0.0035469636786729097, -0.03258846327662468, 0.045129500329494476, -0.01725170388817787, -0.06029876321554184, 0.026668136939406395, 0.01334495097398758, -0.05338157340884209, 0.03635159507393837, -0.03053423762321472, 0.006588433403521776, -0.017370447516441345, 0.04143165796995163, 0.022297894582152367, -0.0068868049420416355, -0.03796952962875366, -0.03962288424372673, 0.008768545463681221, -0.009472951292991638, 0.045630767941474915, -0.0025541388895362616, 0.02099573239684105, -0.002465627621859312, 0.003914903849363327, 0.029137102887034416, 0.037044458091259, 0.001717744511552155, -0.054489314556121826, 0.003838082542642951, 0.06482452154159546, 0.02780400961637497, -0.01929418370127678, -0.02143433876335621, 0.0049146744422614574, -0.010535575449466705, -0.043028924614191055, -0.042749833315610886, -0.02283104695379734, 0.0231384988874197, 0.024562455713748932, -0.05878007784485817, -0.012836160138249397, -0.005266265477985144 ]
<p>I'm trying to understand Noether's theorem, and it's application to gauge symmetry. Below what I've done so far. </p> <p>First, the global gauge symmetry. I'm starting with the Lagragian $$L_{1}=\partial^{\mu}\Psi\partial_{\mu}\Psi^{\ast}-m^{2}\left|\Psi\right|^{2}$$ with classical complex fields. This Lagragian is invariant with respect to the global gauge symmetry $\Psi\rightarrow\tilde{\Psi}=e^{\mathbf{i}\theta}\Psi$, ... such that I end up with $$\delta S=\int dv\left[\dfrac{\delta L_{1}}{\delta\Psi}\delta\Psi+\dfrac{\delta L_{1}}{\delta\Psi^{\ast}}\delta\Psi^{\ast}+\mathbf{i}\left(\Psi\partial^{\mu}\Psi^{\ast}-\Psi^{\ast}\partial^{\mu}\Psi\right)\partial_{\mu}\delta\theta\right]=\int dv\left[\partial_{\mu}j^{\mu}\right]\delta\theta$$ provided the equations of motion ($\delta L / \delta \Psi = 0$, ...) are valid. All along I'm using that $$\dfrac{\delta L}{\delta\phi}=\dfrac{\partial L}{\partial\phi}-\partial_{\mu}\dfrac{\partial L}{\partial\left[\partial_{\mu}\phi\right]}$$ and that $\int dv=\int d^{3}xdt$ for short. The conserved current is of course $$j_{1}^{\mu}=\mathbf{i}\left(\Psi^{\ast}\partial^{\mu}\Psi-\Psi\partial^{\mu}\Psi^{\ast}\right)$$ since $\delta S / \delta \theta =0 \Rightarrow\partial_{\mu}j_{1}^{\mu}=0$. </p> <p><strong>Here is my first question:</strong> Is this really the demonstration for conservation of charge ? Up to now, it seems to me that I only demonstrated that the particle number is conserved, there is no charge for the moment... </p> <p>Then, I switch to the local gauge symmetry. I'm starting with the following Lagrangian $$L_{2}=\left(\partial^{\mu}+\mathbf{i}qA^{\mu}\right)\Psi\left(\partial_{\mu}-\mathbf{i}qA_{\mu}\right)\Psi^{\ast} -m^{2}\left|\Psi\right|^{2} -\dfrac{F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}}{4}$$ with $F^{\mu\nu}=\partial^{\mu}A^{\nu}-\partial^{\nu}A^{\mu}$. This Lagrangian is invariant with respect to the local gauge transformation $$L_{2}\left[\tilde{\Psi}=e^{\mathbf{i}q\varphi\left(x\right)}\Psi\left(x\right),\tilde{\Psi}^{\ast}=e^{-\mathbf{i}q\varphi\left(x\right)}\Psi^{\ast},\tilde{A}_{\mu}=A_{\mu}-\partial_{\mu}\varphi\right]=L_{2}\left[\Psi,\Psi^{\ast},A_{\mu}\right]$$</p> <p>Then I have $$\delta S=\int dv\left[\dfrac{\delta L_{2}}{\delta\Psi}\delta\Psi+\dfrac{\delta L_{2}}{\delta\Psi^{\ast}}\delta\Psi^{\ast}+\dfrac{\delta L_{2}}{\delta A_{\mu}}\delta A_{\mu}\right]$$ with $\delta\Psi=\mathbf{i}q\Psi\delta\varphi$, $\delta A_{\mu}=-\partial_{\mu}\delta\varphi$, ... such that I end up with $$\dfrac{\delta S}{\delta\varphi}=\int dv\left[\mathbf{i}q\Psi\dfrac{\delta L_{2}}{\delta\Psi}+c.c.+\partial_{\mu}\left[j_{2}^{\mu}-\partial_{\nu}F^{\nu\mu}\right]\right]$$ with $j_{2}^{\mu}=\partial L_{2}/\partial A_{\mu}$ and $F^{\nu\mu}=\partial L_{2}/\partial\left[\partial_{\nu}A_{\mu}\right]$</p> <p>Then, by application of the equations of motion, I have $$\partial_{\mu}\left[j_{2}^{\mu}-\partial_{\nu}F^{\nu\mu}\right]=0\Rightarrow\partial_{\mu}j_{2}^{\mu}=0$$ since $\partial_{\mu}\partial_{\nu}F^{\nu\mu}=0$ by construction. Of course the new current is $$j_{2}^{\mu}=\mathbf{i}q\left(\Psi^{\ast}\left(\partial^{\mu}+\mathbf{i}qA^{\mu}\right)\Psi-\Psi\left(\partial^{\mu}-\mathbf{i}qA^{\mu}\right)\Psi^{\ast}\right)$$ and is explicitly dependent on the charge. So it seems to me this one is a better candidate for the conservation of charge.</p> <p>NB: As remarked in <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0009058" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0009058</a>, Eq.(27) one can also suppose the Maxwell's equations to be valid ($j_{2}^{\mu}-\partial_{\nu}F^{\nu\mu} = 0$, since they are also part of the equation of motion after all, I'll come later to this point, which sounds weird to me), and we end up with the same current, once again conserved.</p> <p>Nevertheless, I still have some troubles. Indeed, if I abruptly calculate the equations of motions from the Lagrangian, I end up with (for the $A_{\mu}$ equation of motion) $$j_{2}^{\mu}-\partial_{\nu}F^{\nu\mu}\Rightarrow\partial_{\mu}j_{2}^{\mu}=0$$ by definition of the $F^{\mu \nu}$ tensor. </p> <p>So, my <strong>other questions</strong>: Is there a better way to show the conservation of EM charge ? Is there something wrong with what I did so far ? Why the Noether theorem does not seem to give me something which are not in the equations of motions ? said differently: Why should I use the Noether machinery for something which is intrinsically implemented in the Lagrangian, and thus in the equations of motion for the independent fields ? (Is it because my Lagrangian is too simple ? Is it due to the multiple boundary terms I cancel ?)</p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p> <p>PS: I've the feeling that part of the answer would be in the difference between what high-energy physicists call "on-shell" and "off-shell" structure. So far, I never understood the difference. That's should be my last question today :-)</p>
g7452
[ 0.04938557744026184, -0.054061923176050186, -0.008727863430976868, -0.03498591482639313, 0.03538410738110542, 0.018697619438171387, 0.11333029717206955, 0.045812688767910004, -0.03449791669845581, 0.01886884868144989, -0.011347482912242413, 0.017890384420752525, 0.0037931555416435003, 0.017975548282265663, 0.012813636101782322, 0.00731634208932519, 0.0703907385468483, -0.014235450886189938, 0.04053347185254097, -0.012880752794444561, -0.021511148661375046, -0.006487835198640823, 0.01775161176919937, -0.028391586616635323, 0.007458504755049944, 0.030862169340252876, 0.049900785088539124, -0.010731839574873447, -0.018325896933674812, -0.10845854878425598, 0.031090321019291878, -0.013715723529458046, 0.045901551842689514, -0.0249237772077322, -0.039424870163202286, -0.010341105982661247, 0.03934444114565849, 0.009629667736589909, 0.030747881159186363, 0.0052229720167815685, 0.041363973170518875, -0.021748075261712074, 0.03002081997692585, -0.0010388868395239115, 0.009807636961340904, -0.02367219142615795, -0.0692211389541626, -0.06921113282442093, -0.052509501576423645, 0.01611282117664814, 0.06417790800333023, 0.01928049698472023, 0.008265986107289791, -0.04885262995958328, -0.008127402514219284, -0.014406959526240826, 0.009500621818006039, 0.013507376424968243, 0.003120436565950513, 0.008608797565102577, -0.02606372721493244, -0.032781124114990234, -0.03098311461508274, 0.031997788697481155, 0.012973355129361153, -0.04407677799463272, -0.05736693739891052, -0.020754793658852577, 0.013287532143294811, 0.04781579598784447, -0.05877372622489929, -0.006045210175216198, 0.018387099727988243, -0.0020171336364001036, 0.008284389041364193, 0.03440738841891289, -0.032692402601242065, 0.030465906485915184, 0.038312457501888275, -0.043272022157907486, -0.08348751068115234, -0.003986136056482792, 0.00489311246201396, 0.058855120092630386, 0.051109783351421356, -0.06592804193496704, -0.06917645782232285, -0.03566085547208786, 0.007971434853971004, 0.014333316124975681, 0.030954688787460327, -0.02408057078719139, 0.0188337042927742, -0.025561144575476646, 0.04813069850206375, 0.01728873886168003, 0.02927577681839466, 0.04902981221675873, -0.0027898370753973722, -0.03841244429349899, -0.016094746068120003, -0.002663263352587819, -0.003921678755432367, 0.054297178983688354, 0.041856549680233, 0.04779769107699394, 0.026409205049276352, 0.011666564270853996, -0.023161791265010834, 0.04487186297774315, -0.0029538734816014767, -0.03615683317184448, -0.016680439934134483, 0.006002394482493401, -0.05427956581115723, 0.02965126559138298, -0.024871839210391045, -0.054125670343637466, 0.01471948903053999, 0.0332159698009491, 0.0485355518758297, 0.017202278599143028, 0.05101413279771805, -0.00847707036882639, 0.011477681808173656, 0.005010304972529411, -0.04134061560034752, 0.0028314541559666395, 0.0508120059967041, -0.012895517982542515, 0.0026499286759644747, 0.009985110722482204, 0.013081853277981281, -0.008303568698465824, -0.005489780101925135, -0.009184557944536209, 0.02733713574707508, 0.08373217284679413, 0.02824542112648487, 0.011064951308071613, -0.01221524178981781, -0.0370868556201458, 0.005312442779541016, -0.02706138975918293, -0.023706810548901558, 0.015214227139949799, -0.022534511983394623, -0.023396607488393784, 0.03465668112039566, -0.021231800317764282, 0.017991729080677032, 0.07554589956998825, 0.039859648793935776, 0.02658701129257679, 0.030395327135920525, -0.022736351937055588, 0.04969348758459091, -0.04104747995734215, -0.013019397854804993, -0.025889966636896133, 0.03267494589090347, -0.04583657532930374, 0.04847720265388489, 0.027044303715229034, 0.0029370624106377363, 0.007199060171842575, 0.03290943428874016, -0.06371466815471649, 0.0032326204236596823, -0.1132013350725174, -0.04670420289039612, 0.012222496792674065, 0.029927192255854607, 0.03130539506673813, -0.0009104645578190684, 0.037403710186481476, -0.03872070834040642, -0.04514584317803383, 0.0036053776275366545, -0.03911947086453438, -0.03205517306923866, -0.023286698386073112, 0.059880826622247696, -0.011219051666557789, -0.031551141291856766, 0.020524008199572563, 0.029479270800948143, 0.013372872956097126, -0.0195526871830225, 0.026298871263861656, -0.022729313001036644, 0.05698354169726372, -0.02394036389887333, 0.07282699644565582, -0.013570282608270645, 0.026270238682627678, 0.022336473688483238, -0.05141386017203331, -0.0788445845246315, 0.0024140016175806522, -0.0005940974806435406, 0.01878979429602623, 0.023864086717367172, -0.02678021974861622, 0.03858289495110512, -0.04536643996834755, -0.032941967248916626, -0.053059302270412445, 0.022444074973464012, 0.03063567355275154, 0.029474517330527306, -0.049490220844745636, -0.01593908667564392, -0.03953742980957031, 0.00041571137262508273, -0.02710610255599022, 0.004436023533344269, -0.01674356311559677, -0.06524895131587982, 0.00068845902569592, 0.00806676410138607, -0.005097541958093643, 0.03347344323992729, 0.027462201192975044, -0.018662039190530777, 0.0504368357360363, -0.007375255227088928, 0.007649204693734646, -0.034043312072753906, 0.05176922678947449, -0.04067370295524597, 0.03575814142823219, 0.010524324141442776, 0.027773629873991013, 0.06989233940839767, 0.04568273201584816, -0.03560570254921913, -0.03136639669537544, 0.035121653228998184, 0.01596110500395298, 0.048084307461977005, -0.015784867107868195, -0.018753647804260254, -0.0017386162653565407, 0.07723851501941681, 0.08229967206716537, 0.0406154990196228, 0.014499861747026443, -0.00694193784147501, -0.02549617365002632, -0.021738016977906227, -0.06039929762482643, 0.003597527975216508, -0.002038580598309636, 0.036833807826042175, -0.040252573788166046, 0.04660489037632942, 0.0007829979876987636, 0.023671049624681473, -0.005315693095326424, 0.016601430252194405, 0.005607529543340206, -0.026130395010113716, 0.014177065342664719, -0.042391709983348846, -0.022824980318546295, 0.009421348571777344, 0.023255016654729843, 0.018786272034049034, -0.0230453759431839, -0.002974968869239092, 0.05577012524008751, 0.012547602877020836, 0.04483860358595848, -0.014391161501407623, 0.002053032163530588, 0.01091215293854475, -0.01867850124835968, 0.039762213826179504, -0.05202525109052658, 0.016215981915593147, 0.011771775782108307, -0.008484316989779472, -0.020172031596302986, 0.04623885825276375, -0.06288672238588333, 0.001546295010484755, -0.0026035287883132696, 0.0003592059656511992, 0.04904691129922867, 0.00041627330938354135, 0.04781351983547211, 0.048468273133039474, 0.02504992112517357, -0.020760558545589447, -0.02386338636279106, -0.045270323753356934, -0.06284013390541077, -0.03350953757762909, -0.013540995307266712, 0.018686341121792793, -0.05782979726791382, -0.012087289243936539, 0.05455676466226578, 0.05358832702040672, -0.011209409683942795, -0.03034846857190132, -0.0007921546930447221, 0.01645912043750286, 0.028849028050899506, -0.01630663126707077, -0.009197421371936798, -0.01739429123699665, -0.026451092213392258, -0.0411565937101841, -0.009097681380808353, -0.01268650870770216, -0.010532934218645096, -0.009836181998252869, -0.03886603191494942, -0.01669333688914776, -0.015458608977496624, -0.009710771031677723, 0.00355112599208951, 0.02110019512474537, 0.010237496346235275, -0.0685957819223404, 0.029611242935061455, -0.016154449433088303, 0.007975275628268719, -0.012805753387510777, 0.032434701919555664, -0.005093872081488371, -0.05814678594470024, 0.0038678180426359177, -0.059039708226919174, -0.06282459944486618, -0.0058517842553555965, 0.046869855374097824, -0.009590370580554008, -0.06634019315242767, -0.001148765441030264, -0.09565893560647964, 0.026415593922138214, -0.01223489735275507, -0.030929336324334145, -0.027765575796365738, -0.05436799302697182, -0.02551928721368313, -0.015609894879162312, -0.01905742846429348, -0.05043599382042885, 0.009408069774508476, -0.016308404505252838, 0.004564631264656782, -0.026726940646767616, 0.03337419405579567, 0.027526777237653732, -0.02442670613527298, 0.03812989592552185, 0.016275441274046898, -0.017784802243113518, -0.05719007924199104, 0.00031516567105427384, 0.009649594314396381, 0.011846395209431648, -0.039231184870004654, -0.025596672669053078, -0.007793411146849394, -0.0180929247289896, 0.05025273934006691, -0.030339039862155914, -0.053182948380708694, 0.025493431836366653, 0.03802570700645447, -0.015451581217348576, 0.007992226630449295, 0.013067894615232944, -0.06571706384420395, -0.022989531978964806, 0.02348155900835991, -0.00009682903328211978, -0.018863297998905182, 0.01690923050045967, 0.06468584388494492, 0.05027354136109352, -0.01853151060640812, 0.03546649217605591, 0.012415465898811817, -0.024866938591003418, 0.04843905568122864, 0.021783672273159027, -0.03896159678697586, -0.03813644498586655, 0.030818307772278786, 0.021736908704042435, 0.02104533091187477, -0.006766228470951319, -0.00440263980999589, -0.03262710198760033, -0.034560464322566986, -0.001046240795403719, -0.0016111992299556732, -0.0312004704028368, -0.01680758409202099, -0.05193236470222473, -0.0012960502645000815, 0.015413430519402027, 0.003776316763833165, -0.05409222096204758, -0.023480268195271492, -0.0003387840115465224, -0.0003464710316620767, -0.04752492532134056, -0.008834870532155037, -0.041334331035614014, -0.04796059802174568, -0.05330106243491173, -0.016656769439578056, -0.07242588698863983, 0.06347992271184921, 0.02131941355764866, 0.02855840139091015, -0.02662951685488224, 0.04896247386932373, 0.10121870040893555, 0.06907641142606735, 0.02280998043715954, 0.004243860021233559, -0.004567138385027647, -0.004823511466383934, 0.010076677426695824, 0.05394458770751953, 0.017715182155370712, -0.09615073353052139, 0.018872303888201714, -0.08760548382997513, 0.035265497863292694, -0.021848060190677643, 0.061905018985271454, 0.10870015621185303, 0.0367414765059948, 0.03029680624604225, 0.00761024747043848, 0.0189884752035141, 0.0067538972944021225, -0.015429593622684479, -0.029533060267567635, 0.009436437860131264, -0.017682403326034546, 0.012531697750091553, 0.03019024059176445, -0.011881042271852493, 0.00833191629499197, 0.04091193526983261, -0.01022358424961567, 0.04941258579492569, 0.03215552866458893, -0.00832392554730177, 0.012067575007677078, -0.0608958825469017, -0.04196605458855629, 0.014832902699708939, 0.04076184332370758, 0.0969550758600235, -0.0093295369297266, -0.05194883421063423, 0.023070506751537323, -0.06033502146601677, -0.08167483657598495, 0.03316481038928032, -0.008938880637288094, -0.005423267371952534, -0.09555376321077347, 0.014895538799464703, 0.01082591712474823, 0.008534401655197144, -0.001725469366647303, 0.0002595232508610934, -0.029240092262625694, -0.00039749612915329635, -0.017632775008678436, 0.06149321421980858, 0.037318482995033264, 0.023684803396463394, -0.03580867126584053, -0.025518735870718956, 0.005043849814683199, -0.06057499349117279, -0.02401416376233101, -0.007049991749227047, -0.018878718838095665, 0.044414322823286057, 0.03370850160717964, 0.01767745427787304, 0.0569482184946537, 0.028672996908426285, 0.030344748869538307, -0.03635386750102043, -0.0004103443934582174, -0.01159355603158474, 0.04041939601302147, -0.020899537950754166, -0.008044863119721413, -0.007074397057294846, 0.07221247255802155, 0.09175536036491394, -0.0028335796669125557, -0.02071927674114704, 0.02488589845597744, -0.014459963887929916, 0.011594478040933609, 0.0295172818005085, -0.06142352521419525, 0.02902796119451523, -0.021791966632008553, -0.009628883562982082, -0.04474729672074318, -0.0018699448555707932, 0.011638408526778221, 0.048975903540849686, 0.07809218019247055, 0.048876676708459854, -0.0354950986802578, 0.016338882967829704, 0.03038802556693554, 0.0034397710114717484, -0.049826305359601974, -0.015744511038064957, 0.0031922138296067715, 0.0015197634929791093, -0.03157294914126396, -0.03884011507034302, 0.00924723595380783, 0.039186712354421616, -0.0211635772138834, -0.03363135829567909, -0.030540326610207558, 0.018571283668279648, -0.024095041677355766, 0.029481174424290657, -0.03754289075732231, -0.046733152121305466, -0.018205756321549416, -0.04453537240624428, 0.03395112603902817, -0.04339543357491493, -0.032252486795186996, -0.0009062926983460784, -0.018230006098747253, -0.06529957801103592, -0.011869808658957481, -0.06493894010782242, 0.007690406870096922, -0.0036698696203529835, -0.023336410522460938, 0.04803754761815071, -0.028703849762678146, -0.00962943583726883, -0.0048178816214203835, 0.05020642280578613, -0.0019565385300666094, 0.014372428879141808, 0.029613183811306953, 0.03675003722310066, 0.00020451517775654793, -0.006940916646271944, -0.006411723792552948, 0.037140171974897385, 0.0250946544110775, 0.008779536001384258, 0.04653304070234299, 0.01845511980354786, 0.02248355932533741, 0.012537539005279541, -0.009396877139806747, -0.05409882217645645, -0.019147027283906937, -0.07324341684579849, -0.017329823225736618, -0.0036071694921702147, 0.015865307301282883, 0.06974320113658905, -0.05721321329474449, -0.026727840304374695, 0.02616124413907528, -0.02926953323185444, -0.020161602646112442, 0.029423166066408157, 0.015480860136449337, 0.06432314962148666, 0.02239595726132393, -0.02960915118455887, 0.04665715992450714, -0.0031076755840331316, 0.014921698719263077, 0.03272779658436775, -0.03612549975514412, -0.010793705470860004, 0.01991228759288788, 0.08021847903728485, 0.021152149885892868, 0.04521720111370087, -0.04609483852982521, 0.02289886400103569, 0.05298076570034027, -0.01795368641614914, 0.005109039600938559, 0.005118823144584894, 0.03845125809311867, -0.016771089285612106, 0.015896860510110855, -0.012529948726296425, -0.012458042241632938, 0.024300070479512215, -0.024170124903321266, 0.005735431797802448, 0.0178618635982275, -0.0006190314888954163, 0.007251856382936239, 0.0007466932293027639, 0.011909117922186852, -0.044026318937540054, 0.030343692749738693, 0.046415701508522034, 0.05793040245771408, -0.03153514862060547, 0.002965029329061508, 0.016259949654340744, 0.01388612762093544, -0.01181386224925518, 0.04928257316350937, -0.024318775162100792, 0.04497624188661575, 0.012270712293684483, 0.039056118577718735, -0.06388530880212784, 0.024059345945715904, 0.1172451376914978, 0.025999577715992928, -0.03908009082078934, 0.032482050359249115, 0.025250457227230072, 0.01896371878683567, -0.10258165746927261, 0.009638508781790733, -0.010902018286287785, 0.04576779529452324, -0.09259240329265594, 0.00937702041119337, -0.010914616286754608, 0.011732910759747028, -0.023327065631747246, -0.007042712531983852, -0.024302735924720764, -0.03396235778927803, 0.021946515887975693, -0.018432706594467163, 0.0014009070582687855, -0.041347112506628036, -0.015697667375206947, -0.02311086468398571, 0.03972771763801575, -0.06967904418706894, 0.032488904893398285, 0.0728551372885704, -0.044219907373189926, -0.03201214224100113, 0.01497118454426527, -0.013308637775480747, -0.021260103210806847, -0.024010462686419487, -0.061908360570669174, 0.0024694870226085186, -0.07005181908607483, -0.009528817608952522, 0.07973777502775192, 0.06869597733020782, -0.05830914527177811, -0.013773761689662933, -0.003977701999247074, 0.023316530510783195, -0.02747763693332672, -0.015053345821797848, -0.06461217254400253, -0.035989969968795776, -0.011083466000854969, -0.007119552697986364, -0.028089269995689392, 0.07662263512611389, 0.01391266006976366, -0.037218764424324036, 0.036056485027074814, 0.014849231578409672, -0.04269944876432419, 0.006810573395341635, 0.07768218964338303, 0.018687797710299492, 0.001394600491039455, 0.0004853714781347662, -0.01171655859798193, -0.05047612264752388, 0.015282093547284603, 0.02741451933979988, 0.034379616379737854, -0.017203383147716522, -0.02915024571120739, -0.06903599947690964, -0.01730024255812168, 0.06743228435516357, -0.040925946086645126, 0.010580884292721748, 0.025308357551693916, 0.030694646760821342, 0.10499142110347748, 0.027874840423464775, -0.0015351369511336088, 0.004434442613273859, 0.025625325739383698, 0.0011389105347916484, 0.008441086858510971, -0.018141774460673332, -0.04747218266129494, -0.024810506030917168, -0.031946443021297455, 0.02512027695775032, 0.01228729635477066, 0.025558728724718094, -0.00867598969489336, 0.01335359551012516, -0.09996233135461807, -0.015756014734506607, -0.04430372640490532, 0.06568202376365662, 0.006765810307115316, -0.02346586436033249, 0.01799996942281723, -0.054385945200920105, 0.03344942629337311, 0.001638920628465712, 0.037977419793605804, -0.024699680507183075, 0.005424624774605036, -0.038148365914821625, -0.07353249937295914, -0.01910785399377346, 0.017493123188614845, 0.04574308171868324, 0.05878246948122978, 0.0241998303681612, 0.041400615125894547, -0.0005134065286256373, 0.02508246712386608, 0.00860235933214426, 0.01152733713388443, -0.051493316888809204, 0.04958269000053406, -0.010608755983412266, 0.0018269894644618034, 0.01828024536371231, -0.022952526807785034, -0.031230006366968155, 0.037900615483522415, 0.008366218768060207, -0.048808492720127106, -0.05500141903758049, -0.04573915898799896, -0.016634458675980568 ]
<p>Assuming it's possible to vibrate a human at near light speed without harming him, would a few minutes of this from his point of view be much longer from a stationary observer's point of view?</p> <p>In other words do vibrations work the same as normal movement with regards to time dilation?</p> <p>So a person could walk into such a machine, and walk out hundreds of years in the future, even though a much smaller amount of time would have passed from their perspective?</p>
g7453
[ 0.029895197600126266, 0.07556949555873871, 0.02936648391187191, 0.03374558687210083, -0.057581137865781784, 0.021693110466003418, 0.06058879941701889, 0.02069167047739029, 0.015324229374527931, -0.0037033313419669867, 0.021751567721366882, -0.029263943433761597, -0.02267909049987793, -0.0267945509403944, -0.040937356650829315, -0.021689873188734055, 0.04306919127702713, -0.01745421625673771, -0.010619370266795158, 0.03684055805206299, 0.04190390184521675, -0.029817508533596992, -0.0396246537566185, -0.03268587961792946, -0.04529815912246704, 0.007452917750924826, 0.007002430036664009, -0.0012747672153636813, -0.023892682045698166, -0.008131265640258789, 0.04384872317314148, -0.02777068503201008, -0.054160911589860916, -0.011583021841943264, 0.006562856025993824, -0.05179683491587639, -0.012668661773204803, -0.015277036465704441, 0.02154529094696045, -0.015764562413096428, -0.0166968684643507, -0.013044817373156548, 0.01087444368749857, -0.04563424736261368, 0.07265285402536392, 0.043947484344244, 0.05699187517166138, -0.0009115943685173988, 0.0025620542000979185, 0.014857230708003044, -0.05386564880609512, -0.008260224014520645, -0.015009834431111813, 0.05138997733592987, 0.04369122162461281, 0.014054055325686932, 0.009840037673711777, -0.024356825277209282, 0.013404741883277893, 0.03751996159553528, -0.013555287383496761, -0.059922851622104645, 0.034301165491342545, 0.0724487379193306, 0.0007392123807221651, -0.004171149805188179, -0.031635913997888565, -0.023707915097475052, 0.043914806097745895, 0.02381066232919693, 0.03661307692527771, -0.013386297039687634, -0.0818396508693695, -0.047348812222480774, 0.004646758083254099, 0.04354224354028702, 0.009519337676465511, -0.002091342117637396, 0.029162447899580002, 0.031059691682457924, -0.05991033464670181, -0.01638760231435299, -0.01264031883329153, 0.0029248620849102736, 0.10381539911031723, -0.06200932338833809, -0.05335073545575142, 0.013471927493810654, 0.02097960002720356, 0.037139032036066055, 0.04181346297264099, -0.03868440166115761, 0.08845844119787216, 0.03236246109008789, -0.07356275618076324, -0.03655453398823738, -0.010992096737027168, 0.03831631690263748, -0.03232480585575104, -0.0014108503237366676, 0.008043916895985603, 0.0012541530886664987, 0.001868045306764543, -0.006557136308401823, 0.015384137630462646, -0.02977142482995987, -0.01924455352127552, -0.050249338150024414, 0.011432289145886898, -0.024896077811717987, 0.04809027537703514, -0.07480655610561371, -0.0037172238808125257, 0.018865909427404404, -0.028971124440431595, -0.04534650221467018, 0.042454931885004044, 0.0928139016032219, 0.009535711258649826, 0.015515814535319805, 0.054364901036024094, 0.04549837112426758, -0.01325376145541668, 0.030158305540680885, -0.05808339640498161, 0.0047546192072331905, -0.04926454648375511, -0.002225262811407447, 0.02119484730064869, 0.02279648371040821, 0.055021341890096664, 0.10546500980854034, 0.014935731887817383, 0.023744579404592514, -0.01898142322897911, 0.04205189645290375, 0.04424940422177315, -0.006044649053364992, -0.02266974002122879, 0.033313628286123276, 0.060759611427783966, -0.031028250232338905, -0.008887507021427155, -0.005976556334644556, -0.024393705651164055, 0.04931407421827316, -0.043791815638542175, -0.0007578916265629232, 0.027482446283102036, 0.027926603332161903, -0.0432724691927433, 0.04618746042251587, 0.017065703868865967, 0.0006977792945690453, 0.03355986997485161, 0.01983320713043213, -0.003857174189761281, 0.07616005837917328, -0.016762377694249153, 0.014142974279820919, 0.008864586241543293, 0.014570212922990322, 0.014900868758559227, -0.04804117977619171, -0.05299804359674454, -0.016262363642454147, -0.013431492261588573, -0.07565456628799438, 0.022279944270849228, -0.07328217476606369, -0.04997042566537857, -0.00876993965357542, 0.019554678350687027, 0.06866594403982162, 0.016771040856838226, -0.0035487464629113674, -0.05525880679488182, -0.06913603842258453, -0.046550214290618896, -0.05537709966301918, -0.028276704251766205, -0.026874331757426262, -0.024154791608452797, -0.038641929626464844, -0.0026519321836531162, 0.027341417968273163, 0.038437873125076294, -0.010448280721902847, -0.08396733552217484, 0.003949401900172234, -0.011624051257967949, -0.06275161355733871, 0.018484080210328102, 0.017296282574534416, -0.06511007249355316, -0.01993153989315033, 0.015150077641010284, 0.008577858097851276, -0.003498414531350136, 0.047586534172296524, -0.010694368742406368, 0.02311868779361248, 0.03230268135666847, -0.05315210670232773, 0.04108971357345581, -0.007480081636458635, -0.015420605428516865, -0.0264076329767704, -0.012338506989181042, -0.05788034573197365, 0.0674886703491211, 0.03779686987400055, -0.04068586230278015, 0.005155326798558235, -0.053174540400505066, -0.012498154304921627, -0.036986250430345535, 0.018947940319776535, 0.07280503213405609, 0.0022778483107686043, 0.03575243800878525, 0.04359591007232666, 0.025916099548339844, -0.03749920427799225, 0.0471918061375618, -0.02356864884495735, -0.08733747154474258, -0.027139656245708466, 0.014899088069796562, 0.026022033765912056, -0.05372854322195053, -0.0034351362846791744, 0.030964840203523636, 0.02417369745671749, 0.02934386022388935, 0.027339044958353043, 0.009575331583619118, 0.010643308982253075, 0.031013555824756622, -0.03547413647174835, 0.05046134442090988, -0.001675922074355185, -0.008896923623979092, -0.02680117078125477, 0.0010409054812043905, -0.04128452017903328, 0.02266507036983967, 0.0032019498758018017, 0.0419921800494194, 0.02343783900141716, 0.02015894465148449, 0.00842767022550106, -0.01412177924066782, 0.006730193737894297, 0.027936678379774094, -0.025898097082972527, -0.0005162200541235507, 0.052626870572566986, -0.08244550228118896, -0.0328439325094223, -0.044053900986909866, -0.02093362808227539, 0.02951003983616829, -0.003446984337642789, 0.030764415860176086, -0.023995906114578247, 0.019368473440408707, 0.04049781709909439, -0.013621985912322998, 0.012574475258588791, 0.057144373655319214, 0.030047835782170296, -0.02760358527302742, 0.056192170828580856, -0.032835930585861206, -0.03563901409506798, 0.016501396894454956, -0.037444837391376495, -0.009516970254480839, -0.010589871555566788, -0.03647749498486519, -0.018021149560809135, -0.03674723207950592, 0.018886761739850044, 0.04829239472746849, -0.03402704373002052, -0.07015036046504974, 0.003379819681867957, -0.043020691722631454, -0.007213817443698645, -0.03554104268550873, 0.02872030809521675, 0.0644337609410286, -0.0025284853763878345, -0.005086621735244989, 0.04913321137428284, -0.003524294588714838, -0.030738400295376778, -0.07863082736730576, 0.05785325542092323, -0.004048930015414953, -0.06767585128545761, 0.007803346961736679, 0.06735360622406006, -0.05443874001502991, -0.05993079021573067, -0.033594612032175064, -0.06265613436698914, 0.045048970729112625, -0.04662831500172615, -0.019443295896053314, 0.054537974298000336, -0.05033055692911148, 0.01111800130456686, -0.027220558375120163, -0.02307235635817051, -0.02837901934981346, 0.040990494191646576, -0.02224823646247387, -0.017453424632549286, 0.05279605835676193, -0.03275648504495621, -0.05103857442736626, -0.00885570514947176, 0.027901196852326393, -0.02337891235947609, 0.009181462228298187, 0.01007751002907753, -0.03861194849014282, -0.007300779223442078, -0.01059767697006464, -0.03737618029117584, -0.061482589691877365, -0.02111373282968998, -0.0470815971493721, -0.050996482372283936, -0.029281750321388245, 0.05347837135195732, 0.04405144229531288, -0.03797370195388794, 0.011696886271238327, 0.015233440324664116, -0.06041821837425232, 0.009700611233711243, 0.02267901413142681, 0.013302571140229702, -0.023101765662431717, -0.008196096867322922, -0.03888026997447014, -0.04140773043036461, 0.06845516711473465, -0.010072031058371067, -0.04808901622891426, -0.04736112430691719, 0.032813429832458496, 0.02673340030014515, -0.03251459449529648, 0.0593501515686512, 0.0005906061851419508, -0.037218958139419556, -0.026813261210918427, 0.02947358414530754, 0.009950985200703144, -0.03162992745637894, 0.03757186606526375, 0.03892442584037781, -0.025803543627262115, 0.054598528891801834, 0.06394394487142563, 0.019501391798257828, 0.006740282755345106, -0.06480418890714645, 0.013591096736490726, -0.0221195537596941, -0.023933827877044678, 0.03097640722990036, 0.039561789482831955, -0.0566566102206707, -0.04825002700090408, 0.029719721525907516, -0.014575156383216381, 0.004350684583187103, -0.01257928367704153, -0.0211865846067667, 0.03150253742933273, 0.007410026621073484, -0.008857070468366146, -0.012295449152588844, 0.02254079282283783, 0.028212444856762886, 0.04632628709077835, -0.026630936190485954, 0.024533133953809738, -0.018863659352064133, -0.026623370125889778, -0.023481648415327072, 0.023781120777130127, -0.029622970148921013, 0.0021758314687758684, 0.008341493085026741, 0.01737000048160553, 0.07116677612066269, -0.038027968257665634, 0.08724722266197205, -0.015629107132554054, 0.021914735436439514, 0.01609543152153492, -0.004837998189032078, 0.01568320393562317, -0.004398064222186804, -0.04884621500968933, -0.007326036226004362, 0.007809121161699295, -0.06519348919391632, -0.0033529484644532204, 0.05393065884709358, -0.011186599731445312, -0.04483538120985031, 0.04340425878763199, 0.06753478199243546, -0.0054863858968019485, 0.008789901621639729, -0.025544948875904083, 0.029089689254760742, -0.002277447609230876, 0.03435181826353073, 0.03640507906675339, -0.009866601787507534, -0.011388986371457577, -0.05999716371297836, 0.010173776187002659, 0.007575373165309429, -0.016179164871573448, 0.017161216586828232, -0.009266226552426815, 0.051502130925655365, 0.056856777518987656, -0.010204894468188286, 0.03204747289419174, 0.03263942524790764, 0.016170190647244453, 0.006506569683551788, 0.040524937212467194, 0.0185968317091465, -0.04518073797225952, 0.02259734645485878, -0.017077961936593056, -0.08852782845497131, -0.006765988189727068, -0.042259782552719116, -0.042094215750694275, 0.03149121254682541, -0.08482886105775833, 0.006541938055306673, 0.010719267651438713, -0.03656264394521713, 0.016584618017077446, 0.0013204938732087612, -0.00279407249763608, 0.037664592266082764, -0.012717205099761486, -0.010790993459522724, -0.014219309203326702, -0.03398916870355606, -0.05643240734934807, 0.020265186205506325, -0.012243695557117462, 0.012575407512485981, -0.06815750151872635, -0.017352575436234474, -0.030904607847332954, -0.02946014702320099, 0.01184286642819643, 0.025559984147548676, -0.029914911836385727, 0.027019133791327477, -0.016899311915040016, -0.02197686955332756, 0.003656204091385007, -0.014757179655134678, -0.05563587322831154, 0.002950518624857068, 0.025045763701200485, 0.007350547704845667, -0.0030943749006837606, -0.028460325673222542, -0.06248101219534874, 0.059606920927762985, -0.03032248467206955, -0.02075907588005066, 0.008070332929491997, 0.027710650116205215, -0.009597701951861382, -0.05287611111998558, -0.002111909445375204, 0.003418738953769207, -0.0074022747576236725, 0.023434992879629135, 0.0009844958549365401, 0.006244027521461248, -0.043306607753038406, 0.035096537321805954, 0.007838832214474678, -0.04666541516780853, -0.03619881719350815, 0.0075821843929588795, 0.010251430794596672, 0.019570771604776382, 0.005099570844322443, 0.08108767867088318, -0.0170049536973238, 0.07581142336130142, -0.07294335961341858, 0.06276488304138184, -0.003864533733576536, -0.019078414887189865, -0.009074797853827477, 0.00013145834964234382, -0.0055021620355546474, -0.021574094891548157, 0.04074902832508087, -0.011218124069273472, 0.08561383187770844, 0.018165670335292816, 0.007501813117414713, 0.004597325809299946, -0.005394132807850838, 0.029341595247387886, -0.017836961895227432, 0.017200028523802757, 0.08288368582725525, 0.011771859601140022, 0.057540904730558395, -0.026474304497241974, 0.0006228474667295814, 0.059824466705322266, 0.016993260011076927, -0.01624867506325245, -0.028707049787044525, -0.017915301024913788, -0.038390569388866425, -0.07952871173620224, 0.020682113245129585, 0.08250882476568222, 0.010416479781270027, 0.007213025353848934, 0.0062974318861961365, 0.01369510404765606, 0.008093461394309998, -0.01156129501760006, -0.02518634684383869, 0.023279784247279167, -0.03387345373630524, 0.029367147013545036, -0.01064445823431015, 0.07415459305047989, -0.04968194663524628, -0.009583614766597748, -0.016899440437555313, -0.009459147229790688, 0.10549840331077576, 0.01591775007545948, 0.017985599115490913, -0.029619868844747543, -0.012328507378697395, -0.013507874682545662, -0.005978476256132126, -0.036691732704639435, 0.015952641144394875, 0.06463705748319626, 0.028190400451421738, 0.017247406765818596, 0.06819216907024384, 0.03205505385994911, 0.0021410228218883276, 0.019465390592813492, -0.015053250826895237, -0.06105584651231766, -0.1295594424009323, -0.0012859192211180925, -0.06312970072031021, -0.04054966941475868, -0.053882431238889694, 0.005189270246773958, 0.041695334017276764, 0.00898199062794447, -0.00024154641141649336, 0.0016895036678761244, -0.01849396526813507, 0.03509823605418205, 0.003639054950326681, -0.03407642990350723, -0.07267600297927856, -0.078116774559021, -0.018173011019825935, 0.004364946391433477, 0.013087445870041847, -0.07052517682313919, -0.042343683540821075, 0.03496265411376953, 0.021080661565065384, -0.006441957782953978, 0.06296142190694809, -0.01738668419420719, 0.03762473165988922, 0.06316395848989487, -0.05892254412174225, 0.05483753979206085, 0.052633002400398254, -0.0543816052377224, -0.009103377349674702, 0.017886651679873466, 0.010112009011209011, -0.007879425771534443, 0.0376482754945755, 0.05419859290122986, 0.02088926173746586, -0.02707049436867237, 0.014216567389667034, 0.059700243175029755, 0.012968998402357101, -0.002879663137719035, -0.02966848947107792, -0.023100469261407852, -0.06215019151568413, 0.03203404322266579, -0.016407569870352745, 0.011592085473239422, 0.06915741413831711, 0.04669603332877159, 0.0022517808247357607, -0.04684755578637123, 0.07556191831827164, 0.06891706585884094, 0.04619879275560379, 0.04359319433569908, -0.04299832507967949, -0.029731174930930138, 0.01111050508916378, -0.005648183636367321, 0.037277087569236755, 0.01599578931927681, -0.005252913571894169, 0.0126558318734169, -0.02252284437417984, 0.014746407978236675, 0.013885905966162682, 0.05111535266041756, 0.019263489171862602, -0.04441509395837784, -0.006099569145590067, -0.0270201675593853, -0.02720930613577366, 0.027146972715854645, -0.0340445414185524, -0.002980004297569394, -0.0208979994058609, 0.007885020226240158, 0.02858644165098667, -0.03527418151497841, 0.03425613418221474, 0.008594357408583164, -0.007447798270732164, -0.009951123967766762, -0.06239879131317139, 0.08000693470239639, -0.029564356431365013, -0.04363894462585449, 0.0054732090793550014, 0.011818704195320606, 0.02338174171745777, -0.011796425096690655, -0.0017256971914321184, 0.006770304869860411, -0.0006931262323632836, 0.033189963549375534, -0.02264377847313881, -0.036506809294223785, 0.007607433944940567, 0.034509655088186264, -0.019576355814933777, 0.004724984057247639, 0.015439941547811031, 0.0335063561797142, -0.0010499946074560285, 0.04316380247473717, 0.045981619507074356, -0.03774828836321831, -0.0116427568718791, -0.007684260606765747, 0.0002764987002592534, 0.01072120014578104, -0.015127317979931831, -0.004573298618197441, -0.011645582504570484, -0.0022156094200909138, 0.06354852765798569, 0.013041417114436626, -0.0020008885767310858, 0.05778054893016815, -0.027821380645036697, 0.005565692204982042, 0.06239726021885872, 0.027221452444791794, 0.0011164770694449544, -0.015950607135891914, -0.03785566985607147, -0.036665547639131546, -0.0028349515050649643, 0.036525748670101166, 0.05414244532585144, 0.0771053209900856, -0.042420148849487305, 0.01745450310409069, -0.016620947048068047, -0.017287909984588623, 0.0044509731233119965, 0.034721530973911285, 0.05016941949725151, -0.017323115840554237, 0.002948151668533683, -0.011955762282013893, 0.005926068406552076, -0.03421251103281975, -0.009080412797629833, 0.00138955342117697, 0.014276457019150257, -0.001504978514276445, -0.007690851576626301, -0.045187607407569885, 0.019010029733181, 0.0063388594426214695, -0.010898773558437824, -0.03334338590502739, -0.09288214147090912, 0.03263591229915619, -0.025438718497753143, -0.014703277498483658, -0.07423807680606842, 0.029121246188879013, 0.007478166837245226, 0.015129487961530685, 0.014170820824801922, 0.028995534405112267, 0.03716638311743736, 0.012940684333443642, 0.027317089959979057, -0.04416363313794136, 0.029028674587607384, -0.043513670563697815, 0.00801757164299488, 0.00449926545843482, -0.041476741433143616, -0.04105411842465401, 0.034610994160175323, -0.008541584946215153, -0.005491576157510281, 0.006074865348637104, -0.028822360560297966, -0.01897450163960457, 0.00228892476297915, 0.0016805079067125916, 0.007174353580921888, 0.0024341221433132887, -0.020736726000905037, -0.07034013420343399, 0.006481416057795286, 0.018150275573134422 ]
<p>Question:-</p> <blockquote> <p>When a beam of $1.06eV$ photon of intensity = $2.0 W/m^2$, falls on a platinum surface of area $1.0*10^{-4}m^2$, and work function $5.6eV$, $0.53$% of incident photons ejected photo electrons. Find the number of photoelectrons emitted per second and their minim and maximum energies</p> </blockquote> <p>the solution in my text book is as followed</p> <blockquote> <p>Number of photoelectron's emitted per second</p> </blockquote> <p>=$\frac{(2.0)(1.0*10^{-4})}{(10.6*1.6*10^{-19})}*\frac{0.53}{100} = 6.25*10^{11}$</p> <p>but i am not able to understand what formula has been used here can any one please help me even the formula used here will also help me </p> <p>Thank's </p> <p>Akash</p>
g7454
[ 0.005226494744420052, 0.031194264069199562, 0.009678761474788189, 0.03851218521595001, 0.016830280423164368, -0.03768431022763252, 0.03728021681308746, -0.023832015693187714, -0.007423116825520992, 0.03819670155644417, -0.02892252989113331, 0.08728748559951782, 0.04024142399430275, 0.034385666251182556, -0.007892575114965439, 0.014954612590372562, 0.08808112144470215, -0.00920617114752531, 0.0045165917836129665, 0.04539833962917328, -0.04063261300325394, -0.004870964679867029, -0.03367729112505913, -0.07792472839355469, 0.0077467127703130245, 0.054399725049734116, 0.004305053502321243, -0.004180378746241331, -0.028351955115795135, 0.0031447634100914, -0.03157093748450279, -0.03199820965528488, -0.0046921600587666035, -0.04108399897813797, -0.038432519882917404, -0.025007236748933792, 0.08361315727233887, 0.017742736265063286, 0.019260453060269356, 0.03790359944105148, 0.009312187321484089, -0.04030676186084747, 0.02393062599003315, 0.047906480729579926, -0.006554961204528809, -0.009562640450894833, -0.010449799709022045, 0.01872621849179268, 0.014137371443212032, -0.010198543779551983, -0.00913638062775135, 0.04421096667647362, 0.06407199054956436, -0.0354447141289711, -0.03702038154006004, 0.02933763712644577, -0.03821299597620964, -0.026346201077103615, 0.05373534560203552, 0.05440625548362732, -0.00578501308336854, -0.03545718267560005, 0.029594624415040016, -0.03796849399805069, 0.04246014356613159, -0.01515139825642109, -0.0015604232903569937, -0.017797669395804405, -0.0007248815381899476, -0.00027961033629253507, -0.03492949530482292, -0.008966031484305859, 0.043163783848285675, -0.01949450746178627, 0.007781715597957373, -0.07339371740818024, 0.004154575988650322, -0.03376215696334839, 0.009840365499258041, 0.06478500366210938, 0.020079800859093666, -0.024438338354229927, -0.03095785714685917, -0.008995470590889454, 0.03856922686100006, -0.01852276362478733, -0.013537157326936722, -0.015573789365589619, -0.05040771886706352, -0.034059856086969376, 0.04683117941021919, -0.0090474933385849, 0.036098167300224304, -0.03547598794102669, -0.023046348243951797, 0.012450412847101688, -0.01841377094388008, -0.007246877998113632, -0.04155505821108818, -0.0327201783657074, -0.00139336078427732, -0.03352046757936478, 0.007952897809445858, 0.029335016384720802, -0.000004524003998085391, -0.06861132383346558, -0.0026074599009007215, -0.01582750678062439, -0.038051918148994446, 0.0223923958837986, -0.0377972275018692, -0.0759936273097992, -0.04802623763680458, -0.06264619529247284, -0.08925682306289673, -0.030324075371026993, 0.04386873170733452, -0.05586319416761398, -0.01360385026782751, 0.04875130206346512, 0.043990470468997955, -0.006955241784453392, 0.02152903564274311, -0.0195915624499321, 0.010113264434039593, -0.012707185000181198, -0.002644812688231468, 0.016013653948903084, 0.02937939204275608, -0.010900539346039295, 0.0024848461616784334, 0.008676748722791672, 0.020389826968312263, 0.046399738639593124, 0.002112705959007144, 0.05262478068470955, 0.0363553911447525, 0.025153232738375664, 0.032324712723493576, -0.03318212553858757, -0.026925239711999893, -0.03610028699040413, -0.016864115372300148, -0.0017866338603198528, -0.09533986449241638, 0.02680150978267193, -0.024693066254258156, 0.010872162878513336, 0.04328639432787895, 0.010717500001192093, 0.057367753237485886, 0.04727252200245857, -0.005500896833837032, -0.04303523525595665, 0.01822286657989025, -0.06024731695652008, 0.02089833654463291, -0.020285019651055336, -0.05357767269015312, 0.045746736228466034, 0.03245159983634949, 0.030177267268300056, -0.013387870974838734, 0.012596209533512592, -0.07142685353755951, 0.023188196122646332, -0.03280755132436752, -0.08267354965209961, -0.005543512757867575, -0.05434727296233177, 0.019300704821944237, -0.039082348346710205, 0.026265135034918785, -0.038611311465501785, 0.0003986795782111585, 0.04501715674996376, 0.042581360787153244, 0.013541446067392826, 0.036479927599430084, 0.09226693958044052, 0.03133552521467209, -0.02837333269417286, 0.018980398774147034, 0.02170218713581562, -0.02583775855600834, -0.04094358906149864, 0.005266075488179922, 0.009522328153252602, -0.03992009907960892, 0.0060046277940273285, -0.014254534617066383, 0.02764621563255787, 0.025395890697836876, -0.014415299519896507, -0.07561340183019638, 0.017958125099539757, 0.007133481092751026, -0.08172770589590073, 0.004197878763079643, -0.03430918976664543, -0.008333523757755756, 0.08199343830347061, -0.009988062083721161, 0.016077470034360886, 0.02153804898262024, 0.016811329871416092, -0.01657678559422493, 0.0047331745736300945, 0.03251338750123978, -0.0060436618514359, 0.005919825751334429, -0.02470388077199459, -0.005250119604170322, 0.13329067826271057, -0.018124250695109367, -0.047325585037469864, -0.032382261008024216, 0.045369237661361694, 0.02356402948498726, 0.012287557125091553, -0.034174270927906036, 0.038361843675374985, 0.031605158001184464, 0.03868456929922104, 0.003212996292859316, 0.041529495269060135, 0.018898559734225273, -0.027462471276521683, -0.008438806049525738, 0.025460321456193924, -0.07616928219795227, 0.01545203011482954, -0.04935472458600998, -0.010493402369320393, 0.018150005489587784, -0.003552669659256935, -0.03694619983434677, 0.07591070234775543, -0.004531103186309338, -0.02664428949356079, -0.016894523054361343, 0.011771321296691895, -0.03737347200512886, 0.010386607609689236, -0.006276062224060297, -0.02568897232413292, 0.002327818889170885, -0.014522330835461617, -0.02011599764227867, 0.02600003220140934, 0.036667291074991226, -0.028986310586333275, -0.010909087024629116, 0.02738213911652565, 0.005448356736451387, -0.06568801403045654, -0.06624998897314072, 0.06958431005477905, -0.005481767933815718, -0.00960055273026228, 0.003772053634747863, -0.020378999412059784, 0.005075683351606131, -0.05907869338989258, -0.03182363882660866, -0.01808382384479046, -0.04953983798623085, 0.011127864010632038, 0.044115278869867325, 0.01912800595164299, 0.006945289671421051, 0.04804142192006111, 0.0044431425631046295, 0.04266630858182907, 0.010212069377303123, -0.04814348742365837, 0.021223021671175957, -0.05677655339241028, 0.01511684525758028, -0.005964433308690786, -0.0311580877751112, -0.03203151002526283, -0.030510300770401955, -0.012636492028832436, 0.023934291675686836, -0.07749515771865845, 0.06267541646957397, 0.023131923750042915, -0.011504099704325199, 0.0007849761168472469, -0.047822680324316025, 0.014232555404305458, 0.008977374993264675, 0.012871097773313522, -0.021726008504629135, 0.06193593889474869, 0.083328016102314, 0.024887192994356155, 0.006430213805288076, 0.05109347775578499, -0.012773892842233181, -0.03081490658223629, -0.059241391718387604, -0.05703608691692352, -0.04300490766763687, 0.0029481889214366674, -0.004846635740250349, -0.012639620341360569, 0.010555058717727661, 0.031818509101867676, -0.035246822983026505, 0.03806154429912567, 0.06566892564296722, -0.034475818276405334, -0.042606428265571594, -0.0073225973173975945, 0.010122330859303474, -0.011684831231832504, -0.01594504341483116, 0.00217624194920063, -0.03769032657146454, 0.007951522246003151, 0.027237771078944206, 0.008406958542764187, 0.011587521992623806, 0.029227323830127716, -0.06877268850803375, 0.010452188551425934, 0.007196083199232817, -0.007433532737195492, 0.02087709866464138, -0.01580064184963703, -0.0019677940290421247, 0.0029350866097956896, 0.009188774041831493, -0.03887811675667763, 0.005916660651564598, 0.0988752692937851, 0.010627757757902145, 0.03779051452875137, 0.006522799842059612, 0.0009477160056121647, -0.03868264704942703, -0.01193019188940525, 0.028847720474004745, -0.05279853567481041, -0.011951562948524952, -0.008982056751847267, -0.00466205645352602, 0.040490005165338516, 0.05022969841957092, 0.00719820661470294, -0.010201183147728443, 0.011701375246047974, 0.029728075489401817, 0.027098920196294785, -0.036968398839235306, 0.016582200303673744, 0.02187965251505375, -0.011584015563130379, 0.01947079226374626, -0.020241545513272285, 0.05397450923919678, -0.0284324549138546, -0.03239816054701805, -0.025044742971658707, -0.0034537394531071186, 0.07348665595054626, -0.03139939159154892, -0.011187369003891945, 0.0010834378190338612, -0.07281040400266647, 0.06579127907752991, 0.00339001277461648, -0.07821866869926453, -0.02739718370139599, -0.03772670030593872, -0.022274130955338478, -0.029745467007160187, 0.03371245414018631, 0.013089960440993309, -0.004803838673979044, 0.041749704629182816, -0.030847877264022827, 0.054994478821754456, 0.03303394466638565, 0.00420958548784256, -0.029749272391200066, 0.033392902463674545, -0.059755291789770126, -0.0031187667045742273, -0.02119212970137596, -0.05629466846585274, 0.03793390840291977, -0.03208297863602638, -0.047798771411180496, 0.035777103155851364, 0.009448124095797539, -0.04988456889986992, 0.03147471696138382, 0.05674000456929207, -0.015343576669692993, -0.025503061711788177, -0.028459127992391586, 0.01717572845518589, 0.008463162928819656, 0.06083766371011734, -0.007431017700582743, 0.043206218630075455, 0.009001796133816242, -0.03088073618710041, -0.004874565172940493, -0.023367634043097496, -0.016248267143964767, 0.06284654885530472, 0.013986227102577686, 0.0067638736218214035, 0.021898135542869568, -0.0264488086104393, -0.03119802288711071, 0.000494700507260859, -0.010317191481590271, 0.0509958416223526, -0.0688931941986084, 0.02034992165863514, 0.019618792459368706, 0.03456942364573479, -0.023234039545059204, 0.027043143287301064, 0.0036837549414485693, 0.0009498820290900767, 0.02200539968907833, -0.07177654653787613, 0.02430744655430317, -0.050019290298223495, 0.06640056520700455, 0.006763873156160116, 0.018436500802636147, 0.06857866793870926, 0.04161239415407181, 0.031650740653276443, -0.015217086300253868, 0.006449875887483358, 0.03143258020281792, 0.023883666843175888, 0.037309978157281876, -0.05090022832155228, -0.08646231144666672, 0.016496455296874046, -0.011797008104622364, 0.015028334222733974, -0.03942595422267914, 0.028932515531778336, 0.012426838278770447, -0.000943214981816709, -0.007901798002421856, -0.014717980287969112, -0.012466968968510628, 0.07960935682058334, 0.0924583449959755, -0.00513374013826251, -0.027976887300610542, 0.03716857358813286, -0.0064538572914898396, 0.07151828706264496, 0.024816108867526054, -0.07727018743753433, 0.024190908297896385, -0.08558260649442673, -0.09224627166986465, -0.0350504145026207, -0.015653882175683975, -0.007645125966519117, -0.009193753823637962, -0.03597772493958473, 0.0014532598434016109, -0.03410725295543671, 0.0399649403989315, 0.034430548548698425, 0.008147632703185081, -0.009836012497544289, -0.049026839435100555, -0.05225703492760658, 0.03445693477988243, 0.00040453331894241273, 0.007966483943164349, -0.0418630987405777, 0.004049138631671667, -0.004976057913154364, -0.07789704203605652, -0.03743525967001915, 0.03049485571682453, 0.004644008819013834, -0.06780681014060974, -0.010021368972957134, -0.012587310746312141, 0.02301723323762417, 0.0022258865647017956, 0.04404076933860779, 0.05442645773291588, -0.03354192152619362, -0.01008304487913847, -0.047648657113313675, 0.00627034530043602, -0.016156919300556183, -0.01169565413147211, -0.016587931662797928, 0.04727518558502197, 0.05216478928923607, 0.009901239536702633, 0.0271685179322958, -0.02119159884750843, 0.0411505363881588, -0.014529762789607048, -0.02864987961947918, -0.06914116442203522, -0.008188916370272636, 0.04329097270965576, -0.024227948859333992, -0.00564642995595932, 0.06733845919370651, 0.014426532201468945, 0.00963625218719244, 0.01675264537334442, 0.041214313358068466, -0.0464167594909668, -0.033381346613168716, -0.017193499952554703, 0.058550551533699036, -0.0006802777061238885, -0.0003071804821956903, 0.01748664677143097, -0.05677911266684532, 0.00287566427141428, 0.0059484876692295074, -0.04847060889005661, 0.0038554687052965164, 0.022214896976947784, 0.01359688863158226, -0.05655105784535408, 0.006925903260707855, 0.03228411450982094, 0.03224333003163338, 0.0060560619458556175, 0.06658007204532623, 0.0078096576035022736, -0.02976957894861698, -0.0037736990489065647, 0.03964615613222122, 0.0429377406835556, 0.07874587178230286, 0.06892915070056915, 0.07302869856357574, -0.04702233523130417, 0.030581418424844742, 0.03175673633813858, 0.014887272380292416, 0.02327759563922882, -0.0022996964398771524, -0.04062408581376076, 0.046157412230968475, 0.03467881679534912, 0.017963871359825134, 0.021146005019545555, 0.02668452449142933, -0.03536003455519676, -0.008283677510917187, 0.008993938565254211, -0.008369583636522293, -0.0520816333591938, 0.06626271456480026, 0.013169955462217331, -0.016285765916109085, 0.006169225554913282, 0.02049013413488865, 0.04980329051613808, 0.035732101649045944, -0.06821078062057495, -0.06898580491542816, 0.018620405346155167, -0.01495691854506731, 0.011285788379609585, 0.004724626895040274, 0.002607430797070265, 0.031121863052248955, -0.025730878114700317, 0.017241178080439568, 0.0066886162385344505, -0.0008969369810074568, -0.04870383068919182, -0.006994517054408789, -0.02812928520143032, -0.0061846147291362286, 0.03377430886030197, 0.008437268435955048, -0.010108021087944508, 0.03493507578969002, -0.001856560236774385, 0.0031068306416273117, -0.001883259043097496, 0.030085628852248192, 0.023446155712008476, 0.06475181877613068, -0.010464891791343689, 0.005272578913718462, 0.014129460789263248, 0.0016499789198860526, -0.00750588346272707, -0.054219286888837814, -0.003600359195843339, -0.053581658750772476, 0.022647719830274582, -0.0084005706012249, 0.021604986861348152, 0.018625101074576378, -0.05853523313999176, 0.059216078370809555, 0.03032021038234234, 0.012449719943106174, -0.029615668579936028, 0.01686038449406624, -0.031859949231147766, -0.0002846535644493997, -0.04777256399393082, 0.035569000989198685, 0.06553716212511063, -0.0034219715744256973, -0.0005914528155699372, 0.06281660497188568, -0.038459159433841705, 0.06832009553909302, -0.016335556283593178, -0.00852606724947691, 0.03813375532627106, -0.010844169184565544, 0.03651038929820061, -0.05353040620684624, 0.047824110835790634, -0.028353376314044, 0.05973834544420242, -0.04742535948753357, 0.025843754410743713, 0.04287927970290184, -0.008362827822566032, -0.02613680064678192, 0.010620733723044395, -0.07221051305532455, 0.018387433141469955, -0.024342091754078865, 0.00793815590441227, -0.0007247291505336761, -0.022393764927983284, 0.028825119137763977, -0.001900354167446494, 0.04312088340520859, -0.026287177577614784, -0.012020579539239407, 0.027247941121459007, -0.026862477883696556, -0.026303311809897423, -0.012608788907527924, -0.05177230387926102, 0.031396590173244476, 0.02151414006948471, -0.02827242948114872, 0.031743232160806656, 0.02523421123623848, 0.017788738012313843, -0.0008417275384999812, -0.08881526440382004, -0.020774196833372116, -0.019236169755458832, -0.07335478812456131, -0.013395244255661964, -0.006408856716006994, 0.07138168066740036, 0.030561795458197594, 0.02955830842256546, -0.033537983894348145, -0.016142258420586586, -0.00778014725074172, 0.013491809368133545, -0.05779189616441727, -0.05690494924783707, 0.03672885522246361, -0.03313266485929489, -0.031079111620783806, -0.02420620061457157, 0.05419338867068291, 0.02755916118621826, 0.008674712851643562, 0.001434002653695643, 0.044699933379888535, -0.05812651664018631, 0.0068558636121451855, 0.03131406754255295, -0.03842707350850105, -0.007983068004250526, 0.05655812844634056, 0.0066515002399683, 0.0023738143499940634, -0.021474087610840797, 0.018652010709047318, 0.02113964781165123, -0.07895122468471527, 0.011231798678636551, 0.016721755266189575, -0.014040209352970123, 0.02292601577937603, -0.06756743788719177, -0.008443769998848438, 0.026072420179843903, -0.042849235236644745, 0.009163396432995796, 0.002258904976770282, 0.0034919732715934515, -0.041074804961681366, 0.08945624530315399, 0.029762957245111465, -0.028194740414619446, 0.010784090496599674, 0.0038999354001134634, -0.045369479805231094, -0.050343021750450134, -0.016633542254567146, -0.053839314728975296, 0.012650282122194767, -0.0016464090440422297, -0.003185305977240205, -0.00882628932595253, -0.021742520853877068, -0.006421555299311876, -0.07463505119085312, -0.03930675983428955, 0.045189108699560165, -0.035903532058000565, 0.02768774703145027, 0.0025828643701970577, 0.037899699062108994, 0.06281612813472748, -0.015128038823604584, -0.05997130647301674, -0.016010913997888565, 0.018678655847907066, 0.011311877518892288, -0.0019443267956376076, -0.045479901134967804, -0.03069538250565529, 0.050110556185245514, -0.02276848442852497, -0.006726218853145838, -0.005510290153324604, 0.004897992126643658, 0.037208810448646545, 0.07868642359972, -0.07415306568145752, 0.0882912203669548, -0.02437095157802105, 0.0151921221986413, 0.0032429948914796114, -0.030728958547115326, -0.03292781487107277, -0.03585919365286827, 0.047349851578474045, 0.03888268768787384, -0.0812845304608345, 0.025685828179121017, -0.04787396267056465 ]
<p>What is <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viscosity#Bulk_viscosity" rel="nofollow">bulk viscosity</a> and how does it affect the flow?</p> <p>Explain the idea of introducing such a term in the Navier-Stokes equation. </p> <p>What are the consequences if not taken into account?</p>
g7455
[ 0.013886588625609875, 0.04410277679562569, -0.0006715637282468379, -0.028987163677811623, 0.01304401084780693, -0.03426876291632652, 0.06792481243610382, 0.049936216324567795, 0.006839006207883358, -0.06624432653188705, -0.04520696401596069, -0.03926609829068184, 0.08590938150882721, 0.05928705260157585, -0.015652654692530632, 0.03674335405230522, -0.011836259625852108, 0.0008921405533328652, 0.063951775431633, 0.024468086659908295, -0.02064378187060356, 0.035541631281375885, 0.006520793307572603, -0.02884482964873314, -0.015150357969105244, -0.07083889842033386, 0.0272387582808733, -0.07205606997013092, -0.04559289664030075, -0.0007636508671566844, 0.001533103408291936, 0.05996973440051079, 0.027317611500620842, -0.014766043983399868, -0.02292610891163349, 0.0010300767607986927, -0.03974335640668869, 0.06385181099176407, 0.02949071303009987, -0.0001017628310364671, -0.0023255127016454935, 0.05929931253194809, 0.013034394942224026, -0.05568612366914749, -0.05331806838512421, -0.02327481471002102, -0.04623757302761078, 0.0007261219434440136, -0.008540897630155087, 0.015960123389959335, -0.008336358703672886, -0.02809539996087551, -0.0012132666306570172, -0.020002489909529686, -0.009624941274523735, 0.0028962204232811928, 0.025964779779314995, 0.011288945563137531, 0.01146598532795906, 0.016730355098843575, -0.006932692136615515, -0.03345932438969612, -0.0061750635504722595, 0.02029373310506344, 0.020565297454595566, -0.03821791335940361, -0.03201886638998985, -0.028166059404611588, 0.07511855661869049, 0.0017916293581947684, -0.01452390756458044, 0.0069976202212274075, 0.005035571753978729, -0.04792814329266548, 0.006317830178886652, 0.028353730216622353, -0.017710603773593903, 0.012704108841717243, 0.04215594008564949, -0.0017564359586685896, -0.0007916776812635362, 0.03649657592177391, 0.038244377821683884, 0.03592711687088013, 0.07602996379137039, -0.017774708569049835, 0.0227271169424057, -0.040821291506290436, 0.032172929495573044, 0.022871866822242737, 0.02261584810912609, -0.02161630243062973, -0.019837761297822, -0.027819234877824783, 0.019663702696561813, -0.0042389570735394955, 0.02938721515238285, 0.0042897542007267475, -0.011575240641832352, 0.03136441484093666, -0.04431281238794327, 0.008088520728051662, -0.0008152162190526724, 0.0094672329723835, 0.006562441121786833, -0.019698919728398323, -0.02365783601999283, 0.09651810675859451, -0.0024806740693747997, 0.010784436948597431, -0.04482710734009743, 0.012087109498679638, -0.030190713703632355, -0.000059434209106257185, 0.0028547707479447126, -0.006266525015234947, 0.008241557516157627, 0.013967042788863182, -0.02094009891152382, 0.011240953579545021, 0.015400194562971592, 0.04299534112215042, 0.001233813469298184, 0.07913419604301453, -0.026264837011694908, 0.018148284405469894, 0.012250196188688278, 0.04841829836368561, 0.0601595863699913, -0.08056945353746414, 0.036330386996269226, 0.00977009441703558, 0.016439614817500114, -0.03690153732895851, 0.030962690711021423, -0.012737427838146687, -0.02791638672351837, 0.00007367413491010666, -0.0035758651793003082, -0.014150078408420086, -0.020861905068159103, -0.00320031912997365, 0.004033391829580069, 0.04446140304207802, -0.015476114116609097, -0.06935221701860428, -0.01980254240334034, 0.01142719853669405, 0.0404365248978138, -0.013180735521018505, -0.012263228185474873, 0.03446407988667488, 0.034912217408418655, -0.023153040558099747, 0.015638364478945732, 0.03409324958920479, 0.005217531230300665, 0.008537442423403263, -0.0454057939350605, -0.01087058987468481, 0.0596669539809227, -0.014708071947097778, 0.03232104703783989, 0.0026814527809619904, -0.12366294860839844, -0.03144163638353348, -0.010966707952320576, -0.07119674235582352, 0.004148665815591812, -0.03263070806860924, -0.0458330474793911, 0.017107469961047173, -0.04652555286884308, 0.010885076597332954, 0.03671601042151451, 0.03867689147591591, 0.061673786491155624, 0.036308933049440384, -0.012370537966489792, 0.009819717146456242, -0.05531712993979454, -0.00045263333595357835, -0.0011441227979958057, -0.055185526609420776, 0.024224260821938515, -0.004440869204699993, 0.006734670139849186, -0.0264473557472229, -0.07527447491884232, 0.06133585050702095, -0.03139633312821388, -0.08606810122728348, 0.00781101081520319, -0.009271258488297462, -0.030937042087316513, -0.011187002994120121, -0.025448637083172798, -0.047966402024030685, -0.05146262049674988, -0.031183069571852684, -0.003843252081423998, -0.01267700083553791, 0.031078068539500237, -0.008497461676597595, 0.02848655916750431, -0.04173528775572777, -0.00249552633613348, 0.007625653874129057, -0.02352536842226982, -0.0192613136023283, 0.05835483595728874, -0.03936239704489708, 0.0253042783588171, 0.0008581972797401249, 0.026462361216545105, 0.014083117246627808, 0.010966944508254528, 0.01509822066873312, -0.03570999205112457, 0.0363038145005703, -0.007681458257138729, 0.008470655418932438, 0.040595293045043945, 0.010342146269977093, -0.017504693940281868, -0.024323590099811554, 0.006513053085654974, -0.03932971507310867, -0.011846091598272324, 0.010868903249502182, 0.00916300155222416, -0.02231508307158947, -0.04122545197606087, 0.03291446343064308, 0.008183065801858902, 0.056172002106904984, 0.030891165137290955, 0.016088735312223434, -0.02358209900557995, -0.009867392480373383, -0.005569404922425747, 0.00193477189168334, -0.05231637880206108, -0.04569625481963158, -0.02471429854631424, -0.06008005514740944, 0.01289489958435297, -0.02364930883049965, 0.009719469584524632, -0.00002059217877103947, 0.01872199773788452, -0.060658954083919525, 0.0715591162443161, -0.008994081057608128, 0.04446057975292206, 0.028524504974484444, 0.017060916870832443, -0.02478809654712677, -0.03476573899388313, 0.038237590342760086, 0.01757427304983139, 0.028293143957853317, -0.024058792740106583, 0.009022824466228485, -0.08612797409296036, 0.028336767107248306, 0.011135837994515896, 0.05230364203453064, 0.01312896516174078, -0.01284994836896658, 0.04674956575036049, 0.0605805367231369, -0.023248810321092606, -0.046050090342760086, 0.016983209177851677, 0.025527872145175934, -0.009744994342327118, 0.006812707986682653, -0.008624165318906307, 0.020082416012883186, -0.02462794817984104, 0.010379827581346035, -0.026502035558223724, 0.03772550821304321, -0.014562065713107586, 0.013290210627019405, 0.012268216349184513, 0.012926684692502022, -0.0020049435552209616, -0.026483504101634026, 0.006808065343648195, 0.05405310541391373, -0.02913396619260311, -0.022378604859113693, 0.041451163589954376, -0.07532503455877304, 0.0608745738863945, 0.018163377419114113, 0.05709463730454445, 0.00018059428839478642, -0.04042315483093262, 0.01654800772666931, -0.005343802738934755, 0.04851149767637253, -0.06025442108511925, 0.06623478978872299, -0.026608847081661224, -0.10440436005592346, -0.060191329568624496, -0.0005031544715166092, 0.013698839582502842, -0.0007094342145137489, 0.03129909187555313, 0.05099652707576752, -0.0062922583892941475, 0.06069716438651085, -0.018684810027480125, 0.04533820599317551, 0.03649212792515755, -0.03373086079955101, -0.03901846706867218, -0.01807733066380024, -0.0034311239141970873, -0.013337807729840279, -0.002029334893450141, 0.03883685916662216, 0.038214247673749924, 0.010227249935269356, -0.013527583330869675, 0.008905870839953423, -0.002925773151218891, -0.0062285843305289745, 0.029806066304445267, -0.022952482104301453, -0.034046027809381485, -0.04716005548834801, 0.035818636417388916, -0.026282180100679398, 0.009469316340982914, -0.013627839274704456, -0.00016702119319234043, -0.10085643827915192, -0.009129352867603302, -0.035310305655002594, -0.047731898725032806, 0.014441990293562412, 0.021373098716139793, -0.021212562918663025, 0.00944907870143652, 0.009583178907632828, 0.039913613349199295, -0.045226551592350006, -0.017786506563425064, -0.06770098209381104, -0.023279979825019836, 0.00020406823023222387, 0.02025626227259636, 0.024193141609430313, 0.05524053797125816, -0.0035958527587354183, 0.035867273807525635, -0.014171930029988289, -0.013355058617889881, 0.07385566830635071, -0.010811405256390572, 0.0363934189081192, 0.02295277640223503, -0.003334569977596402, -0.06400756537914276, -0.07400140166282654, -0.035404108464717865, -0.02832469344139099, 0.010844430886209011, 0.07614357769489288, -0.010485668666660786, 0.03103976510465145, 0.05122559517621994, 0.06449153274297714, -0.022904928773641586, -0.02018234319984913, 0.08528464287519455, -0.0007527288398705423, 0.01937037892639637, 0.02192603424191475, -0.023089660331606865, -0.039115168154239655, -0.09338830411434174, -0.01665736734867096, 0.02002139389514923, -0.02923319675028324, 0.008660325780510902, 0.022641446441411972, 0.02537483349442482, -0.006528100464493036, 0.04326561465859413, 0.0020438204519450665, -0.006975112017244101, -0.0001285820617340505, 0.006947409827262163, 0.029328517615795135, -0.015257296152412891, 0.0249676201492548, 0.025640448555350304, 0.04162043705582619, 0.019290868192911148, -0.03213014453649521, 0.04288892075419426, -0.041947752237319946, -0.057245250791311264, 0.00008225512283388525, 0.028526177629828453, -0.044467683881521225, -0.041260574012994766, -0.03368009254336357, 0.028421219438314438, 0.048323314636945724, 0.05394276604056358, -0.03258608654141426, -0.010400977917015553, 0.012567266821861267, -0.006381192244589329, -0.014536773785948753, -0.016090501099824905, 0.014465510845184326, -0.04233408719301224, -0.002443743171170354, 0.0603100061416626, 0.02145918644964695, 0.022792061790823936, -0.014013517647981644, -0.03354234993457794, 0.0669461339712143, -0.04697076231241226, 0.04769200459122658, -0.013648229651153088, -0.008530355989933014, -0.014671927317976952, 0.024974726140499115, -0.03325045853853226, -0.015096400864422321, -0.010021829046308994, 0.021223826333880424, 0.0026884821709245443, -0.0210543442517519, 0.006408987566828728, 0.08032355457544327, 0.02369587868452072, -0.02199050597846508, -0.06457794457674026, -0.04354936257004738, -0.0454096682369709, 0.027370648458600044, 0.03731741011142731, -0.02352176606655121, -0.006041506305336952, 0.010674131102859974, -0.01545257493853569, -0.05034114420413971, -0.008193670772016048, -0.011924655176699162, -0.0819285660982132, 0.01411463227123022, 0.02757290191948414, 0.02611321210861206, 0.007267654873430729, -0.0581074021756649, 0.04032540321350098, -0.017571255564689636, -0.08779481798410416, -0.035025179386138916, 0.018678907305002213, -0.0408400297164917, 0.03904348611831665, 0.0528935082256794, 0.055453501641750336, 0.01815788261592388, 0.021254844963550568, -0.01604553498327732, -0.032081298530101776, -0.08232016861438751, 0.024693965911865234, -0.011276474222540855, 0.07684553414583206, -0.011617635376751423, 0.05118686705827713, 0.02016988955438137, -0.06047584116458893, 0.015832532197237015, 0.023706892505288124, 0.013724285177886486, 0.04322470352053642, 0.041212279349565506, -0.05640740320086479, 0.024524014443159103, -0.005550630856305361, 0.008084913715720177, 0.04808053374290466, 0.03171706944704056, -0.026672618463635445, -0.06908578425645828, -0.000038897731428733096, 0.08743421733379364, 0.03447173163294792, -0.0002419387164991349, 0.06550303846597672, 0.03893901780247688, -0.02151939645409584, -0.07743290066719055, 0.07240153849124908, 0.026031186804175377, -0.00332235568203032, -0.0376376137137413, -0.01266242004930973, -0.023230846971273422, 0.03598352149128914, 0.0177973210811615, -0.01823544129729271, -0.05678560212254524, 0.06996462494134903, -0.01882617175579071, 0.012774702161550522, 0.015007703565061092, -0.01260620541870594, 0.000573454424738884, -0.003417825559154153, -0.005688617937266827, -0.10198371857404709, -0.012771295383572578, 0.06279683113098145, 0.026392290368676186, -0.0026381739880889654, 0.018010523170232773, 0.06605970859527588, 0.06979972124099731, 0.018094521015882492, -0.04991762712597847, -0.010001574642956257, 0.04897589609026909, 0.012602400034666061, -0.0030169684905558825, -0.02749454230070114, 0.02853352203965187, -0.042532261461019516, 0.07789888232946396, -0.038327641785144806, -0.006023989524692297, 0.006036969367414713, -0.0040775807574391365, 0.01213727705180645, -0.07454843819141388, -0.03499585762619972, 0.004331311676651239, 0.0007968085119500756, 0.011506102979183197, -0.02594984509050846, 0.008336197584867477, 0.016319885849952698, -0.002440468640998006, -0.04524609073996544, -0.020172327756881714, -0.014672976918518543, 0.05384114757180214, 0.009913819842040539, 0.0567891001701355, 0.040448401123285294, -0.004776365123689175, 0.025404896587133408, -0.00012739696830976754, 0.04179587587714195, 0.0022966039832681417, -0.08358268439769745, -0.013826513662934303, -0.008483792655169964, -0.09992929548025131, 0.0019057195167988539, 0.03936335816979408, -0.018469281494617462, 0.006683616433292627, -0.042788390070199966, 0.017380794510245323, -0.04401608183979988, -0.027346475049853325, 0.05904856696724892, -0.03739466145634651, -0.01801268383860588, -0.07269006967544556, -0.03431336209177971, 0.015138920396566391, 0.05150089040398598, 0.05978313088417053, 0.013152922503650188, -0.06871789693832397, -0.011875556781888008, -0.004878072999417782, -0.008726109750568867, 0.029802268370985985, 0.0022214024793356657, 0.034351546317338943, -0.019094381481409073, 0.031104519963264465, -0.040301211178302765, 0.04849501699209213, 0.012220844626426697, 0.0029726859647780657, -0.007919883355498314, -0.00798987690359354, 0.03028499335050583, -0.026302345097064972, -0.01737102121114731, 0.05207405611872673, -0.013706674799323082, 0.023875929415225983, 0.014673084020614624, -0.03010454773902893, -0.002606673864647746, -0.013001197017729282, -0.008733706548810005, -0.017828259617090225, 0.05438702180981636, -0.020322280004620552, -0.027250390499830246, -0.09680202603340149, 0.09831525385379791, 0.058557379990816116, 0.052333008497953415, 0.032592013478279114, -0.05850283429026604, 0.012151204980909824, 0.004256878048181534, -0.0019734278321266174, 0.013145782053470612, -0.07070039212703705, -0.03845910727977753, 0.0605195052921772, -0.034793607890605927, -0.019610578194260597, -0.04368165135383606, 0.005370371975004673, 0.05596739426255226, 0.050863128155469894, -0.03435373678803444, 0.019069336354732513, 0.050218138843774796, 0.008840705268085003, -0.09503419697284698, -0.03360896185040474, 0.0006780082476325333, 0.029166817665100098, -0.03997998684644699, -0.02242409437894821, -0.018390599638223648, 0.01585245318710804, -0.022573022171854973, 0.03183485195040703, 0.030482109636068344, 0.018276289105415344, -0.028089461848139763, 0.03983869031071663, -0.019009551033377647, 0.04662531241774559, 0.0006765906582586467, -0.014720071107149124, -0.0006078014266677201, -0.025155775249004364, 0.0448915921151638, 0.05081842839717865, 0.06188545748591423, -0.07337473332881927, -0.0003827510809060186, 0.054471682757139206, 0.02085367776453495, -0.0013002249179407954, -0.011389615945518017, 0.00939418375492096, 0.008853600360453129, -0.04961315914988518, 0.0010173532646149397, -0.019506923854351044, -0.0028108907863497734, 0.008593491278588772, 0.03746916353702545, 0.001977308886125684, 0.06792671233415604, 0.023680128157138824, -0.06038792058825493, 0.0012322298716753721, -0.03210008516907692, 0.028902674093842506, 0.02606862224638462, -0.04856635257601738, 0.019275527447462082, -0.010214139707386494, -0.017725476995110512, -0.013610485009849072, -0.057696983218193054, -0.03627271205186844, -0.012895646505057812, 0.02408604696393013, 0.008653035387396812, -0.0016623287228867412, 0.004587202798575163, 0.012931020930409431, -0.024758893996477127, 0.005125011317431927, 0.0015908059431239963, 0.027673114091157913, 0.09048059582710266, -0.01331531535834074, 0.0066470555029809475, -0.045782651752233505, -0.016777122393250465, -0.008558070287108421, 0.03213291987776756, 0.02936607412993908, -0.015409162268042564, -0.055452603846788406, 0.011378541588783264, -0.05385515093803406, -0.06394617259502411, 0.0007166065624915063, -0.002872301498427987, -0.006583009380847216, -0.02423844113945961, -0.02594609372317791, -0.03347156569361687, 0.03592250868678093, -0.0299957524985075, -0.02103927545249462, -0.03850650414824486, -0.03420780599117279, -0.06879366934299469, -0.06017604470252991, 0.016549820080399513, 0.05238112807273865, 0.002438439754769206, -0.009893190115690231, 0.03882408142089844, -0.010277785360813141, 0.01833963952958584, -0.005408093798905611, 0.020784497261047363, 0.01819557324051857, 0.005876334849745035, -0.0335155613720417, -0.06889993697404861, -0.008901017718017101, 0.032682884484529495, 0.05641840025782585, -0.03271297737956047, 0.006516530178487301, 0.06073584780097008, 0.03566862642765045, 0.022104516625404358, 0.013480518013238907, 0.08577945828437805, -0.03718769550323486, -0.04808035492897034, -0.0009033740498125553, 0.01079810131341219, -0.015685874968767166, 0.0003474988625384867, 0.04007245600223541, -0.012872227467596531, 0.020729782059788704, -0.03255109116435051, -0.06412089616060257, -0.067194864153862, -0.009388213977217674 ]
<p>Can anyone clarify what does mean the angular frequency of a system in case of the vibrating membrane. </p> <p>Angular frequency is measured in radians per second, what does this have with the vertical displacement in case of the wave equation.</p>
g7456
[ 0.04593281447887421, 0.020294005051255226, 0.0034326936583966017, 0.01605960726737976, 0.07501029223203659, 0.020978637039661407, 0.04087204858660698, -0.021129433065652847, 0.038559604436159134, 0.001410445082001388, -0.019575253129005432, 0.02605040743947029, -0.010048460215330124, -0.007312423549592495, -0.015127538703382015, -0.06666779518127441, -0.018286140635609627, 0.024251507595181465, -0.017880795523524284, 0.006084168329834938, -0.009941250085830688, 0.018338464200496674, -0.07223626971244812, -0.033630967140197754, 0.026416370645165443, 0.07997364550828934, 0.0498899444937706, -0.03597185015678406, -0.05499579384922981, -0.008606338873505592, 0.005513536278158426, -0.05062255635857582, -0.0020118411630392075, -0.045609597116708755, 0.028980176895856857, -0.041358280926942825, 0.024791335687041283, -0.022911060601472855, 0.03642837330698967, 0.01279357261955738, 0.01830662414431572, 0.028666360303759575, -0.01637633889913559, 0.019947895780205727, 0.03175736591219902, 0.0008047086885198951, -0.05291007086634636, 0.01144262682646513, -0.04794086888432503, -0.02062516286969185, -0.03383706510066986, -0.0009644922683946788, 0.01195680070668459, 0.02221188321709633, 0.010870137251913548, 0.024193227291107178, 0.03956686332821846, 0.017633633688092232, 0.00453931326046586, 0.0310482457280159, -0.009062958881258965, -0.017869047820568085, 0.012940691784024239, 0.02651885338127613, 0.04018145427107811, -0.018314745277166367, 0.013062408193945885, -0.028118349611759186, 0.022747356444597244, 0.023108867928385735, 0.018725542351603508, -0.05271364003419876, -0.04675934836268425, -0.019619179889559746, -0.06468575447797775, -0.010384263470768929, 0.0278872549533844, -0.040858473628759384, -0.042344920337200165, -0.009387514553964138, -0.03288434073328972, -0.005267217289656401, -0.018080411478877068, 0.003629125654697418, 0.08283471316099167, -0.005472445394843817, -0.03896573930978775, 0.03762110695242882, 0.011223826557397842, 0.034002020955085754, 0.011952634900808334, -0.0325302928686142, 0.05129639059305191, 0.016044627875089645, -0.053962163627147675, -0.04170694574713707, -0.07707975059747696, 0.03404957801103592, 0.015509859658777714, 0.03422117978334427, -0.014218862168490887, 0.010123268701136112, 0.038578275591135025, -0.03772071748971939, 0.0600830502808094, 0.011765491217374802, 0.05401553586125374, -0.051639556884765625, -0.005658034235239029, -0.05231756716966629, 0.013290629722177982, -0.04373576492071152, -0.005022887606173754, -0.023579664528369904, 0.03246847540140152, -0.05546686425805092, 0.07356961071491241, 0.017094535753130913, 0.015120469965040684, 0.052543122321367264, 0.003930775914341211, 0.020369041711091995, -0.04307757690548897, 0.04207908734679222, -0.06526380032300949, 0.024665843695402145, 0.057597529143095016, -0.00914849154651165, 0.03883761167526245, 0.07673367857933044, 0.003085600445047021, 0.004812479950487614, -0.03434465453028679, 0.008476155810058117, 0.03860079497098923, 0.012950102798640728, 0.02839154750108719, -0.03978988155722618, -0.009735764935612679, -0.033214669674634933, 0.014542321674525738, -0.03031129762530327, 0.0558449886739254, -0.05461806058883667, -0.04559862241148949, -0.013460530899465084, 0.04741477593779564, -0.04935852065682411, 0.05512477830052376, -0.016004206612706184, -0.051908623427152634, 0.09543449431657791, 0.006579514592885971, -0.04064260795712471, 0.028608383610844612, -0.03315187990665436, 0.004423615988343954, 0.05148793384432793, 0.017571216449141502, 0.04929710552096367, 0.07376401126384735, 0.0015364232240244746, 0.005429786629974842, 0.04488319903612137, -0.047628115862607956, -0.017364192754030228, -0.015574884600937366, -0.06393304467201233, 0.022572163492441177, -0.03489488363265991, -0.047239720821380615, 0.014789086766541004, 0.011319814249873161, 0.07937470823526382, -0.011157810688018799, 0.07510797679424286, 0.007233940996229649, -0.050687409937381744, -0.00716751953586936, 0.004720789380371571, -0.026384487748146057, -0.015218264423310757, 0.04391416907310486, -0.04715042561292648, -0.0032809381373226643, 0.017708593979477882, -0.006093540228903294, -0.020923465490341187, -0.1081477478146553, 0.030709080398082733, 0.010435938835144043, -0.0015739520313218236, -0.0001358972367597744, -0.0026792215649038553, -0.03551564738154411, 0.04981516674160957, 0.037397291511297226, 0.037803880870342255, 0.0016810632077977061, 0.04537489265203476, 0.05746658891439438, -0.027897806838154793, 0.05739770457148552, -0.011430920101702213, 0.06129952147603035, 0.055380817502737045, -0.038695093244314194, -0.05496791750192642, -0.0125511409714818, 0.007324222009629011, -0.019009223207831383, 0.01942535676062107, -0.07268182933330536, 0.023290663957595825, -0.00527491420507431, 0.0398128479719162, 0.025206971913576126, 0.032878294587135315, 0.015183203853666782, 0.012230243533849716, -0.02108011394739151, -0.04047539085149765, 0.0341167077422142, -0.017460528761148453, 0.003442323300987482, -0.004773145541548729, -0.056308895349502563, -0.01783229410648346, 0.005174457561224699, 0.026848871260881424, -0.03333906829357147, -0.04719533398747444, 0.0424017459154129, 0.03657188639044762, 0.008910664357244968, 0.04974798113107681, -0.0017824152018874884, 0.024103326722979546, -0.0024891223292797804, -0.02675224281847477, -0.0014455369673669338, 0.00017840116925071925, -0.013339079916477203, -0.03006623312830925, 0.0009364653960801661, 0.054866742342710495, 0.07671736925840378, -0.0013901798520237207, 0.03567828610539436, 0.018470320850610733, 0.029814796522259712, -0.015521835535764694, -0.02782888524234295, -0.01817859522998333, 0.0394887775182724, -0.01612490601837635, -0.022639406844973564, 0.058946553617715836, -0.04619327932596207, -0.03867562487721443, -0.004748896230012178, 0.009699832648038864, 0.040522921830415726, 0.014074902981519699, -0.007398601621389389, -0.08539114892482758, 0.016368921846151352, 0.033090025186538696, 0.03925628960132599, 0.016323624178767204, 0.07229173183441162, 0.0761440172791481, -0.010700837709009647, 0.017656700685620308, -0.0338798388838768, -0.08315733075141907, 0.02749118208885193, -0.09297306835651398, -0.04376460984349251, -0.020184678956866264, -0.053865913301706314, 0.0288272462785244, 0.008124131709337234, 0.0044007254764437675, -0.0018512234091758728, 0.007907097227871418, -0.01109256036579609, 0.012180982157588005, -0.005923537537455559, 0.011784480884671211, -0.011443445459008217, 0.03796931356191635, -0.026165341958403587, -0.012189260683953762, -0.05118349939584732, 0.07411205023527145, 0.07193782925605774, -0.03663182631134987, 0.033782970160245895, 0.05158243328332901, -0.0006577274180017412, 0.03191301226615906, -0.03424208611249924, 0.003209394169971347, -0.057312775403261185, -0.0068426793441176414, -0.01891837641596794, 0.0002247879165224731, -0.007916250266134739, 0.05933721363544464, -0.02931850031018257, -0.009159418754279613, 0.059009868651628494, -0.05620502308011055, -0.06976303458213806, 0.0509931854903698, -0.031720999628305435, -0.059460677206516266, -0.0790434330701828, 0.020711978897452354, -0.061646390706300735, -0.049073927104473114, 0.013640270568430424, -0.043823786079883575, 0.03305498883128166, 0.013289378955960274, -0.0034066501539200544, -0.00359629699960351, -0.03798065334558487, -0.03355627506971359, -0.0009673190070316195, -0.022505102679133415, -0.048202116042375565, 0.012208717875182629, 0.04465723782777786, 0.027195002883672714, -0.07714183628559113, 0.009088869206607342, -0.01286221295595169, 0.0045077078975737095, -0.016265785321593285, -0.026127861812710762, 0.0015113429399207234, -0.02603886090219021, -0.053862448781728745, 0.00834816973656416, -0.026851925998926163, -0.004392345901578665, -0.030934209004044533, -0.020629558712244034, -0.001811845926567912, -0.00728007173165679, 0.012151782400906086, -0.03173130750656128, 0.02286072075366974, 0.025228332728147507, 0.0440678708255291, 0.04299145191907883, -0.05015961825847626, -0.029552504420280457, 0.02276371233165264, -0.05819501355290413, 0.02054314874112606, 0.03874896094202995, -0.016627589240670204, 0.017716314643621445, -0.04918086156249046, 0.08343280106782913, -0.044928450137376785, -0.051128122955560684, -0.06608463078737259, -0.019809367135167122, -0.00822416041046381, 0.005051142070442438, 0.0019475298468023539, -0.04436981678009033, 0.037743162363767624, -0.006310164462774992, -0.04194172844290733, -0.0016707031754776835, 0.04403427988290787, -0.01145489513874054, 0.031021058559417725, -0.030589574947953224, 0.019064610823988914, 0.01708822138607502, -0.01906142197549343, 0.03859248757362366, -0.017848307266831398, -0.03884308785200119, 0.0056249164044857025, -0.02562706731259823, -0.00427354546263814, -0.00016426194633822888, 0.04472694545984268, -0.05515405908226967, 0.061650168150663376, 0.002266273135319352, -0.01960114575922489, 0.08551676571369171, 0.034071460366249084, -0.07739613205194473, -0.03826401010155678, 0.022386357188224792, 0.021219702437520027, 0.05150299891829491, 0.006260171066969633, -0.04733497276902199, -0.01456115860491991, 0.009893056936562061, -0.011320085264742374, -0.0030821908731013536, 0.03656954690814018, -0.03899969533085823, -0.02470889687538147, 0.11198237538337708, 0.045590780675411224, -0.03910374641418457, 0.023440837860107422, 0.05799896642565727, -0.04829838499426842, 0.0805874615907669, 0.037263669073581696, -0.00575330900028348, 0.0024873651564121246, 0.04247947037220001, 0.05263397470116615, -0.013170277699828148, -0.029929401353001595, -0.065398670732975, -0.024785758927464485, -0.01585298404097557, -0.0021924558095633984, 0.019166668877005577, 0.008232570253312588, 0.03272940590977669, -0.004567168653011322, 0.00666406936943531, 0.023234911262989044, 0.03471722826361656, 0.022206757217645645, -0.009014169685542583, -0.06644349545240402, -0.009897418320178986, -0.020707963034510612, 0.055186234414577484, 0.02916082739830017, 0.00596446031704545, 0.010228308849036694, 0.007054871413856745, -0.013674608431756496, 0.034867480397224426, -0.03849224001169205, -0.023318536579608917, 0.0006676230113953352, -0.02463938668370247, -0.05954555422067642, -0.050188351422548294, -0.003682925598695874, -0.014060395769774914, -0.02146986313164234, 0.044836536049842834, -0.024088408797979355, -0.017552269622683525, 0.01363988034427166, -0.004547443240880966, -0.006758262403309345, -0.058386076241731644, -0.11324352025985718, -0.005318752955645323, 0.0023503736592829227, -0.06763166189193726, -0.004832850769162178, 0.008858510293066502, 0.0272219218313694, 0.04095790162682533, -0.009057405404746532, -0.017211413010954857, -0.016153503209352493, -0.09632176905870438, -0.00923317763954401, 0.012232367880642414, 0.013538808561861515, 0.005838169250637293, 0.0025803062599152327, -0.02894243784248829, -0.0005996817490085959, 0.01107427291572094, 0.040346138179302216, -0.022138074040412903, 0.0067554861307144165, 0.0312848761677742, 0.006922243628650904, -0.006200402043759823, -0.0024103433825075626, -0.00023587151372339576, 0.021414266899228096, -0.059439949691295624, 0.0058254641480743885, 0.018288515508174896, -0.04084046930074692, -0.0018199696205556393, -0.012744000181555748, 0.019976971670985222, -0.06863660365343094, 0.024554317817091942, -0.014016876928508282, 0.03077150136232376, -0.0034765645395964384, 0.06330273300409317, 0.048196941614151, -0.030503306537866592, -0.00017947374726645648, 0.005851956084370613, 0.03529516980051994, -0.0824141874909401, 0.025016285479068756, 0.03972932696342468, -0.0161470677703619, 0.03400465101003647, -0.005933089181780815, -0.00864564348012209, 0.0290918480604887, -0.05396312102675438, -0.03197749704122543, -0.032820552587509155, -0.02393428236246109, 0.008334720507264137, 0.011541705578565598, 0.04311308637261391, 0.006987698841840029, 0.01897859014570713, 0.05384330824017525, -0.004148791544139385, 0.03682290390133858, -0.012981405481696129, 0.028962284326553345, -0.05679383501410484, 0.043942324817180634, 0.0016244691796600819, -0.03880041465163231, 0.019546393305063248, 0.021395331248641014, 0.06126818805932999, -0.023308170959353447, 0.0364823155105114, 0.00955933891236782, 0.03756614774465561, 0.016349686309695244, 0.04153437912464142, -0.02827049233019352, 0.06017390266060829, 0.007809973321855068, -0.024306949228048325, -0.0384623222053051, 0.027082080021500587, -0.020596003159880638, -0.04610443487763405, -0.000378762255422771, -0.02512875571846962, 0.024034101516008377, 0.025217272341251373, 0.03972123935818672, -0.01055725384503603, 0.008470690809190273, -0.02535669319331646, 0.045456815510988235, 0.05343221500515938, 0.09336479008197784, 0.03756079450249672, -0.030618520453572273, 0.047234050929546356, -0.0377175398170948, -0.005544640123844147, 0.03070821799337864, 0.027131425216794014, -0.02739623188972473, -0.03473599627614021, -0.05133845657110214, -0.005759403109550476, 0.008870359510183334, -0.02349778264760971, -0.03268621861934662, -0.010150027461349964, 0.011809390969574451, -0.04621637985110283, 0.022711116820573807, -0.028240783140063286, 0.016822412610054016, -0.008765341714024544, 0.013111576437950134, -0.01823754794895649, -0.08533696830272675, 0.031701888889074326, 0.0009804529836401343, -0.003075327491387725, -0.021324938163161278, 0.010067544877529144, 0.02471938356757164, 0.053900957107543945, 0.04654631018638611, -0.020983314141631126, 0.053933560848236084, -0.049932338297367096, 0.006240335293114185, -0.037354085594415665, -0.016175607219338417, 0.007758042309433222, -0.06541644036769867, 0.06414647400379181, -0.03824200853705406, -0.0064963772892951965, 0.05023614317178726, 0.005032052285969257, -0.030692582949995995, 0.008108049631118774, 0.0030888833571225405, -0.009235617704689503, -0.01843903586268425, 0.04127845913171768, 0.026384245604276657, -0.0049503701739013195, 0.024994082748889923, 0.0024498626589775085, -0.022633705288171768, 0.03452035412192345, -0.002241897862404585, 0.02116008847951889, 0.00865712109953165, -0.03035230189561844, 0.001864349702373147, -0.0029100519604980946, 0.02113329991698265, 0.023699790239334106, 0.02056269533932209, 0.027267977595329285, -0.05687198042869568, 0.02140352688729763, 0.05506338179111481, -0.008218473754823208, 0.0363503023982048, 0.06363485753536224, 0.03187457099556923, 0.0003700732777360827, -0.03170744329690933, -0.023762717843055725, -0.01777474582195282, -0.006166832987219095, -0.0027205816004425287, -0.012418908067047596, 0.008342010900378227, -0.024355730041861534, -0.0776761919260025, 0.013230541720986366, 0.030880147591233253, 0.03389451652765274, 0.014465789310634136, -0.0033323371317237616, 0.015758056193590164, -0.010261927731335163, -0.04724777862429619, -0.04730405658483505, 0.02263486571609974, 0.009419449605047703, -0.06058577820658684, 0.006628086790442467, -0.05061784014105797, -0.017623431980609894, 0.03904980793595314, -0.033668819814920425, 0.02688579447567463, 0.022858085110783577, 0.020899441093206406, -0.02429782785475254, -0.030929746106266975, 0.017276927828788757, -0.02697976864874363, -0.028462784364819527, -0.005568350199609995, -0.05440660938620567, 0.05144019424915314, -0.018870970234274864, 0.032631393522024155, 0.017961760982871056, -0.049965959042310715, 0.006462957710027695, -0.02781435288488865, 0.02448239177465439, 0.03677285090088844, 0.016511153429746628, 0.03677133098244667, 0.0708286240696907, 0.0012531433021649718, -0.043877050280570984, 0.009032977744936943, -0.034558430314064026, 0.07831484079360962, 0.03380131348967552, -0.0179655272513628, -0.04600278288125992, -0.017467284575104713, -0.002567611401900649, -0.017791716381907463, 0.08703020960092545, 0.02654467523097992, -0.015972452238202095, -0.018494924530386925, -0.03856511414051056, 0.01859183795750141, -0.024262821301817894, 0.003496410558000207, -0.002347536850720644, -0.020759250968694687, -0.00496721500530839, 0.0030000016558915377, -0.011189298704266548, -0.08923552930355072, 0.04044274240732193, -0.09707725793123245, -0.04958955943584442, -0.05355435237288475, -0.014993135817348957, 0.013049067929387093, -0.1138891726732254, -0.045228470116853714, -0.030954686924815178, 0.01699269562959671, 0.004880544263869524, 0.0016833345871418715, -0.009549342095851898, 0.014091653749346733, 0.03085760585963726, -0.03418726474046707, 0.0222195852547884, -0.06889495253562927, 0.05213169381022453, 0.0572587288916111, 0.06849610805511475, 0.017460815608501434, 0.0134133854880929, 0.08032380789518356, 0.01897401735186577, -0.018166322261095047, 0.0206716600805521, -0.022828510031104088, 0.044799719005823135, -0.005444924812763929, -0.03826259449124336, 0.018129626289010048, -0.041289303451776505, -0.028001410886645317, 0.035146210342645645, 0.02039201185107231, 0.020217157900333405, -0.005699418019503355, -0.06112812086939812, 0.0009319040691480041, 0.01969357766211033, -0.02905338816344738, -0.054772499948740005, 0.03969528153538704, 0.02231672592461109, 0.04408741742372513, -0.004164501093327999, 0.005322278011590242, -0.05497187003493309, -0.01827974244952202, 0.004553465638309717 ]
<p>For example, if you have two hydrogen atoms and an oxygen atom, they are all electrically neutral and don't attract each other. But then if they manage to get "close enough" somehow they snap together releasing energy, and to get them apart again requires energy be input into the system. </p> <p>This says that the bound state is a 'lower energy' state than the unbound state, and this is my question: </p> <blockquote> <p>From a Quantum Mechanical point of view, where does this energy come from that is released when the bond is formed? </p> </blockquote> <p>I've done some reading and it has something to do with filling electron shells and electron probability wavefunctions spreading between atoms, and something about the Virial Theorom where the kinetic energy of the electron is reduced as it's range of area is increased. </p> <p>But that doesn't make sense to me, so I was wondering if someone could explain where the bond energy released comes from in terms of the electron wavefunctions? Assume high school physics/freshman maths.</p>
g7457
[ 0.043646328151226044, 0.018564585596323013, 0.01243841927498579, 0.006576336454600096, -0.004414570517838001, 0.0041969045996665955, -0.008353172801434994, 0.07909125089645386, 0.031417712569236755, -0.022277049720287323, -0.020320424810051918, 0.01131482981145382, 0.013792195357382298, 0.005278090015053749, 0.01637820526957512, -0.03096408024430275, 0.030444921925663948, -0.03984641656279564, 0.0409395769238472, 0.05518519505858421, -0.0088081955909729, 0.007285144180059433, -0.024918921291828156, -0.02545640990138054, -0.05198541283607483, -0.04568193852901459, 0.037450261414051056, -0.042313192039728165, -0.05004297196865082, 0.01754181832075119, -0.007592727895826101, 0.03328637778759003, 0.07165417075157166, -0.06650881469249725, -0.024115407839417458, 0.032131630927324295, 0.023895518854260445, -0.008638028986752033, 0.05094895139336586, -0.01073931809514761, 0.03530420735478401, -0.004343265201896429, -0.004959506914019585, -0.03807875141501427, -0.0010351738892495632, -0.015355744399130344, 0.009218634106218815, -0.013907094486057758, 0.040095772594213486, -0.009341452270746231, 0.029983386397361755, 0.06579644232988358, 0.018732784315943718, -0.016969021409749985, 0.02540314942598343, 0.006698278710246086, -0.008173356764018536, 0.019001701846718788, 0.0723370686173439, 0.0011900216341018677, 0.08077242225408554, 0.04219752550125122, 0.07320103049278259, 0.006931585259735584, 0.0858667716383934, 0.003812273731455207, -0.07067762315273285, 0.026377202942967415, 0.042390938848257065, 0.038330648094415665, -0.035617537796497345, -0.052102960646152496, -0.033050548285245895, -0.050991278141736984, -0.004378495272248983, -0.017576901242136955, 0.04536747559905052, -0.036860328167676926, 0.027913779020309448, 0.017884764820337296, -0.026104172691702843, -0.021728428080677986, 0.037458330392837524, 0.017962215468287468, 0.05251458287239075, 0.01479644700884819, -0.03193259611725807, -0.027344148606061935, -0.06290262192487717, 0.0538325309753418, 0.037646882236003876, 0.020563043653964996, 0.06945770978927612, -0.03469277545809746, -0.03589774668216705, 0.005384216085076332, -0.009424382820725441, 0.010311405174434185, 0.0069058556109666824, -0.03569822385907173, -0.039404988288879395, -0.04813281446695328, 0.07587262243032455, -0.029775571078062057, -0.02060576155781746, -0.01274654921144247, -0.051645439118146896, -0.02540849708020687, 0.022332705557346344, 0.038881219923496246, -0.026669856160879135, 0.005029131658375263, -0.027591664344072342, -0.04590646177530289, -0.002030010800808668, 0.0066923159174621105, -0.005057548638433218, -0.033689722418785095, -0.01618032716214657, 0.022772790864109993, 0.005095549393445253, 0.03298691660165787, -0.008263548836112022, -0.013230467215180397, -0.03961392492055893, 0.012945408001542091, -0.007841212674975395, -0.017753928899765015, -0.009266657754778862, -0.007788439281284809, 0.03167899698019028, -0.020999610424041748, -0.01562664471566677, -0.018505865707993507, 0.011047481559216976, 0.016942428424954414, -0.032117921859025955, -0.01581168733537197, 0.0012225370155647397, -0.02548057772219181, -0.039876338094472885, -0.025717629119753838, 0.020416300743818283, -0.04580885171890259, -0.0445677675306797, -0.010783622041344643, 0.019675182178616524, 0.008836383000016212, -0.027004914358258247, 0.033470652997493744, -0.041766416281461716, -0.009872807189822197, -0.0009407535544596612, -0.05618385598063469, 0.04826204478740692, -0.010107421316206455, 0.08882247656583786, -0.05363413318991661, -0.016693606972694397, -0.018375884741544724, 0.110165074467659, -0.035195689648389816, 0.01824844442307949, -0.019307833164930344, -0.07325935363769531, -0.035167284309864044, 0.09988575428724289, -0.06001553311944008, 0.07939086854457855, -0.028324304148554802, 0.00902992207556963, -0.06844385713338852, -0.04601896181702614, 0.037888236343860626, -0.007566842250525951, 0.05558166652917862, 0.062459468841552734, -0.0570279061794281, 0.03179381415247917, 0.019669493660330772, 0.025516929104924202, -0.026816872879862785, 0.03635214641690254, -0.008881657384335995, 0.03827257826924324, -0.025908401235938072, -0.013065825216472149, 0.004167407751083374, -0.0173331331461668, 0.021154623478651047, -0.034646958112716675, -0.03542064502835274, 0.05412761867046356, -0.054210349917411804, -0.01935272291302681, -0.014358249492943287, -0.01452600210905075, -0.053493253886699677, 0.007085862569510937, -0.009126639924943447, -0.0374424085021019, 0.027034496888518333, -0.03986288234591484, 0.011362642981112003, 0.07022019475698471, 0.028881365433335304, 0.033996645361185074, 0.01768064871430397, 0.05044649541378021, -0.03102182410657406, -0.016409698873758316, 0.003192575415596366, 0.018358735367655754, 0.03304542973637581, 0.028062729164958, 0.006537143141031265, 0.03699863329529762, -0.005065940786153078, -0.02184322476387024, -0.01010116282850504, 0.009868616238236427, -0.015275223180651665, 0.03876902908086777, 0.02260255441069603, 0.04098259657621384, 0.021862821653485298, -0.07325685024261475, -0.031150251626968384, -0.07914740592241287, 0.05745064839720726, -0.11005300283432007, 0.01577344723045826, -0.03657364100217819, -0.0028373333625495434, 0.0094993207603693, 0.052460625767707825, -0.023760132491588593, 0.014168842695653439, 0.011534353718161583, -0.051152367144823074, -0.009001226164400578, -0.009959161281585693, 0.00734395906329155, 0.00504999840632081, 0.018485402688384056, -0.051762524992227554, 0.05016285926103592, -0.0258504506200552, -0.016456352546811104, 0.021061277016997337, 0.03948185592889786, 0.004176390822976828, -0.044484835118055344, 0.026379350572824478, -0.04388248547911644, -0.027993351221084595, -0.04986480996012688, 0.011933427304029465, -0.033126749098300934, -0.07409662008285522, -0.005954132881015539, 0.010922298766672611, 0.022768668830394745, 0.01741800457239151, -0.04583508521318436, 0.003632494481280446, 0.015127569437026978, -0.04962879791855812, -0.0029184273444116116, 0.00445995107293129, -0.07279058545827866, 0.09139294922351837, 0.018855230882763863, -0.02213546261191368, 0.032837070524692535, -0.06735068559646606, 0.01227620616555214, -0.058261945843696594, -0.03596757352352142, -0.048902060836553574, -0.014015790075063705, 0.022311020642518997, -0.023914314806461334, 0.00725935772061348, -0.0039740074425935745, -0.03028786927461624, -0.00836203619837761, -0.011231391690671444, 0.009321901947259903, -0.05605114623904228, -0.06257972866296768, 0.021934211254119873, 0.0387127585709095, 0.011529642157256603, -0.054147589951753616, 0.024813735857605934, 0.029198316857218742, -0.008677337318658829, -0.08737322688102722, 0.03803893178701401, -0.07370245456695557, -0.0015244290698319674, -0.021095121279358864, 0.027738358825445175, -0.01936589553952217, 0.03823232650756836, -0.012489236891269684, -0.013957048766314983, -0.03842468932271004, 0.00029789452673867345, -0.019086265936493874, 0.016259340569376945, 0.053412605077028275, -0.0060513811185956, -0.043444763869047165, 0.012279796414077282, -0.02166435308754444, 0.0105775510892272, 0.008124691434204578, -0.08515075594186783, -0.06425932794809341, -0.0019941029604524374, 0.004063592758029699, -0.018382590264081955, 0.01864447630941868, 0.04717497527599335, -0.010073624551296234, -0.05162116140127182, 0.04126850515604019, -0.0026212239172309637, 0.05770094692707062, 0.003720196895301342, 0.020537998527288437, -0.003009657608345151, -0.014730405993759632, -0.05497586354613304, -0.03267311304807663, 0.025660771876573563, 0.07755143195390701, 0.012000076472759247, 0.005146344192326069, 0.026490945369005203, 0.02760891057550907, 0.03757103160023689, 0.02915995754301548, 0.005371383856981993, -0.05573081597685814, 0.016390835866332054, -0.018589533865451813, -0.021572833880782127, -0.01447503361850977, 0.0036599216982722282, -0.02807079628109932, 0.009742499329149723, 0.005793676245957613, 0.015302229672670364, -0.05010917782783508, -0.03693438321352005, 0.00011026301945094019, 0.020074034109711647, -0.0063559855334460735, -0.06465677171945572, 0.02863011322915554, -0.0025332372169941664, -0.016257725656032562, -0.05461430922150612, -0.016882436349987984, 0.018470359966158867, 0.006615570280700922, -0.05276497080922127, -0.05854646489024162, -0.031813327223062515, -0.02017492614686489, 0.06492277979850769, 0.013762218877673149, -0.05458945780992508, -0.0011801994405686855, 0.04332475736737251, -0.017932450398802757, -0.037603650242090225, 0.026721760630607605, -0.019650543108582497, 0.07251697033643723, 0.0688789114356041, 0.05319316312670708, 0.023220384493470192, -0.06355085223913193, -0.0012736937496811152, -0.025690248236060143, -0.007330946624279022, -0.024865994229912758, -0.034052953124046326, -0.01132303848862648, 0.04218186065554619, 0.012187381274998188, -0.004702953156083822, 0.02718973532319069, -0.012297067791223526, 0.03477288410067558, 0.09318429231643677, -0.0002991766668856144, -0.011494616977870464, -0.05735364928841591, -0.037776652723550797, 0.04479476436972618, -0.001529150758869946, 0.03470100834965706, -0.0011908422457054257, -0.020711727440357208, -0.02690553478896618, 0.05019368976354599, -0.03020497038960457, 0.01046463381499052, -0.03400854021310806, 0.00787375308573246, 0.022484159097075462, 0.0691852942109108, 0.0004367091751191765, -0.014166685752570629, 0.030298501253128052, -0.03173651173710823, 0.018352054059505463, 0.028684090822935104, -0.02071099355816841, -0.005289731081575155, 0.1308211088180542, 0.016641978174448013, -0.023779097944498062, 0.009445611387491226, 0.010527487844228745, 0.0017019419465214014, 0.028180770576000214, -0.030322203412652016, -0.027781495824456215, -0.05050564557313919, 0.0022950221318751574, -0.016714584082365036, 0.005445556715130806, -0.0028055605944246054, 0.05428145080804825, 0.07853607833385468, -0.0016460512997582555, -0.017252225428819656, 0.049271438270807266, -0.011284888722002506, -0.0009657024056650698, 0.006774027831852436, 0.006208333186805248, 0.021600909531116486, -0.07637633383274078, -0.0335502028465271, 0.00002937816498160828, -0.00404370529577136, -0.045458681881427765, 0.0027465031016618013, -0.02854827418923378, -0.05130303278565407, 0.03026508167386055, 0.03992856666445732, 0.032926492393016815, -0.052678316831588745, 0.013147792778909206, 0.00131962017621845, 0.016331996768712997, -0.0009817389072850347, -0.04128030315041542, -0.03839222341775894, 0.022091282531619072, -0.059599295258522034, 0.04959283769130707, 0.04144969955086708, 0.03417539596557617, -0.008844378404319286, 0.0023180185817182064, 0.013643097132444382, -0.019342908635735512, -0.01585187204182148, 0.005162529181689024, 0.06871502846479416, -0.07403574883937836, 0.0301510039716959, 0.02197507955133915, -0.018009332939982414, 0.07258159667253494, -0.014043407514691353, 0.008025421760976315, 0.021482352167367935, 0.031246591359376907, 0.03156891465187073, -0.04325922206044197, 0.017290636897087097, 0.03835168108344078, 0.014408501796424389, 0.030496476218104362, 0.004964030347764492, -0.021784218028187752, -0.001502073253504932, 0.027506761252880096, 0.012763304635882378, 0.030555101111531258, -0.06960398703813553, 0.02151884138584137, -0.054586444050073624, 0.0031996802426874638, 0.01925322413444519, 0.02291644923388958, 0.07007583975791931, -0.029907314106822014, 0.024644704535603523, -0.014717496931552887, -0.018811646848917007, -0.021205104887485504, -0.03488481789827347, 0.04341471940279007, 0.059701789170503616, -0.04036751016974449, -0.05318953096866608, 0.028140991926193237, -0.025303123518824577, 0.05033930018544197, 0.002244953764602542, 0.014496714808046818, 0.06260428577661514, -0.030470535159111023, 0.009756526909768581, -0.03541677072644234, -0.01571912132203579, 0.00264036119915545, 0.011302726343274117, 0.03247279301285744, -0.003152941819280386, 0.03408185765147209, 0.03956514596939087, 0.047647710889577866, 0.013687720522284508, -0.0029426373075693846, -0.062388185411691666, 0.025887105613946915, -0.0175459124147892, 0.061864372342824936, 0.04343464970588684, -0.021310534328222275, -0.008518094196915627, 0.0395553894340992, 0.0009509759838692844, -0.03489184379577637, -0.018405001610517502, 0.023493405431509018, 0.03055640123784542, -0.0073662432841956615, -0.021591631695628166, 0.02775191143155098, -0.046170808374881744, -0.04602459818124771, 0.01783757284283638, 0.05520516633987427, 0.003302358789369464, 0.017748652026057243, -0.02456848882138729, 0.008440063335001469, 0.047065626829862595, 0.02347182109951973, 0.03601706773042679, 0.02680829167366028, 0.07189668715000153, -0.020755982026457787, -0.062160879373550415, -0.018243396654725075, 0.005181327927857637, 0.023674845695495605, 0.05613919720053673, -0.03942525386810303, 0.030619628727436066, 0.00402233749628067, 0.0028544438537210226, 0.04472992196679115, -0.020862219855189323, -0.022465137764811516, -0.07879186421632767, -0.016619788482785225, -0.03384345769882202, -0.002946774009615183, -0.00453524012118578, -0.016849057748913765, 0.006094538141041994, 0.06101579964160919, 0.00907273218035698, -0.047477688640356064, 0.04123328626155853, -0.002245278563350439, 0.011767454445362091, -0.0009989311220124364, 0.02160297892987728, 0.02483590878546238, -0.03739051893353462, -0.017033569514751434, 0.0009575303411111236, -0.03262641653418541, -0.037981923669576645, 0.010256617330014706, -0.025255322456359863, 0.05020063370466232, 0.029862605035305023, -0.063765749335289, 0.017730819061398506, 0.039396435022354126, 0.03999585285782814, 0.002764688106253743, -0.01658465340733528, 0.02392042614519596, -0.08716484904289246, 0.00012879280257038772, -0.001226451713591814, -0.038111452013254166, 0.021532045677304268, -0.030078116804361343, 0.022870060056447983, 0.03212325647473335, -0.03600649535655975, 0.005935753230005503, 0.01305318158119917, -0.010452213697135448, 0.01920199766755104, 0.0027256635949015617, 0.045846350491046906, 0.01728069595992565, -0.05599823594093323, 0.017080526798963547, 0.04045780003070831, -0.011293454095721245, -0.020850950852036476, -0.025622792541980743, -0.040008295327425, 0.08114735782146454, -0.03861743584275246, 0.036019328981637955, 0.003856145078316331, -0.006119438447058201, 0.09024890512228012, -0.00018335584900341928, -0.027348347008228302, -0.006227508652955294, 0.057883359491825104, 0.03679173067212105, -0.05794310197234154, 0.00021261874644551426, 0.00613194378092885, 0.010404062457382679, -0.01233646459877491, -0.04677554592490196, -0.04660452529788017, -0.05344207212328911, -0.03310045972466469, -0.0021676302421838045, 0.0036055140662938356, 0.0346938893198967, -0.03718680515885353, -0.0505625456571579, -0.000041333860281156376, -0.004034723620861769, -0.05009869113564491, -0.02027539350092411, 0.02966332621872425, 0.06711891293525696, 0.041288916021585464, 0.01590704172849655, 0.023892516270279884, -0.028198013082146645, -0.019520480185747147, -0.05152108520269394, -0.002148933708667755, -0.07038641721010208, -0.04421945661306381, 0.015903592109680176, -0.05265410989522934, 0.03560633212327957, 0.043901633471250534, 0.025831662118434906, -0.02458876185119152, -0.09870637953281403, -0.021837271749973297, 0.01915191486477852, 0.025940613821148872, -0.0013710111379623413, -0.02115653268992901, 0.0013743711169809103, -0.011316935531795025, -0.02782367542386055, -0.04983080178499222, 0.008730472065508366, -0.012252209708094597, 0.04593772813677788, 0.02922315150499344, -0.05686003342270851, -0.031002845615148544, 0.02567380852997303, 0.044359877705574036, -0.02377191372215748, 0.04534035548567772, 0.010928438045084476, 0.018596390262246132, -0.00505926413461566, 0.0316169410943985, 0.002882335800677538, 0.0697537213563919, 0.025840437039732933, 0.01570574752986431, -0.015950117260217667, -0.042387910187244415, -0.04635968431830406, 0.019569698721170425, -0.043344274163246155, 0.015562491491436958, 0.012855855748057365, 0.014497312717139721, 0.013138586655259132, -0.01374256331473589, 0.08045171946287155, 0.048655543476343155, 0.016299186274409294, 0.014005922712385654, -0.0071794562973082066, 0.04809747263789177, -0.016814347356557846, 0.009421604685485363, 0.004588331561535597, 0.0490514412522316, 0.023523230105638504, -0.00031818851130083203, 0.044018372893333435, -0.03347931429743767, -0.018981145694851875, 0.029597116634249687, -0.0020015668123960495, 0.00553110521286726, -0.004612996242940426, 0.05465754494071007, 0.002963092178106308, 0.049405090510845184, 0.017704304307699203, -0.006562188733369112, -0.053848858922719955, -0.03251788392663002, -0.07504639029502869, 0.004274081438779831, -0.047558873891830444, -0.03968661278486252, 0.029521062970161438, 0.07671158015727997, -0.02359539456665516, -0.0378488227725029, -0.04928040876984596, -0.05231737345457077, 0.09200357645750046, 0.07841134071350098, -0.06712516397237778, 0.0036677811294794083, 0.013341742567718029, 0.023086238652467728, 0.03817899897694588, -0.024019459262490273, -0.014391351491212845, -0.0007347157807089388, -0.06223053112626076, -0.012981140054762363, -0.04502980411052704, -0.017690211534500122, -0.003285888349637389 ]
<p>I use a bike to commute, so I spend a lot of time thinking about how to get the most bang out of my momentum.</p> <p>Aside from the extra distance traveled in a wide turn, does making a sharp turn save you any energy? My guess is no, because these things tend to even out, but it definitely <em>feels</em> like I'm going much faster. I've even considered that maybe taking a turn sharp is worse, because the extra pressure will cause more friction in the bearings and the tires.</p> <p>Either way it's more fun, though that probably doesn't get a term in the equations.</p>
g7458
[ 0.03579030930995941, 0.026438310742378235, 0.031664811074733734, 0.04997286573052406, 0.040618546307086945, -0.003008076222613454, 0.033823516219854355, -0.03615512326359749, -0.028260305523872375, -0.0014147104229778051, 0.0275656096637249, -0.07510626316070557, 0.0002809477155096829, -0.033160723745822906, 0.002382005797699094, -0.06456930190324783, 0.020731225609779358, -0.02675817534327507, -0.035916395485401154, 0.006957771722227335, -0.005943344905972481, -0.010190111584961414, -0.026493383571505547, 0.03907007724046707, -0.05157364532351494, 0.01055985875427723, -0.03346763551235199, -0.048351023346185684, -0.0171490628272295, 0.023728022351861, 0.029151881113648415, 0.011307979002594948, 0.015623795799911022, 0.03514769300818443, -0.10396119952201843, 0.06731473654508591, 0.007688506040722132, -0.03218943253159523, -0.003975491970777512, -0.0535757876932621, -0.021441906690597534, 0.01716645434498787, -0.015568666160106659, 0.058226872235536575, 0.01724068447947502, 0.0015997325535863638, -0.022130893543362617, 0.005103955045342445, -0.023417174816131592, 0.007967752404510975, -0.013909438624978065, -0.004249007441103458, 0.014383337460458279, 0.04303208366036415, 0.06006145104765892, 0.02497037500143051, 0.03328589349985123, 0.003160239662975073, 0.0014470313908532262, 0.02258128672838211, -0.05955960601568222, -0.018135998398065567, -0.0062620509415864944, 0.004382702521979809, 0.03090263344347477, -0.07238393276929855, -0.005190465599298477, 0.02151821367442608, 0.07204800099134445, 0.04333369806408882, 0.034665074199438095, 0.020030301064252853, 0.026728181168437004, -0.00935100857168436, 0.02152220346033573, 0.045193079859018326, 0.03264068439602852, -0.009712181985378265, -0.03632836043834686, 0.04087921604514122, -0.008540569804608822, -0.00180664227809757, -0.020825382322072983, -0.031586725264787674, 0.06932872533798218, -0.0010184424463659525, -0.004360423423349857, -0.019060827791690826, -0.008304174058139324, 0.004382925573736429, 0.11108186095952988, -0.03822672367095947, -0.006372125819325447, 0.023207208141684532, -0.059335023164749146, -0.017313987016677856, -0.0007507679401896894, 0.06444509327411652, 0.02430126629769802, 0.04453178122639656, 0.011925672180950642, -0.020100565627217293, -0.026137912645936012, -0.041487324982881546, 0.01115658413618803, -0.09889427572488785, -0.00483267055824399, -0.030570928007364273, 0.05514400079846382, 0.007696836721152067, -0.01210105512291193, -0.07510308921337128, 0.017086658626794815, -0.017619220539927483, -0.06682244688272476, -0.004307539202272892, 0.060352206230163574, -0.030189914628863335, -0.042729414999485016, 0.015825113281607628, 0.008163383230566978, 0.030349886044859886, -0.027048157528042793, 0.02653323858976364, 0.031532078981399536, -0.0040031494572758675, 0.01948896050453186, -0.020522452890872955, 0.06188179552555084, 0.05037537217140198, -0.02169875055551529, -0.003095298772677779, -0.00624832371249795, -0.028762537986040115, -0.017819005995988846, 0.03319796919822693, -0.02955341897904873, 0.042967475950717926, -0.0004156478971708566, 0.04074328765273094, 0.07631359249353409, -0.043480224907398224, -0.00833530817180872, -0.014048327691853046, -0.06864424794912338, 0.008439557626843452, -0.10951068997383118, -0.014044826850295067, 0.048165954649448395, 0.03027811460196972, 0.047210849821567535, -0.0034055830910801888, -0.039881303906440735, 0.01990518532693386, 0.05719112977385521, 0.02710658311843872, 0.012943732552230358, 0.021149128675460815, 0.03833909332752228, 0.02738085575401783, 0.013393422588706017, -0.01136760227382183, 0.04058968648314476, -0.02230766974389553, 0.007974020205438137, -0.039400335401296616, -0.0011303274659439921, -0.05589228495955467, -0.033823344856500626, 0.015467861667275429, -0.04945112392306328, -0.0496443547308445, 0.04422229528427124, -0.01658635586500168, 0.02325856313109398, -0.036552544683218, -0.027563268318772316, 0.002520681358873844, 0.03470896556973457, 0.012527916580438614, 0.03364633023738861, 0.041636936366558075, -0.01577410288155079, 0.001415418810211122, 0.03465371951460838, 0.028314465656876564, 0.05047868564724922, -0.029216105118393898, -0.06280994415283203, -0.0851057767868042, 0.05479780584573746, -0.055695246905088425, 0.005822045262902975, -0.014012648724019527, -0.07039237022399902, -0.020353373140096664, -0.057123180478811264, 0.06267720460891724, -0.05897112563252449, 0.051167406141757965, -0.04358595982193947, 0.04208485409617424, 0.04061742499470711, -0.01258945744484663, 0.02166777290403843, 0.050808440893888474, -0.00013764647883363068, -0.022627858445048332, 0.031123623251914978, -0.06704195588827133, 0.02207445167005062, 0.009482246823608875, 0.01773231290280819, 0.018401212990283966, -0.012058340013027191, -0.0022562022786587477, -0.04935390129685402, 0.046225208789110184, -0.004281437955796719, 0.01961270347237587, 0.0417267307639122, -0.01786610297858715, 0.009498508647084236, 0.010542716830968857, -0.08474041521549225, -0.016235167160630226, -0.019092896953225136, -0.024484796449542046, -0.009247827343642712, -0.01630941592156887, 0.03536501154303551, 0.030579447746276855, 0.02390960603952408, -0.02625754289329052, 0.026352304965257645, 0.019649771973490715, 0.09450680762529373, 0.02829199843108654, 0.031278062611818314, 0.009709150530397892, 0.06998644769191742, -0.05017000436782837, 0.005583407822996378, -0.03583364933729172, -0.0030422706622630358, -0.02940536104142666, 0.013260932639241219, 0.003925472032278776, -0.008823798969388008, -0.011625712737441063, -0.012280702590942383, -0.006941516418009996, -0.0012893052771687508, -0.008362715132534504, 0.015971314162015915, 0.014311612583696842, -0.016495421528816223, 0.04784931614995003, -0.045981019735336304, 0.006708904635161161, 0.009736824780702591, 0.008825583383440971, -0.06322517991065979, 0.001193246222101152, 0.010269179940223694, 0.05833660066127777, 0.018456140533089638, 0.028321845456957817, 0.005980327725410461, 0.03896274045109749, -0.022585589438676834, -0.002267817733809352, -0.05615228787064552, 0.005482199136167765, -0.010496211238205433, -0.09660069644451141, 0.028384700417518616, -0.011025755666196346, -0.004383347928524017, -0.046960171312093735, -0.016645921394228935, 0.012304299511015415, -0.05245641991496086, 0.05492805317044258, 0.06402513384819031, 0.028382789343595505, -0.015366141684353352, -0.0017014486948028207, -0.028989490121603012, 0.02071022056043148, -0.018039807677268982, 0.0410800501704216, 0.08275270462036133, -0.012493319809436798, 0.0526391975581646, 0.03581388294696808, -0.01057186909019947, -0.038029007613658905, -0.01810009405016899, -0.06607813388109207, -0.00029494313639588654, 0.0102917505428195, -0.03268297389149666, 0.045156389474868774, -0.010218696668744087, 0.06417855620384216, 0.02410951629281044, 0.007537364959716797, -0.04533454403281212, -0.03807699680328369, -0.008742813020944595, 0.0031439894810318947, 0.026803981512784958, 0.029990553855895996, -0.013591540046036243, -0.06285012513399124, -0.008344928734004498, 0.004270224831998348, -0.006437805015593767, 0.02996406890451908, 0.007478136569261551, -0.03139573708176613, 0.008228682912886143, 0.020143112167716026, -0.005917039234191179, 0.04045244678854942, 0.02143099531531334, -0.0028584219980984926, 0.07392564415931702, 0.006228061858564615, -0.008591452613472939, 0.07595518231391907, -0.04648411646485329, 0.00680204201489687, -0.0783751979470253, -0.000029589966288767755, 0.058261167258024216, -0.04001563414931297, 0.01455227192491293, -0.024732720106840134, -0.013649518601596355, 0.04415683448314667, -0.0019029569812119007, 0.020602799952030182, -0.011873025447130203, -0.017380252480506897, 0.03076014295220375, -0.009705426171422005, -0.020916838198900223, -0.036010801792144775, 0.04878270998597145, -0.0855691209435463, -0.01609187386929989, 0.029544299468398094, 0.014710684306919575, -0.07685970515012741, -0.05058908462524414, 0.01390643510967493, 0.03327831253409386, 0.03226502239704132, -0.02847377583384514, 0.02204839326441288, 0.01441182754933834, -0.02485750988125801, -0.03454491123557091, 0.01894642412662506, -0.06398668885231018, -0.059414997696876526, -0.03510273993015289, 0.0025490769185125828, -0.021144812926650047, -0.007177156396210194, 0.004139560274779797, 0.037203751504421234, -0.02982163429260254, 0.004958172794431448, -0.013562222942709923, -0.010046769864857197, -0.00498786848038435, -0.03303278237581253, 0.05684885382652283, 0.0631389319896698, 0.04787261784076691, 0.023094603791832924, -0.020245229825377464, 0.0007347831851802766, -0.0747290626168251, -0.044369373470544815, 0.07204863429069519, 0.0407654233276844, 0.07726766914129257, -0.012966524809598923, -0.0006132801645435393, -0.001288626343011856, -0.006338787265121937, 0.023961104452610016, -0.0159787405282259, 0.004274056293070316, -0.06093066558241844, 0.03943819925189018, 0.011152850463986397, 0.0038830884732306004, -0.006272949278354645, 0.02282658778131008, -0.030011015012860298, -0.031646519899368286, -0.04313146695494652, 0.026960602030158043, -0.08434240520000458, -0.054113440215587616, 0.04770682752132416, -0.011532867327332497, -0.02756659872829914, -0.009632134810090065, -0.022383656352758408, 0.012256791815161705, -0.054564982652664185, 0.03134496882557869, 0.02426532842218876, 0.07143044471740723, -0.03416190668940544, -0.009375989437103271, -0.0252004973590374, 0.0343942753970623, 0.07278752326965332, 0.04080987349152565, 0.039272282272577286, -0.026796210557222366, -0.02963091805577278, 0.040472324937582016, 0.09886635094881058, 0.04785880818963051, 0.022064195945858955, -0.033872999250888824, -0.016825145110487938, 0.0515243336558342, -0.03147941082715988, 0.013996722176671028, -0.005808139685541391, 0.0146882813423872, 0.018190739676356316, 0.04095917567610741, -0.03493374213576317, -0.011938966810703278, -0.020764583721756935, -0.0007939349743537605, -0.06195218116044998, -0.002086686436086893, -0.05092678964138031, -0.040281157940626144, -0.038994982838630676, 0.022855613380670547, -0.020674141123890877, -0.039913110435009, -0.0026885655242949724, -0.014289792627096176, -0.03940097242593765, -0.00634803669527173, 0.004909902345389128, 0.016363615170121193, -0.01577298529446125, 0.03960442170500755, 0.03374900296330452, 0.035008370876312256, 0.011456074193120003, 0.06860435009002686, -0.0580725371837616, -0.04390522465109825, -0.037051133811473846, -0.007449615281075239, -0.027919333428144455, -0.008069957606494427, -0.01752486452460289, 0.009880201891064644, 0.014242636039853096, 0.022380966693162918, 0.01594698801636696, -0.040653008967638016, 0.025493009015917778, -0.024250388145446777, -0.060503508895635605, -0.053596142679452896, 0.05548791587352753, -0.06990638375282288, -0.021121684461832047, -0.04124821349978447, -0.025914430618286133, 0.008489210158586502, 0.03896958753466606, 0.004287846852093935, 0.04128340259194374, 0.08727536350488663, -0.031999506056308746, -0.05956067517399788, -0.033046770840883255, 0.036298129707574844, 0.014781814068555832, 0.001480862032622099, -0.09116516262292862, -0.021975211799144745, -0.007273727562278509, 0.015821067616343498, -0.05747460946440697, -0.06851816177368164, -0.00293886661529541, 0.006548517383635044, 0.020313654094934464, -0.04464133083820343, -0.036072343587875366, 0.04147092625498772, -0.033456750214099884, -0.01539192721247673, 0.0005048360326327384, -0.00010110742732649669, 0.037829458713531494, -0.010053503327071667, -0.0643155574798584, 0.00901543814688921, 0.008081115782260895, -0.020529543980956078, 0.04984497278928757, -0.012022322975099087, -0.002326262416318059, -0.014435390941798687, 0.0067555224522948265, -0.046633340418338776, -0.0681103840470314, 0.005641327705234289, 0.03454222530126572, -0.018141180276870728, 0.01632273942232132, -0.0679955706000328, 0.08157646656036377, 0.09637539088726044, 0.009678037837147713, 0.030771423131227493, -0.01250539906322956, 0.014867800287902355, -0.023876065388321877, -0.024557162076234818, -0.06277117878198624, 0.053746454417705536, -0.010911520570516586, 0.04816846176981926, 0.0226307176053524, -0.02805499918758869, 0.026829643175005913, -0.07581106573343277, 0.0022867685183882713, -0.019615894183516502, -0.018551098182797432, 0.023147225379943848, -0.03220260143280029, -0.005673146806657314, -0.009583924897015095, 0.028967298567295074, 0.0044793845154345036, -0.018705131486058235, 0.07265180349349976, 0.0014521991834044456, -0.014295272529125214, 0.0329655185341835, -0.010212620720267296, -0.023954816162586212, 0.032442133873701096, -0.0028883388731628656, -0.016322312876582146, -0.017990009859204292, 0.0492546521127224, -0.011627443134784698, 0.023821860551834106, 0.03878076747059822, 0.02125132828950882, 0.051856279373168945, 0.010876071639358997, 0.010259871371090412, -0.03107849322259426, 0.051476698368787766, -0.010063297115266323, 0.005925403442233801, -0.0062006572261452675, -0.024626171216368675, -0.03130205348134041, -0.0788748636841774, 0.057415541261434555, 0.059035759419202805, -0.01564566045999527, 0.020476223900914192, 0.035795871168375015, 0.0273116584867239, -0.03961809724569321, 0.03031686693429947, 0.014728885143995285, 0.018321815878152847, 0.013552100397646427, -0.006840906105935574, -0.00790040660649538, 0.008910083211958408, -0.0441780686378479, -0.013644098304212093, -0.02221578173339367, 0.0409427173435688, 0.04568305239081383, 0.011727158911526203, 0.023090532049536705, -0.018026156350970268, 0.0120994346216321, 0.05409759283065796, 0.004509765654802322, -0.02126671001315117, -0.03978150710463524, 0.04208623245358467, 0.046961039304733276, -0.015325915068387985, -0.0028797124978154898, 0.05688847601413727, 0.027629781514406204, -0.06282984465360641, 0.0621463879942894, -0.04551610350608826, 0.004205646924674511, -0.012788002379238605, 0.024464784190058708, 0.017235826700925827, 0.030317645519971848, 0.014873999170958996, -0.03006785921752453, 0.015494347549974918, 0.012338978238403797, -0.037345826625823975, 0.009653289802372456, 0.03345673158764839, -0.02719082124531269, 0.09840422868728638, -0.006129885092377663, -0.02608933486044407, -0.014691471122205257, 0.0448836125433445, -0.019723188132047653, 0.019720446318387985, -0.011913900263607502, 0.02225332334637642, -0.027466654777526855, 0.004658145364373922, -0.07223936170339584, -0.031010599806904793, -0.010512354783713818, -0.011256341822445393, -0.00044527516001835465, -0.0554373636841774, -0.04961235821247101, 0.015929637476801872, -0.012075605802237988, -0.06822534650564194, 0.019578007981181145, 0.014901939779520035, -0.010753470472991467, 0.02962305210530758, 0.0122321005910635, 0.0010335136903449893, 0.03895942494273186, -0.016019953414797783, -0.02694585546851158, -0.03859494626522064, 0.026695219799876213, -0.027516433969140053, 0.014633103273808956, 0.033264290541410446, -0.016157403588294983, 0.014249681495130062, -0.021425118669867516, -0.05084831640124321, -0.012807277031242847, -0.002588900737464428, 0.08591876924037933, -0.008726919069886208, -0.06073199585080147, -0.012219840660691261, 0.00024058490816969424, 0.009171471931040287, -0.021115029230713844, 0.038895558565855026, -0.07258061319589615, 0.060990020632743835, -0.0016126275295391679, 0.008465772494673729, -0.025640910491347313, 0.028618786484003067, -0.06605428457260132, -0.05543716996908188, -0.01939244568347931, 0.013181176967918873, 0.04432135075330734, 0.016992691904306412, -0.016939213499426842, 0.04333820939064026, 0.021145163103938103, 0.03890719264745712, -0.0013028065441176295, 0.03611839562654495, 0.021253278478980064, 0.013798218220472336, 0.02738353982567787, 0.01991667039692402, -0.0009723722469061613, -0.005078723654150963, -0.024924779310822487, -0.05536024644970894, -0.015811806544661522, 0.08487015217542648, 0.06023060902953148, -0.04290920868515968, -0.032660745084285736, 0.003234773874282837, 0.01587958261370659, -0.029900342226028442, 0.047188643366098404, 0.002906856359913945, 0.018879350274801254, 0.015916796401143074, -0.043298643082380295, 0.01862243376672268, 0.012983854860067368, 0.04266546294093132, -0.016694344580173492, -0.03369247168302536, -0.04790794476866722, -0.03239981085062027, 0.04267287626862526, 0.01799253560602665, 0.0032848892733454704, -0.038247715681791306, 0.0007580376113764942, 0.023284561932086945, -0.04472484439611435, -0.04204370826482773, -0.005478954408317804, -0.001515278359875083, -0.08778195083141327, 0.011944802477955818, 0.041582342237234116, 0.038269806653261185, 0.0043965913355350494, -0.011350037530064583, 0.012535247020423412, -0.04857056587934494, 0.07221158593893051, 0.03272781893610954, 0.018385954201221466, 0.04648304730653763, 0.053720276802778244, -0.0306819099932909, -0.06718838214874268, -0.043687667697668076, 0.007844425737857819, 0.039492882788181305, -0.018126944079995155, 0.0023673465475440025, -0.03193867951631546, 0.0187021903693676, -0.004959994927048683, -0.002328047528862953, 0.005381458438932896, -0.028448591008782387, 0.0006305077113211155, -0.04490001127123833, -0.01473794411867857, 0.04429365321993828 ]
<p>Do quantum computer's tell us anything about the foundations of quantum theory? In particular Shor argued in the famous thread by 't Hooft </p> <p><a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/34217/why-do-people-categorically-dismiss-some-simple-quantum-models">Why do people categorically dismiss some simple quantum models?</a></p> <p>that quantum computation was at odds with 't Hooft's ideas. </p> <p>Does quantum computation tell us anything new about hidden variables like <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Broglie%E2%80%93Bohm_theory" rel="nofollow">Bohmian mechanics</a> (which, at least so far, is 100% in agreement with everything we know about physics, contrary to what some people (e.g. Motl) claim)? </p>
g7459
[ 0.030040251091122627, 0.04878595098853111, 0.010472389869391918, -0.023225469514727592, 0.022861743345856667, 0.019570674747228622, 0.03634697571396828, 0.0034855909179896116, -0.052397556602954865, 0.017265331000089645, 0.03029707446694374, -0.009429842233657837, -0.007635440211743116, 0.015478397719562054, -0.08108492195606232, -0.011711154133081436, -0.0032155525404959917, 0.04516337439417839, 0.04866015538573265, 0.013510331511497498, 0.03839500993490219, -0.011565499939024448, -0.018950670957565308, -0.020519910380244255, -0.029758013784885406, 0.019832396879792213, -0.08001917600631714, -0.054608263075351715, 0.020863303914666176, 0.007658218964934349, -0.023280860856175423, -0.01846890151500702, 0.07202553749084473, -0.06997194141149521, -0.02894723415374756, -0.012935839593410492, 0.04351228103041649, -0.048966068774461746, 0.0029768843669444323, 0.008175884373486042, -0.03145989775657654, -0.0501520037651062, -0.03384952247142792, -0.0028698579408228397, -0.05083979293704033, 0.025429364293813705, 0.01164337620139122, 0.008047384209930897, -0.008761841803789139, -0.04932670667767525, 0.06545554846525192, -0.02327766641974449, 0.04238711670041084, 0.04740780219435692, -0.0012708556605502963, 0.029593337327241898, -0.003819397883489728, 0.028130725026130676, 0.07359851151704788, -0.03883817419409752, 0.017348023131489754, 0.0244852676987648, -0.028277171775698662, 0.05376732721924782, 0.022571586072444916, 0.03553885594010353, 0.007954010739922523, -0.012569308280944824, 0.029365388676524162, 0.054418228566646576, 0.04488558694720268, -0.027598029002547264, -0.03046812303364277, -0.006196575239300728, 0.002074343152344227, 0.011659304611384869, -0.02082754112780094, -0.004040816333144903, 0.030209984630346298, 0.005548244807869196, -0.02362845279276371, -0.06758356839418411, 0.03186862915754318, -0.03098379261791706, 0.02706650085747242, -0.002208240330219269, -0.04731927067041397, 0.04345329850912094, 0.009732616133987904, 0.11834405362606049, 0.00983729399740696, -0.03689873218536377, 0.07938798516988754, 0.05439800024032593, 0.011758879758417606, -0.004212245810776949, 0.006937302649021149, -0.038807157427072525, 0.028155440464615822, -0.037060003727674484, -0.021525127813220024, 0.002577361185103655, 0.029804978519678116, 0.002598260762169957, 0.015514908358454704, -0.017358681187033653, -0.021258441731333733, 0.00870850495994091, -0.010097440332174301, 0.024074040353298187, -0.022855045273900032, -0.0005977759719826281, -0.06283554434776306, -0.02166769467294216, -0.03833690285682678, -0.003948241006582975, 0.03759629651904106, -0.030524997040629387, -0.04999617114663124, -0.008931351825594902, -0.05129929259419441, 0.012255141511559486, 0.07639976590871811, 0.024768095463514328, 0.005821733269840479, 0.02117772586643696, -0.022079117596149445, -0.04584275558590889, 0.008250199258327484, -0.04552213475108147, 0.031036455184221268, 0.04802445322275162, -0.07755187898874283, 0.041403885930776596, -0.008830374106764793, 0.018711574375629425, 0.019623471423983574, -0.023569494485855103, 0.08547260612249374, 0.017156051471829414, 0.00863998755812645, -0.03430682793259621, -0.043858014047145844, -0.016388479620218277, 0.06822101026773453, -0.028842926025390625, 0.0268817488104105, 0.016883544623851776, 0.01355486735701561, 0.048183877021074295, -0.0020038620568811893, 0.03909078612923622, 0.005718696396797895, -0.04232969507575035, -0.040126193314790726, 0.022206643596291542, -0.012546743266284466, -0.009592726826667786, -0.05600418895483017, 0.026362959295511246, 0.06134821102023125, 0.003707891097292304, 0.054595693945884705, 0.02328646369278431, -0.018643219023942947, 0.0009631803259253502, -0.019815495237708092, -0.006723694037646055, 0.006391018163412809, 0.02428600564599037, -0.0536995604634285, 0.0341857373714447, -0.045956533402204514, -0.036195579916238785, 0.01300698984414339, 0.05718148499727249, -0.019047636538743973, 0.009367566555738449, 0.05338575318455696, 0.015628743916749954, -0.017081422731280327, 0.028702329844236374, 0.03909100964665413, -0.005582605954259634, -0.02769632451236248, -0.019199185073375702, 0.009933770634233952, 0.022516382858157158, -0.025405164808034897, -0.04318750649690628, -0.07951635867357254, -0.019892120733857155, -0.0017718314193189144, -0.005385896191000938, 0.008343366906046867, 0.00245640124194324, -0.000899953069165349, -0.02731390669941902, 0.007970057427883148, 0.021284276619553566, -0.06841284781694412, 0.0377538725733757, -0.02580215036869049, 0.005706755444407463, 0.018074236810207367, 0.050489362329244614, 0.040365878492593765, 0.007714070379734039, 0.0400189645588398, -0.029251983389258385, 0.015409276820719242, 0.03862276300787926, 0.007374897599220276, 0.04442169517278671, 0.003744639689102769, -0.03845501318573952, 0.0033558339346200228, 0.019613806158304214, 0.0010967064881697297, 0.0031662818510085344, 0.06335107237100601, -0.02839391864836216, -0.012665783986449242, 0.015041188336908817, 0.0032260434236377478, 0.01970028690993786, -0.08931415528059006, -0.06008147820830345, -0.056958798319101334, 0.05638517066836357, -0.03479201719164848, -0.07029622793197632, -0.045812949538230896, -0.020196618512272835, 0.02892211638391018, -0.011736092157661915, 0.02693266049027443, -0.06259971857070923, 0.06801985949277878, 0.04702155664563179, 0.04729936644434929, 0.03802986443042755, -0.05405387654900551, 0.014740091748535633, 0.020847344771027565, -0.05619681254029274, -0.013347065076231956, -0.02951020374894142, -0.03748670592904091, -0.026297777891159058, -0.050582535564899445, -0.05006391182541847, -0.04949205741286278, -0.03587394952774048, 0.013448054902255535, 0.03126375004649162, 0.026150871068239212, -0.026843052357435226, 0.013640288263559341, 0.02046014368534088, 0.029152484610676765, -0.016272397711873055, 0.0026401448994874954, 0.09148095548152924, -0.03533676266670227, -0.05068214610219002, -0.0189188402146101, -0.0072870575822889805, -0.053398676216602325, -0.05426880344748497, 0.04392195865511894, 0.07084954530000687, -0.04518555477261543, -0.0005995607352815568, -0.006588010583072901, -0.01726042479276657, -0.020844561979174614, 0.049627941101789474, 0.011660736054182053, -0.04093407839536667, -0.09318778663873672, 0.008408540859818459, -0.024942250922322273, 0.009897513315081596, 0.06235284358263016, -0.02608805149793625, -0.03131825476884842, -0.027276087552309036, 0.025508079677820206, -0.020581508055329323, 0.030798358842730522, 0.01273298542946577, 0.020145483314990997, 0.05453451722860336, -0.06238425150513649, 0.009424110874533653, -0.0005843030521646142, -0.021453263238072395, -0.044179391115903854, 0.03966345638036728, -0.021430538967251778, 0.01808781363070011, -0.011609054170548916, 0.047930099070072174, 0.029848961159586906, -0.04481273517012596, -0.019604969769716263, 0.01838526874780655, -0.01269727572798729, -0.041647959500551224, -0.007814467884600163, 0.031862229108810425, 0.021058272570371628, -0.017038805410265923, -0.032611824572086334, -0.0013482888462021947, 0.009799542836844921, 0.0449310764670372, 0.02792833372950554, -0.018064294010400772, -0.020115304738283157, 0.04449082911014557, 0.008842289447784424, -0.07105929404497147, 0.09822782129049301, 0.07145638018846512, -0.04552258923649788, 0.05542409420013428, -0.023213807493448257, -0.03130955994129181, 0.04630972072482109, 0.0020456789061427116, 0.012441922910511494, 0.019083606079220772, -0.04816756024956703, -0.10159273445606232, 0.0011734861182048917, 0.038910795003175735, 0.04958803206682205, -0.05671827122569084, 0.019315620884299278, 0.017346631735563278, -0.009951609186828136, 0.040759507566690445, -0.001351432641968131, 0.012343361042439938, -0.038162801414728165, -0.024758607149124146, 0.040203653275966644, -0.05571942776441574, 0.019179902970790863, 0.06017036363482475, 0.013155193999409676, 0.016352731734514236, -0.004472251515835524, 0.051394905894994736, 0.039331965148448944, 0.05096912384033203, 0.04913151636719704, -0.014957096427679062, -0.006051850970834494, 0.031190285459160805, 0.04437777400016785, 0.01924126222729683, -0.002751358551904559, 0.016593284904956818, -0.02823476865887642, 0.02825428918004036, 0.027938907966017723, -0.04513191431760788, -0.05138460919260979, 0.03837265446782112, 0.03225042670965195, 0.04633329063653946, 0.04452208802103996, -0.018599720671772957, 0.05980588123202324, 0.010749442502856255, 0.017478715628385544, -0.03965039923787117, 0.04690368101000786, -0.013125965371727943, 0.014581285417079926, -0.005449650343507528, 0.006294115446507931, -0.006297345273196697, -0.05727648362517357, -0.0048521156422793865, -0.021739011630415916, 0.03459761664271355, -0.03638612478971481, 0.011603654362261295, -0.023929165676236153, 0.025041630491614342, 0.027728799730539322, -0.004536003805696964, -0.027918796986341476, -0.026426346972584724, 0.0006637262995354831, -0.04494323208928108, 0.015515891835093498, -0.0266084223985672, 0.0105637451633811, 0.012517783790826797, -0.038471613079309464, 0.00568706588819623, 0.007380338851362467, -0.04384121671319008, -0.02839621901512146, -0.035235676914453506, -0.006144930608570576, 0.0536634624004364, 0.0013218512758612633, -0.08090056478977203, 0.004193063359707594, 0.02779218927025795, 0.003126144176349044, -0.007903581485152245, -0.021732522174715996, -0.017843328416347504, 0.02349899895489216, 0.06528915464878082, -0.01214966643601656, 0.000606352521572262, -0.05471574887633324, 0.000505104020703584, -0.021408768370747566, -0.018673107028007507, -0.048525817692279816, -0.07320068031549454, 0.038208283483982086, 0.002863213187083602, 0.01597200334072113, 0.058312345296144485, -0.025681473314762115, 0.04068247228860855, -0.04816432297229767, 0.045469049364328384, -0.01630525104701519, -0.006328199990093708, 0.06730940192937851, -0.0010668495669960976, 0.01754961907863617, -0.01343077514320612, -0.013599388301372528, -0.004028516821563244, -0.026389027014374733, 0.01787576824426651, -0.05579524114727974, -0.03469524160027504, -0.000312788033625111, 0.05215019732713699, -0.021217044442892075, -0.008021349087357521, 0.01604708470404148, -0.030376441776752472, -0.03311324864625931, 0.009121883660554886, -0.018866706639528275, 0.023179182782769203, -0.12022338807582855, -0.06175009533762932, 0.019448280334472656, 0.04377437382936478, -0.036400292068719864, -0.005525733344256878, -0.07056771963834763, 0.016727028414607048, -0.0014719843165948987, -0.0472087487578392, -0.007719820365309715, -0.00949794240295887, 0.03736136481165886, -0.004296556115150452, 0.02795577608048916, -0.03293439373373985, 0.021167071536183357, -0.008729826658964157, -0.032896433025598526, 0.04053063318133354, 0.014660236425697803, 0.021552104502916336, -0.005196043290197849, 0.030804118141531944, -0.002891262760385871, 0.028011120855808258, 0.01646299846470356, 0.019353510811924934, -0.0953013002872467, -0.00055927864741534, 0.045440953224897385, 0.01774129830300808, 0.007106429431587458, -0.04199147969484329, -0.05957673117518425, -0.013581778854131699, 0.006553171668201685, 0.016333144158124924, -0.011205961927771568, 0.10711350291967392, -0.07081899046897888, 0.009654592722654343, 0.022544555366039276, -0.020227447152137756, -0.02179855667054653, 0.00969373993575573, 0.10512324422597885, -0.04057632386684418, -0.03365534171462059, 0.010107879526913166, -0.003025470534339547, 0.021081537008285522, -0.032449573278427124, 0.031068162992596626, 0.012171574868261814, -0.014129364863038063, 0.00985540822148323, 0.014708629809319973, -0.023202212527394295, -0.012390399351716042, 0.004540060646831989, 0.02985299937427044, 0.03706330060958862, 0.01245349831879139, 0.019374674186110497, -0.017019912600517273, 0.002051627729088068, -0.05911335349082947, -0.01390264555811882, 0.04364003241062164, 0.05160266160964966, 0.07609517127275467, 0.015047822147607803, 0.03337603062391281, 0.0007825617794878781, 0.011868791654706001, -0.007767410948872566, -0.010417373850941658, 0.0010997036006301641, 0.05496930703520775, -0.010264281183481216, 0.04931746423244476, -0.018408890813589096, 0.08838798850774765, -0.018083563074469566, 0.041555680334568024, -0.06181871145963669, 0.014722044579684734, 0.04381677880883217, -0.0743892714381218, -0.07885726541280746, -0.042106229811906815, 0.011357112787663937, 0.02250620722770691, -0.029502518475055695, -0.004772666841745377, -0.03419478237628937, -0.029346995055675507, 0.01827402040362358, 0.06310071051120758, 0.006774295121431351, 0.06795262545347214, 0.04165938124060631, -0.02214076556265354, 0.032597318291664124, 0.04525598883628845, -0.01510712131857872, -0.03516825661063194, 0.001585390535183251, 0.03017996996641159, 0.0015985507052391768, 0.017237337306141853, -0.010632329620420933, -0.02236758917570114, 0.015265596099197865, -0.025569790974259377, -0.02716318517923355, -0.06283851712942123, -0.041779860854148865, -0.056448403745889664, 0.014687021262943745, -0.02479993738234043, 0.08776421844959259, -0.07857269793748856, 0.04601335525512695, 0.019777951762080193, -0.03250947594642639, 0.007619245909154415, 0.023986583575606346, 0.03218390420079231, -0.04088558629155159, 0.04013964906334877, 0.03949730098247528, -0.0035346902441233397, -0.019262954592704773, -0.044305965304374695, 0.04543376341462135, 0.037777818739414215, -0.021494250744581223, -0.04870973899960518, -0.03994583711028099, -0.04059901461005211, 0.03773900866508484, -0.015719493851065636, 0.03799263760447502, 0.08947913348674774, -0.021142274141311646, 0.038184475153684616, -0.02261015772819519, 0.013188603334128857, -0.04938126355409622, 0.003560583805665374, -0.0062660337425768375, 0.02332145906984806, 0.007335432805120945, -0.09164741635322571, -0.04957783967256546, 0.006680728867650032, -0.03662563115358353, -0.0012135013239458203, 0.07441845536231995, -0.017498599365353584, -0.056250493973493576, 0.01724008284509182, 0.03380703181028366, 0.06746883690357208, -0.0029458790086209774, 0.031026968732476234, 0.06597170233726501, -0.009650024585425854, 0.019502324983477592, -0.00661326851695776, 0.027579415589571, 0.05664505809545517, 0.007481427863240242, 0.050907835364341736, -0.05798441171646118, 0.010453547351062298, -0.024523228406906128, 0.019367026165127754, 0.022823333740234375, -0.012311193160712719, 0.048246119171381, 0.020443018525838852, -0.007781093940138817, -0.036288630217313766, 0.02913760207593441, 0.004113435745239258, -0.04773029312491417, 0.01189478114247322, -0.0012500969460234046, 0.028529589995741844, -0.008012674748897552, 0.014903277158737183, -0.024781830608844757, 0.026189647614955902, 0.003064665012061596, 0.0077554406598210335, -0.002733084838837385, -0.022562474012374878, -0.05127352103590965, -0.0251432154327631, -0.04766278341412544, -0.0426069013774395, 0.020491790026426315, -0.014151700772345066, -0.04305172339081764, 0.013751558028161526, -0.02755984291434288, 0.035518813878297806, -0.00007747359632048756, -0.06451533734798431, -0.023610439151525497, 0.028521062806248665, 0.01638217456638813, -0.034221064299345016, -0.018299737945199013, 0.020610658451914787, -0.025462403893470764, -0.03807218372821808, -0.0011727686505764723, 0.05667930096387863, 0.02557990327477455, 0.0613522082567215, 0.013659651391208172, -0.009880069643259048, 0.010359794832766056, 0.007989476434886456, -0.06293921172618866, -0.0383235327899456, 0.018328433856368065, -0.06521544605493546, 0.03528765216469765, -0.04419585317373276, -0.023100804537534714, 0.010152295231819153, 0.004455744754523039, -0.020683418959379196, 0.016749387606978416, 0.037521347403526306, 0.00517280213534832, 0.028113113716244698, -0.014606988057494164, 0.007957011461257935, 0.048143476247787476, -0.022679205983877182, -0.008376617915928364, 0.040472254157066345, -0.049364831298589706, 0.0032030646689236164, -0.031772714108228683, 0.011969516053795815, -0.021619604900479317, -0.0022526495158672333, 0.013603917323052883, -0.03747411072254181, -0.011746656149625778, -0.030210720375180244, -0.03783247619867325, -0.014066863805055618, 0.018393708392977715, -0.07269025593996048, -0.07573341578245163, -0.03775165602564812, -0.006013922393321991, 0.023651044815778732, -0.009584306739270687, 0.06981922686100006, 0.026403913274407387, -0.009954229928553104, 0.003613518550992012, -0.03692949563264847, -0.010770880617201328, -0.005587349645793438, -0.04358155280351639, 0.04098452627658844, -0.02723109722137451, 0.022479994222521782, -0.05369361862540245, -0.0283118337392807, 0.00849298294633627, 0.003499855985864997, 0.052459850907325745, -0.027397042140364647, -0.03194773197174072, -0.05295588821172714, -0.05134304612874985, 0.001945031457580626, 0.033164817839860916, -0.019273512065410614, 0.023395080119371414, -0.009071607142686844, -0.029028039425611496, 0.026254495605826378, 0.013221010565757751, 0.006484457291662693, -0.046641185879707336, 0.0054181842133402824, 0.09835577756166458, -0.03039783239364624, 0.010130644775927067, -0.031615156680345535, 0.04403972625732422, 0.03604179248213768, -0.04107198864221573, -0.019676459953188896, 0.037134092301130295, 0.028751222416758537 ]
<p>According to numerous sources online, the percentage of oxygen is approximately the same at sea level and 10,000 meters. Since oxygen is heavier than nitrogen, shouldn't the percentage of oxygen decrease with altitude?</p>
g7460
[ 0.051258958876132965, -0.037551116198301315, 0.004708233289420605, 0.12099049985408783, -0.0004583863483276218, 0.04413507878780365, 0.015382256358861923, 0.04337773472070694, -0.031207965686917305, 0.020015330985188484, 0.005703839939087629, -0.040591299533843994, -0.011202938854694366, 0.02094137668609619, -0.010931688360869884, 0.07083404064178467, 0.023064902052283287, -0.06793364882469177, 0.039755381643772125, -0.026716751977801323, -0.04456824064254761, -0.021015040576457977, -0.008164545521140099, 0.0006261100643314421, -0.05642383545637131, 0.060153860598802567, 0.02708965167403221, -0.025115592405200005, -0.05529116466641426, 0.05602319538593292, 0.058514680713415146, 0.013301098719239235, 0.05002889037132263, 0.0302688367664814, -0.022110486403107643, -0.032762520015239716, -0.019849810749292374, 0.03879937902092934, 0.034778665751218796, 0.023064345121383667, 0.052821073681116104, 0.004042261280119419, -0.01110596489161253, 0.013014021329581738, -0.049505144357681274, -0.012592912651598454, -0.03291906788945198, -0.020004913210868835, -0.0040900977328419685, -0.021665869280695915, 0.0015479634748771787, 0.035837672650814056, -0.05435774475336075, 0.04354941472411156, 0.01711956597864628, -0.020601261407136917, 0.0020898552611470222, 0.01402836199849844, -0.02476346865296364, 0.08952471613883972, -0.017080675810575485, 0.0035059356596320868, 0.014232797548174858, 0.010329581797122955, 0.060463931411504745, -0.004903674125671387, -0.04358232393860817, 0.0002524508163332939, 0.05796471983194351, 0.050141558051109314, 0.030342761427164078, -0.0029702219180762768, -0.08807779103517532, -0.006983643397688866, -0.07017754018306732, -0.030011994764208794, -0.02451162040233612, 0.0018454397795721889, 0.04196157306432724, -0.005846050102263689, 0.005124757066369057, 0.023921286687254906, 0.019693979993462563, 0.02305782027542591, 0.015987632796168327, -0.02854163572192192, 0.017473023384809494, -0.02514677681028843, -0.027553759515285492, 0.04995061829686165, 0.04083975404500961, 0.026417866349220276, 0.08883202821016312, 0.0018366932636126876, 0.054028380662202835, -0.021296685561537743, 0.07212139666080475, 0.05910951644182205, 0.02283521369099617, 0.006546772550791502, -0.03921910747885704, -0.09600915759801865, 0.03019702062010765, 0.03779797628521919, -0.005564494524151087, 0.0001007767059491016, -0.0001130566670326516, -0.007872379384934902, 0.023614250123500824, -0.02762368880212307, 0.03667505085468292, 0.03178910166025162, -0.05325701832771301, -0.042314182966947556, -0.06320609897375107, -0.024435311555862427, 0.021497689187526703, 0.01802859641611576, 0.002327214227989316, -0.05155549570918083, 0.035377439111471176, 0.020709510892629623, -0.0338241271674633, 0.002482030540704727, -0.019901813939213753, -0.006847078911960125, -0.01146004069596529, -0.02298683114349842, -0.04787120595574379, -0.04757910221815109, 0.014013881795108318, 0.024908341467380524, -0.06724432855844498, 0.0017863154644146562, 0.007613931782543659, -0.017637906596064568, -0.10962438583374023, -0.0097897844389081, 0.009509830735623837, 0.01731145940721035, 0.029786059632897377, 0.0003651601728051901, 0.01845141500234604, -0.0136819863691926, -0.024576298892498016, -0.01363736018538475, -0.008387398906052113, 0.03793333098292351, 0.032198790460824966, 0.017027292400598526, -0.007672801613807678, 0.0048438687808811665, 0.10063803941011429, -0.017637824639678, -0.032926443964242935, -0.014725567772984505, -0.022397464141249657, 0.024670664221048355, 0.00017804633534979075, 0.04492219164967537, -0.0015174567233771086, 0.0010532825253903866, 0.06437646597623825, -0.01880808360874653, -0.05413990095257759, 0.011350669898092747, -0.00465377327054739, 0.0033821293618530035, -0.01983761228621006, -0.014083607122302055, -0.0046898843720555305, 0.03354748710989952, 0.03348477929830551, 0.021237943321466446, 0.01883995532989502, 0.06325176358222961, 0.09530242532491684, 0.05092277750372887, -0.04651666060090065, -0.0020884466357529163, -0.018496805801987648, 0.0014041741378605366, 0.0012299554655328393, -0.09005666524171829, 0.0016975856851786375, 0.0316682793200016, 0.014126292429864407, -0.012473001144826412, -0.04510248452425003, -0.0022878616582602262, 0.053274113684892654, -0.043318238109350204, 0.005379353184252977, -0.005439749453216791, -0.007100262213498354, 0.010145516134798527, -0.013755090534687042, 0.005778782535344362, -0.00164717435836792, 0.08491578698158264, -0.042186301201581955, -0.015660319477319717, -0.014261910691857338, -0.02596612088382244, -0.005881779361516237, 0.039201874285936356, 0.014680945314466953, 0.027814630419015884, 0.02341257967054844, 0.018871763721108437, -0.023469766601920128, 0.014365863986313343, 0.03550152853131294, 0.062329165637493134, 0.008964037522673607, 0.06834974139928818, -0.013218427076935768, 0.00561420526355505, -0.022970188409090042, -0.015477452427148819, -0.04451596736907959, -0.03956526517868042, 0.004201983567327261, -0.002380657009780407, 0.0018317163921892643, -0.04426981136202812, -0.037427712231874466, -0.027982095256447792, 0.00664146663621068, -0.009076890535652637, -0.01794026792049408, 0.0029100205283612013, -0.020157139748334885, -0.0009744820999912918, -0.0027491494547575712, 0.002302409615367651, 0.03624475374817848, 0.029922986403107643, 0.030485596507787704, -0.00894816406071186, 0.017527282238006592, -0.019599251449108124, -0.008302561938762665, 0.028945066034793854, 0.04529687389731407, 0.007730197627097368, -0.052496254444122314, 0.0038357076700776815, -0.06832291185855865, 0.029463810846209526, -0.02793995477259159, 0.0017945996951311827, -0.0033005885779857635, 0.08443433791399002, -0.015909673646092415, 0.01611992157995701, -0.036862898617982864, -0.035072825849056244, -0.016156397759914398, 0.030247054994106293, -0.05657228082418442, -0.02665551006793976, 0.005863322410732508, -0.042960233986377716, -0.07401813566684723, -0.00039778108475729823, -0.04623856768012047, -0.02170575223863125, 0.07637660205364227, -0.013990799896419048, 0.006186955142766237, 0.048180606216192245, -0.040450915694236755, 0.054545775055885315, -0.024221552535891533, -0.02653970755636692, -0.03587500751018524, 0.033331893384456635, 0.027739359065890312, -0.034469783306121826, 0.013068870641291142, 0.026690993458032608, -0.02008327655494213, 0.03748727962374687, 0.01621125265955925, -0.03419126570224762, -0.022715043276548386, 0.03481226786971092, -0.024514339864253998, -0.029609454795718193, 0.02876640297472477, -0.06029642000794411, 0.0990762785077095, 0.039804939180612564, 0.02288319729268551, 0.019277598708868027, 0.10151238739490509, -0.03683166950941086, -0.04027082398533821, 0.012522679753601551, 0.020625000819563866, -0.03185516223311424, 0.05976423993706703, 0.06167079135775566, -0.0009853674564510584, 0.06718071550130844, -0.03481259569525719, -0.04626147076487541, -0.052075985819101334, 0.03621057793498039, -0.03232928737998009, -0.003249037079513073, 0.027475791051983833, 0.051009178161621094, -0.0010191675974056125, -0.017701521515846252, -0.0529087595641613, -0.03150768578052521, 0.0410849004983902, -0.02111830562353134, -0.06292621791362762, -0.11061794310808182, -0.03034053184092045, -0.02869037352502346, -0.03491454944014549, 0.015477972105145454, -0.012227031402289867, -0.0005840301746502519, -0.02951473370194435, -0.009435524232685566, 0.0032101571559906006, 0.04480593651533127, -0.01781247742474079, 0.029194599017500877, -0.05276986584067345, 0.04139376059174538, 0.012741913087666035, 0.014497595839202404, -0.007115499582141638, 0.018110938370227814, -0.04879629984498024, 0.05629902705550194, 0.02813304401934147, -0.025709709152579308, 0.038181789219379425, 0.008489699102938175, -0.05179709941148758, -0.04979557916522026, -0.0660284161567688, 0.039307788014411926, 0.058376215398311615, -0.03133172541856766, 0.006739105563610792, -0.06006050109863281, -0.014182806946337223, 0.004579466301947832, -0.000175693683559075, 0.003706487361341715, -0.02041328139603138, 0.011054988950490952, 0.05167381465435028, 0.024422595277428627, 0.0010056316386908293, 0.03451820835471153, -0.06717580556869507, -0.022479871287941933, -0.0338892936706543, 0.02636001631617546, -0.015894392505288124, -0.024771682918071747, 0.018144074827432632, 0.009343691170215607, -0.05298491194844246, 0.005648106802254915, 0.009116465225815773, -0.024684414267539978, 0.05564403533935547, -0.01577208749949932, 0.058422017842531204, 0.011154216714203358, 0.051361169666051865, -0.04113030433654785, -0.00228861509822309, -0.060202706605196, 0.011469073593616486, -0.037989769130945206, -0.004580208566039801, -0.004405168350785971, 0.000129808351630345, -0.047277119010686874, -0.05138346552848816, -0.07484956085681915, 0.012298810295760632, 0.04972806200385094, 0.024885963648557663, 0.004247148055583239, 0.0033870507031679153, 0.05765640363097191, 0.044512420892715454, 0.07121261954307556, -0.0034868670627474785, 0.03568722680211067, 0.04482434317469597, 0.03454329073429108, 0.031592220067977905, 0.01167188212275505, 0.06229492649435997, 0.034643713384866714, 0.006153837312012911, 0.062138933688402176, 0.0771278440952301, -0.010439464822411537, -0.06986315548419952, -0.010940710082650185, 0.015386175364255905, 0.0052865855395793915, -0.03338806703686714, 0.02124064974486828, -0.0030549264047294855, 0.02825702726840973, -0.003453984623774886, 0.043533626943826675, -0.025425733998417854, -0.02170105092227459, -0.03855947032570839, 0.07565484195947647, -0.02695457451045513, -0.007197987288236618, -0.0003139369946438819, 0.048058558255434036, -0.018862005323171616, 0.03167394921183586, 0.0024986660573631525, 0.009918573312461376, -0.031216874718666077, 0.023318815976381302, 0.017329450696706772, -0.004061395768076181, 0.02028338983654976, 0.011374005116522312, 0.008092036470770836, 0.09314022213220596, -0.020203812047839165, 0.0036639305762946606, -0.008402729406952858, 0.027492154389619827, 0.0058504738844931126, -0.004132893402129412, -0.03236030042171478, 0.0312521755695343, -0.04869198054075241, -0.014070024713873863, 0.02250104397535324, 0.042009010910987854, -0.05311956629157066, -0.014556260779500008, 0.04729191213846207, 0.003237753640860319, 0.025606978684663773, 0.030518222600221634, -0.08819559216499329, -0.029155191034078598, 0.03195202723145485, 0.001175164245069027, -0.0024531895760446787, -0.008362784050405025, -0.0523919053375721, 0.04162922501564026, -0.014174440875649452, 0.02398955263197422, -0.016855154186487198, -0.03977880999445915, 0.0025989876594394445, 0.0234882440418005, 0.03681710362434387, 0.03472815826535225, -0.019696926698088646, -0.04615493491292, 0.0004567708820104599, -0.04264472424983978, 0.006348512135446072, -0.054217834025621414, -0.027485409751534462, 0.03593582659959793, -0.00759836845099926, -0.00520529318600893, -0.04779839515686035, -0.008851725608110428, 0.03401002287864685, -0.022157786414027214, 0.005890058819204569, 0.038469959050416946, -0.05748474970459938, 0.01875685341656208, -0.041361499577760696, -0.006916390266269445, 0.022315481677651405, 0.02389581874012947, 0.011703742668032646, -0.028826503083109856, -0.03392765671014786, 0.013190093450248241, -0.01668674871325493, -0.03530536964535713, -0.04837775602936745, -0.00899332296103239, 0.03343919292092323, 0.005074803251773119, 0.03845064714550972, 0.03354081138968468, -0.006261587142944336, -0.02056945115327835, -0.06642354279756546, 0.0635845959186554, 0.04374910891056061, -0.024860043078660965, -0.010313761420547962, 0.06359637528657913, -0.002179278526455164, 0.037438422441482544, 0.08424191921949387, -0.03702843189239502, 0.06430692225694656, 0.039354514330625534, 0.026142489165067673, 0.01349963340908289, -0.023739436641335487, -0.0059956395998597145, -0.03659238666296005, -0.001960848458111286, 0.0003584203659556806, 0.013846651650965214, 0.013609427958726883, -0.03338557481765747, 0.004032446537166834, -0.012209288775920868, -0.0015269098803400993, -0.024805577471852303, 0.038369372487068176, 0.01615220122039318, 0.007323869504034519, -0.02551756054162979, -0.007806940469890833, 0.07898136973381042, 0.05069860816001892, 0.006648511625826359, -0.058825213462114334, -0.0010619848035275936, 0.03719043731689453, -0.011493563652038574, -0.026850391179323196, 0.01884814351797104, -0.04774489253759384, 0.013186901807785034, -0.03165648505091667, 0.01772519387304783, 0.06035144254565239, 0.04538270831108093, -0.022444147616624832, -0.013907099142670631, 0.08095654100179672, 0.0025192901957780123, 0.0008498778333887458, 0.030284732580184937, 0.04137197136878967, -0.026468871161341667, -0.020468344911932945, 0.030449112877249718, 0.0057139634154737, -0.027271559461951256, -0.027484387159347534, 0.023782020434737206, -0.05306756868958473, 0.005053855944424868, 0.01948004774749279, -0.0032704886980354786, -0.0308283232152462, -0.04217363893985748, 0.05581531673669815, -0.023821644484996796, 0.027153201401233673, -0.06346126645803452, 0.02818077988922596, -0.05343548208475113, -0.06537751108407974, -0.048248693346977234, 0.00043358549010008574, -0.010520817711949348, 0.08690532296895981, 0.04021352902054787, 0.0029904809780418873, -0.042609553784132004, 0.027021171525120735, -0.005368299316614866, -0.05944083258509636, -0.04644973576068878, 0.018506186082959175, -0.010031563229858875, 0.006357577629387379, 0.007219300605356693, 0.10111285746097565, 0.011800399050116539, 0.05790498107671738, -0.040915366262197495, 0.02341204136610031, 0.05462035909295082, 0.06174962595105171, 0.02198179066181183, 0.02965575084090233, 0.00027615411090664566, -0.013727204874157906, 0.01608016900718212, -0.044686924666166306, -0.025069771334528923, 0.01618312858045101, -0.01678212732076645, 0.014302453026175499, 0.031238077208399773, -0.055288705974817276, 0.025827009230852127, -0.03717340528964996, 0.03073878027498722, -0.025709107518196106, 0.010259625501930714, 0.021916193887591362, -0.0049277436919510365, 0.03141563758254051, 0.009147132746875286, 0.018890710547566414, -0.05802340805530548, -0.007500248029828072, 0.013971333391964436, -0.01625114306807518, -0.003459546947851777, -0.027698831632733345, -0.010175547562539577, 0.01819426752626896, -0.04414653778076172, 0.03797769919037819, 0.014753215946257114, -0.017832845449447632, -0.05445408076047897, 0.020378731191158295, 0.008875726722180843, 0.006884702015668154, -0.012411515228450298, 0.009342357516288757, -0.04073306545615196, -0.045614901930093765, 0.04433128237724304, 0.0180447306483984, -0.028033223003149033, -0.022153416648507118, 0.019656341522932053, 0.008727255277335644, 0.03816552087664604, -0.0366818867623806, 0.01367625966668129, -0.00626740138977766, -0.03131964057683945, -0.026863470673561096, -0.011345337145030499, -0.027727335691452026, 0.021485473960638046, -0.0071639129891991615, -0.028398927301168442, -0.03368539735674858, -0.09736120700836182, 0.006462132558226585, 0.036112796515226364, 0.00013360480079427361, -0.013856800273060799, -0.03353545442223549, -0.0375533364713192, -0.053236957639455795, 0.03241175413131714, -0.04355114698410034, -0.06268920004367828, -0.024230901151895523, 0.06940300762653351, 0.053563762456178665, -0.015094222500920296, -0.006336967460811138, -0.08243121951818466, 0.054978806525468826, -0.043574258685112, -0.025981396436691284, -0.012183090671896935, 0.005807352717965841, -0.0420009009540081, -0.016611488536000252, -0.05342902988195419, -0.0008881004177965224, -0.051046960055828094, -0.025791382417082787, 0.03693235293030739, 0.031273942440748215, -0.007468872237950563, -0.008193109184503555, -0.050435349345207214, 0.01933392509818077, -0.022545788437128067, -0.018460780382156372, -0.022413231432437897, -0.03572549298405647, 0.014966197311878204, 0.025138629600405693, 0.05350465327501297, -0.027928855270147324, -0.03858920559287071, -0.02565186470746994, 0.0009455125546082854, 0.036412253975868225, -0.020073700696229935, -0.00930778868496418, -0.02229410782456398, -0.008628584444522858, -0.09053178876638412, -0.06290841102600098, -0.03206648677587509, 0.022892463952302933, -0.025564715266227722, 0.029898475855588913, -0.029876800253987312, -0.048251185566186905, 0.053065523505210876, 0.07812861353158951, 0.0016509509878233075, 0.08151215314865112, -0.05452202260494232, 0.006087824702262878, 0.001220201258547604, -0.010560319758951664, -0.005295236129313707, 0.026665672659873962, -0.07707066088914871, 0.028101138770580292, -0.04711813107132912, 0.04274551570415497, -0.011538475751876831, 0.02826155535876751, 0.04545680433511734, -0.03622796759009361, -0.02331959456205368, -0.0007437219028361142, -0.0636407658457756, 0.035320132970809937, 0.038164377212524414, 0.020756270736455917, -0.035696644335985184, 0.014622407965362072, -0.05834681913256645, -0.014403164386749268, -0.020474500954151154, 0.03386637195944786, 0.012637222185730934, 0.02461925521492958, -0.03639870882034302, -0.02116883173584938, -0.014806870371103287, -0.009136661887168884, -0.0004980710218660533, 0.0249332282692194, -0.023594973608851433, -0.04178653284907341, -0.03378792479634285, -0.010370348580181599, -0.004505939316004515 ]
<p>If I had a 3V battery, and when no load connected it reads 3.2V, and with a load 2.8V (just a hypothetical example), what is the name for these two terms, with a load or no load?</p> <p>I know the voltage drop occurs due to its internal resistance when a load is connected, however I still am not sure of the terms. Here's a few which may be of help:</p> <ul> <li><p>emf ($\mathcal{E}$)</p></li> <li><p>Potential difference</p></li> <li><p>Terminal voltage</p></li> </ul> <p>Any help would be appreciated in what these terms are called, this is one of those questions where it almost seems too simple to find this answer online.</p>
g7461
[ 0.05725133791565895, -0.027981245890259743, -0.021943556144833565, -0.03831331804394722, 0.07322610914707184, 0.03054318204522133, 0.0013671265915036201, -0.015455975197255611, -0.0484713576734066, 0.008791288360953331, -0.051610272377729416, 0.0178734939545393, 0.009350580163300037, -0.014254945330321789, 0.027949320152401924, 0.02109193056821823, 0.09098335355520248, 0.031123699620366096, 0.07461769878864288, -0.03786331042647362, -0.05046902224421501, 0.026801472529768944, -0.03538826107978821, 0.00359708652831614, -0.00404659379273653, -0.02131316065788269, -0.0314837284386158, 0.006124111358076334, -0.057131655514240265, -0.03981059417128563, -0.03910420835018158, -0.0561559721827507, 0.057031307369470596, -0.04364581033587456, -0.016070878133177757, 0.04834694042801857, 0.06162738800048828, 0.11646676063537598, -0.03288006782531738, 0.03456062823534012, 0.012827437371015549, 0.020851299166679382, 0.05688711628317833, -0.0015573252458125353, -0.049155883491039276, -0.06001994013786316, -0.04634293168783188, 0.0010310179786756635, 0.005995540879666805, -0.03581782430410385, 0.006783226039260626, 0.018997034057974815, 0.02327769808471203, 0.0044976710341870785, 0.048423636704683304, -0.05063752830028534, 0.0311462190002203, 0.006305281072854996, -0.009721016511321068, 0.03963175043463707, 0.056785546243190765, -0.04402245581150055, -0.012277025729417801, -0.01783685013651848, 0.027148565277457237, -0.025255903601646423, -0.021717937663197517, 0.002161105629056692, -0.018323926255106926, -0.01899133063852787, 0.01768127828836441, -0.022284965962171555, -0.0959198996424675, -0.0660678967833519, 0.06205054000020027, -0.00751635292544961, 0.04035131260752678, -0.03161570802330971, 0.05037105828523636, 0.023630553856492043, -0.013318338431417942, 0.01057171169668436, 0.02511470578610897, 0.06487691402435303, 0.09513914585113525, 0.025825707241892815, 0.005483975168317556, 0.07728282362222672, -0.03788067027926445, 0.0388602614402771, 0.012205144390463829, -0.0037639520596712828, 0.05474258214235306, -0.0476999469101429, -0.0766431912779808, 0.001205436303280294, 0.014694617129862309, 0.02998488023877144, 0.05287691950798035, 0.02007359452545643, 0.01151404157280922, -0.013150245882570744, 0.0005458982195705175, -0.07279808819293976, -0.04993598908185959, 0.040872059762477875, 0.024710290133953094, -0.023262593895196915, -0.014499101787805557, -0.006060632411390543, -0.09097970277070999, -0.013767145574092865, -0.03816017881035805, -0.039496779441833496, 0.02774996869266033, -0.053884003311395645, 0.06540026515722275, -0.04513482749462128, -0.012325312942266464, -0.006825445685535669, -0.012835425324738026, -0.007000173442065716, 0.010020466521382332, 0.05294506996870041, -0.01643512025475502, 0.03614562004804611, -0.002519680419936776, 0.01837076060473919, -0.027789857238531113, -0.001686335657723248, 0.04297160729765892, -0.06920525431632996, -0.023131603375077248, 0.022575151175260544, 0.024643095210194588, 0.04993436485528946, 0.0220401082187891, -0.031905800104141235, -0.051891349256038666, 0.03946683555841446, 0.012554737739264965, -0.0738719180226326, -0.004781038966029882, 0.02459569275379181, 0.018906302750110626, -0.0009572310373187065, 0.0020785904489457607, -0.015419304370880127, 0.10538864880800247, 0.025362156331539154, 0.055372972041368484, 0.0017356890020892024, -0.025090361014008522, -0.06723511964082718, 0.012709932401776314, 0.008119210600852966, -0.0022703888826072216, -0.002364744432270527, 0.0059220758266747, 0.007504706736654043, -0.0050788745284080505, 0.009121300652623177, -0.022181065753102303, 0.029153134673833847, -0.03322180360555649, -0.010582593269646168, 0.04538670927286148, 0.024632487446069717, -0.004058276303112507, 0.005390259437263012, -0.007589583285152912, 0.005201996769756079, 0.05596081167459488, 0.050391972064971924, 0.06685702502727509, 0.09298619627952576, 0.06652147322893143, -0.007047068793326616, 0.01918761432170868, 0.038301706314086914, -0.08224006742238998, 0.01648726500570774, 0.02809719927608967, -0.04209205135703087, -0.043900392949581146, -0.002718422096222639, 0.0077032833360135555, 0.012143713422119617, -0.05659260228276253, -0.005719873122870922, -0.10199685394763947, 0.020875006914138794, 0.022565320134162903, -0.0218147374689579, -0.08007953315973282, -0.0026494853664189577, -0.0061308713629841805, 0.007223061751574278, 0.0040830583311617374, -0.07101152092218399, -0.018136175349354744, -0.010500776581466198, 0.005924241617321968, 0.022465839982032776, -0.010589685291051865, -0.016368117183446884, -0.002324305474758148, -0.03318469226360321, 0.03195356950163841, -0.009601878002285957, 0.0058367568999528885, -0.07413917779922485, 0.021483909338712692, 0.02311481535434723, 0.02119315043091774, -0.023244766518473625, 0.0196783896535635, 0.043994367122650146, -0.08107911795377731, 0.00006098909943830222, -0.04918929561972618, -0.021853363141417503, 0.0842149555683136, -0.030401606112718582, 0.006591167766600847, -0.003955789841711521, 0.025539863854646683, 0.004924406297504902, -0.009830571711063385, -0.0335547998547554, -0.05058303475379944, 0.028969576582312584, 0.04368318244814873, -0.047944895923137665, -0.04197558015584946, 0.044413745403289795, -0.03766200691461563, 0.0038337758742272854, 0.00513957254588604, 0.02499522641301155, 0.02022567391395569, -0.0008204400073736906, -0.010073961690068245, 0.027536096051335335, 0.009253351017832756, -0.022978411987423897, 0.00891129206866026, 0.025983771309256554, -0.036212507635354996, -0.012454008683562279, -0.032678715884685516, -0.016435837373137474, -0.0003868341154884547, 0.008100857958197594, -0.03294876590371132, -0.01973673701286316, -0.00863985251635313, -0.007105389144271612, -0.04300453141331673, -0.015173851512372494, 0.005309818312525749, -0.02473440207540989, 0.046331893652677536, 0.04136224091053009, -0.014221238903701305, -0.028883416205644608, 0.021701540797948837, 0.009278692305088043, 0.00201274361461401, -0.014489609748125076, -0.013160115107893944, 0.019206881523132324, 0.003089830745011568, -0.022740129381418228, 0.06399334967136383, -0.02019905485212803, 0.014913017861545086, -0.0650492012500763, 0.02060570940375328, -0.0161906611174345, 0.04620880261063576, -0.003080291673541069, -0.03602925315499306, 0.07144088298082352, -0.04249521344900131, 0.014760938473045826, 0.009796911850571632, 0.002093082759529352, -0.03221512958407402, -0.041749294847249985, -0.030611487105488777, 0.003535124473273754, 0.06211195886135101, -0.027288485318422318, 0.03748628497123718, 0.020061075687408447, 0.009157633408904076, -0.011331716552376747, -0.05648141726851463, -0.02415749430656433, 0.004501925315707922, -0.023235635831952095, 0.00261690397746861, -0.052654869854450226, -0.0010397720616310835, -0.007257041055709124, -0.027456777170300484, -0.02489214763045311, 0.05342872068285942, 0.029520520940423012, -0.08151233196258545, -0.023330742493271828, 0.060181912034749985, -0.022053483873605728, -0.04546269029378891, 0.010777282528579235, 0.004885466769337654, 0.0027671989519149065, -0.009808761067688465, -0.026236452162265778, -0.04731008782982826, -0.034301772713661194, 0.013931263238191605, 0.044497713446617126, -0.005738108418881893, 0.04697494953870773, -0.019676299765706062, 0.08174517005681992, -0.05006543919444084, -0.0021311664022505283, -0.04991087317466736, 0.01415058970451355, 0.01755770668387413, -0.047786690294742584, 0.014114429242908955, 0.03625785559415817, -0.032954514026641846, 0.0721476748585701, 0.029363185167312622, -0.023839129135012627, 0.03692082688212395, 0.014522384852170944, -0.029613588005304337, -0.005679386202245951, -0.04876598343253136, -0.0382024347782135, -0.03808353468775749, -0.0033534460235387087, -0.0007199865649454296, -0.010942807421088219, 0.020981360226869583, 0.026243794709444046, 0.026204660534858704, 0.05459746718406677, -0.001561312354169786, -0.04924407973885536, -0.029503541067242622, -0.04177181050181389, 0.0026435209438204765, 0.0330125130712986, -0.025374790653586388, -0.017901435494422913, 0.003967746160924435, -0.009397754445672035, 0.032852161675691605, -0.03357537463307381, 0.039328690618276596, 0.024838345125317574, -0.04951045289635658, -0.07829707115888596, 0.04858958348631859, 0.015133758075535297, -0.06966158002614975, 0.024745367467403412, 0.02366713248193264, -0.04719862341880798, -0.0047187949530780315, 0.014380709268152714, -0.02157573029398918, 0.038490306586027145, 0.017243098467588425, -0.010216709226369858, 0.01998238079249859, 0.017973918467760086, 0.06453397125005722, -0.06887637078762054, 0.026717999950051308, 0.04936385154724121, 0.01831628754734993, -0.02832149527966976, -0.062121279537677765, 0.03997000306844711, -0.026177482679486275, -0.007056389469653368, 0.011415955610573292, 0.016261035576462746, 0.04318373277783394, -0.012662883847951889, 0.007883293554186821, 0.03398693725466728, 0.04119369387626648, -0.015615944750607014, 0.05276481434702873, 0.042763691395521164, 0.04167584702372551, 0.012366117909550667, 0.06380245834589005, -0.030633311718702316, 0.009773606434464455, -0.004662242252379656, -0.015914158895611763, -0.05094985291361809, 0.06101638823747635, -0.025256382301449776, -0.005186217837035656, -0.00012242782395333052, 0.060769036412239075, 0.025921186432242393, 0.041979942470788956, 0.04781198129057884, 0.04107581079006195, 0.04778466746211052, -0.01481181662529707, -0.04478161409497261, 0.00672771455720067, -0.01763373613357544, 0.014864697121083736, 0.03187662363052368, 0.036075010895729065, -0.022815467789769173, -0.02861587330698967, 0.05877479538321495, -0.040081415325403214, 0.02803933061659336, 0.027678396552801132, 0.02722904086112976, -0.0443388856947422, 0.015754954889416695, -0.02424571104347706, 0.03374120593070984, 0.05327319726347923, -0.0013698572292923927, -0.08429502695798874, 0.05559581145644188, -0.02469230815768242, 0.08542462438344955, -0.02143573760986328, 0.014813668094575405, 0.0365106426179409, -0.0602046474814415, -0.03252612054347992, 0.03484123945236206, -0.010339145548641682, -0.05616605654358864, 0.027930596843361855, -0.0051414151675999165, 0.036649927496910095, -0.0485757477581501, -0.011114474385976791, -0.02048594504594803, -0.013138022273778915, 0.03865240514278412, -0.005156917497515678, -0.03241162747144699, 0.04102972149848938, -0.05829399451613426, -0.02794433757662773, -0.024691268801689148, -0.11811268329620361, -0.0306076779961586, 0.011819249019026756, -0.018627328798174858, 0.012573531828820705, 0.06096308305859566, 0.017857447266578674, -0.024223346263170242, 0.030238879844546318, -0.010215147398412228, -0.07487528771162033, -0.047238994389772415, 0.029257487505674362, -0.001358029549010098, -0.05553411692380905, 0.05221552029252052, -0.015013661235570908, 0.031835563480854034, -0.01362439151853323, 0.0014898838708177209, 0.047278981655836105, -0.009922569617629051, 0.0586344413459301, 0.05288390442728996, -0.009667954407632351, 0.0018363130511716008, -0.009587635286152363, 0.04071277007460594, -0.003775883698835969, 0.0024353875778615475, -0.03373851999640465, -0.024191593751311302, -0.024604758247733116, 0.050614871084690094, 0.011510188691318035, 0.022723903879523277, 0.0284693855792284, 0.008278891444206238, 0.034042537212371826, -0.032913945615291595, 0.01757028140127659, -0.01950291357934475, -0.04649205505847931, 0.014628883451223373, -0.01298293936997652, -0.01785397343337536, -0.019995499402284622, 0.025110924616456032, -0.011573758907616138, -0.01630713790655136, -0.005527454894036055, 0.05343310907483101, 0.01577109843492508, -0.00027740353834815323, 0.06011556088924408, 0.01585162803530693, 0.04486444219946861, -0.006855258718132973, -0.03347101807594299, -0.052491433918476105, 0.010234656743705273, 0.00947501789778471, -0.04151530563831329, 0.02474144846200943, 0.0653928890824318, -0.025133036077022552, -0.032378826290369034, -0.018018605187535286, 0.017427591606974602, 0.02957282029092312, -0.01765199936926365, -0.0011231659445911646, -0.03413373976945877, -0.05022624507546425, -0.009571379981935024, 0.04477040469646454, 0.020822810009121895, 0.0030280209612101316, -0.025881407782435417, -0.04020579159259796, 0.05348002538084984, -0.0719301775097847, -0.04386495053768158, -0.0019676482770591974, -0.005759668070822954, 0.02776019461452961, 0.01254457700997591, -0.028944646939635277, 0.029308659955859184, 0.008043975569307804, -0.04363279417157173, -0.009809312410652637, 0.0010915648890659213, -0.004688975866883993, 0.033719226717948914, 0.01010601595044136, 0.08154639601707458, -0.014668346382677555, -0.0016393392579630017, 0.04044652357697487, 0.017557963728904724, 0.0173674076795578, 0.05881097540259361, -0.00883300881832838, 0.009720038622617722, -0.07923832535743713, 0.034329354763031006, 0.005589110776782036, -0.04839865118265152, -0.05973784998059273, 0.03485684096813202, -0.00966123677790165, -0.04165028780698776, -0.04388391226530075, 0.03491770476102829, -0.005095123313367367, -0.016102081164717674, -0.018393734470009804, -0.010616305284202099, -0.032311130315065384, 0.03595822677016258, -0.03324095159769058, -0.023402316495776176, -0.025629473850131035, 0.01882581040263176, 0.00985961314290762, -0.02951222099363804, 0.02509116753935814, -0.03302489221096039, 0.011963277123868465, 0.06557157635688782, 0.059090886265039444, 0.03113197721540928, 0.059700679033994675, 0.022470636293292046, -0.03167451173067093, 0.06237328425049782, 0.05083020031452179, 0.019695615395903587, -0.015199159272015095, -0.035032719373703, -0.0017931299516931176, -0.006284600123763084, 0.0125969173386693, 0.010112049989402294, -0.00014056474901735783, -0.011239991523325443, -0.030008582398295403, -0.048232290893793106, 0.025696424767374992, 0.018232326954603195, 0.00928219873458147, -0.03572796285152435, -0.07223009318113327, 0.06937576085329056, 0.026663105934858322, 0.03778022527694702, 0.026665138080716133, -0.0202455036342144, -0.0052837468683719635, 0.033785898238420486, -0.04611216112971306, -0.01276858989149332, -0.021450983360409737, -0.01041018683463335, 0.04914398118853569, 0.007691723760217428, 0.032603003084659576, -0.011025569401681423, -0.003570549888536334, 0.05812748521566391, -0.07455385476350784, 0.004292236641049385, 0.042114052921533585, 0.044406019151210785, 0.016427962109446526, 0.006325472611933947, -0.0199861042201519, -0.008425921201705933, -0.05606215447187424, -0.009912457317113876, -0.009207556024193764, 0.007076376583427191, 0.024407044053077698, -0.012829608283936977, 0.008227231912314892, -0.030611451715230942, 0.025777122005820274, 0.014801615849137306, 0.05214504152536392, -0.03377567604184151, -0.014418983832001686, 0.0015307097928598523, -0.00948445126414299, -0.03217040002346039, 0.006152642425149679, 0.0221784096211195, 0.09180335700511932, -0.009643585421144962, -0.12255071103572845, 0.006464840844273567, -0.017798038199543953, -0.01499630231410265, -0.02516339346766472, -0.04309317469596863, 0.020170865580439568, -0.020087357610464096, 0.004642855376005173, -0.028153490275144577, 0.04327889159321785, -0.024256166070699692, -0.053042635321617126, -0.020082052797079086, -0.007964523509144783, -0.02592984214425087, -0.027410615235567093, -0.09106838703155518, 0.02926473319530487, -0.017239293083548546, -0.04029011353850365, 0.0022675564978271723, 0.013335379771888256, 0.08356089890003204, 0.0041604312136769295, 0.035101789981126785, 0.03402840718626976, -0.07795492559671402, 0.000246731418883428, 0.0021278869826346636, 0.005977097433060408, 0.047459620982408524, 0.0076042357832193375, 0.032576341181993484, -0.0036185581702739, -0.0146107142791152, 0.04763282462954521, -0.010524649173021317, 0.007303915452212095, -0.017845414578914642, -0.006467137485742569, -0.04216759279370308, 0.011645309627056122, 0.0196561086922884, 0.0475359745323658, 0.02790401317179203, 0.011124256998300552, -0.017641311511397362, -0.018530206754803658, 0.035118769854307175, 0.029471557587385178, 0.0004454233276192099, 0.03542083501815796, -0.032177843153476715, -0.01589372381567955, 0.030200490728020668, -0.035722605884075165, 0.028942054137587547, 0.00519337086006999, -0.03634759411215782, 0.014896825887262821, 0.016338959336280823, -0.0028023826889693737, -0.04572237655520439, -0.025212084874510765, 0.02353927306830883, -0.005345116835087538, -0.051235828548669815, 0.002739903051406145, 0.0038188244216144085, 0.034318435937166214, -0.006110704969614744, -0.0034874342381954193, -0.002520959824323654, -0.010619835928082466, -0.05124732106924057, -0.013754879124462605, 0.020050490275025368, 0.025863351300358772, 0.005612415261566639, 0.06752552092075348, 0.017740841954946518, -0.057708609849214554, -0.033595867455005646, -0.014729274436831474, -0.07950211316347122, 0.08141487091779709, 0.023257140070199966, -0.01155813504010439, -0.057934969663619995, -0.0017267653020098805, -0.042971402406692505, -0.0369703471660614, -0.03297743946313858, -0.03074377030134201, -0.0637492910027504, -0.009452859871089458, 0.01428875233978033, -0.026118028908967972, -0.022368174046278, 0.01834637112915516 ]
<p>I remember reading about an experiment where fine rods of tungsten were super-heated with millions of amps of electricity, melting them into ionised gas and were then compressed (by magnetic fields?) into plasma.</p> <p>The plasma heated up to temperatures never before reached. I can't remember exactly, but I believe it was a few billion degrees fahrenheit.</p> <p>It was a number of years ago - and I can't find the report via a search engine.</p> <p>Is there a limit to the temperature of plasma? What's the current highest recorded temperature of plasma? Is it hotter than nuclear reactions?</p>
g7462
[ 0.05120541527867317, 0.02429775707423687, 0.0034678392112255096, 0.005015322472900152, 0.010231726802885532, -0.02119683288037777, -0.04211888462305069, 0.07683603465557098, -0.03615373745560646, 0.01134822703897953, 0.01163110788911581, 0.051709119230508804, -0.02334781363606453, -0.01973564922809601, 0.018309783190488815, -0.042913854122161865, 0.05466007813811302, -0.011300116777420044, -0.03260749578475952, 0.039700210094451904, 0.031662892550230026, -0.0734749510884285, 0.006544637028127909, -0.021982908248901367, -0.036617524921894073, 0.016513332724571228, -0.0378059484064579, -0.02380412258207798, 0.004106391686946154, -0.0784221738576889, 0.010473321191966534, 0.009696265682578087, -0.021233540028333664, 0.016536111012101173, 0.015459917485713959, -0.08516418933868408, -0.014578618109226227, -0.013757712207734585, 0.03467070683836937, -0.019740285351872444, -0.058578331023454666, -0.02425331063568592, 0.0863584652543068, 0.02960304543375969, 0.014309710822999477, 0.014521860517561436, 0.004372662398964167, -0.06338953971862793, -0.012126758694648743, 0.01957903616130352, -0.02463139221072197, 0.04710644111037254, 0.02193295583128929, -0.03622185066342354, -0.04395276680588722, -0.03302111476659775, 0.0019601553212851286, 0.0025085045490413904, 0.06481681764125824, 0.07595236599445343, 0.02895856276154518, -0.005687609314918518, 0.03532981872558594, -0.06160552427172661, 0.02153504639863968, -0.030818413943052292, -0.06806426495313644, 0.020666923373937607, 0.017100347205996513, -0.010607939213514328, 0.016823802143335342, -0.035693638026714325, -0.025983821600675583, -0.02045700140297413, 0.06788960844278336, -0.013791531324386597, 0.00656040059402585, -0.03787894546985626, 0.010850037448108196, 0.013103242963552475, -0.02093198336660862, 0.006824243813753128, -0.020652005448937416, -0.011597027070820332, 0.0007358969887718558, -0.040779758244752884, 0.009362568147480488, 0.04060301557183266, 0.006617329549044371, -0.01804768666625023, 0.011647986248135567, 0.041474636644124985, 0.02980935573577881, -0.009170252829790115, 0.045618243515491486, 0.048328179866075516, -0.004000138491392136, 0.04772244393825531, -0.017086859792470932, 0.013391154818236828, -0.015089013613760471, -0.05644984915852547, -0.00828920304775238, -0.0014701380860060453, -0.033742401748895645, 0.0024831099435687065, -0.022089121863245964, -0.04514859616756439, 0.0044151428155601025, -0.016630511730909348, 0.005852535832673311, -0.018963756039738655, -0.04532182961702347, 0.008187993429601192, -0.012875868007540703, -0.006081907544285059, -0.02420862950384617, 0.008984281681478024, -0.0037663995753973722, 0.017742931842803955, 0.03686170652508736, 0.022925546392798424, -0.04174637421965599, 0.07845359295606613, -0.01591481827199459, -0.06346157938241959, 0.06315800547599792, 0.04003076255321503, -0.03551396727561951, -0.05737195163965225, -0.057907406240701675, -0.002159435534849763, -0.0378611721098423, 0.00890339259058237, 0.03510171175003052, 0.02883317321538925, 0.005951525177806616, 0.03100470080971718, -0.02539175935089588, 0.039107222110033035, 0.020303450524806976, -0.017909981310367584, 0.010740041732788086, 0.01046598982065916, 0.008682875894010067, -0.005942995660007, -0.03563788905739784, 0.007468547206372023, 0.0026053301990032196, 0.060268960893154144, 0.015338566154241562, -0.0550035685300827, 0.04144786298274994, -0.07084345072507858, -0.035613156855106354, -0.01459962036460638, 0.022807864472270012, 0.007928586564958096, 0.048077020794153214, -0.052720215171575546, -0.02775408700108528, -0.012875461019575596, 0.004460534546524286, 0.015977928414940834, 0.007396419066935778, 0.017260517925024033, 0.0027703011874109507, 0.029877010732889175, 0.011504909954965115, -0.008726092986762524, -0.09757929295301437, -0.048896994441747665, 0.01972692646086216, 0.02265879139304161, -0.006471717730164528, -0.017504200339317322, 0.04877301678061485, -0.008608615025877953, 0.028130589053034782, -0.07871047407388687, -0.03426766395568848, -0.018481476232409477, 0.033120542764663696, -0.04311129450798035, -0.011808549053966999, 0.03802500292658806, -0.05839192494750023, 0.00015966029604896903, 0.03036210685968399, 0.049200352281332016, -0.07818665355443954, -0.029833875596523285, 0.012268844060599804, -0.03606436774134636, 0.014624595642089844, -0.022289499640464783, 0.005009193439036608, -0.014851952902972698, -0.05666304752230644, -0.016752950847148895, 0.0020063575357198715, 0.08795973658561707, -0.023264113813638687, -0.015019373968243599, 0.0017842103261500597, -0.008578447625041008, -0.04297126829624176, -0.043540894985198975, 0.011603648774325848, 0.018478842452168465, 0.0030279303900897503, 0.007312245201319456, -0.005233217962086201, 0.05715920031070709, 0.04882311075925827, 0.001655620289966464, -0.0083031440153718, -0.004285748582333326, 0.043916478753089905, 0.003045685589313507, 0.01751437969505787, -0.0005914699868299067, 0.045882824808359146, -0.010646583512425423, 0.0200501661747694, -0.025010408833622932, 0.014770716428756714, 0.009191122837364674, 0.026332078501582146, -0.04283330962061882, -0.05491109564900398, 0.025432003661990166, -0.024503333494067192, -0.04428515210747719, -0.003445928916335106, 0.029959699138998985, -0.005949835758656263, -0.027817750349640846, 0.022859077900648117, 0.041630055755376816, 0.0088267857208848, 0.0228043831884861, 0.004160230979323387, 0.02677992358803749, -0.03920939564704895, -0.0727393850684166, -0.058983173221349716, 0.017525529488921165, 0.027223113924264908, -0.002312106778845191, 0.001987778814509511, -0.037263717502355576, 0.02849271520972252, 0.03010747767984867, -0.01324291992932558, -0.005625923164188862, 0.009251265786588192, 0.08497349172830582, -0.044728152453899384, -0.09401410073041916, 0.04820980131626129, 0.02504824288189411, -0.005207458510994911, -0.03996483236551285, -0.023221321403980255, 0.005117257125675678, -0.056513577699661255, 0.012745525687932968, -0.0037845438346266747, 0.014847167767584324, -0.02411850541830063, -0.03101823665201664, -0.034974053502082825, 0.05174584314227104, 0.017564140260219574, -0.0056490302085876465, 0.05326942354440689, 0.009879038669168949, 0.07348424941301346, -0.0690578818321228, -0.008205955848097801, 0.0005656089051626623, -0.03106798231601715, 0.008314529433846474, -0.0033329115249216557, -0.037025850266218185, -0.03782472014427185, -0.018490923568606377, -0.022965312004089355, -0.014490402303636074, -0.051900628954172134, -0.024784857407212257, 0.009184137918055058, -0.0018574694404378533, -0.024768231436610222, 0.02082846686244011, 0.04214952886104584, -0.042660441249608994, -0.0411105640232563, -0.03417016938328743, -0.017073234543204308, -0.07554616034030914, -0.04861537739634514, 0.04565839469432831, 0.012638702057301998, -0.012254400178790092, -0.009199073538184166, -0.032769814133644104, 0.04205045849084854, -0.041635073721408844, -0.001794716576114297, 0.03877268731594086, 0.013036618009209633, 0.02311331406235695, -0.05238371342420578, -0.04852171987295151, 0.06822766363620758, 0.022359807044267654, 0.045145776122808456, 0.0320524163544178, -0.04723673686385155, -0.060987867414951324, 0.05189600959420204, -0.04822753742337227, 0.010094376280903816, 0.00842289999127388, -0.008128851652145386, -0.06027834117412567, -0.024324169382452965, 0.005509619135409594, -0.025990040972828865, 0.02646167203783989, -0.0004181606927886605, 0.028054118156433105, -0.018160346895456314, 0.0021885335445404053, -0.01893988624215126, 0.07261695712804794, 0.048447560518980026, 0.010203307494521141, -0.0025009040255099535, -0.026076357811689377, -0.058846309781074524, -0.046436358243227005, 0.07991731911897659, 0.06183035299181938, -0.015717878937721252, -0.011250798590481281, 0.005937889218330383, 0.0246833935379982, 0.015095196664333344, 0.03177686035633087, -0.04687519744038582, -0.00916433334350586, -0.011311441659927368, 0.034808289259672165, 0.03186699375510216, 0.005866695195436478, -0.028701333329081535, -0.05343880504369736, -0.00042933528311550617, 0.00660275761038065, 0.052105069160461426, -0.08551162481307983, 0.015949858352541924, -0.014450417831540108, -0.0032237491104751825, 0.019574591889977455, 0.013138193637132645, -0.07157827913761139, -0.06398896127939224, -0.050990622490644455, 0.03849342465400696, 0.03702628239989281, -0.004086990375071764, -0.04894623905420303, -0.03869787976145744, 0.07657652348279953, -0.014967916533350945, 0.08313383907079697, -0.01251043751835823, 0.03678840771317482, 0.04162897169589996, -0.014041360467672348, -0.0542357861995697, -0.01663980819284916, -0.009803250432014465, 0.00039872052730061114, -0.0003873764944728464, -0.09006776660680771, 0.057297464460134506, -0.04253021255135536, 0.0049179005436599255, 0.01837887614965439, -0.07605758309364319, -0.043805912137031555, -0.006010804791003466, -0.004859037231653929, 0.0211822260171175, -0.044388752430677414, 0.0387161485850811, 0.02985410951077938, 0.022207025438547134, -0.03960911184549332, -0.012965159490704536, -0.016370799392461777, 0.0029958938248455524, 0.00663168728351593, -0.019657332450151443, -0.03349045664072037, 0.01693945750594139, 0.03263525664806366, -0.0018762252293527126, -0.020222824066877365, 0.03196108713746071, -0.051914189010858536, -0.020334042608737946, -0.021434275433421135, 0.03889444097876549, -0.005367584526538849, -0.029221856966614723, 0.019739050418138504, -0.032173171639442444, 0.018719937652349472, -0.014041632413864136, 0.015208781696856022, -0.02651055157184601, 0.006166255101561546, 0.018092740327119827, 0.003417083527892828, 0.10082798451185226, -0.05114224553108215, -0.09113668650388718, -0.006776007823646069, -0.0021452715154737234, 0.049684491008520126, 0.009690978564321995, -0.01613938808441162, -0.0025993813760578632, 0.10635627061128616, 0.041307542473077774, -0.0038436746690422297, 0.09226926416158676, 0.0189383402466774, 0.018969442695379257, 0.034041378647089005, -0.006923778913915157, -0.00039737255428917706, -0.04278416559100151, 0.0041540456004440784, 0.0029508413281291723, -0.06483893096446991, -0.03417997807264328, -0.002105066552758217, 0.009848367422819138, -0.07494998723268509, -0.004014290403574705, 0.006209248211234808, 0.01328006200492382, 0.0577322393655777, -0.006872170139104128, -0.040098246186971664, -0.003468735609203577, 0.057161152362823486, 0.07379288971424103, 0.026858067139983177, -0.010460725985467434, -0.10105319321155548, -0.05321551859378815, -0.010312385857105255, 0.014959830790758133, 0.019777901470661163, 0.02942906692624092, 0.02498607710003853, -0.020952286198735237, 0.026447879150509834, -0.038309257477521896, -0.0464024618268013, -0.026771970093250275, -0.034762442111968994, -0.026260295882821083, 0.06109844148159027, 0.0026014961767941713, 0.02714323252439499, 0.016414377838373184, 0.00858454778790474, -0.06728780269622803, 0.04500644654035568, 0.047344498336315155, -0.023484807461500168, -0.009266791865229607, -0.003204155480489135, 0.05979226157069206, 0.013914440758526325, -0.000980888493359089, -0.016826637089252472, -0.016353759914636612, -0.061711180955171585, -0.01606011390686035, 0.05965050682425499, 0.02962094359099865, 0.0025537179317325354, -0.029162030667066574, 0.0034826237242668867, -0.006386322434991598, 0.026763902977108955, -0.0373910591006279, 0.0267346128821373, 0.021957287564873695, 0.02887921966612339, 0.018579231575131416, -0.014972691424190998, 0.024870628491044044, -0.022047288715839386, 0.009881006553769112, 0.02766663394868374, -0.0016840037424117327, -0.02506447397172451, 0.02682107873260975, -0.05323837324976921, 0.039246562868356705, -0.044990334659814835, 0.0849260464310646, 0.012665846385061741, -0.07285992801189423, 0.01825299672782421, -0.012035827152431011, 0.04711488261818886, 0.02375359646975994, 0.008994067087769508, 0.04680652916431427, -0.0075997174717485905, 0.053611841052770615, 0.01187838800251484, -0.030399899929761887, 0.03989964351058006, -0.004730962682515383, -0.0002081285056192428, 0.0023221978917717934, 0.0457257442176342, 0.03553914278745651, 0.02368469350039959, 0.04825063422322273, -0.0039404407143592834, 0.015843398869037628, 0.03628571704030037, -0.058256473392248154, 0.00722459377720952, 0.032431334257125854, -0.014263803139328957, 0.010407022200524807, -0.03012263774871826, 0.05189383774995804, -0.058129094541072845, 0.07296626269817352, 0.013134008273482323, 0.03714806213974953, -0.0454830564558506, -0.0032008648850023746, 0.0005879964446648955, 0.0245633814483881, -0.003937818575650454, 0.014753148891031742, 0.01742441952228546, -0.01110936887562275, -0.04606879875063896, -0.03836861625313759, -0.0866299495100975, 0.06276188045740128, 0.06641694158315659, 0.008763422258198261, 0.028496740385890007, 0.01609078422188759, -0.02278432808816433, 0.055733922868967056, -0.036693427711725235, 0.009955577552318573, 0.06794440746307373, 0.027584079653024673, -0.06105469912290573, 0.0002194971457356587, 0.005921058356761932, -0.011270515620708466, 0.019831283017992973, -0.013527466915547848, 0.035404566675424576, -0.01792036183178425, 0.04044291004538536, 0.012433287687599659, -0.027071872726082802, -0.014894763007760048, -0.015298542566597462, 0.02716958150267601, 0.0192473866045475, -0.01771855168044567, -0.07465546578168869, -0.023610910400748253, -0.017568737268447876, 0.00367041677236557, 0.043586693704128265, 0.00798969715833664, 0.028880121186375618, -0.030845534056425095, -0.023501675575971603, 0.056995514780282974, 0.018124675378203392, 0.019790619611740112, 0.047164615243673325, 0.011776315048336983, -0.008996391668915749, -0.014439130201935768, -0.006442749407142401, -0.000020163563021924347, -0.045918893069028854, -0.0251055546104908, -0.040605224668979645, 0.06642446666955948, 0.01419932208955288, -0.016590846702456474, 0.03708427771925926, -0.011096376925706863, -0.019544927403330803, -0.058439698070287704, -0.025378214195370674, -0.0027015446685254574, 0.015268726274371147, -0.02001737244427204, 0.03560604900121689, 0.0524141900241375, -0.024212799966335297, 0.02122950740158558, -0.01355120912194252, -0.0032870101276785135, 0.024350348860025406, 0.028297504410147667, 0.008777213282883167, 0.050451625138521194, 0.00898496899753809, 0.024446768686175346, 0.004707634914666414, -0.014483285136520863, -0.03126847743988037, -0.0028949049301445484, -0.025812026113271713, -0.025937961414456367, -0.0054822457022964954, -0.034475650638341904, -0.012755848467350006, -0.08229383826255798, 0.003163712564855814, -0.011658275499939919, -0.04119056090712547, -0.06573164463043213, 0.055956121534109116, 0.011318136937916279, 0.016707535833120346, 0.039891742169857025, -0.013145104050636292, 0.03370314836502075, 0.026716874912381172, -0.00607634149491787, -0.0074853128753602505, -0.006640819367021322, -0.00012160339247202501, 0.04213434085249901, 0.021583620458841324, -0.004358604084700346, -0.033604804426431656, 0.002346587600186467, -0.07347261160612106, 0.03968401998281479, -0.01457513589411974, -0.016548216342926025, -0.06438957154750824, 0.08322103321552277, -0.008875686675310135, 0.05983169376850128, 0.010703552514314651, 0.0030760790687054396, 0.0030704739037901163, -0.0512227863073349, -0.020334480330348015, 0.03177906200289726, -0.024349898099899292, -0.004594668745994568, -0.05450953543186188, -0.03908240795135498, 0.03874652832746506, 0.0276986975222826, 0.042583953589200974, -0.06270135194063187, 0.027949417009949684, 0.05815860629081726, -0.03780142962932587, 0.05425030738115311, -0.023790407925844193, -0.012952910736203194, -0.029256030917167664, 0.038817837834358215, 0.02074963040649891, -0.004740661941468716, -0.020107902586460114, -0.008702252991497517, 0.007547404151409864, -0.03848220035433769, 0.11595820635557175, 0.048028092831373215, -0.00792026612907648, -0.015085269697010517, 0.0019029134418815374, 0.01890675164759159, 0.065471351146698, 0.03135712444782257, 0.0028317170217633247, 0.07261484861373901, 0.024633849039673805, -0.005001278594136238, -0.05601641908288002, 0.09252811223268509, -0.046351656317710876, 0.05397417023777962, 0.053105421364307404, -0.004412862937897444, -0.0704805925488472, 0.03458388149738312, 0.014767340384423733, 0.015616288408637047, 0.001120781758800149, 0.022580862045288086, -0.013179564848542213, -0.011036012321710587, -0.0044425916858017445, -0.007558450568467379, 0.031163793057203293, -0.04667925089597702, -0.038985587656497955, 0.030647985637187958, 0.02621839940547943, 0.010818175040185452, 0.056799281388521194, 0.008687080815434456, 0.06856489926576614, -0.03839300572872162, -0.022562658414244652, 0.01147489808499813, 0.04174116998910904, -0.0705282986164093, 0.040349654853343964, -0.0067710960283875465, -0.03273971751332283, 0.01939072087407112, -0.0008067486924119294, -0.05991143733263016, 0.04153480753302574, 0.02346096560359001, -0.004416028968989849, -0.021786130964756012, 0.017067130655050278, 0.03548809513449669, 0.023342538625001907, -0.08772479742765427, -0.002850668504834175, 0.07909613847732544, 0.012585087679326534, 0.03330119699239731, -0.021037908270955086, -0.00005096516906633042, -0.036169737577438354 ]
<p>What is the difference between air resistance/friction force and up thrust force? I always think that air friction is the same as up thrust but it does not seem that way.</p>
g7463
[ 0.032437730580568314, 0.021149104461073875, 0.01461485680192709, 0.025027764961123466, 0.025711804628372192, 0.06557510793209076, 0.05490926280617714, -0.008056659251451492, 0.0036089932546019554, -0.04592691734433174, 0.030907543376088142, -0.009940938092768192, -0.049365293234586716, -0.0188212301582098, 0.04824631288647652, 0.004845675081014633, 0.0585058256983757, -0.04420000687241554, 0.016013996675610542, 0.010678758844733238, 0.0074884723871946335, 0.0004682262078858912, -0.049308717250823975, 0.004019470419734716, -0.004696342628449202, -0.011637342162430286, -0.016548262909054756, -0.1019463837146759, -0.026447661221027374, 0.010488810017704964, 0.06772743910551071, 0.014899860136210918, 0.015443642623722553, -0.018572276458144188, -0.03454464673995972, 0.024714909493923187, 0.049502238631248474, 0.003065380034968257, 0.052109330892562866, -0.0365646593272686, -0.010171294212341309, -0.027035359293222427, -0.009549316950142384, 0.041560932993888855, -0.037977784872055054, -0.007868540473282337, -0.057637907564640045, -0.023129045963287354, -0.05576449632644653, -0.012746271677315235, 0.021057484671473503, 0.01970246434211731, -0.028653830289840698, -0.009357774630188942, 0.0011776647297665477, -0.012035318650305271, 0.09070459008216858, -0.03846249729394913, 0.01849336363375187, 0.013954372145235538, -0.06253460049629211, 0.035347335040569305, 0.014904658310115337, -0.03597366809844971, 0.015391822904348373, -0.05755707249045372, 0.03652205690741539, -0.00858609564602375, -0.012491156347095966, -0.005801715888082981, 0.031242411583662033, 0.01386827602982521, 0.023230236023664474, -0.0358167327940464, -0.031111499294638634, -0.02974623069167137, -0.0052245426923036575, -0.01683897338807583, 0.019578665494918823, 0.017464013770222664, 0.030728654935956, 0.04041706398129463, 0.06115133315324783, -0.045057181268930435, 0.09134647995233536, -0.041807547211647034, -0.01700184866786003, 0.056444715708494186, 0.0017121490091085434, -0.02024349756538868, 0.0227473396807909, 0.022486833855509758, 0.01868775300681591, 0.021719755604863167, -0.012127126567065716, 0.018811458721756935, -0.011695888824760914, 0.04270395636558533, -0.002833142876625061, 0.005844497587531805, -0.004106538370251656, -0.014804386533796787, 0.020089229568839073, -0.005288541316986084, 0.012558343820273876, -0.04950727894902229, 0.05916434898972511, 0.04559652507305145, -0.04434555023908615, -0.03801121562719345, -0.027584785595536232, 0.08782301098108292, -0.07792056351900101, -0.017254743725061417, -0.03234965726733208, -0.049318090081214905, -0.010947879403829575, -0.024873994290828705, -0.0004048830596730113, 0.021270591765642166, 0.01465517282485962, -0.006291595287621021, -0.005129666533321142, 0.010005385614931583, -0.015103520825505257, -0.03583870083093643, 0.04859572649002075, -0.06406740099191666, -0.04933732748031616, -0.0124928317964077, 0.06939966231584549, 0.016327740624547005, -0.04593726247549057, -0.04645147919654846, -0.016162920743227005, -0.0377449207007885, -0.03898631036281586, -0.007462200243026018, 0.03996983915567398, 0.027141518890857697, -0.0029475216288119555, -0.044134438037872314, 0.029175084084272385, 0.028138088062405586, 0.01847105100750923, 0.016347676515579224, -0.037432070821523666, 0.07795456051826477, 0.025881821289658546, 0.052180495113134384, 0.08396061509847641, 0.04462389275431633, 0.013559520244598389, -0.04953383654356003, -0.0005073031061328948, -0.011162109673023224, 0.0078577920794487, 0.03843268007040024, 0.024571215733885765, 0.052802976220846176, -0.009980001486837864, -0.0029862297233194113, 0.08582790940999985, -0.012743676081299782, -0.06728664040565491, 0.002616369631141424, -0.04359402135014534, 0.003634742693975568, 0.0019392740214243531, 0.011748936958611012, -0.007782656233757734, -0.016828389838337898, 0.03673538938164711, 0.035683583468198776, 0.013787207193672657, 0.010960769839584827, 0.04971640184521675, 0.01775483787059784, 0.03410416841506958, -0.04022572934627533, 0.05573968216776848, 0.046458229422569275, 0.021167736500501633, -0.008500004187226295, 0.003412158926948905, -0.014274837449193, -0.030219919979572296, -0.04633549600839615, -0.03599118813872337, 0.03264540806412697, -0.06889071315526962, -0.014981294982135296, -0.029241617769002914, 0.010302691720426083, -0.00475729675963521, -0.006656000856310129, -0.035471346229314804, -0.032952096313238144, -0.004513174295425415, 0.00701224897056818, -0.030589720234274864, -0.02136131003499031, 0.02393636666238308, -0.05617311969399452, -0.0008848542347550392, 0.06599770486354828, -0.029420027509331703, 0.008657041005790234, 0.043633174151182175, -0.00877339020371437, 0.03423801064491272, 0.0034843478351831436, 0.053755275905132294, -0.006937811151146889, 0.031166549772024155, -0.0077918642200529575, 0.010822778567671776, -0.009082620032131672, -0.05650754272937775, -0.06720887124538422, 0.007550522685050964, -0.032073117792606354, 0.004228794015944004, 0.01549861952662468, -0.10770878940820694, -0.0002981867000926286, 0.049167271703481674, 0.005992007441818714, -0.00891502108424902, 0.03193071484565735, -0.02049119770526886, -0.027528077363967896, 0.015171305276453495, -0.0312623493373394, 0.04204235598444939, 0.04556514695286751, 0.06019669398665428, 0.07775313407182693, -0.006192190106958151, -0.021301841363310814, -0.023699624463915825, -0.05713596194982529, 0.013680791482329369, 0.037889182567596436, 0.026884060353040695, -0.041243333369493484, -0.013483580201864243, 0.015105080790817738, -0.02596534974873066, -0.003313517663627863, -0.004793513100594282, 0.0447070337831974, -0.022870110347867012, 0.02871011383831501, -0.0346769355237484, 0.011243448592722416, -0.0688827633857727, -0.009993311949074268, 0.02107464149594307, -0.010481744073331356, -0.03689176216721535, 0.012611024081707, -0.029272422194480896, -0.00523891719058156, -0.06087798997759819, 0.08430072665214539, -0.04952070862054825, 0.026874491944909096, 0.00828617811203003, 0.005952652543783188, 0.034900981932878494, -0.01265506912022829, -0.004772224463522434, 0.042147666215896606, -0.01656593568623066, -0.04611667990684509, 0.048298805952072144, -0.029428528621792793, 0.005791449919342995, -0.05303376540541649, 0.02190757542848587, -0.0032566897571086884, -0.05600716546177864, -0.00510204816237092, -0.012484691105782986, -0.0030270435381680727, -0.05140009522438049, 0.0027775876224040985, -0.06759777665138245, 0.008346213027834892, -0.04187680408358574, 0.0002137003029929474, 0.009505689144134521, -0.023222651332616806, 0.018922975286841393, 0.04963575676083565, 0.04865717887878418, -0.045362651348114014, 0.0013958719791844487, 0.023925671353936195, 0.02578609623014927, -0.05623025447130203, 0.0187942236661911, 0.07671131193637848, 0.04395382106304169, 0.04222894832491875, 0.028007036074995995, -0.06004940718412399, -0.07139002531766891, 0.04138167202472687, -0.04166349768638611, 0.06959950178861618, -0.09985256940126419, 0.0013642257545143366, -0.027104564011096954, -0.047168660908937454, 0.04323508217930794, 0.04562290757894516, 0.02706604078412056, 0.03705746680498123, -0.09156699478626251, -0.09817860275506973, 0.0020011805463582277, -0.00415507098659873, -0.005727835930883884, -0.007111908867955208, -0.03672700747847557, 0.030881715938448906, 0.03908206522464752, -0.04346491023898125, -0.009564862586557865, 0.06773803383111954, -0.020242901518940926, 0.006500678136944771, -0.02310384064912796, 0.10164617002010345, 0.011012348346412182, 0.0027087226044386625, -0.0165895763784647, 0.011163036338984966, 0.06856155395507812, 0.03909401223063469, -0.012829703278839588, 0.026259368285536766, -0.01429833099246025, 0.05639795586466789, 0.00569221843034029, 0.05402403697371483, -0.02162366919219494, 0.003572364803403616, 0.06231403723359108, -0.015207407996058464, 0.011502793990075588, 0.016623277217149734, 0.018130095675587654, -0.03750293701887131, 0.0018562327604740858, 0.033312831073999405, -0.0007298610871657729, 0.00797551404684782, 0.05945920944213867, -0.0052583301439881325, 0.006304203532636166, 0.0552649088203907, -0.02968384325504303, -0.06222175061702728, 0.025618694722652435, -0.036822494119405746, -0.05775674059987068, 0.01136336475610733, 0.006916865240782499, -0.017281752079725266, 0.00649585947394371, -0.01788427121937275, 0.01268476340919733, -0.059588462114334106, 0.008756188675761223, -0.034462135285139084, 0.0034672224428504705, -0.008542467840015888, 0.04012331739068031, 0.03673721104860306, 0.03349849581718445, 0.006092001684010029, 0.03653072193264961, 0.020527567714452744, -0.034517522901296616, 0.021460147574543953, 0.03550829738378525, -0.02244669571518898, -0.038769062608480453, 0.017061663791537285, -0.04623062536120415, 0.03379174694418907, 0.024671761319041252, -0.028977101668715477, 0.035677868872880936, 0.028461778536438942, -0.008295790292322636, 0.0004915285971947014, 0.024836421012878418, -0.018012752756476402, -0.042621027678251266, 0.03273184597492218, -0.019483810290694237, 0.06474292278289795, 0.04806056618690491, -0.008113640360534191, -0.014379425905644894, -0.029887327924370766, 0.024490678682923317, -0.015180354006588459, -0.0063996813260018826, 0.013323263265192509, 0.013949341140687466, -0.03587082400918007, -0.08202042430639267, 0.07456326484680176, 0.07814841717481613, 0.028951887041330338, -0.02640032395720482, 0.06275235861539841, -0.050069283694028854, 0.03187825530767441, -0.014471705071628094, 0.03518717736005783, -0.00544660072773695, 0.08303020149469376, 0.03579793497920036, -0.036226093769073486, 0.013016453012824059, 0.010153539478778839, -0.008707549422979355, -0.015756282955408096, -0.03296815976500511, 0.06581654399633408, 0.08176079392433167, 0.00208103796467185, 0.05898985639214516, -0.004021299071609974, 0.006956752389669418, 0.06669784337282181, 0.055083513259887695, -0.03497697040438652, 0.007664000615477562, 0.04129623994231224, -0.02019098401069641, 0.025910411030054092, -0.03904275223612785, 0.0063707963563501835, -0.06627362221479416, -0.024246208369731903, 0.00883012730628252, -0.008993982337415218, -0.08118399232625961, 0.032676249742507935, -0.028566742315888405, -0.08727046847343445, -0.052304428070783615, -0.028544900938868523, -0.0023577723186463118, -0.001636868342757225, 0.01864049769937992, -0.011116167530417442, 0.0229580570012331, 0.020865285769104958, -0.042060691863298416, -0.026760725304484367, -0.00019877923477906734, 0.029621412977576256, 0.05819817632436752, -0.08018583804368973, -0.02053569257259369, 0.07149124890565872, 0.004759929608553648, 0.05448918789625168, 0.08680252730846405, -0.006339100189507008, 0.023335615172982216, 0.005722750443965197, 0.02386467531323433, 0.05590404197573662, 0.005228392314165831, -0.009803736582398415, -0.03668426722288132, -0.016532717272639275, 0.0008430863381363451, -0.006747005507349968, 0.028860321268439293, 0.0017065712017938495, 0.02113870345056057, 0.08479224890470505, -0.02094682678580284, -0.02151874639093876, -0.08091630041599274, 0.037807587534189224, -0.0720762312412262, -0.010892000049352646, -0.010663934983313084, 0.0014343231450766325, -0.040788665413856506, -0.03055942803621292, -0.009263817220926285, -0.010355723090469837, 0.010959860868752003, -0.030737459659576416, 0.09179969877004623, -0.04146455228328705, -0.0062086451798677444, 0.06160961091518402, -0.001914768829010427, -0.0008677610312588513, -0.04227224737405777, -0.0252766702324152, 0.0011512289056554437, 0.04292786493897438, 0.045094557106494904, 0.062488261610269547, 0.043463677167892456, -0.03398752957582474, 0.01853303797543049, 0.007618382107466459, 0.0313708521425724, -0.00548133347183466, -0.021086852997541428, 0.021154774352908134, -0.03301696479320526, 0.03230256959795952, 0.027388732880353928, 0.024193329736590385, -0.01710372045636177, 0.01695684716105461, 0.048020265996456146, -0.03868972882628441, -0.03267790377140045, -0.0351303331553936, 0.0776594951748848, 0.004756860435009003, 0.01729017123579979, -0.0980302095413208, -0.02871527336537838, 0.011833413504064083, 0.002239698078483343, -0.009858924895524979, 0.055461619049310684, 0.012362929061055183, -0.06439092755317688, -0.016209064051508904, 0.03291485831141472, -0.05076543241739273, -0.026181219145655632, 0.022820530459284782, -0.06746108829975128, 0.00007451672718161717, -0.028367403894662857, -0.003022518241778016, 0.02142205834388733, -0.06378678977489471, 0.006909636314958334, -0.01621941849589348, 0.029189063236117363, -0.02506030723452568, -0.015914849936962128, -0.03889419510960579, 0.06609577685594559, -0.062152259051799774, 0.0027459864504635334, 0.016243284568190575, 0.0015513115795329213, -0.03750437870621681, -0.045391980558633804, 0.014638598076999187, 0.0070551298558712006, 0.017964323982596397, 0.02542303130030632, -0.013552422635257244, -0.12112879008054733, -0.01966385543346405, -0.026624612510204315, -0.01980779320001602, 0.031015926972031593, 0.025427158921957016, 0.0008061552071012557, -0.03370148316025734, -0.04106007143855095, 0.025240223854780197, -0.05329952389001846, -0.04218955710530281, 0.08729850500822067, -0.04202984273433685, -0.02201985754072666, 0.023573406040668488, 0.02180815301835537, 0.040630072355270386, -0.01362171582877636, 0.019015390425920486, -0.006231795996427536, 0.06463006138801575, 0.036115970462560654, -0.03403541445732117, 0.010905986651778221, 0.044634997844696045, 0.016090532764792442, 0.00494216987863183, 0.0048424494452774525, -0.023177143186330795, 0.01525198109447956, 0.038079049438238144, 0.04612461104989052, 0.014955981634557247, -0.021474752575159073, -0.0019703591242432594, -0.01967502199113369, -0.03859774023294449, -0.0632447749376297, 0.03122398816049099, 0.018522268161177635, -0.047984909266233444, 0.03709867596626282, 0.0007006905507296324, 0.010172151029109955, -0.027089983224868774, 0.004381400067359209, -0.07683079689741135, 0.023888876661658287, -0.05659236013889313, -0.03147290274500847, 0.012179864570498466, -0.03816002234816551, -0.0031683845445513725, 0.0009795259684324265, 0.0007048501283861697, -0.0155989620834589, 0.011350308544933796, 0.030275681987404823, 0.036198634654283524, -0.031223881989717484, 0.016269877552986145, -0.00018554322014097124, 0.013641192577779293, -0.014562741853296757, -0.007719000335782766, 0.02810029871761799, 0.005793067626655102, -0.0021409422624856234, 0.027432238683104515, -0.003934166394174099, -0.049924299120903015, -0.041454169899225235, -0.05335533991456032, -0.011733819730579853, -0.031694769859313965, -0.04176640883088112, -0.012426472268998623, -0.0282919779419899, 0.04108195751905441, -0.03271280601620674, 0.0010705083841457963, -0.013055038638412952, -0.02684658206999302, 0.05464668199419975, 0.011769479140639305, -0.052987199276685715, 0.05580878630280495, -0.04405907541513443, 0.02312413603067398, -0.009548110887408257, 0.025712713599205017, -0.003086706390604377, -0.025612108409404755, 0.027760956436395645, -0.014062546193599701, 0.01813526451587677, 0.0004227928293403238, -0.027814965695142746, 0.01136727724224329, -0.032600052654743195, 0.04357900843024254, -0.01413813978433609, 0.01167211402207613, -0.025577707216143608, 0.038117729127407074, 0.028231438249349594, 0.020604515448212624, -0.014485673047602177, 0.02837182953953743, 0.011802940629422665, -0.004924460779875517, 0.025940120220184326, -0.04108897224068642, -0.006796351168304682, 0.02604285627603531, 0.005961449351161718, 0.025032073259353638, 0.0031143836677074432, 0.0451805479824543, -0.028218800202012062, 0.04089488461613655, -0.006642595864832401, -0.02505507878959179, 0.028736144304275513, -0.0057925870642066, -0.02161255106329918, 0.0000046379923333006445, -0.02302396297454834, 0.005399946589022875, 0.00449649291113019, 0.01282006036490202, -0.04742996394634247, -0.022674789652228355, 0.016725121065974236, -0.04357394576072693, 0.02967662177979946, 0.008530061691999435, -0.013251055032014847, 0.0005739391781389713, -0.043657127767801285, -0.051817458122968674, 0.009425378404557705, -0.009448417462408543, 0.06229294836521149, -0.01319317426532507, 0.010693184100091457, -0.03822111338376999, 0.004433812573552132, -0.020655658096075058, -0.027258796617388725, 0.016506683081388474, -0.005362736992537975, -0.025869492441415787, -0.03343658521771431, -0.06324096769094467, 0.030568839982151985, 0.044936127960681915, -0.05048464983701706, -0.005723548587411642, 0.03934920206665993, 0.009933368302881718, -0.027580153197050095, 0.037464555352926254, -0.027582403272390366, 0.03357470780611038, 0.01108837965875864, 0.04545748233795166, -0.01279426459223032, -0.03255220875144005, 0.0036340763326734304, 0.07065995782613754, -0.022846465930342674, -0.042067911475896835, 0.048987191170454025, 0.023721592500805855, -0.03491293266415596, -0.03261633962392807, -0.023621583357453346, -0.006779717281460762, -0.028632093220949173, 0.043208032846450806, 0.005991540849208832, -0.01883281208574772, -0.0372549369931221, 0.044173263013362885, 0.021059272810816765, -0.04243112727999687, -0.04172195494174957, -0.058505408465862274, -0.06669909507036209, 0.011326408013701439 ]
<p>I did see some posts on stackexchange on this matter, but I find them to be beyond my scope or not directly related to what I am looking for.</p> <p>I am reading Feynman Lectures III, chapter 4. It talks about scattering of two particles $a$ and $b$ and it defines $f(\theta)$ to be the probability amplitude of particle $a$ scattering at angle $\theta$. Then it says </p> <p>"You might also think that the amplitude for the second process (where particle $b$ instead enters the detector placed at angle $\theta$) is just $f(\pi-\theta)$. But that is not necessarily so, because there could be an arbitrary phase factor."</p> <p>I'm not questioning why things behave the way they are in quantum mechanics. But, isn't it <strong><em>by definition of $f$</em></strong> that the probability amplitude of particle $a$ scattering at angle $\pi-\theta$ is $f(\pi-\theta)$? I don't see why there is a phase factor. If there's a phase factor, it should already be part of $f$.</p>
g7464
[ 0.05137060955166817, -0.011739471927285194, 0.015285855159163475, -0.004880846478044987, 0.09197477251291275, -0.00420027319341898, 0.02548535168170929, 0.0446636825799942, -0.04334493353962898, -0.029318852350115776, -0.00257463869638741, 0.04025097191333771, 0.007720081601291895, -0.027259107679128647, -0.002770292339846492, 0.004129594657570124, 0.03910040482878685, 0.02980561926960945, 0.04825202748179436, 0.05028533935546875, -0.020440086722373962, 0.01589410938322544, -0.0426686629652977, -0.025677284225821495, 0.0021985559724271297, -0.025957319885492325, 0.0010249109473079443, -0.02678113803267479, -0.031783346086740494, -0.05079314112663269, 0.013434233143925667, -0.0010015519801527262, 0.09426847100257874, -0.043170053511857986, -0.04152704402804375, -0.07276903837919235, 0.032753314822912216, 0.0069436123594641685, -0.04213298484683037, -0.00717616593465209, 0.004780148155987263, 0.042890459299087524, 0.013156883418560028, -0.04727255553007126, -0.008923235349357128, 0.01663067564368248, -0.04923965781927109, 0.005381885450333357, -0.05643755570054054, -0.006690158508718014, -0.025128543376922607, 0.002838657470420003, 0.03920752927660942, -0.0014857337810099125, 0.02097490057349205, 0.07222051918506622, -0.01150225568562746, 0.016144094988703728, 0.02727355808019638, 0.06688638776540756, 0.06631767004728317, 0.01171785406768322, 0.03133918344974518, 0.02878810651600361, 0.04775911569595337, 0.012139398604631424, -0.0511026531457901, -0.02245715819299221, -0.04607006534934044, 0.02774827741086483, -0.02368069626390934, -0.08099758625030518, -0.025317737832665443, 0.002004687674343586, 0.0018804346909746528, 0.03190650790929794, -0.031068021431565285, 0.008117795921862125, 0.041484735906124115, 0.00559230986982584, -0.03281838819384575, -0.023617468774318695, 0.009818359278142452, 0.006337540689855814, 0.014965214766561985, -0.001094914274290204, 0.014702449552714825, -0.004310361109673977, 0.00830795057117939, -0.04027634486556053, 0.019948136061429977, -0.02922845631837845, 0.04069098085165024, -0.0029683553148061037, -0.02762862853705883, 0.004786469507962465, -0.02870376966893673, 0.07868997752666473, -0.05561115965247154, 0.03359553962945938, -0.01979176327586174, 0.056772638112306595, 0.017495349049568176, 0.045494526624679565, 0.01013862807303667, -0.027861496433615685, -0.0004542775568552315, 0.008057698607444763, -0.019240859895944595, 0.04433682560920715, -0.05066826567053795, -0.016517043113708496, -0.07443436235189438, -0.04152699559926987, -0.021008042618632317, -0.014131579548120499, 0.057727377861738205, -0.012456628493964672, 0.052521418780088425, 0.04014471173286438, 0.014692478813230991, -0.04231313616037369, 0.06911343336105347, 0.06617534160614014, -0.05519726872444153, 0.028172597289085388, 0.034955944865942, 0.03478211164474487, 0.0706360712647438, -0.03206649795174599, 0.0702444463968277, -0.018193472176790237, -0.024564940482378006, 0.026797477155923843, 0.032046228647232056, 0.0431327261030674, 0.025346582755446434, -0.007121935486793518, 0.00780945410951972, 0.017286084592342377, 0.007797642145305872, 0.04081939905881882, 0.04182590916752815, -0.05025292932987213, -0.02744024433195591, 0.016993258148431778, -0.028122467920184135, -0.0373135581612587, 0.01785523071885109, 0.030964914709329605, -0.043174248188734055, 0.05088620260357857, -0.00964997336268425, -0.012100680731236935, -0.008490456268191338, -0.031901173293590546, 0.037428125739097595, -0.017093848437070847, 0.017164677381515503, 0.0007165937568061054, 0.06367509067058563, -0.03383735567331314, 0.009415888227522373, -0.00877686869353056, -0.056016676127910614, 0.017997460439801216, -0.009710622951388359, -0.0523727685213089, -0.0360453762114048, -0.07899775356054306, 0.004955411888659, 0.0012794423382729292, 0.04085066542029381, 0.03971993178129196, -0.004832015838474035, 0.08802450448274612, -0.019390959292650223, -0.012386266142129898, 0.02362307533621788, 0.04170354828238487, -0.051782093942165375, 0.010505381971597672, -0.013526086695492268, -0.020844189450144768, 0.013303028419613838, -0.037402402609586716, 0.025998637080192566, 0.07639240473508835, -0.053573574870824814, 0.055672526359558105, -0.009632591158151627, -0.0316692553460598, -0.004388936795294285, 0.027150221168994904, 0.008137700147926807, -0.014770527370274067, 0.013015301898121834, -0.05412017181515694, -0.026024051010608673, 0.07161545008420944, -0.004795874934643507, 0.002644455758854747, 0.0028776186518371105, 0.01903964951634407, 0.039489202201366425, 0.04661343991756439, -0.008120664395391941, 0.034864392131567, -0.03276009485125542, -0.03090604580938816, 0.03378266468644142, -0.010756569914519787, -0.01536606065928936, 0.06068533658981323, 0.005837060045450926, 0.00434225145727396, -0.01984558068215847, 0.0065116360783576965, -0.002584652742370963, 0.015635065734386444, 0.022591404616832733, -0.03340443968772888, 0.018029848113656044, -0.06303099542856216, -0.08669708669185638, 0.060942284762859344, -0.02957521378993988, -0.030632760375738144, -0.033972904086112976, 0.07230982929468155, -0.06844966858625412, -0.003574107773602009, -0.07922598719596863, 0.033566076308488846, -0.0035894240718334913, 0.014886630699038506, -0.02338954247534275, 0.00900217518210411, 0.050221942365169525, 0.043412502855062485, -0.035400569438934326, -0.004198130685836077, 0.0048864614218473434, -0.008917476050555706, 0.006379967555403709, -0.02293412573635578, -0.03051218017935753, 0.0021387427113950253, 0.001585302408784628, 0.019419867545366287, 0.019680364057421684, -0.025683997198939323, -0.02589130401611328, -0.01963149383664131, -0.0640910416841507, -0.0018428092589601874, -0.02764606475830078, 0.021031752228736877, -0.05531712621450424, -0.034941136837005615, 0.03440279886126518, 0.04400228336453438, 0.042063020169734955, 0.008752256631851196, -0.010042382404208183, -0.012874809093773365, -0.02278577908873558, 0.07405403256416321, -0.02131780795753002, -0.042552873492240906, -0.09028127789497375, 0.10292895883321762, 0.010989922098815441, 0.00449422188103199, -0.03262470290064812, -0.007997621782124043, -0.012607020325958729, -0.013798972591757774, 0.04165755957365036, 0.0167001411318779, -0.06107315048575401, 0.009311391040682793, -0.022866984829306602, 0.026984423398971558, 0.0011204041074961424, -0.02739248238503933, 0.05386963486671448, 0.06827042996883392, -0.05861803889274597, 0.01865427754819393, 0.01269649900496006, 0.021951936185359955, 0.02541952393949032, -0.024851279333233833, -0.008769731037318707, 0.0576358437538147, 0.024651184678077698, -0.05097518488764763, 0.02822488732635975, 0.0681259036064148, -0.02590114064514637, 0.022777168080210686, -0.026258504018187523, -0.047976303845644, 0.10182827711105347, -0.00879515241831541, -0.035845812410116196, -0.03572085127234459, -0.04034172371029854, -0.006782669108361006, -0.03368617594242096, 0.048872210085392, -0.01371022779494524, 0.00876462273299694, -0.028703179210424423, 0.020083140581846237, 0.017645126208662987, 0.049905043095350266, 0.017299391329288483, 0.0041488162241876125, -0.051152098923921585, -0.012678313069045544, -0.016014989465475082, 0.021100251004099846, 0.06313148885965347, -0.029356248676776886, -0.04127557575702667, 0.06799248605966568, 0.011835532262921333, -0.0640023723244667, 0.04173712804913521, -0.011076477356255054, 0.014342956244945526, -0.011229950934648514, -0.027560902759432793, -0.023500006645917892, -0.012347429990768433, 0.014965045265853405, -0.017753321677446365, -0.011775081045925617, 0.05504053458571434, -0.013033929280936718, 0.008711306378245354, 0.0031937279272824526, 0.014514021575450897, -0.020649729296565056, 0.04894092679023743, 0.0022288428153842688, 0.051508184522390366, -0.002838458400219679, 0.01949211023747921, 0.02781711518764496, 0.02168719656765461, 0.02436484768986702, 0.005167125258594751, 0.010135563090443611, -0.004415024537593126, -0.040596216917037964, 0.055471066385507584, 0.004983524791896343, -0.0055086868815124035, -0.04379527270793915, 0.03954407945275307, 0.016402674838900566, -0.01059055607765913, -0.021215958520770073, -0.037613142281770706, 0.07116314768791199, 0.031753890216350555, 0.020490014925599098, 0.04372241348028183, -0.029411008581519127, 0.010067889466881752, 0.0339217372238636, 0.026209916919469833, -0.025245122611522675, 0.028208792209625244, 0.00806459691375494, -0.05460979789495468, 0.03087187558412552, 0.03344782441854477, 0.015427893958985806, 0.030852267518639565, 0.009718780405819416, 0.06010646000504494, -0.00843451265245676, -0.04985330253839493, -0.0143821956589818, 0.015805892646312714, -0.05543021112680435, 0.04215821996331215, -0.006633725017309189, -0.007295623421669006, 0.013424021191895008, 0.0021397490054368973, 0.0017715594731271267, 0.0584779754281044, -0.02908174693584442, -0.009529962204396725, 0.013199503533542156, 0.0216444730758667, -0.026992617174983025, 0.06705630570650101, 0.0315653458237648, -0.009699265472590923, 0.00030883061117492616, -0.019992465153336525, -0.042372774332761765, -0.008406320586800575, -0.07660668343305588, 0.017013804987072945, 0.0013230391778051853, -0.04068080708384514, -0.011040443554520607, 0.015713565051555634, 0.016231151297688484, 0.023484135046601295, -0.027566660195589066, 0.01939532160758972, -0.023785799741744995, -0.021813426166772842, -0.0029547270387411118, 0.0282145868986845, -0.018419258296489716, 0.030797140672802925, 0.04714047163724899, -0.008815767243504524, 0.010123667307198048, -0.03158994019031525, -0.0708308145403862, 0.016963211819529533, 0.03272867575287819, -0.0030220255721360445, 0.0009170023258775473, -0.07162342965602875, 0.0263204425573349, -0.06035885214805603, 0.017115676775574684, 0.008896972052752972, 0.04948071762919426, 0.06603776663541794, -0.010012567043304443, -0.007126789540052414, -0.0008185113547369838, 0.045590855181217194, 0.02126968279480934, -0.07458148151636124, -0.022731361910700798, 0.03952641785144806, -0.010274132713675499, -0.02388802543282509, 0.034021299332380295, -0.006447520572692156, -0.06785085797309875, -0.0012839077971875668, -0.015502515248954296, -0.011935406364500523, 0.04083814099431038, 0.005665332544595003, 0.01376262865960598, -0.020242992788553238, 0.0018547773361206055, 0.0292142815887928, -0.0021760771051049232, 0.03403692692518234, 0.014128261245787144, -0.04299367591738701, -0.042090047150850296, -0.05855490267276764, -0.019259318709373474, -0.059171754866838455, -0.0034404469188302755, 0.042428310960531235, 0.003036321373656392, 0.01398337073624134, -0.012811808846890926, -0.032652348279953, -0.025183429941534996, -0.05739903822541237, -0.04133986681699753, -0.026304736733436584, -0.007753361947834492, 0.05516367405653, 0.006390347611159086, -0.02992027997970581, -0.005525451619178057, -0.04261479526758194, -0.02081657387316227, -0.016754373908042908, -0.054680079221725464, 0.010579491034150124, 0.025268951430916786, -0.0005760599742643535, -0.017313776537775993, 0.06742578744888306, -0.035597026348114014, 0.03172556683421135, -0.052352793514728546, -0.003275390015915036, 0.03775003179907799, -0.05258988216519356, -0.04491812735795975, -0.03387188911437988, 0.016660599038004875, -0.04235599562525749, 0.09097248315811157, 0.027904538437724113, -0.07411468029022217, -0.020107699558138847, 0.02400101348757744, 0.03601260483264923, -0.020322514697909355, 0.02503921277821064, -0.012133168056607246, 0.04474009945988655, 0.032434046268463135, -0.010615340434014797, -0.002261669375002384, -0.06471813470125198, 0.03219272941350937, 0.06492609530687332, 0.02495846524834633, -0.02990717999637127, -0.04897719994187355, -0.012688939459621906, -0.002361802849918604, -0.02984926477074623, -0.05559156835079193, 0.016634922474622726, 0.06646028906106949, 0.026710929349064827, 0.034572724252939224, 0.037667855620384216, 0.06232812628149986, -0.002523599425330758, -0.09409566968679428, 0.0523531548678875, 0.0008276566513814032, 0.01168937236070633, 0.0017473265761509538, -0.05647130310535431, 0.007032149471342564, 0.02877255156636238, 0.04722556099295616, -0.010199621319770813, -0.00451671751216054, 0.009862254373729229, -0.028402941301465034, 0.004664840176701546, 0.0006456683622673154, -0.024636736139655113, -0.03488051891326904, 0.02075142040848732, -0.04135936126112938, 0.0022731435019522905, 0.03149867802858353, -0.01737741380929947, 0.057265136390924454, -0.03950269892811775, -0.06695840507745743, 0.038446370512247086, -0.08863218873739243, 0.008743207901716232, 0.01290867105126381, 0.025816190987825394, -0.015239104628562927, 0.020113499835133553, 0.0258861742913723, -0.016131266951560974, 0.035515543073415756, 0.05493234843015671, 0.05941106006503105, -0.05484853684902191, -0.0011082227574661374, 0.03422733023762703, 0.039968207478523254, -0.05327094718813896, -0.007875403389334679, -0.03231246769428253, 0.01285597961395979, -0.005335913971066475, 0.028541086241602898, -0.007006377913057804, -0.021432477980852127, -0.039432380348443985, 0.0355304591357708, -0.046175267547369, -0.04195840656757355, 0.07535851001739502, -0.010507186874747276, -0.036628372967243195, -0.02020568773150444, -0.07054213434457779, -0.03198551759123802, -0.04230737313628197, 0.005666415672749281, 0.02683013305068016, -0.018205927684903145, 0.0015108872903510928, 0.04779285937547684, 0.055217307060956955, -0.021453239023685455, 0.03128475323319435, -0.0021935647819191217, 0.0066370125859975815, 0.051109153777360916, 0.021875327453017235, 0.018750600516796112, 0.009704748168587685, 0.010884272865951061, 0.04647953435778618, 0.010052376426756382, -0.010169422253966331, -0.022006722167134285, -0.027633322402834892, -0.08776506036520004, -0.07270987331867218, -0.0015794663922861218, -0.026780076324939728, 0.01912088505923748, 0.06463348865509033, -0.004111425019800663, -0.03275380656123161, -0.0006635162862949073, 0.02863001450896263, 0.03311782330274582, 0.006100036669522524, 0.01844707503914833, 0.06670831888914108, -0.02570541389286518, 0.03472982347011566, -0.03316332772374153, 0.03334176540374756, 0.015011850744485855, -0.03714633360505104, -0.004860767163336277, -0.06221768260002136, 0.0035484670661389828, 0.004048272036015987, 0.008044849149882793, -0.01401358563452959, 0.09727610647678375, 0.010460957884788513, -0.02305799350142479, -0.026826146990060806, -0.009354657493531704, -0.002492529572919011, 0.00046792373177595437, -0.09703206270933151, 0.023660743609070778, 0.045799098908901215, -0.0383334755897522, -0.010866542346775532, -0.0006321236141957343, -0.01204727217555046, 0.00025168227148242295, 0.06448100507259369, 0.03511504456400871, -0.0053929234854876995, -0.06185583025217056, -0.07399942725896835, -0.07119954377412796, 0.008230947889387608, 0.017683861777186394, -0.003334775799885392, 0.02664080262184143, -0.008870059624314308, -0.058001015335321426, -0.01242148783057928, -0.0012244952376931906, -0.017317064106464386, -0.055280402302742004, -0.10648690909147263, -0.04057498276233673, -0.001672362326644361, -0.04080281779170036, 0.026557287201285362, 0.001215578755363822, -0.03536501154303551, 0.03455811366438866, 0.06929509341716766, 0.007137567736208439, -0.03458366543054581, -0.015103085897862911, -0.005082929506897926, 0.052020635455846786, -0.03320571035146713, 0.02315439097583294, 0.0494203194975853, 0.01750122383236885, 0.00639902800321579, 0.009193495847284794, 0.024337898939847946, -0.0471610389649868, -0.023136014118790627, 0.030258480459451675, 0.0462728887796402, 0.027742302045226097, 0.03339056298136711, 0.03360864147543907, 0.009768626652657986, -0.044463466852903366, -0.014247756451368332, 0.00325465714558959, 0.08386867493391037, 0.0008582840673625469, 0.029152927920222282, -0.030145874246954918, -0.017360514029860497, -0.023311447352170944, 0.01075377780944109, 0.03371010348200798, 0.056166086345911026, 0.02672678790986538, -0.04380373656749725, 0.01161031611263752, -0.09358943998813629, 0.03481614962220192, -0.00017438769282307476, -0.024080399423837662, -0.04381095618009567, -0.06654839962720871, -0.08125820010900497, -0.037624429911375046, 0.008080764673650265, -0.039378538727760315, 0.014169992879033089, -0.01116490364074707, 0.005277485586702824, -0.005850620102137327, 0.0021939855068922043, -0.025366928428411484, -0.025446806102991104, 0.06834692507982254, 0.009620852768421173, -0.02828054130077362, 0.028086666017770767, -0.015739232301712036, -0.013488590717315674, 0.002326713176444173, 0.028409603983163834, -0.015080894343554974, 0.001470117480494082, -0.0508408322930336, 0.007070454768836498, -0.0039942506700754166, -0.011693047359585762, 0.012654008343815804, 0.0049193124286830425, 0.022598091512918472, -0.059443578124046326, 0.01821507327258587, -0.044724151492118835, 0.06746066361665726, 0.008655530400574207, -0.041195906698703766, -0.03413575142621994, 0.014902662485837936, 0.024900835007429123, -0.052480556070804596, 0.016969097778201103, -0.013996133580803871, -0.03634079545736313, -0.028982244431972504, -0.04900703951716423, -0.03157545626163483, -0.016104385256767273, 0.06420225650072098 ]
<p>How can the transformer transfer exact power from primary winding to secondary winding if there are core losses, eddy current losses and hysteresis losses?</p>
g7465
[ -0.012304004281759262, -0.03845493867993355, 0.00037312699714675546, -0.01991014927625656, 0.048644401133060455, -0.04628875479102135, 0.0015373647911474109, -0.020521413534879684, -0.02570936642587185, 0.009476710110902786, -0.06308893114328384, 0.010531243868172169, 0.003077272791415453, 0.02741607092320919, 0.032786205410957336, 0.05939419940114021, -0.0017594319069758058, -0.009747566655278206, 0.0540093295276165, 0.021536793559789658, -0.016023455187678337, -0.017721913754940033, -0.039986636489629745, 0.08034241944551468, -0.06413224339485168, -0.005452492740005255, 0.014789743348956108, -0.018363889306783676, -0.007310712244361639, -0.0054874178022146225, -0.02709408476948738, -0.008758148178458214, 0.05185505375266075, -0.00323786330409348, -0.02903148904442787, 0.027884840965270996, 0.03650626912713051, 0.025985121726989746, 0.023267710581421852, 0.025544175878167152, 0.0114126056432724, 0.03286724165081978, 0.005813331808894873, 0.02226206846535206, 0.006708386354148388, -0.017217012122273445, 0.010426493361592293, -0.0086627546697855, -0.06784114986658096, -0.012758128345012665, -0.014012238010764122, -0.0032053973991423845, 0.05960482358932495, -0.0484468974173069, -0.0027307451236993074, -0.05130677670240402, -0.005702021531760693, 0.012243464589118958, 0.03177858516573906, -0.011030081659555435, -0.01095250342041254, 0.0013998349895700812, -0.0017972817877307534, -0.010635093785822392, -0.010562414303421974, -0.0035167071036994457, -0.04671313241124153, 0.0033347108401358128, 0.04548214003443718, 0.02886827290058136, -0.011331895366311073, -0.004777003079652786, 0.04998346418142319, -0.06849139928817749, 0.02835901826620102, -0.020545514300465584, 0.043768320232629776, -0.030987635254859924, 0.03506669029593468, 0.027910931035876274, -0.02274426445364952, -0.0030146713834255934, -0.01784813217818737, 0.09967035055160522, 0.011811835691332817, 0.020536178722977638, -0.035365570336580276, 0.022717859596014023, -0.035887375473976135, 0.03992752730846405, 0.0070245941169559956, -0.018869750201702118, 0.0193304605782032, -0.05393484607338905, 0.06334306299686432, -0.0006855334504507482, 0.026474852114915848, 0.0025603503454476595, 0.02146104723215103, -0.008195960894227028, 0.02794811502099037, -0.08104085177183151, 0.0056359958834946156, -0.02157774195075035, -0.010710564441978931, -0.014270181767642498, 0.036118075251579285, 0.06993193924427032, 0.05996598303318024, 0.06680560857057571, -0.006617007311433554, -0.03802499547600746, -0.03992626443505287, 0.01579127088189125, 0.02528817392885685, -0.07517259567975998, 0.04001886397600174, -0.02045378088951111, 0.0224627498537302, 0.01429992076009512, 0.024128463119268417, -0.028915103524923325, 0.006216866429895163, 0.11216197907924652, 0.008584965951740742, -0.012753086164593697, -0.03854423016309738, 0.006867395248264074, 0.016255145892500877, 0.031019553542137146, 0.03239435702562332, -0.027058716863393784, -0.02215779758989811, 0.036606986075639725, 0.04418160393834114, 0.04486788809299469, -0.0033503184095025063, -0.03408738225698471, 0.01580965146422386, -0.0003688233264256269, -0.061657652258872986, -0.002886958187445998, 0.06411919742822647, -0.021034875884652138, -0.002711751963943243, 0.012624671682715416, 0.017897067591547966, -0.030543331056833267, -0.015285310335457325, -0.036383725702762604, 0.01623358018696308, 0.006894632708281279, 0.024448277428746223, 0.02138303592801094, 0.03431166708469391, -0.02512812614440918, 0.012404442764818668, -0.03418240323662758, 0.037317752838134766, -0.009783576242625713, 0.03757651522755623, -0.02692565508186817, 0.015494586899876595, -0.04110460728406906, -0.032841794192790985, -0.02550315670669079, 0.0049602012149989605, -0.042751651257276535, -0.01352283637970686, -0.04734562709927559, -0.06493470817804337, -0.02038942649960518, 0.05731811374425888, 0.06601081788539886, 0.009133905172348022, 0.056883253157138824, -0.017691830173134804, 0.06493614614009857, 0.07832157611846924, 0.020220410078763962, -0.02673938125371933, 0.027020201086997986, 0.07121585309505463, -0.04049579054117203, -0.016071461141109467, 0.0447952039539814, -0.03243463113903999, 0.0034528637770563364, 0.00561654195189476, -0.019127989187836647, -0.030057189986109734, 0.019069204106926918, 0.04019727557897568, 0.050505947321653366, -0.035385098308324814, -0.006591861601918936, -0.021746208891272545, -0.005571496672928333, -0.06576218456029892, -0.024243516847491264, 0.03052782639861107, -0.03913188725709915, 0.05655316635966301, -0.0032455718610435724, 0.021634520962834358, -0.02902674861252308, 0.00994027964770794, 0.010553273372352123, -0.0029108452145010233, -0.08854592591524124, 0.038836441934108734, 0.037330687046051025, -0.03404752537608147, -0.018785351887345314, -0.046166229993104935, 0.00014146069588605314, -0.03812285140156746, -0.05606221407651901, 0.012297642417252064, 0.06603735685348511, -0.02161283791065216, -0.012072823941707611, 0.07279592752456665, 0.07534181326627731, -0.06708832830190659, -0.01098771020770073, 0.047427911311388016, -0.028519148007035255, -0.026165682822465897, -0.027560653164982796, 0.03191056475043297, -0.018848711624741554, 0.01069680880755186, -0.007253223564475775, 0.06325548887252808, -0.019977472722530365, -0.022185802459716797, 0.03190678358078003, -0.07035136222839355, 0.00006293452315730974, 0.04998551309108734, 0.03399181365966797, 0.001700960099697113, -0.012154200114309788, -0.023281099274754524, 0.03693622350692749, 0.060991495847702026, -0.0017359174089506269, -0.047469865530729294, 0.025995707139372826, -0.021817881613969803, 0.0024474174715578556, -0.008807606995105743, 0.031804922968149185, 0.003251226618885994, -0.06770811229944229, 0.04178750142455101, -0.029458265751600266, 0.026530707255005836, -0.02893216907978058, -0.0395248681306839, -0.008304424583911896, 0.05394811928272247, -0.027943022549152374, -0.0731547474861145, -0.002870905911549926, -0.006346085574477911, -0.022471169009804726, -0.048545535653829575, -0.009187474846839905, -0.001375917810946703, 0.00968379806727171, -0.049424827098846436, 0.03344855085015297, 0.003727488685399294, 0.00983620248734951, 0.043318964540958405, -0.04229842126369476, 0.020614229142665863, 0.05919155851006508, -0.006748193874955177, -0.004655436612665653, -0.0009222655789926648, 0.004353254567831755, -0.031154094263911247, -0.019741594791412354, -0.02573402039706707, 0.009293257258832455, -0.03689251467585564, 0.0331529937684536, -0.029453281313180923, -0.006744928192347288, 0.053202539682388306, -0.028058147057890892, 0.028808722272515297, 0.0393693633377552, 0.01504049263894558, 0.03147470951080322, -0.013847267255187035, -0.0025799355935305357, 0.0026581082493066788, 0.036450035870075226, -0.012710877694189548, -0.011903657577931881, -0.04608137905597687, 0.0545751191675663, -0.017469575628638268, -0.023541398346424103, 0.03893369436264038, 0.03560550883412361, 0.026092667132616043, 0.006098993122577667, -0.00009271767339669168, 0.02031238004565239, -0.0076828766614198685, 0.019358746707439423, -0.0018111630342900753, -0.02826513908803463, 0.00621660053730011, 0.004133404232561588, -0.0519031323492527, 0.02066049538552761, -0.00903748907148838, 0.02987956814467907, -0.029874803498387337, 0.026436489075422287, -0.05233323574066162, -0.00627910764887929, -0.07092808932065964, -0.021833470091223717, -0.025496765971183777, -0.009687663055956364, -0.04027790203690529, -0.02269858308136463, -0.020954471081495285, 0.06470347195863724, 0.0060914745554327965, 0.05891910940408707, -0.032612137496471405, 0.06568457931280136, 0.002640361664816737, -0.034967195242643356, -0.0722283199429512, 0.0331319235265255, 0.03055056557059288, 0.006496497429907322, -0.026612108573317528, -0.028546957299113274, 0.039528798311948776, -0.03558870032429695, 0.03275395557284355, 0.0007535336771979928, -0.02307468093931675, 0.02573956735432148, -0.02184509113430977, 0.0010892447317019105, -0.025885209441184998, -0.011536901816725731, 0.021134281530976295, 0.027429189532995224, -0.03763061761856079, -0.06780154258012772, 0.016306985169649124, 0.028756067156791687, 0.03067260980606079, 0.05747810751199722, 0.02478858269751072, -0.031156107783317566, -0.010845599696040154, 0.005989304278045893, 0.008700606413185596, 0.02735915780067444, -0.08604694902896881, -0.028255129233002663, -0.028157053515315056, -0.03860290348529816, 0.03473399952054024, 0.03911491483449936, -0.0594930425286293, 0.05240488052368164, 0.013630270026624203, 0.029990874230861664, -0.021250834688544273, 0.01521760132163763, -0.007462491746991873, -0.04022099822759628, 0.0004727287159767002, 0.024127399548888206, 0.00392531231045723, 0.022663645446300507, 0.011395012028515339, -0.04034003987908363, 0.025929687544703484, -0.05302700400352478, 0.0069205439649522305, -0.017858212813735008, 0.02711138129234314, -0.053175874054431915, 0.024987343698740005, -0.011705293320119381, -0.060688018798828125, 0.055522166192531586, -0.013361334800720215, -0.015296456404030323, 0.05057737976312637, -0.033846959471702576, 0.0033822390250861645, -0.002172270556911826, 0.009131870232522488, 0.043053027242422104, -0.026008525863289833, 0.024752244353294373, 0.025854047387838364, -0.0178886279463768, 0.035649437457323074, -0.07363534718751907, 0.029496820643544197, -0.0599130280315876, 0.04029744118452072, -0.04299262538552284, 0.012691562063992023, 0.01373994443565607, -0.030853988602757454, 0.04657142981886864, -0.011884985491633415, -0.03859217092394829, 0.004487456288188696, -0.0629543736577034, 0.014009046368300915, -0.02687031216919422, -0.013153908774256706, 0.04467795044183731, 0.05731857940554619, 0.017487717792391777, -0.06078500673174858, -0.014404576271772385, 0.04318679869174957, 0.025585900992155075, -0.045233044773340225, 0.0768183022737503, 0.053684741258621216, -0.006290627643465996, -0.02157852053642273, -0.01627426967024803, -0.034151479601860046, -0.003476422745734453, -0.007777565158903599, -0.04584657400846481, 0.042694948613643646, -0.01651083119213581, 0.008275226689875126, 0.02420642040669918, -0.0002451205800753087, 0.007839450612664223, -0.012089432217180729, -0.0088639622554183, 0.047697097063064575, -0.02072438783943653, 0.0022754769306629896, -0.05110185593366623, -0.05285835638642311, 0.010021459311246872, -0.02034708298742771, 0.01535059604793787, -0.032573312520980835, 0.0035745298955589533, -0.002904504304751754, -0.008935363963246346, -0.06664365530014038, -0.03600175306200981, 0.024806486442685127, 0.0043289801105856895, -0.03283052518963814, 0.034453343600034714, 0.02990143559873104, 0.007571180816739798, 0.009038912132382393, -0.06148071587085724, 0.018493713811039925, 0.059671800583601, -0.03954882174730301, -0.02647174894809723, -0.019161002710461617, 0.05713474750518799, -0.05591607838869095, 0.0042265416122972965, -0.02636796049773693, -0.0031646466813981533, 0.05503499135375023, 0.008334658108651638, -0.0530439168214798, 0.09614302217960358, -0.030290842056274414, -0.09947355836629868, 0.06387033313512802, 0.058102723211050034, 0.07304852455854416, -0.02361430414021015, -0.04707106575369835, 0.05021175369620323, -0.012831766158342361, 0.01884176768362522, -0.052977055311203, 0.0508723109960556, 0.045648086816072464, 0.022878695279359818, 0.02749798819422722, 0.06724368035793304, -0.012035578489303589, 0.0007922046352177858, -0.003300620708614588, 0.08390380442142487, -0.03950823098421097, -0.024010255932807922, 0.023168029263615608, 0.06374246627092361, -0.06216457858681679, 0.007799546699970961, 0.03169330954551697, 0.005557970143854618, 0.004590031690895557, 0.05419756472110748, 0.02833903394639492, -0.06398282945156097, -0.027230948209762573, 0.06050920858979225, -0.03617063909769058, 0.04188583418726921, 0.060150858014822006, 0.01131471712142229, -0.016787486150860786, 0.031734343618154526, -0.006378882564604282, -0.010072649456560612, -0.04175316542387009, -0.01690153405070305, -0.005510022398084402, -0.04464755952358246, -0.039811599999666214, 0.009035701863467693, -0.005494873039424419, -0.008933746255934238, -0.03776078298687935, 0.03602657839655876, -0.030407411977648735, 0.023353565484285355, -0.01938401535153389, -0.03457975015044212, 0.05494460463523865, -0.020314449444413185, 0.0023179089184850454, 0.01733061484992504, 0.03536691889166832, 0.07357444614171982, 0.03387613594532013, -0.0065414817072451115, 0.03536452725529671, -0.0392146073281765, 0.01725093461573124, -0.027325991541147232, -0.010259034112095833, 0.017724046483635902, -0.019841909408569336, -0.03476383164525032, 0.06319862604141235, -0.06575839221477509, -0.001702518085949123, -0.007871033623814583, 0.07340055704116821, 0.03226179629564285, -0.013172230683267117, -0.07870324701070786, 0.01682054065167904, -0.038978878408670425, -0.017145106568932533, -0.005056947004050016, -0.054937928915023804, -0.029199805110692978, 0.09749311208724976, -0.02812143787741661, -0.040985893458127975, -0.0410170704126358, 0.06089048832654953, -0.04255145788192749, 0.0015582663472741842, 0.027359437197446823, -0.033420491963624954, -0.02673964574933052, -0.018740760162472725, 0.08267337828874588, -0.022622855380177498, 0.01286508422344923, -0.0009870982030406594, -0.02312382683157921, 0.022762630134820938, 0.042218759655952454, -0.07468622177839279, 0.04122990369796753, -0.028057748451828957, -0.0017381319776177406, -0.006182507611811161, -0.03984234482049942, 0.022050948813557625, -0.0471159964799881, 0.013585452921688557, 0.009545020759105682, 0.03130883350968361, -0.00625127786770463, 0.005938170477747917, 0.04392408952116966, -0.01473488099873066, -0.05633139610290527, 0.06388439983129501, -0.03284376114606857, -0.03895774856209755, 0.04029145464301109, -0.042735256254673004, -0.019689157605171204, 0.011384068988263607, 0.05185320973396301, 0.06062251701951027, -0.05980733782052994, 0.010200154967606068, -0.0030430585611611605, 0.02727401815354824, 0.04256701096892357, -0.035156480967998505, 0.02207026071846485, -0.016300251707434654, -0.0012337635271251202, -0.05570327490568161, 0.06893078982830048, -0.012121266685426235, 0.00433886656537652, 0.04867865517735481, 0.08412349969148636, -0.0004688935005106032, -0.016629936173558235, 0.06699749827384949, -0.02316615730524063, -0.03703831136226654, 0.07646770030260086, -0.014656255021691322, 0.05008957162499428, -0.11203138530254364, 0.02230546995997429, -0.008624434471130371, -0.019294196739792824, -0.01761716417968273, 0.029782619327306747, 0.01531545352190733, -0.015025394968688488, -0.015540061518549919, 0.0085432268679142, -0.008694407530128956, -0.02447366714477539, -0.030537104234099388, 0.020899882540106773, -0.007041758857667446, -0.017534390091896057, 0.014420710504055023, -0.012097392231225967, 0.00763086648657918, -0.019584983587265015, 0.04780299961566925, 0.0409744568169117, 0.036610256880521774, -0.06819022446870804, -0.012475666590034962, 0.0005127462209202349, -0.012667165137827396, -0.023100612685084343, -0.05059086158871651, 0.024762358516454697, 0.010018947534263134, -0.08118753880262375, 0.00825566053390503, -0.02648366428911686, -0.0045172288082540035, -0.004133997019380331, -0.050932303071022034, -0.059594787657260895, -0.024735039100050926, 0.04260660707950592, 0.02819233573973179, 0.008122090250253677, -0.0677783414721489, 0.06805738806724548, -0.01001722551882267, 0.024272926151752472, -0.05701495707035065, 0.05784567445516586, 0.011524253524839878, 0.00037299361429177225, -0.018318703398108482, 0.028970105573534966, 0.03636724874377251, -0.017129456624388695, 0.04901116341352463, 0.00039170548552647233, 0.03351479023694992, -0.02055826038122177, 0.0169786736369133, 0.021952617913484573, -0.0283149853348732, 0.04053902253508568, -0.029653316363692284, -0.027560658752918243, -0.01073683612048626, 0.059857118874788284, 0.023427795618772507, 0.03139094263315201, -0.03015427477657795, 0.009412608109414577, 0.03428315371274948, 0.04016700014472008, -0.0038323006592690945, -0.06500811129808426, -0.009159998036921024, 0.01875603385269642, -0.003511836752295494, -0.009204159490764141, 0.0007720367866568267, 0.00996783934533596, -0.020712560042738914, -0.06239047273993492, 0.004541273228824139, -0.04431580379605293, -0.06511190533638, -0.002856920473277569, -0.05666707456111908, -0.01841868832707405, 0.028325656428933144, -0.08342161774635315, -0.017993392422795296, 0.0033357099164277315, -0.04616471379995346, -0.040577854961156845, 0.01564837619662285, -0.009610041044652462, 0.0165229644626379, -0.009915006347000599, -0.0101464306935668, 0.01089382078498602, -0.04320596158504486, 0.06594471633434296, 0.008200423792004585, 0.07563839107751846, -0.05466561019420624, -0.055469218641519547, -0.009084970690310001, 0.017541859298944473, 0.023433025926351547, 0.0003945016651414335, -0.026009202003479004, -0.031846486032009125, -0.05424042418599129, 0.014133275486528873, -0.02410130575299263, 0.07270609587430954, -0.036181628704071045, 0.03091622143983841, -0.02678920328617096, -0.04002837836742401, -0.00819858256727457, -0.03179285302758217, -0.02273024432361126, 0.01162547804415226 ]
<p>So I've had a problem for a long time now understanding energy-mass equivalence, in particular I've had a lot of trouble understanding how something like interatomic potentials can be seen as mass. I've heard other people on the site say it depends on how you probe the system, which doesn't make too much sense to me, I don't see why mass should change based on 'what level you view the system at'. Can someone help me understand mass-energy equivalency? </p>
g7466
[ 0.021071944385766983, 0.04624151065945625, 0.010919855907559395, -0.0012533427216112614, 0.032861217856407166, 0.014642390422523022, 0.0034238470252603292, 0.04412821680307388, -0.04126482084393501, 0.024735894054174423, 0.02853626012802124, 0.0035720716696232557, 0.008164185099303722, 0.037716351449489594, 0.010397332720458508, 0.01819535717368126, 0.054144833236932755, -0.04715829715132713, -0.004196023102849722, 0.017341248691082, 0.017141135409474373, 0.018341366201639175, -0.023046055808663368, 0.018611067906022072, 0.01599014177918434, 0.008827520534396172, 0.02628706954419613, -0.035339392721652985, -0.0009721338865347207, 0.0012202528305351734, 0.031221436336636543, 0.014414818026125431, 0.041332755237817764, -0.021235015243291855, 0.005806510336697102, -0.008709719404578209, 0.04628903791308403, 0.0355583056807518, -0.016014236956834793, 0.008387310430407524, 0.02580297738313675, -0.004024429712444544, 0.006660827435553074, -0.036526717245578766, 0.026325123384594917, 0.00002720131669775583, -0.016207478940486908, -0.02184445597231388, 0.028922419995069504, 0.02815055474638939, 0.01586538925766945, 0.050323691219091415, 0.05896598845720291, 0.03522590175271034, 0.03366453945636749, 0.036735501140356064, -0.007438224740326405, 0.0363193154335022, 0.0511082224547863, 0.06066812947392464, 0.07286813110113144, 0.04136455059051514, 0.014197448268532753, -0.008407861925661564, 0.036485373973846436, -0.00596656696870923, -0.0042184824123978615, 0.04877077043056488, -0.01229658629745245, -0.031152872368693352, -0.008288001641631126, 0.014500238932669163, -0.030175935477018356, -0.03145920857787132, 0.047132428735494614, -0.07132947444915771, -0.03146020323038101, -0.0012522703036665916, -0.006739063188433647, -0.034660354256629944, 0.0011123110307380557, -0.028220603242516518, 0.03630487993359566, -0.006774187088012695, 0.07924994081258774, -0.040041059255599976, -0.02957586571574211, 0.0035282361786812544, 0.006991606205701828, 0.012603968381881714, 0.014795675873756409, 0.04437436908483505, 0.06658018380403519, 0.017113948240876198, -0.05864067003130913, 0.005352984182536602, 0.0008980560232885182, 0.054979704320430756, -0.022511471062898636, -0.02071242965757847, -0.029010403901338577, 0.0032762165647000074, 0.013205037452280521, 0.03374825417995453, -0.03977257385849953, 0.02356310561299324, 0.020417526364326477, -0.009585438296198845, 0.012971428222954273, 0.018682057037949562, -0.03047752194106579, -0.02722005918622017, -0.020132767036557198, 0.006868905853480101, -0.05006208270788193, -0.04407680034637451, 0.08128625899553299, 0.0025145583786070347, -0.03229737654328346, 0.045292362570762634, 0.02063450962305069, 0.041686274111270905, -0.0398266576230526, 0.03317529335618019, -0.02750062383711338, -0.09257902204990387, -0.027566421777009964, -0.02870684117078781, -0.0429542101919651, -0.028661523014307022, 0.03888702392578125, -0.02821444161236286, -0.0027463429141789675, -0.04940824583172798, 0.036394234746694565, -0.022279536351561546, -0.016438713297247887, -0.06980637460947037, -0.0010474658338353038, -0.0011496806982904673, 0.030699705705046654, -0.027267996221780777, -0.017958490177989006, -0.007560163736343384, -0.04386596009135246, 0.0030416955705732107, -0.06656917184591293, -0.026811281219124794, 0.02288181707262993, 0.0536830872297287, 0.033324021846055984, 0.08215968310832977, -0.003773848060518503, -0.09835667908191681, 0.04756198450922966, -0.026003127917647362, -0.03560519218444824, -0.013237169943749905, 0.010129060596227646, -0.0028750053606927395, -0.015262848697602749, -0.0032669296488165855, 0.02952592819929123, -0.01453050971031189, -0.036132048815488815, -0.01641521044075489, 0.055401794612407684, -0.02058004029095173, 0.010691291652619839, -0.045224063098430634, -0.026516972109675407, 0.016647014766931534, 0.0017894580960273743, 0.07145702838897705, -0.08086346089839935, 0.06250045448541641, 0.032065216451883316, -0.04933410882949829, 0.0560525506734848, 0.024210313335061073, -0.00369537272490561, -0.04133133590221405, 0.05226938799023628, -0.04309298098087311, -0.01530930120497942, -0.0314665362238884, 0.05174906179308891, 0.033124230802059174, 0.014202778227627277, 0.05575945973396301, -0.01638590171933174, -0.049149416387081146, -0.004032736178487539, -0.009565127082169056, 0.029295800253748894, 0.02571932226419449, -0.011792375706136227, -0.048186566680669785, -0.04918985068798065, -0.05382132530212402, -0.08089487999677658, -0.006934922654181719, 0.02626200020313263, 0.03778873011469841, 0.028445368632674217, 0.011950003914535046, 0.03946937248110771, 0.010155663825571537, 0.04317928105592728, 0.002750833285972476, 0.005365467164665461, -0.02744579128921032, 0.030974343419075012, 0.0004601240798365325, -0.034710679203271866, 0.07464080303907394, 0.023443391546607018, 0.018077529966831207, 0.04845637083053589, -0.021798264235258102, -0.04297822713851929, -0.05969676002860069, 0.0365900993347168, -0.012351966463029385, -0.0348496176302433, 0.005896428599953651, -0.06826326996088028, -0.007007069420069456, 0.0027392711490392685, 0.007781542371958494, 0.0054720728658139706, 0.04980061948299408, 0.031062306836247444, 0.022868987172842026, 0.039488643407821655, 0.03344934061169624, -0.008500252850353718, -0.010713743977248669, 0.043885037302970886, -0.040199678391218185, -0.04039449244737625, -0.04922691732645035, -0.03612460568547249, 0.05048590153455734, 0.06172076240181923, -0.015173118561506271, 0.04671416059136391, -0.02066255547106266, -0.02959713526070118, 0.033024389296770096, -0.01145192701369524, -0.008305679075419903, -0.02651422657072544, 0.028549278154969215, 0.0021338125225156546, -0.03334413468837738, -0.006750299595296383, 0.01545137632638216, 0.006311228033155203, 0.022340482100844383, 0.017112107947468758, -0.03831673413515091, -0.05546104907989502, 0.04219530522823334, -0.031406085938215256, -0.017593348398804665, 0.020840194076299667, -0.06168021634221077, 0.003797737881541252, -0.060807887464761734, 0.02699090726673603, 0.06810826063156128, 0.009657805785536766, 0.035474468022584915, 0.009886716492474079, 0.010131225921213627, 0.01151446346193552, -0.04542192816734314, 0.02537795528769493, -0.053339019417762756, -0.007080889772623777, 0.032586295157670975, -0.03755973279476166, 0.025894630700349808, 0.06188851594924927, -0.06155426427721977, -0.003535809461027384, -0.0323764942586422, -0.01997382752597332, -0.024705037474632263, -0.021524839103221893, -0.041640035808086395, 0.009102036245167255, 0.0018235098104923964, -0.052972011268138885, -0.03864618018269539, 0.037933867424726486, -0.031815990805625916, -0.00928352028131485, 0.002846844494342804, -0.01890011690557003, 0.014961379580199718, 0.003271734807640314, -0.019971530884504318, -0.027654608711600304, 0.044946007430553436, -0.022649142891168594, -0.03970659151673317, -0.08386532962322235, 0.010657761245965958, -0.03476722538471222, 0.02066883258521557, -0.024009697139263153, -0.008824360556900501, 0.0019548290874809027, -0.009024672210216522, 0.0009332069894298911, -0.009469549171626568, -0.022659240290522575, -0.01069671381264925, -0.04830136522650719, 0.016100378707051277, 0.09597223252058029, 0.017437243834137917, -0.026393428444862366, -0.021613197401165962, 0.016374537721276283, -0.06435472518205643, -0.10089464485645294, -0.04912254214286804, 0.0008195241098292172, 0.017757251858711243, -0.03344106301665306, 0.05776427686214447, -0.058757245540618896, -0.02552097849547863, -0.012442686595022678, -0.018825218081474304, 0.02783261053264141, 0.020014261826872826, 0.004821465816348791, 0.04792550951242447, -0.07093919813632965, 0.033058103173971176, -0.058494895696640015, -0.00021703318634536117, -0.028050875291228294, -0.038969073444604874, -0.00004350040399003774, -0.06121394410729408, 0.013156255707144737, 0.06180935725569725, 0.038432396948337555, 0.040115319192409515, -0.0016165163833647966, -0.046284664422273636, 0.027297159656882286, 0.010079885832965374, 0.04764270409941673, 0.04792868345975876, 0.03808217495679855, -0.005397805944085121, 0.07246706634759903, -0.049599383026361465, -0.01705455221235752, 0.008786619640886784, -0.052115995436906815, -0.06259820610284805, 0.02291766367852688, -0.04962977021932602, -0.01947067677974701, -0.04402299225330353, 0.03888792544603348, -0.013545788824558258, 0.005040045361965895, -0.07800384610891342, 0.07238724827766418, 0.0044015198945999146, -0.03570568934082985, -0.004240313079208136, 0.03392864018678665, -0.020921846851706505, -0.014799674041569233, -0.03268931061029434, 0.04872084781527519, 0.016878746449947357, 0.003437708131968975, 0.01944613642990589, -0.0173854548484087, 0.026601223275065422, -0.017112700268626213, -0.08227662742137909, -0.056098513305187225, 0.023562772199511528, 0.022904882207512856, -0.013215501792728901, 0.0022268283646553755, -0.023922644555568695, 0.018121017143130302, 0.08199000358581543, -0.03147654980421066, -0.013154149055480957, -0.03142036870121956, -0.03357787802815437, 0.009515956975519657, -0.014606268145143986, 0.030880631878972054, -0.046784043312072754, -0.03573182597756386, 0.010942963883280754, 0.04148976877331734, 0.003141166642308235, 0.05414878949522972, -0.02092554233968258, -0.05632539838552475, 0.0004113385803066194, -0.0360126830637455, -0.04780067130923271, 0.05157703161239624, 0.060807306319475174, -0.06986980885267258, 0.012275731191039085, -0.026643652468919754, -0.04769047722220421, -0.009779621846973896, 0.15330559015274048, 0.0733533576130867, 0.020163604989647865, -0.007257377728819847, 0.003735323902219534, -0.01141898613423109, 0.03662853688001633, 0.009743179194629192, -0.02842540107667446, -0.07007388025522232, 0.030632589012384415, 0.016132239252328873, -0.004980260506272316, -0.0026529189199209213, 0.007577939890325069, 0.05702808126807213, 0.056284673511981964, -0.05342405289411545, -0.011899354867637157, -0.007005851250141859, 0.005494413897395134, -0.056974735110998154, -0.034164462238550186, -0.0703301802277565, -0.04804011061787605, -0.07782725244760513, 0.014272281900048256, -0.053108714520931244, -0.034886255860328674, -0.042836613953113556, -0.039482906460762024, -0.03829361870884895, -0.006018362939357758, -0.023076660931110382, -0.005225506145507097, -0.02075648307800293, -0.014687160961329937, 0.05368765816092491, -0.009773116558790207, 0.01373964361846447, 0.027497638016939163, -0.014378316700458527, 0.035373758524656296, -0.058825910091400146, -0.022451922297477722, 0.018431618809700012, -0.05307239666581154, 0.00004881809582002461, -0.030770055949687958, 0.0011726964730769396, 0.023494215682148933, 0.00522780092433095, -0.0426473394036293, 0.061019014567136765, -0.055592652410268784, -0.0271364264190197, 0.03951432183384895, 0.08373534679412842, 0.03804498538374901, 0.002350022317841649, 0.0321497917175293, -0.009797124192118645, 0.06418855488300323, 0.02894573286175728, -0.007299352437257767, 0.03197004273533821, 0.04570531100034714, 0.016499435529112816, -0.0101701645180583, 0.06527911126613617, -0.0062387059442698956, 0.05604688450694084, -0.05188712850213051, 0.0006451117806136608, 0.02093094401061535, -0.02318400703370571, 0.020387716591358185, -0.046593476086854935, 0.041229985654354095, 0.035140275955200195, 0.02996346727013588, 0.02995304763317108, -0.07599020004272461, 0.001933371415361762, 0.01274143811315298, -0.02362366020679474, 0.05862461030483246, -0.0033355955965816975, 0.07271269708871841, 0.01471271924674511, -0.012298923917114735, -0.004033657256513834, 0.016454553231596947, 0.016023710370063782, -0.04505285993218422, 0.020606860518455505, -0.019783517345786095, 0.03559165447950363, -0.002193742897361517, -0.03881799429655075, 0.020331338047981262, -0.00443938747048378, -0.010149229317903519, -0.02657241001725197, 0.027153875678777695, 0.009029563516378403, -0.009624959900975227, 0.022385232150554657, -0.013452557846903801, -0.019275706261396408, -0.014663243666291237, -0.06639961153268814, 0.032790180295705795, 0.050701506435871124, 0.05658532679080963, 0.026519296690821648, -0.08444048464298248, -0.009278690442442894, 0.025772808119654655, -0.005241852719336748, 0.0013999566435813904, -0.001126508112065494, -0.03379982337355614, 0.011682352051138878, -0.03523728623986244, -0.03227366507053375, -0.016663236543536186, 0.014088048599660397, -0.044404536485672, 0.05882006511092186, 0.09085214138031006, 0.0044670067727565765, 0.014006068930029869, -0.04222286120057106, -0.002447265200316906, 0.04434395954012871, 0.03567695617675781, 0.007583150640130043, 0.014538449235260487, 0.05055874586105347, -0.09230823069810867, -0.012050487101078033, -0.025591835379600525, 0.05081997811794281, -0.03164853900671005, 0.02717762440443039, 0.04387904331088066, 0.042820803821086884, -0.011789374053478241, 0.021369466558098793, 0.03530590608716011, -0.017209580168128014, -0.03454756736755371, 0.023818742483854294, -0.009032368659973145, -0.002538796979933977, -0.031795062124729156, 0.005613733548671007, 0.03539184108376503, -0.0019707761239260435, 0.019096149131655693, -0.03243732824921608, -0.045751120895147324, 0.037434399127960205, -0.0026847959961742163, -0.0778062492609024, -0.05746927112340927, 0.03363008052110672, -0.012078819796442986, -0.0025555419269949198, 0.07737496495246887, -0.022268591448664665, -0.009431612677872181, 0.012665423564612865, 0.012972322292625904, 0.07180346548557281, -0.012659868225455284, 0.04219915717840195, -0.043743181973695755, -0.0018087057396769524, 0.049003202468156815, -0.026800353080034256, -0.004539411049336195, -0.02046150155365467, -0.007411422207951546, -0.02705310471355915, 0.012512385845184326, -0.022007640451192856, -0.06917323172092438, 0.016949983313679695, -0.017217222601175308, -0.07881736010313034, 0.011079571209847927, -0.020169222727417946, -0.03814488649368286, 0.01888224110007286, 0.004015040583908558, 0.09751811623573303, -0.020139677450060844, 0.04915118217468262, 0.0040747178718447685, -0.005178029648959637, 0.09194754809141159, 0.05555898696184158, -0.010418287478387356, -0.034332286566495895, -0.014653807505965233, 0.024658340960741043, 0.03868917375802994, -0.01952786184847355, 0.011234130710363388, -0.0035349023528397083, -0.008994258008897305, 0.041106004267930984, -0.011861921288073063, -0.012306549586355686, 0.000632639043033123, -0.020643645897507668, 0.04944850876927376, -0.04064415395259857, -0.037028416991233826, 0.01746268942952156, 0.007488062139600515, -0.012277111411094666, -0.026124071329832077, -0.038459792733192444, -0.02089550346136093, -0.06771985441446304, 0.0316823273897171, 0.01348469965159893, 0.02379649318754673, -0.01914031431078911, 0.005561275407671928, 0.04243448004126549, -0.021410660818219185, -0.022203870117664337, 0.032476551830768585, -0.007531382609158754, 0.02482643537223339, 0.02327362820506096, 0.07591382414102554, 0.05331816524267197, -0.031428538262844086, -0.022461554035544395, -0.010671586729586124, -0.011696495115756989, -0.04476199299097061, -0.06402579694986343, 0.0012127392692491412, -0.009713812731206417, 0.020118560642004013, 0.012760905548930168, -0.004718340467661619, -0.027253441512584686, 0.016362369060516357, 0.0019180320668965578, 0.032287001609802246, 0.04371079429984093, 0.06056155264377594, -0.007275851909071207, 0.0047523644752800465, -0.07117432355880737, -0.017640704289078712, -0.031074902042746544, -0.025282498449087143, -0.02318366803228855, -0.015346525236964226, 0.06820792704820633, 0.02333485707640648, -0.01876717619597912, -0.025195816531777382, 0.0603858083486557, 0.021946806460618973, 0.06128668785095215, -0.038650140166282654, 0.023440025746822357, -0.0428633913397789, 0.0017724356148391962, 0.00920692179352045, 0.016079161316156387, -0.008302201516926289, -0.03841087222099304, 0.008150956593453884, -0.011605911888182163, 0.022179730236530304, 0.03086206130683422, 0.010150562971830368, 0.003612346015870571, 0.019268406555056572, 0.022762706503272057, -0.04322575032711029, -0.031092146411538124, 0.017246417701244354, -0.05788138881325722, -0.0119816605001688, 0.03155858442187309, 0.03199130669236183, 0.03827387094497681, -0.062218405306339264, -0.01857810840010643, -0.01923852600157261, 0.02237725630402565, -0.009411304257810116, 0.00014433267642743886, -0.018521275371313095, 0.004584282636642456, 0.04285850375890732, 0.006834930740296841, -0.022412167862057686, -0.023894676938652992, -0.00912999827414751, 0.013409524224698544, -0.0014451701426878572, -0.02034107968211174, 0.008330225013196468, 0.013227924704551697, -0.08759915828704834, 0.004369376692920923, 0.041906315833330154, -0.029154308140277863, -0.011387281119823456, 0.003303221194073558, -0.0015145610086619854, 0.05927601829171181, -0.033482711762189865, -0.008116164244711399, 0.02229568548500538, -0.0679575577378273, 0.03931718319654465, 0.03482263535261154, -0.08251852542161942, 0.054407019168138504, 0.03455493971705437, -0.03784662112593651, 0.0294401403516531, -0.005914235953241587, 0.0010750191286206245, -0.06041118502616882, -0.02789764665067196, -0.024311039596796036, -0.016484081745147705, -0.024330073967576027, 0.01377645693719387 ]
<p>The Rarita-Schwinger action in curved $n$-dimensional spacetime is</p> <p>$$ \int \sqrt{g} \overline{\psi}_a \gamma^{abc} D_b \psi_c $$</p> <p>Here $g = \det(g_{\mu \nu})$, and the indices $a, b \dots$ are 'internal' indices that transform under e.g. $\mathrm{SO} (3,1) $ in $3+1$ dimensions. $\gamma^{abc} = \gamma^{[a} \gamma^{b} \gamma^{c]}$ with the gamma matrices obeying $\gamma^a \gamma^b + \gamma^b \gamma^a = 2 \eta^{ab} $, and $\eta^{ab}=\mathrm{diag}(1,1 \ldots 1,-1,-1 \ldots -1)$ is the 'internal metric'. $\psi_{\mu} = \psi_{c} e^{c}_{\mu} $ is a spinor-valued one form. Spacetime indices $\mu, \nu$ can be 'converted' to internal indices using the frame field $e_a^{\mu}$, and vice versa. The covariant derivative is $D_{\mu} \psi_{\nu} =\partial_{\mu} \psi_{\nu} + \frac{1}{4} \omega_{\mu}^{ab} \gamma_{ab} \psi_{\nu} $. Here $\omega$ is taken to be the torsion free spin connection, and $\gamma^{ab} = \gamma^{[a} \gamma^{b]}$.</p> <p>In flat space, the covariant derivative becomes a normal derivative, and the action then has a symmetry $\psi_c \rightarrow \psi_c + \partial_c \phi $, with $\phi$ an arbitrary function. This freedom can be used to eliminate some of the degrees of freedom from the field $\psi_c$ which correspond to lower spin. However, in curved space there is no corresponding symmetry under $\psi_c \rightarrow \psi_c + D_c \phi$. For this reason, it is said that the Rarita-Schwinger action in curved spacetime is inconsistent. My question is, what goes wrong when you don't have this extra symmetry? And do the problems manifest at the classical level or only at the quantum level?</p>
g7467
[ 0.03617226704955101, -0.029200006276369095, -0.015090467408299446, 0.027313001453876495, 0.025552308186888695, 0.08332233130931854, 0.04543479532003403, -0.02361166663467884, -0.02474185638129711, 0.03565903380513191, -0.009925547055900097, 0.04233225807547569, -0.03668887913227081, -0.02921243943274021, -0.009456275030970573, -0.029156459495425224, 0.05193775147199631, -0.006815772037953138, 0.00594689417630434, -0.008988047018647194, -0.0940631702542305, 0.0011519290274009109, -0.0038657980039715767, 0.023857565596699715, 0.06913665682077408, 0.01671367511153221, 0.011279693804681301, -0.042876288294792175, -0.047793637961149216, -0.006912499666213989, 0.027535146102309227, 0.09396567195653915, 0.0227495227009058, -0.04900667816400528, 0.0451643243432045, -0.036712225526571274, 0.0419468954205513, 0.02324651926755905, -0.007042220328003168, 0.028337931260466576, -0.021029405295848846, -0.016915861517190933, 0.0261104553937912, 0.008684594184160233, -0.007751416880637407, 0.036855243146419525, 0.0012342003174126148, 0.035522252321243286, -0.013767125084996223, -0.009454426355659962, -0.0031976334284991026, 0.04169213026762009, 0.02626906894147396, -0.008076503872871399, -0.014685544185340405, -0.014478737488389015, 0.01423210185021162, 0.010710080154240131, 0.03525503724813461, 0.04154219105839729, -0.050696104764938354, -0.05853063985705376, 0.04238293692469597, 0.06549664586782455, 0.012227610684931278, 0.006702279672026634, -0.05002834275364876, -0.03842499852180481, 0.009807784110307693, 0.0010523608652874827, 0.007355149835348129, -0.054641466587781906, 0.03861573711037636, 0.02319367788732052, -0.09032033383846283, 0.00932912714779377, -0.009431812912225723, 0.012009521014988422, -0.028928790241479874, -0.03657771646976471, -0.030578769743442535, 0.008884578943252563, -0.00990393478423357, 0.020279033109545708, 0.07212422788143158, 0.012067382223904133, -0.008626116439700127, 0.0026502988766878843, -0.033803489059209824, 0.05224915221333504, 0.02107529528439045, -0.034362565726041794, 0.02167651057243347, 0.0026335930451750755, 0.012525966390967369, -0.010041830129921436, 0.017525846138596535, 0.01308614481240511, -0.0529494509100914, -0.01889549382030964, -0.029528573155403137, 0.06848889589309692, 0.0606636181473732, 0.04796230047941208, 0.004421981982886791, -0.03282265365123749, 0.09850982576608658, -0.02413087710738182, -0.007088956888765097, -0.02368582971394062, -0.017827991396188736, -0.03252722695469856, 0.015423107892274857, -0.022340621799230576, -0.008659381419420242, -0.0396207794547081, -0.008151615038514137, -0.048816658556461334, -0.011518501676619053, 0.006766587030142546, -0.0273438673466444, 0.011287711560726166, 0.020882124081254005, 0.00322530884295702, 0.014553971588611603, 0.030814340338110924, -0.004118151962757111, -0.024701042100787163, 0.05927516147494316, -0.0590021125972271, 0.008860490284860134, -0.0032391222193837166, -0.01800723187625408, 0.0770038515329361, -0.018836844712495804, 0.04161440208554268, -0.054072823375463486, 0.041686635464429855, -0.026761438697576523, -0.07319851964712143, -0.016130749136209488, 0.004620065446943045, 0.0430876687169075, 0.005305901635438204, -0.002564351772889495, 0.018485793843865395, 0.020426686853170395, -0.06102155148983002, 0.03741493076086044, -0.002533620223402977, -0.011442922987043858, 0.050747230648994446, -0.06918803602457047, -0.017876844853162766, 0.005765631794929504, -0.017629848793148994, 0.015780635178089142, 0.053098853677511215, 0.005682541988790035, -0.02448480762541294, 0.12001936882734299, -0.029048729687929153, 0.04356002435088158, 0.029465259984135628, -0.021801181137561798, 0.00646905368193984, -0.012302949093282223, -0.015783259645104408, 0.017260989174246788, -0.10033733397722244, -0.0391155369579792, 0.0026715814601629972, -0.006591564975678921, -0.03345964103937149, -0.03593854978680611, 0.07245714962482452, -0.02161724865436554, 0.013939620926976204, 0.0121766971424222, 0.03099365346133709, -0.027660595253109932, -0.030785739421844482, -0.003409366589039564, -0.03778381273150444, -0.020446693524718285, -0.03932679072022438, 0.004625475965440273, -0.052215125411748886, -0.04816553741693497, -0.012950608506798744, 0.035889867693185806, -0.00532096391543746, 0.05007249116897583, 0.08519300818443298, -0.02947784960269928, -0.00010454336734255776, 0.00601638900116086, -0.025454813614487648, -0.06472114473581314, 0.02048882283270359, 0.04395438730716705, 0.0066644614562392235, 0.04020833969116211, -0.006507731508463621, 0.006526072975248098, -0.0004815926367882639, -0.012203244492411613, -0.029072511941194534, 0.05070900171995163, -0.0255601666867733, 0.10137659311294556, -0.02891087904572487, -0.00016101851360872388, -0.03244602680206299, -0.019306210801005363, -0.014626393094658852, 0.06428329646587372, 0.01589137874543667, -0.00012722692918032408, 0.0255022831261158, 0.03146878257393837, -0.03786933049559593, 0.044560302048921585, -0.005316853057593107, -0.015434307977557182, 0.04134952649474144, -0.0738167092204094, -0.024639727547764778, 0.022410884499549866, 0.012734846211969852, -0.04546608775854111, 0.007546341046690941, -0.012917924672365189, 0.0030214611906558275, 0.02049410529434681, 0.03615449741482735, -0.024722538888454437, 0.009947352111339569, 0.026813050732016563, -0.015692900866270065, 0.023291273042559624, 0.023885667324066162, -0.07110115140676498, 0.013957480899989605, 0.06524179130792618, 0.04370148852467537, -0.004188289865851402, 0.010090540163218975, -0.05809825286269188, -0.040815748274326324, 0.020552415400743484, -0.017271436750888824, -0.00963856466114521, -0.006488960701972246, 0.014089509844779968, 0.012779878452420235, -0.0009028576896525919, 0.059777338057756424, -0.06825044006109238, -0.020120687782764435, -0.05086677893996239, 0.015722723677754402, -0.002049949485808611, 0.03388725593686104, -0.015035704709589481, -0.01909252069890499, 0.03569672256708145, 0.02370096929371357, 0.004761744290590286, 0.0034641872625797987, -0.01557920128107071, 0.1175069510936737, -0.057131048291921616, 0.034398388117551804, -0.027685904875397682, 0.0007821845938451588, -0.0499720461666584, -0.014914767816662788, 0.010362579487264156, -0.0109948655590415, 0.022826913744211197, -0.013943789526820183, -0.018980002030730247, -0.02597532980144024, 0.02041519433259964, 0.010934322141110897, -0.04925674572587013, 0.023336200043559074, -0.00001105784122046316, 0.0524519719183445, 0.0031983552034944296, 0.030246850103139877, -0.0017703380435705185, -0.08808271586894989, 0.03620729222893715, 0.012143796309828758, -0.0396801196038723, -0.0322403721511364, 0.004544631578028202, 0.03368564695119858, -0.02731224149465561, -0.062238626182079315, -0.03531385585665703, -0.010221784003078938, -0.04803142324090004, -0.0780598446726799, -0.014887657016515732, -0.06507433205842972, -0.05152653530240059, 0.002628663321956992, 0.008342419750988483, 0.014609676785767078, 0.026130054146051407, -0.012006178498268127, -0.023014619946479797, 0.018318260088562965, -0.02704833261668682, -0.047720957547426224, -0.019302379339933395, 0.0338466502726078, -0.020293133333325386, 0.003014275571331382, -0.01601472683250904, -0.01411730982363224, -0.0151157695800066, -0.00846320390701294, -0.03071354702115059, 0.03266996517777443, -0.009825832210481167, -0.03323056548833847, -0.04985343664884567, 0.0229746475815773, 0.06851179897785187, -0.007720366585999727, -0.08787713944911957, 0.009269182570278645, -0.07629203796386719, 0.01910284347832203, 0.05401234328746796, -0.02594929374754429, -0.09394178539514542, -0.054832786321640015, -0.018043536692857742, 0.020165570080280304, 0.011529490351676941, -0.016966626048088074, 0.012986875139176846, 0.0358283556997776, -0.010521044954657555, 0.045117780566215515, -0.05301335081458092, -0.05599312484264374, -0.008613109588623047, -0.05016313120722771, -0.016637176275253296, 0.036379195749759674, 0.022001206874847412, 0.07465139031410217, -0.039308201521635056, -0.0411418192088604, 0.03279949352145195, -0.022965896874666214, -0.055427435785532, 0.005028120707720518, -0.017999589443206787, 0.03239520266652107, -0.0012277690693736076, -0.042631298303604126, -0.022790629416704178, -0.05034375935792923, 0.06328808516263962, -0.036845337599515915, -0.0031579071655869484, 0.01765187829732895, 0.009948170743882656, -0.009168284013867378, -0.011505628935992718, -0.02539386972784996, -0.00726301409304142, 0.028498724102973938, 0.02841414138674736, -0.03625955805182457, -0.02231755293905735, -0.02056371234357357, -0.006831107661128044, 0.03435877338051796, -0.06257385015487671, 0.022307056933641434, -0.02147250808775425, -0.002459163311868906, -0.006619073450565338, -0.02482093870639801, 0.03091531991958618, 0.02633199281990528, 0.011035704985260963, 0.0006901697488501668, 0.030853500589728355, -0.007706057280302048, -0.008768389001488686, -0.016699250787496567, 0.011728090234100819, -0.02810482494533062, 0.03380903601646423, -0.014660289511084557, 0.024300796911120415, 0.021407125517725945, 0.025435546413064003, -0.030443992465734482, -0.006541593931615353, -0.011994984932243824, 0.014243109151721, 0.04067086800932884, 0.031737808138132095, -0.08823578804731369, 0.06754010915756226, 0.005163365509361029, -0.013011819683015347, -0.022907745093107224, -0.047776222229003906, -0.03764473274350166, 0.019648442044854164, 0.03749401122331619, 0.04345225542783737, 0.03390629589557648, 0.06746332347393036, 0.061788201332092285, 0.056013140827417374, -0.024049464613199234, -0.03745432198047638, -0.059183236211538315, 0.007333794143050909, 0.008509051986038685, -0.020156681537628174, 0.0424460805952549, -0.07242634147405624, 0.05554810166358948, -0.06845376640558243, 0.031378213316202164, -0.006661619525402784, 0.03414870426058769, 0.06805109977722168, 0.014013293199241161, 0.04000990837812424, -0.05635447800159454, -0.035951271653175354, 0.016582230105996132, -0.05884901061654091, -0.03360453620553017, -0.008654413744807243, 0.034288134425878525, 0.009683332405984402, 0.00008799217903288081, -0.025334708392620087, 0.005760123487561941, -0.02070382982492447, -0.03725987300276756, -0.04495066776871681, 0.012779179029166698, 0.031746845692396164, 0.026762953028082848, -0.021700935438275337, -0.030592618510127068, -0.004212232772260904, -0.006221634801477194, 0.05305302515625954, 0.02328830026090145, -0.05234552547335625, 0.009916534647345543, -0.061362750828266144, -0.021148910745978355, 0.056296974420547485, 0.010544072836637497, -0.005811979994177818, -0.04991220310330391, 0.00511547876521945, 0.0741005390882492, -0.02053367719054222, -0.01901864819228649, -0.10474430024623871, -0.028988869860768318, -0.020900731906294823, -0.005349005106836557, 0.014949384145438671, 0.005505281966179609, -0.06139671057462692, -0.04040149971842766, 0.017220234498381615, -0.036498840898275375, 0.0039922199212014675, -0.013951610773801804, 0.021335454657673836, 0.03732720762491226, -0.03295103833079338, -0.0196034237742424, 0.0013302348088473082, 0.05437052994966507, 0.005554315634071827, -0.0435597263276577, -0.03749021515250206, -0.009092607535421848, -0.06423311680555344, 0.016095692291855812, -0.00045895695802755654, -0.01695815473794937, -0.01709492690861225, -0.008518107235431671, 0.027242369949817657, 0.013900939375162125, -0.06358347088098526, 0.04109979048371315, -0.013006110675632954, -0.029395852237939835, 0.02705652080476284, 0.023391084745526314, 0.021768035367131233, 0.020959749817848206, 0.010487782768905163, -0.03315558657050133, 0.020575789734721184, -0.05237649753689766, -0.01640484668314457, 0.03097318299114704, 0.017142698168754578, -0.07587803900241852, 0.07206612825393677, 0.053490541875362396, -0.03505941852927208, -0.041737642139196396, 0.011004379950463772, 0.034350112080574036, 0.007562308106571436, -0.008637122809886932, 0.03924030438065529, 0.019631706178188324, 0.003051147796213627, -0.014497802592813969, -0.023790333420038223, 0.03083602897822857, 0.006996392738074064, 0.013157572597265244, -0.02483258582651615, -0.002239531371742487, -0.01890239678323269, 0.03642182797193527, -0.07681446522474289, 0.061968497931957245, -0.044612277299165726, 0.012050356715917587, -0.020409677177667618, 0.029126079753041267, 0.0010467271786183119, -0.004918708465993404, -0.031063538044691086, 0.024719765409827232, -0.05693114176392555, 0.005451027769595385, 0.040846604853868484, -0.04519125074148178, 0.022452563047409058, -0.011176057159900665, 0.015594993717968464, -0.025600267574191093, 0.08046555519104004, 0.029321713373064995, -0.002692975103855133, -0.022643307223916054, -0.03324907645583153, -0.05496284365653992, 0.0947815403342247, -0.027615273371338844, -0.06021983176469803, 0.03439299762248993, -0.0036007966846227646, 0.04119451716542244, 0.025479070842266083, 0.018278896808624268, -0.012991894967854023, -0.035482022911310196, -0.030410951003432274, 0.03659151867032051, 0.0010357192950323224, 0.008110791444778442, 0.06037938594818115, -0.04043199121952057, 0.010899773798882961, 0.05732410028576851, -0.0018974585691466928, 0.0044919345527887344, 0.01988903433084488, -0.007812554016709328, -0.06657610088586807, 0.006186968646943569, -0.04085687920451164, 0.012648604810237885, 0.0440819188952446, -0.012705299071967602, -0.036809615790843964, -0.014910053461790085, -0.06301386654376984, 0.0077097127214074135, 0.023771138861775398, 0.03586351498961449, 0.06507016718387604, 0.008558571338653564, -0.007851907052099705, -0.002310182899236679, -0.05314312502741814, 0.01841183379292488, 0.004395642317831516, 0.06142274662852287, 0.04598262906074524, 0.02783275954425335, -0.06355198472738266, 0.029800070449709892, 0.03608553111553192, 0.009047313593327999, 0.014797963201999664, 0.029696937650442123, -0.015562143176794052, -0.043878186494112015, 0.018019704148173332, 0.042961761355400085, 0.05730903521180153, 0.01758488267660141, 0.009556774981319904, -0.004560894798487425, -0.0009704852127470076, -0.011998001486063004, -0.0025165798142552376, 0.008906600996851921, 0.015265708789229393, 0.041253287345170975, -0.017344869673252106, 0.038711778819561005, -0.007926573976874352, 0.017560506239533424, -0.039032455533742905, 0.05840358883142471, 0.005162164568901062, 0.01408455055207014, 0.016930434852838516, 0.03586968407034874, 0.06026747450232506, -0.04445771872997284, -0.03366720303893089, -0.023940501734614372, 0.04773791879415512, 0.018460802733898163, -0.07733163237571716, 0.007930297404527664, 0.048500608652830124, 0.001072176150046289, -0.058686040341854095, -0.07606039941310883, 0.002431010827422142, -0.03925907239317894, -0.044939856976270676, 0.060040876269340515, 0.00017949876200873405, -0.09922146052122116, -0.022918496280908585, 0.014647157862782478, -0.009032092988491058, 0.005985889118164778, -0.06683143973350525, 0.09347362071275711, 0.023376254364848137, 0.023593373596668243, 0.030426915735006332, 0.013459957204759121, 0.022112438455224037, -0.021170634776353836, 0.01910964958369732, 0.008123446255922318, 0.05288016423583031, -0.006321261636912823, 0.00895902793854475, 0.021550746634602547, 0.014710778370499611, -0.00595094496384263, 0.005020029842853546, 0.018762247636914253, 0.04225299134850502, 0.05233003944158554, -0.08541535586118698, 0.035952128469944, 0.0032282667234539986, 0.013516354374587536, -0.011460316367447376, -0.0003002026060130447, -0.004953003954142332, -0.0022208509035408497, -0.017639053985476494, -0.00711088115349412, 0.012150035239756107, -0.029121657833456993, 0.032358113676309586, 0.0631045252084732, -0.008595582097768784, 0.04435780271887779, 0.03699091821908951, 0.008569315075874329, -0.003198363585397601, 0.03155110403895378, 0.017769327387213707, -0.00012653229350689799, -0.040833842009305954, -0.016837244853377342, -0.021788068115711212, 0.04882396012544632, 0.00012478820281103253, 0.04264090582728386, -0.011015646159648895, 0.05876699462532997, 0.030303051695227623, 0.024365974590182304, -0.02375418320298195, -0.0030002782586961985, 0.07082642614841461, -0.022477826103568077, -0.035257115960121155, -0.018155526369810104, -0.014839202165603638, -0.07000941038131714, -0.018944762647151947, -0.028965499252080917, 0.017626652494072914, -0.05733880773186684, 0.05886255204677582, -0.045226067304611206, -0.019988346844911575, -0.009364571422338486, -0.05460846424102783, 0.05318513885140419, -0.06396166980266571, 0.016291730105876923, -0.022502059116959572, -0.08008439093828201, 0.013438433408737183, -0.052899621427059174, 0.024997012689709663, 0.0004694978706538677, 0.030496856197714806, 0.02024935558438301, -0.051156360656023026, 0.03998056799173355, 0.031285133212804794, 0.006345152854919434, -0.019237784668803215, 0.01628151163458824, 0.013161267153918743, 0.04109169915318489, 0.06711964309215546, 0.006939675658941269, 0.0008248212398029864, 0.015459468588232994, 0.00044483962119556963, -0.020550640299916267, 0.11082988232374191, 0.021188270300626755, 0.02964942716062069, -0.015962835401296616, -0.011395624838769436, 0.0043057347647845745, 0.0034959441982209682, -0.02366146259009838, 0.021525859832763672, 0.013668286614120007 ]
<p>A moving star's relativistic mass is larger than its rest mass. Is its gravitational pull larger? </p> <p>What about its inertial mass? Does it have larger inertial mass, keeping in mind that inertial mass should equal gravitational mass according to the equivalence principle.</p> <p>I suppose this quote from wikipedia is relavant:</p> <blockquote> <p>However, it turns out that it is impossible to find an objective general definition for the concept of invariant mass in general relativity. At the core of the problem is the non-linearity of the Einstein field equations, which makes it impossible to write the gravitational field energy as part of the Stress–energy tensor in a way that is invariant for all observers. For a given observer, this can be achieved by the Stress–energy–momentum pseudotensor.[21]</p> </blockquote>
g153
[ -0.023175271227955818, 0.030479563400149345, -0.00008523553697159514, 0.0076162186451256275, 0.007506158668547869, 0.032377634197473526, 0.027358783408999443, 0.027352584525942802, -0.08237594366073608, 0.031652119010686874, -0.047961704432964325, -0.05186662822961807, -0.04218350723385811, -0.04433863237500191, 0.028951743617653847, 0.006097637116909027, 0.10986538976430893, -0.04818835109472275, 0.02741762064397335, 0.05832396820187569, 0.0714477077126503, 0.027706801891326904, 0.014444790780544281, 0.010532213374972343, -0.00827715266495943, 0.0419832281768322, 0.009099279530346394, -0.00895982701331377, -0.05216812714934349, 0.019941942766308784, 0.06417925655841827, -0.0040632374584674835, 0.029032662510871887, -0.03576266020536423, 0.006835135165601969, -0.02159598283469677, 0.018284503370523453, 0.03465604782104492, 0.05929163843393326, 0.04112480208277702, 0.002564320806413889, 0.017809251323342323, 0.00979719776660204, -0.025598254054784775, -0.007994107902050018, 0.0014290135586634278, 0.0109788179397583, -0.010105373337864876, 0.01272678468376398, -0.03194930776953697, -0.026919864118099213, 0.052997857332229614, 0.06767340749502182, 0.007068376522511244, -0.019679494202136993, 0.07130961865186691, -0.0004098795761819929, 0.01499378401786089, -0.010594820603728294, 0.0038671777583658695, 0.016988474875688553, -0.014486626721918583, 0.009620160795748234, 0.0019322381122037768, 0.010366182774305344, -0.04344721883535385, -0.006949455477297306, 0.026461640372872353, 0.0378120131790638, -0.01226674485951662, -0.0008890393073670566, 0.003465327899903059, 0.013091455213725567, -0.009873614646494389, -0.051438070833683014, -0.010226016864180565, 0.006281781941652298, 0.03141748905181885, -0.043539080768823624, -0.04740523919463158, -0.00993813294917345, -0.007188837509602308, 0.054497234523296356, 0.02249409817159176, 0.1635003238916397, -0.0324825756251812, -0.0017509863246232271, 0.002713070483878255, -0.008250714279711246, 0.04320530593395233, 0.03059348277747631, -0.010742181912064552, 0.07770410925149918, 0.04462512210011482, 0.005151389632374048, -0.0390169657766819, -0.04665420949459076, 0.03326570615172386, -0.028187574818730354, -0.002251420635730028, 0.010933047160506248, 0.005092567764222622, 0.01879911683499813, 0.0009734140476211905, 0.03169981762766838, -0.0641070008277893, -0.011303124018013477, -0.01780075579881668, -0.02341947890818119, -0.008370749652385712, -0.0056650685146451, -0.05080151930451393, 0.07663878053426743, -0.05200699344277382, -0.07184184342622757, -0.046966806054115295, 0.11555563658475876, 0.007940586656332016, -0.03761173412203789, 0.05800709128379822, -0.019672464579343796, 0.03624628856778145, -0.03500906378030777, 0.10090140998363495, -0.04938832297921181, -0.052880704402923584, -0.0014665006892755628, 0.014981446787714958, 0.02114923670887947, -0.0260748453438282, -0.005941437557339668, -0.03894242271780968, -0.011986988596618176, -0.027819007635116577, -0.007544874679297209, 0.030226288363337517, 0.00327292550355196, -0.0513019859790802, -0.03782214969396591, 0.006416779942810535, 0.027942107990384102, 0.0104764923453331, -0.0035111152101308107, 0.0004915628232993186, 0.02501143142580986, 0.019796540960669518, -0.04397472366690636, -0.017106395214796066, 0.036030516028404236, 0.007214494980871677, 0.025388196110725403, 0.08666766434907913, -0.005003001075237989, -0.0366642028093338, 0.07932170480489731, 0.008344258181750774, -0.054166726768016815, 0.007047052960842848, -0.03498721867799759, 0.04584717005491257, 0.08016587048768997, -0.06143463775515556, 0.03923806548118591, 0.00012447523477021605, 0.005628987681120634, 0.03356325253844261, -0.020454166457057, -0.0035216815304011106, -0.00550122233107686, -0.08613542467355728, -0.06384571641683578, 0.012806358747184277, 0.032897114753723145, 0.01989152282476425, 0.018849365413188934, 0.004571361467242241, 0.014777948148548603, 0.0029275116976350546, -0.007229806389659643, -0.019138824194669724, -0.01530231162905693, -0.05740690976381302, 0.051061633974313736, -0.01519025582820177, 0.0010445255320519209, -0.02057122066617012, 0.035273898392915726, -0.040757592767477036, -0.03247804194688797, 0.038909655064344406, -0.0022619760129600763, 0.03244006633758545, 0.004063256550580263, 0.05023845657706261, 0.04119838401675224, -0.011398689821362495, 0.00933989230543375, -0.02923199161887169, -0.04303726181387901, 0.042305588722229004, -0.022046342492103577, 0.0155831603333354, -0.0038454988971352577, -0.047405969351530075, 0.0031494274735450745, 0.0009612778667360544, -0.010915403254330158, -0.006403454579412937, 0.05455857515335083, -0.0005995308165438473, 0.0473383329808712, -0.05882606282830238, 0.012700541876256466, 0.008969527669250965, -0.05531029775738716, -0.012183199636638165, -0.0013664052821695805, 0.00830517802387476, 0.02314191870391369, 0.003021600190550089, -0.04506467655301094, -0.008917543105781078, 0.03936532512307167, 0.019041555002331734, -0.04355956241488457, 0.0038071151357144117, -0.053943634033203125, -0.029240669682621956, 0.052586618810892105, -0.03166485205292702, -0.029617689549922943, 0.057431597262620926, 0.0011270625982433558, 0.04474901780486107, 0.05461295694112778, 0.010795043781399727, 0.001015468267723918, 0.052802495658397675, 0.022256219759583473, 0.007707110606133938, 0.03211366757750511, -0.00005318601688486524, -0.0039479685947299, -0.06728774309158325, 0.02955658920109272, 0.04364795982837677, 0.04655364155769348, -0.010704856365919113, 0.030921360477805138, 0.06403621286153793, 0.0013152683386579156, -0.04414580017328262, 0.0058927456848323345, -0.049489907920360565, 0.05323796346783638, 0.016015250235795975, 0.01393189374357462, -0.0003472332318779081, -0.04397866874933243, 0.0091312937438488, 0.035419438034296036, -0.059791065752506256, -0.018612556159496307, 0.018864711746573448, -0.06302773207426071, 0.024187151342630386, -0.015962665900588036, 0.026663292199373245, -0.0007364712073467672, 0.024202335625886917, -0.007960853166878223, 0.026786495000123978, -0.014621864072978497, 0.03588053956627846, -0.04376823082566261, 0.011736063286662102, -0.026816831901669502, -0.053759124130010605, -0.004491877742111683, 0.0023509410675615072, -0.005730950273573399, 0.020476287230849266, -0.0662202313542366, -0.009052280336618423, 0.014577191323041916, -0.06471839547157288, 0.004233545158058405, -0.02414809912443161, -0.005443992558866739, 0.005094901658594608, 0.0451258048415184, 0.0072767483070492744, 0.029681190848350525, 0.0008992726216092706, -0.023975448682904243, 0.06966622173786163, -0.016017606481909752, -0.014552661217749119, -0.05833680182695389, -0.0012089270167052746, 0.03032287210226059, -0.017464376986026764, 0.03951338678598404, -0.039171312004327774, -0.021734528243541718, 0.035690512508153915, -0.01666525937616825, -0.023813042789697647, -0.020385807380080223, -0.08223660290241241, -0.024623483419418335, 0.03910813480615616, -0.004020655527710915, 0.012316301465034485, 0.028755033388733864, 0.00808603037148714, -0.021986907348036766, -0.018709886819124222, -0.021157914772629738, -0.024774163961410522, -0.007070827763527632, -0.03229761868715286, 0.018883539363741875, 0.0108189033344388, -0.023692671209573746, -0.028112376108765602, -0.02426382154226303, 0.06623443216085434, -0.080937460064888, -0.05651259422302246, 0.007412313017994165, -0.022794418036937714, -0.04446586221456528, 0.05634242296218872, 0.031007712706923485, -0.002743161516264081, 0.006956809666007757, 0.030472097918391228, 0.10557626187801361, -0.0231523085385561, -0.03271268308162689, 0.02022971585392952, -0.041448384523391724, 0.022416438907384872, -0.02935185842216015, 0.040778905153274536, 0.03055119328200817, -0.06453356146812439, 0.03444858640432358, 0.004472972825169563, 0.021992765367031097, -0.035180121660232544, 0.011629468761384487, -0.040168628096580505, -0.0016768431523814797, 0.006558227818459272, 0.02548966370522976, -0.013836358673870564, 0.01294542383402586, -0.02732987143099308, -0.003097697626799345, 0.01039592083543539, 0.0103310476988554, 0.03477777913212776, 0.005261678248643875, 0.013931497931480408, -0.0029087516013532877, -0.021784281358122826, 0.019136488437652588, 0.025066370144486427, 0.0023414778988808393, -0.050270698964595795, 0.012986994348466396, -0.021741298958659172, -0.0008783650118857622, -0.08722302317619324, 0.05097400024533272, -0.022186841815710068, 0.037656109780073166, -0.012379443272948265, 0.09559153765439987, -0.03141198307275772, -0.05231976509094238, -0.011825121007859707, -0.0020568387117236853, 0.0028640024829655886, -0.033212173730134964, -0.017236944288015366, 0.0777604728937149, -0.018960529938340187, -0.03259190171957016, -0.06058632954955101, -0.009231667034327984, -0.02489796094596386, 0.02781752683222294, -0.009565334767103195, 0.042674921452999115, -0.02063327468931675, 0.016041379421949387, -0.011817839927971363, -0.004910902585834265, 0.05187073349952698, 0.037188444286584854, 0.023117560893297195, -0.02975490503013134, 0.01662072166800499, 0.0317588672041893, -0.019983448088169098, -0.04380723088979721, -0.017972644418478012, 0.025737769901752472, 0.026738014072179794, -0.0061798980459570885, -0.0297168530523777, 0.06433797627687454, 0.01663709245622158, -0.03725037723779678, -0.01694735512137413, 0.07490786910057068, 0.013837519101798534, -0.00913177989423275, 0.004228219855576754, 0.00011119169357698411, -0.056560415774583817, 0.013740419410169125, 0.09406521916389465, 0.07020026445388794, 0.015044145286083221, -0.022748449817299843, -0.02527317963540554, 0.01947895996272564, -0.016701923683285713, 0.048692505806684494, 0.01733492501080036, -0.030600836500525475, 0.05247342959046364, 0.006499220617115498, 0.03651842474937439, 0.015607540495693684, -0.03891978785395622, 0.021879790350794792, 0.029062621295452118, -0.0025213349144905806, -0.01257396675646305, -0.03323480114340782, 0.0793604776263237, 0.04196154698729515, -0.03799475356936455, -0.1000920757651329, -0.0130411796271801, -0.01873420737683773, -0.04819445312023163, -0.013379871845245361, -0.010984774678945541, 0.01528431847691536, -0.011318345554172993, -0.05571511387825012, 0.0063057392835617065, 0.01094597764313221, -0.011113986372947693, 0.013936208561062813, -0.008519112132489681, 0.10217646509408951, 0.06420788168907166, 0.062044043093919754, -0.03616836294531822, -0.08414498716592789, -0.010647176764905453, -0.0083255460485816, 0.010033790022134781, -0.003300408134236932, 0.004806177224963903, -0.01435764878988266, 0.008573170751333237, -0.021396446973085403, -0.013288259506225586, -0.007018346805125475, -0.03297486528754234, 0.007549372501671314, -0.08798161149024963, -0.06420811265707016, 0.04050230234861374, 0.02161025069653988, -0.01850072853267193, 0.022672345861792564, 0.056951068341732025, -0.02978149615228176, 0.039732012897729874, 0.023484114557504654, -0.02611383982002735, 0.012747343629598618, 0.010258877649903297, 0.0011986340396106243, -0.05237722396850586, 0.03179345279932022, 0.0016770429210737348, 0.012768393382430077, -0.021696360781788826, -0.011501103639602661, -0.04317004606127739, -0.023926492780447006, 0.012220635078847408, 0.021859770640730858, 0.03318990021944046, 0.0014574459055438638, 0.015386564657092094, -0.00518330791965127, 0.0039649298414587975, -0.04787856340408325, 0.0168730691075325, 0.026388978585600853, 0.06702311336994171, 0.000571957731153816, 0.026417557150125504, 0.005189924500882626, 0.001601969008333981, 0.06566832214593887, 0.0029695644043385983, 0.008387611247599125, -0.043759990483522415, 0.012578325346112251, -0.07120046019554138, 0.024318261072039604, -0.02112911082804203, -0.017174240201711655, 0.0350661426782608, 0.009894777089357376, -0.04349217191338539, -0.044581975787878036, -0.01317419670522213, 0.0076246801763772964, -0.0661420077085495, 0.03886762261390686, -0.05360224097967148, -0.003887684317305684, -0.011204475536942482, -0.01849878765642643, 0.014295308850705624, 0.009629121981561184, 0.0012466724729165435, -0.042493246495723724, -0.043804146349430084, 0.0026251287199556828, 0.07683813571929932, -0.010244657285511494, 0.020631447434425354, -0.039998844265937805, -0.0060403309762477875, 0.04445481300354004, -0.06630674004554749, -0.04557507485151291, 0.006195612717419863, -0.016360431909561157, 0.011659358628094196, 0.006261177361011505, 0.06288903206586838, -0.031359124928712845, -0.02792404405772686, -0.03255127742886543, -0.024781078100204468, -0.051084838807582855, -0.020840460434556007, 0.028256915509700775, -0.017706172540783882, 0.0072016664780676365, -0.06482826173305511, 0.000961257959716022, -0.05866938456892967, 0.0897996574640274, -0.03849934786558151, 0.004035590216517448, 0.05943327024579048, 0.015698328614234924, 0.002282163593918085, 0.053902097046375275, 0.0037446178030222654, -0.04134330153465271, -0.020405754446983337, 0.016470635309815407, 0.023822985589504242, -0.002904157852753997, -0.00014042865950614214, 0.008188203908503056, -0.04321402683854103, 0.0007179212407208979, -0.008852623403072357, -0.04086638242006302, -0.008142261765897274, 0.02629093825817108, 0.04135556146502495, -0.011862287297844887, -0.03606726601719856, -0.05178142338991165, 0.012627501972019672, -0.07064737379550934, 0.00331860245205462, -0.03479526564478874, -0.03084731660783291, 0.0019314887467771769, -0.020165124908089638, -0.028783537447452545, 0.02176729403436184, 0.10302387923002243, -0.01179908961057663, -0.0006601971690542996, 0.008357814513146877, -0.06457769125699997, 0.010218464769423008, -0.024849234148859978, -0.031328532844781876, -0.04423138499259949, -0.005921324249356985, 0.015530633740127087, 0.0063662840984761715, -0.00438445620238781, 0.026018470525741577, -0.0326853021979332, 0.048312779515981674, -0.021611828356981277, -0.012389637529850006, 0.003770608687773347, 0.00520503893494606, 0.06613105535507202, -0.031487464904785156, 0.01984599232673645, 0.008790446445345879, -0.040698230266571045, 0.041832633316516876, -0.006246234755963087, 0.02810497395694256, -0.05328626558184624, -0.038815490901470184, -0.05654995143413544, 0.03375691920518875, 0.08039230108261108, 0.00769310025498271, -0.018516847863793373, 0.04330182075500488, 0.03567831218242645, -0.013821551576256752, -0.0465884767472744, 0.026009496301412582, -0.014182827435433865, -0.008757401257753372, -0.07246092706918716, -0.01495776604861021, 0.03207025304436684, 0.010355421341955662, -0.048418235033750534, -0.022014785557985306, 0.0023901117965579033, 0.00553520442917943, -0.024082867428660393, -0.00951408315449953, -0.12465178966522217, 0.018488721922039986, -0.014911630190908909, -0.0314398929476738, 0.04280003160238266, -0.0720364972949028, 0.02592591568827629, 0.009424333460628986, 0.017241131514310837, 0.022634295746684074, -0.03181976452469826, 0.04116736352443695, 0.05901617184281349, -0.0361342616379261, -0.034838415682315826, 0.026584332808852196, 0.01742839813232422, -0.05410273000597954, 0.00039960042340680957, -0.010180167853832245, -0.0014998974511399865, -0.052027035504579544, -0.03414204344153404, -0.03340737894177437, -0.026176508516073227, -0.0038768076337873936, -0.032618310302495956, 0.03758600354194641, 0.019530493766069412, 0.0957396999001503, 0.01584460400044918, 0.023388506844639778, -0.019530585035681725, -0.010814809240400791, 0.016503358259797096, -0.018004242330789566, 0.0042357491329312325, 0.06645804643630981, 0.015465639531612396, -0.002964786719530821, -0.03086704947054386, -0.014311488717794418, 0.032920707017183304, 0.05539293959736824, -0.0030108068604022264, -0.03883199021220207, -0.06553388386964798, 0.03941383585333824, 0.0016779726138338447, -0.02049928344786167, 0.06792347878217697, 0.027529533952474594, -0.005829126574099064, 0.006380023900419474, -0.05585514008998871, 0.01898190565407276, 0.07882238179445267, -0.034127797931432724, -0.026913367211818695, -0.03208686783909798, 0.04633059725165367, -0.03761560469865799, -0.0558946430683136, -0.015597142279148102, 0.005501643288880587, -0.017133520916104317, -0.00560788856819272, 0.01456255279481411, 0.01986408233642578, -0.08350628614425659, 0.00929263886064291, -0.02486039698123932, 0.02252516709268093, -0.014005637727677822, -0.0018464409513399005, -0.04301873967051506, -0.029643595218658447, 0.0032111085020005703, -0.04062134772539139, 0.048559609800577164, -0.013726490549743176, 0.04251782223582268, -0.002315747318789363, -0.016684412956237793, -0.023041551932692528, 0.01622895337641239, 0.041751619428396225, -0.06982064992189407, 0.057982709258794785, 0.000015457409972441383, 0.020516784861683846, -0.000187272482435219, 0.020093552768230438, 0.03266787901520729, 0.05879615247249603, -0.012159508652985096, 0.03198278322815895, 0.0556446835398674, -0.045014165341854095, 0.000044667151087196544, 0.05706995353102684, -0.019580626860260963, -0.01090996339917183, 0.0071268086321651936, -0.04782215133309364, 0.020859122276306152, 0.03118673898279667, 0.02145341970026493, -0.03525476157665253, -0.051758620887994766, -0.03093663975596428, -0.007561786100268364, 0.016821568831801414, -0.007514173164963722 ]
<p><strong>Note:</strong> Both diagrams are 2d(they might look 3d because I drew them manually.) I have a prismatic frame that looks like this:<img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/obZR5.png" alt="Frame"><br> I made a section on the half of the first pillar(the red line represents the section), to study the internal forces in it(Normal force, shear force and moment.) Here is a free body diagram at this section:<br> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/YtO2N.png" alt="Section"><br> A is a fixed support so I calculated its reactions as follows:</p> <ul> <li> $X_A= 100 KN$ <li> $Y_A= 200 KN$ <li> $M_A= 300 KN$ </ul> <p>Note: $AB=3m$<br> I have also calculated the normal and the shear force at B, but I have a problem calculating the moment at B and here is why:<br> now let's apply the equilibrium equation of the moments at B, as: </p> <p>$$\Sigma M_B=0$$ </p> <p>As you see there are the following moments: </p> <ul> <li> $X_A\times 3$ <li> $M_B$ <li> and at last $M_A$ </ul> <p>I have done it like this:<br> $$ 3X_A + M_B - M_A = 0 $$ I just need to know what to do with $M_A$ should I multiply it with the distance $AB$ or just leave it.(I tried both cases and I think both are wrong). now can somebody till me what to do with the $M_A$?</p> <h2>Edit:</h2> <p>I guess the diagrams are somehow misleading,(I am not good at drawing!). The axis of moment B is the straight line perpendicular to the plane and passing through B and the same for A. Now please look at the first picture: imagine there is a force just above the red section, this force is causing the bending moment in B and the reaction moment in A. I want to calculate the internal moment B, and that's why I need the sum of moments at B.</p>
g7468
[ 0.027117840945720673, 0.04851569980382919, 0.0012011020444333553, -0.06276557594537735, 0.03186502307653427, -0.025602802634239197, 0.019178591668605804, -0.002851898781955242, 0.016671450808644295, 0.026089509949088097, -0.037540651857852936, 0.004785872530192137, -0.012771273031830788, -0.04267657920718193, 0.06289777159690857, 0.044248033314943314, 0.06700241565704346, -0.04150077700614929, 0.032250139862298965, -0.004612701945006847, -0.059131816029548645, 0.015703484416007996, -0.0585421547293663, -0.041892919689416885, 0.030644534155726433, -0.019162146374583244, -0.012657246552407742, 0.07194837927818298, -0.09822995960712433, 0.012801127508282661, -0.06363780051469803, 0.054596997797489166, 0.011316168121993542, -0.027988675981760025, -0.027160733938217163, 0.019272932782769203, 0.06321140378713608, 0.05836910009384155, 0.019056567922234535, -0.008055674843490124, -0.02971860021352768, -0.07557612657546997, -0.005900636315345764, -0.025360211730003357, -0.0006279224762693048, -0.009109368547797203, -0.0337655283510685, -0.06073456257581711, -0.009263450279831886, -0.023389168083667755, 0.006494373083114624, 0.05472499877214432, 0.06204778701066971, -0.04341547563672066, 0.006534039042890072, 0.02220788784325123, 0.0644133985042572, -0.04334909841418266, 0.020338235422968864, -0.017300641164183617, -0.018964476883411407, -0.05854744836688042, 0.00019467479432933033, 0.0013161030365154147, -0.0024884208105504513, 0.019213132560253143, -0.05591551214456558, 0.0035321020986884832, -0.04407287389039993, -0.013071661815047264, 0.011395107954740524, -0.009280387312173843, 0.00870297010987997, -0.042271796613931656, -0.10033246129751205, -0.0281741451472044, -0.009448541328310966, 0.03005930408835411, -0.005757559090852737, 0.029320919886231422, -0.05473483353853226, 0.06644691526889801, 0.04549305513501167, -0.02188996411859989, 0.0559869110584259, 0.0438958965241909, 0.03795256093144417, 0.04374247416853905, -0.005218425299972296, -0.021444180980324745, -0.005638626404106617, -0.030222564935684204, 0.0008137518307194114, 0.016619743779301643, -0.00396052747964859, -0.00652924831956625, -0.04660554230213165, 0.05290941894054413, 0.007733105216175318, 0.031514234840869904, -0.026178207248449326, 0.0008937764214351773, -0.04175083711743355, 0.006349069532006979, 0.0037959928158670664, -0.05105963349342346, 0.05945577844977379, 0.009281801991164684, -0.0598861388862133, -0.030949441716074944, -0.04577729105949402, -0.04813213273882866, -0.044266242533922195, -0.05513622239232063, 0.0372244231402874, -0.08306685835123062, 0.023818377405405045, -0.05636265128850937, 0.035941943526268005, 0.01107551995664835, -0.0007663315627723932, 0.034084632992744446, 0.028392132371664047, 0.02748190425336361, 0.0008263041381724179, -0.04054576903581619, -0.031364310532808304, 0.014911380596458912, 0.039873965084552765, -0.029377548024058342, -0.011635885573923588, -0.023334579542279243, 0.026632558554410934, 0.04470700025558472, 0.02466418594121933, 0.058701157569885254, -0.030923640355467796, 0.00652899406850338, -0.015008194372057915, 0.023010578006505966, -0.02235502190887928, -0.005279604345560074, 0.011234045028686523, 0.0018335263011977077, -0.05188984051346779, -0.0007920015486888587, 0.011447764001786709, 0.006634545046836138, 0.03830648213624954, -0.013905318453907967, 0.0136033333837986, 0.08480338007211685, -0.04285091534256935, 0.05872586742043495, -0.006716685835272074, 0.005060407333076, 0.027215048670768738, -0.0035038720816373825, -0.014256437309086323, -0.0019320398569107056, 0.01148197054862976, -0.012353994883596897, 0.03430863469839096, -0.03701120987534523, -0.04653525352478027, 0.025974083691835403, 0.04599042236804962, -0.07394491881132126, 0.017537998035550117, -0.04377194494009018, -0.03304396569728851, -0.01744920201599598, -0.010904302820563316, 0.038906216621398926, 0.022922607138752937, 0.05472465232014656, 0.03165728971362114, -0.0029939685482531786, 0.035183098167181015, 0.037693727761507034, 0.0034248766023665667, 0.016634218394756317, 0.03473220765590668, -0.014819737523794174, -0.04735337942838669, -0.018005724996328354, 0.03918098285794258, 0.09853380918502808, -0.027563419193029404, 0.03538443148136139, -0.01738950051367283, 0.017976682633161545, -0.029618069529533386, 0.014943471178412437, -0.09570018947124481, 0.06025949865579605, 0.047898370772600174, -0.05834469944238663, -0.0021527379285544157, 0.003008544910699129, -0.038183990865945816, 0.03503003343939781, -0.03213305026292801, 0.0215464998036623, 0.013694544322788715, 0.023587768897414207, -0.0031594198662787676, 0.00409174058586359, -0.015987887978553772, 0.01811058074235916, -0.0050058732740581036, -0.020077137276530266, -0.02688344195485115, 0.030822649598121643, 0.022783862426877022, 0.00415347795933485, 0.003072364954277873, -0.03542398288846016, -0.027400566264986992, 0.03470565751194954, -0.004093128256499767, 0.023051289841532707, 0.02953544445335865, -0.0787564367055893, -0.023126769810914993, 0.003925114870071411, 0.016605757176876068, 0.021373039111495018, 0.011331839486956596, -0.03929072618484497, -0.015436581335961819, 0.013437697663903236, 0.033042456954717636, -0.0004875143931712955, 0.008135904558002949, 0.007363579235970974, -0.021425900980830193, 0.027136249467730522, -0.0007386812358163297, 0.022034263238310814, 0.032018132507801056, 0.030609210953116417, -0.04399660602211952, -0.010849256068468094, -0.005528077948838472, 0.013176994398236275, 0.07296725362539291, -0.02047022432088852, 0.0008813400636427104, 0.0731533020734787, 0.03179812431335449, 0.02804875373840332, 0.005938011687248945, 0.011817468330264091, -0.04004765674471855, 0.030430953949689865, -0.03305480629205704, -0.008109310641884804, -0.02107437141239643, -0.05515507236123085, -0.012886689975857735, 0.03411836922168732, 0.007690705358982086, 0.042230114340782166, -0.08124198764562607, 0.00013417335867416114, -0.04584655538201332, -0.03432513773441315, -0.01455504260957241, 0.022899197414517403, -0.032328102737665176, 0.027575543150305748, -0.004058948252350092, 0.072777658700943, 0.04004646837711334, -0.02220931462943554, 0.001212664064951241, -0.05289389193058014, -0.003453802317380905, -0.00034200376830995083, 0.02144601009786129, 0.0428769513964653, 0.019266048446297646, 0.05675521865487099, 0.03809075802564621, 0.012852772139012814, -0.025739071890711784, 0.005385587457567453, 0.002211797283962369, 0.008455106988549232, -0.03696344047784805, 0.04211532324552536, 0.0014418422942981124, 0.037281934171915054, 0.017718849703669548, -0.012911857105791569, 0.04955083504319191, -0.10951954126358032, -0.04145726561546326, -0.022249091416597366, -0.03465959429740906, -0.020870620384812355, 0.030737614259123802, 0.04981328174471855, 0.019887307658791542, 0.028560930863022804, 0.00351922819390893, -0.09148608148097992, 0.03251413255929947, 0.013612407259643078, 0.0037002803292125463, -0.03493862226605415, -0.015507634729146957, -0.03400764986872673, -0.0149883097037673, 0.021491331979632378, 0.03661947324872017, -0.016250209882855415, 0.016389930620789528, -0.0011974014341831207, -0.012190176174044609, -0.033917468041181564, 0.02941092476248741, 0.02352665364742279, -0.05183904245495796, 0.03221885859966278, -0.06065397337079048, 0.035535380244255066, -0.022174416109919548, 0.017571991309523582, -0.010058403015136719, 0.048752207309007645, 0.038993433117866516, 0.020506303757429123, -0.010590684600174427, -0.06877297908067703, 0.002469028579071164, -0.0081395972520113, 0.040471021085977554, -0.03534271940588951, -0.006837674882262945, -0.03282599523663521, -0.08093106746673584, -0.03766952455043793, 0.003070460632443428, -0.04724762588739395, -0.012695134617388248, 0.023926645517349243, -0.032020360231399536, -0.0199196208268404, 0.006472851615399122, 0.013474957086145878, -0.025900326669216156, -0.042537011206150055, 0.06533091515302658, 0.020980507135391235, -0.020612655207514763, 0.012892170809209347, -0.04612906649708748, 0.019996358081698418, 0.04068306088447571, -0.04211105778813362, -0.003363995114341378, 0.0606645792722702, -0.003751683747395873, -0.02904701605439186, -0.011962429620325565, 0.053340844810009, 0.030514102429151535, -0.03432120010256767, 0.00947720929980278, -0.0224620308727026, -0.014849603176116943, -0.019128836691379547, 0.039044689387083054, -0.0452125109732151, 0.03144574910402298, -0.028215909376740456, -0.012244430370628834, 0.05021502822637558, 0.09898137301206589, 0.003318766364827752, -0.027557602152228355, 0.006640398874878883, 0.03813326731324196, 0.0500338077545166, -0.00695498613640666, -0.0019960880745202303, 0.03903620317578316, -0.0010045580565929413, 0.022420372813940048, -0.048063959926366806, -0.031714990735054016, -0.015247812494635582, 0.04837709665298462, -0.030959973111748695, 0.024078544229269028, 0.011718068271875381, -0.07666648179292679, -0.012095128186047077, 0.013343491591513157, -0.004203599877655506, -0.01148336660116911, 0.021084440872073174, -0.023111652582883835, 0.033689022064208984, 0.01463654637336731, -0.0003541390469763428, 0.028887668624520302, -0.0011956741800531745, 0.004617108032107353, 0.016962377354502678, 0.03303270787000656, -0.06075481325387955, 0.009679361246526241, -0.03618098422884941, -0.02081540785729885, 0.010608888231217861, 0.005507024936378002, 0.008321658708155155, -0.0012615578016266227, 0.06926252692937851, 0.002494986867532134, -0.026806402951478958, 0.03323958441615105, -0.00832010805606842, 0.039048630744218826, -0.00025297931279055774, 0.019012896344065666, -0.054304949939250946, -0.024360649287700653, 0.027327341958880424, -0.03575807809829712, -0.0575374998152256, -0.022322749719023705, 0.07057461142539978, -0.05214822664856911, -0.029424773529171944, -0.06323479115962982, 0.0573338158428669, -0.0026231706142425537, 0.027471056208014488, 0.02414865791797638, -0.060794245451688766, 0.021594688296318054, 0.012210607528686523, -0.10287642478942871, -0.061585742980241776, 0.018194690346717834, -0.09919267892837524, -0.011367044411599636, -0.012367230840027332, 0.055349674075841904, -0.0160041656345129, 0.013651403598487377, -0.014463542029261589, -0.018507950007915497, -0.00003696274143294431, 0.013135051354765892, 0.027855807915329933, -0.03190569207072258, 0.01233526598662138, 0.008274535648524761, -0.014797288924455643, 0.02430093288421631, 0.008828979916870594, -0.0051473588682711124, 0.010982953011989594, 0.02839825116097927, -0.07839099317789078, 0.05854656547307968, -0.038947027176618576, 0.009257475845515728, -0.02849644236266613, -0.01856418140232563, 0.03180519491434097, -0.07144944369792938, 0.05990387126803398, 0.05245240777730942, 0.00758453318849206, -0.014764994382858276, -0.0026150622870773077, -0.0026318649761378765, -0.007191036827862263, 0.004412468988448381, -0.04672710970044136, -0.04166392609477043, -0.055215246975421906, 0.006179137621074915, -0.00741932075470686, 0.0023976359516382217, -0.030444202944636345, -0.022146938368678093, -0.06752925366163254, -0.002156291389837861, 0.03394727036356926, 0.009826208464801311, -0.024326656013727188, -0.04261389002203941, 0.01850845105946064, -0.03001187928020954, 0.0010222273413091898, -0.031161988154053688, -0.030822401866316795, 0.005594898015260696, 0.008077799342572689, 0.05477551743388176, -0.005171526689082384, 0.018466565757989883, 0.07518628239631653, 0.01785481907427311, -0.03380070999264717, 0.11192017793655396, 0.010454968549311161, -0.009125645272433758, 0.010206622071564198, 0.027938485145568848, 0.02548997849225998, -0.02792682684957981, -0.04118306189775467, 0.06593567878007889, 0.0071517121978104115, 0.06859348714351654, -0.05622249096632004, 0.025502637028694153, -0.004356073215603828, 0.0017942774575203657, 0.008724822662770748, -0.027801048010587692, -0.021571889519691467, -0.06741292774677277, 0.0006202785880304873, 0.02563520148396492, 0.001707047107629478, -0.012020089663565159, -0.08855116367340088, 0.012790278531610966, -0.021730657666921616, 0.01276400126516819, -0.050239693373441696, 0.052856914699077606, -0.0406825914978981, 0.03533986955881119, 0.019265567883849144, -0.019300181418657303, 0.01773102954030037, -0.03819359466433525, -0.028341207653284073, 0.0421750582754612, 0.019770335406064987, 0.005987604148685932, 0.03238218277692795, -0.06377606093883514, 0.02471351809799671, -0.0008333828300237656, -0.0034022426698356867, 0.018953358754515648, -0.05343740060925484, 0.010476658120751381, -0.030829595401883125, 0.051794495433568954, -0.04362956061959267, -0.017659544944763184, 0.025893906131386757, -0.03457627445459366, -0.018739081919193268, -0.01905965618789196, 0.01538939867168665, 0.027894288301467896, -0.0010446858359500766, 0.03503066673874855, 0.016838517040014267, 0.006111627910286188, 0.0081176133826375, 0.03800090402364731, 0.09985271841287613, -0.0000034780159694491886, -0.0014566107420250773, -0.029722226783633232, 0.027351489290595055, -0.053541067987680435, 0.01392404641956091, 0.03704442083835602, -0.0010246209567412734, -0.018622465431690216, 0.06668050587177277, -0.008446061983704567, -0.08220913261175156, 0.04339874908328056, -0.07790898531675339, 0.00471431715413928, 0.010110113769769669, -0.010718228295445442, -0.008832819759845734, 0.02610892429947853, -0.02695259265601635, -0.0319284126162529, -0.054187361150979996, 0.003275480354204774, 0.09134364128112793, -0.01134602539241314, 0.028912128880620003, 0.018648412078619003, -0.08117759227752686, 0.022382786497473717, -0.025361962616443634, -0.012227917090058327, 0.005021036136895418, -0.04059460014104843, 0.008418798446655273, 0.05485440045595169, 0.011987597681581974, -0.014074262231588364, 0.03762027248740196, 0.019030151888728142, 0.0004905289388261735, 0.030361784622073174, 0.035511672496795654, -0.031619392335414886, -0.016635099425911903, -0.02010512165725231, -0.012947652488946915, 0.006062726490199566, -0.062061768025159836, 0.01845027133822441, 0.06954449415206909, -0.09690368920564651, -0.032925497740507126, -0.0044647036120295525, -0.017335662618279457, 0.0061974250711500645, 0.016839483752846718, -0.03232283517718315, 0.047651033848524094, -0.05776705965399742, 0.048990994691848755, 0.008495233952999115, 0.02856941521167755, 0.028794629499316216, 0.059751998633146286, -0.033851511776447296, 0.033395808190107346, 0.010669716633856297, 0.00948826689273119, -0.046223703771829605, -0.04396073892712593, 0.005850645247846842, -0.02884933538734913, -0.1140739768743515, -0.012571682222187519, -0.011144575662910938, 0.012813451699912548, 0.05157734826207161, 0.04633523151278496, -0.028476964682340622, 0.026000410318374634, 0.03333430364727974, 0.03199200704693794, 0.043568696826696396, 0.012276073917746544, -0.0014837796334177256, 0.0353914350271225, 0.02354101650416851, -0.018572311848402023, 0.0017351926071569324, 0.05428784340620041, -0.021109653636813164, -0.00883574690669775, -0.0010384074412286282, -0.00517241982743144, -0.0468752384185791, -0.010559866204857826, -0.05421653017401695, 0.06154824420809746, -0.005896934773772955, 0.056479282677173615, 0.06446065753698349, -0.021462874487042427, -0.016099296510219574, -0.024385936558246613, 0.028364865109324455, 0.05440248176455498, -0.053508758544921875, -0.04314291104674339, -0.0246687363833189, 0.020263466984033585, 0.018014024943113327, 0.04437484219670296, 0.026232272386550903, 0.008331360295414925, 0.0204580370336771, 0.06808312982320786, -0.004952709656208754, -0.05754443258047104, -0.03170107677578926, 0.0357024259865284, 0.001834554597735405, 0.038466885685920715, 0.04088130220770836, -0.0625397115945816, 0.01931045390665531, -0.043967366218566895, -0.009975732304155827, 0.012774660252034664, -0.003940819296985865, -0.00534264650195837, -0.03158513456583023, 0.010844020172953606, 0.019225986674427986, -0.006183799356222153, 0.04590696468949318, 0.013921139761805534, 0.0671982541680336, -0.01474284939467907, -0.01428382471203804, 0.011144553311169147, -0.017423860728740692, 0.06811444461345673, 0.030414368957281113, 0.0077383797615766525, -0.020359765738248825, 0.0021702577359974384, -0.04029909893870354, -0.053932350128889084, -0.007976086810231209, -0.042729318141937256, -0.020140616223216057, -0.003922830335795879, -0.02104489505290985, 0.034180089831352234, -0.01297847181558609, -0.03477920591831207, -0.002351246075704694, 0.029826896265149117, 0.02203669399023056, -0.03839972987771034, 0.009406086057424545, -0.08922545611858368, 0.03243234008550644, 0.03576349839568138, -0.035550449043512344, -0.05286586284637451, -0.025805681943893433, 0.02634074166417122, 0.026830550283193588, -0.007477681618183851, -0.056849971413612366, 0.09071695804595947, 0.035067252814769745, 0.0407109409570694, -0.01174849458038807, 0.036193180829286575, 0.02478969469666481, -0.02275078557431698, 0.040929365903139114, -0.037334199994802475, -0.023977885022759438, 0.032746389508247375, 0.057544633746147156, 0.01663946732878685, -0.03801484778523445, 0.055807627737522125, -0.0284461360424757, 0.022449489682912827, 0.03708935156464577, -0.027132397517561913, -0.008338186889886856, -0.0035833886358886957 ]
<p>I read that as the air density is lower at high altitudes, the scattering is less, hence the darker blue but then other colors are scattering lesser than blue, why don't we see a darker shade of the other colors?</p>
g7469
[ 0.035992879420518875, 0.04267112538218498, 0.0012201553909108043, 0.028820989653468132, 0.04967555031180382, 0.08828175812959671, -0.0023971472401171923, 0.026213359087705612, -0.016889285296201706, -0.04609764367341995, 0.06522351503372192, 0.023070385679602623, -0.0033347064163535833, 0.02571638487279415, 0.03576504811644554, 0.02633160538971424, -0.0034288535825908184, -0.03625434637069702, 0.038003306835889816, -0.0030317483469843864, -0.05232297256588936, -0.02483244612812996, -0.00933830812573433, -0.046127475798130035, -0.06929510831832886, 0.08994419872760773, -0.07437684386968613, -0.06384169310331345, 0.028727835044264793, -0.03519323095679283, 0.0887017622590065, 0.0043522207997739315, 0.009524642489850521, 0.013484316878020763, 0.027805892750620842, 0.018248628824949265, 0.018401872366666794, 0.04517855495214462, -0.06836732476949692, 0.01977412961423397, 0.040393464267253876, 0.010743855498731136, -0.038767922669649124, -0.03014124184846878, -0.04455507546663284, 0.010333358310163021, -0.0413454994559288, 0.017261682078242302, -0.051458291709423065, -0.060976892709732056, -0.018546005710959435, 0.024546509608626366, -0.04146101698279381, -0.0070961532182991505, 0.04429943114519119, -0.027225099503993988, 0.02303035743534565, 0.009556402452290058, 0.0007550247828476131, 0.022793129086494446, 0.010578691028058529, 0.060276422649621964, 0.013402927666902542, 0.04701320827007294, 0.017494136467576027, -0.020198296755552292, -0.05097673460841179, -0.06399770826101303, 0.000602800224442035, 0.002595637459307909, -0.015059558674693108, -0.05544401332736015, -0.06769853830337524, 0.021686894819140434, -0.0498519241809845, -0.03833655267953873, 0.003963684197515249, 0.010840722359716892, 0.03389681875705719, 0.03833077475428581, 0.00483710877597332, -0.000718729745130986, -0.009434288367629051, -0.01943659968674183, 0.05641428381204605, 0.003578827017918229, 0.03338566794991493, -0.04436920955777168, 0.041419629007577896, -0.021535001695156097, 0.041366446763277054, -0.03199600800871849, 0.05196844041347504, 0.028284268453717232, 0.030842872336506844, -0.02295793406665325, 0.023992810398340225, 0.07185815274715424, -0.050086501985788345, -0.034974269568920135, -0.04144904017448425, -0.0058064572513103485, -0.01825740560889244, 0.020808415487408638, 0.045597419142723083, -0.00645695673301816, -0.013124694116413593, -0.022523360326886177, -0.03917793184518814, -0.006254390813410282, -0.03244849666953087, -0.0008640474989078939, -0.05966911464929581, 0.031230198219418526, -0.02889307774603367, -0.04535488784313202, -0.008577769622206688, -0.001546617946587503, -0.007682046387344599, 0.08978280425071716, 0.031481705605983734, 0.03032664582133293, 0.01068295631557703, -0.03212058171629906, 0.024621760472655296, -0.006947564426809549, 0.018834171816706657, -0.05633040890097618, -0.01136415172368288, -0.04015117511153221, 0.013329997658729553, 0.02532966248691082, -0.03794349357485771, 0.060065366327762604, 0.02528984844684601, -0.05860036239027977, -0.007942264899611473, 0.00676681287586689, -0.0043509723618626595, 0.039132457226514816, 0.05271037667989731, 0.030267134308815002, 0.02217773161828518, -0.04169119894504547, 0.001793534029275179, 0.008645623922348022, -0.01434140931814909, 0.018512161448597908, 0.01159734558314085, -0.020095188170671463, -0.02726156823337078, -0.08092670142650604, 0.0732111781835556, -0.002187668578699231, -0.07742779701948166, -0.013372140936553478, 0.02333984337747097, 0.035335272550582886, 0.01319296844303608, 0.03624550253152847, 0.02371278405189514, -0.01804296113550663, -0.06795762479305267, 0.013569285161793232, -0.03391260653734207, -0.03282898664474487, 0.03509115055203438, -0.010459880344569683, 0.030671073123812675, -0.036901336163282394, -0.026561973616480827, 0.002930756425485015, -0.03355346620082855, -0.018409129232168198, 0.12029319256544113, 0.04580766707658768, 0.10285452753305435, -0.006232568994164467, 0.029368238523602486, 0.0026245014742016792, -0.06542400270700455, 0.010455655865371227, -0.02518640272319317, -0.10931864380836487, 0.04228401929140091, 0.004359866492450237, -0.02221309207379818, -0.03607612103223801, 0.0017562417779117823, 0.006026692688465118, 0.024743223562836647, -0.029190050438046455, -0.006841858383268118, 0.005529932677745819, 0.014847327023744583, -0.055643342435359955, -0.0336994044482708, 0.06891612708568573, -0.02778051421046257, 0.11421623826026917, -0.01618248224258423, 0.012188267894089222, 0.07656311243772507, 0.015436827205121517, 0.034177523106336594, 0.047607697546482086, -0.038647908717393875, 0.008045452646911144, 0.045179981738328934, -0.05052832514047623, -0.05370410159230232, -0.049681760370731354, 0.04878168925642967, 0.049174945801496506, 0.025604143738746643, 0.028978219255805016, -0.013161182403564453, 0.02855735644698143, 0.005859933327883482, 0.021802490577101707, -0.026117021217942238, -0.012173707596957684, -0.03367704525589943, 0.029516253620386124, -0.020894087851047516, 0.016063038259744644, -0.04652204364538193, -0.009310069493949413, 0.03862591087818146, 0.012718929909169674, -0.018077977001667023, 0.03953050822019577, -0.009465127252042294, 0.006542337127029896, -0.011175055056810379, -0.026056675240397453, 0.035623595118522644, -0.011097582057118416, 0.05581324175000191, 0.053744103759527206, -0.00549160735681653, -0.04506641998887062, -0.02989036589860916, 0.0912378802895546, 0.01949194073677063, 0.05210772156715393, -0.03630850091576576, -0.012043995782732964, -0.03428816795349121, 0.03252360597252846, -0.0008087113965302706, 0.028243714943528175, -0.031792789697647095, 0.005357787013053894, -0.06510385125875473, -0.06676100194454193, -0.05114144831895828, -0.02970981039106846, -0.0028832806274294853, -0.02294769696891308, -0.04028572887182236, -0.022550176829099655, 0.007768833544105291, -0.0449807271361351, -0.07609677314758301, 0.05440858006477356, -0.03667889162898064, -0.0002676993317436427, -0.013601027429103851, -0.007001486606895924, 0.0020886482670903206, 0.051381729543209076, 0.009298221208155155, -0.02602984383702278, -0.015640128403902054, 0.004635523539036512, -0.00042252492858096957, -0.0035129019524902105, 0.03022427298128605, 0.024999454617500305, 0.0007069359417073429, 0.04755956679582596, -0.0013611866161227226, -0.027708904817700386, 0.0736365020275116, 0.0020911232568323612, 0.019719736650586128, 0.0748816430568695, 0.016568608582019806, -0.009318799711763859, 0.049298398196697235, 0.04954018071293831, 0.05270996317267418, 0.032143305987119675, -0.016523974016308784, 0.01668146625161171, 0.0312389824539423, -0.013455449603497982, 0.009981035254895687, -0.014365565963089466, -0.02053225040435791, -0.019473250955343246, 0.01772146113216877, 0.036896057426929474, 0.026461925357580185, 0.01153616700321436, -0.017282379791140556, 0.008098741061985493, -0.0694006085395813, 0.004164590034633875, 0.029801050201058388, 0.007128374185413122, -0.017393652349710464, 0.06201265752315521, -0.02787655219435692, 0.0006732255569659173, -0.0041437228210270405, 0.009971876628696918, 0.026855669915676117, -0.0008058623643592, 0.032819684594869614, -0.027646180242300034, -0.026129426434636116, -0.05171201750636101, -0.008768748492002487, -0.012636838480830193, -0.06281941384077072, 0.026124000549316406, 0.012846981175243855, -0.01562244538217783, 0.00561486417427659, 0.02718990109860897, -0.011963548138737679, 0.045131146907806396, -0.057767946273088455, -0.028611663728952408, -0.02043183520436287, -0.04045676067471504, 0.008311484009027481, 0.014233458787202835, 0.002561204368248582, -0.023865610361099243, -0.08375907689332962, 0.0035462703090161085, -0.036667585372924805, -0.027487726882100105, 0.019833911210298538, 0.0004683443403337151, -0.0294803436845541, 0.012955411337316036, 0.03122641146183014, 0.010865340009331703, 0.04190709814429283, -0.050490982830524445, -0.02522130310535431, 0.025243932381272316, 0.004564544185996056, 0.003889350686222315, 0.06363900750875473, 0.004448097664862871, 0.010921979323029518, -0.01515952404588461, -0.020553193986415863, -0.018365934491157532, -0.016967862844467163, -0.03221128508448601, -0.050011467188596725, 0.06884819269180298, 0.015776928514242172, 0.04531015828251839, -0.008154836483299732, 0.03322673961520195, -0.0073078651912510395, 0.07116229832172394, 0.020878689363598824, -0.014173462055623531, 0.05119159445166588, 0.04485136643052101, 0.030896944925189018, 0.024317344650626183, 0.008275369182229042, 0.039430394768714905, 0.010165907442569733, -0.02552410028874874, -0.011275878176093102, 0.013280991464853287, -0.013021357357501984, -0.024915317073464394, -0.07882889360189438, -0.09941552579402924, -0.050793714821338654, -0.0024057950358837843, -0.01685580611228943, 0.02592054195702076, -0.006568752229213715, -0.007448021322488785, 0.03988368436694145, 0.0028942127246409655, -0.0448719747364521, 0.022565606981515884, -0.04006147384643555, 0.028052696958184242, 0.0050978162325918674, -0.025994347408413887, 0.007824504747986794, 0.002992142690345645, 0.003921011462807655, -0.010306132957339287, 0.044423121958971024, 0.030816754326224327, 0.006863376125693321, -0.019188309088349342, -0.034431248903274536, -0.06406190246343613, -0.0028939854819327593, -0.023364372551441193, 0.009549735113978386, 0.05005950108170509, 0.03410758450627327, 0.02541281096637249, 0.09959720075130463, -0.031686343252658844, 0.004535013809800148, -0.01956222578883171, 0.025041840970516205, 0.022990979254245758, -0.028042323887348175, 0.00235385331325233, -0.028239745646715164, 0.012125249020755291, 0.01984616555273533, -0.0365217849612236, -0.022061118856072426, -0.01110575720667839, -0.04396707937121391, 0.029693542048335075, -0.009889946319162846, -0.01629841886460781, 0.03836894780397415, 0.019358841702342033, 0.0353713184595108, 0.012803740799427032, -0.02668936178088188, -0.05247437581419945, 0.02742096781730652, 0.015725048258900642, 0.009675867855548859, -0.02004016563296318, -0.013297952711582184, 0.04170767590403557, -0.060277149081230164, -0.026210978627204895, 0.015467870980501175, 0.03738728165626526, -0.04052954539656639, 0.012577049434185028, -0.0334615483880043, 0.005820056423544884, 0.027337588369846344, 0.062055300921201706, -0.027513723820447922, -0.002624895190820098, -0.021345840767025948, -0.02992727793753147, 0.01762780174612999, -0.02559538558125496, -0.03382130712270737, 0.03843586891889572, -0.02371928282082081, 0.014547035098075867, -0.06319580227136612, 0.018415255472064018, -0.0015727680874988437, 0.0013601022073999047, 0.05224981904029846, 0.03433794155716896, -0.0554046593606472, -0.01904970221221447, 0.018550273030996323, -0.023288415744900703, -0.006852214690297842, 0.007588617969304323, 0.02822013385593891, -0.0069479732774198055, -0.03293725475668907, 0.11356571316719055, -0.06062847375869751, 0.027819322422146797, -0.012733443640172482, -0.08389270305633545, 0.033293988555669785, -0.022817397490143776, -0.05431022122502327, 0.001045103301294148, -0.027782252058386803, -0.03948311507701874, 0.005316763184964657, -0.04771872237324715, 0.004076327662914991, 0.002175705973058939, 0.011936923488974571, 0.016922950744628906, 0.014170277863740921, -0.01207891758531332, -0.03453141450881958, 0.04881357029080391, 0.06612163782119751, -0.028862623497843742, 0.05609472841024399, 0.07364004105329514, -0.05219587683677673, -0.06808394938707352, 0.025140604004263878, -0.004261448513716459, -0.022582225501537323, -0.04725095257163048, -0.05067825689911842, 0.04241994023323059, 0.008566024713218212, -0.03307804465293884, 0.013822242617607117, -0.015241038054227829, 0.007907208986580372, 0.022599825635552406, 0.029674900695681572, -0.02528965473175049, -0.01113121211528778, -0.02310958318412304, 0.013456813991069794, -0.02223382517695427, 0.007228097878396511, 0.03623078390955925, 0.0721561461687088, -0.007735638413578272, 0.06039489060640335, -0.038531966507434845, -0.007455900311470032, 0.004076755605638027, -0.05373021960258484, 0.03199908509850502, -0.011154251173138618, 0.014656905084848404, -0.019667934626340866, 0.06356693804264069, 0.013893847353756428, -0.011810445226728916, 0.022312594577670097, 0.0016954666934907436, 0.04915447160601616, 0.01910945400595665, -0.003452369710430503, 0.008928396739065647, 0.005379354115575552, 0.04603041335940361, -0.020404987037181854, -0.017070066183805466, -0.006317512597888708, 0.005530238151550293, 0.047898948192596436, 0.03127142786979675, 0.015794644132256508, -0.006322015542536974, 0.0008821848314255476, -0.02721516229212284, 0.001125252339988947, -0.023053038865327835, 0.00811677984893322, 0.06298258900642395, 0.06484997272491455, 0.018890762701630592, -0.029892070218920708, 0.01579810306429863, 0.019044650718569756, 0.009292998351156712, 0.02070591412484646, -0.0051253135316073895, -0.0037956919986754656, -0.039021916687488556, -0.01482050959020853, -0.03943223878741264, 0.04625069350004196, 0.013028203509747982, -0.004850003868341446, -0.006814765743911266, -0.07297185063362122, -0.03523622825741768, 0.01323761884123087, -0.025288954377174377, 0.04275243356823921, -0.029747219756245613, -0.005196808371692896, 0.0024596136063337326, 0.03935711830854416, -0.027122819796204567, -0.06358141452074051, -0.0490773506462574, -0.050346553325653076, 0.030893927440047264, -0.041799452155828476, -0.048945531249046326, 0.12195898592472076, -0.03176150098443031, 0.05932736024260521, 0.03034542314708233, 0.010119130834937096, 0.026190010830760002, 0.04000524803996086, -0.04175432026386261, 0.057428374886512756, 0.04902579262852669, -0.0442194864153862, 0.01652037538588047, -0.03358054906129837, -0.01053677313029766, 0.004017876926809549, -0.02370128035545349, 0.014551728032529354, 0.025914084166288376, -0.002185426652431488, -0.07686984539031982, 0.008344755508005619, -0.010007135570049286, -0.03956412896513939, -0.04618864506483078, -0.0034215510822832584, -0.0041697071865201, 0.0003278326184954494, 0.00033954362152144313, 0.034472182393074036, 0.01132368203252554, 0.028363404795527458, 0.029070919379591942, 0.016399089246988297, 0.01177665963768959, -0.023287342861294746, -0.008969600312411785, 0.0008071170886978507, -0.021523259580135345, -0.013107964769005775, -0.05898873135447502, 0.012563870288431644, -0.019988851621747017, 0.018860291689634323, -0.0362657755613327, 0.054372258484363556, 0.058545514941215515, 0.03061637468636036, -0.06023385748267174, -0.03337019681930542, -0.03214024379849434, 0.009672611951828003, -0.00264255004003644, 0.027251098304986954, -0.06533794850111008, 0.02516133151948452, -0.024941299110651016, 0.045523714274168015, 0.05520188808441162, -0.03874064236879349, -0.005860138684511185, -0.05056260898709297, -0.018032072111964226, -0.10461562871932983, 0.07425913214683533, -0.02189197950065136, 0.011575710028409958, 0.05473857745528221, -0.04268632456660271, -0.009292934089899063, 0.06745170056819916, -0.009987062774598598, -0.051890868693590164, -0.012710381299257278, -0.04396294429898262, 0.013346605002880096, -0.01590874046087265, -0.033077090978622437, 0.01177680678665638, 0.03915028274059296, 0.025322604924440384, 0.06853379309177399, -0.009954997338354588, 0.048279110342264175, -0.03427071496844292, -0.02026979811489582, 0.005462950561195612, -0.06430298089981079, -0.019920388236641884, 0.011912308633327484, -0.05971376597881317, -0.052827246487140656, -0.005334263201802969, -0.011971753090620041, -0.08582765609025955, -0.02371084690093994, -0.008302761241793633, 0.02034446969628334, -0.024779433384537697, -0.003461628220975399, -0.02001170441508293, -0.01906927488744259, -0.017346758395433426, 0.05084194615483284, -0.02598234824836254, 0.04251357167959213, -0.03230627253651619, 0.01686159521341324, 0.027716880664229393, -0.03660346567630768, -0.04261135309934616, 0.016463352367281914, 0.02777058817446232, 0.044947877526283264, 0.0487147755920887, -0.007233243435621262, 0.034888286143541336, 0.0007257958059199154, -0.06437712907791138, -0.06527470052242279, 0.03767072781920433, 0.0038412960711866617, -0.03397378697991371, 0.01178674679249525, -0.02099226787686348, -0.015795202925801277, 0.01059170812368393, 0.040911946445703506, 0.006466982886195183, 0.013226947747170925, 0.018882514908909798, -0.031238645315170288, 0.034683726727962494, 0.058079350739717484, -0.023250317201018333, -0.0020720360334962606, -0.038122761994600296, 0.04189364239573479, -0.0034350426867604256, 0.05780761316418648, 0.0005763219087384641, -0.029451770707964897, 0.03675282746553421, -0.049045201390981674, -0.017487850040197372, 0.016520101577043533, -0.022979475557804108, 0.0513189435005188, 0.005098909139633179, 0.028450511395931244, -0.024519043043255806, -0.03708864375948906, 0.008326275274157524, -0.008604512549936771, 0.014424209482967854, 0.04137759283185005, 0.024551287293434143, 0.09568299353122711, -0.04766044020652771, -0.012822057120501995, -0.04350907355546951, -0.03579597920179367, -0.0049859206192195415, -0.010668226517736912, 0.008743606507778168, -0.06228233873844147, 0.0073814308270812035, -0.018969416618347168, -0.01998615451157093 ]
<p>Is there any open database of elemental sensitivity factors for Auger electrons?</p> <p>I'm trying to figure out graphite oxidation degree from AES spectra, so relative sensitivity of O to C is required. Spectra were registered with the primary electron energy of 1500 eV. I found some reference data in Perkin Elmer AES handbook and this paper [1], but they are contradictive ( O/C = 0.37 @AES handbook; O/C = 0.26 @[1] with 3 keV) and presents quite distant points from my excitation conditions (1, 3, 5, 10 keV @handbook and 3, 5, 10 keV @[1] vs 1.5 keV of mine).</p> <p>Experimental data would be preferable but if there aren't any, link to theoretical calculation software will be helpful too!</p> <p>[1]: Calculated Auger yields and sensitivity factors for K L L–N O O transitions with 1–10 kV primary beams <a href="http://www.materialinterface.com/_files/Calculated%20AES%20yields%20Matl%20Interface.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.materialinterface.com/_files/Calculated%20AES%20yields%20Matl%20Interface.pdf</a></p>
g7470
[ 0.04444311559200287, 0.00636996328830719, 0.010384466499090195, 0.0130529273301363, 0.04258357360959053, -0.022242024540901184, 0.008762195706367493, -0.008017858490347862, -0.021335111930966377, 0.019859157502651215, 0.014882550574839115, 0.11545364558696747, 0.012040449306368828, 0.018626775592565536, -0.008159727789461613, 0.007494776509702206, 0.058990806341171265, -0.001098542008548975, 0.05988672375679016, 0.05335097014904022, -0.023102328181266785, -0.05399252474308014, -0.043822724372148514, 0.025348464027047157, 0.013845556415617466, -0.0328858308494091, -0.02659802883863449, 0.00556251872330904, -0.04150468111038208, 0.03373480215668678, -0.0671207532286644, 0.04347743093967438, 0.003155803307890892, 0.05199478939175606, 0.019959930330514908, 0.011124612763524055, -0.005145242903381586, 0.01870427280664444, 0.0025581063237041235, -0.029173370450735092, 0.005696658510714769, -0.007449930999428034, -0.02077646367251873, 0.03929321840405464, -0.039392586797475815, 0.002078118035569787, -0.06973915547132492, -0.03590309992432594, -0.00005855723065906204, -0.03989437595009804, -0.0839085727930069, 0.0668761283159256, 0.02673172578215599, -0.01723581925034523, -0.05362618714570999, 0.020296789705753326, -0.06544497609138489, 0.027018507942557335, 0.01551856379956007, 0.006316876970231533, 0.014995448291301727, 0.045599739998579025, 0.0041550989262759686, -0.037501249462366104, -0.02220872789621353, 0.035156942903995514, 0.024845954030752182, -0.013830679468810558, 0.02563316375017166, -0.005122612230479717, -0.003192978911101818, 0.033398039638996124, -0.06858327984809875, 0.026910092681646347, 0.008765042759478092, 0.004141548648476601, 0.0070525105111300945, -0.0035179771948605776, 0.0783195048570633, -0.017795341089367867, 0.0009495866834186018, 0.0061380756087601185, 0.019001176580786705, -0.0014828687999397516, 0.012036343105137348, -0.022878671064972878, -0.00926639698445797, 0.017243968322873116, 0.002811606740579009, -0.05814047530293465, 0.050996508449316025, 0.007324478588998318, 0.0014583505690097809, -0.011746951378881931, 0.00789358839392662, 0.05689673125743866, -0.026669315993785858, 0.047568000853061676, -0.01946987956762314, -0.06316175311803818, -0.031562019139528275, -0.049978986382484436, -0.021033968776464462, -0.047109685838222504, -0.04606802761554718, -0.030492039397358894, 0.01751495711505413, -0.013394973240792751, 0.000017037826182786375, 0.012004571035504341, 0.019048400223255157, 0.039848025888204575, -0.03065749630331993, 0.025208739563822746, -0.02323279157280922, 0.0023790004197508097, -0.011717775836586952, -0.05002525448799133, -0.04123230278491974, 0.007030438631772995, 0.05422399565577507, 0.01186405960470438, 0.02970600686967373, 0.008230200968682766, 0.02663544937968254, -0.02904415875673294, 0.020670324563980103, -0.01952584832906723, 0.012056744657456875, -0.009743805974721909, 0.010492137633264065, -0.03953816741704941, 0.020642586052417755, 0.006533173378556967, 0.04392878711223602, 0.03671456500887871, -0.05700753256678581, 0.04207271710038185, -0.025323107838630676, -0.05661093443632126, -0.017579516395926476, 0.008228068239986897, -0.0027451817877590656, -0.03028308041393757, 0.018002400174736977, -0.005295120645314455, -0.07050807029008865, 0.035547178238630295, 0.0241995882242918, 0.006381109822541475, 0.07139909267425537, -0.010885778814554214, -0.00824602972716093, -0.03627299144864082, -0.022006036713719368, -0.006747550796717405, -0.007368233520537615, -0.07136864960193634, -0.048404645174741745, 0.08168355375528336, -0.011399871669709682, -0.0065738181583583355, 0.048919450491666794, 0.010160648263990879, -0.004260219633579254, -0.010706795379519463, -0.04057082161307335, -0.013553479686379433, 0.048452578485012054, 0.024064620956778526, -0.06331571191549301, -0.005786428693681955, 0.057771045714616776, -0.04641929268836975, -0.02253316342830658, 0.08616157621145248, 0.033676180988550186, 0.006167387589812279, 0.08735975623130798, 0.018207533285021782, 0.05953889340162277, 0.005021804012358189, -0.02527199685573578, 0.042954497039318085, -0.012474414892494678, -0.013004066422581673, -0.008595244027674198, 0.028123527765274048, 0.01026708260178566, 0.0009266056586056948, -0.0049284109845757484, 0.023001722991466522, -0.020405540242791176, -0.011920634657144547, 0.0188743956387043, -0.006833760067820549, -0.031160980463027954, -0.01595914736390114, -0.06899645179510117, -0.050650227814912796, 0.003267423016950488, 0.023411665111780167, -0.03997443616390228, 0.024017207324504852, 0.03278319910168648, 0.008625357411801815, -0.006167116109281778, 0.003692581783980131, 0.052315302193164825, -0.018035495653748512, -0.04634948819875717, 0.019091499969363213, 0.013331436552107334, 0.10977467894554138, 0.020947160199284554, 0.0007798867300152779, -0.04083055257797241, 0.03201946243643761, -0.013885405845940113, 0.030237024649977684, -0.0007263668230734766, 0.004323625471442938, 0.03665028139948845, 0.06793637573719025, -0.05553516745567322, -0.014011695049703121, 0.014349956065416336, -0.014693299308419228, 0.04159001633524895, -0.006007746793329716, -0.07161755859851837, 0.02911628596484661, -0.008017908781766891, -0.062242452055215836, -0.03721093013882637, -0.03509408235549927, -0.042405642569065094, -0.06305673718452454, 0.0025781700387597084, 0.00854989793151617, 0.0036797893699258566, 0.04137397184967995, -0.040202170610427856, -0.029816599562764168, -0.02655753493309021, 0.003259949153289199, 0.012350570410490036, 0.03418383747339249, -0.055231571197509766, 0.02680736593902111, -0.08535537868738174, 0.05463935434818268, -0.07409589737653732, 0.09375821799039841, -0.08475176244974136, 0.0010935601312667131, -0.04820404574275017, -0.02081686444580555, -0.05393749475479126, 0.016510197892785072, -0.023962751030921936, -0.04011407494544983, 0.04421620070934296, -0.011620121076703072, 0.007660410366952419, 0.011869821697473526, -0.011296384036540985, -0.10361751914024353, -0.011553256772458553, -0.022654544562101364, -0.03503541275858879, 0.016118234023451805, -0.008690728805959225, -0.008140007965266705, 0.03178764507174492, -0.005118023604154587, 0.03131936863064766, 0.04890536144375801, -0.01355327945202589, -0.006696958560496569, -0.05434318631887436, -0.01361486129462719, -0.018507184460759163, 0.02223704755306244, -0.004182363860309124, 0.021351654082536697, 0.00562736950814724, -0.0021177439484745264, 0.03134584799408913, -0.03079376555979252, -0.05971712991595268, -0.01759539358317852, -0.005578162148594856, 0.03742985054850578, -0.03388142213225365, -0.04575955495238304, 0.07138634473085403, 0.002855279017239809, 0.036093104630708694, 0.11878645420074463, 0.029135867953300476, -0.020922914147377014, -0.037501413375139236, 0.010024523362517357, -0.042740337550640106, 0.01145400945097208, -0.01177945639938116, -0.04954555630683899, -0.007893085479736328, 0.0394253246486187, -0.06507667154073715, -0.0751374363899231, 0.03177309036254883, -0.019598480314016342, -0.004117545206099749, -0.02123931050300598, 0.01243429072201252, 0.016126342117786407, -0.005900951102375984, -0.04616279900074005, -0.008179806172847748, -0.03642658889293671, 0.028445541858673096, 0.005340525880455971, -0.009132856503129005, -0.0029942796099931, 0.009843501262366772, 0.020118992775678635, 0.011661972850561142, 0.04527650773525238, 0.02941344864666462, 0.014614631421864033, 0.014769130386412144, 0.014971536584198475, -0.014352419413626194, 0.011628921143710613, -0.04977298155426979, 0.01700820028781891, -0.03188657388091087, 0.030022835358977318, 0.0017744639189913869, 0.015029262751340866, -0.04432997852563858, -0.006996857468038797, 0.0051145791076123714, -0.013814713805913925, -0.03792572394013405, -0.008356469683349133, -0.02510184422135353, -0.04239083454012871, 0.07369327545166016, 0.00843309797346592, -0.04930012300610542, 0.031028052791953087, -0.010871458798646927, -0.0346856489777565, 0.08815726637840271, -0.007371597457677126, -0.031117988750338554, 0.068955197930336, -0.051012393087148666, -0.0668811947107315, 0.033786337822675705, -0.010511079803109169, -0.0300064105540514, -0.005376390181481838, -0.014411300420761108, 0.010736238211393356, 0.07609543949365616, -0.016779379919171333, 0.013123849406838417, 0.010419582016766071, 0.06767915934324265, 0.039761319756507874, -0.06443887948989868, -0.021006647497415543, -0.018219348043203354, 0.023844817653298378, 0.007842538878321648, 0.01326824352145195, 0.0017901428509503603, 0.014111630618572235, 0.0255014356225729, -0.010928872972726822, 0.0017980887787416577, -0.060089826583862305, 0.004107899498194456, -0.019381646066904068, -0.024173708632588387, -0.042644474655389786, -0.01641794852912426, -0.056775692850351334, -0.0734555795788765, 0.026596317067742348, -0.02079610340297222, -0.029599953442811966, -0.00874605868011713, -0.003846903098747134, -0.03153400123119354, 0.044150035828351974, -0.006914633791893721, -0.01629449427127838, 0.033113811165094376, -0.011767066083848476, 0.06001776084303856, 0.02425912581384182, -0.0018888942431658506, 0.028367778286337852, 0.03657360002398491, -0.031571924686431885, -0.0069435671903193, -0.020625686272978783, -0.00929773785173893, -0.015268316492438316, 0.030797233805060387, -0.003409304888918996, -0.0022218283265829086, -0.031063375994563103, 0.040677282959222794, -0.07158804684877396, 0.0297909714281559, 0.015856146812438965, -0.014260552823543549, -0.0064214360900223255, -0.02747092768549919, 0.05186250060796738, -0.04906844720244408, -0.027261296287178993, 0.07843926548957825, 0.05769747123122215, 0.021764904260635376, 0.030626384541392326, -0.029305091127753258, -0.05260971188545227, -0.014952343888580799, 0.06948327273130417, 0.030489619821310043, 0.03658795729279518, 0.012538752518594265, 0.005500518251210451, 0.013349845074117184, 0.062127020210027695, 0.0001611380575923249, 0.005951910279691219, 0.015983497723937035, -0.006441872101277113, -0.05047882720828056, -0.0550197996199131, 0.017155764624476433, 0.008986789733171463, 0.02995774894952774, -0.08913169801235199, -0.001015078043565154, 0.00817983690649271, 0.004703665152192116, 0.027942728251218796, 0.013386940583586693, 0.02651429921388626, 0.039700400084257126, 0.01018935814499855, -0.016461094841361046, -0.0375019833445549, -0.01799624413251877, -0.01762121170759201, 0.00786203145980835, 0.06088392436504364, -0.009381851181387901, 0.07707881927490234, -0.06553888320922852, -0.04338887333869934, 0.010321308858692646, -0.06978850066661835, 0.027962569147348404, -0.0032623286824673414, 0.004663996864110231, -0.028734538704156876, 0.067583367228508, -0.03427565470337868, 0.04240976646542549, 0.013868452981114388, -0.07060134410858154, 0.002448124811053276, 0.033412326127290726, 0.05274113267660141, 0.020034661516547203, -0.017979614436626434, 0.010200330056250095, 0.03624977171421051, -0.017312750220298767, -0.05667303130030632, 0.07323295623064041, 0.08015848696231842, -0.043786775320768356, -0.05380993336439133, 0.021285714581608772, 0.06872541457414627, 0.0029152482748031616, 0.03236091881990433, 0.02548297308385372, 0.07673840969800949, -0.024622119963169098, 0.03657783567905426, -0.05699317157268524, 0.007450064178556204, -0.0027227906975895166, 0.03162696212530136, 0.0728151798248291, -0.08020235598087311, 0.034266021102666855, -0.00700578885152936, -0.012789548374712467, 0.03378088399767876, 0.026137353852391243, -0.016933150589466095, -0.013341380283236504, 0.00790947861969471, -0.04893995076417923, 0.014213532209396362, -0.03709980845451355, -0.03219980001449585, 0.040829695761203766, -0.026728738099336624, 0.025384224951267242, 0.00891632866114378, -0.05523504316806793, 0.0290523748844862, -0.0010569078149273992, -0.05346669629216194, 0.08821998536586761, -0.007860586978495121, 0.001001725671812892, 0.05664932727813721, -0.01725812442600727, 0.0011681853793561459, 0.054581452161073685, -0.033470023423433304, -0.024631833657622337, 0.023104675114154816, -0.0003081702161580324, -0.008866467513144016, -0.009026287123560905, 0.04211398586630821, 0.010464605875313282, 0.007981128059327602, -0.021324245259165764, 0.0429714135825634, -0.0031390630174428225, -0.014675689861178398, 0.02405538409948349, -0.05938055366277695, 0.02839978225529194, 0.0299979317933321, 0.04280891269445419, -0.03630881384015083, 0.02595706097781658, 0.04001883789896965, 0.013344592414796352, 0.023216228932142258, 0.017642956227064133, -0.009046344086527824, 0.06939178705215454, 0.04890117049217224, 0.017859192565083504, -0.0387582890689373, 0.06991690397262573, -0.08013034611940384, -0.006486184429377317, 0.006826336495578289, -0.02939770743250847, 0.0054250601679086685, 0.010669667273759842, -0.04121929034590721, -0.01628132350742817, -0.021723376587033272, 0.04383112117648125, 0.05890844389796257, -0.07790426909923553, 0.013328306376934052, 0.032189082354307175, -0.004880058579146862, 0.009582774713635445, 0.024745406582951546, -0.030714303255081177, 0.02649807557463646, -0.06577233970165253, -0.01506873406469822, -0.017993472516536713, 0.0019480682676658034, 0.022363655269145966, -0.04206060245633125, -0.05092056840658188, 0.01630234904587269, 0.03330704942345619, 0.022708002477884293, -0.018343837931752205, 0.02859448827803135, 0.0007236009696498513, 0.021775029599666595, 0.05692021921277046, 0.09348412603139877, -0.002999592339619994, 0.04326043650507927, -0.01500528771430254, 0.04846163094043732, -0.018810180947184563, -0.002470908686518669, -0.01859591156244278, 0.018315723165869713, 0.03708375245332718, 0.0029251528903841972, -0.042898766696453094, -0.003352926578372717, 0.032820925116539, -0.057463638484478, 0.030792608857154846, 0.007697761058807373, 0.034021250903606415, -0.026409124955534935, -0.023057211190462112, 0.05965670943260193, 0.016627036035060883, -0.04636644944548607, 0.007808230351656675, -0.0026367006357759237, 0.047066036611795425, 0.04888515919446945, -0.007801590953022242, 0.024548813700675964, -0.038716889917850494, -0.03403298184275627, -0.011646304279565811, 0.05542407184839249, 0.03734682872891426, 0.004524925723671913, 0.059175483882427216, 0.05977950245141983, -0.019521638751029968, -0.023331988602876663, 0.02754971943795681, -0.007737733889371157, -0.030298393219709396, -0.01259518601000309, 0.02024891972541809, -0.013149724341928959, -0.018200600519776344, -0.04207523539662361, 0.0009278394281864166, 0.07996800541877747, -0.05246403440833092, 0.004405846353620291, 0.03857029601931572, -0.023937050253152847, 0.004066587891429663, -0.07239307463169098, 0.04031315818428993, 0.013323351740837097, -0.052162282168865204, -0.003884168341755867, 0.03560710698366165, 0.018307330086827278, 0.04341311380267143, -0.05584316328167915, 0.06124742701649666, 0.03649546578526497, 0.0033971520606428385, -0.02558528073132038, -0.0358688049018383, -0.038014572113752365, -0.024857843294739723, -0.005045527592301369, -0.02726152539253235, 0.014253594912588596, 0.007609119173139334, 0.005433577112853527, 0.0007298788987100124, 0.017928346991539, -0.06844716519117355, -0.0108559625223279, -0.04498474672436714, 0.07127287983894348, -0.026859194040298462, 0.03922669216990471, 0.008433128707110882, 0.0028466868679970503, -0.03771580755710602, -0.04951127618551254, -0.0582815520465374, -0.008068625815212727, -0.011775163002312183, -0.01733403094112873, -0.03369048982858658, -0.03899610787630081, 0.01592809520661831, -0.039618078619241714, -0.041677866131067276, -0.01695834845304489, -0.026489464566111565, 0.006836800370365381, 0.06596250087022781, 0.005479043815284967, 0.016033655032515526, 0.013581670820713043, -0.04682447016239166, 0.013531864620745182, 0.00944649986922741, -0.04044221714138985, -0.03832163289189339, 0.03873905539512634, 0.0018484480679035187, 0.010788889601826668, 0.0030996098648756742, 0.033959027379751205, -0.004097046796232462, 0.0326848030090332, 0.04923621937632561, 0.000925750529859215, 0.008527819067239761, 0.00987199041992426, -0.039603881537914276, 0.07940739393234253, -0.0198091771453619, -0.006312472280114889, -0.006477757357060909, 0.038771625608205795, 0.04591643810272217, -0.04926598072052002, -0.041166387498378754, -0.006667246110737324, 0.031401343643665314, 0.006975130643695593, 0.01015254482626915, -0.020184941589832306, 0.010838083922863007, 0.0016080449568107724, -0.06621425598859787, -0.0028753948863595724, -0.0083161611109972, -0.023481670767068863, 0.06991046667098999, 0.07237008213996887, 0.011826041154563427, 0.0041921851225197315, -0.08161723613739014, -0.017514411360025406, -0.0305172186344862, -0.0372428297996521, -0.008616955950856209, 0.005954262800514698, -0.015492302365601063, -0.0033210949040949345, -0.0493152029812336, -0.02230685204267502, 0.03304090350866318, -0.04952523484826088, -0.03741820901632309, 0.015347699634730816, -0.00425966689363122, -0.02607802301645279, 0.01820715144276619, -0.0008621461456641555, -0.06597230583429337, 0.03670617192983627, -0.017789283767342567, 0.007512092590332031, 0.05113228037953377, -0.024470703676342964, -0.019588528200984, -0.07985761761665344 ]
<p><a href="http://www.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/teaching/HPS_0410/chapters/Special_relativity_rel_sim/index.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/teaching/HPS_0410/chapters/Special_relativity_rel_sim/index.html</a></p> <p>Talking about the situation of clocks shown on this page. Clocks A&amp;B. Now suppose clock B is moving towards A with constant velocity. A sees B coming towards it, and figures out that the clock B is running slow, and by symmetry B says the same. Now, B &amp; A meet at a space-time and actually compare readings. Now they will know one of the clocks ran slower. How is this possible</p>
g7471
[ 0.038834165781736374, 0.02570297010242939, -0.03381061553955078, -0.030295871198177338, 0.04346463456749916, 0.03437330946326256, 0.04818594828248024, 0.002662618411704898, -0.05645771697163582, -0.015542360953986645, 0.016386615112423897, 0.013802707195281982, 0.038937125355005264, -0.004832233302295208, 0.014323347248136997, -0.02194247767329216, 0.09362951666116714, 0.004918192978948355, 0.0466017946600914, 0.01976299285888672, 0.08900933712720871, 0.02435706928372383, 0.0011510589392855763, -0.04471898078918457, 0.028173601254820824, -0.005582897923886776, -0.03065509907901287, -0.025412283837795258, -0.09076415002346039, -0.047123659402132034, 0.05832541361451149, 0.005890570115298033, 0.022755244746804237, -0.012266856618225574, 0.020550528541207314, -0.058008644729852676, 0.015643084421753883, -0.0064201015047729015, -0.04058847576379776, 0.08078403025865555, 0.024724435061216354, 0.004579158034175634, -0.016160547733306885, -0.013147693127393723, 0.021915733814239502, 0.010103325359523296, -0.00707906624302268, 0.00581560842692852, -0.010617077350616455, -0.03116997703909874, -0.01645784080028534, 0.028169607743620872, -0.0013938664924353361, -0.00581606850028038, 0.029514163732528687, 0.023299936205148697, 0.05314278602600098, -0.003791994182392955, 0.04957268759608269, 0.046226080507040024, -0.018615994602441788, -0.038163453340530396, 0.06123564764857292, 0.048954371362924576, 0.06291626393795013, 0.018043501302599907, 0.01418980211019516, -0.02271280251443386, 0.0006501236348412931, -0.011082828044891357, -0.014754931442439556, -0.02585974894464016, 0.011749700643122196, -0.008677343837916851, -0.05011574178934097, 0.04171806201338768, 0.07360126823186874, -0.017360812053084373, -0.050766587257385254, 0.024598093703389168, -0.04879910871386528, -0.010466617532074451, -0.02128828503191471, 0.03625426068902016, 0.04650295153260231, 0.011094669811427593, 0.024396363645792007, -0.003078789683058858, -0.019059984013438225, 0.027409685775637627, -0.005328669212758541, -0.03982478752732277, 0.08303049951791763, 0.05152905732393265, -0.04276705160737038, 0.008201822638511658, -0.02881273254752159, 0.06459373235702515, -0.017645109444856644, -0.011862439103424549, -0.025324810296297073, 0.02338491380214691, 0.004208024591207504, -0.009807080030441284, 0.005790259689092636, -0.03562874719500542, 0.00047470623394474387, -0.0007093364256434143, -0.047705233097076416, -0.04314325377345085, -0.01064328569918871, -0.09470048546791077, -0.026005888357758522, -0.03882203996181488, -0.04408220201730728, -0.024513419717550278, 0.06636030972003937, -0.006315438076853752, -0.013422960415482521, -0.009373227134346962, 0.01312955655157566, -0.011434038169682026, -0.08000841736793518, 0.06173780560493469, 0.001626205281354487, 0.027431447058916092, -0.009494096040725708, -0.015920720994472504, 0.029072940349578857, 0.033744096755981445, -0.00206586392596364, 0.005089944694191217, 0.02985754795372486, 0.04886294901371002, -0.043837085366249084, -0.0015079517615959048, 0.05242275074124336, 0.0008062427514232695, -0.038629982620477676, 0.002088311593979597, -0.0016771720256656408, -0.02992665022611618, 0.003775364952161908, -0.04308553785085678, -0.0015452895313501358, 0.0078645721077919, -0.028282444924116135, -0.026771938428282738, -0.025711003690958023, -0.006314973346889019, -0.0030229652766138315, 0.12169469147920609, -0.0005029208259657025, 0.014060412533581257, 0.01213749498128891, 0.002803805284202099, 0.01539855357259512, 0.01782790571451187, -0.018115585669875145, 0.0009731125901453197, 0.07032430917024612, -0.06278011202812195, -0.029468566179275513, 0.0027284969110041857, -0.10002834349870682, 0.04635467007756233, 0.009669598191976547, -0.049804408103227615, 0.003497687866911292, -0.03834063187241554, -0.06229029595851898, -0.009664226323366165, 0.007107017561793327, 0.07519130408763885, 0.02764589712023735, 0.030085735023021698, 0.024903062731027603, -0.0008187154890038073, -0.032014090567827225, -0.007759262342005968, -0.031851876527071, -0.03194451332092285, -0.006422488950192928, -0.05516991391777992, 0.016841605305671692, -0.013596128672361374, -0.020992305129766464, 0.009577499702572823, -0.10006996244192123, -0.036642998456954956, -0.029811127111315727, -0.03856981545686722, -0.009519386105239391, 0.043422870337963104, -0.008657406084239483, -0.021416867151856422, -0.0332016684114933, -0.0027511732187122107, -0.01912713795900345, 0.07630577683448792, -0.013991383835673332, 0.018346698954701424, 0.030995866283774376, -0.005644881632179022, 0.009499084204435349, -0.013354508206248283, -0.012860940769314766, -0.016719063743948936, 0.05206209421157837, -0.013089410029351711, 0.004405598156154156, 0.036656927317380905, -0.008626611903309822, -0.03382525593042374, 0.0178986843675375, 0.009289094246923923, 0.03142645210027695, 0.017652040347456932, -0.015920022502541542, 0.018126757815480232, -0.012701532803475857, -0.03617887571454048, 0.04914962500333786, -0.012381927110254765, -0.01750751957297325, -0.03064509853720665, -0.03993731737136841, 0.0020213110838085413, -0.018745405599474907, 0.012990372255444527, -0.03142246976494789, 0.052164994180202484, -0.017704114317893982, 0.027794472873210907, 0.04915180802345276, 0.04438895359635353, 0.034780118614435196, 0.029948940500617027, 0.012488776817917824, 0.014764823019504547, 0.027431538328528404, 0.010574819520115852, 0.014425499364733696, 0.024120457470417023, 0.037620700895786285, -0.05463261902332306, 0.06945635378360748, 0.005827265325933695, -0.026636812835931778, 0.031025271862745285, 0.03176586702466011, -0.057588525116443634, -0.06184087693691254, -0.028495172038674355, -0.009830057621002197, -0.02130074054002762, 0.009190713986754417, 0.0171652864664793, -0.07399137318134308, -0.036116424947977066, 0.02400875650346279, 0.0006337068043649197, 0.04499422386288643, 0.0567353330552578, 0.03791007772088051, -0.057065267115831375, 0.002099694451317191, 0.020598655566573143, -0.03161340579390526, -0.015118696726858616, -0.032463908195495605, 0.01632589101791382, 0.048961538821458817, 0.054816942662000656, -0.05964018404483795, -0.014657375402748585, 0.03670033439993858, -0.04888781160116196, 0.013173012062907219, 0.027532143518328667, -0.05404894798994064, -0.028967635706067085, -0.026283107697963715, -0.044293761253356934, 0.08280056715011597, -0.04098403826355934, -0.02265126071870327, 0.01600836217403412, -0.004624974448233843, 0.06572017818689346, -0.026227006688714027, 0.049789171665906906, -0.0025276767555624247, 0.013436517678201199, 0.0061109187081456184, 0.09527528285980225, 0.02402307838201523, -0.11105956882238388, -0.04348640888929367, 0.011266562156379223, 0.029001375660300255, -0.04004914313554764, 0.021082695573568344, 0.03674515709280968, 0.01712985150516033, -0.00876738503575325, -0.033629920333623886, -0.039271581918001175, 0.0015663402155041695, -0.028861267492175102, 0.07171902805566788, 0.019268453121185303, -0.018761146813631058, -0.0042674485594034195, 0.021506676450371742, 0.013751575723290443, -0.02796015702188015, -0.006666092202067375, 0.04524644836783409, 0.03697963431477547, 0.0008354557794518769, 0.011269076727330685, -0.03145580366253853, -0.04526267945766449, 0.010018409229815006, -0.02546079270541668, 0.019716067239642143, 0.023155614733695984, -0.0788426473736763, 0.014858541078865528, 0.018506882712244987, 0.00456912349909544, -0.02793353609740734, 0.021134905517101288, 0.00026649926439858973, 0.011697209440171719, -0.016895730048418045, 0.030367892235517502, 0.012830625288188457, 0.01061257068067789, 0.03261910006403923, 0.015181994996964931, -0.06841092556715012, 0.046126704663038254, 0.01228197943419218, 0.033494092524051666, 0.04013974592089653, 0.021672455593943596, 0.0034789876081049442, -0.03755560144782066, 0.004288533702492714, 0.009440867230296135, 0.026208942756056786, -0.020146973431110382, 0.002461259253323078, 0.03136003389954567, 0.022359570488333702, 0.03288951888680458, 0.019969971850514412, -0.010768855921924114, -0.003253208240494132, 0.01793244667351246, -0.020506424829363823, 0.021066302433609962, -0.002565238391980529, -0.003778096055611968, -0.01696966215968132, 0.034435421228408813, 0.02706112153828144, -0.00655546598136425, 0.027745770290493965, 0.01589827612042427, 0.012588132172822952, 0.01382635347545147, 0.06392388790845871, -0.06739404797554016, 0.017895104363560677, -0.013391422107815742, 0.0043348753824830055, 0.009381521493196487, 0.05102182552218437, 0.01545303501188755, -0.007346985395997763, -0.03494732826948166, 0.06825081259012222, 0.006054720841348171, -0.021129842847585678, -0.04368375986814499, -0.028949836269021034, -0.06169633939862251, 0.0662560686469078, -0.021527018398046494, -0.023529451340436935, -0.032122623175382614, -0.021183235570788383, 0.0045741465874016285, 0.019318105652928352, -0.03681828826665878, 0.0007675017695873976, 0.00244528497569263, -0.02209138125181198, 0.03529990091919899, -0.022840779274702072, 0.0025441504549235106, -0.05168994888663292, 0.007955988869071007, -0.008213620632886887, 0.007047696504741907, -0.0015403077704831958, 0.023633765056729317, -0.03004303388297558, 0.030902763828635216, 0.01440721657127142, -0.08715253323316574, 0.013428328558802605, 0.08177462965250015, 0.008314140141010284, 0.017479516565799713, 0.01651020348072052, 0.03806418180465698, 0.00047168138553388417, 0.04487423598766327, 0.05860869958996773, -0.043391961604356766, 0.0038277956191450357, 0.07386656105518341, 0.06019468232989311, 0.014632697217166424, -0.023613668978214264, -0.05649875849485397, 0.0579625740647316, 0.019198305904865265, 0.028776904568076134, 0.044471245259046555, -0.02611544169485569, 0.02588285505771637, 0.010013701394200325, 0.05866847187280655, 0.014282007701694965, 0.056989721953868866, 0.016848687082529068, 0.01687406376004219, 0.037279341369867325, -0.028210164979100227, -0.05165446922183037, 0.09692110121250153, -0.06676711142063141, -0.05272428318858147, -0.04720298573374748, -0.0686827227473259, -0.028720993548631668, 0.032091401517391205, -0.02913712151348591, 0.00877140648663044, -0.010701105929911137, -0.03708576783537865, -0.025106102228164673, 0.10830851644277573, -0.01963355951011181, 0.028858590871095657, -0.042981307953596115, -0.019774867221713066, 0.09083745628595352, -0.04745379462838173, 0.014182506129145622, 0.01653663069009781, -0.02232547476887703, -0.0448378287255764, -0.04600426182150841, -0.02474897913634777, 0.007786591537296772, -0.01657763123512268, -0.022276243194937706, 0.02246050536632538, -0.0104975001886487, -0.019683195278048515, -0.02991160936653614, 0.01803952269256115, -0.0020710197277367115, -0.011805701069533825, -0.04666733369231224, 0.00662976922467351, 0.02756832167506218, 0.010500962845981121, -0.03102731890976429, 0.01570742577314377, -0.026942288503050804, 0.015376354567706585, 0.00475280312821269, -0.020320801064372063, 0.018291540443897247, -0.050877369940280914, 0.03084065392613411, -0.050957515835762024, -0.0011248488444834948, -0.01567838527262211, 0.03630902245640755, 0.026794932782649994, 0.013889639638364315, -0.03527131304144859, -0.06563084572553635, 0.030589397996664047, -0.0018720850348472595, -0.04750010371208191, 0.02569645643234253, 0.07853225618600845, 0.024892274290323257, 0.02942594699561596, -0.0351012647151947, 0.08677364885807037, -0.0187950748950243, 0.033260393887758255, -0.0068461233749985695, 0.012670669704675674, 0.0404643714427948, -0.028160888701677322, 0.024967830628156662, -0.02274203859269619, 0.01818806119263172, -0.08482862263917923, -0.002801261143758893, 0.037787243723869324, 0.01330671738833189, -0.022926412522792816, 0.0016674833605065942, -0.021046170964837074, -0.058912768959999084, -0.0003720882523339242, -0.020678164437413216, -0.022686133161187172, 0.01992819644510746, -0.018336394801735878, 0.015433716587722301, -0.013661734759807587, 0.05495527759194374, -0.029310813173651695, 0.08771860599517822, -0.04653147608041763, 0.025662213563919067, 0.052490316331386566, -0.047610197216272354, -0.036147862672805786, 0.007756204344332218, 0.04836443439126015, -0.035194281488657, -0.03751234710216522, -0.07895878702402115, 0.023824771866202354, 0.04094614088535309, -0.022231081500649452, -0.061742618680000305, 0.030300812795758247, 0.006565614137798548, 0.04819866642355919, -0.017427952960133553, 0.02228013426065445, 0.018756475299596786, -0.012753919698297977, -0.06992103904485703, -0.017221590504050255, 0.05119268596172333, -0.009045280516147614, 0.07640504091978073, -0.029800573363900185, -0.016925198957324028, -0.04791201278567314, 0.014690784737467766, -0.03924133628606796, 0.07489273697137833, 0.044152986258268356, 0.0060759964399039745, -0.029812783002853394, 0.005650873761624098, -0.04218433424830437, -0.012811419554054737, 0.00922904722392559, -0.013676680624485016, -0.023852873593568802, -0.03911939635872841, -0.004361150786280632, -0.005602742545306683, -0.019616173580288887, -0.02414792962372303, -0.07037045061588287, -0.04028898477554321, 0.02378001995384693, -0.016688449308276176, 0.00600037444382906, 0.03163649141788483, -0.013431549072265625, -0.0354468896985054, -0.02414155751466751, -0.029936376959085464, -0.045360323041677475, -0.010663282126188278, -0.020153341814875603, -0.006868619937449694, 0.032878484576940536, -0.07297217845916748, 0.06336971372365952, 0.0036721290089190006, -0.03622502088546753, 0.0673108771443367, -0.02020469680428505, 0.0012808594619855285, 0.02292262390255928, -0.053309209644794464, 0.00925287976861, 0.024234624579548836, 0.03078392893075943, -0.022490007802844048, 0.007189517840743065, -0.0003057386784348637, 0.08002648502588272, -0.02098715864121914, 0.007721368223428726, 0.020781386643648148, -0.046675968915224075, -0.02463587373495102, -0.039084795862436295, 0.10419817268848419, -0.010926364921033382, -0.05557124689221382, -0.056915853172540665, 0.058648839592933655, -0.02518417127430439, -0.04590864107012749, -0.011927295476198196, 0.02542761340737343, 0.014093141071498394, 0.002448619343340397, -0.049688275903463364, -0.03814079985022545, -0.018960483372211456, 0.05455731227993965, 0.014435680583119392, -0.030223220586776733, 0.040776222944259644, 0.010380348190665245, 0.043282024562358856, 0.04607323929667473, 0.028198720887303352, -0.03672507777810097, 0.028708094730973244, -0.024921609088778496, -0.0063714454881846905, 0.03995323181152344, 0.031586043536663055, -0.01973423920571804, -0.009861770085990429, -0.013511615805327892, -0.04771188646554947, -0.0761721208691597, 0.0581146739423275, -0.06838037818670273, -0.023914989084005356, 0.010562660172581673, -0.025476394221186638, 0.03547963872551918, -0.07783262431621552, -0.007760863285511732, -0.03580638766288757, -0.039029620587825775, -0.005267874337732792, -0.006056438200175762, 0.011451506055891514, -0.03622929006814957, 0.0008006509742699564, 0.041228536516427994, -0.02510148100554943, -0.041313041001558304, -0.023304598405957222, -0.010607508942484856, 0.004851316101849079, 0.047695036977529526, 0.0037605571560561657, -0.025221623480319977, -0.009455137886106968, 0.001874783425591886, -0.055795758962631226, -0.0009936251444742084, 0.023185119032859802, -0.024994051083922386, 0.0665135309100151, -0.00014792197907809168, 0.08939605206251144, 0.006984307896345854, -0.01070960983633995, -0.013331725262105465, -0.02688765898346901, 0.004547247663140297, 0.009434329345822334, -0.021222323179244995, 0.03021472878754139, -0.002508866833522916, 0.03209016099572182, 0.00986032746732235, 0.024946462363004684, -0.06478656083345413, 0.0066955299116671085, -0.01553045492619276, -0.014126685447990894, 0.029321670532226562, 0.08287208527326584, 0.009137007407844067, -0.01559680886566639, -0.0264865905046463, -0.025617633014917374, -0.02828623726963997, 0.005140628665685654, -0.02152031846344471, 0.04460640624165535, 0.03684646636247635, -0.043783314526081085, 0.010316817089915276, 0.0031498316675424576, -0.02751520834863186, -0.0568452849984169, 0.023855535313487053, 0.0005507923197001219, -0.025750525295734406, -0.03949853405356407, 0.013201027177274227, -0.058632925152778625, 0.018913673236966133, -0.027191275730729103, 0.04725585877895355, -0.05304202437400818, -0.009653409942984581, -0.03039729595184326, -0.001976580824702978, 0.027066640555858612, -0.03109760396182537, 0.039269134402275085, -0.00468794908374548, 0.02781912125647068, -0.006387979257851839, -0.04395873472094536, -0.053489696234464645, 0.02502448856830597, -0.01747814007103443, -0.0516885481774807, 0.011179184541106224, 0.013513275422155857, 0.01042791549116373, -0.04927946627140045, 0.010853785090148449, 0.060639165341854095, 0.030465243384242058, -0.06225107982754707, 0.06120075657963753, 0.03632879629731178, -0.07769361883401871, -0.01946028135716915, 0.0936029702425003, 0.016001220792531967, 0.0200095996260643, -0.00008956476813182235, -0.04599468782544136, -0.0010890454286709428, -0.03242615982890129, 0.00006406896864064038, -0.023938845843076706, 0.010410478338599205, -0.023746473714709282, -0.025883859023451805, -0.01536477915942669, 0.028895363211631775 ]
<p>I am looking at a manifold of dimension $n$ (And I am considering a local co-ordinates system $x_1,x_2,\ldots x_n$) and the metric defined by the components $g_{ij} = \frac{\delta_{ij}}{x_1^2}$. I'm wanting to find the components of the corresponding Riemann tensor. This should be a pretty straight forward task but I cannot seem to match my workings to the actual answer.</p> <p>Of course $g^{ij} = x_1^2\delta^{ij}$ and I have that $R^l_{ijk} = \frac{\partial}{\partial x^j} \Gamma^l_{ik} - \frac{\partial}{\partial x^k} \Gamma^l_{ij} + \Gamma^s_{ik}\Gamma^l_{sj} - \Gamma^s_{ij}\Gamma^l_{sk}$</p> <p>And I also have derived that $\Gamma^l_{ij} = \frac{1}{2}g^{lm}(g_{im,j}+g_{jk,i}-g_{ij,m})$</p> <p>So I've done the hard stuff, and it should just be an easy calculation to get the the components of the Riemann tensor. But I can't get my answer to match.</p> <p>Could someone please help me with the calculations please?</p>
g7472
[ -0.004667583387345076, 0.007422396447509527, -0.03340267017483711, -0.04734594374895096, 0.00032557675149291754, 0.00467223534360528, 0.0681942030787468, 0.00796436332166195, -0.03877047821879387, 0.01453277375549078, 0.013216099701821804, 0.012527876533567905, 0.07174926996231079, -0.03503577038645744, -0.026537716388702393, 0.014540755189955235, 0.017024574801325798, 0.026768015697598457, -0.02231496572494507, -0.034405436366796494, -0.07369859516620636, -0.04792652651667595, 0.0732002779841423, -0.05595116317272186, 0.05815419554710388, -0.03605380654335022, 0.0783030241727829, 0.006522831507027149, -0.05329572781920433, -0.05955836921930313, 0.0021242096554487944, -0.0014542124699801207, 0.009328417479991913, -0.04276067391037941, -0.023830216377973557, 0.019637051969766617, 0.04025164246559143, 0.01497016940265894, 0.02088036946952343, -0.003231653943657875, -0.004813054576516151, -0.05012034252285957, 0.06563960015773773, -0.006837418768554926, 0.017383992671966553, 0.027885163202881813, -0.014315524138510227, 0.042301662266254425, -0.019761011004447937, 0.00852422509342432, -0.011056008748710155, 0.0327848419547081, -0.04594963788986206, 0.0025974030140787363, -0.018561767414212227, 0.0011522379936650395, 0.05517039820551872, -0.043247245252132416, 0.015387769788503647, -0.01020960882306099, 0.010830872692167759, -0.025840897113084793, -0.03394739702343941, -0.007707708515226841, 0.04268483817577362, -0.01312386617064476, 0.0040975287556648254, -0.05063922330737114, 0.049670733511447906, -0.009612477384507656, -0.011679338291287422, 0.0010930763091892004, 0.10801363736391068, 0.020968660712242126, 0.017585622146725655, -0.026741918176412582, 0.018852118402719498, 0.05506664887070656, 0.03181928023695946, 0.014538721181452274, 0.02664360962808132, -0.012122679501771927, 0.05692046880722046, 0.014499259181320667, 0.09546656906604767, 0.03544748201966286, 0.010099705308675766, 0.07610777765512466, -0.030261116102337837, 0.047122176736593246, -0.001771921175532043, 0.030509021133184433, 0.04206070303916931, -0.01761634834110737, 0.04143436998128891, -0.028386829420924187, -0.06665948033332825, 0.029584821313619614, -0.000906566099729389, -0.055811431258916855, 0.01455463282763958, 0.0006132654380053282, -0.005153376143425703, 0.006826114375144243, 0.009395317174494267, -0.0043878210708498955, 0.023189082741737366, -0.00541814137250185, -0.03135666251182556, -0.03926664590835571, -0.0076133813709020615, 0.02267162874341011, 0.010017053224146366, -0.051576416939496994, 0.021940553560853004, -0.002723397221416235, 0.03445309400558472, -0.040588345378637314, 0.027099933475255966, 0.02942105010151863, 0.03437795862555504, 0.011500264517962933, -0.009081399068236351, 0.032141733914613724, 0.03666001185774803, -0.012915769591927528, -0.023948833346366882, 0.00510846683755517, 0.04534638673067093, 0.010143864899873734, -0.006837769411504269, 0.04436272382736206, -0.004347522743046284, 0.007956339046359062, -0.03197372332215309, 0.054388463497161865, 0.022366177290678024, 0.021862508729100227, -0.013864426873624325, -0.019184516742825508, -0.012510119006037712, -0.014991886913776398, -0.047944337129592896, 0.0013871261617168784, -0.020213263109326363, 0.013990080915391445, -0.007227298337966204, -0.09661206603050232, -0.009451591409742832, -0.013346252962946892, 0.05009965971112251, 0.048103030771017075, -0.014374951831996441, -0.0035947971045970917, 0.04050636664032936, -0.0011944883735850453, -0.017607571557164192, -0.018111949786543846, -0.044406525790691376, -0.023288697004318237, 0.02232224866747856, -0.0015565241919830441, 0.08167025446891785, -0.0064624580554664135, 0.0018463621381670237, 0.040304310619831085, 0.008547253906726837, -0.021150436252355576, 0.0029089979361742735, -0.04633722081780434, -0.07746569067239761, -0.005243571009486914, 0.002869814168661833, -0.004273158963769674, 0.029987305402755737, 0.051587361842393875, -0.014396040700376034, -0.008272587321698666, 0.06451933830976486, 0.003232460469007492, -0.010173709131777287, -0.0414159782230854, 0.02989327907562256, 0.0005563381128013134, 0.011588572524487972, -0.0200083926320076, -0.04096471518278122, 0.018320634961128235, -0.0014806381659582257, 0.0025014476850628853, -0.026215635240077972, 0.05331367254257202, 0.038477230817079544, 0.06279371678829193, 0.05315224081277847, 0.013633421622216702, 0.0026179454289376736, -0.061617542058229446, -0.04254904016852379, 0.05333954095840454, -0.04333219677209854, 0.0021509190555661917, 0.009108894504606724, 0.030593933537602425, 0.004443195648491383, -0.022932646796107292, -0.026608198881149292, 0.006669745314866304, 0.027556298300623894, -0.0059432657435536385, -0.0119599848985672, -0.05955640599131584, 0.017281239852309227, -0.023276163265109062, 0.011211707256734371, -0.03084275871515274, -0.013452310115098953, -0.021509641781449318, -0.014474410563707352, -0.02148490957915783, -0.011598645709455013, 0.008958065882325172, 0.07685036957263947, -0.07787958532571793, -0.03575892746448517, -0.023075416684150696, -0.008155260235071182, -0.025508472695946693, -0.015251888893544674, -0.012667660601437092, -0.01680176332592964, 0.0004461993230506778, 0.03859863802790642, -0.006528501398861408, 0.032400790601968765, 0.034602921456098557, -0.057263389229774475, -0.0413232296705246, 0.023278219625353813, 0.026006488129496574, -0.007629899308085442, -0.00561338197439909, 0.016064707189798355, 0.046824440360069275, 0.013040062040090561, 0.019354021176695824, 0.06797479093074799, 0.008573957718908787, -0.046943727880716324, 0.05242493376135826, -0.0446104034781456, 0.01643962226808071, -0.04724382236599922, -0.002095947740599513, -0.012707220390439034, -0.01059714611619711, 0.002757817041128874, 0.00040346512105315924, 0.002465103520080447, -0.011803588829934597, -0.06275085359811783, -0.023451054468750954, -0.01654522307217121, 0.06197873875498772, -0.06793075799942017, -0.015545076690614223, -0.018023604527115822, -0.0246229637414217, 0.038206979632377625, 0.050512973219156265, 0.0391206368803978, 0.008532249368727207, 0.049442846328020096, 0.07411573082208633, -0.04950207471847534, 0.017541998997330666, -0.014945488423109055, 0.015357418917119503, -0.006812500301748514, 0.01109233871102333, 0.0028714172076433897, 0.019978757947683334, 0.04962087422609329, 0.01486832182854414, 0.033609598875045776, -0.07150638103485107, 0.03248552978038788, 0.04217259958386421, 0.013075831346213818, 0.048045068979263306, 0.006275062449276447, 0.004066617228090763, -0.02763378620147705, -0.04213930666446686, -0.02595520205795765, -0.0022482157219201326, 0.020877167582511902, -0.05015410855412483, -0.03685622289776802, 0.08656682819128036, 0.04144923388957977, -0.01662902906537056, 0.059219762682914734, -0.06285610795021057, -0.0030227384995669127, -0.004103927407413721, -0.06344299763441086, -0.04987963289022446, 0.03201586380600929, -0.002861190587282181, 0.015423307195305824, -0.02718702144920826, 0.06045364961028099, -0.02513781748712063, -0.001148768700659275, 0.005268764216452837, -0.020029636099934578, -0.007240745704621077, -0.10549357533454895, 0.015260249376296997, -0.01473650150001049, -0.052211396396160126, -0.04078373685479164, 0.006332218647003174, -0.007889906875789165, 0.02387133054435253, -0.07772626727819443, -0.0061133848503232, -0.0011546778259798884, 0.0187999214977026, -0.025392770767211914, -0.011133176274597645, 0.019417358562350273, 0.026625793427228928, -0.0394878126680851, -0.021646782755851746, -0.12636719644069672, -0.03149908035993576, -0.002931328723207116, -0.023083521053195, -0.05666998028755188, -0.022888751700520515, -0.02611246518790722, -0.002053790492936969, -0.04170523211359978, -0.016112105920910835, -0.00935217086225748, -0.0026186383329331875, 0.01562601886689663, -0.01921422965824604, -0.03543170541524887, 0.0012116682482883334, 0.027977008372545242, -0.025117523968219757, -0.015379580669105053, 0.0051413062028586864, 0.08643531799316406, 0.06387200951576233, -0.025481974706053734, -0.018915735185146332, 0.03478672727942467, -0.011053248308598995, -0.030644796788692474, -0.003598931711167097, -0.028318902477622032, -0.01676812395453453, 0.05113614350557327, 0.03771910443902016, -0.040121398866176605, 0.051939938217401505, 0.06599781662225723, 0.028249436989426613, -0.0011777762556448579, 0.0669766291975975, -0.02975398302078247, -0.04184664413332939, -0.03133859485387802, -0.03350179269909859, 0.008234056644141674, -0.011980004608631134, -0.004539251793175936, 0.05137115716934204, -0.0039102621376514435, -0.01217939518392086, 0.04641417786478996, -0.0032720742747187614, 0.024325035512447357, 0.020927492529153824, 0.002715378999710083, -0.022844726219773293, 0.02950659766793251, -0.0752764567732811, -0.09579375386238098, 0.024526428431272507, 0.02253594622015953, 0.0023781766649335623, 0.022793082520365715, 0.076344795525074, -0.03542859107255936, 0.03024730645120144, -0.0021778475493192673, 0.019403856247663498, 0.04593047499656677, -0.011493660509586334, 0.016565624624490738, -0.010473771952092648, -0.02991364151239395, 0.00857557076960802, 0.08177988976240158, 0.032962676137685776, -0.01069597713649273, -0.016831234097480774, 0.0695151537656784, -0.07135168462991714, 0.035904549062252045, -0.019533634185791016, -0.0006988415261730552, -0.02327236346900463, -0.0038242139853537083, -0.03576663136482239, -0.017648210749030113, -0.025601835921406746, 0.014775634743273258, -0.01925782486796379, 0.0032828180119395256, 0.006132129579782486, 0.06273125857114792, -0.028161849826574326, -0.04293554276227951, -0.012004956603050232, 0.018169952556490898, -0.014798358082771301, -0.024187350645661354, 0.01596655696630478, -0.03618817776441574, 0.04963812604546547, -0.013027253560721874, -0.03846096992492676, 0.018496373668313026, -0.01535961776971817, 0.014192570000886917, -0.011729279533028603, 0.02631489746272564, -0.08188731968402863, 0.018483854830265045, 0.03804346174001694, -0.04645321145653725, -0.04355050250887871, -0.038819365203380585, -0.012708988040685654, 0.021264107897877693, -0.02131209336221218, 0.051424041390419006, -0.06306476891040802, 0.022762620821595192, 0.04616553708910942, 0.0036157220602035522, -0.032552074640989304, -0.010244294069707394, 0.008672483265399933, 0.021244211122393608, -0.025364583358168602, 0.03978075832128525, -0.014510758221149445, 0.05365782603621483, -0.0022257319651544094, -0.049500856548547745, 0.09036243706941605, -0.022545987740159035, -0.013097867369651794, 0.05215097963809967, 0.02137685753405094, -0.021066337823867798, -0.0705462321639061, 0.04491567611694336, 0.063456691801548, -0.041578419506549835, 0.023553723469376564, 0.013955434784293175, 0.0029085115529596806, -0.008197493851184845, -0.01880139485001564, 0.009031076915562153, -0.013668300583958626, 0.036710310727357864, -0.0030005655717104673, 0.036132145673036575, -0.010237074457108974, 0.020375102758407593, -0.005328328814357519, 0.024935400113463402, 0.007376470137387514, 0.02761511690914631, 0.0038418001495301723, 0.025203349068760872, 0.025675693526864052, -0.004695615731179714, -0.08408355712890625, 0.004696459509432316, 0.017387624830007553, -0.012571996077895164, 0.07084956020116806, 0.018074514344334602, -0.031710460782051086, 0.0008007914293557405, 0.044103335589170456, 0.06590049713850021, -0.010577606037259102, -0.006093107629567385, 0.06615500152111053, -0.011591373942792416, 0.007997024804353714, 0.06523729860782623, 0.041955430060625076, -0.041694726794958115, -0.02820715866982937, 0.03683881089091301, 0.07616206258535385, 0.05065117031335831, -0.05521877482533455, 0.03321298956871033, -0.0008509141625836492, -0.010971087962388992, -0.019852319732308388, 0.02482539601624012, 0.03773431107401848, -0.055385176092386246, -0.05608337000012398, 0.006800569128245115, -0.0007608550367876887, 0.004633209202438593, 0.012626026757061481, -0.05368722230195999, -0.03817608579993248, 0.029996072873473167, -0.07918690890073776, -0.00918964296579361, -0.020851248875260353, 0.06647610664367676, -0.007565326523035765, -0.03973615542054176, -0.003983093425631523, 0.0030733912717550993, 0.015686146914958954, -0.009707712568342686, -0.002681913087144494, 0.003161825705319643, -0.00002692789894354064, 0.008645757101476192, 0.036759618669748306, -0.06716590374708176, 0.003169245785102248, 0.05658544972538948, -0.02175189182162285, -0.009443556889891624, -0.025574106723070145, 0.034124065190553665, -0.024198129773139954, -0.035487886518239975, 0.016657153144478798, 0.02332262508571148, -0.03534248471260071, -0.04180384799838066, 0.05801726505160332, -0.09062980860471725, -0.029979422688484192, -0.0023196747060865164, -0.02626827359199524, 0.058866843581199646, -0.017955340445041656, -0.002389393514022231, -0.009774381294846535, 0.011105727404356003, 0.038744162768125534, 0.055026594549417496, 0.008045753464102745, -0.06107877939939499, -0.06797711551189423, 0.006005707662552595, 0.0097423754632473, 0.008169099688529968, 0.04037836194038391, 0.061140693724155426, -0.021301303058862686, -0.0445324145257473, 0.01736982725560665, -0.068227618932724, -0.05725076422095299, 0.02405070699751377, 0.018723653629422188, 0.029979446902871132, 0.009922214783728123, -0.02754639834165573, -0.009075811132788658, -0.03291582316160202, -0.09336996078491211, -0.017355047166347504, 0.04904830455780029, -0.03322116658091545, -0.0025166093837469816, 0.02253534458577633, 0.01631193794310093, 0.02594720758497715, -0.00392198795452714, -0.0022647341247648, -0.0037859990261495113, -0.07304809242486954, -0.013315989635884762, -0.039542462676763535, 0.022148264572024345, 0.04516186565160751, 0.08605313301086426, -0.043603863567113876, 0.03594508767127991, 0.0638115331530571, -0.008472620509564877, -0.006344360765069723, 0.027971526607871056, -0.010995905846357346, -0.006102548912167549, 0.09826435148715973, 0.007889533415436745, -0.04885469377040863, -0.0328739732503891, 0.00467781163752079, 0.02535846270620823, 0.02886531688272953, 0.002130052773281932, -0.03985454887151718, 0.020091716200113297, 0.006662736646831036, -0.006321065593510866, -0.0542273074388504, -0.02267852984368801, -0.009604953229427338, 0.0038022471126168966, -0.004912035074084997, -0.001686261733993888, 0.05390278249979019, 0.055344048887491226, 0.01768624596297741, -0.007555556017905474, -0.013723360374569893, -0.009060527198016644, 0.02465926669538021, -0.0011263058986514807, 0.030032454058527946, 0.030623070895671844, -0.094039686024189, 0.05274824798107147, 0.06056521460413933, 0.030900469049811363, 0.02336202934384346, -0.006540736183524132, -0.06124240905046463, -0.04731340706348419, -0.03648848459124565, 0.02322511188685894, 0.03315034508705139, -0.0035487243440002203, -0.06816007941961288, -0.00782178994268179, 0.012772555463016033, 0.033098362386226654, -0.07795259356498718, 0.02752208709716797, 0.030761096626520157, 0.01850682869553566, 0.01516831573098898, -0.001689307508058846, -0.04486435651779175, -0.041776929050683975, -0.012936643324792385, 0.03158268332481384, 0.016238585114479065, -0.012670296244323254, -0.005526792723685503, 0.010989497415721416, -0.046079665422439575, -0.00992635078728199, -0.03487474471330643, 0.09235703945159912, -0.050385333597660065, 0.030253754928708076, -0.02442697435617447, 0.013384721241891384, 0.01497724186629057, -0.05560454726219177, 0.032810669392347336, 0.09203460812568665, -0.021390220150351524, 0.04744081571698189, -0.062189795076847076, 0.025944316759705544, -0.028271885588765144, -0.056705132126808167, -0.018660007044672966, 0.047511614859104156, -0.06949073076248169, -0.010184082202613354, 0.035456135869026184, 0.0048737479373812675, 0.0003407736076042056, -0.017280854284763336, -0.00802551582455635, -0.014077411033213139, -0.01717435009777546, -0.06850410252809525, 0.02076536789536476, 0.0402299165725708, -0.0007243019645102322, 0.032437343150377274, -0.039708416908979416, 0.0065534976311028, -0.019449448212981224, 0.005896494258195162, -0.06387248635292053, 0.04307231679558754, 0.035296034067869186, -0.048859190195798874, -0.09073222428560257, -0.022465724498033524, 0.023756979033350945, -0.06051341071724892, -0.05510809272527695, -0.033172499388456345, 0.009717180393636227, 0.01150913443416357, 0.022772278636693954, 0.015232550911605358, -0.02431906759738922, -0.06761125475168228, -0.03246164694428444, -0.004152314271777868, -0.019650228321552277, -0.018893711268901825, 0.01813255250453949, -0.03992422670125961, 0.016740528866648674, 0.03784314543008804, -0.004526997916400433, -0.08148394525051117, 0.012586645781993866, -0.008392971009016037, -0.006253174506127834, -0.04121736064553261, 0.018915019929409027, 0.062375348061323166, -0.0010246571619063616, 0.013511843048036098, 0.01226131059229374, 0.08440332114696503, 0.05911855772137642, -0.011087771505117416, 0.00030579062877222896, -0.02551671490073204, -0.01214168407022953, -0.007985252887010574, 0.030478909611701965, -0.014347170479595661, 0.03061118721961975, 0.03060232847929001, -0.018696049228310585, 0.028204645961523056, 0.01571565493941307, 0.010578039102256298, -0.003548118518665433, -0.011239957995712757 ]
<p>Refraction gives rise to a momentum change orthogonal to the propagation direction. This must result in an equal and opposite change to the medium at the boundary. Entry and exit cancel, and the medium experiences no net force. The problem is that the forces on the medium do not in general line up, so we have a pair of forces, opposite but parallel - i.e. a couple. Can we therefore conclude that refraction imparts a couple to a refracting medium? (and if so, has the experiment been done?).</p> <p>Assuming this couple indeed exists: Since the light loses no energy and loses no momentum, and yet the medium appears to have gained rotational energy and momentum, where does the medium's extra angular momentum come from?</p>
g7473
[ 0.0459451861679554, -0.006851579528301954, 0.018141934648156166, -0.036746248602867126, 0.017621492967009544, -0.012322744354605675, -0.017666049301624298, 0.0003127672243863344, 0.025522766634821892, 0.008943871594965458, 0.06212833523750305, 0.0020970844198018312, -0.021084189414978027, -0.000322783860610798, 0.019761130213737488, 0.0010201713303104043, 0.05943606048822403, -0.03263325244188309, 0.02041924186050892, 0.013502540066838264, -0.057619787752628326, -0.0044970279559493065, -0.035799700766801834, -0.04768386110663414, -0.024231616407632828, -0.0005032359040342271, 0.009512363001704216, -0.04146277531981468, -0.022424684837460518, 0.04648635536432266, 0.058860670775175095, -0.05056200549006462, 0.034503210335969925, -0.06963984668254852, -0.035676032304763794, 0.0010534818284213543, 0.0499117411673069, 0.01494122575968504, -0.010198050178587437, 0.0018992280820384622, 0.026775293052196503, -0.018366673961281776, -0.08513820171356201, 0.009701102040708065, 0.0406683050096035, 0.019594300538301468, -0.0004436121671460569, 0.03643932193517685, 0.01618783175945282, -0.020060714334249496, -0.02848934754729271, 0.07697297632694244, 0.03020574152469635, 0.014409317634999752, 0.01112414337694645, 0.09114797413349152, 0.011138963513076305, 0.011467297561466694, 0.09324045479297638, 0.0014747014502063394, -0.010512745939195156, 0.008710876107215881, 0.005758469458669424, 0.005444416310638189, 0.04469666630029678, -0.06939312070608139, -0.005452313926070929, 0.013610977679491043, 0.07479708641767502, -0.023797418922185898, 0.019479745998978615, 0.004985461011528969, -0.010513477958738804, 0.025693029165267944, -0.02050146460533142, -0.02038426324725151, 0.010940385051071644, 0.0005321841454133391, -0.06686026602983475, -0.00004800418537342921, 0.029490869492292404, -0.05363951623439789, -0.0010292355436831713, 0.013298471458256245, 0.021143296733498573, -0.041070837527513504, 0.07948464900255203, 0.020748106762766838, -0.04156696796417236, 0.016528664156794548, 0.07402075082063675, -0.03765549883246422, 0.04660908877849579, 0.04296650364995003, -0.0011143599404022098, -0.037104833871126175, -0.038081273436546326, 0.01538757048547268, 0.013666145503520966, -0.003631484927609563, -0.04848690330982208, -0.012945960275828838, -0.023453596979379654, 0.024522097781300545, 0.03367586433887482, -0.010177058167755604, 0.047318536788225174, 0.0452147014439106, -0.022051572799682617, 0.015319623984396458, -0.0609656497836113, -0.0614987276494503, -0.03634608909487724, -0.078201524913311, -0.0187822338193655, -0.09629444777965546, 0.05546664446592331, 0.005835366901010275, 0.02041742205619812, 0.10212810337543488, 0.01218164712190628, 0.05567781999707222, 0.002008988056331873, 0.08986854553222656, 0.012536885216832161, 0.008301908150315285, -0.025207025930285454, 0.01943913660943508, 0.07535247504711151, -0.0031267935410141945, 0.0031223162077367306, -0.08960843086242676, 0.046948254108428955, -0.006753868889063597, 0.03548940643668175, -0.016640333458781242, 0.027016017585992813, 0.006726536434143782, -0.0007513663731515408, 0.014456934295594692, -0.034255318343639374, 0.015462611801922321, -0.005915822461247444, -0.026561539620161057, -0.023401809856295586, 0.015806490555405617, 0.038666725158691406, 0.027356551960110664, 0.009731040336191654, 0.025415973737835884, 0.04894240200519562, 0.06517533212900162, -0.01837262138724327, -0.004775848239660263, -0.0456213615834713, -0.027428779751062393, 0.09449928998947144, -0.025510551407933235, 0.016903353855013847, -0.00894258264452219, 0.07280173897743225, 0.02607153169810772, 0.014705922454595566, 0.012158962897956371, -0.04893903061747551, -0.004227099008858204, -0.0013205111026763916, -0.019719714298844337, -0.048107221722602844, -0.047948047518730164, -0.10399561375379562, 0.0049708629958331585, 0.00903054978698492, 0.0501079261302948, 0.017210274934768677, 0.06627345085144043, 0.03826124221086502, -0.02137378603219986, -0.04757600277662277, 0.037090033292770386, -0.035649631172418594, 0.04584961012005806, 0.04296651855111122, -0.025884605944156647, 0.02770894207060337, -0.0023967379238456488, -0.022761672735214233, 0.07272212207317352, -0.07334047555923462, -0.03535192832350731, -0.007199192885309458, 0.0025859398301690817, -0.04928397014737129, -0.004195582587271929, -0.002939531346783042, 0.052712664008140564, -0.007573812268674374, -0.04063350334763527, -0.012492949143052101, 0.04187006503343582, -0.03736498951911926, 0.04873233288526535, 0.043395813554525375, 0.04736771807074547, -0.012437479570508003, -0.0062056416645646095, 0.007144815754145384, -0.011606736108660698, 0.06797746568918228, -0.05490192398428917, -0.013810861855745316, 0.023930467665195465, -0.029532741755247116, -0.036908477544784546, -0.01319081336259842, -0.008223102428019047, 0.037322137504816055, 0.0045058224350214005, -0.05999104306101799, 0.013953190296888351, -0.02277379110455513, 0.017041295766830444, -0.03639153018593788, 0.001335931709036231, -0.038593098521232605, -0.06132484972476959, -0.017743445932865143, 0.01499393954873085, -0.023008277639746666, 0.06969152390956879, -0.026827434077858925, 0.022737225517630577, 0.029087873175740242, -0.005422334186732769, 0.007656965870410204, 0.007712889928370714, -0.02635575830936432, 0.06325732171535492, -0.036407507956027985, -0.011146767064929008, 0.016551267355680466, -0.018667401745915413, -0.0759245976805687, 0.04690626636147499, 0.00296234549023211, -0.0009944785851985216, 0.0451488122344017, -0.020763806998729706, 0.010809794068336487, 0.010845348238945007, 0.08096682280302048, -0.000043155272578587756, 0.008327335119247437, 0.01123720407485962, -0.01934390515089035, -0.000028874595955130644, -0.07086624950170517, 0.0479048490524292, -0.0909418910741806, -0.03574008122086525, -0.002849051496013999, 0.05130433663725853, 0.030405312776565552, 0.03357730060815811, -0.0670241191983223, 0.030720217153429985, 0.01846313662827015, 0.07567022740840912, 0.004499682225286961, 0.05263551324605942, -0.009512344375252724, 0.043609850108623505, -0.0051780263893306255, -0.02108498476445675, 0.0005362325464375317, -0.007819789461791515, 0.05199756845831871, -0.024771608412265778, 0.007018881384283304, -0.0036306625697761774, -0.00761782331392169, 0.0411311499774456, -0.04572475329041481, 0.021127920597791672, 0.035499636083841324, -0.0036521332804113626, 0.03003699705004692, 0.025542566552758217, -0.011600421741604805, -0.0012026283657178283, -0.1319606602191925, 0.027759399265050888, 0.051140476018190384, -0.007930869236588478, 0.0021558261942118406, -0.042557183653116226, 0.05426255241036415, -0.022021975368261337, -0.0036267582327127457, 0.03563883900642395, -0.03083629161119461, 0.01900087669491768, -0.010486623272299767, 0.016248928382992744, 0.025939950719475746, 0.006937108933925629, -0.054853156208992004, -0.05341053381562233, 0.005254974588751793, 0.02908492647111416, -0.026381637901067734, 0.06434343755245209, -0.016892394050955772, 0.004929063841700554, -0.023463746532797813, 0.05565013363957405, 0.038401056081056595, -0.035048969089984894, 0.020285550504922867, 0.014254476875066757, -0.013682391494512558, -0.018651505932211876, -0.014632624574005604, -0.022289304062724113, 0.03674263507127762, 0.010319478809833527, -0.08574748039245605, 0.04785905033349991, -0.024738164618611336, 0.010497728362679482, 0.02696644701063633, 0.019676215946674347, -0.02178146131336689, 0.00006128942914074287, -0.01387140154838562, 0.061660174280405045, 0.0057195331901311874, 0.0017242997419089079, 0.04760653153061867, 0.09419384598731995, 0.05068430304527283, 0.03783069923520088, -0.012347311712801456, 0.003047874430194497, 0.005254182033240795, 0.05232396349310875, -0.013603883795440197, 0.005049816332757473, 0.02304871939122677, -0.04191581904888153, 0.052759166806936264, -0.029992030933499336, 0.05010605975985527, -0.019170595332980156, -0.05392104387283325, 0.0020964129362255335, 0.04036605730652809, 0.04218786954879761, 0.03986479341983795, -0.03457745909690857, 0.012601153925061226, -0.011239800602197647, 0.020952653139829636, -0.054251134395599365, -0.023892367258667946, -0.025117281824350357, -0.017922190949320793, 0.028906626626849174, -0.02547372132539749, -0.049891382455825806, 0.002788393758237362, -0.06976574659347534, -0.05044006556272507, 0.011354856193065643, 0.0005714395083487034, -0.010339077562093735, -0.01823090761899948, -0.012250487692654133, -0.011129137128591537, 0.0497540645301342, 0.02096870169043541, 0.01306119468063116, -0.010025895200669765, 0.0800415650010109, -0.008283662609755993, 0.02962515689432621, 0.01988581381738186, 0.009113585576415062, 0.0666310116648674, -0.011046206578612328, 0.017605099827051163, -0.02728857658803463, 0.007949489168822765, 0.01025648508220911, 0.002100764773786068, -0.01787620037794113, -0.020151402801275253, -0.06885603070259094, -0.018843285739421844, -0.020732754841446877, -0.025483770295977592, -0.015156143344938755, -0.06530064344406128, -0.05868632346391678, -0.009611832909286022, 0.04877597466111183, -0.004820435307919979, 0.0030479137785732746, -0.028649065643548965, -0.006860773544758558, 0.01652437448501587, 0.024887867271900177, -0.05248242989182472, -0.06176237016916275, 0.0004899289924651384, -0.0069577619433403015, -0.016648128628730774, -0.0073625179938972, 0.029199348762631416, 0.04279209300875664, -0.03089907579123974, 0.11249522864818573, -0.0688197910785675, 0.006715839263051748, 0.006719091907143593, 0.10196516662836075, 0.001227856264449656, -0.04722103103995323, -0.026058930903673172, -0.07454089820384979, -0.005772038362920284, 0.0339684821665287, 0.016723476350307465, 0.002609261777251959, -0.0022248399909585714, 0.001000004936940968, -0.04723385348916054, -0.01107277162373066, 0.03972446545958519, 0.0607580691576004, 0.025564707815647125, -0.005928682629019022, 0.048708654940128326, -0.04983296990394592, 0.01029091328382492, 0.03393610194325447, 0.014776787720620632, -0.02310805395245552, -0.01736871898174286, -0.034836288541555405, -0.03265312314033508, -0.025256596505641937, -0.025906607508659363, -0.02464667148888111, -0.053071632981300354, 0.017325427383184433, -0.04234950244426727, -0.0073517486453056335, -0.046058353036642075, 0.027356550097465515, -0.07041648030281067, 0.02369609847664833, 0.0343865305185318, -0.007776910439133644, 0.04365863278508186, 0.01486467756330967, 0.03418858349323273, -0.07409589737653732, -0.051560498774051666, -0.012788129970431328, -0.022466223686933517, 0.015062196180224419, 0.039490409195423126, -0.04373280331492424, 0.02450309880077839, -0.03788607195019722, -0.05821914225816727, 0.026686618104577065, 0.022441495209932327, -0.02374196983873844, 0.0021649268455803394, 0.0650930106639862, 0.060595329850912094, -0.0019026523223146796, 0.0010980142978951335, -0.03296078369021416, -0.062191788107156754, 0.05750422924757004, 0.05416209623217583, -0.051444537937641144, -0.014801464974880219, -0.025103922933340073, -0.05499720573425293, -0.04724516347050667, 0.023338114842772484, 0.026351887732744217, -0.0026629995554685593, 0.011991036124527454, -0.03692805394530296, 0.01698141358792782, -0.019485047087073326, -0.0438707135617733, -0.02626168727874756, 0.032601531594991684, -0.04078562557697296, -0.02105863019824028, 0.025005199015140533, -0.0008182669407688081, 0.02869061380624771, 0.06234622374176979, -0.054379597306251526, -0.050645604729652405, 0.0063739949837327, -0.01083541288971901, 0.025650301948189735, 0.006696343421936035, -0.048252299427986145, -0.022553613409399986, -0.03927767276763916, -0.011130103841423988, -0.04511575773358345, -0.031655050814151764, -0.012118869461119175, -0.027815844863653183, 0.011752761900424957, 0.011100731790065765, -0.05729784443974495, 0.04640861600637436, -0.004564205650240183, 0.018072789534926414, 0.011563700623810291, 0.009856175631284714, 0.006953589152544737, -0.03139403089880943, 0.009913057088851929, -0.0574524812400341, 0.03252648189663887, -0.0056123193353414536, 0.0068335579708218575, 0.01565149985253811, -0.0662439838051796, -0.037245362997055054, 0.031419526785612106, 0.08699887245893478, -0.040908332914114, 0.034623391926288605, -0.05254792422056198, -0.027651965618133545, 0.05196041241288185, 0.01481892354786396, -0.014322780072689056, -0.018248017877340317, 0.0006859113927930593, 0.004794922191649675, 0.017315329983830452, -0.03957361727952957, -0.006753954105079174, -0.02096528373658657, 0.014675498940050602, 0.003234109841287136, 0.030910294502973557, -0.002101245103403926, 0.024201029911637306, 0.0015889940550550818, 0.02679249830543995, -0.009931067936122417, 0.011857697740197182, -0.012317010201513767, -0.012964054942131042, -0.026676636189222336, -0.038187429308891296, -0.017468389123678207, -0.05339738726615906, 0.036861155182123184, 0.026438258588314056, 0.014319811947643757, -0.022144757211208344, 0.038592517375946045, -0.03958556056022644, -0.01049853302538395, 0.028500158339738846, 0.009193767793476582, -0.015286047011613846, -0.01183963194489479, -0.05367789417505264, 0.018030978739261627, -0.043403517454862595, 0.0333683043718338, 0.06160552799701691, -0.018354350700974464, -0.052967607975006104, -0.018236327916383743, -0.025108208879828453, -0.011102207005023956, -0.03722536563873291, -0.01357183326035738, 0.020834922790527344, 0.05210261791944504, -0.02832794561982155, 0.008575048297643661, 0.03696766495704651, -0.012007669545710087, 0.050232239067554474, -0.04597710445523262, 0.031348783522844315, -0.005538219586014748, 0.017704153433442116, -0.011096930131316185, 0.06323317438364029, -0.011986540630459785, 0.01044655591249466, 0.02923104166984558, -0.06559275090694427, 0.03008410520851612, -0.043765369802713394, -0.0023380788043141365, 0.031114958226680756, 0.029957065358757973, -0.0006351161282509565, -0.01893608830869198, 0.024607481434941292, -0.09748862683773041, 0.05562537908554077, -0.03769741952419281, -0.007754637394100428, 0.002013091929256916, -0.06592552363872528, 0.020883776247501373, 0.02714725024998188, -0.009542285464704037, 0.02487708441913128, -0.014085710048675537, -0.03076701983809471, -0.020487193018198013, 0.027889864519238472, 0.03831637650728226, -0.04893418028950691, -0.0019762450829148293, 0.041787829250097275, -0.0124738197773695, 0.04421837627887726, 0.035428114235401154, -0.030660228803753853, -0.010138588957488537, -0.04392720386385918, -0.026642659679055214, 0.021328452974557877, -0.058958329260349274, 0.010893406346440315, 0.006131112575531006, -0.06176844984292984, -0.028397906571626663, -0.01717221923172474, 0.022839313372969627, -0.05620928853750229, 0.08413848280906677, 0.004237678833305836, 0.03531448543071747, -0.023885125294327736, -0.016938352957367897, -0.0013531557051464915, -0.0024500980507582426, -0.004868433810770512, -0.028210921213030815, -0.009315289556980133, 0.005082613788545132, 0.037358496338129044, -0.02786950394511223, 0.046991799026727676, 0.06518959999084473, 0.03779301792383194, -0.046199336647987366, -0.020621711388230324, -0.0071984692476689816, -0.03637656569480896, 0.01077396422624588, 0.025710739195346832, -0.01991848647594452, 0.028828129172325134, -0.04554091393947601, 0.012824148871004581, 0.04847604036331177, 0.008098590187728405, 0.0552484355866909, 0.004399279598146677, -0.016100289300084114, 0.0015238767955452204, 0.016940096393227577, -0.029857179149985313, -0.00978148728609085, 0.020998965948820114, 0.06020123139023781, 0.046771127730607986, 0.030952323228120804, -0.036413513123989105, -0.02925659716129303, 0.043581876903772354, 0.0441373847424984, -0.008597161620855331, -0.03776455670595169, -0.046997085213661194, -0.030153676867485046, -0.022891400381922722, 0.04274619370698929, -0.0000431786356784869, -0.007287004962563515, -0.020824339240789413, -0.015049224719405174, -0.0036935717798769474, 0.02048286236822605, 0.054039087146520615, -0.016239304095506668, -0.023951618000864983, 0.00813206471502781, -0.034222107380628586, 0.0049373856745660305, -0.02545734867453575, 0.05171991139650345, 0.03735947608947754, 0.00450440589338541, -0.025018982589244843, -0.04886246845126152, 0.003505557309836149, -0.04031740874052048, -0.05694187059998512, -0.034253139048814774, 0.04426916688680649, -0.016464805230498314, 0.03358722850680351, 0.04370550438761711, 0.023185765370726585, 0.003580881282687187, -0.05871345102787018, -0.012418712489306927, -0.00588738638907671, -0.042914051562547684, 0.005916140507906675, -0.0011186003684997559, 0.008289992809295654, -0.003509658155962825, -0.035206906497478485, -0.07372552156448364, -0.012999190017580986, -0.01867755874991417, 0.012892825528979301, -0.019218336790800095, 0.03911328315734863, 0.07638542354106903, -0.011282464489340782, 0.0651351734995842, -0.004544044844806194, -0.006498654372990131, -0.020661627873778343, 0.008816398680210114, 0.03519643843173981, -0.09457865357398987, -0.01427541021257639, 0.004676160402595997, 0.006100498139858246, -0.03411221131682396, -0.008418011479079723, -0.01627124659717083, -0.014138712547719479, -0.035830844193696976, 0.01444784551858902, 0.016049770638346672, -0.0030410343315452337, 0.017826683819293976 ]
<p>For a significant part of my life I have been taught that, if a photon of the "correct" energy meets an excited atom, the atom will then (with a certain probability) undergo transition to a lower energy state, emitting a photon, which 1)has the same energy as the incident photon, 2)propagates in the same direction, 3)and is in phase with that incident photon.</p> <p>Unfortunately, this statement is rarely, almost never, followed by a discussion about reasons behind the stimulated emission being the way it is. After some searching I have even come up with a few texts claiming that the description above is "not exactly true", meaning that some variation in phase and energy of the stimulated photons is possible. Again followed by no explanation whatsoever. </p> <p>Currently the most exhaustive discussion I have found is this: <a href="http://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/stimem.htm" rel="nofollow">http://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/stimem.htm</a> which is still far from perfect. At least, now I am somewhat convinced, that the two photons should propagate in the same direction. For those not willing to follow that link, the reasoning goes like this: Take two principles (symmetry of physical phenomena under time inversion, and the idea that physical phenomena should be isotropic in an isotropic medium) and apply them to all the variations of the stimulated emission you can think of: 1)the stimulated photon propagates in a random direction. Under time inversion this becomes simple absorption, where one of the spatial directions (in which the former incident photon is propagating) is undesirable; 2)the stimulated photon propagates in the same direction as the incident photon. Under time inversion this becomes completely normal and isotropic absorption (as expected).</p> <p>However, this argumentation is valid only if we presume that the two photons are completely indistinguishable (identical) in the first place. Therefore a "blue" photon (say, 400nm) stimulating emission of a "red" (600nm) photon in a random direction would still be decent physical process. Another stackexchange question tackling this particular matter (can a photon stimulate emission of a different energy photon) <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/119660/can-one-stimulate-emission-of-a-photon-with-an-energy-different-from-the-emitted">here</a> is apparently still waiting for a satisfactory answer.</p> <p>Tl;dr / Long story short, why the photon produced in stimulated emission has the same (1)energy; (2)propagation direction and (3)phase as the incident photon? Pointers to books/papers and decent web resources are much appreciated!</p>
g7474
[ -0.015137333422899246, 0.034950222820043564, 0.008053566329181194, 0.008529496379196644, 0.01581050083041191, 0.028831997886300087, 0.04810779169201851, 0.0494004562497139, 0.008819335140287876, -0.03880761191248894, 0.054087553173303604, 0.05706768482923508, 0.009073513559997082, -0.05110162869095802, -0.03710908070206642, -0.025854146108031273, 0.12058842927217484, -0.013806880451738834, 0.024840636178851128, 0.08813343197107315, -0.06359829753637314, -0.0057405736297369, -0.043894581496715546, -0.061135273426771164, -0.06507012993097305, -0.037038642913103104, -0.01387851033359766, -0.08183661848306656, -0.0009056614362634718, -0.06316621601581573, 0.06539909541606903, -0.039669185876846313, 0.004022217355668545, 0.002304783323779702, -0.01812567189335823, -0.07071264833211899, -0.005321275442838669, -0.023972271010279655, 0.003245989093557, 0.059030842036008835, 0.07349789142608643, -0.013964815065264702, 0.0019971192814409733, -0.04938708245754242, 0.013134302571415901, 0.0028520897030830383, -0.0016884934157133102, 0.0035827509127557278, 0.014634056948125362, -0.038144875317811966, 0.016033202409744263, 0.0733218565583229, 0.03444855287671089, 0.023986032232642174, 0.006635712925344706, 0.024379469454288483, 0.024583028629422188, -0.004134904593229294, 0.06970952451229095, 0.0005174598190933466, -0.048105716705322266, 0.011772616766393185, 0.03584914654493332, 0.007533765397965908, 0.056327950209379196, -0.036383140832185745, -0.03641408309340477, 0.024294788017868996, 0.01862158440053463, 0.008478096686303616, 0.024408161640167236, -0.019943254068493843, -0.04517402872443199, 0.046486251056194305, 0.011380955576896667, -0.07273458689451218, 0.026281112805008888, -0.04022197052836418, -0.04988297447562218, 0.030230224132537842, -0.030092379078269005, -0.008034362457692623, -0.015593680553138256, -0.023661134764552116, 0.05750394985079765, 0.05017085000872612, 0.01944483257830143, 0.017444312572479248, 0.0197471771389246, -0.008096718229353428, 0.05436289682984352, 0.07477885484695435, 0.11119145154953003, 0.03853251785039902, -0.03323110193014145, -0.012950470671057701, -0.030455607920885086, 0.09709474444389343, -0.052599675953388214, -0.005330806132405996, -0.08589554578065872, -0.02546190470457077, 0.025373214855790138, 0.00011517735401866958, -0.03470557928085327, -0.017858248203992844, 0.038120076060295105, 0.0033679588232189417, -0.03281163051724434, 0.01113714836537838, -0.04514755681157112, -0.019096773117780685, -0.022638488560914993, -0.020850347355008125, -0.040679361671209335, -0.020273998379707336, 0.058713339269161224, 0.02662114053964615, 0.04106602072715759, 0.10709425806999207, 0.06508788466453552, 0.023556848987936974, -0.010979716666042805, 0.029206430539488792, -0.02239205129444599, 0.013404336757957935, -0.02780935913324356, -0.022863922640681267, -0.019385091960430145, -0.02504110522568226, -0.012720074504613876, -0.003214839845895767, -0.0372333824634552, 0.00757429376244545, 0.0201448742300272, -0.0014622412854805589, 0.020751439034938812, -0.012738971039652824, 0.02343853935599327, -0.010399417951703072, 0.04834175109863281, -0.018618449568748474, -0.06218338757753372, 0.018133267760276794, -0.027663588523864746, 0.03233691677451134, -0.04310063272714615, -0.012316416949033737, 0.03670554980635643, 0.0022786827757954597, 0.028239982202649117, 0.07491662353277206, 0.03804253414273262, -0.011845619417726994, 0.01826038956642151, -0.04229513928294182, -0.021429944783449173, -0.046488016843795776, -0.04485812410712242, 0.035728976130485535, 0.047377776354551315, -0.01983772963285446, -0.026500098407268524, -0.012180259451270103, -0.0022502129431813955, 0.020713677629828453, 0.03874044120311737, -0.040298257023096085, -0.0219226386398077, -0.09492743760347366, -0.0274578258395195, 0.024104632437229156, 0.0008369103888981044, -0.012157207354903221, -0.007949834689497948, 0.025428196415305138, 0.04664319008588791, -0.007422149647027254, -0.042628686875104904, 0.006588680204004049, -0.054901838302612305, -0.001577459741383791, -0.012732375413179398, -0.07327520847320557, 0.028069185093045235, -0.019903400912880898, -0.016503578051924706, 0.024919388815760612, -0.03690207004547119, 0.015595926903188229, -0.013542551547288895, -0.020331265404820442, -0.044929035007953644, 0.004972661379724741, -0.04638594388961792, -0.013451100327074528, 0.015772584825754166, -0.0028497898019850254, -0.001138014835305512, 0.06125740334391594, -0.0006540205795317888, -0.0005648161168210208, -0.02472100406885147, -0.01653391122817993, 0.019261879846453667, 0.0125687625259161, 0.025133997201919556, 0.012490056455135345, 0.023167399689555168, 0.01646365225315094, 0.007362394593656063, -0.01526608131825924, 0.0013580393278971314, 0.02316095121204853, -0.0052384850569069386, 0.0199825968593359, 0.004788231570273638, -0.02220727689564228, 0.0012721630046144128, -0.056273140013217926, 0.040868423879146576, -0.0067715211771428585, 0.03286172077059746, -0.0386679470539093, -0.04537587612867355, 0.01893608272075653, -0.10885757207870483, -0.03534775972366333, -0.03910335525870323, 0.07406598329544067, -0.058043476194143295, 0.0443662665784359, -0.01356161292642355, -0.04529847577214241, 0.062259551137685776, -0.013515153899788857, 0.010993322357535362, -0.021928053349256516, 0.021899085491895676, -0.03293849155306816, 0.02146577090024948, -0.02516140416264534, -0.045695025473833084, 0.02865605428814888, -0.03142005577683449, -0.08329946547746658, 0.05369124934077263, -0.02012946642935276, 0.00639552203938365, -0.02020306885242462, 0.050069745630025864, 0.004095473326742649, -0.016150422394275665, -0.02992783859372139, -0.0240681990981102, -0.06032386049628258, -0.0326358862221241, 0.0916285514831543, -0.08954449743032455, -0.03397979959845543, 0.007334036752581596, -0.029823094606399536, 0.04580741003155708, 0.012569934129714966, -0.041772566735744476, 0.028174107894301414, -0.0035940087400376797, -0.014168158173561096, -0.036835793405771255, -0.04360031336545944, -0.004235174972563982, 0.0587238147854805, 0.02647426910698414, 0.01631440781056881, -0.006444289814680815, 0.03390688821673393, 0.0008487647282890975, -0.011264129541814327, 0.045611608773469925, -0.01697845570743084, -0.041728608310222626, -0.024500900879502296, 0.00801144354045391, 0.0065013994462788105, 0.05331003665924072, -0.05041472241282463, 0.018229497596621513, -0.01171830017119646, -0.027129879221320152, 0.005361570511013269, -0.056169480085372925, 0.016671540215611458, 0.05585801228880882, 0.048606183379888535, -0.0462057888507843, 0.003010036190971732, 0.037245865911245346, -0.02803006023168564, -0.04991702362895012, 0.03955183923244476, 0.0014049343299120665, -0.02213607355952263, -0.009944370947778225, -0.011908600106835365, 0.07575681060552597, -0.01445739809423685, -0.06378549337387085, -0.031023582443594933, -0.049444228410720825, 0.04885716363787651, -0.06453248113393784, 0.06589949131011963, -0.006772846914827824, 0.012467493303120136, -0.04080071672797203, 0.0036266951356083155, -0.009441092610359192, 0.05166581645607948, 0.016823673620820045, 0.03393958881497383, -0.05492238327860832, 0.047796398401260376, -0.01344714779406786, 0.012669842690229416, 0.0250401571393013, -0.004207263700664043, -0.04563836753368378, 0.010996464639902115, -0.09792666882276535, 0.023472389206290245, 0.02026205137372017, 0.017665784806013107, -0.05714746564626694, -0.008506128564476967, 0.006411879323422909, -0.02967587672173977, -0.04183623567223549, 0.007536397315561771, 0.03188827633857727, -0.005172953009605408, 0.06450501084327698, -0.014099907130002975, 0.013699539005756378, 0.05018163099884987, 0.0020639747381210327, 0.016392042860388756, -0.012343235313892365, 0.0241988617926836, 0.03304443135857582, -0.009045204147696495, 0.09050212055444717, 0.0028762018773704767, 0.041283003985881805, -0.030929196625947952, -0.043852549046278, 0.007648180238902569, 0.00039600886520929635, 0.01998746767640114, 0.051145076751708984, -0.002187161473557353, -0.011028183624148369, 0.0168355330824852, 0.019488198682665825, -0.02010476402938366, -0.03411053866147995, 0.020878450945019722, -0.02720320224761963, 0.04841488227248192, 0.010681253857910633, 0.017176296561956406, 0.019180094823241234, -0.031476907432079315, -0.008009226061403751, -0.006404006853699684, -0.02092055045068264, -0.015884265303611755, 0.003930414095520973, 0.003591780550777912, -0.06940218061208725, 0.060981206595897675, -0.0287218876183033, -0.019359776750206947, 0.04008268192410469, 0.0018073891988024116, 0.060650527477264404, 0.03880029544234276, -0.03516606613993645, -0.020631596446037292, -0.015350916422903538, -0.011225017718970776, -0.013101146556437016, -0.0035442691296339035, -0.014532161876559258, 0.01345041859894991, 0.01881476491689682, 0.038134243339300156, 0.025199951604008675, -0.023672092705965042, 0.045459531247615814, -0.023651767522096634, -0.00007121855014702305, -0.06299351155757904, -0.03752817213535309, 0.004310848657041788, -0.033019572496414185, 0.05805361643433571, 0.03864601254463196, -0.027068806812167168, -0.002460106275975704, -0.01769263856112957, 0.03615289553999901, 0.04769956320524216, 0.02147497609257698, -0.062019046396017075, 0.014283646829426289, -0.03493703529238701, 0.01702144742012024, 0.02927873283624649, 0.03469177335500717, 0.029554355889558792, 0.006521956063807011, 0.03254866972565651, 0.02665022760629654, -0.013137352652847767, 0.05722460895776749, 0.11557356268167496, 0.07648682594299316, -0.014633780345320702, -0.0061151860281825066, 0.0018203874351456761, 0.024669591337442398, 0.0006073788972571492, 0.023091884329915047, 0.0025416959542781115, 0.007364011835306883, -0.015410174615681171, -0.005107294302433729, 0.0864998921751976, 0.06400658935308456, 0.008610866963863373, 0.09605830162763596, -0.006505097262561321, 0.009071212261915207, 0.008738300763070583, 0.0017907865112647414, 0.00830045435577631, -0.05656696483492851, -0.04607206583023071, -0.03477145731449127, -0.05236753821372986, -0.012453793548047543, 0.013741202652454376, 0.013195683248341084, -0.02642141841351986, -0.03063291124999523, -0.003176603000611067, -0.040139101445674896, 0.07091599702835083, -0.0220523439347744, 0.029518771916627884, -0.04143696278333664, -0.02282085455954075, 0.004879929590970278, -0.04902379959821701, 0.018349602818489075, -0.01248151808977127, -0.05181771144270897, 0.02233600988984108, -0.05815695598721504, -0.009599006734788418, 0.01624923199415207, -0.009401156567037106, 0.012343224138021469, -0.0007307368796318769, 0.04060416668653488, -0.034947194159030914, -0.01947285234928131, -0.0677572637796402, 0.01668095588684082, 0.01691851019859314, -0.015228575095534325, -0.026373013854026794, 0.04888298735022545, -0.013188975863158703, -0.026226337999105453, 0.024189678952097893, -0.05352741852402687, 0.03362997621297836, -0.01738903485238552, -0.10544322431087494, 0.04739353433251381, -0.021441664546728134, 0.007315889932215214, -0.049514081329107285, 0.033528562635183334, 0.024640753865242004, 0.008112961426377296, 0.027662813663482666, -0.03200514614582062, 0.023781854659318924, -0.08874036371707916, 0.045869722962379456, -0.0273367278277874, -0.02757757343351841, 0.0033475211821496487, -0.026007981970906258, 0.05784209817647934, 0.014398312196135521, -0.03988047316670418, 0.051492005586624146, -0.033317871391773224, -0.048011261969804764, -0.004338429309427738, 0.058004315942525864, 0.017156215384602547, -0.027925312519073486, -0.011335453018546104, 0.03786947950720787, 0.012220649980008602, -0.01742279902100563, -0.03897743672132492, -0.0032844922970980406, -0.0014031834434717894, -0.052928268909454346, 0.04968137666583061, 0.004155938513576984, -0.020457588136196136, 0.04252210631966591, -0.014026537537574768, -0.06385565549135208, 0.003004479920491576, 0.07774338871240616, -0.00002611678428365849, -0.0370875746011734, -0.01723311096429825, 0.019506702199578285, -0.00432149413973093, 0.0006604131194762886, -0.01720096915960312, 0.008940448984503746, -0.023074667900800705, -0.04933833330869675, 0.023073386400938034, -0.02713785134255886, 0.020587675273418427, -0.004555556923151016, -0.027107950299978256, -0.04322762042284012, -0.025967834517359734, -0.021212387830018997, 0.02820778824388981, 0.031504593789577484, 0.027257472276687622, 0.013433312997221947, -0.005285706836730242, 0.02033725008368492, -0.014949727803468704, -0.0038990105967968702, 0.005997083615511656, -0.05365275591611862, 0.04896390810608864, -0.01482510007917881, 0.02188788168132305, 0.05570755526423454, 0.028340550139546394, -0.048918716609478, 0.017671508714556694, -0.048125240951776505, -0.024208491668105125, 0.0762757807970047, 0.013789515942335129, 0.007198424078524113, -0.002001614309847355, 0.0034796148538589478, 0.03432995453476906, -0.0378924161195755, 0.0028250617906451225, -0.03669075667858124, -0.03291516378521919, 0.015377004630863667, 0.028571665287017822, -0.010632378049194813, -0.014014611020684242, -0.010161821730434895, -0.00936734490096569, 0.012218168005347252, -0.058259446173906326, -0.0056540509685873985, 0.09440161287784576, 0.020201805979013443, -0.027725620195269585, -0.03545001894235611, -0.030917569994926453, -0.031716618686914444, -0.008736902847886086, -0.04005594179034233, 0.0017745839431881905, -0.028130028396844864, -0.02337649092078209, 0.012576887384057045, 0.006752519402652979, -0.004887930117547512, 0.02984294481575489, 0.020803367719054222, 0.011405209079384804, 0.04623549059033394, 0.01603209599852562, 0.04152568057179451, 0.0663222000002861, 0.04840777814388275, -0.012814092449843884, 0.018542228266596794, -0.014220702461898327, -0.015407642349600792, 0.00048514953232370317, -0.02798202447593212, -0.031130505725741386, 0.02162572182714939, 0.0496002659201622, 0.005279058590531349, 0.047478675842285156, 0.014039725996553898, 0.05242731049656868, 0.015732016414403915, 0.008916497230529785, 0.034933216869831085, -0.016795963048934937, 0.08386988192796707, 0.021903377026319504, 0.03422199934720993, 0.004216649103909731, -0.033735308796167374, -0.05436361953616142, 0.037191182374954224, -0.012832267209887505, -0.008414453826844692, -0.06142817810177803, -0.005327524617314339, 0.016327103599905968, 0.0008650047820992768, 0.0029882427770644426, 0.0543455071747303, 0.018272092565894127, 0.03617091476917267, -0.03711611405014992, 0.060178887099027634, 0.013528968207538128, -0.02249542623758316, -0.028451308608055115, 0.05758155509829521, -0.005806336645036936, -0.01909438706934452, -0.09488195180892944, -0.005637793336063623, 0.029751786962151527, 0.07802179455757141, -0.02775193378329277, 0.025982609018683434, 0.041216034442186356, -0.05638694763183594, -0.026827776804566383, -0.03137009218335152, -0.031218411400914192, 0.008627546019852161, 0.0016359292203560472, 0.004772965330630541, 0.020252985879778862, -0.04806320369243622, -0.01710744947195053, 0.005863150116056204, 0.029112448915839195, -0.056932445615530014, -0.03877778351306915, -0.007742913439869881, -0.019768333062529564, 0.0025604753755033016, 0.0015954269329085946, 0.0753903016448021, 0.027504190802574158, -0.010936353355646133, 0.0052679660730063915, 0.04582967981696129, -0.007827101275324821, -0.00819212757050991, -0.011641968972980976, 0.04673556983470917, -0.0369100496172905, 0.01562194712460041, -0.08884099125862122, -0.034529902040958405, -0.030645251274108887, -0.008457769639790058, -0.019034352153539658, 0.02245390973985195, -0.03022271953523159, 0.020707832649350166, 0.02430340275168419, 0.023677796125411987, -0.05965583398938179, -0.01588740572333336, 0.0016523286467418075, -0.03944425284862518, -0.011740204878151417, 0.011580871418118477, 0.048165395855903625, -0.011917701922357082, 0.00884507317095995, 0.009008022956550121, -0.0044211517088115215, -0.04979867488145828, 0.0005054898792877793, -0.013588531874120235, 0.05161561816930771, 0.04332353174686432, -0.02657310478389263, 0.0035921854432672262, -0.07361336052417755, 0.036074019968509674, 0.03391395881772041, -0.011103304103016853, -0.024700963869690895, 0.0071139028295874596, -0.04496615007519722, 0.010804593563079834, -0.016567625105381012, 0.005734279286116362, 0.0487816222012043, -0.038798391819000244, 0.04128485172986984, -0.03735809028148651, 0.03481782600283623, -0.000013345563274924643, 0.01697334460914135, -0.036921724677085876, -0.01077901292592287, 0.029254380613565445, 0.03954649716615677, 0.022013584151864052, 0.05758974701166153, -0.016142265871167183, 0.01942252367734909, -0.03843157738447189, -0.0033571075182408094, -0.031613364815711975, 0.01113796979188919, -0.06413587182760239, -0.021312164142727852, 0.020052269101142883, 0.039902668446302414, -0.0534142404794693, -0.02499557100236416, -0.018191032111644745, -0.0547352135181427, 0.05979632958769798, 0.05213285610079765, -0.04646862670779228, 0.010168836452066898, 0.03861790895462036, -0.004905947484076023, -0.028357019647955894, 0.024893486872315407, -0.012533755041658878, 0.0003968157107010484, -0.028135225176811218, -0.061714306473731995, 0.021270330995321274, 0.0007412465056404471, 0.008808346465229988 ]
<p>I'm a physics tutor tutoring High School students. A question confused me a lot.</p> <p>Question is:</p> <blockquote> <p>Suppose a mass less rod length $l$ has a particle of mass $m$ attached at its end and the rod is hinged at the other end in vertical plane. Another point object of mass $m$ is moving with velocity $v$ and hits the rod at its end and continues in its path with velocity $v/2$. The rod gets enough velocity that it can complete a vertical circular path. What would be the force due to hinge on the rod just after collision? Assume that time taken for collision is very small.</p> </blockquote> <p>From conservation of momentum, the particle attached to rod gets velocity $V' = v/2$ which is equal to $2\sqrt{gl}$ and therefore $$T-mg=\frac{mv'^2}{l}$$ The tension in the rod is the Normal reaction due to hinge on the other end of the rod. Hence, the force exerted by rod is $$\frac{mv'^2}{l}+mg$$</p> <p>But other teacher claims that I'm wrong. He says there will be horizontal force due to hinge on the rod. I say, there won't be any horizontal force. He gives an example that suppose there is a rod and you flick it at one end with finger then won't the other end move (or tend to move)? Well it does.</p> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong></p> <p>I've understood your answers mathematically.I still don't know how to counter my friend's argument. I'm convinced by it. Because it sounds intuitive. He says, suppose you have a rod (massless or with mass) in space, and you flicked at one of its end, then the other end surely will have velocity.Similarly, in the above problem, the collision will impart velocity to one end, so other end also must move but it is hinged and can't move because of hinge. So, there is a horizontal force due to hinge on the rod. </p>
g7475
[ 0.11064405739307404, 0.03638170659542084, 0.002916969358921051, -0.0007726215990260243, 0.031982358545064926, 0.020058294758200645, 0.08232956379652023, 0.04156417399644852, -0.0440753810107708, -0.03956027328968048, 0.008835311979055405, 0.014917674474418163, -0.034869350492954254, -0.0012353606289252639, 0.04727645218372345, 0.044623855501413345, 0.10571103543043137, -0.025304537266492844, 0.02069615200161934, 0.09863695502281189, -0.06730909645557404, 0.0008411192684434354, -0.08464515209197998, -0.02175254561007023, 0.011540482752025127, -0.01795850694179535, 0.029555566608905792, -0.029284663498401642, -0.012355937622487545, -0.017312726005911827, 0.016200248152017593, -0.03273643180727959, 0.006933864206075668, -0.10941094905138016, -0.04027242213487625, -0.047887012362480164, 0.07145620882511139, -0.03248101845383644, 0.015097075141966343, -0.037905119359493256, 0.045923519879579544, -0.008295368403196335, 0.0038729419466108084, -0.033979807049036026, 0.043924786150455475, 0.02286972478032112, -0.01597760245203972, -0.03613923117518425, -0.020425323396921158, -0.0179813914000988, -0.016814731061458588, -0.022757600992918015, 0.008208164945244789, -0.028919342905282974, 0.014791343361139297, 0.050421323627233505, 0.04787059128284454, 0.003969887737184763, 0.027080072090029716, 0.0355469286441803, -0.014739695005118847, 0.024553563445806503, -0.0245036818087101, 0.018322022631764412, 0.04527120292186737, -0.0712985098361969, -0.08325892686843872, -0.016568318009376526, 0.059872858226299286, -0.01220523752272129, 0.0023678401485085487, -0.05017205327749252, 0.00742344930768013, -0.06252138316631317, -0.05790136381983757, -0.024478863924741745, 0.0008917309460230172, -0.016746556386351585, -0.011809001676738262, -0.037731897085905075, -0.06583376228809357, -0.002527878386899829, 0.006438957527279854, 0.0337570384144783, 0.0604056678712368, -0.014462004415690899, -0.034203607589006424, 0.036224037408828735, -0.019604302942752838, -0.012674800120294094, 0.025416024029254913, -0.06805907934904099, 0.06352563947439194, 0.027378929778933525, -0.02828223630785942, -0.01614616997539997, -0.008695865981280804, 0.07128842175006866, 0.060510117560625076, -0.05762261152267456, -0.02687971107661724, -0.08161328732967377, -0.031434666365385056, 0.008253096602857113, 0.0578448586165905, -0.028734629973769188, 0.036629870533943176, 0.051369138062000275, -0.005357518792152405, -0.02162405103445053, -0.03592151775956154, -0.043031033128499985, -0.044144608080387115, -0.05616699159145355, 0.004752623848617077, -0.02774433232843876, 0.1160259023308754, 0.015529445372521877, 0.001857006805948913, 0.03629091754555702, -0.015746470540761948, -0.005050403531640768, -0.00710261007770896, 0.08721623569726944, -0.020014196634292603, -0.0512409582734108, 0.01590609736740589, 0.04587634280323982, 0.0017400901997461915, -0.014473069459199905, -0.035326674580574036, -0.032181669026613235, 0.036404021084308624, 0.016158640384674072, 0.026232749223709106, 0.053330011665821075, 0.024703389033675194, -0.0025321810971945524, 0.05326465144753456, 0.000848219555336982, -0.024104483425617218, 0.015249253250658512, -0.023264361545443535, -0.00441304687410593, -0.05184117332100868, 0.0628451332449913, -0.0013040101621299982, 0.003666816046461463, -0.022256478667259216, -0.0007463201181963086, 0.0133218290284276, 0.038971416652202606, -0.016003238037228584, -0.008994807489216328, 0.03305697441101074, 0.009049669839441776, 0.07195446640253067, 0.0068076178431510925, -0.01931106112897396, 0.026569806039333344, 0.0038352105766534805, -0.056731950491666794, -0.006426333449780941, -0.030117733404040337, -0.07414533197879791, 0.022250909358263016, 0.0036901955027133226, -0.05348648130893707, -0.02147763967514038, -0.04122799634933472, -0.07818242162466049, -0.022351620718836784, 0.05021221190690994, 0.05660282075405121, 0.01380747277289629, -0.01066055428236723, -0.021127954125404358, -0.06007719412446022, 0.004948468878865242, -0.023679189383983612, 0.007351525127887726, -0.03814037889242172, 0.09245123714208603, 0.02684551291167736, 0.0133511358872056, 0.057101041078567505, 0.04593632370233536, 0.04201439023017883, -0.011865041218698025, -0.009648262523114681, -0.06308724731206894, -0.03350909799337387, -0.020509209483861923, 0.035980477929115295, -0.04172451049089432, -0.002267716685310006, 0.01814665086567402, -0.018926430493593216, -0.06175295263528824, 0.0244507547467947, -0.021588027477264404, 0.04974205791950226, 0.036119379103183746, 0.024711143225431442, 0.004343579988926649, -0.0074894907884299755, 0.012543389573693275, -0.0069262306205928326, 0.035878609865903854, 0.009674636647105217, 0.024281518533825874, 0.023061931133270264, -0.03332751244306564, 0.04830784723162651, 0.0038650017231702805, -0.06469722092151642, -0.004068635404109955, 0.03826682269573212, -0.013414895161986351, -0.0441882498562336, -0.007112911902368069, -0.031930625438690186, 0.03062678687274456, -0.035006336867809296, -0.002768033416941762, -0.013981794938445091, -0.011559633538126945, -0.04162090644240379, 0.014703621156513691, 0.024231139570474625, -0.0008899062522687018, 0.005557784345000982, -0.011166923679411411, -0.02171291783452034, 0.07176119089126587, 0.04028582572937012, 0.027968721464276314, 0.02092597261071205, -0.000498525274451822, -0.008407307788729668, 0.07152760028839111, -0.030976194888353348, -0.009415515698492527, -0.07893236726522446, 0.019222715869545937, -0.0397351011633873, 0.019429562613368034, -0.011491833254694939, 0.019963454455137253, 0.04326755180954933, 0.02954717166721821, 0.008824645541608334, 0.011511323973536491, 0.03566848114132881, 0.06972792744636536, 0.0008837619097903371, -0.04376166686415672, 0.009373079054057598, -0.02708551101386547, -0.08850593864917755, -0.005357610527426004, -0.03794930502772331, -0.011168655008077621, 0.029412640258669853, -0.08512262254953384, -0.011473801918327808, -0.017576342448592186, -0.010045265778899193, 0.029070407152175903, 0.032245516777038574, -0.05140526965260506, -0.010181906633079052, -0.0161624513566494, 0.02285773679614067, -0.017222927883267403, -0.03613552823662758, 0.024512337520718575, 0.013701471500098705, 0.02377145178616047, 0.0038044189568609, 0.0015162167837843299, 0.08233842253684998, -0.023567715659737587, 0.023437654599547386, 0.06463133543729782, 0.02492288127541542, -0.02629551850259304, 0.014794123359024525, -0.0661301538348198, -0.00002735856469371356, -0.05031699314713478, 0.008951978757977486, 0.05552922189235687, -0.015879197046160698, 0.015691600739955902, 0.04201582819223404, -0.02441168949007988, -0.02680453658103943, -0.06360843032598495, -0.031051166355609894, -0.04445473104715347, 0.013199642300605774, -0.011241689324378967, 0.035144057124853134, 0.016236480325460434, 0.0035911540035158396, -0.04586262255907059, -0.08012080937623978, 0.007426591124385595, 0.010128877125680447, -0.031369470059871674, 0.06637685745954514, 0.005076931323856115, 0.02886015921831131, -0.054045092314481735, -0.02380453050136566, 0.03208712488412857, 0.02932962030172348, -0.06352023035287857, 0.05217406526207924, -0.02389977127313614, -0.037899699062108994, 0.03206617757678032, -0.003022911725565791, 0.022090554237365723, 0.007633165922015905, -0.06421986222267151, -0.0000512822916789446, -0.025155924260616302, -0.0030764939729124308, 0.015494621358811855, 0.04715535417199135, 0.0022894665598869324, -0.016923362389206886, -0.0006434879032894969, -0.018432369455695152, -0.0020656208507716656, 0.012950192205607891, 0.06722443550825119, 0.06505876779556274, -0.0076150004751980305, -0.0125204436480999, -0.016779517754912376, 0.009053758345544338, -0.005058285780251026, 0.03404693305492401, 0.0469001829624176, 0.03594918176531792, 0.0017820020439103246, 0.007079331204295158, 0.03467099741101265, 0.0013126864796504378, 0.0030648168176412582, -0.029479077085852623, -0.0013878534082323313, 0.08050568401813507, -0.03459520637989044, 0.01802775077521801, -0.019771989434957504, -0.019666187465190887, 0.03255228325724602, -0.002222175942733884, 0.008895532228052616, 0.02080017514526844, -0.012289744801819324, 0.013961448334157467, -0.024711551144719124, 0.012431898154318333, -0.010088632814586163, -0.03220692276954651, 0.039025310426950455, -0.07768251746892929, -0.030763300135731697, 0.04532119631767273, 0.026066230610013008, -0.03958946838974953, 0.09930773079395294, -0.023720650002360344, 0.013065449893474579, 0.025861000642180443, 0.018988609313964844, 0.05314042419195175, -0.020335635170340538, 0.022786755114793777, 0.005920563358813524, 0.03311826288700104, -0.025716446340084076, 0.05085773766040802, 0.026909319683909416, -0.0015650903806090355, 0.021580388769507408, -0.030871551483869553, -0.04454925283789635, 0.029248949140310287, 0.024962328374385834, -0.018999863415956497, 0.1017565131187439, -0.005807563662528992, 0.013276868499815464, -0.03947455808520317, -0.0006654230528511107, 0.0041854060254991055, -0.0027253790758550167, -0.039675794541835785, -0.08247774094343185, 0.06638612598180771, 0.01263056043535471, -0.04379786178469658, 0.0012293417239561677, -0.06369272619485855, 0.011903786100447178, -0.0026251738891005516, -0.05572786554694176, -0.025492912158370018, 0.0058500259183347225, -0.010520482435822487, 0.01119594369083643, 0.061432745307683945, -0.011832239106297493, -0.019764842465519905, 0.008125574328005314, 0.047399893403053284, 0.01163577102124691, -0.0069499267265200615, -0.005950083024799824, 0.10003232955932617, 0.03796848654747009, 0.04326247051358223, -0.007174578495323658, -0.06287551671266556, 0.023900335654616356, 0.0280716884881258, -0.04643440619111061, -0.027838490903377533, -0.016841785982251167, 0.053949739784002304, 0.011528330855071545, -0.025104351341724396, 0.02062474936246872, 0.05437920615077019, 0.025271499529480934, 0.006748352665454149, -0.015086658298969269, 0.016006428748369217, -0.029728863388299942, 0.045812591910362244, 0.007520168088376522, -0.04764875769615173, 0.002282641129568219, -0.026187961921095848, -0.043157484382390976, -0.0012946049682796001, -0.006701898295432329, -0.015129903331398964, 0.033105313777923584, -0.023834213614463806, -0.047857288271188736, 0.0015232597943395376, -0.03171955794095993, -0.060476623475551605, -0.05978797376155853, 0.02024376206099987, 0.047406021505594254, -0.02486221119761467, 0.044152721762657166, -0.02358381822705269, -0.005522354505956173, -0.030923057347536087, -0.0011683282209560275, 0.032483648508787155, -0.01652897335588932, 0.005174350459128618, 0.010990296490490437, -0.03534570708870888, -0.027061311528086662, 0.004614656325429678, 0.015623798593878746, 0.03823832422494888, 0.03970690071582794, -0.020227499306201935, 0.0004747389757540077, 0.048896510154008865, -0.053238335996866226, -0.0146628487855196, 0.04656904190778732, -0.0737123042345047, 0.002492183120921254, 0.021694589406251907, 0.025359995663166046, -0.04651850461959839, -0.026809222996234894, -0.023393044248223305, -0.07587042450904846, -0.017585380002856255, -0.01216805912554264, -0.009503565728664398, 0.01157528068870306, 0.00009955949644790962, -0.023196393623948097, -0.0014513321220874786, -0.05798891931772232, -0.03744911029934883, -0.00482139503583312, 0.016121605411171913, -0.02964397706091404, 0.0643538236618042, -0.011901079677045345, 0.004728961735963821, -0.0181846022605896, 0.048931531608104706, -0.005430061370134354, -0.00195131276268512, 0.005951974540948868, 0.008356583304703236, -0.002761625684797764, -0.009349419735372066, 0.007575878873467445, 0.0007617989322170615, -0.013111112639307976, 0.015377607196569443, 0.046143628656864166, 0.007427639327943325, 0.011249099858105183, 0.0005685186479240656, 0.016008945181965828, -0.013989790342748165, -0.015286262147128582, 0.002968067303299904, -0.06639818102121353, 0.07950939983129501, 0.0035158467944711447, -0.05480669066309929, 0.009807485155761242, 0.048991475254297256, -0.051935531198978424, -0.03207880258560181, -0.03908688575029373, -0.02851608209311962, 0.03786933049559593, -0.004496780224144459, -0.014713208191096783, -0.008575089275836945, 0.07053118199110031, 0.07476944476366043, -0.06348025053739548, 0.03953404724597931, -0.047324009239673615, -0.057664744555950165, -0.0011117489775642753, -0.0063693830743432045, -0.06545946002006531, 0.06250586360692978, -0.024680189788341522, 0.039821699261665344, 0.003894515335559845, 0.017169678583741188, 0.013670546002686024, -0.0015277983620762825, 0.061170633882284164, -0.021711258217692375, 0.05796070396900177, -0.026948707178235054, 0.03205707669258118, 0.0035920250229537487, 0.046839263290166855, -0.04573812335729599, -0.020106671378016472, 0.0006605077651329339, 0.05534612759947777, -0.006338655948638916, 0.018086018040776253, -0.0039771487936377525, -0.03716789931058884, 0.05192817002534866, 0.056116338819265366, 0.03937803953886032, -0.03782258927822113, -0.009759216569364071, -0.05772755667567253, 0.050224289298057556, -0.006508188787847757, -0.024020224809646606, 0.006730353459715843, -0.033322107046842575, -0.0032254888210445642, 0.008152250200510025, -0.021065808832645416, -0.051065076142549515, 0.019750813022255898, 0.004119729157537222, -0.04515034332871437, -0.010921048000454903, -0.0575895756483078, 0.04983622580766678, -0.02848428301513195, 0.014336837455630302, 0.03352120518684387, 0.004413875285536051, 0.020329231396317482, 0.061963196843862534, 0.04804561659693718, 0.032841119915246964, 0.01587803289294243, -0.04425302520394325, 0.004122387617826462, 0.060342151671648026, -0.05102056637406349, 0.02929185889661312, 0.030799033120274544, 0.0038290591910481453, 0.007775759790092707, 0.022992029786109924, 0.02789309062063694, 0.005167994648218155, -0.003926071338355541, -0.050622399896383286, 0.016697203740477562, -0.040396686643362045, -0.010463972575962543, -0.02410244569182396, -0.03193925321102142, 0.008534369058907032, 0.025130080059170723, -0.05198834091424942, 0.054688647389411926, -0.030060188844799995, -0.05430883914232254, -0.025531604886054993, 0.049115389585494995, -0.006319449748843908, 0.030675582587718964, -0.0379730761051178, -0.020470820367336273, 0.007134126964956522, -0.015836089849472046, 0.0448366142809391, 0.003673466620966792, 0.03382054716348648, 0.031187571585178375, 0.03757544606924057, 0.03316008672118187, -0.025808196514844894, -0.034753330051898956, 0.02250736765563488, -0.07459035515785217, -0.06734700500965118, 0.025607531890273094, -0.00450023403391242, -0.060047443956136703, -0.028554031625390053, -0.02193126268684864, 0.05072690546512604, -0.050835445523262024, 0.019643502309918404, -0.041984062641859055, -0.007703689858317375, -0.042621251195669174, -0.0013097876217216253, 0.01874343864619732, 0.016406768932938576, -0.08296838402748108, 0.014391668140888214, 0.05270317569375038, 0.024735692888498306, -0.01706027239561081, 0.0319361612200737, -0.04370499402284622, -0.02643502503633499, -0.013981431722640991, -0.0011893961345776916, 0.030155276879668236, -0.06648850440979004, -0.04188457131385803, 0.044430214911699295, 0.010645611211657524, 0.05631942301988602, 0.02668340876698494, -0.028733771294355392, -0.04054209217429161, -0.021003350615501404, 0.011204556562006474, 0.013937562704086304, -0.015489686280488968, 0.0046153683215379715, -0.034436147660017014, -0.017704613506793976, 0.008228646591305733, 0.009169227443635464, 0.013772597536444664, -0.00017233182734344155, -0.013878935016691685, 0.046177200973033905, 0.04872797057032585, -0.02065921574831009, 0.0013967338018119335, -0.01833995245397091, 0.04591650143265724, 0.015112127177417278, -0.033755164593458176, 0.010127963498234749, -0.030965249985456467, -0.03347241133451462, -0.012846183031797409, 0.01779252663254738, 0.031289242208004, 0.0626489594578743, -0.004036032594740391, 0.010614247992634773, -0.015916116535663605, 0.01805928722023964, 0.03450998291373253, 0.062241293489933014, -0.004130368586629629, 0.012984377332031727, 0.0038414509035646915, 0.00033268335391767323, 0.015913186594843864, 0.038745246827602386, 0.06850282102823257, -0.003985876217484474, -0.04503512755036354, -0.003921625204384327, -0.03244243934750557, -0.08439383655786514, -0.07909099757671356, -0.02101440727710724, 0.02532302588224411, -0.013425794430077076, -0.023878537118434906, 0.03826700150966644, 0.018496261909604073, -0.028439275920391083, 0.003955894615501165, -0.02486277185380459, 0.006743591278791428, -0.004699436016380787, -0.0012446673354133964, 0.014500820077955723, -0.0005535977543331683, 0.031206350773572922, 0.017989743500947952, -0.026712670922279358, -0.04996374621987343, -0.02132858894765377, 0.01975066401064396, -0.041200872510671616, 0.03862704709172249, 0.04329807311296463, 0.025237558409571648, 0.017700016498565674, 0.014328785240650177, 0.01962422765791416, -0.0035607663448899984, 0.017198828980326653, 0.017409339547157288, -0.020628130063414574, -0.03651197999715805, -0.0007896973402239382, -0.04456628859043121, -0.019062723964452744, -0.009836850687861443, 0.021550169214606285, 0.035689424723386765, -0.09540574252605438, -0.016097143292427063, 0.0068528554402291775, -0.020238645374774933, 0.036651238799095154 ]
<p>I am a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geographic_information_system" rel="nofollow">GIS</a> programmer implementing a visualization.</p> <p>I am modeling the idealized trajectory of a particle ejected from a volcanic vent using:</p> <p>$$\text{distance} = \frac{(v^2 \times sin(2\theta))}{g}.$$</p> <p>Where $g = 1.62\:\mathrm{m/s^2}$, $v$ is velocity, and $\theta$ is ejection angle. $g$ is the lunar gravity constant I was supplied.</p> <p>How can I incorporate the slope of the underlying surface assuming a single point of ejection? $$$$$$$$</p> <p>EDIT: My current workflow is to compute total travel distance, extract a topographic profile along the total theoretical travel distance and then check the height of the projectile to the height of the actual surface at 100m intervals. In this way I can compute the landing site for the projectile.</p> <p>EDIT 2: I updated the question with the correct formula. Apologies for the incorrect transposition. My implementation now assumes a completely flat surface. What happens when the ejection surface is sloped either uphill or downhill?</p>
g7476
[ 0.05392226576805115, 0.002635721582919359, -0.011262800544500351, -0.0029448075219988823, 0.042375966906547546, 0.025946810841560364, 0.011582511477172375, -0.011569874361157417, -0.07160665839910507, -0.014243612997233868, -0.027185462415218353, 0.04351042956113815, 0.10841556638479233, 0.021828668192029, -0.031195053830742836, 0.009782187640666962, 0.05078112706542015, -0.03348496928811073, 0.03642691299319267, 0.003842455567792058, 0.013968359678983688, -0.03098008781671524, 0.04470677301287651, -0.00814385898411274, 0.012335703708231449, -0.05337929353117943, 0.08064711838960648, 0.05175553262233734, -0.03906631097197533, 0.06838174909353256, -0.032641757279634476, -0.010710014961659908, 0.02689894288778305, 0.035309311002492905, -0.06630625575780869, 0.02627011016011238, -0.015893518924713135, -0.005505056120455265, -0.022113962098956108, -0.052297770977020264, 0.017987016588449478, -0.039734333753585815, 0.0018802742706611753, 0.032716426998376846, 0.018926549702882767, -0.03357688710093498, -0.03546972572803497, -0.02183576673269272, -0.011475740931928158, 0.004718939308077097, -0.05496707186102867, 0.031190168112516403, -0.08878765255212784, -0.05835746228694916, -0.06126894801855087, 0.025918634608387947, 0.032278355211019516, -0.04427829384803772, 0.04107218235731125, 0.045713160187006, -0.003085486125200987, -0.057653069496154785, -0.002431199885904789, -0.010890196077525616, 0.08711359649896622, 0.020697209984064102, -0.0836467295885086, 0.035265158861875534, -0.02393755316734314, 0.023157935589551926, -0.008497518487274647, -0.008886462077498436, 0.02323387749493122, -0.06244916096329689, -0.10221656411886215, 0.00406865356490016, 0.058140408247709274, -0.03007497452199459, 0.024621153250336647, -0.014728980138897896, -0.018796896561980247, 0.05869276821613312, 0.048704102635383606, -0.07992421835660934, 0.01950710639357567, 0.004672944080084562, 0.03911314159631729, 0.028909020125865936, -0.028580641373991966, -0.04893457889556885, -0.05638979747891426, 0.010023805312812328, -0.0027743657119572163, 0.05995184928178787, -0.014284196309745312, -0.07223912328481674, -0.02414488047361374, 0.040379904210567474, -0.005302495323121548, -0.023376181721687317, -0.02134525775909424, -0.009876564145088196, -0.027374207973480225, 0.018699415028095245, 0.04238099604845047, -0.0520893856883049, 0.08251145482063293, 0.037054188549518585, 0.09375961869955063, -0.04049575328826904, 0.03416496887803078, -0.07243797183036804, -0.0231789518147707, -0.069542795419693, -0.0021002681460231543, -0.025354523211717606, 0.01788323186337948, 0.030908063054084778, -0.021420424804091454, 0.06159356236457825, 0.04023103788495064, -0.0028549206908792257, -0.04366070404648781, -0.004547294229269028, -0.030800603330135345, -0.04039270058274269, -0.05599423125386238, -0.043859194964170456, -0.0010538637870922685, 0.008444094099104404, -0.04327045753598213, -0.0060090371407568455, 0.011884989216923714, 0.03790458291769028, 0.022039243951439857, -0.007785155903548002, 0.00850084237754345, 0.030518919229507446, -0.026884837076067924, 0.008449167013168335, 0.005411257967352867, -0.019213397055864334, -0.024318544194102287, 0.026964860036969185, -0.05700354278087616, -0.016656601801514626, -0.0035310126841068268, 0.009295972064137459, 0.02695632353425026, -0.05497165769338608, -0.012381237000226974, 0.078425332903862, 0.009079174138605595, -0.00017601839499548078, 0.040961530059576035, -0.010579540394246578, 0.006177866365760565, 0.032894380390644073, 0.004246924072504044, -0.03361352160573006, 0.0453801229596138, -0.01691552624106407, 0.019416049122810364, 0.003904889337718487, -0.05115986987948418, 0.0016498849727213383, -0.012057548388838768, -0.07448551058769226, -0.04185374081134796, -0.018658576533198357, 0.00787649117410183, 0.034192945808172226, 0.037332721054553986, -0.000604194647166878, 0.03273628652095795, -0.0400661900639534, 0.0035091920290142298, -0.01770305261015892, -0.01993105374276638, 0.02147168293595314, 0.038267992436885834, -0.03541778400540352, 0.0006548610399477184, 0.03016681596636772, 0.027546711266040802, -0.030891235917806625, 0.02362862601876259, -0.006421336438506842, 0.0009018704877234995, 0.016208119690418243, 0.028622940182685852, 0.010263391770422459, -0.0026698790024966, 0.009018927812576294, -0.02134447731077671, -0.03766057267785072, 0.07785342633724213, -0.07335278391838074, -0.05506068468093872, 0.056389521807432175, 0.002611150499433279, 0.041655540466308594, 0.022488072514533997, 0.015273568220436573, -0.04622281342744827, 0.017789656296372414, 0.02704249694943428, 0.00940353237092495, -0.04941355064511299, 0.01882949285209179, -0.0461428239941597, -0.019367855042219162, 0.04443936422467232, 0.04266301542520523, 0.0342865027487278, -0.0005965842865407467, -0.017588067799806595, 0.015025458298623562, 0.007547880057245493, -0.02752949297428131, -0.023713063448667526, -0.002972023095935583, 0.024420052766799927, -0.020878108218312263, -0.00223251199349761, 0.023355642333626747, 0.009740153327584267, 0.019920239225029945, 0.035825684666633606, -0.02812875434756279, -0.03256608545780182, 0.030093956738710403, -0.02860313653945923, -0.07100219279527664, 0.08832541853189468, 0.021509217098355293, -0.02304271049797535, 0.028282923623919487, 0.004716916475445032, -0.01178999524563551, -0.001964335097000003, -0.10000824928283691, -0.0016490406123921275, -0.052399665117263794, 0.015500949695706367, -0.0652591809630394, 0.019845135509967804, 0.059158116579055786, -0.006406267173588276, 0.02769322693347931, -0.0459134504199028, 0.004408564418554306, -0.05344832316040993, 0.023298079147934914, -0.004330805968493223, -0.04109744355082512, -0.05080704018473625, -0.013813386671245098, -0.01934172213077545, -0.006383939180523157, -0.06290484219789505, -0.05478854477405548, -0.004933936987072229, 0.019234327599406242, -0.027919363230466843, 0.04417862370610237, 0.005682665854692459, 0.006302759051322937, -0.011946136131882668, 0.002986814361065626, 0.030834440141916275, 0.005780225154012442, 0.04043341800570488, 0.09179407358169556, -0.025804854929447174, 0.026072923094034195, 0.03158045560121536, 0.020889928564429283, 0.026576342061161995, 0.0275989081710577, -0.004705635365098715, -0.07199053466320038, -0.015091000124812126, 0.039235834032297134, -0.010033541359007359, -0.07520503550767899, 0.05986388027667999, 0.057566046714782715, -0.026794012635946274, -0.007808692753314972, -0.04511483758687973, -0.07207437604665756, 0.00806609820574522, 0.013433301821351051, -0.0011596801923587918, 0.06066969037055969, 0.03562077879905701, -0.0057166279293596745, 0.08040477335453033, -0.0047128587029874325, 0.008247473277151585, -0.009788659401237965, -0.019854452461004257, -0.011467387899756432, -0.05917523428797722, 0.022346559911966324, 0.036845508962869644, -0.06404971331357956, -0.020897017791867256, -0.034360531717538834, -0.03582555428147316, 0.05892425775527954, -0.00940138753503561, -0.006714401766657829, -0.009691614657640457, -0.03215625509619713, 0.009477154351770878, 0.012092695571482182, -0.048220571130514145, 0.08728226274251938, -0.04327009990811348, -0.0633358582854271, -0.006679138634353876, 0.04433433711528778, -0.009713474661111832, 0.015354844741523266, -0.028742125257849693, 0.062126580625772476, -0.021162251010537148, -0.018988527357578278, 0.053477272391319275, 0.06649923324584961, -0.013699925504624844, -0.05538884177803993, 0.09082085639238358, -0.0052034370601177216, 0.03436485305428505, 0.021281935274600983, 0.04280644282698631, 0.03895197808742523, -0.07171855121850967, -0.01659681275486946, -0.03781008720397949, -0.00994042493402958, 0.06062314286828041, -0.015519185923039913, -0.0007769029471091926, 0.06462912261486053, -0.005256356671452522, -0.035126760601997375, 0.045887649059295654, -0.011959304101765156, 0.030166925862431526, 0.003558873664587736, 0.03243974596261978, 0.05144098773598671, 0.027601709589362144, -0.004536637105047703, 0.00827413983643055, 0.007878689095377922, 0.030007988214492798, 0.007091224193572998, -0.03998108208179474, 0.00469578243792057, 0.012531541287899017, -0.005465294234454632, -0.003929350059479475, 0.0430825911462307, -0.005492404568940401, -0.00013298372505232692, 0.017175015062093735, -0.037128373980522156, 0.0010869753314182162, -0.005295520182698965, -0.017930297181010246, 0.02358761988580227, 0.011023638769984245, 0.020975163206458092, -0.04311193525791168, 0.026065688580274582, 0.03865326941013336, 0.010741055943071842, 0.030627207830548286, -0.01699177175760269, -0.0007299353019334376, 0.029869653284549713, -0.05125634744763374, 0.006826275028288364, 0.10089294612407684, -0.02591860666871071, -0.015766693279147148, -0.0876082107424736, -0.01364885363727808, 0.0020026538986712694, 0.017197242006659508, -0.009621618315577507, -0.0007448670221492648, 0.04334062710404396, 0.0012562685878947377, 0.03459465876221657, 0.02308678813278675, 0.0392891988158226, 0.026677507907152176, 0.009944175370037556, -0.049582209438085556, -0.034206803888082504, 0.07299227267503738, -0.0053658741526305676, -0.009010925889015198, 0.0280771404504776, 0.017445862293243408, -0.0348970852792263, 0.0021352109033614397, 0.008841198869049549, 0.034026775509119034, -0.019158562645316124, 0.009802007116377354, 0.03341974690556526, -0.009486190043389797, -0.036321621388196945, -0.0010924683883786201, 0.051194071769714355, 0.054889265447854996, -0.047247834503650665, 0.046739816665649414, 0.014413544908165932, 0.019938765093684196, 0.009836910292506218, 0.018085679039359093, 0.041565146297216415, -0.03795262798666954, 0.05441925674676895, -0.0053691864013671875, 0.011899401433765888, -0.04389524459838867, 0.07848741859197617, -0.02719958871603012, 0.016717562451958656, 0.0016371861565858126, -0.018373139202594757, -0.0478496253490448, -0.02778090536594391, 0.011308398097753525, 0.01772197335958481, -0.012091325595974922, 0.04527588561177254, -0.0346154160797596, -0.04311995953321457, -0.023834919556975365, -0.009202496148645878, 0.0018956951098516583, -0.003971420228481293, -0.021611275151371956, -0.0005409716977737844, -0.01888062246143818, -0.029446471482515335, -0.01914929784834385, -0.004338088445365429, 0.009866575710475445, -0.026170287281274796, 0.04320434108376503, -0.0069218832068145275, -0.0192754864692688, -0.006710391957312822, -0.02788267843425274, -0.04602768272161484, -0.06683126091957092, -0.017883572727441788, 0.0362577848136425, -0.01792239025235176, -0.042642440646886826, 0.022255828604102135, 0.0501914843916893, 0.006660438608378172, -0.0017410953296348453, 0.010066799819469452, 0.007281281054019928, 0.010533090680837631, 0.025697041302919388, -0.050149645656347275, -0.018495846539735794, -0.061176083981990814, 0.00040311634074896574, -0.005472124088555574, -0.04803844541311264, 0.016591215506196022, -0.04540266841650009, -0.07334759086370468, 0.008435758762061596, 0.0493684820830822, 0.02996477112174034, -0.05868120864033699, 0.006877986714243889, 0.0020447031129151583, -0.034632183611392975, -0.04664681479334831, 0.0017048651352524757, 0.028943005949258804, 0.01923574134707451, -0.012220943346619606, -0.023579522967338562, -0.04391750320792198, -0.019599614664912224, 0.06917723268270493, -0.005209050606936216, 0.03036651387810707, 0.05572833493351936, 0.010586374439299107, 0.04209810495376587, 0.008389568887650967, 0.06492841988801956, -0.002846174407750368, -0.013204364106059074, -0.0041097793728113174, 0.01007409393787384, -0.027153240516781807, 0.010537337511777878, 0.07632740586996078, -0.04812204837799072, -0.0020713103003799915, 0.047365281730890274, -0.015977226197719574, 0.0008228430524468422, 0.035362374037504196, 0.06780152022838593, -0.01401565782725811, -0.07403486222028732, -0.035893797874450684, 0.02333284355700016, -0.009304897859692574, 0.002032641088590026, -0.03662766516208649, -0.07151466608047485, 0.05644689500331879, -0.04365946352481842, -0.023675259202718735, 0.030961889773607254, 0.020240316167473793, 0.053312476724386215, -0.08299726247787476, -0.07377469539642334, -0.05524919554591179, -0.008079759776592255, 0.0808643326163292, 0.004105020314455032, 0.020965585485100746, -0.019426904618740082, 0.039042968302965164, 0.04635185748338699, -0.06039891764521599, -0.022654900327324867, 0.048185743391513824, 0.05273105204105377, 0.032610934227705, -0.005232941824942827, 0.025182407349348068, -0.015689291059970856, 0.03677855804562569, -0.005288301035761833, -0.04012948274612427, 0.010969799943268299, -0.023021839559078217, -0.008594798855483532, 0.02385079860687256, 0.006002898793667555, -0.039897371083498, 0.01714480109512806, -0.014842510223388672, 0.03137681260704994, -0.040609173476696014, 0.020395610481500626, -0.054719749838113785, -0.016673022881150246, 0.03503067418932915, 0.009751101024448872, -0.002673145616427064, -0.0025923086795955896, -0.029632436111569405, -0.004342034459114075, 0.012301969341933727, -0.012154036201536655, -0.014019647613167763, 0.02647971734404564, 0.01115269772708416, -0.03300907835364342, 0.0026049038860946894, -0.08934979885816574, -0.01236016396433115, 0.006996357347816229, -0.03110014833509922, -0.0008981343708001077, -0.005529314745217562, -0.011603567749261856, 0.005372704938054085, -0.07006767392158508, -0.018535805866122246, 0.011067311279475689, 0.04148484393954277, -0.01132415235042572, -0.012992024421691895, 0.057494331151247025, 0.0317351259291172, 0.030640950426459312, 0.010341731831431389, 0.010336335748434067, 0.011478138156235218, -0.042993344366550446, 0.011511402204632759, 0.021072346717119217, -0.09984526038169861, 0.0279996357858181, 0.07686860859394073, 0.011991697363555431, 0.022695643827319145, -0.01938691921532154, 0.024239556863904, -0.03709641098976135, 0.005376548506319523, -0.03922414034605026, -0.047826364636421204, 0.05763724446296692, -0.012134312652051449, -0.015623779967427254, 0.008685113862156868, -0.009489438496530056, -0.04597995802760124, 0.032754119485616684, 0.07672115415334702, 0.05345190688967705, 0.01320637110620737, 0.03375821188092232, 0.040036093443632126, 0.0014523256104439497, -0.03978922590613365, -0.013070162385702133, 0.04804942011833191, -0.026932209730148315, 0.025602079927921295, 0.009746724739670753, 0.02647022344172001, -0.002649735426530242, 0.004989472217857838, -0.006092439871281385, 0.04225946590304375, -0.055663060396909714, 0.016585957258939743, -0.058516550809144974, -0.0017754121217876673, -0.033930350095033646, 0.012969998642802238, 0.06276736408472061, -0.04570398107171059, -0.03774763643741608, 0.029835496097803116, 0.040475063025951385, 0.018907492980360985, -0.01573760062456131, 0.005849956069141626, 0.027505753561854362, -0.020801225677132607, 0.0005719073233194649, -0.04720483720302582, -0.02446959726512432, -0.03940575197339058, 0.02661730907857418, -0.0028681685216724873, -0.017687024548649788, -0.053812187165021896, 0.013321258127689362, -0.058732446283102036, -0.006418392527848482, -0.013457409106194973, -0.027817165479063988, 0.05511823669075966, -0.026206456124782562, -0.03137446194887161, -0.025778600946068764, 0.03711302950978279, -0.01485388446599245, 0.0423862598836422, 0.02922683209180832, 0.04759351909160614, 0.005251599475741386, -0.014603277668356895, 0.00911878515034914, -0.022324642166495323, -0.008809232152998447, 0.020588424056768417, -0.05320952832698822, -0.016619719564914703, -0.028992675244808197, -0.035524796694517136, 0.005542353261262178, 0.004350222181528807, 0.07027537375688553, 0.008973282761871815, 0.013101290911436081, -0.008970861323177814, 0.05239615589380264, 0.00011302953498670831, 0.0734720453619957, 0.038062985986471176, 0.039171453565359116, -0.05222480744123459, 0.0021318006329238415, 0.019324904307723045, 0.04336035996675491, 0.02924634888768196, -0.06636054068803787, -0.00892569962888956, 0.01790103130042553, 0.010718298144638538, -0.013664859347045422, 0.019909529015421867, -0.0247922632843256, 0.05219888687133789, -0.014737950637936592, 0.0473291389644146, -0.022875096648931503, -0.02414323389530182, -0.04715022072196007, -0.016805345192551613, 0.02322070673108101, -0.08741088211536407, 0.015356283634901047, -0.016740761697292328, -0.03160436451435089, -0.01246879156678915, 0.035426631569862366, -0.05843270942568779, 0.03868537023663521, 0.005832356866449118, -0.021416660398244858, 0.008791624568402767, -0.023637454956769943, 0.010406997986137867, 0.010936159640550613, -0.06788355857133865, -0.0350382924079895, 0.0013199843233451247, -0.02494196407496929, 0.021304816007614136, 0.016439244151115417, -0.0000018952877098854515, -0.01688675954937935, 0.023996202275156975, 0.02211790345609188, 0.0388471893966198, 0.05432480201125145, -0.018557604402303696, 0.08006230741739273, 0.03674185276031494, -0.009631565771996975, 0.023121604695916176, 0.003155518090352416, -0.022196751087903976, -0.0350436232984066, -0.026097150519490242, 0.03646145761013031, -0.030680101364850998, -0.020381079986691475, -0.04841960594058037, -0.0029583321884274483, -0.01859046146273613, -0.01680734008550644, -0.021999703720211983, -0.04642799124121666, 0.06545953452587128 ]
<p>If an equal torque of equal radius and size is produced on two bodies of the same weight and same center of gravity, but with different weight distribution (say one has a 1kg mass 1 meter above the center of mass, while the other has it 10 cm above). Will this affect the angular velocity of it?</p>
g7477
[ 0.08955980837345123, 0.006575750187039375, 0.036976758390665054, 0.006537700071930885, 0.0024092979729175568, 0.005895937792956829, 0.05296316742897034, -0.007439545821398497, -0.027377186343073845, 0.019606508314609528, -0.022426776587963104, -0.00608478207141161, 0.011323877610266209, -0.029746318235993385, 0.030232157558202744, 0.011565964668989182, 0.03961917385458946, -0.034247126430273056, 0.047780781984329224, 0.045896537601947784, -0.023894531652331352, -0.016657596454024315, -0.03034942038357258, -0.001493832329288125, 0.005177514627575874, -0.03258448839187622, -0.02707459218800068, -0.021300170570611954, -0.04860204830765724, 0.043653734028339386, -0.03864084929227829, 0.018459102138876915, -0.01660126820206642, -0.06752536445856094, -0.05940438434481621, -0.005988547578454018, 0.03760635480284691, 0.014380139298737049, -0.03750889003276825, -0.01146628987044096, 0.05347936600446701, -0.013166774064302444, -0.001205523032695055, -0.03563395515084267, 0.012272701598703861, -0.03588767349720001, 0.0487963929772377, 0.051943447440862656, -0.0544772744178772, 0.03555901721119881, -0.045333970338106155, 0.022662892937660217, -0.010753275826573372, -0.042037542909383774, 0.03335865959525108, -0.015201656147837639, 0.026174528524279594, -0.025994552299380302, -0.03651292622089386, 0.054817985743284225, -0.03863302618265152, -0.0015177587047219276, -0.06789474934339523, 0.01781385950744152, 0.03535916283726692, -0.026124222204089165, -0.013339602388441563, 0.030612343922257423, -0.019038546830415726, -0.0002772778389044106, -0.014615409076213837, -0.004315142519772053, -0.014684459194540977, -0.03449301794171333, -0.026146627962589264, -0.027637207880616188, 0.03965992480516434, 0.02868303656578064, -0.0027966995257884264, 0.0018671867437660694, -0.03907749056816101, 0.027141833677887917, 0.039327576756477356, 0.04218441992998123, 0.006469437852501869, -0.028304606676101685, 0.046853434294462204, 0.03707071393728256, 0.0015639617340639234, 0.050571318715810776, 0.12129863351583481, -0.0565401166677475, 0.03081607259809971, 0.062316250056028366, -0.014307701028883457, -0.04306304082274437, -0.011426394805312157, 0.031265679746866226, -0.003064493415877223, 0.035709135234355927, -0.029759839177131653, 0.03849998861551285, -0.03006301075220108, -0.013752574101090431, -0.010376377031207085, 0.0018776218639686704, 0.055301032960414886, 0.0032584492582827806, -0.01814146712422371, -0.021281244233250618, 0.013199401088058949, -0.09795930981636047, -0.006229633931070566, 0.00822143629193306, -0.08080042153596878, -0.08178195357322693, 0.12038534879684448, -0.02761094458401203, -0.026545755565166473, 0.025988494977355003, -0.009325209073722363, 0.014061513356864452, -0.002131941495463252, 0.07821577787399292, -0.03852513059973717, 0.009839808568358421, -0.024341465905308723, 0.0598994642496109, 0.03465936332941055, -0.058756023645401, 0.015293193981051445, -0.028998680412769318, -0.0018274257890880108, -0.02356218546628952, 0.01761494390666485, 0.05497542768716812, -0.03613569587469101, 0.01818550005555153, 0.010790369473397732, -0.02441670000553131, 0.02206086926162243, 0.0032531970646232367, 0.02266939915716648, 0.0051144761964678764, -0.045101508498191833, 0.029050495475530624, -0.012384850531816483, -0.01748189702630043, 0.04136925935745239, 0.014818903990089893, 0.02124660089612007, -0.005028765182942152, -0.005758494138717651, -0.03737863153219223, -0.00391546543687582, 0.0016815612325444818, -0.05793893709778786, 0.03155889734625816, 0.014845894649624825, -0.018319033086299896, 0.03758721798658371, -0.02787238545715809, 0.08381537348031998, -0.0213906392455101, -0.019783344119787216, 0.04327937215566635, 0.002676157047972083, 0.0368373729288578, -0.003462555119767785, -0.07966774702072144, -0.052534524351358414, -0.00193191843573004, -0.013329782523214817, 0.023418588563799858, -0.04648859053850174, -0.034719280898571014, -0.04744371026754379, -0.053050149232149124, 0.02115001156926155, 0.013117552734911442, -0.08000759780406952, 0.024884624406695366, 0.011701018549501896, -0.04293619841337204, -0.0032247817143797874, 0.02230842411518097, 0.03681843727827072, 0.010970460250973701, -0.04051564261317253, 0.02361130155622959, -0.030409228056669235, 0.012198343873023987, -0.03754880279302597, 0.04696900397539139, -0.042450129985809326, -0.010559026151895523, -0.0010613849153742194, 0.025140641257166862, -0.047589465975761414, 0.04682233929634094, -0.014460235834121704, 0.05592988431453705, 0.016814518719911575, 0.014702239073812962, 0.012121914885938168, 0.004517266061156988, -0.003412535646930337, -0.0018619515467435122, 0.07686500251293182, -0.02341449074447155, 0.027142522856593132, 0.014086300507187843, -0.017431063577532768, 0.040070321410894394, 0.016388652846217155, 0.024885067716240883, -0.00999127421528101, 0.026044758036732674, 0.0036768883001059294, 0.0002496987581253052, 0.006263070274144411, -0.015241504646837711, -0.004689808934926987, -0.030171135440468788, -0.0382423922419548, -0.060634445399045944, -0.023466667160391808, -0.07397859543561935, -0.012267635203897953, -0.0014136843383312225, -0.0002659214078448713, 0.01588687114417553, 0.046102769672870636, -0.020661506801843643, 0.007433438673615456, 0.033172592520713806, 0.020789634436368942, 0.015770405530929565, -0.0319860503077507, -0.028924889862537384, 0.03810695558786392, -0.007051498629152775, -0.0037124301306903362, -0.008962211199104786, 0.05028854310512543, -0.0006118256133049726, 0.030320487916469574, 0.009934240020811558, 0.040610719472169876, 0.02848307229578495, -0.01975421980023384, 0.0085464958101511, -0.08355138450860977, 0.00913861021399498, 0.0014650316443294287, 0.0325048603117466, -0.011562881991267204, -0.010943684726953506, -0.036430440843105316, -0.0382140576839447, -0.04065927863121033, -0.004201181698590517, 0.020764226093888283, 0.025342034175992012, -0.08126766979694366, 0.02126648835837841, -0.0026544714346528053, -0.009970568120479584, 0.04293292388319969, 0.021877728402614594, -0.029841292649507523, 0.04442640393972397, -0.054853059351444244, 0.07753214240074158, -0.04550258070230484, -0.006199727300554514, -0.025329237803816795, -0.04723113402724266, -0.03399104252457619, 0.007223430555313826, -0.02759547531604767, 0.0077359601855278015, -0.017600389197468758, 0.03924548998475075, 0.05027942731976509, -0.030188975855708122, -0.027422647923231125, -0.022548498585820198, -0.052397750318050385, -0.028297139331698418, -0.012832454405725002, 0.09622613340616226, 0.0794864073395729, -0.022739432752132416, 0.04871237277984619, 0.03689936548471451, -0.015683988109230995, 0.002964999061077833, -0.03210931643843651, -0.005704562645405531, -0.008360038511455059, -0.03977876529097557, 0.007421727757900953, 0.023035837337374687, 0.020388510078191757, 0.004325827583670616, -0.04492618888616562, -0.03468387573957443, 0.005163421854376793, 0.05305923894047737, -0.07601790130138397, 0.0018366866279393435, -0.014316188171505928, -0.014003756456077099, -0.08068045228719711, -0.03782515227794647, 0.008446034975349903, -0.02554742619395256, -0.018544388934969902, -0.012088993564248085, -0.021305473521351814, -0.03704424574971199, -0.0163839403539896, -0.002918885089457035, -0.014536204747855663, 0.05746405944228172, -0.047052159905433655, 0.06129239872097969, 0.0023574514780193567, -0.024435171857476234, -0.016442855820059776, 0.027507903054356575, -0.007871254347264767, 0.011101176962256432, -0.021573804318904877, 0.016009757295250893, 0.028707249090075493, 0.010453282855451107, 0.01727248728275299, 0.025711510330438614, 0.0023136334493756294, 0.004389279987663031, -0.0021742687094956636, -0.05458536744117737, 0.02081787772476673, 0.06616250425577164, -0.010327896103262901, -0.011110554449260235, -0.020494995638728142, 0.007410883437842131, 0.04465734586119652, -0.021584684029221535, 0.02289292775094509, -0.02896602638065815, 0.03051382303237915, -0.006703558843582869, 0.03953511640429497, 0.00760787446051836, -0.04775490239262581, 0.0026491910684853792, 0.012003202922642231, -0.02627064660191536, -0.029690131545066833, 0.04351748898625374, -0.020775388926267624, 0.01953613944351673, 0.01917836256325245, 0.02914607711136341, 0.01193921733647585, 0.032454464584589005, -0.04051322117447853, -0.02001415751874447, 0.019021684303879738, -0.042654287070035934, 0.03423116356134415, -0.0074739642441272736, 0.059036985039711, 0.0294171255081892, -0.025434445589780807, -0.02406817488372326, 0.08639494329690933, 0.051955413073301315, -0.06953992694616318, -0.005978172644972801, -0.0376165509223938, -0.00021312208264134824, -0.023743506520986557, 0.003960801288485527, 0.06717104464769363, -0.021627360954880714, -0.03895317763090134, -0.09744343906641006, -0.0031635300256311893, 0.020232398062944412, 0.06439946591854095, 0.027225645259022713, -0.01485096663236618, -0.07094032317399979, 0.04632851853966713, 0.047050684690475464, -0.011416293680667877, 0.05436507239937782, -0.004185155499726534, -0.015125694684684277, -0.021370934322476387, 0.042138271033763885, 0.056609880179166794, 0.028146911412477493, -0.06302346289157867, 0.042873281985521317, 0.026075201109051704, 0.014238202013075352, 0.02355535514652729, -0.04159671068191528, 0.009636351838707924, -0.002810334786772728, -0.059249747544527054, -0.02299487590789795, -0.009193336591124535, 0.019900338724255562, -0.04375925287604332, 0.03923974931240082, 0.03382326290011406, -0.004766641650348902, 0.04068748652935028, -0.03080221451818943, 0.060916468501091, -0.009860161691904068, 0.012372398748993874, -0.005261843092739582, -0.05813487246632576, 0.01849774271249771, -0.002703380072489381, -0.016979539766907692, -0.004190083127468824, 0.033303190022706985, -0.011695624329149723, -0.002585357055068016, 0.05469721183180809, -0.02295519784092903, 0.00906248390674591, 0.046351224184036255, -0.021563921123743057, -0.023566199466586113, -0.014873494394123554, 0.05216095969080925, -0.00644143670797348, -0.020317457616329193, 0.03888551518321037, 0.0041282870806753635, -0.03641727566719055, -0.04993608593940735, -0.005417359992861748, -0.04604936018586159, -0.034120067954063416, 0.02118939347565174, 0.020903414115309715, 0.01602177880704403, 0.023647861555218697, -0.06220847740769386, -0.059284523129463196, 0.015419966541230679, 0.02105095237493515, 0.01852123998105526, -0.029036343097686768, -0.04375492036342621, -0.04970625042915344, 0.0656355544924736, -0.05627179145812988, -0.0016317225527018309, -0.02749469317495823, -0.008082316257059574, 0.011950064450502396, 0.049706146121025085, 0.0062344009056687355, 0.034561339765787125, -0.0028993962332606316, -0.05330945923924446, 0.008753388188779354, -0.03697425499558449, -0.07204801589250565, -0.05296329781413078, 0.0015848249895498157, -0.03669509291648865, 0.06485011428594589, -0.025686977431178093, -0.00719247292727232, -0.010167423635721207, 0.08816730231046677, -0.01468736119568348, 0.030231164768338203, -0.019139092415571213, -0.04970526322722435, -0.014810467138886452, 0.03340524807572365, 0.0814695879817009, 0.0007253121002577245, -0.03394428640604019, 0.008288001641631126, -0.004585867282003164, -0.062111832201480865, 0.04686959832906723, -0.010118304751813412, 0.04667786508798599, -0.03411729633808136, 0.07230906933546066, 0.029693080112338066, 0.0016767411725595593, -0.015367243438959122, 0.06783609092235565, -0.0435546450316906, 0.035498589277267456, 0.0034712457563728094, 0.02364818938076496, -0.0011866643326357007, 0.004252235405147076, 0.008879666216671467, 0.0013035190058872104, -0.0002453667111694813, 0.026862608268857002, 0.043182168155908585, -0.03328612074255943, 0.04611115902662277, 0.002015791367739439, -0.004991538822650909, 0.01737574301660061, -0.009376992471516132, 0.035097960382699966, -0.04769664630293846, 0.06651347130537033, 0.029829876497387886, 0.04857213795185089, 0.03147045150399208, -0.02758701890707016, -0.018695538863539696, -0.03066677786409855, -0.014256500639021397, -0.002739541232585907, 0.06482846289873123, -0.010621365159749985, 0.004588454030454159, -0.0636996403336525, 0.02422463335096836, 0.002509346231818199, -0.05834358185529709, -0.014887440018355846, -0.03470979258418083, -0.05016948655247688, 0.04350712522864342, -0.035430070012807846, -0.01833776943385601, 0.08438283205032349, -0.016305429860949516, -0.028170941397547722, -0.039448387920856476, 0.023588743060827255, -0.004325236659497023, 0.008904018439352512, 0.028574544936418533, -0.01992608793079853, 0.05910305306315422, -0.016809925436973572, 0.10767675191164017, -0.012785974889993668, -0.008228875696659088, -0.09667779505252838, -0.017801282927393913, -0.04720693826675415, 0.03178894892334938, 0.016428224742412567, -0.02707381546497345, -0.008635263890028, -0.038429226726293564, -0.0629177913069725, 0.0817238986492157, 0.01833220385015011, -0.05952341482043266, -0.00013539833889808506, -0.018310362473130226, 0.014048495329916477, 0.045001838356256485, -0.008557810448110104, -0.002777216723188758, -0.0032586471643298864, 0.02279183268547058, 0.02689312770962715, -0.041051123291254044, 0.0406833216547966, 0.09092617779970169, -0.03297393023967743, -0.07775191217660904, -0.043043337762355804, -0.02997094765305519, -0.0071175312623381615, -0.07683929800987244, -0.013292394578456879, -0.06217395141720772, 0.02300640009343624, -0.024986552074551582, 0.0683862566947937, 0.0691353976726532, -0.027684377506375313, 0.045212771743535995, -0.016354428604245186, 0.011839880608022213, 0.007431196514517069, 0.0025236201472580433, -0.021297650411725044, 0.026824334636330605, 0.005973562132567167, 0.03453068062663078, 0.06889098882675171, 0.03968475013971329, 0.013441971503198147, -0.043919745832681656, 0.01911197043955326, 0.0052360426634550095, -0.033490609377622604, -0.04552629962563515, -0.041286490857601166, 0.03773551806807518, -0.0062948972918093204, -0.018895696848630905, -0.0644015297293663, 0.023141883313655853, -0.0028860345482826233, -0.023005347698926926, 0.020285192877054214, 0.0063525037840008736, 0.01187206618487835, 0.04028113931417465, 0.043310265988111496, -0.02467823587357998, -0.013243883848190308, 0.006727550644427538, 0.05945245176553726, -0.04164161905646324, 0.04109998047351837, 0.04526614025235176, 0.06689866632223129, 0.021624745801091194, 0.06000255048274994, -0.019405506551265717, 0.016396360471844673, -0.05818988010287285, 0.00139238138217479, 0.0421646311879158, 0.0025344514288008213, -0.02258314937353134, 0.03148932382464409, -0.00499919755384326, 0.02085321955382824, -0.025858312845230103, 0.015872523188591003, -0.019502364099025726, -0.0492277666926384, 0.002843649359419942, 0.03070256859064102, -0.013813012279570103, -0.00823256466537714, -0.023711945861577988, 0.022065240889787674, -0.01706933043897152, 0.013511594384908676, -0.026721609756350517, 0.03032352775335312, -0.008264366537332535, 0.018235953524708748, -0.019680291414260864, 0.05536998435854912, 0.011375067755579948, -0.0028624506667256355, -0.03148946538567543, 0.013749334029853344, 0.00045334448805078864, 0.03669799119234085, -0.010082144290208817, -0.04733509197831154, -0.0008254903368651867, 0.04025912657380104, 0.017831087112426758, 0.0028523793444037437, -0.020864902064204216, 0.04087105020880699, -0.016344018280506134, 0.029352257028222084, -0.035189803689718246, 0.004975313786417246, 0.041660409420728683, -0.049957484006881714, -0.018035562708973885, 0.045499928295612335, -0.04867308586835861, 0.006821758113801479, -0.06904938071966171, -0.021642666310071945, -0.0020596212707459927, 0.09339912980794907, 0.007049310952425003, -0.008150088600814342, -0.011645684018731117, -0.008715993724763393, -0.02912476658821106, 0.052461303770542145, 0.0037935469299554825, 0.051279447972774506, 0.005915716290473938, 0.046846259385347366, -0.048133790493011475, 0.019473940134048462, 0.05769854784011841, -0.0025050288531929255, 0.050072770565748215, 0.021397080272436142, -0.06472712755203247, 0.02580614760518074, -0.014452527277171612, 0.05329669266939163, 0.07267836481332779, -0.0025154068134725094, -0.07189178466796875, 0.002220741007477045, 0.026315653696656227, -0.06916593760251999, -0.0944649949669838, -0.08470691740512848, -0.01099917758256197, -0.008520982228219509, 0.008557249791920185, -0.020007086917757988, 0.0248164813965559, 0.002854594262316823, -0.04516397416591644, 0.040230780839920044, -0.022908950224518776, 0.03002275712788105, -0.008834834210574627, -0.02133532054722309, -0.009261983446776867, -0.011019423604011536, -0.004000898916274309, -0.04711976274847984, 0.012869110330939293, -0.0036208610981702805, -0.0335688553750515, 0.06393727660179138, 0.01995128020644188, 0.022224601358175278, 0.01341137196868658, -0.026221778243780136, 0.0017460511298850179, 0.0016576135531067848, -0.04757297784090042, 0.03024217113852501, -0.007639516144990921, -0.023960866034030914, -0.03741481155157089, 0.01682969741523266, -0.030558045953512192, -0.02717473916709423, -0.04781007394194603, 0.028610246255993843, -0.0031031579710543156, -0.08026737719774246, -0.010535936802625656, 0.0019500107737258077, -0.01955213025212288, 0.07003406435251236 ]
<p>I am currently a high school student interested in a research career in physics. I have self taught myself single variable calculus and elementary physics upto the level of IPHO . And I am comfortable with euclidean geometry upto the point of some basic theorems like Pythagoras or Thales and the geometry in Cartesian coordinates and use of vectors. </p> <p>I have read at a lot of places that somehow geometry is very much essential for doing physics? Now I don't know in what context, as in do you ever need the complex geometrical theorems that are upto the level of IMO, in physics or are you just good knowing simple theorems and their proofs and trigonometric relations and similarity etc.</p> <p>Plus what other forms of geometry are essential for doing physics? </p> <p>Is linear algebra a form of geometry? </p> <p>What next step should I take to dive into geometry that will help me in my physics career for making an early start? Non-euclidean? And what is it about the geometry names, hyperbolic, elliptical? I can understand if someone tells me that plane geometry / 3d geometry, but what is the essence of hyperbolic/elliptical geometry?</p> <p>And what are non euclidean geometries and topologies?</p> <p>Is there a theoretical minimum that you need in all forms of geometries to do physics? I want to learn the math now properly so that I get used to its machinery and later on, don't have to struggle with it later, especially geometry, since the names of these geometries intrigue me .</p> <p>Is there any need for learning euclidean geometry, upto the levels of <em>Geometry Revisited</em> by Coxeter?</p> <p>Also I'd be grateful, if some book recommendations are also provided.</p>
g108
[ 0.006072528660297394, 0.043317846953868866, 0.001450356445275247, -0.0022615985944867134, 0.0312553234398365, 0.014342665672302246, 0.05127981677651405, -0.0015160025795921683, -0.0212312713265419, -0.017705388367176056, -0.019750576466321945, -0.016298355534672737, 0.06075408309698105, -0.03497321903705597, -0.010049453005194664, -0.004118009470403194, -0.0049403393641114235, 0.008334597572684288, 0.033883508294820786, -0.008650930598378181, 0.00885828584432602, 0.00817751046270132, 0.08137182146310806, -0.05412956699728966, -0.08616569638252258, -0.02262956090271473, -0.007100751157850027, -0.05280696228146553, -0.028804218396544456, -0.0039397901855409145, 0.04288165271282196, -0.04700320586562157, 0.05028894171118736, -0.014757535420358181, 0.008565865457057953, -0.066578708589077, 0.02904866635799408, 0.026264380663633347, 0.028294147923588753, -0.0026130981277674437, 0.002957381075248122, -0.0458584763109684, 0.0036175772547721863, -0.0094029251486063, 0.016376009210944176, 0.057093650102615356, -0.04031302034854889, -0.01776914857327938, 0.010078681632876396, 0.028139306232333183, 0.011025323532521725, 0.00044483356759883463, 0.017549052834510803, 0.01969730108976364, 0.010162249207496643, -0.024294428527355194, 0.02192538231611252, -0.018100228160619736, 0.10139558464288712, -0.04041959345340729, 0.0024214154109358788, 0.08964758366346359, -0.05524753779172897, 0.031142814084887505, 0.031220821663737297, 0.03504364192485809, -0.0519878976047039, -0.016706664115190506, -0.038312096148729324, 0.036988090723752975, 0.014972220174968243, -0.05207834765315056, 0.040089547634124756, 0.002226862357929349, -0.016329102218151093, 0.003667282871901989, 0.06620272994041443, -0.06116444244980812, 0.022358324378728867, 0.026111125946044922, -0.026199884712696075, 0.04059085249900818, 0.025446848943829536, -0.03120145946741104, 0.05795639380812645, -0.020712271332740784, -0.08911959081888199, -0.016341431066393852, 0.0036099024582654238, -0.025692958384752274, 0.02136148512363434, 0.032586902379989624, 0.04697951674461365, 0.01184358261525631, 0.022026201710104942, -0.02716509997844696, -0.051779210567474365, 0.09445974975824356, 0.017224254086613655, 0.06456499546766281, -0.042126599699258804, -0.085296131670475, 0.043681152164936066, -0.021911650896072388, 0.07591409236192703, 0.008376368321478367, 0.01240110769867897, 0.03358364477753639, 0.07397782802581787, 0.006191377528011799, -0.07757911086082458, 0.04009230434894562, -0.028099549934267998, -0.0008209104998968542, -0.08541770279407501, 0.023364603519439697, 0.04497183486819267, -0.026775456964969635, 0.059031493961811066, 0.1003757193684578, 0.009203540161252022, 0.03184949606657028, 0.042625732719898224, 0.03837595880031586, -0.026032686233520508, -0.021451875567436218, 0.04601920396089554, -0.05892115458846092, 0.011407668702304363, -0.0042547183111310005, 0.014109536074101925, 0.006584498565644026, -0.029161395505070686, 0.0369856022298336, -0.051969777792692184, 0.0428178496658802, 0.014704986475408077, 0.00788622535765171, 0.06367876380681992, 0.028299817815423012, -0.009647376835346222, 0.010271219536662102, 0.06339805573225021, -0.07247880101203918, -0.020464571192860603, -0.0028907274827361107, 0.0021063433960080147, 0.00007137280044844374, -0.020886117592453957, 0.006917341612279415, -0.0026947641745209694, 0.013709532096982002, 0.045749012380838394, -0.03565850481390953, 0.018772076815366745, 0.011566822417080402, 0.037130411714315414, 0.0006978230667300522, 0.09428314119577408, -0.029129445552825928, 0.10162710398435593, 0.008956336416304111, -0.04166531190276146, 0.018687183037400246, 0.007242242339998484, 0.01765434630215168, -0.012601547874510288, -0.0870559960603714, 0.024545658379793167, 0.03045138344168663, -0.0490955114364624, -0.013256587088108063, 0.041294731199741364, 0.04037350416183472, -0.06471285223960876, 0.0008068546303547919, 0.015718869864940643, -0.07835857570171356, -0.0027939816936850548, -0.027831340208649635, 0.008608518168330193, -0.052540749311447144, 0.022766780108213425, -0.0005216264398768544, -0.025128697976469994, 0.08331627398729324, -0.05017989128828049, 0.03852609172463417, -0.038909606635570526, 0.006776511203497648, -0.013933171518146992, -0.015540002845227718, -0.003870999440550804, 0.01380162127315998, 0.02590503729879856, 0.02300042100250721, 0.010200181044638157, 0.027780117467045784, -0.011849286034703255, 0.06061369180679321, 0.004322655498981476, 0.02007092535495758, 0.04827940836548805, 0.054829906672239304, -0.02525976486504078, 0.03866288438439369, -0.025864949449896812, -0.033603865653276443, 0.024462932720780373, 0.028366299346089363, 0.0037335692904889584, -0.015513437800109386, 0.034214794635772705, -0.015632232651114464, 0.02565474435687065, -0.006366731133311987, -0.007998919114470482, -0.05505811423063278, -0.04751542583107948, 0.09304776042699814, -0.007505570538341999, -0.01751687563955784, 0.02904582768678665, -0.03027953766286373, -0.0064024231396615505, -0.0002660676254890859, -0.03190585598349571, -0.02465328387916088, 0.045842669904232025, 0.007911533117294312, 0.010655125603079796, 0.005305858328938484, 0.04032716900110245, -0.0893259271979332, 0.0640057623386383, 0.016184112057089806, 0.017308488488197327, -0.07896493375301361, 0.02710343711078167, 0.010640139691531658, 0.011973953805863857, 0.010026703588664532, 0.011843451298773289, -0.05139997601509094, 0.0384259857237339, -0.05963171645998955, 0.04735191538929939, -0.018007885664701462, -0.035419587045907974, -0.022969061508774757, 0.05916156619787216, -0.08555583655834198, -0.07291972637176514, 0.015285531990230083, 0.004642473999410868, 0.047413863241672516, 0.030345913022756577, 0.008237522095441818, -0.023095520213246346, -0.036531057208776474, -0.024762043729424477, -0.03681162744760513, -0.056633111089468, -0.02855112962424755, -0.10204043239355087, 0.057619862258434296, -0.03503215312957764, 0.015469017438590527, -0.022914377972483635, -0.029890507459640503, 0.012300527654588223, 0.03588039055466652, 0.00451470073312521, -0.032709311693906784, -0.02485954575240612, 0.01707942970097065, -0.02132413536310196, -0.020034290850162506, 0.023000270128250122, -0.022346844896674156, 0.03345873951911926, -0.04637095332145691, -0.01738705486059189, 0.006500312127172947, 0.010907748714089394, -0.03267689049243927, 0.046293120831251144, -0.02908531203866005, -0.04262641444802284, -0.021782025694847107, -0.02089753746986389, -0.02983597293496132, 0.03822558745741844, -0.006097369361668825, -0.032960761338472366, 0.011509827338159084, -0.029965391382575035, 0.007963132113218307, -0.03389488905668259, 0.01626831293106079, -0.03476227819919586, -0.025229914113879204, 0.04627286642789841, -0.02091945894062519, -0.042297668755054474, 0.019855713471770287, -0.01026664488017559, -0.04565310478210449, -0.03044743649661541, 0.027250895276665688, -0.016042454168200493, -0.01609172113239765, 0.006350147072225809, 0.028661781921982765, 0.009388881735503674, -0.039325956255197525, 0.023012304678559303, 0.017126737162470818, 0.006320689804852009, -0.03480556234717369, -0.004794517531991005, 0.029255226254463196, 0.019305238500237465, -0.042967166751623154, 0.04237106814980507, 0.048405151814222336, 0.03384352847933769, -0.0470583513379097, -0.0159533079713583, 0.020696328952908516, 0.005624216981232166, -0.0030822691041976213, -0.06187491491436958, -0.02808576449751854, -0.06886707991361618, -0.0331096276640892, 0.011166724376380444, -0.013704619370400906, 0.001365048112347722, -0.04126942530274391, 0.04862329363822937, -0.0391959547996521, -0.039184682071208954, -0.0578051432967186, 0.020916080102324486, -0.011241617612540722, -0.03199475631117821, 0.016372239217162132, -0.027724863961338997, -0.03250763565301895, 0.03807145729660988, -0.01107848808169365, 0.020011233165860176, -0.01810474693775177, -0.013910366222262383, 0.04136873409152031, 0.045575227588415146, 0.0480310283601284, -0.04834158718585968, -0.023932207375764847, -0.04730507358908653, -0.03269026428461075, 0.008923318237066269, 0.04759862273931503, -0.05855898931622505, 0.030004022642970085, 0.0013368870131671429, -0.010051022283732891, -0.0383756086230278, 0.004056182224303484, -0.03481019288301468, -0.03309468924999237, -0.05396318435668945, -0.015112856402993202, -0.0345795676112175, -0.00771802943199873, 0.04409581422805786, -0.004410624969750643, -0.010991228744387627, -0.043383896350860596, -0.01496682409197092, 0.031191760674118996, 0.022333256900310516, 0.003951923456043005, 0.015035311691462994, 0.02031427063047886, 0.012969695962965488, 0.005167471244931221, 0.00255527812987566, 0.02658570185303688, 0.03193935751914978, 0.011943012475967407, -0.02099575102329254, 0.0038122725673019886, -0.003170124953612685, -0.021026309579610825, -0.010368204675614834, 0.013690448366105556, -0.01014848705381155, 0.034310221672058105, -0.021768026053905487, 0.014919263310730457, -0.031228506937623024, 0.051723890006542206, -0.02197204902768135, -0.041565291583538055, -0.012339525856077671, 0.005153776612132788, -0.0071564181707799435, -0.00016220945690292865, 0.009633855894207954, -0.06624752283096313, 0.01764814741909504, -0.03779955208301544, 0.057505905628204346, 0.004607705399394035, -0.06814906001091003, -0.07592159509658813, 0.019681457430124283, -0.0065005505457520485, 0.05179359391331673, 0.0846983790397644, 0.02502642571926117, -0.03672271966934204, 0.017877904698252678, 0.06713307648897171, 0.039508383721113205, -0.0021664618980139494, -0.027451295405626297, 0.023853546008467674, 0.055739231407642365, -0.009221539832651615, 0.017260489985346794, -0.024510135874152184, -0.050572190433740616, -0.023603718727827072, -0.014436285942792892, 0.0355837345123291, -0.04552951827645302, -0.052513379603624344, 0.01632690615952015, 0.033990491181612015, -0.00817123707383871, -0.017057206481695175, -0.031035346910357475, 0.01925400085747242, -0.038601893931627274, 0.03087584301829338, 0.002060294384136796, -0.026758361607789993, -0.020984234288334846, 0.024564268067479134, 0.004775491077452898, -0.022240135818719864, -0.06777077168226242, -0.01278991624712944, -0.003971966914832592, 0.0022503910586237907, 0.03754895552992821, 0.05052778124809265, 0.020725945010781288, 0.028557974845170975, -0.049963973462581635, 0.059664711356163025, 0.003093088511377573, 0.0031441885512322187, -0.05519561469554901, 0.01522720418870449, -0.00952186994254589, -0.01677660085260868, -0.03745678439736366, -0.007434720639139414, 0.036529894918203354, -0.03360535576939583, 0.008958300575613976, 0.016430949792265892, -0.03043937124311924, -0.003458202350884676, -0.06357713043689728, -0.011683148331940174, -0.028504453599452972, 0.014174933545291424, 0.02949690632522106, 0.028141049668192863, 0.011064608581364155, -0.019253894686698914, -0.07101413607597351, -0.006744422949850559, 0.0009192180586978793, 0.060619886964559555, -0.030494891107082367, 0.02936394140124321, 0.03966787829995155, 0.011030130088329315, -0.06424357742071152, -0.030189311131834984, 0.006130474619567394, -0.05561130493879318, -0.020187877118587494, -0.019223082810640335, -0.029058124870061874, 0.030537480488419533, -0.031879670917987823, -0.0401080921292305, 0.0076653906144201756, 0.006675082258880138, 0.016544030979275703, -0.004530365113168955, 0.01763305626809597, -0.04119311273097992, 0.016888732090592384, -0.008529288694262505, -0.04839759320020676, -0.005262540653347969, 0.022792765870690346, -0.019491609185934067, -0.01749000884592533, 0.036453790962696075, -0.015230880118906498, 0.030027061700820923, 0.021520281210541725, 0.004260580521076918, 0.04648495465517044, -0.001800361555069685, 0.04429423436522484, -0.022127702832221985, -0.019020341336727142, 0.03293890133500099, 0.0032253116369247437, 0.03883775696158409, 0.015682240948081017, 0.02186049334704876, -0.04098430275917053, 0.035454072058200836, -0.06662355363368988, -0.0038770860992372036, 0.002774448599666357, 0.0020772782154381275, 0.03170577436685562, -0.01280297338962555, -0.042153775691986084, 0.00750324223190546, 0.008119928650557995, 0.035246361047029495, -0.000550692668184638, -0.03465498983860016, 0.06854458898305893, 0.08421499282121658, 0.105583555996418, -0.061980511993169785, -0.04718606546521187, -0.042028721421957016, 0.01685738004744053, -0.03117009997367859, -0.02187238819897175, -0.01443901564925909, 0.005933338776230812, 0.005103120114654303, -0.015388942323625088, -0.021847208961844444, 0.014629974029958248, -0.03698490560054779, 0.02115347608923912, 0.028919022530317307, 0.02686408720910549, -0.02514069713652134, 0.0038711766246706247, -0.03929414227604866, 0.08772144466638565, 0.011684210039675236, -0.02111060731112957, -0.041579581797122955, -0.018291844055056572, 0.02536028064787388, 0.04041317105293274, 0.010075856931507587, 0.00957000907510519, -0.02930282987654209, 0.002598096616566181, 0.04761917144060135, -0.025792745873332024, 0.05629495903849602, 0.04474707320332527, -0.04029340669512749, -0.0009518173756077886, 0.07610812783241272, -0.008546760305762291, -0.03297721967101097, -0.06842811405658722, -0.05804714933037758, -0.058577001094818115, 0.013249239884316921, 0.008784107863903046, 0.005560474935919046, -0.03316950798034668, 0.035561829805374146, 0.05391617864370346, 0.016621042042970657, -0.005541080608963966, -0.002099337289109826, -0.05532955005764961, -0.021776609122753143, -0.018287718296051025, 0.02870059572160244, 0.0028316897805780172, 0.039110347628593445, 0.030373064801096916, -0.04947067052125931, -0.02647014707326889, -0.0015799528919160366, 0.05941186100244522, 0.014769505709409714, -0.011856062337756157, 0.035317566245794296, -0.07223299890756607, -0.011182821355760098, 0.020774899050593376, -0.04570680111646652, 0.012657390907406807, -0.13583408296108246, 0.01618904247879982, 0.012838155962526798, 0.029602693393826485, 0.021618226543068886, 0.0014100874541327357, 0.009076321497559547, -0.01473317388445139, 0.07870925962924957, 0.043197792023420334, -0.022606177255511284, 0.012593841180205345, 0.017119569703936577, 0.044896237552165985, 0.06687482446432114, 0.022233622148633003, 0.058695800602436066, 0.032217446714639664, -0.016560900956392288, 0.03242137283086777, 0.02924233302474022, -0.003922828007489443, -0.02661464363336563, 0.04265674576163292, -0.013874835334718227, 0.004459562711417675, -0.04635727033019066, -0.06815383583307266, -0.0325767919421196, -0.010896693915128708, 0.0486789271235466, -0.00437784381210804, -0.03826122358441353, -0.016234159469604492, -0.00780812231823802, 0.03923109918832779, 0.0032667405903339386, 0.01548862736672163, 0.015589050948619843, 0.018230102956295013, -0.06240721046924591, -0.050866495817899704, 0.016057521104812622, 0.05013003572821617, -0.027911262586712837, -0.022017614915966988, 0.0490269772708416, -0.011778531596064568, 0.004694007802754641, -0.04961761087179184, 0.03307165578007698, -0.016492672264575958, -0.023991776630282402, -0.07682102173566818, 0.01087144948542118, 0.019433574751019478, -0.035383980721235275, -0.007244040258228779, -0.03213610500097275, 0.004830846097320318, -0.0243715550750494, -0.007611900568008423, 0.044025078415870667, 0.00394055712968111, 0.042837079614400864, -0.010148730129003525, 0.053905557841062546, 0.006900913082063198, -0.01198259461671114, -0.02733227238059044, -0.016958089545369148, -0.05082675442099571, -0.012520928867161274, -0.031442005187273026, -0.04589900001883507, 0.05524124577641487, -0.022753922268748283, 0.09286144375801086, 0.010692331939935684, 0.011076177470386028, -0.010380975902080536, -0.02681690827012062, -0.007763939909636974, -0.014017452485859394, 0.0004275266546756029, -0.01059100590646267, 0.020249908789992332, 0.0005908002494834363, 0.010425937362015247, -0.0032092093024402857, 0.0686149150133133, -0.04563393443822861, 0.03540867939591408, 0.04808972403407097, 0.02489384077489376, 0.02070949599146843, 0.030845046043395996, 0.014407848939299583, -0.0026154094375669956, -0.03651975467801094, -0.006936174351722002, -0.041629813611507416, 0.016281358897686005, 0.01846066676080227, -0.0239652618765831, -0.029698818922042847, 0.000257808220339939, -0.026815177872776985, -0.01654413901269436, -0.03144669905304909, -0.03333873301744461, 0.02877074107527733, 0.025401584804058075, -0.014153032563626766, 0.06499752402305603, -0.009914306923747063, -0.023320069536566734, 0.055253684520721436, -0.05970178171992302, 0.026569180190563202, -0.017149217426776886, 0.021949831396341324, 0.00836122129112482, 0.0025105606764554977, -0.008454224094748497, -0.007271807640790939, -0.03829106315970421, 0.0058504133485257626, 0.057590022683143616, -0.0005109555786475539, -0.002582065761089325, -0.0773799940943718, 0.057741157710552216, 0.05474558472633362, 0.0886947512626648, -0.020490877330303192, -0.05792638659477234, 0.055052660405635834, 0.010423017665743828, 0.017982762306928635, -0.028432859107851982, 0.02578427828848362, 0.033350810408592224, 0.07613503187894821, 0.027106724679470062, -0.045978233218193054, 0.005179629195481539, -0.03989247605204582, -0.0003875106922350824 ]
<p>I understand that quantum teleportation fidelity is the overlap of the initial quantum state with the teleported quantum state. If the teleportation is perfect, then the fidelity would equal 1 or 100% successful of retrieving the quantum state at the desired location.</p> <p>In all real experiments I've glanced at and read thoroughly, the fidelities are never 1. Doesn't this suggest that what the experimenters "teleported" was really just a different state? Doesn't the fidelity have to be exactly 1 in order to really remove a quantum state from one location and make it appear at another location?</p> <p>My concern is that either I've missed something, or that we aren't really teleporting at all because the final state achieved on the other side is not equal to the initial state!</p>
g7478
[ -0.026231667026877403, 0.049436237663030624, 0.015366071835160255, 0.04641983285546303, 0.023348703980445862, -0.028105931356549263, 0.006859872955828905, 0.06354858726263046, -0.006817359011620283, 0.04967501014471054, -0.04082484915852547, -0.034264545887708664, -0.04431595280766487, -0.031338371336460114, -0.059422340244054794, -0.03459789231419563, 0.09964314103126526, 0.027738993987441063, 0.0707353726029396, 0.012878121808171272, -0.022164765745401382, -0.027317862957715988, -0.05766147002577782, -0.039218511432409286, -0.09920858591794968, -0.009813600219786167, -0.037820521742105484, -0.038369711488485336, -0.08661142736673355, -0.033422015607357025, 0.006466771941632032, -0.05042531341314316, 0.056538891047239304, -0.0048251100815832615, -0.045939281582832336, 0.011582301929593086, -0.025642627850174904, -0.01286173053085804, 0.022310640662908554, -0.012182158417999744, -0.04753889888525009, 0.004820430185645819, -0.018317073583602905, -0.043304238468408585, 0.02659722976386547, 0.07412499189376831, 0.005207938142120838, -0.016525009647011757, 0.04064563661813736, -0.0543571300804615, -0.0124928904697299, 0.04986671730875969, 0.027225349098443985, 0.08058460056781769, 0.02602073922753334, 0.021029097959399223, -0.03204852715134621, 0.002119580516591668, 0.010610911063849926, -0.06354499608278275, 0.03942738100886345, -0.0025290946941822767, -0.03582744300365448, 0.0062822215259075165, 0.003927959594875574, 0.01829536445438862, -0.03619891032576561, 0.052665382623672485, -0.008810721337795258, 0.022606780752539635, 0.036520376801490784, -0.01728491112589836, -0.02194555290043354, -0.03413628786802292, 0.022694608196616173, 0.015019931830465794, 0.04562484845519066, -0.06548143178224564, -0.029463158920407295, 0.02481471747159958, -0.028930386528372765, -0.08014177531003952, 0.004165614955127239, 0.01049820613116026, 0.04626340791583061, 0.03832684084773064, -0.012198244221508503, 0.012588389217853546, -0.02599913999438286, 0.014142063446342945, 0.024035213515162468, -0.015974711626768112, 0.04817371442914009, 0.06227367743849754, -0.04492892324924469, -0.04185856878757477, -0.042760927230119705, 0.010259260423481464, 0.01264191698282957, -0.004074075259268284, -0.005740356165915728, 0.018084067851305008, -0.014976633712649345, -0.00572116719558835, -0.05350112169981003, 0.0005741841741837561, 0.022230001166462898, 0.006066037807613611, -0.009814472869038582, 0.0209302119910717, 0.004016562830656767, -0.011555014178156853, 0.033780816942453384, -0.01112903282046318, -0.030237367376685143, 0.04277009516954422, -0.03108249045908451, 0.016437582671642303, 0.0000796595704741776, -0.04725134000182152, 0.08835542947053909, 0.00788795854896307, 0.023782597854733467, 0.04651027172803879, -0.003926451317965984, 0.010824800468981266, -0.011237122118473053, -0.02083243429660797, 0.011169936507940292, 0.026247378438711166, 0.012488131411373615, -0.007870064117014408, -0.011172979138791561, 0.011974280700087547, -0.02577163837850094, -0.04128978028893471, 0.07710772007703781, 0.020602509379386902, 0.026524994522333145, 0.0018175808945670724, -0.00034153054002672434, -0.023209435865283012, 0.010428929701447487, -0.024599513038992882, -0.012094607576727867, -0.01816755160689354, -0.004625606816262007, 0.015046893619000912, -0.0002615367411635816, -0.002032395452260971, 0.06725918501615524, -0.012580977752804756, 0.040781062096357346, -0.021549701690673828, -0.03306935355067253, 0.0021873414516448975, 0.04332970455288887, -0.01985049434006214, 0.014187711291015148, 0.06850559264421463, 0.03980278968811035, -0.012965915724635124, 0.05058789625763893, -0.006805207580327988, 0.008556130342185497, 0.02271474339067936, 0.006320444867014885, -0.06463710963726044, 0.03284237161278725, -0.033026378601789474, 0.00609381590038538, 0.0026344258803874254, 0.012648247182369232, 0.038763970136642456, 0.02929304726421833, 0.015851862728595734, 0.0693679228425026, -0.004114022012799978, -0.04045179858803749, 0.012225867249071598, 0.03264103829860687, 0.03521271422505379, -0.04290600121021271, -0.02368629164993763, -0.006283263675868511, -0.029104186221957207, -0.04075723513960838, -0.034521713852882385, -0.02439514547586441, 0.0074246469885110855, 0.048064712435007095, -0.002770298859104514, -0.02864626795053482, -0.07042224705219269, -0.028490688651800156, -0.04620261490345001, -0.004039370454847813, -0.03750783950090408, -0.008958439342677593, 0.020453423261642456, 0.014153788797557354, 0.053038131445646286, 0.04966532438993454, 0.01839800737798214, -0.03716806322336197, -0.003196857636794448, -0.039994075894355774, -0.032842446118593216, -0.04062926024198532, -0.026063034310936928, -0.044062454253435135, -0.03293663635849953, -0.014509963802993298, 0.05274716019630432, 0.01017611101269722, -0.003919336479157209, 0.058200445026159286, 0.026762282475829124, 0.019209569320082664, -0.01266003493219614, -0.019154343754053116, 0.0009287964203394949, 0.1356503665447235, 0.024441275745630264, -0.013305925764143467, 0.03081269934773445, -0.06213796138763428, -0.04892747849225998, -0.017275867983698845, 0.07329238951206207, -0.023323940113186836, 0.01821759156882763, -0.05062664672732353, -0.009771319106221199, 0.021607281640172005, 0.05265737324953079, -0.008336730301380157, 0.016850171610713005, 0.03263430669903755, 0.0017652176320552826, 0.013022532686591148, -0.014156004413962364, -0.05959729105234146, 0.06563926488161087, 0.01040776539593935, 0.006862548645585775, -0.012771612964570522, -0.04711299017071724, 0.011838247999548912, -0.07169201225042343, -0.01646111160516739, -0.011981592513620853, -0.026267440989613533, -0.0035949205048382282, -0.0023816614411771297, -0.017233137041330338, -0.004961659200489521, 0.029421187937259674, -0.027122892439365387, 0.022309929132461548, -0.012268642894923687, -0.050972096621990204, 0.05915931984782219, -0.026563327759504318, -0.0514100007712841, 0.03168635442852974, 0.018109897151589394, 0.004938873462378979, -0.06048675626516342, -0.046629466116428375, -0.03926469758152962, 0.02348208986222744, 0.0009417689288966358, 0.05030429735779762, 0.04332898557186127, -0.03981096297502518, -0.039636190980672836, 0.012717029079794884, -0.0063178157433867455, 0.022328227758407593, -0.0787629708647728, 0.0344325415790081, -0.07813378423452377, 0.008006290532648563, -0.0055201672948896885, -0.0650797039270401, 0.029292799532413483, 0.03819049522280693, -0.029237525537610054, 0.03790748119354248, 0.047147683799266815, -0.034624725580215454, 0.04856450855731964, 0.015595409087836742, -0.047632597386837006, 0.0014480389654636383, -0.003622395684942603, -0.04638803005218506, 0.007394328713417053, 0.03299130126833916, -0.015740448608994484, 0.08003980666399002, -0.010585103183984756, 0.01872025430202484, -0.017580969259142876, 0.06349775940179825, -0.022208919748663902, 0.015860695391893387, -0.04760245978832245, 0.012339085340499878, -0.049435436725616455, 0.05671003833413124, -0.018956221640110016, -0.03631332144141197, 0.04462225362658501, -0.03876258432865143, 0.030594492331147194, 0.03988456726074219, 0.0445755198597908, 0.04357646033167839, -0.004655461758375168, 0.003958217799663544, -0.027280213311314583, -0.008539438247680664, 0.10368769615888596, 0.029408391565084457, -0.06980438530445099, 0.013971365056931973, 0.008113360963761806, -0.03337086737155914, 0.032917167991399765, 0.017524980008602142, -0.010507683269679546, -0.061422497034072876, -0.05634510517120361, -0.07031600922346115, -0.060966212302446365, 0.021885382011532784, 0.055601656436920166, -0.0021018546540290117, -0.07097714394330978, 0.00663407938554883, 0.032116662710905075, 0.07863190770149231, 0.057391177862882614, 0.01394710224121809, 0.007306504063308239, 0.03496841341257095, 0.021500643342733383, -0.02049228362739086, 0.06218487769365311, -0.005692674312740564, -0.03889567404985428, 0.01731235347688198, -0.04223975911736488, 0.0590413436293602, -0.023739691823720932, -0.003601043252274394, -0.0025015741121023893, 0.015314897522330284, 0.03985828533768654, 0.003114072373136878, 0.02835509181022644, -0.055308837443590164, 0.016941914334893227, -0.004609948489814997, -0.006967438384890556, 0.07683947682380676, -0.005459955427795649, 0.028177522122859955, -0.04331805929541588, -0.04144582152366638, -0.05146653577685356, 0.03316295146942139, 0.03746381029486656, 0.0536697618663311, -0.03798535838723183, 0.021940110251307487, 0.010480965487658978, 0.029620079323649406, 0.011490137316286564, 0.03910422325134277, -0.004149912856519222, 0.004793953616172075, 0.021988486871123314, 0.019366133958101273, -0.03608441725373268, -0.01654530130326748, 0.003956913016736507, -0.0011251813266426325, -0.0033200825564563274, -0.019368866458535194, -0.005917266942560673, 0.052743006497621536, 0.028495054692029953, 0.03518085926771164, 0.022842561826109886, -0.0011245720088481903, 0.08658948540687561, 0.026933247223496437, 0.016106922179460526, -0.014535089023411274, -0.041027847677469254, -0.015297951176762581, -0.03624742478132248, -0.06407518684864044, -0.0004087013367097825, 0.06401169300079346, -0.01287724357098341, -0.019549360498785973, -0.025397012010216713, 0.05903162062168121, -0.015058178454637527, 0.005837046541273594, 0.010300632566213608, 0.05685779079794884, -0.021724723279476166, -0.047975968569517136, 0.02164524607360363, -0.02079034224152565, -0.05236378312110901, 0.04822593927383423, 0.04189110919833183, -0.011966212652623653, 0.02415832318365574, 0.021365942433476448, 0.01956743188202381, 0.002225368982180953, -0.00013353326357901096, -0.012865154072642326, 0.02009662240743637, -0.020099304616451263, 0.034434061497449875, 0.014598294161260128, -0.05055040121078491, 0.011403864249587059, 0.006678695324808359, 0.03247109055519104, 0.03552365303039551, 0.025201167911291122, 0.02070242166519165, 0.028367415070533752, -0.016793102025985718, 0.057024478912353516, -0.018226727843284607, -0.04490061476826668, -0.07366855442523956, 0.0043480307795107365, 0.005293007008731365, -0.03643875941634178, 0.001119627384468913, 0.015965618193149567, 0.016455942764878273, -0.037538886070251465, -0.02193574607372284, -0.00823123473674059, 0.0106217535212636, 0.04078442603349686, -0.019834134727716446, 0.005378037691116333, -0.01120307669043541, 0.028722751885652542, 0.008745844475924969, 0.020471885800361633, -0.024086134508252144, 0.04614228010177612, -0.03497837483882904, -0.017886437475681305, -0.05199984461069107, 0.011144854128360748, -0.00521433399990201, 0.018085934221744537, 0.0121557442471385, 0.0948953852057457, 0.03855554014444351, -0.09004736691713333, -0.01156863383948803, -0.011452725157141685, -0.008792323991656303, -0.033491600304841995, -0.05337892472743988, 0.014678140170872211, 0.050437167286872864, 0.002380205085501075, -0.028348596766591072, -0.01903996430337429, -0.020483138039708138, -0.012043887749314308, 0.0016863290220499039, -0.008836009539663792, 0.0543719157576561, 0.022686254233121872, 0.02454962208867073, -0.07463929057121277, 0.01555465254932642, -0.05039859190583229, -0.015618565492331982, 0.013707350008189678, -0.010791493579745293, -0.001841951860114932, -0.04141346365213394, 0.023370753973722458, 0.017506033182144165, -0.00306823942810297, -0.025379493832588196, 0.04578966274857521, 0.05356942489743233, -0.07748913764953613, -0.0412239246070385, -0.08086495101451874, -0.005034797824919224, 0.010631482116878033, -0.09644585102796555, -0.06453384459018707, 0.045151446014642715, 0.010092451237142086, -0.06533000618219376, 0.058118972927331924, 0.013710967265069485, 0.03865364193916321, -0.015856623649597168, 0.04866313189268112, -0.029190531000494957, -0.029676655307412148, -0.02498018741607666, 0.019153408706188202, -0.033783216029405594, 0.012933830730617046, 0.01883525960147381, 0.05149025470018387, 0.006836573127657175, 0.09480508416891098, 0.04074843227863312, 0.021067772060632706, -0.03862406685948372, -0.03520699217915535, 0.03806552663445473, -0.059338025748729706, 0.019951781257987022, 0.02479684352874756, -0.0023091372568160295, 0.012638408690690994, -0.030086543411016464, 0.10497449338436127, 0.0074385651387274265, -0.019875744357705116, -0.05038612708449364, -0.05088425427675247, -0.03251982852816582, -0.07363326847553253, -0.059348080307245255, 0.022710157558321953, -0.05909065157175064, 0.011745793744921684, 0.025442443788051605, 0.01589771918952465, -0.04743645712733269, 0.05699794739484787, -0.046035297214984894, 0.037109795957803726, 0.00814067479223013, 0.04632986709475517, 0.033700890839099884, -0.01752350851893425, 0.022604215890169144, -0.0073807621374726295, -0.04234164208173752, 0.02772609144449234, -0.029827412217855453, 0.04419289156794548, -0.015860432758927345, -0.0035048441495746374, -0.01000041514635086, 0.007629737723618746, 0.00004612275006365962, -0.010815907269716263, -0.09246908873319626, -0.044144582003355026, -0.03671516478061676, -0.03962080180644989, 0.0019388151122257113, -0.025167472660541534, 0.009982475079596043, 0.0035885851830244064, -0.032224178314208984, 0.030021097511053085, -0.0373702198266983, -0.031100060790777206, 0.02658872865140438, -0.014752186834812164, -0.0355990007519722, 0.05636616796255112, 0.047430336475372314, -0.04819687828421593, -0.021611934527754784, -0.0281737819314003, 0.021700972691178322, 0.030360376462340355, -0.04658639058470726, 0.024256179109215736, -0.011538084596395493, -0.04956169053912163, -0.018201014026999474, -0.001174109405837953, -0.006487538106739521, 0.051076628267765045, 0.010636107996106148, 0.021857697516679764, 0.024109819903969765, 0.01207785215228796, 0.00945072341710329, 0.02759591117501259, -0.039164796471595764, -0.01247754693031311, -0.036907970905303955, -0.002351508941501379, 0.011376775801181793, 0.016703512519598007, -0.01586226187646389, 0.05913582444190979, 0.08770367503166199, -0.03565524145960808, 0.0009999522008001804, 0.08290845900774002, -0.0024184267967939377, 0.060401707887649536, 0.01944728009402752, 0.02231379970908165, 0.04584815725684166, 0.008942530490458012, -0.026683304458856583, -0.008734763599932194, 0.01172226294875145, 0.025802036747336388, 0.017823414877057076, 0.037222955375909805, -0.028892667964100838, -0.007276288233697414, -0.056388866156339645, 0.0010648200986906886, -0.008389769122004509, -0.014169646427035332, 0.06569560617208481, -0.0525997169315815, -0.042961236089468, 0.06898504495620728, -0.024105742573738098, 0.04696321487426758, -0.042843710631132126, 0.02280842699110508, -0.002371282083913684, -0.03334839642047882, -0.04260268807411194, -0.05701244994997978, 0.003905945224687457, 0.0013427305966615677, -0.01230121310800314, -0.0010379429440945387, -0.035788122564554214, -0.04038923978805542, -0.03262040764093399, -0.05893561989068985, -0.051261983811855316, -0.01156394463032484, 0.010278922505676746, -0.009743920527398586, 0.034654974937438965, -0.024679139256477356, -0.021614031866192818, -0.01904538832604885, 0.02649734914302826, 0.021863259375095367, -0.03434261307120323, 0.08155764639377594, 0.015112746506929398, -0.005729344207793474, -0.008223998360335827, 0.04374881833791733, -0.0025038691237568855, -0.0018347909208387136, -0.015659289434552193, 0.012191709131002426, 0.02934463694691658, 0.026708927005529404, 0.011115917935967445, 0.005552386399358511, 0.00486340606585145, 0.008427243679761887, -0.05362706258893013, -0.04295403137803078, 0.025309080258011818, -0.02787022292613983, 0.037021439522504807, 0.0037165782414376736, -0.01597967930138111, 0.026961499825119972, 0.05418363958597183, 0.011147351004183292, 0.035651493817567825, 0.02477942779660225, -0.02291729673743248, -0.05636477470397949, 0.011808731593191624, 0.0030193717684596777, 0.008132625371217728, -0.019744781777262688, -0.030245771631598473, 0.029848039150238037, -0.012051090598106384, 0.008268826641142368, 0.053915221244096756, 0.02232109196484089, 0.027706831693649292, 0.02126079984009266, 0.020855292677879333, -0.08570059388875961, -0.06806953996419907, 0.015746301040053368, 0.05442285165190697, -0.04498659074306488, 0.029533561319112778, 0.02780328504741192, 0.002956658834591508, 0.0030038212426006794, -0.01348218135535717, 0.01384740974754095, -0.017441920936107635, 0.0006211534491740167, 0.002169712446630001, -0.0404803641140461, 0.010147197172045708, -0.0010655507212504745, 0.014555901288986206, 0.017494244500994682, 0.010854511521756649, 0.021849386394023895, 0.033633820712566376, -0.047344572842121124, 0.0027315730694681406, 0.010544955730438232, 0.00908574927598238, -0.026242757216095924, 0.01005594152957201, -0.007468298077583313, 0.002206180477514863, -0.03459028899669647, -0.027660513296723366, 0.08170663565397263, -0.019856275990605354, -0.049300167709589005, 0.0012182865757495165, -0.03688432276248932, -0.0609307587146759, 0.07103021442890167, 0.050941530615091324, -0.02491299994289875, 0.006773445755243301, -0.0087171271443367, 0.0055964644998312, 0.03340580314397812, 0.006511310581117868, -0.02126474305987358, 0.0069467839784920216, 0.026766978204250336, -0.10917457193136215, -0.021211793646216393, -0.03501826152205467, 0.03387616574764252 ]
<p>Looking at the Moody chart I think to myself, the <em>friction factor</em> doesn't decrease much at all with Reynolds number after a certain point. I wonder if laminar flow is more efficient in a sense, and what sense would that be?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/1bIeg.jpg" alt="Moody diagram"></p> <p>I understand that in laminar flow you have clear lines that the fluid doesn't cross, whereas that wouldn't be true in turbulent flow. We could imagine a pipe with a divider placed in the middle to keep the fluid from mixing in eddies, but that would just create more friction with the divider. There are thinkable cases, however, where you could introduce a divider that moves along with the fluid, in particular, the Taylor-Couette flow...</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taylor%E2%80%93Couette_flow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taylor%E2%80%93Couette_flow</a></p> <p>This setup describes basically one cylinder rotating within another cylinder with a fluid in-between them.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/zA1r3.png" alt="Concentric rotating cylinders"></p> <p>Let's say that you kept the fluid the same, and the distance between the inner cylinder and outer cylinder the same. In that system, let's say you insert a divider at a radius in the middle of the annular area, and this divider was mostly buoyant in the fluid, so it's not experiencing friction on the edges, and it also is free to rotate with the fluid.</p> <p>Would doing so actually reduce the frictional torque on the rotating inner cylinder? If you could introduce an infinite number of infinitely thin dividers is there a theoretical limit to how much you could reduce the retarding torque? Would that just make it laminar, or laminar-ish?</p>
g7479
[ 0.019258297979831696, -0.019800754263997078, 0.02037810906767845, -0.04892970621585846, 0.014153063297271729, -0.07098309695720673, 0.093624047935009, -0.019669994711875916, -0.07335221022367477, -0.011519134044647217, 0.007980759255588055, -0.05106235295534134, -0.006345225498080254, -0.033199552446603775, 0.04584812372922897, 0.036379534751176834, -0.004998225253075361, -0.020607605576515198, 0.0026420135982334614, 0.03037823550403118, -0.0174575112760067, 0.041516419500112534, -0.008855392225086689, -0.027261905372142792, 0.06193375214934349, 0.006272231228649616, 0.0013317451812326908, 0.018294265493750572, -0.0462995246052742, 0.014276516623795033, 0.03146877512335777, 0.020807532593607903, 0.0364668034017086, -0.00935392640531063, -0.04275045916438103, 0.03133845701813698, 0.027062615379691124, 0.03295043110847473, -0.012904409319162369, -0.02573765628039837, 0.05800516530871391, -0.008239454589784145, -0.009120956994593143, -0.00017942654085345566, -0.046093594282865524, -0.020665254443883896, 0.010112274438142776, 0.0016819291049614549, -0.03586100786924362, 0.025244496762752533, -0.007401493843644857, -0.0724223256111145, -0.0066464911215007305, 0.023824768140912056, 0.012477959506213665, 0.031534161418676376, -0.03428937867283821, -0.0018050173530355096, -0.008707145228981972, 0.04483679309487343, 0.010135282762348652, -0.008562791161239147, -0.0252518393099308, -0.010286430828273296, -0.027768125757575035, -0.01113123819231987, 0.004576431587338448, 0.003986071329563856, 0.028893867507576942, 0.029165027663111687, -0.005900962743908167, -0.016830429434776306, 0.04925224557518959, -0.043806638568639755, -0.02652687579393387, 0.0370241217315197, -0.01020180992782116, -0.03366653248667717, 0.009300172328948975, -0.0397733598947525, -0.027495913207530975, -0.006530934013426304, -0.029439160600304604, 0.006871418561786413, 0.05480646342039108, 0.03012506663799286, 0.02329545095562935, -0.016675295308232307, -0.018175574019551277, 0.09325608611106873, 0.06295190006494522, -0.06851505488157272, 0.06293885409832001, 0.0060636079870164394, 0.03998643159866333, -0.054554615169763565, 0.015094923786818981, 0.010483050718903542, 0.012164758518338203, 0.005011989735066891, -0.01685478910803795, 0.00543959392234683, 0.030882716178894043, 0.039492081850767136, 0.01170389261096716, 0.00943397730588913, 0.00967035535722971, -0.01253457274287939, -0.041252512484788895, 0.02829483337700367, -0.028142530471086502, -0.05723165348172188, -0.012318497523665428, 0.013324489817023277, 0.02991010993719101, -0.019922979176044464, 0.051195986568927765, 0.027164921164512634, -0.018196426331996918, -0.0053056711331009865, -0.005293684545904398, 0.07291696965694427, 0.01830325834453106, 0.07633087784051895, 0.03259490802884102, 0.03564797341823578, 0.017066383734345436, 0.034029893577098846, 0.05669904872775078, -0.01259300485253334, 0.020943840965628624, -0.0009651101427152753, 0.038373105227947235, -0.0011425456032156944, -0.01869269087910652, 0.05482875555753708, -0.049150098115205765, 0.02546890825033188, -0.01958451233804226, 0.01123796310275793, 0.06171238422393799, -0.028700940310955048, -0.010280505754053593, -0.015979357063770294, -0.06476104259490967, -0.011123527772724628, -0.038669485598802567, -0.024652106687426567, -0.006587035022675991, 0.006269110832363367, 0.017939161509275436, -0.0415138378739357, 0.01391177624464035, 0.02442214824259281, -0.02470216527581215, 0.04656219109892845, 0.043223172426223755, -0.027495134621858597, 0.04007935896515846, 0.020496277138590813, 0.01597781293094158, -0.014202350750565529, 0.11386223882436752, -0.046136900782585144, -0.07918763160705566, 0.04365546256303787, -0.05918273329734802, -0.034249626100063324, -0.034046486020088196, -0.028433453291654587, -0.06264369189739227, -0.005698853638023138, -0.006197626236826181, -0.003418463282287121, 0.02420675940811634, 0.02383953332901001, 0.042954400181770325, 0.029330242425203323, -0.025582121685147285, 0.012060611508786678, -0.013240666128695011, 0.052177008241415024, 0.016991641372442245, -0.03012149967253208, 0.011544385924935341, -0.03250124678015709, -0.010401311330497265, -0.06599736958742142, -0.05939614400267601, 0.007114468142390251, 0.007950032129883766, 0.021265951916575432, 0.0014559491537511349, 0.05113423243165016, -0.07951395958662033, 0.018567733466625214, -0.03608066961169243, -0.006067746318876743, -0.1040067970752716, 0.018881214782595634, -0.01646762527525425, -0.007645464967936277, 0.033937420696020126, -0.002674202201887965, -0.017466675490140915, 0.014649265445768833, -0.008980766870081425, -0.01850857026875019, 0.013054396025836468, -0.011344400234520435, 0.06348606944084167, 0.02229134365916252, -0.047047536820173264, -0.024317312985658646, 0.01465301401913166, -0.0551748089492321, 0.02681470289826393, 0.01284361444413662, -0.009170050732791424, 0.013849190436303616, 0.00564896734431386, 0.01131194457411766, 0.0160660520195961, -0.009890272282063961, -0.0991935133934021, -0.011317972093820572, -0.018503624945878983, 0.011971410363912582, -0.03908373415470123, 0.02733186073601246, -0.01047690398991108, 0.011034661903977394, -0.0011637179413810372, -0.032820023596286774, 0.0018284233519807458, -0.011724296025931835, -0.02485603839159012, 0.03428272157907486, -0.0277597364038229, 0.05660366639494896, 0.04373077303171158, 0.026403063908219337, -0.04627777263522148, 0.006741390563547611, 0.029482295736670494, -0.06148551031947136, 0.02021760866045952, -0.049877870827913284, -0.020795203745365143, 0.03861541301012039, 0.0019504434894770384, -0.005055944435298443, -0.0174043420702219, 0.06003333255648613, 0.00395606504753232, 0.010583213530480862, -0.012369445525109768, 0.02739500068128109, -0.01712217926979065, -0.002634794684126973, -0.017922334372997284, 0.04730338603258133, 0.048411399126052856, 0.04101686179637909, -0.03599932789802551, 0.04323640093207359, -0.016653191298246384, 0.02006058394908905, 0.054819077253341675, 0.04720153287053108, -0.07053742557764053, 0.05019975081086159, 0.0020987915340811014, 0.005587601102888584, 0.0015489943325519562, 0.03118995577096939, 0.007253154646605253, 0.03346759453415871, -0.024426857009530067, -0.010621648281812668, 0.08144493401050568, 0.03568711504340172, -0.03200766071677208, 0.0609712116420269, 0.017376037314534187, -0.01526897493749857, -0.0055545601062476635, 0.01410689763724804, -0.017858492210507393, 0.011882688850164413, -0.0028864238411188126, 0.04228583723306656, 0.04511727765202522, -0.029939506202936172, 0.07038794457912445, 0.008957026526331902, 0.004447392653673887, -0.053143713623285294, -0.04292101413011551, -0.03852594643831253, -0.056655626744031906, 0.05345447361469269, -0.005992426071316004, 0.04316288232803345, -0.05104105547070503, -0.020056866109371185, -0.015307614579796791, -0.03235586732625961, -0.013398830778896809, -0.02198060415685177, 0.027070002630352974, 0.015347582288086414, -0.0307582076638937, -0.029031360521912575, -0.006823902018368244, -0.032020844519138336, 0.03284420073032379, -0.008338035084307194, 0.053303152322769165, 0.07239702343940735, -0.019289091229438782, -0.015589931979775429, 0.009182598441839218, -0.05425918847322464, 0.02304796874523163, 0.04316049441695213, -0.06345602869987488, -0.012135948985815048, -0.05906078219413757, 0.021287886425852776, -0.00695551885291934, 0.06158626824617386, -0.030177103355526924, 0.009372150525450706, -0.0037074193824082613, 0.019423050805926323, 0.002559792250394821, 0.02590339630842209, -0.0041252197697758675, -0.002221482340246439, -0.04716449975967407, -0.07023454457521439, -0.028287740424275398, -0.016582591459155083, -0.01975519023835659, 0.05801704153418541, -0.009969526901841164, -0.018995603546500206, 0.02094627171754837, 0.016938287764787674, 0.06944561004638672, -0.10151144862174988, 0.02208518236875534, -0.05558668076992035, 0.03141869232058525, -0.028435779735445976, -0.012959404848515987, 0.0370902344584465, -0.039732128381729126, 0.008964267559349537, -0.010745114646852016, -0.025932088494300842, 0.00592153100296855, -0.012785072438418865, 0.016148122027516365, 0.02929435670375824, 0.042558494955301285, -0.01844002678990364, -0.021209588274359703, -0.027014635503292084, -0.06933015584945679, 0.027652911841869354, -0.03727642446756363, -0.002801721915602684, 0.008313617669045925, -0.05960994213819504, 0.04422939941287041, 0.052803315222263336, 0.08554099500179291, 0.013093371875584126, 0.03369057923555374, -0.005275753792375326, -0.09657510370016098, 0.012985926121473312, -0.021762089803814888, 0.040208712220191956, -0.021092621609568596, -0.014499511569738388, 0.051778391003608704, -0.03335965424776077, -0.02792055904865265, 0.0184949804097414, 0.04249044507741928, 0.002730658510699868, -0.00806740578263998, 0.022696124389767647, -0.03139195591211319, -0.015407552011311054, -0.012783153913915157, 0.05371067300438881, 0.0331270694732666, -0.01800883188843727, -0.04731003940105438, 0.06245117634534836, -0.008824815973639488, -0.02075548656284809, 0.0550219863653183, 0.007418966386467218, 0.020200764760375023, -0.04714445769786835, 0.03671766817569733, -0.047133903950452805, -0.037245649844408035, -0.040262363851070404, 0.05688399448990822, -0.0037381809670478106, -0.042488958686590195, 0.0555618479847908, 0.005010651424527168, 0.026033632457256317, -0.012656929902732372, 0.05380362644791603, -0.027390703558921814, 0.04785560071468353, -0.04070321470499039, -0.05516047030687332, 0.0008627003408037126, 0.014549299143254757, -0.02793261595070362, -0.08229117095470428, 0.04821871966123581, 0.002819407731294632, -0.03732360154390335, -0.016277235001325607, -0.004387519787997007, 0.010761777870357037, 0.008518954738974571, -0.011662551201879978, -0.02984641306102276, -0.01815122179687023, -0.06288766115903854, -0.02875417470932007, 0.06755591183900833, 0.011748544871807098, -0.002204578137025237, 0.004864160902798176, 0.008246148936450481, -0.06861533224582672, 0.0179821215569973, 0.026178602129220963, -0.04829072952270508, -0.0244468841701746, 0.017318207770586014, -0.01164573896676302, -0.052482277154922485, -0.03196243196725845, -0.002504014177247882, 0.0036596464924514294, -0.010169407352805138, -0.02014531008899212, -0.01798802614212036, 0.003530035959556699, -0.03895735368132591, 0.03402729704976082, -0.057607293128967285, 0.045371487736701965, 0.008027898147702217, 0.004150115419179201, -0.06214113160967827, 0.005911915563046932, 0.012872188352048397, 0.03500741720199585, 0.019631000235676765, 0.029614418745040894, -0.022047441452741623, -0.027730943635106087, 0.02413427270948887, -0.025234658271074295, 0.055232010781764984, -0.06312039494514465, -0.01600765623152256, 0.03727584704756737, 0.0931069478392601, -0.020309604704380035, 0.02207229658961296, -0.015925731509923935, -0.07645834237337112, -0.01637527160346508, -0.03600000962615013, -0.010661453939974308, 0.01802276261150837, 0.04207754135131836, -0.023729000240564346, -0.016441121697425842, -0.01970716193318367, 0.014272374100983143, 0.056439463049173355, -0.043902426958084106, -0.01737581379711628, 0.0287089291960001, -0.052459366619586945, 0.036076322197914124, -0.017790505662560463, -0.048804283142089844, -0.03469092771410942, 0.006121236365288496, 0.00027981880703009665, -0.04798673093318939, -0.010287808254361153, 0.09020137786865234, -0.011454104445874691, -0.0008059471729211509, -0.015323103405535221, 0.0028817367274314165, 0.009168155491352081, -0.0046059428714215755, -0.039832305163145065, -0.018077470362186432, 0.0058069610968232155, 0.0034332559444010258, -0.019079340621829033, 0.018965354189276695, -0.036100346595048904, 0.05672379583120346, -0.04062046483159065, 0.05018649250268936, -0.060713592916727066, 0.032430414110422134, -0.07600659132003784, -0.0026365926023572683, 0.04723825305700302, 0.055881571024656296, 0.06294555217027664, 0.0923987403512001, -0.012348947115242481, -0.0018567865481600165, 0.044775642454624176, -0.03366546332836151, 0.0577765554189682, -0.01004780549556017, 0.020938917994499207, -0.033997323364019394, -0.0797036811709404, 0.03757910802960396, -0.007591904141008854, -0.02923034317791462, -0.09284251183271408, 0.007833815179765224, 0.034209687262773514, -0.051606472581624985, -0.053016528487205505, 0.03615162521600723, -0.0009035183466039598, 0.01743381656706333, -0.06569460779428482, 0.028161484748125076, 0.05704814940690994, -0.022285329177975655, 0.06324655562639236, 0.04144160822033882, 0.006609825417399406, 0.022197559475898743, -0.04105280712246895, 0.031505435705184937, -0.01037143636494875, -0.017851488664746284, 0.010725054889917374, -0.020588289946317673, 0.0633346289396286, 0.08058442920446396, 0.011290640570223331, -0.030508704483509064, 0.025919362902641296, 0.037570007145404816, 0.08253207802772522, 0.0018722150707617402, -0.024160923436284065, -0.007780808489769697, -0.04172579571604729, 0.018972007557749748, 0.02628430351614952, 0.022811705246567726, -0.03239036351442337, -0.06061610206961632, -0.004383227322250605, 0.06069844588637352, -0.03158841282129288, -0.01040283590555191, 0.035965558141469955, 0.0032786123920232058, -0.03535960242152214, -0.0184409748762846, 0.016214992851018906, 0.009506044909358025, 0.03143356367945671, 0.014357115142047405, -0.0061662751249969006, 0.024333279579877853, 0.04892764240503311, 0.023685205727815628, 0.005554183851927519, 0.026933444663882256, 0.04519817233085632, 0.014449047856032848, -0.037461329251527786, 0.012233845889568329, -0.01361542847007513, -0.02735316753387451, 0.011632852256298065, 0.03744314983487129, 0.05952975153923035, 0.006450200453400612, 0.03701498359441757, -0.006815980188548565, -0.018570516258478165, 0.05462063476443291, -0.04838521406054497, -0.037468209862709045, 0.038813214749097824, 0.022221945226192474, 0.05071791633963585, -0.0354599691927433, -0.006753008812665939, 0.02762014977633953, 0.03190603852272034, 0.07473775744438171, -0.07818020135164261, -0.00003143566573271528, 0.05461481213569641, -0.04304711893200874, 0.07493482530117035, 0.016687512397766113, -0.008745381608605385, 0.08705765753984451, -0.01075337827205658, -0.04391089081764221, -0.08091797679662704, -0.038319386541843414, 0.015272104181349277, 0.09415052086114883, -0.015900559723377228, 0.04846815764904022, 0.013572271913290024, 0.058612335473299026, 0.03310868516564369, -0.04396313801407814, 0.03330560773611069, 0.027492685243487358, -0.06142641603946686, 0.006061677820980549, -0.03995421156287193, -0.03133988007903099, -0.04540867730975151, 0.01837393082678318, -0.011141931638121605, -0.01060385163873434, 0.01826121099293232, -0.009895437397062778, -0.07467439025640488, 0.0509737990796566, 0.007405511103570461, 0.0020096914377063513, -0.0059617855586111546, 0.003273146925494075, 0.015856457874178886, -0.005883506033569574, 0.0007291760412044823, 0.044029202312231064, -0.02692117914557457, -0.01219013798981905, 0.03729778155684471, -0.019020680338144302, -0.07344279438257217, -0.007323791738599539, 0.000631993287242949, -0.008558505214750767, -0.00003011614717252087, -0.04647834971547127, -0.016560403630137444, 0.03587881475687027, -0.021945791319012642, -0.024152012541890144, 0.003756488673388958, -0.0007491931319236755, -0.020080547779798508, 0.05342266336083412, -0.02597707509994507, -0.007111620623618364, -0.06320321559906006, -0.09056859463453293, -0.021669834852218628, 0.05823882296681404, -0.0017374586313962936, 0.017938248813152313, -0.05369951203465462, 0.024383408948779106, -0.0035621870774775743, 0.04793288931250572, -0.019014565274119377, -0.0020296049769967794, -0.025216564536094666, -0.05826597660779953, -0.008482856675982475, 0.0030241585336625576, -0.0006841847207397223, 0.03927763178944588, -0.006733932998031378, 0.011703587137162685, -0.025094276294112206, 0.0404801145195961, -0.021809397265315056, 0.007365326397120953, 0.03886469081044197, -0.06524129211902618, -0.015134107321500778, 0.01874450407922268, -0.038869939744472504, -0.02960667572915554, 0.011616154573857784, 0.019537117332220078, -0.016346922144293785, 0.017012331634759903, 0.04215610399842262, -0.05886070057749748, -0.05425717681646347, -0.029549844563007355, 0.019323818385601044, -0.04752340540289879, -0.036711547523736954, -0.05876679718494415, -0.022626245394349098, 0.011858220212161541, 0.003350648330524564, 0.006509819068014622, -0.05079926922917366, -0.022378534078598022, 0.05634179338812828, 0.008073722943663597, -0.010527352802455425, 0.015446864999830723, -0.015391728840768337, -0.019657203927636147, 0.00356903113424778, -0.03133311867713928, 0.0008598848362453282, 0.03485161438584328, 0.016432277858257294, 0.05247178673744202, -0.027314672246575356, 0.020430080592632294, -0.011373802088201046, 0.003764934139326215, 0.006160315126180649, -0.037061259150505066, 0.07485318928956985, -0.04811679199337959, -0.026506949216127396, 0.02710193768143654, -0.031159162521362305, -0.023707397282123566, -0.025681592524051666, 0.04766597971320152, -0.03713800385594368, 0.016815200448036194, 0.004391053691506386, -0.034438904374837875, 0.037599362432956696, -0.03410990163683891 ]
<p>I was told by a former physicist that he thinks that the now dormant S-Matrix Theory has the potential to lead to a breakthrough in formulating a Grand Unified Theory. He stated several reasons for this; all of which I do not remember except for one: The non-linearity of the differential equations that constitute it could mean that we could apply Dynamical Systems Theory to it, which could lead to a breakthrough in the unification of QM and GR. </p> <p>Can anyone add this or elucidate on why this theory has this potential, and what would be the potential avenues for exploring it? </p>
g7480
[ -0.022029396146535873, 0.07824864983558655, -0.008927111513912678, 0.037154991179704666, -0.01141863688826561, -0.004659467376768589, 0.039695173501968384, 0.033095452934503555, -0.0007937821210362017, -0.033067092299461365, -0.005690441001206636, 0.026025524362921715, 0.04454198107123375, -0.0029647524934262037, -0.02917424589395523, -0.011962242424488068, 0.0024357724469155073, 0.04067850857973099, -0.029853690415620804, -0.03201517462730408, 0.00936149712651968, -0.0245730672031641, 0.05151553079485893, -0.02187246084213257, -0.056282173842191696, -0.01598537527024746, 0.05729517340660095, 0.025332225486636162, 0.014495550654828548, 0.03361719846725464, 0.02763347700238228, -0.09273509681224823, 0.033066194504499435, -0.043593455106019974, 0.01753915846347809, 0.021375689655542374, 0.05221129581332207, 0.015560783445835114, 0.04792708531022072, -0.01847865805029869, 0.016010485589504242, -0.05212540552020073, 0.005788756534457207, -0.024058256298303604, -0.006896377075463533, -0.008531609550118446, 0.013621198944747448, -0.04074757546186447, 0.02263377420604229, -0.02622400037944317, 0.018472973257303238, 0.06144595891237259, 0.08014810085296631, -0.04295008257031441, -0.03563230484724045, 0.015317321754992008, 0.044633958488702774, 0.030461061745882034, 0.02995586208999157, -0.05041993781924248, -0.028654253110289574, 0.034456562250852585, 0.06251537054777145, -0.042312122881412506, 0.03825249522924423, 0.027928274124860764, -0.03750940039753914, -0.042575251311063766, 0.011895333416759968, -0.036148592829704285, -0.036096636205911636, -0.017888961359858513, 0.055501461029052734, -0.03472971171140671, 0.0035470277070999146, 0.06643693894147873, 0.034252215176820755, -0.025573544204235077, 0.010218501091003418, -0.037231504917144775, -0.019135521724820137, -0.03362511098384857, 0.08630961179733276, -0.015913644805550575, 0.04310261830687523, -0.018586892634630203, 0.005361017771065235, 0.007767018862068653, 0.0299394391477108, -0.0006153506692498922, 0.046747952699661255, 0.05142592638731003, -0.03152104467153549, 0.013297232799232006, -0.0437542088329792, -0.04130827262997627, 0.02586684748530388, 0.005980857647955418, 0.0027296743355691433, -0.008952003903687, -0.05418501794338226, -0.04294540733098984, 0.04444313421845436, -0.05988265201449394, 0.008638978935778141, 0.027173208072781563, -0.017162997275590897, -0.001122707617469132, 0.0013903914950788021, 0.06806733459234238, -0.014043728820979595, 0.04015003889799118, -0.03991556912660599, 0.018714886158704758, -0.0147477388381958, -0.013271970674395561, 0.048236239701509476, -0.07230290025472641, -0.025529196485877037, -0.005737092811614275, 0.005501591134816408, 0.01952008157968521, -0.038991913199424744, -0.00009729050361784175, -0.048548679798841476, 0.03931238502264023, 0.009392124600708485, 0.020969688892364502, 0.002390462439507246, -0.022941259667277336, 0.05019311606884003, 0.020992523059248924, -0.0646081492304802, 0.06168597191572189, 0.0700826346874237, 0.028488432988524437, -0.042253248393535614, 0.011773418635129929, 0.034659553319215775, 0.030151769518852234, 0.0019202776020392776, -0.03796329349279404, -0.05449417605996132, 0.024569259956479073, 0.031778573989868164, -0.027333244681358337, 0.017722325399518013, 0.07629518210887909, -0.04885699972510338, 0.005587863735854626, -0.021079592406749725, 0.06668207794427872, -0.0068146418780088425, -0.07060501724481583, -0.025204448029398918, 0.015498770400881767, -0.03391758352518082, -0.055723775178194046, -0.04148605465888977, -0.11407465487718582, 0.01561246532946825, -0.00446747662499547, 0.0007590703316964209, -0.05341137945652008, -0.057737063616514206, -0.02421083301305771, 0.011489671654999256, -0.07406632602214813, -0.025366555899381638, -0.03696589916944504, -0.03317840024828911, 0.058111608028411865, 0.034565385431051254, 0.057771727442741394, -0.022218292579054832, 0.07883443683385849, 0.03264957293868065, -0.05725922808051109, 0.05111875757575035, 0.019568031653761864, -0.058842699974775314, -0.04510458558797836, -0.007894977927207947, -0.051563944667577744, 0.04751167446374893, 0.07949494570493698, 0.029339751228690147, 0.043117914348840714, 0.00792328268289566, 0.0319518968462944, -0.011959963478147984, -0.044583674520254135, 0.03439803421497345, 0.017297176644206047, 0.055710069835186005, 0.0101469149813056, 0.006718946620821953, -0.013488028198480606, -0.061454419046640396, 0.034544724971055984, -0.06654178351163864, 0.04193127155303955, 0.01113261841237545, -0.03361021727323532, 0.02581755444407463, 0.040159352123737335, 0.006535080261528492, 0.037535008043050766, 0.028042182326316833, 0.018008993938565254, 0.025577446445822716, -0.013478194363415241, 0.06179001182317734, -0.00202848925255239, -0.05108074098825455, -0.016567878425121307, 0.03496003895998001, -0.04845819249749184, 0.017324645072221756, 0.07818024605512619, -0.027484700083732605, 0.012841803021728992, -0.01603780686855316, 0.061653949320316315, -0.00753214443102479, 0.05774868279695511, -0.026705751195549965, -0.05815820023417473, -0.027161166071891785, 0.007705580908805132, -0.05416609346866608, 0.01265999861061573, -0.013761671259999275, -0.08584242314100266, 0.03841611370444298, 0.030916566029191017, 0.01836642064154148, -0.050358131527900696, 0.03178270161151886, 0.04486452788114548, -0.01823626086115837, -0.01737147942185402, 0.013071090914309025, 0.03480566665530205, -0.025216128677129745, -0.02525218389928341, -0.03553583472967148, -0.01977279782295227, 0.011376487091183662, 0.007509215269237757, -0.01191682554781437, 0.007093524560332298, -0.0462118461728096, -0.017554212361574173, 0.0005681661423295736, -0.009393098764121532, 0.02082052268087864, 0.05127054825425148, -0.04994992911815643, -0.03020053543150425, 0.00206046923995018, 0.0049173529259860516, -0.04289543256163597, 0.0008432348258793354, -0.012314238585531712, -0.005836517550051212, 0.0018107183277606964, -0.05609118938446045, -0.0743865892291069, -0.0024731496814638376, -0.01500776782631874, 0.04053932800889015, 0.024605631828308105, -0.003854373935610056, -0.04034813493490219, 0.059354521334171295, 0.03278577700257301, 0.036691028624773026, -0.0005671014077961445, -0.06050631403923035, -0.04898763820528984, -0.03206983581185341, 0.004802284296602011, 0.009716776199638844, 0.0021866182796657085, -0.07340473681688309, 0.01661669835448265, 0.05390945449471474, 0.008282395079731941, 0.002349538030102849, -0.02005096711218357, 0.027873007580637932, -0.006502219475805759, -0.024637725204229355, -0.11035261303186417, 0.04474460333585739, 0.03134295716881752, -0.033175669610500336, -0.029394878074526787, -0.027342451736330986, -0.020125513896346092, -0.053207382559776306, 0.013864203356206417, 0.009892753325402737, 0.0037597438786178827, 0.039269544184207916, -0.06542150676250458, 0.015413383021950722, -0.04330786317586899, -0.0021209854166954756, 0.0012039626017212868, 0.031055191531777382, -0.006731558125466108, -0.05793345719575882, -0.023307859897613525, -0.006742569617927074, -0.012668706476688385, 0.03893717750906944, 0.007721342146396637, -0.011866213753819466, -0.09030398726463318, -0.08705291897058487, -0.03371924161911011, -0.03616304323077202, 0.0037577785551548004, -0.00004634389915736392, -0.02100803330540657, -0.00794888287782669, -0.039204709231853485, 0.002433996181935072, 0.005621449556201696, -0.019413486123085022, 0.003538678865879774, 0.025316962972283363, -0.01468399353325367, -0.008394061587750912, 0.0031147722620517015, -0.01742725819349289, 0.031113427132368088, -0.027999676764011383, -0.06032367795705795, -0.030260980129241943, 0.0002717844326980412, -0.025330856442451477, -0.03526753559708595, 0.018362892791628838, -0.005251626949757338, -0.029761532321572304, 0.005614220630377531, 0.01499222032725811, -0.023085180670022964, 0.019894540309906006, -0.006521117873489857, -0.010557339526712894, -0.008805290795862675, 0.017472421750426292, 0.04017805680632591, 0.08663211017847061, -0.003092091763392091, 0.02408083900809288, -0.04411999508738518, 0.0054277293384075165, 0.03483852744102478, 0.014396822080016136, 0.06242810934782028, 0.055442482233047485, -0.042959585785865784, -0.014911478385329247, -0.02350829355418682, 0.014635702595114708, 0.023495350033044815, 0.0031129452399909496, -0.04517868533730507, -0.012532377615571022, 0.08495711535215378, 0.011164923198521137, -0.011540918610990047, -0.006943733897060156, -0.006380690261721611, 0.01410579588264227, 0.029377974569797516, 0.029233621433377266, 0.008839594200253487, 0.05667240172624588, 0.040713176131248474, 0.05683786794543266, -0.016416581347584724, 0.022479599341750145, -0.05538417771458626, -0.022750278934836388, -0.015187879092991352, 0.05192016065120697, -0.011247595772147179, -0.007587713189423084, -0.03866839408874512, 0.036785949021577835, -0.025602679699659348, -0.037154801189899445, 0.00040110156987793744, 0.004658307880163193, 0.008483056910336018, -0.02600952982902527, 0.011855566874146461, -0.024557923898100853, -0.04116662219166756, -0.05018823221325874, 0.00917851086705923, -0.023431845009326935, -0.0023853532038629055, -0.020460739731788635, -0.00005313539077178575, 0.01240141224116087, 0.03783726319670677, -0.07148969918489456, 0.03151136636734009, 0.04111820459365845, -0.005479247774928808, -0.04865037649869919, 0.00007184138667071238, 0.01112944632768631, 0.009643711149692535, 0.058521293103694916, 0.012137684971094131, 0.01766286976635456, -0.007001001853495836, -0.024110782891511917, -0.013659048825502396, -0.022888023406267166, 0.00613081781193614, -0.03533680737018585, 0.04353411868214607, 0.021936608478426933, -0.0180345606058836, -0.02075125277042389, -0.026835868135094643, 0.005781842395663261, -0.000923044397495687, 0.010699463076889515, -0.04486716911196709, 0.044956453144550323, 0.030872292816638947, 0.01171148382127285, 0.03727051988244057, 0.014319137670099735, 0.04828544706106186, 0.029400432482361794, 0.041328996419906616, -0.013473247177898884, -0.02408468909561634, -0.01217041164636612, -0.005512190982699394, -0.0005650155944749713, 0.01630389876663685, 0.012788128107786179, -0.054822731763124466, -0.032819055020809174, -0.07960433512926102, 0.008361568674445152, -0.008074011653661728, 0.08925430476665497, -0.016694247722625732, -0.004319208674132824, -0.007595217786729336, 0.016014091670513153, 0.08289825171232224, -0.0399862602353096, -0.028524355962872505, 0.03751087933778763, -0.04097732901573181, -0.045116011053323746, 0.030855383723974228, 0.04287342727184296, 0.04194096475839615, 0.04238933324813843, -0.03470952436327934, -0.04835563153028488, -0.003202430671080947, -0.02607373520731926, 0.09064245223999023, -0.017873765900731087, 0.005777766462415457, 0.057756517082452774, 0.056364819407463074, 0.04262896254658699, 0.028513040393590927, 0.055937714874744415, -0.04394765570759773, -0.01538146659731865, -0.07250354439020157, -0.023211218416690826, 0.07260740548372269, 0.05382126197218895, 0.008885238319635391, -0.028194701299071312, 0.0138239786028862, 0.010815718211233616, 0.005357326474040747, -0.0360114723443985, -0.06098054721951485, -0.024411680176854134, -0.01073895301669836, 0.04528162628412247, 0.005498107522726059, 0.02930551953613758, 0.04598410055041313, -0.005367412231862545, 0.027087382972240448, -0.021321680396795273, 0.0026821387000381947, -0.019058048725128174, 0.004631131887435913, -0.06042454391717911, -0.011906859464943409, 0.04187692701816559, 0.003906292375177145, 0.01581745222210884, -0.013396970927715302, -0.03109493851661682, -0.00765436515212059, -0.035676728934049606, -0.014419982209801674, -0.021023480221629143, 0.007225794717669487, -0.06825365126132965, 0.01966494508087635, 0.03903641551733017, 0.0003555622242856771, 0.04149957001209259, 0.015151320956647396, 0.01442362554371357, 0.007621909026056528, -0.0797358825802803, 0.023218998685479164, 0.01883900910615921, 0.0592937208712101, 0.013125195167958736, 0.023740015923976898, 0.0022312800865620375, -0.005086948629468679, -0.002950635040178895, 0.007726018317043781, 0.006453924812376499, 0.018343141302466393, 0.003924870863556862, -0.017763929441571236, -0.07747812569141388, -0.01718645729124546, -0.0017272724071517587, 0.032218050211668015, -0.02853289246559143, -0.04058283939957619, -0.028705984354019165, -0.05939149484038353, -0.03480426222085953, -0.006318415515124798, 0.05369891598820686, -0.07056621462106705, -0.03288111835718155, -0.005750985816121101, 0.05230209603905678, 0.044154804199934006, 0.007338945288211107, 0.013319591991603374, 0.013674499467015266, 0.024083491414785385, 0.01609945483505726, 0.01808364875614643, 0.007649995386600494, 0.1140495017170906, 0.024412240833044052, -0.03652601316571236, 0.048856500536203384, 0.03447785973548889, 0.06234364211559296, -0.026015738025307655, -0.08152211457490921, 0.03658714517951012, -0.0267353393137455, -0.0455126017332077, -0.02180783636868, -0.02465970069169998, 0.009120864793658257, 0.09886172413825989, -0.007242471445351839, -0.01734236441552639, 0.033346615731716156, -0.07735805958509445, 0.02783183567225933, 0.008298843167722225, 0.081938236951828, 0.040305718779563904, 0.02647557482123375, -0.031490832567214966, 0.007829287089407444, -0.06017689406871796, 0.012003728188574314, 0.004121058154851198, 0.0026126038283109665, -0.003337666392326355, 0.009464395232498646, -0.00234741042368114, 0.005656893830746412, 0.04673955217003822, 0.006917236372828484, 0.015665575861930847, 0.05389782413840294, -0.017593123018741608, -0.004420694895088673, 0.010594055987894535, -0.006590777542442083, 0.006524188444018364, 0.02569115348160267, 0.02154216356575489, 0.014196879230439663, 0.03969765454530716, -0.03873950615525246, 0.028308497741818428, -0.014234697446227074, -0.044141028076410294, 0.05647243186831474, -0.004092935007065535, 0.04256968945264816, 0.0009722391841933131, -0.03690631315112114, -0.02286091074347496, 0.006525426171720028, -0.03327525034546852, -0.054896727204322815, 0.03878392279148102, 0.04603556916117668, -0.03456432372331619, -0.012657598592340946, 0.08367516845464706, -0.012119410559535027, -0.004223925061523914, -0.014106042683124542, -0.005211499519646168, 0.014015600085258484, 0.011478698812425137, -0.0377470999956131, -0.04488065466284752, -0.020764250308275223, 0.033461861312389374, -0.04116123542189598, 0.0036982058081775904, 0.020709296688437462, 0.04940420761704445, 0.0027334580663591623, 0.018087688833475113, 0.01365702599287033, 0.06004473567008972, -0.04068116471171379, -0.024346986785531044, 0.01605416089296341, -0.04016577824950218, 0.0040816981345415115, 0.021998383104801178, -0.03137992322444916, 0.118392214179039, 0.02330860309302807, -0.009482164867222309, -0.0193155650049448, 0.03365546092391014, -0.01613742485642433, -0.011495811864733696, 0.036487411707639694, 0.03201734647154808, -0.05932554602622986, 0.031988684087991714, -0.011162356473505497, 0.007769238203763962, -0.0412113182246685, -0.02364727295935154, -0.046080876141786575, 0.012790781445801258, 0.013765787705779076, -0.017563343048095703, 0.0013543893583118916, -0.0369483083486557, 0.017607856541872025, 0.018311213701963425, 0.020157108083367348, -0.026753755286335945, 0.015991585329174995, -0.022650083526968956, 0.021589113399386406, 0.04488168656826019, 0.04836222156882286, -0.0778239518404007, 0.004278544336557388, -0.021145343780517578, -0.01379362866282463, -0.0606614425778389, 0.003192847827449441, -0.03704925626516342, 0.017241252586245537, -0.02050950564444065, 0.04622248187661171, 0.012650374323129654, 0.0724652037024498, -0.05965305492281914, -0.02074347250163555, -0.051960621029138565, 0.025778649374842644, 0.030175412073731422, -0.001520582940429449, 0.019940044730901718, -0.042605627328157425, -0.022399434819817543, 0.03438020497560501, -0.07109338045120239, 0.029859550297260284, -0.021320369094610214, 0.037659090012311935, 0.007244456559419632, -0.026518506929278374, -0.012285140343010426, 0.0196676068007946, 0.007741880603134632, 0.0033260227646678686, -0.0031686171423643827, -0.0008526866440661252, -0.007699864450842142, -0.05420876294374466, -0.05151437595486641, 0.013695898465812206, 0.05934974551200867, -0.028890276327729225, -0.02858969010412693, -0.041149161756038666, -0.024611253291368484, -0.035850729793310165, -0.051274046301841736, 0.005105768330395222, -0.02654455043375492, -0.006260593421757221, -0.027735479176044464, 0.01585051789879799, -0.010862483642995358, 0.017113175243139267, -0.004598039668053389, -0.0408005490899086, 0.03492312878370285, -0.02580897882580757, 0.03299302980303764, 0.018298543989658356, -0.007609374821186066, 0.00647664163261652, 0.034986793994903564, -0.032811619341373444, -0.015080196782946587, -0.024500498548150063, -0.015946101397275925, 0.04061378166079521, 0.12822680175304413, -0.04826957359910011, -0.017062708735466003, 0.057735953480005264, -0.011539427563548088, -0.010618171654641628, 0.05370667204260826, 0.016386544331908226, 0.00505880918353796, -0.026072120293974876, -0.04868341609835625, -0.013543389737606049, -0.034432657063007355, 0.01774747483432293 ]
<p>Given that the boiling point of a liquid is the temperature at which the vapor pressure is equal to the ambient (surrounding) pressure, what significance does a liquid's vapor pressure have in the formation of bubbles that happens at and above the boiling point? </p> <p>The definition of boiling point seems to imply that the pressure inside of the bubbles must be at least as great as the liquid's vapor pressure in order to balance the outside pressure, but is there any particular reason why the pressure inside of the bubbles is related to the vapor pressure? </p> <p>The vapor pressure seems to be a measurement describing the tendency of the molecules to escape from the surface of the liquid, but I don't see how that relates to bubble formation within the liquid.</p> <p>This question has bothered me for a while, so any help would be much appreciated.</p>
g7481
[ -0.013211709447205067, -0.019690485671162605, 0.00329990335740149, 0.023590702563524246, 0.011002986691892147, 0.055654652416706085, 0.009833704680204391, 0.05121602118015289, -0.04442779719829559, 0.0007254122756421566, -0.0523219034075737, -0.005249784328043461, -0.0042272768914699554, 0.02246561087667942, 0.008650359697639942, -0.04763208329677582, -0.00008532722131349146, -0.027861980721354485, -0.020412564277648926, -0.03082994557917118, -0.010823766700923443, -0.021121984347701073, -0.027313275262713432, -0.038327571004629135, -0.07400759309530258, -0.03627482429146767, 0.028087357059121132, -0.010521003976464272, 0.008535451255738735, 0.04317184165120125, -0.0014007030986249447, 0.06314690411090851, 0.014107205905020237, -0.03623269125819206, 0.010831033810973167, -0.04806967079639435, 0.004389248788356781, 0.027867930009961128, -0.011603332124650478, -0.027435418218374252, 0.03930133953690529, 0.02907368540763855, -0.012816325761377811, 0.027349170297384262, -0.020143982023000717, -0.006709476467221975, -0.0030649227555841208, -0.0032460640650242567, -0.04601318761706352, -0.026768991723656654, 0.0265441183000803, 0.017510415986180305, -0.018275221809744835, -0.00959406141191721, 0.053857434540987015, -0.005513483192771673, 0.024062512442469597, 0.007615347392857075, 0.012195304967463017, 0.008777257055044174, 0.043290670961141586, 0.008938949555158615, -0.02491515874862671, 0.02567574754357338, 0.03185439482331276, 0.04397626966238022, -0.1115872785449028, 0.007932907901704311, 0.011651935987174511, 0.05095306411385536, 0.02313205972313881, -0.04060722514986992, -0.058080822229385376, 0.0018357806839048862, -0.08787140995264053, -0.008738331496715546, -0.015884751453995705, -0.04917384311556816, 0.029696054756641388, 0.04127568379044533, 0.048872146755456924, -0.007141521666198969, 0.013840515166521072, 0.04178685322403908, 0.08153536170721054, -0.006715331692248583, -0.0043784379959106445, -0.0310573261231184, -0.07146918773651123, 0.035365693271160126, 0.03851863369345665, 0.018622230738401413, 0.06409473717212677, -0.017995521426200867, -0.023356053978204727, 0.005046585109084845, 0.05359118431806564, -0.0212217029184103, 0.00449488265439868, 0.025624677538871765, -0.005055131856352091, -0.0007055400055833161, 0.05210116133093834, 0.0732220709323883, -0.03407479077577591, 0.031689271330833435, 0.028185434639453888, -0.00893620029091835, -0.011211752891540527, -0.0316065214574337, 0.01506732776761055, -0.01669221557676792, -0.05928410217165947, -0.018454736098647118, -0.029360320419073105, 0.026417331770062447, 0.009225531481206417, 0.06340830773115158, 0.02617715857923031, 0.07955650240182877, 0.026903223246335983, 0.04973219707608223, -0.015849648043513298, -0.02953074499964714, 0.02478547766804695, 0.03328332304954529, 0.00757612194865942, 0.022612862288951874, 0.011867617256939411, 0.012372516095638275, 0.040538132190704346, 0.03685392811894417, -0.05488233640789986, -0.05496366694569588, 0.05328633636236191, 0.05871567875146866, -0.034864794462919235, -0.0034151531290262938, 0.03312188759446144, -0.004008591175079346, 0.008898081257939339, 0.07960169017314911, -0.015423017553985119, -0.009214948862791061, 0.012876993976533413, 0.028162607923150063, -0.006148233078420162, 0.04085295647382736, -0.02954457886517048, -0.026357749477028847, -0.027948051691055298, 0.045694079250097275, 0.04779341071844101, -0.03949781507253647, 0.01810133457183838, 0.020605012774467468, -0.043945327401161194, -0.024059025570750237, 0.00984192080795765, 0.03967515751719475, 0.03677522763609886, -0.05138711631298065, 0.02261635661125183, 0.03889213129878044, -0.07294947654008865, 0.0037827191408723593, -0.006990768481045961, 0.02442554384469986, -0.04840056970715523, -0.03238113597035408, -0.043231528252363205, 0.022698985412716866, -0.007771263364702463, -0.0010983208194375038, 0.07366105169057846, 0.026594582945108414, 0.06600131094455719, 0.019331127405166626, 0.07141555845737457, 0.02026292309165001, -0.0028531744610518217, -0.056163787841796875, 0.009359716437757015, -0.02523976005613804, -0.013155289925634861, -0.00838943850249052, 0.03973490372300148, -0.03337390348315239, -0.055574942380189896, 0.028927017003297806, 0.04004531353712082, -0.03230755403637886, -0.01699596829712391, -0.02204562909901142, -0.040278561413288116, -0.07212042808532715, 0.042739562690258026, -0.011208241805434227, -0.027327096089720726, 0.04005943983793259, -0.06651347130537033, 0.00249579269438982, 0.013013116084039211, -0.033973328769207, -0.020400729030370712, 0.04586157947778702, 0.008418982848525047, 0.07869265228509903, -0.007599578704684973, 0.05262818932533264, -0.059555020183324814, 0.02455184794962406, 0.005208922084420919, -0.034689001739025116, -0.02632952108979225, 0.021843351423740387, -0.012159891426563263, -0.005763966590166092, -0.012923951260745525, 0.028655581176280975, -0.033132895827293396, 0.004874637816101313, -0.010125727392733097, 0.03420336917042732, -0.0551004558801651, -0.029419194906949997, 0.0036829072050750256, -0.036597102880477905, -0.0061955866403877735, 0.04013874754309654, -0.047954853624105453, -0.02404170110821724, 0.029522007331252098, -0.012956906110048294, -0.009750675410032272, -0.012211529538035393, 0.013539307750761509, 0.04783828184008598, 0.023084402084350586, 0.014572682790458202, -0.029755886644124985, 0.0014374125748872757, -0.07292327284812927, 0.06402367353439331, 0.006984803359955549, -0.026827393099665642, -0.026005402207374573, -0.039020050317049026, -0.04209941625595093, 0.036077745258808136, -0.00348535249941051, 0.066340371966362, 0.051512058824300766, -0.03009140118956566, -0.017318444326519966, -0.03334178030490875, 0.011651110835373402, -0.000499541056342423, -0.05820127949118614, -0.04079575836658478, 0.025774173438549042, 0.013925724662840366, 0.003282953053712845, -0.04846072196960449, -0.055663201957941055, 0.03504013642668724, 0.03126964345574379, -0.03639976680278778, 0.03579605743288994, -0.0012742297258228064, 0.04199380427598953, 0.019193165004253387, -0.03420792520046234, 0.007739434018731117, 0.013371665962040424, -0.10411397367715836, -0.03301570191979408, -0.006406664382666349, 0.01810731552541256, -0.005935405846685171, -0.02623113989830017, -0.03354538977146149, -0.07111503183841705, 0.019501710310578346, -0.02127331867814064, -0.041276559233665466, 0.05494272708892822, 0.024232231080532074, 0.03487037867307663, -0.027184652164578438, 0.03177531808614731, -0.029154261574149132, -0.036320760846138, 0.03365214541554451, 0.0659824088215828, 0.021124424412846565, 0.024846700951457024, 0.01885179802775383, -0.02979404665529728, -0.062099482864141464, -0.0242177601903677, -0.05059555172920227, -0.01636163890361786, -0.012086714617908001, 0.04393390566110611, 0.043886031955480576, -0.036108508706092834, 0.021402163431048393, -0.04684503749012947, -0.01936795562505722, 0.007045060396194458, -0.010180134326219559, -0.02165144868195057, -0.016614345833659172, -0.0038119517266750336, 0.05670489743351936, 0.019863052293658257, 0.058972276747226715, 0.0010196855291724205, -0.03796883299946785, -0.09356648474931717, 0.021314380690455437, -0.004548997618257999, 0.019724035635590553, 0.04896532744169235, 0.028144948184490204, -0.029163021594285965, -0.0028810780495405197, -0.01110752858221531, -0.01599440909922123, 0.0026646966580301523, -0.031458742916584015, -0.027502337470650673, 0.00257498980499804, 0.013082509860396385, -0.05717123672366142, -0.04024123772978783, -0.010664570145308971, 0.006882043089717627, -0.00911604892462492, 0.0847388282418251, -0.00828868430107832, 0.015539227053523064, 0.03117203339934349, -0.01560854259878397, -0.02110804244875908, -0.002519757952541113, 0.02822466567158699, 0.01808158867061138, 0.023230712860822678, 0.055775195360183716, -0.0032437124755233526, 0.007046686951071024, 0.0016849824460223317, -0.022558273747563362, -0.004029699135571718, 0.01787952147424221, 0.005610132124274969, -0.05464198440313339, -0.044444385915994644, 0.023309258744120598, -0.024532103911042213, 0.055704474449157715, 0.001508642453700304, -0.04765352979302406, -0.0623728446662426, -0.008627956733107567, 0.0033850055187940598, -0.051132768392562866, -0.01790493354201317, -0.036026906222105026, 0.018960323184728622, -0.015590226277709007, -0.020439397543668747, 0.039763446897268295, -0.05591512471437454, 0.07604508846998215, 0.013376833871006966, -0.07597167044878006, -0.0379551500082016, 0.06251110881567001, 0.01739203743636608, -0.03590025752782822, 0.022490181028842926, 0.04414578527212143, -0.0066097937524318695, -0.06267422437667847, 0.05693020671606064, 0.02248973771929741, -0.07021250575780869, -0.04095088690519333, -0.04327894374728203, -0.0029242343734949827, 0.0052219778299331665, 0.01353765930980444, 0.03223271667957306, 0.011720954440534115, 0.026641448959708214, 0.029407799243927002, 0.015756117179989815, 0.019334319978952408, -0.058231692761182785, 0.03225082904100418, 0.01022056769579649, 0.01654260978102684, -0.008739112876355648, 0.06725254654884338, -0.012701436877250671, 0.0017564304871484637, -0.020570045337080956, 0.059017181396484375, 0.04344503954052925, -0.022540900856256485, 0.0053285821340978146, -0.05643603578209877, -0.03837255761027336, 0.015183654613792896, -0.01338190771639347, 0.045353058725595474, 0.022182650864124298, -0.05264568328857422, -0.05310436338186264, 0.057957395911216736, -0.010932601056993008, -0.019592951983213425, 0.02049568109214306, 0.05402519181370735, -0.01903325319290161, -0.039059482514858246, -0.037209995090961456, -0.05333241447806358, 0.07744743674993515, -0.03303122520446777, 0.031298451125621796, 0.017602495849132538, 0.023034334182739258, -0.006298869848251343, -0.011107183992862701, -0.012432401068508625, -0.03932308405637741, -0.0019057539757341146, -0.016606690362095833, -0.020441867411136627, 0.04358317703008652, -0.011810343712568283, -0.009954246692359447, -0.015481993556022644, 0.022670160979032516, -0.051637597382068634, -0.08206047117710114, -0.040001608431339264, 0.03999093547463417, 0.013012610375881195, -0.04189245030283928, -0.08176030218601227, 0.028017671778798103, 0.031571920961141586, -0.01933504454791546, -0.02236451394855976, 0.0038810214027762413, 0.007066790014505386, -0.022315772250294685, -0.0534709095954895, 0.03444661200046539, 0.035239119082689285, -0.014342603273689747, -0.05592373013496399, -0.07388827949762344, -0.038361504673957825, 0.03965863212943077, 0.027155529707670212, 0.025002827867865562, 0.07166872918605804, 0.08402658998966217, 0.03728058561682701, 0.08466576039791107, -0.01586540788412094, -0.029217440634965897, 0.016385721042752266, -0.05415986850857735, -0.011019292287528515, 0.055266693234443665, 0.04568053409457207, 0.03680610656738281, -0.011213384568691254, -0.00045514755765907466, -0.012888496741652489, -0.00817881803959608, 0.04177185148000717, 0.00997128151357174, 0.008764918893575668, 0.006588063668459654, 0.030077513307332993, 0.0011248703813180327, -0.009429451078176498, -0.06933028250932693, 0.038405030965805054, 0.027723325416445732, 0.044108033180236816, 0.04733210429549217, -0.04535506293177605, 0.003941126633435488, 0.020144252106547356, 0.02928188629448414, 0.03372032195329666, 0.025833062827587128, -0.024503612890839577, -0.013139034621417522, 0.04362056404352188, -0.004103695508092642, -0.03370893746614456, 0.020148780196905136, -0.011348802596330643, 0.009348227642476559, 0.07828525453805923, -0.018504543229937553, -0.004266031086444855, -0.06289160251617432, -0.06042690575122833, 0.03125458583235741, -0.007775259204208851, -0.013290573842823505, -0.013586193323135376, 0.04609590023756027, 0.016127178445458412, 0.03605921193957329, -0.029706060886383057, 0.011977605521678925, 0.003959765657782555, -0.013592916540801525, -0.03572619706392288, -0.030508005991578102, 0.10480266064405441, 0.01178829837590456, -0.01234840601682663, 0.027789859101176262, -0.08674569427967072, 0.004448371939361095, 0.07954215258359909, 0.027801355347037315, 0.009497362188994884, -0.02888159267604351, -0.06392425298690796, 0.003784007392823696, 0.03005419671535492, 0.0480818934738636, -0.034665387123823166, 0.01857198029756546, -0.011330747976899147, -0.011587877757847309, 0.024602219462394714, 0.03442107513546944, -0.03281678631901741, -0.02905901148915291, -0.03487257659435272, 0.016899079084396362, 0.04853726923465729, -0.013074600137770176, -0.019036374986171722, -0.03429340571165085, -0.04438212513923645, -0.011156458407640457, -0.04544676095247269, 0.11347096413373947, -0.01870785467326641, -0.04274732246994972, 0.0012645593378692865, 0.022102365270256996, -0.0003765546716749668, 0.0451703742146492, 0.03251517564058304, 0.01922539994120598, 0.004199100658297539, -0.039357468485832214, 0.004759117495268583, 0.005394717212766409, -0.01563536375761032, 0.06698315590620041, -0.04897375777363777, 0.010216615162789822, 0.010422066785395145, 0.04192941635847092, 0.032436907291412354, -0.052887994796037674, -0.034504201263189316, -0.041780587285757065, 0.025821072980761528, 0.01244084071367979, -0.0015150494873523712, -0.0032051787711679935, -0.011789189651608467, 0.030732765793800354, -0.03665981441736221, -0.040526412427425385, 0.07842613011598587, 0.010844076983630657, 0.010453585535287857, -0.01630672812461853, -0.03573538362979889, -0.07112721353769302, 0.03426676616072655, -0.01467843633145094, -0.01262663770467043, -0.0027726124972105026, -0.05090929567813873, -0.04192964360117912, -0.019888784736394882, 0.0101393461227417, -0.04490135982632637, 0.03029174730181694, -0.009615449234843254, 0.0188485998660326, 0.060647960752248764, -0.0009952527470886707, 0.028952930122613907, -0.009644389152526855, -0.021091649308800697, 0.006667954847216606, -0.05309387668967247, -0.0016045160591602325, 0.011875010095536709, -0.006198318675160408, 0.03614267706871033, -0.02404150925576687, 0.09331735223531723, -0.004398338962346315, -0.017589766532182693, 0.0066386437974870205, -0.025148462504148483, 0.03689277917146683, -0.04436775669455528, -0.027438761666417122, -0.023683160543441772, 0.009383860975503922, -0.04218142852187157, -0.01877102069556713, -0.03514878451824188, -0.014012232422828674, 0.0363827683031559, 0.05726032704114914, -0.04661423712968826, -0.06838580965995789, -0.01120456401258707, 0.050534043461084366, -0.014531788416206837, 0.010048795491456985, 0.05216316878795624, -0.006958247162401676, -0.054528314620256424, 0.023518957197666168, 0.01207650639116764, -0.04173106327652931, 0.03429415449500084, 0.008594104088842869, -0.03627752140164375, 0.025135504081845284, -0.005465913098305464, 0.011218434199690819, -0.02181030623614788, 0.007306039333343506, -0.020779862999916077, 0.009216341190040112, 0.029329892247915268, 0.04144728183746338, 0.031351424753665924, 0.06219150871038437, 0.053192488849163055, -0.05241716280579567, -0.005101469811052084, 0.0015698575880378485, 0.025400536134839058, 0.0016597057692706585, -0.0034635819029062986, -0.06856603920459747, -0.0036132410168647766, 0.03156716376543045, 0.03413301706314087, 0.042345646768808365, -0.000746780657209456, -0.010639581829309464, -0.057521507143974304, 0.008746111765503883, -0.008588233962655067, -0.03382810950279236, -0.06823578476905823, 0.0031307078897953033, -0.04985372722148895, -0.023978756740689278, -0.01362465787678957, -0.04935333505272865, -0.026258423924446106, -0.003272430505603552, 0.018939999863505363, -0.06539537012577057, 0.024798423051834106, 0.06842450052499771, 0.0917084813117981, -0.00435918802395463, -0.01844540797173977, -0.05876537039875984, 0.020726200193166733, -0.07145863026380539, -0.029612533748149872, -0.04592163860797882, 0.02695378102362156, 0.02106615900993347, 0.026575686410069466, 0.028036748990416527, -0.007906938903033733, -0.002783303614705801, 0.03435841202735901, -0.030616814270615578, 0.0468386635184288, -0.0636046901345253, 0.03796417638659477, -0.02616868168115616, -0.07798022031784058, 0.000024880408091121353, -0.026132559403777122, 0.02131153829395771, -0.0018691463628783822, -0.0370350256562233, 0.022906454280018806, -0.037925153970718384, -0.002085514832288027, -0.005035645328462124, 0.008687542751431465, 0.006181871984153986, -0.030477197840809822, -0.026174470782279968, -0.05434291809797287, 0.0490964911878109, 0.0073345429264009, 0.013504489324986935, -0.02939664013683796, 0.002894461853429675, 0.08024303615093231, 0.011779394932091236, 0.018724586814641953, 0.029725443571805954, 0.007039701100438833, 0.04511122778058052, 0.08954271674156189, -0.013673819601535797, -0.0010732290102168918, -0.08179489523172379, -0.002141796750947833, 0.008373033255338669, 0.019791854545474052, -0.0015209157718345523, -0.026318039745092392, 0.04337449371814728, 0.03646104410290718, 0.04053623229265213, 0.008340040221810341, -0.03777050971984863, -0.028877759352326393, 0.042860742658376694, 0.007179028820246458, -0.03681560978293419, -0.03390858694911003, 0.047701988369226456, -0.015556572005152702, 0.04064880311489105, -0.01671396940946579, 0.009949949570000172, 0.005961863789707422, -0.024469664320349693 ]
<p>It is my understanding that in quantum mechanics (for 1/2 spin particles) the </p> <p>probability function that describes the direction of a particle's spin state is </p> <p>proportional to the overlap of the theoretical hemispheres formed by the motion of </p> <p>the particle (in either spin state). However, with this theory, it is also </p> <p>imperative to assume that the only eigenvalues to describe a particle's spin state </p> <p>are ± ħ / 2. If we do assume that the spin state of a particle is well defined, </p> <p>even if it is not observed,how would we formulate a function to determine the </p> <p>expected value of a spin state for particles with more than two spin states (such </p> <p>as the 3/2 delta baryons)? Are the results in any way linked to an overlapping of </p> <p>the hemispheres in the various spin states? In addition, if it were ever </p> <p>necessary, could we formulate such a function for particles with an even higher </p> <p>number of spin states?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ySf3u.jpg" alt=" "></p> <p>Here we see a visual of this theory. The spin components of particles (a) and (b) have an angle between their vectors, $\phi$. Using this, we can see that the probability of finding both particles in a certain spin state is proportional to the overlap of their hemispheres.</p> <p>$\textbf{These calculations are mine, but I thought that it made sense intuitively }$</p> <p>$\textbf{}$</p> <p>This is the basic Idea behind the Hemisphere mathematics I described to you:</p> <p>The expected value will be denoted as $\langle\sigma^{(ab)}\rangle $ and:</p> <p>$\langle\sigma^{(ab)}\rangle $ = $P(u,u) + P(d,d) − P(u,d) − P(d,u)$, where $(d)$ donotes down and $(u)$ donotes up.</p> <p>This spin values are relative to a set field direction that corresponds to a Stern-Gorlach apparatus. </p> <p>Consequently, we can assume that if we observe the value $ +\cfrac\hslash2$, the spin of the particle will lie in the $"up"$ hemisphere, and contrarily, if we observe a value of $-\cfrac\hslash2$, our spin will reside in the $"down"$ hemisphere. </p> <p>Now, if we denote angle between the spin states of 2 particles as $(\phi)$, the probability of observing both of the particles in a down state with be equivalent to $(P(u,u)=(P(d,d))=(\cfrac\phi\pi)$</p> <p>Therefore, the proportionality coefficient has to equal (1) when $\phi=\pi$ and the probability of finding the particles in two different spin states will be $P(u,d) = x\phi + y$</p> <p>This probability is equal to (1) when the two hemispheres coincide ($\phi$ = 0) and consequently $y = 1$ [note that this disappears if $\phi = \pi$]. Thus, $x = −\cfrac1π$ and $P(u,d) = P(d,u) = 1 − \phi$</p>
g7482
[ 0.007072736043483019, 0.011430992744863033, -0.017671432346105576, -0.049737777560949326, 0.03951573371887207, 0.0430733896791935, 0.11876391619443893, 0.02040649764239788, 0.026175038889050484, -0.015315700322389603, 0.026684636250138283, -0.0064423843286931515, 0.06551165878772736, -0.024403972551226616, 0.00036745061515830457, -0.006340411491692066, 0.027315223589539528, 0.032210446894168854, 0.025635331869125366, 0.038945626467466354, -0.03569231927394867, -0.001167620881460607, 0.007655027322471142, -0.04679585620760918, 0.009125343523919582, -0.0538579523563385, -0.03719625622034073, -0.0496872216463089, -0.06824905425310135, 0.04101712256669998, -0.008709385059773922, -0.0017042573308572173, -0.009245719760656357, -0.0599076971411705, -0.026841912418603897, -0.038663871586322784, 0.024892935529351234, 0.08674480020999908, -0.0233547855168581, 0.0020594634115695953, -0.042284224182367325, -0.03431978076696396, 0.013312202878296375, -0.06425143033266068, 0.015392681583762169, 0.059303294867277145, 0.01102711632847786, 0.014669325202703476, -0.046532101929187775, -0.014595151878893375, -0.045654188841581345, 0.07117516547441483, 0.0918869748711586, 0.0017069624736905098, 0.02002553641796112, 0.01990964077413082, 0.04058068245649338, -0.03252026438713074, 0.03595035895705223, 0.04750392585992813, 0.048692043870687485, -0.024466531351208687, -0.02529636211693287, -0.01796504482626915, 0.06571733951568604, 0.00012566040095407516, -0.03763049468398094, 0.04170680418610573, -0.023325709626078606, 0.02274741604924202, -0.008112211711704731, -0.04820156469941139, 0.013607552275061607, -0.0698755756020546, -0.04375004395842552, 0.018456092104315758, -0.007343810051679611, -0.012050848454236984, 0.06989733129739761, 0.049551382660865784, -0.00030280277132987976, -0.01827235147356987, -0.012923982925713062, -0.032296322286129, 0.05931652709841728, 0.038266342133283615, 0.012949338182806969, -0.004864110611379147, -0.05447943136096001, 0.011432460509240627, -0.021869365125894547, -0.02442016638815403, 0.06362707167863846, -0.009190795943140984, 0.0031679433304816484, -0.07201988995075226, -0.029212575405836105, 0.017981037497520447, -0.021270837634801865, 0.024143481627106667, -0.03612546622753143, 0.00839956570416689, -0.01734115369617939, -0.02103356271982193, -0.01277170144021511, -0.0181164238601923, 0.07845849543809891, 0.05794324353337288, 0.031976789236068726, -0.006808054633438587, -0.06597238034009933, 0.057021066546440125, 0.008375684730708599, 0.011109322309494019, -0.03674686327576637, -0.04549456760287285, 0.03682298958301544, -0.027699686586856842, 0.021531930193305016, 0.024314016103744507, 0.06333823502063751, 0.018245326355099678, -0.0012504118494689465, 0.10086024552583694, -0.013483070768415928, -0.017108898609876633, -0.06037838011980057, -0.01257449109107256, 0.012983527965843678, 0.032369215041399, 0.05509514361619949, -0.04458793252706528, 0.04324408993124962, 0.010211125947535038, -0.037439774721860886, -0.0007442442583851516, 0.030706116929650307, 0.05848312005400658, -0.01484938245266676, -0.038570236414670944, -0.0012258298229426146, -0.019707677885890007, 0.042947057634592056, -0.033364661037921906, 0.03213975578546524, -0.0192121509462595, 0.00047366926446557045, -0.09368418157100677, -0.007047642488032579, 0.01058597955852747, 0.041917089372873306, 0.0347929522395134, 0.017579829320311546, 0.014980675652623177, 0.010644454509019852, -0.010198925621807575, 0.05337106063961983, -0.03537663817405701, -0.01370709203183651, 0.04140019044280052, 0.04324502497911453, -0.02513718791306019, 0.0012897592969238758, 0.031132644042372704, -0.031023230403661728, 0.011989614926278591, 0.012690303847193718, -0.03259778395295143, -0.011071468703448772, -0.0748048797249794, 0.005797215737402439, 0.011968561448156834, 0.022725403308868408, -0.007805117405951023, -0.003680021734908223, 0.08125817775726318, 0.0035437848418951035, -0.02118946611881256, 0.02625119872391224, 0.04906124994158745, -0.00717811519280076, 0.04815182089805603, 0.009819305501878262, 0.02972608245909214, -0.023154087364673615, -0.004753412678837776, -0.008354660123586655, 0.006635521538555622, -0.04478241875767708, 0.01911601424217224, 0.02763640694320202, 0.0005685038049705327, 0.016559479758143425, 0.00505390390753746, -0.04343476518988609, -0.004945238120853901, 0.028417466208338737, -0.08078278601169586, -0.012246647849678993, 0.05644742026925087, 0.021508442237973213, 0.05382902920246124, 0.02582128718495369, 0.02623228169977665, 0.001966169336810708, -0.030540961772203445, 0.04821221902966499, 0.08432409167289734, 0.037550829350948334, -0.011367488652467728, 0.0007817217265255749, -0.00837804563343525, -0.0263017900288105, 0.05254298821091652, 0.015589823946356773, 0.019715597853064537, 0.05639398843050003, -0.007520319428294897, -0.01136770099401474, -0.03562068194150925, 0.03221796825528145, -0.044589463621377945, 0.0649949163198471, -0.014678681269288063, 0.00048672486445866525, 0.041280198842287064, -0.09121017903089523, 0.00933966226875782, -0.016906550154089928, 0.08633356541395187, -0.032956063747406006, -0.013275058008730412, 0.035406213253736496, -0.007719289977103472, 0.04993300139904022, 0.05863875895738602, 0.00999380461871624, 0.020466305315494537, 0.031282007694244385, -0.027811069041490555, -0.023410674184560776, 0.003309819148853421, -0.06101679429411888, 0.01883460208773613, -0.008579349145293236, 0.01992248371243477, 0.01839039847254753, 0.011151181533932686, -0.013789920136332512, 0.09805599600076675, 0.0279254037886858, -0.051119860261678696, -0.039136022329330444, 0.030329179018735886, -0.0157717727124691, -0.023240890353918076, -0.02855715900659561, 0.024972619488835335, -0.015139438211917877, -0.045140545815229416, -0.019694866612553596, -0.03866465017199516, 0.04038083553314209, 0.02482432685792446, -0.024153094738721848, -0.01776048168540001, -0.024133488535881042, -0.010824319906532764, -0.011434153653681278, -0.02528858184814453, -0.02905239351093769, 0.05600510537624359, 0.006092322524636984, 0.06678041070699692, -0.0016955657629296184, -0.04771893471479416, 0.003228881862014532, 0.006565894931554794, -0.028853105381131172, 0.0055969469249248505, -0.04707574099302292, 0.016422336921095848, 0.014019722118973732, 0.027729202061891556, 0.05200115218758583, -0.054837916046381, 0.030860766768455505, 0.03557310253381729, -0.04445423558354378, 0.05612426623702049, 0.04059986770153046, 0.022286007180809975, 0.015633028000593185, -0.06040479242801666, 0.019522836431860924, -0.021119842305779457, 0.011166621930897236, -0.029555968940258026, -0.0036450023762881756, 0.044890519231557846, -0.019780190661549568, -0.0048133558593690395, -0.0010088583221659064, 0.016266442835330963, 0.050059724599123, 0.00011069264292018488, -0.054856348782777786, -0.025515707209706306, -0.02839195542037487, -0.02828354574739933, -0.025423282757401466, 0.04708700627088547, -0.03674344718456268, -0.005696158390492201, -0.027377594262361526, -0.0014057300286367536, -0.03617776557803154, 0.049587681889534, 0.02234267070889473, 0.012227512896060944, -0.014156526885926723, 0.00146409310400486, -0.010072239674627781, -0.010104324668645859, 0.013855253346264362, -0.05783623829483986, -0.029011161997914314, -0.0037386808544397354, -0.06044847145676613, 0.013364559039473534, 0.012588074430823326, 0.013317583128809929, -0.028918104246258736, 0.0247773639857769, -0.051341187208890915, 0.0036154768895357847, -0.006307248491793871, -0.02874765172600746, 0.06983217597007751, 0.017831582576036453, 0.003933146130293608, -0.035590194165706635, -0.030078968033194542, 0.013715601526200771, 0.01272319070994854, -0.05408981814980507, -0.018145062029361725, 0.023730028420686722, 0.018454011529684067, 0.013694796711206436, -0.021118175238370895, 0.02922273427248001, 0.005579482298344374, 0.018648603931069374, 0.06452292203903198, -0.005213398020714521, 0.05754837766289711, 0.03714178502559662, 0.023475050926208496, 0.025213811546564102, 0.048409201204776764, -0.011283399537205696, -0.035516344010829926, 0.0027472784277051687, -0.012986646965146065, -0.017248524352908134, 0.01856224797666073, 0.030400201678276062, 0.019458189606666565, -0.06641951948404312, 0.009326647967100143, -0.005656604655086994, -0.010152480565011501, -0.009263798594474792, -0.0014604328898712993, -0.01668679155409336, 0.0010962357046082616, -0.035921674221754074, -0.05649587884545326, 0.010048575699329376, -0.022325647994875908, 0.04878192022442818, 0.016680944710969925, 0.04807475954294205, -0.023934466764330864, 0.02526608109474182, -0.01289913710206747, 0.0018810885958373547, -0.021397404372692108, 0.00004058584090671502, 0.03549851477146149, -0.056905440986156464, -0.06192680075764656, 0.04470494017004967, 0.08415473997592926, -0.003064893651753664, -0.0017750993138179183, -0.008133087307214737, 0.03410107269883156, 0.024198779836297035, -0.06136874854564667, -0.06620565056800842, 0.019058259204030037, -0.008907865732908249, -0.05360649898648262, -0.01915557309985161, 0.017726082354784012, 0.02088448405265808, 0.01813422329723835, -0.041795361787080765, 0.0034900037571787834, 0.05138895660638809, 0.03414621204137802, 0.012179886922240257, 0.04023030772805214, 0.010074768215417862, -0.024732038378715515, -0.04769708961248398, 0.014451805502176285, -0.020147399976849556, -0.005128631368279457, 0.05197899416089058, 0.02640788070857525, 0.013713671825826168, -0.04813915118575096, 0.015564941801130772, 0.0030940084252506495, -0.016094885766506195, -0.05715864151716232, -0.017322253435850143, -0.030690135434269905, 0.05213083699345589, 0.03207766264677048, 0.016479624435305595, -0.05976628139615059, 0.0011098398827016354, -0.052522093057632446, -0.0065477872267365456, 0.014662523753941059, 0.013826183043420315, -0.04950752109289169, -0.01400621235370636, -0.05779711529612541, -0.029767654836177826, 0.01928286999464035, -0.004145501181483269, -0.028223760426044464, -0.04265220835804939, 0.03092195838689804, -0.07040902227163315, -0.0288301520049572, 0.0015289803268387914, -0.05156683176755905, 0.015357567928731441, -0.029920948669314384, -0.03776067495346069, 0.010323379188776016, 0.08515292406082153, -0.0070843929424881935, -0.0019049652619287372, -0.02965242601931095, -0.05726466327905655, -0.013951066881418228, -0.05712319165468216, -0.006686626933515072, 0.01019564550369978, -0.07686057686805725, -0.005304491613060236, -0.052862878888845444, -0.011419202201068401, -0.03784051910042763, -0.0058306544087827206, 0.049929048866033554, -0.009344872087240219, -0.015179118141531944, 0.002419157885015011, -0.02098117582499981, 0.007029776927083731, -0.02991090901196003, -0.05892510339617729, -0.04180024936795235, -0.03568703308701515, 0.02696075849235058, 0.0019283043220639229, 0.008929183706641197, -0.049138039350509644, 0.01926501840353012, -0.07421182096004486, 0.029628170654177666, 0.001611876767128706, 0.01795615442097187, -0.001735888421535492, 0.01524512842297554, 0.007940152660012245, 0.03740423917770386, -0.059180304408073425, -0.018330533057451248, -0.006011347286403179, 0.05219542980194092, 0.009324494749307632, 0.015528482384979725, 0.04284248873591423, -0.017085852101445198, 0.00835645291954279, -0.0060853734612464905, 0.02382325939834118, 0.06268973648548126, -0.02601691521704197, 0.0022682922426611185, 0.007160915527492762, -0.004927491769194603, -0.024980826303362846, -0.0005385017720982432, -0.0034795592073351145, -0.019824592396616936, -0.003263100516051054, -0.021473193541169167, 0.08656217157840729, -0.007958472706377506, 0.01849490776658058, 0.006123424973338842, -0.006455107592046261, 0.007210165727883577, -0.02625052072107792, -0.014668011106550694, -0.02802068367600441, -0.04706154763698578, 0.017153408378362656, 0.011933124624192715, 0.03605576604604721, 0.004084601998329163, 0.031821250915527344, -0.05562523379921913, 0.055234894156455994, 0.03343474119901657, -0.08603238314390182, -0.02316761203110218, 0.0034269157331436872, 0.08018744736909866, 0.051107607781887054, -0.04446800798177719, -0.01446293294429779, 0.015435351058840752, 0.058418188244104385, -0.05051781237125397, 0.020311245694756508, 0.0003088234516326338, -0.055465977638959885, 0.00887641217559576, -0.056117575615644455, -0.06272169947624207, 0.04805080592632294, -0.044399186968803406, -0.001150876865722239, 0.018524719402194023, 0.037267331033945084, -0.00040540247573517263, 0.004987630993127823, 0.02988038957118988, 0.02550230734050274, 0.008926717564463615, -0.04563870280981064, 0.04821816459298134, 0.02726137824356556, -0.018742818385362625, 0.03613881766796112, -0.047008879482746124, 0.017844611778855324, -0.022499263286590576, 0.014764837920665741, -0.0349893718957901, -0.08593545854091644, -0.03890364244580269, 0.05368797853589058, 0.050302114337682724, 0.04100964590907097, -0.031814660876989365, -0.032251037657260895, 0.011345521546900272, 0.004119642544537783, 0.0011016532080247998, -0.008827801793813705, 0.021007908508181572, 0.006888371892273426, -0.04883261397480965, 0.07761546969413757, -0.005885536316782236, -0.0006169650587253273, 0.0420624241232872, 0.02265194058418274, -0.032159555703401566, 0.0009363674907945096, -0.03157567232847214, -0.0235736146569252, -0.01873926818370819, -0.05598249286413193, -0.0005541357677429914, -0.0010521883377805352, -0.050732772797346115, -0.04470048099756241, 0.0686054676771164, -0.042340487241744995, -0.0028791227377951145, -0.007132403086870909, 0.009024560451507568, 0.02060680091381073, -0.0684848353266716, -0.06200871616601944, -0.013196907006204128, 0.008999924175441265, 0.03740285709500313, -0.048067621886730194, -0.012441881000995636, 0.01999880187213421, 0.002204655669629574, -0.06546619534492493, 0.00613996759057045, -0.008394009433686733, -0.06800027936697006, 0.031024891883134842, 0.04819812625646591, 0.032172705978155136, -0.03900523856282234, -0.06751566380262375, 0.04032110422849655, 0.0045621562749147415, -0.01674245484173298, -0.053672634065151215, 0.029361020773649216, 0.031462810933589935, 0.03888976201415062, -0.026481706649065018, 0.01400441862642765, 0.030875027179718018, 0.017196999862790108, -0.049040332436561584, -0.039643172174692154, -0.024126576259732246, 0.002561113564297557, 0.06907331943511963, -0.018168751150369644, 0.02835197001695633, 0.07301627099514008, -0.009638027288019657, -0.07041271030902863, -0.059222929179668427, 0.007907477207481861, 0.010684192180633545, -0.07266386598348618, 0.0187236238270998, 0.006493271328508854, -0.018819408491253853, 0.01991911418735981, -0.016190990805625916, -0.0046217734925448895, 0.02228207141160965, 0.07637130469083786, 0.017617451027035713, 0.04110531508922577, -0.04643138125538826, -0.03670845553278923, -0.0364823155105114, -0.05227570980787277, 0.007621369324624538, -0.01287622656673193, -0.012646771967411041, 0.005932013038545847, -0.04612869396805763, 0.0035990134347230196, -0.05027177184820175, 0.009018843993544579, -0.01822795532643795, -0.088973268866539, 0.0161056499928236, -0.04606454819440842, -0.01210398506373167, 0.003914350178092718, 0.02990279532968998, 0.025725504383444786, -0.01734211854636669, 0.026243360713124275, 0.018152529373764992, 0.005267395172268152, 0.005245856940746307, -0.048700764775276184, -0.025329001247882843, 0.021270200610160828, 0.008362313732504845, -0.048811137676239014, 0.03288658335804939, 0.02910911664366722, -0.02011271007359028, 0.050420839339494705, -0.025244081392884254, -0.01457519643008709, 0.0018522378522902727, 0.04741239175200462, 0.03587942570447922, -0.011780223809182644, -0.002290856558829546, 0.0401591993868351, -0.02466893196105957, 0.03251247480511665, -0.04607119411230087, 0.027011115103960037, 0.0007874456350691617, 0.06873809546232224, -0.021932024508714676, -0.015628475695848465, -0.023479236289858818, 0.0015495019033551216, 0.05813124403357506, 0.03975197300314903, 0.013798613101243973, 0.009714649990200996, 0.0015632369322702289, -0.011390678584575653, 0.022670628502964973, 0.05686463788151741, 0.049600936472415924, -0.0708174854516983, -0.008493299596011639, -0.02452803961932659, 0.02747439220547676, 0.010927248746156693, -0.010342387482523918, 0.03871685639023781, 0.03853733465075493, 0.029392968863248825, 0.007326234597712755, 0.031061643734574318, 0.07104994356632233, -0.050989601761102676, 0.04064733535051346, -0.07683490216732025, -0.012797092087566853, 0.009452632628381252, -0.008774093352258205, 0.010200939141213894, -0.009670720435678959, -0.0035363610368222, -0.03422819823026657, -0.006760179065167904, -0.07617652416229248, -0.07542486488819122, 0.0180718582123518, -0.017707306891679764, 0.044966552406549454, 0.09370823949575424, 0.0320693701505661, -0.03887499123811722, 0.05457266420125961, 0.006556845270097256, 0.045537516474723816, 0.07069848477840424, -0.025483645498752594, 0.0701955258846283, -0.012956324964761734, -0.04685572162270546, 0.018993522971868515, 0.0006438916316255927, -0.058187615126371384, 0.02215813659131527, -0.0031460828613489866, -0.04772196710109711, -0.022534728050231934, -0.05905931442975998, 0.07186927646398544 ]
<p>I ask <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/q/884412/">this question</a> on math stackexchange but got no answer. Not sure how to move the post so I'm reposting it here.</p> <p>I was arguing with my friend that <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brownian_motion" rel="nofollow">Brownian motion</a>, in the sense of a pollen moving in the fluid, could be explained by physics laws (such as $F=ma$) and statistics laws. </p> <p>To check it out I found Albert Einstein's paper, "Investigations on the theory of Brownian motion", however I found it a bit hard to understand. It starts with osmotic pressure which i have no idea, and the paper is 114 pages long, though in big font.</p> <p>I'm wondering if there's an easier iteration? hopefully shorter?</p>
g7483
[ 0.016770564019680023, 0.08864971250295639, -0.01907704584300518, -0.021675333380699158, 0.01784374937415123, 0.0014553993241861463, 0.059691909700632095, -0.02508963830769062, 0.0002625694323796779, -0.010934975929558277, -0.008814587257802486, -0.015707576647400856, 0.11044736951589584, 0.009783965535461903, -0.04137574881315231, -0.029072299599647522, 0.06774437427520752, -0.009078174829483032, 0.0009206729009747505, -0.016962651163339615, 0.024955280125141144, 0.046059656888246536, 0.021154124289751053, -0.06120463088154793, -0.03395746648311615, 0.007494398858398199, -0.08340509235858917, 0.008661541156470776, -0.0427522212266922, -0.09248977154493332, 0.08231744915246964, -0.006450195796787739, 0.008495681919157505, -0.036283377557992935, 0.001300276955589652, -0.01914500817656517, 0.006658144295215607, -0.040693990886211395, 0.03629232570528984, 0.02735684998333454, 0.02931668423116207, -0.0022410533856600523, 0.02912874147295952, -0.021124161779880524, 0.009761631488800049, -0.00011802690278273076, -0.007232781499624252, -0.02347439154982567, -0.025386212393641472, -0.008855714462697506, -0.03186306729912758, 0.07747996598482132, 0.03420852869749069, 0.030665012076497078, -0.011600752361118793, 0.03391726687550545, 0.00033705896930769086, -0.03715401515364647, 0.024218780919909477, 0.018460247665643692, -0.033247075974941254, -0.01412245538085699, -0.009422723203897476, 0.040827687829732895, -0.02724338509142399, -0.027345649898052216, -0.016969656571745872, -0.029469894245266914, 0.026641668751835823, -0.02674003876745701, 0.023604203015565872, -0.010068259201943874, -0.06796452403068542, -0.06182713806629181, -0.050824619829654694, 0.038809288293123245, 0.012264800257980824, 0.008740665391087532, 0.06327749788761139, -0.06161511316895485, -0.04235823452472687, 0.03226900100708008, -0.0019268657779321074, -0.024655185639858246, 0.10521306097507477, -0.009352308697998524, -0.004694079514592886, -0.008695689961314201, 0.04518419876694679, -0.05565127730369568, -0.05230416730046272, -0.03169917315244675, 0.05664512515068054, 0.00039231369737535715, 0.0013304934836924076, -0.07729768753051758, -0.06433122605085373, 0.02846839278936386, -0.04530229791998863, -0.008728873915970325, -0.03312603011727333, 0.0037094794679433107, 0.03084763139486313, -0.012414994649589062, 0.04256395623087883, -0.021316276863217354, 0.004227025900036097, 0.005729395896196365, -0.051657360047101974, 0.012777681462466717, -0.06026081368327141, -0.008694020099937916, -0.013765123672783375, -0.01910576969385147, 0.028791137039661407, -0.051925480365753174, 0.011633411981165409, 0.023184308782219887, -0.0027303900569677353, 0.06759073585271835, -0.026809388771653175, 0.07335405796766281, 0.03532896190881729, 0.017255457118153572, -0.031814996153116226, 0.04939652979373932, 0.01978655718266964, -0.008465703576803207, 0.04958206042647362, 0.01957721821963787, 0.0339558869600296, 0.010579993017017841, 0.06107422709465027, -0.00374594540335238, -0.029191743582487106, 0.02154666930437088, -0.03438553586602211, 0.02165084145963192, -0.05456188693642616, 0.011520450003445148, 0.05036857724189758, -0.033199235796928406, 0.03394269943237305, -0.006947886664420366, -0.05217573791742325, 0.063945472240448, -0.007060041185468435, -0.014029474928975105, 0.034210871905088425, -0.0018612639978528023, -0.01973055489361286, 0.06544658541679382, 0.012713491916656494, 0.0031372583471238613, 0.0474572516977787, -0.019148431718349457, 0.031648531556129456, 0.023395152762532234, 0.005320280324667692, -0.021204810589551926, 0.07129044830799103, -0.023823238909244537, 0.04049764573574066, 0.006999984383583069, -0.08908721804618835, 0.06718060374259949, 0.0013776241103187203, -0.040325962007045746, -0.02743060700595379, -0.02458556927740574, -0.078152596950531, -0.0347251296043396, -0.008087320253252983, 0.0986904725432396, -0.039301421493291855, 0.03493258357048035, -0.026994209736585617, -0.05051641911268234, -0.04550272971391678, 0.01806151494383812, 0.01223939098417759, -0.021471356973052025, 0.018856508657336235, -0.02527107670903206, 0.01373952068388462, 0.048174094408750534, 0.02206391468644142, 0.004671518690884113, -0.08554542809724808, -0.01709778606891632, -0.045289136469364166, -0.02746051549911499, -0.021822597831487656, 0.030447261407971382, 0.027442000806331635, -0.01902717724442482, -0.009292139671742916, -0.06778541952371597, 0.0037533375434577465, 0.04384344071149826, 0.01932726427912712, 0.025414416566491127, 0.03812140226364136, -0.024286821484565735, -0.020008688792586327, 0.006314546801149845, -0.026507331058382988, 0.01833452843129635, 0.044618554413318634, 0.020516347140073776, 0.02195981703698635, -0.01096415240317583, 0.025669556111097336, 0.0025895219296216965, -0.037676382809877396, 0.009549706242978573, 0.0012002107687294483, 0.013430468738079071, -0.04747392609715462, 0.012823162600398064, 0.0001242317957803607, -0.0021070996299386024, -0.031826265156269073, 0.061840713024139404, -0.007321661338210106, -0.012372239492833614, -0.07268226891756058, -0.04245210438966751, -0.02349943295121193, 0.04807097464799881, -0.04915839806199074, 0.0071105207316577435, -0.005480654072016478, -0.0029692070093005896, 0.07059498131275177, 0.048140183091163635, -0.013513834215700626, -0.013919164426624775, -0.005336781498044729, 0.05146854370832443, -0.04529353231191635, -0.0517844595015049, -0.013775770552456379, -0.005909713916480541, 0.02967153862118721, -0.008003463968634605, 0.06921492516994476, -0.017802448943257332, 0.03469587489962578, 0.04348864033818245, 0.043927568942308426, -0.02030613087117672, 0.0567527636885643, -0.012605693191289902, -0.010537664406001568, 0.00713161239400506, -0.03656277060508728, 0.03508259356021881, -0.0103877242654562, -0.0275221299380064, -0.030174603685736656, -0.05370704084634781, 0.06240026280283928, 0.002706806641072035, -0.036619674414396286, -0.025842804461717606, -0.032320842146873474, 0.0227823406457901, -0.0048792362213134766, 0.018396660685539246, 0.015217921696603298, 0.01682743802666664, -0.016767432913184166, 0.009065201506018639, -0.0284765362739563, 0.047720011323690414, 0.027026589959859848, -0.06471708416938782, 0.030312901362776756, -0.007232296280562878, 0.002890269970521331, -0.012161735445261002, -0.014680380001664162, 0.0036631771363317966, 0.053866706788539886, -0.02648891881108284, -0.011489439755678177, 0.026080504059791565, 0.030113153159618378, -0.0406663753092289, 0.035644639283418655, 0.01782524399459362, 0.03277505561709404, 0.07096832245588303, -0.00233529438264668, 0.07707905769348145, 0.05817491561174393, -0.05244021117687225, -0.026434343308210373, 0.07247909903526306, 0.018372246995568275, -0.02737421542406082, -0.012403625063598156, -0.018051227554678917, 0.018748104572296143, 0.032622069120407104, -0.08149097859859467, -0.0607759952545166, 0.018404154106974602, 0.014184962958097458, 0.041556116193532944, 0.05077766999602318, -0.0559559129178524, 0.04568936303257942, -0.015669258311390877, -0.016546880826354027, 0.002028790535405278, -0.0031173909083008766, 0.11041395366191864, -0.004708108492195606, -0.031662773340940475, -0.05668223649263382, -0.010774691589176655, -0.028238531202077866, 0.06213987246155739, -0.020561547949910164, -0.026710087433457375, -0.016313109546899796, -0.047437477856874466, 0.0032098337542265654, 0.05853498727083206, 0.025131316855549812, -0.022796016186475754, -0.03577975556254387, -0.020862940698862076, -0.08117267489433289, -0.017167015001177788, 0.03555562347173691, 0.03765840083360672, 0.017172081395983696, -0.022692352533340454, -0.030106600373983383, -0.03104725107550621, -0.03319878131151199, -0.04715457558631897, 0.05084763839840889, 0.04165653511881828, 0.005995606072247028, 0.004258459899574518, -0.03397706523537636, 0.05480269342660904, -0.04420914128422737, 0.018076959997415543, -0.008740764111280441, -0.034046754240989685, -0.007858505472540855, 0.0701042115688324, -0.009436818771064281, 0.052458446472883224, 0.024139296263456345, -0.006763654761016369, -0.040163978934288025, -0.004448371008038521, 0.05869898572564125, 0.013916654512286186, 0.023015957325696945, -0.008332343772053719, 0.010553400963544846, -0.03227941691875458, -0.025580571964383125, -0.03249039500951767, -0.030024336650967598, 0.010208496823906898, 0.05839447304606438, 0.0338967926800251, 0.003421106841415167, 0.05838099122047424, 0.022672178223729134, -0.03589160740375519, 0.020619725808501244, 0.0666234940290451, 0.00047780651948414743, 0.048598550260066986, 0.024932585656642914, -0.01882709562778473, -0.012744026258587837, -0.07586288452148438, 0.014265891164541245, 0.029490670189261436, -0.03028544783592224, 0.0007120530353859067, -0.021473459899425507, -0.00649573840200901, -0.04095945134758949, 0.03311706334352493, -0.030965128913521767, 0.011573728173971176, 0.024237969890236855, -0.009118037298321724, 0.038012176752090454, 0.03789845108985901, -0.010013178922235966, 0.001122775487601757, -0.029423732310533524, -0.032833874225616455, 0.0440988652408123, 0.027041610330343246, -0.0547906868159771, 0.01493816263973713, -0.024882106110453606, -0.029832400381565094, 0.006605928763747215, 0.019281921908259392, -0.000017114631191361696, -0.02092922106385231, 0.0065971738658845425, -0.02161545306444168, 0.020010827109217644, -0.04165961965918541, 0.04303628206253052, 0.03236706554889679, -0.013551616109907627, 0.020763669162988663, -0.041925638914108276, -0.04919630289077759, 0.04435725137591362, 0.056739192456007004, -0.0007951862644404173, -0.005377305671572685, -0.07747410982847214, -0.02396070770919323, -0.01075507141649723, 0.004946535918861628, 0.050910282880067825, -0.024603094905614853, 0.04634901508688927, 0.004773634020239115, 0.027587559074163437, -0.026972245424985886, 0.0415072925388813, 0.004710332956165075, -0.010439812205731869, 0.03868470340967178, -0.02805004082620144, 0.030036700889468193, 0.0917787030339241, 0.04641393944621086, -0.05197875574231148, -0.04041292145848274, 0.002697404008358717, 0.008725609630346298, 0.028835728764533997, -0.009586607106029987, 0.025460215285420418, -0.021698204800486565, 0.01560915820300579, -0.07549871504306793, 0.050406575202941895, -0.029052892699837685, 0.06735818088054657, -0.03886048123240471, 0.05159211903810501, 0.025918832048773766, 0.014465917833149433, 0.03348798677325249, -0.047045040875673294, 0.0362582765519619, -0.04507856443524361, -0.023738747462630272, 0.01416123379021883, 0.01909305341541767, 0.02186349406838417, -0.006486253812909126, 0.012726839631795883, 0.020275289192795753, 0.025418346747756004, 0.014514093287289143, -0.0001290175277972594, 0.031275056302547455, -0.0326831191778183, 0.009811044670641422, 0.019457174465060234, 0.030002010986208916, -0.008450462482869625, 0.01153517421334982, 0.0316176600754261, -0.07528949528932571, 0.022689124569296837, -0.05301010236144066, -0.010786094702780247, -0.029615920037031174, 0.010513702407479286, 0.057212430983781815, 0.025233622640371323, -0.059907808899879456, -0.06075500696897507, 0.04848776012659073, -0.012375264428555965, 0.007939214818179607, -0.009634168818593025, -0.07262653112411499, -0.004206046927720308, -0.004448032006621361, -0.00281754182651639, 0.0425126813352108, -0.0054242308251559734, 0.04475139454007149, 0.01764626055955887, 0.0008979230187833309, 0.07314793020486832, 0.016282260417938232, 0.047047752887010574, -0.010714837349951267, -0.0315188504755497, 0.015614612028002739, -0.013737482018768787, -0.004235632251948118, -0.029347822070121765, 0.014756528660655022, -0.029220260679721832, 0.053917113691568375, -0.011314158327877522, 0.035949576646089554, 0.011264881119132042, -0.006652767304331064, -0.03322792425751686, -0.11293714493513107, -0.012106608599424362, 0.015046017244458199, -0.010811453685164452, -0.0027383393608033657, -0.07114797830581665, 0.0475769005715847, 0.020080868154764175, -0.03585005924105644, -0.018134726211428642, 0.023715030401945114, 0.024948252364993095, 0.012526920065283775, 0.047369491308927536, -0.02300109714269638, -0.03918847069144249, 0.009074578061699867, 0.08192306011915207, -0.0008822490344755352, 0.013751520775258541, -0.03127472102642059, -0.0015396253438666463, 0.08370508253574371, -0.03909669443964958, -0.05066804215312004, 0.054441601037979126, 0.005052945110946894, -0.021462462842464447, -0.01527474820613861, -0.0036733844317495823, 0.008415759541094303, -0.07726805657148361, 0.03227303549647331, 0.021046645939350128, 0.03609657660126686, 0.04074021428823471, 0.026583701372146606, -0.007169389631599188, 0.0296227615326643, -0.060752030462026596, -0.011921248398721218, 0.006102120969444513, 0.031503017991781235, 0.08130212873220444, -0.0022636002395302057, 0.021341070532798767, 0.003751775249838829, 0.016756629571318626, -0.014566510915756226, -0.021841395646333694, 0.041549328714609146, 0.025224152952432632, -0.04988400265574455, -0.025714242830872536, -0.022279823198914528, 0.04109957441687584, 0.012722696177661419, -0.025937102735042572, -0.0006168200052343309, 0.009360037744045258, -0.06133440136909485, 0.038978029042482376, 0.04860233515501022, -0.028788074851036072, -0.018224848434329033, -0.039061713963747025, -0.04834035784006119, -0.047402262687683105, -0.016453629359602928, -0.04958954453468323, -0.018553586676716805, -0.06062748283147812, 0.0031767324544489384, 0.021884068846702576, -0.03891098499298096, -0.011684703640639782, -0.015412265434861183, -0.02579907700419426, -0.018946610391139984, 0.006023590452969074, -0.06258469074964523, -0.0227704718708992, 0.020312681794166565, -0.008282867260277271, -0.07922296971082687, 0.005811195354908705, 0.025925444439053535, -0.011400612071156502, 0.010324232280254364, -0.049128208309412, -0.045159149914979935, 0.016107670962810516, 0.04490554332733154, -0.0008651941316202283, -0.005947883706539869, -0.035775456577539444, 0.07910594344139099, -0.035129085183143616, -0.009348510764539242, 0.04141242057085037, -0.017173154279589653, -0.013015265576541424, 0.019851146265864372, -0.014623326249420643, 0.01639881171286106, 0.05725232884287834, 0.007156592793762684, 0.03120032325387001, 0.016764424741268158, -0.007788570132106543, -0.054415784776210785, 0.008678783662617207, 0.05182044580578804, 0.013503741472959518, -0.008208367973566055, 0.011066910810768604, 0.06490396708250046, 0.03302102908492088, -0.000752470747102052, 0.02192790061235428, -0.03381996601819992, -0.02085665799677372, -0.10847403109073639, 0.0014214643742889166, 0.011920547112822533, 0.004460863769054413, -0.041074104607105255, 0.050037045031785965, -0.013346731662750244, 0.0373757965862751, -0.012730938382446766, -0.02416585385799408, 0.012093586847186089, -0.015468659810721874, -0.05782243609428406, -0.028561735525727272, 0.005750172305852175, -0.0028400514274835587, 0.00508436094969511, 0.06007536128163338, 0.013766956515610218, 0.0006753266206942499, 0.024727562442421913, -0.026683254167437553, 0.053614601492881775, -0.0022740724962204695, -0.04834352061152458, 0.06469900906085968, -0.034780990332365036, -0.013884182088077068, 0.02983185276389122, 0.012692560441792011, -0.023128224536776543, -0.012126350775361061, 0.0498553104698658, -0.008154010400176048, 0.018975822255015373, -0.018849292770028114, -0.05793708562850952, 0.022153669968247414, -0.06909311562776566, 0.0435999296605587, 0.011399621143937111, 0.035371314734220505, -0.02192706987261772, 0.029033586382865906, 0.025600174441933632, 0.033497799187898636, 0.026935312896966934, 0.03929289057850838, 0.043129947036504745, -0.061769939959049225, -0.0014710788382217288, 0.000658451346680522, -0.01496997568756342, -0.012243601493537426, -0.02797691896557808, -0.01077592745423317, -0.007421873044222593, -0.0762816071510315, -0.08461295813322067, 0.0023822018411010504, -0.05496809631586075, -0.03215854987502098, -0.006170973181724548, -0.02229267917573452, -0.0476311519742012, 0.013901110738515854, 0.01847064681351185, 0.017610803246498108, -0.043566253036260605, 0.024846049025654793, -0.017918916419148445, 0.0010370055679231882, -0.001882205018773675, 0.003570644883438945, -0.007959699258208275, -0.07201680541038513, -0.021106436848640442, -0.0007292504888027906, -0.06696117669343948, 0.010877556167542934, -0.0054221064783632755, -0.03498632833361626, -0.030771533027291298, -0.02736915647983551, 0.016352878883481026, -0.02321713976562023, -0.03304586187005043, 0.02215886302292347, 0.003207314061000943, -0.011240432038903236, 0.014043111354112625, -0.008319942280650139, 0.02384076453745365, -0.02844906970858574, 0.04304695129394531, -0.030388040468096733, 0.02225242182612419, -0.07039035856723785, -0.04142465069890022, 0.06804779171943665, 0.047787997871637344, -0.03298042714595795, 0.02028728276491165, 0.006200097035616636, -0.001658820197917521, 0.009521541185677052, 0.03815581277012825, -0.0063117933459579945, 0.010351506061851978, 0.115571528673172, 0.018506724387407303, -0.0039749182760715485, -0.00977899506688118, -0.02888432703912258, -0.015054511837661266, -0.01727963797748089, 0.011461643502116203, -0.03731728345155716, -0.007007577922195196, -0.010352893732488155 ]
<p>This is a continuation of <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/22183/2451">this question</a>.</p> <p><a href="http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/8-01-physics-i-classical-mechanics-fall-1999/video-lectures/lecture-1/" rel="nofollow">http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/8-01-physics-i-classical-mechanics-fall-1999/video-lectures/lecture-1/</a> skip this lecture to around 25:50.</p> <p>After doing dimensional analysis on $t\propto h^\alpha m^\beta g^\gamma$ Lewin concludes that:</p> <p>$$\alpha = \frac{1}{2}, \gamma = -1/2, \beta = 0$$</p> <p>This is all fully understood, but he then goes to conclude from this that:</p> <p>$$t = C \sqrt{\frac{h}{g}}$$</p> <p>How did he get to this? And why is he allowed to just assume that there is a constant, C, there when he doesn't even know its value or what it is?</p> <p>Keep things as simple as possible please, I'm 16.</p>
g7484
[ 0.04297688603401184, 0.00014619262947235256, -0.015502344816923141, -0.05698096379637718, 0.0867912769317627, 0.04635300114750862, 0.06254152953624725, -0.02480532042682171, -0.11138080060482025, -0.05870033800601959, -0.03940523788332939, -0.004075092729181051, 0.01727120578289032, -0.00515102269127965, 0.03808118775486946, -0.025203341618180275, -0.0040224152617156506, -0.026350149884819984, 0.006733849178999662, -0.043271519243717194, 0.0011116513051092625, -0.01770774833858013, 0.013116867281496525, -0.06435687839984894, 0.06043995916843414, -0.010893366299569607, -0.00687558576464653, 0.06701070070266724, -0.021335884928703308, -0.010323126800358295, 0.005863530095666647, -0.014846913516521454, 0.07723604142665863, -0.011887446977198124, -0.018589017912745476, -0.022109149023890495, 0.025399819016456604, 0.040034037083387375, 0.06686422228813171, -0.0384952574968338, -0.04757821932435036, -0.012900224886834621, -0.03024592064321041, 0.02943725511431694, -0.01813373528420925, 0.020086070522665977, -0.03915056213736534, 0.032664842903614044, -0.017624596133828163, 0.020117249339818954, 0.02552765980362892, -0.010730724781751633, 0.06258463114500046, -0.01949811913073063, 0.04306374862790108, 0.03286522254347801, 0.04674149304628372, -0.03215834125876427, 0.0869031473994255, 0.02306302636861801, -0.008413570001721382, 0.00019751519721467048, 0.03018837235867977, 0.05067141354084015, 0.02683362551033497, -0.04361187294125557, 0.0034358040429651737, -0.0021727655548602343, -0.017384853214025497, -0.008898107334971428, 0.016260910779237747, -0.05708852782845497, -0.002762881573289633, 0.0007930468418635428, -0.031192786991596222, 0.006094681099057198, 0.05408288910984993, 0.025940699502825737, -0.00738742109388113, -0.025276578962802887, -0.003492684569209814, -0.01738240197300911, -0.0015514080878347158, 0.008013397455215454, 0.049046169966459274, -0.001657099463045597, 0.005534785334020853, -0.004671140573918819, -0.004117542877793312, 0.011548742651939392, -0.021343698725104332, -0.02133004739880562, 0.03818744793534279, -0.009978355839848518, -0.03330370783805847, -0.06709886342287064, -0.015117514878511429, 0.029019879177212715, -0.018399307504296303, -0.02349892631173134, 0.027279937639832497, 0.02660592459142208, 0.01501467451453209, 0.013904854655265808, -0.02363492362201214, 0.04401183873414993, -0.008484454825520515, 0.009877004660665989, 0.042402781546115875, -0.037184521555900574, -0.055476125329732895, 0.05564604327082634, -0.031144877895712852, -0.08866669237613678, -0.051460545510053635, -0.01576700247824192, 0.06877193599939346, -0.002546423813328147, 0.009845780208706856, 0.012052018195390701, -0.03715914860367775, 0.020454367622733116, 0.0031846717465668917, 0.07248324155807495, 0.007243429776281118, 0.012691384181380272, 0.015522021800279617, 0.03180472552776337, 0.049429457634687424, 0.00187719298992306, -0.018951890990138054, 0.02508872002363205, 0.012940524145960808, 0.0037646025884896517, 0.039615362882614136, 0.0921187698841095, -0.00914656464010477, 0.015165327116847038, -0.04460011422634125, 0.03762829676270485, -0.04555460065603256, -0.0033679024782031775, 0.014640132896602154, -0.00014221438323147595, 0.015875933691859245, 0.02315937541425228, -0.04647978022694588, -0.028823664411902428, -0.001862054574303329, -0.004733191803097725, 0.009260295890271664, 0.10190105438232422, 0.04795405641198158, -0.0032649626955389977, 0.045578572899103165, -0.0029084491543471813, 0.06361115723848343, -0.006622911896556616, -0.035652343183755875, 0.0025845197960734367, 0.07981249690055847, -0.028621159493923187, 0.004370112903416157, -0.0006059206207282841, -0.07894741743803024, 0.05509468540549278, -0.024384675547480583, -0.05106334015727043, -0.010459594428539276, -0.018215276300907135, -0.03515215963125229, 0.03748522698879242, 0.009703577496111393, 0.034409504383802414, 0.01270146481692791, 0.06502865999937057, -0.027195893228054047, -0.022851785644888878, 0.061025943607091904, 0.006596999242901802, -0.0013126900885254145, 0.02799723856151104, 0.041238121688365936, -0.03315415233373642, -0.023498548194766045, 0.008412339724600315, -0.014260426163673401, -0.0019540823996067047, 0.0099608413875103, -0.0041329944506287575, -0.031148584559559822, -0.02055962383747101, -0.0347432903945446, 0.025932522490620613, 0.03083171136677265, -0.030233077704906464, 0.03503689169883728, -0.051992692053318024, -0.03416013345122337, 0.04462650790810585, -0.011866777203977108, -0.005449456162750721, 0.0675416961312294, -0.022579442709684372, 0.04996195062994957, 0.013354072347283363, 0.02724357321858406, -0.008570577017962933, 0.02950860559940338, -0.035241011530160904, -0.05087076127529144, -0.036962125450372696, -0.0033977411221712828, 0.0034052880946546793, 0.01951581798493862, -0.08520007133483887, -0.0008479857933707535, 0.024257037788629532, 0.007562138605862856, 0.0441339835524559, -0.013813912868499756, 0.012351879850029945, 0.010195896029472351, 0.022861076518893242, -0.003622623858973384, 0.021992145106196404, -0.056744132190942764, 0.0024165334179997444, -0.04036673158407211, 0.02042129822075367, -0.05964800342917442, -0.0022547170519828796, -0.06593942642211914, 0.005055421032011509, 0.06463829427957535, 0.05393030866980553, -0.08075509965419769, -0.025679852813482285, 0.027630507946014404, 0.03418739140033722, 0.054985351860523224, -0.014101197011768818, -0.03314705565571785, -0.031038131564855576, 0.027129298076033592, 0.028066294267773628, 0.07803314924240112, 0.016841620206832886, -0.0024937272537499666, 0.008336537517607212, -0.034898120909929276, -0.00701893400400877, -0.011595482006669044, -0.006118270102888346, -0.018667971715331078, -0.011955837719142437, -0.0028374723624438047, 0.022378455847501755, -0.02722095511853695, -0.021704310551285744, -0.03500204160809517, -0.04267531633377075, 0.03737562149763107, -0.006572111044079065, -0.06195802614092827, -0.019359854981303215, -0.034063905477523804, -0.003108482575044036, -0.015863269567489624, -0.03823217749595642, 0.007639163639396429, 0.04884043335914612, 0.03178422525525093, 0.032558124512434006, -0.032598596066236496, -0.03727997839450836, 0.023900363594293594, -0.02926214411854744, 0.061313446611166, -0.01906965859234333, -0.03838431090116501, 0.0018938666908070445, -0.0368008092045784, 0.018853239715099335, 0.013265400193631649, -0.010209601372480392, 0.018204668536782265, 0.012172188609838486, 0.008849311619997025, 0.009012183174490929, -0.019010446965694427, 0.0018964385380968451, -0.03341740742325783, -0.03721585497260094, 0.019651390612125397, 0.014577948488295078, 0.012883273884654045, -0.017343025654554367, -0.03497811034321785, 0.03952924162149429, -0.005864311475306749, -0.014774243347346783, -0.03704783320426941, -0.028727110475301743, -0.008500701747834682, -0.0067380513064563274, 0.008002818562090397, -0.07192996889352798, -0.04750264063477516, 0.06761708110570908, 0.03822248429059982, 0.022764461115002632, 0.026977352797985077, -0.05135561525821686, -0.04956326633691788, -0.001056665787473321, -0.013485203497111797, -0.021951336413621902, 0.009129042737185955, 0.002842737128958106, -0.04779990017414093, -0.07544821500778198, -0.029247146099805832, -0.02836301550269127, 0.012898098677396774, 0.007403234485536814, -0.07163731008768082, 0.007713555358350277, -0.05285249650478363, -0.04408755153417587, 0.029959524050354958, -0.039709996432065964, -0.019210094586014748, -0.004320952109992504, -0.011265316046774387, -0.09219741076231003, -0.052295710891485214, 0.028784988448023796, 0.040974561125040054, -0.012147092260420322, -0.08095069229602814, -0.061319008469581604, -0.011345899663865566, 0.015129431150853634, -0.006169607397168875, -0.017877966165542603, -0.02639097534120083, 0.023876728489995003, 0.018316829577088356, -0.010921263135969639, -0.04051423445343971, 0.005405530799180269, 0.0037117614410817623, 0.02609965018928051, -0.013790620490908623, 0.06666623800992966, -0.0036495542153716087, 0.047136250883340836, 0.018397672101855278, -0.040239010006189346, 0.042284294962882996, -0.05094588175415993, 0.012780214659869671, 0.027702806517481804, 0.03880876302719116, 0.0009777097729966044, 0.003992930520325899, 0.1064114049077034, 0.04400143399834633, 0.015195534564554691, 0.02900264412164688, 0.04593193531036377, 0.05358966439962387, 0.08628309518098831, 0.04999817907810211, -0.039884135127067566, -0.005485983099788427, -0.014393804594874382, -0.018143652006983757, 0.05052892863750458, 0.034144867211580276, 0.020857378840446472, 0.03267400711774826, -0.0046691568568348885, 0.0020687668584287167, 0.00613659480586648, -0.045257020741701126, -0.023971352726221085, 0.016869639977812767, -0.0659383162856102, 0.050805650651454926, 0.004936025012284517, -0.01745595782995224, -0.005214139819145203, -0.011743276380002499, -0.003512403229251504, 0.023429885506629944, -0.0013043555663898587, -0.032196421176195145, 0.021265815943479538, -0.018659010529518127, 0.009862728416919708, 0.002367795445024967, -0.02939838543534279, -0.01340404711663723, 0.040547292679548264, 0.01063371542841196, -0.024924933910369873, 0.09011553227901459, -0.06571707129478455, -0.012026801705360413, 0.006678284145891666, 0.011319159530103207, -0.07718168199062347, 0.06395436823368073, -0.021062185987830162, 0.034411098808050156, -0.03229730203747749, 0.039685267955064774, -0.060853954404592514, -0.0020410707220435143, -0.0016195412026718259, -0.017308829352259636, -0.03469621390104294, 0.08804095536470413, 0.0396113283932209, 0.01948658563196659, 0.029605073854327202, -0.03842775896191597, -0.08412719517946243, 0.03165585547685623, -0.0009016691474243999, -0.01972910389304161, 0.020898468792438507, -0.06893273442983627, 0.034611281007528305, -0.04011233523488045, 0.0587155781686306, -0.027582630515098572, 0.03306392952799797, 0.006232968531548977, -0.008045227266848087, 0.01659231446683407, -0.027919530868530273, 0.0053602359257638454, 0.020084403455257416, -0.008321979083120823, -0.028093766421079636, -0.006403317674994469, 0.021704398095607758, -0.033928390592336655, 0.03041471168398857, -0.016815589740872383, -0.03048221953213215, 0.031331002712249756, -0.06769078224897385, -0.013679210096597672, 0.03879512846469879, 0.019231973215937614, -0.011573257856070995, -0.05390637367963791, -0.03475411981344223, -0.02221478335559368, 0.016351444646716118, 0.091572105884552, 0.010619265958666801, -0.003995976876467466, 0.03414443880319595, -0.0074594272300601006, -0.03536749631166458, -0.010656883008778095, 0.05427978187799454, 0.01047206949442625, -0.04389694333076477, -0.020467311143875122, -0.002931493567302823, 0.002964823739603162, 0.029339611530303955, -0.00653634499758482, 0.017738010734319687, -0.02819322980940342, -0.012969844974577427, 0.021688196808099747, 0.008749919012188911, -0.03830208256840706, 0.044416334480047226, -0.030654653906822205, -0.03972344845533371, -0.015486461110413074, -0.0078072380274534225, 0.024651125073432922, 0.005772438365966082, 0.01215027179569006, 0.017372682690620422, -0.06741514801979065, -0.04297676682472229, 0.053578827530145645, 0.004951323848217726, -0.011555005796253681, 0.006594138685613871, -0.08030340820550919, 0.002683943137526512, 0.014440798200666904, -0.006285720970481634, 0.02130843512713909, 0.11427338421344757, 0.06414984911680222, -0.035827912390232086, -0.029788289219141006, 0.05304097756743431, -0.005537942983210087, -0.0037898635491728783, 0.05251171812415123, 0.04513479396700859, 0.06617192178964615, 0.005791383795440197, 0.005733700003474951, 0.014707248657941818, -0.004757730755954981, -0.010365878231823444, 0.010320045053958893, 0.036534663289785385, 0.008959617465734482, -0.04899286851286888, 0.004285899456590414, 0.011867249384522438, -0.08122148364782333, -0.0784057229757309, 0.013451891019940376, 0.06107780337333679, 0.0044002896174788475, -0.008538279682397842, -0.01590910367667675, -0.01124650053679943, -0.010173959657549858, -0.006678581237792969, -0.02158256061375141, -0.06191679835319519, 0.030045613646507263, -0.005340809002518654, -0.018872158601880074, -0.034135252237319946, -0.028520306572318077, 0.0810229703783989, -0.025036834180355072, -0.011123084463179111, -0.022109780460596085, 0.002900567837059498, 0.03958264738321304, -0.06278052181005478, -0.03823733702301979, 0.015330885536968708, -0.016892176121473312, -0.02304057963192463, 0.006260212045162916, 0.03807036578655243, -0.00892936997115612, -0.00987661350518465, -0.023967798799276352, -0.002075785771012306, 0.03546998277306557, 0.028595151379704475, 0.014635901898145676, 0.0014224067563191056, 0.04163390398025513, -0.055366404354572296, 0.0213598795235157, -0.03489716723561287, 0.09543734788894653, 0.051083292812108994, -0.015366467647254467, 0.06205013021826744, 0.04445071518421173, 0.07501798123121262, 0.021157093346118927, 0.06955491006374359, -0.04639780893921852, -0.04340649023652077, -0.0008410841692239046, 0.010191324166953564, -0.0045579569414258, 0.042999517172575, 0.06368239223957062, -0.02487773634493351, -0.02950309030711651, 0.0821332335472107, -0.03851328790187836, 0.007406672928482294, 0.00026269032969139516, -0.0011344279628247023, -0.0031254554633051157, 0.01504287589341402, -0.054873574525117874, -0.013057613745331764, 0.029862551018595695, -0.04344257712364197, 0.030807286500930786, -0.016158821061253548, -0.010887795127928257, 0.0005557967815548182, 0.025438325479626656, 0.038059137761592865, 0.015172841027379036, -0.019812850281596184, -0.014542629010975361, 0.03333216905593872, -0.0005339272320270538, -0.021107546985149384, 0.025100814178586006, 0.025382786989212036, -0.0408463180065155, 0.032838206738233566, -0.022405210882425308, -0.000013391706488619093, 0.054667312651872635, -0.04224894940853119, 0.0036952102091163397, 0.030764348804950714, -0.04118628054857254, 0.014815087430179119, 0.0655534565448761, -0.012554066255688667, 0.008319048210978508, -0.022976582869887352, 0.03762955218553543, 0.04585155472159386, -0.027874445542693138, 0.010106571950018406, 0.06924133747816086, -0.0029411478899419308, -0.0035371684934943914, 0.0401102676987648, -0.010068844072520733, 0.043281540274620056, 0.013468826189637184, 0.025048814713954926, -0.08711240440607071, 0.020618300884962082, 0.00408402131870389, 0.026859574019908905, 0.001285694306716323, 0.03694157302379608, 0.026406269520521164, -0.007635371759533882, -0.04771982878446579, 0.006816565059125423, 0.01930857077240944, 0.0038211557548493147, -0.12372494488954544, 0.04130297154188156, 0.09946271032094955, 0.025851357728242874, -0.04072749242186546, 0.009948472492396832, -0.02298954501748085, -0.0245318952947855, 0.00652168458327651, 0.01472007017582655, 0.029121313244104385, -0.06376095861196518, -0.07147281616926193, 0.004249241203069687, 0.029602142050862312, 0.01767992228269577, -0.0015224078670144081, 0.018332017585635185, -0.005147677380591631, -0.056215304881334305, 0.004282234702259302, -0.08432034403085709, -0.02039443328976631, 0.025285160169005394, -0.0018142485059797764, 0.009662512689828873, -0.018716225400567055, 0.015529004856944084, -0.011127341538667679, 0.034047503024339676, -0.016876474022865295, -0.012676208280026913, -0.014450397342443466, 0.02610648050904274, -0.029620777815580368, -0.042072657495737076, -0.026000317186117172, 0.01934574544429779, -0.022932030260562897, -0.030016856268048286, -0.00698514049872756, 0.034494880586862564, -0.046708885580301285, -0.03320830687880516, 0.01702476292848587, -0.004227963276207447, -0.010078518651425838, -0.058724064379930496, -0.02140117436647415, 0.026035454124212265, -0.0047493609599769115, -0.009930782951414585, -0.011723378673195839, -0.03452405706048012, -0.021108921617269516, -0.030636325478553772, 0.00831690151244402, 0.014051816426217556, 0.00012574288120958954, -0.021778885275125504, -0.050964031368494034, -0.006124705076217651, 0.013712008483707905, -0.01998749189078808, -0.022754933685064316, 0.02115689590573311, 0.04580884799361229, 0.05962084233760834, -0.03187812119722366, 0.009838536381721497, 0.03641381859779358, -0.08024033904075623, 0.0019264271249994636, -0.051734644919633865, -0.016691356897354126, -0.07027669996023178, -0.028598695993423462, -0.038149431347846985, 0.005401643458753824, -0.05950510501861572, 0.0024770915042608976, 0.04995293170213699, -0.050039827823638916, 0.018227459862828255, 0.018751295283436775, -0.004173947032541037, -0.08264459669589996, 0.05165886506438255, 0.05811290815472603, -0.06070741266012192, 0.016715722158551216, 0.020103711634874344, -0.04475962370634079, -0.010887879878282547, 0.028537221252918243, -0.00036122906021773815, 0.0064519732259213924, -0.03342631086707115, -0.06698458641767502, 0.07812201976776123, 0.012777858413755894, -0.05219411104917526, -0.009193677455186844, 0.01866920106112957, 0.012982018291950226, -0.0004917632904835045, 0.06907223910093307, -0.039948828518390656, 0.005669344216585159, 0.03283369541168213, 0.05973408371210098, 0.04291573539376259, -0.018395472317934036, -0.007505910471081734, -0.006376292090862989, 0.05348993092775345, 0.0021201896015554667, -0.04083662107586861, -0.03549618273973465, 0.00932277087122202 ]
<p>I would like to know if there is an equation to predict the pressure drop in a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venturi_tube#Venturi_tubes" rel="nofollow">venturi</a> device using a compressible fluid as the working medium. In particular, I'd like to use this equation to predict the amount of vacuum created for a given $\Delta p$ across the device. Simplifying assumptions can be made, such as equivalent inlet and outlet areas.</p>
g7485
[ -0.00012488887296058238, 0.028323553502559662, -0.02006794884800911, 0.026900336146354675, 0.007187407463788986, -0.012345698662102222, 0.01959189958870411, 0.025017673149704933, -0.09127535670995712, -0.05285421013832092, -0.005760570988059044, 0.031074319034814835, 0.018878702074289322, 0.024526655673980713, 0.03651367872953415, 0.015133211389183998, 0.09701438248157501, -0.0066315834410488605, 0.013153135776519775, -0.04284490644931793, -0.02220761775970459, 0.025369374081492424, 0.02224222756922245, -0.021726083010435104, 0.008602634072303772, -0.020963257178664207, 0.014706224203109741, 0.06305157393217087, 0.0010221595875918865, -0.009674370288848877, 0.030346661806106567, -0.005052066408097744, -0.027086786925792694, 0.013436184264719486, 0.0011162711307406425, -0.03172832354903221, 0.008076521568000317, 0.03923279792070389, -0.023359013721346855, -0.0363231897354126, 0.008474640548229218, 0.01812930777668953, -0.012805563397705555, 0.03898441046476364, -0.03307750076055527, -0.012118680402636528, -0.04974052682518959, -0.036362309008836746, -0.024692703038454056, 0.028769321739673615, 0.036773644387722015, 0.004727953113615513, -0.020357023924589157, 0.006203960161656141, -0.013509350828826427, 0.014491863548755646, -0.008841581642627716, -0.023201866075396538, 0.029004745185375214, 0.022563951089978218, -0.05344197899103165, -0.011541949585080147, -0.013625641353428364, 0.008514435961842537, 0.07475554198026657, 0.008243289776146412, -0.03133527934551239, -0.03869808465242386, -0.013195764273405075, -0.009793763048946857, -0.02843085117638111, 0.0292732622474432, 0.04123079776763916, 0.011256561614573002, -0.0239134319126606, 0.05173158645629883, -0.041853953152894974, -0.02655869722366333, 0.07029387354850769, -0.05947423726320267, 0.03833439573645592, -0.014655937440693378, 0.02575492113828659, 0.017498359084129333, 0.018734348937869072, -0.06700494885444641, 0.01165030524134636, 0.04218060523271561, 0.042075015604496, -0.0013267400208860636, -0.00996347889304161, -0.015838131308555603, 0.031591519713401794, 0.004040908999741077, 0.01662536896765232, -0.007171480916440487, -0.014772995375096798, 0.027569683268666267, 0.025482242926955223, -0.058332882821559906, 0.04526752233505249, 0.007965552620589733, 0.029437461867928505, -0.03935650736093521, -0.025673530995845795, 0.002565954579040408, -0.004695064388215542, -0.00174687837716192, -0.005657237488776445, -0.05096147581934929, -0.034953534603118896, -0.028281988576054573, -0.0860961452126503, 0.06677725166082382, -0.01160587277263403, -0.06519521772861481, -0.022809328511357307, -0.011463447473943233, 0.022716784849762917, 0.02608501724898815, -0.00447247177362442, 0.07036298513412476, 0.02502995915710926, -0.006347070913761854, -0.03369264677166939, 0.025966694578528404, -0.08179323375225067, -0.01888241246342659, 0.01609531044960022, 0.047907378524541855, 0.05410464480519295, -0.03907102718949318, -0.010100522078573704, 0.006684189196676016, 0.031097661703824997, 0.05530541390180588, -0.04941624402999878, -0.026709962636232376, 0.019655434414744377, 0.0017525178845971823, 0.050010502338409424, 0.004290995188057423, -0.020370904356241226, 0.01267270091921091, 0.03082485869526863, -0.039324428886175156, -0.018233923241496086, -0.018830833956599236, 0.009347331710159779, -0.02308969385921955, 0.027090691030025482, 0.04004187136888504, -0.006661561317741871, -0.0011821126099675894, 0.046015605330467224, 0.00445809168741107, -0.011931338347494602, -0.012677256017923355, -0.05279635265469551, -0.0221879743039608, 0.06617250293493271, -0.017719104886054993, 0.05278641730546951, -0.005676195956766605, -0.03761480003595352, -0.007444689981639385, -0.019675130024552345, -0.02512698993086815, -0.03366584703326225, -0.026377631351351738, -0.012767507694661617, -0.0247260183095932, 0.003409074852243066, 0.026097845286130905, -0.008587713353335857, 0.006498127244412899, 0.10812292993068695, 0.042075544595718384, 0.012583745643496513, -0.044411979615688324, 0.015381303615868092, -0.0125195337459445, 0.07795009016990662, -0.021590949967503548, -0.021359167993068695, 0.032340433448553085, 0.03181719034910202, -0.000017458945876569487, -0.07875397801399231, 0.004559189081192017, 0.007019385229796171, 0.0019446124788373709, 0.08517307788133621, 0.04750242456793785, 0.006834610365331173, 0.06946805864572525, 0.02498765103518963, -0.04713907092809677, 0.030282944440841675, 0.02682456746697426, -0.007752387784421444, 0.05426758527755737, 0.0731826052069664, 0.015910958871245384, 0.040110498666763306, -0.022703271359205246, 0.020377283915877342, -0.01365788746625185, 0.030510472133755684, -0.020226437598466873, 0.010082951746881008, -0.01589387282729149, 0.04622340574860573, 0.05266554281115532, -0.02124445140361786, -0.04664945229887962, -0.005308447405695915, 0.01662595197558403, 0.00035090502933599055, 0.028388170525431633, -0.03595425933599472, -0.0020228216890245676, -0.05634358152747154, -0.01561501994729042, -0.04065978154540062, -0.02728537656366825, 0.02248656377196312, -0.018481474369764328, 0.00701392674818635, 0.005891505628824234, -0.0018473573727533221, 0.008613035082817078, -0.0077290344052016735, -0.0013987029669806361, 0.005828160792589188, 0.017430735751986504, -0.03424382209777832, -0.0012004663003608584, 0.0185819361358881, 0.02930542640388012, 0.032480571419000626, -0.09715285897254944, 0.02827274426817894, -0.0038835417944937944, -0.07142909616231918, -0.060024693608284, -0.03029784746468067, -0.08448880910873413, 0.07819215953350067, 0.0038432134315371513, -0.0343458466231823, -0.023158542811870575, 0.011873865500092506, -0.03331705555319786, -0.002377129625529051, 0.029718251898884773, 0.001010347856208682, 0.002002537716180086, -0.002072902163490653, -0.010063860565423965, -0.009623223915696144, 0.0070341103710234165, 0.02958216704428196, 0.044661812484264374, 0.010432753711938858, -0.0010305189061909914, 0.003830365603789687, 0.03179384395480156, 0.05936316400766373, 0.09289103001356125, 0.02382306382060051, -0.014656501822173595, 0.006748763844370842, -0.0157028678804636, 0.0021687608677893877, -0.06625520437955856, 0.047632694244384766, 0.01254917960613966, -0.014422557316720486, 0.0248628631234169, 0.022968415170907974, -0.0503988042473793, -0.02922799438238144, 0.06300535798072815, -0.008821251802146435, -0.06396429985761642, 0.05758043751120567, 0.022040067240595818, 0.01847216859459877, 0.08108092844486237, 0.02758551947772503, 0.00027575762942433357, -0.04444583132863045, -0.0029214643873274326, 0.0006067412905395031, 0.06799091398715973, 0.05075353384017944, 0.061827465891838074, -0.015897227451205254, 0.0075953262858092785, -0.058356452733278275, -0.07167638093233109, 0.009388577193021774, -0.004284631460905075, -0.0021234408486634493, -0.01249772123992443, -0.0013494845479726791, 0.01369791105389595, 0.012042025104165077, -0.033696431666612625, -0.07094742357730865, 0.0417143739759922, 0.05343220755457878, -0.05126883462071419, -0.050900302827358246, -0.01693594455718994, 0.033066291362047195, -0.009947906248271465, -0.030043017119169235, 0.07676688581705093, 0.05681433901190758, -0.04788152873516083, 0.02902952767908573, -0.01652148924767971, -0.004404969979077578, 0.019603822380304337, -0.022980738431215286, 0.04687989503145218, -0.011973152868449688, 0.014557353220880032, 0.07213906943798065, 0.004206470213830471, 0.005499518010765314, -0.03994418680667877, 0.004508873447775841, 0.004960689228028059, -0.04932347312569618, 0.061077602207660675, -0.010484977625310421, -0.010382357984781265, -0.039239998906850815, -0.05912477895617485, 0.007014847826212645, -0.0113648297265172, -0.006094517186284065, 0.02440599538385868, 0.037924014031887054, 0.06450175493955612, 0.0650748610496521, 0.04301432892680168, 0.048600878566503525, -0.028470581397414207, 0.0006277224165387452, -0.028516873717308044, 0.008464493788778782, 0.019649511203169823, 0.06020849570631981, -0.0020431524608284235, -0.018182363361120224, 0.007643314078450203, 0.05760744586586952, -0.09162066876888275, -0.03242999687790871, 0.0041739982552826405, -0.01584439165890217, -0.04774162545800209, 0.0650314912199974, 0.0025486948434263468, -0.033772341907024384, -0.037089746445417404, -0.005080231465399265, 0.0013931668363511562, 0.006403186824172735, 0.061110980808734894, -0.04911963641643524, -0.06153310835361481, 0.0072318012826144695, -0.023884499445557594, -0.0368511825799942, 0.03400999307632446, 0.01929805614054203, 0.018016105517745018, -0.030170539394021034, -0.014721376821398735, -0.027796290814876556, -0.029106760397553444, -0.056880224496126175, 0.06355452537536621, 0.05428905785083771, -0.08506801724433899, -0.030833914875984192, -0.06324181705713272, -0.08067381381988525, 0.025473549962043762, -0.0034752804785966873, 0.014806689694523811, 0.03875090554356575, -0.006645622197538614, -0.048818930983543396, -0.00512021454051137, 0.006486078724265099, -0.007972382940351963, 0.06620825827121735, 0.033987097442150116, -0.01486348919570446, -0.018476229161024094, 0.042150795459747314, 0.02771972492337227, 0.0035127117298543453, -0.03974822163581848, 0.02518247812986374, -0.02327319048345089, -0.034492190927267075, -0.025625506415963173, 0.05214213952422142, -0.029254095628857613, -0.046142641454935074, 0.0037753244396299124, 0.03662944585084915, 0.015569789335131645, 0.03919642046093941, -0.015329590998589993, 0.04852858558297157, 0.03508386388421059, -0.05094442516565323, 0.008000529371201992, 0.036461085081100464, 0.034918513149023056, -0.001967164222151041, -0.023987948894500732, 0.017832528799772263, -0.02497483603656292, -0.019925083965063095, 0.03237420693039894, 0.0013634399510920048, 0.035952743142843246, -0.023897580802440643, -0.07082556188106537, 0.009397892281413078, -0.04096834734082222, 0.006838780362159014, -0.016935676336288452, 0.010289348661899567, -0.022928200662136078, -0.021660327911376953, 0.12487103044986725, 0.011377712711691856, -0.05416279658675194, -0.011321582831442356, 0.05641917511820793, -0.07639067620038986, -0.028668664395809174, 0.021656591445207596, -0.07238785177469254, 0.020165253430604935, 0.054625559598207474, 0.008842709474265575, -0.032784175127744675, 0.08283321559429169, -0.0259112399071455, 0.020711924880743027, -0.030587133020162582, -0.011556008830666542, 0.03908872604370117, 0.011197037994861603, -0.026748592033982277, -0.035669438540935516, -0.020609626546502113, -0.026433873921632767, -0.024474404752254486, -0.06808783113956451, -0.014857898466289043, -0.016713136807084084, 0.05168823525309563, 0.020993374288082123, 0.007901645265519619, -0.010260673239827156, -0.012977509759366512, -0.0009400818962603807, -0.006960403174161911, -0.011506905779242516, -0.0004054173768963665, -0.005965161137282848, 0.00393048208206892, 0.006147164385765791, -0.006042111199349165, -0.06325963884592056, 0.05464094132184982, 0.001611185958608985, -0.0005534594529308379, 0.04550803452730179, 0.031506430357694626, -0.0064948019571602345, -0.03011074848473072, -0.08066172152757645, -0.029872551560401917, 0.03397022932767868, -0.0372331328690052, -0.05393098294734955, 0.031851787120103836, -0.07078917324542999, -0.017512165009975433, -0.008457029238343239, -0.03417033702135086, 0.018752308562397957, 0.012390571646392345, 0.014851284213364124, 0.0086214579641819, 0.05829823389649391, 0.09084053337574005, 0.03211154416203499, 0.011469168588519096, -0.039943818002939224, -0.022121794521808624, 0.009020613506436348, 0.027205143123865128, -0.056730788201093674, 0.008491884917020798, -0.05373081937432289, 0.009616292081773281, 0.050693683326244354, -0.013791650533676147, 0.0313907228410244, 0.068560391664505, -0.019603224471211433, -0.014350760728120804, -0.02362002618610859, -0.03432658687233925, 0.04984583705663681, -0.026292238384485245, -0.052433520555496216, -0.0377182699739933, 0.02185848355293274, 0.003637295216321945, -0.010592497885227203, 0.00954283308237791, 0.03025973215699196, 0.05759076774120331, 0.07466888427734375, -0.024372052401304245, -0.0434311218559742, 0.034551750868558884, -0.015501121990382671, 0.022068332880735397, 0.01952465809881687, 0.024994950741529465, -0.016482068225741386, 0.06460894644260406, 0.019213519990444183, -0.0533360056579113, -0.04967596009373665, 0.06374238431453705, -0.018539972603321075, 0.025037351995706558, 0.027631713077425957, -0.03934192657470703, 0.08616861701011658, 0.019194964319467545, 0.0071615194901824, -0.004214494489133358, 0.00047497785999439657, -0.02383696846663952, 0.01887686364352703, 0.030337324365973473, -0.028081443160772324, -0.05148522928357124, -0.028697241097688675, -0.007081086281687021, 0.06105395033955574, 0.044943105429410934, 0.0038446050602942705, -0.021737584844231606, -0.0504399798810482, -0.09115885198116302, -0.04774964228272438, -0.018112249672412872, 0.016709158197045326, -0.024230370298027992, -0.0055047147907316685, 0.042181190103292465, 0.0348719023168087, 0.011625198647379875, 0.04435659199953079, -0.006873792968690395, 0.017286216840147972, 0.042901232838630676, -0.021088534966111183, 0.00680195027962327, -0.0038979854434728622, 0.06125514581799507, 0.06574010848999023, -0.009385334327816963, 0.015265502966940403, 0.02717440389096737, 0.002873299876227975, -0.02404920756816864, -0.05598466098308563, 0.012161076068878174, 0.033453311771154404, 0.010937625542283058, 0.0032342730555683374, 0.06796541064977646, -0.07585091143846512, -0.0233760979026556, -0.012587218545377254, 0.01134596485644579, -0.04333283752202988, 0.028215110301971436, -0.013627206906676292, -0.023764681071043015, 0.004635212477296591, 0.012847076170146465, 0.04575420543551445, -0.01191070955246687, 0.023089587688446045, -0.020522838458418846, 0.037956103682518005, 0.0023755026049911976, -0.0004061564104631543, 0.008368164300918579, 0.02884647063910961, -0.0020047156140208244, -0.0024486538022756577, -0.05385403335094452, -0.01474957074970007, 0.043882403522729874, -0.02944149076938629, -0.01789029687643051, 0.06552082300186157, -0.019779471680521965, -0.021832499653100967, -0.04303222522139549, 0.005817025434225798, 0.011686495505273342, -0.05882880091667175, 0.029634254053235054, -0.003448337083682418, -0.04040735960006714, 0.04978479444980621, 0.025395262986421585, 0.001010711770504713, -0.00828635785728693, 0.008878097869455814, 0.042392928153276443, -0.04620851203799248, -0.0072659775614738464, -0.006764847785234451, 0.05645532160997391, -0.004259235691279173, -0.02393997274339199, 0.020858868956565857, -0.06591677665710449, 0.008844321593642235, 0.02578604221343994, -0.04218282550573349, 0.02060686983168125, -0.028844162821769714, -0.014818255789577961, -0.02577054686844349, -0.043224629014730453, 0.06703957915306091, -0.07007214426994324, 0.022007690742611885, 0.039330754429101944, 0.04163562133908272, 0.023551370948553085, -0.003812402253970504, -0.043657053261995316, 0.04640769585967064, -0.055947452783584595, 0.020997654646635056, -0.017672495916485786, -0.048503972589969635, -0.022644711658358574, -0.03717184066772461, -0.03515610471367836, 0.015547031536698341, -0.05261057987809181, -0.03615805134177208, -0.04233381524682045, -0.05273658409714699, -0.034331198781728745, -0.03231910988688469, -0.06473094969987869, -0.04983258247375488, 0.05994563549757004, 0.011293536052107811, -0.019581902772188187, -0.018174121156334877, 0.02816716395318508, -0.008914698846638203, 0.0076310764998197556, 0.06273776292800903, -0.02137640118598938, -0.02503775991499424, 0.031039899215102196, 0.01953626051545143, -0.020265288650989532, -0.0013583425898104906, -0.04287207871675491, 0.03548673540353775, 0.048181165009737015, -0.05573089420795441, 0.0037572698201984167, -0.05811503157019615, 0.02380209043622017, -0.0368155874311924, 0.03678704425692558, 0.009319187141954899, 0.016509024426341057, 0.05945105478167534, 0.006751365028321743, -0.021241940557956696, -0.011819853447377682, -0.0013484569499269128, -0.05485813319683075, -0.05899489298462868, 0.007790358737111092, 0.04190773889422417, 0.009129391983151436, -0.05558649078011513, -0.007882521487772465, 0.003855216782540083, -0.05179798603057861, 0.020651662722229958, 0.01855628937482834, -0.041325271129608154, 0.014456810429692268, -0.05920281261205673, 0.012379676103591919, -0.025485532358288765, 0.027858451008796692, -0.013476988300681114, 0.04970071464776993, 0.01554282009601593, -0.05909678339958191, 0.01912209764122963, 0.05053035542368889, -0.024055682122707367, -0.011299417354166508, 0.0020089084282517433, -0.010853013023734093, -0.016199693083763123, -0.04723815247416496, 0.04469186067581177, -0.03632689267396927, -0.04207947477698326, 0.008870447985827923, 0.040149055421352386, -0.003034791210666299, 0.05234191194176674, 0.006314228754490614, 0.04172839596867561, -0.03485848754644394, 0.009991683065891266, -0.06330346316099167, -0.036125510931015015, 0.020716406404972076, -0.013479720801115036, -0.06996926665306091, 0.004271305166184902, 0.021113689988851547, -0.0029091292526572943, -0.05666708946228027, 0.009493935853242874, 0.03527317941188812, 0.04410107061266899, -0.033019207417964935 ]
<p>I am currently struggling with the formula for an exact current in QFT, a fermion with an upcoming momentum $p$ and an outgoing momentum $p&#39;$. My problem is to show whether or not a term of the form $\bar{u}(p&#39;)F(q^2)i\sigma^{\mu\nu}(p+p&#39;)^{\nu}$ where $\sigma^{\mu\nu}=\frac{i}{2}[\gamma^{\mu},\gamma^{\nu}]$. I would like it to be forbidden by current conservation but I can't prove it, is my intuition wrong?</p>
g7486
[ 0.003268014406785369, -0.04782487452030182, 0.0038919951766729355, -0.08228444308042526, 0.06079883128404617, -0.0038203198928385973, -0.01411409955471754, -0.0076370141468942165, -0.04612317681312561, 0.022657103836536407, -0.019936541095376015, 0.025392262265086174, -0.07079817354679108, 0.037240512669086456, 0.04322398826479912, 0.042370375245809555, 0.04944003373384476, 0.0204740259796381, -0.015128649771213531, -0.0030380107928067446, -0.022908078506588936, -0.020991837605834007, 0.020459380000829697, 0.0028031091205775738, 0.03333202004432678, 0.0032630651257932186, -0.021831389516592026, 0.005474550649523735, -0.002293376484885812, -0.02103581093251705, -0.013539078645408154, 0.04227323457598686, 0.022731656208634377, -0.015754640102386475, -0.015234144404530525, -0.008425537496805191, 0.07537247985601425, -0.0022268020547926426, 0.07816760241985321, -0.04506237432360649, -0.025411318987607956, 0.030197536572813988, -0.01126669067889452, 0.001636960543692112, -0.023141011595726013, -0.015882516279816628, -0.040501344949007034, -0.01133333146572113, -0.057016197592020035, -0.012791838496923447, -0.043471336364746094, 0.016366280615329742, 0.029344141483306885, -0.052280984818935394, -0.04381393641233444, 0.005406645592302084, 0.0016242270357906818, -0.057435594499111176, -0.006906143389642239, 0.016570832580327988, 0.0002994771348312497, -0.03485949710011482, 0.02813698910176754, 0.01676778309047222, 0.03625866398215294, -0.0029861077200621367, -0.04541270062327385, 0.0004478952323552221, -0.023156536743044853, 0.021650943905115128, -0.05050931125879288, 0.006718911230564117, 0.006948187947273254, 0.009173284284770489, 0.045258790254592896, 0.06031201779842377, -0.040814440697431564, 0.019435202702879906, 0.03040287271142006, -0.014202872291207314, -0.05879081413149834, -0.027852166444063187, 0.05821080878376961, 0.04653506353497505, 0.044133443385362625, -0.037881121039390564, -0.04963573440909386, 0.054028578102588654, 0.0027579939924180508, -0.030838437378406525, 0.009848061949014664, -0.09233850240707397, -0.02967638336122036, -0.028762565925717354, 0.05731087550520897, 0.034013304859399796, -0.0028216103091835976, 0.0344601608812809, -0.019791804254055023, 0.02228916995227337, 0.009920436888933182, 0.01629640720784664, 0.014726015739142895, 0.06687479466199875, -0.01857849396765232, -0.05966589227318764, 0.009495142847299576, 0.012867932207882404, 0.009795846417546272, 0.01677890121936798, -0.008639483712613583, -0.0026802837383002043, -0.009874697774648666, -0.027694538235664368, -0.03916852921247482, -0.02001909539103508, -0.046446822583675385, -0.005555069539695978, 0.006645287852734327, 0.025210192427039146, -0.048785287886857986, 0.030580073595046997, 0.06854520738124847, 0.03655301779508591, 0.024203937500715256, -0.03514889255166054, -0.06210467219352722, 0.06018437445163727, 0.06413891911506653, 0.027350297197699547, -0.008939215913414955, -0.04790319874882698, 0.029151268303394318, 0.012719987891614437, 0.02683553658425808, -0.006039994768798351, 0.0333387516438961, 0.00572539959102869, 0.019760416820645332, -0.022674845531582832, 0.004622709006071091, -0.02870526909828186, 0.02426941879093647, -0.017342260107398033, -0.04548102617263794, -0.03126991167664528, 0.015117851085960865, -0.003709387267008424, 0.03515412285923958, 0.030515475198626518, 0.004984322004020214, 0.09322014451026917, -0.06396782398223877, 0.0745948925614357, 0.0349765345454216, -0.023141629993915558, 0.02919461578130722, -0.026769746094942093, -0.013919222168624401, 0.027023574337363243, 0.05971783027052879, 0.02491449937224388, -0.0014018871588632464, -0.059113211929798126, -0.04092016443610191, -0.046748414635658264, 0.019892465323209763, -0.036249492317438126, -0.07462668418884277, -0.029851386323571205, -0.08239619433879852, 0.04620008170604706, 0.05878240615129471, 0.056719645857810974, 0.018756510689854622, 0.02250341884791851, -0.023122649639844894, 0.014444251544773579, 0.014677965082228184, 0.025881629437208176, -0.05370225012302399, -0.04768405109643936, 0.0284224022179842, 0.0005871264147572219, -0.06482047587633133, 0.022137925028800964, -0.03129775449633598, 0.08080001175403595, -0.01214628852903843, -0.019924314692616463, -0.035637062042951584, 0.010131984017789364, -0.004719182848930359, 0.062021564692258835, -0.02378622069954872, 0.068161740899086, -0.005239128600805998, -0.05346253141760826, -0.04635380953550339, 0.04827660694718361, -0.05194640904664993, 0.07285089790821075, 0.06537804007530212, 0.02329675480723381, 0.05948805436491966, 0.019379740580916405, 0.010822459124028683, -0.026167007163167, 0.07356879860162735, -0.01179834920912981, 0.027914267033338547, -0.06272107362747192, 0.0013540465151891112, 0.05761842802166939, -0.01343105174601078, -0.060461852699518204, 0.011068463325500488, 0.023255785927176476, -0.06369737535715103, 0.047866091132164, -0.01511771697551012, -0.028455257415771484, 0.053346943110227585, 0.0348944365978241, -0.07930097728967667, 0.037405408918857574, -0.021436909213662148, -0.020492304116487503, -0.04166005924344063, 0.06774773448705673, -0.0510452538728714, 0.0244913250207901, -0.020850207656621933, -0.006897305138409138, -0.02330828085541725, 0.0280483178794384, -0.030464665964245796, 0.029965491965413094, -0.009056155569851398, 0.025181347504258156, -0.009257953613996506, 0.009821522049605846, -0.03640563413500786, 0.004139134660363197, 0.003733918769285083, -0.04357033967971802, 0.05798284709453583, 0.06006063148379326, 0.015478224493563175, 0.008706826716661453, 0.03952563554048538, 0.007128554861992598, -0.013289916329085827, 0.05070085451006889, -0.06475500017404556, -0.000674089475069195, 0.00007731516234343871, -0.006876090541481972, -0.06762904673814774, -0.056963931769132614, 0.00920113269239664, -0.09956511110067368, 0.003410405246540904, -0.0016580006340518594, -0.012463037855923176, 0.041355885565280914, -0.008357912302017212, 0.0640704482793808, 0.015783468261361122, 0.04099893197417259, -0.03770953789353371, 0.032903529703617096, -0.016106970608234406, 0.05773324519395828, -0.006969634909182787, -0.0042150020599365234, 0.012784064747393131, -0.042673997581005096, -0.001304235658608377, 0.0009965141071006656, -0.034672677516937256, 0.048729799687862396, -0.048414625227451324, 0.059355877339839935, 0.002629580209031701, -0.0380430705845356, 0.00043139970512129366, 0.026437515392899513, 0.0325610376894474, -0.014139276929199696, 0.02120637334883213, 0.026615211740136147, 0.04777689278125763, 0.036468278616666794, -0.024432135745882988, 0.022263692691922188, -0.01777634210884571, -0.006703621242195368, -0.023217525333166122, 0.028297532349824905, 0.04472833499312401, 0.019937684759497643, 0.014536394737660885, 0.0071353004314005375, 0.06523023545742035, 0.022326635196805, -0.041457243263721466, -0.009824324399232864, 0.0037803782615810633, -0.015390102751553059, -0.06886960566043854, 0.0705878958106041, 0.0005982225993648171, -0.01713520474731922, -0.0820607990026474, -0.003977624699473381, 0.0053853606805205345, -0.027216585353016853, -0.013956745155155659, 0.012079194188117981, -0.01726621203124523, -0.016853606328368187, 0.01142892800271511, 0.015777938067913055, 0.050897471606731415, 0.03783340007066727, -0.02916421741247177, 0.03554489463567734, -0.06309527903795242, -0.03654317557811737, 0.016872141510248184, 0.05135536193847656, 0.009797586128115654, -0.04112674668431282, -0.00984287541359663, -0.0032162093557417393, 0.000321939995046705, 0.06655292958021164, 0.007268398068845272, -0.009737756103277206, -0.0016659750835970044, -0.005500442814081907, -0.011416960507631302, -0.005260964389890432, 0.009357276372611523, -0.017650073394179344, 0.005392061080783606, 0.03474476560950279, 0.008524754084646702, -0.01361779309809208, -0.069198839366436, -0.0015300322556868196, 0.002258923137560487, -0.006240943446755409, 0.033681344240903854, 0.02306205965578556, -0.013889444060623646, 0.06004704535007477, 0.03356108069419861, -0.010425032116472721, -0.0302891843020916, -0.03414769843220711, 0.03401936963200569, 0.06608574837446213, 0.004367487970739603, -0.04025774076581001, 0.016440164297819138, -0.029255453497171402, 0.0006432633381336927, -0.009635012596845627, 0.04461223632097244, 0.01031589787453413, -0.0151638463139534, 0.06104874610900879, -0.0005952577921561897, -0.06018667295575142, 0.03146833926439285, -0.008823485113680363, -0.06386920064687729, 0.022646067664027214, 0.011333286762237549, 0.008467031642794609, 0.007509788032621145, 0.05964798107743263, 0.0012839250266551971, 0.07306043058633804, -0.03508689999580383, 0.012933073565363884, 0.031183715909719467, -0.0004376314755063504, -0.0009066486964002252, 0.01997736468911171, 0.01696578413248062, -0.012020519003272057, -0.03670309856534004, -0.03459334746003151, 0.04541667923331261, -0.06017906591296196, 0.0019023376516997814, -0.015711773186922073, -0.007247738540172577, 0.01749657653272152, 0.010700087063014507, -0.05691084265708923, -0.033842653036117554, 0.036259885877370834, -0.013426641002297401, -0.030269043520092964, 0.030977804213762283, -0.051583606749773026, -0.04669107496738434, 0.010915757156908512, 0.01255338080227375, 0.013680927455425262, 0.023974724113941193, -0.02967490628361702, -0.024868708103895187, -0.04997562989592552, -0.011430488899350166, -0.011611242778599262, 0.06911924481391907, 0.01965017430484295, 0.010089805349707603, 0.004242802504450083, 0.04603764787316322, 0.04303620755672455, 0.04777541011571884, -0.004147215746343136, -0.021691078320145607, -0.01893881894648075, 0.01810440793633461, 0.06919331103563309, -0.03373066335916519, 0.013759727589786053, -0.10812178999185562, 0.03456523269414902, -0.11107956618070602, -0.01524181105196476, 0.02485720068216324, 0.080281563103199, 0.0587308444082737, -0.03287651762366295, 0.017733260989189148, -0.019173311069607735, 0.015330606140196323, 0.03949678689241409, -0.033852461725473404, -0.02195383608341217, 0.05073033645749092, 0.026673907414078712, -0.02399812638759613, -0.03370223939418793, -0.00935422070324421, -0.04237140715122223, 0.03326130658388138, -0.017515115439891815, -0.06127389520406723, -0.020406268537044525, 0.027482880279421806, -0.017495695501565933, -0.02415355108678341, -0.02312343381345272, 0.06925419718027115, 0.01740032061934471, 0.045065343379974365, -0.0007751904777251184, -0.07299778610467911, 0.02795662172138691, -0.019134169444441795, -0.05180596560239792, 0.015321501530706882, 0.019519787281751633, 0.03745885193347931, -0.03745123744010925, -0.0371972918510437, 0.028118249028921127, 0.0012695458717644215, -0.003371365601196885, -0.022764690220355988, -0.06982680410146713, 0.01363140344619751, -0.012596238404512405, -0.004855106119066477, 0.02854248322546482, -0.015726501122117043, 0.017051545903086662, -0.029032547026872635, 0.02906970866024494, -0.00012650743883568794, -0.04935548081994057, -0.004059073980897665, 0.06584783643484116, 0.02473372407257557, 0.0024888920597732067, -0.003881399054080248, 0.03665480390191078, 0.01438012532889843, 0.024145934730768204, -0.011699269525706768, -0.02011614851653576, 0.006973156705498695, -0.05556882545351982, -0.041512757539749146, 0.019188180565834045, 0.027149399742484093, 0.10147217661142349, 0.05843299999833107, -0.031229721382260323, 0.006756143178790808, -0.028512341901659966, 0.008737350814044476, -0.005567831452935934, 0.05637623369693756, -0.07296950370073318, 0.028807951137423515, 0.03609895333647728, -0.01070626825094223, -0.05026771128177643, -0.0346580371260643, -0.0421612374484539, 0.02167660929262638, 0.04254542291164398, -0.017153790220618248, -0.0012098801089450717, 0.012533416971564293, 0.0040937019512057304, -0.0215595755726099, -0.04324807599186897, 0.008086233399808407, 0.030028071254491806, 0.04808879271149635, -0.05601920932531357, 0.008688656613230705, -0.03157215565443039, 0.002210197038948536, 0.0013083495432510972, 0.07078529894351959, 0.017594726756215096, -0.060854434967041016, 0.007561633829027414, -0.024836791679263115, 0.010172244161367416, -0.024030352011322975, 0.0705466940999031, -0.057196564972400665, -0.005428353324532509, -0.02961268462240696, -0.06926946341991425, 0.054131824523210526, -0.0648820698261261, 0.017356622964143753, -0.008132432587444782, -0.047797154635190964, -0.027492458000779152, 0.020476732403039932, 0.033614642918109894, 0.006828452926129103, -0.003281337209045887, -0.03414258733391762, -0.011426691897213459, -0.016843590885400772, -0.04390402138233185, -0.0005428089643828571, -0.013884852640330791, 0.031779687851667404, -0.018110735341906548, 0.0030963337048888206, -0.013689768500626087, 0.06275402009487152, -0.006198551505804062, 0.011184551753103733, 0.06772226095199585, -0.0014448739821091294, 0.010957509279251099, -0.007772466633468866, -0.008451282978057861, -0.003419858403503895, -0.009164566174149513, 0.012917608954012394, 0.015063215047121048, 0.0001966202980838716, 0.03203386813402176, 0.02242814190685749, -0.05285961553454399, 0.01025289949029684, 0.05860577151179314, -0.015562121756374836, -0.010524770244956017, 0.023338576778769493, 0.025036172941327095, 0.003633584827184677, 0.037380848079919815, -0.01535914558917284, 0.003693364327773452, 0.021512232720851898, 0.046590644866228104, 0.010188568383455276, -0.08214441686868668, -0.005191055126488209, 0.022758593782782555, 0.0006221369840204716, -0.025867903605103493, 0.0033352405298501253, 0.013206847943365574, 0.04654749110341072, 0.0681418925523758, 0.024902954697608948, 0.07385749369859695, 0.0016440507024526596, -0.016206664964556694, 0.029423944652080536, 0.013549499213695526, 0.027787545695900917, -0.008606791496276855, -0.029775166884064674, -0.06637074053287506, -0.011181775480508804, 0.053412195295095444, -0.07898770272731781, -0.016423091292381287, 0.0708962082862854, 0.016022715717554092, -0.009292563423514366, -0.03175027295947075, 0.05064209923148155, 0.02915368601679802, -0.018104244023561478, 0.010357175953686237, 0.016854748129844666, 0.00026929256273433566, 0.022417115047574043, 0.013401152566075325, 0.028597425669431686, -0.043839916586875916, -0.00974202249199152, 0.056625038385391235, 0.0013373232213780284, 0.05414026975631714, 0.007213890086859465, 0.02257750928401947, 0.04419897496700287, -0.007005934137851, -0.011909513734281063, -0.005241628736257553, -0.06305058300495148, 0.011747500859200954, 0.049161043018102646, -0.005747242830693722, -0.11347202956676483, 0.010627088136970997, 0.05266310274600983, 0.01370092760771513, 0.016957459971308708, 0.018809866160154343, -0.044647179543972015, 0.0020430637523531914, 0.01578650437295437, -0.015995673835277557, -0.021526185795664787, -0.05121565982699394, 0.042175691574811935, -0.013333655893802643, 0.001116676488891244, -0.0020755615551024675, 0.02861841395497322, 0.007396601140499115, -0.008966800756752491, -0.07933308184146881, 0.047312408685684204, -0.04090012237429619, 0.009587573818862438, -0.051665373146533966, -0.045810602605342865, -0.04333944618701935, -0.01750902459025383, 0.0013395389541983604, -0.005386629141867161, 0.06403116881847382, -0.008366084657609463, -0.016949811950325966, -0.027397891506552696, 0.015866322442889214, -0.056307487189769745, -0.04137396067380905, -0.017801877111196518, 0.015958217903971672, -0.007362427189946175, -0.03131568059325218, -0.0023514870554208755, 0.048080090433359146, -0.00970490463078022, 0.003180521307513118, 0.04658201336860657, -0.07450675964355469, -0.0007158197113312781, 0.021537592634558678, -0.002014594152569771, 0.03237025812268257, 0.011757039465010166, 0.030379436910152435, 0.04161631315946579, -0.0263203252106905, 0.023975927382707596, -0.0027721328660845757, 0.02602211758494377, 0.03174876794219017, 0.001205818960443139, -0.058782774955034256, -0.041827134788036346, -0.025339582934975624, 0.0575302429497242, -0.006764107849448919, 0.0036956199910491705, -0.0280374176800251, 0.04413975402712822, -0.035747334361076355, -0.015191599726676941, -0.005711408331990242, 0.062962107360363, -0.035881441086530685, 0.010995401069521904, 0.01352347619831562, -0.11039121448993683, -0.02470940537750721, -0.06721658259630203, -0.011264827102422714, -0.024668360128998756, 0.0024831187911331654, -0.0020140085835009813, 0.015588121488690376, -0.0644390657544136, -0.013019620440900326, -0.028703272342681885, -0.015139689669013023, -0.053395483642816544, -0.02124863490462303, -0.06449314951896667, -0.04533913731575012, 0.006507783196866512, -0.01073447335511446, -0.014139320701360703, -0.01510348916053772, 0.003878477495163679, 0.007624352816492319, -0.026827838271856308, -0.0039135850965976715, -0.00010546315024839714, 0.0351468063890934, 0.04868561401963234, -0.021122684702277184, -0.004702464211732149, 0.04944434389472008, -0.06796106696128845, 0.01785300485789776, 0.019828319549560547, -0.06598079949617386, -0.07162194699048996, 0.02311939187347889, -0.004920573439449072, 0.03959380090236664, -0.03486517444252968, 0.009103653952479362, 0.003386270720511675, 0.0421542152762413, 0.009021004661917686, -0.07146550714969635, 0.013943557627499104, -0.01984790712594986 ]
<p>For a centrifugal compressor, as found in most turbochargers on internal combustion engines, is there a noticeable change in flow rate versus a naturally aspirated flow rate? In other words, does the pump effectively increase the pressure of the gas only, or does it also increase the flow rate? Really what I'd like to know is how much of the work a turbocharger does goes into increasing the density of the fluid versus how much of it goes into raising its temperature, per the ideal gas law.</p>
g7487
[ 0.019105441868305206, 0.03260420262813568, 0.016458911821246147, 0.0391569547355175, 0.06150952726602554, -0.040720514953136444, -0.0075430492870509624, 0.06427215039730072, -0.07051241397857666, 0.012531881220638752, 0.03386063873767853, -0.036002255976200104, 0.012319066561758518, 0.00820718053728342, 0.028340529650449753, -0.0015053197275847197, 0.02749154344201088, -0.03785989060997963, 0.057764723896980286, 0.02076566405594349, -0.02499672956764698, -0.002172734122723341, 0.025687485933303833, -0.016583392396569252, 0.018083306029438972, 0.00453363498672843, -0.010329614393413067, 0.0020324531942605972, -0.020291736349463463, -0.04209776967763901, 0.008832831867039204, 0.011271648108959198, 0.0426071472465992, -0.009172739461064339, -0.08959463983774185, -0.014619322493672371, 0.07093730568885803, -0.010512626729905605, 0.03375938907265663, -0.05730542540550232, 0.07141018658876419, -0.006996911484748125, 0.04093301296234131, -0.021524887531995773, -0.04574614390730858, 0.001531599904410541, -0.0470016673207283, 0.013125496916472912, -0.022931154817342758, 0.02242196910083294, -0.019762765616178513, 0.025870902463793755, -0.03501033037900925, 0.04658985882997513, 0.0034561140928417444, 0.012405808083713055, -0.02678448148071766, 0.011683410964906216, -0.014520049095153809, 0.047461025416851044, -0.05054793879389763, 0.002589434152469039, 0.0332786999642849, 0.0058479830622673035, -0.058798979967832565, -0.018622910603880882, 0.014428624883294106, -0.028676319867372513, 0.03654726222157478, 0.030820384621620178, -0.035538624972105026, -0.01577199064195156, 0.019747447222471237, -0.015077515505254269, 0.029341911897063255, -0.011843272484838963, -0.03951321914792061, -0.057756826281547546, 0.04934156313538551, -0.005429549142718315, 0.03954554721713066, -0.004289010539650917, 0.002578848274424672, -0.03094160370528698, 0.010204825550317764, 0.0007166892755776644, -0.03575916215777397, -0.02219260111451149, -0.028208574280142784, -0.003792127361521125, 0.011661536060273647, -0.015143725089728832, 0.02831016480922699, -0.011030277237296104, 0.004450730048120022, -0.0416838601231575, -0.025134814903140068, -0.028554102405905724, 0.045978110283613205, 0.05518202856183052, 0.013058282434940338, 0.017980074509978294, 0.07178537547588348, -0.010526944883167744, -0.04400449991226196, -0.035423796623945236, 0.009735777974128723, -0.014554750174283981, -0.04749336466193199, -0.05334168300032616, 0.04599577188491821, -0.043771106749773026, -0.06976955384016037, 0.03877880051732063, -0.046185895800590515, -0.008196712471544743, -0.023187899962067604, 0.03690468519926071, -0.07930038124322891, -0.02214810624718666, -0.007371435407549143, 0.0877629965543747, 0.0007435053121298552, 0.06001698598265648, 0.036480508744716644, 0.06518443673849106, -0.017746230587363243, 0.010139663703739643, 0.015782754868268967, 0.033725205808877945, 0.0505995936691761, 0.031100723892450333, -0.0482465885579586, -0.007351138163357973, 0.026319563388824463, 0.02921474725008011, -0.052490878850221634, 0.009579956531524658, 0.05362865328788757, 0.005815797485411167, 0.054708197712898254, -0.036261070519685745, 0.00016884159413166344, -0.007889775559306145, 0.004925185814499855, -0.006290442775934935, -0.025587787851691246, 0.02568381279706955, 0.016079595312476158, -0.02590968646109104, -0.02291865088045597, -0.024875512346625328, 0.09098643809556961, -0.029726462438702583, 0.038980334997177124, 0.08169747143983841, 0.07031049579381943, 0.027408510446548462, -0.03377765789628029, 0.02794570103287697, 0.05545143783092499, -0.033675532788038254, 0.06585478782653809, 0.014905677177011967, -0.07277052104473114, 0.0008282773778773844, -0.0031619854271411896, -0.045960087329149246, -0.001583290402777493, 0.022773660719394684, -0.007364241871982813, 0.00375915109179914, -0.026123471558094025, 0.0448574461042881, 0.021820595487952232, -0.028615597635507584, 0.06428169459104538, -0.0011355254100635648, -0.010197781957685947, -0.01314739603549242, -0.07928165793418884, 0.02014186605811119, 0.0006706168642267585, -0.07697837054729462, -0.028069479390978813, 0.012255014851689339, 0.02800251729786396, -0.045863181352615356, -0.07783287763595581, 0.03810584172606468, -0.038895342499017715, -0.000036878955143038183, 0.03131258487701416, 0.04326244071125984, -0.015777520835399628, 0.009178413078188896, -0.06637027859687805, 0.0013766313204541802, -0.04721275717020035, -0.01852114498615265, -0.05577351152896881, 0.020443076267838478, 0.03534004092216492, -0.036014605313539505, -0.012312022037804127, -0.014986635185778141, 0.00019924508524127305, -0.0571073554456234, -0.011412901803851128, -0.001188934314996004, 0.018685150891542435, -0.011651945300400257, 0.029101358726620674, 0.004701394587755203, -0.053344108164310455, 0.02895837090909481, -0.005425402894616127, 0.04105706140398979, 0.04723949730396271, 0.018658999353647232, -0.018905723467469215, 0.01676659658551216, -0.0270969457924366, 0.020105360075831413, -0.056203436106443405, -0.05186174809932709, 0.01628190465271473, 0.010737260803580284, -0.019691089168190956, 0.03599274158477783, -0.01151143666356802, 0.0014288696693256497, 0.03260335326194763, -0.006031373981386423, -0.028996825218200684, 0.040863387286663055, 0.001080825924873352, 0.03098936192691326, 0.09618065506219864, 0.030406232923269272, 0.014126076363027096, -0.014762157574295998, -0.009064191952347755, 0.04572093486785889, 0.02340678870677948, -0.016256531700491905, -0.002533992752432823, -0.008813988417387009, 0.010697180405259132, -0.04108625650405884, -0.003711744211614132, -0.02338736318051815, 0.006053709425032139, 0.0001138956577051431, -0.03751425817608833, 0.0063203987665474415, -0.03835287690162659, -0.008334224112331867, -0.03017968311905861, 0.02037780173122883, 0.008485054597258568, 0.0038129102904349566, 0.0038161168340593576, 0.01932593062520027, 0.0005596296396106482, -0.011984926648437977, -0.00248446105979383, 0.039126720279455185, 0.0323626883327961, 0.04935585707426071, -0.020545735955238342, 0.022804511711001396, -0.01076470036059618, 0.02830933965742588, -0.027931034564971924, 0.01462200190871954, -0.03110695630311966, 0.024587983265519142, -0.05762116238474846, -0.06955771893262863, 0.04051373898983002, -0.0006412247894331813, 0.0044081686064600945, 0.03279272839426994, 0.06371235847473145, 0.01794550195336342, 0.012030520476400852, -0.04866922274231911, 0.01172074768692255, 0.01816858910024166, 0.0001692240039119497, -0.014269071631133556, 0.01834966242313385, 0.03666665032505989, 0.0796343982219696, 0.04185329005122185, 0.1076871007680893, 0.008657313883304596, -0.011290193535387516, -0.028518199920654297, -0.04945579543709755, -0.031865786761045456, -0.028761006891727448, 0.024226045235991478, -0.012088575400412083, 0.014557376503944397, -0.05282384157180786, 0.01780952326953411, -0.039107199758291245, 0.05100705847144127, -0.041910383850336075, -0.008410688489675522, -0.028904806822538376, -0.04275371879339218, -0.03308210149407387, -0.05084063485264778, -0.014802283607423306, -0.004704018589109182, -0.03233183175325394, 0.05723261460661888, -0.001491081202402711, -0.03816244751214981, 0.002504467498511076, -0.03238781541585922, 0.043286170810461044, 0.0461597703397274, 0.015720590949058533, -0.028900865465402603, -0.020496951416134834, -0.07137499004602432, 0.01316861156374216, 0.0017407536506652832, -0.018155353143811226, -0.03250208497047424, -0.07027330994606018, 0.03574325144290924, -0.029203323647379875, 0.017324481159448624, -0.014155879616737366, -0.025000574067234993, 0.07182228565216064, 0.01908561773598194, -0.03323497250676155, -0.022327154874801636, -0.02209407091140747, 0.026308884844183922, -0.022675922140479088, -0.004623337183147669, -0.02432207018136978, 0.06405153125524521, 0.0771750956773758, -0.05238088592886925, 0.0008697409648448229, -0.054505545645952225, 0.05838346481323242, -0.028189023956656456, 0.009026174433529377, 0.04154104366898537, -0.08662103861570358, 0.01847897842526436, 0.03222903609275818, 0.001501624472439289, 0.00872865878045559, 0.027578391134738922, -0.0686345249414444, 0.02689104713499546, 0.006738028489053249, -0.010964599438011646, 0.007402515504509211, 0.012257586233317852, 0.02822408825159073, 0.01934419944882393, -0.0021085150074213743, 0.045317642390728, 0.02113432250916958, -0.029148804023861885, -0.031547773629426956, 0.0023845150135457516, 0.06645222008228302, 0.01627291738986969, 0.013275211676955223, -0.054495275020599365, 0.022996971383690834, -0.06027998402714729, -0.023405659943819046, -0.012424967251718044, -0.02425726316869259, 0.09667269885540009, 0.04188104718923569, -0.012501834891736507, -0.027691319584846497, -0.02135958895087242, -0.003230415051802993, 0.0014051910256966949, 0.004552952013909817, 0.03217359632253647, -0.021931219846010208, -0.035239364951848984, -0.00021360264508984983, -0.013770275749266148, -0.03895305097103119, 0.03073521889746189, 0.04146542400121689, 0.029612915590405464, 0.05247486010193825, -0.05531202256679535, 0.054427728056907654, 0.015121345408260822, -0.016698455438017845, -0.052194155752658844, 0.01326977089047432, 0.01370785478502512, -0.033748216927051544, -0.009164849296212196, 0.049746766686439514, -0.06791748106479645, -0.054860785603523254, -0.009698192588984966, 0.06060362979769707, 0.007798504550009966, 0.010917393490672112, -0.03514707088470459, -0.00923629105091095, 0.04928237944841385, -0.024461103603243828, 0.04646556079387665, 0.06170126050710678, -0.019648946821689606, -0.013807794079184532, -0.03784414753317833, 0.030017800629138947, -0.05541641265153885, 0.008755920454859734, 0.08082308620214462, -0.006761382333934307, 0.0016291711945086718, 0.0015194895677268505, 0.03245525807142258, 0.023983901366591454, -0.025535685941576958, 0.0002170244843000546, 0.07567328959703445, 0.044617388397455215, 0.007978237234055996, 0.008811677806079388, 0.045868128538131714, -0.011535483412444592, 0.027553215622901917, 0.0065184361301362514, 0.0023290859535336494, -0.009756013751029968, 0.056672096252441406, -0.025232473388314247, -0.027381593361496925, 0.007974685169756413, 0.011463821865618229, -0.012288713827729225, -0.02715287357568741, -0.012313821353018284, -0.014949855394661427, -0.0419389083981514, -0.028221413493156433, -0.022742196917533875, -0.005933790467679501, -0.033882010728120804, -0.07706571370363235, 0.07193771749734879, -0.046181999146938324, -0.0653408095240593, -0.017341122031211853, 0.011037809774279594, 0.02180936560034752, 0.012629061937332153, -0.014746978878974915, 0.055935345590114594, -0.01908201351761818, 0.052042558789253235, -0.020549720153212547, 0.015985174104571342, -0.029644062742590904, 0.03182070329785347, 0.03473217412829399, 0.004180551506578922, 0.007854544557631016, 0.034680142998695374, -0.007031806278973818, -0.030794106423854828, 0.01641729101538658, -0.013650134205818176, 0.002876149956136942, 0.05261774733662605, 0.032447583973407745, 0.010071676224470139, 0.05105940252542496, -0.05087820440530777, 0.05074585974216461, 0.008660390973091125, -0.035097744315862656, 0.003365777200087905, 0.032232023775577545, -0.09054739028215408, 0.026286154985427856, -0.04604241997003555, -0.001860645366832614, -0.024358069524168968, 0.021953266113996506, -0.0191046055406332, 0.01978604681789875, -0.04579775407910347, 0.04680386930704117, -0.005550907459110022, -0.007363425567746162, 0.015989119186997414, 0.044184956699609756, 0.06451834738254547, -0.0048331464640796185, -0.026815734803676605, -0.038259293884038925, 0.05771319568157196, -0.06303734332323074, 0.04712226614356041, -0.03796425089240074, 0.05282888188958168, 0.046561140567064285, 0.026073722168803215, 0.027008624747395515, -0.0009400761337019503, -0.009889588691294193, 0.06378824263811111, -0.004641351755708456, -0.055367350578308105, 0.004460975993424654, 0.011599991470575333, -0.010379690676927567, -0.04111044481396675, -0.004621348809450865, -0.010166327469050884, 0.03465545177459717, 0.07126378268003464, 0.008865959011018276, -0.057014260441064835, -0.009803247638046741, -0.029885966330766678, -0.01719479449093342, 0.025761954486370087, 0.0032374896109104156, -0.01127513125538826, 0.027440233156085014, 0.049337998032569885, -0.05204609036445618, -0.0640518069267273, 0.005469179712235928, 0.022781826555728912, -0.010363093577325344, 0.029446767643094063, 0.04099685326218605, 0.0619625486433506, 0.04391881078481674, -0.0004218365647830069, -0.042604073882102966, 0.02193550579249859, 0.011824698187410831, 0.020084600895643234, 0.036950644105672836, 0.0051292418502271175, -0.0273286160081625, -0.02282569743692875, -0.03926271200180054, 0.06805244833230972, 0.046500109136104584, 0.032409798353910446, -0.0745733380317688, 0.05187024921178818, -0.05929892882704735, 0.07914916425943375, -0.01657792553305626, -0.030248643830418587, 0.03578442707657814, -0.08559483289718628, -0.014483734965324402, 0.01524672843515873, -0.03896976634860039, 0.001993130659684539, -0.02744961343705654, 0.04120992496609688, 0.05865801125764847, -0.030080730095505714, 0.07897064834833145, 0.0005331980064511299, 0.037541430443525314, -0.010561414062976837, 0.00947515107691288, 0.013278860598802567, 0.03580956161022186, 0.004042111337184906, -0.04635284096002579, -0.07693222910165787, -0.0021625554654747248, 0.02154618501663208, -0.06781606376171112, -0.028074048459529877, 0.06710974127054214, -0.03626755625009537, -0.026494668796658516, 0.028691178187727928, 0.0009195629390887916, -0.003229420864954591, -0.014134245924651623, -0.01946890540421009, 0.018831754103302956, -0.02043680101633072, -0.027557989582419395, 0.04164143651723862, -0.02740800753235817, 0.03015325777232647, -0.03159104660153389, 0.011688935570418835, -0.015943367034196854, 0.0008168215863406658, 0.06659340113401413, -0.00010070409189211205, -0.011113578453660011, 0.05957026407122612, -0.07862458378076553, 0.030372336506843567, 0.009712469764053822, -0.049115050584077835, 0.03019416518509388, 0.08022806793451309, -0.00880736205726862, -0.018046623095870018, 0.06338101625442505, -0.04674866050481796, 0.041526854038238525, 0.01214647851884365, -0.04748573899269104, -0.04323312267661095, 0.04242397099733353, 0.054267529398202896, 0.02895347960293293, -0.014468515291810036, 0.025111205875873566, 0.01719636656343937, 0.018287984654307365, -0.0719446986913681, 0.002965498948469758, 0.04763621836900711, -0.026374079287052155, -0.05410191789269447, -0.030783958733081818, -0.045905955135822296, -0.0327080562710762, -0.03378235548734665, -0.00805717334151268, -0.007134257350116968, -0.008686995133757591, -0.02563663385808468, 0.019557105377316475, 0.043387193232774734, -0.06585540622472763, 0.009982319548726082, -0.00552966957911849, 0.008036420680582523, 0.0537697896361351, 0.06597749888896942, -0.05603218823671341, 0.003612194210290909, 0.0041169836185872555, 0.026855191215872765, -0.045467935502529144, 0.01987178809940815, 0.008220250718295574, 0.009047134779393673, -0.038619812577962875, 0.023269642144441605, -0.014466856606304646, -0.07245903462171555, -0.04354551434516907, 0.02931319549679756, -0.04751754552125931, 0.017454057931900024, -0.0174772460013628, -0.011734583415091038, -0.013655724003911018, -0.028460441157221794, 0.02262171357870102, -0.08171327412128448, -0.039497919380664825, -0.03736428543925285, -0.016158072277903557, -0.007830245420336723, -0.06798986345529556, 0.008449338376522064, 0.031008291989564896, -0.07584080845117569, 0.022656990215182304, 0.027498552575707436, -0.04307723790407181, -0.023358270525932312, -0.027858378365635872, 0.02103157341480255, -0.0032487884163856506, 0.0034496281296014786, 0.006899917498230934, 0.035508301109075546, 0.022082341834902763, 0.01815730333328247, -0.02115931175649166, -0.06754199415445328, 0.04684531316161156, 0.012242859229445457, -0.04824058711528778, -0.007193577941507101, -0.03919249027967453, -0.011191222816705704, -0.0656011775135994, -0.01438562199473381, 0.008256264962255955, -0.012238405644893646, -0.006578992586582899, 0.03714597225189209, -0.007935582660138607, -0.003843196202069521, -0.05763277783989906, -0.02947555109858513, 0.04297152906656265, -0.05610170215368271, 0.009007571265101433, -0.005748686380684376, -0.01106248889118433, -0.020735321566462517, -0.04298335686326027, 0.041712719947099686, -0.027537237852811813, -0.06616166979074478, 0.012281714007258415, 0.08229529857635498, 0.0006309957825578749, -0.02444937825202942, 0.012971192598342896, -0.025269152596592903, -0.013708272017538548, 0.02690897136926651, 0.04322868585586548, -0.030289707705378532, -0.005650361999869347, 0.01907293125987053, 0.04364023357629776, 0.01564493589103222, 0.03767061233520508, 0.041975703090429306, -0.03768530115485191, -0.030993597581982613, -0.013655690476298332, -0.051067959517240524, -0.021769553422927856, -0.03622176870703697, 0.05006067827343941, -0.004727565683424473, -0.0325479619204998, 0.024766605347394943, 0.047073788940906525, 0.010907845571637154, -0.05708001181483269, -0.01817302033305168, 0.032344359904527664, 0.024285605177283287, -0.03466929495334625 ]
<p><strong>Note:</strong> This question may be difficult or impossible to answer within the rules of these forums due to its philosophical nature. I will delete the question if I am violating the rules.</p> <p>Onto the question! Recently I have been curious whether classical electromagnetism is fully solved (up to the divergences). Specifically, can we completely mathematically describe and then interpret the classical world of charges and currents and them the associated fields. Let us assume that our world is classical and that electromagnetism is a complete theory even though there are certain inconsistencies (self-interactions, infinite energy of point charges, etc). A common description of $\textbf{E}(\textbf{r}, t)$ and $\textbf{B}(\textbf{r}, t)$ among physics textbooks is that changing electric fields induce magnetic fields and vice-versa. This is assuming that there are no external fields or sources of field present. In symbols,</p> <p>$$ \partial_t\textbf{E} \neq \textbf{0} \implies \exists \textbf{B} \quad (1) $$</p> <p>$$ \partial_t\textbf{B} \neq \textbf{0} \implies \exists \textbf{E} \quad (2) $$</p> <p>Many physicists come to this conclusion from <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell&#39;s_equations" rel="nofollow">Maxwell's equations</a>. Specifically, they argue that Faraday's law,</p> <p>$$ \nabla \times \textbf{E}(\textbf{r}, t) = -\partial_t\textbf{B}(\textbf{r},t), $$</p> <p>implies (1), and that Ampere's law (with Maxwell's correction term and no currents),</p> <p>$$ \nabla \times \textbf{B}(\textbf{r}, t) = \partial_t \textbf{E}(\textbf{r},t), $$</p> <p>implies (2). Note that we are using natural units with $c = 1$. However, these equations do not have any obvious causal connection. While we may like to pretend that <em>right</em> implies <em>left</em>, this is purely notational convention. Who is to say from these equations alone that one field having a nonzero curl doesn't produce a changing dual field? One attempt at reconciling this problem seems to be in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jefimenko&#39;s_equations" rel="nofollow">Jefimenko's equations</a>. I will state the equations without derivation, but the fields can be solved for completely in terms of the source charges and currents (I'm lazy and the following equations are in mks units from Wikipedia):</p> <p>$$ \textbf{E}(\textbf{r}, t) = \frac{1}{4 \pi \epsilon_0}\int [\frac{\rho(\textbf{r}', t_r)}{|\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}'|^3} + \frac{1}{c}\frac{\partial_t \rho(\textbf{r}', t_r)}{|\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}'|^2}] (\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}') - \frac{1}{c^2}\frac{\partial_t \textbf{J}(\textbf{r}', t_r)}{|\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}'|^2} d^3\textbf{r}', $$</p> <p>$$ \textbf{B}(\textbf{r}, t) = \frac{\mu_0}{4 \pi}\int [\frac{\textbf{J}(\textbf{r}', t_r)}{|\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}'|^3} + \frac{1}{c}\frac{\partial_t \textbf{J}(\textbf{r}', t_r)}{|\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}'|^2}] \times (\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}' )d^3\textbf{r}' , $$</p> <p>where $t_r = t - |\textbf{r} - \textbf{r}'|/c$ is the retarded time. These equations seem to imply that neither of the fields "causes" the other. Instead, Jefimenko's equations imply that only the source charges and currents generate the fields (without the presence of external charges, currents, or fields). My question is related to this approach. Is it valid? What are the arguments for and against? Is the matter settled in the classical context of electromagnetism, or are there certain subtleties I've skipped over?</p> <p>As an extra question, is it instead better to consider $F_{\mu \nu}$, and treat it as one object arising solely from $J^\mu = (\rho, \textbf{J})$, instead of looking at the individual fields?</p> <p>Thanks in advance for any and all answers!</p>
g7488
[ 0.0676332488656044, -0.03205373138189316, -0.011036978103220463, -0.02314496785402298, 0.06736930459737778, 0.00792701169848442, 0.07977326214313507, 0.02332647144794464, -0.00972369872033596, 0.006186065264046192, -0.06415574252605438, 0.007922271266579628, -0.024296222254633904, -0.0031850391533225775, -0.04664551839232445, -0.006948654539883137, 0.03790790215134621, -0.02938513085246086, 0.03858928382396698, 0.01674513705074787, -0.04267715662717819, 0.03669365495443344, 0.035979799926280975, -0.015040900558233261, -0.07044272124767303, -0.012730088084936142, 0.007890112698078156, 0.014618982560932636, -0.03757886961102486, -0.06046168506145477, -0.026830583810806274, 0.04907648637890816, 0.04050637409090996, -0.024286409839987755, 0.002414416754618287, -0.02980888821184635, 0.04047270864248276, 0.003639566246420145, -0.010940303094685078, 0.025285515934228897, 0.03108946606516838, 0.014851701445877552, 0.028456421568989754, -0.009921121411025524, 0.023161383345723152, -0.03280424326658249, -0.016930557787418365, -0.0059037161991000175, -0.020940789952874184, -0.008520307019352913, -0.046327654272317886, 0.029599560424685478, 0.0590173713862896, -0.002817768370732665, 0.016481447964906693, 0.04161541908979416, 0.05225447937846184, 0.01169742550700903, 0.03308992460370064, 0.0031975700985640287, 0.008943459950387478, -0.007445877883583307, -0.025753146037459373, 0.0013427437515929341, -0.02185242436826229, 0.010285749100148678, -0.055015575140714645, -0.012397742830216885, -0.0007850208203308284, 0.012049820274114609, -0.03518480807542801, -0.07522957026958466, -0.055650223046541214, -0.0012737388024106622, 0.02431812696158886, 0.02669091336429119, 0.06288715451955795, -0.016981180757284164, 0.014885256998240948, -0.03801991790533066, -0.014485274441540241, -0.04412446171045303, -0.04676569998264313, 0.059674814343452454, 0.048086006194353104, -0.028237445279955864, 0.007829511538147926, 0.04149783402681351, 0.026943661272525787, -0.0006729071028530598, -0.038300663232803345, 0.008455577306449413, 0.05006098002195358, -0.05366983264684677, 0.005073892883956432, -0.02793307416141033, 0.03540615737438202, 0.044703204184770584, -0.0066599356941878796, -0.017025727778673172, -0.027989095076918602, 0.014172961935400963, 0.01695290580391884, 0.05590713769197464, -0.03731593117117882, 0.020170891657471657, 0.06758664548397064, 0.028589608147740364, -0.022594939917325974, -0.007386849727481604, -0.04913383349776268, -0.03680445998907089, -0.019605280831456184, 0.016505859792232513, -0.04848172515630722, -0.028951559215784073, -0.051740240305662155, -0.011361926794052124, -0.049564462155103683, 0.11348557472229004, -0.022256609052419662, -0.023454109206795692, 0.03223919868469238, 0.07953338325023651, -0.0020747343078255653, 0.013273397460579872, -0.01737412065267563, 0.045054201036691666, 0.07420390844345093, -0.012019370682537556, -0.010376625694334507, -0.0019445494981482625, 0.009494451805949211, 0.0051769595593214035, 0.009908351115882397, 0.05204450339078903, -0.013926384039223194, 0.007381968200206757, 0.040993496775627136, 0.0010062132496386766, -0.011637073010206223, -0.02826640009880066, 0.009464223869144917, -0.01900865137577057, -0.017432058230042458, 0.027836410328745842, -0.0005319227348081768, -0.07768753170967102, 0.019441725686192513, 0.05993925407528877, -0.0014618095010519028, 0.10158263891935349, -0.01595734991133213, 0.018421033397316933, -0.03877032920718193, 0.05949915200471878, 0.001576217240653932, -0.019292833283543587, 0.005514630116522312, -0.03461010009050369, 0.0690789669752121, -0.03221489489078522, 0.02240569144487381, 0.019061202183365822, 0.0010563149116933346, 0.0014125615125522017, -0.009407689794898033, -0.06438197940587997, -0.00904338899999857, -0.0032565188594162464, -0.09702515602111816, 0.02331608161330223, 0.010794472880661488, 0.03968276455998421, 0.009208320640027523, 0.04285464808344841, -0.008504449389874935, 0.0024191047996282578, -0.012333187274634838, 0.01561645045876503, -0.10847799479961395, 0.004224366508424282, 0.022704463452100754, 0.002654114505276084, -0.02979237027466297, 0.038956526666879654, -0.09226834774017334, 0.07902300357818604, -0.034000784158706665, -0.041430309414863586, -0.06741520017385483, -0.020796682685613632, -0.031431663781404495, 0.06906867027282715, -0.025518039241433144, 0.007991575635969639, -0.05224466323852539, -0.0025457791052758694, -0.015874361619353294, -0.025234084576368332, 0.04055424779653549, 0.035404860973358154, 0.054046861827373505, 0.047714218497276306, -0.002431730506941676, 0.015681099146604538, 0.015435840934515, -0.057520460337400436, 0.051222193986177444, -0.041570089757442474, 0.049480415880680084, -0.036895088851451874, -0.039953526109457016, -0.004870919045060873, -0.04396655037999153, -0.11755896359682083, -0.03286276012659073, -0.008192473091185093, -0.0835936889052391, -0.006848823744803667, -0.05091436207294464, -0.002687467262148857, 0.03566807880997658, -0.007630450651049614, -0.05464252829551697, 0.01881353184580803, 0.00802365131676197, -0.017173031345009804, -0.038138825446367264, -0.015267767012119293, -0.055603425949811935, -0.0010965133551508188, 0.03680611774325371, -0.02884889766573906, 0.0632479339838028, 0.026653390377759933, -0.024475714191794395, -0.037999022752046585, 0.048928152769804, -0.03582419455051422, 0.03195617347955704, -0.052537087351083755, -0.01267288252711296, 0.03421706333756447, 0.003296795068308711, -0.022550243884325027, 0.12183952331542969, 0.013592340983450413, -0.005529924761503935, -0.005226158536970615, -0.0026021741796284914, -0.03691522404551506, -0.02399471215903759, 0.05751703679561615, -0.036443132907152176, -0.013668444938957691, 0.038894351571798325, 0.08551614731550217, -0.03208503872156143, -0.022441299632191658, -0.03256440907716751, 0.03194151818752289, -0.0033283925149589777, 0.07688523828983307, -0.05898817628622055, -0.045313019305467606, -0.02452864684164524, -0.017758512869477272, -0.040542859584093094, -0.009351409040391445, -0.03493785858154297, 0.04362689331173897, 0.006371405906975269, 0.015713442116975784, 0.014403793029487133, -0.012786001898348331, -0.024491041898727417, 0.0013718866975978017, 0.00653309840708971, -0.005711756646633148, 0.03381882980465889, 0.016606710851192474, 0.02255556732416153, -0.02275862544775009, 0.011101474985480309, -0.016338028013706207, -0.019804975017905235, -0.009705222211778164, -0.010673155076801777, 0.03201868012547493, -0.02645704708993435, 0.044145382940769196, 0.08204521238803864, -0.05432054400444031, -0.035335637629032135, 0.009995531290769577, -0.017167557030916214, -0.09968077391386032, -0.04203575849533081, 0.009113996289670467, 0.031450361013412476, -0.008108885958790779, -0.03082813322544098, 0.039464082568883896, 0.03030168078839779, 0.018352938815951347, -0.07565827667713165, -0.061293479055166245, 0.05461015924811363, -0.009123461320996284, 0.004758409224450588, 0.05609339103102684, 0.011223121546208858, 0.0010914173908531666, 0.012056057341396809, 0.0023858400527387857, -0.020362025126814842, 0.0038502730894833803, 0.03925027698278427, -0.03786185756325722, -0.04422711953520775, -0.07381895929574966, -0.01001790538430214, 0.020025737583637238, 0.02826232649385929, -0.0009402871946804225, -0.027700424194335938, 0.017449576407670975, -0.030230067670345306, 0.04081711545586586, -0.04417429491877556, -0.002193416003137827, 0.030692443251609802, -0.0315534844994545, -0.05424291267991066, -0.02470398135483265, 0.006930722389370203, 0.040449775755405426, 0.04055196791887283, 0.022130083292722702, -0.023212147876620293, -0.02585655264556408, -0.057320453226566315, -0.03714631870388985, -0.01334961038082838, 0.02319061942398548, 0.0011899915989488363, -0.007547168992459774, -0.005338893737643957, 0.011189899407327175, 0.022884173318743706, -0.011790517717599869, 0.026842741295695305, 0.05280701816082001, -0.02965092658996582, 0.016583815217018127, 0.03344808518886566, 0.08317861706018448, 0.008623925037682056, -0.009920875541865826, 0.01848400942981243, -0.033838361501693726, 0.008177236653864384, 0.019298702478408813, 0.031445443630218506, 0.031634848564863205, 0.011999723501503468, -0.0015163267962634563, -0.019328078255057335, -0.06797099858522415, 0.08935288339853287, 0.010010557249188423, -0.03792616352438927, 0.010466023348271847, 0.004521726630628109, -0.015033754520118237, 0.014714165590703487, 0.05269633233547211, -0.05329461768269539, 0.04824312403798103, 0.029501689597964287, 0.03884823992848396, 0.028677385300397873, 0.028372347354888916, 0.016762113198637962, 0.03500739112496376, -0.016301125288009644, -0.01942298375070095, -0.050447262823581696, 0.034920983016490936, 0.0009593767463229597, 0.05349251627922058, 0.025312626734375954, 0.03923032432794571, -0.0185807254165411, 0.006221542600542307, -0.004427480045706034, -0.029486367478966713, 0.035397518426179886, -0.011869361624121666, 0.03533240780234337, 0.010560664348304272, 0.017589731141924858, -0.009176199324429035, -0.028438713401556015, -0.016432221978902817, 0.0021852494683116674, -0.038254398852586746, 0.05206340551376343, -0.06669028103351593, -0.026994729414582253, 0.00850998517125845, -0.03554709628224373, -0.026599762961268425, 0.013202858157455921, -0.0164027102291584, -0.003480678889900446, -0.02135094441473484, 0.09447304159402847, -0.0131858354434371, 0.055114831775426865, 0.011307825334370136, -0.036709174513816833, -0.02352778986096382, 0.005677804350852966, 0.05759509652853012, 0.055555444210767746, -0.004054292105138302, -0.027641339227557182, -0.005763217806816101, -0.06270848959684372, 0.07161131501197815, -0.03952893614768982, 0.005137962754815817, -0.039713773876428604, -0.006820432376116514, -0.07094229012727737, 0.08476534485816956, 0.00904991663992405, -0.00020311237312853336, 0.08751390874385834, -0.01306341215968132, 0.0625835731625557, -0.034205108880996704, -0.0435066781938076, 0.03404500335454941, -0.03086792305111885, -0.0091544259339571, 0.0527268685400486, -0.03813942149281502, -0.04143738001585007, 0.09315408021211624, 0.041958507150411606, 0.020364301279187202, -0.03742431476712227, 0.009450231678783894, 0.03592488542199135, -0.009037620387971401, -0.015131130814552307, -0.029320666566491127, -0.00988242868334055, 0.003880691947415471, -0.006619071122258902, 0.021551650017499924, 0.05716409906744957, -0.03784602880477905, -0.031927868723869324, -0.011295399628579617, -0.059079140424728394, -0.030546968802809715, 0.008766873739659786, 0.029523160308599472, -0.015562659129500389, -0.05420056730508804, 0.02585276961326599, -0.0077451011165976524, -0.0044094170443713665, -0.0337713286280632, -0.10988374799489975, -0.013943440280854702, -0.010149288922548294, -0.04651083052158356, -0.013005668297410011, 0.04855727031826973, 0.006619687657803297, 0.06600576639175415, -0.015676245093345642, 0.02291076071560383, -0.03206333890557289, -0.06083180010318756, 0.009342002682387829, 0.04862743616104126, 0.0421467088162899, -0.023167725652456284, -0.056245747953653336, 0.04720351845026016, -0.011731816455721855, 0.004473395645618439, -0.0406813882291317, 0.022947100922465324, -0.05355771258473396, -0.001477084937505424, -0.035816363990306854, 0.025403164327144623, 0.004987645894289017, 0.05092981830239296, 0.0280953086912632, 0.032348185777664185, 0.021327964961528778, 0.0588851235806942, -0.0005694566061720252, 0.011825586669147015, -0.0007550643058493733, 0.02974759228527546, 0.027589915320277214, 0.03320679813623428, -0.08125463128089905, -0.029947439208626747, 0.014174919575452805, -0.08112526684999466, -0.01081095077097416, -0.032344453036785126, 0.017552684992551804, -0.049641020596027374, 0.009782768785953522, 0.06643611192703247, -0.049108538776636124, -0.07564651966094971, 0.04046043008565903, 0.02766178920865059, 0.00148999213706702, 0.0571499764919281, 0.010501883924007416, 0.02095520682632923, -0.0006914415280334651, -0.02353283204138279, 0.04203859716653824, -0.03165808692574501, -0.03135621175169945, 0.05492417886853218, 0.0012559674214571714, 0.017581757158041, 0.05475359037518501, 0.02227635681629181, -0.06524263322353363, -0.022072870284318924, 0.021082846447825432, -0.01576141268014908, 0.041515808552503586, -0.021260233595967293, -0.04053618013858795, 0.013604786247015, 0.0022295918315649033, 0.029433337971568108, 0.027860064059495926, 0.0486319474875927, 0.012600922957062721, 0.013726252131164074, -0.06450541317462921, -0.05628754943609238, 0.0051817214116454124, -0.00499030901119113, -0.011737762950360775, 0.04523207247257233, 0.026188047602772713, -0.028988201171159744, 0.0399501696228981, 0.008618575520813465, 0.04558519646525383, -0.010285573080182076, 0.0355205237865448, 0.005129650235176086, -0.04487898573279381, -0.02988431416451931, 0.011820083484053612, 0.03249268978834152, -0.013534977100789547, -0.03728218004107475, 0.012334559112787247, 0.0025423900224268436, 0.03747523948550224, -0.0005149850621819496, 0.011849824339151382, -0.009675855748355389, -0.01064225472509861, 0.018756628036499023, -0.07361914962530136, -0.0007859815377742052, 0.011655288748443127, 0.032439589500427246, 0.0005617904826067388, 0.008832956664264202, 0.014587908051908016, -0.01079957652837038, 0.007260046899318695, -0.003519888734444976, 0.01188619714230299, 0.0339399054646492, 0.00903369951993227, -0.0020728311501443386, -0.013732893392443657, 0.022129645571112633, 0.018737150356173515, 0.0055566648952662945, 0.06336837261915207, -0.0077898381277918816, -0.046640317887067795, 0.0016205828869715333, -0.006918612867593765, 0.005194812081754208, 0.03519265726208687, -0.05854785814881325, -0.06448036432266235, -0.05424875766038895, -0.0035089277662336826, -0.019916214048862457, -0.06250413507223129, 0.05030769482254982, -0.03749896213412285, 0.009168987162411213, 0.004563326481729746, -0.04056111350655556, 0.04986092820763588, -0.002317160600796342, -0.003820555517449975, 0.061790917068719864, 0.011098603717982769, 0.03355293720960617, 0.047471318393945694, 0.011438829824328423, 0.036037493497133255, 0.016020702198147774, -0.04861068353056908, 0.036459822207689285, 0.01798621192574501, 0.025872696191072464, 0.03611239418387413, 0.00020304700592532754, -0.007671068422496319, 0.010954570956528187, 0.005970661528408527, -0.004457004833966494, 0.0453677698969841, -0.015290020033717155, -0.04970888793468475, -0.07918613404035568, 0.012125929817557335, 0.011609046719968319, -0.07804577052593231, 0.03172324597835541, 0.018651042133569717, -0.009963816031813622, -0.013803165405988693, -0.0029991071205586195, 0.0068207476288080215, -0.030611524358391762, 0.01638266071677208, 0.012413541786372662, -0.03803089261054993, -0.03981338441371918, -0.006121616344898939, -0.0015927482163533568, -0.04831993579864502, -0.01554184127599001, 0.01716689206659794, -0.011378871276974678, -0.011759328655898571, -0.03984306752681732, 0.001705471659079194, 0.0004807465593330562, 0.01679300330579281, -0.0484565868973732, 0.040937598794698715, 0.0003214862081222236, -0.046634603291749954, -0.009782860055565834, -0.0012039385037496686, 0.055958207696676254, 0.03650049492716789, -0.016736887395381927, 0.02066025510430336, 0.00229007750749588, -0.026480086147785187, 0.026837743818759918, -0.038776692003011703, 0.018633047118782997, -0.03933827206492424, -0.0008068250608630478, -0.03376847878098488, 0.030098292976617813, 0.012846949510276318, -0.004190544132143259, -0.0005506150773726404, 0.037153586745262146, 0.0032476529013365507, 0.02107013389468193, 0.03041447512805462, 0.057058729231357574, 0.05662832409143448, -0.03108227252960205, 0.052016481757164, -0.0010645687580108643, -0.03648259863257408, -0.031033139675855637, -0.004900126252323389, 0.03522009775042534, -0.034823231399059296, -0.01820795051753521, -0.033404313027858734, 0.015786509960889816, -0.046474967151880264, 0.03426940739154816, 0.030805375427007675, 0.010552036575973034, 0.04250870272517204, 0.029083430767059326, -0.024411801248788834, 0.01343409065157175, 0.029997074976563454, 0.028037874028086662, -0.052469540387392044, -0.020963385701179504, -0.10409397631883621, -0.011854019947350025, -0.050777334719896317, 0.03589626029133797, 0.00045204535126686096, -0.04021602123975754, -0.008262873627245426, 0.03203504532575607, 0.004437334835529327, -0.07293534278869629, -0.01672518067061901, 0.01307629607617855, -0.03835740685462952, -0.021868491545319557, -0.0019601567182689905, -0.011868808418512344, 0.026080768555402756, -0.061056386679410934, -0.012397082522511482, -0.03732463717460632, -0.02911372482776642, -0.028463592752814293, -0.040400851517915726, 0.00047564806300215423, 0.009931863285601139, 0.06515401601791382, 0.0313105508685112, 0.017752116546034813, -0.029501214623451233, 0.004078424535691738, -0.026996130123734474, 0.027504215016961098, 0.03142281621694565, -0.0011293785646557808, 0.004584191367030144, 0.04499093070626259, 0.02073388732969761, 0.06621647626161575, -0.02334231324493885, -0.0626608207821846, 0.01972467638552189, 0.008311999030411243, 0.031288377940654755, 0.009649994783103466, -0.020340820774435997, 0.01638961397111416 ]
<p>What are the differences between comet versus asteroid versus meteoroid versus meteor versus meteorite in practical terms?</p>
g7489
[ 0.00827821996062994, 0.0019082260550931096, -0.007111299317330122, -0.04537007585167885, -0.008204436860978603, -0.012858647853136063, -0.040672577917575836, -0.09549086540937424, 0.015448925085365772, -0.024225326254963875, 0.006495238747447729, -0.010354219004511833, 0.056153155863285065, -0.064878910779953, -0.012323686853051186, -0.05885721743106842, 0.04179061949253082, -0.04088721051812172, -0.026809411123394966, 0.08795011788606644, -0.002140800002962351, 0.021321073174476624, -0.044239334762096405, -0.0035399775952100754, -0.08372440934181213, -0.002348045352846384, -0.031261831521987915, 0.012761704623699188, -0.000802069203928113, -0.011934814974665642, 0.033339615911245346, -0.023212740197777748, 0.032927192747592926, -0.021995987743139267, -0.05502768233418465, -0.00946106854826212, -0.006366943009197712, 0.010577834211289883, 0.03442642092704773, -0.00028715102234855294, -0.006841620430350304, 0.008336303755640984, 0.003964450675994158, 0.06040012091398239, -0.04538491740822792, -0.007282285951077938, 0.020550299435853958, -0.024215755984187126, 0.06356251239776611, -0.05592971667647362, 0.03241885080933571, 0.02893962897360325, 0.061294812709093094, -0.023818768560886383, -0.011765781790018082, 0.0017899497179314494, 0.04449243098497391, 0.0038808858953416348, 0.053140874952077866, -0.029699109494686127, 0.0076858303509652615, 0.007259479723870754, -0.04893168434500694, -0.026727579534053802, 0.03029477782547474, -0.02769886516034603, 0.010123520158231258, 0.07577119767665863, 0.029499627649784088, -0.040219321846961975, 0.03234366327524185, -0.014221148565411568, -0.00692714611068368, -0.012125371024012566, -0.05647533759474754, 0.002032764023169875, -0.026710396632552147, -0.03005339205265045, 0.02429920621216297, 0.01680207997560501, 0.056553956121206284, 0.022306738421320915, 0.012563422322273254, 0.024632206186652184, 0.07750138640403748, 0.034288033843040466, -0.025036312639713287, -0.026123633608222008, 0.0003154846781399101, -0.04268605262041092, -0.007968507707118988, -0.029935933649539948, -0.0660695880651474, 0.026666544377803802, -0.040367789566516876, 0.056946560740470886, -0.025866681709885597, -0.020681116729974747, 0.034189529716968536, 0.0319504551589489, 0.004182486794888973, -0.06312590092420578, 0.0385490283370018, 0.024328196421265602, -0.003402123926207423, -0.04601020738482475, 0.019443783909082413, -0.02539462223649025, 0.016011616215109825, -0.023343250155448914, -0.007357557769864798, -0.0164308100938797, 0.030657855793833733, -0.01141900010406971, -0.009934407658874989, 0.02877284400165081, 0.01094944216310978, 0.027655567973852158, -0.02842801995575428, 0.032765839248895645, 0.008549628779292107, 0.06277979165315628, 0.04479139298200607, 0.013419890776276588, -0.03698071092367172, -0.01754767820239067, 0.06798968464136124, -0.02169090136885643, 0.001696040970273316, -0.05849442258477211, -0.008568398654460907, -0.015793517231941223, -0.028107209131121635, -0.006734855938702822, -0.03665114939212799, 0.03732839971780777, -0.009081895463168621, -0.015277640894055367, 0.0034099328331649303, -0.006717841140925884, 0.07736712694168091, -0.04918340966105461, -0.018308939412236214, -0.014830619096755981, -0.06820891052484512, 0.0320652537047863, -0.0367986299097538, 0.019623128697276115, 0.0010523153468966484, 0.021895986050367355, 0.04692128300666809, 0.01667903922498226, -0.011728211306035519, -0.012820154428482056, 0.0024691997095942497, -0.013614936731755733, 0.016187354922294617, 0.026804085820913315, -0.03530048578977585, 0.0103364959359169, -0.049033273011446, 0.013503898866474628, -0.0033629508689045906, 0.03262564167380333, -0.018914183601737022, 0.007596381939947605, 0.01562453992664814, 0.0034555629827082157, 0.009716120548546314, 0.02748859114944935, 0.008518563583493233, -0.08491013199090958, 0.0205719955265522, 0.008168084546923637, -0.013074265792965889, -0.021773716434836388, 0.053259190171957016, -0.034650158137083054, -0.0070027573965489864, 0.020477943122386932, 0.02183729037642479, 0.000844212481752038, -0.07080059498548508, 0.037643663585186005, -0.02036447636783123, -0.013766078278422356, -0.015432281419634819, -0.017153142020106316, 0.00013599339581560344, 0.033648062497377396, -0.004404603503644466, -0.08525971323251724, -0.017215946689248085, 0.01982409693300724, -0.0038194400258362293, -0.07215772569179535, -0.047463156282901764, 0.06101265922188759, -0.08702756464481354, -0.006601335015147924, 0.040189679712057114, 0.03911865875124931, -0.022984780371189117, 0.030317995697259903, 0.02892247773706913, 0.027108455076813698, 0.0026943732518702745, 0.002952567534521222, 0.006556666921824217, -0.019911665469408035, -0.008075008168816566, -0.0023600899148732424, 0.012226063758134842, 0.0013674169313162565, -0.043775685131549835, 0.01090010441839695, -0.040375109761953354, 0.041549764573574066, 0.011162007227540016, -0.03329019993543625, -0.07320613414049149, -0.03797449544072151, 0.005728269927203655, -0.0732208639383316, -0.025478078052401543, 0.030627546831965446, 0.021446315571665764, 0.00675471406430006, 0.09766309708356857, 0.022077763453125954, 0.005100537091493607, -0.03236169368028641, -0.01799733005464077, 0.007987724617123604, -0.0023818924091756344, 0.018645957112312317, 0.03080497495830059, -0.08192314952611923, 0.028612565249204636, 0.04737767577171326, -0.03481949865818024, -0.03988071158528328, 0.012370414100587368, -0.030694633722305298, 0.07066971808671951, -0.07000397890806198, 0.01849951222538948, -0.007086500991135836, -0.024230659008026123, -0.004359441809356213, -0.06989892572164536, 0.04980020225048065, -0.09510651975870132, 0.017930665984749794, -0.016765207052230835, -0.032048195600509644, -0.01982409879565239, -0.01673312857747078, -0.042092982679605484, 0.09063703566789627, 0.017529858276247978, -0.04937750846147537, 0.004621385131031275, 0.041328079998493195, 0.030589379370212555, 0.013573803938925266, -0.049576058983802795, 0.03451354429125786, 0.04328033700585365, -0.042168956249952316, 0.060882098972797394, 0.02841326780617237, -0.014643281698226929, -0.0275433249771595, -0.03702578693628311, 0.017131155356764793, -0.022972239181399345, 0.022033460438251495, -0.0516187958419323, -0.028076259419322014, 0.08812915533781052, -0.01284864917397499, -0.031136760488152504, 0.024380240589380264, 0.04277021437883377, 0.028027357533574104, -0.0008695245487615466, 0.043161023408174515, -0.06085113808512688, -0.029913321137428284, -0.04461078718304634, 0.017029155045747757, 0.030246030539274216, 0.004795888438820839, -0.05510038882493973, 0.01120922714471817, 0.013186621479690075, 0.05830063670873642, 0.03845485299825668, -0.06504669040441513, 0.05294504016637802, 0.025543782860040665, 0.014047842472791672, 0.05561324954032898, 0.03067457303404808, 0.05870911106467247, -0.003252332331612706, -0.023276325315237045, 0.003918736707419157, -0.03220750018954277, 0.020410360768437386, 0.03851456940174103, -0.030854353681206703, 0.050908833742141724, -0.0004419558681547642, 0.025576021522283554, -0.03611776605248451, 0.04707722365856171, 0.03778831288218498, 0.04871585965156555, 0.005368340760469437, -0.04334970563650131, 0.05996991693973541, -0.004931899718940258, -0.07379700243473053, 0.082278311252594, -0.010796582326292992, -0.006819461472332478, -0.016887735575437546, -0.020592160522937775, -0.055911727249622345, 0.022441236302256584, -0.01738166995346546, -0.03538376837968826, -0.024830536916851997, -0.0065611498430371284, 0.03633289784193039, -0.05373474210500717, 0.041944075375795364, -0.018766408786177635, 0.07368568331003189, 0.06143863871693611, -0.0058120861649513245, -0.024429595097899437, 0.0046286615543067455, 0.0039574517868459225, 0.008581726811826229, -0.004464276134967804, 0.006173090077936649, -0.06317619979381561, 0.044395361095666885, -0.0034366589970886707, 0.05014932528138161, -0.04468628391623497, 0.0014213785761967301, -0.01708945818245411, -0.024659138172864914, 0.0253909882158041, 0.036786846816539764, 0.03009110502898693, 0.05533755570650101, 0.050529249012470245, -0.024470876902341843, 0.005036077927798033, -0.00004248207187629305, 0.044167689979076385, -0.0043924725614488125, 0.004264828749001026, -0.03842403367161751, -0.006121270824223757, 0.035000454634428024, 0.01215685997158289, 0.03181101754307747, -0.009907803498208523, 0.1057196706533432, -0.018984215334057808, -0.011237031780183315, 0.0028613077010959387, -0.038758307695388794, -0.05419817566871643, 0.0131023358553648, -0.023384936153888702, 0.008606990799307823, 0.01562899351119995, 0.0482570081949234, 0.018824277445673943, -0.00705733522772789, 0.04207150265574455, -0.03418416529893875, -0.04562484472990036, -0.003984080161899328, -0.046705033630132675, -0.02623874507844448, -0.05774741247296333, 0.00337534979917109, -0.0317097008228302, 0.008235658518970013, 0.006915028672665358, 0.05949923023581505, 0.06679936498403549, -0.02358907461166382, 0.021583233028650284, 0.016409307718276978, -0.0023059712257236242, 0.02427626959979534, -0.011310060508549213, -0.020534098148345947, -0.03243149071931839, -0.07622861862182617, -0.055021531879901886, 0.0492788590490818, 0.0014553533401340246, 0.0044767484068870544, 0.05118953064084053, -0.009613617323338985, -0.049979183822870255, -0.019012870267033577, -0.004486912861466408, 0.034053459763526917, 0.020467573776841164, -0.02113797329366207, 0.026067186146974564, -0.03137652203440666, -0.03192802146077156, 0.0414031483232975, 0.06881673634052277, -0.009725376032292843, 0.03425855189561844, -0.005717146676033735, 0.0513819195330143, 0.08601225912570953, 0.031830426305532455, 0.02485090121626854, 0.011405089870095253, -0.005675844848155975, 0.05196016654372215, -0.0003613322915043682, 0.046226952224969864, 0.010782323777675629, -0.024553343653678894, 0.03336576744914055, 0.0799945667386055, -0.007987416349351406, 0.043771665543317795, 0.01659243367612362, 0.013040917925536633, 0.042037975043058395, -0.012756014242768288, -0.0564415380358696, 0.009277869015932083, -0.013880965299904346, 0.011121902614831924, -0.04635050892829895, -0.021526964381337166, -0.042252544313669205, 0.009927078150212765, 0.008128354325890541, -0.0034253415651619434, 0.025982070714235306, 0.031018735840916634, -0.05094994604587555, 0.01779152825474739, 0.04832688719034195, 0.011119428090751171, 0.06874336302280426, 0.005536420736461878, -0.08830273896455765, -0.0065557584166526794, -0.03641292452812195, -0.053143203258514404, -0.00996672548353672, -0.01837819069623947, 0.022244492545723915, 0.023374583572149277, -0.013117708265781403, -0.06816527247428894, 0.018648728728294373, -0.04878338798880577, 0.06563675403594971, 0.0027723798993974924, 0.007456690538674593, -0.020804395899176598, -0.03940592333674431, 0.07180189341306686, -0.02113223262131214, 0.00796751119196415, -0.01914335787296295, -0.0612991526722908, 0.04546776041388512, 0.0426468588411808, 0.03369961306452751, 0.014623506926000118, -0.02184932306408882, -0.029910435900092125, -0.0039976355619728565, -0.06068192049860954, -0.033094827085733414, -0.04212754964828491, -0.004013721365481615, 0.01315741054713726, -0.050858717411756516, 0.009005621075630188, 0.0032605205196887255, -0.013342325575649738, 0.0210125632584095, 0.03443111851811409, 0.09094679355621338, -0.030367430299520493, 0.0579976812005043, 0.021675776690244675, 0.029538342729210854, -0.03419201076030731, -0.045660316944122314, 0.03690794110298157, -0.04178595915436745, 0.01894296519458294, 0.0446510948240757, 0.02863745205104351, 0.023677198216319084, -0.03950360789895058, -0.029761862009763718, 0.016036001965403557, 0.03373689204454422, 0.05333762615919113, 0.014917539432644844, -0.02659623883664608, -0.01576356217265129, -0.046588532626628876, 0.023605281487107277, 0.01610412448644638, 0.004436337389051914, 0.018880479037761688, -0.021788282319903374, 0.012295923195779324, -0.037575613707304, -0.01298853661864996, -0.07253468036651611, 0.055551402270793915, 0.06034458801150322, -0.04942178726196289, -0.05015600845217705, -0.007215292192995548, 0.026043450459837914, 0.04371181130409241, -0.00918975006788969, -0.018401140347123146, 0.009577928110957146, 0.025822818279266357, 0.02447640709578991, 0.01529445219784975, 0.007835421711206436, 0.012128276750445366, -0.04636315628886223, -0.030239950865507126, 0.020814450457692146, 0.01498795859515667, -0.024694733321666718, 0.003637350630015135, -0.07606407254934311, -0.04577065259218216, -0.056734248995780945, 0.007331163622438908, -0.03153282403945923, 0.002759045222774148, 0.023256391286849976, -0.04327743500471115, -0.020389290526509285, -0.022329207509756088, 0.00568448007106781, -0.0032729313243180513, 0.0028122065123170614, 0.014346176758408546, -0.02694174461066723, 0.02618875354528427, 0.04721485823392868, 0.006972535979002714, -0.04709932953119278, 0.015478188171982765, -0.026260798797011375, 0.024850474670529366, 0.024405932053923607, -0.011745424009859562, 0.00013109076826367527, 0.01971714198589325, -0.014209164306521416, 0.09253998845815659, -0.04264996573328972, -0.005647829733788967, -0.039884693920612335, -0.017600292339920998, 0.03348920866847038, -0.005354513414204121, 0.017362236976623535, -0.047211334109306335, -0.04784666746854782, 0.02786066383123398, -0.045938845723867416, -0.04497508332133293, 0.013651709072291851, -0.006019639316946268, 0.0032279426231980324, -0.005848381202667952, 0.0507812574505806, 0.08947862684726715, 0.03896468132734299, 0.016693104058504105, -0.002961890771985054, 0.02797575667500496, 0.017085028812289238, -0.01762351766228676, -0.006639297120273113, 0.06132514029741287, 0.06558908522129059, 0.0452193021774292, -0.05926434323191643, 0.014247311279177666, -0.04798103868961334, -0.008053355850279331, 0.033810943365097046, -0.016930678859353065, -0.03726949170231819, 0.004309569485485554, -0.013113335706293583, -0.021650323644280434, 0.007714252453297377, -0.007907013408839703, -0.008841377682983875, 0.0511527918279171, 0.02125256322324276, -0.0011038095690310001, -0.025213850662112236, -0.0038279155269265175, 0.03257336467504501, 0.058247048407793045, -0.034100599586963654, -0.02534383162856102, -0.04636034369468689, -0.0006656557670794427, -0.0021353240590542555, -0.007195562589913607, 0.03894311934709549, 0.004017107654362917, -0.0031170216389000416, 0.020903686061501503, 0.02069546841084957, 0.03746567666530609, 0.018818223848938942, -0.024161724373698235, 0.01444912701845169, -0.07145851105451584, -0.008422771468758583, -0.013539627194404602, 0.026115044951438904, -0.029386375099420547, -0.01386935729533434, 0.0861278548836708, 0.05071857571601868, 0.04001397266983986, 0.08373749256134033, -0.024941597133874893, 0.0401805154979229, 0.032227519899606705, 0.024369018152356148, -0.012376590631902218, 0.019800271838903427, -0.00394252547994256, 0.025073377415537834, -0.0422116257250309, -0.04150835797190666, 0.0076386709697544575, 0.04421216994524002, 0.011196945793926716, -0.037679195404052734, -0.025757785886526108, 0.008252395316958427, 0.008066718466579914, 0.0053267087787389755, -0.06240013986825943, -0.031044170260429382, 0.03390001878142357, 0.014568678103387356, 0.023100368678569794, 0.029712514951825142, -0.022554943338036537, 0.019044630229473114, 0.0567019097507, -0.08429449051618576, -0.015370692126452923, 0.07836239784955978, -0.07123945653438568, -0.011196264997124672, 0.051931895315647125, 0.004131419584155083, -0.053521834313869476, -0.03200622648000717, -0.026055626571178436, -0.033175028860569, 0.0464070662856102, 0.043907880783081055, -0.01832321472465992, -0.009317039512097836, 0.051822204142808914, 0.05360770225524902, -0.029663890600204468, 0.06156153231859207, -0.01602848805487156, -0.024447625502943993, 0.05665230751037598, -0.06097051501274109, -0.02592032216489315, -0.02018742822110653, 0.02179076336324215, 0.029825251549482346, -0.008673883974552155, -0.033268366008996964, -0.03643416240811348, 0.02022268995642662, -0.02773657999932766, -0.03853670507669449, 0.0519249401986599, 0.02772916853427887, -0.03706218674778938, 0.009685165248811245, -0.061909019947052, -0.0007963984389789402, 0.01488171610981226, -0.019792402163147926, -0.039203107357025146, 0.05343152955174446, -0.059667494148015976, -0.04116755723953247, 0.05340031161904335, -0.011592435650527477, 0.021825822070240974, -0.052235353738069534, 0.04604436829686165, -0.021826282143592834, -0.04733938351273537, -0.06491793692111969, 0.0200456902384758, 0.014372942969202995, 0.0456920862197876, -0.031743504106998444, 0.0232843030244112, -0.07514380663633347, -0.017196020111441612, -0.03381282463669777, -0.020010827109217644, -0.014074437320232391, -0.026455480605363846, 0.04244030639529228, -0.027024075388908386, -0.026980523020029068, -0.007184837944805622, -0.052014272660017014, 0.019889576360583305, -0.04516799375414848, 0.01081059593707323, 0.036738477647304535, -0.008696366101503372, 0.012650539167225361, 0.04785127937793732, 0.0076982672326266766, -0.008487810380756855, -0.040921974927186966, -0.009253110736608505, -0.0447886660695076, -0.024708924815058708 ]
<p>As far as I know, particles vibrate with a frequency and wavelength determined by their energy level.</p> <p>Is this vibration in 3D space?</p>
g7490
[ 0.06284802407026291, 0.009513904340565205, 0.0013667810708284378, 0.020250316709280014, 0.015661772340536118, 0.04389305040240288, -0.0416119247674942, -0.013958231545984745, -0.012036739848554134, -0.0023917441722005606, -0.0034558544866740704, -0.014739087782800198, -0.009288647212088108, -0.038858357816934586, -0.05691050365567207, -0.025961806997656822, -0.016980677843093872, 0.0009966453071683645, 0.012075159698724747, 0.03741726279258728, -0.009731830097734928, -0.025089209899306297, -0.044383492320775986, -0.06553930044174194, 0.03139696642756462, 0.03547151759266853, -0.003382922848686576, -0.0654333233833313, 0.013445836491882801, -0.02679629437625408, 0.08213149011135101, 0.00569189852103591, 0.04798350855708122, 0.0013504112139344215, 0.02835509553551674, -0.03100552223622799, 0.003116695210337639, 0.005744584836065769, -0.02530387043952942, -0.00431075319647789, -0.039563294500112534, -0.03466078266501427, 0.011914709582924843, -0.010551848448812962, 0.043907057493925095, 0.03789827972650528, 0.009993156418204308, 0.013985146768391132, -0.034311648458242416, -0.005560900550335646, -0.03000050038099289, 0.03432584926486015, -0.02552846260368824, 0.052864331752061844, 0.010243669152259827, 0.002680424600839615, 0.008812855929136276, -0.0014446359127759933, 0.058747343719005585, 0.044902946799993515, -0.04448191449046135, 0.0358152762055397, -0.0049401381984353065, 0.03007594123482704, 0.02556740492582321, -0.02573012188076973, -0.05760113522410393, -0.029287807643413544, 0.009861059486865997, -0.04541892558336258, 0.06295302510261536, -0.023571470752358437, -0.017957305535674095, -0.0362992100417614, -0.05364387482404709, -0.032805442810058594, 0.022353120148181915, 0.024693146347999573, -0.03158066049218178, 0.016505178064107895, -0.07539457827806473, 0.020757729187607765, -0.046580277383327484, -0.059872012585401535, 0.08380218595266342, -0.018843604251742363, -0.03220432624220848, -0.03581380099058151, 0.023140432313084602, 0.02789890766143799, -0.010567396879196167, 0.026802580803632736, 0.08554818481206894, 0.017799200490117073, 0.01517338678240776, -0.04515257105231285, -0.029945986345410347, 0.12959955632686615, 0.000005980009518680163, -0.028413884341716766, -0.01740320771932602, 0.0002591904194559902, 0.04122842103242874, -0.021902767941355705, -0.0010354231344535947, -0.018201759085059166, 0.012124309316277504, -0.059159960597753525, 0.03900708630681038, -0.03534576669335365, -0.02322022244334221, -0.006450180895626545, 0.03173326700925827, 0.0176667682826519, -0.038213592022657394, -0.005224996246397495, 0.08188970386981964, 0.01540987566113472, 0.07478700578212738, 0.07437454164028168, 0.056138135492801666, 0.01543860137462616, -0.013453047722578049, 0.027931712567806244, -0.04250097647309303, 0.020325569435954094, 0.022391771897673607, 0.01120004616677761, -0.03826083242893219, 0.02886318974196911, 0.026296745985746384, 0.023011982440948486, -0.02520112320780754, -0.03554074838757515, -0.004412696231156588, 0.0409659780561924, -0.0028804223984479904, -0.008441738784313202, -0.04616693779826164, 0.04911139979958534, 0.009314209222793579, -0.038282688707113266, 0.04146316647529602, -0.004721394274383783, -0.04463578760623932, 0.02410782314836979, -0.003862272948026657, -0.0207779873162508, 0.031033091247081757, 0.04849878326058388, 0.0021545900963246822, 0.09516294300556183, 0.05717313662171364, -0.07446620613336563, 0.031594447791576385, -0.029698960483074188, -0.01601014845073223, 0.03778329864144325, 0.00301172723993659, -0.01751636527478695, 0.012941385619342327, -0.0511188879609108, 0.007595197297632694, -0.011155408807098866, 0.03903871774673462, -0.02091694250702858, -0.007482933346182108, -0.06716950237751007, 0.0018364742863923311, 0.007407430559396744, -0.04112454503774643, -0.010035118088126183, -0.0076386104337871075, 0.004363301210105419, -0.04125243425369263, 0.01068353932350874, -0.03863184154033661, -0.03393496945500374, 0.014996575191617012, -0.01546845119446516, 0.013476836495101452, -0.0075974236242473125, -0.021063588559627533, -0.0574989877641201, 0.023478122428059578, 0.021161502227187157, -0.021185116842389107, -0.03747427463531494, -0.005867845378816128, 0.031229887157678604, -0.04786831885576248, 0.010008440352976322, 0.04486166313290596, -0.01667402870953083, -0.01808178424835205, -0.03972075879573822, 0.022654615342617035, 0.029805636033415794, 0.014608027413487434, 0.04781152680516243, 0.0305881779640913, 0.007794491946697235, 0.046521078795194626, -0.0022965394891798496, 0.10446861386299133, 0.005522591061890125, -0.010878675617277622, -0.02055475302040577, -0.06182479485869408, 0.03299402818083763, 0.03700632601976395, 0.037870846688747406, 0.01099440734833479, 0.005475722718983889, 0.008402271196246147, 0.012301208451390266, -0.020661961287260056, 0.0485420748591423, 0.04197264835238457, -0.011765695177018642, -0.04840661585330963, -0.06058935448527336, 0.037066467106342316, -0.009154622443020344, 0.011941601522266865, -0.04153876379132271, -0.08517888188362122, 0.018345149233937263, 0.047447897493839264, 0.05129893869161606, -0.07752993702888489, -0.026156360283493996, -0.023738544434309006, -0.0035330248065292835, 0.08378759026527405, 0.07396639883518219, -0.061500970274209976, -0.022034719586372375, 0.01880265586078167, 0.00734612625092268, 0.0457783006131649, -0.006823365576565266, 0.0065953959710896015, -0.027680594474077225, 0.028802601620554924, -0.02928183227777481, -0.01051376573741436, -0.0126026701182127, 0.0012144803768023849, -0.03383700177073479, 0.03425631299614906, 0.007096234243363142, -0.02177778258919716, 0.029244543984532356, -0.01198360975831747, 0.020188022404909134, -0.058156173676252365, 0.016155118122696877, -0.08405087143182755, -0.050488099455833435, 0.0317554846405983, -0.04437767714262009, 0.009264498949050903, -0.0024409890174865723, 0.05598874017596245, -0.044454436749219894, 0.07722794264554977, 0.03751930966973305, -0.042593203485012054, 0.007657897192984819, 0.02767742983996868, 0.04116470366716385, -0.010752924717962742, -0.011582916602492332, -0.028151197358965874, 0.011501617729663849, 0.028902515769004822, -0.0586148239672184, 0.02859116718173027, -0.03083508461713791, -0.016461605206131935, 0.04505879804491997, -0.06975746899843216, -0.028716210275888443, -0.0014956335071474314, 0.0007251541828736663, -0.015073325484991074, -0.0008006456191651523, 0.0038274312391877174, -0.04480711743235588, 0.029540402814745903, -0.039273981004953384, -0.031245926395058632, -0.00828844215720892, -0.055000267922878265, 0.006389542482793331, 0.04434293508529663, -0.005779898259788752, 0.014038708992302418, 0.07525710761547089, 0.016762228682637215, -0.04550223797559738, 0.04446091130375862, -0.018293317407369614, -0.024646254256367683, 0.0017794985324144363, 0.002552290912717581, 0.01273692399263382, -0.004844547715038061, -0.002858893945813179, -0.03896903246641159, 0.06227187439799309, 0.021785883232951164, 0.03999398648738861, -0.043239813297986984, 0.004927386064082384, -0.037222135812044144, -0.027286475524306297, -0.024974949657917023, -0.04488707706332207, -0.0507638044655323, -0.02455788478255272, 0.02119063027203083, -0.032045166939496994, 0.003805481130257249, 0.017733857035636902, 0.022494876757264137, -0.0440666601061821, -0.010172681882977486, -0.020194273442029953, -0.018381942063570023, -0.023659342899918556, -0.04383489862084389, -0.012505115009844303, -0.009062941186130047, -0.06208570674061775, -0.07765904068946838, -0.006531106308102608, 0.077629953622818, 0.007255019154399633, -0.022240690886974335, -0.008113080635666847, 0.011152301914989948, -0.03206542506814003, -0.013049138709902763, 0.049262769520282745, -0.03951048105955124, -0.0199637021869421, -0.008027126081287861, -0.055286865681409836, 0.04331258684396744, 0.008557594381272793, 0.031140251085162163, -0.02452823519706726, 0.011344070546329021, 0.019078312441706657, 0.014055573381483555, 0.008673910982906818, -0.04618264362215996, -0.03699220344424248, -0.01705765724182129, -0.046587347984313965, 0.04648992419242859, -0.04528489336371422, -0.012030529789626598, -0.04955282434821129, 0.008200203068554401, 0.004143964033573866, 0.04982835054397583, 0.019028175622224808, -0.019919052720069885, -0.03820769861340523, -0.041888244450092316, 0.043403320014476776, 0.02076832205057144, -0.007792367599904537, -0.00503987492993474, -0.07432045787572861, -0.05155840143561363, -0.030506500974297523, -0.02703253924846649, 0.003701353445649147, 0.05350857973098755, -0.030047712847590446, 0.025525379925966263, 0.05339720472693443, -0.04193902760744095, 0.004656529054045677, -0.01369461789727211, -0.0052369264885783195, -0.0018357393564656377, -0.06116404011845589, -0.0054381294175982475, 0.001074679777957499, 0.02046382986009121, -0.05892340838909149, 0.049941372126340866, 0.0025835561100393534, 0.012432033196091652, 0.0726589784026146, 0.015303445979952812, 0.04003266990184784, -0.03368522971868515, -0.014474933966994286, 0.025258159264922142, 0.035677265375852585, 0.00624674279242754, -0.05693830922245979, -0.04235405847430229, -0.004500385373830795, -0.013811038807034492, -0.013558002188801765, 0.04848286136984825, -0.07478710263967514, -0.00960636232048273, 0.01615387573838234, -0.025431102141737938, -0.02262880653142929, 0.023559831082820892, 0.04700158163905144, 0.0195416621863842, 0.07635534554719925, 0.026056550443172455, 0.031688589602708817, 0.05347498133778572, 0.05872739478945732, 0.06501541286706924, 0.022414622828364372, -0.08822457492351532, -0.00355568528175354, 0.040456049144268036, -0.03772461414337158, 0.019606105983257294, 0.006824673153460026, -0.03456498682498932, 0.014136013574898243, -0.017506996169686317, -0.019697556272149086, 0.025568345561623573, 0.01655985787510872, 0.016188086941838264, 0.023217475041747093, 0.018738841637969017, -0.015369897708296776, 0.006110284477472305, 0.05530094355344772, -0.03758290037512779, 0.00321508152410388, 0.0052459402941167355, 0.023452337831258774, 0.010181068442761898, 0.03400491923093796, -0.09716813266277313, 0.002996754366904497, -0.0008856261265464127, 0.021883413195610046, -0.0027237574104219675, -0.021091820672154427, -0.004682768136262894, -0.01870015636086464, -0.03938905522227287, -0.026696687564253807, 0.004029945936053991, 0.02378983609378338, 0.00548211857676506, 0.0025738209951668978, -0.04677420109510422, 0.007735094521194696, -0.04177908971905708, 0.015496657229959965, 0.022040989249944687, -0.05679500848054886, 0.0039548189379274845, -0.002981291152536869, 0.03398879989981651, -0.008478113450109959, 0.0050318269059062, -0.02796459011733532, -0.0015403433935716748, -0.06145571544766426, 0.011468727141618729, -0.0058015394024550915, 0.055875133723020554, -0.005145583767443895, -0.017732396721839905, -0.00683936383575201, -0.04567181318998337, 0.053616929799318314, -0.009568353183567524, -0.005802895408123732, -0.032115597277879715, -0.036436889320611954, -0.04625526815652847, -0.004128145985305309, -0.05470164120197296, -0.0017492842162027955, -0.041113413870334625, -0.08433739840984344, 0.01252399105578661, 0.036775149405002594, 0.010513911023736, -0.05814528465270996, 0.04934116452932358, -0.024060651659965515, -0.05138451233506203, 0.050992172211408615, 0.021610423922538757, -0.034165650606155396, -0.03388034552335739, 0.001371254213154316, -0.021947314962744713, -0.006120589096099138, -0.029955197125673294, 0.07237664610147476, 0.016851410269737244, -0.03738674521446228, 0.04990974813699722, 0.11543350666761398, 0.0002122362784575671, 0.04002441465854645, -0.03660382330417633, 0.01696818880736828, 0.06027108430862427, -0.06522911787033081, 0.014668046496808529, 0.021174266934394836, -0.0064817192032933235, 0.050119902938604355, 0.042560476809740067, 0.085296131670475, -0.02190253883600235, 0.017220180481672287, 0.007034111302345991, 0.0008522906573489308, -0.012206790037453175, -0.011509097181260586, 0.030032696202397346, 0.04674364626407623, 0.013496258296072483, 0.0431874617934227, -0.03590870276093483, -0.08816266804933548, 0.0006814230582676828, 0.041914697736501694, -0.00792502798140049, 0.036847010254859924, -0.014997747726738453, 0.036877188831567764, 0.058828987181186676, 0.010880258865654469, -0.03882643207907677, 0.007897987961769104, -0.034824188798666, 0.0027914997190237045, -0.04392537102103233, 0.024844558909535408, -0.014344274997711182, -0.01502949371933937, 0.014004548080265522, -0.02778197079896927, 0.035623595118522644, 0.007447783835232258, 0.0320000946521759, -0.06405369192361832, 0.010398945771157742, -0.0018755171913653612, -0.013904212974011898, -0.003487824695184827, 0.0446784645318985, 0.02498445101082325, -0.0791231095790863, 0.0794338807463646, 0.026878347620368004, 0.0012005881872028112, 0.05549773946404457, -0.012396455742418766, 0.004094843287020922, -0.03457442671060562, -0.1064944863319397, 0.00893049780279398, 0.04721317067742348, 0.035253673791885376, 0.00493499543517828, 0.019436411559581757, 0.0038480586372315884, 0.006312388461083174, 0.05087433010339737, -0.017315810546278954, 0.0025778920389711857, -0.059773437678813934, -0.03502025082707405, -0.05028194561600685, -0.04694094508886337, 0.046109799295663834, -0.0032608690671622753, -0.04292519390583038, 0.005965676624327898, 0.01925019733607769, 0.003404528135433793, 0.036691706627607346, 0.03606052324175835, 0.008696656674146652, -0.05331619828939438, -0.018603447824716568, 0.004237112123519182, -0.009421461261808872, -0.03151768818497658, 0.012865236960351467, -0.008546147495508194, 0.05460383743047714, -0.03424671292304993, 0.003434319281950593, 0.013137798756361008, 0.03145419806241989, 0.018634647130966187, -0.05980212986469269, 0.037608399987220764, 0.004482838325202465, 0.061853595077991486, -0.0027252663858234882, 0.006140426266938448, -0.025851216167211533, 0.009694905020296574, -0.025109516456723213, 0.05970219150185585, 0.021857211366295815, -0.05201449617743492, 0.03314980864524841, 0.05865905061364174, 0.0238488856703043, -0.03629564866423607, 0.008529020473361015, 0.06405407935380936, 0.07043449580669403, 0.009803716093301773, -0.01704442873597145, -0.04550282284617424, -0.014982353895902634, 0.020368531346321106, 0.03550971671938896, 0.0007540105725638568, -0.006465781945735216, 0.047103192657232285, -0.006516784429550171, -0.08856579661369324, -0.006504438817501068, 0.06959933787584305, -0.025815395638346672, 0.012507821433246136, -0.005076113622635603, -0.013269555754959583, -0.03710486367344856, -0.009751022793352604, 0.017132945358753204, 0.0019572782330214977, 0.024531373754143715, -0.025553930550813675, 0.015270453877747059, -0.015498352237045765, -0.050347700715065, -0.044332947582006454, -0.04265637323260307, -0.023971883580088615, 0.024888839572668076, -0.030802404507994652, 0.07467295229434967, 0.00846047792583704, -0.022422993555665016, -0.005877883173525333, -0.023562686517834663, -0.019220825284719467, -0.01349152997136116, -0.009531044401228428, 0.007613872177898884, -0.04494190216064453, 0.017991701140999794, -0.07625753432512283, 0.055309899151325226, 0.057279013097286224, -0.002327459864318371, 0.08075958490371704, 0.043371886014938354, 0.031154247000813484, 0.021654756739735603, 0.009337984025478363, 0.021001974120736122, -0.001392278471030295, -0.016839638352394104, -0.013981591910123825, -0.005909677594900131, -0.002555633895099163, 0.01973130740225315, 0.01281827874481678, -0.07434619963169098, -0.032682012766599655, -0.05365671217441559, 0.07502985745668411, 0.024577006697654724, 0.011600750498473644, 0.014761567115783691, -0.024632969871163368, -0.005781679414212704, 0.013970399275422096, 0.017531616613268852, -0.027008451521396637, -0.03120873123407364, 0.028205838054418564, -0.03255968168377876, -0.0030418350361287594, -0.018129844218492508, 0.0015108268707990646, 0.04256328195333481, -0.02739527076482773, 0.05231984704732895, 0.041405513882637024, 0.028025584295392036, 0.0012279233196750283, 0.045130059123039246, -0.012834400869905949, -0.05262022837996483, -0.02907439135015011, 0.042816340923309326, 0.02052166312932968, -0.04957178235054016, 0.01629113405942917, -0.016671685501933098, 0.0298254806548357, -0.002209892962127924, 0.060891471803188324, 0.016243156045675278, -0.017064379528164864, 0.07579050213098526, 0.00037952163256704807, 0.031085925176739693, -0.046584393829107285, 0.03965414687991142, 0.007288715336471796, 0.02538742497563362, -0.02917870320379734, 0.014020181261003017, 0.037741176784038544, 0.05153856426477432, 0.006483947392553091, -0.010119364596903324, -0.006720921490341425, -0.03233359754085541, -0.02337053418159485, 0.0073901996947824955, 0.0614326186478138, -0.05783405527472496, -0.018423324450850487, 0.0035142088308930397, -0.018095623701810837, 0.040245525538921356, 0.05138509348034859, -0.058795440942049026, 0.020705262199044228, 0.007697568740695715, -0.037744488567113876, -0.06536409258842468, 0.013346628285944462, 0.021240489557385445, 0.04919186234474182, -0.025693539530038834, -0.012140616774559021, -0.09149598330259323, 0.006591335870325565, 0.06275069713592529 ]
<p>Right now, our resolution + light gathering power are still far too low to take direct images of exoplanets, so we're limited to subtracting the planet spectra from the parent star spectra when the planet undergoes a transit (and this isn't going to be possible for decades, according to Jim Kasting's latest book). So in this case, it seems that light gathering power is more important.</p> <p>So, Is angular resolution more important when we want to measure the spectra of an Earth-like Exo?</p>
g7491
[ 0.008915320038795471, 0.08049885928630829, 0.015897519886493683, -0.02527162805199623, 0.026886843144893646, -0.013913613744080067, -0.043947625905275345, -0.007812988013029099, 0.0022506066597998142, -0.04750674590468407, 0.029727047309279442, 0.032774168998003006, 0.08598227798938751, -0.02954043447971344, 0.01127210259437561, -0.037719957530498505, 0.01807515136897564, -0.054795075207948685, 0.02891288883984089, 0.01547973696142435, 0.01192532293498516, -0.008313422091305256, 0.0064373561181128025, 0.01097775436937809, -0.030891932547092438, 0.029530566185712814, -0.03263323754072189, -0.04937547817826271, -0.006628827657550573, -0.0008274541469290853, 0.04880776256322861, 0.017417563125491142, 0.00339211686514318, -0.048230480402708054, -0.02980629727244377, -0.013853137381374836, 0.019396645948290825, 0.03878137096762657, 0.04695499688386917, -0.037206146866083145, -0.009031050838530064, -0.016345037147402763, -0.011666709557175636, 0.031934820115566254, 0.016315381973981857, -0.07676452398300171, 0.017836788669228554, 0.015659520402550697, 0.02119905687868595, -0.0182492658495903, -0.016732702031731606, 0.01749427802860737, -0.003088831203058362, 0.0007326271734200418, 0.049222301691770554, 0.01480643730610609, -0.052932318300008774, -0.02374330908060074, 0.023870345205068588, -0.037704434245824814, 0.027267172932624817, -0.008474490605294704, 0.012655162252485752, 0.00684730289503932, -0.022306503728032112, -0.037957943975925446, -0.04484500735998154, -0.003504830878227949, 0.03756539523601532, -0.01026241760700941, 0.03790908306837082, 0.01775255799293518, -0.016200440004467964, -0.014097286388278008, -0.022872319445014, -0.009905350394546986, 0.019950438290834427, -0.04702708497643471, -0.014354203827679157, 0.0815381333231926, 0.009763061068952084, -0.05439246818423271, -0.03481263667345047, 0.015185697935521603, 0.05714826285839081, 0.01364305429160595, -0.036392562091350555, -0.010604255832731724, 0.03924986720085144, 0.087883859872818, 0.10085278004407883, -0.0020269877277314663, 0.02594451606273651, -0.01917078346014023, -0.035831719636917114, 0.03589559718966484, 0.024695008993148804, -0.006433022674173117, -0.035903505980968475, 0.034255463629961014, -0.005290762986987829, 0.00927767064422369, 0.014849678613245487, 0.0447363518178463, 0.04129357635974884, -0.011824091896414757, 0.03469201549887657, -0.05816832557320595, -0.0148731404915452, -0.0005648939986713231, -0.021000899374485016, -0.009704167023301125, 0.0695362538099289, -0.029635630548000336, -0.05971454456448555, 0.00919975433498621, 0.08065459132194519, -0.04780005291104317, 0.0336342453956604, 0.08219372481107712, 0.06173808500170708, 0.00006036284685251303, 0.060353606939315796, 0.06605653464794159, -0.02104903757572174, -0.02377239055931568, 0.07524686306715012, -0.002439375501126051, 0.014915645122528076, -0.011582588776946068, -0.06560581177473068, -0.0396893247961998, -0.03522844985127449, 0.032915111631155014, 0.07091057300567627, 0.005319151561707258, -0.0726972371339798, -0.01907452754676342, -0.04189249500632286, 0.01427940558642149, 0.03336707502603531, 0.030271688476204872, 0.048360634595155716, 0.04343459755182266, -0.04230160638689995, 0.017028411850333214, -0.04352845624089241, -0.0020089366007596254, 0.036085907369852066, 0.005123272072523832, -0.06367194652557373, -0.01982797682285309, 0.05886545777320862, 0.0036746596451848745, 0.06585228443145752, 0.010714281350374222, 0.031317196786403656, -0.048396509140729904, -0.004295527935028076, 0.01647224836051464, 0.06776746362447739, 0.00470988592132926, -0.0367572158575058, 0.03489261493086815, 0.009776059538125992, -0.03975727781653404, -0.007544069550931454, -0.039812829345464706, -0.008198545314371586, -0.04135526716709137, -0.0085118617862463, 0.011405818164348602, 0.09423938393592834, -0.017117314040660858, -0.019656090065836906, -0.00645151874050498, 0.05699517950415611, -0.02788732573390007, 0.0038612487260252237, 0.008428513072431087, -0.00816464051604271, -0.030712785199284554, -0.03760393708944321, -0.01922542043030262, 0.026698218658566475, -0.06327132135629654, 0.0029080009553581476, -0.02661118283867836, 0.021335339173674583, 0.011290009133517742, 0.05683493986725807, -0.0006967465742491186, 0.0023925350978970528, 0.03052792139351368, 0.00943437498062849, -0.024744512513279915, -0.020698176696896553, 0.0066071623004972935, -0.08496954292058945, 0.0018216632306575775, -0.020181257277727127, 0.006228190381079912, 0.01759309507906437, 0.04268096759915352, -0.011370672844350338, -0.029107853770256042, -0.03300779312849045, -0.025997092947363853, 0.04577866569161415, -0.0676681399345398, 0.023539526388049126, -0.005119000561535358, -0.06244108825922012, -0.015660777688026428, -0.06486991792917252, -0.024185018613934517, -0.024963848292827606, -0.008379978127777576, -0.000802856229711324, 0.01859208382666111, -0.07747545838356018, 0.000778338813688606, 0.030910683795809746, 0.01979939080774784, -0.02980726584792137, -0.012028900906443596, -0.04828429967164993, 0.011058218777179718, 0.04792274534702301, 0.011923999525606632, -0.018934475257992744, -0.007169430609792471, 0.04192062467336655, 0.043752796947956085, -0.010664353147149086, -0.023789018392562866, 0.01313060987740755, -0.02108841761946678, 0.019185161218047142, 0.057305362075567245, 0.013374068774282932, -0.010215844959020615, 0.005796908866614103, -0.0003430944634601474, 0.06097608804702759, 0.043961867690086365, 0.0029631578363478184, 0.009060997515916824, -0.07316403836011887, -0.00627802824601531, -0.039882831275463104, 0.03576085343956947, -0.007741269655525684, 0.01876709796488285, -0.03472459316253662, 0.012433496303856373, 0.02223063074052334, 0.049819767475128174, -0.08420447260141373, 0.02065316028892994, -0.01994418166577816, -0.04190966486930847, 0.008677751757204533, -0.026106959208846092, 0.049597516655921936, -0.011398730799555779, 0.007338311523199081, 0.00439816527068615, 0.006527419202029705, -0.0528646856546402, -0.043731991201639175, 0.024022512137889862, -0.03548477217555046, -0.02008996345102787, -0.0070066023617982864, 0.017739959061145782, 0.009678004309535027, -0.034642692655324936, 0.0024758786894381046, -0.017379838973283768, -0.008456653915345669, 0.0013833856210112572, 0.007977557368576527, 0.044043492525815964, 0.012897204607725143, -0.0035830193664878607, 0.0029250485822558403, 0.04356782138347626, 0.01953730173408985, -0.009118761867284775, 0.006960137281566858, -0.015281378291547298, 0.0010654282523319125, -0.041952937841415405, 0.013018373399972916, -0.0158822201192379, 0.05263864994049072, 0.017796095460653305, 0.016282301396131516, 0.000005604172656603623, 0.007562787272036076, -0.029488788917660713, 0.006687904708087444, 0.03753187134861946, 0.022669263184070587, -0.04586618021130562, 0.002344014123082161, -0.04662632197141647, -0.028221791610121727, 0.02970290370285511, -0.007879146374762058, -0.0177701935172081, -0.0430576428771019, 0.0858973041176796, 0.006572782061994076, -0.012028704397380352, -0.04367551580071449, 0.0278297308832407, 0.0010725304018706083, 0.007923319935798645, -0.017684299498796463, 0.0019052923889830709, 0.008694738149642944, -0.06925145536661148, -0.017510445788502693, 0.01577548310160637, -0.028321390971541405, -0.0744028091430664, -0.03156242147088051, 0.008105865679681301, -0.01874980516731739, 0.02875942550599575, -0.010971851646900177, 0.06108502298593521, -0.07998624444007874, 0.04779614508152008, -0.02712603658437729, 0.02524096518754959, 0.01273727510124445, 0.07421979308128357, -0.04938246309757233, -0.0161807369440794, -0.09370942413806915, -0.02609235979616642, 0.0001295526890316978, -0.002387427259236574, -0.022189892828464508, -0.02745521254837513, -0.058056920766830444, -0.04712776839733124, -0.02748906798660755, 0.00461942283436656, 0.000503772811498493, 0.0021518876310437918, 0.053282469511032104, 0.029655519872903824, 0.06272042542695999, 0.00040004891343414783, -0.027144214138388634, -0.005388970021158457, -0.00891044456511736, 0.021929392591118813, 0.01972007192671299, -0.021261803805828094, 0.0567966103553772, -0.0240929052233696, -0.06940199434757233, 0.03543170168995857, -0.028294451534748077, 0.029705429449677467, -0.01370942685753107, -0.009080855175852776, -0.014709524810314178, 0.058904800564050674, 0.016569409519433975, -0.03863302245736122, 0.05187741667032242, 0.018247507512569427, 0.06416958570480347, -0.024193204939365387, 0.03006119467318058, 0.046362198889255524, -0.020571067929267883, -0.01628929376602173, -0.012939712032675743, -0.0008903107955120504, -0.03115660697221756, 0.0030352564062923193, -0.027027953416109085, 0.01737792231142521, -0.01827283762395382, -0.08082987368106842, -0.010712459683418274, -0.03964623436331749, -0.04056223854422569, -0.05719919502735138, -0.0024637167807668447, -0.062343157827854156, -0.03173968568444252, 0.08630265295505524, -0.05240621417760849, -0.03102804720401764, 0.03847520798444748, -0.0013122069649398327, -0.022016379982233047, 0.043125931173563004, -0.016590727493166924, -0.03148495778441429, -0.11883509904146194, 0.04832940921187401, 0.04897952079772949, 0.029148802161216736, -0.04535948112607002, -0.02330312505364418, -0.018129874020814896, -0.032199274748563766, -0.03695803880691528, -0.035363804548978806, 0.024779094383120537, 0.00509796803817153, 0.016910985112190247, 0.031179022043943405, 0.021049942821264267, -0.014268780127167702, 0.020335819572210312, 0.06769666820764542, 0.021898094564676285, -0.044853806495666504, -0.019903138279914856, 0.015081633813679218, 0.01105208694934845, -0.0013200577814131975, 0.03761162608861923, -0.019848011434078217, -0.02044213004410267, 0.06103162467479706, 0.02264498732984066, 0.02263488993048668, 0.033370181918144226, -0.0011376182083040476, 0.032592207193374634, 0.02571658417582512, 0.002151197288185358, -0.0016852719709277153, -0.060244541615247726, -0.010558155365288258, 0.030510514974594116, 0.04993676394224167, 0.03509371727705002, -0.027730144560337067, 0.038357436656951904, 0.007316494360566139, -0.0006173555157147348, -0.05041039362549782, -0.03020969033241272, -0.08621355146169662, -0.041042353957891464, -0.015285272151231766, 0.02920624054968357, 0.0330953411757946, -0.004513604566454887, 0.04913392290472984, 0.040483299642801285, 0.031501274555921555, 0.06672918051481247, 0.01980159804224968, -0.08678270876407623, -0.011416186578571796, 0.01290210522711277, -0.048192404210567474, -0.04314015433192253, -0.05751180276274681, 0.04886625334620476, 0.04787175729870796, -0.0419260673224926, 0.0347898043692112, -0.009480990469455719, -0.032738298177719116, 0.03038281947374344, -0.06419330835342407, -0.06698822975158691, -0.04633307829499245, 0.026562141254544258, 0.03191136568784714, -0.05666038766503334, 0.07875941693782806, -0.03137059137225151, -0.07365035265684128, -0.002940535545349121, 0.03180664777755737, -0.014619269408285618, 0.0016783172031864524, 0.013715807348489761, -0.01169937290251255, 0.0005510031478479505, 0.017625220119953156, 0.054225530475378036, -0.07534883171319962, 0.02526678331196308, -0.0008214500267058611, -0.0161705631762743, 0.014811557717621326, -0.04978850856423378, -0.026623733341693878, -0.026678506284952164, 0.030629608780145645, 0.06002209335565567, -0.019697459414601326, 0.05542987585067749, 0.020431088283658028, 0.01564689911901951, -0.02252770960330963, -0.015380489639937878, 0.02908041514456272, 0.04075847566127777, -0.08269850164651871, 0.02865247055888176, 0.04624451696872711, -0.022792518138885498, -0.08822321146726608, -0.036283228546381, -0.022494859993457794, -0.009159470908343792, 0.004158366937190294, 0.06097707152366638, 0.010108969174325466, 0.04633661359548569, 0.00933708343654871, -0.004172617569565773, 0.01575036719441414, 0.038215432316064835, 0.02103607915341854, 0.03009994886815548, 0.029958216473460197, 0.05370454862713814, -0.027452070266008377, -0.029469870030879974, 0.06789109110832214, 0.020985880866646767, -0.024761639535427094, -0.06366869807243347, 0.022380221635103226, 0.013273017480969429, 0.01224486529827118, 0.04507698491215706, -0.044431500136852264, 0.038814570754766464, 0.04862544313073158, 0.041710205376148224, 0.006034170277416706, -0.015831097960472107, -0.003572859801352024, -0.03050679713487625, -0.024064810946583748, -0.0825294628739357, 0.036317020654678345, 0.02746981754899025, -0.0008678712183609605, -0.000003096784439549083, -0.022415373474359512, 0.06049520522356033, -0.01102604903280735, 0.04256368800997734, -0.016865720972418785, 0.037711918354034424, -0.014213823713362217, 0.034522004425525665, -0.04268480837345123, 0.03996708616614342, 0.01742113009095192, -0.0781092643737793, -0.0068508596159517765, 0.040148790925741196, 0.015169422142207623, 0.0584133006632328, 0.029468895867466927, -0.029532257467508316, 0.0024959982838481665, 0.02058163471519947, -0.03775644674897194, -0.04667133837938309, 0.02656099759042263, 0.007300586439669132, 0.050074074417352676, 0.04615102335810661, -0.023165462538599968, -0.00008218132279580459, 0.06821043789386749, 0.045873336493968964, -0.06596747040748596, 0.010934659279882908, -0.07022213190793991, 0.018079187721014023, -0.015637671574950218, -0.03452110290527344, 0.013182049617171288, -0.04929250106215477, -0.00507171219214797, -0.03687933832406998, 0.009439676068723202, 0.06101818010210991, 0.027321647852659225, 0.02071089670062065, -0.024461276829242706, 0.02316574938595295, -0.028239373117685318, -0.021105293184518814, 0.031983062624931335, 0.022957932204008102, -0.024416483938694, -0.035760555416345596, 0.05678945407271385, 0.05612899735569954, -0.011709450744092464, -0.008570533245801926, 0.009653908200562, 0.008587879128754139, 0.0003442470624577254, 0.020322680473327637, 0.019935566931962967, 0.011033318936824799, 0.0043435776606202126, -0.007815997116267681, 0.02542543224990368, 0.0032121040858328342, 0.029463622719049454, -0.025393731892108917, -0.010236323811113834, 0.005055490415543318, 0.04429423063993454, -0.005967049393802881, 0.05524846911430359, 0.001517879543825984, 0.017519475892186165, -0.005635818466544151, -0.007025908678770065, -0.06455809623003006, -0.01000019907951355, 0.009528250433504581, 0.007586413063108921, -0.008082429878413677, 0.04282570630311966, -0.0022123579401522875, -0.04845045879483223, -0.03699754551053047, 0.0470484234392643, -0.0074171582236886024, -0.013120059855282307, -0.00812860019505024, -0.025606533512473106, 0.04532192274928093, -0.03447790443897247, -0.0009977876907214522, -0.07079530507326126, 0.006005638744682074, 0.017271745949983597, 0.011820671148598194, -0.012130982242524624, -0.017825530841946602, -0.04549933597445488, 0.00407868018373847, -0.027826925739645958, -0.021092817187309265, 0.01618158631026745, 0.01775394380092621, -0.08254721760749817, 0.03224779665470123, 0.0031116604804992676, 0.01109328307211399, 0.0032015847973525524, 0.017648791894316673, 0.009005519561469555, -0.03833335265517235, -0.024153508245944977, 0.03569972887635231, 0.012802056036889553, -0.07167535275220871, -0.07844828814268112, -0.03518993780016899, 0.018021611496806145, -0.019416291266679764, 0.02547670528292656, 0.05846160277724266, 0.04749854654073715, -0.06960365921258926, -0.01186529453843832, -0.09642583131790161, -0.0481126643717289, 0.0006545194773934782, -0.03235755115747452, -0.03839427977800369, 0.09703149646520615, 0.015230337157845497, 0.0011622390011325479, -0.05644267052412033, -0.027154013514518738, 0.011305085383355618, -0.018530985340476036, 0.07386595755815506, -0.02570079080760479, -0.009687718003988266, -0.009450686164200306, 0.032992295920848846, -0.02389225736260414, 0.05550622567534447, -0.030273010954260826, 0.002722994890064001, 0.01860068365931511, -0.0023239669390022755, -0.0010748055065050721, 0.010214690119028091, 0.03834664076566696, -0.02258511260151863, -0.004735327325761318, 0.021998856216669083, 0.0006623737281188369, -0.01017057802528143, 0.02631775289773941, 0.00945612508803606, 0.06766027957201004, -0.03156786784529686, -0.016898611560463905, 0.03531894087791443, -0.03455525264143944, -0.0054699210450053215, -0.004714358597993851, 0.04682353883981705, -0.000028318017939454876, 0.10090544074773788, -0.062351591885089874, 0.0036006029695272446, 0.07031586021184921, -0.018543073907494545, 0.03909039497375488, -0.038738496601581573, 0.039485957473516464, 0.002723975805565715, -0.04215383902192116, -0.060841552913188934, 0.008553918451070786, -0.03819043189287186, 0.017974531278014183, 0.04180068522691727, -0.013880718499422073, 0.0017163277370855212, 0.007549249101430178, 0.0241868793964386, -0.006517469417303801, 0.004213195294141769, 0.027910364791750908, -0.05049905553460121, 0.022671466693282127, 0.0395156666636467, 0.005313367582857609, 0.010461954399943352, 0.01565656252205372, 0.0264990646392107, -0.06474431604146957, -0.01837952621281147, -0.018737075850367546, -0.027859564870595932, 0.0371394045650959, 0.024195488542318344, -0.021405966952443123, 0.025792459025979042, -0.06448432803153992, -0.026652604341506958, 0.02651238441467285 ]
<p>On the new <a href="http://astronomy.stackexchange.com/">Astronomy.SE</a> site, I was having a short discussion on one of my answers. The basic discrepancy was; can MACHOs like black holes/brown dwarfs/neutron stars be termed "dark matter"?</p> <p>My reasoning is that these objects do not radiate EM radiation on their own but they do gravitate, and thus constitute a small part of the total dark matter in the universe. I agree that there is a lot of dark matter which doesn't</p> <p>In other words, can the term "dark matter" be applied to nonradiating (or faintly radiating) bodies which still participate in the electromagnetic interaction (baryonic or otherwise)? Or is it necessary for all dark matter to not interact electromagnetically?</p>
g7492
[ 0.026730742305517197, -0.025149686262011528, 0.017962032929062843, -0.0168299563229084, 0.0822984129190445, 0.038815610110759735, -0.0492384172976017, -0.04380121827125549, -0.010023679584264755, -0.02798640914261341, 0.03652242571115494, 0.02508039027452469, -0.00935575645416975, -0.047044072300195694, -0.06268777698278427, 0.004710956010967493, 0.05356645956635475, -0.019719669595360756, -0.0014083132846280932, 0.02845136821269989, 0.003010140499100089, -0.0014886062126606703, 0.04972715303301811, -0.1127169206738472, -0.04002228379249573, -0.0007471540593542159, 0.030663322657346725, -0.05927880108356476, -0.030807465314865112, 0.01185830682516098, 0.020572617650032043, 0.022514935582876205, 0.06144074723124504, 0.06033872067928314, -0.029156750068068504, -0.0672716498374939, 0.043853484094142914, -0.009250478819012642, 0.038627710193395615, -0.0014035592321306467, 0.026611972600221634, -0.013846821151673794, 0.0013029515976086259, 0.025928840041160583, -0.0037357753608375788, 0.05646735802292824, -0.020705994218587875, 0.01844673790037632, 0.02865510620176792, -0.05127755552530289, 0.04118853434920311, -0.013057399541139603, 0.09384560585021973, 0.032949771732091904, -0.004463151562958956, -0.07424454391002655, 0.02060358226299286, -0.005418641958385706, 0.0642809346318245, -0.008148159831762314, -0.00644213380292058, 0.07186267524957657, -0.04286114126443863, 0.01657368242740631, -0.038285426795482635, 0.02597152814269066, -0.04870641976594925, -0.054553188383579254, -0.030697982758283615, -0.008814907632768154, 0.044892147183418274, 0.020542100071907043, -0.008600947447121143, -0.016444532200694084, -0.04337174817919731, 0.025304988026618958, -0.011977305635809898, -0.03806986287236214, 0.027254119515419006, -0.01779184862971306, -0.020973781123757362, -0.009562471881508827, 0.060534246265888214, -0.04888886958360672, 0.08834832906723022, 0.005595819093286991, -0.01770673878490925, -0.022629164159297943, 0.026199471205472946, 0.04935344681143761, 0.0548834390938282, 0.02518296055495739, 0.037630632519721985, 0.0162589680403471, 0.10978774726390839, 0.049925796687603, -0.011229489929974079, 0.03845798596739769, -0.026406867429614067, -0.04657160863280296, -0.07837801426649094, 0.012579639442265034, -0.006920801475644112, 0.019789107143878937, 0.08482673019170761, 0.008725791238248348, 0.014346588402986526, -0.01277354545891285, 0.013925337232649326, 0.04433922469615936, -0.03841928765177727, -0.015435460954904556, -0.027771232649683952, -0.04957103356719017, -0.025338897481560707, -0.020703589543700218, 0.02557789720594883, -0.018058085814118385, -0.0029104731511324644, 0.10134918987751007, 0.006465209182351828, 0.022856956347823143, 0.0554967038333416, 0.007744649425148964, -0.05025224760174751, -0.025008048862218857, 0.008738848380744457, -0.021116318181157112, 0.016690751537680626, -0.08663258701562881, -0.004755659028887749, 0.029848383739590645, -0.014133164659142494, 0.010204046033322811, -0.04184368625283241, 0.03298386186361313, 0.06290163844823837, -0.06200096756219864, 0.009935412555932999, -0.00513534527271986, 0.026624618098139763, -0.0016497389879077673, 0.005445380229502916, -0.026972927153110504, -0.031508445739746094, 0.015265015885233879, -0.031372375786304474, -0.039910998195409775, 0.030055886134505272, -0.0019845948554575443, 0.03722119703888893, 0.02497708797454834, -0.0016496570315212011, -0.07660891115665436, -0.03739851340651512, 0.05993994325399399, 0.001314400346018374, 0.00543217221274972, -0.018977921456098557, 0.010388855822384357, 0.028875593096017838, 0.0013805126072838902, 0.009381011128425598, -0.021738100796937943, -0.018916599452495575, -0.008647008799016476, -0.059806112200021744, -0.0760670006275177, 0.04078453406691551, -0.045275043696165085, -0.06771886348724365, 0.013478833250701427, 0.028441915288567543, 0.038995858281850815, 0.002947682049125433, 0.010093209333717823, 0.02982768975198269, -0.057314611971378326, -0.061500903218984604, -0.01761888898909092, -0.01470246072858572, -0.009445144794881344, -0.03442631661891937, -0.04455077648162842, 0.029572682455182076, -0.028488874435424805, 0.014765853993594646, 0.0043692090548574924, 0.011684578843414783, 0.0008253793930634856, -0.03173297271132469, -0.006902391090989113, 0.05194578692317009, 0.009647984988987446, 0.0396239310503006, -0.01803482510149479, -0.00804694090038538, 0.0021712537854909897, 0.00012421407154761255, 0.05056605115532875, 0.022088998928666115, 0.05227944999933243, 0.007948696613311768, -0.014604410156607628, 0.00887980591505766, -0.005184645298868418, -0.004444345831871033, -0.0008690694812685251, 0.04128122329711914, -0.01952054724097252, 0.09597232192754745, -0.031171759590506554, -0.03796464577317238, 0.012552386149764061, -0.09384637326002121, -0.013071115128695965, -0.05023915320634842, 0.06209249049425125, -0.03322902321815491, -0.01340995728969574, -0.10013286024332047, -0.007509498856961727, 0.0036221551708877087, -0.042860742658376694, -0.038867637515068054, 0.00846742931753397, -0.02381947822868824, 0.012874042615294456, 0.001970971468836069, -0.007989753037691116, -0.02310177870094776, 0.016673864796757698, 0.03303314372897148, -0.019530389457941055, 0.05424414202570915, 0.012783410958945751, 0.013566956855356693, -0.04056279733777046, -0.017254335805773735, 0.019276876002550125, -0.0168734323233366, -0.050563450902700424, -0.016866765916347504, -0.033883899450302124, 0.04853946715593338, -0.04790790006518364, -0.002242865040898323, 0.025056248530745506, 0.005440148990601301, -0.02585400827229023, 0.05908289924263954, -0.046287652105093, -0.02128356322646141, 0.0058973804116249084, 0.027998756617307663, -0.024770477786660194, -0.025441870093345642, 0.007136142812669277, -0.11115065962076187, 0.018311087042093277, 0.05362626165151596, -0.043644364923238754, 0.024578535929322243, 0.02300398238003254, -0.06602951884269714, -0.01877393200993538, -0.027187345549464226, -0.007307486608624458, 0.008087403140962124, 0.01912882924079895, -0.0350688099861145, -0.010268725454807281, 0.016911305487155914, -0.003435499267652631, -0.013885891996324062, 0.08063403517007828, -0.06296051293611526, 0.047560643404722214, 0.049213673919439316, -0.035662151873111725, 0.03699247166514397, -0.007874799892306328, -0.025384623557329178, -0.08857910335063934, 0.014120559208095074, -0.024945374578237534, -0.053937267512083054, -0.01652568392455578, -0.04668669402599335, -0.021003952249884605, 0.023921968415379524, 0.044059593230485916, 0.030539022758603096, 0.03651899844408035, 0.004252051468938589, 0.03177212178707123, 0.005453428719192743, 0.03578592464327812, -0.051336534321308136, 0.04971756413578987, 0.028755461797118187, -0.05071372911334038, -0.013314099982380867, 0.018196405842900276, 0.040522657334804535, 0.04298195615410805, -0.07562568783760071, -0.07019331306219101, 0.04203085973858833, -0.03697832301259041, 0.06428524851799011, 0.04466289281845093, 0.00027775324997492135, 0.02756529487669468, -0.011807319708168507, 0.022154096513986588, 0.015308107249438763, -0.03727097436785698, 0.014256682246923447, 0.006464067846536636, 0.01802297867834568, 0.009609417989850044, 0.036150973290205, -0.06451890617609024, 0.03933737054467201, 0.04871097207069397, 0.03583545237779617, -0.03814634308218956, 0.012057517655193806, 0.04288457706570625, 0.0031868056394159794, -0.021959597244858742, 0.0028424966149032116, 0.021471893414855003, -0.0633956640958786, 0.010433239862322807, -0.013107993640005589, 0.019896063953638077, 0.0590844489634037, 0.006622945889830589, 0.0066164531745016575, -0.011493164114654064, -0.05807339772582054, 0.04306253045797348, -0.018151015043258667, 0.0723048523068428, -0.07705455273389816, -0.030296538025140762, -0.04647668078541756, -0.003784965956583619, -0.016204500570893288, 0.00719353836029768, 0.02904059924185276, -0.032229915261268616, -0.045441076159477234, -0.028340840712189674, 0.03286726027727127, 0.05305115133523941, -0.0009301192476414144, -0.0026669439394026995, 0.024039344862103462, 0.024199524894356728, 0.00003668194040074013, -0.0009336028015241027, 0.02408294565975666, -0.01612030528485775, 0.04465135186910629, 0.00665079103782773, -0.008784986101090908, -0.015753919258713722, 0.02221900038421154, 0.013174237683415413, -0.05532115325331688, 0.03308556601405144, 0.02695630118250847, -0.02504453808069229, 0.028773296624422073, 0.019968198612332344, -0.013801692984998226, -0.03834223747253418, -0.039636194705963135, 0.03244982659816742, -0.020854508504271507, 0.06315286457538605, 0.059681087732315063, -0.016751129180192947, 0.031314652413129807, -0.008197201415896416, -0.02108214795589447, -0.03778381645679474, -0.028420813381671906, -0.002461257390677929, -0.012191717512905598, -0.011721714399755001, 0.014185940846800804, -0.03191292658448219, 0.008611860685050488, -0.04058793932199478, 0.08019637316465378, 0.02239927463233471, 0.02618381753563881, 0.08005940169095993, 0.04264473542571068, -0.03207986801862717, 0.044728249311447144, 0.03916804865002632, -0.013415305875241756, -0.030125565826892853, -0.01461879163980484, 0.0019948757253587246, 0.003688132856041193, -0.01266255509108305, -0.02301184833049774, 0.005092312581837177, 0.041875213384628296, 0.018199851736426353, -0.04212110489606857, -0.027898112311959267, -0.025506842881441116, -0.005352881271392107, 0.03523542359471321, -0.0009699960355646908, -0.042355820536613464, 0.028485087677836418, -0.06176356226205826, 0.05687306076288223, 0.0318874716758728, -0.009941098280251026, -0.049791369587183, 0.05571214482188225, -0.011777440086007118, -0.03580140322446823, 0.004005755297839642, 0.023482436314225197, -0.02340848557651043, 0.03616796061396599, -0.03920970484614372, 0.017168426886200905, 0.05764291435480118, -0.017312530428171158, 0.07940477132797241, -0.0008750403067097068, 0.0034258365631103516, -0.031035596504807472, 0.004179138690233231, 0.06596030294895172, -0.010190777480602264, -0.02493649162352085, -0.00726298987865448, 0.020298242568969727, -0.017020439729094505, 0.01640394888818264, -0.042665764689445496, -0.02193981036543846, -0.019070344045758247, 0.02716095559298992, 0.01218451838940382, 0.006628043949604034, -0.00022054223518352956, 0.01577421836555004, -0.04241844639182091, -0.008508545346558094, 0.01586221158504486, 0.049028173089027405, 0.05951058492064476, -0.05958305671811104, -0.022816011682152748, 0.004301759414374828, -0.03869689255952835, -0.005833810660988092, -0.027159400284290314, 0.038750749081373215, 0.028717709705233574, 0.0067216139286756516, -0.008563765324652195, 0.009657627902925014, -0.022434674203395844, -0.03903202340006828, -0.02936503477394581, -0.009236111305654049, -0.007731073535978794, -0.05513004958629608, 0.02086799032986164, 0.01500812079757452, 0.014654787257313728, 0.08993420749902725, -0.027309410274028778, 0.043063417077064514, -0.031207000836730003, 0.04502681642770767, -0.04040273651480675, -0.00787554681301117, -0.024932323023676872, -0.03107973001897335, -0.03680230304598808, 0.018689576536417007, -0.018448203802108765, -0.03983577713370323, -0.025370514020323753, -0.010984499007463455, 0.04476836696267128, 0.006077646743506193, -0.01398946437984705, -0.056040115654468536, -0.015575977973639965, 0.020478790625929832, -0.00008977038669399917, -0.034211911261081696, 0.033741652965545654, -0.008486243896186352, -0.04385926201939583, 0.004956102464348078, 0.009830793365836143, 0.11045590043067932, -0.0420510396361351, -0.040485795587301254, -0.0013903190847486258, 0.06282789260149002, 0.04934151470661163, -0.036134399473667145, -0.010199202224612236, -0.03385758399963379, 0.03880907967686653, 0.021163923665881157, 0.03439010679721832, -0.014641344547271729, 0.03135966137051582, 0.03844285011291504, 0.00705681974068284, 0.07868297398090363, -0.0017185237957164645, 0.03058812953531742, 0.016237707808613777, 0.0034081232734024525, -0.030407054349780083, -0.060904741287231445, 0.01958940364420414, 0.06406894326210022, 0.0421050488948822, 0.015340850688517094, 0.013915215618908405, 0.010395301505923271, 0.05002967268228531, 0.018799161538481712, 0.0335349477827549, 0.015017620287835598, 0.027553407475352287, 0.014324055053293705, 0.024528276175260544, -0.06533905863761902, -0.03287747874855995, -0.022835923358798027, -0.043479472398757935, 0.05713094025850296, -0.020047591999173164, 0.0404357872903347, -0.03168446198105812, -0.031388167291879654, -0.008031405508518219, -0.06792242079973221, 0.020004870370030403, 0.009927994571626186, 0.011110483668744564, -0.01414327323436737, -0.042884811758995056, -0.00041847905959002674, 0.040422920137643814, -0.03511287271976471, -0.00484985439106822, -0.08754703402519226, -0.0074339997954666615, 0.03650858625769615, -0.02499358355998993, 0.020994745194911957, 0.002075832337141037, -0.07207032293081284, 0.009336719289422035, 0.04462052136659622, -0.022538507357239723, -0.00960744172334671, 0.0072060152888298035, -0.0192622821778059, 0.05838289111852646, -0.020719416439533234, -0.019633255898952484, -0.02045094221830368, 0.0026978247333317995, 0.07685607671737671, -0.020706554874777794, -0.015147581696510315, -0.007827038876712322, -0.00835399143397808, 0.0011859929654747248, 0.021379318088293076, -0.05961696058511734, -0.03099898062646389, -0.026182139292359352, -0.003990615252405405, -0.04894363507628441, -0.0021452968940138817, -0.03577563166618347, -0.04062129929661751, 0.032711684703826904, 0.08237675577402115, 0.05895553156733513, -0.014958754181861877, -0.07042080163955688, -0.01712929643690586, 0.021965404972434044, 0.039093777537345886, -0.03504686802625656, 0.0020258959848433733, -0.039580896496772766, 0.037183523178100586, -0.04557451233267784, -0.007203338667750359, -0.07838734984397888, -0.04509113356471062, -0.017095718532800674, -0.003716885345056653, -0.06716146320104599, 0.03566556051373482, 0.030026467517018318, -0.020542142912745476, -0.012439681217074394, 0.029857758432626724, -0.06766650080680847, 0.04843754693865776, 0.048302680253982544, 0.018000412732362747, -0.009396625682711601, 0.023266155272722244, -0.0038087614811956882, -0.0303147304803133, -0.014014487154781818, -0.0008940080879256129, 0.04324394464492798, -0.03526864945888519, 0.01715732365846634, -0.048537611961364746, 0.0067269629798829556, -0.027694907039403915, 0.029749063774943352, 0.052354052662849426, 0.02315152995288372, -0.020405424758791924, 0.024796519428491592, 0.03157858923077583, -0.04243847355246544, 0.028471549972891808, -0.023284532129764557, -0.02600071206688881, 0.038943931460380554, -0.011470249854028225, -0.05564960464835167, 0.010120364837348461, -0.029802223667502403, -0.019582359120249748, 0.009578611701726913, -0.013050608336925507, 0.003474891884252429, -0.024917742237448692, -0.10458220541477203, -0.031955596059560776, -0.0017660045996308327, -0.0403381884098053, 0.02662769891321659, -0.008535634726285934, -0.04751375690102577, -0.020203102380037308, -0.006715700030326843, -0.04642823338508606, -0.018977154046297073, 0.004289099480956793, -0.019945725798606873, -0.08869463950395584, 0.007801616098731756, -0.041658636182546616, 0.04000655934214592, 0.04321729764342308, 0.0493314154446125, -0.014002890326082706, 0.012399694882333279, 0.06097806617617607, -0.022535324096679688, 0.0507315956056118, -0.02133115753531456, -0.015438884496688843, 0.05421411618590355, 0.0523482970893383, 0.004481044132262468, 0.009017741307616234, 0.026544826105237007, -0.0021297745406627655, -0.03328024595975876, 0.0030074792448431253, 0.03202022239565849, 0.07067915052175522, -0.0021565447095781565, -0.00082939158892259, -0.018282661214470863, 0.018981045112013817, 0.012191740795969963, -0.020053861662745476, -0.0001650734047871083, 0.05288916081190109, 0.049535203725099564, 0.04809238016605377, -0.04660257324576378, -0.01197400689125061, 0.012784385122358799, 0.06582850962877274, 0.01542649231851101, 0.0016671271296218038, -0.051585640758275986, 0.0004118264187127352, -0.0020585223101079464, -0.00986966397613287, 0.013862297870218754, -0.03988000750541687, 0.03866402804851532, 0.04147614911198616, -0.025891350582242012, -0.0017749634571373463, -0.015674304217100143, -0.03715373948216438, -0.011888334527611732, 0.024249663576483727, 0.023886585608124733, -0.024974649772047997, -0.029060237109661102, 0.035797618329524994, -0.019869660958647728, 0.015017043799161911, -0.0045529259368777275, 0.002772378269582987, -0.03421015292406082, -0.0029417525511235, 0.01656990870833397, 0.03550198674201965, 0.01629345864057541, -0.0597979873418808, 0.020058663561940193, 0.006013898178935051, -0.03665178641676903, 0.0061927130445837975, -0.018523776903748512, 0.001349661499261856, 0.00717313913628459, 0.01882861740887165, -0.060070592910051346, 0.02666236273944378, 0.028689105063676834, 0.07145874947309494, 0.07059057801961899, -0.0288652703166008, -0.008166615851223469, -0.003893520450219512, -0.051140524446964264, 0.04283237084746361, 0.02456074394285679, -0.004935608711093664, -0.011394484899938107, 0.018742643296718597, 0.053163520991802216, -0.03513316810131073, -0.01730235479772091, 0.03568602353334427 ]
<p>The FRW is a nice isotropic and symmetric metric but I think its assumptions are too many. I was wondering about alternative models. Specifically are there any prominent alternatives that have more fleshed out local detail? For example, are there any models that can ascribe a more local interpretation to data which was considered as crucial support for the Big Bang. </p>
g7493
[ 0.021066628396511078, -0.0106698302552104, -0.0014536313246935606, -0.06981921195983887, -0.032180141657590866, 0.02121516317129135, 0.02837422676384449, -0.041149236261844635, -0.025995632633566856, -0.052393462508916855, 0.06374217569828033, -0.04922548681497574, 0.07594891637563705, 0.032414600253105164, -0.0007986995042301714, -0.023449096828699112, -0.006013020407408476, -0.05391271039843559, 0.03614429384469986, 0.013800115324556828, -0.03333498537540436, 0.016325002536177635, -0.002108955755829811, 0.05521408095955849, -0.07181625813245773, 0.0038742271717637777, 0.06046131253242493, 0.017092473804950714, -0.007375962566584349, -0.05222930386662483, 0.0056413309648633, -0.022820334881544113, 0.016449864953756332, -0.07885619252920151, -0.019552895799279213, -0.014282016083598137, -0.014025971293449402, 0.05911782383918762, 0.038115400820970535, 0.03310927748680115, 0.04242142662405968, -0.056420449167490005, 0.009527151472866535, 0.04744415357708931, -0.01192537508904934, -0.01674441620707512, -0.024119844660162926, 0.03397425636649132, 0.06110202893614769, -0.007033083122223616, -0.006317818537354469, 0.047381624579429626, 0.03186532109975815, -0.02032260224223137, 0.02578829787671566, 0.022897806018590927, 0.02879732847213745, -0.011905324645340443, 0.03524591773748398, 0.02441028319299221, -0.04441462829709053, 0.0096594812348485, -0.06786992400884628, -0.03856917470693588, -0.037087682634592056, 0.012222873978316784, -0.030349334701895714, -0.012038822285830975, 0.016071336343884468, -0.05933961644768715, 0.05657950043678284, -0.0018504088511690497, 0.014048664830625057, -0.04834946617484093, -0.08687712252140045, 0.0375719889998436, -0.06643843650817871, 0.03691817820072174, -0.03595077246427536, -0.07039427757263184, -0.041365016251802444, 0.05224958807229996, 0.027866357937455177, -0.0019741773139685392, 0.04038627818226814, -0.010099473409354687, 0.0005972082144580781, 0.07550131529569626, 0.05676233768463135, -0.06682527810335159, -0.02567659690976143, -0.02975935861468315, 0.030318772420287132, -0.03706368803977966, 0.003800663398578763, 0.030183881521224976, -0.0667383149266243, 0.03359074145555496, -0.020969219505786896, -0.023613134399056435, -0.0010378261795267463, 0.0333494134247303, 0.026928678154945374, 0.03586126118898392, 0.005134620238095522, -0.0684792548418045, -0.011995429173111916, 0.02416631020605564, 0.0031520326156169176, 0.011760733090341091, 0.01976919174194336, -0.010368365794420242, 0.027094127610325813, 0.0041948724538087845, -0.08534146845340729, -0.05178996920585632, 0.04661869630217552, -0.07108240574598312, -0.023114321753382683, 0.04799538850784302, 0.011674140579998493, 0.012088934890925884, -0.04247494414448738, -0.010842310264706612, -0.05078446865081787, -0.0032156798988580704, -0.013994667679071426, -0.020262761041522026, -0.00044819849426858127, -0.02714027278125286, 0.05026976391673088, 0.009288206696510315, 0.021709926426410675, 0.030579591169953346, -0.02179335057735443, -0.017308907583355904, -0.04776478186249733, 0.055667534470558167, 0.0026535026263445616, 0.04570624977350235, -0.026287710294127464, -0.020393159240484238, -0.020879216492176056, 0.017428278923034668, -0.016117125749588013, -0.031016239896416664, 0.021380897611379623, 0.002900331746786833, 0.03287889435887337, -0.013874435797333717, -0.02106202207505703, 0.11247581243515015, -0.0005106308381073177, -0.011510155163705349, -0.03969927132129669, -0.04509344324469566, 0.007253479212522507, -0.010869042947888374, -0.004935511853545904, -0.0492403618991375, 0.02395818568766117, -0.04389980062842369, 0.050607893615961075, 0.018700366839766502, 0.008387632668018341, 0.05278361216187477, 0.008293751627206802, -0.007566411513835192, -0.015498119406402111, -0.012805605307221413, -0.07973678410053253, 0.00687794666737318, 0.03602359816431999, 0.03954203799366951, 0.061249345541000366, -0.0316266231238842, -0.028509635478258133, -0.0289157684892416, -0.011541040614247322, 0.05451349541544914, -0.05509886145591736, -0.024518238380551338, -0.003127259900793433, 0.017538363113999367, 0.033788781613111496, -0.036385707557201385, -0.01742464490234852, 0.026716426014900208, 0.02772579714655876, 0.032305434346199036, 0.01706874929368496, -0.0047140358947217464, 0.015346404165029526, 0.039857178926467896, 0.015181563794612885, -0.008102593943476677, 0.02719532512128353, -0.01234100479632616, 0.013124375604093075, 0.08465003967285156, 0.016931721940636635, 0.029345953837037086, 0.009668389335274696, 0.04252755269408226, 0.039995066821575165, 0.0762806385755539, 0.0012309583835303783, -0.01988290622830391, 0.0343928225338459, -0.014083024114370346, -0.007460135035216808, -0.06743999570608139, 0.014812390320003033, 0.034316498786211014, 0.0023920631501823664, -0.022638779133558273, 0.005729795433580875, 0.09826098382472992, -0.011832437478005886, 0.03051288053393364, -0.02323925495147705, -0.020392542704939842, 0.04172464460134506, -0.017000043764710426, 0.04088522866368294, -0.04257066175341606, 0.02001042291522026, 0.004594878759235144, 0.026900500059127808, 0.0561242438852787, -0.03635754808783531, 0.0075350068509578705, 0.046539150178432465, 0.0097988061606884, 0.07340559363365173, 0.030688313767313957, 0.00476294569671154, -0.033225953578948975, 0.019386548548936844, 0.0068052709102630615, 0.025871187448501587, -0.05303831771016121, -0.06489033252000809, -0.03034217469394207, -0.04946376010775566, 0.011838220059871674, 0.047040943056344986, -0.002182131865993142, 0.02746882103383541, -0.01726563274860382, 0.002600346691906452, 0.006288077682256699, -0.030477352440357208, -0.040260739624500275, -0.007657802663743496, -0.0034770930651575327, 0.0024708120618015528, 0.06760752201080322, -0.04302828386425972, -0.012209233827888966, -0.0016483684303238988, -0.030895549803972244, -0.017046233639121056, 0.03650085628032684, 0.007857023738324642, 0.02027531899511814, -0.010851547122001648, 0.018822357058525085, -0.09530525654554367, -0.010162771679461002, 0.051176879554986954, 0.016783330589532852, 0.012775974348187447, 0.045226600021123886, 0.01942557469010353, 0.043205540627241135, 0.02254936285316944, -0.01671581156551838, 0.014816805720329285, -0.011530168354511261, -0.00531903188675642, -0.02803807519376278, 0.016948608681559563, -0.022628819569945335, 0.0643380880355835, 0.014120290987193584, -0.02172170765697956, -0.028286712244153023, 0.05018918588757515, -0.03641363978385925, -0.03118342161178589, 0.016376545652747154, 0.03484639525413513, 0.012824412435293198, -0.058044906705617905, 0.06202574819326401, -0.013548633083701134, -0.012575364671647549, 0.006591037381440401, 0.02960248664021492, 0.0142943961545825, -0.03547200933098793, 0.007950382307171822, 0.014655102975666523, -0.033227432519197464, -0.027502739802002907, -0.03503647446632385, -0.0641179233789444, -0.023470066487789154, -0.04789774492383003, 0.029829759150743484, 0.03967921435832977, -0.05286768451333046, 0.011243785731494427, -0.06971487402915955, -0.014269277453422546, -0.02757692150771618, 0.06450764834880829, 0.02427416667342186, -0.04023441672325134, -0.0346478708088398, 0.008430346846580505, 0.035938117653131485, -0.03513161092996597, 0.010542835108935833, 0.06307879835367203, -0.07060825079679489, -0.031856562942266464, -0.05804905667901039, 0.0033418869134038687, 0.018368015065789223, -0.010339764878153801, 0.0022909468971192837, -0.015421397052705288, -0.10876360535621643, -0.03552982211112976, -0.06176930293440819, 0.010032153688371181, 0.06619703769683838, -0.010531026870012283, -0.007793822791427374, -0.016205281019210815, 0.015764042735099792, -0.01399082038551569, -0.0041024829261004925, 0.02220867946743965, 0.0012843115255236626, -0.015180072747170925, 0.05090300366282463, -0.0186606552451849, -0.028484657406806946, 0.011208089999854565, 0.019345145672559738, -0.04669114574790001, 0.02943897247314453, -0.028454171493649483, 0.08894561976194382, -0.018567312508821487, 0.04071718826889992, 0.009848088957369328, 0.045977964997291565, 0.011906209401786327, -0.03173505887389183, 0.0010254043154418468, -0.06670471280813217, 0.0007935850298963487, -0.017417142167687416, -0.023242583498358727, -0.03763687238097191, -0.06291496753692627, 0.04682636633515358, 0.005652477033436298, 0.06287311017513275, 0.042272988706827164, 0.061235684901475906, -0.0010057989275082946, 0.05913398414850235, 0.014741016551852226, -0.01464912574738264, 0.006378827150911093, 0.049158040434122086, 0.023987682536244392, -0.01448532659560442, 0.0020948892924934626, -0.00865986105054617, -0.07238084822893143, -0.04655434191226959, -0.020849410444498062, -0.05353619158267975, 0.004639854189008474, 0.014020306058228016, -0.07884709537029266, -0.03812679275870323, -0.00031134943128563464, 0.050154268741607666, -0.052551332861185074, -0.029851537197828293, -0.0323343388736248, 0.026532631367444992, 0.03615904226899147, -0.02415047585964203, -0.012097703292965889, 0.021161161363124847, 0.028121229261159897, -0.017724277451634407, 0.0192611925303936, -0.06763874739408493, -0.05273915082216263, -0.045772261917591095, -0.04679356887936592, 0.027304431423544884, 0.039596766233444214, 0.06281571090221405, -0.059115637093782425, 0.06181444227695465, -0.03917178884148598, 0.03770248591899872, -0.08549182862043381, 0.056095633655786514, 0.01130315288901329, -0.016870329156517982, 0.06381817907094955, 0.03266063705086708, 0.010577738285064697, 0.04168589785695076, 0.06925579905509949, 0.0416373685002327, -0.03462030738592148, -0.04839547723531723, 0.039045125246047974, 0.008212298154830933, 0.006695845630019903, 0.014426426962018013, 0.065655417740345, -0.02624993957579136, 0.03660532459616661, -0.02924771048128605, -0.013786873780190945, -0.02636444941163063, -0.025007374584674835, 0.016888627782464027, -0.041403211653232574, -0.0213581845164299, -0.037360768765211105, 0.0431104376912117, 0.06642953306436539, -0.008830288425087929, 0.03425411134958267, -0.035700712352991104, 0.017342964187264442, -0.03442348167300224, 0.003960669040679932, -0.020729131996631622, 0.037488970905542374, 0.0185251384973526, 0.03806040808558464, -0.005539091769605875, 0.017662858590483665, 0.020890332758426666, -0.007754364516586065, -0.06448371708393097, 0.005452306941151619, -0.03101612627506256, 0.004418071825057268, 0.015256627462804317, -0.03341148793697357, -0.051819875836372375, 0.04445419833064079, -0.0071020531468093395, -0.019728761166334152, -0.023793499916791916, 0.03253689035773277, 0.05677628889679909, -0.013249896466732025, -0.0016024200012907386, 0.09135930985212326, -0.0023438744246959686, -0.013888825662434101, -0.00953175313770771, 0.003035501344129443, -0.0004446015227586031, -0.011064243502914906, -0.0007779299048706889, 0.011023423634469509, 0.01094102393835783, 0.012663633562624454, -0.007859558798372746, -0.02505330927670002, -0.015882553532719612, -0.014039668254554272, 0.04528111591935158, 0.02880018763244152, 0.024873310700058937, 0.06866347789764404, -0.014620955102145672, 0.04217489808797836, 0.05105714499950409, -0.028465010225772858, 0.044379718601703644, 0.05115961655974388, -0.021585138514637947, 0.06694043427705765, 0.05036458745598793, -0.04899896681308746, 0.01905105449259281, 0.059658732265233994, 0.02470351755619049, -0.002925617853179574, -0.011397575959563255, 0.018372882157564163, 0.013270820491015911, 0.006843507289886475, 0.004203260410577059, -0.010902675800025463, 0.012136604636907578, -0.015255733393132687, 0.011321326717734337, -0.015961874276399612, 0.006695382762700319, -0.041805922985076904, 0.024734610691666603, -0.014253778383135796, 0.06343554705381393, 0.0003172465949319303, -0.008465192280709743, -0.03330383822321892, -0.05067415535449982, -0.031232072040438652, -0.014974959194660187, -0.05719366669654846, 0.029022591188549995, 0.02880246937274933, -0.02041529305279255, 0.04385972023010254, 0.03161576762795448, 0.025827597826719284, 0.008751699700951576, 0.010658140294253826, 0.0223361998796463, -0.023400839418172836, -0.03602577745914459, 0.0520525798201561, 0.0307503379881382, 0.009489519521594048, 0.003602284239605069, 0.010249696671962738, -0.008894494734704494, 0.05803132802248001, 0.0023680042941123247, -0.05508890748023987, -0.030741248279809952, -0.023223958909511566, -0.013944348320364952, 0.028702586889266968, -0.05917462706565857, 0.009445562027394772, -0.023909879848361015, -0.029511358588933945, -0.04075024276971817, 0.013734529726207256, -0.05292730778455734, 0.040404148399829865, 0.03147658705711365, 0.05528140813112259, -0.04559801146388054, -0.026903267949819565, -0.02665489912033081, -0.052455052733421326, 0.040185410529375076, -0.022405406460165977, -0.03465047851204872, -0.0290087778121233, -0.004576669540256262, 0.058996666222810745, -0.034621529281139374, -0.0862022340297699, 0.02990877814590931, 0.0038642999716103077, 0.0529082790017128, 0.009673804976046085, -0.010865726508200169, -0.025417547672986984, 0.05179322883486748, -0.0015419976552948356, -0.022669918835163116, 0.06810547411441803, -0.04096381366252899, 0.031370773911476135, -0.04010903462767601, -0.010934163816273212, 0.04450773447751999, -0.07840574532747269, 0.021851856261491776, -0.001913987216539681, -0.006933294236660004, -0.010755646973848343, 0.02808784693479538, -0.03204900771379471, -0.040330931544303894, -0.06628849357366562, -0.040190938860177994, 0.010153600014746189, 0.05542119964957237, -0.012488027103245258, 0.07544207572937012, -0.001272322959266603, -0.03509281948208809, 0.01866724155843258, 0.017803091555833817, -0.030757376924157143, 0.04033804312348366, 0.05194728821516037, -0.0010803613113239408, 0.0476459264755249, 0.00793879572302103, -0.014920434914529324, 0.011800429783761501, -0.0114712193608284, -0.05151950567960739, -0.022966548800468445, 0.0285174623131752, -0.0236174575984478, -0.0416911244392395, 0.017299285158514977, -0.040600620210170746, 0.02865857258439064, -0.03435429185628891, 0.054088883101940155, -0.01509437058120966, 0.03165137767791748, 0.04323843494057655, 0.06154434755444527, 0.050341516733169556, 0.010053802281618118, -0.023363200947642326, 0.044245850294828415, -0.01127068791538477, 0.005599037278443575, -0.0015032660448923707, 0.019444255158305168, 0.0072877719067037106, 0.01697644032537937, -0.0075065977871418, -0.011019345372915268, -0.04518462345004082, -0.025564227253198624, 0.01277104765176773, -0.0025824876502156258, -0.027377193793654442, 0.019928567111492157, -0.0007188399322330952, 0.031135303899645805, -0.03729274123907089, -0.019460424780845642, -0.02073868364095688, -0.0024167480878531933, -0.0006290177116170526, 0.02483333833515644, 0.06330490857362747, -0.01784113608300686, 0.007249880116432905, 0.030331477522850037, 0.012092622928321362, -0.03413985297083855, -0.013359510339796543, 0.0074415868148207664, -0.026119142770767212, -0.03214123100042343, 0.018471797928214073, 0.0013661719858646393, 0.016111817210912704, -0.05093495547771454, -0.04285220056772232, -0.014309129677712917, -0.017789369449019432, -0.09500434994697571, -0.07466498017311096, -0.012040250934660435, -0.011241643689572811, -0.006503768265247345, 0.009860246442258358, 0.09683909267187119, 0.002390117384493351, 0.032510124146938324, -0.01713307574391365, 0.07879116386175156, 0.02265853062272072, -0.0075209480710327625, -0.03575056418776512, 0.00702344486489892, -0.05342353507876396, 0.04073146730661392, 0.0333554670214653, -0.012993344105780125, -0.028578151017427444, -0.023766174912452698, -0.04328739643096924, 0.02246859297156334, 0.026178548112511635, -0.07592184096574783, 0.06185442954301834, 0.024545583873987198, -0.05186993256211281, -0.054297398775815964, 0.031774044036865234, -0.057582926005125046, -0.0485989972949028, -0.024419257417321205, 0.012605031952261925, 0.0029123900458216667, 0.008136490359902382, 0.09149045497179031, 0.029652811586856842, 0.007866675034165382, 0.03366461768746376, -0.014228783547878265, -0.10091251879930496, 0.007195104379206896, 0.004786889534443617, -0.02434743009507656, -0.012561449781060219, -0.01328824833035469, -0.021026598289608955, -0.03362147882580757, 0.022580934688448906, -0.01825263909995556, -0.03407071903347969, -0.03076770342886448, 0.013870658352971077, 0.011087050661444664, -0.028384368866682053, -0.020985370501875877, -0.037900034338235855, 0.02212790958583355, -0.052501171827316284, 0.0516941174864769, 0.03484278544783592, -0.036884598433971405, -0.03513903170824051, 0.0075699989683926105, -0.010772250592708588, -0.011047092266380787, 0.011270278133451939, -0.027703261002898216, -0.04579220712184906, -0.0022932838182896376, 0.012659547850489616, 0.03144950419664383, 0.043223775923252106, -0.015109374187886715, 0.04304417595267296, 0.04912332072854042, -0.015155121684074402, -0.012270118109881878, -0.05860806256532669, -0.0019853035919368267, 0.017398377880454063, 0.0006010376382619143, -0.0008651309181004763, -0.061753708869218826, 0.02529319003224373, 0.009212799370288849, 0.051758695393800735, 0.03363123536109924, 0.006371830124408007, 0.007324447389692068, 0.02397266961634159, 0.030403543263673782 ]
<p><a href="http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/604/is-it-possible-to-get-pregnant-through-natural-means-in-space">http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/604/is-it-possible-to-get-pregnant-through-natural-means-in-space</a> indicates cosmonauts are at risk of irradiation whilst in space. </p> <p>What little I know about space is that planets, and inhabitants are largely protected from deep cosmic rays by - Sun's magnetic sheath - Solar Wind - Planet's own magnetic sheath</p> <p>When in orbit, a cosmonaut and satellites are periodically in the Sun. At other times, they are in the dark. On the sunward side, any body is directly in the Solar wind, whereas in shadow the planet/body probably acts as a shield against the Solar Wind; I may be wrong!</p> <ol> <li><p>Where is the deep-space radiation higher - on the Sunward side of Earth, or on the side in Earth's shadow? I guess this may also be rephrased to read - what fraction of shielding from deep cosmic rays within the Solar System is provided by the Solar wind?</p></li> <li><p>Is a cosmonaut at greater health risk on the Sunward Side, or in Earth's shadow? (<em>This second part may fit better on Biology SE but since it is contingent on the former I post it here</em>)</p></li> </ol>
g7494
[ 0.006817506160587072, 0.04236119985580444, 0.004107864107936621, 0.02955622225999832, -0.019879881292581558, 0.0739181786775589, -0.004491329658776522, -0.033246416598558426, -0.0331285186111927, -0.05457567796111107, 0.05144064500927925, 0.0881759375333786, 0.03430173918604851, -0.0014177217381075025, -0.010875187814235687, -0.0394243448972702, 0.09007290750741959, -0.0018398702377453446, 0.08427131921052933, 0.038471952080726624, -0.034708473831415176, -0.02391749806702137, -0.003058973466977477, -0.013639864511787891, -0.004914593882858753, 0.01407570019364357, 0.027095990255475044, -0.052585575729608536, 0.012877073138952255, -0.05982454493641853, 0.08314193040132523, -0.01122402772307396, 0.037973035126924515, -0.049154557287693024, -0.029401926323771477, -0.06154800206422806, -0.01156122237443924, -0.00134068273473531, -0.02379925176501274, 0.007729487959295511, 0.025839345529675484, -0.05896439030766487, 0.08334178477525711, 0.016316184774041176, 0.008627579547464848, 0.04760579392313957, -0.014284574426710606, 0.018925629556179047, -0.012477577663958073, -0.04785165935754776, -0.0572018027305603, -0.024927711114287376, -0.02296842634677887, 0.02448209561407566, 0.08657011389732361, -0.08185841143131256, -0.030054090544581413, -0.011816066689789295, 0.08126423507928848, -0.033767152577638626, 0.033359505236148834, 0.0743112787604332, -0.007944861426949501, 0.03304136544466019, 0.03608037531375885, -0.018377229571342468, -0.03845136985182762, 0.04922739043831825, 0.05266351252794266, 0.0038589825853705406, 0.053256191313266754, 0.0009944100165739655, 0.005580616183578968, -0.016985656693577766, 0.061915453523397446, 0.014155336655676365, 0.008843506686389446, 0.05593297258019447, -0.025669582188129425, 0.08026844263076782, -0.005315753165632486, -0.009628656320273876, -0.04350673034787178, -0.021058734506368637, 0.0923745259642601, 0.04448637738823891, -0.012395097874104977, -0.046960532665252686, 0.025146575644612312, 0.020815813913941383, 0.0453181117773056, 0.017611410468816757, 0.05320214107632637, 0.0277676060795784, -0.009254758246243, 0.04309438169002533, 0.0477079413831234, 0.017532898113131523, -0.05567111819982529, -0.04416373744606972, -0.029136696830391884, -0.018371136859059334, 0.02604038082063198, 0.051446039229631424, -0.004855411592870951, -0.05736011639237404, 0.048899415880441666, -0.00044167673331685364, -0.04006054624915123, -0.004731703549623489, -0.010417076759040356, -0.049076952040195465, -0.0069345468655228615, -0.022543584927916527, -0.033087994903326035, 0.009152411483228207, 0.05172889307141304, 0.009508330374956131, 0.046244002878665924, 0.06677501648664474, 0.006677432917058468, 0.08318465203046799, -0.02229069545865059, 0.08017753064632416, -0.0004702637088485062, 0.019207946956157684, -0.037937965244054794, -0.0598178505897522, 0.035988811403512955, 0.02314329892396927, -0.021248579025268555, 0.0060507990419864655, 0.006698230747133493, 0.01547722052782774, 0.052563685923814774, 0.012987960129976273, 0.005533974152058363, 0.01303987018764019, 0.0024903654120862484, -0.036079902201890945, 0.007359061855822802, 0.027381302788853645, 0.05379638448357582, -0.02724035084247589, -0.04311484470963478, 0.003112231148406863, -0.018164563924074173, 0.015906566753983498, 0.0012355729704722762, 0.026053013280034065, 0.014842359349131584, 0.07170900702476501, -0.017122192308306694, -0.03822460025548935, 0.035442691296339035, -0.002769761485978961, 0.004200022667646408, 0.06051153317093849, 0.020384101197123528, 0.06681269407272339, 0.06268803030252457, 0.03842033073306084, -0.008968381211161613, -0.040969982743263245, -0.0071140918880701065, -0.007439304143190384, -0.03458096832036972, -0.07429338991641998, -0.07895483076572418, 0.05385075882077217, -0.011772467754781246, -0.025054924190044403, 0.06109486520290375, -0.02165973000228405, 0.0015780770918354392, 0.007211516611278057, 0.03722362965345383, -0.0863371342420578, 0.03784964233636856, 0.0016754617681726813, 0.023821255192160606, -0.034656330943107605, 0.017461933195590973, -0.007616177201271057, 0.016466595232486725, -0.04812098294496536, 0.011383368633687496, -0.03258132562041283, -0.05616132169961929, -0.009695697575807571, -0.006983096711337566, -0.04328242689371109, -0.0014485165011137724, -0.02436557598412037, -0.026859916746616364, -0.03342543914914131, 0.0286805871874094, 0.05152745172381401, 0.016547653824090958, 0.00028007739456370473, -0.03424793481826782, 0.04947312921285629, 0.023314442485570908, 0.006327516864985228, -0.02415020391345024, 0.05654425546526909, 0.00829438678920269, -0.0068473247811198235, 0.023326320573687553, -0.04490673169493675, 0.029700133949518204, 0.004081160761415958, -0.017037900164723396, 0.0310587789863348, 0.028248023241758347, 0.024120964109897614, -0.05339127779006958, 0.02727506123483181, -0.04929889366030693, -0.012776155956089497, 0.0034550768323242664, -0.022934820502996445, 0.03459527716040611, 0.01862867921590805, 0.003792933654040098, 0.024772850796580315, -0.028140228241682053, 0.0021113192196935415, 0.06141645833849907, 0.0031674494966864586, -0.07675938308238983, -0.0014882234390825033, 0.03103230893611908, -0.0111174201592803, -0.011028492823243141, -0.02937251701951027, 0.015837162733078003, -0.02370675653219223, 0.007382950279861689, 0.012153713963925838, 0.03152693435549736, -0.03721574693918228, -0.04507638141512871, 0.03846069797873497, 0.0689886063337326, -0.05561559647321701, 0.007570489309728146, -0.010213824920356274, -0.0107041634619236, 0.0037853801622986794, 0.03834274783730507, 0.015613761730492115, -0.025364115834236145, 0.016429539769887924, -0.004703601356595755, 0.009777181781828403, -0.09167556464672089, -0.005644487217068672, -0.08310024440288544, 0.034913793206214905, 0.030184689909219742, -0.06379018723964691, -0.024918431416153908, 0.027606351301074028, 0.000059941325162071735, 0.04555465653538704, -0.01590387523174286, 0.036579813808202744, 0.02619464136660099, 0.003611148800700903, 0.00007518898200942203, 0.095533587038517, 0.014764000661671162, 0.03616742417216301, -0.0230632983148098, 0.035077910870313644, 0.05886956676840782, -0.03194980323314667, 0.014066830277442932, 0.0026622938457876444, 0.0036048954352736473, 0.05884667485952377, 0.028456754982471466, -0.010330555029213428, 0.03949357569217682, -0.0008960997802205384, -0.04530993476510048, -0.0341099314391613, 0.0033345131669193506, 0.02831321209669113, 0.011676406487822533, -0.04355154186487198, 0.02621760219335556, 0.05081566795706749, 0.01125316321849823, 0.022538883611559868, -0.007568878121674061, 0.012829869985580444, -0.043739352375268936, -0.021462740376591682, -0.017390210181474686, 0.020735280588269234, 0.05419553816318512, 0.025996804237365723, -0.051459528505802155, -0.005518210586160421, -0.02250048518180847, -0.06017056107521057, 0.04255511239171028, -0.0314834900200367, 0.009807644411921501, 0.04284157603979111, 0.005670074373483658, 0.05392363667488098, 0.01782846264541149, 0.019615259021520615, -0.06579190492630005, -0.04762260615825653, 0.020887477323412895, 0.0017462240066379309, -0.010780911892652512, 0.001941028400324285, -0.03641756251454353, 0.001718483748845756, -0.013464340940117836, -0.027067698538303375, -0.009102806448936462, 0.009701315313577652, -0.03933523967862129, -0.005486271809786558, 0.03292182832956314, 0.013667908497154713, -0.002703913953155279, 0.01018912810832262, -0.05935991182923317, 0.07211142033338547, -0.07076399773359299, 0.03144095093011856, 0.030383436009287834, 0.03264986723661423, -0.022467341274023056, -0.0468919537961483, -0.016725687310099602, -0.02535422332584858, -0.0178106389939785, 0.04241872578859329, -0.006811118219047785, 0.0062383562326431274, -0.002252940321341157, -0.013142196461558342, 0.04507061466574669, 0.001954982988536358, -0.03923827037215233, 0.019372232258319855, -0.011898386292159557, 0.01799936778843403, -0.001504760468378663, 0.018581043928861618, 0.003845164319500327, -0.012801136821508408, 0.001780532649718225, 0.0051004947163164616, 0.012167262844741344, -0.0288519486784935, 0.0246727392077446, 0.012953710742294788, 0.046260636299848557, 0.051233839243650436, 0.017194455489516258, 0.029104070737957954, -0.03884413465857506, -0.003112439066171646, -0.036796700209379196, -0.03154131770133972, 0.05787259712815285, -0.008797499351203442, -0.010025565512478352, -0.019712669774889946, -0.006645201239734888, -0.0543225072324276, 0.02669532410800457, -0.04272255301475525, 0.03313947841525078, -0.029906468465924263, 0.044824521988630295, 0.03370504826307297, -0.015905272215604782, -0.0017528089229017496, -0.05729769542813301, -0.023813782259821892, -0.02036179043352604, -0.03104945831000805, -0.0256210770457983, -0.03240034356713295, 0.05310000106692314, 0.012326937168836594, 0.05113166198134422, 0.017012936994433403, 0.03683413937687874, 0.01260277908295393, 0.0320294126868248, 0.010236757807433605, 0.03849976509809494, 0.011623161844909191, -0.04032665491104126, -0.01610827073454857, -0.007295567542314529, -0.04067627713084221, -0.044059768319129944, 0.01495406124740839, 0.054548777639865875, 0.04620145261287689, -0.026139238849282265, -0.05323801189661026, 0.06873368471860886, -0.004767936654388905, -0.01280494499951601, -0.013495415449142456, 0.01902684196829796, 0.02877911366522312, 0.01370514091104269, 0.009547785855829716, 0.015135525725781918, -0.008294794708490372, -0.02776728756725788, 0.10778015851974487, 0.019266393035650253, -0.037827108055353165, 0.03284497186541557, 0.06275244057178497, 0.01987278461456299, 0.03398526459932327, -0.03848693147301674, 0.05706102028489113, -0.003093000501394272, 0.04659363254904747, -0.0608857162296772, -0.03597171604633331, -0.027358215302228928, 0.02363472804427147, -0.004418854136019945, 0.006086127366870642, 0.05730623006820679, -0.04777219519019127, -0.017517462372779846, 0.06323014199733734, -0.006390536669641733, -0.004944128450006247, -0.021226102486252785, -0.025352440774440765, -0.014252681285142899, -0.031661536544561386, -0.006017882842570543, -0.06420136243104935, -0.035284217447042465, -0.00834862794727087, -0.02512175403535366, -0.0854756087064743, -0.0015314531046897173, -0.0008689728565514088, -0.03514984995126724, 0.04940144345164299, 0.04617217555642128, -0.03608556091785431, -0.01038117241114378, 0.017177602276206017, -0.043668586760759354, 0.010502319782972336, 0.0010650681797415018, 0.017642362043261528, -0.00741985160857439, -0.0014853727770969272, -0.005261991638690233, -0.05440483242273331, -0.029033232480287552, -0.004725362174212933, -0.026096832007169724, -0.039639025926589966, -0.06528745591640472, -0.0346074216067791, 0.06374151259660721, 0.009761199355125427, -0.030176864936947823, 0.012430177070200443, -0.040407445281744, 0.02033643238246441, -0.027171650901436806, 0.02161230519413948, 0.02434559538960457, -0.010730131529271603, -0.05382833257317543, -0.07798194885253906, 0.0060868472792208195, 0.00024358979135286063, -0.015402142889797688, 0.029568379744887352, 0.031239451840519905, -0.07269269973039627, 0.01591365970671177, -0.019682051613926888, -0.04447061941027641, -0.02505945973098278, 0.026655813679099083, -0.04504306986927986, -0.012618284672498703, -0.0131462337449193, 0.04481930658221245, -0.029216183349490166, -0.017027122899889946, -0.016144927591085434, -0.062093015760183334, -0.006009231321513653, -0.03803136944770813, 0.006532211322337389, 0.019533587619662285, -0.051234226673841476, 0.006083997432142496, 0.003502989886328578, 0.026476169005036354, -0.03952595591545105, -0.03690227493643761, 0.029694974422454834, 0.06317907571792603, 0.029298027977347374, 0.04562529921531677, -0.06765418499708176, -0.03319460526108742, 0.04202895611524582, -0.0129924351349473, 0.026220573112368584, -0.020606761798262596, 0.038270480930805206, -0.0073572853580117226, -0.009245054796338081, -0.020245838910341263, -0.049333542585372925, 0.005803440697491169, 0.08483202010393143, 0.0488489530980587, -0.019013790413737297, 0.019094783812761307, -0.025196151807904243, -0.023391135036945343, 0.059346746653318405, -0.05543152615427971, 0.012270413339138031, -0.03371394798159599, 0.025385437533259392, -0.025704151019454002, 0.05202319845557213, -0.010526223108172417, -0.027732951566576958, -0.003932061139494181, 0.039150550961494446, -0.013607613742351532, 0.04758497327566147, -0.010432522743940353, 0.051139701157808304, -0.011698911897838116, -0.017218410968780518, -0.005612084176391363, 0.04344947636127472, 0.00840067956596613, 0.02056482620537281, -0.025059131905436516, 0.05777748301625252, 0.011411714367568493, -0.09770802408456802, 0.039807289838790894, -0.008702949620783329, 0.01704500988125801, -0.04441125690937042, -0.05422551929950714, -0.0037788802292197943, 0.016720132902264595, -0.04087081924080849, -0.015979230403900146, -0.04586915299296379, -0.05864015221595764, 0.04125310480594635, -0.038109421730041504, 0.02842901647090912, 0.027108971029520035, -0.08459719270467758, -0.0021287277340888977, 0.05422981083393097, -0.018460603430867195, 0.0125205647200346, -0.03920583426952362, -0.03304043039679527, 0.03306030109524727, -0.0270653385668993, -0.03613956645131111, 0.05091409012675285, -0.03883952647447586, -0.03927719220519066, 0.040076714009046555, 0.022221839055418968, -0.04691464453935623, 0.07007231563329697, 0.005954090505838394, 0.009722290560603142, 0.05443070828914642, 0.0008600197616033256, 0.08429276943206787, -0.012180301360785961, -0.03552326187491417, 0.05859935283660889, 0.008672080002725124, 0.00015889626229181886, 0.019664889201521873, -0.024871015921235085, -0.010401640087366104, 0.06126074120402336, -0.04644222557544708, 0.023193586617708206, -0.032792966812849045, 0.008100119419395924, -0.061266396194696426, 0.08070504665374756, 0.036760538816452026, 0.02024533972144127, 0.002509201178327203, -0.029048476368188858, 0.03733499348163605, -0.0168027114123106, -0.044002436101436615, -0.002474983921274543, 0.007675452623516321, 0.026887910440564156, -0.05016624554991722, 0.06811530143022537, -0.03238910809159279, 0.014496189542114735, 0.02372160367667675, -0.017453908920288086, 0.00022721583081874996, 0.03251202404499054, -0.0027564235497266054, 0.01812439225614071, -0.06165856868028641, -0.04120509698987007, 0.029323263093829155, 0.02940547652542591, -0.007513293530791998, -0.03667854890227318, -0.02005745843052864, -0.050999123603105545, -0.026012204587459564, -0.011846695095300674, 0.01888052187860012, -0.049951616674661636, -0.00434890016913414, -0.027133598923683167, 0.05967432260513306, 0.05653572827577591, -0.019273320212960243, -0.008896194398403168, -0.0007297448464669287, -0.08025413751602173, 0.015815364196896553, -0.009850358590483665, -0.0038057626225054264, 0.025622688233852386, -0.011727774515748024, -0.030129753053188324, 0.05631513521075249, -0.02852102369070053, -0.010021060705184937, 0.004648890346288681, -0.02924584411084652, -0.01685466058552265, -0.030292751267552376, 0.01030072383582592, -0.024039801210165024, -0.04113296419382095, -0.025155803188681602, -0.021882012486457825, -0.01884017512202263, -0.019560806453227997, 0.007614045403897762, 0.01231164950877428, -0.02035958133637905, 0.06951773166656494, -0.01152309775352478, -0.03879585862159729, 0.042179420590400696, -0.042065754532814026, -0.03514816612005234, -0.059968218207359314, -0.047642432153224945, 0.0021904443856328726, -0.04394238069653511, -0.04549894109368324, -0.002573368838056922, -0.043519698083400726, 0.0468001589179039, 0.04805763438344002, 0.0040132757276296616, -0.01300121657550335, -0.026740090921521187, 0.025162791833281517, 0.008368965238332748, -0.028393855318427086, 0.06393350660800934, 0.0034872014075517654, -0.009689372964203358, -0.005938890390098095, -0.07845792174339294, -0.0006679421057924628, 0.09247208386659622, 0.007899010553956032, -0.006252245511859655, 0.013487744145095348, -0.02441319450736046, -0.0034276116639375687, -0.004079723730683327, 0.005995141342282295, -0.06036891043186188, 0.0047466144897043705, -0.034119442105293274, -0.0014913819031789899, 0.007548415567725897, -0.026631271466612816, -0.004029122181236744, -0.03670144081115723, 0.02028770186007023, 0.036644574254751205, 0.010985798202455044, -0.09445203095674515, 0.023316072300076485, -0.010151342488825321, 0.009581317193806171, -0.08592039346694946, 0.018181901425123215, -0.021628445014357567, -0.02024276740849018, -0.07188891619443893, -0.009497305378317833, 0.017526408657431602, -0.014810319058597088, 0.04051048308610916, 0.005453953985124826, 0.001511076814495027, -0.016055863350629807, 0.04860449209809303, -0.020792953670024872, 0.016702093183994293, -0.01901153288781643, -0.04041460528969765, 0.030518190935254097, -0.0026608866173774004, 0.050235819071531296, 0.016921130940318108, 0.04346669092774391, -0.03273521736264229, 0.022892393171787262, -0.07768867164850235, -0.009943223558366299, -0.00439736433327198, -0.004878925159573555, -0.037068452686071396, 0.005091497208923101, -0.021197613328695297, -0.010897540487349033, -0.008817288093268871, 0.014337727800011635, -0.003968411590903997 ]
<p>Related: <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/72368/why-are-most-metals-gray-silver">Why are most metals gray/silver?</a></p> <p>After reading Johannes’ impressive answer to Ali Abbasinasab question of why do most metals appear silver in color with the exception of gold (and copper), my lack of experience with quantum mechanics (I’m an undergraduate and I will take graduate quantum mechanics this coming quarter) is not enough for me to appreciate the relativistic quantum solution. What struck me most was Stefan Bischof’s statement: “Here physics has to explain more than just “is there a d valence electron”.” I took this as a challenge to see if I could explain the golden color of gold (and copper). Here is my humble attempt to answer this very question using scattering and EM approaches.</p>
g7495
[ 0.05737682059407234, 0.0589885488152504, 0.009661112911999226, -0.01763804443180561, 0.06468559801578522, 0.06380550563335419, 0.009697233326733112, -0.021949147805571556, 0.02078627608716488, 0.027673089876770973, 0.020627683028578758, 0.06534762680530548, 0.01753372885286808, 0.030397387221455574, -0.011396978050470352, -0.010735011659562588, 0.04083767905831337, -0.023532124236226082, 0.05094105005264282, 0.024583060294389725, -0.01685003750026226, -0.0029709357768297195, 0.015334156341850758, -0.061205051839351654, -0.02193385735154152, 0.026467153802514076, -0.07609712332487106, 0.008543471805751324, 0.03103526309132576, -0.015585744753479958, 0.05268621817231178, -0.004425243474543095, 0.038185641169548035, 0.0026264810003340244, -0.03874089941382408, 0.021437808871269226, 0.07306645810604095, 0.03809354826807976, -0.030226102098822594, 0.07423679530620575, -0.06763163954019547, -0.04795459657907486, -0.028609147295355797, -0.0272965207695961, 0.024045919999480247, 0.0202130489051342, -0.003473023883998394, -0.009688637219369411, -0.015926113352179527, -0.05361665040254593, -0.007467952091246843, 0.08728642761707306, 0.05999314412474632, -0.03917673975229263, -0.041399963200092316, -0.012372941710054874, 0.00793527252972126, 0.058222249150276184, 0.038215190172195435, 0.04173557087779045, 0.04497080296278, 0.07315963506698608, -0.003526926739141345, -0.045089371502399445, 0.01672428660094738, -0.0016040040645748377, 0.015049529261887074, -0.014992461539804935, 0.020490532740950584, -0.011436139233410358, -0.011398841626942158, -0.08118759095668793, -0.03851085528731346, -0.003445245325565338, 0.005605117883533239, -0.003303659614175558, 0.006432543974369764, 0.05265365540981293, 0.07781068235635757, 0.011074401438236237, -0.04538602754473686, -0.004889937583357096, 0.06086234003305435, -0.0024735727347433567, 0.03768729791045189, 0.006483911536633968, -0.038578011095523834, -0.028893904760479927, 0.018861955031752586, -0.0049149529077112675, 0.044558051973581314, -0.0007286851177923381, 0.03024279698729515, 0.008438930846750736, -0.02141888067126274, 0.02992536686360836, -0.018365653231739998, 0.014452622272074223, 0.016337260603904724, -0.053420037031173706, 0.007467248942703009, 0.002228428842499852, -0.013090105727314949, 0.0179938655346632, 0.00895080529153347, -0.0652124285697937, 0.04010602459311485, 0.04292164742946625, -0.046987440437078476, 0.025967435911297798, -0.10179812461137772, -0.005044441670179367, -0.022347941994667053, 0.018467983230948448, -0.0909639224410057, 0.007222273387014866, 0.05172404274344444, -0.04155515134334564, 0.019464608281850815, 0.07074476033449173, -0.03729318827390671, 0.012368038296699524, 0.02548196166753769, -0.010880951769649982, -0.00012712640454992652, -0.008985285647213459, -0.0069812447763979435, -0.049736812710762024, 0.02972031757235527, -0.024079924449324608, -0.009235893376171589, 0.02126971259713173, 0.0019412433030083776, 0.0265430249273777, 0.03243497759103775, -0.05291225388646126, -0.05364088714122772, 0.014518195763230324, -0.03990863263607025, 0.019642457365989685, 0.010704409331083298, -0.028087778016924858, -0.022217461839318275, -0.021011171862483025, -0.028440779075026512, 0.009376290254294872, -0.04028026759624481, -0.033204663544893265, 0.017341673374176025, -0.010170523077249527, 0.02548712119460106, -0.0503995418548584, 0.0378541424870491, -0.04790440574288368, -0.06792562454938889, -0.028230134397745132, -0.02914193645119667, -0.020367976278066635, 0.007595770061016083, 0.034551143646240234, 0.02706446498632431, -0.04973501339554787, -0.06057069078087807, 0.026058126240968704, 0.03542374074459076, -0.005383187439292669, -0.019821492955088615, -0.09366878867149353, -0.005233819130808115, -0.06264585256576538, -0.021498462185263634, -0.009711701422929764, -0.009734046645462513, 0.011232179589569569, -0.005885227583348751, 0.05050517991185188, 0.02275700494647026, -0.05335264280438423, 0.04684736952185631, 0.010902954265475273, 0.008916309103369713, -0.05182991921901703, 0.07071088999509811, -0.040464334189891815, 0.029587576165795326, -0.008920806460082531, 0.009484236128628254, 0.019443536177277565, 0.009634596295654774, 0.03251290321350098, -0.03592146560549736, -0.004056100733578205, 0.031509846448898315, -0.019610507413744926, 0.058945804834365845, -0.0032798375468701124, -0.03527098149061203, 0.048948392271995544, -0.031359121203422546, 0.037584975361824036, 0.006179207470268011, -0.006519176531583071, -0.09851400554180145, 0.02961895428597927, 0.04103761911392212, -0.011666407808661461, -0.04612985625863075, -0.020238609984517097, 0.053710006177425385, -0.025188473984599113, 0.016814667731523514, -0.003133956342935562, 0.019511578604578972, 0.020374977961182594, -0.034286826848983765, -0.005463687237352133, 0.028203509747982025, 0.027593130245804787, 0.0007883430807851255, 0.08418337255716324, -0.015204520896077156, -0.022077616304159164, -0.025998640805482864, 0.05840914696455002, 0.030674457550048828, 0.04351364076137543, -0.0671856626868248, -0.036037739366292953, 0.008209236897528172, -0.001026448211632669, -0.03281966969370842, 0.07077052444219589, 0.000508917379193008, -0.01107678934931755, 0.04861453175544739, 0.008083712309598923, 0.008484725840389729, -0.02190193347632885, 0.03610154986381531, 0.006868790369480848, -0.05861186981201172, 0.02694268710911274, -0.029473159462213516, 0.06906305998563766, -0.03125637024641037, 0.04585348069667816, -0.008465234190225601, -0.04889744147658348, -0.007318082265555859, -0.004347858484834433, 0.024147486314177513, -0.004097545053809881, -0.021135807037353516, -0.0690617710351944, 0.014837410300970078, -0.0628662183880806, -0.014243618585169315, 0.030646812170743942, 0.021936114877462387, 0.01356861088424921, 0.02352607250213623, -0.029812157154083252, -0.019689345732331276, 0.027513790875673294, -0.08843156695365906, 0.043612606823444366, -0.01597696542739868, -0.00193584687076509, -0.0529027134180069, -0.011784008704125881, -0.027110179886221886, 0.027172062546014786, -0.027744093909859657, -0.010055373422801495, -0.0025973105803132057, -0.045469559729099274, -0.005547362379729748, -0.014154324308037758, 0.02137361466884613, 0.01360328309237957, -0.051001306623220444, 0.013874360360205173, -0.038106877356767654, -0.03414054214954376, 0.022886717692017555, 0.026860790327191353, 0.0642358735203743, -0.017923740670084953, 0.032284192740917206, 0.012430138885974884, 0.020659077912569046, 0.044176969677209854, -0.0011221157619729638, 0.025277070701122284, -0.0587780699133873, 0.027636848390102386, 0.03772851824760437, -0.013932081870734692, -0.01358757633715868, 0.037027642130851746, -0.018821734935045242, 0.02038259617984295, 0.007406281773000956, 0.04360869899392128, 0.03323899954557419, 0.018767068162560463, -0.01880345679819584, 0.03363749757409096, -0.0258940476924181, -0.03420305997133255, 0.010765982791781425, 0.02258259430527687, 0.05476580187678337, 0.007287004496902227, -0.06802821159362793, 0.003306022612378001, 0.006757586728781462, 0.009239080362021923, 0.0070348093286156654, -0.03349704667925835, 0.01811012253165245, -0.004660641774535179, 0.028055936098098755, -0.060317132622003555, 0.05777100473642349, 0.017779115587472916, -0.015967436134815216, 0.032849524170160294, -0.05694194883108139, -0.03410919010639191, 0.00981888361275196, 0.01902942731976509, -0.03853397071361542, 0.043995920568704605, -0.03831547498703003, -0.03715118020772934, 0.007994508370757103, 0.016028234735131264, 0.04817607253789902, 0.03429173678159714, 0.030796902254223824, -0.06530070304870605, -0.04163157939910889, 0.02287747524678707, -0.003244362771511078, -0.0010088817216455936, -0.001474647899158299, -0.028587685897946358, 0.03234606608748436, 0.0031326059252023697, -0.004941372200846672, 0.04814020171761513, 0.044647712260484695, 0.025320041924715042, -0.01580391824245453, -0.019583972170948982, 0.017074810341000557, -0.002622429747134447, 0.00830572098493576, 0.01881667971611023, 0.009486699476838112, -0.028621332719922066, 0.04014436528086662, -0.10328100621700287, 0.02184125781059265, -0.02173578180372715, -0.0009477213607169688, 0.03642691299319267, 0.049951232969760895, -0.0009398694382980466, 0.04337822273373604, 0.005434844177216291, 0.010629580356180668, 0.03045414201915264, 0.034048400819301605, -0.007946953177452087, -0.0357377715408802, 0.07590499520301819, -0.02407253533601761, -0.010510703548789024, -0.028929637745022774, 0.056616704910993576, 0.05471489951014519, 0.0073723094537854195, -0.0014211864909157157, -0.01594451442360878, -0.00892348401248455, -0.01092859823256731, -0.0537295937538147, -0.08592000603675842, -0.0016223957063630223, -0.014791060239076614, -0.026015497744083405, 0.03446067497134209, -0.022156748920679092, 0.01911894604563713, 0.046178702265024185, 0.00024739783839322627, 0.023486487567424774, 0.015685586258769035, -0.04134437069296837, -0.009846987202763557, 0.008161434903740883, -0.029944753274321556, -0.026382694020867348, 0.03365534916520119, -0.021340200677514076, -0.0830313116312027, 0.003947096411138773, -0.014802836813032627, -0.03860197588801384, 0.06543921679258347, 0.018736936151981354, -0.035819198936223984, -0.04074132815003395, 0.024170897901058197, 0.03422562777996063, -0.011252069845795631, 0.004436633549630642, -0.02093101292848587, 0.06079017370939255, -0.015582083724439144, 0.04418330639600754, 0.00016151701856870204, 0.047213271260261536, 0.015430470928549767, -0.052282992750406265, 0.042626939713954926, -0.015383266843855381, 0.026678046211600304, 0.03875812515616417, -0.028591172769665718, 0.018009280785918236, -0.0010822435142472386, -0.06695626676082611, 0.0417599193751812, -0.03781316429376602, 0.004988435190171003, -0.01235357765108347, 0.05768584832549095, 0.0592678003013134, 0.029149213805794716, 0.011685194447636604, 0.004776389803737402, -0.013474770821630955, -0.008254637941718102, -0.003748280229046941, -0.021774880588054657, -0.02141674980521202, -0.014600447379052639, 0.007257197052240372, -0.0023667544592171907, -0.023000938817858696, 0.032019324600696564, 0.017268791794776917, -0.02183316834270954, -0.03757145255804062, 0.033397745341062546, 0.012151218950748444, 0.08221310377120972, -0.031966280192136765, -0.02229820191860199, -0.029993796721100807, -0.002708862069994211, 0.06940599530935287, -0.011179443448781967, 0.0350516214966774, -0.009164836257696152, -0.073860764503479, -0.022464070469141006, -0.08514764904975891, 0.055506110191345215, 0.01800393871963024, -0.0501752607524395, 0.09250879287719727, -0.018126508221030235, -0.002158552873879671, -0.029514065012335777, 0.0011488451855257154, 0.0025496110320091248, -0.02887977659702301, -0.02916974574327469, 0.05363450571894646, -0.007071495521813631, -0.04765279218554497, 0.03604105859994888, -0.057840634137392044, 0.08328060060739517, -0.035611722618341446, -0.057700492441654205, 0.0129358796402812, -0.08382967859506607, 0.000753793166950345, -0.010934829711914062, -0.08783704787492752, 0.030143557116389275, -0.014242319390177727, -0.04739159718155861, 0.0395946130156517, -0.04186844825744629, -0.055468637496232986, 0.04667321965098381, 0.013154287822544575, -0.022566692903637886, 0.007621503435075283, -0.011411051265895367, 0.020961374044418335, -0.033014729619026184, 0.03469892963767052, 0.016721932217478752, -0.021169252693653107, -0.037657368928194046, 0.026058340445160866, 0.014236892573535442, 0.047453444451093674, -0.04965769872069359, -0.05619273707270622, 0.05150216445326805, -0.01192909013479948, -0.01769442670047283, -0.01952540874481201, -0.008200600743293762, 0.00020295345166232437, -0.019691890105605125, 0.012625478208065033, 0.02943287044763565, -0.0591927096247673, 0.002586499322205782, 0.0740995854139328, 0.03879264369606972, 0.02469426952302456, 0.03633236885070801, 0.06019291654229164, -0.009113828651607037, 0.05142837390303612, -0.014523596502840519, -0.003535787807777524, 0.05527152121067047, -0.03525621443986893, 0.07602833211421967, 0.040762677788734436, 0.030653638765215874, 0.0013240899424999952, 0.05470806360244751, -0.012435965240001678, 0.009435522370040417, 0.07124128937721252, -0.01779140904545784, 0.04127225652337074, -0.03985714167356491, 0.0010071417782455683, 0.030276622623205185, 0.02787839248776436, -0.007041508797556162, 0.03523770347237587, -0.002855300670489669, -0.015799837186932564, -0.057713914662599564, 0.004981701727956533, 0.01121156383305788, 0.023376256227493286, 0.01788666658103466, 0.030522063374519348, -0.01839849166572094, 0.015919389203190804, 0.0008453118498437107, -0.022463412955403328, -0.010673409327864647, 0.051427699625492096, 0.01687299646437168, -0.04959770292043686, 0.03224925324320793, 0.03998522460460663, 0.026539389044046402, 0.06378471106290817, 0.024164613336324692, -0.021715695038437843, -0.06641758233308792, -0.04661565274000168, -0.07783027738332748, 0.03179420530796051, 0.026110094040632248, 0.000015211591744446196, 0.03695184364914894, -0.08462776243686676, 0.019886065274477005, 0.013331709429621696, -0.001387429772876203, -0.02102969028055668, -0.04067869856953621, 0.009324070997536182, -0.008641218766570091, 0.035870857536792755, -0.02718467079102993, -0.047449227422475815, -0.020878462120890617, 0.037218429148197174, -0.01610943116247654, -0.02487916871905327, -0.017593076452612877, 0.022848743945360184, -0.0275130458176136, 0.021525833755731583, 0.04746637120842934, 0.06019004061818123, 0.042797669768333435, -0.0234114658087492, -0.020952295511960983, 0.03044533170759678, 0.0052171386778354645, -0.0663604661822319, 0.05157364159822464, -0.03373533487319946, -0.0029101306572556496, -0.030294980853796005, -0.05891551822423935, -0.03393927216529846, 0.012864731252193451, -0.0015482837334275246, -0.0010993253672495484, 0.018623361364006996, -0.05573271960020065, -0.014002894051373005, 0.004784978460520506, -0.006782081909477711, 0.05733272433280945, -0.07149437814950943, 0.035764772444963455, 0.06889273971319199, -0.04617299884557724, -0.003713402897119522, -0.030248461291193962, 0.027369936928153038, 0.012998674064874649, 0.009413364343345165, -0.0011113323271274567, 0.01927291229367256, -0.04798513278365135, -0.013471375219523907, 0.013559462502598763, -0.05845486745238304, -0.04986067861318588, 0.04217391461133957, 0.008928493596613407, 0.015137268230319023, -0.0038243685849010944, 0.06811841577291489, -0.04580759257078171, -0.05096627399325371, 0.014989477582275867, 0.047258343547582626, -0.05600379779934883, 0.014748002402484417, -0.021679645404219627, 0.02231396734714508, 0.006589480210095644, -0.0032005126122385263, 0.010611512698233128, 0.048972103744745255, -0.053267981857061386, -0.044652312994003296, 0.016655586659908295, 0.0006135256844572723, -0.012325969524681568, -0.03344007581472397, 0.06291066110134125, 0.021822452545166016, -0.02759275771677494, 0.014767793007194996, 0.020727839320898056, -0.046666219830513, -0.009252181276679039, 0.01092506293207407, -0.027950741350650787, 0.011862012557685375, -0.033880747854709625, -0.008203309960663319, -0.003702552057802677, 0.031940095126628876, -0.005232708528637886, 0.017457757145166397, 0.036815740168094635, 0.014305406250059605, -0.035099804401397705, -0.030297933146357536, -0.06160639598965645, -0.045863281935453415, 0.03579533472657204, -0.03135324642062187, 0.04721192270517349, -0.010426213964819908, -0.042086776345968246, 0.01528916321694851, -0.05115099251270294, 0.021068956702947617, -0.023235682398080826, -0.0023554041981697083, 0.021900657564401627, 0.08213292807340622, -0.020972494035959244, -0.048860687762498856, -0.013836693949997425, -0.030656829476356506, -0.014731811359524727, -0.0011602407321333885, 0.009011738933622837, -0.022092560306191444, 0.016202125698328018, -0.03319958969950676, -0.03641432151198387, 0.036205440759658813, 0.0070297494530677795, 0.027229851111769676, -0.022410040721297264, 0.029836922883987427, -0.03694874420762062, -0.024421075358986855, -0.009306319989264011, -0.028711451217532158, 0.017215494066476822, 0.058930885046720505, 0.01389087550342083, 0.05694304406642914, 0.026163741946220398, 0.0005599456490017474, -0.06762511283159256, 0.016105711460113525, -0.045132678002119064, -0.03234102949500084, 0.016700247302651405, -0.0327763557434082, -0.009693971835076809, 0.024530712515115738, 0.009699191898107529, -0.006989410147070885, 0.0019842421170324087, 0.005481172353029251, -0.015371821820735931, 0.0013582137180492282, 0.015048927627503872, -0.042492181062698364, -0.045887868851423264, -0.04468955099582672, 0.016629289835691452, -0.006761496886610985, -0.024434398859739304, -0.0011812064331024885, 0.02542756125330925, -0.023803070187568665, -0.07218784838914871, -0.1021992489695549, 0.054937347769737244, -0.03284185752272606, 0.040491845458745956, 0.061403531581163406, -0.06993492692708969, 0.09253410995006561, 0.010970047675073147, 0.004629974253475666, 0.022796375676989555, -0.03544940799474716, 0.00040184383396990597, -0.0402546152472496, 0.06252709031105042, -0.042438410222530365, -0.04760917276144028, -0.028186578303575516, -0.0327257364988327 ]
<p>Why is there an absolute entropy? Given any non-discrete probability distribution, we don't really have an absolute entropy because the entropy depends on the parametrization of the distribution (e.g. Beta vs. Beta-prime) which was arbitrarily chosen. Another way to put it is that instead of entropies we only have <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kullback%E2%80%93Leibler_divergence" rel="nofollow">Kullback–Leibler (KL) divergences</a> aka relative entropies. So, why isn't there a physics analogue to KL-divergence? Just as we have relativistic velocity, which has some properties, why don't we also have relative entropies, which have some properties? Instead of saying the absolute entropy of the universe increases, why don't we say that the relative entropy given our prior belief of the universe increases?</p> <p>Alternatively, what is the relation between entropy and number of microstates when the physical system is continuous, and how do we "count microstates"?</p>
g7496
[ 0.016285602003335953, 0.026238087564706802, -0.0007450779667124152, -0.0604315809905529, 0.005221586674451828, 0.009217427112162113, 0.004437862429767847, 0.024055466055870056, -0.04106840118765831, -0.07117269188165665, -0.03558780997991562, -0.05178132280707359, 0.04516887664794922, 0.044729866087436676, 0.018072394654154778, -0.00035497749922797084, 0.024668114259839058, -0.014113059267401695, 0.023567907512187958, 0.03332362323999405, -0.04376141354441643, -0.031066959723830223, 0.048854585736989975, -0.050001513212919235, 0.06625194102525711, -0.025982601568102837, 0.019179249182343483, -0.041014332324266434, -0.005802105646580458, 0.011444659903645515, 0.03268907591700554, 0.011352785862982273, 0.032524123787879944, -0.03396100550889969, 0.05604160949587822, -0.044215742498636246, 0.012509994208812714, 0.0017597534460946918, 0.030659407377243042, -0.05471087619662285, -0.009128602221608162, 0.02395988442003727, -0.07876736670732498, -0.014149442315101624, 0.0004342016763985157, 0.002510813996195793, 0.002404309343546629, -0.0015215488383546472, 0.011845468543469906, 0.010206001810729504, 0.01773986406624317, 0.009963009506464005, 0.043851569294929504, 0.042141206562519073, 0.04436720907688141, -0.00801147986203432, 0.02804739959537983, -0.01990765519440174, 0.026423834264278412, 0.01838657259941101, 0.006470011081546545, -0.04022355005145073, 0.0038304910995066166, 0.030304882675409317, 0.05085056647658348, -0.024833185598254204, -0.01966170407831669, -0.020984631031751633, 0.02919994294643402, 0.061487775295972824, -0.00033903340226970613, -0.023966120555996895, -0.05157771334052086, -0.024107830598950386, 0.0060785128735005856, 0.0017085574800148606, 0.0026807563845068216, -0.008245619013905525, 0.06055213138461113, -0.01945403218269348, -0.04808932915329933, -0.02236032858490944, 0.05898788571357727, -0.008781319484114647, 0.07851521670818329, -0.04063299670815468, -0.01774296909570694, -0.036147281527519226, 0.028098590672016144, 0.008253457024693489, -0.03496765345335007, 0.007914839312434196, 0.03799321502447128, 0.039772361516952515, -0.0408148318529129, -0.018449896946549416, -0.04860147461295128, 0.0332738496363163, 0.014536959119141102, 0.03526394069194794, 0.02987099625170231, 0.02300211228430271, 0.07295920699834824, -0.004413575865328312, -0.006514523644000292, -0.06099272519350052, -0.022504577413201332, -0.0162651464343071, -0.005120413843542337, 0.03667210042476654, -0.016810525208711624, -0.021512437611818314, -0.030997036024928093, -0.037961509078741074, -0.0005804552347399294, 0.03129884600639343, 0.04596835374832153, -0.04791642352938652, -0.04659275710582733, 0.034038182348012924, 0.0430198535323143, 0.05729604884982109, -0.0015882709994912148, 0.07632607221603394, -0.031440701335668564, 0.0016199066303670406, 0.031846724450588226, 0.0017713694833219051, 0.0009985535871237516, -0.03870100900530815, 0.06630612909793854, 0.00704028457403183, -0.016918273642659187, 0.024828506633639336, 0.0034707249142229557, 0.007925961166620255, -0.02716829627752304, 0.02076699584722519, -0.01916707120835781, 0.052319664508104324, -0.041810374706983566, -0.019744668155908585, 0.0072434707544744015, 0.0074773808009922504, -0.03387509658932686, 0.0029855570755898952, -0.11186591535806656, 0.002511524362489581, 0.0007972787716425955, 0.02512967213988304, 0.07567553222179413, 0.01628161408007145, -0.003201819024980068, 0.007163965608924627, -0.01877562701702118, 0.02497897855937481, 0.06384343653917313, -0.018554115667939186, -0.020563248544931412, 0.03107631951570511, 0.029361294582486153, 0.006905491463840008, 0.016797272488474846, -0.03164080157876015, -0.05565803870558739, 0.08026303350925446, 0.007496077101677656, -0.037778839468955994, 0.04045872017741203, -0.03442417085170746, -0.038625720888376236, -0.0006454078247770667, -0.049680743366479874, 0.022052379325032234, 0.03311624750494957, 0.023735612630844116, -0.00655395956709981, 0.003734198398888111, 0.00504732271656394, -0.022951949387788773, -0.0257672481238842, 0.023276804015040398, 0.0677405297756195, -0.01018961425870657, -0.015797672793269157, -0.004841584712266922, -0.04396111145615578, 0.02041660062968731, -0.04320068657398224, -0.03440684452652931, 0.026654530316591263, -0.06517107784748077, -0.04405532032251358, 0.016078701242804527, 0.03270099312067032, 0.0009649123530834913, -0.029397593811154366, -0.039826855063438416, -0.034993696957826614, 0.03977847099304199, 0.04924721270799637, 0.015828680247068405, 0.008324159309267998, -0.017885325476527214, 0.06974270939826965, 0.0438019260764122, -0.04175857827067375, -0.017619412392377853, 0.04452531039714813, -0.009624463506042957, 0.06080944463610649, -0.13045190274715424, 0.020067140460014343, -0.014973059296607971, -0.0007829719688743353, -0.022712115198373795, 0.0529172383248806, -0.007510097231715918, -0.0036219980102032423, 0.023602241650223732, 0.01875278539955616, 0.0009984461357817054, 0.054300930351018906, 0.09092653542757034, -0.021538829430937767, 0.022862406447529793, -0.07561326026916504, 0.028697768226265907, 0.01963312365114689, 0.024799078702926636, -0.07203955948352814, -0.011539338156580925, 0.05736264958977699, 0.04154958575963974, 0.04450119659304619, 0.03656900301575661, 0.015706242993474007, 0.07309752702713013, -0.01263753417879343, 0.018328946083784103, 0.04891713708639145, -0.052295833826065063, -0.05627390742301941, 0.0922825038433075, 0.02792212925851345, -0.05777234584093094, 0.01917346939444542, 0.0018076124833896756, -0.03423229604959488, -0.0006762101547792554, -0.033862266689538956, -0.01181465107947588, -0.02014894224703312, -0.038148023188114166, 0.04716465249657631, -0.009935575537383556, 0.0023349111434072256, 0.04564381018280983, -0.06455764919519424, -0.026390671730041504, 0.006278547458350658, -0.012151467613875866, 0.039500802755355835, -0.023078957572579384, -0.015396200120449066, 0.04622618108987808, -0.02675003558397293, 0.04459215700626373, -0.028157202526926994, -0.035436440259218216, 0.012908842414617538, 0.02578818053007126, -0.037721555680036545, 0.04142254963517189, -0.005749328527599573, 0.040945056825876236, 0.059359658509492874, -0.058725956827402115, 0.01890222355723381, -0.02274290658533573, -0.030009208247065544, 0.020626552402973175, -0.029573887586593628, -0.014669169671833515, 0.017639661207795143, -0.0974489077925682, 0.03484306111931801, -0.022737465798854828, -0.007543085142970085, -0.028671596199274063, 0.04578576236963272, -0.005264369770884514, 0.0029233810491859913, 0.012530958279967308, -0.005515044555068016, 0.03454994782805443, 0.01508637610822916, -0.024675726890563965, -0.051433563232421875, 0.04745092615485191, 0.012478996999561787, -0.0014965925365686417, 0.005764506757259369, -0.02236873470246792, -0.04477476328611374, 0.08633789420127869, -0.026145916432142258, -0.028170576319098473, -0.002989746630191803, -0.009223650209605694, -0.055426646023988724, 0.037042610347270966, -0.017467273399233818, 0.04355676472187042, -0.03093023970723152, 0.02295711450278759, 0.008607558906078339, 0.077442467212677, 0.037587713450193405, -0.019849473610520363, 0.037705183029174805, 0.007331575732678175, 0.006152282934635878, -0.009823102504014969, 0.060112364590168, 0.038788627833127975, -0.06832334399223328, 0.0028716984670609236, -0.02462402731180191, -0.044914182275533676, 0.019090550020337105, -0.03838851675391197, 0.0770551934838295, -0.001978130079805851, -0.08108824491500854, -0.06353899091482162, -0.039866846054792404, -0.05266154929995537, 0.026531532406806946, 0.031961288303136826, -0.004173422697931528, 0.022350186482071877, -0.06001076102256775, 0.0535232275724411, -0.04341341182589531, 0.06986527144908905, 0.02505139261484146, 0.008264816366136074, 0.004111569840461016, 0.008877442218363285, 0.03486054390668869, 0.002617265796288848, 0.038761746138334274, 0.018258050084114075, -0.002575347665697336, 0.03345271199941635, 0.00211624288931489, -0.03706393763422966, 0.03249511122703552, -0.02538224868476391, -0.010876976884901524, -0.01759791187942028, 0.006127659697085619, -0.034075018018484116, 0.0021748263388872147, 0.05361592024564743, 0.0035998469684273005, 0.0014791992725804448, 0.03792058303952217, 0.007242137100547552, 0.03989066928625107, -0.0515662357211113, -0.061718229204416275, -0.005494457669556141, 0.07579152286052704, -0.02911212481558323, 0.07425334304571152, 0.034322358667850494, -0.03143996745347977, -0.036169495433568954, 0.07181727886199951, 0.007393131498247385, 0.03757590427994728, 0.014552322216331959, -0.005319805815815926, -0.03296152874827385, -0.07546550035476685, 0.009426776319742203, -0.05167143791913986, -0.027737393975257874, 0.04903920367360115, -0.010693028569221497, -0.004263927228748798, -0.026487911120057106, -0.023502906784415245, -0.016536548733711243, 0.026981830596923828, 0.0015619437908753753, 0.02816435880959034, 0.0655696913599968, 0.02601022832095623, -0.009961319155991077, -0.04180619493126869, 0.03691020607948303, 0.014733847230672836, 0.007485651411116123, 0.0072459629736840725, -0.00017087283777073026, -0.012696519494056702, -0.028625596314668655, 0.053062375634908676, -0.0035337500739842653, 0.017190691083669662, -0.07741544395685196, -0.011695148423314095, 0.012114408425986767, -0.002807046752423048, -0.08579069375991821, 0.07084403187036514, 0.0162948165088892, -0.004598632454872131, 0.0007917138864286244, 0.00004666699533117935, -0.002470204373821616, -0.025237033143639565, 0.043762389570474625, 0.0566822774708271, 0.04109439253807068, -0.032264258712530136, -0.026918476447463036, 0.006703173741698265, 0.032793670892715454, 0.029715752229094505, 0.03983357921242714, 0.032945021986961365, 0.010846441611647606, -0.0875796228647232, 0.04645979031920433, -0.011095657013356686, -0.02061924710869789, 0.046308133751153946, -0.02021951414644718, 0.0034327595494687557, 0.020074373111128807, -0.04140433669090271, 0.08028773963451385, -0.018140869215130806, -0.017021501436829567, -0.06073550879955292, 0.017799679189920425, -0.007114681415259838, 0.04087342321872711, -0.03434864431619644, -0.042339421808719635, -0.00005566371328313835, -0.0054268548265099525, -0.029188906773924828, 0.03964200243353844, 0.033355239778757095, 0.06387899070978165, -0.06299000978469849, 0.051169950515031815, 0.054656390100717545, -0.057935625314712524, 0.027682041749358177, -0.006139857228845358, -0.045714907348155975, 0.027979975566267967, -0.06588146835565567, -0.026736387982964516, 0.024213682860136032, 0.034332238137722015, -0.005129446275532246, 0.018706925213336945, 0.0063318368047475815, 0.022777652367949486, 0.03030853159725666, -0.03425218164920807, -0.014510830864310265, -0.03362777456641197, -0.0512770414352417, -0.020125750452280045, 0.006115984171628952, 0.00641136709600687, 0.048781491816043854, 0.04695259407162666, -0.03454824909567833, -0.039566121995449066, -0.02088293433189392, -0.027192648500204086, 0.008942969143390656, 0.025678858160972595, 0.057194069027900696, 0.002127500483766198, 0.0036646525841206312, 0.025675656273961067, -0.042074572294950485, 0.03364120051264763, 0.0021748975850641727, -0.044099707156419754, -0.07647804170846939, 0.018438471481204033, -0.009541873820126057, -0.056970853358507156, 0.014301306568086147, 0.020979544147849083, 0.04759982228279114, 0.011613287962973118, -0.0163937546312809, 0.005699687637388706, -0.01388924103230238, 0.00095560954650864, -0.02287266217172146, -0.028535375371575356, 0.0005264520295895636, -0.0015811817720532417, -0.011792306788265705, -0.07017117738723755, 0.005612140521407127, -0.04775046557188034, 0.006082533858716488, 0.029684150591492653, 0.012707220390439034, 0.016708331182599068, 0.00012567028170451522, -0.019224507734179497, -0.050814248621463776, -0.03479288890957832, -0.019821103662252426, 0.05712748318910599, 0.022709224373102188, 0.0193348191678524, 0.01870790496468544, -0.04270780086517334, -0.01797623373568058, 0.008264074102044106, -0.022621123120188713, 0.03558989614248276, 0.013209487311542034, 0.03340303525328636, -0.005869165528565645, -0.0023337292950600386, -0.019147349521517754, 0.03418399393558502, -0.005961280316114426, -0.011359456926584244, -0.007956482470035553, 0.003664286807179451, 0.014186299405992031, -0.05060455575585365, -0.026522498577833176, 0.027045881375670433, 0.006101132836192846, -0.02722982130944729, -0.04419086128473282, 0.02742486074566841, 0.002326653338968754, 0.04481377825140953, -0.043762702494859695, 0.020350409671664238, -0.03089738078415394, -0.013921535573899746, 0.027830034494400024, -0.010957195423543453, -0.013872897252440453, -0.09880556911230087, 0.014338251203298569, -0.06544511765241623, 0.0030467023607343435, 0.03967127576470375, 0.007708224467933178, -0.00006544749339809641, 0.010073412209749222, 0.017308633774518967, 0.009042109362781048, -0.00186061835847795, -0.05860177055001259, -0.10047157853841782, -0.02929249405860901, -0.04383360967040062, -0.05390377342700958, -0.019917991012334824, 0.024117786437273026, 0.017744962126016617, -0.022463081404566765, 0.02758597955107689, -0.0513138510286808, -0.027022328227758408, -0.03358890861272812, 0.007905794307589531, 0.0014766599051654339, 0.02795921266078949, -0.040179476141929626, -0.005130533594638109, -0.07516027987003326, -0.003775227814912796, 0.011947454884648323, -0.02018345706164837, -0.005546162836253643, -0.057171884924173355, -0.037906281650066376, -0.02804514206945896, 0.04070573300123215, -0.024980442598462105, -0.036639049649238586, 0.0037851238157600164, -0.01653902418911457, 0.025694087147712708, 0.00885185319930315, 0.01492219790816307, -0.022867653518915176, 0.004904625471681356, -0.0020060897804796696, -0.013143865391612053, 0.00758271524682641, -0.020253799855709076, -0.06116814911365509, 0.02450418286025524, -0.012626919895410538, 0.04502158239483833, 0.03159921243786812, -0.014242224395275116, 0.023573338985443115, -0.050050485879182816, 0.05496307834982872, 0.03222298249602318, -0.07614847272634506, 0.05595272406935692, 0.04858565330505371, 0.07722669839859009, -0.013048600405454636, 0.014811632223427296, 0.029988344758749008, 0.05616854131221771, 0.009165371768176556, 0.045953359454870224, -0.02840452827513218, -0.0023599346168339252, 0.060399118810892105, 0.016585277393460274, -0.006663782987743616, -0.027690991759300232, 0.04825834184885025, 0.025472570210695267, 0.053969305008649826, -0.027540169656276703, -0.0007420373149216175, 0.009438447654247284, -0.035806797444820404, 0.0037707649171352386, -0.0031857392750680447, -0.05238699913024902, -0.013391578570008278, -0.03314123675227165, -0.015212907455861568, 0.07884321361780167, 0.0021413320209831, 0.015142565593123436, 0.0034237350337207317, -0.05339714139699936, 0.005765039473772049, 0.0014588350895792246, -0.028011897578835487, -0.02702932246029377, -0.011755380779504776, 0.04233095794916153, 0.06081925705075264, -0.021021287888288498, 0.019799787551164627, -0.02520686760544777, 0.023487985134124756, -0.02059646137058735, -0.04065205901861191, 0.029276909306645393, -0.04306919127702713, 0.0011776856845244765, 0.008859798312187195, 0.019152652472257614, 0.0270504392683506, -0.0053174421191215515, -0.04633639380335808, 0.058600060641765594, -0.007944301702082157, 0.004478015936911106, -0.03793463855981827, 0.07196737825870514, -0.06847809255123138, -0.01596304401755333, 0.004656297620385885, -0.04166065528988838, 0.00896625965833664, -0.024119718000292778, -0.008907895535230637, -0.015822788700461388, -0.00696667330339551, 0.023352129384875298, 0.08839410543441772, 0.012768280692398548, 0.02301386557519436, -0.08720093965530396, 0.04909629002213478, 0.02913266234099865, 0.021432962268590927, 0.008109754882752895, 0.053972262889146805, 0.004030219744890928, 0.01750294119119644, -0.004875650629401207, -0.07544869929552078, 0.010790245607495308, -0.04034680128097534, -0.03562241420149803, 0.06364913284778595, -0.020573345944285393, -0.011024130508303642, -0.029881229624152184, -0.05132574960589409, -0.004487423226237297, 0.009531792253255844, -0.05414678156375885, 0.018425295129418373, -0.0462847538292408, -0.0007117058848962188, -0.049406975507736206, -0.022721057757735252, -0.04648135229945183, -0.021863173693418503, -0.028610188513994217, 0.025495868176221848, 0.01622297428548336, -0.01617383398115635, 0.053216367959976196, -0.01766802743077278, 0.006377775222063065, -0.09690799564123154, 0.03559819981455803, 0.06398164480924606, 0.03175788372755051, 0.027553072199225426, -0.0038906510453671217, -0.01002170704305172, -0.012993821874260902, 0.0738108828663826, 0.028434831649065018, 0.026198217645287514, -0.06358691304922104, -0.029819292947649956, 0.024623695760965347, 0.045034922659397125, -0.0372438058257103, -0.0527457557618618, -0.018451014533638954, -0.004053568467497826, -0.013206110335886478, 0.05592043697834015, 0.013446947559714317, 0.04945342615246773, -0.004707867279648781, -0.011556459590792656, 0.003952800761908293, -0.04185101389884949, -0.05930640548467636, -0.0330425500869751, 0.011547799222171307, -0.015133053064346313, -0.038331884890794754, -0.03924824297428131, 0.012032865546643734 ]
<p>I am working on a game involving flying and steering a paper airplane for WP7. I want the plane to fly just like how normal paper airplanes fly (see this game for an example <a href="http://armorgames.com/play/7598/flight" rel="nofollow">http://armorgames.com/play/7598/flight</a>) but I can't seem to find an equation for how paper airplanes fly.</p> <p>Anyone have any experience with this? In my game now, it just follows the usual motion for an object in a vacuum, which makes for some flight, but it doesn't feel perfect, and traveling at a slight downward angle makes you lose speed, which isn't right.</p> <p>Thoughts?</p>
g7497
[ 0.014337913133203983, 0.0320914126932621, -0.012644622474908829, 0.03512408956885338, 0.033459730446338654, 0.016605619341135025, -0.04331532493233681, -0.031326256692409515, -0.01964716613292694, -0.01946919783949852, 0.038280803710222244, -0.00041797320591285825, 0.03482206538319588, 0.038555536419153214, 0.02211589366197586, 0.020120365545153618, -0.007392097730189562, -0.012048793025314808, 0.0019630652386695147, 0.03450673073530197, 0.08205313980579376, -0.01163927186280489, 0.030348680913448334, -0.01643913798034191, -0.022209983319044113, -0.021250734105706215, -0.1115211471915245, -0.0592520572245121, -0.05549777299165726, -0.018769245594739914, -0.008040512911975384, 0.004449817817658186, 0.032479286193847656, -0.013610183261334896, -0.013142050243914127, 0.021108906716108322, -0.028070969507098198, 0.03240680694580078, 0.03220938518643379, -0.012187549844384193, -0.021124549210071564, -0.016652286052703857, -0.058567605912685394, 0.04241760075092316, 0.07125897705554962, 0.016423916444182396, -0.009425311349332333, -0.011595255695283413, -0.011535895988345146, -0.012747910805046558, -0.05526590347290039, 0.014031590893864632, -0.026297884061932564, -0.016941366717219353, -0.048662759363651276, 0.0011873777257278562, 0.05282096192240715, -0.03961919993162155, 0.05948527529835701, 0.004709744360297918, -0.04506487399339676, -0.00007969440775923431, 0.014447377994656563, 0.014746977016329765, 0.034285612404346466, -0.03319491446018219, -0.047875791788101196, -0.06066272035241127, 0.004910327028483152, -0.05663233995437622, -0.003965391777455807, 0.012824179604649544, -0.02431981824338436, -0.05499626323580742, 0.002004052512347698, 0.02043677493929863, 0.01082959771156311, -0.0797252207994461, 0.11127195507287979, -0.011818062514066696, 0.015691634267568588, 0.036386001855134964, 0.023094240576028824, 0.00006084281994844787, 0.06732074916362762, -0.0361262746155262, 0.03037269599735737, -0.03562391549348831, 0.028545884415507317, -0.054303765296936035, -0.014878744259476662, 0.011036831885576248, 0.01567395217716694, -0.025087377056479454, -0.0027600927278399467, -0.017899416387081146, -0.06768129765987396, 0.07346092164516449, -0.08809559792280197, 0.007172610145062208, -0.014088441617786884, 0.047809336334466934, 0.016645196825265884, -0.014418371953070164, -0.0009008902125060558, -0.016730161383748055, 0.037603359669446945, 0.013141227886080742, 0.004378865007311106, -0.05241706967353821, 0.007010759320110083, -0.05012478306889534, -0.030832257121801376, -0.040919121354818344, -0.01255640760064125, -0.014036235399544239, -0.014827346429228783, 0.010054311715066433, 0.05654431879520416, 0.0505249910056591, -0.0033018491230905056, -0.0021638229954987764, -0.02502279356122017, 0.039005767554044724, 0.04761350154876709, -0.04996899887919426, -0.03001542016863823, -0.03034176304936409, -0.007550365291535854, 0.023955881595611572, 0.01945788599550724, -0.034581322222948074, -0.034131139516830444, -0.012419789098203182, -0.008405025117099285, -0.0019033449934795499, -0.0545659102499485, 0.010192311368882656, -0.014960207976400852, -0.05341365933418274, 0.05594317987561226, -0.039288681000471115, 0.0038223168812692165, 0.018949758261442184, -0.04138157516717911, -0.004688960965722799, -0.0005080680712126195, 0.04153915122151375, 0.05216636881232262, 0.0007917582406662405, 0.030383944511413574, 0.04427552968263626, 0.02698158100247383, -0.009431022219359875, -0.016366438940167427, 0.006467005703598261, 0.022887203842401505, 0.023871971294283867, 0.0214417465031147, -0.008964641019701958, 0.04582349583506584, -0.017707455903291702, 0.041215457022190094, 0.01881776750087738, -0.07708082348108292, 0.03640548884868622, 0.0357484444975853, 0.0017102191923186183, -0.039500825107097626, 0.005562744569033384, 0.026645595207810402, -0.027092454954981804, 0.030339716002345085, 0.0398406907916069, 0.04542016610503197, -0.006593438796699047, 0.05794031172990799, 0.030226143077015877, 0.018560685217380524, -0.05074455216526985, 0.048452623188495636, -0.0035949917510151863, -0.00011656893184408545, -0.022760434076189995, 0.03648043051362038, -0.002429859945550561, -0.05536975339055061, 0.03899889439344406, -0.016117040067911148, -0.052465733140707016, -0.004479735158383846, -0.028651542961597443, 0.021894942969083786, -0.016623640432953835, -0.07490172237157822, -0.039840810000896454, 0.023503296077251434, -0.02448371797800064, -0.04606771841645241, 0.004441651050001383, 0.043383385986089706, 0.000879513390827924, 0.12067298591136932, -0.03484835475683212, 0.019151659682393074, -0.0967203676700592, -0.01403232105076313, -0.01738683693110943, -0.011814656667411327, 0.04516345635056496, 0.033679548650979996, 0.01169940922409296, 0.030209412798285484, 0.07610194385051727, 0.022828228771686554, 0.061926309019327164, 0.002340184524655342, -0.02837027795612812, -0.03300852328538895, -0.008934893645346165, 0.05939251556992531, -0.057152215391397476, -0.0010497408220544457, -0.016117321327328682, 0.0250533577054739, -0.04044278711080551, 0.0003283159458078444, -0.0003661489172372967, -0.018360685557127, -0.005853757727891207, -0.041990943253040314, 0.013265004381537437, -0.03744382783770561, -0.07143325358629227, 0.06862591207027435, -0.025981562212109566, -0.04692420735955238, 0.05179750174283981, 0.023331383243203163, -0.011364507488906384, -0.017548270523548126, 0.010191145353019238, 0.021992461755871773, 0.02627391740679741, 0.012526696547865868, -0.048182517290115356, 0.029925299808382988, -0.0278554018586874, 0.00850700307637453, 0.07177182286977768, 0.004495047498494387, -0.024007953703403473, -0.021340301260352135, 0.017724724486470222, -0.06611793488264084, -0.04514562338590622, -0.038615744560956955, 0.01969238370656967, 0.02684146910905838, 0.00449936231598258, 0.0083242142572999, 0.02560427226126194, -0.0016120487125590444, -0.016904985532164574, 0.00863107293844223, -0.018803374841809273, -0.01557508297264576, -0.013831845484673977, 0.07065743207931519, 0.010324339382350445, -0.002578064100816846, -0.00020386942196637392, -0.027542633935809135, 0.0001953873288584873, 0.038540903478860855, -0.057389676570892334, 0.04416143149137497, 0.011935410089790821, -0.026925621554255486, 0.053932059556245804, 0.03647962957620621, 0.002510878723114729, -0.07167698442935944, 0.005002697929739952, 0.011529571376740932, -0.03475458174943924, 0.005162615794688463, 0.011070136912167072, -0.046785321086645126, 0.07712621241807938, -0.04939211905002594, 0.03579755127429962, 0.043366167694330215, -0.05343109741806984, 0.034420598298311234, 0.07663397490978241, 0.07136952131986618, -0.026657938957214355, 0.004852088168263435, 0.041277628391981125, -0.00005296272865962237, -0.027943043038249016, -0.020651618018746376, 0.035461604595184326, -0.05730579048395157, 0.03748258575797081, 0.022030727937817574, -0.014401491731405258, -0.003839949844405055, 0.0525151751935482, 0.01477751974016428, 0.0787719264626503, -0.01923208124935627, 0.027276648208498955, 0.026837920770049095, -0.03688953444361687, -0.0561530664563179, 0.048079509288072586, -0.020394403487443924, 0.03255714103579521, 0.005098668858408928, -0.08103387802839279, -0.0026316423900425434, 0.009159096516668797, 0.021788131445646286, 0.05873052403330803, 0.020450783893465996, 0.012782640755176544, -0.010690362192690372, -0.03437327966094017, 0.05381890758872032, -0.012321882881224155, -0.003235942916944623, 0.003921233583241701, 0.009857255965471268, 0.04195215925574303, 0.011552069336175919, 0.046326473355293274, 0.039073746651411057, -0.05168015882372856, -0.009314073249697685, -0.09112469106912613, -0.015978844836354256, -0.04858020693063736, -0.008001509122550488, -0.052352067083120346, 0.05223465338349342, 0.04168703779578209, 0.039850588887929916, -0.019976962357759476, 0.07232823967933655, -0.04130300506949425, -0.00422666734084487, -0.08028430491685867, 0.0187071543186903, 0.00862633716315031, 0.03259305655956268, -0.016647476702928543, -0.009898807853460312, 0.09094858169555664, -0.03961910679936409, 0.05951477214694023, -0.01961355097591877, 0.0013295578537508845, -0.024680105969309807, -0.05267031490802765, -0.05154984071850777, 0.08177521824836731, -0.03854946792125702, -0.0045956894755363464, -0.027132723480463028, -0.01262763049453497, 0.012845693156123161, -0.03688871115446091, -0.023205796256661415, -0.013621250167489052, 0.0797075480222702, 0.015220621600747108, -0.06252236664295197, 0.01377924345433712, 0.01760014332830906, 0.032530445605516434, 0.005005782004445791, 0.061862435191869736, 0.028291519731283188, 0.04234026372432709, -0.05563562735915184, -0.03570490702986717, 0.044105760753154755, -0.01974104717373848, -0.02352219633758068, -0.05859484523534775, -0.0315915048122406, -0.0077294763177633286, 0.047937631607055664, 0.01756024919450283, -0.07040099054574966, 0.029786504805088043, -0.01322512049227953, -0.006341082509607077, 0.04085619002580643, 0.07294875383377075, 0.004266058560460806, 0.02013983763754368, 0.030478928238153458, 0.02131224423646927, 0.01935955509543419, -0.015676522627472878, -0.028265831992030144, 0.011241817846894264, 0.0014315509470179677, -0.003069185186177492, -0.037306006997823715, -0.011559299193322659, -0.06725078821182251, -0.007658783812075853, -0.02307351492345333, 0.10219776630401611, -0.0028060462791472673, 0.00946967676281929, 0.019167086109519005, 0.06641394644975662, 0.0017082809936255217, -0.04083625227212906, -0.027723347768187523, 0.013565652072429657, 0.0013732798397541046, -0.004578381776809692, 0.025508303195238113, 0.024844469502568245, 0.03707330301403999, -0.00280865584500134, 0.007705604191869497, 0.06965754926204681, -0.02625081315636635, 0.003129054792225361, 0.05460308864712715, 0.039838600903749466, 0.10145437717437744, -0.019260959699749947, 0.01761869713664055, -0.0002612034440971911, 0.037908416241407394, -0.023452717810869217, -0.018658334389328957, 0.0030123526230454445, -0.056004349142313004, 0.016976647078990936, -0.006816844921559095, -0.01141335628926754, -0.03669022396206856, 0.007901151664555073, 0.01126408576965332, -0.02843628078699112, -0.0804019570350647, 0.0011448216391727328, 0.008683652617037296, 0.013453814201056957, 0.016962744295597076, -0.05596739798784256, 0.02418108657002449, 0.017357373610138893, -0.022946510463953018, -0.08177236467599869, -0.011426098644733429, 0.02990580163896084, -0.03503090515732765, -0.057125430554151535, -0.04928312450647354, -0.04730721935629845, -0.007122839335352182, -0.019560448825359344, -0.05748142674565315, 0.11668308824300766, 0.0033032039646059275, -0.012915241532027721, -0.030937472358345985, 0.0010763596510514617, -0.008563623763620853, -0.021887321025133133, 0.024978099390864372, -0.0005593027453869581, 0.016508102416992188, -0.0424613282084465, -0.04168669506907463, -0.028182117268443108, -0.038732826709747314, 0.03524816781282425, 0.04007503017783165, -0.06721003353595734, 0.024251090362668037, -0.008996784687042236, -0.09389090538024902, -0.08588673174381256, -0.08533680438995361, -0.0020492766052484512, -0.0433838814496994, 0.004954518750309944, 0.006996435113251209, -0.04715723544359207, -0.06351421773433685, -0.011444970965385437, 0.02220781520009041, 0.01403723657131195, 0.019027795642614365, -0.00375238130800426, 0.01001673936843872, -0.03485219553112984, -0.05554350093007088, 0.03893926739692688, 0.005548987537622452, -0.005293906666338444, -0.0010594293707981706, 0.011618783697485924, -0.014233339577913284, 0.001152797369286418, -0.03779533505439758, 0.02298959717154503, 0.010969135910272598, 0.013888753019273281, 0.04266379401087761, -0.007917288690805435, -0.0014486545696854591, -0.039529457688331604, 0.009329377673566341, 0.019894005730748177, -0.07176084816455841, -0.022281786426901817, 0.03740875795483589, -0.02634056843817234, -0.020351143553853035, -0.04088122025132179, 0.009247910231351852, 0.01551451999694109, -0.07405615597963333, -0.030598342418670654, 0.018034009262919426, -0.052025604993104935, 0.06727808713912964, 0.014187339693307877, -0.024617668241262436, 0.06477408856153488, -0.030099445953965187, 0.1108110323548317, 0.06282635778188705, -0.055104583501815796, 0.007079947739839554, 0.0007395213469862938, 0.030169202014803886, 0.005504317115992308, -0.05471695587038994, 0.0457623116672039, -0.015723953023552895, 0.020577777177095413, 0.006431005895137787, 0.008599231019616127, -0.023855943232774734, -0.0067719812504947186, 0.04180734232068062, -0.014179898425936699, 0.028124552220106125, 0.010288492776453495, 0.034339241683483124, -0.00983220711350441, 0.009196020662784576, 0.020896146073937416, 0.04823527857661247, 0.01462092436850071, 0.024162961170077324, -0.035506587475538254, -0.054606691002845764, 0.007883039303123951, -0.006823663599789143, 0.06682823598384857, 0.0009147172095254064, -0.034716926515102386, -0.020488083362579346, -0.0640857145190239, -0.009959790855646133, 0.022653108462691307, 0.02674584835767746, -0.006333550903946161, -0.020428288727998734, -0.017212893813848495, -0.006765417288988829, 0.011603589169681072, -0.03006533719599247, 0.011706000193953514, 0.02485719509422779, 0.016794364899396896, -0.01331252884119749, 0.039081472903490067, -0.006607875227928162, -0.046207644045352936, -0.009863349609076977, 0.020659804344177246, 0.03637876734137535, 0.04005613923072815, 0.013135687448084354, 0.017015844583511353, -0.016686279326677322, 0.05921164155006409, -0.013183249160647392, -0.06444893777370453, 0.006290880497545004, -0.002821624744683504, 0.009695105254650116, 0.04265081509947777, 0.020945318043231964, -0.0427810363471508, -0.02671068161725998, 0.046110834926366806, 0.056696709245443344, -0.00432113790884614, -0.020190687850117683, 0.011923533864319324, 0.07089487463235855, 0.034588299691677094, 0.057134684175252914, -0.06589227169752121, 0.027021700516343117, -0.04411608353257179, -0.03330971300601959, -0.034133654087781906, 0.01374417170882225, 0.0012829031329602003, -0.01915815658867359, -0.012177837081253529, 0.000582078006118536, 0.03686952590942383, 0.013165210373699665, -0.03130638226866722, -0.004436812363564968, 0.006548532750457525, 0.025480685755610466, 0.005829045083373785, -0.035691726952791214, 0.04402005299925804, 0.06663298606872559, 0.06060601398348808, -0.0018859939882531762, 0.028235385194420815, 0.008896049112081528, 0.014453724026679993, -0.059488244354724884, -0.0021337484940886497, -0.02478230744600296, 0.02007732167840004, -0.034357305616140366, -0.07147735357284546, -0.00729911495000124, -0.018451355397701263, 0.006572656333446503, 0.022483117878437042, 0.00030723577947355807, -0.025787899270653725, 0.04046444967389107, -0.03459925949573517, -0.01124049723148346, -0.00476052425801754, 0.02952379733324051, -0.01752585358917713, -0.04003971070051193, 0.004671753849834204, -0.06636992841959, 0.0419020801782608, -0.029277853667736053, 0.06238500028848648, -0.02956860512495041, -0.019041193649172783, 0.007798825856298208, -0.003593574510887265, 0.02192600630223751, 0.047891657799482346, -0.014792547561228275, 0.019603116437792778, -0.0307454913854599, 0.008274305611848831, 0.02541528083384037, 0.015342851169407368, 0.07764007151126862, 0.018285512924194336, 0.03422098979353905, -0.04237231984734535, -0.023192675784230232, 0.003534351009875536, 0.011939290910959244, 0.006563211791217327, -0.018886981531977654, -0.0397363156080246, 0.007407644297927618, 0.008213559165596962, 0.0511372834444046, 0.0049947891384363174, -0.030834771692752838, 0.062023766338825226, 0.026551607996225357, 0.0046577309258282185, -0.055640265345573425, 0.015782058238983154, 0.013525230810046196, -0.01861555129289627, 0.02927754633128643, 0.04472179710865021, -0.027118176221847534, 0.004747644532471895, -0.06932399421930313, -0.06016291305422783, -0.018225977197289467, -0.008672250434756279, -0.01795896328985691, -0.014923380687832832, 0.017274461686611176, -0.0003257461648900062, -0.020075170323252678, 0.0046153804287314415, -0.005006042309105396, -0.03625369071960449, -0.027721092104911804, 0.0339948907494545, -0.03683527559041977, 0.02418636903166771, 0.017776401713490486, -0.038188714534044266, 0.023136889562010765, -0.030565254390239716, -0.01947375014424324, -0.030235297977924347, 0.03383241221308708, -0.03376255929470062, -0.018417544662952423, -0.023351222276687622, 0.03752521052956581, 0.04223055765032768, -0.023925742134451866, -0.030142514035105705, -0.02882286161184311, -0.010600127279758453, 0.033936936408281326, 0.0038697710260748863, 0.026258349418640137, -0.005498756654560566, -0.04543791711330414, -0.024730274453759193, 0.06509274989366531, -0.0009924059268087149, 0.030654460191726685, 0.028293432667851448, 0.024896608665585518, 0.0008378666825592518, 0.06613519042730331, 0.032354261726140976, -0.04323733225464821, 0.015853147953748703, 0.012440355494618416, -0.006856036838144064, 0.028329985216259956, -0.011394684202969074, -0.017773015424609184, -0.013095604255795479, 0.006285810377448797, -0.028280941769480705, 0.03968796879053116, 0.03678250312805176, -0.049628958106040955, -0.03889487311244011, -0.01636032573878765, 0.014410053379833698 ]
<p>Euler's laws of motion for a distributed mass are:</p> <p>$$F = \frac{d}{dt} MV_{cm},\ N = \frac{d}{dt} L$$</p> <p>$F$ are the sum of the external forces, $M$ the total mass, $V_{cm}$ the velocity of the centre of mass. $N$ are the sum of the moments of the external forces about some given point, L the total angular momentum about the same point.</p> <p>If a gyroscope is supported at its base with its axis horizontal, it precesses at a constant angular velocity. Using the above equations, how does one show this?</p>
g7498
[ 0.08892995864152908, 0.002848769538104534, -0.002418919000774622, -0.017614509910345078, 0.09205902367830276, 0.02483229525387287, 0.06076623871922493, -0.016486629843711853, -0.03360165283083916, -0.025012319907546043, -0.06243550404906273, -0.037443939596414566, 0.0272538922727108, 0.0009862157749012113, 0.04596227779984474, 0.00994565524160862, 0.007511076983064413, -0.016083937138319016, 0.025374243035912514, 0.02387055568397045, 0.023118626326322556, -0.02662673592567444, -0.010081727989017963, -0.05170150101184845, 0.04719958454370499, -0.01910984329879284, 0.014429976232349873, 0.0169756468385458, -0.05318678542971611, 0.03768226131796837, -0.0009499646257609129, -0.007800158113241196, 0.02849380113184452, -0.08755338191986084, 0.03865611553192139, -0.03250821679830551, 0.027640054002404213, 0.019903821870684624, 0.025105686858296394, -0.04408750310540199, 0.023318573832511902, -0.014707178808748722, -0.001044148113578558, 0.008388414978981018, 0.018386967480182648, -0.007075008004903793, -0.020409129559993744, 0.001975954044610262, -0.05985449254512787, -0.011235094629228115, -0.06369798630475998, 0.10241203010082245, 0.04281783476471901, -0.041469864547252655, 0.029247049242258072, 0.056366756558418274, 0.004795485641807318, -0.05658487230539322, 0.01553349569439888, 0.010918836109340191, -0.0034231278114020824, -0.04990403354167938, -0.03668105974793434, -0.0025603133253753185, 0.04952487722039223, -0.019981352612376213, -0.08250840753316879, -0.0174047090113163, 0.035651616752147675, 0.0007131806341931224, -0.06538775563240051, -0.06114962697029114, -0.0020776591263711452, -0.061246708035469055, -0.04552765190601349, -0.012691566720604897, 0.0003809166664723307, 0.03222224861383438, -0.0007010289700701833, -0.015364359132945538, -0.03862053528428078, -0.009493937715888023, 0.06634161621332169, 0.020389346405863762, 0.03994313254952431, -0.032323647290468216, 0.0347290076315403, 0.04520848020911217, -0.007665677461773157, 0.01519773155450821, 0.024968653917312622, -0.026285745203495026, 0.0551895909011364, 0.06145671382546425, -0.04910379648208618, -0.052470408380031586, -0.03937574103474617, 0.04342222213745117, 0.007516406010836363, -0.045497771352529526, -0.022849246859550476, -0.003025864018127322, -0.05297422409057617, -0.010055914521217346, 0.04479405656456947, 0.0010577276116237044, 0.05906673148274422, 0.05386584997177124, -0.015799827873706818, -0.01517125777900219, -0.008067135699093342, -0.020226426422595978, -0.020270848646759987, -0.04534866660833359, -0.052219320088624954, -0.08394640684127808, 0.09010370820760727, -0.01310835499316454, 0.014383374713361263, 0.0033835123758763075, 0.00030907473410479724, 0.027573546394705772, -0.06126696988940239, 0.07983864098787308, -0.08796931058168411, 0.034287936985492706, 0.002738009439781308, 0.02438345178961754, 0.07842272520065308, 0.03618287667632103, 0.009825636632740498, 0.02638218365609646, 0.023142430931329727, 0.03851158544421196, 0.026706360280513763, 0.0475364588201046, -0.05701789632439613, -0.030027927830815315, -0.03784593939781189, 0.025828499346971512, 0.025295374915003777, -0.011983739212155342, 0.024081407114863396, -0.008818600326776505, -0.0165601447224617, 0.038808465003967285, -0.0037467426154762506, -0.027005618438124657, 0.037301525473594666, 0.01019364781677723, -0.014314970932900906, 0.08598864078521729, 0.059020549058914185, -0.010054752230644226, 0.07385384291410446, -0.04004627838730812, 0.0021715981420129538, -0.02253166399896145, 0.012451376765966415, 0.01020551472902298, 0.01646023616194725, -0.011134302243590355, 0.04693683981895447, 0.01640935428440571, -0.06855574250221252, 0.032698266208171844, -0.03303033858537674, 0.050827544182538986, 0.04384028911590576, -0.024517936632037163, -0.05081531032919884, 0.0011556887766346335, 0.008854204788804054, 0.016692016273736954, 0.03371464088559151, -0.006785053759813309, -0.02599511295557022, -0.037262264639139175, 0.008545947261154652, 0.02304942160844803, 0.03388058394193649, -0.02249198779463768, 0.06732822209596634, 0.016452623531222343, -0.024434877559542656, 0.07441303879022598, -0.011410064995288849, 0.004297940526157618, -0.0582965649664402, 0.01746509037911892, -0.03130174055695534, -0.0210980623960495, -0.02654663473367691, 0.06276419758796692, 0.042331594973802567, 0.0011546266032382846, 0.007555248215794563, -0.06093442440032959, -0.005472938530147076, 0.07118000835180283, 0.006698668003082275, 0.03458203747868538, 0.04283825308084488, 0.027518784627318382, 0.007070398423820734, -0.0004279720888007432, 0.008136010728776455, 0.027198633179068565, 0.05360627919435501, 0.035621847957372665, -0.007311247754842043, 0.010654889047145844, -0.0853561982512474, -0.0005510188639163971, -0.022890694439411163, -0.030990976840257645, 0.005097620189189911, 0.026544544845819473, -0.0065934848971664906, 0.0042725661769509315, -0.08609513193368912, -0.021754149347543716, -0.009327184408903122, -0.008785885758697987, -0.01800941303372383, -0.037984419614076614, -0.05299887806177139, -0.008354018442332745, 0.0032307689543813467, 0.012942234054207802, -0.03286365047097206, -0.024991920217871666, -0.011148146353662014, -0.009659742936491966, 0.041195716708898544, 0.0015031060902401805, -0.02244146168231964, 0.028210289776325226, -0.002437051385641098, 0.02216312102973461, -0.05516188219189644, -0.03447970747947693, -0.014996047131717205, -0.07558576762676239, 0.020139461383223534, -0.019219202920794487, 0.050119850784540176, 0.05830470845103264, 0.02553820051252842, 0.06119278073310852, 0.024307118728756905, 0.00289550400339067, 0.019344525411725044, 0.0014343714574351907, 0.009162197820842266, 0.001238561701029539, -0.02750847488641739, -0.019794363528490067, -0.03361846134066582, -0.006193343549966812, -0.04040691629052162, -0.007650983985513449, 0.011921634897589684, 0.03914910927414894, -0.035354387015104294, 0.00968085415661335, -0.02422546222805977, 0.036324430257081985, 0.03548050671815872, 0.0043894341215491295, 0.00622037285938859, 0.09027885645627975, -0.0017775505548343062, 0.0525425486266613, -0.05832640454173088, -0.0744294822216034, 0.05448148027062416, -0.040672965347766876, -0.01845766417682171, 0.02419234812259674, 0.0002919250400736928, 0.022644327953457832, -0.01380600593984127, -0.017714517191052437, 0.04740453511476517, 0.007019130978733301, -0.03511042892932892, 0.016244132071733475, 0.005884915124624968, -0.0061751133762300014, 0.01560591347515583, 0.057690080255270004, 0.049939196556806564, -0.02720327116549015, -0.054647766053676605, 0.06735746562480927, 0.06250625848770142, -0.02593742311000824, 0.00020354001026134938, 0.06171374395489693, -0.024898724630475044, 0.0018366024596616626, 0.035693176090717316, 0.03171355649828911, -0.0015245394315570593, -0.001230817986652255, -0.02235317789018154, -0.049225665628910065, 0.014979375526309013, 0.01764020323753357, 0.006720256991684437, 0.019804857671260834, 0.02717764675617218, -0.05895240977406502, -0.056307896971702576, -0.0033179770689457655, -0.012394748628139496, 0.00031263206619769335, -0.051462698727846146, 0.017528371885418892, -0.0719686895608902, -0.09166496247053146, 0.002149388659745455, -0.018440116196870804, 0.05472453683614731, 0.0348505899310112, 0.02980806492269039, 0.02103620022535324, -0.016777167096734047, -0.07385986298322678, 0.0006154020084068179, 0.028388865292072296, 0.04629018157720566, 0.005354033783078194, -0.002901606261730194, -0.04321868717670441, -0.0038752632681280375, -0.020924706012010574, 0.007094018626958132, 0.048643238842487335, 0.009561634622514248, 0.00784323737025261, -0.07940608263015747, -0.016502073034644127, -0.013366978615522385, -0.019557330757379532, -0.01505220029503107, 0.008436123840510845, 0.031655989587306976, -0.0020906839054077864, -0.03446872904896736, -0.018356284126639366, -0.011006982065737247, 0.008567923679947853, 0.027301864698529243, 0.008815293200314045, 0.02235259860754013, 0.0077198343351483345, -0.0056263175792992115, 0.005104342941194773, 0.07327663153409958, 0.014494218863546848, -0.025954779237508774, 0.00984013918787241, 0.019024215638637543, 0.004781231749802828, 0.004569907207041979, 0.026649797335267067, 0.024486593902111053, 0.03733811527490616, -0.009411854669451714, -0.033048491925001144, 0.022057708352804184, 0.009739015251398087, -0.0042801667004823685, -0.05003436654806137, 0.05460143834352493, -0.015209462493658066, -0.010154614225029945, 0.010032887570559978, 0.08010132610797882, 0.05778839439153671, -0.05393819883465767, -0.005901797208935022, -0.025621330365538597, 0.026289597153663635, -0.049426011741161346, 0.027548884972929955, 0.03313198313117027, -0.0371210016310215, 0.054108791053295135, -0.12123711407184601, 0.009747439064085484, 0.014611521735787392, 0.030581118538975716, -0.04866310954093933, 0.009534846059978008, 0.006044479086995125, -0.023268189281225204, 0.03363469988107681, 0.03332583233714104, 0.047006282955408096, 0.016842275857925415, -0.02365434356033802, 0.029215877875685692, 0.062145620584487915, -0.00244103092700243, -0.0065889013931155205, 0.001881490694358945, -0.006442918907850981, 0.05022284388542175, 0.03433879092335701, -0.02526731789112091, -0.020524878054857254, 0.054466426372528076, 0.008385890163481236, 0.01032985094934702, -0.015325883403420448, -0.031966131180524826, 0.01588917337357998, -0.013683431781828403, -0.0007606429280713201, 0.03125035762786865, -0.04073388874530792, -0.07592606544494629, 0.03681018948554993, 0.025105975568294525, 0.0006969613023102283, -0.010499543510377407, -0.013723788782954216, -0.04104439169168472, -0.016414981335401535, -0.008981196209788322, -0.01349575910717249, -0.03632800281047821, 0.05680157244205475, 0.010326709598302841, -0.012980494648218155, -0.03613756597042084, -0.0021757613867521286, 0.027772685512900352, 0.03933544084429741, -0.007429309654980898, -0.020311683416366577, -0.04279034957289696, 0.05539851635694504, -0.029698515310883522, -0.03618687763810158, -0.0030602416954934597, -0.043072864413261414, -0.0370553620159626, -0.014069342985749245, -0.010208983905613422, -0.00043192581506446004, 0.019573716446757317, 0.012994183227419853, -0.029166923835873604, 0.04759419709444046, -0.02764526940882206, -0.09337080270051956, -0.055922433733940125, -0.018786119297146797, -0.01587529666721821, -0.037560395896434784, 0.0688052698969841, 0.0029572020284831524, 0.017109287902712822, 0.022038666531443596, 0.03827427700161934, -0.014951576478779316, 0.03077767789363861, -0.018525252118706703, 0.02248721942305565, -0.018754661083221436, -0.04066242277622223, 0.04867846518754959, 0.03290465846657753, 0.01672867126762867, 0.03051198646426201, -0.0165585707873106, 0.01389343198388815, 0.02929544262588024, 0.011114452034235, -0.057768408209085464, 0.020382897928357124, -0.07372560352087021, 0.03321842849254608, -0.021308906376361847, 0.007804286666214466, -0.01956569030880928, -0.04462572932243347, 0.010916262865066528, -0.02361197955906391, -0.05311549827456474, 0.0163030494004488, 0.038076501339673996, -0.0021043182350695133, -0.04900669306516647, 0.0033194529823958874, -0.015116441994905472, -0.07995004206895828, 0.028632765635848045, 0.027695313096046448, 0.02477162703871727, 0.05101422592997551, 0.06826796382665634, -0.000013604648302134592, 0.017903480678796768, -0.0054146042093634605, 0.05753881856799126, 0.00474477419629693, 0.013981073163449764, 0.023143241181969643, 0.03294825553894043, -0.03824526444077492, -0.05154025927186012, 0.03981201350688934, -0.049151863902807236, 0.030928395688533783, 0.035998497158288956, 0.05253837630152702, -0.03889021649956703, 0.020359870046377182, -0.02261253260076046, -0.05738220736384392, 0.01636926643550396, -0.012573562562465668, -0.029041863977909088, -0.035678680986166, 0.022502049803733826, 0.006466431077569723, -0.06718999892473221, 0.04662509635090828, -0.03251451998949051, 0.036036986857652664, -0.06849382817745209, 0.0015721413074061275, -0.038144301623106, 0.02799220196902752, -0.017865359783172607, -0.04890495166182518, -0.03123721480369568, 0.03362729772925377, 0.05865641310811043, -0.0584319606423378, 0.011600476689636707, -0.004739511292427778, 0.04507294297218323, 0.06258998811244965, -0.05005933716893196, -0.01293760072439909, 0.06103267893195152, 0.007415530271828175, -0.03489278256893158, -0.05490635335445404, 0.055155131965875626, -0.01616794802248478, -0.017523346468806267, -0.03447291627526283, 0.007282326463609934, 0.018080227077007294, 0.002464753808453679, 0.08221438527107239, -0.007653241977095604, -0.0008936651865951717, -0.06370623409748077, 0.005135827697813511, -0.012536885216832161, 0.04623693972826004, 0.031145112589001656, -0.007867520675063133, 0.03138207271695137, -0.11308601498603821, 0.015191241167485714, 0.0896807536482811, 0.046334292739629745, -0.03370313346385956, -0.0038028175476938486, -0.05117551609873772, 0.03674018010497093, -0.01523279957473278, 0.0009246122790500522, 0.06540585309267044, -0.0008141352445818484, -0.05284930765628815, 0.017513271421194077, -0.06843675673007965, -0.03884505107998848, 0.02669989876449108, -0.035908814519643784, 0.00507473386824131, 0.018033817410469055, -0.05362338572740555, -0.047101546078920364, 0.019027763977646828, 0.020343711599707603, 0.04119155928492546, 0.009308951906859875, 0.027402721345424652, 0.015094218775629997, 0.09632551670074463, 0.024899741634726524, 0.04158896207809448, -0.001253852155059576, -0.0032369722612202168, -0.013454237021505833, -0.05402226373553276, -0.024963557720184326, 0.012450180016458035, 0.00008254912972915918, 0.022919800132513046, 0.054823338985443115, 0.036813754588365555, -0.009836802259087563, 0.0005284614162519574, 0.01197127066552639, 0.0020432095043361187, 0.023275522515177727, -0.024147741496562958, -0.007633180357515812, 0.03193875402212143, 0.02250414527952671, -0.013707928359508514, -0.015338081866502762, -0.008297575637698174, -0.014238064177334309, -0.010101446881890297, -0.008049546740949154, 0.0870966762304306, 0.030612703412771225, 0.000029407818146864884, 0.00916480366140604, -0.026962885633111, -0.03390154615044594, -0.008235061541199684, 0.07763980329036713, -0.009760258719325066, 0.016505680978298187, 0.029758138582110405, 0.08661504089832306, 0.02293574996292591, 0.01767856813967228, 0.009193066507577896, -0.013165121898055077, 0.02461020089685917, 0.012975454330444336, 0.04838833585381508, 0.012500998564064503, 0.00530614797025919, 0.0048211729153990746, -0.020420396700501442, -0.05177735164761543, 0.008450808003544807, 0.03221769630908966, -0.0636884942650795, -0.0003167005779687315, 0.03787616640329361, -0.01378681045025587, 0.004610569681972265, 0.004338451661169529, -0.003369569545611739, -0.0008331235148943961, 0.033738262951374054, 0.01275330875068903, -0.06489160656929016, 0.012569727376103401, 0.025427741929888725, -0.035313207656145096, 0.016227377578616142, -0.030910130590200424, -0.011998186819255352, -0.014264432713389397, -0.03157874569296837, -0.023229246959090233, -0.012601860798895359, -0.019882328808307648, -0.026469146832823753, -0.02300647646188736, -0.05039907246828079, -0.017027661204338074, -0.026840955018997192, 0.05421549081802368, -0.007371143437922001, 0.07604248821735382, -0.07854993641376495, 0.006558057852089405, -0.012359022162854671, -0.025257620960474014, 0.03960162028670311, -0.028250066563487053, -0.0033220199402421713, 0.05806218087673187, 0.03139572590589523, -0.04922427982091904, 0.009048368781805038, -0.03295889496803284, 0.014597599394619465, -0.00921250693500042, -0.030139600858092308, -0.046822793781757355, -0.010076623409986496, -0.04051515832543373, -0.01116751879453659, 0.060646407306194305, 0.041461654007434845, 0.010872634127736092, -0.02875410206615925, -0.02722397819161415, -0.006109429057687521, -0.00557364197447896, 0.004572545178234577, -0.0441681370139122, 0.006092834286391735, -0.0397329218685627, 0.007937387563288212, 0.01259707473218441, -0.05514165014028549, 0.05070067197084427, 0.00569674838334322, 0.011434709653258324, -0.058223724365234375, -0.02860097773373127, -0.034942299127578735, -0.051093485206365585, -0.0428520031273365, -0.05372023209929466, -0.05320204049348831, -0.014748855493962765, 0.025315631181001663, -0.0279376357793808, 0.0007612908375449479, 0.05181539058685303, -0.031207630410790443, 0.011734860017895699, -0.03696637973189354, 0.002112138783559203, -0.018729647621512413, -0.07087019085884094, -0.0272833202034235, -0.008297663182020187, 0.002194345463067293, -0.08466488122940063, -0.016102498397231102, -0.003922800533473492, 0.013154719956219196, 0.017928652465343475, -0.004962617065757513, -0.01157568022608757, 0.009462918154895306, 0.03636690229177475, 0.026048239320516586, 0.00017067501903511584, -0.02241118811070919, -0.020987356081604958, 0.014935435727238655, -0.04400116205215454, -0.014698585495352745, 0.0049779387190938, -0.018019502982497215, -0.005262031219899654, -0.0363599993288517, -0.0034403635654598475, 0.018250340595841408, 0.003552316688001156, -0.023374805226922035, -0.04070659726858139, -0.07056521624326706, 0.0544046126306057 ]
<p>Clouds are made up of tiny water or ice droplets, depending on temperature. This implies that cloud density is greater than that of dry air. Why don't clouds sink through their surrounding atmosphere rather than float by in a variety of formations? </p>
g260
[ 0.04725189134478569, 0.08173651993274689, -0.01416544709354639, -0.01791008561849594, 0.008824068121612072, 0.07302483916282654, 0.03175509348511696, -0.03837074339389801, -0.07825655490159988, -0.027427123859524727, 0.0371781587600708, -0.0020857094787061214, 0.06867951154708862, -0.011240527033805847, -0.0368863083422184, 0.06500802934169769, -0.03156735748052597, -0.007419034838676453, 0.02391671948134899, 0.045861076563596725, 0.02426644042134285, -0.05041413754224777, 0.022364754229784012, 0.0025428642984479666, -0.12397406995296478, 0.00721772899851203, -0.001073483843356371, -0.0524158775806427, -0.037002094089984894, 0.01283209677785635, 0.022362137213349342, 0.03332627937197685, -0.02263594977557659, 0.01382770761847496, 0.016231635585427284, -0.016314677894115448, 0.006773047614842653, -0.024477355182170868, -0.006644439417868853, -0.06898444890975952, -0.0012600624468177557, 0.028900541365146637, 0.020910050719976425, 0.01156290341168642, -0.03807784244418144, -0.002224583411589265, 0.03682746738195419, 0.00572231924161315, -0.021667957305908203, -0.08558246493339539, 0.0014672504039481282, 0.02490009367465973, -0.040013089776039124, 0.02287772297859192, -0.06346207857131958, 0.005178821738809347, 0.040006719529628754, -0.008412658236920834, 0.002220420865342021, 0.008102311752736568, 0.029922839254140854, 0.049882955849170685, 0.0038987600710242987, -0.0025758501142263412, 0.02221553772687912, -0.03388257697224617, -0.03066132962703705, 0.023852379992604256, 0.07452064007520676, 0.017757097259163857, 0.012468914501369, -0.007919215597212315, 0.011816391721367836, -0.026819802820682526, -0.04388473927974701, 0.005681947804987431, -0.04012766852974892, -0.0006332055781967938, 0.05606801435351372, 0.013189733028411865, 0.023820336908102036, -0.03435130789875984, 0.030492229387164116, -0.01894327811896801, 0.07511407881975174, 0.03543796390295029, 0.012508398853242397, -0.031129222363233566, 0.022382359951734543, 0.016024449840188026, -0.0372578427195549, -0.021240049973130226, 0.09034308046102524, 0.04093576595187187, -0.027564121410250664, -0.05260898172855377, 0.03444492816925049, -0.011355284601449966, -0.017574287950992584, 0.0054154894314706326, -0.021472850814461708, 0.013685859739780426, 0.011810552328824997, -0.0026878193020820618, 0.05547903850674629, 0.020067300647497177, -0.0014633346581831574, 0.039824072271585464, 0.006680489983409643, -0.01525904331356287, 0.018396833911538124, -0.02412879280745983, -0.046547722071409225, 0.033752020448446274, -0.00023415288887917995, -0.021358350291848183, -0.024774281308054924, 0.032008472830057144, 0.006564718205481768, 0.043574050068855286, 0.025206705555319786, 0.012162799946963787, -0.006288448348641396, 0.022871892899274826, 0.017107563093304634, 0.0021867072209715843, 0.0835685208439827, -0.013414534740149975, -0.015392071567475796, -0.034348100423812866, 0.05880636349320412, 0.00963839516043663, -0.09689895063638687, 0.0009412749204784632, -0.012589061632752419, -0.04794548824429512, -0.031715430319309235, -0.029574166983366013, -0.0072630951181054115, -0.012342975474894047, 0.03139953315258026, 0.03623654693365097, 0.0603874996304512, -0.026709401980042458, -0.021747255697846413, -0.053442418575286865, -0.0637107789516449, 0.026713969185948372, 0.004955069161951542, -0.006917831487953663, -0.01590769737958908, -0.06963255256414413, 0.03406480327248573, -0.017960842698812485, 0.025181345641613007, 0.0032585831359028816, 0.043153490871191025, 0.03271043300628662, -0.017717093229293823, 0.051032938063144684, 0.009927509352564812, 0.03455905243754387, -0.018571218475699425, 0.026858557015657425, -0.03168101981282234, 0.044918447732925415, 0.040835484862327576, 0.03211517632007599, 0.0033320700749754906, 0.014095800928771496, 0.005700071807950735, 0.0029941329266875982, -0.06831898540258408, 0.07480324059724808, 0.07855241000652313, -0.010980217717587948, 0.09843818843364716, 0.011661428958177567, 0.050640057772397995, 0.001798047567717731, 0.01619964838027954, -0.022658510133624077, -0.028890499845147133, -0.04762372002005577, 0.03876067325472832, -0.031217630952596664, 0.05750608816742897, -0.01988351158797741, 0.00013066918472759426, -0.011199595406651497, 0.022737668827176094, -0.00446633156388998, -0.013898729346692562, 0.012125171720981598, 0.04406909644603729, -0.03501532971858978, 0.0669253021478653, 0.02822624333202839, -0.027577916160225868, -0.008231068029999733, -0.006045967806130648, -0.03139853477478027, 0.02975933626294136, -0.015276633203029633, -0.0045614661648869514, 0.08873062580823898, -0.017666904255747795, 0.018964191898703575, 0.05601774901151657, -0.05096646398305893, -0.0548197478055954, 0.0008363956003449857, 0.00027814190252684057, -0.018164992332458496, 0.006322639994323254, -0.016904665157198906, -0.017218871042132378, 0.0009589347755536437, -0.03730391710996628, -0.027663877233862877, -0.06530705839395523, -0.008560744114220142, -0.029339373111724854, -0.0035961817484349012, 0.0027298838831484318, 0.010946289636194706, -0.00738257123157382, 0.01853611320257187, 0.039837546646595, 0.022263579070568085, -0.026822609826922417, 0.011664542369544506, 0.02595812827348709, -0.02009492740035057, -0.012773021124303341, 0.001457173377275467, -0.03108472004532814, -0.02714296616613865, 0.05904778093099594, 0.004987949039787054, -0.04067737236618996, -0.06431436538696289, -0.009057917632162571, -0.03582186624407768, 0.011457428336143494, -0.04271211475133896, -0.04590852931141853, -0.02177230641245842, -0.02918480709195137, 0.0012582010822370648, 0.031061310321092606, -0.02115640416741371, -0.006511027459055185, -0.042525745928287506, 0.010630949400365353, -0.03827989101409912, -0.05162232741713524, 0.002914841752499342, 0.021212272346019745, -0.011275186203420162, -0.023759709671139717, -0.01877390779554844, -0.0205965768545866, -0.04116274043917656, -0.07832778990268707, 0.007030231412500143, -0.05209769308567047, 0.0383080430328846, 0.0705643817782402, -0.0273429062217474, 0.013777509331703186, 0.022014997899532318, 0.016641652211546898, 0.039877165108919144, -0.015513679943978786, 0.01338649820536375, -0.007829786278307438, 0.01870056428015232, 0.0029598926194012165, -0.010691038332879543, 0.017105000093579292, -0.002140507334843278, -0.05402521789073944, -0.023630822077393532, 0.060271088033914566, -0.08335298299789429, -0.01757407747209072, 0.017803380265831947, -0.026246489956974983, -0.022834420204162598, 0.05555007606744766, 0.022088371217250824, 0.04502060264348984, 0.031277578324079514, 0.07877150177955627, 0.0009046306367963552, -0.05365567281842232, 0.0032921908423304558, -0.10394815355539322, 0.02018815465271473, -0.0007892039138823748, 0.03503456711769104, 0.06407049298286438, 0.009838162921369076, 0.011618243530392647, 0.07433437556028366, -0.004635029472410679, -0.02014266513288021, -0.072938472032547, -0.02452288754284382, 0.0483216866850853, 0.048069264739751816, -0.0627795159816742, -0.0017830971628427505, -0.030787121504545212, -0.002015146194025874, 0.000034153967135353014, 0.03146078810095787, 0.03538601100444794, -0.03516607731580734, 0.001476247445680201, 0.035093244165182114, -0.02039140649139881, 0.013708190061151981, 0.03547382727265358, 0.026255931705236435, -0.02396228164434433, -0.058050841093063354, 0.011923347599804401, -0.01510740164667368, -0.04913044720888138, -0.02019256167113781, 0.011828234419226646, -0.009454164654016495, -0.0768275037407875, 0.0046157813630998135, 0.030014650896191597, -0.00855817086994648, -0.022163640707731247, -0.04251380264759064, 0.0016693118959665298, -0.004122793674468994, -0.06258868426084518, -0.01007735263556242, -0.01828831434249878, -0.009293198585510254, 0.022228511050343513, 0.017583558335900307, 0.0017895573982968926, 0.0022363944444805384, 0.013917275704443455, -0.031507425010204315, 0.02638218179345131, 0.0011315963929519057, -0.015673689544200897, 0.0445108562707901, 0.06307853758335114, 0.0025075471494346857, 0.05943332985043526, 0.012357424944639206, 0.035363756120204926, -0.019095389172434807, 0.012000489979982376, -0.015333189629018307, -0.03211753070354462, -0.014196034520864487, -0.044777706265449524, -0.007741974201053381, -0.018715614452958107, 0.0450955294072628, -0.004695850424468517, 0.039344921708106995, -0.040425997227430344, 0.022526074200868607, 0.06553664803504944, -0.03963516652584076, 0.0594099685549736, 0.03584844991564751, 0.02310931123793125, -0.044015273451805115, 0.04653535038232803, -0.014242874458432198, 0.018322302028536797, -0.008935882709920406, -0.009360016323626041, 0.03252657502889633, -0.011501613073050976, 0.022458897903561592, -0.07869365066289902, 0.011797256767749786, -0.08061929792165756, 0.0016125153051689267, 0.007830513641238213, 0.0161681417375803, -0.030726900324225426, -0.008787860162556171, -0.02274991013109684, 0.032824594527482986, -0.032871536910533905, 0.02287503518164158, 0.0030083730816841125, -0.000017821203073253855, -0.052012961357831955, -0.062306907027959824, 0.053629741072654724, 0.029992936179041862, 0.013425502926111221, -0.01134455669671297, -0.04144638404250145, -0.05249212682247162, 0.09438558667898178, 0.007595303002744913, -0.03864040970802307, 0.006348796654492617, 0.03321773186326027, -0.02662890963256359, 0.00901018176227808, 0.03220352157950401, 0.04361266642808914, 0.032528337091207504, 0.01016741432249546, 0.0419311448931694, -0.002766782883554697, 0.028973443433642387, -0.01919018290936947, 0.019615046679973602, 0.032581545412540436, 0.03113461099565029, -0.04798359423875809, -0.05577142536640167, -0.00006547674274770543, -0.037525128573179245, 0.001597207156009972, -0.010051369667053223, 0.0038688071072101593, 0.0400223508477211, 0.03704487159848213, -0.0030441933777183294, -0.008807155303657055, 0.043247707188129425, -0.0011829988798126578, 0.02512958273291588, -0.008526618592441082, -0.02109561301767826, -0.014039557427167892, 0.05779332295060158, -0.009485887363553047, 0.001294019864872098, -0.022880330681800842, 0.024441421031951904, -0.0429660826921463, 0.03006586991250515, -0.02872385084629059, -0.01799270324409008, -0.030742362141609192, -0.0011712746927514672, -0.009257764555513859, -0.0034199196379631758, 0.0013539454666897655, 0.006077664904296398, -0.03872363269329071, 0.01157672330737114, 0.047944508492946625, 0.01170439925044775, 0.009259218350052834, 0.0013563361717388034, 0.045932333916425705, -0.030110498890280724, 0.011147208511829376, 0.0008665254572406411, -0.009674550034105778, 0.103144071996212, -0.024090629070997238, 0.09179054200649261, 0.05292697623372078, 0.028257664293050766, 0.03149235621094704, -0.05057910457253456, 0.046289291232824326, -0.04613383486866951, 0.024421969428658485, 0.015804370865225792, 0.01681727170944214, 0.055819254368543625, -0.008914695121347904, 0.015594991855323315, 0.004625509027391672, 0.031134026125073433, -0.011962180957198143, -0.0329175628721714, -0.01921982131898403, -0.07661868631839752, -0.049356915056705475, -0.00031335948733612895, -0.01666124351322651, -0.034416455775499344, -0.0032362963538616896, 0.004238377325236797, 0.009310969151556492, -0.03278341516852379, -0.004609914496541023, -0.045715123414993286, 0.02377813681960106, -0.017494473606348038, 0.04088997468352318, 0.04150620102882385, 0.09453748911619186, -0.01005369983613491, 0.004861111287027597, 0.032089367508888245, -0.05781692638993263, -0.01214221678674221, 0.004713881760835648, 0.028257127851247787, 0.02477981708943844, -0.045854855328798294, -0.009972156956791878, 0.03762506693601608, 0.016484254971146584, 0.008716871030628681, -0.04331399127840996, -0.0188994649797678, -0.018005777150392532, 0.06272249668836594, 0.036366913467645645, -0.0030218951869755983, -0.04913155362010002, -0.05504065006971359, 0.027323998510837555, 0.0004210399347357452, 0.0008888324373401701, 0.01963209919631481, 0.03800678998231888, -0.0793716087937355, -0.012799505144357681, -0.02913450449705124, -0.013990255072712898, 0.012145831249654293, 0.09901823103427887, 0.021975647658109665, -0.02499108947813511, -0.049203913658857346, -0.033466972410678864, 0.07968362420797348, 0.06409537047147751, -0.02914724498987198, 0.045576583594083786, 0.061508435755968094, 0.06629959493875504, 0.021161595359444618, -0.03463422507047653, 0.015847090631723404, -0.09788769483566284, -0.02776370942592621, -0.05129145830869675, 0.02691110596060753, -0.02976895123720169, -0.020665498450398445, -0.031399134546518326, -0.009034601971507072, 0.0197009164839983, 0.028710011392831802, 0.023121971637010574, 0.005923393648117781, -0.020367708057165146, 0.02821957878768444, -0.0517023466527462, 0.04205678775906563, 0.04195478558540344, 0.007360250223428011, 0.006361499894410372, -0.017708702012896538, 0.047254376113414764, -0.03630562499165535, 0.0010405643843114376, 0.03297717124223709, 0.01262866985052824, 0.017012324184179306, 0.021414397284388542, -0.05430453643202782, 0.054173264652490616, -0.037960655987262726, 0.014752882532775402, -0.033074457198381424, 0.026667283847928047, -0.035224590450525284, -0.041909411549568176, -0.05641256645321846, 0.01265722792595625, 0.026146305724978447, -0.06015574559569359, 0.0027966543566435575, 0.013509634882211685, -0.053768351674079895, -0.04205337166786194, -0.06605236977338791, 0.005410546436905861, 0.05012822523713112, -0.048017166554927826, -0.09615123271942139, 0.032643239945173264, 0.04000508412718773, 0.045642588287591934, 0.028525006026029587, -0.03526037931442261, 0.016310805454850197, 0.03996322676539421, 0.045150719583034515, -0.013752576895058155, 0.02028399147093296, -0.07668463885784149, -0.00037955332663841546, 0.015368852764368057, -0.028438877314329147, -0.015052206814289093, -0.04785853996872902, 0.019637735560536385, 0.021929945796728134, -0.04261961206793785, -0.05294828861951828, -0.022689851000905037, -0.028761621564626694, -0.006929656956344843, -0.05561140179634094, -0.002044806955382228, 0.024604439735412598, 0.009118938818573952, 0.06520077586174011, 0.03723913058638573, 0.04047710448503494, 0.043919436633586884, 0.009675845503807068, -0.03635617718100548, 0.01056837197393179, -0.029242051765322685, 0.03353385999798775, -0.024142304435372353, -0.002486133947968483, 0.03756902739405632, -0.05828961357474327, -0.019047075882554054, -0.01700683683156967, 0.009231753647327423, 0.017434628680348396, -0.00723341153934598, -0.02370377816259861, -0.0174162145704031, -0.06591666489839554, -0.029767321422696114, -0.028589783236384392, 0.024240750819444656, 0.004470668267458677, 0.01846880279481411, -0.012392217293381691, -0.010544960387051105, -0.0028501986525952816, -0.0044701541773974895, 0.04633323475718498, -0.00040288656600750983, -0.03831300511956215, -0.053782202303409576, 0.040883343666791916, -0.015691816806793213, 0.07015881687402725, 0.02277420461177826, -0.001953908707946539, 0.034585509449243546, -0.016375966370105743, 0.03450864180922508, 0.010117198340594769, 0.01616046391427517, 0.015659628435969353, -0.02927231416106224, -0.048191215842962265, 0.008620642125606537, 0.008858408778905869, 0.00035251330700702965, -0.009611540473997593, 0.03040274791419506, 0.046829380095005035, 0.02067413739860058, 0.004709796980023384, 0.021432898938655853, -0.009610727429389954, -0.020292159169912338, 0.03195241466164589, -0.00257301633246243, 0.03803076222538948, 0.024897195398807526, -0.046157047152519226, 0.02613643743097782, 0.01907559484243393, -0.023252351209521294, -0.011192022822797298, -0.08693423867225647, 0.038131117820739746, 0.09311861544847488, -0.09996895492076874, 0.02216934598982334, 0.013871276751160622, -0.004901351407170296, -0.04119126871228218, 0.054069098085165024, -0.03359461575746536, 0.008116212673485279, -0.03098122775554657, 0.047441061586141586, 0.04952540621161461, -0.05554071068763733, -0.0679750069975853, -0.04041220620274544, -0.004538712091743946, 0.06272880733013153, -0.05870235711336136, 0.008918682113289833, -0.062405627220869064, -0.0040635960176587105, -0.01564083993434906, -0.11331487447023392, -0.008081210777163506, -0.019824694842100143, -0.04122494161128998, 0.02495552785694599, -0.05965733155608177, -0.017182325944304466, -0.006670499686151743, -0.015876078978180885, 0.001265489961951971, -0.0066042132675647736, 0.018101437017321587, -0.04427553713321686, 0.08255580812692642, -0.040013305842876434, -0.00781222665682435, 0.035513296723365784, 0.011771128512918949, 0.016762657091021538, -0.017885420471429825, 0.03468134254217148, -0.022383524104952812, -0.04903950169682503, 0.0007784637855365872, -0.013219873420894146, -0.05047827214002609, 0.026078207418322563, -0.07983430474996567, 0.033425066620111465, 0.002976334886625409, -0.0010641529224812984, -0.014895412139594555, 0.01038863230496645, 0.051465362310409546, -0.0160630252212286, -0.010320495814085007, -0.0001933432067744434, 0.03504033014178276, 0.025495236739516258, 0.053293388336896896, 0.003325721714645624, -0.07065251469612122, -0.027200425043702126, -0.030049024149775505, 0.013735429383814335, 0.0011055102804675698, -0.024523811414837837, 0.011767720803618431, 0.019571760669350624, 0.006194046698510647 ]
<p>Matt in <a href="http://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/9597/what-does-a-hexagonal-sun-tell-us-about-the-camera-lens-sensor/9601#9601">his answer</a> on <a href="http://photo.stackexchange.com/q/9597/64">What does a hexagonal sun tell us about the camera lens/sensor?</a> mentions</p> <blockquote> <p>Incidentally the number of (distinct) points to the star is equal to double the total number of unique orientations* in the sides of the aperture shape i.e. three blades would be six points, six blades would also be six points as a hexagon has only three unique orientations in its sides.</p> <p>* a hexagonal aperture has six sides but only three unique orientations as there are three pairs of parallel sides.</p> </blockquote> <p>I think It makes sense to have three pointed star in case of three blades.</p> <p>But how does a six blade aperture also result in a three pointed star?</p>
g7499
[ 0.0023393076844513416, 0.01985684223473072, 0.003924742341041565, 0.0076508065685629845, 0.07038688659667969, -0.003459604922682047, 0.0051205093041062355, 0.007664557080715895, 0.037224024534225464, -0.00941753201186657, -0.016714319586753845, 0.022334152832627296, 0.047935862094163895, -0.007908942177891731, 0.06366509944200516, -0.00805323664098978, 0.01902260072529316, -0.01328172255307436, 0.04446418583393097, 0.08942899107933044, 0.027557438239455223, 0.05616529658436775, 0.001365829724818468, -0.04664520546793938, -0.008347047492861748, -0.024230511859059334, -0.000255732040386647, -0.044903047382831573, -0.03454047814011574, -0.0013810336822643876, 0.043156251311302185, 0.005604161880910397, 0.031185228377580643, 0.046005457639694214, -0.00934680737555027, -0.057458359748125076, -0.009818360209465027, 0.07027522474527359, -0.005321556236594915, -0.049212098121643066, -0.0282832533121109, 0.004206474870443344, -0.0028425375930964947, -0.005652695894241333, -0.005068859551101923, -0.005671653896570206, -0.024066049605607986, -0.01282248180359602, 0.07609988749027252, -0.005115776788443327, 0.02189965918660164, -0.005017579533159733, 0.034683968871831894, -0.0034963262733072042, 0.014958838000893593, 0.07955171912908554, -0.03603225201368332, -0.001393149490468204, 0.07742694765329361, -0.0102827874943614, -0.05796477571129799, 0.0410553403198719, -0.02295995131134987, 0.0478779561817646, 0.03253315016627312, 0.013125359080731869, 0.01964722014963627, 0.05530356988310814, -0.010865534655749798, -0.04929336532950401, 0.009692751802504063, -0.046432945877313614, 0.039154790341854095, 0.008910082280635834, -0.024557648226618767, 0.015909187495708466, 0.0005486475420184433, 0.008277387358248234, -0.0580437146127224, 0.050468411296606064, 0.009606136940419674, -0.012852641753852367, -0.020545516163110733, -0.020693985745310783, 0.05901079997420311, -0.014377675019204617, 0.053045887500047684, 0.032308824360370636, -0.01471804641187191, -0.006677788682281971, 0.01236259937286377, 0.01967737264931202, 0.05637267604470253, -0.023119961842894554, -0.047672901302576065, -0.022010529413819313, 0.019694624468684196, 0.04274808242917061, -0.05506959557533264, -0.0009350299369543791, -0.035131365060806274, 0.030276888981461525, -0.000409452710300684, -0.02571585774421692, 0.008481798693537712, 0.016230810433626175, 0.02415953017771244, 0.02082693763077259, -0.016063569113612175, -0.051400911062955856, -0.08555058389902115, -0.0008020906243473291, -0.09501003473997116, 0.012512854300439358, -0.04594581574201584, -0.011294793337583542, 0.06368768215179443, -0.036323294043540955, 0.061082322150468826, 0.020670827478170395, -0.005736961029469967, -0.016116296872496605, -0.03480085730552673, 0.08295444399118423, 0.00828242115676403, 0.009120672009885311, 0.028860827907919884, -0.03957822918891907, 0.07496277242898941, -0.003961032256484032, 0.017939573153853416, -0.00442636338993907, -0.02624320425093174, -0.02340942807495594, 0.005736075807362795, 0.046442314982414246, -0.019410133361816406, 0.004934624303132296, 0.01736769638955593, 0.02205667272210121, -0.01554085873067379, 0.00887412577867508, -0.024866893887519836, -0.021420275792479515, 0.004807134624570608, -0.044338930398225784, -0.03660017251968384, -0.025523271411657333, 0.004637954756617546, 0.0015196867752820253, 0.02932996302843094, 0.030450589954853058, 0.05138704925775528, 0.003750171745195985, -0.03314761444926262, -0.04712556302547455, -0.023456638678908348, -0.02516796439886093, 0.019439255818724632, 0.07038511335849762, 0.08512192219495773, -0.03497035801410675, 0.0014784591039642692, 0.014941263012588024, -0.04656971991062164, -0.06519174575805664, -0.04193219169974327, -0.06942374259233475, -0.03383621945977211, -0.01535617746412754, 0.009130171500146389, 0.05163731798529625, 0.005687439814209938, -0.056795597076416016, 0.03669511154294014, -0.001810070127248764, 0.010454575531184673, -0.022542620077729225, 0.03203870728611946, 0.06243939697742462, -0.02108369581401348, 0.027934271842241287, -0.009290884248912334, -0.0025678493548184633, -0.030814513564109802, 0.0257588978856802, 0.05689441040158272, -0.009318121708929539, 0.02025800757110119, 0.03627254068851471, -0.018682710826396942, -0.012687380425632, 0.005268592853099108, 0.005883319303393364, -0.004327099770307541, -0.018800225108861923, -0.01627877727150917, -0.039616793394088745, -0.009120095521211624, 0.06641018390655518, -0.01803779788315296, -0.0026847172994166613, -0.012768862769007683, 0.02882551960647106, 0.0019869643729180098, -0.013313310220837593, -0.003982584457844496, 0.04683101922273636, 0.010329144075512886, 0.012165977619588375, -0.018212173134088516, 0.014330582693219185, 0.03320254012942314, 0.03217248246073723, 0.006083791144192219, 0.02663227543234825, -0.0032106367871165276, 0.029540691524744034, 0.020757779479026794, -0.033179618418216705, -0.007817715406417847, 0.0017310626571998, -0.0316116139292717, -0.05357753112912178, -0.0430830642580986, 0.06317779421806335, -0.009953709319233894, -0.019585875794291496, 0.038429517298936844, -0.007658543065190315, -0.03545025363564491, -0.05281244218349457, 0.0236813984811306, -0.051306627690792084, 0.01598515175282955, -0.004834929946810007, -0.013366494327783585, 0.0083675067871809, -0.020799804478883743, -0.009931487031280994, 0.0482415035367012, 0.0127839595079422, -0.04794929176568985, 0.05438723415136337, 0.03388432785868645, 0.0409969724714756, 0.016787094995379448, -0.010591103695333004, -0.011230322532355785, 0.08015014231204987, 0.04069971293210983, -0.00846659392118454, -0.015378296375274658, 0.03135374188423157, 0.0033625729847699404, 0.012180984951555729, -0.04139772430062294, -0.002241916721686721, -0.10531170666217804, 0.038328394293785095, -0.01807524636387825, -0.028496311977505684, -0.012502776458859444, -0.08646150678396225, 0.0015818896936252713, -0.03354916721582413, -0.010769271291792393, -0.018610920757055283, 0.014561870135366917, 0.014950288459658623, -0.007545202970504761, 0.021012168377637863, 0.06936986744403839, -0.00030475386301986873, -0.051549360156059265, 0.024099793285131454, -0.0015568442177027464, -0.024693340063095093, -0.02016868069767952, -0.035848647356033325, -0.005903715267777443, 0.052671052515506744, -0.09366685897111893, 0.013464581221342087, -0.010639180429279804, 0.11048438400030136, 0.014660815708339214, 0.0662454217672348, -0.021855970844626427, 0.0006192818400450051, -0.07598230242729187, -0.012537813745439053, 0.0492263101041317, -0.09123427420854568, 0.03080027922987938, 0.04285610094666481, 0.013877194374799728, 0.0025294763036072254, 0.023943845182657242, 0.02934000827372074, -0.026110442355275154, 0.026814399287104607, -0.009151259437203407, -0.06157670542597771, 0.05249985307455063, 0.004606736358255148, -0.02844865620136261, -0.073477603495121, 0.051660578697919846, -0.04637293517589569, 0.024711696431040764, -0.03754264488816261, -0.025754090398550034, 0.03721240535378456, -0.019481468945741653, 0.032527897506952286, -0.06163918599486351, 0.04531409963965416, -0.05703267082571983, 0.06408637762069702, -0.03621600195765495, 0.05829881504178047, -0.009291429072618484, 0.0168906282633543, 0.005722261965274811, 0.057876430451869965, 0.00709124468266964, 0.01621604710817337, 0.03326992318034172, 0.00679379515349865, -0.003979382570832968, -0.013897054828703403, -0.027695097029209137, 0.007258805446326733, 0.046218086034059525, 0.037004366517066956, -0.0624111145734787, 0.009259895421564579, 0.04160327836871147, -0.0727592259645462, 0.06856559216976166, -0.029380282387137413, -0.05914340168237686, -0.04980310797691345, 0.0009791519260033965, -0.019238322973251343, 0.06800831854343414, -0.019689802080392838, 0.027459898963570595, -0.0016669403994455934, 0.010178014636039734, 0.006825509015470743, -0.05466786399483681, -0.02101040817797184, -0.028063571080565453, 0.04486065357923508, -0.05629346892237663, 0.02792367897927761, -0.01768319122493267, 0.02679494395852089, 0.00614231126382947, -0.034094683825969696, 0.00802380871027708, -0.034948304295539856, 0.06208828091621399, 0.014416230842471123, 0.027533190324902534, -0.021733911707997322, 0.0027156402356922626, 0.01576428860425949, -0.0538017638027668, -0.06163094937801361, -0.03559780865907669, -0.0769324004650116, 0.00017428124556317925, -0.03952828422188759, 0.01513521745800972, -0.011895309202373028, -0.0071112955920398235, 0.07036729902029037, -0.02708182856440544, 0.01694430783390999, 0.026832370087504387, -0.007296778727322817, 0.012725583277642727, 0.013578470796346664, 0.01076106633991003, -0.045243751257658005, 0.007998543791472912, -0.0239628404378891, 0.050911612808704376, -0.062215935438871384, -0.049243584275245667, -0.04948980733752251, 0.048926644027233124, -0.01232463214546442, 0.00016457097081001848, -0.013381298631429672, 0.00531806331127882, -0.019853897392749786, 0.055018242448568344, 0.0012964856578037143, 0.05384145304560661, -0.03949308395385742, -0.06916605681180954, -0.007242714054882526, 0.04380624741315842, 0.00630493788048625, -0.008551184087991714, -0.000683287566062063, -0.04970739781856537, -0.0028298876713961363, 0.04724149405956268, -0.022201519459486008, 0.08792183548212051, 0.003316733753308654, -0.0028961272910237312, -0.0028700127732008696, 0.020603559911251068, -0.017987459897994995, 0.044234905391931534, 0.05541885271668434, -0.03089916706085205, -0.015181864611804485, 0.035171255469322205, 0.05601424351334572, 0.01724046841263771, 0.019967176020145416, 0.000924843770917505, 0.0109555684030056, 0.07736153900623322, -0.010238686576485634, 0.049714840948581696, -0.0029459670186042786, -0.015302387066185474, 0.03208888694643974, -0.05552683770656586, 0.07837662100791931, -0.0061821285635232925, 0.006805253215134144, -0.05367222800850868, -0.01657964661717415, -0.01615791767835617, -0.022301875054836273, 0.02582649327814579, -0.03006516583263874, -0.015750721096992493, 0.052795737981796265, -0.022554676979780197, 0.02125505730509758, -0.03210192918777466, -0.06947993487119675, -0.08284870535135269, 0.0302128866314888, -0.07794803380966187, 0.03158560022711754, -0.02284112386405468, -0.025921529158949852, 0.009879542514681816, 0.04636317119002342, -0.0431063212454319, -0.014780412428081036, -0.008450527675449848, 0.036360424011945724, 0.038901008665561676, 0.015679655596613884, -0.002546494361013174, 0.020503371953964233, -0.0021883349400013685, 0.0011816780315712094, -0.01755972020328045, 0.06863559037446976, -0.029477078467607498, 0.04486314207315445, -0.009940454736351967, -0.05110263079404831, -0.02391846664249897, -0.04562626779079437, -0.036980245262384415, -0.001419010222889483, -0.013724978081882, 0.012731501832604408, 0.022279677912592888, 0.024242252111434937, -0.040512192994356155, -0.018366605043411255, -0.04909570887684822, -0.010542219504714012, -0.043189968913793564, 0.06524297595024109, -0.010214476846158504, -0.032266367226839066, -0.009791268967092037, -0.04009583964943886, 0.00935750175267458, -0.01756509579718113, 0.02496849000453949, 0.006245970726013184, 0.05054092779755592, 0.03483757749199867, -0.031178385019302368, -0.0023250887170434, -0.06034879758954048, -0.0021002988796681166, 0.035600751638412476, 0.019007816910743713, 0.04457009211182594, -0.061787258833646774, 0.029841426759958267, 0.024210602045059204, 0.07982681691646576, -0.019264690577983856, -0.01641783118247986, 0.002178595634177327, 0.03262694925069809, -0.012137635610997677, -0.02694878727197647, 0.053228575736284256, 0.03778322413563728, -0.0014622117159888148, 0.013511751778423786, 0.012649113312363625, -0.029420537874102592, -0.04779106006026268, 0.01137152872979641, -0.06716160476207733, -0.0760975182056427, 0.013663060963153839, 0.02837926335632801, -0.04975442960858345, -0.026835624128580093, 0.11398705095052719, -0.014880367554724216, 0.018974782899022102, 0.03390321880578995, -0.03510716184973717, 0.022135833278298378, 0.01586391218006611, 0.08544425666332245, -0.0030952065717428923, -0.057933155447244644, 0.040629640221595764, -0.02179129235446453, 0.045068226754665375, -0.012730692513287067, -0.00011514826474012807, -0.0071958694607019424, 0.021041272208094597, 0.047357793897390366, 0.02628965489566326, -0.03239147737622261, 0.06327393651008606, 0.032422032207250595, -0.026575293391942978, -0.016863875091075897, -0.020362451672554016, -0.009477526880800724, -0.01933431066572666, 0.03521444648504257, -0.0647955909371376, 0.002942776307463646, 0.0639587938785553, 0.05689145624637604, -0.013822159729897976, 0.029353581368923187, -0.04469466954469681, -0.013473419472575188, -0.01931134983897209, 0.019881846383213997, -0.0217872466892004, -0.017124515026807785, -0.020411858335137367, 0.034986890852451324, 0.052007757127285004, 0.051814183592796326, -0.00957290269434452, -0.0274055078625679, 0.008190657012164593, -0.0667291060090065, 0.06909116357564926, -0.0003762207634281367, 0.010183778591454029, 0.0011025917483493686, -0.03223774582147598, 0.03420797362923622, 0.009347822517156601, 0.012790585868060589, 0.023195920512080193, 0.010931243188679218, -0.08969110995531082, 0.022563572973012924, -0.008020385168492794, -0.03415427729487419, 0.03665897250175476, -0.002508441684767604, 0.022064559161663055, 0.017154399305582047, 0.08781258761882782, -0.025699647143483162, -0.00962802954018116, 0.04196220263838768, 0.08034559339284897, 0.08621963113546371, -0.005176639650017023, -0.0354757234454155, -0.0043286713771522045, -0.02220897749066353, -0.022368816658854485, 0.013738149777054787, -0.04806884750723839, 0.03902489319443703, 0.0198383666574955, 0.008935130201280117, -0.026048066094517708, 0.01734687015414238, 0.0011041939724236727, -0.016570603474974632, -0.07814013957977295, -0.017236078158020973, 0.006468977779150009, 0.010134595446288586, -0.02412394993007183, -0.027575964108109474, -0.08115892112255096, -0.005089893937110901, 0.03527488559484482, -0.014940478838980198, -0.010077962651848793, -0.022564871236681938, 0.0268690288066864, -0.008004897274076939, -0.0156400166451931, 0.01205405779182911, 0.0665644109249115, 0.03591814637184143, -0.04212434962391853, -0.05006164312362671, 0.0017689571250230074, 0.010883917100727558, 0.019539179280400276, 0.008474374189972878, 0.010011276230216026, 0.020038893446326256, 0.016123032197356224, -0.020587025210261345, -0.0450897216796875, -0.04568958654999733, -0.002966272411867976, -0.03668734058737755, -0.008411196991801262, -0.03288312256336212, -0.06664052605628967, -0.015791261568665504, 0.032882917672395706, 0.03981325775384903, 0.04971163347363472, -0.02342458814382553, -0.0267364289611578, -0.04603942483663559, -0.021807853132486343, -0.05069388449192047, 0.028072010725736618, -0.017540406435728073, -0.0008285664953291416, 0.0015552977565675974, -0.030476752668619156, 0.09450819343328476, -0.03955502808094025, -0.030417589470744133, 0.059119414538145065, -0.03514451906085014, 0.043081898242235184, -0.03630136325955391, -0.006560927256941795, -0.0029303301125764847, 0.040842581540346146, -0.02931514009833336, -0.03497189283370972, -0.00788062158972025, 0.005870271008461714, 0.015517110005021095, 0.02961341105401516, 0.05427839979529381, -0.02239874191582203, -0.0944809690117836, -0.035202302038669586, -0.042374830693006516, -0.028236739337444305, 0.029974665492773056, -0.05982149392366409, 0.005942554213106632, 0.03476431965827942, 0.042196281254291534, -0.04087941348552704, 0.03250480443239212, -0.000040221060771727934, 0.007293465547263622, 0.04376720264554024, -0.03832467272877693, 0.024866212159395218, -0.04079302027821541, 0.016211040318012238, 0.018734071403741837, -0.01813243329524994, 0.06589412689208984, 0.0006737162475474179, -0.009123146533966064, 0.03362168371677399, 0.04859577864408493, -0.03137575089931488, 0.029475262388586998, -0.0451904833316803, 0.013738841749727726, 0.018900785595178604, -0.03439812362194061, -0.04263584315776825, -0.017977025359869003, 0.03370899707078934, -0.040552668273448944, -0.01562086958438158, -0.04470081254839897, -0.0327724851667881, 0.007596680428832769, -0.001695763785392046, -0.002707534236833453, -0.0030324356630444527, 0.03763503581285477, -0.0021021191496402025, 0.010721314698457718, -0.020905358716845512, 0.00024915882386267185, 0.01564030908048153, -0.009514030069112778, 0.006375287659466267, -0.04498983919620514, -0.024089327082037926, -0.012444107793271542, -0.04632588475942612, -0.02442566677927971, -0.0078947264701128, 0.013364910148084164, 0.002034250646829605, 0.021505199372768402, -0.0907549038529396, -0.014311051927506924, -0.03182873874902725, -0.05441546067595482, 0.044783081859350204, 0.026421530172228813, -0.01575074903666973, 0.016906123608350754, 0.03576509281992912, 0.02931741066277027, -0.00473264092579484, 0.022898707538843155, -0.028078125789761543, 0.02487410604953766, -0.010597428306937218, 0.0022025068756192923, -0.02229023166000843, -0.018003135919570923, 0.015264006331562996, 0.004996143281459808, -0.0037501484621316195, 0.016412852331995964, -0.06620200723409653, -0.062447234988212585, 0.013825828209519386 ]