question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>Is there a general theorem which gives some information about which influence have the lattice geometry (for example sub-lattice structure, square lattice, honeycomb lattice, lattice symmetries, ...) to the dispersion relation in the low-energy regime? </p> <p>For example: graphene or magnons in antiferromagnets. Both have a sub-lattice structure and the dispersion relations are linear.</p>
g9729
[ 0.03739869222044945, 0.015808487311005592, -0.010113251395523548, -0.02277684211730957, -0.007350636646151543, 0.00006972830306040123, 0.012506281957030296, 0.012251301668584347, -0.04002794995903969, -0.019375735893845558, 0.0017641709418967366, 0.03495568409562111, -0.02341930940747261, -0.015921780839562416, -0.04193386435508728, 0.030703824013471603, 0.035459186881780624, 0.0382784865796566, 0.031144076958298683, 0.05644827336072922, -0.03419874235987663, 0.01000992488116026, -0.004191219341009855, -0.035988327115774155, 0.0066908313892781734, 0.03254958987236023, 0.04087771475315094, -0.0678066611289978, -0.05219203606247902, 0.0075330305844545364, 0.06021798029541969, -0.03676726669073105, 0.06644100695848465, -0.04675103351473808, -0.03871501237154007, -0.01871638372540474, 0.041435357183218, -0.03127792477607727, 0.0053100185468792915, -0.018294723704457283, 0.0009801659034565091, -0.018767166882753372, 0.0034353192895650864, 0.0028432023245841265, -0.018137773498892784, 0.009519653394818306, -0.04258452728390694, -0.00014526097220368683, -0.01983318291604519, -0.003574265632778406, 0.012280531227588654, 0.05167003720998764, 0.040542978793382645, 0.009690694510936737, 0.027071379125118256, -0.022424686700105667, -0.0013346531195566058, -0.026826437562704086, 0.06572053581476212, -0.005734910722821951, -0.04060358926653862, 0.050005052238702774, -0.04520975053310394, 0.04847661405801773, 0.03009011037647724, 0.006253125611692667, -0.09220647066831589, -0.0371008925139904, 0.007363361306488514, 0.001026482437737286, 0.017651421949267387, -0.0459144227206707, -0.005994467996060848, -0.017455056309700012, 0.01253680232912302, -0.029329264536499977, 0.026451606303453445, -0.0060381037183105946, -0.003414813196286559, 0.001889687729999423, -0.031870175153017044, 0.029777398332953453, 0.024245087057352066, -0.0048099602572619915, 0.05469874292612076, 0.00011294458818156272, 0.0022120673675090075, -0.012689033523201942, 0.004908375907689333, 0.04014921933412552, 0.025300374254584312, -0.0019354941323399544, 0.02996324934065342, -0.015700336545705795, -0.06058414652943611, 0.07536741346120834, 0.03638036921620369, -0.00025102021754719317, -0.057291317731142044, -0.009422805160284042, -0.02038291096687317, 0.018289566040039062, -0.014943909831345081, 0.02075747400522232, 0.015031686052680016, 0.011095237918198109, -0.01041482761502266, -0.050490736961364746, 0.015036108903586864, 0.038318220525979996, -0.025696134194731712, 0.0035930429585278034, -0.04797230660915375, 0.0549127496778965, -0.04869295284152031, -0.04480334371328354, 0.07085538655519485, -0.06093310937285423, 0.014260170049965382, 0.03501315787434578, 0.07608839869499207, 0.016383888199925423, -0.036655258387327194, 0.07309180498123169, -0.014181433245539665, -0.027814697474241257, 0.0019474511500447989, 0.05644010752439499, 0.022068630903959274, 0.009473862126469612, 0.03163163736462593, -0.024152154102921486, -0.010308204218745232, 0.040085408836603165, -0.012742406688630581, 0.0022065965458750725, -0.0015571062685921788, 0.03208523616194725, 0.00037864354089833796, 0.004235990811139345, -0.026697680354118347, -0.005897603463381529, -0.007236947771161795, -0.07403801381587982, -0.02898389659821987, -0.018412884324789047, 0.04289799928665161, 0.005768144968897104, 0.007011940702795982, 0.03817916288971901, -0.0028781136497855186, 0.015588457696139812, -0.0340593196451664, -0.035003796219825745, 0.011310502886772156, 0.03483280912041664, 0.006052474491298199, -0.027375325560569763, 0.045932378619909286, -0.00939648225903511, 0.01738688349723816, 0.010470178909599781, 0.0034650624729692936, 0.029260553419589996, 0.008204384706914425, -0.06798674166202545, 0.011776951141655445, -0.02294769696891308, -0.024145549163222313, 0.019782157614827156, -0.07542453706264496, 0.02577953040599823, -0.03474290668964386, 0.06078076362609863, 0.02848273329436779, 0.04538304731249809, -0.030019186437129974, -0.07273657619953156, 0.04096478596329689, -0.0057284291833639145, -0.002859404543414712, 0.004494126886129379, 0.01268155686557293, -0.026799019426107407, -0.012388053350150585, 0.07318318635225296, -0.003518099896609783, -0.04315496236085892, -0.01969326101243496, -0.005043238867074251, 0.018160128965973854, 0.0000627984045422636, -0.030422603711485863, -0.05706637352705002, 0.022766685113310814, -0.03424088656902313, 0.044248394668102264, 0.06288241595029831, -0.05108145251870155, -0.0014313962310552597, 0.009621718898415565, -0.0019459087634459138, 0.0542650930583477, -0.007957903668284416, 0.027843590825796127, 0.02553517557680607, -0.05185293033719063, 0.007586182095110416, 0.06587118655443192, -0.021898889914155006, -0.028234468773007393, -0.03318028897047043, 0.024787912145256996, -0.018818030133843422, 0.01793360710144043, -0.029210440814495087, 0.0028252366464585066, -0.007071203086525202, 0.012003561481833458, 0.0498436838388443, -0.04462611302733421, 0.03244534507393837, 0.04515707492828369, 0.04346416890621185, -0.013604974374175072, -0.051273275166749954, 0.04405422508716583, 0.02277875877916813, 0.004923347383737564, -0.06366840749979019, -0.052142251282930374, -0.027591634541749954, 0.01038353331387043, -0.07390011847019196, 0.003745189169421792, -0.021644970402121544, -0.031275760382413864, -0.04061175882816315, 0.0322793610394001, -0.002741666743531823, -0.030575523152947426, -0.0058014546521008015, -0.059025101363658905, -0.01948232389986515, 0.006625957787036896, -0.026050036773085594, 0.06201304495334625, -0.002527465345337987, 0.011903868056833744, -0.003145885653793812, 0.04486558958888054, 0.022370146587491035, -0.03661040961742401, -0.0044954512268304825, -0.018738262355327606, 0.00012965268979314715, -0.08640371263027191, 0.009888474829494953, -0.06355521082878113, -0.058937303721904755, 0.03700252249836922, -0.03302701562643051, 0.007102371193468571, -0.0104767344892025, -0.018841419368982315, -0.016186103224754333, 0.03487324342131615, 0.053179383277893066, -0.022873925045132637, 0.012180302292108536, 0.010402834042906761, 0.09550115466117859, -0.01656429097056389, 0.022584496065974236, -0.06093185767531395, -0.03699604794383049, 0.0476696640253067, -0.02562948502600193, -0.006235014647245407, 0.026270616799592972, -0.0063044726848602295, -0.0694378986954689, -0.04482030123472214, -0.010310470126569271, 0.01569431461393833, -0.012594928964972496, 0.007430842146277428, -0.042473576962947845, -0.03125004842877388, 0.014977320097386837, -0.03295589238405228, -0.0029584039002656937, 0.05650056153535843, 0.03152152895927429, 0.029913878068327904, -0.016418959945440292, 0.02692166343331337, -0.001968235010281205, -0.02916616201400757, 0.02657465822994709, 0.015580011531710625, -0.004886241164058447, 0.006908707320690155, 0.020684512332081795, 0.006369400769472122, 0.028601571917533875, -0.020594699308276176, -0.06960567086935043, -0.036922626197338104, -0.03676265850663185, -0.05544954538345337, 0.031129295006394386, 0.0204774159938097, 0.041652120649814606, -0.0008030545432120562, 0.06415018439292908, 0.0032542843837291002, 0.03246290981769562, 0.015966160222887993, -0.06222386285662651, -0.0064668357372283936, 0.004503829870373011, 0.024092596024274826, -0.05111479386687279, -0.03141310438513756, 0.03287609666585922, -0.04358891397714615, 0.043192584067583084, -0.016952622681856155, 0.011180654168128967, 0.0024899481795728207, -0.045553065836429596, 0.012294512242078781, -0.013127385638654232, -0.04469577595591545, -0.005156878847628832, -0.00444690091535449, -0.032381944358348846, -0.03119252249598503, 0.02038225717842579, -0.023798514157533646, 0.0014682046603411436, -0.04962320998311043, 0.01800578087568283, 0.041541390120983124, -0.0008329219999723136, -0.04482517018914223, 0.012526082806289196, -0.045261695981025696, 0.009815137833356857, -0.030339764431118965, -0.04741976782679558, 0.06409134715795517, 0.0333002507686615, -0.016528265550732613, -0.05797561630606651, 0.03515080735087395, 0.009047536179423332, -0.0007818498415872455, -0.03154202178120613, 0.01418288890272379, 0.003407735377550125, 0.03024018555879593, -0.03240055590867996, -0.0022419593296945095, 0.050305116921663284, -0.003204174106940627, 0.05517129972577095, -0.02267342433333397, -0.015341067686676979, -0.026862850412726402, -0.04347721114754677, -0.03184681385755539, -0.0227864608168602, 0.045756347477436066, -0.014684796333312988, -0.019442740827798843, -0.029062574729323387, -0.06599731743335724, -0.029093651100993156, 0.0044536585919559, 0.038904160261154175, 0.03004387579858303, 0.010645993985235691, 0.019716449081897736, -0.053372833877801895, -0.06354645639657974, 0.024888109415769577, -0.04763491451740265, -0.02647661417722702, -0.06147502735257149, -0.03602582588791847, -0.020191628485918045, 0.02629111148416996, 0.023483887314796448, 0.015117986127734184, 0.02500756084918976, -0.008427880704402924, 0.023024599999189377, 0.052237872034311295, -0.0013353205285966396, 0.026537034660577774, -0.04632572829723358, -0.03448450565338135, 0.07627304643392563, 0.0031101638451218605, 0.007256465032696724, 0.0013624208513647318, -0.030852138996124268, -0.008229464292526245, 0.027856597676873207, -0.014484819024801254, -0.02226468361914158, -0.04944350942969322, -0.019364474341273308, -0.041825614869594574, 0.0003992288839071989, -0.051149338483810425, 0.025696611031889915, -0.005066358018666506, 0.04751339182257652, 0.11473166197538376, 0.021763836964964867, -0.0001311181695200503, 0.0037119193002581596, 0.035947006195783615, 0.03478292375802994, -0.07975849509239197, -0.048090722411870956, -0.009081603959202766, -0.003760346444323659, 0.012940903194248676, -0.001987728988751769, -0.018732966855168343, -0.034607842564582825, -0.027799736708402634, -0.041291460394859314, 0.05415317043662071, 0.023829812183976173, 0.025853289291262627, 0.07016557455062866, 0.06674531102180481, 0.027242502197623253, -0.005858493968844414, -0.013223542831838131, 0.03629833459854126, -0.07488422840833664, -0.026395993307232857, 0.007745277136564255, -0.008766477927565575, 0.05315528064966202, -0.0000010397480991741759, 0.013089717365801334, -0.0799211859703064, -0.036418016999959946, 0.0006951277027837932, -0.025887826457619667, 0.033528100699186325, 0.09313350915908813, 0.019267210736870766, -0.0012408063048496842, 0.04538697749376297, -0.055516067892313004, 0.024227717891335487, -0.002782174851745367, 0.047119226306676865, -0.029457291588187218, 0.014218171127140522, -0.054904695600271225, -0.046458784490823746, -0.0001718171697575599, 0.022849470376968384, -0.018604718148708344, 0.01654791459441185, 0.019690407440066338, 0.039308421313762665, -0.023864230141043663, -0.024160753935575485, -0.02107640542089939, -0.008716018870472908, -0.00891945045441389, 0.0329853780567646, 0.053260620683431625, -0.050857674330472946, 0.03183308243751526, -0.011278914287686348, 0.020830487832427025, 0.026466595008969307, 0.021668529137969017, -0.04448876902461052, 0.03475058451294899, -0.03047061711549759, -0.02499924972653389, 0.0680617094039917, -0.036515261977910995, -0.04761609435081482, 0.04443652927875519, -0.014632542617619038, 0.0531085804104805, -0.0015844418667256832, -0.017078744247555733, 0.04984230920672417, 0.04207954928278923, 0.004125005099922419, -0.0576808825135231, 0.05203888565301895, 0.10561619699001312, -0.07555574178695679, -0.005624850746244192, -0.0392441563308239, -0.08547143638134003, 0.017718592658638954, 0.005047088023275137, 0.031792838126420975, -0.026191430166363716, -0.011031853035092354, -0.06034821644425392, 0.01629127562046051, 0.029625246301293373, -0.01255956944078207, 0.019940827041864395, 0.008774899877607822, 0.008383986540138721, -0.023718509823083878, -0.021043548360466957, -0.008325297385454178, -0.029642468318343163, -0.004478835500776768, 0.05195525661110878, 0.019762422889471054, 0.013741993345320225, 0.039497118443250656, 0.0039778356440365314, 0.05730752274394035, 0.026244331151247025, -0.0419197641313076, -0.007682056166231632, 0.042367544025182724, 0.010800995863974094, 0.002254433697089553, -0.019220681861042976, -0.01865009032189846, 0.036061860620975494, 0.06428069621324539, 0.053690388798713684, -0.0005776123143732548, 0.000464432843727991, 0.006049453280866146, 0.020264970138669014, 0.012095862068235874, 0.0034576761536300182, 0.006554967258125544, 0.0001262784790014848, 0.0009912217501550913, -0.020356761291623116, -0.02011098526418209, -0.013780569657683372, -0.0027393032796680927, 0.01993394084274769, 0.050219710916280746, 0.059256672859191895, 0.02743064984679222, 0.03753931075334549, -0.015498933382332325, 0.0003819260746240616, -0.048969924449920654, -0.03861161693930626, -0.05076809227466583, 0.04990823194384575, -0.002555543789640069, 0.00571600254625082, -0.025138700380921364, -0.005185986403375864, 0.001040949602611363, 0.005447927862405777, -0.01546703651547432, 0.001988764852285385, -0.10031179338693619, -0.03864523023366928, 0.02416788786649704, -0.021500399336218834, 0.056593265384435654, -0.04777290299534798, 0.008730471134185791, -0.008190317079424858, 0.0341203548014164, 0.02530624531209469, 0.05045349895954132, -0.01574210450053215, -0.03594326600432396, 0.012434303760528564, -0.018144477158784866, -0.02919100597500801, 0.022067347541451454, 0.00022209598682820797, -0.004389200825244188, 0.003764672437682748, 0.012006745673716068, -0.013210936449468136, 0.0689433291554451, 0.054144445806741714, -0.06420054286718369, 0.04432668536901474, 0.003910415805876255, 0.01896657980978489, 0.045906394720077515, 0.07152300328016281, 0.007419017143547535, -0.053542546927928925, -0.003900132142007351, 0.006842224393039942, 0.039646752178668976, 0.08243001997470856, 0.0236816443502903, 0.06300365179777145, -0.09295506775379181, -0.10730361193418503, -0.04571652412414551, -0.019062338396906853, -0.08716274052858353, -0.06591799110174179, -0.05680881068110466, -0.07639727741479874, -0.02836671471595764, 0.059193048626184464, 0.023018497973680496, -0.04601490497589111, 0.0069521451368927956, 0.03762787953019142, -0.00898084044456482, -0.012316680513322353, 0.02821565419435501, 0.0020600631833076477, 0.03674826771020889, 0.0019072456052526832, -0.010611118748784065, -0.0501503124833107, 0.014449679292738438, 0.037892021238803864, 0.05137008801102638, 0.0071622407995164394, 0.03735150396823883, 0.01025010272860527, -0.02915172092616558, 0.006319970823824406, -0.025678562000393867, -0.015979614108800888, 0.0219557024538517, 0.06952357292175293, -0.015215343795716763, 0.026439445093274117, -0.023400701582431793, -0.05185019597411156, 0.05497371405363083, -0.002463648561388254, -0.03977019339799881, 0.0340549498796463, 0.019084829837083817, 0.03193460404872894, -0.019190743565559387, -0.11649985611438751, 0.0006126027437858284, 0.02780476026237011, -0.004546268377453089, -0.04615112021565437, -0.010748364962637424, 0.036118168383836746, -0.02908347174525261, -0.04249509051442146, -0.03230786696076393, -0.06585291028022766, -0.06604810804128647, 0.008381732739508152, -0.006446346640586853, 0.048284512013196945, -0.038396041840314865, -0.0450945645570755, -0.015340005978941917, -0.007999656721949577, -0.02667710930109024, -0.004975148476660252, 0.05327795445919037, 0.07731184363365173, 0.008065278641879559, -0.01737656630575657, 0.03901652246713638, -0.03401365131139755, -0.009648557752370834, -0.022437309846282005, -0.05648390203714371, 0.0061341580003499985, 0.003645005403086543, 0.043204788118600845, -0.0159799475222826, -0.028303291648626328, -0.010043258778750896, 0.030054204165935516, 0.0857817679643631, -0.03527732193470001, -0.0001179739847430028, 0.015801072120666504, 0.017379771918058395, -0.054526038467884064, 0.047079913318157196, 0.005519387312233448, -0.0227557010948658, 0.02186592109501362, -0.01168773602694273, -0.036956749856472015, -0.01961299031972885, 0.016724273562431335, 0.04462846741080284, 0.06793496757745743, 0.0662253275513649, 0.09114596992731094, 0.05895375832915306, -0.012650194577872753, -0.019365917891263962, 0.0018869462655857205, 0.07357332855463028, -0.017427045851945877, -0.02922738529741764, 0.038617540150880814, -0.10651545971632004, 0.000568068353459239, -0.04989209398627281, -0.00228872406296432, -0.05787641555070877, 0.042708199471235275, 0.0394599474966526, 0.01202391181141138, -0.016516709700226784, -0.015281641855835915, 0.048460815101861954, -0.020472221076488495, 0.050981555134058, 0.03074582852423191, -0.045713815838098526, 0.05358048155903816, 0.020801611244678497, -0.02222871407866478, 0.037281204015016556, 0.04877638816833496, -0.017458437010645866, 0.016762102022767067, 0.004239749629050493, 0.01767834648489952, -0.005307890009135008, 0.023601097986102104, -0.015834761783480644, -0.08214282989501953, 0.025267815217375755, 0.035534944385290146, -0.04363749921321869, 0.0005906797596253455, -0.017924970015883446, 0.021858947351574898, 0.004268954508006573, 0.015517034567892551, -0.011060572229325771, 0.010811185464262962, 0.009061270393431187, 0.014246268197894096, 0.05658959597349167, -0.04036518931388855, 0.05341053381562233, -0.019406264647841454, -0.01097211055457592 ]
<p>Im studying anisotropic system composed by a elastic matrix (Young modulus $E_m$) filled with oriented rods. </p> <p>Given this filler orientation, the material is elastic-anisotropic, with Young elastic modulus $E_\parallel$ in the direction of the rods orientation and $E_\perp$ in the transversal direction of the oriented rods. </p> <p>If we set the axis $z$ like the direction of the rods orientation, then $E_\parallel = E_z$ and $E_\perp = E_x = E_y$. </p> <p>I know the stress -strain curves for the material in $z$ and $x$ (or $y$) directions. </p> <p>Given the initial position of the rods, how can I obtain the final positions of the rods if a stress $\sigma$ is applied in the $z$ direction?</p>
g9730
[ 0.03401017189025879, -0.005021622404456139, -0.011666612699627876, -0.04963034391403198, 0.04659685492515564, -0.04264141619205475, 0.04652069881558418, -0.019513996317982674, -0.018292436376214027, 0.03950543701648712, -0.02382446639239788, 0.006883010268211365, -0.003104005241766572, -0.03918466717004776, 0.0450434610247612, -0.025996048003435135, 0.10652177780866623, 0.026717007160186768, 0.053528495132923126, 0.0064288112334907055, -0.02568903937935829, -0.04120030626654625, 0.00901910662651062, 0.018816564232110977, 0.045047491788864136, -0.018433578312397003, 0.03014715388417244, 0.0006361264386214316, -0.013128098100423813, 0.0034908547531813383, 0.020170312374830246, -0.024381009861826897, 0.05854488164186478, -0.013044223189353943, -0.005760427098721266, 0.017266934737563133, 0.037319742143154144, -0.01738426461815834, 0.032287538051605225, 0.0025789400096982718, -0.07316675037145615, -0.0391344390809536, -0.023557698354125023, 0.018243974074721336, -0.004416829906404018, -0.0574246384203434, -0.042359549552202225, 0.027333728969097137, -0.0036420735996216536, -0.010751460678875446, 0.03321005031466484, 0.03482391685247421, 0.05410809814929962, -0.05551335960626602, 0.004698991775512695, 0.013161956332623959, 0.01443163026124239, 0.032664984464645386, 0.04965551197528839, 0.040522582828998566, 0.017511339858174324, -0.00892582442611456, -0.017626408487558365, -0.021004438400268555, 0.006319081876426935, 0.012528553605079651, 0.005009819753468037, 0.01366809569299221, -0.02468070387840271, -0.003904256271198392, 0.03120299056172371, 0.0127719109877944, 0.08860669285058975, -0.02748900093138218, -0.10890717059373856, -0.016480321064591408, -0.0010775820119306445, -0.02507142908871174, -0.008196813054382801, -0.03257264941930771, -0.024611717090010643, 0.03192843869328499, 0.04221610724925995, -0.061376769095659256, 0.059667304158210754, 0.030475297942757607, 0.07670048624277115, 0.02429545484483242, 0.0006178191979415715, 0.005918137263506651, 0.02903791144490242, 0.029422251507639885, -0.03379221633076668, 0.04166005551815033, 0.021547304466366768, -0.07415716350078583, -0.04163482040166855, 0.03467150777578354, 0.03493216633796692, -0.07019255310297012, -0.00718647288158536, -0.012777132913470268, -0.0270643699914217, -0.0063884062692523, -0.01538048218935728, 0.037700966000556946, 0.010747772641479969, 0.010829048231244087, -0.027963997796177864, 0.01244425680488348, -0.06513198465108871, 0.020536230877041817, -0.030630236491560936, -0.005521425977349281, -0.005094572901725769, 0.06616614013910294, 0.01968715712428093, 0.0018562402110546827, 0.004953933414071798, 0.028116751462221146, 0.043993640691041946, -0.002371055306866765, 0.02500196360051632, 0.0361308753490448, -0.005598500370979309, 0.0026763761416077614, -0.010399973019957542, 0.020874500274658203, 0.04270867258310318, -0.016600223258137703, -0.02783966436982155, -0.02556661330163479, 0.09443984925746918, -0.0018824798753485084, -0.024484427645802498, 0.031963881105184555, -0.034079525619745255, -0.003848087741062045, 0.02887856401503086, 0.06878145039081573, -0.04141390323638916, -0.0436212532222271, 0.0006395718082785606, 0.04877524822950363, -0.016385279595851898, -0.059072621166706085, 0.009325938299298286, -0.018680112436413765, 0.0324396975338459, 0.03276164457201958, 0.011012633331120014, 0.03434410318732262, -0.021134234964847565, 0.01663840375840664, -0.03166615590453148, -0.008585242554545403, -0.031977102160453796, -0.04764886572957039, 0.020994534716010094, -0.01838817447423935, -0.008617080748081207, -0.0031773021910339594, -0.0014530627522617579, 0.00788356363773346, -0.025851218029856682, -0.022002551704645157, -0.036473989486694336, -0.04559924453496933, 0.030936017632484436, 0.0045786588452756405, -0.08008765429258347, 0.004316803999245167, 0.014866014942526817, -0.0026671169325709343, 0.01968788541853428, 0.10482017695903778, -0.008014212362468243, -0.04110081493854523, 0.11562106758356094, 0.06479601562023163, 0.019299054518342018, 0.02985350601375103, 0.06134676933288574, 0.025989163666963577, -0.012674938887357712, -0.05171431601047516, 0.04691410809755325, 0.0070371972396969795, -0.09044533967971802, 0.06598851829767227, 0.001309831626713276, 0.00907351728528738, -0.007314045913517475, 0.026068218052387238, -0.04508276283740997, -0.05812106654047966, 0.0031847497448325157, -0.030157389119267464, -0.04279101639986038, 0.03994941711425781, 0.07776883989572525, 0.013205264694988728, 0.03196200355887413, 0.0011297519085928798, -0.04982684925198555, 0.005723526701331139, -0.0173947773873806, 0.017062624916434288, 0.012867983430624008, 0.05000760033726692, -0.021235914900898933, -0.012232755310833454, 0.01350245252251625, 0.029372354969382286, -0.01207972876727581, 0.003951617982238531, 0.05622868239879608, 0.017755301669239998, -0.028717882931232452, 0.06944207102060318, -0.00168340012896806, 0.013758239336311817, 0.01811889186501503, 0.005586650688201189, -0.002386902691796422, -0.025838354602456093, 0.0314830057322979, -0.001679150853306055, -0.020665517076849937, -0.021276826038956642, -0.04288538917899132, 0.004218706861138344, 0.051648207008838654, 0.028689773753285408, 0.05436898395419121, -0.0033538092393428087, 0.01615474559366703, 0.05101887881755829, -0.0005274313152767718, 0.01269377302378416, -0.02447771094739437, 0.03122716024518013, 0.027896519750356674, 0.012286587618291378, -0.0019643735140562057, -0.00708868820220232, 0.026717383414506912, -0.054113682359457016, 0.027550823986530304, 0.0626794621348381, 0.07115748524665833, 0.007505651563405991, -0.024729304015636444, 0.004070641938596964, 0.003962366841733456, -0.03552519157528877, -0.09146416187286377, 0.009461960755288601, 0.004124573897570372, -0.06372563540935516, -0.012480826117098331, 0.040933359414339066, 0.06886663287878036, -0.015206629410386086, -0.021747108548879623, 0.028099801391363144, -0.03609192743897438, -0.11726325750350952, 0.05908709764480591, 0.03226182982325554, -0.033807702362537384, 0.012816494330763817, 0.05795666575431824, 0.055230963975191116, 0.07540127635002136, -0.05655280500650406, 0.02637532725930214, 0.03460779786109924, -0.03879620507359505, 0.02449960634112358, -0.013285176828503609, -0.008131247945129871, -0.00024163397029042244, 0.028629103675484657, -0.005030772183090448, -0.007591578643769026, 0.06561929732561111, -0.0037597527261823416, -0.017501236870884895, 0.012679725885391235, -0.05955692008137703, 0.022578556090593338, 0.013760830275714397, 0.004294733516871929, 0.0025797723792493343, 0.019279154017567635, 0.022774798795580864, -0.03139849007129669, -0.044022075831890106, 0.04590305685997009, -0.08161531388759613, -0.003220628947019577, 0.01708625629544258, -0.016487017273902893, 0.0427168644964695, 0.025818299502134323, -0.04770274832844734, -0.060729168355464935, 0.02802593633532524, -0.009163297712802887, -0.02830924093723297, -0.03150757774710655, 0.06162617355585098, -0.009450677782297134, -0.02709740586578846, 0.06808623671531677, -0.027607198804616928, -0.07200928777456284, 0.012836660258471966, 0.020976830273866653, -0.03958559036254883, 0.042399827390909195, 0.020471222698688507, 0.03926107659935951, -0.014093064703047276, 0.02534329704940319, 0.004360885825008154, 0.038359787315130234, -0.0643865093588829, 0.01835077628493309, 0.02123885601758957, 0.01940368488430977, -0.03315837308764458, -0.02125333622097969, -0.022558577358722687, -0.014495495706796646, -0.08983980119228363, -0.008911448530852795, -0.025514813140034676, 0.021154997870326042, -0.04403620585799217, 0.007962848991155624, 0.0911789983510971, 0.042333878576755524, -0.043799515813589096, -0.01609773188829422, 0.00978561956435442, 0.03853895887732506, 0.027863996103405952, 0.018625594675540924, -0.04367682710289955, 0.015651704743504524, -0.028659062460064888, -0.02303311601281166, 0.006185689475387335, 0.041670385748147964, 0.07292956858873367, -0.002252854174003005, -0.008168204687535763, -0.01384058315306902, -0.028066080063581467, -0.06764909625053406, -0.06771591305732727, -0.02026563137769699, 0.06671717762947083, 0.03181188926100731, 0.021137097850441933, 0.016217250376939774, 0.02883751690387726, 0.02113277278840542, 0.004902251996099949, -0.037164315581321716, 0.03724116459488869, -0.0295778326690197, -0.0294690802693367, -0.06575779616832733, -0.01922704465687275, 0.04123158007860184, -0.047045595943927765, 0.030166590586304665, 0.016945907846093178, -0.023752106353640556, -0.04271748289465904, 0.0051880585961043835, -0.010893338359892368, 0.008689425885677338, 0.042643893510103226, 0.02667788788676262, -0.019022315740585327, 0.02244463376700878, -0.004422295838594437, -0.04047644883394241, -0.0062732701189816, 0.06434701383113861, 0.03545861318707466, -0.03880774602293968, 0.021270669996738434, 0.00798614602535963, -0.05166027322411537, -0.03702102601528168, -0.015763577073812485, 0.013758987188339233, 0.04746091738343239, -0.007414611987769604, -0.0317094586789608, -0.0020177296828478575, -0.026430167257785797, -0.00915374793112278, 0.0006390124326571822, -0.0383102186024189, 0.02789951302111149, -0.03791900351643562, 0.028780611231923103, -0.02643938735127449, 0.07386475056409836, 0.02113102376461029, 0.023450134322047234, 0.00780272763222456, 0.025487061589956284, -0.017353875562548637, 0.01778373494744301, 0.022689932957291603, 0.028522150591015816, -0.0993579849600792, 0.03640463575720787, 0.04590549319982529, 0.019518941640853882, -0.06173086166381836, 0.06858751177787781, -0.041099533438682556, -0.025593189522624016, -0.017153579741716385, 0.03581411391496658, -0.08392006158828735, -0.0006088863592594862, 0.018768204376101494, 0.01347839180380106, -0.04510188102722168, 0.01894035004079342, 0.01482621394097805, -0.025403453037142754, -0.002335880184546113, -0.002364612417295575, -0.01358976773917675, -0.021797966212034225, -0.011405473574995995, -0.035503797233104706, -0.0008400421356782317, -0.006207451224327087, -0.059170108288526535, -0.04756741598248482, -0.04450945556163788, 0.01954229362308979, -0.04639916867017746, -0.008872656151652336, -0.010836481116712093, -0.026993002742528915, -0.010345189832150936, 0.01957084983587265, -0.014851171523332596, -0.004583686124533415, -0.04852854833006859, -0.027458636090159416, -0.0034898382145911455, 0.004075434058904648, -0.008292133919894695, 0.01686711050570011, 0.017108144238591194, -0.03588993847370148, 0.06407768279314041, 0.02188814803957939, 0.013134804554283619, 0.03822022303938866, -0.01200826745480299, -0.011267311871051788, -0.004209277220070362, -0.021530766040086746, -0.012770408764481544, -0.04449168220162392, -0.013080843724310398, -0.02627655677497387, -0.015946073457598686, 0.01393323577940464, -0.0660727247595787, -0.007948610000312328, -0.07968100905418396, -0.05388327315449715, -0.02746710367500782, -0.024145768955349922, 0.008346084505319595, -0.013083714060485363, 0.023096129298210144, -0.059485066682100296, -0.05323603004217148, -0.012505115941166878, -0.05128197371959686, 0.0016779931029304862, -0.027762513607740402, -0.036483388394117355, 0.0028953158762305975, -0.03605513647198677, 0.02757170982658863, -0.04067375883460045, 0.03032761439681053, -0.018507525324821472, 0.056167591363191605, 0.03780679404735565, -0.02249685488641262, 0.015657657757401466, -0.015360518358647823, 0.039407879114151, 0.004359216894954443, 0.03870634362101555, -0.00566868344321847, 0.006253974512219429, 0.0005704321665689349, -0.041887447237968445, 0.05168672651052475, -0.03727222979068756, 0.03952454403042793, -0.030835453420877457, 0.04867713525891304, -0.014776679687201977, -0.045336294919252396, -0.03470085561275482, -0.009971682913601398, -0.021949972957372665, -0.02808745950460434, -0.02756633423268795, -0.009374825283885002, -0.0631546601653099, -0.0041870311833918095, 0.008249837905168533, 0.03970238193869591, 0.018293676897883415, -0.019830621778964996, 0.013587282970547676, -0.023578833788633347, 0.02437850460410118, -0.05902448669075966, 0.0494864322245121, -0.0717817172408104, 0.0695892870426178, 0.03417687863111496, -0.10756038874387741, 0.03576359525322914, -0.021008839830756187, -0.024107225239276886, 0.022322753444314003, -0.047001902014017105, -0.04768505319952965, 0.08748657256364822, -0.009032887406647205, 0.03583534434437752, 0.012895695865154266, 0.033911969512701035, -0.0002649298985488713, -0.023244211450219154, -0.007669201120734215, -0.02695511281490326, 0.01095957774668932, -0.06753601133823395, -0.03914039954543114, 0.015046954154968262, -0.0025314707309007645, 0.021316781640052795, -0.006626547779887915, 0.05251941457390785, 0.07214323431253433, 0.008513173088431358, 0.06266829371452332, -0.058907702565193176, 0.02734762243926525, 0.053205519914627075, 0.05273519456386566, -0.0026172753423452377, -0.03730566427111626, -0.0012777629308402538, 0.003990910481661558, 0.06575479358434677, 0.028860175982117653, 0.020295459777116776, -0.03446289896965027, 0.08397436141967773, 0.04175670072436333, 0.07613535225391388, 0.029926836490631104, -0.06574361026287079, 0.03099130466580391, -0.029697701334953308, -0.06065642088651657, -0.03829876706004143, -0.03502209112048149, 0.06928148865699768, -0.016109416261315346, 0.020484013482928276, 0.051832787692546844, 0.07250446081161499, 0.06154664605855942, 0.10251559317111969, -0.0074600949883461, -0.027382072061300278, 0.05759822204709053, -0.013729363679885864, 0.06196775287389755, -0.04621219262480736, 0.011442036367952824, 0.02137431502342224, -0.01678091287612915, -0.0539097785949707, 0.015826405957341194, 0.050744518637657166, -0.02328222244977951, 0.07864082604646683, 0.05589370056986809, -0.012010559439659119, -0.021973544731736183, 0.03975153714418411, -0.009167639538645744, -0.0034885338973253965, 0.03228815644979477, 0.017775746062397957, -0.005939948372542858, -0.049250148236751556, -0.014465400017797947, -0.02027120441198349, -0.06546588987112045, -0.04815767705440521, 0.008327506482601166, -0.03203889727592468, 0.013821343891322613, 0.013746870681643486, -0.027943797409534454, 0.014962229877710342, -0.009949494153261185, -0.002343022031709552, 0.004390891175717115, 0.023007206618785858, -0.0030375593341886997, 0.06465140730142593, -0.012845284305512905, 0.014667096547782421, -0.000664475723169744, 0.03520529344677925, -0.02752063050866127, 0.009121797047555447, 0.00040081029874272645, -0.03710401803255081, -0.061689283698797226, 0.017853284254670143, -0.009508272632956505, -0.015346036292612553, 0.006065598223358393, -0.0037133595906198025, 0.010915464721620083, 0.02971288561820984, -0.03523977845907211, -0.025037258863449097, 0.01572173275053501, 0.019526787102222443, -0.031340938061475754, 0.03646588698029518, -0.0012631223071366549, -0.001547912135720253, -0.0317520834505558, 0.010235287249088287, 0.0384475439786911, -0.04839625209569931, -0.01720230095088482, 0.015389464795589447, 0.004811276216059923, -0.06482668966054916, 0.014249499887228012, 0.02854262664914131, 0.010712728835642338, 0.012016700580716133, -0.02040700614452362, 0.006725855637341738, -0.06287279725074768, -0.00625273771584034, -0.04924741014838219, 0.0018093357793986797, -0.0276415403932333, -0.020727870985865593, 0.04215919226408005, 0.0019013375276699662, 0.04966495558619499, -0.02440614253282547, -0.04485103860497475, -0.035070352256298065, 0.005484537687152624, -0.0032763176131993532, -0.004938873928040266, 0.006942387670278549, -0.0023563376162201166, -0.029167449101805687, 0.028199460357427597, 0.02948572300374508, -0.03224571794271469, 0.009506392292678356, -0.000025676252334960736, -0.04949585720896721, -0.057129308581352234, 0.029818246141076088, -0.0362725593149662, -0.03380052000284195, -0.07624001055955887, 0.03774556517601013, 0.005676360335201025, 0.015477749519050121, -0.05083337798714638, -0.011090005747973919, -0.009949423372745514, -0.017116742208600044, -0.017357775941491127, 0.0061329444870352745, -0.0704566165804863, 0.04356496036052704, 0.040186285972595215, -0.001454484066925943, -0.03461051359772682, 0.02500901184976101, -0.006506177131086588, -0.013986511155962944, -0.07145129889249802, 0.023388633504509926, -0.0002383712271694094, 0.02831958793103695, -0.03732875734567642, -0.015661239624023438, 0.020239612087607384, -0.015089873224496841, 0.0026668503414839506, 0.0481821708381176, -0.00764972111210227, -0.0388900451362133, -0.02039279043674469, -0.039542462676763535, 0.005461685825139284, -0.00841502659022808, -0.008045879192650318, -0.031098835170269012, -0.04065638408064842, -0.03814426809549332, 0.03799081966280937, 0.06198429316282272, -0.055978670716285706, 0.05090969428420067, -0.013468529097735882, -0.023221157491207123, -0.05855473875999451, -0.034503091126680374, 0.027830995619297028, 0.005450972355902195, -0.005575182847678661, 0.023984747007489204, 0.03616900369524956, -0.010785873048007488, 0.011170527897775173, 0.01580078899860382, 0.01165144331753254, 0.008552292361855507, -0.03101702779531479, -0.0013232268393039703, 0.01803204044699669, 0.019309787079691887, -0.03362709656357765, -0.00899508036673069 ]
<p>The BICEP experiment's recent announcement included the preprint of their paper,</p> <blockquote> <p>BICEP2 I: Detection of $B$-mode polarization at degree angular scales. BICEP2 Collaboration. To be submitted. <a href="http://bicepkeck.org/b2_respap_arxiv_v1.pdf" rel="nofollow">BICEP-Keck preprint</a>, <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1403.3985" rel="nofollow">arXiv:1403.3985</a>.</p> </blockquote> <p>Gravitational lensing of the CMB’s light by large scale structure at relatively late times produces small deflections of the primordial pattern, converting a small portion of E-mode power into B-modes. The lensing B-mode spectrum is similar to a smoothed version of the E-mode spectrum but a factor 100 lower in power, and hence also rises toward sub-degree scales and peaks around $\ell$ = 1000.</p> <p>I think the $\ell$ is this:</p> <p>For example $\ell=10$ corresponds to roughly 10 degrees on the sky, $\ell=100$ corresponds to roughly 1 degree on the sky. (From <a href="http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/intermediate/map5.html" rel="nofollow">CMB introduction</a>, by Wayne Hu.)</p> <p>But how does that apply here? When BICEP looks for something with an $\ell$ around 80, does that mean a "multipole moment" which spans 80 degrees across the sky?</p>
g9731
[ -0.002127773594111204, 0.03460162132978439, -0.008659875951707363, -0.056719668209552765, 0.06904042512178421, -0.00418239226564765, 0.02696392498910427, 0.005560330580919981, 0.021483054384589195, -0.001418716856278479, -0.039454199373722076, 0.0430542454123497, 0.06335873901844025, -0.03483319282531738, 0.06881798058748245, -0.019975651055574417, 0.06438807398080826, 0.02785431779921055, 0.050722163170576096, -0.05119933560490608, -0.05258364975452423, 0.026717737317085266, 0.0143453199416399, -0.049282483756542206, 0.03145495802164078, 0.06422349810600281, 0.01843244954943657, 0.014073123224079609, -0.08239785581827164, -0.011049053631722927, -0.005312788300216198, -0.012143143452703953, 0.07176072895526886, -0.066633440554142, -0.011827778071165085, 0.045125484466552734, 0.017822394147515297, 0.030066564679145813, -0.018190588802099228, 0.013421379029750824, -0.017088107764720917, -0.036430928856134415, -0.015255210921168327, 0.008749542757868767, 0.015806566923856735, -0.020346730947494507, -0.008715915493667126, -0.010602028109133244, -0.017211806029081345, -0.019281940534710884, -0.010759841650724411, 0.04678599163889885, 0.0877416655421257, -0.007451001554727554, 0.013161391951143742, 0.043066274374723434, 0.001819690689444542, 0.031571730971336365, 0.0525168813765049, 0.013816344551742077, 0.02766733430325985, 0.029662027955055237, 0.0356321781873703, 0.021653205156326294, 0.009548850357532501, -0.016396543011069298, -0.0732901319861412, -0.04385264962911606, 0.0038047973066568375, 0.009722184389829636, 0.0015501742018386722, -0.03685568645596504, -0.05473313108086586, -0.0025922416243702173, -0.06205591559410095, -0.010084033943712711, -0.01931801065802574, -0.019559647887945175, 0.004714175593107939, 0.06482783704996109, -0.027865514159202576, 0.0005290915141813457, -0.03347083926200867, 0.01695786602795124, 0.05717875435948372, -0.01033850573003292, 0.016125362366437912, 0.07898207753896713, 0.0006790700717829168, 0.037146300077438354, 0.043876368552446365, -0.0413198247551918, 0.0357176773250103, -0.004174595698714256, 0.017634471878409386, -0.03665893152356148, 0.048552677035331726, 0.04704677313566208, -0.07907308638095856, -0.03403943404555321, -0.03216797485947609, 0.08195137232542038, -0.11565956473350525, 0.04026179760694504, -0.03130017966032028, 0.03576354309916496, -0.017615048214793205, -0.04664357006549835, -0.01438780315220356, 0.05190511420369148, -0.0688551813364029, -0.0168442502617836, -0.029183873906731606, -0.016898903995752335, -0.11294785141944885, -0.07379760593175888, 0.03977525979280472, -0.012797635979950428, -0.009216890670359135, 0.04286672919988632, 0.07360830157995224, -0.0829998329281807, -0.03471013158559799, 0.06798934936523438, -0.061913177371025085, 0.003492089221253991, -0.017498116940259933, -0.005425570532679558, 0.08221349120140076, -0.015259855426847935, -0.021032728254795074, -0.025118106976151466, -0.04893747717142105, -0.00979237537831068, 0.023854142054915428, 0.002418328309431672, 0.008330726064741611, -0.010695533826947212, -0.029161443933844566, 0.03294370323419571, -0.0034154769964516163, 0.003411670681089163, 0.02656988427042961, -0.07887016981840134, -0.0047529395669698715, 0.0017291528638452291, -0.006027949042618275, 0.04472871869802475, 0.08393505215644836, 0.03887256234884262, -0.011245290748775005, 0.07923825830221176, 0.00775892473757267, -0.007776731159538031, -0.0361332893371582, 0.05294731631875038, 0.014655590988695621, -0.02494153007864952, -0.001105650793761015, 0.06274931877851486, 0.024072254076600075, -0.04207804054021835, 0.006343761924654245, 0.01711241900920868, -0.022833524271845818, 0.020321547985076904, -0.021627841517329216, -0.030394239351153374, 0.0446256585419178, -0.06252981722354889, -0.10351267457008362, 0.0031888631638139486, 0.03236343339085579, -0.040798019617795944, 0.0010953935561701655, 0.06000257655978203, -0.002937100827693939, -0.017747344449162483, 0.05144764482975006, 0.0535096600651741, -0.06637641787528992, 0.05377919226884842, -0.03590589761734009, 0.0013967253034934402, 0.019792305305600166, -0.06384819746017456, -0.003203681204468012, 0.012787824496626854, 0.0426967553794384, -0.007672610692679882, -0.001610399573110044, -0.019910600036382675, -0.05206482857465744, 0.03873389959335327, 0.027117623016238213, -0.00549096055328846, 0.029555710032582283, -0.05854814872145653, -0.0696360245347023, 0.07611098140478134, -0.018019801005721092, -0.004322862718254328, 0.03860988840460777, 0.02494385838508606, 0.02246353030204773, -0.010594287887215614, 0.0025223353877663612, 0.025678949430584908, 0.012657515704631805, -0.05265244096517563, 0.011992492713034153, -0.004366565961390734, -0.08027028292417526, 0.006669384893029928, -0.06738561391830444, 0.0437576025724411, -0.0012558858143165708, 0.04952075332403183, 0.01550616230815649, 0.03585091978311539, -0.03417588770389557, 0.01921253092586994, 0.015483433380723, 0.02635245956480503, 0.023107748478651047, 0.023985741659998894, -0.09460090845823288, 0.005989778786897659, 0.051565226167440414, 0.01261649839580059, -0.07645998895168304, 0.07841784507036209, 0.05995840206742287, -0.013400048017501831, 0.00269370898604393, -0.028275232762098312, 0.014039289206266403, 0.022760214284062386, -0.010483075864613056, -0.013859441503882408, -0.0032801043707877398, -0.0470125786960125, -0.024369118735194206, 0.028529053553938866, 0.006667465437203646, 0.06730145961046219, 0.058855921030044556, 0.016582371667027473, -0.02755814604461193, 0.04294344410300255, 0.0530739463865757, 0.005908511579036713, -0.003235762706026435, 0.0588640458881855, -0.06891462206840515, 0.01794089749455452, 0.03746197745203972, 0.05359553173184395, -0.11782895773649216, -0.0019084048690274358, 0.007000800222158432, -0.03185213357210159, 0.004016165155917406, -0.05975545197725296, 0.0064111873507499695, -0.017480921000242233, -0.04492641240358353, -0.006117913872003555, -0.017793603241443634, 0.013276787474751472, -0.04160870611667633, 0.10181457549333572, 0.02794603258371353, 0.00926100742071867, -0.0008756645838730037, -0.014814960770308971, 0.010865134187042713, -0.01860886625945568, -0.02919473685324192, 0.01647253707051277, -0.08873310685157776, 0.007589683867990971, -0.013915839605033398, 0.0389978364109993, 0.018614578992128372, -0.01668199710547924, 0.010627208277583122, 0.07388358563184738, -0.022990794852375984, 0.033478740602731705, 0.02668549120426178, -0.005521842278540134, 0.03830847889184952, 0.020575817674398422, 0.05180101841688156, -0.001108610536903143, 0.08078283071517944, -0.048458993434906006, -0.03715204820036888, 0.026363583281636238, 0.0042059654369950294, -0.017160901799798012, -0.003924054559320211, -0.02864094078540802, 0.009449058212339878, 0.029840486124157906, -0.02325335331261158, -0.03605024516582489, -0.031500399112701416, 0.013043292798101902, -0.03497624769806862, -0.013181331567466259, 0.006957978010177612, 0.059906166046857834, 0.0009545075008645654, 0.030335506424307823, -0.05546443164348602, 0.016823630779981613, -0.007129619363695383, -0.00815635360777378, 0.00592189934104681, -0.032955367118120193, 0.036618493497371674, 0.04827609285712242, 0.04946589097380638, 0.015998098999261856, 0.005185799673199654, 0.025910118594765663, -0.02540629915893078, 0.018052751198410988, -0.045045532286167145, -0.01795268803834915, -0.006906048860400915, 0.035247258841991425, 0.006204737816005945, 0.001006445731036365, -0.04140220209956169, 0.023530829697847366, 0.0725378468632698, -0.012631095014512539, 0.04142926260828972, -0.0037869818042963743, -0.014883620664477348, -0.019908735528588295, 0.06512387841939926, -0.02164865843951702, -0.009248646907508373, -0.014480916783213615, -0.056139782071113586, -0.01656695269048214, -0.04219404608011246, -0.0012257401831448078, 0.00158125429879874, -0.02796541154384613, -0.026682816445827484, 0.018184375017881393, 0.004839800763875246, 0.02046184428036213, 0.05214524269104004, 0.029856979846954346, 0.02247726172208786, -0.0016478670295327902, 0.02871100977063179, 0.03719672933220863, -0.04053622856736183, -0.04995042085647583, 0.006781360134482384, 0.01845598965883255, 0.010808711871504784, 0.029399123042821884, 0.04621269926428795, -0.03510678932070732, -0.02754802070558071, 0.03512299433350563, 0.011575114913284779, 0.020196544006466866, 0.035513006150722504, 0.005678998772054911, -0.0132445078343153, 0.02230086736381054, -0.06892003864049911, 0.057806335389614105, 0.025486784055829048, 0.01411065086722374, -0.013627858832478523, -0.015607589855790138, -0.037710100412368774, -0.056285690516233444, 0.03675132989883423, -0.01353065948933363, 0.0044121467508375645, -0.015772614628076553, 0.008795551024377346, 0.003525261301547289, 0.031710099428892136, -0.07909351587295532, 0.005355873145163059, -0.037401504814624786, -0.00595990801230073, 0.025058701634407043, -0.007616162300109863, 0.04306528717279434, 0.01345157716423273, -0.0008720156620256603, -0.019680505618453026, 0.019281307235360146, -0.02025786228477955, 0.022940095514059067, -0.027098385617136955, 0.02651761658489704, 0.07066968083381653, -0.043117400258779526, 0.015064532868564129, -0.1020565927028656, 0.02691611647605896, 0.03886330872774124, 0.03626321256160736, -0.020168054848909378, 0.07395301014184952, 0.0051387157291173935, 0.016609758138656616, 0.007242235355079174, -0.040746670216321945, -0.006381398532539606, -0.03595056012272835, 0.024051178246736526, 0.014071485958993435, 0.018237506970763206, 0.005630264524370432, 0.008774281479418278, 0.0056931027211248875, -0.04029181972146034, -0.011154460720717907, -0.037451568990945816, -0.045266538858413696, 0.036276575177907944, -0.030171314254403114, 0.008347708731889725, 0.020433548837900162, 0.015527743846178055, 0.07100911438465118, -0.028871115297079086, 0.03740997612476349, -0.009679029695689678, 0.009762396104633808, 0.012996437028050423, -0.02338307723402977, -0.028633564710617065, -0.00652802549302578, 0.012696999125182629, 0.02447168342769146, -0.005016210023313761, -0.01619284600019455, -0.003365972777828574, 0.0006338222301565111, -0.03359435126185417, 0.04767085611820221, 0.07155205309391022, 0.017414022237062454, -0.005333841312676668, -0.057443518191576004, -0.054969217628240585, 0.03231654688715935, -0.0034355251118540764, 0.024575036019086838, 0.023371782153844833, -0.028741689398884773, -0.054686758667230606, -0.005863223224878311, -0.027822619304060936, -0.011614931747317314, -0.04191390797495842, 0.03539138287305832, 0.010213946923613548, -0.024502253159880638, 0.04836183413863182, -0.036407310515642166, -0.003330554347485304, 0.04085744917392731, -0.01924712583422661, -0.06650784611701965, -0.0328652448952198, -0.027005435898900032, -0.0231296606361866, -0.0399618037045002, -0.017439398914575577, -0.03180685266852379, -0.029845155775547028, -0.016592200845479965, 0.016071612015366554, 0.016703438013792038, 0.03328937664628029, 0.03219784051179886, -0.03938315808773041, -0.0023596324026584625, -0.014719643630087376, 0.05306733399629593, -0.008478443138301373, 0.08995969593524933, -0.02219369448721409, -0.029523812234401703, 0.02148916758596897, -0.002031693933531642, -0.0038435705937445164, -0.0067215571179986, 0.05563034862279892, 0.03913073614239693, -0.017648780718445778, 0.018499502912163734, 0.0703263133764267, -0.07023457437753677, -0.017052173614501953, -0.004250979982316494, 0.03591513633728027, -0.01826043799519539, -0.07896482199430466, 0.001201127772219479, 0.027302227914333344, 0.013799129985272884, -0.05915207043290138, 0.011430075392127037, -0.07098609209060669, 0.026875006034970284, -0.012064151465892792, 0.04380272328853607, 0.010676140896975994, -0.04380199685692787, 0.008925105445086956, 0.030287927016615868, 0.043408848345279694, 0.001094983541406691, -0.02274288795888424, 0.08571511507034302, 0.04735160246491432, 0.04435400292277336, 0.029507508501410484, 0.01741456612944603, 0.015785738825798035, -0.004146981984376907, -0.012992529198527336, -0.019377920776605606, -0.030587660148739815, 0.022931426763534546, 0.007828513160347939, 0.014573762193322182, -0.047415655106306076, 0.03403373435139656, -0.058323293924331665, 0.00411867955699563, -0.04766787961125374, 0.0034338845871388912, 0.030104082077741623, 0.047862596809864044, 0.012419559061527252, -0.0354309007525444, 0.029623135924339294, -0.003874031128361821, -0.054969269782304764, -0.025363221764564514, -0.024134865030646324, 0.04567135125398636, 0.004980573896318674, 0.03362448886036873, -0.015732627362012863, 0.011998387053608894, -0.042001236230134964, 0.02395607717335224, -0.04252559691667557, 0.07168631255626678, 0.03236163407564163, -0.06495453417301178, 0.027783703058958054, 0.009916933253407478, 0.04248063638806343, 0.05127471312880516, -0.0007465008529834449, -0.00027682475047186017, -0.0004759030125569552, 0.02509613335132599, -0.0449315570294857, 0.011447437107563019, 0.025571787729859352, 0.05875834450125694, 0.035395532846450806, -0.01449714694172144, 0.02020370401442051, -0.0023918042425066233, 0.0023986506275832653, 0.05258931964635849, -0.0012041960144415498, -0.02122037671506405, -0.016934996470808983, -0.0022209438029676676, -0.019793232902884483, -0.05748450383543968, -0.0005856056814081967, -0.004021002445369959, 0.006567377131432295, -0.0531018041074276, -0.02014695666730404, 0.026169544085860252, 0.020756568759679794, 0.002554269041866064, -0.015122231096029282, 0.02082821913063526, -0.007497549522668123, -0.03507130965590477, -0.03958826884627342, -0.0063765342347323895, 0.0397324338555336, 0.0018843947909772396, -0.0024312809109687805, -0.01692062057554722, -0.00030739844078198075, -0.020214105024933815, -0.04406842589378357, -0.02148808352649212, -0.02040034532546997, -0.0247638002038002, 0.003774444106966257, 0.029732218012213707, -0.04096793383359909, -0.010387150570750237, -0.021440813317894936, 0.026507211849093437, 0.02836521528661251, 0.051061153411865234, 0.006136247422546148, 0.04038025438785553, -0.001809597946703434, -0.05511808767914772, 0.056860968470573425, -0.008876312524080276, 0.04054057598114014, -0.003122746478766203, 0.0006210744031704962, -0.089504674077034, 0.020734088495373726, 0.03776134178042412, 0.00038233466329984367, 0.029579220339655876, 0.015687450766563416, 0.03357155621051788, -0.030515672639012337, -0.011552182957530022, -0.007615462876856327, -0.05042571574449539, -0.023333171382546425, 0.018311969935894012, -0.049887463450431824, 0.03484692424535751, -0.025833239778876305, 0.010304467752575874, -0.0026647518388926983, -0.021430952474474907, -0.011070923879742622, 0.0593019500374794, 0.012029982171952724, 0.045566003769636154, -0.06453315913677216, -0.03120976686477661, 0.018122047185897827, -0.018442580476403236, -0.010205114260315895, 0.0049608005210757256, -0.001020960626192391, 0.013018345460295677, -0.06981965154409409, -0.00913331564515829, -0.025700606405735016, -0.036859359592199326, -0.00943068228662014, -0.075621098279953, 0.029965940862894058, -0.018111318349838257, -0.022569064050912857, -0.07167881727218628, -0.08369041234254837, 0.008481894619762897, 0.0847926214337349, 0.044353555887937546, 0.038798071444034576, 0.0017400620272383094, 0.041173193603754044, -0.03312240540981293, -0.010062409564852715, -0.08884931355714798, 0.011620838195085526, 0.025781497359275818, -0.04158363863825798, -0.01962287351489067, 0.021309878677129745, -0.04101422429084778, -0.056693654507398605, 0.030816558748483658, -0.006230373401194811, 0.020053867250680923, -0.02378208376467228, -0.0005546403699554503, 0.016546880826354027, 0.04176006466150284, 0.006023037247359753, -0.03342350572347641, -0.022167272865772247, 0.041829194873571396, 0.02959788590669632, 0.026613179594278336, -0.044892020523548126, 0.0011693467386066914, 0.05012461543083191, -0.05756613612174988, 0.02254968322813511, 0.016097674146294594, -0.0017188265919685364, -0.02474493347108364, -0.008498440496623516, 0.004868789575994015, -0.02553729899227619, -0.036327656358480453, 0.036863021552562714, -0.04071524366736412, 0.0024022257421165705, -0.013588658533990383, -0.03285527974367142, 0.007474175188690424, -0.04487370699644089, -0.012605613097548485, -0.0020956136286258698, 0.02229427918791771, -0.023238955065608025, -0.0015792847843840718, -0.054330386221408844, -0.036193326115608215, 0.0012983294436708093, -0.020535066723823547, 0.019403398036956787, -0.040850862860679626, -0.012686447240412235, -0.020326964557170868, 0.012355471029877663, -0.017890002578496933, -0.06021085008978844, 0.027192754670977592, 0.03518247604370117, -0.022921424359083176, 0.023161184042692184, -0.0354076512157917, 0.02889149822294712, 0.02650292217731476, 0.01821248047053814, -0.014524845406413078, -0.014271773397922516, -0.014726781286299229, 0.004602150525897741, 0.016612382605671883, -0.019262319430708885, -0.016626907512545586, -0.06187921017408371, -0.006255805492401123, -0.07321791350841522, -0.01469118520617485, 0.004558571148663759, -0.003917735069990158, -0.0008853611652739346, -0.0217124093323946, -0.02071036398410797, -0.00979691557586193, 0.042872145771980286 ]
<p>In MRI we measure $T_1$ and $T_2$ relaxation times. $T_1$ relaxation time is defined as the time it takes for the longitudinal component of magnetization to recover $1-1/e$ of its original value, and $T_2$ relaxation time is the time it takes for the transverse component of magnetization to recover $1/e$ of its original value. Is there any significance to those two numbers adding to 1? ($1-1/e + 1/e = 1$)</p> <p>As far as I understand, $T_2$ relaxation time is influenced by different atoms falling out of phase with each other. Was the reason for $1-1/e$ and $1/e$ that if the atoms would stay in phase, then $T_1$ would be equal to $T_2$, so that the difference between $T_1$ and $T_2$ relaxation time measures the degree of interaction? In that case, since $T_1$ and $T_2$ measure orthogonal components of a vector, shouldn't it have been $1/e$ and $\sqrt{1-1/e^2}$, so that the length of the vector becomes $1$ instead of the sum of the components becoming $1$?</p>
g9732
[ -0.03310295194387436, 0.01957995444536209, 0.0008869464509189129, -0.04606437683105469, 0.042387641966342926, -0.022107770666480064, 0.03684023767709732, 0.037297364324331284, -0.034641433507204056, 0.05009409412741661, -0.018992383033037186, 0.003187074325978756, 0.007137168664485216, -0.02837441675364971, -0.0016475517768412828, -0.016757743433117867, 0.01963130757212639, -0.008643719367682934, -0.06328613311052322, -0.008265099488198757, -0.0030166851356625557, 0.046468235552310944, 0.004074482247233391, -0.03629796952009201, 0.007177157327532768, 0.004485089797526598, 0.021224550902843475, 0.014240234158933163, -0.07240380346775055, -0.016126742586493492, 0.05464187264442444, 0.011482205241918564, 0.031997062265872955, -0.023525051772594452, -0.007826427929103374, -0.07052949070930481, 0.04568510502576828, 0.059354573488235474, 0.045230381190776825, 0.0016892642015591264, 0.0038577064406126738, -0.0671156719326973, 0.06926646083593369, 0.008011679165065289, 0.05942177399992943, 0.046378232538700104, -0.03077864460647106, 0.014294985681772232, -0.024080855771899223, -0.005594344809651375, 0.05772889032959938, 0.0223995354026556, 0.054513853043317795, 0.03247382864356041, 0.014822743833065033, -0.005809458438307047, -0.014779307879507542, -0.013260643929243088, 0.057350218296051025, 0.0725342333316803, 0.05157282575964928, -0.06445612758398056, -0.02654992789030075, 0.05090020224452019, 0.04465218633413315, 0.000027319425498717465, -0.029312409460544586, 0.002493262989446521, 0.011795412749052048, 0.012979695573449135, -0.03538965433835983, -0.06297136098146439, -0.04664810746908188, 0.028767665848135948, -0.054259561002254486, 0.013337287120521069, 0.05644920468330383, -0.03971260040998459, 0.010535462759435177, 0.01137758418917656, -0.0627979040145874, -0.015498042106628418, -0.009672984480857849, 0.06463059037923813, 0.06308705359697342, 0.07602813839912415, -0.015848957002162933, 0.0014837343478575349, -0.02093631401658058, 0.10460950434207916, 0.0293550007045269, -0.03525856137275696, 0.010384729132056236, 0.024201596155762672, -0.001979973167181015, -0.016419146209955215, 0.018194541335105896, 0.03566654771566391, -0.01955289952456951, 0.04912834241986275, -0.013310139067471027, -0.002129974076524377, -0.035189155489206314, -0.037186600267887115, -0.013524266891181469, 0.018342023715376854, -0.016478121280670166, 0.026892079040408134, -0.03421533852815628, 0.01600271463394165, -0.03787193447351456, -0.031030984595417976, -0.022082634270191193, 0.017467301338911057, -0.04009149968624115, -0.007475861813873053, 0.04315095394849777, -0.0490787997841835, 0.011060373857617378, 0.012204529717564583, 0.04959636926651001, -0.03088943287730217, 0.011246020905673504, 0.039815083146095276, 0.005143394693732262, 0.0505259744822979, 0.026657605543732643, 0.00534012308344245, 0.038674455136060715, 0.06047201529145241, -0.044257089495658875, -0.011885999701917171, -0.003029993735253811, 0.03484119847416878, -0.04489946737885475, 0.0017449583392590284, 0.02859167754650116, 0.036313023418188095, -0.03195380046963692, 0.012200562283396721, -0.002447473583742976, -0.04379407316446304, 0.0022892714478075504, -0.05985293164849281, -0.015973152592778206, 0.043050117790699005, 0.019521309062838554, -0.04776786267757416, 0.018658677116036415, 0.018771646544337273, 0.035527702420949936, 0.01442975178360939, 0.02503758855164051, -0.02909213677048683, -0.010429074987769127, -0.017926035448908806, 0.017687847837805748, -0.061660103499889374, 0.037831615656614304, 0.04460630938410759, 0.04401402920484543, 0.0025555193424224854, 0.04422670602798462, 0.01381388958543539, 0.016013864427804947, 0.002030460862442851, 0.09278186410665512, -0.04364703595638275, 0.02079925127327442, -0.046175528317689896, -0.0317821279168129, -0.035346828401088715, -0.0013204615097492933, 0.023216497153043747, 0.009842929430305958, 0.08314041048288345, 0.018735842779278755, -0.05370031297206879, 0.020554279908537865, 0.012741820886731148, -0.01796516589820385, 0.05681924894452095, -0.02335922233760357, -0.006715696770697832, 0.029968304559588432, 0.02213532105088234, 0.03851565718650818, 0.05175785720348358, -0.11785819381475449, 0.01817994937300682, 0.021839668974280357, -0.02857092395424843, -0.024423865601420403, 0.050540193915367126, -0.02129719965159893, -0.02019859105348587, 0.01797659695148468, -0.031879935413599014, -0.04955942928791046, 0.062003765255212784, -0.07878830283880234, -0.05721233785152435, 0.06815726310014725, 0.007153835613280535, 0.02025787904858589, -0.039551910012960434, -0.045184820890426636, -0.013096456415951252, 0.06394735723733902, 0.0009510326199233532, 0.02539799176156521, 0.05413234606385231, -0.021008525043725967, 0.028001248836517334, -0.008421576581895351, -0.030273888260126114, 0.02377096749842167, 0.0057701291516423225, 0.00957518070936203, 0.01689922623336315, -0.03318416699767113, -0.023216256871819496, 0.011097196489572525, -0.024454960599541664, -0.01671561971306801, 0.004898684099316597, 0.006390958558768034, -0.00013209061580710113, -0.0450875461101532, -0.03221514821052551, -0.04560491070151329, 0.04544844478368759, -0.018474148586392403, 0.04163572937250137, 0.022685915231704712, -0.009045856073498726, 0.012509159743785858, -0.03705770522356033, -0.0033948407508432865, 0.032247137278318405, 0.013887880370020866, 0.03755517303943634, -0.024213429540395737, 0.02396625094115734, -0.02295038290321827, -0.000022512504074256867, 0.009092145599424839, -0.017911268398165703, 0.046253327280282974, -0.025048568844795227, -0.018747694790363312, -0.05611177533864975, -0.02045128121972084, -0.037451308220624924, 0.001140213804319501, -0.016724323853850365, 0.013569840230047703, 0.015436390414834023, -0.04978043586015701, -0.009004172869026661, -0.011424764059484005, 0.03998660296201706, 0.028239158913493156, -0.02155184932053089, -0.051989685744047165, -0.006198131944984198, -0.0388462133705616, 0.03397339582443237, 0.016409974545240402, -0.032343540340662, -0.08377178013324738, 0.004813882522284985, 0.006428741384297609, 0.01565377600491047, -0.04434764385223389, -0.05229775235056877, 0.042542435228824615, -0.0009680767543613911, 0.01949683018028736, -0.04924721643328667, -0.06731448322534561, -0.02594730444252491, -0.08700767159461975, -0.02483367547392845, 0.0020666897762566805, 0.04124130308628082, -0.018123598769307137, 0.04122493043541908, -0.08814775198698044, 0.062342725694179535, -0.07199105620384216, 0.0483991913497448, 0.025966377928853035, -0.020046021789312363, 0.029237136244773865, 0.04216930642724037, 0.03364521265029907, -0.05284043401479721, -0.04848479852080345, 0.09591799974441528, -0.007835783064365387, 0.020272381603717804, -0.002505777170881629, -0.019413581117987633, 0.014377610757946968, -0.011490002274513245, -0.0806112289428711, -0.06017739698290825, -0.020563410595059395, -0.007522195111960173, -0.011112751439213753, 0.11028438806533813, 0.02307993732392788, 0.02832130715250969, -0.03039475344121456, 0.01345239020884037, -0.032095059752464294, 0.03467954695224762, 0.03413117676973343, -0.000416786439018324, -0.008554404601454735, -0.0388282835483551, -0.0034241790417581797, -0.00828550010919571, 0.03271975368261337, -0.053165730088949203, -0.03531904146075249, 0.009929531253874302, -0.01668352633714676, -0.002336476929485798, -0.009253825061023235, -0.0073655471205711365, 0.0031699729152023792, -0.02606818825006485, -0.07009849697351456, 0.009748908691108227, 0.005790975876152515, 0.03266150876879692, -0.004888894036412239, 0.018377304077148438, -0.0688762217760086, 0.009859312325716019, -0.02023654244840145, 0.029723361134529114, 0.05630229786038399, -0.025591105222702026, -0.003826260333880782, -0.0342835932970047, -0.006259068381041288, -0.012989246286451817, -0.004403592087328434, 0.059575822204351425, 0.048700422048568726, -0.018212484195828438, -0.03038579225540161, 0.028416521847248077, 0.04529200866818428, -0.022187530994415283, -0.02609734795987606, -0.009459243156015873, 0.043548181653022766, -0.027355870231986046, -0.041354816406965256, -0.010655487887561321, -0.05516917631030083, -0.006461692042648792, -0.018158074468374252, 0.0652746707201004, 0.07254549860954285, -0.03633442148566246, 0.006476132664829493, 0.014275402761995792, 0.00657462514936924, -0.005254859104752541, -0.005234239157289267, -0.00724101671949029, 0.00048021692782640457, 0.015190226025879383, -0.04863373190164566, -0.0009322204859927297, -0.0029387101531028748, -0.05791017413139343, -0.036454688757658005, -0.00525102112442255, 0.026777133345603943, -0.05764066427946091, -0.0006691696471534669, -0.011110276915133, -0.017100006341934204, -0.055319901555776596, 0.03297905996441841, 0.04409448057413101, -0.0302908793091774, 0.020557550713419914, 0.06588895618915558, 0.0009065436897799373, 0.013246056623756886, 0.057905856519937515, 0.01878199726343155, -0.020179128274321556, -0.026195339858531952, 0.010091433301568031, -0.0344107486307621, 0.0009887502528727055, 0.0547715462744236, 0.02813289687037468, 0.046923115849494934, 0.022752439603209496, 0.031045254319906235, -0.006652096752077341, -0.07088591903448105, -0.011986571364104748, 0.030167974531650543, -0.006709985435009003, 0.03395421430468559, 0.0036330800503492355, -0.009047828614711761, -0.015641529113054276, -0.030694004148244858, -0.014812025241553783, 0.0010801743483170867, 0.01986684836447239, -0.01976470835506916, -0.0290910042822361, -0.031139222905039787, -0.015957355499267578, -0.013472511433064938, 0.041910696774721146, -0.0018148805247619748, 0.01777554489672184, 0.02328346110880375, 0.012957554310560226, 0.008716431446373463, -0.00022413884289562702, -0.04949066787958145, 0.054074227809906006, 0.0041973949410021305, 0.06454893201589584, 0.026886744424700737, -0.014421384781599045, 0.04521160200238228, 0.003935105167329311, -0.018267735838890076, -0.02666502073407173, -0.0509779155254364, -0.00453174440190196, 0.003505182918161154, -0.0057462300173938274, -0.03868737444281578, -0.016533663496375084, -0.035754308104515076, 0.07229742407798767, 0.0014124452136456966, -0.07007784396409988, 0.05539106950163841, -0.0774790346622467, -0.028287624940276146, 0.061085864901542664, 0.07159396260976791, 0.08051575720310211, 0.010347994044423103, 0.040951065719127655, -0.04264341667294502, -0.021928954869508743, -0.04748406633734703, -0.04814998060464859, 0.014809305779635906, 0.03122636303305626, -0.022515596821904182, 0.07521097362041473, -0.0033020973205566406, -0.05685293674468994, 0.018946466967463493, 0.003772568190470338, 0.057399023324251175, 0.0029315652791410685, -0.03145459666848183, -0.012811095453798771, -0.005125842988491058, -0.08723337948322296, -0.017767876386642456, -0.028360547497868538, -0.010173851624131203, -0.0038508956786245108, 0.02252820134162903, -0.039888378232717514, -0.04603653773665428, -0.053132664412260056, 0.022381380200386047, -0.018877951428294182, 0.003644441720098257, 0.027187561616301537, 0.04587704688310623, -0.014574929140508175, 0.02174707129597664, -0.056017279624938965, 0.019766883924603462, -0.014325810596346855, -0.05104392021894455, -0.04117932170629501, -0.006510205566883087, 0.0611739344894886, 0.015754202380776405, -0.010920279659330845, -0.06027725711464882, 0.02171185612678528, 0.04264435917139053, -0.030083317309617996, -0.088211789727211, 0.034473564475774765, -0.03112710826098919, 0.007443683221936226, 0.02323968894779682, 0.08195986598730087, 0.00555619178339839, 0.026413099840283394, 0.04522092640399933, 0.008167215622961521, -0.04099360108375549, 0.002426281338557601, 0.03068622760474682, 0.019790498539805412, 0.05100160464644432, -0.05253361910581589, 0.005040583200752735, 0.01688206009566784, -0.020456284284591675, -0.011660832911729813, 0.030409591272473335, 0.04107273370027542, 0.03235650807619095, -0.015739159658551216, -0.011598547920584679, 0.013392919674515724, 0.0094864871352911, -0.013816983439028263, -0.015458937734365463, -0.03885349631309509, -0.015543979592621326, -0.001094894134439528, 0.005864187143743038, -0.002412555506452918, 0.018619239330291748, 0.05580315738916397, -0.01155448891222477, -0.00783523079007864, 0.07835578918457031, -0.05027319863438606, -0.003864506259560585, -0.008019614033401012, -0.05063498020172119, -0.045931700617074966, -0.034107036888599396, -0.04042970389127731, 0.01350333634763956, 0.029415253549814224, 0.03637324273586273, -0.008026396855711937, -0.0021574434358626604, 0.009027914144098759, 0.020801009610295296, -0.020665358752012253, -0.017208654433488846, 0.003308406099677086, 0.016229838132858276, -0.02938925102353096, -0.008125895634293556, 0.041793037205934525, 0.027162156999111176, 0.04908193647861481, 0.05149158462882042, -0.02129564993083477, 0.014121153391897678, 0.03154861554503441, 0.027140237390995026, 0.09820866584777832, -0.08561725169420242, -0.06810876727104187, -0.0194489024579525, -0.05364759638905525, -0.009207366034388542, -0.027489157393574715, -0.01870700716972351, -0.015035874210298061, 0.04032459482550621, -0.005828570108860731, -0.045278627425432205, -0.09548726677894592, 0.07854761928319931, 0.038159143179655075, -0.002295710612088442, 0.048208028078079224, -0.056726422160863876, -0.046929292380809784, -0.02672061324119568, -0.015908313915133476, -0.04246440902352333, -0.06092219054698944, -0.023762216791510582, 0.048974648118019104, 0.014772544614970684, -0.002870747586712241, 0.012088611721992493, 0.004554152488708496, -0.047001246362924576, -0.00002356599179620389, -0.051287394016981125, 0.009596762247383595, 0.01078849472105503, 0.02863554283976555, 0.02274036593735218, 0.03014765866100788, -0.026863943785429, 0.043106142431497574, 0.027641331776976585, -0.04906812310218811, 0.011553122662007809, 0.04110768064856529, -0.04953460767865181, 0.010862862691283226, -0.035819802433252335, -0.0030299616046249866, 0.011696308851242065, 0.009981952607631683, 0.001983208814635873, 0.029470380395650864, -0.04825276508927345, -0.011905770748853683, 0.022468792274594307, -0.004188191145658493, 0.012302560731768608, -0.03568635135889053, 0.026937980204820633, 0.005241652950644493, 0.029860131442546844, -0.0050447117537260056, -0.05768769606947899, -0.020798716694116592, -0.006080008111894131, 0.06890210509300232, 0.033797841519117355, -0.016499238088726997, -0.021439524367451668, -0.04371223971247673, -0.04787391051650047, 0.017505375668406487, 0.02869388274848461, 0.0051610819064080715, -0.08273441344499588, 0.024280013516545296, 0.004735097289085388, 0.03927821293473244, -0.0291494932025671, 0.029735786840319633, -0.01003959309309721, -0.032283201813697815, -0.032732199877500534, -0.049187738448381424, 0.05384863540530205, -0.016601594164967537, -0.08797379583120346, 0.01203424297273159, -0.04230117425322533, -0.007387402001768351, 0.022778084501624107, -0.01924150250852108, 0.012966525740921497, -0.03295283764600754, 0.06705641746520996, -0.05811825022101402, 0.006481793709099293, -0.024421142414212227, 0.01584728993475437, 0.001081438735127449, 0.015460546128451824, 0.01898198388516903, -0.014321020804345608, -0.04477040097117424, 0.005111463833600283, -0.005537999793887138, -0.0327998548746109, 0.010816261172294617, 0.00882072001695633, -0.002005326794460416, -0.04328638315200806, 0.08490002155303955, -0.031730957329273224, -0.007893498986959457, -0.023626336827874184, -0.0009005832253023982, 0.027798721566796303, 0.00026030029403045774, 0.019967064261436462, 0.10356857627630234, -0.04288316145539284, -0.021169573068618774, 0.03198942542076111, 0.058663927018642426, -0.026766862720251083, -0.036749180406332016, 0.021310336887836456, -0.017616843804717064, 0.06388464570045471, 0.017522312700748444, 0.04560907185077667, 0.0002651943941600621, 0.008079531602561474, -0.08011265844106674, -0.008563759736716747, -0.04355551674962044, -0.03891044855117798, 0.023940471932291985, 0.03626687452197075, 0.019207891076803207, -0.015459202229976654, -0.020738281309604645, 0.0004834830469917506, -0.01950356736779213, 0.029294142499566078, 0.006859968416392803, -0.009045985527336597, -0.038034241646528244, -0.01380063034594059, -0.04466927424073219, -0.05858994275331497, -0.028773486614227295, 0.029300369322299957, 0.019490467384457588, 0.07564029097557068, 0.017651788890361786, 0.006308190058916807, 0.011264048516750336, -0.03157155588269234, 0.04075349494814873, 0.038539819419384, 0.053907230496406555, 0.04199355095624924, -0.012129677459597588, -0.008463370613753796, -0.018728982657194138, 0.00978089403361082, 0.0006286221905611455, 0.0502786859869957, -0.009781384840607643, -0.025665760040283203, 0.00000828344127512537, -0.023935426026582718, 0.07913821935653687, 0.03926469013094902, -0.04326925799250603, -0.03401608392596245, -0.03309565410017967, -0.013548221439123154, 0.07905735820531845, 0.00495256157591939, 0.04517226666212082, 0.02590140327811241, 0.02863895334303379, 0.029643328860402107, -0.04595605283975601, 0.01712391898036003, 0.018844272941350937, -0.039170391857624054, -0.003284740960225463, -0.00745562044903636, 0.009460150264203548, -0.0006225499091669917, 0.012467941269278526 ]
<p>The starting point and notations used here are presented in <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/77758/two-puzzles-on-the-projective-symmetry-grouppsg">Two puzzles on the Projective Symmetry Group(PSG)?</a>. As we know, Invariant Gauge Group(IGG) is a <em>normal subgroup</em> of Projective Symmetry Group(PSG), but it may not be a <em>normal subgroup</em> of $SU(2)$, like $IGG=U(1)$. But this may results in a trouble:</p> <p>By definition, we can calculate the $IGG$ and $IGG'$ of the $SU(2)$ gauge equivalent mean-field Hamiltonians $H(\psi_i)$ and $H(\widetilde{\psi_i})$, respectively. And it's easy to see that for each site $i$, we have $U_i'=G_iU_iG_i^\dagger$, where $U_i'\in IGG'$ and $U_i\in IGG$, which means that $IGG'=G_i\text{ }IGG \text{ }G_i^\dagger$. Now the trouble is explicit, if $IGG$(like $U(1)$) is not a <em>normal subgroup</em> of $SU(2)$, then $IGG'$ may <strong>not</strong> equal to $IGG$, so does this mean that <em>two $SU(2)$ gauge equivalent mean-field Hamiltonians $H(\psi_i)$ and $H(\widetilde{\psi_i})$ may have different IGGs</em> ? Or in other words, does the low-energy gauge structure depend on the choice of $SU(2)$ gauge freedom?</p> <p>Thank you very much.</p>
g9733
[ -0.023926621302962303, 0.03485221415758133, -0.03389747440814972, -0.01289927214384079, 0.012557060457766056, -0.0010260195704177022, 0.0016180522507056594, 0.005930463783442974, -0.0162345040589571, 0.03608319163322449, 0.038653336465358734, 0.021441170945763588, -0.05500907823443413, -0.048964403569698334, -0.0005842988030053675, 0.05876467749476433, 0.09628760814666748, 0.010831846855580807, 0.054101865738630295, -0.04421136528253555, -0.03813933953642845, 0.022500846534967422, 0.0026203214656561613, 0.0029000232461839914, 0.05845089629292488, -0.016476456075906754, 0.04148827865719795, -0.049720119684934616, -0.026765545830130577, 0.0003871787048410624, 0.01693587191402912, 0.03404545038938522, 0.07424748688936234, -0.05669756978750229, 0.009099812246859074, -0.023068325594067574, 0.057066794484853745, 0.04511016234755516, 0.0071779293939471245, 0.0034238314256072044, 0.005841303616762161, -0.002637621946632862, 0.013364559970796108, -0.041388995945453644, -0.08422894030809402, -0.006991806905716658, 0.01655009761452675, -0.009173505008220673, 0.004913348704576492, -0.048860158771276474, 0.04754883795976639, 0.01782871223986149, 0.06204439327120781, -0.01748143509030342, -0.014536391012370586, 0.01719699241220951, 0.0004949573194608092, -0.023226933553814888, 0.01803991198539734, 0.06225847080349922, 0.021099932491779327, 0.03080737590789795, -0.0026521622203290462, 0.05317400023341179, 0.009015128016471863, 0.016489265486598015, -0.04846006631851196, 0.014101389795541763, 0.021140266209840775, -0.014543602243065834, -0.02519022300839424, -0.03950543329119682, 0.02137318253517151, 0.01802205480635166, -0.04619617015123367, 0.019837509840726852, 0.024881409481167793, -0.002275362377986312, 0.02795599028468132, -0.03877006098628044, -0.009995314292609692, 0.012412646785378456, -0.016236281022429466, -0.00946353655308485, 0.03767980635166168, -0.04922478273510933, -0.035048406571149826, 0.07150868326425552, -0.005495606455951929, 0.031091412529349327, 0.019488750025629997, -0.04927176237106323, 0.06518429517745972, -0.008210738189518452, -0.0007261889986693859, 0.07019050419330597, 0.03390116989612579, 0.08792988955974579, -0.08676853775978088, 0.04453036189079285, -0.0229335967451334, 0.0018009212799370289, -0.005500391591340303, 0.05078498646616936, 0.025796739384531975, 0.00628063827753067, 0.09082316607236862, 0.01204756647348404, 0.03192642331123352, 0.008089350536465645, -0.0072849527932703495, 0.027635881677269936, -0.07148852199316025, 0.011887547560036182, -0.03554463014006615, -0.03501637279987335, 0.037473853677511215, -0.052948106080293655, 0.040104303508996964, 0.01707582175731659, 0.028202442452311516, 0.000240537483477965, 0.026717064902186394, 0.046217482537031174, 0.0231616273522377, -0.024366775527596474, -0.06397540122270584, -0.04269609972834587, 0.024966975674033165, -0.020887475460767746, -0.014948725700378418, -0.04709793999791145, -0.005637707654386759, 0.07360988855361938, -0.015768544748425484, -0.028090914711356163, 0.01912897825241089, 0.05693591386079788, 0.03214140608906746, -0.0034742977004498243, -0.1008114218711853, -0.00347542529925704, -0.035612255334854126, -0.016137106344103813, -0.0052420832216739655, -0.033806391060352325, 0.024513352662324905, -0.061481572687625885, -0.041631244122982025, 0.030682126060128212, 0.04193396493792534, 0.04159530624747276, 0.016192955896258354, 0.017638085409998894, 0.006703993771225214, -0.045412950217723846, -0.039642274379730225, 0.06022656336426735, 0.0564114935696125, 0.026739761233329773, 0.025977883487939835, -0.026205698028206825, 0.07155556976795197, 0.0009026066982187331, -0.002237026346847415, 0.0024601509794592857, 0.07663697004318237, 0.004120576195418835, -0.03759753704071045, -0.07107435166835785, -0.0019198870286345482, -0.029990125447511673, 0.000534223800059408, 0.061142317950725555, -0.0018121316097676754, 0.03837047517299652, 0.0021007205359637737, 0.01653732918202877, -0.004712668247520924, -0.00630955770611763, -0.013606688939034939, -0.016489466652274132, 0.025819992646574974, -0.030306903645396233, -0.05160127207636833, 0.05583275109529495, 0.020937761291861534, -0.015863750129938126, 0.01694568060338497, 0.040037479251623154, 0.012909685261547565, 0.07873385399580002, -0.014436646364629269, 0.039070259779691696, -0.025313416495919228, 0.004132348112761974, 0.006424253806471825, -0.007030517794191837, -0.031492363661527634, 0.02244987152516842, -0.006919703911989927, 0.04109804332256317, -0.050117895007133484, -0.06454403698444366, -0.020183682441711426, 0.006655416917055845, 0.023134035989642143, -0.028514420613646507, -0.008909085765480995, -0.012842657044529915, -0.026278767734766006, 0.008565815165638924, 0.011120297014713287, 0.055503055453300476, 0.05041186138987541, 0.03377634659409523, -0.013816426508128643, -0.040474116802215576, -0.05629535764455795, -0.0458429753780365, 0.0028482447378337383, 0.015580957755446434, 0.030132297426462173, -0.0022285720333456993, 0.014925967901945114, 0.04335664585232735, -0.038897331804037094, 0.0013495476450771093, -0.01956506073474884, 0.00038770525134168565, -0.038126103579998016, 0.0012614403385668993, 0.003801672486588359, -0.037435755133628845, 0.0019242538837715983, -0.022623037919402122, -0.0010934200836345553, -0.005255341529846191, 0.10701997578144073, 0.008807607926428318, -0.000293110468192026, -0.004727829247713089, -0.02497166581451893, 0.046329155564308167, 0.04876749962568283, -0.002476463094353676, -0.029004860669374466, -0.04019467905163765, -0.022097783163189888, 0.06950660049915314, 0.01664562337100506, -0.021989895030856133, -0.0248413123190403, -0.056617606431245804, -0.014033446088433266, -0.025277769193053246, 0.04820409417152405, -0.022066710516810417, -0.04770667850971222, 0.01337738148868084, 0.02001621015369892, -0.012689360417425632, -0.016321714967489243, 0.020301880314946175, -0.04430869594216347, -0.026452528312802315, 0.051305465400218964, -0.005074673797935247, -0.04277821630239487, -0.06552291661500931, 0.010577508248388767, 0.04967084154486656, -0.013698022812604904, 0.001473503652960062, 0.027256956323981285, -0.058819882571697235, -0.02364993467926979, -0.0017671200912445784, -0.014944695867598057, -0.03511630743741989, 0.03002111054956913, 0.04417853802442551, -0.01746603474020958, 0.02956707403063774, 0.039894599467515945, -0.04031530022621155, -0.021631717681884766, -0.04096762835979462, -0.05869610607624054, 0.047894567251205444, 0.00013480213237926364, 0.038824889808893204, 0.07447163015604019, -0.005916173569858074, -0.0016955238534137607, -0.007017826661467552, -0.017230035737156868, -0.07131132483482361, -0.026600275188684464, 0.026002133265137672, -0.0020726495422422886, -0.005074917338788509, 0.0032139834947884083, -0.022419098764657974, 0.062352295964956284, -0.09445639699697495, -0.021332548931241035, -0.016552239656448364, -0.013409792445600033, -0.017194457352161407, -0.06353737413883209, 0.03305276855826378, 0.03968922421336174, 0.020127367228269577, -0.0002607963979244232, 0.029085827991366386, -0.060016341507434845, 0.03034525364637375, -0.047545671463012695, -0.02341107837855816, -0.05332481861114502, 0.015289432369172573, 0.019525745883584023, 0.055956363677978516, -0.01888883113861084, -0.015724841505289078, -0.05800071358680725, -0.009292704984545708, 0.013336816802620888, 0.011395631358027458, 0.026044359430670738, -0.038334231823682785, -0.031062979251146317, 0.033875737339258194, 0.026391545310616493, -0.014117677696049213, 0.053738608956336975, 0.03210335224866867, 0.02526961639523506, 0.0044310493394732475, 0.047084737569093704, -0.025937475264072418, -0.0002156787522835657, 0.013676903210580349, -0.054029181599617004, -0.04731735214591026, 0.0009017420816235244, -0.023358581587672234, -0.020788904279470444, 0.005445483606308699, -0.0017696358263492584, 0.022048085927963257, 0.020661616697907448, 0.019118133932352066, 0.027120469138026237, 0.025818590074777603, -0.001598264672793448, -0.0282660610973835, -0.05772695690393448, 0.021460510790348053, 0.026677172631025314, -0.0065555148757994175, -0.007544348016381264, 0.023091251030564308, -0.02915799617767334, 0.0008876440697349608, -0.049754805862903595, -0.02767775021493435, 0.017634470015764236, -0.05040733888745308, 0.010509097948670387, -0.03018396906554699, 0.03336040675640106, 0.010882276110351086, 0.011076642200350761, 0.015565001405775547, 0.026623135432600975, -0.04097314178943634, -0.0450248122215271, -0.028626736253499985, -0.013875763863325119, -0.039714571088552475, 0.029204295948147774, 0.00031765340827405453, 0.08675552159547806, -0.003361028851941228, -0.0007023153593763709, 0.027653388679027557, 0.006357603240758181, -0.018879961222410202, -0.03726348280906677, -0.03934131935238838, -0.05990191921591759, 0.06238396465778351, 0.017372334375977516, 0.008450951427221298, 0.002906513400375843, 0.007660965900868177, -0.017998136579990387, -0.0020455699414014816, 0.045059338212013245, -0.002236466621980071, 0.004279811400920153, -0.019352102652192116, -0.028738422319293022, -0.027159584686160088, 0.016512135043740273, -0.03689420223236084, 0.001644429750740528, -0.0003042059252038598, -0.013680858537554741, -0.0044013019651174545, 0.02735433541238308, -0.03877240791916847, 0.0030962747987359762, -0.017503932118415833, 0.01004158053547144, 0.0018251618603244424, -0.007307846564799547, 0.011037933640182018, 0.007307892199605703, 0.04463846608996391, 0.08263436704874039, -0.04216979816555977, -0.009674621745944023, 0.09471584856510162, 0.011456652544438839, 0.05093740299344063, -0.004545094911009073, -0.07788737863302231, 0.044352706521749496, -0.02022061124444008, 0.052253253757953644, -0.029623784124851227, -0.0646514743566513, -0.0058171385899186134, -0.06592986732721329, -0.025725647807121277, -0.054667387157678604, 0.053683340549468994, 0.053983576595783234, 0.03829281032085419, 0.02960280142724514, -0.04918265342712402, -0.015125662088394165, -0.06794163584709167, -0.03857015445828438, -0.022492913529276848, -0.04397550970315933, -0.005211766343563795, 0.010711122304201126, -0.02390502765774727, 0.01658785529434681, -0.006143751088529825, -0.02603616937994957, -0.024745240807533264, 0.00965526606887579, 0.07108351588249207, 0.014401146210730076, 0.0069671692326664925, 0.00018758318037725985, -0.061012960970401764, 0.10161519795656204, 0.014942537061870098, 0.06352472305297852, 0.04578718915581703, -0.10888271033763885, 0.018717728555202484, 0.019156619906425476, -0.06323080509901047, -0.0019428733503445983, 0.0052948747761547565, 0.005732645746320486, -0.08260398358106613, 0.03805302083492279, 0.04534466192126274, -0.036598559468984604, -0.015818936750292778, 0.004845533985644579, -0.026031840592622757, -0.028413837775588036, 0.004627144895493984, 0.028995420783758163, -0.0047037312760949135, -0.0038610410410910845, -0.03278644382953644, -0.016504542902112007, 0.05479089543223381, -0.06402330845594406, -0.0723024383187294, -0.047759655863046646, -0.02586241625249386, 0.003044380573555827, 0.031802594661712646, 0.041732799261808395, 0.02619796432554722, 0.04234522953629494, 0.01740902103483677, -0.02807636745274067, -0.03741222247481346, -0.03221792355179787, 0.06773840636014938, 0.041177935898303986, 0.03965490683913231, 0.01551690511405468, 0.036269206553697586, 0.07045493274927139, 0.03260253369808197, 0.028149357065558434, 0.02987883985042572, -0.028035005554556847, -0.06310079991817474, -0.00637986371293664, -0.032821714878082275, 0.08048264682292938, 0.05750569328665733, -0.012722915038466454, -0.047582920640707016, -0.0012353825150057673, -0.01710042543709278, 0.054939426481723785, -0.0042195976711809635, 0.04002242907881737, -0.03664453700184822, 0.023994188755750656, 0.06949348002672195, -0.0356416180729866, -0.06982846558094025, 0.041138727217912674, 0.01607663929462433, 0.027472637593746185, -0.027229728177189827, -0.03430921956896782, -0.019221842288970947, 0.04378512129187584, -0.028802042827010155, -0.008774789050221443, -0.05730661004781723, -0.008220409043133259, 0.018391815945506096, -0.01486546266824007, -0.09292171150445938, 0.009216666221618652, 0.004260469228029251, -0.005709722638130188, -0.0019094032468274236, 0.0010184868006035686, -0.009738242253661156, -0.0513768196105957, -0.0012282076058909297, -0.08496060967445374, -0.040059007704257965, 0.024201106280088425, -0.021145617589354515, -0.022768577560782433, 0.005083461292088032, 0.02979482151567936, 0.016669973731040955, 0.048227183520793915, -0.041225917637348175, 0.03159071132540703, -0.021527988836169243, -0.03279709443449974, 0.0008066646987572312, 0.02503913827240467, -0.043159112334251404, 0.0002541565045248717, -0.0540713369846344, 0.02895720675587654, 0.01854918897151947, 0.012399871833622456, 0.06008263677358627, 0.038543399423360825, -0.004212565720081329, 0.03892548382282257, 0.029424123466014862, -0.015712318941950798, 0.022063056007027626, 0.035300545394420624, 0.025273902341723442, -0.00012291765597183257, 0.026649722829461098, 0.0024281456135213375, -0.018704572692513466, -0.03023947961628437, 0.10296852886676788, -0.013068951666355133, -0.05185719206929207, 0.03858782351016998, 0.007528738118708134, -0.009521634317934513, -0.022291770204901695, -0.033650338649749756, 0.015000836923718452, 0.014604546129703522, 0.03247141093015671, 0.01379303727298975, -0.03337375074625015, -0.044336844235658646, 0.017280338332057, 0.05190219730138779, 0.016363639384508133, 0.057782500982284546, 0.005687277298420668, 0.017810601741075516, 0.06076297536492348, -0.007082443684339523, 0.007970123551785946, -0.02789810299873352, 0.019829511642456055, 0.0013088957639411092, 0.007333356887102127, -0.039571646600961685, 0.025127572938799858, -0.01875201426446438, -0.02911839447915554, 0.006400722078979015, -0.019933758303523064, -0.01105138286948204, 0.024490633979439735, 0.03273523226380348, -0.057270731776952744, -0.036629822105169296, -0.058057721704244614, 0.017282379791140556, 0.033732570707798004, 0.01441950909793377, -0.007575687952339649, 0.04518993943929672, -0.0015572962583974004, -0.005818200763314962, -0.02643575891852379, -0.008332774974405766, 0.010967458598315716, -0.042970675975084305, -0.07646901905536652, -0.057190440595149994, 0.058325305581092834, 0.009360804222524166, -0.015418379567563534, -0.020697642117738724, 0.03548070043325424, 0.04843367636203766, 0.0033706603571772575, -0.06126707047224045, 0.06310390681028366, -0.024212777614593506, -0.0024813185445964336, -0.035725850611925125, 0.018726427108049393, 0.006771401036530733, -0.01033998467028141, -0.04566071927547455, 0.0006504881894215941, -0.00660120090469718, 0.0229747723788023, 0.011787675321102142, -0.010881737805902958, 0.008930588141083717, -0.04272059351205826, 0.0024621468037366867, 0.06682084500789642, -0.028894631192088127, -0.012138842605054379, -0.039018917828798294, 0.024209039285779, -0.02160228043794632, 0.011438462883234024, -0.0021344139240682125, -0.013159184716641903, -0.05142304673790932, -0.020313095301389694, -0.026587940752506256, -0.024267125874757767, 0.040839362889528275, -0.035839688032865524, 0.0044655813835561275, 0.044420696794986725, -0.004794908221811056, -0.037695322185754776, 0.027286257594823837, -0.02867395430803299, 0.004853855352848768, -0.00792109128087759, -0.04332813248038292, 0.010777906514704227, 0.011876383796334267, 0.002839805092662573, -0.031746916472911835, 0.02105219103395939, -0.011134708300232887, -0.051149316132068634, 0.02906692400574684, 0.0162851233035326, -0.024519307538866997, -0.007780759129673243, -0.013223245739936829, 0.06631169468164444, 0.02562515065073967, -0.022224504500627518, 0.021285362541675568, -0.021852778270840645, -0.04314744099974632, -0.003310189116746187, 0.028561454266309738, 0.014470867812633514, 0.02235935814678669, -0.009840639308094978, -0.016374381259083748, -0.04708635434508324, -0.02391996420919895, 0.09003191441297531, -0.013857933692634106, 0.06874282658100128, 0.08087173849344254, -0.014143749140202999, -0.058362241834402084, -0.05445363372564316, 0.004817962180823088, 0.07601801306009293, -0.019840091466903687, -0.037603508681058884, 0.019226355478167534, -0.01457970030605793, 0.0018074789550155401, -0.07885763049125671, 0.027729282155632973, -0.03025311976671219, 0.018663987517356873, -0.010749765671789646, -0.06634025275707245, -0.034555986523628235, -0.02991698496043682, 0.03624057024717331, -0.0034730432089418173, 0.013964129611849785, -0.06276557594537735, -0.06503719836473465, 0.06082938238978386, 0.03577070310711861, 0.01123882457613945, -0.033293887972831726, 0.020221251994371414, 0.043337631970644, -0.026862969622015953, 0.016719473525881767, 0.009589302353560925, 0.016561834141612053, -0.010419855825603008, -0.004981749225407839, 0.02063281461596489, 0.03054780699312687, -0.04025796428322792, 0.07336209714412689, 0.041243135929107666, -0.08999408781528473, 0.01800491474568844, 0.015393303707242012, 0.04876738414168358, 0.007137138396501541, -0.029319269582629204, -0.019870581105351448, -0.0588960237801075, -0.004964078776538372, -0.029978221282362938, -0.04210217669606209, 0.005563829094171524, 0.06074171140789986 ]
<p>Landau Lifshitz claim in their Mechanics book (39.11) that for a uniform rotation we have </p> <p>$ E = \frac{mv^2}{2} - \frac{m}{2} (\omega \times r)^2 + U,$ where the rotation is given by $v' = v + \omega \times r.$</p> <p>This does not make sense to me, since this centrifugal term is negative( I mean, compared to the energy of the rotating system the energy in the inertial system should be HIGHER, since there is an additional kinetic energy of the rotation) as I had exected something like $ E = \frac{m(v + \omega \times r)^2}{2} + U$ in the inertial frame.</p> <p>Then they claim that in the rotating system(in that case they use the notation $v_0$ instead of $v'$ we have $ E = \frac{mv'^2}{2} - m v' \omega \times r+ U,$ ( This looks reasonable to me, as kinetic energy is less than the inertial one), but still,in that case I had expected something like </p> <p>$ E = \frac{m(v' - \omega \times r)^2}{2} + U,$</p> <p>so where am I wrong(especially about my reasoning in the first place) and why is it wrong, just to plug in the velocity of the transformation.</p>
g9734
[ 0.052651528269052505, 0.013814658857882023, 0.00014835594629403204, -0.0075227669440209866, 0.014245055615901947, 0.014910698868334293, 0.059408530592918396, 0.02149130590260029, -0.0016814469126984477, -0.002192631596699357, 0.0032683745957911015, -0.0045637874864041805, -0.02335614524781704, -0.0008196613052859902, 0.0018569135572761297, -0.04599400982260704, 0.06383337080478668, 0.028165090829133987, 0.04182182252407074, 0.0632045567035675, -0.03499618172645569, -0.008456594310700893, 0.005823846906423569, -0.03178101032972336, 0.04071485996246338, -0.0022799023427069187, 0.006735983304679394, 0.01761934719979763, -0.02104959264397621, 0.021781351417303085, 0.038275837898254395, 0.033800672739744186, -0.011013652198016644, -0.0696820467710495, -0.04723808914422989, 0.004271816462278366, 0.08126199245452881, 0.010265502147376537, 0.03815969079732895, -0.0009190856944769621, 0.007268436253070831, 0.014520145021378994, -0.01824202574789524, 0.05549265071749687, 0.005236453842371702, 0.017168445512652397, 0.017904624342918396, 0.016976146027445793, -0.03858528286218643, 0.02817911095917225, -0.0029184354934841394, 0.047643888741731644, 0.01617613062262535, 0.013350246474146843, 0.009744465351104736, 0.060532983392477036, 0.027498960494995117, -0.04390864819288254, 0.011997189372777939, 0.03796377032995224, 0.002590770134702325, -0.06818845123052597, -0.01300766970962286, -0.013946346938610077, -0.013451357372105122, -0.06540414690971375, -0.010350354947149754, 0.008384937420487404, -0.030554406344890594, -0.025297202169895172, -0.028437253087759018, -0.014632130041718483, 0.03267327696084976, -0.014738190919160843, -0.010173019953072071, 0.048311591148376465, 0.051829248666763306, -0.04213179275393486, 0.06942430138587952, -0.04126959666609764, -0.042272280901670456, 0.01844732277095318, 0.002118179574608803, -0.013602158986032009, 0.06382810324430466, -0.016544776037335396, 0.009814395569264889, 0.03448471426963806, 0.03061693161725998, 0.045580774545669556, 0.005134071223437786, -0.04619026184082031, 0.06468740105628967, 0.008420070633292198, -0.06069153547286987, 0.00675079645588994, -0.042186539620161057, 0.059098824858665466, -0.027568908408284187, 0.018482983112335205, -0.030066724866628647, 0.012401536107063293, -0.002088658744469285, -0.046565599739551544, 0.06503114104270935, -0.07762162387371063, -0.004477479495108128, -0.016023755073547363, 0.010209373198449612, -0.01883566565811634, 0.0004337791760917753, -0.03894262760877609, -0.011966540478169918, -0.040755994617938995, -0.002116674091666937, 0.009279276244342327, 0.06980979442596436, 0.029004564508795738, -0.011934489943087101, 0.04313090816140175, 0.004969766829162836, 0.021904421970248222, -0.006517412140965462, 0.088014617562294, 0.009670759551227093, -0.006553168874233961, -0.021517343819141388, -0.03259318694472313, 0.0770367980003357, -0.00996433012187481, -0.055279623717069626, -0.02537475898861885, 0.0006634747260250151, 0.0005472545744851232, 0.04891763627529144, 0.025999443605542183, -0.01073512714356184, 0.008741922676563263, -0.01563763990998268, -0.024089310318231583, 0.02118128165602684, -0.06229435279965401, 0.027886319905519485, -0.0400678776204586, -0.036233946681022644, 0.043116554617881775, -0.028037065640091896, -0.004334220662713051, 0.07698347419500351, 0.03360108286142349, -0.03777678310871124, 0.06769543886184692, -0.01571355201303959, -0.008778464049100876, 0.014099309220910072, 0.014792267233133316, 0.07676953077316284, -0.00818922370672226, -0.008525146171450615, 0.0649707242846489, 0.03688201680779457, -0.03813404589891434, 0.016635391861200333, -0.0015789212193340063, -0.04114305600523949, 0.01569768600165844, 0.009552054107189178, 0.0032616457901895046, -0.0035124337300658226, 0.0062719653360545635, -0.06750685721635818, -0.00770057737827301, 0.01887378841638565, 0.03627093881368637, 0.003443254856392741, 0.03992185741662979, -0.03892840817570686, -0.011713949963450432, -0.01835966296494007, 0.024988671764731407, -0.024236097931861877, -0.003934384323656559, 0.037283893674612045, -0.018748939037322998, -0.025353848934173584, -0.006293983198702335, 0.010679475963115692, 0.07801716029644012, -0.04743753746151924, 0.022716833278536797, 0.022267842665314674, 0.01255327370017767, 0.007478697691112757, -0.029732119292020798, -0.000553842808585614, 0.027250133454799652, -0.006714013405144215, -0.05603930726647377, -0.027737842872738838, 0.06507998704910278, -0.01662430539727211, 0.022821467369794846, 0.08157207071781158, -0.03351321816444397, 0.0481082908809185, -0.015552511438727379, -0.037528909742832184, -0.06602475047111511, 0.05506857857108116, 0.020750783383846283, -0.02330733835697174, -0.019040189683437347, -0.026519108563661575, 0.04372621327638626, -0.026510294526815414, -0.007672687992453575, 0.03945780545473099, 0.02370634488761425, -0.01470186561346054, 0.013514522463083267, -0.0032905880361795425, -0.015283576212823391, 0.011517922393977642, 0.0032540520187467337, -0.05772901698946953, -0.02837047353386879, -0.04502708837389946, 0.005137198138982058, -0.021683959290385246, 0.006391615141183138, -0.011852173134684563, 0.007862083613872528, -0.028436094522476196, 0.07007741928100586, 0.020441841334104538, 0.01666870340704918, -0.012099381536245346, 0.00176975317299366, 0.060364365577697754, 0.05666523426771164, 0.03082278184592724, -0.03687424212694168, -0.04041167348623276, -0.05190277099609375, 0.04606841132044792, -0.02288120426237583, 0.09881814569234848, -0.03395877778530121, -0.010528444312512875, 0.03151804953813553, 0.022070953622460365, -0.029339617118239403, -0.015616641379892826, -0.03071391023695469, 0.004822221584618092, -0.042767707258462906, -0.04109249636530876, 0.022739581763744354, -0.013036302290856838, 0.044397905468940735, 0.039441611617803574, -0.03340038284659386, 0.0076209548860788345, 0.05901811644434929, -0.08221440017223358, 0.01158993411809206, -0.03009064681828022, 0.04107020050287247, 0.023168174549937248, 0.007664830889552832, 0.006175059359520674, 0.05708656832575798, -0.00451725022867322, 0.08047186583280563, -0.04631410911679268, -0.06849301606416702, 0.0006463158060796559, -0.014749608933925629, 0.004330345429480076, -0.02592466212809086, -0.053877733647823334, -0.0040335156954824924, -0.03113517537713051, 0.02200423553586006, 0.010416824370622635, -0.07506808638572693, -0.07905005663633347, 0.043727390468120575, -0.039470523595809937, 0.039161596447229385, -0.02491515316069126, 0.014696961268782616, 0.021335426717996597, -0.009104641154408455, 0.015386390499770641, 0.018582625314593315, 0.08014407753944397, -0.07685871422290802, 0.004069510381668806, 0.06591954082250595, 0.056147251278162, -0.02354278787970543, -0.028072122484445572, 0.03907947987318039, -0.013920099474489689, 0.027330610901117325, -0.01816542074084282, -0.06360014528036118, -0.03472454100847244, 0.01921505481004715, -0.04555400088429451, 0.03560342267155647, 0.049987904727458954, -0.01776529848575592, -0.08495262265205383, -0.014112131670117378, 0.00022408457880374044, -0.020886488258838654, 0.012414593249559402, -0.013228127732872963, -0.04588590934872627, -0.013553344644606113, 0.029390085488557816, -0.03864036500453949, 0.0651613399386406, 0.006349598988890648, -0.05090745538473129, -0.018275676295161247, -0.03986251726746559, -0.0427020825445652, 0.041973717510700226, 0.06814641505479813, 0.004485133569687605, 0.012181165628135204, -0.05306694284081459, 0.012379433028399944, -0.001945123658515513, 0.02280375175178051, 0.020593279972672462, -0.027804721146821976, -0.029233703389763832, 0.02044263295829296, -0.03462995961308479, 0.06637556850910187, 0.012456653639674187, 0.008702619932591915, -0.08846698701381683, 0.020684441551566124, -0.010673298500478268, 0.0020297334995120764, 0.011701722629368305, 0.040661681443452835, 0.03500350937247276, -0.014686147682368755, -0.027149945497512817, 0.0008526821620762348, 0.03428632393479347, 0.04079833999276161, -0.013099339790642262, 0.044738736003637314, 0.04098369926214218, -0.03507861867547035, -0.014878426678478718, 0.0013374552363529801, -0.00809101015329361, 0.04217151552438736, -0.013049755245447159, 0.01293940469622612, -0.045665428042411804, -0.03695128113031387, -0.04400601610541344, -0.03304126113653183, 0.03251007944345474, -0.0373200848698616, 0.035982951521873474, -0.12491168826818466, 0.01712730899453163, 0.05731167644262314, 0.012173296883702278, 0.023036491125822067, 0.06299193948507309, -0.05557733401656151, -0.002042461186647415, 0.004357893019914627, -0.01683819480240345, 0.04268631711602211, -0.06170674040913582, 0.009959373623132706, -0.015340374782681465, -0.024895120412111282, -0.0038776169531047344, 0.04155992716550827, -0.02410172112286091, 0.0018014672677963972, 0.014079229906201363, -0.018802456557750702, 0.0450243316590786, -0.007914221845567226, 0.001819969736970961, 0.04789284989237785, -0.030362434685230255, -0.006125461310148239, 0.0012433282099664211, -0.04448365047574043, 0.009041506797075272, 0.0428585447371006, 0.025492936372756958, -0.005712209269404411, 0.02624446526169777, -0.025482594966888428, 0.01906716078519821, 0.015287120826542377, 0.02390729822218418, -0.05989883840084076, -0.015510915778577328, 0.018511958420276642, -0.010826308280229568, -0.06095806509256363, -0.016264615580439568, 0.0015991762047633529, -0.002026302507147193, 0.03171023726463318, 0.011577831581234932, 0.012234150432050228, 0.007282453589141369, 0.07173439860343933, 0.08680341392755508, 0.040658991783857346, -0.015648845583200455, -0.040954168885946274, 0.009528803639113903, 0.019454989582300186, -0.04224521294236183, 0.009221124462783337, -0.04221859946846962, -0.012917800806462765, -0.006348073482513428, 0.024602010846138, 0.03548295423388481, 0.06662442535161972, 0.021028295159339905, -0.04395328462123871, -0.006094236858189106, -0.04446978494524956, -0.021633818745613098, 0.03733084723353386, 0.03455285727977753, -0.02809162065386772, 0.031792111694812775, -0.005320490803569555, -0.044654179364442825, 0.010288964956998825, 0.026255225762724876, 0.026892375200986862, 0.020083237439393997, 0.00008974192314781249, -0.07659976184368134, 0.0073190126568078995, 0.0023144774604588747, 0.019453315064311028, -0.036206092685461044, 0.03166333958506584, -0.02891658991575241, -0.027325039729475975, 0.010931622236967087, 0.06641820818185806, -0.009286575019359589, 0.019620578736066818, -0.06777171790599823, -0.04592415317893028, 0.04239261895418167, -0.03771309182047844, -0.06049799174070358, 0.004806037526577711, 0.05968828871846199, 0.006627672351896763, 0.04193684086203575, -0.0009410938946530223, -0.017754146829247475, -0.05207910016179085, -0.019866520538926125, -0.008539048954844475, 0.011871395632624626, -0.02021629549562931, 0.004745798651129007, 0.04297662526369095, -0.049977581948041916, 0.0029903033282607794, 0.009638236835598946, -0.032955996692180634, 0.010990658774971962, 0.03634355217218399, -0.018483789637684822, -0.03588009625673294, 0.010684005916118622, 0.07551801204681396, 0.03228713572025299, -0.06622219830751419, -0.0020211213268339634, 0.01544477790594101, -0.07511568069458008, -0.016444914042949677, -0.050236303359270096, -0.013075496070086956, 0.014773148111999035, 0.017132839187979698, 0.03367288410663605, 0.014863880351185799, -0.03873160853981972, 0.05596417561173439, 0.042119525372982025, 0.011369057931005955, 0.024974040687084198, -0.007236768025904894, 0.019516801461577415, -0.046823762357234955, -0.006052555050700903, -0.02763913758099079, 0.03515130653977394, -0.09809931367635727, 0.05116330459713936, 0.029371289536356926, 0.05255119875073433, -0.08817403018474579, -0.05388828366994858, 0.02179419994354248, -0.023247312754392624, -0.03514108061790466, -0.01954752393066883, 0.07983289659023285, 0.018274959176778793, -0.03995702415704727, 0.010455145500600338, 0.030151108279824257, 0.032794855535030365, 0.0061063687317073345, -0.02523845061659813, 0.005181671120226383, 0.027320360764861107, -0.007655283901840448, -0.037848927080631256, -0.07263582199811935, -0.012229744344949722, 0.03844799846410751, -0.07505565881729126, 0.08973687142133713, 0.02657214365899563, -0.009221158921718597, 0.03639775514602661, -0.008691288530826569, -0.04572233557701111, 0.00804846826940775, 0.005700806155800819, -0.05675075203180313, 0.027231382206082344, -0.0000642472441541031, 0.006861858069896698, 0.02279258519411087, -0.05947112664580345, -0.01006973348557949, 0.018287450075149536, -0.04071293771266937, 0.03270043060183525, -0.004086160566657782, 0.03954559192061424, -0.0004653200157918036, 0.0029826604295521975, 0.015568045899271965, 0.03391273692250252, 0.029400527477264404, 0.028037209063768387, 0.0016222975682467222, -0.006204227916896343, 0.03204115480184555, 0.06789321452379227, 0.04006560519337654, -0.013364527374505997, -0.0755857452750206, -0.024592813104391098, -0.028829684481024742, 0.004956364165991545, -0.0598393976688385, 0.017724115401506424, -0.06321673840284348, -0.01684524677693844, -0.0277397483587265, -0.013804296031594276, -0.021434109658002853, -0.03426814824342728, -0.02536112256348133, -0.011448363773524761, 0.021734042093157768, -0.017042355611920357, -0.01273069716989994, 0.002483051037415862, 0.01025305688381195, -0.043927859514951706, -0.04240080714225769, 0.022143015637993813, -0.01393861509859562, 0.020058339461684227, -0.014423705637454987, 0.06219077110290527, 0.011816008947789669, -0.024780794978141785, 0.009394397027790546, -0.08453938364982605, 0.05773165449500084, 0.006249207071959972, 0.07062225043773651, -0.03594142943620682, -0.04063396900892258, -0.006614659912884235, 0.053265199065208435, 0.0011676165740936995, -0.012280172668397427, 0.0015719898510724306, 0.05310690775513649, 0.006672933232039213, -0.014919726178050041, 0.0364467091858387, -0.040920644998550415, -0.0016696264501661062, -0.007725714705884457, 0.03506501764059067, 0.06739769130945206, -0.06265328079462051, 0.04908296838402748, 0.08197067677974701, -0.03641868755221367, 0.04197525605559349, -0.027327148243784904, -0.03674871847033501, 0.0675191879272461, 0.05701453238725662, -0.002886081812903285, -0.02878815494477749, 0.004975663032382727, 0.04720499366521835, -0.018660183995962143, -0.03714803233742714, 0.05419643968343735, 0.03327592834830284, 0.011769103817641735, -0.08140268921852112, -0.015124927274882793, -0.014349072240293026, -0.0076768891885876656, -0.05896884948015213, 0.02942795306444168, 0.0067578209564089775, -0.026902273297309875, -0.01591772958636284, -0.00862678699195385, -0.03341546282172203, -0.07893340289592743, 0.0007743876776657999, 0.02126171439886093, 0.06431645154953003, -0.0494031198322773, 0.01907198876142502, 0.009331871755421162, 0.030919751152396202, 0.02687263675034046, -0.05816682428121567, -0.0021001205313950777, -0.0677172839641571, -0.025018006563186646, 0.08153180778026581, -0.06346089392900467, 0.02279040403664112, -0.010769556276500225, -0.032171618193387985, 0.02259369008243084, -0.03303385153412819, 0.006909293122589588, -0.03547598049044609, -0.011206096038222313, 0.006856068037450314, -0.014918570406734943, 0.007190188858658075, -0.017457665875554085, -0.0005428525619208813, 0.027880633249878883, -0.005664470139890909, 0.008085583336651325, -0.05680939555168152, -0.04329235106706619, -0.028496311977505684, -0.026921169832348824, 0.016483813524246216, 0.051304496824741364, 0.06232202798128128, 0.047993503510951996, -0.029029835015535355, -0.011308570392429829, 0.024496497586369514, 0.035695403814315796, -0.01848818175494671, -0.02058809995651245, 0.0410100519657135, -0.0017945196013897657, 0.0028178105130791664, 0.02759777195751667, 0.016453351825475693, 0.056040916591882706, 0.030679864808917046, -0.06315634399652481, -0.011728767305612564, -0.03294701129198074, 0.029393214732408524, -0.028542714193463326, -0.04835096001625061, -0.03435089439153671, 0.041297655552625656, -0.006732713431119919, 0.049083810299634933, -0.022245801985263824, -0.03912957385182381, -0.012072852812707424, -0.020336225628852844, -0.0137304263189435, -0.005297353025525808, -0.06570199877023697, -0.03602908179163933, -0.038210105150938034, 0.018362345173954964, -0.024051964282989502, -0.05292457714676857, 0.025361308827996254, -0.04455963522195816, 0.005837643519043922, -0.022745512425899506, 0.007643829565495253, -0.04124677553772926, -0.04018327593803406, -0.025124942883849144, -0.03382829949259758, -0.02579951286315918, 0.021549880504608154, 0.0324011892080307, -0.047763921320438385, -0.03390483558177948, -0.01404684130102396, -0.057957906275987625, -0.0011018674122169614, -0.03390936553478241, -0.025974268093705177, 0.008488144725561142, 0.01611633226275444, -0.008574184030294418, 0.045317672193050385, -0.00936012715101242, 0.02256830595433712, 0.05318751186132431, -0.02463652566075325, 0.05237022042274475, 0.03770984336733818, -0.030165936797857285, -0.0010961074149236083, -0.020628277212381363, -0.033277563750743866, 0.0035969277378171682, -0.005116967484354973, 0.005894998088479042, -0.07242961972951889, 0.00025952138821594417, 0.038252972066402435 ]
<p>If the Higgs mass is in a certain range, the quartic self-coupling of the Higgs field becomes negative after renormalization group flow to a high energy scale, signalling an instability of the vacuum itself.</p> <p>However, I don't know how to interpret the fact that the vacuum appears to be stable at a certain scale, and not stable at a higher scale. Does it mean the actual collapse of the vacuum will start from the higher momentum modes? In other words, when the vacuum collapses, is it true that the value of the scalar field averaged over large distances remain bounded for an extended period of time, but appears to be diverging quickly when averaged over short distances? Also, is it true that such a collapse only happens via the slow process of quantum tunneling under usual circumstances, but will take place quickly if a particle is produced at a high energy comparable to instability energy scale?</p>
g9735
[ -0.0013926391256973147, 0.03338423743844032, -0.021525312215089798, -0.01005682535469532, 0.03900819644331932, 0.07482508569955826, -0.026359744369983673, -0.01595276966691017, -0.04273111745715141, -0.008633444085717201, -0.0718117207288742, 0.011300470679998398, 0.036452073603868484, 0.06686481833457947, 0.0014561396092176437, 0.03505532816052437, 0.06284687668085098, 0.011376393027603626, 0.05530296638607979, -0.030682923272252083, -0.06280051171779633, -0.030496079474687576, 0.018895447254180908, 0.036659397184848785, -0.03416670486330986, 0.017460769042372704, 0.019237376749515533, 0.0021850266493856907, 0.04517534747719765, -0.024231690913438797, 0.07156335562467575, 0.05735813081264496, 0.040808964520692825, -0.05696190521121025, 0.007504249922931194, -0.051701243966817856, 0.027487674728035927, 0.030065370723605156, -0.00349433277733624, -0.03328268229961395, -0.008069249801337719, -0.05646106228232384, 0.03415760025382042, -0.07811655104160309, -0.04068834334611893, 0.0333610475063324, -0.006959607359021902, -0.03672041743993759, 0.025045987218618393, 0.0027592582628130913, 0.034163180738687515, 0.0221412293612957, 0.010965333320200443, 0.028537791222333908, 0.03971588611602783, 0.038181714713573456, -0.029709123075008392, 0.0317695252597332, 0.034521106630563736, -0.016306865960359573, -0.017168698832392693, 0.01953979954123497, 0.025731366127729416, 0.009133069775998592, 0.07762237638235092, 0.016797754913568497, -0.09677137434482574, -0.03887656703591347, 0.015600654296576977, 0.0022570823784917593, -0.021283408626914024, -0.06956100463867188, -0.03997933864593506, 0.007245621643960476, -0.040040336549282074, 0.055627211928367615, 0.042841993272304535, -0.035534463822841644, -0.02466779574751854, -0.008355279453098774, -0.056154415011405945, 0.03958163782954216, 0.04987366497516632, -0.02846195548772812, 0.03641142696142197, -0.05544052645564079, -0.014124182984232903, -0.005705355666577816, -0.050534509122371674, 0.014688607305288315, -0.02464599534869194, -0.008291958831250668, 0.00934609305113554, -0.026902252808213234, 0.009900758042931557, 0.008452046662569046, 0.0020848512649536133, 0.12147334963083267, -0.004908009432256222, -0.004777091555297375, -0.06182454153895378, -0.006358413957059383, -0.015269492752850056, -0.02739652246236801, -0.08965522795915604, 0.011402107775211334, -0.009509675204753876, 0.006662486586719751, 0.11844302713871002, -0.0067097521387040615, -0.014798074960708618, 0.04915187135338783, -0.0727023258805275, -0.06190073862671852, 0.0007700935238972306, -0.02888440527021885, 0.053539227694272995, -0.027697816491127014, 0.04703898727893829, 0.018482975661754608, 0.04501424729824066, -0.014390792697668076, -0.01913977973163128, -0.03720318153500557, -0.009101254865527153, -0.013965672813355923, -0.02654912881553173, 0.024759357795119286, 0.0671081691980362, -0.0050940001383423805, 0.03980491682887077, -0.043788183480501175, -0.05790327116847038, -0.005496192257851362, 0.005225598346441984, 0.0310294758528471, 0.04227904602885246, -0.009128937497735023, -0.01853431947529316, -0.0067574745044112206, -0.03791360929608345, -0.01781310886144638, 0.025304153561592102, 0.025387417525053024, 0.009008664637804031, -0.019470784813165665, 0.07583329826593399, 0.05682370811700821, -0.039073437452316284, 0.03366892412304878, -0.005945349112153053, 0.11576172709465027, -0.02144298329949379, -0.047942642122507095, 0.0015208522090688348, 0.04476779326796532, 0.042765986174345016, 0.06442543119192123, 0.00019396266725379974, -0.0589061863720417, 0.04582909122109413, -0.01606663689017296, -0.04878246411681175, 0.03191275894641876, -0.05603749677538872, 0.02286824770271778, 0.022323401644825935, -0.039732273668050766, -0.005382369738072157, 0.011750944890081882, -0.03445512801408768, 0.025858785957098007, -0.00970650278031826, 0.04100232571363449, 0.014841835014522076, 0.009639098308980465, 0.006745135877281427, 0.01062459871172905, 0.011423084884881973, 0.03107406385242939, 0.045610710978507996, -0.007317329756915569, 0.02126474119722843, -0.051119133830070496, 0.06762956082820892, 0.055885668843984604, 0.007596619427204132, 0.06943965703248978, 0.017142070457339287, -0.030320510268211365, -0.008351953700184822, 0.0010867479722946882, -0.04015503078699112, 0.02990647964179516, -0.004879041109234095, 0.030163396149873734, 0.06649058312177658, -0.06979808211326599, -0.024080926552414894, -0.006486982572823763, -0.02530771493911743, 0.03278515487909317, -0.006643264554440975, 0.03297291323542595, 0.008015097118914127, -0.039923131465911865, -0.029070846736431122, -0.0037197440396994352, 0.011383256874978542, -0.011475512757897377, 0.018415553495287895, -0.03447463735938072, 0.018954727798700333, 0.03466101363301277, -0.01882367953658104, 0.0009092194377444685, 0.042031429708004, 0.06452186405658722, 0.003460976295173168, 0.03667163848876953, -0.046803005039691925, -0.03013974241912365, 0.029801592230796814, -0.0044228509068489075, -0.006431172136217356, -0.027806127443909645, -0.04747884348034859, -0.03499409556388855, 0.024208737537264824, 0.008934457786381245, -0.07692842185497284, 0.017618456855416298, -0.048164863139390945, -0.006153639871627092, -0.023496486246585846, 0.03142506256699562, -0.00902438722550869, -0.013194525614380836, 0.047912951558828354, 0.022057097405195236, 0.05539346858859062, -0.018307577818632126, -0.08972048759460449, -0.03004390373826027, 0.0015149344690144062, -0.014311393722891808, 0.07164394855499268, -0.0039234464056789875, -0.06447841227054596, -0.0032741003669798374, 0.036515865474939346, -0.03994908928871155, 0.012087940238416195, 0.016347648575901985, -0.03202922269701958, -0.018322234973311424, 0.00218615191988647, 0.002041286788880825, -0.047373536974191666, -0.04041014239192009, 0.009332183748483658, 0.002184482291340828, -0.028263738378882408, 0.016141057014465332, -0.025713734328746796, -0.021969009190797806, 0.04565897211432457, 0.015739798545837402, -0.06149987131357193, -0.02730591408908367, 0.009321847930550575, 0.060235992074012756, 0.007196853868663311, 0.052804190665483475, 0.011693754233419895, -0.061749666929244995, -0.057029590010643005, -0.040096111595630646, 0.04705687612295151, -0.09844516217708588, -0.045076314359903336, 0.010162881575524807, 0.017605092376470566, -0.01875792071223259, -0.02606918290257454, -0.07624295353889465, 0.015547322109341621, 0.02144901640713215, -0.03218332305550575, 0.07060382515192032, -0.021923759952187538, -0.042011432349681854, -0.00041981457616202533, 0.042922113090753555, -0.010629045777022839, 0.0698244571685791, 0.0465126670897007, -0.015191817656159401, 0.020972777158021927, -0.0026873531751334667, 0.00452252384275198, -0.034473173320293427, -0.09168146550655365, -0.05332233011722565, 0.005098976194858551, -0.00822979211807251, -0.020276768133044243, 0.024176649749279022, -0.0969504788517952, 0.0018792812479659915, -0.006533058825880289, 0.019925903528928757, 0.0031772423535585403, -0.01895287074148655, -0.022194555029273033, 0.013766972348093987, -0.003243724349886179, 0.024522829800844193, -0.03551076352596283, -0.01889638416469097, 0.0029577561654150486, -0.05925949290394783, 0.005641738418489695, -0.0008313985308632255, 0.00901395920664072, 0.023144708946347237, -0.024682139977812767, 0.03506501019001007, -0.01215437427163124, 0.010099824517965317, 0.008948219940066338, -0.03732895106077194, 0.06293447315692902, 0.003176020458340645, -0.023661257699131966, -0.000022579324649996124, -0.009752104990184307, 0.00517346290871501, 0.03466620668768883, 0.017693033441901207, 0.013302929699420929, 0.013750671409070492, -0.02664618380367756, 0.027804292738437653, 0.02414354681968689, 0.048192307353019714, 0.0022803302854299545, -0.03168879449367523, 0.0358167365193367, -0.051032904535532, 0.004787851125001907, 0.03812672197818756, 0.048230238258838654, -0.05566676706075668, -0.05767015367746353, 0.016767388209700584, -0.053108736872673035, 0.007676346227526665, -0.02851950004696846, -0.05135459825396538, -0.026565728709101677, -0.040443845093250275, -0.030148189514875412, -0.01647576317191124, -0.05681926757097244, -0.011688877828419209, -0.01209350861608982, -0.0026587729807943106, -0.038896579295396805, -0.0131544079631567, 0.04068053886294365, -0.026990534737706184, -0.05139336362481117, 0.056009866297245026, 0.0030412410851567984, -0.04090310260653496, 0.06811796873807907, -0.06443433463573456, 0.0053382148034870625, 0.025207560509443283, 0.042252786457538605, 0.026462571695446968, -0.006972860544919968, -0.03858470916748047, -0.031016666442155838, 0.03468797728419304, -0.08222630620002747, -0.04630405083298683, -0.020517589524388313, 0.0034303804859519005, -0.09033101797103882, -0.023287776857614517, -0.01941932551562786, -0.021653596311807632, 0.01877986453473568, -0.01584256812930107, 0.010155020281672478, 0.023682326078414917, 0.003988416865468025, 0.03432956710457802, 0.004331033211201429, 0.03822220116853714, -0.04657580330967903, 0.0315646268427372, 0.02763104997575283, -0.006756767630577087, -0.002019569044932723, -0.002049162285402417, -0.017253262922167778, -0.010426760651171207, 0.014888118952512741, -0.0020781392231583595, -0.050741344690322876, -0.07556800544261932, 0.07796049118041992, -0.01696566492319107, 0.0784251019358635, 0.013075570575892925, 0.028397737070918083, -0.011522331275045872, 0.023923253640532494, -0.024991475045681, 0.011373890563845634, 0.02044723369181156, -0.07419170439243317, -0.004177377559244633, 0.017662137746810913, 0.038507211953401566, -0.037062227725982666, -0.007127097807824612, 0.06520626693964005, 0.032655805349349976, 0.0034788926132023335, -0.009220264852046967, 0.011200876906514168, 0.0514981634914875, 0.030979987233877182, -0.02473442628979683, -0.012353658676147461, 0.05627991259098053, 0.038558103144168854, -0.0011767121031880379, 0.011899787932634354, 0.025265134871006012, -0.02740137279033661, 0.05356220901012421, -0.0408199280500412, -0.003596265334635973, 0.013639407232403755, -0.001777774770744145, -0.05356636643409729, 0.07023435831069946, 0.04123729094862938, -0.017590800300240517, 0.07106564193964005, -0.060016438364982605, -0.05348992720246315, 0.07178976386785507, 0.0260765440762043, -0.027189435437321663, -0.07249240577220917, 0.01056100893765688, -0.012430235743522644, 0.027124503627419472, 0.030611829832196236, -0.06790629029273987, -0.025146236643195152, 0.010120376944541931, -0.016530999913811684, -0.03368370234966278, 0.0032625505700707436, -0.01235835812985897, -0.019825829192996025, -0.06061692163348198, 0.02044937200844288, 0.03168831765651703, -0.01094830222427845, 0.009558403864502907, -0.0008470619795843959, -0.060961782932281494, 0.06099722534418106, 0.013829243369400501, 0.004720656201243401, 0.03355606645345688, -0.0486590713262558, -0.01266536582261324, -0.04276244342327118, -0.03948850557208061, 0.051861975342035294, -0.031236188486218452, -0.025639420375227928, 0.052823442965745926, 0.033540379256010056, 0.030424702912569046, 0.03611430153250694, -0.04087131842970848, 0.037933673709630966, 0.010284008458256721, -0.009043845348060131, -0.008394292555749416, -0.03624231368303299, -0.01746349036693573, -0.016483832150697708, 0.01691289246082306, -0.021175889298319817, 0.035875800997018814, 0.024976417422294617, 0.011389023624360561, 0.07561963051557541, -0.031240269541740417, -0.05167173594236374, 0.03598187118768692, -0.00871946755796671, -0.0017500878311693668, 0.0018753629410639405, -0.05148843303322792, 0.011317991651594639, 0.03135184943675995, -0.024913521483540535, 0.01308241207152605, 0.01788061484694481, -0.03403865545988083, -0.002034876262769103, 0.02980688214302063, 0.037470392882823944, 0.048050712794065475, -0.03433363139629364, -0.03328417241573334, -0.005650186911225319, -0.009335819631814957, 0.06951978802680969, -0.04888557642698288, 0.02007843740284443, 0.0033612926490604877, 0.03040299192070961, 0.01603781431913376, 0.012456848286092281, 0.009841891936957836, 0.03167939931154251, 0.008726607076823711, -0.039259061217308044, -0.055731743574142456, -0.05672817304730415, 0.05968249961733818, 0.029433898627758026, -0.00036038184771314263, 0.0019546232651919127, 0.027157418429851532, 0.022979823872447014, -0.034212253987789154, -0.026312440633773804, -0.002656158059835434, -0.0029716379940509796, 0.021147338673472404, -0.022911228239536285, -0.001554327318444848, 0.03571780398488045, 0.0019200819078832865, -0.028221581131219864, -0.028893684968352318, 0.044961266219615936, -0.014902080409228802, 0.05259094014763832, -0.010271089151501656, 0.007076877169311047, 0.005809318274259567, 0.037451665848493576, -0.05560099333524704, 0.02536788210272789, -0.020917948335409164, 0.025788439437747, 0.014150507748126984, 0.04255228117108345, -0.03100143000483513, 0.0021691720467060804, -0.00224636890925467, 0.006911201402544975, -0.016522232443094254, -0.022985180839896202, -0.02314404584467411, -0.009466499090194702, -0.016585536301136017, 0.031052997335791588, -0.06079989671707153, -0.0474705845117569, 0.0010145447449758649, -0.039101965725421906, -0.03319655731320381, 0.05111406370997429, 0.05034824460744858, -0.0025182217359542847, 0.05103026703000069, 0.007558916695415974, 0.04079209640622139, 0.01567653939127922, 0.02223690040409565, -0.04089877009391785, -0.0683395192027092, -0.048475757241249084, -0.04115865007042885, 0.034995198249816895, 0.0688645988702774, -0.01758633367717266, -0.021710937842726707, -0.004786695819348097, 0.01901720091700554, 0.04027726501226425, 0.08660577982664108, -0.023401156067848206, 0.0914011225104332, 0.0726645290851593, 0.016117896884679794, -0.005940653849393129, -0.011074945330619812, 0.03491242974996567, 0.009506450966000557, 0.06569254398345947, 0.014265093952417374, -0.0252198688685894, 0.018853146582841873, -0.018866006284952164, 0.0057109324261546135, 0.052789099514484406, 0.029305849224328995, -0.03254253417253494, -0.004094593692570925, 0.04036623239517212, 0.0416034571826458, 0.036758895963430405, -0.03188437968492508, 0.054092150181531906, -0.0312652513384819, 0.0018874575616791844, 0.01825566403567791, 0.013908585533499718, 0.0396752767264843, -0.08610618114471436, -0.009569750167429447, 0.008338960818946362, 0.020638391375541687, 0.016391977667808533, -0.02211618423461914, 0.019527889788150787, -0.02569449692964554, 0.0005236484576016665, 0.00001914810673042666, -0.005956104490906, 0.00686819851398468, 0.028983034193515778, 0.017246663570404053, 0.019181305542588234, 0.01832086220383644, -0.03785284608602524, -0.04815474525094032, -0.025598138570785522, 0.013501819223165512, -0.060784921050071716, 0.05574512481689453, -0.023811178281903267, -0.05861305817961693, 0.0737631544470787, 0.0003068051300942898, 0.04554346948862076, 0.02555573731660843, 0.014514262787997723, 0.06590670347213745, -0.03507789224386215, -0.05356377363204956, 0.026042329147458076, -0.04796399921178818, 0.020840462297201157, -0.02983345463871956, -0.044787656515836716, -0.031057083979249, -0.014066438190639019, -0.0031136004254221916, -0.06127641722559929, 0.06312444061040878, 0.004482405260205269, 0.023687928915023804, -0.01165916956961155, 0.0004282285808585584, 0.04321202635765076, -0.04259645938873291, -0.008663994260132313, 0.008825032040476799, 0.004172753542661667, -0.0038456174079328775, -0.014900613576173782, 0.020127704367041588, -0.015956660732626915, -0.018608124926686287, 0.01632118411362171, 0.033187706023454666, 0.0017996474634855986, 0.02436903677880764, 0.0014238458825275302, -0.03154967352747917, -0.009534144774079323, -0.0027766921557486057, 0.04017350450158119, 0.008299733512103558, -0.016633274033665657, 0.030622657388448715, 0.011912107467651367, 0.008650928735733032, 0.058436956256628036, -0.028831299394369125, -0.05188548192381859, 0.00010556091729085892, -0.003312162822112441, 0.01829349622130394, 0.02362651564180851, 0.005298136733472347, 0.012314578518271446, -0.02490074373781681, -0.028114788234233856, -0.052778154611587524, -0.053667619824409485, -0.017036980018019676, -0.025489475578069687, -0.009725295938551426, -0.007729960139840841, -0.033620551228523254, -0.007140295580029488, -0.0056677707470953465, 0.010023749433457851, 0.020848143845796585, -0.0006261169328354299, -0.022521544247865677, -0.05525805428624153, 0.03257346525788307, -0.04193578660488129, -0.026128510013222694, -0.010799028910696507, 0.04600181803107262, 0.026174113154411316, -0.018535230308771133, 0.010255317203700542, 0.011490531265735626, -0.010212681256234646, -0.017500298097729683, 0.05328219383955002, 0.03982754051685333, 0.010026012547314167, -0.04225059971213341, 0.005005639512091875, -0.04246262088418007, 0.06381790339946747, -0.0319400317966938, 0.037947919219732285, -0.03177231177687645, 0.0101937185972929, 0.07047009468078613, 0.0042098406702280045, 0.0024389191530644894, -0.022902825847268105, -0.0008320357301272452, -0.0245938990265131, -0.019286926835775375, 0.0397590808570385, -0.06370452791452408, 0.025572730228304863, -0.04545404762029648, -0.029874464496970177, -0.03091169148683548, -0.038652315735816956, -0.07067981362342834 ]
<p>I am looking for good and recent references to constructing twistor space for curved spacetime. This could be a general spacetime, or specific ones (say maximally symmetric spaces different from Minkowski). This could be in he context of the twistor correspondence, or the twistor transform of field equations, either subject generalized to curved spacetime.</p> <p>The references I am familiar with are the standard ones from about 30-40 years ago, where most constructions involve flat spacetime. Some generalizations are mentioned, but my impression is that the community had not settled at the time on a single approach. Many things happened since, and one of the things I am hoping to get is some understanding of the landscape of current approaches to the subject.</p>
g9736
[ 0.01012976560741663, -0.023119350895285606, -0.012480358593165874, 0.013394131325185299, -0.004189479164779186, -0.013963774777948856, 0.02899780124425888, 0.017944546416401863, -0.03485356271266937, 0.02408427931368351, -0.003785599023103714, -0.03642365336418152, 0.07542534917593002, -0.006228474900126457, -0.02921435609459877, -0.01119889784604311, 0.033906567841768265, 0.0032465632539242506, -0.01843990944325924, -0.015697138383984566, 0.04004976153373718, -0.04061293601989746, 0.028742048889398575, 0.013956405222415924, -0.031160930171608925, -0.010976290330290794, 0.03929172083735466, -0.04850808158516884, -0.04915368929505348, -0.010211446322500706, 0.04631334915757179, 0.09260541200637817, -0.0052649835124611855, -0.016597948968410492, -0.003415909828618169, -0.022359177470207214, -0.007091976236552, -0.007346177473664284, 0.035216715186834335, 0.06336475908756256, 0.05349333956837654, 0.050631552934646606, 0.000979634583927691, 0.047348376363515854, 0.04603179544210434, 0.014053631573915482, -0.042700767517089844, 0.06436959654092789, -0.0016549701103940606, 0.010366739705204964, -0.009313995018601418, 0.04818517714738846, -0.003981466870754957, -0.0868336632847786, -0.032432328909635544, -0.014536493457853794, 0.013444427400827408, -0.004241873975843191, 0.020516322925686836, -0.019601283594965935, -0.061912283301353455, 0.001491064322181046, 0.009108667261898518, 0.043707866221666336, -0.016549795866012573, 0.09551730006933212, -0.012262551113963127, -0.022634973749518394, 0.05701553076505661, 0.030871178954839706, 0.08167921751737595, 0.022407082840800285, 0.09321220219135284, -0.02780872955918312, -0.025046812370419502, -0.01830621063709259, -0.012203630059957504, 0.023118682205677032, -0.028035201132297516, -0.08265820890665054, 0.024797234684228897, -0.009572754614055157, -0.011053710244596004, 0.00426360173150897, 0.05686790496110916, -0.015698902308940887, -0.012299834750592709, 0.034012455493211746, -0.005926134064793587, 0.010617739520967007, 0.0342797227203846, 0.0036120221484452486, 0.030271237716078758, 0.016870902851223946, -0.037707991898059845, -0.02767600677907467, 0.0043288543820381165, -0.06488949060440063, -0.049704186618328094, 0.0069998325780034065, -0.01393603440374136, -0.0072585344314575195, 0.018335070461034775, 0.058458857238292694, -0.009050829336047173, 0.013676204718649387, 0.0052541946060955524, -0.015994511544704437, 0.014976550824940205, -0.004651146475225687, -0.05573857203125954, 0.029530290514230728, 0.009043378755450249, -0.0013027347158640623, -0.03364922106266022, 0.002244198229163885, -0.02853216789662838, -0.04001038521528244, 0.012279263697564602, 0.08503250777721405, 0.01910281367599964, 0.02980044297873974, -0.012574810534715652, 0.030513815581798553, 0.013818856328725815, 0.014760123565793037, -0.027401920408010483, -0.03648059442639351, 0.05513725429773331, -0.024355947971343994, -0.013645251281559467, -0.006505267228931189, -0.028785699978470802, 0.023785674944519997, -0.054820429533720016, 0.035768698900938034, -0.05158737301826477, -0.01671529747545719, 0.016633670777082443, -0.018297407776117325, -0.012569433078169823, -0.0269026942551136, 0.03257136419415474, 0.05849706381559372, 0.01490233838558197, 0.002302270382642746, 0.008428930304944515, -0.043860264122486115, -0.019630003720521927, 0.0024454016238451004, -0.06632932275533676, 0.06016222760081291, 0.05395643413066864, -0.009027072228491306, -0.004330003168433905, 0.03274110332131386, 0.013761145062744617, -0.012677055783569813, 0.07133487612009048, -0.01507684774696827, 0.01665574312210083, -0.01008144672960043, -0.040539517998695374, -0.021496042609214783, -0.037161607295274734, 0.008999897167086601, -0.025087811052799225, -0.054806195199489594, -0.009052993729710579, -0.06053760647773743, -0.06583566218614578, -0.03187308460474014, 0.08290818333625793, 0.002530042314901948, 0.005211477633565664, -0.0034798812121152878, 0.02171868458390236, -0.020872309803962708, 0.004233459010720253, -0.02216838300228119, -0.05818137526512146, -0.06183484196662903, -0.00936227384954691, 0.016093777492642403, -0.017634928226470947, 0.0429060123860836, -0.06732877343893051, -0.020385611802339554, -0.0657435953617096, 0.0355023518204689, 0.046809472143650055, -0.0004564150294754654, 0.03083834983408451, 0.09825637936592102, 0.01848485693335533, 0.06515457481145859, 0.06767995655536652, -0.0636044517159462, -0.026912871748209, -0.005763056222349405, -0.011591438204050064, -0.006945646833628416, 0.019761858507990837, 0.02784130536019802, 0.010240075178444386, 0.02091141790151596, -0.013508976437151432, -0.05766689032316208, 0.0526682510972023, 0.04196822643280029, 0.025747351348400116, -0.023630226030945778, 0.054018378257751465, -0.058776699006557465, -0.026703782379627228, 0.006327589508146048, -0.017674949020147324, 0.0004920962965115905, -0.024914348497986794, 0.010562927462160587, 0.05401988700032234, 0.017506804317235947, -0.028767621144652367, 0.041275136172771454, 0.03337650001049042, -0.0018705982947722077, 0.02706589736044407, 0.002853912767022848, 0.020464610308408737, 0.0018704792018979788, -0.10091087967157364, 0.06667532026767731, -0.021545421332120895, -0.02037285640835762, 0.004911500960588455, -0.027340827509760857, -0.014466503635048866, 0.04163751378655434, 0.020053507760167122, 0.04520191624760628, 0.010966639034450054, 0.07149927318096161, -0.04707740619778633, -0.008813896216452122, -0.00026846249238587916, 0.0029551866464316845, 0.005517549347132444, -0.017677774652838707, -0.001941715949214995, -0.026637939736247063, -0.05254359915852547, -0.0287920031696558, 0.013388194143772125, -0.012952535413205624, 0.015545162372291088, -0.009365150704979897, 0.02775881625711918, 0.022387171164155006, -0.09600190073251724, -0.05801021680235863, 0.04473596066236496, 0.035580042749643326, -0.050657711923122406, 0.02173307165503502, -0.03769621625542641, -0.02631274051964283, 0.035086583346128464, 0.011964844539761543, -0.025030644610524178, 0.05129178240895271, -0.013010542839765549, 0.04403804615139961, -0.028235018253326416, -0.0366009920835495, -0.04490848630666733, -0.015270770527422428, -0.030174288898706436, -0.027220189571380615, -0.020799504593014717, -0.005374446045607328, 0.03816412389278412, -0.06771491467952728, -0.05012989789247513, 0.009682206436991692, -0.03283429518342018, -0.014874464832246304, -0.06368935108184814, -0.009165812283754349, 0.012405472807586193, 0.04102155193686485, 0.0034836234990507364, 0.032857414335012436, -0.022314976900815964, -0.10095183551311493, -0.05122286081314087, 0.055363867431879044, -0.045049820095300674, 0.016185594722628593, 0.009732184000313282, 0.005083010531961918, -0.015043147839605808, -0.03209700062870979, 0.04311959445476532, 0.004009381402283907, -0.016931654885411263, -0.0696755051612854, -0.016855882480740547, -0.09527884423732758, -0.02568436972796917, 0.014650199562311172, -0.03249501436948776, -0.011738195084035397, 0.025982631370425224, 0.03936374559998512, -0.07355201989412308, 0.01937967911362648, -0.015871362760663033, 0.036339644342660904, -0.05299168825149536, -0.07756606489419937, 0.020126232877373695, 0.025020692497491837, 0.0033216476440429688, -0.0005248527741059661, 0.017264677211642265, 0.02765636332333088, -0.042980995029211044, -0.013335119932889938, 0.012553581036627293, -0.0019907166715711355, -0.001603004871867597, 0.011005493812263012, 0.03492116183042526, -0.02340969815850258, -0.03240472078323364, -0.0320439487695694, -0.026874909177422523, 0.0010608569718897343, -0.010070404969155788, -0.06180765852332115, 0.026954669505357742, -0.03177184984087944, -0.04697538539767265, -0.04950353130698204, 0.0027676858007907867, 0.11059104651212692, 0.0410553477704525, -0.0022653022315353155, 0.04300687089562416, 0.01943034678697586, -0.015991054475307465, -0.004880022257566452, 0.03371117636561394, 0.0007865793886594474, 0.03758495673537254, 0.030681736767292023, 0.015139827504754066, -0.02377748116850853, 0.030773883685469627, -0.03208379074931145, -0.016243744641542435, 0.02222556248307228, -0.040596622973680496, -0.031167173758149147, -0.034182921051979065, -0.0068944115191698074, 0.02172505110502243, -0.1030503660440445, -0.07437749952077866, -0.006503001786768436, 0.07166112959384918, 0.07501689344644547, -0.017904413864016533, 0.03998821601271629, 0.005431327503174543, -0.03152519464492798, -0.010388214141130447, 0.047715023159980774, -0.0065523190423846245, -0.05115723982453346, 0.04448635131120682, 0.014402608387172222, 0.05231944099068642, 0.03953707218170166, -0.012425723485648632, 0.00961145106703043, -0.012684046290814877, 0.020364021882414818, 0.01836639642715454, -0.030918890610337257, 0.030652983114123344, 0.025960378348827362, 0.05514802783727646, -0.04890143871307373, -0.04173906520009041, -0.036545444279909134, 0.015562157146632671, 0.04561499133706093, -0.03909274563193321, -0.02305859886109829, -0.013090147636830807, 0.0012985229259356856, 0.05218992009758949, -0.05146852880716324, -0.031188705936074257, -0.01744753122329712, -0.012867491692304611, -0.0005089818150736392, -0.045652322471141815, -0.05563109740614891, 0.03425716236233711, 0.01601540669798851, -0.014260400086641312, -0.10595749318599701, 0.03832080960273743, -0.007698396686464548, -0.010169818997383118, -0.057278696447610855, 0.04572311043739319, -0.03977477550506592, 0.013076787814497948, 0.02245314046740532, -0.0035846803802996874, 0.0008954009972512722, 0.020069103688001633, 0.01196345966309309, 0.024457581341266632, -0.047603413462638855, -0.001201006700284779, 0.006712739355862141, 0.04038723558187485, 0.005007321480661631, -0.04082468897104263, 0.03512062132358551, -0.07431817799806595, 0.002490543993189931, -0.025789888575673103, -0.0064775897189974785, 0.025683827698230743, -0.039409659802913666, 0.04252384603023529, -0.007840980775654316, 0.008283612318336964, -0.009250661358237267, -0.05405297502875328, 0.06192570552229881, -0.0538923405110836, -0.026162121444940567, -0.03903161361813545, 0.04370381310582161, -0.029163483530282974, 0.020648038014769554, 0.051881127059459686, 0.03280046954751015, -0.04372396692633629, 0.0010762026067823172, 0.008717003278434277, -0.007481604814529419, 0.048192255198955536, 0.03724702075123787, 0.008850017562508583, -0.056969236582517624, -0.020255882292985916, 0.05745268240571022, 0.003326385049149394, 0.023740479722619057, -0.052170902490615845, -0.012884301133453846, 0.010052639991044998, -0.00782516784965992, 0.015238634310662746, 0.04271557554602623, -0.047648679465055466, -0.00865330919623375, 0.037626713514328, 0.05873478204011917, 0.009315121918916702, -0.0501582995057106, -0.09273294359445572, 0.020180752500891685, -0.03664660081267357, -0.009037488140165806, -0.03879247605800629, -0.0028637689538300037, 0.005500198341906071, 0.01709463633596897, 0.023237043991684914, 0.01249481551349163, 0.027634086087346077, -0.03957464173436165, -0.016990846022963524, 0.051962461322546005, 0.0019886845257133245, 0.016244616359472275, -0.033675841987133026, 0.04514886066317558, -0.04516570270061493, -0.027183592319488525, -0.015515806153416634, 0.04769245907664299, 0.03268736973404884, 0.04035951942205429, 0.04263180121779442, -0.017298653721809387, -0.044085793197155, 0.0008070377516560256, 0.044206682592630386, 0.04366828873753548, -0.09153315424919128, 0.040477950125932693, 0.060582760721445084, -0.01292230375111103, 0.021152332425117493, 0.04028042405843735, 0.024599701166152954, -0.013210456818342209, -0.0751771628856659, -0.0072676800191402435, -0.0023689395748078823, -0.057968370616436005, -0.013464362360537052, 0.010297857224941254, 0.029394203796982765, -0.013674994930624962, -0.0055359345860779285, 0.0883890762925148, -0.029270106926560402, -0.019572675228118896, 0.02191857248544693, -0.05760500952601433, 0.01268769521266222, -0.009067564271390438, 0.06235654279589653, -0.030791152268648148, -0.036610543727874756, -0.038466572761535645, 0.026634404435753822, 0.10238441079854965, 0.04779903590679169, -0.0019850065000355244, -0.022106774151325226, -0.009819377213716507, -0.028870578855276108, 0.000600668485276401, -0.04801824316382408, 0.04083632305264473, -0.009097754955291748, -0.009475364349782467, 0.020260285586118698, 0.00512468907982111, -0.0446978323161602, -0.022701451554894447, -0.010599751956760883, -0.05940601974725723, 0.016295956447720528, 0.04114329069852829, 0.001916192122735083, -0.03975841775536537, -0.06524396687746048, -0.011103855445981026, 0.025479691103100777, -0.053240448236465454, 0.028368208557367325, -0.0365375280380249, -0.02539058029651642, 0.01493451651185751, 0.01303714606910944, -0.07516113668680191, 0.07617925107479095, 0.03875241056084633, -0.016613686457276344, 0.03497963398694992, 0.016759740188717842, 0.01800152286887169, -0.010734237730503082, -0.04986836761236191, 0.031613487750291824, -0.09817539155483246, -0.07259757071733475, -0.0106083108112216, 0.04480062425136566, -0.013818386010825634, 0.02363777905702591, -0.062236346304416656, -0.07447851449251175, 0.013201465830206871, -0.033539026975631714, 0.04586063325405121, -0.032628271728754044, -0.0400022491812706, -0.0008558276458643377, 0.014230038039386272, 0.03777982294559479, -0.008797397837042809, 0.012262416072189808, 0.03852824866771698, 0.013597488403320312, 0.04538474604487419, -0.003967423923313618, 0.0175444558262825, -0.02233530953526497, 0.04523390531539917, 0.03728898614645004, 0.04789770394563675, -0.013713264837861061, 0.02486524172127247, -0.015965010970830917, 0.07165850698947906, 0.056681688874959946, -0.0046715280041098595, 0.031206725165247917, -0.0011741461930796504, -0.016621023416519165, 0.05428921803832054, 0.00290356925688684, -0.022647058591246605, 0.013134191744029522, -0.013598359189927578, 0.02752765640616417, -0.025248168036341667, 0.023869477212429047, 0.02818659134209156, -0.018920589238405228, 0.04300662502646446, -0.026460474357008934, 0.043956611305475235, -0.030319472774863243, -0.014569713734090328, 0.02354709804058075, -0.03359097242355347, 0.022493688389658928, -0.023175816982984543, 0.04444350302219391, 0.03581349551677704, 0.049810249358415604, 0.04513069987297058, -0.058021947741508484, 0.06396269798278809, -0.005424412898719311, 0.05745801329612732, -0.011417814530432224, -0.04510285705327988, -0.010033644735813141, -0.012357695959508419, 0.0003727508010342717, -0.04423268511891365, 0.006074526812881231, 0.0387890450656414, 0.01270660012960434, -0.019253594800829887, 0.032523710280656815, -0.03652884438633919, 0.004817633423954248, -0.004436281509697437, -0.06835969537496567, 0.023740533739328384, -0.002129773609340191, -0.007824125699698925, -0.0041433703154325485, -0.02663612738251686, 0.038946088403463364, -0.00754387304186821, 0.037553489208221436, -0.020921343937516212, -0.01715782657265663, 0.03091387264430523, 0.000771535444073379, 0.060860875993967056, 0.034385040402412415, 0.03241631016135216, 0.01949719525873661, 0.0007956496556289494, -0.009873527102172375, 0.002124092308804393, 0.03145204856991768, -0.04029558598995209, -0.046058446168899536, 0.020833902060985565, 0.01860825903713703, 0.010738168843090534, -0.037518780678510666, 0.03783704340457916, -0.0417557992041111, 0.009121769107878208, -0.01735306903719902, 0.02652967907488346, -0.00013540645886678249, -0.01566285453736782, -0.033118732273578644, -0.03372669219970703, -0.01384853944182396, 0.013878321275115013, -0.009708045981824398, -0.04762781783938408, -0.02902217209339142, 0.023200703784823418, 0.03595098853111267, 0.02432326041162014, -0.018078293651342392, 0.003995442762970924, -0.02264859527349472, 0.006968505680561066, -0.043416090309619904, 0.004128727130591869, 0.03317747637629509, 0.002196815563365817, -0.04094460979104042, -0.0612214170396328, 0.0141280023381114, 0.047077979892492294, -0.04222266003489494, 0.04001622647047043, -0.02284393087029457, -0.016602428629994392, 0.0024267802946269512, 0.03479572758078575, -0.007167308125644922, 0.06512296944856644, 0.037429530173540115, -0.007697533816099167, -0.008116409182548523, -0.020967992022633553, 0.04970476031303406, -0.06314302235841751, 0.01908191852271557, -0.019501943141222, -0.0008489913307130337, -0.018569936975836754, 0.013211172074079514, -0.017340034246444702, 0.07534805685281754, 0.001195198972709477, -0.05625041574239731, 0.010859398171305656, 0.014885331504046917, 0.01642400585114956, -0.030031269416213036, -0.05898021161556244, 0.0508255772292614, 0.006906553637236357, 0.024275725707411766, -0.026276737451553345, -0.015940973535180092, -0.034309737384319305, -0.031147675588726997, 0.00298877595923841, 0.014211299829185009, 0.012169018387794495, -0.035789668560028076, -0.00931549072265625, -0.001959356712177396, 0.07020596414804459, 0.008357099257409573, 0.02839924767613411, 0.025594761595129967, -0.006077192723751068, 0.025077223777770996, -0.01103229820728302, 0.06921058148145676, 0.05125874653458595, 0.0078051029704511166, 0.0283113531768322, 0.06495720148086548, 0.016873670741915703, -0.024508995935320854, 0.024750588461756706, 0.018330063670873642, 0.012080607004463673 ]
<p>An important aspect of the AdS/CFT correspondence is the recipe to compute correlation functions of a boundary operator $\mathcal{O} $ in terms of the supergravity fields in the interior of the $AdS_{n+1}$ (as we approach the boundary). Namely, $\big&lt; \exp \int_{\mathbb{S}^n} \mathcal{O} \phi_{0}\big &gt; = \mathbb{Z}_{s} (\phi \big|_{\partial(AdS)} = \phi_0)$, where $\mathbb{Z}_s$ is the supergravity partition function.</p> <p>The review papers I have found (and Witten's original paper as well) explain how to use the above formula but fail to provide a satisfactory explanation why the formula ought to work, or even how it came about.</p> <p>Can anyone explain if there is a logical (and/or insightful) path that would lead to the above correspondence between the generating function of the $n$-points correlators and supergravity/string theory?</p>
g9737
[ 0.058094896376132965, 0.019578419625759125, -0.01618567481637001, -0.005263428669422865, 0.006949977949261665, 0.025455735623836517, 0.1017199382185936, 0.0012960254680365324, -0.006563385017216206, -0.048833150416612625, -0.02426316775381565, 0.02583560161292553, 0.040916889905929565, 0.014134105294942856, -0.02527325227856636, -0.04234907031059265, 0.022469807416200638, 0.001411333098076284, -0.006091362331062555, -0.08390194922685623, 0.02745731733739376, -0.005209194030612707, 0.00795134250074625, -0.04633570462465286, -0.015279955230653286, -0.003395644947886467, 0.018582111224532127, -0.033928874880075455, -0.0011033699847757816, 0.015575828030705452, 0.07012572139501572, 0.05529327690601349, -0.0012705125845968723, 0.00025635756901465356, -0.023847855627536774, 0.005558789242058992, 0.01309922058135271, 0.11316873878240585, -0.0019166598794981837, -0.007815681397914886, 0.004945989232510328, -0.0662236213684082, 0.003507272806018591, -0.00941442046314478, -0.06648256629705429, -0.01651042513549328, -0.00801712553948164, 0.04667943716049194, -0.016106892377138138, -0.0467609204351902, -0.021675441414117813, 0.08831942826509476, 0.05355488881468773, -0.029401805251836777, -0.019887790083885193, 0.05381300672888756, 0.046124450862407684, 0.02800724282860756, -0.023393699899315834, 0.05901426449418068, -0.05550038069486618, -0.014250913634896278, 0.034400004893541336, 0.06821750104427338, 0.06524334847927094, 0.037746068090200424, -0.0051731751300394535, -0.037624504417181015, -0.0164234209805727, 0.013837861828505993, 0.00036922338767908514, 0.010937072336673737, 0.07613822817802429, 0.05769288167357445, -0.0566437765955925, 0.004019347485154867, 0.004838382359594107, -0.00468131247907877, -0.0007383223855867982, 0.029083823785185814, 0.005413878709077835, -0.03728024289011955, -0.0018308667931705713, 0.050582364201545715, 0.0001750703522702679, -0.02801726572215557, 0.014431317336857319, 0.022005442529916763, 0.014234931208193302, 0.025781339034438133, 0.027299145236611366, 0.01955116167664528, 0.0006672696908935905, -0.00798438023775816, -0.008321798406541348, 0.02022811956703663, 0.03292018920183182, 0.018091686069965363, -0.06911720335483551, -0.09824451059103012, 0.010727516375482082, 0.057886943221092224, 0.047229550778865814, 0.07794135808944702, -0.018072236329317093, -0.029900219291448593, 0.07621850073337555, -0.0027575171552598476, 0.025611964985728264, 0.059371475130319595, -0.07867889851331711, 0.04495019465684891, -0.006224418058991432, -0.05019513890147209, -0.02511247806251049, 0.024903850629925728, 0.022442927584052086, -0.033513277769088745, -0.002692329464480281, -0.0001126716670114547, -0.0038340978790074587, 0.0030965013429522514, -0.02935507521033287, 0.030623044818639755, -0.03127168491482735, -0.010925611481070518, -0.019316351041197777, -0.011499829590320587, 0.012697482481598854, -0.03644111752510071, 0.025527125224471092, -0.017574546858668327, 0.021726885810494423, 0.043349739164114, 0.023165008053183556, -0.02080371417105198, -0.012655578553676605, -0.03621197119355202, -0.022308388724923134, -0.019152672961354256, -0.09423276782035828, -0.05927390977740288, -0.009477016516029835, -0.02279672399163246, -0.00408153748139739, 0.025733046233654022, 0.02967342920601368, -0.06030920892953873, -0.022540027275681496, -0.03195950388908386, 0.030455272644758224, 0.058920931071043015, -0.012803057208657265, 0.022171983495354652, 0.0030798339284956455, -0.0005670810933224857, -0.006081106141209602, -0.09178396314382553, 0.012452363967895508, -0.000003620374627644196, 0.002270250115543604, 0.013233541510999203, 0.05878933146595955, -0.004625433590263128, -0.007482742425054312, -0.039960190653800964, 0.01904948242008686, -0.05459735170006752, -0.019631223753094673, -0.031334344297647476, -0.06665012240409851, 0.08002514392137527, 0.05858152359724045, 0.03769320994615555, 0.04687881097197533, 0.03702622652053833, -0.033835019916296005, 0.0327393040060997, 0.03281708434224129, 0.026965687051415443, -0.030073590576648712, -0.014134528115391731, 0.0187873262912035, 0.0069573973305523396, 0.014484417624771595, -0.006353014148771763, 0.013286341913044453, -0.016794322058558464, -0.03663225844502449, 0.05120217055082321, -0.0016159965889528394, -0.031115876510739326, -0.041026558727025986, 0.03571084141731262, -0.04945731908082962, 0.0662795677781105, 0.03540918603539467, -0.09722138941287994, 0.016868606209754944, -0.062399640679359436, -0.007338455878198147, 0.05257357284426689, 0.09632138907909393, -0.023457320407032967, 0.04600934311747551, 0.007209910545498133, -0.01578480936586857, 0.007035025395452976, -0.0294332392513752, 0.029583143070340157, -0.04273369163274765, -0.06940502673387527, -0.025839386507868767, -0.013366433791816235, -0.024016505107283592, -0.08226599544286728, -0.00928540900349617, 0.005407267715781927, -0.024673258885741234, 0.03870610147714615, 0.020817983895540237, 0.024728894233703613, 0.04762943089008331, 0.009519245475530624, -0.03433038294315338, 0.053040433675050735, 0.031830888241529465, 0.019692998379468918, 0.0000064210121308860835, -0.008186718448996544, -0.06906722486019135, 0.02582220919430256, 0.027210405096411705, -0.034764569252729416, -0.007521436549723148, -0.036935824900865555, 0.046894654631614685, 0.0455087311565876, 0.00905599258840084, 0.0870276689529419, 0.032937031239271164, 0.06007989123463631, -0.01825803518295288, 0.02527722716331482, 0.02182641066610813, 0.0185549259185791, -0.013390491716563702, 0.043448761105537415, -0.03833046555519104, 0.017640363425016403, 0.012823386117815971, 0.02537257969379425, -0.02500784955918789, 0.020010409876704216, 0.0153829175978899, 0.010199658572673798, -0.015848293900489807, -0.034097570925951004, 0.016840768977999687, -0.04153188318014145, 0.0006623202934861183, -0.00281210127286613, 0.002675982192158699, -0.01829138956964016, -0.007143457420170307, -0.04183565825223923, -0.02209479920566082, -0.037017639726400375, 0.014799496158957481, 0.012595409527420998, -0.029365956783294678, 0.058137036859989166, 0.026264218613505363, -0.0030675670132040977, -0.03558235615491867, -0.021448375657200813, -0.03738287091255188, 0.04365084320306778, 0.06486953794956207, 0.0114916255697608, 0.008687985129654408, 0.03796062618494034, 0.023923765867948532, 0.022438179701566696, 0.013108787126839161, -0.05780644342303276, 0.00010363712499383837, 0.028261946514248848, 0.004251464735716581, 0.02648971788585186, 0.0386136956512928, -0.0013628097949549556, -0.029191942885518074, 0.04361110180616379, 0.020654907450079918, -0.0012227528495714068, 0.03542760759592056, -0.03937086835503578, -0.005509503651410341, 0.07175937294960022, -0.0029001664370298386, -0.010188847780227661, 0.0063999309204518795, -0.00278432946652174, 0.0023000005166977644, 0.018888160586357117, -0.041779499500989914, -0.0752938985824585, -0.008345773443579674, -0.009406027384102345, -0.012549852021038532, 0.029775142669677734, 0.03159892186522484, -0.06075740605592728, 0.035621196031570435, 0.06662674248218536, 0.0660797581076622, 0.03596721589565277, 0.023363022133708, -0.07608859241008759, -0.05485692620277405, -0.011572469025850296, -0.025956977158784866, -0.021636953577399254, -0.005533621180802584, 0.05093824863433838, -0.07166516780853271, 0.034493595361709595, -0.047388602048158646, 0.00311378319747746, -0.018621068447828293, -0.018420863896608353, 0.02398093044757843, 0.026515502482652664, -0.06472646445035934, 0.0036234718281775713, -0.031104255467653275, 0.0016727749025449157, 0.030413128435611725, -0.017698384821414948, -0.02869942970573902, 0.03464898839592934, -0.007410991471260786, -0.016116345301270485, -0.005725321359932423, 0.043634846806526184, 0.0031839951407164335, 0.08364678919315338, 0.01014082320034504, -0.03779115527868271, -0.024972276762127876, -0.015203211456537247, 0.020806271582841873, 0.02777770347893238, -0.011811096221208572, 0.0846383273601532, 0.04475899040699005, -0.00011844581604236737, -0.03373159468173981, 0.013264752924442291, 0.02957635000348091, 0.023650942370295525, 0.023079801350831985, 0.028039798140525818, 0.017559366300702095, -0.06796572357416153, -0.006993339397013187, -0.019770773127675056, -0.051478028297424316, -0.01137083675712347, 0.03642070293426514, -0.03802257776260376, 0.015331964008510113, -0.012602787464857101, 0.05459073185920715, -0.07519028335809708, -0.01155408751219511, -0.020645642653107643, -0.0009535791468806565, -0.03953493386507034, 0.023702846840023994, 0.042287904769182205, 0.034553151577711105, -0.042959872633218765, 0.041538313031196594, 0.014289348386228085, -0.03071598894894123, -0.017633168026804924, 0.00725512346252799, -0.02923491597175598, -0.028204260393977165, -0.014826697297394276, 0.018343521282076836, 0.04339313879609108, 0.04538179561495781, -0.02348342537879944, -0.022585680708289146, 0.02150217816233635, 0.007836895994842052, -0.009969065897166729, -0.004687367007136345, 0.023602984845638275, 0.028546564280986786, -0.06759423017501831, -0.052270349115133286, -0.06076808646321297, 0.005121223162859678, -0.035272110253572464, -0.008431848138570786, -0.03528253734111786, -0.02614019252359867, -0.025044366717338562, 0.01764620840549469, -0.04278591275215149, 0.07274868339300156, -0.04885568469762802, 0.013041161000728607, 0.005167169962078333, 0.08019713312387466, -0.03772309795022011, 0.021996917203068733, -0.0030029446352273226, 0.0755162313580513, -0.009570140391588211, -0.035011276602745056, 0.006066890899091959, -0.04519633203744888, -0.006246713921427727, -0.009080469608306885, 0.00371932634152472, 0.03818964958190918, 0.054171834141016006, 0.021265141665935516, 0.05909945070743561, -0.07382560521364212, 0.05973515287041664, -0.023099467158317566, 0.004771204199641943, -0.03119400329887867, -0.02875768579542637, 0.036281686276197433, -0.022962098941206932, 0.033014509826898575, -0.013531751930713654, 0.03253418952226639, -0.0035228654742240906, -0.02419503591954708, 0.004205799195915461, 0.003937185276299715, -0.02540556713938713, -0.002200929680839181, -0.006036478094756603, 0.03406883776187897, -0.02883993089199066, -0.015410378575325012, -0.04983451962471008, 0.0642622858285904, -0.013543352484703064, 0.035375017672777176, -0.0010069129057228565, -0.04745447263121605, -0.003397605149075389, 0.02183504030108452, -0.0019697954412549734, 0.07952257245779037, 0.02352861687541008, -0.030094128102064133, -0.023071471601724625, -0.01913846842944622, 0.00640943692997098, 0.04795248061418533, 0.002191013190895319, 0.019023677334189415, -0.08878260105848312, -0.05341476574540138, 0.030860498547554016, -0.020766818895936012, -0.005076046567410231, -0.060817472636699677, -0.0322420671582222, -0.016010340303182602, 0.051603686064481735, -0.019221771508455276, -0.02099643275141716, -0.017226269468665123, -0.013360667042434216, -0.014203253202140331, -0.03832942247390747, -0.04236437380313873, -0.023163674399256706, 0.013449149206280708, -0.07516422122716904, 0.052040502429008484, -0.004019385669380426, -0.047480929642915726, -0.009825773537158966, -0.004364068154245615, -0.03715835139155388, 0.025874555110931396, -0.061227016150951385, -0.0231048334389925, 0.009751008823513985, 0.017927128821611404, 0.057501547038555145, 0.010910670273005962, 0.042106371372938156, 0.027035703882575035, -0.005012108013033867, -0.01546874176710844, 0.03739410266280174, 0.03263099119067192, 0.034487538039684296, -0.057112205773591995, 0.030513660982251167, -0.0249994695186615, 0.002935179974883795, 0.014227718114852905, 0.011877571232616901, -0.03876253962516785, -0.028599465265870094, 0.057777177542448044, -0.004267815966159105, -0.028579432517290115, 0.017203405499458313, 0.03723496198654175, 0.08336587995290756, -0.03415638580918312, -0.03784046694636345, 0.07570777833461761, 0.011743098497390747, -0.008890500292181969, -0.0038101591635495424, -0.011961288750171661, 0.034913383424282074, -0.00004973454269929789, -0.08330068737268448, 0.00028598238714039326, 0.03206409513950348, 0.0492146871984005, -0.0238681361079216, -0.004992797039449215, 0.0990377888083458, -0.0519963838160038, 0.004472593776881695, -0.0037956025917083025, 0.006425907369703054, -0.058475181460380554, -0.005505230277776718, -0.007776315324008465, -0.012918172404170036, -0.007103509735316038, 0.029103275388479233, -0.033510684967041016, 0.016816703602671623, 0.0019858761224895716, 0.04695121571421623, -0.007638606242835522, -0.014819557778537273, -0.009889082983136177, 0.010592622682452202, -0.013803152367472649, 0.006776074413210154, -0.01088385283946991, 0.006416898220777512, -0.047762416303157806, 0.007838689722120762, -0.022284265607595444, -0.029490405693650246, 0.00479031540453434, -0.01789851114153862, -0.04898485168814659, 0.012754207476973534, -0.01351083442568779, 0.01132386177778244, -0.021555308252573013, 0.03807729482650757, 0.010657880455255508, -0.07151897996664047, -0.052029985934495926, -0.011868367902934551, 0.00034631986636668444, 0.03438212350010872, 0.01734120398759842, -0.0484292134642601, -0.07872140407562256, 0.04450904577970505, -0.0679367184638977, -0.03994104638695717, 0.05493167042732239, -0.03752467408776283, 0.007317201234400272, -0.029923584312200546, -0.02039317600429058, 0.02119079791009426, -0.023569708690047264, -0.03809647262096405, 0.09998011589050293, 0.008258172310888767, -0.015597650781273842, -0.013199372217059135, 0.07016085088253021, 0.07847205549478531, 0.06778834760189056, -0.04413984343409538, -0.02942761220037937, 0.024139147251844406, -0.002592669799923897, -0.048321232199668884, -0.006569370161741972, 0.02336917631328106, 0.06785578280687332, 0.03822211176156998, 0.016631493344902992, 0.06832989305257797, 0.04623889550566673, 0.028248634189367294, -0.01610570214688778, 0.023707203567028046, -0.020172584801912308, 0.026521215215325356, 0.02215971052646637, 0.0027846116572618484, -0.04186580330133438, 0.03393017128109932, 0.021077215671539307, 0.006599685177206993, 0.03184378892183304, -0.03017576038837433, -0.023579834029078484, -0.0038367335218936205, -0.01340538915246725, 0.03972962871193886, -0.019371455535292625, 0.003090545302256942, -0.048806414008140564, 0.04978809878230095, -0.010079857893288136, -0.0034617886412888765, -0.04951208457350731, 0.0702727735042572, -0.04166867583990097, 0.0027525839395821095, -0.005985685158520937, -0.010502144694328308, -0.06981828808784485, -0.05346197634935379, 0.039124973118305206, 0.03767994046211243, -0.09585916996002197, 0.049221329391002655, 0.012167722918093204, -0.048834074288606644, -0.03445318341255188, -0.030946159735322, -0.07614824920892715, -0.019586442038416862, -0.0009793073404580355, -0.04492264986038208, -0.033942416310310364, 0.002517922082915902, -0.04955940693616867, -0.035204607993364334, -0.029690342023968697, 0.0042711785063147545, -0.01806502602994442, 0.05600864440202713, 0.021147487685084343, 0.051248699426651, 0.03270827978849411, -0.029020801186561584, 0.0022273303475230932, -0.03241414576768875, -0.03408413380384445, 0.03873639926314354, -0.0068887569941580296, -0.00555784534662962, -0.004161428660154343, 0.006605692207813263, -0.02514285035431385, -0.022943297401070595, 0.00461657764390111, -0.016696948558092117, -0.0006630326970480382, 0.009455529972910881, -0.03543145954608917, 0.023361559957265854, -0.005356652196496725, 0.01600397750735283, -0.0048470767214894295, 0.014328671619296074, -0.0026738522574305534, -0.01672118343412876, -0.007499036379158497, -0.0024777755606919527, 0.06262563914060593, 0.0013507326366379857, 0.023602930828928947, 0.06012541428208351, 0.03292500600218773, 0.07287232577800751, 0.018722841516137123, -0.03130817040801048, -0.06004445254802704, -0.04175557568669319, -0.002379822777584195, 0.03468602895736694, 0.017870085313916206, -0.053690630942583084, -0.011117241345345974, 0.011716035194694996, 0.0276911873370409, -0.011174638755619526, -0.023493792861700058, -0.019363906234502792, -0.001328183338046074, 0.04304216057062149, -0.010977237485349178, -0.008660361170768738, -0.0014924375573173165, -0.05098016932606697, 0.006403764709830284, 0.0011125383898615837, -0.004040554165840149, -0.0340237021446228, -0.06188046187162399, 0.0013025321532040834, -0.01684289239346981, -0.03243348002433777, 0.011394747532904148, 0.021498797461390495, -0.06601805239915848, -0.0449746772646904, -0.021613888442516327, -0.0076138777658343315, -0.019349629059433937, 0.0018933897372335196, -0.01304903905838728, -0.05040706694126129, 0.05309415981173515, -0.021152714267373085, 0.0024375254288315773, -0.035207394510507584, 0.042252067476511, -0.06364062428474426, -0.002000384731218219, -0.03349822759628296, -0.018140289932489395, 0.024292049929499626, 0.007094661705195904, -0.008448700420558453, 0.0415777750313282, 0.034463170915842056, 0.03846884146332741, 0.044616784900426865, 0.0480353869497776, -0.041398562490940094, -0.010780935175716877, -0.045577891170978546, 0.05489463731646538, 0.007643272168934345, -0.017435245215892792, -0.036713410168886185, 0.0415395088493824, -0.005932861007750034, -0.0317765511572361, -0.02120508812367916, -0.017882414162158966, 0.04205193743109703 ]
<p>Everytime I hear about adding torsion to GR, something struggles me: how do you create a kinetic term for the electromagnetic field that is still gauge-invariant? One of the consequences of torsion is that covariant derivatives no more commute on scalar functions, so by looking at the $F_{\mu\nu} = \nabla_{\mu}A_{\nu}-\nabla_{\nu}A_{\mu}$ (constrained to minimal coupling by the equivalence principle) and we perform a gauge transformation on it $A_{\mu} \to A_{\mu} + \partial_{\mu}\Lambda$ we get $F_{\mu\nu} \to F_{\mu\nu} + T^{\rho}_{\mu\nu}\partial_{\rho}\Lambda$ where $T^{\rho}_{\mu\nu}$ is the torsion tensor. So how can we handle torsion in non pure-gravity?</p>
g9738
[ 0.03547244146466255, 0.005797721911221743, -0.021656453609466553, 0.0008740260964259505, 0.06498350203037262, 0.05658315494656563, 0.085604228079319, 0.041020020842552185, -0.043923307210206985, 0.012693020515143871, 0.023882728070020676, -0.03216498717665672, -0.004271971061825752, -0.019837720319628716, 0.014938990585505962, 0.016656121239066124, 0.05420917645096779, -0.007644986733794212, 0.08599977940320969, 0.00696313614025712, -0.01880567893385887, -0.017254462465643883, 0.04972940683364868, -0.042248278856277466, 0.04350770637392998, 0.005955717992037535, 0.04715743288397789, -0.01925009675323963, 0.027320072054862976, -0.003053228836506605, 0.04403354972600937, 0.011084661819040775, 0.019115541130304337, -0.016723623499274254, -0.0288836807012558, -0.011648541316390038, 0.034825850278139114, 0.07558032870292664, 0.017817100510001183, 0.0009571717237122357, -0.008285541087388992, -0.044986966997385025, -0.0021511628292500973, 0.011391588486731052, -0.012530493550002575, 0.0218601543456316, 0.0277207363396883, 0.006870366167277098, -0.030373871326446533, 0.0048180194571614265, -0.05852280184626579, 0.017480624839663506, 0.04336871951818466, -0.0099845165386796, -0.03972993791103363, 0.020781518891453743, 0.05902915075421333, 0.02556818537414074, -0.019857343286275864, 0.026103850454092026, -0.007629264146089554, -0.037377290427684784, 0.051481764763593674, 0.011131728067994118, 0.012333233840763569, -0.02130870334804058, -0.05706743896007538, 0.012945241294801235, 0.006921896245330572, 0.0056515284813940525, -0.012577292509377003, 0.008309945464134216, 0.0280481968075037, 0.042082320898771286, 0.02227434702217579, -0.015270896255970001, -0.013477370142936707, 0.011306059546768665, 0.025409439578652382, -0.08952981233596802, 0.012165309861302376, -0.00002851095086953137, 0.008429888635873795, -0.005667980294674635, 0.04927889630198479, -0.01303860079497099, -0.009188052266836166, 0.03455733507871628, -0.018745411187410355, 0.03581811487674713, 0.045933183282613754, -0.07319124788045883, 0.061489615589380264, 0.022550130262970924, 0.04944920167326927, -0.012007778510451317, -0.0011992048239335418, 0.07813233137130737, -0.027120402082800865, -0.04939163848757744, -0.03312501683831215, 0.013015561737120152, 0.06689862906932831, 0.008947469294071198, 0.031243961304426193, -0.04990863800048828, 0.05744767189025879, 0.018115317448973656, 0.013554207049310207, -0.015171420760452747, -0.03685709089040756, 0.05120977386832237, -0.006804467644542456, -0.04767580330371857, -0.032558608800172806, -0.013095456175506115, 0.04868829622864723, 0.00461881048977375, -0.03681353107094765, 0.024244679138064384, -0.05114530026912689, 0.009350603446364403, -0.007317120674997568, 0.029305540025234222, -0.010060150176286697, -0.032967329025268555, -0.03977270424365997, -0.011846024543046951, 0.05590973049402237, -0.07246998697519302, 0.0030018475372344255, -0.005672593601047993, 0.03325303643941879, 0.011492657475173473, -0.014146365225315094, 0.0840376690030098, -0.022634072229266167, 0.007738779298961163, -0.028644928708672523, 0.029983147978782654, -0.0743466466665268, -0.08267499506473541, -0.003131806617602706, 0.015266606584191322, 0.009337043389678001, 0.029938368126749992, 0.024007972329854965, -0.06568040698766708, 0.04000929370522499, 0.009396002627909184, 0.08481772989034653, 0.05576099455356598, 0.018115254119038582, -0.02356559969484806, 0.07468235492706299, -0.03761664405465126, 0.061821479350328445, -0.016590723767876625, 0.007601751480251551, -0.017345987260341644, 0.07467278093099594, -0.011597393080592155, 0.06052213907241821, 0.01877296343445778, -0.01443312969058752, 0.004444606136530638, 0.02514670044183731, -0.013820667751133442, 0.04525052383542061, -0.08818303048610687, -0.052832283079624176, 0.006881501525640488, 0.03510146215558052, 0.029357552528381348, -0.054413020610809326, 0.06740645319223404, -0.07380206137895584, 0.01831885240972042, -0.05030201002955437, 0.04806816205382347, -0.037353646010160446, -0.030767150223255157, 0.050437770783901215, -0.026613539084792137, -0.024155566468834877, -0.0414147824048996, -0.02613755315542221, -0.014772904105484486, -0.04140738397836685, 0.0375368557870388, -0.020361701026558876, 0.008607696741819382, -0.007998771965503693, 0.08734789490699768, -0.06437752395868301, 0.04296321049332619, -0.004022177308797836, -0.040922101587057114, -0.03512030839920044, 0.06702025234699249, -0.013276475481688976, 0.010267958976328373, 0.003389830933883786, -0.028591811656951904, 0.012992577627301216, -0.0409698449075222, -0.014340933412313461, -0.04686766490340233, 0.05548452213406563, -0.029948847368359566, 0.059281304478645325, -0.015734797343611717, 0.03476859629154205, 0.00676536513492465, -0.042287178337574005, 0.03840016573667526, -0.012768595479428768, -0.0050686937756836414, -0.04889430105686188, -0.0182859655469656, 0.019814833998680115, 0.007101844996213913, 0.048149846494197845, 0.0572250559926033, 0.011155166663229465, -0.05738089233636856, -0.02423202618956566, 0.02588232234120369, -0.01528972014784813, -0.03510267660021782, 0.006248368415981531, 0.0993199273943901, -0.012980024330317974, 0.018920719623565674, 0.010919114574790001, 0.041744962334632874, -0.02414356917142868, 0.022686120122671127, -0.0038449601270258427, 0.005553813185542822, 0.07858425378799438, -0.022062793374061584, -0.002447557868435979, 0.0030976305715739727, 0.057187288999557495, 0.004446760751307011, 0.06717611849308014, 0.027678055688738823, -0.036971140652894974, 0.013339570723474026, -0.0003155106969643384, -0.06152937933802605, 0.011723165400326252, -0.04528044909238815, 0.010538612492382526, 0.03166705742478371, -0.0061865621246397495, 0.03256537765264511, -0.036998119205236435, 0.022932862862944603, 0.038569457828998566, -0.05808226391673088, 0.024001097306609154, 0.06195515766739845, -0.07571195811033249, -0.007659207563847303, 0.016977597028017044, 0.01375941839069128, 0.01048313919454813, 0.03722642734646797, -0.0980590209364891, 0.020020896568894386, -0.00289889401756227, 0.04768935963511467, 0.007905377075076103, -0.02699909172952175, 0.003346819896250963, 0.04197525233030319, -0.03466526418924332, 0.03283480182290077, -0.012932573445141315, -0.039557814598083496, 0.0000433593122579623, -0.033628229051828384, 0.00910164974629879, -0.027882324531674385, 0.0014760864432901144, -0.007198614068329334, 0.02307874895632267, 0.028891509398818016, 0.025065753608942032, 0.01335129514336586, 0.013112133368849754, -0.024760428816080093, -0.026664724573493004, -0.0024723641108721495, -0.03501276299357414, -0.02825063280761242, 0.014275742694735527, 0.012777960859239101, 0.03803885355591774, -0.02115475758910179, -0.01963075064122677, -0.01118307001888752, -0.0876312106847763, -0.02877257950603962, -0.05302231386303902, -0.07969096302986145, 0.04636199772357941, -0.012415061704814434, -0.052426036447286606, 0.018202735111117363, -0.04065157473087311, 0.03184027969837189, -0.061136115342378616, -0.010753342881798744, 0.016392743214964867, 0.02614355832338333, -0.007533414755016565, -0.02127744071185589, -0.008478960022330284, -0.04774938151240349, 0.03562625125050545, -0.004161013290286064, 0.014540525153279305, 0.0174575038254261, -0.017575105652213097, 0.030678831040859222, -0.021191177889704704, 0.0010340905282646418, 0.04109654575586319, -0.02246054820716381, -0.010033532045781612, -0.009933628141880035, -0.04189533740282059, 0.0013179659144952893, -0.019526833668351173, -0.00877432618290186, 0.05308986082673073, -0.04777032881975174, -0.06068267673254013, -0.03149256482720375, -0.0830041840672493, 0.06171043589711189, -0.06475813686847687, 0.01534393709152937, -0.013546853326261044, 0.02106046862900257, 0.04043691232800484, -0.004972395487129688, -0.020623572170734406, 0.00004287288902560249, -0.008240667171776295, 0.02599877119064331, 0.009145515970885754, 0.043997399508953094, 0.04101475700736046, 0.007405612152069807, 0.0023427079431712627, -0.007512927986681461, 0.011335006915032864, -0.0345769077539444, -0.051289841532707214, 0.042022354900836945, 0.0028492312412708998, 0.028544055297970772, 0.002446109429001808, -0.011812164448201656, 0.012849905528128147, 0.030858613550662994, -0.035967376083135605, -0.029263753443956375, 0.042885489761829376, 0.0336538590490818, 0.001423909212462604, -0.04733696207404137, 0.012081755325198174, 0.009032879956066608, -0.007778295315802097, 0.05495539307594299, -0.03663860633969307, 0.005122519563883543, 0.0001748019567457959, -0.024715328589081764, 0.003440495114773512, 0.026410261169075966, -0.04842319339513779, 0.029198909178376198, 0.019482716917991638, 0.003895181929692626, -0.020673932507634163, 0.028481759130954742, -0.02024810202419758, 0.00648023746907711, 0.02245999500155449, -0.04994003102183342, 0.03543875738978386, -0.0016978421481326222, -0.009153839200735092, 0.006541599053889513, 0.054412733763456345, 0.013406064361333847, 0.041216034442186356, 0.007659414783120155, -0.05833975970745087, -0.022165674716234207, 0.00804609153419733, 0.006337994243949652, 0.009314618073403835, -0.009745717979967594, -0.028808871284127235, -0.0504719614982605, 0.047829169780015945, -0.0926346406340599, 0.06737186759710312, -0.023635409772396088, -0.01721825636923313, -0.0475129671394825, -0.011121171526610851, -0.01517454907298088, 0.02815099246799946, 0.04870227351784706, 0.08548548817634583, 0.017255764454603195, -0.006188536528497934, 0.05635838583111763, 0.06176058202981949, -0.016681857407093048, 0.02025790885090828, -0.0335792601108551, -0.004258392844349146, 0.027332941070199013, 0.015065929852426052, 0.026436561718583107, -0.0455922856926918, 0.01200175005942583, -0.11103934049606323, 0.014966967515647411, -0.027476010844111443, 0.008087756112217903, 0.06638644635677338, 0.009388046339154243, 0.04054265469312668, -0.04219425842165947, -0.05472877249121666, 0.020653551444411278, 0.026559142395853996, -0.025260182097554207, -0.03509864956140518, 0.0023356114979833364, -0.001353620202280581, 0.012502769008278847, -0.022079212591052055, 0.030994849279522896, 0.00031767485779710114, 0.0028578934725373983, -0.04900608956813812, -0.030693598091602325, 0.006193225271999836, -0.01391355786472559, -0.04805390164256096, 0.0002039491810137406, 0.04535771906375885, -0.021550772711634636, 0.02391323633491993, -0.017162365838885307, -0.020313480868935585, -0.007376613561064005, -0.06060297414660454, -0.05907374992966652, 0.002864409936591983, 0.020258788019418716, 0.004555851686745882, -0.02779492922127247, 0.025079157203435898, 0.0687529593706131, 0.06892377883195877, 0.006634844932705164, -0.03506200760602951, -0.06458964198827744, -0.02613016963005066, -0.028667887672781944, 0.023422757163643837, -0.002591746626421809, -0.011326341889798641, 0.01762184128165245, 0.03437136486172676, -0.015279285609722137, -0.01365529466420412, -0.05820174887776375, 0.01632007397711277, 0.05539236217737198, -0.023180270567536354, 0.03727535903453827, -0.01863078586757183, 0.05217047408223152, 0.008214051835238934, -0.010257170535624027, -0.00433583976700902, -0.03934868425130844, -0.006049791816622019, -0.009582451544702053, -0.027337169274687767, 0.017280276864767075, 0.00985649973154068, 0.0427064411342144, 0.01616458036005497, -0.012257035821676254, -0.02700415626168251, 0.04333161190152168, -0.01127853337675333, -0.0026479449588805437, -0.04871923103928566, 0.042457714676856995, 0.03647184744477272, 0.009511011652648449, -0.03524358943104744, -0.0036441173870116472, -0.04311613738536835, -0.14337290823459625, 0.019065188243985176, 0.014936810359358788, 0.007981307804584503, -0.018608521670103073, 0.057374607771635056, -0.010732193477451801, 0.007457933854311705, -0.015728291124105453, -0.013300790451467037, 0.05717811360955238, 0.016473762691020966, -0.05439199507236481, 0.006978487595915794, 0.001249779132194817, 0.004916237201541662, -0.04759294167160988, 0.021083448082208633, 0.020841402933001518, 0.008944402448832989, 0.010738631710410118, -0.008770963177084923, 0.002113410271704197, -0.00015869522758293897, 0.0030363600235432386, -0.06474754214286804, 0.016449999064207077, -0.040601249784231186, -0.011311654932796955, -0.01229665707796812, -0.06265146285295486, -0.05599646642804146, -0.011393828317523003, 0.053908027708530426, -0.01125734206289053, 0.002383863553404808, 0.024168917909264565, 0.015041707083582878, -0.06684249639511108, -0.043285951018333435, -0.019090810790657997, 0.039498452097177505, 0.017915336415171623, 0.027543840929865837, 0.019919127225875854, 0.026303373277187347, -0.0580921471118927, -0.0020514533389359713, -0.06556372344493866, 0.07385571300983429, 0.014538577757775784, -0.0442039929330349, 0.04379069432616234, -0.03148357942700386, -0.010983572341501713, 0.00738599942997098, -0.009935490787029266, -0.05082830414175987, -0.06094163656234741, -0.01185294147580862, 0.03837147727608681, -0.0016089737182483077, -0.02913249097764492, 0.02224777080118656, -0.0967017337679863, -0.07640096545219421, 0.005774295423179865, -0.0038597872480750084, -0.017199579626321793, 0.008399540558457375, 0.05910157412290573, -0.034883055835962296, 0.015165324322879314, -0.006591638084501028, 0.056475672870874405, 0.019472358748316765, -0.00500214658677578, -0.03954421356320381, -0.025678463280200958, -0.026782337576150894, 0.024883974343538284, 0.011443705298006535, 0.013171171769499779, 0.07690143585205078, 0.034377023577690125, 0.025415534153580666, 0.05360610410571098, -0.09364868700504303, -0.06149539351463318, 0.03738453611731529, 0.018526436761021614, 0.0015787327429279685, -0.011359096504747868, -0.05154511332511902, 0.005425456911325455, 0.030304212123155594, -0.0032529609743505716, -0.04765593633055687, 0.03261653333902359, -0.040066592395305634, -0.006797350011765957, -0.012769795954227448, -0.03758683428168297, 0.061150990426540375, 0.019595203921198845, 0.01342300046235323, 0.043942950665950775, -0.021345313638448715, -0.003278132062405348, -0.02376273088157177, -0.020674724131822586, -0.022180020809173584, 0.014883242547512054, -0.043044790625572205, 0.023018721491098404, 0.003891219850629568, 0.02353462018072605, -0.009664902463555336, -0.028641970828175545, 0.07385294884443283, -0.00864201970398426, -0.05312105268239975, 0.05715681612491608, 0.10356730222702026, -0.018884088844060898, -0.08215010166168213, -0.019445644691586494, -0.009036482311785221, 0.01628330536186695, -0.064772829413414, 0.026826543733477592, -0.02964463271200657, -0.04609605669975281, -0.04613360017538071, 0.031200366094708443, -0.04910608008503914, 0.003829356748610735, 0.000873345066793263, 0.037024471908807755, -0.04856797307729721, -0.01176127977669239, -0.04296621307730675, 0.021427566185593605, 0.003047374775633216, 0.022204339504241943, 0.03875616192817688, 0.017606083303689957, 0.0120881712064147, 0.01559348963201046, 0.07549063861370087, -0.010315615683794022, -0.008305179886519909, -0.004667415749281645, 0.022016914561390877, 0.04414728656411171, 0.0017981077544391155, -0.012963935732841492, -0.05129009112715721, 0.026488792151212692, 0.009548177942633629, -0.00580159155651927, -0.042484723031520844, 0.04352960363030434, 0.02568887546658516, 0.05547874793410301, -0.024545885622501373, 0.020657707005739212, -0.032334502786397934, 0.03739113733172417, -0.007039858493953943, 0.026397379115223885, 0.01327203307300806, 0.04341771826148033, 0.004986683838069439, 0.02651415765285492, -0.017037831246852875, -0.014349780976772308, 0.008257748559117317, 0.02687339298427105, 0.03346646949648857, -0.015469549223780632, 0.009883652441203594, -0.026365531608462334, -0.04210357740521431, -0.012895122170448303, 0.046762868762016296, 0.024544602259993553, -0.0016936438623815775, -0.0716082900762558, -0.06953524053096771, 0.007905982434749603, 0.020143073052167892, 0.07983430474996567, -0.03039296343922615, 0.03272893279790878, 0.008456668816506863, -0.014190097339451313, -0.011597531847655773, -0.010580151341855526, 0.01530814915895462, -0.05034270137548447, -0.02557295374572277, -0.03324580565094948, -0.04871514067053795, -0.05381662771105766, 0.001926660304889083, 0.016058454290032387, -0.007266068831086159, -0.06321852654218674, -0.0009180211927741766, -0.02858744189143181, -0.02344457060098648, -0.0429326631128788, -0.012172813527286053, 0.01832500658929348, -0.02650880627334118, 0.06723382323980331, -0.056902237236499786, -0.02949235774576664, 0.010197625495493412, -0.013670566491782665, 0.0017103353748098016, -0.04659374803304672, -0.029014181345701218, 0.005974586121737957, 0.018640434369444847, 0.05091877654194832, 0.013570908457040787, 0.04708871245384216, -0.03230082243680954, 0.008717125281691551, 0.029756981879472733, 0.06103115156292915, -0.008227605372667313, -0.020496364682912827, 0.036500781774520874, -0.0556686706840992, 0.016580728814005852, 0.0035936927888542414, 0.038984209299087524, 0.04035673663020134, 0.01792314276099205, -0.012429851107299328, -0.048521801829338074, 0.02978920377790928, -0.025214899331331253, -0.07505936175584793, 0.011132444255053997, -0.008873413316905499 ]
<p>I've heard Astronomers talking about backlit CCD sensors, and talking about how much better they are than other types. What are they, why might I want to get one, and what are the pros/cons of this compared to related technologies?</p>
g9739
[ 0.03320947661995888, 0.03895426169037819, 0.02120940200984478, 0.03556066006422043, 0.06657494604587555, -0.010003522038459778, -0.018500031903386116, -0.08484183251857758, 0.03420376032590866, -0.04620618745684624, 0.015704700723290443, 0.06819342821836472, 0.0003574667207431048, 0.012555914930999279, -0.018745392560958862, -0.030609888955950737, -0.06981703639030457, 0.024821406230330467, 0.03556782379746437, 0.025705425068736076, 0.020815318450331688, 0.004767616745084524, -0.028059212490916252, 0.023880885913968086, -0.039403170347213745, 0.016951143741607666, 0.01942935399711132, -0.022079266607761383, 0.07066112756729126, -0.025640146806836128, 0.016029823571443558, -0.04274171590805054, 0.05764165148139, 0.03104032389819622, 0.0020707929506897926, 0.03264038264751434, 0.0010906809475272894, -0.03222702443599701, -0.03009958006441593, -0.026179548352956772, -0.02621377818286419, 0.06515020877122879, 0.02782280184328556, 0.01289347093552351, 0.06831544637680054, 0.02019265852868557, -0.0033166578505188227, -0.026091771200299263, 0.07615693658590317, -0.023511720821261406, 0.02175997756421566, 0.009332026354968548, 0.013117409311234951, 0.06159120053052902, 0.0236043781042099, -0.04181632027029991, -0.08154154568910599, 0.006052295211702585, -0.00914173386991024, -0.07709739357233047, -0.06756673008203506, 0.041528839617967606, -0.06588201224803925, -0.05815655365586281, -0.0012576228473335505, 0.009464966133236885, -0.010004285722970963, -0.01617046445608139, 0.051264096051454544, 0.051730599254369736, 0.04681674763560295, 0.027296261861920357, -0.033137641847133636, 0.04124251753091812, -0.037974629551172256, -0.04124140739440918, -0.03138101473450661, 0.008167692460119724, 0.005000903736799955, 0.02888665720820427, -0.009590351954102516, -0.05937588959932327, -0.030948206782341003, -0.003304219339042902, 0.014912864193320274, 0.03196752816438675, 0.01450954470783472, 0.0012981864856556058, -0.012319379486143589, 0.02193782664835453, 0.03650003671646118, -0.06818956136703491, 0.035624630749225616, 0.0039050080813467503, -0.0012034827377647161, 0.03768377751111984, 0.04328281804919243, -0.019442463293671608, 0.0391206294298172, 0.02958236262202263, -0.018688363954424858, -0.060111936181783676, -0.013241893611848354, 0.0733088031411171, 0.004103850107640028, -0.008434286341071129, -0.022507479414343834, -0.017259646207094193, 0.010271700099110603, 0.05593159422278404, -0.021254513412714005, 0.014389707706868649, -0.0011406721314415336, -0.030960330739617348, -0.042128752917051315, 0.028471972793340683, 0.018047304823994637, 0.04514116421341896, 0.06453200429677963, 0.06915347278118134, -0.008708067238330841, 0.06224862113595009, 0.003499599639326334, -0.006328396964818239, -0.022925110533833504, 0.02451244555413723, 0.0756252110004425, -0.020751936361193657, 0.04107290878891945, 0.019147220999002457, 0.09146101772785187, -0.0055572763085365295, -0.05940577760338783, -0.0191099364310503, 0.013024787418544292, 0.04579826444387436, -0.019947314634919167, -0.00964853074401617, -0.018205244094133377, 0.001611442188732326, 0.06056619808077812, 0.019030673429369926, -0.015706529840826988, 0.006150637753307819, 0.009213536977767944, 0.023163573816418648, -0.043417882174253464, 0.05459769070148468, 0.02174788899719715, 0.016451271250844002, 0.07155642658472061, 0.02527611330151558, 0.031220899894833565, -0.05598404258489609, 0.009434884414076805, 0.0013841589679941535, 0.00040707760490477085, 0.015566032379865646, -0.02157946303486824, 0.015316386707127094, 0.02851071022450924, 0.03379444777965546, -0.053030822426080704, 0.0007088891579769552, -0.044664327055215836, -0.0550595298409462, -0.026549750939011574, -0.057931944727897644, -0.014846564270555973, 0.0053747897036373615, 0.00357114733196795, 0.07446958869695663, -0.007383715361356735, 0.009808976203203201, 0.028166893869638443, -0.01347855944186449, -0.0461772158741951, 0.0031358124688267708, -0.002282865811139345, -0.04456919804215431, -0.05550765618681908, 0.012650862336158752, -0.04720104858279228, 0.034606002271175385, 0.038959864526987076, -0.05798563361167908, 0.01399279572069645, -0.028634393587708473, -0.007398340385407209, 0.026126787066459656, 0.0362960621714592, -0.0933280661702156, -0.01772378198802471, -0.005574681796133518, 0.010318603366613388, -0.040337275713682175, -0.03583548590540886, 0.006232993211597204, -0.048420000821352005, 0.027395015582442284, -0.05128869041800499, -0.015538974665105343, 0.015534200705587864, 0.025805938988924026, -0.010101615451276302, -0.007244611158967018, -0.019205713644623756, 0.01387879904359579, 0.018383437767624855, -0.043727051466703415, -0.004798796959221363, 0.003515401389449835, 0.02619165927171707, -0.024982698261737823, 0.02165493555366993, 0.01840314082801342, -0.03825605660676956, 0.024131961166858673, 0.08704915642738342, -0.06640046834945679, 0.022658729925751686, -0.028603870421648026, 0.013739568181335926, -0.028808671981096268, -0.006887430790811777, 0.0446857213973999, -0.03321672976016998, 0.04237009957432747, 0.0963955819606781, 0.050547949969768524, -0.018369708210229874, -0.01400352269411087, 0.031144101172685623, 0.04878440871834755, 0.02880181185901165, 0.054927706718444824, 0.05331491678953171, -0.0926627591252327, -0.0061121731996536255, 0.035164862871170044, -0.00025699849356897175, -0.017761442810297012, 0.0236760675907135, -0.04493088275194168, 0.002610845724120736, -0.0010082382941618562, 0.015152692794799805, 0.02694518305361271, -0.05748463422060013, -0.014147232286632061, 0.0437740758061409, -0.013880190439522266, 0.0019476977176964283, 0.007148469798266888, -0.05433591827750206, -0.004075108096003532, 0.07275720685720444, 0.02030099742114544, -0.08582435548305511, 0.04018917307257652, -0.03281910717487335, -0.04026022553443909, -0.00303071946837008, -0.09959535300731659, 0.06662794202566147, -0.012780328281223774, -0.04314433038234711, 0.03684048354625702, 0.01780134253203869, -0.004536081571131945, 0.033529456704854965, 0.05378264561295509, -0.0015987626975402236, -0.027095364406704903, 0.02376890741288662, 0.07382361590862274, 0.023132281377911568, -0.04327596351504326, 0.048698559403419495, -0.05838105455040932, 0.09685193002223969, -0.010079678148031235, -0.0027786330319941044, 0.025367168709635735, 0.01047685369849205, 0.04149649292230606, 0.0014135261299088597, 0.025859495624899864, 0.04258415102958679, 0.007472059689462185, -0.03436655178666115, -0.04236587509512901, 0.05901278555393219, -0.031951870769262314, 0.03749857097864151, -0.01895551197230816, 0.07484269887208939, 0.016344042494893074, 0.042432572692632675, 0.024959160014986992, -0.030878184363245964, 0.014779643155634403, 0.06053142622113228, -0.015895919874310493, 0.0167203601449728, -0.01834646239876747, 0.013416611589491367, -0.0258146021515131, -0.015811029821634293, -0.0127580426633358, 0.002460094168782234, -0.03199448063969612, -0.024843854829669, 0.031380701810121536, 0.017117727547883987, -0.004704300779849291, 0.006847440730780363, -0.002419752534478903, -0.04240841791033745, 0.018711963668465614, 0.03649909049272537, 0.023844512179493904, -0.012503785081207752, -0.03875579312443733, 0.03666754812002182, 0.018272168934345245, -0.0011252403492107987, -0.06628061830997467, 0.011922524310648441, -0.021142171695828438, 0.03405626118183136, 0.022304346784949303, 0.014341429807245731, 0.03472347930073738, -0.028248146176338196, 0.0082603320479393, -0.023760627955198288, 0.021490352228283882, 0.004356014542281628, 0.001822603982873261, 0.012042844668030739, 0.00696919159963727, -0.02815736085176468, -0.02591228112578392, 0.010460919700562954, -0.039575688540935516, 0.04746629297733307, -0.06046866998076439, 0.02375468984246254, -0.06860624253749847, 0.024151859804987907, 0.0018143338384106755, 0.019300268962979317, -0.017911620438098907, -0.016506049782037735, -0.003118384862318635, -0.0926271602511406, -0.004216616041958332, -0.012998039834201336, -0.009160462766885757, 0.005247058812528849, 0.049781545996665955, 0.0019382924074307084, -0.02602381631731987, -0.029806451871991158, -0.06312461942434311, 0.0056090462021529675, -0.02774221822619438, -0.025578975677490234, -0.019408635795116425, -0.01312147919088602, 0.05190841481089592, -0.01199992373585701, 0.03018716350197792, -0.007472592871636152, -0.017053237184882164, -0.029840124770998955, -0.03739466518163681, 0.04025166854262352, -0.06442946195602417, 0.01293978001922369, 0.017929639667272568, 0.02189483866095543, -0.022918911650776863, 0.009626106359064579, -0.03225582093000412, -0.014520898461341858, -0.014492444694042206, 0.013010531663894653, -0.03861679136753082, 0.07585526257753372, -0.032424431294202805, -0.02037624642252922, -0.05929947271943092, 0.058396901935338974, -0.04091772437095642, 0.011307870969176292, -0.04158750921487808, 0.056230101734399796, -0.05974799767136574, 0.03471965342760086, 0.026023440062999725, 0.03281806409358978, 0.011986958794295788, -0.034752536565065384, -0.04032374545931816, -0.010936442762613297, -0.0007180929533205926, -0.028458114713430405, 0.02126549370586872, -0.03189088776707649, 0.009951567277312279, -0.010685596615076065, 0.02455594763159752, 0.061893295496702194, 0.036531150341033936, 0.013314824551343918, -0.01824687421321869, 0.03413253650069237, 0.05739213153719902, -0.03268178924918175, -0.011600007303059101, -0.029855167493224144, 0.005036807153373957, -0.0274195559322834, 0.03696918860077858, 0.023308027535676956, -0.020767709240317345, -0.02533026784658432, 0.017367346212267876, 0.10874180495738983, -0.026408948004245758, 0.04284344241023064, -0.01438881829380989, -0.0034864048939198256, 0.029912669211626053, -0.013201895169913769, 0.0605783574283123, -0.029639191925525665, 0.021814607083797455, 0.004493896849453449, 0.031032662838697433, 0.05626596882939339, -0.016189323738217354, 0.028868431225419044, 0.025265444070100784, -0.03046247363090515, 0.04079923778772354, -0.04627430811524391, -0.023658327758312225, 0.005205064546316862, -0.010999844409525394, -0.04634334146976471, -0.01963874138891697, -0.02467038296163082, 0.010598764754831791, -0.012778754346072674, 0.000761833623982966, 0.00802854634821415, 0.014437434263527393, -0.004656543023884296, 0.028299903497099876, 0.07340272516012192, -0.02805395796895027, 0.03753453493118286, 0.03301199898123741, -0.05126184597611427, -0.02850559540092945, -0.019381245598196983, 0.009842394851148129, -0.05968780815601349, 0.018945390358567238, 0.0242032241076231, 0.029078641906380653, -0.04263533279299736, -0.06844688951969147, 0.001016046036966145, -0.004811205435544252, -0.02960745245218277, 0.007185366004705429, -0.05652562528848648, 0.008857794106006622, -0.011354795657098293, 0.023046478629112244, -0.01837279461324215, 0.013648610562086105, -0.02779882401227951, 0.0006194579182192683, -0.01795700006186962, -0.01184454932808876, -0.031655825674533844, 0.01176952850073576, 0.0304105244576931, -0.0909801796078682, -0.01583462953567505, -0.02980748564004898, 0.015702739357948303, 0.0054501015692949295, -0.009336316026747227, 0.045970965176820755, -0.03545884042978287, -0.003513048402965069, -0.03255803883075714, -0.01640782132744789, -0.025188276544213295, 0.03579019382596016, -0.02867068536579609, -0.053611915558576584, 0.01784519851207733, -0.0028081960044801235, -0.03648969531059265, -0.007079739589244127, -0.040878698229789734, 0.02874201536178589, 0.03245310112833977, 0.009351878426969051, 0.013448947109282017, -0.03162803873419762, 0.04321780800819397, 0.03308538347482681, -0.07929873466491699, -0.050424396991729736, 0.013505854643881321, 0.030407177284359932, 0.027780350297689438, -0.052653469145298004, -0.017363321036100388, 0.020668545737862587, -0.01006921287626028, -0.06903458386659622, -0.02743750438094139, 0.014772610738873482, 0.0604156032204628, -0.011812381446361542, 0.03392714262008667, 0.009191414341330528, -0.06465010344982147, 0.06566935032606125, 0.06271163374185562, -0.018497109413146973, -0.04706863313913345, -0.02146538347005844, 0.00031424147891812027, 0.06319357454776764, -0.006041144486516714, -0.018273742869496346, 0.02024746872484684, 0.08806920796632767, 0.012127233669161797, -0.003223673440515995, 0.0058700209483504295, 0.0013260676059871912, 0.040493227541446686, -0.0006140178884379566, -0.04410327598452568, -0.0015530051896348596, -0.02588406763970852, 0.04545865207910538, 0.00886338297277689, -0.051176004111766815, 0.016551561653614044, 0.03970012068748474, -0.023540053516626358, -0.04280181974172592, 0.03297054022550583, -0.011694484390318394, -0.005053400527685881, -0.0038423649966716766, 0.018643589690327644, 0.03145189210772514, -0.005700899753719568, -0.030476419255137444, 0.014863084070384502, 0.0028323286678642035, -0.0066045005805790424, -0.021526578813791275, -0.010420369915664196, 0.03348569944500923, -0.004075344651937485, -0.034445736557245255, 0.06299014389514923, 0.013263593427836895, -0.008663181215524673, -0.09831986576318741, 0.05663895979523659, -0.04069104045629501, 0.0032050239387899637, 0.029346315190196037, -0.023918386548757553, -0.04387659206986427, 0.022780047729611397, -0.023427138105034828, 0.04290253296494484, 0.028346462175250053, -0.05033130571246147, -0.0032953519839793444, -0.04161900654435158, 0.003927440848201513, -0.060827430337667465, -0.041416529566049576, 0.0009958037408068776, 0.011229300871491432, -0.012435292825102806, 0.021448545157909393, -0.02437281422317028, -0.03733528032898903, 0.00814027339220047, -0.03949064761400223, 0.05798531696200371, -0.012913456186652184, -0.032269321382045746, 0.011974016204476357, -0.010272791609168053, 0.001682391157373786, -0.013750125654041767, -0.0112984050065279, -0.0038379859179258347, -0.07956308126449585, 0.041487496346235275, 0.03057536855340004, 0.012426268309354782, 0.0065017687156796455, -0.03255476802587509, 0.029144547879695892, 0.02349173091351986, 0.06608835607767105, -0.007541365921497345, 0.07085112482309341, 0.056742142885923386, 0.07823380082845688, 0.0038517643697559834, 0.04117583855986595, 0.07464125752449036, 0.059634119272232056, 0.034483566880226135, 0.016853956505656242, -0.03692731633782387, -0.012990414164960384, 0.04350412264466286, 0.012917067855596542, -0.01237599365413189, 0.021539364010095596, 0.012465576641261578, -0.0559082068502903, -0.02821185626089573, 0.05427376553416252, 0.004897788632661104, -0.04190570116043091, -0.023649845272302628, -0.03487730398774147, -0.051592305302619934, -0.054301317781209946, -0.02851901762187481, 0.006745690945535898, 0.025240926072001457, 0.04728319123387337, -0.025235826149582863, 0.01850476674735546, 0.0013285328168421984, -0.05617981031537056, 0.04044656455516815, -0.01895655132830143, -0.06453555077314377, 0.018214643001556396, 0.044209886342287064, -0.037984661757946014, -0.0005772783770225942, -0.04109397158026695, 0.013239659368991852, 0.05501936376094818, 0.025505997240543365, -0.00422096811234951, -0.03423662111163139, -0.042388252913951874, -0.009609841741621494, 0.011465569958090782, -0.06671170890331268, -0.03786937892436981, -0.026570765301585197, 0.0004924008972011507, -0.05329841375350952, 0.036572493612766266, 0.02155092917382717, 0.025041818618774414, -0.0822879895567894, -0.0027897965628653765, -0.05118183791637421, -0.0019698808901011944, 0.022911526262760162, -0.10390953719615936, -0.049651939421892166, -0.023668065667152405, -0.059693098068237305, -0.02392037771642208, 0.008304312825202942, -0.00415129866451025, -0.032635707408189774, 0.06077160686254501, -0.010455594398081303, -0.04623909667134285, -0.06300565600395203, -0.018094368278980255, 0.00038241827860474586, 0.005803751293569803, 0.05188202112913132, -0.0397806279361248, -0.0064049381762743, 0.04298827052116394, 0.03912832587957382, 0.0723409429192543, -0.04071339592337608, 0.018654579296708107, 0.017634466290473938, 0.013514204882085323, -0.010733024217188358, -0.052832283079624176, -0.04515653848648071, -0.0093871233984828, -0.0510830394923687, 0.06459295749664307, 0.013380958698689938, -0.0014254141133278608, 0.02562635764479637, 0.0163725633174181, 0.005446692928671837, -0.03538540005683899, -0.015269450843334198, -0.00886326190084219, -0.017353465780615807, -0.021847277879714966, 0.004409492947161198, 0.029439834877848625, -0.05374784395098686, -0.019571825861930847, -0.06093169003725052, 0.007569752633571625, 0.011256800964474678, -0.023287329822778702, -0.040496330708265305, 0.006684678606688976, 0.010937639512121677, -0.0009351492626592517, 0.024113161489367485, -0.07314075529575348, -0.055081624537706375, -0.0020981449633836746, -0.026056181639432907, -0.0011623869650065899, 0.018527621403336525, 0.015098581090569496, 0.0357697419822216, 0.057525619864463806, 0.04200192913413048, -0.029350722208619118, -0.0430142916738987, 0.008300583809614182, 0.024506844580173492, -0.012357383966445923, 0.054616138339042664, 0.018850799649953842, 0.07250120490789413, 0.027625778689980507, 0.024910273030400276, 0.0012107001384720206, -0.045747336000204086, -0.004500495735555887, -0.04288013279438019, 0.01027069240808487 ]
<p><a href="http://www.news.com.au/technology/sci-tech/magnetic-bubbles-160-million-km-wide-may-be-earths-first-defence-against-cosmic-rays/story-fn5fsgyc-1226072932809" rel="nofollow">This</a> article reported today, a finding from one of the voyager probes. It talks about magnetic structures at the (far) outer edge of our solar system. Does that mean we're still able to pick up a signal from the Voyager probes ? And how long does it take to receive a transmission from a probe that is 16billion km from earth ?</p>
g9740
[ -0.036702580749988556, 0.047529853880405426, -0.01576227694749832, -0.03250163048505783, 0.02627134509384632, 0.02314748615026474, -0.013536114245653152, -0.022280864417552948, -0.01691928505897522, -0.02088143117725849, 0.05102110654115677, 0.045030780136585236, 0.02261611819267273, -0.027889030054211617, 0.014788102358579636, -0.033855922520160675, 0.05762132257223129, -0.03981408104300499, 0.033697571605443954, 0.017909303307533264, -0.01719360426068306, -0.013884523883461952, -0.01684178225696087, -0.02403036691248417, -0.027088196948170662, -0.0013508632546290755, 0.039176635444164276, 0.003089382778853178, 0.028762400150299072, -0.045794107019901276, 0.06906785070896149, -0.04668889939785004, 0.04893416538834572, -0.08154246211051941, -0.032864004373550415, -0.0301933865994215, -0.04817613214254379, 0.00275303702801466, -0.02906310185790062, -0.05340314656496048, 0.030523870140314102, -0.043201252818107605, 0.013681584969162941, 0.05256710201501846, 0.03779323026537895, 0.008387750014662743, -0.07224158197641373, 0.005731912329792976, 0.0032853649463504553, -0.014657595194876194, -0.0515931211411953, 0.01195924635976553, 0.03292950242757797, 0.08642017841339111, -0.0063174329698085785, -0.023769022896885872, 0.028944920748472214, -0.0253858994692564, 0.08615709096193314, -0.06709782034158707, 0.016278382390737534, 0.05174468085169792, -0.020828336477279663, 0.03961632773280144, 0.02375694550573826, 0.004318304359912872, -0.08230867236852646, 0.032379526644945145, 0.00037772892392240465, 0.027194423601031303, 0.0626654252409935, -0.04854908213019371, -0.04313865676522255, -0.09322284907102585, 0.0024463641457259655, 0.026521604508161545, 0.016618894413113594, -0.0012222810182720423, 0.009069886058568954, 0.10123976320028305, 0.006205597892403603, -0.013240331783890724, -0.06202772632241249, -0.007686612196266651, 0.04485584422945976, 0.038084179162979126, -0.03831850737333298, -0.0077956304885447025, -0.03202878683805466, 0.06301584839820862, 0.0761660784482956, -0.029083557426929474, -0.05785978212952614, -0.055468760430812836, 0.04989215359091759, -0.003696419531479478, 0.02038399502635002, -0.007182619534432888, -0.0517231710255146, -0.02271013706922531, -0.039544496685266495, 0.03237230330705643, -0.0021873789373785257, 0.003174931975081563, 0.036168601363897324, 0.0266672745347023, 0.009300652891397476, -0.03984186425805092, 0.040222007781267166, -0.0013160204980522394, 0.017431803047657013, -0.03695101663470268, 0.01614764891564846, -0.02893335558474064, -0.06027306616306305, -0.027300097048282623, -0.0030561513267457485, 0.021264400333166122, -0.020626354962587357, 0.07373064756393433, 0.033321067690849304, 0.009966508485376835, -0.030631693080067635, 0.06184292957186699, -0.0014507533051073551, 0.028578225523233414, 0.037378232926130295, -0.02976786345243454, 0.02426336705684662, 0.020660400390625, -0.03584164008498192, 0.028558749705553055, -0.008724990300834179, 0.007562615908682346, -0.012237107381224632, -0.02645866759121418, 0.06639549136161804, 0.0010061712237074971, 0.019471855834126472, 0.01951390877366066, -0.011875457130372524, 0.0072069657035171986, 0.055716127157211304, -0.05586351826786995, -0.02261422574520111, 0.028148265555500984, 0.020052049309015274, 0.031168803572654724, 0.009682835079729557, -0.01516622956842184, -0.006047477480024099, 0.05360807850956917, 0.06930448859930038, -0.026642318814992905, -0.02917725220322609, -0.013627243228256702, 0.03986451402306557, -0.028240373358130455, 0.053347133100032806, 0.019623255357146263, -0.012484683655202389, 0.03215312957763672, 0.000907107547391206, 0.014835081994533539, 0.003010807791724801, -0.039540886878967285, 0.03610672801733017, -0.026445718482136726, 0.023578893393278122, -0.0010166362626478076, -0.07960359752178192, -0.013631545007228851, 0.04948240891098976, 0.02987034246325493, -0.019206896424293518, 0.024904070422053337, 0.024745628237724304, -0.057965051382780075, 0.0025216133799403906, 0.05752906948328018, 0.015195665881037712, -0.04722979664802551, 0.006557427812367678, 0.08741898834705353, -0.05373789370059967, 0.007623620796948671, 0.004785696044564247, -0.050280872732400894, 0.013075778260827065, 0.020221803337335587, -0.005381582770496607, -0.04859528690576553, -0.014924850314855576, 0.007348848506808281, 0.025564078241586685, -0.03890872746706009, 0.05034709721803665, -0.008569774217903614, -0.03155991807579994, 0.030406799167394638, -0.030014602467417717, 0.07531265914440155, 0.023925520479679108, 0.00373093131929636, -0.028581595048308372, -0.05474567413330078, -0.0010195319773629308, -0.05207262560725212, 0.05769805982708931, -0.021220261231064796, 0.06410345435142517, -0.012018850073218346, -0.02812010422348976, 0.03257007151842117, -0.024972958490252495, -0.01731683872640133, -0.00777012063190341, 0.058872658759355545, 0.024442479014396667, 0.002986904699355364, -0.05850908160209656, 0.02480924315750599, 0.06056513264775276, -0.025825176388025284, 0.010805340483784676, -0.039882842451334, 0.015628449618816376, -0.023872483521699905, -0.02616017870604992, -0.0032537714578211308, 0.015804516151547432, 0.02153969742357731, 0.008688217028975487, 0.0400250069797039, 0.001522093079984188, -0.01454172283411026, 0.04292653501033783, -0.06136469542980194, -0.03666269779205322, -0.014936467632651329, 0.02382168546319008, 0.0008631459786556661, -0.06039508432149887, 0.005955600645393133, -0.014051023870706558, -0.03560603782534599, 0.008006979711353779, -0.0149234002456069, -0.042211681604385376, -0.03132810443639755, 0.07278314977884293, 0.003763006068766117, 0.06808369606733322, 0.08027823269367218, -0.020419355481863022, -0.02047608233988285, 0.013872078619897366, 0.015305914916098118, -0.0906626433134079, -0.040781598538160324, 0.02493557706475258, 0.01811734400689602, 0.06346308439970016, -0.008133032359182835, -0.014186672866344452, -0.024583252146840096, -0.013958442956209183, 0.0007109035504981875, -0.03244641795754433, -0.05488315969705582, -0.018165020272135735, 0.021042844280600548, 0.009588179178535938, 0.02211720496416092, -0.0038543324917554855, -0.05086877569556236, 0.02229285053908825, 0.003996421117335558, -0.004371775779873133, 0.02082226425409317, -0.03407096117734909, 0.03252141550183296, 0.009673361666500568, -0.00728987529873848, -0.02145467884838581, 0.012123245745897293, -0.06481131911277771, -0.0014362859074026346, -0.0033034367952495813, 0.02728974260389805, 0.03726794943213463, -0.03756849467754364, 0.08731154352426529, 0.003458078019320965, 0.017543846741318703, 0.007328320294618607, 0.0384836345911026, 0.05732228606939316, 0.008325520902872086, -0.04117792099714279, 0.0778074562549591, -0.00325693073682487, -0.0018693797755986452, -0.005557638593018055, -0.016380542889237404, -0.046361878514289856, -0.017809264361858368, -0.01642441190779209, -0.0037474515847861767, -0.025291796773672104, 0.056590382009744644, 0.07107646018266678, 0.01107362937182188, 0.021374598145484924, 0.05953582376241684, 0.04676634818315506, 0.0032727415673434734, 0.05127983167767525, 0.09404348582029343, 0.07796743512153625, 0.019488461315631866, 0.002927273977547884, 0.0016055655432865024, -0.03962200507521629, 0.02727699838578701, 0.02543545700609684, -0.03660860285162926, -0.052414339035749435, -0.04006531089544296, 0.045955874025821686, -0.008538790047168732, -0.0029798103496432304, 0.007633374538272619, -0.03616643697023392, -0.07245446741580963, 0.05593178793787956, 0.024997103959321976, 0.06652546674013138, 0.07436702400445938, 0.04689167067408562, -0.05445503070950508, -0.004126071464270353, -0.10434293001890182, 0.01803075522184372, -0.02161918208003044, 0.02909684367477894, -0.06064245104789734, -0.024852776899933815, -0.01993277482688427, 0.0136092659085989, 0.0028496321756392717, 0.015755629166960716, 0.006176968105137348, 0.0004227908793836832, -0.022342219948768616, 0.015979161486029625, 0.02954602800309658, -0.06168859452009201, -0.014731637202203274, -0.03013530559837818, 0.03602783754467964, 0.04253192991018295, 0.052925366908311844, -0.04949963837862015, 0.028336286544799805, 0.002604706445708871, 0.017239371314644814, -0.005642070434987545, 0.07001294940710068, -0.012446712702512741, -0.022978035733103752, 0.010572472587227821, -0.04973280057311058, 0.07540878653526306, 0.04477902874350548, -0.048051439225673676, -0.005528438836336136, -0.016245145350694656, 0.02858751080930233, 0.03217180445790291, -0.0006278353394009173, 0.04258725047111511, -0.016339074820280075, -0.059880331158638, 0.0864001139998436, 0.0016203061677515507, -0.035218432545661926, -0.034254517406225204, -0.023198101669549942, -0.05024340748786926, -0.0019553881138563156, -0.0345706008374691, -0.009183368645608425, 0.018018729984760284, -0.028529202565550804, -0.027924221009016037, -0.01605944335460663, -0.009353847242891788, -0.05158361792564392, 0.0030299879144877195, 0.006585446186363697, 0.004671281669288874, 0.019087158143520355, -0.05257591977715492, -0.009543650783598423, -0.048544883728027344, -0.017553145065903664, 0.001793139730580151, 0.0068736812099814415, -0.0050414688885211945, 0.030885620042681694, -0.022488320246338844, -0.017878860235214233, -0.055996231734752655, -0.015277276746928692, -0.017357364296913147, 0.02623140439391136, -0.012192531488835812, 0.034203071147203445, -0.02890593744814396, -0.020338164642453194, 0.058782387524843216, 0.030781269073486328, 0.004217483103275299, -0.044398993253707886, 0.04992552474141121, -0.002649854402989149, -0.031242622062563896, -0.00574867520481348, -0.0021981135942041874, -0.027295909821987152, 0.018044965341687202, -0.0006256079068407416, 0.03354448825120926, -0.019078942015767097, 0.06746696680784225, -0.02207242324948311, -0.03704483062028885, 0.04174785315990448, 0.018603507429361343, 0.07065244764089584, -0.05106394365429878, 0.04203121364116669, 0.002466730074957013, 0.01247427612543106, 0.13001446425914764, 0.021170882508158684, 0.005811668001115322, 0.059214744716882706, -0.014101111330091953, 0.036088068038225174, -0.04915815219283104, -0.03256753087043762, 0.003937066532671452, 0.004298418294638395, -0.015878919512033463, 0.006341990549117327, -0.032942034304142, -0.0006109984242357314, 0.0343836285173893, -0.024124540388584137, 0.01769433729350567, 0.0034124746453016996, 0.03781550005078316, 0.03789607062935829, 0.0148979052901268, -0.005849430803209543, -0.057993993163108826, -0.04250079765915871, 0.018821517005562782, -0.029009046033024788, 0.04976643621921539, 0.06077958643436432, -0.021786442026495934, -0.02221706509590149, 0.038753874599933624, -0.019425610080361366, -0.040274590253829956, -0.007317373529076576, -0.03111329674720764, 0.04206317290663719, -0.024871762841939926, -0.02964487113058567, 0.01712953858077526, -0.0153884282335639, 0.05570007488131523, -0.06088978797197342, 0.026278570294380188, -0.05988020449876785, -0.009522957727313042, 0.0016246911836788058, -0.04858030378818512, -0.00015989906387403607, -0.03373682126402855, -0.0453328862786293, -0.030002985149621964, 0.019752895459532738, -0.04338182136416435, 0.012759589590132236, -0.003781589912250638, 0.024136479943990707, 0.010563126765191555, -0.029359260573983192, -0.005337712820619345, -0.026230238378047943, 0.019479872658848763, -0.024126993492245674, -0.029396986588835716, 0.010164179839193821, 0.022350143641233444, -0.05961840972304344, 0.025462377816438675, -0.047959230840206146, -0.029989853501319885, 0.03077392466366291, -0.03633138909935951, 0.0012463271850720048, 0.002301045460626483, -0.011844092048704624, -0.01438149530440569, -0.017243141308426857, -0.018473468720912933, 0.05525586009025574, 0.01617269217967987, -0.03716964274644852, -0.002783604199066758, -0.019786838442087173, 0.0022023203782737255, 0.012677383609116077, -0.009868119843304157, 0.029809167608618736, 0.04320180416107178, 0.0357307605445385, -0.023725681006908417, 0.038546886295080185, -0.021196559071540833, 0.059646960347890854, -0.003339646616950631, 0.000009432200386072509, -0.10434923321008682, 0.0049323225393891335, -0.04537456855177879, 0.008706429973244667, 0.02280350588262081, -0.011488551273941994, 0.029472336173057556, 0.028527094051241875, 0.011584035120904446, 0.0036276604514569044, 0.019738009199500084, -0.024342775344848633, -0.05077836662530899, -0.02749858982861042, 0.01695631630718708, -0.013799937441945076, -0.018504753708839417, 0.0020574999507516623, -0.019313869997859, -0.02131529711186886, -0.04696335643529892, 0.011709866113960743, 0.0019874833524227142, -0.026764433830976486, 0.04639464616775513, -0.026110008358955383, -0.013759772293269634, 0.02560310624539852, -0.031150106340646744, 0.006589806172996759, 0.038398388773202896, 0.02000133879482746, -0.07764827460050583, -0.06991999596357346, 0.017894158139824867, 0.05399066209793091, -0.03715765103697777, 0.02110697142779827, 0.06363297998905182, -0.033130843192338943, -0.005731872282922268, -0.026751860976219177, -0.0046010250225663185, 0.025441709905862808, -0.059169284999370575, 0.05519000068306923, 0.029817814007401466, -0.06336074322462082, 0.024607282131910324, 0.0442989245057106, -0.041214242577552795, -0.000817127525806427, -0.07220631092786789, 0.005870584398508072, -0.007865438237786293, -0.04524949938058853, -0.08527521044015884, 0.031229756772518158, 0.0028126616962254047, -0.06071298196911812, 0.056434549391269684, -0.0023964904248714447, -0.026375072076916695, 0.04362146556377411, -0.005537408869713545, 0.04323938861489296, -0.060079608112573624, -0.02199600636959076, 0.019581498578190804, -0.017938282340765, -0.021447811275720596, 0.01981213130056858, 0.011182007379829884, -0.007271377835422754, -0.01430911011993885, -0.028295794501900673, -0.0262491162866354, 0.032937996089458466, 0.009424256160855293, 0.015774600207805634, 0.0028567598201334476, -0.02174586057662964, 0.05046652629971504, -0.07032196968793869, -0.01986812800168991, -0.048096027225255966, 0.028223922476172447, 0.021529192104935646, -0.04402447119355202, -0.002312116092070937, 0.039943840354681015, 0.00985314603894949, 0.021001571789383888, 0.03536178544163704, 0.041078511625528336, 0.023583779111504555, -0.0301902424544096, 0.06886380910873413, 0.010699219070374966, 0.04832453280687332, -0.017024721950292587, -0.01650722324848175, -0.07136248052120209, 0.025387143716216087, -0.0059009636752307415, -0.030350973829627037, -0.024388665333390236, -0.02957771345973015, 0.0496075376868248, -0.006335596088320017, 0.011394277215003967, 0.03745058923959732, -0.027729233726859093, 0.05057848244905472, -0.0182357020676136, -0.009511572308838367, -0.03744513541460037, -0.005524028558284044, -0.020785989239811897, -0.0043723443523049355, -0.0560489147901535, 0.05034317076206207, -0.058834273368120193, -0.03684823587536812, -0.01621721312403679, 0.042498473078012466, 0.029385484755039215, -0.021743886172771454, -0.05346094071865082, -0.036350201815366745, -0.020085971802473068, -0.02108844183385372, -0.02639644406735897, 0.024115808308124542, -0.010382410138845444, 0.011430282145738602, 0.023774918168783188, -0.016213292255997658, -0.09978927671909332, 0.016210535541176796, 0.029546603560447693, 0.034126877784729004, 0.06274225562810898, 0.02465711161494255, 0.059008024632930756, 0.013509232550859451, 0.008622863329946995, -0.08693618327379227, -0.018466785550117493, 0.006450973451137543, -0.0002644128107931465, 0.021064626052975655, 0.09231975674629211, 0.027469195425510406, -0.02409273013472557, 0.013765833340585232, 0.00035611932980827987, -0.008025935851037502, -0.02575748786330223, -0.008313237689435482, -0.020418474450707436, -0.025006944313645363, 0.04188261181116104, 0.010826699435710907, -0.014796563424170017, 0.037216346710920334, 0.012295592576265335, -0.07703088223934174, -0.0018352383049204946, 0.02413894608616829, 0.0614759624004364, 0.04803357273340225, 0.016854701563715935, -0.017824288457632065, 0.0756617933511734, -0.0032320059835910797, 0.04311599209904671, -0.04336290434002876, -0.0039524780586361885, 0.008630328811705112, -0.005316179245710373, 0.03629100322723389, -0.02308250032365322, -0.011011099442839622, -0.026374222710728645, -0.03854144364595413, -0.03159715607762337, 0.011177175678312778, 0.04451649263501167, 0.03866005316376686, -0.08160056173801422, 0.05747171491384506, 0.029125796630978584, -0.04074912145733833, -0.032155584543943405, -0.021368123590946198, -0.027672164142131805, 0.013086192309856415, -0.009513807483017445, -0.006870328448712826, -0.010322577320039272, 0.0023100622929632664, 0.03767547383904457, 0.0010105798719450831, -0.0009144797222688794, -0.02015685848891735, 0.014960569329559803, -0.026477016508579254, -0.0366409569978714, -0.017625536769628525, 0.0028820389416068792, -0.01810535043478012, -0.07286038249731064, -0.013922312296926975, 0.006499059498310089, -0.001213217619806528, -0.022646399214863777, -0.04747314751148224, -0.05734773725271225, 0.027845535427331924, -0.02556980773806572, -0.017568400129675865, 0.02951895445585251, 0.05124575272202492, 0.02210850641131401, 0.021865198388695717, -0.0010513935703784227, 0.011242486536502838, 0.008025731891393661 ]
<p>It seems obvious why mercury has no atmosphere, given its proximity to the sun--but yet Venus is also fairly close, and has an extremely dense atmosphere. Titan is a large moon with an atmosphere thicker than Earth's, and then Triton, a more distant large moon, has only a tenuous Nitrogen atmosphere. Why aren't more rocky bodies able to maintain an atmosphere? What factors affect whether a planet or moon is able to hold on to its atmosphere? What factors determine whether a planet or moon develops an atmosphere to begin with?</p>
g9741
[ 0.04276030510663986, 0.011191463097929955, -0.007439095061272383, 0.068943090736866, 0.09149076789617538, 0.07545460015535355, 0.04150930792093277, 0.008593671023845673, -0.020975522696971893, -0.028452519327402115, 0.0026302433107048273, -0.015122858807444572, 0.026144200935959816, -0.006751356180757284, 0.01119240652769804, 0.011827519163489342, 0.039662230759859085, -0.024935225024819374, 0.06241024658083916, 0.0004335801349952817, 0.0175173282623291, -0.025669913738965988, 0.0218823179602623, -0.0209279153496027, -0.03646225854754448, 0.010842941701412201, 0.018154019489884377, -0.03741402179002762, 0.05425605550408363, -0.016858737915754318, 0.0010911496356129646, -0.042530957609415054, 0.07842012494802475, -0.004215443041175604, 0.02206837199628353, -0.027264337986707687, -0.021073270589113235, 0.045076001435518265, -0.025593658909201622, -0.06427144259214401, 0.041661523282527924, -0.057551197707653046, 0.002767482539638877, -0.014038003981113434, -0.06204210966825485, -0.05383522808551788, -0.03300200402736664, -0.047390345484018326, -0.0180209968239069, -0.03322896733880043, -0.02454918809235096, 0.0011792958248406649, -0.03944826498627663, -0.024530775845050812, -0.0028826138004660606, 0.031239062547683716, 0.043564412742853165, 0.02432345598936081, 0.025670502334833145, 0.01410594116896391, 0.014874937944114208, -0.052744507789611816, 0.0015758045483380556, 0.04457990452647209, 0.011138031259179115, -0.001748427632264793, -0.05145446956157684, 0.0272731464356184, 0.08144597709178925, 0.004033437464386225, -0.001805606996640563, -0.014254927635192871, -0.02372349053621292, -0.03682684525847435, 0.0009964528726413846, 0.036100003868341446, -0.0263980645686388, -0.006342815700918436, 0.0718904435634613, 0.02530907467007637, 0.06538546830415726, 0.04230288416147232, 0.010487637482583523, 0.04754476249217987, 0.02006934955716133, -0.023513447493314743, -0.005092833656817675, -0.031376924365758896, -0.023404588922858238, 0.03634653240442276, 0.06821637600660324, -0.006920147687196732, 0.014504197984933853, -0.03128820285201073, 0.006399815436452627, 0.04733048006892204, 0.017556240782141685, 0.061875928193330765, 0.02132163941860199, -0.01691460609436035, 0.021018583327531815, -0.044161390513181686, 0.046308379620313644, -0.010357437655329704, 0.06016917899250984, -0.056296456605196, 0.01338788028806448, 0.023732304573059082, 0.008469129912555218, 0.0003244967956561595, -0.023978056386113167, 0.01981307566165924, -0.024442346766591072, -0.03865482658147812, 0.004197998903691769, -0.00867007952183485, 0.027445292100310326, -0.06098061054944992, 0.085069939494133, 0.05887318029999733, -0.041469212621450424, 0.07636068016290665, -0.03145788982510567, -0.015719067305326462, -0.06466302275657654, -0.014087607152760029, 0.014352799393236637, -0.028363801538944244, 0.0021559633314609528, -0.06260039657354355, -0.013059389777481556, 0.021817410364747047, -0.03523724898695946, -0.026980234310030937, -0.023024192079901695, -0.007797765079885721, -0.05144130438566208, -0.0038225275930017233, -0.048234619200229645, 0.02479347214102745, 0.026378760114312172, 0.04240519180893898, 0.03791244328022003, -0.003453496377915144, -0.09309828281402588, 0.028797641396522522, -0.02982168085873127, 0.004999928642064333, 0.02525591105222702, -0.002726444276049733, 0.022126441821455956, -0.006420840043574572, 0.047341134399175644, -0.0027814877685159445, -0.0044676619581878185, -0.01243622601032257, 0.07519975304603577, -0.029131241142749786, -0.004747070372104645, 0.008393928408622742, 0.008529964834451675, 0.030477965250611305, 0.019349729642271996, -0.0010381453903391957, -0.031035112217068672, 0.014630163088440895, -0.025159282609820366, -0.03629476577043533, -0.05099299177527428, -0.0309833362698555, -0.015018279664218426, 0.006732238456606865, 0.035118624567985535, 0.11757674813270569, -0.023206191137433052, -0.032069217413663864, 0.12072255462408066, -0.012761944904923439, 0.006964396219700575, -0.0003601349890232086, 0.048279911279678345, 0.0034722283016890287, -0.02766598016023636, -0.021660923957824707, -0.006474857684224844, -0.023495689034461975, 0.015763571485877037, -0.07356855273246765, -0.04243350774049759, 0.03239882364869118, 0.039620768278837204, 0.029996195808053017, 0.04947911947965622, -0.05500524118542671, 0.006849007681012154, -0.09437115490436554, -0.03858758509159088, -0.02153424359858036, 0.009793533943593502, 0.012307751923799515, -0.05005054175853729, 0.03670472651720047, -0.007561312988400459, -0.016716672107577324, -0.05030427873134613, 0.037015821784734726, -0.008849085308611393, -0.004968569613993168, 0.06767826527357101, 0.0023287504445761442, -0.01457515824586153, -0.0031232195906341076, 0.003221394494175911, 0.04125010222196579, 0.004004549700766802, -0.033118631690740585, -0.025659000501036644, 0.010829604230821133, 0.018512682989239693, -0.04138108715415001, 0.01273271907120943, -0.03512429818511009, 0.05422411859035492, -0.06596533209085464, -0.03127087280154228, 0.007054538931697607, -0.014691594056785107, 0.009942397475242615, 0.06505581736564636, 0.03672962635755539, -0.012902740389108658, 0.002857333980500698, -0.009057965129613876, 0.01866227015852928, -0.015284121967852116, -0.0011146474862471223, 0.014329512603580952, -0.04024781659245491, -0.025584012269973755, 0.07501903921365738, -0.028134766966104507, -0.05430708825588226, -0.016915977001190186, 0.03657382354140282, 0.014670048840343952, -0.06132359057664871, -0.028347758576273918, 0.02448815479874611, -0.024134153500199318, 0.042752496898174286, -0.021159421652555466, 0.043356914073228836, -0.05290753394365311, -0.030225232243537903, -0.004641667008399963, -0.0287949126213789, -0.011633289977908134, -0.010601512156426907, -0.06471094489097595, -0.034975823014974594, -0.016892481595277786, -0.07129663974046707, 0.023279890418052673, 0.03377866744995117, -0.06000003218650818, -0.0008337202598340809, -0.03436630964279175, -0.000058863210142590106, 0.015304503962397575, -0.04085364192724228, 0.013523775152862072, 0.049057263880968094, 0.005898995324969292, -0.008581356145441532, -0.08655817806720734, 0.0564718060195446, -0.03054765611886978, 0.01857670582830906, -0.01877870224416256, -0.01029654499143362, 0.004789353348314762, -0.0014296072768047452, -0.001174891833215952, -0.041436806321144104, 0.060266584157943726, -0.017806192860007286, 0.02881227619946003, 0.03560761734843254, -0.017118999734520912, -0.028805507346987724, 0.023730972781777382, 0.033662695437669754, 0.03332304209470749, 0.06606783717870712, -0.011849279515445232, 0.02550065889954567, -0.049683235585689545, -0.003780293045565486, -0.07322343438863754, 0.007832595147192478, -0.04735098406672478, 0.023516450077295303, 0.07963696867227554, 0.06263178586959839, 0.05533745884895325, -0.013828154653310776, -0.06646974384784698, 0.011682032607495785, 0.028704503551125526, -0.010582750663161278, -0.00442657433450222, 0.018748605623841286, -0.056731559336185455, 0.10490480810403824, -0.07176484912633896, 0.024619290605187416, -0.05350598320364952, 0.03085222840309143, 0.04427953436970711, 0.014512859284877777, -0.0074696410447359085, -0.028386052697896957, 0.027342520654201508, 0.0102793388068676, -0.022328980267047882, -0.023680202662944794, -0.05123871937394142, -0.00014114039367996156, 0.01661711558699608, -0.017319058999419212, -0.010233551263809204, 0.04673149064183235, 0.010086480528116226, 0.007796520367264748, -0.06252177804708481, 0.08330761641263962, 0.09470297396183014, -0.017320502549409866, 0.003970918711274862, 0.023025305941700935, -0.0011999326525256038, -0.0044507174752652645, -0.0764504000544548, -0.05988897383213043, -0.01001833938062191, 0.01763010211288929, 0.012855728156864643, -0.03438947722315788, -0.010139372199773788, -0.01571005769073963, 0.004360927734524012, -0.010083197616040707, 0.0006657926714979112, 0.015563532710075378, -0.03745627775788307, 0.011269891634583473, 0.006573079153895378, 0.017259541898965836, -0.021919766440987587, -0.03862537816166878, 0.03669438883662224, 0.017217660322785378, -0.048762548714876175, -0.005299089010804892, 0.03781725466251373, 0.002992462133988738, -0.03881514444947243, 0.006407588254660368, 0.02375848777592182, 0.025454286485910416, 0.04022569954395294, 0.015072371810674667, 0.01149968896061182, 0.033744506537914276, 0.06944723427295685, -0.046648114919662476, 0.03014559857547283, 0.02828347496688366, 0.01863938197493553, 0.013882594183087349, 0.05180564150214195, -0.005480644293129444, -0.04156126081943512, 0.0462697371840477, -0.004124821629375219, -0.0298893004655838, -0.01145288534462452, 0.024260055273771286, -0.04669838771224022, -0.04732443764805794, -0.03918320685625076, -0.06302960962057114, -0.01944982446730137, 0.03652498126029968, 0.02373875118792057, -0.06047601252794266, 0.05307397618889809, 0.0097549082711339, 0.028205785900354385, 0.009970735758543015, -0.0010637813247740269, 0.013146970421075821, 0.008523082360625267, -0.0450042299926281, -0.022866956889629364, 0.008475109934806824, -0.0011681256582960486, 0.05125974863767624, 0.01167331449687481, 0.03101753443479538, 0.0373021624982357, 0.034203287214040756, -0.05125422030687332, -0.014060269109904766, -0.030363906174898148, -0.0033593939151614904, -0.008201909251511097, -0.02020534873008728, 0.024904845282435417, 0.015842316672205925, -0.0058165136724710464, 0.030102672055363655, 0.014093676581978798, -0.007588207721710205, 0.0338531918823719, 0.07619132101535797, 0.026771020144224167, -0.025575866922736168, -0.03724462911486626, 0.027928363531827927, 0.014523506164550781, -0.011029786430299282, 0.025896644219756126, -0.010780571028590202, 0.003555821254849434, 0.028923535719513893, -0.022245004773139954, -0.02087155357003212, -0.002216851571574807, 0.034113142639398575, 0.008346287533640862, 0.03152245283126831, -0.02005866728723049, 0.002622935688123107, -0.041146378964185715, 0.052548184990882874, 0.009830153547227383, 0.00014668767107650638, 0.018750708550214767, 0.060016632080078125, -0.037750761955976486, -0.07009119540452957, -0.005146200302988291, 0.010933921672403812, -0.051447611302137375, -0.009653444401919842, 0.05299581214785576, 0.0168293546885252, -0.01961096003651619, 0.02004886418581009, -0.018531931564211845, 0.019752901047468185, 0.03350525721907616, 0.073696069419384, -0.011395983397960663, -0.05152780935168266, -0.008537720888853073, 0.044757816940546036, -0.022960785776376724, 0.01603919081389904, -0.06324759125709534, 0.025775590911507607, -0.013605811633169651, 0.11339006572961807, -0.03494353964924812, -0.02727498486638069, -0.0017817040206864476, -0.04401160776615143, 0.0261777825653553, -0.028110921382904053, 0.02869138866662979, 0.004410283174365759, 0.02314567193388939, 0.0949772447347641, -0.04210833087563515, 0.016111833974719048, -0.05168621614575386, 0.00010076848411699757, -0.05013040080666542, 0.03176821395754814, -0.03155841678380966, -0.002452925546094775, -0.007996738888323307, 0.042951058596372604, -0.026141652837395668, -0.03750428557395935, -0.01679050363600254, -0.0021183695644140244, 0.0101533317938447, 0.0010425210930407047, -0.0056699588894844055, 0.05706221982836723, -0.04228134825825691, 0.0034799494314938784, 0.03348948433995247, -0.011225785128772259, 0.0181654654443264, -0.06971418112516403, 0.051884524524211884, -0.009717979468405247, -0.0671042799949646, 0.008458083495497704, -0.00001764538319548592, 0.02216860093176365, 0.00908455066382885, -0.01229710690677166, 0.0021666493266820908, 0.04930924251675606, -0.02546359971165657, -0.003711403114721179, 0.012712085619568825, -0.015851248055696487, 0.02231370285153389, -0.004008277785032988, 0.04920252040028572, 0.053520169109106064, -0.0030485850293189287, -0.03131924569606781, -0.05667288601398468, 0.04348701611161232, 0.011162389069795609, -0.015221204608678818, 0.03434230387210846, -0.00633753789588809, -0.013149041682481766, -0.05448244884610176, -0.005385521333664656, 0.03364606201648712, 0.014022604562342167, -0.01942143775522709, -0.028829464688897133, 0.009291592985391617, -0.018173594027757645, 0.05220374837517738, 0.04943803325295448, -0.004967390093952417, -0.008960334584116936, 0.07569409161806107, 0.04786716029047966, 0.04412605240941048, -0.06429480016231537, 0.004395470023155212, -0.049420081079006195, -0.04680319502949715, -0.03584463894367218, 0.014230002649128437, 0.021809721365571022, 0.004375074524432421, -0.021949714049696922, 0.007400098722428083, 0.025810426101088524, 0.025287000462412834, 0.012448831461369991, 0.01841949112713337, -0.04875217005610466, 0.02746620588004589, -0.02753995917737484, 0.01748557575047016, 0.03554864972829819, -0.0047372449189424515, 0.009553233161568642, 0.028278697282075882, -0.006664343643933535, -0.02408880740404129, -0.009189926087856293, -0.010781846009194851, -0.06237810477614403, 0.022755103185772896, 0.004623446613550186, -0.026514926925301552, 0.020388638600707054, -0.046020302921533585, -0.011292208917438984, 0.02236158959567547, -0.03484698385000229, 0.012918207794427872, 0.005696048494428396, -0.03984025865793228, 0.04787971451878548, -0.012601763941347599, 0.027731891721487045, 0.01913333125412464, 0.009669596329331398, -0.05049407109618187, -0.0259231124073267, -0.029552673920989037, -0.03993901610374451, 0.008798287250101566, -0.013026849366724491, 0.010593022219836712, 0.08628722280263901, 0.05813442915678024, 0.059870291501283646, -0.0042207324877381325, 0.02079847641289234, 0.015782859176397324, 0.004473919980227947, 0.05510042980313301, -0.004440934397280216, 0.022136995568871498, -0.0090411975979805, 0.026991045102477074, 0.012088126502931118, -0.02553211711347103, -0.014139201492071152, -0.03934066370129585, -0.012275424785912037, 0.04860904812812805, -0.07618973404169083, 0.02842182107269764, -0.025034060701727867, -0.028025859966874123, 0.00957497302442789, -0.05445288121700287, -0.004703102167695761, -0.020365221425890923, -0.0005718384636566043, 0.0540008582174778, -0.0040216813795268536, -0.04524768143892288, 0.0407627671957016, -0.01881466433405876, -0.023674746975302696, 0.027776680886745453, -0.014048411510884762, 0.01651403307914734, -0.019963782280683517, -0.039648618549108505, 0.014065259136259556, -0.050470251590013504, -0.029935814440250397, -0.08715753257274628, 0.018189754337072372, 0.051514510065317154, 0.019594747573137283, 0.00960535928606987, 0.0197027325630188, -0.02532661147415638, 0.014721332117915154, 0.022478658705949783, -0.01222043577581644, -0.06511934846639633, 0.014891134575009346, 0.0018519290024414659, 0.025214271619915962, 0.06440624594688416, -0.06326033174991608, -0.046235814690589905, 0.017011811956763268, -0.036342982202768326, -0.005235061049461365, 0.027097415179014206, 0.03678131476044655, 0.044809937477111816, 0.031337227672338486, 0.019077926874160767, 0.035698357969522476, -0.06701304018497467, -0.0180710069835186, 0.02886771596968174, -0.0023738888558000326, -0.005031950771808624, -0.028029998764395714, 0.0142211290076375, -0.040054917335510254, 0.028089573606848717, 0.016096465289592743, -0.04842411354184151, 0.03806150332093239, -0.029690274968743324, -0.008814606815576553, -0.024999268352985382, 0.014733820222318172, -0.028325462713837624, 0.03214910626411438, -0.019267430528998375, -0.03617198020219803, 0.025852179154753685, -0.0021302406676113605, -0.011597069911658764, -0.028648847714066505, 0.04084533825516701, -0.007184660993516445, -0.03794164955615997, -0.04126697778701782, -0.027103306725621223, 0.04429662972688675, -0.027148481458425522, 0.01565721072256565, -0.05299954488873482, -0.016916578635573387, -0.04288027063012123, 0.029339147731661797, -0.07350511103868484, 0.06208137050271034, 0.04019031673669815, 0.017607582733035088, 0.040796734392642975, -0.05099278688430786, 0.022505514323711395, 0.01230664923787117, 0.022240011021494865, 0.012642440386116505, 0.019086165353655815, 0.02478397637605667, -0.009585394524037838, -0.006040275562554598, 0.0003103986964561045, -0.055990755558013916, -0.06998198479413986, -0.05709544196724892, -0.03827265277504921, 0.07748236507177353, -0.10289368778467178, -0.021551987156271935, -0.002099853940308094, 0.02856573835015297, -0.027710730209946632, 0.029216760769486427, -0.083806611597538, -0.04381345957517624, 0.0813402533531189, -0.0003263817052356899, 0.016133079305291176, -0.04901045933365822, 0.0015671350993216038, 0.049786243587732315, -0.07615777105093002, -0.039501678198575974, 0.008791663683950901, -0.035204168409109116, 0.049602292478084564, 0.0029393371660262346, -0.009832216426730156, 0.03524063900113106, 0.022514088079333305, -0.0246305949985981, 0.07359444350004196, 0.013980650343000889, -0.05084485188126564, -0.041348353028297424, 0.030265331268310547, 0.04576188325881958, -0.012522459030151367, -0.016055794432759285, 0.004929348360747099, -0.02885771542787552, -0.025985630229115486, 0.015171040780842304, -0.03287398815155029, -0.011708332225680351, 0.06467778980731964, 0.03978706896305084, -0.07544585317373276, -0.036490339785814285, 0.041857775300741196, -0.047940533608198166, -0.023975050076842308 ]
<p>It's not going to last forever - Jeans Escape is going to eventually act on the atmosphere after trillions of trillions of years: see <a href="http://faculty.washington.edu/dcatling/Catling2009_SciAm.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://faculty.washington.edu/dcatling/Catling2009_SciAm.pdf</a></p>
g9742
[ 0.03759026527404785, 0.03481115773320198, -0.008952295407652855, -0.01169033907353878, -0.02006583660840988, 0.03975792974233627, 0.0036709823179990053, 0.04004134610295296, -0.030027220025658607, -0.025559382513165474, -0.021674957126379013, 0.02237359620630741, -0.027136996388435364, -0.04609601944684982, 0.05520947277545929, -0.01947842724621296, 0.021058063954114914, -0.04196600615978241, 0.010285263881087303, -0.021911446005105972, -0.04637153446674347, -0.028402216732501984, 0.023682106286287308, -0.04693743586540222, 0.024390829727053642, -0.07112904638051987, -0.012556961737573147, 0.012079193256795406, -0.02297682873904705, 0.05225177854299545, 0.06909895688295364, -0.044354163110256195, -0.049024198204278946, -0.04954120144248009, -0.03849993273615837, -0.039535414427518845, -0.014222555793821812, -0.013467258773744106, 0.02391662634909153, 0.03326373174786568, -0.045933254063129425, -0.014369986020028591, 0.03996022418141365, 0.0017551607452332973, 0.027451694011688232, 0.03403301537036896, -0.047158367931842804, -0.03397155925631523, 0.07895710319280624, -0.019902031868696213, -0.030931882560253143, 0.05004194378852844, -0.02264399826526642, 0.01786014437675476, 0.013054017908871174, -0.04804530739784241, 0.04737064987421036, -0.048582930117845535, 0.04065890982747078, -0.04059585556387901, 0.04589462652802467, -0.03616711497306824, -0.02075793966650963, 0.07112705707550049, 0.05905236676335335, 0.014678449369966984, -0.05087120085954666, 0.002377100056037307, 0.06465385109186172, -0.04310102015733719, 0.04962297901511192, -0.03900894895195961, -0.06625688076019287, 0.0013730539940297604, 0.036339014768600464, 0.07311351597309113, -0.05054287239909172, 0.027289800345897675, 0.006762852426618338, 0.07004855573177338, -0.04133987054228783, 0.04061337560415268, -0.06528352200984955, 0.043778128921985626, -0.004463089630007744, 0.013002725318074226, -0.015780124813318253, 0.004488041158765554, -0.04658367112278938, 0.0014985447051003575, 0.037114936858415604, 0.04940056428313255, 0.03901934251189232, 0.02461463212966919, 0.00022466396330855787, -0.012383226305246353, 0.022581569850444794, -0.010693318210542202, -0.009248062036931515, -0.0014863035175949335, -0.030596818774938583, -0.052309490740299225, 0.004225112032145262, -0.022197457030415535, -0.02009538561105728, 0.004051767755299807, 0.000917018682230264, -0.045309197157621384, -0.000461923104012385, 0.029557200148701668, 0.01345555204898119, 0.023306993767619133, -0.07938343286514282, -0.02940361760556698, 0.0023808397818356752, 0.06610454618930817, -0.024256817996501923, -0.035777702927589417, 0.044361189007759094, 0.0019534253515303135, 0.043467674404382706, -0.02974063903093338, 0.057440388947725296, -0.04238972067832947, 0.020476100966334343, -0.036125507205724716, 0.0006537170265801251, 0.012040928937494755, -0.0019805296324193478, 0.0011217776918783784, -0.08937322348356247, 0.05562131851911545, 0.02090456336736679, -0.006334416102617979, -0.001957617700099945, 0.006985929328948259, -0.04013820365071297, -0.04199225455522537, 0.0021134319249540567, 0.033197417855262756, 0.052717991173267365, -0.007657951209694147, 0.029715951532125473, 0.009696657769382, -0.030246371403336525, -0.0249212384223938, -0.04420812427997589, 0.03570890054106712, -0.030793579295277596, 0.04242570325732231, -0.0036007515154778957, 0.04583375155925751, -0.014699122868478298, -0.009818765334784985, -0.047284651547670364, 0.0047110808081924915, 0.03692151606082916, 0.02682057023048401, -0.03215555101633072, -0.029147768393158913, -0.0037230518646538258, -0.016193825751543045, 0.0011672411346808076, -0.015216614119708538, -0.0967678651213646, -0.02387949824333191, 0.010881590656936169, -0.0028750936035066843, -0.04560523480176926, 0.007342367433011532, -0.03286350890994072, -0.013297995552420616, -0.010275154374539852, 0.06579788029193878, 0.018010616302490234, -0.020205017179250717, 0.028580192476511, -0.031404249370098114, -0.026606187224388123, -0.09504695981740952, 0.03475721552968025, -0.0629795715212822, -0.003071728628128767, -0.012636838480830193, 0.037897929549217224, 0.04185165464878082, -0.04637739807367325, 0.04224038124084473, -0.00215025432407856, -0.028830111026763916, -0.015138274058699608, -0.060962237417697906, -0.002480151364579797, -0.015816103667020798, -0.05470249429345131, -0.040506575256586075, 0.016642017289996147, -0.0188737940043211, -0.0457625687122345, -0.022245479747653008, 0.04999949783086777, 0.0022055066656321287, 0.008715332485735416, -0.07554113119840622, 0.006958236452192068, 0.007306231651455164, 0.052470918744802475, 0.009353984147310257, -0.0018796200165525079, 0.007297144737094641, 0.09655185043811798, -0.0037119295448064804, 0.007369629107415676, 0.026792895048856735, -0.03192639723420143, -0.0386100672185421, 0.01855999231338501, 0.007790524512529373, 0.015413855202496052, 0.07017061859369278, 0.005220823455601931, 0.021815747022628784, 0.03103579208254814, -0.050469107925891876, 0.08017794787883759, -0.011774507351219654, -0.061666350811719894, -0.06644202768802643, -0.0023526991717517376, 0.028412889689207077, -0.03975320979952812, -0.008270460180938244, -0.03614358231425285, -0.014665182679891586, -0.012447228655219078, 0.057462047785520554, 0.09157498925924301, 0.010737136006355286, -0.00561880599707365, 0.016651570796966553, 0.029579000547528267, -0.013001547195017338, -0.012604846619069576, -0.023009127005934715, 0.03418292850255966, -0.017577890306711197, -0.0041158609092235565, -0.006437248550355434, -0.014977481216192245, -0.007985866628587246, 0.003226121189072728, -0.03357351943850517, -0.054882489144802094, 0.027832893654704094, 0.012362903915345669, -0.030683675780892372, 0.00037452796823345125, -0.005914193112403154, -0.036737412214279175, -0.05959451198577881, 0.024537192657589912, -0.023898011073470116, 0.03993167355656624, 0.005970892030745745, -0.06827571243047714, -0.014466420747339725, 0.007652568630874157, 0.02070588618516922, -0.010885476134717464, -0.05481785908341408, -0.0006677818018943071, 0.0357048325240612, 0.03185325860977173, 0.003926174249500036, 0.0029816925525665283, 0.06016327813267708, -0.00797338131815195, 0.007087763864547014, -0.01194731518626213, -0.037275105714797974, -0.05222214758396149, -0.02955298312008381, -0.031191237270832062, 0.061835143715143204, 0.04648841544985771, -0.08913829922676086, 0.01319544855505228, 0.007106382865458727, 0.005643307231366634, -0.013697654008865356, 0.027579380199313164, -0.015303384512662888, 0.008005312643945217, -0.010288593359291553, -0.022760743275284767, 0.002050605369731784, -0.034884314984083176, -0.00672332476824522, -0.033330436795949936, -0.025764871388673782, 0.08263883739709854, -0.01830943301320076, 0.010324445553123951, -0.005913679488003254, -0.03317815065383911, 0.018762947991490364, -0.0072235180996358395, -0.03547268360853195, 0.012710672803223133, -0.061337750405073166, 0.0830603614449501, 0.06827214360237122, 0.002215499524027109, 0.014499036595225334, 0.001224953681230545, 0.06165064498782158, 0.028227679431438446, -0.03144719451665878, 0.03770330920815468, -0.01116205658763647, 0.019291363656520844, 0.014517046511173248, 0.02590872347354889, -0.03399648889899254, -0.0009482829482294619, -0.0009536333964206278, -0.01499885506927967, -0.03761546313762665, -0.023111063987016678, -0.009441490285098553, 0.014713563024997711, 0.04125500097870827, 0.013768617063760757, -0.04976082220673561, -0.03465844318270683, -0.013829823583364487, -0.014664740301668644, -0.00048608024371787906, -0.007793566212058067, -0.01493471022695303, -0.046578310430049896, -0.02746836096048355, -0.016492949798703194, 0.05260481685400009, 0.026559356600046158, 0.01686696894466877, 0.025589535012841225, 0.0026824125088751316, 0.04031258448958397, 0.03793305531144142, 0.03725960850715637, -0.0536513514816761, 0.015013054013252258, -0.028109507635235786, -0.08718965202569962, -0.03799350932240486, 0.022955814376473427, -0.023330843076109886, 0.01611744426190853, -0.001145783462561667, -0.03781397268176079, -0.006511742249131203, 0.04519199952483177, 0.03548847511410713, 0.011578734964132309, 0.02137119695544243, 0.016052769497036934, 0.028904544189572334, 0.049785491079092026, 0.0004465079109650105, -0.026017824187874794, 0.03516049310564995, -0.02430703118443489, 0.02941434644162655, -0.027083255350589752, 0.00340692768804729, 0.009264904074370861, -0.05120870843529701, -0.03165840357542038, 0.062487561255693436, -0.024352263659238815, 0.01329745352268219, -0.01878080703318119, -0.005010487977415323, 0.03444918617606163, 0.02471318654716015, -0.009016819298267365, -0.04880250617861748, -0.04239413142204285, -0.012333760969340801, 0.01203115750104189, 0.03757687658071518, 0.004530249163508415, -0.008432876318693161, -0.017246592789888382, -0.049866072833538055, -0.012872176244854927, 0.046823129057884216, -0.014668221585452557, -0.0421372652053833, 0.025037609040737152, -0.02928139641880989, -0.043086811900138855, 0.10217421501874924, 0.022920090705156326, 0.02484619803726673, 0.047677766531705856, -0.0028919216711074114, 0.014521213248372078, -0.07105275988578796, -0.00932061392813921, 0.012819618918001652, -0.01545810978859663, -0.07399292290210724, 0.04168575629591942, -0.07165475189685822, 0.06484100222587585, -0.009279035963118076, 0.03166930750012398, 0.006068152375519276, 0.017994727939367294, 0.06139019876718521, -0.01800054870545864, 0.008618433959782124, 0.026896581053733826, 0.010524940676987171, -0.01816718466579914, 0.023328930139541626, -0.002029124880209565, -0.03979276120662689, 0.013417499139904976, 0.01335944700986147, -0.03269441798329353, 0.02881339192390442, -0.027772722765803337, 0.07129441946744919, 0.07077738642692566, -0.007257337216287851, -0.01669682003557682, 0.05255948379635811, 0.07380621135234833, -0.043436650186777115, 0.07555241882801056, 0.031392376869916916, 0.03550727665424347, 0.0767812430858612, 0.10088279098272324, -0.0710965245962143, 0.039903368800878525, 0.021891344338655472, 0.031246598809957504, -0.014866914600133896, -0.008882712572813034, 0.04611898213624954, 0.04870978742837906, -0.02409280277788639, 0.0012991739204153419, 0.020039809867739677, 0.03844545781612396, 0.00006869083881611004, -0.0417427122592926, 0.013464543037116528, -0.052949704229831696, -0.0036154035478830338, -0.06595350801944733, 0.030099039897322655, -0.022168872877955437, -0.06471718102693558, 0.020278675481677055, 0.015778059139847755, -0.010909318923950195, 0.051974352449178696, 0.029099946841597557, 0.056461822241544724, -0.00994033832103014, -0.04880274832248688, 0.02858363837003708, 0.003196724457666278, 0.047894008457660675, 0.030099352821707726, 0.028963198885321617, 0.00112090480979532, 0.003946439828723669, 0.0035152859054505825, 0.047722917050123215, 0.04122002422809601, -0.040702592581510544, -0.01789098046720028, -0.03608943149447441, -0.02388676442205906, 0.002281449269503355, -0.014388114213943481, 0.013765658251941204, 0.054658617824316025, -0.007803475018590689, -0.02472613751888275, 0.03227032348513603, 0.022847838699817657, 0.026526371017098427, 0.013451828621327877, -0.03470095992088318, 0.033136166632175446, -0.011448663659393787, -0.007437294814735651, 0.008865431882441044, 0.03204823657870293, 0.05424439162015915, 0.00958100613206625, -0.007186338771134615, 0.016918208450078964, -0.03782770782709122, 0.0019061812199652195, 0.06741095334291458, 0.041003234684467316, 0.054896529763936996, -0.008124809712171555, -0.004382911138236523, 0.016785789281129837, 0.02141609601676464, -0.0026147442404180765, 0.06152627244591713, 0.01754557341337204, 0.010784028097987175, 0.01972482167184353, 0.10800179094076157, -0.01768741011619568, -0.038458287715911865, -0.05621087923645973, 0.009871152229607105, -0.0055362144485116005, 0.04231012985110283, -0.006835561245679855, 0.010048754513263702, -0.06771679222583771, -0.010892963968217373, 0.042188920080661774, -0.007695244625210762, 0.004598935600370169, 0.021302368491888046, -0.0296648982912302, -0.04541458189487457, -0.018688833341002464, -0.012604563497006893, 0.05366043373942375, -0.023398423567414284, -0.004402139224112034, -0.009790304116904736, 0.006055626552551985, -0.014521812088787556, -0.012941194698214531, 0.007298588287085295, 0.004606449976563454, 0.03842790424823761, 0.00951228104531765, 0.04429065063595772, 0.0540245920419693, 0.01588706485927105, -0.01140507310628891, -0.0036081280559301376, 0.0640561655163765, -0.031303636729717255, 0.06293129175901413, 0.04132911562919617, 0.06947964429855347, 0.03148734197020531, -0.04723455384373665, -0.03190552443265915, -0.04383702948689461, 0.021339891478419304, 0.020220205187797546, 0.040587443858385086, 0.03221272677183151, -0.03238406404852867, -0.01127880159765482, -0.05627833679318428, 0.03631968796253204, -0.03307995945215225, -0.015528381802141666, -0.017258353531360626, -0.027852395549416542, -0.017935041338205338, -0.06790194660425186, 0.006642648950219154, -0.021235397085547447, -0.043786752969026566, -0.029451122507452965, 0.007622474804520607, -0.03615317866206169, 0.08080872148275375, 0.03018861450254917, -0.02118087001144886, -0.0415322445333004, -0.03570900112390518, -0.032780908048152924, -0.02105109393596649, -0.05149851739406586, 0.008522730320692062, -0.011062407866120338, -0.030885783955454826, -0.004117509815841913, -0.050447601824998856, 0.019262246787548065, -0.015460852533578873, -0.06310120970010757, 0.022056832909584045, -0.0021002774592489004, 0.021809633821249008, 0.018820293247699738, 0.06138734146952629, 0.029929671436548233, -0.06504524499177933, -0.00997118279337883, 0.03965700790286064, 0.004465787205845118, 0.03951747342944145, -0.016124486923217773, 0.03972800448536873, 0.08527153730392456, -0.031141189858317375, 0.04006655514240265, -0.03608328476548195, 0.021565688773989677, -0.000005295520622894401, -0.002989394823089242, -0.028290029615163803, -0.0027357428334653378, 0.04061395674943924, 0.005832982715219259, 0.005675534252077341, 0.02175201289355755, -0.08131945133209229, 0.034615106880664825, -0.014015457592904568, 0.008210168220102787, -0.04547223448753357, 0.007354872766882181, -0.05884791910648346, -0.03643825650215149, -0.00020154075173195451, 0.0035556061193346977, 0.007561537902802229, -0.06041131913661957, -0.0058517116121947765, 0.002853900194168091, -0.05938143655657768, 0.0752507820725441, -0.005631281994283199, -0.023887401446700096, 0.03717857226729393, -0.04095723479986191, 0.05755171924829483, -0.054492343217134476, -0.005208889022469521, 0.026456885039806366, -0.02482377178966999, 0.057332079857587814, 0.0017735155997797847, -0.05351946875452995, 0.01900560036301613, -0.011109232902526855, -0.04079714044928551, -0.07735107839107513, 0.011050271801650524, 0.003777160309255123, -0.02446899563074112, -0.011873888783156872, 0.045540060847997665, -0.05867142230272293, 0.06287088245153427, 0.013790697790682316, -0.050028733909130096, -0.018454406410455704, 0.026458989828824997, -0.060424815863370895, -0.031368207186460495, -0.013301719911396503, -0.052194930613040924, 0.011747660115361214, 0.037240076810121536, -0.00017437823407817632, 0.03272944316267967, 0.02217937260866165, -0.0009932006942108274, -0.05833890289068222, 0.016088344156742096, -0.03208843618631363, -0.021051211282610893, -0.0033341420348733664, 0.021259790286421776, 0.012890467420220375, -0.02983173169195652, -0.04479233920574188, -0.029675953090190887, -0.001556328614242375, -0.007143509574234486, 0.011941115371882915, 0.02687109261751175, 0.0019772809464484453, 0.013591229915618896, 0.014354763552546501, 0.017367839813232422, 0.04735666885972023, 0.009359978139400482, -0.041899174451828, -0.01039212942123413, 0.05600002035498619, 0.053283993154764175, -0.011297523975372314, -0.013263673521578312, 0.03461558744311333, -0.02918096072971821, -0.007038904819637537, 0.02240806072950363, 0.055551040917634964, 0.03851768374443054, -0.021896973252296448, 0.06769335269927979, 0.010204046964645386, 0.035453081130981445, 0.02784821204841137, -0.001825967337936163, 0.03211219981312752, -0.02080594189465046, -0.030399154871702194, -0.035303425043821335, 0.006737675052136183, 0.008910329081118107, -0.029637835919857025, -0.06879217177629471, -0.06300240755081177, -0.05870707705616951, 0.00030947718187235296, -0.014008020050823689, -0.09890696406364441, -0.015327900648117065, 0.02594711259007454, -0.019176840782165527, -0.05382341518998146, -0.04865048825740814, -0.0034059465397149324, 0.008311604149639606, -0.027255063876509666, 0.007832422852516174, -0.022010382264852524, 0.05273919180035591, -0.004976567346602678, -0.004843374248594046, 0.011217661201953888, -0.06130676344037056, 0.02333623357117176, 0.07178493589162827, 0.018758855760097504, -0.051017217338085175, 0.028989827260375023, 0.04693817347288132, -0.02083863690495491, -0.003976833075284958, 0.0054326788522303104, 0.06758542358875275, -0.05506431683897972, -0.019929567351937294, 0.038331590592861176, -0.008082748390734196, -0.0053038159385323524, 0.03931000083684921, -0.0482717789709568, 0.06759598851203918, -0.04078138247132301 ]
<p>There is the specific universe we live in, the "actual" universe with planet Earth, humans evolving, and us discussing metaphysical debates on physics.se in 2012, etc. There might or might not also be other possible/potential worlds out there, some differing majorly, like in the laws of physics, or minorly, almost like our current world, but maybe I didn't pose this question on physics.se. According to many worlds advocates, the other possible worlds also exist out there in Platonic space. Is this world we find ourselves the only universe out there, or do other possible worlds also exist?</p>
g9743
[ 0.004894518293440342, 0.037363216280937195, 0.03974296152591705, 0.035334933549165726, 0.019312798976898193, 0.02664165385067463, -0.05740233510732651, 0.004319958854466677, 0.04160002991557121, -0.018950361758470535, 0.06341741234064102, -0.046512674540281296, -0.006708397530019283, 0.07053430378437042, -0.0480642206966877, -0.03692815080285072, 0.008020292967557907, -0.05947767198085785, 0.026039570569992065, -0.0023722993209958076, -0.0783722996711731, -0.039458755403757095, 0.03278739005327225, -0.01190453302115202, -0.06605847179889679, 0.014905082061886787, -0.02982208877801895, -0.028825726360082626, 0.027573762461543083, -0.054980624467134476, 0.0119699751958251, -0.036395203322172165, 0.015948237851262093, 0.0010671095224097371, -0.03597671538591385, -0.02971486561000347, -0.001773733994923532, -0.0026273143012076616, 0.016796467825770378, -0.04655816778540611, 0.004056272562593222, 0.020493915304541588, -0.003853675676509738, -0.0021519374568015337, 0.01904965564608574, 0.009911853820085526, -0.02254563383758068, 0.017441239207983017, 0.08561469614505768, -0.033357881009578705, -0.008438813500106335, 0.011209369637072086, 0.043710242956876755, 0.049463916569948196, 0.03155992552638054, -0.034583330154418945, 0.055485811084508896, 0.012797958217561245, 0.01817161776125431, -0.016732944175601006, -0.015306741930544376, 0.02653064951300621, 0.032569825649261475, 0.06874673068523407, -0.01744392327964306, 0.07112831622362137, -0.07042983919382095, -0.011225921101868153, 0.03165804222226143, -0.05180640518665314, 0.03246660530567169, -0.043515466153621674, -0.012087950482964516, -0.0031921209301799536, 0.018566342070698738, 0.07668664306402206, 0.03998902067542076, -0.03374187648296356, 0.06567608565092087, 0.021946825087070465, -0.03598102182149887, -0.028647281229496002, -0.033519353717565536, -0.028986070305109024, 0.01380892563611269, -0.07792026549577713, -0.060024816542863846, 0.021945763379335403, -0.03488124534487724, 0.0033903406001627445, 0.04071561247110367, 0.08081232011318207, 0.042914122343063354, -0.03255993500351906, -0.03768852725625038, -0.01145437266677618, 0.04145406186580658, 0.04069916531443596, -0.007601170800626278, 0.007024812046438456, -0.06276791542768478, -0.020073790103197098, 0.01108093373477459, 0.0065366290509700775, 0.03746958076953888, -0.021040966734290123, -0.011008736677467823, -0.021654648706316948, -0.04885238781571388, 0.003987772855907679, -0.021755388006567955, -0.04193760082125664, -0.0278782956302166, 0.0617733858525753, -0.010396079160273075, -0.028214668855071068, 0.04911121353507042, 0.008359681814908981, 0.008923443965613842, 0.09015589952468872, 0.03836294263601303, 0.03443998098373413, 0.02175460383296013, 0.02089005894958973, -0.004591628443449736, 0.03302977606654167, 0.014437527395784855, -0.05894879624247551, 0.032357681542634964, -0.01502646878361702, 0.040857404470443726, 0.011995025910437107, 0.01234359946101904, 0.020022133365273476, -0.08212783932685852, 0.015104435384273529, 0.02009616605937481, 0.026902038604021072, 0.024035608395934105, 0.021680397912859917, 0.02180742658674717, -0.017732996493577957, -0.005542862229049206, -0.008681471459567547, -0.02026333287358284, 0.011557978577911854, -0.01833496056497097, -0.009441983886063099, -0.029392192140221596, 0.043331556022167206, 0.007028520107269287, 0.009097271598875523, 0.0064552295953035355, 0.00926029309630394, -0.05110950395464897, 0.010897432453930378, -0.007747012190520763, 0.013434367254376411, 0.014053771272301674, 0.011030036024749279, 0.022583534941077232, 0.0004246050666552037, -0.00769337872043252, -0.0019610729068517685, 0.02539646252989769, -0.00631031533703208, -0.014989964663982391, -0.0730295479297638, -0.007193014491349459, -0.016284367069602013, -0.05768353492021561, -0.05856429785490036, 0.0173749178647995, 0.04256928712129593, 0.03290049359202385, 0.028004422783851624, -0.010644832625985146, 0.0071136802434921265, -0.07077044993638992, 0.03763705864548683, -0.011305548250675201, -0.0215750802308321, 0.034511465579271317, -0.008913933299481869, 0.03388974443078041, -0.015354854986071587, -0.04492411017417908, -0.007382404524832964, 0.044782258570194244, -0.010961854830384254, -0.055754709988832474, -0.02438877895474434, -0.008387702517211437, 0.0024497490376234055, 0.06052065268158913, -0.02850179746747017, -0.024092748761177063, -0.013953114859759808, 0.01947905868291855, -0.015490284189581871, 0.025544334203004837, 0.052686113864183426, 0.020504416897892952, -0.007219657301902771, -0.010952671058475971, -0.025395402684807777, 0.005051776766777039, -0.009391790255904198, 0.05586453154683113, -0.01644444651901722, 0.10698020458221436, -0.0429958812892437, 0.013533560559153557, 0.012129813432693481, -0.04872700199484825, -0.03423638641834259, -0.03511185199022293, -0.0117071233689785, -0.028721598908305168, 0.012991626746952534, 0.03975978493690491, -0.01182795874774456, -0.025850461795926094, 0.027602238580584526, -0.0003694681217893958, -0.019967880100011826, -0.09064959734678268, -0.008047029376029968, 0.0542445033788681, 0.06568557769060135, -0.011763647198677063, 0.0006682539824396372, 0.07685226202011108, -0.0592094287276268, -0.01813424751162529, 0.03663591668009758, 0.0022267072927206755, -0.02953978069126606, -0.027164043858647346, 0.03457337245345116, -0.006598563399165869, -0.03661612048745155, -0.0244941096752882, 0.03569372370839119, 0.05396875739097595, -0.07297579199075699, 0.017365701496601105, 0.001114032231271267, -0.014612292870879173, 0.04357028007507324, 0.06939602643251419, -0.03470373526215553, -0.0035387780517339706, -0.014723984524607658, -0.013255732133984566, 0.037111490964889526, 0.03068232350051403, 0.0797896608710289, -0.0035984888672828674, -0.049407944083213806, 0.003989092539995909, -0.01782154105603695, 0.011933965608477592, 0.08526615053415298, 0.012237980961799622, 0.02150637097656727, -0.05384830757975578, -0.03027361072599888, -0.07749312371015549, 0.0189755130559206, 0.033028535544872284, -0.04391442611813545, -0.02462388388812542, -0.002986706094816327, 0.0141517985612154, 0.08714326471090317, -0.0023615662939846516, -0.01731783151626587, 0.03714008629322052, 0.024254320189356804, 0.02104521170258522, 0.045489806681871414, 0.05484495311975479, -0.015300445258617401, 0.0032679776195436716, -0.07832517474889755, -0.04640986770391464, -0.04017923027276993, -0.03811817988753319, 0.015341493301093578, 0.025156548246741295, -0.017347725108265877, 0.03474365547299385, -0.021142836660146713, -0.021496079862117767, 0.06515667587518692, -0.036865781992673874, -0.013632084242999554, -0.03302224725484848, -0.012560980394482613, -0.012044395320117474, -0.059106770902872086, 0.05978584662079811, 0.042781975120306015, 0.030995063483715057, 0.010378279723227024, -0.03274219483137131, -0.0013499425258487463, 0.03240962326526642, -0.03623371571302414, 0.025557391345500946, 0.10935315489768982, -0.02028222754597664, 0.03540969640016556, -0.03206496685743332, 0.061271313577890396, 0.03803463652729988, 0.031936414539813995, 0.015168902464210987, -0.02919657528400421, 0.022953761741518974, 0.0092180036008358, 0.022646436467766762, -0.030453631654381752, 0.04313460737466812, 0.001258170697838068, -0.03118513897061348, -0.01414515357464552, -0.033354151993989944, -0.03830816224217415, -0.029380688443779945, -0.05137202516198158, -0.060332976281642914, -0.02245699055492878, -0.05444474145770073, -0.03256005048751831, -0.014152458868920803, -0.03439042717218399, 0.10510003566741943, 0.022346792742609978, -0.0025273107457906008, 0.0005039689713157713, 0.021602924913167953, 0.008533800020813942, -0.026793502271175385, 0.05666704475879669, -0.010401464998722076, 0.04769393429160118, 0.01527361012995243, 0.003130711615085602, 0.0765417218208313, -0.0174784567207098, 0.011498573236167431, 0.04030129685997963, 0.006422544363886118, 0.05012001842260361, -0.007898249663412571, -0.022144144400954247, -0.011251062154769897, -0.0764087364077568, -0.055820152163505554, -0.04833995923399925, 0.0497666597366333, -0.058599185198545456, 0.004763122648000717, 0.0025555368047207594, 0.05534551665186882, -0.05816199630498886, 0.010575788095593452, 0.008105563931167126, 0.07631036639213562, -0.0412772037088871, -0.0044267852790653706, -0.00808710977435112, 0.07218706607818604, -0.007760677486658096, -0.006562008522450924, 0.042320966720581055, -0.0019661560654640198, 0.00230706250295043, -0.008077094331383705, 0.019963840022683144, 0.047360610216856, 0.04542174190282822, 0.006390238180756569, 0.03921147808432579, -0.018786899745464325, -0.028436286374926567, -0.015038855373859406, -0.0138245839625597, 0.011845306493341923, 0.023192640393972397, 0.04037702828645706, 0.0015596060547977686, 0.02235320955514908, -0.020980143919587135, -0.006678909529000521, -0.05788491666316986, 0.028369618579745293, 0.016301756724715233, 0.022222066298127174, -0.04539286345243454, 0.045995086431503296, -0.003728763200342655, 0.02667691931128502, -0.019357888028025627, 0.04290109500288963, 0.010852035135030746, -0.03391765058040619, -0.03521792218089104, 0.025387700647115707, 0.02633843570947647, 0.029798338189721107, -0.019921423867344856, 0.02780115231871605, 0.021338289603590965, -0.042575228959321976, -0.05589180812239647, 0.04469204321503639, -0.029016833752393723, 0.048052266240119934, 0.048407815396785736, -0.02709074318408966, 0.0392063669860363, -0.007111530750989914, 0.04440712556242943, 0.025356151163578033, -0.05181480944156647, -0.0317346416413784, 0.037819892168045044, -0.03800554201006889, 0.01067968737334013, 0.0456010177731514, 0.06897345185279846, -0.010743116959929466, 0.012798812240362167, -0.005976846907287836, 0.020736977458000183, 0.017961017787456512, -0.008216826245188713, 0.005007880739867687, -0.010972168296575546, 0.0058121769689023495, -0.004038973245769739, -0.03467291221022606, 0.04362713545560837, 0.026895729824900627, 0.0036699005868285894, -0.02958565205335617, -0.015432045795023441, -0.05513382703065872, -0.01983523741364479, -0.0011369814164936543, 0.029458194971084595, -0.03244485706090927, -0.04092574492096901, 0.024858782067894936, -0.012599547393620014, -0.041030749678611755, 0.01332310400903225, -0.07072459161281586, -0.030938178300857544, 0.019811538979411125, 0.06000802665948868, 0.032441940158605576, -0.02385084517300129, -0.023586954921483994, -0.02531840279698372, -0.07668136805295944, -0.025271395221352577, 0.020998716354370117, 0.03382405266165733, -0.013920735567808151, -0.015686335042119026, -0.03372897207736969, -0.017728552222251892, 0.0034167333506047726, -0.035794202238321304, -0.05088450387120247, -0.004612731281667948, -0.04146929830312729, 0.03676006197929382, -0.025004224851727486, 0.001507646287791431, -0.04691200330853462, 0.04569479078054428, -0.04988447204232216, 0.020410293713212013, -0.07621220499277115, -0.002517982851713896, 0.005744133144617081, -0.05232097581028938, 0.034630268812179565, -0.04744857922196388, -0.03701435774564743, -0.044920239597558975, -0.08753246068954468, -0.08126386255025864, -0.05931173637509346, 0.03365074470639229, 0.049943581223487854, -0.027417587116360664, 0.013613355346024036, -0.05620381236076355, -0.005882591474801302, 0.018225667998194695, -0.02856045961380005, -0.013505504466593266, 0.02345992624759674, -0.001720235450193286, 0.06816576421260834, 0.01734878309071064, -0.0605546273291111, 0.023944951593875885, 0.054156117141246796, -0.025754213333129883, 0.003802098799496889, -0.040916960686445236, 0.0446942113339901, -0.07352990657091141, -0.015387670136988163, 0.02877732180058956, 0.00533022778108716, -0.024996763095259666, -0.005080139730125666, 0.03250055015087128, 0.020486418157815933, -0.08357000350952148, -0.020754944533109665, 0.022149743512272835, 0.04127459600567818, 0.014744576998054981, 0.006021270994096994, 0.01438175980001688, 0.03184695541858673, 0.002479794668033719, -0.05847843736410141, 0.01886012591421604, 0.022052379325032234, 0.001936411252245307, -0.04227716103196144, -0.02063751593232155, -0.007504147011786699, 0.030354615300893784, 0.0008121164864860475, 0.06579386442899704, -0.06070651486515999, 0.024637840688228607, 0.0033363739494234324, -0.021440798416733742, -0.07168594002723694, 0.009280647151172161, -0.027070026844739914, 0.03399766609072685, -0.04995886981487274, 0.0009116503642871976, -0.06711957603693008, 0.0452149398624897, -0.005269699264317751, -0.00008440619421890005, 0.001835972536355257, 0.07418227940797806, -0.02692105621099472, 0.0010396514553576708, -0.11043685674667358, -0.023683231323957443, 0.051316116005182266, -0.023276042193174362, 0.029951658099889755, 0.021506644785404205, -0.009537837468087673, 0.014147442765533924, 0.01572454907000065, -0.02131160907447338, 0.03762270510196686, -0.04538324847817421, 0.0037175503093749285, 0.01755012571811676, -0.00006170730193844065, -0.0036912700161337852, 0.017882296815514565, 0.011755489744246006, 0.0002288499817950651, -0.009853620082139969, 0.017569303512573242, 0.05261556804180145, -0.042715489864349365, -0.03674497827887535, -0.06174337491393089, -0.04513988643884659, -0.01787632331252098, -0.016613012179732323, 0.01614370569586754, 0.005690541118383408, -0.08358928561210632, 0.016172004863619804, -0.010606613010168076, 0.02851038984954357, -0.0630563497543335, 0.05450000986456871, 0.0229814350605011, -0.014831249602138996, 0.04851186275482178, -0.007262442260980606, -0.0016660068649798632, 0.05729921907186508, -0.08054924756288528, -0.021685654297471046, 0.028842374682426453, 0.009135479107499123, 0.03321857377886772, 0.0006656096666119993, -0.028239628300070763, 0.0486835278570652, -0.01699054054915905, -0.07534884661436081, 0.018530836328864098, -0.04750026389956474, -0.03057965263724327, 0.006714924238622189, 0.006845042109489441, -0.01625039614737034, -0.011980457231402397, -0.0016731165815144777, -0.03235941380262375, 0.0018664333038032055, -0.05257956311106682, 0.008308596909046173, 0.01233849860727787, 0.029472146183252335, 0.03146982192993164, -0.0029352682176977396, 0.06907056272029877, 0.003546501509845257, 0.0061560506001114845, 0.043533798307180405, 0.024803422391414642, -0.03467843309044838, 0.013515034690499306, -0.062227100133895874, -0.023257166147232056, -0.03527262806892395, 0.04550512507557869, 0.017103930935263634, 0.006837714929133654, -0.012125491164624691, 0.02016720548272133, 0.01008042972534895, 0.008194574154913425, 0.020375844091176987, 0.046822693198919296, -0.022830214351415634, -0.010027709417045116, -0.026095546782016754, -0.026523089036345482, 0.053692515939474106, -0.004480286967009306, -0.034715380519628525, -0.03171360120177269, -0.08750757575035095, -0.010442822240293026, 0.0022351054940372705, -0.05553849786520004, 0.02079826593399048, -0.022254424169659615, 0.038782283663749695, 0.005718369502574205, -0.033253204077482224, -0.0317961759865284, 0.03674616664648056, 0.000882215506862849, -0.015720309689641, -0.05128738284111023, -0.04195290058851242, 0.050912097096443176, -0.037754833698272705, -0.04265782609581947, 0.01140563003718853, 0.05292639881372452, 0.019345471635460854, 0.02448573149740696, 0.05068366229534149, -0.0023482919204980135, 0.015505293384194374, 0.04395581781864166, 0.04645754396915436, 0.08345634490251541, -0.044743768870830536, -0.07694373279809952, -0.011661984957754612, 0.014595390297472477, 0.0022309226915240288, 0.02301664464175701, -0.03546923026442528, 0.017871985211968422, -0.006655902601778507, 0.02094544656574726, 0.06519768387079239, 0.00925410632044077, -0.034703489392995834, -0.051546767354011536, 0.02003628946840763, 0.001060252427123487, 0.02181774191558361, 0.05287871137261391, -0.06694953143596649, -0.016405215486884117, 0.03203224763274193, -0.026807876303792, 0.02836640551686287, -0.01347656361758709, 0.08602646738290787, -0.02029789239168167, 0.03416227176785469, 0.023820240050554276, 0.015885714441537857, 0.006656109355390072, -0.03012189455330372, -0.021649934351444244, 0.01712558977305889, -0.03312835842370987, -0.022459862753748894, -0.027066033333539963, 0.013789738528430462, -0.04019710421562195, 0.0024091361556202173, -0.00292474078014493, -0.014648441225290298, -0.036090437322854996, -0.017683764919638634, -0.01242134254425764, -0.016420410946011543, 0.008626720868051052, 0.009911268018186092, -0.037975553423166275, 0.018050899729132652, 0.0027091163210570812, -0.024260573089122772, -0.015145620331168175, -0.03861710801720619, 0.03282405063509941, -0.04630070924758911, 0.06328420341014862, 0.02291567623615265, 0.010775364004075527, -0.012389491312205791, 0.0024697037879377604, 0.02335340715944767, -0.010559826157987118, -0.02501661889255047, -0.0802125483751297, 0.07612967491149902, 0.019814379513263702, 0.02380654402077198, 0.0007646739832125604, -0.028639161959290504, 0.019064368680119514, 0.05046537518501282, 0.005754874553531408, 0.08161687850952148, -0.00009346611477667466, 0.01680096425116062, 0.03676915168762207, 0.018614068627357483, 0.018275029957294464, 0.009959539398550987, -0.005384702235460281, 0.03571890667080879 ]
<p>Work is expressed as <code>W=F*d</code>, where the <code>F</code> is in Newton, <code>d</code> is in meters and result <code>W</code> is in <strong>Joules</strong>. For example, if I take <code>1N</code> on earth and lift it <code>1m</code> up in the air I have done <code>1J</code> of work.</p> <p>Kinetic energy is expressed as <code>E=(1/2)*m*v^2</code>, where the <code>m</code> is mass of the body in kilograms and <code>v</code> is the speed of the body in m/s and the result is again in <strong>Joules</strong>. For example, if I have 80kg and run at speed of 5m/s then I have 2000J of kinetic energy.</p> <p>I am very puzzled because I do not see the relation between newtons and kilograms in these two examples. </p> <p>I mean, how can you mix up two different things such are mass and force and get the results in same unit such as Joule - Are those two results are the same Joules???</p>
g9744
[ 0.06050768867135048, -0.013199801556766033, -0.006045587360858917, 0.009674904868006706, 0.053539376705884933, 0.015127776190638542, 0.021414771676063538, 0.0386572889983654, -0.03880263864994049, -0.00002469613536959514, 0.001544067170470953, -0.04618198424577713, 0.017028486356139183, -0.0383453294634819, -0.04154794663190842, -0.019990479573607445, 0.10739191621541977, -0.003442317247390747, 0.01546446979045868, 0.06993787735700607, -0.030554702505469322, 0.03477666527032852, -0.051158368587493896, -0.052012741565704346, -0.05340924113988876, -0.025591738522052765, -0.011300066486001015, -0.004034975543618202, -0.06261985003948212, -0.008331182412803173, 0.043594446033239365, 0.011785286478698254, 0.05814193934202194, -0.03309030085802078, -0.0641074851155281, -0.03000454045832157, 0.028821853920817375, 0.014924905262887478, -0.014878527261316776, -0.01440969668328762, -0.0094646867364645, -0.04777371138334274, 0.014197357930243015, 0.009987160563468933, -0.008610845543444157, -0.042268577963113785, -0.042280763387680054, -0.023108486086130142, 0.004281158093363047, 0.004020992666482925, -0.04095277190208435, 0.04820278659462929, 0.006786109879612923, 0.04006872698664665, 0.010583880357444286, -0.028254713863134384, 0.05335273593664169, -0.03746642544865608, 0.06323077529668808, 0.012541569769382477, 0.01839747466146946, -0.013172008097171783, 0.03160083293914795, -0.004190894775092602, 0.07419344037771225, -0.032144658267498016, 0.002693425165489316, -0.00680341012775898, -0.038333017379045486, -0.006003048270940781, -0.024652427062392235, -0.009379569441080093, 0.016839373856782913, -0.028351949527859688, 0.006077968515455723, -0.048402830958366394, 0.08041031658649445, 0.012968276627361774, 0.02079278789460659, 0.009019753895699978, 0.01730409450829029, 0.028780026361346245, 0.018074309453368187, -0.007763619534671307, 0.02908337488770485, -0.026104198768734932, -0.018139375373721123, 0.053218234330415726, -0.02896782010793686, 0.05172709375619888, -0.011798669584095478, 0.005018605850636959, 0.10115736722946167, 0.08580823987722397, -0.060428474098443985, -0.047089286148548126, -0.018692240118980408, 0.08419612795114517, -0.002689919201657176, -0.03048446588218212, -0.009113634936511517, 0.0010453606955707073, -0.020755017176270485, 0.04244376718997955, -0.03265438601374626, -0.04077509790658951, 0.025681592524051666, 0.023179952055215836, -0.05228004232048988, -0.03359267860651016, -0.054117459803819656, -0.015234360471367836, -0.0029877701308578253, -0.007322086486965418, -0.034723781049251556, -0.030677897855639458, 0.025820322334766388, 0.005738111678510904, -0.019145797938108444, 0.010449276305735111, 0.014266915619373322, 0.01672700233757496, 0.007198153994977474, 0.027541397139430046, -0.025057872757315636, -0.025153838098049164, 0.02169344574213028, 0.0018822505371645093, 0.038407813757658005, -0.08707242459058762, 0.003025743877515197, -0.015225163660943508, -0.035080183297395706, 0.029584975913167, -0.05475885793566704, 0.0030523426830768585, -0.05263674259185791, 0.0216677188873291, -0.03267943114042282, 0.031008712947368622, -0.0009685134282335639, -0.03037702850997448, 0.0160861536860466, -0.01567722111940384, -0.020291980355978012, 0.0008291378035210073, -0.0676351860165596, -0.011496036313474178, 0.06475793570280075, -0.005132169462740421, 0.014971313998103142, 0.07177753746509552, -0.011186586692929268, -0.08382423222064972, 0.0509645976126194, -0.02452218346297741, -0.0027090993244200945, 0.0608292818069458, 0.029601043090224266, -0.017982250079512596, 0.06336729973554611, -0.03969704732298851, 0.06717349588871002, 0.00885889120399952, -0.005161570850759745, 0.0028068318497389555, -0.002859376138076186, -0.016013098880648613, 0.036789990961551666, -0.044934071600437164, -0.09684579074382782, -0.05658469349145889, -0.03283383324742317, 0.01813625544309616, -0.0315367616713047, 0.04422253742814064, 0.059932008385658264, -0.0019239367684349418, -0.04793610796332359, 0.013879146426916122, 0.005438865628093481, -0.007573666051030159, 0.04149550572037697, -0.0441296324133873, -0.0196298286318779, 0.00426909513771534, -0.003529891138896346, 0.03753504157066345, -0.06211291253566742, 0.024201545864343643, -0.01858125813305378, -0.004291116259992123, -0.0023176101967692375, 0.013844959437847137, -0.02942570298910141, 0.0361265204846859, -0.031121375039219856, -0.06031002104282379, -0.001643456518650055, 0.0356002040207386, 0.013847015798091888, 0.00889162253588438, 0.004087386652827263, 0.01054463628679514, 0.055350590497255325, 0.012899096123874187, -0.01191386766731739, 0.06089724600315094, 0.01986747980117798, -0.01484361756592989, 0.0007688109180890024, 0.009890252724289894, -0.004611131735146046, 0.07512880116701126, -0.026950852945446968, -0.037317100912332535, -0.011000800877809525, -0.02519858069717884, -0.048462964594364166, -0.025146931409835815, -0.07946757227182388, -0.05508376285433769, 0.040495529770851135, -0.030899619683623314, -0.017970722168684006, -0.05004090815782547, -0.020519310608506203, -0.016946488991379738, -0.03700285032391548, 0.009976381435990334, -0.0651116594672203, 0.0388273224234581, -0.0006050298688933253, -0.0028440121095627546, 0.07995269447565079, 0.061012960970401764, 0.0029198823031038046, -0.00526146125048399, -0.0008024345152080059, 0.022842474281787872, 0.0026076859794557095, -0.061039429157972336, -0.029994331300258636, -0.012317772023379803, 0.03553451970219612, 0.00484013045206666, 0.059723205864429474, -0.006132015958428383, -0.00843026489019394, 0.020845750346779823, -0.03713995963335037, -0.00949042197316885, -0.10337458550930023, 0.01806790940463543, 0.039379388093948364, 0.004563238471746445, -0.07795130461454391, 0.00732198404148221, -0.02492845617234707, -0.012493102811276913, 0.04661402106285095, -0.010461942292749882, 0.0102896299213171, 0.09065087884664536, -0.05482622608542442, -0.026375804096460342, -0.036641865968704224, -0.05050132796168327, 0.03198697790503502, -0.010379078797996044, -0.038698770105838776, 0.008885682560503483, 0.005118981935083866, 0.016661066561937332, -0.04240226373076439, -0.07196087390184402, 0.006129092071205378, -0.0780511349439621, 0.021139008924365044, -0.02854751981794834, -0.0013655786169692874, 0.00820080004632473, 0.011795424856245518, 0.05282701924443245, -0.0064362999983131886, -0.0746486634016037, -0.0040796478278934956, 0.020810509100556374, -0.010170484893023968, 0.01986759528517723, -0.006492570508271456, 0.06124620884656906, 0.06509094685316086, 0.009042751044034958, -0.027092885226011276, 0.07495921850204468, 0.07708216458559036, -0.0779573917388916, -0.01689797081053257, -0.02693319320678711, 0.028097283095121384, -0.03255420923233032, -0.012950735166668892, 0.07092563807964325, 0.023186801001429558, 0.00760471448302269, -0.008469506166875362, -0.047767262905836105, -0.03443412855267525, -0.056073106825351715, 0.012274658307433128, 0.020052744075655937, 0.010904827155172825, 0.013508782722055912, -0.056852057576179504, -0.03970156982541084, -0.04283924028277397, -0.05290212482213974, 0.03587009385228157, -0.0363338477909565, -0.019414138048887253, -0.05699325352907181, 0.05584355443716049, -0.022659730166196823, -0.027762167155742645, 0.05920929089188576, -0.05459362640976906, 0.018897678703069687, -0.0408509336411953, -0.018569335341453552, -0.02729860134422779, 0.010268473997712135, -0.025205641984939575, -0.017344951629638672, -0.05856720358133316, -0.008621913380920887, -0.06068408489227295, 0.0031826794147491455, 0.04095449671149254, -0.0026430594734847546, 0.010055112652480602, 0.05521785467863083, -0.045019105076789856, 0.014670767821371555, 0.011173813603818417, 0.05253000557422638, 0.035539716482162476, 0.01691075786948204, -0.0292745940387249, -0.0511164590716362, 0.021669669076800346, 0.012198196724057198, -0.0073740435764193535, -0.039090465754270554, -0.023348361253738403, -0.020482802763581276, 0.01476176269352436, 0.060287438333034515, 0.010812153108417988, -0.021727506071329117, 0.03784070909023285, 0.029850171878933907, 0.007192650809884071, 0.007102480623871088, -0.06983722001314163, 0.04281557351350784, 0.054852716624736786, 0.088245689868927, -0.007217130158096552, -0.041805777698755264, -0.02525058016180992, -0.044204793870449066, 0.038736723363399506, -0.023442136123776436, 0.02896469458937645, -0.04764151573181152, 0.035299040377140045, 0.00765956798568368, 0.0002576695987954736, 0.027516327798366547, 0.04668264463543892, 0.02471180632710457, -0.0198070015758276, 0.02015891671180725, 0.037752967327833176, -0.04195305332541466, -0.004418366122990847, 0.0045615145936608315, 0.08455740660429001, -0.026660965755581856, 0.001181386411190033, -0.021826954558491707, -0.0556858591735363, 0.03906448185443878, 0.0017549581825733185, -0.05502156913280487, 0.029968786984682083, -0.00417593726888299, -0.018150854855775833, 0.042899131774902344, -0.03199481591582298, 0.04597832262516022, 0.0017983908765017986, -0.013140033930540085, -0.037090033292770386, -0.02810189500451088, 0.012639203108847141, -0.0400991253554821, 0.021495506167411804, 0.011279463768005371, 0.0031514917500317097, -0.025657089427113533, 0.031181886792182922, -0.0769958570599556, -0.06051204353570938, -0.017228486016392708, -0.029703393578529358, -0.005713547579944134, 0.042149562388658524, -0.0003403899900149554, -0.006231792736798525, 0.08075392246246338, -0.0024996341671794653, -0.0034834800753742456, -0.001365203526802361, 0.06660815328359604, 0.06834238767623901, 0.00558603135868907, 0.049696240574121475, -0.02124013938009739, -0.013369465246796608, 0.03109893389046192, 0.07155493646860123, -0.030322067439556122, -0.02485106885433197, 0.03798699378967285, 0.018336042761802673, 0.014703046530485153, 0.046588100492954254, 0.028677068650722504, 0.06756378710269928, 0.041488923132419586, -0.007050811778753996, 0.01824396476149559, 0.01077542919665575, 0.04296945780515671, -0.017366789281368256, -0.05077313259243965, -0.03028739243745804, -0.0296351108700037, -0.04257413372397423, 0.038765810430049896, -0.04086509346961975, -0.020992018282413483, 0.022616129368543625, 0.055113982409238815, 0.011683154851198196, -0.03072267398238182, -0.008778024464845657, 0.02309275045990944, -0.030250241979956627, -0.03456179425120354, 0.11137168109416962, -0.0005198978469707072, 0.004756974056363106, -0.005484911613166332, -0.0588972307741642, 0.03180360049009323, -0.05630910396575928, -0.04453495517373085, 0.04378177970647812, -0.003261141711845994, -0.004219144582748413, 0.047741156071424484, 0.0981692224740982, -0.009374202229082584, -0.016811085864901543, -0.035219706594944, -0.003995407372713089, -0.005928222555667162, -0.015209661796689034, 0.018717259168624878, 0.020555619150400162, 0.02652028389275074, 0.014931412413716316, -0.013870945200324059, -0.031366750597953796, -0.007413454353809357, 0.03783167898654938, -0.007834113202989101, 0.0985676720738411, 0.059982381761074066, 0.014983254484832287, -0.028507979586720467, -0.016807887703180313, 0.0605025477707386, 0.023896947503089905, -0.023043382912874222, 0.009202312678098679, 0.026971902698278427, -0.033163029700517654, -0.0036984651815146208, -0.06556978076696396, 0.027935689315199852, 0.025524387136101723, 0.04258555546402931, 0.08453385531902313, 0.006165647879242897, 0.005330168176442385, 0.03285318613052368, 0.023582031950354576, 0.027319317683577538, -0.01430396270006895, 0.04168982431292534, 0.0011065772268921137, 0.008497802540659904, 0.03789501637220383, 0.01850319281220436, -0.028549354523420334, -0.05161066725850105, 0.08580691367387772, -0.0013944640522822738, 0.03916682302951813, 0.014192290604114532, -0.03395763039588928, 0.0049908882938325405, -0.036064740270376205, -0.005581354722380638, 0.002861965447664261, 0.07441724836826324, 0.005720087792724371, -0.0029963795095682144, 0.045509446412324905, 0.028412150219082832, -0.028625477105379105, -0.027982361614704132, -0.004004763904958963, 0.017438700422644615, 0.017131129279732704, -0.004762607626616955, 0.022942155599594116, -0.017507877200841904, 0.03433046117424965, 0.007344920188188553, -0.00725359283387661, 0.005584078375250101, 0.006372660398483276, -0.049730103462934494, 0.007651458960026503, -0.019624697044491768, 0.00417130533605814, 0.032934341579675674, -0.0072267563082277775, -0.018914535641670227, 0.023995377123355865, -0.010931463912129402, 0.009722363203763962, -0.05252926051616669, -0.03633684664964676, -0.00841374322772026, 0.03254714980721474, 0.025443697348237038, 0.00008660296589368954, 0.027442704886198044, 0.07483165711164474, -0.06079341471195221, -0.008055083453655243, 0.039432235062122345, 0.00036705180536955595, 0.01865127496421337, 0.047856640070676804, 0.017229393124580383, -0.017963552847504616, -0.04380517080426216, 0.0052606756798923016, 0.019256478175520897, -0.0200670063495636, 0.0020052846521139145, 0.011035408824682236, 0.011851825751364231, 0.031456854194402695, -0.009129218757152557, -0.010255556553602219, 0.0045939851552248, -0.08273373544216156, 0.02566763572394848, 0.0012725823326036334, 0.0332149975001812, 0.035290494561195374, -0.06448575109243393, -0.0432259701192379, -0.031133253127336502, -0.05060642212629318, 0.004776396788656712, -0.05866460129618645, -0.015166126191616058, -0.002115702722221613, -0.01529082003980875, 0.014905201271176338, 0.040332548320293427, 0.01675346866250038, -0.012402046471834183, 0.014882341958582401, -0.02220156602561474, 0.004578924737870693, 0.01438138261437416, -0.03684164211153984, 0.019348522648215294, -0.030165649950504303, 0.034742213785648346, -0.01690702885389328, 0.026235321536660194, -0.01838897354900837, 0.019365038722753525, -0.011276742443442345, -0.046814948320388794, -0.012217821553349495, -0.022732211276888847, -0.01643892377614975, -0.029668675735592842, 0.01184782199561596, -0.016837220638990402, 0.06358527392148972, -0.03564617410302162, 0.032381024211645126, 0.015828069299459457, -0.04557093232870102, 0.06382720172405243, 0.03959133103489876, -0.01407673116773367, 0.006803569849580526, 0.0030367437284439802, -0.010052697733044624, 0.013825930655002594, 0.027072545140981674, 0.030607886612415314, -0.017358489334583282, 0.03148842975497246, 0.03409455716609955, 0.045137472450733185, -0.03900016099214554, 0.02254711091518402, 0.03774046525359154, 0.0380672812461853, -0.040368031710386276, 0.0021913708187639713, 0.0434400737285614, -0.0062860650941729546, -0.04185250774025917, 0.03271132707595825, -0.016983289271593094, -0.030599819496273994, -0.03562471643090248, 0.019508808851242065, -0.01402447372674942, 0.07665035128593445, -0.00761196156963706, -0.03734535351395607, 0.05804506316781044, -0.05161040648818016, -0.0016519582131877542, 0.0066518886014819145, -0.01872112601995468, 0.016998954117298126, -0.017003631219267845, 0.05417464300990105, -0.03509174659848213, 0.05008683726191521, -0.012727518565952778, -0.020353542640805244, -0.023498734459280968, -0.018288182094693184, -0.02699749544262886, 0.0210499819368124, 0.022944245487451553, 0.018673745915293694, -0.04503025859594345, -0.00007424366049235687, -0.0020246512722223997, -0.022000955417752266, 0.000793583516497165, 0.04050455614924431, -0.030469471588730812, 0.029133571311831474, 0.0029840017668902874, 0.08375674486160278, -0.05902370437979698, 0.0110810287296772, 0.059039223939180374, 0.016674749553203583, 0.011342201381921768, 0.03260144963860512, 0.03684249147772789, 0.03449105843901634, -0.03370250388979912, 0.014243449084460735, 0.018820537254214287, 0.046554043889045715, 0.025081712752580643, 0.0049064550548791885, 0.0362250842154026, 0.0360298715531826, -0.008768124505877495, 0.019552258774638176, -0.04235319048166275, 0.039013464003801346, -0.03265974298119545, -0.028770994395017624, -0.020563222467899323, -0.02306412346661091, -0.0015077274292707443, -0.017087528482079506, 0.04724052548408508, 0.04164879769086838, 0.018625548109412193, -0.0008109979098662734, -0.05069129168987274, -0.0036194061394780874, 0.037778858095407486, -0.018789075314998627, -0.061515454202890396, -0.01995909959077835, -0.009323995560407639, -0.08948054909706116, -0.011865774169564247, -0.0166278388351202, 0.0020910531748086214, 0.00025806299527175725, -0.06382672488689423, 0.030307095497846603, -0.00023959102691151202, -0.03053228370845318, -0.03007935732603073, -0.011946437880396843, 0.01150775421410799, -0.03869929909706116, 0.03990573808550835, -0.05850692838430405, -0.015659652650356293, 0.041024137288331985, -0.037287432700395584, -0.06081021577119827, -0.028459232300519943, 0.035091716796159744, -0.017185388132929802, -0.06905461102724075, -0.06539154052734375, 0.07377824932336807, 0.017689531669020653, -0.037557873874902725, 0.007000139448791742, 0.04426155611872673, -0.055223558098077774, 0.03329148143529892, -0.002572505734860897, -0.06864859908819199, 0.017868801951408386, 0.028803018853068352, -0.01986108347773552, -0.02497846633195877, 0.00041352194966748357, 0.016829846426844597, -0.06950698047876358, -0.008793454617261887, 0.013840700499713421, -0.024650653824210167, -0.034612152725458145, 0.011757858097553253 ]
<p>For a <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/B0061DSNCC" rel="nofollow">typical flourescent light available in the United States</a> on a a standard 120V 60Hz line, is there information available on the decay time of the light? For example, if I am running the light a full power (ON) and shut off power (instantaneously) how long before the light is completely off (or reduced by $1/e$...)?</p> <p>E.g. if the luminance is given by </p> <p>$$ L = L_0 e^{-t/\tau} $$ where $t$ is the time elapsed after killing the power: what is $\tau$? Order of magnitude estimates would be great. More precision would be even better. I couldn't find this information easily on google.</p>
g9745
[ 0.05848684161901474, -0.0003541674232110381, -0.012380600906908512, -0.0034888661466538906, 0.0076692234724760056, -0.05263540521264076, 0.012037994340062141, 0.037165846675634384, -0.023086290806531906, -0.022729329764842987, 0.0025909715332090855, 0.04047124832868576, 0.06264108419418335, 0.03486458957195282, 0.018508216366171837, -0.04103957489132881, 0.05122514069080353, -0.041415050625801086, 0.043527260422706604, -0.017727918922901154, -0.021866830065846443, -0.04229680821299553, -0.03191855177283287, -0.025387294590473175, 0.014247201383113861, 0.008410627022385597, 0.011144679971039295, 0.03835101053118706, -0.04451659321784973, -0.05784839391708374, -0.05106404051184654, -0.005311409942805767, -0.0007990239537321031, -0.0029918374493718147, -0.0031523851212114096, 0.025736549869179726, 0.054006848484277725, -0.0032804422080516815, 0.00868681725114584, 0.03980110585689545, 0.024316120892763138, -0.006326737813651562, 0.09348534047603607, -0.015314178541302681, 0.04318176954984665, -0.01131268311291933, -0.021100057289004326, 0.01020844280719757, -0.030936913564801216, -0.012264974415302277, -0.012678224593400955, 0.010020267218351364, 0.0634618028998375, -0.04544658586382866, -0.01658685691654682, -0.025417150929570198, -0.018840037286281586, 0.006852002814412117, -0.010224791243672371, 0.04355321452021599, 0.021624786779284477, -0.01682460866868496, 0.0026802108623087406, -0.036456018686294556, 0.016720397397875786, 0.015780629590153694, 0.003470269963145256, -0.027894169092178345, 0.026829898357391357, -0.001957249129191041, -0.026308352127671242, -0.001968363067135215, -0.05075106397271156, -0.0722297951579094, 0.00821573194116354, 0.014093196019530296, -0.0357397198677063, -0.008269286714494228, -0.015590537339448929, 0.03524656221270561, -0.051734864711761475, -0.004727070219814777, -0.01083909347653389, 0.06469028443098068, -0.0008395418408326805, -0.005185118410736322, 0.005867899861186743, -0.00783718191087246, 0.030043380334973335, -0.005952177103608847, 0.07418753206729889, 0.0018135708523914218, 0.044322457164525986, -0.041421737521886826, 0.03335796669125557, 0.000586761103477329, -0.010662642307579517, 0.026539573445916176, -0.034194935113191605, 0.05543166399002075, 0.02315082587301731, -0.026602650061249733, -0.05114633962512016, -0.0398075245320797, 0.004931730218231678, -0.019415613263845444, 0.010497990995645523, 0.013579186052083969, -0.01096313912421465, 0.056295495480298996, -0.003269247245043516, 0.035961877554655075, -0.040035903453826904, -0.028402751311659813, -0.03609493747353554, -0.03093254752457142, 0.09350646287202835, -0.06508509069681168, 0.009250461123883724, -0.015537860803306103, 0.03761281073093414, -0.00518110953271389, 0.020330531522631645, 0.04786524921655655, -0.02545468509197235, 0.005778040271252394, 0.011893924325704575, 0.014460941776633263, -0.004540276248008013, 0.06720326095819473, -0.039336755871772766, -0.023733440786600113, -0.029600737616419792, 0.03892022743821144, 0.0324132926762104, 0.07499879598617554, 0.07809615880250931, 0.003634250722825527, -0.0017353262519463897, -0.023366862908005714, 0.02831856720149517, -0.02892429754137993, 0.006041886750608683, -0.02875511348247528, -0.1150912493467331, 0.09227464348077774, 0.0134502612054348, -0.01140725240111351, 0.1253921389579773, 0.021718589588999748, 0.007009907625615597, 0.04556563124060631, -0.01300447154790163, -0.03242211416363716, 0.010627922601997852, -0.04748758673667908, -0.00995981227606535, -0.08743883669376373, -0.08781925588846207, 0.02481301687657833, 0.011223452165722847, 0.015233641490340233, -0.040429335087537766, 0.01043600682169199, -0.035704292356967926, -0.025904210284352303, 0.01609032228589058, -0.016489526256918907, 0.011885281652212143, -0.10108392685651779, -0.04035385325551033, 0.05241922661662102, 0.08858498185873032, 0.03425724431872368, 0.008090819232165813, 0.010917856357991695, 0.053493522107601166, -0.0029565137811005116, 0.005907829850912094, 0.05435089394450188, -0.015023590065538883, 0.009911575354635715, -0.022871434688568115, -0.012733272276818752, 0.01258999202400446, 0.0029269172810018063, 0.006195541471242905, -0.02645113691687584, -0.01665429212152958, 0.02990500070154667, -0.010008580051362514, -0.026135418564081192, 0.040619026869535446, 0.06356853991746902, -0.04018021747469902, 0.024228304624557495, -0.028020113706588745, -0.019658103585243225, 0.0009433302911929786, -0.025774557143449783, -0.02546943537890911, 0.001493142917752266, -0.0033277738839387894, 0.04479667544364929, 0.0498613640666008, -0.029413262382149696, 0.00043377908878028393, -0.02858584374189377, -0.011689701117575169, 0.04801734909415245, 0.01155849825590849, 0.028229592368006706, -0.000372046313714236, 0.02993062697350979, 0.023410867899656296, 0.009464157745242119, -0.016786718741059303, 0.05752332881093025, 0.02088666707277298, 0.03832326456904411, 0.0004607783048413694, 0.04564511403441429, 0.011182316578924656, -0.032919589430093765, -0.02013215236365795, -0.00210180482827127, -0.013572781346738338, 0.03870261460542679, -0.0009460769360885024, -0.006969833746552467, -0.020475436002016068, 0.04657585546374321, -0.019997838884592056, -0.06493157893419266, -0.053089071065187454, 0.01860453374683857, 0.018586615100502968, -0.024451956152915955, 0.04012290760874748, 0.05577448382973671, 0.011224448680877686, 0.009936663322150707, -0.021030014380812645, 0.06363333761692047, -0.04254090413451195, -0.03419624641537666, 0.005230901762843132, -0.035333145409822464, -0.07728703320026398, 0.015876401215791702, -0.01860264502465725, -0.013660593889653683, 0.06569270044565201, 0.07361351698637009, -0.061565086245536804, -0.06139067932963371, 0.006605897564440966, 0.017482588067650795, -0.07430337369441986, 0.013136583380401134, -0.06180396303534508, 0.020663822069764137, -0.014903846196830273, -0.009377215057611465, 0.04196358844637871, 0.007338964845985174, 0.020700180903077126, 0.03228272497653961, 0.0367228239774704, -0.02491758204996586, 0.06752645969390869, 0.04570087045431137, -0.017456432804465294, 0.04655677452683449, 0.009526652283966541, 0.009470341727137566, 0.03487491235136986, -0.00623812060803175, 0.011627733707427979, -0.0016083595110103488, -0.016670653596520424, -0.0479438491165638, -0.06979188323020935, 0.06237838789820671, -0.021525071933865547, -0.054055217653512955, 0.01977885328233242, 0.015763267874717712, -0.05034573748707771, 0.0031194076873362064, -0.07254316657781601, 0.01580744981765747, 0.015347583219408989, -0.0015058733988553286, -0.03611765056848526, 0.02766912244260311, 0.016409914940595627, -0.02723793312907219, 0.0037628766149282455, 0.0019370007794350386, 0.05829310789704323, -0.02807273156940937, -0.08050080388784409, -0.045167382806539536, -0.005892429035156965, 0.00881807878613472, -0.04603555053472519, -0.048677243292331696, -0.006977962329983711, -0.003082302398979664, -0.019421260803937912, 0.012297511100769043, 0.03729062154889107, -0.026821831241250038, -0.0511498898267746, -0.006847810465842485, 0.019916042685508728, 0.05026208981871605, -0.04584181681275368, -0.009912103414535522, 0.06321588158607483, -0.015280853025615215, -0.015598572790622711, 0.007938370108604431, 0.013606572523713112, -0.008724480867385864, -0.02813396230340004, 0.03116394206881523, -0.02002621814608574, 0.0374312661588192, -0.0014209727523848414, -0.022246699780225754, -0.028869835659861565, -0.03318353742361069, -0.03119044378399849, 0.030725829303264618, -0.023717181757092476, 0.060444436967372894, 0.006286547984927893, 0.030604906380176544, 0.008737600408494473, 0.012601722963154316, -0.030281100422143936, 0.05876898765563965, 0.046164944767951965, -0.04314461722970009, -0.061022914946079254, 0.029864491894841194, -0.012456018477678299, -0.006189103238284588, 0.060837522149086, -0.011889535933732986, -0.008183179423213005, -0.06590571999549866, -0.03933142125606537, 0.036846794188022614, 0.009678862057626247, 0.03422340378165245, 0.012981297448277473, 0.02038440853357315, 0.0354413278400898, -0.04176566004753113, 0.053457316011190414, -0.010422419756650925, 0.011947769671678543, 0.00604946119710803, -0.010107382200658321, 0.06783895194530487, 0.009254459291696548, -0.02846117690205574, -0.0029907829593867064, 0.03763573244214058, -0.0004953297902829945, 0.025189967826008797, -0.031520675867795944, 0.006771796382963657, 0.0071443356573581696, -0.01764168031513691, -0.029322493821382523, 0.07421500235795975, 0.006637949962168932, 0.008683305233716965, 0.004810977727174759, -0.05098649114370346, -0.011913806200027466, -0.017195168882608414, -0.022319596260786057, -0.06169591844081879, -0.020910706371068954, -0.10341213643550873, 0.0050492798909544945, -0.1233316957950592, 0.00634926138445735, -0.014501356519758701, -0.02019367180764675, 0.0035497189965099096, 0.05307405814528465, 0.03174348920583725, 0.006420055869966745, -0.0012309380108490586, -0.007430122699588537, 0.04470456391572952, 0.0225876122713089, 0.07896395772695541, 0.00634546997025609, 0.016524970531463623, -0.020494045689702034, -0.05745570734143257, 0.03894886001944542, -0.04027735814452171, 0.003216631943359971, 0.015168622136116028, -0.012162202969193459, -0.012493002228438854, -0.011832509189844131, 0.026030883193016052, 0.009420657530426979, 0.022536668926477432, 0.053700387477874756, -0.01087774895131588, 0.03785913437604904, 0.012624282389879227, 0.0012653260491788387, -0.03052293136715889, -0.010912326164543629, 0.022346321493387222, -0.03196829929947853, -0.03835233300924301, 0.015446619130671024, -0.012236316688358784, 0.08290418237447739, 0.02833702601492405, -0.0029647161718457937, -0.0032042458187788725, -0.030097657814621925, 0.017872724682092667, -0.012551226653158665, 0.049635689705610275, 0.013392699882388115, 0.05787910148501396, 0.03060726821422577, -0.026319699361920357, -0.004606232512742281, 0.010746226646006107, -0.020475275814533234, 0.03160207346081734, -0.03685721382498741, -0.01568238064646721, 0.029301898553967476, -0.043555282056331635, -0.015010460279881954, 0.04954152926802635, -0.10239774733781815, -0.039352741092443466, 0.009673272259533405, -0.003257791046053171, 0.007081000600010157, 0.042319443076848984, 0.03504021838307381, -0.0011937943054363132, -0.026049716398119926, -0.02984762191772461, 0.0032773087732493877, -0.050690602511167526, 0.008329791948199272, -0.005269673187285662, -0.018446331843733788, -0.008924808353185654, -0.10610349476337433, -0.029380224645137787, -0.014960508793592453, -0.05022958666086197, 0.09681408852338791, -0.006764833349734545, -0.04974468797445297, 0.00729161873459816, 0.015374135226011276, 0.028024625033140182, 0.05596351996064186, 0.029613947495818138, -0.03208169341087341, -0.039413876831531525, -0.032536935061216354, -0.017093297094106674, 0.008650475181639194, 0.025276439264416695, -0.050440967082977295, -0.009884394705295563, 0.05800161883234978, -0.05811368301510811, -0.02518516592681408, 0.042465075850486755, 0.017573293298482895, -0.031568899750709534, -0.014218897558748722, -0.016684869304299355, 0.0048857638612389565, -0.05638599023222923, 0.005884949117898941, 0.02430795505642891, -0.02286008931696415, 0.009220059961080551, 0.019167594611644745, -0.006075303070247173, -0.014200359582901001, 0.03894350677728653, 0.029708491638302803, -0.04342842102050781, 0.027893243357539177, 0.06970728933811188, 0.036012403666973114, 0.08243369311094284, 0.05158456042408943, 0.04491778835654259, -0.0042809671722352505, 0.0015655442839488387, -0.09399843961000443, 0.06898154318332672, -0.022885030135512352, -0.04804246500134468, -0.03572772070765495, 0.003748903516680002, 0.009513265453279018, 0.0013187348376959562, 0.027359552681446075, -0.017686497420072556, -0.06967020779848099, 0.028760449960827827, 0.01274891383945942, -0.06531065702438354, 0.008319612592458725, 0.01644221320748329, -0.03876631334424019, -0.027447376400232315, -0.005463524721562862, 0.01950298622250557, 0.021966079249978065, -0.03872009366750717, -0.008360805921256542, 0.024530509486794472, -0.053139857947826385, 0.022093411535024643, -0.019774051383137703, 0.03144681453704834, 0.0017740338807925582, -0.017230549827218056, 0.019441042095422745, -0.04562544822692871, -0.02725035883486271, -0.003315857844427228, 0.011418618261814117, -0.03356674686074257, 0.041262805461883545, 0.026003004983067513, -0.005835124757140875, 0.07136929780244827, 0.04284881427884102, 0.01907891407608986, -0.0706733763217926, -0.021836912259459496, 0.02980700135231018, -0.01054264698177576, 0.03433133289217949, -0.021394113078713417, 0.024916023015975952, -0.04635492339730263, 0.04184257984161377, -0.03569871559739113, -0.008646752685308456, 0.04299110919237137, 0.06022488698363304, -0.053099434822797775, -0.005864351987838745, -0.03576144576072693, -0.00465378537774086, 0.007926670834422112, -0.026981592178344727, -0.012519936077296734, -0.022852076217532158, -0.0227892454713583, -0.017605943605303764, -0.037152037024497986, 0.006903316825628281, 0.014429702423512936, 0.004959286190569401, 0.01356470212340355, 0.010480622760951519, 0.03237415477633476, 0.027396300807595253, 0.012120161205530167, 0.03814774006605148, -0.010574893094599247, -0.0016779587604105473, -0.04329079017043114, 0.036948103457689285, 0.0030491126235574484, -0.007407671306282282, 0.028285399079322815, 0.015858443453907967, -0.005988152232021093, -0.029996776953339577, 0.06882275640964508, 0.058168649673461914, -0.08861987292766571, 0.08494721353054047, 0.03965902328491211, 0.013093063607811928, 0.016299305483698845, 0.013252248987555504, -0.0028949861880391836, 0.05403699353337288, -0.013815714977681637, -0.006079829763621092, 0.025974443182349205, -0.018073132261633873, -0.03923209756612778, 0.049394432455301285, 0.05722298473119736, -0.02155805006623268, 0.06963890045881271, -0.010004693642258644, -0.050500400364398956, 0.0018626258242875338, -0.005685354582965374, 0.02122144028544426, 0.08788933604955673, 0.038425080478191376, -0.02112533152103424, 0.005292823072522879, -0.024535851553082466, 0.03903576359152794, -0.06970392167568207, 0.045678526163101196, -0.007189252879470587, 0.027382921427488327, 0.02858545444905758, -0.029787307605147362, 0.021034788340330124, 0.007122531533241272, 0.004080936778336763, 0.001863192650489509, 0.02537406235933304, 0.04100842401385307, -0.01650761067867279, -0.06505685299634933, 0.02352825738489628, 0.0279117152094841, 0.004940251354128122, 0.01760704442858696, 0.02165110595524311, 0.035188134759664536, -0.04386730119585991, 0.031424250453710556, -0.016051171347498894, 0.048736684024333954, 0.03910590708255768, -0.018128039315342903, 0.03027847595512867, -0.06299830228090286, -0.06371726840734482, 0.055935852229595184, -0.08643373101949692, -0.025304501876235008, 0.004585490562021732, 0.02166185900568962, 0.01925089582800865, 0.019114572554826736, -0.08942756056785583, 0.009620368480682373, -0.06020438298583031, 0.005348533857613802, -0.021607358008623123, 0.0037205361295491457, -0.03318687528371811, -0.015200888738036156, 0.011038764379918575, -0.0901927649974823, 0.05315754562616348, 0.01485621277242899, -0.019017865881323814, -0.029431121423840523, 0.0187387652695179, -0.024184666574001312, -0.05756178870797157, -0.007621351629495621, 0.03764628246426582, -0.053871966898441315, 0.003083846066147089, 0.022167138755321503, 0.003201686777174473, -0.04934835061430931, 0.01720801554620266, 0.01965811289846897, -0.05490604788064957, 0.010288700461387634, -0.07126341760158539, 0.021170035004615784, -0.039995353668928146, 0.04740358889102936, 0.03700733557343483, 0.0369790643453598, -0.027461331337690353, 0.025405608117580414, -0.024219999089837074, -0.04807354882359505, 0.030174044892191887, -0.01965653896331787, -0.10043974965810776, -0.026332423090934753, 0.0027002000715583563, 0.0178578719496727, 0.04812582954764366, -0.01411446277052164, -0.02272636815905571, 0.01140908058732748, 0.0024451930075883865, -0.011459033004939556, -0.05551107972860336, 0.013995572924613953, 0.05432169884443283, -0.06113748252391815, -0.010640974156558514, -0.005517752841114998, -0.01331396121531725, 0.007555356714874506, 0.0047159865498542786, -0.03112752176821232, 0.04265279695391655, 0.0382566936314106, -0.02173454314470291, 0.024828897789120674, -0.03499814495444298, 0.0025650975294411182, 0.025134587660431862, 0.008079970255494118, 0.034059152007102966, 0.02094070427119732, 0.018058106303215027, -0.011889970861375332, 0.050083525478839874, -0.046188730746507645, -0.03518705815076828, -0.007603023666888475, -0.014388175681233406, -0.015458924695849419, 0.01850002445280552, -0.014772308990359306, 0.007567420601844788, 0.00875562708824873, -0.022156285122036934, -0.014362760819494724, 0.032524339854717255, -0.04153045266866684, -0.008429630659520626, 0.03894409164786339, -0.049211304634809494, -0.005323448218405247, -0.06091291457414627, 0.010139530524611473, -0.04357768967747688, -0.05152434483170509, -0.005414785351604223, -0.0033961955923587084, 0.06380632519721985, 0.020720582455396652, -0.037082359194755554, -0.020550746470689774, -0.03982262313365936 ]
<p>I am going through Sakurai's quantum mechanics, and at one point the solution to a problem says:</p> <p>$(\sin(\beta)\cos(\alpha)-i\sin(\beta)\sin(\alpha))b+\cos(\beta)a=a$ $(\sin(\beta)\cos(\alpha)+i\sin(\beta)\sin(\alpha))a-\cos(\beta)b=b$</p> <p>$a,b$ are the complex coefficients for some state, so we have:</p> <p>$|a|^2+|b|^2=1$</p> <p>What I don't understand is that from there he goes to:</p> <p>$a=\cos(\frac{\beta}{2})e^{i\theta_a}$</p> <p>For some $\theta_a$. I understand that you can write $a$ as $r e^{i\theta}$ for some $r,\theta$, but I dont see how he is able to get $r=\cos(\frac{\beta}{2})$. Where does this come from?</p>
g9746
[ 0.023570669814944267, -0.01842253841459751, -0.01598883979022503, -0.02481924742460251, 0.08078618347644806, -0.02305549941956997, 0.0850682258605957, -0.017757989466190338, -0.029640553519129753, -0.00835426989942789, -0.08163342624902725, 0.048839736729860306, 0.025975525379180908, 0.004410478286445141, 0.03371807560324669, -0.003974568098783493, 0.01810723915696144, 0.052937671542167664, -0.005860573146492243, 0.017145812511444092, -0.007939746603369713, -0.0025609061121940613, 0.014501434750854969, -0.027876531705260277, 0.08211632072925568, -0.0115817217156291, 0.016011886298656464, 0.04487074166536331, -0.00888501014560461, -0.0032222613226622343, 0.008543534204363823, 0.06380865722894669, 0.09908623993396759, -0.06472373753786087, -0.008251591585576534, 0.013422337360680103, 0.027666516602039337, -0.0049809846095740795, 0.02023799903690815, -0.036898210644721985, 0.013867232017219067, -0.03478867560625076, 0.020763374865055084, -0.028763124719262123, 0.0004831200058106333, -0.01535744033753872, 0.024988461285829544, -0.01890781708061695, -0.018431104719638824, 0.02399357222020626, 0.020445749163627625, -0.014841152355074883, 0.023338111117482185, -0.006948919966816902, 0.006306203547865152, 0.04036878049373627, 0.05055216699838638, -0.04222894087433815, 0.023953653872013092, 0.04706133157014847, 0.00980454869568348, -0.008169053122401237, 0.08658537268638611, 0.04620026424527168, 0.03832785412669182, -0.045581407845020294, 0.023736383765935898, 0.022355051711201668, -0.04215582087635994, 0.023947319015860558, 0.009640314616262913, -0.05931597203016281, 0.05554990842938423, -0.04144473746418953, -0.04694008827209473, -0.03061372973024845, 0.07470518350601196, 0.001908602542243898, -0.01147705502808094, 0.008334282785654068, -0.01862504333257675, -0.08003547787666321, 0.043014004826545715, -0.003229354275390506, 0.03962469846010208, 0.011771537363529205, 0.018815549090504646, -0.00330267078243196, -0.023249251767992973, -0.024236248806118965, -0.029582254588603973, -0.02847900800406933, 0.013365778140723705, -0.008215240202844143, 0.009774986654520035, -0.026931431144475937, -0.004149014130234718, -0.0241741593927145, -0.060152817517519, -0.026122484356164932, 0.008116313256323338, -0.0017907852306962013, 0.05496750771999359, -0.0006016080733388662, -0.004062296357005835, 0.016764644533395767, 0.02227180451154709, -0.003217988647520542, 0.04080803319811821, -0.0313684344291687, -0.04314237833023071, 0.03292830288410187, -0.04143664985895157, -0.0839252769947052, 0.0022700224071741104, 0.0075805215165019035, -0.004348623100668192, 0.007162714842706919, -0.004286099690943956, 0.02481270395219326, -0.04684523865580559, 0.012785193510353565, -0.0014887399738654494, 0.06287955492734909, -0.035204801708459854, 0.06800151616334915, 0.02895124815404415, 0.022651556879281998, 0.09445023536682129, -0.0482545904815197, -0.03515366092324257, 0.006685878150165081, 0.01009351946413517, 0.02122025191783905, 0.01044579315930605, 0.044832486659288406, -0.03898971527814865, 0.012540562078356743, 0.003971341531723738, -0.020345600321888924, -0.04309682920575142, -0.05969322845339775, -0.016741270199418068, -0.0029646926559507847, -0.012286005541682243, 0.022228561341762543, 0.02268945798277855, -0.005958425346761942, 0.0009950901148840785, 0.013174387626349926, -0.0014757286990061402, 0.05073966830968857, 0.014975419268012047, 0.002038252539932728, 0.04281659424304962, 0.0006950384704396129, 0.03073182702064514, -0.02577630989253521, -0.04195816069841385, 0.0032995801884680986, 0.04590080678462982, -0.017133839428424835, 0.02937457710504532, 0.03101813979446888, -0.08663896471261978, 0.03335273638367653, -0.048367999494075775, -0.051539331674575806, -0.04320763051509857, -0.027912374585866928, -0.030321219936013222, 0.043119680136442184, -0.013841016218066216, 0.005384829360991716, 0.04999777674674988, 0.09034307301044464, -0.034645017236471176, -0.0028403194155544043, 0.04697425663471222, 0.01460365578532219, -0.009950497187674046, -0.021238157525658607, 0.009158618748188019, 0.031552672386169434, -0.005460499320179224, -0.012321378104388714, 0.015099069103598595, 0.029278995469212532, -0.028597205877304077, 0.00039817680954001844, 0.03611678630113602, 0.05556485429406166, 0.0022846462670713663, -0.022493712604045868, -0.022209152579307556, 0.0035096558276563883, 0.0407942570745945, -0.08566351234912872, -0.012561035342514515, 0.004907965660095215, -0.02319551259279251, 0.04646138474345207, -0.02040679380297661, -0.030529407784342766, 0.030689576640725136, -0.0032841945067048073, 0.0058180904015898705, -0.038018058985471725, -0.03565621003508568, 0.03302989527583122, -0.05819934234023094, -0.04519651457667351, 0.019156089052557945, 0.0532802939414978, -0.036987029016017914, -0.05441485717892647, 0.07882002741098404, 0.020295504480600357, -0.040129829198122025, 0.015352965332567692, -0.056473713368177414, -0.025397183373570442, 0.041414372622966766, -0.011884557083249092, 0.01828828826546669, 0.08364055305719376, -0.04979060962796211, -0.00045030651381239295, -0.008661150000989437, 0.03663609176874161, -0.07222343981266022, -0.01666008122265339, -0.049477942287921906, -0.0015289365546777844, 0.0015074246330186725, 0.019759783521294594, -0.013963146135210991, -0.00526262354105711, 0.014767407439649105, 0.04218681529164314, 0.0198845062404871, -0.030947823077440262, -0.0046180966310203075, 0.016624340787529945, -0.005198013503104448, 0.04775302857160568, 0.062456198036670685, -0.006736908573657274, -0.09409984201192856, 0.0000616503821220249, -0.03529628738760948, -0.023963481187820435, -0.04704979062080383, 0.040984123945236206, -0.0020591234788298607, -0.051423825323581696, 0.03685741126537323, 0.010424138978123665, -0.0034378536511212587, -0.016981085762381554, 0.010512948036193848, -0.03800885006785393, 0.011164884082973003, 0.039960186928510666, -0.03567170724272728, 0.04192425683140755, -0.02491544559597969, -0.07255583256483078, 0.017204008996486664, -0.02781810611486435, -0.0494924932718277, 0.07619801163673401, -0.004917432554066181, 0.04063303396105766, -0.012546873651444912, -0.03369968757033348, 0.013046199455857277, -0.023071780800819397, 0.05540020763874054, -0.04467228427529335, -0.0704917386174202, 0.04339418187737465, -0.010144725441932678, 0.04161687195301056, -0.041620884090662, -0.009345944039523602, -0.012508106417953968, 0.047217369079589844, 0.0648036077618599, 0.006001190282404423, 0.016309473663568497, 0.03476579114794731, 0.010066099464893341, 0.0018171478295698762, 0.04865942895412445, 0.04553091526031494, 0.03630009666085243, -0.05114728957414627, 0.004354377277195454, 0.06196635961532593, 0.024123335257172585, -0.00024497235426679254, 0.0002732961147557944, -0.05517761781811714, 0.020867833867669106, -0.011973727494478226, 0.0524226650595665, -0.013283922336995602, 0.014594542793929577, -0.0030160960741341114, -0.013418296352028847, -0.05279975011944771, 0.027719857171177864, -0.019981753081083298, -0.017825838178396225, -0.0002308566472493112, 0.02878953516483307, -0.046560030430555344, 0.08618877828121185, 0.02787262201309204, -0.049761250615119934, -0.0733405351638794, 0.0174995269626379, -0.012389931827783585, -0.013401971198618412, -0.003019158961251378, -0.09825313836336136, -0.004954193718731403, 0.031941626220941544, -0.06153969466686249, 0.007424980401992798, -0.06173607334494591, 0.04014291614294052, -0.020874114707112312, -0.003395981388166547, -0.022385424003005028, -0.030176734551787376, 0.06948918849229813, 0.03119690530002117, -0.020518049597740173, -0.050142981112003326, -0.04485442861914635, -0.001400514505803585, 0.02422805316746235, 0.011919737793505192, -0.011277785524725914, 0.007711989805102348, 0.01617578975856304, 0.0315946489572525, -0.037342943251132965, -0.05794411525130272, -0.0006400408456102014, -0.03932390734553337, -0.024907490238547325, -0.012605949304997921, 0.031540289521217346, -0.0032771385740488768, 0.011082224547863007, 0.013319790363311768, -0.0019865124486386776, 0.03818320482969284, -0.0027741286903619766, 0.04032745212316513, 0.05115151032805443, 0.01222642045468092, -0.010348636656999588, 0.02839408628642559, 0.026836100965738297, -0.027248533442616463, -0.013964228332042694, -0.005482794716954231, -0.0033392987679690123, 0.09208923578262329, 0.027761323377490044, 0.032770901918411255, -0.05211720988154411, -0.04932297393679619, -0.008285267278552055, 0.02305588871240616, 0.03132243454456329, -0.0029612586367875338, -0.03554346412420273, 0.037067774683237076, 0.015493813902139664, 0.040433142334222794, 0.022408971562981606, 0.0071208239533007145, 0.005649453029036522, 0.036843638867139816, -0.051800284534692764, -0.009976387023925781, -0.04562612622976303, -0.019208218902349472, -0.019515162333846092, -0.0072252643294632435, -0.050908517092466354, 0.0177350714802742, -0.007356231566518545, -0.044230081140995026, 0.020839739590883255, -0.05595916137099266, -0.05340161547064781, 0.04151754453778267, 0.027869373559951782, 0.012876185588538647, 0.01442316547036171, 0.015466910786926746, -0.031858544796705246, 0.04219352453947067, -0.012966969981789589, -0.011699823662638664, 0.0082222456112504, 0.03415324166417122, -0.004801152274012566, 0.0546586848795414, 0.03210345655679703, 0.030243687331676483, -0.015816252678632736, 0.04174919053912163, -0.05448198318481445, -0.03249448165297508, 0.000655713549349457, 0.04514307156205177, -0.00643535191193223, 0.07935335487127304, 0.01726176217198372, 0.02561730146408081, 0.04498506337404251, -0.006196279544383287, -0.013262588530778885, 0.03336741030216217, 0.009926664642989635, 0.0014406839618459344, -0.00957625824958086, -0.07214836776256561, 0.0592225156724453, -0.0805361270904541, -0.03667730838060379, -0.008252772502601147, 0.022826198488473892, 0.022239351645112038, 0.028959358111023903, 0.027269849553704262, -0.044740062206983566, 0.018441665917634964, -0.008236910216510296, -0.010371255688369274, -0.07771455496549606, -0.00798237044364214, -0.006741226185113192, -0.042900267988443375, 0.0063901012763381, 0.03564407676458359, -0.022358672693371773, 0.009641154669225216, -0.038132552057504654, -0.029820963740348816, 0.02037128433585167, -0.043349917978048325, 0.001977652544155717, -0.04516555368900299, -0.04264095053076744, -0.019207358360290527, -0.004341410007327795, 0.024059129878878593, 0.027665268629789352, -0.03637469559907913, 0.03744765371084213, -0.012227623723447323, -0.012728988192975521, 0.020833464339375496, 0.01934506557881832, 0.0386495515704155, -0.012064068578183651, 0.02521960437297821, -0.008181668817996979, -0.008177096024155617, -0.04014364257454872, -0.06144510582089424, -0.02840573899447918, -0.012739031575620174, -0.003929857164621353, -0.006498382892459631, 0.029464922845363617, 0.007004315033555031, -0.019050966948270798, -0.007786985021084547, -0.021435275673866272, 0.0047678640112280846, -0.029804149642586708, 0.02627340890467167, 0.10356316715478897, -0.029798835515975952, -0.017598235979676247, 0.016995081678032875, 0.022662831470370293, 0.015358811244368553, -0.006217302288860083, 0.0037664526607841253, 0.004700963851064444, -0.05543031170964241, 0.02099812775850296, -0.027984725311398506, 0.06737227737903595, 0.023530609905719757, 0.04109958931803703, 0.05687438324093819, -0.007764467038214207, 0.0031096460297703743, 0.0116593511775136, 0.012930257245898247, -0.06500555574893951, -0.019239796325564384, 0.004892424214631319, 0.01037310529500246, 0.012565335258841515, -0.04858686402440071, 0.014870691113173962, -0.04715703800320625, -0.027853872627019882, 0.02482932060956955, -0.013409494422376156, 0.008479282259941101, -0.03300086408853531, 0.015006765723228455, -0.03492583706974983, -0.03733700513839722, -0.10865657031536102, 0.04350394383072853, -0.0008563996525481343, -0.03315708041191101, -0.02272641472518444, -0.02555321715772152, 0.011749486438930035, 0.041505321860313416, -0.02160143479704857, -0.06866929680109024, -0.03575293347239494, 0.014665048569440842, 0.009788096882402897, -0.00974259153008461, -0.026739908382296562, 0.04439496994018555, 0.06433382630348206, -0.034361839294433594, 0.040885742753744125, -0.01621606945991516, 0.021634673699736595, 0.0006977964658290148, 0.026986243203282356, -0.07357486337423325, -0.010246748104691505, -0.0654623731970787, -0.03963838890194893, 0.0035447408445179462, 0.012936160899698734, 0.00615188991650939, 0.007857429794967175, 0.028604969382286072, 0.030658181756734848, 0.0332939513027668, -0.05698961019515991, -0.01950742118060589, 0.009791242890059948, 0.022961122915148735, -0.04404482617974281, 0.022625789046287537, 0.044132381677627563, 0.03629704937338829, 0.03300033137202263, 0.01857123151421547, -0.0033750543370842934, -0.008948163129389286, 0.011891097761690617, 0.038246750831604004, 0.06371308118104935, -0.04640154540538788, -0.02377297170460224, -0.015928255394101143, 0.008509025909006596, -0.02510003186762333, -0.001414948608726263, -0.0022494816221296787, 0.0059806834906339645, -0.019687842577695847, 0.04980405792593956, -0.028222983703017235, -0.0008701313054189086, 0.02501334622502327, -0.006109865382313728, -0.03009636141359806, 0.01638726331293583, -0.0368877649307251, -0.04041067138314247, -0.01648889295756817, 0.036990970373153687, 0.04364452883601189, 0.03677424043416977, -0.01573595218360424, -0.005437063053250313, 0.09528522938489914, 0.012754997238516808, 0.04559783637523651, -0.029842955991625786, 0.013606893830001354, 0.017721081152558327, -0.0273909755051136, -0.023254629224538803, -0.010217145085334778, 0.062162209302186966, -0.028216902166604996, -0.005727536976337433, -0.026754045858979225, 0.040692053735256195, 0.015321552753448486, -0.01796889491379261, 0.041360002011060715, 0.0850583091378212, 0.00413033552467823, 0.015192999504506588, 0.08315923810005188, -0.010324599221348763, 0.009439121931791306, -0.0381205752491951, 0.08152548968791962, -0.021626200526952744, 0.0009973773267120123, 0.012031866237521172, 0.03594530373811722, 0.03336550295352936, -0.002414704067632556, 0.029129918664693832, -0.0780605673789978, 0.04969855770468712, -0.013746162876486778, 0.03085397742688656, -0.021347491070628166, -0.027757886797189713, -0.004270133562386036, 0.028866812586784363, -0.054990578442811966, 0.04631027579307556, 0.02269374392926693, 0.01068925391882658, -0.07143044471740723, 0.02810806967318058, -0.006564992479979992, -0.005138345994055271, -0.11672534793615341, 0.0363832488656044, 0.10141628980636597, 0.017461320385336876, -0.024639422073960304, 0.013625525869429111, -0.04649002104997635, -0.05059712007641792, 0.03785396367311478, 0.019276494160294533, -0.019776474684476852, -0.06830228120088577, -0.030309900641441345, 0.0007273568771779537, 0.026795318350195885, -0.0012094323756173253, 0.016634171828627586, 0.09227614849805832, 0.011437118984758854, -0.04067588970065117, 0.03650030866265297, -0.06565912812948227, 0.013224052265286446, -0.020618682727217674, -0.05059494450688362, 0.004622363951057196, -0.007599018979817629, 0.007312138099223375, -0.00924644898623228, 0.024403272196650505, -0.044802069664001465, -0.00036988002830184996, 0.024736883118748665, -0.007405167445540428, 0.012605260126292706, -0.03579612821340561, -0.02750583365559578, 0.035950519144535065, -0.01648605987429619, 0.04393816366791725, -0.0009123509516939521, 0.0426192432641983, 0.009920521639287472, -0.023358715698122978, -0.01600378006696701, 0.029943926259875298, -0.0018444220768287778, -0.031231006607413292, 0.016986839473247528, 0.04463792219758034, -0.003453990910202265, 0.017561931163072586, 0.053407758474349976, -0.018058301880955696, 0.05956761911511421, -0.0034716918598860502, 0.03225799649953842, -0.0014875144697725773, -0.02159918285906315, 0.01170874573290348, -0.05714588239789009, -0.06952989846467972, -0.021018952131271362, -0.05434189736843109, -0.024130068719387054, 0.04250073805451393, -0.004024666268378496, 0.049675021320581436, -0.025423452258110046, 0.07058464735746384, -0.032077476382255554, -0.021580955013632774, -0.050140440464019775, -0.03143015876412392, -0.006847938522696495, -0.06684982031583786, -0.004162256605923176, -0.07367020845413208, -0.013004792854189873, 0.01831144653260708, -0.027025798335671425, 0.02773761749267578, -0.03346896544098854, 0.026757199317216873, -0.07366863638162613, 0.046730365604162216, -0.03773929178714752, 0.01821639947593212, -0.006535307038575411, -0.1093064546585083, 0.009022500365972519, -0.0011140316491946578, 0.007351039443165064, -0.05753263831138611, 0.037963539361953735, -0.0043569812551140785, 0.0012337450170889497, 0.027891555801033974, -0.02023971825838089, -0.011973442509770393, 0.030544433742761612, -0.01802418753504753, -0.02523610182106495, 0.07065693289041519, -0.05227408930659294, 0.045439500361680984, 0.06463288515806198, -0.04396364092826843, -0.017513584345579147, -0.020244114100933075, 0.006634002551436424, 0.025020012632012367, -0.02648690901696682, 0.023718560114502907, -0.07028146833181381, 0.027341194450855255, -0.01280573196709156, -0.0776793360710144, -0.038196008652448654, 0.04064688831567764 ]
<p>The exact solution representing a FLRW universe with $k&gt;0$ and dust (p=0), and $\Lambda=0$, is described by a cycloid. What is the exact solution for dust, in the presence of a positive cosmological constant $\Lambda&gt;0$? Could you give references?</p>
g9747
[ 0.03773333132266998, -0.034330643713474274, 0.0023278663866221905, -0.0651482418179512, 0.030356483533978462, 0.007435627747327089, -0.05415241792798042, -0.03307605907320976, -0.07123049348592758, -0.03893917053937912, -0.037263981997966766, -0.022873036563396454, 0.08466921746730804, 0.04973034933209419, 0.015560663305222988, 0.029614534229040146, -0.015766896307468414, 0.026187703013420105, 0.005445469170808792, -0.03289378806948662, -0.035100456327199936, -0.027641864493489265, -0.0004236582899466157, -0.026815062388777733, 0.04036441817879677, 0.006285838782787323, 0.010131548158824444, 0.06051064282655716, -0.03651367127895355, -0.10304002463817596, 0.017011333256959915, 0.00912881176918745, -0.025749238207936287, -0.020551975816488266, -0.037841372191905975, 0.0330888032913208, 0.008343393914401531, 0.029255244880914688, 0.013887234032154083, -0.030279770493507385, 0.030894285067915916, 0.0017979759722948074, 0.02936876378953457, 0.07664743065834045, 0.002738887444138527, 0.021463308483362198, -0.016730530187487602, 0.04686231166124344, 0.026492146775126457, -0.03233759105205536, -0.04554381221532822, 0.006729138549417257, 0.027519429102540016, -0.04292478784918785, 0.007416350767016411, 0.059699200093746185, 0.056007467210292816, -0.05194120109081268, 0.012695834040641785, 0.04770354926586151, -0.02180527150630951, -0.003260816913098097, 0.03799300640821457, -0.05706474557518959, 0.006312282290309668, 0.014988316223025322, 0.014772625640034676, -0.01657615229487419, -0.01052740029990673, -0.07289133965969086, 0.009920966811478138, 0.032356105744838715, 0.03313203155994415, -0.06401879340410233, -0.0287387166172266, 0.020068617537617683, -0.008644355461001396, 0.0487913079559803, 0.027119381353259087, -0.03440145403146744, -0.02799796499311924, 0.02748585119843483, -0.013958769850432873, 0.004008191172033548, -0.0007677154499106109, 0.017070163041353226, -0.018339287489652634, -0.02335054986178875, 0.013254977762699127, -0.07544714957475662, -0.002160129602998495, -0.024800829589366913, -0.0579555407166481, -0.05084121227264404, 0.047482963651418686, -0.00934293121099472, -0.026560112833976746, 0.06552819907665253, -0.061495669186115265, -0.04931364208459854, -0.00034468225203454494, 0.004987478256225586, 0.04032570496201515, 0.016874680295586586, -0.014910456724464893, -0.007853429764509201, 0.02870800718665123, 0.013722979463636875, 0.025848643854260445, -0.02351486124098301, -0.034983426332473755, 0.018327390775084496, -0.004675676580518484, -0.07295981794595718, -0.056482840329408646, -0.010992969386279583, 0.10164719820022583, 0.02976207807660103, 0.06695115566253662, 0.06039613485336304, -0.01454530656337738, 0.0035368630196899176, -0.034003209322690964, -0.010585259646177292, -0.0325169675052166, -0.039553429931402206, 0.012442166917026043, -0.02603904716670513, 0.04553653299808502, 0.0012162178754806519, 0.065699003636837, 0.006674677133560181, 0.02982151508331299, 0.02559570223093033, -0.04793332889676094, 0.0362117737531662, 0.007044249214231968, -0.013273356482386589, -0.01259972620755434, 0.025873830541968346, 0.003313775174319744, -0.036097556352615356, 0.020157085731625557, 0.017106354236602783, -0.04042784869670868, 0.00020391357247717679, -0.013479693792760372, 0.016299448907375336, -0.0012097300495952368, 0.007932745851576328, 0.028668733313679695, 0.08061676472425461, -0.049550849944353104, 0.006170818116515875, -0.026118172332644463, -0.007813254371285439, 0.024954209104180336, 0.03518366813659668, -0.007090367842465639, 0.03879740834236145, 0.051254138350486755, 0.012574954889714718, 0.006831207312643528, -0.0491386279463768, -0.003118316177278757, 0.025625210255384445, -0.05232976749539375, -0.002133464440703392, -0.054130736738443375, 0.023114098235964775, -0.016371700912714005, 0.011203899048268795, 0.01611367240548134, 0.013388806954026222, 0.03214586153626442, -0.0049402606673538685, 0.046458322554826736, 0.06356337666511536, -0.020842570811510086, -0.03167057782411575, 0.024605127051472664, -0.03788449987769127, 0.025349454954266548, 0.06152962148189545, -0.014391869306564331, -0.04627717286348343, 0.0020219727884978056, 0.0410824790596962, -0.013080545701086521, -0.04729144647717476, 0.015270460397005081, -0.021286137402057648, 0.0338548868894577, 0.05075874552130699, -0.022711852565407753, 0.02349056676030159, 0.013570965267717838, -0.03537272289395332, -0.013630981557071209, -0.03864910453557968, 0.0048913974314928055, 0.05224722996354103, 0.010133842006325722, 0.021166382357478142, 0.0101395882666111, 0.015254083089530468, 0.002720644697546959, -0.009100710041821003, 0.0076128640212118626, -0.007162655238062143, -0.008753078058362007, -0.014058376662433147, 0.01968272402882576, 0.06549328565597534, 0.03697934374213219, -0.034990523010492325, -0.014005989767611027, 0.055039942264556885, -0.014227520674467087, -0.0052034687250852585, -0.01609373651444912, -0.00280053005553782, 0.04576127603650093, -0.01187204010784626, 0.06420130282640457, 0.01173397246748209, 0.007121470756828785, 0.01684257760643959, 0.020720038563013077, 0.024381352588534355, -0.03369120508432388, -0.011013880372047424, -0.001551371649838984, -0.01848800852894783, 0.02949838526546955, 0.006636358331888914, 0.016638481989502907, 0.07795345038175583, -0.017829177901148796, 0.014105815440416336, -0.017644120380282402, 0.033702921122312546, -0.11129798740148544, 0.01659466326236725, -0.0319858081638813, -0.023168513551354408, 0.03550179302692413, -0.030140262097120285, -0.04180805757641792, 0.004379673395305872, 0.05397073179483414, -0.0016876875888556242, 0.0506841316819191, -0.010842349380254745, -0.03750764578580856, -0.054213643074035645, 0.028688905760645866, 0.026709597557783127, -0.049810513854026794, 0.011569742113351822, 0.06687361001968384, -0.05011536180973053, -0.023049259558320045, -0.053472377359867096, -0.008441906422376633, -0.006504671182483435, -0.05649556219577789, 0.03494242951273918, -0.02704494260251522, 0.010320941917598248, 0.007426734548062086, -0.0020962469279766083, -0.014009694568812847, 0.04922858998179436, -0.00015014158270787448, -0.021783292293548584, 0.07278110086917877, -0.028608381748199463, -0.010266655124723911, 0.010425482876598835, 0.06301949918270111, 0.02205568738281727, -0.06378369778394699, 0.021564066410064697, -0.026681222021579742, -0.03912045806646347, -0.040808435529470444, 0.01691068336367607, 0.03200122341513634, -0.012278870679438114, 0.0020103042479604483, 0.03979722037911415, -0.007739810273051262, 0.006590771488845348, -0.03194792568683624, 0.07266344130039215, 0.016636857762932777, 0.04834084212779999, 0.014667347073554993, -0.017139369621872902, 0.07003176957368851, -0.006334827281534672, -0.014209834858775139, -0.032001279294490814, -0.05995975807309151, 0.00033602133044041693, 0.0131436912342906, -0.021447917446494102, 0.018590066581964493, -0.03586914390325546, -0.06713399291038513, 0.053190141916275024, 0.010792133398354053, 0.03451351821422577, 0.010559252463281155, 0.07886745780706406, 0.018379785120487213, 0.009078064933419228, 0.00013251493510324508, -0.004093840252608061, 0.007969862781465054, -0.006020142696797848, 0.020480001345276833, 0.008366490714251995, -0.03797008469700813, -0.03192084655165672, -0.027785109356045723, -0.015628879889845848, -0.05548686534166336, 0.027574991807341576, -0.026109380647540092, -0.004319692030549049, 0.05392499268054962, -0.03738149255514145, -0.016530709341168404, -0.031140534207224846, -0.08178701251745224, -0.03182290121912956, 0.010553115047514439, 0.011046755127608776, -0.05191580951213837, 0.04185577109456062, -0.048833638429641724, -0.015013722702860832, -0.023844266310334206, 0.06401660293340683, 0.03240654245018959, -0.01822209730744362, 0.05457739531993866, -0.007552738301455975, 0.030013393610715866, 0.016768869012594223, -0.004268364980816841, -0.03290397301316261, 0.0005658078007400036, 0.032844655215740204, 0.0008920305990613997, 0.038601022213697433, 0.014565970748662949, 0.025908999145030975, 0.041611749678850174, -0.04237518459558487, -0.007615011651068926, 0.0013862017076462507, 0.05828971043229103, -0.0076680863276124, 0.00011518092651385814, 0.004699489567428827, -0.005024544429033995, 0.050367165356874466, 0.0052107819356024265, 0.02103731967508793, 0.04525544494390488, 0.009868217632174492, 0.01891935057938099, -0.0001919642963912338, -0.046666767448186874, -0.008605818264186382, -0.050912316888570786, 0.013387301005423069, 0.012861963361501694, -0.0044543007388710976, 0.026892194524407387, 0.055513180792331696, -0.00005957271787337959, 0.052928898483514786, -0.07800396531820297, -0.03632436320185661, -0.03705675154924393, -0.034063246101140976, 0.08862718194723129, 0.008803888224065304, 0.0002205716009484604, 0.03856759890913963, 0.009980130940675735, -0.024442290887236595, 0.015884609892964363, -0.059816624969244, -0.03716660663485527, -0.008983212523162365, 0.09042148292064667, 0.032738327980041504, 0.025030050426721573, -0.025007667019963264, -0.02014307677745819, 0.0009372337954118848, -0.02040717750787735, -0.04968017339706421, 0.03169500455260277, -0.0015692493179813027, -0.004713448695838451, 0.07615417242050171, 0.0006208492559380829, -0.020103568211197853, 0.05736256763339043, -0.01760486513376236, -0.0015531807439401746, 0.01999342441558838, 0.038291893899440765, -0.014993974007666111, 0.009463028982281685, 0.03498680517077446, -0.026677602902054787, -0.009300494566559792, 0.0562409982085228, -0.05525781214237213, 0.025608956813812256, 0.05790232494473457, -0.01982675865292549, -0.027892161160707474, -0.006343852262943983, 0.026213519275188446, 0.00007710649515502155, 0.062490057200193405, -0.01138718519359827, 0.03713162615895271, -0.05018213018774986, -0.0032111885957419872, -0.04183132201433182, -0.0025353918317705393, 0.04661744832992554, -0.0025029322132468224, 0.011987426318228245, -0.05592979118227959, -0.03873391076922417, 0.08620240539312363, 0.0030356054194271564, -0.0693126693367958, -0.002022539032623172, -0.02435576170682907, 0.003951522056013346, 0.032981909811496735, 0.013005698099732399, 0.00871713925153017, -0.010893790051341057, -0.04670272022485733, 0.01742732897400856, -0.00393171701580286, 0.05131207033991814, 0.053074564784765244, 0.002265150425955653, 0.029185205698013306, 0.08127152919769287, 0.006404570769518614, 0.07336202263832092, -0.010968653485178947, -0.04944029450416565, 0.03345197066664696, -0.060809023678302765, 0.010856833308935165, 0.019505348056554794, 0.06335221976041794, -0.03044661320745945, -0.02163369581103325, -0.07288660109043121, 0.024284090846776962, -0.06265504658222198, -0.047474972903728485, 0.004036698956042528, 0.005474896170198917, 0.010020696558058262, -0.061046503484249115, 0.010821494273841381, -0.006594071630388498, -0.0032587398309260607, 0.053512897342443466, 0.0016979518113657832, 0.03474422171711922, 0.025414835661649704, -0.018842874094843864, 0.04231922701001167, 0.005465433467179537, 0.05796142295002937, -0.015332648530602455, -0.007659262511879206, 0.02526923269033432, 0.0031512288842350245, -0.06409140676259995, 0.0569881871342659, 0.029874077066779137, 0.008555056527256966, 0.009926144964993, 0.04121283069252968, 0.002058705547824502, 0.011588869616389275, 0.04276129603385925, -0.00608484260737896, 0.03753580525517464, -0.007230804767459631, 0.000280825566733256, -0.012911801226437092, -0.02258029766380787, 0.056354641914367676, 0.07967999577522278, -0.032916754484176636, -0.03201659396290779, -0.039275869727134705, -0.006739409640431404, -0.050995830446481705, 0.014666799455881119, -0.033916208893060684, 0.08885536342859268, -0.021571053192019463, -0.04056968167424202, 0.020267542451620102, -0.008306934498250484, -0.008397124707698822, 0.011337244883179665, -0.03808289021253586, -0.012523532845079899, 0.047962602227926254, 0.01891181617975235, 0.004720892757177353, -0.000994927017018199, 0.043984830379486084, -0.03599290922284126, 0.04029875621199608, 0.047647103667259216, -0.01586739905178547, 0.016280468553304672, -0.016450462862849236, -0.015570511110126972, 0.0322498194873333, -0.011832017451524734, -0.037127017974853516, -0.032900821417570114, -0.028994178399443626, 0.07468994706869125, 0.052519384771585464, -0.07620994746685028, -0.018517646938562393, 0.013085123151540756, 0.033118996769189835, 0.05059468373656273, -0.05023830011487007, 0.039183977991342545, 0.013289415277540684, -0.003187800757586956, -0.05838426202535629, -0.03471226245164871, 0.000037369067285908386, 0.010675806552171707, -0.013435224071145058, 0.007626563310623169, -0.0564662329852581, -0.034612998366355896, 0.0023432928137481213, -0.06367401778697968, 0.033730048686265945, -0.0007504334207624197, -0.01942473277449608, 0.03875143080949783, -0.010926127433776855, 0.007509589660912752, 0.030096691101789474, -0.014281299896538258, -0.03515426814556122, -0.040176838636398315, -0.001951466198079288, 0.004393871873617172, 0.011991548351943493, 0.013711846433579922, 0.057529617100954056, -0.07055234909057617, 0.0013098267372697592, -0.02582930400967598, -0.043980784714221954, -0.021795012056827545, 0.05954404175281525, 0.008008298464119434, 0.008346622809767723, -0.01202694233506918, -0.025152381509542465, -0.020334770902991295, 0.0402667261660099, 0.08811674267053604, -0.006321155000478029, -0.0548953078687191, -0.052154894918203354, -0.042880211025476456, -0.013727483339607716, -0.008764088153839111, 0.08726642280817032, -0.018680864945054054, 0.02142823114991188, -0.07990526407957077, -0.09312929213047028, 0.063143789768219, 0.04143530875444412, 0.021053818985819817, 0.06173761188983917, 0.020036743953824043, -0.038119278848171234, -0.036216095089912415, 0.0038949805311858654, -0.012522772885859013, 0.05189037322998047, 0.0467446930706501, -0.024101069197058678, -0.07815688103437424, -0.02651197835803032, -0.0630272924900055, -0.013132276944816113, -0.0009240368381142616, -0.005102537572383881, 0.007422668393701315, -0.0018401432316750288, 0.05007138475775719, 0.04582596942782402, 0.027765562757849693, 0.03448227047920227, 0.044214099645614624, -0.025521831586956978, -0.007894545793533325, -0.04372899979352951, 0.006241498049348593, -0.098917156457901, 0.018716994673013687, 0.01904875412583351, 0.021643497049808502, -0.014532064087688923, 0.03272203356027603, 0.033472940325737, -0.02621927112340927, 0.00652265502139926, 0.05552796646952629, 0.05118882283568382, -0.05403799191117287, -0.007213934324681759, -0.00706841005012393, -0.007282855920493603, -0.030508626252412796, -0.001946629723533988, 0.035516805946826935, -0.02510387822985649, 0.0031563497614115477, 0.021864820271730423, 0.007164181675761938, -0.03951377049088478, -0.008110163733363152, 0.007727786898612976, -0.06262028217315674, -0.026142388582229614, -0.00011520620319060981, -0.03454914316534996, 0.048072073608636856, 0.04395061358809471, -0.014084666036069393, 0.0564395971596241, -0.04765594005584717, 0.0018799153622239828, -0.011803952977061272, -0.058798663318157196, -0.007242875639349222, -0.04814063757658005, 0.013601862825453281, -0.07372984290122986, 0.04690234363079071, -0.007734918035566807, -0.029977085068821907, -0.04826090484857559, -0.013633662834763527, -0.0161935705691576, -0.0740497037768364, 0.00824031699448824, 0.04469689726829529, -0.0043906476348638535, 0.004162669647485018, -0.020435823127627373, -0.05492505058646202, -0.008645590394735336, 0.05675126239657402, 0.005006803665310144, -0.08504611998796463, 0.001269653090275824, -0.00040148512925952673, -0.024583466351032257, -0.0089986277744174, 0.047633908689022064, -0.007209667935967445, 0.009975899010896683, -0.06194760277867317, -0.05182959511876106, 0.011234138160943985, -0.010156216099858284, -0.07731268554925919, -0.06890424340963364, -0.010897542349994183, -0.003320332383736968, 0.001093256170861423, 0.022066956385970116, 0.01859094947576523, -0.021394912153482437, 0.007832495495676994, 0.007141095586121082, 0.011906304396688938, -0.04116496443748474, 0.0009291658643633127, 0.04662492871284485, 0.04436294734477997, -0.047202806919813156, 0.038348644971847534, 0.017712503671646118, -0.030510079115629196, -0.010776134207844734, 0.0012678313069045544, -0.07021907716989517, -0.060162633657455444, 0.017606331035494804, -0.0023034783080220222, 0.007578027900308371, -0.00904479157179594, -0.003561420598998666, 0.04389328509569168, -0.060524482280015945, 0.010438124649226665, -0.046394240111112595, 0.005425671115517616, -0.0011909689055755734, 0.03157126158475876, -0.06687041372060776, -0.06813415139913559, -0.0024368364829570055, 0.028809240087866783, 0.03859248384833336, -0.017491912469267845, -0.019836533814668655, 0.003987906966358423, 0.0685185119509697, -0.05174899846315384, -0.027618002146482468, 0.0015887584304437041, 0.01886950246989727, -0.04588668793439865, -0.027274323627352715, -0.043848779052495956, 0.035382479429244995, -0.031040320172905922, -0.03140636533498764, -0.037914860993623734, -0.059829238802194595, 0.002458085771650076, -0.020072078332304955, 0.06940149515867233, 0.035985253751277924, 0.011017869226634502, 0.02672981470823288, 0.006766374688595533 ]
<p>What, fundamentally, is an electromagnetic wave? As far as I know, all wave phenomena are derivations of an oscillating processes, e.g. particles vibrating in a medium. I can't imagine a wave process which couldn't be explained as moving particles: sound wave - movement of gas molecules, waves on the water - movement of water molecules, earthquake - movement of ground particles (and finally molecules), even phonons - vibrational movement of crystal lattice. Phonons are virtual but the atoms arranged in lattice are real.</p> <p>I tend to think that the reason has to do with the restless nature of the photons along with the uncertainty principle - the impossibility to localize a primary chunk of matter (with momentum) - when we catch the wave (stop the process) the frequency is gone. But again, it looks like it is a particle and we just can't observe it with our methods.</p> <p>So, what is the electromagnetic wave? How can it move vibrating across the vacuum? How can we physically interpret phenomenon of electromagnetic waves?</p> <p>&nbsp;</p> <p><strong><em>Update</em></strong></p> <p>The concept of <em>field</em> is itself very complex phenomenon to understand its physical meaning by our "everyday" mind. The field looks like a math tool to describe and predict nature events. But its physical representation is unclear. I can't think of light as some 3-D helix shaped pulsing of continuous substance :) The world is quantized and it's obvious that the <code>sine</code>-shape like objects cannot be elementary in reality.</p>
g9748
[ 0.04026801139116287, -0.0029787831008434296, -0.002301557455211878, 0.025011636316776276, 0.059495583176612854, 0.035601645708084106, 0.01745150052011013, 0.059064846485853195, 0.050334081053733826, -0.078427754342556, 0.018842598423361778, -0.0018064855830743909, 0.03688349202275276, 0.012970461510121822, -0.0558641292154789, -0.03059987910091877, 0.02171802520751953, 0.008430561982095242, 0.028851792216300964, 0.0019145655678585172, 0.02779824659228325, 0.03354000300168991, 0.040175653994083405, -0.05990052968263626, -0.09287341684103012, 0.010813123546540737, 0.02809746190905571, -0.05532614514231682, 0.07106932997703552, -0.03526056557893753, 0.016699358820915222, -0.04271559417247772, 0.0844162181019783, -0.027635103091597557, 0.019985683262348175, -0.023896077647805214, -0.011399215087294579, 0.04255668446421623, 0.012498150579631329, 0.04535149037837982, 0.00958435982465744, -0.007205131463706493, -0.015348440036177635, -0.004927788395434618, 0.003428663592785597, -0.001642884686589241, -0.018205387517809868, -0.03206632286310196, -0.031887270510196686, 0.012899888679385185, -0.0214870423078537, -0.02537105418741703, 0.09694290906190872, 0.0726563110947609, 0.05938521772623062, 0.04257876053452492, 0.03697813302278519, 0.03614170104265213, 0.0893217921257019, -0.04259946569800377, 0.04418705403804779, 0.020213814452290535, 0.052949994802474976, 0.044891826808452606, 0.04174075648188591, -0.04564080014824867, -0.08938739448785782, -0.004857963882386684, 0.02760784886777401, -0.004045756999403238, 0.0310300774872303, -0.07783415913581848, -0.07680977135896683, -0.00431888597086072, -0.000058042431192006916, 0.014667386189103127, 0.0036269586998969316, 0.0007333947578445077, 0.0172190610319376, -0.04157126694917679, 0.020219625905156136, -0.007675004657357931, 0.012223922647535801, -0.011368649080395699, 0.0332564041018486, -0.05460406467318535, -0.020510653033852577, -0.011581710539758205, 0.027819788083434105, -0.01604887843132019, 0.03042149916291237, -0.02661343850195408, 0.06842099130153656, -0.01401434000581503, -0.048097457736730576, -0.06943994760513306, -0.041579365730285645, 0.04858005419373512, 0.0011157122207805514, 0.00700076948851347, -0.007534733507782221, -0.04895893111824989, 0.003757988102734089, -0.023600058630108833, 0.027241475880146027, 0.017142990604043007, -0.047656260430812836, -0.0013355074916034937, 0.03427412733435631, 0.04894539713859558, -0.0247502364218235, 0.0007883236976340413, -0.014760120771825314, -0.02007850632071495, -0.0312839150428772, -0.01639709249138832, 0.029381727799773216, 0.040101297199726105, 0.03202757239341736, 0.06281044334173203, 0.04561105743050575, 0.04083985835313797, 0.04629199951887131, 0.020896829664707184, -0.016376161947846413, -0.010815548710525036, -0.001777969067916274, -0.04653236269950867, 0.0011165864998474717, -0.004289485048502684, 0.04473350942134857, 0.06408946961164474, -0.0702444389462471, -0.004106968175619841, 0.005249257665127516, 0.04688101261854172, 0.03165432810783386, -0.030206501483917236, 0.031014002859592438, -0.030050288885831833, 0.038951575756073, -0.034857191145420074, 0.012492937035858631, -0.07882892340421677, -0.06051608920097351, 0.03503498435020447, 0.0035170766059309244, -0.038793135434389114, 0.044986166059970856, -0.014342027716338634, 0.015966646373271942, 0.08228064328432083, -0.004443129058927298, -0.03151235356926918, 0.02298501506447792, -0.014095946215093136, 0.03523804992437363, 0.03982645645737648, -0.04257015883922577, 0.03232300281524658, 0.07882238179445267, 0.02880481816828251, -0.03209853917360306, -0.0017315372824668884, -0.034787867218256, -0.030688447877764702, -0.013779046945273876, -0.04823518171906471, 0.02151603437960148, -0.010495118796825409, -0.0156959630548954, -0.05123107135295868, -0.001078608212992549, 0.07623016089200974, -0.036881353706121445, 0.07115846872329712, 0.059084463864564896, -0.030063200742006302, -0.004053198266774416, -0.03806736692786217, -0.04772929847240448, -0.03988119587302208, -0.012252602726221085, -0.021082784980535507, -0.014635931700468063, 0.017128048464655876, -0.011708407662808895, -0.017357459291815758, -0.02347475104033947, -0.025082845240831375, -0.04323394224047661, -0.08713333308696747, 0.028010711073875427, 0.037391871213912964, 0.004307248163968325, -0.017072752118110657, -0.03980500251054764, 0.003716724691912532, -0.013217620551586151, 0.013840239495038986, 0.03043963946402073, 0.05285029113292694, 0.038292933255434036, 0.01780380867421627, 0.03873341903090477, 0.011813291348516941, 0.020244082435965538, -0.016362842172384262, -0.03919828683137894, 0.05071114003658295, 0.062359556555747986, -0.014653319492936134, 0.04322286322712898, 0.0184475127607584, -0.024537641555070877, -0.01577702723443508, -0.030190814286470413, -0.003713202429935336, 0.008210237137973309, 0.0061826808378100395, -0.020659593865275383, -0.03624459356069565, 0.03274300694465637, -0.012001432478427887, -0.00014949619071558118, 0.008809557184576988, -0.05262055993080139, -0.008340156637132168, 0.03881668671965599, 0.0015796009683981538, -0.04372166842222214, 0.03872267156839371, 0.015279392711818218, 0.020972352474927902, 0.06594038009643555, 0.04713723808526993, -0.07418114691972733, -0.003128904616460204, 0.021380513906478882, -0.006632961332798004, 0.0073298378847539425, -0.004630499053746462, 0.025384705513715744, -0.06056023761630058, 0.010465328581631184, -0.09397900104522705, 0.03172546997666359, -0.0244157575070858, -0.00257034576497972, -0.00973349530249834, 0.09006960690021515, -0.08773278445005417, 0.012978876009583473, -0.013343572616577148, 0.0026304968632757664, -0.038780029863119125, 0.004340494982898235, 0.09552793949842453, -0.020655248314142227, 0.022969648241996765, 0.019762270152568817, -0.016429224982857704, 0.015101023949682713, 0.056348130106925964, -0.01245856937021017, -0.036757513880729675, -0.020729809999465942, 0.0712822824716568, -0.03559480980038643, -0.08584867417812347, -0.05703815072774887, 0.02818230353295803, -0.03928123041987419, -0.05504470691084862, -0.005020117852836847, 0.004203176125884056, 0.02840818651020527, 0.0038653872907161713, 0.002990595530718565, -0.01954428292810917, -0.010583717375993729, 0.01833038032054901, -0.020367620512843132, -0.046421874314546585, 0.000454518391052261, -0.08664165437221527, -0.012809276580810547, -0.025727348402142525, 0.0017599908169358969, -0.02134789153933525, 0.028621073812246323, -0.012041042558848858, 0.0004071422736160457, -0.0015779337845742702, -0.1011633425951004, 0.05300300195813179, -0.0027007507160305977, -0.04660329967737198, -0.008159851655364037, 0.006270849145948887, 0.0466243252158165, 0.013692387379705906, -0.0006347423186525702, -0.015619455836713314, 0.04772166535258293, 0.017612973228096962, 0.00016288418555632234, -0.0020966429729014635, 0.008288044482469559, 0.019787883386015892, 0.03301050886511803, 0.05267608165740967, -0.016108518466353416, 0.02556813322007656, -0.04473881423473358, 0.027634307742118835, -0.017859825864434242, 0.013421093113720417, 0.021544823423027992, -0.006746808532625437, -0.051652874797582626, -0.05937274172902107, 0.004936122335493565, -0.03203883394598961, 0.052546508610248566, -0.01278634462505579, -0.029390722513198853, -0.00794359389692545, -0.07192160189151764, -0.039956580847501755, -0.03492145240306854, -0.048727892339229584, -0.06838459521532059, -0.0323147252202034, -0.010477717965841293, -0.06431173533201218, -0.048157304525375366, 0.007359365466982126, 0.06548313796520233, -0.06171102449297905, 0.04824606329202652, -0.016980819404125214, -0.012876548804342747, -0.007516917306929827, -0.028674790635704994, 0.03415858373045921, -0.03202236816287041, -0.05939709395170212, 0.008836038410663605, -0.01652020961046219, 0.015252270735800266, 0.051785361021757126, -0.006635705009102821, -0.004333558492362499, -0.039059899747371674, 0.02095271833240986, 0.07378578931093216, 0.008941840380430222, 0.04313863441348076, -0.0628022775053978, -0.07406416535377502, 0.003264802508056164, 0.0371687188744545, -0.030122268944978714, -0.03216378390789032, 0.003306205850094557, 0.026133351027965546, 0.02088988572359085, 0.03664831444621086, 0.007584347855299711, -0.011668385937809944, -0.04422575235366821, -0.021711671724915504, 0.009832426905632019, 0.024195285513997078, -0.015286251902580261, 0.01305019948631525, 0.00363329891115427, -0.056426040828228, 0.024637704715132713, 0.015536499209702015, 0.04854041710495949, 0.052926402539014816, -0.01880396157503128, -0.010165584273636341, 0.022485624998807907, -0.053190767765045166, 0.028740448877215385, -0.025638654828071594, 0.0007887250976637006, 0.03480580076575279, 0.0053665535524487495, -0.02744971215724945, -0.015499903820455074, 0.023516230285167694, -0.059584204107522964, 0.01804869994521141, -0.011679342947900295, -0.009162254631519318, 0.018827959895133972, 0.05894482508301735, -0.023052772507071495, 0.009352401830255985, 0.002911700401455164, 0.00038826369564048946, 0.018291963264346123, -0.0001223439903696999, -0.04825681075453758, -0.007338215596973896, -0.04540543258190155, -0.006758387200534344, 0.013811273500323296, 0.00898558646440506, -0.07467558234930038, 0.001027695252560079, 0.052777454257011414, 0.023897627368569374, -0.029496103525161743, 0.006362102460116148, 0.056206122040748596, 0.026209691539406776, 0.07005531340837479, 0.030526114627718925, 0.003949541132897139, -0.022894734516739845, 0.061165034770965576, 0.050348006188869476, -0.03147493302822113, -0.020983465015888214, -0.03590933978557587, -0.004695830401033163, 0.02408783696591854, 0.01640830561518669, 0.04287675768136978, -0.047303345054388046, 0.025554733350872993, -0.03523290902376175, 0.045974001288414, 0.04652421548962593, 0.02425048127770424, 0.07545197755098343, 0.00027306791162118316, 0.007435671519488096, 0.014815504662692547, -0.04166054725646973, 0.032341547310352325, -0.01358047965914011, -0.009258544072508812, -0.006623782217502594, -0.02972567453980446, -0.061219096183776855, 0.048000045120716095, -0.05612679570913315, -0.014645527116954327, 0.010710478760302067, 0.0015378267271444201, -0.014050362631678581, -0.014068708755075932, -0.025382457301020622, 0.020669547840952873, -0.056603994220495224, 0.019266141578555107, 0.02469845488667488, 0.051745038479566574, 0.03198123723268509, -0.01572752743959427, -0.03949756920337677, -0.05294591560959816, -0.06331207603216171, 0.00007731630466878414, -0.00026903144316747785, 0.025827914476394653, 0.029558949172496796, 0.005634764675050974, -0.0016772616654634476, 0.03544054925441742, -0.029955625534057617, -0.010769857093691826, 0.0023195373360067606, -0.05619832128286362, -0.014212381094694138, 0.012145590037107468, 0.024508042261004448, 0.013808428309857845, -0.04222962632775307, -0.009487347677350044, -0.005928358528763056, 0.08108573406934738, -0.08990459144115448, -0.03138285130262375, 0.02397029474377632, 0.0031056138686835766, 0.0067815291695296764, -0.03982188552618027, 0.006048059090971947, -0.07328025996685028, 0.0154196722432971, 0.019387656822800636, -0.03200765699148178, -0.03052699938416481, -0.03724334388971329, -0.0099332295358181, -0.03594553470611572, -0.008731206879019737, -0.009788895025849342, -0.029104072600603104, -0.013052433729171753, -0.03334859013557434, -0.026796462014317513, 0.034913912415504456, 0.016819002106785774, -0.003775962395593524, -0.08893759548664093, 0.017963189631700516, 0.039210278540849686, -0.014853735454380512, -0.0008446003776043653, 0.02824924886226654, 0.004626840353012085, 0.033175475895404816, -0.03921343386173248, -0.005269377958029509, 0.09088461846113205, -0.0546409972012043, 0.02299792505800724, 0.008232418447732925, -0.0633971318602562, 0.005189842078834772, 0.05432102456688881, 0.06088022515177727, -0.00888479221612215, 0.01907164976000786, 0.024182453751564026, -0.0037921576295048, -0.010495703667402267, 0.004113853443413973, 0.04257629066705704, -0.03518786281347275, 0.007463775109499693, 0.027220534160733223, -0.032983697950839996, 0.0018096017884090543, 0.0003627077676355839, 0.045166391879320145, 0.038217559456825256, 0.025626791641116142, 0.03916267678141594, 0.02956313081085682, 0.09075762331485748, 0.004385973326861858, -0.018485674634575844, -0.0015642482321709394, 0.016015155240893364, -0.023300912231206894, -0.0028367042541503906, 0.05082916095852852, -0.022485261783003807, -0.053955014795064926, -0.03236252814531326, -0.04386549070477486, 0.00301514845341444, 0.04626508429646492, -0.034229863435029984, -0.045686252415180206, 0.019308410584926605, -0.020453769713640213, 0.006654901895672083, -0.01913505606353283, 0.03621089085936546, 0.061109088361263275, -0.0453781932592392, 0.05338846519589424, 0.023523153737187386, 0.008641707710921764, -0.021116020157933235, -0.014976054430007935, 0.023104099556803703, -0.001307034632191062, -0.0828285738825798, -0.0020263330079615116, 0.03452999144792557, 0.04890666529536247, 0.060235489159822464, -0.010146033950150013, -0.016079029068350792, 0.023807795718312263, -0.052465666085481644, 0.004518451634794474, 0.04971398785710335, 0.026647523045539856, -0.018352393060922623, 0.039451614022254944, -0.057422757148742676, -0.013086168095469475, -0.008955606259405613, -0.06557872891426086, 0.017258744686841965, 0.02440507337450981, 0.00008888485172064975, 0.032376982271671295, 0.002505292184650898, 0.016479982063174248, -0.04468812420964241, 0.010732779279351234, 0.03535007685422897, 0.01538652554154396, -0.030056672170758247, -0.03934234753251076, -0.02407696843147278, -0.01754540205001831, -0.005106115248054266, 0.007342431228607893, -0.00911613181233406, -0.013196887448430061, -0.032128363847732544, -0.05929457023739815, -0.004143101163208485, 0.02360297180712223, 0.017697246745228767, -0.0182296484708786, -0.04339544475078583, 0.004557785578072071, 0.01619773544371128, 0.003141425782814622, 0.02121090143918991, -0.01939409039914608, -0.04184167832136154, 0.013615484349429607, 0.030438076704740524, -0.000531796074938029, -0.006253338884562254, -0.007336887996643782, 0.03402804583311081, 0.05753963068127632, -0.0038357072044163942, -0.011741268448531628, -0.01385149173438549, 0.005294784903526306, 0.05421987548470497, -0.04984226077795029, -0.001983237685635686, 0.044365886598825455, 0.06804035604000092, 0.006157144904136658, -0.08611253648996353, -0.0015446749748662114, 0.03385346755385399, -0.018038520589470863, -0.017071349546313286, 0.020477257668972015, 0.0006613603327423334, -0.06622087210416794, -0.004146171733736992, 0.001336457789875567, -0.011541031301021576, 0.038599345833063126, 0.0005532762734219432, -0.01878984645009041, -0.01870221458375454, -0.06504467129707336, -0.05539180338382721, -0.03787679970264435, -0.002985259285196662, -0.020507441833615303, 0.02743927575647831, 0.020066997036337852, -0.002800936112180352, -0.03836948424577713, 0.004017405677586794, -0.04825841262936592, 0.016194352880120277, -0.004960909951478243, 0.026578404009342194, -0.010532679967582226, 0.0240506362169981, 0.00004789505692315288, -0.038056813180446625, 0.028425196185708046, 0.00934402085840702, -0.013222225941717625, -0.02316266857087612, 0.07005144655704498, 0.027714448049664497, -0.003672936698421836, 0.043763428926467896, 0.06652107834815979, -0.07602119445800781, 0.059509798884391785, -0.06409454345703125, -0.03926532715559006, 0.021477358415722847, 0.020228665322065353, -0.03293783962726593, -0.04313887655735016, 0.011163616552948952, 0.00715492432937026, 0.013395068235695362, 0.00851405505090952, 0.042875390499830246, -0.016365157440304756, -0.029479356482625008, 0.010926350019872189, 0.004352045711129904, -0.00915823969990015, 0.0035189036279916763, -0.024210195988416672, 0.042795319110155106, -0.028306465595960617, -0.031915146857500076, 0.020051002502441406, 0.0014216710114851594, 0.040974847972393036, 0.0015180823393166065, -0.0013511406723409891, 0.027012402191758156, 0.07158833742141724, 0.027435265481472015, 0.017239689826965332, -0.03250075876712799, -0.00043256767094135284, -0.0545729361474514, 0.013943290337920189, -0.029865363612771034, -0.031145945191383362, 0.0029437339399009943, 0.012397348880767822, 0.033183686435222626, -0.03733859583735466, 0.020411979407072067, -0.06438840925693512, -0.016205545514822006, 0.023876769468188286, 0.01872674934566021, -0.009271780028939247, -0.014069422148168087, 0.08068295568227768, -0.0237885732203722, 0.02396046184003353, -0.0039149438962340355, -0.03196636214852333, 0.12092263996601105, 0.011766208335757256, -0.008863706141710281, -0.006681044586002827, -0.005203265231102705, -0.020809251815080643, -0.025619234889745712, 0.04137204587459564, 0.02717522159218788, -0.020598197355866432, -0.00668049743399024, 0.064576156437397, -0.017755873501300812, 0.06109838932752609, 0.04102163389325142, -0.07989683747291565, -0.004298962187021971, 0.03907717391848564, 0.05626637488603592, -0.03483292832970619, -0.012779337354004383, 0.011499040760099888, 0.0020790507551282644, -0.013838573358952999, -0.05429735407233238, -0.05342099070549011, -0.02753247506916523, 0.023195616900920868 ]
<p>Does anyone know where I can find the analytical expressions of the scattering amplitude in second Born Approximation for the Yukawa potential? I need it for the both cases of the method of partial waves and the Born series as defined to solve the Lippmann-Schwinger equation. In general the second term is unimportant being the Born Approximation very good in high-energy physics but it is not my case as I consider collisions in semiconductors. I would not like to waste time to calculate it as I presume that probably someone else has already done. </p>
g9749
[ 0.04113813117146492, -0.0020684462506324053, 0.024251844733953476, -0.019278978928923607, 0.001849172287620604, -0.001813361537642777, 0.008253410458564758, 0.02037675678730011, 0.0010854708962142467, -0.032780714333057404, -0.053297705948352814, -0.018209772184491158, 0.025831252336502075, 0.07702529430389404, 0.002143052639439702, -0.03654804825782776, 0.0289983619004488, -0.00557921826839447, 0.021953847259283066, -0.0011107050813734531, -0.031862590461969376, 0.03047630377113819, -0.02870168909430504, -0.004483634140342474, 0.010248488746583462, -0.004106192849576473, 0.0501093752682209, 0.011781804263591766, -0.014055551961064339, -0.025271493941545486, -0.0027540491428226233, -0.0003959238529205322, 0.08528333157300949, 0.006505026947706938, -0.0032046146225184202, 0.02681013010442257, 0.020365789532661438, -0.00811996590346098, -0.02494995854794979, -0.005150767508894205, 0.020062178373336792, -0.07576429843902588, -0.0037109050899744034, 0.026027020066976547, 0.003519446821883321, -0.04718649014830589, -0.06992392987012863, 0.020012712106108665, 0.0029484019614756107, 0.000983623438514769, 0.001981966430321336, -0.029223093762993813, 0.04746837168931961, 0.00497342087328434, 0.033663712441921234, 0.008063563145697117, 0.004394774790853262, -0.024747628718614578, 0.04827112704515457, 0.010385134257376194, 0.039654266089200974, 0.009185440838336945, 0.0278264582157135, -0.013294734060764313, 0.03800439462065697, -0.07214534282684326, 0.006674237083643675, -0.016728168353438377, -0.04226496443152428, -0.035850606858730316, 0.04320494085550308, -0.02656773291528225, -0.07823607325553894, 0.04042791947722435, 0.017854809761047363, -0.020751668140292168, -0.021862268447875977, 0.03614792227745056, 0.013446547091007233, 0.01601969078183174, -0.05192844942212105, -0.07502733170986176, -0.020594388246536255, 0.06416667252779007, 0.0016533462330698967, -0.03465593233704567, 0.05421198904514313, 0.000979468459263444, -0.035487376153469086, -0.0645676702260971, -0.07310663908720016, 0.0669318437576294, 0.004529419355094433, -0.10220612585544586, 0.06661533564329147, 0.011758256703615189, -0.005851081106811762, 0.03601791709661484, 0.027766307815909386, -0.013569268397986889, 0.011823221109807491, 0.10480046272277832, 0.0022263487335294485, 0.026641689240932465, -0.0035373219288885593, 0.006385479122400284, 0.024449992924928665, -0.025839675217866898, -0.04351130500435829, -0.002694120164960623, -0.029597440734505653, -0.03387029469013214, 0.003550176043063402, -0.005344952456653118, -0.008364243432879448, -0.01836055889725685, -0.02775617688894272, -0.048913147300481796, 0.03473374992609024, 0.037298522889614105, -0.06083190068602562, 0.008886636234819889, 0.015252781100571156, 0.006953500676900148, 0.024233762174844742, 0.06689773499965668, -0.050580233335494995, -0.00044006327516399324, 0.009318203665316105, 0.00477630877867341, 0.08392350375652313, -0.050376154482364655, 0.03574277088046074, 0.026411792263388634, 0.03488451987504959, -0.03265281021595001, 0.03394623100757599, 0.006925263442099094, -0.005956091918051243, -0.02548667974770069, 0.030386418104171753, -0.016884421929717064, 0.011443492956459522, 0.02420547418296337, 0.006272685714066029, 0.044353123754262924, 0.023945486173033714, -0.014645637013018131, 0.008826124481856823, 0.017191607505083084, 0.008182698860764503, 0.01807444356381893, 0.03542661666870117, -0.04802577570080757, 0.0019282413413748145, -0.004469670355319977, 0.0779523029923439, 0.021583056077361107, 0.008546959608793259, 0.00783213134855032, 0.012646125629544258, -0.030413979664444923, -0.015663260594010353, 0.017000960186123848, 0.02938557043671608, 0.03468415513634682, 0.003704942762851715, -0.06378807127475739, 0.00967464316636324, -0.05134125053882599, 0.026162585243582726, 0.028915954753756523, 0.025561777874827385, 0.013083437457680702, 0.022121313959360123, 0.033022694289684296, 0.016861651092767715, -0.031999412924051285, -0.04119659960269928, 0.03790505230426788, -0.02216627076268196, -0.04573090001940727, -0.037119537591934204, 0.0220872163772583, 0.025934435427188873, -0.05298057571053505, 0.0037353304214775562, 0.0343797542154789, 0.056855298578739166, -0.024687891826033592, -0.026692405343055725, -0.016864027827978134, 0.03447180241346359, -0.027450282126665115, -0.0073898909613490105, 0.06728033721446991, 0.09372550249099731, 0.00583169050514698, -0.009117526933550835, 0.010309903882443905, 0.02464292012155056, 0.0738481730222702, -0.016905302181839943, -0.037187863141298294, 0.0720217376947403, 0.03426261618733406, -0.01418114360421896, 0.013676545582711697, -0.011511494405567646, -0.011960107833147049, -0.11609270423650742, -0.04489077255129814, 0.054907821118831635, 0.03006097301840782, 0.0012879885034635663, -0.00703679071739316, -0.02353464812040329, 0.023308925330638885, -0.0125371553003788, 0.04919562488794327, -0.023637346923351288, -0.0599905289709568, -0.027132632210850716, 0.022947173565626144, -0.019768863916397095, 0.06784095615148544, 0.04969233646988869, 0.030948564410209656, -0.007005492225289345, 0.04742700979113579, -0.030705714598298073, -0.03632892295718193, -0.09629138559103012, -0.01098538376390934, -0.027179690077900887, -0.011232439428567886, -0.08387285470962524, -0.04576772078871727, 0.014586302451789379, 0.032306768000125885, -0.01416479330509901, 0.0483151450753212, 0.035103291273117065, 0.09445760399103165, 0.011358139105141163, -0.02873668074607849, 0.09394856542348862, 0.01830356754362583, -0.0031958927866071463, -0.016224315389990807, 0.02213016338646412, -0.03791243955492973, -0.0251028910279274, -0.03229406476020813, -0.0006679411744698882, 0.0046441578306257725, -0.0006066811620257795, 0.01785118505358696, -0.006229600869119167, -0.1041511744260788, 0.032879848033189774, 0.002344507724046707, -0.06259793788194656, -0.01803942210972309, -0.022264109924435616, 0.026524389162659645, -0.0256324615329504, 0.00033635980798862875, -0.012342577800154686, 0.0011524608125910163, -0.039312511682510376, 0.06146346777677536, -0.003176386235281825, 0.028164973482489586, -0.007144976872950792, -0.04360131546854973, -0.01081575732678175, -0.06338980048894882, 0.015980806201696396, 0.0077014523558318615, -0.03256557509303093, -0.0006312430487014353, 0.03351467475295067, 0.026117684319615364, 0.025527672842144966, -0.03207548335194588, 0.0591692179441452, 0.02080671116709709, 0.015454929322004318, 0.022348033264279366, 0.022872736677527428, -0.016298403963446617, -0.03280239552259445, 0.03118394874036312, -0.07246953248977661, 0.07282704859972, 0.013418677262961864, -0.044377975165843964, -0.030516093596816063, 0.004333191551268101, 0.0715535581111908, -0.005245770327746868, 0.011689303442835808, -0.019360670819878578, 0.06340248137712479, -0.009810973890125751, 0.017534229904413223, -0.006832186598330736, 0.06480783969163895, 0.019875576719641685, -0.017348656430840492, 0.03484700247645378, 0.024095164611935616, -0.03181179240345955, 0.021462447941303253, -0.038814544677734375, 0.03888596221804619, -0.02698495239019394, -0.012295955792069435, -0.06505477428436279, -0.012968060560524464, -0.05590084195137024, 0.04663589596748352, 0.05537181347608566, 0.027697701007127762, -0.0022689669858664274, -0.03145282715559006, 0.009225195273756981, -0.004243699833750725, -0.03959847241640091, 0.005879607517272234, -0.03637037053704262, 0.016601668670773506, 0.025208214297890663, -0.025509262457489967, -0.05503489822149277, 0.006043027155101299, -0.013383322395384312, -0.007916823029518127, 0.038528356701135635, -0.04346116632223129, -0.03732830286026001, -0.07070963084697723, 0.0002154371904907748, -0.025768795982003212, -0.02858075499534607, 0.002669342327862978, 0.037330932915210724, -0.025258868932724, -0.013466781005263329, 0.016000661998987198, 0.028299951925873756, 0.007657838054001331, 0.06319856643676758, -0.04122157022356987, 0.011378027498722076, 0.005065872333943844, -0.008273255079984665, 0.05737713724374771, 0.01192487869411707, 0.013260861858725548, -0.005575199611485004, 0.008695962838828564, 0.026860801503062248, 0.02398630790412426, -0.0914585143327713, -0.03612135350704193, 0.030865008011460304, -0.008797341026365757, 0.008202538825571537, 0.011515543796122074, -0.018204983323812485, 0.05916087329387665, -0.011328162625432014, -0.06858465820550919, -0.06526856124401093, -0.008798325434327126, 0.02445416897535324, -0.007671764586120844, 0.06832390278577805, 0.011334107257425785, 0.015603579580783844, 0.048538923263549805, 0.02605244144797325, 0.023284712806344032, -0.04412844032049179, -0.04395364597439766, 0.02282402664422989, -0.0207598228007555, -0.011555309407413006, 0.00983351469039917, -0.04093999043107033, -0.03201502561569214, -0.016124943271279335, 0.011510142125189304, -0.019848736003041267, 0.00763329491019249, -0.006791246589273214, 0.00930788740515709, 0.011918977834284306, -0.021421341225504875, 0.012307480908930302, 0.07934584468603134, -0.027024349197745323, 0.06561394780874252, 0.001314750756137073, -0.005524436477571726, -0.00350866187363863, -0.037656519562006, 0.02022320032119751, -0.03747004270553589, 0.019254159182310104, -0.029583577066659927, 0.013106320053339005, -0.015973826870322227, -0.0602332167327404, 0.0724884644150734, -0.04995366558432579, 0.025371475145220757, 0.05622505396604538, 0.0026912069879472256, -0.014791841618716717, -0.0319366529583931, -0.01573197916150093, -0.011038247495889664, 0.04473065212368965, 0.02741888538002968, -0.023945461958646774, 0.03233025595545769, -0.020473835989832878, -0.04226375371217728, 0.040833353996276855, -0.0076830885373055935, 0.06633017212152481, -0.04294707626104355, 0.008602428250014782, -0.00845196470618248, -0.0170945692807436, 0.057272814214229584, -0.04637395218014717, 0.033340178430080414, 0.005374053493142128, -0.04596659913659096, -0.005599761847406626, 0.010759024880826473, 0.06137147918343544, -0.0739942267537117, -0.04597916454076767, 0.020725689828395844, -0.05614933371543884, -0.0187861155718565, 0.044968970119953156, 0.031222371384501457, -0.059580154716968536, -0.029571320861577988, 0.017615361139178276, -0.05705733969807625, 0.012626074254512787, 0.034936632961034775, 0.04323180392384529, 0.004295354709029198, -0.023798586800694466, -0.0066672726534307, -0.06412192434072495, 0.06436864286661148, -0.05275433883070946, -0.007876710034906864, 0.02401607856154442, -0.0557471439242363, -0.0034763338044285774, -0.03920171782374382, -0.06299428641796112, -0.010525248944759369, -0.05196601524949074, -0.02252192795276642, -0.04934906214475632, -0.03448783978819847, -0.003229808295145631, -0.06532341986894608, -0.0030668938998132944, 0.0032408274710178375, -0.03176567330956459, -0.0026347802486270666, 0.04444224759936333, -0.017499234527349472, 0.024991663172841072, 0.012716492637991905, 0.008032253012061119, 0.03362913802266121, 0.002064808737486601, 0.06395559012889862, 0.0020308492239564657, -0.017521288245916367, -0.037275027483701706, 0.05042123794555664, 0.04630053788423538, -0.0026707740034908056, -0.03824174776673317, -0.04134763777256012, 0.03357262536883354, -0.026067819446325302, -0.059608228504657745, -0.04828554019331932, -0.002202439121901989, -0.026463694870471954, 0.04928610473871231, 0.05588844418525696, -0.060760896652936935, -0.0332285575568676, -0.024565622210502625, 0.0361078716814518, -0.005580054130405188, 0.028091302141547203, 0.043049756437540054, -0.00026295011048205197, -0.0007662870339117944, -0.008758144453167915, -0.02134113386273384, -0.07204373180866241, -0.010210131295025349, 0.06577453017234802, 0.010809820145368576, -0.01222192868590355, 0.0015201980713754892, -0.0050622159615159035, -0.013234714977443218, 0.008390962146222591, 0.008014297112822533, 0.016567332670092583, -0.027164028957486153, 0.003537191078066826, 0.06606300920248032, -0.038870345801115036, -0.05269009247422218, 0.05216775834560394, -0.010428173467516899, -0.044228725135326385, 0.0036854876670986414, -0.060225408524274826, -0.0097015630453825, -0.041361816227436066, 0.03091832995414734, 0.02134665846824646, 0.0129157155752182, -0.014896005392074585, 0.03806634992361069, 0.008108891546726227, 0.03631732240319252, 0.030490249395370483, 0.008660253137350082, -0.060662928968667984, 0.0062637049704790115, -0.018736181780695915, 0.014699963852763176, 0.026564443483948708, -0.033078793436288834, -0.005591699853539467, -0.000491444778162986, -0.010521089658141136, 0.022351227700710297, 0.03144923225045204, -0.007201128173619509, 0.0008764950907789171, -0.014460121281445026, 0.03498900681734085, 0.0009031853987835348, -0.015960516408085823, 0.02393397130072117, 0.05021757259964943, -0.043523479253053665, 0.005324364639818668, 0.031943429261446, -0.04805776849389076, -0.020525135099887848, 0.02038954198360443, 0.04919865354895592, 0.01948733441531658, -0.01547393761575222, -0.002491079503670335, 0.030604198575019836, -0.02702602557837963, 0.03502356633543968, 0.025023046880960464, -0.023948773741722107, -0.017214002087712288, -0.0203744824975729, 0.0001311305386479944, -0.0049176826141774654, 0.028749411925673485, 0.06821873039007187, -0.01925983652472496, -0.03228108584880829, -0.00047740733134560287, -0.0697285458445549, 0.024628575891256332, -0.023810844868421555, 0.018257053568959236, -0.011047204956412315, -0.04546228051185608, 0.009372112341225147, 0.040849339216947556, -0.02054731361567974, -0.06578315794467926, 0.05441465973854065, 0.02344895526766777, 0.024784475564956665, 0.011663484387099743, 0.01078076008707285, -0.05305967479944229, 0.016976764425635338, -0.03406766802072525, 0.018051819875836372, -0.005916343070566654, 0.024425741285085678, -0.01858508586883545, -0.044567205011844635, 0.010628749616444111, 0.020633142441511154, -0.010403634048998356, -0.08097510039806366, 0.024761660024523735, -0.034282613545656204, -0.0009325245628133416, -0.014327551238238811, -0.017350774258375168, -0.01817188411951065, -0.001627718098461628, 0.012257402762770653, -0.002568032592535019, -0.012232724577188492, 0.06781456619501114, -0.022372286766767502, 0.031377989798784256, 0.008597559295594692, -0.023816067725419998, -0.009409870021045208, -0.008923071436583996, -0.013684132136404514, -0.06412597745656967, -0.020848259329795837, -0.07441557943820953, 0.08447105437517166, -0.009798496030271053, -0.021673183888196945, -0.024152804166078568, 0.04558149725198746, -0.01508309505879879, -0.019824640825390816, -0.10159271210432053, -0.01593586802482605, 0.050849661231040955, 0.0041938298381865025, -0.06605150550603867, 0.03958342596888542, -0.03512513265013695, -0.05595526844263077, 0.07125642895698547, 0.0068581001833081245, -0.010934018529951572, -0.021343285217881203, -0.017728140577673912, -0.020047388970851898, 0.05964680761098862, -0.01297437958419323, -0.017717478796839714, 0.024678897112607956, 0.038255687803030014, -0.10690758377313614, 0.013380326330661774, 0.08550107479095459, -0.025597644969820976, -0.029702462255954742, -0.015541044063866138, -0.005037244409322739, 0.007211712654680014, -0.0008098825928755105, 0.023769257590174675, -0.007679975125938654, -0.007922526448965073, -0.006190937012434006, 0.009643887169659138, -0.014413019642233849, -0.0075545418076217175, -0.02538713812828064, 0.0224333293735981, 0.06989132612943649, 0.03038398176431656, 0.0210605189204216, -0.015285934321582317, 0.02012406289577484, 0.03025742992758751, 0.07867419719696045, -0.03029332123696804, -0.032547757029533386, 0.0016214147908613086, 0.024847785010933876, -0.04363882914185524, 0.05406326428055763, 0.015099667012691498, 0.01663532666862011, -0.0025558380875736475, -0.01595775969326496, 0.0017010055016726255, -0.029620110988616943, -0.0502648800611496, -0.06176543980836868, 0.042507465928792953, -0.05350479111075401, -0.0177102480083704, -0.05165708065032959, 0.0687328428030014, 0.011931928806006908, 0.07002263516187668, 0.03553842380642891, -0.005704856012016535, 0.08948391675949097, 0.019761599600315094, 0.04847826063632965, -0.023749154061079025, 0.007481749635189772, 0.02722165361046791, -0.029768597334623337, 0.06142211705446243, -0.011749235913157463, 0.017381006851792336, -0.03121078573167324, -0.041068125516176224, -0.005446822848170996, 0.01379038393497467, 0.0056611220352351665, 0.004271012265235186, -0.0032963831909000874, -0.02330046333372593, 0.03522467985749245, -0.01155062485486269, 0.028418827801942825, -0.023313773795962334, 0.007423726376146078, 0.07907325029373169, -0.03400520980358124, 0.010894720442593098, -0.11836128681898117, 0.054782118648290634, -0.007307887077331543, 0.011421560309827328, -0.0538342259824276, -0.02781018055975437, -0.059383511543273926, 0.027448004111647606, -0.01985623687505722, -0.0091189444065094, 0.03998509421944618, 0.005143493879586458, 0.06934502720832825, 0.05940456688404083, -0.037244804203510284, 0.019282743334770203, 0.02190251648426056, -0.023291677236557007, -0.017183108255267143, 0.02219395339488983, 0.011701870709657669, -0.011042395606637001, 0.04410974681377411, 0.04184752702713013, -0.05428898707032204, -0.015420273877680302, -0.04466461017727852 ]
<p>The <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lennard-Jones_potential">Lennard-Jones potential</a> has the form:</p> <p>$$U(r) = 4\epsilon\left[ \left(\frac{\sigma}{r}\right)^{12} - \left(\frac{\sigma}{r}\right)^{6} \right]$$</p> <p>The (attractive) $r^{-6}$ term describes the dispersion force (<em>attraction at long range</em>). Why is the power $-6$ rather than something else?</p> <p>I think that it has to do with dipole-dipole interactions, but I am having difficulty working out the physics. Can you please help me? </p> <p>I know that, at a distance $z$ away, the on-axis electric potential due to a dipole at the origin and aligned on the z-axis is given by:</p> <p>$$V = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0} \frac{p}{z^2}$$</p> <p>where $p$ is the (magnitude of the) dipole moment.</p> <p>But if there is an atom nearby, the dipole will induce a dipole on the atom. The induced dipole will in turn induce a dipole on the first dipole. Is it possible to classically derive the $r^{-6}$ dependence of the dispersion force? Thanks for your time.</p>
g9750
[ -0.023124756291508675, 0.05127552151679993, -0.024553950875997543, -0.017651384696364403, -0.0032200010027736425, 0.008522800169885159, 0.01029442623257637, -0.005846773274242878, -0.01760658249258995, -0.04343391954898834, -0.062403518706560135, 0.024593887850642204, -0.0066495719365775585, -0.012879078276455402, 0.07032106816768646, 0.03728654980659485, 0.058146119117736816, 0.007142175454646349, 0.04999668896198273, 0.025324968621134758, -0.05371742323040962, -0.04687635228037834, -0.05146004259586334, -0.10495729744434357, -0.03369520977139473, -0.019685441628098488, 0.03665167838335037, -0.002381383441388607, -0.04698455333709717, -0.023814190179109573, 0.02948783151805401, 0.022461535409092903, 0.07029294967651367, -0.00898731965571642, 0.00031126601970754564, -0.03700996935367584, -0.0171011071652174, -0.006407558917999268, 0.03966113552451134, 0.031920548528432846, -0.06016482785344124, 0.030990172177553177, 0.016453057527542114, 0.016833042725920677, -0.0157184898853302, -0.0043878438882529736, -0.015040765516459942, -0.014674780890345573, 0.026270519942045212, 0.03948749974370003, -0.037416525185108185, 0.022682249546051025, 0.007080887444317341, -0.02235710248351097, 0.0051039825193583965, 0.022340722382068634, -0.006796273868530989, 0.04708211123943329, 0.005587429273873568, 0.050178833305835724, 0.03727525472640991, 0.0059380074962973595, -0.010645225644111633, 0.007522190921008587, 0.0346621572971344, -0.06481044739484787, -0.05115639418363571, 0.023684512823820114, -0.007572099566459656, -0.04575173556804657, -0.03817855194211006, -0.0710524171590805, -0.04862174391746521, -0.025224946439266205, -0.05056429281830788, 0.04059496149420738, 0.009671209380030632, 0.008786921389400959, 0.016380609944462776, -0.03438671678304672, -0.02181374281644821, -0.03407704457640648, 0.0675177052617073, 0.020343387499451637, 0.07780580967664719, -0.028699839487671852, -0.03334095701575279, 0.018010497093200684, -0.024853160604834557, -0.04365234449505806, 0.02866830863058567, 0.024535836651921272, -0.03281935304403305, -0.042666755616664886, -0.030586523935198784, -0.04909471794962883, 0.0317208506166935, 0.020872026681900024, -0.009713667444884777, -0.04752373322844505, -0.017993008717894554, 0.016231359913945198, 0.01143715437501669, 0.001806928077712655, -0.0597962848842144, -0.03466422110795975, -0.008377098478376865, 0.020909041166305542, 0.014909107238054276, 0.00886054988950491, 0.001163586275652051, -0.0012233403977006674, 0.01144420262426138, 0.01328343152999878, -0.03715367615222931, -0.020000305026769638, 0.06969230622053146, -0.06029854342341423, 0.0045928917825222015, 0.04502982273697853, -0.001247804262675345, 0.05713583156466484, 0.012943681329488754, 0.0060310098342597485, -0.005289140157401562, -0.030255476012825966, 0.025333194062113762, 0.039759352803230286, 0.03796694427728653, -0.006715479306876659, 0.058143798261880875, -0.0005884102429263294, -0.013204437680542469, -0.004009043797850609, 0.002317543141543865, 0.015814177691936493, 0.0008417504141107202, -0.024428218603134155, -0.057557493448257446, 0.023843029513955116, -0.03315727785229683, -0.023397602140903473, 0.03960733860731125, -0.021931316703557968, -0.04172324016690254, 0.053665291517972946, -0.04483405500650406, -0.05046183988451958, 0.0553065650165081, -0.011746174655854702, 0.006932785734534264, 0.016912320628762245, 0.004120946396142244, -0.03909957408905029, -0.018725242465734482, 0.0025691601913422346, 0.005385460332036018, -0.04394874721765518, 0.03472822904586792, 0.0394764207303524, 0.04863078147172928, 0.016808684915304184, -0.01716449484229088, 0.05246249958872795, -0.02756366692483425, 0.005586201790720224, 0.06524723023176193, -0.04185343161225319, -0.006415239535272121, 0.0068291788920760155, -0.037583090364933014, 0.003216272220015526, -0.002788526238873601, 0.018177159130573273, 0.006694509647786617, 0.00027071297517977655, -0.010457990691065788, -0.0260627418756485, 0.03887229040265083, 0.03311273083090782, -0.01266784779727459, -0.03346827253699303, -0.017263345420360565, 0.01290495228022337, 0.0018141245236620307, -0.014257957227528095, -0.013352888636291027, 0.043968092650175095, 0.007169860415160656, 0.0008703017956577241, -0.029771283268928528, 0.005444332025945187, -0.013241083361208439, -0.003037838963791728, -0.04216212406754494, -0.0202178955078125, 0.028802989050745964, -0.13735122978687286, 0.018288251012563705, 0.025786830112338066, -0.03112868219614029, 0.008244088850915432, 0.07514556497335434, 0.0027808782178908587, 0.01598668284714222, -0.036467570811510086, -0.026751123368740082, 0.04199177771806717, 0.035412922501564026, -0.01650812104344368, -0.03166501596570015, -0.045295704156160355, 0.0012326622381806374, -0.04606543108820915, 0.015772035345435143, -0.06457912176847458, -0.040289029479026794, 0.04682937264442444, -0.054035406559705734, 0.08633150905370712, -0.01184743084013462, 0.008977826684713364, 0.020210914313793182, 0.044392526149749756, -0.08269052952528, -0.03380531072616577, 0.0025809507351368666, 0.0018397996900603175, -0.021391747519373894, 0.006035123486071825, -0.05812348797917366, 0.010640127584338188, 0.0267364252358675, 0.028024232015013695, 0.017692413181066513, 0.02835286408662796, -0.011948644183576107, -0.040032580494880676, -0.0010355819249525666, -0.04535392299294472, -0.012127891182899475, -0.07441737502813339, -0.06059500202536583, 0.06955437362194061, -0.008862683549523354, 0.004939919337630272, 0.04566045105457306, 0.02139236591756344, -0.0006137628224678338, 0.029128126800060272, 0.07689254730939865, -0.023495938628911972, -0.017988871783018112, -0.026585232466459274, -0.011680223979055882, 0.006683298386633396, -0.06661660224199295, 0.0640256255865097, -0.06878405064344406, -0.044878039509058, -0.03831929713487625, 0.010792464017868042, 0.02434990182518959, -0.00059988081920892, -0.030727744102478027, 0.07965037226676941, -0.034090280532836914, -0.007196696475148201, -0.023467697203159332, 0.02094372548162937, -0.03193860501050949, 0.09221792966127396, 0.03098517842590809, 0.016775261610746384, 0.03457573801279068, -0.02302708476781845, -0.01044452004134655, -0.0008427813299931586, 0.05706747993826866, 0.0348343551158905, -0.02899540401995182, 0.005943432450294495, -0.04732311889529228, 0.0017556790262460709, 0.018713708966970444, -0.01470437552779913, 0.00949975848197937, 0.031238524243235588, 0.026723304763436317, -0.0519801564514637, -0.039582863450050354, -0.02290935628116131, 0.013649355620145798, -0.05116301402449608, -0.013648934662342072, -0.02460739016532898, 0.014747780747711658, -0.04995967820286751, -0.01672401651740074, 0.059108488261699677, 0.07198997586965561, -0.05171611160039902, 0.013703925535082817, 0.05510859191417694, 0.04680054262280464, 0.016229039058089256, -0.04927777871489525, -0.033068589866161346, -0.03534397482872009, -0.031586114317178726, -0.03288711607456207, 0.044023871421813965, -0.004444540478289127, 0.011819968931376934, -0.00686877965927124, 0.00048553055967204273, 0.03552120923995972, 0.028565380722284317, 0.013782242313027382, -0.05126277357339859, 0.003396350657567382, -0.040465474128723145, -0.034469664096832275, 0.02532476931810379, 0.007514054886996746, 0.027763288468122482, -0.05371342599391937, 0.017818927764892578, -0.003080891678109765, 0.004548218101263046, 0.04611345753073692, -0.023064840584993362, 0.04701726883649826, -0.05773521587252617, -0.10358249396085739, -0.038421664386987686, 0.0026822476647794247, 0.02974490262567997, -0.001780264195986092, 0.04913567751646042, -0.0012876552063971758, -0.01508784294128418, -0.07718102633953094, 0.010282771661877632, 0.033657729625701904, 0.07851304858922958, -0.015779685229063034, 0.005060694180428982, 0.04896073788404465, 0.0393422394990921, -0.028596181422472, -0.020449750125408173, 0.04985353723168373, -0.0006286437273956835, 0.009992653504014015, -0.013952360488474369, -0.043514687567949295, -0.0022951639257371426, 0.00800435058772564, 0.02897793799638748, -0.012396841309964657, 0.02676090970635414, 0.00850268080830574, -0.028933295980095863, 0.013494350016117096, -0.030911728739738464, -0.046156901866197586, 0.025410640984773636, 0.03555633872747421, -0.00263194483704865, 0.008479157462716103, -0.005756536964327097, 0.00019347836496308446, -0.04447741433978081, 0.007810328155755997, 0.003243613289669156, -0.01771724596619606, -0.020851267501711845, -0.03773947060108185, 0.031295474618673325, -0.0037636554334312677, 0.05554857477545738, -0.016833918169140816, 0.1066274642944336, 0.03601229563355446, 0.017436373978853226, -0.04145963862538338, 0.00866332184523344, -0.024993019178509712, 0.02018669620156288, -0.035657692700624466, -0.06271646171808243, -0.02538999542593956, 0.005058157257735729, 0.004040856380015612, -0.013960056938230991, 0.053720809519290924, 0.009175173006951809, -0.013636551797389984, 0.026131898164749146, 0.010868924669921398, 0.05373584106564522, 0.021828949451446533, -0.03312643989920616, -0.0003298558294773102, 0.00920542050153017, 0.025394367054104805, -0.000991133856587112, 0.024491678923368454, -0.028912566602230072, 0.0019271299242973328, 0.061913393437862396, 0.02112644910812378, -0.050916094332933426, -0.02284165844321251, 0.017086857929825783, 0.044671669602394104, 0.011318697594106197, 0.033762384206056595, 0.02032964862883091, 0.033677633851766586, -0.0005251112161204219, 0.0437876358628273, -0.03338684141635895, -0.00006951187242520973, -0.003056168556213379, 0.0473194345831871, -0.016041835770010948, 0.009093012660741806, 0.012352187186479568, -0.04992156848311424, 0.045069389045238495, -0.039503827691078186, -0.033483829349279404, -0.04781292751431465, 0.0043583218939602375, -0.034611206501722336, 0.03927764296531677, 0.05394506826996803, 0.09260240942239761, 0.06629464030265808, 0.030012570321559906, 0.07608089596033096, 0.010422920808196068, 0.03346488997340202, 0.02384594827890396, -0.08032423257827759, -0.0441792830824852, 0.02866242453455925, -0.04830760881304741, -0.030598456040024757, -0.03674275428056717, -0.0023322475608438253, -0.06048813834786415, 0.012657882645726204, 0.0360141322016716, -0.025162246078252792, 0.02454511821269989, 0.03794628754258156, 0.012524796649813652, -0.02305460162460804, -0.025122571736574173, -0.07042771577835083, 0.006413853727281094, 0.02751140296459198, 0.02277478761970997, 0.02149907872080803, -0.0006428665365092456, -0.049454182386398315, -0.0349855050444603, 0.008369989693164825, 0.03332390636205673, 0.020788663998246193, -0.007182450033724308, 0.01331915520131588, 0.021858984604477882, -0.022815663367509842, 0.01841718889772892, 0.023076564073562622, -0.045771338045597076, 0.0016358487773686647, -0.017239274457097054, 0.03916734829545021, -0.0020699119195342064, -0.03569268435239792, -0.03862955421209335, 0.02278543822467327, 0.0018966321367770433, -0.0357108972966671, 0.012875148095190525, 0.04871288314461708, 0.024275803938508034, -0.02091367542743683, -0.05805014446377754, 0.007414395920932293, 0.01713169366121292, 0.022054430097341537, 0.043488308787345886, 0.018359212204813957, 0.04083379730582237, -0.004419985692948103, 0.029871627688407898, -0.06046660244464874, 0.011863432824611664, -0.021573344245553017, 0.049900609999895096, 0.12544512748718262, -0.019468065351247787, 0.02350517362356186, 0.007500277832150459, -0.04405654966831207, 0.058971207588911057, 0.038039084523916245, 0.026773473247885704, -0.055679500102996826, -0.01875348947942257, -0.05369710549712181, 0.08341104537248611, -0.02553863264620304, 0.005718463100492954, 0.04059074446558952, -0.02799513004720211, 0.004464093595743179, -0.05701041221618652, -0.011090830899775028, -0.014270725660026073, -0.04326755926012993, 0.014970806427299976, 0.013516250997781754, -0.021041885018348694, -0.007542935665696859, 0.03577128052711487, 0.03416915982961655, 0.012065998278558254, 0.040766842663288116, -0.03565927967429161, 0.07408000528812408, -0.025645745918154716, -0.032267726957798004, 0.022428853437304497, 0.07897348701953888, -0.06502632796764374, -0.0023109165485948324, 0.030711278319358826, -0.023791544139385223, -0.02664589136838913, 0.016590137034654617, -0.010334689170122147, 0.022213516756892204, 0.018827803432941437, -0.003093720180913806, 0.01048376876860857, -0.026522859930992126, 0.027252953499555588, -0.010274394415318966, -0.05923815444111824, 0.056714169681072235, -0.0005134224193170667, -0.0016581987729296088, -0.0233516376465559, 0.020474746823310852, -0.014847846701741219, -0.024392826482653618, -0.026054631918668747, 0.022260311990976334, -0.027882713824510574, -0.017945826053619385, -0.045408062636852264, 0.02845826931297779, 0.023845771327614784, 0.029051760211586952, 0.011696454137563705, -0.01175900362432003, 0.016197634860873222, 0.04888811707496643, 0.07383565604686737, 0.033980779349803925, -0.02998390421271324, 0.014737600460648537, 0.048897236585617065, -0.004163186531513929, -0.009378012269735336, -0.017552858218550682, -0.018478935584425926, -0.04267589747905731, 0.04020341858267784, -0.06237713620066643, -0.06254193186759949, 0.05984865874052048, -0.04854410141706467, 0.005804205778986216, -0.03752264380455017, 0.00840107910335064, -0.034034427255392075, -0.047483958303928375, 0.02695053443312645, -0.022175483405590057, -0.011709732934832573, 0.003544148523360491, 0.019221602007746696, 0.07159168273210526, -0.006865596864372492, 0.027955295518040657, 0.015219380147755146, 0.00007667005411349237, -0.03669317811727524, 0.02697194367647171, -0.05629324913024902, -0.022296156734228134, -0.0019730825442820787, 0.033236064016819, 0.012750431895256042, -0.012489130720496178, -0.05635681375861168, 0.015377018600702286, -0.044937148690223694, 0.019106749445199966, 0.046006184071302414, -0.0029305636417120695, 0.0023375307209789753, -0.002350850962102413, 0.0031178570352494717, -0.008805370889604092, -0.053378984332084656, 0.0012497763382270932, 0.01194683276116848, -0.054112356156110764, 0.046500466763973236, 0.03859006240963936, 0.016802970319986343, 0.03515893220901489, -0.021586783230304718, -0.07892753183841705, 0.06911859661340714, -0.016011612489819527, 0.011655322276055813, -0.022672956809401512, -0.015542730689048767, 0.047619495540857315, 0.029000723734498024, -0.021031374111771584, 0.010992898605763912, 0.01994919590651989, 0.0029375306330621243, 0.00263034924864769, -0.042694225907325745, 0.04531951621174812, 0.07474686205387115, -0.00427031796425581, 0.02245202474296093, 0.018196962773799896, -0.04590390622615814, 0.018427113071084023, 0.02836417779326439, -0.004855730105191469, -0.05400487035512924, 0.002775767585262656, 0.024428315460681915, 0.02221990004181862, -0.055211134254932404, -0.0038441820070147514, -0.00742628937587142, -0.03838447108864784, 0.0048262388445436954, -0.048984527587890625, 0.06177552789449692, 0.03780384361743927, -0.053596824407577515, -0.02453671395778656, -0.060092877596616745, -0.021428029984235764, -0.05716110020875931, -0.009450865909457207, -0.041468508541584015, -0.014248844236135483, 0.06488500535488129, -0.006734633352607489, -0.006189071107655764, -0.0017259911401197314, 0.0021769071463495493, -0.038557231426239014, 0.04969675838947296, -0.01018535252660513, -0.01909318007528782, -0.04067825898528099, 0.03214729204773903, -0.0031176558695733547, -0.037668876349925995, -0.02313181944191456, -0.036679722368717194, -0.00144749425817281, 0.027701858431100845, -0.005312496796250343, 0.003024469595402479, -0.025488778948783875, -0.04837463051080704, -0.0000717640868970193, 0.01929847151041031, -0.01108354702591896, 0.08025620877742767, 0.031013313680887222, -0.03846713528037071, 0.010665779002010822, -0.011148313991725445, 0.06449299305677414, -0.04903315380215645, -0.037127912044525146, 0.008631770499050617, -0.030333641916513443, -0.0100595373660326, 0.024665920063853264, -0.03322310000658035, 0.029062660411000252, -0.022527750581502914, 0.077887162566185, 0.06522711366415024, 0.007695434615015984, 0.05765910819172859, -0.035028960555791855, 0.04847283288836479, 0.03471284732222557, 0.011303050443530083, 0.05621352046728134, -0.01407549623399973, -0.07480031251907349, -0.018255652859807014, -0.038121942430734634, -0.05999906733632088, 0.008822638541460037, -0.008630363270640373, -0.043559763580560684, -0.02228931523859501, -0.06824566423892975, 0.017983872443437576, -0.029015695676207542, -0.014415205456316471, 0.020088952034711838, 0.04133552685379982, 0.04804260656237602, 0.038765087723731995, 0.0135877700522542, -0.06453518569469452, 0.06063586473464966, -0.006190578918904066, 0.006183764431625605, -0.03722366318106651, -0.011639939621090889, 0.06106242537498474, 0.05485832318663597, 0.0322924368083477, -0.03731432929635048, -0.011533191427588463, -0.039363306015729904, -0.015330199152231216, 0.07866720855236053, -0.06303510814905167, -0.03699653595685959, 0.09898307919502258, 0.028619682416319847, 0.002077404409646988, -0.04022187367081642, -0.03241720050573349, -0.01940091885626316, 0.07234837114810944, 0.016089409589767456, 0.01150416024029255, -0.07946674525737762, 0.004822795744985342 ]
<p>Once an object reaches terminal velocity in free fall, is there a point in time when the object actually starts slowing down due to resistance, or does it stay constant?</p>
g9751
[ 0.07272088527679443, 0.01670129969716072, 0.019930021837353706, -0.03748355433344841, 0.04070436581969261, 0.03068983182311058, 0.05248133838176727, 0.005234948359429836, -0.053953804075717926, -0.03619898483157158, -0.06873737275600433, -0.019746044650673866, 0.008907461538910866, -0.019144844263792038, 0.03769977018237114, -0.024994101375341415, 0.01952381245791912, -0.057600587606430054, 0.019804976880550385, -0.009619811549782753, 0.013370408676564693, -0.024721354246139526, -0.02022184059023857, -0.017926279455423355, -0.01231538224965334, 0.05141378566622734, -0.008516103029251099, -0.01644347608089447, -0.03573409467935562, 0.012358884327113628, 0.011543797329068184, 0.014971964061260223, -0.000860594620462507, -0.024491487070918083, -0.03952600434422493, -0.07343491166830063, 0.03465552628040314, 0.03328371047973633, 0.025308379903435707, 0.010270331986248493, 0.0182193536311388, -0.041392646729946136, -0.04087638109922409, 0.017612474039196968, 0.005816254764795303, -0.006126021035015583, 0.004756689537316561, 0.007117120083421469, -0.021077312529087067, -0.01884717121720314, -0.010162090882658958, 0.0615217424929142, -0.001282287179492414, -0.025840729475021362, -0.03176892176270485, -0.013276173733174801, -0.0016431092517450452, -0.03708931431174278, -0.03360651060938835, 0.02854684181511402, -0.026409948244690895, 0.03587273508310318, -0.00040232075843960047, -0.020588582381606102, 0.09498728811740875, 0.0405348539352417, -0.008688734844326973, -0.02315784990787506, 0.02066383883357048, -0.020844200626015663, 0.014957718551158905, 0.0008503959979861975, -0.07391832768917084, 0.0006146798259578645, -0.030780432745814323, 0.04892974719405174, -0.019891276955604553, 0.002186199650168419, -0.03230953961610794, 0.012450795620679855, -0.07577278465032578, 0.05324949324131012, 0.05438289791345596, 0.040103912353515625, 0.035030826926231384, -0.010601610876619816, 0.03060104511678219, 0.03142319619655609, -0.049566470086574554, 0.01635226607322693, 0.005578911397606134, -0.06652761250734329, 0.02440340258181095, -0.02397182211279869, 0.009598607197403908, -0.003891708329319954, -0.022618785500526428, 0.055647674947977066, -0.0008975646342150867, 0.03577864170074463, -0.01681063324213028, 0.005443432368338108, 0.0053018308244645596, -0.07058139145374298, -0.004591503646224737, -0.015435250476002693, 0.09443642944097519, -0.037382762879133224, -0.017705999314785004, -0.056395187973976135, 0.04299980029463768, -0.027022426947951317, -0.05045050010085106, 0.021891634911298752, -0.04640275612473488, -0.040665850043296814, 0.060118332505226135, -0.03963805362582207, 0.002058228477835655, 0.011052507907152176, -0.061819422990083694, -0.03706072270870209, -0.018932869657874107, 0.046119824051856995, -0.039684783667325974, -0.011754069477319717, 0.03662116080522537, -0.029401762410998344, -0.059926994144916534, 0.061037369072437286, -0.011146264150738716, 0.037373729050159454, -0.006553948391228914, 0.011044268496334553, -0.008922803215682507, 0.011749111115932465, 0.030396435409784317, -0.011991565115749836, 0.001926128868944943, 0.06761134415864944, -0.018034489825367928, -0.08252325654029846, 0.04433102533221245, -0.03379693254828453, -0.00815906748175621, 0.009817094542086124, 0.055307161062955856, 0.055669888854026794, 0.07168912887573242, 0.008405519649386406, -0.0055582295171916485, 0.05898400768637657, 0.01624346897006035, -0.03353026881814003, 0.012382933869957924, -0.015375667251646519, 0.018777910619974136, -0.014277425594627857, 0.06911751627922058, -0.009473699145019054, 0.0028350309003144503, -0.026204261928796768, 0.02771584875881672, 0.02377942204475403, -0.05911693349480629, -0.034807685762643814, -0.03683662787079811, 0.018407749012112617, 0.019919605925679207, -0.050082866102457047, -0.05898341163992882, 0.03126460686326027, 0.026855118572711945, 0.07323657721281052, 0.044498953968286514, -0.03319640830159187, 0.01910370960831642, 0.004384470172226429, -0.029942063614726067, -0.002340199425816536, 0.05605265125632286, -0.029915498569607735, -0.0071736532263457775, -0.04209386184811592, 0.021364759653806686, -0.016487179324030876, 0.02665852941572666, 0.040543634444475174, -0.06777283549308777, -0.025789432227611542, -0.01095018070191145, -0.04175884649157524, -0.030452102422714233, 0.04610639065504074, -0.030064938589930534, 0.010433951392769814, 0.005252399016171694, -0.033533550798892975, -0.057604726403951645, -0.018671389669179916, 0.013093902729451656, 0.03983820229768753, 0.02518220618367195, 0.02386791817843914, -0.0191391259431839, -0.0325251966714859, 0.01510069239884615, -0.027728261426091194, -0.00806594081223011, 0.009879818186163902, 0.049853429198265076, 0.051756586879491806, -0.02136792615056038, 0.0243056807667017, 0.013374985195696354, 0.013767745345830917, -0.0016802847385406494, 0.05314870923757553, 0.039850275963544846, 0.03220429643988609, -0.007243022322654724, 0.014328652061522007, -0.00888771191239357, -0.036092810332775116, -0.037825051695108414, -0.027625158429145813, 0.020123928785324097, -0.01938379928469658, 0.039488136768341064, -0.025883017107844353, -0.0060952939093112946, 0.04614109918475151, -0.08141116797924042, -0.0029095590580254793, 0.0341106578707695, 0.007276714313775301, 0.02658933773636818, -0.010193011723458767, 0.01591305620968342, -0.07197635620832443, -0.002290814183652401, -0.01807813160121441, -0.022456085309386253, -0.024005865678191185, -0.017073707655072212, -0.062032461166381836, -0.028868617489933968, -0.0011052353074774146, -0.01346159540116787, -0.009965824894607067, -0.01015444565564394, -0.00021383621788118035, -0.01137042697519064, 0.06516111642122269, -0.009983732365071774, 0.05318322777748108, -0.02853025123476982, 0.005757947918027639, -0.05282490327954292, -0.0425625704228878, 0.049856457859277725, 0.02600749023258686, 0.007478679530322552, -0.007316155359148979, -0.07800494134426117, -0.011312127113342285, 0.006202219054102898, 0.04585374519228935, 0.029684703797101974, 0.0486844927072525, 0.003734322264790535, 0.051737722009420395, 0.02843751758337021, 0.062278393656015396, 0.015486432239413261, -0.0026112247724086046, 0.02166079171001911, -0.06338516622781754, -0.023297136649489403, -0.028397556394338608, -0.013318615034222603, -0.009848110377788544, -0.06516652554273605, -0.0015903828898444772, -0.02067507803440094, -0.04512757062911987, -0.0005750968703068793, 0.0453827828168869, -0.07767492532730103, 0.0037445437628775835, -0.0019098520278930664, 0.05372079834342003, 0.06223822757601738, 0.04112214595079422, 0.02413494698703289, 0.04639752581715584, 0.030294565483927727, -0.045641276985406876, -0.026167405769228935, 0.05604271963238716, 0.03671891614794731, -0.03674840182065964, -0.01398471836000681, -0.035165559500455856, 0.02909715287387371, 0.01905592530965805, -0.007104508113116026, -0.014222600497305393, -0.011532360687851906, 0.011509250849485397, -0.025341913104057312, 0.045695822685956955, -0.04719100520014763, -0.010519261471927166, -0.04731477424502373, 0.026954365894198418, 0.013908366672694683, 0.053266629576683044, -0.008373669348657131, 0.007320041302591562, -0.007624693680554628, -0.03531671315431595, 0.019716428592801094, 0.02966799959540367, 0.005675989203155041, -0.036780208349227905, 0.035398293286561966, -0.001623955904506147, 0.009934655390679836, 0.021711133420467377, 0.031778257340192795, 0.004887319169938564, 0.02246357873082161, -0.0038418155163526535, -0.010824589058756828, 0.05943896993994713, 0.07003127783536911, -0.009583931416273117, 0.034267254173755646, 0.037540484219789505, -0.0045667835511267185, -0.023247838020324707, -0.04281989857554436, 0.05363738164305687, 0.03660651296377182, -0.01580832153558731, -0.015549831092357635, 0.002008033450692892, 0.00666959211230278, 0.0016198831144720316, 0.04585571587085724, -0.012334971688687801, -0.02346741408109665, -0.05103401467204094, -0.05480169132351875, 0.022212546318769455, -0.024747150018811226, 0.01693408191204071, -0.1036190465092659, 0.018906285986304283, 0.011232876218855381, -0.0330548994243145, 0.05315054580569267, 0.04816791042685509, -0.006204942706972361, -0.015267201699316502, 0.027133764699101448, 0.03112400323152542, 0.020978715270757675, -0.0139094153419137, 0.011521364562213421, 0.023477451875805855, -0.029231877997517586, 0.08277492970228195, -0.011310150846838951, -0.003308148356154561, -0.01613752730190754, 0.06299915164709091, 0.00875166803598404, 0.03398745879530907, 0.05382324382662773, -0.03038305789232254, -0.058134861290454865, -0.01023447047919035, -0.014089132659137249, 0.020153241232037544, -0.020782245323061943, -0.05948032811284065, 0.039144180715084076, -0.05812636390328407, -0.015033487230539322, -0.004186184145510197, 0.021304238587617874, -0.01950046978890896, 0.08218037337064743, 0.005358844064176083, -0.021893445402383804, -0.0015577826416119933, 0.017803220078349113, 0.008436476811766624, 0.03886367753148079, 0.06048538163304329, -0.05025982856750488, 0.01140509732067585, 0.04973267391324043, 0.032999224960803986, 0.03029840998351574, -0.02427223138511181, -0.04786098748445511, 0.009274432435631752, 0.0036245298106223345, -0.002958647906780243, -0.059572819620370865, -0.031174203380942345, -0.02674434334039688, -0.05465100333094597, 0.015093551948666573, 0.028979334980249405, 0.06634391099214554, -0.033520087599754333, 0.059400636702775955, 0.02231966145336628, -0.012993129901587963, -0.05443710833787918, -0.012428360991179943, 0.00522884214296937, -0.028737638145685196, 0.06176828220486641, -0.0300266295671463, -0.02936028689146042, -0.03167957440018654, -0.009843405336141586, 0.035510577261447906, 0.014274717308580875, -0.009252164512872696, 0.060168150812387466, 0.028938479721546173, 0.024850845336914062, -0.02811126597225666, -0.006822320632636547, -0.004504246171563864, 0.014509698376059532, 0.031939033418893814, -0.021168334409594536, -0.050452277064323425, 0.09223373979330063, -0.007005499210208654, 0.0217756237834692, 0.09099343419075012, -0.03277856111526489, -0.05098691210150719, 0.072383351624012, -0.04147797077894211, -0.023270422592759132, -0.010202952660620213, -0.0029077811632305384, 0.045241013169288635, -0.006192388478666544, -0.025314491242170334, -0.018750617280602455, -0.062840536236763, -0.004221444483846426, -0.04494176805019379, 0.01241250615566969, -0.0060974061489105225, -0.054231949150562286, 0.020766139030456543, -0.04041825607419014, -0.007878541015088558, 0.016425209119915962, -0.0052773538045585155, -0.009942450560629368, 0.06498029083013535, 0.0846303254365921, 0.012230871245265007, 0.003672526916489005, 0.035698842257261276, 0.009813489392399788, 0.07627979665994644, -0.013215611688792706, -0.01954355649650097, 0.02217467688024044, -0.03891274705529213, -0.07912884652614594, 0.0052248635329306126, -0.014960397966206074, -0.07978513836860657, 0.031753018498420715, 0.06182370334863663, -0.04709341749548912, 0.049442190676927567, -0.020014740526676178, -0.011395967565476894, 0.03798903524875641, -0.01713988371193409, 0.004503875505179167, -0.016353238373994827, 0.00413948018103838, -0.006796734407544136, -0.021125756204128265, -0.05110185965895653, -0.011956325732171535, 0.04958631843328476, 0.06197836250066757, 0.002023520413786173, 0.046352215111255646, 0.02906711958348751, -0.029687831178307533, -0.050537362694740295, 0.05089878663420677, 0.025444651022553444, 0.031675174832344055, 0.004329872317612171, 0.007718630135059357, -0.03949153795838356, 0.023805532604455948, -0.014436758123338223, -0.003962245769798756, 0.0009297484648413956, -0.019800150766968727, 0.007693837396800518, 0.04180600494146347, -0.00927245058119297, 0.04583851993083954, -0.023188382387161255, 0.05805042386054993, -0.03157757595181465, -0.028316117823123932, -0.0035701580345630646, 0.057040732353925705, 0.05488896369934082, -0.012247169390320778, 0.022247225046157837, -0.037475768476724625, -0.06468687206506729, 0.026100946590304375, 0.047465432435274124, -0.008542108349502087, -0.00028207115246914327, -0.020093701779842377, -0.03978804498910904, -0.004303573630750179, -0.0000012084356058039702, 0.029141807928681374, 0.01275821216404438, -0.012083875946700573, -0.021033266559243202, 0.02530481480062008, 0.018378430977463722, -0.11038908362388611, -0.05844763666391373, 0.022711072117090225, -0.08449031412601471, 0.04973887279629707, -0.01362520456314087, 0.0671590268611908, 0.005578174721449614, -0.006875847931951284, 0.009664065204560757, -0.009509124793112278, 0.009648691862821579, 0.013333961367607117, 0.06043512001633644, 0.010242274962365627, 0.043746545910835266, -0.08213260024785995, -0.011580780148506165, -0.025209641084074974, 0.02242162637412548, 0.012899559922516346, 0.025882864370942116, -0.008957933634519577, -0.020886365324258804, -0.006517026573419571, 0.01638811081647873, 0.025268426164984703, -0.05423599109053612, -0.05644731968641281, -0.025835568085312843, -0.004564325325191021, -0.049176353961229324, -0.03170468658208847, 0.0073112971149384975, -0.044337548315525055, -0.042897846549749374, 0.007214741315692663, -0.021225258708000183, -0.05593066290020943, -0.003876125905662775, 0.04578261449933052, -0.053192172199487686, 0.024544162675738335, -0.02345091477036476, 0.0023311059921979904, 0.001333751599304378, 0.042928297072649, -0.020013477653265, -0.06832889467477798, -0.01774241216480732, 0.055038679391145706, -0.035594504326581955, 0.007764727342873812, 0.05903005227446556, -0.027704717591404915, 0.023279154673218727, 0.005344714969396591, 0.034524545073509216, -0.030232582241296768, 0.0560462661087513, 0.011643176898360252, 0.02116379886865616, 0.024404266849160194, 0.07281851023435593, 0.017520451918244362, -0.051517002284526825, 0.03292984887957573, 0.07952285557985306, 0.025647176429629326, -0.05808763578534126, 0.036300744861364365, 0.030095940455794334, -0.06369005888700485, -0.03910989314317703, 0.030839014798402786, -0.01738719828426838, 0.015495155937969685, 0.006979637313634157, -0.009345180355012417, 0.005418659653514624, -0.03569755330681801, 0.015866434201598167, -0.006170210428535938, -0.03925403207540512, -0.007806737907230854, -0.002977153519168496, 0.057640206068754196, -0.038785651326179504, 0.055374450981616974, 0.021433670073747635, 0.008541323244571686, 0.07370677590370178, 0.04115529730916023, -0.057161614298820496, 0.023277530446648598, -0.029578274115920067, -0.008430213667452335, 0.05378340557217598, -0.02023443765938282, -0.043672114610672, -0.06596915423870087, 0.030855055898427963, -0.008190636523067951, 0.011867474764585495, 0.019769130274653435, -0.029389377683401108, 0.01535992044955492, 0.015110676176846027, -0.0013761647278442979, -0.021406129002571106, -0.010288730263710022, 0.004003767855465412, -0.011136786080896854, -0.016406260430812836, -0.005654306150972843, -0.042052894830703735, 0.060390278697013855, -0.016681024804711342, -0.05999791622161865, 0.03643326833844185, -0.0002991776855196804, 0.024221979081630707, 0.018082786351442337, 0.029969263821840286, 0.013963253237307072, 0.04716835170984268, 0.042152248322963715, -0.06806233525276184, -0.025040477514266968, -0.023919282481074333, 0.03338475152850151, 0.008528154343366623, 0.04855506867170334, -0.009528439491987228, -0.04118754342198372, -0.016797712072730064, 0.08075729012489319, -0.05303642526268959, -0.013139257207512856, 0.01891104131937027, -0.010231638327240944, -0.0018562973709776998, 0.08529907464981079, 0.047294747084379196, -0.026654405519366264, 0.007712373975664377, -0.005899437703192234, 0.0004669732879847288, 0.028574125841259956, -0.041124265640974045, 0.03641428425908089, -0.000019700362827279605, -0.013906221836805344, -0.010708961635828018, 0.03523968532681465, -0.020196976140141487, 0.007540659513324499, -0.10466382652521133, -0.029340393841266632, -0.035827524960041046, 0.012558470480144024, -0.026771875098347664, 0.029700377956032753, 0.031533658504486084, -0.04567386209964752, -0.055687423795461655, -0.013759714551270008, -0.024108802899718285, -0.08482710272073746, -0.008660977706313133, 0.016667794436216354, 0.008136800490319729, -0.027173275128006935, -0.017410894855856895, -0.04420364275574684, -0.007104201707988977, -0.01153577771037817, -0.06661464273929596, -0.0686563178896904, 0.00601202854886651, -0.018821338191628456, -0.03039143979549408, -0.026237912476062775, -0.0014345536474138498, 0.05458458140492439, -0.0068094199523329735, 0.018559617921710014, -0.0025273554492741823, 0.010285831056535244, -0.01353873498737812, -0.003656773827970028, -0.00957445427775383, -0.0394565612077713, -0.024370770901441574, 0.0866495668888092, 0.02933015115559101, 0.006019296124577522, 0.08434823900461197, 0.048035867512226105, 0.050376396626234055, -0.007015519309788942, 0.04890398681163788, -0.012722007930278778, -0.05358804762363434, 0.026004644110798836, -0.005477759055793285, -0.051666244864463806, -0.07716390490531921, -0.015691429376602173, -0.018693210557103157, -0.011855018325150013, -0.04528007656335831, 0.012034068815410137, 0.023792119696736336, -0.03049454465508461, -0.036817844957113266, -0.055322445929050446, -0.018167804926633835, -0.01140460092574358 ]
<p>What causes ice to melt in these patterns?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/WlcMR.jpg" alt="Melting Ice"></p> <p>And why does this always happen when the ice is covered in snow?</p>
g9752
[ 0.022076411172747612, 0.05676717311143875, -0.027048194780945778, 0.026370225474238396, 0.02316056191921234, 0.027601946145296097, 0.03966563940048218, 0.06151400879025459, -0.018732910975813866, -0.0036713210865855217, -0.06453173607587814, -0.01267359871417284, 0.058972783386707306, 0.02214757166802883, -0.05321722850203514, 0.05931048467755318, 0.011711567640304565, 0.02161160670220852, 0.004364788997918367, 0.06981855630874634, 0.005667963530868292, -0.020203912630677223, 0.0011662434553727508, 0.010864628478884697, -0.03897234797477722, 0.013211892917752266, 0.039637982845306396, -0.012103263288736343, -0.01923205889761448, 0.0011435719206929207, 0.022493131458759308, 0.046144746243953705, -0.030277464538812637, -0.01977931335568428, 0.060706742107868195, -0.04683568328619003, 0.04391434043645859, 0.0039338902570307255, -0.00030424134456552565, 0.002134696813300252, -0.038121458142995834, 0.01494623813778162, -0.0027846945449709892, 0.002750423038378358, -0.05754213035106659, -0.041303083300590515, 0.007489430718123913, -0.019977740943431854, -0.0761004388332367, -0.003248350229114294, 0.0352715365588665, -0.012461703270673752, 0.03979247063398361, -0.01883923076093197, 0.022888783365488052, 0.005160063039511442, 0.03650946170091629, 0.038651298731565475, -0.0004989325534552336, -0.0023677421268075705, 0.025092342868447304, 0.021447598934173584, 0.0029114196076989174, -0.0717819407582283, -0.008494531735777855, -0.008418389596045017, 0.01980901136994362, 0.01818150095641613, 0.05820613354444504, 0.050154462456703186, -0.01848721131682396, 0.0009651490254327655, -0.05740036070346832, -0.014049696736037731, -0.05247703194618225, -0.022555235773324966, 0.006588739808648825, 0.08316856622695923, 0.07194838672876358, 0.03364234417676926, -0.00862455926835537, 0.03998713940382004, -0.06820264458656311, -0.01680869236588478, 0.06242122873663902, 0.007696348242461681, -0.020536497235298157, -0.002808226039633155, -0.04803190380334854, 0.007839078083634377, -0.02853333204984665, 0.0007061383803375065, 0.041526369750499725, 0.008433395065367222, -0.047678206115961075, -0.03484174981713295, 0.02708437852561474, 0.016891472041606903, -0.01777632348239422, 0.056151632219552994, -0.004024912137538195, -0.030207380652427673, 0.0334598608314991, -0.07107844203710556, 0.04950569570064545, 0.02305358648300171, 0.011184141039848328, -0.04323204979300499, -0.022909188643097878, 0.020114772021770477, -0.017686575651168823, 0.03134638071060181, -0.07006775587797165, 0.004885419271886349, 0.03591662272810936, -0.014108735136687756, 0.019162388518452644, 0.06263409554958344, 0.019565759226679802, 0.04096360132098198, 0.03333699703216553, -0.048634689301252365, -0.09676310420036316, 0.028910938650369644, -0.05543315038084984, 0.01832461729645729, 0.07316876947879791, -0.049999821931123734, -0.03148140013217926, 0.000054026553698349744, 0.04210237041115761, 0.038397423923015594, -0.023874491453170776, -0.0005413389881141484, 0.032249823212623596, 0.033915676176548004, 0.002500307746231556, 0.011528990231454372, 0.022758180275559425, -0.04447772726416588, -0.025559844449162483, 0.05503931641578674, 0.02091095969080925, -0.03487343713641167, 0.007050490938127041, -0.013279601000249386, -0.04529820382595062, -0.0057071903720498085, -0.02590302936732769, 0.014760840684175491, -0.0452813096344471, 0.02392442710697651, 0.027715623378753662, -0.06674572080373764, 0.04473445564508438, 0.0021164757199585438, -0.053832508623600006, 0.022342434152960777, 0.010332496836781502, 0.01564842276275158, 0.017720414325594902, -0.05798802524805069, -0.0029386267997324467, 0.045155610889196396, -0.07009951770305634, 0.06874685734510422, 0.011630206368863583, 0.008903673849999905, 0.05831112340092659, 0.045058462768793106, 0.01426052488386631, 0.03826117888092995, -0.03907467797398567, 0.08190605789422989, 0.027276363223791122, 0.01571076735854149, 0.05437670648097992, -0.03069956600666046, 0.08012520521879196, -0.017164891585707664, 0.014381909742951393, 0.01428456511348486, -0.004321129061281681, -0.06821884959936142, 0.047419846057891846, -0.03741456940770149, 0.0776563510298729, -0.02068418450653553, -0.0625673234462738, 0.01885402947664261, 0.003515645395964384, -0.06780316680669785, -0.004923079162836075, -0.014486027881503105, 0.03498518839478493, -0.027843758463859558, -0.03341122344136238, -0.00586602883413434, -0.07104572653770447, 0.0030332349706441164, 0.025318626314401627, -0.03586214408278465, -0.017647864297032356, -0.012415071949362755, -0.06994319707155228, 0.035158853977918625, 0.02407575212419033, 0.043987937271595, -0.008419841527938843, 0.02919837273657322, -0.05609586462378502, -0.020993325859308243, -0.005759959574788809, -0.014590020291507244, 0.01419177558273077, 0.06655646860599518, 0.049839556217193604, -0.011208882555365562, -0.029771588742733, -0.01207908894866705, 0.03069330006837845, 0.020734064280986786, -0.07054856419563293, -0.01555780228227377, -0.05297952890396118, -0.008428147062659264, -0.02606581337749958, -0.033592190593481064, 0.008958783932030201, -0.035975825041532516, 0.007510743569582701, -0.032270755618810654, 0.037791311740875244, -0.05365193635225296, 0.023499609902501106, 0.042362917214632034, -0.01939452812075615, 0.025691477581858635, 0.06362472474575043, -0.04659919813275337, -0.05165110528469086, 0.03082258254289627, -0.03691801056265831, -0.012690202333033085, 0.04719388484954834, -0.030989140272140503, 0.004551115911453962, -0.020233357325196266, -0.019656002521514893, 0.050863999873399734, 0.004061409737914801, 0.06792784482240677, -0.02810494787991047, -0.010903432965278625, 0.012446993961930275, -0.02054041437804699, -0.005584754515439272, 0.02151039056479931, 0.07850082963705063, 0.002277999883517623, -0.059891462326049805, -0.010161216370761395, -0.03050686977803707, -0.005656039342284203, -0.08501218259334564, -0.013956229202449322, -0.009435558691620827, 0.015699127689003944, 0.020535273477435112, 0.023401815444231033, -0.021514125168323517, 0.0235601793974638, 0.05138228461146355, 0.007528499234467745, -0.0263975840061903, 0.02299441769719124, 0.0019688878674060106, 0.0010726028122007847, -0.003030578140169382, 0.003983278293162584, 0.08981297165155411, 0.018366245552897453, -0.0497431643307209, 0.06138671189546585, 0.05658625066280365, -0.03378714621067047, -0.08171957731246948, 0.020778948441147804, -0.07817116379737854, -0.0021992716938257217, 0.005221132189035416, -0.04645366221666336, 0.009562661871314049, 0.002381399506703019, -0.006280049216002226, 0.026560481637716293, -0.005121939815580845, 0.03580407798290253, -0.05695820599794388, 0.04895675927400589, -0.006045113783329725, 0.04890449345111847, -0.003268522210419178, 0.01846446841955185, 0.03883666172623634, 0.03116779215633869, 0.015896234661340714, -0.053395308554172516, -0.030658593401312828, 0.00879195611923933, 0.0689474567770958, 0.004154914058744907, -0.037056565284729004, 0.05709134414792061, -0.005509103648364544, 0.044830020517110825, -0.02238505333662033, 0.019699489697813988, 0.04595986753702164, -0.0397300124168396, -0.07174050807952881, 0.003165490459650755, 0.04770376533269882, 0.037622712552547455, -0.0004668698238674551, 0.03738117590546608, 0.009000922553241253, -0.003298366442322731, 0.021070506423711777, 0.017193224281072617, -0.03462906926870346, -0.01666402630507946, -0.049584172666072845, -0.030708350241184235, -0.01647377386689186, -0.006608374882489443, 0.013876346871256828, -0.017472442239522934, -0.045226216316223145, 0.005800054874271154, 0.021012477576732635, 0.004202590323984623, -0.010312086902558804, -0.053378161042928696, -0.03222102299332619, -0.03376070037484169, -0.026324953883886337, -0.03113282471895218, -0.0036359254736453295, -0.014028212055563927, 0.0318567231297493, 0.012874643318355083, -0.034730326384305954, -0.002233213512226939, -0.036620669066905975, 0.029628688469529152, -0.029722528532147408, 0.0001829546963563189, 0.01416073553264141, -0.006517027970403433, 0.014695856720209122, 0.032391440123319626, -0.06639497727155685, 0.04162120446562767, -0.0369308665394783, 0.023106394335627556, 0.03192920610308647, -0.07201126217842102, 0.0009958092123270035, -0.002393541391938925, 0.017163798213005066, 0.07001644372940063, -0.030723413452506065, -0.015052628703415394, 0.013589483685791492, 0.02459254115819931, -0.0013945242390036583, 0.0866205170750618, 0.011583062820136547, -0.00267341872677207, -0.010158267803490162, -0.01002081111073494, 0.03401266038417816, -0.02678092010319233, 0.014770746231079102, 0.005366391967982054, -0.023827921599149704, -0.002732923487201333, -0.021612124517560005, 0.010536742396652699, -0.023504551500082016, 0.02389761246740818, 0.04265604540705681, 0.04182540997862816, 0.008958457037806511, -0.02062319591641426, -0.01904979720711708, 0.039618391543626785, -0.0041254605166614056, -0.029840165749192238, 0.018917502835392952, 0.006746765226125717, 0.0014829906867817044, -0.07862243056297302, 0.04567642882466316, -0.03707656264305115, -0.01162907388061285, 0.002277267863973975, 0.013144070282578468, 0.025630034506320953, 0.03211136534810066, -0.004668091889470816, -0.03337888792157173, -0.023380421102046967, 0.05361832305788994, 0.00610320083796978, 0.026022903621196747, 0.0033871361520141363, 0.04957357794046402, -0.042807694524526596, 0.0012882723240181804, -0.009134633466601372, -0.06195523589849472, -0.04170839488506317, -0.027320202440023422, 0.017086895182728767, -0.05392264947295189, -0.06028081104159355, -0.013721895404160023, -0.03789425641298294, 0.04505418613553047, -0.01809142716228962, -0.05282346531748772, -0.024819184094667435, -0.025167033076286316, 0.0031792984809726477, -0.034650810062885284, -0.011576078832149506, 0.0011095092631876469, 0.017746753990650177, -0.028623636811971664, -0.025785448029637337, 0.023123212158679962, 0.009094735607504845, -0.009841070510447025, 0.022827642038464546, 0.06881687045097351, 0.03870777040719986, 0.03316831961274147, -0.04060631990432739, -0.02128954790532589, 0.04357249289751053, -0.0061013419181108475, 0.03036821261048317, 0.0006133605493232608, -0.04962886869907379, 0.010123985819518566, 0.06985209137201309, -0.008870212361216545, 0.043805740773677826, -0.01274118386209011, 0.004763912409543991, 0.05052674934267998, -0.022317636758089066, -0.01946013607084751, 0.011301741935312748, -0.03071768395602703, -0.04440607130527496, 0.028083888813853264, -0.02680002711713314, 0.021018438041210175, 0.056420981884002686, -0.016590198501944542, 0.04426741972565651, 0.00196249783039093, 0.01659286953508854, -0.0653025209903717, 0.011072947643697262, 0.012026346288621426, -0.011259843595325947, 0.00688743544742465, -0.0198435727506876, 0.005137265659868717, -0.03553779795765877, -0.020538756623864174, 0.005580408498644829, -0.03602709621191025, 0.03290979564189911, 0.016881287097930908, -0.03504962846636772, 0.01831705868244171, -0.062492307275533676, 0.027995795011520386, 0.00004234062726027332, -0.007352540269494057, -0.0677417516708374, 0.006316597573459148, 0.011582967825233936, 0.058652088046073914, -0.0314907468855381, 0.032615356147289276, -0.06533205509185791, 0.005295653361827135, -0.0514117106795311, 0.02091962844133377, -0.002793805208057165, 0.017162416130304337, -0.01448814943432808, 0.03770578280091286, -0.11392679065465927, 0.021554894745349884, 0.03538797050714493, 0.012652575969696045, -0.017184382304549217, 0.04195458069443703, -0.02258024923503399, -0.012388656847178936, -0.04937443509697914, 0.031057877466082573, -0.005592862609773874, -0.05905330553650856, -0.03152591362595558, 0.0264679454267025, -0.0035152037162333727, -0.0295407772064209, -0.010369183495640755, -0.09511319547891617, -0.03381228446960449, 0.011767379939556122, -0.006260036490857601, 0.00517998868599534, -0.014458419755101204, 0.02013266645371914, 0.032693762332201004, 0.01097969152033329, -0.03274748846888542, -0.025517169386148453, -0.031972724944353104, 0.001995768863707781, 0.05923108756542206, 0.03594325855374336, -0.006479910109192133, -0.028456075116991997, 0.04319227114319801, -0.003972929902374744, -0.019050275906920433, 0.08561395853757858, 0.043023061007261276, 0.03048344887793064, 0.0007868364336900413, -0.029247919097542763, 0.02600790746510029, 0.027842730283737183, -0.03772431239485741, -0.0058319056406617165, -0.03197822347283363, -0.0655764639377594, 0.015405511483550072, -0.024453751742839813, -0.012296664528548717, 0.019702158868312836, -0.016638867557048798, -0.0006775310030207038, -0.019769558683037758, 0.05673214793205261, -0.027818890288472176, -0.013789156451821327, 0.043452225625514984, 0.046363916248083115, 0.05490870401263237, 0.05338514223694801, 0.001236651325598359, 0.0169855784624815, 0.012404975481331348, -0.009246286936104298, 0.10617391020059586, -0.03324844688177109, 0.03217168524861336, -0.0022253624629229307, -0.0474739633500576, 0.05541936680674553, -0.007692974992096424, -0.04051187261939049, -0.023618904873728752, 0.005733247380703688, 0.0037344545125961304, -0.03706296533346176, 0.030511779710650444, 0.0018236878095194697, -0.03858233615756035, -0.040890179574489594, -0.04006638750433922, 0.0009307325235567987, -0.009080853313207626, -0.010223135352134705, -0.0604131855070591, -0.006180441007018089, 0.06490853428840637, -0.020157136023044586, -0.08173036575317383, -0.0001635247899685055, 0.016022253781557083, 0.08051769435405731, 0.036544427275657654, -0.10911682993173599, -0.019947536289691925, 0.043507713824510574, -0.023730231449007988, -0.0024640667252242565, 0.052735451608896255, -0.01695840246975422, 0.00861656479537487, 0.00767413480207324, 0.003782618558034301, -0.08021672815084457, -0.053610894829034805, -0.04190251603722572, 0.02930661104619503, 0.00018178526079282165, -0.09034111350774765, -0.03256070986390114, -0.05183667689561844, -0.013260036706924438, -0.058608632534742355, -0.030006512999534607, 0.011456319130957127, 0.036769699305295944, 0.03023468516767025, 0.03705117106437683, -0.024563107639551163, -0.016703426837921143, 0.024430157616734505, -0.04340018332004547, 0.024553662165999413, -0.054766491055488586, 0.06277061253786087, 0.025129467248916626, 0.02570505626499653, 0.009728588163852692, 0.01501631923019886, 0.0010949006536975503, -0.013198243454098701, 0.02983022853732109, -0.019290007650852203, 0.02722511626780033, 0.028636110946536064, -0.04225459322333336, -0.09166605025529861, -0.003094074549153447, -0.009233790449798107, 0.008776253089308739, 0.019543219357728958, 0.009115567430853844, -0.029887894168496132, -0.0029108431190252304, 0.002576009836047888, 0.010317487642168999, -0.006456479430198669, 0.013929159380495548, -0.06029060110449791, -0.07014907151460648, -0.0010501040378585458, -0.05507895350456238, 0.010047689080238342, 0.06230699270963669, 0.021780015900731087, 0.055351439863443375, 0.004715675488114357, -0.019599590450525284, -0.004649765323847532, -0.08779484778642654, 0.018663182854652405, 0.043980348855257034, -0.025187265127897263, 0.028829779475927353, 0.003857587929815054, 0.029586346819996834, -0.0025452624540776014, 0.011860775761306286, 0.02584017440676689, 0.040682803839445114, 0.03838133439421654, 0.031960587948560715, -0.06324270367622375, 0.010887963697314262, 0.06859298050403595, 0.04284505546092987, 0.04642745479941368, 0.010400502942502499, -0.006081945728510618, -0.0002564036403782666, 0.044582799077034, 0.03166719898581505, 0.03563849627971649, 0.013609889894723892, 0.004685116466134787, -0.00270530441775918, -0.033233579248189926, -0.02410680428147316, 0.03428079932928085, -0.01001029834151268, 0.022176679223775864, -0.021185584366321564, -0.05037953704595566, -0.027603285387158394, -0.06262689083814621, -0.014853406697511673, 0.009982092306017876, 0.07582641392946243, 0.006918049417436123, 0.004004793707281351, 0.043925169855356216, 0.11360211670398712, -0.010276690125465393, 0.0049013374373316765, 0.00865949783474207, -0.01317368634045124, -0.025095872581005096, -0.10292289406061172, -0.003132623853161931, 0.015960795804858208, -0.005084068048745394, -0.01570926420390606, -0.05952998250722885, -0.03907444700598717, 0.010581131093204021, 0.05729488283395767, -0.012837029993534088, 0.003646174445748329, 0.0041828276589512825, -0.04645812511444092, 0.052943624556064606, -0.003452015807852149, 0.016733545809984207, 0.006081299856305122, -0.03189479187130928, 0.004891133401542902, -0.010603370144963264, -0.0028261549305170774, 0.07201236486434937, 0.016349438577890396, 0.03311798721551895, -0.01554270088672638, -0.04549528285861015, 0.01145324669778347, -0.0281229130923748, 0.028791051357984543, 0.028752274811267853, 0.008651853539049625, 0.003824877552688122, -0.02375437319278717, 0.01829281449317932, -0.004322030581533909, -0.005231802351772785, 0.028636176139116287, 0.010530827566981316, -0.07748553156852722, 0.0338013581931591, -0.007949424907565117, 0.04037225618958473, 0.013990125618875027, -0.07384441047906876, -0.034013014286756516, -0.024200668558478355, -0.01553938165307045, 0.03341883048415184, -0.0008451557368971407, -0.03787767514586449 ]
<p>Lightning contains a lot of energy, so where does this energy go after lightning has hit the ground? </p> <p>Does it travel all the way to the core? What happens after that?</p>
g9753
[ 0.05976817384362221, 0.0703938901424408, 0.01292517501860857, -0.04189860075712204, -0.030907001346349716, -0.009684206917881966, 0.01539409626275301, 0.0441223606467247, -0.022490642964839935, -0.051466166973114014, -0.06436774134635925, -0.001339751179330051, -0.021927468478679657, -0.04711134359240532, -0.019104083999991417, -0.012427347712218761, 0.053920865058898926, -0.026093125343322754, 0.04830765724182129, 0.03357922285795212, 0.007827109657227993, -0.0027142520993947983, 0.017299363389611244, -0.03659171983599663, -0.0323190912604332, 0.02192811109125614, 0.04142902046442032, 0.006066181231290102, -0.031494975090026855, -0.0035164598375558853, 0.013566491194069386, 0.025717807933688164, 0.04843387007713318, -0.08532552421092987, -0.005951414816081524, -0.011995439417660236, 0.024542799219489098, -0.025114886462688446, 0.08650943636894226, -0.027236230671405792, 0.034120820462703705, -0.004210083745419979, -0.009272140450775623, -0.04647209122776985, -0.022135749459266663, -0.014654559083282948, 0.013140689581632614, -0.024867800995707512, -0.03023792803287506, 0.008433458395302296, -0.023183271288871765, 0.0184024665504694, 0.004326190799474716, 0.052355971187353134, 0.04628991708159447, 0.012784830294549465, 0.032565101981163025, -0.02302747406065464, 0.05655253306031227, 0.022335249930620193, 0.028219671919941902, -0.019151022657752037, 0.03825193643569946, -0.01983274146914482, 0.014686875976622105, -0.04271448031067848, -0.084668830037117, -0.01608957163989544, 0.062715083360672, -0.04138626903295517, 0.03399760648608208, -0.04748017340898514, -0.05752940475940704, -0.05758034065365791, 0.001509866095148027, -0.04065177962183952, 0.06071765720844269, 0.042586032301187515, 0.0303779449313879, 0.04654868692159653, 0.02304004319012165, -0.00022922131756786257, 0.013301391154527664, -0.04296683892607689, 0.008590941317379475, 0.017117388546466827, -0.025610288605093956, -0.0007645470905117691, 0.007636762224137783, -0.010148454457521439, 0.009692138992249966, 0.05771739408373833, 0.07016076892614365, -0.0390302948653698, -0.03216411918401718, -0.030337834730744362, -0.01770872250199318, 0.03231867402791977, 0.01512376219034195, 0.014374510385096073, -0.03886937350034714, -0.09068489819765091, -0.005477682687342167, -0.012307829223573208, 0.039941076189279556, -0.026107780635356903, -0.05198472738265991, -0.032431356608867645, 0.03320009633898735, 0.03222198039293289, 0.02434462122619152, -0.040646038949489594, 0.039176180958747864, -0.03202467039227486, -0.056039951741695404, -0.04584593325853348, 0.10292753577232361, -0.009257360361516476, 0.014670776203274727, 0.040707867592573166, 0.020070428028702736, 0.03702283650636673, -0.015389441512525082, 0.0681220218539238, -0.021697111427783966, -0.023885047063231468, 0.04783236235380173, 0.008410152979195118, -0.05275193229317665, 0.0062982249073684216, -0.0225310530513525, -0.04559667035937309, -0.017655951902270317, 0.01902974210679531, 0.05578172951936722, 0.03793305158615112, 0.03718090057373047, 0.055355846881866455, -0.054678067564964294, 0.0444176085293293, 0.014492136426270008, 0.0006214825552888215, 0.06779125332832336, -0.012410726398229599, 0.03789576515555382, -0.012090432457625866, -0.004699333570897579, -0.026406437158584595, 0.00786516536027193, 0.025353413075208664, -0.0010994257172569633, -0.02444862388074398, 0.0009749464807100594, -0.01818779483437538, 0.033091939985752106, -0.06308529525995255, 0.006621208041906357, -0.015263672918081284, 0.008325987495481968, -0.006451891269534826, 0.02617066167294979, -0.04602871835231781, 0.06913959234952927, -0.001065906835719943, 0.024602003395557404, 0.01405089721083641, 0.0067971982061862946, -0.02817077748477459, 0.037042997777462006, 0.025806300342082977, -0.0007378598093055189, -0.00176593370269984, 0.009029397740960121, 0.02576042152941227, 0.014767859131097794, 0.05110546201467514, 0.016382766887545586, -0.041835132986307144, -0.011601786129176617, -0.008784778416156769, -0.020527351647615433, 0.005200513172894716, 0.02414684370160103, -0.05030406638979912, 0.01880359649658203, -0.022913359105587006, -0.05002124607563019, -0.056607410311698914, 0.028858548030257225, -0.0006754223140887916, -0.0235252995043993, -0.07096190005540848, 0.012686445377767086, 0.029810572043061256, 0.012784757651388645, -0.00989687629044056, -0.009237202815711498, -0.02375034987926483, -0.0343930646777153, -0.08322528749704361, 0.07344959676265717, -0.034322984516620636, 0.01983068883419037, 0.03471299633383751, 0.03236202895641327, 0.06548453867435455, -0.020864510908722878, -0.0020818382035940886, -0.00898374617099762, -0.010919935069978237, -0.043854981660842896, -0.04653706029057503, 0.0011513670906424522, 0.04692583531141281, -0.015427099540829659, -0.019461320713162422, -0.010653618723154068, 0.008577080443501472, -0.0023478460498154163, 0.027569960802793503, -0.04420749843120575, -0.0013661370612680912, -0.014431136660277843, -0.021227246150374413, 0.009984512813389301, 0.05507299676537514, -0.004535484593361616, -0.021274898201227188, -0.037026021629571915, 0.05349753797054291, -0.026647983118891716, 0.01623450592160225, -0.04192257672548294, -0.03609286993741989, 0.04676029458642006, 0.029492702335119247, -0.032494816929101944, 0.004343611188232899, -0.02589358575642109, -0.07353847473859787, -0.05697294697165489, -0.009905382990837097, 0.07249448448419571, 0.032010409981012344, 0.03691529482603073, -0.03934711217880249, 0.04457743093371391, 0.020077595487236977, -0.01436364185065031, 0.015867311507463455, 0.05956456810235977, 0.02100810967385769, -0.05874916538596153, 0.06338530033826828, 0.007014487870037556, -0.06981199234724045, 0.003869574051350355, 0.012609551660716534, -0.04684710502624512, -0.1062350645661354, 0.002458483912050724, -0.01920609176158905, -0.04030650481581688, -0.00956538412719965, -0.028686873614788055, 0.005053849425166845, 0.02209438942372799, -0.04615188017487526, 0.021592022851109505, -0.03370599076151848, -0.05900644138455391, 0.04532459005713463, 0.035306695848703384, 0.0264006145298481, 0.0427984818816185, -0.028846556320786476, -0.01886589638888836, -0.0025897002778947353, 0.02818366512656212, -0.0630652904510498, -0.013994700275361538, -0.010628205724060535, -0.02376941218972206, 0.01318817026913166, -0.018954185768961906, -0.06220872700214386, -0.022022496908903122, 0.004858581814914942, -0.029617520049214363, -0.0287755336612463, -0.006381630431860685, -0.011550619266927242, 0.018428055569529533, -0.04691975936293602, -0.03703192621469498, 0.0027728951536118984, 0.04472362995147705, -0.01054326817393303, -0.020086992532014847, 0.03238634392619133, 0.0003122335474472493, -0.0021330874878913164, 0.025651784613728523, -0.00416215555742383, -0.028541309759020805, 0.07167130708694458, 0.013149497099220753, -0.05134022235870361, 0.0029050318989902735, 0.0050639561377465725, 0.028281401842832565, 0.057066965848207474, -0.025744061917066574, 0.02878199703991413, 0.01647302135825157, -0.01727484166622162, -0.03345179930329323, 0.02388940006494522, 0.07771434634923935, 0.02580866776406765, -0.006155331619083881, 0.021749921143054962, 0.016428256407380104, 0.04778464883565903, 0.011701148934662342, 0.027038156986236572, -0.024501921609044075, 0.03469094634056091, -0.004698141478002071, -0.020181626081466675, -0.07424864917993546, 0.07764323800802231, -0.044806063175201416, 0.016246283426880836, 0.027102716267108917, -0.01634773053228855, -0.03225152567028999, 0.020780319347977638, 0.06814093887805939, 0.06940027326345444, 0.03819023817777634, 0.004982031881809235, 0.008449035696685314, 0.02914351038634777, 0.055800143629312515, 0.013583794236183167, -0.029055146500468254, -0.03969230875372887, 0.0180257149040699, -0.021191010251641273, 0.016720738261938095, -0.05136292427778244, -0.04095843806862831, -0.031174736097455025, -0.05749352276325226, 0.01744207926094532, -0.011971835978329182, 0.023763317614793777, 0.0056050922721624374, 0.003255597548559308, -0.023686343804001808, -0.025020791217684746, 0.04956458508968353, 0.008530992083251476, 0.027108391746878624, 0.021308770403265953, 0.0009180365595966578, -0.0562860444188118, 0.023614194244146347, 0.03337574377655983, 0.041750166565179825, 0.025971831753849983, -0.020835107192397118, 0.06464948505163193, -0.03709869459271431, -0.049365296959877014, 0.04753818362951279, 0.024623239412903786, -0.04299888759851456, 0.02232353761792183, 0.005473816301673651, -0.008135790936648846, 0.060195114463567734, -0.028224371373653412, 0.01606500893831253, 0.021381445229053497, 0.019785232841968536, -0.0002668874803930521, 0.00799466297030449, 0.04893064871430397, -0.02289283648133278, -0.06424213200807571, 0.028365565463900566, -0.0003754542558453977, 0.0025950020644813776, -0.04077022895216942, 0.025594273582100868, 0.04903082922101021, 0.0006795629160478711, 0.07001778483390808, 0.005677310284227133, 0.03980349004268646, -0.02321029081940651, -0.030851267278194427, 0.055382631719112396, 0.06073739752173424, 0.007052803412079811, -0.05761364474892616, -0.021715257316827774, -0.05708787590265274, 0.056155093014240265, 0.004099298268556595, -0.044378288090229034, -0.03048393875360489, 0.01375449076294899, -0.0589834526181221, 0.02956400439143181, -0.03913194313645363, -0.014839298091828823, -0.07006548345088959, 0.02747572585940361, 0.0069603584706783295, 0.02719438076019287, -0.020444920286536217, -0.0290804635733366, 0.05886131525039673, -0.016354132443666458, -0.034402456134557724, -0.04368320852518082, 0.00001005870581138879, -0.09034934639930725, 0.02414897456765175, 0.025194965302944183, -0.0023235962726175785, -0.03665103763341904, 0.035866934806108475, 0.008601115085184574, -0.02209612727165222, -0.009252332150936127, 0.05333056300878525, 0.09208174794912338, 0.05657915025949478, -0.005431002005934715, -0.007741505280137062, -0.02917032688856125, 0.0013332207454368472, 0.03264019265770912, 0.00471129734069109, 0.009422416798770428, -0.04584126174449921, -0.02577696181833744, 0.020237749442458153, 0.0013501127250492573, 0.010605224408209324, -0.06013544648885727, -0.020743949338793755, 0.012297152541577816, -0.02378661371767521, -0.009226557798683643, 0.019210027530789375, -0.040393222123384476, -0.020774653181433678, -0.031037019565701485, 0.030525032430887222, 0.02810642123222351, -0.020162537693977356, 0.02991500496864319, -0.03664541617035866, -0.042703449726104736, 0.002187754027545452, 0.01595945842564106, 0.017663955688476562, 0.019774500280618668, -0.0014236600836738944, 0.04297878220677376, 0.03432108461856842, -0.02139255777001381, -0.019342416897416115, 0.051106471568346024, -0.019930237904191017, 0.017426786944270134, 0.02830464579164982, -0.029563618823885918, -0.01570768840610981, -0.023693988099694252, 0.002329988405108452, 0.017328020185232162, 0.024437567219138145, 0.04351609945297241, 0.003753555938601494, -0.04016510024666786, 0.03304699808359146, 0.00718219019472599, -0.02810533344745636, -0.03777312487363815, 0.01445871964097023, 0.024313170462846756, 0.036352064460515976, -0.001297110691666603, 0.014970178715884686, -0.04821554943919182, 0.004498552531003952, 0.013789706863462925, 0.03803001344203949, 0.008774823509156704, 0.06332740187644958, 0.01594756916165352, 0.02615378051996231, -0.04628496244549751, 0.020463336259126663, -0.010049120523035526, 0.003196968464180827, -0.11312465369701385, 0.030239321291446686, -0.005245638079941273, -0.02871667593717575, -0.058575645089149475, 0.09566144645214081, -0.0174254197627306, 0.06979654729366302, -0.040856070816516876, -0.038410525768995285, 0.028444016352295876, -0.024832310155034065, 0.015652388334274292, 0.011286771856248379, -0.06165957823395729, -0.013448195531964302, 0.013611848466098309, 0.04786916822195053, -0.03946563974022865, 0.03837249055504799, 0.018524548038840294, 0.0025861007161438465, -0.010229339823126793, 0.041119564324617386, -0.03568538278341293, -0.06779218465089798, 0.01123880036175251, 0.030601896345615387, -0.0022758282721042633, -0.05398555472493172, 0.005969784688204527, 0.016132930293679237, -0.0025724382139742374, 0.014451541006565094, 0.02972077950835228, 0.021652836352586746, 0.056771837174892426, -0.05438264459371567, 0.005320040043443441, -0.0075762635096907616, 0.003230579663068056, 0.011249469593167305, 0.008921775035560131, 0.011309650726616383, 0.016395263373851776, -0.004611901938915253, 0.007888905704021454, -0.010968975722789764, 0.029092656448483467, -0.00903756357729435, -0.01914725825190544, -0.05877815932035446, 0.1290351152420044, -0.07030760496854782, -0.013790354132652283, -0.08153551816940308, 0.06571627408266068, -0.00017985005979426205, 0.06926888972520828, -0.05594193562865257, 0.020940478891134262, -0.02132726088166237, -0.008885989896953106, 0.038645483553409576, -0.033408600836992264, 0.009192299097776413, -0.009527008049190044, -0.07400337606668472, 0.03477984666824341, -0.03344731405377388, 0.04025736078619957, -0.036747585982084274, 0.002014569006860256, 0.027300724759697914, -0.01425241306424141, 0.010787910781800747, 0.06553304940462112, 0.011511753313243389, -0.02211429923772812, 0.003252473659813404, 0.026113003492355347, -0.05322592332959175, 0.0016674306243658066, -0.0445319302380085, 0.07077661156654358, 0.016185248270630836, 0.018658841028809547, 0.05120702460408211, -0.024615755304694176, -0.026356752961874008, 0.01456261333078146, -0.06772519648075104, 0.05289866775274277, -0.033487800508737564, 0.0439695306122303, -0.04773329570889473, -0.0040873074904084206, 0.035325925797224045, 0.0033981825690716505, -0.01876820996403694, 0.04299641773104668, -0.02823144756257534, -0.031831610947847366, 0.032108888030052185, -0.028375035151839256, -0.05229936167597771, 0.0551735945045948, 0.003500961698591709, -0.054328735917806625, -0.07087289541959763, -0.018709750846028328, -0.02727462165057659, -0.01486915908753872, -0.004237068351358175, 0.004474976100027561, 0.043166518211364746, 0.02506989985704422, 0.0050400919280946255, -0.031046869233250618, 0.03755558282136917, 0.004981910809874535, 0.04065605625510216, 0.010258033871650696, -0.0009525209316052496, 0.018079163506627083, -0.05027247592806816, -0.004012377001345158, -0.04391234368085861, 0.014859549701213837, 0.030860435217618942, -0.04911074787378311, 0.02162977121770382, -0.06317697465419769, -0.010171731002628803, 0.0028299002442508936, -0.05080656707286835, -0.04009779915213585, -0.01843758299946785, 0.009421424940228462, -0.010176798328757286, -0.0388915129005909, -0.021811028942465782, -0.0464719757437706, -0.00034435439738444984, -0.014836907386779785, 0.04124224931001663, 0.011587773449718952, -0.07907477021217346, -0.025808272883296013, -0.0011613507522270083, -0.06528577953577042, 0.02755647897720337, 0.024162709712982178, 0.044853728264570236, 0.05589844286441803, -0.05655505135655403, 0.02189304493367672, 0.017895134165883064, 0.03394613787531853, -0.03072742000222206, -0.05264434590935707, 0.02293248474597931, -0.0477774478495121, -0.01117558404803276, -0.021488413214683533, 0.026861852034926414, 0.016970735043287277, -0.04036813974380493, -0.0016477708704769611, 0.022684937343001366, -0.033396705985069275, 0.01299744751304388, 0.047603629529476166, 0.046440981328487396, -0.022719524800777435, -0.004523654002696276, -0.047945957630872726, 0.018386781215667725, 0.002064325148239732, 0.0286458320915699, 0.0413447842001915, -0.06345977634191513, -0.002399252727627754, -0.06328502297401428, 0.06432994455099106, -0.06296943873167038, 0.015226636081933975, 0.00775090791285038, -0.030371809378266335, -0.035514891147613525, 0.026755372062325478, -0.026610154658555984, 0.018432337790727615, 0.04249674826860428, -0.006497388239949942, -0.02036982588469982, -0.06452935934066772, 0.001077897846698761, 0.030566228553652763, 0.003931406885385513, 0.0010876315645873547, 0.012476851232349873, -0.0043064896017313, 0.09670548886060715, 0.04137492924928665, 0.01561612356454134, 0.021411962807178497, -0.008046076633036137, -0.026712561026215553, 0.0032307959627360106, -0.01543049793690443, 0.011705307289958, -0.016965311020612717, 0.07795986533164978, -0.007163301110267639, -0.014900320209562778, 0.005433950107544661, 0.0038294701371341944, -0.02530933916568756, 0.018057189881801605, 0.02839590795338154, -0.020372075960040092, -0.05001644790172577, -0.04767659306526184, 0.061095092445611954, -0.06914196163415909, 0.0802433118224144, -0.013660924509167671, 0.009234427474439144, -0.062204547226428986, -0.036367081105709076, -0.010975504294037819, 0.002233425620943308, 0.01451797317713499, 0.03484387695789337, 0.03278954699635506, 0.07816429436206818, -0.08242832869291306, 0.06822121888399124, 0.0268813855946064, -0.026222137734293938, 0.012785632163286209, 0.0077789886854588985, 0.01814238913357258, -0.003088083816692233, 0.005174349993467331, -0.06220760568976402, 0.01800292357802391, -0.011837254278361797, -0.03882626071572304, 0.01337380986660719, -0.026961736381053925, -0.02320302277803421, 0.008953510783612728, -0.016874542459845543, -0.021839816123247147 ]
<p>So consider the case where there is a particle and a moving telescope: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/HD5xk.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>If the particle is located at position 1, and the telescope is moving horizontally as shown, the EM radiation appears to be coming from position 2, from the telescopes perspective.</p> <p>Let us now think of the object 1 as being an electron, producing a static electric field. Now, the telescope will detect the electric field to indeed be at position 1, despite travelling at the horizontal velocity.</p> <p>Why is there such a difference between EM and electric fields.</p>
g9754
[ 0.0559685043990612, 0.01318931020796299, -0.020858656615018845, -0.0000700596792739816, 0.12339663505554199, 0.04173848405480385, 0.009096859954297543, -0.00038022652734071016, -0.033070243895053864, -0.012899735942482948, 0.014130095951259136, 0.036293875426054, 0.04279607534408569, -0.029112430289387703, -0.018031472340226173, 0.00924188643693924, 0.07788059860467911, -0.010834303684532642, -0.005439578555524349, 0.049593038856983185, -0.007439901586622, 0.020455345511436462, 0.004565086215734482, -0.016925804316997528, 0.005018199793994427, -0.020579393953084946, 0.008721104823052883, -0.0394127182662487, 0.006389514543116093, -0.041476134210824966, -0.00013273584772832692, 0.01224347110837698, 0.037556931376457214, -0.02073589526116848, -0.03445817530155182, -0.058817289769649506, 0.01959797739982605, 0.04949291795492172, -0.009008500725030899, 0.017770716920495033, 0.021259110420942307, 0.0019298396073281765, -0.014349422417581081, 0.016586698591709137, 0.009311867877840996, -0.03293363377451897, 0.003569373395293951, 0.0012285533593967557, -0.015016156248748302, -0.04259156808257103, -0.05240456387400627, -0.019747283309698105, -0.009850060567259789, 0.046998802572488785, 0.05418064817786217, -0.03410188853740692, -0.03322237357497215, -0.0034919611643999815, 0.08908303081989288, -0.016950564458966255, 0.010369548574090004, 0.000608420989010483, -0.005194750148802996, -0.005302313715219498, -0.004327429458498955, -0.0025119951460510492, -0.06418055295944214, 0.023143643513321877, -0.011225019581615925, -0.0058278427459299564, -0.03051399067044258, -0.04382473975419998, -0.0848565399646759, -0.02490425668656826, -0.0035232703667134047, -0.03978860750794411, -0.008525299839675426, -0.05116240680217743, 0.008086904883384705, -0.020045122131705284, -0.008339266292750835, 0.02312767505645752, 0.011548066511750221, 0.05028850585222244, 0.1060565710067749, 0.006751809734851122, -0.0053598154336214066, 0.0016576435882598162, -0.003549287561327219, -0.07853467017412186, 0.016123944893479347, -0.01089062076061964, 0.08607035875320435, 0.05165179446339607, -0.05914340540766716, -0.03403240814805031, -0.018771223723888397, 0.07437998056411743, 0.014026263728737831, -0.025668010115623474, -0.01911737583577633, 0.001591647625900805, 0.016038918867707253, 0.06116558611392975, 0.025237057358026505, -0.026702923700213432, 0.0062361350283026695, 0.023528216406702995, -0.01939588226377964, -0.02622612938284874, -0.0017478395020589232, -0.04364842176437378, -0.057328760623931885, -0.022176381200551987, -0.042568501085042953, 0.01231887936592102, 0.06533516198396683, -0.01376062911003828, -0.0056309774518013, 0.032992467284202576, 0.022672532126307487, 0.024151815101504326, -0.058908917009830475, 0.06235416233539581, -0.05570103973150253, 0.00136117625515908, 0.0003669376310426742, -0.02320857159793377, 0.031795307993888855, 0.006654303055256605, 0.032845787703990936, -0.0016654017381370068, -0.014165631495416164, 0.02765769138932228, -0.007883846759796143, 0.04580698162317276, -0.007513769436627626, -0.05157514289021492, 0.02068847045302391, 0.01412878092378378, 0.011294453404843807, -0.032265327870845795, 0.0008455634815618396, -0.03469720482826233, -0.0406661294400692, 0.033092692494392395, 0.01793011836707592, -0.010185162536799908, 0.08128300309181213, 0.006641180254518986, -0.0021409320179373026, 0.046024952083826065, -0.008908412419259548, 0.014152644202113152, 0.050395503640174866, -0.04284029081463814, 0.0405886247754097, 0.028717361390590668, 0.014571309089660645, -0.015884004533290863, 0.036559052765369415, -0.029200786724686623, 0.036856357008218765, -0.02063768543303013, -0.06357056647539139, 0.01930832490324974, 0.006322694476693869, -0.03570513054728508, 0.027955012395977974, -0.06377466768026352, -0.02938995510339737, 0.00001962094393093139, 0.039689693599939346, 0.03151555731892586, -0.01368832029402256, 0.05311831459403038, 0.003772877622395754, -0.03826948627829552, 0.01843211241066456, 0.02420547418296337, -0.07473394274711609, -0.048163797706365585, -0.001935111708007753, -0.0022332272492349148, 0.011871364898979664, -0.027986420318484306, -0.019105419516563416, -0.006590323522686958, -0.05048900097608566, 0.02268625609576702, 0.0007503511151298881, -0.07287952303886414, -0.03035886026918888, 0.07226294279098511, -0.015658244490623474, -0.028443237766623497, -0.02866578847169876, -0.02111077308654785, -0.08260993659496307, 0.02814156748354435, 0.01687709614634514, 0.04821865260601044, 0.01282876543700695, -0.003490493167191744, 0.038446225225925446, -0.02979007177054882, -0.013470955193042755, -0.021449806168675423, 0.032459087669849396, -0.01932492107152939, 0.0012736851349473, 0.01583295688033104, 0.018641840666532516, -0.048967499285936356, -0.003421289846301079, -0.03300163522362709, -0.015514049679040909, 0.025107108056545258, -0.0251182671636343, -0.039914440363645554, -0.060657650232315063, -0.05433177947998047, 0.0725773498415947, -0.03766225278377533, -0.08311083167791367, -0.010615641251206398, -0.013939729891717434, -0.012000937014818192, -0.016246343031525612, 0.031107774004340172, -0.037950899451971054, 0.03162364289164543, -0.01744459569454193, -0.003965515643358231, 0.07486655563116074, -0.012610732577741146, -0.021747643128037453, 0.006903619505465031, 0.027770599350333214, -0.033582501113414764, 0.019384125247597694, -0.0026903378311544657, 0.0010304793249815702, -0.03680190443992615, 0.05214483290910721, -0.03992718085646629, 0.06519414484500885, 0.03541019558906555, -0.03929327428340912, 0.009302088059484959, 0.013182480819523335, -0.006903257220983505, -0.04847126826643944, 0.020462628453969955, 0.01497335359454155, -0.026856325566768646, -0.06656916439533234, 0.021735602989792824, -0.03864206001162529, 0.02016294375061989, -0.03294692561030388, -0.03893139213323593, 0.03929416090250015, 0.010028056800365448, 0.009366375394165516, 0.0019631392788141966, -0.009669031947851181, 0.045608654618263245, 0.015240390785038471, -0.034925058484077454, -0.012786619365215302, 0.05650204420089722, -0.0013620982645079494, -0.017572658136487007, -0.02028867043554783, -0.019707510247826576, 0.05270947888493538, 0.01603729836642742, 0.007332195062190294, -0.019380785524845123, -0.01208203099668026, -0.01138259656727314, -0.04868648201227188, -0.008484537713229656, 0.016081562265753746, -0.030842004343867302, -0.00915976706892252, -0.029177524149417877, -0.06136278808116913, -0.025871500372886658, -0.01605474017560482, 0.009089007042348385, 0.05818982049822807, -0.04194894805550575, -0.008290916681289673, 0.009094327688217163, -0.0017861750675365329, -0.013471340760588646, -0.03350934386253357, -0.007056254893541336, 0.000154007226228714, 0.016140464693307877, 0.015996599569916725, 0.01841682940721512, 0.07614171504974365, 0.01789272204041481, -0.08374454826116562, -0.06348086893558502, 0.04630868136882782, -0.03022656962275505, 0.023556575179100037, 0.053054168820381165, -0.002596976701170206, 0.01563028059899807, 0.025965547189116478, 0.011568040587008, -0.03285735473036766, 0.031592246145009995, 0.022257087752223015, 0.05268574506044388, -0.03623466566205025, -0.035014644265174866, 0.013461210764944553, -0.01080127153545618, 0.05246001109480858, 0.03076719306409359, 0.0011652298271656036, 0.041070401668548584, -0.049762748181819916, -0.03812015801668167, -0.003184117376804352, 0.0011513372883200645, 0.01334389578551054, -0.041581686586141586, -0.017270086333155632, 0.003080697264522314, -0.013534088619053364, 0.031736262142658234, 0.009507549926638603, -0.007032562512904406, 0.025274012237787247, 0.0038018105551600456, -0.1119893491268158, -0.013640573248267174, -0.027776332572102547, 0.0013508464908227324, 0.00613518338650465, -0.04904939606785774, 0.04505902901291847, -0.025306636467576027, 0.03352130949497223, -0.022401493042707443, 0.02790015935897827, 0.01959623023867607, -0.06695248931646347, -0.03598072752356529, 0.004244743846356869, -0.0064898584969341755, -0.0165102556347847, 0.010986763052642345, 0.055172376334667206, -0.018071996048092842, -0.012155648320913315, -0.002201021881774068, -0.0036565265618264675, -0.0002484855358488858, -0.017898010089993477, 0.03516874089837074, -0.0018149835523217916, 0.02401679940521717, -0.035727519541978836, -0.017997493967413902, -0.028323348611593246, 0.004260055720806122, 0.029084788635373116, -0.04430849477648735, 0.03643834963440895, -0.01570703275501728, -0.014171871356666088, -0.016409926116466522, 0.026934221386909485, 0.037400662899017334, 0.017461230978369713, 0.026822170242667198, 0.04486804082989693, -0.019134484231472015, -0.047871947288513184, 0.04419424757361412, -0.007631750777363777, -0.04362447187304497, 0.041204169392585754, -0.0022546746768057346, -0.011741619557142258, 0.02010774239897728, 0.00039711230783723295, -0.019450001418590546, 0.06885485351085663, -0.031395088881254196, 0.08208902180194855, 0.0009726541466079652, 0.06940945237874985, 0.04659924656152725, 0.026728413999080658, -0.006535098422318697, -0.03867131099104881, -0.013125530444085598, 0.04721768572926521, -0.002344488864764571, -0.030513346195220947, -0.032672133296728134, 0.0030162620823830366, 0.00019861091277562082, -0.006456416100263596, -0.033695038408041, 0.019650571048259735, 0.03613904491066933, -0.013292823918163776, 0.05703892558813095, 0.06402251869440079, 0.010612636804580688, 0.017520209774374962, 0.055871494114398956, 0.05587035417556763, -0.0437898151576519, -0.021723512560129166, 0.14171041548252106, 0.03043154813349247, 0.008242517709732056, -0.02394842356443405, -0.02599201910197735, 0.05964967608451843, 0.04565521702170372, -0.0025003973860293627, 0.013731461949646473, -0.044471558183431625, 0.04950905591249466, -0.013071296736598015, 0.04718032851815224, 0.005451234523206949, -0.0043198056519031525, 0.12520314753055573, -0.029565267264842987, -0.003602760611101985, -0.015017272904515266, -0.02280907891690731, 0.046695590019226074, -0.02659151703119278, -0.014276687987148762, -0.0491257943212986, -0.025601793080568314, -0.025363808497786522, 0.029559284448623657, -0.04097520932555199, -0.013726144097745419, -0.041932858526706696, -0.05176045373082161, 0.006980549078434706, -0.05694027617573738, -0.0030947134364396334, -0.009069505147635937, -0.05898386985063553, 0.025288505479693413, 0.06684765964746475, 0.03279658034443855, 0.06827469170093536, 0.025373773649334908, -0.08504480123519897, -0.06295697391033173, -0.055823471397161484, 0.0035382872447371483, -0.007383659947663546, 0.03850928694009781, -0.007216039579361677, 0.0334026962518692, 0.01521188486367464, 0.04138575866818428, -0.015260149724781513, -0.03716142848134041, -0.02569386176764965, -0.06410549581050873, -0.05975165218114853, -0.05358662083745003, 0.05353478714823723, -0.0034265208523720503, -0.015840400010347366, -0.027313528582453728, -0.035466860979795456, 0.06478651612997055, 0.0344843789935112, -0.035358499735593796, 0.05451430752873421, -0.024873441085219383, -0.0037721232511103153, -0.05908054858446121, -0.03622568026185036, -0.03607930615544319, 0.011015523225069046, -0.0004113056929782033, 0.009598635137081146, 0.020815281197428703, -0.04985247924923897, -0.045875631272792816, -0.03623327612876892, 0.008041707798838615, 0.0040180739015340805, 0.05080084502696991, 0.06912359595298767, -0.03367702662944794, 0.035148005932569504, 0.008493262343108654, 0.028222713619470596, -0.02104937471449375, -0.009893578477203846, 0.024333275854587555, 0.030524006113409996, 0.012505406513810158, -0.016966741532087326, 0.01276389043778181, 0.0049758353270590305, -0.007290794979780912, 0.045554790645837784, 0.02763049677014351, 0.0875450149178505, -0.03608240559697151, 0.01926713064312935, 0.009798405691981316, -0.04370556399226189, 0.02136952057480812, 0.025261422619223595, 0.06391981244087219, 0.04843390733003616, 0.028805429115891457, 0.05583299323916435, 0.045399170368909836, 0.011609869077801704, -0.04968294873833656, 0.049178432673215866, 0.0034618787467479706, 0.03600824996829033, 0.0036896702367812395, -0.01677650399506092, -0.04152093455195427, 0.03926679864525795, 0.028316082432866096, -0.014248988591134548, 0.018880028277635574, 0.012101637199521065, -0.015836013481020927, 0.05295770242810249, -0.04026098921895027, 0.010884820483624935, 0.06546700745820999, -0.0021373790223151445, 0.019637571647763252, -0.047660358250141144, 0.05574429780244827, 0.007713440805673599, -0.039861854165792465, -0.06273199617862701, -0.06914045661687851, 0.022156281396746635, -0.027481118217110634, 0.05343875288963318, -0.017895307391881943, 0.0822763592004776, -0.014995957724750042, 0.005474376492202282, -0.009266707114875317, 0.035684965550899506, 0.03525986149907112, -0.008150532841682434, 0.019696153700351715, -0.001010671490803361, 0.027605995535850525, 0.028935644775629044, 0.017086472362279892, -0.04584787040948868, 0.020643606781959534, -0.12270083278417587, 0.04425463452935219, 0.03031640127301216, 0.02630499377846718, 0.029472777619957924, -0.04583384096622467, 0.007857142947614193, 0.005673309322446585, -0.05443505197763443, -0.007128991652280092, 0.11285531520843506, -0.023212425410747528, -0.05178185552358627, -0.030566005036234856, 0.012424658983945847, -0.013257407583296299, -0.056024111807346344, -0.0520765446126461, -0.024321552366018295, -0.022666187956929207, -0.027880817651748657, 0.07755786925554276, 0.05929679423570633, -0.04782591015100479, 0.017474127933382988, -0.021015310660004616, 0.01644820161163807, -0.014577728696167469, -0.04641764238476753, 0.029153598472476006, 0.03760870546102524, -0.026042195037007332, -0.027639344334602356, -0.014612890779972076, -0.01968722604215145, -0.05153582990169525, -0.050940901041030884, 0.0018566492944955826, -0.053117018193006516, -0.016683515161275864, 0.015842514112591743, -0.0403437577188015, -0.03665431961417198, -0.00988710206001997, -0.044615454971790314, -0.00935928151011467, 0.02440236322581768, 0.007250872440636158, -0.059376806020736694, 0.01465035229921341, 0.032661329954862595, -0.02731589414179325, -0.018022067844867706, 0.03274953365325928, -0.004376406315714121, 0.04400646314024925, 0.012199967168271542, -0.05892396345734596, 0.013625381514430046, -0.004502547904849052, -0.02754371426999569, 0.013030357658863068, -0.010583517141640186, 0.06994437426328659, 0.05228262394666672, -0.008738982491195202, -0.00321521726436913, 0.005630254279822111, 0.03930801525712013, 0.03297216445207596, -0.086859792470932, -0.000751631916500628, -0.036604974418878555, -0.05008458346128464, 0.0036034290678799152, -0.0032345091458410025, -0.032063644379377365, 0.03768395259976387, 0.008994895033538342, 0.008456598035991192, 0.009643901139497757, -0.014220213517546654, -0.03751194849610329, -0.016992777585983276, -0.0360410138964653, 0.04881339147686958, 0.03132087364792824, -0.029910581186413765, -0.04474160075187683, -0.04263177141547203, -0.002936549251899123, -0.0038011574652045965, -0.021556619554758072, -0.027738550677895546, -0.027601314708590508, 0.02999575063586235, -0.0038760865572839975, -0.04622873663902283, -0.026357218623161316, 0.011997233144938946, -0.020632494240999222, -0.0006889835349284112, -0.005211534444242716, 0.05516096577048302, 0.038678254932165146, 0.008427867665886879, -0.025970177724957466, 0.01578233577311039, -0.07459156215190887, -0.0018968995427712798, 0.061073847115039825, -0.061266858130693436, 0.03531356155872345, 0.024974031373858452, 0.062047723680734634, -0.009125356562435627, -0.03433402255177498, 0.0026364661753177643, -0.00220800400711596, 0.04255428537726402, 0.035784099251031876, -0.0033823330886662006, 0.004690060392022133, 0.016195762902498245, 0.026410819962620735, -0.015612710267305374, 0.03247951716184616, -0.0509905070066452, 0.03613722324371338, 0.020479559898376465, -0.02925253100693226, -0.011123472824692726, 0.03204783797264099, 0.07042233645915985, 0.053831376135349274, 0.035707488656044006, -0.022148894146084785, 0.009633638896048069, -0.03336977958679199, 0.05001344159245491, 0.007239384111016989, 0.05135757848620415, 0.0015767032746225595, 0.015186233446002007, 0.005781513638794422, -0.05118445307016373, 0.034969452768564224, -0.00943303108215332, 0.017634974792599678, -0.05655759945511818, 0.07415395975112915, -0.03833624720573425, -0.003087781136855483, 0.04515552520751953, -0.024459976702928543, 0.0003882108139805496, -0.032617561519145966, 0.055232491344213486, 0.021561535075306892, -0.015800777822732925, 0.0023239946458488703, -0.04029090330004692, -0.004076357930898666, -0.008754037320613861, -0.02358398027718067, -0.036179643124341965, -0.03295250982046127, -0.034269802272319794, 0.03226799890398979, 0.021411921828985214, 0.02060086466372013, -0.026123035699129105, 0.0293247289955616, -0.032988615334033966, -0.06357753276824951, 0.06821935623884201, 0.05588372424244881, -0.04573008045554161, -0.006773681845515966, 0.005127971060574055, 0.004785172175616026, 0.02313077822327614, 0.002265405608341098, 0.026481427252292633, 0.015994679182767868, -0.059149619191884995, -0.06433339416980743, -0.012893231585621834, -0.013036432676017284, 0.051602497696876526 ]
<p>In semi-empirical quantum chemistry, one frequently encounters the so called <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_differential_overlap" rel="nofollow"><em>zero differential overlap</em></a> approximation</p> <p>$$\langle \mu \nu | \lambda \sigma \rangle = \delta_{\mu\nu}\delta_{\lambda\sigma} \langle \mu \mu | \lambda \lambda \rangle .$$</p> <p>Why is it rather not written as</p> <p>$$\langle \mu \nu | \lambda \sigma \rangle = \delta_{\mu\nu}\delta_{\lambda\sigma} \langle \mu \nu | \lambda \sigma \rangle = \langle \mu \mu | \lambda \lambda \rangle $$</p> <p>since on the right hand side of the first equation there are no $\nu$ nor $\sigma$ contained anymore. So either all four variables <strong>plus</strong> the Kronecker Deltas (middle expression of second equation), or only the "remaining" variables after evaluation of the Kronecker deltas (last expression of second equation).</p>
g9755
[ 0.007692979648709297, -0.062337446957826614, 0.007296132855117321, -0.007928685285151005, 0.045016098767519, 0.045737702399492264, 0.012113962322473526, 0.0065537854097783566, -0.07683181762695312, -0.02467464841902256, 0.027663683518767357, -0.010484268888831139, 0.009151137433946133, 0.05580764636397362, 0.023586004972457886, -0.028749851509928703, 0.04644158482551575, -0.011869095265865326, 0.07444202154874802, 0.029529588297009468, -0.1268068552017212, 0.03993280977010727, -0.030964169651269913, -0.08202370256185532, -0.015755778178572655, -0.038403987884521484, -0.006098192650824785, -0.05356606841087341, -0.06306272000074387, -0.05328112840652466, 0.00468780193477869, 0.03244251757860184, 0.08119381219148636, 0.03497050702571869, -0.02001260034739971, -0.009205065667629242, 0.06746392697095871, 0.030466673895716667, 0.044759176671504974, -0.04512416198849678, 0.0099467933177948, 0.004219174385070801, 0.030927475541830063, -0.013824749737977982, -0.03065425716340542, 0.004354201722890139, -0.031038600951433182, 0.05764327943325043, 0.008605487644672394, -0.017348602414131165, -0.0015351629117503762, 0.08373364806175232, 0.022481553256511688, 0.021656330674886703, 0.07059302926063538, 0.02754370868206024, 0.019577959552407265, -0.006424422841519117, 0.021690767258405685, 0.038253236562013626, 0.021911438554525375, -0.0004467597173061222, -0.015355916693806648, 0.0063462876714766026, 0.040874842554330826, 0.02259480580687523, -0.018229974433779716, -0.01865023374557495, 0.033119961619377136, 0.001271928078494966, -0.024229783564805984, -0.02974768541753292, -0.015271446667611599, 0.011196908541023731, 0.020155059173703194, -0.003982346970587969, 0.009693613275885582, -0.02250213362276554, -0.003101312555372715, -0.03649771958589554, -0.1289132535457611, 0.026406170800328255, 0.013230088166892529, -0.00861024484038353, 0.02387247048318386, 0.035343367606401443, -0.019647616893053055, 0.00654223095625639, 0.016598239541053772, 0.04138753190636635, 0.03390677273273468, -0.024690110236406326, -0.016524329781532288, -0.027986381202936172, -0.035606805235147476, -0.03004777804017067, -0.0388084314763546, 0.06921303272247314, 0.05585906282067299, -0.011103596538305283, 0.0021841528359800577, 0.041247107088565826, 0.008960627019405365, -0.0031908811070024967, -0.009247051551938057, 0.006389162037521601, 0.017438868060708046, 0.011592255905270576, -0.02888137847185135, 0.01311244536191225, -0.03530639782547951, 0.02703062817454338, -0.015272931195795536, -0.09451589733362198, 0.04432088881731033, -0.007262190338224173, 0.017923086881637573, -0.03362781181931496, -0.007670629303902388, 0.019275924190878868, 0.007648969069123268, 0.023730477318167686, 0.07424431294202805, 0.03351057320833206, 0.015905093401670456, -0.037235505878925323, -0.002149957697838545, -0.04734345152974129, 0.032972611486911774, -0.055224813520908356, 0.010868597775697708, 0.02200770564377308, -0.005586947314441204, 0.019018834456801414, 0.01528970804065466, -0.003979290835559368, -0.006863489281386137, -0.011885377578437328, -0.0405893474817276, 0.03723570704460144, 0.017061157152056694, -0.04481862857937813, 0.002329851035028696, -0.04520417004823685, -0.05251254141330719, -0.04078232869505882, -0.02497156336903572, -0.037350405007600784, -0.017628682777285576, -0.031012915074825287, 0.018998097628355026, 0.01735953986644745, 0.048587072640657425, 0.08150339871644974, -0.06763381510972977, 0.013491841033101082, 0.05408989265561104, -0.03125480189919472, -0.004791108425706625, 0.03232012689113617, 0.005885436665266752, 0.016934989020228386, 0.005461869295686483, 0.007649200968444347, 0.006149786524474621, 0.0423470064997673, 0.00034906319342553616, -0.07957468181848526, -0.04533509165048599, -0.07156410068273544, 0.006998779252171516, 0.04054306447505951, 0.021372396498918533, -0.022989552468061447, -0.020638052374124527, 0.08551386743783951, 0.07667934149503708, 0.002532034879550338, 0.008606204763054848, 0.04144006967544556, -0.01633409969508648, 0.004910061601549387, -0.002869056072086096, -0.033668894320726395, 0.012741281650960445, 0.032714758068323135, -0.025349382311105728, -0.00819152407348156, -0.056634802371263504, -0.043863505125045776, 0.022221824154257774, -0.0011244198540225625, 0.08244170993566513, 0.02002200298011303, -0.06340061128139496, 0.05844375863671303, 0.031849078834056854, -0.06464548408985138, -0.03445430099964142, 0.03184129670262337, -0.019813114777207375, 0.07935749739408493, 0.018426768481731415, -0.008360063657164574, -0.02594357170164585, 0.040510643273591995, -0.024021029472351074, -0.0005721020861528814, 0.04644325375556946, -0.026849942281842232, -0.0030760355293750763, -0.03707731515169144, 0.013180194422602654, 0.019861994311213493, -0.04332466423511505, -0.04944729432463646, 0.018818648532032967, -0.0014760536141693592, -0.0017903026891872287, 0.08141656965017319, -0.033907338976860046, -0.024055277928709984, 0.017296550795435905, 0.040435995906591415, 0.0013985323021188378, -0.01335358340293169, -0.0418987050652504, -0.027933897450566292, -0.010704931803047657, 0.0008826772100292146, -0.038398195058107376, -0.04400825500488281, -0.019260957837104797, 0.013518040999770164, 0.03573573753237724, 0.026457687839865685, 0.016011131927371025, 0.013800419867038727, 0.03858786076307297, 0.05758051574230194, 0.03798140212893486, 0.007329760584980249, -0.04031401872634888, 0.06276953965425491, 0.012048181146383286, -0.012250683270394802, 0.016831301152706146, 0.019046207889914513, -0.007934749126434326, 0.017262257635593414, -0.04471997916698456, 0.02218776009976864, 0.02343408577144146, -0.010594160296022892, 0.005667683202773333, -0.03972844034433365, -0.05777030438184738, -0.029527341946959496, 0.00018523693142924458, 0.0040490878745913506, 0.014659827575087547, 0.0022140133660286665, -0.0002036446239799261, -0.019975198432803154, -0.03198734670877457, 0.03554568067193031, -0.05150926485657692, 0.01147107221186161, 0.06225236505270004, -0.007197498343884945, -0.07373502105474472, 0.07319288700819016, 0.000642290513496846, 0.024467380717396736, -0.03685872629284859, 0.005079160910099745, -0.04313173145055771, 0.027644935995340347, -0.011711549945175648, 0.025980118662118912, 0.03934672474861145, -0.01309005543589592, 0.023013727739453316, 0.025626791641116142, -0.00670252600684762, -0.08422642201185226, 0.03946191444993019, 0.007004816550761461, -0.0008246814832091331, -0.042798493057489395, 0.05102986469864845, -0.00012818563845939934, -0.0165997501462698, -0.00021634731092490256, -0.021026965230703354, 0.012335010804235935, -0.002060474129393697, -0.009846579283475876, -0.010484015569090843, 0.03345969319343567, -0.007890956476330757, 0.013844420202076435, -0.00112414441537112, -0.011660362593829632, 0.027546793222427368, -0.005519052501767874, -0.028539877384901047, -0.04201273247599602, -0.04154377430677414, 0.02080501616001129, 0.03702225163578987, -0.018689369782805443, -0.013690601103007793, -0.012711280025541782, -0.053221751004457474, 0.008277819491922855, -0.03529854118824005, -0.026591025292873383, 0.009913026355206966, -0.004388308618217707, 0.008473883382976055, -0.02513408660888672, 0.05476422980427742, 0.026072677224874496, 0.015786651521921158, 0.012863787822425365, -0.024191832169890404, -0.002380678430199623, -0.05865377560257912, 0.02973209135234356, 0.04498540610074997, 0.01441245712339878, 0.029878558591008186, 0.0027718066703528166, -0.015637369826436043, -0.03290017321705818, -0.03889185190200806, -0.02004464715719223, 0.005074367392808199, 0.02002737857401371, -0.03329751640558243, -0.030917655676603317, 0.00868633110076189, 0.05375923961400986, 0.008544196374714375, -0.002436624839901924, 0.012153113260865211, 0.05144595354795456, -0.024009674787521362, -0.007525261491537094, 0.014248444698750973, 0.04460272938013077, -0.009911962784826756, 0.03526992350816727, 0.0037206015549600124, 0.03527124598622322, 0.019447194412350655, 0.0217781662940979, 0.02896958589553833, 0.02929217554628849, 0.04581022262573242, -0.014884943142533302, -0.020674388855695724, 0.021342262625694275, 0.02331598848104477, 0.03626586124300957, 0.03462573140859604, 0.059768930077552795, 0.008770952932536602, 0.002780022332444787, -0.01396050862967968, 0.0593450628221035, 0.00933779589831829, -0.018603956326842308, -0.003972744569182396, -0.06702691316604614, 0.0055979229509830475, 0.020048268139362335, -0.03242570906877518, 0.02987584099173546, 0.028159096837043762, -0.025512410327792168, -0.02802172675728798, 0.04417799040675163, 0.021370109170675278, -0.03928060084581375, -0.04701667279005051, -0.013186550699174404, -0.012851467356085777, -0.005621742457151413, -0.0022023420315235853, 0.03880317509174347, 0.0185772106051445, 0.07226631045341492, -0.010798853822052479, -0.042528726160526276, 0.040788110345602036, 0.03266651928424835, -0.019922873005270958, 0.03790322691202164, -0.0470048151910305, -0.012357407249510288, 0.023337407037615776, -0.015299363061785698, -0.0286884643137455, 0.0008418126381002367, -0.033939216285943985, -0.007782942149788141, 0.03255361691117287, -0.008151563815772533, 0.02448536455631256, -0.030237192288041115, -0.041638802736997604, 0.03222820907831192, 0.0243695005774498, -0.010980811901390553, 0.014637168496847153, -0.04008390009403229, -0.06953047215938568, -0.010543105192482471, -0.002393377013504505, 0.02509852685034275, -0.009666181169450283, 0.02469603531062603, 0.04896226152777672, -0.022463282570242882, -0.008448091335594654, 0.017785219475626945, 0.029182488098740578, -0.04297979548573494, -0.03671718016266823, 0.02594694495201111, 0.030711863189935684, 0.03381110355257988, -0.048232439905405045, 0.015631742775440216, -0.017363525927066803, 0.08404306322336197, -0.0403105691075325, 0.10723284631967545, 0.026670636609196663, -0.028541013598442078, -0.01306618470698595, -0.006262625101953745, -0.0015957402065396309, -0.02162424474954605, -0.040126901119947433, -0.034903306514024734, 0.032998133450746536, -0.012457374483346939, -0.08006788045167923, 0.02269577421247959, -0.005306755192577839, 0.022639146074652672, 0.031839556992053986, -0.03159473091363907, -0.02359156310558319, 0.028002247214317322, -0.007854231633245945, 0.035147033631801605, -0.04163587465882301, -0.021191652864217758, -0.004472765605896711, 0.03167412802577019, -0.006925022229552269, -0.04303127899765968, -0.07114897668361664, 0.003394461004063487, -0.06416448205709457, -0.023507118225097656, -0.0016436027362942696, 0.07518012076616287, 0.024551542475819588, 0.0019996005576103926, 0.044113680720329285, -0.04760359972715378, -0.010812372900545597, 0.003721130546182394, -0.0437467060983181, -0.04788229614496231, 0.0014457738725468516, -0.01682102121412754, 0.008748999796807766, 0.06302100419998169, 0.0260494165122509, 0.03365735337138176, 0.020540470257401466, -0.11348122358322144, -0.023575102910399437, 0.04512479901313782, 0.07828419655561447, 0.010856511071324348, 0.011799926869571209, -0.006888893432915211, -0.010474923998117447, 0.05240977182984352, -0.0035962045658379793, -0.0217685978859663, 0.03916332870721817, -0.005287475883960724, -0.056530874222517014, 0.01817581057548523, -0.014929334633052349, -0.04832024127244949, -0.00803097803145647, 0.03449540212750435, 0.028754597529768944, 0.0068856459110975266, -0.009751263074576855, -0.005571190733462572, 0.008706673979759216, -0.0006175243179313838, 0.02017250843346119, 0.0199903417378664, -0.044766537845134735, 0.02878352627158165, -0.02406165562570095, 0.04195712134242058, -0.05017619952559471, -0.10409659892320633, 0.03633125126361847, -0.01243024691939354, -0.045966800302267075, -0.0002680780889932066, 0.033920735120773315, -0.031825676560401917, 0.017348194494843483, -0.06832268089056015, -0.02773023024201393, 0.04860411584377289, 0.011389567516744137, 0.038675036281347275, 0.0010125036351382732, 0.014982902444899082, 0.00881288293749094, -0.06733740121126175, 0.005073721054941416, 0.03560328483581543, -0.0303035881370306, -0.008701138198375702, -0.0047232103534042835, 0.01770283468067646, -0.027104243636131287, 0.10100068151950836, -0.03342511132359505, -0.023963037878274918, 0.04491889849305153, 0.001435834332369268, 0.00390599831007421, -0.08310215175151825, -0.01784941554069519, -0.0025635957717895508, -0.03089768812060356, 0.018034091219305992, 0.01677948422729969, -0.025279754772782326, 0.033099427819252014, -0.016104048117995262, -0.01263128500431776, -0.010287823155522346, -0.019663525745272636, -0.03696039319038391, -0.021270042285323143, 0.013632560148835182, -0.04932988062500954, -0.05928441509604454, -0.05709056928753853, -0.0376361608505249, 0.003328626975417137, 0.024696335196495056, -0.029400043189525604, 0.018294386565685272, -0.01885882019996643, 0.010967161506414413, 0.024119842797517776, 0.043414633721113205, -0.0017140352865681052, -0.03627756983041763, -0.005844615865498781, 0.01558645348995924, -0.025807585567235947, 0.007773141842335463, -0.022806212306022644, -0.040226634591817856, -0.046501174569129944, -0.0288966353982687, 0.004457887262105942, 0.023794377222657204, 0.045391663908958435, 0.03759310394525528, -0.017778759822249413, -0.007216856349259615, -0.010999225080013275, -0.0014823487726971507, 0.0234938133507967, -0.019211703911423683, 0.004371223039925098, 0.03780268505215645, -0.03540639579296112, -0.0242654737085104, 0.03984599560499191, -0.01618078723549843, 0.05935634300112724, 0.01623314805328846, 0.04958895221352577, -0.03581371158361435, -0.06394996494054794, -0.0185929536819458, -0.058675091713666916, 0.04918748140335083, -0.0028347717598080635, 0.011737650260329247, -0.010692697018384933, 0.017910288646817207, -0.022662656381726265, -0.14140143990516663, -0.07667052000761032, 0.05048227682709694, -0.04201722890138626, 0.06153707951307297, 0.0391237847507, -0.04929677024483681, 0.014769239351153374, 0.02178312838077545, -0.01031468715518713, 0.06628020107746124, -0.03770429268479347, 0.013382937759160995, 0.016305701807141304, -0.019519533962011337, 0.027593059465289116, 0.0203006099909544, -0.007128536701202393, -0.00025572083541192114, 0.00627924082800746, 0.03197014331817627, -0.05449380353093147, 0.0322047658264637, 0.019546708092093468, 0.07812254130840302, -0.026126978918910027, 0.031324487179517746, 0.13172689080238342, 0.0006019349093548954, -0.015400990843772888, -0.012835257686674595, 0.029252447187900543, 0.01496143639087677, -0.08006428927183151, 0.0030101819429546595, 0.07381214201450348, 0.009661417454481125, -0.02249661274254322, -0.01620914600789547, 0.003069226397201419, 0.021946579217910767, 0.040801528841257095, -0.017864087596535683, -0.005881572142243385, -0.02931034192442894, -0.023303160443902016, -0.03351262956857681, -0.019172416999936104, 0.02647947147488594, 0.010035245679318905, 0.044229570776224136, 0.04583393782377243, -0.0461355522274971, -0.023069769144058228, 0.0531173013150692, 0.0016601417446509004, -0.058767687529325485, -0.0015668973792344332, -0.021780215203762054, 0.03339042887091637, -0.0035298920702189207, 0.02136261761188507, 0.002968498971313238, -0.013141636736690998, -0.02649196982383728, 0.025267478078603745, -0.030849942937493324, -0.01742454245686531, -0.032009076327085495, -0.03651609271764755, 0.01235944777727127, 0.03139347955584526, 0.009554525837302208, 0.009050337597727776, 0.05111347883939743, 0.028931457549333572, 0.017021862789988518, 0.029792914167046547, -0.025153284892439842, 0.008883822709321976, 0.04826771467924118, 0.038571007549762726, 0.0027554098051041365, 0.001512734917923808, 0.0115211121737957, 0.10454317927360535, -0.027330880984663963, 0.021584006026387215, -0.01925876922905445, 0.05764531344175339, 0.025661271065473557, -0.004461175296455622, -0.023263443261384964, 0.008120962418615818, -0.034285351634025574, 0.03738050535321236, 0.0018808088498190045, -0.010033435188233852, 0.03265281394124031, 0.05383724346756935, -0.052600838243961334, -0.027956746518611908, -0.026669226586818695, -0.031662046909332275, -0.03839201107621193, -0.04091785475611687, -0.025021830573678017, -0.02072645165026188, -0.06347079575061798, -0.03931901976466179, -0.033598627895116806, -0.04111287742853165, 0.00998725276440382, 0.021818075329065323, 0.0073292450979352, -0.07541907578706741, -0.0035284264013171196, -0.02588677778840065, 0.04790258780121803, -0.07004168629646301, -0.01696745492517948, -0.02775311842560768, 0.05995077267289162, 0.018427062779664993, -0.0455709733068943, -0.008013241924345493, -0.06223755329847336, 0.006268931087106466, 0.009772758930921555, 0.02833344228565693, -0.05450265854597092, -0.00011112260835943744, -0.00948840007185936, 0.0597776398062706, -0.022695982828736305, -0.05909357964992523, 0.0790429562330246, -0.0699080303311348, 0.09811600297689438, 0.10321541875600815, -0.0371665395796299, 0.05785362422466278, 0.01914183981716633, -0.02507198043167591, 0.0339510440826416, -0.017840979620814323, -0.054901037365198135, -0.021542128175497055, 0.030013026669621468, -0.027215123176574707, -0.02584795095026493, -0.046565208584070206, -0.010487952269613743 ]
<p>Right after take-off (which means an airplane already exceeded V1) it is recommended that an airplane keeps climbing even when emergency occurs. Beside worries of crashing into houses and buildings by flying low altitude, why should an airplane not stop climbing up? Why should it climb up and then, lowers to some altitude and then land?</p>
g9756
[ 0.0462728887796402, 0.011660817079246044, -0.010590808466076851, 0.09215277433395386, -0.005153552163392305, 0.061720993369817734, 0.0005692624254152179, 0.01554262638092041, -0.04825921356678009, 0.016255147755146027, -0.008433472365140915, 0.010753979906439781, 0.021925348788499832, 0.008692839182913303, 0.021761827170848846, 0.02609020657837391, -0.05647139996290207, -0.06428525596857071, -0.018993834033608437, -0.05342414602637291, -0.07186930626630783, -0.0035538976080715656, 0.04930941015481949, 0.02511885017156601, -0.13852062821388245, 0.016758810728788376, -0.012629161588847637, -0.006841202732175589, -0.02406817488372326, 0.011819752864539623, 0.02335057593882084, -0.032436005771160126, 0.015522734262049198, -0.01164270006120205, -0.003930120728909969, -0.036085449159145355, 0.016055528074502945, 0.024365732446312904, -0.014219320379197598, -0.0007692445069551468, -0.009510325267910957, -0.02245277538895607, -0.02807188592851162, 0.025368908420205116, -0.009550157003104687, 0.03749283030629158, 0.007518347352743149, -0.0068505797535181046, 0.016448533162474632, -0.003857659874483943, 0.007865291088819504, 0.0425565205514431, -0.042485080659389496, 0.022732850164175034, 0.009052974171936512, 0.00044381304178386927, 0.05922679975628853, 0.03117920458316803, 0.008762170560657978, 0.03820919618010521, -0.00919787585735321, 0.005669751204550266, 0.009205400943756104, 0.01843932829797268, 0.04129897058010101, 0.0016928971745073795, -0.06176786497235298, 0.002858266932889819, 0.04045375436544418, 0.005729928147047758, 0.0035656134132295847, -0.0961318165063858, -0.05653218924999237, 0.050841160118579865, -0.029517199844121933, -0.028869174420833588, 0.04017828777432442, -0.06256343424320221, 0.05256054550409317, -0.0006406854372471571, -0.014347836375236511, 0.06581312417984009, 0.021070154383778572, -0.05752090364694595, -0.011013126000761986, 0.0241936594247818, 0.0018207913963124156, -0.03008810430765152, 0.008082236163318157, -0.017039386555552483, 0.025837522000074387, 0.004780469462275505, 0.037808287888765335, -0.015108457766473293, -0.007720760069787502, -0.04135117307305336, 0.020154885947704315, 0.06107047572731972, -0.017802489921450615, -0.027236444875597954, -0.006254647858440876, -0.06372194737195969, -0.02225949801504612, -0.020968854427337646, -0.07190867513418198, -0.037132613360881805, 0.06282582879066467, 0.03027704916894436, 0.025505071505904198, -0.04535989835858345, -0.01234478410333395, 0.009680367074906826, 0.02037331834435463, -0.0211164690554142, 0.004995371680706739, 0.019194237887859344, 0.04987623542547226, -0.0018593105487525463, -0.028312494978308678, -0.02937176078557968, -0.011075444519519806, -0.0566239133477211, 0.05461995676159859, -0.025683866813778877, 0.004976606462150812, -0.0693703293800354, 0.057853829115629196, -0.02549157477915287, -0.04538905248045921, -0.027326783165335655, 0.010522611439228058, 0.04135701432824135, -0.0832335352897644, 0.04139428213238716, 0.032864898443222046, -0.01716558262705803, -0.02598934806883335, -0.02008196711540222, 0.04123839735984802, -0.016942618414759636, -0.014583409763872623, 0.040444329380989075, 0.020038573071360588, -0.007311942521482706, 0.014781365171074867, 0.05167168378829956, 0.025374943390488625, 0.05797645077109337, 0.0324278362095356, -0.0016599406953901052, -0.03264593705534935, -0.012478932738304138, -0.01040597166866064, -0.006955013610422611, 0.01139842439442873, 0.024040307849645615, 0.02032395265996456, 0.014019605703651905, 0.01848776452243328, 0.04071804881095886, 0.03198334947228432, -0.027220964431762695, -0.03170022740960121, 0.048186954110860825, -0.07965358346700668, 0.0390528105199337, -0.020904986187815666, -0.0007228048052638769, -0.03543434664607048, 0.03390401229262352, -0.020342031493782997, 0.011969496496021748, 0.009277443401515484, -0.0316179096698761, 0.0576833076775074, -0.0017875859048217535, 0.07205626368522644, -0.022861355915665627, 0.035225797444581985, -0.04923789203166962, -0.008116032928228378, -0.001570307184010744, 0.003179523628205061, 0.041686758399009705, 0.007564951200038195, -0.038346465677022934, 0.011406708508729935, 0.008094202727079391, -0.04888805001974106, -0.012093842960894108, 0.05140720307826996, -0.06700655072927475, 0.040347129106521606, 0.0008677018922753632, -0.06783519685268402, -0.025746751576662064, 0.03535570949316025, -0.00812791008502245, -0.07369551062583923, 0.04507676139473915, 0.020200425758957863, -0.045758675783872604, 0.03601711988449097, -0.03426332026720047, -0.02999947965145111, 0.04304997995495796, 0.001542185782454908, -0.004598596133291721, -0.01057378202676773, -0.04390333965420723, -0.005374910309910774, -0.018134262412786484, 0.04190950468182564, 0.0036595321726053953, -0.027517123147845268, -0.013777317479252815, 0.032606981694698334, -0.013031338341534138, 0.04255159944295883, 0.017693325877189636, -0.012142845429480076, 0.011140407994389534, -0.0017085598083212972, -0.05244056507945061, -0.01990816742181778, 0.008145023137331009, -0.027271674945950508, -0.07663296908140182, 0.025628671050071716, -0.06803034245967865, -0.017816947773098946, -0.01476703118532896, -0.027979373931884766, -0.06553340703248978, 0.04216431826353073, -0.05442981794476509, 0.045802995562553406, 0.028420019894838333, 0.032036714255809784, 0.019909948110580444, 0.020259562879800797, 0.005340298172086477, 0.07121206820011139, -0.012383255176246166, 0.010047131218016148, -0.06877174973487854, -0.03462930768728256, -0.015534546226263046, 0.005266122054308653, 0.007317281793802977, -0.015101270750164986, -0.03456318750977516, -0.018765389919281006, 0.015498126856982708, 0.00563849275931716, -0.04498336836695671, -0.0002655471907928586, 0.03880009055137634, 0.05106210336089134, 0.03927250951528549, -0.00003780905171879567, 0.0282047837972641, 0.0025556425098329782, -0.032253433018922806, -0.09225749969482422, 0.03834710642695427, -0.0448322556912899, 0.0537090040743351, -0.002580358413979411, -0.030381983146071434, -0.017247222363948822, 0.016624214127659798, -0.01737343519926071, 0.07739941775798798, 0.020384568721055984, -0.026370596140623093, -0.047236159443855286, 0.0011386307887732983, 0.03659101575613022, 0.04528343304991722, -0.003854096867144108, -0.023137999698519707, -0.06400143355131149, -0.017528854310512543, 0.026859771460294724, -0.027750512585043907, 0.030433498322963715, -0.008679448626935482, -0.07521927356719971, -0.05363323539495468, -0.0013544484972953796, 0.009324825368821621, 0.011137006804347038, -0.0065169017761945724, 0.034135714173316956, 0.016890311613678932, -0.002996790688484907, -0.02823713794350624, 0.0035796344745904207, 0.022093258798122406, -0.017306257039308548, -0.06394009292125702, 0.03369421884417534, -0.037269227206707, -0.028048915788531303, 0.05460866540670395, 0.04377332329750061, 0.0260414220392704, -0.082876056432724, 0.017400968819856644, 0.0027703256346285343, 0.01445110235363245, -0.01824670284986496, -0.008386213332414627, 0.010053192265331745, 0.032026082277297974, -0.008951406925916672, -0.015004229731857777, 0.008756035938858986, -0.025087367743253708, -0.06581868976354599, -0.020363014191389084, -0.027897266671061516, 0.013318699784576893, -0.003925180993974209, 0.0582282729446888, 0.00008279306348413229, 0.05366580933332443, 0.06010447070002556, 0.005317215342074633, 0.07288710027933121, 0.037535540759563446, 0.004495806526392698, -0.022808076813817024, -0.014711163006722927, -0.030601616948843002, 0.013883713632822037, 0.031559064984321594, -0.002499108202755451, 0.039279501885175705, -0.05707526206970215, 0.020349685102701187, 0.05715351551771164, 0.01681973971426487, 0.061726074665784836, -0.009131823666393757, 0.020914888009428978, -0.019100988283753395, 0.020381199195981026, -0.04577450826764107, 0.006429978180676699, -0.02204890176653862, 0.002257254207506776, -0.00046651976299472153, -0.04695872217416763, 0.04337562248110771, 0.004987938795238733, 0.015883687883615494, -0.057809483259916306, -0.021660756319761276, 0.011144942604005337, 0.04616251587867737, 0.022183220833539963, 0.03340182080864906, 0.017763391137123108, -0.007827138528227806, -0.06494306027889252, 0.0754847452044487, -0.008033797144889832, -0.0023375290911644697, 0.07393233478069305, 0.05221569910645485, -0.05440930649638176, -0.005879492033272982, -0.03711763024330139, -0.020095044746994972, 0.0767645537853241, 0.008755303919315338, 0.02694755792617798, -0.026797737926244736, 0.06314851343631744, -0.006142540834844112, -0.0003120403562206775, -0.03750649094581604, 0.015503866598010063, -0.0016253036446869373, -0.028030984103679657, -0.013817132450640202, 0.03845851123332977, 0.01732180081307888, -0.01359914243221283, -0.03620663657784462, 0.013915457762777805, 0.05601242929697037, 0.020409371703863144, 0.01580941677093506, 0.005752826575189829, 0.03428236022591591, 0.002577879000455141, 0.013071318157017231, 0.011893506161868572, 0.015913112089037895, -0.05440021678805351, 0.03822118416428566, 0.025187790393829346, 0.010245234705507755, 0.03491329401731491, -0.002153431996703148, -0.0061244061216712, -0.01779576763510704, 0.0797581821680069, 0.025347594171762466, -0.04268333315849304, -0.027307499200105667, -0.017491064965724945, -0.03062419593334198, 0.05783675238490105, 0.012814279645681381, 0.07844973355531693, 0.03465927764773369, 0.07025212794542313, 0.03563378378748894, 0.016911720857024193, -0.04655785486102104, 0.0030316615011543036, 0.031248630955815315, -0.04608245566487312, 0.00490723829716444, -0.0225394107401371, -0.005057880654931068, 0.027674270793795586, 0.04957552254199982, -0.019757933914661407, -0.047508273273706436, -0.03032894805073738, 0.037453144788742065, 0.04176266863942146, 0.0897313579916954, -0.02065366320312023, -0.017508041113615036, 0.03486979007720947, 0.02785094641149044, -0.00991437491029501, 0.029683079570531845, 0.042620155960321426, 0.015098254196345806, -0.00854469370096922, 0.030670326203107834, 0.041136521846055984, 0.05912863090634346, -0.0375693254172802, 0.01028229296207428, 0.06877288967370987, -0.017284289002418518, -0.024840787053108215, -0.06614624708890915, -0.013762530870735645, -0.03843921422958374, 0.030825745314359665, 0.04148996248841286, 0.06022268906235695, -0.05003809183835983, -0.02624812163412571, 0.03436747565865517, -0.009981542825698853, 0.0010416042059659958, -0.06508872658014297, -0.030470790341496468, 0.00331334606744349, 0.013699270784854889, -0.05182567611336708, 0.032887887209653854, -0.018129847943782806, 0.09995206445455551, 0.017614660784602165, 0.01996631920337677, 0.020513536408543587, -0.004068425390869379, 0.0054589263163506985, -0.04195599630475044, 0.07100074738264084, -0.04263276979327202, -0.07314913719892502, 0.009190522134304047, -0.001006387290544808, -0.03861108422279358, -0.0066826012916862965, -0.045489825308322906, 0.05777321383357048, -0.0034042978659272194, 0.08196289837360382, 0.08695755898952484, -0.006545573472976685, -0.012777382507920265, -0.03980393335223198, -0.08221804350614548, -0.04480711743235588, 0.03269003704190254, 0.03378075733780861, -0.06895400583744049, -0.009011154063045979, -0.04354056715965271, 0.01297799777239561, -0.03492496535181999, -0.047017280012369156, -0.033692654222249985, 0.03211953863501549, -0.012122008949518204, 0.023956315591931343, -0.011594395153224468, -0.030023708939552307, -0.03995399922132492, 0.028930798172950745, 0.02048862725496292, 0.010025239549577236, -0.023280026391148567, 0.017942022532224655, 0.032590512186288834, -0.008408169262111187, 0.016712374985218048, 0.016173845157027245, -0.027391942217946053, -0.0005113303777761757, -0.016705546528100967, 0.02670242078602314, -0.007717751897871494, 0.006366569083184004, -0.054888710379600525, 0.039244379848241806, 0.05112074688076973, 0.008865304291248322, -0.02706853300333023, -0.007768494077026844, 0.029114659875631332, 0.0010514637688174844, 0.05065388232469559, -0.050440479069948196, -0.023828640580177307, 0.03768929839134216, 0.006579355336725712, -0.034061431884765625, -0.0023524679709225893, -0.010785840451717377, 0.08687254041433334, 0.013280020095407963, -0.06777697056531906, -0.011367536149919033, 0.045317456126213074, 0.02971864491701126, 0.018707580864429474, -0.029506340622901917, -0.04329885542392731, -0.046668678522109985, 0.0033142217434942722, -0.023116467520594597, -0.015692653134465218, 0.026911737397313118, 0.04715178534388542, -0.028007354587316513, -0.05132465809583664, 0.01659524068236351, -0.03447641059756279, 0.004040958825498819, 0.0205626729875803, 0.05820496752858162, -0.01693141646683216, 0.03289920091629028, 0.012304617092013359, 0.003067336045205593, -0.01735779456794262, -0.03345102444291115, 0.059918854385614395, 0.0342305563390255, 0.04088945686817169, -0.008091175928711891, 0.02276809886097908, -0.02618749812245369, -0.036608319729566574, 0.017476191744208336, -0.04090363159775734, -0.026532279327511787, 0.01573999971151352, 0.029055112972855568, -0.07474002242088318, -0.03707556799054146, -0.061778150498867035, -0.03038928098976612, -0.025532599538564682, 0.029064062982797623, 0.011014040559530258, -0.04648444056510925, 0.028018908575177193, 0.009827647358179092, 0.03379440680146217, 0.01862969808280468, -0.07111004739999771, -0.012624397873878479, 0.009328040294349194, -0.004245850257575512, -0.035478100180625916, 0.07644914090633392, 0.024196244776248932, 0.005517909768968821, -0.027794934809207916, -0.0019224697025492787, 0.037504732608795166, 0.08395794779062271, 0.012543577700853348, 0.04547639191150665, 0.0021278683561831713, -0.021211057901382446, 0.012504613026976585, 0.03431980311870575, 0.0016135163605213165, -0.005448489915579557, -0.03470117598772049, 0.029499707743525505, 0.024070896208286285, 0.0012136460281908512, -0.016054172068834305, -0.009392786771059036, -0.02712707407772541, 0.007128812372684479, -0.019071178510785103, -0.036236800253391266, -0.005143680144101381, 0.02681206539273262, 0.033174969255924225, 0.058200765401124954, 0.060185644775629044, -0.06161098927259445, 0.021742476150393486, -0.04714043810963631, 0.049530886113643646, -0.03894178569316864, 0.005114073399454355, 0.007475470658391714, 0.020248401910066605, -0.0018245845567435026, -0.023176925256848335, -0.017469186335802078, -0.0003110869147349149, 0.012008914723992348, -0.044306643307209015, -0.0031341705471277237, -0.007128912955522537, -0.02306067757308483, -0.06468554586172104, 0.005067108664661646, -0.002197515917941928, 0.04090719297528267, -0.07076576352119446, -0.037494804710149765, -0.050616759806871414, -0.023125076666474342, -0.03881071135401726, -0.020474283024668694, -0.001777982572093606, -0.032786786556243896, -0.016749002039432526, 0.04304373264312744, 0.022909702733159065, -0.02725333906710148, 0.03129258379340172, -0.02569112926721573, -0.022796280682086945, 0.025084329769015312, -0.08583668619394302, -0.0033643299248069525, 0.02973894216120243, -0.006678761448711157, 0.0073741646483540535, 0.008611861616373062, -0.076051265001297, 0.03269153833389282, 0.007866381667554379, -0.0298321396112442, -0.009975557215511799, 0.03227818384766579, 0.052163016051054, 0.033327456563711166, -0.04903198406100273, 0.006604979280382395, -0.0570068322122097, 0.0474163293838501, 0.08195537328720093, -0.022166168317198753, 0.031728554517030716, -0.010155832394957542, -0.014604887925088406, -0.03471333160996437, -0.02507828362286091, 0.014962418004870415, -0.04452189803123474, -0.016478460282087326, 0.024580590426921844, -0.04257494956254959, -0.053897157311439514, -0.05176158621907234, -0.04224115610122681, 0.0237991102039814, -0.007825339213013649, 0.0433952659368515, -0.04804680868983269, -0.0635685995221138, 0.03148316964507103, 0.03389405459165573, 0.02713552676141262, -0.023159772157669067, -0.011130166240036488, -0.04452497512102127, -0.001398867228999734, 0.02822975069284439, 0.010902832262217999, -0.03584228456020355, -0.00003737940642167814, 0.07996661961078644, -0.07330671697854996, -0.07059633731842041, 0.023668624460697174, -0.005684616509824991, -0.034394022077322006, -0.05470030754804611, -0.10225167125463486, -0.016771666705608368, 0.07753363996744156, -0.024524495005607605, -0.05664899945259094, 0.0286867693066597, -0.04502491652965546, -0.008893100544810295, 0.019921930506825447, 0.008091526105999947, 0.022134151309728622, 0.005561960395425558, 0.004419954493641853, 0.01215317752212286, 0.01610952988266945, -0.008725369349122047, -0.014752138406038284, 0.006691485643386841, 0.045088645070791245, 0.00486869877204299, 0.05973154678940773, 0.0016769722569733858, -0.04705812782049179, 0.07208869606256485, -0.009947697632014751, 0.03722965344786644, 0.0012012680526822805, -0.034330643713474274, -0.0006971093243919313, 0.016552820801734924, 0.03721333295106888, -0.017018906772136688, 0.01856992021203041, -0.03392497077584267, -0.07075764238834381, 0.015211310237646103, -0.017680887132883072, 0.00048517819959670305, 0.015183446928858757, 0.027538307011127472, -0.028575072064995766, 0.01897468790411949, -0.05409073829650879, -0.05154974013566971, 0.013854525052011013 ]
<p>Can someone explain the difference between hopping and tunneling? The context I'm considering is conduction in semiconductors, specifically between impurity states within the bandgap. It's always been my understanding that hopping <em>is</em> tunneling. Variable range hopping and nearest neighbor hopping, as I understand it, are both forms of tunneling between overlapping states (for example, see <a href="http://igitur-archive.library.uu.nl/dissertations/2002-0806-101243/c4.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://igitur-archive.library.uu.nl/dissertations/2002-0806-101243/c4.pdf</a>). However, in papers such as DJ Thouless 1974 <em>Electrons in Disordered Systems and the Theory of Localization</em>, hopping and tunneling are described as two different processes. I guess I don't exactly understand what "hopping" is supposed to mean, with respect to charge transport.</p>
g9757
[ 0.017535127699375153, -0.001266757259145379, -0.02069205604493618, 0.07048125565052032, -0.019252609461545944, 0.023075925186276436, -0.013116988353431225, 0.025864683091640472, 0.03549899905920029, -0.014828781597316265, -0.03371400013566017, 0.016960173845291138, 0.021675867959856987, 0.004822751507163048, -0.035013191401958466, -0.06164853274822235, 0.014408957213163376, 0.02487838827073574, 0.023286152631044388, 0.0011027127038687468, -0.020156657323241234, 0.024109095335006714, 0.018638459965586662, -0.015781091526150703, -0.004368549678474665, -0.04940423741936684, -0.02110358700156212, -0.02962385304272175, 0.006143548525869846, -0.002702295547351241, 0.032650548964738846, -0.06764085590839386, 0.04896808788180351, -0.03041670098900795, -0.030836686491966248, 0.0028971154242753983, 0.010661223903298378, -0.03729144483804703, 0.024739209562540054, 0.024433555081486702, 0.035247836261987686, 0.03498098999261856, 0.008134470321238041, -0.018413234502077103, -0.02559952810406685, -0.008737655356526375, -0.04075641557574272, 0.030278105288743973, 0.02589317224919796, 0.004794611595571041, -0.021507807075977325, 0.04723373427987099, 0.025342538952827454, 0.009254504926502705, 0.08284774422645569, -0.07425467669963837, -0.022424178197979927, 0.025532551109790802, 0.049930963665246964, -0.008028347045183182, 0.08052044361829758, 0.033935293555259705, -0.04022098332643509, -0.01408226415514946, 0.07576324790716171, 0.02854706160724163, -0.040953442454338074, 0.007401311304420233, -0.0020240352023392916, -0.02035435475409031, 0.05757247284054756, -0.0384892001748085, -0.07351889461278915, -0.0502927228808403, 0.01009379606693983, -0.019337967038154602, -0.0013889246620237827, -0.030286096036434174, 0.05467186123132706, 0.023821555078029633, -0.04973176494240761, -0.009036180563271046, 0.00044054471072740853, -0.0077878376469016075, 0.08906849473714828, -0.01243746280670166, -0.0019354629330337048, 0.00743135716766119, -0.011016772128641605, 0.02512221969664097, -0.059908851981163025, -0.010391147807240486, 0.04397493600845337, -0.006606577895581722, -0.09508854895830154, -0.04497415944933891, -0.06859835982322693, 0.05666712298989296, -0.00600087596103549, 0.02848077565431595, -0.01888786070048809, -0.06531252712011337, 0.04029493406414986, 0.0010730181820690632, 0.013150623068213463, -0.040005434304475784, -0.047715380787849426, -0.0017443960532546043, 0.022559717297554016, 0.026529014110565186, -0.0456111803650856, -0.018941422924399376, 0.045645229518413544, 0.013875527307391167, -0.0022626963909715414, 0.04845326393842697, -0.015066352672874928, 0.03340332582592964, 0.02553800493478775, -0.020561160519719124, 0.01965695433318615, 0.0376589410007, -0.024555496871471405, 0.019318455830216408, 0.05855734646320343, 0.046607259660959244, -0.034110285341739655, -0.04432886838912964, 0.023846209049224854, 0.061739932745695114, -0.030026420950889587, -0.00381875061430037, -0.0035480535589158535, 0.01809987612068653, -0.040623754262924194, -0.027359995990991592, 0.08547728508710861, -0.009948944672942162, 0.00993893202394247, 0.008949683047831059, 0.04036999121308327, -0.022812694311141968, 0.008131356909871101, -0.0911373421549797, 0.021537097170948982, -0.0008249687380157411, -0.01908036507666111, -0.022553330287337303, 0.030570300295948982, -0.025560233741998672, -0.0024667761754244566, 0.07632216811180115, 0.01254548504948616, -0.05720748007297516, -0.003303049597889185, -0.02500346675515175, 0.03659898415207863, -0.007923049852252007, 0.05709131434559822, 0.04848400875926018, -0.015103279612958431, -0.044456228613853455, 0.014052817597985268, -0.003018330316990614, 0.023351557552814484, -0.016398105770349503, 0.03430695831775665, -0.03840550407767296, -0.011304899118840694, -0.0448896549642086, 0.0007820731843821704, -0.026391901075839996, 0.04078388586640358, 0.056485336273908615, 0.0006693261093460023, 0.055094920098781586, 0.041038643568754196, -0.03753512725234032, -0.053956978023052216, -0.008114853873848915, -0.005321355536580086, -0.033718254417181015, -0.020125702023506165, 0.014975612983107567, -0.020584851503372192, -0.003692690283060074, -0.02453559823334217, -0.06560702621936798, -0.004992967005819082, -0.04545081406831741, 0.006358735729008913, -0.046050310134887695, 0.038522519171237946, 0.0003155559825245291, 0.0017190197249874473, -0.02665119618177414, 0.055946823209524155, -0.003911392763257027, 0.03145778179168701, -0.05026407539844513, -0.07096095383167267, -0.004509856458753347, -0.03627564385533333, -0.0168048907071352, 0.07670588791370392, 0.052562445402145386, -0.08140171319246292, -0.04863199591636658, -0.003553081303834915, 0.003335844026878476, -0.047063540667295456, 0.025591976940631866, 0.003420606255531311, 0.01978391222655773, 0.001646495540626347, -0.02899627946317196, 0.05552516132593155, -0.04648337513208389, 0.021116355434060097, -0.02339220605790615, 0.021540801972150803, -0.07703784108161926, 0.046967145055532455, -0.014430364593863487, 0.03715740516781807, 0.005987830460071564, -0.046947166323661804, 0.0632585659623146, -0.021214120090007782, 0.056671347469091415, -0.04295836016535759, -0.05645518749952316, 0.000364020059350878, -0.0016010660910978913, -0.03600410744547844, 0.04784318059682846, 0.0019369221990928054, 0.042622022330760956, 0.023643219843506813, -0.03435702621936798, -0.015354641713202, 0.0015483623137697577, -0.02738628350198269, -0.001493906369432807, -0.012126345187425613, -0.042534977197647095, 0.0012057001003995538, -0.05941938981413841, -0.04169265180826187, -0.02643686719238758, 0.01706703007221222, -0.009824838489294052, 0.014733431860804558, 0.006092718802392483, -0.0119927441701293, -0.04849177226424217, 0.027746418491005898, -0.002008537296205759, -0.014361492358148098, 0.00035025988472625613, -0.004390004090964794, -0.0027514032553881407, 0.01769375242292881, 0.017588378861546516, -0.007110476493835449, -0.09364153444766998, 0.023089727386832237, 0.025885451585054398, -0.0318450890481472, -0.03228876739740372, -0.006678084377199411, 0.018299514427781105, 0.013654657639563084, -0.0126844746991992, 0.014838125556707382, -0.10529758781194687, 0.004051350988447666, -0.01403301116079092, 0.009645850397646427, -0.0009311351459473372, -0.0773773342370987, -0.02187040075659752, 0.01800641044974327, -0.03237668797373772, 0.029701730236411095, -0.08878546953201294, 0.07078089565038681, -0.06534308940172195, -0.033057067543268204, 0.05039697512984276, 0.016481874510645866, -0.04366464540362358, 0.015494318678975105, 0.03789359703660011, 0.0014656948624178767, -0.0035284573677927256, 0.01983530819416046, -0.02654491364955902, -0.010505804792046547, 0.011158728040754795, -0.0233924500644207, -0.02017391473054886, 0.019973797723650932, -0.02423854172229767, 0.06585534662008286, 0.05691300332546234, 0.016210000962018967, -0.05119665339589119, -0.051483798772096634, -0.016130806878209114, -0.029658116400241852, 0.015686150640249252, -0.03351181000471115, 0.037904754281044006, 0.040562666952610016, -0.05482253059744835, -0.09263647347688675, 0.05207343399524689, 0.05383312702178955, -0.06562232971191406, -0.08699005097150803, -0.0022293226793408394, 0.01694902777671814, 0.0019046507077291608, 0.04512585327029228, 0.03320557251572609, -0.04141323268413544, -0.015296360477805138, 0.010015961714088917, 0.027080418542027473, -0.027387648820877075, -0.0021258334163576365, -0.06598791480064392, -0.0608217753469944, -0.00019889065879397094, -0.10754178464412689, 0.010627126321196556, 0.08187530934810638, 0.057699259370565414, 0.0016561904922127724, 0.04026346281170845, 0.019276266917586327, -0.0577392540872097, 0.0014185404870659113, 0.001435365411452949, 0.06587151437997818, -0.005322189535945654, -0.03794778138399124, 0.024959350004792213, -0.009403576143085957, 0.017262518405914307, 0.044877152889966965, -0.001870262436568737, 0.0360233411192894, -0.049441296607255936, -0.012068524025380611, -0.09387717396020889, -0.021997444331645966, 0.019102713093161583, 0.04724067077040672, -0.02394331991672516, -0.029038671404123306, 0.008757321164011955, 0.025647126138210297, -0.004390019923448563, -0.013429157435894012, 0.008510216139256954, 0.01186396088451147, 0.023829877376556396, -0.054315268993377686, 0.018580298870801926, 0.014189288951456547, -0.01791001483798027, 0.022887738421559334, 0.052037499845027924, 0.0373280793428421, 0.034612011164426804, 0.03618789091706276, -0.04148970544338226, -0.02775035798549652, -0.031164033338427544, -0.013401714153587818, 0.005436193197965622, 0.004471384920179844, 0.021728871390223503, -0.05044160038232803, -0.023905225098133087, 0.031340934336185455, -0.0336713008582592, -0.018552200868725777, -0.023684440180659294, 0.05005592852830887, 0.016454966738820076, 0.04082576557993889, -0.025961970910429955, 0.01267021894454956, 0.019175458699464798, -0.009731813333928585, 0.05164700374007225, 0.04657851159572601, 0.011183464899659157, 0.0276092030107975, -0.029524624347686768, -0.01895245350897312, 0.03339709714055061, 0.021703915670514107, 0.03995824232697487, -0.0314830020070076, -0.02590680494904518, -0.03396940976381302, -0.022042442113161087, 0.059778761118650436, -0.06412094831466675, 0.03228864446282387, -0.006361704785376787, -0.02179298922419548, 0.009426778182387352, -0.03575478866696358, -0.022047409787774086, 0.008156432770192623, 0.008561261929571629, 0.04441313445568085, 0.05468132719397545, -0.010089271701872349, -0.00010782346362248063, 0.05127028003334999, -0.02271384932100773, 0.0692899227142334, 0.015230377204716206, -0.033409763127565384, -0.03608099743723869, 0.04472200572490692, 0.020202038809657097, 0.011659207753837109, -0.06504812091588974, -0.0275907963514328, 0.008753815665841103, -0.01733016036450863, 0.017475444823503494, 0.014906749129295349, 0.042735375463962555, 0.0324496328830719, 0.05813046172261238, 0.09404291212558746, 0.018312951549887657, -0.008337834849953651, -0.03254624456167221, -0.0014978650724515319, -0.011384055018424988, -0.002873179502785206, -0.022489244118332863, -0.013869251124560833, -0.026586472988128662, -0.04539525508880615, 0.01608225330710411, -0.02014082483947277, -0.03952620178461075, 0.01567929983139038, 0.07056374847888947, -0.005340178031474352, -0.023350095376372337, 0.007712520193308592, 0.032631054520606995, 0.022089416161179543, 0.009827454574406147, 0.023241853341460228, -0.009448467753827572, -0.008957963436841965, -0.056716591119766235, 0.034076228737831116, 0.021802576258778572, -0.006334283389151096, 0.009118874557316303, 0.07354772835969925, 0.1093684583902359, -0.0056929453276097775, 0.016727043315768242, -0.017942853271961212, -0.049583565443754196, -0.07302989810705185, -0.04157606139779091, -0.02672395668923855, 0.04335585609078407, 0.013061550445854664, -0.07123570889234543, 0.004787269979715347, -0.016191570088267326, 0.006531496066600084, 0.007826163433492184, 0.007479984778910875, 0.03703656047582626, -0.030046924948692322, 0.03820604458451271, -0.010147915221750736, 0.03157690539956093, -0.04821527376770973, 0.03172256425023079, 0.03755781799554825, -0.06545378267765045, 0.03427832946181297, 0.014087519608438015, -0.04727218672633171, -0.03431199863553047, -0.01606704480946064, 0.0308365635573864, 0.03554871305823326, 0.05613293871283531, -0.008398731239140034, -0.02142675593495369, -0.0414249412715435, -0.0291140079498291, 0.0036212995182722807, -0.028910307213664055, -0.04652920737862587, -0.0018825768493115902, 0.0048140184953808784, -0.03327476233243942, -0.017878789454698563, -0.015334350056946278, 0.04263926297426224, -0.0011754088336601853, 0.013251335360109806, -0.021734682843089104, -0.008758638054132462, 0.033980514854192734, -0.030954735353589058, -0.037030644714832306, -0.019151929765939713, 0.024850619956851006, -0.011213891208171844, 0.06587416678667068, 0.05081898719072342, -0.005804954096674919, 0.0035626867320388556, -0.04915304854512215, 0.008485158905386925, -0.017068028450012207, 0.0371156744658947, -0.04204361140727997, 0.0686187744140625, -0.05131952464580536, -0.04855784401297569, 0.015469546429812908, 0.05971650034189224, -0.01401230413466692, -0.06547535210847855, 0.01659955456852913, -0.019662896171212196, 0.009827817790210247, 0.013324649073183537, -0.05276235193014145, 0.026708289980888367, -0.051994044333696365, -0.02360968478024006, 0.0164219681173563, -0.00018757003999780864, 0.032807063311338425, 0.006793083623051643, -0.06364385038614273, -0.01221722923219204, 0.04627026244997978, 0.016104601323604584, 0.01018028985708952, -0.003429208416491747, 0.07121971249580383, 0.06667477637529373, -0.04941675439476967, 0.030692681670188904, -0.0003763393615372479, 0.04191584885120392, -0.05177738890051842, -0.02107972651720047, -0.01041673868894577, 0.02125304378569126, -0.042328834533691406, 0.047589145600795746, 0.005381457507610321, 0.012266934849321842, -0.002877086866647005, 0.0381331741809845, -0.0080654202029109, 0.029468417167663574, 0.02544078603386879, 0.006834025029093027, -0.021522097289562225, 0.02494770660996437, -0.005236694123595953, -0.05213266611099243, 0.0790850967168808, 0.0041685570031404495, -0.03107522614300251, 0.06690777838230133, 0.01654708944261074, 0.017473459243774414, -0.009762617759406567, -0.03171176835894585, -0.032292868942022324, 0.04274864122271538, -0.05440111830830574, 0.03004530444741249, 0.06897763162851334, -0.023872796446084976, 0.0013966106344014406, 0.03661957010626793, 0.022305816411972046, 0.020312443375587463, 0.0277127493172884, 0.04494601860642433, -0.05588487535715103, 0.05579248443245888, -0.025203309953212738, -0.009532244876027107, 0.005590556189417839, -0.06074157729744911, -0.038936566561460495, 0.005098768975585699, -0.06685125827789307, 0.0452120304107666, -0.008651326410472393, -0.03361852839589119, -0.009999715723097324, 0.008237366564571857, 0.007867284119129181, 0.053189877420663834, 0.03829978406429291, 0.04637817665934563, -0.017576828598976135, 0.02184780314564705, 0.02878941409289837, -0.034846507012844086, -0.05684852600097656, -0.022301718592643738, -0.0363166369497776, 0.0742693766951561, 0.016811495646834373, 0.0017143499571830034, -0.05628879740834236, -0.021487561985850334, -0.027186203747987747, 0.03072969615459442, -0.017268596217036247, -0.006523116957396269, 0.05944054573774338, 0.021959079429507256, 0.03571593388915062, -0.005495600402355194, -0.027050094678997993, -0.013113618828356266, 0.022546878084540367, 0.01854344829916954, -0.02860140986740589, -0.0008094034856185317, -0.04261874035000801, 0.025769175961613655, 0.04128517583012581, 0.005993679631501436, -0.005568324588239193, 0.04995279014110565, -0.014863519929349422, 0.0014221597230061889, -0.041725460439920425, 0.01609097234904766, -0.00806205254048109, 0.03930959105491638, 0.0011868311557918787, 0.028013363480567932, -0.039344992488622665, 0.0019726785831153393, -0.030730221420526505, 0.005322619341313839, -0.003512928495183587, -0.042802006006240845, -0.014646030962467194, -0.0031614573672413826, 0.039934176951646805, -0.018452422693371773, -0.042420364916324615, 0.05689588561654091, -0.0342194065451622, -0.044255807995796204, 0.02312423847615719, 0.005281975492835045, 0.04050321504473686, 0.004917709156870842, 0.01206875592470169, 0.03863413259387016, -0.04480399191379547, -0.011641249991953373, -0.08265556395053864, -0.06360656023025513, 0.02876807563006878, -0.09857766330242157, 0.04114677384495735, -0.01746618002653122, 0.00019823982438538224, 0.06748725473880768, 0.02492840588092804, 0.02805175818502903, 0.000323685584589839, -0.016028545796871185, 0.057010505348443985, -0.018637290224432945, 0.026702694594860077, -0.00791570357978344, 0.04360916092991829, -0.03730988875031471, 0.0023933753836899996, -0.01670537143945694, -0.0012584610376507044, -0.043713413178920746, 0.015274123288691044, 0.013882333412766457, 0.06447999179363251, 0.04490714520215988, -0.07656143605709076, -0.0022170355077832937, 0.021239323541522026, 0.025776050984859467, -0.04154151305556297, 0.03582580387592316, 0.07368650287389755, -0.001579638454131782, 0.0836016982793808, 0.004886606242507696, -0.0051413895562291145, -0.009434070438146591, 0.016820214688777924, 0.03878772258758545, 0.009118031710386276, -0.00397017365321517, -0.0027032617945224047, -0.015027711167931557, -0.005771405529230833, -0.03554244711995125, -0.01688515953719616, 0.039263222366571426, 0.06898603588342667, 0.009150304831564426, 0.025620104745030403, -0.028871772810816765, 0.01900804229080677, -0.0006935661076568067, 0.030345091596245766, -0.022280525416135788, -0.061476193368434906, -0.0052253385074436665, 0.001762395491823554, 0.010926797986030579, 0.0154770128428936, 0.02638482302427292, -0.04398205876350403, 0.006834663916379213, 0.036653611809015274, 0.06879117339849472, 0.02123929187655449, 0.011136924847960472, -0.025395065546035767, 0.02799389697611332, 0.03313585743308067, -0.009869936853647232, -0.0693214014172554, 0.00876940879970789, -0.005259110126644373, 0.00039628168451599777, -0.00998076144605875, -0.02384256012737751, -0.04208836704492569, -0.017325598746538162 ]
<p>Light has a dual nature, one of photons and the other of waves. But energy doesn't really travel in waves. So what do the wave represent?</p>
g9758
[ 0.005511169321835041, 0.028176648542284966, 0.004020560998469591, -0.0025419341400265694, 0.04795895889401436, 0.02975897677242756, -0.007548767141997814, 0.02149716578423977, 0.002443389967083931, -0.06711926311254501, 0.04425232857465744, 0.018428685143589973, 0.017673587426543236, -0.004683626350015402, -0.049134112894535065, -0.03748875856399536, 0.05220381170511246, -0.013928849250078201, 0.0810273140668869, 0.018388276919722557, -0.05626244097948074, 0.013982517644762993, 0.00666928943246603, -0.009938828647136688, -0.053692255169153214, 0.015489712357521057, 0.029781466349959373, -0.05483279004693031, -0.056714486330747604, -0.014999687671661377, 0.020828180015087128, -0.030262747779488564, 0.05024094507098198, 0.017730163410305977, -0.0329032838344574, 0.011069151572883129, 0.009842989966273308, 0.054240643978118896, 0.029802393168210983, 0.023338038474321365, -0.00038012658478692174, -0.0006546040531247854, -0.020296495407819748, -0.009182900190353394, 0.024956688284873962, 0.005491772200912237, 0.03729631006717682, 0.015199889428913593, 0.0033020214177668095, -0.050352275371551514, 0.016623789444565773, 0.009665393270552158, 0.017611892893910408, 0.07572682201862335, 0.11897112429141998, -0.011497477069497108, 0.0016976851038634777, 0.013517538085579872, 0.09569884836673737, 0.032960690557956696, 0.011390884406864643, 0.027849936857819557, 0.023431051522493362, 0.049263130873441696, 0.04939877986907959, -0.027048740535974503, -0.013624059036374092, -0.09865758568048477, 0.07071889936923981, -0.03047424741089344, 0.040361639112234116, -0.05628491938114166, -0.00535418139770627, -0.025636935606598854, 0.08603076636791229, -0.009120054543018341, -0.0023355730809271336, 0.011856098659336567, -0.06275739520788193, 0.006182091310620308, 0.008106798864901066, -0.014781586825847626, -0.019759202376008034, 0.0026398622430860996, 0.032042354345321655, 0.0026811102870851755, -0.01140277087688446, -0.018872583284974098, -0.016040880233049393, -0.00107351946644485, -0.006497671827673912, 0.023982582613825798, 0.12362461537122726, -0.005781223997473717, -0.011043526232242584, -0.02842698059976101, -0.022326413542032242, 0.008672014810144901, 0.0017455917550250888, 0.020460719242691994, -0.02999342419207096, 0.010543446987867355, 0.00378733454272151, -0.017457472160458565, 0.06073887273669243, 0.01325555332005024, 0.0007524791290052235, -0.029284415766596794, -0.03836912661790848, -0.04055892303586006, -0.029221078380942345, -0.026173492893576622, 0.027251819148659706, -0.052321888506412506, -0.047160543501377106, -0.07569671422243118, -0.008219380863010883, -0.07117865979671478, 0.05212562531232834, 0.06370927393436432, 0.08484277874231339, -0.017268886789679527, 0.04572715982794762, 0.10284943133592606, 0.04631102457642555, 0.013059105724096298, 0.01223484892398119, -0.025483503937721252, 0.017247144132852554, -0.024065131321549416, 0.041339270770549774, -0.023513145744800568, -0.0033931583166122437, 0.025274893268942833, 0.011418148875236511, -0.01879945397377014, -0.02675338089466095, 0.01677583158016205, -0.0026576633099466562, 0.013435780070722103, 0.016581501811742783, -0.06612510979175568, -0.01594051718711853, 0.012392288073897362, 0.028062589466571808, 0.004682098515331745, 0.006928921211510897, -0.02109447494149208, 0.004079322796314955, 0.02479846589267254, 0.04901822283864021, 0.10057221353054047, -0.014048491604626179, -0.0335504375398159, 0.07272445410490036, -0.04909750446677208, 0.0960715040564537, 0.003232521703466773, -0.09313341975212097, -0.008470568805932999, 0.08968508988618851, 0.04728153720498085, 0.049282241612672806, -0.006612653844058514, 0.005166575312614441, -0.039088912308216095, 0.02408243715763092, -0.03528783470392227, 0.02376207336783409, 0.017601339146494865, 0.0235957782715559, -0.02649843320250511, -0.02119060792028904, 0.03251729533076286, 0.035884350538253784, 0.049773480743169785, 0.002398548647761345, 0.0003843567974399775, 0.013260984793305397, 0.025747112929821014, -0.049085237085819244, -0.00877212081104517, -0.028414597734808922, -0.02473590523004532, -0.033352382481098175, -0.02485216222703457, 0.015197382308542728, -0.033205147832632065, -0.0505838468670845, 0.008122364990413189, -0.0022102207876741886, -0.02720532938838005, 0.07065635174512863, -0.0035304271150380373, -0.0007768202340230346, -0.0200655534863472, -0.033669956028461456, 0.018034152686595917, -0.00400264747440815, -0.009667249396443367, 0.010589653626084328, 0.03383916616439819, 0.04565681889653206, -0.012878620997071266, 0.014998885802924633, 0.043171126395463943, 0.00012792859342880547, -0.014962353743612766, 0.027375664561986923, -0.027357371523976326, 0.008156971074640751, -0.0243564210832119, 0.027969136834144592, -0.016471480950713158, -0.003824410494416952, -0.04441433027386665, -0.03379186987876892, 0.011838158592581749, -0.07679690420627594, 0.015616771765053272, -0.05355323851108551, 0.03050408326089382, 0.04217506945133209, -0.0453055240213871, -0.023674819618463516, 0.05737835168838501, -0.04548592492938042, -0.015742721036076546, -0.006114946212619543, -0.0007400591275654733, -0.03550001233816147, 0.006996002979576588, 0.036055758595466614, 0.02438461408019066, 0.038280338048934937, 0.04102221876382828, -0.03164413198828697, 0.01380098145455122, 0.07659789174795151, -0.05972839519381523, 0.013931668363511562, 0.006599453277885914, 0.006878925487399101, 0.020243240520358086, 0.04101182520389557, -0.0034900670871138573, 0.038444533944129944, 0.01889560930430889, -0.03780887648463249, 0.04565725103020668, 0.03613683953881264, -0.03659098967909813, -0.026987291872501373, 0.03862842917442322, -0.0060084727592766285, -0.025456640869379044, 0.013026717118918896, -0.020356636494398117, -0.05759887397289276, -0.00858192890882492, 0.020897552371025085, 0.0015090821543708444, -0.05234145373106003, -0.006367262452840805, -0.007600224576890469, -0.027072863653302193, 0.0570361502468586, 0.042846158146858215, 0.006960361264646053, -0.043145474046468735, 0.0005167427007108927, 0.03701075166463852, 0.044130392372608185, -0.09336352348327637, 0.003969328012317419, -0.040830906480550766, 0.016529325395822525, -0.028868690133094788, -0.020488228648900986, -0.07818790525197983, 0.02894395962357521, 0.03135204315185547, -0.051898691803216934, 0.005619002506136894, 0.01944061554968357, -0.13733087480068207, 0.0324520505964756, 0.04579635709524155, -0.014627822674810886, 0.028475582599639893, -0.023523477837443352, 0.01519352849572897, 0.007651203777641058, 0.009768999181687832, -0.06320913881063461, -0.020921673625707626, 0.03625592589378357, -0.02778518758714199, -0.0013152247993275523, 0.006726942956447601, -0.036296553909778595, -0.03278509899973869, 0.04393518343567848, -0.030283257365226746, 0.010428758338093758, -0.002323759952560067, -0.032396283000707626, -0.0019239743705838919, -0.008104458451271057, 0.05902564898133278, 0.0036828697193413973, 0.05118633061647415, -0.019628653302788734, 0.03919728100299835, -0.030214061960577965, 0.0016348095377907157, -0.08856076002120972, -0.010604389011859894, -0.032213978469371796, -0.03150550276041031, -0.014176586642861366, -0.03818506374955177, 0.02749374322593212, 0.05571538954973221, 0.000988527899608016, 0.00045927497558295727, -0.023479953408241272, 0.0059468126855790615, 0.01988641545176506, 0.011313526891171932, -0.025035617873072624, 0.020731298252940178, -0.04044225066900253, 0.019190160557627678, 0.013894680887460709, 0.0032403499353677034, -0.02946341224014759, -0.02117747627198696, 0.0334610790014267, 0.03989768028259277, -0.0019839236047118902, -0.025894371792674065, 0.0023230279330164194, 0.03449510037899017, 0.051574014127254486, -0.05160149559378624, -0.023682190105319023, -0.02832750789821148, -0.0024238084442913532, -0.02518540993332863, -0.024253590032458305, -0.0033364444971084595, 0.00762467086315155, 0.033687569200992584, -0.032253019511699677, 0.007182486820966005, 0.02128320001065731, 0.01094447448849678, 0.04099730774760246, -0.013325301930308342, -0.042306941002607346, 0.02220594696700573, 0.04226309061050415, -0.03786501660943031, -0.009865330532193184, -0.0034766700118780136, -0.009839980863034725, -0.014933858998119831, 0.00009117443551076576, 0.019127996638417244, 0.019226253032684326, -0.03150108829140663, -0.021174287423491478, 0.008732211776077747, -0.01723083294928074, -0.07667544484138489, -0.03464829549193382, -0.06309927999973297, -0.03942032530903816, 0.05871240049600601, 0.009653826244175434, 0.004290675278753042, 0.06317494064569473, 0.03943004459142685, 0.009571785107254982, 0.03643288090825081, -0.016997044906020164, 0.0025426181964576244, 0.03691469132900238, 0.08781171590089798, -0.016820179298520088, -0.021219613030552864, -0.057402074337005615, -0.0072075193747878075, 0.007115197833627462, -0.004268823191523552, 0.019225414842367172, 0.013518490828573704, -0.0653499960899353, 0.02268574759364128, -0.017473392188549042, 0.024489853531122208, 0.03779169172048569, -0.05459160730242729, -0.0020842032972723246, 0.05014004185795784, 0.06109050661325455, -0.09337108582258224, -0.04085874184966087, -0.0034564535599201918, 0.02186209335923195, 0.020826304331421852, 0.038331590592861176, -0.038921184837818146, -0.028700588271021843, 0.0063500008545815945, -0.0021081180311739445, -0.08363869786262512, 0.022266579791903496, 0.0761810764670372, 0.006693036295473576, 0.09496839344501495, 0.01413575280457735, -0.014913314022123814, -0.0275740809738636, 0.018207738175988197, 0.04811016470193863, 0.008716230280697346, -0.07257264107465744, -0.036980342119932175, -0.015045992098748684, -0.01111045852303505, -0.00377032277174294, 0.05315551906824112, -0.016839077696204185, 0.06614121049642563, -0.024856973439455032, -0.02047991193830967, 0.05709034949541092, 0.06611476838588715, 0.07137831300497055, 0.012961212545633316, 0.015442948788404465, -0.013740056194365025, 0.002215983811765909, 0.04591451957821846, -0.008086809888482094, -0.014455071650445461, -0.03942299634218216, -0.055293820798397064, -0.03900904208421707, 0.06199520081281662, 0.00045243953354656696, -0.030168624594807625, 0.006795017048716545, 0.05128497630357742, -0.01687181554734707, -0.00507441395893693, 0.010228416882455349, -0.010804012417793274, -0.06796302646398544, 0.014346581883728504, 0.003071541665121913, 0.0030812041368335485, 0.03238330036401749, -0.010402909480035305, -0.025926239788532257, 0.013035332784056664, -0.021455392241477966, -0.009061095304787159, 0.025616245344281197, -0.0472399927675724, -0.0018496154807507992, -0.02612779289484024, 0.025515783578157425, -0.009781350381672382, -0.03404245153069496, -0.029407480731606483, -0.04699588567018509, -0.0343506783246994, 0.02224493771791458, 0.0036768096033483744, -0.021893609315156937, 0.015602797269821167, -0.03197198361158371, 0.04099859669804573, -0.033954303711652756, 0.05953588709235191, 0.005262924823909998, -0.007460963912308216, -0.013950515538454056, -0.02139672078192234, -0.0229848213493824, -0.006200181785970926, 0.000027617155865300447, 0.034600697457790375, -0.01595682092010975, 0.015793360769748688, 0.009128645993769169, -0.02117975801229477, -0.03875767067074776, 0.04078138992190361, 0.02550331875681877, -0.024192489683628082, 0.015454040840268135, 0.028892740607261658, 0.039845507591962814, 0.006931803654879332, -0.02649746835231781, 0.008784680627286434, 0.04998760297894478, -0.0799451395869255, -0.0490071065723896, 0.01717165671288967, 0.04333314672112465, -0.028043508529663086, -0.02493320405483246, 0.030157078057527542, 0.04125748202204704, 0.005719998851418495, -0.041693247854709625, 0.018864525482058525, 0.061259277164936066, -0.03261859342455864, 0.06955567002296448, 0.02472282387316227, -0.026546930894255638, -0.06660611927509308, 0.07132352143526077, 0.04116752743721008, 0.035077888518571854, 0.05783655494451523, 0.03156360611319542, -0.020526178181171417, 0.012852690182626247, -0.02830611914396286, 0.009805820882320404, 0.0021564383059740067, 0.027607988566160202, -0.002223155228421092, -0.020369023084640503, -0.01572319306433201, 0.007900727912783623, 0.05595548450946808, 0.01847311481833458, 0.022102097049355507, -0.023885268718004227, -0.00741153210401535, 0.0030197221785783768, 0.027940552681684494, 0.005946311168372631, -0.016133129596710205, -0.011326828971505165, 0.029567936435341835, 0.05275803431868553, 0.0020194719545543194, 0.00017836346523836255, -0.0603664256632328, -0.049226101487874985, -0.008201244287192822, -0.0057942504063248634, 0.08414122462272644, -0.029827231541275978, -0.009841712191700935, 0.04892044514417648, -0.06828043609857559, 0.024992749094963074, -0.04696417599916458, 0.019916974008083344, -0.043342556804418564, -0.008107569068670273, 0.019008703529834747, 0.03792138025164604, -0.022816713899374008, 0.010407072491943836, 0.0034780637361109257, 0.012534700334072113, -0.05761915445327759, -0.04294923320412636, -0.03637969493865967, 0.007948941551148891, 0.020804990082979202, -0.006702630780637264, 0.01612999476492405, -0.0439850278198719, -0.004017712082713842, -0.00404376583173871, -0.025764448568224907, 0.056587278842926025, 0.0025038395542651415, 0.009605326689779758, -0.005399144720286131, -0.024293575435876846, -0.0015082762110978365, 0.03349057212471962, -0.04197331890463829, 0.012498175725340843, -0.014693147502839565, -0.015453891828656197, 0.047157544642686844, -0.02414431981742382, -0.023707907646894455, -0.013537382706999779, 0.021663453429937363, 0.02559475600719452, 0.0643797293305397, -0.03321512043476105, -0.028502238914370537, -0.013113112188875675, 0.02192261628806591, -0.014110923744738102, -0.016943974420428276, -0.035573095083236694, -0.014780367724597454, -0.03456690162420273, -0.05907461792230606, -0.054338689893484116, 0.012600713409483433, 0.002959913806989789, 0.007983796298503876, -0.018821263685822487, -0.05672937631607056, 0.02858634851872921, 0.02773171477019787, 0.039996594190597534, 0.06458067148923874, -0.05204370245337486, 0.10031850636005402, 0.0111110033467412, -0.010314276441931725, -0.0013272023061290383, -0.00040008584619499743, 0.038968540728092194, 0.08622346818447113, 0.012271638959646225, -0.0671803280711174, -0.09231127053499222, 0.03586564585566521, 0.022314714267849922, -0.017659874632954597, 0.020550142973661423, 0.06397552043199539, 0.036187972873449326, -0.008908167481422424, -0.07050135731697083, 0.06471845507621765, 0.017525268718600273, -0.06133119389414787, -0.0024845749139785767, -0.029361777007579803, -0.030675791203975677, 0.005075450055301189, -0.034892737865448, 0.020333286374807358, -0.046311866492033005, -0.01688876934349537, -0.036193426698446274, -0.014862709678709507, -0.03942515701055527, -0.039001286029815674, -0.029563823714852333, -0.05798276513814926, -0.02898162603378296, 0.013339304365217686, 0.013324486091732979, 0.0008178259013220668, 0.004020940512418747, -0.06061091646552086, -0.03947897627949715, -0.0005851653986610472, -0.05420723557472229, -0.0405307337641716, 0.02543613128364086, 0.009039266966283321, -0.05930693820118904, 0.0090772220864892, -0.08289314061403275, 0.022439882159233093, 0.008218580856919289, -0.04491933807730675, -0.005321267992258072, 0.04605821520090103, -0.02249634452164173, 0.017295552417635918, 0.029028091579675674, -0.02549320086836815, -0.002797451103106141, -0.03470063954591751, -0.016935838386416435, -0.0009011435322463512, 0.007192940451204777, 0.0008223069016821682, 0.032762493938207626, -0.053581882268190384, -0.006998404860496521, -0.011367429047822952, 0.05279276892542839, 0.05109698697924614, 0.015792306512594223, 0.012156683020293713, -0.01490695495158434, 0.023616015911102295, 0.005600044038146734, 0.011096137575805187, -0.03528096526861191, 0.0012718711514025927, 0.021588994190096855, -0.07039454579353333, -0.027594851329922676, -0.052410416305065155, -0.052943527698516846, 0.0353146567940712, 0.0038805652875453234, 0.036043569445610046, 0.04156007617712021, 0.04809853434562683, 0.02999126724898815, 0.059661444276571274, -0.007197889965027571, -0.000007011919933574973, -0.008834508247673512, -0.022144563496112823, -0.060993075370788574, -0.04180193319916725, 0.0029006153345108032, 0.005324326455593109, 0.048526402562856674, -0.009320479817688465, 0.002929143374785781, 0.014342966489493847, -0.04465619847178459, 0.014236959628760815, -0.023225881159305573, -0.008873547427356243, -0.04843105748295784, 0.01003982499241829, -0.03175714612007141, 0.013125792145729065, 0.052355535328388214, -0.0008212566026486456, 0.0015334945637732744, -0.06606940180063248, -0.011304987594485283, -0.048684604465961456, -0.02322600781917572, -0.07320962101221085, -0.022117797285318375, -0.020820319652557373, 0.05678580701351166, -0.016819918528199196, 0.01830555684864521, 0.030184635892510414, -0.0005489485920406878, 0.07598952949047089, 0.015585655346512794, -0.02718953602015972, 0.03940301761031151, -0.027420004829764366, 0.0001005127705866471, -0.004205404315143824, -0.01773763634264469, -0.023868966847658157, 0.07360439747571945, 0.004771113861352205, -0.027918141335248947, -0.017378317192196846, -0.024996362626552582, -0.014673055149614811 ]
<p>I was wondering as how would appear the interference pattern of a double-slit experiment moving at a relativistic speed v, 1) in the case of light and, 2) in the case wave matter (i.e. electrons for instance) as seen in comparison between rest and moving reference frames (respectively S and S’). </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/BzhTC.jpg" alt="enter image description here"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/8yogk.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>More precisely, I am considering the spacing between fringes and their nature. In terms of the spatial distribution of the individual speckles observed on the screen, my first impression was that it must be exactly of the same nature, i.e. fringes being centered at same screen positions (the y axis being transversal to the relative movement). Doing the usual simple math (see details below) to obtain fringes positions and spacing, and using the longitudinal length contraction L’ = L / G(v) (where G(v) is the usual gamma factor G(v) = 1/(1 – (v/c)**2)**0,5) gives me finally an equation relating the respective wavelengths in S’ and S :</p> <p>Lambda’ = G(v) Lambda</p> <p><strong>And then, I have the following two questions:</strong></p> <p><strong>1) In the case of light</strong> (with Lambda = c/f), this would imply that f’ = f / G(v) (see details below). Then is it true that a red shift must always be taken into account due to a Doppler effect acting only transversally? </p> <p><strong>2) Since for a matter wave</strong>, the de Broglie wavelength is Lambda = h/p, the observed pattern spacing would be maintained if p’ = p / G(v) (see details below). But I doubt seriously that there is such a simple relativistic transformation between the respective linear momenta of rest and moving frame (the correct composition of momenta is different). What are the errors then?</p> <p>Thanks for your patience. I would clearly appreciate the help of someone.</p> <p><strong>Details of the simple math:</strong> </p> <p>Starting in the frame S with the walk difference delta(m) for a maximum of intensity observed at fringe of order m on the screen (along the y axis):</p> <p>delta(m) = r2 – r1 = m Lambda and d/L -> epsilon<br> => y(m)/L = tan theta -> sin theta = delta(m) / d = m Lambda / d => position of fringe m: y(m) = m Lambda L / d<br> and spacing : Dy = y(m+1) – y(m) = Lambda L / d</p> <p>The same shall be true in the frame S’: position of fringe m: y’(m) = m Lambda’ L’ / d and spacing Dy’ = Lambda’ L’ / d. Then, the length contraction, together with the requirement that the spacing must remain the same give:</p> <p>L’ = L / G(v) with Dy = Dy’ => Lambda L / d = Lambda’ L’ / d = Lambda’ L / (G(v) d) => Lambda’ = G(v) Lambda</p> <p><strong>1) In the case of light</strong> having a constant speed </p> <p>c = Lambda f = Lambda’ f’ = G(v) Lambda f’ => f’ = f / G(v). </p> <p>which is the transversal Doppler Effect with the resulting red shift of the fringe colors. This seems a priori reasonable since the moving experimental setup is observed transversally as it moves (from left to right), thus, there is no need to have a longitudinal Doppler Effect. However, this appears somehow in contradiction with the fact that the walk difference delta’(m) = m Lambda’ is drawn along a diagonal (at angle theta’) and has also a longitudinal component. What does that mean in terms of possible x and y components of (longitudinal and transversal) Doppler effects? What is missing or wrong here (either in the calculation or the interpretation)?</p> <p><strong>2) In the case of wave matter</strong> (electrons) having the de Broglie wavelength Lambda = h/p, things become more complicated since one should suppose for the electron beam a speed u in the reference frame S and a speed w in S’ being related through the relative speed v of S’ by the subtractive relativistic composition of speeds (with u > v): </p> <p>w = (u – v)/(1 – uv/(c**2)) with the well-known geometric identity<br> w G(w) = (u – v) G(u)G(v)</p> <p>Then, the relation between wavelengths leads to a relation between p = p(u) = G(u) m0 u and p’ = p(w) = G(w) m0 w (where m0 stands for the electron rest mass and G for the relativistic gamma factor):</p> <p>Lambda’ = G(v) Lambda => h/p(w) = G(v) h/p(u) => p(w) = p(u)/G(v)</p> <p>which is surprising and possibly too simple to be true. Indeed, using the geometric identity w G(w) = (u – v) G(u)G(v), one can see that the correct composition of momenta for p’ = p(w) should read as :</p> <p>p(w) = G(w) m0 w = G(w) m0 (u – v) G(u)G(v)/G(w) = m0 (u – v) G(u)G(v) = G(v) G(u) m0 u – G(u) G(v) m0 v = G(v) p(u) – G(u) p(v)</p> <p>And again, as it was the case for the light situation, one should observe that these momenta are not necessarily longitudinal since they are related to the walk difference delta’(m) = m Lambda’ which is drawn along a diagonal (at angle theta’). So, what is wrong in this logic and in these probably too simple calculations?</p> <p>Thanks for your help!</p> <p>Wilj</p>
g9759
[ 0.004483742173761129, -0.02385924942791462, 0.01088216993957758, -0.03744269907474518, 0.09217826277017593, 0.025734158232808113, 0.10971775650978088, 0.003537942422553897, -0.04529937729239464, 0.009204186499118805, 0.02116209827363491, 0.020940562710165977, -0.01512843556702137, 0.03535430505871773, -0.05211431160569191, -0.028865981847047806, 0.08146238327026367, -0.026026804000139236, 0.026417560875415802, -0.031796298921108246, -0.010999584570527077, 0.009407751262187958, -0.032793983817100525, -0.0828140452504158, -0.015863442793488503, 0.05050679296255112, 0.017355874180793762, -0.05275982990860939, -0.0130526814609766, -0.003387053729966283, 0.04120217636227608, -0.017360059544444084, -0.010917829349637032, -0.062237031757831573, -0.02471747435629368, 0.007907725870609283, 0.04413227364420891, 0.051276326179504395, -0.015843892470002174, 0.08074606209993362, -0.023474866524338722, -0.0527445450425148, 0.005821858067065477, -0.02471114508807659, 0.014676321297883987, -0.006309267599135637, -0.03491717576980591, -0.05020662024617195, -0.018476441502571106, -0.005654339678585529, -0.030396731570363045, 0.08952874690294266, 0.0007557077915407717, 0.034861452877521515, 0.01998966373503208, 0.024925069883465767, -0.003924568649381399, -0.014570961706340313, 0.0787321999669075, 0.039295922964811325, 0.016819771379232407, -0.04037685692310333, 0.004209077917039394, 0.0031453219708055258, -0.0019105261890217662, 0.029184862971305847, -0.03265846520662308, -0.021029163151979446, -0.024649934843182564, -0.042320214211940765, -0.01825219951570034, -0.10792919993400574, -0.02474476583302021, 0.0015455757966265082, 0.017094561830163002, -0.01780533976852894, 0.009260958060622215, -0.025849075987935066, -0.019386358559131622, -0.008631200529634953, -0.047150854021310806, -0.04868660494685173, -0.008320140652358532, 0.06568432599306107, 0.06549961119890213, -0.0021419068798422813, -0.03801780194044113, 0.008032278157770634, 0.03191687539219856, 0.01484039518982172, 0.028266938403248787, -0.0798688530921936, 0.03738759458065033, 0.04108607769012451, -0.02241712249815464, -0.0011782415676862001, -0.053512975573539734, 0.050444137305021286, -0.002893504686653614, -0.0014609468635171652, -0.003981701098382473, -0.04354129731655121, -0.01679806038737297, 0.021091554313898087, -0.036695029586553574, -0.030433012172579765, -0.0006324223359115422, -0.009096208028495312, -0.03536531329154968, -0.005269577261060476, -0.07287755608558655, -0.04689422994852066, -0.018412664532661438, -0.03348321467638016, -0.028484055772423744, -0.030288968235254288, 0.01864227093756199, -0.025985989719629288, 0.03551911935210228, 0.029567323625087738, 0.02127564325928688, 0.012040643021464348, 0.007242447230964899, 0.06711266189813614, 0.016124198213219643, -0.021604565903544426, -0.036156535148620605, -0.013946359045803547, 0.01809106208384037, 0.012159683741629124, -0.005303991958498955, 0.025372005999088287, -0.011273716576397419, 0.06341324001550674, -0.007821767590939999, -0.053582724183797836, 0.08488532155752182, 0.02496606670320034, -0.0037382589653134346, -0.04762870445847511, 0.03639302775263786, -0.005785912275314331, 0.015043501742184162, -0.051117077469825745, -0.019352898001670837, 0.0057181427255272865, -0.01630488783121109, -0.008790817111730576, 0.07948581874370575, -0.04389016702771187, 0.0036313049495220184, 0.04317669942975044, -0.04910872131586075, 0.02223627269268036, -0.029250571504235268, -0.0001339349546469748, 0.042753737419843674, -0.011346029117703438, 0.0004566690477076918, 0.04722072556614876, 0.049091190099716187, -0.022825345396995544, -0.02313072420656681, -0.00489007355645299, -0.019769607111811638, -0.02534600719809532, 0.04385499656200409, -0.04271187260746956, 0.03619411587715149, -0.08333252370357513, -0.0587732270359993, -0.0026058584917336702, -0.02023460529744625, -0.007502671796828508, 0.03938226401805878, 0.09590071439743042, 0.04002051427960396, -0.017872052267193794, 0.009788199327886105, 0.009991385042667389, -0.05582356080412865, -0.006906487047672272, -0.028011713176965714, -0.04494879022240639, -0.0015565037028864026, -0.048869162797927856, 0.006981858983635902, -0.02399594336748123, -0.07249239832162857, 0.008841967210173607, -0.02365574799478054, -0.032992374151945114, -0.029801078140735626, 0.029817601665854454, -0.022046593949198723, 0.0172373428940773, 0.019808754324913025, -0.021256815642118454, -0.0804024487733841, 0.036743808537721634, -0.052326660603284836, -0.006035211030393839, 0.015453151427209377, -0.0017199857393279672, 0.057294223457574844, 0.06817947328090668, -0.03641187399625778, -0.0077238925732672215, 0.008237045258283615, 0.022336123511195183, 0.03081698715686798, 0.012209875509142876, -0.02881111204624176, 0.03664779290556908, 0.0009239333448931575, -0.04375820234417915, 0.0019856421276926994, -0.041039030998945236, -0.015568423084914684, 0.02063857764005661, -0.051937200129032135, -0.0011202937457710505, -0.007532306015491486, -0.033046919852495193, 0.010815073736011982, -0.02732512354850769, -0.007758656982332468, -0.02494504675269127, -0.0000023859272459958447, 0.06615663319826126, -0.03805197775363922, 0.01888245716691017, -0.028405630961060524, -0.05400467291474342, 0.04424111545085907, 0.008706961758434772, -0.019145045429468155, 0.01138392835855484, 0.014738153666257858, -0.01191110908985138, 0.04746273159980774, 0.04093746468424797, -0.09256604313850403, -0.01168147474527359, 0.04692808911204338, -0.007122027687728405, 0.054080501198768616, 0.00007614016067236662, -0.006264651194214821, 0.02738128788769245, 0.03189891204237938, -0.0018656720640137792, -0.020907390862703323, 0.006030093878507614, -0.005884223151952028, -0.014820629730820656, -0.02413228712975979, 0.0028916411101818085, -0.06194598600268364, -0.014241653494536877, -0.020935337990522385, 0.053818196058273315, 0.026183901354670525, -0.004389162175357342, -0.005179370287805796, -0.006140066776424646, -0.011219961568713188, 0.039463430643081665, -0.012509781867265701, -0.04402312636375427, 0.03626646101474762, 0.00767791923135519, 0.009293746203184128, -0.003548216540366411, 0.006611611694097519, 0.016320062801241875, 0.012021269649267197, -0.04564058035612106, 0.018204743042588234, 0.01405403297394514, -0.014704792760312557, 0.008413868956267834, -0.0317351296544075, 0.031103037297725677, 0.03771856054663658, -0.05909508094191551, 0.038292236626148224, 0.06094127520918846, -0.03904407098889351, 0.05499017611145973, -0.04025328531861305, 0.07781949639320374, 0.028902923688292503, 0.03360608592629433, -0.01174433808773756, 0.03190561756491661, 0.03911956027150154, -0.044246330857276917, -0.0020099536050111055, 0.04479171335697174, -0.0036696195602416992, 0.05899503082036972, -0.021962573751807213, 0.026171693578362465, 0.08611030131578445, -0.017587509006261826, -0.04809950664639473, -0.07372671365737915, -0.018481474369764328, 0.002133481903001666, 0.04982446879148483, 0.02428440935909748, 0.02116936445236206, 0.023794660344719887, -0.017292318865656853, -0.01143591571599245, -0.047042299062013626, -0.02286897972226143, 0.010022916831076145, 0.040672726929187775, 0.04505728557705879, 0.014292150735855103, -0.029324043542146683, -0.017834050580859184, 0.056472402065992355, 0.023037753999233246, -0.025339800864458084, 0.04578058421611786, -0.09805445373058319, 0.025362003594636917, 0.002673350740224123, 0.039474938064813614, -0.009277899749577045, -0.017152858898043633, 0.03314391151070595, -0.031708378344774246, 0.015595432370901108, 0.04964118450880051, 0.028649339452385902, 0.06258800625801086, 0.005598611664026976, 0.020842675119638443, -0.06270842254161835, 0.020288798958063126, 0.026084640994668007, -0.0032120465766638517, 0.037914734333753586, -0.01729455590248108, -0.039762504398822784, -0.029227545484900475, -0.004166450351476669, -0.005018740426748991, -0.028591860085725784, -0.015029320493340492, -0.002672798465937376, -0.020612673833966255, 0.03383241221308708, -0.005858293734490871, 0.07604217529296875, -0.03829774633049965, -0.0213692095130682, -0.051831163465976715, -0.027069009840488434, -0.061997443437576294, 0.013027745299041271, 0.02004629373550415, -0.01033500861376524, 0.03556668758392334, 0.03553364425897598, -0.04690246656537056, -0.025781217962503433, -0.0005484521389007568, -0.031243542209267616, -0.004955546464771032, -0.052945565432310104, -0.03534865379333496, 0.04201589152216911, 0.05673111602663994, -0.030372781679034233, 0.07424920797348022, 0.022253692150115967, 0.010395483113825321, -0.0347101092338562, 0.01280152890831232, 0.022691426798701286, -0.0235766489058733, -0.02832155115902424, -0.031168514862656593, -0.007934067398309708, -0.026718605309724808, -0.03429616615176201, 0.002254727529361844, -0.049209047108888626, -0.010699988342821598, 0.05471708998084068, -0.04129284992814064, 0.07773392647504807, 0.04373832046985626, 0.034692078828811646, 0.01517317071557045, -0.012715601362287998, -0.01332952082157135, -0.027493426576256752, 0.011682355776429176, -0.0802854672074318, 0.030002322047948837, 0.01925583928823471, -0.025208864361047745, -0.01651282049715519, -0.0019095524912700057, -0.07988877594470978, 0.016662217676639557, -0.003986353985965252, -0.07419240474700928, 0.02653912641108036, 0.02745611034333706, 0.049280665814876556, -0.006441798526793718, -0.0049795834347605705, 0.016491418704390526, 0.00044288847129791975, 0.09556443244218826, 0.07408451288938522, 0.011154278181493282, -0.017766129225492477, 0.10133108496665955, -0.007592509035021067, 0.01956961490213871, 0.040435872972011566, -0.018389862030744553, -0.0103943832218647, 0.02926759235560894, 0.005645570810884237, 0.015576799400150776, -0.04811741039156914, 0.06122379004955292, -0.04909096658229828, 0.04303283616900444, 0.01760799251496792, 0.0453675203025341, 0.06288881599903107, -0.03823070973157883, 0.03264430910348892, -0.024048730731010437, -0.020154573023319244, 0.05458975210785866, -0.08262446522712708, -0.027119476348161697, 0.002406052080914378, -0.01586465910077095, -0.0026529659517109394, 0.07804908603429794, -0.008455179631710052, -0.013133873231709003, 0.03314150124788284, 0.003003778401762247, -0.030871348455548286, 0.011745220981538296, 0.016519291326403618, -0.01609526388347149, -0.04419625177979469, 0.057365741580724716, 0.0055022453889250755, -0.025710033252835274, 0.04413275420665741, 0.02707921899855137, -0.0687934011220932, -0.02360820211470127, -0.06765405833721161, 0.012030195444822311, 0.0008948357426561415, -0.03360302746295929, 0.007969224825501442, 0.0030554034747183323, -0.0006995429284870625, 0.020697208121418953, -0.04775899276137352, 0.023767920210957527, -0.029430458322167397, -0.04075389727950096, -0.057855088263750076, -0.05063452944159508, 0.06450649350881577, 0.003371560713276267, -0.003497532568871975, 0.0010724107269197702, -0.02704135701060295, 0.024658581241965294, 0.02270263247191906, -0.008556753396987915, 0.02150818519294262, -0.019132079556584358, -0.056990139186382294, -0.022373978048563004, 0.017670894041657448, 0.030000008642673492, 0.04753316938877106, 0.008928608149290085, -0.03404070436954498, 0.011740833520889282, -0.005311514250934124, 0.09014317393302917, 0.02897292748093605, 0.003256820375099778, -0.05622883513569832, 0.08147493749856949, 0.03326232731342316, -0.038514669984579086, -0.0490078367292881, -0.003206673776730895, -0.04352022334933281, 0.01830993965268135, -0.00943225622177124, -0.02034837007522583, -0.006913077551871538, -0.07144208252429962, 0.07337460666894913, -0.011411182582378387, -0.010275513865053654, -0.071406289935112, 0.0342215970158577, 0.015801019966602325, -0.0077849761582911015, -0.005594720132648945, 0.04062661901116371, -0.008858246728777885, -0.0032972393091768026, -0.03225661814212799, 0.005130798555910587, -0.019992616027593613, 0.0011135715758427978, 0.021184353157877922, 0.048190850764513016, 0.04926365986466408, -0.0107059795409441, -0.05374401807785034, 0.0286147128790617, -0.020126665011048317, -0.011449606157839298, -0.01689264178276062, -0.04765528067946434, 0.01071992702782154, 0.00665149325504899, 0.08937273919582367, -0.03432156518101692, 0.001498270547017455, -0.009083928540349007, -0.025678906589746475, 0.011909865774214268, -0.007084628567099571, -0.005723963025957346, -0.007766186725348234, 0.014288848266005516, 0.025116782635450363, -0.020427891984581947, 0.011627870611846447, 0.00019567944400478154, -0.057513803243637085, -0.033118490129709244, -0.009887447580695152, 0.015618458390235901, 0.03501322120428085, -0.043825600296258926, 0.03619572892785072, -0.020105840638279915, 0.037355516105890274, 0.035027481615543365, -0.07811655104160309, 0.04827549308538437, 0.013927535153925419, -0.052554696798324585, -0.01814999245107174, -0.023334313184022903, 0.007139402441680431, -0.027720745652914047, 0.051524270325899124, -0.011643770150840282, -0.042056385427713394, -0.09689770638942719, -0.031006280332803726, 0.015036876313388348, 0.03899714723229408, -0.011815108358860016, -0.014274472370743752, -0.075310118496418, 0.005851841066032648, -0.0025652002077549696, -0.0016174225602298975, 0.029504133388400078, -0.02678525820374489, -0.000501050497405231, 0.01118274312466383, 0.008336830884218216, -0.004745039623230696, -0.027841387316584587, -0.05146462097764015, 0.02162383683025837, -0.057316314429044724, -0.008011914789676666, 0.1090063601732254, 0.0369596928358078, -0.002862178720533848, 0.05172741040587425, -0.011735049076378345, 0.020250335335731506, -0.02025573141872883, -0.06042309105396271, 0.04637353867292404, -0.03527840971946716, 0.053749825805425644, 0.016300003975629807, 0.01725674234330654, 0.0035142635460942984, 0.007479625754058361, -0.027358688414096832, -0.021042827516794205, -0.06469827145338058, 0.007745156530290842, -0.008972742594778538, -0.008760233409702778, 0.05935335531830788, -0.03106747381389141, -0.039940983057022095, -0.01713685877621174, 0.0066155605018138885, 0.06289273500442505, -0.026201123371720314, 0.002535856096073985, 0.030069541186094284, -0.012740549631416798, 0.03456040099263191, -0.03203018754720688, -0.007609002757817507, 0.032200105488300323, 0.026567835360765457, 0.007591346278786659, -0.07708714157342911, 0.02636406384408474, 0.032786592841148376, 0.021649587899446487, 0.04618963971734047, 0.02386053092777729, 0.05459526553750038, -0.0474851168692112, -0.033780865371227264, 0.01917966455221176, 0.05382987856864929, -0.008020777255296707, -0.0636184811592102, -0.013956427574157715, -0.03068549558520317, 0.007136838510632515, -0.029934125021100044, 0.059474796056747437, -0.022500235587358475, 0.017828283831477165, 0.008954635821282864, 0.009656980633735657, -0.000507002288941294, -0.08281750231981277, -0.06808701902627945, -0.05965782701969147, -0.020400753244757652, 0.03045693226158619, 0.006302966270595789, 0.05706533044576645, 0.0063359616324305534, -0.006379228550940752, -0.03146054595708847, 0.017314059659838676, 0.019878840073943138, -0.051359623670578, -0.005945710930973291, 0.0774846076965332, 0.004926999099552631, -0.014838124625384808, 0.031908225268125534, 0.031016165390610695, -0.05716777220368385, -0.06727540493011475, 0.00232696533203125, 0.033147960901260376, 0.009127121418714523, 0.054453376680612564, -0.05994474142789841, 0.020402103662490845, -0.007075599394738674, -0.012172442860901356, 0.004956440068781376, 0.009223607368767262, 0.05115461349487305, 0.0597895048558712, -0.001855741604231298, 0.005116414278745651, -0.01888211816549301, 0.06866265833377838, 0.023276200518012047, 0.037910159677267075, 0.0007157521904446185, 0.028456691652536392, 0.017991768196225166, 0.010531227104365826, -0.06149769201874733, 0.03277990221977234, 0.06177154555916786, 0.046700648963451385, 0.0023113698698580265, 0.0009704234544187784, -0.004949693102389574, 0.013318600133061409, 0.03771596401929855, 0.04248768836259842, 0.0024901642464101315, 0.02645069733262062, 0.02693140134215355, -0.028033198788762093, -0.0019783179741352797, 0.05531928688287735, 0.006161062512546778, 0.009958919137716293, -0.008283063769340515, -0.00254595885053277, -0.05777130275964737, -0.03473810479044914, 0.006403109524399042, -0.015789823606610298, 0.03312210738658905, 0.012344993650913239, 0.0025307456962764263, -0.003612466622143984, -0.02096656523644924, 0.010858474299311638, -0.09266524016857147, -0.039041854441165924, -0.04881899803876877, 0.049889352172613144, 0.04527537152171135, -0.050855107605457306, 0.010094532743096352, 0.022303853183984756, 0.015749290585517883, -0.01646886020898819, -0.015547236427664757, -0.0064375801011919975, -0.0066744741052389145, -0.0017097193049266934, 0.019857080653309822, -0.026714447885751724, 0.01773037202656269, -0.025322550907731056, 0.028627999126911163, 0.024171458557248116, -0.023919614031910896, 0.03562935069203377, 0.04123762249946594, -0.013372652232646942, 0.015142559073865414, -0.02240794710814953, 0.02604510635137558, -0.0049294643104076385, -0.013033581897616386, -0.018681932240724564, -0.02247880958020687, 0.022743426263332367, -0.013240693137049675, -0.012690416537225246, 0.004070034250617027, 0.03824063390493393 ]
<p>In an answer to <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/101766/does-any-material-glow-under-appropriate-conditions/101768#101768">this SE question</a>, the respondent explains that heating a perfect diamond will not cause it to glow with thermal blackbody radiation. I don't quite follow his explanation. I think it comes down to: there is no mechanism for diamond to generate light in the visible region of the spectrum.</p> <p>He mentions that interband transitions are well out of the visual range, so there will be no contribution from that.</p> <p>He mentions that the Debye temperature for diamond is > 2000 K. I presume that the argument here is that optical phonons will be frozen out, too. (But diamond doesn't have infrared-active phonons, does it?)</p> <p>So is that why hot diamond doesn't glow? </p> <p>I suppose that if one considers real (not ideal) crystals, imperfections, impurities, and the existence of surfaces lead to the possibility of emission mechanisms, and thus glow. In fact it might be the case that a finite but otherwise perfect crystal might have an extremely faint glow.</p> <p>Is this basically the reason that hot diamond does not glow? Further elucidation welcome.</p>
g9760
[ 0.03648146614432335, 0.01244603656232357, 0.01203907560557127, 0.031227948144078255, -0.04138871282339096, 0.04182659462094307, -0.006191418971866369, 0.005447531584650278, 0.026736441999673843, -0.033229243010282516, -0.004342856351286173, 0.03221970424056053, 0.020837031304836273, -0.018635040149092674, -0.0716923177242279, 0.05256519094109535, -0.02592489868402481, -0.023154377937316895, 0.04572874307632446, 0.08488763868808746, -0.06187508627772331, -0.017566682770848274, -0.0008919961401261389, -0.06756281852722168, -0.0403657890856266, 0.011523622088134289, 0.05428334325551987, -0.022022491320967674, 0.00935057271271944, -0.051733531057834625, 0.03898921608924866, 0.04051348939538002, 0.031207581982016563, 0.0375451035797596, 0.006300163455307484, -0.02177610993385315, 0.005166931543499231, 0.013886593282222748, -0.021801862865686417, 0.006300338543951511, 0.029285486787557602, 0.015996664762496948, -0.0003363782016094774, 0.01222184021025896, -0.00155221251770854, 0.018745871260762215, 0.044340163469314575, 0.012313933111727238, 0.026137595996260643, 0.028365185484290123, 0.06534438580274582, 0.018409952521324158, 0.0656047984957695, -0.048709090799093246, -0.0174440648406744, -0.03027414344251156, -0.039284802973270416, 0.018113628029823303, -0.01013056468218565, 0.008903509937226772, -0.017356114462018013, -0.0286484993994236, 0.012984005734324455, 0.003943589515984058, 0.057246092706918716, -0.008318168111145496, -0.01798037253320217, -0.020956791937351227, 0.010311760939657688, -0.0047630444169044495, -0.009095444343984127, 0.0723286122083664, -0.011296860873699188, 0.01873973198235035, -0.012113753706216812, -0.008865353651344776, 0.02086133509874344, -0.006922033615410328, -0.03662931174039841, -0.03069600649178028, 0.0034000768791884184, 0.01521002035588026, 0.04038155823945999, 0.05866469442844391, 0.07329622656106949, 0.0058278231881558895, -0.02419225312769413, 0.024321716278791428, 0.002530191093683243, 0.03148788586258888, 0.08692710846662521, 0.03769250959157944, 0.038066547363996506, -0.013913207687437534, 0.012324617244303226, -0.002736017806455493, 0.005036469548940659, 0.06282737106084824, -0.030505351722240448, -0.023483866825699806, -0.0168718583881855, -0.015259284526109695, -0.011883577331900597, 0.02096826210618019, -0.003539348253980279, -0.0023615204263478518, -0.045553792268037796, -0.030245978385210037, -0.03875149413943291, 0.004353351425379515, -0.03462948277592659, -0.05279757082462311, -0.03934367746114731, -0.006022881716489792, -0.01341579481959343, 0.017695657908916473, 0.05996759980916977, 0.0050835018046200275, 0.008832820691168308, 0.03714902698993683, 0.08254867792129517, 0.04488012194633484, -0.009419877082109451, 0.05512997508049011, 0.007618744857609272, -0.013050624169409275, -0.0013303011655807495, -0.03258359059691429, -0.04166116565465927, -0.016462795436382294, -0.02857685275375843, 0.08561690151691437, -0.021636471152305603, 0.033431582152843475, 0.02434627339243889, 0.053109705448150635, 0.007523480337113142, 0.029581768438220024, 0.005427831783890724, 0.0011627307394519448, 0.01090047787874937, 0.0029655841644853354, -0.025898585096001625, -0.0018936574924737215, -0.024055734276771545, 0.03389369696378708, -0.03927036374807358, -0.009705152362585068, 0.05243520066142082, 0.06125549226999283, -0.004785931669175625, 0.10105970501899719, 0.05119325965642929, -0.07711565494537354, -0.0867890939116478, -0.022708363831043243, 0.035699810832738876, 0.0009803969878703356, 0.04645445942878723, -0.016206208616495132, 0.02625405043363571, 0.043805912137031555, -0.0005258225719444454, -0.03481636568903923, 0.02276644855737686, -0.02873735874891281, -0.06477745622396469, -0.03777589648962021, -0.040172554552555084, 0.01581599749624729, -0.021357249468564987, -0.013887200504541397, 0.05146978050470352, 0.04336871951818466, -0.022998837754130363, -0.00021359867241699249, 0.027623744681477547, 0.013537142425775528, 0.031041260808706284, -0.09757927060127258, -0.010015973821282387, -0.029274405911564827, 0.01827097125351429, -0.07808287441730499, -0.00492927385494113, 0.001976137515157461, -0.014813052490353584, -0.03156300261616707, 0.025556199252605438, 0.029613906517624855, -0.0760892778635025, -0.03582252562046051, -0.005395994056016207, 0.03508615493774414, 0.038968898355960846, -0.02716270461678505, -0.013708991929888725, -0.016045937314629555, -0.06350573152303696, 0.029879000037908554, 0.004935364704579115, 0.00836875755339861, -0.049941789358854294, -0.04508102685213089, 0.01774679310619831, 0.07127297669649124, -0.03958534076809883, 0.022806797176599503, -0.011459105648100376, -0.003182176733389497, 0.01233712024986744, 0.04264195263385773, 0.040805112570524216, 0.006598906125873327, 0.04065863788127899, 0.07283906638622284, -0.029000679031014442, -0.01565892994403839, 0.011639947071671486, -0.04230383038520813, -0.050437815487384796, 0.05004284158349037, 0.01584821753203869, -0.012295883148908615, -0.024287432432174683, -0.018077734857797623, -0.09855471551418304, -0.0035973493941128254, 0.0305668655782938, -0.0072570922784507275, -0.053181540220975876, -0.0781208798289299, -0.006261367816478014, 0.0056673563085496426, 0.008801768533885479, 0.023460058495402336, -0.033043261617422104, -0.014314412139356136, -0.00017752821440808475, 0.014858214184641838, -0.012507244013249874, -0.07044178992509842, -0.043157387524843216, 0.0033380112145096064, 0.011134696193039417, -0.03954846411943436, -0.05842609331011772, 0.0037840709555894136, 0.006783151067793369, 0.011106940917670727, 0.054187119007110596, 0.016620494425296783, 0.0258307084441185, -0.014196069911122322, -0.0038806090597063303, 0.00300571764819324, -0.0044843889772892, 0.04293551295995712, -0.012793734669685364, -0.04636547714471817, 0.005915460176765919, -0.06850259006023407, -0.02566593326628208, -0.014126104302704334, -0.08536547422409058, 0.04169928655028343, -0.03965664654970169, -0.004518168978393078, -0.006121561396867037, 0.015597662888467312, -0.04997627064585686, 0.02800208330154419, -0.0009732304024510086, 0.021383091807365417, 0.028378458693623543, 0.046907052397727966, -0.0425853356719017, 0.031213857233524323, 0.03639513999223709, 0.0008820578223094344, 0.012001457624137402, -0.023343266919255257, -0.0843171775341034, -0.007741243112832308, 0.02798483707010746, 0.0035776211880147457, -0.04567103087902069, -0.024052567780017853, 0.028435803949832916, -0.03888605907559395, -0.0015034396201372147, -0.02889077179133892, 0.022260425612330437, 0.07795260101556778, -0.07165881991386414, -0.02625116892158985, -0.004401514772325754, 0.012148533947765827, -0.006920706480741501, 0.010397624224424362, 0.014736022800207138, 0.009360465221107006, 0.002083484549075365, 0.04166337475180626, -0.04464995861053467, 0.02927456982433796, -0.034880753606557846, -0.09138468652963638, 0.06085548549890518, -0.0629284679889679, 0.044560402631759644, 0.00807615090161562, 0.00875136163085699, 0.02976289764046669, 0.013621187768876553, 0.02428409829735756, -0.048976607620716095, 0.019852841272950172, 0.05463770031929016, -0.023801611736416817, -0.04232238605618477, 0.0913943275809288, -0.011830667965114117, -0.06998127698898315, -0.003058206057175994, 0.009755178354680538, 0.037633057683706284, -0.0689278393983841, -0.02875983528792858, 0.04175084829330444, -0.004338916391134262, 0.0058353859931230545, -0.0508737675845623, 0.03486756607890129, -0.0023697956930845976, -0.012237580493092537, -0.061202097684144974, 0.0654132291674614, 0.005273826420307159, 0.06164742633700371, 0.011008278466761112, -0.020745497196912766, -0.0021437720861285925, 0.0010815835557878017, 0.06678404659032822, -0.0003339909017086029, -0.0201191958039999, -0.04863843694329262, -0.04309532791376114, 0.007806001231074333, 0.057709284126758575, -0.0613534040749073, -0.014835605397820473, 0.004176449496299028, -0.017798887565732002, 0.035326238721609116, 0.03179914131760597, 0.023218445479869843, 0.02601906843483448, -0.01982739567756653, -0.046940289437770844, 0.00852589588612318, 0.07024359703063965, -0.09891416132450104, -0.03326937183737755, 0.005119724199175835, 0.05802946910262108, 0.010353174060583115, 0.03977415710687637, 0.041631631553173065, -0.001030607963912189, -0.03411770984530449, -0.026926884427666664, 0.011236670427024364, 0.0551070012152195, 0.03631015494465828, 0.00517986249178648, 0.037589266896247864, -0.05446906387805939, 0.04808990657329559, -0.01438295841217041, 0.06397053599357605, 0.004103224724531174, 0.021534882485866547, 0.03753587231040001, 0.022347666323184967, -0.036053963005542755, 0.029977913945913315, -0.030394399538636208, -0.04332635551691055, 0.01043873280286789, 0.032378487288951874, 0.042392753064632416, 0.02863689325749874, -0.026168372482061386, -0.022262820973992348, -0.013176020234823227, -0.01895100064575672, 0.07098743319511414, -0.04195296764373779, 0.07765666395425797, 0.06046850234270096, 0.018567325547337532, -0.06365778297185898, 0.016141613945364952, 0.04351125285029411, -0.01113985851407051, 0.01683185249567032, 0.03635421022772789, -0.008594122715294361, -0.024134516716003418, 0.0004527681740000844, 0.028106991201639175, 0.0005603895988315344, 0.027718396857380867, 0.013140342198312283, -0.06074129045009613, -0.04611662030220032, -0.00659209955483675, 0.006491462234407663, -0.0047253193333745, -0.07222609966993332, 0.01727239042520523, -0.013563154265284538, 0.025020062923431396, 0.05815230682492256, 0.06198135018348694, -0.06127557158470154, 0.020368576049804688, -0.009176804684102535, 0.01421070285141468, -0.04555438086390495, -0.029765479266643524, -0.03321987763047218, -0.029414687305688858, 0.06789574027061462, 0.0003217716875951737, 0.07316037267446518, -0.021877044811844826, 0.04906108230352402, 0.01928246021270752, 0.038425423204898834, 0.09814772754907608, 0.014722618274390697, -0.03816414624452591, -0.0065635074861347675, 0.00975021068006754, -0.0544012114405632, -0.03163902088999748, -0.0686827152967453, 0.017585359513759613, -0.024441111832857132, -0.05731707438826561, -0.011973503977060318, -0.013835950754582882, -0.07020656764507294, -0.04577743262052536, 0.07758557796478271, -0.022207817062735558, 0.08608394861221313, -0.06624244153499603, -0.047532688826322556, 0.017229802906513214, 0.03608705475926399, 0.0033382533583790064, -0.008626267313957214, -0.0185130313038826, -0.0063601527363061905, 0.005829204339534044, 0.019134381785988808, -0.018794391304254532, 0.04193144291639328, -0.009947099722921848, 0.08807099610567093, 0.03138973191380501, -0.019115550443530083, -0.0333721823990345, -0.04660626873373985, 0.04682452231645584, -0.0696173906326294, -0.005616244859993458, 0.05022003874182701, 0.06512128561735153, 0.015293707139790058, -0.028878478333353996, -0.018389498814940453, -0.08633376657962799, 0.03168092295527458, -0.03205437958240509, -0.016744505614042282, 0.04325874149799347, 0.028548162430524826, -0.04479648545384407, -0.02693876251578331, -0.01963699422776699, -0.011045861057937145, 0.05223167687654495, 0.029561525210738182, -0.03673776239156723, 0.04559537395834923, -0.056264158338308334, -0.009873459115624428, 0.011759351007640362, -0.022530758753418922, 0.03221574425697327, 0.007497139275074005, 0.006649404298514128, -0.0009662759839557111, 0.040311768651008606, -0.03135453164577484, -0.018461478874087334, 0.017448734492063522, -0.028506359085440636, 0.032329536974430084, -0.017612500116229057, -0.029501402750611305, -0.02413886785507202, -0.067088283598423, -0.01913031004369259, 0.023088255897164345, -0.05361209064722061, -0.03903115540742874, -0.00366538786329329, -0.03957080468535423, 0.05969687178730965, -0.008840665221214294, 0.019126322120428085, 0.004022209905087948, 0.02863762527704239, 0.03648301586508751, 0.06196559965610504, 0.06348110735416412, -0.010258616879582405, -0.016060704365372658, 0.0052480134181678295, 0.020775465294718742, 0.008158286102116108, -0.008344411849975586, -0.0024155168794095516, 0.05289532616734505, 0.0026296230498701334, -0.016541020944714546, 0.04101034253835678, 0.03877532482147217, 0.06498550623655319, -0.018866661936044693, -0.004112040624022484, -0.004724772647023201, -0.0010228579631075263, 0.014856750145554543, 0.04287385195493698, 0.07727573812007904, -0.02704765647649765, 0.006577301304787397, 0.02698531560599804, 0.011787427589297295, -0.02606566622853279, 0.03288508579134941, 0.023566223680973053, -0.038705307990312576, 0.017209209501743317, 0.040167007595300674, -0.008587821386754513, 0.006679255049675703, 0.009460431523621082, 0.012670233845710754, -0.005997301544994116, -0.013952193781733513, 0.02135370671749115, 0.016814643517136574, -0.04938666522502899, -0.02977403998374939, 0.05277891457080841, -0.008810093626379967, -0.020511562004685402, 0.014496084302663803, -0.026642128825187683, -0.03631332889199257, -0.037534695118665695, -0.02444598823785782, 0.020785601809620857, 0.04677004739642143, 0.02955719269812107, -0.010017050430178642, -0.011741234920918941, 0.0054700677283108234, 0.01419361773878336, 0.025803178548812866, -0.03768135607242584, -0.009665596298873425, -0.03351125493645668, -0.0020440046209841967, -0.05383587256073952, 0.0018432060023769736, -0.013531049713492393, -0.03379306569695473, -0.023014023900032043, -0.053709547966718674, -0.055829428136348724, -0.0557689368724823, 0.0035587309394031763, -0.032801564782857895, -0.01122215110808611, 0.04479179531335831, -0.012125581502914429, -0.0028511094860732555, 0.050328873097896576, 0.0027346790302544832, -0.019562311470508575, 0.024881694465875626, -0.05494098365306854, 0.02958773821592331, 0.013279315084218979, -0.03567971661686897, 0.02168545313179493, -0.059093642979860306, -0.052295442670583725, 0.04791105166077614, 0.01959707960486412, 0.001729389070533216, -0.03482406958937645, -0.0060737039893865585, 0.04779433831572533, -0.0678183063864708, 0.022313669323921204, 0.007230895571410656, -0.06379307806491852, 0.02830525115132332, 0.0682559609413147, 0.02062874101102352, 0.018070580437779427, -0.02435634285211563, -0.010243967175483704, 0.010760549455881119, 0.04154922813177109, 0.017794840037822723, 0.0032304704654961824, -0.009514078497886658, -0.0135907381772995, -0.011891022324562073, -0.030321583151817322, 0.006129106041043997, 0.03792230784893036, 0.023866554722189903, 0.005679133348166943, 0.0384892039000988, -0.00643673911690712, -0.01573028974235058, -0.022709613665938377, -0.00014789662964176387, 0.015430845320224762, -0.06482566893100739, -0.06457169353961945, -0.01381981186568737, -0.005838118959218264, 0.030042918398976326, -0.04012303054332733, -0.004088406451046467, 0.012229601852595806, -0.00555781926959753, -0.03601294383406639, 0.0030349181033670902, -0.013601304031908512, 0.018740011379122734, 0.05219913646578789, -0.0009960400639101863, -0.005364592652767897, -0.03602012246847153, 0.015331522561609745, -0.007190081290900707, 0.056316982954740524, 0.026785342022776604, 0.026947783306241035, -0.0472077801823616, 0.02269437350332737, 0.03259515389800072, -0.037664562463760376, 0.03487306088209152, 0.0033973262179642916, 0.02181495726108551, -0.03075590915977955, 0.0060556260868906975, -0.020150532945990562, -0.0024102346505969763, 0.032274022698402405, 0.00667297188192606, -0.04663357511162758, -0.00913738552480936, -0.024465715512633324, -0.013020516373217106, -0.04448902979493141, -0.019681336358189583, -0.04512428119778633, -0.013192011043429375, -0.022374995052814484, 0.009563427418470383, -0.005394458770751953, -0.05918195843696594, -0.012836850248277187, -0.016069049015641212, -0.03467431291937828, -0.008824174292385578, 0.03277928754687309, -0.005163852125406265, 0.015916382893919945, 0.02009805664420128, 0.059649281203746796, 0.03482048213481903, -0.02536088041961193, 0.005795865785330534, 0.08066997677087784, 0.010949290357530117, 0.022670136764645576, -0.04359012469649315, -0.04002109169960022, -0.046419408172369, -0.05660280957818031, -0.05296174809336662, 0.02679581753909588, -0.02226504310965538, 0.014519747346639633, -0.00751170190051198, 0.03058766759932041, -0.00200020894408226, 0.015022644773125648, -0.04827412962913513, -0.019871681928634644, 0.0015818211250007153, 0.06309215724468231, -0.03736259788274765, 0.005399901419878006, 0.05867405980825424, 0.014488976448774338, -0.0303645096719265, -0.07346195727586746, 0.012879337184131145, 0.013150682672858238, 0.005854879971593618, 0.036351121962070465, 0.03466002270579338, -0.02071976661682129, 0.03243870288133621, 0.004217610694468021, -0.08434176445007324, 0.03234932944178581, -0.021849898621439934, -0.03976232931017876, 0.026746787130832672, 0.030731242150068283, 0.024685123935341835, -0.1267026662826538, -0.020664626732468605, -0.0033126294147223234, -0.042866963893175125, 0.025914715602993965, -0.0038449440617114305, -0.012759586796164513, 0.016698895022273064, 0.007212284952402115, -0.025409787893295288, -0.06594926118850708, -0.019581874832510948, 0.0060899751260876656, 0.00479715084657073, -0.016824277117848396, -0.014139511622488499, 0.05822308734059334, -0.03660241886973381 ]
<p>Assume a test charge with charge $Q$ is placed at the center of a 13-sided regular polygon, the vertices of which are charges with equal charge $q$. What is the electrical force on the center charge?</p> <p>To start we write this as our electrical force... $$ \vec{F}_{Q} = \sum^{13}_{n} \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_{0}}\frac{qQ}{R^{2}} \left(cos\left(\frac{2n\pi}{13}\right)\hat{i} , sin\left(\frac{2n\pi}{13}\right)\hat{j}\right) $$ </p> <p>and with some simplification we get... $$ \vec{F}_{Q} = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_{0}}\frac{qQ}{R^{2}} \left\{1-2cos\left(\frac{\pi}{13}\right) + 2cos\left(\frac{2\pi}{13}\right)-2cos\left(\frac{3\pi}{13}\right) + 2sin\left(\frac{\pi}{26}\right)-2sin\left(\frac{3\pi}{26}\right)+2sin\left(\frac{5\pi}{26}\right), 0\right\}$$ ...more simplification... $$ \vec{F}_{Q} = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_{0}}\frac{qQ}{R^{2}} \left\{ 1.11022\times10^{-16}, 0 \right\} $$ Now we have an electrical force on the test charge, however, in a ring of equidistant charges such as the one mentioned above, shouldn't the $\hat{i}$ component be equal to zero? Does anyone have any ideas as to why I'm getting a non-zero number for my $\hat{i}$ component?</p>
g9761
[ 0.02968464605510235, 0.0016604879638180137, -0.02298000082373619, -0.09033581614494324, 0.11442781984806061, -0.06333108991384506, 0.05270077660679817, 0.00643281452357769, 0.008271493948996067, 0.02327747456729412, -0.05128590390086174, 0.01669388636946678, -0.05829045549035072, -0.007572786416858435, 0.007917357608675957, 0.06761263310909271, 0.03878561407327652, 0.00814125407487154, 0.05156564712524414, 0.024269094690680504, -0.04819733276963234, 0.03090963512659073, -0.03818436339497566, -0.025685781612992287, 0.027796676382422447, -0.0242985300719738, 0.0664132833480835, 0.03379452973604202, -0.04383595287799835, -0.07308707386255264, -0.024887053295969963, 0.0430435873568058, 0.020184768363833427, -0.03235846757888794, -0.04057074338197708, 0.03029935620725155, 0.017852818593382835, 0.018520310521125793, 0.017255626618862152, -0.015783539041876793, -0.022433383390307426, -0.030072268098592758, 0.033744797110557556, -0.018180301412940025, 0.0323764830827713, 0.005841750185936689, -0.020323621109128, 0.012490909546613693, -0.026997797191143036, 0.01877022162079811, -0.061299219727516174, -0.01780863292515278, 0.009194206446409225, -0.0416468009352684, 0.003940362483263016, 0.006126719061285257, 0.0010535228066146374, 0.01192993950098753, -0.027127107605338097, 0.11310447007417679, 0.03932256996631622, 0.04374752193689346, 0.014767426066100597, 0.04353128746151924, 0.022496845573186874, -0.013283543288707733, 0.03943977132439613, 0.044205598533153534, -0.026450999081134796, 0.02297891303896904, -0.06544822454452515, -0.07634904980659485, 0.03291076421737671, 0.0026971232146024704, -0.008139736950397491, -0.0043261488899588585, 0.04192115366458893, 0.03601692244410515, -0.018687529489398003, -0.054120372980833054, 0.02161148376762867, -0.029534613713622093, 0.03787248581647873, 0.013645321130752563, 0.06875240802764893, -0.020945647731423378, -0.017778409644961357, -0.01650824025273323, 0.016190189868211746, 0.012377000413835049, 0.0056869774125516415, 0.03937254473567009, 0.05010658875107765, 0.02689625695347786, -0.0022697830572724342, -0.053541190922260284, 0.013100958429276943, 0.013943439349532127, 0.00307728024199605, 0.009396376088261604, -0.02756597474217415, -0.003922492265701294, -0.017875274643301964, 0.015534310601651669, -0.013017005287110806, 0.015489653684198856, -0.027224266901612282, 0.048639170825481415, -0.025204848498106003, -0.02757333591580391, -0.014582711271941662, 0.01140262745320797, -0.07925178110599518, -0.0587991438806057, -0.03467390313744545, 0.03333701565861702, 0.05284472927451134, -0.031088531017303467, -0.002278317231684923, 0.04226679354906082, 0.027922924607992172, 0.0019843806512653828, -0.0015486115589737892, 0.04058825224637985, -0.05553141236305237, -0.017618050798773766, 0.04365799203515053, 0.06900009512901306, 0.028581537306308746, 0.030328402295708656, 0.008981493301689625, -0.011664576828479767, -0.01617865264415741, -0.01624264381825924, -0.004466605372726917, 0.02642957866191864, -0.042694155126810074, -0.002578727900981903, 0.006177340634167194, -0.023621566593647003, -0.04468455910682678, -0.02855253964662552, 0.0011091141495853662, -0.01636495068669319, -0.01296026911586523, -0.023987123742699623, -0.03203166648745537, -0.03831151872873306, 0.013356602750718594, -0.014537716284394264, 0.00041045143734663725, 0.03289565071463585, 0.031469251960515976, -0.06440854072570801, -0.008246595971286297, -0.06983647495508194, 0.0551629513502121, -0.023787984624505043, 0.011211968027055264, 0.019785013049840927, 0.04430589824914932, 0.0186669509857893, 0.05992193520069122, 0.004476768430322409, -0.042106688022613525, -0.005000568460673094, 0.00759190134704113, -0.036039479076862335, 0.03206939622759819, -0.03629973903298378, -0.016093064099550247, 0.008259239606559277, -0.006582472939044237, -0.00347924348898232, -0.003318670205771923, 0.0409361757338047, -0.060842808336019516, -0.04348761960864067, 0.07383180409669876, 0.006684149615466595, -0.02706610970199108, 0.004114333540201187, 0.037998951971530914, 0.0268484428524971, -0.06136066094040871, -0.020963259041309357, -0.029300130903720856, 0.08046641945838928, 0.027938906103372574, -0.001480781240388751, -0.07644735276699066, 0.06879084557294846, -0.07137495279312134, 0.07580521702766418, -0.006399320438504219, -0.026185669004917145, -0.05978270247578621, -0.07611083984375, -0.01605672761797905, -0.0684618428349495, -0.01649259589612484, 0.036845698952674866, -0.00952164176851511, 0.00922113936394453, -0.017413636669516563, -0.04206739366054535, -0.030086426064372063, -0.050915855914354324, 0.04709400236606598, 0.02124149724841118, 0.005923235323280096, -0.020618801936507225, -0.04017093405127525, 0.06594938039779663, 0.014159019105136395, -0.057901687920093536, 0.013841803185641766, -0.046545639634132385, -0.05762757360935211, 0.04398401081562042, -0.05104086548089981, -0.0247443038970232, 0.05085111781954765, -0.05265304073691368, -0.040982551872730255, -0.009205112233757973, 0.053745392709970474, -0.02432497777044773, -0.07031289488077164, 0.018049487844109535, -0.05195319280028343, 0.036058396100997925, -0.03151080384850502, 0.02248365245759487, 0.043195270001888275, 0.03850062936544418, -0.05438581109046936, -0.016200942918658257, 0.007071956992149353, -0.06736207753419876, 0.009666820988059044, 0.005279888864606619, -0.0375501848757267, 0.016339927911758423, 0.025262730196118355, 0.0039038490504026413, 0.054490815848112106, -0.0009468400967307389, -0.049848996102809906, 0.04109347611665726, -0.01625637523829937, -0.003200898412615061, -0.017129089683294296, 0.06047382205724716, -0.01918494515120983, 0.006720416247844696, -0.012063278816640377, -0.006840688642114401, -0.013459368608891964, -0.07500535994768143, -0.06584290415048599, -0.011702358722686768, -0.01263235229998827, 0.047627151012420654, -0.06883223354816437, 0.02092645689845085, -0.06712079048156738, -0.0025733124930411577, 0.04577694460749626, -0.008182366378605366, 0.008830654434859753, 0.057405661791563034, 0.01091232430189848, 0.02548024244606495, 0.006956030149012804, -0.027311870828270912, -0.025118164718151093, 0.007687046192586422, 0.05252227559685707, 0.008355033583939075, 0.028973305597901344, 0.037011291831731796, 0.020257772877812386, 0.05819462984800339, -0.034467682242393494, -0.018819540739059448, 0.023508314043283463, 0.02716275118291378, 0.003911393694579601, -0.01616034097969532, -0.04984143376350403, 0.014918128028512001, 0.04900597035884857, -0.07043812423944473, 0.06711623072624207, 0.022890303283929825, -0.0019489035475999117, -0.043140847235918045, 0.024511361494660378, 0.04350440204143524, 0.006418648641556501, -0.030885078012943268, -0.019340695813298225, 0.023624714463949203, 0.054233308881521225, 0.03207472711801529, 0.005350921303033829, -0.061459463089704514, 0.03654218092560768, 0.010773955844342709, -0.023027515038847923, 0.026836631819605827, 0.022663796320557594, -0.011692267842590809, -0.03428085520863533, -0.002016616752371192, 0.0073397536762058735, 0.017809534445405006, -0.056770019233226776, -0.0029007280245423317, 0.0016255637165158987, 0.005285603925585747, 0.02741553820669651, 0.015214024111628532, 0.0013446161756291986, 0.03452131152153015, -0.03855897858738899, 0.07015541940927505, 0.009343773126602173, -0.015472532249987125, 0.023108797147870064, 0.04898057132959366, -0.004923742730170488, -0.003899511881172657, -0.01411390956491232, -0.024045975878834724, -0.03330918774008751, 0.10711104422807693, 0.02346489019691944, 0.05271056294441223, -0.059228233993053436, -0.01699090376496315, -0.023216625675559044, -0.06434664130210876, -0.008852326311171055, -0.04111003503203392, 0.00757732056081295, 0.007290429901331663, 0.017757775261998177, 0.005901305470615625, 0.008378654718399048, -0.03866324946284294, -0.0075304340571165085, 0.0295543372631073, 0.011522474698722363, -0.005776513367891312, 0.010092816315591335, 0.0191350094974041, -0.07459836453199387, 0.05789284035563469, 0.04779746010899544, 0.003715594531968236, 0.022765304893255234, -0.025539148598909378, 0.023977912962436676, -0.007272247225046158, -0.022688541561365128, 0.04442720115184784, 0.01969699189066887, -0.0678083524107933, 0.018330445513129234, -0.00748329097405076, 0.010646101087331772, -0.0324678048491478, 0.035738199949264526, -0.02038222923874855, -0.04230014979839325, -0.0064702690578997135, -0.025846054777503014, 0.020117856562137604, 0.04563188552856445, -0.00408632168546319, -0.00640996964648366, 0.013876314274966717, 0.022966675460338593, -0.0053662885911762714, 0.00648536579683423, 0.006698080338537693, 0.02749202586710453, -0.017412761226296425, 0.03286822885274887, -0.006534138694405556, 0.020388061180710793, 0.04401472955942154, 0.010278631001710892, -0.0736660584807396, 0.01934337429702282, -0.04220294952392578, -0.06511648744344711, -0.0091534573584795, 0.035104118287563324, 0.009472277015447617, 0.01665698178112507, -0.009320078417658806, -0.024325504899024963, 0.02230500616133213, 0.022043321281671524, 0.014491699635982513, 0.06174928694963455, -0.04167288541793823, -0.0019097616896033287, -0.02322404831647873, 0.006098045036196709, -0.033750325441360474, 0.044675130397081375, 0.01156510878354311, 0.019393472000956535, 0.06857452541589737, -0.013322869315743446, -0.04907359927892685, 0.025265313684940338, 0.020886404439806938, -0.014428257942199707, -0.03720651566982269, 0.052191220223903656, 0.0029045012779533863, 0.03683886304497719, 0.03881918266415596, -0.002926172222942114, -0.01378396525979042, -0.026142708957195282, 0.058440662920475006, 0.007825103588402271, -0.04162333160638809, -0.0504584014415741, 0.019288942217826843, -0.05310387164354324, 0.013574090786278248, -0.049659162759780884, 0.07686974853277206, 0.017712311819195747, 0.05768134072422981, 0.005984841845929623, -0.03147868812084198, 0.03942140191793442, 0.0031869334634393454, -0.044133350253105164, -0.010697734542191029, -0.010621780529618263, -0.026376960799098015, -0.013766099698841572, -0.0019929599948227406, 0.004787394776940346, -0.0417567677795887, 0.018032237887382507, 0.0014964601723477244, -0.0052072228863835335, 0.018505169078707695, -0.06942003220319748, 0.021659793332219124, -0.054944973438978195, -0.014203674159944057, -0.06153566390275955, -0.009949312545359135, 0.013491998426616192, 0.03364904597401619, -0.04506028816103935, 0.011353225447237492, 0.018127908930182457, 0.005273184739053249, 0.03741760551929474, 0.017232030630111694, 0.10082042962312698, 0.04878195375204086, -0.026636207476258278, 0.03859388828277588, 0.02668328955769539, 0.012840185314416885, -0.06422197818756104, -0.03671777993440628, -0.03656163066625595, -0.0020656257402151823, -0.04341331124305725, -0.009843159466981888, 0.01637732982635498, -0.019262121990323067, 0.00914687104523182, -0.03215234726667404, -0.007375859189778566, 0.008486016653478146, -0.006384310312569141, -0.01453377865254879, 0.011771473102271557, -0.04263010993599892, 0.08746408671140671, 0.07805676758289337, 0.0007673660875298083, -0.0555170401930809, 0.04104209691286087, 0.03267405927181244, 0.0005776570760644972, 0.03995220363140106, -0.007319965399801731, 0.039999619126319885, -0.00817153975367546, 0.008048098534345627, 0.024889422580599785, -0.047979436814785004, -0.01253875158727169, 0.002665230305865407, -0.061335496604442596, 0.04396438971161842, 0.06090540066361427, 0.028722960501909256, -0.010318918153643608, 0.08771707117557526, -0.04479338973760605, -0.04028170928359032, -0.024471605196595192, 0.06424997001886368, 0.014850340783596039, -0.020249150693416595, 0.054968688637018204, -0.07360667735338211, 0.02826542593538761, 0.008948644623160362, 0.004395628813654184, -0.09715253114700317, -0.016064288094639778, 0.0282584261149168, -0.011968032456934452, 0.019562985748052597, -0.001729352748952806, -0.0056904456578195095, -0.035038065165281296, -0.050191257148981094, 0.006409235764294863, -0.02265697717666626, 0.036375727504491806, -0.02360018715262413, 0.042814988642930984, -0.07005281001329422, 0.05048217996954918, 0.006178464740514755, -0.03520304709672928, 0.027190355584025383, -0.027720332145690918, -0.01669667661190033, 0.016847193241119385, -0.03350210562348366, 0.00045552378287538886, 0.040956564247608185, -0.042090240865945816, -0.04232145845890045, 0.022257504984736443, 0.01331275049597025, 0.013498298823833466, 0.002889781491830945, -0.020561635494232178, -0.04826192930340767, 0.05144217982888222, -0.006853873375803232, -0.03797700256109238, 0.04684296250343323, 0.022005930542945862, -0.01721961796283722, -0.023809384554624557, 0.015347477048635483, 0.025783488526940346, 0.007445653900504112, 0.08081438392400742, -0.04917887598276138, 0.028985032811760902, 0.010296739637851715, 0.06961575895547867, 0.012466887012124062, -0.034166570752859116, -0.029222922399640083, -0.036630429327487946, 0.01676318608224392, -0.018104294314980507, 0.007973178289830685, 0.04651298746466637, 0.01372832152992487, 0.070665143430233, 0.03976140543818474, -0.03764520213007927, -0.022265084087848663, 0.011439616791903973, -0.03781729191541672, -0.04225430637598038, -0.03931872174143791, 0.02338508889079094, -0.031122354790568352, -0.04209551960229874, 0.012994959019124508, 0.03638678416609764, 0.039510905742645264, 0.04297531023621559, 0.032585736364126205, 0.0532599575817585, 0.009588507004082203, 0.022074874490499496, 0.013706588186323643, 0.03746901452541351, -0.008318422362208366, 0.04245574027299881, -0.06447308510541916, -0.0842328742146492, -0.0054618134163320065, 0.027764497324824333, 0.03537649288773537, -0.044286247342824936, -0.002821131842210889, 0.03225259855389595, -0.010345536284148693, 0.05264898017048836, -0.01937147043645382, -0.04815323278307915, -0.03207092359662056, 0.032308004796504974, 0.008522833697497845, -0.011970261111855507, -0.012180186808109283, 0.0338912159204483, 0.032548997551202774, 0.015863310545682907, -0.009750597178936005, 0.03461041674017906, 0.005716119892895222, -0.005811885930597782, 0.016685623675584793, -0.04158942028880119, 0.02284480631351471, 0.03992868587374687, 0.03289707005023956, -0.01300265546888113, -0.012058736756443977, 0.04272160306572914, 0.05065368115901947, -0.02663813903927803, 0.05039123818278313, 0.013682402670383453, -0.006433896720409393, -0.03235902264714241, -0.006760800257325172, 0.03028184361755848, 0.012151076458394527, -0.04184844717383385, 0.07005608826875687, 0.07674622535705566, 0.0027796204667538404, 0.024954045191407204, 0.04653843492269516, -0.06885220855474472, -0.021884735673666, 0.04321258142590523, 0.0026757840532809496, 0.007431922014802694, -0.01877570152282715, -0.054152246564626694, 0.04622233286499977, -0.018755143508315086, 0.0010619463864713907, -0.04784052446484566, 0.043511178344488144, -0.024723613634705544, -0.05937282741069794, -0.0025267109740525484, -0.07985389232635498, 0.01069014985114336, -0.05494635924696922, -0.04281756281852722, -0.02975248545408249, 0.0008416761993430555, 0.054461318999528885, 0.008107857778668404, 0.05851292237639427, -0.05750306695699692, 0.006767228711396456, -0.037584420293569565, 0.03731752187013626, 0.000934686278924346, 0.013093636371195316, -0.06749643385410309, 0.0025550557766109705, -0.05146172270178795, -0.026521963998675346, -0.011644401587545872, 0.027957148849964142, 0.036610424518585205, 0.043281979858875275, 0.0014309530379250646, 0.08127617090940475, 0.012619747780263424, -0.0013322834856808186, -0.0050867279060184956, 0.04374590516090393, 0.021204566583037376, 0.002087224507704377, 0.02349507436156273, -0.039197564125061035, 0.006837410852313042, -0.05390267074108124, 0.01194694172590971, 0.030251910910010338, -0.06387597322463989, 0.01752437651157379, -0.03478100150823593, -0.04400493577122688, -0.003915803506970406, 0.003044047160074115, -0.018264008685946465, 0.00746941938996315, 0.04522513598203659, 0.06308632344007492, 0.0007396776927635074, 0.045933306217193604, 0.009029898792505264, -0.014769241213798523, -0.048087168484926224, -0.029253501445055008, -0.012751257047057152, -0.04899595305323601, -0.03695957735180855, -0.04619898647069931, -0.005909422412514687, 0.032922763377428055, 0.06335318833589554, -0.029487881809473038, 0.003233429277315736, -0.014882653951644897, -0.016149628907442093, 0.017675280570983887, -0.03439463675022125, -0.04506939277052879, 0.013086256571114063, -0.03488490730524063, 0.020820921286940575, 0.004864642396569252, -0.04837910458445549, -0.04656166955828667, -0.007692884653806686, -0.04709429293870926, -0.01960553415119648, 0.0038211154751479626, -0.050958409905433655, 0.0349237434566021, 0.015006015077233315, 0.022125553339719772, 0.0069492575712502, 0.021505799144506454, -0.07532069832086563, 0.012808654457330704, 0.022067418321967125, -0.02911575511097908, 0.020065151154994965, -0.017797155305743217, 0.022456087172031403, 0.008175622671842575, -0.02042517252266407, 0.0016101478831842542, -0.029835917055606842, 0.025527020916342735, 0.03279842063784599, -0.06344026327133179, -0.03700605779886246, 0.031744759529829025 ]
<p>I've read <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/44457/41825">this question and answers</a>, but neither of the posts does seem to address my concerns. The problem is as follows:</p> <blockquote> <p>Assuming a device that keeps something in a gravitational field on a constant height, like an electromagnet, how does one measure the required power?</p> </blockquote> <p>I'm stumbling on that because the equation $P = Fv$ would mean that, assuming the object stays in place, the power is zero. That might be true for, say, a rigid construction holding something up. What if I am <em>actively</em> trying to keep something up, like holding it in my hand, or powering an electromagnet to create an electromagnetic field to keep something in the air? I am applying a constant force, but <strong>the object doesn't move</strong>!</p> <p>I've tried to imagine it from the point of <em>theoretical</em> loss of potential energy I'm preventing, but it only got me to something like $P = g^2 m t$, which depends on time. In fact, every attempt to tackle the energy was in vain, because the velocity of the object in a gravitational field, if left without the support, wouldn't be constant (thus making the power depend on time), and is apparently not fit to describe the problem formally.</p>
g315
[ 0.03380409628152847, 0.04314865544438362, 0.003155461745336652, 0.0012915058759972453, 0.013711635954678059, 0.021969320252537727, -0.0017378961201757193, 0.006046010181307793, -0.08052951842546463, -0.023891190066933632, -0.03289519250392914, -0.028049301356077194, -0.05230824649333954, -0.01240681204944849, 0.031064778566360474, 0.03141351044178009, 0.06107495352625847, -0.05015096068382263, 0.019274134188890457, 0.005489227827638388, 0.023395981639623642, -0.03565223515033722, -0.0024810314644128084, -0.006524884141981602, -0.01953953690826893, -0.009022869169712067, 0.041521552950143814, -0.054857444018125534, -0.044059280306100845, -0.06753405928611755, 0.00966890063136816, 0.0028980060014873743, 0.05761305242776871, -0.07073615491390228, -0.07314140349626541, -0.005391465034335852, 0.1021120622754097, 0.04347546026110649, 0.03731970861554146, 0.029880516231060028, 0.013769038952887058, -0.02927863411605358, -0.010568160563707352, -0.011703007854521275, 0.012131301686167717, 0.017960578203201294, 0.014231635257601738, -0.02797369472682476, 0.0094026830047369, -0.03951975330710411, -0.013631798326969147, 0.024644717574119568, 0.06094713509082794, -0.04337412118911743, 0.03022291325032711, 0.018157662823796272, 0.01621377095580101, 0.003881014883518219, 0.011423127725720406, 0.01096835546195507, 0.029898596927523613, -0.02764267288148403, 0.01740330085158348, -0.032739073038101196, 0.010541972704231739, -0.012817532755434513, -0.0751117691397667, -0.021468715742230415, -0.016691602766513824, 0.04251468554139137, 0.00952924694865942, -0.02968607097864151, 0.01930958963930607, -0.02591717801988125, -0.0013927771942690015, 0.032391227781772614, 0.004709851928055286, -0.01183244213461876, 0.04391121864318848, 0.0074640074744820595, -0.005689767189323902, 0.0279310941696167, 0.09097230434417725, 0.052576202899217606, 0.03165820986032486, 0.04659807309508324, -0.02001134864985943, 0.014647776260972023, -0.00604875385761261, 0.044905927032232285, -0.000911437557078898, 0.028490476310253143, 0.059478145092725754, 0.0005580769502557814, 0.025586726143956184, 0.007194166071712971, 0.006456655450165272, 0.032631631940603256, -0.014124393463134766, 0.008203983306884766, -0.0079010846093297, -0.043124280869960785, -0.02726474031805992, -0.01538242306560278, 0.011379700154066086, -0.04360153526067734, 0.023567216470837593, 0.050189319998025894, -0.007059047464281321, -0.011606018990278244, 0.017804250121116638, 0.019463034346699715, -0.01174421701580286, -0.07591712474822998, -0.0683387815952301, -0.0597403347492218, 0.08661750704050064, -0.024207597598433495, -0.017854195088148117, 0.011537935584783554, -0.04961991310119629, 0.0480756051838398, 0.004013036843389273, 0.07185308635234833, -0.059903018176555634, -0.010764652863144875, -0.04833937808871269, -0.01427172776311636, 0.0009575377916917205, 0.0021622339263558388, 0.009379399940371513, -0.018701765686273575, -0.0167279914021492, 0.009055753238499165, -0.0017869389848783612, 0.0724552571773529, -0.005576955154538155, -0.059391312301158905, 0.016879107803106308, 0.019350118935108185, -0.004525010008364916, -0.06723067909479141, 0.03239506483078003, -0.00266657886095345, -0.016011234372854233, 0.053043827414512634, 0.03540361300110817, -0.008739016018807888, 0.06666839867830276, -0.03428618982434273, 0.003974566236138344, 0.1356274038553238, -0.03145663067698479, -0.0793963372707367, 0.11791426688432693, 0.012326844036579132, 0.08331571519374847, 0.0004250708152540028, 0.006087505258619785, 0.013407720252871513, 0.12678931653499603, 0.015881458297371864, 0.03085222840309143, -0.047273408621549606, -0.05034543573856354, -0.007374335080385208, -0.008565228432416916, -0.03090265579521656, 0.014761568047106266, -0.041182637214660645, -0.07789194583892822, -0.007781816180795431, 0.0474792942404747, 0.07084501534700394, -0.040637943893671036, 0.00827515497803688, 0.02639288827776909, -0.013467819429934025, 0.025500696152448654, -0.016989778727293015, 0.012872065417468548, -0.0025940947234630585, 0.04125198721885681, -0.030597133561968803, -0.05878768488764763, 0.027001840993762016, -0.022007830440998077, 0.037309784442186356, -0.03106599859893322, 0.02302705869078636, -0.026579082012176514, 0.016060559079051018, 0.022989578545093536, 0.13005799055099487, -0.02864735759794712, 0.029130036011338234, 0.03224751725792885, -0.056389953941106796, -0.03733474761247635, -0.010604117065668106, -0.01761346310377121, 0.028643660247325897, 0.06465849280357361, 0.03947242721915245, 0.036403752863407135, -0.02129349298775196, 0.007059602532535791, -0.021694881841540337, 0.01984439790248871, -0.0184883214533329, 0.07823541760444641, 0.007549632340669632, -0.056888289749622345, -0.0036178017035126686, 0.03717067837715149, -0.012357449159026146, -0.021147700026631355, 0.019538814201951027, -0.004571150057017803, 0.03764386102557182, -0.06988520175218582, 0.040930863469839096, 0.05068320780992508, 0.016951270401477814, -0.04576645419001579, -0.062258530408144, -0.03101181983947754, 0.002387592801824212, -0.023751745000481606, -0.037176210433244705, -0.03984247148036957, 0.031852103769779205, -0.027175184339284897, -0.00810274202376604, 0.08280172944068909, 0.018081925809383392, -0.03660127893090248, 0.06711270660161972, 0.022766338661313057, -0.002586458809673786, 0.023894082754850388, -0.03084990754723549, 0.019340066239237785, -0.04073497653007507, -0.00964268296957016, -0.03443319350481033, 0.038027726113796234, 0.004626390524208546, -0.021988600492477417, -0.009773352183401585, 0.011398591101169586, -0.044242605566978455, 0.004723329562693834, 0.012846248224377632, -0.01478259265422821, 0.010847576893866062, -0.007168222218751907, 0.011532783508300781, -0.059250883758068085, -0.03606048598885536, -0.013015402480959892, -0.060288313776254654, 0.055705476552248, 0.05946947634220123, -0.01766173727810383, -0.03334585949778557, -0.02701762318611145, -0.02896508015692234, 0.03261175379157066, 0.030470190569758415, -0.04566328227519989, 0.049693651497364044, 0.018413031473755836, 0.045747242867946625, 0.024045871570706367, -0.06318475306034088, 0.005584803409874439, -0.032690901309251785, 0.04499022662639618, 0.047511570155620575, -0.014168362133204937, -0.01952470652759075, -0.041573166847229004, 0.043328385800123215, -0.0035991074983030558, -0.06456632912158966, 0.010430009104311466, -0.0011980512645095587, -0.014955282211303711, -0.051419902592897415, -0.030553536489605904, 0.05316723883152008, 0.010851521976292133, 0.028352094814181328, -0.06210652366280556, 0.03275753930211067, -0.059332430362701416, -0.03286020830273628, -0.036001045256853104, -0.004183789249509573, -0.009971951134502888, 0.021518640220165253, -0.005085742566734552, 0.009017297998070717, -0.0024189825635403395, -0.003930441569536924, -0.022004494443535805, -0.051004379987716675, 0.04739199951291084, -0.00005458036685013212, 0.00003466425187070854, 0.08410616964101791, 0.028318991884589195, 0.0136239193379879, -0.06775861978530884, -0.011485916562378407, 0.0020641894079744816, -0.020504696294665337, -0.03553588688373566, -0.056061986833810806, 0.004875244107097387, -0.044790033251047134, -0.012887583114206791, -0.0018663436640053988, 0.013186502270400524, 0.05285822972655296, -0.04149145632982254, 0.05942181870341301, -0.006232026498764753, 0.013069266453385353, 0.015677595511078835, 0.0007474242593161762, 0.0075467778369784355, -0.04755128547549248, 0.0036594474222511053, -0.021045850589871407, 0.04160409793257713, -0.007924945093691349, 0.055751461535692215, 0.037930671125650406, 0.002621962921693921, 0.006958812940865755, -0.07291177660226822, 0.012132545933127403, 0.017507966607809067, -0.0032339568715542555, -0.02321641519665718, -0.0006308619049377739, 0.006088548805564642, -0.02357720211148262, 0.040304865688085556, -0.03316623345017433, 0.010627125389873981, -0.0003090048849117011, 0.020845362916588783, 0.013538720086216927, 0.002186810364946723, 0.006868697237223387, -0.06487130373716354, 0.003009165870025754, 0.03761163726449013, 0.013313183560967445, 0.030648766085505486, 0.022075338289141655, -0.006994784343987703, -0.0127510204911232, -0.06581834703683853, 0.06009603664278984, -0.011089902371168137, 0.0044908239506185055, 0.06499108672142029, 0.015355399809777737, -0.04503592848777771, 0.02755703404545784, 0.02631698176264763, -0.05115371197462082, 0.0547473169863224, -0.054550763219594955, -0.015961365774273872, -0.007886909879744053, 0.022628113627433777, 0.03485376760363579, -0.04149232432246208, 0.00044585546129383147, -0.00015084396000020206, 0.022258512675762177, -0.04915233701467514, 0.008443356491625309, 0.04862670972943306, -0.039584383368492126, 0.005338733084499836, -0.0206671841442585, -0.009565028361976147, 0.00027244145167060196, 0.0033294495660811663, 0.0064173354767262936, -0.0016068891854956746, -0.03578956797719002, 0.029558055102825165, 0.008392573334276676, 0.055286575108766556, 0.026636755093932152, -0.027831394225358963, -0.006086067762225866, 0.026808176189661026, -0.04486791789531708, 0.09443250298500061, -0.03165033459663391, -0.0322997085750103, 0.0009060015436261892, 0.01166575588285923, -0.04645337909460068, -0.021083777770400047, -0.08449671417474747, 0.038820553570985794, -0.04720717668533325, 0.02757476083934307, 0.021602926775813103, 0.052838388830423355, 0.002881100634112954, 0.02467290498316288, 0.05700962617993355, 0.01639530435204506, -0.06833472847938538, -0.04000922664999962, 0.01983078010380268, -0.016030408442020416, 0.014962395653128624, -0.001208691275678575, 0.019852498546242714, 0.006672537885606289, 0.015309018082916737, 0.027753693982958794, -0.01783636212348938, -0.028903739526867867, 0.0417054109275341, -0.03664114326238632, 0.023694943636655807, 0.0019627753645181656, 0.00776359299197793, 0.059548210352659225, 0.010007294826209545, 0.014710251241922379, 0.0038401922211050987, -0.08599770814180374, 0.04429357126355171, -0.024855751544237137, 0.011190694756805897, 0.04990598186850548, -0.011963989585638046, -0.028136320412158966, 0.000590289244428277, -0.003357065375894308, -0.01520453579723835, 0.00682801054790616, -0.003083076560869813, -0.02018873021006584, -0.036310359835624695, 0.0851350799202919, 0.012077990919351578, -0.05153081938624382, -0.04456470534205437, -0.04003748670220375, 0.03264986723661423, 0.011241578496992588, -0.0050038681365549564, -0.04004465043544769, -0.06758154928684235, -0.027587994933128357, -0.008179252035915852, 0.015137788839638233, 0.018764493986964226, -0.006135331466794014, 0.06175493821501732, -0.04141610488295555, 0.014609858393669128, -0.012425174005329609, 0.03221505507826805, 0.06094428151845932, -0.00872893538326025, -0.014431432820856571, -0.010761696845293045, -0.01089369785040617, -0.0042258561588823795, -0.015736863017082214, -0.0008951799245551229, -0.06104743480682373, 0.028168192133307457, 0.04027019441127777, -0.016944503411650658, 0.02443147450685501, 0.019234973937273026, 0.00026797197642736137, 0.011386912316083908, -0.04639425128698349, -0.003644270356744528, 0.0032089476007968187, 0.01372662652283907, -0.03810136020183563, -0.006686294451355934, -0.0069059147499501705, 0.013093661516904831, -0.001160749001428485, -0.02484516054391861, -0.023945380002260208, 0.031046980991959572, 0.04030890017747879, 0.05093187838792801, 0.01943201571702957, 0.04577900469303131, -0.040654972195625305, 0.04725387319922447, 0.010810275562107563, 0.04818880930542946, -0.019648320972919464, -0.033256132155656815, -0.0077233449555933475, -0.011123516596853733, -0.087175153195858, -0.0042826272547245026, 0.04859483242034912, 0.0328034944832325, 0.050110530108213425, -0.035477165132761, 0.07348588109016418, 0.03852840140461922, -0.043089576065540314, 0.010867082513868809, -0.0040192194283008575, 0.04120544716715813, 0.053751833736896515, -0.011867312714457512, -0.06841010600328445, -0.07140360027551651, -0.06009699031710625, -0.0341765396296978, 0.06333845108747482, -0.009230333380401134, 0.01719479076564312, 0.006344979628920555, -0.016911573708057404, -0.013534615747630596, 0.024210559204220772, 0.0031738043762743473, -0.03272128105163574, -0.02152342163026333, -0.022442542016506195, -0.0017657032003626227, 0.07216868549585342, -0.033647552132606506, -0.029778476804494858, -0.014046693220734596, -0.022607645019888878, 0.059539660811424255, -0.0008969522314146161, -0.04139858856797218, 0.025056157261133194, -0.05156402289867401, -0.02367369644343853, -0.0496855154633522, 0.0008516180096194148, 0.009929273277521133, 0.000306696689222008, -0.015819067135453224, 0.043808791786432266, -0.058981701731681824, 0.03319733589887619, -0.04549010097980499, 0.037963367998600006, 0.07860016822814941, 0.02688230760395527, 0.046943794935941696, 0.027851609513163567, -0.00034552576835267246, 0.013665854930877686, -0.0007742641028016806, -0.07855521142482758, -0.001542511978186667, -0.015709292143583298, 0.04044057056307793, -0.025030840188264847, 0.047973889857530594, 0.06878640502691269, -0.02549678646028042, 0.031014975160360336, 0.04002077504992485, -0.05896303430199623, -0.009563620202243328, 0.02330433391034603, -0.007954762317240238, 0.016088249161839485, 0.0005884213023819029, -0.019672738388180733, 0.013522719964385033, -0.04548504576086998, 0.025931615382432938, -0.021068356931209564, -0.04014981538057327, -0.016053633764386177, 0.027302568778395653, -0.01667231135070324, -0.01926587149500847, 0.0128134461119771, -0.058571670204401016, 0.04458682984113693, 0.059022966772317886, 0.010765629820525646, 0.001673911465331912, 0.011030454188585281, -0.050550155341625214, -0.0432438999414444, 0.02024293877184391, 0.028062958270311356, -0.0036303303204476833, -0.026890473440289497, -0.021418433636426926, 0.03562234714627266, 0.002624369692057371, -0.032753851264715195, 0.01269094180315733, -0.004790131002664566, -0.015319745056331158, 0.014347121119499207, -0.025363177061080933, 0.04911524057388306, -0.0049200765788555145, -0.03634551540017128, 0.010918578132987022, 0.027318386361002922, -0.022763635963201523, -0.030073968693614006, 0.014830443076789379, -0.0028906483203172684, 0.02428360842168331, -0.0066032144241034985, 0.09737251698970795, -0.03301417455077171, 0.039625369012355804, 0.009320683777332306, 0.009898048825562, -0.008024550043046474, 0.03535300865769386, 0.013252641074359417, 0.0024684283416718245, -0.0659986063838005, 0.0035695398692041636, 0.001973049947991967, 0.049750566482543945, -0.024413753300905228, -0.013525616377592087, -0.015792107209563255, -0.03741772100329399, -0.026962684467434883, -0.028666408732533455, -0.037115197628736496, 0.06691545248031616, -0.03674803301692009, -0.05156444013118744, -0.009707571007311344, -0.036249563097953796, 0.022545091807842255, -0.05855267867445946, 0.003524498548358679, 0.0017005613772198558, -0.045105960220098495, 0.018885524943470955, -0.03603293001651764, -0.02432299219071865, 0.03264079988002777, -0.010958541184663773, -0.01186065562069416, -0.025181394070386887, -0.01706273853778839, -0.01727660745382309, 0.0004377764998935163, -0.01961158774793148, -0.0037127574905753136, 0.010511606931686401, 0.0030336291529238224, -0.04921890050172806, -0.056729912757873535, -0.00835415069013834, -0.04879515618085861, -0.018672078847885132, 0.0007724251481704414, 0.0023606610484421253, -0.06401766091585159, 0.005511438939720392, 0.0626351535320282, -0.00031642502290196717, 0.017955873161554337, 0.07549776136875153, 0.051635999232530594, -0.001025780919007957, 0.021097462624311447, -0.016406573355197906, 0.00855381228029728, 0.022717896848917007, 0.04175293445587158, -0.035329464823007584, 0.005587116349488497, -0.021039370447397232, 0.004902214277535677, 0.021463116630911827, 0.006043127737939358, 0.033075347542762756, -0.05913224443793297, -0.05403315648436546, -0.0571771003305912, 0.05903986468911171, -0.02794531360268593, 0.06430621445178986, -0.02883877605199814, -0.04370497912168503, 0.048464298248291016, 0.036943886429071426, -0.057581573724746704, 0.012321650050580502, 0.0033311324659734964, -0.019762510433793068, -0.04190694913268089, 0.012643285095691681, -0.0029036356136202812, -0.06651902198791504, -0.01473531685769558, 0.014062226749956608, 0.005716178100556135, -0.028826428577303886, 0.028355594724416733, 0.004046429879963398, -0.01263759471476078, -0.04479262977838516, -0.0067516821436584, 0.039537183940410614, 0.04068753495812416, -0.029276378452777863, 0.004834746476262808, -0.013310977257788181, -0.004215351305902004, -0.011305206455290318, -0.032021377235651016, -0.03986939415335655, -0.04948418587446213, 0.014200008474290371, 0.04497740790247917, 0.010070889256894588, -0.0647808313369751, 0.0662899911403656, 0.07351416349411011, -0.00979606807231903, 0.004937454592436552, 0.025547737255692482, -0.06545453518629074, 0.014370123855769634, 0.00930323451757431, -0.03581836819648743, -0.02528194710612297, -0.05869929865002632, 0.040613312274217606, 0.032029084861278534, -0.013926636427640915, -0.018008766695857048, -0.040870022028684616, -0.0349549874663353, -0.0260122399777174, -0.04116726666688919, 0.05251043662428856, 0.03984766826033592 ]
<p>I have been told that the a freezer will freeze food slower if: a) the product load is greater then the capacity b) the capacity is greater then then the load.</p> <p>In a) I think this means if a freezer can freeze 2kg of food in 12 hours, using more food will cause the freezer to work slower and so freeze slower. Is this the case?</p> <p>In b) surely if the capacity is greater then the load that means it will freeze fast or at a normal rate? Or do you think it is referring to a much larger capacity i.e. if 1kg of food is placed inside a deep freezer, then it will freeze slower then if 1kg of food was placed inside a smaller freezer. If this is the case, why?</p> <p>Not sure what is right. Can somebody please explain.</p> <p>Thanks</p>
g9762
[ 0.04306695982813835, 0.10066494345664978, 0.02196139097213745, 0.03441297262907028, 0.014364922419190407, -0.016459325328469276, 0.008020598441362381, 0.02804105170071125, -0.10292772203683853, -0.000261620560195297, -0.03337883576750755, 0.03822870925068855, -0.01279072929173708, 0.0006684961263090372, 0.0029489723965525627, 0.03281465172767639, 0.07222875207662582, 0.002424178645014763, 0.004537139553576708, 0.06826993823051453, 0.015174959786236286, 0.041062355041503906, -0.00910938810557127, -0.021548008546233177, -0.10066089779138565, 0.04414660856127739, -0.03082328289747238, 0.053837232291698456, -0.05815626308321953, 0.012525339610874653, 0.015130676329135895, 0.004977855831384659, -0.05513536185026169, -0.037638794630765915, -0.008946139365434647, -0.05483046919107437, 0.08650285750627518, 0.033856309950351715, -0.011641638353466988, -0.030043132603168488, 0.013149002566933632, 0.04644762724637985, 0.0584949254989624, -0.03628833591938019, -0.029950829222798347, -0.002341948449611664, 0.004517222288995981, 0.03442998230457306, -0.002514868276193738, -0.0374375581741333, -0.011830419301986694, 0.06511098891496658, -0.057894717901945114, -0.03429309278726578, -0.009912654757499695, 0.027934297919273376, 0.007085167802870274, 0.04212116450071335, -0.009493821300566196, 0.035734351724386215, -0.028287459164857864, 0.017267532646656036, 0.03362641483545303, -0.0034848933573812246, 0.0407477542757988, 0.01940973848104477, 0.011808698996901512, -0.022334815934300423, 0.09489979594945908, 0.0410471074283123, 0.03457585722208023, -0.04134228453040123, -0.053425051271915436, -0.06918561458587646, 0.03619661182165146, -0.05458710715174675, 0.011728032492101192, 0.024452252313494682, 0.043811339884996414, 0.044806525111198425, -0.052977558225393295, -0.031506847590208054, -0.0023231056984514, 0.05446958541870117, 0.031160861253738403, 0.06381204724311829, -0.024042561650276184, -0.010157454758882523, 0.017876416444778442, 0.10396400094032288, 0.033019766211509705, -0.04786025360226631, 0.029967034235596657, 0.025341326370835304, -0.0602058470249176, 0.034388791769742966, 0.034163106232881546, 0.045898813754320145, -0.011789760552346706, 0.037905268371105194, -0.01880648173391819, 0.023422030732035637, 0.049044638872146606, -0.013632913120090961, -0.02669987455010414, 0.01795809529721737, 0.022402213886380196, -0.007249433547258377, -0.048601455986499786, 0.03796938806772232, 0.03163967281579971, -0.02123304270207882, -0.03857212886214256, 0.015955207869410515, -0.008348715491592884, 0.06180733069777489, 0.04334079846739769, -0.0003042146854568273, 0.025534454733133316, -0.0051450119353830814, 0.028437310829758644, 0.04451839253306389, -0.024805251508951187, 0.02626204676926136, 0.009680213406682014, 0.03104148432612419, 0.01748376153409481, 0.06573484092950821, 0.05474105104804039, -0.0006804801523685455, 0.02619188465178013, 0.012103583663702011, -0.03324555605649948, -0.008220182731747627, -0.03041234239935875, 0.003467441303655505, -0.03017786331474781, 0.02028309553861618, 0.009785297326743603, 0.015033486299216747, -0.04078013449907303, -0.022352302446961403, 0.03717217966914177, 0.041453927755355835, -0.027022315189242363, 0.02396346442401409, -0.02499815821647644, 0.007749819662421942, -0.00747331790626049, -0.00016562633391004056, 0.02293522283434868, 0.04893946647644043, -0.015531700104475021, -0.010045929811894894, 0.020437225699424744, 0.022158991545438766, 0.0035407165996730328, 0.041795916855335236, 0.025585003197193146, 0.024893352761864662, 0.05236606299877167, 0.028733249753713608, 0.02048267051577568, 0.048961568623781204, -0.05274577811360359, 0.044324230402708054, 0.07071354240179062, -0.009741907939314842, -0.047742847353219986, 0.02550126053392887, -0.0031788707710802555, 0.013243480585515499, 0.005793556105345488, 0.020507842302322388, -0.0009797851089388132, 0.025670796632766724, 0.08475320786237717, 0.02429232932627201, 0.01735714264214039, -0.016107570379972458, -0.046960752457380295, 0.0419343039393425, -0.001171203562989831, -0.08787544816732407, 0.027122631669044495, 0.03528731316328049, 0.05455834046006203, 0.0007659676484763622, 0.005549890920519829, 0.007192736491560936, 0.0009712207247503102, 0.03179249167442322, 0.05842656269669533, 0.0496184267103672, -0.01961592026054859, 0.023040419444441795, -0.02060818299651146, -0.027362743392586708, -0.00451932568103075, -0.081052266061306, -0.04738285765051842, -0.05840030312538147, -0.004922230262309313, -0.018910270184278488, -0.02941056899726391, 0.020848123356699944, -0.046389833092689514, 0.008389578200876713, 0.04092835634946823, 0.014984255656599998, -0.0032652593217790127, -0.02687866985797882, 0.007931498810648918, 0.05627967417240143, 0.05317762866616249, 0.02669691853225231, -0.0049666534177958965, -0.0007091669831424952, -0.01016619335860014, 0.02656497061252594, 0.00797300599515438, -0.018019286915659904, 0.009564835578203201, 0.03923408314585686, -0.014520561322569847, -0.04528399556875229, 0.03859661892056465, -0.055851224809885025, 0.012875608168542385, 0.06316859275102615, -0.012574107386171818, 0.02908337488770485, -0.024310017004609108, -0.01329862792044878, -0.01918523944914341, 0.09135639667510986, 0.019075598567724228, 0.03243514895439148, 0.0009569063549861312, 0.014857799746096134, 0.027851710096001625, 0.012956926599144936, -0.03089701011776924, 0.012350495904684067, 0.009143698960542679, -0.052581313997507095, 0.0606665201485157, -0.042635295540094376, 0.03208615630865097, 0.01792030595242977, -0.022884950041770935, -0.0014993519289419055, 0.04285605251789093, -0.05472131073474884, 0.03717535734176636, -0.04224371537566185, -0.015660742297768593, 0.017856227234005928, 0.0023699391167610884, -0.05847194045782089, -0.0021118312142789364, 0.04898582026362419, 0.020988639444112778, 0.012372972443699837, -0.03288187459111214, -0.006305684335529804, -0.06708665937185287, 0.012101542204618454, 0.0669635757803917, 0.03267828747630119, -0.006020764820277691, -0.03762005269527435, -0.040213584899902344, -0.016840072348713875, 0.020568907260894775, -0.010505742393434048, -0.05487966910004616, -0.020116884261369705, 0.08447085320949554, -0.028641702607274055, 0.000597536563873291, -0.03616201505064964, -0.03028682805597782, -0.01035289466381073, -0.0223776176571846, 0.014881527051329613, -0.07087399065494537, 0.020334018394351006, -0.03920261934399605, 0.04536261782050133, -0.034879133105278015, 0.01959826983511448, 0.03409909829497337, -0.04199986532330513, 0.029697779566049576, 0.09611261636018753, -0.009526744484901428, -0.03677699714899063, -0.0481746532022953, -0.04917236790060997, -0.014039212837815285, -0.053834229707717896, -0.06556917726993561, 0.036930885165929794, 0.022678742185235023, 0.04960408806800842, -0.05687037110328674, -0.021661898121237755, -0.0437374971807003, 0.0033556222915649414, -0.025976942852139473, 0.07267870754003525, -0.04140607640147209, 0.015983687713742256, -0.019897397607564926, -0.0652884989976883, 0.03718772530555725, 0.027395475655794144, -0.015950212255120277, -0.0660141259431839, 0.0005855472991243005, -0.01145169511437416, 0.014470312744379044, 0.002000275766476989, -0.0057318927720189095, 0.0514034703373909, -0.016075391322374344, -0.01134918536990881, 0.026901254430413246, 0.032106973230838776, 0.012569625861942768, 0.045732684433460236, -0.047254566103219986, -0.030305344611406326, -0.010861150920391083, 0.02613115683197975, -0.004336605314165354, 0.021375222131609917, 0.014964035712182522, -0.013989834114909172, 0.024326222017407417, 0.012576736509799957, -0.030058324337005615, 0.022410260513424873, -0.07882119715213776, -0.012257276102900505, -0.03638235107064247, 0.008174940943717957, -0.02843509428203106, 0.058183059096336365, 0.02082689106464386, 0.0051620760932564735, -0.014516206458210945, 0.013428691774606705, -0.04803798720240593, -0.02052927203476429, -0.02329273521900177, -0.0343426950275898, -0.01862409897148609, -0.018974535167217255, 0.016315417364239693, -0.00761822797358036, -0.005695459898561239, 0.06601632386445999, -0.06562395393848419, 0.02792595885694027, 0.05285356938838959, -0.03894886374473572, -0.04461544007062912, -0.05941883847117424, 0.009648937731981277, 0.018391752615571022, 0.005632065236568451, 0.03179694339632988, 0.04564148560166359, -0.02064993418753147, -0.01647992990911007, 0.006460260134190321, 0.02470768801867962, -0.00014309180551208556, -0.003773842239752412, -0.0512738861143589, -0.04200560227036476, -0.005332873202860355, 0.003459619591012597, -0.06281041353940964, 0.028707707300782204, -0.018826261162757874, -0.00738638686016202, -0.048114702105522156, 0.0008956817327998579, -0.041928764432668686, -0.01822718046605587, 0.0012862930307164788, 0.022707566618919373, -0.001194775104522705, 0.026472708210349083, 0.011868285946547985, 0.02146427147090435, -0.032773394137620926, -0.036757782101631165, 0.008695675060153008, 0.0018400055123493075, -0.038437388837337494, -0.02056320384144783, -0.011075534857809544, 0.024050483480095863, -0.004466011188924313, -0.043289411813020706, -0.010813609696924686, 0.0019241557456552982, -0.00709178950637579, -0.01275059673935175, -0.02505122311413288, -0.03406749665737152, -0.009942459873855114, 0.03444601967930794, -0.0029470818117260933, 0.02546575292944908, -0.02173367328941822, 0.04708794131875038, -0.0039847069419920444, -0.029507845640182495, -0.04800143465399742, -0.02723529003560543, 0.029849665239453316, 0.001757207908667624, 0.020073099061846733, -0.002495528431609273, -0.04991449788212776, 0.03209827467799187, 0.04201686754822731, -0.022036852315068245, -0.005158201791346073, 0.028648123145103455, 0.03545185923576355, -0.002383040264248848, -0.013313528150320053, 0.04449654743075371, 0.0051391939632594585, -0.027860619127750397, -0.01218461710959673, -0.025989942252635956, 0.04668055847287178, -0.006343130022287369, 0.04215940833091736, -0.0543416403234005, -0.012084314599633217, -0.05154247209429741, -0.0945027768611908, 0.023700719699263573, 0.05875125899910927, -0.08497494459152222, -0.06326788663864136, 0.11402914673089981, 0.029910802841186523, 0.00926661491394043, 0.01563485525548458, -0.04379523918032646, 0.03385557979345322, -0.019869429990649223, 0.036687660962343216, 0.016867712140083313, -0.047501254826784134, -0.00847324077039957, -0.039836760610342026, 0.0309311393648386, -0.04107821732759476, -0.044685084372758865, -0.001606481266207993, 0.018459733575582504, -0.03725757077336311, -0.033699166029691696, 0.04756665602326393, 0.03751876950263977, -0.013143486343324184, -0.0044031874276697636, 0.03171234577894211, -0.024330230429768562, 0.022488264366984367, -0.006870574317872524, 0.05819206312298775, -0.024030812084674835, -0.0028219239320605993, 0.021429194137454033, -0.021010756492614746, -0.01886851340532303, 0.004794625099748373, 0.06003018468618393, -0.029273206368088722, 0.04642033576965332, 0.01954473927617073, -0.013348652981221676, 0.06861766427755356, 0.0058739143423736095, 0.010534253902733326, 0.021424675360322, -0.01553274504840374, 0.006677092984318733, -0.03803499415516853, -0.004063980188220739, -0.06824693083763123, 0.01099245622754097, -0.06171802803874016, -0.009965484030544758, 0.05272352322936058, 0.02561366558074951, -0.003242540406063199, 0.004795491229742765, -0.02416572906076908, -0.005973700433969498, 0.0892379879951477, 0.0023264663759618998, -0.003853149013593793, 0.0671466812491417, -0.07957037538290024, 0.005162906367331743, -0.050421714782714844, 0.015635890886187553, 0.025522705167531967, 0.015095073729753494, 0.04673095420002937, 0.04958639666438103, -0.01763766072690487, -0.0790257379412651, -0.019705381244421005, -0.030604224652051926, -0.02022453024983406, 0.03360416740179062, -0.0028437338769435883, 0.010349730029702187, 0.0036132147070020437, 0.06175770238041878, -0.020946163684129715, -0.033167995512485504, 0.000767795427236706, 0.008872829377651215, 0.005789758637547493, 0.013942303135991096, 0.006927285809069872, -0.0025706610176712275, -0.023285163566470146, -0.02695428393781185, 0.0625329539179802, -0.0006589503027498722, -0.07885661721229553, -0.026312287896871567, -0.031149325892329216, 0.014149035327136517, -0.056342896074056625, -0.0586300790309906, -0.019934697076678276, -0.03645382449030876, -0.022770266979932785, 0.036685094237327576, 0.03805354982614517, 0.02005002461373806, 0.03843749314546585, 0.057086750864982605, -0.03672081604599953, -0.033373571932315826, 0.005368049722164869, 0.006986912339925766, -0.07152903825044632, 0.020974332466721535, -0.09175796061754227, -0.006730781402438879, 0.027678346261382103, 0.08700685203075409, -0.036829281598329544, 0.054509036242961884, 0.008373971097171307, -0.019397076219320297, 0.01539874728769064, 0.02966250851750374, 0.006720762699842453, 0.04967838525772095, 0.020659292116761208, -0.012542028911411762, -0.04524531215429306, 0.028690628707408905, -0.028136063367128372, 0.011653464287519455, 0.011188140138983727, 0.020363546907901764, 0.06339829415082932, -0.005401020869612694, 0.028395794332027435, -0.04292004555463791, -0.050067752599716187, -0.0021455485839396715, -0.021537810564041138, 0.01181354932487011, -0.0368284210562706, 0.003689727047458291, 0.05348984897136688, -0.06204909458756447, -0.0007894579321146011, -0.02995380014181137, 0.009870423004031181, -0.016949284821748734, 0.046739596873521805, 0.03186948969960213, -0.06320901960134506, -0.0895334780216217, 0.019730878993868828, 0.01857929490506649, 0.04643254727125168, -0.043499160557985306, 0.06983136385679245, -0.023159874603152275, 0.024424977600574493, 0.08696258068084717, 0.013161255978047848, 0.015937576070427895, -0.0013861781917512417, -0.02970816195011139, -0.028206659480929375, 0.026527920737862587, -0.0051510510966181755, 0.009307912550866604, -0.06655765324831009, -0.036251962184906006, -0.024122772738337517, 0.038074955344200134, 0.0004254476516507566, -0.033852458000183105, -0.004088376183062792, 0.04556289315223694, -0.023894086480140686, -0.005293669644743204, -0.06826838850975037, -0.011879611760377884, 0.07552371919155121, 0.019970959052443504, 0.036948155611753464, -0.016171704977750778, 0.059618838131427765, -0.07144705951213837, -0.023817891255021095, 0.0064766439609229565, 0.0016625249991193414, -0.03399413824081421, 0.03864973038434982, -0.020786408334970474, -0.006404006388038397, 0.006091468967497349, 0.014353702776134014, 0.013271061703562737, -0.03658691421151161, -0.07556668668985367, 0.03123263269662857, -0.006233962718397379, -0.0019319459097459912, -0.017531340941786766, 0.017075831070542336, -0.053081411868333817, 0.07389555126428604, 0.025694509968161583, -0.016826434060931206, 0.013066960498690605, 0.023176046088337898, 0.012634682469069958, 0.00517117977142334, -0.02234141156077385, 0.019475940614938736, -0.003654557978734374, -0.04304058849811554, -0.009905659593641758, -0.0792231336236, -0.004702572710812092, -0.007968657650053501, -0.05830897018313408, -0.04713144525885582, 0.04838370159268379, 0.06805557012557983, -0.010960913263261318, -0.02304408885538578, -0.037381794303655624, -0.012411887757480145, -0.014874759130179882, -0.021130576729774475, -0.025175416842103004, 0.006408611312508583, -0.04580802097916603, 0.03154842182993889, 0.001492811250500381, -0.00955341849476099, 0.03366876393556595, -0.01870153658092022, 0.02650652639567852, -0.017405584454536438, 0.0432964488863945, 0.010195199400186539, -0.07654038071632385, 0.041412949562072754, -0.01793726719915867, 0.022612394765019417, -0.030108250677585602, 0.02642480842769146, -0.03245767578482628, 0.013294842094182968, -0.03161017969250679, 0.04227712005376816, 0.00835204217582941, 0.011061050929129124, 0.030249711126089096, 0.0028285703156143427, -0.02891472727060318, -0.021476468071341515, -0.008523696102201939, 0.012634738348424435, 0.020414026454091072, 0.02993685007095337, 0.0026890982408076525, -0.05645408481359482, -0.04134206473827362, -0.05149301141500473, -0.02266981452703476, -0.07323016226291656, -0.0031347055919468403, -0.04802478849887848, -0.027459392324090004, 0.02175554819405079, -0.011590210720896721, 0.009157177060842514, -0.006725126877427101, -0.02781747467815876, -0.024139689281582832, -0.01780831813812256, -0.0018673682352527976, 0.028301795944571495, -0.04552868753671646, -0.036245908588171005, -0.022465551272034645, -0.012937204912304878, -0.00024474578094668686, -0.006777612958103418, -0.040499087423086166, 0.03913532942533493, -0.006931344047188759, 0.04639868065714836, -0.040778402239084244, -0.011629623360931873, -0.0032804463990032673, 0.002659520832821727, -0.024418173357844353, 0.04378574714064598, 0.0527668371796608, -0.014760770834982395, -0.04019896313548088, -0.04267961159348488, -0.06684953719377518, 0.0050978222861886024, -0.050858527421951294, -0.000010486731298442464, -0.04953165724873543, 0.05729327350854874, -0.07684306055307388, -0.00695606367662549, 0.04373817518353462, -0.002183998702093959, 0.015083632431924343, -0.007511296309530735, -0.016517389565706253, 0.04354221373796463, 0.0028739182744175196, -0.044433992356061935 ]
<p>Does anyone know any materials that have an electroluminescent threshold in the millivolt or microvolt range?</p> <p>Specifically, a stable solid state material. I hope to deposited the material as a thin film.</p> <p>Thank you for the help!</p>
g9763
[ 0.0346234068274498, 0.031146511435508728, 0.011805976741015911, 0.034328460693359375, -0.0386054553091526, 0.04575926065444946, -0.11155454069375992, -0.006373207550495863, 0.02729843184351921, 0.014292380772531033, -0.028340477496385574, 0.07132695615291595, 0.003935088403522968, 0.020185431465506554, -0.0461726039648056, 0.011562146246433258, 0.08165917545557022, 0.02347441576421261, 0.018186474218964577, 0.005149404983967543, -0.030877886340022087, -0.045564182102680206, -0.035483960062265396, -0.04428249970078468, 0.04179028794169426, 0.041950929909944534, -0.014043524861335754, 0.03159252926707268, 0.02276289463043213, -0.025327589362859726, 0.031821489334106445, -0.04256238788366318, 0.024692391976714134, 0.010475735180079937, 0.03999428078532219, -0.010675660334527493, -0.031155185773968697, 0.012875082902610302, 0.03372538834810257, 0.03765365853905678, 0.02820880524814129, 0.013776477426290512, -0.010295762680470943, -0.012436166405677795, 0.055255863815546036, 0.008208787068724632, -0.018656445667147636, -0.02859143540263176, 0.019164210185408592, -0.08345586806535721, 0.049924638122320175, -0.038595933467149734, 0.03868221491575241, -0.04216444864869118, 0.00013700741692446172, -0.006678856443613768, -0.08995775878429413, -0.014539653435349464, -0.04243405535817146, -0.00865698792040348, 0.011011631228029728, 0.008726169355213642, -0.007573900744318962, -0.05079447850584984, 0.02110561914741993, -0.01776459813117981, -0.02293580211699009, -0.06626402586698532, -0.004138015676289797, 0.022767767310142517, 0.04076375812292099, 0.06867411732673645, -0.0411200076341629, 0.015513972379267216, 0.005872066132724285, 0.02029857039451599, 0.009353174827992916, 0.05365670844912529, 0.02144598215818405, -0.06945393234491348, -0.003122062189504504, 0.005336153786629438, -0.018527111038565636, 0.04077732935547829, 0.03092437982559204, -0.04864867404103279, 0.02865736372768879, 0.03541538119316101, -0.028581153601408005, -0.055593956261873245, 0.004177543800324202, 0.018310891464352608, -0.03006056137382984, -0.05397675931453705, 0.005223869811743498, 0.02020908147096634, 0.016479870304465294, 0.008778407238423824, -0.015309903770685196, -0.015209036879241467, 0.03218371048569679, -0.09283281117677689, 0.01827467419207096, -0.014923554845154285, -0.026340428739786148, 0.014912252314388752, -0.03837095946073532, -0.04575108364224434, -0.05207478255033493, 0.012250165455043316, 0.008130716159939766, 0.0034529236145317554, -0.06858759373426437, -0.0015390582848340273, -0.019034482538700104, 0.02550230175256729, 0.06792418658733368, -0.010307548567652702, -0.006268166936933994, 0.015905361622571945, 0.10351559519767761, -0.01674012839794159, 0.03867398574948311, 0.014361223205924034, -0.022869952023029327, 0.015684422105550766, 0.025191932916641235, 0.012752974405884743, -0.005124938674271107, 0.00040852793608792126, 0.06688649207353592, -0.050307296216487885, -0.033652909100055695, -0.02378156967461109, -0.081824891269207, 0.013553552329540253, 0.03384677693247795, -0.029012903571128845, 0.03241268917918205, -0.024280540645122528, 0.0752316415309906, 0.001917109009809792, 0.020580176264047623, 0.010039295069873333, -0.014113126322627068, -0.025032229721546173, -0.013256344012916088, 0.042442746460437775, 0.05936514586210251, 0.05759601667523384, 0.005151667632162571, 0.03568160533905029, -0.00739420298486948, -0.050954435020685196, -0.04908633604645729, -0.027349814772605896, 0.011308110319077969, -0.020767994225025177, -0.022718457505106926, -0.017644470557570457, -0.01503010280430317, 0.03530670702457428, -0.044291526079177856, -0.03876296803355217, 0.00038154618232510984, -0.010038685984909534, -0.05155792459845543, 0.037091679871082306, 0.015721959993243217, 0.07232612371444702, 0.03273409977555275, 0.06084926426410675, 0.06449039280414581, 0.10046206414699554, 0.03733629360795021, 0.00966933835297823, 0.030364735051989555, -0.0452212356030941, -0.007838067598640919, -0.05407270789146423, -0.01025073416531086, 0.005567232146859169, -0.02790972962975502, -0.011408797465264797, -0.03682585060596466, -0.0228411965072155, 0.06760498881340027, -0.0006109828245826066, -0.02142222411930561, 0.036556754261255264, -0.05906962603330612, 0.034594908356666565, -0.059845149517059326, -0.023112988099455833, -0.02844986319541931, -0.02664032019674778, 0.06045445427298546, -0.05829073488712311, 0.02877947688102722, -0.08660143613815308, 0.04621700942516327, -0.024046966806054115, 0.010911750607192516, 0.05187562108039856, -0.042789313942193985, 0.0007831933326087892, 0.016819117590785027, -0.06098935380578041, -0.004696447867900133, -0.0047740633599460125, -0.054596174508333206, 0.0019001062028110027, 0.036174219101667404, -0.003536682343110442, 0.019199296832084656, -0.03310919925570488, 0.03735817223787308, 0.007123185787349939, -0.007860354147851467, 0.023174302652478218, 0.04691341891884804, 0.04379129782319069, 0.018044644966721535, 0.0009649474523030221, 0.00910193845629692, -0.06233114004135132, 0.03576429560780525, 0.0207862239331007, 0.06514520198106766, -0.0173310749232769, -0.05611846596002579, -0.001982984831556678, -0.014158369973301888, 0.01128449011594057, -0.0026005390100181103, 0.044739920645952225, -0.09672946482896805, -0.05789555236697197, -0.022279713302850723, 0.003926518838852644, -0.023222245275974274, -0.019216889515519142, -0.014069950208067894, -0.02053956501185894, -0.036965057253837585, -0.001594458008185029, -0.013043375685811043, 0.013214975595474243, 0.050512589514255524, 0.026274548843503, 0.03670854866504669, -0.07469545304775238, 0.011557403951883316, 0.07986321300268173, -0.02396862395107746, -0.03731150180101395, -0.03593917191028595, 0.0355319045484066, -0.014173698611557484, 0.03593749180436134, 0.0013245940208435059, -0.004640302155166864, -0.017069324851036072, -0.03160832077264786, 0.03402937948703766, -0.023242825642228127, -0.029332056641578674, -0.04300035536289215, 0.029831379652023315, 0.015046831220388412, 0.023575449362397194, 0.03107903152704239, -0.008417842909693718, 0.030001560226082802, 0.041213229298591614, -0.015818985179066658, 0.04670717567205429, -0.04152795672416687, 0.057372190058231354, -0.0053877090103924274, 0.004238007124513388, -0.06358229368925095, 0.02297622710466385, 0.02443498931825161, -0.03653271868824959, -0.0616985559463501, 0.01468033716082573, 0.009736673906445503, -0.0017048653680831194, 0.013096448965370655, -0.04357531666755676, -0.04097627103328705, -0.02722923457622528, 0.014608774334192276, 0.029934048652648926, -0.013500481843948364, -0.038564447313547134, 0.020194627344608307, -0.02590073086321354, 0.0648145079612732, 0.018032951280474663, -0.017502939328551292, 0.03171385079622269, -0.04761965200304985, -0.024510273709893227, 0.005756923463195562, 0.03952145576477051, 0.034935954958200455, -0.008371969684958458, 0.007483351975679398, -0.035582005977630615, -0.007778148632496595, 0.017955347895622253, -0.019942430779337883, -0.07707013189792633, 0.02638167515397072, 0.05298769474029541, 0.021113816648721695, 0.029734091833233833, -0.048037681728601456, 0.03994109854102135, 0.07547985762357712, 0.026710061356425285, 0.0033621490001678467, 0.002653483534231782, 0.021559732034802437, 0.01699318177998066, -0.045326828956604004, -0.03754114732146263, 0.054876770824193954, 0.06661899387836456, 0.004000429064035416, 0.04766125977039337, 0.0158531554043293, -0.02135714516043663, -0.07235651463270187, -0.05367428436875343, -0.0005760767380706966, 0.019869910553097725, 0.008725705556571484, 0.01664711721241474, 0.0053185960277915, -0.009713608771562576, -0.04562988132238388, 0.0016477194149047136, -0.01851418800652027, 0.018304701894521713, -0.011980632320046425, -0.002002100460231304, -0.005372420884668827, 0.03126735985279083, -0.01922171749174595, 0.005480318795889616, -0.05457128584384918, -0.021468767896294594, 0.003759954124689102, 0.011237048543989658, 0.009282580576837063, 0.021033817902207375, -0.06365811824798584, -0.04116950184106827, -0.012176170013844967, 0.07504691928625107, -0.1048872098326683, -0.05601960048079491, -0.009965796954929829, 0.027836428955197334, 0.06542601436376572, 0.0014621185837313533, 0.03192085027694702, -0.002251735655590892, 0.004212087951600552, -0.03375764191150665, -0.007064065895974636, -0.0297545175999403, -0.014422394335269928, -0.020254366099834442, -0.0008046629372984171, -0.08053960651159286, 0.00244124885648489, 0.005827922374010086, -0.0016730891074985266, 0.0005154729005880654, 0.00004162885670666583, -0.05044211074709892, -0.004725529812276363, -0.02176392637193203, -0.003617603797465563, -0.027376612648367882, -0.05562567338347435, -0.06265133619308472, 0.013142132200300694, -0.031238753348588943, -0.014686855487525463, 0.0019723218865692616, -0.05653399974107742, 0.017123989760875702, -0.06819985806941986, 0.09411198645830154, 0.02469712123274803, 0.1090608611702919, 0.03802856057882309, 0.027828650549054146, 0.02731720730662346, 0.06719496846199036, 0.01272729691118002, 0.03344408795237541, -0.0018747961148619652, -0.02740021049976349, -0.009886574000120163, -0.026893824338912964, -0.044063251465559006, -0.00830008089542389, 0.01774648390710354, -0.008433190174400806, 0.014451432973146439, -0.029758600518107414, 0.0045295655727386475, 0.028011014685034752, -0.0007553713512606919, 0.0016171567840501666, 0.020140958949923515, 0.006867979187518358, -0.03010028600692749, -0.0012410967610776424, 0.03763509914278984, 0.031558647751808167, -0.0466429702937603, -0.023993391543626785, 0.03199518471956253, 0.03273656964302063, 0.03462546318769455, -0.012831187807023525, -0.014192404225468636, 0.03957826644182205, 0.018627474084496498, 0.008605139330029488, -0.019321706146001816, 0.004823997151106596, 0.013494154438376427, 0.02400689758360386, -0.04308543726801872, -0.013219025917351246, 0.02758837677538395, -0.03344346955418587, 0.04955791309475899, -0.043716270476579666, 0.014872148633003235, -0.008995966985821724, -0.008086303249001503, 0.009053044952452183, -0.04361990839242935, 0.0297807939350605, -0.004298129118978977, 0.022150741890072823, -0.0024417408276349306, -0.027704060077667236, 0.017161797732114792, 0.05466390773653984, 0.04721996933221817, -0.016530446708202362, 0.047579314559698105, -0.02089552767574787, -0.01920122466981411, 0.004384595900774002, 0.009931868873536587, -0.04281587526202202, 0.013849717564880848, 0.007660129107534885, -0.021987106651067734, -0.037496212869882584, -0.0084642069414258, 0.012946722097694874, 0.046104006469249725, -0.07699877768754959, -0.03200387954711914, -0.05791577324271202, -0.025237848982214928, -0.02900001034140587, -0.015898579731583595, -0.0495227612555027, -0.01612907089293003, -0.02175467275083065, 0.008349400945007801, 0.07185693830251694, 0.05178986117243767, -0.05908990651369095, 0.0564160980284214, 0.0632391944527626, -0.016659623011946678, 0.0140683613717556, -0.018311506137251854, 0.041380349546670914, 0.026933662593364716, -0.011378691531717777, 0.0416642390191555, 0.03875838592648506, -0.026618747040629387, 0.011744978837668896, 0.07541149854660034, 0.022485261783003807, 0.018267372623085976, -0.013284995220601559, 0.002321336418390274, -0.02735494263470173, -0.018303709104657173, -0.018319934606552124, -0.025671225041151047, 0.0201053936034441, -0.004915136378258467, -0.06086078658699989, 0.028597310185432434, -0.009555605240166187, -0.014685492031276226, -0.05117693170905113, -0.009758650325238705, -0.018889471888542175, 0.028253378346562386, -0.0687040314078331, 0.002077636308968067, -0.014829621650278568, -0.06078411266207695, -0.013887470588088036, 0.03340020775794983, 0.017492348328232765, 0.02154051512479782, -0.028350481763482094, 0.005997971631586552, -0.009880173951387405, 0.01678142510354519, 0.014275167137384415, -0.00010090158320963383, -0.01182656828314066, -0.07034248858690262, -0.006941395811736584, 0.01655730791389942, 0.023556848987936974, 0.003169124945998192, -0.006038656458258629, 0.05081004649400711, -0.023856235668063164, -0.021034734323620796, -0.005161464214324951, 0.08108722418546677, 0.1134834811091423, 0.039554063230752945, 0.025274844840168953, 0.04847405478358269, 0.03090812638401985, -0.05893032252788544, 0.029802652075886726, 0.06331773102283478, -0.03848801180720329, 0.044758763164281845, -0.00656499108299613, 0.0878436490893364, 0.02544194832444191, 0.017761314287781715, 0.017393676564097404, 0.0011621675221249461, 0.03764118626713753, -0.027087343856692314, -0.02304043248295784, -0.045612551271915436, -0.0021342046093195677, -0.03836148977279663, 0.030962901189923286, -0.01115361601114273, -0.000836484890896827, 0.0018881841097027063, -0.004903564695268869, 0.03500336781144142, -0.003210049355402589, 0.007098646834492683, -0.05542057752609253, 0.019601920619606972, -0.008751921355724335, -0.04365668073296547, -0.013410699553787708, 0.015571524389088154, -0.0008652177639305592, 0.034390855580568314, -0.016741732135415077, 0.051560062915086746, -0.012766566127538681, -0.019497515633702278, -0.0389978289604187, -0.022539209574460983, -0.03705979883670807, -0.06736874580383301, -0.03265541419386864, -0.009152918122708797, -0.014320449903607368, 0.0003772942873183638, -0.015377052128314972, -0.008094001561403275, -0.039063017815351486, -0.00488341273739934, 0.02372780628502369, -0.008194370195269585, -0.008514177985489368, -0.030053142458200455, -0.015122808516025543, -0.013991175219416618, -0.0009047939092852175, 0.005078773945569992, 0.004496658220887184, 0.021414287388324738, 0.0029646821785718203, -0.006537988781929016, 0.015772445127367973, -0.01622220315039158, 0.009925599209964275, 0.0138094462454319, -0.05435650795698166, -0.006321393419057131, -0.011643314734101295, 0.026675133034586906, -0.00453628646209836, -0.026140257716178894, -0.022050248458981514, -0.00667567178606987, 0.004558276385068893, 0.03729463368654251, 0.0175488218665123, 0.011101744137704372, -0.03243383392691612, 0.037653252482414246, 0.0256221704185009, 0.008524575270712376, -0.011502271518111229, -0.042651303112506866, 0.08043330162763596, 0.03842007368803024, 0.026003176346421242, -0.028332578018307686, 0.03697996586561203, -0.07647689431905746, 0.009981412440538406, -0.0682670921087265, -0.023432647809386253, 0.04794471710920334, 0.03784951567649841, 0.09151923656463623, 0.0010386358480900526, 0.03356042876839638, -0.02467857301235199, 0.031100653111934662, 0.061346713453531265, -0.003744270885363221, 0.05763234943151474, -0.04933029040694237, -0.02109592594206333, -0.018520211800932884, 0.010635938495397568, 0.04197808355093002, -0.017687657848000526, 0.015962090343236923, 0.05067777633666992, 0.04790913313627243, 0.016594527289271355, 0.06516753882169724, -0.0003595725283958018, -0.06742510199546814, 0.012659544125199318, 0.04116515442728996, -0.045668382197618484, -0.051125045865774155, -0.041003622114658356, -0.009613608941435814, 0.04626462981104851, -0.013404921628534794, -0.01812317781150341, -0.027532201260328293, -0.07819347828626633, -0.02914842590689659, -0.04215889796614647, 0.07646318525075912, 0.006815480999648571, -0.013367616571485996, -0.052077766507864, 0.04164810851216316, 0.008871120400726795, -0.06495530158281326, -0.0070251296274363995, 0.0496186763048172, -0.012365434318780899, 0.03232334926724434, 0.059065721929073334, 0.0032485355623066425, -0.004971639718860388, -0.0068406397476792336, 0.04031577333807945, -0.043670471757650375, 0.037237267941236496, -0.04580359533429146, -0.006390235852450132, -0.04451398178935051, 0.059192974120378494, 0.02028268575668335, -0.021807653829455376, -0.012131201103329659, -0.017210286110639572, -0.012614465318620205, -0.05399603396654129, 0.060242630541324615, -0.017630504444241524, 0.03138774260878563, -0.03979143127799034, 0.032056041061878204, 0.016115304082632065, 0.06842643022537231, 0.06263885647058487, 0.04988802596926689, 0.046906840056180954, -0.0022618244402110577, -0.06364287436008453, 0.04864586517214775, 0.011863542720675468, 0.057336341589689255, -0.03513069823384285, 0.03711280971765518, 0.023085743188858032, -0.017612455412745476, 0.012634696438908577, -0.07274996489286423, -0.020960308611392975, -0.012826732359826565, 0.07351680845022202, 0.043810322880744934, 0.03775474429130554, -0.019491730257868767, 0.01528251077979803, -0.019644720479846, -0.05842549353837967, -0.017852354794740677, 0.018369967117905617, 0.011280864477157593, 0.04591850936412811, -0.006371091585606337, 0.01926305517554283, -0.02797558531165123, -0.05805101618170738, -0.032984256744384766, 0.03943398594856262, -0.011722804047167301, -0.04296208173036575, 0.004286058712750673, -0.04538000375032425, -0.0326077863574028, -0.08384425193071365, -0.03404088690876961, -0.03030850924551487, 0.025823818519711494, 0.04493580013513565, -0.043747298419475555, 0.018737392500042915, -0.03464211896061897, -0.024962536990642548, -0.019825784489512444, -0.014081108383834362, -0.040592774748802185, 0.0120491161942482, 0.023012196645140648, 0.022607730701565742, -0.008600893430411816, 0.03729243576526642, -0.0014370190910995007 ]
<p>After reading a very informative tutorial on elementary particles physics over at <a href="http://www.particleadventure.org" rel="nofollow">http://www.particleadventure.org</a>, I have a question I can't figure out.</p> <p>I understand the need to accelerate a particle to high energy level, as it allows to view "smaller" stuff when you bombard a target with it. But the resulting particles that fly out into detectors have very short life as they quickly decay. Does it mean that those particles don't occur in nature because they decay very rapidly? And if so, what is the usefulness of studying those particles?</p>
g9764
[ 0.027859583497047424, 0.06187835708260536, 0.0012367579620331526, -0.0062120407819747925, 0.06815899908542633, 0.04484054818749428, -0.003466122318059206, 0.024255933240056038, -0.0456143356859684, -0.08298575133085251, -0.015938781201839447, 0.05986582860350609, 0.032465290278196335, -0.006878817919641733, -0.03131943941116333, -0.022547343745827675, 0.04975617676973343, -0.018302693963050842, 0.03386202082037926, 0.04029880091547966, 0.042915232479572296, 0.01655426435172558, -0.022505013272166252, -0.044516671448946, 0.0022293070796877146, 0.0015929542714729905, 0.00808718428015709, -0.012408114038407803, -0.026700226590037346, -0.03459210693836212, 0.012446041218936443, -0.0493093840777874, 0.016868481412529945, -0.016808519139885902, 0.048002906143665314, -0.11301545053720474, 0.07153674960136414, -0.0007252846262417734, -0.021296218037605286, -0.02063164860010147, -0.011970337480306625, -0.06668093055486679, 0.05795793607831001, -0.046627212315797806, 0.03716094046831131, 0.09133860468864441, -0.006103581748902798, -0.02804846130311489, 0.03144621476531029, -0.09338655322790146, -0.010057803243398666, -0.02560507319867611, 0.003857007250189781, 0.039495717734098434, 0.022697269916534424, 0.02047652192413807, -0.03501226380467415, -0.049504250288009644, 0.10644182562828064, -0.02371125854551792, 0.04024539515376091, 0.0310379471629858, -0.006019551306962967, -0.022199168801307678, 0.0414518304169178, -0.0037745998706668615, -0.03370342403650284, -0.007388767786324024, 0.03899284079670906, 0.007150677498430014, 0.011614250019192696, -0.03209742158651352, -0.09069158136844635, -0.05523012951016426, 0.04594070836901665, -0.012946258299052715, -0.030324427410960197, -0.0033267680555582047, -0.02622118592262268, 0.036987368017435074, -0.013214640319347382, 0.008621254935860634, -0.028307395055890083, -0.021973196417093277, 0.030248725786805153, 0.005128947086632252, -0.04298676922917366, -0.006710303481668234, 0.0010066404938697815, -0.029634825885295868, 0.02652006782591343, 0.03011052869260311, 0.046110209077596664, -0.007796396967023611, -0.056262701749801636, 0.03159927576780319, 0.001202422077767551, 0.06255444884300232, 0.0005357707850635052, 0.04246576502919197, -0.008132360875606537, -0.06598111242055893, 0.020273707807064056, 0.02195711061358452, 0.01710589788854122, -0.05059482529759407, -0.002891350770369172, 0.023647064343094826, 0.04577593132853508, -0.0030745912808924913, 0.005337613634765148, -0.04502412676811218, -0.054269030690193176, 0.00839461013674736, -0.0357024148106575, 0.04417641460895538, 0.049288466572761536, 0.04086584225296974, -0.024573346599936485, 0.038005635142326355, 0.012522798031568527, 0.05002401024103165, 0.02648431621491909, -0.0077032963745296, 0.0023499669041484594, -0.04845818877220154, 0.05972127988934517, 0.00917990505695343, -0.01624741591513157, 0.04104830324649811, 0.016624540090560913, -0.007747193332761526, -0.030308984220027924, 0.0417114682495594, 0.015188652090728283, 0.038110971450805664, -0.004550362937152386, 0.025403261184692383, 0.01976015977561474, -0.024047477170825005, 0.007774975150823593, -0.03231775388121605, 0.03811456263065338, -0.005087235011160374, -0.04641750082373619, 0.0658501461148262, -0.015277059748768806, -0.002362943021580577, -0.0003592847497202456, 0.05889444425702095, -0.0043625012040138245, 0.07458867877721786, 0.0331202857196331, -0.058404840528964996, 0.051855359226465225, 0.014507538639008999, 0.014004535041749477, 0.00006538409797940403, -0.021858179941773415, 0.04016184061765671, 0.04489847645163536, 0.009812208823859692, -0.06463132053613663, 0.0632195994257927, -0.08259714394807816, 0.05176340788602829, 0.02512822486460209, -0.07521600276231766, 0.0016392827965319157, -0.0320015586912632, -0.0178679171949625, 0.005006359424442053, 0.044980037957429886, 0.026397138833999634, -0.033554792404174805, 0.005850260611623526, 0.03543305769562721, -0.030682291835546494, -0.018153129145503044, -0.041818492114543915, -0.08197657763957977, -0.047056905925273895, 0.013198185712099075, -0.016600308939814568, 0.026727845892310143, 0.04446285218000412, 0.009258497506380081, 0.03590008243918419, -0.005908070132136345, 0.02870115078985691, -0.025981158018112183, -0.09046421945095062, -0.007652821950614452, 0.025274084880948067, -0.06741596758365631, -0.057988934218883514, 0.007740366738289595, -0.059811558574438095, -0.0011043796548619866, -0.04641266167163849, -0.02616092562675476, 0.01268064696341753, -0.00917432177811861, 0.06235743314027786, 0.07329162955284119, -0.019969740882515907, -0.038009874522686005, 0.0454271174967289, -0.035156287252902985, -0.05166773870587349, 0.05366729572415352, 0.01266477070748806, -0.006483361590653658, 0.024716880172491074, -0.018196674063801765, -0.03208792582154274, -0.05325353518128395, 0.0486111044883728, 0.04243197664618492, -0.0038510726299136877, -0.04764675348997116, -0.05151623860001564, 0.029912322759628296, -0.031682610511779785, -0.015977859497070312, 0.050188638269901276, -0.024032974615693092, -0.0075684804469347, -0.01982661709189415, 0.04027402028441429, -0.07109696418046951, 0.07613185048103333, -0.04238072410225868, -0.003831487149000168, 0.05565764382481575, 0.011156463995575905, 0.008931421674787998, -0.04008081927895546, 0.05772306025028229, 0.013096130453050137, -0.02879488654434681, -0.06521368771791458, -0.03212672099471092, -0.016422562301158905, 0.06652453541755676, -0.10115430504083633, 0.019593840464949608, -0.00196696980856359, -0.07252190262079239, -0.017242688685655594, 0.0009478881256654859, -0.029808232560753822, 0.027619780972599983, 0.07868027687072754, -0.008208044804632664, -0.014620983973145485, -0.021281417459249496, 0.025195594877004623, -0.020183200016617775, -0.04496780410408974, 0.026280943304300308, 0.04182066023349762, -0.01793156936764717, -0.02066675014793873, 0.06068963184952736, -0.04421814903616905, -0.009675045497715473, 0.02372557856142521, -0.00922575406730175, 0.00718067167326808, -0.03600789234042168, 0.07263045758008957, -0.00627405708655715, 0.002813632832840085, 0.007294177543371916, 0.004313687328249216, 0.024763787165284157, 0.029762931168079376, 0.02150190807878971, -0.010206463746726513, 0.010982273146510124, -0.0009014701936393976, -0.08560705184936523, -0.011651266366243362, 0.032762687653303146, -0.08527356386184692, 0.013021435588598251, -0.02143521048128605, -0.02100333385169506, -0.038237422704696655, 0.0017182542942464352, -0.014617843553423882, 0.04373889043927193, -0.012288134545087814, 0.0029481707606464624, -0.004928133450448513, 0.0402902290225029, -0.0338396392762661, -0.006706866901367903, 0.04585472121834755, -0.001988232834264636, -0.028943410143256187, -0.011912649497389793, -0.03773236647248268, 0.005003439262509346, 0.024112818762660027, -0.08286171406507492, -0.021591562777757645, -0.06321804970502853, 0.009260443039238453, -0.0030730105936527252, 0.032851994037628174, 0.004465121775865555, 0.05036188289523125, -0.015469147823750973, -0.021946052089333534, -0.04704098030924797, 0.042146116495132446, 0.00657656230032444, -0.03201274573802948, 0.02333851158618927, -0.019872773438692093, 0.01328181754797697, -0.010540186427533627, 0.027011025696992874, 0.0005354366730898619, 0.018544472754001617, -0.061228469014167786, 0.03716224804520607, -0.005123402923345566, 0.04918814077973366, -0.03243729844689369, -0.03348234295845032, 0.0120138730853796, -0.04870907962322235, -0.053306467831134796, -0.028926901519298553, 0.029859038069844246, 0.012691153213381767, -0.019366158172488213, 0.029346592724323273, 0.03772685304284096, -0.04611934721469879, -0.002602020977064967, 0.04631980136036873, 0.0004460276395548135, 0.023500237613916397, 0.008582262322306633, -0.039435163140296936, -0.0673537477850914, 0.040253058075904846, 0.0216031763702631, 0.014053631573915482, -0.037799663841724396, -0.06443533301353455, -0.020563168451189995, 0.008265490643680096, -0.02332332357764244, 0.053050681948661804, -0.00601028511300683, -0.00785030797123909, 0.022649453952908516, 0.025791602209210396, 0.04636109992861748, -0.048401884734630585, 0.01329504232853651, -0.08598625659942627, 0.031700678169727325, 0.04035543277859688, -0.03933320939540863, -0.013492288999259472, 0.034222789108753204, -0.01797039993107319, 0.04274045675992966, -0.01880764588713646, 0.018353041261434555, 0.05788939446210861, 0.009586850181221962, -0.033450547605752945, -0.019471561536192894, 0.009174617938697338, 0.021138304844498634, 0.03743818402290344, -0.03711019456386566, 0.03546593710780144, 0.011486266739666462, -0.04749683663249016, -0.05451585724949837, -0.006084187887609005, -0.004715251736342907, -0.004917338024824858, -0.039620522409677505, -0.03105846792459488, 0.02899225428700447, 0.00717312004417181, -0.07508359849452972, 0.03242724388837814, -0.009245696477591991, 0.054107844829559326, 0.050750982016325, -0.010571643710136414, 0.05289140343666077, -0.035263657569885254, -0.005205182824283838, 0.011310945264995098, 0.04765649884939194, 0.007509609684348106, -0.01671212539076805, -0.02933311276137829, 0.010363337583839893, 0.020963119342923164, 0.0037949492689222097, 0.021666888147592545, -0.03682827204465866, -0.0341753326356411, -0.02506282553076744, 0.01817486807703972, -0.014778808690607548, 0.004474558401852846, 0.03914660960435867, 0.012530636042356491, 0.018167806789278984, -0.0020577602554112673, 0.015180534683167934, -0.06397959589958191, 0.05718456208705902, 0.0034965837839990854, 0.06348098069429398, -0.06674377620220184, 0.009246264584362507, 0.07269294559955597, 0.025995507836341858, 0.006807766389101744, -0.029777279123663902, 0.009708283469080925, 0.001451596268452704, 0.03153005242347717, 0.026393096894025803, -0.005225128494203091, 0.06571786105632782, 0.0697406455874443, 0.02167792245745659, 0.05235915631055832, 0.008575543761253357, 0.017233621329069138, 0.06647297739982605, -0.07803235948085785, 0.02514365129172802, 0.015069091692566872, -0.03505405783653259, -0.000873491691891104, 0.05744253471493721, -0.026579737663269043, -0.052276477217674255, -0.0025834604166448116, -0.00941094383597374, -0.027829665690660477, -0.007629237603396177, 0.03633248805999756, 0.076649010181427, -0.08255257457494736, 0.045546647161245346, 0.03886624425649643, -0.014930866658687592, -0.020681297406554222, 0.0029945613350719213, -0.011707029305398464, -0.01897711493074894, -0.051886577159166336, -0.019824670627713203, -0.05224849656224251, -0.029496103525161743, 0.020235681906342506, -0.04982718452811241, -0.029490025714039803, -0.05651497095823288, -0.002831930760294199, -0.02929033525288105, 0.004370054695755243, -0.028286190703511238, -0.011552980169653893, 0.011680200695991516, -0.04233001917600632, -0.011409923434257507, -0.005878726486116648, 0.022059231996536255, -0.0872274786233902, 0.006508892867714167, 0.02902671881020069, -0.04669024050235748, 0.0404963493347168, 0.031089676544070244, 0.013392862863838673, 0.008785014972090721, 0.01148515660315752, -0.06448660045862198, 0.07529279589653015, -0.006644348613917828, -0.023738471791148186, 0.0018872016808018088, 0.009238751605153084, -0.09404580295085907, -0.04454934224486351, 0.04574369639158249, 0.006808256730437279, 0.050098318606615067, 0.06985285133123398, -0.06261106580495834, 0.035738129168748856, -0.024634992703795433, -0.030535470694303513, 0.020575055852532387, 0.03092215768992901, 0.010251096449792385, -0.01998920366168022, 0.030300205573439598, -0.015977079048752785, 0.04133513569831848, -0.052491914480924606, 0.030286215245723724, 0.01722455583512783, 0.020823517814278603, 0.03373432159423828, 0.023977752774953842, 0.08402805030345917, 0.0007246861350722611, -0.04255182668566704, -0.000897026329766959, 0.021850498393177986, 0.04495695233345032, 0.05244849622249603, -0.02269025146961212, -0.005243225023150444, 0.031011387705802917, -0.025194507092237473, 0.02047855593264103, 0.004435664042830467, -0.014652395620942116, -0.03407915681600571, -0.04325051233172417, -0.021158158779144287, 0.011258249171078205, 0.017836520448327065, 0.04219594597816467, -0.005178964231163263, 0.002698569791391492, -0.03477191925048828, 0.03919342905282974, 0.0751204788684845, -0.015199362300336361, -0.05422453582286835, -0.019945982843637466, 0.08104751259088516, -0.041036270558834076, 0.04918443784117699, 0.03760656341910362, 0.03098137117922306, 0.027542101219296455, -0.03146888688206673, -0.045154452323913574, 0.0194185022264719, 0.046166688203811646, 0.04399920254945755, 0.018534669652581215, 0.04978581517934799, -0.04086662828922272, -0.007647174410521984, -0.023767950013279915, 0.02997867949306965, -0.008204241283237934, 0.00028978384216316044, 0.02353082038462162, 0.030802132561802864, 0.004870053380727768, 0.02572876214981079, 0.034787796437740326, 0.005763813387602568, -0.011243700981140137, -0.06696735322475433, 0.010096406564116478, 0.031097441911697388, -0.002692315960302949, 0.02595323510468006, -0.011056382209062576, 0.05981554463505745, 0.014251991175115108, -0.03556496277451515, 0.009547566063702106, 0.03791860118508339, -0.010092055425047874, 0.005522461608052254, -0.040502093732357025, -0.014863370917737484, -0.014588487334549427, -0.07237506657838821, 0.014224488288164139, -0.005696883425116539, -0.02467699721455574, -0.0406414270401001, -0.007573430892080069, 0.009326573461294174, 0.014663408510386944, -0.027753815054893494, -0.012379455380141735, 0.02486278861761093, 0.03133479878306389, -0.01329867448657751, -0.0008607362979091704, -0.00022090251150075346, 0.0274762324988842, -0.032428666949272156, -0.015264718793332577, 0.006975848693400621, -0.01082611083984375, -0.02078370563685894, -0.03503499925136566, 0.01615033857524395, -0.030700821429491043, 0.0015947467181831598, 0.002955137984827161, 0.040416888892650604, -0.007327274419367313, 0.039404477924108505, -0.02676810882985592, 0.006069096736609936, 0.037402600049972534, 0.026551885530352592, 0.04443308338522911, 0.042833924293518066, 0.014817736111581326, -0.04524931684136391, -0.016656458377838135, 0.019804617390036583, 0.05220988765358925, -0.03342806547880173, 0.04127374291419983, 0.03635462000966072, 0.05439464747905731, -0.04655569791793823, -0.011290828697383404, -0.011035129427909851, -0.01694440469145775, 0.012288015335798264, -0.023826586082577705, -0.04624782130122185, -0.017415231093764305, 0.006889102049171925, 0.03349991887807846, -0.009550330229103565, -0.023885168135166168, -0.019998349249362946, -0.0414673313498497, 0.007373827043920755, -0.0319550558924675, 0.028961237519979477, -0.0013831169344484806, 0.01963954232633114, -0.0056053451262414455, 0.030118824914097786, -0.036983612924814224, -0.04795384779572487, -0.0343259796500206, -0.0021956053096801043, -0.02294573187828064, -0.004616277292370796, -0.00014766374079044908, 0.013938264921307564, -0.039887357503175735, 0.002314132871106267, -0.013286374509334564, -0.004218251444399357, -0.061505723744630814, -0.04227598011493683, -0.06102573126554489, 0.028075644746422768, 0.03189178183674812, -0.08527516573667526, 0.009075132198631763, -0.006797359324991703, -0.002053028903901577, 0.004977105185389519, 0.03279297053813934, 0.02835370972752571, 0.05008600652217865, 0.0010256788227707148, 0.07366348803043365, -0.10639151185750961, 0.0036334253381937742, 0.0249421875923872, -0.00023221061564981937, -0.051101021468639374, 0.034872882068157196, 0.09317965060472488, -0.06200752779841423, -0.028514260426163673, -0.022236937656998634, 0.0331505686044693, -0.0210751760751009, -0.020820382982492447, 0.0043113576248288155, 0.0157695934176445, 0.01246299035847187, 0.05176721140742302, -0.014208463951945305, -0.01326728705316782, 0.0032125082798302174, 0.008556249551475048, -0.04411866515874863, -0.0021927186753600836, 0.024508746340870857, -0.01763179525732994, -0.00270196795463562, 0.043130602687597275, 0.019729847088456154, 0.007096529006958008, -0.02292080782353878, 0.00469994405284524, -0.016300886869430542, 0.013088025152683258, -0.013956518843770027, 0.01986663229763508, -0.007958006113767624, -0.016922147944569588, -0.004293077625334263, 0.019788680598139763, -0.039751894772052765, -0.011799906380474567, 0.06327956914901733, 0.032469626516103745, 0.0001727599446894601, -0.01913982816040516, 0.004307383671402931, 0.0006893380195833743, 0.004483675118535757, -0.03707301616668701, -0.0221986286342144, 0.04145966097712517, 0.006640617270022631, -0.06694699823856354, 0.03607083484530449, 0.02209191955626011, 0.009084793739020824, 0.0035992437042295933, 0.014757927507162094, -0.050408586859703064, -0.06352746486663818, -0.006178514566272497, 0.02396969310939312, 0.012462224811315536, -0.021113069728016853, 0.0224499199539423, 0.004254239145666361, -0.01814388483762741, 0.07799894362688065, -0.00812334194779396, -0.029910240322351456, 0.055158331990242004, 0.0345219261944294, -0.005172817502170801, -0.07606866955757141, -0.01789052039384842, -0.001410313998349011, 0.016883304342627525, -0.026289671659469604, -0.010973166674375534, -0.06514176726341248, 0.01223086379468441, -0.02250286191701889 ]
<p>There are people proposing the possibility of using entropic force to explain the gravity force between objects. The emphasis is that entropy is more fundamental than energy. It is the closest study as entropy is closely related to information. What is Mathematical formulation of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity" rel="nofollow">entropic Gravitational force</a>?</p> <blockquote> <p>... It implies that gravity is not a fundamental interaction, but an emergent phenomenon which arises from the statistical behavior of microscopic degrees of freedom encoded on a holographic screen...</p> </blockquote>
g751
[ 0.03581353276968002, 0.06398759037256241, 0.011442472226917744, -0.018213996663689613, 0.025017395615577698, -0.00614795321598649, 0.017688972875475883, 0.02397727034986019, -0.08382479101419449, -0.02549343928694725, 0.0836174488067627, -0.0362081378698349, 0.009588899090886116, -0.028364429250359535, -0.013770326972007751, 0.06816738098859787, 0.07556323707103729, -0.004358488135039806, 0.05546898767352104, 0.04387930408120155, 0.01410623174160719, -0.004890885669738054, 0.00031917545129545033, -0.05393931642174721, -0.08173385262489319, -0.02163592539727688, 0.06451872736215591, -0.04731738567352295, -0.034070126712322235, 0.007671764120459557, -0.019666265696287155, 0.018888546153903008, 0.0338139533996582, -0.08027675747871399, -0.07275578379631042, 0.012535955756902695, -0.0002063585416181013, 0.051112979650497437, 0.030384711921215057, -0.005514547694474459, -0.029220324009656906, 0.0467761792242527, -0.07003270834684372, -0.022813566029071808, -0.0003518920566421002, 0.0068809110671281815, 0.029027434065937996, -0.0016422242624685168, -0.00012595726002473384, -0.030752388760447502, 0.0004679079574998468, 0.10495691001415253, 0.0256656464189291, 0.07066076248884201, 0.0428425595164299, 0.07574648410081863, 0.07580462843179703, 0.0007682626601308584, 0.052808474749326706, -0.03285406902432442, 0.017657261341810226, 0.05716174095869064, 0.016568098217248917, -0.0031768479384481907, 0.059315603226423264, -0.016973642632365227, -0.019291281700134277, -0.023393621668219566, 0.01601964794099331, -0.009580997750163078, -0.013240226544439793, -0.018793843686580658, -0.006940923631191254, 0.006121649872511625, 0.011085902340710163, 0.030568275600671768, -0.0013476427411660552, 0.01099442970007658, -0.0016559173818677664, -0.004965667612850666, -0.005947920493781567, -0.052403032779693604, 0.04588967561721802, 0.01207815483212471, 0.08881422132253647, -0.058194708079099655, -0.03845183923840523, -0.04338688403367996, 0.031690455973148346, 0.024011651054024696, -0.0036358488723635674, -0.006019574590027332, 0.05783327296376228, 0.04278859123587608, -0.0337800458073616, -0.002038729377090931, -0.0024859094992280006, 0.019971167668700218, 0.011972981505095959, 0.006406106054782867, -0.031033756211400032, -0.029074091464281082, 0.05803786218166351, -0.019925307482481003, 0.027048448100686073, -0.030565939843654633, -0.0274016335606575, -0.0017192866653203964, -0.0656559020280838, 0.009643669240176678, -0.006934563163667917, 0.04291956126689911, -0.011900000274181366, -0.02266811765730381, -0.0001443504443159327, -0.053853850811719894, 0.09725385904312134, -0.029464544728398323, -0.0506155826151371, -0.009499939158558846, -0.07702776789665222, 0.05532665178179741, 0.024372702464461327, 0.08501318097114563, -0.007512797601521015, 0.025348512455821037, 0.04482188820838928, -0.08574826270341873, -0.010171393863856792, -0.07407626509666443, 0.03400165215134621, -0.008707638829946518, -0.03340646252036095, -0.010212612338364124, -0.01600399613380432, 0.044060371816158295, -0.024949748069047928, -0.034951094537973404, -0.019843684509396553, 0.01678197644650936, -0.02227473258972168, -0.041544146835803986, -0.004419358912855387, -0.0668453723192215, -0.0023468066938221455, 0.010739009827375412, -0.01811983995139599, 0.019829900935292244, 0.04212743788957596, -0.04584197700023651, -0.03154223412275314, 0.05554993078112602, 0.008235972374677658, -0.07487078756093979, -0.00035228702472522855, 0.006557044573128223, 0.05945269390940666, 0.0031908713281154633, -0.01819535531103611, 0.01581590622663498, 0.06029706075787544, 0.023931171745061874, 0.07021383196115494, -0.03260200098156929, -0.03299274668097496, 0.01750768907368183, 0.03260527923703194, -0.03724212199449539, 0.03979366645216942, -0.11350148916244507, -0.12041345983743668, 0.018735267221927643, -0.03501853719353676, 0.04480046406388283, 0.01882764883339405, -0.011604875326156616, -0.005599844269454479, -0.008831452578306198, 0.030444717034697533, 0.01519493293017149, 0.01908743940293789, -0.009864435531198978, 0.05043981596827507, -0.007273448631167412, -0.012584546580910683, -0.0021812382619827986, 0.05906254053115845, 0.03917544707655907, -0.03314756229519844, 0.02613203600049019, -0.05736987292766571, -0.0346786193549633, -0.03603430837392807, 0.029289374127984047, 0.026112886145710945, 0.05761392414569855, 0.04302218556404114, -0.035767748951911926, -0.03669922053813934, -0.0005584247992374003, -0.035555776208639145, 0.0027519443538039923, 0.013165039010345936, 0.011932730674743652, -0.020296573638916016, 0.07072898000478745, -0.017437303438782692, 0.05589497089385986, -0.009934797883033752, -0.016606247052550316, 0.013811329379677773, -0.06556650996208191, 0.002413903595879674, 0.04104822129011154, -0.019524002447724342, -0.019895970821380615, -0.002557998290285468, -0.02022438682615757, -0.0621902160346508, 0.04822198301553726, 0.03269527852535248, 0.03386487439274788, -0.0020706455688923597, 0.05283181369304657, -0.01788860559463501, -0.010097179561853409, -0.0483410470187664, -0.03217330574989319, -0.05109936371445656, -0.0005594628164544702, -0.042296916246414185, 0.020408516749739647, 0.019764050841331482, 0.05673416331410408, 0.000016963382222456858, 0.03615842014551163, 0.01188758946955204, 0.03755435720086098, -0.026819325983524323, -0.004135232884436846, 0.06802024692296982, -0.05255325511097908, -0.024045230820775032, 0.02807575836777687, 0.049675486981868744, 0.010113351978361607, -0.022403376176953316, -0.038913749158382416, 0.044123925268650055, 0.02538825199007988, 0.025500915944576263, -0.051833271980285645, -0.036872994154691696, -0.025034787133336067, 0.026449155062437057, -0.01892511174082756, -0.01660795882344246, 0.017825035378336906, -0.047064200043678284, -0.02657775767147541, -0.031097011640667915, -0.003447568276897073, 0.01765955239534378, 0.020743951201438904, 0.001739935833029449, -0.02172696590423584, -0.022991830483078957, 0.0031712502241134644, -0.027107441797852516, 0.002390264766290784, -0.029390892013907433, 0.03330349549651146, -0.03607499971985817, -0.01576773263514042, -0.030862048268318176, 0.01981993205845356, -0.010070576332509518, -0.02466464415192604, -0.026652146130800247, -0.04159965738654137, -0.008762978948652744, 0.006976498290896416, -0.07177858799695969, 0.03934115916490555, 0.01995965652167797, -0.040367256850004196, -0.02828514575958252, -0.0037120997440069914, 0.02240564115345478, -0.08115962147712708, 0.026129739359021187, 0.017652660608291626, -0.013873160816729069, 0.0190350953489542, -0.05763722211122513, 0.02980898879468441, 0.005885113961994648, 0.020279597491025925, -0.049265578389167786, 0.046640798449516296, -0.025355570018291473, -0.0003732959448825568, 0.05184900760650635, 0.0672774389386177, -0.04447023943066597, -0.006225819233804941, -0.05119343101978302, -0.05387260019779205, -0.010224000550806522, 0.014107363298535347, -0.024820251390337944, 0.020213773474097252, -0.01026378944516182, 0.047656212002038956, -0.06552273035049438, -0.018213767558336258, 0.028437398374080658, 0.010628857649862766, -0.002009202493354678, -0.07115769386291504, 0.024945713579654694, -0.004873558878898621, 0.006463623605668545, 0.010142377577722073, 0.032235171645879745, 0.022441355511546135, -0.06536807119846344, 0.0428491085767746, -0.039788395166397095, -0.014459029771387577, 0.03676758334040642, -0.04257664829492569, 0.013040469028055668, -0.015015353448688984, -0.050943393260240555, -0.033323369920253754, 0.010712632909417152, -0.006613763049244881, 0.03231506794691086, 0.035565201193094254, 0.029947537928819656, 0.007002148311585188, -0.04592166468501091, 0.004002810455858707, 0.008009943179786205, 0.07340610772371292, -0.00585465831682086, 0.011364626698195934, 0.038188640028238297, 0.0003372742503415793, -0.023753326386213303, -0.0016036010347306728, 0.042912039905786514, -0.030455902218818665, 0.031256306916475296, -0.015649937093257904, 0.017632337287068367, -0.07436668127775192, 0.010423965752124786, -0.00420838687568903, 0.03753916919231415, 0.003247414017096162, 0.017601575702428818, -0.02464287541806698, -0.026335233822464943, -0.016145428642630577, -0.03432350978255272, 0.04897410795092583, -0.026291389018297195, -0.020527713000774384, 0.0489448681473732, -0.08459498733282089, -0.005939127877354622, -0.0030166844371706247, 0.09641750901937485, -0.05010960251092911, 0.05851897969841957, -0.04604097455739975, 0.0489984005689621, -0.020036965608596802, 0.061297882348299026, 0.04348171129822731, 0.008690961636602879, -0.01900857873260975, 0.09913024306297302, -0.013554906472563744, -0.03869938105344772, 0.0039415135979652405, 0.05425719916820526, -0.02263217233121395, -0.032515544444322586, -0.007445306517183781, 0.005391439888626337, 0.02048504911363125, 0.03878659009933472, 0.02592952735722065, 0.027192911133170128, 0.012866806238889694, 0.04382818937301636, 0.004084055311977863, 0.030563540756702423, -0.017019515857100487, -0.016480112448334694, 0.04033898189663887, 0.007401205599308014, 0.005387454759329557, 0.04033700004220009, 0.004681861028075218, -0.018987348303198814, -0.016992390155792236, 0.038397300988435745, 0.0022634605411440134, 0.012224370613694191, -0.06318507343530655, 0.020505068823695183, 0.014307962730526924, -0.0011953371576964855, 0.0050859213806688786, 0.028966888785362244, 0.04469385743141174, 0.010929550975561142, 0.08243819326162338, -0.015783807262778282, 0.0004881391650997102, -0.031217090785503387, 0.02557329274713993, 0.047774966806173325, 0.03276389092206955, -0.04088505357503891, -0.04151393845677376, -0.004171294625848532, 0.01122747641056776, 0.00007422987255267799, 0.01750136725604534, -0.022456549108028412, 0.016548557206988335, -0.03810902312397957, 0.006251858547329903, 0.04162515699863434, 0.01698092557489872, 0.05400897562503815, 0.013862503692507744, -0.012589987367391586, 0.01522884052246809, 0.013674293644726276, 0.08172542601823807, 0.025518596172332764, -0.004046407528221607, -0.04584188014268875, 0.004347304813563824, 0.012605608440935612, -0.05238477140665054, -0.01817469112575054, -0.008553773164749146, 0.009596357122063637, 0.060524530708789825, -0.035311922430992126, 0.04696096107363701, -0.019272826611995697, -0.030578162521123886, -0.043585117906332016, 0.027432594448328018, -0.004493323154747486, 0.025737449526786804, -0.020325271412730217, -0.032239947468042374, -0.08279494196176529, 0.004479726776480675, -0.002251490717753768, 0.000023916614736663178, -0.009339653886854649, -0.018913336098194122, 0.0360938124358654, 0.03511703014373779, -0.008064765483140945, -0.004436657764017582, 0.021930377930402756, -0.0057723429054021835, 0.04481351003050804, -0.04131297022104263, -0.05222344398498535, 0.014318211935460567, 0.040511272847652435, -0.0017290442483499646, 0.046675633639097214, -0.028762344270944595, -0.026575926691293716, 0.03482330963015556, -0.03884563595056534, 0.023086154833436012, 0.018014706671237946, 0.019082987681031227, -0.0006517387228086591, -0.01627831719815731, -0.059963490813970566, -0.03866320103406906, 0.017496442422270775, 0.005394447594881058, 0.008606042712926865, -0.0355028361082077, -0.01076799351722002, 0.015097202733159065, -0.03764043375849724, 0.004535464569926262, 0.002549951896071434, -0.008516794070601463, 0.029508188366889954, -0.010818702168762684, -0.026002001017332077, 0.11147653311491013, -0.05559273436665535, -0.03006679005920887, -0.028256481513381004, 0.056755244731903076, 0.002462835982441902, -0.001066292985342443, 0.03495842590928078, -0.004621129482984543, -0.04041960835456848, -0.0007434802246280015, 0.07057031244039536, -0.030319811776280403, -0.012009778991341591, 0.004207231570035219, 0.027642477303743362, 0.04290204495191574, -0.005485156551003456, 0.026506952941417694, -0.019880102947354317, 0.05235232412815094, 0.009847559966146946, 0.038454435765743256, 0.021442128345370293, -0.03058040887117386, -0.005216063465923071, -0.04373117536306381, 0.03440133482217789, 0.04948287457227707, 0.03834087774157524, -0.021653104573488235, -0.009857521392405033, 0.029689129441976547, -0.059764761477708817, 0.05614742636680603, 0.011913723312318325, 0.01957772485911846, -0.038797955960035324, -0.04094552993774414, 0.018712779507040977, -0.01940952241420746, 0.0038923914544284344, 0.003409553784877062, 0.02214834839105606, 0.015269191935658455, -0.0010548611171543598, -0.008574030362069607, 0.003982404246926308, -0.04048706218600273, 0.01338705699890852, -0.008847192861139774, 0.021983249112963676, 0.04632153734564781, 0.019828883931040764, -0.027786796912550926, 0.018206100910902023, -0.035138532519340515, 0.004241245798766613, -0.04525694623589516, -0.007024130318313837, 0.051334697753190994, -0.012126978486776352, 0.0044527300633490086, -0.01699637435376644, 0.014105737209320068, 0.02808026224374771, -0.038373012095689774, -0.0020697235595434904, -0.0535527728497982, -0.03834550082683563, -0.023014353588223457, -0.0034327262546867132, -0.02484866976737976, 0.052237749099731445, -0.055508311837911606, -0.04024865850806236, 0.005207150708884001, -0.06417858600616455, -0.005205738823860884, -0.012304779142141342, -0.03307074308395386, 0.008642518892884254, -0.03962134197354317, -0.044117044657468796, 0.01687636226415634, -0.03175676241517067, 0.0015711092855781317, 0.017912190407514572, 0.03266986086964607, -0.005523736588656902, 0.011013271287083626, -0.02820519171655178, 0.028852200135588646, 0.06710406392812729, 0.0003200837236363441, 0.021039573475718498, 0.02886481024324894, -0.05799706280231476, -0.019615432247519493, 0.0006409045890904963, -0.03029738925397396, -0.051855627447366714, 0.02525355853140354, -0.005897496361285448, -0.011835823766887188, -0.004392760805785656, -0.03646474704146385, -0.07671140879392624, -0.011130424216389656, -0.027239859104156494, 0.04409952089190483, -0.02327354997396469, -0.0035752367693930864, 0.03063574619591236, -0.10094496607780457, 0.005409505683928728, 0.06782913208007812, -0.04166796803474426, 0.01972987689077854, 0.023005347698926926, 0.036114402115345, -0.03275599703192711, -0.01004345715045929, 0.03602741286158562, 0.037595320492982864, -0.043063387274742126, 0.01340288482606411, -0.07761235535144806, 0.008436723612248898, 0.0854186862707138, 0.025882326066493988, 0.017179163172841072, -0.004005845636129379, 0.07190285623073578, 0.01011026930063963, -0.052997879683971405, 0.01906026527285576, -0.010155455209314823, 0.02703106589615345, -0.05698680877685547, -0.01078025996685028, -0.00671287951990962, -0.04985957592725754, -0.0012342978734523058, 0.018710507079958916, -0.07533233612775803, 0.09112028777599335, -0.02638491429388523, -0.041619665920734406, -0.0015563603956252337, -0.06746161729097366, -0.033846523612737656, -0.012334799394011497, 0.027166327461600304, 0.014253594912588596, -0.05101146921515465, 0.03447206690907478, -0.01706463098526001, -0.002274436177685857, -0.009295903146266937, -0.018634743988513947, 0.014635349623858929, -0.07912930101156235, 0.002867993898689747, -0.0007070581777952611, -0.05718106031417847, -0.021344734355807304, 0.003383380128070712, -0.021969188004732132, 0.006379768252372742, 0.0061571323312819, -0.010211443528532982, 0.04631988704204559, 0.019753288477659225, 0.059118691831827164, -0.031039033085107803, 0.05555306002497673, 0.020799877122044563, 0.043092839419841766, -0.034992020577192307, -0.015410319902002811, -0.018370559439063072, 0.03349035605788231, -0.05768297240138054, -0.014746436849236488, -0.0694279596209526, 0.006571086123585701, 0.02708018198609352, 0.06346692889928818, -0.01749558374285698, 0.010620028711855412, -0.011969543062150478, -0.07550738751888275, -0.025516850873827934, -0.010050063952803612, 0.03467448055744171, 0.0280003622174263, 0.011538405902683735, 0.02108299732208252, -0.04074868932366371, 0.02772236242890358, 0.03944502770900726, -0.012948082759976387, 0.007331635802984238, -0.010788536630570889, -0.000031234423659043387, 0.01766543835401535, 0.0024611721746623516, 0.0014585123863071203, -0.010580475442111492, 0.03499742969870567, 0.010559775866568089, -0.046658728271722794, -0.04418697580695152, -0.0770028680562973, -0.06115582957863808, 0.014544012024998665, -0.010507049039006233, -0.008468915708363056, 0.014262538403272629, -0.004058788530528545, -0.027836041525006294, -0.018677877262234688, -0.011609457433223724, 0.0039945910684764385, -0.0462278313934803, 0.08653707057237625, -0.004125919658690691, -0.016942249611020088, -0.006978715769946575, 0.0027429508045315742, 0.06545708328485489, 0.03563767671585083, 0.011110221967101097, -0.04768748953938484, 0.03986094146966934, -0.06408938765525818, -0.06681427359580994, -0.0006492426036857069, 0.02964281477034092, 0.010022218339145184, 0.010059605352580547, -0.018296251073479652, 0.022207606583833694, -0.019616125151515007, 0.06122460961341858, -0.0501684807240963, 0.004214382730424404, 0.019702816382050514, 0.03286365792155266, -0.04392680525779724, 0.0291525200009346, -0.013535445556044579, -0.017937112599611282, 0.017328383401036263, -0.027277538552880287, 0.007524565793573856, -0.000842979468870908, 0.0579056516289711 ]
<p>Essentially, there is a beam of length L and negligible mass sticking out of a wall with a mass Mg hanging at the end of it. We are given an equation for elastic energy (which I don't think needs to be modified), and we have to come up with the potential energy contribution from the mass, and then hopefully be able to minimize the energy using variational techniques. </p> <p>The elastic energy per unit length can be approximated to be $U[y]=\int_0^L \frac{1}{2} EI (y'')^2 dz$ If I can properly define the potential energy of the mass, I think I can do the rest, but I can't figure out the right term. Thanks for reading, and please comment if there is more I should add, including my work involved getting the (incorrect) gravity terms.</p>
g9765
[ 0.05189935117959976, 0.03695852681994438, -0.010009059682488441, 0.02874830923974514, -0.029573602601885796, -0.001011797459796071, 0.0003039476869162172, 0.0529983825981617, -0.06762483716011047, 0.01982729882001877, -0.014139342121779919, -0.013474833220243454, -0.04410652816295624, 0.02671285904943943, 0.025639023631811142, 0.010229476727545261, 0.13071846961975098, -0.03363611549139023, 0.013396481983363628, -0.003906619735062122, -0.01052742451429367, -0.015841221436858177, 0.030891701579093933, -0.030982596799731255, 0.03122650273144245, 0.009015709161758423, 0.04988677427172661, 0.03751293569803238, -0.1056903824210167, 0.011951537802815437, -0.018861040472984314, -0.01882893592119217, 0.030022040009498596, -0.03079407289624214, -0.020090997219085693, 0.017323575913906097, 0.05528842657804489, 0.03162506967782974, 0.03249860927462578, -0.0175246000289917, -0.0000779921974753961, -0.05238566920161247, -0.023048020899295807, 0.020745327696204185, -0.01898127608001232, -0.016707872971892357, 0.016026871278882027, -0.0017183790914714336, 0.012401835061609745, -0.04981599003076553, 0.026968294754624367, 0.085833840072155, 0.04416421055793762, -0.0780760869383812, 0.012204257771372795, 0.0356755368411541, -0.06991850584745407, -0.0029380316846072674, 0.04118723049759865, 0.08091539144515991, 0.07415012270212173, -0.04146314784884453, -0.027355555444955826, -0.034334998577833176, 0.021459020674228668, -0.02406224235892296, -0.04511100798845291, -0.025026360526680946, 0.024136919528245926, -0.02801714837551117, 0.039941124618053436, 0.026615500450134277, -0.006311324425041676, -0.03139650821685791, -0.03232978284358978, -0.044887930154800415, -0.024452054873108864, 0.025496872141957283, -0.007213371340185404, -0.05402394384145737, -0.023593183606863022, 0.0024259553756564856, -0.02623426355421543, -0.013628141954541206, -0.0033838299568742514, 0.02085147611796856, 0.005533050280064344, 0.033250484615564346, -0.04098396748304367, 0.016593577340245247, 0.008622136898338795, -0.000458757538581267, 0.07041019201278687, -0.01263502798974514, 0.006118853576481342, 0.012387123890221119, -0.025350060313940048, 0.011835153214633465, 0.020644022151827812, 0.01808689534664154, 0.008009185083210468, -0.023490117862820625, 0.002754617715254426, 0.02402150258421898, -0.013301914557814598, 0.006242499686777592, 0.013748890720307827, -0.04635428264737129, 0.0238469410687685, 0.006071581970900297, -0.04018982872366905, -0.02571691758930683, 0.012726567685604095, -0.05638305842876434, -0.04556645452976227, -0.04226787015795708, 0.08490408957004547, -0.026403136551380157, -0.0302494578063488, 0.04083084687590599, -0.043808989226818085, 0.03834150359034538, 0.011510192416608334, 0.049057722091674805, -0.03748432174324989, -0.022638842463493347, -0.06710287928581238, 0.007212919183075428, 0.013584698550403118, -0.05558234080672264, -0.0055641476064920425, -0.037024617195129395, 0.05115757882595062, -0.025104230269789696, 0.0019057157915085554, 0.02262151427567005, -0.024212878197431564, 0.02466055564582348, -0.00762965390458703, 0.041402097791433334, -0.037350330501794815, -0.0515727773308754, -0.000539455737452954, -0.032339438796043396, -0.04065913334488869, 0.061408478766679764, -0.043672095984220505, 0.004757395479828119, 0.054676156491041183, 0.01997070387005806, -0.01796141266822815, 0.1025288924574852, -0.016146551817655563, -0.06827839463949203, 0.1080375611782074, 0.004832431674003601, 0.020653782412409782, -0.06371539831161499, -0.017824096605181694, -0.04125474765896797, 0.005922126583755016, -0.01695241592824459, 0.05272899568080902, -0.028788411989808083, -0.020535893738269806, 0.03665747866034508, 0.010285632684826851, 0.011396458372473717, 0.006629659328609705, -0.039813652634620667, -0.017277903854846954, -0.06065506488084793, 0.03692251443862915, 0.0646972730755806, -0.04970584437251091, 0.08154655992984772, 0.05774177238345146, -0.04009237512946129, -0.010376994498074055, 0.062468864023685455, 0.005482785403728485, -0.030792970210313797, 0.05055621266365051, -0.025582635775208473, -0.03583037853240967, -0.015154293738305569, 0.058959126472473145, 0.029424145817756653, -0.0003030867374036461, -0.0076028769835829735, -0.019779685884714127, 0.04284881055355072, -0.02460487000644207, 0.023434685543179512, -0.04046905040740967, 0.0651453360915184, 0.06818030029535294, -0.042121417820453644, -0.023921236395835876, -0.003825311316177249, -0.02012496441602707, 0.012187210842967033, 0.03687461465597153, 0.0007660562405362725, 0.08296655863523483, -0.029272029176354408, 0.00900872889906168, 0.006205334328114986, 0.003391231643036008, 0.008971295319497585, -0.00948314554989338, -0.06573713570833206, -0.017993416637182236, 0.05903333052992821, 0.007366155739873648, -0.025070592761039734, -0.011892142705619335, 0.06234629452228546, -0.021155469119548798, 0.01453376468271017, -0.06903231143951416, 0.04165032133460045, 0.022074472159147263, 0.05144980922341347, 0.013194380328059196, -0.017421066761016846, -0.020350145176053047, -0.008392535150051117, -0.006846444681286812, -0.02568621002137661, -0.05714065581560135, 0.09646910429000854, 0.03245500102639198, -0.03411280736327171, 0.026501351967453957, -0.03466019779443741, -0.008600196801126003, 0.01054506003856659, 0.0018774637719616294, -0.007100316695868969, -0.003927596844732761, -0.05009208247065544, -0.006205972284078598, -0.05603628233075142, 0.024127619341015816, 0.02774908021092415, 0.07175416499376297, 0.048696208745241165, 0.02624640427529812, 0.0320308655500412, 0.002642372390255332, 0.002886833157390356, -0.07177688926458359, -0.0037417160347104073, 0.002268567681312561, -0.030307712033391, -0.053581975400447845, 0.03003530576825142, 0.035395264625549316, -0.02112364023923874, 0.005657501984387636, -0.10067760944366455, 0.04058999568223953, 0.06782021373510361, -0.04607316479086876, 0.03210420534014702, 0.03369462117552757, -0.026042386889457703, 0.03326564282178879, 0.016859954223036766, 0.027254093438386917, 0.057829104363918304, 0.011505044996738434, 0.05116900056600571, 0.011767040006816387, -0.06189475581049919, 0.019341597333550453, 0.021274110302329063, 0.013924582861363888, -0.005105121526867151, -0.009502640925347805, 0.01765574887394905, -0.03775649517774582, 0.06829989701509476, 0.03984905406832695, -0.01710297353565693, 0.012073011137545109, -0.008255830965936184, 0.003204643726348877, -0.0035370972473174334, -0.0421171709895134, 0.007019890006631613, 0.02697545289993286, -0.0028055249713361263, 0.003573185997083783, -0.004774978384375572, 0.011034487746655941, -0.003504511434584856, -0.07428460568189621, 0.009096754714846611, -0.09448858350515366, -0.0006491542444564402, -0.026285352185368538, 0.04072854295372963, -0.03744415193796158, 0.016999054700136185, -0.001318262773565948, -0.06494151800870895, 0.030936289578676224, -0.03239201754331589, -0.0090189753100276, 0.04492175579071045, 0.11245346814393997, -0.00819147378206253, -0.07519151270389557, 0.006323425564914942, -0.02605142630636692, -0.057012028992176056, -0.08282296359539032, -0.05162014067173004, -0.05375336855649948, -0.00293620303273201, 0.03795074298977852, 0.008357725106179714, 0.005305709317326546, 0.09170813113451004, -0.027272863313555717, 0.014946629293262959, -0.07075185328722, 0.03919830173254013, 0.012251654639840126, -0.013925222679972649, -0.010863578878343105, -0.006340205203741789, -0.03375760093331337, -0.10677693784236908, -0.014275279827415943, -0.010472013615071774, 0.07948561012744904, 0.05120278522372246, -0.038219209760427475, 0.014618619345128536, -0.002562769688665867, 0.014691255986690521, -0.03546031937003136, -0.02901691012084484, -0.030924348160624504, 0.017865590751171112, -0.01309910323470831, -0.055058520287275314, 0.000733397901058197, -0.04221440851688385, -0.00795948226004839, 0.01985911838710308, 0.04670257866382599, 0.0013757453998550773, 0.021614978089928627, 0.017465610057115555, -0.014459677040576935, 0.025370655581355095, 0.04021711274981499, -0.016343453899025917, 0.02156561240553856, 0.009702015668153763, -0.0328817144036293, -0.056728165596723557, -0.016404099762439728, -0.003659474663436413, 0.011111526750028133, -0.028254594653844833, 0.034739069640636444, -0.06243911758065224, 0.02640032395720482, -0.015452872030436993, -0.03977573290467262, -0.02450845204293728, -0.013419288210570812, 0.011590472422540188, -0.009792420081794262, -0.03115278109908104, -0.0029787563253194094, -0.06320042163133621, 0.0057078576646745205, 0.009984303265810013, -0.03795342147350311, 0.04737405478954315, -0.03369869291782379, 0.015064774081110954, 0.025969915091991425, 0.021340884268283844, -0.0417935885488987, -0.06601390987634659, -0.03148850053548813, 0.015566040761768818, 0.00032753052073530853, 0.017268551513552666, 0.058559685945510864, 0.03047288954257965, -0.05293706804513931, 0.04117146506905556, 0.010620118118822575, 0.04439840465784073, 0.03304058685898781, 0.009771150536835194, 0.024589775130152702, -0.0030224439688026905, 0.08327044546604156, -0.031308162957429886, 0.03816598653793335, 0.005976845044642687, 0.031145626679062843, -0.06808127462863922, 0.020272746682167053, -0.02152719348669052, 0.029948122799396515, -0.05248221009969711, 0.015457727015018463, -0.031429748982191086, 0.01987946406006813, 0.07881850749254227, 0.03049704059958458, 0.03895624354481697, -0.042603690177202225, -0.05284994840621948, -0.021156873553991318, 0.05192862078547478, 0.05029704421758652, 0.011177480220794678, 0.01766050048172474, 0.015383015386760235, -0.0040621329098939896, 0.049550168216228485, -0.03430783376097679, -0.05234662815928459, -0.0458538793027401, 0.032950837165117264, -0.01257764920592308, -0.025163503363728523, -0.009476609528064728, 0.07346239686012268, 0.016322549432516098, -0.0068345279432833195, -0.020186126232147217, -0.012292956002056599, 0.01783711463212967, 0.0194091759622097, -0.05591464042663574, -0.05563725158572197, -0.00907809380441904, -0.016908425837755203, -0.00446251081302762, -0.0492328479886055, 0.032811038196086884, -0.02677985467016697, 0.06219562515616417, 0.0011636395938694477, -0.027430009096860886, 0.03516903892159462, 0.09078622609376907, 0.0052627804689109325, 0.006581482477486134, 0.020315583795309067, -0.025845913216471672, -0.009312525391578674, 0.013628997839987278, -0.00804207194596529, -0.0105404919013381, 0.02709922194480896, 0.0017783866496756673, -0.019904274493455887, 0.02076823078095913, 0.016958924010396004, -0.007518608123064041, 0.00886214803904295, 0.02681940793991089, -0.04499947279691696, -0.029078563675284386, 0.001092563383281231, 0.03447459638118744, 0.010022561997175217, -0.03420402482151985, -0.0009965943172574043, -0.04085998982191086, 0.0005589383072219789, 0.01956699602305889, -0.004544249270111322, -0.05403987690806389, 0.01747269369661808, 0.005645998287945986, -0.009125064127147198, -0.005773094482719898, 0.013010756112635136, -0.03597036004066467, -0.01408801507204771, 0.029819078743457794, 0.06587589532136917, 0.015498478896915913, -0.03133745864033699, 0.008762264624238014, 0.005397674161940813, -0.02267882414162159, 0.06323619931936264, -0.05772560089826584, 0.005942830350250006, -0.029607616364955902, 0.04214216768741608, 0.027933748438954353, -0.023866135627031326, -0.01971309632062912, 0.07180897146463394, -0.0245098564773798, 0.007569541689008474, 0.04051242396235466, -0.04438691586256027, -0.014980310574173927, -0.05181921273469925, 0.004375182092189789, -0.0032065738923847675, -0.031531501561403275, 0.01189775113016367, 0.04534419625997543, -0.039368513971567154, 0.032976578921079636, -0.02983107790350914, 0.040879569947719574, -0.015001669526100159, -0.02894367091357708, -0.030406083911657333, -0.02582980878651142, 0.008500604890286922, 0.006410310044884682, -0.020397275686264038, 0.006137435790151358, 0.012418139725923538, 0.011955969966948032, 0.00003285761340521276, -0.013740593567490578, -0.024438058957457542, -0.006570576690137386, -0.056061629205942154, 0.0064148074015975, -0.02192450873553753, 0.06592300534248352, 0.010966580361127853, 0.0035982888657599688, -0.01506754569709301, 0.00013997493078932166, -0.02257073111832142, 0.023541543632745743, -0.01843336410820484, -0.02882332354784012, 0.016896545886993408, 0.01596076600253582, -0.005317640956491232, 0.013945112936198711, 0.0423218235373497, 0.00687527796253562, -0.019347598776221275, -0.0018284093821421266, 0.004804015625268221, 0.040244489908218384, -0.04480800777673721, -0.03838493302464485, 0.014267873018980026, 0.027230916544795036, -0.024362117052078247, -0.029477223753929138, -0.057988859713077545, 0.025087006390094757, 0.0051928358152508736, -0.0034128683619201183, 0.038727499544620514, -0.013708739541471004, -0.0156349278986454, 0.004703167360275984, -0.0020586675964295864, 0.017726480960845947, -0.04418429359793663, -0.05536256730556488, 0.008156645111739635, -0.04249488189816475, 0.010478893294930458, 0.009186618030071259, -0.023602254688739777, -0.002118106698617339, 0.01953131891787052, -0.02065156400203705, -0.047321565449237823, -0.0021018781699240208, -0.011137510649859905, -0.015749523416161537, -0.026406286284327507, -0.011862999759614468, 0.017798619344830513, -0.05638255923986435, -0.021672414615750313, 0.03524195775389671, -0.06347009539604187, 0.0063985115848481655, 0.07783162593841553, 0.06269081681966782, 0.044637877494096756, -0.007158810272812843, 0.02784331701695919, 0.045206520706415176, 0.014143096283078194, -0.039353568106889725, 0.04547949507832527, -0.03535410389304161, -0.018176013603806496, -0.02060205489397049, 0.05672300234436989, -0.004269655793905258, -0.015456370078027248, -0.03619729354977608, -0.027356687933206558, -0.027667799964547157, 0.04383844509720802, 0.0031043633352965117, -0.017686886712908745, 0.004457749426364899, -0.0292908176779747, 0.08289559185504913, -0.07175922393798828, 0.05357445403933525, -0.018238821998238564, -0.06445224583148956, 0.006753911264240742, 0.007387555669993162, -0.03573048114776611, -0.00033612974220886827, 0.028304442763328552, -0.0031514381989836693, 0.062027182430028915, -0.04347050189971924, 0.0826953873038292, -0.0017823190428316593, 0.0775931179523468, 0.04313374310731888, 0.024182183668017387, -0.044774413108825684, 0.053819674998521805, 0.0017153272638097405, 0.06332602351903915, -0.0893353745341301, -0.03974703326821327, -0.02381175011396408, 0.013587317429482937, -0.010404272936284542, -0.007116770371794701, 0.007927827537059784, -0.02489319257438183, 0.002314656740054488, 0.025361141189932823, -0.0667148306965828, 0.019883684813976288, -0.015664150938391685, -0.03261930122971535, 0.07867913693189621, -0.04548360034823418, 0.004199513234198093, 0.02469463087618351, 0.03739099204540253, -0.013159913942217827, -0.009230945259332657, 0.07460014522075653, 0.012963698245584965, 0.011476692743599415, -0.021439217031002045, -0.010467438958585262, -0.011226688511669636, -0.022722041234374046, -0.06301230192184448, 0.017330404371023178, -0.023176049813628197, 0.022294847294688225, 0.022754063829779625, 0.006382437888532877, -0.0010545863769948483, 0.002635146025568247, 0.020819932222366333, 0.009442389011383057, -0.0674428716301918, -0.04649415612220764, 0.010603800415992737, -0.010876930318772793, 0.020938707515597343, -0.028195030987262726, 0.022136757150292397, 0.03375526890158653, 0.010202428326010704, 0.05062362551689148, 0.04295007884502411, 0.03392857685685158, -0.05852774530649185, -0.008970718830823898, 0.02849552594125271, -0.009003570303320885, 0.07439261674880981, 0.009332144632935524, 0.032825544476509094, -0.007637582719326019, 0.014974463731050491, 0.02226513996720314, -0.05536802113056183, -0.016675181686878204, -0.027463946491479874, -0.0010843054624274373, -0.015449062921106815, -0.016656043007969856, 0.019461480900645256, 0.04402916878461838, -0.019535457715392113, -0.015500160865485668, -0.01291256956756115, 0.049453649669885635, -0.03383621945977211, 0.0875149518251419, -0.013479933142662048, -0.016816893592476845, 0.005942768882960081, 0.010472992435097694, -0.0027317360509186983, -0.06403244286775589, 0.013907314278185368, -0.023006942123174667, -0.051331810653209686, 0.00426445109769702, 0.0009081630851142108, -0.002039513550698757, 0.02102850191295147, -0.01646939106285572, 0.01382350642234087, -0.03679214045405388, 0.020547647029161453, -0.015158109366893768, -0.005351352039724588, -0.03196920081973076, 0.03041406162083149, 0.0204126238822937, 0.017875419929623604, -0.10575298964977264, -0.01719670742750168, -0.017421165481209755, 0.0376444011926651, 0.008224735036492348, -0.060082752257585526, 0.005819837562739849, 0.07151297479867935, 0.0033178876619786024, -0.030861428007483482, -0.014276115223765373, 0.0028952357824891806, 0.01293147075921297, 0.030620520934462547, -0.046006470918655396, 0.00396385695785284, 0.04705790802836418, -0.05415542796254158, 0.0005827604327350855, 0.016220450401306152, -0.01127215102314949, -0.02123255655169487, -0.017189305275678635, 0.03429353982210159, -0.004951547831296921, 0.05533245578408241, 0.009014702402055264 ]
<p>I've found this interesting paper that mentions another possible way to interpret the recent BICEP2 results, and that hadn't been ruled out yet <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1403.5166" rel="nofollow">1</a>. As interesting as the possibility that the BICEP2 team has observed CMB polarization due to gravitational waves resulting from a self ordering scalar field transition sounds, I would like to know what its implications/significance would be!</p>
g9766
[ 0.033933792263269424, 0.037996500730514526, 0.00905571412295103, -0.02015206217765808, 0.06852129846811295, -0.018158361315727234, 0.05253593623638153, -0.0058985017240047455, -0.010942766442894936, 0.006839557085186243, -0.03040742501616478, 0.04741841182112694, -0.013315124437212944, -0.02418844774365425, 0.07975161075592041, -0.0479266457259655, 0.027571164071559906, 0.011205395683646202, 0.007719297893345356, -0.02364039048552513, -0.046142108738422394, 0.04028954356908798, 0.023517724126577377, -0.024597352370619774, -0.03898518905043602, 0.05561291426420212, 0.03874975070357323, -0.024889957159757614, -0.015539444051682949, -0.045684121549129486, 0.02505538985133171, 0.003043973119929433, 0.037868548184633255, -0.03819187730550766, -0.0750821903347969, -0.008063537068665028, 0.060472648590803146, 0.0022822159808129072, 0.005783592816442251, 0.048400282859802246, -0.03524095192551613, -0.037016987800598145, -0.03234703093767166, -0.03287211433053017, 0.026791848242282867, -0.047765959054231644, -0.01972021907567978, 0.021381231024861336, 0.021936936303973198, -0.06017627194523811, 0.0010518087074160576, -0.00456620566546917, 0.10990464687347412, 0.041630327701568604, 0.013604470528662205, 0.0240238718688488, 0.040705423802137375, 0.014432377181947231, 0.11493261903524399, -0.030066469684243202, -0.005436828825622797, 0.027710789814591408, 0.04585151746869087, -0.008673879317939281, 0.03375411778688431, -0.029517117887735367, -0.0562666691839695, -0.021312925964593887, -0.017174355685710907, 0.02494066208600998, 0.02957303822040558, -0.044537127017974854, -0.007831578142940998, -0.02246185764670372, -0.04055799916386604, 0.026490362361073494, -0.016734380275011063, -0.03178897872567177, 0.017763502895832062, -0.01598849520087242, -0.024178143590688705, 0.0035779711324721575, -0.06582523137331009, -0.0016621743561699986, 0.0800013616681099, -0.03842128813266754, 0.028150292113423347, 0.06581810861825943, -0.05355071648955345, 0.04876148700714111, -0.008540871553122997, -0.018926702439785004, 0.009948784485459328, 0.016879448667168617, -0.0025605249684304, -0.01982227712869644, 0.04091557487845421, 0.04160752147436142, -0.011926695704460144, -0.013559460639953613, -0.05988846719264984, 0.06410310417413712, -0.0797562301158905, 0.019448500126600266, -0.01704481430351734, 0.023122375831007957, -0.032208364456892014, 0.014073275960981846, 0.0004693613154813647, 0.04192992299795151, -0.027049114927649498, 0.02861136943101883, 0.025160932913422585, -0.005873485002666712, -0.06357712298631668, -0.052780553698539734, 0.0381130650639534, 0.005712924525141716, -0.016277391463518143, 0.07697980105876923, 0.03480866551399231, -0.03584107756614685, -0.04837751016020775, 0.05223111808300018, -0.04165587201714516, -0.006410837173461914, -0.033121880143880844, -0.006667138077318668, 0.07714635133743286, -0.01488211378455162, -0.035824693739414215, 0.0003514100972097367, -0.01564060151576996, 0.014225945807993412, -0.006800721865147352, -0.02664404734969139, 0.010050318203866482, -0.033881474286317825, 0.004823350813239813, -0.009511377662420273, 0.012273860163986683, -0.029537634924054146, 0.03517983853816986, -0.055268771946430206, 0.006415995769202709, 0.01591137982904911, 0.035386644303798676, 0.04391905292868614, 0.03924499824643135, 0.025252798572182655, 0.006923956330865622, 0.04113748297095299, -0.009635166265070438, -0.018052781000733376, -0.012693743221461773, 0.049738090485334396, -0.04891931265592575, 0.026940934360027313, 0.01946745067834854, 0.0657140240073204, 0.07556585967540741, -0.00021519599249586463, -0.012010069563984871, 0.0030450867488980293, -0.01966855861246586, 0.00018111502868123353, 0.05000782012939453, -0.0191911943256855, 0.049258675426244736, 0.00814977940171957, -0.08881907165050507, -0.02018849551677704, 0.011754211038351059, 0.08472007513046265, -0.02657405287027359, 0.08549240976572037, -0.01292469073086977, -0.043884050101041794, -0.026697343215346336, 0.013979545794427395, -0.06147259846329689, 0.0377732589840889, 0.005007467698305845, 0.0219540074467659, 0.03758569061756134, -0.026497062295675278, -0.05230983719229698, 0.0815856084227562, -0.015088110230863094, -0.0535375252366066, -0.040025774389505386, -0.0004873802827205509, -0.03634538874030113, 0.05335655063390732, 0.010672040283679962, 0.051163990050554276, 0.022713545709848404, 0.009286491200327873, -0.00803424883633852, 0.0600539892911911, 0.0415043830871582, 0.02845519408583641, 0.008770235814154148, -0.014710502699017525, -0.010783501900732517, -0.022760696709156036, -0.002727530663833022, -0.008650536648929119, 0.05425981432199478, -0.057413965463638306, 0.025869160890579224, -0.0116425147280097, -0.018746620044112206, -0.03419597074389458, -0.023012666031718254, 0.03705286979675293, 0.0001867780229076743, 0.01500406302511692, -0.014003493823111057, 0.026247844099998474, -0.017398269847035408, 0.0076735978946089745, 0.028785832226276398, 0.08287262171506882, 0.007812954485416412, -0.0024429752957075834, -0.08324631303548813, -0.04814035817980766, -0.025192810222506523, -0.04942699894309044, -0.04499706253409386, 0.10562021285295486, 0.05153961107134819, -0.010065518319606781, 0.05372951924800873, -0.000038112055335659534, -0.042105287313461304, 0.021203452721238136, 0.008090956136584282, -0.0014401392545551062, 0.01986381597816944, -0.04139735549688339, -0.032428842037916183, -0.023689378052949905, 0.009682342410087585, -0.001292998786084354, 0.043833233416080475, 0.017363306134939194, -0.0031897365115582943, -0.04989009350538254, 0.06500284373760223, -0.002352052368223667, -0.041547711938619614, -0.03252905234694481, -0.05022640898823738, -0.03221292048692703, 0.03305140137672424, 0.07652471959590912, -0.05981242656707764, -0.06097472459077835, -0.03192553296685219, -0.03384442999958992, 0.03362505882978439, 0.010379765182733536, -0.0028365012258291245, -0.008318687789142132, 0.0024721594527363777, -0.023040425032377243, -0.06515225768089294, -0.023624319583177567, -0.017044516280293465, 0.01736452989280224, 0.010111624374985695, 0.04674479737877846, -0.04244018718600273, -0.006575993727892637, 0.03223740682005882, 0.045030005276203156, -0.07302667200565338, 0.008549241349101067, -0.09070242941379547, 0.04383378103375435, -0.0012984515633434057, 0.027921242639422417, -0.007351905107498169, 0.013411212712526321, 0.006699369754642248, 0.0029859738424420357, 0.03254539519548416, 0.037990372627973557, 0.10094386339187622, 0.004961517173796892, 0.039172183722257614, 0.05047185346484184, 0.023250848054885864, 0.03426516801118851, 0.0010438953759148717, -0.010697350837290287, -0.013198886066675186, -0.0031389554496854544, 0.0679398626089096, 0.028796417638659477, -0.0007827805238775909, -0.014684801921248436, -0.0612911656498909, -0.028205793350934982, -0.031914208084344864, -0.0646582618355751, -0.0013964270474389195, 0.03549519553780556, 0.011562314815819263, 0.02922639437019825, 0.03642145171761513, -0.0009291277965530753, 0.024356026202440262, -0.014420476742088795, -0.07702946662902832, 0.0402580164372921, 0.008018692024052143, -0.029466617852449417, -0.029770584776997566, -0.06190408766269684, 0.010603569447994232, 0.017609596252441406, 0.06767062097787857, -0.008151581510901451, -0.013815867714583874, 0.052199725061655045, -0.08541519939899445, -0.023467060178518295, -0.025003550574183464, -0.051373716443777084, -0.008572003804147243, 0.0038668124470859766, 0.015735330060124397, -0.06714976578950882, -0.023118503391742706, 0.05206203833222389, 0.04580187425017357, 0.026893500238656998, 0.06401743739843369, -0.015905512496829033, -0.009777074679732323, -0.024042002856731415, 0.0023697458673268557, 0.08247725665569305, 0.014291870407760143, -0.0299675390124321, -0.06180886551737785, -0.019152145832777023, -0.022987494245171547, 0.008307269774377346, 0.04279113933444023, 0.032786499708890915, -0.05734116584062576, 0.00419048173353076, 0.0634506344795227, -0.014176101423799992, 0.013560672290623188, 0.015681343153119087, -0.06744865328073502, -0.06561270356178284, 0.02737395092844963, 0.04094931110739708, 0.011654900386929512, -0.008584906347095966, -0.003055783687159419, 0.0015633583534508944, -0.011793405748903751, -0.019634423777461052, 0.012645070441067219, -0.07234902679920197, -0.007022269070148468, 0.048062898218631744, 0.007431592792272568, -0.06048492714762688, 0.013033505529165268, 0.0096366498619318, -0.006174834910780191, -0.0008121994324028492, -0.049373459070920944, 0.03271390125155449, 0.03839676082134247, 0.03281610831618309, 0.02246587537229061, -0.056975286453962326, -0.0459805466234684, -0.003190516261383891, -0.04435815289616585, -0.05576230585575104, 0.006336561404168606, 0.02069825306534767, -0.008383338339626789, -0.01450282707810402, -0.013137266039848328, -0.054260801523923874, -0.03896471858024597, -0.016950644552707672, -0.00006154545553727075, 0.03663177788257599, -0.010897231288254261, 0.00791121181100607, -0.024342309683561325, -0.011466576717793941, -0.04068950191140175, -0.02990637719631195, 0.0123591972514987, -0.013622327707707882, -0.012523580342531204, 0.010380852036178112, 0.02749478630721569, -0.013425745069980621, -0.03901393711566925, -0.08057595044374466, 0.037492234259843826, 0.036679547280073166, -0.009882589802145958, 0.0010040426859632134, 0.059467896819114685, 0.051535360515117645, 0.051737021654844284, 0.007821105420589447, -0.03059963881969452, -0.016627097502350807, -0.034877218306064606, 0.02040836028754711, 0.033186256885528564, -0.0010583489201962948, -0.018412858247756958, -0.005431646481156349, 0.007155967876315117, 0.025679398328065872, 0.018086280673742294, -0.015789667144417763, -0.025484854355454445, 0.036787249147892, -0.04633912444114685, 0.003463189350441098, 0.02085193805396557, -0.01349763572216034, 0.039735499769449234, -0.04641149938106537, 0.030758049339056015, -0.022304562851786613, 0.004997543059289455, 0.04152148962020874, -0.029831578955054283, -0.03705160692334175, 0.03579222038388252, -0.018587518483400345, -0.008362870663404465, 0.0012571229599416256, 0.04008583724498749, 0.035075634717941284, 0.05038059502840042, -0.021619487553834915, 0.03939932584762573, 0.08557271957397461, -0.02862982638180256, 0.010773521848022938, 0.004398572724312544, -0.0466226264834404, -0.01574639044702053, 0.01024952158331871, 0.025456536561250687, 0.0285630002617836, -0.016948936507105827, -0.0513734370470047, -0.0562991164624691, 0.03478293865919113, -0.021856270730495453, -0.009734218940138817, 0.007383840158581734, -0.012109361588954926, -0.04725745692849159, 0.030727587640285492, -0.047887347638607025, -0.0009656320908106863, 0.011668366380035877, -0.034352365881204605, -0.03221625089645386, -0.018589451909065247, -0.002476015593856573, -0.04111963510513306, 0.0009690910228528082, 0.047066036611795425, -0.03460637852549553, 0.004427977371960878, -0.061398714780807495, -0.029638854786753654, 0.032300904393196106, 0.01406670082360506, 0.006903692614287138, -0.01943030394613743, -0.02453567273914814, 0.020180320367217064, 0.023505648598074913, -0.029421120882034302, 0.02253190614283085, -0.02160414680838585, -0.06921840459108353, 0.053510505706071854, -0.005729088559746742, 0.01375669613480568, -0.03768298774957657, 0.05546993389725685, 0.024501685053110123, 0.027025464922189713, -0.013839931227266788, 0.04677731543779373, -0.029616544023156166, -0.02925487793982029, 0.01564972475171089, 0.016858287155628204, -0.00314647750928998, -0.04455035552382469, 0.01175745390355587, 0.0075027658604085445, 0.010020807385444641, -0.058219339698553085, 0.019105518236756325, -0.021968774497509003, 0.0849432423710823, -0.011743145063519478, 0.040619056671857834, 0.04416994750499725, 0.006423072889447212, 0.037656743079423904, 0.058332011103630066, 0.005750960670411587, 0.007097707130014896, 0.018118852749466896, 0.10913214832544327, 0.044132113456726074, 0.04647631198167801, -0.074934221804142, 0.05962533503770828, 0.07042121887207031, 0.0003942019829992205, 0.02014397829771042, -0.04956857115030289, 0.004024546127766371, -0.02231200970709324, 0.04224336892366409, 0.007614821661263704, 0.023203987628221512, 0.03684127330780029, -0.06406156718730927, -0.0009465454495511949, -0.12179556488990784, -0.018024466931819916, 0.015551545657217503, 0.014853081665933132, 0.024381084367632866, -0.02636386826634407, 0.010644862428307533, -0.02880788967013359, -0.07558906078338623, -0.02094957046210766, -0.012128387577831745, -0.021224334836006165, 0.04186263307929039, 0.021174868568778038, -0.020917894318699837, 0.01862126588821411, -0.0011883769184350967, 0.0431625135242939, -0.014036793261766434, 0.05417822673916817, -0.0009356493246741593, -0.027088163420557976, 0.07315707206726074, 0.0001470795104978606, 0.06112026795744896, -0.00032424321398139, -0.008818850852549076, 0.024950718507170677, -0.0424489751458168, 0.016448499634861946, -0.026399416849017143, 0.017918096855282784, 0.0327911451458931, 0.034786369651556015, -0.01759476028382778, -0.05565797537565231, 0.04008982703089714, -0.021971141919493675, 0.005737619008868933, 0.0577244907617569, 0.014848028309643269, -0.043006617575883865, -0.04042956605553627, -0.007369775325059891, -0.021644700318574905, -0.006775205489248037, -0.011650887317955494, -0.015671052038669586, 0.01816471852362156, -0.05712457746267319, 0.007718103006482124, -0.013794667087495327, 0.006889003794640303, 0.008940380997955799, 0.020692816004157066, 0.007936510257422924, -0.03025614656507969, -0.03129712864756584, 0.0025572783779352903, 0.007794687058776617, 0.02380220592021942, -0.022415243089199066, -0.017883555963635445, -0.024474142119288445, 0.006035261787474155, 0.028067855164408684, -0.012475092895328999, -0.012299350462853909, 0.016810806468129158, -0.004147388972342014, 0.07884188741445541, 0.018715018406510353, 0.02787691354751587, 0.013634025119245052, -0.049749940633773804, -0.037422485649585724, -0.011323514394462109, 0.013794281519949436, -0.015235976316034794, 0.0271066315472126, 0.029851628467440605, -0.03562778979539871, 0.058333974331617355, 0.03143313527107239, 0.037333812564611435, 0.018443424254655838, -0.028098803013563156, -0.03012736700475216, -0.033250946551561356, 0.01639554649591446, -0.031134653836488724, 0.01076570712029934, -0.005377041641622782, 0.023462820798158646, -0.05435192212462425, -0.02997487783432007, 0.07766976207494736, 0.026400161907076836, -0.04289473965764046, 0.006365905981510878, -0.011809934861958027, -0.004851188976317644, 0.008236533030867577, -0.017321579158306122, -0.02472340129315853, -0.006597814615815878, 0.016598831862211227, 0.04609251394867897, -0.022068696096539497, 0.03836672380566597, -0.005028547253459692, -0.02731310762465, -0.00028136055334471166, -0.029948392882943153, 0.01534438505768776, -0.018035154789686203, -0.019421428442001343, -0.05961494892835617, -0.030152302235364914, -0.0010772219393402338, 0.0024337240029126406, -0.004729750566184521, -0.04402041435241699, -0.0090126171708107, -0.0016386013012379408, 0.0006533545674756169, -0.015389691106975079, 0.001168615068309009, -0.04283912107348442, 0.020964251831173897, 0.10301854461431503, 0.03722138702869415, 0.034030891954898834, 0.006168900057673454, 0.011662798933684826, -0.002675943775102496, 0.05874064937233925, -0.05291217193007469, -0.024906020611524582, -0.038556866347789764, 0.019738569855690002, -0.011456114239990711, -0.0002410309825791046, -0.09691792726516724, -0.030529893934726715, 0.05241778865456581, -0.017420394346117973, -0.0035551628097891808, 0.07719431817531586, -0.01890973374247551, 0.01403946802020073, 0.0046310084871947765, 0.006228146608918905, -0.06087325140833855, -0.016026992350816727, -0.016964981332421303, 0.004791896790266037, 0.03642678260803223, -0.04473384842276573, -0.04431144893169403, -0.016271131113171577, -0.0037248649168759584, 0.02095613069832325, 0.00570816220715642, -0.023212136700749397, -0.038427870720624924, 0.06129588559269905, -0.06441990286111832, -0.012065804563462734, 0.03676509112119675, 0.008580970577895641, -0.027774808928370476, 0.04237774759531021, -0.060529451817274094, 0.0414876751601696, 0.023325517773628235, -0.03448992222547531, -0.043305687606334686, 0.018091266974806786, 0.017509520053863525, -0.00891756359487772, 0.0028428775258362293, -0.04008563980460167, 0.0043774801306426525, -0.03314925357699394, 0.01920744590461254, 0.036487285047769547, -0.02499842643737793, 0.08189602941274643, 0.01432409230619669, -0.03951453045010567, 0.014706018380820751, -0.038193996995687485, 0.010763704776763916, -0.05921400710940361, 0.0014152292860671878, -0.01579628884792328, -0.055825117975473404, 0.0262795127928257, -0.01082686148583889, -0.05404927581548691, -0.016232412308454514, -0.007373490836471319, -0.005372717045247555, 0.06536772102117538, -0.0019640394020825624, -0.027893077582120895, -0.0012168824905529618, -0.024695809930562973, -0.01564871147274971, -0.06841123104095459, -0.011359396390616894, -0.0018013998633250594, -0.024499453604221344, -0.0074713462963700294, -0.05396377295255661, -0.03144122287631035, -0.01447023544460535, 0.02546825259923935 ]
<blockquote> <p>When I see <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonic_coordinates" rel="nofollow">harmonic coordinates</a> used somewhere, what should my association be? </p> <p>Is there some general use or need to consider the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonic_coordinate_condition" rel="nofollow">harmonic cooridnate condition</a>? </p> </blockquote> <p>I don't really see what's behind all the things said in the wikipedia article and I've seen these coordinates used in some papers but don't really understan their significance, other than that one can consequently algebraically use the relation $\Delta x^\mu=0$ in computations. I don't see what that means though, do the full set of these coordinates have some general geometrically visible properties, maybe characterized with the associated base of distributions?</p> <p>Moreover, do these cooridnates have some special role in geometric quantization?</p>
g9767
[ 0.038054876029491425, 0.0070103914476931095, -0.015894392505288124, -0.05406250059604645, 0.06055508553981781, -0.006916206330060959, 0.058517586439847946, 0.02648027427494526, -0.05985937640070915, -0.011390683241188526, 0.021737145259976387, -0.0016004275530576706, 0.03295886889100075, 0.012741070240736008, -0.07054849714040756, 0.02178961969912052, 0.027479954063892365, 0.07842718064785004, 0.051224853843450546, -0.021376455202698708, -0.017273757606744766, 0.02264147438108921, -0.011140192858874798, 0.014082466252148151, 0.006430785171687603, -0.026277052238583565, 0.03659079968929291, -0.07005377858877182, -0.01961703412234783, -0.06555262207984924, 0.014539633877575397, 0.04350290447473526, 0.10377804934978485, 0.010903991758823395, -0.04265527054667473, 0.013055703602731228, 0.03755413740873337, 0.03389459103345871, 0.008018587715923786, 0.02227815054357052, 0.0575902946293354, 0.00894083920866251, -0.004279736895114183, -0.0028908217791467905, -0.08176612108945847, 0.02960529737174511, -0.02185923047363758, -0.00620675552636385, 0.007513674441725016, 0.024844810366630554, 0.04387474060058594, 0.03490850701928139, 0.04629301279783249, 0.010584519244730473, 0.06885583698749542, 0.03413810953497887, 0.029388928785920143, -0.0021682216320186853, 0.03488142043352127, 0.040692850947380066, -0.02032063901424408, 0.013025496155023575, 0.002865283517166972, 0.06408543884754181, 0.058807238936424255, 0.03316246345639229, -0.03399587795138359, -0.06223860755562782, -0.03010896034538746, 0.017886685207486153, -0.018979620188474655, -0.03906377777457237, 0.009940346702933311, 0.008696974255144596, -0.02887921780347824, -0.010129313915967941, 0.003609781851992011, -0.01014869287610054, 0.038859773427248, 0.006758235860615969, 0.004479000810533762, 0.0035331575199961662, 0.05929040163755417, 0.0005792775191366673, 0.04897739738225937, 0.0025333066005259752, 0.009477896615862846, 0.019083630293607712, 0.022302988916635513, 0.00885639525949955, 0.07189881801605225, -0.02944619581103325, 0.0021091413218528032, 0.0421382300555706, -0.0010278205154463649, 0.042938727885484695, -0.04511924833059311, 0.036686841398477554, 0.017221322283148766, 0.0016501171048730612, -0.019112585112452507, 0.03275274112820625, 0.029677806422114372, 0.027805767953395844, 0.027324387803673744, -0.02686442621052265, 0.0037702738773077726, 0.014745919033885002, -0.009363565593957901, 0.022840425372123718, -0.07636571675539017, 0.046453893184661865, -0.03960507735610008, -0.06886014342308044, -0.03020629845559597, -0.06399761140346527, 0.019050154834985733, -0.04092413932085037, -0.018048109486699104, 0.05655631795525551, -0.03172403946518898, 0.01817336678504944, 0.07631795853376389, 0.05444740131497383, -0.024611568078398705, 0.03321950137615204, 0.026610292494297028, -0.018444400280714035, 0.024243274703621864, -0.07800871878862381, 0.021256612613797188, 0.02901001088321209, 0.018384920433163643, 0.022615188732743263, -0.05644887685775757, -0.005014881491661072, 0.012486533261835575, 0.0006590030388906598, 0.008594981394708157, 0.01693197526037693, -0.031944867223501205, -0.024338217452168465, 0.00970504991710186, -0.06568332016468048, 0.002495342865586281, -0.03315339609980583, 0.023984545841813087, -0.06405278295278549, 0.01895570009946823, 0.07159724831581116, -0.05022864788770676, 0.027752188965678215, -0.03396636247634888, -0.016185663640499115, 0.007020196411758661, -0.0002981623983941972, -0.003205760382115841, -0.026596715673804283, -0.0488402284681797, 0.036493103951215744, 0.03835296258330345, 0.0226767398416996, 0.05272061005234718, -0.00564696965739131, -0.016324227675795555, -0.025855494663119316, -0.022453956305980682, -0.052216459065675735, 0.0038419696502387524, -0.018370777368545532, 0.01452394388616085, 0.017008937895298004, -0.017745917662978172, -0.02324622869491577, 0.02378537878394127, 0.020917972549796104, -0.008527684956789017, 0.007963738404214382, 0.06943304091691971, 0.011072955094277859, -0.006061164196580648, -0.004555039573460817, 0.058471523225307465, -0.03561905771493912, -0.0010515775065869093, 0.03487584367394447, 0.0020069878082722425, -0.017229167744517326, -0.08787272870540619, 0.06894420832395554, -0.01747262105345726, -0.030587485060095787, 0.000068444169301074, 0.05457141995429993, -0.029591601341962814, 0.04602639377117157, -0.04156935214996338, 0.0020230922382324934, -0.06336117535829544, 0.027858585119247437, -0.05761696398258209, 0.02622416988015175, 0.05409901961684227, 0.03197111189365387, 0.0009663150412961841, 0.04724771901965141, 0.013894639909267426, 0.05474747717380524, -0.011201536282896996, 0.02692505158483982, -0.030233612284064293, -0.07149898260831833, 0.025924598798155785, -0.0005768667324446142, -0.0041991607286036015, -0.032532040029764175, 0.02035997435450554, -0.030098911374807358, -0.06924532353878021, 0.02332470938563347, -0.029518991708755493, -0.051520898938179016, 0.05593639239668846, -0.009636769071221352, 0.00015440562856383622, 0.02994365431368351, 0.0003685606352519244, -0.05710206180810928, 0.020853886380791664, 0.03593834489583969, -0.012083329260349274, -0.05274900421500206, 0.033560071140527725, 0.012565565295517445, -0.0343366339802742, 0.0705411285161972, -0.0697970762848854, -0.054422758519649506, -0.013126053847372532, 0.10026533901691437, 0.029162924736738205, -0.04228280112147331, 0.013172718696296215, 0.012286180630326271, 0.03415843844413757, 0.0098450668156147, 0.06208368390798569, 0.016613539308309555, -0.013708675280213356, 0.03479135036468506, -0.028838979080319405, -0.052709199488162994, 0.05225322023034096, 0.0013771567028015852, 0.02493443712592125, -0.0025593689642846584, 0.010385044850409031, -0.026223022490739822, -0.03774252533912659, -0.051714442670345306, -0.01632983610033989, -0.06749576330184937, -0.025178587064146996, 0.023930607363581657, -0.049225978553295135, -0.02529686503112316, -0.006280183792114258, -0.00967484712600708, -0.0022896372247487307, -0.030853381380438805, -0.01710943691432476, 0.00992786604911089, 0.03182016313076019, 0.0555361770093441, -0.04826122149825096, 0.03450629115104675, -0.026709407567977905, 0.03915636986494064, -0.044930510222911835, 0.016003301367163658, 0.016584359109401703, 0.020526662468910217, -0.01963225193321705, 0.043902233242988586, 0.051204320043325424, -0.0055968924425542355, -0.05901918560266495, 0.05142882466316223, 0.008527515456080437, -0.023033680394291878, -0.023265989497303963, -0.007249328773468733, -0.037404149770736694, 0.004341742489486933, -0.009018706157803535, -0.0020805143285542727, -0.02875322848558426, -0.02196863293647766, 0.0627744197845459, 0.0811566561460495, 0.022126872092485428, 0.012631627731025219, 0.002496889792382717, -0.0006447299383580685, 0.015850668773055077, 0.04422399401664734, -0.011931976303458214, -0.04406809061765671, -0.05818638205528259, 0.00930042564868927, 0.061480700969696045, -0.007733430713415146, 0.01402378361672163, -0.0007729652570560575, -0.003909176215529442, -0.012395589612424374, 0.00207468681037426, -0.03634868562221527, -0.026388730853796005, -0.03734784945845604, -0.018425993621349335, -0.018343791365623474, -0.06902841478586197, -0.03344952315092087, 0.08558887988328934, 0.07930707931518555, 0.007523652631789446, 0.020300548523664474, -0.0124185336753726, -0.025758177042007446, -0.012070498429238796, 0.02214701659977436, 0.041045304387807846, 0.0170072540640831, -0.053039293736219406, -0.09747754037380219, -0.0734848752617836, 0.035713016986846924, 0.060569558292627335, -0.023843914270401, 0.00344296102412045, -0.025699744001030922, -0.014117177575826645, 0.003234055358916521, -0.020579766482114792, -0.0060959928669035435, -0.014294609427452087, 0.04799829050898552, -0.0048716990277171135, -0.029401931911706924, -0.031843192875385284, -0.08243066817522049, 0.03485048562288284, -0.008626865223050117, 0.05443166196346283, 0.020456714555621147, 0.04451727494597435, -0.005052174441516399, 0.006324985530227423, -0.0072642043232917786, 0.02167562209069729, 0.04166208952665329, -0.002252268837764859, 0.02479705959558487, 0.037396322935819626, 0.008194638416171074, -0.009231575764715672, 0.018811341375112534, -0.04819753021001816, -0.023822611197829247, 0.01602710597217083, -0.02008514665067196, 0.008699363097548485, -0.031681597232818604, 0.010709199123084545, -0.03275718539953232, 0.0002511361672077328, -0.02511664107441902, -0.019942712038755417, 0.01034870557487011, 0.00390440970659256, 0.00002741415119089652, 0.006659138016402721, -0.012966693378984928, 0.04897189512848854, -0.024410782381892204, -0.03855845704674721, 0.03409333527088165, 0.037550218403339386, -0.03595868870615959, 0.0028803632594645023, -0.0013875572476536036, -0.019260916858911514, -0.024030830711126328, -0.047796059399843216, -0.031810544431209564, 0.015252555720508099, 0.011510503478348255, -0.015943149104714394, 0.040837813168764114, -0.050119880586862564, -0.04682480916380882, 0.010632253251969814, 0.04635055735707283, -0.004828739445656538, 0.03625853732228279, 0.014978679828345776, 0.006735797505825758, 0.06309442222118378, -0.05788402259349823, -0.012918267399072647, -0.025774119421839714, 0.03388683870434761, -0.03604871779680252, 0.07429947704076767, 0.032848674803972244, -0.013937500305473804, -0.005486648064106703, -0.02681366167962551, -0.020466534420847893, -0.031757455319166183, 0.03332388773560524, 0.038748033344745636, -0.024394595995545387, 0.04213949665427208, 0.03024175576865673, 0.05711369961500168, -0.021344348788261414, 0.028754524886608124, 0.021838000044226646, 0.059621844440698624, 0.02084333635866642, 0.03442661091685295, -0.014837633818387985, -0.07225088030099869, 0.012870242819190025, -0.08234049379825592, 0.10384386032819748, -0.02033545821905136, 0.035184141248464584, 0.07025431841611862, 0.04230111837387085, 0.011507965624332428, -0.06965941190719604, -0.023307815194129944, 0.025256114080548286, -0.010282455943524837, -0.0037976251915097237, 0.01984258182346821, -0.0702645406126976, 0.02986336685717106, -0.007424387149512768, 0.030558835715055466, -0.04394923895597458, 0.04617062211036682, -0.01496375072747469, -0.004686701111495495, -0.008703161962330341, -0.013084744103252888, 0.023563159629702568, -0.056564345955848694, -0.0038094031624495983, -0.015477053821086884, 0.003917845897376537, 0.02601851336658001, -0.02609754540026188, -0.09043309837579727, -0.024766024202108383, 0.004746105056256056, -0.012317975051701069, 0.007581754121929407, 0.01723688282072544, 0.024950074031949043, -0.02427297830581665, 0.017162049189209938, 0.032609112560749054, 0.014289208687841892, -0.024539131671190262, -0.07096424698829651, -0.059759024530649185, -0.0011874537449330091, 0.04180007055401802, 0.05226708576083183, -0.015191665850579739, 0.025489363819360733, -0.01273066271096468, 0.01941804029047489, -0.05282735452055931, 0.0047543952241539955, 0.02204436995089054, 0.000777594861574471, -0.0068071926943957806, 0.02005699835717678, 0.06537572294473648, -0.03447714447975159, -0.010145118460059166, 0.005752975586801767, -0.03677835687994957, 0.013254284858703613, -0.033605173230171204, 0.009998979978263378, 0.05754478648304939, 0.027163362130522728, 0.006730844732373953, 0.009197975508868694, 0.05002785474061966, 0.07097866386175156, -0.04514898732304573, 0.033322762697935104, -0.007904039695858955, 0.004048303700983524, 0.07257714867591858, -0.058823615312576294, 0.031048264354467392, -0.009946788661181927, 0.007810280658304691, -0.04378076270222664, -0.007126929238438606, -0.04443991929292679, -0.04774880036711693, 0.04148271307349205, -0.0016962196677923203, -0.010642357170581818, -0.08221150189638138, 0.06598182022571564, -0.050896961241960526, -0.0042689284309744835, -0.04893326014280319, 0.030852871015667915, 0.05367347598075867, -0.022767283022403717, 0.014344049617648125, 0.03736609220504761, 0.02472781017422676, -0.001027029356919229, -0.010782580822706223, -0.017058931291103363, -0.032387956976890564, 0.02398856170475483, 0.03933272138237953, -0.0336555577814579, 0.005177417304366827, -0.03320309519767761, 0.0784367099404335, -0.03974728286266327, -0.01838727667927742, -0.019778240472078323, 0.0077619729563593864, -0.015154456719756126, -0.01817478984594345, -0.033471833914518356, -0.02560986392199993, 0.04987554997205734, -0.013480105437338352, -0.022235406562685966, 0.017526505514979362, 0.026203956454992294, 0.019805381074547768, -0.04288777709007263, -0.029988693073391914, 0.025569749996066093, 0.03916076570749283, -0.03822749853134155, 0.03359318524599075, 0.03173229470849037, -0.0231129489839077, 0.021108942106366158, 0.017346220090985298, 0.052868422120809555, 0.029772436246275902, 0.02630443498492241, -0.035449665039777756, 0.0034458041191101074, 0.00901454035192728, 0.04126637056469917, 0.036965277045965195, -0.07328781485557556, -0.041573572903871536, -0.08923866599798203, 0.0019554838072508574, -0.023969201371073723, 0.010169151239097118, 0.0364595502614975, -0.062151554971933365, -0.015146789140999317, 0.025128431618213654, -0.03291003406047821, -0.0037687032017856836, 0.04390906170010567, 0.043711479753255844, 0.04093164950609207, -0.0024221441708505154, -0.027015533298254013, 0.02755693718791008, -0.03008733130991459, -0.03619706630706787, 0.020013898611068726, 0.0692838579416275, -0.004935045726597309, -0.035501573234796524, 0.0011233460390940309, -0.02369905635714531, 0.06617002934217453, 0.024371759966015816, 0.02265366166830063, 0.022847475484013557, 0.01528473012149334, -0.01756463199853897, -0.05052272230386734, -0.004746644292026758, -0.03733247518539429, 0.07012694329023361, 0.009625199250876904, 0.020298084244132042, 0.023456841707229614, -0.06492341309785843, -0.048767752945423126, -0.008250633254647255, -0.05943264067173004, -0.020929329097270966, 0.021105999127030373, -0.0323122963309288, -0.04566565155982971, 0.04966049641370773, 0.03770425170660019, 0.04975575953722, -0.02859078347682953, -0.027696531265974045, 0.026757076382637024, -0.00877345073968172, -0.0413326732814312, 0.0024613060522824526, -0.0043066320940852165, 0.008749958127737045, -0.036477554589509964, -0.05720619857311249, -0.07901615649461746, -0.024501295760273933, 0.09032077342271805, 0.045174986124038696, 0.0026896195486187935, 0.007661084178835154, 0.07178156077861786, -0.019801350310444832, -0.04070354253053665, -0.060375165194272995, 0.022647658362984657, -0.010246988385915756, -0.08879665285348892, -0.007113644387573004, 0.023379284888505936, -0.015461266040802002, -0.03486219793558121, 0.033373624086380005, -0.028942357748746872, 0.0262359119951725, 0.028329020366072655, 0.0013239182299003005, -0.06855091452598572, -0.007006877567619085, -0.08928041905164719, 0.012983621098101139, -0.045685917139053345, -0.015556996688246727, -0.06295786798000336, 0.01828460767865181, -0.01465960405766964, -0.014223619364202023, -0.0649557039141655, -0.0004957237397320569, -0.04588412865996361, -0.014564523473381996, 0.02675306238234043, -0.0247657373547554, 0.021689658984541893, 0.01642543449997902, -0.01287694089114666, 0.03615480661392212, -0.02402799390256405, -0.03234422206878662, 0.0013509450946003199, 0.025747667998075485, 0.017595112323760986, -0.04398872330784798, -0.07337933778762817, 0.03898605704307556, -0.028986340388655663, -0.047864776104688644, -0.018031775951385498, 0.00042217932059429586, -0.0046498836018145084, 0.03613109886646271, -0.053665097802877426, -0.03062448464334011, -0.01263163611292839, -0.004847860895097256, 0.059445179998874664, 0.023985600098967552, -0.04202784597873688, 0.050699349492788315, 0.028798310086131096, -0.043651118874549866, -0.01266887504607439, 0.010718932375311852, 0.01542697660624981, -0.008680087514221668, 0.05485580861568451, 0.0012996434234082699, -0.050144970417022705, 0.004074605647474527, 0.0385650172829628, -0.024526895955204964, -0.04758639261126518, 0.011774977669119835, 0.02683587744832039, 0.04641653597354889, 0.0359625481069088, 0.0110966507345438, -0.05444120988249779, -0.004495501983910799, 0.02086038701236248, -0.009480944834649563, 0.012814530171453953, -0.03963635116815567, -0.041553862392902374, 0.022225139662623405, -0.021399574354290962, 0.03243929147720337, -0.0028309107292443514, -0.01717855967581272, -0.01755966618657112, -0.01790650747716427, 0.02587515488266945, 0.032849717885255814, -0.04614732787013054, 0.005729285534471273, -0.01828063651919365, -0.013404116965830326, -0.027468400076031685, 0.03054370917379856, 0.012957551516592503, 0.020904622972011566, 0.000419760646764189, -0.04847266525030136, -0.009570538997650146, 0.00841681007295847, -0.012851130217313766, 0.06492045521736145, 0.003693701233714819, -0.022373465821146965, -0.0002787145785987377, 0.03182961791753769, -0.008359819650650024, 0.006369020324200392, -0.024860834702849388, -0.024995528161525726, -0.0068467650562524796, 0.03502833470702171, 0.0927082747220993, -0.06385885924100876, 0.03316478431224823, 0.016817644238471985, -0.0351518951356411, -0.0031839089933782816, -0.03746739774942398, -0.0591433122754097, -0.03779294714331627, -0.014543799683451653 ]
<p>Would it be possible to determine the rest mass of a particle by computing the potential energy related to the presence (existence) of the particle, if this potential energy could be determined accurately enough?</p> <p>I noticed from the answers to a recent question that I always assumed this to be true, without even thinking about it. However, it occurred to me that this concept was at least unfamiliar to the people who answered and commented on that question, and that it's even unclear whether this concept is true or meaningful at all.</p> <p>Let me explain this concept for an idealized situation. Consider an idealized classical spherical particle with a charge $q$ and a radius $r$ at the origin. Assume that the particle generates an electrostatic field identical to the one of a point charge $q$ in the region outside of radius $r$ and vanishing inside the region of radius $r$. Now let's use a point charge $-q$ and move it to the origin in order to cancel this field in the region outside of radius $r$. Moving the point charge to the origin will generate a certain amount of energy, and that would be the energy which I mean by the potential energy related to the presence (existence) of this idealized classical spherical particle.</p> <p>I'm well aware that really computing the potential energy related to the presence (existence) of any real particle is not practically feasible for a variety of reasons, but that never worried me with respect to this concept. What worries me now is whether this notion of potential energy is even well defined at all, and even if it is, whether it really accounts for the entire rest mass (not explained by other sources of kinetic, internal or potential energy) of a particle. After all, the rest mass of a particle might simply be greater than the mass explained by any sort of potential energy.</p>
g9768
[ 0.08031753450632095, -0.04613599553704262, 0.011857984587550163, -0.02392149530351162, 0.03962527960538864, 0.003938365262001753, -0.011997229419648647, 0.06675130128860474, -0.048139821738004684, 0.033872343599796295, -0.025073304772377014, -0.018465757369995117, 0.017328107729554176, -0.033826254308223724, -0.060534100979566574, 0.001284150523133576, 0.09078986197710037, -0.008187446743249893, -0.01918148808181286, 0.06128675490617752, 0.03833191841840744, -0.012651344761252403, 0.041324418038129807, 0.0065003326162695885, -0.04332456737756729, 0.03474750742316246, -0.0007488581468351185, 0.030084773898124695, -0.0433693490922451, -0.06552352011203766, 0.011180426925420761, -0.0187776368111372, 0.015109702944755554, -0.0269452016800642, -0.013283078558743, -0.007772922981530428, 0.03879473730921745, 0.039962105453014374, -0.035977546125650406, -0.0135427201166749, 0.0036827779840677977, -0.05603323131799698, 0.026021527126431465, 0.0031072350684553385, 0.013399123214185238, 0.021102212369441986, 0.03269161283969879, 0.014885750599205494, 0.0030376759823411703, -0.043041080236434937, -0.03424236178398132, 0.017510462552309036, 0.015672391280531883, -0.01042600441724062, 0.0026434636674821377, 0.03830898553133011, 0.015742452815175056, 0.012066301889717579, 0.019532417878508568, 0.03931964933872223, 0.06028730049729347, 0.006647187285125256, -0.04494992643594742, -0.020336313173174858, 0.04329916834831238, -0.012900673784315586, -0.08371690660715103, 0.02614738419651985, -0.04694939777255058, -0.008902739733457565, 0.018904706463217735, -0.024858901277184486, -0.1126570776104927, -0.01564369723200798, -0.034612275660037994, 0.028039222583174706, -0.009457453154027462, 0.023339256644248962, 0.005929369013756514, -0.023073939606547356, -0.012130576185882092, -0.04304661229252815, 0.026816537603735924, 0.020560232922434807, 0.06930634379386902, -0.029966121539473534, -0.01196858286857605, -0.03366989269852638, -0.0006748622981831431, 0.003564591985195875, -0.0028249898459762335, 0.011068915948271751, 0.11155891418457031, -0.03340377286076546, 0.0052490923553705215, -0.010289989411830902, -0.013862784020602703, 0.03520101681351662, -0.02593313530087471, 0.014140481129288673, 0.012877736240625381, -0.03511989489197731, -0.015643667429685593, 0.021636825054883957, -0.03411759063601494, 0.0013600698439404368, 0.013322331942617893, -0.028446132317185402, 0.04321346431970596, 0.0023424243554472923, 0.016173183917999268, -0.05145029351115227, -0.026518922299146652, 0.0029763500206172466, -0.09318631142377853, -0.04974474757909775, 0.1202336996793747, -0.03966213017702103, -0.020896291360259056, 0.07801272720098495, -0.02458876371383667, 0.06669264286756516, -0.012885121628642082, 0.011936984024941921, -0.0044249300844967365, 0.026350846514105797, -0.013535912148654461, 0.015231401659548283, -0.006750877480953932, -0.021987546235322952, 0.006176326889544725, -0.02847478538751602, -0.017980266362428665, -0.02146420069038868, -0.0006627574912272394, 0.013308284804224968, -0.0036664705257862806, 0.015081225894391537, 0.005563824437558651, 0.01752707175910473, 0.036015287041664124, -0.018988830968737602, -0.009175022132694721, -0.008082708343863487, -0.028521215543150902, 0.05038895830512047, 0.007003079168498516, -0.028838250786066055, 0.017184456810355186, 0.09557191282510757, 0.01652676612138748, 0.04339567571878433, 0.03661514073610306, -0.051901254802942276, 0.07521294802427292, -0.005760480649769306, -0.03724701330065727, 0.006868807598948479, -0.006741218734532595, 0.0362207405269146, 0.06533373147249222, 0.008296865038573742, 0.05542830005288124, 0.015305591747164726, 0.029544461518526077, -0.00989050604403019, -0.02750134840607643, -0.022547129541635513, -0.021110672503709793, -0.09814678132534027, -0.032761525362730026, -0.007815905846655369, 0.012689284980297089, 0.03249330073595047, -0.05574345588684082, 0.026247920468449593, 0.010399636812508106, 0.00008276494918391109, 0.019540006294846535, 0.021378785371780396, -0.03212873637676239, -0.018890565261244774, 0.049637194722890854, -0.019820963963866234, -0.018124409019947052, 0.019992418587207794, 0.0388188399374485, 0.0250837504863739, -0.0007929859566502273, -0.020969077944755554, -0.04981307312846184, -0.010852928273379803, -0.022489679977297783, 0.024299204349517822, 0.01821090653538704, -0.01760595478117466, 0.05802679434418678, -0.010777140967547894, -0.011218101717531681, 0.006034449674189091, -0.02467210590839386, 0.050714705139398575, 0.017889561131596565, 0.017199866473674774, 0.06862469017505646, -0.052402425557374954, 0.03640354052186012, -0.01830269768834114, 0.009072696790099144, 0.0029735693242400885, 0.027947772294282913, 0.0014578180853277445, 0.035499729216098785, 0.010475710034370422, -0.017592227086424828, -0.009348726831376553, -0.062049154192209244, -0.010926585644483566, -0.023946816101670265, -0.0323936901986599, -0.11303582042455673, 0.010651664808392525, 0.005452374927699566, 0.033106204122304916, -0.03489174321293831, 0.07776685804128647, -0.11476761102676392, 0.007670057006180286, -0.05093524977564812, 0.012402406893670559, -0.05208542197942734, 0.06492972373962402, 0.03316907584667206, -0.037537481635808945, 0.0595998652279377, 0.04575385898351669, -0.06727128475904465, -0.05306209623813629, 0.0358954481780529, -0.0069374265149235725, 0.001664481358602643, -0.056629329919815063, 0.010818352922797203, 0.015488406643271446, 0.05880402773618698, -0.004751140717417002, 0.044948138296604156, -0.004492966923862696, -0.006174092181026936, -0.005641705356538296, -0.01601414754986763, 0.00771939754486084, 0.010879467241466045, -0.038274239748716354, -0.009154575876891613, 0.005228491500020027, 0.013718602247536182, 0.0331919863820076, 0.014787868596613407, -0.036365754902362823, -0.03980409726500511, -0.01969626545906067, -0.020194800570607185, 0.05273730680346489, -0.037523303180933, 0.003883474739268422, -0.011400474235415459, 0.014472168870270252, -0.021503504365682602, 0.01592167094349861, 0.017888855189085007, 0.07682184875011444, 0.0268666073679924, 0.03495776280760765, 0.02354375272989273, -0.07110663503408432, -0.005272836424410343, 0.016890326514840126, 0.035636141896247864, -0.0027576268184930086, 0.02757626213133335, -0.013559896498918533, -0.03152039274573326, 0.07880765199661255, -0.01834722049534321, -0.07757171243429184, 0.006279902532696724, 0.01070786826312542, 0.02995389699935913, -0.01767471246421337, 0.00728559261187911, -0.006228155922144651, 0.050872549414634705, -0.04557571932673454, -0.00756556773558259, 0.06979038566350937, -0.0061867693439126015, -0.07963799685239792, 0.014058666303753853, -0.0009450746001675725, 0.016208354383707047, -0.013080012053251266, -0.02105879597365856, -0.013068774715065956, 0.029001357033848763, 0.03478939086198807, -0.057620879262685776, -0.01338688749819994, 0.025715555995702744, -0.03792382776737213, 0.0005217938451096416, 0.047635938972234726, -0.01994764432311058, 0.018404453992843628, -0.018668605014681816, 0.010250425897538662, -0.0127548947930336, -0.027343975380063057, -0.0019474478904157877, -0.033257920295000076, -0.0023693209514021873, -0.012081139720976353, 0.04470312222838402, 0.0067948405630886555, 0.045408230274915695, 0.055269502103328705, -0.05516478419303894, 0.02514205500483513, -0.05508230999112129, -0.03182653710246086, 0.010747810825705528, -0.012583950534462929, -0.04166026785969734, -0.014612996950745583, 0.014947610907256603, -0.10886728018522263, -0.00011483072012197226, 0.0158209390938282, 0.1004922166466713, -0.009019694291055202, 0.03194139152765274, 0.04304414987564087, 0.002125590806826949, -0.04689272493124008, -0.04872119054198265, 0.06633929163217545, -0.060065291821956635, -0.06513211876153946, 0.012275570072233677, -0.009149198420345783, 0.03998786583542824, -0.013145530596375465, 0.007212573196738958, 0.02363542839884758, 0.024364527314901352, -0.007702019065618515, 0.012578792870044708, 0.03877648711204529, 0.04929296299815178, -0.019676536321640015, 0.002639227546751499, -0.026145879179239273, 0.06805802136659622, -0.05158936232328415, 0.022220570594072342, -0.06016284227371216, -0.01063521672040224, -0.04608749598264694, -0.00350358197465539, -0.04658256098628044, 0.019080474972724915, -0.03967394307255745, 0.0015785821015015244, 0.03162165731191635, 0.030689049512147903, 0.014281295239925385, 0.011646881699562073, 0.010462461039423943, -0.056249503046274185, -0.012803701683878899, 0.015734754502773285, -0.01975836418569088, 0.008693186566233635, -0.015158255584537983, -0.02593347057700157, 0.04347055405378342, -0.11281166225671768, 0.004828702192753553, 0.03406358137726784, -0.00036118977004662156, -0.010730067268013954, -0.11232639849185944, -0.04430564492940903, -0.018715549260377884, 0.02433435246348381, 0.04703653231263161, 0.0005468805902637541, -0.06374754756689072, 0.08479436486959457, 0.009049804881215096, -0.0016100913053378463, 0.036047276109457016, -0.01275221724063158, 0.023520182818174362, 0.046449270099401474, -0.030036352574825287, 0.05987957864999771, -0.0034337874967604876, -0.030363649129867554, -0.058406926691532135, 0.009295046329498291, 0.022073877975344658, 0.03919140249490738, -0.07196511328220367, -0.02667950838804245, 0.0038683689199388027, -0.04313870891928673, -0.006933767814189196, 0.017812836915254593, 0.030724162235856056, -0.0091346874833107, -0.03458196669816971, -0.018885480239987373, 0.00584619352594018, 0.008754545822739601, 0.07756107300519943, 0.07828636467456818, -0.014670857228338718, -0.04168180748820305, -0.02002023719251156, 0.01873721182346344, 0.04243602976202965, 0.06484534591436386, -0.007960198447108269, -0.03280999884009361, -0.0336892195045948, -0.061586976051330566, 0.026753319427371025, 0.023745805025100708, -0.004805685020983219, 0.04460800439119339, 0.03406395763158798, 0.04843193292617798, -0.02257784828543663, -0.04899934306740761, 0.022824602201581, -0.05646362155675888, -0.018660375848412514, 0.03609296306967735, -0.03416711091995239, -0.023238064721226692, -0.03843703866004944, -0.021707994863390923, -0.03581376001238823, -0.03456449136137962, -0.003726430470123887, -0.05159526318311691, -0.01672256551682949, -0.044196296483278275, -0.021370358765125275, 0.019832156598567963, 0.004481342155486345, 0.028867436572909355, 0.04416999593377113, 0.07743511348962784, -0.022514574229717255, -0.016169428825378418, 0.029291728511452675, -0.04803158715367317, -0.006274832878261805, -0.02849549613893032, 0.037848472595214844, 0.0324665866792202, -0.0029861414805054665, -0.04127196595072746, -0.04943559691309929, -0.007185068912804127, -0.0661967396736145, 0.007349416613578796, 0.004099326673895121, -0.02655828185379505, 0.03597308322787285, -0.0041745505295693874, -0.00240335869602859, -0.06490544974803925, 0.05617973953485489, -0.053141314536333084, 0.016471393406391144, -0.00772840203717351, 0.01868160255253315, 0.04009528085589409, -0.0001782841864041984, 0.023954052478075027, -0.030611557886004448, 0.04739715903997421, 0.008674662560224533, 0.01864444650709629, -0.00603865459561348, -0.06531310826539993, 0.03203640133142471, 0.021960612386465073, 0.024197639897465706, -0.018939653411507607, 0.006792103406041861, -0.009979994036257267, -0.0113995261490345, 0.027749428525567055, -0.019581930711865425, 0.022983131930232048, -0.007043988443911076, 0.02718786522746086, 0.06570634245872498, -0.016519322991371155, 0.0435495525598526, -0.005725614260882139, -0.015652470290660858, -0.02833249792456627, 0.012545370496809483, -0.018917834386229515, 0.005451791919767857, 0.022000260651111603, 0.007198350969702005, 0.02385741099715233, -0.05104014649987221, -0.00480077276006341, 0.013283132575452328, -0.02243739739060402, -0.013415991328656673, 0.011688824743032455, 0.06075672060251236, -0.0019565296825021505, -0.018780013546347618, -0.06196165457367897, 0.016462547704577446, -0.040970396250486374, -0.0548272468149662, -0.03745971620082855, -0.011513455770909786, 0.04076312482357025, -0.008642277680337429, -0.03599436208605766, -0.05629372224211693, 0.022072099149227142, 0.03417392820119858, 0.00972805917263031, 0.03285529837012291, -0.03044847771525383, -0.026504799723625183, 0.05575350299477577, -0.061004389077425, 0.0056860921904444695, 0.041814547032117844, -0.013187350705265999, 0.005287316162139177, -0.013596937991678715, 0.012338374741375446, -0.013656455092132092, -0.0086656603962183, -0.022765735164284706, -0.017783651128411293, -0.019650740548968315, -0.03539532423019409, -0.021911069750785828, 0.02604077011346817, 0.04820191115140915, 0.0024450698401778936, -0.014135995879769325, -0.022540144622325897, 0.04430985450744629, 0.02101510763168335, -0.0286116823554039, 0.018107036128640175, -0.00013553837197832763, -0.015491653233766556, 0.06558515131473541, 0.01010053139179945, -0.013968820683658123, 0.03252227604389191, -0.02425161562860012, -0.015534450300037861, 0.040266845375299454, 0.0537399984896183, 0.04866017773747444, -0.05819372087717056, 0.02694312296807766, 0.0054962048307061195, -0.04944625496864319, -0.022958189249038696, 0.061824485659599304, -0.0084263626486063, 0.03530248999595642, -0.0013259522384032607, -0.05603788420557976, 0.011379645206034184, -0.041160810738801956, 0.001962922979146242, 0.025098364800214767, -0.023280633613467216, -0.022651074454188347, 0.03903450444340706, 0.039945997297763824, -0.012274318374693394, -0.000709617743268609, -0.024540308862924576, 0.041518986225128174, 0.024511216208338737, -0.0052789123728871346, 0.010432202368974686, -0.04134685546159744, -0.007994350977241993, -0.045786209404468536, 0.02099004201591015, -0.012935807928442955, -0.03399261087179184, -0.005476889666169882, -0.014815176837146282, -0.06089521944522858, 0.0244554802775383, -0.05488232150673866, -0.0457010418176651, 0.021754175424575806, 0.04027273505926132, 0.02225678786635399, -0.034814972430467606, 0.06929551810026169, 0.004164086654782295, 0.0020913276821374893, 0.0727018415927887, 0.06297995150089264, 0.02678939700126648, -0.009195549413561821, 0.015948323532938957, 0.030530817806720734, 0.028586897999048233, 0.05404287204146385, 0.038710251450538635, 0.021506505087018013, 0.014307111501693726, -0.0008761279168538749, -0.010781004093587399, -0.04068345949053764, -0.0014872250612825155, 0.015107085928320885, 0.0262755136936903, -0.08289395272731781, -0.039885155856609344, 0.07738254219293594, 0.0496901199221611, -0.05169421806931496, 0.0004312790115363896, 0.006889568641781807, 0.00774194672703743, -0.011410493403673172, -0.01835767552256584, -0.019687024876475334, 0.011310217902064323, -0.025369148701429367, 0.029549188911914825, -0.01746154949069023, -0.1098853051662445, 0.01710141822695732, -0.0037603280507028103, 0.02672482468187809, -0.015689436346292496, -0.03591155633330345, 0.022276338189840317, -0.013010507449507713, -0.04926438257098198, -0.04292396083474159, -0.03273344784975052, 0.03687937557697296, -0.03775963932275772, -0.09047171473503113, -0.004482300020754337, -0.003751909825950861, 0.015074905008077621, 0.043991945683956146, 0.019073719158768654, 0.020259466022253036, 0.00426709046587348, -0.0030933080706745386, 0.03750661388039589, -0.06275401264429092, 0.034815188497304916, -0.023922953754663467, 0.01098884828388691, -0.0205391775816679, -0.01265719160437584, 0.02543431520462036, 0.060528647154569626, -0.007294008042663336, 0.03757062181830406, 0.026144064962863922, 0.027646534144878387, -0.02769337221980095, 0.018331196159124374, 0.07657694816589355, 0.04440765082836151, 0.06568809598684311, 0.00014228034706320614, 0.025906424969434738, -0.022112395614385605, 0.06593989580869675, -0.03530021384358406, 0.03305545821785927, 0.0068760341964662075, -0.019766047596931458, -0.001516738091595471, -0.05128379911184311, 0.04332530498504639, 0.05401533842086792, 0.005658119451254606, 0.009832174517214298, 0.007847522385418415, 0.01715315319597721, -0.0018377761589363217, -0.04365294426679611, 0.06601037830114365, 0.026252541691064835, 0.00032876303885132074, -0.01249891147017479, 0.013168634846806526, 0.0053786528296768665, -0.0217905230820179, -0.0051104240119457245, -0.01039925031363964, -0.008572650142014027, -0.0008887322037480772, 0.0030661404598504305, -0.015556047670543194, 0.019700000062584877, 0.013998966664075851, -0.024396656081080437, -0.01740087755024433, -0.010426308959722519, 0.01637832261621952, -0.042222414165735245, 0.018390972167253494, -0.004872418940067291, -0.053027473390102386, -0.011058238334953785, -0.07913428544998169, 0.057611800730228424, -0.0953311175107956, -0.025857193395495415, -0.04263273626565933, -0.018082382157444954, 0.056755535304546356, 0.07314826548099518, 0.02870963141322136, -0.039639271795749664, -0.0028311656787991524, -0.057395730167627335, 0.015753449872136116, 0.07584334164857864, -0.056078165769577026, 0.0004535179177764803, 0.020008757710456848, -0.027743341401219368, -0.0196103323251009, 0.004398143384605646, -0.011545833200216293, 0.02367119863629341, 0.0012120193568989635, -0.00915446039289236, -0.008419555611908436, 0.030036967247724533, 0.032528024166822433 ]
<p>For someone who likes learning about astronomy what are the blogs and/or podcasts that I should be following?</p>
g9769
[ 0.008688961155712605, 0.011677609756588936, -0.005866609048098326, -0.006357426289469004, 0.003608764847740531, 0.03582924231886864, -0.030173422768712044, -0.045069288462400436, 0.05111374333500862, -0.026065202429890633, 0.07768069952726364, 0.05747343227267265, 0.07922781258821487, 0.006303026340901852, -0.001995471306145191, -0.032864511013031006, 0.006325984373688698, 0.012549370527267456, -0.011321659199893475, 0.02433486469089985, -0.0299227237701416, 0.04356730356812477, 0.03980008885264397, -0.030590932816267014, -0.09837942570447922, -0.04410753771662712, -0.02918699011206627, -0.022256148979067802, 0.05127155780792236, -0.048190467059612274, -0.017724763602018356, -0.04085785523056984, -0.004528251942247152, 0.027331281453371048, 0.03018546849489212, 0.028079001232981682, -0.011347510851919651, 0.0031361104920506477, -0.04366954416036606, -0.004470772575587034, 0.003034690860658884, -0.005977517459541559, 0.008032036945223808, 0.049580253660678864, -0.008144975639879704, -0.05625728517770767, -0.03955397754907608, -0.011364159174263477, 0.03995116800069809, 0.03420443832874298, 0.030347736552357674, 0.03156887739896774, 0.036571551114320755, 0.01833787001669407, -0.02685941942036152, -0.01736302860081196, 0.007096055895090103, -0.040654122829437256, 0.06859441846609116, -0.02945425920188427, 0.02604912966489792, -0.0295102559030056, -0.0015084847109392285, 0.005382605362683535, 0.01735912449657917, 0.07870553433895111, 0.049002744257450104, 0.023569194599986076, 0.01002408005297184, 0.01567937806248665, 0.08058099448680878, 0.0026936319191008806, 0.005983293056488037, 0.03982854261994362, -0.07747595012187958, -0.009009292349219322, 0.06687930226325989, -0.01918426901102066, 0.007471295539289713, 0.038205500692129135, -0.019439129158854485, 0.0020884573459625244, 0.012240557000041008, -0.006659229751676321, 0.022670859470963478, -0.010182310827076435, -0.04036941006779671, -0.031287360936403275, -0.009563607163727283, -0.041666917502880096, 0.000027570487873163074, -0.045102808624506, -0.01077835913747549, -0.0758991464972496, 0.06480531394481659, 0.010425912216305733, -0.004060813225805759, 0.01460106112062931, -0.01315218210220337, 0.022117000073194504, -0.07813809812068939, -0.015541252680122852, 0.024939898401498795, 0.07325867563486099, -0.0010870208498090506, -0.017583584412932396, -0.012991085648536682, -0.01742434687912464, -0.01883021928369999, 0.0583280473947525, 0.01251933816820383, -0.023335402831435204, 0.0376928374171257, -0.03285793215036392, -0.06301587074995041, -0.000012438448720786255, 0.05575905740261078, -0.03899206593632698, 0.015723615884780884, 0.07030605524778366, -0.005925741512328386, -0.0033210881520062685, 0.064940445125103, 0.030645549297332764, -0.010857615619897842, -0.010014833882451057, 0.05545583367347717, -0.055438656359910965, -0.028354858979582787, 0.02551029995083809, 0.04043049365282059, -0.032193373888731, -0.054063282907009125, -0.004314412362873554, -0.001758446916937828, 0.00048067091847769916, -0.0021333065815269947, 0.008013589307665825, 0.012303004041314125, -0.03387945145368576, 0.010222630575299263, -0.018380992114543915, 0.05796101689338684, -0.03970717638731003, -0.007318120449781418, -0.03707681596279144, -0.03594280406832695, 0.0016831114189699292, 0.03916189447045326, -0.04862883687019348, 0.029854560270905495, 0.052470020949840546, -0.026006724685430527, -0.04387729614973068, 0.016338668763637543, -0.03942444175481796, 0.0004052725853398442, -0.05776762217283249, 0.06337154656648636, 0.043084532022476196, -0.007504650391638279, -0.006496759597212076, -0.03628915175795555, 0.04067693278193474, 0.024325920268893242, 0.04433498531579971, -0.020205212756991386, -0.014132369309663773, 0.006283847149461508, 0.011807058937847614, -0.014328783378005028, -0.005176698323339224, -0.01796586997807026, 0.03249039500951767, 0.05165749415755272, 0.06095357611775398, 0.012378277257084846, -0.03805878385901451, -0.0025078789331018925, 0.003932473715394735, 0.04064226895570755, -0.04401562362909317, -0.03383006155490875, 0.014402134343981743, -0.013106693513691425, 0.045979924499988556, -0.039357271045446396, -0.014099938794970512, -0.09622959047555923, 0.047120124101638794, 0.013723989017307758, -0.011655876412987709, 0.007239547558128834, -0.00026608406915329397, -0.0041016642935574055, -0.019552331417798996, 0.049474697560071945, 0.015721265226602554, -0.01917099952697754, 0.057566169649362564, 0.021210474893450737, -0.04866291955113411, 0.012460542842745781, 0.035580042749643326, -0.0027389945462346077, 0.022692406550049782, 0.0005229810485616326, -0.00147243810351938, 0.0067360373213887215, 0.012581760995090008, -0.02491404488682747, -0.034288082271814346, 0.040987107902765274, 0.026873497292399406, -0.005389723461121321, 0.07267338782548904, -0.04967128112912178, 0.0222031120210886, 0.02019212581217289, -0.014862211421132088, 0.044329047203063965, -0.02716887556016445, -0.022538278251886368, -0.07294867187738419, 0.021156659349799156, -0.004581197630614042, 0.01367709506303072, -0.011063406243920326, 0.06658053398132324, 0.01199402753263712, -0.08778561651706696, -0.03328625112771988, 0.04547009989619255, 0.008431091904640198, 0.01978965289890766, 0.0489463172852993, 0.020303435623645782, -0.08530085533857346, -0.010932262055575848, 0.04148345813155174, -0.03321696072816849, 0.06398425996303558, 0.00608123280107975, -0.04295851290225983, 0.02294083498418331, -0.04096332564949989, 0.030009791254997253, -0.03050936385989189, -0.015368334017693996, -0.02452368475496769, 0.07997885346412659, 0.05385705456137657, -0.008937227539718151, 0.007304307073354721, -0.07396739721298218, 0.011701096780598164, -0.06923103332519531, 0.027854669839143753, -0.03639237955212593, 0.003553821239620447, 0.04917959123849869, 0.006686540320515633, -0.009127172641456127, -0.06138056889176369, 0.04881054535508156, -0.02106184884905815, -0.046671923249959946, 0.011094595305621624, -0.00549014937132597, -0.032239846885204315, 0.05267435312271118, 0.04091804474592209, 0.02121858298778534, -0.0537528321146965, -0.08324263244867325, 0.01664462871849537, 0.033534158021211624, -0.04672166332602501, 0.015648841857910156, -0.015511000528931618, 0.07235672324895859, -0.0025841055903583765, -0.022343534976243973, -0.013501201756298542, 0.01167354267090559, 0.005033999681472778, -0.018429066985845566, -0.003948883153498173, 0.032212477177381516, 0.013818750157952309, -0.004812188446521759, 0.011980404146015644, -0.008406038396060467, 0.03488371521234512, -0.02810441143810749, -0.0006458738353103399, 0.012334298342466354, 0.09309740364551544, 0.0006959298625588417, 0.060069385915994644, 0.019794298335909843, -0.027816027402877808, 0.050733599811792374, -0.004275268875062466, -0.04324086755514145, -0.0103989876806736, -0.016430750489234924, -0.01501031406223774, -0.007346589583903551, 0.034436825662851334, -0.006171420216560364, -0.005151965655386448, 0.03189730644226074, 0.019910097122192383, 0.013859321363270283, -0.015189840458333492, -0.03626519441604614, 0.006203659810125828, -0.0038318298757076263, 0.01527828723192215, -0.049111831933259964, 0.03877146542072296, -0.02821064181625843, -0.01351751945912838, 0.014999370090663433, 0.03387577459216118, -0.009800298139452934, -0.09466951340436935, -0.00991859007626772, 0.008069888688623905, -0.014932982623577118, -0.005605627316981554, -0.020264500752091408, -0.04777643457055092, -0.016774145886301994, -0.011632668785750866, 0.03192567452788353, 0.012116879224777222, 0.041658785194158554, 0.035132165998220444, 0.009649544954299927, 0.10389598459005356, -0.02188149467110634, 0.013511656783521175, -0.040295906364917755, -0.06594943255186081, 0.01021324098110199, 0.028100505471229553, 0.014770040288567543, -0.06895707547664642, 0.01468581147491932, 0.03609691187739372, 0.03278278931975365, -0.046092286705970764, -0.03019668348133564, 0.009670200757682323, 0.0024467455223202705, 0.0040754457004368305, 0.01126030832529068, -0.023826852440834045, -0.027026090770959854, 0.019806010648608208, -0.01160523109138012, 0.02453957125544548, -0.08396598696708679, -0.0002889166644308716, 0.010370885021984577, -0.048946548253297806, -0.03909717872738838, 0.014604486525058746, 0.0334869883954525, 0.07359140366315842, 0.012334726750850677, 0.01938886195421219, -0.06200938671827316, -0.04101007059216499, 0.018483731895685196, 0.05207321420311928, 0.010930093005299568, -0.018077649176120758, -0.01606435514986515, -0.02596464939415455, -0.0010015841107815504, 0.03240808844566345, 0.010281184688210487, 0.016611266881227493, 0.04744492471218109, 0.03906034305691719, -0.009832974523305893, -0.017839133739471436, 0.020921187475323677, -0.04776454344391823, 0.004953242372721434, -0.010122338309884071, 0.016958188265562057, -0.11818670481443405, 0.02549470029771328, 0.013115590438246727, 0.06985124200582504, 0.06945580989122391, -0.027728699147701263, 0.010895296931266785, -0.02960793487727642, 0.00584779167547822, 0.027218777686357498, 0.06343714147806168, -0.016510747373104095, -0.03640216961503029, 0.0004723835445474833, 0.007754449732601643, 0.0179580207914114, -0.049871888011693954, -0.014872545376420021, 0.01879197172820568, 0.03878272697329521, 0.019173378124833107, -0.010265517048537731, -0.009392487816512585, 0.01727984845638275, -0.0037815882824361324, -0.07565577328205109, 0.09643913805484772, 0.007236425764858723, -0.02773953601717949, 0.014270915649831295, 0.048360664397478104, 0.023178229108452797, -0.01753491349518299, 0.00039298858609981835, 0.06354132294654846, 0.007032429799437523, -0.06731497496366501, 0.015278847888112068, 0.018065426498651505, -0.06290902197360992, 0.055842384696006775, 0.05117686092853546, 0.05060337856411934, -0.029404133558273315, -0.005708054173737764, 0.03568881005048752, -0.0004174996283836663, -0.04044678434729576, -0.03789748251438141, 0.0013413112610578537, 0.09083294868469238, -0.009056216105818748, 0.07230532169342041, 0.015846282243728638, -0.03200075402855873, 0.008107287809252739, -0.037228427827358246, -0.022611072286963463, -0.057744793593883514, 0.033959873020648956, -0.02213536575436592, -0.058199211955070496, 0.022461246699094772, 0.057806916534900665, -0.029329922050237656, 0.029763121157884598, -0.04109542444348335, 0.051067594438791275, 0.0010484368540346622, 0.028679711744189262, 0.02790486067533493, -0.09288612008094788, -0.03170500695705414, 0.049742940813302994, -0.0058467453345656395, -0.04238562285900116, 0.00009575506555847824, -0.022165073081851006, -0.02138843573629856, -0.022353261709213257, -0.013808569870889187, 0.03631694242358208, 0.0006391539936885238, -0.010032099671661854, -0.015219544060528278, 0.027474762871861458, -0.017681581899523735, -0.026897042989730835, 0.021275080740451813, -0.0517466701567173, -0.02109305001795292, -0.0289817713201046, 0.007342436816543341, -0.004904226399958134, -0.0002819365181494504, -0.024083895608782768, -0.03192458301782608, 0.031366437673568726, -0.03947191312909126, -0.06569136679172516, -0.015495402738451958, -0.06474051624536514, -0.06516803056001663, 0.02712729014456272, -0.017882615327835083, -0.050729162991046906, -0.016534894704818726, -0.04451360926032066, 0.009484805166721344, 0.055776290595531464, 0.014447583816945553, 0.04971783608198166, -0.01360171940177679, -0.034321945160627365, -0.002156779868528247, 0.01714513637125492, 0.037030912935733795, -0.0563163198530674, 0.05071844160556793, -0.012830757535994053, -0.0394432470202446, 0.021379617974162102, 0.0025182936806231737, 0.011586994864046574, 0.014656082727015018, -0.09185696393251419, -0.036704424768686295, -0.009751321747899055, 0.045165177434682846, 0.03750406578183174, -0.003159067127853632, -0.055063724517822266, 0.034553054720163345, 0.05234644189476967, -0.057234279811382294, 0.036339569836854935, 0.04248186945915222, 0.01746692694723606, 0.002602740889415145, 0.007035317365080118, 0.01155809499323368, -0.003157672705128789, 0.0232109185308218, 0.002150951186195016, -0.035689037293195724, -0.03272702917456627, 0.05048198252916336, 0.046800218522548676, -0.03201834857463837, -0.011609922163188457, -0.010327653959393501, 0.03571900725364685, 0.05964755639433861, 0.0323319248855114, -0.021109454333782196, 0.0468086376786232, -0.00454634428024292, -0.008849059231579304, -0.010683402419090271, -0.035262998193502426, 0.05092652142047882, -0.019096950069069862, 0.0013467702083289623, -0.03935212641954422, -0.041180744767189026, -0.0935760885477066, -0.0364602729678154, -0.025745874270796776, 0.05207096412777901, 0.03752715140581131, 0.006414876319468021, -0.006948794238269329, -0.06696075201034546, 0.018536562100052834, -0.03047335334122181, -0.012133289128541946, -0.02087007649242878, -0.07445323467254639, -0.032986778765916824, 0.03753357753157616, 0.017639974132180214, 0.014316157437860966, -0.02700365148484707, -0.05933211371302605, -0.05486941337585449, 0.01016431674361229, 0.024519095197319984, 0.026151953265070915, 0.005445158574730158, -0.008362692780792713, 0.002867454197257757, -0.00932198204100132, 0.007938208058476448, 0.016447734087705612, -0.05246676877140999, 0.020442551001906395, -0.008463447913527489, 0.009286151267588139, 0.023783473297953606, -0.029226476326584816, -0.020548027008771896, 0.03605280816555023, -0.004089111462235451, 0.022015046328306198, -0.026861585676670074, -0.10916352272033691, -0.06574654579162598, 0.05135389417409897, 0.016378795728087425, 0.005376589484512806, -0.011301086284220219, -0.017968861386179924, 0.015252958983182907, 0.053722184151411057, 0.02532518282532692, -0.010281480848789215, 0.004443999379873276, 0.06139494478702545, 0.02557499334216118, -0.0319574736058712, 0.005050790961831808, -0.020710431039333344, -0.03991051763296127, 0.007897444069385529, -0.018713761121034622, 0.01590222306549549, 0.07150910794734955, -0.03069632314145565, 0.01973501779139042, -0.02534056454896927, 0.03423342481255531, 0.01549565140157938, -0.02191341295838356, -0.0063459197990596294, 0.008906968869268894, 0.0023407291155308485, 0.0000050958765314135235, -0.0599096305668354, 0.008129642345011234, 0.009651857428252697, -0.010777571238577366, 0.043209999799728394, -0.015563782304525375, 0.00859470758587122, 0.009703384712338448, -0.00629090191796422, 0.026313617825508118, 0.026431765407323837, 0.02364199608564377, 0.030167123302817345, -0.011204333044588566, -0.037338946014642715, -0.03028583712875843, -0.05314177647233009, 0.0033684605732560158, -0.007880093529820442, 0.0009389949846081436, -0.00048718680045567453, 0.04125223681330681, -0.06985779106616974, 0.042217183858156204, 0.05182595178484917, -0.03028564341366291, 0.024119233712553978, -0.06917256116867065, 0.006646266672760248, 0.027409078553318977, -0.00315642892383039, -0.0009298992226831615, -0.007461687084287405, -0.02089688554406166, -0.007375712972134352, -0.02227269858121872, -0.044814132153987885, 0.020246271044015884, -0.03738883137702942, -0.03735771402716637, -0.053873948752880096, -0.018352072685956955, -0.04906391352415085, -0.02338607981801033, -0.0503360889852047, -0.003379806410521269, 0.033615827560424805, 0.016279440373182297, -0.032340843230485916, 0.0286883357912302, -0.006338760256767273, 0.009059595875442028, 0.005262933671474457, 0.03545648604631424, -0.03422074764966965, -0.03149687498807907, 0.02639792673289776, -0.019720736891031265, -0.03970058262348175, -0.009818708524107933, -0.03866639360785484, -0.029269356280565262, 0.006405450403690338, -0.011717616580426693, -0.011478586122393608, -0.011264856904745102, -0.030499903485178947, 0.009129705838859081, -0.016427677124738693, 0.06923115253448486, -0.01963432878255844, -0.029766513034701347, 0.05024388059973717, 0.030904537066817284, -0.013760991394519806, 0.014795788563787937, 0.0016239628894254565, -0.02123686671257019, -0.014072718098759651, -0.04728403687477112, 0.03682110458612442, 0.018419113010168076, 0.006893417332321405, -0.009589405730366707, 0.03939526528120041, 0.05849246680736542, -0.030848363414406776, 0.016491811722517014, -0.01259735319763422, -0.011470495723187923, 0.03250817582011223, 0.025330008938908577, -0.0246493611484766, 0.021003631874918938, -0.010368693619966507, -0.047927211970090866, -0.027405299246311188, 0.015242422930896282, -0.009829931892454624, 0.07339447736740112, -0.02124144695699215, -0.10959275811910629, -0.02980218268930912, 0.06379017978906631, 0.01702306978404522, -0.057162124663591385, 0.07751668989658356, 0.036109186708927155, 0.040953733026981354, 0.007961146533489227, 0.027473170310258865, -0.022237081080675125, -0.016705211251974106, -0.09608208388090134, 0.03294946998357773, 0.017534101381897926, 0.044751059263944626, -0.005197099409997463, -0.05302475020289421, 0.10292887687683105, 0.06716743111610413, 0.0031498356256633997, -0.08398236334323883, 0.046443045139312744, -0.014271602965891361, -0.009978825226426125, 0.04972101002931595, -0.007502796594053507, 0.04901912808418274, -0.012288819067180157, 0.04401731491088867, -0.007915593683719635, -0.0023577455431222916, 0.04349073767662048, 0.022755859419703484, -0.003776234108954668 ]
<p>Or in other words, are there differences in average Lyapunov timescale between orbits interior to Jupiter and orbits exterior to Jupiter? I'm trying to answer a question at <a href="http://www.quora.com/Why-does-Pluto-have-so-many-satellites/answer/Alex-K-Chen">http://www.quora.com/Why-does-Pluto-have-so-many-satellites/answer/Alex-K-Chen</a> but I'm not totally sure if the last part of my answer is right. I'll quote the last part of it:</p> <blockquote> <p>If the 2nd theory is true, then it's harder to answer this. One thing for sure though: Jupiter is much farther away, so its tug on the system is a much smaller factor than it is for the inner planets (where it can be a major source of instability over the solar system's lifetime)</p> <p>In fact - I suspect that another factor is that from Pluto's perspective, Jupiter is practically in the center of the solar system anyways, so you're unlikely to see periods of time where Jupiter is in such a position where its constant gravitational tugs (over several Jupiter orbits) can accumulate and tug a satellite into an unstable orbit (which is what can happen with planets that orbit the Sun at distances interior to Jupiter [1]). Anyways I don't fully know the physics on this (yet) so some of my details could be wrong - what I do know is that it could happen to both asteroid belt objects and to Mercury's orbit - <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stability_of_the_Solar_System#Mercury.E2.80.93Jupiter_1:1_resonance">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stability_of_the_Solar_System#Mercury.E2.80.93Jupiter_1:1_resonance</a> - perhaps because there are positions where Jupiter's pull on interior bodies is in a direction opposite to that of the Sun's pull (we never hear about the Sun creating any orbital instabilities). And Mercury is much closer to Jupiter than Pluto is.</p> <p>Of course, Pluto is vulnerable to Neptune's influence, but Pluto and Neptune have a 3:2 orbital resonance so it's relatively safe from collisions with Neptune (although the resonance may not be constant over the solar system's lifetime)</p> <p>Anyways, we might finally know more once New Horizons reaches Pluto in a few years</p> <p>[1] <a href="http://www.alpheratz.net/murison/papers/Lyapunov/LFM.pdf">http://www.alpheratz.net/murison/papers/Lyapunov/LFM.pdf</a> says that there is something special about asteroids with orbits interior to Jupiter - I'll try to find more information on this.</p> </blockquote>
g9770
[ -0.08101671189069748, 0.10222747176885605, -0.0020294201094657183, -0.007512170355767012, 0.04747018218040466, 0.014883172698318958, -0.002841202775016427, -0.09572996199131012, -0.03400317206978798, -0.033771079033613205, 0.02385600097477436, 0.0319395437836647, -0.0009908046340569854, -0.049252428114414215, 0.02178257144987583, -0.027021272107958794, 0.04220835864543915, 0.015260886400938034, 0.004110593814402819, 0.01771603524684906, -0.06878684461116791, -0.002891792682930827, -0.011371667496860027, 0.028895623981952667, 0.008181098848581314, 0.033150412142276764, 0.022073792293667793, -0.008581874892115593, -0.039734747260808945, -0.010682495310902596, 0.04413766413927078, -0.0519198514521122, 0.04385070875287056, -0.03389325365424156, -0.02659660018980503, -0.039041344076395035, 0.02576453611254692, 0.002312486758455634, -0.017672931775450706, 0.04390333220362663, 0.01298703532665968, -0.06444591283798218, 0.026136184111237526, 0.022271526977419853, 0.03164486959576607, -0.05116394907236099, -0.03992252051830292, -0.0529157891869545, -0.013368252664804459, 0.006482377648353577, -0.017300115898251534, -0.008071034215390682, -0.015523535199463367, -0.019372642040252686, -0.02596115693449974, 0.04836103692650795, 0.013419114053249359, -0.011168860830366611, 0.033628951758146286, 0.0005306057864800096, 0.03220180422067642, 0.012251857668161392, 0.02267729863524437, 0.0005166432820260525, 0.002111989539116621, 0.00026775928563438356, -0.004626510664820671, 0.03719829395413399, -0.011085663922131062, -0.02414909563958645, -0.0242540892213583, 0.02279689349234104, -0.024496333673596382, -0.038941606879234314, -0.04173791781067848, 0.08187729865312576, 0.0014894093619659543, -0.004813893232494593, 0.011010226793587208, 0.05207143723964691, -0.019339842721819878, 0.022550836205482483, -0.03962204232811928, -0.013617606833577156, 0.06739814579486847, 0.0021175288129597902, 0.0254987645894289, 0.034504737704992294, -0.010995591059327126, 0.053079839795827866, -0.017114723101258278, -0.007258366793394089, 0.01655896194279194, 0.01963036321103573, 0.013233726844191551, 0.022995272651314735, 0.04645790904760361, 0.09618077427148819, -0.03862868249416351, 0.030002113431692123, -0.018398605287075043, -0.0033136482816189528, -0.005760192405432463, 0.04152018949389458, -0.01848127320408821, -0.035291168838739395, 0.071642205119133, -0.021632026880979538, 0.022244006395339966, -0.007758076768368483, -0.03507731482386589, -0.021572092548012733, 0.03870388865470886, 0.0176613237708807, 0.005138075910508633, 0.02098042704164982, 0.00412838626652956, 0.013462603092193604, 0.0503213033080101, 0.015948764979839325, -0.005017066840082407, 0.007874068804085255, -0.008505531586706638, 0.0643148273229599, -0.007200776599347591, -0.032810937613248825, 0.012586161494255066, 0.0020218626596033573, 0.05339987948536873, 0.027784092351794243, -0.07703808695077896, -0.0036892066709697247, -0.04036422818899155, 0.012566249817609787, 0.018146611750125885, 0.028579523786902428, 0.015584539622068405, -0.01932366192340851, -0.05445040389895439, -0.026158027350902557, 0.014989517629146576, -0.049315061420202255, 0.005361807066947222, -0.0739230066537857, -0.06885258108377457, 0.052933450788259506, -0.03958240896463394, -0.007033839821815491, -0.0012586947996169329, 0.029409736394882202, 0.02635575272142887, 0.0662396028637886, 0.01334105059504509, -0.018707724288105965, -0.03022649884223938, 0.0316605344414711, -0.04434967786073685, 0.03329235315322876, -0.021172048524022102, 0.040569182485342026, -0.03165583312511444, -0.042416490614414215, -0.0069952658377587795, 0.02507658302783966, -0.055710211396217346, 0.08364842087030411, 0.009404501877725124, -0.03407847508788109, -0.021757980808615685, -0.005808042827993631, -0.07363712042570114, -0.07008689641952515, 0.03950667753815651, 0.06893663853406906, 0.03495810925960541, 0.046041861176490784, 0.02048829011619091, -0.03515753895044327, 0.012306910939514637, 0.03354200720787048, 0.03126661479473114, -0.0034160122741013765, -0.02574537880718708, -0.059286151081323624, 0.005362242925912142, -0.010665319859981537, -0.001598927192389965, 0.018321789801120758, -0.013962327502667904, 0.029424887150526047, -0.011731188744306564, 0.009611518122255802, -0.006570586934685707, 0.0017366032116115093, 0.04755062237381935, -0.06384009122848511, -0.008091806434094906, -0.034527212381362915, -0.06385402381420135, -0.0021307028364390135, -0.004570373799651861, -0.06868590414524078, 0.04741690307855606, -0.051062338054180145, 0.03822551295161247, 0.014098129235208035, -0.012471573427319527, -0.00863704551011324, -0.018738500773906708, -0.05210946500301361, 0.008520280010998249, -0.01468699425458908, -0.025829581543803215, 0.07555428892374039, -0.04136483371257782, -0.033384114503860474, 0.011998218484222889, 0.03444695845246315, 0.059486713260412216, 0.002317069098353386, 0.03797241300344467, 0.004890688695013523, 0.07926365733146667, 0.00409435760229826, -0.015479687601327896, -0.003119866130873561, -0.004771051928400993, -0.00959171075373888, -0.0071768807247281075, 0.01680263690650463, -0.0438121072947979, 0.01996966078877449, 0.020244944840669632, 0.014768244698643684, 0.016791604459285736, -0.0355851873755455, 0.028445415198802948, -0.06825318932533264, 0.0007539541693404317, 0.03589710593223572, 0.036919042468070984, -0.04252083972096443, -0.093640998005867, -0.015342170372605324, 0.01686037704348564, -0.08273132145404816, 0.01923982799053192, -0.02568853087723255, -0.0400707945227623, 0.04098941758275032, -0.018944313749670982, 0.08256791532039642, -0.017511483281850815, -0.014132185839116573, -0.028183728456497192, -0.023751480504870415, 0.007572951726615429, 0.03528740629553795, -0.055668678134679794, 0.024351000785827637, 0.02882145531475544, -0.06392296403646469, 0.023851389065384865, 0.045754868537187576, -0.000868768198415637, 0.008289837278425694, -0.0010998424841091037, 0.014451906085014343, -0.04497867450118065, -0.019532831385731697, 0.01720069907605648, 0.06200389564037323, 0.010780800133943558, 0.044534094631671906, -0.034393101930618286, 0.05864888057112694, -0.06162982061505318, -0.06375642865896225, 0.0008463588892482221, -0.007425236981362104, 0.02028399147093296, -0.04823106899857521, -0.02955157309770584, -0.015994589775800705, -0.009767417795956135, -0.011017054319381714, -0.025468358770012856, 0.05212881788611412, -0.007355297915637493, 0.021608885377645493, 0.02079147845506668, 0.0036621850449591875, 0.037958137691020966, 0.025253959000110626, -0.019956005737185478, 0.04951042681932449, 0.03216129541397095, -0.039442278444767, 0.0009823235450312495, -0.02101907879114151, -0.020447829738259315, -0.0027345416601747274, 0.031315773725509644, 0.029861483722925186, 0.056968215852975845, 0.020039698109030724, -0.056239448487758636, 0.013024727813899517, -0.00888199731707573, -0.03556346893310547, -0.006421952974051237, 0.05952572450041771, -0.06582003831863403, 0.03467760980129242, 0.05912578105926514, -0.016031276434659958, -0.017169825732707977, 0.05680094286799431, 0.04206067696213722, -0.027521001175045967, 0.031466223299503326, -0.01472427323460579, -0.025676166638731956, -0.006719094235450029, -0.0077156685292720795, -0.01839977502822876, -0.09127058833837509, -0.018722208216786385, -0.035652030259370804, 0.014286847785115242, -0.03840160742402077, -0.0015215931925922632, 0.029811693355441093, -0.015927519649267197, -0.0837274119257927, 0.031055491417646408, 0.0632237046957016, 0.0634070634841919, 0.07001722604036331, -0.02033969759941101, -0.013977858237922192, -0.04092857614159584, -0.03261793404817581, -0.013339564204216003, 0.023144785314798355, 0.01587595045566559, 0.027124879881739616, -0.026835927739739418, 0.012823132798075676, -0.01809600554406643, 0.004641770385205746, -0.039825063198804855, 0.0027765429113060236, -0.03802519664168358, 0.030983878299593925, 0.027816785499453545, -0.0464431457221508, 0.009647499769926071, -0.0009301924728788435, -0.007094653323292732, -0.023956909775733948, 0.005930660292506218, 0.002393510425463319, 0.0052937776781618595, 0.02256578579545021, -0.016688894480466843, -0.01711425930261612, 0.015822215005755424, -0.013505795039236546, -0.05404215678572655, -0.04517420008778572, 0.07240381091833115, -0.005872142035514116, -0.051864150911569595, 0.09554316103458405, -0.05805876851081848, 0.05598839744925499, 0.0060256714932620525, 0.01441150065511465, 0.038770370185375214, 0.08226488530635834, 0.04613982513546944, -0.06047076731920242, 0.02562088705599308, 0.06493454426527023, 0.018464021384716034, -0.019255420193076134, -0.049962662160396576, -0.018767306581139565, -0.040542278438806534, -0.0713990181684494, -0.055919334292411804, 0.021962402388453484, -0.034529946744441986, 0.038919493556022644, -0.026170432567596436, 0.008089001290500164, 0.015624023042619228, 0.05487094447016716, -0.020191049203276634, 0.00742435222491622, -0.026742298156023026, -0.05389033630490303, -0.025333814322948456, -0.03913218528032303, -0.007749477867037058, 0.007530517876148224, 0.006534786894917488, -0.017417751252651215, -0.023920899257063866, 0.06267929077148438, 0.03093886189162731, 0.005361932795494795, -0.06641233712434769, 0.005113808438181877, -0.015894543379545212, -0.004523150157183409, -0.02417953684926033, 0.04344005882740021, -0.004644386935979128, -0.02746482565999031, 0.09017740935087204, -0.047057218849658966, 0.004571553785353899, 0.00994631927460432, 0.006197958253324032, 0.007857627235352993, 0.010688334703445435, -0.01287890039384365, 0.02279561385512352, 0.025082917883992195, 0.058544449508190155, 0.038723092526197433, -0.006562568247318268, -0.024884553626179695, 0.03651006519794464, -0.0018347096629440784, 0.02991304360330105, 0.005497449077665806, -0.023900922387838364, 0.004230703692883253, 0.06184446066617966, 0.03525437414646149, -0.008587092161178589, -0.011182059533894062, 0.03617576137185097, 0.08555962145328522, -0.010467483662068844, 0.0478128045797348, -0.05835617333650589, -0.0739896297454834, -0.017659613862633705, 0.0405125617980957, -0.0038924156688153744, -0.018548142164945602, -0.0058530718088150024, 0.02708389051258564, 0.0025746943429112434, -0.002988539868965745, -0.022218964993953705, 0.004357052035629749, -0.037232618778944016, -0.019420461729168892, 0.07085796445608139, 0.043973445892333984, -0.030218373984098434, -0.026773296296596527, 0.009913033805787563, -0.08437468111515045, -0.030502596870064735, 0.04232073202729225, 0.02867642603814602, 0.037435904145240784, -0.03478972613811493, -0.005151780787855387, -0.029309669509530067, -0.031249646097421646, -0.002975093200802803, -0.013328060507774353, -0.05015655234456062, -0.027663471177220345, -0.02118317410349846, 0.05622097849845886, 0.009768811985850334, -0.055524252355098724, 0.00838769506663084, -0.04438991844654083, -0.028395967558026314, -0.0017372568836435676, -0.009436753578484058, -0.04607900604605675, -0.06256528198719025, 0.05334470421075821, -0.03101509064435959, -0.07378742098808289, -0.017552467063069344, -0.006807395722717047, -0.03474939987063408, -0.0014074885984882712, -0.009008839726448059, -0.0023500348906964064, 0.034285929054021835, 0.031170951202511787, -0.02489371970295906, 0.021770881488919258, 0.0031596675980836153, 0.03452867269515991, -0.02673555351793766, 0.008562115021049976, -0.0293464083224535, 0.011337287724018097, 0.08030354976654053, -0.05000363662838936, 0.03670177981257439, 0.005836799740791321, -0.021398739889264107, 0.010621740482747555, 0.02829671837389469, -0.010782087221741676, -0.021816646680235863, 0.021894371137022972, -0.004284953232854605, 0.04702651500701904, 0.023011470213532448, 0.057909637689590454, 0.08516454696655273, 0.041064269840717316, -0.009054560214281082, -0.05851001664996147, 0.008714784868061543, 0.0060687377117574215, -0.0005634044064208865, 0.010525475256145, 0.03245053067803383, -0.019644269719719887, -0.026408327743411064, -0.01799120008945465, 0.05844777077436447, 0.029432885348796844, -0.06101782247424126, 0.040390290319919586, -0.04786331579089165, -0.01753883622586727, 0.016600532457232475, -0.059156980365514755, 0.02554364874958992, 0.009492382407188416, -0.01100150402635336, 0.0046636550687253475, 0.009996202774345875, 0.021451475098729134, 0.06169537827372551, -0.03188609331846237, 0.004380856174975634, -0.02149641513824463, 0.05138416960835457, 0.011479586362838745, 0.04735593497753143, -0.023346880450844765, -0.03343743458390236, 0.0027780295349657536, 0.010076464153826237, 0.027965711429715157, 0.03345504030585289, 0.023538732901215553, 0.02777198702096939, -0.02118316851556301, -0.03189069405198097, 0.0679178535938263, 0.03240976110100746, 0.07427015900611877, -0.021769298240542412, -0.00672540720552206, 0.012338623404502869, 0.05018167197704315, 0.011444002389907837, -0.03438665717840195, -0.03795691207051277, -0.0368594154715538, -0.0018041784642264247, 0.008768814615905285, -0.046460073441267014, 0.0003372824576217681, -0.023933669552206993, -0.052228402346372604, 0.07443764060735703, -0.0049826172180473804, -0.028308499604463577, 0.04098920524120331, -0.04911714419722557, -0.019176939502358437, -0.009825296700000763, -0.004231485538184643, -0.01624583639204502, -0.044385213404893875, 0.08449304103851318, -0.03788061812520027, -0.02309623546898365, 0.0001789095695130527, -0.000043082847696496174, 0.0035550217144191265, 0.03372281789779663, 0.07746747881174088, -0.015682026743888855, -0.04111587628722191, 0.04293990880250931, 0.008012799546122551, 0.013720753602683544, 0.00803390983492136, 0.053621817380189896, 0.01637357473373413, 0.009906223975121975, 0.07021079212427139, 0.055783674120903015, -0.04684411361813545, -0.034650836139917374, -0.005870192311704159, 0.015345221385359764, -0.024803895503282547, 0.014625847339630127, 0.027260297909379005, -0.02560701034963131, 0.008160293102264404, -0.009471400640904903, -0.006051633041352034, 0.08703697472810745, 0.021774837747216225, 0.008517754264175892, 0.016952306032180786, -0.045265283435583115, 0.01290416531264782, -0.011259399354457855, -0.02421402558684349, 0.08282213658094406, 0.010987242683768272, -0.025734517723321915, -0.0059169079177081585, -0.014721645973622799, -0.00036516410182230175, -0.016696419566869736, -0.012942170724272728, -0.06562334299087524, 0.08996765315532684, 0.052436113357543945, -0.028311440721154213, -0.000029695576813537627, 0.03831839561462402, 0.03409900143742561, -0.04680408537387848, 0.02630757912993431, 0.00665908632799983, -0.060127850621938705, -0.01940026506781578, -0.019760744646191597, 0.05720751732587814, 0.013823372311890125, 0.006622284650802612, -0.03379489853978157, 0.03616594895720482, -0.0654618889093399, 0.008041351102292538, 0.0032512180041521788, 0.006630284246057272, 0.023843012750148773, -0.014733699150383472, 0.050400327891111374, 0.012011513113975525, -0.033139485865831375, -0.07128870487213135, 0.006944774184376001, -0.015325489453971386, -0.02313755825161934, -0.05300959572196007, -0.008680992759764194, -0.007450656965374947, -0.0006957361474633217, -0.0036417371593415737, -0.057060398161411285, -0.003951663617044687, 0.014239217154681683, 0.07139845192432404, -0.01746695674955845, 0.022047752514481544, 0.016294127330183983, -0.0026842495426535606, 0.0817917063832283, -0.03416602313518524, -0.0636913999915123, -0.037258461117744446, -0.023054201155900955, 0.006198059767484665, 0.09545207768678665, 0.002860957058146596, -0.02260073460638523, -0.015302994288504124, 0.00045675941510125995, -0.018349505960941315, 0.05422351509332657, -0.01318064983934164, -0.0085686594247818, 0.032883454114198685, 0.001217301469296217, 0.029937738552689552, -0.03286725655198097, 0.06772115081548691, -0.0006429717759601772, -0.025992190465331078, -0.012728394009172916, -0.0207439586520195, 0.017142748460173607, 0.04230447858572006, 0.028617963194847107, -0.01557141076773405, -0.029059793800115585, 0.003301995573565364, -0.009986535646021366, 0.02605287916958332, -0.0011957015376538038, -0.06730949878692627, 0.00951854046434164, -0.00888113398104906, -0.050049711018800735, 0.05623694136738777, -0.0842285230755806, -0.061943475157022476, -0.030505454167723656, 0.04321279376745224, -0.05373355746269226, 0.009843449108302593, -0.09162484109401703, -0.015431887470185757, 0.023577699437737465, -0.026789721101522446, -0.04122712463140488, -0.0447959341108799, 0.0009888408239930868, -0.01640165224671364, -0.03225744888186455, -0.051585305482149124, -0.0016602867981418967, -0.004343980457633734, -0.03642492741346359, 0.04150846600532532, 0.0218949131667614, -0.016872547566890717, 0.05706338956952095, -0.03504204377532005, 0.010523613542318344, 0.0061189960688352585, -0.050883252173662186, -0.028844375163316727, -0.024916689842939377, 0.006282629445195198, 0.06474380195140839, 0.024207592010498047, 0.004686375614255667, -0.06946706026792526, 0.012466917745769024, -0.05015275254845619, 0.011687356978654861, -0.003917229827493429, 0.027675339952111244, 0.009406600147485733, -0.02595057338476181, -0.009162411093711853, -0.015065011568367481, -0.021302498877048492, 0.0014615744585171342 ]
<p>Is there a general way to calculate the magnetic field for a time dependent current of a long thing wire?</p> <p>For ex:</p> <p>If the current is</p> <p>$$ I(t)=I\sin wt, $$ is there a general method to use in order to calculate the magnetic field? </p> <p>I know for time-independent currents we can use $$ \int \vec B\cdot d\vec l=\mu_0 I_{enc} $$ if the symmetry of the system is nice, or we can use Biot-Savart Law for other cases. Thanks...</p>
g9771
[ 0.004464836325496435, 0.028595251962542534, -0.012427805922925472, -0.05915176868438721, -0.005878808442503214, -0.0043392423540353775, 0.012155110016465187, 0.008605320006608963, -0.06913968175649643, 0.037293363362550735, -0.04555419459939003, 0.03898639231920242, -0.01559205912053585, 0.002650314709171653, -0.019781112670898438, -0.031602781265974045, 0.03598162904381752, -0.003756661666557193, 0.05589362233877182, -0.012337565422058105, 0.033391281962394714, 0.017457781359553337, 0.0184230525046587, -0.008387680165469646, 0.024130798876285553, -0.0071276165544986725, 0.0306992270052433, 0.03397306799888611, -0.00026062229881063104, -0.06771869957447052, -0.03746497631072998, 0.002220266032963991, 0.04656745865941048, 0.01027807965874672, -0.03687569871544838, -0.026227720081806183, -0.009983877651393414, 0.00897823553532362, 0.09731633961200714, 0.004865147173404694, -0.000847883871756494, 0.04678342491388321, 0.03181026875972748, 0.04105842486023903, -0.012688851915299892, -0.029344340786337852, -0.06313005834817886, -0.033954255282878876, -0.09039706736803055, 0.01038807351142168, -0.007626117207109928, -0.014650865457952023, 0.05278772488236427, -0.03359569236636162, -0.041090600192546844, -0.051014646887779236, 0.05004246532917023, -0.05272569879889488, -0.04629156365990639, 0.011010109446942806, 0.0013335606781765819, -0.0023475990165024996, -0.009208938106894493, 0.010600799694657326, 0.0062373727560043335, -0.057539861649274826, -0.015746276825666428, -0.014251496642827988, -0.013367726467549801, 0.0358211025595665, 0.018120942637324333, -0.02637498825788498, -0.00524916360154748, -0.0025458468589931726, -0.040068358182907104, 0.06675096601247787, 0.04657934978604317, 0.04707270860671997, 0.020213991403579712, 0.006362763699144125, -0.02273520827293396, -0.00015593291027471423, -0.025448763743042946, 0.027855750173330307, -0.016600245609879494, -0.029954416677355766, 0.04568907245993614, 0.037869643419981, 0.03229844197630882, 0.02143947221338749, 0.01196837704628706, 0.005967516452074051, 0.02874184027314186, -0.0012673117453232408, 0.005421893671154976, -0.021247534081339836, 0.040997449308633804, 0.02390340156853199, 0.0013341914163902402, 0.04756719991564751, 0.0029214173555374146, 0.01190584059804678, -0.049700018018484116, 0.01531350426375866, -0.004145363811403513, -0.0041260505095124245, 0.04755661264061928, -0.036329638212919235, -0.010965624824166298, -0.010087055154144764, -0.0119080301374197, -0.05401632562279701, -0.033926885575056076, 0.07360062748193741, -0.059122782200574875, -0.004647518508136272, -0.007834327407181263, -0.04298833757638931, -0.018753858283162117, -0.0022813156247138977, 0.011461013928055763, -0.0035769003443419933, -0.009695680812001228, 0.07588786631822586, -0.029007576406002045, 0.023761605843901634, -0.06305120885372162, 0.03671017661690712, 0.05134347453713417, -0.009148848243057728, 0.0434119813144207, -0.01718967594206333, 0.03920703008770943, 0.01967804506421089, -0.028312893584370613, 0.020729832351207733, -0.024427268654108047, 0.02377476915717125, -0.034757450222969055, 0.007503353524953127, -0.024928532540798187, -0.0907827839255333, 0.013674755580723286, -0.014231301844120026, -0.033247776329517365, 0.06723640859127045, -0.0200351569801569, -0.09117541462182999, 0.029312454164028168, 0.030606165528297424, 0.016012750566005707, 0.0772068127989769, -0.030430512502789497, 0.0016082079382613301, 0.012504411861300468, 0.00855942815542221, 0.008508838713169098, -0.051521044224500656, 0.03433269262313843, -0.020572854205965996, -0.02640778198838234, 0.0004469953419174999, -0.00171519978903234, -0.013068006373941898, -0.04788542166352272, 0.002327194670215249, 0.03419242799282074, 0.00007383989577647299, -0.03539232909679413, -0.0726689025759697, -0.04513123258948326, 0.007876396179199219, 0.025655193254351616, 0.014410561881959438, -0.02316698618233204, 0.016916349530220032, -0.0459166020154953, 0.003564623184502125, 0.008502453565597534, -0.0267518050968647, -0.02576483227312565, 0.0075263152830302715, 0.035433877259492874, 0.005581930745393038, -0.05272594839334488, 0.01850724034011364, -0.031126150861382484, 0.014850986190140247, -0.0619853176176548, -0.018239730969071388, -0.05484872683882713, 0.04727303981781006, 0.006802551448345184, 0.012106411159038544, -0.04360036924481392, 0.004988655913621187, 0.016582410782575607, 0.0025365056935697794, -0.03751731663942337, -0.005770788062363863, -0.015033292584121227, 0.0916639119386673, 0.050577323883771896, 0.036925069987773895, 0.006013453006744385, -0.010014255531132221, -0.009725258685648441, -0.001095419516786933, 0.051834139972925186, 0.009088543243706226, 0.09051697701215744, 0.03788823261857033, -0.0370461642742157, -0.006605030037462711, -0.0486268512904644, -0.030240671709179878, -0.08129391819238663, -0.0011214010883122683, -0.023941460996866226, -0.010388651862740517, 0.0463431254029274, -0.03061569295823574, 0.08129757642745972, 0.03176715224981308, -0.08015922456979752, 0.005271482281386852, 0.007846850901842117, 0.005205272696912289, 0.009314191527664661, -0.03941973298788071, -0.001959084765985608, 0.02369583770632744, -0.07814442366361618, 0.007550079375505447, 0.016959812492132187, 0.07531248778104782, 0.0267370343208313, -0.04232271760702133, 0.010227104648947716, 0.049726326018571854, 0.0011023712577298284, -0.000533714541234076, 0.04994388669729233, -0.019584806635975838, -0.012958281673491001, -0.05826238542795181, 0.07268346846103668, 0.06932362914085388, -0.026724964380264282, -0.02637391723692417, -0.0028235535137355328, -0.037967514246702194, 0.009410702623426914, 0.0094853974878788, -0.009143649600446224, -0.012082207947969437, 0.03396925702691078, 0.08499540388584137, -0.03945203125476837, -0.05204501003026962, -0.005391818471252918, -0.055296290665864944, 0.005867054685950279, 0.06452380865812302, 0.04405667632818222, -0.002675811294466257, -0.023724209517240524, -0.044498927891254425, 0.04748831316828728, 0.018068255856633186, -0.008988690562546253, 0.051698796451091766, -0.0123627670109272, -0.01233481615781784, 0.02125430479645729, -0.06534814089536667, 0.019615737721323967, 0.03674733638763428, 0.0011990468483418226, -0.01567561738193035, 0.025487935170531273, -0.0025723555590957403, 0.00459682010114193, 0.009050884284079075, 0.014270828105509281, -0.05202800780534744, -0.014691132120788097, -0.050100915133953094, 0.024357443675398827, 0.02547028847038746, 0.00039967542397789657, -0.02059791423380375, 0.0017893563490360975, -0.015362909995019436, -0.0506804920732975, -0.017096659168601036, -0.007886812090873718, -0.029093001037836075, -0.02721422351896763, 0.03921608254313469, 0.007692463230341673, 0.000040030383388511837, 0.004386452026665211, 0.04124948009848595, -0.0031607826240360737, -0.015525887720286846, 0.01096384972333908, -0.11056054383516312, 0.047075849026441574, -0.048467449843883514, -0.007921857759356499, 0.04622865840792656, 0.04798039421439171, -0.0503561906516552, -0.01137760654091835, 0.004343044012784958, 0.02140848897397518, -0.02553016133606434, 0.04441297426819801, -0.0000058719870139611885, -0.021528443321585655, -0.07196216285228729, 0.015539832413196564, -0.008051392622292042, -0.01573382318019867, -0.013382311910390854, 0.027114050462841988, -0.02228805609047413, -0.04761923849582672, 0.017774414271116257, -0.029560476541519165, -0.018718203529715538, 0.015115924179553986, 0.0027465594466775656, -0.04328225180506706, -0.045848000794649124, 0.04221236705780029, -0.006613347213715315, -0.07566995918750763, 0.018529770895838737, -0.04148762673139572, -0.04885690659284592, -0.07390689104795456, 0.013153808191418648, -0.0035580149851739407, -0.006365039851516485, 0.009206620045006275, 0.03474703058600426, 0.04633435234427452, -0.024077173322439194, 0.03359494358301163, 0.03715851157903671, 0.027898378670215607, 0.020953062921762466, -0.01839982345700264, 0.03425927460193634, -0.002048990922048688, 0.06314538419246674, -0.035993944853544235, 0.017047474160790443, -0.029456201940774918, -0.03233925998210907, 0.02529664896428585, 0.05316901206970215, 0.007604716811329126, 0.016679415479302406, 0.034900836646556854, 0.016922567039728165, 0.04114595055580139, -0.07630724459886551, 0.024511924013495445, 0.03782885894179344, 0.045550160109996796, -0.08901258558034897, -0.019309790804982185, -0.003922886680811644, 0.024860545992851257, -0.02236340008676052, -0.05400829389691353, 0.01979842036962509, 0.02424069121479988, 0.005010707303881645, -0.025154270231723785, 0.04423333704471588, 0.04185423254966736, -0.018866246566176414, -0.01993897184729576, 0.0679953321814537, -0.03388116508722305, -0.0027317346539348364, 0.04103684797883034, -0.03335433825850487, 0.012822150252759457, -0.035926442593336105, -0.02155020833015442, -0.009868948720395565, 0.03743874281644821, 0.005240228027105331, 0.02251744270324707, -0.0785829946398735, 0.07521601021289825, -0.026453042402863503, 0.0629412904381752, 0.007149470038712025, 0.03290506824851036, 0.038319092243909836, -0.006182270124554634, -0.04606371000409126, 0.04926211014389992, 0.034940317273139954, -0.057299185544252396, -0.026681557297706604, 0.013797127641737461, -0.0032642302103340626, 0.035209257155656815, -0.028542567044496536, 0.06160132959485054, -0.016437917947769165, -0.004018597304821014, 0.0006457859999500215, -0.015466463752090931, -0.03376159071922302, -0.0024047791957855225, -0.03902960568666458, -0.06237320974469185, 0.04437893629074097, 0.03302016854286194, -0.03702447563409805, 0.008370435796678066, -0.04151978716254234, -0.0004676438111346215, 0.06847009807825089, -0.05527855083346367, -0.035979826003313065, -0.10393010824918747, 0.025705361738801003, -0.02136865444481373, 0.015370442532002926, 0.005449001211673021, 0.04152293503284454, 0.04506302997469902, 0.008839612826704979, 0.08748160302639008, -0.020937180146574974, -0.0025091960560530424, 0.025422804057598114, -0.06980956345796585, -0.02459724433720112, 0.0014846997801214457, -0.02011721208691597, -0.02259884960949421, 0.03164852410554886, -0.026851432397961617, 0.007903200574219227, -0.019636867567896843, 0.02611672878265381, 0.01580875739455223, 0.03136651962995529, 0.04598087817430496, 0.03893284127116203, -0.08255668729543686, -0.026410529389977455, -0.05781359225511551, 0.025507142767310143, -0.015211321413516998, 0.038804084062576294, 0.011441566050052643, -0.03279144689440727, -0.040962912142276764, 0.03299599513411522, 0.016103655099868774, 0.04286414384841919, 0.008192172273993492, -0.041846178472042084, 0.0029545908328145742, 0.023593002930283546, -0.033207256346940994, -0.020624525845050812, -0.012810169719159603, -0.0006438883137889206, -0.00994197092950344, -0.05959818884730339, -0.045257098972797394, 0.041172340512275696, 0.016265062615275383, 0.00041710655204951763, 0.04430271312594414, 0.041629891842603683, -0.018623020499944687, -0.07741814106702805, -0.014426994137465954, 0.08414614945650101, 0.052995745092630386, -0.01679731160402298, -0.01918213814496994, -0.01951194554567337, 0.0012910906225442886, 0.019866105169057846, -0.0653362050652504, -0.015844102948904037, -0.03692474216222763, 0.0016145327826961875, -0.0888851135969162, 0.016162116080522537, -0.035307250916957855, 0.05547730624675751, -0.0010450376430526376, -0.004540355410426855, -0.039485055953264236, 0.007088125683367252, 0.04510421305894852, 0.03388919681310654, -0.016270089894533157, 0.04420009255409241, 0.03646278753876686, 0.021431105211377144, -0.04486289620399475, -0.00003235585609218106, 0.028931258246302605, -0.02026781253516674, 0.0024589854292571545, 0.008657217025756836, -0.0000596223799220752, -0.043319448828697205, 0.017983168363571167, 0.012566066347062588, -0.11559166014194489, -0.06047298014163971, 0.008313296362757683, -0.06395955383777618, -0.004578628111630678, -0.021472949534654617, -0.0024929430801421404, -0.020680978894233704, 0.055290587246418, 0.016752542927861214, 0.03049522638320923, -0.07472837716341019, -0.04645814001560211, 0.046585846692323685, 0.004107498098164797, -0.009873784147202969, 0.011317254044115543, -0.009062367491424084, -0.02719077281653881, -0.04567612335085869, 0.024466900154948235, -0.028680993244051933, 0.013965481892228127, -0.020460525527596474, -0.06827937811613083, 0.016591764986515045, 0.04176422581076622, 0.02588289976119995, 0.03421655669808388, -0.0010541352676227689, -0.011212958954274654, -0.01188019197434187, -0.01425339374691248, 0.021109431982040405, 0.04714636504650116, -0.013671237975358963, -0.032148707658052444, -0.058103758841753006, -0.0043077412992715836, 0.00755606172606349, -0.0033599555026739836, 0.013101265765726566, 0.06287167221307755, 0.061299681663513184, 0.02688354067504406, 0.006792038679122925, -0.028836732730269432, -0.03352557495236397, 0.034062955528497696, 0.039870936423540115, -0.019275112077593803, -0.03631105646491051, 0.017193904146552086, 0.008089550770819187, -0.017674986273050308, 0.02485465258359909, 0.02671954594552517, -0.06332588940858841, 0.0005502568674273789, 0.015301017090678215, -0.04804675281047821, -0.052821625024080276, 0.023701854050159454, 0.037138164043426514, -0.0025536371394991875, 0.034241482615470886, 0.000917876313906163, -0.010664466768503189, 0.04786716029047966, 0.006360598374158144, -0.060569487512111664, -0.010919196531176567, 0.04412161186337471, 0.05346807837486267, -0.0007300262805074453, 0.022582802921533585, 0.02692839689552784, -0.018240245059132576, 0.06268814206123352, 0.04032864421606064, -0.02604128234088421, 0.040574751794338226, -0.021512651816010475, -0.01513989083468914, 0.07692211866378784, -0.04187558963894844, -0.04627507925033569, 0.00721328379586339, 0.05779659375548363, 0.023582061752676964, -0.010455646552145481, -0.004112171940505505, -0.023800333961844444, 0.0725209042429924, -0.03187568113207817, -0.025151327252388, -0.06304946541786194, -0.0006188178085722029, -0.0036055538803339005, 0.06307603418827057, -0.03882751241326332, -0.02147204428911209, -0.03310167416930199, -0.0326850526034832, 0.030794834718108177, 0.005971388425678015, -0.02223614789545536, -0.028816254809498787, 0.034562405198812485, 0.05017993971705437, 0.06114900857210159, 0.013109087012708187, 0.023173687979578972, 0.08880399912595749, -0.012478628195822239, 0.04245429113507271, 0.005346427205950022, -0.0008056170190684497, -0.012472482398152351, -0.04089602082967758, -0.019372619688510895, 0.08595363795757294, -0.035671960562467575, 0.03676144406199455, 0.04300358518958092, -0.006454953923821449, 0.013340596109628677, 0.03125184029340744, 0.0023576244711875916, -0.04786807671189308, 0.020261358469724655, 0.0056597283110022545, 0.0034313062205910683, 0.01257349643856287, -0.0014062323607504368, -0.028707308694720268, -0.017396526411175728, -0.05212190002202988, 0.05848231539130211, 0.07670707255601883, 0.03585923835635185, -0.04904182255268097, 0.05142698436975479, -0.020393988117575645, -0.04670897126197815, -0.057337258011102676, 0.02226780727505684, 0.019873475655913353, 0.015070159919559956, -0.028636440634727478, -0.009903410449624062, -0.005212516523897648, -0.04467255249619484, 0.011377476155757904, -0.01784680038690567, 0.013994899578392506, -0.028849532827734947, -0.052511051297187805, -0.0011054289061576128, 0.03630431368947029, -0.018969731405377388, -0.00773634621873498, 0.0020953828934580088, 0.034455977380275726, -0.03761664032936096, 0.02792242169380188, 0.03144561126828194, -0.026061857119202614, -0.0005186359630897641, 0.015186645090579987, 0.04120442643761635, -0.0003642690717242658, 0.051747072488069534, 0.04298638552427292, 0.05208646133542061, 0.0023801703937351704, 0.00021342920081224293, -0.0063344258815050125, 0.018525652587413788, -0.05373745411634445, -0.08852679282426834, -0.0005506130401045084, -0.031070426106452942, 0.057910092175006866, -0.009531990624964237, 0.08202750235795975, -0.009643196128308773, 0.001525426865555346, 0.01092286966741085, 0.02069661393761635, -0.045181144028902054, -0.007455835584551096, 0.007361383643001318, 0.03154560923576355, -0.028565453365445137, -0.029997333884239197, 0.018022242933511734, -0.008247490040957928, 0.03092324361205101, 0.015802830457687378, -0.014289196580648422, -0.018956070765852928, 0.013753341510891914, 0.0058085438795387745, -0.013280044309794903, -0.02077690325677395, -0.00789472833275795, -0.006115122232586145, 0.025386516004800797, 0.007543574552983046, -0.010033379308879375, -0.06794778257608414, 0.011164137162268162, 0.024746207520365715, 0.08858557045459747, 0.00631863484159112, -0.04480968415737152, -0.005029237829148769, -0.006068000104278326, 0.07904736697673798, -0.05323098599910736, 0.006656200625002384, 0.041129834949970245, 0.008767983876168728, 0.0529949925839901, 0.005520749371498823, -0.041193269193172455, -0.04811999201774597, -0.008169790729880333, -0.018423572182655334, -0.0510798841714859, 0.03564683720469475, 0.005991705693304539, 0.09248213469982147, -0.03923044726252556, -0.010370074771344662, -0.020039260387420654, 0.059659816324710846, 0.029840834438800812, -0.009989396668970585, -0.018687503412365913, 0.002328369300812483 ]
<p>I believe earth-based detectors measure mainly solar neutrinos, which have energies on the MeV scale of nuclear physics, are directed from the sun, and have flavors determined by the sun's nuclear reactions plus neutrino oscillations. In addition to this, I recently learned from a physics.SE answer that the universe contains neutrinos that are thermalized with respect to the 3 K background temperature of the universe. I assume these latter can't be detected with present technology...?</p> <p>What is our best present knowledge of the universe's population of neutrinos? Energy spectrum? Flavors? Directions of motion? (Are they isotropic?) Spatial distribution? Are there antineutrinos in the mix? Is the neutrino contribution to the cosmological stress-energy tensor primarily from one component of this population?</p>
g9772
[ -0.002029290422797203, 0.01409292034804821, 0.004525986034423113, 0.008787906728684902, 0.024150380864739418, 0.03512319549918175, -0.026410359889268875, 0.030979527160525322, -0.0022708866745233536, -0.055604562163352966, 0.03506092727184296, 0.026553526520729065, 0.04546329751610756, 0.03297830745577812, 0.000499052694067359, -0.01404276117682457, 0.013559501618146896, -0.003094462910667062, 0.08228771388530731, 0.025542614981532097, 0.050070229917764664, 0.008431272581219673, 0.04719152674078941, -0.041522614657878876, -0.03061634674668312, 0.016014426946640015, 0.009415303356945515, -0.0023691195528954268, -0.025194019079208374, -0.020333580672740936, 0.051349785178899765, -0.055447086691856384, 0.06770009547472, -0.02024860680103302, -0.029908999800682068, 0.006317310035228729, 0.01864238642156124, -0.015794161707162857, 0.02045101299881935, -0.03944513201713562, -0.024204323068261147, -0.006153957452625036, -0.01982758566737175, -0.027949417009949684, 0.04940590262413025, 0.026203574612736702, -0.05067098140716553, 0.0035496035125106573, 0.04168156161904335, -0.017460692673921585, -0.003889247542247176, -0.05780385062098503, 0.00451392587274313, 0.06610237807035446, 0.06040894240140915, -0.053171902894973755, -0.025387592613697052, -0.022795937955379486, 0.06612160801887512, -0.026727383956313133, 0.053704410791397095, -0.017465366050601006, -0.03552788868546486, -0.01381799764931202, 0.0024492631200701, -0.01460148487240076, -0.050433702766895294, 0.0604388602077961, 0.016598599031567574, 0.03971085324883461, 0.05019989237189293, -0.012399250641465187, 0.021378494799137115, 0.052919767796993256, 0.046498704701662064, -0.027318822219967842, -0.008570278994739056, -0.0134193804115057, -0.005979916080832481, -0.0016322156880050898, 0.033681098371744156, -0.03174908459186554, -0.000624499109108001, -0.05211436003446579, 0.06452319771051407, -0.10530268400907516, -0.010173185728490353, 0.0663524866104126, 0.00268274056725204, 0.027907051146030426, 0.006955673918128014, -0.0012857854599133134, 0.0861344188451767, -0.03908355534076691, 0.04225657135248184, 0.038589201867580414, 0.0027985579799860716, 0.02950127422809601, -0.021455947309732437, -0.0323227159678936, -0.03190630301833153, 0.039163559675216675, 0.010447802022099495, -0.022333400323987007, 0.04862690716981888, 0.014800388365983963, 0.02149638906121254, -0.018811631947755814, -0.03928670659661293, -0.03421524912118912, -0.02981172502040863, -0.032814159989356995, 0.008533801883459091, 0.07625046372413635, -0.06549900025129318, -0.017903782427310944, -0.008440645411610603, -0.03618448227643967, 0.010742243379354477, 0.08712614327669144, 0.009106703102588654, 0.056520022451877594, -0.04252445325255394, 0.055098164826631546, -0.07283579558134079, -0.030561020597815514, 0.013261043466627598, -0.01363467238843441, -0.027768662199378014, 0.010210508480668068, 0.02034587599337101, -0.024809284135699272, -0.018198145553469658, -0.02980056405067444, 0.04185139015316963, 0.02267223224043846, 0.03553605452179909, 0.04841604083776474, -0.009727760218083858, 0.02009233832359314, 0.03212132304906845, -0.013504687696695328, 0.015154804103076458, 0.021736331284046173, 0.013289114460349083, -0.010110250674188137, -0.03544957563281059, -0.0004977788194082677, 0.007839355617761612, 0.012102128937840462, 0.004449643660336733, 0.05192102864384651, -0.03682134300470352, -0.06735815852880478, 0.00855498481541872, -0.039029158651828766, -0.0629105195403099, -0.023913780227303505, -0.005609420593827963, -0.009093568660318851, 0.030860859900712967, -0.04931296035647392, -0.004458534996956587, 0.031402893364429474, 0.06489044427871704, -0.003456335049122572, -0.004061112646013498, -0.019753500819206238, 0.054993513971567154, 0.034146394580602646, -0.08946408331394196, 0.009567868895828724, -0.05933458358049393, -0.02011881023645401, -0.03590208664536476, 0.0417470745742321, 0.028954772278666496, -0.01784173585474491, 0.014050809666514397, 0.04711661860346794, -0.05201183259487152, -0.01289469376206398, 0.04755061864852905, 0.02928653173148632, 0.023755334317684174, -0.06103784963488579, -0.0328899584710598, 0.01394742913544178, 0.07751282304525375, 0.03475626930594444, -0.002632247982546687, -0.011084182187914848, 0.005377260968089104, 0.027951067313551903, 0.024183364585042, -0.021199164912104607, -0.03503614664077759, -0.03669431060552597, -0.0036032777279615402, -0.021533148363232613, 0.010437967255711555, -0.00638038944453001, 0.034470852464437485, 0.033581484109163284, -0.026687603443861008, 0.005803804844617844, 0.04734422266483307, 0.017528682947158813, 0.01682514138519764, 0.00004153601184953004, 0.04260028898715973, -0.056567296385765076, 0.05262916162610054, -0.01252142433077097, -0.04565345123410225, 0.008518913760781288, -0.008095425553619862, -0.022764811292290688, 0.020529305562376976, -0.00967853982001543, -0.053119905292987823, 0.03985729441046715, 0.03988857939839363, -0.020925136283040047, -0.012450669892132282, 0.05655844509601593, -0.05412905663251877, -0.005083833821117878, 0.04476722329854965, 0.03485574945807457, -0.10243835300207138, 0.05892173573374748, 0.0457458458840847, 0.027512872591614723, 0.007893349975347519, 0.036106549203395844, -0.006383699364960194, 0.002764183096587658, 0.007397440727800131, 0.010435925796627998, -0.057118553668260574, -0.022962559014558792, -0.0209280364215374, 0.10314759612083435, 0.06967829167842865, -0.053725503385066986, 0.026949556544423103, 0.028383776545524597, -0.07183735817670822, 0.023867134004831314, 0.02784583903849125, -0.019036127254366875, 0.01182719599455595, 0.03903849422931671, 0.01853339560329914, 0.035282883793115616, 0.0047155399806797504, 0.0191951896995306, -0.04485177993774414, -0.044794194400310516, 0.04800097644329071, -0.08411450684070587, -0.010521911084651947, 0.007972804829478264, 0.08564354479312897, -0.01918862573802471, -0.036534905433654785, 0.028865087777376175, -0.03607707843184471, -0.018048027530312538, -0.03700251132249832, 0.032919395714998245, 0.003603563643991947, -0.004368675872683525, 0.036832988262176514, -0.013835358433425426, 0.021801386028528214, -0.0008936550584621727, 0.015589874237775803, -0.007724008057266474, 0.019336672499775887, 0.03094850480556488, -0.01400778442621231, -0.0616404190659523, 0.007460870314389467, -0.012234702706336975, -0.05424322560429573, -0.04156908020377159, 0.03694672882556915, -0.020569533109664917, 0.07001377642154694, -0.05776376649737358, 0.03513680025935173, -0.011437398381531239, -0.00010477352770976722, -0.06499143689870834, 0.001153579680249095, 0.022384393960237503, -0.010655914433300495, 0.024323424324393272, 0.014604348689317703, -0.0630202367901802, 0.027162209153175354, -0.07828960567712784, -0.02657160349190235, -0.021955205127596855, -0.013761199079453945, -0.021018782630562782, 0.03069469891488552, -0.03675277903676033, -0.07685420662164688, 0.03077640011906624, 0.002637183293700218, 0.05278491973876953, -0.007958640344440937, -0.004674735479056835, -0.03478308767080307, 0.05021396651864052, 0.022693360224366188, -0.0742415115237236, 0.04542382434010506, -0.04558722674846649, 0.017426304519176483, 0.037447184324264526, 0.03145409747958183, 0.034926481544971466, 0.009621171280741692, 0.02039242908358574, -0.03403029963374138, -0.01722809299826622, 0.02480689063668251, -0.012690020725131035, -0.027571676298975945, 0.0431787483394146, -0.060836538672447205, 0.07273691892623901, -0.018844615668058395, -0.01753011718392372, 0.07694108784198761, 0.03892770782113075, -0.05014919862151146, 0.0009115093853324652, -0.004168355371803045, -0.01338693406432867, 0.006198695860803127, -0.01146863866597414, -0.023015180602669716, 0.006554488558322191, 0.011782257817685604, -0.010920872911810875, 0.05239966884255409, 0.01909426972270012, -0.00825200229883194, -0.05006639286875725, -0.027991365641355515, 0.02535426989197731, -0.03051287680864334, -0.039119601249694824, 0.03069775551557541, -0.005790802650153637, -0.02951996773481369, 0.003890827763825655, 0.033746346831321716, -0.02354319393634796, -0.024631915614008904, -0.06698372215032578, 0.02251020446419716, -0.022481370717287064, -0.015214093960821629, -0.0026812413707375526, -0.04300372302532196, -0.039151567965745926, -0.054412830621004105, -0.06452257931232452, 0.023590410128235817, 0.024453891441226006, -0.019640618935227394, 0.016432994976639748, 0.010380837135016918, 0.06303997337818146, -0.01260099932551384, -0.008233443833887577, 0.036390285938978195, -0.06371327489614487, 0.028379321098327637, 0.03541714325547218, -0.051099177449941635, -0.05178625509142876, -0.01892322301864624, -0.026620391756296158, -0.015896854922175407, -0.06382027268409729, 0.0013189237797632813, 0.002255392028018832, -0.0019459708128124475, -0.10393781960010529, 0.013123011216521263, 0.0421011708676815, 0.01499953679740429, 0.050494030117988586, -0.0012675935868173838, -0.06250020116567612, 0.05049940571188927, -0.05918075144290924, 0.02060379646718502, 0.0465538427233696, -0.04339256510138512, -0.02997266873717308, -0.05350762978196144, -0.03295230120420456, 0.021785788238048553, 0.04114653542637825, -0.029821062460541725, -0.04892999678850174, 0.03485838696360588, -0.06306221336126328, 0.017240284010767937, -0.06415964663028717, 0.002458152361214161, 0.002969253808259964, 0.02560812421143055, -0.010607031174004078, -0.014449259266257286, -0.0031384730245918036, -0.047585535794496536, 0.059512145817279816, 0.04871467128396034, 0.00024172350822482258, -0.04119899123907089, 0.03632543981075287, 0.03319581598043442, -0.02265569567680359, 0.03638771176338196, 0.04646863415837288, 0.048014480620622635, 0.011286214925348759, 0.005612020380795002, 0.009867675602436066, -0.013722922652959824, 0.022343667224049568, 0.04634125158190727, -0.02028544619679451, -0.006854343693703413, -0.013925299048423767, -0.07129452377557755, 0.08535922318696976, -0.027476580813527107, 0.02101731486618519, -0.04352400451898575, -0.01910598762333393, 0.0015885846223682165, 0.023997977375984192, -0.05770246684551239, 0.03772493079304695, 0.017853178083896637, 0.009948688559234142, 0.0462668314576149, -0.02681097947061062, 0.010728159919381142, 0.010163652710616589, -0.0594746433198452, -0.008735813200473785, 0.039969559758901596, 0.000396908464608714, -0.016863813623785973, -0.020622534677386284, -0.045175373554229736, 0.026799693703651428, -0.030378105118870735, 0.005726402625441551, 0.0011018828954547644, 0.009810361079871655, 0.046561963856220245, -0.0029953704215586185, -0.03516377881169319, 0.001988976961001754, 0.007901114411652088, -0.042857442051172256, 0.00005775801037088968, 0.033190906047821045, -0.011900104582309723, 0.027689211070537567, -0.022260695695877075, 0.027506614103913307, -0.075701504945755, 0.03974786400794983, -0.07011203467845917, 0.01860290765762329, -0.031487271189689636, -0.002575030317530036, 0.013159556314349174, 0.019556203857064247, 0.08233219385147095, -0.03507139906287193, -0.01563330739736557, 0.009278887882828712, -0.008187972009181976, -0.045524414628744125, 0.05784755200147629, -0.01882144622504711, -0.016247611492872238, -0.0179633479565382, -0.029737848788499832, -0.009320806711912155, 0.010285244323313236, 0.025726839900016785, 0.037256818264722824, -0.05518553406000137, -0.025000309571623802, -0.005541319027543068, 0.03517505154013634, -0.0012742916587740183, -0.01733955554664135, -0.025534728541970253, 0.021449729800224304, -0.02609296701848507, -0.018247490748763084, -0.031058086082339287, 0.009362616576254368, 0.04060403257608414, -0.08050394803285599, -0.0027062094304710627, 0.055631328374147415, 0.04824278503656387, 0.08115095645189285, -0.06322190910577774, 0.03019796311855316, 0.019383154809474945, -0.009213375858962536, -0.009310674853622913, 0.008363363333046436, 0.03576751798391342, 0.017246976494789124, 0.0258401557803154, 0.05935794860124588, -0.02544640377163887, 0.04173515364527702, 0.043717801570892334, 0.02961587719619274, 0.009168252348899841, -0.01173549983650446, -0.02296588011085987, -0.0015227561816573143, 0.008976204320788383, -0.02759181708097458, 0.009540324099361897, -0.03900512680411339, 0.058841999620199203, -0.0013156557688489556, -0.005208311602473259, -0.062365561723709106, 0.024730289354920387, 0.0838531032204628, -0.061608899384737015, -0.06362337619066238, -0.009991507045924664, -0.011665623635053635, 0.004483417142182589, -0.0353279747068882, -0.01737668365240097, -0.008576949127018452, 0.028500773012638092, 0.0033695048186928034, 0.022835705429315567, 0.0005833918694406748, -0.047071296721696854, -0.020044855773448944, -0.015529315918684006, 0.04932473972439766, 0.019215378910303116, 0.04768035188317299, -0.016663769260048866, 0.041518621146678925, -0.044168516993522644, 0.008369018323719501, -0.06785425543785095, -0.02046673558652401, 0.014493311755359173, -0.031176874414086342, -0.04167553409934044, 0.027768202126026154, -0.016802607104182243, 0.03947680816054344, -0.014845816418528557, 0.024697577580809593, 0.04572966322302818, -0.011154069565236568, 0.023747559636831284, -0.024146705865859985, -0.015318751335144043, 0.07313327491283417, -0.049416858702898026, 0.024136751890182495, 0.02139444276690483, -0.05700414627790451, -0.012557252310216427, 0.03312947228550911, 0.0050271907821297646, -0.06770817190408707, 0.04232735186815262, -0.052508894354104996, -0.01310761459171772, 0.05186561122536659, 0.000386101717595011, 0.05097344517707825, -0.027018731459975243, 0.027945492416620255, 0.05688795447349548, -0.001849674154073, -0.016466472297906876, -0.0204501710832119, 0.01886485330760479, -0.018327100202441216, -0.016435272991657257, -0.017461426556110382, -0.0521857813000679, 0.01656957156956196, -0.05910678580403328, -0.0055618928745388985, -0.023984190076589584, 0.015364939346909523, 0.04438445344567299, -0.00927465409040451, 0.026492372155189514, 0.02413056790828705, 0.04480146989226341, -0.021530814468860626, 0.02306452952325344, 0.015416187234222889, 0.034790437668561935, 0.019935516640543938, 0.027751881629228592, 0.06237577274441719, 0.04934738948941231, 0.004827072843909264, -0.02082081325352192, 0.0075136637315154076, 0.022436458617448807, -0.03298624977469444, 0.024541784077882767, -0.030435243621468544, -0.017683112993836403, 0.010303913615643978, -0.0018259206553921103, -0.03776858001947403, 0.05195089429616928, -0.0014826238621026278, -0.0006428404012694955, 0.01801394857466221, -0.046848759055137634, -0.01726030744612217, -0.02335510589182377, 0.02882941998541355, -0.004474340006709099, -0.022938352078199387, 0.05724088475108147, -0.004883213900029659, 0.0085053201764822, 0.05819486826658249, -0.11802588403224945, 0.014840017072856426, -0.03393665701150894, -0.023568589240312576, 0.04816334694623947, 0.05269695818424225, 0.04157617315649986, 0.030877958983182907, -0.03660230338573456, -0.007010758388787508, -0.04110933840274811, 0.001281382399611175, -0.007010211702436209, -0.05352945625782013, -0.0195604395121336, -0.06046948581933975, -0.05101381242275238, -0.053212475031614304, -0.046305544674396515, 0.04405582323670387, -0.019792046397924423, 0.015034981071949005, 0.013240255415439606, 0.006518765352666378, 0.05606713518500328, -0.002614110941067338, 0.045512549579143524, -0.05242575332522392, -0.0345790758728981, -0.01323719508945942, -0.012858545407652855, -0.018832601606845856, 0.03831060230731964, -0.005782178603112698, -0.01675252616405487, -0.022737855091691017, -0.009192902594804764, -0.009033625945448875, 0.01745779439806938, 0.04958629980683327, -0.038654573261737823, 0.005272169131785631, -0.010651852935552597, 0.02964859828352928, 0.035329580307006836, 0.0029639173299074173, -0.05981174856424332, 0.02146623469889164, -0.04147661104798317, -0.03721405193209648, 0.07761276513338089, 0.00548391742631793, 0.021863970905542374, 0.02768254466354847, 0.08671281486749649, -0.030782334506511688, 0.026233995333313942, -0.09761083871126175, -0.021632781252264977, 0.009821048937737942, -0.007516160141676664, -0.018003322184085846, 0.001396240433678031, 0.056095827370882034, 0.04097609966993332, -0.016524776816368103, -0.016087280586361885, -0.023342404514551163, 0.01719302125275135, 0.04459415376186371, -0.048887912184000015, -0.0018036625115200877, -0.0022448268719017506, -0.00597945274785161, -0.017827773466706276, -0.016834629699587822, 0.0343829020857811, 0.03242682293057442, -0.0017805909737944603, -0.03237580880522728, -0.02673959545791149, -0.016407469287514687, -0.017337627708911896, 0.011400419287383556, -0.01239168643951416, -0.008286059834063053, -0.09284685552120209, -0.05451370030641556, 0.04135696589946747, 0.012184121645987034, -0.03986453637480736, 0.022444499656558037, 0.006985448766499758, 0.021378086879849434, 0.02793998457491398, -0.054424118250608444, 0.015159071423113346, 0.05873376876115799, -0.032506782561540604, -0.040046364068984985, -0.021653925999999046, 0.0123159633949399, -0.027254212647676468, 0.017368201166391373, -0.029976842924952507, 0.0200849287211895, 0.010220609605312347, 0.025373995304107666, -0.013994266279041767 ]
<p>I was recently overviewing various <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massive_compact_halo_object" rel="nofollow">massive compact halo object</a> studies (the Anglo-Australian MACHO collaboration and the French I/II EROS collaboration), and they frequently reference "blue bumper stars," irregular variable stars which produce light curves very similar to <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_microlensing" rel="nofollow">gravitational microlensing</a> event. Further searches for more information about them was mostly fruitless, producing a few conference proceedings: </p> <ul> <li><a href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1995llnl.reptR....P" rel="nofollow">The MACHO Project LMC variable star inventory: Aperiodic blue variables</a> (code <em>1995llnl.reptR....P</em>)</li> <li><a href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1995AAS...18710202P" rel="nofollow">The MACHO Project LMC Variable Star Inventory: Aperiodic Blue Variables</a> (code <em>1995AAS...18710202P</em>), </li> </ul> <p>but little else. </p> <p>Is there any more information on this type of variable star, especially a more rigorous and targeted study of them? Also, how is it possible to get the full text for either of those articles?</p>
g9773
[ -0.010239792056381702, -0.000792775594163686, 0.0023988510947674513, -0.04882301017642021, -0.01691354438662529, 0.013754578307271004, -0.013559648767113686, -0.0624142624437809, -0.05282380059361458, -0.046159740537405014, 0.04448717460036278, 0.04951499029994011, 0.060916900634765625, -0.023275155574083328, 0.04962337762117386, -0.019653523340821266, -0.028505874797701836, -0.04202869534492493, -0.024686235934495926, 0.0009024280589073896, 0.08539103716611862, 0.0458260141313076, -0.007456828840076923, -0.03345407545566559, 0.03690744936466217, 0.04539390280842781, 0.03220938518643379, 0.0013325531035661697, -0.008418338373303413, -0.015061069279909134, 0.02341816946864128, 0.009606316685676575, 0.0423208549618721, -0.04254237189888954, 0.006555743515491486, 0.025928299874067307, -0.014870218932628632, 0.011951086111366749, 0.008099602535367012, 0.07819312810897827, -0.013977868482470512, 0.018386442214250565, 0.033435672521591187, 0.036083899438381195, -0.0013567098649218678, -0.014606545679271221, -0.0331074595451355, -0.05641338229179382, 0.020804407075047493, -0.06687729060649872, 0.06651163846254349, 0.03339426591992378, 0.09070241451263428, -0.05864131078124046, 0.04841835796833038, 0.06322799623012543, 0.03705531731247902, -0.08747779577970505, 0.025539446622133255, 0.04079122841358185, 0.07307958602905273, 0.013844839297235012, -0.0026617529802024364, 0.03728776425123215, 0.017154846340417862, -0.031819142401218414, 0.026058901101350784, -0.10025931149721146, -0.04824201390147209, -0.036970995366573334, 0.03710959479212761, 0.010158965364098549, -0.003243145300075412, -0.019246110692620277, -0.03993029519915581, 0.019608283415436745, -0.05500020086765289, -0.01090201921761036, 0.021006785333156586, -0.03891780227422714, -0.019904445856809616, 0.007043843157589436, -0.07250847667455673, 0.043584052473306656, 0.08422182500362396, -0.007693360559642315, 0.0393926240503788, 0.027795691043138504, 0.05112355202436447, -0.03942825645208359, 0.06137414276599884, -0.009753838181495667, 0.0137521056458354, -0.027830692008137703, 0.014210201799869537, 0.01474406011402607, -0.030010852962732315, 0.022101664915680885, -0.10458382219076157, 0.03766819089651108, -0.051317792385816574, 0.04081849008798599, -0.049235984683036804, 0.0444808229804039, 0.02714650146663189, -0.006506567820906639, -0.010306271724402905, -0.03785260021686554, -0.048507995903491974, 0.017910607159137726, -0.0071805315092206, 0.016838394105434418, -0.03451377525925636, -0.05419250950217247, -0.03735530003905296, -0.03691638261079788, -0.024000942707061768, 0.00009231018339050934, -0.014853505417704582, 0.032614320516586304, 0.004661416169255972, -0.049808260053396225, 0.05727642402052879, 0.03334462270140648, -0.02070794627070427, -0.03301528841257095, 0.04420850798487663, -0.02436061203479767, -0.0001832533162087202, -0.049018487334251404, -0.004995862487703562, -0.0036521025467664003, 0.022789523005485535, -0.01639057695865631, -0.01890397071838379, -0.007929010316729546, -0.007724537048488855, 0.017935991287231445, 0.014973598532378674, 0.014072083868086338, 0.01566954329609871, -0.04028515890240669, 0.01546945609152317, 0.010404253378510475, 0.006117438431829214, -0.004987501539289951, -0.03163697198033333, -0.008789926767349243, 0.05760094150900841, -0.06465830653905869, 0.011790357530117035, 0.017473729327321053, -0.005507152061909437, -0.061656493693590164, -0.09276188910007477, 0.01127991359680891, -0.0541808158159256, -0.03995908796787262, -0.06377819180488586, 0.03870629519224167, 0.004122842103242874, -0.04838930815458298, 0.033018678426742554, -0.015245609916746616, 0.0076289065182209015, 0.032487399876117706, -0.002930874703451991, 0.012386998161673546, 0.007063515949994326, -0.0798989087343216, -0.02567373774945736, -0.0467182882130146, 0.05519738793373108, 0.005150496494024992, 0.03255685418844223, 0.027261406183242798, 0.04881230741739273, -0.006296856328845024, -0.007611238397657871, -0.008413651958107948, -0.04068666696548462, -0.013909988105297089, -0.023607591167092323, -0.0072290487587451935, 0.020748326554894447, -0.036791082471609116, 0.009597995318472385, 0.019770478829741478, 0.022714601829648018, 0.010224685072898865, 0.011020244099199772, -0.007675269152969122, 0.013123097829520702, -0.004756624344736338, -0.0182387325912714, -0.03190348297357559, -0.0011188541539013386, -0.030028412118554115, -0.06230248138308525, 0.02894572727382183, -0.0037607450503855944, 0.010980602353811264, 0.03418035805225372, -0.002688670763745904, 0.039441391825675964, 0.05588926002383232, 0.03367408365011215, -0.0160511564463377, -0.0022665371652692556, 0.014877405017614365, 0.04226481914520264, -0.06087946891784668, -0.01280913595110178, -0.0056473370641469955, -0.019620908424258232, 0.010877610184252262, -0.028828712180256844, 0.01868576370179653, 0.04230412095785141, 0.025325778871774673, 0.016253992915153503, -0.023828500881791115, 0.000028109485356253572, -0.03890746831893921, 0.04575289785861969, 0.028897957876324654, 0.04953337088227272, -0.015094727277755737, 0.039217934012413025, -0.03606950491666794, -0.04178135097026825, 0.04589878022670746, -0.0406634621322155, -0.013973414897918701, -0.009224683046340942, -0.07084979116916656, 0.056760523468256, 0.044892165809869766, 0.019230974838137627, 0.05376750975847244, 0.04669050872325897, -0.06148793175816536, 0.015191190876066685, -0.042717888951301575, -0.008795984089374542, -0.07968004792928696, 0.010417808778584003, 0.04927587881684303, -0.036952003836631775, -0.0007762424647808075, -0.032544467598199844, -0.0070310127921402454, -0.008718437515199184, 0.03656782954931259, 0.02948514185845852, 0.02261301502585411, 0.016177522018551826, -0.005136512685567141, -0.034612905234098434, -0.01640407182276249, 0.0641859918832779, 0.01771918125450611, 0.03577980771660805, -0.004866695497184992, 0.03404424339532852, 0.0029244483448565006, -0.029939724132418633, -0.030926942825317383, -0.015182025730609894, 0.017549335956573486, -0.06184118241071701, 0.03439623489975929, -0.008102302439510822, -0.02955646440386772, -0.011038091033697128, 0.032113198190927505, -0.01227461639791727, 0.04666280001401901, 0.02837827429175377, -0.025357194244861603, -0.02668054588139057, -0.025633452460169792, -0.021020635962486267, -0.03427562862634659, -0.04787011072039604, 0.005681303329765797, -0.03311305493116379, 0.023861750960350037, 0.001529454835690558, 0.01819310151040554, 0.022420935332775116, 0.011624887585639954, -0.005882616154849529, 0.013666142709553242, 0.006191838998347521, -0.039949242025613785, -0.043367356061935425, 0.09430188685655594, -0.009567959234118462, -0.002965145045891404, 0.031582366675138474, -0.03229019045829773, 0.011678455397486687, -0.015773041173815727, -0.01407626923173666, -0.008141924627125263, -0.04096446931362152, -0.08788222074508667, 0.027263641357421875, -0.015099729411303997, 0.04272318631410599, 0.08046919107437134, -0.031049657613039017, 0.049201834946870804, -0.010911301709711552, -0.0056094275787472725, -0.043759699910879135, -0.02561185695230961, 0.007539123296737671, 0.032802145928144455, -0.010971928015351295, -0.010117625817656517, 0.015917429700493813, -0.04339279979467392, 0.02536294236779213, -0.045657262206077576, 0.00321552949026227, -0.025050342082977295, -0.009785288013517857, 0.05070136487483978, -0.005665336269885302, -0.01651478372514248, 0.04549737647175789, -0.004582101013511419, -0.016956914216279984, 0.009916570037603378, -0.0661456435918808, -0.0022634819615632296, 0.04009147360920906, 0.01357092335820198, 0.002785738790407777, 0.01964077726006508, -0.04938798025250435, -0.01720583066344261, -0.01342418696731329, 0.01189024280756712, 0.02287423424422741, -0.009586992673575878, 0.000414516864111647, -0.0559539832174778, 0.022624313831329346, -0.02763792872428894, 0.0791812315583229, -0.04468115419149399, -0.0172486063092947, -0.01572573557496071, 0.04679189249873161, -0.01081124972552061, 0.01099445391446352, -0.04308823496103287, -0.08963506668806076, 0.006915423087775707, 0.004784229211509228, 0.04111024737358093, -0.03990454599261284, -0.013288612477481365, 0.010422182269394398, 0.014922000467777252, 0.0036333256866782904, -0.0390482135117054, -0.006956384051591158, 0.06004256010055542, -0.005706041119992733, 0.005152663215994835, -0.0634656548500061, 0.021218471229076385, 0.02167443558573723, -0.015666121616959572, -0.00944854598492384, 0.011014980264008045, -0.0009833460208028555, 0.04615399241447449, 0.054937589913606644, -0.01430080272257328, -0.017652515321969986, -0.06232207641005516, -0.007011964917182922, -0.015176483429968357, 0.0077741555869579315, -0.10046254843473434, -0.031579721719026566, -0.049122896045446396, -0.04866893216967583, -0.026012688875198364, 0.0370279960334301, -0.012210551649332047, 0.01960359700024128, -0.05059230327606201, 0.006999731995165348, 0.02866647206246853, 0.0023037672508507967, 0.00859677605330944, 0.03542092442512512, 0.01891458034515381, -0.03909362107515335, 0.0011225671041756868, -0.014570415951311588, -0.0024485462345182896, -0.01581752859055996, 0.03394152969121933, 0.06230052560567856, -0.00016916038293857127, 0.0346619188785553, -0.06246389076113701, 0.09744592756032944, -0.006841021589934826, -0.017802907153964043, -0.006582527421414852, 0.02489425800740719, 0.0026057125069200993, 0.016728036105632782, -0.0037713346537202597, -0.04027559235692024, -0.005043635610491037, 0.0698859915137291, 0.013866333290934563, -0.03962840884923935, 0.014968487434089184, -0.04504403844475746, 0.012626973912119865, 0.06108348071575165, -0.02217155694961548, -0.003102535381913185, -0.0053591299802064896, 0.0034809669014066458, 0.02138698473572731, -0.04019024595618248, -0.019784001633524895, 0.051989492028951645, 0.00763761717826128, -0.003701749723404646, 0.010456853546202183, 0.0034291332121938467, -0.0187287088483572, 0.019869200885295868, 0.09528754651546478, -0.0518752858042717, 0.0032893286552280188, 0.001343401032499969, 0.019535288214683533, 0.033573102205991745, -0.05869137495756149, 0.0076988255605101585, -0.00016247015446424484, 0.07571035623550415, 0.0168017465621233, 0.03331611305475235, 0.01644793339073658, 0.07934588938951492, -0.021618740633130074, 0.002847850788384676, -0.025084814056754112, 0.03261786699295044, 0.07075431942939758, 0.07374133169651031, -0.025386909022927284, -0.0300173070281744, -0.0047944821417331696, -0.023047160357236862, 0.002432178007438779, -0.05191943794488907, 0.06137287989258766, 0.06541334092617035, -0.010710423812270164, 0.035274289548397064, -0.026931727305054665, -0.032412875443696976, -0.06507285684347153, -0.0016097616171464324, 0.020087409764528275, -0.03164374828338623, 0.03749766945838928, 0.015388603322207928, -0.02993650920689106, 0.0250963494181633, 0.06597381085157394, -0.02208675444126129, 0.016332734376192093, -0.06292006373405457, 0.03585495427250862, -0.00259216851554811, -0.04143141210079193, 0.02958371303975582, -0.017061926424503326, 0.011078085750341415, -0.02256988175213337, 0.06698416918516159, 0.011909735389053822, 0.027518246322870255, -0.005553734954446554, -0.0012286260025575757, 0.032828472554683685, -0.011451669968664646, 0.001728915493004024, -0.026552969589829445, 0.04702422767877579, 0.02044077031314373, -0.032401517033576965, 0.00931516196578741, 0.004952937830239534, 0.01066552009433508, 0.008960823528468609, 0.0445379875600338, -0.011488620191812515, -0.06853410601615906, 0.02329627238214016, 0.013532721437513828, 0.08755529671907425, 0.0165400467813015, -0.027492376044392586, -0.04463185369968414, -0.01987096667289734, -0.013249323703348637, 0.04318799823522568, 0.009989645332098007, -0.010514555498957634, 0.034444987773895264, -0.041394561529159546, -0.009100861847400665, -0.031156344339251518, -0.06671649217605591, 0.03209851682186127, 0.05963752418756485, 0.03207894414663315, -0.014182457700371742, 0.01710647903382778, 0.08140073716640472, 0.06827854365110397, 0.018771657720208168, -0.01785886660218239, -0.024119006469845772, -0.0013342674355953932, -0.03659263998270035, 0.012486590072512627, -0.023542867973446846, -0.01964600570499897, 0.0310415867716074, 0.03859739378094673, 0.09239387512207031, -0.05138020217418671, -0.0173189640045166, 0.015021267347037792, 0.09392412006855011, 0.062327418476343155, -0.069559745490551, 0.014198633842170238, -0.05044221132993698, 0.0014015923952683806, -0.04613448306918144, 0.0017475959612056613, -0.03984818607568741, 0.0011281040497124195, 0.01256257388740778, 0.040148887783288956, -0.014479260891675949, -0.03377644717693329, -0.010341369546949863, -0.050114430487155914, 0.020808259025216103, 0.03842514380812645, 0.030296972021460533, 0.05662756785750389, -0.010023673065006733, 0.05605074018239975, 0.05270965024828911, -0.10523734986782074, -0.007653765380382538, 0.04909756779670715, -0.05671875923871994, -0.011424780823290348, 0.04250435158610344, -0.005497028585523367, -0.015944145619869232, 0.05015213415026665, 0.012164892628788948, -0.0023286049254238605, 0.013585175387561321, 0.0027595642022788525, -0.054971300065517426, -0.0725724846124649, -0.04525505378842354, -0.0067415484227240086, -0.021356873214244843, -0.014820278622210026, -0.06717627495527267, -0.04285385087132454, -0.06045568361878395, 0.0626482367515564, -0.056460246443748474, 0.026430534198880196, -0.0359131395816803, 0.006833204533904791, -0.01575327292084694, 0.024689393118023872, -0.002060504863038659, -0.040702614933252335, -0.050455596297979355, 0.053359340876340866, 0.030000166967511177, 0.002334454795345664, -0.0327732153236866, 0.007498362101614475, 0.002747641410678625, -0.0009885741164907813, -0.018513869494199753, -0.016475606709718704, -0.0001595653302501887, 0.016184169799089432, 0.019722314551472664, -0.021612249314785004, 0.0013572049792855978, -0.053680259734392166, 0.039262399077415466, -0.02423333190381527, -0.004959302023053169, 0.0015301522798836231, -0.02083658054471016, -0.03911183029413223, -0.027754703536629677, 0.003881440032273531, -0.004854938015341759, 0.029361233115196228, 0.017762159928679466, 0.04728367552161217, 0.01761595904827118, 0.025810660794377327, -0.06041890010237694, 0.04494279995560646, 0.04824594780802727, -0.037432197481393814, 0.04706581309437752, 0.036155007779598236, 0.028355205431580544, 0.0190216526389122, -0.010570388287305832, 0.022189734503626823, -0.02075762115418911, 0.030235212296247482, 0.05453880503773689, 0.02084922417998314, -0.0011678922455757856, -0.05793391168117523, 0.02204255573451519, -0.028338691219687462, -0.060171812772750854, 0.08373027294874191, -0.005041752941906452, -0.025319477543234825, -0.008630223572254181, -0.007527610752731562, -0.03384862840175629, 0.03967105597257614, -0.06808913499116898, 0.016092423349618912, 0.011763877235352993, 0.013047320768237114, -0.013259440660476685, -0.04143992438912392, 0.000007975870175869204, 0.03068637102842331, 0.03917619213461876, 0.021739760413765907, -0.048852212727069855, -0.0409696102142334, 0.018445681780576706, -0.03909613564610481, -0.038778796792030334, -0.018339065834879875, 0.013768292032182217, 0.03393013775348663, 0.027896061539649963, 0.007335792761296034, 0.014664149843156338, 0.03333160653710365, -0.014182689599692822, 0.0032435120083391666, -0.12494583427906036, 0.014072069898247719, 0.07964247465133667, -0.025093847885727882, -0.010711596347391605, 0.020278330892324448, -0.006680476013571024, -0.047853194177150726, -0.008497915230691433, -0.0696934312582016, -0.03858618065714836, 0.01995747722685337, -0.007466423790901899, 0.056155405938625336, 0.01348020974546671, 0.049956776201725006, -0.010081897489726543, -0.018179548904299736, 0.03888392820954323, 0.03795672208070755, -0.027386624366044998, 0.024863839149475098, -0.03764175623655319, 0.009318015538156033, -0.042753059417009354, 0.06282152235507965, -0.015576672740280628, -0.015344126150012016, -0.04164943844079971, -0.013372023589909077, -0.03004380315542221, -0.03517540916800499, 0.010303250513970852, 0.06674672663211823, -0.02384437993168831, -0.01740110293030739, 0.0030111633241176605, 0.003772395895794034, 0.05671587586402893, -0.04599704220890999, -0.03985154256224632, 0.01907128468155861, -0.03668291121721268, 0.019443580880761147, -0.006749853026121855, -0.012116849422454834, 0.016097499057650566, 0.013318339362740517, 0.0010714203817769885, -0.023077508434653282, -0.017702020704746246, -0.023243559524416924, -0.02180108241736889, -0.020622950047254562, 0.0632503479719162, -0.06711053103208542, 0.010323320515453815, -0.02252812311053276, -0.04116471856832504, 0.05579090118408203, -0.03342556208372116, 0.012500431388616562, 0.04497752711176872, 0.009694491513073444, 0.048596449196338654, 0.06850180774927139, -0.0190106313675642, -0.00541846314445138, -0.022963788360357285, 0.0031130188144743443, 0.017247356474399567, 0.01939033716917038, -0.03146236389875412, -0.007613475434482098, -0.02727408893406391, 0.008405856788158417, -0.009224679321050644, 0.038503825664520264, 0.020281918346881866, 0.002295051934197545, -0.0022283880971372128, 0.06102271005511284 ]
<p>I'm not going to post the full question, I just want a general idea of how I should go about solving this type of problem. </p> <p>There is a square with 4 charged masses on each of the corners, in the center of the square, there is a fifth charged mass. I am supposed to find the net force acting on the center mass ($m_{5}$).</p> <p>Now I could find the gravitational forces between the center mass and each of the corner masses, split that into x and y components, and then repeat the same process for the electrostatic forces. I'm pretty sure there is an easier, less cumbersome way to do this. Any ideas?</p> <pre><code>m2--------m1 | | | m5 | | | m3--------m4 </code></pre> <p>None of the charges/masses directly cancel each other out, however the electrostatic ones seem to be small enough to be trivial in the final result. </p>
g9774
[ 0.06078657880425453, 0.006800853181630373, -0.004923701286315918, -0.07988299429416656, 0.03243222460150719, -0.041801370680332184, 0.028037235140800476, -0.028133701533079147, -0.045087285339832306, 0.004106986802071333, 0.000147976927109994, -0.03523939102888107, -0.009068693965673447, 0.0028440372552722692, 0.010704531334340572, 0.06083192303776741, 0.05069619417190552, -0.005041082855314016, 0.008258117362856865, 0.048299938440322876, 0.007278093136847019, -0.01128263771533966, 0.042030464857816696, -0.04800913482904434, -0.060553230345249176, 0.014370402321219444, 0.06546969711780548, 0.023355579003691673, -0.09627983719110489, 0.01824253983795643, -0.016213735565543175, 0.03468409925699234, 0.049631234258413315, -0.07803469896316528, -0.07517743855714798, 0.03266527131199837, 0.053900301456451416, -0.010282238945364952, -0.0332534983754158, 0.02229556441307068, 0.015086165629327297, -0.05163440480828285, 0.022645264863967896, 0.024704042822122574, 0.04080270975828171, -0.016754044219851494, -0.01972169801592827, -0.029134204611182213, -0.025458915159106255, -0.041346706449985504, -0.04046374186873436, 0.07725679874420166, 0.02367716282606125, -0.07235004007816315, -0.020950865000486374, 0.06274981796741486, 0.02439924143254757, -0.01664978265762329, 0.007683698087930679, 0.07180248200893402, 0.03328174725174904, 0.021303651854395866, -0.024625180289149284, 0.021811261773109436, 0.02425483986735344, 0.00823380146175623, -0.019189869984984398, 0.003521217731758952, -0.05577654391527176, 0.003372160019353032, -0.04618455097079277, 0.01628556288778782, -0.024301983416080475, -0.030044227838516235, 0.01518926676362753, 0.019934091717004776, 0.01156347244977951, 0.06805047392845154, -0.047580551356077194, 0.005057088099420071, 0.006895551923662424, -0.040106914937496185, 0.07664216309785843, 0.014185003004968166, 0.0824127122759819, -0.0728096291422844, -0.021877851337194443, -0.016830479726195335, -0.04956270009279251, -0.040277834981679916, 0.019520340487360954, 0.003905761055648327, 0.005127917975187302, 0.02052244171500206, -0.011885670013725758, -0.032755088061094284, 0.010671614669263363, 0.033260393887758255, 0.013401134870946407, -0.0378042608499527, -0.00844559632241726, 0.009032392874360085, -0.04354453459382057, -0.013341049663722515, -0.010401670821011066, -0.017582494765520096, 0.016971303150057793, 0.057733986526727676, 0.005957628600299358, 0.0141336340457201, -0.001592518063262105, -0.017889535054564476, -0.041688673198223114, -0.058268386870622635, -0.06423040479421616, -0.04145176708698273, 0.07681932300329208, -0.022645214572548866, -0.07139395922422409, -0.006514947395771742, -0.06003221124410629, 0.012513981200754642, -0.0036263735964894295, 0.020292680710554123, -0.01867980696260929, -0.02547909878194332, 0.047887980937957764, 0.059722159057855606, 0.011677954345941544, -0.002030890667811036, 0.03813118487596512, -0.05386420339345932, -0.002026286441832781, 0.014290094375610352, -0.019334733486175537, 0.07354738563299179, -0.008243422955274582, -0.019427375867962837, 0.012304265983402729, -0.010839848779141903, -0.010666986927390099, 0.005256992299109697, 0.006095985881984234, -0.035733915865421295, -0.002231771592050791, 0.02302766963839531, -0.05112402141094208, -0.03725569322705269, 0.005079998634755611, -0.017193695530295372, -0.007299546152353287, 0.0653265118598938, -0.01013818010687828, -0.01541640143841505, 0.023833347484469414, -0.028847044333815575, 0.031007379293441772, -0.023144571110606194, 0.01169492956250906, -0.0223289355635643, 0.002938025863841176, 0.005670929327607155, 0.0382096953690052, -0.006547168362885714, -0.022723259404301643, 0.04159710556268692, -0.006605385337024927, -0.0066824969835579395, 0.023412911221385002, -0.054781097918748856, -0.07488179206848145, -0.05136420205235481, -0.013693328946828842, 0.07323190569877625, 0.014062880538403988, 0.0580567866563797, -0.023376110941171646, -0.04580076411366463, 0.04793619364500046, 0.034072499722242355, 0.0056873466819524765, 0.019544726237654686, 0.03125743940472603, 0.049523547291755676, -0.019331498071551323, 0.008291005156934261, 0.016110528260469437, 0.09003541618585587, -0.00865697767585516, -0.033725857734680176, -0.034443262964487076, 0.02865096926689148, -0.050574708729982376, 0.03620811179280281, 0.04169068858027458, -0.010661625303328037, 0.016416499391198158, -0.030315954238176346, -0.016171706840395927, -0.0372590646147728, -0.036249980330467224, 0.02988443709909916, 0.0015611116541549563, 0.06606218963861465, 0.03718829154968262, 0.027632541954517365, -0.025210333988070488, -0.045433927327394485, 0.03383129462599754, -0.0004458017647266388, 0.004867049865424633, -0.03267154470086098, 0.019987575709819794, -0.016967132687568665, -0.05381061136722565, -0.008933791890740395, -0.016809215769171715, 0.03535544127225876, -0.008707861416041851, 0.05999675393104553, -0.09768840670585632, 0.01680716872215271, 0.00223408336751163, -0.029582487419247627, -0.03940184786915779, -0.025662589818239212, 0.03985869884490967, 0.04031405597925186, 0.018562227487564087, -0.0037957478780299425, -0.014814695343375206, 0.08053137362003326, -0.008818191476166248, 0.012261902913451195, 0.02935987338423729, 0.018742525950074196, -0.049929339438676834, 0.003047751495614648, -0.021771185100078583, -0.028823424130678177, 0.0007487207185477018, 0.02149507775902748, 0.0038574517238885164, -0.03208828344941139, 0.10047976672649384, -0.009417859837412834, 0.06151006370782852, 0.04645618796348572, 0.001583848730660975, 0.0044733136892318726, -0.013317517004907131, -0.019272636622190475, -0.062269069254398346, 0.026883937418460846, 0.03296802565455437, -0.022458132356405258, 0.008233320899307728, 0.0044533442705869675, -0.008257860317826271, -0.048657577484846115, -0.07877177745103836, -0.02090318687260151, 0.02801147662103176, 0.07281652092933655, -0.05256783962249756, -0.07226449996232986, -0.06523235887289047, -0.009316136129200459, 0.04758992791175842, 0.013381634838879108, -0.011190329678356647, 0.0752946138381958, 0.03860815241932869, 0.008743906393647194, -0.02262748032808304, -0.009189066477119923, 0.025266427546739578, -0.03474503010511398, 0.002298645908012986, 0.040828172117471695, 0.05300047993659973, -0.003929921891540289, -0.0004048394621349871, 0.01340112928301096, 0.04722509905695915, -0.029996903613209724, 0.03837062045931816, 0.006239116191864014, -0.0026969301979988813, -0.015982620418071747, -0.00667595025151968, 0.011855581775307655, 0.07531951367855072, -0.035272397100925446, 0.00757552171126008, 0.04119198024272919, -0.014144079759716988, -0.030887523666024208, 0.006477865856140852, 0.011665597558021545, -0.04547286778688431, -0.009844161570072174, 0.041712600737810135, 0.01844334416091442, -0.03496207296848297, 0.011060253717005253, 0.00791683979332447, -0.027714326977729797, 0.04931589588522911, -0.032172854989767075, 0.06255310773849487, 0.009819716215133667, 0.009196208789944649, -0.01214334275573492, -0.03182096406817436, -0.0280082356184721, 0.025556229054927826, -0.06425365805625916, 0.008361214771866798, -0.02951037883758545, -0.02833583578467369, -0.012440855614840984, 0.05474371463060379, 0.002830538433045149, -0.026049165055155754, 0.1268802136182785, -0.04811903461813927, 0.06489081680774689, -0.041548434644937515, 0.004625638946890831, -0.025689061731100082, 0.024840116500854492, 0.026161255314946175, 0.011556941084563732, -0.014687205664813519, -0.03628888726234436, 0.029876036569476128, -0.0038724939804524183, 0.020522000268101692, 0.011277919635176659, 0.01615985669195652, -0.006700270343571901, -0.05393210053443909, -0.045154642313718796, -0.006867626216262579, 0.009810362942516804, 0.020854400470852852, -0.00704810069873929, 0.014435390010476112, -0.05662728473544121, -0.022616354748606682, -0.045293234288692474, 0.028926832601428032, 0.021625060588121414, 0.006820136681199074, -0.0204506516456604, 0.0017457795329391956, -0.01599714532494545, -0.008211885578930378, -0.0006250888109207153, 0.014788620173931122, -0.004644701723009348, -0.002389064757153392, 0.012498842552304268, 0.024270713329315186, -0.004202024545520544, 0.04229292273521423, 0.03709988668560982, -0.018789924681186676, -0.04831980541348457, 0.04798680543899536, -0.052079662680625916, 0.005332875996828079, -0.03509265184402466, -0.008291083388030529, -0.07668223232030869, 0.033302828669548035, -0.03023684211075306, 0.06873529404401779, 0.020345160737633705, 0.04706830158829689, 0.013646313920617104, -0.005539990495890379, -0.005434892605990171, 0.02356841042637825, 0.015243032947182655, -0.015708543360233307, 0.022145334631204605, 0.042369816452264786, -0.02118854783475399, -0.0014044544659554958, -0.009229235351085663, -0.03737715631723404, -0.008368084207177162, -0.02038244716823101, 0.0034934375435113907, 0.002767902333289385, -0.04030681028962135, -0.026580970734357834, -0.0024667533580213785, 0.04278013855218887, 0.019941911101341248, 0.010297073982656002, 0.03018667735159397, 0.026924360543489456, 0.0202171728014946, 0.008237451314926147, -0.016884280368685722, 0.05564779415726662, 0.018483269959688187, 0.007412904407829046, -0.03000255487859249, 0.040238890796899796, -0.03461742401123047, 0.09023180603981018, -0.010945295915007591, 0.006999456323683262, 0.039379194378852844, 0.008892606943845749, -0.041850700974464417, 0.022882310673594475, 0.04879697039723396, -0.06220974400639534, -0.016465596854686737, 0.006087689194828272, 0.011968458071351051, 0.022353431209921837, -0.017223108559846878, 0.02804209105670452, -0.01647769846022129, -0.01919802650809288, 0.07014390826225281, -0.03474365547299385, -0.014394939877092838, -0.04510921984910965, -0.019855748862028122, -0.061467207968235016, -0.03274877741932869, -0.0005517799872905016, 0.07365775108337402, 0.07852906733751297, 0.04238433763384819, -0.006553713697940111, -0.015013430267572403, 0.023382369428873062, 0.030275024473667145, -0.02443782426416874, -0.007286023814231157, 0.0031648220028728247, 0.039582207798957825, -0.02735312096774578, -0.04177658632397652, -0.03493335098028183, -0.0387527160346508, 0.00904009584337473, -0.021608421579003334, -0.0005557539407163858, 0.01262435968965292, 0.01935548707842827, 0.025374798104166985, 0.021038930863142014, -0.03616247698664665, -0.016235172748565674, 0.006484949961304665, 0.05943721905350685, -0.012678302824497223, -0.03674447908997536, 0.034262724220752716, 0.023728221654891968, -0.06194455549120903, 0.019270284101366997, 0.07645488530397415, 0.017435157671570778, -0.0034058191813528538, -0.0005320745985955, -0.007349679712206125, -0.020207928493618965, 0.005319095682352781, 0.02729971893131733, -0.02026868425309658, -0.04249351844191551, 0.010818593204021454, -0.019647756591439247, 0.0020196072291582823, 0.03094666078686714, 0.0036378554068505764, 0.008567006327211857, -0.06317306309938431, -0.011200129054486752, -0.021244743838906288, 0.0011485823197290301, 0.0013805244816467166, -0.00029453972820192575, -0.037907011806964874, 0.05224982649087906, 0.002990718698129058, 0.0014468599110841751, -0.05165183171629906, 0.011415672488510609, 0.019976312294602394, 0.00018584249482955784, 0.00204740883782506, -0.02666887640953064, 0.07440025359392166, 0.023526210337877274, 0.02381773851811886, 0.009462387301027775, -0.03598152846097946, -0.006307566538453102, 0.05757030472159386, -0.030160529538989067, 0.014449097216129303, 0.06469668447971344, 0.022208066657185555, -0.029339682310819626, 0.043677665293216705, -0.01096250582486391, 0.04149152338504791, -0.015569198876619339, -0.005806843284517527, 0.08114971965551376, -0.0019201517570763826, -0.013019201345741749, 0.004549289587885141, 0.06666803359985352, -0.027652235701680183, -0.0031986283138394356, -0.0013467191020026803, -0.030645936727523804, -0.005477674305438995, -0.018301228061318398, -0.06639599800109863, -0.00828887801617384, -0.028453389182686806, -0.04638059809803963, -0.07025928795337677, 0.004025026690214872, -0.04298669472336769, 0.050870802253484726, -0.045302096754312515, 0.01596742495894432, -0.030183065682649612, 0.020086130127310753, -0.025100041180849075, -0.03857797756791115, 0.01585412584245205, -0.005623723845928907, -0.0011418290669098496, 0.002956817392259836, -0.013087340630590916, -0.03348197042942047, 0.008012714795768261, 0.01014619879424572, 0.008638102561235428, -0.010755987837910652, 0.02157209813594818, -0.03529621660709381, 0.01894872635602951, -0.014139908365905285, -0.009438803419470787, 0.06417851895093918, -0.054339490830898285, 0.018133537843823433, 0.038531750440597534, 0.0005558744305744767, 0.016037385910749435, -0.012523988261818886, 0.0014132214710116386, 0.012053240090608597, -0.001065851654857397, 0.04268878698348999, 0.01234900951385498, -0.0315980426967144, 0.021286599338054657, 0.014125400222837925, 0.016499292105436325, -0.014525331556797028, 0.028246652334928513, -0.024858541786670685, 0.029743865132331848, 0.0033658721949905157, -0.020493658259510994, 0.02846115455031395, 0.0007742396555840969, -0.00702139176428318, 0.09559249877929688, -0.05837387964129448, -0.003508360590785742, 0.030626831576228142, -0.04431314393877983, -0.0059905522502958775, -0.05282728001475334, -0.013743208721280098, -0.008210589177906513, -0.06609178334474564, 0.024463480338454247, 0.022815082222223282, 0.013574882410466671, 0.016905276104807854, 0.07904824614524841, 0.04708300530910492, -0.014144054614007473, 0.03613823279738426, -0.04839480295777321, 0.015299118123948574, 0.0035094358026981354, -0.001792452298104763, -0.041809920221567154, -0.07423951476812363, -0.04121547192335129, -0.012219447642564774, -0.030402202159166336, -0.035774633288383484, -0.03245224058628082, 0.007242468185722828, -0.042610470205545425, -0.007506827358156443, 0.059525955468416214, 0.017880037426948547, -0.07375894486904144, -0.019132448360323906, 0.0072664846666157246, -0.02423878200352192, -0.02981935814023018, 0.04883026331663132, 0.022181684151291847, 0.031171031296253204, -0.04956256225705147, 0.05902945622801781, -0.011739683337509632, 0.03992043435573578, -0.03954499587416649, 0.06559430807828903, 0.0010555663611739874, -0.0034144974779337645, 0.060160085558891296, -0.01634773053228855, 0.010692069306969643, 0.03748501464724541, 0.034197624772787094, -0.026084911078214645, 0.028894132003188133, 0.014786303974688053, 0.015489760786294937, 0.006381442304700613, -0.023678215220570564, 0.04030611738562584, 0.029506273567676544, 0.0036965711042284966, 0.027284465730190277, -0.0005995418759994209, -0.03890344500541687, -0.007248345296829939, -0.029640810564160347, -0.08847171068191528, 0.029868172481656075, 0.05776209756731987, -0.02111847512423992, 0.06393361836671829, -0.021795447915792465, -0.07183215022087097, -0.018004976212978363, 0.01416449248790741, 0.003661479102447629, 0.012006026692688465, 0.047497741878032684, -0.025767728686332703, 0.015763159841299057, 0.0005415202467702329, -0.03153926506638527, -0.0258027371019125, -0.03879696503281593, -0.03449901565909386, 0.07284972071647644, 0.0069511388428509235, 0.020803214982151985, 0.008998791687190533, 0.007014633156359196, 0.00045508347102440894, 0.01431550644338131, 0.0024037163238972425, -0.007931954227387905, -0.07613984495401382, 0.04266021028161049, -0.04042733088135719, 0.07329905778169632, -0.046452056616544724, 0.050908830016851425, 0.01874866709113121, 0.07009602338075638, 0.019542314112186432, 0.060205958783626556, 0.01730947755277157, 0.02503283880650997, -0.05353452265262604, 0.008654803968966007, -0.0011719308095052838, 0.03426320105791092, 0.03874044120311737, -0.013953568413853645, -0.06298665702342987, -0.042656026780605316, 0.031190654262900352, -0.07681269198656082, -0.030330738052725792, 0.024539170786738396, -0.10065227001905441, -0.04843611270189285, 0.008158670738339424, 0.020503250882029533, 0.01063665933907032, 0.0285553690046072, -0.02030511386692524, -0.02696939744055271, 0.0032261712476611137, 0.052009716629981995, -0.052671026438474655, 0.041485875844955444, 0.05864458158612251, -0.013596021570265293, -0.06278544664382935, -0.014944066293537617, -0.011039216071367264, -0.05328145995736122, -0.0594402551651001, -0.032504912465810776, -0.04167995601892471, 0.013402719981968403, 0.05196232721209526, -0.0236864872276783, -0.0034881867468357086, -0.03982791677117348, -0.004916297737509012, -0.02162572741508484, 0.03528394550085068, -0.03908079117536545, -0.014517524279654026, -0.08450658619403839, 0.06338275969028473, -0.0017304318025708199, -0.03693987429141998, -0.14180468022823334, -0.04556376487016678, -0.043247804045677185, 0.0453452505171299, 0.055388569831848145, -0.04271172732114792, 0.020819075405597687, 0.0440838560461998, 0.030701516196131706, 0.07242826372385025, -0.019666820764541626, -0.05717066675424576, -0.006935622077435255, -0.02899988740682602, -0.05089297890663147, 0.009530791081488132, 0.053439222276210785, 0.017344031482934952, 0.007501058280467987, -0.05670041963458061, -0.02592596225440502, -0.02438870631158352, -0.009171012789011002, 0.012103462591767311, -0.005490009672939777, 0.0292389877140522, 0.030133889988064766 ]
<p>I have question related to electromagnetic Spectrum.</p> <p>If energy of photon is $E=m_e c^2$, to which part of the electromagnetic spectrum does it belong ? </p>
g9775
[ 0.025372952222824097, -0.03103262558579445, 0.007146981079131365, -0.025695765390992165, 0.009438644163310528, 0.049608517438173294, 0.0010608176235109568, 0.026552347466349602, -0.027170276269316673, 0.004954760894179344, 0.023887140676379204, 0.0037466203793883324, 0.017233528196811676, 0.0269495639950037, -0.016181187704205513, -0.03179425746202469, 0.09880789369344711, 0.024041632190346718, -0.028651239350438118, 0.00571943074464798, -0.05943942070007324, 0.0046339137479662895, -0.00026438559871166945, -0.05047374963760376, 0.042583320289850235, 0.009577387943863869, 0.10827024281024933, 0.012279109098017216, -0.004947471432387829, -0.03765725716948509, 0.007147514261305332, 0.042311593890190125, 0.09322629868984222, 0.010247459635138512, -0.038765110075473785, -0.001722015906125307, 0.08410267531871796, 0.03981868550181389, 0.025025302544236183, 0.04656796157360077, 0.029191793873906136, 0.0047920807264745235, -0.03168110176920891, 0.005301770754158497, 0.0359487310051918, 0.015901295468211174, 0.0193083044141531, 0.030055781826376915, -0.04389971122145653, 0.025871340185403824, 0.021725669503211975, 0.008862228132784367, 0.05167791247367859, -0.002882647793740034, 0.02845713123679161, -0.021913129836320877, 0.0027965784538537264, -0.017503488808870316, 0.05391437187790871, 0.05001731961965561, 0.03527573496103287, -0.00013828460942022502, 0.0020691738463938236, 0.018749842420220375, 0.010285254567861557, 0.00811113603413105, -0.038848306983709335, -0.021971574053168297, -0.053639404475688934, -0.02038906142115593, 0.024203138425946236, -0.05703962594270706, 0.012714843265712261, -0.0023014869075268507, 0.002641901606693864, -0.07714290171861649, 0.009602140635251999, -0.01818021573126316, 0.006532004103064537, 0.012155075557529926, 0.032263875007629395, 0.002065961016342044, -0.02348605915904045, -0.0765637531876564, 0.05742814764380455, -0.026101604104042053, -0.03302886709570885, 0.018110202625393867, -0.028364989906549454, 0.004535347688943148, 0.009943547658622265, -0.03253234177827835, 0.09268637746572495, -0.002133446279913187, 0.05302608013153076, -0.013744506053626537, 0.01542014442384243, 0.032610900700092316, -0.041047755628824234, -0.020290307700634003, -0.05771303176879883, -0.04795201122760773, -0.0005191989475861192, 0.00893035065382719, 0.045177992433309555, 0.03689249977469444, -0.04655059054493904, -0.03695669397711754, -0.004735669121146202, 0.031593311578035355, 0.014594913460314274, -0.012410526163876057, -0.02673322521150112, -0.05437587946653366, -0.09023085981607437, -0.004448132123798132, 0.07236064225435257, -0.06958480924367905, -0.011832339689135551, 0.11774171888828278, 0.09199218451976776, -0.03766593709588051, 0.018443068489432335, 0.054911065846681595, 0.0061597744934260845, 0.017307518050074577, 0.01766795851290226, -0.0006533571286126971, 0.03802041709423065, -0.0485944002866745, 0.002111756708472967, 0.010610603727400303, 0.018083281815052032, -0.037965402007102966, 0.024521471932530403, 0.06272865831851959, 0.021941814571619034, 0.0191373098641634, -0.009498723782598972, -0.040051549673080444, -0.0035761818289756775, 0.04029534384608269, 0.07438971102237701, -0.0431513786315918, -0.02170579321682453, 0.03081085905432701, 0.048775117844343185, -0.0033806641586124897, 0.02999039925634861, 0.0589153952896595, 0.017727278172969818, 0.06524980068206787, -0.03461870178580284, -0.07664041966199875, 0.05940671265125275, -0.020064426586031914, 0.025207223370671272, -0.02133515290915966, -0.031472448259592056, 0.027463609352707863, 0.022724896669387817, 0.029156194999814034, 0.035536110401153564, -0.018274717032909393, 0.028257962316274643, 0.010141154751181602, -0.01798180490732193, -0.03122330829501152, -0.02323114313185215, -0.029308363795280457, 0.006966727320104837, 0.04181749373674393, 0.0307601410895586, 0.012795763090252876, -0.036368563771247864, 0.046679507941007614, 0.019390834495425224, -0.02677091583609581, 0.05708932876586914, 0.014985065907239914, -0.02037246897816658, 0.0016348776407539845, 0.030424095690250397, -0.028417371213436127, 0.008541503921151161, -0.0416422002017498, -0.025434963405132294, 0.018220018595457077, -0.03271837905049324, 0.008831732906401157, -0.01255713403224945, 0.037902798503637314, -0.052056845277547836, 0.0009130469406954944, 0.005098073277622461, 0.0009431252838112414, -0.0360604003071785, -0.02383648045361042, -0.030532298609614372, -0.020915379747748375, 0.006961040664464235, 0.04209848493337631, -0.01867038384079933, 0.018879346549510956, 0.02167525887489319, 0.0490918792784214, 0.028911788016557693, -0.07364080101251602, -0.005307164043188095, 0.04351433739066124, 0.02793845348060131, -0.03160476312041283, -0.00233253906480968, 0.03761107847094536, -0.016118301078677177, 0.004060080740600824, -0.0501243881881237, 0.013691329397261143, -0.054458897560834885, 0.035860419273376465, -0.07539809495210648, -0.01372481882572174, 0.015255202539265156, -0.04387786239385605, 0.015296285040676594, 0.012246651574969292, -0.07425238937139511, 0.038039881736040115, -0.019118398427963257, -0.028379026800394058, -0.02080986648797989, 0.04761854559183121, 0.017717773094773293, -0.034190673381090164, 0.06209658086299896, -0.00892319530248642, -0.06894563138484955, 0.019596396014094353, 0.02415485866367817, 0.02029523067176342, -0.005472789518535137, 0.016661562025547028, 0.03314458206295967, -0.013707184232771397, -0.03610401228070259, -0.005427750758826733, 0.0539860762655735, 0.006785565987229347, 0.00368690793402493, -0.016865039244294167, -0.010225425474345684, -0.05264836549758911, 0.019518572837114334, 0.050627440214157104, -0.0008740172488614917, -0.03534621000289917, -0.031658172607421875, 0.06222043186426163, -0.06659556180238724, 0.006536352913826704, -0.007766662165522575, -0.043020106852054596, -0.02728874795138836, -0.0477171391248703, -0.0764695331454277, 0.039563264697790146, -0.04896503686904907, -0.023557795211672783, 0.029876820743083954, -0.018863724544644356, -0.002127002691850066, 0.07010619342327118, -0.017853446304798126, 0.01848762482404709, 0.0223157349973917, -0.07672455906867981, 0.04322439059615135, -0.045613065361976624, 0.03557293117046356, -0.08445186913013458, 0.013483650982379913, -0.013598788529634476, 0.006285578478127718, -0.028527814894914627, -0.004901717882603407, -0.0737602487206459, -0.001500523998402059, -0.012104756198823452, -0.030981628224253654, -0.028952986001968384, -0.0028276501689106226, -0.0448383092880249, -0.01811324618756771, -0.0063355304300785065, 0.026817692443728447, -0.0016740275314077735, 0.09472069144248962, 0.021526619791984558, -0.036527179181575775, 0.0446467325091362, -0.013502070680260658, -0.017636427655816078, -0.012550574727356434, -0.08614278584718704, 0.02139201946556568, -0.028105568140745163, -0.021897243335843086, -0.016783175989985466, 0.05695977434515953, 0.02186925709247589, -0.057913098484277725, 0.06004006788134575, -0.00299859419465065, 0.02457820437848568, -0.05099353566765785, 0.03786206990480423, -0.07133805751800537, -0.024151796475052834, -0.02561011165380478, 0.01753390021622181, -0.05330445617437363, -0.013020756654441357, 0.03812805190682411, -0.014314542524516582, 0.08251581341028214, 0.030629577115178108, 0.025480112060904503, 0.0033405679278075695, -0.01316479966044426, 0.013428894802927971, -0.04546215012669563, -0.005031451117247343, -0.031816333532333374, 0.033542171120643616, 0.04943215847015381, 0.019872494041919708, -0.007697560358792543, 0.004983718041330576, 0.014410675503313541, 0.061067719012498856, 0.045938972383737564, 0.013262606225907803, 0.0036910802591592073, 0.02940092235803604, -0.0018628992838785052, -0.04800495505332947, -0.029321622103452682, 0.011310732923448086, -0.017956485971808434, -0.03728608042001724, -0.02702980302274227, -0.001306302030570805, -0.021495476365089417, -0.0015839417465031147, -0.006761671043932438, -0.002942542312666774, -0.021736623719334602, 0.01170647144317627, 0.010537521913647652, -0.004814888350665569, 0.01811029575765133, -0.017911897972226143, 0.060865554958581924, -0.025827618315815926, -0.04311620816588402, -0.007124640047550201, -0.0682615339756012, 0.003460500156506896, 0.036962199956178665, 0.012895721942186356, 0.03359626978635788, -0.002588613424450159, 0.009882543236017227, 0.034487102180719376, -0.0255728829652071, -0.06480888277292252, -0.02335449680685997, -0.013493290171027184, 0.00330195645801723, -0.03127731755375862, -0.03947076573967934, -0.038324903696775436, 0.029814109206199646, 0.029187684878706932, 0.04772183299064636, -0.02443508431315422, -0.025371765717864037, 0.03130312263965607, 0.01164913084357977, 0.026061268523335457, 0.0571773536503315, -0.028008107095956802, -0.045877862721681595, -0.01967809535562992, -0.011199870146811008, -0.025739872828125954, 0.03721620514988899, -0.03975045680999756, 0.016134200617671013, 0.055375270545482635, 0.07545352727174759, 0.054761942476034164, 0.032989371567964554, -0.0021570383105427027, 0.007810737006366253, 0.09046724438667297, 0.035614896565675735, -0.07457093894481659, 0.027493327856063843, 0.007010329980403185, 0.009898056276142597, -0.053553756326436996, -0.01589018665254116, -0.06143918260931969, 0.03474115952849388, 0.018072839826345444, 0.015603938139975071, -0.04074589163064957, -0.03707582503557205, -0.030135726556181908, -0.026041405275464058, -0.010441317223012447, -0.006843455135822296, 0.0002592770615592599, 0.008845960721373558, 0.10238514840602875, 0.0745134949684143, 0.023582475259900093, -0.04987439140677452, 0.02106591686606407, 0.004993055481463671, -0.0021292604506015778, -0.03235583379864693, -0.004902224987745285, -0.05622769519686699, 0.020920248702168465, 0.015292251482605934, -0.044364556670188904, -0.010397526435554028, 0.021263152360916138, 0.08123898506164551, -0.00396075751632452, -0.008822436444461346, 0.010592347010970116, -0.026632413268089294, 0.017943410202860832, 0.037865277379751205, -0.009447512216866016, -0.05879271775484085, 0.033771343529224396, 0.027395568788051605, -0.016372309997677803, -0.04532968997955322, -0.025065550580620766, 0.057087838649749756, -0.04490868002176285, -0.010133381001651287, -0.03699866682291031, 0.054161567240953445, 0.02092806063592434, 0.008035741746425629, -0.01692049764096737, -0.004268705379217863, 0.05361892282962799, 0.10607122629880905, -0.010749178938567638, -0.05832218751311302, 0.0034139410126954317, -0.036566898226737976, 0.03271110728383064, 0.05668199062347412, 0.013575160875916481, 0.020790766924619675, -0.06403906643390656, 0.05056328698992729, 0.02580147795379162, -0.06842953711748123, -0.002007303759455681, -0.032229628413915634, -0.02103514038026333, 0.024285919964313507, -0.04881195351481438, -0.027771640568971634, 0.023480404168367386, -0.009297100827097893, 0.024143708869814873, -0.01021173968911171, 0.037207379937171936, 0.043457992374897, -0.049260735511779785, 0.004471142776310444, 0.040810476988554, -0.026813216507434845, -0.030918603762984276, 0.006704594008624554, 0.021695047616958618, 0.007909193634986877, -0.04633982852101326, 0.02925451658666134, -0.0570359043776989, 0.02343425340950489, -0.014332184568047523, -0.05828966200351715, 0.03442692384123802, -0.0017352602444589138, -0.0005846972926519811, 0.0532887764275074, 0.04554080590605736, -0.04906369373202324, 0.03580782935023308, -0.012676818296313286, -0.05516917631030083, 0.007151096593588591, -0.013189703226089478, 0.002944110194221139, -0.017498742789030075, -0.03464585915207863, 0.029252009466290474, 0.018335554748773575, 0.0002847440482582897, 0.0020930436439812183, 0.011245706118643284, 0.02990487590432167, -0.019313838332891464, 0.051327887922525406, -0.005470972042530775, 0.004034700337797403, 0.01662386767566204, 0.03953442722558975, 0.01402110792696476, 0.07747071981430054, 0.01365628931671381, 0.009327314794063568, -0.009613349102437496, 0.014691609889268875, -0.030877308920025826, -0.02939189225435257, -0.011845027096569538, 0.03410647436976433, 0.02220567688345909, -0.0022194343619048595, -0.09129711985588074, 0.036761507391929626, -0.019717084243893623, 0.04043508693575859, 0.04979843646287918, 0.010402104817330837, 0.02752862498164177, 0.0007659324910491705, -0.010636663064360619, 0.009424431249499321, -0.02236241288483143, 0.0020455147605389357, -0.020946478471159935, -0.009867660701274872, 0.0016330768121406436, 0.040530864149332047, 0.02685404196381569, 0.03106631338596344, -0.0333784744143486, 0.007731160148978233, -0.008829771541059017, -0.0370962955057621, -0.02331564761698246, 0.007428211160004139, -0.07357966899871826, 0.005421018693596125, -0.028648262843489647, -0.0005158965941518545, 0.005286241881549358, -0.02698470465838909, -0.0032627368345856667, -0.0015894727548584342, -0.006391265895217657, -0.007913460955023766, -0.03482373431324959, 0.033409327268600464, 0.004481562878936529, -0.021104464307427406, -0.03987337648868561, 0.030688541010022163, 0.030101533979177475, 0.0054070777259767056, -0.043185047805309296, -0.02765730582177639, 0.05515167489647865, -0.0021772293839603662, -0.010927141644060612, 0.04273565858602524, -0.04589725285768509, -0.05536113306879997, 0.019922930747270584, -0.018725896254181862, 0.04211491346359253, -0.0031716562807559967, -0.02063426561653614, -0.01020265556871891, -0.029328374192118645, 0.022364016622304916, 0.03937285393476486, 0.03219445422291756, -0.026010796427726746, 0.03378870338201523, 0.03956340625882149, 0.022349555045366287, 0.006882882677018642, -0.03460637480020523, -0.03093474730849266, -0.039709966629743576, 0.02895122580230236, -0.0123826265335083, -0.058343589305877686, -0.002396875759586692, -0.06009528785943985, -0.04396557807922363, -0.0133825046941638, -0.04279639199376106, 0.002462810603901744, -0.009351142682135105, 0.013744386844336987, -0.009462977759540081, -0.02942393161356449, 0.01749802939593792, -0.035923365503549576, 0.05627284571528435, 0.05892804265022278, 0.0017543485155329108, 0.01762997917830944, 0.07535935193300247, -0.06158545985817909, 0.007739745546132326, 0.0006540920003317297, 0.010729714296758175, 0.013205437920987606, 0.011051869951188564, -0.03698253631591797, -0.08380547910928726, -0.07654888182878494, 0.01154771726578474, 0.025235017761588097, -0.024154698476195335, 0.0314817950129509, 0.05642656981945038, 0.015116854570806026, -0.03794755041599274, 0.04136258363723755, 0.02053515985608101, -0.05317900702357292, -0.048617489635944366, 0.008023991249501705, -0.013938316144049168, 0.025855951011180878, 0.027560098096728325, -0.010868635028600693, -0.04717518016695976, -0.023621397092938423, -0.021038001403212547, -0.03477877005934715, 0.010340414941310883, -0.06339359283447266, 0.013667677529156208, 0.004384895786643028, -0.04890770837664604, 0.05300399661064148, 0.006496417801827192, 0.0457024984061718, 0.014825211837887764, -0.08401420712471008, -0.03546615317463875, -0.04591088369488716, -0.03260551765561104, -0.04481925070285797, -0.05387895926833153, -0.02191828191280365, -0.07006711512804031, -0.001478790189139545, -0.0064653973095119, 0.027710195630788803, -0.023922551423311234, -0.035463396459817886, -0.0249923188239336, -0.003884683595970273, -0.008953828364610672, -0.008930744603276253, -0.04192700982093811, 0.0032650167122483253, -0.042463745921850204, -0.035325996577739716, 0.04265369847416878, -0.018973080441355705, 0.00575212761759758, -0.0112503906711936, 0.023134276270866394, -0.04683439061045647, 0.01338335033506155, -0.03504011034965515, 0.008821879513561726, -0.009888437576591969, 0.020043833181262016, 0.04019984230399132, 0.03530219942331314, -0.004219533409923315, 0.012811879627406597, -0.014851733110845089, -0.03652377426624298, 0.08017638325691223, -0.01187354139983654, 0.0014870467130094767, -0.05068686977028847, -0.009505728259682655, -0.01662488281726837, 0.017314106225967407, 0.013510451652109623, 0.008195994421839714, -0.0014936577063053846, 0.020161764696240425, -0.01010223664343357, 0.071709044277668, 0.01790241338312626, -0.013554357923567295, -0.010274061001837254, 0.016814539209008217, -0.025111839175224304, 0.00021546725474763662, -0.04264092445373535, -0.011238079518079758, 0.027324475347995758, -0.01070834044367075, 0.043041717261075974, -0.04625706374645233, 0.025617728009819984, 0.03654803708195686, -0.008328926749527454, -0.02057844214141369, 0.007904508151113987, -0.024308370426297188, -0.0005129803321324289, 0.013610530644655228, 0.09205591678619385, 0.01646619290113449, 0.010108578018844128, -0.06557956337928772, -0.010900930501520634, 0.016687819734215736, -0.028410928323864937, -0.05429614335298538, -0.04425469785928726, -0.03456138074398041, 0.05410992354154587, 0.04520033672451973, -0.05035144463181496, 0.005569908302277327, -0.00008208569488488138, 0.13715212047100067, 0.07324451953172684, -0.038831401616334915, 0.08807490766048431, -0.04715845361351967, -0.0060960385017097, 0.03209436684846878, -0.030381156131625175, 0.0016504869563505054, -0.0041976491920650005, -0.03512587398290634, 0.015517017804086208, -0.02740694209933281, 0.025770194828510284, 0.04216372221708298 ]
<p>In a paper by Gregory and Laflamme (<a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9301052" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9301052</a>) in 1993, it was demonstrated that black strings and $p$-branes which were solutions to certain low energy string theories were unstable by searching for solutions to the perturbation equations,</p> <p>$$\delta R_{ab}=-\frac{1}{2}\Delta_L h_{ab}=0$$</p> <p>where $h_{ab}$ is a linear perturbation, and $\Delta_L$ the Lichnerowicz operator,$^{\dagger}$ computed with respect to the background solution, e.g. a black string. In addition, they formulated an <em>ansatz</em>,</p> <p>$$h^{\mu\nu}= e^{\Omega t} e^{i\mu_i x^i}\left( \begin{matrix} H^{tt} &amp; H^{tr} &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; \dots \\ H^{tr} &amp; H^{rr} &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; \dots \\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; K &amp; 0 &amp; \dots \\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; K/\sin^2 \theta &amp; \dots \\ \dots &amp; \dots &amp; \dots &amp; \dots &amp; \dots \end{matrix} \right)$$</p> <p>My questions are the following:</p> <ol> <li>What is the motivation for the <em>ansatz</em> above?</li> <li>Why are solutions to the perturbation equations which maintain the Ricci curvature (and hence energy-momentum tensor) deemed instabilities?</li> <li>Is the general approach outlined above applied to most solutions to determine instabilities? Are there alternate methods (excluding the entropic argument by comparing solutions' entropies)?</li> </ol> <hr> <p>$\dagger$ In de Donder gauge, the operator is given by $\Delta_L h_{ab}=\left[\delta^c_a \delta^d_b (\nabla_e \nabla^e) +2R^{cd}_{ab}\right]h_{cd}$.</p>
g9776
[ 0.02790260873734951, 0.0018010367639362812, -0.005560235120356083, 0.00979415699839592, 0.08489560335874557, -0.012913718819618225, 0.07097898423671722, -0.02694324031472206, -0.07166475057601929, -0.01264502014964819, -0.0021356784272938967, 0.05164342001080513, 0.05710424855351448, 0.03324403241276741, 0.009010271169245243, 0.0029941964894533157, 0.04563006013631821, 0.023529812693595886, 0.05504833161830902, -0.03739939630031586, -0.05645390972495079, 0.01487202662974596, 0.06163930892944336, -0.037544913589954376, 0.05008573457598686, -0.03512229770421982, 0.016384020447731018, 0.00770058948546648, -0.026978790760040283, 0.018347829580307007, -0.011918669566512108, 0.05146229267120361, 0.028982294723391533, -0.05263691022992134, -0.027883000671863556, -0.040308255702257156, 0.0709524005651474, 0.014820325188338757, 0.004817849025130272, 0.02206183411180973, 0.038101717829704285, -0.05374729260802269, -0.016532082110643387, -0.03661138191819191, -0.005700824316591024, -0.016897641122341156, -0.013870643451809883, 0.021170612424612045, -0.028848392888903618, 0.015603182837367058, 0.03577270358800888, 0.014931665733456612, 0.11761140078306198, -0.04113641008734703, -0.006628609728068113, 0.04576173797249794, -0.03946981206536293, -0.024569526314735413, 0.0075991349294781685, 0.0624501071870327, -0.04238477721810341, -0.05792057514190674, 0.0040320842526853085, -0.008412706665694714, -0.05044473335146904, -0.1165914237499237, -0.010075741447508335, -0.04132852330803871, 0.0721568763256073, -0.014842765405774117, 0.024388784542679787, -0.035157740116119385, 0.024447759613394737, -0.03256094828248024, -0.05419421195983887, 0.005832631140947342, -0.037091732025146484, -0.03859950974583626, 0.014717498794198036, -0.06980887800455093, 0.014785484410822392, 0.040361497551202774, -0.02603011019527912, -0.024466808885335922, 0.07494135946035385, -0.01870758831501007, 0.061747968196868896, 0.059203021228313446, 0.014775278978049755, -0.0008085246663540602, 0.012695330195128918, -0.023703331127762794, 0.008954561315476894, -0.026668280363082886, 0.009734532795846462, 0.009062190540134907, 0.010565193369984627, 0.021234268322587013, -0.01917896419763565, -0.06206874921917915, 0.0086556700989604, 0.03373671695590019, 0.01049492135643959, 0.048408251255750656, 0.02136549912393093, -0.0065281265415251255, 0.01977442391216755, -0.004302835091948509, 0.01278764009475708, 0.02761756256222725, -0.02361348271369934, -0.017899416387081146, -0.021859046071767807, -0.060130976140499115, 0.011038155294954777, 0.00799711886793375, 0.012274304404854774, -0.07473152875900269, -0.022890815511345863, 0.06340675801038742, -0.03396362066268921, -0.02008158713579178, 0.038406867533922195, 0.00858039129525423, 0.024364057928323746, 0.005268339533358812, -0.015808748081326485, -0.041990697383880615, 0.06648024916648865, 0.004253986291587353, 0.027914850041270256, 0.0290229432284832, 0.004942709114402533, 0.03554321080446243, 0.039336420595645905, 0.06059633195400238, -0.040946029126644135, 0.054344017058610916, -0.010407841764390469, -0.04163181409239769, -0.0054298886097967625, -0.0823817104101181, 0.01454309280961752, 0.04029349237680435, -0.007190103642642498, -0.006542237941175699, -0.012814247980713844, -0.005776776932179928, -0.0036269458942115307, 0.04495605453848839, -0.03303322196006775, 0.06662909686565399, -0.011611148715019226, 0.004566911142319441, 0.013540690764784813, 0.04872332513332367, 0.04463237151503563, 0.03568495064973831, -0.022643540054559708, 0.039791982620954514, 0.034059956669807434, -0.018483450636267662, 0.023091569542884827, 0.02801513485610485, 0.007776767481118441, 0.01093586627393961, -0.009479462169110775, -0.028752606362104416, 0.02502640336751938, -0.03747985139489174, -0.041997261345386505, 0.01809941790997982, 0.04432404413819313, 0.01020125113427639, 0.04110877588391304, 0.01013383362442255, -0.024189837276935577, -0.01353746373206377, 0.05841074138879776, -0.039024874567985535, -0.024358538910746574, -0.008112110197544098, 0.06763174384832382, -0.04375226050615311, 0.05611884966492653, 0.05092604085803032, -0.02581617422401905, -0.024900352582335472, -0.01770482398569584, -0.020910926163196564, -0.019602645188570023, -0.0255123283714056, -0.010294958017766476, 0.06000902131199837, 0.02762509137392044, 0.005840386264026165, 0.03745289891958237, -0.08214390277862549, 0.0060674580745399, 0.06492593139410019, 0.02913745678961277, 0.04257011041045189, 0.015499728731811047, -0.007627473212778568, -0.03126947209239006, -0.015414665453135967, -0.030981678515672684, 0.0064984941855072975, 0.048458896577358246, -0.03304240480065346, -0.026947779580950737, -0.06988600641489029, 0.05215051397681236, 0.027674321085214615, -0.05205314978957176, -0.010116907767951488, 0.026670286431908607, 0.03571827709674835, -0.0030182315967977047, 0.05005858466029167, -0.01523490622639656, -0.020988814532756805, -0.029152290895581245, 0.10979688912630081, -0.031444236636161804, 0.016511498019099236, -0.07675790786743164, -0.04168323054909706, 0.018460705876350403, -0.018248116597533226, -0.04851920157670975, -0.02537650242447853, -0.004285114351660013, 0.04038495197892189, 0.013297867961227894, 0.003823281265795231, 0.08504980802536011, -0.035808514803647995, -0.007736216299235821, 0.009336205199360847, 0.0015231294091790915, -0.019896091893315315, 0.006599290296435356, 0.0313541404902935, -0.01725621335208416, 0.015004631131887436, 0.03189528360962868, -0.04471974819898605, -0.06590262800455093, 0.0013653411297127604, -0.03530510514974594, -0.005836388561874628, -0.012022525072097778, 0.022046953439712524, 0.002421610290184617, -0.03665745258331299, 0.018170924857258797, 0.023438405245542526, 0.006765218451619148, 0.008624738082289696, 0.04509955644607544, 0.04797004163265228, -0.021762022748589516, 0.016962146386504173, -0.09974323213100433, -0.00036259100306779146, -0.029705319553613663, -0.02697703428566456, -0.02442271076142788, 0.01685379445552826, -0.009531890973448753, 0.0302291102707386, -0.00821780413389206, 0.039175961166620255, 0.027699066326022148, -0.020884381607174873, -0.028651315718889236, 0.005170923657715321, 0.020276468247175217, -0.0434158593416214, -0.024811681360006332, -0.008151637390255928, -0.06768158078193665, -0.00899533275514841, -0.016101893037557602, -0.03154945746064186, -0.0345868356525898, -0.015055704861879349, 0.038720328360795975, 0.0009389666374772787, 0.01549055427312851, 0.021275756880640984, -0.040367770940065384, -0.014588095247745514, -0.07245737314224243, 0.013880636543035507, -0.0038322829641401768, -0.048162177205085754, -0.007306438405066729, 0.036421213299036026, 0.0324222594499588, 0.06900260597467422, -0.02859330363571644, 0.01132472325116396, 0.022247716784477234, -0.04463716223835945, -0.10224229842424393, -0.05863534286618233, 0.022637754678726196, 0.056494276970624924, -0.02494906820356846, -0.05155039578676224, -0.02314957045018673, 0.022299587726593018, 0.0050326865166425705, 0.03401663154363632, -0.03853809833526611, -0.00899580493569374, 0.020428188145160675, -0.06623055785894394, -0.048921674489974976, -0.005108174402266741, 0.014115205965936184, -0.026614846661686897, 0.00184905668720603, 0.00786317978054285, -0.05142371729016304, -0.00392602663487196, -0.046139247715473175, -0.01427472848445177, 0.010890334844589233, 0.00016944044909905642, 0.06422145664691925, 0.009441177360713482, -0.014593342319130898, -0.06402010470628738, 0.0069354441948235035, 0.0294187031686306, 0.05731012299656868, 0.0215316005051136, 0.0014579042326658964, -0.024190839380025864, -0.009869001805782318, 0.015888726338744164, 0.002725115278735757, 0.046389542520046234, 0.03058008663356304, 0.006467306055128574, -0.010019795969128609, -0.01701362244784832, 0.0026430680882185698, -0.021148188039660454, 0.021367553621530533, -0.04556700587272644, -0.02206968143582344, 0.025119071826338768, 0.051411449909210205, -0.008036071434617043, 0.03517847880721092, 0.028226131573319435, -0.026516444981098175, -0.002919750986620784, -0.042136311531066895, -0.018977029249072075, -0.03355337306857109, -0.01625165529549122, 0.016341738402843475, 0.0075807576067745686, -0.06571560353040695, -0.035489246249198914, 0.044675398617982864, 0.02113449200987816, 0.021870741620659828, -0.007374289445579052, 0.0034749070182442665, -0.010754641145467758, 0.0050245425663888454, 0.004494904074817896, 0.009174920618534088, 0.03597385808825493, 0.007893326692283154, 0.005474483128637075, -0.012378891929984093, 0.02986491098999977, -0.03466417267918587, 0.04314389452338219, -0.007159774657338858, -0.009447374381124973, -0.025842463597655296, -0.019804762676358223, -0.02558225393295288, -0.0286551620811224, -0.00029386335518211126, -0.03666166216135025, 0.01910903863608837, 0.058119893074035645, -0.03034384734928608, 0.04804417863488197, 0.005512616131454706, -0.029594646766781807, 0.03215194493532181, -0.0337853766977787, 0.02759609930217266, -0.03753324970602989, 0.026815470308065414, 0.04559764638543129, -0.050544142723083496, 0.036893267184495926, 0.017226310446858406, -0.001181531697511673, 0.08458200842142105, -0.003675979096442461, 0.03628429397940636, -0.06266345083713531, 0.041128989309072495, -0.06235261261463165, 0.053978707641363144, -0.0276231337338686, -0.012343847192823887, -0.02632000297307968, 0.02100243978202343, -0.041928600519895554, -0.007802150212228298, -0.03375446796417236, 0.003825331339612603, 0.07108259201049805, 0.03223346546292305, 0.024064641445875168, 0.04366273805499077, 0.02446357160806656, 0.013417765498161316, -0.035638097673654556, 0.020398639142513275, 0.022587740793824196, -0.03556246683001518, 0.030197253450751305, -0.03130514547228813, 0.007616730406880379, 0.017755785956978798, 0.05281426012516022, 0.0821368470788002, -0.006990479771047831, 0.04515144228935242, -0.07169261574745178, -0.06457652151584625, -0.030475029721856117, 0.01931360363960266, -0.017218178138136864, 0.006661975756287575, -0.008392822928726673, 0.0005234417621977627, 0.013189997524023056, 0.01710066758096218, -0.015283006243407726, -0.023528385907411575, -0.04361627250909805, -0.027156606316566467, 0.047728899866342545, -0.006309059448540211, 0.0007612771587446332, 0.015933115035295486, -0.01755310222506523, -0.05511714890599251, 0.029777944087982178, 0.04274015501141548, -0.0461246557533741, 0.012987969443202019, -0.03500926494598389, -0.020398525521159172, -0.05812891572713852, 0.026379553601145744, 0.04158586636185646, 0.026874443516135216, -0.08634167164564133, 0.04097528010606766, -0.01659497246146202, -0.03992857038974762, -0.0009521052706986666, -0.06546767801046371, -0.0439620278775692, -0.03514401987195015, -0.01731240563094616, -0.03589685261249542, 0.010081282816827297, 0.01378557551652193, -0.028000617399811745, 0.0031743987929075956, -0.0017792661674320698, 0.005083851516246796, 0.005541693419218063, 0.007112836465239525, 0.032417986541986465, 0.018341951072216034, -0.03904236480593681, 0.005171497818082571, -0.014533976092934608, 0.015045439824461937, 0.02765693888068199, -0.023430489003658295, 0.0005505303270183504, -0.05493590608239174, -0.004753365181386471, -0.02286257967352867, -0.026177501305937767, 0.028221147134900093, 0.0026051567401736975, 0.06880505383014679, -0.023569010198116302, 0.0560639314353466, 0.017249081283807755, 0.00035215160460211337, 0.07455363869667053, 0.0070120650343596935, 0.061854537576436996, 0.017188940197229385, -0.02223191224038601, -0.025471754372119904, 0.022828474640846252, -0.06650274246931076, -0.07248920947313309, 0.03943094611167908, -0.02952185459434986, -0.0024298576172441244, -0.008685718290507793, 0.10332480818033218, 0.06260788440704346, -0.06352483481168747, -0.018171830102801323, -0.009187859483063221, -0.04112737625837326, -0.002104922430589795, 0.009860888123512268, -0.0069343456998467445, -0.05518403276801109, 0.01547411922365427, -0.056548550724983215, 0.003152376739308238, 0.008150890469551086, -0.020407184958457947, -0.03660087659955025, 0.03807895630598068, 0.05140320956707001, -0.009388511069118977, 0.06504722684621811, -0.0370001494884491, 0.004675785079598427, 0.05667923763394356, 0.01823820173740387, -0.03014501743018627, -0.08543164283037186, -0.02730311080813408, 0.0493801087141037, -0.013181998394429684, -0.007915289141237736, -0.018460866063833237, -0.004601872526109219, 0.04286351427435875, -0.06120909005403519, -0.02987189218401909, 0.04424700513482094, 0.06481175124645233, -0.04083681106567383, 0.02054538019001484, 0.042017530649900436, 0.07041852176189423, -0.00895033311098814, -0.026996025815606117, 0.008864171802997589, 0.0014607153134420514, 0.05221311375498772, -0.029340090230107307, 0.04520412161946297, -0.008048059418797493, 0.0360446497797966, 0.019028590992093086, -0.006914105731993914, -0.044916920363903046, -0.08748335391283035, -0.041821226477622986, -0.06085406616330147, -0.026502352207899094, 0.045236699283123016, 0.06058351323008537, -0.03730778396129608, -0.054762162268161774, -0.026489663869142532, -0.0030309446156024933, -0.030603963881731033, 0.04527687281370163, 0.010535708628594875, -0.01185142993927002, 0.04051535949110985, -0.014868172816932201, -0.014353330247104168, -0.04354167729616165, 0.12978045642375946, -0.0111067621037364, 0.016957804560661316, -0.03877519443631172, -0.019867239519953728, 0.06497475504875183, 0.023870054632425308, 0.026921605691313744, 0.04061095416545868, -0.013524910435080528, -0.001391799421980977, -0.018381016328930855, 0.017512932419776917, -0.06505763530731201, 0.04746897518634796, 0.019349483773112297, 0.01080289576202631, -0.01938316784799099, -0.017698325216770172, -0.0015151133993640542, 0.018548980355262756, -0.05334492027759552, 0.014791246503591537, 0.007145467679947615, 0.04195832833647728, 0.019729459658265114, -0.04871981963515282, 0.026657668873667717, -0.026231316849589348, 0.03447992354631424, 0.027064451947808266, -0.006287101190537214, -0.020887019112706184, -0.027553709223866463, 0.03318078815937042, 0.010841598734259605, -0.00015781298861838877, -0.03170681372284889, 0.060789525508880615, -0.019990939646959305, -0.005599511321634054, -0.04268191382288933, 0.03778062015771866, -0.011020354926586151, 0.02500983700156212, -0.01815715804696083, 0.0066802180372178555, 0.05821520835161209, -0.05633793771266937, -0.023029180243611336, 0.045991383492946625, 0.05648375675082207, -0.027891987934708595, -0.03080848790705204, 0.021847572177648544, 0.012145224027335644, -0.023514503613114357, -0.016350222751498222, -0.03364555537700653, -0.003273781156167388, -0.050969161093235016, -0.04821314290165901, -0.01025873888283968, 0.018544908612966537, -0.07742635160684586, 0.012840447947382927, 0.06946735829114914, 0.06036550924181938, 0.04429914429783821, -0.0012238086201250553, 0.0226737167686224, 0.003957837354391813, -0.016025641933083534, 0.08655685931444168, 0.01578814908862114, 0.01705249957740307, -0.029684966430068016, -0.05477587506175041, -0.02815648727118969, -0.03451502323150635, -0.006947672925889492, 0.0062891035340726376, 0.04088955000042915, -0.007508570794016123, 0.04087068513035774, 0.0522414892911911, -0.01563030667603016, 0.010270140133798122, 0.012584810145199299, -0.05305631831288338, 0.017616819590330124, 0.014596343971788883, 0.03740167245268822, -0.010968361981213093, 0.020541025325655937, -0.015584411099553108, 0.07739947736263275, -0.017587900161743164, 0.01799515262246132, -0.04517872631549835, -0.027444351464509964, -0.03753863647580147, 0.036625638604164124, 0.041776370257139206, 0.0027189578395336866, -0.02529132179915905, -0.049897029995918274, 0.04588610306382179, 0.02630523219704628, -0.0008648737566545606, 0.010847973637282848, -0.02384592592716217, -0.05369222164154053, -0.03923304006457329, 0.029756350442767143, -0.01785544492304325, -0.014792311936616898, -0.007066537160426378, -0.011036423034965992, 0.016871942207217216, -0.02415531314909458, 0.010814848355948925, -0.016988292336463928, -0.0611344613134861, 0.014317421242594719, 0.04108792915940285, -0.037958599627017975, 0.013149358332157135, -0.01176263764500618, -0.006031673867255449, -0.06005872040987015, 0.0015392329078167677, -0.02657567709684372, -0.045094083994627, -0.007093584630638361, -0.05771605297923088, -0.04529780149459839, -0.05393754690885544, -0.02868327684700489, -0.029847294092178345, 0.049173276871442795, -0.017293376848101616, -0.007288436871021986, 0.07328565418720245, -0.01936151273548603, 0.05815709009766579, -0.06458314508199692, -0.04608184099197388, -0.004435194190591574, 0.009308147244155407, 0.01670560985803604, 0.02217927575111389, 0.008266806602478027, 0.030622659251093864, 0.004724770784378052, -0.0035223178565502167, -0.005475747399032116, 0.00027652058633975685, 0.0804145410656929, 0.053441278636455536, 0.01586863212287426, -0.01944565400481224, -0.00596193503588438, 0.04633903130888939, 0.026654962450265884, 0.0019003232009708881, -0.039524197578430176, 0.0009293944458477199, -0.018499530851840973, -0.03839312866330147, -0.03477119654417038, -0.00159413309302181, 0.014718993566930294 ]
<p>I have often heard it said that several problems in the theory of electromagnetism as described by Maxwell's equations led Einstein to his theory of Special Relativity. What exactly were these problems that Einstein had in mind, and how does <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_special_relativity">Special Relativity</a> solve them?</p>
g9777
[ 0.03232279419898987, 0.04004528373479843, -0.010772433131933212, 0.037649065256118774, 0.048369150608778, 0.046656545251607895, 0.07288549840450287, 0.07333441823720932, 0.01800909824669361, 0.01006407756358385, -0.0605512335896492, -0.011360369622707367, 0.04331238195300102, 0.019329015165567398, -0.035266146063804626, -0.016388490796089172, 0.04686173051595688, 0.00048457359662279487, -0.025878533720970154, -0.021826840937137604, 0.08597356826066971, -0.022437596693634987, 0.03981280326843262, -0.01458768267184496, -0.012750642374157906, -0.011022421531379223, -0.022167177870869637, 0.021377306431531906, -0.026502083986997604, -0.053154248744249344, 0.0004462836659513414, 0.029718849807977676, 0.03011188842356205, -0.017921561375260353, 0.025375187397003174, -0.06244537979364395, -0.03369219973683357, 0.04896257072687149, 0.014133589342236519, 0.01971161924302578, 0.020416226238012314, -0.047599148005247116, -0.029250212013721466, -0.018964212387800217, 0.06122196093201637, -0.02722826786339283, -0.04087541624903679, 0.03247116506099701, -0.05489300563931465, -0.021431757137179375, 0.04184892773628235, 0.05262436717748642, 0.062270376831293106, 0.022722747176885605, 0.05638085678219795, 0.00032921473030000925, 0.03125866875052452, 0.022009341046214104, 0.06348846107721329, -0.0021211691200733185, -0.02120177075266838, -0.017209725454449654, 0.04732908681035042, 0.03123980201780796, 0.015590718016028404, -0.015175632201135159, 0.05268356204032898, -0.07072238624095917, 0.022008156403899193, 0.011221777647733688, 0.017495008185505867, -0.03687868267297745, 0.005571003071963787, -0.02079695276916027, -0.012216114439070225, 0.014583168551325798, 0.06771697103977203, 0.015706904232501984, -0.004065833054482937, 0.021705947816371918, -0.010306333191692829, -0.004903774242848158, -0.01983003132045269, -0.041025225073099136, 0.08261647820472717, 0.034104932099580765, -0.048181500285863876, 0.019477248191833496, -0.01607559435069561, -0.018002644181251526, -0.04157146438956261, 0.012647767551243305, 0.035302404314279556, 0.0009465602342970669, -0.014378600753843784, -0.0491512157022953, 0.011417122557759285, 0.0033817037474364042, 0.04728903993964195, -0.0221774410456419, -0.05761970207095146, -0.046578895300626755, -0.0017970434855669737, 0.015634823590517044, 0.004046211484819651, 0.029503801837563515, -0.002511660335585475, 0.09396195411682129, 0.003264501690864563, 0.02822643332183361, -0.08850052952766418, -0.05213318392634392, -0.027501443400979042, -0.008498459123075008, -0.04824908822774887, -0.010997951030731201, 0.031181009486317635, -0.030016101896762848, -0.012510331347584724, 0.008198177441954613, -0.02844732627272606, 0.032469332218170166, -0.013476338237524033, 0.015110724605619907, -0.03982673957943916, 0.03790752589702606, 0.015910079702734947, -0.006363986991345882, -0.016367610543966293, 0.008960292674601078, 0.014728584326803684, -0.013712958432734013, -0.006129415240138769, -0.013157946057617664, -0.0379507839679718, 0.05494353547692299, -0.006497912108898163, -0.05186154320836067, 0.004897668492048979, -0.014164253138005733, 0.048877157270908356, -0.007470789831131697, 0.016682930290699005, -0.02573593147099018, -0.007420793175697327, -0.007161449640989304, -0.03973529115319252, 0.021896274760365486, -0.05723598599433899, 0.00509850587695837, -0.04866673797369003, 0.06952571868896484, -0.01276487298309803, -0.08394309133291245, 0.02546193078160286, -0.014316815882921219, -0.018149785697460175, 0.007267986424267292, -0.014116514474153519, -0.016010141000151634, 0.06487623602151871, -0.04762190580368042, 0.029803046956658363, 0.0240985918790102, -0.034083787351846695, 0.039200302213430405, -0.006239643320441246, -0.06238965317606926, 0.026298683136701584, -0.008488998748362064, -0.011475556530058384, -0.0036373483017086983, 0.055048417299985886, 0.0593097060918808, 0.04494498297572136, 0.05939600244164467, 0.014987880364060402, -0.045602764934301376, 0.07480429112911224, -0.0011708242818713188, -0.05012050271034241, 0.0044790273532271385, 0.015562319196760654, -0.03929577395319939, -0.017455821856856346, 0.010951622389256954, -0.04153725132346153, -0.028117969632148743, -0.03170465677976608, 0.0023421563673764467, -0.021989472210407257, 0.022701414301991463, -0.003008177736774087, 0.05797581002116203, -0.00323574454523623, 0.022061416879296303, 0.0021540189627557993, -0.019988222047686577, -0.032035402953624725, 0.024038447067141533, -0.009352450259029865, 0.054633669555187225, -0.01662253588438034, -0.009284967556595802, -0.0026026659179478884, 0.01399326790124178, 0.004719482734799385, -0.07330881804227829, 0.12087005376815796, 0.03549917787313461, 0.016984188929200172, -0.04147060960531235, 0.015719126909971237, -0.06341846287250519, -0.07923661917448044, 0.006719422526657581, -0.008002622984349728, -0.007709199097007513, -0.04242352768778801, 0.065875343978405, -0.02617609314620495, -0.022049680352211, -0.010534331202507019, 0.0435207225382328, -0.02904902771115303, -0.0005883014528080821, -0.030202925205230713, -0.032510869204998016, -0.03788748010993004, -0.037109896540641785, -0.020254425704479218, 0.020377373322844505, 0.010093148797750473, -0.028534667566418648, 0.06381186842918396, 0.007612952962517738, -0.04684524983167648, -0.0827949121594429, 0.03509275242686272, -0.032739512622356415, -0.03497486189007759, 0.005704134702682495, 0.05924123153090477, -0.016093498095870018, -0.01746021956205368, -0.027485057711601257, 0.06642726063728333, -0.053888771682977676, -0.06103129684925079, 0.038489628583192825, -0.002680483041331172, -0.03936946019530296, -0.03238046541810036, 0.03873370215296745, 0.02073403261601925, -0.017234770581126213, 0.021104633808135986, 0.044591981917619705, -0.011242957785725594, -0.016472745686769485, -0.029008597135543823, -0.038971658796072006, 0.004358320496976376, 0.008702963590621948, -0.06520135700702667, -0.030417336151003838, -0.07326814532279968, 0.0022921247873455286, 0.012369979172945023, -0.02130810171365738, -0.05169559270143509, 0.040958087891340256, -0.030109072104096413, -0.03491684049367905, 0.007533378899097443, -0.03794431686401367, 0.008414361625909805, 0.02799910679459572, 0.06489582359790802, 0.000008398232239414938, -0.03199901804327965, -0.006196398753672838, -0.05069167912006378, -0.04175270348787308, 0.024791423231363297, -0.06712206453084946, -0.012684100307524204, -0.016147077083587646, 0.03421291708946228, 0.007453655358403921, -0.01815422810614109, 0.009156552143394947, 0.04754563048481941, -0.04126186668872833, -0.016153570264577866, 0.07635713368654251, 0.011290821246802807, -0.029489753767848015, -0.11354807764291763, -0.02497853711247444, 0.04181637987494469, 0.05079982429742813, 0.011201716028153896, -0.024317165836691856, -0.03818059340119362, -0.0017862520180642605, -0.012598343193531036, -0.006431041285395622, 0.012381416745483875, -0.029853779822587967, -0.03759779781103134, 0.059839677065610886, 0.039236247539520264, 0.01322402898222208, -0.05772285535931587, 0.02493678592145443, -0.004144483245909214, -0.006101752165704966, 0.0902593731880188, -0.0032116970978677273, -0.04193458333611488, -0.019216781482100487, 0.01341540738940239, -0.03205462917685509, 0.07279707491397858, 0.021387629210948944, -0.01843968778848648, -0.0101026501506567, 0.02841711975634098, 0.07083602249622345, -0.03470735251903534, -0.018604183569550514, -0.1016024649143219, 0.02363278903067112, -0.02221987582743168, 0.0024536324199289083, -0.03601358085870743, 0.04145435988903046, 0.0072247800417244434, -0.04145471379160881, 0.06866199523210526, -0.04936416819691658, -0.08188866078853607, -0.01621079258620739, -0.0037743281573057175, 0.0719911977648735, 0.039399389177560806, -0.002920691855251789, 0.01575419120490551, -0.03952962905168533, -0.0029070593882352114, -0.01153132226318121, -0.013444212265312672, 0.05191556364297867, -0.03379940241575241, -0.006486693862825632, 0.02700466476380825, 0.05909926816821098, 0.047795794904232025, 0.008201826363801956, 0.008195217698812485, 0.04042069986462593, -0.01911412738263607, 0.03248543292284012, -0.02315366268157959, -0.034780554473400116, 0.008612734265625477, -0.011455773375928402, -0.03477150946855545, -0.04773321375250816, 0.07365602254867554, 0.018085932359099388, 0.025930866599082947, 0.014858500100672245, 0.006392381154000759, -0.04070177674293518, -0.023625219240784645, 0.025812113657593727, -0.058886636048555374, 0.023731736466288567, -0.007268897723406553, 0.06444908678531647, 0.04446394369006157, -0.01038332562893629, 0.041581183671951294, -0.042774301022291183, -0.00885965395718813, 0.0008246690849773586, -0.02102862484753132, -0.010789462365210056, 0.0028975990135222673, 0.04067858308553696, -0.052612222731113434, -0.03507285565137863, -0.002326782327145338, -0.0007495380123145878, 0.021804751828312874, -0.01364956609904766, 0.04678165167570114, 0.004022363573312759, 0.04755423218011856, 0.034652434289455414, 0.059504084289073944, 0.012467275373637676, -0.03619605675339699, -0.0015538090374320745, 0.0401286743581295, -0.02364363893866539, 0.04189786687493324, 0.049118850380182266, 0.0027585693169385195, 0.024436043575406075, -0.010787595994770527, -0.06478720158338547, 0.044940635561943054, -0.012893227860331535, 0.0030273315496742725, -0.0023646049667149782, -0.004538300447165966, -0.010895938612520695, 0.013045432046055794, 0.007936391979455948, 0.017909938469529152, -0.059334930032491684, 0.035357099026441574, 0.07434777170419693, 0.0698351263999939, 0.0025390852242708206, -0.004378279205411673, 0.008485590107738972, 0.0018823391292244196, 0.003499327227473259, -0.0315067395567894, 0.021183108910918236, -0.030950337648391724, -0.008595732972025871, 0.04760516434907913, -0.00904573779553175, -0.0021333445329219103, -0.00928776990622282, 0.04299582913517952, 0.014502519741654396, 0.042525939643383026, -0.025490956380963326, -0.03721601143479347, 0.00015406368765980005, 0.009715555235743523, -0.009776122868061066, -0.07265347987413406, -0.00901477038860321, 0.000247305870288983, 0.014764102175831795, -0.018049059435725212, 0.016519704833626747, -0.045962657779455185, 0.01674412563443184, -0.011466506868600845, 0.05016929283738136, 0.04603427276015282, 0.06742117553949356, -0.0034405167680233717, -0.04543495178222656, -0.01247092429548502, 0.01739712990820408, 0.06431259959936142, -0.029772229492664337, -0.028147006407380104, -0.013403150252997875, -0.10256931185722351, -0.02015342190861702, -0.017565151676535606, 0.01742313988506794, 0.027950122952461243, 0.00030774707556702197, 0.031451620161533356, 0.01997273415327072, -0.005622717086225748, 0.002408948028460145, -0.04805203527212143, 0.008741570636630058, 0.008236952126026154, -0.016467858105897903, -0.04578283801674843, 0.045782670378685, -0.00011308933608233929, -0.021152857691049576, -0.020734023302793503, 0.0746830478310585, -0.0390106625854969, -0.08488211035728455, -0.04411410540342331, 0.025120148435235023, 0.04989991709589958, -0.05723598599433899, -0.06124883517622948, -0.013771254569292068, -0.025643303990364075, 0.0458279550075531, -0.016489094123244286, -0.029660314321517944, 0.010749920271337032, 0.04072785750031471, -0.018840277567505836, -0.018422776833176613, 0.01769586279988289, -0.05252654105424881, -0.03353017568588257, 0.08923549205064774, -0.02401077188551426, 0.008711092174053192, -0.02468258887529373, 0.004853040911257267, 0.022734088823199272, 0.02306218631565571, 0.040377553552389145, 0.0033503014128655195, -0.04725763201713562, 0.0018653664737939835, 0.0744757130742073, -0.027342932298779488, -0.018422409892082214, -0.012658612802624702, 0.013704918324947357, -0.027548478916287422, 0.01943100616335869, -0.010077769868075848, -0.050589337944984436, 0.004425967577844858, 0.02770112454891205, -0.05321207642555237, 0.0062843551859259605, -0.0016015523578971624, 0.05355500802397728, -0.030758967623114586, 0.03503157198429108, -0.0568108931183815, 0.06347335875034332, -0.015825770795345306, -0.009128168225288391, 0.06145583838224411, -0.0011361618526279926, 0.02513897605240345, 0.020006351172924042, 0.05768285691738129, -0.0016248584724962711, -0.04359474033117294, -0.006417693104594946, 0.02820693887770176, 0.07148223370313644, -0.06012199446558952, -0.06675949692726135, 0.025679634883999825, 0.008708363398909569, -0.005242492537945509, -0.03830280900001526, 0.0299396775662899, 0.03324957564473152, -0.03406709060072899, 0.0067049297504127026, -0.0300573892891407, 0.057374004274606705, -0.04933742433786392, 0.004961383529007435, 0.0024207462556660175, -0.05750063806772232, -0.042739491909742355, 0.024437688291072845, 0.007596664596349001, 0.033625464886426926, 0.02880137413740158, -0.009231358766555786, 0.035938967019319534, 0.009515889920294285, 0.01892213150858879, -0.009772438555955887, -0.0019184121629223228, -0.0007676639943383634, -0.002130264649167657, -0.04984358698129654, 0.008463500067591667, 0.016485687345266342, 0.02488441951572895, 0.07037883251905441, -0.03601634502410889, -0.032012466341257095, 0.05075365677475929, -0.04516998678445816, -0.009173392318189144, 0.04759613052010536, -0.07914451509714127, 0.003781986888498068, 0.03164245933294296, 0.013791008852422237, -0.04831540212035179, -0.03890732675790787, -0.027341820299625397, 0.06625252217054367, 0.001612012623809278, -0.013608045876026154, 0.05551641061902046, 0.03177330642938614, 0.013784108683466911, 0.03424230217933655, 0.09492766857147217, 0.022286755964159966, -0.0002079364494420588, -0.03686936944723129, -0.008279843255877495, 0.042920105159282684, -0.022152472287416458, 0.006423059850931168, -0.021376818418502808, -0.06112417206168175, -0.011361867189407349, -0.00541067635640502, 0.012886452488601208, -0.012806754559278488, 0.03398631140589714, -0.002418442629277706, -0.03207376226782799, 0.02183770202100277, 0.006187440361827612, 0.0034797927364706993, 0.012047230266034603, 0.016283268108963966, -0.019993232563138008, 0.04165942966938019, -0.0267714224755764, 0.05731241777539253, -0.0014800706412643194, -0.016601551324129105, 0.029187439009547234, -0.027186477556824684, -0.009726819582283497, 0.019918391481041908, -0.018952172249555588, 0.022030355408787727, -0.04443958029150963, -0.017946522682905197, 0.0382070429623127, -0.0552218034863472, -0.03247227519750595, 0.010226954706013203, 0.023334983736276627, -0.07514984905719757, 0.02840120531618595, 0.02023804746568203, -0.01898297667503357, -0.06848378479480743, 0.04654356464743614, 0.006225749384611845, -0.0360892191529274, -0.0443958081305027, -0.01293279230594635, -0.06501549482345581, -0.036631662398576736, -0.07324814796447754, 0.007457937579602003, 0.022067904472351074, -0.04634958505630493, -0.021772513166069984, 0.05277836695313454, -0.036344900727272034, -0.005899866111576557, 0.007258707191795111, 0.0564444325864315, 0.030239103361964226, -0.05854126065969467, 0.008819733746349812, -0.025317585095763206, -0.007918735034763813, -0.008006272837519646, -0.01722770556807518, 0.041108716279268265, -0.011847961694002151, -0.035845257341861725, 0.002054647309705615, 0.0316692553460598, -0.005847051739692688, -0.0397622212767601, -0.01365584135055542, 0.09130875021219254, -0.01812887378036976, -0.0291811004281044, -0.008229529485106468, 0.026942623779177666, -0.019845718517899513, 0.009192614816129208, -0.02918854169547558, 0.039674632251262665, 0.003827841253951192, 0.0015911293448880315, -0.02620505355298519, 0.046321529895067215, 0.01577930338680744, -0.012360009364783764, 0.026085877791047096, 0.06789229065179825, 0.04429085925221443, -0.022402413189411163, -0.04789406806230545, -0.006523025222122669, 0.0015661113429814577, 0.022792527452111244, 0.020194711163640022, -0.015752991661429405, -0.05688030272722244, -0.02753891423344612, -0.023668019101023674, 0.04691104590892792, -0.016578910872340202, 0.01026210468262434, 0.037715230137109756, 0.05043760687112808, -0.01660776138305664, 0.06672413647174835, -0.05990239232778549, 0.006433085538446903, 0.005004908889532089, -0.021465040743350983, -0.0411546565592289, 0.058129046112298965, -0.01785416528582573, -0.0250232070684433, 0.03679002821445465, 0.04848660156130791, 0.0658641830086708, 0.000912033545318991, -0.017196115106344223, -0.04613060504198074, 0.036028288304805756, -0.01951744593679905, -0.015835115686058998, 0.0706077590584755, -0.01633216254413128, -0.02660520188510418, -0.024790413677692413, -0.024585865437984467, 0.01966859959065914, -0.007971642538905144, 0.019736701622605324, -0.018012242391705513, -0.018083637580275536, -0.03840557485818863, -0.003291014116257429, -0.05697338655591011, -0.01194952242076397, 0.01834867149591446, 0.0234963521361351, 0.014455853030085564, -0.04007642716169357, -0.002038169652223587, -0.06181573495268822, 0.027171092107892036, 0.07227147370576859, -0.04012550786137581, 0.03055661730468273, -0.01276655588299036, 0.03453339263796806, 0.050608761608600616, -0.030688321217894554, -0.013030101545155048, 0.005613135639578104, 0.012860218994319439, -0.019040485844016075, -0.005663521122187376, 0.04883838817477226, -0.014988627284765244 ]
<blockquote> <p>We have a point charge $q&gt;0$ in vacuum at a distance $a$ from the center $M$ of an isolated metal sphere that has a total charge $-q$ and radius $R$. ($a&gt;R$)</p> <p>A) Use the method of images to find a charge configuration that has the same boundary conditions. (hint: you need 3 charges)</p> </blockquote> <p>For question A I know that my point charge $q$ should stay in the same place and that I need to place 2 other point charges inside the sphere. But I can't figure out what the charge and place of these two charges should be.</p> <p>My book (introduction to Electrodynamics, Griffiths) has an example where the sphere isn't charged but they seem to magically find the answer. They place a new charge $q'=-\frac{R}{a}q$ at a distance $b=\frac{R^2}{a}$ but they don't explain how this is a logical configuration. Can someone please explain this to me, as I would like to know how to place my point charges for different situations and not just one.</p>
g9778
[ 0.1102018877863884, -0.019237006083130836, -0.019745731726288795, -0.016077980399131775, 0.11905168741941452, 0.013621829450130463, 0.024321354925632477, -0.026568109169602394, -0.0676458477973938, 0.020475275814533234, -0.0232583899050951, 0.04983508214354515, -0.009974868968129158, 0.027191685512661934, -0.045787155628204346, 0.021925076842308044, 0.06725676357746124, -0.02721027284860611, 0.012122554704546928, -0.031609080731868744, 0.006830667611211538, 0.00595937529578805, 0.002059785183519125, -0.027544807642698288, -0.04828869551420212, -0.0012311728205531836, 0.03107030689716339, 0.05024038255214691, -0.001172957243397832, -0.04765026271343231, 0.027959341183304787, 0.010971524752676487, 0.0517430379986763, -0.012060295790433884, -0.04573473334312439, -0.03341062739491463, 0.07653051614761353, 0.0037230998277664185, -0.03922001272439957, -0.055762920528650284, 0.03203947842121124, -0.040691837668418884, 0.007910273969173431, -0.004902923479676247, -0.03422318771481514, -0.05802891403436661, -0.013467206619679928, 0.024965157732367516, 0.0389152355492115, -0.0037545457016676664, 0.005138910375535488, 0.06769674271345139, 0.01831057295203209, -0.02944699488580227, 0.045930005609989166, 0.031363923102617264, -0.020619675517082214, -0.022738141939044, 0.035286206752061844, 0.051430393010377884, -0.005916165187954903, -0.004485866986215115, 0.009925581514835358, 0.024494268000125885, 0.02169625088572502, 0.00460844999179244, -0.08856875449419022, -0.011807575821876526, -0.06351947039365768, -0.002398434095084667, -0.013757086358964443, -0.1270270049571991, 0.007390077691525221, -0.056643687188625336, -0.05510183051228523, -0.0040953196585178375, -0.005939722992479801, 0.0021257041953504086, 0.07597065716981888, 0.004248237702995539, -0.023307213559746742, -0.03620623052120209, 0.0938420370221138, -0.019482098519802094, 0.05294562503695488, 0.008289356715977192, -0.0021312397439032793, -0.04514553025364876, -0.036948055028915405, -0.04921425133943558, -0.015109586529433727, 0.016090216115117073, 0.015937959775328636, -0.011645946651697159, 0.03159105032682419, 0.007593919988721609, -0.002015192760154605, 0.04216129705309868, -0.001978369429707527, -0.0018425311427563429, -0.03897792473435402, 0.03580433875322342, 0.020441167056560516, 0.06505728513002396, -0.029256539419293404, -0.02184923365712166, 0.0377507321536541, 0.05062762647867203, 0.02065938524901867, -0.045213013887405396, -0.025734292343258858, -0.03268875181674957, -0.03636360168457031, -0.029032347723841667, -0.06281314045190811, -0.0014721505576744676, 0.09809072315692902, 0.007904106751084328, 0.05255545303225517, 0.005215480457991362, 0.0221884585916996, 0.031484927982091904, 0.02525489218533039, -0.039084043353796005, 0.012174462899565697, -0.001262615667656064, -0.01667196676135063, -0.0201038159430027, 0.055501531809568405, 0.008075517602264881, 0.01260441355407238, 0.007917688228189945, -0.011273151263594627, -0.014037317596375942, -0.04369451478123665, 0.0335816815495491, 0.025961460545659065, -0.03862221539020538, 0.025745196267962456, -0.033726975321769714, 0.01081898994743824, -0.005418150220066309, -0.020354920998215675, -0.04166164621710777, -0.041019316762685776, -0.016773847863078117, 0.0063435835763812065, -0.051223088055849075, 0.06074288487434387, -0.019319884479045868, 0.04712536185979843, 0.06044013425707817, 0.007626926526427269, -0.009731960482895374, 0.021360866725444794, -0.009447995573282242, 0.06240203231573105, 0.008291730657219887, 0.07483802735805511, -0.027567530050873756, 0.0274850744754076, 0.02312629669904709, 0.008243575692176819, 0.03053421340882778, -0.06376288831233978, -0.00508386455476284, 0.02454075589776039, -0.06732804328203201, 0.021042674779891968, -0.12017322331666946, 0.005519290454685688, -0.01979168877005577, 0.03628779947757721, 0.01795545220375061, -0.0023729768581688404, 0.04350746423006058, -0.062340255826711655, -0.027285536751151085, 0.07422948628664017, 0.04797470569610596, -0.0039380197413265705, 0.001880205818451941, 0.06850426644086838, -0.014381179586052895, -0.041883859783411026, 0.034039415419101715, 0.031168323010206223, 0.03474081680178642, -0.005167111288756132, -0.015633830800652504, -0.0033197281882166862, 0.008695385418832302, -0.04299665987491608, 0.0266326405107975, 0.007705627474933863, 0.002913020085543394, 0.05140107497572899, -0.07402697205543518, -0.01943615823984146, 0.027990393340587616, -0.012580011039972305, 0.030443664640188217, 0.014189346693456173, 0.06434720754623413, 0.00996257085353136, -0.0028095112647861242, 0.017362866550683975, -0.008672801777720451, 0.03930392861366272, 0.03611529991030693, -0.018893439322710037, -0.02334962785243988, 0.02967255562543869, 0.001710187760181725, 0.0008981688297353685, -0.013793705962598324, 0.03656884282827377, -0.02632407657802105, -0.04556136950850487, -0.013999558985233307, -0.07968001067638397, 0.000820044195279479, 0.04079491272568703, 0.0031455212738364935, 0.03706181421875954, 0.017033010721206665, -0.015939682722091675, -0.00783468410372734, -0.029260698705911636, -0.001630512299016118, -0.05979440361261368, -0.006782616022974253, 0.014318414032459259, -0.04208354651927948, 0.0665871798992157, 0.05620190501213074, -0.10852736234664917, 0.01564326509833336, -0.003818878438323736, -0.028789954259991646, -0.02546892873942852, 0.0027317535132169724, -0.012089974246919155, 0.013334970921278, 0.028677187860012054, -0.008170277811586857, 0.021234942600131035, -0.009312905371189117, -0.016768846660852432, 0.06405468285083771, 0.023219358175992966, -0.006188347470015287, 0.023690519854426384, -0.016694914549589157, -0.022811319679021835, -0.01341690868139267, -0.03226277604699135, 0.07476978003978729, -0.02627173811197281, -0.05793958902359009, -0.04800876975059509, -0.0430421382188797, 0.0033081131987273693, 0.02839837037026882, -0.07952091842889786, 0.010932357981801033, -0.058489106595516205, 0.03396924212574959, 0.06951596587896347, 0.03202967718243599, -0.000506877840962261, 0.08207588642835617, 0.0661996454000473, 0.012647591531276703, 0.015685725957155228, -0.030917206779122353, 0.010827474296092987, 0.003979947883635759, 0.052171654999256134, 0.0029065527487546206, 0.05226226896047592, -0.0023080892860889435, -0.058319736272096634, 0.0675305724143982, 0.030085518956184387, -0.038467295467853546, 0.02124939113855362, 0.032784707844257355, -0.04011482745409012, -0.07023423910140991, -0.05249113216996193, 0.03248665854334831, 0.06753932684659958, -0.07309629023075104, 0.05550156906247139, 0.012531369924545288, -0.01958884671330452, 0.023509431630373, 0.008448660373687744, 0.027381720021367073, 0.004618556704372168, -0.046136051416397095, -0.014563639648258686, -0.005880769807845354, 0.07789849489927292, 0.07638666778802872, -0.01990213617682457, -0.031026970595121384, 0.021995972841978073, 0.04102328047156334, 0.022874729707837105, 0.0023842465598136187, -0.04645434767007828, -0.0034515566658228636, 0.0006132652633823454, -0.030725860968232155, 0.02097979560494423, 0.003595375455915928, -0.0004635055083781481, 0.0175271388143301, -0.017685482278466225, 0.016054747626185417, 0.02553691528737545, 0.0002669349778443575, 0.03672558441758156, 0.08525009453296661, -0.0251301359385252, -0.01614297553896904, -0.0074486820958554745, -0.0089696254581213, -0.040544334799051285, 0.01490788720548153, 0.050287265330553055, -0.07504662871360779, -0.002243687165901065, -0.0856027752161026, -0.0040055220015347, 0.04649726301431656, 0.04873932525515556, -0.00014490162720903754, 0.02184342034161091, -0.013124343939125538, 0.01439522486180067, -0.019129309803247452, 0.001628936268389225, -0.02332226373255253, -0.033366769552230835, 0.029105275869369507, 0.003551430767402053, 0.015996798872947693, -0.0011315851006656885, 0.0037830076180398464, 0.0002968631742987782, 0.015595282427966595, -0.005893991328775883, -0.027743393555283546, -0.030034026131033897, 0.004486622754484415, -0.03571481630206108, -0.019944900646805763, 0.03927413746714592, -0.013797707855701447, -0.01377586554735899, -0.08238799124956131, 0.03248262777924538, -0.03731711953878403, 0.02435705065727234, -0.015035688877105713, -0.02192145399749279, -0.03146875277161598, 0.029185671359300613, -0.042007528245449066, -0.02697460539638996, -0.006610847543925047, 0.03281000629067421, -0.009829859249293804, -0.010389897041022778, 0.006017336156219244, -0.02370644174516201, 0.0367332361638546, -0.049289826303720474, 0.011496513150632381, 0.0034973674919456244, -0.018724117428064346, -0.00559880631044507, 0.06181878596544266, -0.004099425859749317, 0.017804065719246864, 0.021587861701846123, -0.06256348639726639, -0.007240076549351215, -0.04559985175728798, -0.03646649047732353, -0.011936355382204056, -0.04420873150229454, -0.020602388307452202, 0.027704238891601562, -0.05229546129703522, -0.010147655382752419, -0.017808780074119568, 0.04341958090662956, 0.0030830034520477057, -0.049806803464889526, -0.04284093901515007, -0.028059249743819237, -0.0813291147351265, 0.027820026502013206, -0.04423730820417404, 0.021961575374007225, 0.00962542649358511, -0.009226180613040924, -0.0638372078537941, 0.009813424199819565, -0.050074927508831024, -0.0036066679749637842, -0.059858065098524094, 0.01195569708943367, 0.031307268887758255, -0.04860236123204231, -0.011437628418207169, 0.02433830499649048, 0.02393021620810032, 0.007531995885074139, -0.05633272975683212, 0.027425462380051613, 0.03505143150687218, 0.0239484254270792, 0.026662487536668777, 0.037269800901412964, 0.04253565892577171, -0.028624586760997772, 0.03775753080844879, -0.021810824051499367, 0.011500337161123753, -0.04885384440422058, -0.0030578088480979204, -0.0752294734120369, 0.008561593480408192, -0.03675439581274986, 0.03401618078351021, 0.03425087779760361, -0.001646192278712988, 0.00022523220104631037, -0.05206441879272461, -0.018830856308341026, 0.019673559814691544, -0.04433396831154823, 0.015624092891812325, 0.06400518119335175, -0.01888453960418701, -0.02102820947766304, 0.01646282896399498, -0.02899165265262127, 0.007836546748876572, -0.012054305523633957, -0.0174773670732975, -0.005360456649214029, -0.016560448333621025, 0.01959088072180748, -0.017090823501348495, -0.02625361643731594, 0.007825510576367378, 0.026704885065555573, -0.01678662747144699, 0.03896156698465347, 0.020308636128902435, -0.033172521740198135, -0.022698797285556793, -0.007694549858570099, -0.00980131234973669, 0.026247017085552216, 0.04057895019650459, 0.042578164488077164, -0.033320579677820206, 0.05066869780421257, 0.027047451585531235, 0.07188399881124496, -0.011350261978805065, 0.014055171050131321, -0.02459232322871685, -0.04077577218413353, 0.003578736213967204, -0.004679560195654631, 0.0072761713527143, -0.040735796093940735, 0.017932197079062462, 0.011078054085373878, 0.0010057392064481974, 0.01934990845620632, 0.038184717297554016, 0.021396862342953682, -0.04567565396428108, 0.0013706650352105498, 0.023707183077931404, 0.035373903810977936, 0.04944706708192825, 0.019233854487538338, 0.018583403900265694, -0.014072753489017487, 0.011807008646428585, 0.030622906982898712, -0.03366430848836899, -0.01780947484076023, 0.008789123967289925, -0.031867753714323044, 0.057860907167196274, 0.01908247545361519, 0.020390799269080162, 0.02893640659749508, 0.014330616220831871, 0.0029790354892611504, -0.014213108457624912, 0.001665716990828514, 0.015509638004004955, 0.02880731225013733, 0.033145759254693985, -0.02435293048620224, 0.03890127316117287, -0.04108278080821037, 0.020519956946372986, 0.03389829397201538, -0.009441487491130829, 0.014880971051752567, -0.06480177491903305, 0.019597258418798447, 0.01584170199930668, -0.022768042981624603, -0.025848163291811943, 0.02885686792433262, 0.018189696595072746, -0.058159105479717255, -0.0362640880048275, -0.046351704746484756, -0.030980268493294716, -0.03469479829072952, -0.03040352091193199, -0.009100616909563541, -0.016051698476076126, 0.05192219093441963, -0.013963141478598118, 0.030731484293937683, -0.06077452003955841, -0.03467082232236862, 0.024277396500110626, -0.06685314327478409, -0.0011153444647789001, -0.05870930850505829, 0.029752107337117195, 0.006887259893119335, -0.001044299453496933, 0.005397457629442215, 0.0030284118838608265, -0.06056177243590355, -0.035699859261512756, 0.009160288609564304, -0.01514914259314537, -0.04411395266652107, -0.014597021974623203, -0.05888104438781738, 0.005304871592670679, 0.005204963032156229, -0.011774173006415367, -0.0039014362264424562, 0.024047356098890305, 0.015115996822714806, -0.054048433899879456, -0.028403496369719505, 0.0015524209011346102, 0.06642938405275345, 0.04400279372930527, 0.008619184605777264, 0.008592086844146252, 0.014069278724491596, -0.0071740769781172276, 0.1140376478433609, -0.025689471513032913, -0.029589850455522537, 0.049766652286052704, -0.015708690509200096, 0.011521494016051292, -0.004424089565873146, 0.04960404336452484, 0.07487425953149796, -0.005622026976197958, 0.0655289813876152, 0.05439211428165436, -0.02566482312977314, -0.06781776249408722, 0.01868033967912197, -0.058338504284620285, 0.04047380015254021, 0.0044105639681220055, 0.011890744790434837, 0.023958539590239525, 0.010314371436834335, 0.028242338448762894, 0.039124198257923126, 0.029844840988516808, -0.02993324026465416, 0.016915330663323402, 0.024356331676244736, -0.015338150784373283, 0.05860075354576111, 0.006961727049201727, 0.041579172015190125, 0.024553397670388222, -0.030114565044641495, -0.032048363238573074, 0.013548188842833042, 0.023243950679898262, -0.06672965735197067, 0.025626763701438904, -0.03601644188165665, 0.035476431250572205, 0.027760878205299377, 0.015929153189063072, -0.017628004774451256, -0.011564881540834904, -0.01889909617602825, 0.012462151236832142, 0.0320613719522953, -0.01090189814567566, -0.10845211893320084, -0.010459636338055134, 0.051352497190237045, 0.026386315003037453, -0.010470369830727577, 0.0011058611562475562, 0.058639947324991226, 0.02681022696197033, -0.007919094525277615, -0.053923189640045166, -0.012078775092959404, 0.016249394044280052, -0.014496171846985817, 0.039965059608221054, -0.00975776556879282, 0.01736970990896225, 0.02863595448434353, 0.020296946167945862, -0.023205898702144623, -0.009913911111652851, 0.030019434168934822, 0.004020024556666613, -0.012426778674125671, -0.014311186969280243, 0.011828438378870487, -0.04833868518471718, -0.00407722732052207, 0.06607422232627869, 0.02502121590077877, 0.030091730877757072, -0.015057281590998173, 0.03488205373287201, -0.01811422035098076, 0.0326554998755455, -0.01666456088423729, 0.004766753874719143, -0.0714980885386467, -0.018568038940429688, -0.01888481341302395, 0.016894720494747162, -0.07603466510772705, -0.017794327810406685, -0.008564667776226997, 0.00968411285430193, -0.024756409227848053, -0.037610799074172974, 0.0037274309433996677, -0.05934242159128189, -0.011981911957263947, 0.019323430955410004, -0.059330690652132034, 0.03705079108476639, 0.0004888034891337156, 0.011346965096890926, 0.07977813482284546, 0.10785366594791412, -0.022983906790614128, -0.015080406330525875, 0.03129587322473526, 0.026869969442486763, -0.016280241310596466, -0.03431093320250511, -0.05573944374918938, -0.022653738036751747, -0.039134953171014786, 0.00862591527402401, 0.030270960181951523, -0.018232379108667374, 0.06703898310661316, 0.03386875241994858, 0.02178889699280262, 0.04564063623547554, -0.0007751269731670618, 0.04701939597725868, 0.036457713693380356, 0.009374081157147884, 0.043177325278520584, -0.06725001335144043, -0.00020080633112229407, -0.08864685148000717, 0.010015534237027168, -0.014600168913602829, -0.0069405753165483475, -0.03044084645807743, -0.03752110153436661, 0.04161936044692993, -0.014095742255449295, 0.01713189110159874, 0.03426669165492058, -0.002433842048048973, 0.018507923930883408, 0.0024236382450908422, 0.022026197984814644, 0.0011413681786507368, -0.03400364890694618, 0.08500870317220688, 0.03880254551768303, 0.008301649242639542, -0.042316775768995285, 0.009043675847351551, 0.036805059760808945, -0.04052184149622917, -0.022017305716872215, -0.03856427222490311, 0.011444052681326866, 0.016183504834771156, -0.003464354434981942, -0.032205335795879364, -0.03652852773666382, -0.023997321724891663, -0.03324313461780548, 0.019857658073306084, 0.02366015873849392, -0.014419390819966793, 0.022804688662290573, -0.05121096223592758, 0.014118467457592487, -0.01981624774634838, -0.030362069606781006, -0.04593942314386368, -0.020712479948997498, -0.062133610248565674, -0.054700251668691635, -0.01412585936486721, -0.0726047158241272, 0.05195256322622299, 0.09730138629674911, -0.03548399731516838, 0.01511934120208025, -0.01793687790632248, -0.04268968850374222, -0.034868065267801285, 0.021514028310775757, -0.029187237843871117, -0.0006683904794044793, 0.027233628556132317, 0.026162786409258842, 0.023545172065496445, -0.012947587296366692, -0.020272377878427505, -0.03949911892414093, 0.0028757862746715546, 0.05759371817111969, -0.053157445043325424, 0.003333260305225849, -0.008772427216172218 ]
<p>In my experiment, I use a laser beam with wavelength $\lambda=894 \text{nm}$ for some magnetic resonance experiment. Right now, I'm doing some calculation using Quantum Mechanics, which requires the amplitude of the electric field to be inserted to my Hamiltonian.</p> <p><strong>My question is basically: How do I go from a power, measured in $\mu W$ to an Electric Field amplitude $E_0$ to use it in a QM's Hamiltonian?</strong></p> <p>So I think that I need to use the Poynting vector, which is defined as:</p> <p>$$\vec{S}=\frac{1}{\mu_0} \vec{E}\times \vec{B}$$</p> <p>where I'm using $\mu_0$ because the interactions happen in a vacated, dilute gas cell. If I take the magnitude of the last equation I get</p> <p>$$S=\frac{EB}{\mu_0}=\frac{E^2}{c \mu_0}$$</p> <p>where I used the fact that $E_0=c B_0$ according to Maxwell equations.</p> <p>However, the Poynting vector is energy per unit area per unit time, or power per unit area. This means that I have to know the area of my laser beam, <strong>and that's my problem now</strong>.</p> <p>The laser beam in my experiment comes out of a multi-mode fiber, and then it goes to a linear polarizer, and then a quarter wave plate, where we use the latter to get circularly polarized light, and then a collimator lens. And after that it interacts with my atoms.</p> <p>I know the core-diameter of my multi-mode fiber, let's call it $r_F$, but I don't know what transverse modes are produced in it. How can I know the effective area of my laser beam (call it $A_L$), so that I could substitute that in my Poynting vector and calculate the electric field amplitude of my laser beam?</p> <p>I imagine that eventually I should be able to calculate $A_L$, and I can use the following relation to get my electric field amplitude, which I get from the Poynting vector definition</p> <p>$$E=\sqrt{\frac{\mu_0 c S}{B}}=\sqrt{\frac{\mu_0 c P}{B A_L}}$$</p> <p>where $P$ is the power of my beam.</p> <p>Is my reasoning correct? Please advise. If I'm missing something in the problem, let me know.</p> <p>Please note: this is a real experiment, so all practical approximations are allowed.</p>
g9779
[ -0.02059582807123661, -0.025330908596515656, 0.0016356278210878372, -0.06811041384935379, 0.003844984108582139, -0.03964383900165558, -0.027087651193141937, 0.02347090095281601, -0.00008164693281287327, 0.026804102584719658, 0.00024671663413755596, -0.008904722519218922, -0.03460843116044998, 0.024407867342233658, 0.02756425552070141, 0.00681247329339385, 0.07447037100791931, 0.014978647232055664, 0.07310667634010315, -0.034099750220775604, -0.015359272249042988, -0.003145870054140687, -0.0388668030500412, -0.06805326044559479, -0.003991387784481049, -0.053509507328271866, 0.017894241958856583, 0.012575974687933922, -0.02605402283370495, -0.031449317932128906, -0.03968646749854088, 0.009145432151854038, 0.054712776094675064, -0.04920589178800583, -0.0630989819765091, 0.01774047128856182, 0.0442548431456089, 0.0795719251036644, 0.03103228099644184, 0.017030619084835052, -0.0007003990467637777, -0.040163084864616394, 0.04651464894413948, -0.007367655169218779, 0.01725897565484047, -0.03664484620094299, -0.012081687338650227, -0.05124790593981743, -0.01809130422770977, 0.0104098841547966, -0.012390287593007088, 0.0034177727065980434, 0.05044858157634735, -0.010826499201357365, 0.018339484930038452, 0.07751180231571198, -0.07357959449291229, -0.014414521865546703, 0.04097349941730499, 0.05690231919288635, 0.049041882157325745, -0.03662751615047455, 0.01286100223660469, -0.0057893297635018826, 0.03494740650057793, 0.01768120750784874, -0.07770189642906189, -0.031457412987947464, -0.030630217865109444, 0.0013499647611752152, -0.01587243564426899, -0.08197575807571411, 0.012098741717636585, 0.025607923045754433, 0.020579177886247635, -0.007882907055318356, -0.022479021921753883, 0.007750697899609804, 0.022781213745474815, 0.01212620921432972, -0.017826279625296593, -0.03684939071536064, 0.009941201657056808, -0.017743796110153198, 0.0015779330860823393, -0.008528541773557663, 0.0007139295339584351, 0.011199706234037876, 0.018608761951327324, 0.02290065959095955, 0.0329066701233387, 0.08693117648363113, 0.07730308175086975, 0.046844083815813065, 0.014373027719557285, -0.017319465056061745, 0.008784027770161629, 0.017734332010149956, -0.020546097308397293, 0.00587082002311945, -0.026509210467338562, 0.0232046227902174, -0.0014839958166703582, -0.017081385478377342, -0.025072455406188965, 0.061978358775377274, -0.03571823984384537, -0.048493642359972, -0.03726319223642349, 0.03451455384492874, -0.06662038713693619, -0.005749889183789492, -0.07137357443571091, -0.03341095522046089, -0.07774186879396439, -0.07740887254476547, 0.07470297813415527, -0.03553520888090134, -0.017284346744418144, -0.012601924128830433, 0.031143750995397568, 0.01808007061481476, 0.0484151765704155, 0.022027278319001198, -0.03079218603670597, 0.01569472998380661, -0.013400178402662277, -0.000470484810648486, 0.054709430783987045, 0.02603984624147415, -0.05636543035507202, -0.03053910844027996, -0.008654375560581684, 0.03145401179790497, 0.04585234075784683, 0.025288591161370277, 0.001607438549399376, -0.00517424987629056, 0.0769716128706932, 0.045558780431747437, -0.033747777342796326, -0.022769730538129807, -0.006975857075303793, -0.04181978479027748, -0.04319368675351143, 0.03611592948436737, -0.0034470106475055218, -0.05952161177992821, 0.05803485959768295, 0.06070874258875847, 0.04129185900092125, 0.09661697596311569, -0.006865176372230053, -0.019513769075274467, 0.02741849794983864, 0.01456828135997057, 0.039434272795915604, -0.061653316020965576, 0.027291923761367798, -0.013563668355345726, 0.04184731841087341, -0.014667689800262451, 0.023958634585142136, -0.012715635821223259, -0.031208351254463196, 0.014450331218540668, 0.042498521506786346, -0.05957280844449997, 0.04666511341929436, -0.016767552122473717, -0.014276299625635147, -0.03950389847159386, 0.047912124544382095, -0.059551071375608444, -0.008332641795277596, 0.1190992221236229, 0.020171962678432465, 0.0006395899108611047, 0.0567660890519619, 0.03521519899368286, -0.000329155707731843, 0.025099778547883034, 0.017504410818219185, -0.050747182220220566, -0.07193664461374283, 0.011293277144432068, 0.013291114941239357, 0.010568627156317234, -0.04912059009075165, 0.03074791096150875, -0.025642812252044678, 0.02656480111181736, 0.01225140318274498, -0.011773699894547462, -0.0527426078915596, 0.018924519419670105, 0.032423291355371475, -0.0671420767903328, -0.05847322568297386, -0.0361003614962101, -0.009211068972945213, 0.03321593999862671, 0.026711465790867805, 0.02627711184322834, 0.0888986885547638, -0.010837973095476627, 0.020060986280441284, 0.026320526376366615, 0.0032156570814549923, 0.02634204924106598, 0.009285088628530502, -0.013295702636241913, -0.010650381445884705, 0.08445965498685837, 0.004199125804007053, 0.01581747457385063, -0.009746460244059563, 0.030294764786958694, -0.00826595351099968, 0.061276812106370926, -0.05458884686231613, 0.004845134448260069, 0.04425077512860298, 0.010812407359480858, -0.021233001723885536, 0.019401054829359055, 0.0033073704689741135, 0.004254689905792475, -0.08309950679540634, 0.023707136511802673, -0.07677219808101654, 0.04292221739888191, -0.0011284108040854335, -0.04168548807501793, 0.027636658400297165, 0.015784703195095062, -0.07207182794809341, 0.03640466183423996, -0.02259472757577896, -0.007391804829239845, 0.03353468328714371, -0.01591501198709011, -0.00958358496427536, 0.008971672505140305, -0.013708174228668213, 0.0031965787056833506, 0.015569950453937054, -0.0014327637618407607, -0.01754436083137989, 0.009804085828363895, 0.01423436589539051, 0.013664787635207176, 0.015962814912199974, -0.02634553238749504, -0.03353048488497734, 0.0011264762142673135, -0.046283211559057236, 0.04388123005628586, -0.05635402724146843, -0.02057458646595478, 0.01801975630223751, -0.0015377128729596734, 0.01079614832997322, 0.017688056454062462, -0.031104538589715958, -0.022114641964435577, -0.05603299289941788, 0.007321089040488005, -0.00028606000705622137, 0.004590484779328108, -0.03675015643239021, 0.04835645109415054, 0.0005151121877133846, 0.00021981798636261374, 0.041286710649728775, -0.05416276678442955, 0.03450752794742584, 0.007069820538163185, 0.07513701170682907, -0.07913292199373245, -0.056181617081165314, 0.037594497203826904, -0.05195054039359093, 0.04223237559199333, -0.0019059551414102316, -0.04548027366399765, 0.06414999067783356, 0.0549735501408577, 0.031245945021510124, -0.005791479721665382, -0.047585997730493546, 0.027841882780194283, -0.05664753168821335, -0.01161880511790514, -0.051074638962745667, -0.021806135773658752, 0.026943709701299667, -0.00431805569678545, 0.04331440106034279, 0.02878330461680889, -0.007278176955878735, -0.03632720187306404, -0.027078568935394287, -0.02777768485248089, 0.026080390438437462, 0.007757279556244612, -0.05167147517204285, -0.0303778275847435, 0.03704914450645447, 0.042266614735126495, -0.007936982437968254, -0.018495267257094383, 0.019535433501005173, -0.048645712435245514, -0.06369800120592117, -0.04785331338644028, -0.007201686501502991, -0.0385173000395298, 0.0373733825981617, 0.006923805922269821, -0.0019911741837859154, -0.036790359765291214, 0.01611396111547947, -0.02616754174232483, -0.02852066606283188, 0.008256025612354279, -0.004252333659678698, -0.024123797193169594, -0.007064971141517162, -0.003559475066140294, -0.019761575385928154, -0.002107028616592288, -0.0003119664324913174, 0.006889930460602045, -0.005715097300708294, -0.012270072475075722, -0.07189775258302689, 0.01012321189045906, -0.027464592829346657, 0.015295096673071384, -0.012944894842803478, -0.07749523222446442, -0.026712648570537567, -0.01612355001270771, -0.018259672448039055, -0.03655846416950226, -0.04414772614836693, -0.004573793616145849, -0.0023714168928563595, -0.055655039846897125, -0.003118559718132019, -0.022133121266961098, -0.030149856582283974, 0.020588351413607597, 0.012728544883430004, 0.03132658824324608, 0.020471781492233276, 0.04311959818005562, 0.051747728139162064, -0.05118972808122635, 0.012933420017361641, -0.03309151530265808, 0.033116377890110016, -0.0014527839375659823, -0.038759227842092514, 0.0226249098777771, 0.012647111900150776, 0.0434008352458477, 0.014963940717279911, 0.017583973705768585, -0.01045268215239048, -0.051051460206508636, -0.02508862316608429, -0.0020716500002890825, 0.012793726287782192, -0.027165431529283524, 0.007459599059075117, 0.010079978965222836, -0.011131731793284416, 0.05439978092908859, -0.029330167919397354, 0.08952316641807556, 0.01719069294631481, 0.034246284514665604, 0.034737493842840195, 0.028104612603783607, 0.004600530490279198, -0.002984275808557868, 0.04431532323360443, 0.044631678611040115, -0.025981327518820763, -0.045874398201704025, -0.051912449300289154, -0.026137778535485268, -0.030367033556103706, -0.04975990206003189, 0.018398158252239227, 0.01454000174999237, -0.03616844490170479, 0.03936653956770897, 0.012780440971255302, -0.0008316431776620448, 0.056168586015701294, 0.02024703286588192, -0.051160428673028946, -0.03093530796468258, 0.02856212668120861, 0.026487920433282852, -0.0026854174211621284, 0.012830867432057858, -0.009663022123277187, -0.07287530601024628, 0.003940708469599485, -0.08069141209125519, 0.005559838376939297, 0.033150460571050644, 0.030170578509569168, -0.03300675377249718, 0.028052357956767082, -0.007186135742813349, 0.052249081432819366, 0.05625909939408302, 0.038190677762031555, -0.04217210412025452, 0.011827895417809486, 0.027316465973854065, 0.015098335221409798, -0.021217510104179382, 0.05483970791101456, -0.044934093952178955, -0.012707752175629139, 0.03767964616417885, -0.02787482738494873, 0.005084453150629997, -0.041506119072437286, 0.044881537556648254, -0.04881013557314873, -0.0018255128525197506, 0.07327158749103546, 0.049161724746227264, 0.05038301646709442, -0.03554389625787735, -0.0044588614255189896, -0.03314904868602753, -0.015390577726066113, 0.01513835322111845, -0.08004620671272278, -0.044925373047590256, -0.037671543657779694, -0.04636608064174652, -0.011994247324764729, 0.0040015289559960365, -0.029759559780359268, -0.01950850710272789, -0.008290346711874008, 0.016807300969958305, -0.0027710027061402798, 0.0140874944627285, 0.09141384065151215, 0.034944139420986176, -0.05670608952641487, 0.026577461510896683, -0.05213308334350586, -0.0014987942995503545, 0.03546077385544777, -0.02981533482670784, -0.0436100959777832, 0.034953534603118896, -0.023395491763949394, -0.026822393760085106, 0.058287713676691055, -0.05348329618573189, 0.0387723483145237, 0.009452786296606064, -0.0042057940736413, -0.03611031174659729, 0.00896154623478651, -0.027046699076890945, 0.02926359325647354, -0.0642138347029686, 0.004559780471026897, -0.05593505874276161, 0.026358170434832573, 0.017498044297099113, -0.030360305681824684, 0.014242603443562984, -0.0017448144499212503, -0.012491695582866669, 0.007085111923515797, 0.01677054539322853, -0.056242432445287704, 0.06745242327451706, 0.010587145574390888, -0.016537928953766823, 0.0018002029974013567, 0.0399584136903286, 0.0017033368349075317, -0.0801263079047203, 0.0068347561173141, -0.008819377049803734, -0.013261529617011547, 0.05511072650551796, -0.0724366083741188, -0.01694517396390438, -0.042023710906505585, 0.03334016352891922, 0.020642956718802452, -0.011150342412292957, -0.02853088267147541, 0.012665812857449055, 0.024534093216061592, -0.00720355287194252, 0.005003881640732288, 0.04909030720591545, 0.02558102272450924, -0.03348217532038689, -0.029577935114502907, 0.06891477108001709, -0.08106619864702225, -0.015016956254839897, 0.07102623581886292, -0.023387227207422256, -0.0019255400402471423, -0.037367213517427444, 0.023565303534269333, 0.037426501512527466, -0.02913571149110794, -0.014005864039063454, 0.006642874795943499, -0.02948266826570034, -0.0041373493149876595, 0.03448471054434776, -0.005592787638306618, 0.05324404686689377, -0.011564739048480988, 0.002962858183309436, 0.0007898021722212434, -0.06441371142864227, 0.006206644233316183, -0.050998859107494354, -0.02660994417965412, -0.02992269955575466, 0.03486960381269455, 0.013151644729077816, 0.010398617014288902, 0.008630274794995785, 0.024135170504450798, -0.02713903971016407, 0.019960768520832062, 0.006968240719288588, -0.04228227213025093, -0.015184524469077587, -0.003883708966895938, -0.056094273924827576, 0.014720086008310318, 0.043664902448654175, -0.00616729911416769, -0.02011404186487198, -0.021608427166938782, 0.027328507974743843, 0.08719705790281296, -0.020841995254158974, 0.013177374377846718, -0.042532481253147125, 0.00022127010743133724, -0.027723709121346474, -0.002202818635851145, -0.007632475811988115, 0.049799058586359024, 0.01667553372681141, -0.028829948976635933, 0.04807424172759056, -0.01614847406744957, 0.014273684471845627, 0.08856142312288284, 0.0721578449010849, 0.00032559531973674893, -0.014592351391911507, -0.03194919228553772, 0.019774867221713066, 0.0008743330836296082, 0.02016015164554119, 0.02979871816933155, -0.026640428230166435, -0.004206531215459108, 0.019033130258321762, -0.02027158997952938, -0.016062593087553978, 0.04620492458343506, -0.03871885687112808, -0.06974156200885773, 0.014344542287290096, -0.009875557385385036, -0.021885540336370468, -0.01693318784236908, -0.001820248900912702, -0.01066072378307581, -0.027863578870892525, 0.005071273539215326, 0.08389559388160706, 0.022959614172577858, 0.01818179525434971, 0.004027369897812605, -0.009615600109100342, 0.023065641522407532, 0.03978003188967705, -0.027649937197566032, -0.05444784462451935, -0.005922505632042885, 0.0124495355412364, 0.024586165323853493, 0.017630239948630333, 0.0393381230533123, 0.023065034300088882, 0.042692411690950394, -0.0037298521492630243, 0.021720100194215775, -0.004985489882528782, 0.032773442566394806, 0.07271931320428848, 0.0117991603910923, -0.022473009303212166, 0.018827371299266815, -0.012051161378622055, 0.05870639532804489, 0.026712866500020027, -0.02953295409679413, -0.020500890910625458, 0.031527191400527954, -0.03047707863152027, 0.0018475805409252644, -0.022049296647310257, -0.013138383626937866, 0.02291259542107582, -0.05600028112530708, 0.047665681689977646, -0.040854018181562424, 0.04712971672415733, 0.03804197534918785, 0.008343523368239403, -0.028220469132065773, 0.052582163363695145, 0.02383410558104515, -0.0239311121404171, -0.038849979639053345, -0.02321215718984604, -0.03545912727713585, 0.003102038288488984, -0.014855221845209599, 0.08174001425504684, 0.004547659773379564, 0.03217706456780434, -0.020304225385189056, 0.05052315443754196, -0.008810415863990784, 0.056083500385284424, 0.039285991340875626, 0.017493920400738716, -0.02057020366191864, -0.025759147480130196, 0.0005723942304030061, -0.07920875400304794, 0.020241228863596916, -0.0738629698753357, 0.03754172474145889, 0.04550841450691223, -0.04103177413344383, -0.008767352439463139, -0.02173132635653019, -0.022872833535075188, -0.02677827887237072, -0.08314555138349533, -0.06520586460828781, 0.015135006047785282, -0.02675936371088028, -0.017452631145715714, -0.011946541257202625, 0.05568920820951462, -0.014574076980352402, -0.00835928414016962, -0.031519416719675064, 0.01687564142048359, -0.06573782861232758, 0.029557527974247932, 0.01740395277738571, 0.004512484185397625, -0.007212711498141289, 0.03165832906961441, 0.02506089210510254, 0.03284833952784538, -0.014276704750955105, -0.0366968959569931, 0.015735741704702377, -0.005298164673149586, 0.018394513055682182, 0.024820460006594658, 0.03384874016046524, 0.011496162042021751, 0.05426642671227455, 0.028032539412379265, 0.0021721976809203625, -0.013755655847489834, -0.004921620711684227, -0.014496402814984322, -0.0014748842222616076, 0.05488695204257965, -0.02851068787276745, -0.030066747218370438, -0.023367537185549736, 0.028023438528180122, -0.014651539735496044, 0.06837096065282822, 0.030644208192825317, 0.05974790081381798, 0.052939169108867645, -0.012737131677567959, -0.03520435467362404, 0.050474878400564194, 0.023235520347952843, -0.023655777797102928, -0.07297589629888535, 0.019505485892295837, -0.026507830247282982, -0.008758757263422012, 0.04144920036196709, -0.04791278764605522, -0.030508756637573242, 0.037898946553468704, 0.012847504578530788, 0.03833268582820892, -0.02988358773291111, -0.03556492179632187, -0.03942405432462692, -0.013843831606209278, -0.009382862597703934, -0.00819496437907219, 0.0029697008430957794, 0.0007411988917738199, 0.016639910638332367, 0.08330583572387695, 0.06373558938503265, -0.07760991901159286, 0.00566933723166585, 0.01302671991288662, 0.007927044294774532, 0.005967371165752411, -0.054744426161050797, 0.1041417270898819, 0.052037566900253296, -0.07291198521852493, -0.007719449698925018, 0.060429539531469345, -0.002231256105005741, 0.026301875710487366, 0.05416330695152283, -0.06506266444921494, -0.00047877096221782267, 0.013718713074922562, 0.03938273712992668, -0.0308536347001791, 0.014432759955525398, 0.0017517316155135632, -0.02567637525498867, 0.02117079868912697, -0.018777132034301758, -0.039135079830884933, -0.03800294175744057, 0.004918409511446953 ]
<p>If there exists a natural magnetic field due to the metallic core of the earth... could we then extract and get free energy from the earth core ??</p>
g82
[ 0.043480876833200455, 0.07263655960559845, 0.03575699403882027, -0.032009754329919815, 0.009685281664133072, 0.006930931005626917, -0.03382798656821251, 0.01036838162690401, -0.03846917301416397, 0.010817242786288261, 0.0010332157835364342, 0.03949766233563423, -0.027854017913341522, -0.0474407859146595, -0.007075316738337278, 0.040333472192287445, 0.01663319766521454, 0.004774187691509724, 0.06445173174142838, 0.017086250707507133, -0.021687239408493042, -0.0365012101829052, 0.04894424229860306, -0.025796765461564064, -0.07014650851488113, 0.013439838774502277, 0.025003764778375626, -0.0075999293476343155, -0.00427624536678195, -0.020677171647548676, 0.00691796001046896, -0.03947708010673523, 0.06860047578811646, -0.05235368758440018, -0.08100306987762451, 0.006938904989510775, 0.07331880182027817, 0.00984121859073639, 0.03291935846209526, -0.02039323002099991, 0.013629619963467121, -0.05630984529852867, -0.00317417667247355, 0.02737201750278473, -0.0017129553016275167, 0.005691005382686853, 0.02257380820810795, 0.0019509227713569999, -0.027267783880233765, -0.01670604944229126, -0.04213492199778557, -0.009598756209015846, 0.07796434313058853, 0.02506040222942829, -0.014547409489750862, 0.0032493441831320524, 0.05746031180024147, -0.00472847418859601, 0.03741252422332764, -0.0029393050353974104, 0.006270070094615221, 0.03297434747219086, 0.023134853690862656, 0.016311204060912132, -0.008679291233420372, -0.028975222259759903, -0.06559338420629501, 0.030510541051626205, 0.011168592609465122, 0.015148187056183815, 0.02002096176147461, -0.04821181297302246, -0.04374193400144577, -0.005879078060388565, 0.039313022047281265, 0.06345581263303757, 0.03266701474785805, 0.01173540111631155, 0.04069775342941284, 0.037695128470659256, 0.011603052727878094, -0.022707099094986916, 0.014783323742449284, 0.017787665128707886, 0.0421290248632431, -0.06391214579343796, -0.0036900495178997517, 0.006598607171326876, 0.03601919114589691, 0.015426340512931347, 0.03802476078271866, 0.007446307688951492, 0.027242818847298622, -0.009110582061111927, 0.045608483254909515, 0.01764003559947014, 0.03757571801543236, 0.006489879917353392, -0.092186339199543, 0.012254904955625534, -0.029725540429353714, -0.05005641654133797, 0.05302831158041954, -0.02731405757367611, 0.036883048713207245, -0.049946658313274384, -0.0021155294962227345, 0.007136999629437923, 0.0458720438182354, 0.0024986478965729475, 0.0751178115606308, 0.012398621998727322, -0.006607933435589075, 0.029664572328329086, -0.014432447031140327, -0.029446812346577644, 0.08063019067049026, -0.024924973025918007, -0.016743937507271767, 0.07674182951450348, -0.015220532193779945, 0.0000850199576234445, -0.01792946085333824, 0.11110061407089233, -0.04267267882823944, 0.01215184573084116, 0.018930578604340553, -0.029399890452623367, -0.034527551382780075, -0.03893468528985977, -0.028259091079235077, -0.05241424962878227, 0.0029764233622699976, 0.006995023228228092, 0.04349309206008911, 0.017816493287682533, -0.026879047974944115, 0.0713605210185051, -0.039217736572027206, 0.004697149153798819, -0.010023378767073154, -0.02082049660384655, -0.012588775716722012, 0.013117123395204544, -0.0229987520724535, 0.03571968153119087, -0.04186999425292015, -0.011963190510869026, 0.006018779706209898, 0.06870733201503754, -0.020256180316209793, -0.008632749319076538, 0.002123825717717409, -0.022009409964084625, 0.023692598566412926, -0.026866259053349495, 0.008290710859000683, -0.04013117030262947, -0.001989909214898944, -0.05458913743495941, 0.04435927793383598, -0.027238300070166588, 0.05617649853229523, 0.004821097478270531, 0.04269491881132126, -0.016530409455299377, 0.048317547887563705, -0.0017515475628897548, 0.05349717289209366, -0.02194911427795887, -0.041676949709653854, 0.020010391250252724, -0.011800259351730347, 0.03432789817452431, -0.0017433674074709415, 0.016221679747104645, -0.005464089568704367, -0.04507296159863472, -0.020772438496351242, 0.04930872842669487, 0.004366383887827396, -0.005916495807468891, -0.0008216006681323051, -0.008651409298181534, 0.0236654132604599, 0.00222771312110126, -0.027502719312906265, 0.03910870477557182, 0.037162184715270996, 0.0003489140945021063, -0.047522127628326416, 0.0005120777641423047, 0.04615909233689308, 0.06380379945039749, 0.007604438345879316, -0.007892996072769165, -0.02615799382328987, 0.005793857853859663, 0.006264100316911936, -0.024137156084179878, 0.021528830751776695, 0.04997808486223221, -0.021338660269975662, 0.006166538689285517, 0.0380244143307209, -0.024503687396645546, 0.05561335012316704, -0.03139113634824753, 0.055015504360198975, -0.03127380460500717, 0.08293802291154861, -0.002860808512195945, -0.07451773434877396, -0.00325517519377172, 0.008844953961670399, -0.008855212479829788, -0.04412137717008591, 0.00936640053987503, -0.03821849450469017, 0.05820857733488083, -0.1001543328166008, 0.014955095946788788, -0.0008228716906160116, 0.0062311491928994656, -0.01842544972896576, -0.01183546893298626, 0.016440387815237045, -0.038916487246751785, -0.04335852712392807, -0.038781456649303436, -0.04118388146162033, -0.02552686259150505, 0.07170788943767548, 0.0026344419457018375, 0.027767784893512726, 0.043704114854335785, -0.022474803030490875, -0.003164068330079317, -0.07321912795305252, 0.023637643083930016, 0.009165501222014427, 0.004836037755012512, 0.033532314002513885, 0.009355844929814339, -0.018260499462485313, -0.022522464394569397, 0.03343047574162483, 0.04466576501727104, -0.003538189921528101, -0.043934036046266556, 0.061865031719207764, -0.016029486432671547, -0.07135076075792313, 0.04147696495056152, -0.006892141420394182, -0.022740889340639114, 0.017795082181692123, 0.08474280685186386, -0.0448758602142334, -0.0536169558763504, 0.032137732952833176, -0.002555935410782695, -0.005289322230964899, 0.08805133402347565, 0.0038009362760931253, 0.008174343965947628, -0.02429104968905449, -0.018684281036257744, -0.02784932404756546, 0.008027846924960613, -0.041585419327020645, 0.013835560530424118, -0.026646656915545464, 0.0413728766143322, 0.024986617267131805, -0.035063400864601135, 0.0641036108136177, 0.014671184122562408, -0.0013633803464472294, -0.03337894007563591, -0.0176880843937397, 0.03269157186150551, 0.018234919756650925, 0.02535431459546089, -0.012147126719355583, -0.00884721428155899, -0.09675992280244827, -0.014178366400301456, 0.035051316022872925, -0.045515239238739014, 0.025507880374789238, -0.02160174772143364, 0.045384619385004044, 0.00695373397320509, -0.05685801804065704, -0.017268015071749687, 0.038489844650030136, -0.04917905107140541, -0.02441910281777382, 0.04968664422631264, 0.058151159435510635, -0.03587492182850838, -0.028648242354393005, 0.017433466389775276, -0.08831299841403961, -0.019395090639591217, 0.0205707885324955, 0.020346278324723244, 0.03274202719330788, -0.07943492382764816, -0.0068209790624678135, 0.08814731240272522, 0.03634112700819969, 0.02693404257297516, 0.008687642402946949, 0.030397210270166397, -0.022520361468195915, -0.06189584732055664, 0.08694879710674286, 0.003078794339671731, -0.044123392552137375, -0.054900240153074265, -0.04611939564347267, -0.017819933593273163, 0.0011378478957340121, 0.0009774371283128858, -0.05790156498551369, -0.034392356872558594, -0.045737676322460175, -0.0061428118497133255, -0.029411878436803818, 0.005736595951020718, -0.06017600744962692, 0.04639331251382828, -0.07704856991767883, 0.019570156931877136, -0.012518334202468395, 0.03677750751376152, 0.02379368431866169, 0.03849443048238754, -0.044896651059389114, 0.00048139854334294796, -0.07595344632863998, 0.004363432060927153, -0.030602294951677322, 0.07249508798122406, -0.020234229043126106, -0.0294988751411438, -0.007866289466619492, 0.0029157325625419617, 0.039481762796640396, -0.048607658594846725, 0.023361757397651672, -0.011195547878742218, -0.012671951204538345, 0.028727542608976364, 0.023836949840188026, 0.007612347137182951, -0.034617748111486435, -0.025653444230556488, -0.041429027915000916, 0.01724255457520485, 0.09958518296480179, -0.04045991972088814, 0.009570092894136906, 0.05379325523972511, -0.035035390406847, 0.0003076272550970316, -0.017896555364131927, -0.06715226918458939, 0.012677628546953201, -0.02852654457092285, -0.03383631259202957, 0.00637388089671731, 0.007039995398372412, -0.000018926824850495905, 0.02613387070596218, 0.011880641803145409, -0.03363429382443428, -0.04644571617245674, 0.025276251137256622, -0.005919387564063072, 0.011920398101210594, 0.03578614071011543, -0.011794340796768665, 0.029379453510046005, 0.011241992004215717, 0.017538465559482574, -0.03928832709789276, 0.008877508342266083, 0.010513593442738056, -0.039175279438495636, 0.009186393581330776, 0.024939777329564095, -0.021395303308963776, -0.022358424961566925, -0.017879605293273926, -0.04851271212100983, 0.013278434984385967, 0.024634454399347305, 0.022251039743423462, -0.01619330234825611, 0.013397561386227608, 0.006903881207108498, 0.03409890830516815, -0.0016508782282471657, 0.002561261411756277, -0.03186812251806259, -0.021499698981642723, -0.05053766071796417, 0.005346291698515415, -0.0056514195166528225, 0.005874727386981249, 0.03541810065507889, 0.0595429353415966, -0.03787834569811821, -0.022600233554840088, -0.01726045273244381, 0.049436215311288834, -0.041470594704151154, -0.009035269729793072, 0.03252090513706207, 0.02061987854540348, 0.01675129309296608, -0.0220132227987051, 0.04069371521472931, -0.00944548100233078, -0.04347951337695122, -0.023719511926174164, -0.011133766733109951, -0.03112425096333027, 0.009995181113481522, 0.009559283964335918, -0.04956388846039772, -0.04458528757095337, 0.024072056636214256, -0.05447658523917198, 0.028257418423891068, -0.010106253437697887, -0.006320018786936998, 0.018668027594685555, 0.04421829432249069, 0.08758895844221115, 0.0098020751029253, -0.01587708480656147, 0.05395255610346794, 0.03956915810704231, -0.019396591931581497, 0.02005067653954029, -0.04600708559155464, 0.03927505761384964, -0.025601590052247047, -0.034000247716903687, 0.019003255292773247, 0.016992924734950066, -0.01817304454743862, -0.02274765633046627, -0.012444871477782726, 0.031300339847803116, 0.017952989786863327, -0.0821368619799614, 0.04797211289405823, -0.010765261016786098, 0.06338615715503693, -0.0036240003537386656, -0.022433405742049217, -0.05883445963263512, -0.04378851130604744, -0.010752709582448006, 0.00024319894146174192, 0.01688685081899166, 0.04511643946170807, 0.05362996459007263, -0.007021781988441944, 0.008265865035355091, 0.01555172074586153, -0.012593739666044712, -0.060806188732385635, 0.029120469465851784, -0.06938455998897552, -0.006353937089443207, 0.012868458405137062, -0.008904069662094116, 0.01974670961499214, -0.03894149139523506, 0.06357094645500183, -0.06597509235143661, 0.03472384065389633, -0.039911240339279175, -0.03239354491233826, -0.03150256723165512, -0.024794334545731544, 0.027303703129291534, -0.07750614732503891, -0.003025308484211564, 0.01973864808678627, -0.04314665123820305, -0.014346749521791935, -0.028569171205163002, -0.024277329444885254, -0.018149258568882942, -0.0030735903419554234, -0.07792365550994873, 0.054166242480278015, 0.046520981937646866, 0.07072795182466507, 0.07251138240098953, 0.03307485580444336, -0.0016670790500938892, 0.04069015383720398, -0.0020776307210326195, -0.05124163255095482, -0.006106076296418905, 0.03235252946615219, 0.051191363483667374, -0.0020195594988763332, 0.006566456053406, 0.06310305744409561, 0.034395962953567505, 0.02157590351998806, -0.015721473842859268, 0.03152480348944664, 0.06247255951166153, -0.0350530743598938, 0.001546751125715673, 0.04095516726374626, 0.012390048243105412, 0.008132240734994411, 0.06721663475036621, 0.023177338764071465, -0.01653188094496727, -0.015353272669017315, 0.01582123339176178, -0.007087780628353357, 0.06719650328159332, -0.00041250407230108976, -0.005313555244356394, 0.004055500496178865, 0.013770906254649162, 0.004883173853158951, 0.039134301245212555, -0.09053061157464981, 0.06391451507806778, -0.05259663611650467, 0.001216113567352295, 0.017380664125084877, 0.003189379582181573, -0.011543470434844494, 0.006772669963538647, -0.044779591262340546, -0.029857752844691277, 0.000261365610640496, -0.012080542743206024, -0.029446793720126152, 0.030424581840634346, 0.023066988214850426, 0.021864602342247963, 0.006608308292925358, -0.00578200863674283, -0.0007810477982275188, 0.016344476491212845, 0.05855998769402504, -0.02947450801730156, 0.02535851113498211, -0.01455617044121027, -0.007117981091141701, 0.04531566798686981, -0.05848991125822067, 0.034262657165527344, -0.018968280404806137, 0.030782749876379967, 0.0029248534701764584, -0.03714616596698761, -0.0024103845935314894, 0.029160035774111748, -0.038493141531944275, -0.008756037801504135, 0.04657352343201637, 0.0025806932244449854, -0.03359193354845047, 0.04124635457992554, -0.0393645204603672, -0.006112676579505205, -0.03239678964018822, 0.003405049443244934, 0.061070766299963, -0.032995905727148056, 0.028896348550915718, -0.018003109842538834, -0.050569452345371246, 0.015202388167381287, 0.00441081402823329, 0.03135586529970169, -0.012730861082673073, -0.028423169627785683, -0.07650928944349289, -0.037436049431562424, -0.06348733603954315, 0.002075660042464733, 0.052209291607141495, -0.02476758509874344, -0.011588585563004017, -0.03289494290947914, -0.05402567237615585, 0.07645252346992493, 0.021661315113306046, 0.0193405169993639, 0.018567845225334167, -0.020944789052009583, 0.00025097947218455374, -0.04674967750906944, -0.05288439616560936, 0.002068040193989873, -0.03632232919335365, -0.006159673444926739, 0.0007187029696069658, 0.039440035820007324, -0.03671044856309891, 0.024030614644289017, 0.04756290838122368, 0.0068284254521131516, -0.020237747579813004, -0.026927052065730095, -0.09617121517658234, -0.02777869440615177, 0.022522956132888794, -0.057684022933244705, 0.020842060446739197, 0.039672017097473145, 0.012460485100746155, -0.0377674400806427, 0.07262230664491653, 0.023480450734496117, -0.0011629386572167277, 0.005684780888259411, 0.04258165881037712, -0.0036540955770760775, -0.027487991377711296, 0.013305813074111938, 0.0030465617310255766, -0.024117514491081238, -0.02040695771574974, 0.004570343066006899, -0.0007353652035817504, -0.05782768502831459, 0.04731079190969467, -0.017964376136660576, -0.03079475276172161, -0.0030632554553449154, 0.010971137322485447, 0.02484782226383686, -0.03770054131746292, 0.03791956976056099, -0.0560917966067791, -0.03160727396607399, -0.06336727738380432, -0.030267836526036263, -0.029130030423402786, -0.019576415419578552, -0.03783554956316948, 0.0041198343969881535, -0.006993468850851059, 0.0019434711430221796, -0.02528323605656624, 0.04653875157237053, -0.008986325934529305, 0.018610842525959015, -0.025817614048719406, -0.033610302954912186, 0.03200066462159157, -0.019571561366319656, -0.03329210355877876, -0.02431361936032772, 0.048608601093292236, -0.05121612176299095, 0.017228998243808746, -0.08966828882694244, -0.02846524864435196, 0.06635251641273499, -0.01060920674353838, -0.022816339507699013, 0.01595025695860386, -0.029503224417567253, 0.0058669536374509335, 0.027104971930384636, -0.01761254109442234, -0.03619401156902313, 0.024391284212470055, -0.006523902993649244, 0.04053786024451256, -0.014439603313803673, 0.09060321003198624, 0.05451337993144989, -0.03961114585399628, -0.006492328364402056, -0.040366511791944504, 0.011083818972110748, 0.02060038410127163, 0.060287825763225555, -0.01397821493446827, -0.001238486380316317, 0.011840654537081718, -0.014255625195801258, -0.01049297209829092, -0.03015878051519394, -0.0022889485117048025, -0.012760677374899387, 0.0436365082859993, -0.11942209303379059, 0.04821745306253433, 0.013724246993660927, 0.024583736434578896, 0.001306799240410328, 0.05192543566226959, 0.07169888913631439, 0.051446206867694855, 0.02512812428176403, 0.06150232255458832, 0.027077341452240944, 0.02673047035932541, -0.019267115741968155, -0.010806290432810783, -0.05635373666882515, -0.012531114742159843, -0.014417223632335663, 0.08088705688714981, -0.041771676391363144, -0.03412405401468277, 0.021760808303952217, -0.04198313504457474, 0.005938705522567034, -0.0440816655755043, -0.002786681754514575, -0.026495307683944702, 0.0021118323784321547, -0.04616615176200867, -0.027201863005757332, -0.01554990466684103, 0.01672588661313057, -0.023919478058815002, -0.0013405894860625267, -0.020340440794825554, 0.02553713694214821, -0.016757028177380562, 0.01674341782927513, 0.08878037333488464, -0.03359726816415787, 0.08886264264583588, -0.0042404839769005775, -0.0016545536927878857, -0.01770286075770855, -0.03344128653407097, -0.03177871182560921, 0.02250695787370205, 0.035967860370874405, -0.07101766765117645, -0.016798412427306175, 0.03514804318547249, -0.03579726815223694, 0.037883784621953964, -0.018406428396701813, -0.03701126575469971, -0.008596508763730526, 0.00660283025354147, -0.006799811962991953, -0.0068375905975699425, -0.02361547388136387, 0.044532936066389084 ]
<p>In the usual $(x,y,z)$ system of coordinates, if we expand the Maxwell's curls equations for phasors</p> <p>$$\nabla \times \mathbf{E} = - \mathbf{J}_m - j \omega \mu \mathbf{H}$$ $$\nabla \times \mathbf{H} = \mathbf{J} + j \omega \epsilon \mathbf{E}$$</p> <p>we obtain equations like the following:</p> <p>$$\displaystyle \frac{\partial H_y}{\partial z} - \frac{\partial H_z}{\partial y} = J_{x} + j \omega \epsilon E_x\tag{1}$$</p> <p>Now, let $\mathbf{E}'$, $\mathbf{H}'$, $\mathbf{J}'$, $\mathbf{J}_m'$ be a new field (with its new sources). In particular we have</p> <p>$$H'_y = H_y$$ $$H'_z = - H_z$$ $$J'_x = - J_x$$ $$E'_x = - E_x$$</p> <p>The equation (1) for this field becomes</p> <p>$$\displaystyle \frac{\partial H'_y}{\partial z} - \frac{\partial H'_z}{\partial y} = J'_{x} + j \omega \epsilon E'_x\tag{2}$$</p> <p>If we define $x' = x$, $y' = y$, $z' = -z$, (2) becomes</p> <p>$$\displaystyle -\frac{\partial H'_y}{\partial z'} - \frac{\partial H'_z}{\partial y'} = J'_{x} + j \omega \epsilon E'_x$$</p> <p>that is, substituting the primed quantities with the equivalent unprimed ones,</p> <p>$$\displaystyle - \frac{\partial H_y}{\partial z'} + \frac{\partial H_z}{\partial y'} = -J_{x} - j \omega \epsilon E_x$$</p> <p>$$\displaystyle \frac{\partial H_y}{\partial z'} - \frac{\partial H_z}{\partial y'} = J_{x} + j \omega \epsilon E_x\tag{3}$$</p> <p>The equation (2) can be written in the form (3): so, we have obtained the same equation as (1), but with respect to the primed variables!</p> <p><strong>Questions</strong>: can (3) still be considered a <em>Maxwell's equation</em> as well as (1)? Why?</p> <p>My question arises because (3) is weird: it involves components of fields along the unprimed unit vectors ($\mathbf{u}_x$, $\mathbf{u}_y$ and $\mathbf{u}_z$), and derivation with respect to the primed variables ($x'$, $y'$ and $z'$).</p> <p>In particular, $H_z$ has a different behaviour according to the system of coordinates, because $\mathbf{u}_z = - \mathbf{u}_{z'}$. So, how can this be taken into account while evaluating (3)? This is what I can't understand.</p> <p>This demonstration is used to derive the fields in the Method of the Images in the Electromagnetic theory (the primed field is the image field).</p>
g9780
[ 0.002824874361976981, -0.0022220860701054335, -0.0388559065759182, -0.02820066548883915, 0.04492705315351486, 0.005070671439170837, 0.08296292275190353, 0.007680471520870924, 0.05863666906952858, -0.00882017146795988, -0.0256817564368248, 0.011609933339059353, -0.008555041626095772, 0.008395939134061337, -0.017916947603225708, -0.005273289978504181, 0.059469811618328094, -0.037570737302303314, 0.057031650096178055, 0.030451033264398575, -0.06943485140800476, 0.009834212251007557, 0.022453337907791138, -0.04517370089888573, -0.010276255197823048, -0.02710055746138096, 0.02629936672747135, -0.02449723146855831, -0.07735733687877655, -0.025050269439816475, -0.006804979871958494, 0.0534568689763546, 0.03224088251590729, -0.027005866169929504, -0.016442283987998962, -0.0026831175200641155, 0.046349216252565384, 0.05559565871953964, 0.014378685504198074, 0.02057662233710289, -0.008223403245210648, -0.02722739800810814, 0.03415146842598915, 0.04430172219872475, -0.005404533352702856, -0.05552799627184868, -0.05277246609330177, 0.02685067616403103, -0.02499256655573845, 0.030144494026899338, 0.007183310110121965, 0.013571834191679955, 0.021597733721137047, -0.01886412873864174, 0.030407430604100227, 0.027592027559876442, 0.028484294191002846, -0.014973815530538559, 0.05320662260055542, 0.058182720094919205, -0.0104611124843359, 0.00954006239771843, 0.03609122335910797, 0.017024775967001915, 0.020140044391155243, -0.020808668807148933, -0.042916931211948395, -0.058582697063684464, -0.02196614444255829, 0.01684851013123989, -0.009575549513101578, -0.030600005760788918, 0.004946847911924124, -0.05522690713405609, -0.019691094756126404, -0.014624369330704212, 0.037421368062496185, -0.04784343019127846, 0.039382755756378174, -0.020741118118166924, 0.014636718668043613, 0.03529159352183342, 0.0019351864466443658, 0.024328580126166344, 0.03571680933237076, 0.01849246397614479, 0.013138001784682274, 0.015832915902137756, -0.010571107268333435, 0.006720594596117735, 0.021258248016238213, 0.010508343577384949, 0.07741782069206238, -0.002394359325990081, 0.010632998310029507, -0.03930181637406349, 0.042760394513607025, 0.03731521591544151, 0.040757231414318085, -0.01624509133398533, -0.021108347922563553, 0.012818064540624619, 0.03636988624930382, 0.04041900113224983, -0.0557243786752224, 0.04038191959261894, 0.01497373916208744, 0.04265815392136574, 0.02254316210746765, 0.002539216075092554, -0.09494464099407196, 0.025904638692736626, -0.04124893993139267, -0.004784297663718462, -0.04057352617383003, -0.024973032996058464, 0.006328323855996132, -0.008509526029229164, -0.009341721422970295, 0.06423463672399521, 0.04133918136358261, -0.005979968700557947, 0.009237095713615417, 0.0668121948838234, -0.02508685737848282, 0.003592811292037368, 0.02811446785926819, 0.00014092292985878885, 0.03535059094429016, -0.014144540764391422, -0.04067856818437576, -0.020738504827022552, 0.013863910920917988, 0.008242695592343807, 0.008221249096095562, 0.006369709502905607, -0.031637560576200485, -0.00420975498855114, 0.03963596001267433, 0.04399754852056503, 0.00982729159295559, -0.04411633312702179, -0.023490218445658684, -0.09111635386943817, -0.024317894130945206, 0.024086302146315575, 0.03200341388583183, -0.06466779112815857, 0.07959280163049698, 0.03426791727542877, -0.011361707001924515, 0.10075527429580688, 0.021190591156482697, -0.008192014880478382, -0.040095191448926926, 0.044769372791051865, -0.0036137576680630445, -0.018328726291656494, 0.01999317668378353, 0.010861854068934917, 0.04944950342178345, -0.04340440407395363, 0.01693141646683216, 0.001041425857692957, 0.021606871858239174, 0.006641032174229622, -0.011948209255933762, -0.0741623193025589, -0.048311274498701096, -0.06263339519500732, -0.02940281480550766, 0.0062832036055624485, -0.013144358992576599, -0.01051137875765562, 0.01833302713930607, 0.0493348091840744, 0.023514609783887863, -0.012618286535143852, 0.027726244181394577, 0.016471264883875847, -0.08380845189094543, -0.03622763231396675, 0.026355933398008347, -0.0005761421052739024, 0.0009649934945628047, 0.02282976172864437, -0.04052514582872391, 0.06481455266475677, -0.0674053281545639, 0.02295873872935772, -0.04769597947597504, 0.04961337149143219, 0.0013805078342556953, 0.09755212068557739, -0.0023726157378405333, 0.025936271995306015, 0.014278209768235683, -0.05139771103858948, -0.056900106370449066, 0.03083670884370804, -0.004512983374297619, 0.025897156447172165, 0.05577932670712471, 0.04760164022445679, 0.02191987633705139, -0.01485354732722044, -0.04463183879852295, 0.01946907304227352, 0.057554543018341064, -0.04214027523994446, 0.009694126434624195, -0.061263151466846466, 0.01048623863607645, 0.035044413059949875, -0.05574837327003479, -0.04181377589702606, 0.03482380509376526, -0.02027677558362484, -0.02259143628180027, 0.04146527498960495, -0.03028881922364235, -0.004503719042986631, 0.03700433671474457, -0.004637868609279394, -0.06471197307109833, -0.01599876955151558, 0.013399090617895126, -0.0023537026718258858, -0.03317469730973244, 0.049928825348615646, -0.058974914252758026, -0.029980547726154327, 0.03370720148086548, 0.0007911513675935566, 0.06071782857179642, -0.04327825829386711, -0.05417996644973755, 0.000835341343190521, -0.011224706657230854, 0.0007502228836528957, 0.028482601046562195, 0.006623841822147369, 0.03193741291761398, -0.013178038410842419, 0.02486015111207962, -0.021594908088445663, 0.06138274446129799, -0.04966411739587784, -0.016201894730329514, -0.014307652600109577, 0.04588465020060539, -0.025321772322058678, 0.05807820335030556, 0.01618342101573944, -0.031475458294153214, -0.016057290136814117, 0.0196752417832613, 0.02784721553325653, -0.02025558240711689, 0.008896146900951862, 0.003997279796749353, -0.016840295866131783, -0.07745300978422165, 0.03563923016190529, -0.04595218598842621, -0.005363511387258768, -0.008091285824775696, -0.020968107506632805, 0.005748355761170387, -0.026444682851433754, -0.07999013364315033, 0.09573351591825485, -0.00710845272988081, 0.014329607598483562, -0.019480165094137192, -0.004890552256256342, -0.0005236848373897374, 0.021346058696508408, 0.0428682342171669, 0.009965246543288231, -0.019902052357792854, -0.008097412064671516, -0.002497035311535001, 0.007801612373441458, -0.0018394999206066132, -0.07309719175100327, 0.011055946350097656, -0.005675008520483971, -0.00177012849599123, 0.010633866302669048, -0.009085852652788162, 0.04935494065284729, 0.03314615786075592, -0.05149618163704872, -0.06979349255561829, -0.020574668422341347, 0.03245387226343155, -0.09206289052963257, -0.009871433489024639, 0.013284247368574142, 0.021905189380049706, 0.005585354752838612, 0.0447060726583004, -0.0049932049587368965, 0.04767965152859688, -0.0010770127410069108, -0.04959515482187271, -0.07118908315896988, 0.05546165630221367, -0.02964615635573864, -0.011845454573631287, 0.05690876394510269, -0.009258849546313286, -0.007835566066205502, -0.016252776607871056, -0.03240665793418884, -0.043180838227272034, -0.017315354198217392, -0.003465818241238594, -0.03331805020570755, -0.08478561788797379, -0.0662190243601799, -0.02260117419064045, -0.03774907812476158, 0.038860540837049484, -0.016857443377375603, 0.01543421670794487, 0.004364526830613613, -0.015404167585074902, 0.03581168130040169, 0.027751291170716286, -0.013940667733550072, 0.021306388080120087, -0.017383217811584473, -0.012486531399190426, -0.021424895152449608, -0.0918402150273323, 0.056044802069664, 0.03959949314594269, -0.0589074082672596, 0.0006136539159342647, -0.006269532721489668, -0.09007720649242401, 0.004920536186546087, -0.028953341767191887, -0.00041560022509656847, -0.006168213672935963, -0.030591031536459923, 0.011762170121073723, -0.04402392730116844, -0.001360395341180265, -0.007323296274989843, 0.02731138840317726, -0.007600740995258093, -0.02963007614016533, 0.026833506301045418, 0.0028680108953267336, 0.03518027812242508, 0.049783796072006226, -0.0010342441964894533, 0.04208633303642273, -0.03204241394996643, 0.014609098434448242, -0.017026279121637344, 0.0005658683367073536, 0.026007678359746933, 0.03029690682888031, 0.09043581783771515, -0.08602370321750641, -0.037176333367824554, 0.023751230910420418, 0.005299474578350782, 0.014094320125877857, 0.029303178191184998, -0.034916117787361145, -0.003294212743639946, -0.0029515353962779045, -0.029091421514749527, -0.059273771941661835, 0.006641343701630831, 0.013850468210875988, 0.02151232399046421, 0.07181735336780548, 0.055982623249292374, 0.012336278334259987, 0.004406600724905729, 0.03381286561489105, 0.014778103679418564, 0.0264115110039711, 0.013200567103922367, 0.028561949729919434, 0.030941534787416458, -0.005488364491611719, 0.01854630373418331, 0.05975117161870003, -0.04879232123494148, 0.012411135248839855, -0.060683783143758774, -0.04012458398938179, -0.019624928012490273, -0.0036181763280183077, 0.03980102390050888, 0.0404600165784359, -0.015785319730639458, -0.060660552233457565, -0.042455971240997314, 0.015425723977386951, -0.01383355911821127, 0.09638107568025589, -0.03118143044412136, -0.02480270154774189, -0.008714750409126282, 0.0715816468000412, -0.05584164708852768, 0.012081917375326157, 0.02394629269838333, 0.04324052110314369, -0.027373120188713074, 0.015461438335478306, -0.059293489903211594, 0.07492712885141373, 0.008974123746156693, -0.004815148655325174, -0.014665279537439346, -0.027657875791192055, 0.07020288705825806, 0.06504601985216141, -0.059489183127880096, -0.01118976529687643, -0.05505656823515892, -0.0010085329413414001, 0.06824754923582077, 0.017635414376854897, -0.0001461390929762274, -0.044452693313360214, 0.036629609763622284, -0.012444165535271168, 0.049712300300598145, 0.03861849009990692, 0.0625472143292427, 0.13853423297405243, -0.021355485543608665, 0.05729852244257927, -0.014030251652002335, 0.020488567650318146, -0.010759701021015644, -0.011491579934954643, -0.049388110637664795, -0.00011830969015136361, -0.009597662836313248, -0.037994660437107086, 0.0508330799639225, 0.028458071872591972, -0.0024538030847907066, 0.011403316631913185, -0.0027515830006450415, -0.018602240830659866, -0.042717598378658295, 0.06328736990690231, 0.015947291627526283, -0.06044035777449608, -0.031175129115581512, -0.05969581753015518, 0.026116134598851204, 0.060141339898109436, -0.006208677776157856, -0.05776653811335564, -0.02341107651591301, -0.04369925707578659, -0.014763151295483112, 0.06302344053983688, -0.01807556487619877, 0.030186930671334267, -0.027418103069067, 0.04275308921933174, 0.007048070430755615, -0.016783582046628, 0.03358960524201393, -0.0856432393193245, -0.040332112461328506, -0.003315870650112629, 0.014652124606072903, -0.03288297355175018, -0.007626147475093603, 0.012266187928617, 0.04238221049308777, -0.026604946702718735, 0.008594594895839691, -0.007443488575518131, -0.057894643396139145, 0.020249005407094955, 0.01897354982793331, -0.01813337206840515, 0.018485860899090767, -0.032282229512929916, -0.0048843505792319775, -0.006133847404271364, -0.0021353974007070065, 0.05735646188259125, -0.015157024376094341, -0.051710400730371475, -0.0007577472133561969, -0.06822160631418228, 0.025283660739660263, 0.007658518385142088, 0.027401285246014595, 0.030993903055787086, 0.03113386407494545, 0.0388265922665596, 0.02287871576845646, 0.06772778183221817, -0.02920243889093399, 0.02867944911122322, 0.008830934762954712, 0.01907709240913391, -0.009412051178514957, -0.039932217448949814, 0.037487611174583435, 0.008865953423082829, -0.06962183862924576, 0.039831168949604034, -0.00296241813339293, 0.08634526282548904, -0.04430991783738136, -0.02839287370443344, 0.06447312235832214, -0.03561671823263168, -0.046809423714876175, -0.02806178666651249, -0.05024340748786926, -0.013677485287189484, 0.0038145650178194046, -0.003016597358509898, 0.019135620445013046, 0.026135984808206558, -0.07428684830665588, 0.005758405663073063, -0.013889331370592117, 0.0012671771692112088, -0.005104098003357649, -0.006315252743661404, -0.06174827739596367, 0.05213999003171921, 0.031169116497039795, -0.06986024975776672, 0.022514281794428825, 0.06506909430027008, 0.012103786692023277, 0.04053590074181557, -0.01935752108693123, -0.021588781848549843, -0.04298783838748932, -0.03821096569299698, -0.017865657806396484, 0.00009131097613135353, 0.05579756572842598, 0.017597027122974396, -0.03882163390517235, -0.01867116428911686, -0.03926938399672508, -0.015779798850417137, -0.019927019253373146, -0.02838425152003765, 0.0031719994731247425, 0.00248643197119236, -0.056440312415361404, 0.030525080859661102, 0.0549849234521389, 0.033980172127485275, 0.057909198105335236, -0.02651407942175865, 0.02915935404598713, -0.005641912575811148, 0.04585937038064003, 0.003179386490955949, 0.012564602307975292, -0.02430499717593193, -0.02534278854727745, -0.002375122159719467, 0.040067531168460846, -0.007345684338361025, 0.007182982284575701, 0.0448557548224926, -0.0008676348370499909, 0.020603934302926064, -0.01673644781112671, -0.0840337947010994, 0.03013683669269085, 0.06369037926197052, -0.053282637149095535, -0.014705425128340721, -0.028535518795251846, 0.02298814430832863, -0.02267022244632244, -0.00035086521529592574, 0.02208859473466873, -0.007650695741176605, 0.03143564239144325, -0.0077821193262934685, 0.012909414246678352, 0.06789901107549667, -0.014021458104252815, 0.03450576961040497, -0.03241695836186409, 0.016085252165794373, 0.0003498312726151198, -0.028028102591633797, -0.03905080258846283, 0.06215580180287361, -0.011506418697535992, 0.039409175515174866, -0.020024225115776062, -0.07322417944669724, 0.007509331684559584, 0.05070733651518822, -0.07826906442642212, 0.009035181254148483, 0.033742014318704605, 0.008729021064937115, -0.006441883742809296, -0.01121069397777319, -0.02488204464316368, 0.017485106363892555, -0.03835419565439224, -0.03564205393195152, -0.03436371311545372, 0.016022348776459694, 0.032844074070453644, 0.01015065610408783, -0.009366699494421482, 0.04987512528896332, 0.027301624417304993, -0.0510660745203495, 0.0480758436024189, 0.014885369688272476, 0.05252961069345474, 0.005150056444108486, 0.027684293687343597, 0.002770524239167571, 0.0010586450807750225, -0.01245973538607359, 0.07761453837156296, 0.0009035886614583433, 0.005807930137962103, -0.06604849547147751, 0.001978154992684722, -0.010906049981713295, 0.03418711945414543, -0.06984873861074448, 0.03164319694042206, 0.01078779250383377, 0.009398113936185837, -0.02612660452723503, -0.004369733389467001, 0.01991173066198826, 0.01405934989452362, -0.012267494574189186, 0.011792520061135292, -0.03727337345480919, -0.0005793643067590892, -0.028505368158221245, -0.02151671051979065, -0.029877934604883194, 0.05958065018057823, -0.025799140334129333, 0.00043224915862083435, 0.043659549206495285, -0.002775409258902073, 0.024997742846608162, 0.04023294523358345, 0.0010940092615783215, -0.04461365565657616, 0.005867809522897005, -0.03707039728760719, 0.015229381620883942, -0.05599362775683403, -0.022987183183431625, 0.024461986497044563, -0.013767980970442295, -0.014035158790647984, 0.006285473238676786, 0.0015318465884774923, -0.025750311091542244, -0.04874642565846443, -0.013180035166442394, -0.03027636744081974, -0.029428936541080475, -0.03161052241921425, 0.015784740447998047, 0.02356696128845215, -0.026510270312428474, -0.0027018256951123476, 0.055148445069789886, 0.04634099081158638, 0.01950746774673462, 0.010549372993409634, -0.020397871732711792, 0.023919427767395973, -0.02007775940001011, -0.019791707396507263, -0.012577665038406849, -0.0050957947969436646, 0.0022541270591318607, -0.02403535693883896, -0.0014227061765268445, 0.0119555639103055, 0.0003536167787387967, 0.022992834448814392, 0.008838139474391937, -0.0010715449461713433, -0.07445351034402847, 0.03965410962700844, -0.04360995069146156, 0.05388496071100235, -0.020322171971201897, 0.02250944823026657, -0.023960188031196594, -0.006757291499525309, -0.018558822572231293, -0.05123847723007202, -0.03885430470108986, 0.004898133687674999, -0.07002261281013489, -0.08550984412431717, 0.008916258811950684, 0.010641684755682945, 0.027161594480276108, -0.007302815094590187, -0.0008198950090445578, 0.004539384040981531, 0.0015634329756721854, -0.053260430693626404, -0.021758224815130234, 0.029115114361047745, -0.023991914466023445, -0.007714074570685625, -0.04126666486263275, 0.02781805954873562, 0.039176907390356064, -0.059108950197696686, -0.025942282751202583, -0.09356861561536789, -0.0150816785171628, -0.05679784342646599, -0.019536323845386505, 0.03213779628276825, -0.0508243590593338, 0.030437136068940163, 0.05416466295719147, 0.03566260263323784, -0.02792471833527088, 0.017157381400465965, -0.029670706018805504, 0.06304628401994705, 0.019642557948827744, 0.0065269144251942635, 0.02274184860289097, 0.053038571029901505, 0.04265391081571579, 0.00876125879585743, -0.007474274840205908, -0.014868884347379208, -0.001923870062455535, -0.008484523743391037, -0.019975896924734116, -0.030182601884007454, -0.023664377629756927, 0.011608857661485672 ]
<p>We have notions of derivative for a continuous and differentiable vector fields. The operations like curl,divergence etc. have well defined precise notions for these fields.</p> <p>We know electrostatic and magneto static fields aren't actually well behaved. They blow up at the sources, have discontinuities and yet we use the same mathematical formulations for them as we would have done for continuous and differentiable vector field.</p> <p>Why is this done ? Why are laws of electromagnetism(maxwell's equations) expressed in the so called differential forms when clearly that mathematical theory is not perfectly consistent with the electromagnetic field. Why not use a new mathematical structure ?</p> <p>Is there a source/book, which can help me overcome these issues without handwaving at particular instances when the methods seem to give wrong results.</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>: Also one of the major concerns is that, given a charge distributions, the maxwell equations in differential form, will always give a nicely behaved continuous and differentiable vector field solution. But the integral form (alone, not satisfying the differential form) can give a discontinuous solution as well. Leading to two different answers for the same configuration of charges. hence there is an inconsistency. Like there is an discontinuous solution for the boundary condition of 2D surface, the perpendicular component of the electric field is discontinuous. ( May be it is just an approximation) and actually the field is continuous but due to not being able to solve the differential equation we give such an approximation, but this isn't mentioned in the textbooks.</p>
g9781
[ 0.09419681876897812, -0.04264093190431595, -0.024855701252818108, 0.015985539183020592, 0.08266104012727737, 0.029396897181868553, 0.04185512289404869, -0.019213035702705383, -0.04858829453587532, -0.03555773198604584, -0.024276630952954292, -0.04180964455008507, 0.04441472142934799, -0.009510806761682034, -0.008386450819671154, -0.04358580335974693, 0.008827188052237034, -0.032627079635858536, 0.025271037593483925, 0.014944217167794704, -0.00926060788333416, 0.022553900256752968, 0.07971051335334778, 0.014591029845178127, -0.039828360080718994, -0.01952173188328743, 0.018047545105218887, -0.03335928916931152, 0.02332446351647377, -0.09681214392185211, -0.010554391890764236, 0.03300582617521286, 0.08963759243488312, 0.0009757273946888745, 0.02091873250901699, -0.028244415298104286, 0.008671344257891178, 0.012928245589137077, 0.023235557600855827, -0.006917537655681372, 0.09580611437559128, -0.03398600220680237, 0.006472442764788866, 0.005145171191543341, -0.0021700402721762657, -0.07002700120210648, -0.06896480917930603, -0.03533605858683586, -0.01945374719798565, 0.010919691063463688, 0.001468006637878716, 0.0028348921332508326, 0.05106518417596817, -0.002228038152679801, 0.039731595665216446, -0.01892940141260624, 0.03359043598175049, 0.024426380172371864, 0.01682669296860695, -0.0741482600569725, 0.019992470741271973, -0.019615670666098595, -0.011159766465425491, 0.013638617470860481, 0.030302053317427635, -0.04760356619954109, -0.07846526801586151, -0.04367440193891525, -0.05555848032236099, 0.005429861135780811, 0.004378235433250666, -0.08182383328676224, 0.018676334992051125, -0.00304588139988482, -0.001575398608110845, -0.03538357466459274, 0.05760003253817558, -0.05061250925064087, 0.009414023719727993, -0.03771277889609337, -0.07426747679710388, 0.01213086862117052, -0.0027808526065200567, 0.007447366137057543, 0.0703229084610939, -0.03884612023830414, 0.035133328288793564, 0.025736810639500618, 0.0385286845266819, -0.048800498247146606, -0.03551983833312988, 0.030511923134326935, 0.03890569508075714, 0.01519783865660429, -0.01737656071782112, -0.03281706944108009, -0.019611462950706482, 0.07263016700744629, -0.024095019325613976, -0.031773604452610016, 0.012525741942226887, 0.02853483147919178, -0.0005406099953688681, 0.07185131311416626, -0.014830934815108776, 0.03911799564957619, 0.023523954674601555, 0.08232136815786362, 0.00143728859256953, -0.023180130869150162, -0.022915227338671684, 0.014186196029186249, -0.027830570936203003, 0.04780745133757591, -0.016245422884821892, -0.011642846278846264, 0.02063816599547863, -0.05878525972366333, -0.020679088309407234, 0.03173667937517166, -0.038218237459659576, -0.01990169659256935, 0.07366511970758438, 0.03496260568499565, 0.03625151887536049, -0.016763845458626747, -0.006753672380000353, 0.014247553423047066, 0.03657635673880577, -0.04079897329211235, 0.023808401077985764, 0.008961522951722145, -0.01505411509424448, 0.00930721778422594, 0.010364052839577198, 0.02182837948203087, -0.013017645105719566, -0.014396989718079567, 0.006184294354170561, -0.018905775621533394, 0.03454138711094856, -0.03047795593738556, -0.0009301764075644314, -0.007606199011206627, -0.010643813759088516, 0.005431842058897018, 0.01696137897670269, -0.04795967787504196, 0.04371906444430351, 0.0017540224362164736, 0.05308273807168007, 0.03829328715801239, -0.002724777441471815, 0.0009286426939070225, 0.004203921649605036, 0.04336659982800484, 0.05069094896316528, -0.0061409492045640945, 0.037480901926755905, -0.034396909177303314, 0.03558633476495743, -0.015370634384453297, -0.0293283574283123, 0.040730394423007965, 0.027362540364265442, -0.024999042972922325, -0.019464684650301933, -0.022824322804808617, 0.007804685737937689, -0.032750848680734634, -0.023083478212356567, 0.03212612122297287, 0.015618184581398964, 0.04136846959590912, 0.040703002363443375, 0.03518940880894661, -0.013741372153162956, -0.07015090435743332, 0.03954960033297539, 0.01613566093146801, -0.05722673237323761, 0.032652709633111954, 0.005573144182562828, -0.011311053298413754, 0.03538375347852707, 0.03355242684483528, -0.0846872329711914, -0.03307408094406128, -0.04181181266903877, -0.030147992074489594, -0.030898116528987885, 0.0006026131450198591, -0.05191560834646225, 0.06477685272693634, -0.0340067595243454, 0.03870359808206558, -0.003191400086507201, -0.0071436576545238495, -0.05602099001407623, 0.027220411226153374, 0.007796110585331917, 0.07471627742052078, 0.06403744965791702, 0.05538414046168327, -0.0137821976095438, 0.001014059642329812, -0.019665373489260674, -0.013673401437699795, 0.09582339227199554, 0.004422872792929411, 0.03603844717144966, -0.04005758464336395, 0.020522376522421837, 0.03391684219241142, 0.009818482212722301, -0.057787105441093445, -0.006652766838669777, -0.02827388048171997, -0.06627804785966873, -0.021162349730730057, -0.025545528158545494, -0.06142140552401543, 0.06157748028635979, 0.029713695868849754, -0.06257554888725281, 0.016650373116135597, -0.03330270200967789, 0.03473319858312607, -0.008725478313863277, -0.051810409873723984, -0.06341083347797394, -0.032751914113759995, 0.0100625054910779, -0.02083277516067028, 0.05251916125416756, 0.0004674202937167138, -0.01896773837506771, -0.06853512674570084, 0.04343213886022568, 0.01017304603010416, 0.015155015513300896, -0.05285728722810745, 0.03800598159432411, 0.012251126579940319, -0.032766323536634445, -0.06920479238033295, 0.07859881222248077, 0.021432554349303246, 0.021748129278421402, 0.025638295337557793, -0.0014990512281656265, -0.045976899564266205, -0.02518140897154808, 0.022250397130846977, -0.014093654230237007, -0.03786270692944527, -0.045876141637563705, 0.04099540412425995, -0.004249260760843754, -0.009247725829482079, -0.017402175813913345, 0.003575648181140423, 0.02686278335750103, 0.0962677150964737, -0.04089744761586189, -0.008306385949254036, 0.011903680860996246, 0.06007019057869911, 0.048480402678251266, -0.029043937101960182, -0.04817322641611099, 0.05503636226058006, 0.0029840911738574505, -0.006005377043038607, -0.021145518869161606, -0.012962943874299526, -0.005778029095381498, 0.02784963697195053, 0.04263242706656456, -0.0027064778842031956, -0.001765070017427206, -0.029584310948848724, 0.018677573651075363, -0.045559898018836975, 0.04909374937415123, -0.043522294610738754, -0.05925818905234337, -0.03668023273348808, -0.018767938017845154, 0.019470425322651863, -0.01330582331866026, 0.0501948781311512, 0.0025193828623741865, -0.05520585551857948, -0.05375921353697777, 0.00000864881349116331, -0.057163409888744354, -0.08418440073728561, -0.08079829066991806, -0.0057019563391804695, -0.02965332753956318, 0.03150448203086853, 0.014038280583918095, 0.009299042634665966, 0.046175517141819, 0.011964085511863232, -0.004901316482573748, -0.04565627500414848, 0.05695601552724838, -0.03232128545641899, 0.0011182656744495034, 0.015799088403582573, 0.02368330955505371, -0.016795754432678223, -0.015695136040449142, -0.02621002495288849, 0.04483812302350998, 0.03305200859904289, 0.07644156366586685, -0.0031562289223074913, -0.013997810892760754, -0.04224985092878342, 0.01604919135570526, 0.0023705081548541784, 0.03003326989710331, 0.0532500259578228, -0.03621779382228851, 0.04621604457497597, -0.016962852329015732, 0.010179338045418262, 0.009534803219139576, 0.012559931725263596, 0.04847150668501854, -0.01941664330661297, -0.01205911859869957, -0.010058942250907421, -0.007406583987176418, 0.03276815265417099, 0.05153363198041916, 0.009944085031747818, 0.02674119733273983, -0.04058919847011566, -0.10206228494644165, 0.007997384294867516, -0.05540136992931366, -0.045422717928886414, 0.00907672755420208, -0.013376747258007526, 0.007195640355348587, -0.020205868408083916, 0.00858883187174797, -0.00898258201777935, 0.07781830430030823, 0.01339973509311676, -0.06008503958582878, -0.013155746273696423, -0.002749801380559802, 0.03226092830300331, 0.011579180136322975, 0.05878240987658501, 0.038384754210710526, 0.009763314388692379, -0.010495886206626892, 0.026605656370520592, 0.027167756110429764, 0.039321914315223694, 0.04727129265666008, 0.08247102051973343, -0.06707801669836044, -0.035203464329242706, 0.04934487119317055, 0.04009213671088219, 0.021155480295419693, -0.012003576382994652, -0.04417974129319191, -0.031093498691916466, -0.024551400914788246, 0.04803960397839546, -0.025674475356936455, -0.02901570126414299, 0.06669891625642776, 0.061110109090805054, 0.0009498537401668727, 0.018377788364887238, 0.02617514505982399, 0.02649153769016266, 0.007962750270962715, -0.008505922742187977, -0.02737182378768921, -0.003151888959109783, 0.0028953810688108206, 0.006711701862514019, -0.011071202345192432, 0.02454252541065216, -0.04191843047738075, -0.048851002007722855, -0.04453560709953308, -0.004362220875918865, -0.00974272284656763, -0.0066162822768092155, 0.05089837312698364, -0.015255991369485855, -0.022456424310803413, 0.02086929976940155, -0.018212955445051193, -0.024235917255282402, 0.031233301386237144, -0.05478391423821449, 0.05057091638445854, -0.017725614830851555, -0.0013731351355090737, -0.03875930234789848, -0.0005217332509346306, -0.004035351797938347, 0.059434931725263596, -0.031875599175691605, 0.03753260523080826, 0.028216056525707245, 0.021325236186385155, -0.03218913823366165, 0.08590006828308105, 0.04436648264527321, -0.056116558611392975, -0.03461219742894173, 0.0035606962628662586, 0.06755249947309494, 0.043611738830804825, -0.0014820905635133386, 0.02532319165766239, 0.00032607660978101194, -0.012924348935484886, 0.043179165571928024, -0.04608059674501419, -0.03436502814292908, -0.06298600137233734, 0.01987261138856411, -0.06491297483444214, 0.05198889970779419, -0.005359482951462269, 0.04379148781299591, 0.05190272256731987, 0.0020827781409025192, 0.03306545317173004, -0.031360067427158356, -0.03182051330804825, 0.03486683964729309, -0.056868165731430054, -0.0355798676609993, 0.0015459178248420358, -0.0668845996260643, -0.05829945579171181, 0.021258896216750145, -0.01117647159844637, 0.0013604230480268598, -0.051864657551050186, -0.031242405995726585, -0.011104323901236057, -0.03651924058794975, 0.014693194068968296, 0.00646245339885354, -0.010206402279436588, -0.0007457845495082438, -0.013362937606871128, -0.007195540238171816, -0.0044257063418626785, -0.006059705279767513, -0.07392927259206772, 0.022070106118917465, -0.03515809774398804, 0.01294915471225977, 0.011616429314017296, 0.09908771514892578, -0.0028437792789191008, -0.05174750089645386, 0.06381504237651825, -0.02758416347205639, 0.021700697019696236, 0.019014736637473106, -0.04633293300867081, -0.007288831286132336, -0.04246379807591438, -0.040203068405389786, 0.035234495997428894, 0.0597151443362236, -0.003907798323780298, -0.020617317408323288, 0.030035728588700294, 0.03421523794531822, -0.01143551804125309, -0.0503648966550827, 0.037892017513513565, 0.02580273523926735, 0.017879953607916832, -0.002920071594417095, -0.010691249743103981, 0.03330405801534653, -0.028312016278505325, 0.024433737620711327, -0.03756803274154663, -0.025761280208826065, -0.08460475504398346, -0.0446380153298378, -0.06147482246160507, 0.0029856099281460047, 0.03793010488152504, 0.08811122924089432, 0.08959538489580154, -0.012452002614736557, 0.0030262935906648636, -0.01036510057747364, 0.017973966896533966, -0.014666670002043247, 0.03648127615451813, 0.03913208469748497, 0.006082362961024046, 0.0230251532047987, -0.028707558289170265, 0.03406793996691704, -0.01201903447508812, -0.041383225470781326, 0.061220768839120865, 0.019812844693660736, -0.0061124516651034355, -0.058290526270866394, 0.018592730164527893, 0.009546620771288872, -0.03937987983226776, -0.06581216305494308, -0.012134223245084286, 0.017869455739855766, 0.006047361996024847, 0.02545023150742054, 0.003292492125183344, -0.014611832797527313, -0.07382674515247345, -0.03589033707976341, 0.03533533588051796, 0.007311264052987099, -0.012295243330299854, 0.008821613155305386, -0.022807780653238297, 0.00707133999094367, 0.035346586257219315, 0.024794461205601692, 0.022813139483332634, -0.0302425529807806, 0.012169531546533108, 0.037655167281627655, 0.020372483879327774, -0.05469570681452751, -0.02230936661362648, -0.005393712315708399, -0.022671155631542206, -0.009896107017993927, -0.020896144211292267, -0.019498266279697418, -0.02882552333176136, -0.00675504794344306, -0.0669393315911293, -0.001881960080936551, 0.04862625151872635, -0.030120912939310074, -0.004612365737557411, -0.0449109822511673, -0.004324146080762148, -0.02972213178873062, 0.04026765003800392, 0.045019976794719696, 0.03014727681875229, 0.03076869063079357, -0.00014310005644802004, 0.025447335094213486, 0.005516155622899532, -0.015380504541099072, -0.020150363445281982, -0.030843989923596382, 0.01955563575029373, -0.025179807096719742, 0.005718747153878212, 0.02447465807199478, 0.05662260577082634, -0.0175069198012352, 0.02869056724011898, -0.039701029658317566, -0.011233894154429436, 0.006812859792262316, -0.060189083218574524, 0.0007236744277179241, 0.04205266758799553, 0.0070850178599357605, 0.046051207929849625, 0.05593467876315117, 0.05173380300402641, 0.0063564954325556755, -0.024225350469350815, -0.021736208349466324, 0.04363081604242325, 0.045825980603694916, 0.031059443950653076, -0.021249186247587204, 0.019053740426898003, 0.038478925824165344, -0.00008946692105382681, 0.012010196223855019, 0.06848344951868057, 0.01658664643764496, 0.002534060040488839, 0.01100856065750122, -0.02289685234427452, -0.019968828186392784, 0.017973411828279495, -0.0035743550397455692, -0.13062995672225952, -0.005585077218711376, -0.027082612738013268, -0.003250947454944253, -0.07268411666154861, 0.04156976193189621, -0.014448299072682858, -0.019463591277599335, -0.046256374567747116, 0.0045879436656832695, -0.014295034110546112, -0.0058859484270215034, -0.01437256671488285, -0.0010098390048369765, -0.01801532320678234, 0.03912389278411865, 0.03462349250912666, -0.013086033053696156, 0.06131875142455101, 0.035508595407009125, 0.014575001783668995, 0.010557344183325768, -0.006057083141058683, 0.0546678826212883, -0.0010159768862649798, 0.019225042313337326, 0.00620252313092351, 0.0327567495405674, -0.03346196934580803, 0.03931303694844246, 0.10922226309776306, 0.021836820989847183, -0.013914271257817745, -0.03929506987333298, 0.006451788824051619, 0.012910723686218262, -0.06826148182153702, 0.04362619295716286, 0.05151979997754097, 0.004754163324832916, 0.01624273881316185, -0.033458735793828964, 0.01727956533432007, 0.03689808025956154, 0.024561960250139236, -0.04203595966100693, -0.028254076838493347, -0.04536789655685425, 0.0068929437547922134, 0.0331856869161129, -0.0058428137563169, -0.007273436523973942, -0.012278874404728413, -0.01714135706424713, 0.02120909094810486, 0.0020591793581843376, 0.019349975511431694, -0.014476564712822437, 0.021634433418512344, -0.05996619537472725, 0.019063683226704597, 0.010686246678233147, -0.02050175331532955, -0.0249070692807436, -0.03476085141301155, 0.04439045116305351, -0.010308336466550827, -0.03921104967594147, -0.011167547665536404, 0.05144922807812691, 0.01782645843923092, -0.023683637380599976, -0.036031391471624374, -0.010800509713590145, -0.07594263553619385, 0.022618405520915985, 0.01610170491039753, 0.039866961538791656, 0.02380548045039177, -0.023356761783361435, -0.011562284082174301, 0.016439571976661682, -0.019310999661684036, 0.01761111430823803, -0.012186885811388493, 0.04383410885930061, 0.05722900107502937, -0.0021206745877861977, 0.03867420554161072, -0.007741672918200493, -0.003113802522420883, -0.022748522460460663, 0.009179866872727871, -0.009173611178994179, -0.03856959193944931, 0.018742987886071205, -0.04920133203268051, -0.008712668903172016, -0.02635868452489376, 0.016659768298268318, -0.021962089464068413, 0.01773460954427719, -0.01789141446352005, 0.05297891050577164, -0.01254237350076437, -0.0023610449861735106, -0.021642211824655533, -0.01023687794804573, -0.01181280892342329, 0.0064892820082604885, -0.015657750889658928, -0.08183223009109497, 0.053560882806777954, -0.005018075928092003, -0.03825097903609276, -0.010245013050734997, -0.003910009283572435, 0.008692130446434021, -0.010428871028125286, 0.017994357272982597, -0.003551282687112689, 0.02906768210232258, -0.014263230375945568, -0.013301602564752102, 0.011416029185056686, -0.019919700920581818, 0.01695413701236248, -0.07893498241901398, 0.02814939245581627, -0.08231222629547119, -0.028222471475601196, -0.04075410217046738, 0.02159150131046772, 0.004994871560484171, -0.014377818442881107, 0.015738002955913544, 0.04288186505436897, 0.0023895667400211096, -0.021947123110294342, -0.02435218170285225, -0.07330048084259033, 0.059373773634433746, 0.025155939161777496, -0.05783620476722717, 0.018543647602200508, 0.00553429638966918, 0.05787784233689308, 0.007738043554127216, -0.05038601905107498, -0.032512787729501724, 0.02444150298833847, 0.0008416204364039004, -0.00885008368641138, -0.01048334687948227, -0.047252677381038666, -0.005386942531913519 ]
<p>Energies of wind and water can produce electricity. But, can sound energy also be used to produce electricity?</p>
g9782
[ 0.0786355510354042, 0.02907700277864933, -0.0018642012728378177, -0.0053629400208592415, -0.005808296147733927, 0.01411581039428711, -0.056668613106012344, 0.022361697629094124, -0.013603568077087402, -0.013805684633553028, 0.02537674456834793, 0.01115240529179573, -0.053128596395254135, 0.020645642653107643, -0.04402759298682213, 0.04418647289276123, 0.05146164447069168, -0.012431042268872261, -0.012868912890553474, 0.05002794787287712, -0.0460960753262043, -0.06772630661725998, 0.007505925837904215, -0.02999153546988964, -0.017860349267721176, -0.020680412650108337, -0.016070101410150528, -0.04165705293416977, -0.05024271830916405, -0.04057655110955238, -0.0010606525465846062, 0.046077433973550797, 0.030820323154330254, 0.010813861154019833, -0.10465270280838013, -0.01145484484732151, 0.0013324001338332891, -0.020518900826573372, 0.05497134104371071, 0.016423700377345085, -0.03207213059067726, 0.05652598664164543, -0.019324451684951782, -0.006048216950148344, 0.007755628786981106, -0.0033077981788665056, 0.07014071196317673, -0.006039436906576157, -0.02410987950861454, -0.05757088586688042, 0.013021431863307953, -0.010665399953722954, 0.04217314347624779, 0.08446807414293289, -0.011249021627008915, 0.0279800146818161, -0.0031498409807682037, -0.05395342409610748, 0.08207534998655319, 0.006871121469885111, -0.020871896296739578, 0.05377194285392761, -0.0014334877487272024, -0.008209755644202232, 0.0710902065038681, -0.03793927654623985, -0.021486273035407066, -0.024023111909627914, 0.05094515159726143, 0.04619075730443001, 0.08708231896162033, -0.0167746152728796, -0.01264936849474907, -0.000620092439930886, 0.06695177406072617, -0.00022850792447570711, 0.04056382551789284, -0.021480603143572807, -0.08300725370645523, 0.03994375467300415, 0.0335964672267437, -0.028341688215732574, -0.0050281682051718235, -0.0130688501521945, 0.049917079508304596, -0.031997840851545334, 0.032131925225257874, 0.0020739573519676924, 0.042031388729810715, -0.028372962027788162, -0.015974147245287895, -0.013381066732108593, 0.025918850675225258, -0.000935693213250488, -0.017653444781899452, -0.018056249246001244, -0.04341784492135048, -0.0007664901786483824, 0.03259838744997978, 0.02643734961748123, -0.039577994495630264, -0.011109137907624245, 0.04590119421482086, -0.031477946788072586, 0.026240918785333633, 0.015982910990715027, -0.0034945367369800806, -0.09197986871004105, -0.0024491928052157164, -0.02823212929069996, 0.028525596484541893, -0.004578438121825457, 0.055848296731710434, -0.0023762439377605915, -0.06524798274040222, -0.010351527482271194, 0.05087482929229736, -0.02019781805574894, -0.007227505557239056, 0.08114410191774368, 0.022257117554545403, 0.013964843936264515, -0.006729208864271641, 0.017477411776781082, -0.009566010907292366, -0.003713450860232115, 0.010609802789986134, 0.010138989426195621, 0.026876386255025864, -0.04161479324102402, 0.06655188649892807, 0.0011480430839583278, -0.012813384644687176, -0.03873850777745247, 0.10727650672197342, 0.05142439156770706, -0.017329324036836624, -0.017365839332342148, 0.02299448847770691, 0.006923670414835215, 0.034908831119537354, 0.007964837364852428, 0.011582932434976101, -0.03581450134515762, -0.01985529623925686, -0.0054518431425094604, -0.030322829261422157, -0.02073919214308262, -0.02493416517972946, 0.05027347058057785, -0.03152759373188019, -0.004095739219337702, 0.007356416899710894, -0.01350424811244011, 0.031225329264998436, 0.005965055897831917, -0.021222062408924103, 0.006452178116887808, -0.02249562367796898, 0.015969157218933105, 0.04502218961715698, 0.020022345706820488, 0.06153487041592598, -0.019135691225528717, 0.021098433062434196, -0.040564246475696564, -0.009252030402421951, 0.034554723650217056, -0.0074760885909199715, 0.033473119139671326, -0.0419171079993248, 0.0019537380430847406, 0.020116599276661873, 0.04252460226416588, 0.04828928783535957, 0.026284847408533096, 0.05460665747523308, -0.04523738846182823, -0.048048149794340134, -0.02679346315562725, -0.015459314920008183, 0.0038344606291502714, -0.04092695191502571, -0.018741099163889885, -0.02656058594584465, 0.029262984171509743, -0.01138362381607294, -0.005983947776257992, -0.016688141971826553, 0.0003096695872955024, -0.042437803000211716, 0.011100835166871548, -0.02715953439474106, 0.005211599171161652, 0.020738886669278145, -0.0023123235441744328, -0.0255912933498621, -0.016347598284482956, -0.02510601095855236, 0.03168538585305214, 0.015611160546541214, -0.0034789745695888996, -0.00249662809073925, -0.037945497781038284, 0.028151359409093857, 0.10251397639513016, -0.015068035572767258, -0.06609614938497543, 0.0369817391037941, -0.048272598534822464, 0.04443293437361717, -0.03548409789800644, 0.006312802899628878, 0.04717059060931206, -0.0637233629822731, -0.004500311799347401, -0.06530537456274033, -0.10533659905195236, -0.04836033657193184, 0.018009783700108528, -0.02983320690691471, 0.016569169238209724, 0.005587350111454725, 0.034233663231134415, 0.003078591311350465, 0.03599725663661957, -0.028757687658071518, -0.024857021868228912, -0.07349547743797302, -0.028071079403162003, 0.01598842442035675, 0.023843035101890564, 0.02636578120291233, -0.02581566944718361, 0.017286114394664764, 0.03636296093463898, 0.016881944611668587, 0.010772613808512688, 0.004912121687084436, 0.0018714976031333208, 0.004004585091024637, -0.007081868126988411, 0.010540254414081573, 0.0071761030703783035, 0.0034858693834394217, 0.02601141855120659, -0.013005798682570457, -0.011565981432795525, 0.06413894146680832, 0.0030094522517174482, 0.06993365287780762, -0.002777319634333253, -0.005517328158020973, 0.065807044506073, 0.00837321300059557, -0.025804009288549423, 0.041971344500780106, 0.061226680874824524, 0.011277351528406143, 0.0005835136980749667, 0.010175887495279312, -0.027572516351938248, 0.0031891365069895983, 0.004364317283034325, 0.004098429810255766, -0.004782257601618767, -0.013870148919522762, -0.04775669798254967, -0.03870116174221039, -0.03313736245036125, -0.037410374730825424, 0.033689673990011215, -0.029551805928349495, 0.008249318227171898, -0.05818912386894226, -0.06877780705690384, 0.005004637409001589, 0.020289834588766098, 0.03908497467637062, -0.005202662665396929, -0.012768074870109558, -0.05928819626569748, 0.006856254767626524, 0.06851961463689804, 0.0028443720657378435, -0.03268476948142052, -0.01107091549783945, -0.019543753936886787, 0.017915455624461174, -0.007853700779378414, 0.012350073084235191, 0.021590542048215866, 0.05498919263482094, -0.0686960220336914, -0.02370300330221653, 0.009131253696978092, -0.032857224345207214, 0.014715236611664295, -0.00234247837215662, -0.016398290172219276, 0.04935121908783913, -0.03306116908788681, -0.021340634673833847, 0.0537424236536026, -0.035595789551734924, 0.016257338225841522, -0.023931652307510376, 0.007373972795903683, 0.05058526247739792, 0.004631065763533115, -0.016338104382157326, 0.009413753636181355, 0.032747842371463776, 0.02549559809267521, -0.07772789895534515, -0.0010448560351505876, -0.030599752441048622, -0.05533381924033165, 0.03159446269273758, -0.03983953967690468, 0.002707405248656869, -0.0028670926112681627, 0.08543615788221359, -0.031017117202281952, -0.04342344403266907, 0.04568982124328613, 0.015313406474888325, 0.028908617794513702, -0.030724426731467247, -0.061004023998975754, -0.023720141500234604, -0.043236710131168365, -0.013231288641691208, -0.002973122987896204, -0.03212139382958412, -0.013203726150095463, 0.04926317557692528, 0.05068691074848175, 0.00794178619980812, 0.06106001138687134, 0.06994570046663284, 0.023357171565294266, -0.037456247955560684, 0.005880024749785662, -0.04285283014178276, 0.0362725630402565, -0.025420214980840683, -0.029903484508395195, -0.010732901282608509, -0.025582894682884216, -0.011388619430363178, -0.026283124461770058, -0.011853141710162163, 0.02431952767074108, -0.01530973520129919, -0.024379005655646324, 0.03605538234114647, 0.00677072536200285, -0.003537370590493083, 0.014016869477927685, 0.011967213824391365, -0.026349233463406563, 0.07985026389360428, -0.034939005970954895, -0.004835308063775301, -0.014613257721066475, -0.007240607403218746, 0.015403581783175468, -0.012621788308024406, -0.0036854268983006477, 0.024691186845302582, -0.020991817116737366, -0.06610922515392303, -0.0077534690499305725, 0.02654128335416317, -0.02227398008108139, 0.02334655448794365, 0.0005563038866966963, -0.04506269842386246, -0.009149386547505856, 0.050138574093580246, -0.006549548357725143, 0.040114663541316986, 0.048706237226724625, -0.045954931527376175, -0.06097598746418953, -0.021725861355662346, 0.02195873111486435, 0.0009716117638163269, -0.061472371220588684, -0.02878662757575512, -0.02706320397555828, -0.025543691590428352, -0.028745753690600395, -0.015289274975657463, -0.02251654490828514, 0.01386726088821888, -0.023825576528906822, -0.02054048888385296, 0.10882675647735596, 0.013227367773652077, 0.026896970346570015, 0.015839114785194397, -0.020267654210329056, 0.034940049052238464, -0.03586050868034363, 0.04872763529419899, -0.04858243465423584, -0.04519930109381676, -0.05665088817477226, 0.01257395837455988, -0.045708805322647095, 0.010438681580126286, -0.01736612804234028, -0.031311050057411194, -0.0352427139878273, 0.000312729855068028, -0.030850766226649284, 0.06317503750324249, 0.050068385899066925, 0.0011517974780872464, 0.06346443295478821, 0.002978552132844925, 0.012196464464068413, -0.03797782585024834, 0.08843173831701279, 0.012417971156537533, -0.06308203935623169, -0.05939135327935219, -0.02619040757417679, -0.0014551085187122226, 0.005541769787669182, -0.02494644559919834, -0.03588579595088959, -0.008663039654493332, 0.07292214035987854, -0.016865821555256844, 0.009551377967000008, 0.04076188802719116, 0.020315038040280342, 0.08070725947618484, -0.01094217598438263, 0.005295456387102604, 0.02078291028738022, 0.037473343312740326, 0.049659423530101776, 0.040989067405462265, -0.05195062234997749, 0.001518978038802743, -0.015738442540168762, -0.04076226055622101, 0.008282337337732315, -0.019551314413547516, -0.0013031305279582739, 0.05667868256568909, 0.021199744194746017, -0.07062800973653793, 0.03759316727519035, -0.00676168454810977, 0.009278766810894012, 0.02714734524488449, -0.030718998983502388, 0.062005188316106796, 0.02285172790288925, 0.043762847781181335, 0.012117693200707436, -0.01634363830089569, -0.05903618782758713, -0.046982139348983765, -0.04932638630270958, 0.059417713433504105, 0.026533786207437515, -0.03240671753883362, 0.054622240364551544, -0.029341183602809906, -0.057821739464998245, -0.0247978363186121, -0.042241498827934265, -0.03333880752325058, -0.02458266355097294, 0.04337884485721588, -0.04052887484431267, -0.0028196340426802635, 0.031698986887931824, 0.0006339519168250263, 0.03941362723708153, -0.030774444341659546, 0.051798343658447266, 0.026404382660984993, -0.029492288827896118, -0.02696826122701168, 0.033362410962581635, 0.016133558005094528, -0.0423622652888298, 0.0035989503376185894, 0.08605652302503586, -0.01104238722473383, -0.046851687133312225, -0.07388783991336823, 0.015025603584945202, 0.028232935816049576, -0.04886186122894287, -0.06935855746269226, 0.008968484587967396, 0.031153734773397446, 0.027673985809087753, 0.040105707943439484, 0.015109107829630375, -0.004305493086576462, 0.057813797146081924, 0.011274308897554874, -0.024699263274669647, -0.04955078288912773, 0.046538449823856354, 0.06462659686803818, -0.022326111793518066, 0.010908336378633976, 0.018118223175406456, -0.011220860294997692, 0.002727318787947297, 0.07404403388500214, -0.031033536419272423, -0.01439250074326992, -0.04300603270530701, -0.0187184140086174, 0.003527020802721381, -0.06013577803969383, 0.024685416370630264, 0.0591723769903183, 0.07448700070381165, 0.06193972006440163, 0.031141158193349838, -0.00037825285107828677, -0.012901750393211842, 0.07564156502485275, -0.03420785441994667, -0.03608233481645584, -0.009790724143385887, -0.00027245437377132475, 0.0032868599519133568, 0.04033999145030975, -0.005345914047211409, 0.047446366399526596, 0.037528157234191895, 0.02713756449520588, 0.01126357726752758, -0.023198960348963737, 0.0030896798707544804, -0.011016055941581726, -0.054550379514694214, -0.015571855939924717, 0.049340225756168365, 0.0070419916883111, 0.005222163628786802, -0.010267761535942554, 0.010456331074237823, -0.005988546647131443, -0.04234924539923668, -0.02665560506284237, -0.01674775220453739, 0.030363943427801132, 0.0627487525343895, 0.015174591913819313, 0.0001922522933455184, 0.07067408412694931, -0.0031249248422682285, 0.022586265578866005, -0.029161877930164337, -0.04421157017350197, 0.040349651128053665, -0.008020714856684208, 0.048897843807935715, 0.01788043975830078, -0.05164965242147446, 0.04130465164780617, -0.08333653211593628, 0.021764498203992844, -0.04082893952727318, 0.0299919992685318, -0.045344483107328415, 0.030942898243665695, -0.022672085091471672, 0.015792246907949448, -0.008018877357244492, 0.005989664699882269, -0.021503644064068794, -0.007490066811442375, 0.00041539358790032566, -0.00004563334005069919, -0.0041335816495120525, 0.004883923102170229, -0.05042605474591255, -0.020995797589421272, -0.013563199900090694, 0.0009228478302247822, -0.047845907509326935, 0.0016409087693318725, -0.001987264957278967, -0.01910092681646347, -0.008497926406562328, -0.0069552697241306305, 0.005369117949157953, 0.052346449345350266, -0.008073176257312298, 0.009495843201875687, -0.039253536611795425, -0.02773963287472725, 0.04256428778171539, -0.022778186947107315, -0.009459919296205044, -0.06562313437461853, -0.0001995300262933597, 0.01668516919016838, -0.039238907396793365, -0.053018901497125626, 0.02062785066664219, -0.02873128280043602, -0.014564648270606995, 0.02864033728837967, -0.02188572846353054, 0.06307520717382431, -0.01960020326077938, 0.05711498111486435, -0.07405997812747955, 0.042128708213567734, 0.022199243307113647, -0.0526190884411335, 0.05749930068850517, 0.04930862784385681, -0.0032023442909121513, 0.006783455144613981, 0.04480353370308876, 0.03412766754627228, 0.043800339102745056, -0.026282470673322678, -0.0014202769380062819, 0.011325069703161716, -0.024863529950380325, 0.043454863131046295, -0.0071112303994596004, -0.010560046881437302, 0.059027593582868576, 0.018087241798639297, 0.047320298850536346, -0.027686160057783127, -0.023290293291211128, 0.03911174088716507, -0.06940215826034546, -0.028188331052660942, -0.0450650118291378, -0.00409017875790596, -0.07543966174125671, -0.006971194874495268, 0.004186457023024559, -0.02776433527469635, 0.029384391382336617, -0.032623540610075, -0.002659400925040245, 0.0020554300863295794, 0.04028899595141411, 0.04452002793550491, 0.02250649407505989, 0.02074321359395981, 0.05055945739150047, 0.022003788501024246, 0.009522229433059692, 0.016838453710079193, -0.027179503813385963, -0.008769705891609192, 0.04712149500846863, 0.029372379183769226, -0.04397619143128395, -0.044265519827604294, 0.01000869832932949, -0.09567217528820038, -0.044055499136447906, 0.002292585326358676, 0.04365196079015732, -0.004512702580541372, -0.03772985562682152, 0.028460893779993057, -0.03214876726269722, -0.059856634587049484, -0.037713002413511276, 0.061465129256248474, -0.030112069100141525, 0.006994301453232765, 0.012289187870919704, 0.0021607375238090754, -0.023626038804650307, -0.05545162409543991, 0.05325252190232277, 0.016261612996459007, -0.04681015387177467, -0.04526545852422714, -0.020226726308465004, 0.0987294465303421, -0.007577868178486824, -0.0027077114209532738, 0.06195880472660065, 0.01882229372859001, 0.017547739669680595, -0.015203864313662052, -0.004751953296363354, -0.06323757022619247, 0.006476357113569975, 0.03526930510997772, 0.009151235222816467, -0.027370039373636246, -0.039979543536901474, -0.03107668086886406, 0.003334897104650736, -0.03678170591592789, 0.06784636527299881, 0.009869802743196487, -0.004601780325174332, 0.009464984759688377, 0.03968356177210808, 0.013170057907700539, 0.05087114870548248, -0.0010299833957105875, 0.005013264715671539, -0.025049475952982903, -0.014671473763883114, -0.0010058123152703047, 0.0025279372930526733, 0.029387228190898895, -0.029902447015047073, 0.016719579696655273, -0.01763768494129181, -0.07311364263296127, -0.03582629933953285, 0.009254851378500462, -0.07368630170822144, -0.01066946517676115, -0.04676073417067528, 0.02595859207212925, -0.03641579672694206, 0.03941003978252411, 0.010350024327635765, 0.03884534165263176, 0.009888974018394947, -0.044977933168411255, -0.01842159777879715, 0.022309890016913414, -0.07300247997045517, -0.011287342756986618, 0.07637391984462738, 0.03290277719497681, -0.06577731668949127, 0.02782454527914524, -0.014269055798649788, -0.021859578788280487, 0.075985386967659, 0.04933016747236252, -0.029241885989904404, 0.047452863305807114, 0.027779316529631615, -0.002855955855920911, 0.006446524523198605, -0.05500573292374611, 0.04501285403966904, 0.009335157461464405, -0.04351639375090599, -0.03467956930398941, -0.04060206189751625, 0.0025039867032319307, 0.008521178737282753 ]
<p>I know this is an already answered question, but I couldn't make head or tail of it, and it's bugging me. I know I'm probably asking a silly question, but please bear with me as I'm 14 and this is my first post. </p> <p>I saw this perturbation while studying up a bit of linearised gravity:</p> <p>$$g_{\mu\nu} = \eta_{\mu\nu} + h_{\mu\nu} \tag{1}$$</p> <p>and then the next line says: " you raise the indices to get":</p> <p>$$g^{\mu\nu} = \eta^{\mu\nu} - h^{\mu\nu}. \tag{2}$$</p> <p>I have done a bit of tensor calculus, but I still couldn't understand how the obvious fact $g_{\mu\nu}\, g^{\mu\rho} = \delta^{\rho}_{\nu}$ leads to the second equation. I tried everything I could, but all I get is the first equation with raised indices different from the given ones, and a persistent + sign. Please explain and derive the second equation step by step, as if to an idiot.</p>
g9783
[ 0.0248358603566885, 0.02326809987425804, -0.024342063814401627, -0.02250562235713005, 0.031853727996349335, 0.03567294031381607, 0.049714382737874985, 0.0014618131099268794, -0.08740583807229996, -0.04160259664058685, -0.019577858969569206, 0.08792506158351898, 0.057682886719703674, -0.007204858120530844, 0.06977123022079468, -0.055891189724206924, 0.0448579303920269, 0.025284048169851303, -0.005891883280128241, -0.0036965198814868927, -0.07660000771284103, 0.024323178455233574, 0.09344514459371567, -0.06806422770023346, 0.057529475539922714, -0.011221452616155148, 0.06910983473062515, 0.031046047806739807, -0.07446131855249405, 0.0034711332991719246, 0.03067266196012497, -0.013400480151176453, 0.05095851421356201, -0.0086342953145504, -0.02337433211505413, 0.005835032090544701, 0.0724726989865303, -0.001886628451757133, 0.04505658149719238, -0.02838064916431904, 0.023250125348567963, -0.06298938393592834, 0.015599305741488934, 0.0304584838449955, -0.026944370940327644, 0.018909206613898277, -0.0028882548213005066, -0.004865186754614115, 0.0010999294463545084, -0.007616140879690647, -0.0652688518166542, 0.024254372343420982, 0.057538628578186035, -0.015027212910354137, -0.05482464283704758, 0.05012243986129761, 0.017921600490808487, -0.06312529742717743, 0.03432425484061241, 0.07693937420845032, 0.009935935027897358, -0.05497907102108002, 0.04689890518784523, -0.02807551622390747, 0.018105976283550262, -0.031129494309425354, -0.012683842331171036, -0.03109530359506607, 0.008524751290678978, 0.002577685983851552, -0.03640322387218475, -0.03876496106386185, 0.06073137745261192, -0.03864140808582306, 0.03913481906056404, -0.012809140607714653, 0.030654093250632286, -0.004333529621362686, -0.013651669956743717, 0.011734075844287872, -0.0011893435148522258, 0.0012112403055652976, 0.053941961377859116, -0.033603083342313766, 0.0015809140168130398, 0.0376637727022171, 0.03139926865696907, 0.012608915567398071, -0.06848807632923126, 0.03776555880904198, 0.029667573049664497, -0.02361564338207245, 0.020159779116511345, 0.02750588022172451, 0.00882046576589346, -0.02077183686196804, -0.02343587763607502, 0.012938853353261948, -0.02709035575389862, -0.02868851274251938, 0.007364744320511818, 0.04889276251196861, 0.034411538392305374, -0.00771348224952817, 0.009847295470535755, 0.048030510544776917, 0.07196130603551865, 0.04080445319414139, 0.0013084333622828126, -0.027877192944288254, -0.048403818160295486, 0.007384357508271933, 0.019597847014665604, -0.05608261004090309, -0.006679663900285959, -0.026897653937339783, 0.03832505643367767, 0.0009825574234127998, 0.007666891440749168, 0.05217961594462395, -0.06553826481103897, 0.014941662549972534, 0.012005091644823551, 0.053995050489902496, 0.00671004643663764, -0.02430112659931183, 0.014188806526362896, -0.00978755485266447, 0.06468487530946732, 0.008441343903541565, 0.047026220709085464, -0.01290143933147192, -0.011278780177235603, 0.04293854534626007, 0.007504462264478207, 0.03151076287031174, 0.002154465764760971, -0.003085443051531911, -0.06587451696395874, -0.007243875879794359, -0.028386283665895462, -0.05620018392801285, -0.005601064767688513, -0.017441030591726303, 0.010125288739800453, -0.0306349229067564, 0.07707476615905762, -0.035551927983760834, 0.02298947609961033, -0.03506770730018616, -0.011603915132582188, 0.07140987366437912, 0.019564630463719368, -0.04962645098567009, 0.03716651722788811, 0.0040394640527665615, 0.03904300928115845, -0.03636661171913147, -0.01543958019465208, 0.005920471623539925, 0.06682513654232025, -0.07208595424890518, 0.07125144451856613, 0.020167073234915733, -0.004817703273147345, 0.05226351320743561, 0.03304849937558174, -0.059111081063747406, -0.055414650589227676, -0.03464646264910698, -0.012028795666992664, -0.00734354741871357, 0.03869134187698364, 0.051700279116630554, -0.012371622957289219, 0.054976556450128555, 0.047143734991550446, -0.020698856562376022, 0.021726621314883232, -0.01716628111898899, 0.012009272351861, -0.0481523759663105, 0.015215546824038029, -0.042193032801151276, 0.027090318500995636, -0.032951705157756805, -0.05522150918841362, 0.03151492774486542, -0.04639377444982529, 0.007966774515807629, -0.0445476770401001, -0.002629533177241683, 0.02483091875910759, 0.10157139599323273, 0.042573481798172, 0.01735367439687252, 0.019896911457180977, -0.07244724035263062, -0.018686186522245407, 0.13791994750499725, -0.1008499264717102, -0.019755935296416283, 0.03439104184508324, -0.04008098691701889, -0.018920043483376503, -0.04515461251139641, 0.011149677447974682, -0.0021665217354893684, 0.045018520206213, -0.03739570081233978, 0.010606777854263783, -0.029755868017673492, 0.029609110206365585, -0.004243715666234493, -0.0682009756565094, -0.03290414437651634, 0.03519944101572037, -0.01676279865205288, 0.003007633378729224, 0.018104901537299156, -0.020177584141492844, 0.006294814869761467, 0.026466844603419304, 0.049428779631853104, 0.01565098762512207, -0.011357838287949562, 0.015364287421107292, -0.00599968945607543, 0.027020560577511787, -0.02327750250697136, -0.023287514224648476, 0.010271703824400902, 0.012034128420054913, 0.038585174828767776, -0.0034786956384778023, -0.011875547468662262, -0.007256004028022289, 0.018467193469405174, -0.009000379592180252, 0.02443746291100979, -0.04029794782400131, 0.019612733274698257, 0.024068793281912804, -0.017464861273765564, 0.016421955078840256, 0.026141496375203133, 0.05495467409491539, 0.01672416925430298, -0.0182657390832901, 0.0583903044462204, -0.005587588995695114, -0.05549155920743942, -0.015074540860950947, 0.008086984045803547, 0.01335530448704958, -0.005331572610884905, 0.0011185349430888891, 0.014170251786708832, -0.0012828442268073559, 0.055330514907836914, 0.04817741736769676, -0.009958282113075256, 0.016966475173830986, -0.005839888006448746, -0.06128610670566559, -0.007888750173151493, -0.02513115666806698, 0.004899090155959129, 0.02225903421640396, -0.010047192685306072, -0.014580038376152515, 0.03939491882920265, 0.025669753551483154, 0.033549729734659195, -0.07728354632854462, -0.0303507037460804, 0.03220902010798454, -0.0183864776045084, -0.00004379495294415392, -0.016520611941814423, 0.003188539994880557, 0.0035171692725270987, -0.06237693503499031, -0.012393159791827202, 0.023946981877088547, -0.04389854893088341, 0.010635145008563995, 0.01808091811835766, -0.0036062593571841717, 0.03796010836958885, -0.0016590887680649757, 0.03443249315023422, -0.015160630457103252, -0.005397601518779993, -0.043417658656835556, 0.03190283477306366, -0.039525847882032394, 0.017605949193239212, -0.04931189864873886, 0.004432517569512129, 0.007126112002879381, -0.029216742143034935, 0.026923099532723427, -0.021883444860577583, 0.035408154129981995, -0.03973284363746643, -0.01908864825963974, -0.02716156654059887, 0.01862623170018196, 0.04028406739234924, 0.0017587924376130104, -0.03849590942263603, 0.009995407424867153, -0.023817453533411026, 0.018774040043354034, -0.010746950283646584, 0.01580314338207245, -0.05246392637491226, -0.02511386014521122, -0.04223312437534332, -0.00900645088404417, -0.08086466789245605, -0.005479730665683746, 0.06600778549909592, -0.009957403875887394, -0.033771537244319916, -0.0317392498254776, 0.02791372686624527, -0.009857204742729664, -0.026440810412168503, 0.040524501353502274, -0.025829140096902847, 0.003074552631005645, -0.045605458319187164, -0.03482801467180252, 0.017907598987221718, -0.012200628407299519, 0.020326809957623482, 0.052793823182582855, 0.0007871014531701803, -0.019070960581302643, -0.018648367375135422, -0.022346405312418938, 0.009559516794979572, 0.00020733232668135315, 0.036347080022096634, -0.0031349738128483295, 0.010638672858476639, -0.031377289444208145, -0.012561232782900333, -0.014624507166445255, 0.022741379216313362, 0.03616219013929367, -0.034258682280778885, -0.022965433076024055, -0.0013909743865951896, 0.03656269237399101, 0.02406829409301281, -0.013696745038032532, -0.051069993525743484, -0.01410717237740755, -0.04134725406765938, -0.05973139777779579, 0.042763661593198776, 0.024470839649438858, 0.02081296406686306, 0.03532803803682327, 0.05936205014586449, -0.04425854980945587, -0.027753524482250214, 0.023824429139494896, 0.05354413390159607, 0.0030112117528915405, 0.022848540917038918, 0.014756309799849987, -0.05388382822275162, -0.008017206564545631, -0.0577445924282074, -0.014662661589682102, 0.032841067761182785, -0.02176789380609989, -0.029592419043183327, 0.02271341346204281, -0.005552311427891254, -0.017821189016103745, -0.02120157703757286, -0.030445829033851624, -0.01691116765141487, 0.061535801738500595, -0.04360812529921532, 0.013423731550574303, -0.0007725411560386419, 0.0083392933011055, 0.009774020873010159, -0.01876458339393139, -0.006758281961083412, 0.003060505958274007, 0.04772835597395897, -0.046994537115097046, 0.020344728603959084, -0.00174372224137187, -0.02876346930861473, 0.027424007654190063, 0.01684156432747841, -0.02656564861536026, -0.014998102560639381, 0.013876806013286114, 0.046190839260816574, 0.05087079480290413, -0.02352120541036129, 0.04755297675728798, 0.003954652696847916, 0.050787553191185, -0.04380035400390625, 0.0718182772397995, -0.015415089204907417, 0.051236044615507126, -0.009309311397373676, -0.026394890621304512, 0.010702071711421013, -0.02495564892888069, 0.03890883922576904, 0.017652880400419235, -0.003391771810129285, -0.003725051414221525, 0.08055765926837921, 0.017293447628617287, -0.010232891887426376, -0.035688627511262894, -0.010749214328825474, 0.0254889577627182, 0.01190581452101469, 0.03696137294173241, 0.04513310641050339, -0.0641254112124443, 0.0613262876868248, -0.08614806830883026, 0.092011958360672, -0.048633769154548645, -0.054302655160427094, 0.11283472180366516, 0.0004605411959346384, 0.010406424291431904, -0.05698336660861969, -0.05379531532526016, 0.01409773901104927, 0.0012747057480737567, 0.0016958779888227582, 0.02193521521985531, 0.01015371736139059, -0.057359497994184494, -0.002430242719128728, 0.060861144214868546, -0.021119574084877968, -0.00036786391865462065, -0.02439061738550663, 0.006208003498613834, 0.04256370663642883, 0.0020602403674274683, -0.023115217685699463, -0.05028277263045311, -0.024225713685154915, -0.017103010788559914, 0.016499191522598267, 0.06750968098640442, -0.016103366389870644, -0.022875096648931503, 0.03965919092297554, -0.05335952714085579, -0.02361728996038437, 0.03053000569343567, 0.01917513646185398, -0.00677315890789032, -0.04113597050309181, 0.01579291746020317, 0.02376854047179222, -0.010835382156074047, -0.025166470557451248, -0.02292124554514885, -0.06440256536006927, -0.03328126668930054, -0.005407672841101885, 0.013302973471581936, -0.007258792873471975, 0.00016422725457232445, 0.0041915373876690865, -0.03950386494398117, -0.020474744960665703, 0.022925211116671562, -0.021312160417437553, -0.006596857216209173, -0.000358234770828858, 0.024556046351790428, -0.00001064656680682674, -0.0347171314060688, -0.04087130352854729, -0.0341821052134037, 0.010965852066874504, -0.012400681152939796, -0.030368968844413757, -0.05921608954668045, 0.012724463827908039, 0.004106581211090088, 0.025943536311388016, 0.03780999779701233, 0.030615366995334625, 0.043552130460739136, 0.024450162425637245, 0.07805206626653671, 0.06603513658046722, -0.03306898474693298, -0.0315779484808445, 0.035237397998571396, -0.010961449705064297, -0.024186644703149796, 0.004976974800229073, 0.02751358225941658, -0.01613432914018631, -0.0008556251414120197, -0.08230631053447723, 0.04909137263894081, -0.0444796048104763, 0.02963453345000744, -0.023960253223776817, 0.05837685987353325, 0.05522121116518974, -0.03861449286341667, 0.013667897321283817, 0.03939869999885559, 0.0364246591925621, 0.024283243343234062, -0.023951569572091103, -0.009821980260312557, -0.05981414020061493, 0.05814962461590767, -0.026251673698425293, 0.02477964758872986, -0.026555033400654793, -0.002812081715092063, -0.01359675731509924, -0.01234961487352848, 0.009036222472786903, 0.034164153039455414, 0.07100307941436768, 0.014705639332532883, -0.0423685722053051, 0.016177097335457802, 0.014465618878602982, -0.0012231459841132164, -0.008730548433959484, -0.044507838785648346, -0.007305131759494543, 0.061519064009189606, 0.039470262825489044, -0.026913456618785858, 0.005608764011412859, 0.04511559009552002, -0.022464817389845848, -0.025384191423654556, -0.01802876777946949, 0.006314172875136137, -0.027026722207665443, -0.015166392549872398, 0.06221180781722069, 0.017377333715558052, -0.06565778702497482, -0.0043996647000312805, -0.024721018970012665, 0.07709631323814392, 0.038563791662454605, -0.02509654313325882, 0.060760438442230225, -0.03411976248025894, 0.019163308665156364, 0.05868052691221237, 0.05003736913204193, -0.09470178931951523, 0.02324400283396244, 0.0313093401491642, 0.017524033784866333, -0.05542868748307228, 0.029780935496091843, 0.010038470849394798, -0.059431564062833786, -0.05940499156713486, 0.003300726879388094, -0.04862828552722931, -0.0029135120566934347, 0.05126291140913963, -0.00883378554135561, -0.03712661564350128, 0.0003647933481261134, -0.0909929871559143, -0.053164757788181305, -0.013417168520390987, -0.01724005676805973, -0.018364740535616875, -0.004117749165743589, -0.012283645570278168, -0.03536877781152725, 0.06477978080511093, 0.007441098336130381, 0.05112574249505997, 0.04756254330277443, 0.04627066105604172, -0.04025902971625328, 0.005573353264480829, 0.012706876732409, -0.000934876617975533, 0.054889243096113205, -0.026276113465428352, 0.0072028483264148235, -0.012225495651364326, 0.005004424136132002, -0.015965638682246208, -0.022109709680080414, -0.0006753900088369846, 0.07972532510757446, -0.014261075295507908, -0.011892168782651424, 0.03788282722234726, 0.020457925274968147, 0.050742410123348236, -0.04509139060974121, 0.06645338982343674, -0.012348860502243042, 0.041905686259269714, -0.030372312292456627, -0.025857459753751755, 0.017699075862765312, -0.028037503361701965, 0.022643791511654854, -0.06030236929655075, -0.01023467443883419, -0.022042063996195793, -0.0020675642881542444, -0.04216684028506279, 0.030993307009339333, 0.004554812330752611, 0.056668397039175034, -0.013781729154288769, 0.05645139515399933, 0.029166489839553833, -0.03708500415086746, -0.0159260593354702, -0.05191115662455559, 0.04902152717113495, 0.01614258997142315, -0.09763169288635254, 0.0038612429052591324, 0.043114472180604935, -0.030528366565704346, -0.0132548613473773, 0.013240473344922066, -0.002740636467933655, 0.0005438752705231309, -0.03342193365097046, -0.02203703112900257, 0.04294358566403389, -0.021338993683457375, -0.06041537970304489, 0.011784609407186508, 0.022579951211810112, 0.06588498502969742, -0.01503345463424921, -0.002130297012627125, 0.03313368186354637, 0.007763133849948645, 0.08623994141817093, -0.019884247332811356, -0.010931545868515968, 0.005619831848889589, 0.01853116787970066, 0.02502182312309742, 0.028439301997423172, -0.00231313519179821, -0.01944860629737377, 0.021380817517638206, 0.015895500779151917, 0.006546602118760347, 0.006970519665628672, -0.026494981721043587, -0.03426484018564224, -0.07908748835325241, -0.01322336494922638, 0.026648834347724915, -0.045956097543239594, -0.001420025946572423, 0.007005305495113134, -0.0016343655297532678, -0.016941992565989494, 0.038431379944086075, -0.02503282204270363, 0.04085918888449669, -0.022848276421427727, 0.018121404573321342, -0.06323077529668808, 0.05134880170226097, -0.005860737059265375, -0.039583101868629456, 0.004398242570459843, -0.03200140222907066, -0.041312530636787415, -0.02967001125216484, 0.02325323224067688, 0.006413769908249378, -0.011555202305316925, -0.035410117357969284, -0.0472111813724041, -0.008643773384392262, -0.013533230870962143, -0.048822224140167236, -0.053584761917591095, -0.014852064661681652, 0.013789650984108448, -0.0036177237052470446, -0.02141551859676838, -0.020262902602553368, -0.007753578945994377, 0.011601296253502369, -0.02174481377005577, -0.035500627011060715, 0.00005414080078480765, -0.08475007116794586, -0.06017410010099411, -0.03526797518134117, -0.01917099952697754, -0.008641044609248638, -0.035431236028671265, 0.06436175853013992, -0.04344028979539871, -0.045881740748882294, -0.011450804769992828, -0.03386601060628891, 0.006801330950111151, -0.0017150274943560362, -0.004130403511226177, -0.08355601876974106, 0.03617632016539574, -0.042597297579050064, -0.011107192374765873, -0.11918895691633224, 0.04242796450853348, 0.03898018226027489, 0.023414812982082367, 0.01394801214337349, -0.0005635741981677711, 0.02873934805393219, 0.01664365828037262, -0.052267253398895264, -0.011872210539877415, -0.003995523788034916, -0.021893728524446487, 0.056832484900951385, 0.06840510666370392, 0.00522654177621007, -0.038229890167713165, 0.03483029082417488, -0.009602293372154236, -0.015896998345851898, 0.014106737449765205, -0.022796647623181343, 0.007146745920181274, -0.007196936756372452, -0.010538649745285511, -0.019262628629803658, -0.025592194870114326, 0.022330015897750854 ]
<p>I am looking into Landau Levels and keep coming across a magnetic length defined as follows for a 2D system:</p> <p>$l_B=\sqrt{\frac{\hbar c}{e B}}$</p> <p>I have seen numerous sources say this is:</p> <p>$l_B\approx 26nm \sqrt{B[Tesla]} $</p> <p>But by plugging those numbers in I don't see how this is the case - the units are just plain wrong. The thing is, I cannot for the life of me figure out what type of theorist units they used to 1) get this expression in the first place, and 2) calculate it for something realistic. The only hint I have is that it was done in the "Landau Gauge" - googling this yields nothing useful.</p> <p>What units are being used, and how did they calculate this number?</p>
g9784
[ 0.0020354785956442356, 0.05254596844315529, -0.018289003521203995, -0.02571449987590313, 0.04210729897022247, 0.03397252783179283, 0.014954499900341034, 0.022039251402020454, -0.013817306607961655, 0.02851942367851734, -0.0587426982820034, 0.04790326952934265, -0.0013854416320100427, 0.01784641295671463, 0.04106852039694786, -0.00946753192692995, 0.04896944761276245, 0.022679129615426064, 0.030591875314712524, -0.03371953219175339, -0.0418291799724102, 0.01140790618956089, -0.030011480674147606, -0.027793359011411667, -0.011682606302201748, -0.0015191314741969109, -0.007679009344428778, 0.09619739651679993, -0.07234109193086624, -0.051161762326955795, -0.03545789048075676, 0.06034905090928078, 0.08031758666038513, -0.06832921504974365, -0.049628034234046936, -0.0184511486440897, 0.018175465986132622, 0.027119865640997887, 0.022736992686986923, -0.03532087802886963, 0.010885360650718212, -0.041296206414699554, -0.03249005228281021, 0.012363727204501629, -0.027590086683630943, 0.030734451487660408, -0.024629367515444756, 0.0011969684856012464, -0.028421910479664803, -0.0003730125608853996, 0.014970976859331131, 0.041814133524894714, 0.10392583906650543, 0.06607844680547714, 0.01926446706056595, 0.038231708109378815, -0.04447251930832863, -0.05579899623990059, 0.0534573458135128, 0.0662841796875, 0.04602570831775665, 0.001779842423275113, -0.000014761949387320783, 0.000025651539544924162, -0.005492838565260172, 0.04738307744264603, 0.001615240122191608, 0.011476357467472553, -0.025906076654791832, 0.01750798150897026, 0.007028159219771624, -0.06537527590990067, 0.012624685652554035, -0.030173219740390778, -0.06681892275810242, 0.03348058462142944, 0.021191120147705078, 0.036151014268398285, 0.07454841583967209, -0.0025154089089483023, -0.024473559111356735, 0.0015921462327241898, 0.021161306649446487, 0.011835451237857342, 0.06091909855604172, 0.07270796597003937, -0.04730236530303955, 0.03145739808678627, -0.017026258632540703, 0.01816338300704956, -0.05599342659115791, -0.05592264607548714, -0.01857786253094673, 0.022748777642846107, -0.015791531652212143, -0.04498728737235069, 0.06997168064117432, -0.013517876155674458, -0.005320393014699221, 0.016099894419312477, -0.048785045742988586, 0.035394392907619476, -0.0408051498234272, 0.0002822282549459487, -0.057865943759679794, 0.004510132595896721, -0.004497102927416563, -0.015093243680894375, 0.06328095495700836, -0.02165226824581623, -0.04390812665224075, 0.01925787515938282, -0.07557287067174911, 0.022535450756549835, -0.04194928705692291, 0.045229632407426834, 0.06237923726439476, -0.008347071707248688, -0.029950207099318504, -0.008738984353840351, 0.05806121602654457, -0.027278227731585503, 0.02350858971476555, 0.06692837178707123, 0.015131588093936443, 0.004061706829816103, -0.04119878262281418, 0.038552723824977875, 0.025160156190395355, 0.006976018194109201, -0.022394193336367607, -0.034951742738485336, -0.008494389243423939, -0.030535979196429253, -0.005630034487694502, 0.08851880580186844, 0.019197730347514153, 0.027812009677290916, -0.020185265690088272, -0.021966448053717613, -0.021376892924308777, -0.07735035568475723, 0.018954211845993996, -0.06859204173088074, -0.03579753264784813, 0.046088192611932755, -0.006016172468662262, -0.040820807218551636, -0.005227468442171812, 0.022348545491695404, 0.011799040250480175, 0.07946687191724777, 0.02045203372836113, -0.0310230515897274, -0.04350752755999565, 0.013108411803841591, 0.05177424103021622, 0.011812166310846806, -0.005889217369258404, 0.003590325126424432, 0.012651173397898674, -0.04184957966208458, -0.036282166838645935, 0.0016442977357655764, -0.07811763137578964, 0.02173280157148838, -0.0000367350185115356, -0.06535298377275467, -0.006266881711781025, -0.029278380796313286, 0.004487808793783188, 0.02442212402820587, 0.06000287085771561, 0.044791191816329956, 0.00222015380859375, 0.0652671530842781, 0.06859824806451797, 0.013894883915781975, 0.0703202560544014, 0.02060691826045513, 0.01702745445072651, 0.02408105693757534, 0.06383001804351807, 0.008074604906141758, -0.06506737321615219, 0.026501117274165154, -0.047112833708524704, 0.01124199852347374, 0.05458911880850792, -0.0412694551050663, 0.000018222532162326388, 0.01344109047204256, -0.020517583936452866, -0.00578743452206254, -0.03247344493865967, -0.026732107624411583, -0.02386043593287468, -0.025615982711315155, -0.022056590765714645, -0.026725078001618385, -0.03934735432267189, -0.0030916091054677963, 0.060399796813726425, 0.02912389300763607, 0.10780941694974899, -0.05534159392118454, -0.028481563553214073, -0.02567034400999546, -0.007868126966059208, 0.01875210367143154, -0.03669757395982742, 0.01300319004803896, -0.013889097608625889, 0.026659971103072166, 0.011294388212263584, -0.06404653936624527, -0.028958141803741455, 0.020615534856915474, 0.015456560999155045, 0.013690267689526081, -0.031283263117074966, -0.007216643542051315, 0.06332747638225555, 0.022892426699399948, 0.0014422045787796378, -0.03291197866201401, 0.043105896562337875, 0.014238595962524414, -0.02385653741657734, -0.016225501894950867, -0.001717127743177116, -0.0005882296827621758, -0.044758088886737823, -0.0052270060405135155, 0.004540320485830307, 0.013890271075069904, -0.01029317919164896, -0.05125865340232849, 0.02681419439613819, 0.026736799627542496, 0.012655998580157757, 0.01875782012939453, 0.009701451286673546, 0.0577760748565197, 0.026664478704333305, 0.00887189619243145, 0.05143086984753609, 0.03022219054400921, -0.08555644750595093, 0.03510107472538948, -0.0550367645919323, -0.02930234558880329, 0.019091371446847916, -0.015855900943279266, 0.013457929715514183, -0.002577431034296751, -0.010789488442242146, 0.02658960223197937, -0.018917784094810486, -0.015229384414851665, 0.028461677953600883, -0.02271350473165512, 0.029168322682380676, 0.0375133715569973, -0.03456112742424011, -0.037408776581287384, -0.06452053040266037, -0.010262894444167614, 0.04166818782687187, -0.012406633235514164, 0.02849624678492546, 0.01785466820001602, -0.006179886870086193, -0.039432454854249954, 0.032962873578071594, -0.05015457049012184, 0.06078353896737099, -0.013750584796071053, 0.0463024340569973, -0.02476009540259838, 0.007825306616723537, -0.018009550869464874, -0.019465934485197067, 0.024107828736305237, 0.058610789477825165, -0.007108638063073158, -0.011477606371045113, 0.0018271830631420016, -0.0193275548517704, 0.025424938648939133, -0.023431379348039627, -0.028139814734458923, -0.008752631954848766, -0.006742342375218868, 0.007534228730946779, 0.01778339594602585, 0.010521428659558296, -0.00910569541156292, -0.03337755426764488, 0.022569704800844193, 0.023507803678512573, -0.00752842053771019, -0.015934685245156288, -0.03270379453897476, -0.0297454334795475, 0.014235695824027061, 0.016475042328238487, -0.05705615505576134, -0.006056233309209347, -0.049595464020967484, -0.03899339586496353, 0.03173632547259331, 0.09416455030441284, -0.027671227231621742, -0.007913152687251568, -0.005073659121990204, 0.04353935271501541, 0.058791663497686386, 0.005570697132498026, -0.0071374839171767235, 0.007070711813867092, -0.06438625603914261, 0.05399375036358833, -0.00856520514935255, -0.017630821093916893, -0.01571374014019966, -0.025798829272389412, -0.006889836397022009, -0.049056123942136765, -0.020104065537452698, 0.00679481728002429, -0.04995504766702652, 0.017208177596330643, -0.011162557639181614, -0.062211066484451294, -0.03759129345417023, 0.01126809325069189, 0.03530619293451309, 0.0077658346854150295, 0.006069334223866463, -0.011129374615848064, -0.0022701756097376347, -0.024888429790735245, 0.01192994974553585, 0.0163697749376297, 0.0031370888464152813, -0.02495134063065052, 0.008298799395561218, -0.05781760439276695, -0.017101123929023743, 0.012647535651922226, 0.04971586912870407, -0.018599065020680428, 0.006539801135659218, -0.014294862747192383, 0.05183742195367813, 0.03494153171777725, 0.0374702624976635, 0.014022516086697578, -0.01476051565259695, 0.06132691726088524, 0.007501070387661457, 0.029015418142080307, 0.026741109788417816, 0.01820535399019718, -0.013754047453403473, -0.0052529447712004185, 0.07613328844308853, 0.045647937804460526, -0.058422237634658813, 0.02827318385243416, -0.024333778768777847, 0.016102219000458717, -0.0016002713236957788, -0.02646113932132721, -0.028073962777853012, -0.03143741190433502, 0.001519898883998394, -0.026854557916522026, 0.009071104228496552, -0.0010738339042291045, 0.07980628311634064, 0.008542572148144245, -0.0007331857923418283, -0.031291790306568146, -0.053608350455760956, -0.06087611988186836, -0.005894289817661047, -0.012021610513329506, -0.04973838850855827, -0.06595204770565033, -0.011225325055420399, -0.08011793345212936, -0.024664990603923798, -0.01127002015709877, -0.006370249204337597, 0.01822039857506752, 0.004983845632523298, 0.013013764284551144, 0.04062024503946304, 0.015740931034088135, -0.022604437544941902, 0.0036861791741102934, 0.015448521822690964, -0.023760827258229256, -0.03084028884768486, 0.03254689648747444, -0.0785018727183342, 0.05928032100200653, 0.03843637555837631, -0.025327129289507866, -0.026987360790371895, 0.058119114488363266, -0.05350140482187271, 0.03864477947354317, 0.002652376424521208, -0.024516962468624115, -0.027798250317573547, 0.03435821831226349, -0.02286578342318535, 0.030565908178687096, -0.029706159606575966, 0.013245496898889542, -0.04207301139831543, -0.0346546396613121, -0.008391659706830978, -0.011844566091895103, 0.0286147091537714, 0.015612230636179447, -0.030598653480410576, 0.05672203376889229, 0.01810617931187153, -0.050464045256376266, 0.02516023814678192, -0.057520780712366104, -0.0030722988303750753, -0.027097981423139572, 0.033575646579265594, -0.019608691334724426, 0.08308800309896469, -0.0022119623608887196, -0.022481193765997887, 0.028967900201678276, -0.014756710268557072, 0.04930597543716431, -0.06205516681075096, -0.011232985183596611, -0.05378808453679085, -0.02706756815314293, 0.023727083578705788, -0.008708330802619457, 0.03451887518167496, 0.00271879811771214, -0.021935472264885902, 0.0663706362247467, -0.00971753429621458, -0.026779336854815483, 0.008637762628495693, 0.04969550296664238, -0.047572068870067596, -0.04217458888888359, -0.017492275685071945, -0.02462098002433777, -0.04625621438026428, -0.008801507763564587, 0.006903844885528088, -0.011037793010473251, 0.0069447048008441925, -0.004855484701693058, -0.025309709832072258, 0.006663089152425528, -0.03269104287028313, -0.014817065559327602, -0.028448820114135742, 0.07091628760099411, -0.04544968158006668, -0.0005345850368030369, 0.017878804355859756, -0.032754264771938324, -0.0473388247191906, -0.0354003868997097, 0.015094656497240067, -0.01322118379175663, 0.01835503801703453, -0.024574391543865204, 0.033601608127355576, -0.04328636825084686, 0.010329979471862316, 0.022697266191244125, -0.025314927101135254, -0.015787430107593536, 0.04931602627038956, -0.02117915078997612, -0.01870633289217949, -0.04677511006593704, -0.0404755063354969, 0.038433488458395004, -0.015386998653411865, -0.013728140853345394, -0.0048333993181586266, -0.019220957532525063, -0.011453965678811073, 0.018382908776402473, 0.014743991196155548, -0.0033279601484537125, 0.05316712707281113, 0.038830988109111786, -0.04384045675396919, 0.008713738061487675, -0.026015521958470345, 0.026066673919558525, 0.023186489939689636, 0.03249509260058403, 0.009985513053834438, 0.04248594492673874, 0.04393414780497551, 0.007986788637936115, 0.06917472183704376, -0.026508066803216934, -0.00015238940250128508, -0.0018942770548164845, 0.0031494745053350925, 0.05769318714737892, -0.07109243422746658, -0.03964770957827568, -0.023078851401805878, -0.03558617830276489, -0.03753672540187836, 0.011585310101509094, 0.04437738656997681, -0.04176134616136551, -0.04435868188738823, -0.02352352999150753, -0.018285315483808517, -0.006791523192077875, 0.006746598519384861, 0.03823639452457428, -0.017747143283486366, -0.012850540690124035, 0.004458014387637377, -0.014787279069423676, 0.03035910613834858, -0.06122748926281929, 0.07753351330757141, 0.0015396819217130542, -0.0015944592887535691, 0.03433644771575928, -0.05721241608262062, 0.0211951807141304, -0.06222672387957573, -0.08240489661693573, 0.0021040451247245073, 0.015512735582888126, -0.029597846791148186, 0.04546809569001198, 0.027278628200292587, -0.0483563132584095, 0.034579239785671234, 0.015363174490630627, 0.07166538387537003, 0.012999063357710838, -0.027554573491215706, -0.010625419206917286, -0.004821698181331158, 0.004258314147591591, -0.004437928553670645, -0.01521343644708395, 0.06929141283035278, 0.06579238176345825, 0.08356373757123947, -0.007384828757494688, -0.028563613072037697, -0.04156719520688057, -0.017322786152362823, 0.07916388660669327, 0.04580927640199661, 0.01624898985028267, -0.07861079275608063, 0.0011798711493611336, 0.03124094381928444, -0.028481794521212578, 0.024026788771152496, -0.001321435091085732, -0.009324236772954464, -0.028293941169977188, 0.09718778729438782, -0.027720099315047264, -0.03930586203932762, -0.05831805616617203, 0.05599265918135643, -0.011602385900914669, 0.008302433416247368, -0.059107422828674316, -0.005235138349235058, -0.0027732427697628736, -0.006482895463705063, 0.018330536782741547, -0.010118789970874786, 0.0010260185226798058, -0.01853482611477375, 0.00745268864557147, 0.03504433482885361, -0.03219926357269287, -0.005645212717354298, 0.045972105115652084, 0.030140578746795654, -0.09476378560066223, 0.013400760479271412, -0.0154716232791543, 0.0378805436193943, -0.027060484513640404, -0.008043932728469372, -0.02973879873752594, 0.014031890779733658, 0.04938991367816925, -0.045941177755594254, 0.010551409795880318, 0.002852365607395768, -0.010746166110038757, 0.07152853161096573, 0.022903701290488243, -0.03828097879886627, -0.02322584018111229, -0.03753022104501724, 0.05993259325623512, 0.040185946971178055, 0.07015176117420197, -0.0043569947592914104, 0.05985936522483826, -0.014844830147922039, -0.025257188826799393, -0.019186971709132195, 0.0035189895424991846, 0.023732369765639305, 0.02787153236567974, 0.03171604499220848, -0.03497713804244995, 0.006487986072897911, 0.034793972969055176, 0.03388993442058563, -0.034465767443180084, -0.04305959492921829, 0.01545584388077259, 0.04287923872470856, -0.021721769124269485, -0.05838838592171669, -0.01315855048596859, 0.033148143440485, -0.07523809373378754, 0.030144836753606796, -0.027019858360290527, -0.00020107769523747265, -0.0378543883562088, -0.01858549751341343, -0.023267662152647972, -0.01923913136124611, 0.03971092030405998, 0.009768454357981682, 0.07822930812835693, -0.05073718726634979, 0.025815537199378014, -0.008273660205304623, 0.0005562612786889076, -0.02642286755144596, 0.010266100987792015, 0.06318961083889008, 0.0056754895485937595, -0.02166799083352089, 0.06986420601606369, -0.10701845586299896, -0.031055400148034096, -0.022276565432548523, -0.00859097857028246, 0.01706075482070446, -0.008275723084807396, -0.010196774266660213, -0.017070600762963295, 0.024280989542603493, -0.025194672867655754, 0.0066588339395821095, 0.030565200373530388, 0.02879946120083332, 0.0010317569831386209, -0.08727910369634628, -0.023759758099913597, -0.011148042976856232, -0.03951922804117203, 0.004842853173613548, 0.08002874255180359, 0.05182880535721779, 0.051417913287878036, 0.05572003498673439, 0.05834052711725235, 0.026077022776007652, -0.05993454530835152, 0.004237815737724304, 0.020092004910111427, -0.012913928367197514, 0.06130761280655861, 0.02189391292631626, 0.08489512652158737, -0.012278602458536625, -0.038022588938474655, -0.01679854281246662, 0.0664680227637291, -0.005151102319359779, 0.03268161043524742, -0.026771457865834236, -0.0052865310572087765, -0.05930570140480995, -0.03266483545303345, 0.025347666814923286, 0.039719607681035995, 0.047224171459674835, 0.03956941142678261, 0.04317358508706093, 0.007624040357768536, -0.00011178721615578979, 0.018869882449507713, -0.02229510247707367, -0.036332372575998306, -0.04483961686491966, 0.02096213400363922, -0.0038939069490879774, 0.009252270683646202, -0.0349002331495285, 0.0279985461384058, 0.03586791455745697, -0.030398929491639137, 0.0062416899017989635, -0.006341375410556793, -0.05480470880866051, -0.013328981585800648, 0.011434937827289104, -0.051643744111061096, -0.05308651551604271, -0.030348187312483788, 0.010289168916642666, 0.003663900773972273, -0.01736506260931492, -0.001640412607230246, -0.059676364064216614, 0.02448037452995777, -0.036380745470523834, -0.013149361126124859, -0.0193930696696043, -0.08611679822206497, 0.04961085692048073, 0.025575755164027214, -0.0426492877304554, 0.018390841782093048, -0.0013784943148493767, 0.02196187525987625, 0.020351124927401543, 0.04592428356409073, -0.059104565531015396, 0.009338190779089928, 0.05439930036664009, -0.006556383334100246, 0.03341694548726082, 0.004654102958738804, -0.04168305918574333, 0.014107150956988335, 0.03146911412477493, -0.015689603984355927, -0.0014299442991614342, -0.015860665589571, -0.006991994101554155 ]
<p>The oil drop experiment performed by Robert Millikan in 1909 enables us to calculate the elementary charge.</p> <p>The following forces have effect on the droplet:</p> <ol> <li>$F_\mathrm{G} = m g = \frac{4}{3} \, \pi r^3 \rho_\mathrm{Oil} g$</li> <li>$F_\mathrm{A} = \frac{4}{3} \, \pi r^3 \rho_\mathrm{Air} g$</li> <li>$F_\mathrm{E} = q E = \frac{qU}{d}$</li> <li>$F_\mathrm{R} = 6\,\pi\eta r v$</li> </ol> <p>However, which steps of calculation are necessary to finally calculate the elementary electric charge (charge of the electron) or at least a multiple of it?</p> <p>$$q = \frac{9 \pi d}{2 U} \sqrt{\frac{\eta^3 (v_1 - v_2)}{\rho^* g}} (v_1 + v_2)$$</p>
g9785
[ 0.0034079544711858034, 0.007591425906866789, -0.034858159720897675, -0.045226097106933594, 0.09330526739358902, 0.038238584995269775, -0.04705798998475075, -0.011193188838660717, -0.048111412674188614, 0.007100635673850775, -0.025063881650567055, -0.007513003423810005, 0.013129877857863903, 0.017274383455514908, -0.002740762196481228, 0.03292318060994148, 0.0454634353518486, -0.039407480508089066, 0.040309127420186996, -0.020426467061042786, -0.021686995401978493, -0.006075319834053516, -0.028537238016724586, -0.08417840301990509, 0.020494822412729263, -0.04602433368563652, 0.006646598689258099, 0.05738930031657219, 0.0033859368413686752, -0.020362360402941704, -0.020427178591489792, 0.012421012856066227, 0.0006396464304998517, -0.018054544925689697, -0.08072906732559204, -0.034142449498176575, 0.018702711910009384, 0.06368332356214523, -0.005624605808407068, -0.05741884931921959, -0.07263067364692688, 0.007662681397050619, 0.06332020461559296, 0.005190973170101643, 0.02846008725464344, -0.04400214925408363, -0.021213719621300697, -0.032736942172050476, -0.009893983602523804, 0.03240582346916199, 0.022787686437368393, 0.04434346407651901, 0.03744067624211311, 0.002930733375251293, -0.020140908658504486, 0.017981939017772675, 0.008132370188832283, -0.029575252905488014, 0.016057513654232025, 0.06644090265035629, 0.021083654835820198, -0.008197534829378128, 0.01591172255575657, -0.028293022885918617, 0.018921686336398125, -0.041506122797727585, -0.058974653482437134, -0.0034989805426448584, 0.0034344198647886515, 0.017807835713028908, -0.02138534188270569, -0.06043918430805206, -0.016820209100842476, 0.00008264554344350472, 0.0029826476238667965, -0.01661035791039467, -0.01466380339115858, -0.005055797286331654, 0.09302998334169388, -0.056022029370069504, 0.020685873925685883, -0.01605752483010292, 0.05032942444086075, 0.030875125899910927, -0.011825550347566605, -0.031286220997571945, -0.05579560622572899, 0.014994518831372261, -0.0007532636518590152, -0.012388837523758411, 0.01590215414762497, -0.008213228546082973, 0.027169259265065193, -0.005415111780166626, -0.0009380405535921454, -0.08492276817560196, -0.006771293934434652, 0.06303000450134277, 0.01833326183259487, 0.00610391516238451, 0.004381756763905287, -0.03946039825677872, 0.02326740138232708, -0.007695189211517572, -0.00009087729267776012, -0.011545024812221527, 0.003042899537831545, 0.055127017199993134, 0.000012637956388061866, 0.024004651233553886, -0.021208103746175766, -0.04868542402982712, 0.005239027552306652, -0.05506325140595436, -0.011892667040228844, 0.009153223596513271, 0.04850764200091362, -0.02617206797003746, -0.01078090164810419, 0.03284119442105293, -0.027205385267734528, 0.07818859815597534, 0.10174565017223358, 0.05207427218556404, -0.004094504285603762, -0.06917231529951096, 0.03142617270350456, 0.025873616337776184, 0.04626572132110596, -0.02465002052485943, 0.027484260499477386, -0.017115021124482155, -0.02877230755984783, -0.030524365603923798, 0.029073059558868408, 0.008158876560628414, -0.023585962131619453, 0.01134443562477827, 0.015734553337097168, -0.06944713741540909, 0.013726184144616127, -0.0022122052032500505, -0.008022074587643147, -0.028753358870744705, -0.0043785301968455315, 0.011407739482820034, -0.04478800669312477, -0.016073260456323624, 0.021207183599472046, -0.007495195604860783, 0.04981939494609833, -0.03388386592268944, 0.06771139055490494, -0.02633843943476677, 0.03397234529256821, -0.003122447757050395, 0.044194817543029785, -0.04778745025396347, -0.007247439119964838, 0.05524247884750366, 0.03154004365205765, -0.015100084245204926, 0.045736659318208694, 0.04179460182785988, -0.04820636659860611, 0.036077339202165604, 0.07359287887811661, -0.009890899062156677, 0.04534992203116417, -0.022499773651361465, -0.019861917942762375, -0.0418408177793026, -0.0006563267670571804, 0.022002117708325386, 0.025129657238721848, -0.011549479328095913, -0.02699005790054798, -0.0733303427696228, 0.04859454557299614, 0.036345187574625015, 0.04617008939385414, 0.0237052571028471, 0.033973488956689835, 0.042898062616586685, -0.007943298667669296, 0.027806978672742844, -0.018807947635650635, 0.024689747020602226, 0.005722137168049812, -0.0017863836837932467, -0.055928606539964676, 0.022425012663006783, 0.018173830583691597, -0.024638937786221504, -0.009429902769625187, 0.007222247775644064, 0.020970307290554047, -0.0393514409661293, -0.03771505877375603, 0.04105722904205322, -0.025021903216838837, 0.001501765800639987, 0.02546808123588562, 0.02936532162129879, 0.010127641260623932, 0.04293124005198479, 0.02723703533411026, -0.023961422964930534, 0.010322864167392254, -0.06204792484641075, 0.00836358591914177, 0.021211620420217514, 0.025122107937932014, 0.013501550070941448, -0.04523796960711479, -0.003545579267665744, -0.010869045741856098, -0.02963855117559433, -0.03178559988737106, 0.06008933112025261, -0.059751156717538834, 0.028652260079979897, -0.028874600306153297, 0.002195468172430992, 0.013165032491087914, 0.017944667488336563, 0.04365677013993263, -0.07312624901533127, -0.03755827620625496, -0.017090357840061188, -0.0459311380982399, 0.0275015439838171, -0.08718115836381912, 0.02629692107439041, 0.00027299870271235704, 0.032031163573265076, -0.101902075111866, -0.06889069825410843, 0.04418925940990448, -0.022859318181872368, 0.0356387197971344, -0.036202020943164825, 0.05150740221142769, 0.0007356760324910283, -0.01192562747746706, 0.035122379660606384, 0.04438963904976845, 0.03817382827401161, -0.017786478623747826, 0.0029745232313871384, 0.0008513138745911419, -0.006601537577807903, -0.053745485842227936, 0.05316563695669174, -0.016938121989369392, 0.02738245390355587, -0.055764779448509216, 0.024271897971630096, 0.04097476601600647, -0.005058785434812307, -0.05821279063820839, 0.0535954013466835, 0.0548761710524559, -0.02558591216802597, -0.05349510908126831, -0.005149392411112785, -0.053055692464113235, 0.00811771396547556, 0.02611047588288784, -0.0418194979429245, -0.02688920684158802, 0.021395377814769745, 0.024953700602054596, 0.01699993945658207, 0.014884870499372482, -0.07179892063140869, 0.03135838732123375, 0.0091039277613163, 0.02473466843366623, -0.0008579487330280244, -0.044837914407253265, 0.00022672473278362304, -0.02670360542833805, 0.03706856444478035, 0.009578614495694637, -0.05033782869577408, 0.07720101624727249, -0.012371545657515526, -0.0031449024099856615, -0.07635727524757385, -0.048367127776145935, 0.02440517209470272, 0.01952119916677475, -0.02150704525411129, -0.018390195444226265, 0.005667217541486025, 0.07532960921525955, -0.0024706630501896143, -0.03355149179697037, 0.04846595972776413, 0.02559918910264969, -0.03376636281609535, -0.029023831710219383, 0.038364194333553314, 0.03641568869352341, 0.06203977018594742, 0.004552674014121294, -0.03357939049601555, -0.0011279309401288629, 0.05576450750231743, -0.06294877082109451, 0.06816994398832321, 0.0049525052309036255, -0.04219161719083786, -0.06642796844244003, -0.014748248271644115, 0.012093202210962772, 0.0001631800114409998, -0.03121573105454445, -0.041516829282045364, 0.03323165327310562, -0.0509478822350502, -0.009075659327208996, 0.001870735315605998, 0.03027252107858658, 0.10581540316343307, -0.07353314757347107, 0.006644915323704481, -0.009057747200131416, -0.03608148172497749, -0.010473396629095078, 0.011710788123309612, -0.01220772136002779, -0.013229585252702236, -0.0275772325694561, -0.02656593732535839, -0.023730913177132607, 0.016798341646790504, -0.025019971653819084, 0.02237287349998951, -0.010874861851334572, -0.053997837007045746, -0.053444504737854004, -0.06107698008418083, -0.021211793646216393, -0.007006621919572353, -0.018448399379849434, 0.015929505228996277, 0.0065801115706563, -0.012325587682425976, 0.004017611965537071, -0.035974375903606415, 0.007456017658114433, 0.016876118257641792, 0.0002848101139534265, -0.022914767265319824, -0.0034589802380651236, -0.005766277667135, 0.002877205843105912, 0.04538605362176895, 0.028476154431700706, -0.04885810986161232, 0.042154766619205475, -0.01506814081221819, 0.033737633377313614, -0.05543791130185127, -0.02452142909169197, 0.05470392853021622, 0.015541738830506802, -0.02794342301785946, -0.04332345351576805, 0.06148015707731247, -0.00037073204293847084, 0.027740994468331337, 0.021994290873408318, -0.03552583232522011, 0.017519135028123856, 0.002141191391274333, -0.050878625363111496, 0.030145015567541122, 0.004496649373322725, -0.011009521782398224, -0.009775611571967602, 0.010545185767114162, 0.020825348794460297, 0.012128588743507862, -0.01357937976717949, 0.030759230256080627, 0.026336709037423134, -0.04391684755682945, -0.025734631344676018, -0.026606183499097824, -0.060553498566150665, 0.019834140315651894, -0.036596957594156265, -0.02045552246272564, 0.08805008977651596, -0.08044429123401642, -0.020096858963370323, 0.05305035784840584, 0.015607111155986786, 0.008780399337410927, 0.06242543086409569, -0.038051120936870575, 0.0072172642685472965, 0.04624931886792183, 0.07386619597673416, -0.05516984686255455, 0.05264187976717949, -0.02512630634009838, -0.010931281372904778, -0.055189188569784164, -0.008478601463139057, -0.00863990094512701, -0.044005073606967926, -0.07338379323482513, 0.06439685821533203, 0.022114060819149017, -0.03591890260577202, 0.0018863248405978084, 0.03473644331097603, 0.014457683078944683, -0.01587744802236557, -0.06404377520084381, -0.00888347253203392, -0.013737023808062077, 0.05138068646192551, -0.02822967804968357, 0.02787105366587639, -0.016354411840438843, 0.028992051258683205, 0.03604963794350624, -0.03460731729865074, 0.015427649952471256, -0.07785622030496597, 0.030573131516575813, -0.02619958110153675, -0.020442413166165352, -0.02628934010863304, 0.02425951138138771, 0.10043245553970337, 0.012325678020715714, -0.028114931657910347, 0.03829233720898628, 0.0290487390011549, 0.05243244022130966, -0.04558444768190384, -0.017150646075606346, 0.043542373925447464, -0.04263399541378021, -0.014604147523641586, -0.003106440184637904, 0.042456742376089096, 0.009962593205273151, 0.04509185627102852, 0.03060472384095192, 0.001699330983683467, -0.004476687405258417, -0.02092192880809307, 0.039877571165561676, -0.035488177090883255, 0.0449913926422596, 0.003888024017214775, 0.03442848473787308, 0.056273989379405975, -0.004913111217319965, -0.040219713002443314, -0.010273812338709831, -0.018201375380158424, -0.04049375653266907, -0.017102180048823357, 0.029768995940685272, 0.06883838772773743, -0.00685045775026083, 0.02530701272189617, -0.035451412200927734, 0.010953276418149471, 0.016382096335291862, 0.008563841693103313, -0.030247686430811882, -0.03516707941889763, -0.06045078486204147, -0.060123641043901443, 0.03470761701464653, -0.021966584026813507, -0.02783682942390442, -0.04673110693693161, -0.0009254259639419615, -0.030632570385932922, 0.006303824950009584, 0.016683001071214676, 0.057903919368982315, -0.010969818569719791, -0.02409559302031994, 0.008503115735948086, 0.0230192169547081, 0.033941153436899185, -0.008179941214621067, -0.01198023371398449, 0.038083285093307495, -0.06100693717598915, 0.006040743086487055, -0.009908229112625122, 0.02095300517976284, -0.01588575355708599, 0.03396528959274292, 0.007112827152013779, -0.05079527944326401, 0.013308930210769176, 0.025134684517979622, -0.009135540574789047, 0.015869922935962677, 0.029439713805913925, 0.008848370984196663, -0.023130228742957115, 0.028546927496790886, -0.0315987803041935, -0.013307932764291763, -0.04310992360115051, -0.04084226116538048, 0.07956741750240326, 0.01562989503145218, -0.02071387693285942, 0.033706191927194595, -0.019711429253220558, 0.004646769259124994, -0.03217732161283493, -0.06945982575416565, 0.04623795673251152, 0.00958792120218277, -0.03387463837862015, 0.00935641210526228, 0.005112688522785902, -0.023463193327188492, -0.01108623668551445, 0.006659378297626972, 0.03570493683218956, -0.03591487929224968, 0.06160518527030945, 0.035988423973321915, 0.014699110761284828, 0.013608192093670368, 0.02607816830277443, 0.07813377678394318, 0.06669590622186661, 0.010461176745593548, -0.02944182977080345, 0.05802483484148979, 0.07985508441925049, -0.0022147754207253456, 0.04488154873251915, 0.009771741926670074, -0.021246375516057014, 0.01891494356095791, 0.016972582787275314, -0.023847360163927078, 0.029846852645277977, -0.07874632626771927, -0.08955417573451996, -0.008239558897912502, 0.035247914493083954, -0.04580829665064812, -0.0315232127904892, 0.01481386087834835, 0.040639329701662064, -0.03399510309100151, 0.004178025759756565, -0.0028625179547816515, 0.03946634754538536, 0.012805980630218983, 0.00006142624624771997, 0.013535172678530216, -0.041573815047740936, -0.020997589454054832, 0.0655495822429657, 0.0019299625419080257, -0.0008415457559749484, -0.0072115883231163025, -0.038827940821647644, -0.015220832079648972, -0.0035241441801190376, 0.016835428774356842, 0.022360119968652725, -0.016978446394205093, -0.006068952847272158, 0.06400247663259506, -0.02944169007241726, -0.048511482775211334, 0.011179274879395962, -0.050039250403642654, -0.018325693905353546, -0.003598344512283802, -0.008201268501579762, -0.044509436935186386, 0.00011052754416596144, -0.024144375696778297, 0.01777675747871399, -0.00026423283270560205, 0.042918942868709564, 0.05382420867681503, -0.007764148060232401, 0.030710237100720406, 0.00012280185183044523, -0.015990663319826126, 0.047004517167806625, -0.017525658011436462, -0.010441739112138748, -0.007378971204161644, -0.0339093916118145, -0.01284162700176239, -0.026490669697523117, 0.006944570224732161, 0.011836006306111813, -0.05955522879958153, 0.009475466795265675, 0.019088836386799812, 0.04971657693386078, 0.03540205582976341, 0.030523041263222694, 0.004700660705566406, -0.00427660346031189, 0.012804790399968624, 0.022448118776082993, -0.08027137815952301, 0.030018553137779236, 0.06666751205921173, -0.028573639690876007, 0.0010768338106572628, 0.013131934218108654, -0.01235050056129694, -0.02536584436893463, -0.008720866404473782, -0.02186179719865322, 0.011355717666447163, -0.017051709815859795, 0.021486246958374977, 0.012307163327932358, 0.006790367420762777, -0.013605215586721897, 0.06102685630321503, -0.03649699687957764, 0.03817261755466461, 0.06464552879333496, 0.023662123829126358, -0.059410516172647476, 0.030530977994203568, 0.030852876603603363, -0.010990248061716557, -0.0110420361161232, 0.029916662722826004, 0.06908789277076721, -0.02084055170416832, 0.07315666973590851, 0.03337490186095238, -0.03345416486263275, 0.0006943416083231568, 0.07060734182596207, 0.060079652816057205, -0.00984546821564436, -0.01636502332985401, -0.019154759123921394, -0.012964188121259212, -0.008554442785680294, -0.00005455908831208944, -0.020687125623226166, -0.043512433767318726, -0.012826208025217056, -0.11881345510482788, 0.0021299077197909355, -0.04214197024703026, -0.008306828327476978, -0.019995834678411484, -0.03961930423974991, -0.010630644857883453, -0.003897505346685648, 0.0007228945614770055, 0.03293972462415695, -0.015318046323955059, -0.0707814171910286, 0.02183566428720951, -0.05242190882563591, 0.04919673129916191, 0.008315511047840118, -0.03351515531539917, -0.01300264522433281, 0.020619921386241913, -0.06428486108779907, 0.015352051705121994, 0.06518920511007309, 0.010601665824651718, 0.03376690670847893, 0.05528426915407181, -0.05039080232381821, 0.017580604180693626, -0.008133474737405777, -0.027099531143903732, -0.0190606527030468, -0.05540664121508598, 0.08583320677280426, 0.004622367210686207, 0.0020619179122149944, -0.07338248193264008, 0.0007007484673522413, -0.03430720418691635, -0.08227872848510742, 0.024398675188422203, -0.031018344685435295, 0.05960628390312195, -0.02047516405582428, 0.003293234622105956, 0.06658492237329483, -0.006760673597455025, 0.0022896709851920605, 0.01657778210937977, 0.09119246155023575, -0.008217176422476768, -0.008095240220427513, 0.05072561278939247, -0.013682489283382893, 0.020188868045806885, 0.010452660731971264, 0.01329028606414795, 0.004841265734285116, -0.028466472402215004, -0.03407092019915581, 0.04177074134349823, -0.02716054953634739, 0.007295665796846151, 0.007603534497320652, 0.014496847987174988, 0.01447964645922184, -0.032999951392412186, 0.024886468425393105, -0.009912381879985332, 0.027200404554605484, 0.03423280268907547, 0.009665372781455517, -0.028001947328448296, 0.048870187252759933, 0.02671116217970848, -0.009159283712506294, -0.03515235334634781, -0.053314145654439926, -0.03853708505630493, -0.04410935938358307, -0.04079147428274155, -0.06995776295661926, 0.029290372505784035, 0.009650948457419872, 0.029329026117920876, -0.0022062885109335184, 0.029717708006501198, -0.00632388424128294, 0.006253810599446297, 0.04046311974525452, -0.042632345110177994, -0.057357143610715866, 0.04721902683377266, 0.07667745649814606, -0.017184458673000336, -0.021502137184143066, 0.02191011793911457, -0.031246371567249298, 0.04069669172167778, 0.027923408895730972, -0.06899020075798035, 0.021048536524176598, 0.01710466854274273 ]
<p>I came across a New Study at : <a href="http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1101/1101.2565v1.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1101/1101.2565v1.pdf</a> . Which talks about Time like quantum entanglement. What does that mean? </p> <p><strong>Comment added by L.Motl</strong>: The same preprint has been discussed in <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3357/what-is-time-teleportation">this question</a> and will be discussed in <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/6286/algorithm-definition-generalisation-time-entaglement-phenomennon">this question</a> in the future.</p>
g9786
[ 0.01861169934272766, 0.04705045372247696, -0.011480489745736122, -0.004165781196206808, 0.009643376804888248, -0.01041865162551403, -0.03957601636648178, 0.03263619542121887, 0.005046742036938667, 0.05263638123869896, -0.018502507358789444, -0.0006571808480657637, 0.02682403288781643, -0.0035431236028671265, -0.024746734648942947, -0.022639309987425804, 0.07133768498897552, 0.04405179247260094, 0.050156012177467346, 0.004682792350649834, 0.009106284938752651, 0.029379934072494507, -0.055166177451610565, -0.044049616903066635, 0.012814285233616829, -0.045052554458379745, 0.012618623673915863, -0.034823622554540634, -0.03542288765311241, -0.03802407905459404, 0.06707748770713806, -0.06895599514245987, 0.019519152119755745, -0.03796909749507904, -0.03711535781621933, -0.06679725646972656, -0.04131544008851051, -0.03725285828113556, 0.05633516237139702, 0.012163366191089153, 0.008317433297634125, 0.04528582841157913, -0.050008177757263184, -0.043287768959999084, 0.011784248054027557, -0.0018764450214803219, 0.00789976492524147, 0.021671965718269348, 0.015584466978907585, -0.03821505606174469, -0.040557850152254105, 0.00988068338483572, 0.02478896826505661, 0.025973787531256676, 0.050361812114715576, 0.009357349947094917, 0.044284287840127945, -0.020478228107094765, 0.06738238036632538, 0.009552227333188057, 0.04713106155395508, -0.017565399408340454, 0.01192418672144413, 0.01661239005625248, 0.0604979433119297, -0.034512393176555634, -0.06843205541372299, -0.005680387374013662, 0.038840897381305695, -0.011874821968376637, 0.032339807599782944, -0.02151929773390293, -0.0541805699467659, 0.024577874690294266, 0.12123601138591766, 0.057804420590400696, 0.07872500270605087, -0.008152354508638382, 0.03997145593166351, 0.0011011363239958882, -0.09551133960485458, -0.046037208288908005, -0.06409111618995667, 0.024226877838373184, 0.04556336626410484, -0.060014355927705765, -0.02706313505768776, 0.010152234695851803, 0.020199473947286606, 0.030087240040302277, 0.00915935542434454, -0.0340987928211689, 0.07426387071609497, 0.0031522128265351057, -0.06827428191900253, -0.01845712587237358, 0.02654258720576763, 0.022930605337023735, -0.0017683071782812476, -0.01020421925932169, -0.0396827757358551, 0.0010083268862217665, 0.030922066420316696, -0.03906533122062683, -0.029744843021035194, -0.005746131297200918, -0.05807586759328842, -0.09602006524801254, -0.05431436002254486, -0.022639378905296326, -0.005040622781962156, 0.0163052286952734, -0.04180453345179558, 0.025086646899580956, -0.05971795693039894, 0.00924938078969717, 0.01272179652005434, -0.02722759172320366, -0.02317015267908573, -0.012616385705769062, 0.03442462906241417, 0.004054059274494648, 0.014100699685513973, 0.0530729666352272, -0.014448043890297413, 0.04740534722805023, -0.007585638668388128, -0.06251020729541779, -0.01414088811725378, 0.012046268209815025, 0.03587033227086067, 0.037616536021232605, -0.013197527267038822, 0.0753762349486351, -0.025582455098628998, 0.04372415691614151, 0.025100871920585632, -0.018340742215514183, -0.019230464473366737, 0.021943068131804466, 0.008426249958574772, -0.04430104047060013, 0.029779568314552307, -0.023012688383460045, -0.016656745225191116, -0.02553715370595455, -0.04931844770908356, 0.014303678646683693, -0.01381746307015419, 0.0005588578060269356, 0.018052468076348305, 0.04271229729056358, 0.014409823343157768, -0.060846976935863495, 0.03042696788907051, 0.01219942420721054, -0.03624085709452629, 0.010183141566812992, -0.026611672714352608, 0.0714978352189064, 0.05370495840907097, 0.007004521321505308, -0.022797856479883194, 0.0049758851528167725, -0.0594685897231102, 0.016726983711123466, 0.03807694464921951, -0.02641022391617298, -0.015600473619997501, -0.05473129451274872, -0.037347640842199326, 0.014758718200027943, -0.04568618908524513, 0.01786196231842041, 0.025829318910837173, 0.002444805111736059, -0.00008726883243070915, -0.05038617551326752, -0.026810545474290848, -0.018940886482596397, -0.003321210853755474, -0.007008778862655163, -0.035308193415403366, -0.024442002177238464, -0.030477669090032578, 0.021796803921461105, -0.03244524821639061, -0.03425149619579315, -0.014887725003063679, -0.04236026853322983, -0.0286687221378088, -0.054535798728466034, -0.0026725877542048693, 0.026587335392832756, -0.020107142627239227, -0.0346393920481205, 0.014356059953570366, 0.03577112779021263, 0.008376219309866428, -0.04945763573050499, -0.0005977055989205837, 0.00821027159690857, 0.012812096625566483, 0.03346711024641991, 0.035543136298656464, 0.0367400124669075, -0.02165784314274788, -0.014177471399307251, 0.026338886469602585, -0.013508968986570835, 0.062008533626794815, -0.0015632030554115772, -0.01606445200741291, 0.041271865367889404, -0.03167261555790901, -0.02533045783638954, 0.03919311240315437, 0.008806442841887474, -0.007451874669641256, 0.026307187974452972, -0.0006672995514236391, -0.02373597025871277, 0.02238067053258419, -0.026191817596554756, -0.004219154827296734, -0.03363616764545441, -0.03279725834727287, -0.0754731297492981, -0.024646000936627388, 0.0068046944215893745, -0.03137702867388725, 0.05381064489483833, -0.07566199451684952, -0.03092220239341259, 0.07402092218399048, 0.06536562740802765, 0.008085718378424644, 0.05181846767663956, 0.036566466093063354, 0.03061932511627674, 0.051431767642498016, -0.004426638595759869, -0.027809932827949524, 0.003935596439987421, 0.005657508969306946, 0.009707148186862469, 0.06525588780641556, -0.09774960577487946, 0.0013715103268623352, -0.01844525709748268, 0.028654081746935844, -0.053515758365392685, -0.02161339670419693, 0.005721139721572399, -0.01141335628926754, -0.03498624265193939, 0.05483020469546318, 0.0179121270775795, -0.06423147767782211, -0.006113373674452305, 0.04260140284895897, 0.006582409143447876, -0.007849025540053844, -0.025093041360378265, -0.03151969239115715, -0.019131675362586975, -0.0050582000985741615, 0.03960004448890686, -0.0013557890197262168, -0.05050218105316162, -0.05874134227633476, 0.06911694258451462, 0.022732704877853394, 0.006851406767964363, -0.01214580424129963, -0.040105562657117844, -0.03151508793234825, -0.014984830282628536, 0.010226594284176826, -0.04585706815123558, -0.029357220977544785, -0.012075762264430523, -0.0411381721496582, 0.03105292096734047, 0.006302096880972385, -0.07967185229063034, 0.021628160029649734, 0.0005174080142751336, 0.005855259485542774, 0.04526486247777939, 0.05925624445080757, -0.014091409742832184, 0.0278166513890028, 0.006745441351085901, -0.017254488542675972, 0.01832141913473606, -0.004381293430924416, -0.023083914071321487, 0.025971107184886932, -0.0013434825232252479, -0.03055400960147381, -0.028713645413517952, 0.03302670642733574, 0.03447233885526657, 0.07313449680805206, -0.020304124802350998, -0.06625433266162872, -0.03158697113394737, -0.06023072078824043, -0.048847656697034836, -0.009017501026391983, 0.022927459329366684, -0.028844626620411873, -0.021462643519043922, 0.03437589108943939, 0.009605408646166325, -0.0449051670730114, 0.031859464943408966, 0.04394983872771263, -0.0018845885060727596, 0.008866788819432259, -0.02264110930263996, 0.010812647640705109, -0.024848001077771187, 0.06087358668446541, -0.002115205628797412, -0.035326436161994934, 0.000689884414896369, -0.03567514196038246, 0.005331614054739475, -0.005152150057256222, -0.08270952105522156, 0.03332913666963577, 0.0011217474238947034, -0.047209255397319794, -0.10634414106607437, -0.004284886177629232, 0.05128009617328644, -0.010455458424985409, -0.010497108101844788, 0.022981878370046616, -0.07180546224117279, 0.03941572457551956, 0.042226895689964294, 0.06398651748895645, 0.028578881174325943, -0.00688250083476305, 0.02861836738884449, 0.0509372353553772, 0.04956989362835884, 0.024779697880148888, 0.05582175403833389, -0.007763215806335211, -0.011427300982177258, -0.016115499660372734, 0.0432949960231781, -0.0231780968606472, 0.01872117631137371, 0.03423665463924408, -0.04335084185004234, -0.028404133394360542, 0.00693274661898613, 0.08019118756055832, 0.037681445479393005, 0.008113338612020016, -0.007283912505954504, 0.0032119136303663254, 0.03791207820177078, 0.03892332687973976, 0.03469289466738701, 0.01365781668573618, 0.0015844141598790884, -0.02682267501950264, 0.024400334805250168, 0.052615489810705185, 0.008568148128688335, 0.009609623812139034, -0.027586933225393295, 0.01620197854936123, 0.004143700934946537, 0.021024024114012718, 0.03736718371510506, 0.04718611761927605, -0.007599391043186188, 0.03906256705522537, 0.02521831914782524, -0.03465309366583824, -0.0052152457647025585, -0.05878818780183792, -0.0765436589717865, -0.012540451250970364, 0.060582149773836136, 0.011996150948107243, -0.05262775719165802, 0.003969793673604727, 0.014156137593090534, 0.03891589865088463, 0.01195688545703888, 0.030209138989448547, -0.034856487065553665, 0.03835088014602661, 0.01787174865603447, -0.031238753348588943, 0.030170176178216934, 0.04160739853978157, -0.04197468236088753, -0.002945360029116273, -0.056231480091810226, 0.006223611067980528, -0.050714537501335144, -0.005530565045773983, 0.03159066289663315, -0.006526975892484188, -0.02545630745589733, 0.00868722703307867, 0.024109242483973503, 0.06064620986580849, -0.047685425728559494, -0.033210303634405136, 0.007053862325847149, 0.035048339515924454, 0.09674790501594543, 0.05813493952155113, -0.007711930200457573, -0.036755673587322235, -0.014378266409039497, 0.029083654284477234, 0.007020873948931694, -0.036410968750715256, -0.05948230251669884, -0.001027218997478485, -0.0310510266572237, -0.015340051613748074, -0.026903944090008736, -0.05278846621513367, -0.006009948905557394, 0.016368551179766655, 0.0298715028911829, 0.06728316843509674, 0.031068572774529457, 0.07515013962984085, -0.0031850123777985573, 0.05130329355597496, 0.05955618619918823, 0.009702874347567558, 0.04069685563445091, -0.03701963648200035, -0.026217084378004074, -0.029417935758829117, -0.01454942673444748, -0.024952774867415428, 0.06273943930864334, 0.02841029316186905, -0.058686450123786926, -0.019708631560206413, 0.005219111684709787, 0.021456891670823097, 0.000756170367822051, 0.0014285219367593527, -0.010397213511168957, -0.08487343788146973, 0.06721165776252747, 0.011924312449991703, 0.0248104277998209, -0.012011250481009483, 0.004301701206713915, -0.023976314812898636, -0.02102540247142315, -0.04859355092048645, -0.006408805958926678, -0.030740270391106606, -0.03442024439573288, -0.01915648765861988, 0.0035653947852551937, 0.054292578250169754, -0.02566206082701683, 0.02220049314200878, -0.01695423573255539, 0.022099606692790985, -0.01340826228260994, -0.008362730033695698, -0.007279296405613422, 0.025305364280939102, 0.001240932964719832, 0.016021760180592537, 0.030958129093050957, 0.027378788217902184, 0.028834152966737747, 0.004061088431626558, -0.059043366461992264, 0.017291462048888206, -0.04710644483566284, 0.0007696162792854011, -0.01465961616486311, -0.019120927900075912, -0.03578687459230423, 0.00501231150701642, 0.012332380749285221, -0.021412691101431847, -0.024267544969916344, 0.0059411427937448025, 0.044718898832798004, 0.007400017697364092, -0.01085381768643856, 0.007465644273906946, -0.012231645174324512, 0.010512360371649265, -0.01711004041135311, -0.018032265827059746, 0.0035677405539900064, -0.022844906896352768, 0.03513645380735397, -0.06847508996725082, 0.014590226113796234, -0.004677331540733576, 0.00036447131424210966, -0.05333835259079933, -0.061508893966674805, -0.0004930171999149024, 0.011479338631033897, -0.04396064579486847, 0.04090018942952156, 0.021460548043251038, -0.04858243092894554, -0.015485633164644241, 0.012366514652967453, -0.04294914752244949, 0.007771712727844715, 0.05090278387069702, 0.07570405304431915, 0.032786253839731216, 0.044195037335157394, 0.06269845366477966, -0.028425171971321106, -0.02247113548219204, 0.03451244533061981, 0.0006141308113001287, 0.0034498809836804867, 0.027289094403386116, -0.01338094100356102, 0.02130027674138546, -0.0016429779352620244, -0.014425711706280708, 0.06961996853351593, 0.019597003236413002, -0.0506817027926445, -0.05013164505362511, -0.018054567277431488, 0.02938007563352585, -0.020305069163441658, 0.015943678095936775, -0.016213858500123024, 0.012394823133945465, -0.001981285633519292, 0.03313640505075455, 0.019024018198251724, 0.031494323164224625, -0.04278062656521797, -0.03994082286953926, 0.0495874248445034, -0.00749235600233078, 0.08074123412370682, 0.009517835453152657, 0.009300973266363144, 0.012824555858969688, -0.0337119922041893, -0.02313692681491375, 0.02680930308997631, 0.031648777425289154, 0.07384514808654785, 0.02069954387843609, 0.011744617484509945, 0.03938836604356766, 0.00816687848418951, -0.005641631316393614, -0.0382658950984478, -0.0013434652937576175, -0.08559529483318329, -0.0722782239317894, -0.03670136630535126, 0.0030707227997481823, -0.04499312862753868, 0.017290649935603142, -0.01103889662772417, -0.0034248773008584976, 0.01110917143523693, -0.02016068436205387, -0.007937860675156116, 0.07790069282054901, 0.007290273439139128, -0.036775942891836166, 0.041886020451784134, -0.01761636696755886, -0.09022314846515656, -0.026368997991085052, 0.06882630288600922, 0.028117410838603973, 0.043949563056230545, -0.03773902729153633, 0.028554636985063553, -0.05463067814707756, -0.013841762207448483, 0.023050770163536072, 0.0465262308716774, 0.03594956547021866, 0.10384199768304825, -0.005813258700072765, -0.00809876061975956, 0.013404380530118942, -0.006245343014597893, -0.0036255917511880398, -0.05680639296770096, 0.033719051629304886, -0.008655784651637077, -0.01339718047529459, -0.03810190036892891, -0.06615729629993439, 0.01457088254392147, 0.0030869673937559128, 0.05633344128727913, 0.0260634608566761, 0.008553196676075459, -0.02104051411151886, 0.025158816948533058, 0.0014409073628485203, 0.1065172404050827, -0.023438598960638046, 0.006901288405060768, -0.01799122430384159, 0.004054605029523373, -0.04007621109485626, -0.06804440170526505, -0.013531435281038284, 0.05694228410720825, -0.03842994570732117, 0.001124104019254446, -0.045602403581142426, 0.057561736553907394, 0.045144304633140564, 0.004820383619517088, -0.00515212956815958, 0.014170537702739239, 0.05436542257666588, -0.033821798861026764, -0.044346604496240616, 0.06319452822208405, 0.03781178966164589, -0.012498204596340656, -0.05285900831222534, -0.04190504178404808, 0.036497343331575394, -0.028099315240979195, -0.07096144556999207, 0.07404018938541412, -0.002713375259190798, -0.04595278948545456, -0.009538853541016579, -0.005238677375018597, 0.03870581090450287, -0.057023901492357254, -0.06650756299495697, -0.024190234020352364, -0.010588755831122398, 0.04976552724838257, -0.03000069595873356, 0.02815905027091503, 0.02417612262070179, -0.06400631368160248, 0.02171063981950283, -0.06986650079488754, -0.01702091097831726, 0.004849307704716921, 0.02930886670947075, -0.03461436554789543, -0.03953620791435242, -0.01910133846104145, -0.01933029294013977, 0.016320183873176575, -0.05221272259950638, 0.027090847492218018, 0.007385161239653826, 0.04427209123969078, 0.047783173620700836, -0.01651960238814354, 0.0019442200427874923, 0.05423573777079582, -0.03556567057967186, 0.004134703427553177, -0.08244051039218903, -0.04705240949988365, 0.023600155487656593, 0.0002892383199650794, -0.02366785518825054, -0.004376051016151905, 0.02866813726723194, 0.015112128108739853, 0.03643230348825455, 0.007224029861390591, 0.02020273543894291, 0.02522260509431362, -0.02793119288980961, 0.058913763612508774, 0.010605225339531898, 0.009694021195173264, -0.008745085448026657, -0.004603526555001736, -0.011271364986896515, 0.007637185975909233, -0.006330419331789017, 0.01681968942284584, -0.029885170981287956, -0.002295189304277301, 0.022166751325130463, 0.016672125086188316, -0.007637495640665293, -0.001105705974623561, -0.0017406619153916836, -0.018824871629476547, -0.00549296336248517, -0.008566981181502342, 0.031111570075154305, 0.01097587589174509, -0.03320682793855667, -0.03504984825849533, -0.057671502232551575, -0.008656704798340797, 0.026656271889805794, -0.01791306957602501, 0.0163028035312891, -0.03277699276804924, 0.027316806837916374, -0.06893064826726913, 0.018138118088245392, 0.06698108464479446, 0.027905985713005066, 0.0883529856801033, 0.030145615339279175, 0.017409125342965126, -0.024082768708467484, 0.03986326605081558, 0.04118000715970993, -0.002571508754044771, -0.027775773778557777, -0.006369256880134344, -0.017317188903689384, -0.04713490605354309, -0.04462484270334244, 0.03574954345822334, -0.005819419398903847, -0.07775194197893143, 0.014619650319218636, 0.030435731634497643, -0.01387809682637453, 0.06940905004739761, 0.027769897133111954, -0.02966683730483055, 0.028501568362116814, -0.023215696215629578, 0.06276987493038177, -0.008797293528914452, 0.009103583171963692, 0.01642354018986225, 0.010323164984583855, -0.0018397277453914285, -0.035002950578927994, 0.00552360201254487, -0.01067327056080103, -0.023180115967988968 ]
<p>Currently I am learning <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell%E2%80%93Boltzmann_distribution" rel="nofollow">Maxwell-Boltsmann distribution</a> (MBD) and in that I am learning about <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microstate_%28statistical_mechanics%29" rel="nofollow">microstate</a>, macrostate and thermodynamic probability (TDP). I understood the derivation of MBD but I am getting hard time (and also confusing) to visualise these terms (microstate, macrostate and TDP) with MBD. Can any one explain (possibly with pictures) what is microstate, macrostate and TDP and how it is used to derive MBD.</p>
g9787
[ 0.048151541501283646, 0.03574233874678612, -0.02679004892706871, -0.054064083844423294, -0.008219525218009949, 0.049149289727211, 0.05487380549311638, 0.030736388638615608, -0.014060202054679394, -0.03788456320762634, -0.015819991007447243, -0.02520345337688923, 0.09349148720502853, -0.008635224774479866, 0.011457636952400208, -0.023502375930547714, 0.02279200404882431, 0.05574503540992737, 0.040918055921792984, 0.025155026465654373, -0.046091631054878235, 0.04732890799641609, -0.05277733877301216, -0.07817195355892181, 0.01394735462963581, 0.015503858216106892, -0.022183313965797424, 0.01147309597581625, -0.03897134214639664, -0.023526307195425034, -0.0017583970911800861, 0.018721701577305794, 0.040753114968538284, -0.04389428719878197, -0.029667014256119728, 0.007221498992294073, 0.05859329178929329, 0.014575892128050327, -0.033412884920835495, 0.003945255186408758, 0.012220432981848717, -0.013562861829996109, 0.02081707864999771, -0.027602020651102066, -0.00025086276582442224, 0.04465928301215172, -0.04933043196797371, -0.054055213928222656, -0.020374268293380737, 0.016359856352210045, 0.07433655858039856, 0.0525590255856514, 0.10171429067850113, -0.00660950830206275, 0.055006708949804306, -0.007462035398930311, 0.05008085072040558, -0.04307852312922478, 0.0823436751961708, -0.01526995375752449, 0.06756654381752014, -0.01841285452246666, -0.06032584607601166, 0.0006749538006260991, 0.05756211653351784, -0.004635219927877188, -0.05836805701255798, 0.011815967038273811, 0.015671253204345703, -0.01671156845986843, -0.023239348083734512, -0.032609712332487106, -0.03311283513903618, -0.05918291211128235, -0.02255311980843544, -0.0007695005042478442, 0.01660536415874958, 0.0028177329804748297, 0.06671635806560516, 0.04448007047176361, -0.03586355224251747, 0.036908525973558426, 0.02785268798470497, -0.023425376042723656, 0.05872087553143501, 0.0010712494840845466, 0.00291117443703115, 0.01270902156829834, 0.011549215763807297, 0.007034757174551487, -0.02684558555483818, 0.06982673704624176, 0.0829409807920456, 0.06210888549685478, -0.06928456574678421, -0.009066798724234104, -0.10722202062606812, 0.06074591353535652, -0.008401722647249699, 0.034591034054756165, -0.014836857095360756, 0.006317394319921732, -0.004241831600666046, -0.017718898132443428, -0.029220839962363243, 0.02970924973487854, -0.00922433752566576, 0.0027312536258250475, -0.030930107459425926, 0.06344766169786453, -0.09265107661485672, -0.011282901279628277, -0.08221372216939926, 0.02058357000350952, -0.053998902440071106, -0.02212832309305668, -0.01703096367418766, 0.024315733462572098, -0.0230171550065279, 0.06293872743844986, 0.03111417032778263, -0.03896111249923706, 0.008288353681564331, 0.007441975176334381, -0.0017490142490714788, -0.0035519006196409464, -0.03013652376830578, 0.016553249210119247, -0.020159495994448662, -0.033276692032814026, 0.046100687235593796, 0.0015155135188251734, 0.007868781685829163, -0.024508748203516006, 0.010631891898810863, 0.0437714122235775, 0.015126659534871578, 0.02081996016204357, -0.05541369691491127, 0.020632870495319366, 0.03134313225746155, -0.030175166204571724, 0.005272533744573593, -0.022253720089793205, -0.0264469925314188, 0.006680473685264587, -0.015412063337862492, -0.02938462607562542, 0.06299717724323273, 0.013508079573512077, 0.025274615734815598, 0.030731014907360077, -0.0507083460688591, -0.04822767153382301, 0.011925221420824528, -0.0014201985904946923, -0.007858768105506897, -0.04606239125132561, -0.038400810211896896, 0.009398305788636208, -0.033822257071733475, -0.07291942834854126, 0.0214333925396204, 0.0024453862570226192, -0.01094114687293768, -0.02328106202185154, 0.04355742037296295, -0.03564344719052315, 0.018036048859357834, -0.051922403275966644, 0.007296434603631496, -0.034547362476587296, -0.0048331404104828835, 0.005214825738221407, -0.009965877048671246, 0.07751628011465073, -0.009523743763566017, -0.04160618409514427, 0.008899834007024765, -0.00038782673073001206, -0.009598094038665295, 0.021074028685688972, 0.08759981393814087, -0.03925109654664993, -0.02812190167605877, -0.04502753168344498, 0.015523124486207962, 0.04463985189795494, -0.02215227112174034, 0.023451250046491623, -0.0494333878159523, -0.060982462018728256, -0.017236296087503433, 0.0008294379222206771, 0.027943672612309456, -0.034611839801073074, 0.010532613843679428, -0.010109709575772285, 0.001647857134230435, 0.00907175149768591, 0.02176833711564541, -0.05271310359239578, -0.024606063961982727, 0.02749651111662388, 0.03463860601186752, 0.014193294569849968, 0.009599016048014164, 0.041527461260557175, -0.007733672857284546, 0.023300278931856155, -0.02014809660613537, -0.06377643346786499, 0.014301029033958912, 0.03785509988665581, -0.006992908660322428, -0.03323939070105553, 0.03381328284740448, -0.038971830159425735, 0.004426288418471813, -0.015379457734525204, -0.009793720208108425, -0.0525018684566021, 0.018392100930213928, -0.0023526716977357864, 0.03421512991189957, 0.06744489073753357, 0.0033692987635731697, 0.03754747658967972, -0.026366526260972023, 0.0557621531188488, -0.05418924614787102, 0.02065119706094265, -0.006212466862052679, 0.03896547481417656, 0.0259951651096344, 0.04667992517352104, -0.0006708442233502865, 0.03645759075880051, -0.07453799247741699, 0.05531700700521469, -0.015461147762835026, -0.045165710151195526, 0.019727949053049088, -0.017771972343325615, -0.023353174328804016, -0.04710398241877556, 0.07940348237752914, 0.016287848353385925, 0.07123780250549316, -0.01509563997387886, -0.008941253647208214, -0.04615972936153412, -0.005615690257400274, 0.0013718052068725228, 0.019413864240050316, -0.03932040184736252, -0.056178588420152664, -0.004945540800690651, -0.10252241790294647, 0.02812490239739418, 0.005267116706818342, 0.010423583909869194, 0.03041827492415905, 0.015431437641382217, -0.03314406797289848, -0.0796068087220192, -0.04459020122885704, -0.031046001240611076, 0.03160175308585167, -0.0064194765873253345, -0.0007893475121818483, 0.03596451133489609, 0.020686136558651924, 0.020894493907690048, 0.029354095458984375, -0.033792126923799515, 0.03144164755940437, -0.011709792539477348, 0.0012082862667739391, -0.04942670464515686, -0.04397261515259743, -0.03674173727631569, -0.006642431952059269, -0.027241991832852364, 0.022991247475147247, -0.029813632369041443, 0.07128003984689713, 0.012725599110126495, 0.003329080529510975, 0.0009768592426553369, -0.04699625074863434, 0.040272776037454605, 0.04746796190738678, -0.031593967229127884, -0.032656166702508926, 0.00749985221773386, 0.009867911227047443, -0.06981800496578217, 0.009262152947485447, -0.01280161552131176, -0.0030333383474498987, 0.0006115353899076581, 0.031390346586704254, -0.015634629875421524, 0.017616018652915955, 0.05321699380874634, -0.034361615777015686, -0.04991975054144859, 0.0027456479147076607, 0.0070037576369941235, -0.05118844658136368, 0.03212958574295044, -0.006803578231483698, -0.019453901797533035, -0.04759875684976578, 0.024209091439843178, 0.031239541247487068, 0.01647905446588993, 0.09784279763698578, 0.04463255777955055, 0.005650158505886793, -0.022332962602376938, 0.02404201030731201, -0.05374867469072342, 0.07119728624820709, 0.031884025782346725, -0.012914328835904598, 0.0033006626181304455, -0.033557306975126266, 0.00858648493885994, 0.03379577025771141, 0.005068604368716478, -0.014573674649000168, 0.00437585124745965, -0.06680884212255478, -0.0615793839097023, -0.05829412490129471, -0.016638638451695442, 0.04379287362098694, -0.04131990298628807, 0.007656745612621307, -0.004033207893371582, -0.07104359567165375, -0.008990786038339138, -0.023871764540672302, -0.015217850916087627, 0.03342036157846451, -0.03837331384420395, 0.051455553621053696, -0.051908940076828, 0.010680269449949265, 0.00945300329476595, 0.08377701789140701, -0.0012036070693284273, -0.03248823434114456, 0.050984058529138565, 0.034381765872240067, -0.05726194009184837, 0.06023293733596802, 0.052007872611284256, -0.05123790353536606, -0.05447400361299515, -0.028164131566882133, 0.026680365204811096, -0.002108330372720957, 0.028198931366205215, -0.007503190543502569, 0.08885715156793594, -0.016249151900410652, -0.11073729395866394, 0.021832825616002083, -0.03648464009165764, 0.006979748141020536, 0.03606543317437172, 0.02680867165327072, -0.027319705113768578, 0.004713841713964939, 0.05120973661541939, -0.0453583188354969, -0.028777290135622025, 0.019205596297979355, 0.007766306400299072, 0.05232403799891472, -0.0017647515051066875, 0.06242642551660538, -0.049232907593250275, -0.013061744160950184, -0.001302311196923256, 0.03347545117139816, -0.004969875793904066, 0.010737203992903233, -0.03648052364587784, -0.06128065288066864, -0.006490226369351149, 0.04891595616936684, 0.04097401350736618, 0.017826974391937256, 0.03377888724207878, 0.03265797346830368, 0.046961650252342224, -0.015677202492952347, 0.009649903513491154, 0.002077995566651225, 0.023392437025904655, -0.008743618614971638, 0.013759157620370388, -0.010086056776344776, -0.06098036840558052, 0.05980949476361275, -0.052624743431806564, 0.03846936300396919, -0.0353512242436409, 0.06050335615873337, -0.013076894916594028, 0.022330299019813538, -0.020835846662521362, 0.05164486542344093, 0.01573178917169571, -0.0014380302745848894, 0.0751921683549881, 0.0292351171374321, -0.030986877158284187, 0.008426491171121597, -0.048739492893218994, -0.015624560415744781, 0.022611236199736595, 0.06874775141477585, -0.03173031657934189, 0.024887003004550934, -0.0011771636782214046, 0.00624893419444561, -0.015313174575567245, -0.015064905397593975, -0.010437479242682457, 0.00831614900380373, -0.02008744888007641, -0.04314441233873367, 0.030474968254566193, -0.016648663207888603, -0.04571140184998512, 0.017936354503035545, -0.032370034605264664, -0.046320486813783646, -0.030439050868153572, -0.01586015522480011, 0.04965946823358536, 0.02749292552471161, -0.04593842104077339, -0.005538363009691238, -0.035173919051885605, -0.02777675911784172, 0.0258648581802845, -0.013686008751392365, -0.023961592465639114, 0.00881979614496231, -0.006697418633848429, 0.005665704607963562, 0.021318498998880386, 0.058173034340143204, 0.0195265244692564, -0.04503834992647171, 0.007144920062273741, -0.000059871548728551716, -0.012429049238562584, 0.00003124096110695973, -0.04018957540392876, 0.0006081315805204213, 0.04766564443707466, -0.04241744801402092, -0.02438133768737316, 0.012366113252937794, -0.0278058722615242, -0.03199519217014313, -0.045572444796562195, 0.07719957828521729, 0.005731318145990372, 0.017756616696715355, -0.0690450370311737, 0.01093677245080471, -0.027932224795222282, 0.00748600997030735, 0.029648998752236366, 0.03787395358085632, -0.012957972474396229, 0.045461878180503845, 0.06278785318136215, 0.03235501050949097, -0.016876501962542534, -0.001622450421564281, -0.0029862523078918457, 0.047580283135175705, 0.06671679019927979, 0.029955647885799408, 0.06300466507673264, -0.032891225069761276, 0.0071357195265591145, 0.02751275710761547, 0.01274878904223442, -0.035979729145765305, -0.03057008609175682, -0.06672712415456772, -0.01555236242711544, -0.026850257068872452, 0.025225285440683365, 0.004783790558576584, 0.017295222729444504, 0.03983233496546745, -0.024275926873087883, -0.0034813235979527235, 0.051754869520664215, 0.0033729563001543283, 0.010818195529282093, -0.015412823297083378, -0.03270304948091507, -0.020379260182380676, -0.04644331336021423, 0.003683675779029727, 0.0020023081451654434, 0.04026621952652931, -0.06293265521526337, 0.03367134928703308, 0.013057887554168701, 0.05172830820083618, -0.0032367545645684004, -0.05520811304450035, -0.0671548992395401, -0.026497622951865196, 0.004686450585722923, -0.005495560821145773, -0.04788262024521828, -0.02104496769607067, 0.06080813705921173, 0.07383695989847183, 0.006075603887438774, -0.01874566078186035, -0.026813406497240067, 0.009065218269824982, 0.0019704075530171394, 0.027193445712327957, 0.01618638075888157, 0.0031499858014285564, 0.006083767395466566, -0.0021842888090759516, -0.03540823981165886, -0.004528064746409655, -0.02111271396279335, 0.04793316870927811, -0.017858820036053658, 0.012068131007254124, -0.033484648913145065, 0.02127111330628395, 0.028204461559653282, 0.028600677847862244, -0.033698756247758865, 0.0253838412463665, 0.05333265662193298, -0.015536118298768997, -0.05168411135673523, -0.04662984237074852, -0.0038766555953770876, 0.015017588622868061, 0.026729878038167953, 0.04561854898929596, 0.02606256864964962, -0.023866664618253708, -0.052751388400793076, -0.022915510460734367, 0.04148978367447853, -0.026024330407381058, 0.0999593436717987, 0.05033523216843605, 0.018203917890787125, -0.023800764232873917, 0.04452572390437126, 0.020264778286218643, 0.029932774603366852, -0.0056897415779531, -0.008804907090961933, -0.03307001292705536, 0.036372020840644836, 0.014061030931770802, 0.029255447909235954, -0.03289050608873367, 0.010472857393324375, -0.05151341110467911, 0.027108851820230484, -0.037831760942935944, -0.017922237515449524, -0.02978064864873886, -0.0017582977889105678, -0.011287949979305267, 0.0019949572160840034, -0.052354298532009125, -0.024087214842438698, -0.01796640455722809, -0.007983176037669182, -0.01658443920314312, 0.020341703668236732, 0.004443423356860876, -0.000404530786909163, -0.03802480548620224, 0.009475314989686012, -0.059056248515844345, -0.02925867959856987, 0.01922924630343914, -0.0009521363535895944, -0.007838770747184753, 0.025057226419448853, 0.0032050006557255983, 0.028770800679922104, -0.017344126477837563, -0.007741392124444246, -0.013463961891829967, -0.03546142578125, 0.06714048236608505, -0.01923072710633278, -0.028758127242326736, 0.044005136936903, -0.00370645965449512, 0.01206302922219038, 0.02231013961136341, -0.026355663314461708, 0.08988624811172485, -0.00788184255361557, 0.016751253977417946, 0.045879047363996506, -0.03147619217634201, 0.028342721983790398, 0.036831215023994446, -0.003969679586589336, 0.02884340099990368, -0.031237494200468063, -0.007715513464063406, 0.0355425588786602, -0.004578238818794489, 0.08178460597991943, -0.06968019157648087, -0.010674222372472286, 0.07194884866476059, 0.025545911863446236, -0.014903982169926167, -0.014316176995635033, 0.03477955609560013, -0.011087054386734962, -0.005783432628959417, -0.006770976819097996, -0.0403456948697567, 0.03149023279547691, -0.03307098522782326, -0.026572125032544136, -0.03001786209642887, 0.0013927503023296595, -0.02284212037920952, 0.023878412321209908, 0.00531711895018816, 0.0634080246090889, 0.002437338698655367, 0.019919410347938538, 0.04245613142848015, -0.03854016959667206, -0.058385804295539856, -0.00499512255191803, -0.04900346323847771, -0.06526052951812744, 0.02630600519478321, 0.06614238023757935, 0.012070772238075733, -0.0033168646041303873, -0.00869673676788807, -0.05199297145009041, 0.008722053840756416, -0.04359397664666176, -0.024795815348625183, 0.04568222537636757, 0.010748188942670822, -0.01326338667422533, 0.028416287153959274, 0.0545496940612793, -0.010782944038510323, -0.015957601368427277, -0.005894724279642105, -0.0035142952110618353, -0.04178909584879875, -0.007711693178862333, 0.003789663314819336, 0.028364814817905426, -0.05604465305805206, -0.016745420172810555, 0.04258144274353981, 0.03018154948949814, -0.017719009891152382, -0.07637794315814972, -0.01570778712630272, 0.02273029275238514, -0.016230538487434387, 0.0033110661897808313, 0.07643395662307739, 0.03988025337457657, 0.05431995913386345, -0.025275399908423424, -0.0065298606641590595, 0.015103456564247608, -0.011720497161149979, 0.025680089369416237, 0.05504457652568817, 0.035410378128290176, -0.025147119536995888, -0.006326423492282629, -0.037798866629600525, -0.06721558421850204, -0.002889466704800725, -0.002345286775380373, 0.027550334110856056, 0.004320858046412468, -0.03747255355119705, -0.005001567304134369, -0.031856123358011246, -0.004040474072098732, -0.01800684817135334, 0.04362943395972252, -0.004661085084080696, -0.0315304733812809, 0.019947931170463562, -0.023073691874742508, -0.005264153704047203, -0.049862395972013474, -0.040423434227705, 0.03734327107667923, -0.025477975606918335, 0.013254590332508087, -0.08672980219125748, -0.012182248756289482, 0.03740431368350983, -0.009389073587954044, 0.003289014333859086, -0.00138220249209553, 0.049215879291296005, -0.02637161873281002, 0.06545805931091309, -0.02792939729988575, 0.05231982097029686, -0.05513102933764458, 0.05751202255487442, -0.0072771105915308, -0.020944280549883842, 0.006598039995878935, -0.031438540667295456, 0.03557329997420311, 0.035581231117248535, -0.030662165954709053, -0.02447674795985222, 0.009888549335300922, -0.04122019186615944, -0.020882869139313698, -0.007333762943744659, -0.017834074795246124, 0.07947160303592682, 0.029101230204105377, 0.039202362298965454, -0.005424863193184137, -0.016310986131429672, -0.0852246806025505, -0.00886718649417162, -0.050218790769577026, -0.03761804476380348, 0.014321137219667435, -0.03202800825238228, -0.021303940564393997 ]
<p>Are there any good theories on inverting the law of physics?</p> <p>To make physics work the opposite way of what it does.</p> <p>Please ask question if this is unclear! I'll answer as well as I can. </p> <p>Ok, I'll try to explain better. I was taking a smoke break and started thinking about time travel, and somehow I concluded that to travel in time itself is impossible. </p> <p>But then I thought that, what if we instead of travel in time, could reverse all processes in the world, or in an area for example. To make all particles do all what they have already done, but in reversed order. </p> <p>i.ex. A candlelight produces heat and light emitting from the flame, the candle itself melts and turns into vapor.</p> <p>If we reverse that, all the heat, vapor and light would be absorbed by its origin point and reassemble the candle the way it was. </p> <p>Damn this is hard to explain. And there are so many holes in what I'm thinking here. </p>
g9788
[ 0.008901183493435383, 0.012973291799426079, 0.00025125988759100437, -0.021360965445637703, 0.06810009479522705, 0.003840935882180929, -0.03681156039237976, 0.06999851763248444, -0.0015625538071617484, 0.009453954175114632, 0.03708735853433609, 0.0028292136266827583, 0.008648838847875595, -0.015208406373858452, -0.010517768561840057, -0.010753908194601536, 0.06515964865684509, 0.044674549251794815, 0.023756809532642365, 0.03731996938586235, 0.036894042044878006, -0.023508496582508087, -0.017140762880444527, -0.06664499640464783, -0.07134217023849487, -0.055268701165914536, -0.03198522329330444, -0.03120725229382515, -0.009956874884665012, -0.020253976806998253, 0.04726099595427513, -0.07905510812997818, -0.031435370445251465, -0.044419318437576294, -0.005824311636388302, -0.01640363410115242, 0.008145657368004322, 0.01802023872733116, 0.026375874876976013, 0.04191044345498085, -0.034128617495298386, -0.01112974900752306, 0.048365041613578796, 0.030733747407794, 0.06465573608875275, 0.01703830249607563, 0.031088417395949364, 0.049013905227184296, -0.02970038913190365, -0.03840990737080574, -0.0071085053496062756, 0.026258455589413643, 0.02877170778810978, 0.07951592653989792, 0.018531635403633118, -0.035468075424432755, 0.00400608079507947, -0.048443231731653214, 0.1216559112071991, -0.0028636043425649405, -0.07679729908704758, -0.019610634073615074, 0.0482536144554615, 0.06507230550050735, -0.003576597897335887, -0.043112579733133316, -0.039149295538663864, -0.013783094473183155, 0.0596550852060318, -0.0367860309779644, 0.06400511413812637, -0.02022218517959118, -0.04391446337103844, 0.009652244858443737, -0.023453908041119576, 0.043456193059682846, 0.031306829303503036, -0.006019111257046461, -0.0038110180757939816, -0.017405733466148376, -0.08385460078716278, -0.02473302371799946, -0.0049975598230957985, 0.02244466170668602, 0.03565620630979538, -0.07436208426952362, 0.02026265300810337, -0.009312600828707218, -0.044404104351997375, -0.03574696555733681, -0.024077145382761955, -0.02983080968260765, 0.1188901886343956, 0.021404853090643883, -0.017697308212518692, -0.022750629112124443, 0.027491332963109016, 0.04783806577324867, -0.03923197463154793, 0.014559480361640453, -0.029731890186667442, -0.06851841509342194, 0.03201830014586449, 0.018810084089636803, -0.014389279298484325, -0.025921467691659927, 0.05119597539305687, -0.010103704407811165, 0.0011061226250603795, 0.035254668444395065, -0.046333104372024536, -0.006068524904549122, -0.011282233521342278, -0.027698755264282227, -0.00037751984200440347, -0.03669733554124832, 0.05605747923254967, 0.02206777222454548, 0.013511360622942448, 0.05777081102132797, 0.020450282841920853, 0.008293183520436287, -0.030612444505095482, 0.028315147385001183, -0.02859676629304886, -0.022539760917425156, -0.04274200275540352, -0.018116671591997147, 0.038018450140953064, -0.025725623592734337, 0.008774013258516788, 0.014738109894096851, -0.0335526168346405, 0.08260461688041687, 0.007855032570660114, -0.021507462486624718, 0.011667869053781033, -0.0036965629551559687, 0.034214701503515244, -0.012607566080987453, 0.051927246153354645, 0.011565567925572395, 0.024508191272616386, 0.013516755774617195, -0.0564969927072525, 0.011063801124691963, -0.034609753638505936, 0.03400424122810364, -0.03611147403717041, -0.014769690111279488, 0.007749487180262804, 0.04912130907177925, 0.019571909680962563, 0.018975287675857544, 0.014306957833468914, -0.03834925591945648, 0.032449036836624146, 0.05827255919575691, -0.018996775150299072, -0.053704626858234406, 0.07543620467185974, -0.038411855697631836, -0.036720652133226395, -0.021449370309710503, -0.005622404627501965, 0.020622553303837776, -0.01634102314710617, -0.0015707203419879079, -0.008961239829659462, -0.04968922212719917, -0.10777827352285385, 0.022756995633244514, -0.037319496273994446, 0.06152445822954178, -0.00351719674654305, 0.0069757732562720776, -0.006708581931889057, -0.001580338808707893, -0.06468039751052856, -0.01438756100833416, 0.00704538356512785, -0.04232665151357651, -0.053906332701444626, -0.014072002843022346, 0.04087140038609505, 0.013585364446043968, -0.01032018568366766, 0.0679563581943512, -0.04522291570901871, -0.03635718673467636, 0.06926833838224411, 0.015182854607701302, -0.04584565386176109, 0.019515156745910645, 0.032429758459329605, -0.08011943846940994, 0.01011622603982687, 0.03242991492152214, 0.017857035622000694, 0.03863722085952759, 0.009775690734386444, 0.028618840500712395, 0.0623626783490181, 0.01668587140738964, -0.016638997942209244, -0.008373992517590523, -0.04852718114852905, -0.019575294107198715, 0.02893209457397461, 0.018266580998897552, 0.05759924650192261, 0.002005849266424775, 0.018590688705444336, -0.013044330291450024, -0.04270140454173088, 0.01193593256175518, -0.020864220336079597, -0.013869947753846645, -0.008839549496769905, -0.0010042417561635375, -0.02059844136238098, -0.001552649657242, -0.0037951802369207144, -0.007181748282164335, -0.010070058517158031, -0.019600575789809227, -0.030514821410179138, -0.069546639919281, 0.01132041122764349, -0.006019052118062973, -0.09699546545743942, 0.01860031485557556, -0.043294280767440796, -0.029388030990958214, 0.05800095945596695, -0.00332828052341938, 0.009375205263495445, -0.00895023811608553, 0.051653895527124405, -0.030767150223255157, -0.03709520772099495, 0.0025413651019334793, -0.016673021018505096, -0.023212404921650887, 0.004150239750742912, -0.06904470175504684, 0.01676846295595169, -0.028183698654174805, -0.01753472164273262, -0.006321258377283812, 0.06613783538341522, 0.017826413735747337, -0.05666511133313179, -0.050246499478816986, -0.017250780016183853, -0.011637956835329533, 0.013254649005830288, 0.08830363303422928, -0.01700774021446705, -0.02210919000208378, 0.004237466026097536, -0.0051438892260193825, -0.017611991614103317, 0.025133846327662468, -0.025772426277399063, -0.009819362312555313, -0.035205990076065063, -0.009958600625395775, -0.008421104401350021, 0.03175734728574753, -0.009493646211922169, 0.035710133612155914, 0.01471609529107809, -0.032712433487176895, 0.013135840184986591, 0.009349226951599121, 0.05758840963244438, -0.057614054530858994, 0.03574417904019356, 0.04735582321882248, 0.023496029898524284, 0.019824473187327385, -0.06792750954627991, 0.010318134911358356, 0.049625057727098465, -0.08765018731355667, -0.04525817930698395, -0.03067193552851677, -0.015593758784234524, 0.024493325501680374, 0.006551876198500395, -0.0016005199868232012, 0.04242826625704765, 0.031495533883571625, -0.021626237779855728, 0.0666399672627449, 0.03712291643023491, -0.08989164978265762, -0.05924448370933533, 0.023315902799367905, -0.01066022552549839, -0.04271576181054115, 0.006849543657153845, 0.037541866302490234, -0.007318306248635054, 0.023757921531796455, -0.04242594540119171, -0.011864399537444115, -0.005288184154778719, -0.023773066699504852, -0.014478137716650963, 0.04863682761788368, -0.07340027391910553, -0.005163612309843302, 0.02176191844046116, 0.0546574629843235, -0.043704256415367126, 0.002055511577054858, 0.0664929673075676, 0.003764358814805746, -0.035611625760793686, 0.0017315740697085857, 0.022446436807513237, -0.03807739540934563, 0.07741767913103104, 0.022476840764284134, -0.01598598249256611, -0.05759480968117714, -0.0628151223063469, -0.026293808594346046, -0.005656953435391188, 0.0029500776436179876, -0.022386467084288597, -0.022653728723526, -0.04145582392811775, -0.018919464200735092, -0.04608960449695587, -0.005428374279290438, 0.05435752123594284, 0.04195209592580795, -0.009870611131191254, -0.0604076012969017, -0.01664983294904232, -0.012524234130978584, 0.043074022978544235, 0.038992539048194885, -0.060172222554683685, 0.08367328345775604, 0.010911538265645504, 0.03605075925588608, 0.06852035969495773, -0.024145353585481644, 0.0076087480410933495, -0.029085492715239525, 0.04655315354466438, 0.047251392155885696, 0.08734997361898422, 0.07174421101808548, 0.022823702543973923, -0.01928720250725746, -0.04048052430152893, -0.011022035032510757, 0.021679457277059555, -0.023376459255814552, -0.014893338084220886, 0.04141801595687866, 0.019972676411271095, -0.024658633396029472, -0.005373355932533741, -0.017634723335504532, -0.007440896704792976, -0.013954687863588333, -0.05024970695376396, -0.026270095258951187, 0.044493868947029114, -0.0027890941128134727, 0.06338293105363846, 0.049760378897190094, -0.019173387438058853, 0.04474709555506706, 0.04346032068133354, -0.009874988347291946, 0.018074316903948784, -0.008046725764870644, 0.008191932924091816, 0.05208279564976692, -0.010507904924452305, 0.0011439758818596601, -0.017631186172366142, -0.02182452566921711, -0.024858376011252403, 0.04841548204421997, -0.005398053675889969, -0.04920745640993118, -0.0011024827836081386, 0.014730291441082954, -0.03981434553861618, -0.03639142960309982, -0.033074673265218735, -0.06181582808494568, 0.06547511368989944, 0.01121143251657486, 0.03812900930643082, 0.02034013532102108, -0.037414949387311935, 0.00026507783331908286, 0.06430820375680923, -0.11661071330308914, -0.022615112364292145, 0.010593901388347149, -0.015803858637809753, -0.01006196066737175, -0.02481350675225258, -0.055431559681892395, 0.0332304947078228, 0.01756775937974453, 0.014549870043992996, -0.015503665432333946, 0.06886504590511322, 0.009907267056405544, 0.09332249313592911, 0.061927687376737595, 0.025100618600845337, 0.006545223295688629, 0.020394574850797653, 0.06168075650930405, 0.028092896565794945, -0.0031264773570001125, -0.03593752905726433, -0.021224288269877434, -0.030733590945601463, -0.01032933034002781, -0.026826951652765274, -0.022345440462231636, -0.0045378804206848145, -0.009104679338634014, 0.01982382871210575, 0.03851289674639702, 0.042865823954343796, 0.019586438313126564, 0.006078870967030525, -0.020288076251745224, -0.0022123088128864765, 0.0021546785719692707, -0.0017079616663977504, 0.04627179354429245, -0.012390083633363247, 0.0010825922945514321, -0.026193631812930107, -0.023594118654727936, -0.04317200928926468, 0.03691144287586212, -0.04095036908984184, -0.012022944167256355, -0.037605904042720795, 0.02531818486750126, -0.016483627259731293, 0.07202134281396866, -0.04592737555503845, 0.05735898017883301, -0.1002994254231453, 0.0172614436596632, 0.01853111758828163, 0.03558993339538574, 0.007246814202517271, 0.04633385315537453, -0.03894583508372307, -0.026482628658413887, -0.04753653705120087, -0.001395692117512226, -0.028258468955755234, 0.030395632609725, -0.03915926069021225, 0.02231239341199398, 0.051249053329229355, -0.04917783662676811, 0.0034411936067044735, 0.016014616936445236, -0.04436712712049484, -0.06979334354400635, -0.037812791764736176, 0.007793942000716925, 0.035965822637081146, 0.007550701033324003, -0.0332203283905983, 0.032320376485586166, -0.07331621646881104, 0.026741454377770424, -0.0041190460324287415, -0.07428097724914551, -0.02965831197798252, 0.0045203254558146, 0.007343181874603033, -0.08236164599657059, -0.0004334289696998894, 0.021468130871653557, -0.021254252642393112, -0.0028246655128896236, -0.022863313555717468, -0.012022912502288818, -0.040638331323862076, -0.035008326172828674, -0.00965807307511568, -0.036836884915828705, 0.04530421644449234, -0.03374158963561058, 0.02031657285988331, 0.04884723201394081, -0.07677136361598969, 0.005980803165584803, 0.024938376620411873, 0.014926716685295105, -0.02755667082965374, 0.060483433306217194, 0.06525274366140366, -0.0036922197323292494, -0.043170016258955, -0.010839730501174927, 0.027394944801926613, -0.07349641621112823, -0.03575073927640915, 0.0013969333376735449, 0.04263239726424217, -0.014485139399766922, -0.02617700956761837, 0.07590645551681519, -0.04480226710438728, -0.01258368045091629, 0.044980209320783615, -0.032867953181266785, -0.013327939435839653, -0.022099150344729424, 0.07712561637163162, -0.029335441067814827, -0.06738000363111496, 0.009061481803655624, 0.005879322532564402, 0.033390626311302185, 0.026404298841953278, 0.05746087059378624, -0.0011651318054646254, -0.007670604158192873, 0.011345183476805687, 0.04613972082734108, -0.00655168853700161, 0.005300572607666254, -0.00038102795951999724, 0.02050522342324257, 0.020150668919086456, -0.005940626375377178, 0.003909399267286062, 0.044843483716249466, -0.002154628047719598, 0.017414750531315804, 0.023314928635954857, 0.03107902593910694, -0.0070897052064538, -0.003914122935384512, -0.013480127789080143, -0.008910040371119976, 0.027655210345983505, 0.05169073864817619, 0.03347616642713547, 0.013746615499258041, 0.03674282133579254, -0.026597268879413605, 0.024439502507448196, 0.005156586412340403, 0.023405812680721283, -0.005159072112292051, 0.012162772007286549, 0.017390238121151924, -0.01995183154940605, 0.005200790707021952, 0.012076633051037788, -0.05649761110544205, 0.00920689757913351, -0.08049747347831726, -0.016923971474170685, 0.028859753161668777, 0.0067536430433392525, 0.028586922213435173, 0.01858425699174404, -0.04799111187458038, -0.04328486695885658, -0.008412749506533146, -0.008449296467006207, 0.03544853627681732, 0.029308592900633812, -0.007822860963642597, -0.0032282937318086624, 0.007608036510646343, -0.02169807441532612, -0.022303184494376183, -0.00900467112660408, -0.017407847568392754, 0.004162058234214783, -0.06351237744092941, -0.007331788539886475, 0.05004075542092323, -0.052327632904052734, -0.0286796223372221, -0.012277794070541859, -0.029721766710281372, 0.039831049740314484, 0.049785029143095016, -0.07073302567005157, 0.04377230629324913, 0.033416472375392914, -0.02869372069835663, 0.05762995034456253, -0.015423880890011787, 0.018543479964137077, 0.020714309066534042, 0.0008289613761007786, 0.031232189387083054, -0.021473467350006104, 0.004595644306391478, 0.04503732547163963, 0.012712781317532063, -0.009768054820597172, -0.017530780285596848, -0.016974568367004395, 0.02086682990193367, 0.02742183767259121, 0.048896100372076035, -0.04028504714369774, 0.02962595410645008, 0.047469597309827805, 0.022098062559962273, 0.02054649032652378, -0.01111525483429432, 0.00557609461247921, 0.01801358349621296, 0.0033901259303092957, -0.00032459371141158044, 0.006988627836108208, 0.02395913191139698, -0.06240351125597954, 0.02016749605536461, -0.021220071241259575, -0.014283214695751667, -0.01470132265239954, 0.03934912756085396, -0.022960247471928596, 0.030245065689086914, 0.00037340610288083553, -0.06778687983751297, -0.04339955002069473, 0.002836178755387664, 0.0055955564603209496, -0.03491992503404617, -0.044852323830127716, 0.022327860817313194, -0.009254120290279388, -0.005117337219417095, 0.027611494064331055, 0.04691009968519211, -0.008228631690144539, -0.026217155158519745, -0.03891275078058243, -0.026263339444994926, 0.016866367310285568, 0.018960081040859222, 0.0013691746862605214, 0.04797089099884033, 0.019245419651269913, -0.047252316027879715, -0.010855830274522305, -0.003626089310273528, -0.0323648639023304, -0.03334455564618111, -0.027767611667513847, -0.006987455766648054, -0.0026502157561481, -0.01923285238444805, 0.027315326035022736, 0.06997068226337433, -0.00291221821680665, -0.00587565777823329, -0.033310115337371826, 0.057176705449819565, 0.0022378924768418074, -0.03397003188729286, 0.018001504242420197, 0.033224575221538544, -0.04281175136566162, 0.05637284368276596, -0.06239211931824684, -0.05649162828922272, -0.05970676243305206, 0.03555513173341751, -0.002175949513912201, 0.0026314128190279007, 0.062034592032432556, 0.056088678538799286, 0.09482705593109131, 0.012563244439661503, -0.04374267905950546, -0.02627268247306347, 0.0028237663209438324, 0.012313511222600937, 0.009226037189364433, -0.029704852029681206, -0.025034967809915543, -0.02760453335940838, -0.035636670887470245, 0.020672092214226723, -0.017737599089741707, 0.032815854996442795, -0.026914430782198906, 0.02353881299495697, 0.0030017257668077946, 0.08048716187477112, 0.07475540041923523, -0.0071808090433478355, -0.06683909893035889, -0.018840238451957703, 0.007276886608451605, 0.012146690860390663, -0.017316432669758797, 0.04546882212162018, -0.014902411960065365, -0.030865613371133804, -0.009014504961669445, 0.009541066363453865, 0.026532867923378944, -0.0002322408981854096, -0.005132755730301142, -0.03573499619960785, 0.06389602273702621, 0.03876068815588951, 0.00371782504953444, -0.010098792612552643, -0.0006066199275664985, 0.01462515164166689, 0.003061039140447974, -0.020253144204616547, -0.010253566317260265, -0.0343729704618454, 0.0043489509262144566, -0.022560356184840202, -0.04803884029388428, -0.02541482448577881, -0.02320711500942707, -0.07478313893079758, -0.01592169888317585, 0.02396329492330551, 0.007046851795166731, -0.027198828756809235, 0.03781221807003021, 0.034070562571287155, -0.0186636820435524, 0.023327482864260674, 0.02995290793478489, 0.013321745209395885, -0.0014142252039164305, 0.06592398136854172, 0.036254219710826874, -0.009910623542964458, 0.010281581431627274, -0.011747203767299652, 0.005881065037101507, 0.03268642723560333, -0.02543463744223118, 0.018600311130285263, -0.04260595515370369, 0.011272662319242954 ]
<p>I'm programing simulation software for solenoid and hemholtz coils, where I have to calculate <strong>B(x,y,z)</strong>. I have found dozens of variations of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biot%E2%80%93Savart_law" rel="nofollow">Biot-savart law</a> for determining B on axis. But how about <strong>outside of the solenoid</strong>?</p> <p>This is <a href="http://plasma.kulgun.net/sol_page/" rel="nofollow">said to be outside of solenoid</a>: $$ B(z) = \frac{\mu_0}{4\pi}\cdot\frac{iR^2}{2(R^2+z^2)^{\frac{3}{2}}} $$<br> But why only z coordinate? What about length of solenoid? In order to build simulation, I have to count with finite-length solenoid. </p> <p>There are hints, that I should apply line integral (curve integral?) to the biot-savart law. But what is that curve? The electric wire? So I have to use eliptic integral to have something close to the solenoid? I'm quite lost in all of this. </p>
g9789
[ 0.037549879401922226, 0.08152998238801956, -0.029003245756030083, -0.022760096937417984, 0.01372694130986929, -0.012592020444571972, 0.0034975979942828417, 0.03360089659690857, -0.02476082555949688, -0.014016646891832352, -0.045562125742435455, 0.005238669924438, 0.015300171449780464, 0.04348952695727348, 0.05112328752875328, -0.0021863572765141726, 0.0558624304831028, 0.015566054731607437, 0.06988395005464554, -0.058310367166996, -0.01338118314743042, 0.014989209361374378, -0.008753595873713493, 0.011454467661678791, 0.033374056220054626, 0.018746670335531235, 0.08346649259328842, 0.00033820566022768617, -0.019859986379742622, -0.09721610695123672, -0.028926892206072807, 0.005976844113320112, 0.06784824281930923, 0.0018611776176840067, -0.02914925292134285, -0.006682383827865124, -0.01612245664000511, 0.0348278246819973, 0.009369073435664177, -0.010698444209992886, -0.021045083180069923, -0.014967183582484722, 0.026759972795844078, -0.023669270798563957, 0.020835932344198227, -0.04118448868393898, -0.015462794341146946, 0.0035227201879024506, 0.0062652938067913055, -0.015827830880880356, 0.00448196567595005, -0.011225895024836063, 0.01436800416558981, -0.0460323728621006, 0.02174539677798748, 0.02616862766444683, -0.018409788608551025, 0.0011684676865115762, 0.007246748544275761, 0.03424040600657463, 0.018896261230111122, 0.004971059504896402, -0.01696735806763172, -0.010086688213050365, 0.018786314874887466, 0.0010006760712713003, -0.06625086814165115, -0.03667600825428963, -0.05008867383003235, 0.05804426595568657, -0.008018012158572674, -0.06354303658008575, 0.004604245536029339, 0.0002178424911107868, -0.06488538533449173, 0.019891738891601562, -0.0076677934266626835, 0.007455756422132254, -0.01961028017103672, 0.03099457174539566, -0.021831627935171127, 0.005906329490244389, -0.05095158517360687, 0.037206828594207764, -0.010483413003385067, 0.026393936946988106, 0.015037166886031628, 0.01849447563290596, 0.03322690352797508, 0.003845085622742772, -0.009276583790779114, 0.0598871186375618, -0.0012411867501214147, 0.008917504921555519, -0.016629459336400032, -0.02584506943821907, 0.0179962906986475, 0.06546147912740707, -0.0019344218308106065, -0.04299769550561905, -0.027915548533201218, 0.02544659748673439, -0.05756637081503868, 0.008093082346022129, -0.041416872292757034, 0.025501064956188202, 0.011279511265456676, 0.030243396759033203, -0.016428085044026375, -0.03795500844717026, -0.06945046037435532, -0.06625331193208694, -0.01838511787354946, -0.013310877606272697, -0.015590894967317581, 0.030192965641617775, 0.023989206179976463, -0.03607461601495743, -0.020129816606640816, 0.06025604531168938, -0.00593705615028739, -0.053155623376369476, 0.061365701258182526, 0.08496946841478348, -0.026940999552607536, 0.044556837528944016, 0.020039523020386696, 0.05788740888237953, 0.010706060566008091, 0.005994025617837906, 0.02986828051507473, -0.039498221129179, 0.027672765776515007, -0.0021921051666140556, 0.03077056258916855, 0.0011804854730144143, -0.0015937626594677567, 0.03701018542051315, -0.02497245743870735, 0.038133084774017334, 0.035383567214012146, -0.07834961265325546, 0.01101706363260746, -0.051323987543582916, -0.04034189134836197, 0.013643156737089157, 0.018347429111599922, -0.011749239638447762, -0.012874186038970947, -0.0350341722369194, -0.014934796839952469, 0.05255519226193428, 0.011260255239903927, 0.021065937355160713, -0.01499629020690918, -0.013316451571881771, 0.029579877853393555, 0.037869278341531754, 0.021547257900238037, -0.05523524060845375, -0.009468631818890572, -0.005530884489417076, 0.05275585502386093, -0.0038125705905258656, -0.05285479128360748, 0.014379192143678665, 0.019478611648082733, -0.012599593959748745, 0.016496947035193443, -0.08540940284729004, -0.07862398773431778, -0.035628654062747955, -0.01482569333165884, -0.02419067919254303, 0.02034425176680088, 0.04217933490872383, -0.0008536704699508846, 0.012886350974440575, 0.03480255603790283, 0.005890706088393927, -0.015838677063584328, 0.015942959114909172, 0.018218932673335075, 0.031091254204511642, -0.059542130678892136, 0.03880782797932625, -0.01491701789200306, -0.012964029796421528, -0.03977121412754059, 0.0006311815814115107, -0.046740420162677765, 0.014515059068799019, 0.004771669395267963, 0.06643815338611603, -0.08709872514009476, 0.0017450214363634586, -0.019480369985103607, -0.035139743238687515, -0.02472580410540104, -0.004288064315915108, -0.011463658884167671, 0.09360568225383759, 0.10371668636798859, 0.013213722966611385, -0.01666170544922352, -0.10117750614881516, -0.02552839368581772, -0.019875099882483482, 0.021623851731419563, -0.008974427357316017, 0.07270175963640213, 0.0323634147644043, -0.01920197159051895, 0.0054171583615243435, -0.024576345458626747, -0.06921469420194626, 0.006023026537150145, -0.020779820159077644, -0.024453656747937202, 0.009225590154528618, 0.04011809080839157, -0.04226960614323616, 0.041460536420345306, 0.030417826026678085, -0.0521559864282608, 0.006503193639218807, 0.040823981165885925, 0.011504613794386387, -0.016455935314297676, -0.02818300761282444, -0.07267281413078308, -0.03976650908589363, 0.011476147919893265, -0.05203726515173912, 0.014735035598278046, -0.016257790848612785, 0.03175792470574379, 0.018156521022319794, 0.027292052283883095, 0.04246072843670845, 0.04814332723617554, -0.07964232563972473, 0.022211357951164246, 0.01275855116546154, 0.03514917939901352, 0.016582440584897995, 0.04832610487937927, 0.00973146315664053, -0.04137437418103218, 0.03414885327219963, -0.02300778217613697, 0.039166927337646484, 0.014285650104284286, 0.06463131308555603, -0.027235358953475952, 0.05999620631337166, -0.022801309823989868, 0.028971416875720024, -0.021361099556088448, -0.05296924710273743, -0.027075253427028656, -0.029938388615846634, 0.03972844406962395, 0.012306123040616512, -0.01836736872792244, 0.037989918142557144, -0.055471163243055344, -0.033810555934906006, 0.02127424068748951, -0.01415084209293127, -0.05480825901031494, 0.08011655509471893, -0.017415156587958336, 0.010796932503581047, 0.04802992194890976, -0.015870139002799988, 0.04583161696791649, -0.015015876851975918, 0.034814536571502686, 0.02829730696976185, -0.00655958941206336, 0.011498529464006424, 0.002063953084871173, 0.03450421616435051, -0.020074831321835518, 0.014121092855930328, 0.040484797209501266, 0.02121243067085743, -0.009003649465739727, -0.006868119351565838, -0.011459744535386562, 0.004092860966920853, -0.019585423171520233, -0.011641724966466427, -0.020648404955863953, 0.024025999009609222, -0.05985912308096886, -0.008580649271607399, 0.04782801866531372, 0.004317310638725758, -0.01761465147137642, 0.023809295147657394, 0.018957234919071198, -0.022179914638400078, 0.004425436723977327, -0.04050612449645996, -0.04820914939045906, -0.1067083328962326, 0.039540983736515045, 0.011056462302803993, 0.03269851580262184, -0.0065964339300990105, 0.040703579783439636, -0.06768713146448135, 0.009357056580483913, 0.02392519637942314, -0.0038598799146711826, -0.0024882371071726084, 0.0631713941693306, 0.03621684014797211, -0.03144426643848419, -0.09912649542093277, 0.011036739684641361, 0.02909681387245655, 0.010716426186263561, -0.016287168487906456, 0.004120067693293095, -0.007639153394848108, -0.036805931478738785, -0.0005961013375781476, -0.01013983879238367, 0.0324346087872982, 0.0487445630133152, -0.034535884857177734, -0.01975790224969387, -0.021987203508615494, -0.020424941554665565, 0.03143908455967903, 0.023889504373073578, 0.01311461254954338, -0.08055007457733154, -0.08708213269710541, 0.014618719927966595, -0.049400996416807175, -0.0805143341422081, 0.014846911653876305, 0.03173678368330002, 0.02989957667887211, 0.05515233054757118, -0.0065549458377063274, 0.07758702337741852, 0.017809482291340828, 0.032799165695905685, -0.016840491443872452, 0.017466334626078606, 0.0008680367609485984, 0.018223879858851433, 0.03014013171195984, 0.01293470710515976, 0.009520946070551872, 0.04870830476284027, 0.006191316992044449, -0.02563534490764141, 0.010609284043312073, -0.021692855283617973, -0.01985975168645382, 0.0394241139292717, 0.08722054213285446, 0.004341355990618467, -0.024812588468194008, 0.00908381212502718, -0.021433210000395775, 0.03217732906341553, -0.0054467772133648396, 0.014432841911911964, -0.039101943373680115, -0.00964298751205206, 0.04771845415234566, 0.009383821859955788, 0.023605968803167343, 0.04394996911287308, 0.017587481066584587, 0.05071432888507843, -0.019002387300133705, 0.021482257172465324, 0.02347528375685215, 0.04304911196231842, 0.002408125437796116, 0.005988622549921274, -0.061182815581560135, 0.01291462779045105, -0.06697073578834534, -0.022639265283942223, -0.07068821042776108, 0.0015989345265552402, -0.032577548176050186, 0.059083886444568634, -0.017568210139870644, -0.04109592363238335, 0.04727853089570999, 0.009020267054438591, -0.015267341397702694, 0.00260135717689991, 0.010340815410017967, -0.03383893519639969, -0.00920290406793356, 0.010952829383313656, -0.04142286255955696, 0.044645871967077255, -0.018994031473994255, 0.00424632104113698, -0.0041525699198246, 0.06544888019561768, -0.08982819318771362, 0.06215742975473404, -0.05176825448870659, 0.017354384064674377, 0.002091439673677087, -0.037331219762563705, -0.010537082329392433, 0.013709144666790962, -0.024262702092528343, -0.006740454584360123, -0.08625337481498718, -0.06803634762763977, -0.017887769266963005, -0.002425036858767271, 0.011051506735384464, 0.04122127592563629, -0.02676524966955185, -0.008796175010502338, 0.048688460141420364, -0.022240901365876198, 0.012753658927977085, -0.06882874667644501, 0.0161871500313282, -0.03784843534231186, 0.03334619849920273, -0.022210273891687393, 0.1098242923617363, -0.014887179248034954, -0.016853300854563713, 0.024891743436455727, 0.004029805772006512, 0.008485035039484501, 0.05321130156517029, -0.08251819014549255, -0.041456546634435654, -0.05760166794061661, -0.02933729812502861, -0.005829785019159317, 0.06281749159097672, 0.007857147604227066, 0.057170335203409195, -0.009281252510845661, 0.01299916859716177, -0.008360043168067932, 0.01784721203148365, 0.054494354873895645, 0.00996825285255909, -0.07395715266466141, 0.020782731473445892, -0.022353066131472588, -0.004770582541823387, 0.051519766449928284, -0.002766098128631711, -0.03665025904774666, -0.01787295937538147, -0.012763286009430885, 0.042641256004571915, -0.020224757492542267, 0.020186783745884895, 0.041114505380392075, -0.05453019216656685, -0.002439409727230668, -0.03713008388876915, 0.025421954691410065, 0.033201172947883606, -0.04646401107311249, -0.03393890708684921, -0.037337787449359894, 0.02219361998140812, -0.0599324107170105, 0.04773469641804695, -0.029375921934843063, -0.007043242454528809, -0.052919939160346985, -0.013396764174103737, -0.02783893048763275, -0.0011274104472249746, -0.03467308357357979, 0.004720574710518122, 0.03326199948787689, 0.007832859642803669, -0.004165270831435919, -0.03188519924879074, 0.04303247109055519, -0.055014725774526596, -0.028969984501600266, 0.004093983210623264, -0.11498814076185226, -0.005917515605688095, 0.004262123256921768, -0.04746272414922714, -0.05566573143005371, 0.0567871630191803, 0.07529470324516296, -0.04134439304471016, -0.02710079215466976, 0.033764392137527466, 0.02039288356900215, 0.02284558117389679, 0.0329514779150486, -0.019019199535250664, -0.016862792894244194, 0.04499971494078636, -0.02474065124988556, 0.019656917080283165, -0.026638420298695564, -0.047721829265356064, 0.049642860889434814, -0.019542094320058823, 0.0002807347336784005, -0.023676849901676178, -0.0000016683655985616497, -0.07020439207553864, -0.02843104675412178, -0.09096658229827881, -0.04385404661297798, 0.016607725992798805, -0.05392099916934967, -0.006650759372860193, -0.03155302628874779, 0.051192671060562134, -0.005037546623498201, 0.013569538481533527, 0.0029707869980484247, -0.03270264342427254, -0.020865047350525856, -0.025010833516716957, 0.06083860620856285, 0.031375836580991745, -0.021438926458358765, 0.06397289037704468, -0.04978162422776222, -0.03556408733129501, -0.00022052782878745347, -0.028691867366433144, 0.052213154733181, -0.0363696925342083, -0.05957487225532532, 0.05578196048736572, 0.0030403758864849806, -0.00857752189040184, -0.004082617815583944, 0.03292899951338768, 0.018725767731666565, -0.012749110348522663, 0.030154990032315254, 0.020952874794602394, 0.032995469868183136, -0.031087085604667664, -0.039290882647037506, 0.038569655269384384, -0.05964146926999092, -0.03907502442598343, 0.01607304997742176, 0.05921905115246773, 0.05617673322558403, 0.061345137655735016, 0.05548639968037605, -0.038700416684150696, -0.04602386802434921, 0.014211566187441349, 0.03557971119880676, 0.050987064838409424, -0.021964000537991524, -0.005782075226306915, -0.02038058452308178, 0.005074739456176758, -0.035448264330625534, 0.08668334782123566, -0.003100764472037554, -0.04515890032052994, 0.011807115748524666, 0.003239478450268507, -0.03489914909005165, -0.025501957163214684, 0.012874179519712925, 0.053465548902750015, 0.0300076175481081, 0.019300229847431183, -0.002844217699021101, -0.0610123910009861, -0.03520666062831879, -0.024318497627973557, 0.029092319309711456, 0.00989613775163889, 0.007867898792028427, 0.0266000647097826, 0.009813062846660614, 0.02422732673585415, 0.014737262390553951, -0.02849687822163105, 0.034260474145412445, -0.006412907503545284, -0.014209325425326824, 0.009573845192790031, -0.008504847064614296, 0.010179003700613976, 0.07113132625818253, 0.013478213921189308, -0.061416711658239365, 0.012047703377902508, 0.026263568550348282, -0.03805960714817047, -0.008875198662281036, -0.00766352191567421, -0.018856940791010857, 0.00156282854732126, 0.030659254640340805, 0.03421472758054733, -0.016873998567461967, 0.055969949811697006, 0.05002140626311302, -0.03428094834089279, -0.011576795019209385, 0.007817045785486698, 0.054890237748622894, -0.036520544439554214, 0.044142946600914, 0.030333181843161583, -0.06554821878671646, 0.05145249143242836, -0.005535626318305731, 0.05525252968072891, -0.00578056275844574, 0.006597496569156647, 0.015730639919638634, 0.06901663541793823, -0.03339877724647522, 0.022972583770751953, 0.07497351616621017, 0.021557986736297607, -0.04514457657933235, -0.03997986018657684, 0.04278308525681496, -0.014555037021636963, -0.03316492214798927, 0.01649695821106434, 0.049917902797460556, 0.00042109517380595207, -0.0446227490901947, 0.02206513285636902, -0.020119119435548782, 0.018867388367652893, 0.007857794873416424, -0.0007262848666869104, 0.03921838849782944, -0.01019969116896391, -0.04473191499710083, -0.017113523557782173, 0.006387326400727034, -0.01564895175397396, 0.06875934451818466, 0.07739683240652084, 0.023958846926689148, -0.009757071733474731, 0.03716535493731499, -0.01764335110783577, 0.0017640759469941258, -0.01906893402338028, -0.04812239482998848, -0.035879217088222504, 0.00780510576441884, -0.01609894074499607, 0.026462197303771973, 0.02664966881275177, -0.04372291639447212, -0.0021759402006864548, 0.009356323629617691, 0.019427265971899033, -0.023139886558055878, -0.049790557473897934, 0.005246987100690603, 0.019965507090091705, -0.04182134568691254, 0.03405488654971123, 0.014674861915409565, 0.032288599759340286, -0.01336025632917881, 0.004510379396378994, -0.012117497622966766, -0.018623262643814087, -0.021496403962373734, -0.0008245321805588901, -0.011668042279779911, 0.03156191483139992, 0.06035855785012245, 0.02189885824918747, 0.07805811613798141, -0.06859122961759567, 0.0008483189158141613, 0.039636384695768356, 0.051443591713905334, 0.016425861045718193, -0.037175122648477554, -0.013271466828882694, -0.019115429371595383, -0.009152472019195557, -0.032772209495306015, 0.032285407185554504, 0.0038775077555328608, 0.03480292856693268, 0.03211108222603798, 0.03166680037975311, -0.01173963863402605, -0.04187597706913948, 0.024401776492595673, -0.034202490001916885, -0.03936908394098282, -0.01594395749270916, 0.0017592892982065678, 0.0028285053558647633, 0.025420039892196655, -0.020619841292500496, -0.021649837493896484, 0.03905894607305527, -0.013354053720831871, 0.007751832250505686, -0.06429002434015274, -0.046928975731134415, -0.016459239646792412, 0.034324612468481064, -0.05896231159567833, -0.03985019400715828, 0.014870606362819672, -0.007874445989727974, -0.009729934856295586, -0.011177455075085163, 0.044351641088724136, -0.0920613557100296, -0.0015961561584845185, -0.038398537784814835, 0.00756924320012331, 0.031920868903398514, -0.04202274605631828, 0.021492112427949905, 0.04555550590157509, 0.010812069289386272, 0.03387211635708809, 0.008309395983815193, -0.002250759629532695, -0.0023433149326592684, 0.0010290772188454866, -0.045009076595306396, -0.03869912773370743, -0.025515539571642876, 0.06807505339384079, 0.04167725890874863, 0.007718604989349842, 0.0026653686072677374, 0.02576901949942112, 0.04865390434861183, -0.031482961028814316, -0.032190434634685516, 0.0028323307633399963, 0.018110113218426704 ]
<p>I would like to know what is the energy needed <strong>considering the air resistance</strong> to shoot from ground to the orbit a 100g object (even if it vaporizes in the process). </p> <p><strong>Variables to make approx calculations:</strong> Lets assume it has a <strong>pointy bullet shape</strong> (best know shape) with <strong>5cm diameter x 10cm length</strong> and the orbit is the lower possible, lets assume the <strong>ISS orbit 150km above ground</strong>, <strong>we are at equator latitude</strong> shooting to the <strong>east</strong> (<strong>Earth spining thrust, 1500km/h</strong>)</p> <p>The first thing that crossed my mind was the russian meteor entry and its tremendous bright and shock wave (dissipated energy)</p> <p>According to a news on <a href="http://physicsworld.com/cws/article/news/2013/aug/20/us-firm-seeks-funding-for-novel-slingatron-prototype" rel="nofollow">physicsworld.com</a></p>
g9790
[ -0.012690920382738113, 0.08053547143936157, -0.014100226573646069, -0.002442166907712817, -0.02923153154551983, 0.005416187923401594, -0.034116361290216446, -0.0024770465679466724, -0.008408253081142902, -0.0039642564952373505, -0.021415797993540764, 0.07063236087560654, 0.03442372381687164, -0.024545200169086456, 0.003315507434308529, 0.0017550939228385687, 0.09597651660442352, -0.08138713985681534, 0.016614513471722603, 0.06286965310573578, 0.023289518430829048, -0.10585737973451614, -0.01713695377111435, -0.07151896506547928, -0.003616171656176448, 0.039008744060993195, 0.0396115705370903, -0.01738719828426838, -0.06129755079746246, 0.011279224418103695, 0.02639300934970379, -0.030671732500195503, 0.005530206020921469, -0.053731974214315414, -0.08497840166091919, -0.006231526378542185, 0.010142745450139046, 0.022458776831626892, -0.01837633177638054, -0.02448211796581745, -0.030515534803271294, -0.07941091060638428, -0.012915690429508686, 0.033395349979400635, 0.03152987360954285, 0.011703106574714184, 0.0402916744351387, -0.01804858259856701, 0.007048549130558968, -0.004887823481112719, -0.03048848919570446, 0.029732108116149902, -0.045267537236213684, -0.0541316419839859, -0.04363368824124336, 0.04129178449511528, -0.0189182311296463, 0.024587338790297508, 0.03513717278838158, -0.05618598312139511, -0.01147850975394249, -0.02161894179880619, -0.049604132771492004, -0.043475400656461716, 0.06727395951747894, -0.003330435836687684, -0.07368441671133041, -0.011718505062162876, 0.0356224849820137, 0.02777094393968582, 0.05861709266901016, 0.009505528025329113, -0.07767193019390106, 0.03229072690010071, -0.02861785888671875, -0.029604556038975716, -0.07831079512834549, 0.035847507417201996, 0.008931493386626244, -0.006543253548443317, 0.00917595811188221, 0.032367777079343796, -0.019270725548267365, -0.05487756058573723, 0.07486653327941895, -0.025908319279551506, -0.041191428899765015, 0.012021418660879135, 0.02048129215836525, 0.005942479707300663, 0.029443791136145592, 0.05152064561843872, 0.05503125116229057, -0.0022759840358048677, 0.02609628066420555, 0.018935594707727432, -0.012106699869036674, 0.04006913676857948, -0.03071640245616436, 0.03805680200457573, -0.014381444081664085, -0.06927269697189331, -0.052878957241773605, -0.017642205581068993, 0.016966741532087326, -0.025337960571050644, 0.03850617632269859, 0.0016519884811714292, 0.04859059676527977, -0.01986517570912838, 0.015098413452506065, -0.012557515874505043, -0.033707305788993835, -0.026627110317349434, -0.030316611751914024, -0.011885583400726318, 0.05309278517961502, -0.028055470436811447, -0.012097546830773354, 0.049389034509658813, 0.01709637977182865, 0.013730141334235668, 0.00566869368776679, 0.07858739793300629, -0.025040680542588234, -0.06203191354870796, 0.05584706366062164, -0.04805484786629677, -0.0028442218899726868, -0.0446922592818737, 0.0018983094487339258, -0.022903479635715485, 0.018800675868988037, -0.015422268770635128, 0.03231837600469589, 0.01065312884747982, -0.04072984308004379, -0.006392521318048239, -0.016019251197576523, -0.006271929480135441, 0.05260084196925163, -0.009807023219764233, 0.03976823389530182, 0.062107522040605545, -0.03153177350759506, 0.05083861202001572, -0.028744492679834366, 0.03594067320227623, -0.005158621352165937, 0.015189651399850845, 0.0388001911342144, 0.049766190350055695, 0.01697477698326111, -0.07490513473749161, 0.011106190271675587, -0.03271941468119621, 0.0022828569635748863, -0.016009368002414703, 0.01513171847909689, -0.0024732553865760565, 0.04652424901723862, 0.003470383817330003, 0.005520388949662447, -0.010393531993031502, -0.04969010874629021, 0.011857879348099232, 0.002301163272932172, -0.010532214306294918, 0.003991506062448025, -0.06356137245893478, -0.03984956070780754, -0.00005105890886625275, 0.038192473351955414, 0.06243521347641945, -0.03277761861681938, 0.01553306169807911, 0.06341515481472015, 0.020359154790639877, -0.01005612127482891, -0.0018932835664600134, 0.09108927845954895, -0.01561802625656128, 0.00953545793890953, 0.0074124084785580635, -0.010999790392816067, -0.007418592926114798, 0.03415622189640999, -0.00518444087356329, 0.011237717233598232, 0.028395958244800568, 0.010885313153266907, -0.014535931870341301, 0.025145547464489937, 0.013084204867482185, 0.0035206209868192673, -0.013445471413433552, 0.0847635492682457, -0.008244420401751995, -0.066970095038414, 0.0022372545208781958, 0.019369859248399734, 0.03565618768334389, -0.0063333637081086636, 0.004766244441270828, 0.06838322430849075, 0.016739865764975548, 0.010780664160847664, 0.019032597541809082, -0.022621668875217438, -0.005660173483192921, 0.0236918106675148, -0.038817912340164185, 0.006186190061271191, 0.030369127169251442, 0.0816400945186615, 0.03159673139452934, -0.0332937091588974, 0.023859910666942596, -0.03930102288722992, -0.009833005256950855, 0.018474319949746132, 0.03302096202969551, 0.03414323553442955, -0.008803260512650013, -0.049510128796100616, 0.012956097722053528, 0.004584057722240686, -0.025335704907774925, 0.04936743900179863, 0.026094384491443634, -0.023325834423303604, 0.02010730281472206, -0.027900908142328262, -0.0571749247610569, 0.055562034249305725, 0.005692013539373875, 0.034949809312820435, -0.0017625924665480852, 0.02177794650197029, -0.006103805731981993, 0.01605100743472576, -0.04776226356625557, 0.015048454515635967, -0.0022405588533729315, 0.06298234313726425, -0.0628242939710617, 0.010636821389198303, 0.02840765193104744, -0.03364100679755211, -0.01664598658680916, -0.030358457937836647, -0.051246318966150284, -0.08663831651210785, 0.04721234366297722, -0.0544731430709362, 0.02405439503490925, -0.017192330211400986, -0.014621877111494541, -0.06943964958190918, -0.0002582698070909828, -0.008485905826091766, -0.049898043274879456, -0.018140386790037155, 0.000020854153262916952, -0.03589024022221565, 0.04765472561120987, -0.022320743650197983, -0.0652487501502037, -0.0010731812799349427, -0.037258580327034, 0.033679548650979996, 0.060501422733068466, 0.0068919057957828045, 0.022069575265049934, 0.02341785654425621, -0.01698983833193779, 0.034254200756549835, 0.004582720808684826, 0.001513808500021696, -0.005938148126006126, -0.02332310751080513, -0.04466390982270241, -0.015280714258551598, 0.06606941670179367, 0.008966159075498581, -0.05956295132637024, -0.03288533166050911, 0.09129691869020462, -0.005611384753137827, -0.07509814947843552, -0.04942338541150093, 0.008359048515558243, -0.00863862968981266, -0.007797671016305685, -0.017055528238415718, 0.014639434404671192, 0.047412898391485214, 0.02256046235561371, 0.03474244847893715, -0.00889580324292183, -0.004828006960451603, -0.007309326436370611, -0.005329124629497528, -0.00036364185507409275, -0.009237469173967838, 0.013308093883097172, 0.011593326926231384, -0.054791636765003204, -0.0064926957711577415, -0.011628868989646435, -0.02459821291267872, 0.056912824511528015, 0.028739001601934433, 0.012375147081911564, -0.06744162738323212, -0.03329665586352348, -0.0006227742414921522, 0.02753501571714878, 0.010955680161714554, 0.030462296679615974, -0.0022631091997027397, -0.09475260972976685, 0.004216314293444157, 0.006092648021876812, -0.01948866993188858, 0.08219616115093231, -0.0446285717189312, -0.006282534450292587, -0.004049641080200672, 0.007283751852810383, -0.045234762132167816, 0.07201359421014786, -0.028758855536580086, -0.008978030644357204, 0.016331788152456284, 0.025490641593933105, 0.03401845693588257, 0.03624574840068817, 0.04030410572886467, 0.07789522409439087, -0.04544048756361008, -0.014837346971035004, -0.01599705219268799, 0.010100318118929863, 0.026884114369750023, 0.0009403679869137704, 0.010817503556609154, -0.010087117552757263, -0.027988629415631294, -0.07473175972700119, 0.04831764101982117, -0.03530193865299225, -0.02332533337175846, -0.04850826412439346, -0.018802011385560036, 0.026080027222633362, 0.0004019611806143075, 0.03909822180867195, 0.05364253371953964, 0.015077396295964718, 0.008361867628991604, 0.0074402508325874805, 0.04562967270612717, -0.0008585526375100017, -0.00022239636746235192, -0.0022397800348699093, -0.059731002897024155, -0.046608589589595795, -0.028743837028741837, -0.05052870139479637, -0.029294371604919434, -0.03110477328300476, -0.06292643398046494, -0.003303930163383484, 0.05361828953027725, 0.03430652245879173, 0.0264070276170969, 0.02639872580766678, -0.046915117651224136, 0.026788197457790375, 0.03391910716891289, -0.0009785157162696123, 0.00769398408010602, 0.03054645098745823, 0.025816021487116814, 0.015260615386068821, 0.0020383584778755903, -0.016520759090781212, 0.0022457048762589693, -0.04087486118078232, -0.023185675963759422, -0.08719722926616669, 0.0007007241365499794, -0.03210977464914322, 0.003532990114763379, 0.015266768634319305, 0.026335779577493668, -0.010959516279399395, -0.002992209978401661, 0.04604722931981087, 0.07636916637420654, -0.0005039601237513125, 0.0036368882283568382, -0.04601849615573883, -0.003798987250775099, 0.016525287181138992, 0.012409405782818794, -0.00868770107626915, -0.05072522163391113, -0.019110973924398422, 0.07890460640192032, 0.014605574309825897, -0.01941545307636261, -0.06520561128854752, 0.015698958188295364, -0.02422967553138733, -0.009162715636193752, -0.0013164568226784468, -0.012196711264550686, -0.0582030713558197, -0.03756377473473549, 0.04653743654489517, -0.0030479468405246735, -0.039263200014829636, 0.03836817666888237, 0.023614654317498207, -0.0018672264413908124, 0.0025463050696998835, 0.027429375797510147, 0.018443170934915543, 0.051443856209516525, 0.029139366000890732, -0.01105539221316576, 0.038967378437519073, -0.0629095733165741, 0.07027185708284378, 0.04042919725179672, 0.00379173387773335, 0.00263402983546257, 0.030638674274086952, 0.004835580941289663, 0.0158710815012455, 0.032630812376737595, 0.007397225592285395, 0.023800410330295563, 0.08697551488876343, -0.03158446401357651, 0.002554182894527912, -0.011412902735173702, -0.014059089124202728, 0.007141338661313057, -0.03316446766257286, -0.0064020343124866486, 0.026178894564509392, -0.05436089634895325, 0.032085202634334564, -0.004124137107282877, 0.029990652576088905, 0.02401779405772686, 0.07693315297365189, -0.07161678373813629, 0.030150894075632095, 0.03220674395561218, 0.045033879578113556, 0.04411124438047409, -0.029574228450655937, -0.04450453817844391, -0.020503388717770576, 0.01098494790494442, -0.031918372958898544, 0.0009709657169878483, -0.02811235561966896, 0.06374888122081757, 0.03353501856327057, -0.025923695415258408, -0.016189565882086754, -0.007324653211981058, -0.07348276674747467, 0.11759094148874283, -0.003506299341097474, -0.03908887505531311, -0.017883678898215294, -0.03277662768959999, -0.007280864752829075, -0.025016164407134056, 0.022387957200407982, -0.03036068193614483, -0.011995150707662106, 0.04138954356312752, -0.010090484283864498, -0.032951757311820984, 0.03949983790516853, -0.037199318408966064, -0.04748758673667908, 0.0003755962534341961, 0.026163961738348007, 0.05517177656292915, -0.015806738287210464, 0.004217224661260843, 0.03131451457738876, -0.04811893031001091, -0.054453641176223755, -0.01835324801504612, 0.024212243035435677, -0.013594945892691612, -0.03401239961385727, 0.016369644552469254, -0.002649900270625949, -0.001988280564546585, 0.033640168607234955, -0.0544901043176651, -0.015761300921440125, 0.027046505361795425, -0.034965261816978455, 0.012977822683751583, -0.03790852800011635, -0.005320209544152021, 0.0314362533390522, -0.02192562259733677, 0.023464616388082504, 0.05177629739046097, -0.02139841765165329, 0.03213177248835564, 0.054765064269304276, 0.002342837629839778, 0.027623241767287254, -0.07363549619913101, 0.005001740530133247, 0.003072985215112567, 0.022536538541316986, -0.013349330052733421, -0.011842336505651474, -0.04813501238822937, 0.004574568942189217, -0.002561223227530718, -0.01925056055188179, 0.018351752310991287, 0.039100974798202515, 0.0014359995257109404, -0.09130838513374329, -0.014902783557772636, 0.021294906735420227, 0.024866744875907898, 0.04398288205265999, -0.023466667160391808, -0.015759948641061783, 0.01896880567073822, 0.009754756465554237, 0.030791988596320152, -0.014327269978821278, -0.026346487924456596, 0.057144396007061005, 0.03637981787323952, -0.050258997827768326, 0.008897892199456692, 0.04620414972305298, -0.014077654108405113, -0.0016521575162187219, 0.011974133551120758, -0.03691601753234863, 0.019322965294122696, 0.02286640927195549, -0.009809473529458046, 0.03288782015442848, 0.06352026015520096, -0.005340637639164925, -0.05864992365241051, -0.044335994869470596, 0.07288680970668793, -0.02485952153801918, -0.011928418651223183, -0.012055792845785618, -0.09603048115968704, -0.03531090170145035, 0.045675136148929596, -0.037648383527994156, -0.012033768929541111, 0.004519286565482616, -0.02423878200352192, 0.02830028533935547, 0.02284279279410839, -0.00013162371760699898, 0.01886322908103466, 0.037494271993637085, -0.03108169324696064, 0.040065743029117584, -0.025295039638876915, 0.004214247222989798, -0.025676747784018517, -0.0431576669216156, -0.012126944959163666, 0.011147122830152512, 0.022737199440598488, -0.0723104476928711, -0.04938950762152672, 0.027304843068122864, 0.04372372105717659, -0.03859635069966316, -0.020501025021076202, 0.03189859166741371, 0.011109420098364353, 0.04494767263531685, 0.000685000151861459, 0.032456088811159134, 0.025006406009197235, 0.025123396888375282, 0.042308539152145386, 0.008214985951781273, 0.03517376631498337, 0.006476603914052248, 0.0071686203591525555, 0.0161864273250103, 0.03509548678994179, -0.0014562482247129083, -0.047635819762945175, 0.029357265681028366, 0.018047094345092773, 0.010851421393454075, 0.038657017052173615, -0.03854995220899582, 0.007377774454653263, 0.006189935840666294, 0.026454148814082146, 0.0008849165169522166, -0.0317835658788681, -0.014604541473090649, 0.012793288566172123, 0.04907089099287987, -0.011847437359392643, -0.03358474373817444, -0.00943917129188776, 0.03558880463242531, -0.005646038800477982, 0.03071269392967224, -0.018887847661972046, 0.052306804805994034, -0.011207256466150284, 0.026594992727041245, -0.03926529362797737, 0.029257232323288918, 0.027382442727684975, -0.0217356625944376, -0.005037305876612663, 0.00970670860260725, -0.07666847109794617, 0.03229483589529991, 0.004159971605986357, -0.008271618746221066, 0.0015028826892375946, -0.04045312479138374, -0.012295445427298546, -0.08351930975914001, -0.01351791713386774, -0.0399613156914711, -0.007564037572592497, 0.029530402272939682, -0.01640160381793976, -0.013887361623346806, 0.007933760061860085, -0.03967653959989548, 0.06831225007772446, -0.006580979097634554, 0.014295562170445919, -0.017461679875850677, -0.009236774407327175, 0.02380528673529625, 0.020915325731039047, 0.02050287276506424, 0.006280139554291964, -0.003880381816998124, 0.036322783678770065, 0.016135310754179955, -0.09508989006280899, -0.001961069880053401, -0.037115272134542465, -0.03097204491496086, 0.043455690145492554, -0.015577559359371662, -0.007731212768703699, -0.005291893146932125, -0.002732272492721677, 0.03080109693109989, -0.0467282198369503, 0.08735337853431702, 0.004047422669827938, 0.05062100291252136, -0.03359286114573479, -0.020391924306750298, 0.054721083492040634, -0.027644731104373932, -0.024805167689919472, 0.10444215685129166, 0.03783412650227547, -0.027844445779919624, 0.007606928702443838, 0.0251719132065773, 0.002160404808819294, 0.02433685027062893, 0.05773016810417175, 0.010763287544250488, 0.011556027457118034, 0.03565327450633049, 0.03365126997232437, -0.005848954897373915, -0.041280049830675125, 0.05134393274784088, 0.03343823552131653, 0.04329037666320801, -0.06023060157895088, 0.012646153569221497, 0.02883288264274597, 0.012180568650364876, 0.030345726758241653, 0.048026829957962036, 0.00022106037067715079, 0.004721151664853096, -0.01557223405689001, 0.047903452068567276, 0.017728695645928383, 0.022121930494904518, -0.010217749513685703, 0.03025233931839466, -0.008918240666389465, -0.028238356113433838, 0.004933828022330999, -0.043664295226335526, -0.03924427181482315, -0.021892735734581947, 0.017980031669139862, -0.10986819863319397, 0.00757180480286479, -0.04152494668960571, -0.02007131651043892, -0.013492591679096222, -0.019349288195371628, -0.016392208635807037, -0.029761796817183495, -0.0727572962641716, -0.0007517657359130681, 0.0747881606221199, 0.0204731747508049, -0.01776978000998497, -0.04980729892849922, -0.04530955106019974, 0.03469875827431679, -0.0705801472067833, -0.03369370475411415, 0.079676054418087, 0.028474504128098488, -0.003145037218928337, 0.09900584816932678, 0.006367158144712448, -0.03755371272563934, 0.00026024787803180516, -0.032248355448246, -0.0716506689786911, -0.04382975026965141, 0.008002743124961853, -0.05454380810260773, -0.03487953543663025, -0.03215796872973442, -0.002253703773021698, 0.020851342007517815, -0.005994358565658331, 0.024351077154278755, -0.07999477535486221, -0.014022164978086948, 0.030694466084241867 ]
<p>How to mathematically formulate the Two Slit Experiment in a Lorentz invariant framework.</p> <p>Is there a paper about this?</p>
g9791
[ 0.033351801335811615, 0.0029800415504723787, -0.0007510064169764519, -0.05356593430042267, 0.012113338336348534, -0.015317026525735855, 0.01724361628293991, 0.06019752100110054, -0.017569497227668762, -0.017118290066719055, 0.015834031626582146, 0.0795050635933876, 0.0025670677423477173, 0.028359660878777504, -0.015808794647455215, -0.015189450234174728, 0.05775388330221176, 0.013170610181987286, 0.013815742917358875, -0.015966108068823814, 0.0016797601711004972, 0.034633416682481766, -0.04119794815778732, -0.06273457407951355, -0.010720660910010338, -0.010207531042397022, 0.007373129948973656, -0.0006691013695672154, -0.05942999944090843, 0.011316248215734959, 0.013884165324270725, -0.0579574890434742, 0.015693586319684982, -0.007532589603215456, -0.037600673735141754, -0.042283643037080765, -0.007965050637722015, 0.03550577163696289, -0.05694232136011124, 0.013958399184048176, -0.012074352242052555, 0.008489763364195824, -0.02502170391380787, -0.03890923410654068, 0.00929945893585682, 0.00023124218569137156, -0.02231006883084774, 0.0009804392466321588, 0.04329245537519455, 0.010280455462634563, -0.005098051391541958, 0.040673207491636276, 0.1151866540312767, -0.02347519062459469, -0.018110176548361778, 0.03230278193950653, -0.010075175203382969, 0.016061753034591675, 0.07961029559373856, -0.00028380576986819506, 0.02649090066552162, -0.035042524337768555, -0.016148796305060387, 0.0033167365472763777, 0.03285713493824005, 0.07234350591897964, -0.028085175901651382, 0.00733230821788311, 0.027069473639130592, -0.012248069047927856, 0.004113959148526192, -0.019152285531163216, 0.027961064130067825, -0.012505702674388885, -0.054269030690193176, 0.031773991882801056, 0.007514720316976309, 0.02600737288594246, -0.020549524575471878, 0.01081481296569109, -0.03375387191772461, 0.005047140643000603, -0.018008865416049957, 0.0036921128630638123, 0.06056248024106026, -0.009679654613137245, 0.0436137318611145, -0.011993644759058952, 0.025926411151885986, -0.006818346679210663, 0.015843089669942856, -0.027406636625528336, 0.04664895683526993, 0.006189995910972357, 0.04591760039329529, 0.0264140572398901, -0.04110874980688095, 0.0644090548157692, -0.02821650728583336, 0.016948094591498375, -0.004405539948493242, 0.020925765857100487, -0.005439320113509893, 0.07822062075138092, -0.03451910987496376, -0.0052342489361763, 0.047000959515571594, 0.02701389603316784, -0.002381429076194763, 0.015176906250417233, -0.05016107112169266, -0.023552142083644867, 0.012659355998039246, -0.045669734477996826, -0.01818407140672207, -0.014497235417366028, 0.07416457682847977, -0.02420883998274803, 0.027753572911024094, 0.03302937373518944, 0.06877623498439789, 0.06798101216554642, -0.009956263937056065, 0.05019809678196907, 0.022969713434576988, 0.0062767695635557175, -0.04088333621621132, 0.022907214239239693, 0.025394171476364136, -0.0013614736963063478, 0.05353211984038353, 0.014115830883383751, 0.04551008343696594, -0.008589602075517178, -0.01748981699347496, 0.031190792098641396, 0.05470113456249237, 0.005074989516288042, -0.02637178637087345, -0.04510031268000603, -0.07056288421154022, -0.07138719409704208, -0.030559401959180832, -0.0035659729037433863, 0.05226490646600723, 0.004360263701528311, 0.01781844161450863, -0.029411446303129196, 0.00022031000116840005, -0.02967415191233158, -0.01500861719250679, 0.07104752212762833, -0.014269919134676456, 0.0037559366319328547, -0.026506749913096428, -0.02175203524529934, 0.03473569452762604, -0.050762660801410675, 0.008402734994888306, 0.04066813364624977, 0.03774075210094452, -0.0366579033434391, -0.016454048454761505, 0.018651770427823067, -0.0441645048558712, 0.004926818422973156, 0.03483600169420242, -0.050478849560022354, 0.007458847016096115, -0.041513923555612564, -0.06444907188415527, -0.04934439808130264, 0.02389177866280079, 0.0436573401093483, 0.021427689120173454, 0.14753766357898712, -0.03342524915933609, 0.012933752499520779, -0.002085193758830428, 0.05284745618700981, -0.007392054423689842, 0.003691264195367694, -0.01626322604715824, -0.04061194881796837, 0.020262662321329117, -0.015438518486917019, 0.03598847612738609, 0.001936968881636858, -0.07383301854133606, -0.014653864316642284, 0.02329033426940441, -0.003707488998770714, -0.03961823508143425, -0.020680347457528114, -0.04740127921104431, -0.007119858171790838, 0.07458139955997467, -0.03008238412439823, -0.009684947319328785, 0.04081282764673233, -0.039414770901203156, 0.07224570959806442, 0.006966381799429655, -0.0338682197034359, -0.024109037593007088, 0.02195747382938862, -0.03939821198582649, 0.006397213786840439, 0.008996294811367989, -0.03313716873526573, -0.0027248768601566553, 0.01778540387749672, 0.00018085223564412445, -0.004530369304120541, 0.03546426072716713, -0.003927975427359343, 0.021634384989738464, -0.022130612283945084, -0.060247648507356644, 0.005099861416965723, -0.003407478565350175, 0.0013426588848233223, 0.04138828441500664, 0.007347672712057829, -0.018072959035634995, -0.008165188133716583, -0.021241988986730576, 0.005887859966605902, -0.010326935909688473, 0.003588563995435834, -0.07309707254171371, 0.029960181564092636, -0.04501708596944809, -0.05926438421010971, 0.02893482893705368, 0.043451081961393356, -0.013603301718831062, 0.0559508353471756, 0.030119527131319046, -0.037132732570171356, 0.015949293971061707, 0.009629742242395878, -0.06449031084775925, 0.06522748619318008, 0.018315663561224937, -0.04214158281683922, 0.034396667033433914, 0.01640891470015049, -0.021541442722082138, 0.028167909011244774, 0.003623482771217823, -0.030780049040913582, 0.012526212260127068, -0.003918773028999567, -0.01754036545753479, -0.021217459812760353, 0.0011403091484680772, 0.04192161560058594, -0.08907808363437653, -0.007592434529215097, 0.026978490874171257, 0.030538499355316162, 0.04036025330424309, -0.00599437952041626, -0.018727274611592293, -0.0993766114115715, 0.012799535878002644, -0.006881876848638058, -0.048131294548511505, -0.03862939402461052, 0.022073272615671158, 0.026857083663344383, 0.034748345613479614, -0.002021725056692958, 0.058374661952257156, -0.016657492145895958, -0.01219770684838295, -0.05465482175350189, 0.01956181414425373, -0.04153217747807503, 0.003043513046577573, -0.017283184453845024, -0.059815503656864166, 0.05525311082601547, -0.00040926900692284107, -0.05931781604886055, -0.024765264242887497, 0.04241263121366501, 0.014363881200551987, 0.028906334191560745, -0.0729050263762474, -0.0025085406377911568, -0.01125175878405571, -0.032613545656204224, -0.027704788371920586, 0.000020186191250104457, 0.013356286101043224, -0.08028024435043335, -0.028226742520928383, -0.015163961797952652, -0.0004326034104451537, 0.014587974175810814, 0.02066793106496334, 0.010947996750473976, 0.04940372332930565, -0.003231690963730216, -0.0025772901717573404, -0.04360022768378258, 0.012761426158249378, -0.013179595582187176, -0.022358320653438568, 0.04633653163909912, 0.04469224065542221, 0.008823879994452, -0.04315776377916336, 0.04953562468290329, 0.030898619443178177, 0.01921534165740013, 0.07359015941619873, 0.03240078315138817, 0.04044199734926224, -0.001161889755167067, 0.04300941154360771, 0.02708708681166172, 0.039760492742061615, -0.04918557405471802, -0.022460101172327995, -0.013165654614567757, -0.06640428304672241, -0.013714440166950226, 0.012842575088143349, 0.011007164604961872, 0.008138999342918396, -0.021296866238117218, 0.07829011231660843, -0.031413733959198, 0.026564398780465126, 0.03472631797194481, 0.012811534106731415, 0.03841695562005043, 0.026752164587378502, -0.09325037896633148, -0.05064001306891441, 0.02148282900452614, -0.011424404568970203, 0.014936340972781181, -0.0031471303664147854, 0.007040946278721094, 0.019478689879179, -0.007773871533572674, 0.03505932539701462, -0.05260927602648735, -0.012553554959595203, -0.03177335485816002, 0.009337336756289005, -0.03278660401701927, 0.020419184118509293, -0.024241331964731216, 0.02985941432416439, 0.025713900104165077, -0.015708936378359795, -0.0020138712134212255, -0.025821447372436523, -0.03871288523077965, -0.047347668558359146, -0.007260811980813742, -0.0001344815391348675, 0.007015763316303492, -0.04801641032099724, -0.028565455228090286, -0.056741975247859955, -0.004994619637727737, -0.04138076305389404, 0.004995941184461117, -0.03511945530772209, -0.06525490432977676, 0.007639966439455748, 0.02653397060930729, -0.025593044236302376, 0.05425434559583664, -0.01252046599984169, 0.028053512796759605, 0.025787005200982094, 0.024171045050024986, 0.05615711584687233, -0.0034119198098778725, -0.011311606504023075, 0.04565398767590523, 0.003623389406129718, -0.03919327259063721, 0.0360737182199955, 0.0072571211494505405, -0.06018425151705742, 0.019542530179023743, -0.020462343469262123, -0.04943065345287323, 0.06870631128549576, -0.007260127458721399, 0.011964557692408562, 0.015987619757652283, 0.025002792477607727, 0.010186231695115566, -0.04441070929169655, -0.02582910843193531, -0.06256396323442459, 0.0360744409263134, 0.03680308535695076, -0.016877206042408943, -0.022403668612241745, 0.03612828254699707, -0.004988265223801136, 0.016943028196692467, 0.009479283355176449, -0.0579557865858078, 0.04477360099554062, -0.010706478729844093, 0.012506433762609959, -0.019623801112174988, -0.005273366812616587, 0.002475646324455738, -0.01083173044025898, 0.08823663741350174, 0.023523136973381042, -0.046055328100919724, -0.044797468930482864, 0.011341908946633339, 0.01837821491062641, 0.022816933691501617, 0.0008728429675102234, -0.09714464843273163, 0.0658465102314949, 0.023593440651893616, -0.006093040574342012, 0.028679467737674713, -0.09310508519411087, 0.01316166203469038, -0.08418989926576614, 0.011734685860574245, -0.029286235570907593, 0.05700214207172394, 0.03070143237709999, -0.05833175405859947, -0.012977875769138336, -0.017782893031835556, -0.040125567466020584, 0.08406320959329605, -0.018610091879963875, -0.06623808294534683, -0.024350246414542198, -0.03597021847963333, -0.026713231578469276, -0.015958357602357864, -0.017968103289604187, 0.047158580273389816, 0.01455540768802166, -0.01837332546710968, -0.024876462295651436, 0.04453819617629051, 0.04679258167743683, 0.0240565724670887, -0.04493272304534912, -0.018477050587534904, -0.024252794682979584, 0.024611907079815865, 0.016500843688845634, -0.01733706332743168, -0.01987164281308651, -0.07578185945749283, -0.05872829258441925, 0.02082175947725773, 0.025022514164447784, -0.024348370730876923, -0.010625477880239487, -0.004884873051196337, 0.042400140315294266, 0.03335179015994072, -0.03697452321648598, -0.012907717376947403, 0.015402710065245628, -0.022589514032006264, -0.06124721094965935, -0.022899258881807327, 0.046341776847839355, -0.030073132365942, 0.014105166308581829, -0.0002820003719534725, -0.02798028104007244, 0.017785105854272842, 0.027204079553484917, -0.05734321102499962, -0.02626907452940941, -0.03905906900763512, 0.05828510969877243, -0.009267307817935944, -0.01613025739789009, 0.024056442081928253, 0.02112073078751564, -0.005969851743429899, 0.009039309807121754, -0.029208874329924583, -0.02591387927532196, 0.01743358187377453, 0.04512281343340874, 0.015365148894488811, -0.037123680114746094, 0.03548485413193703, 0.01696608029305935, 0.014081975445151329, -0.03824876993894577, 0.03324390947818756, -0.0037684310227632523, 0.014157694764435291, -0.009749433025717735, -0.03805769234895706, 0.0673675388097763, -0.00969233550131321, 0.052687227725982666, 0.0014333147555589676, -0.031673721969127655, -0.0645553469657898, -0.012769252993166447, 0.026368016377091408, 0.008642408065497875, -0.03376662731170654, 0.04476315900683403, 0.032442085444927216, -0.08090349286794662, -0.019207818433642387, 0.0060758148320019245, -0.08230855315923691, -0.007784586399793625, 0.027565019205212593, 0.009581896476447582, 0.04756055027246475, 0.03894869238138199, -0.06714595854282379, 0.035084597766399384, -0.006094407290220261, -0.03998731076717377, 0.00767834298312664, -0.01941695809364319, -0.02640356868505478, 0.09599024057388306, 0.01581488363444805, -0.022831669077277184, -0.02565012313425541, 0.0033649092074483633, 0.01991891674697399, 0.042781490832567215, -0.008309324271976948, -0.030628841370344162, -0.07738903164863586, 0.013557517901062965, 0.03871692344546318, -0.028964927420020103, 0.009633407928049564, -0.012297172099351883, -0.07118376344442368, 0.03662608191370964, 0.0017115663504227996, 0.02773607149720192, 0.07355394214391708, 0.0025003135669976473, 0.03101225756108761, -0.02171020582318306, 0.006230845116078854, -0.025273118168115616, -0.04740748926997185, 0.08074979484081268, -0.018405690789222717, -0.032051436603069305, 0.073813296854496, -0.020428452640771866, 0.019447658210992813, 0.007367693353444338, 0.03638074919581413, 0.04874163866043091, -0.013181736692786217, -0.0072885495610535145, -0.049661971628665924, 0.039802055805921555, 0.08841956406831741, -0.0067629883997142315, 0.017247559502720833, -0.03594435378909111, 0.0679335966706276, -0.055338043719530106, 0.02594844065606594, 0.0013611252652481198, 0.022134549915790558, -0.04505531117320061, -0.061179086565971375, 0.01772879809141159, -0.023919612169265747, -0.02735629305243492, 0.03294328972697258, 0.010521515272557735, -0.010474801063537598, -0.05649930238723755, 0.05988625809550285, -0.0021235058084130287, -0.05960472300648689, 0.023203793913125992, 0.013233182951807976, 0.022227291017770767, 0.02960275299847126, -0.007593044079840183, -0.01881735399365425, -0.01970256306231022, 0.00015624378283973783, -0.040863100439310074, 0.019299441948533058, -0.045862242579460144, -0.0029892465099692345, 0.015525789931416512, -0.019084038212895393, 0.023503659293055534, 0.027521468698978424, 0.0359501875936985, 0.019593950361013412, 0.028527691960334778, -0.04570208489894867, -0.06190771237015724, -0.0431554801762104, 0.004531574435532093, 0.05731881782412529, -0.024198265746235847, -0.034351252019405365, 0.013112944550812244, 0.0005592729430645704, -0.00639704754576087, -0.028423234820365906, 0.046453893184661865, 0.038139715790748596, -0.021501051262021065, 0.029761869460344315, 0.006517814472317696, 0.024484707042574883, 0.027880512177944183, 0.018525302410125732, 0.026323894038796425, 0.07433585077524185, 0.06275392323732376, -0.02111191675066948, -0.03001767210662365, 0.006275297608226538, 0.003571093315258622, -0.019925439730286598, -0.07162465900182724, -0.019944503903388977, 0.03298820182681084, -0.03479308634996414, -0.016618620604276657, 0.046367235481739044, -0.008861856535077095, 0.04313303902745247, 0.051559727638959885, 0.007612849585711956, 0.0029851903673261404, -0.03380848839879036, -0.0008965178276412189, -0.0054412041790783405, 0.020307108759880066, -0.043454281985759735, -0.04905681684613228, 0.03110983967781067, -0.032202575355768204, -0.020249979570508003, 0.06369633227586746, -0.021687205880880356, -0.04376702383160591, -0.024115413427352905, -0.027318406850099564, 0.06814268231391907, -0.025557301938533783, -0.04303107410669327, 0.018248658627271652, 0.03438509255647659, -0.03869742155075073, -0.05905371531844139, -0.04061945155262947, 0.02030046284198761, -0.022446364164352417, 0.022798480466008186, -0.084170863032341, -0.0006087804213166237, -0.019705140963196754, -0.007829251699149609, 0.013068106025457382, 0.017037780955433846, 0.014161815866827965, 0.004492766689509153, 0.00904114730656147, -0.059818483889102936, -0.06356692314147949, 0.017480457201600075, 0.046270739287137985, 0.05636870488524437, -0.008719967678189278, 0.013548324815928936, 0.03282366693019867, 0.040713388472795486, -0.02789425477385521, 0.045479852706193924, 0.06256984919309616, 0.01943512074649334, 0.024088798090815544, -0.00009061129094334319, -0.02405671961605549, -0.04316287487745285, -0.01852673850953579, 0.023792728781700134, 0.005426585674285889, 0.02616909332573414, 0.040603309869766235, -0.013404265977442265, -0.062126584351062775, 0.03970928117632866, 0.031249886378645897, 0.009793678298592567, -0.0016461930936202407, -0.012552861124277115, 0.0397011935710907, 0.0018460534047335386, 0.02151636593043804, -0.049472320824861526, -0.020874887704849243, -0.045942164957523346, -0.005856734700500965, 0.04198788106441498, 0.018216025084257126, -0.01609170064330101, -0.06992501765489578, 0.07170293480157852, 0.015399039722979069, 0.017613030970096588, 0.030242186039686203, -0.017867395654320717, 0.016747239977121353, -0.004532145336270332, 0.02298397198319435, 0.0063170697540044785, 0.004375841934233904, -0.10327885299921036, -0.02413083054125309, -0.00027171315741725266, -0.03009594790637493, 0.0018378315726295114, 0.038083434104919434, -0.012274868786334991, -0.004162199795246124, 0.01672554388642311, -0.04570736736059189, 0.08960415422916412, 0.0809004008769989, -0.08495080471038818, -0.04773221164941788, -0.012180752120912075, 0.023602895438671112, 0.007370604667812586, -0.0032115373760461807, 0.04654589295387268, -0.00444671418517828, -0.002119671553373337, -0.04615987464785576, -0.03680550307035446, 0.046561989933252335, 0.04790022596716881 ]
<p>Once I discussed cars and there was a question about rate at which the car gains its speed ($100\:\mathrm{km/h}$) from standstill (i.e. acceleration). At some point of conversation it came up that cars cannot gain their $100\:\mathrm{km/h}$ speed for such tiny time interval I proposed (less than $3$ seconds), because <em>it can't go with acceleration more than $g$</em> i.e. <em>free fall accel</em> on Earth (we talked about wheel-driven vehicles - not a rocket-driven - and all we know that at certain acceleration value the wheels lose their grip with ground and vehicle is not moving forward it's burning tyres istead).</p> <p>I was disagree, I feel intuitively that the critical acceleration for the wheel traction exists but it couldn't be equal to $g$ or approaching to, because it should look like a some deep law of the nature (between friction and acceleration) and this phenomenon would be widely known (but I couldn't find anything).</p> <p>We started searching for contra-evidence. I found <code>Bugatti Veyron</code> which achieves $100\:\mathrm{km/h}$ speed roughly for $2.5\:s$ and some <code>Formula 1</code> cars. But the sources of acceleration values were considered as non-reliable and not proven.</p> <p>I know that the friction and cohesion proccesses are very untrivial, it brings electromagnetic interactions between atoms and molecules on microscopic level as well as surface geometry on macrolevel - that was another my argument against the statement that <em>acceleration can't be more than $g$ without traction loss</em> - because such complex and heterogeneous process as wheel traction can't have such a simple solution and equal to $g$.</p> <p>So, could someone prove it or provide a formula or methods to show that <em>critical acceleration of wheel-driven body without traction loss could be more than $g$</em> (or less)?</p>
g9792
[ 0.050805263221263885, 0.04613930359482765, 0.006761690601706505, 0.06626248359680176, 0.09738611429929733, 0.01662546582520008, 0.04542527720332146, -0.051556672900915146, -0.06793143600225449, -0.019264502450823784, 0.0004899197956547141, -0.05718022957444191, 0.07123269140720367, 0.03232239559292793, 0.003677838481962681, -0.022483866661787033, 0.030567405745387077, -0.054879412055015564, -0.018654247745871544, -0.017652690410614014, -0.0009152348502539098, -0.026135506108403206, -0.0674259141087532, 0.001683378592133522, -0.05498939007520676, -0.008025634102523327, 0.01728118397295475, -0.029175149276852608, -0.027173874899744987, 0.002302988665178418, 0.017007989808917046, -0.09167664498090744, 0.04741955175995827, -0.04572366178035736, -0.006725292187184095, -0.031626131385564804, 0.032841213047504425, -0.010768556036055088, 0.007944309152662754, -0.011089574545621872, 0.0786975547671318, -0.11083193868398666, 0.037520620971918106, 0.004245562944561243, 0.03747071325778961, -0.014258502051234245, -0.03775230050086975, 0.009922699071466923, -0.03554527461528778, -0.019799433648586273, -0.038753338158130646, 0.06246807798743248, 0.0368485264480114, -0.04255301132798195, -0.019782865419983864, 0.03135876730084419, 0.0198285523802042, -0.007138227578252554, 0.015795886516571045, 0.061630889773368835, -0.06788574904203415, -0.054733164608478546, 0.02099050208926201, -0.03841391205787659, 0.08504617214202881, -0.011331754736602306, -0.046832021325826645, 0.0015696012414991856, 0.01984119415283203, 0.0068549723364412785, 0.018900321796536446, 0.014898139983415604, -0.010906205512583256, -0.011115895584225655, -0.024497775360941887, -0.010684110224246979, -0.025272252038121223, -0.006583477836102247, 0.07377757132053375, 0.037907276302576065, -0.0487794391810894, 0.07570971548557281, -0.06466904282569885, 0.015389740467071533, 0.011755644343793392, -0.05933520197868347, 0.04478869214653969, 0.0398058257997036, 0.028075778856873512, 0.009718569926917553, 0.0832897424697876, -0.07586267590522766, 0.001878192531876266, -0.0028517816681414843, -0.022020405158400536, 0.0003689914010465145, -0.01930529810488224, 0.06946849077939987, 0.03062942996621132, -0.023545678704977036, 0.008665038272738457, -0.03869929537177086, 0.019343528896570206, -0.04326368123292923, 0.03993624821305275, -0.01493583619594574, -0.03640368580818176, 0.01687619835138321, 0.045268118381500244, -0.010747678577899933, 0.023644475266337395, -0.013718976639211178, -0.08104773610830307, -0.03316923975944519, -0.015437542460858822, -0.028133410960435867, 0.022494709119200706, 0.0024555549025535583, 0.012263788841664791, 0.005865367129445076, -0.046765055507421494, 0.03412717580795288, -0.03352878615260124, 0.06869660317897797, -0.007583290804177523, -0.03451290726661682, -0.024121738970279694, -0.006855549290776253, -0.030970891937613487, -0.008990478701889515, -0.025739170610904694, 0.009253558702766895, 0.03805271536111832, -0.00512514216825366, -0.04297566041350365, 0.016310064122080803, -0.021211404353380203, 0.025823311880230904, -0.019204873591661453, 0.04509098082780838, -0.06728190183639526, 0.025231599807739258, 0.05905589088797569, 0.005755703430622816, -0.055638398975133896, 0.03743379935622215, -0.04512191191315651, 0.09368125349283218, 0.023322727531194687, 0.04421006515622139, 0.010404439643025398, 0.026657497510313988, 0.02824597992002964, -0.04857657477259636, 0.04693189263343811, 0.013392681255936623, 0.0153738334774971, -0.02976800501346588, -0.04960140585899353, 0.04592641443014145, 0.05447420850396156, -0.040914956480264664, 0.023391077294945717, 0.010941007174551487, -0.041740965098142624, 0.007878421805799007, -0.03860175237059593, -0.032523978501558304, -0.02663474902510643, -0.015384216792881489, -0.05894910916686058, 0.015585992485284805, 0.08523577451705933, 0.0808948203921318, -0.0190605279058218, -0.014108956791460514, 0.07989982515573502, -0.019695915281772614, -0.010228052735328674, 0.009025135077536106, 0.03529282659292221, -0.04618656635284424, -0.0026517848018556833, 0.008857348002493382, 0.028258327394723892, -0.02915238030254841, 0.022045684978365898, 0.018969757482409477, -0.020158305764198303, 0.02339118905365467, -0.04962582141160965, -0.04101914167404175, 0.003425567876547575, 0.0032153171487152576, -0.027987418696284294, 0.03801042586565018, -0.02714921161532402, -0.05442238599061966, 0.03283458948135376, 0.05722032114863396, -0.014502014964818954, 0.02327086217701435, -0.05818461626768112, -0.015509883873164654, 0.06142166256904602, -0.08113887161016464, 0.031244982033967972, -0.04796809330582619, 0.036330513656139374, -0.025947870686650276, 0.04914669692516327, 0.04776797816157341, -0.05412808805704117, 0.056357208639383316, 0.005819014739245176, -0.07726840674877167, 0.012583157978951931, 0.008326002396643162, 0.03805636614561081, 0.00298526999540627, 0.06311122328042984, 0.011365776881575584, 0.020075133070349693, -0.022217674180865288, -0.012356271967291832, -0.03294922038912773, -0.02096085250377655, -0.029561888426542282, 0.008950764313340187, 0.050253208726644516, -0.01588861085474491, 0.025897154584527016, -0.018121730536222458, -0.10291826725006104, 0.0043800268322229385, 0.05186215788125992, 0.03619220480322838, -0.050632014870643616, 0.013929766602814198, 0.051811713725328445, 0.043583944439888, -0.04200311005115509, -0.04075207933783531, -0.04005734995007515, 0.006430392153561115, -0.07106684148311615, -0.010786906816065311, 0.025558944791555405, -0.026395367458462715, -0.023866137489676476, 0.01862397789955139, -0.02771352045238018, 0.00013917533215135336, 0.019685760140419006, -0.027320684865117073, 0.0449153296649456, -0.03003966435790062, 0.012069234624505043, -0.022455815225839615, 0.016966411843895912, 0.023494793102145195, -0.013217990286648273, 0.04453597217798233, 0.019090034067630768, -0.09832709282636642, 0.009066273458302021, -0.023654241114854813, -0.07025723904371262, -0.05128536373376846, 0.00919556524604559, -0.06002180278301239, 0.0037867785431444645, -0.06971802562475204, 0.07961820811033249, -0.025064239278435707, -0.021067235618829727, 0.00605275621637702, -0.027922431007027626, 0.0354074165225029, 0.00944056361913681, -0.04386613890528679, -0.00021944631589576602, 0.005657017230987549, -0.03372803330421448, -0.02975723147392273, -0.0003815661184489727, 0.01617959514260292, 0.026303600519895554, -0.017681991681456566, -0.028135724365711212, -0.02000642940402031, 0.0021019254345446825, 0.09296123683452606, 0.04251045361161232, 0.006790632847696543, 0.08390410244464874, 0.031211264431476593, -0.019973358139395714, -0.003792294068261981, -0.04930207133293152, 0.0477910153567791, -0.022346358746290207, 0.016359206289052963, 0.020986445248126984, 0.026469353586435318, 0.01288670115172863, -0.03261245787143707, -0.04267909377813339, -0.0507478304207325, 0.034292906522750854, -0.005803538020700216, 0.012925642542541027, 0.007089250721037388, -0.041209157556295395, -0.06421461701393127, -0.025023216381669044, 0.00812707468867302, 0.01600162498652935, 0.04436080530285835, 0.03617718070745468, -0.005741183180361986, -0.07602419704198837, -0.010913549922406673, -0.05213154852390289, 0.01833810657262802, 0.05281275883316994, -0.05593784898519516, -0.010154237039387226, -0.009995092637836933, -0.029695972800254822, 0.03424900397658348, 0.042207907885313034, 0.032175637781620026, 0.016597745940089226, -0.025635574012994766, -0.0053404043428599834, 0.05370140075683594, 0.03757956996560097, 0.03768419846892357, 0.028298284858465195, -0.06070437282323837, -0.004197032656520605, -0.040152497589588165, -0.058855947107076645, 0.012665445916354656, 0.037347227334976196, 0.018476609140634537, -0.004322490189224482, -0.024891512468457222, -0.05314864218235016, 0.02233462780714035, -0.02321946807205677, -0.024886906147003174, -0.013565197587013245, -0.04998587444424629, 0.09106580168008804, -0.013899390585720539, -0.02022305130958557, 0.007264743559062481, -0.004061483778059483, -0.023233234882354736, 0.0022610581945627928, 0.01007170882076025, -0.0159933939576149, 0.06460276991128922, -0.03777162358164787, -0.020340807735919952, 0.07891871780157089, 0.0087733780965209, -0.0016896578017622232, 0.004783398937433958, 0.010156753472983837, 0.004443694371730089, 0.004715297371149063, -0.01492193154990673, -0.01489028800278902, 0.014767280779778957, 0.020111510530114174, -0.03401728719472885, -0.0009285653359256685, 0.036431439220905304, 0.0633099228143692, -0.0053083524107933044, 0.038950905203819275, 0.020986855030059814, 0.007724151015281677, -0.0325668603181839, -0.040610358119010925, 0.006464545149356127, 0.022773368284106255, -0.010714833624660969, -0.022510221228003502, 0.04632778465747833, -0.022836649790406227, -0.04139421880245209, -0.024257121607661247, -0.05074893310666084, -0.009561989456415176, 0.013127565383911133, 0.029803238809108734, -0.0010839655296877027, 0.05264630168676376, 0.001704073860310018, 0.031568046659231186, -0.04333235323429108, 0.02320626936852932, -0.0008902401314117014, 0.03898417577147484, 0.03760029003024101, 0.002171492902562022, 0.05220717564225197, 0.05476401746273041, -0.04408702999353409, -0.018465030938386917, 0.012754526920616627, 0.002225334756076336, -0.027582794427871704, -0.03562495484948158, 0.038465846329927444, 0.01948411762714386, 0.01922179013490677, -0.0060430350713431835, -0.027134930714964867, -0.014245946891605854, 0.016729749739170074, 0.02171190083026886, -0.02612454444169998, 0.01939665898680687, 0.009784859605133533, 0.0019077571341767907, 0.019101228564977646, 0.007475993596017361, -0.03994181007146835, 0.017988940700888634, -0.02670595981180668, 0.051665108650922775, 0.0035717228893190622, 0.07612071186304092, 0.030869008973240852, 0.04549629986286163, -0.01252459641546011, 0.06332865357398987, 0.06403255462646484, 0.013354151509702206, 0.017607130110263824, 0.06564295291900635, -0.029171882197260857, -0.002610882045701146, 0.014142471365630627, -0.0190119668841362, 0.017093203961849213, -0.018145672976970673, 0.01257628295570612, 0.041311610490083694, -0.038799919188022614, -0.013673807494342327, -0.048445556312799454, -0.021836113184690475, -0.011742162518203259, 0.021699581295251846, -0.05891517922282219, 0.0036208685487508774, -0.02276422083377838, 0.021994389593601227, 0.05739784240722656, -0.05563041940331459, -0.017304830253124237, 0.0029922393150627613, -0.03567793220281601, -0.00131253304425627, -0.005926406476646662, -0.0040918560698628426, 0.015761855989694595, -0.02832811139523983, -0.0033689835108816624, -0.0048636505380272865, 0.0318169966340065, 0.03509843349456787, 0.00134439452085644, -0.022596167400479317, -0.026519574224948883, -0.014230471104383469, 0.002066604793071747, -0.033867452293634415, -0.01549555454403162, 0.06154805049300194, -0.05110970884561539, -0.004441047552973032, -0.009973827749490738, -0.03383982181549072, 0.03881028667092323, -0.0035590180195868015, -0.04945755749940872, -0.05051714554429054, -0.0067863608710467815, 0.03952805697917938, 0.030908573418855667, -0.05792304500937462, -0.03512360528111458, 0.019035087898373604, -0.0763169452548027, 0.009841764345765114, -0.0031815944239497185, 0.017833074554800987, 0.006757791619747877, 0.028750769793987274, 0.048843659460544586, -0.023104505613446236, 0.02633078210055828, 0.05115140229463577, -0.007260379381477833, 0.06699778139591217, 0.05555681511759758, -0.007751148194074631, -0.019375436007976532, -0.0056380620226264, 0.005633806809782982, -0.03661132603883743, 0.03818894177675247, -0.018209658563137054, 0.03249527886509895, -0.037799037992954254, -0.023195013403892517, -0.0009882505983114243, -0.05041380226612091, 0.03967226669192314, -0.011171516962349415, -0.06017403304576874, 0.011046845465898514, 0.0263501089066267, 0.02825404331088066, -0.03672688454389572, 0.029227478429675102, 0.01240848284214735, -0.03209369257092476, -0.027158962562680244, 0.04914797469973564, 0.0021353147458285093, -0.0014124016743153334, -0.05059221759438515, -0.05175616592168808, -0.02486221119761467, 0.015491414815187454, 0.043323080986738205, 0.02466055005788803, -0.00939685944467783, -0.08857418596744537, 0.005310500506311655, 0.047603096812963486, -0.08387869596481323, -0.016597896814346313, 0.011944591999053955, -0.00010162052058149129, -0.007357328198850155, -0.062243957072496414, 0.07161270081996918, 0.02281847782433033, -0.043813761323690414, -0.020098280161619186, -0.004855010192841291, 0.04518319293856621, -0.02526293881237507, 0.07174813747406006, 0.030258839949965477, 0.035979386419057846, -0.0271172933280468, 0.012243333272635937, -0.011095767840743065, 0.02467487007379532, 0.009896310046315193, -0.023234201595187187, 0.009140953421592712, -0.007173129357397556, 0.0032705797348171473, 0.012846351601183414, -0.03722389042377472, 0.001172253512777388, 0.006039002910256386, -0.030944736674427986, 0.030798066407442093, -0.017690280452370644, 0.01990691013634205, 0.011698001064360142, -0.019446926191449165, -0.04638564959168434, -0.04413827881217003, -0.06265558302402496, 0.004244447220116854, 0.016891777515411377, -0.0532861091196537, -0.036152951419353485, 0.06563688814640045, -0.034620437771081924, -0.026432465761899948, -0.057900477200746536, -0.08470188081264496, -0.037736184895038605, -0.06402256339788437, -0.023506535217165947, 0.048669762909412384, 0.05588522553443909, 0.027362380176782608, 0.020224547013640404, 0.016959574073553085, 0.009906327351927757, 0.014129024930298328, 0.034368474036455154, -0.006210953928530216, 0.0443684384226799, 0.007761357352137566, -0.015583820641040802, 0.02774181216955185, -0.006155569106340408, 0.03160678595304489, -0.05957886949181557, 0.0033541542943567038, 0.018111517652869225, 0.01633130945265293, -0.02223368175327778, -0.03840696066617966, 0.028808292001485825, 0.0455874428153038, 0.014343729242682457, -0.021336792036890984, -0.004672573413699865, -0.019081059843301773, -0.007363706827163696, 0.03430214896798134, 0.053598009049892426, -0.03199008107185364, 0.0012567046796903014, -0.024238266050815582, 0.025285949930548668, 0.03411294147372246, 0.004841967485845089, 0.04554746672511101, -0.04328254982829094, 0.0336647629737854, 0.04129231721162796, 0.01991536282002926, -0.03697671368718147, -0.025369009003043175, 0.009801022708415985, -0.005777319893240929, -0.022813014686107635, -0.03495270013809204, 0.039640121161937714, 0.031090684235095978, 0.022069713100790977, -0.003675323212519288, -0.0043332381173968315, -0.0646781399846077, -0.0042782933451235294, 0.027469707652926445, 0.0017615666147321463, 0.00047089692088775337, -0.03169906139373779, 0.04049905389547348, 0.0479329414665699, 0.0024760905653238297, -0.005922358483076096, 0.029415901750326157, 0.08161453157663345, -0.009959529154002666, -0.031843215227127075, 0.053677767515182495, -0.011932827532291412, -0.05249018594622612, 0.017690325155854225, 0.05535208806395531, 0.028526822105050087, -0.008502176962792873, -0.057504650205373764, -0.048659417778253555, 0.004759911447763443, 0.000305186869809404, -0.05101309344172478, 0.014997278340160847, 0.023972805589437485, 0.025657672435045242, 0.018276002258062363, 0.0023117109667509794, -0.011113145388662815, 0.030314162373542786, 0.025473877787590027, 0.03859777748584747, -0.002406476764008403, 0.022688522934913635, 0.007114018313586712, -0.028878672048449516, -0.06283623725175858, -0.02567366138100624, 0.030525512993335724, 0.012726008892059326, 0.003936435095965862, -0.03855053335428238, -0.0231466144323349, 0.02047707326710224, 0.011699522845447063, 0.00549301179125905, -0.004907074384391308, -0.007854525931179523, -0.008496694266796112, 0.0508364774286747, -0.03621695935726166, 0.06622666120529175, -0.03781132772564888, -0.0032704584300518036, -0.08297552168369293, -0.0013786159688606858, -0.0024463601876050234, 0.02811126969754696, -0.00894436426460743, 0.016691531985998154, 0.046778105199337006, 0.06339946389198303, 0.033861249685287476, -0.0014875013148412108, 0.0029089278541505337, -0.024633651599287987, 0.0049986098892986774, -0.04237227886915207, 0.03762985020875931, -0.07461461424827576, 0.0013908786932006478, -0.02177731692790985, -0.05040683597326279, -0.03491908684372902, 0.032262302935123444, -0.006115208379924297, -0.01611739955842495, 0.0026314191054552794, 0.07862550020217896, 0.008894899860024452, -0.06057412177324295, 0.002692303154617548, 0.023260798305273056, 0.0012327880831435323, -0.06911417841911316, 0.0005075070657767355, -0.056182388216257095, -0.05328795686364174, 0.01746009662747383, 0.054405562579631805, 0.010250203311443329, 0.02620694227516651, -0.001226128195412457, 0.07120262831449509, 0.04631277918815613, 0.027257997542619705, -0.011453474871814251, 0.011551478877663612, -0.03350752592086792, 0.04349498450756073, 0.01450135838240385, -0.051245857030153275, -0.025230493396520615, 0.01205356977880001, 0.003361091250553727, 0.00656651146709919, -0.040207866579294205, -0.013343713246285915, 0.0175893884152174, -0.047243326902389526, 0.03218071907758713, -0.028103739023208618, -0.02713862434029579, -0.0037274472415447235 ]
<p>This question is regarding a definition of Tensor product of Hilbert spaces that I found in Wald's book on QFT in curved space time. Let's first get some notation straight.</p> <p>Let $(V,+,*)$ denote a set $V$, together with $+$ and $*$ being the addition and multiplication maps on $V$ that satisfy the vector space axioms. We define the complex conjugate multiplication ${\overline *}:{\mathbb C} \times V \to V$ as $$ c {\overline *} \Psi = {\overline c} * \Psi,~~\forall~~\Psi \in V $$ The vector space formed by $(V,+,{\overline *})$ is called the complex conjugate vector space and is denoted by ${\overline V}$.</p> <p>Given two Hilbert spaces ${\cal H}_1$ and ${\cal H}_2$ and a bounded linear map $A: {\cal H}_1 \to {\cal H}_2$, we define the adjoint of this map $A^\dagger: {\cal H}_2 \to {\cal H}_1$ as $$ \left&lt; \Psi_2, A \Psi_1 \right&gt;_{{\cal H}_2} = \left&lt; A^\dagger \Psi_2 , \Psi_1 \right&gt;_{{\cal H}_1} $$ where $\left&lt; ~, ~ \right&gt;_{{\cal H}_1}$ is the inner product as defined on ${\cal H}_1$ (similarly for ${\cal H}_2$) and $\Psi_1 \in {\cal H}_1,~\Psi_2 \in {\cal H}_2$. That such map always exists can be proved using the Riesz lemma.</p> <p>Here the word "bounded" simply means that there exists some $C \in {\mathbb R}$ such that $$\left\| A(\Psi_1) \right\|_{{\cal H}_2} \leq C \left\| \Psi_1 \right\|_{{\cal H}_1}$$ for all $\Psi_1 \in {\cal H}_1$ and where $\left\| ~~ \right\|_{{\cal H}_1}$ is the norm as defined on ${\cal H}_1$ (similarly for ${\cal H}_2$)</p> <p>Great! Now for the statement. Here it is.</p> <blockquote> <p>The tensor product, ${\cal H}_1 \otimes {\cal H}_2$, of two Hilbert spaces, ${\cal H}_1$ and ${\cal H}_2$, may be defined as follows. Let $V$ denote the set of linear maps $A: {\overline {\cal H}}_1 \to {\cal H}_2$, which have finite rank, i.e. such that the range of $A$ is a finite dimensional subspace of ${\cal H}_2$. The $V$ has a natural vector space structure. Define the inner product on $V$ by $$ \left&lt; A, B \right&gt;_V = \text{tr}\left( A^\dagger B \right) $$ (The right side of the above equation is well defined, since $A^\dagger B: {\overline {\cal H}}_1 \to {\overline {\cal H}}_1$ has a finite rank). We define ${\cal H}_1 \otimes {\cal H}_2$ to be the Hilbert space completion of $V$. It follows that ${\cal H}_1 \otimes {\cal H}_2$ consists of all linear maps $A: {\overline {\cal H}}_1 \to {\cal H}_2$ that satisfy the Hilbert-Schmidt condition $\text{tr}\left( A^\dagger A \right) &lt; \infty$.</p> </blockquote> <p>My question is</p> <p><strong>1. How does this definition of the Tensor product of Hilbert spaces match up with the one we are familiar with when dealing with tensors in General relativity?</strong></p> <p>PS - I also have a similar problem with Wald's definition of a Direct Sum of Hilbert spaces. I have decided to put that into a separate question. If you could answer this one, please consider checking out that one too. It can be found <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/70601/direct-sum-of-hilbert-spaces">here</a>. Thanks!</p>
g9793
[ -0.009682396426796913, -0.0003519680176395923, -0.02523987926542759, -0.01161867380142212, -0.02294835075736046, -0.031468700617551804, 0.035513486713171005, -0.06289993971586227, -0.008992064744234085, -0.023139571771025658, 0.01830296218395233, -0.002858033636584878, 0.009957497008144855, -0.04643178731203079, -0.014712193980813026, 0.0018425238085910678, 0.0009162590722553432, 0.039954978972673416, 0.006411907263100147, -0.08139457553625107, -0.03792477771639824, 0.02655724249780178, 0.009428284130990505, -0.04682259261608124, -0.011502744629979134, 0.0038150877226144075, 0.0482669435441494, 0.008299083448946476, -0.05041372403502464, -0.02877476066350937, 0.034381888806819916, 0.015464960597455502, -0.012555791065096855, -0.02287394367158413, -0.02660522609949112, -0.04050935059785843, 0.05769981071352959, 0.030276469886302948, 0.09435822814702988, -0.02389216236770153, 0.04807651787996292, -0.018376944586634636, 0.03093108907341957, -0.05442645773291588, 0.03126947209239006, -0.03951830789446831, -0.04321174696087837, 0.027672233060002327, 0.03421390429139137, 0.015051727183163166, -0.05475158244371414, 0.012731324881315231, 0.034362517297267914, -0.03867251053452492, 0.004813686944544315, 0.0037033604457974434, -0.014841137453913689, -0.04387640953063965, 0.04192085936665535, -0.01843639276921749, -0.021762555465102196, -0.01338519062846899, 0.04927971586585045, -0.016112660989165306, 0.03920039162039757, -0.030192086473107338, 0.003333591390401125, 0.016373038291931152, 0.026730196550488472, 0.04622546583414078, 0.004517851397395134, -0.03141065314412117, 0.06733141839504242, -0.006703192833811045, -0.025179097428917885, 0.02933754213154316, 0.034662969410419464, 0.04012342542409897, 0.037521909922361374, 0.00856134295463562, -0.015266938135027885, -0.04001446068286896, 0.02026398479938507, 0.010848795995116234, 0.020746437832713127, 0.02704981528222561, 0.009427969343960285, 0.02318163402378559, -0.0030778993386775255, 0.02579011581838131, 0.01001989096403122, -0.020118409767746925, 0.05575425177812576, 0.0781799852848053, 0.005553878843784332, -0.03711053729057312, 0.006329696159809828, 0.020003603771328926, 0.010981597006320953, -0.03978540003299713, -0.014236371032893658, 0.06441882997751236, 0.031358398497104645, -0.004238274414092302, 0.013843869790434837, 0.03232671692967415, 0.04796304926276207, -0.015781177207827568, 0.007642068434506655, -0.0033926847390830517, -0.03344111144542694, -0.00444349180907011, -0.004560891538858414, -0.07683082669973373, -0.007737091276794672, 0.016682639718055725, -0.016525981947779655, 0.021382369101047516, -0.0006249030120670795, 0.061561550945043564, -0.024691440165042877, -0.0349058173596859, 0.047777049243450165, 0.024334019050002098, 0.022837365046143532, 0.019426757469773293, 0.020934978500008583, -0.009354382753372192, 0.029449397698044777, 0.004966279491782188, 0.005526935216039419, -0.023548593744635582, 0.029857829213142395, 0.03933068364858627, -0.059856440871953964, -0.035504866391420364, 0.016300346702337265, 0.01517515443265438, -0.03893107548356056, -0.05843023210763931, -0.01779484748840332, -0.0035097470972687006, 0.019983604550361633, -0.025245916098356247, 0.03478092700242996, -0.020644214004278183, 0.060063645243644714, -0.010781532153487206, 0.027280626818537712, -0.01971305161714554, -0.03595057502388954, 0.08429846912622452, -0.044669490307569504, -0.06245974823832512, -0.007985740900039673, 0.039049696177244186, 0.015070508234202862, 0.006729275453835726, 0.03680126368999481, 0.03924836963415146, -0.008562262170016766, 0.028847604990005493, 0.001284551341086626, -0.0022165251430124044, 0.01039209496229887, -0.04594416543841362, 0.04125325381755829, -0.07187618315219879, 0.04920325055718422, -0.047005027532577515, -0.027990924194455147, 0.026938939467072487, 0.03778531774878502, -0.04217400401830673, 0.062469396740198135, -0.013834195211529732, -0.015968983992934227, -0.010376643389463425, -0.03661542013287544, -0.002119617536664009, -0.09037645906209946, -0.002840572502464056, -0.001146974740549922, 0.009789654985070229, -0.029822027310729027, 0.023121841251850128, -0.011982258409261703, -0.0492921806871891, -0.02000614069402218, 0.0654401108622551, -0.009415514767169952, 0.0019373197574168444, 0.037788935005664825, 0.020930174738168716, 0.03336259722709656, 0.07122287899255753, 0.07502447813749313, -0.05461529269814491, -0.03557789698243141, 0.019289687275886536, -0.007436994928866625, -0.006944253575056791, -0.02377302199602127, 0.02181694656610489, -0.008181207813322544, 0.02779494971036911, -0.017045259475708008, -0.01329325046390295, 0.020819641649723053, 0.013730354607105255, 0.0075440374203026295, -0.03336453437805176, -0.046899452805519104, 0.018791036680340767, -0.01794244907796383, -0.08542024344205856, -0.017040733247995377, 0.02996056340634823, -0.022600453346967697, 0.06179291009902954, -0.012204215861856937, -0.0017994516529142857, 0.02763320878148079, -0.030426016077399254, 0.0043370407074689865, 0.01816316321492195, -0.00024578761076554656, -0.06647933274507523, -0.00266127847135067, 0.04559169337153435, -0.04277311637997627, 0.014649024233222008, -0.019119301810860634, -0.07636721432209015, 0.031309038400650024, -0.045021723955869675, -0.019345225766301155, 0.07539074867963791, 0.024385131895542145, 0.10458693653345108, 0.020679371431469917, -0.022574719041585922, 0.006061397027224302, 0.01167811919003725, 0.0077040488831698895, 0.0041123502887785435, -0.009420651011168957, -0.03978333622217178, -0.017108261585235596, -0.002053707605227828, -0.03563341125845909, -0.010567066259682178, -0.01195137295871973, 0.032526709139347076, 0.031318679451942444, -0.007792683318257332, -0.0049652233719825745, -0.038547370582818985, -0.07747156172990799, -0.023332802578806877, -0.021279562264680862, 0.06037125736474991, 0.005287547130137682, 0.03751378878951073, -0.03996623307466507, 0.03517546132206917, -0.02214226685464382, 0.025798015296459198, 0.07291055470705032, 0.03209840506315231, -0.039202943444252014, 0.04213709011673927, 0.01088815275579691, 0.02691897563636303, -0.04926902428269386, -0.006231646053493023, -0.05828219652175903, -0.07826167345046997, -0.02870701439678669, -0.017905738204717636, -0.04214763268828392, -0.022575974464416504, -0.04183284938335419, 0.03442202880978584, -0.026981495320796967, -0.06640785187482834, 0.04222889617085457, 0.03767039626836777, -0.0017441820818930864, 0.01214039046317339, -0.043044138699769974, 0.05045383796095848, -0.02460014447569847, 0.01952705904841423, 0.020128102973103523, 0.019831040874123573, -0.023141324520111084, -0.035699233412742615, -0.013170093297958374, 0.004125566221773624, 0.04008287191390991, -0.016849465668201447, 0.051820430904626846, -0.041493769735097885, 0.014991792850196362, -0.05101897194981575, -0.049843572080135345, -0.013654990121722221, -0.041038572788238525, 0.012522902339696884, 0.017845112830400467, 0.043298378586769104, 0.06442878395318985, -0.0763639360666275, 0.010971632786095142, -0.02458477020263672, -0.011163854040205479, -0.03273770585656166, 0.005594436079263687, -0.03384804353117943, -0.06519018858671188, -0.011477233842015266, -0.02013113908469677, 0.004740989301353693, 0.03126559779047966, -0.0011463399277999997, -0.04284526780247688, 0.036012955009937286, -0.0071685584262013435, -0.03158481791615486, -0.02788642607629299, 0.04077759012579918, 0.047402799129486084, 0.06121068075299263, -0.014035090804100037, -0.02399020455777645, -0.03713363781571388, 0.04675642028450966, 0.08375400304794312, -0.01563025265932083, -0.028001943603157997, 0.024432506412267685, -0.0074845291674137115, -0.00102965475525707, 0.0008257306180894375, 0.040023528039455414, -0.015824148431420326, 0.06769904494285583, -0.025893181562423706, 0.034161921590566635, 0.025223158299922943, -0.0444951206445694, 0.03394190967082977, 0.02659081667661667, -0.028766101226210594, 0.047473009675741196, 0.055743686854839325, 0.07153791934251785, 0.046387042850255966, -0.06677817553281784, -0.011912671849131584, -0.021420065313577652, 0.007814859971404076, -0.0356503427028656, -0.036008693277835846, -0.05738857761025429, 0.13246403634548187, -0.02614571899175644, -0.052527546882629395, 0.01270818430930376, 0.06684432923793793, 0.017359737306833267, -0.05892477184534073, 0.06553766876459122, -0.004533512983471155, -0.031942564994096756, 0.030292576178908348, -0.026894541457295418, -0.012103271670639515, -0.053022123873233795, -0.005627430975437164, 0.06715323030948639, 0.0537581630051136, 0.0320492684841156, 0.007561609614640474, -0.027179351076483727, 0.015766022726893425, -0.02718174457550049, 0.048490073531866074, -0.014239843003451824, -0.008439968340098858, -0.048416655510663986, -0.02804170735180378, -0.003913653548806906, 0.006256795022636652, 0.018644854426383972, 0.014217584393918514, 0.030415402725338936, -0.0512838289141655, -0.033291786909103394, 0.024683015421032906, 0.0018459104467183352, 0.046783287078142166, -0.0457717664539814, -0.017858101055026054, -0.03942212462425232, 0.032179709523916245, -0.010025680996477604, 0.03069048747420311, -0.028516778722405434, 0.03913993015885353, -0.016374314203858376, -0.003051659557968378, -0.017424453049898148, 0.0334976390004158, 0.023658765479922295, 0.04068224877119064, -0.03852096199989319, -0.019891269505023956, -0.021956952288746834, -0.03605970740318298, 0.01727316528558731, 0.032481130212545395, -0.031269583851099014, -0.003943856339901686, 0.041824113577604294, 0.045044925063848495, -0.010684377513825893, -0.01763305254280567, -0.022184252738952637, 0.012622366659343243, 0.007941375486552715, -0.03427819535136223, 0.02965543419122696, -0.0715709999203682, 0.017018860206007957, -0.02961673215031624, -0.00012330680328886956, -0.013704007491469383, -0.026800846680998802, 0.04856542497873306, 0.015304134227335453, 0.03981615602970123, -0.01870669238269329, 0.0035884452518075705, 0.0015415758825838566, -0.047294408082962036, -0.04547461122274399, -0.022508395835757256, -0.027755817398428917, 0.010320590808987617, 0.06623335927724838, 0.043266743421554565, -0.01612166129052639, 0.009717158041894436, -0.009486895054578781, 0.0027236919850111008, 0.01809186115860939, -0.0608915276825428, 0.023100823163986206, 0.008253639563918114, 0.00760459341108799, 0.05697178468108177, -0.006471789907664061, 0.03535373881459236, -0.06706910580396652, -0.07838025689125061, -0.028843559324741364, -0.0707831010222435, -0.0075797028839588165, 0.030873458832502365, 0.04833446815609932, 0.02740194834768772, 0.013258998282253742, -0.041166093200445175, -0.016979115083813667, -0.003099167486652732, -0.02071692794561386, -0.06323797255754471, -0.029150545597076416, -0.015273893252015114, -0.0051985569298267365, -0.029966505244374275, 0.039955127984285355, 0.04411855712532997, -0.0005049182800576091, -0.008825241588056087, -0.02631962113082409, 0.007488924544304609, -0.056900814175605774, 0.007794759701937437, 0.042387835681438446, 0.020891770720481873, 0.058683693408966064, -0.07727249711751938, 0.020155994221568108, -0.03630787879228592, -0.08534932136535645, 0.00769880972802639, -0.000144532197737135, -0.02105080895125866, 0.04021177068352699, 0.017823927104473114, 0.012356680817902088, -0.01629532314836979, -0.03845664858818054, 0.02491767704486847, 0.04054039716720581, -0.01823420077562332, 0.06860955059528351, 0.061708468943834305, 0.017538830637931824, 0.03604815527796745, -0.02176903933286667, 0.041004493832588196, 0.00443005096167326, -0.02168508805334568, 0.02451370283961296, -0.040501344949007034, -0.031038518995046616, -0.03631353750824928, 0.002779696136713028, -0.011637681163847446, 0.007431000005453825, 0.10357193648815155, 0.05293293297290802, -0.01744922809302807, -0.09197613596916199, -0.022550418972969055, 0.055326927453279495, 0.014848185703158379, -0.0077498909085989, -0.028510861098766327, -0.03591030463576317, -0.007861402817070484, -0.029478132724761963, 0.04254508018493652, 0.019373895600438118, 0.040989432483911514, 0.011289414018392563, 0.017924001440405846, -0.05356747284531593, -0.051251769065856934, 0.03458008915185928, -0.021649369969964027, 0.01501045748591423, -0.04138892516493797, -0.013416294939815998, -0.00203661248087883, -0.03538871556520462, -0.007652053609490395, -0.06596015393733978, -0.05402231961488724, -0.04517810419201851, 0.028818683698773384, 0.04548105597496033, -0.00123009888920933, -0.057476092129945755, -0.044192008674144745, -0.02854253351688385, -0.008043703623116016, -0.010873086750507355, -0.01689891144633293, -0.02914917655289173, 0.014224532060325146, -0.0021517861168831587, 0.01725909113883972, -0.006744466256350279, 0.0527937114238739, 0.008893155492842197, 0.022416191175580025, 0.04969993233680725, 0.025747179985046387, 0.05242738872766495, 0.030015334486961365, 0.0033772962633520365, 0.005443572998046875, -0.017954282462596893, -0.044631484895944595, 0.003791342256590724, 0.0025386428460478783, 0.007350263651460409, 0.019895145669579506, -0.06487797200679779, -0.004955110140144825, 0.01746807061135769, -0.01944168284535408, 0.05642146244645119, 0.047063034027814865, -0.014045540243387222, -0.01585659757256508, 0.008132435381412506, -0.02247196063399315, -0.04342491552233696, -0.030807342380285263, 0.08203821629285812, 0.03602419048547745, 0.038306865841150284, 0.007697510067373514, -0.045902229845523834, -0.007648346479982138, 0.04346982017159462, 0.053005151450634, 0.045820217579603195, 0.034439120441675186, 0.00826514046639204, -0.07640668749809265, -0.05662419646978378, 0.008135216310620308, 0.009826342575252056, 0.0374683141708374, 0.0034682699479162693, -0.00021427811589092016, 0.07831886410713196, -0.04645276069641113, -0.036174263805150986, 0.015855100005865097, 0.009515979327261448, -0.007209869101643562, 0.003429804230108857, 0.04293043911457062, 0.011618060059845448, 0.03464309498667717, 0.013379495590925217, -0.004708278924226761, 0.004575029015541077, 0.015453068539500237, 0.013564473018050194, -0.0012197857722640038, 0.007890974171459675, -0.01104834582656622, -0.03115779533982277, -0.00879782997071743, -0.040730539709329605, -0.06724852323532104, -0.0281967855989933, 0.013306153006851673, 0.058775708079338074, 0.02442719228565693, 0.040855590254068375, -0.003474012017250061, 0.0018370853504166007, 0.024138623848557472, -0.037370018661022186, -0.0296974815428257, 0.010105549357831478, 0.05164662376046181, -0.05973287299275398, -0.10059575736522675, 0.020024051889777184, 0.05685734748840332, 0.03667398542165756, -0.007523530162870884, 0.013476705178618431, -0.046151164919137955, -0.029256196692585945, 0.02387017384171486, 0.03743285313248634, 0.03459745645523071, -0.022017408162355423, -0.013911510817706585, -0.029673585668206215, -0.05540741607546806, 0.05210995674133301, -0.010918348096311092, 0.04434991627931595, -0.039528295397758484, 0.009763156995177269, 0.008179150521755219, -0.01004504319280386, -0.007571462541818619, 0.050014786422252655, 0.02153516560792923, 0.02403772994875908, -0.004557378590106964, -0.03230573236942291, 0.01960776187479496, 0.031122399494051933, 0.005251477472484112, 0.0008725187508389354, -0.039848487824201584, 0.025782134383916855, -0.06987381726503372, 0.016749151051044464, -0.028680186718702316, -0.020154956728219986, -0.02284584566950798, -0.02842642180621624, 0.0529462993144989, 0.01422661729156971, 0.004468541592359543, 0.015721900388598442, -0.010957472957670689, -0.02045494318008423, 0.036340080201625824, 0.005965926218777895, 0.09306284040212631, 0.04305865615606308, -0.012615477666258812, 0.01835879124701023, -0.010406545363366604, 0.018113473430275917, -0.06555669009685516, -0.01747232861816883, -0.0017096134833991528, 0.036051928997039795, -0.0034299809485673904, -0.009436809457838535, 0.030995558947324753, 0.022648585960268974, -0.009685875847935677, 0.0280673336237669, -0.007416377309709787, -0.019748922437429428, 0.025103570893406868, -0.025576898828148842, 0.0060471720062196255, -0.023049594834446907, 0.04068547487258911, -0.057967107743024826, 0.0019642962142825127, 0.01735689304769039, -0.04665445536375046, -0.07928556948900223, -0.021861903369426727, 0.019174229353666306, -0.035759005695581436, -0.08552861958742142, 0.0015071772504597902, 0.040394362062215805, 0.05524265021085739, -0.054738253355026245, -0.03328033536672592, 0.08187300711870193, 0.04379009082913399, 0.014274518005549908, 0.0038524549454450607, -0.03826799616217613, 0.017986536026000977, 0.03526392579078674, -0.029933813959360123, -0.09483963251113892, 0.006084137130528688, 0.014919017441570759, -0.0540943518280983, 0.03201179578900337, -0.016515245661139488, 0.012427212670445442, 0.015793276950716972, 0.007362540811300278, -0.0585559718310833, 0.07044225186109543, 0.0063085658475756645, 0.07758436352014542, 0.05781300365924835, -0.07558341324329376, 0.012999975122511387, 0.04346449673175812, 0.07199204713106155, -0.013917039148509502, 0.005769743118435144, 0.01328242290765047, -0.041256051510572433, -0.03288924694061279, -0.057354602962732315, -0.008134614676237106, -0.014333867467939854, -0.040452927350997925 ]
<p>Before using anticommutation relatives the energy, momentum, charge and number operators of the Dirac field have following expressions: $$ \hat {H} = \int \epsilon_{\mathbf p}\left( \hat {a}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {a}_{s}(\mathbf p ) - \hat {b}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {b}_{s}^{+}(\mathbf p ) \right)d^{3}\mathbf p, $$</p> <p>$$ \hat {\mathbf P} = \int \mathbf p \left( \hat {a}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {a}_{s}(\mathbf p ) - \hat {b}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {b}_{s}^{+}(\mathbf p ) \right)d^{3}\mathbf p, $$</p> <p>$$ \hat {Q} = \int \left( \hat {a}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat{a}_{s}(\mathbf p ) + \hat{b}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat{b}^{+}_{s}( \mathbf p )\right)d^{3}\mathbf p, $$</p> <p>$$ \hat {N} = \int \left( \hat {a}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat{a}_{s}(\mathbf p ) + \hat{b}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat{b}^{+}_{s}( \mathbf p )\right)d^{3}\mathbf p. $$ After using anticommutation relations and "neglecting" of infinite constant $\delta (0)$ (as we can do in a case of free field) in an expressions of energy and momentum operators, they transformed into $$ \hat {H} = \int \epsilon_{\mathbf p}\left( \hat {a}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {a}_{s}(\mathbf p ) + \hat {b}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {b}_{s}(\mathbf p ) \right)d^{3}\mathbf p, $$</p> <p>$$ \hat {\mathbf P} = \int \mathbf p \left( \hat {a}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {a}_{s}(\mathbf p ) + \hat {b}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {b}_{s}(\mathbf p ) \right)d^{3}\mathbf p . $$</p> <p>But I have a couple of questions in connection with number and charge operators.</p> <ol> <li><p>What can I do with infinite constant into espressions of charge and number operators? For example, $$ \hat {N} = \int (\hat {a}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {a}_{s}(\mathbf p ) + \delta (0) - \hat {b}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {b}_{s}(\mathbf p ))d^{3} \mathbf p . $$ Can I neglect summand with infinite constant in a reason that it is connected with infinite "vacuum" energy of field?</p></li> <li><p>(Under the condition of neglecting infinite constant). When I acted on one-antiparticle state $|E_{\mathbf k }\rangle = \hat {b}^{+}_{s'}(\mathbf k )| \rangle$ by number operator, I got minus: $$ \hat {N}{b}^{+}_{s'}(\mathbf k )| \rangle = -\int \hat {b}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {b}_{s}(\mathbf p )\hat {b}^{+}_{s'}(\mathbf k)d^{3}\mathbf p | \rangle = -| E_{\mathbf k } \rangle . $$ But $\hat {b}^{+}_{s}(\mathbf p )$ is creation operator (i.e. it was the creation operator before using anticommutation relations; the relations changed this (?)). Did I make the mistake?</p></li> </ol>
g9794
[ 0.033661726862192154, -0.03912399336695671, -0.03800404816865921, -0.035775840282440186, 0.07413993775844574, 0.010841652750968933, 0.09127731621265411, 0.031066879630088806, -0.0457041934132576, -0.015740077942609787, -0.08814727514982224, -0.0012157553574070334, -0.01705724187195301, 0.006496194750070572, 0.032387491315603256, 0.018806759268045425, 0.035097911953926086, -0.007574058603495359, -0.00885627418756485, -0.03488609567284584, -0.045175597071647644, -0.02240683324635029, 0.0007220761617645621, -0.04872746393084526, 0.043808046728372574, -0.04929336905479431, 0.0171060673892498, -0.030508674681186676, -0.012193134054541588, -0.09208935499191284, 0.06711602210998535, 0.057130709290504456, -0.03775625303387642, -0.03919782117009163, -0.024714121595025063, -0.01746416464447975, 0.10135743021965027, 0.03855380043387413, 0.02827535755932331, 0.029227716848254204, -0.004346344619989395, -0.015849292278289795, 0.049313951283693314, 0.020003791898489, -0.005932196043431759, 0.01329079084098339, 0.03031868487596512, 0.011409519240260124, 0.011759486049413681, -0.015105686150491238, -0.0014405203983187675, 0.00333117856644094, 0.004671085625886917, 0.004755697678774595, -0.024849269539117813, 0.05033578723669052, 0.030103592202067375, -0.0884087085723877, 0.021820448338985443, 0.04904503747820854, -0.044462140649557114, -0.08369825780391693, -0.01042983215302229, 0.003688499331474304, 0.05578906461596489, -0.0254469383507967, -0.015139869414269924, 0.04998352378606796, -0.04672085493803024, 0.019070670008659363, -0.0060844277031719685, -0.040896378457546234, 0.0036842080298811197, -0.047461602836847305, 0.04218687862157822, -0.011239571496844292, 0.05758783221244812, -0.06608879566192627, 0.019449438899755478, -0.019919076934456825, -0.00750110624358058, -0.01949227601289749, 0.05573664605617523, -0.006141909398138523, 0.039322782307863235, -0.00572932418435812, 0.011736570857465267, 0.021598687395453453, 0.0216690506786108, 0.002434622496366501, -0.06469964236021042, -0.06232583522796631, 0.018027599900960922, 0.024914998561143875, 0.005153295584022999, -0.042021606117486954, -0.022002996876835823, 0.0033135097473859787, -0.010471316054463387, 0.004749624989926815, 0.045770902186632156, 0.025832263752818108, 0.02341924048960209, -0.023750869557261467, 0.02224406972527504, -0.006670823786407709, 0.05825556442141533, -0.03307383134961128, 0.04629706218838692, -0.015988551080226898, -0.043679140508174896, -0.008840086869895458, -0.03355434164404869, -0.08467382937669754, -0.051091909408569336, 0.005172952078282833, 0.005982954520732164, -0.0419989638030529, -0.019575484097003937, 0.018330533057451248, -0.00730504235252738, 0.03631315752863884, 0.01721775159239769, -0.02817939780652523, 0.007634032517671585, -0.010200957767665386, -0.050062987953424454, 0.022315295413136482, 0.03579972684383392, -0.037071190774440765, -0.001281085191294551, -0.025510035455226898, -0.004551366437226534, 0.0348895788192749, 0.001090291771106422, 0.0021832636557519436, -0.040294431149959564, 0.04652949795126915, 0.023683667182922363, -0.03463657200336456, 0.014210867695510387, -0.03388356417417526, 0.0003057891735807061, -0.0034886831417679787, -0.035963356494903564, -0.019086383283138275, -0.025546634569764137, -0.05957877263426781, 0.010007670149207115, -0.017669519409537315, 0.02419375069439411, 0.055330488830804825, 0.014969061128795147, -0.006540792062878609, 0.0013809993397444487, -0.010892361402511597, 0.05859798938035965, 0.013171711936593056, -0.0014690218959003687, 0.006289680488407612, -0.01580938510596752, 0.025486471131443977, 0.010789008811116219, 0.03816954791545868, 0.033623650670051575, -0.0090909069404006, 0.023430446162819862, -0.011850346811115742, 0.038326043635606766, -0.0120621956884861, -0.012757857330143452, 0.027385490015149117, 0.012485500425100327, -0.026893382892012596, 0.066758893430233, 0.0065767294727265835, -0.05223066732287407, -0.03445620834827423, -0.006860898341983557, -0.02201816998422146, -0.0501495786011219, -0.02805052138864994, 0.035402242094278336, -0.01531318761408329, 0.0038106779102236032, 0.014774038456380367, 0.007881013676524162, 0.031350038945674896, -0.010875833220779896, 0.0035353675484657288, -0.051070794463157654, 0.0429593101143837, -0.03989996761083603, 0.0658918246626854, 0.012630733661353588, 0.04136431962251663, 0.003975192550569773, -0.06610270589590073, -0.027070943266153336, -0.01348141860216856, 0.03389637917280197, 0.009066933766007423, 0.017489390447735786, -0.004530378617346287, 0.02089576981961727, 0.015160366892814636, -0.021258380264043808, -0.04086228832602501, -0.020783646032214165, -0.000742374628316611, 0.004424768965691328, -0.03471492975950241, -0.02023806981742382, 0.0014298325404524803, 0.007738618180155754, -0.025642594322562218, 0.0082720210775733, -0.018777744844555855, 0.004864536225795746, 0.015497320331633091, -0.08279616385698318, -0.038984641432762146, 0.07403585314750671, -0.019665943458676338, -0.03726368024945259, 0.006815642584115267, 0.04603736102581024, 0.01531483605504036, 0.0015240840148180723, -0.02681245468556881, -0.0374755784869194, 0.004519525449723005, -0.006603645626455545, -0.0649467334151268, 0.00431946013122797, 0.031732961535453796, 0.004618778824806213, 0.027616262435913086, -0.01718689501285553, 0.027876663953065872, 0.007411451078951359, 0.01570068672299385, -0.023371241986751556, 0.026924999430775642, 0.007763259578496218, -0.018982140347361565, 0.047573868185281754, 0.016036679968237877, -0.020913735032081604, -0.002193826949223876, -0.029303070157766342, 0.025849729776382446, 0.006365128792822361, 0.037288062274456024, -0.020982816815376282, -0.016085144132375717, 0.02037663757801056, -0.0033342440146952868, 0.03506256639957428, 0.04444145783782005, 0.027393855154514313, 0.009053310379385948, -0.02346181683242321, 0.0382983461022377, -0.05339204519987106, -0.0191376730799675, -0.014469210989773273, 0.06873434782028198, 0.028645697981119156, 0.027631452307105064, -0.038427501916885376, 0.01667858473956585, 0.014295075088739395, 0.025328027084469795, 0.01470765471458435, -0.02858036756515503, -0.01607581228017807, -0.06857310235500336, 0.06564367562532425, -0.01759675145149231, -0.03754841536283493, 0.021589409559965134, -0.02130756713449955, 0.047724440693855286, 0.014690273441374302, -0.043735381215810776, -0.0010085502872243524, -0.005411192309111357, -0.01146692130714655, -0.01252234261482954, 0.04124866798520088, 0.056515440344810486, 0.04412360116839409, 0.005746939219534397, 0.0029380093328654766, 0.016805097460746765, 0.0500490665435791, -0.05943593755364418, -0.023142261430621147, 0.06612460315227509, -0.005565337371081114, -0.02061484009027481, 0.0015698603820055723, 0.07005242258310318, 0.046855658292770386, 0.03708880394697189, -0.07050859183073044, 0.013400736264884472, -0.020151061937212944, 0.02605484426021576, -0.04015562683343887, -0.021289927884936333, 0.001888207159936428, -0.054966699331998825, 0.04228843003511429, 0.02329978533089161, 0.002745210425928235, -0.038336481899023056, -0.014334042556583881, -0.0020489986054599285, -0.03685322776436806, -0.038742709904909134, 0.05588721111416817, -0.037368785589933395, 0.019714467227458954, 0.08525756746530533, -0.0685843750834465, 0.04907043278217316, -0.0575050413608551, -0.03821634501218796, 0.00009557574230711907, -0.01217633206397295, 0.08362232893705368, -0.025587132200598717, -0.08129982650279999, 0.030788879841566086, -0.020412268117070198, 0.008331546559929848, 0.025063106790184975, -0.02134622260928154, 0.018839156255126, 0.0776524469256401, -0.0065423534251749516, -0.00804655347019434, -0.018404366448521614, -0.02332904003560543, -0.005435553379356861, -0.014658873900771141, -0.017676034942269325, -0.009052996523678303, -0.028206557035446167, 0.0020194263197481632, 0.06140519678592682, 0.04747028648853302, -0.06122792512178421, 0.0211111418902874, 0.011905830353498459, 0.06354904174804688, -0.014663808047771454, -0.029526297003030777, -0.02022225223481655, -0.021328596398234367, 0.02530205249786377, 0.024688271805644035, -0.024317234754562378, 0.00382696813903749, -0.0434955433011055, -0.009863603860139847, -0.011232184246182442, -0.07493966817855835, 0.0008952265488915145, -0.0547800213098526, 0.009821218438446522, -0.021156733855605125, -0.06262558698654175, -0.04302564635872841, 0.03561282902956009, 0.06170748174190521, -0.047856125980615616, 0.04450354725122452, 0.025976816192269325, 0.011403236538171768, 0.015105043537914753, -0.005097275134176016, -0.02246267721056938, 0.08743114769458771, 0.04599160701036453, -0.016467956826090813, -0.04282673820853233, 0.005997007712721825, 0.02372513711452484, -0.035129912197589874, -0.03650161251425743, 0.006864501629024744, -0.005924838595092297, 0.004170823376625776, 0.008598532527685165, -0.06502527743577957, -0.025413313880562782, 0.05031536892056465, 0.010913359001278877, -0.04026298224925995, 0.007402696646749973, -0.04902775585651398, -0.015028304420411587, -0.0016576899215579033, 0.0609462708234787, 0.02822284772992134, 0.052797675132751465, -0.028509559109807014, -0.045797400176525116, -0.01169653795659542, 0.04678336903452873, -0.049311988055706024, -0.05889097601175308, -0.044321563094854355, -0.011584504507482052, 0.004159834701567888, -0.015987752005457878, -0.012230834923684597, 0.01157959271222353, 0.042276009917259216, 0.00419704569503665, -0.00262800557538867, 0.03321152180433273, 0.09494052827358246, 0.04345018044114113, -0.05129913240671158, -0.017874516546726227, -0.009431016631424427, 0.005842521321028471, 0.06677860766649246, -0.02945653907954693, 0.05472337082028389, -0.03573022037744522, 0.013442078605294228, -0.04609762504696846, 0.04818982630968094, -0.041108980774879456, 0.0221747737377882, 0.09360187500715256, 0.07191367447376251, 0.005799843464046717, -0.03918103501200676, -0.012245383113622665, 0.0633075088262558, -0.0416453555226326, -0.05613289773464203, 0.002146079670637846, 0.01701297052204609, 0.027784500271081924, 0.06892380863428116, 0.05021744966506958, -0.042442746460437775, 0.06084702908992767, -0.01529956329613924, -0.07320002466440201, -0.0001877556787803769, 0.007398814894258976, -0.018520144745707512, -0.019781168550252914, -0.01176978275179863, -0.02334858849644661, -0.013284466229379177, 0.05619248002767563, -0.02044537290930748, -0.06147610768675804, 0.0006988590466789901, -0.0841665044426918, -0.03544122353196144, 0.02380266599357128, 0.019401585683226585, 0.002491507213562727, -0.010604138486087322, -0.08567444980144501, -0.06943356245756149, 0.009846196509897709, 0.010764651000499725, -0.06138652563095093, 0.011914718896150589, -0.02758353017270565, 0.027876924723386765, -0.015421638265252113, 0.002410208573564887, -0.02602195367217064, 0.04201130196452141, -0.03171330690383911, 0.00012543196498882025, -0.01802600361406803, -0.008858186192810535, 0.0125432088971138, -0.0035966362338513136, 0.06473518908023834, 0.002125810831785202, 0.03790482506155968, 0.0683244988322258, -0.05475937947630882, 0.02336154505610466, 0.030535032972693443, 0.061407484114170074, -0.015346135944128036, -0.0054161157459020615, -0.04091240093111992, 0.017194025218486786, 0.006049016490578651, 0.012225143611431122, 0.07889296114444733, 0.06050955131649971, 0.04979265481233597, -0.01804940588772297, 0.009781339205801487, 0.024364545941352844, 0.07552206516265869, 0.003878568299114704, -0.020355332642793655, 0.00614928686991334, -0.07615406066179276, -0.06378825753927231, -0.056088902056217194, -0.0995953381061554, 0.003426599781960249, -0.021358488127589226, 0.08529548346996307, 0.0004909084527753294, 0.02240927331149578, -0.024967150762677193, 0.0027231944259256124, -0.0668075904250145, -0.025202563032507896, 0.011735178530216217, 0.03594871610403061, 0.03213783726096153, -0.02815580554306507, -0.05525733903050423, -0.004398229066282511, -0.014724627137184143, -0.024088315665721893, 0.04085693508386612, 0.050932884216308594, -0.0194679107517004, 0.03346915543079376, -0.06404880434274673, -0.031822893768548965, 0.0541113056242466, -0.102297842502594, 0.031881023198366165, -0.03075564093887806, -0.020777259021997452, 0.02615469880402088, -0.02078418806195259, 0.03568682819604874, 0.030184190720319748, 0.01268785074353218, -0.02521357126533985, 0.018154066056013107, 0.029105063527822495, -0.016925163567066193, 0.006414379458874464, -0.06625286489725113, 0.020911570638418198, -0.03867529705166817, -0.006328283343464136, 0.053929056972265244, 0.09577509760856628, -0.0047811116091907024, -0.016895685344934464, 0.028165163472294807, -0.0178243275731802, 0.0025717990938574076, 0.021852286532521248, 0.028154369443655014, -0.001806674525141716, -0.007758643478155136, -0.019883474335074425, 0.0656004399061203, -0.012331059202551842, -0.008496475405991077, -0.06060691922903061, -0.029443291947245598, -0.043875742703676224, -0.0016067404067143798, -0.011360063217580318, 0.00136619305703789, -0.03328017145395279, -0.05027538537979126, 0.047084156423807144, -0.03748146444559097, 0.011767604388296604, 0.053832340985536575, -0.01053498312830925, -0.08897842466831207, -0.05283712223172188, -0.0015921078156679869, -0.0019366624765098095, 0.030649367719888687, 0.029599376022815704, -0.01151985116302967, -0.055418096482753754, 0.001970532350242138, 0.023405926302075386, 0.07063882052898407, 0.02045503817498684, -0.0016430841060355306, -0.009523219428956509, -0.04618535563349724, 0.09349215775728226, -0.06783656030893326, 0.007191179320216179, -0.018820667639374733, -0.0010276854736730456, -0.03782367333769798, -0.059771280735731125, -0.006322059314697981, 0.006917949300259352, -0.01382280234247446, -0.010610001161694527, -0.021835558116436005, 0.08248881250619888, -0.026408184319734573, -0.03427567332983017, 0.05492566153407097, 0.010390501469373703, -0.03117527812719345, 0.008707854896783829, 0.02388206124305725, 0.048291102051734924, 0.029561571776866913, 0.03379318118095398, 0.04625958204269409, 0.02869485318660736, 0.006960143800824881, -0.010738387703895569, -0.02104610577225685, 0.01508931815624237, 0.026263482868671417, 0.051091160625219345, -0.030299797654151917, 0.06929518282413483, -0.014147152192890644, 0.026333697140216827, -0.0015988667728379369, 0.028486937284469604, 0.040200572460889816, 0.015458784066140652, -0.015700561925768852, -0.008092387579381466, 0.013095337897539139, 0.002852826612070203, -0.035750988870859146, -0.019652554765343666, 0.008291908539831638, 0.009420238435268402, -0.047112129628658295, 0.05196768417954445, 0.00011419212387409061, 0.005164599511772394, 0.01955709047615528, 0.05836760252714157, 0.01557935867458582, -0.0631052702665329, 0.009809477254748344, -0.03287221118807793, -0.011278769932687283, 0.0009244757820852101, -0.025224994868040085, 0.02733536623418331, -0.00007578353688586503, -0.0328834168612957, 0.05952676758170128, -0.021524706855416298, -0.010010349564254284, -0.026368536055088043, -0.030994128435850143, -0.00427321158349514, 0.020172981545329094, -0.0027640543412417173, 0.08880909532308578, 0.05136851221323013, -0.01991119608283043, -0.009972683154046535, -0.027874087914824486, 0.05196875333786011, -0.03477311506867409, -0.023022668436169624, -0.00009218329068971798, 0.03777959197759628, -0.038429293781518936, 0.043329425156116486, -0.0015416627284139395, -0.004818422254174948, 0.005748603027313948, -0.018803000450134277, 0.046414896845817566, 0.003986312076449394, -0.0016298076370730996, -0.0012346664443612099, 0.023529665544629097, 0.04519340395927429, 0.0737612396478653, -0.009143875911831856, 0.012893373146653175, -0.01765957847237587, -0.013277942314743996, -0.02645055204629898, -0.03989277780056, 0.04301859065890312, -0.007504974026232958, 0.002020803513005376, -0.0004930837894789875, 0.028845325112342834, -0.01448829472064972, -0.028845392167568207, -0.012753413990139961, -0.011976238340139389, 0.04311969503760338, 0.0006972809205763042, -0.021661775186657906, 0.034166932106018066, 0.005779277998954058, 0.00792870856821537, 0.0009862696751952171, 0.009054992347955704, -0.02425469271838665, 0.0007903226069174707, -0.01795089989900589, -0.03946014493703842, -0.053976599127054214, 0.021933890879154205, 0.019778696820139885, 0.007193334400653839, -0.07615647464990616, -0.008709456771612167, -0.0893331840634346, 0.012989606708288193, -0.05967404693365097, -0.015274944715201855, 0.02615439146757126, -0.03601882979273796, 0.028164224699139595, -0.024906668812036514, -0.05568469315767288, -0.03565647080540657, 0.021961279213428497, 0.018843036144971848, 0.018536975607275963, -0.05504056438803673, -0.046082887798547745, 0.011053496971726418, 0.047835905104875565, 0.05174574628472328, -0.013159054331481457, 0.054216332733631134, -0.013598678633570671, 0.037413183599710464, 0.06041347607970238, 0.0038745859637856483, 0.07344945520162582, 0.019250204786658287, 0.012856188230216503, 0.025983907282352448, -0.005616039503365755, -0.02752801403403282, -0.014875035732984543, 0.0070940409786999226, -0.008883225731551647, -0.023089854046702385, -0.01534653827548027, 0.01649722270667553 ]
<p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Ashes_series" rel="nofollow">The 2013 Ashes series</a> (a cricket thing between England and Australia) are underway as of today and it seems they have a new (to me) gimmick. It appears that they are now able to measure almost instantaneously (within a few seconds) the rotational speed of balls bowled by spin bowlers.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/lSivF.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>On the (golf) driving range, I was able to get similar readings, but they were from a machine only a few feet away from the tee. I don't quite understand that either, but it seems at least easier. Although there, they were even able to determine the rotational axis as well.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/tpu8i.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>But in cricket they also have a rotational axis along the direction of the ball, which is even more difficult to measure (unless they have a third radar somewhere perpendicular-<em>ish</em> to the pitch).</p> <p><em>I think</em> I now see that they placed very small black boxes between two of the stumps on either end of the pitch. I guess that must be the first two radars. (One of which will be useless because the batsman is standing in front of it.)</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/KaMpw.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>So, essentially: How do they do it? And, how accurate can it be, given that the reflection of the "sides" of the ball may be poor? Or are they using (visible-light) camera images, as suggested by the comments of udiboy and Deer Hunter below? (I'm fairly confident the golf system doesn't do that, but I don't <em>know</em>. Anyways, to make sure, the question is primarily about the cricket.)</p> <hr> <p><em>Added later.</em></p> <p>I found that they measure spin rates in baseball as well: <a href="http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/tom_verducci/04/12/fastballs.trackman/index.html" rel="nofollow">http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/tom_verducci/04/12/fastballs.trackman/index.html</a>.</p> <p>The <a href="http://trackman.dk" rel="nofollow">http://trackman.dk</a> site refers to these technologies and (patent/patent application) numbers:</p> <blockquote> <ul> <li><p>Measuring spin rate of sports balls by radar using multiple harmonic spectrum traces. (US2009/0075744, EP1698380, DE602006009719.0, GB/EP/1698380, ZL200680006869.0, JP2008/538085A and KR10/0947898)</p></li> <li><p>Measuring spin axis orientation of sport balls from trajectory measurements by radar. (US2009/0075744, DE602006015036.9, GB/EP/1853362, ZL200680006869.0, JP2008/538085A and KR10/0947898)</p></li> </ul> </blockquote>
g9795
[ -0.033932823687791824, -0.0182504802942276, -0.018687667325139046, -0.06822041422128677, 0.0815787985920906, -0.027180654928088188, 0.04127005487680435, -0.006453856825828552, -0.002923013875260949, 0.021671010181307793, 0.03187837451696396, 0.028184929862618446, 0.025966651737689972, -0.04871983826160431, 0.016386820003390312, -0.04489903897047043, 0.011182278394699097, -0.025014173239469528, 0.024135254323482513, 0.0388728491961956, 0.013064735569059849, -0.018641076982021332, -0.03075895830988884, -0.028237126767635345, -0.0077864076010882854, -0.037490736693143845, -0.052531011402606964, -0.038486093282699585, -0.03350476175546646, -0.011702342890202999, 0.006375262979418039, -0.03600912541151047, -0.010670555755496025, -0.034232523292303085, 0.05885773152112961, 0.018968630582094193, -0.057010404765605927, -0.024825474247336388, -0.05870269238948822, 0.009822622872889042, -0.005352201405912638, -0.015806319192051888, 0.027340656146407127, -0.027037324383854866, 0.03170014172792435, 0.0011320237535983324, 0.028723062947392464, 0.04977051168680191, -0.00597773352637887, 0.027249908074736595, 0.01500594150274992, -0.07819051295518875, 0.065875343978405, 0.05459630489349365, -0.004919028840959072, 0.056825101375579834, 0.009032982401549816, 0.00998079963028431, 0.06684914231300354, -0.023577822372317314, -0.06830915808677673, -0.042291831225156784, -0.05711917579174042, 0.005161236971616745, 0.04867078736424446, -0.032554976642131805, 0.00972695555537939, -0.026087773963809013, -0.031035451218485832, -0.026774389669299126, -0.002500376896932721, -0.0073678139597177505, 0.019116265699267387, -0.04421951621770859, -0.007427098695188761, -0.030943909659981728, -0.009474183432757854, -0.0316147655248642, 0.010656552389264107, 0.02683640457689762, 0.020537124946713448, -0.018731242045760155, -0.08460086584091187, 0.010896686464548111, 0.037792570888996124, 0.020845094695687294, -0.030375780537724495, -0.03031516820192337, 0.017845280468463898, 0.027105772867798805, 0.07877936214208603, 0.02366817742586136, 0.024271175265312195, 0.02385098859667778, -0.07339472323656082, -0.012629147619009018, -0.07301469892263412, 0.04008270055055618, 0.03129012882709503, 0.032144349068403244, -0.027245255187153816, 0.07277730107307434, -0.008223896846175194, -0.029305581003427505, 0.00023235971457324922, 0.025233061984181404, 0.006968657486140728, 0.017823584377765656, 0.005093092564493418, -0.003257360775023699, -0.012534194625914097, -0.013312788680195808, -0.006691282149404287, 0.01151297613978386, 0.009562295861542225, -0.00902706477791071, 0.04372456669807434, 0.055290017277002335, 0.027801603078842163, 0.07095156610012054, 0.05068213865160942, 0.009552772156894207, 0.032695572823286057, 0.03641785308718681, 0.0011747621465474367, 0.029305297881364822, -0.014069242402911186, -0.035323746502399445, 0.03304775431752205, 0.001706829760223627, -0.03921050950884819, -0.04577624052762985, 0.021697524935007095, 0.008695261552929878, -0.02072177268564701, 0.040448881685733795, 0.0329258069396019, -0.0036887761671096087, -0.00814502127468586, 0.005487590562552214, 0.015737144276499748, -0.03288443759083748, 0.027203375473618507, -0.040397994220256805, 0.03308865427970886, 0.0337543822824955, 0.028217675164341927, -0.027283189818263054, 0.06860624998807907, 0.009717682376503944, 0.06369610875844955, 0.0463356114923954, 0.03930577635765076, -0.010686400346457958, -0.014232407324016094, -0.006742618512362242, 0.02089313045144081, 0.024790193885564804, -0.013456519693136215, 0.06673087924718857, 0.07018430531024933, -0.021729636937379837, 0.04379820078611374, 0.031486738473176956, -0.009071958251297474, 0.05128144100308418, 0.0066412268206477165, -0.032611873000860214, -0.007126737851649523, -0.05331100896000862, -0.06573568284511566, 0.013747484423220158, 0.02044505812227726, -0.01817590557038784, -0.024956002831459045, 0.033376529812812805, 0.04259462654590607, -0.051612488925457, 0.006667509209364653, 0.024656234309077263, -0.028825409710407257, 0.035313930362463, 0.04168175533413887, -0.02072116918861866, 0.0055674840696156025, -0.04289575666189194, 0.033308953046798706, -0.0504634715616703, 0.025150518864393234, -0.03402131423354149, 0.009475769475102425, -0.05455968528985977, -0.024991588667035103, 0.0289981197565794, -0.03350399062037468, 0.030578473582863808, 0.04549195244908333, -0.04915386065840721, 0.006896622944623232, 0.02881496585905552, -0.02677936851978302, 0.003186713671311736, 0.04594898968935013, -0.06393874436616898, 0.031317152082920074, -0.019566835835576057, 0.02533789910376072, 0.02304213121533394, 0.01119502168148756, 0.04434950277209282, 0.008690329268574715, 0.0361974872648716, -0.009777165949344635, -0.023800116032361984, 0.05712808668613434, 0.050668682903051376, -0.05370297282934189, 0.012050210498273373, -0.011449200101196766, 0.035119302570819855, 0.07772589474916458, -0.014434113167226315, 0.033516284078359604, -0.021196793764829636, -0.03928563371300697, 0.02345736138522625, -0.015339207835495472, 0.04362969845533371, -0.015104343183338642, 0.03801119700074196, 0.003934832289814949, -0.05359937250614166, 0.0630936399102211, 0.01001246552914381, 0.048291899263858795, 0.002741352654993534, 0.02907531149685383, -0.028558284044265747, 0.033066123723983765, 0.04140282794833183, 0.07677508890628815, -0.034138672053813934, -0.05445752292871475, -0.005915408488363028, -0.0514267161488533, 0.00003300166645203717, 0.07055852562189102, 0.022980105131864548, 0.009926470927894115, 0.03857423737645149, 0.0734601765871048, -0.022262901067733765, 0.00755877373740077, -0.010322611778974533, -0.045097608119249344, -0.03560107573866844, 0.0028850750532001257, 0.02940824255347252, -0.0383443683385849, 0.02119155041873455, -0.01671369932591915, -0.002009960124269128, 0.08296478539705276, -0.004468781407922506, 0.061037588864564896, 0.003187943482771516, -0.034916240721940994, -0.015998532995581627, -0.022848306223750114, -0.0020995906088501215, -0.0879836305975914, 0.019301190972328186, 0.017983173951506615, -0.043390076607465744, -0.008620399050414562, 0.002915077842772007, 0.0033807498402893543, -0.008922685869038105, 0.0019262436544522643, 0.015894537791609764, -0.036484938114881516, 0.0059303711168468, -0.024403659626841545, -0.03352774307131767, 0.00036748748971149325, 0.03528362885117531, -0.02236483246088028, 0.004849711898714304, -0.018028322607278824, 0.016790729016065598, -0.016002237796783447, -0.024306777864694595, 0.03840551897883415, -0.0437353141605854, -0.0028048083186149597, 0.015849625691771507, 0.07600203901529312, -0.02495787851512432, 0.05859217420220375, 0.0004696500254794955, 0.01740569807589054, -0.03996635600924492, -0.01970629021525383, -0.00039573339745402336, 0.025133322924375534, 0.018457932397723198, -0.0842684656381607, -0.06551234424114227, 0.020323196426033974, 0.015462551265954971, 0.005326413083821535, -0.02554960548877716, 0.0007261285791173577, 0.010804777964949608, -0.019596247002482414, -0.0037248684093356133, -0.06132456660270691, 0.05352505296468735, 0.029123079031705856, 0.09234491735696793, -0.033414218574762344, 0.0009724338888190687, -0.021912429481744766, -0.006938217207789421, 0.04920259863138199, 0.011150484904646873, 0.014600302092730999, -0.020916549488902092, -0.08231684565544128, -0.04381874203681946, 0.0026471223682165146, 0.06005740910768509, -0.010654154233634472, 0.011110409162938595, -0.04719450697302818, -0.010016003623604774, 0.0035145049914717674, -0.004210175015032291, 0.06612376868724823, -0.008592220954596996, -0.000578950741328299, -0.02559565380215645, -0.027347302064299583, -0.04610062390565872, -0.01638171635568142, -0.004459336865693331, -0.035603005439043045, 0.013843952678143978, -0.05577424541115761, 0.004945763386785984, 0.006757543422281742, -0.0019897716119885445, -0.005342160351574421, -0.028565917164087296, 0.03475869819521904, 0.017350712791085243, -0.029371242970228195, 0.004416151903569698, 0.019730864092707634, -0.01629962958395481, -0.02884766459465027, 0.04956928640604019, -0.018346291035413742, -0.03997387737035751, -0.018489591777324677, 0.010925219394266605, -0.01154382061213255, -0.01871432177722454, -0.009643965400755405, 0.02215472236275673, -0.08391159027814865, -0.0027794099878519773, -0.005908663850277662, -0.012847083620727062, 0.004318539518862963, -0.02180010825395584, 0.02477145381271839, 0.008396990597248077, -0.06205892935395241, 0.006151898764073849, -0.04816983640193939, 0.02269946038722992, 0.0484180748462677, -0.002222180599346757, -0.03486160561442375, 0.04422488808631897, 0.03037579171359539, -0.05743633955717087, -0.03036634251475334, -0.002394041046500206, 0.02109503373503685, -0.0034752190113067627, 0.010861827060580254, 0.001955392537638545, -0.00965944491326809, -0.030979616567492485, -0.02308504842221737, -0.03677941858768463, -0.01458782609552145, 0.08654416352510452, -0.026884639635682106, 0.0035288238432258368, -0.006491169799119234, 0.019071776419878006, -0.06790284812450409, 0.009560135193169117, -0.027341116219758987, 0.036722417920827866, 0.038560714572668076, -0.022589268162846565, -0.025718100368976593, -0.011987971141934395, -0.04505497217178345, -0.03207926079630852, 0.013075817376375198, 0.067323699593544, -0.02112555503845215, 0.029348870739340782, -0.04207446426153183, 0.042776502668857574, 0.008986023254692554, 0.009045976214110851, 0.06317107379436493, -0.06037534028291702, -0.05626382306218147, 0.00516944844275713, 0.03653857856988907, -0.0005873607005923986, -0.014120458625257015, -0.021792206913232803, 0.09402032941579819, -0.00714484229683876, 0.05748644843697548, 0.028292309492826462, 0.016858000308275223, 0.03987475484609604, 0.047912731766700745, -0.032770995050668716, 0.06412491202354431, -0.06857848167419434, 0.0018987063085660338, -0.05219952389597893, -0.00662999926134944, -0.1105220764875412, -0.07528379559516907, 0.07108775526285172, -0.08057159185409546, -0.01061380747705698, -0.018671168014407158, -0.015751101076602936, 0.018867075443267822, 0.03961664065718651, -0.06020062044262886, 0.032755378633737564, -0.015355419367551804, -0.03803308308124542, -0.03645530343055725, 0.02042192593216896, 0.03245473653078079, -0.026955822482705116, -0.04865782707929611, 0.042057719081640244, -0.030947072431445122, -0.05307265371084213, -0.019341496750712395, 0.04966472089290619, -0.0064049893990159035, -0.004470032174140215, -0.00635090097784996, -0.030804697424173355, -0.05657992884516716, -0.03679947555065155, 0.03639093041419983, -0.0056200516410171986, -0.00937560759484768, 0.05141294375061989, -0.018892116844654083, -0.0022170203737914562, 0.011017444543540478, -0.046801429241895676, -0.043086569756269455, -0.016458729282021523, -0.015111208893358707, -0.035052958875894547, -0.012887278571724892, -0.017953766509890556, 0.057119280099868774, -0.026895878836512566, 0.01104538980871439, 0.037224505096673965, 0.019344979897141457, 0.010005868971347809, -0.0610433928668499, -0.01330480258911848, -0.02668658457696438, -0.01431331317871809, 0.042295973747968674, -0.0342596136033535, -0.04887733608484268, -0.01597573049366474, -0.029673239216208458, 0.0512525774538517, 0.011883714236319065, -0.020656822249293327, -0.0020333626307547092, 0.06571783125400543, 0.05307968705892563, -0.00009796468657441437, -0.0008413006435148418, 0.03830387443304062, -0.022685378789901733, 0.015847912058234215, 0.01923896186053753, 0.01028307992964983, -0.01343662478029728, -0.03488380089402199, 0.06236273795366287, 0.04252444580197334, -0.017035149037837982, -0.002470522653311491, -0.02408970147371292, 0.039596542716026306, 0.012841916643083096, 0.011642920784652233, -0.020265206694602966, 0.023800933733582497, -0.05031032860279083, 0.017377492040395737, -0.001503577223047614, -0.0009326935978606343, -0.0032773204147815704, -0.016663312911987305, 0.006946335081011057, -0.011797958053648472, -0.0012077844003215432, 0.010652032680809498, -0.03055226244032383, -0.07721295207738876, 0.002383902668952942, -0.02591346763074398, -0.027657559141516685, 0.028646206483244896, 0.012670665048062801, 0.05577436089515686, 0.01284996047616005, -0.04947277903556824, -0.0003518101875670254, -0.07256579399108887, 0.026301227509975433, 0.017223600298166275, 0.014713365584611893, 0.05154934525489807, -0.011022690683603287, -0.025644386187195778, -0.051239974796772, 0.07161859422922134, -0.06546288728713989, -0.019131502136588097, -0.038874994963407516, 0.007559009827673435, 0.04974987357854843, -0.011340226978063583, 0.01843254640698433, 0.010249676182866096, -0.050016362220048904, 0.011442509479820728, 0.00657750153914094, 0.009903564117848873, 0.01296377182006836, -0.0032416784670203924, -0.04619958624243736, -0.05485710874199867, 0.018615610897541046, 0.11023528128862381, 0.018424825742840767, 0.016842147335410118, -0.013603883795440197, 0.0012822779826819897, -0.021243290975689888, 0.0188740361481905, 0.011025985702872276, 0.0003908699727617204, 0.030216457322239876, 0.004184857942163944, 0.058097485452890396, 0.03428196534514427, -0.008097242563962936, 0.0671941488981247, 0.06611543893814087, -0.08549245446920395, -0.08708163350820541, 0.0037424855399876833, -0.03267940133810043, -0.04299669712781906, -0.019584139809012413, -0.04114909842610359, -0.018185613676905632, 0.027824923396110535, -0.04094595089554787, 0.05110033228993416, -0.048554569482803345, -0.06719668954610825, 0.028938723728060722, -0.033024728298187256, -0.011666703037917614, -0.006244460586458445, 0.0013909762492403388, -0.02573709562420845, 0.004151357803493738, -0.039956096559762955, -0.01659362018108368, 0.008947653695940971, 0.022857975214719772, 0.06543321907520294, -0.04493654891848564, 0.0205185916274786, 0.02398843877017498, -0.029587723314762115, 0.028182553127408028, -0.03150811046361923, -0.0020895518828183413, 0.026282280683517456, -0.022099066525697708, -0.007001567631959915, -0.023162534460425377, -0.02232012152671814, -0.008856932632625103, 0.017628205940127373, 0.0031642497051507235, 0.0018381683621555567, 0.0654531866312027, 0.006512606516480446, -0.018214711919426918, 0.01360560953617096, 0.02287161536514759, -0.06340508162975311, 0.02335231937468052, 0.08035683631896973, 0.0769830048084259, 0.041649412363767624, 0.011950197629630566, 0.06748108565807343, -0.07113172113895416, 0.014955185353755951, -0.07397851347923279, 0.000006091629074944649, 0.0023176618851721287, 0.015702014788985252, -0.022904839366674423, 0.025129040703177452, -0.04060428962111473, -0.09248510748147964, 0.008168616332113743, 2.2727465420757653e-7, -0.010994989424943924, 0.028536932542920113, 0.042475875467061996, -0.025064826011657715, 0.029997536912560463, -0.08389957249164581, 0.0005640466697514057, -0.04984471574425697, -0.04115765914320946, -0.027410663664340973, -0.03555567190051079, -0.022976305335760117, -0.008875508792698383, -0.025347815826535225, 0.008641471154987812, -0.02263840101659298, 0.010833724401891232, -0.0450734980404377, 0.03381418064236641, -0.02825229801237583, -0.004918787162750959, 0.015668699517846107, -0.0425751656293869, 0.02136535942554474, 0.000692696135956794, 0.009335935115814209, -0.044010188430547714, 0.04526689648628235, 0.039389822632074356, 0.010078116320073605, -0.035497236996889114, 0.04112401604652405, -0.02420925535261631, 0.03783772885799408, 0.04798974096775055, -0.07187442481517792, -0.01851831004023552, 0.03994524106383324, -0.005653151776641607, 0.06035350263118744, 0.05337366834282875, -0.07103222608566284, 0.005457633174955845, 0.025357896462082863, -0.03879286348819733, -0.03251142427325249, 0.05129965767264366, 0.014647450298070908, 0.07688271999359131, 0.038251861929893494, 0.013954916968941689, -0.03598233684897423, -0.007065143436193466, -0.03652158007025719, 0.0027005751617252827, 0.009833280928432941, -0.0275593101978302, -0.0067502036690711975, 0.019900456070899963, 0.03456859663128853, -0.051168233156204224, 0.017547892406582832, -0.013765226118266582, 0.01757039688527584, -0.038850750774145126, 0.004062608350068331, -0.04266328737139702, 0.017285507172346115, 0.019364656880497932, -0.0291429553180933, 0.022754931822419167, 0.0012754135532304645, 0.076670341193676, 0.028318513184785843, 0.07519595324993134, -0.07155197113752365, 0.03756082057952881, 0.035573530942201614, -0.012121584266424179, 0.07377348840236664, -0.045178428292274475, 0.04064531251788139, -0.039415813982486725, 0.06809145957231522, -0.029212340712547302, 0.026027798652648926, 0.013782884925603867, 0.01339229941368103, 0.019182244315743446, -0.043556611984968185, -0.03224362060427666, 0.007439055945724249, 0.019930483773350716, 0.09690512716770172, -0.05631890520453453, -0.026999307796359062, 0.05172666907310486, 0.034520041197538376, -0.035789843648672104, 0.016712868586182594, 0.014392943121492863, 0.009747667238116264, 0.018897654488682747, 0.02725338377058506, 0.0024041859433054924, -0.01602899469435215, -0.020313765853643417, -0.028137212619185448, 0.011609097942709923, 0.007831702008843422, 0.03151865676045418, -0.052921462804079056, -0.034370116889476776, 0.027807297185063362 ]
<p>I am a physicist who is not that well-versed in mathematical rigour (a shame, I know! But I'm working on it.) In Wald's book on QFT in Curved spacetimes, I found the following definitions of the direct sum of Hilbert spaces. He says - </p> <blockquote> <p>Next, we define the direct sum of Hilbert spaces. Let $\{ {\cal H}_\alpha \}$ be an arbitrary collection of Hilbert spaces, indexed by $\alpha$ (We will be interested only with the case where there are at most a countable number of Hilbert spaces, but no such restriction need be made for this construction). The elements of the Cartesian product $\times_\alpha {\cal H}_\alpha$ consist of the collection of vectors $\{\Psi_\alpha\}$ for each $\Psi_\alpha \in {\cal H}_\alpha$. Consider, now, the subset, $V \subset \times_\alpha {\cal H}_\alpha$, composed of elements for which all but finitely many of the $\Psi_\alpha$ vanish. Then $V$ has the natural structure of an inner product space. We define the <em>direct sum Hilbert space</em> $\bigoplus\limits_\alpha {\cal H}_\alpha$ to be the Hilbert space completion of $V$. It follows that in the case of a countable infinite collection of Hilbert spaces $\{{\cal H}_i\}$ each $\Psi \in \bigoplus\limits_i {\cal H}_i$ consists of arbitrary sequences $\{\Psi_i\}$ such that each $\Psi_i \in {\cal H}_i$ and $\sum\limits_i \left\| \Psi_i \right\|_i^2 &lt; \infty$.</p> </blockquote> <p>Here $\left\| ~~\right\|_i$ is the norm defined in ${\cal H}_i$. Also, Hilbert space completion of an inner product vector space $V$ is a space ${\cal H}$ such that $V \subset {\cal H}$ and ${\cal H}$ is complete in the associated norm. It is constructed from $V$ by taking equivalence classes of Cauchy sequences in $V$.</p> <p>Now the questions - </p> <p><strong>1. Why does $V$ have the structure of an inner product space?</strong></p> <p><strong>2. How does he conclude that $\sum\limits_i \left\| \Psi_i \right\|_i^2 &lt; \infty$?</strong> </p> <p><strong>3. How does this definition of the direct sum match up with the usual things we see when looking at tensors in general relativity or in representations of Lie algebras, etc.?</strong></p> <p>PS - I also have a similar problem with Wald's definition of a Tensor Product of Hilbert spaces. I have decided to put that into a separate question. If you could answer this one, please consider checking out that one too. It can be found <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/70604/tensor-product-of-hilbert-spaces">here</a>. Thanks!</p>
g9796
[ -0.027245981618762016, 0.030769798904657364, -0.03941744193434715, -0.023505551740527153, -0.04029164835810661, -0.012623962946236134, 0.04381712153553963, -0.05269021913409233, -0.0234973281621933, -0.017260048538446426, -0.019995663315057755, -0.006732253823429346, 0.03031318634748459, -0.021363362669944763, -0.004886554554104805, -0.0019551911391317844, 0.007918450981378555, -0.0005514576914720237, 0.036371778696775436, -0.05193403363227844, 0.008262726478278637, 0.03361920639872551, -0.011566980741918087, -0.013778571970760822, -0.013246458023786545, 0.04737422615289688, 0.05196186900138855, 0.0026756422594189644, -0.03286939486861229, -0.03813872113823891, 0.03162170946598053, -0.006709848530590534, 0.00984206423163414, -0.019875546917319298, -0.016369221732020378, 0.0023987293243408203, 0.05910353362560272, 0.027698395773768425, 0.0502815879881382, -0.02606370858848095, -0.0018564113415777683, -0.0182397048920393, 0.05107230693101883, -0.0830836370587349, 0.018041472882032394, -0.0300295427441597, -0.017910799011588097, 0.009869777597486973, 0.042458802461624146, 0.009553923271596432, -0.02354588359594345, 0.01577487774193287, 0.02088331989943981, -0.06255315989255905, 0.01919880323112011, 0.0016433638520538807, -0.006698507349938154, -0.055402033030986786, 0.06000351533293724, -0.016935762017965317, -0.0028897863812744617, 0.009939097799360752, 0.022565722465515137, -0.0015772965271025896, 0.014134976081550121, -0.034047067165374756, -0.05387245491147041, 0.020329119637608528, 0.06310626119375229, 0.06270294636487961, 0.06167801469564438, -0.018645210191607475, 0.05486353859305382, -0.03871780261397362, -0.018941698595881462, 0.027851389721035957, 0.011555451899766922, 0.09484349936246872, 0.04956609010696411, 0.029842708259820938, -0.015674954280257225, -0.04324207827448845, 0.02018732577562332, -0.008801580406725407, 0.03785906732082367, 0.014612813480198383, -0.022583620622754097, 0.025216583162546158, 0.023286398500204086, 0.05419720709323883, 0.0383848212659359, 0.003226562635973096, 0.03509974107146263, 0.11671208590269089, 0.0013498447369784117, -0.045359499752521515, -0.020101159811019897, 0.04138582944869995, -0.008969715796411037, 0.003254157258197665, 0.006400858052074909, 0.014660920016467571, 0.05093276873230934, -0.02345927432179451, 0.018259592354297638, 0.02578561007976532, 0.022575583308935165, 0.02903827838599682, 0.012226250022649765, 0.009073922410607338, -0.046498242765665054, 0.01532442681491375, -0.018064213916659355, -0.06125486269593239, -0.03734705224633217, 0.020815333351492882, 0.0028835542034357786, 0.01457793079316616, -0.03138088062405586, 0.08448329567909241, -0.012547369115054607, -0.01638881117105484, 0.03737267851829529, -0.00464895274490118, -0.006886935327202082, -0.0006702289683744311, 0.030024461448192596, 0.02834123559296131, 0.060206327587366104, -0.0072320569306612015, 0.013060040771961212, -0.022509833797812462, -0.007877293974161148, 0.028291922062635422, -0.04394279047846794, -0.07330471277236938, 0.0070913019590079784, -0.019694741815328598, 0.0427287295460701, -0.02926737442612648, -0.05156552419066429, -0.027473676949739456, 0.013656822964549065, -0.0022478047758340836, 0.025219783186912537, -0.016207324340939522, 0.05647101625800133, -0.03447442874312401, 0.05519356578588486, -0.01176524255424738, -0.03832464665174484, 0.12027508020401001, -0.02475794218480587, -0.0264675822108984, 0.007324695121496916, 0.00509131932631135, -0.015260674059391022, 0.02830880507826805, 0.043098289519548416, -0.0043143006041646, -0.018588580191135406, 0.016004404053092003, -0.005717295687645674, -0.02228187583386898, 0.012567136436700821, -0.004761545918881893, -0.02282710187137127, -0.04335620999336243, 0.04273133724927902, -0.03786357864737511, -0.025133276358246803, 0.015877630561590195, 0.0493679977953434, 0.0005881108809262514, 0.004206918179988861, -0.0018006890313699841, 0.015679696574807167, -0.010159567929804325, -0.018798092380166054, -0.028161494061350822, -0.08029720932245255, -0.04927936568856239, 0.03811727836728096, -0.022795138880610466, -0.021791357547044754, 0.04542728140950203, -0.048078931868076324, -0.012128565460443497, -0.006804804317653179, 0.06917346268892288, -0.0030197768937796354, 0.043297477066516876, -0.0026364154182374477, 0.07656972110271454, 0.043000902980566025, 0.04704804718494415, 0.0557347796857357, -0.07622503489255905, -0.021864768117666245, -0.013723289594054222, 0.05058563873171806, -0.007960114628076553, -0.040033016353845596, 0.039943352341651917, -0.009780660271644592, 0.062012191861867905, -0.03847646713256836, 0.010649599134922028, -0.006214042194187641, 0.010817506350576878, 0.06922333687543869, -0.06348483264446259, -0.02902139537036419, 0.003769591683521867, 0.005514993332326412, -0.046492088586091995, -0.01735551841557026, -0.02342800423502922, -0.011988505721092224, 0.03281800076365471, -0.028402023017406464, -0.015146084129810333, 0.001332052517682314, -0.06404886394739151, -0.00566706620156765, 0.013454742729663849, -0.015426232479512691, -0.0795741155743599, 0.014585147611796856, 0.03105030581355095, -0.046810973435640335, 0.009565089829266071, -0.052652690559625626, -0.06012123078107834, 0.05847179889678955, -0.016977060586214066, -0.0038974073249846697, 0.021123619750142097, 0.003488450078293681, 0.08607781678438187, 0.03602731600403786, -0.011719447560608387, -0.011918477714061737, 0.026554519310593605, 0.023668142035603523, 0.015207293443381786, -0.012312151491641998, -0.03505029156804085, -0.045706141740083694, -0.0013244241708889604, -0.042582135647535324, -0.006737556308507919, 0.018859129399061203, 0.046190984547138214, 0.0484953448176384, -0.0017558346735313535, 0.01505492813885212, -0.001731257769279182, -0.03004218265414238, -0.0416044257581234, -0.01984904333949089, 0.04693756625056267, -0.004943490028381348, 0.04463817924261093, -0.030697589740157127, -0.007948070764541626, -0.006700070109218359, -0.009294317103922367, 0.034765105694532394, 0.05361631512641907, -0.043847743421792984, 0.062401846051216125, 0.03267848864197731, 0.005478548351675272, -0.017111487686634064, 0.05327557399868965, -0.0661190003156662, -0.05090482905507088, -0.019261464476585388, 0.0018029597122222185, -0.02916840650141239, 0.04182105138897896, -0.023303627967834473, 0.04710069298744202, 0.00013932748697698116, -0.05639825388789177, 0.03219744563102722, 0.00802441593259573, 0.03755943104624748, 0.021877359598875046, 0.0336962454020977, 0.06004336476325989, 0.0006653791642747819, 0.036289531737565994, -0.018031252548098564, 0.01753239892423153, -0.044460758566856384, -0.0176366176456213, -0.02561965025961399, -0.01937362551689148, 0.015914907678961754, 0.005508344620466232, 0.04947919026017189, -0.07456248998641968, 0.04051182046532631, -0.06928840279579163, -0.04367101565003395, -0.0007719093118794262, -0.06823913753032684, 0.020487070083618164, 0.04238756746053696, -0.005065778736025095, 0.05548955872654915, -0.07673811167478561, -0.048245470970869064, 0.030415691435337067, 0.01865568570792675, -0.028158200904726982, 0.007898292504251003, -0.021168828010559082, -0.01877070590853691, -0.010360999964177608, -0.0288552176207304, 0.017470981925725937, 0.04649106040596962, 0.007332918234169483, -0.02088206075131893, 0.019424283877015114, -0.008350997231900692, -0.03273755684494972, -0.020179426297545433, 0.019109059125185013, 0.00772962998598814, 0.04559946432709694, -0.050813209265470505, -0.015907729044556618, -0.04518432170152664, 0.013125895522534847, 0.0927700623869896, -0.017827752977609634, -0.013319267891347408, 0.01728060282766819, -0.019048307090997696, 0.013719086535274982, -0.007590215653181076, 0.030349278822541237, -0.006678018253296614, 0.044231608510017395, 0.02697577327489853, 0.03651439771056175, 0.010130167007446289, -0.06193690001964569, 0.03948038071393967, -0.001268200110644102, -0.027334170415997505, 0.05115977302193642, 0.0481615848839283, 0.033521514385938644, 0.027136221528053284, -0.09217812865972519, 0.002299652900546789, -0.03211777284741402, 0.0009921722812578082, 0.004008011426776648, -0.042530544102191925, -0.050206080079078674, 0.12041832506656647, -0.02041160874068737, -0.0037816185504198074, 0.017573118209838867, 0.05296865105628967, 0.04776156321167946, -0.046072158962488174, 0.07076527178287506, 0.01919100619852543, -0.024936705827713013, 0.05311751738190651, -0.03960183635354042, -0.013229068368673325, -0.04886792600154877, 0.026730570942163467, 0.04753417521715164, 0.04381560534238815, 0.011279250495135784, 0.018412739038467407, -0.005169499199837446, -0.027710434049367905, -0.01952298730611801, 0.004194226581603289, -0.01664993353188038, 0.007106962148100138, -0.023626122623682022, -0.011271837167441845, -0.005853675771504641, -0.041757870465517044, -0.05449870973825455, -0.0034460658207535744, 0.01813664846122265, -0.07940705865621567, -0.03496148809790611, 0.01775779388844967, -0.02335151843726635, 0.028363998979330063, -0.0487777478992939, 0.014949778094887733, -0.006707703694701195, -0.0066452655009925365, -0.025683503597974777, 0.005417097359895706, -0.07659687846899033, 0.018032487481832504, -0.011793993413448334, 0.0034566354006528854, 0.0012799941468983889, 0.0640464723110199, -0.018063586205244064, -0.012656320817768574, -0.042821045964956284, 0.027582669630646706, -0.016817789524793625, -0.01539498008787632, 0.0031176467891782522, 0.014930457808077335, -0.018057219684123993, 0.037234555929899216, 0.041390787810087204, 0.01282447762787342, 0.010920064523816109, -0.010878464207053185, -0.04768715798854828, 0.004836528096348047, 0.010595361702144146, 0.0013359851436689496, 0.036190226674079895, -0.0936480164527893, 0.033878251910209656, -0.0309849064797163, 0.04808379337191582, -0.04474642127752304, -0.03022076189517975, 0.06639286875724792, 0.019232412800192833, 0.02911846525967121, -0.03351404517889023, 0.03765087574720383, 0.003231442766264081, -0.06626611948013306, -0.04119129851460457, -0.036673203110694885, -0.02419145405292511, 0.032216448336839676, 0.03304805979132652, 0.040704842656850815, 0.007639097981154919, 0.0200981292873621, -0.00876068789511919, -0.023831548169255257, 0.019591467455029488, -0.0700000748038292, 0.029636017978191376, -0.007216284051537514, -0.014679810032248497, 0.0174300204962492, 0.0343889519572258, 0.01627248525619507, -0.021194985136389732, -0.054777197539806366, -0.04499165341258049, -0.09002505987882614, -0.00010314817336620763, 0.01854582130908966, 0.04022859036922455, 0.03455973044037819, -0.00898571964353323, -0.050713006407022476, -0.0057412246242165565, -0.012014158070087433, -0.05004975572228432, -0.07609996199607849, -0.04984218627214432, -0.03360309079289436, -0.01186413038522005, -0.01243705116212368, 0.05162743851542473, 0.027120113372802734, -0.008675401099026203, -0.011987761594355106, -0.07459862530231476, -0.020615288987755775, -0.060998983681201935, -0.03768453001976013, 0.04395036771893501, -0.007355323527008295, 0.017120789736509323, -0.06662098318338394, 0.020915936678647995, -0.004633791744709015, -0.07439613342285156, 0.007650960236787796, 0.00018515301053412259, -0.015565982088446617, 0.0004669703193940222, 0.04723866283893585, 0.006202402990311384, -0.02595570497214794, -0.009172681719064713, 0.05958252772688866, 0.03128886967897415, -0.02029271051287651, 0.02337968721985817, 0.06750840693712234, 0.022323664277791977, -0.012773433700203896, -0.0002872658078558743, 0.05482122302055359, 0.024823429062962532, -0.0008543857838958502, 0.021167872473597527, -0.049071040004491806, -0.010796323418617249, -0.06470868736505508, -0.016010504215955734, 0.010448201559484005, 0.029404474422335625, 0.06973014026880264, 0.02554442547261715, -0.019527647644281387, -0.09516743570566177, -0.021381927654147148, 0.046745121479034424, 0.0046902010217309, 0.014808714389801025, -0.039696238934993744, -0.015271051786839962, -0.054658979177474976, -0.01921803131699562, 0.048057347536087036, -0.022308900952339172, 0.040839869529008865, 0.009410121478140354, -0.0166343804448843, -0.02748136594891548, -0.028190353885293007, 0.05061239376664162, 0.005245627835392952, 0.01777070388197899, -0.019398702308535576, -0.04967725649476051, 0.04258519411087036, -0.038348015397787094, -0.024582479149103165, -0.03008168563246727, -0.056405264884233475, -0.044163767248392105, 0.010921393521130085, 0.05548626929521561, -0.005229075439274311, -0.023798277601599693, -0.06461947411298752, -0.013443311676383018, -0.011322238482534885, -0.03576527163386345, -0.02118699811398983, -0.02256949059665203, 0.017487745732069016, 0.036364439874887466, 0.016934193670749664, 0.00508314510807395, 0.03360985592007637, 0.018452683463692665, 0.02375805377960205, 0.05991848185658455, 0.062285348773002625, 0.025499237701296806, 0.04128386825323105, -0.01968405395746231, 0.006572582293301821, -0.02906160242855549, -0.032586101442575455, 0.016545122489333153, 0.004055545199662447, -0.012463443912565708, 0.07515321671962738, -0.0653713196516037, -0.012444840744137764, 0.018931638449430466, -0.04795921966433525, 0.027860255911946297, 0.045945942401885986, -0.018802352249622345, -0.002358849160373211, 0.0012463968014344573, 0.05137156322598457, -0.03672598674893379, -0.0008206399506889284, 0.05612226575613022, 0.04175112769007683, -0.003038929309695959, -0.0016451622359454632, -0.06951247900724411, -0.019086042419075966, 0.01925284042954445, 0.05792274326086044, 0.020612137392163277, 0.0245874784886837, -0.00763627840206027, -0.07860850542783737, -0.07574402540922165, 0.0021457092370837927, 0.03992967680096626, 0.01770796813070774, -0.009418356232345104, 0.020311567932367325, 0.08495306223630905, -0.003934801090508699, -0.05810612440109253, 0.009698022156953812, 0.017224615439772606, 0.032580919563770294, -0.022758131846785545, 0.03697945550084114, 0.014491083100438118, 0.043482448905706406, 0.005769261624664068, -0.056013546884059906, 0.03025190159678459, 0.00862420629709959, -0.005526762921363115, 0.01592295616865158, 0.0323750302195549, -0.020738540217280388, -0.02261117473244667, -0.0478583499789238, 0.013268545269966125, -0.0633339136838913, 0.021984364837408066, -0.06969916075468063, 0.03252866864204407, 0.011566594243049622, -0.006019499618560076, -0.018769005313515663, 0.029352907091379166, -0.00853524636477232, -0.002175531815737486, -0.05072058364748955, 0.004523301497101784, 0.02945689484477043, -0.08505885303020477, -0.08505072444677353, -0.0018585724756121635, 0.05991731584072113, 0.05382591858506203, 0.01550072431564331, 0.004317580722272396, -0.050805460661649704, -0.012781850062310696, 0.039169054478406906, -0.006764040794223547, 0.008882051333785057, -0.05868535116314888, 0.009130093269050121, 0.028583556413650513, -0.031050879508256912, 0.015145809389650822, 0.0007499699713662267, 0.05328661948442459, -0.014015371911227703, -0.028330272063612938, 0.008548136800527573, 0.026230139657855034, 0.04630698636174202, 0.0689253956079483, -0.019407598301768303, 0.016910994425415993, 0.028568830341100693, -0.01658744364976883, 0.018571460619568825, -0.0004214735818095505, -0.02155643329024315, 0.004952970892190933, -0.03768700361251831, 0.06633229553699493, -0.044107675552368164, 0.017761901021003723, -0.04090218245983124, -0.013837046921253204, -0.0018910085782408714, -0.002238636137917638, 0.022853519767522812, 0.015055752359330654, -0.005909858737140894, 0.004293470177799463, -0.012098019942641258, -0.05720499902963638, 0.036968618631362915, -0.006969265174120665, 0.05616925284266472, -0.017730185762047768, -0.02170559950172901, -0.0011277294252067804, -0.006287985946983099, 0.016009986400604248, -0.07972374558448792, -0.007989121600985527, -0.016187716275453568, 0.04994918406009674, -0.0012470229994505644, -0.015803782269358635, 0.021723631769418716, 0.03254774212837219, 0.03353365510702133, 0.01856924407184124, -0.0011824677931144834, -0.0020005519036203623, 0.06038159132003784, -0.00943599734455347, -0.031076235696673393, -0.021455921232700348, 0.04344901815056801, -0.07641121000051498, -0.005473549943417311, 0.001090788864530623, -0.004489303100854158, -0.04182023927569389, -0.04944915324449539, 0.031052356585860252, -0.00727094104513526, -0.08764059096574783, 0.004495453089475632, 0.023692626506090164, 0.02412291243672371, -0.018272146582603455, 0.0009501246968284249, 0.0013038903707638383, 0.0009406906319782138, 0.08027144521474838, -0.006207739003002644, -0.06050833687186241, 0.021489426493644714, -0.05351174250245094, -0.0028773618396371603, -0.04548047482967377, -0.0048367176204919815, 0.011196425184607506, -0.0641840323805809, 0.03486434742808342, -0.04529193416237831, 0.0034588484559208155, 0.017580974847078323, 0.0032709864899516106, -0.054813969880342484, 0.0587182380259037, 0.01140677835792303, 0.0672060027718544, 0.030211208388209343, -0.042569100856781006, 0.06107907369732857, 0.0504642017185688, 0.04237841069698334, 0.017474234104156494, -0.011292824521660805, 0.03382847458124161, 0.0021841658744961023, -0.016804704442620277, -0.018672792240977287, -0.016207518056035042, -0.007101702969521284, -0.037014856934547424 ]
<p>I am a Physics undergraduate, so provide references with your responses.</p> <p>Landau &amp; Lifshitz write in page one of their mechanics textbook:</p> <blockquote> <p>If all the co-ordinates and velocities are simultaneously specified, it is known from experience that the state of the system is completely determined and that its subsequent motion can, in principle, be calculated. Mathematically this means that, if all the co-ordinates $q$ and $\dot{q}$ are given at some instant, the accelerations $\ddot{q}$ at that instant are uniquely defined.</p> </blockquote> <p>They justify this as being "known from experience", which is not entirely satisfactory. What is the basis for their assertion?</p> <p>Similar: <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/4102/why-are-only-derivatives-to-the-first-order-relevant">Why are only derivatives to the first order relevant?</a></p> <p>Is his question equivalent to mine, even though his solely refers to Lagrangian Mechanics?</p> <p>Furthermore, this might just indicate how mathematically crude my mind is, but why is it not sufficient simply to give the coordinates $q$, and determine $\dot{q}$ from that, i.e. if $q$ is given by some smooth function, can we not determine all further derivatives from that alone?</p>
g397
[ 0.07501759380102158, 0.04704470559954643, -0.008303885348141193, 0.010326776653528214, 0.07781870663166046, -0.031184004619717598, 0.05653727799654007, 0.024667493999004364, -0.005179199390113354, -0.023713959380984306, -0.033509429544210434, 0.003843888873234391, 0.04146299138665199, 0.06012954190373421, -0.05011636018753052, -0.012315924279391766, 0.03414144366979599, 0.005911529529839754, 0.006561716552823782, 0.0271062683314085, -0.018242450430989265, 0.00013429528917185962, -0.007411174010485411, -0.028459198772907257, 0.05713674798607826, -0.021224452182650566, 0.01995374821126461, -0.094610296189785, -0.05341753363609314, 0.008673152886331081, 0.010402536019682884, 0.005590204149484634, 0.022860245779156685, -0.09311888366937637, -0.02921333722770214, -0.011467642150819302, 0.07500382512807846, -0.034683357924222946, 0.021920431405305862, 0.012943534180521965, 0.02319679781794548, -0.07061024010181427, 0.0004966277629137039, -0.011025329120457172, -0.017084084451198578, 0.004578934982419014, -0.014327696524560452, -0.0036216850858181715, -0.002612882759422064, 0.03916265815496445, 0.00033418674138374627, 0.0644419938325882, 0.0324740968644619, -0.008002202026546001, -0.03428168222308159, 0.07475890219211578, 0.06257574260234833, 0.031107790768146515, 0.038651421666145325, -0.031521108001470566, -0.03603629767894745, -0.03790883719921112, 0.02676916867494583, -0.03206733986735344, 0.05788256227970123, -0.023680871352553368, -0.011001069098711014, 0.009542454034090042, 0.006426803767681122, 0.008256602101027966, 0.004574633203446865, -0.006532290019094944, 0.010981759987771511, -0.009524461813271046, 0.005496963392943144, 0.06170206516981125, 0.0442177914083004, 0.009760555811226368, 0.06201459467411041, 0.02880645915865898, -0.026729024946689606, -0.013105517253279686, 0.0735766738653183, 0.04145801439881325, 0.09488600492477417, 0.014933964237570763, 0.019029390066862106, -0.008584234863519669, 0.031384535133838654, 0.04007954150438309, -0.021766159683465958, 0.011291000060737133, 0.04652757942676544, 0.04552450403571129, -0.011804826557636261, -0.01881292834877968, -0.026401067152619362, 0.08591077476739883, 0.055222976952791214, 0.01813996210694313, -0.01567382924258709, 0.030239339917898178, -0.03545113652944565, -0.04846131429076195, -0.009884081780910492, -0.06507114320993423, 0.04139509052038193, -0.008828231133520603, 0.0349077470600605, -0.04673970863223076, -0.02167016826570034, 0.022555554285645485, -0.022841928526759148, 0.005159193649888039, -0.03408799320459366, 0.020247669890522957, 0.015228001400828362, 0.010327747091650963, -0.06529346108436584, 0.03389546275138855, -0.0761144608259201, 0.002704803366214037, 0.004566872958093882, 0.054439082741737366, 0.016747133806347847, 0.012779549695551395, 0.004293275531381369, -0.00009883695020107552, -0.01288796029984951, -0.018261421471834183, -0.008274005725979805, 0.05414099246263504, 0.0415680855512619, 0.039783839136362076, 0.002087380737066269, 0.012180994264781475, 0.03014373779296875, 0.02679469995200634, 0.005040997173637152, -0.004581736400723457, -0.011164125986397266, -0.018662013113498688, -0.05641219764947891, -0.023506751284003258, -0.0011373386951163411, 0.01138250157237053, -0.02796325646340847, 0.015097031369805336, 0.04114323854446411, 0.054284755140542984, -0.019177988171577454, 0.05329227074980736, -0.02923504263162613, 0.030822671949863434, 0.009750179015100002, -0.02145756594836712, 0.02286596968770027, -0.02186886966228485, -0.05719892308115959, 0.03151213377714157, 0.07627680152654648, 0.015283999964594841, -0.010744228027760983, 0.0036173881962895393, -0.03049500472843647, 0.02786029875278473, 0.006935463286936283, -0.07175545394420624, 0.05940358340740204, -0.029840560629963875, -0.05192861333489418, -0.017284203320741653, -0.011211132630705833, 0.03385409712791443, -0.01680796407163143, 0.04055541381239891, 0.0072827814146876335, -0.04748254269361496, 0.027170279994606972, 0.05038827657699585, -0.004887979477643967, -0.03571451082825661, 0.03673306107521057, -0.005735298153012991, -0.04020841419696808, 0.011162839829921722, -0.0244086142629385, 0.03648722544312477, -0.08909422904253006, 0.04030555114150047, 0.04136495292186737, -0.047513097524642944, -0.0338260680437088, 0.008177069015800953, -0.024263733997941017, -0.029163425788283348, -0.017141954973340034, 0.004816454369574785, -0.05183234438300133, 0.023252056911587715, -0.02528676949441433, 0.06189781799912453, 0.05851924419403076, 0.024404479190707207, 0.0061137480661273, 0.022337598726153374, -0.012767912819981575, -0.0533154159784317, 0.03607875108718872, -0.00136827421374619, 0.045624811202287674, -0.045232485979795456, 0.006152849178761244, 0.05584166571497917, 0.03672967851161957, -0.06743013113737106, 0.021690672263503075, 0.016190219670534134, 0.010232456959784031, -0.031242400407791138, -0.00431028101593256, -0.000132005283376202, 0.020960886031389236, 0.006780581083148718, -0.08015759289264679, -0.02355133928358555, -0.04113752022385597, -0.026752810925245285, -0.05760780721902847, 0.031239453703165054, -0.04180654510855675, -0.03658453747630119, 0.010395894758403301, 0.024727286770939827, 0.03826773911714554, 0.04688137769699097, -0.02327069640159607, -0.020928876474499702, 0.08039180189371109, 0.11163544654846191, 0.03419220820069313, -0.06669960170984268, 0.00954887643456459, 0.009866669774055481, -0.006134794093668461, -0.04720509424805641, 0.10217336565256119, 0.029855163767933846, 0.0007867598906159401, -0.004480648320168257, -0.010317450389266014, -0.06167205423116684, -0.016847562044858932, -0.04900549724698067, 0.040730901062488556, -0.023961028084158897, 0.03766213357448578, -0.009921235032379627, -0.037005215883255005, 0.00657500559464097, 0.009996294043958187, -0.0021859072148799896, 0.020200418308377266, 0.05514109134674072, -0.07002627104520798, -0.01614166609942913, 0.01354285329580307, -0.019046509638428688, -0.003109040902927518, -0.07055588066577911, -0.005757309030741453, 0.018270712345838547, -0.0016362132737413049, 0.08895837515592575, -0.01740635745227337, -0.0005594710819423199, -0.008682027459144592, -0.05632179602980614, -0.02812213823199272, 0.006714005954563618, -0.06148571893572807, -0.04010927677154541, -0.019129987806081772, 0.051051508635282516, -0.001370192039757967, -0.0393063984811306, 0.03652813285589218, -0.006112903822213411, -0.020129991695284843, -0.0027553103864192963, -0.06082239747047424, 0.05115427076816559, 0.005916898604482412, -0.00728449085727334, -0.06409446895122528, 0.0507812425494194, -0.05514014884829521, -0.03692612797021866, -0.01993487775325775, 0.05870557576417923, 0.03974829614162445, -0.03627628833055496, 0.04488068446516991, 0.04047471284866333, 0.0013033866416662931, 0.06609879434108734, -0.05080367252230644, 0.0014767796965315938, -0.009706007316708565, -0.014361034147441387, -0.02226836234331131, 0.023045044392347336, -0.019153205677866936, -0.03609232231974602, -0.04561898112297058, -0.03417303040623665, 0.03061845526099205, -0.010958652012050152, 0.025772925466299057, -0.038176991045475006, -0.06790193915367126, -0.004659539554268122, -0.012035385705530643, -0.016870535910129547, 0.0473015271127224, 0.041799772530794144, -0.038427822291851044, -0.0014572754735127091, 0.0027184917125850916, -0.01617220602929592, -0.000061190796259325, 0.019542556256055832, 0.055592164397239685, -0.0003774230135604739, -0.014636814594268799, -0.11501004546880722, -0.025088191032409668, 0.016844671219587326, 0.03467680886387825, -0.012356409803032875, -0.021760214120149612, -0.027334822341799736, -0.07420201599597931, 0.062320269644260406, 0.03734366595745087, -0.050384003669023514, 0.002453065710142255, 0.020024528726935387, 0.0009484835900366306, -0.011517795734107494, 0.01349846925586462, 0.0009974288986995816, 0.015524226240813732, 0.012048011645674706, -0.034844547510147095, 0.038456548005342484, 0.09771382063627243, 0.05930544063448906, -0.03193897753953934, 0.017419463023543358, -0.01944645680487156, -0.02511592209339142, -0.06403927505016327, 0.0221068374812603, 0.0683005079627037, 0.007742532063275576, -0.04967842251062393, 0.030660361051559448, -0.07104458659887314, -0.019448058679699898, 0.011372886598110199, -0.012574825435876846, 0.035806041210889816, -0.031408555805683136, 0.03788675740361214, -0.06829123198986053, 0.018707510083913803, 0.011247198097407818, -0.023751184344291687, -0.0026472867466509342, 0.02947859652340412, 0.06498221307992935, 0.023811733350157738, 0.012997597455978394, 0.005251500755548477, 0.03930336609482765, -0.08239927142858505, -0.0016092588193714619, -0.013206303119659424, -0.031651824712753296, 0.00830658059567213, -0.006728570442646742, -0.03648754209280014, 0.03246834874153137, 0.015766680240631104, -0.00021270141587592661, 0.07991189509630203, -0.00034446819336153567, 0.03847916051745415, 0.061061546206474304, -0.04450821876525879, -0.07015449553728104, -0.060667239129543304, -0.029002536088228226, 0.005810519214719534, 0.025921287015080452, 0.021451761946082115, -0.03944844752550125, 0.027535434812307358, 0.004650730639696121, -0.006178563926368952, -0.01739090122282505, 0.04218350723385811, -0.015861287713050842, 0.036660291254520416, 0.005505810491740704, -0.013408043421804905, -0.04949469864368439, 0.007082226220518351, -0.014949630945920944, 0.06621718406677246, 0.0007254215306602418, 0.021055592224001884, -0.05330510437488556, 0.052259527146816254, 0.058632999658584595, 0.04310974106192589, -0.009782187640666962, -0.0277186781167984, -0.016768917441368103, -0.017491474747657776, 0.001789737492799759, 0.007157210726290941, 0.030536718666553497, -0.034303341060876846, -0.0037641203962266445, -0.0009009178029373288, 0.10677400231361389, 0.0571117140352726, 0.08621740341186523, 0.003959964029490948, 0.012034245766699314, 0.0026647502090781927, -0.031503044068813324, -0.021787406876683235, 0.034179821610450745, 0.01325504295527935, -0.015186728909611702, 0.007453886792063713, -0.04157276451587677, -0.012543827295303345, 0.011530395597219467, -0.027818933129310608, -0.0006712330505251884, -0.005936362314969301, -0.023386206477880478, -0.012566590681672096, -0.01775941252708435, -0.004027724731713533, 0.03152870759367943, -0.02250814065337181, -0.0321502685546875, 0.02754388377070427, 0.0253454577177763, -0.004899417515844107, 0.05590304732322693, -0.048281531780958176, 0.031988561153411865, -0.10033790022134781, -0.018763381987810135, 0.044021494686603546, -0.008482478559017181, 0.013992627151310444, 0.019010106101632118, 0.03677830472588539, 0.01719258353114128, -0.00011251657997490838, 0.02114487625658512, 0.008574808947741985, 0.023442218080163002, -0.039322398602962494, -0.021286768838763237, 0.051443278789520264, -0.012794898822903633, -0.0015180585905909538, 0.005506344139575958, -0.011850970797240734, -0.026338282972574234, -0.000031241943361237645, -0.018871057778596878, 0.023051107302308083, 0.022307369858026505, 0.00793757475912571, 0.02202603965997696, -0.07904047518968582, -0.02038520574569702, 0.002827755641192198, -0.054501768201589584, -0.011273792944848537, 0.007188654970377684, -0.1121746078133583, 0.03543948754668236, 0.02319757454097271, -0.010429833084344864, 0.003943381831049919, 0.0341937281191349, 0.05113467201590538, -0.020664550364017487, -0.025367991998791695, -0.022220361977815628, 0.020372336730360985, 0.0946565568447113, 0.0022955455351620913, 0.008829301223158836, 0.0265593733638525, -0.04718281701207161, 0.014532913453876972, -0.012904088944196701, -0.04409269243478775, -0.06336110085248947, 0.04507111757993698, 0.039544858038425446, 0.06568870693445206, -0.06491050124168396, -0.012163353152573109, 0.003012174041941762, -0.06769123673439026, -0.012358203530311584, -0.043299879878759384, 0.06965386122465134, 0.031064040958881378, 0.025428228080272675, -0.03020089492201805, -0.031261131167411804, -0.015850739553570747, -0.008271882310509682, -0.023642035201191902, -0.03419935703277588, 0.0008169456268660724, -0.0012591701233759522, -0.09611961990594864, -0.046285003423690796, 0.009701209142804146, 0.022553585469722748, 0.00855996459722519, 0.02074967324733734, -0.0471603088080883, -0.0013381069293245673, 0.049408573657274246, -0.06008873134851456, -0.058619603514671326, 0.015307897701859474, -0.010675745084881783, -0.025838101282715797, -0.053492024540901184, 0.07072753459215164, -0.035989951342344284, -0.00221083452925086, -0.056781843304634094, -0.018656261265277863, 0.04299892485141754, -0.02369898371398449, 0.05539221689105034, -0.006899089086800814, -0.011829202994704247, 0.04869811609387398, 0.03227779269218445, 0.03811732679605484, 0.04794493317604065, 0.006820864509791136, 0.029489025473594666, -0.02967601642012596, -0.01633068174123764, -0.0008604394970461726, 0.060028817504644394, 0.008884038776159286, -0.03451168164610863, -0.026948828250169754, -0.011442677117884159, -0.010654713027179241, -0.04974570870399475, -0.014619185589253902, 0.023342113941907883, -0.06397341191768646, -0.01392148993909359, -0.0034702655393630266, -0.04610680416226387, -0.0044676801189780235, 0.0023722092155367136, 0.035384926944971085, 0.0010930168209597468, -0.013150915503501892, -0.05812518671154976, -0.08707073330879211, 0.017304467037320137, -0.009883302263915539, 0.0590740405023098, 0.01200019009411335, -0.03382084518671036, 0.014560268260538578, 0.014794680289924145, -0.003535918425768614, 0.009928246960043907, -0.02050391398370266, 0.017717372626066208, 0.04127975180745125, -0.00867266021668911, 0.056750502437353134, 0.029078833758831024, 0.023445874452590942, -0.0411088727414608, 0.006839551497250795, -0.022287802770733833, 0.009126911871135235, 0.014635944738984108, 0.020399965345859528, -0.033126648515462875, 0.054090797901153564, -0.02596704661846161, -0.05524052307009697, 0.0187658853828907, 0.006300765089690685, -0.057007767260074615, 0.02210620604455471, -0.002581236883997917, 0.01629524864256382, -0.014547393657267094, 0.022060170769691467, 0.03134184330701828, 0.004013502970337868, 0.031918805092573166, -0.00259447586722672, -0.026094289496541023, 0.040254417806863785, 0.02871902659535408, 0.03290785476565361, 0.00009091501851798967, 0.017859522253274918, 0.017904508858919144, 0.002421226818114519, 0.005717742256820202, 0.00373634765855968, 0.006693259347230196, 0.0069089108146727085, -0.043422453105449677, -0.03414779528975487, 0.037122584879398346, 0.04388734698295593, -0.07813522219657898, -0.01263301819562912, 0.030045177787542343, -0.007017321418970823, -0.03713841736316681, -0.004236376844346523, 0.011529258452355862, -0.012861491180956364, 0.019230686128139496, 0.01027466356754303, 0.01347887609153986, -0.01946733333170414, -0.05593312159180641, -0.039221037179231644, 0.03875178098678589, -0.013979236595332623, -0.033445168286561966, 0.003985103219747543, 0.011118745431303978, -0.034821588546037674, 0.01373380608856678, -0.03330732882022858, -0.0020596864633262157, -0.0816231444478035, 0.026783932000398636, 0.04479885473847389, 0.003802805207669735, 0.016072124242782593, -0.03336486592888832, 0.038558054715394974, 0.0012136508012190461, 0.029233943670988083, -0.05002525821328163, 0.050570305436849594, -0.013031703419983387, -0.01150127500295639, -0.02399606443941593, 0.06488162279129028, -0.017142079770565033, -0.046415701508522034, -0.0032736363355070353, -0.056545983999967575, -0.024855321273207664, 0.022723112255334854, 0.00481840968132019, -0.009328184649348259, -0.014092826284468174, -0.022647613659501076, 0.03817044198513031, 0.05589665099978447, -0.041058626025915146, 0.040804360061883926, 0.003081954549998045, -0.04135505482554436, -0.02457530051469803, 0.029108770191669464, 0.016139615327119827, -0.022635923698544502, 0.06529298424720764, -0.05104479938745499, -0.03542749583721161, 0.020171407610177994, 0.0024595328141003847, 0.00841506663709879, -0.029814237728714943, -0.023819362744688988, -0.028114059939980507, 0.017581218853592873, 0.02152596227824688, 0.015323285013437271, 0.004660784732550383, 0.018441690132021904, 0.030999451875686646, -0.016627904027700424, 0.004486850928515196, -0.05093439295887947, 0.01381922047585249, -0.039409637451171875, -0.057070668786764145, -0.01589900255203247, -0.026671383529901505, -0.021456468850374222, -0.006348891649395227, -0.033805377781391144, 0.019413989037275314, 0.05488639324903488, -0.049593035131692886, 0.010628802701830864, 0.015258390456438065, -0.02546248584985733, -0.03301738202571869, 0.054571736603975296, -0.025239376351237297, -0.017818020656704903, -0.03319363668560982, 0.005437728017568588, -0.028082430362701416, -0.035920046269893646, 0.012292508967220783, 0.023585937917232513, 0.02064598724246025, -0.0015533772530034184, -0.02636900171637535, -0.02253984473645687, -0.014337684027850628, 0.012780326418578625, -0.01505340076982975, -0.04389854148030281, -0.03657623007893562, 0.005667263176292181, 0.052401620894670486, 0.016346652060747147, -0.056246574968099594, -0.0038238277193158865, 0.04009661823511124, -0.03274624049663544, -0.01395644061267376, -0.0721578374505043, 0.02579313889145851, -0.03421097248792648 ]
<p>The Hubbard model reads $$H = -t \sum_{\langle ij \rangle, \sigma} c_{j\sigma}^\dagger c_{i\sigma} + U\sum_i n_{i\uparrow}n_{i\downarrow} $$</p> <p>In the large $U$ limit and at half-filling, the Hubbard model tranforms to $t$-$J$ model $$H = -t \sum_{\langle ij \rangle, \sigma} c_{j\sigma}^\dagger c_{i\sigma} + J\sum_{\langle ij \rangle}S_i\cdot S_j$$ where $J=4t^2/U$. Obviously, ground state favors anti-parallel spin configurations but it is not obvious to see whether it is the Neel state $(\uparrow\downarrow\uparrow\downarrow...) - (\downarrow\uparrow\downarrow\uparrow...)$ or the dimerized state $(\uparrow\downarrow)(\uparrow\downarrow)...$ where $(\uparrow\downarrow) = \uparrow\downarrow - \downarrow\uparrow$. Calculation shows, in 1-D, dimerized state has lower energy (I'm not very clear about the calculation.)</p> <p>It is also known that holon and doublon are not bounded in 1D (absence of Mott transition, Lieb-Wu's analytic result + VMC simulations). While in higher dimensions, Mott transitions do occur and dimerization is suppressed.</p> <p>It seems that the occurance of dimerization is correlated with the absence of Mott transition. So are there any pictures that show why Neel states lead to bounded doublon-holon?</p>
g9797
[ -0.04540152847766876, 0.043290264904499054, -0.012938965111970901, -0.027846427634358406, 0.028411341831088066, -0.00612872838973999, 0.07101164758205414, 0.04522239789366722, 0.05219594016671181, 0.020858723670244217, -0.03095555678009987, 0.012000154703855515, 0.03382372111082077, 0.008923704735934734, 0.006729263812303543, 0.002043290762230754, 0.03675078600645065, 0.034301090985536575, 0.01163590606302023, -0.05798104405403137, 0.01950714737176895, 0.021703632548451424, 0.025927361100912094, -0.09530355036258698, -0.024240750819444656, -0.002536185085773468, 0.04615404084324837, -0.07404521107673645, -0.0000933243936742656, 0.06000414490699768, 0.009553678333759308, -0.014851412735879421, 0.05289221927523613, -0.03654711693525314, -0.051733192056417465, -0.03930409625172615, 0.02980959787964821, 0.03287651389837265, -0.03054320253431797, 0.02440596930682659, -0.03136252611875534, -0.01848280429840088, 0.013076197355985641, -0.07250487804412842, -0.009035753086209297, 0.0029073518235236406, 0.044691383838653564, 0.06745641678571701, 0.007694695144891739, 0.026079589501023293, -0.019672757014632225, 0.07260318100452423, 0.04637614265084267, 0.006824176292866468, 0.010762584395706654, 0.040613796561956406, -0.035248950123786926, -0.027827709913253784, 0.053197234869003296, 0.008189021609723568, 0.015728479251265526, 0.024453070014715195, -0.052987515926361084, 0.057277143001556396, 0.0555538572371006, -0.013133895583450794, -0.031056534498929977, -0.02783745341002941, 0.06689127534627914, 0.04192046448588371, -0.019749661907553673, -0.03924618288874626, 0.0030269583221524954, -0.06490029394626617, -0.0574817880988121, 0.04749375581741333, -0.02002142369747162, -0.012472658418118954, 0.006653163116425276, -0.0135357566177845, -0.04923894628882408, -0.019080057740211487, 0.009759319014847279, -0.005029742140322924, 0.02820170484483242, -0.020066771656274796, -0.004334072582423687, 0.06779878586530685, -0.037517525255680084, 0.08977875113487244, 0.038832154124975204, -0.060552068054676056, -0.003254648530855775, -0.009189354255795479, 0.015875281766057014, -0.03586515784263611, 0.010204153135418892, 0.050192974507808685, -0.042169712483882904, -0.04262141138315201, -0.024498727172613144, 0.06056006997823715, 0.027671221643686295, -0.0020303046330809593, 0.0450676828622818, 0.09264085441827774, -0.004237390588968992, -0.01435977965593338, 0.015849443152546883, 0.0190152358263731, -0.07073654979467392, 0.006291219498962164, -0.0018951097736135125, -0.025265861302614212, -0.024565856903791428, 0.0042815483175218105, -0.013137293979525566, -0.05001310631632805, 0.0024184309877455235, 0.003061684314161539, 0.0467202253639698, -0.04500989243388176, -0.013036046177148819, 0.011810414493083954, -0.03556890785694122, 0.027665885165333748, -0.02949388138949871, 0.0028011684771627188, -0.021440278738737106, 0.0022338256239891052, -0.015102994628250599, 0.02676817588508129, -0.07220251858234406, 0.056372128427028656, 0.010258696973323822, -0.030154263600707054, -0.02707894891500473, 0.013610731810331345, 0.02216244675219059, 0.008325249888002872, 0.005962652619928122, -0.006367938593029976, -0.04614555835723877, -0.018502796068787575, -0.016095181927084923, 0.012109312228858471, 0.06862504780292511, -0.03700907528400421, 0.05255270376801491, 0.00908542238175869, 0.022775521501898766, 0.03736868500709534, 0.023589707911014557, -0.016751859337091446, -0.010060308501124382, 0.01990746147930622, 0.019182877615094185, -0.0038833741564303637, 0.0582430362701416, 0.003248184686526656, -0.047606151551008224, 0.009465668350458145, -0.055579233914613724, 0.022181808948516846, -0.03697577491402626, -0.036032672971487045, 0.0033124713227152824, -0.025323331356048584, 0.03623327612876892, -0.03869986906647682, -0.0278276726603508, 0.011250493116676807, -0.002574691316112876, -0.022767113521695137, 0.01792609877884388, 0.030071290209889412, -0.022111348807811737, -0.00925571657717228, 0.003313765162602067, 0.015191556885838509, 0.022049343213438988, 0.0062857381999492645, 0.03505018725991249, 0.04996098205447197, 0.031573519110679626, -0.04306061193346977, 0.012712079100310802, 0.048109039664268494, 0.014970388263463974, 0.020621897652745247, 0.009956955909729004, 0.00838552974164486, -0.00040713741327635944, -0.017549851909279823, -0.009116342291235924, 0.008765319362282753, 0.06605137884616852, -0.03925657272338867, -0.04020272567868233, -0.025964995846152306, -0.004125654697418213, -0.01925751008093357, 0.05320814996957779, 0.013051226735115051, -0.03546861186623573, 0.029928673058748245, 0.0022399898152798414, 0.010488901287317276, 0.0937899649143219, -0.005204149056226015, 0.034420039504766464, -0.030968016013503075, -0.01380393747240305, 0.004968203604221344, 0.005421034060418606, 0.03359346464276314, 0.01841805689036846, -0.0009620037162676454, 0.011816821992397308, 0.027060125023126602, -0.0221809521317482, -0.05864711478352547, 0.06239644065499306, 0.013018463738262653, 0.016154639422893524, 0.015582883730530739, 0.029971079900860786, 0.0040046279318630695, -0.03073742240667343, 0.030057530850172043, -0.0883944034576416, 0.0025525756645947695, -0.033711597323417664, -0.05777795985341072, 0.02948291227221489, 0.02177395485341549, 0.016005348414182663, -0.007939432747662067, -0.05048520863056183, -0.04027160257101059, -0.048139069229364395, -0.007247482426464558, -0.023218609392642975, 0.04653428867459297, 0.04366978630423546, 0.010814656503498554, -0.002506497548893094, -0.006371566094458103, -0.043636396527290344, -0.003433166304603219, 0.031095100566744804, -0.008085203357040882, -0.002527076518163085, -0.06679188460111618, -0.008659346960484982, -0.002974821487441659, 0.010125964879989624, 0.005515333265066147, -0.029413867741823196, -0.0060141123831272125, -0.060647860169410706, -0.03002970851957798, -0.0029958016239106655, 0.0008547446341253817, -0.028069013729691505, -0.051530081778764725, 0.049087803810834885, -0.05575697124004364, 0.010999179445207119, 0.07022400200366974, -0.010038044303655624, 0.08369945734739304, -0.016668910160660744, -0.015690576285123825, -0.05036819726228714, 0.03957560658454895, 0.03404920548200607, -0.02582279033958912, -0.01914265938103199, 0.010651946067810059, -0.03733305260539055, -0.010130726732313633, -0.02547818422317505, -0.02286405675113201, 0.04155644774436951, -0.014792333357036114, -0.03049652650952339, -0.0050483206287026405, -0.029996570199728012, 0.037253253161907196, -0.05907997116446495, 0.021905530244112015, 0.02544317953288555, 0.02204560674726963, 0.042034812271595, -0.004750375635921955, -0.01298022922128439, 0.017801564186811447, -0.04255234822630882, 0.06273245066404343, -0.016214173287153244, -0.01748100481927395, -0.0234216321259737, 0.010386152192950249, -0.03365781903266907, -0.04737337306141853, -0.05187474936246872, -0.005420451518148184, -0.0580412894487381, -0.0411134697496891, -0.004739356227219105, 0.051206450909376144, -0.041818249970674515, -0.05638919770717621, 0.01479003019630909, -0.02609792724251747, -0.02921900898218155, 0.009713232517242432, 0.014922307804226875, -0.056991904973983765, -0.017156526446342468, 0.006528619676828384, -0.02752269059419632, -0.025624189525842667, 0.0019379234872758389, 0.00504918210208416, -0.06808877736330032, -0.013280769810080528, -0.06470810621976852, -0.04340323805809021, 0.0794021487236023, -0.04209045693278313, 0.07786725461483002, -0.008190995082259178, -0.07686764001846313, -0.04668423905968666, -0.04611038416624069, 0.017523840069770813, 0.022066116333007812, -0.0030459240078926086, -0.04802808538079262, -0.02204587124288082, -0.018565773963928223, 0.05393445864319801, 0.04214233160018921, 0.011317877098917961, -0.06058955192565918, -0.011890695430338383, 0.04490269348025322, 0.023404186591506004, 0.0353628471493721, 0.0413205660879612, -0.01538128312677145, -0.016261016950011253, -0.003883126424625516, 0.015048316679894924, -0.002355508040636778, 0.033389486372470856, -0.006447568070143461, -0.022470053285360336, -0.012874141335487366, -0.02546675130724907, 0.017840132117271423, 0.029046306386590004, -0.02025645785033703, 0.00762161985039711, 0.04446284472942352, -0.0009044739999808371, 0.07034950703382492, 0.005074568558484316, 0.012468788772821426, -0.025929821655154228, 0.015461048111319542, 0.061626918613910675, 0.024745557457208633, -0.013035369105637074, -0.055663809180259705, 0.02696956694126129, 0.0419754758477211, -0.02051250822842121, -0.008285271003842354, -0.026011332869529724, 0.005698009859770536, 0.012829383835196495, 0.010061698965728283, -0.024525629356503487, -0.010878164321184158, -0.008031204342842102, 0.0013746406184509397, -0.0062247831374406815, 0.02374182641506195, -0.029662994667887688, 0.04908604547381401, -0.00669066933915019, 0.0838744044303894, 0.00005631832391372882, 0.001839618431404233, -0.06173751503229141, -0.058861471712589264, -0.030127571895718575, -0.022450340911746025, -0.03570851683616638, -0.06972738355398178, -0.07312127202749252, -0.0953264907002449, -0.02285962551832199, -0.05800218880176544, 0.05912080407142639, 0.006693381816148758, -0.013497085310518742, -0.017568504437804222, 0.0658130943775177, -0.017423521727323532, -0.03225966542959213, 0.03857536241412163, -0.05100083723664284, -0.00606026966124773, -0.0320756733417511, -0.014578035101294518, 0.022471953183412552, 0.015084926038980484, 0.05671597644686699, -0.05683445557951927, 0.04460446164011955, 0.055069323629140854, 0.016300002112984657, -0.03294939547777176, 0.053644437342882156, -0.029345523566007614, -0.007811770308762789, 0.008033518679440022, -0.023023588582873344, -0.030032513663172722, -0.0157061405479908, -0.08526603877544403, 0.028155053034424782, -0.059935253113508224, 0.026435939595103264, -0.0598980188369751, 0.05995699390769005, 0.012336352840065956, 0.03404177352786064, 0.06398099660873413, 0.044263433665037155, 0.007980123162269592, -0.003310967003926635, -0.050097424536943436, -0.03662491962313652, -0.005600789096206427, -0.03753937408328056, -0.016479171812534332, -0.004975584801286459, -0.03743130713701248, -0.006968448404222727, 0.055070601403713226, 0.015823351219296455, -0.022553252056241035, 0.057063281536102295, 0.008624625392258167, 0.06807718425989151, -0.04808417335152626, -0.032375726848840714, -0.0031831965316087008, -0.006936678197234869, -0.004264787770807743, 0.006506415084004402, -0.04090485721826553, 0.044378988444805145, -0.029773835092782974, 0.012806657701730728, 0.03257852420210838, 0.044461689889431, 0.07353316247463226, -0.04751698300242424, 0.0076927486807107925, 0.020189078524708748, -0.024118473753333092, -0.0403173454105854, -0.03762661665678024, 0.013985683210194111, 0.02014290727674961, -0.017430780455470085, 0.0695338249206543, 0.05380045622587204, 0.007948844693601131, 0.05536708980798721, 0.01978386752307415, 0.004563761875033379, -0.024744562804698944, -0.04815156012773514, 0.007048866245895624, 0.05004281550645828, -0.06620000302791595, 0.03478192538022995, 0.005668151192367077, 0.06405647099018097, -0.023257195949554443, 0.014751311391592026, 0.006314472761005163, 0.0345318540930748, -0.03345958888530731, 0.0016948679694905877, -0.026381351053714752, -0.004170827567577362, 0.03646262362599373, 0.06003212183713913, 0.0731925293803215, 0.016557855531573296, 0.012780643068253994, -0.007191706448793411, -0.05890941619873047, -0.04400389641523361, 0.01948760449886322, 0.0007737172418273985, 0.042183030396699905, 0.0000998329051071778, 0.0017536869272589684, 0.027143899351358414, -0.0062748705968260765, -0.033422086387872696, -0.015689007937908173, -0.023800591006875038, 0.005817622411996126, -0.015664007514715195, 0.0616009421646595, 0.0001282150042243302, 0.07355193793773651, -0.007520453073084354, -0.012570486404001713, 0.06298065930604935, 0.04071085527539253, -0.00841855350881815, 0.026598474010825157, 0.06003629043698311, 0.04152093082666397, -0.01769712008535862, 0.02935696579515934, 0.05396502837538719, 0.019365357235074043, 0.052753549069166183, 0.06003676727414131, -0.029165659099817276, -0.0642886608839035, 0.04776647686958313, -0.07186982780694962, -0.010797068476676941, 0.0068888356909155846, -0.02188158966600895, 0.002440215088427067, -0.007450542412698269, -0.015272285789251328, -0.005479114595800638, -0.024400053545832634, -0.03233892843127251, -0.00842287577688694, -0.03729695826768875, 0.08459195494651794, -0.02572348527610302, -0.0600086934864521, 0.0364016517996788, -0.011397973634302616, 0.00043949062819592655, 0.05263541266322136, 0.09221742302179337, -0.008411219343543053, 0.009360743686556816, -0.030697057023644447, -0.04264098405838013, 0.028867578133940697, -0.05672323703765869, 0.0576590895652771, -0.021442878991365433, -0.014303578995168209, 0.03711831569671631, 0.02242634817957878, 0.0005235536955296993, -0.014593386091291904, -0.057777587324380875, -0.015308002941310406, 0.018074899911880493, -0.033648282289505005, 0.0032046528067439795, 0.032299451529979706, 0.05412452667951584, 0.02928762137889862, 0.012795514427125454, -0.05204814299941063, -0.013827328570187092, 0.013456961140036583, 0.038047682493925095, -0.09417375177145004, -0.02269822731614113, -0.008068601600825787, 0.053358450531959534, 0.03361304849386215, 0.011502176523208618, -0.059253569692373276, 0.027616506442427635, -0.08858397603034973, -0.05139246955513954, 0.045276541262865067, 0.006747338455170393, 0.03915340453386307, -0.005165410693734884, 0.019029758870601654, 0.07702922821044922, -0.044853564351797104, 0.0033743747044354677, 0.0034297334495931864, 0.03585636615753174, 0.03023485839366913, 0.007815681397914886, -0.00024265718820970505, 0.002962061669677496, 0.0019246807787567377, -0.09760241955518723, -0.008810007944703102, 0.043617475777864456, -0.04945102706551552, 0.056729041039943695, 0.013565028086304665, -0.01783645711839199, -0.014979640953242779, -0.03356141224503517, -0.014465661719441414, 0.09715213626623154, -0.019587712362408638, -0.016184305772185326, -0.012529081664979458, -0.0187075175344944, -0.0044187926687300205, 0.005461563356220722, -0.03660501539707184, -0.014729402959346771, 0.012677940540015697, 0.008912851102650166, -0.05285731703042984, 0.0012377662351354957, 0.004690404981374741, 0.0785021260380745, -0.01624315418303013, 0.017438670620322227, 0.08053303509950638, 0.015920599922537804, -0.008523914031684399, 0.028679270297288895, 0.011692814528942108, 0.0004262184083927423, 0.0453670360147953, -0.026669085025787354, 0.019393697381019592, -0.00503964489325881, -0.01825208030641079, 0.013102365657687187, -0.02843478135764599, 0.03152204304933548, 0.029304424300789833, -0.02184101566672325, -0.029837511479854584, -0.019617551937699318, 0.0036818201187998056, -0.03885011747479439, -0.07202411442995071, 0.011653208173811436, -0.020308613777160645, 0.0017897605430334806, 0.030024314299225807, -0.0008025884162634611, 0.04562868922948837, -0.03293111175298691, -0.0509382039308548, -0.02936386875808239, -0.03384833782911301, 0.010277208872139454, 0.010556944645941257, -0.010103845037519932, 0.013002818450331688, 0.00686034606769681, 0.009942074306309223, -0.05881146341562271, -0.04873194918036461, 0.04288762807846069, 0.0560319609940052, 0.002351845847442746, 0.008793557062745094, -0.012748743407428265, -0.04125173017382622, 0.039219241589307785, -0.023582635447382927, -0.00035896257031708956, 0.017989935353398323, 0.01509922742843628, 0.017958039417862892, -0.011673853732645512, -0.03252600505948067, 0.017890596762299538, 0.004700993187725544, -0.035965122282505035, -0.029291432350873947, 0.028467636555433273, 0.029365869238972664, -0.0602455772459507, -0.01931261643767357, -0.003266312647610903, 0.0022604172118008137, 0.021566828712821007, 0.029620174318552017, 0.009094181470572948, 0.028033195063471794, -0.03270566835999489, 0.03897477313876152, 0.03328472003340721, -0.04537862166762352, -0.0016757078701630235, 0.0008470839820802212, -0.06831292062997818, -0.03551148995757103, -0.07462108880281448, 0.07377780228853226, -0.017040075734257698, -0.004214247222989798, -0.003879948752000928, 0.04402677342295647, -0.0010498207993805408, -0.020201191306114197, -0.06189248338341713, 0.017216980457305908, 0.04112861678004265, -0.011523935943841934, 0.0728238895535469, -0.059752628207206726, 0.036860957741737366, -0.06571412831544876, -0.04457300156354904, -0.028453590348362923, 0.025643901899456978, -0.010664932429790497, -0.02501801960170269, -0.02195219323039055, 0.006634617689996958, -0.0937223881483078, 0.006821171846240759, 0.07549864053726196, -0.021590005606412888, -0.008868880569934845, 0.007665607146918774, -0.017579058185219765, -0.0021732940804213285, -0.0062652286142110825, 0.048734117299318314, 0.055971283465623856, 0.03381740301847458, 0.02539140358567238, -0.021621424704790115, 0.03333570063114166, 0.00474292179569602, 0.022863226011395454, 0.028183821588754654, 0.02902798540890217, 0.0029180613346397877, 0.009073449298739433, -0.05995793640613556, 0.0284733809530735, 0.003263351507484913, -0.025700643658638, 0.014834847301244736, -0.04745245724916458, -0.0018861372955143452 ]
<p>If I now see the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schr%C3%B6dinger_equation" rel="nofollow">Schrödinger equation</a>, I just see a bunch of weird symbols, but I want to know what it actually means. So I'm taking a course of Linear Algebra and I'm planning on starting with PDE's next month. What 'other math' is needed other than Linear Algebra and (Partial) Differential Equations to gain a full understanding of this equation?</p>
g9798
[ -0.007056212052702904, 0.016017448157072067, -0.022410515695810318, 0.010526035912334919, 0.04067007452249527, -0.0013493831502273679, 0.03172006830573082, 0.06153220683336258, 0.007407268974930048, -0.03756922483444214, -0.0497894249856472, 0.03495277836918831, 0.06731915473937988, 0.004084745422005653, -0.007306213956326246, -0.0046753971837460995, 0.03149041533470154, -0.028173720464110374, -0.022499073296785355, 0.006780494935810566, -0.04271563142538071, 0.08212128281593323, 0.004716631956398487, -0.02493232861161232, 0.0012343962443992496, -0.02869117632508278, -0.013094237074255943, -0.053237635642290115, -0.06218988448381424, -0.05012466758489609, -0.004300507251173258, 0.004587923176586628, 0.04192366451025009, -0.018694527447223663, 0.02295248582959175, -0.02335047721862793, 0.05816170573234558, 0.05381188914179802, 0.05522353947162628, 0.01991329714655876, 0.012422271072864532, 0.021091278642416, -0.0208156555891037, -0.029557187110185623, 0.014876257628202438, -0.006863299757242203, -0.03589063137769699, -0.03354610875248909, 0.047856926918029785, 0.015879712998867035, 0.036447376012802124, 0.008790711872279644, 0.04561368003487587, -0.014893956482410431, -0.014812976121902466, 0.06622093170881271, 0.026010900735855103, -0.016535142436623573, 0.0628344863653183, 0.011053100228309631, -0.005344591103494167, -0.01162694115191698, -0.017776302993297577, 0.0348912812769413, 0.0028803241439163685, -0.0006196991889737546, 0.01086915098130703, -0.04362637922167778, -0.041909780353307724, 0.01321617141366005, 0.05860840529203415, -0.0236786101013422, 0.003317388938739896, -0.02775556407868862, 0.013027210719883442, -0.011911574751138687, 0.015043184161186218, -0.049806829541921616, 0.10513439029455185, 0.02962961606681347, -0.05647377669811249, 0.028608426451683044, 0.02845911495387554, -0.005824535619467497, 0.04961685463786125, 0.04629020765423775, -0.0662510022521019, -0.052981726825237274, 0.005230383947491646, 0.010388622991740704, -0.006631854455918074, 0.04607992619276047, -0.02487124875187874, -0.04603525623679161, 0.04834015294909477, -0.011712978594005108, -0.05273467302322388, 0.05688931792974472, 0.03240317106246948, -0.02003290317952633, -0.08255165815353394, 0.0029990337789058685, 0.020071301609277725, -0.03778574988245964, 0.06756669282913208, 0.0015305692795664072, -0.009227615781128407, 0.03779333829879761, 0.00004228112084092572, -0.014574488624930382, -0.05505231395363808, 0.030144354328513145, -0.04496370255947113, 0.013086395338177681, 0.0030899913981556892, -0.06177970767021179, -0.036330778151750565, -0.002468154765665531, 0.020944349467754364, 0.05057306960225105, 0.017344893887639046, -0.001052197301760316, 0.08898291736841202, 0.05235886573791504, -0.022932829335331917, 0.030996523797512054, 0.04563819244503975, -0.07079784572124481, 0.022592242807149887, -0.037036795169115067, 0.04373506084084511, -0.03002011403441429, -0.006679981015622616, 0.0051092845387756824, -0.005557224154472351, 0.06629585474729538, -0.011771595105528831, 0.022236280143260956, 0.008587758988142014, 0.02303590439260006, 0.010103540495038033, -0.03846250846982002, 0.011875090189278126, -0.008998441509902477, 0.006464493926614523, -0.049084294587373734, -0.042706333100795746, -0.0036773832980543375, 0.008487597107887268, -0.01892843283712864, -0.04059148207306862, 0.059077002108097076, 0.01353225577622652, -0.07351909577846527, 0.007181332912296057, -0.005018454510718584, 0.008057563565671444, -0.05271514132618904, 0.014207231812179089, 0.014622029848396778, 0.0973585695028305, -0.06080044433474541, 0.019779032096266747, 0.07520347088575363, -0.09682982414960861, 0.01498963963240385, 0.003443017601966858, -0.049581047147512436, -0.01666445843875408, -0.036369092762470245, 0.003149825381115079, -0.0056716143153607845, 0.014775357209146023, -0.0047799670137465, -0.032952290028333664, 0.08078812807798386, 0.005655589513480663, 0.01582719385623932, 0.04227365180850029, 0.043394818902015686, 0.01259523630142212, 0.009393208660185337, 0.08716106414794922, -0.010610484518110752, -0.02664741687476635, 0.012696952559053898, -0.09357047080993652, 0.061665575951337814, -0.02796182595193386, 0.049273259937763214, -0.014098751358687878, 0.0028195686172693968, -0.00901133194565773, 0.05885870382189751, 0.018494268879294395, 0.04188670217990875, -0.07067150622606277, -0.032944757491350174, -0.03188977763056755, -0.018572773784399033, 0.00805900152772665, -0.012944091111421585, 0.040888819843530655, 0.010748215019702911, 0.027514217421412468, -0.028481140732765198, -0.018309583887457848, -0.044063422828912735, 0.019435051828622818, -0.018125956878066063, 0.03404402732849121, -0.0778103917837143, 0.02400650642812252, 0.030815735459327698, -0.019221683964133263, 0.0046034869737923145, -0.011032912880182266, -0.030265606939792633, -0.05786383897066116, 0.038345735520124435, -0.009365268051624298, -0.033459730446338654, -0.026083340868353844, -0.018208099529147148, 0.030606558546423912, 0.09262153506278992, -0.03608065843582153, -0.054488200694322586, -0.023514574393630028, 0.04613616317510605, 0.008785978890955448, -0.05733632296323776, -0.04076235368847847, -0.020230837166309357, 0.07837403565645218, 0.059939876198768616, 0.028315935283899307, -0.04356813430786133, 0.002995385555550456, 0.07375862449407578, 0.03927236050367355, 0.013227892108261585, 0.018291402608156204, 0.034236520528793335, 0.0380995087325573, 0.03898362070322037, 0.02671399526298046, -0.01811118982732296, -0.02829335257411003, -0.03904285281896591, -0.02112683281302452, -0.0733158215880394, 0.040992263704538345, 0.026955902576446533, 0.008705290965735912, 0.01823449321091175, -0.014211717993021011, -0.01497875526547432, -0.03343137726187706, 0.03700198605656624, 0.005946403369307518, 0.04450726509094238, -0.041370924562215805, 0.03167160227894783, -0.08139428496360779, -0.03911278769373894, -0.06677212566137314, 0.022355888038873672, 0.02813320979475975, -0.01803358644247055, -0.03586025908589363, -0.00825916975736618, -0.012092766351997852, -0.05223754793405533, -0.04918554797768593, -0.029555926099419594, -0.009857095777988434, -0.0019091914873570204, 0.012815482914447784, -0.02737518399953842, 0.01037435419857502, 0.03886854276061058, 0.0025941734202206135, 0.05786437541246414, 0.021490411832928658, -0.012559737078845501, 0.06217503920197487, 0.048311010003089905, -0.04114677011966705, -0.02779906429350376, -0.05968857184052467, -0.004021017346531153, -0.03117581270635128, -0.020973490551114082, -0.0543958842754364, -0.023275168612599373, 0.016448430716991425, 0.03402723744511604, 0.006591480690985918, 0.04657547175884247, -0.03552040457725525, -0.020859625190496445, 0.009887320920825005, -0.02229597419500351, 0.016388408839702606, 0.011723627336323261, 0.0015582498162984848, -0.0583006925880909, 0.029421458020806313, 0.02184302546083927, -0.006987992208451033, -0.002227579476311803, -0.001256595249287784, -0.015197288244962692, 0.04160857945680618, 0.0073862224817276, -0.0556788295507431, 0.03831230476498604, 0.05132805183529854, -0.01934497058391571, -0.025135941803455353, -0.09404170513153076, -0.04047973453998566, -0.032767340540885925, 0.021402033045887947, -0.008174839429557323, -0.010347308591008186, 0.026026882231235504, -0.01503760926425457, -0.03076290898025036, 0.019397195428609848, -0.023389291018247604, -0.02333393134176731, -0.007542777806520462, -0.004912912379950285, -0.04078732803463936, -0.01937953382730484, -0.007054487243294716, 0.018839851021766663, -0.04825836047530174, 0.04509671404957771, -0.02992670051753521, -0.016909224912524223, 0.021413695067167282, -0.018299954012036324, -0.05440415441989899, -0.023760685697197914, 0.01100149005651474, 0.0032089620362967253, -0.051888905465602875, 0.032209765166044235, -0.02961641736328602, -0.012086424045264721, -0.054865315556526184, -0.005018798168748617, -0.012734503485262394, 0.029167093336582184, -0.01468411460518837, -0.033143024891614914, 0.01392307598143816, -0.024977130815386772, -0.03740540146827698, -0.019512146711349487, 0.08641047775745392, 0.009714034385979176, -0.006694236770272255, -0.034546349197626114, 0.00954329315572977, -0.031010065227746964, -0.05737121403217316, -0.01727910339832306, -0.01998194120824337, 0.004535680171102285, 0.038487713783979416, -0.022909151390194893, -0.02219373732805252, -0.01288992166519165, 0.006413118913769722, -0.002455043373629451, 0.01707323081791401, -0.03823668137192726, 0.023980632424354553, 0.02563498169183731, 0.0014317038003355265, 0.01100930292159319, -0.0007386882207356393, -0.007266887929290533, 0.013055241666734219, 0.025782519951462746, 0.0048271045088768005, 0.05324292927980423, -0.004938642494380474, -0.06690885871648788, 0.025432663038372993, -0.005958447232842445, 0.013573708944022655, -0.006802751217037439, 0.0039550731889903545, -0.03613689914345741, 0.027516307309269905, -0.04130786657333374, 0.009541160427033901, 0.046295393258333206, 0.009310147725045681, -0.008814584463834763, -0.014414610341191292, 0.04621150344610214, -0.022006699815392494, -0.00972886011004448, -0.0007163884001784027, -0.05744769051671028, -0.02763434313237667, -0.021914511919021606, -0.005650653038173914, 0.0201624296605587, 0.007648829370737076, 0.026502851396799088, -0.07998450100421906, -0.01291942410171032, 0.01267339289188385, 0.062186889350414276, -0.043125227093696594, -0.06075764819979668, -0.04757862538099289, -0.028399240225553513, -0.016484547406435013, 0.014233840629458427, 0.0443999208509922, -0.0838688313961029, -0.025527067482471466, 0.015119613148272038, 0.009680422954261303, 0.0034759026020765305, 0.04751688241958618, -0.059085506945848465, 0.026734502986073494, -0.035711802542209625, 0.08535879850387573, -0.08167272806167603, 0.011806584894657135, 0.057656075805425644, 0.013491463847458363, 0.008287081494927406, -0.03663918003439903, -0.003414006205275655, 0.0036396998912096024, -0.014243443496525288, -0.015724342316389084, -0.039400577545166016, -0.004252586513757706, -0.023038988932967186, 0.0753692090511322, 0.0008339421474374831, -0.01185748353600502, 0.040808990597724915, 0.01146697998046875, 0.003539863508194685, -0.019372450187802315, -0.011750183999538422, 0.05370992794632912, -0.05311910808086395, -0.014983490109443665, 0.02175622247159481, -0.01913635991513729, 0.038358211517333984, -0.03608601167798042, 0.01777523197233677, -0.025704387575387955, 0.007448605261743069, -0.04171999543905258, -0.003606595331802964, -0.0049977414309978485, 0.028939135372638702, -0.023936133831739426, 0.02192162536084652, -0.0569317564368248, -0.01783391460776329, -0.026601161807775497, -0.02339412085711956, -0.008268396370112896, 0.023534530773758888, 0.04241228848695755, 0.039551496505737305, 0.03597605973482132, 0.0021645938977599144, 0.0426548570394516, -0.017280282452702522, 0.03777520731091499, -0.0029549747705459595, 0.024970857426524162, 0.009441179223358631, 0.03982411324977875, -0.011533567681908607, -0.003934918437153101, -0.05716313421726227, -0.0038245131727308035, 0.06265836209058762, -0.03240334615111351, 0.03596906736493111, 0.025613581761717796, -0.04726790264248848, 0.04636998102068901, 0.017217300832271576, -0.026506396010518074, 0.029367994517087936, 0.029310375452041626, 0.041517507284879684, -0.037205375730991364, 0.017023060470819473, -0.006662275642156601, 0.025062834843993187, -0.05266707018017769, -0.024280058220028877, 0.019629759714007378, -0.008574354462325573, 0.005098660942167044, -0.015111640095710754, 0.0232646893709898, -0.018313728272914886, 0.016154980286955833, 0.015491493977606297, 0.021358637139201164, 0.006251489743590355, -0.025232801213860512, -0.015014084056019783, -0.035117462277412415, -0.048707541078329086, -0.016999348998069763, 0.00995688233524561, 0.05095980688929558, -0.019356975331902504, 0.050235867500305176, 0.05912023037672043, 0.03223332390189171, 0.06551561504602432, -0.03547937050461769, 0.018876569345593452, -0.0208787452429533, 0.05832522362470627, 0.022121049463748932, -0.02353879064321518, 0.04275553300976753, -0.024782666936516762, 0.08582178503274918, -0.045940689742565155, -0.0563131608068943, 0.030827002599835396, 0.07572724670171738, 0.009759817272424698, -0.038274187594652176, 0.006370959337800741, -0.04913413152098656, 0.03166041523218155, -0.01211321260780096, 0.022272847592830658, -0.02753070928156376, 0.00810855720192194, -0.03212856128811836, -0.034718651324510574, -0.04251125827431679, 0.020446695387363434, 0.009703736752271652, -0.044356461614370346, -0.0008713433635421097, -0.007460686378180981, -0.008747958578169346, -0.03755040839314461, 0.001839983044192195, 0.11508559435606003, 0.03588724136352539, -0.0158726517111063, -0.01971488818526268, -0.05550682917237282, 0.022373106330633163, 0.024730516597628593, -0.00015711275045759976, -0.0158764086663723, -0.022178538143634796, 0.002215357031673193, 0.003290459979325533, -0.03500700369477272, -0.015318614430725574, 0.06395747512578964, -0.05001801624894142, 0.000832141493447125, 0.017774321138858795, -0.005462269298732281, -0.026297228410840034, 0.023014478385448456, 0.059957440942525864, -0.008559336885809898, 0.032710421830415726, -0.000706168357282877, 0.016225408762693405, 0.005425501149147749, -0.07352486997842789, 0.051659587770700455, 0.021647993475198746, 0.038544584065675735, -0.03671349212527275, -0.060648005455732346, 0.0766788050532341, -0.010777970775961876, 0.044027723371982574, 0.002003418980166316, 0.04609426483511925, 0.01986103318631649, -0.009897103533148766, 0.027964787557721138, -0.0027971991803497076, -0.04385914281010628, 0.03925400227308273, -0.04893585294485092, 0.03108086623251438, 0.020882312208414078, -0.07403555512428284, -0.005131329409778118, 0.050428055226802826, 0.03995371237397194, -0.02109663560986519, 0.034181490540504456, -0.05627623572945595, -0.02040773630142212, 0.05605417117476463, -0.005538555793464184, 0.04748867079615593, -0.0037552514113485813, 0.04542574658989906, 0.06368642300367355, 0.008697113022208214, 0.013295894488692284, -0.0007393124396912754, -0.03625738248229027, 0.03157053515315056, 0.0509115569293499, 0.026006698608398438, -0.03051070310175419, 0.02766253426671028, 0.05949363484978676, 0.02843187004327774, 0.008278251625597477, 0.004502939525991678, 0.06826390326023102, -0.05274442210793495, -0.07267189770936966, -0.02274802140891552, -0.008363576605916023, 0.009913939982652664, -0.010704913176596165, -0.030529214069247246, -0.022233296185731888, -0.0541885681450367, -0.06327635049819946, 0.003556362586095929, 0.009610614739358425, -0.006969283800572157, 0.012287634424865246, 0.0010668258182704449, 0.03486892208456993, -0.020502591505646706, 0.0017583768349140882, -0.002847527852281928, 0.011766685172915459, -0.05055761709809303, -0.018099667504429817, 0.04648800194263458, 0.01788775436580181, -0.010175696574151516, 0.025646110996603966, 0.04056625813245773, -0.006466482300311327, -0.020667660981416702, 0.023284954950213432, -0.018499309197068214, -0.05096171796321869, 0.05216921493411064, 0.05753296613693237, -0.015249049291014671, -0.020001482218503952, -0.008353536017239094, 0.03601020574569702, 0.028615307062864304, 0.008041455410420895, -0.02133326046168804, -0.04345592111349106, -0.011437525972723961, 0.021502546966075897, 0.0012004023883491755, 0.009841183200478554, 0.016030222177505493, -0.007059747818857431, -0.000950041925534606, -0.03675372153520584, -0.025311671197414398, 0.020983589813113213, -0.01290521863847971, -0.0036198387388139963, 0.04949270188808441, 0.0215993020683527, -0.0001821647019824013, -0.005556622985750437, -0.04388513043522835, -0.06294471770524979, 0.019982047379016876, 0.013131218031048775, -0.03695688769221306, -0.011563477106392384, -0.06952852755784988, -0.007979515008628368, 0.006779168266803026, -0.06470433622598648, -0.06017562747001648, -0.020376401022076607, 0.012829518876969814, 0.04334539920091629, 0.03698505833745003, 0.049869243055582047, 0.001301222713664174, -0.08661483973264694, -0.022311246022582054, 0.03649115562438965, 0.0649445578455925, 0.004861295223236084, -0.07844384759664536, -0.028941597789525986, 0.015794167295098305, -0.02136661484837532, 0.04577894136309624, -0.01588762365281582, -0.01647520251572132, -0.0517193041741848, 0.00839193444699049, 0.013539593666791916, 0.08920086175203323, -0.01631498895585537, 0.00966631155461073, -0.004102278035134077, -0.018979055806994438, 0.012590729631483555, 0.018304815515875816, 0.09149067103862762, -0.030719883739948273, -0.053275808691978455, -0.0373498760163784, -0.0070353662595152855, 0.001905728247947991, 0.03432653471827507, 0.04475049301981926, 0.05152033269405365, 0.019888924434781075, -0.0031928056851029396, 0.02773892879486084, 0.0242274459451437, 0.017378848046064377, 0.08060318976640701, -0.07274097204208374, 0.00348547357134521, 0.019625067710876465, 0.042114272713661194, -0.019893482327461243, -0.015369297005236149, -0.002522531896829605, 0.05046767368912697, 0.02119331806898117, -0.0218657273799181, -0.08381877839565277, -0.08859378844499588, -0.053679101169109344 ]
<p>So I was operating a Laue machine recently which generates x-rays and fires them at a sample, and I noticed that there was a high-pitched whine coming from the instrument (nothing abnormal, just something I noticed). Both the current and the voltage could be set separately; typically values are 10 mA and 20 kV. I noticed that if you change the current, the frequency increases or decreases with it. A frequency spectrum app on my phone showed that the frequency was roughly proportional to the current being applied, so, for example, at 5 mA there'd be a 2000 Hz sound and at 10 mA it'd be 4000 Hz. (I don't remember the exact frequencies. I do remember there were lots of harmonics excited.) The voltage, on the other hand, only caused a small change of the frequency even if doubled. </p> <p>My question is how would such a sound be generated? </p> <p>My best guess is that the vacuum tube where the electrons are accelerated has its current adjusted by moving either the anode or cathode, and that forms a variable capacitor which happens to modulate the resonance frequency of the circuit such that the frequency and current increase together. Is this reasonable? </p>
g9799
[ 0.021498752757906914, -0.003462449414655566, -0.007111226674169302, -0.04532420635223389, 0.06765144318342209, 0.013723242096602917, -0.04050975292921066, 0.009513532742857933, -0.04977162554860115, -0.018185390159487724, -0.04139779135584831, 0.07398801296949387, 0.0519290454685688, 0.07516252994537354, -0.02053256519138813, 0.007798728067427874, 0.021879106760025024, 0.001845601829700172, 0.024913286790251732, 0.01986091583967209, 0.00670295674353838, 0.007942908443510532, 0.014287333935499191, -0.07845418155193329, 0.025521429255604744, 0.008946469984948635, 0.02023959346115589, 0.050064779818058014, -0.00020989061158616096, -0.0070681204088032246, 0.024252917617559433, -0.01025349274277687, 0.05379617214202881, 0.06654864549636841, -0.04826352372765541, -0.006604739930480719, 0.042818695306777954, -0.00363972713239491, -0.0013344113249331713, 0.02466508001089096, 0.00883953645825386, 0.011956337839365005, 0.03343094140291214, 0.004483010154217482, 0.001773365424014628, 0.003859015414491296, -0.06093280389904976, -0.01810130849480629, -0.00900519359856844, -0.008258714340627193, -0.034970447421073914, -0.031228315085172653, -0.0011873788898810744, 0.023386944085359573, 0.011325241066515446, -0.005460810847580433, -0.021811125800013542, -0.005951351020485163, 0.05279073864221573, 0.01784459315240383, -0.039906881749629974, -0.02743370272219181, 0.055538609623909, -0.022855892777442932, 0.07994896173477173, 0.005074129905551672, -0.010824065655469894, 0.03690183907747269, 0.028689362108707428, 0.03587997332215309, -0.03115135058760643, -0.05848325788974762, -0.034380458295345306, -0.03616958111524582, 0.049960363656282425, 0.05399307608604431, 0.008590452373027802, 0.00015110142703633755, -0.007970131002366543, -0.019952895119786263, -0.017231902107596397, 0.003675907850265503, 0.0886388048529625, -0.011564991436898708, -0.0031186274718493223, -0.11332099884748459, -0.01765279658138752, -0.000052010163926752284, 0.012183363549411297, -0.027436280623078346, 0.022467555478215218, -0.017526134848594666, 0.0366312637925148, -0.02707609347999096, -0.03457755595445633, -0.052833441644907, -0.021070117130875587, 0.08196813613176346, 0.02551432140171528, 0.015098994597792625, -0.009718697518110275, -0.02036922425031662, 0.056829020380973816, -0.026769589632749557, -0.095843605697155, 0.023481830954551697, 0.012451814487576485, -0.03806117922067642, -0.005946495104581118, -0.04447471722960472, 0.024933332577347755, -0.08774574846029282, 0.017517363652586937, -0.043817225843667984, 0.014600435271859169, -0.012683875858783722, -0.029406050220131874, 0.011368807405233383, -0.03389762341976166, 0.02873336710035801, -0.008489001542329788, 0.029101021587848663, -0.047771986573934555, -0.019337300211191177, -0.03747987747192383, -0.00890551507472992, 0.023961078375577927, 0.02133539505302906, 0.011502938345074654, 0.04259157180786133, 0.014755862765014172, -0.030908972024917603, -0.05125807225704193, 0.007950435392558575, 0.051730427891016006, 0.02988871932029724, 0.05215225741267204, 0.0038713905960321426, 0.03562646731734276, -0.019568851217627525, 0.034965481609106064, -0.023374494165182114, 0.06556593626737595, -0.05597611144185066, -0.036458633840084076, 0.02044920064508915, -0.011606257408857346, -0.029051005840301514, 0.057214122265577316, 0.027147376909852028, 0.0010063815861940384, 0.05402357876300812, 0.009547945111989975, -0.043409913778305054, 0.018290763720870018, 0.02994026243686676, 0.014491978101432323, 0.01930435560643673, -0.01923070289194584, -0.004733869340270758, 0.06906910240650177, -0.05369102209806442, 0.01764504984021187, -0.00842368882149458, -0.024286625906825066, 0.0058847940526902676, 0.01564192585647106, -0.013231853023171425, -0.0335642471909523, 0.044753193855285645, -0.03063715249300003, -0.040578994899988174, 0.01297883689403534, 0.037453461438417435, 0.015381025150418282, 0.04354964196681976, 0.09364315122365952, 0.009565426036715508, 0.019583795219659805, -0.00042131487862206995, -0.038418132811784744, -0.06768310070037842, -0.026424866169691086, -0.023489121347665787, 0.020384320989251137, -0.00458189845085144, -0.017724815756082535, -0.0017470581224188209, 0.0023848284035921097, 0.0081142857670784, -0.024757102131843567, -0.0535423718392849, -0.005866012070327997, -0.005022244527935982, -0.03241191431879997, -0.04985165223479271, -0.06592415273189545, -0.07186809927225113, 0.004034106619656086, 0.06870210915803909, 0.0022551403380930424, 0.033252499997615814, 0.07441017031669617, 0.018899252638220787, 0.0763794556260109, -0.0038627078756690025, -0.03984006494283676, -0.08145930618047714, -0.022168241441249847, 0.026433508843183517, 0.018696490675210953, 0.055336493998765945, 0.0246115755289793, 0.038822147995233536, -0.03619709238409996, -0.013345589861273766, -0.04186622425913811, -0.03734969720244408, 0.04493138566613197, 0.04417052119970322, 0.023718422278761864, -0.03153010457754135, 0.06991245597600937, 0.010268683545291424, -0.02405724674463272, -0.018012739717960358, 0.03089303709566593, -0.07654552161693573, -0.06220417469739914, -0.013795512728393078, -0.0028631542809307575, -0.028366290032863617, 0.0005982495495118201, 0.0029447826091200113, -0.025269096717238426, 0.040805794298648834, -0.02031087689101696, 0.009311670437455177, -0.05450010299682617, -0.03515142574906349, -0.009080510586500168, -0.01628182828426361, 0.015274781733751297, -0.009568188339471817, -0.017545774579048157, -0.013783934526145458, -0.007347031496465206, 0.004681978840380907, -0.006556916516274214, 0.013696721754968166, 0.0072817252948880196, -0.08351494371891022, -0.022069290280342102, 0.031967565417289734, -0.012823300436139107, -0.07755624502897263, 0.03220979496836662, 0.10186471045017242, -0.014226637780666351, 0.0033172299154102802, -0.013945267535746098, 0.015761476010084152, 0.026969993487000465, 0.012852654792368412, -0.017235593870282173, -0.014437614008784294, 0.06984243541955948, -0.03179873153567314, -0.007437004242092371, -0.018776457756757736, -0.027032487094402313, 0.023712053894996643, 0.020881323143839836, 0.0004957671044394374, -0.0004709624336101115, -0.0028095771558582783, -0.0041893296875059605, -0.009754524566233158, 0.03294813632965088, -0.01969483122229576, 0.008674249984323978, 0.0036631945986300707, -0.05907222256064415, -0.04626665636897087, -0.030091913416981697, 0.008375442586839199, 0.05999373644590378, -0.07528085261583328, 0.012095059268176556, 0.0656128004193306, -0.011922352947294712, -0.04879893735051155, -0.01891225390136242, -0.008738821372389793, -0.0217531006783247, 0.016320398077368736, 0.024698078632354736, 0.03974202275276184, -0.027876054868102074, 0.03872305899858475, 0.03849734365940094, -0.03813604637980461, -0.022135427221655846, -0.002020495245233178, -0.02386791631579399, -0.027160383760929108, -0.008182305842638016, 0.000296807789709419, -0.022982504218816757, 0.09430529922246933, -0.04585731774568558, -0.03115239553153515, 0.05191235989332199, -0.004064421635121107, -0.02469806931912899, -0.031415898352861404, 0.0038936305791139603, -0.015478380024433136, -0.03221872076392174, -0.012598047964274883, 0.0016999876825138927, -0.021548539400100708, 0.028271926566958427, -0.044389571994543076, -0.0013851638650521636, 0.015956109389662743, 0.026722583919763565, 0.001981410663574934, -0.0350918211042881, -0.040516309440135956, 0.03813296556472778, -0.0033781134989112616, -0.045703012496232986, -0.023282811045646667, 0.05002694949507713, -0.012749167159199715, 0.014408794231712818, 0.07056335359811783, 0.023403111845254898, 0.07191077619791031, 0.0076886136084795, -0.019259169697761536, -0.06530293077230453, -0.043900955468416214, -0.016721419990062714, 0.0628766193985939, -0.008867723867297173, -0.009755943901836872, -0.00011978660768363625, -0.052722346037626266, 0.019952112808823586, 0.015831587836146355, 0.014795527793467045, 0.010931109078228474, -0.03401719033718109, -0.02996622957289219, 0.04361775517463684, 0.03642486035823822, -0.0637345090508461, -0.027825230732560158, -0.021103834733366966, -0.07741144299507141, -0.023737337440252304, 0.007760214153677225, 0.00529382424429059, -0.014407237991690636, 0.011573795229196548, 0.08045444637537003, 0.02151685580611229, -0.01813364028930664, -0.05071647837758064, 0.009053883142769337, -0.03388479724526405, 0.03629302233457565, -0.047880884259939194, -0.022859079763293266, -0.004053420387208462, -0.016686931252479553, -0.05823756381869316, 0.045334842056035995, 0.03443741053342819, -0.0009953024564310908, 0.015455863438546658, -0.054785847663879395, -0.02865239977836609, -0.00979628600180149, -0.050072867423295975, 0.009984835051000118, -0.03498348593711853, -0.06298554688692093, -0.007097805384546518, -0.04380832612514496, -0.04021775722503662, -0.03431703522801399, -0.04121546819806099, -0.029808465391397476, 0.04358680173754692, -0.026099735870957375, 0.061592359095811844, 0.04167475923895836, 0.03181225061416626, 0.06900360435247421, -0.000888202921487391, 0.010333365760743618, 0.016187097877264023, -0.011859613470733166, 0.07626432925462723, -0.05061522126197815, 0.007899705320596695, 0.004868591204285622, -0.03671656921505928, 0.024512043222784996, -0.026224907487630844, -0.04269392415881157, -0.03348546102643013, 0.0022373744286596775, 0.016375122591853142, 0.03753228113055229, 0.046734366565942764, 0.0552176758646965, 0.00759431067854166, 0.06169502064585686, 0.05344704911112785, 0.0522957369685173, 0.024141686037182808, 0.015590351074934006, -0.011832969263195992, -0.060987211763858795, 0.0325852632522583, -0.03509864956140518, 0.016882995143532753, -0.004242046270519495, -0.004902175161987543, 0.027552874758839607, -0.004456936847418547, 0.04372943565249443, -0.05601505935192108, 0.015887010842561722, -0.0035215369425714016, 0.020437637344002724, 0.10047949105501175, -0.09369146823883057, -0.010346041060984135, -0.015980850905179977, -0.0024943912867456675, 0.04690435901284218, -0.014649175107479095, -0.026650315150618553, 0.020748499780893326, -0.015316078439354897, -0.03609315678477287, 0.013703255914151669, -0.03878423944115639, -0.05873028188943863, 0.11345189809799194, -0.029957467690110207, 0.01249490026384592, 0.016563547775149345, 0.04790526255965233, -0.023107610642910004, -0.049721118062734604, -0.002680287230759859, -0.0064108166843652725, 0.027889210730791092, 0.06380452960729599, 0.014523112215101719, -0.027583599090576172, -0.1036461740732193, -0.05719778686761856, -0.012294149957597256, 0.04534035548567772, -0.07546752691268921, -0.042460840195417404, 0.04973312467336655, -0.005199006292968988, -0.005751524120569229, -0.03177976608276367, -0.03816066309809685, -0.057447440922260284, -0.07922833412885666, -0.012578458525240421, -0.01719612628221512, 0.06118990108370781, -0.0389702245593071, -0.031903039664030075, -0.026218092069029808, -0.030094627290964127, 0.03292122483253479, 0.015241180546581745, -0.03321892395615578, 0.061821915209293365, 0.0742567703127861, 0.035277169197797775, -0.03055870532989502, -0.0032536687795072794, -0.0023193624801933765, 0.01100222859531641, -0.014078683219850063, -0.006722960155457258, 0.03214026242494583, -0.035736966878175735, -0.009057951159775257, -0.027670281007885933, -0.003966886550188065, -0.00493647763505578, 0.03293916583061218, 0.008710659109055996, -0.04640135169029236, 0.010649628937244415, 0.0008252999396063387, 0.03993102163076401, 0.08013014495372772, 0.06695139408111572, 0.02693994529545307, 0.034179747104644775, 0.015641994774341583, -0.02114713191986084, 0.010964866727590561, -0.01085689291357994, 0.018222717568278313, 0.05064815655350685, -0.019542623311281204, 0.009085179306566715, 0.010512078180909157, -0.03903952240943909, 0.0027198921889066696, 0.005114132072776556, 0.017439493909478188, 0.020102420821785927, 0.048018913716077805, 0.021238649263978004, 0.0015622114297002554, -0.008501764386892319, -0.042887862771749496, 0.016536256298422813, 0.005792360752820969, 0.011679359711706638, 0.03498014062643051, -0.016496170312166214, 0.03647485375404358, 0.0378483347594738, -0.02582629956305027, 0.016007881611585617, 0.02628675289452076, 0.035668570548295975, -0.033389005810022354, 0.010157888755202293, 0.022022670134902, 0.02851690724492073, -0.0066968584433197975, -0.06062090024352074, 0.05162239819765091, 0.05370812863111496, 0.055127453058958054, -0.005873921327292919, 0.026141498237848282, 0.013717363588511944, -0.051906768232584, -0.012824444100260735, -0.06593815982341766, 0.07168394327163696, 0.043276190757751465, 0.040934838354587555, -0.019190331920981407, 0.03774424269795418, 0.0015809930628165603, 0.05394677072763443, 0.00546277267858386, 0.05666737258434296, 0.009670930914580822, -0.03374841436743736, -0.0010712655493989587, 0.005070966202765703, -0.07573157548904419, -0.00765859754756093, 0.027900628745555878, -0.042496152222156525, 0.022428790107369423, 0.018714023754000664, -0.00004797505971509963, -0.033190611749887466, -0.02157950960099697, -0.011102372780442238, 0.0017263052286580205, 0.05363665521144867, 0.02637214958667755, 0.007143351715058088, -0.01711359992623329, 0.051168136298656464, -0.012443742714822292, -0.07306098192930222, 0.015283062122762203, -0.007497080136090517, -0.009085732512176037, 0.0198725126683712, 0.019245292991399765, -0.047702375799417496, -0.0373615100979805, 0.024857016280293465, -0.005092819221317768, 0.015925638377666473, 0.04405027627944946, -0.039910804480314255, 0.005468534771353006, -0.0073661901988089085, -0.036395348608493805, -0.014961003325879574, 0.039187222719192505, -0.017515355721116066, 0.00553532550111413, -0.007816466502845287, -0.018460191786289215, 0.04707997292280197, -0.007569111883640289, -0.0022979741916060448, 0.024091824889183044, 0.04268079996109009, 0.028595922514796257, 0.028873911127448082, 0.09840328246355057, 0.04099367931485176, -0.0011419713264331222, -0.062391214072704315, -0.010216501541435719, -0.004017086233943701, 0.005164967384189367, -0.015678539872169495, -0.013158232904970646, 0.08048830181360245, -0.039164476096630096, -0.06417575478553772, 0.03669968992471695, -0.004804579541087151, 0.007660877890884876, -0.023831533268094063, 0.008493753150105476, 0.04586079716682434, -0.03596915304660797, 0.03938983753323555, 0.0014027208089828491, 0.03470718488097191, -0.002292676828801632, 0.012516750954091549, 0.016984352841973305, -0.006611831020563841, 0.0036185842473059893, 0.017181308940052986, 0.02358952909708023, -0.02836506813764572, -0.009714215062558651, -0.03163598105311394, -0.06908445805311203, -0.06456705927848816, 0.0826113224029541, 0.017583796754479408, -0.0104916887357831, 0.005101986229419708, -0.008591657504439354, 0.06202564015984535, -0.010097880847752094, -0.028542732819914818, -0.04015495628118515, 0.0008771191933192313, -0.012511874549090862, 0.05919015780091286, 0.02230154164135456, -0.04861728474497795, -0.0305158831179142, 0.0055246492847800255, -0.02661842666566372, 0.022178281098604202, -0.026029884815216064, 0.0289310235530138, -0.0033849491737782955, -0.013170544058084488, -0.03303920477628708, -0.04291503503918648, 0.04566735774278641, -0.05081145092844963, 0.013790148310363293, -0.0109940180554986, -0.03207480534911156, 0.0010890105040743947, -0.024285148829221725, -0.015376171097159386, -0.03066910244524479, -0.06534942239522934, 0.04157382622361183, 0.0033730443101376295, -0.008252087980508804, -0.01779686100780964, 0.008120345883071423, 0.039136990904808044, 0.025886084884405136, -0.03304832801222801, 0.04617961496114731, -0.01666305959224701, -0.05160178989171982, -0.0020598547998815775, 0.045665837824344635, 0.048613663762807846, 0.02232358045876026, -0.019932961091399193, 0.030903972685337067, 0.01705763302743435, 0.02979881502687931, 0.064479760825634, -0.05455134063959122, -0.011597719974815845, -0.02221793122589588, -0.07061558961868286, 0.05221576616168022, 0.001214921590872109, 0.0209993626922369, 0.023657847195863724, -0.00005741711356677115, -0.02195925824344158, 0.061699941754341125, -0.022389966994524002, 0.002551670651882887, -0.03618469089269638, 0.022941887378692627, 0.012149157002568245, -0.023285333067178726, 0.08007217943668365, -0.021190974861383438, -0.028842031955718994, 0.06245587393641472, -0.06010505557060242, 0.017278563231229782, -0.045903805643320084, -0.0300785843282938, 0.00544181652367115, 0.009907343424856663, -0.03423921763896942, -0.04738273844122887, 0.015845146030187607, 0.06927299499511719, 0.01914934627711773, 0.015909994021058083, -0.0327845960855484, 0.006319865118712187, -0.0468907356262207, 0.020732006058096886, -0.04430137202143669, 0.010547745041549206, -0.032065249979496, -0.0015241110231727362, 0.012897184118628502, -0.07696910947561264, -0.03611680120229721, -0.029978986829519272, -0.04870796203613281, 0.004333670251071453, 0.06588374078273773, -0.013739571906626225, -0.01622011512517929, 0.030082060024142265, 0.03377578407526016, -0.02597906067967415, -0.023284748196601868, 0.05009867995977402, 0.004989899229258299, 0.023902270942926407, 0.006772209424525499, -0.02916054055094719, -0.0011641958262771368, -0.03737219050526619 ]
<p>The black hole at the center of the Milky Way is believed to have erupted as an active galactic nucleus (AGN) approximately 2 million years ago, at which time <a href="http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn24257-early-humans-saw-black-hole-light-in-the-night-sky.html" rel="nofollow">it would have been visible to early humans</a>. How visibly bright would such an eruption have been, and how sudden would its onset have been?</p>
g9800
[ 0.014120355248451233, -0.004569931421428919, 0.016925713047385216, -0.03436564281582832, -0.02020956017076969, 0.0028132221195846796, 0.0009051428060047328, 0.01523872371762991, 0.026109589263796806, -0.0068056620657444, 0.04210589453577995, 0.04708559066057205, 0.0567912757396698, -0.026621803641319275, 0.02645721100270748, -0.03451169654726982, 0.005759370047599077, -0.04725194722414017, -0.02138122171163559, -0.0029871256556361914, 0.022731471806764603, -0.07056828588247299, 0.03747662529349327, -0.0032791062258183956, -0.009522346779704094, -0.0033427097368985415, 0.04493483528494835, 0.0035517881624400616, -0.01375934761017561, -0.06731974333524704, 0.06393998116254807, -0.01041205134242773, 0.017270442098379135, -0.010393217206001282, -0.016717055812478065, -0.004774152766913176, -0.014061478897929192, 0.006884265691041946, 0.011825010180473328, 0.008541380055248737, 0.0008545203018002212, -0.051076821982860565, 0.048120371997356415, 0.014461244456470013, -0.04543565213680267, 0.04135870933532715, 0.04640424996614456, 0.03357250243425369, 0.045600928366184235, 0.003093358362093568, -0.07027721405029297, 0.020892325788736343, 0.010020404122769833, 0.0072134705260396, 0.016249224543571472, 0.07517232745885849, 0.00004385275315144099, -0.002114497357979417, -0.018271716311573982, 0.0513458326458931, -0.0685371682047844, 0.02117575891315937, 0.034993935376405716, -0.08013839274644852, 0.025051746517419815, 0.023109035566449165, -0.020421231165528297, 0.03422136232256889, 0.0041409083642065525, 0.05064169690012932, -0.011605040170252323, -0.05778149142861366, 0.0012019245186820626, 0.03409844636917114, -0.04851772263646126, 0.02682160772383213, -0.05920696631073952, 0.00954069197177887, -0.0074462490156292915, 0.03217947855591774, -0.01699831336736679, 0.017417196184396744, -0.0038213899824768305, -0.045866455882787704, 0.0624384805560112, -0.013464076444506645, -0.021793430671095848, -0.0341908298432827, 0.03653441742062569, -0.006211274769157171, 0.09465881437063217, 0.037955135107040405, -0.01594291254878044, -0.03900107368826866, 0.026907747611403465, 0.01171314250677824, -0.007814723998308182, 0.010403201915323734, 0.01136370562016964, 0.041853051632642746, -0.054203491657972336, -0.021482277661561966, 0.004755774512887001, 0.00924722570925951, -0.017880816012620926, 0.015469980426132679, -0.009019672870635986, 0.016913482919335365, -0.02145136520266533, 0.047641366720199585, 0.00026059671654365957, -0.04164077341556549, 0.004566841293126345, -0.03141212835907936, -0.034401945769786835, 0.027111660689115524, 0.03371710702776909, 0.007857446558773518, 0.005363668780773878, 0.05166468396782875, 0.0504894033074379, -0.011080672033131123, -0.020204508677124977, -0.025450585409998894, -0.01950790360569954, -0.06791988760232925, -0.01606493629515171, -0.017183471471071243, 0.0284731462597847, 0.006899590138345957, 0.0045599727891385555, -0.00043695291969925165, -0.01758277229964733, 0.04780372604727745, 0.013619148172438145, 0.04140278324484825, 0.030750049278140068, -0.0037289808969944715, -0.022112222388386726, 0.005524507723748684, 0.03723141923546791, 0.0009945279452949762, 0.04325590655207634, 0.0034888521768152714, -0.00667624780908227, 0.04455943778157234, 0.012422476895153522, -0.03468438610434532, 0.04041822627186775, 0.019829118624329567, -0.039919495582580566, 0.01898888684809208, 0.03246261924505234, 0.01368753518909216, -0.038638968020677567, 0.01581696793437004, -0.016193030402064323, -0.00008014935883693397, -0.09056797623634338, -0.050373829901218414, 0.020554514601826668, -0.005711984355002642, 0.007349576335400343, 0.001891085528768599, -0.07521065324544907, -0.04568709060549736, 0.029260441660881042, -0.05696167051792145, 0.07151613384485245, 0.020852932706475258, 0.03901612013578415, 0.037915024906396866, -0.013659178279340267, -0.05213247612118721, -0.031797729432582855, -0.04075714573264122, 0.06923067569732666, -0.02751735784113407, 0.02330264262855053, 0.018837805837392807, -0.005078247282654047, -0.019505348056554794, -0.08339947462081909, 0.003937374800443649, 0.04548213630914688, -0.10693665593862534, 0.05466604605317116, -0.006208567880094051, 0.0146262776106596, 0.04811086878180504, -0.06712853163480759, -0.010900851339101791, -0.012219272553920746, 0.07418972253799438, -0.011742331087589264, -0.03155522048473358, 0.003498467616736889, 0.02406260184943676, 0.02329019270837307, 0.08631785959005356, 0.012463550083339214, 0.027996277436614037, -0.02628352679312229, 0.001953886356204748, 0.021509714424610138, 0.0377122238278389, -0.021145861595869064, -0.0009093816042877734, 0.022897925227880478, -0.0134562524035573, -0.0007230212213471532, 0.009047040715813637, -0.015160329639911652, -0.007405301555991173, -0.07090577483177185, 0.06828214228153229, -0.04207902401685715, 0.0896269679069519, 0.013116709887981415, 0.023419303819537163, -0.019717909395694733, 0.017312539741396904, -0.015981217846274376, -0.06089518219232559, -0.01032306905835867, 0.027909953147172928, -0.013452842831611633, -0.0070831915363669395, -0.011205733753740788, 0.008229099214076996, -0.07536116987466812, 0.061054762452840805, -0.0261408518999815, 0.02240796387195587, 0.010618322528898716, 0.011233891360461712, 0.010695675387978554, -0.04804665967822075, 0.04725450649857521, -0.02051619067788124, -0.03976644203066826, 0.006876232568174601, -0.024450378492474556, -0.013958921656012535, -0.00010447089880472049, -0.051528312265872955, -0.000980050303041935, -0.02869662083685398, -0.01808176189661026, -0.0013009276008233428, -0.0025579098146408796, -0.08704663813114166, 0.012773401103913784, -0.029020287096500397, -0.02679743990302086, -0.007458917796611786, 0.0007106605917215347, 0.07489624619483948, -0.0511268675327301, -0.021387750282883644, 0.004195811692625284, -0.05024566873908043, -0.0018260458018630743, -0.06333890557289124, 0.031151866540312767, 0.007829238660633564, -0.020844077691435814, -0.021549612283706665, -0.022421352565288544, 0.0009834328666329384, 0.02168060652911663, -0.023544451221823692, 0.0005653128609992564, -0.007104154676198959, -0.045126043260097504, 0.009222958236932755, -0.05092610791325569, 0.012805342674255371, 0.041956283152103424, 0.003634895896539092, -0.01758739724755287, 0.006189405452460051, -0.07113762944936752, 0.020189404487609863, 0.018943430855870247, -0.052004385739564896, 0.02704920619726181, 0.046050239354372025, -0.00438955333083868, -0.024247070774435997, 0.013963614590466022, 0.012976081110537052, -0.01849186420440674, 0.08080953359603882, -0.02314356155693531, 0.004486259073019028, 0.03799111023545265, 0.05329768359661102, 0.026094291359186172, 0.0065679713152348995, 0.08765122294425964, -0.08495265990495682, -0.03603636845946312, -0.015828121453523636, -0.005266773980110884, -0.026302184909582138, -0.013464154675602913, 0.03274570778012276, 0.021524537354707718, -0.041919875890016556, 0.01672825962305069, 0.028336461633443832, -0.026140954345464706, 0.08180389553308487, -0.01604963093996048, -0.016383251175284386, 0.022683916613459587, 0.03328271955251694, 0.012293019331991673, 0.016259023919701576, 0.016597535461187363, 0.0007761220913380384, -0.054515473544597626, -0.049082331359386444, 0.011874985881149769, 0.03520413115620613, 0.023239046335220337, 0.009112144820392132, -0.023580588400363922, -0.03857187554240227, -0.06034047529101372, -0.016211578622460365, -0.08790972828865051, 0.011203398928046227, -0.003467096947133541, 0.007245178800076246, -0.03161768615245819, 0.03366416320204735, 0.021440375596284866, 0.067484050989151, 0.044035136699676514, -0.01256071962416172, -0.05042959004640579, -0.02121133916079998, 0.04589824378490448, -0.060332510620355606, 0.018160121515393257, -0.11826664209365845, -0.0033428596798330545, 0.009757272899150848, 0.012630904093384743, -0.07470925897359848, 0.013168957084417343, -0.013812938705086708, 0.038198377937078476, 0.005436798557639122, 0.07517148554325104, 0.02232789434492588, 0.02690928988158703, -0.01025393046438694, -0.06174672767519951, -0.025167906656861305, 0.01336124911904335, -0.025414440780878067, 0.021182073280215263, -0.01613430865108967, 0.010927984490990639, -0.0010253224754706025, 0.0786738246679306, 0.01852506212890148, 0.021471111103892326, 0.02984408289194107, 0.011754599399864674, -0.004123383667320013, 0.0014160849386826158, -0.010534849017858505, -0.0017616242403164506, 0.036183129996061325, -0.011310648173093796, 0.06331587582826614, -0.03810039162635803, -0.010320072993636131, 0.05922240391373634, 0.046430982649326324, -0.013636531308293343, 0.012437742203474045, 0.031613193452358246, -0.054422326385974884, 0.012465160340070724, -0.06018923595547676, 0.006436612457036972, -0.003527174238115549, 0.01757671870291233, -0.04536814242601395, 0.011315066367387772, 0.008678721264004707, 0.004128601402044296, 0.018026193603873253, 0.0198814757168293, -0.009206928312778473, 0.006153789348900318, 0.03664473071694374, 0.04690716043114662, 0.01983676292002201, -0.02463141456246376, 0.010344593785703182, -0.014385055750608444, 0.012480289675295353, 0.027830706909298897, -0.038699325174093246, 0.010480532422661781, 0.03256357088685036, 0.00008200493175536394, 0.0061538261361420155, 0.013740114867687225, 0.009667330421507359, 0.04963669925928116, -0.005364420358091593, 0.023714734241366386, 0.015522267669439316, 0.006799453869462013, -0.04507026448845863, -0.008295398205518723, 0.02939373068511486, 0.02224719524383545, -0.018076347187161446, -0.01558766607195139, 0.018059974536299706, -0.020960142835974693, 0.02825404331088066, 0.051066137850284576, -0.013340483419597149, -0.030106352642178535, 0.035148341208696365, -0.05441967770457268, 0.006585441529750824, -0.0027601495385169983, -0.011883488856256008, 0.011791162192821503, -0.019911587238311768, 0.033567704260349274, -0.021555377170443535, -0.009122848510742188, 0.018323702737689018, 0.06415362656116486, 0.036778468638658524, 0.04160190001130104, 0.018283158540725708, -0.0012134781572967768, 0.012362843379378319, 0.0170946903526783, -0.020319173112511635, 0.019176922738552094, -0.025791294872760773, -0.0051893023774027824, -0.04669791832566261, -0.036042261868715286, 0.058906588703393936, -0.04714817926287651, 0.09793046116828918, -0.028586577624082565, 0.011892586946487427, -0.010041924193501472, -0.009514710865914822, 0.046045850962400436, -0.04210770130157471, -0.06344730406999588, -0.04872048646211624, 0.050588902086019516, -0.000767318531870842, -0.07748205214738846, 0.008331331424415112, 0.0341932475566864, -0.012825648300349712, -0.0954323261976242, 0.038451701402664185, 0.03269200399518013, -0.04077266901731491, 0.024438779801130295, -0.018400557339191437, 0.020688556134700775, -0.0004282303270883858, 0.0168821569532156, 0.024964412674307823, 0.027034569531679153, 0.02642981708049774, -0.018623314797878265, 0.006947208661586046, -0.05110004171729088, 0.014436452649533749, 0.032709550112485886, -0.0715879574418068, 0.006829294376075268, -0.0065021817572414875, -0.04481235146522522, -0.058505479246377945, -0.01318887248635292, -0.04076772928237915, 0.0074980538338422775, 0.06490331143140793, -0.09460455179214478, 0.07125981897115707, -0.031880974769592285, 0.011745979078114033, -0.04564610868692398, 0.03189907595515251, -0.048854656517505646, -0.038085613399744034, 0.053412314504384995, 0.058634281158447266, -0.010731963440775871, -0.015581280924379826, -0.02789326198399067, 0.01926482282578945, 0.029429016634821892, -0.03299582004547119, -0.02951234206557274, 0.023576006293296814, 0.0485144667327404, 0.003406188450753689, -0.04073154926300049, -0.031757451593875885, -0.009591205045580864, 0.04975041002035141, 0.048387184739112854, 0.01907985843718052, -0.008161323145031929, 0.04239552840590477, 0.05119049921631813, -0.04737371951341629, -0.0007658741087652743, -0.028832932934165, -0.03349824249744415, -0.053346943110227585, 0.05742744356393814, 0.024899031966924667, 0.025076420977711678, -0.001717719598673284, 0.0211036317050457, -0.030234184116125107, -0.042532116174697876, -0.012937131337821484, 0.013020564801990986, -0.03412162512540817, 0.010973380878567696, -0.0024539215955883265, -0.028865836560726166, 0.02396748960018158, -0.01292014867067337, 0.0014200153527781367, 0.03820101544260979, 0.02289625070989132, 0.05037423223257065, 0.10415352135896683, -0.015081143006682396, 0.06918641924858093, 0.008798954077064991, -0.026987098157405853, 0.005767508875578642, -0.06915323436260223, 0.05852905288338661, -0.01385209895670414, -0.04443211480975151, 0.037233006209135056, -0.004043930675834417, -0.01700723171234131, -0.0009980349568650126, -0.03800388425588608, 0.039532337337732315, -0.006458994001150131, 0.011961580254137516, -0.017847390845417976, 0.04196380078792572, -0.0012674302561208606, 0.018983962014317513, 0.01972562074661255, 0.03827786445617676, 0.06171772629022598, -0.06183715537190437, -0.005634081084281206, -0.01964772678911686, -0.0319683663547039, 0.05776798725128174, -0.00858280248939991, 0.023655368015170097, -0.04101964458823204, -0.0269412063062191, 0.08013434708118439, 0.0003415379615034908, -0.013382130302488804, 0.04575370252132416, -0.013294420205056667, 0.01865609548985958, -0.02764793112874031, -0.0685487911105156, -0.017791060730814934, -0.013294655829668045, -0.043464694172143936, -0.03417125344276428, -0.043891992419958115, 0.0004901944193989038, 0.01557845901697874, -0.029895035549998283, 0.007755455560982227, -0.04141008108854294, -0.027563469484448433, 0.00907366443425417, -0.0016811927780508995, 0.0718265101313591, -0.028260502964258194, 0.05443081259727478, 0.05807691812515259, -0.030347876250743866, 0.008259286172688007, 0.0062204888090491295, -0.014937128871679306, 0.03819257393479347, 0.0017903452971950173, 0.04181549698114395, 0.008796118199825287, 0.02326229214668274, 0.06677070260047913, -0.007935154251754284, -0.0161345973610878, -0.010619398206472397, 0.002173596527427435, -0.08000333607196808, 0.03322673588991165, 0.016747260466217995, 0.04100925475358963, 0.035874057561159134, 0.0383622944355011, 0.021155722439289093, 0.026657097041606903, 0.06527582556009293, -0.01392741035670042, -0.05668489634990692, -0.03595462068915367, -0.0200823787599802, -0.019764093682169914, 0.036132827401161194, -0.07175058871507645, 0.012309749610722065, -0.021577846258878708, 0.018071990460157394, 0.03838350996375084, -0.0004549066652543843, 0.03690014407038689, -0.043245989829301834, -0.01764584705233574, 0.010741546750068665, -0.10960525274276733, -0.014255254529416561, -0.028633851557970047, -0.07277939468622208, 0.009281330741941929, -0.008483032695949078, 0.004356743302196264, -0.014090870507061481, -0.07627987116575241, 0.004801114089787006, 0.033251434564590454, -0.07950635254383087, -0.0430733785033226, -0.026099130511283875, -0.04756179451942444, 0.07207531481981277, -0.018794255331158638, -0.01135900430381298, -0.022932130843400955, 0.04105452448129654, -0.02553309127688408, -0.07082293182611465, -0.005491493735462427, -0.0995245948433876, -0.01809442974627018, 0.010363882407546043, 0.026610299944877625, 0.09000001847743988, 0.040876660495996475, 0.026948751881718636, -0.0046082460321486, -0.01063256524503231, 0.06878665089607239, -0.0002889340976253152, -0.010322260670363903, -0.07555359601974487, -0.001401551766321063, 0.0414268784224987, 0.017063317820429802, -0.08998549729585648, -0.0680786520242691, -0.027152981609106064, -0.024536296725273132, 0.039666395634412766, -0.03690788149833679, 0.005163051653653383, 0.014832183718681335, 0.03769703209400177, -0.05359776318073273, -0.027938295155763626, -0.0028756780084222555, -0.011734358966350555, -0.09030990302562714, -0.03952424228191376, 0.025322264060378075, 0.00795318465679884, 0.0360562689602375, -0.06555911153554916, -0.012811802327632904, 0.02665994130074978, 0.08669393509626389, 0.03909510746598244, -0.008035260252654552, -0.016453130170702934, -0.005718289874494076, 0.006306231953203678, -0.028825782239437103, -0.021351156756281853, 0.008382262662053108, -0.0028198023792356253, 0.03557178005576134, -0.017620299011468887, 0.013862243853509426, 0.011774630285799503, 0.04509151354432106, 0.010068210773169994, 0.010987290181219578, 0.012296883389353752, -0.04800369217991829, 0.023290647193789482, 0.00019913556752726436, -0.03174421563744545, -0.015001500025391579, -0.024498561397194862, 0.01653708517551422, 0.00240267813205719, 0.05109792575240135, -0.035158392041921616, 0.005009172018617392, -0.04636726155877113, 0.014821737073361874, 0.021734243258833885, -0.018886422738432884, 0.04102183133363724, -0.0022478397004306316, 0.002161107724532485, 0.05225055292248726, 0.01403170358389616, -0.04036940261721611, 0.017280003055930138, -0.005589932203292847, -0.004818607587367296, 0.02130226418375969, 0.04546426609158516, 0.001202323124743998, -0.04633883759379387, 0.007124254945665598, -0.0678277239203453, -0.01940694823861122, -0.04580719769001007, 0.026245618239045143, 0.03881616145372391, -0.01723344251513481, 0.01134582795202732, -0.004174473229795694, 0.03133593127131462, -0.01155678927898407 ]
<p>It is well known that if the compactification manifold of a supergravity theory has non-zero Betti numbers, this may lead to the so called Betti multiplets in the spectrum of the low dimensional theory. A famous example is compactification of IIB supergravity on $T^{1,1}$, where a Betti multiplet shows up because of the nonzero second Betti number of $T^{1,1}$.</p> <p>My question is this: is it the <a href="http://www.google.com/search?q=L2+Betti+number" rel="nofollow">$L^2$-Betti numbers</a> that necessitate Betti multiplets in the low dimensional theory, or just normal <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betti_number" rel="nofollow">Betti numbers</a>? In particular, do Betti numbers generated by smooth (fixed point free) discrete identification (orbifolding) of trivial manifolds lead to Betti multiplets? (I am actually not even sure if smooth orbifolding of trivial topologies can yield non-zero Betti numbers.) Is there a good reference I can look into for that?</p>
g9801
[ 0.04171161353588104, 0.05386355519294739, -0.009457099251449108, -0.001899181050248444, 0.017434734851121902, 0.004252966493368149, 0.055419016629457474, 0.014129814691841602, -0.05128854885697365, -0.03531906008720398, -0.036748211830854416, -0.007598663680255413, 0.06916536390781403, 0.026705624535679817, -0.016518322750926018, -0.027552269399166107, 0.05942341685295105, 0.0023137275129556656, 0.038918387144804, -0.03722259774804115, 0.012727991677820683, 0.011337623000144958, 0.008470376022160053, -0.01737695373594761, -0.037597864866256714, 0.03469259664416313, 0.054027508944272995, 0.05899041146039963, -0.023317279294133186, -0.033815205097198486, 0.0037984796799719334, -0.01545012928545475, 0.034088458865880966, 0.0071339053101837635, 0.011064060963690281, 0.013260471634566784, 0.05062729865312576, 0.010737110860645771, -0.021183008328080177, -0.0014523941790685058, 0.02475344017148018, -0.03155213221907616, 0.030669962987303734, 0.0298189427703619, -0.07532642781734467, -0.011424279771745205, 0.003884087083861232, 0.01188685093075037, 0.024237174540758133, 0.0056627895683050156, 0.12322715669870377, -0.04530375823378563, 0.041751429438591, -0.019172875210642815, -0.05338415876030922, 0.037748128175735474, -0.04273207113146782, -0.04123368486762047, -0.0016314100939780474, 0.07435588538646698, -0.038473766297101974, 0.017256086692214012, 0.026712575927376747, 0.06326320767402649, -0.001785583095625043, 0.06464429944753647, -0.011706603690981865, -0.007143272086977959, 0.03624189645051956, 0.020591244101524353, -0.057259444147348404, 0.0049773105420172215, 0.0377521738409996, 0.012636483646929264, -0.05483439192175865, 0.022068774327635765, 0.006784903816878796, -0.033993106335401535, -0.027209633961319923, 0.02603563666343689, -0.020271852612495422, 0.01841467246413231, -0.021657153964042664, 0.010898146778345108, 0.07042736560106277, 0.004804082680493593, -0.02415347285568714, 0.024653298780322075, 0.007187527138739824, 0.006827211938798428, 0.07900809496641159, 0.0262985248118639, -0.002203431911766529, 0.008268138393759727, 0.01587238349020481, 0.031006908044219017, 0.019572705030441284, 0.049056462943553925, -0.07732607424259186, -0.02472638711333275, -0.006523990537971258, 0.031676698476076126, 0.063593290746212, 0.01696084812283516, 0.05018487945199013, 0.016026901081204414, 0.02756188064813614, -0.02655242756009102, 0.09749814122915268, 0.017418812960386276, -0.0727066621184349, -0.002943784464150667, 0.012910370714962482, -0.04627789929509163, -0.037587009370326996, -0.00032723377807997167, 0.018238844349980354, -0.027668064460158348, -0.03412093594670296, 0.030946653336286545, 0.055129241198301315, -0.02644568867981434, 0.03952965885400772, 0.014983871020376682, -0.002146103186532855, -0.008247608318924904, -0.019759561866521835, 0.027145830914378166, 0.03351360186934471, -0.00009306481661042199, -0.03442217409610748, 0.009295511990785599, 0.048510342836380005, 0.011625225655734539, 0.0019287335453554988, 0.0321231372654438, 0.005450971890240908, 0.018358346074819565, 0.018745942041277885, -0.017035992816090584, -0.05813288316130638, -0.053505972027778625, -0.015771014615893364, -0.02901127189397812, 0.08170575648546219, 0.027337538078427315, 0.02794943004846573, -0.024575717747211456, 0.0404689759016037, 0.033646829426288605, 0.02891257032752037, 0.06325660645961761, 0.06459461152553558, -0.020341116935014725, 0.006223959382623434, 0.04150069132447243, 0.010861702263355255, 0.005430522840470076, 0.03290533274412155, -0.03322792425751686, 0.053082212805747986, -0.03240539878606796, 0.06154350936412811, -0.03868820518255234, -0.026896852999925613, 0.06035236269235611, 0.03178182244300842, -0.014067943207919598, -0.026944229379296303, -0.00529458187520504, 0.019559746608138084, -0.019579298794269562, 0.08494634181261063, 0.05924246460199356, 0.010501970537006855, 0.0018931996310129762, -0.05066400766372681, 0.034217774868011475, -0.02054719440639019, -0.028666267171502113, -0.04270709306001663, -0.050304312258958817, -0.04505034536123276, -0.014098608866333961, 0.021072586998343468, 0.01507444679737091, -0.009893794544041157, 0.04344382882118225, 0.044204484671354294, 0.018468521535396576, 0.048789139837026596, 0.021520111709833145, 0.04747533053159714, 0.07855790108442307, -0.023408055305480957, 0.029861483722925186, 0.026784468442201614, -0.026369595900177956, -0.03777201101183891, -0.015374347567558289, 0.03470512479543686, 0.0329304113984108, -0.005400749854743481, -0.047679249197244644, -0.060108184814453125, -0.00041278230492025614, -0.012497400864958763, -0.030860817059874535, -0.004704382736235857, -0.02023146115243435, -0.012143808417022228, -0.03659667447209358, -0.02738301455974579, 0.003049633465707302, -0.04042839631438255, -0.04380107298493385, -0.01759098842740059, -0.022950466722249985, -0.00967477634549141, -0.034918397665023804, 0.0068941256031394005, 0.039068739861249924, 0.01603587530553341, 0.01531736645847559, -0.00861046276986599, 0.019237056374549866, 0.013688495382666588, -0.062029190361499786, 0.006937005091458559, 0.005196959711611271, -0.03367744758725166, -0.03566966950893402, 0.07100202143192291, -0.03631364181637764, 0.026675311848521233, 0.0037624698597937822, -0.015323846600949764, -0.03224993124604225, 0.021740945056080818, 0.05209539085626602, 0.032232869416475296, -0.04635315015912056, -0.030090712010860443, -0.03269408643245697, 0.039367590099573135, -0.0396948978304863, 0.008288750424981117, -0.013725622557103634, -0.05278565734624863, 0.03717564791440964, -0.0763760656118393, -0.0043320790864527225, 0.023446302860975266, 0.03174096345901489, -0.046196628361940384, 0.03160279989242554, 0.028697704896330833, 0.01688339188694954, -0.020540770143270493, -0.02244195155799389, 0.060879867523908615, -0.044858165085315704, -0.008701116777956486, -0.021284854039549828, -0.03530672565102577, -0.026869306340813637, 0.027550984174013138, -0.017628928646445274, -0.08545146882534027, -0.014676807448267937, 0.014554250985383987, 0.04560014605522156, 0.025028714910149574, -0.02434997260570526, 0.00428850157186389, -0.011955450288951397, -0.03655362129211426, 0.028055794537067413, -0.04043889045715332, -0.015576398000121117, -0.02100667916238308, -0.02813706547021866, -0.03752320259809494, -0.00896593276411295, 0.004504780285060406, 0.0005117864930070937, -0.01599850133061409, -0.02198190614581108, -0.03248630091547966, 0.03101583756506443, -0.02060198225080967, 0.01921067200601101, -0.004764491692185402, 0.0042739929631352425, -0.003646131604909897, -0.007927813567221165, -0.033307481557130814, -0.036610156297683716, 0.0234232060611248, 0.0502217635512352, 0.050396159291267395, -0.02051389403641224, 0.05032021179795265, -0.03508612513542175, -0.01723148301243782, -0.03541112318634987, -0.047876134514808655, -0.11394963413476944, -0.023854028433561325, -0.04787971079349518, -0.014323612675070763, -0.015355965122580528, 0.03938181325793266, 0.009611273184418678, -0.006459636613726616, 0.018543213605880737, -0.02848806418478489, -0.027207227423787117, 0.01898595131933689, -0.029475485906004906, -0.051492251455783844, -0.023791223764419556, -0.004345813766121864, -0.00033027667086571455, 0.06465983390808105, 0.04569398611783981, 0.011246944777667522, 0.021643217653036118, 0.025771168991923332, 0.005563532933592796, 0.022627754136919975, -0.017730260267853737, -0.06817765533924103, 0.029123030602931976, -0.010016354732215405, -0.022028451785445213, -0.0169580839574337, -0.055457502603530884, 0.068949855864048, 0.032800931483507156, -0.012164703570306301, 0.013638745062053204, -0.026163510978221893, -0.01956784725189209, 0.00042707103420980275, -0.014584307558834553, 0.007850313559174538, 0.08519823849201202, -0.07489871233701706, 0.013065950945019722, 0.011835116893053055, -0.06610652059316635, 0.024643536657094955, -0.015206447802484035, 0.016503246501088142, 0.04227141663432121, 0.007324164733290672, 0.00022244920546654612, -0.007449090946465731, 0.02183903008699417, 0.06459607928991318, 0.02232755348086357, 0.03050445392727852, 0.025801971554756165, 0.04888294264674187, -0.020097512751817703, -0.016304481774568558, -0.019195109605789185, 0.0020334869623184204, 0.037141215056180954, 0.008676707744598389, -0.0400598868727684, 0.013548039831221104, 0.010685284622013569, 0.05113263800740242, -0.010730568319559097, -0.023296045139431953, 0.012131334282457829, 0.01732078194618225, 0.013943161815404892, -0.029785748571157455, -0.0525820255279541, 0.060198068618774414, -0.02594800479710102, 0.020215202122926712, -0.009759193286299706, -0.04721582680940628, -0.009539601393043995, 0.0017192228697240353, -0.06882821023464203, 0.030669040977954865, -0.004345528315752745, 0.01618383638560772, 0.011172034777700901, 0.014287031255662441, -0.0022962798830121756, -0.01035277172923088, -0.023693865165114403, -0.04643062874674797, 0.08301941305398941, 0.005223213694989681, -0.04982302710413933, -0.01094385702162981, -0.009405387565493584, 0.0039142523892223835, 0.04355161637067795, 0.02060694806277752, 0.008294024504721165, 0.04740636423230171, -0.018181035295128822, -0.01998489908874035, -0.04072421416640282, 0.04715975373983383, -0.0731249675154686, 0.049263350665569305, 0.006267768796533346, -0.039718564599752426, -0.08295950293540955, 0.02672918699681759, 0.038182053714990616, 0.009862096980214119, 0.04173438996076584, 0.005840367637574673, -0.01925281435251236, -0.052557457238435745, 0.0496530756354332, 0.09112116694450378, -0.02052154764533043, 0.009099690243601799, -0.038560718297958374, 0.045329414308071136, 0.04055626690387726, -0.03238915279507637, 0.02595209702849388, -0.04719990864396095, -0.024207329377532005, -0.039812151342630386, 0.06560209393501282, 0.018560338765382767, -0.017910132184624672, 0.06515958905220032, 0.04854081943631172, 0.022030066698789597, -0.00622042641043663, -0.006490564905107021, 0.022955462336540222, -0.005317457485944033, 0.015568893402814865, -0.0013532668817788363, -0.01541280560195446, 0.023505840450525284, -0.019087065011262894, -0.033823493868112564, -0.024831373244524002, 0.0006184098892845213, 0.0289500430226326, -0.02239004522562027, -0.008783877827227116, 0.07918823510408401, 0.026365943253040314, 0.03597145155072212, -0.025365369394421577, 0.013792676851153374, 0.013177053071558475, 0.04757146164774895, -0.024176783859729767, -0.09037763625383377, 0.049350474029779434, -0.0012912446400150657, -0.038456402719020844, -0.002141800941899419, -0.03616844117641449, -0.027046924456954002, -0.0746803879737854, -0.041174065321683884, -0.0025874441489577293, -0.01553004328161478, -0.01928652636706829, 0.0060043646954, 0.007906136102974415, 0.015936631709337234, -0.00410647876560688, 0.006140139419585466, -0.02979217655956745, 0.024237174540758133, 0.013445517979562283, -0.01617022603750229, -0.07376623153686523, 0.004943349864333868, -0.05289888009428978, 0.007206889800727367, -0.05885415896773338, 0.055382609367370605, 0.023195113986730576, -0.06839388608932495, -0.0073565649800002575, 0.0298994742333889, -0.04662247374653816, -0.025854092091321945, -0.04366367682814598, 0.013101331889629364, 0.015976957976818085, 0.10642798244953156, 0.037251297384500504, 0.004895061254501343, 0.007233082316815853, 0.039642661809921265, -0.027485966682434082, -0.006807411089539528, 0.022478727623820305, -0.04349789768457413, 0.019681166857481003, -0.06106008589267731, -0.024658067151904106, 0.013683020137250423, -0.04298523813486099, -0.014810041524469852, -0.0009866238106042147, 0.03327561169862747, 0.020522180944681168, -0.040125999599695206, -0.019685300067067146, -0.01234586350619793, 0.00038659549318253994, 0.10023485869169235, 0.0016364047769457102, -0.03526061400771141, -0.058599215000867844, 0.0482199601829052, 0.045223791152238846, 0.037649091333150864, -0.010259756818413734, -0.0120452381670475, -0.017919303849339485, 0.05084734782576561, 0.08569344133138657, -0.043883562088012695, 0.005069236736744642, 0.024862507358193398, 0.07623434066772461, -0.017627038061618805, -0.024679142981767654, 0.024699021130800247, -0.0321025587618351, 0.04924507066607475, -0.007126650307327509, 0.00016864377539604902, 0.05497823655605316, -0.0377461239695549, -0.0005338650662451982, -0.06195726618170738, -0.00947659183293581, 0.012913241982460022, 0.028929658234119415, 0.0024920024443417788, 0.03450947627425194, -0.04472984001040459, -0.02421870455145836, -0.020432934165000916, 0.013435541652143002, -0.03316355124115944, 0.047468673437833786, 0.03666123375296593, 0.02706591971218586, -0.043533824384212494, -0.04692244529724121, 0.009333646856248379, -0.0054984078742563725, -0.031662777066230774, -0.033112216740846634, -0.015459918417036533, -0.010222568176686764, 0.02597670815885067, 0.02674931101500988, 0.028275301679968834, 0.0388609915971756, -0.03799420967698097, -0.035741645842790604, -0.04029815271496773, 0.002373554278165102, -0.03252435475587845, 0.07807910442352295, 0.039369065314531326, -0.0785963162779808, -0.021942146122455597, 0.050277918577194214, 0.013819891028106213, -0.052881065756082535, -0.0728830099105835, 0.030464904382824898, 0.007823647931218147, 0.03830175846815109, -0.05798414349555969, 0.018112804740667343, 0.0020629579667001963, 0.02656690403819084, -0.019052451476454735, 0.05212128907442093, -0.04933803901076317, -0.03154081851243973, 0.0574839785695076, 0.008306389674544334, 0.09181363880634308, 0.03369034081697464, -0.08891402930021286, 0.03090909868478775, -0.019272055476903915, -0.037266261875629425, 0.04387805610895157, 0.045680731534957886, 0.010600429028272629, -0.006554576102644205, -0.07196490466594696, -0.010260773822665215, 0.0003805799933616072, 0.016830096021294594, -0.03820962831377983, -0.048271987587213516, 0.01655750349164009, -0.004430656787008047, 0.09767835587263107, -0.06391826272010803, -0.030215444043278694, 0.0058149369433522224, 0.040168534964323044, 0.029175709933042526, 0.040803514420986176, -0.006456949282437563, 0.0033654801081866026, -0.020025786012411118, -0.019735252484679222, 0.009126024320721626, -0.008892945945262909, 0.03635212033987045, -0.01560604851692915, 0.03747555613517761, -0.049782801419496536, 0.0372021310031414, -0.006142697762697935, 0.00798578280955553, 0.01416475884616375, -0.0440940298140049, -0.0009305909043177962, -0.061749789863824844, 0.03689040243625641, 0.00515790143981576, -0.03830178081989288, 0.04478413984179497, -0.03511781245470047, 0.00969128217548132, -0.0024076085537672043, -0.046068549156188965, -0.01799316704273224, 0.006177470088005066, -0.01203091163188219, -0.028345780447125435, -0.05684022232890129, -0.01812971755862236, -0.018128350377082825, 0.016068028286099434, -0.049990564584732056, 0.03497276082634926, -0.014229722321033478, -0.047835856676101685, 0.0013504730304703116, 0.0338946171104908, -0.006560332607477903, -0.021910369396209717, 0.020711509510874748, -0.0108358608558774, -0.0233925748616457, -0.036392007023096085, -0.04660523682832718, -0.015548327006399632, 0.012274296954274178, 0.003113636514171958, -0.0017632974777370691, 0.04012344032526016, -0.058497827500104904, 0.005105732940137386, 0.0030026393942534924, 0.0018941204762086272, 0.04012115299701691, 0.013304447755217552, -0.046885401010513306, 0.07580836117267609, -0.01082554366439581, 0.0372735820710659, -0.07608728110790253, -0.004988718777894974, 0.003138198284432292, -0.037326592952013016, 0.002241526497527957, -0.02835727296769619, 0.00795852579176426, -0.07945555448532104, 0.04192192852497101, 0.03243939206004143, -0.006973711773753166, 0.03617018833756447, 0.03183120861649513, -0.039763495326042175, -0.0828796923160553, -0.013943522237241268, 0.00322585366666317, 0.029907364398241043, 0.024777082726359367, -0.019851038232445717, -0.040584102272987366, 0.012468774802982807, -0.034090545028448105, 0.018142743036150932, -0.03888240456581116, 0.02192402258515358, -0.012266706675291061, 0.005156767088919878, -0.02646169625222683, -0.03333587571978569, -0.01876082643866539, -0.06143764778971672, -0.007970906794071198, -0.04583650454878807, 0.0247675571590662, 0.00813505332916975, 0.0027456614188849926, -0.0006308432784862816, -0.03909658268094063, 0.00196016114205122, 0.015323023311793804, 0.0874256119132042, -0.051118697971105576, -0.004278938286006451, 0.0005725324735976756, -0.006028375588357449, -0.05310666933655739, -0.021431881934404373, 0.014687138609588146, 0.005503724329173565, 0.023285837844014168, -0.04230264201760292, 0.02413414604961872, 0.03559769690036774, 0.015318423509597778, 0.013684071600437164, -0.06903205066919327, 0.02827906794846058, -0.060655683279037476, -0.003115445375442505, 0.011741393245756626, -0.007827727124094963, -0.00418463908135891, -0.000358403951395303, 0.04741959273815155, 0.05052370950579643, 0.02166726067662239, 0.031042519956827164, -0.03184003755450249, -0.08136863261461258, 0.011509784497320652, -0.028254495933651924, -0.08631037175655365, -0.014939269050955772, -0.009846706874668598, 0.020219316706061363, -0.05066315457224846, -0.011992231011390686, -0.00009823705477174371, 0.08239053934812546 ]
<p>I have a (probably) simple question regarding boundary conditions. In electrostatic simulations, the relevant Maxwell equation is $\nabla \cdot \mathbf{D}=\rho$ where $\mathbf{E}=-\nabla V$, and $\mathbf{D}$ is related to $\mathbf{E}$ through any applicable constitutive relations. When a floating-potential metal object is embedded inside a domain, I've read that the relevant boundary condition for the metal surface is $$\int_{\partial\Omega}\mathbf{D}\cdot\mathbf{n}dS=0.$$ For example, in this picture the red square is at potential 1V, the blue square is at 0V and the bottom edge is an electrically-isolated metal surface: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/pXMWv.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Is there a simple explanation for why the integral boundary condition indeed describes a floating equipotential metal surface? The source I found it in (COMSOL's documentation) does not provide a derivation. Apologies if this is intro E/M stuff that I've just forgotten. I keep thinking of using the divergence theorem, but the boundary $\partial\Omega$ does not necessarily enclose a space over which a volume integration may be performed.</p>
g9802
[ 0.11342967301607132, 0.04524725675582886, -0.005567999090999365, -0.06775104254484177, 0.05051499977707863, 0.07090892642736435, 0.06866644322872162, -0.015731291845440865, -0.044705767184495926, -0.03043772652745247, -0.008988257497549057, 0.037797555327415466, -0.012516148388385773, 0.03223699703812599, -0.022326739504933357, 0.011227048002183437, -0.02872876264154911, -0.02931530959904194, -0.012196457013487816, 0.01821376197040081, -0.00441779987886548, 0.058661043643951416, -0.012883842922747135, 0.019631873816251755, 0.05716988071799278, -0.008843783289194107, 0.05915893241763115, -0.06217176839709282, -0.0074937110766768456, -0.043943651020526886, -0.028318889439105988, 0.05195717513561249, 0.041429921984672546, -0.0023870959412306547, -0.06657246500253677, -0.015853440389037132, 0.048698119819164276, 0.021191155537962914, -0.009263649582862854, -0.060921426862478256, 0.0583946593105793, -0.05467178672552109, -0.009239536710083485, 0.04352308809757233, 0.01128266379237175, -0.04441632330417633, -0.04294530674815178, -0.043218642473220825, -0.00811066571623087, -0.03342027962207794, -0.0016000254545360804, 0.06361257284879684, 0.004159008618444204, -0.07015759497880936, -0.016498927026987076, 0.007937134243547916, 0.03718293830752373, 0.007971074432134628, -0.0022792601957917213, 0.024875802919268608, 0.030548909679055214, -0.03042624145746231, -0.026408726349473, 0.003864060156047344, 0.06215297058224678, -0.0033497256226837635, -0.02083955705165863, 0.0091466149315238, -0.01706969179213047, -0.011810247786343098, 0.028191957622766495, 0.007199237588793039, 0.029424970969557762, -0.05220463499426842, -0.03062504716217518, 0.02452734299004078, 0.028773318976163864, -0.027196528390049934, 0.027991723269224167, -0.059563565999269485, -0.015179724432528019, -0.0546618215739727, 0.05271199345588684, 0.030930910259485245, -0.001961126923561096, 0.03645633906126022, -0.009350700303912163, -0.00672666123136878, -0.01305478811264038, -0.035792089998722076, -0.023422647267580032, -0.004579369444400072, 0.011774133890867233, 0.001759482896886766, 0.043571460992097855, 0.02203473076224327, 0.022954825311899185, 0.0445559024810791, -0.018983948975801468, -0.07047832757234573, 0.009796956554055214, -0.00677048834040761, 0.006589582189917564, 0.019782479852437973, -0.025017084553837776, 0.02525286003947258, 0.044570181518793106, 0.018696293234825134, -0.005027998238801956, 0.004577187355607748, -0.033923715353012085, -0.004847385920584202, -0.06693515926599503, -0.032161276787519455, -0.0014652820536866784, 0.014255234971642494, 0.04155907407402992, -0.026841262355446815, -0.0339805893599987, 0.009130014106631279, -0.0033908416517078876, -0.006532397586852312, 0.04781780391931534, 0.016998011618852615, 0.005333067383617163, -0.017817525193095207, -0.004497522488236427, 0.009356964379549026, 0.022509925067424774, 0.0017032644245773554, 0.02168118767440319, 0.043695319443941116, -0.04767083004117012, -0.023124191910028458, 0.0033199007157236338, -0.007965481840074062, -0.020875602960586548, -0.048169929534196854, 0.019339151680469513, -0.015578977763652802, -0.00917898304760456, -0.01266684290021658, -0.05949537828564644, -0.03490356355905533, -0.03944109380245209, 0.004378685262054205, -0.004615941550582647, -0.04181357100605965, -0.0037927355151623487, 0.06952475011348724, 0.022857539355754852, 0.03305894881486893, 0.004738500341773033, -0.06901908665895462, -0.013434738852083683, 0.0203058160841465, 0.05632598698139191, -0.05573811009526253, 0.09294481575489044, 0.014714359305799007, 0.04821019247174263, 0.04987382888793945, -0.027425622567534447, 0.001292938250117004, -0.01857866905629635, 0.012151673436164856, -0.004387137480080128, -0.04753158986568451, -0.0006069861119613051, -0.05336834117770195, -0.007540362887084484, 0.012800192460417747, -0.00722208246588707, 0.05248419940471649, 0.029939550906419754, 0.018175063654780388, -0.004590451717376709, -0.030972469598054886, 0.036155011504888535, 0.012473332695662975, -0.01348466519266367, -0.032754167914390564, 0.02683109976351261, 0.010298244655132294, 0.00002062756902887486, -0.0546562559902668, -0.00989505648612976, 0.015200006775557995, 0.009940467774868011, 0.05027206242084503, -0.04327056184411049, 0.03486013785004616, -0.017904868349432945, -0.025030888617038727, -0.006874172016978264, 0.029780808836221695, 0.07965297251939774, -0.035229627043008804, -0.015561692416667938, -0.07565043121576309, -0.020157426595687866, 0.07271196693181992, 0.04138949513435364, 0.018031533807516098, 0.020617740228772163, 0.015703996643424034, -0.028156477957963943, 0.006892540492117405, 0.05025052651762962, 0.015774158760905266, 0.020675307139754295, -0.01922391727566719, 0.058954279869794846, 0.005745287984609604, 0.03264874592423439, -0.021999109536409378, 0.01067083328962326, 0.031557340174913406, -0.0682644248008728, 0.013583294115960598, -0.016172252595424652, -0.02446640096604824, 0.0378837063908577, 0.0034524425864219666, -0.018116304650902748, 0.015577632933855057, 0.0037474161945283413, 0.05637402832508087, 0.002239357214421034, 0.02955397590994835, -0.06830710172653198, 0.00401616096496582, 0.04864940419793129, -0.023643067106604576, 0.014170310460031033, 0.019892005249857903, -0.03566206246614456, 0.012531282380223274, -0.021632760763168335, -0.012936792336404324, 0.021898305043578148, -0.022626914083957672, -0.034761495888233185, -0.01355381403118372, -0.03659818693995476, -0.016005806624889374, 0.0024853621143847704, 0.04240982234477997, -0.020870374515652657, 0.020797882229089737, -0.0027308885473757982, -0.03132916986942291, 0.00659550353884697, 0.015027792192995548, 0.004915401339530945, -0.04676832631230354, -0.061798688024282455, 0.011084040626883507, 0.01213340274989605, -0.027470270171761513, -0.011348642408847809, -0.05131568759679794, 0.011253266595304012, 0.030692951753735542, -0.0743069052696228, -0.0017734764842316508, -0.06961016356945038, 0.016781454905867577, 0.08254565298557281, 0.05384767800569534, 0.04760199785232544, 0.0008104534936137497, -0.035158511251211166, 0.046580828726291656, 0.00913687888532877, -0.048638589680194855, 0.008604505099356174, -0.050007011741399765, 0.053931087255477905, 0.009076033718883991, -0.047811541706323624, -0.04854309931397438, -0.02764470875263214, 0.06036529690027237, -0.04275776073336601, -0.05760424956679344, 0.012674463912844658, 0.0014954537618905306, 0.021742073819041252, -0.013109778985381126, -0.03451674059033394, -0.029710600152611732, -0.028444405645132065, 0.0090250913053751, 0.002327313181012869, 0.018643414601683617, -0.02646460384130478, -0.03767681494355202, 0.013253995217382908, -0.01030329242348671, 0.008835062384605408, 0.014662063680589199, 0.02222524769604206, 0.006939092185348272, -0.030295919626951218, 0.058043550699949265, -0.012618541717529297, -0.02811882458627224, 0.03240831568837166, -0.05383024737238884, 0.007882723584771156, 0.08881762623786926, 0.016752049326896667, 0.0028763054870069027, -0.02838546223938465, -0.016940437257289886, 0.04070751741528511, -0.05278291553258896, -0.05732814595103264, -0.06651190668344498, -0.07721560448408127, -0.01273661945015192, 0.050525568425655365, 0.026860753074288368, 0.06114407256245613, 0.030956488102674484, 0.0067160180769860744, 0.03613555431365967, -0.014415248297154903, 0.02720756269991398, 0.03058275394141674, -0.006111547816544771, 0.03535105288028717, 0.013093211688101292, -0.03053680993616581, -0.02944329008460045, 0.003346188459545374, 0.02275741845369339, 0.05013135075569153, -0.0002970111963804811, -0.024726299569010735, -0.06564045697450638, 0.009053193032741547, -0.0029506320133805275, -0.006635322701185942, -0.04238555207848549, -0.020078938454389572, 0.04475245252251625, 0.019622817635536194, 0.0024990455713123083, 0.03847242519259453, -0.007277006283402443, 0.050709959119558334, -0.009293819777667522, -0.02258988469839096, 0.01685095950961113, 0.05422398820519447, 0.03669937327504158, -0.02521907165646553, 0.0324089340865612, 0.02669679746031761, -0.00778060220181942, -0.00472340127453208, -0.05029982328414917, 0.04718112200498581, -0.015263507142663002, 0.008938316255807877, 0.043673787266016006, -0.04302069917321205, -0.06692399829626083, 0.023391591385006905, -0.03580019250512123, -0.01478038914501667, 0.049100689589977264, 0.07645950466394424, -0.0707298293709755, -0.027986424043774605, 0.016363896429538727, 0.027982652187347412, -0.03128388524055481, 0.05274660512804985, 0.05650738254189491, 0.055404093116521835, 0.008621511049568653, -0.03208714351058006, 0.043242085725069046, 0.009121973067522049, 0.03438455983996391, 0.0003750848991330713, -0.09523102641105652, -0.0056291744112968445, 0.00410740589722991, -0.052966710180044174, -0.00012111292744521052, 0.00868949294090271, 0.015392557717859745, -0.018860671669244766, 0.005977471824735403, 0.03496978059411049, 0.0015689062420278788, 0.021418966352939606, -0.0289707463234663, -0.05883513018488884, 0.03028123825788498, -0.002571174642071128, -0.034567344933748245, 0.011673490516841412, -0.044187724590301514, -0.04835713654756546, -0.010666209273040295, 0.025417692959308624, -0.02599995769560337, -0.04491608589887619, -0.0023233091924339533, -0.018623868003487587, 0.005126411560922861, -0.013747485354542732, 0.022278273478150368, 0.006696921307593584, -0.006813167128711939, -0.01066976971924305, 0.006499481853097677, -0.03228402137756348, 0.03683377429842949, 0.02286660484969616, 0.040289368480443954, 0.04963981732726097, -0.0017126314342021942, -0.008024456910789013, 0.005905827507376671, -0.04072103276848793, 0.060919519513845444, -0.08966783434152603, 0.02320096269249916, -0.060656942427158356, 0.058368172496557236, -0.05406258627772331, 0.04185609892010689, -0.03309420123696327, 0.061005331575870514, 0.04586784541606903, -0.004698755219578743, -0.009839534759521484, -0.021764252334833145, 0.020889440551400185, 0.05183317884802818, -0.01695968769490719, -0.06202881783246994, 0.028956228867173195, -0.0075670876540243626, -0.02666468732059002, -0.02795942686498165, -0.00013430965191219002, -0.010609360411763191, -0.058409396559000015, -0.06029544398188591, 0.0030404096469283104, -0.018931813538074493, -0.03486118093132973, -0.0166154932230711, 0.007922982797026634, -0.019367877393960953, -0.05911256745457649, -0.015123939141631126, 0.018169725313782692, -0.026449909433722496, 0.015617718920111656, 0.03398151695728302, -0.06525510549545288, 0.043093323707580566, 0.05295578017830849, 0.10998190194368362, 0.04656251519918442, 0.01712288334965706, 0.02328537404537201, 0.06670999526977539, 0.052242472767829895, -0.0058812848292291164, -0.018197257071733475, -0.050759151577949524, -0.0015717224450781941, 0.02682543359696865, 0.011148619465529919, 0.07025768607854843, -0.007672369480133057, 0.04764002934098244, -0.029164595529437065, 0.03768294304609299, -0.04164279252290726, 0.009492882527410984, 0.014071489684283733, -0.05852389335632324, -0.016261380165815353, 0.025089779868721962, -0.02195272035896778, -0.03100467100739479, -0.004916809964925051, 0.000345533830113709, -0.01064674649387598, -0.025634586811065674, -0.02986033447086811, -0.023501740768551826, -0.012268093414604664, -0.014539072290062904, 0.03113527223467827, 0.05659870058298111, 0.011832942254841328, -0.06424446403980255, 0.05489209666848183, -0.019798222929239273, -0.003139670705422759, 0.011144369840621948, 0.0034735635854303837, 0.011355588212609291, 0.03871004655957222, -0.057435885071754456, -0.07577400654554367, 0.03338467702269554, -0.02222503535449505, 0.008235550485551357, 0.019111741334199905, 0.014798211865127087, -0.03886532783508301, -0.045354604721069336, 0.05725070834159851, 0.011152911931276321, 0.024880969896912575, -0.06828511506319046, -0.009876922704279423, 0.07526081800460815, 0.004899419844150543, 0.03115673176944256, 0.013778275810182095, -0.021752402186393738, 0.00308137945830822, -0.05440162494778633, 0.00010875925363507122, -0.030147304758429527, 0.03711805120110512, 0.04423721879720688, 0.023560136556625366, -0.02598261833190918, -0.011449568904936314, 0.05416598543524742, -0.01607588864862919, 0.012493615970015526, -0.011546170338988304, 0.03437891975045204, 0.007709072437137365, -0.07761157304048538, 0.01913302019238472, -0.018147628754377365, -0.052399661391973495, 0.054691120982170105, 0.010499650612473488, -0.017925366759300232, -0.01619533635675907, 0.016631459817290306, -0.038245052099227905, -0.06865401566028595, 0.08296163380146027, -0.004731718450784683, 0.010272270068526268, -0.012087654322385788, -0.005882394500076771, -0.03749746084213257, 0.015544435009360313, 0.06082044169306755, 0.035998422652482986, -0.014941119588911533, 0.00268709403462708, -0.02661263383924961, 0.042350273579359055, 0.010187530890107155, -0.0012715806951746345, 0.02147248387336731, -0.057053983211517334, -0.010707353241741657, -0.0002596834965515882, -0.007371759973466396, -0.041987210512161255, 0.038504458963871, 0.017149727791547775, -0.03758212924003601, 0.03446299582719803, 0.00038580282125622034, -0.08794908970594406, -0.06690342724323273, -0.0029074603226035833, -0.042809486389160156, -0.003902390133589506, 0.008083333261311054, 0.05395575985312462, -0.0023315800353884697, 0.006551367696374655, 0.03985120356082916, 0.02439216524362564, 0.056345365941524506, 0.02158696949481964, 0.033682454377412796, 0.06543739885091782, 0.017302118241786957, 0.019362539052963257, -0.007021166384220123, 0.03741323947906494, 0.013509848155081272, 0.016228187829256058, -0.02749434858560562, -0.056498654186725616, -0.021065352484583855, 0.023028003051877022, 0.04404737055301666, -0.021005302667617798, -0.042991288006305695, 0.0001199167309096083, -0.016041850671172142, -0.026187436655163765, -0.0002749971463344991, -0.0023885827977210283, 0.045073866844177246, -0.014806498773396015, -0.004095610696822405, 0.013470840640366077, -0.01734762266278267, 0.029633482918143272, -0.04353872314095497, -0.05044817179441452, -0.011847948655486107, 0.032818835228681564, 0.02229451946914196, 0.07284028083086014, -0.00612703338265419, 0.027972159907221794, -0.01814086362719536, -0.012099010869860649, 0.05697239562869072, 0.03989553079009056, -0.016342375427484512, 0.04333993420004845, 0.021608369424939156, -0.0734151303768158, 0.019114980474114418, 0.033843521028757095, 0.026555771008133888, -0.0450872965157032, -0.03418684005737305, 0.02972610481083393, -0.0007087929989211261, -0.026353683322668076, 0.0027796507347375154, 0.060032594949007034, -0.012015554122626781, -0.09677637368440628, -0.015366737730801105, -0.05516914650797844, 0.007810722570866346, 0.004598923493176699, -0.024695856496691704, -0.05846983566880226, 0.01822521537542343, -0.025821154937148094, -0.01665705442428589, -0.054899055510759354, -0.0353800393640995, -0.004127133637666702, -0.006380388513207436, 0.04119753837585449, -0.03256231173872948, -0.030826793983578682, -0.06351310759782791, 0.005471320357173681, -0.036287955939769745, 0.013237467035651207, 0.09458065032958984, -0.00538749760016799, 0.049124594777822495, 0.0229350533336401, 0.05860424414277077, 0.010556685738265514, 0.010951902717351913, 0.015135250054299831, 0.051993709057569504, -0.03050021268427372, -0.03308211639523506, -0.0291144996881485, -0.04842647537589073, -0.037043262273073196, -0.014886625111103058, -0.0006719715311191976, 0.04312603920698166, 0.07022316753864288, 0.014118068851530552, -0.004029606003314257, 0.033881403505802155, -0.013604436069726944, -0.00035597136593423784, 0.06893877685070038, 0.09793392568826675, 0.11558247357606888, -0.017379185184836388, -0.0451485738158226, -0.04362744092941284, -0.00918504036962986, -0.04717738926410675, 0.012464097701013088, 0.0036784012336283922, -0.03206830844283104, 0.018537120893597603, -0.04437217861413956, -0.0017460363451391459, 0.06464620679616928, 0.02175772190093994, 0.027037398889660835, -0.07161684334278107, -0.006770456209778786, 0.019880104809999466, -0.02544180490076542, -0.0033609780948609114, 0.03407422825694084, 0.01654922403395176, 0.014770404435694218, 0.028693579137325287, -0.017061971127986908, -0.028801003471016884, 0.0048004877753555775, -0.06625695526599884, -0.03884131461381912, -0.036542024463415146, 0.00969854649156332, -0.011171117424964905, -0.0580582357943058, -0.022910619154572487, 0.0015925646293908358, 0.012971675023436546, -0.006803931202739477, -0.03299729526042938, 0.05674735829234123, -0.001713296165689826, 0.06442015618085861, -0.05496467649936676, 0.038836751133203506, -0.08331584930419922, 0.020180653780698776, -0.0245114304125309, -0.02649577334523201, -0.009930678643286228, -0.04640493169426918, 0.0005392375751398504, 0.040676962584257126, 0.019474143162369728, -0.02780928462743759, 0.003047919599339366, -0.03064754791557789, 0.006117603275924921, 0.05845082178711891, -0.07504356652498245, -0.014386373572051525, -0.0008519154507666826, 0.02946661040186882, 0.04348420724272728, -0.035305630415678024, -0.011702877469360828, 0.007135805673897266, -0.008454594761133194, -0.02139168605208397, -0.07987909764051437, -0.006323057692497969, 0.057067714631557465 ]
<p>What is the reason for the observation that across the board fields in physics are generally governed by second order (partial) differential equations?</p> <hr> <p>If someone on the street would flat out ask me that question, then I'd probably mumble something about physicists wanting to be able to use the Lagrangian approach. And to allow a positive rotation and translation invariant energy term, which allows for local propagation, you need something like $-\phi\Delta\phi$.</p> <p>I assume the answer goes in this direction, but I can't really justify why more complex terms in the Lagrangian are not allowed or why higher orders are a physical problem. Even if these require more initial data, I don't see the a priori problem.</p> <p>Furthermore you could come up with quantities in the spirit of $F\wedge F$ and $F \wedge *F$ and okay yes... maybe any made up scalar just doesn't describe physics or misses valuable symmetries. On there other hand in the whole renormalization business, they seem to be allowed to use lots and lots of terms in their Lagrangians. And if I understand correctly, supersymmetry theory is basically a method of introducing new Lagrangian densities too. </p> <p>Do we know the limit for making up these objects? What is the fundamental justification for order two?</p>
g257
[ 0.0637379065155983, 0.05545594170689583, -0.01627170667052269, -0.02025175839662552, 0.03582257032394409, -0.022632237523794174, 0.0332791805267334, 0.07106947153806686, -0.05003859102725983, -0.05786082521080971, -0.0026232642121613026, -0.012460404075682163, 0.008889015763998032, 0.021304165944457054, -0.026441700756549835, -0.02010917477309704, 0.003937564790248871, -0.007129265461117029, 0.037785854190588, -0.004154089372605085, -0.044854097068309784, -0.0009196272003464401, 0.051862623542547226, -0.04673037305474281, -0.07266432791948318, 0.03526818007230759, 0.05283695459365845, -0.05558251589536667, -0.01851942203938961, -0.04580437391996384, 0.015842344611883163, 0.011754753068089485, 0.04937177523970604, -0.04272165894508362, -0.029017146676778793, -0.05136818438768387, 0.0016109729185700417, -0.005150509066879749, 0.06705933064222336, -0.0015662546502426267, -0.010990319773554802, -0.08247797191143036, 0.01450874749571085, -0.08203277736902237, -0.021843958646059036, -0.024419933557510376, -0.04415573179721832, -0.004537566564977169, 0.004142845515161753, -0.026494380086660385, 0.047558922320604324, 0.012954535894095898, 0.05766110494732857, -0.00016795581905171275, -0.02185347117483616, 0.04338248819112778, 0.004049786366522312, 0.012753848917782307, 0.0701460987329483, -0.01172824576497078, -0.004897295497357845, -0.012255564332008362, 0.004591459408402443, -0.023558512330055237, 0.06496939808130264, -0.014799048192799091, -0.047472383826971054, -0.020101290196180344, 0.007889057509601116, 0.043376125395298004, 0.011898042634129524, -0.07474792748689651, 0.00332456617616117, -0.07450133562088013, -0.0029954323545098305, 0.0012423102743923664, -0.0421762652695179, -0.0017435651971027255, 0.01943984627723694, -0.02159672975540161, -0.06101716309785843, -0.016188111156225204, -0.004106191452592611, 0.040702879428863525, 0.10007727146148682, -0.012332426384091377, 0.03007378615438938, 0.022489964962005615, 0.008588013239204884, 0.0420881025493145, 0.016891570761799812, -0.014512419700622559, 0.04559500887989998, 0.0032299852464348078, -0.010986093431711197, -0.0006934953271411359, 0.0034101037308573723, 0.02345212735235691, -0.0019532472360879183, -0.0215790793299675, -0.037103720009326935, 0.051567938178777695, 0.04731966182589531, 0.058531131595373154, 0.004110140260308981, 0.0059099639765918255, 0.060131870210170746, 0.036901745945215225, 0.029570627957582474, 0.011321132071316242, 0.003234227653592825, 0.06783093512058258, -0.010976527817547321, 0.013841578736901283, -0.058786541223526, 0.0033767803106456995, 0.04816307872533798, -0.03293178603053093, -0.012086804956197739, 0.0660482868552208, 0.030051985755562782, -0.018165603280067444, 0.030273353680968285, 0.056791167706251144, -0.02714107558131218, 0.023271510377526283, -0.010998477227985859, -0.010436042211949825, 0.03480302542448044, -0.02833741158246994, 0.0023179654963314533, -0.018254023045301437, -0.01565326191484928, 0.016878070309758186, -0.01261594332754612, 0.04050281643867493, -0.007295482791960239, 0.028463760390877724, 0.04793768376111984, -0.06475137174129486, -0.005316880531609058, -0.036522358655929565, 0.006895385682582855, -0.039949096739292145, 0.03621857240796089, -0.00006974179268581793, 0.03578534349799156, -0.008012915030121803, -0.003316357731819153, -0.0030430590268224478, -0.013615606352686882, 0.07557788491249084, 0.01644890382885933, -0.004321516025811434, 0.03443894535303116, 0.007437598891556263, 0.04113292321562767, -0.026538779959082603, 0.03121495619416237, -0.019232774153351784, 0.06946613639593124, 0.009620290249586105, -0.02788582071661949, 0.015653690323233604, 0.0049069710075855255, 0.05026139318943024, 0.008935865014791489, -0.024636687710881233, -0.04271398112177849, -0.017504917457699776, -0.07156427949666977, 0.013511396944522858, 0.004573811311274767, 0.06689473241567612, 0.009189228527247906, 0.08965978026390076, -0.01669890433549881, -0.034395910799503326, 0.03040349669754505, 0.05882679671049118, -0.08310563862323761, -0.022672591730952263, -0.02597617357969284, -0.011016028933227062, 0.007167777977883816, 0.00711053004488349, -0.030741896480321884, 0.0409640409052372, 0.0036422531120479107, 0.008868888020515442, 0.0068907286040484905, 0.02032526582479477, -0.02276286482810974, 0.04616669937968254, -0.0034046038053929806, 0.05459043011069298, -0.0018501206068322062, -0.03058725595474243, -0.04423847794532776, 0.0338296964764595, 0.004993251990526915, 0.04448770359158516, 0.023350419476628304, -0.05146463215351105, 0.005436732433736324, 0.035328593105077744, -0.06057627126574516, 0.018361400812864304, 0.03857959061861038, 0.003160472959280014, 0.024907683953642845, -0.06335718184709549, 0.014135253615677357, 0.04804399237036705, -0.02083098515868187, -0.08617966622114182, 0.009426225908100605, 0.003734078025445342, -0.025558289140462875, 0.06887742131948471, -0.024814510717988014, -0.040666863322257996, 0.03138556331396103, 0.0206441693007946, -0.032509125769138336, 0.0418180488049984, -0.017832359299063683, -0.04516693949699402, -0.011673145927488804, 0.012865673750638962, -0.056163232773542404, -0.034251436591148376, 0.01613282971084118, -0.0017140815034508705, 0.04423543065786362, -0.015970908105373383, -0.0225517638027668, -0.006828631274402142, 0.07671933621168137, 0.04907859489321709, 0.010258345864713192, -0.003306719707325101, -0.015414228662848473, 0.02320324257016182, 0.08171446621417999, -0.05147522687911987, 0.08914618194103241, 0.027696190401911736, -0.03552405163645744, 0.014518028125166893, 0.007641751319169998, -0.051397234201431274, -0.07872042059898376, -0.012935233302414417, -0.01835346408188343, -0.04565995931625366, 0.03217208385467529, 0.07843534648418427, -0.02069172076880932, -0.04831660911440849, 0.011820259504020214, 0.003147426061332226, 0.02671610377728939, -0.004467176739126444, -0.07095732539892197, 0.012300219386816025, -0.04807593673467636, 0.012348243035376072, 0.009573446586728096, 0.003729633055627346, -0.011168264783918858, 0.056556835770606995, 0.017720595002174377, 0.008767642080783844, -0.004635392222553492, 0.025707649067044258, 0.021789291873574257, -0.011232097633183002, 0.021235523745417595, -0.014464974403381348, -0.010148570872843266, -0.08137794584035873, -0.00892859511077404, 0.06851378828287125, 0.056511376053094864, -0.03995692729949951, 0.03785499185323715, -0.048667583614587784, -0.022765979170799255, 0.04478533938527107, -0.0018023777520284057, 0.020511498674750328, -0.011289809830486774, 0.020888760685920715, -0.04382490739226341, -0.0012477650307118893, -0.032330602407455444, -0.05483364313840866, -0.0016226612497121096, -0.014764737337827682, 0.000004737311428471003, -0.01366235688328743, 0.06342451274394989, 0.0329759418964386, -0.004987027961760759, -0.020277252420783043, -0.011890590190887451, -0.027519049122929573, 0.03187107294797897, -0.004772039595991373, 0.028107725083827972, 0.04227127507328987, -0.023030798882246017, -0.011626336723566055, -0.03524370491504669, -0.024924835190176964, 0.011282917112112045, 0.015826839953660965, 0.04691147431731224, -0.03809178248047829, -0.020380474627017975, -0.007455372717231512, 0.028074944391846657, -0.01638769917190075, 0.04377720132470131, 0.0653965100646019, -0.06427615135908127, 0.026148539036512375, -0.02311757765710354, -0.0497809536755085, 0.023822637274861336, -0.007937007583677769, -0.00959996972233057, -0.004941131453961134, -0.03888438269495964, -0.027965093031525612, -0.05898312106728554, -0.014504761435091496, 0.06038862094283104, -0.021219277754426003, -0.07702290266752243, -0.04621674120426178, -0.09675715118646622, 0.06196441128849983, 0.03703348711133003, 0.026799872517585754, -0.03737792745232582, 0.006244227755814791, -0.019268831238150597, -0.040959782898426056, 0.005251261871308088, -0.017660677433013916, 0.028531240299344063, 0.006351409945636988, -0.02668720856308937, 0.061717770993709564, 0.08411503583192825, -0.010369688272476196, 0.008342322893440723, -0.004385013598948717, 0.006267633754760027, 0.024170245975255966, -0.03507372736930847, 0.013392653316259384, -0.021899770945310593, 0.024746548384428024, -0.024095995351672173, 0.00045848198351450264, -0.04773832485079765, -0.03789123147726059, 0.05094125494360924, -0.01720322296023369, -0.024879159405827522, -0.00013548527203965932, 0.029511725530028343, -0.01670035533607006, -0.008569762110710144, 0.042979903519153595, -0.034538548439741135, 0.019076591357588768, 0.030010733753442764, 0.038958590477705, 0.0003598330949898809, 0.00485680578276515, -0.01999884471297264, 0.03566842898726463, -0.07392952591180801, -0.014067086391150951, -0.017192300409078598, -0.005838504992425442, -0.004248589277267456, -0.0033271522261202335, -0.024655137211084366, -0.008983819745481014, 0.03065696731209755, -0.04988810420036316, -0.012620406225323677, 0.0031181746162474155, -0.006738143041729927, 0.017173804342746735, -0.02121405303478241, -0.05316467955708504, 0.01119559071958065, -0.022698508575558662, -0.01892179250717163, 0.009710305370390415, 0.018626807257533073, 0.018052199855446815, -0.000347576045896858, -0.0539034940302372, 0.03069606050848961, 0.016342053189873695, -0.016777409240603447, -0.08294328302145004, 0.03532765060663223, -0.050184216350317, -0.030480893328785896, -0.0752677246928215, -0.0261993370950222, -0.015552441589534283, 0.03399328887462616, 0.0036859551910310984, 0.06301900744438171, -0.02247794158756733, 0.01899801567196846, 0.08174288272857666, 0.03863372653722763, -0.06412149965763092, -0.04991038143634796, -0.06885745376348495, 0.01103122252970934, 0.011861761100590229, 0.0033773225732147694, 0.007232907228171825, -0.054857153445482254, -0.039001647382974625, -0.08677113801240921, 0.035804200917482376, -0.01893189363181591, 0.07343606650829315, 0.03054647147655487, -0.03979485481977463, 0.030695773661136627, -0.021516043692827225, 0.028079036623239517, -0.0031191508751362562, 0.0030516867991536856, -0.04229791462421417, -0.014839507639408112, -0.0035095473285764456, 0.010325422510504723, 0.006836665328592062, -0.017694061622023582, -0.018326042219996452, -0.006451102904975414, -0.024896711111068726, -0.047939594835042953, 0.007102509494870901, 0.019138693809509277, 0.004131128545850515, -0.05176959186792374, -0.04370638728141785, -0.033456530421972275, -0.0047853859141469, 0.0362839438021183, -0.008291730657219887, -0.06469473242759705, 0.0139523446559906, -0.058035094290971756, -0.05195755138993263, -0.004873555153608322, -0.02339806780219078, 0.03363235294818878, -0.015980856493115425, 0.03206854686141014, 0.012840239331126213, -0.02160053886473179, -0.00035924481926485896, -0.015970103442668915, -0.06865254044532776, -0.053091853857040405, 0.007592289242893457, 0.06173217296600342, 0.04155806079506874, -0.018603790551424026, -0.04154067113995552, -0.028770333155989647, -0.008925572037696838, -0.013180944137275219, -0.040324147790670395, 0.010581474751234055, 0.05391993746161461, 0.02049797587096691, 0.07129228860139847, -0.030268743634223938, 0.03835903853178024, 0.011552345007658005, -0.06582613289356232, -0.02524579130113125, -0.025289103388786316, -0.05496538057923317, 0.03989456221461296, 0.04613780230283737, -0.05776018276810646, -0.0032840254716575146, 0.04798183962702751, 0.13142912089824677, -0.027208395302295685, -0.027617644518613815, -0.007945866324007511, -0.0033080654684454203, -0.02773609198629856, -0.009225540794432163, -0.021905619651079178, 0.03653893247246742, -0.04938504099845886, 0.050404757261276245, -0.00033419026294723153, -0.06915230304002762, -0.03931407257914543, 0.021165339276194572, 0.012637073174118996, 0.046313997358083725, 0.0032593579962849617, -0.006102920044213533, 0.022222215309739113, -0.08149890601634979, -0.0257056076079607, 0.026864074170589447, 0.01174798235297203, 0.03468654304742813, 0.024085473269224167, -0.01362980343401432, -0.008556166663765907, -0.008873539045453072, -0.05731822922825813, -0.040900520980358124, 0.022160237655043602, -0.02937416546046734, -0.007975452579557896, -0.02149268239736557, -0.0026365332305431366, 0.020444760099053383, 0.03558759391307831, 0.0050699664279818535, 0.012525603175163269, 0.018752429634332657, -0.00743850227445364, 0.023223817348480225, -0.00018930045189335942, -0.03563731536269188, 0.0032290045637637377, 0.01628793217241764, -0.011063122190535069, -0.0003168343100696802, 0.05203542113304138, -0.058954402804374695, -0.04063034802675247, -0.010032315738499165, 0.018871905282139778, 0.05285230651497841, 0.030209681019186974, 0.03164706751704216, 0.002571934601292014, -0.0020122951827943325, -0.0335552878677845, 0.05268904194235802, 0.009478596039116383, -0.008724169805645943, 0.004952993243932724, -0.018859287723898888, 0.07815039157867432, 0.03718158230185509, 0.08030538260936737, 0.04903149977326393, -0.0070962123572826385, -0.0038461205549538136, -0.02756534330546856, -0.005352997686713934, -0.001467019785195589, -0.023780031129717827, 0.09266141802072525, 0.03266507759690285, -0.0026320796459913254, -0.030506018549203873, 0.06304704397916794, -0.03149864822626114, -0.007549231871962547, 0.023645665496587753, -0.015081887133419514, 0.01627662591636181, -0.018455689772963524, -0.005141273140907288, 0.007076432462781668, -0.002865498187020421, 0.05167371407151222, 0.0395323671400547, -0.022135917097330093, -0.04973715916275978, 0.026813656091690063, 0.0670761689543724, -0.003821217454969883, 0.01513659581542015, 0.018338171765208244, 0.024034401401877403, 0.025835173204541206, -0.037619784474372864, 0.060274239629507065, -0.017487358301877975, 0.023714005947113037, 0.007347376085817814, -0.015930889174342155, -0.003466807771474123, 0.010918774642050266, -0.004915174562484026, -0.028082724660634995, -0.016110142692923546, 0.08282288163900375, -0.010268260724842548, -0.03491109609603882, 0.02441967837512493, -0.010159789584577084, -0.05860103294253349, -0.024268677458167076, -0.008312607184052467, -0.0038839131593704224, -0.005308717954903841, 0.02626783587038517, 0.0829424187541008, 0.06741123646497726, 0.08467622846364975, 0.04294782504439354, 0.031021133065223694, 0.05801765248179436, 0.025180628523230553, 0.027836037799715996, -0.07277598232030869, 0.010294144041836262, -0.003981378395110369, -0.007051904685795307, 0.02468898333609104, 0.02287527173757553, 0.04241982847452164, -0.0459599569439888, -0.03316965326666832, 0.032551754266023636, 0.023587144911289215, -0.02259494923055172, -0.07837428152561188, 0.007264311891049147, 0.02854401245713234, -0.00856807641685009, -0.03912696987390518, -0.016663603484630585, -0.012959001585841179, 0.0020390613935887814, 0.00821529608219862, 0.013441355898976326, 0.011256804689764977, -0.018046686425805092, -0.03596577048301697, 0.05005272477865219, 0.03957546874880791, -0.004640523344278336, -0.023332973942160606, 0.017664127051830292, -0.05801217257976532, -0.011688869446516037, 0.03702661767601967, -0.0006574564031325281, -0.0018083107424899936, -0.040296535938978195, -0.07572954893112183, 0.035358164459466934, -0.0013796003768220544, -0.03201275318861008, 0.015697473660111427, 0.015539679676294327, 0.009403914213180542, 0.03164113312959671, 0.04135627672076225, 0.03920995816588402, 0.026986267417669296, -0.020864946767687798, -0.04993399977684021, 0.06213860213756561, 0.028842691332101822, 0.020905736833810806, -0.031189732253551483, -0.0035583190619945526, 0.0028117229230701923, -0.04264407604932785, -0.013864581473171711, 0.029391368851065636, -0.0470794215798378, -0.01957731880247593, 0.024748828262090683, 0.0694366991519928, 0.004423155449330807, -0.008883120492100716, 0.010126946493983269, 0.00781415868550539, -0.04061361029744148, -0.026352573186159134, 0.042593684047460556, -0.02496699057519436, 0.03847620636224747, -0.06503058969974518, -0.037383515387773514, -0.0027968930080533028, -0.028770027682185173, 0.02839330956339836, 0.05107961595058441, 0.0539327934384346, 0.04051128402352333, 0.0282113216817379, -0.016339024528861046, -0.009854513220489025, -0.05006466805934906, -0.02160933054983616, 0.03183472901582718, 0.015343361534178257, 0.007803936023265123, -0.060544539242982864, 0.024376381188631058, -0.018673641607165337, -0.00314317480660975, -0.06934903562068939, -0.011398030444979668, 0.035474859178066254, -0.04799864813685417, -0.0033174080308526754, -0.016069047152996063, 0.07138335704803467, -0.06850194185972214, -0.009045329876244068, 0.0009188667754642665, -0.041900187730789185, -0.0023155303206294775, -0.026941007003188133, 0.0280365701764822, -0.0553339347243309, 0.0011349959531798959, 0.006258648820221424, -0.04943237081170082, 0.00045358319766819477, -0.036840517073869705, 0.002467454643920064, 0.01945669576525688, -0.0037724978756159544, -0.020859185606241226, 0.07965793460607529, -0.04320326820015907, -0.009173285216093063, 0.023945510387420654, -0.06100881099700928, 0.036517392843961716, 0.04155249148607254, 0.03194413334131241, 0.026295164600014687, -0.007871131412684917, -0.0027464337181299925, 0.05174332112073898, -0.044263117015361786, -0.04124793782830238, -0.06389883905649185, -0.024668892845511436, -0.0128064239397645 ]
<p>I want to understand what is wrong with the following argument:</p> <p><em>in a topologically compact spacetime, a closed 3D boundary separates the spacetime in two connected components, because of this continuous symmetry, either one of the two things must happen</em></p> <p>1) <em>the stokes theorem is not valid</em></p> <p>2) <em>the integral of the derivative of any form field in each connected component must be equal in magnitude and opposite in sign, since both must be equal to the surface integral of the form field, and they must be all identical to zero at all times</em></p> <p>In layman terms, if the space is compact, a gauss surface does not separate the space neatly in a interior region and an external region, rather, both connected components are topologically equivalent, so one is led to the startling conclusion that the validity of the stokes theorem (which naively looks of a local, differential nature) depends for its validity on the asymptotic boundary conditions of the space</p>
g9803
[ 0.0843472108244896, -0.03129519149661064, 0.008078656159341335, -0.024490028619766235, 0.010099150240421295, 0.09900933504104614, 0.05289410054683685, -0.002946023363620043, -0.04145932197570801, -0.038160908967256546, 0.05738908797502518, -0.042681362479925156, 0.0288772564381361, -0.009806870482861996, -0.019713958725333214, -0.02230401337146759, -0.012113788165152073, -0.003110000630840659, -0.006119595840573311, 0.033146534115076065, -0.07535381615161896, 0.002794378437101841, 0.037334244698286057, -0.03220749273896217, -0.01027388870716095, -0.013080371543765068, 0.03482342138886452, -0.07272769510746002, -0.04471658915281296, -0.03632296621799469, 0.11112603545188904, 0.046532731503248215, 0.05279814824461937, -0.01808854192495346, -0.006196451373398304, -0.05743899941444397, -0.032802239060401917, 0.05820552632212639, -0.025152401998639107, -0.041008271276950836, 0.07341425120830536, 0.046962711960077286, 0.021305367350578308, -0.015793554484844208, -0.013839428313076496, 0.010766676627099514, -0.06026405096054077, 0.011216994374990463, 0.03672516345977783, -0.03962080925703049, 0.01498512551188469, 0.06670989841222763, -0.016184400767087936, -0.020220573991537094, 0.016996825113892555, 0.004810777027159929, 0.0392487570643425, 0.010709784924983978, 0.03554796054959297, -0.030138229951262474, -0.018181975930929184, -0.04967538267374039, -0.04036994278430939, 0.0903547927737236, 0.08244390785694122, -0.006723296362906694, -0.003262919606640935, 0.01662609726190567, 0.00045753028825856745, -0.0028527111280709505, -0.001984399277716875, -0.05712684243917465, 0.07826641947031021, 0.013703097589313984, -0.05774901434779167, 0.010118813253939152, -0.006451013032346964, -0.01030813716351986, -0.004269280005246401, 0.01932811364531517, -0.07289303839206696, 0.019520463421940804, -0.01311962679028511, 0.045717090368270874, 0.018711641430854797, -0.04042875021696091, 0.044967878609895706, -0.0394914336502552, -0.01595284231007099, 0.0358286090195179, 0.002991330809891224, -0.056353334337472916, 0.04700927436351776, 0.0008277465822175145, 0.020155994221568108, -0.01820283755660057, 0.06638888269662857, 0.06409630924463272, -0.04284602031111717, -0.001014996087178588, -0.032220594584941864, 0.01364597026258707, -0.029179366305470467, 0.007397428620606661, 0.008252247236669064, -0.02012386918067932, -0.004702889826148748, 0.032875534147024155, -0.014312166720628738, -0.05993673950433731, 0.02413545921444893, -0.011665868572890759, -0.03262174129486084, 0.01895218901336193, 0.018076367676258087, 0.01162946317344904, 0.022109387442469597, -0.060649190098047256, 0.026928920298814774, -0.01594739593565464, 0.0019231617916375399, 0.012798222713172436, 0.018523134291172028, 0.03573940321803093, 0.025208624079823494, 0.030587254092097282, -0.01646651141345501, -0.01951466128230095, 0.023879624903202057, 0.0077688321471214294, -0.004408847540616989, -0.002336635487154126, 0.005494468845427036, -0.021143194288015366, 0.05123710632324219, 0.012947039678692818, -0.011298265308141708, -0.04288283735513687, -0.011127468198537827, -0.020241202786564827, -0.005700008478015661, 0.02231094241142273, -0.0007083708187565207, -0.0066540134139359, 0.010628736577928066, 0.006460882257670164, 0.02028965763747692, -0.08479594439268112, 0.031033053994178772, 0.004201769828796387, 0.017606239765882492, 0.07842454314231873, -0.035009242594242096, 0.012821020558476448, 0.01962604746222496, 0.015155408531427383, 0.03961929678916931, -0.01869228482246399, 0.04937302693724632, -0.011854731477797031, 0.029224218800663948, 0.007731495890766382, -0.0028694772627204657, 0.014447794295847416, -0.06500351428985596, -0.03015308454632759, 0.002527223899960518, -0.0418795682489872, -0.03049073927104473, -0.012974523939192295, -0.05248535796999931, 0.08267412334680557, -0.007725768722593784, 0.028140192851424217, 0.05990242585539818, 0.03300375118851662, -0.03222407400608063, 0.012831850908696651, 0.009352929890155792, 0.05969897657632828, -0.039808738976716995, 0.0013675291556864977, -0.03179846704006195, -0.028141522780060768, 0.032764412462711334, 0.02756490930914879, -0.025379905477166176, -0.021655479446053505, -0.06441599875688553, 0.0273516234010458, 0.011200269684195518, 0.030634716153144836, -0.05930088832974434, 0.0973285362124443, 0.013781242072582245, 0.04889407008886337, 0.03358610346913338, 0.01164269633591175, -0.03524206206202507, 0.008162853308022022, -0.03523627296090126, 0.08249921351671219, 0.0819815918803215, 0.006631769705563784, 0.012745602056384087, 0.006672891788184643, -0.034219466149806976, 0.005227506626397371, -0.006827277597039938, 0.004655487835407257, 0.01664268970489502, -0.01424364373087883, -0.027504995465278625, 0.021608512848615646, 0.017839770764112473, -0.01741318590939045, -0.011598299257457256, 0.034557897597551346, -0.012910227291285992, -0.03491565212607384, 0.00833689421415329, 0.002287766896188259, 0.07041674852371216, -0.04619130492210388, -0.09461164474487305, -0.0021795458160340786, -0.04603699967265129, 0.003916260786354542, -0.016613563522696495, -0.024725742638111115, -0.04827534779906273, -0.0601155124604702, -0.0004592240147758275, -0.03955899924039841, 0.041461821645498276, 0.05421360209584236, -0.0233200341463089, 0.0013532140292227268, 0.018786843866109848, 0.059083301573991776, 0.020176129415631294, -0.02782711200416088, -0.0014951929915696383, -0.03717910125851631, 0.02872091718018055, -0.039726950228214264, 0.007660190109163523, 0.019051609560847282, -0.006177171133458614, 0.006604208145290613, -0.028352679684758186, -0.011609642766416073, 0.009423117153346539, 0.022196732461452484, -0.02339750900864601, -0.04113234207034111, 0.030310284346342087, 0.019424384459853172, -0.01744777522981167, -0.007248745299875736, -0.01884613372385502, -0.02846968173980713, 0.023598887026309967, 0.013945206068456173, -0.03539836034178734, -0.013394213281571865, -0.029374293982982635, 0.06328023225069046, 0.054455243051052094, -0.016589762642979622, 0.004271041601896286, 0.06839431077241898, -0.007746350020170212, 0.03344506397843361, 0.006199053023010492, 0.001064472016878426, 0.017057564109563828, -0.05822835490107536, 0.00977897085249424, 0.010212637484073639, -0.012305953539907932, -0.02125498652458191, -0.023757988587021828, -0.021365853026509285, -0.01845938339829445, -0.046142298728227615, 0.016348835080862045, 0.020342545583844185, -0.01916758343577385, 0.04921511933207512, 0.04233907535672188, 0.051931098103523254, 0.005437172949314117, -0.025830723345279694, 0.01877954974770546, 0.0026153596118092537, -0.02605845220386982, -0.05765945464372635, -0.03610781580209732, 0.027623571455478668, -0.03137277811765671, 0.007212563883513212, 0.03207560256123543, -0.027413299307227135, -0.01642335020005703, -0.0184657983481884, 0.024555206298828125, -0.07425869256258011, -0.04456884041428566, -0.02287851832807064, 0.049865081906318665, 0.01034269668161869, 0.02463608793914318, -0.0732521042227745, 0.026298193261027336, 0.05224639177322388, -0.027407458052039146, -0.018818607553839684, -0.03520575538277626, 0.01579873450100422, -0.029168130829930305, 0.045380089432001114, -0.05177317559719086, -0.013858409598469734, -0.020346445962786674, 0.003593447618186474, -0.0235123448073864, 0.009451455436646938, -0.029127052053809166, -0.02504957839846611, -0.009241575375199318, 0.010472345165908337, 0.03631416708230972, -0.027017802000045776, -0.05939764901995659, -0.0219748392701149, 0.015264972113072872, 0.00505121098831296, 0.015274128876626492, 0.04385485500097275, 0.007143906783312559, -0.01598169282078743, -0.03482290357351303, 0.005582028534263372, 0.004264273215085268, 0.0194292850792408, 0.0032587077002972364, 0.09651226550340652, -0.021001895889639854, 0.005521033424884081, 0.0011567991459742188, 0.010522871278226376, 0.0519026480615139, -0.03339485079050064, -0.0669720247387886, 0.03211282566189766, 0.007684728130698204, 0.0182478167116642, 0.0003446267219260335, -0.021933091804385185, 0.057480260729789734, -0.007675723172724247, -0.005674729123711586, 0.018428819254040718, -0.017050303518772125, -0.01982913725078106, 0.06498215347528458, 0.07178623229265213, -0.06500151008367538, -0.006899855099618435, 0.02288488857448101, -0.02673408016562462, -0.020553618669509888, 0.0028188289143145084, 0.029309239238500595, -0.029985347762703896, 0.012069754302501678, -0.017019130289554596, 0.031729694455862045, -0.0008088448084890842, 0.09258287400007248, 0.04395554959774017, -0.004883178975433111, -0.028897684067487717, 0.05899658426642418, 0.03582191839814186, -0.03901130333542824, -0.008610992692410946, 0.0047379471361637115, -0.046289049088954926, -0.002552252495661378, 0.004832117818295956, -0.0319162979722023, -0.01896705850958824, -0.013628394342958927, 0.004331050906330347, -0.019022975116968155, -0.005385557189583778, -0.003607046091929078, 0.03422345221042633, -0.0023320834152400494, -0.017032479867339134, -0.09218250960111618, 0.02005867473781109, -0.016047649085521698, -0.003433046629652381, 0.01842157170176506, 0.02745409496128559, -0.010989592410624027, 0.020217642188072205, 0.03478977456688881, -0.03241599723696709, 0.007584950886666775, -0.056170880794525146, 0.06539714336395264, 0.0017125541344285011, -0.008285482414066792, -0.021459653973579407, 0.017622221261262894, -0.037773557007312775, 0.0017515915678814054, 0.02757544443011284, -0.05527555197477341, 0.0021573049016296864, 0.030115820467472076, 0.07529473304748535, 0.031076259911060333, 0.04129045829176903, -0.04071610048413277, -0.026118731126189232, 0.028832927346229553, 0.05729923024773598, -0.05038740113377571, 0.045387301594018936, -0.06624691933393478, 0.041349273175001144, -0.03415773808956146, 0.08581805974245071, -0.04651332274079323, -0.020828042179346085, 0.023077217862010002, -0.008663815446197987, 0.0029958048835396767, 0.012733334675431252, 0.06296887993812561, 0.05244602635502815, -0.013294371776282787, -0.06550360471010208, -0.012224112637341022, -0.028527934104204178, -0.05704471841454506, 0.0017249257070943713, 0.025559870526194572, -0.035819098353385925, -0.0363403856754303, -0.015358743257820606, -0.01290074735879898, -0.012080670334398746, -0.0036819300148636103, 0.008144954219460487, -0.01447209995239973, -0.03957638517022133, -0.021412108093500137, 0.02953524887561798, 0.0970565527677536, 0.04265020042657852, -0.11918831616640091, 0.07520557194948196, -0.0025990197900682688, 0.0005983355804346502, 0.028886735439300537, 0.07309377193450928, -0.022407978773117065, -0.01580754853785038, 0.006934633478522301, 0.04008539393544197, 0.051847103983163834, -0.01705678179860115, -0.05144371837377548, -0.035531479865312576, 0.012326241470873356, -0.03787979111075401, 0.04779190942645073, 0.03965476155281067, -0.02892647497355938, 0.007934214547276497, -0.009566405788064003, 0.01574980467557907, -0.009739379398524761, -0.0006856638938188553, 0.06447836756706238, 0.05040633678436279, -0.037409763783216476, 0.00036564309266395867, 0.019506193697452545, -0.023136712610721588, 0.0046310340985655785, -0.03994368389248848, -0.056343596428632736, -0.03667045757174492, -0.07462576776742935, 0.008083324879407883, 0.05769621580839157, 0.029043784365057945, 0.035832520574331284, 0.05162262171506882, 0.016828224062919617, -0.007311862427741289, 0.0057459138333797455, 0.03107815980911255, 0.01854311302304268, -0.06820037215948105, 0.01992403343319893, -0.02170303836464882, 0.006402698811143637, 0.04903629422187805, 0.0017368507105857134, -0.02063593454658985, 0.01159780751913786, 0.0007360366871580482, 0.03203824907541275, 0.03118082508444786, -0.019646475091576576, -0.053923122584819794, 0.03767231106758118, 0.030125806108117104, -0.026173673570156097, -0.014862246811389923, -0.030085118487477303, 0.025045689195394516, -0.00383387366309762, 0.05651643127202988, -0.0050436207093298435, 0.0074785128235816956, -0.0029975376091897488, -0.03854082524776459, 0.010894538834691048, 0.0031688290182501078, 0.059071749448776245, -0.033295050263404846, -0.05462220683693886, -0.0012775907525792718, -0.04793952405452728, 0.05811202526092529, -0.02200573869049549, 0.01995411142706871, -0.05767451226711273, -0.044459469616413116, 0.06061718612909317, -0.04072384163737297, -0.03357098996639252, -0.0022775577381253242, -0.06273144483566284, 0.00792065542191267, 0.009694834239780903, 0.0011506169103085995, -0.05555572733283043, -0.015668990090489388, -0.014280840754508972, -0.01687292940914631, 0.06184615567326546, 0.011799122206866741, -0.007554840296506882, -0.010366901755332947, -0.011807195842266083, -0.03385785594582558, 0.0329451784491539, 0.06879568099975586, -0.037466708570718765, -0.030172936618328094, 0.006166869308799505, 0.008754948154091835, 0.06610749661922455, 0.014992482028901577, -0.030344907194375992, 0.013145004399120808, 0.011583891697227955, -0.018127894029021263, -0.03350457176566124, 0.019272267818450928, -0.054231587797403336, -0.01737445779144764, 0.05190839618444443, -0.07972408086061478, -0.025751693174242973, 0.015537882223725319, -0.08825330436229706, -0.03689790144562721, 0.06590812653303146, 0.010929359123110771, 0.017151977866888046, 0.007350041996687651, -0.04875917360186577, 0.020089508965611458, 0.03729020804166794, -0.04868238419294357, 0.005051588639616966, -0.0172574482858181, 0.00016246720042545348, 0.0007980235968716443, -0.017205001786351204, -0.030502839013934135, 0.010823559015989304, 0.023646272718906403, -0.020668791607022285, 0.03422145918011665, 0.03388364240527153, -0.0265518631786108, -0.0035203152801841497, -0.018380993977189064, 0.03734372928738594, 0.04912804812192917, -0.008998570032417774, 0.040152471512556076, 0.05140859633684158, -0.03136914595961571, -0.06737516075372696, -0.007671428844332695, 0.0319274477660656, -0.010687427595257759, 0.06232925131917, 0.060773637145757675, -0.04915777966380119, 0.0006725600105710328, 0.026968391612172127, 0.005636315327137709, -0.002429870655760169, 0.038697995245456696, -0.03432832658290863, 0.04092978313565254, 0.006587442010641098, -0.010827734135091305, -0.04968193545937538, -0.031495146453380585, -0.011887705884873867, -0.032685521990060806, -0.06873128563165665, -0.04356330260634422, 0.05362321063876152, 0.02703610621392727, -0.03334730863571167, 0.04312070459127426, 0.030096696689724922, 0.00742999417707324, -0.012757700867950916, -0.018662795424461365, 0.034870587289333344, -0.014385254122316837, -0.10835976898670197, 0.02630782313644886, 0.03821079060435295, 0.0550197958946228, -0.00418434664607048, -0.05652909725904465, -0.0074834502302110195, -0.00691386591643095, -0.052261821925640106, -0.03860233351588249, -0.0077177658677101135, -0.03612132743000984, -0.04311145842075348, 0.03579302504658699, -0.03753569722175598, -0.020753338932991028, -0.03393562510609627, 0.05691497027873993, 0.022825924679636955, 0.02717253565788269, 0.00908094272017479, -0.03656332194805145, -0.03546600416302681, -0.02396084927022457, 0.014114642515778542, 0.02836356684565544, -0.02339068613946438, -0.014952666126191616, -0.009852764196693897, 0.03485264256596565, 0.07159138470888138, 0.0008856742060743272, 0.04105406627058983, 0.020685147494077682, -0.024222837761044502, 0.01846424676477909, -0.04570230469107628, -0.010378113947808743, -0.028670260682702065, -0.021305203437805176, -0.0033676233142614365, 0.021790364757180214, 0.0258466936647892, 0.006990917958319187, 0.009097464382648468, -0.007239372469484806, 0.002700062235817313, 0.008601270616054535, 0.055028922855854034, 0.05536460503935814, -0.004399715457111597, 0.011487318202853203, 0.01888050138950348, -0.025981202721595764, -0.0016444269567728043, -0.015361826866865158, 0.032219093292951584, 0.037777554243803024, 0.051875241100788116, 0.010841550305485725, -0.056602440774440765, -0.03245527669787407, -0.01872441917657852, -0.01074979081749916, 0.03451886400580406, -0.011598700657486916, 0.028987735509872437, -0.040624335408210754, -0.02667861431837082, -0.05249824747443199, 0.04114024341106415, -0.057221852242946625, -0.006244962103664875, -0.01888004131615162, -0.06414025276899338, -0.08090397715568542, -0.016816401854157448, 0.015300571918487549, 0.024058151990175247, -0.05866122618317604, 0.043285999447107315, 0.017526349052786827, -0.09388811141252518, 0.05863409861922264, 0.006751708686351776, 0.02171934023499489, -0.08306392282247543, 0.0030888360925018787, 0.029875628650188446, -0.034384068101644516, 0.0032016802579164505, -0.0027087742928415537, -0.007599605247378349, -0.0304166991263628, 0.05659075826406479, -0.07899599522352219, -0.007369110826402903, 0.026785777881741524, -0.0408359095454216, 0.00908083189278841, 0.048189111053943634, -0.012346869334578514, 0.02386179380118847, -0.020326459780335426, 0.022785717621445656, 0.022804811596870422, 0.04085041210055351, -0.07316998392343521, 0.008454840630292892, -0.012707180343568325, 0.07511094212532043, -0.00015419244300574064, -0.04662061855196953, 0.008878277614712715, -0.019841264933347702, -0.008038489148020744, -0.01635482907295227, -0.05552062392234802, 0.013444955460727215, 0.03807593137025833 ]
<p>Every Solution of the Dirac Equation is also a solution of the Klein-Gordon equation.</p> <p>So the K-G equation does not necessarily represent particles with non-zero spin.</p> <p>Would it be incorrect to conclude that KG equation relates solely to zero-spin particles?</p>
g9804
[ -0.0016802692553028464, -0.001248299260623753, 0.014558370225131512, 0.020401963964104652, 0.07185697555541992, -0.0021027717739343643, -0.012391344644129276, 0.025763453915715218, -0.024933403357863426, 0.010808944702148438, 0.0013345555635169148, -0.012184304185211658, -0.005208743270486593, 0.012277758680284023, 0.019755713641643524, -0.016007857397198677, 0.006977537181228399, -0.002058384707197547, -0.02441122755408287, 0.05062548816204071, -0.0022588055580854416, -0.029883112758398056, 0.028242284432053566, -0.052361175417900085, 0.009512421675026417, -0.04149381071329117, -0.026439504697918892, -0.054967284202575684, -0.034867338836193085, 0.010239236056804657, 0.02230633795261383, -0.027815770357847214, -0.016355842351913452, -0.06327851116657257, -0.04284178838133812, -0.045705396682024, 0.05632662773132324, 0.06150450184941292, -0.019857244566082954, -0.02238202840089798, 0.018376270309090614, 0.060852792114019394, -0.01943817362189293, -0.016436543315649033, 0.019571175798773766, 0.039616793394088745, 0.015246042981743813, 0.09898437559604645, -0.04642849415540695, 0.02252647466957569, -0.03938361257314682, 0.03047214262187481, 0.03877821937203407, 0.02213306538760662, -0.04216933995485306, 0.027009570971131325, 0.061232790350914, -0.03529926389455795, 0.061000559478998184, 0.07482630014419556, 0.013077245093882084, -0.01297070924192667, -0.00492709968239069, -0.021463895216584206, 0.05674275383353233, -0.020746031776070595, -0.02697133831679821, 0.025966767221689224, 0.013429789803922176, 0.026139356195926666, -0.008657317608594894, -0.02632598765194416, 0.04366910085082054, -0.008692818693816662, 0.01823614165186882, 0.01445518247783184, 0.05344724282622337, 0.02818649634718895, 0.03634553775191307, -0.027018951252102852, -0.024500340223312378, 0.020321765914559364, 0.021393299102783203, -0.07887010276317596, 0.011420561000704765, 0.014800612814724445, -0.010091766715049744, -0.01001769583672285, 0.06605572253465652, 0.031560059636831284, 0.03960468992590904, -0.015399644151329994, 0.049660876393318176, -0.01854272186756134, -0.02393624186515808, -0.027905810624361038, -0.02538219280540943, 0.03709724545478821, -0.02714955061674118, 0.02332834154367447, -0.039558932185173035, 0.0001261032884940505, -0.07706478238105774, -0.023024899885058403, 0.0004952810704708099, -0.026964718475937843, 0.007488057017326355, 0.060649339109659195, 0.0400923527777195, -0.03670909255743027, -0.0422828234732151, 0.025442667305469513, -0.03801188990473747, 0.04115680605173111, -0.037573277950286865, -0.011922484263777733, 0.034110650420188904, -0.05037476867437363, 0.03842537850141525, 0.017489580437541008, 0.006976421922445297, 0.018520846962928772, 0.007102308329194784, 0.06114530935883522, 0.014313122257590294, -0.05148515850305557, -0.018212515860795975, 0.03157897666096687, 0.028955994173884392, -0.024783894419670105, -0.00795660074800253, -0.0280905868858099, -0.026949239894747734, 0.01778319478034973, 0.01637064293026924, 0.03398808836936951, -0.011952711269259453, 0.021682491526007652, -0.026273099705576897, 0.0020006559789180756, -0.05240631103515625, -0.050522759556770325, 0.024080868810415268, 0.017267266288399696, -0.034159015864133835, -0.026293903589248657, 0.00043622308294288814, -0.027339568361639977, -0.03040349669754505, 0.056245844811201096, -0.0006451682420447469, 0.05903148278594017, 0.02568650245666504, -0.008294750936329365, 0.04712354764342308, -0.038236431777477264, 0.05463442951440811, -0.0208969097584486, 0.02391548827290535, -0.001961700851097703, 0.03706062212586403, -0.032443854957818985, 0.060031116008758545, -0.0178074948489666, -0.03902174532413483, -0.0042694672010838985, 0.023013809695839882, -0.0021289275027811527, -0.02500232681632042, -0.025328462943434715, -0.03055596724152565, 0.008776211179792881, -0.038565170019865036, 0.028327910229563713, 0.018278758972883224, 0.051947686821222305, 0.011174489744007587, -0.03884395211935043, 0.007930531166493893, -0.0010041893692687154, -0.0037304782308638096, 0.015619775280356407, 0.053301114588975906, -0.014870812185108662, -0.00793727207928896, 0.04224320873618126, 0.012419827282428741, 0.09458352625370026, -0.022051271051168442, -0.04353726655244827, -0.0026851219590753317, 0.009553995914757252, 0.020898278802633286, -0.00018848992476705462, 0.019747309386730194, 0.02239075116813183, -0.05468311160802841, -0.02742648497223854, -0.05525294691324234, 0.05759924650192261, 0.041414327919483185, 0.039381884038448334, -0.008268097415566444, -0.022680621594190598, 0.04168519750237465, -0.047211188822984695, -0.03193369880318642, -0.031250547617673874, 0.10844987630844116, -0.10907144099473953, 0.04806171730160713, -0.014806017279624939, -0.02835412323474884, 0.04029404744505882, -0.01273603830486536, -0.06962059438228607, 0.0115596242249012, 0.031074626371264458, 0.03637728840112686, 0.024248024448752403, -0.07689515501260757, 0.011289781890809536, 0.010720456950366497, 0.0012519992887973785, 0.01401903759688139, -0.003946313168853521, 0.007281506434082985, -0.06732698529958725, -0.028032995760440826, 0.00815563928335905, -0.024048754945397377, -0.03707039728760719, -0.03632007911801338, 0.003346460871398449, 0.04873253405094147, 0.06850706785917282, -0.05784231424331665, -0.03003603033721447, 0.011885606683790684, 0.05434805527329445, -0.0373125821352005, -0.015631593763828278, -0.051360685378313065, 0.03330468013882637, 0.03361257165670395, 0.02277481183409691, 0.017500903457403183, -0.03358422964811325, -0.009269527159631252, 0.009859306737780571, 0.053189996629953384, -0.030859297141432762, -0.037269849330186844, -0.06631545722484589, 0.05607067421078682, 0.00032210833160206676, 0.03868697211146355, 0.022775741294026375, -0.04574315994977951, -0.0024841604754328728, 0.06894512474536896, -0.06329622864723206, -0.025221500545740128, 0.028132440522313118, -0.04052902013063431, 0.012517742812633514, 0.0280732624232769, 0.060153622180223465, 0.025354113429784775, 0.003230796894058585, -0.04646378383040428, 0.020759474486112595, -0.003921600989997387, 0.026181867346167564, -0.0376284196972847, -0.0552288256585598, -0.01205856166779995, 0.03773301839828491, 0.025914743542671204, -0.047666653990745544, -0.03239389881491661, -0.007189654745161533, -0.03122877888381481, -0.015074660070240498, -0.0600988008081913, -0.06732919812202454, -0.018867719918489456, 0.005523866042494774, 0.03935441002249718, -0.006605247035622597, -0.010289859026670456, 0.05459245294332504, 0.08381689339876175, -0.024425003677606583, -0.022751349955797195, 0.03119373880326748, 0.002760981908068061, -0.014929204247891903, 0.026527967303991318, 0.07703304290771484, 0.029090942814946175, -0.023148568347096443, -0.03844226151704788, 0.0014608950586989522, 0.02340635657310486, 0.038191698491573334, -0.017884740605950356, -0.09496690332889557, -0.06423243880271912, -0.0289457980543375, -0.04112953692674637, 0.08097689598798752, 0.020037056878209114, 0.05825157091021538, 0.0013341723242774606, -0.01358549389988184, -0.04249345511198044, 0.028361082077026367, 0.014299641363322735, -0.01937960274517536, 0.008057396858930588, -0.043435316532850266, 0.03398178890347481, 0.02316724695265293, 0.0007360570598393679, 0.032083507627248764, -0.06554824858903885, -0.004179650451987982, -0.006701520644128323, 0.014927564188838005, -0.017609134316444397, -0.018159177154302597, 0.0462631992995739, 0.0332544781267643, -0.07968680560588837, -0.023355476558208466, -0.009557419456541538, -0.027972672134637833, -0.0790654793381691, 0.004400479607284069, -0.03116903081536293, -0.053055036813020706, -0.016977334395051003, 0.03888462111353874, 0.006331501994282007, 0.042747557163238525, -0.03215629234910011, -0.02854442223906517, -0.01157595869153738, -0.01532911416143179, -0.020723717287182808, 0.0469856858253479, 0.04698585718870163, 0.03614898398518562, -0.06292947381734848, -0.02978048473596573, 0.03869323804974556, 0.05631691962480545, 0.003464874578639865, 0.018133988603949547, 0.005534568801522255, 0.00244896300137043, 0.02670607529580593, 0.015090752393007278, 0.03591825067996979, -0.020582783967256546, 0.015827076509594917, -0.0032618087716400623, 0.003436339320614934, -0.04105846956372261, -0.028956172987818718, 0.01132418867200613, 0.08851595222949982, -0.06257825344800949, 0.013291665352880955, -0.01513275783509016, -0.01323181577026844, 0.00028150048456154764, -0.03544516861438751, -0.00528740556910634, -0.05224176123738289, -0.01055684220045805, 0.03567814081907272, 0.05943296104669571, -0.017305629327893257, 0.03733835741877556, 0.004727977328002453, -0.016034554690122604, -0.027353249490261078, 0.042165130376815796, 0.009342791512608528, 0.0005376418703235686, -0.014363360591232777, 0.030895354226231575, 0.01806754618883133, 0.02710079215466976, -0.011295702308416367, -0.060123443603515625, 0.02867177687585354, 0.04375269263982773, -0.04691591486334801, 0.013850076124072075, 0.04848729819059372, -0.02723792940378189, 0.038415487855672836, 0.029572129249572754, -0.0018457103287801147, -0.01181592233479023, 0.013947932980954647, -0.00838867761194706, -0.00687392707914114, 0.008393394760787487, 0.006969832815229893, -0.01487452257424593, 0.04921399801969528, -0.062257006764411926, -0.05442773550748825, -0.04529840126633644, -0.020048629492521286, 0.0037524739746004343, 0.07193503528833389, -0.018933149054646492, -0.006282956805080175, 0.013372110202908516, 0.01896781660616398, -0.006420730147510767, 0.005822178442031145, 0.05775780975818634, -0.051945071667432785, 0.030107706785202026, -0.05323491245508194, -0.022025950253009796, 0.03475017473101616, 0.013996523804962635, -0.015720568597316742, 0.012577117420732975, -0.026302946731448174, 0.024162644520401955, -0.009889856912195683, -0.024142766371369362, 0.052267465740442276, 0.0064904107712209225, 0.00551020260900259, 0.004667238332331181, 0.006136978976428509, 0.03355397656559944, 0.0019016460282728076, -0.01049051433801651, -0.03527144715189934, 0.018311191350221634, 0.0013935220194980502, 0.016565490514039993, -0.04578973725438118, 0.04207555949687958, -0.013341150246560574, -0.007544959895312786, 0.0001980526139959693, 0.014076219871640205, -0.02358195371925831, 0.027233390137553215, -0.03513946756720543, -0.029580777511000633, 0.015386798419058323, -0.00405083317309618, 0.039708275347948074, 0.02697117067873478, -0.03218942880630493, 0.03317570686340332, -0.11896509677171707, -0.06349147856235504, -0.039970967918634415, -0.005200531333684921, 0.013767808675765991, -0.0329337902367115, -0.023366691544651985, 0.043335821479558945, -0.03755964711308479, 0.0009620373602956533, -0.05006902292370796, 0.01649544946849346, -0.029236529022455215, -0.02774769812822342, 0.024784589186310768, -0.004130128771066666, -0.004231583327054977, 0.04470614716410637, -0.01694088615477085, 0.03321314603090286, -0.02653351053595543, -0.00746848015114665, 0.08820199966430664, -0.026464421302080154, -0.03153006732463837, -0.013390316627919674, 0.06359262019395828, 0.029808945953845978, -0.021644091233611107, 0.004283696413040161, 0.03852646425366402, 0.06821656972169876, 0.012323325499892235, -0.02903941459953785, 0.027450770139694214, 0.01195863913744688, -0.010753912851214409, 0.06647642701864243, 0.021185172721743584, -0.03333393111824989, 0.01680666022002697, 0.023583760485053062, 0.04537872225046158, -0.052371080964803696, 0.009601617231965065, 0.040416862815618515, 0.006161937490105629, -0.004640302155166864, -0.04759141057729721, -0.03126446157693863, 0.008453994058072567, -0.0025465814396739006, -0.00433691218495369, 0.03179970011115074, -0.034583866596221924, 0.005841236561536789, -0.03092086873948574, -0.009346447885036469, 0.018139362335205078, 0.013048473745584488, 0.058366015553474426, 0.05037999153137207, 0.05241354554891586, 0.020488006994128227, 0.02389002963900566, 0.059908345341682434, 0.031900592148303986, -0.05127940699458122, 0.005937765818089247, 0.09409503638744354, 0.05551425367593765, 0.002109118038788438, -0.006700990255922079, 0.030552826821804047, 0.008738286793231964, 0.008338674902915955, -0.06578459590673447, 0.03330196812748909, 0.0014494810020551085, -0.027227578684687614, 0.013561345636844635, -0.12640367448329926, -0.0507214330136776, 0.008126314729452133, 0.0419403538107872, 0.0157706867903471, 0.014022352173924446, 0.0000992767745628953, -0.016872312873601913, 0.013691865839064121, 0.020586110651493073, -0.0050460537895560265, -0.0031452702824026346, -0.02251879684627056, 0.014624250121414661, 0.026022782549262047, 0.021129589527845383, -0.0018134030979126692, -0.01582077331840992, -0.12882256507873535, 0.05493541434407234, -0.07563541829586029, -0.11080602556467056, -0.006316631566733122, -0.03165297582745552, 0.03936726972460747, -0.021447934210300446, -0.045160941779613495, 0.009579957462847233, -0.04920699819922447, -0.02662276290357113, 0.03874032944440842, -0.0009910097578540444, 0.03547436371445656, -0.00290943356230855, -0.051158394664525986, -0.043241214007139206, 0.019971465691924095, -0.005373894236981869, 0.018049990758299828, 0.03155600652098656, 0.10549353063106537, -0.0330352745950222, -0.013589256443083286, -0.07796911895275116, -0.02725384384393692, 0.0032598604448139668, -0.011162640526890755, 0.009690763428807259, -0.025368578732013702, -0.04448714852333069, -0.04623403400182724, 0.03019973635673523, 0.017028160393238068, -0.006215323694050312, 0.03338146209716797, -0.005820287391543388, -0.026578987017273903, -0.06652648746967316, 0.03824648633599281, -0.0023275914136320353, 0.005316469818353653, 0.009991711005568504, 0.04241049289703369, 0.03105068951845169, -0.012248133309185505, 0.03856278210878372, -0.06589607149362564, -0.012872823514044285, 0.0032676244154572487, -0.02727654203772545, -0.053658563643693924, 0.03369910642504692, 0.02031630091369152, -0.0147057780995965, -0.0147746866568923, 0.02925645001232624, 0.028515366837382317, -0.0016016722656786442, 0.09516420215368271, 0.0033701607026159763, 0.039536215364933014, -0.009467449970543385, 0.04529021680355072, -0.038230933248996735, -0.031496595591306686, 0.008080528117716312, -0.014352384023368359, -0.04898180067539215, -0.0014253873378038406, 0.0021272138692438602, 0.023943817242980003, -0.03174854442477226, 0.00705765001475811, 0.03635168820619583, -0.04638676345348358, -0.027525564655661583, 0.018848320469260216, 0.029822176322340965, 0.03619078919291496, -0.09045540541410446, -0.017913218587636948, 0.015236406587064266, -0.02213241346180439, 0.016448836773633957, -0.024324076250195503, 0.0033072868827730417, -0.061990998685359955, 0.003444533096626401, 0.013536575250327587, 0.08328615874052048, -0.032708439975976944, -0.05866996943950653, -0.021159373223781586, 0.005254252813756466, -0.03851955384016037, -0.04751316457986832, 0.014148294925689697, 0.0020144854206591845, 0.007346165832132101, 0.03837614133954048, 0.014622200280427933, -0.03602561354637146, -0.027880974113941193, -0.004282224457710981, -0.03036639839410782, -0.030288157984614372, 0.00684947706758976, -0.010486955754458904, -0.005551833193749189, -0.04482244700193405, 0.026002950966358185, 0.018559781834483147, 0.010234021581709385, 0.004207081161439419, 0.001321443822234869, -0.04153108969330788, 0.017301490530371666, 0.04024553298950195, -0.04447837546467781, -0.022875221446156502, 0.028696738183498383, -0.021954799070954323, 0.03855146840214729, 0.06963950395584106, -0.027420634403824806, -0.0060677723959088326, -0.01180436834692955, 0.003535169642418623, 0.057138413190841675, 0.04296599328517914, -0.038471002131700516, 0.03657218813896179, -0.0027025179006159306, -0.038026511669158936, 0.03849302604794502, 0.031396158039569855, -0.002539996989071369, 0.08149898052215576, -0.045357782393693924, -0.040422674268484116, -0.005986623931676149, -0.019320441409945488, 0.00804710853844881, -0.019640864804387093, 0.08637499064207077, -0.005434338469058275, 0.026953574270009995, -0.05557484179735184, -0.03785302862524986, 0.02986556477844715, -0.0633845403790474, 0.010302014648914337, 0.019276799634099007, 0.011188605800271034, -0.04860924184322357, -0.02406228706240654, -0.019929848611354828, -0.010954818688333035, 0.009176747873425484, 0.006393373012542725, 0.017023345455527306, -0.03891951963305473, 0.027236418798565865, -0.06197817251086235, 0.0470491386950016, -0.004249135032296181, -0.0036974744871258736, -0.05005822703242302, -0.0423707515001297, 0.04710609093308449, 0.0313529334962368, -0.01860848441720009, -0.01437256671488285, 0.0017668481450527906, 0.056924622505903244, 0.004758038558065891, 0.012382341548800468, 0.0037086536176502705, -0.0045959968119859695, 0.038183052092790604, 0.00917430967092514, 0.0059749349020421505, 0.041857607662677765, 0.013586240820586681, 0.0031080967746675014, -0.0015307668363675475, -0.07392726838588715, 0.013751579448580742, 0.05334020406007767, -0.01913163810968399, 0.046245671808719635, -0.01689048856496811, -0.06865265220403671, -0.03889142721891403, 0.020699748769402504, -0.011026381514966488, -0.05478812754154205, -0.04191014915704727, 0.06817159056663513 ]
<p>Is there any difference between using a positive versus a negative charge to test an electric field?</p>
g9805
[ 0.07243333756923676, 0.02379179373383522, -0.004764378070831299, 0.009493198245763779, 0.061361752450466156, 0.02002887986600399, -0.02246313914656639, -0.036676838994026184, -0.010421075858175755, -0.003755209967494011, 0.023706184700131416, -0.0008687337976880372, -0.05819929018616676, -0.013467604294419289, -0.014111137017607689, -0.04553482308983803, 0.09815314412117004, -0.004051289055496454, 0.013820510357618332, 0.028622299432754517, -0.031917504966259, 0.013387026265263557, -0.04099114611744881, -0.005847325548529625, -0.010620566084980965, -0.06382676959037781, -0.0866885557770729, 0.041645508259534836, 0.0014696581056341529, -0.07264817506074905, -0.007232727948576212, 0.004087548237293959, 0.013156920671463013, -0.019159534946084023, -0.08314643055200577, -0.0014446788700297475, 0.04057599604129791, 0.06354108452796936, 0.004748934879899025, -0.001307084341533482, 0.030242638662457466, 0.025920838117599487, 0.038026582449674606, -0.044908031821250916, 0.044373925775289536, -0.025217218324542046, 0.024492589756846428, 0.04055989161133766, 0.008707689121365547, -0.03167932108044624, -0.03521513193845749, -0.01177799142897129, -0.0063513838686048985, -0.006850629113614559, 0.05984161049127579, 0.005634347442537546, -0.003701962996274233, 0.0015867273323237896, -0.027903202921152115, -0.018802911043167114, 0.011488157324492931, 0.04647590592503548, 0.003155987011268735, -0.019217200577259064, 0.012254001572728157, 0.034126102924346924, -0.026686305180191994, -0.04539469629526138, -0.007554951123893261, 0.03200457990169525, -0.029401544481515884, -0.010896054096519947, -0.028655806556344032, 0.012351231649518013, 0.0011311485432088375, 0.006972561124712229, 0.00846993550658226, -0.043389227241277695, 0.005801805295050144, -0.0028278196696192026, 0.011884257197380066, -0.09467421472072601, 0.0012511585373431444, 0.026045477017760277, 0.07697899639606476, -0.030227620154619217, 0.023015761747956276, -0.015912551432847977, 0.023492004722356796, -0.04730832204222679, 0.008976160548627377, 0.021828284487128258, 0.049056507647037506, 0.027519723400473595, -0.02515198104083538, 0.05030812695622444, 0.016930481418967247, 0.03285819664597511, 0.017285538837313652, 0.026158642023801804, 0.006852179300040007, 0.00041907612467184663, 0.03223299980163574, 0.003286699065938592, -0.04413282871246338, 0.01939593441784382, -0.017906272783875465, -0.029164593666791916, -0.0073035284876823425, -0.04560483992099762, 0.003967201337218285, 0.00006197866605361924, -0.08795695751905441, -0.018407275900244713, -0.06836995482444763, 0.04502089321613312, 0.0696781724691391, -0.10128427296876907, -0.039431821554899216, -0.028357330709695816, 0.0017028587171807885, 0.03565511107444763, 0.00929602887481451, 0.010345589369535446, -0.05101390928030014, 0.008083146065473557, -0.033810410648584366, -0.0024117203429341316, 0.04233518987894058, 0.020375212654471397, 0.01777111180126667, 0.01539398543536663, -0.05062517151236534, -0.03484460711479187, -0.008525587618350983, 0.04588581994175911, 0.025426873937249184, -0.03236747160553932, -0.0019707055762410164, -0.0372929684817791, 0.027139732614159584, -0.04155929759144783, 0.0012005983153358102, 0.013958978466689587, 0.024337053298950195, 0.0029195586685091257, 0.01029902696609497, 0.002898561768233776, 0.07094225287437439, 0.056671857833862305, 0.02535158023238182, -0.054922979325056076, 0.08027830719947815, -0.013006797060370445, -0.0008180596050806344, -0.026446344330906868, 0.06395223736763, 0.02199982851743698, 0.03567526862025261, -0.014405859634280205, 0.003184431931003928, 0.013711873441934586, 0.047222815454006195, -0.013680738396942616, 0.0020882468670606613, -0.04579569771885872, 0.0212102010846138, 0.03421352803707123, 0.028872450813651085, -0.02263925038278103, 0.011921782977879047, -0.04234124347567558, 0.05274798348546028, -0.05261176452040672, 0.029749460518360138, 0.0270845964550972, -0.04947211220860481, -0.04844648763537407, 0.04429434612393379, 0.05795484408736229, -0.08357252180576324, -0.00969955138862133, -0.005351200234144926, -0.0023995875380933285, -0.0034008463844656944, 0.017575716599822044, -0.02600998431444168, 0.026260752230882645, -0.04734799265861511, 0.011874930933117867, -0.02375209517776966, -0.06378635764122009, -0.025794347748160362, 0.03020157478749752, -0.05155392363667488, -0.05033750832080841, -0.034547705203294754, 0.02638246677815914, -0.013150913640856743, -0.010053611360490322, -0.01221739687025547, 0.03662120923399925, -0.005822656210511923, 0.06453242152929306, -0.007148046512156725, -0.0862283855676651, -0.04483691230416298, -0.07937553524971008, 0.06275022029876709, 0.008809682913124561, 0.0016030309488996863, 0.03658051788806915, 0.0257027056068182, 0.050290051847696304, 0.021330686286091805, -0.016102062538266182, -0.027704859152436256, -0.002020694315433502, -0.05869494006037712, 0.019494997337460518, -0.0513564795255661, -0.01619367115199566, 0.09535511583089828, -0.022419527173042297, -0.02690272592008114, 0.02676405757665634, 0.01574205793440342, 0.01722855679690838, -0.06209389120340347, -0.04448113217949867, -0.07054659724235535, -0.013366874307394028, -0.009479396045207977, -0.010805523954331875, -0.007154287304729223, 0.048753634095191956, 0.02284083142876625, -0.0017355175223201513, -0.014611585065722466, -0.027307618409395218, -0.02890102006494999, -0.04032091423869133, -0.005012204870581627, 0.08549873530864716, 0.00004607886148733087, -0.04695120081305504, 0.004648581147193909, 0.010216101072728634, -0.018258655443787575, 0.01324478443711996, -0.0024388753809034824, 0.050405483692884445, -0.00328302220441401, 0.040553897619247437, 0.009280691854655743, -0.002211812185123563, -0.0255400650203228, -0.0008884959388524294, -0.004768501501530409, 0.012143763713538647, 0.022754916921257973, -0.06666610389947891, -0.05307023972272873, 0.01702219620347023, 0.0068406229838728905, -0.05582239478826523, -0.08681438118219376, -0.02006838470697403, 0.056670576333999634, 0.045674219727516174, 0.012280617840588093, 0.07931936532258987, 0.02855495736002922, -0.027343962341547012, 0.02263740450143814, -0.05112271010875702, -0.03747493773698807, 0.023559631779789925, 0.06831256300210953, -0.07703055441379547, 0.03794071450829506, 0.023808971047401428, -0.0011515364749357104, 0.025417346507310867, 0.04065273329615593, -0.014759044162929058, 0.027156056836247444, -0.045954279601573944, -0.06493031233549118, 0.045941311866045, 0.005856342613697052, 0.033300548791885376, 0.023509636521339417, -0.06183980777859688, 0.026660319417715073, -0.032452501356601715, 0.010023931041359901, -0.09601333737373352, 0.007101114839315414, -0.020851803943514824, 0.003271723398938775, -0.017855819314718246, -0.04739023372530937, 0.07506410032510757, 0.09564372897148132, 0.030339296907186508, -0.038135334849357605, -0.02423248626291752, 0.054602447897195816, 0.021532991901040077, -0.1105816587805748, 0.04160264879465103, 0.02900931052863598, -0.01993132010102272, -0.018001222983002663, -0.016132988035678864, 0.013887942768633366, 0.04872344806790352, 0.007792519871145487, 0.009855210781097412, 0.02803025394678116, -0.022015344351530075, 0.013358373194932938, 0.04965602606534958, -0.01760506071150303, 0.03213410824537277, 0.027629723772406578, 0.019511405378580093, 0.014479200355708599, -0.026456182822585106, 0.02114063687622547, 0.0479227639734745, -0.004062577150762081, 0.003978748805820942, 0.035611316561698914, 0.009583908133208752, -0.029892325401306152, 0.011348805390298367, -0.04417354613542557, 0.008940795436501503, 0.029218023642897606, -0.00297484896145761, -0.08132501691579819, -0.022047635167837143, -0.01646212488412857, -0.022282876074314117, 0.014279852621257305, 0.005478297360241413, 0.03493587300181389, 0.00644295196980238, 0.012116128578782082, -0.01775745302438736, -0.011370697058737278, 0.0002735384041443467, -0.020347392186522484, -0.035991597920656204, -0.009701105765998363, 0.028406016528606415, -0.050698842853307724, 0.05974602699279785, 0.015772713348269463, -0.005901764612644911, 0.013153435662388802, -0.025659436360001564, 0.0056720576249063015, 0.055998146533966064, -0.05652065947651863, 0.04838437959551811, -0.0397685207426548, -0.01209460198879242, -0.007711188867688179, 0.021974189206957817, 0.0338640995323658, 0.0175849087536335, 0.06925993412733078, 0.008456263691186905, 0.015604405663907528, 0.017324082553386688, -0.03727849945425987, 0.004867380019277334, 0.005343225318938494, -0.008337029255926609, -0.026871858164668083, 0.010802975855767727, -0.015615906566381454, -0.053569406270980835, 0.02374444529414177, -0.011318485252559185, -0.018464596942067146, -0.03194881230592728, -0.04260079935193062, 0.05475093051791191, -0.062446724623441696, 0.047024305909872055, 0.029228035360574722, -0.035546690225601196, -0.00979131180793047, 0.0002658171870280057, 0.026705965399742126, 0.008672698400914669, 0.053622350096702576, 0.0373653769493103, 0.05548699572682381, -0.002222480485215783, -0.029304012656211853, -0.056826066225767136, 0.026537735015153885, 0.0007940929499454796, -0.04211957007646561, -0.0084762591868639, -0.025764957070350647, -0.01192396879196167, -0.05956926569342613, -0.009854461997747421, 0.010106237605214119, -0.009541720151901245, 0.03202865272760391, 0.059088580310344696, 0.0748424232006073, 0.04535908252000809, 0.07844391465187073, 0.0490969642996788, 0.01962997391819954, -0.07451522350311279, 0.007904666475951672, 0.011425748467445374, 0.052951354533433914, 0.03756209835410118, 0.01258130557835102, -0.02516419067978859, -0.03393714502453804, 0.07239491492509842, -0.01608014665544033, 0.003940071444958448, -0.04340529814362526, 0.07827844470739365, -0.041165225207805634, 0.009003318846225739, 0.01680329442024231, 0.021863024681806564, 0.035683970898389816, 0.012384941801428795, -0.028778836131095886, -0.03384814038872719, -0.02694358490407467, 0.04988936707377434, -0.015109681524336338, -0.024619299918413162, -0.007359545212239027, -0.05735847353935242, -0.04515906795859337, 0.051035720854997635, -0.015295539982616901, -0.0529932864010334, -0.02421584539115429, -0.006233375519514084, 0.004588478244841099, 0.013138850219547749, -0.050236936658620834, 0.04077574610710144, -0.018009401857852936, 0.009741255082190037, 0.05115199461579323, 0.0017109186155721545, 0.04697667807340622, 0.01200693566352129, -0.04660167172551155, -0.06501735001802444, -0.017417164519429207, 0.0034459817688912153, -0.0005884308484382927, 0.000834124453831464, 0.04500189796090126, 0.019437376409769058, 0.03577788174152374, -0.0037362638395279646, 0.015849269926548004, 0.03245221823453903, -0.06936734914779663, -0.04274711012840271, -0.0224016010761261, 0.0061905463226139545, 0.004478673450648785, -0.027469908818602562, -0.0057706451043486595, 0.01881531812250614, -0.004926973953843117, 0.0655631572008133, 0.022398585453629494, -0.07267612218856812, 0.03940214589238167, 0.006986608263105154, 0.03135807067155838, 0.0042388769797980785, -0.03175961598753929, -0.0063309078104794025, -0.04300566017627716, 0.005761740729212761, -0.07322662323713303, -0.008292515762150288, -0.054053377360105515, -0.04172886535525322, -0.048919931054115295, -0.0034224316477775574, -0.022810399532318115, 0.013658281415700912, 0.0457877516746521, -0.04484381154179573, 0.018136758357286453, -0.011026951484382153, -0.05442383512854576, -0.01967710629105568, 0.020619593560695648, 0.05623561516404152, 0.035473015159368515, 0.03261444717645645, -0.05271454155445099, 0.0016631016042083502, -0.08167219907045364, 0.007093527354300022, 0.027478672564029694, -0.013084552250802517, 0.056256718933582306, -0.033089980483055115, 0.02006310224533081, 0.017634687945246696, -0.013941465876996517, -0.029154298827052116, 0.07441781461238861, -0.05148039013147354, 0.05449936166405678, 0.014201424084603786, 0.060777876526117325, 0.04263320565223694, 0.009348946623504162, -0.05153775215148926, 0.026507079601287842, 0.013156410306692123, 0.024490324780344963, 0.007190317381173372, -0.01841619610786438, -0.032397955656051636, 0.03495248779654503, 0.008568033576011658, -0.004147205967456102, -0.013481955043971539, -0.03440115973353386, 0.01616608165204525, -0.029171813279390335, -0.06662570685148239, -0.026912322267889977, 0.03554230555891991, -0.055176153779029846, -0.06039739027619362, 0.015658775344491005, 0.046647265553474426, 0.01714351400732994, -0.028569934889674187, 0.022324159741401672, -0.003570189233869314, -0.011898672208189964, -0.03658950328826904, -0.028581000864505768, 0.030059337615966797, 0.04494912922382355, 0.04918557405471802, 0.04276138171553612, -0.00017642159946262836, -0.01359847653657198, -0.034757349640131, 0.009443143382668495, 0.021484877914190292, 0.016581781208515167, -0.015373438596725464, 0.0412222221493721, 0.0047090002335608006, -0.002814759034663439, 0.03650690242648125, 0.007322472985833883, -0.02201896719634533, 0.0563211552798748, -0.0012095249257981777, 0.0418582446873188, -0.009353839792311192, 0.06459413468837738, 0.04456731677055359, -0.0003003104357048869, 0.006674426607787609, 0.02816775254905224, 0.0032313389237970114, -0.020527485758066177, -0.0038032729644328356, 0.061850860714912415, -0.044156692922115326, -0.011216172948479652, -0.04676157236099243, -0.06796302646398544, -0.04498942941427231, -0.01404605433344841, 0.008504984900355339, 0.009595056995749474, -0.002173441229388118, -0.015645725652575493, -0.050435036420822144, 0.015106410719454288, 0.0048616924323141575, 0.06136143207550049, 0.06796860694885254, -0.001945598516613245, 0.0032347480300813913, -0.05824144557118416, 0.0022763488814234734, 0.00945989042520523, -0.026767084375023842, 0.02833283506333828, 0.012636524625122547, 0.04692525789141655, -0.00925810169428587, 0.035940539091825485, 0.028522726148366928, -0.008550183847546577, -0.02007967233657837, -0.0399521104991436, 0.007701281923800707, 0.022568415850400925, 0.0694267675280571, -0.003959760535508394, 0.007632672321051359, -0.00736373383551836, -0.027572577819228172, -0.03483188524842262, 0.05908999964594841, -0.06364453583955765, 0.0585610494017601, -0.004644438158720732, -0.002556801540777087, 0.021322529762983322, 0.045178670436143875, 0.062370575964450836, 0.012421892024576664, -0.043602701276540756, 0.05426906421780586, 0.0059805503115057945, -0.007654154673218727, -0.022908048704266548, 0.02978678233921528, -0.02009461633861065, 0.009589338675141335, -0.044309649616479874, 0.012857258319854736, 0.010453271679580212, 0.029564285650849342, 0.03301946446299553, -0.0020671754609793425, -0.008260322734713554, 0.03774629533290863, 0.05589151754975319, 0.08519209921360016, -0.026628848165273666, -0.01717507280409336, 0.01965019479393959, -0.04832145944237709, -0.08698952198028564, -0.003677710425108671, -0.013758637942373753, -0.00038517577922903, -0.04446563869714737, -0.0297682024538517, 0.003440833417698741, -0.01229501236230135, 0.06056535243988037, -0.0031303667929023504, -0.020396696403622627, -0.018266012892127037, -0.0006339739775285125, -0.046308405697345734, -0.035479504615068436, 0.02872302755713463, -0.05906544253230095, -0.03788657486438751, -0.024456458166241646, -0.008965186774730682, 0.04581494256854057, -0.021521620452404022, -0.02327919565141201, -0.04927566647529602, -0.07721436023712158, -0.00018860171257983893, 0.03060268796980381, -0.04468819871544838, -0.0045187450014054775, 0.006287819240242243, 0.01978280022740364, -0.023998817428946495, -0.0300507303327322, -0.017994916066527367, 0.01028783991932869, 0.046554550528526306, 0.012704980559647083, -0.016695544123649597, -0.02532198652625084, 0.011278711259365082, 0.02615693025290966, 0.0015149986138567328, 0.025943320244550705, -0.022518739104270935, -0.0050943773239851, -0.0015638538170605898, -0.0842045471072197, -0.04065105319023132, 0.03996840491890907, 0.03242160379886627, 0.017261607572436333, 0.06897663325071335, 0.03962983563542366, -0.01639789529144764, -0.03218097612261772, 0.013790084049105644, -0.02052403800189495, 0.03132921829819679, 0.02794097736477852, 0.00446783984079957, -0.01402148324996233, 0.003409977536648512, -0.023920617997646332, -0.013451788574457169, -0.0038701933808624744, 0.05667334794998169, 0.06868135184049606, -0.009264037013053894, -0.04264451190829277, -0.026566019281744957, -0.02085476741194725, -0.006744074635207653, -0.06215003877878189, 0.0023996741510927677, 0.021166445687413216, 0.022170981392264366, 0.034684598445892334, 0.03404182195663452, 0.008477894589304924, 0.0195460207760334, -0.033718571066856384, -0.06876473128795624, 0.008781637996435165, -0.025058193132281303, 0.0013227849267423153, 0.07349592447280884, 0.030115820467472076, -0.03371470421552658, -0.0018685741815716028, -0.04487807676196098, -0.05621467903256416, 0.07766461372375488, 0.0008998609846457839, -0.0011812044540420175, -0.01859983615577221, 0.0015452743973582983, 0.04458055645227432, 0.012370800599455833, 0.054526470601558685, -0.003937904257327318, -0.008849728852510452, -0.01528016198426485, -0.03195686638355255, -0.07215164601802826, -0.0006278397049754858, 0.0006018269923515618 ]
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/vBxf1.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>(a) I am a little confused about this part. The point at A to B isn't radial. The electric field is radially outward, but if I look at the integral</p> <p>$$\int_{a}^{b}\mathbf{E}\cdot d\mathbf{s} = \int_{a}^{b}\frac{\rho r}{3\epsilon_0}\mathbf{\hat{r}}\cdot d\mathbf{s}$$</p> <p>The vector ds and r can't be in the same direction, so do I have to express it in norm form of the dot product? I am afraid to do so. So my wishful thinking answer (since it says it is 2 marks ) is </p> <p>$$\int_{a}^{b}\mathbf{E}\cdot d\mathbf{s} = \int_{r}^{R} \frac{\rho r}{3\epsilon_0}dr$$</p> <p>(b) Okay this one isn't too bad, but i am extremely paranoid. So I went back to the definition of potential</p> <p>$$V = k\int\frac{dq}{d}$$ Since the density is uniform, I simply get $V = \dfrac{kQ}{d}$</p> <p>Now I just substitute $r$ into equation and get $V = \dfrac{kQ}{r} = \dfrac{Q}{4\pi \epsilon_0r}$. </p> <p>Note that "d" is the radial distance. I avoided using r or R becuase the picture uses r and R</p> <p>Thank you for reading</p>
g9806
[ 0.02207518368959427, -0.018526718020439148, -0.03462474048137665, -0.05483094975352287, 0.059653304517269135, 0.02298259735107422, 0.05035938695073128, -0.0019695600494742393, -0.04457651451230049, -0.0022681760601699352, -0.01885109208524227, 0.06466446071863174, 0.007692945655435324, -0.03850427642464638, 0.03979530185461044, -0.006529341917484999, 0.011010780930519104, -0.05080844461917877, 0.014002006500959396, -0.02607414685189724, -0.059546150267124176, -0.0001013109358609654, 0.006973640993237495, 0.012467721477150917, 0.02724212035536766, -0.037065405398607254, 0.02187451720237732, 0.0014646346680819988, -0.07585081458091736, -0.06400060653686523, -0.00100266607478261, 0.08111530542373657, 0.04202266409993172, 0.009576603770256042, -0.02368015982210636, 0.005870077759027481, 0.03551207482814789, 0.08616277575492859, -0.0016260261181741953, -0.042243827134370804, 0.0127283725887537, -0.026462147012352943, 0.04677240550518036, 0.010494919493794441, 0.018657799810171127, -0.019736289978027344, -0.029100004583597183, 0.008512872271239758, 0.028342192992568016, 0.004123182035982609, -0.028235288336873055, 0.024912716820836067, 0.006585107650607824, -0.04380536079406738, -0.013117676600813866, 0.031434204429388046, -0.023796578869223595, -0.04498916119337082, 0.03509765490889549, 0.002515994245186448, -0.00015642789367120713, 0.004557161591947079, 0.0022392331156879663, -0.015367181971669197, 0.03164857625961304, -0.028721440583467484, -0.006389035377651453, -0.009562509134411812, -0.07464297860860825, -0.0175036508589983, 0.0354735441505909, -0.06002011522650719, 0.018440740182995796, -0.045037172734737396, -0.06706871837377548, -0.02003292366862297, 0.026232091709971428, -0.008733232505619526, -0.005003727972507477, -0.00698355957865715, -0.019198449328541756, -0.052363403141498566, 0.015402811579406261, 0.02766425348818302, 0.04644204303622246, -0.013647228479385376, 0.07599026709794998, 0.00042164232581853867, 0.011901447549462318, -0.007995771244168282, -0.003265164792537689, -0.006813495885580778, 0.0416547991335392, 0.02016502618789673, -0.010527602396905422, -0.03277115151286125, -0.049327604472637177, 0.04808143526315689, -0.018510637804865837, -0.06842826306819916, 0.03496822342276573, 0.02247460186481476, 0.04425392299890518, -0.005038372706621885, -0.058056384325027466, 0.004029287490993738, 0.0689522922039032, -0.013778402470052242, -0.008585953153669834, -0.07778429239988327, -0.058684930205345154, -0.05457943305373192, -0.03965342044830322, -0.04194948822259903, -0.008278897032141685, -0.009360394440591335, 0.04175744205713272, -0.042920421808958054, -0.010375582613050938, 0.04663633182644844, 0.04179476574063301, 0.041386883705854416, 0.05209719017148018, 0.06284943968057632, 0.02231462299823761, 0.030326293781399727, -0.032144561409950256, -0.00213926425203681, 0.05522174388170242, -0.021833933889865875, 0.002280542394146323, 0.015447307378053665, 0.009823815897107124, -0.03061286360025406, 0.0008061478729359806, 0.017750535160303116, -0.005431674420833588, 0.010010192170739174, 0.021942386403679848, -0.005530963651835918, 0.007817825302481651, -0.007022206671535969, -0.01760801114141941, -0.05504658445715904, -0.057739634066820145, -0.0040656691417098045, 0.00892807450145483, -0.0690668448805809, 0.041851118206977844, -0.014425904490053654, 0.04321872070431709, 0.07014475017786026, -0.041311439126729965, -0.015813367441296577, -0.002437895629554987, -0.006495899986475706, 0.03329140320420265, 0.027874764055013657, 0.06608802825212479, -0.017652885988354683, 0.03917734697461128, 0.013238685205578804, -0.03961864858865738, 0.023390555754303932, 0.0036077103577554226, 0.0028024727944284678, 0.06461027264595032, -0.013444815762341022, -0.0120368842035532, -0.06346017122268677, -0.028405172750353813, 0.028953850269317627, 0.022045843303203583, -0.006580841727554798, 0.004634861834347248, 0.05771307647228241, -0.059223540127277374, 0.03591226413846016, 0.0006130427354946733, -0.01799958571791649, -0.06666882336139679, -0.03857748582959175, 0.06853567063808441, -0.03032018430531025, -0.01636355370283127, -0.015468239784240723, 0.030650196596980095, 0.06054535508155823, -0.016720013692975044, -0.0008918214007280767, -0.023819344118237495, 0.018259676173329353, -0.04623828083276749, 0.04614517465233803, 0.0033652503043413162, 0.04237550497055054, 0.03136841207742691, -0.05593124032020569, -0.007696984335780144, -0.0071518332697451115, -0.023970510810613632, 0.051582783460617065, 0.05570272356271744, 0.031405139714479446, 0.016175489872694016, -0.000609901559073478, 0.015960754826664925, 0.027028651908040047, 0.06363148987293243, 0.02790028043091297, -0.01690952479839325, -0.07380560785531998, -0.008641879074275494, 0.0860738530755043, -0.027149071916937828, -0.0736890584230423, 0.006013927981257439, 0.04546963796019554, -0.06916089355945587, 0.02947503700852394, -0.09699807316064835, -0.01892206072807312, 0.05475589260458946, 0.011858242563903332, -0.026889318600296974, 0.01973591558635235, -0.0013110132422298193, -0.004073836375027895, -0.004441111348569393, -0.020376160740852356, -0.05473963916301727, -0.028394892811775208, -0.0074127777479588985, -0.04216856509447098, 0.027886802330613136, 0.02715046890079975, -0.04443299025297165, -0.07647424191236496, -0.016357121989130974, -0.016076523810625076, 0.03930753096938133, -0.00909148994833231, 0.03016030788421631, 0.06027200445532799, 0.0676971897482872, 0.012190934270620346, 0.07120736688375473, 0.04045308753848076, -0.03788600116968155, 0.028870832175016403, 0.028294887393712997, 0.07086183875799179, -0.005522510036826134, 0.020405273884534836, -0.00832615327090025, -0.027444906532764435, -0.026826485991477966, 0.01965261995792389, 0.05535081773996353, -0.04245976731181145, -0.06144199147820473, -0.01683938503265381, 0.037025801837444305, -0.01911953091621399, -0.07348122447729111, 0.03408220782876015, -0.03161177411675453, 0.01305775810033083, 0.06193947419524193, 0.0045689488761126995, -0.0026314647402614355, 0.056652531027793884, 0.015780240297317505, 0.027386317029595375, -0.007669891230762005, -0.038667209446430206, 0.009276862256228924, -0.056664712727069855, 0.017137864604592323, 0.022269142791628838, 0.023213302716612816, -0.011400870978832245, 0.018312467262148857, 0.016476133838295937, 0.04555312544107437, -0.03407570719718933, 0.025608863681554794, 0.10935735702514648, -0.008553155697882175, -0.02098742499947548, -0.022363469004631042, 0.03321556746959686, 0.03830421343445778, -0.03482675552368164, 0.008381438441574574, 0.001194713287986815, 0.007627265993505716, -0.07008565962314606, 0.0366545245051384, -0.016262657940387726, -0.030665727332234383, 0.016196507960557938, -0.054173339158296585, -0.03516945615410805, 0.06689370423555374, -0.030809449031949043, -0.029079493135213852, -0.03377692773938179, 0.009731674566864967, -0.0120641915127635, 0.05553283914923668, 0.003159045008942485, 0.01547451876103878, -0.030444437637925148, 0.01086499821394682, -0.021365508437156677, -0.015595696866512299, 0.0019774013198912144, 0.0875866711139679, 0.022072339430451393, 0.013366946950554848, -0.03926904872059822, -0.013168927282094955, 0.04305384308099747, 0.03212413936853409, 0.04247348755598068, -0.05404076725244522, 0.007352175656706095, -0.04371752589941025, -0.009798816405236721, -0.02320898324251175, -0.010865424759685993, -0.010998341254889965, -0.04899638891220093, -0.063247911632061, 0.00866451021283865, -0.0409402996301651, 0.06066036596894264, 0.023970775306224823, -0.04446610435843468, -0.03468208387494087, -0.04425559192895889, -0.038178104907274246, -0.04360436648130417, -0.014486519619822502, 0.0020298552699387074, 0.005562616512179375, 0.07533027231693268, 0.035831764340400696, 0.04105044901371002, -0.022794127464294434, -0.028681950643658638, 0.0460951142013073, -0.007521982304751873, 0.01609424501657486, -0.00362466205842793, -0.00444856658577919, 0.03636527061462402, 0.0063009923323988914, -0.012260285206139088, 0.005995787214487791, -0.05782504007220268, 0.005321237724274397, -0.020174674689769745, -0.0022755926474928856, -0.026613706722855568, -0.012004458345472813, 0.028914645314216614, -0.06906551122665405, 0.001993392826989293, -0.011852429248392582, -0.03914578631520271, 0.031272970139980316, 0.03939668834209442, 0.04466937854886055, -0.05078931897878647, -0.026365438476204872, -0.006319753360003233, -0.025963706895709038, 0.06714479625225067, 0.00556277995929122, 0.052561305463314056, 0.030738992616534233, -0.04645291343331337, 0.04524224251508713, 0.02762737311422825, -0.01563374511897564, -0.01538250595331192, 0.057691533118486404, -0.012035435996949673, 0.007695164997130632, -0.02049551159143448, -0.033811140805482864, -0.014793526381254196, -0.01055680401623249, -0.01439700834453106, 0.017438117414712906, -0.025504259392619133, -0.08114944398403168, 0.0472799614071846, -0.013745173811912537, -0.03835185244679451, 0.05592597648501396, -0.012658962979912758, -0.015866372734308243, -0.043958090245723724, 0.010070199146866798, -0.00584381865337491, 0.04133822023868561, -0.03893482685089111, -0.012636619620025158, -0.03896332532167435, 0.013490683399140835, -0.03614595904946327, 0.030918063595891, 0.00746475625783205, 0.06562595814466476, 0.0020126309245824814, 0.016516074538230896, -0.010785480961203575, 0.003010408952832222, -0.012664800509810448, 0.029667513445019722, -0.02703903056681156, 0.0232836976647377, 0.06985078006982803, 0.11686360090970993, -0.01838552951812744, 0.005171139724552631, 0.02645602822303772, -0.026363587006926537, 0.05548674613237381, -0.028953198343515396, 0.004579535685479641, -0.07724474370479584, 0.04068251699209213, -0.08090790361166, 0.01857420615851879, 0.00636623939499259, 0.02728869579732418, -0.004041791427880526, -0.03679255396127701, 0.01452728547155857, -0.008169949986040592, -0.008609548211097717, 0.03768506646156311, -0.04974561929702759, -0.026189463213086128, 0.008621854707598686, -0.011291959322988987, -0.049747906625270844, 0.028008224442601204, 0.029233282431960106, -0.011679369024932384, 0.0025912343990057707, -0.02321339026093483, -0.04388435184955597, -0.014909758232533932, 0.036503806710243225, -0.01532638818025589, -0.016845857724547386, 0.004597121849656105, -0.04015231877565384, -0.030032193288207054, 0.0808681920170784, -0.024386467412114143, -0.04430641606450081, 0.015684714540839195, -0.0381028987467289, -0.02299589477479458, 0.03569408878684044, 0.009470438584685326, 0.022001292556524277, -0.02241227775812149, 0.03859443962574005, 0.0061324057169258595, 0.02161371149122715, -0.0038629453629255295, -0.02922273986041546, -0.02895524352788925, -0.04704061150550842, -0.02349506877362728, 0.026338623836636543, 0.06073083356022835, 0.010802377946674824, 0.03349551185965538, 0.003743597073480487, -0.013319249264895916, -0.014211416244506836, -0.004763252101838589, 0.020086020231246948, 0.05760239437222481, 0.006892477162182331, 0.023590918630361557, 0.034503500908613205, 0.04579392448067665, 0.011930773966014385, 0.006200021132826805, -0.0217775609344244, -0.03384964540600777, -0.08245356380939484, -0.02514430694282055, -0.03261478990316391, 0.021396316587924957, -0.017521072179079056, 0.05533371493220329, 0.0490836538374424, -0.013501320965588093, 0.05108882859349251, 0.03814205527305603, 0.01642494834959507, -0.005772106349468231, 0.059728484600782394, 0.004776312038302422, -0.014329466037452221, -0.04809429123997688, -0.07722155004739761, 0.03131124749779701, -0.01196402870118618, -0.06871979683637619, 0.0913979783654213, -0.02918996848165989, 0.007506858091801405, -0.06607354432344437, 0.07140226662158966, -0.008298628963530064, -0.026647036895155907, -0.06868626922369003, -0.0032408584374934435, 0.04880277067422867, -0.03363823890686035, 0.023346178233623505, 0.005124855320900679, -0.017836501821875572, -0.0253696721047163, -0.03716424107551575, -0.04398806393146515, -0.0011614372488111258, 0.07298091799020767, -0.029967213049530983, 0.03336659073829651, -0.027317726984620094, -0.029068101197481155, -0.005305145867168903, -0.11561769992113113, 0.020512420684099197, 0.0019062019418925047, -0.03005884774029255, 0.010492662899196148, -0.03058253414928913, 0.014934856444597244, 0.03323503956198692, -0.07229162752628326, -0.029929181560873985, 0.047616634517908096, -0.023079408332705498, -0.014245695434510708, -0.02505098469555378, -0.049123410135507584, -0.029963241890072823, 0.017567504197359085, -0.022011425346136093, -0.02925017662346363, 0.03829033672809601, -0.007772167678922415, -0.06252766400575638, 0.03447341546416283, -0.0008149928180500865, 0.058873262256383896, 0.012142975814640522, 0.0106344074010849, -0.04513389244675636, 0.011759694665670395, 0.01795642450451851, 0.05784180015325546, -0.007799281273037195, 0.008419168181717396, 0.0015577126760035753, 0.005239246878772974, 0.007079637609422207, 0.00784187763929367, 0.05853934958577156, 0.018657060340046883, -0.04853510856628418, -0.012434466741979122, 0.050570376217365265, -0.031051138415932655, -0.04316525533795357, 0.02631428651511669, -0.030293848365545273, -0.02470334991812706, 0.02417062222957611, -0.019656075164675713, 0.012751031666994095, -0.009403439238667488, 0.021846838295459747, -0.029236767441034317, 0.010625644586980343, 0.011315528303384781, 0.004557670094072819, -0.0033969467040151358, 0.016660554334521294, 0.004853198770433664, -0.010269016958773136, 0.03283719718456268, 0.0017694192938506603, 0.031747594475746155, -0.010500499047338963, -0.06623301655054092, 0.015422757714986801, 0.018276801332831383, 0.047065768390893936, -0.006157636642456055, 0.04604412242770195, 0.058787282556295395, 0.03245903551578522, 0.016131781041622162, 0.036506287753582, -0.03631708398461342, 0.025260308757424355, 0.0030442443676292896, -0.00560728320851922, -0.005717590916901827, -0.0007570679881609976, 0.023996546864509583, 0.04527086392045021, -0.029074115678668022, -0.02815231680870056, 0.0147009352222085, 0.0210157111287117, 0.00973393302410841, -0.023122189566493034, -0.04447055235505104, 0.06825469434261322, 0.024134473875164986, 0.026256658136844635, -0.027021456509828568, 0.033733662217855453, 0.04088437929749489, 0.0366303026676178, -0.05917786806821823, 0.03548713028430939, -0.01079768780618906, -0.019855396822094917, -0.04088016599416733, -0.07065332680940628, 0.024532241746783257, 0.015129203908145428, -0.053330689668655396, 0.007125991862267256, 0.0807725042104721, 0.049866244196891785, -0.03074593096971512, -0.02934705652296543, -0.0050846245139837265, -0.02056293934583664, 0.058698371052742004, 0.07684630155563354, -0.021641137078404427, -0.036949463188648224, -0.00819091685116291, -0.014078167267143726, -0.041799090802669525, -0.015946006402373314, 0.006406736094504595, 0.004658613819628954, -0.01219488587230444, -0.04186636209487915, -0.0757153108716011, -0.09723624587059021, 0.025985250249505043, 0.030243007466197014, 0.03236595541238785, 0.03564343973994255, 0.021331194788217545, 0.045262861996889114, 0.038472481071949005, 0.0028685342986136675, -0.012231688015162945, -0.0059244041331112385, -0.004439289681613445, 0.019104965031147003, -0.014352478086948395, -0.020281851291656494, -0.06027153879404068, 0.034537412226200104, -0.04318782687187195, -0.026419274508953094, 0.04758827015757561, 0.048089828342199326, -0.005273257847875357, 0.03919842839241028, -0.0004091092851012945, 0.005941739771515131, 0.010317393578588963, 0.048414647579193115, 0.013948148116469383, 0.03817541524767876, 0.024715248495340347, 0.018460627645254135, -0.004367121960967779, -0.022551404312253, -0.011432463303208351, -0.04405719414353371, 0.018659697845578194, -0.006077425088733435, 0.020992614328861237, 0.00964412372559309, -0.024808203801512718, 0.008628363721072674, 0.0708896741271019, -0.0239724013954401, 0.006655727047473192, -0.006966221146285534, 0.04154256358742714, 0.021712379530072212, -0.038730185478925705, 0.0829700231552124, -0.016103196889162064, -0.05149661377072334, 0.00821679923683405, 0.029942449182271957, 0.011254841461777687, -0.025337180122733116, -0.01903579942882061, -0.0431903600692749, -0.023930106312036514, -0.05251358449459076, 0.05669107660651207, -0.01785527728497982, -0.04266979917883873, 0.0008033124031499028, -0.03580079227685928, 0.012352627702057362, -0.027866102755069733, 0.028438750654459, -0.016298076137900352, -0.023533672094345093, 0.030548932030797005, -0.004622222855687141, -0.019543154165148735, -0.06239548698067665, 0.011708084493875504, -0.014017129316926003, -0.018362246453762054, -0.006647223606705666, -0.037512391805648804, 0.019063707441091537, 0.07310876995325089, -0.02781592682003975, -0.0073809316381812096, -0.009438691660761833, -0.06456825882196426, 0.03449621796607971, 0.07157596200704575, -0.03464272618293762, 0.044152941554784775, 0.014994575642049313, 0.03539382293820381, -0.01208075787872076, -0.005609976593405008, -0.05061081424355507, -0.03556197136640549, 0.035210900008678436, 0.022027449682354927, -0.06102937459945679, -0.045398883521556854, 0.034883491694927216 ]
<p>Where is the source of the photon. </p> <p>If the photon propagates from within the electrons transit does this point to some sort of field?</p> <p>Does the energy come from a boundary being broken in laymens terms a sound barrier type effect the electron performs on its shell as it changes orbit?</p>
g9807
[ 0.018832139670848846, 0.07634952664375305, 0.01225918810814619, -0.01868591643869877, 0.007827783934772015, -0.0007965241675265133, 0.020405510440468788, 0.028875721618533134, 0.012878131121397018, -0.02350059151649475, -0.017225166782736778, 0.04351555183529854, 0.007691891398280859, -0.017241135239601135, -0.009168446995317936, -0.05359697341918945, 0.0861540213227272, -0.01313288975507021, 0.041560444980859756, 0.07750066369771957, -0.055226825177669525, -0.012376491911709309, -0.024723554030060768, -0.04199093580245972, -0.008256953209638596, -0.011575603857636452, 0.05294191464781761, -0.04723137617111206, 0.010683353990316391, -0.05380094796419144, 0.006495581939816475, -0.07275677472352982, 0.06655455380678177, -0.041124191135168076, -0.03851979970932007, 0.006785158533602953, 0.029676126316189766, 0.0785076841711998, 0.043090153485536575, 0.021499261260032654, 0.031604692339897156, -0.04812770336866379, -0.007890066131949425, -0.017847100272774696, 0.03314921632409096, -0.022492611780762672, 0.007533009629696608, -0.017399977892637253, 0.00974821113049984, -0.0392991304397583, -0.05702640488743782, 0.04065593332052231, 0.01499771699309349, 0.04901720955967903, 0.021968496963381767, 0.02036236971616745, -0.02448788657784462, -0.010391326621174812, 0.11848682910203934, -0.04574959725141525, 0.00558300269767642, 0.023038171231746674, 0.02615997940301895, 0.011901363730430603, 0.04192239046096802, -0.02275245636701584, -0.06505322456359863, 0.04263238236308098, -0.01662023738026619, -0.01868232525885105, 0.06858740746974945, -0.03607989102602005, -0.017786182463169098, -0.04251052439212799, -0.0014844376128166914, -0.005704969167709351, -0.001962752314284444, 0.00033566507045179605, -0.0636291429400444, 0.04060788080096245, 0.0239108894020319, -0.0680987611413002, 0.025284964591264725, -0.03836260735988617, 0.10199142247438431, -0.001480619888752699, -0.006739236880093813, 0.025308625772595406, -0.03897952660918236, -0.017678000032901764, 0.042222630232572556, -0.02931063249707222, 0.044073235243558884, -0.025703366845846176, -0.016800565645098686, -0.04312587156891823, -0.01985771395266056, 0.03966513276100159, 0.005416713189333677, -0.006126300431787968, -0.041763368993997574, -0.0038462502416223288, 0.01820058934390545, 0.019237905740737915, -0.004225235432386398, -0.017830688506364822, -0.009650776162743568, -0.060978226363658905, 0.028598833829164505, 0.02863636612892151, 0.022549768909811974, -0.06725060939788818, -0.01784728281199932, -0.0582234263420105, -0.015808774158358574, 0.006653864402323961, 0.03191997483372688, -0.008600971661508083, 0.017231857404112816, 0.07878054678440094, 0.0118569890037179, 0.023830804973840714, -0.034896235913038254, 0.035749293863773346, -0.02067834697663784, 0.05262913554906845, -0.004474183544516563, -0.037439413368701935, 0.018686512485146523, 0.00023420884099323303, 0.015331431291997433, 0.03091488778591156, 0.0017522841226309538, -0.0048654647544026375, 0.05491110682487488, 0.01061298418790102, 0.05995002016425133, -0.020235413685441017, 0.020471852272748947, -0.015114965848624706, 0.030072849243879318, 0.016678424552083015, 0.005885440390557051, -0.04603331908583641, -0.008026732131838799, -0.0038098390214145184, 0.02723047323524952, 0.005788497626781464, 0.03357577696442604, 0.042819224298000336, 0.01365697756409645, 0.03981446474790573, -0.036537300795316696, -0.0339268259704113, 0.05002162605524063, -0.04069312661886215, 0.02585098333656788, 0.003884786507114768, 0.0055122580379247665, 0.02233896031975746, 0.036284275352954865, 0.008335931226611137, 0.012320050038397312, -0.012040331028401852, -0.03956490382552147, -0.03706565126776695, -0.0043510207906365395, -0.047408975660800934, -0.0031241646502166986, 0.00722854258492589, 0.01799049787223339, -0.010501121170818806, -0.013517779298126698, 0.028858238831162453, -0.04968972131609917, 0.07250628620386124, 0.01413760893046856, -0.005581338424235582, 0.03766190633177757, 0.0318375825881958, -0.012041987851262093, -0.0499207004904747, 0.05804912745952606, -0.04812401160597801, 0.05360247194766998, -0.04655297100543976, -0.04642702266573906, -0.062442101538181305, -0.02623353712260723, 0.020997527986764908, -0.015785060822963715, -0.010104024782776833, 0.01865614950656891, -0.022362783551216125, -0.03564919903874397, -0.024213578552007675, -0.009370059706270695, -0.06249302998185158, -0.009269879199564457, -0.052044741809368134, -0.013154398649930954, 0.053243450820446014, -0.010227003134787083, 0.011272631585597992, 0.02347848005592823, 0.047760527580976486, 0.0006792648346163332, 0.003422765526920557, -0.039780277758836746, 0.013887648470699787, 0.058914460241794586, -0.043902311474084854, 0.02600594237446785, 0.01781141199171543, -0.045569535344839096, 0.02016741782426834, -0.0028031535912305117, -0.008867545984685421, 0.043496277183294296, 0.012859598733484745, -0.03206338360905647, 0.015020230785012245, 0.017161695286631584, -0.05828006938099861, -0.0013431771658360958, 0.021129652857780457, -0.04281305521726608, -0.03550545498728752, -0.032546091824769974, 0.07359175384044647, -0.061136629432439804, -0.014847816899418831, -0.04566194862127304, -0.03352857008576393, 0.060897521674633026, -0.06751138716936111, -0.04217349737882614, -0.03176499903202057, -0.018540309742093086, -0.029490970075130463, 0.07109473645687103, -0.03039574809372425, -0.06535954773426056, 0.0006320739048533142, 0.006081494502723217, -0.023818323388695717, 0.06418327987194061, -0.0007416617008857429, -0.014477773569524288, -0.03501396253705025, 0.033965423703193665, -0.02270030416548252, -0.010822929441928864, 0.05208415165543556, -0.024702049791812897, -0.057222288101911545, -0.00689267460256815, 0.03474744036793709, -0.04163180664181709, -0.055376406759023666, -0.06237801909446716, -0.024519911035895348, -0.0053675416857004166, -0.054950959980487823, 0.013147611171007156, -0.006847800686955452, 0.03838053345680237, 0.0030709209386259317, -0.022654766216874123, 0.008914065547287464, -0.0422833152115345, 0.101953886449337, 0.06432951241731644, 0.0004010291304439306, 0.027607711032032967, -0.025464341044425964, 0.00220679584890604, -0.01902521401643753, 0.022847607731819153, -0.05635501816868782, -0.019247837364673615, 0.010367412120103836, 0.0028639486990869045, -0.013038503006100655, 0.023607030510902405, -0.08565331250429153, 0.047258395701646805, -0.03899526968598366, 0.006914906203746796, -0.04157238453626633, -0.02994164451956749, -0.025932788848876953, 0.04461842030286789, 0.022848090156912804, -0.009436213411390781, -0.0078069595620036125, 0.03022637590765953, 0.030239246785640717, -0.0124439662322402, -0.00645947502925992, -0.029946468770503998, 0.014987349510192871, -0.06658277660608292, -0.010326355695724487, -0.0004990606103092432, -0.021499646827578545, -0.0064345793798565865, -0.011935469694435596, -0.007387291640043259, 0.00554746575653553, 0.025178346782922745, 0.01974211260676384, 0.06035928428173065, 0.0345919094979763, 0.0025033869314938784, 0.021569857373833656, -0.05120507627725601, 0.022508755326271057, 0.02426799386739731, -0.006429813336580992, -0.06286492198705673, -0.0027061065193265676, -0.022099420428276062, -0.00840034056454897, 0.01687498204410076, 0.04107222706079483, 0.016986969858407974, 0.004938760306686163, -0.03644418343901634, -0.044202759861946106, -0.022198397666215897, -0.02669108286499977, -0.05621706694364548, 0.008819290436804295, 0.04152800142765045, 0.001773162162862718, 0.013905477710068226, 0.06870836764574051, 0.040920838713645935, 0.024124396964907646, 0.03098253905773163, 0.015830811113119125, -0.028038714081048965, 0.04236360266804695, 0.013472533784806728, 0.00045889971079304814, -0.0031103985384106636, -0.04026836156845093, 0.02438652142882347, -0.024291016161441803, 0.012340877205133438, -0.0038546123541891575, -0.02127297781407833, 0.02263510972261429, -0.0631486102938652, -0.007897734642028809, -0.016500072553753853, 0.013711812905967236, 0.018390430137515068, 0.0039095026440918446, 0.002771734492853284, -0.04450291767716408, 0.07909838110208511, -0.015706628561019897, -0.019499195739626884, 0.007954730652272701, -0.007111700251698494, -0.028963975608348846, 0.03324116766452789, -0.005901515018194914, -0.041015010327100754, -0.011860963888466358, -0.01479571033269167, 0.03055417165160179, -0.0074307676404714584, -0.03519632667303085, -0.04751955345273018, 0.005801822058856487, -0.05575039982795715, -0.005257437936961651, -0.00117978744674474, 0.0007359267910942435, 0.06631218641996384, -0.0017285667126998305, 0.024115756154060364, 0.005463459528982639, -0.020118119195103645, -0.008356720209121704, -0.037979159504175186, -0.001170994946733117, 0.012387310154736042, -0.030414773151278496, -0.010988879017531872, 0.012280362658202648, 0.009148165583610535, -0.007285763043910265, 0.0010387373622506857, -0.041799791157245636, 0.0276077538728714, 0.055947981774806976, 0.03322264179587364, 0.017106005921959877, -0.021926434710621834, -0.015691833570599556, -0.012387766502797604, 0.007004193030297756, 0.09720156341791153, -0.046194326132535934, -0.08123423904180527, -0.021609295159578323, 0.01782555691897869, -0.029187243431806564, -0.06592600792646408, -0.05898149684071541, -0.037497036159038544, -0.022939134389162064, 0.05889438837766647, 0.06402748823165894, 0.030276335775852203, -0.010022209957242012, -0.060382381081581116, 0.011414241045713425, 0.05969269573688507, 0.010133984498679638, -0.03832472860813141, 0.10298312455415726, 0.027102582156658173, -0.021502967923879623, 0.0015788843156769872, -0.014880357310175896, -0.009237915277481079, 0.017869215458631516, -0.024602169170975685, 0.03966112062335014, -0.02465840056538582, 0.047381963580846786, -0.06053326651453972, -0.021884966641664505, -0.009744451381266117, -0.002730849664658308, 0.10642692446708679, -0.01641588844358921, 0.02293422631919384, 0.03381752222776413, -0.012275038287043571, 0.056807421147823334, 0.010589507408440113, -0.02435212768614292, 0.01720225252211094, -0.04438992962241173, -0.06663449853658676, -0.020864104852080345, -0.026398755609989166, 0.013678880408406258, 0.02166283316910267, -0.015255528502166271, -0.036508481949567795, -0.07049983739852905, -0.020825855433940887, 0.012830239720642567, -0.02472086064517498, -0.048267923295497894, 0.050550296902656555, 0.031194524839520454, 0.00811175350099802, -0.04974794387817383, -0.04476642608642578, 0.012657132931053638, -0.03481737896800041, 0.015529045835137367, 0.029577357694506645, 0.046127431094646454, 0.008710426278412342, 0.02084592543542385, 0.01943986490368843, -0.017288953065872192, -0.05503058433532715, 0.009302280843257904, -0.03545525297522545, -0.0780029222369194, 0.05461578816175461, 0.006947475951164961, 0.033979445695877075, 0.023144017904996872, -0.030144870281219482, 0.06596315652132034, -0.044706620275974274, 0.04396241903305054, 0.039011865854263306, -0.0887269452214241, 0.021630246192216873, 0.023954203352332115, -0.02280978299677372, -0.0653117448091507, 0.019072825089097023, 0.007202375214546919, 0.029879163950681686, -0.0015977045986801386, 0.03368525579571724, 0.04103682562708855, -0.048101965337991714, 0.017478594556450844, 0.019130345433950424, 0.06764191389083862, -0.0018425602465867996, 0.049902014434337616, 0.026692522689700127, -0.0027044296730309725, 0.008935458026826382, -0.008450957015156746, 0.004295835271477699, -0.03349531069397926, -0.0741080790758133, -0.025359179824590683, 0.053348757326602936, -0.0477757528424263, 0.00909111462533474, 0.03618622198700905, 0.019165845587849617, -0.021669067442417145, -0.003960977774113417, 0.0007350768428295851, 0.02111183851957321, -0.02978389523923397, 0.08603716641664505, -0.0005605613114312291, -0.02467193268239498, -0.02810467593371868, 0.022189611569046974, 0.0063284034840762615, 0.027929166331887245, 0.0470859631896019, 0.045664023607969284, 0.005946007091552019, -0.017036516219377518, -0.08007030189037323, -0.00011041853576898575, 0.012030423618853092, -0.03839428350329399, 0.0026367499958723783, -0.01577111706137657, -0.05271436274051666, 0.0007382806506939232, 0.018985530361533165, -0.00561554217711091, 0.006146751809865236, -0.07443038374185562, 0.03309690207242966, 0.01294182613492012, -0.0409623347222805, 0.03675537556409836, 0.027422646060585976, -0.043478865176439285, -0.0003191047871951014, -0.0291499774903059, 0.02935113199055195, -0.00047082436503842473, -0.0147708710283041, -0.03728274628520012, -0.03668193891644478, 0.04221922531723976, 0.0365355908870697, 0.003847756190225482, 0.05080645903944969, 0.05196612328290939, 0.025410695001482964, -0.03233703225851059, -0.03818008303642273, 0.007591149304062128, -0.017072031274437904, 0.009040840901434422, 0.028505852445960045, -0.06901800632476807, -0.04294604808092117, -0.0016541143413633108, -0.012583747506141663, -0.011758853681385517, -0.01368437148630619, -0.10590766370296478, -0.0023187906481325626, -0.00024679579655639827, 0.04127708077430725, 0.036032769829034805, -0.007834019139409065, 0.014844120480120182, 0.03399856761097908, -0.05141511186957359, 0.03241631016135216, 0.11889788508415222, 0.011793289333581924, 0.006515915039926767, -0.03317505866289139, 0.013353820890188217, 0.018295791000127792, -0.03655192255973816, -0.030680086463689804, 0.0016304011223837733, -0.012573516927659512, -0.008411508984863758, 0.058693353086709976, -0.018353454768657684, -0.014213619753718376, -0.002176827983930707, -0.03987029939889908, 0.04759247973561287, 0.008007665164768696, 0.01128045842051506, 0.019994931295514107, 0.0027839909307658672, -0.0007658825488761067, 0.015017415396869183, -0.0028863553889095783, 0.04369259625673294, -0.0028130547143518925, -0.048353198915719986, 0.015799276530742645, -0.03045744262635708, 0.0055594430305063725, -0.017861992120742798, 0.006926676258444786, 0.04144727438688278, -0.02746674232184887, 0.023233328014612198, -0.022398386150598526, 0.02196291647851467, 0.07627667486667633, -0.041131068021059036, 0.03048841841518879, 0.041505131870508194, -0.02196073718369007, 0.013351432979106903, 0.03202745318412781, -0.02867668867111206, 0.032639238983392715, -0.03206164017319679, 0.012713952921330929, -0.008676928468048573, 0.00808093324303627, -0.0018130306852981448, 0.03531835600733757, 0.04583672806620598, 0.011203735135495663, 0.055802326649427414, 0.02385447360575199, -0.011680973693728447, 0.050944432616233826, 0.02354128472507, 0.01085145864635706, -0.03619726002216339, -0.04504980519413948, -0.02031441405415535, 0.005052781198173761, -0.019894970580935478, -0.005081390496343374, 0.013899382203817368, 0.05351082608103752, -0.020395182073116302, 0.024349721148610115, -0.020476359874010086, -0.07146072387695312, -0.012890305370092392, -0.016170112416148186, -0.039306674152612686, 0.036502957344055176, 0.016409870237112045, 0.013949790969491005, -0.023906247690320015, -0.05637424439191818, -0.011970997788012028, 0.009884310886263847, 0.03618260845541954, -0.07792563736438751, -0.06393066793680191, 0.06320716440677643, -0.027597375214099884, 0.025277860462665558, -0.0033621129114180803, 0.04473099112510681, -0.04088715463876724, -0.04576132819056511, 0.04983466863632202, 0.05739326402544975, 0.0016777666751295328, -0.029595501720905304, 0.014524029567837715, -0.04942784830927849, -0.028968801721930504, -0.03975500166416168, -0.001348055899143219, 0.00818414893001318, 0.04528796300292015, 0.030308352783322334, 0.015140206553041935, -0.06504231691360474, -0.032346438616514206, -0.016837315633893013, -0.014752828516066074, 0.0844387412071228, 0.03508581966161728, 0.025513067841529846, -0.0306384414434433, 0.0011930454056710005, 0.02463805302977562, -0.00955455843359232, 0.013290733098983765, 0.00900302454829216, 0.028279168531298637, 0.014019660651683807, -0.02449899911880493, -0.02097896859049797, 0.03977504000067711, -0.01365702971816063, 0.016650095582008362, 0.0065392483957111835, 0.0036151523236185312, 0.026112262159585953, 0.027576513588428497, 0.14716969430446625, 0.05565207451581955, 0.03878634423017502, 0.020559921860694885, 0.01929735578596592, -0.018007371574640274, 0.020000774413347244, -0.00005200373925617896, 0.005562023259699345, 0.04246241971850395, -0.05231187865138054, 0.0028686653822660446, -0.0519060380756855, -0.002353242365643382, 0.012157823890447617, -0.0010188926244154572, -0.07793028652667999, -0.038513921201229095, -0.0035943652037531137, 0.05034802109003067, -0.021383702754974365, 0.08268030732870102, -0.03235896676778793, 0.021527906879782677, -0.07035911083221436, 0.01703096181154251, -0.02490556798875332, -0.0019931914284825325, -0.0011883457191288471, -0.005701789166778326, -0.008021555840969086, 0.029587941244244576, -0.0532953254878521, 0.02536299265921116, -0.010682059451937675, -0.05068948492407799, 0.061335135251283646, 0.04768248274922371, -0.10927601903676987, -0.011525831185281277, -0.015204302035272121, -0.006530950777232647, 0.006479255389422178, 0.010081787593662739, -0.011143150739371777, 0.07712962478399277, -0.027876047417521477, -0.0589132085442543, 0.011538847349584103, 0.033537477254867554, -0.030186332762241364 ]
<p>There are a decent number of complex mathematical descriptions of the zero-dispersion wavelength online, but I can't seem to find any basic explanations. So to be redundant, what is it?</p>
g9808
[ -0.027792412787675858, -0.014805030077695847, -0.022417521104216576, -0.01036048773676157, 0.031426865607500076, -0.012224691919982433, 0.06294532120227814, 0.027802418917417526, -0.009052908048033714, -0.056829068809747696, -0.010802029632031918, -0.009360612370073795, 0.04959907382726669, 0.002237017499282956, -0.0031376739498227835, -0.026235679164528847, -0.04177921637892723, 0.054427631199359894, 0.055966250598430634, 0.03762385994195938, -0.057540107518434525, -0.06288683414459229, -0.0010433789575472474, -0.08260829746723175, -0.0745575875043869, 0.005015923175960779, 0.004743733908981085, -0.03638477995991707, -0.035107456147670746, -0.0511169359087944, 0.05486830323934555, -0.000029606690077343956, 0.08330807089805603, 0.0023763570934534073, -0.05047817900776863, 0.0668124109506607, -0.04289691150188446, 0.012607377953827381, -0.014300488866865635, 0.03004147857427597, 0.027474205940961838, -0.014239298179745674, -0.002122560515999794, -0.056651823222637177, -0.033783186227083206, 0.01704498566687107, -0.03507913276553154, 0.02015654183924198, -0.011055788956582546, -0.002003105590119958, 0.019482174888253212, -0.05572136119008064, 0.07630650699138641, 0.03120514564216137, 0.023380566388368607, -0.020340174436569214, 0.006357073783874512, 0.013434010557830334, 0.016917049884796143, 0.06872350722551346, 0.014199323020875454, 0.020549351349473, -0.04713226854801178, 0.049663446843624115, 0.051423098891973495, 0.021374277770519257, -0.008613228797912598, -0.014353985898196697, 0.025884954258799553, 0.010427437722682953, -0.006363036576658487, -0.08081304281949997, -0.07057802379131317, -0.01981746405363083, -0.031101223081350327, -0.011344147846102715, 0.002091052243486047, 0.04135949909687042, 0.016885466873645782, -0.0006311251199804246, -0.06275048851966858, 0.01650909148156643, -0.02442013844847679, 0.0345744714140892, 0.022833066061139107, 0.030949337407946587, 0.02943998947739601, -0.003176589962095022, 0.013518531806766987, -0.012008581310510635, 0.008730359375476837, 0.03366326540708542, 0.030836546793580055, -0.026611393317580223, 0.0235440693795681, -0.04471723362803459, 0.013473794795572758, 0.04770955070853233, 0.005264642648398876, -0.0200498066842556, 0.007115039974451065, -0.012445091269910336, -0.007861443795263767, 0.00867433287203312, 0.007937788031995296, 0.08154766261577606, -0.015879938378930092, -0.02008487470448017, -0.0010152936447411776, 0.012892493978142738, -0.05802435427904129, 0.007480680011212826, -0.047186821699142456, 0.023473316803574562, -0.001365196192637086, -0.01596040278673172, 0.07611510902643204, -0.01273682713508606, 0.04367087781429291, -0.005209349095821381, 0.03975742682814598, 0.035374246537685394, 0.02322816103696823, 0.03962124139070511, -0.036917466670274734, -0.028323110193014145, 0.05279112979769707, -0.0022030677646398544, -0.01506537850946188, -0.003496771212667227, 0.040381722152233124, 0.04799818992614746, -0.05287308990955353, 0.0023204777389764786, 0.022061729803681374, -0.010955275036394596, 0.010439923033118248, -0.03833432495594025, -0.028065258637070656, 0.07111305743455887, -0.021026214584708214, -0.035003911703825, 0.038755152374506, -0.05732615664601326, 0.014759323559701443, -0.031568098813295364, -0.004055628087371588, -0.04047517478466034, 0.05805742368102074, -0.004435397684574127, 0.0298959668725729, 0.06268791109323502, 0.017897741869091988, -0.05753142386674881, -0.03688126057386398, -0.017877258360385895, 0.04950624704360962, -0.0628151148557663, 0.010333778336644173, 0.013818617910146713, 0.059735167771577835, -0.021717287600040436, -0.02817443758249283, 0.03133541718125343, -0.05981079861521721, -0.03552250936627388, -0.009119725786149502, -0.06350072473287582, 0.01426259521394968, -0.04168311506509781, 0.01904463768005371, -0.02216060645878315, -0.013470839709043503, 0.07001601159572601, -0.006681382190436125, 0.03798024728894234, 0.06305667757987976, 0.022016173228621483, -0.030179211869835854, -0.022866399958729744, -0.01688320003449917, 0.0026624344754964113, 0.0074765803292393684, -0.029046766459941864, 0.04842193424701691, -0.0007182802073657513, -0.010123227722942829, -0.02240127883851528, -0.021030904725193977, 0.04619219899177551, -0.001245112274773419, -0.026874305680394173, 0.08055606484413147, 0.025819206610322, -0.026907367631793022, -0.013631874695420265, -0.009792385622859001, 0.011709933169186115, -0.023969555273652077, 0.04565104842185974, -0.0022056850139051676, 0.04987187683582306, 0.025145573541522026, 0.008862207643687725, -0.007199055515229702, -0.02286679856479168, -0.018823079764842987, 0.0376870222389698, 0.019977614283561707, 0.00635360274463892, 0.030161291360855103, -0.03360770270228386, 0.04201577603816986, -0.01511662732809782, 0.02313387207686901, -0.023565955460071564, -0.07104340940713882, -0.008917314931750298, -0.01599903404712677, 0.035445116460323334, -0.016274234279990196, -0.012364359572529793, 0.06895099580287933, -0.003474232042208314, -0.0029786007944494486, 0.002157997339963913, 0.030731352046132088, -0.03949892893433571, 0.03721948713064194, 0.05402703210711479, -0.039776530116796494, -0.06659340113401413, -0.04040716215968132, -0.010390370152890682, -0.019664378836750984, 0.024479467421770096, -0.008164185099303722, 0.02690943144261837, -0.007642814889550209, 0.032337870448827744, 0.023335911333560944, -0.012755430303514004, -0.04782862961292267, 0.07551407068967819, 0.011086090467870235, -0.05552934110164642, 0.025763386860489845, -0.049258049577474594, -0.01686311699450016, -0.0030285113025456667, 0.016658995300531387, -0.02571149170398712, -0.026570647954940796, 0.013179788365960121, -0.017518965527415276, -0.02204093150794506, 0.016294395551085472, 0.03667886555194855, -0.08273442089557648, -0.033745210617780685, 0.038741759955883026, 0.014850001782178879, 0.004217319656163454, -0.021923070773482323, 0.0009743167902342975, -0.03757210820913315, -0.02880852110683918, 0.059206437319517136, -0.041554972529411316, -0.03272214159369469, 0.014697426930069923, 0.049474604427814484, -0.013947601430118084, -0.015478293411433697, -0.04331880807876587, 0.009730921126902103, 0.03527553379535675, 0.016530700027942657, 0.03836221247911453, 0.004241185262799263, 0.08707305043935776, -0.007722506765276194, -0.015617558732628822, -0.0010281055001541972, -0.015049345791339874, -0.10274796932935715, 0.029807034879922867, 0.08208491653203964, 0.010387345217168331, -0.04079741612076759, 0.004200119990855455, -0.01957543194293976, -0.03193172812461853, 0.035539913922548294, -0.009982100687921047, -0.02912067621946335, 0.04192294925451279, -0.019441192969679832, 0.011426392942667007, -0.009951629675924778, -0.03900723531842232, 0.010920267552137375, 0.027000347152352333, -0.04060094431042671, 0.012634442187845707, 0.03674779459834099, -0.017640814185142517, -0.03827301040291786, -0.04714073985815048, -0.0070475125685334206, -0.012723124586045742, 0.030981242656707764, 0.009955231100320816, 0.027838435024023056, 0.01083636935800314, 0.02906385064125061, -0.0357222780585289, -0.04674564674496651, 0.023290041834115982, -0.0006360367988236248, -0.04957476630806923, -0.009453712031245232, 0.006787706632167101, -0.008986524306237698, 0.0026456336490809917, 0.0534231923520565, 0.011987743899226189, -0.013891172595322132, -0.055623967200517654, 0.04676247015595436, -0.0002590690564829856, -0.04301561042666435, -0.00955649372190237, -0.01151563972234726, -0.02084273099899292, -0.05671892315149307, -0.023506134748458862, -0.02683849073946476, 0.05314338952302933, 0.029183216392993927, 0.007944853976368904, 0.0015628442633897066, -0.05359547957777977, 0.013105258345603943, 0.02661513350903988, 0.03431975096464157, -0.016094442456960678, 0.028966305777430534, -0.021395640447735786, -0.02097141183912754, 0.012857181020081043, -0.00629766657948494, -0.01565047912299633, -0.06818372756242752, -0.044854652136564255, 0.012691755779087543, 0.009862277656793594, 0.029556987807154655, 0.06771081686019897, -0.007403860799968243, 0.06458025425672531, -0.034956250339746475, 0.01316036656498909, 0.0005552312359213829, 0.01828109100461006, -0.023721065372228622, -0.014524471946060658, 0.021139049902558327, -0.044312313199043274, -0.00047701899893581867, -0.047031715512275696, -0.005781498271971941, -0.06665672361850739, -0.022539382800459862, -0.007591655012220144, 0.0012898333370685577, -0.018543384969234467, -0.002792840823531151, -0.02267427183687687, 0.06839112192392349, 0.011127796955406666, 0.04084618762135506, 0.053628187626600266, -0.017138397321105003, -0.004441147670149803, -0.022027194499969482, -0.10268896818161011, -0.059921346604824066, -0.022482017055153847, -0.016283376142382622, -0.015096179209649563, -0.013601922430098057, 0.040426693856716156, -0.023752247914671898, 0.011091413907706738, 0.0004603670386131853, -0.013333895243704319, 0.004204013850539923, 0.015596947632730007, 0.059095628559589386, 0.01957198604941368, 0.06206779181957245, 0.003935692831873894, -0.02889091707766056, 0.011924831196665764, 0.04737617447972298, 0.02552747167646885, -0.02339211478829384, 0.014738773927092552, 0.005577779840677977, -0.020594120025634766, 0.0374043770134449, -0.030972594395279884, -0.07674174010753632, 0.026120517402887344, 0.05469002574682236, 0.03821961581707001, -0.03821078687906265, 0.006459122058004141, 0.03951128572225571, -0.0002534142986405641, -0.016084447503089905, 0.011599193327128887, -0.001582071534357965, 0.024096602573990822, 0.011324354447424412, 0.043636828660964966, 0.021101176738739014, -0.014716112986207008, -0.014049699530005455, 0.014745288528501987, 0.006568828132003546, -0.010424751788377762, 0.04205814749002457, -0.0208603385835886, 0.025284217670559883, 0.0030942922458052635, 0.08220253884792328, -0.002457588678225875, 0.023556873202323914, 0.06660079210996628, 0.000029892060410929844, 0.03824726492166519, 0.025392496958374977, -0.024822847917675972, -0.02884102053940296, -0.004205254837870598, -0.07865092903375626, -0.012201876379549503, -0.05402258038520813, 0.0189642496407032, 0.03870951384305954, -0.030401594936847687, -0.07916274666786194, -0.037825942039489746, -0.013603562489151955, -0.044050272554159164, 0.0657876506447792, 0.04835599660873413, 0.002030727919191122, -0.08514659851789474, -0.0016207573935389519, -0.04143775627017021, 0.026222139596939087, 0.04148354008793831, -0.0006971832481212914, -0.0027965507470071316, 0.03415980935096741, -0.06059369072318077, -0.0007978003704920411, -0.006221340037882328, -0.009403634816408157, 0.00651263864710927, 0.0012694780016317964, 0.030646923929452896, 0.0030706985853612423, 0.006261062808334827, -0.029388396069407463, -0.026234645396471024, -0.010841721668839455, -0.013930654153227806, -0.041575539857149124, 0.0895417183637619, 0.014141620136797428, 0.045527033507823944, 0.040120434015989304, -0.02917582355439663, 0.0005418172222562134, -0.010611942037940025, -0.04559210687875748, 0.023494936525821686, 0.00822847243398428, 0.0027386131696403027, -0.04497823491692543, 0.01194575522094965, -0.06356022506952286, 0.041947562247514725, -0.011079569347202778, -0.026427393779158592, -0.018463151529431343, -0.0023610645439475775, 0.012203553691506386, 0.002721492201089859, 0.007771667093038559, 0.016456138342618942, 0.01313088834285736, 0.04089624434709549, -0.037288885563611984, -0.0008711533737368882, -0.009634426794946194, -0.0013113068416714668, -0.012149734422564507, -0.04557240381836891, 0.008476462215185165, 0.06287535279989243, -0.04440397024154663, -0.05067019164562225, -0.03459542617201805, -0.013442743569612503, 0.025907907634973526, -0.07831143587827682, -0.015571835450828075, -0.01759915240108967, -0.01711169257760048, -0.03985661640763283, -0.037347227334976196, -0.05971040576696396, 0.02828950434923172, -0.004016737453639507, -0.02709459327161312, 0.007652644533663988, 0.03937258943915367, 0.0007658044341951609, 0.012955439276993275, 0.012953883968293667, -0.009557700715959072, -0.012807543389499187, 0.044880278408527374, -0.03482605516910553, 0.009244932793080807, -0.015476154163479805, 0.058840129524469376, -0.029802029952406883, 0.05983924865722656, -0.01576232723891735, -0.04549712687730789, 0.06386394798755646, 0.02141282893717289, 0.028999103233218193, -0.012863744981586933, -0.018611954525113106, -0.0030643416102975607, 0.06951126456260681, -0.042327508330345154, 0.0005595905240625143, 0.004540133289992809, -0.01227851677685976, 0.05526914447546005, -0.027707649394869804, -0.03989779204130173, 0.013704403303563595, 0.07381325215101242, -0.045802075415849686, -0.017033927142620087, 0.007009067106992006, -0.040242016315460205, -0.04930414631962776, 0.015125134959816933, 0.05797494575381279, 0.004858002066612244, -0.07543106377124786, 0.01216330099850893, 0.023781215772032738, 0.013190414756536484, 0.029977114871144295, 0.028240583837032318, 0.038255475461483, -0.015816885977983475, -0.04533596709370613, -0.020758705213665962, 0.014274723827838898, 0.0375572107732296, 0.008555535227060318, 0.0008245451608672738, -0.07326409220695496, 0.012517381459474564, -0.011134866625070572, -0.03455876186490059, 0.09364550560712814, 0.007846140302717686, -0.0004628418246284127, 0.011420145630836487, 0.01719668321311474, -0.0529044009745121, -0.00856511015444994, -0.03493223711848259, 0.017781458795070648, 0.09031731635332108, -0.005732513964176178, -0.04915083572268486, 0.024540934711694717, -0.009660627692937851, 0.010768754407763481, 0.04338241368532181, 0.07832486182451248, 0.021440912038087845, 0.010427245870232582, -0.06271902471780777, -0.05494554340839386, 0.04521111398935318, -0.0013568407157436013, 0.023985372856259346, 0.06183042749762535, -0.006811013910919428, 0.0030477556865662336, -0.11159025877714157, -0.07024543732404709, 0.02327978052198887, 0.007125786505639553, -0.00949081964790821, 0.03138401359319687, -0.09483233094215393, 0.01116167288273573, -0.002163197845220566, -0.016502905637025833, 0.016790473833680153, 0.049822643399238586, 0.039689287543296814, 0.02078499272465706, -0.03927045315504074, 0.016394266858696938, 0.013162672519683838, -0.0053277513943612576, 0.031191544607281685, -0.002118099946528673, 0.024393495172262192, -0.10700483620166779, 0.0012336049694567919, 0.021871265023946762, 0.0019498321926221251, 0.00645274855196476, 0.04248702526092529, 0.04433787986636162, -0.013774815946817398, -0.011612437665462494, 0.03336498886346817, -0.010180579498410225, -0.012275747023522854, 0.008111759088933468, -0.040502604097127914, -0.0238741934299469, -0.025533996522426605, -0.012789705768227577, 0.08745775371789932, -0.012631789781153202, -0.03850052133202553, -0.02665947563946247, -0.011892679147422314, -0.03703751415014267, -0.05142366141080856, -0.007602520752698183, -0.021382303908467293, 0.006116720847785473, 0.003839620854705572, -0.023593613877892494, 0.06215287744998932, 0.07704895734786987, -0.039817146956920624, 0.00533723458647728, -0.012784512713551521, 0.02499385178089142, -0.0039129313081502914, -0.011716191656887531, -0.06323140114545822, 0.0331319198012352, 0.0077672055922448635, -0.05496766418218613, 0.062444109469652176, -0.009609722532331944, -0.046527374535799026, 0.03511328995227814, 0.019801322370767593, 0.01946321688592434, -0.04012467712163925, -0.0003231910231988877, 0.034235674887895584, -0.00443369010463357, 0.0451713465154171, -0.007594404276460409, -0.016573341563344002, -0.011288241483271122, -0.022082868963479996, 0.021878134459257126, -0.027710266411304474, 0.02759229950606823, 0.03613516688346863, 0.02742578461766243, 0.023031804710626602, 0.004904991015791893, 0.061481863260269165, 0.03267627954483032, -0.06992559134960175, -0.03845316171646118, 0.02748420648276806, 0.051342979073524475, 0.0031919085886329412, -0.008523681201040745, -0.012737881392240524, 0.006770136300474405, -0.07425461709499359, 0.02627510018646717, -0.00463075190782547, 0.015794474631547928, 0.010859310626983643, -0.024435624480247498, 0.006010393146425486, -0.023547595366835594, -0.020361866801977158, -0.08540657162666321, -0.012419931590557098, -0.006541179958730936, 0.02882891334593296, 0.09595770388841629, -0.03232429549098015, -0.058716218918561935, 0.011210833676159382, 0.008853571489453316, -0.014985509216785431, 0.030213618651032448, 0.017070328816771507, -0.022960320115089417, 0.01888732984662056, -0.005594857968389988, 0.04450865089893341, -0.053060710430145264, 0.05284922197461128, -0.021291593089699745, 0.06620702892541885, -0.04080155864357948, 0.051956016570329666, 0.10870417207479477, 0.06220201775431633, -0.060129739344120026, -0.0792495608329773, -0.046334702521562576, -0.045830365270376205, 0.02908395603299141, -0.012157590128481388, 0.06113395467400551, -0.027994439005851746, -0.05404882878065109, 0.06736860424280167, 0.007103108335286379, 0.02965761348605156, 0.07024262845516205, -0.07258667796850204, 0.024629199877381325, 0.004592373967170715, 0.02657684125006199, -0.01918439380824566, 0.020122988149523735, -0.008449312299489975, 0.028977418318390846, 0.043217018246650696, -0.06268249452114105, 0.0044646901078522205, -0.03601417317986488, 0.029659319669008255 ]
<p>Is perturbation theory usually taught in undergraduate physics, and how much of it is taught in quantum mechanics courses?</p> <p>Also, how much of quantum field theory would be taught in undergraduate physics?</p>
g9809
[ 0.015198434703052044, -0.005962925497442484, 0.005511983763426542, -0.05810932070016861, -0.008888307958841324, 0.04683105647563934, -0.010877994820475578, 0.02066577970981598, 0.006501725874841213, -0.015429193153977394, 0.056282177567481995, 0.024336528033018112, -0.004575116094201803, 0.0066899750381708145, 0.0051878406666219234, 0.018428673967719078, 0.06528626382350922, 0.01687764562666416, -0.022086210548877716, -0.008231600746512413, -0.012734035961329937, 0.005319788586348295, 0.019717831164598465, -0.042347948998212814, -0.015005925670266151, -0.015888486057519913, -0.0552050918340683, -0.053838100284338, 0.0010552139719948173, 0.001066506141796708, -0.032994870096445084, 0.028315402567386627, 0.045539360493421555, -0.06821806728839874, -0.030747458338737488, -0.02025228925049305, 0.06280551850795746, -0.0061948238871991634, -0.005907371640205383, -0.013613189570605755, 0.009402846917510033, -0.05406466871500015, 0.032309141010046005, 0.010141169652342796, -0.03691738098859787, -0.005973564460873604, 0.01914217695593834, 0.0006700936355628073, -0.02719954587519169, 0.1072847843170166, -0.05345604568719864, -0.014873454347252846, 0.07416237890720367, 0.03824450448155403, 0.061554573476314545, 0.06163778901100159, 0.0027502665761858225, -0.03548498451709747, 0.045094117522239685, 0.022984907031059265, 0.06609533727169037, 0.013630199246108532, 0.017619071528315544, -0.027297940105199814, -0.028734464198350906, -0.006750090047717094, -0.06307414919137955, -0.015224220231175423, 0.02502257190644741, 0.02898401767015457, 0.001669441582635045, -0.05550732463598251, 0.014256044290959835, -0.001540748868137598, 0.015096216462552547, -0.008628870360553265, -0.01468606386333704, -0.032759200781583786, -0.01411685161292553, 0.02105717919766903, -0.02282612770795822, -0.02848079986870289, 0.01213270053267479, -0.06700366735458374, 0.04389185458421707, -0.02864832431077957, -0.015630895271897316, 0.031530510634183884, 0.005061544012278318, -0.006596125662326813, -0.018638696521520615, 0.009486992843449116, 0.02409156784415245, 0.0201540756970644, 0.02101411297917366, -0.033825211226940155, -0.011641712859272957, -0.017312174662947655, -0.014099826104938984, 0.03036618046462536, -0.04048089310526848, 0.06896282732486725, 0.018710864707827568, 0.01681751385331154, 0.014705294743180275, -0.0047677350230515, 0.023391705006361008, -0.024873245507478714, 0.03620658814907074, 0.043988823890686035, -0.06993044912815094, -0.01323343813419342, -0.035529810935258865, -0.0027574123814702034, -0.05660596117377281, -0.0013961007352918386, 0.043665092438459396, -0.022707322612404823, 0.036470189690589905, 0.07190126925706863, -0.04920957610011101, 0.007681463845074177, 0.010279327630996704, 0.01794743910431862, 0.026316003873944283, 0.02115633524954319, -0.05500301346182823, -0.008618487976491451, -0.00811008457094431, 0.022059043869376183, 0.021185295656323433, -0.03510783240199089, -0.0560712106525898, -0.014721217565238476, 0.05119314044713974, 0.05394955351948738, 0.014098206534981728, 0.03335180878639221, 0.01253318041563034, 0.0360102541744709, 0.044226668775081635, 0.006668380461633205, -0.0006580780609510839, 0.008702986873686314, -0.026034602895379066, -0.02667085826396942, 0.0649624615907669, -0.035407036542892456, -0.01547306403517723, -0.021410765126347542, 0.07116097956895828, -0.004059594590216875, 0.06388352066278458, -0.023454589769244194, 0.016582636162638664, 0.017699159681797028, -0.011207712814211845, -0.05323703959584236, 0.06112617999315262, 0.015674667432904243, 0.006243725307285786, 0.00359113491140306, 0.038794081658124924, 0.02313775010406971, -0.024174857884645462, -0.013537154532968998, 0.0022959422785788774, -0.013539397157728672, 0.026538047939538956, -0.01609748974442482, -0.01301005482673645, -0.020247621461749077, 0.026436103507876396, 0.026378275826573372, -0.045658934861421585, 0.04348344728350639, 0.013738780282437801, -0.06669629365205765, -0.012090449221432209, 0.0023910291492938995, 0.033546239137649536, -0.007492043077945709, -0.00850715022534132, -0.045814238488674164, 0.009323818609118462, 0.008389724418520927, -0.08241138607263565, 0.04753602668642998, -0.06354963779449463, 0.014394962228834629, -0.05293791741132736, -0.027962513267993927, 0.028325533494353294, -0.009720848873257637, 0.018757468089461327, -0.019709844142198563, -0.014421592466533184, 0.006446463987231255, -0.006633750628679991, 0.026016535237431526, -0.012325689196586609, 0.027637934312224388, 0.03754112869501114, -0.06758135557174683, 0.013375756330788136, 0.059066444635391235, -0.051515135914087296, 0.04148698225617409, 0.009067240171134472, -0.03486132621765137, 0.013796746730804443, 0.02107878215610981, 0.05385386198759079, 0.08052325248718262, -0.03742392733693123, 0.007258196361362934, -0.014426427893340588, 0.00542393047362566, -0.006471486762166023, 0.11910207569599152, 0.036913711577653885, 0.020535917952656746, 0.013222901150584221, 0.027469303458929062, 0.0027176348958164454, 0.03664068132638931, -0.05311506241559982, -0.008357825689017773, -0.0371510274708271, 0.02282067947089672, -0.03220141679048538, -0.02317812852561474, -0.04460917040705681, 0.00024196127196773887, 0.019053487107157707, 0.03701261058449745, 0.004250254016369581, -0.04351735860109329, 0.008923247456550598, -0.041198257356882095, 0.0021401995327323675, -0.010396961122751236, 0.030521592125296593, 0.017158672213554382, -0.009645534679293633, -0.03311959654092789, 0.009954496286809444, -0.022012904286384583, -0.005125414114445448, 0.002085333690047264, 0.02290564402937889, -0.03177161514759064, -0.03517572581768036, 0.05855197459459305, 0.0023219038266688585, 0.015398104675114155, -0.021257463842630386, 0.03212902322411537, -0.0577915757894516, 0.0057720099575817585, 0.04678535833954811, -0.034826286137104034, -0.016296084970235825, -0.029387233778834343, -0.047807853668928146, -0.006070017348974943, -0.028970731422305107, 0.021028291434049606, -0.02405720390379429, 0.0073938434943556786, -0.0053078471682965755, 0.08413275331258774, -0.03390045091509819, -0.025228191167116165, -0.043433450162410736, -0.008848696947097778, -0.0010702965082600713, -0.023315448313951492, -0.008764106780290604, -0.04696448892354965, -0.004488418810069561, -0.010203134268522263, -0.09069657325744629, 0.015477092005312443, 0.0509762279689312, -0.0991269052028656, -0.0007545396802015603, -0.02288062311708927, 0.002953857649117708, 0.018077155575156212, -0.02465563453733921, 0.019137566909193993, -0.008559565991163254, 0.041343048214912415, -0.035697560757398605, -0.038194090127944946, 0.016505636274814606, -0.0034110688138753176, -0.06458792835474014, 0.08487680554389954, 0.011975654400885105, 0.017724154517054558, -0.04424331337213516, 0.03254305198788643, 0.014785338193178177, -0.01352671068161726, -0.019802987575531006, -0.0052188606932759285, 0.008462768979370594, 0.027403827756643295, -0.0733603984117508, 0.020161448046565056, 0.06862498819828033, 0.07567451894283295, -0.054739098995923996, -0.01279155071824789, 0.02196931652724743, -0.0033724410459399223, 0.0031438241712749004, -0.04989678040146828, 0.009721723385155201, -0.015526415780186653, 0.07662996649742126, 0.033521898090839386, 0.05595961585640907, 0.06560298055410385, 0.048542898148298264, 0.02237303927540779, -0.014744462445378304, -0.030121510848402977, 0.05900225415825844, -0.08242214471101761, -0.047551434487104416, -0.0037196434568613768, 0.012963016517460346, 0.003213713178411126, 0.06583385169506073, 0.06289446353912354, 0.03871837630867958, -0.04861173778772354, 0.04280966520309448, -0.030535312369465828, 0.0376533679664135, -0.045508332550525665, 0.02410624362528324, -0.0015969563974067569, -0.03176466375589371, -0.016081618145108223, 0.0076966420747339725, -0.0262540802359581, 0.07061353325843811, 0.011274520307779312, 0.05416350066661835, -0.0037528621032834053, 0.02382536046206951, 0.004523036535829306, 0.031047217547893524, 0.0475195087492466, 0.0012865294702351093, -0.011488777585327625, -0.05591892823576927, -0.069414883852005, -0.00031949213007465005, 0.03015345335006714, -0.02270962856709957, 0.013240035623311996, -0.054143063724040985, 0.022613365203142166, 0.04452073946595192, 0.013658057898283005, -0.058123309165239334, 0.027988748624920845, -0.034977756440639496, -0.022958872839808464, 0.0009816125966608524, -0.04718048870563507, 0.03375750035047531, -0.013092102482914925, -0.0488576777279377, -0.02944423072040081, -0.016740500926971436, 0.03912964463233948, 0.021658390760421753, 0.01772785559296608, 0.009280342608690262, 0.05658520385622978, 0.04554096236824989, -0.026062950491905212, 0.039003364741802216, 0.015724215656518936, -0.009267925284802914, -0.06710459291934967, 0.018661122769117355, 0.04116759076714516, -0.027824584394693375, -0.055220142006874084, 0.001207696390338242, 0.058438871055841446, 0.051640719175338745, 0.055354319512844086, -0.014562353491783142, 0.011575756594538689, 0.0012295055203139782, -0.00234046159312129, 0.02384045720100403, 0.05640001967549324, 0.0015230727149173617, -0.036497414112091064, -0.021413691341876984, -0.039368242025375366, 0.015747791156172752, 0.0004937310004606843, -0.02056807279586792, -0.03289599344134331, -0.00886459369212389, -0.006870264653116465, -0.03922542184591293, -0.018675493076443672, 0.061133116483688354, -0.006080536171793938, 0.05872226879000664, 0.03717115521430969, 0.025127898901700974, -0.0008366612601093948, -0.005912431515753269, 0.010749478824436665, -0.01668713428080082, 0.011903824284672737, 0.04317953810095787, -0.058363936841487885, 0.029598496854305267, -0.013548914343118668, -0.0015982765471562743, 0.019666213542222977, -0.043740108609199524, -0.01567952148616314, -0.05440862849354744, 0.03294069319963455, 0.05592917650938034, -0.03847978636622429, 0.0897928923368454, -0.0331045500934124, -0.023626968264579773, -0.03546862676739693, -0.08207568526268005, -0.024248309433460236, -0.022880200296640396, -0.04952219873666763, 0.039568569511175156, -0.08168771862983704, -0.012651635333895683, -0.010969980619847775, 0.024765197187662125, -0.029529374092817307, -0.03838120400905609, -0.06868474930524826, -0.0013027297100052238, 0.03365587070584297, 0.03351766616106033, 0.04507898539304733, -0.027993928641080856, 0.033775243908166885, 0.02487998642027378, 0.009602622129023075, -0.04083762690424919, 0.002278416184708476, 0.0006743380799889565, -0.005121467635035515, -0.07394448667764664, -0.04947905242443085, 0.013730628415942192, -0.06066570803523064, 0.04047214239835739, -0.0364280603826046, 0.011449701152741909, -0.038567762821912766, -0.029094038531184196, -0.07971705496311188, -0.03190969303250313, -0.025350166484713554, 0.017380161210894585, -0.03430693969130516, 0.03924039378762245, 0.02402428165078163, -0.0446312241256237, -0.06854744255542755, -0.01967880316078663, 0.021566493436694145, -0.030209122225642204, -0.06810837239027023, 0.0003225683467462659, 0.011088347062468529, 0.018196463584899902, 0.021698065102100372, -0.08644399046897888, -0.042099159210920334, -0.021777406334877014, -0.04035317897796631, -0.018340691924095154, -0.021449776366353035, -0.060880083590745926, 0.003941983915865421, 0.01935695670545101, -0.0441514290869236, -0.0709637701511383, 0.001596673741005361, 0.030896039679646492, 0.01349068246781826, -0.03380254656076431, 0.006336007732897997, 0.02958446554839611, 0.016922911629080772, 0.026001842692494392, -0.009038914926350117, 0.043245621025562286, 0.0025617924984544516, -0.03203612193465233, 0.01262409146875143, -0.048899486660957336, -0.029377134516835213, 0.050859127193689346, -0.021072622388601303, -0.0005220577004365623, -0.012327301315963268, 0.09426789730787277, 0.018042266368865967, -0.06680890172719955, 0.00323954364284873, -0.01946033351123333, 0.008188649080693722, 0.02252115309238434, 0.010992922820150852, -0.029168514534831047, -0.01921844109892845, 0.0025628977455198765, 0.0870446041226387, 0.02579120546579361, -0.026299715042114258, -0.03097846731543541, 0.05388699471950531, -0.03813371807336807, 0.012642071582376957, 0.04532540589570999, -0.012159253470599651, 0.02126295492053032, -0.01135139912366867, 0.004250551573932171, -0.023266572505235672, 0.08240378648042679, -0.045946162194013596, -0.03296782076358795, 0.00862578023225069, 0.012839681468904018, -0.04733070358633995, -0.010206210426986217, 0.046312425285577774, -0.027589792385697365, -0.04186614975333214, -0.004468579776585102, 0.03912276402115822, 0.05787528306245804, -0.02324284054338932, 0.0044912174344062805, -0.02616165019571781, -0.052876293659210205, 0.020022904500365257, 0.0012507075443863869, -0.04144492372870445, 0.03594223037362099, 0.01716223917901516, -0.02514493837952614, 0.039378874003887177, 0.01317740511149168, -0.03223636373877525, 0.05218346789479256, 0.030530471354722977, -0.025131696835160255, -0.039098598062992096, 0.006209409795701504, -0.031359098851680756, 0.04207022115588188, 0.034262798726558685, 0.035027652978897095, -0.05189385265111923, 0.022289752960205078, 0.0274406298995018, -0.01028359029442072, 0.04552941769361496, 0.05896224081516266, 0.05229413881897926, -0.019474389031529427, 0.02205510437488556, -0.027017246931791306, -0.07711751759052277, 0.0017750718398019671, 0.023375902324914932, 0.05406995117664337, -0.01655437983572483, -0.021025119349360466, 0.018381724134087563, -0.02603994682431221, -0.012124994769692421, -0.015739845111966133, 0.010531838051974773, 0.048137467354536057, 0.04036813601851463, 0.010043150745332241, -0.01907767727971077, -0.041691314429044724, 0.027961375191807747, -0.010976351797580719, -0.004603448323905468, 0.016866551712155342, 0.01927773468196392, -0.009540962055325508, 0.03700432553887367, -0.017891639843583107, 0.05855729803442955, -0.015318114310503006, 0.011462454684078693, 0.04710790142416954, -0.01622479036450386, -0.02014182321727276, -0.0027323360554873943, -0.007974180392920971, 0.0451652966439724, 0.009920505806803703, -0.0032518268562853336, 0.05719967186450958, -0.09537600725889206, 0.02477501705288887, -0.033564064651727676, 0.007262025959789753, -0.049362968653440475, 0.04032137989997864, 0.10197543352842331, -0.026682989671826363, -0.03242872655391693, -0.006961644161492586, -0.012792613357305527, -0.01921691745519638, 0.01063391100615263, 0.06439359486103058, 0.00848276074975729, -0.05455506220459938, -0.06828362494707108, 0.02982054091989994, 0.008249489590525627, -0.058707304298877716, 0.021790891885757446, -0.0014089447213336825, 0.02992190606892109, -0.011199155822396278, -0.023922668769955635, -0.008040961809456348, 0.05868496745824814, 0.057829342782497406, 0.017804047092795372, 0.05555040389299393, -0.06155150756239891, -0.03946565091609955, 0.00618045823648572, -0.03903970494866371, -0.016999786719679832, 0.022618452087044716, 0.034366756677627563, -0.0011547787580639124, 0.00638275733217597, 0.02506275102496147, 0.03775639459490776, 0.02374461106956005, -0.013398845680058002, -0.05258825421333313, 0.05718722194433212, 0.002285422058776021, -0.03241629898548126, -0.0030184199567884207, 0.022791707888245583, -0.0012779312673956156, -0.049933746457099915, 0.031040620058774948, -0.02418702282011509, -0.02670947089791298, -0.010654348880052567, -0.022432243451476097, 0.007090527564287186, 0.01708848588168621, 0.016013355925679207, 0.006084104999899864, -0.030387787148356438, -0.009286198765039444, -0.056846436113119125, -0.023267988115549088, -0.03728893771767616, 0.0643095076084137, 0.02219262719154358, 0.07724443078041077, -0.03116689994931221, 0.0625506192445755, -0.002747712656855583, 0.028925471007823944, 0.005444332957267761, 0.014889939688146114, -0.042557794600725174, 0.06617053598165512, 0.005104607902467251, 0.042532555758953094, -0.005515771452337503, -0.03882846608757973, -0.039336174726486206, -0.0913524329662323, 0.008342895656824112, 0.07052541524171829, 0.035349778831005096, 0.007695608306676149, -0.028312144801020622, 0.000496602151542902, -0.03055010735988617, 0.04200995713472366, 0.01012036669999361, 0.037694886326789856, 0.022992365062236786, 0.008868173696100712, 0.012105301953852177, -0.062424708157777786, 0.00047605062718503177, 0.05113305151462555, -0.08560284972190857, -0.008210384286940098, -0.006255540065467358, -0.0029823167715221643, 0.0100859971717, -0.02569079026579857, -0.03763873875141144, -0.05953214690089226, 0.03556304797530174, 0.038802217692136765, -0.006143213249742985, -0.03173217922449112, -0.03905552253127098, 0.002536413259804249, 0.005579266231507063, 0.0003560774785000831, 0.0208577997982502, -0.03146630525588989, 0.08565732836723328, -0.0631943792104721, -0.02046528086066246, 0.03819963335990906, -0.06287677586078644, -0.04944084957242012, 0.01596217043697834, 0.02324873022735119, 0.06003967672586441, 0.011034596711397171, -0.02370263636112213, -0.0025574665050953627, 0.03097458928823471, -0.017650913447141647, 0.017964687198400497, 0.009556394070386887, 0.015915976837277412, 0.06243385747075081, -0.02866813726723194, -0.04024321585893631, -0.030390603467822075, 0.017404232174158096, -0.03072504512965679 ]
<p>Are the gravity waves detectors all working on the same principle/effect ?</p>
g9810
[ 0.015988780185580254, 0.036285772919654846, 0.013042419217526913, 0.050069160759449005, 0.08779527246952057, 0.013384072110056877, 0.014486150816082954, -0.039975836873054504, -0.030174527317285538, -0.06382150948047638, -0.004314741585403681, 0.021432306617498398, -0.05617328733205795, 0.024929378181695938, -0.025969000533223152, -0.0313517265021801, 0.07495495676994324, 0.003594340058043599, -0.0014556189998984337, 0.047784797847270966, 0.025575097650289536, 0.026753665879368782, -0.06652835011482239, -0.015203038230538368, -0.055772166699171066, 0.03106485679745674, 0.017329730093479156, -0.018710587173700333, -0.02092622220516205, -0.0325830802321434, 0.05048967897891998, -0.04907621815800667, 0.04579290747642517, -0.08049922436475754, -0.059570107609033585, -0.020414460450410843, 0.026923000812530518, 0.026739463210105896, -0.02952350303530693, 0.028079943731427193, -0.026503480970859528, 0.016775591298937798, -0.028473813086748123, -0.008480913005769253, -0.015069476328790188, -0.025165388360619545, 0.0034916645381599665, -0.016946690157055855, 0.02770570106804371, -0.05969689413905144, 0.00012161576159996912, -0.001425314461812377, 0.04708913341164589, 0.044174596667289734, -0.003392128273844719, 0.029030855745077133, -0.026078874245285988, 0.006713625509291887, 0.024054987356066704, -0.0016784773906692863, -0.025016961619257927, 0.008872037753462791, 0.014985451474785805, 0.030886609107255936, 0.006747804582118988, 0.011009964160621166, -0.049542371183633804, -0.06745593249797821, -0.01366876345127821, 0.02304457314312458, 0.036007337272167206, -0.03587695211172104, -0.05634301155805588, 0.01960071548819542, -0.004434617701917887, -0.0006839886773377657, -0.0105807576328516, 0.05507936328649521, 0.008691569790244102, 0.0004899076884612441, -0.0018198229372501373, -0.10421349853277206, -0.07517897337675095, 0.050859708338975906, 0.03224031627178192, -0.04637449234724045, 0.003603782970458269, 0.04591649770736694, -0.024835022166371346, 0.014360509812831879, 0.012767483480274677, -0.041589684784412384, 0.058227069675922394, 0.025942275300621986, -0.026510711759328842, 0.042607128620147705, 0.03946268558502197, 0.0667983889579773, -0.02159965969622135, 0.0042709182016551495, -0.01936064474284649, 0.05378327891230583, -0.004409266170114279, 0.05530019849538803, 0.013687750324606895, -0.014113528653979301, 0.013281119056046009, -0.007777271792292595, 0.04290078952908516, -0.011948766186833382, -0.027531342580914497, 0.02628754824399948, 0.019395893439650536, 0.011541394516825676, -0.06669878214597702, -0.031664203852415085, 0.03819912672042847, 0.016390547156333923, 0.014312611892819405, -0.0001710339856799692, -0.04069261625409126, 0.011779998429119587, 0.012995060533285141, 0.05018202215433121, -0.01730182021856308, 0.014370690099895, 0.008058907464146614, 0.02502051368355751, 0.005385460332036018, 0.013667149469256401, 0.0534658245742321, 0.03235568106174469, -0.05805850774049759, 0.0095562394708395, 0.026368554681539536, -0.02395763248205185, 0.008072936907410622, 0.008505569770932198, 0.01788897067308426, -0.0007399049354717135, -0.04390547424554825, -0.04958277940750122, 0.015334304422140121, -0.07131021469831467, 0.0556420162320137, 0.0005432164180092514, -0.0103074936196208, 0.023152323439717293, 0.05085386335849762, -0.025362994521856308, -0.03328937664628029, 0.08654894679784775, 0.06941089779138565, -0.022940276190638542, -0.006512789521366358, 0.014521360397338867, -0.028010888025164604, -0.02552632801234722, -0.01018522772938013, 0.06264372169971466, 0.009427616372704506, -0.05726278945803642, 0.07071403414011002, 0.024528594687581062, 0.0008331895805895329, -0.005526071414351463, 0.041802357882261276, -0.031211787834763527, 0.057158589363098145, 0.015695424750447273, -0.052486877888441086, 0.008972895331680775, -0.021923748776316643, 0.05979274585843086, 0.025507330894470215, 0.06718189269304276, -0.012287640944123268, -0.07046357542276382, -0.004118397366255522, 0.03130466490983963, -0.08934570848941803, 0.010783512145280838, -0.018269740045070648, -0.07554160803556442, 0.022528449073433876, 0.022414544597268105, 0.00975182093679905, -0.059181757271289825, -0.01962905190885067, -0.001287516439333558, -0.05832435563206673, -0.031824976205825806, -0.03207624703645706, 0.04340336099267006, 0.025513986125588417, 0.002869704971089959, -0.03432980924844742, 0.0005186289781704545, -0.029092533513903618, 0.09602214395999908, 0.0015084283659234643, 0.06143395975232124, 0.03260481730103493, -0.014508308842778206, 0.021431582048535347, -0.015414120629429817, -0.0032762461341917515, -0.018324753269553185, 0.07713836431503296, -0.040572237223386765, 0.0006704669794999063, -0.004182309843599796, 0.03534397855401039, -0.024841992184519768, -0.008426758460700512, -0.0033456941600888968, -0.0010992389870807528, 0.009918236173689365, 0.008641714230179787, -0.008151252754032612, -0.03383971005678177, 0.06261229515075684, 0.02268132008612156, 0.00880124606192112, -0.018241578713059425, 0.01497669704258442, -0.05316529422998428, -0.003343689488247037, -0.012291847728192806, -0.032183773815631866, -0.002199780661612749, 0.006113836541771889, 0.03463023155927658, -0.0355817936360836, 0.06029137969017029, 0.025359924882650375, 0.0007503371452912688, -0.01931469328701496, 0.04487112909555435, 0.0022632607724517584, -0.018183231353759766, -0.04007695987820625, -0.025488998740911484, 0.014261070638895035, 0.0771302804350853, -0.042654626071453094, 0.0004523529496509582, 0.03858432173728943, -0.008599991910159588, 0.03718671202659607, -0.013840919360518456, 0.013444582000374794, -0.04368780925869942, 0.03535139560699463, 0.027798879891633987, 0.024821359664201736, 0.00010392774129286408, -0.0029859268106520176, -0.05704973638057709, 0.010481933131814003, 0.010863675735890865, 0.03303777426481247, 0.02479628287255764, -0.0022082498762756586, 0.006953809410333633, -0.07983909547328949, 0.044181939214468, 0.021882062777876854, -0.027038786560297012, 0.01472886186093092, -0.0006234496249817312, 0.051370978355407715, 0.05135874077677727, 0.027349937707185745, -0.04265884682536125, 0.05903171747922897, 0.03947649896144867, -0.008238308131694794, 0.015317722223699093, -0.024017730727791786, -0.05416946858167648, 0.0023401009384542704, -0.04414926469326019, -0.020393768325448036, 0.005264977924525738, -0.08477220684289932, 0.0009123385534621775, -0.05019346624612808, -0.02603113278746605, 0.03199334815144539, 0.023420603945851326, -0.02485511265695095, 0.07186631858348846, 0.02471866086125374, -0.07463883608579636, 0.01843751221895218, 0.018582819029688835, -0.02175142616033554, -0.0111038563773036, 0.00850218627601862, 0.029141224920749664, -0.02311009354889393, -0.007743476424366236, 0.047798383980989456, 0.0666869506239891, 0.004826527554541826, -0.011714535765349865, -0.029914861544966698, -0.015127156861126423, -0.005292797461152077, -0.025842810049653053, 0.048240624368190765, 0.0274947676807642, -0.023977193981409073, 0.03408217802643776, -0.01634399965405464, -0.017423447221517563, 0.019495254382491112, 0.0022675846703350544, -0.0007196600781753659, -0.021868299692869186, 0.005852052476257086, -0.0008785446407273412, -0.08891038596630096, 0.01791849359869957, 0.0688740462064743, 0.013789300806820393, 0.007964237593114376, -0.032259441912174225, 0.014964562840759754, 0.04552653804421425, 0.026073073968291283, -0.028056643903255463, 0.023391176015138626, 0.023351246491074562, -0.03769305348396301, 0.0070748599246144295, 0.03609616309404373, 0.013660339638590813, 0.0777987465262413, -0.024536266922950745, 0.018284277990460396, -0.027144931256771088, 0.004069356247782707, -0.03670746833086014, 0.047300975769758224, -0.0030009413603693247, 0.02662178874015808, -0.029810309410095215, -0.021512461826205254, 0.016103675588965416, 0.048414409160614014, -0.01597496308386326, -0.00822183396667242, -0.045667778700590134, -0.07081346213817596, 0.009349893778562546, 0.013752100989222527, -0.0019319220446050167, 0.010600066743791103, 0.030347101390361786, 0.05731172859668732, 0.02343357354402542, -0.014846717938780785, -0.0055082254111766815, -0.006348796654492617, 0.0169158186763525, -0.022469809278845787, -0.005750329699367285, -0.046961475163698196, 0.01580081507563591, 0.03142612427473068, 0.02816728688776493, -0.0005390977021306753, 0.05759494751691818, -0.02377723529934883, 0.012287477031350136, -0.037648797035217285, -0.051005613058805466, 0.01114161591976881, 0.037388306111097336, 0.019160132855176926, 0.010326198302209377, -0.011375335045158863, 0.03169133514165878, -0.012458872981369495, -0.02246062271296978, 0.00025211574393324554, -0.006424867082387209, -0.053741421550512314, -0.038035232573747635, 0.02070743590593338, 0.01783784292638302, 0.016386887058615685, -0.01165337860584259, -0.011040926910936832, -0.015405656769871712, -0.039777081459760666, 0.038624733686447144, 0.024888167157769203, 0.029125366359949112, 0.014687984250485897, 0.008379838429391384, 0.005385460797697306, -0.04134904593229294, -0.02731015346944332, 0.02760123834013939, -0.0063803973607718945, -0.02918083406984806, 0.07308924198150635, -0.020415358245372772, -0.03202898055315018, 0.009174371138215065, -0.04834625869989395, 0.05444570258259773, 0.009373550303280354, 0.017556510865688324, -0.005490824114531279, 0.024782001972198486, 0.03442329913377762, 0.05227893218398094, 0.0692623108625412, -0.008342945016920567, -0.00006298943480942398, -0.062257662415504456, 0.052827946841716766, 0.008613924495875835, 0.007309073582291603, -0.016836075112223625, -0.02767297811806202, 0.028701888397336006, -0.012329780496656895, 0.00907785166054964, 0.031657371670007706, -0.024624330922961235, 0.008957442827522755, -0.050253983587026596, 0.04695029556751251, 0.021089091897010803, -0.0024945035111159086, 0.058747872710227966, 0.003807478118687868, -0.015156405977904797, -0.017633482813835144, 0.07734904438257217, 0.1262185126543045, -0.02656143344938755, -0.009866510517895222, 0.054108455777168274, 0.014419679529964924, -0.022978875786066055, 0.012423374690115452, -0.034875672310590744, -0.025630446150898933, 0.030803576111793518, 0.044362202286720276, 0.024830305948853493, 0.03859361633658409, 0.006127829197794199, -0.013531869277358055, -0.04511868581175804, 0.01758337952196598, 0.0322287492454052, 0.020747367292642593, 0.01708327792584896, -0.026213763281702995, -0.07625225186347961, -0.06888589262962341, -0.07641200721263885, -0.019826896488666534, 0.04198254644870758, -0.004357956815510988, 0.008338862098753452, 0.023946089670062065, -0.019157439470291138, 0.012187435291707516, 0.054490234702825546, 0.03657342866063118, -0.002052752301096916, -0.0245245099067688, -0.06883647292852402, 0.012918506748974323, -0.03330778330564499, -0.0298648439347744, -0.008249583654105663, 0.09092985093593597, -0.07626314461231232, 0.04404524713754654, -0.012388821691274643, -0.06988831609487534, 0.06099581718444824, -0.05623343214392662, 0.001994235208258033, -0.06108194962143898, 0.014150859788060188, -0.03686017915606499, 0.0008335113525390625, -0.036733388900756836, -0.04266178235411644, -0.01097002625465393, 0.008635740727186203, -0.012859822250902653, -0.02849162556231022, -0.028145723044872284, -0.026820065453648567, 0.045970428735017776, 0.04475409910082817, 0.02700032852590084, -0.02378969080746174, 0.04459698870778084, -0.05406714230775833, -0.02239738591015339, -0.018266186118125916, 0.007551299408078194, 0.04208699241280556, -0.02386031672358513, -0.04276337847113609, -0.028359221294522285, -0.03431021422147751, -0.04081328585743904, 0.017110463231801987, -0.023312430828809738, -0.0187116339802742, 0.0016598750371485949, 0.0684119164943695, 0.03812606632709503, -0.029070138931274414, 0.015154268592596054, 0.028339775279164314, -0.05848722159862518, 0.0007508390699513257, 0.014058800414204597, 0.05847174674272537, 0.04029356315732002, 0.04137830436229706, -0.05157729983329773, 0.06541979312896729, -0.006907292641699314, 0.038767214864492416, -0.07511457800865173, 0.015595176257193089, 0.05683048069477081, 0.06258998066186905, -0.009536203928291798, -0.03488868847489357, 0.03829832002520561, -0.05226549506187439, 0.012199629098176956, -0.02278812974691391, -0.08955089747905731, -0.04497111961245537, -0.002673524431884289, 0.045481037348508835, 0.042699769139289856, -0.03199746832251549, 0.030675474554300308, -0.06508243829011917, -0.05740528553724289, -0.040884293615818024, -0.02258218452334404, 0.04293914511799812, 0.029882509261369705, 0.000947889406234026, -0.05138802528381348, 0.038643237203359604, -0.02950545959174633, 0.016420364379882812, -0.042834825813770294, -0.015946757048368454, -0.014403190463781357, -0.052851829677820206, 0.015690553933382034, 0.012045690789818764, -0.05005795881152153, -0.010866018943488598, -0.008884410373866558, 0.06864722818136215, -0.028178513050079346, -0.004088350106030703, -0.004362623672932386, 0.03150536119937897, -0.017455490306019783, 0.0045007928274571896, -0.024433448910713196, 0.025782620534300804, 0.013813231140375137, -0.043409623205661774, 0.007576038595288992, -0.02342478185892105, -0.006077880505472422, -0.04832640290260315, -0.06670153886079788, -0.04209553450345993, 0.00316674099303782, -0.01933862455189228, -0.0580359548330307, 0.022359604015946388, 0.002985495375469327, -0.027927955612540245, -0.010983524844050407, 0.0028091813437640667, -0.012832450680434704, 0.062312472611665726, 0.023459365591406822, -0.02822422981262207, -0.03619879484176636, -0.03865499794483185, -0.04106860235333443, 0.00926928035914898, 0.0029653413221240044, -0.02859824150800705, -0.014424500055611134, 0.043242402374744415, -0.03507503122091293, 0.02085653319954872, -0.0641552060842514, 0.04390126094222069, -0.007971132174134254, 0.07517744600772858, 0.04050073400139809, 0.019995929673314095, 0.015549890697002411, -0.058229003101587296, -0.019983110949397087, -0.00035721174208447337, 0.01190413348376751, 0.0015774463536217809, -0.09084376692771912, 0.012650216929614544, 0.02036796323955059, -0.025692014023661613, 0.07830854505300522, 0.06371024250984192, 0.00110531784594059, -0.05891736224293709, 0.03761076554656029, 0.05682004243135452, -0.0030955031979829073, -0.0331474244594574, 0.0022304619196802378, 0.011203973554074764, 0.08317886292934418, 0.01872117444872856, -0.003037228249013424, -0.037710562348365784, 0.08179756999015808, -0.007875276729464531, -0.004363729618489742, -0.012638622894883156, 0.021411199122667313, 0.013305903412401676, -0.04885425791144371, 0.03772934898734093, 0.04147662967443466, -0.03448440879583359, -0.0018436455866321921, 0.05121491849422455, -0.06358343362808228, 0.02012772299349308, -0.023725366219878197, -0.023227132856845856, -0.07567994296550751, 0.0068119908683001995, -0.0033587468788027763, -0.034671980887651443, -0.006471953820437193, -0.06227261945605278, -0.02503708191215992, 0.0029601934365928173, 0.010560221038758755, 0.014217286370694637, -0.022485794499516487, 0.00034122311626560986, -0.014497087337076664, -0.006953100208193064, -0.019839173182845116, -0.039790403097867966, -0.013327930122613907, -0.01697852648794651, 0.029631784185767174, -0.012441250495612621, 0.051809508353471756, 0.012301312759518623, 0.04969799146056175, 0.03283870592713356, 0.04840179905295372, -0.07798145711421967, -0.06277859210968018, -0.03704703971743584, -0.0143040232360363, -0.016744250431656837, 0.015052162110805511, 0.05110844969749451, -0.02099451795220375, 0.023501206189393997, 0.04313268885016441, -0.011341064237058163, 0.1097087562084198, -0.03315464407205582, -0.028099115937948227, -0.03994103521108627, 0.034414976835250854, -0.04835290089249611, 0.03699257969856262, 0.053883761167526245, -0.029787786304950714, -0.01146530732512474, -0.05756949633359909, 0.007199106737971306, -0.0014673927798867226, -0.01438054908066988, 0.024935755878686905, 0.013483795337378979, 0.015248273499310017, -0.01873159036040306, 0.02068318985402584, -0.11285760998725891, -0.026730967685580254, 0.03954469785094261, -0.0162669587880373, 0.012758337892591953, -0.020306438207626343, -0.02978375367820263, 0.004790167789906263, -0.010327350348234177, 0.03212973102927208, -0.000425162841565907, 0.0021930746734142303, 0.04316186159849167, -0.00813478883355856, -0.06765878200531006, -0.014634106308221817, -0.022654278203845024, -0.006665531545877457, 0.003353683277964592, 0.018184324726462364, 0.032015055418014526, -0.02657514438033104, -0.0020401673391461372, 0.004199435468763113, 0.031871259212493896, 0.03112536109983921, -0.00037154852179810405, -0.02620040811598301, -0.045495547354221344, 0.012237539514899254, 0.00943810772150755, -0.02738489955663681, -0.015759915113449097, -0.08015461266040802, 0.006541748531162739, 0.028923487290740013, -0.04016418382525444, 0.049288149923086166, -0.026514822617173195, -0.05456158146262169, 0.006672299467027187, -0.011003835126757622, 0.027625449001789093, -0.04657077044248581, 0.030221397057175636, -0.019361374899744987, -0.04889697581529617, -0.024005770683288574, -0.04243214428424835, -0.01986723765730858, 0.03211698308587074, 0.015577261336147785 ]
<p>1: Do neutrinos undergo <strong>elastic</strong> collisions with fermions?</p> <p>2: Would this imply a <strong>variable</strong> speed for neutrinos?</p> <p>3: Can neutrinos transfer <strong>momenta</strong> in interactions?</p>
g9811
[ 0.021744215860962868, -0.005169043783098459, 0.030505873262882233, 0.004716003313660622, 0.09403403848409653, -0.003337788162752986, -0.06939589977264404, 0.011371639557182789, -0.012140030041337013, 0.011468479409813881, -0.04331937059760094, -0.004526760429143906, -0.03156209737062454, 0.018374402076005936, -0.019134270027279854, 0.031141284853219986, 0.06039419025182724, -0.033300671726465225, 0.04361264780163765, 0.05032531917095184, -0.02765245921909809, -0.01676364801824093, -0.028736380860209465, -0.048866819590330124, 0.0323500782251358, 0.0004730761284008622, -0.008735822513699532, -0.00862359069287777, -0.05273907631635666, 0.011171174235641956, 0.035706788301467896, -0.03734954819083214, 0.021872788667678833, -0.0792996883392334, -0.01310734637081623, -0.016217853873968124, 0.0569181814789772, -0.030894584953784943, 0.03106493130326271, 0.0050938972271978855, 0.0022802590392529964, 0.002961444668471813, -0.04042516648769379, -0.016199491918087006, -0.004001379944384098, 0.00568037386983633, -0.058157604187726974, -0.02546008862555027, -0.03535674512386322, -0.027866728603839874, 0.009781899861991405, -0.014149224385619164, 0.016947126016020775, 0.015071718022227287, 0.06048775464296341, 0.021994858980178833, 0.06472894549369812, -0.02071903459727764, 0.08449053764343262, -0.009404868818819523, -0.025906894356012344, -0.08476191014051437, -0.015442358329892159, -0.04065835103392601, 0.053752630949020386, -0.0049749803729355335, -0.03660351037979126, 0.025748420506715775, 0.049481235444545746, -0.002811226062476635, -0.0023882563691586256, -0.0019028412643820047, -0.010779233649373055, -0.06071611866354942, 0.03142071142792702, 0.017914026975631714, -0.01762733794748783, -0.04806919023394585, -0.014043597504496574, -0.01577271707355976, -0.01712220348417759, -0.0015377189265564084, -0.004716953262686729, -0.044562481343746185, 0.03346375748515129, -0.03791424259543419, 0.02664790488779545, 0.045162640511989594, 0.031211592257022858, 0.03795317932963371, 0.014852352440357208, -0.05712015926837921, -0.004312310833483934, 0.04198715463280678, -0.015695873647928238, -0.021815946325659752, 0.008004127070307732, 0.04610065743327141, 0.024781782180070877, -0.01582568883895874, -0.04331579431891441, -0.02610296942293644, 0.03147700056433678, -0.021043691784143448, 0.011092012748122215, -0.017403459176421165, 0.04089329019188881, -0.0016409374075010419, 0.005449660588055849, 0.024508614093065262, -0.0007572699687443674, -0.034706588834524155, 0.019947482272982597, 0.018139775842428207, 0.027968736365437508, -0.022814106196165085, -0.05647769942879677, -0.0002476852387189865, -0.010848118923604488, 0.10951519757509232, -0.0070101008750498295, 0.04082276672124863, -0.014652300626039505, 0.02279599942266941, -0.08258878439664841, -0.06970644742250443, 0.025023994967341423, 0.026940176263451576, 0.01943206787109375, 0.01859617792069912, -0.034369174391031265, -0.027545727789402008, 0.05807340145111084, 0.018627693876624107, 0.030107373371720314, 0.043646179139614105, 0.07591252774000168, 0.04009583219885826, -0.017813820391893387, 0.020831629633903503, 0.011238707229495049, -0.02806839346885681, -0.05303892865777016, -0.03254658728837967, -0.04208754748106003, -0.029471199959516525, -0.0010828665690496564, 0.010616897605359554, -0.030471034348011017, 0.011380529962480068, -0.00820465013384819, 0.06630410999059677, -0.033256739377975464, -0.011454903520643711, -0.003757244208827615, 0.022913049906492233, -0.027475368231534958, 0.003211281029507518, 0.04718450829386711, 0.005171458702534437, 0.06254822015762329, -0.03304491937160492, -0.011033870279788971, 0.0180667694658041, 0.01882295496761799, 0.00810954999178648, 0.055800508707761765, -0.04167137295007706, 0.06932329386472702, -0.0001463936932850629, -0.10586947947740555, -0.028608376160264015, -0.038816120475530624, 0.018293293192982674, -0.04538654536008835, -0.005106726661324501, -0.04921809956431389, -0.020878469571471214, -0.056012094020843506, -0.017798498272895813, -0.051289983093738556, -0.010146228596568108, 0.015220098197460175, -0.026709502562880516, 0.014941404573619366, -0.026457032188773155, 0.02199653908610344, 0.07104279845952988, -0.043499648571014404, 0.03340030834078789, -0.042022813111543655, -0.009310922585427761, 0.03749872371554375, 0.02720569260418415, 0.018280325457453728, -0.004366024397313595, 0.07446969300508499, -0.0036435353104025126, -0.03817969188094139, -0.022899452596902847, -0.007315021473914385, 0.04364698380231857, 0.055309273302555084, -0.01394623052328825, 0.04948657751083374, 0.03980302810668945, -0.0028747867327183485, 0.04392790421843529, 0.0073240515775978565, -0.027773519977927208, 0.04932978004217148, 0.03544148802757263, -0.050161559134721756, 0.012869175523519516, -0.02928750216960907, -0.0038649190682917833, -0.01924854703247547, 0.0015338403172791004, -0.006637584418058395, 0.06011788547039032, -0.010130015201866627, -0.02435026504099369, -0.03559405729174614, -0.03250369802117348, -0.06921880692243576, -0.03564134240150452, 0.013755803927779198, 0.0002704724029172212, 0.005159423220902681, 0.02393531985580921, -0.09335090219974518, 0.08838313072919846, -0.01511235348880291, -0.036285847425460815, -0.04066802188754082, 0.07221420854330063, 0.002564856316894293, -0.006813830230385065, -0.006070422474294901, -0.03183235600590706, 0.06613984704017639, -0.05526307225227356, 0.02062360942363739, 0.02392253279685974, 0.006265804637223482, -0.05995155870914459, 0.01662871614098549, -0.044020380824804306, 0.021478595212101936, 0.023158850148320198, 0.02139255963265896, -0.014300774782896042, -0.03713907673954964, 0.008490613661706448, 0.004837213549762964, -0.003904038341715932, 0.011041420511901379, 0.0393197275698185, -0.04000109061598778, -0.016060680150985718, 0.054008375853300095, 0.0662156268954277, 0.009074991568922997, 0.039817627519369125, 0.022011930122971535, 0.02159961313009262, 0.00666885357350111, -0.02781333588063717, -0.10109060257673264, 0.047183696180582047, -0.094450443983078, 0.020461546257138252, -0.002387044718489051, 0.0018019682029262185, 0.05811597406864166, -0.06635286659002304, 0.05003174766898155, 0.021449605002999306, -0.042000651359558105, -0.003032100386917591, -0.07881855964660645, 0.016635529696941376, 0.004166684579104185, -0.04042837396264076, 0.027582725510001183, -0.028416257351636887, -0.0008002476533874869, -0.03813186660408974, -0.02277635969221592, 0.0134229501709342, 0.03232216089963913, -0.0026840714272111654, 0.039076920598745346, 0.039432987570762634, 0.007640492636710405, -0.016901245340704918, 0.03507041558623314, -0.008460044860839844, -0.038418959826231, 0.05318921431899071, 0.02146412990987301, -0.020504536107182503, -0.04202006384730339, 0.04956148564815521, 0.048170607537031174, 0.01634356752038002, -0.006403223145753145, 0.010335220023989677, 0.026682110503315926, -0.019678674638271332, 0.020979322493076324, 0.08427541702985764, 0.013117281720042229, 0.051453981548547745, -0.09687412530183792, -0.03979359194636345, 0.015361622907221317, 0.0543488971889019, 0.00368759804405272, -0.06893345713615417, 0.006934245117008686, -0.09396074712276459, 0.0383262000977993, 0.02780756913125515, -0.01870325766503811, -0.002858772873878479, -0.05143600329756737, 0.009190581738948822, -0.05089552700519562, 0.009469479322433472, -0.03633200749754906, 0.023328201845288277, -0.02000543661415577, -0.004600897431373596, -0.10137920826673508, 0.0035075899213552475, 0.023894449695944786, -0.0002734587760642171, 0.02586013823747635, 0.034256551414728165, 0.016849514096975327, -0.038616735488176346, -0.0731859877705574, 0.009938014671206474, -0.007540358230471611, -0.008014017716050148, 0.010952465236186981, -0.029098190367221832, 0.027578676119446754, 0.004684600047767162, 0.03242150694131851, -0.016477560624480247, 0.012609495781362057, -0.028024397790431976, 0.02129070833325386, -0.02631421945989132, -0.04045645892620087, 0.014715394005179405, -0.02747453935444355, -0.01660796068608761, 0.012486017309129238, 0.0018641098868101835, 0.01991255395114422, 0.01626010052859783, -0.07287464290857315, -0.014720363542437553, -0.05097423121333122, 0.03745068237185478, 0.048500899225473404, 0.007498381193727255, 0.030190186575055122, -0.04969772696495056, -0.043742790818214417, -0.014572793617844582, 0.045443687587976456, 0.016589289531111717, 0.0434805266559124, 0.015745429322123528, -0.04358506575226784, 0.037941813468933105, 0.04180275276303291, -0.006345920730382204, -0.011677742004394531, 0.03765663132071495, 0.00013772555394098163, 0.019465738907456398, -0.06329736113548279, 0.024060040712356567, -0.02841372787952423, -0.06227143853902817, 0.010479260236024857, 0.025791900232434273, -0.024453453719615936, 0.027228960767388344, 0.013815280050039291, -0.029102304950356483, 0.034904491156339645, -0.039899274706840515, -0.044640399515628815, 0.0402604341506958, -0.04073886573314667, 0.008800511248409748, -0.011972245760262012, -0.04727913439273834, -0.013801977969706059, 0.058456987142562866, -0.065333291888237, 0.006648417562246323, -0.026985645294189453, -0.04354824870824814, -0.026950664818286896, -0.023656178265810013, -0.03118075616657734, -0.019986318424344063, -0.020859606564044952, -0.04116525501012802, -0.03332027047872543, -0.03331422433257103, -0.05334775149822235, -0.04054414853453636, 0.05434378981590271, -0.025765210390090942, 0.001983698457479477, 0.0703987404704094, 0.026201559230685234, 0.015516413375735283, 0.08492349088191986, 0.013951270841062069, -0.039927318692207336, -0.02617415226995945, 0.001918140915222466, 0.03415084257721901, 0.019022470340132713, 0.017501773312687874, 0.006160690449178219, 0.06960374116897583, -0.0056032296270132065, 0.010260515846312046, 0.04421102628111839, 0.05174253508448601, 0.029415346682071686, -0.02580767124891281, 0.0333910807967186, -0.03033040650188923, -0.015577180311083794, 0.07090239226818085, -0.1018274798989296, 0.024844534695148468, -0.007569056935608387, -0.02070007100701332, -0.00856429897248745, 0.0030397693626582623, -0.014133109711110592, 0.013014942407608032, 0.02269226685166359, -0.0039726728573441505, 0.031793296337127686, -0.021844467148184776, 0.05612068623304367, -0.03184942901134491, -0.03305710107088089, 0.010558689944446087, 0.08077390491962433, 0.01530870608985424, -0.046475425362586975, -0.01843992993235588, -0.007177384570240974, -0.015640530735254288, -0.012490354478359222, -0.0026951611507683992, -0.014425397850573063, 0.0016275893431156874, 0.03226645663380623, 0.056042034178972244, 0.02149742841720581, 0.0009020370780490339, -0.034144554287195206, -0.012803220190107822, 0.03715375065803528, -0.021412638947367668, 0.021661654114723206, -0.04852880910038948, -0.0029292975086718798, -0.043008822947740555, -0.06236044690012932, -0.018138736486434937, -0.05301659181714058, 0.0399169847369194, -0.002425174694508314, -0.006209449376910925, -0.020616691559553146, 0.003890874795615673, 0.017301687970757484, 0.05197913944721222, -0.0365358404815197, 0.024573085829615593, 0.04680576175451279, -0.01880670338869095, 0.0010480075143277645, -0.01589699275791645, -0.029013855382800102, -0.02440088987350464, -0.023471953347325325, 0.019315773621201515, -0.06926585733890533, 0.0817958265542984, 0.08067148923873901, -0.03151998668909073, -0.03187306597828865, -0.027148980647325516, 0.03106502629816532, 0.05189167708158493, 0.033997178077697754, -0.02365472912788391, -0.021007586270570755, 0.06410975009202957, 0.0031316070817410946, -0.004572088364511728, -0.007344573736190796, 0.02269522286951542, 0.03868929296731949, 0.02623535506427288, -0.015618265606462955, 0.027730416506528854, 0.004066905938088894, -0.04337373003363609, 0.023168493062257767, -0.05423211678862572, -0.0013046273961663246, 0.023440277203917503, 0.02021161839365959, -0.04934977740049362, 0.015079498291015625, 0.05333547294139862, -0.018499387428164482, -0.059224437922239304, 0.004663865547627211, -0.023986222222447395, -0.0363987572491169, -0.03211572393774986, -0.021675169467926025, -0.01890401542186737, -0.017070187255740166, 0.07028030604124069, -0.04029682278633118, -0.022675933316349983, 0.0004075330507475883, -0.009771803393959999, 0.013102243654429913, 0.030610013753175735, -0.060494646430015564, 0.0059906793758273125, -0.007050564046949148, -0.04273116588592529, -0.01671837456524372, 0.02241617441177368, 0.010675386525690556, -0.0012130149407312274, 0.04994489625096321, -0.0780358538031578, 0.005184587556868792, 0.004829134326428175, 0.0062270332127809525, 0.06002337113022804, -0.04347655177116394, -0.02549206092953682, -0.04566137492656708, -0.010127496905624866, 0.06530122458934784, 0.031089873984456062, 0.08172246068716049, 0.05569888651371002, -0.031246758997440338, -0.021565116941928864, 0.003661527531221509, -0.04005122929811478, -0.0018344206036999822, 0.02633025497198105, -0.011703197844326496, -0.026989281177520752, 0.010534443892538548, -0.0688042864203453, -0.008747209794819355, -0.005890097934752703, -0.014708842150866985, 0.039985764771699905, 0.05050387606024742, 0.027142638340592384, -0.04383024200797081, 0.012137486599385738, 0.03702281415462494, -0.0404181107878685, -0.02957874909043312, -0.03853587433695793, -0.0191538967192173, -0.06175549700856209, -0.056394487619400024, -0.02895515039563179, -0.043242957442998886, 0.12151018530130386, 0.009488927200436592, 0.02364807017147541, 0.043679989874362946, 0.046819452196359634, 0.009006932377815247, 0.013897896744310856, 0.03576599061489105, 0.031362082809209824, 0.025865871459245682, 0.030886724591255188, -0.006893935613334179, 0.036847542971372604, 0.020609214901924133, 0.014670114032924175, -0.011593954637646675, -0.03924011066555977, -0.021572785452008247, -0.039520688354969025, 0.042830225080251694, -0.029148489236831665, 0.02751106396317482, -0.04225276783108711, 0.04277550056576729, -0.02163289114832878, -0.012695815414190292, 0.0059832739643752575, -0.05604078993201256, 0.02712314762175083, 0.04108923673629761, -0.019897717982530594, 0.03994058817625046, 0.060489192605018616, 0.009857581928372383, 0.07589808851480484, -0.02247617579996586, 0.0616522952914238, 0.008439104072749615, -0.020165756344795227, -0.015530652366578579, -0.00855247862637043, 0.035926688462495804, 0.017061594873666763, -0.0018262936500832438, 0.03159124404191971, -0.011221474036574364, 0.07239168882369995, 0.0421271026134491, -0.035055987536907196, 0.0032588886097073555, -0.019010648131370544, -0.04365093633532524, -0.015375017188489437, -0.013881240971386433, 0.024514446035027504, -0.023838110268115997, 0.0149292116984725, -0.022479524835944176, 0.051751963794231415, 0.044260554015636444, -0.021630657836794853, -0.016653550788760185, 0.005996594205498695, 0.029308339580893517, -0.0055123139172792435, 0.04711625352501869, 0.01346023939549923, -0.023661816492676735, -0.029860584065318108, -0.004057563375681639, -0.019942138344049454, 0.0059738196432590485, -0.04290444031357765, -0.02347756363451481, -0.01316769514232874, -0.02419309690594673, -0.0758809894323349, -0.044274408370256424, -0.03598150610923767, 0.07794994860887527, 0.015584639273583889, 0.056237637996673584, -0.02288198098540306, -0.008820608258247375, 0.004597369581460953, -0.008689723908901215, 0.07080602645874023, 0.004751778673380613, 0.015641210600733757, -0.014006777666509151, 0.0030400226823985577, 0.015193668194115162, 0.011517694219946861, 0.03820154070854187, 0.017356256023049355, -0.029208840802311897, -0.024132531136274338, -0.019816745072603226, 0.03932978957891464, -0.00918133370578289, 0.03647288307547569, -0.013664043508470058, 0.024168068543076515, -0.022373082116246223, 0.031880274415016174, 0.03411753103137016, 0.010851170867681503, 0.007655947003513575, -0.04135233163833618, -0.04458843544125557, 0.06647901237010956, 0.009805947542190552, 0.03799079731106758, 0.03806718811392784, 0.04270009323954582, -0.006753048859536648, -0.005113072693347931, -0.015822118148207664, -0.025091005489230156, 0.0237076748162508, 0.015794795006513596, 0.026094254106283188, -0.021820271387696266, -0.056031107902526855, 0.013363382779061794, -0.033762019127607346, -0.04402938112616539, 0.0003196603211108595, 0.006800252944231033, -0.02128099650144577, 0.03702691197395325, -0.011487261392176151, -0.040749285370111465, -0.038446228951215744, -0.008748811669647694, 0.007278007455170155, 0.029670165851712227, -0.024667883291840553, 0.03451837971806526, -0.08799004554748535, 0.00974310003221035, -0.011206012219190598, 0.010212183929979801, 0.010082446038722992, 0.048631709069013596, -0.03282254561781883, -0.02633754536509514, -0.004266010597348213, 0.04986028000712395, 0.01629202999174595, -0.01703352853655815, 0.04941166192293167, -0.011194540187716484, -0.04009599983692169, 0.08269713819026947, -0.01739809475839138, 0.013873684220016003, -0.02947891689836979, 0.024851400405168533, -0.06636282056570053, -0.029348647221922874, -0.010954716242849827, 0.05309557169675827, 0.0014918931992724538, -0.023938892409205437, 0.007806052919477224, 0.015922678634524345, -0.06003690883517265, 0.05634832754731178 ]
<p>I came across a very recent paper by Gerard 't Hooft The abstract says: </p> <p>It is often claimed that the collapse of the wave function and Born's rule to interpret the square of the norm as a probability, have to be introduced as separate axioms in quantum mechanics besides the Schroedinger equation. Here we show that this is not true in certain models where quantum behavior can be attributed to underlying deterministic equations. It is argued that indeed the apparent spontaneous collapse of wave functions and Born's rule are features that strongly point towards determinism underlying quantum mechanics. </p> <p><a href="http://de.arxiv.org/abs/1112.1811">http://de.arxiv.org/abs/1112.1811</a></p> <p>I am wondering why this view seems to unpopular?</p>
g9812
[ 0.018766988068819046, 0.0042892214842140675, 0.023776397109031677, -0.02609926275908947, 0.04204950109124184, 0.014103155583143234, 0.01733660139143467, 0.003898972412571311, 0.011956064961850643, -0.026420166715979576, 0.040574412792921066, -0.00880234595388174, 0.050954125821590424, 0.06936130672693253, -0.030130280181765556, -0.018718672916293144, 0.05463990569114685, 0.014333561062812805, 0.053209561854600906, 0.05936162918806076, -0.02819974720478058, 0.025141917169094086, 0.035749491304159164, 0.018765486776828766, 0.02393687330186367, -0.01259221788495779, 0.06032150611281395, -0.04759259894490242, 0.010386399924755096, -0.0028253153432160616, 0.018967559561133385, 0.041625555604696274, 0.09034781157970428, -0.039980463683605194, 0.012704126536846161, 0.00914012547582388, 0.026532163843512535, -0.042148906737565994, 0.003120793728157878, -0.05091281235218048, -0.027692584320902824, 0.024804499000310898, -0.0068872044794261456, -0.006126876920461655, -0.01324436441063881, -0.03138099983334541, 0.003641925984993577, 0.010678758844733238, 0.009716876782476902, 0.009516334161162376, 0.033489350229501724, -0.01657278649508953, 0.05776118487119675, -0.008256420493125916, 0.03089420311152935, 0.03830932080745697, 0.01059718243777752, -0.0002454349887557328, 0.03829311579465866, -0.0004958747304044664, 0.008756623603403568, 0.007706453558057547, 0.04676993936300278, -0.014858859591186047, 0.05554371327161789, -0.00641006650403142, -0.015234870836138725, 0.02079843170940876, 0.01375513058155775, 0.002358530182391405, 0.02210245467722416, -0.07604528218507767, -0.033990439027547836, -0.01591753028333187, 0.036763038486242294, 0.023142047226428986, -0.005231664516031742, -0.016756238415837288, -0.041130200028419495, 0.028312617912888527, -0.03677251189947128, 0.0020382802467793226, 0.030184442177414894, 0.00877884216606617, 0.03973064571619034, -0.030345454812049866, 0.040039364248514175, -0.052144430577754974, 0.029127273708581924, 0.040943462401628494, -0.005650706589221954, -0.08896753191947937, 0.06259731948375702, -0.020958688110113144, 0.0182225089520216, -0.008839585818350315, -0.03635638579726219, 0.029194962233304977, 0.0033487288746982813, -0.003085462609305978, -0.02851809374988079, 0.01853148639202118, 0.004141237121075392, -0.03180044889450073, -0.0492561012506485, -0.018558211624622345, -0.040862616151571274, 0.015081876888871193, -0.0049795787781476974, -0.08928238600492477, 0.008827872574329376, 0.013423406518995762, -0.004917267244309187, -0.054021626710891724, -0.057745400816202164, -0.014951882883906364, 0.02102784626185894, -0.027413589879870415, -0.026447128504514694, 0.032716456800699234, -0.04226476699113846, 0.02548343501985073, 0.056661587208509445, 0.01049137208610773, -0.017680687829852104, 0.036027975380420685, -0.021189890801906586, -0.007173897698521614, 0.03913622722029686, 0.0027307583950459957, 0.011817713268101215, 0.016641894355416298, -0.023058442398905754, 0.05519803613424301, 0.008715410716831684, 0.04371284693479538, 0.014435483142733574, 0.02804536744952202, 0.03559495136141777, -0.033507443964481354, 0.004635206889361143, -0.0249305572360754, 0.05190589278936386, -0.03285304829478264, -0.003198661608621478, -0.04206963628530502, 0.07303331792354584, 0.018147701397538185, 0.009055005386471748, 0.02928711101412773, -0.0795295387506485, 0.003576287068426609, -0.07959243655204773, -0.048709671944379807, -0.03879319131374359, 0.011945215053856373, 0.05286083370447159, -0.004763336386531591, -0.0503777451813221, 0.0021323994733393192, 0.03572386875748634, 0.014565624296665192, -0.03534185141324997, 0.015140101313591003, -0.05333516001701355, -0.02381640113890171, -0.05272709205746651, -0.06373507529497147, -0.003228820161893964, 0.005110524594783783, 0.013396119698882103, 0.0001369092206005007, -0.0515361949801445, 0.08048701286315918, 0.01153401006013155, 0.022484058514237404, -0.02078942023217678, -0.014293413609266281, -0.014281299896538258, -0.03570020571351051, 0.005858431104570627, 0.006531506776809692, 0.025278525426983833, -0.0680352970957756, -0.007249094545841217, 0.011649206280708313, 0.016442129388451576, 0.034989967942237854, -0.034027379006147385, -0.030863674357533455, -0.019053885713219643, -0.0056786807253956795, 0.007100530434399843, 0.04528618976473808, 0.04575163498520851, -0.010501189157366753, 0.030559245496988297, -0.012148919515311718, 0.005568045657128096, 0.07434960454702377, 0.04265664890408516, 0.062175508588552475, 0.015222991816699505, -0.033506907522678375, -0.006209117826074362, 0.04556386172771454, -0.04106238856911659, 0.06116431578993797, 0.015544031746685505, -0.045310892164707184, 0.02705060876905918, -0.010945825837552547, 0.013719181530177593, -0.0049087549559772015, 0.021446069702506065, -0.031383950263261795, 0.0014614303363487124, 0.018882865086197853, -0.025437001138925552, 0.030837344005703926, -0.029675278812646866, 0.03149239718914032, 0.021418550983071327, 0.009082609787583351, 0.035674892365932465, 0.034286048263311386, -0.06924205273389816, -0.031447671353816986, -0.0016454722499474883, 0.00224807346239686, -0.059941694140434265, -0.04172496497631073, -0.024967217817902565, 0.03119855746626854, 0.012849921360611916, 0.03807222470641136, -0.029806189239025116, -0.02245762199163437, 0.0633116140961647, 0.02226259931921959, -0.008085294626653194, 0.015559148974716663, -0.02673453465104103, 0.006759033538401127, 0.0511225201189518, -0.042310938239097595, -0.03683279827237129, -0.0523245744407177, -0.004330718889832497, -0.02699745073914528, -0.0006085984641686082, -0.04845539852976799, -0.03568073734641075, 0.0146569749340415, -0.017612887546420097, 0.007304552011191845, -0.007193597499281168, 0.06353922188282013, -0.03317968174815178, -0.06895235925912857, -0.022964734584093094, 0.07781679928302765, -0.026667160913348198, 0.034482233226299286, -0.012220862321555614, -0.04651535674929619, -0.0021416808012872934, 0.007078363094478846, -0.012516461312770844, -0.011536763049662113, -0.00889446772634983, 0.047668568789958954, -0.021385565400123596, 0.026326199993491173, -0.0329684354364872, -0.013363249599933624, -0.044048551470041275, -0.05303208529949188, -0.04659395292401314, -0.011925425380468369, -0.024236906319856644, -0.01903418079018593, -0.07184945791959763, 0.012584025971591473, 0.038297828286886215, -0.11311932653188705, 0.036642637103796005, 0.004268502350896597, 0.027676565572619438, 0.02673622965812683, -0.012984370812773705, -0.001556418021209538, -0.053292952477931976, 0.011844923719763756, -0.05136924982070923, 0.027146335691213608, -0.00010781555465655401, -0.02911178581416607, -0.020716000348329544, 0.09880730509757996, 0.0009926524944603443, -0.039614222943782806, -0.007153946906328201, 0.014706816524267197, 0.02625962160527706, 0.05831553041934967, -0.000922863488085568, -0.0021871270146220922, -0.045800309628248215, -0.03461846709251404, -0.014968915842473507, 0.04299548268318176, -0.016367437317967415, -0.019653111696243286, 0.016207169741392136, -0.006136373151093721, -0.05067665874958038, 0.02088269405066967, 0.07797756046056747, -0.09194407612085342, -0.04225754737854004, -0.014216438867151737, -0.03189382702112198, -0.013117143884301186, 0.07161092758178711, -0.011015313677489758, -0.03823832422494888, 0.08797785639762878, 0.0063413879834115505, -0.033729977905750275, 0.04769988730549812, -0.029978062957525253, 0.06229997053742409, 0.005970356985926628, -0.06927493214607239, -0.02237727865576744, 0.02960248477756977, 0.004565444774925709, 0.015516679733991623, -0.035082537680864334, 0.05873837321996689, -0.00404655747115612, -0.017138971015810966, 0.04415010288357735, -0.00045167378266341984, 0.01683780364692211, -0.03441540524363518, 0.005761708598583937, 0.07090441882610321, -0.011335410177707672, -0.03775733336806297, -0.0005946691962890327, 0.11059176921844482, 0.025839129462838173, -0.027511589229106903, 0.010583422146737576, 0.019809788092970848, 0.018973333761096, -0.011198390275239944, 0.023119503632187843, 0.010424738749861717, -0.010521397925913334, 0.0399681031703949, -0.013054276816546917, -0.024337807670235634, -0.017640559002757072, -0.004480854608118534, 0.08367636054754257, 0.04470532760024071, -0.06324605643749237, 0.007055426016449928, 0.018115539103746414, -0.03270668536424637, 0.05683989077806473, 0.04589926823973656, -0.03050224669277668, 0.04353250563144684, 0.01975199021399021, -0.029576171189546585, -0.007958238013088703, 0.06532512605190277, -0.012249686755239964, 0.008625208400189877, 0.03462400287389755, 0.025204861536622047, -0.021124619990587234, -0.0003626201068982482, -0.05914080888032913, -0.02371053956449032, -0.01814677007496357, 0.04270093888044357, -0.013614115305244923, 0.03540521860122681, 0.052794553339481354, 0.0069723776541650295, 0.05807093158364296, -0.011059246957302094, -0.026291169226169586, 0.011098021641373634, 0.06431461870670319, -0.016231641173362732, 0.018324319273233414, -0.03315329924225807, 0.0043771350756287575, 0.03934444114565849, -0.006716378964483738, 0.017450401559472084, -0.011216394603252411, -0.044048648327589035, -0.051035668700933456, 0.007126947399228811, -0.0026834229938685894, -0.02992059476673603, -0.009859354235231876, 0.061514414846897125, 0.0030235410667955875, 0.04823916405439377, -0.03475670889019966, 0.02163061685860157, -0.01410533394664526, 0.025881191715598106, 0.029063856229186058, -0.00556150684133172, 0.00046859923168085515, -0.030100980773568153, -0.029772773385047913, 0.03636138513684273, -0.020759014412760735, -0.04070117324590683, -0.07055597007274628, -0.03201739490032196, -0.0053246039897203445, 0.01110479049384594, 0.004076015204191208, -0.0020781762432307005, -0.000607556663453579, -0.021161632612347603, 0.07699556648731232, 0.002732947003096342, 0.07023510336875916, 0.03981706127524376, -0.035337407141923904, 0.03035930171608925, 0.037872735410928726, 0.0574820376932621, 0.03623650595545769, -0.03787662833929062, -0.02475862391293049, 0.005406680982559919, -0.023613784462213516, -0.00581959867849946, 0.06465138494968414, 0.04523467645049095, -0.026438791304826736, 0.014954296872019768, -0.05885995924472809, -0.08470066636800766, 0.049740634858608246, 0.0021598150487989187, 0.01949555054306984, 0.017249982804059982, -0.11964187771081924, 0.015296782366931438, -0.007340626325458288, 0.0329948365688324, 0.004709044471383095, -0.0284409299492836, 0.06112796813249588, -0.03388538584113121, -0.015872003510594368, -0.0010570758022367954, -0.015425057150423527, 0.017337767407298088, -0.01795748807489872, -0.01472551841288805, -0.042197976261377335, -0.015726841986179352, -0.03499189391732216, 0.04119201749563217, -0.05829108878970146, -0.01656907983124256, -0.07052873075008392, 0.010690266266465187, -0.013035403564572334, -0.013499835506081581, 0.017518524080514908, 0.06770829111337662, -0.0435783714056015, -0.010751038789749146, -0.08536844700574875, 0.04628262668848038, -0.008641039952635765, -0.0032843551598489285, 0.03431472182273865, 0.011623968370258808, -0.007748306263238192, 0.02474108710885048, -0.035320308059453964, -0.016206169500947, 0.012179273180663586, -0.12130311131477356, -0.02585478127002716, -0.02580304630100727, 0.0028452109545469284, -0.010594968684017658, 0.03252774477005005, 0.08164364844560623, -0.022673292085528374, -0.05621727555990219, -0.02567562460899353, 0.05089537426829338, -0.04928698390722275, 0.04992320016026497, 0.0267202015966177, 0.015025594271719456, -0.03860785439610481, -0.04512106999754906, -0.009482833556830883, 0.0005924784345552325, -0.03078918717801571, 0.010226644575595856, 0.056456197053194046, 0.01184347365051508, -0.03940655291080475, 0.051928043365478516, -0.028987646102905273, -0.015659816563129425, -0.02784876897931099, 0.002136358292773366, 0.0579034760594368, 0.050496745854616165, 0.04400920122861862, 0.012791384011507034, 0.03855391964316368, 0.0022250202018767595, -0.02157541550695896, -0.0744302049279213, 0.06924057751893997, -0.015351064503192902, -0.04368238523602486, 0.00790778174996376, 0.041440825909376144, 0.01673784665763378, 0.049954719841480255, -0.005863255821168423, 0.010381819680333138, -0.06143558770418167, 0.001562205608934164, 0.05399436876177788, -0.02056117169559002, -0.029445573687553406, 0.03491327911615372, -0.09435618668794632, -0.028058910742402077, -0.016419444233179092, -0.003227637382224202, -0.04190495237708092, 0.02338053472340107, -0.05331689864397049, -0.01032578106969595, 0.017305105924606323, 0.01522289589047432, 0.012093093246221542, 0.03335392847657204, 0.03830088675022125, 0.025700287893414497, -0.002377360360696912, 0.04087623581290245, -0.037733856588602066, 0.06287430971860886, 0.027280893176794052, -0.005322634242475033, 0.002905786270275712, 0.04755128175020218, -0.01160898432135582, 0.011125819757580757, 0.002776294481009245, -0.06884169578552246, 0.0337182879447937, -0.05102098360657692, -0.00918236467987299, 0.020382054150104523, 0.02966436930000782, -0.05880412831902504, -0.05939456820487976, -0.000009518063052382786, -0.006075570359826088, -0.009590205736458302, 0.02216089703142643, 0.0588061548769474, 0.010905170813202858, -0.03313403204083443, 0.021389037370681763, 0.043354298919439316, 0.01602838933467865, -0.022283418104052544, 0.08613757789134979, -0.03330143913626671, -0.031331371515989304, -0.05218755826354027, -0.022642306983470917, -0.02722030133008957, 0.02776537463068962, -0.0314132496714592, 0.015907330438494682, 0.029581556096673012, 0.008182579651474953, 0.010374450124800205, 0.016187051311135292, 0.004184171557426453, -0.0329844132065773, -0.00008520103438058868, -0.025956958532333374, 0.013235832564532757, -0.010665697045624256, -0.07326918095350266, -0.06425929814577103, 0.05126428231596947, -0.07021985203027725, 0.005263942293822765, 0.03472006693482399, 0.019776398316025734, 0.036372099071741104, -0.00955697800964117, -0.02454293519258499, -0.0035743294283747673, 0.01912945695221424, 0.027593381702899933, 0.04604242742061615, 0.02782079391181469, -0.02360878698527813, -0.035684797912836075, -0.05406488478183746, 0.007729180622845888, -0.020470695570111275, 0.010179541073739529, -0.05241076648235321, -0.05461936816573143, 0.01942860335111618, -0.002944267587736249, -0.04507169872522354, 0.04873811453580856, 0.09491534531116486, 0.02499365620315075, -0.06029195711016655, 0.03769809007644653, 0.0524972528219223, 0.015440021641552448, -0.06829669326543808, -0.047985952347517014, 0.0038473017048090696, 0.024901486933231354, -0.04885179176926613, -0.008167150430381298, -0.017957394942641258, -0.024036167189478874, 0.005743909627199173, 0.003925287630409002, 0.01343776285648346, -0.06619662046432495, 0.030835287645459175, 0.0028305004816502333, 0.018613487482070923, -0.034759268164634705, -0.005087059456855059, 0.026534710079431534, -0.027298318222165108, -0.01381902489811182, -0.03615109622478485, -0.002802878851071, -0.011863326653838158, -0.021645694971084595, -0.02104407735168934, -0.025485938414931297, -0.012211639434099197, 0.03184633329510689, 0.007985194213688374, -0.0320478193461895, 0.053654372692108154, -0.03938509523868561, 0.018988220021128654, 0.013397320173680782, -0.028317740187048912, -0.01703842543065548, 0.0162274781614542, 0.05182597413659096, 0.005597446579486132, -0.00039922501309774816, -0.01708213984966278, 0.00786754209548235, -0.043211739510297775, 0.004619089886546135, 0.06336759030818939, -0.04486601799726486, 0.05605154484510422, -0.048224277794361115, -0.0037950975820422173, 0.04434725269675255, 0.030277492478489876, 0.03321642801165581, -0.005280554294586182, -0.018505901098251343, -0.04238574579358101, -0.012849514372646809, -0.02086716517806053, 0.02346869371831417, 0.029873386025428772, -0.08501265943050385, -0.019722243770956993, -0.032078735530376434, -0.00627814419567585, -0.021679196506738663, -0.009229936636984348, -0.037008218467235565, 0.04803543537855148, 0.0036496841348707676, -0.01306686270982027, 0.042374130338430405, 0.035604096949100494, -0.06291462481021881, 0.05680344998836517, -0.04118720442056656, -0.03802236169576645, -0.04338056594133377, -0.013574810698628426, 0.014790515415370464, 0.008455357514321804, -0.04131283238530159, -0.014826023019850254, 0.01635032333433628, -0.03263193368911743, -0.03011404722929001, -0.0007285603205673397, 0.03299526497721672, -0.0774223804473877, 0.04157107695937157, 0.044674087315797806, 0.03987972438335419, -0.05366615206003189, 0.006522781681269407, 0.019187459722161293, 0.004016919061541557, 0.025118568912148476, -0.04761086404323578, 0.00034574471646919847, -0.07212896645069122, -0.02891514077782631, -0.047581203281879425, 0.03268052637577057, 0.004052118863910437, -0.02627667598426342, 0.009148777462542057, -0.02205962873995304, 0.08509837836027145, 0.012979519553482533, -0.03367031738162041, 0.02336716465651989, 0.014939822256565094, 0.05766422301530838, 0.014007018879055977, 0.0300502460449934, -0.03356402739882469, 0.025303548201918602, -0.020339472219347954, 0.013394192792475224, -0.016278907656669617, 0.029143717139959335, 0.03231000527739525 ]
<p>Is charge of something for (e.g.) an electron related to electromagnetic space if it exists due to energy, due to which it may have mass? I don't know about quantum mechanics or advanced particle models. Can anyone just simply give an intuitive idea? </p> <p>EDIT I want to mean what actually gives electron charge if it is not assumed fundamental but result of some other physical phenomenon or it is just the quantity defined to explain physical interactions?I think now it is clear</p>
g189
[ 0.05093657225370407, 0.011122195050120354, -0.016801957041025162, -0.023395802825689316, 0.08083003759384155, 0.0740988478064537, -0.06947648525238037, 0.03154706954956055, -0.01184752956032753, -0.009693789295852184, 0.02710699290037155, -0.034794650971889496, 0.05244963988661766, 0.012378811836242676, -0.04166530445218086, 0.017501357942819595, 0.08106834441423416, 0.008036446757614613, 0.029575210064649582, -0.0029571163468062878, 0.0192596223205328, 0.0009373402572236955, 0.005349806044250727, -0.03140600398182869, -0.07700619846582413, 0.005247882567346096, 0.09281932562589645, 0.04605117067694664, 0.041211340576410294, -0.06897982209920883, 0.023530473932623863, 0.0011541391722857952, 0.07282422482967377, -0.03202110901474953, -0.0632338598370552, -0.03390147164463997, 0.025508658960461617, 0.03653315082192421, -0.01689279079437256, 0.014103252440690994, 0.00938953272998333, -0.017692068591713905, -0.04587315768003464, 0.006797530222684145, -0.021891659125685692, 0.0004618992388714105, -0.057173144072294235, -0.0034941541962325573, -0.012143989093601704, -0.012159643694758415, -0.00865793414413929, 0.025014178827404976, 0.04706428572535515, 0.0050591533072292805, 0.054680969566106796, 0.017394741997122765, 0.022317709401249886, 0.03046480193734169, 0.08767411857843399, 0.06425143033266068, 0.04437599331140518, 0.09607720375061035, 0.004693548195064068, 0.009530911222100258, 0.02679779753088951, 0.006278768181800842, -0.03670410066843033, -0.010639793239533901, -0.0018474272219464183, 0.01458753366023302, 0.02975565381348133, -0.03365530073642731, -0.051688238978385925, -0.007146344054490328, 0.014211591333150864, -0.03102688491344452, -0.0021313843317329884, 0.026583321392536163, 0.04601330682635307, -0.022334054112434387, 0.019472258165478706, -0.03262071684002876, 0.06519390642642975, 0.0338674932718277, 0.08176137506961823, -0.042093776166439056, -0.06209574267268181, -0.010483944788575172, 0.005928304512053728, -0.005410594865679741, 0.002484632423147559, 0.010989786125719547, 0.04242897033691406, 0.016943292692303658, -0.03899497538805008, -0.031301937997341156, 0.018405558541417122, 0.03418252244591713, -0.0525088906288147, 0.009732445701956749, -0.022661861032247543, -0.005061437841504812, 0.05869545787572861, 0.022408006712794304, 0.025392567738890648, 0.026795528829097748, -0.017093762755393982, 0.04614855349063873, 0.013573563657701015, 0.04001471772789955, 0.030342714861035347, -0.016403593122959137, -0.024442654103040695, -0.006862661801278591, -0.05221378058195114, 0.020217176526784897, 0.05484971031546593, -0.04807823523879051, -0.0037142375949770212, 0.08188176155090332, -0.00143693876452744, 0.009661075659096241, -0.004650500603020191, 0.06169873848557472, -0.023824693635106087, -0.03140860050916672, 0.03450468182563782, -0.008479636162519455, 0.012373079545795918, -0.002196146408095956, -0.017187997698783875, -0.03450249508023262, -0.03537135198712349, -0.01454863976687193, 0.031074848026037216, 0.018830806016921997, -0.02627492882311344, -0.007099540904164314, 0.0051689776591956615, -0.004609458614140749, -0.026290958747267723, -0.0012912710662931204, 0.005379231180995703, -0.027722537517547607, -0.03880254924297333, 0.012310408055782318, -0.0016470544505864382, 0.018413567915558815, 0.02907416969537735, 0.019909054040908813, -0.005970243830233812, 0.04589086025953293, -0.006047293543815613, -0.04125666245818138, 0.058348748832941055, 0.0069245342165231705, 0.001990352990105748, -0.02779104746878147, -0.03037283942103386, -0.03638331964612007, -0.0011991283390671015, 0.0102250836789608, 0.019244465976953506, -0.031197449192404747, -0.05474168434739113, -0.04135402664542198, 0.02523561380803585, -0.08593544363975525, -0.018357764929533005, -0.0008624671609140933, -0.027803966775536537, -0.016286762431263924, 0.00880067702382803, 0.06148937717080116, 0.0228489451110363, 0.03174610435962677, -0.0015499010914936662, -0.004486038815230131, 0.0838814303278923, -0.01424524374306202, -0.04197012260556221, 0.01804298721253872, 0.07990292459726334, -0.03456001728773117, -0.0484195202589035, -0.006793826352804899, -0.04059644415974617, 0.02037922851741314, -0.0181684922426939, 0.021013814955949783, -0.04783781245350838, -0.03662222996354103, 0.029459455981850624, 0.03992992639541626, 0.017557041719555855, 0.02612466923892498, -0.006608436815440655, -0.015009047463536263, -0.007497171405702829, -0.02312305010855198, -0.024704329669475555, 0.020640458911657333, 0.02057619020342827, 0.022343134507536888, 0.07368341088294983, 0.031021464616060257, -0.011975670233368874, -0.04196159169077873, 0.023231374099850655, 0.005450114607810974, 0.01643621362745762, -0.0643409714102745, 0.022793682292103767, 0.056610915809869766, -0.02211884967982769, -0.047049351036548615, -0.05209115147590637, 0.01384847704321146, -0.018669016659259796, 0.010554393753409386, -0.029575051739811897, -0.06865867972373962, 0.023819925263524055, 0.06378336250782013, -0.021750058978796005, -0.006711393594741821, 0.00008043597335927188, -0.006163203623145819, -0.05308113992214203, 0.03571336716413498, -0.02618124894797802, 0.04275745153427124, -0.007278125733137131, 0.005066451616585255, 0.036072298884391785, 0.03105650469660759, -0.04827513173222542, -0.04676428064703941, 0.002839514520019293, -0.003704322734847665, -0.04053747281432152, -0.026027977466583252, 0.008895279839634895, 0.007660174276679754, 0.021615711972117424, -0.019430704414844513, 0.016461912542581558, 0.013442488387227058, -0.04811260476708412, -0.018416933715343475, -0.04223192110657692, -0.023257311433553696, 0.011267418973147869, -0.02031002566218376, 0.030826352536678314, -0.031339507550001144, -0.02201893739402294, 0.06938651204109192, -0.05875588580965996, -0.04733581095933914, -0.009114223532378674, 0.0001959358633030206, -0.022669410333037376, 0.040493957698345184, -0.03589191660284996, -0.012777857482433319, 0.0008072967757470906, 0.018472235649824142, 0.012433408759534359, -0.03083651512861252, 0.003773147938773036, 0.055841006338596344, -0.020481914281845093, -0.02350701577961445, 0.010044221766293049, -0.00017648848006501794, 0.04600224643945694, 0.011711591854691505, 0.04931566119194031, -0.13257654011249542, 0.0050392188131809235, -0.005329822655767202, -0.06401676684617996, 0.020445216447114944, 0.03022228553891182, -0.0348794087767601, 0.003280554199591279, -0.024639179930090904, 0.014790607616305351, -0.03847741335630417, -0.006783188320696354, -0.043478548526763916, 0.04614151641726494, -0.030203642323613167, -0.015398574993014336, 0.005372063722461462, 0.03028373047709465, 0.02452933043241501, 0.0071747140027582645, 0.039525020867586136, 0.010653533972799778, -0.02299121394753456, -0.011339889839291573, -0.018283706158399582, 0.05518842861056328, 0.06346683949232101, -0.02825046516954899, -0.04966730996966362, -0.0014085323782637715, -0.008272680453956127, -0.05188710242509842, 0.058939434587955475, -0.019494039937853813, 0.04374542087316513, -0.029592197388410568, 0.0008528524776920676, -0.0018910630606114864, 0.0028808685019612312, -0.027432147413492203, -0.06678715348243713, -0.01539127342402935, -0.05439898744225502, 0.023751957342028618, -0.05702909454703331, 0.06077384576201439, 0.05490938574075699, -0.047146718949079514, -0.021955108270049095, -0.00610755942761898, 0.0010692119831219316, 0.02015344426035881, -0.028915541246533394, -0.047467175871133804, -0.0038077051285654306, -0.0322972908616066, -0.05757720768451691, -0.019260378554463387, 0.02944401279091835, 0.04108477383852005, 0.008087697438895702, 0.08547792583703995, 0.014001223258674145, -0.03404852747917175, 0.007543790619820356, -0.0197925828397274, 0.012653238140046597, -0.05432417616248131, -0.04281425476074219, 0.03331802785396576, -0.03308575972914696, 0.02070736140012741, -0.0007148445583879948, -0.009421455673873425, 0.038661882281303406, -0.028122924268245697, 0.01454437430948019, 0.038415517657995224, 0.007795688230544329, -0.024032482877373695, -0.01837478205561638, -0.012074561789631844, -0.04086994007229805, 0.04700057953596115, -0.04370115324854851, 0.014161487109959126, 0.023767687380313873, -0.03189515694975853, -0.009143318980932236, 0.0263229850679636, -0.07338742911815643, 0.006390288472175598, 0.013431930914521217, -0.025181008502840996, 0.030635543167591095, 0.011686473153531551, -0.03492457792162895, -0.0019665593281388283, 0.020611654967069626, -0.05548801273107529, -0.03461862727999687, 0.015831343829631805, 0.038332052528858185, 0.04601089283823967, 0.023493709042668343, 0.04782971739768982, -0.005688579753041267, -0.04682084172964096, 0.03456341475248337, -0.012627855874598026, -0.008358499966561794, -0.033537834882736206, -0.030579403042793274, -0.050551943480968475, -0.025856519117951393, 0.0018544138874858618, -0.07492125779390335, 0.045156799256801605, -0.061883632093667984, 0.0870712623000145, -0.015971830114722252, 0.0016594744520261884, 0.04887915775179863, 0.006375681143254042, -0.016507277265191078, 0.037520214915275574, 0.012768865562975407, 0.08104220032691956, -0.04608478024601936, 0.0012317784130573273, -0.02620767429471016, 0.02443644404411316, 0.0028411373496055603, 0.015521454624831676, 0.0029607743490487337, -0.0574132576584816, 0.034229397773742676, -0.022068774327635765, -0.04078289493918419, 0.036314692348241806, 0.05536960810422897, 0.03682052716612816, 0.032853271812200546, 0.029597453773021698, -0.015711462125182152, -0.011802289634943008, 0.1136401817202568, 0.03714701533317566, -0.0043957107700407505, -0.022313883528113365, -0.0015894707757979631, -0.030982716009020805, 0.06536949425935745, -0.005475933663547039, 0.013893913477659225, -0.07168862968683243, 0.03303263336420059, -0.14754340052604675, 0.047126755118370056, -0.038457319140434265, 0.0027791771572083235, 0.10446003824472427, 0.053366679698228836, 0.015262306667864323, -0.0004360605962574482, -0.0046360082924366, 0.039832647889852524, -0.04932227358222008, -0.02009221538901329, -0.02986752800643444, -0.04004175215959549, -0.02622096799314022, -0.0043967184610664845, -0.03146079555153847, -0.0459623746573925, -0.00008504716970492154, -0.00919177196919918, 0.004327694419771433, -0.05044892057776451, 0.01585225574672222, 0.0000982994242804125, -0.0799802914261818, -0.024847501888871193, 0.045346055179834366, 0.03950057178735733, 0.024812106043100357, -0.07586450129747391, -0.02532981149852276, -0.029830310493707657, -0.034675758332014084, -0.025966070592403412, 0.01809382438659668, 0.01745612360537052, 0.036776211112737656, -0.02346598356962204, 0.05742885544896126, 0.002640471328049898, 0.0034912300761789083, -0.0325779914855957, -0.03794543072581291, 0.009372386150062084, -0.03322933241724968, -0.02071073092520237, 0.01801804080605507, 0.013081973418593407, -0.029096217826008797, -0.01643311232328415, -0.01389545388519764, 0.09323471039533615, 0.007821976207196712, -0.05049830302596092, 0.0008581612491980195, 0.036481842398643494, -0.007479992229491472, 0.003044622950255871, -0.029777074232697487, -0.03063507191836834, -0.02599056251347065, 0.02627354860305786, 0.009505487978458405, 0.0316256508231163, 0.025928691029548645, 0.0031640646047890186, 0.008839950896799564, 0.04626724123954773, -0.020062554627656937, -0.01521945558488369, 0.08144870400428772, -0.042065370827913284, -0.0238442774862051, 0.007652906700968742, -0.018323242664337158, 0.012183035723865032, -0.010652421042323112, 0.024439483880996704, 0.01032388024032116, 0.04597463458776474, -0.035266321152448654, 0.015835197642445564, 0.000571520475205034, 0.03839957341551781, 0.04951760545372963, -0.031036633998155594, 0.05520585551857948, -0.02874331921339035, -0.002546817995607853, -0.01651638187468052, -0.014531586319208145, -0.00570480152964592, 0.010871294885873795, 0.12154658883810043, -0.0010539965005591512, -0.003918352071195841, 0.05330999195575714, -0.03919165953993797, -0.028788821771740913, -0.038847003132104874, 0.025120370090007782, 0.03143864870071411, 0.041474372148513794, 0.009638410061597824, -0.029218455776572227, -0.03968258574604988, 0.012314710766077042, 0.07548119872808456, 0.08985207974910736, 0.002958084223791957, -0.013363114558160305, 0.0028099941555410624, 0.058795806020498276, -0.044865984469652176, -0.016170362010598183, 0.017972802743315697, 0.012032774277031422, -0.05549296364188194, -0.0028036395087838173, 0.030254876241087914, 0.00447142543271184, -0.02358131669461727, -0.07598306238651276, -0.024099506437778473, 0.04760674014687538, 0.040600188076496124, -0.021716592833399773, 0.005500990431755781, -0.004906101617962122, 0.02920510433614254, 0.03569416701793671, -0.051823414862155914, 0.008258745074272156, -0.013813705183565617, 0.007956603541970253, 0.01874339021742344, 0.033945366740226746, -0.040341757237911224, 0.034481074661016464, -0.013501116074621677, -0.002146461047232151, -0.006494844797998667, -0.06798738241195679, -0.03488079085946083, 0.07700871676206589, -0.016772544011473656, 0.04772639647126198, -0.019970638677477837, 0.0023497738875448704, 0.05640413239598274, -0.04017927125096321, -0.04396761208772659, 0.04013703390955925, -0.0015760251553729177, -0.01583549566566944, 0.014662583358585835, 0.013282861560583115, -0.027368081733584404, -0.030004438012838364, 0.023180054500699043, 0.0543791726231575, -0.0055196997709572315, -0.0062593757174909115, 0.04693194106221199, -0.0037078869063407183, 0.03579964488744736, 0.004062470048666, 0.0235650185495615, 0.06332334131002426, 0.037432387471199036, -0.015756947919726372, -0.00652348855510354, -0.0449814535677433, 0.02250789850950241, -0.0894860178232193, -0.01726379431784153, -0.022781338542699814, -0.05231336131691933, 0.004481526091694832, -0.04213098809123039, -0.033419445157051086, 0.04152465984225273, -0.03880644217133522, 0.030306102707982063, -0.027387045323848724, -0.021815693005919456, -0.007172885816544294, -0.0315534882247448, 0.0740065798163414, 0.03122691810131073, -0.032657019793987274, 0.06729672849178314, 0.05929604545235634, -0.03383079543709755, -0.07732033729553223, 0.003510202979668975, -0.01894264668226242, 0.035345930606126785, 0.01664133369922638, 0.038943950086832047, 0.03686535358428955, -0.03421419858932495, 0.07680433243513107, 0.025547048076987267, -0.010200398974120617, -0.04173201695084572, 0.055458664894104004, 0.02697189338505268, -0.08436623215675354, -0.08092701435089111, 0.02106230892241001, -0.024909744039177895, -0.04642345756292343, -0.03774001821875572, -0.023768065497279167, -0.008272926323115826, 0.04783457890152931, 0.00356606999412179, -0.015908684581518173, -0.0028002543840557337, 0.024211037904024124, -0.007094040513038635, 0.021526025608181953, -0.054415397346019745, -0.0516568087041378, -0.007045283913612366, -0.009783640503883362, 0.013006999157369137, 0.04477338120341301, 0.0012691112933680415, -0.02004566229879856, -0.06449344009160995, -0.012555591762065887, -0.02553943544626236, -0.0023362396750599146, -0.06475607305765152, -0.024858130142092705, 0.027972612529993057, -0.023864246904850006, -0.029364410787820816, 0.03660600632429123, 0.060670219361782074, -0.0186197180300951, -0.007661039009690285, 0.011494842357933521, 0.08866289258003235, 0.00445566326379776, 0.03150990605354309, -0.022786550223827362, 0.009183506481349468, -0.03497990220785141, -0.005146331619471312, -0.018971486017107964, 0.0030882360879331827, -0.005298420321196318, -0.05167684704065323, -0.0008407002897001803, -0.04017028212547302, -0.00759692071005702, -0.0014128136681392789, 0.05672144889831543, 0.03956347703933716, 0.04677896946668625, 0.015133104287087917, 0.000017845930415205657, -0.019338637590408325, 0.0008326339302584529, -0.026794813573360443, 0.016347244381904602, -0.0032467779237776995, 0.001528480788692832, -0.041151393204927444, -0.05818929895758629, 0.020886557176709175, -0.027941090986132622, 0.01831764541566372, 0.039830829948186874, 0.01638692617416382, 0.01212136261165142, 0.025495052337646484, 0.0014569162158295512, 0.05980173125863075, -0.026915298774838448, 0.028400270268321037, -0.007693121675401926, -0.01187963504344225, 0.003212985349819064, -0.029725102707743645, -0.024524115025997162, -0.033583320677280426, -0.010491475462913513, -0.03264467418193817, 0.04597305878996849, -0.00952010229229927, 0.018610665574669838, 0.005208452697843313, 0.004388215020298958, 0.011743779294192791, -0.02992519922554493, 0.041446104645729065, 0.02320430986583233, -0.020407844334840775, 0.020098868757486343, 0.002259935950860381, 0.023452267050743103, -0.05539381504058838, -0.023834122344851494, -0.026784226298332214, -0.06384366005659103, -0.004508765414357185, -0.033785510808229446, 0.0469265952706337, 0.04727216437458992, 0.05068786069750786, -0.04507938399910927, 0.027573788538575172, -0.04391152784228325, 0.04127228260040283, 0.058501485735177994, -0.038516558706760406, -0.019925307482481003, -0.0018304773839190602, -0.02478860132396221, -0.00497085927054286, -0.011512937024235725, -0.00406003650277853, 0.007807793561369181, -0.004442746285349131, -0.016741080209612846, -0.04030781611800194, -0.009647106751799583, -0.006256395950913429 ]
<p>This titled position of the earths axis is known as inclination of the earths axis. The earth's rotation axis makes an angle of about 66.5 degrees with the plane of its orbit around the sun, or about 23.5 degrees from the perpendicular to the ecliptic plane</p> <p>what is the scientific reason for the inclination of earth's rotation axis? </p> <p>and what will happen if the inclination angel changed?</p>
g9813
[ 0.07316846400499344, 0.034191444516181946, 0.009539032354950905, -0.007845425978302956, -0.017058517783880234, 0.035240720957517624, 0.053070489317178726, -0.014107213355600834, -0.0068586054258048534, -0.03482064977288246, 0.0012303156545385718, 0.024562489241361618, 0.03590779006481171, -0.04382003843784332, 0.04999832063913345, 0.0065306127071380615, 0.02102566696703434, 0.005567491520196199, -3.7492208093681256e-7, 0.011130310595035553, 0.0032558413222432137, -0.019865944981575012, -0.012896839529275894, -0.03161108121275902, -0.03700782358646393, -0.018521739169955254, 0.02464352175593376, -0.006285255774855614, 0.0010089626302942634, 0.04545522481203079, 0.03320020064711571, -0.03202500566840172, 0.05499253794550896, 0.005266865715384483, -0.0250636488199234, -0.04272591695189476, -0.0077354456298053265, 0.019979525357484818, 0.0638217031955719, -0.011599518358707428, 0.015535324811935425, 0.002137347823008895, 0.018018057569861412, 0.003478325204923749, 0.003869759850203991, -0.06465035676956177, -0.01601179875433445, 0.007944010198116302, 0.025983838364481926, -0.0170559361577034, -0.008078468963503838, 0.011227400973439217, 0.026672838255763054, -0.007710753008723259, 0.004846333526074886, 0.01871459372341633, 0.008224787190556526, 0.05619814246892929, 0.021981218829751015, 0.015102257952094078, -0.020878372713923454, -0.04042719304561615, 0.020525768399238586, -0.007350902538746595, 0.019695907831192017, -0.05861186608672142, -0.034397613257169724, 0.009439583867788315, 0.025854064151644707, 0.005310134030878544, 0.00038457318441942334, -0.03382444754242897, -0.03721337392926216, -0.004735944326967001, -0.029262680560350418, 0.0002498819667380303, 0.03368131071329117, -0.013588874600827694, -0.0069674537517130375, 0.01906602270901203, -0.012477090582251549, 0.021294258534908295, -0.013957739807665348, 0.00951636303216219, 0.08168640732765198, -0.05222176015377045, 0.013357673771679401, -0.017649956047534943, -0.009788783267140388, -0.05670447275042534, 0.04351632297039032, -0.030441952869296074, 0.04084309935569763, 0.02053394913673401, -0.031170420348644257, -0.0658913254737854, -0.02558388002216816, 0.015236354433000088, -0.016356639564037323, 0.009907083585858345, -0.006420564837753773, -0.03546589985489845, 0.015044387429952621, 0.012463181279599667, 0.03749847412109375, 0.0053171394392848015, -0.0014223476173356175, 0.01212669163942337, -0.0057583097368478775, -0.03612798452377319, 0.004640664905309677, -0.043821223080158234, -0.005466155242174864, -0.0014695374993607402, 0.010611840523779392, -0.0031923726201057434, 0.05276625603437424, -0.05304425209760666, 0.08418241888284683, 0.07343746721744537, 0.02394840493798256, 0.017736854031682014, -0.006935094483196735, 0.07471652328968048, -0.019821202382445335, -0.0254968274384737, 0.03787945583462715, 0.009713231585919857, -0.002035607350990176, -0.01852317899465561, -0.026983845978975296, 0.009798369370400906, -0.05909990891814232, -0.01136852614581585, 0.05389467999339104, -0.019756536930799484, -0.03773355856537819, -0.041304174810647964, 0.02068517915904522, -0.006293628830462694, 0.028126806020736694, 0.03156234323978424, 0.08581969887018204, 0.021010873839259148, -0.023483991622924805, 0.022021768614649773, 0.049027685075998306, 0.028773434460163116, 0.06577903032302856, 0.013709116727113724, -0.049463458359241486, 0.01887374371290207, 0.04021289944648743, -0.0495234839618206, 0.03859800100326538, -0.021230824291706085, -0.011818413622677326, 0.04298419877886772, -0.007932622916996479, 0.0075007290579378605, 0.06202185899019241, 0.005570463370531797, 0.0027538526337593794, 0.05146525427699089, -0.03038741648197174, 0.04522634297609329, -0.023212863132357597, -0.027490787208080292, -0.03766470029950142, 0.035561636090278625, -0.030305543914437294, 0.005287273786962032, 0.021220142021775246, 0.060794465243816376, -0.004438197240233421, 0.08633863180875778, 0.02954302541911602, -0.0011757686734199524, 0.019115205854177475, 0.016632556915283203, 0.027103638276457787, 0.01366797462105751, -0.028294960036873817, 0.0023363276850432158, -0.03326427936553955, -0.0796271562576294, 0.029179461300373077, -0.021836545318365097, -0.05795471370220184, -0.005589808337390423, 0.0589464008808136, 0.012418671511113644, -0.07858260720968246, 0.013902089558541775, -0.019998915493488312, -0.017369752749800682, -0.020686618983745575, -0.005136991385370493, -0.028108302503824234, 0.04536856338381767, -0.022456903010606766, -0.018634265288710594, 0.01797438971698284, 0.01684342510998249, -0.046192511916160583, -0.04108856990933418, -0.005636036396026611, 0.027892377227544785, 0.022624259814620018, 0.01117808185517788, 0.07550177723169327, 0.04704930633306503, 0.02154633216559887, -0.009141232818365097, -0.008166629821062088, 0.07971974462270737, 0.03960968554019928, -0.05313465744256973, 0.005748163443058729, -0.00900281686335802, 0.03943849354982376, -0.04821956530213356, -0.01457554567605257, 0.000050928545533679426, -0.010870853438973427, -0.008048462681472301, -0.08237344026565552, -0.014494409784674644, 0.086075559258461, -0.024085015058517456, -0.030784491449594498, -0.021597974002361298, 0.04960717260837555, -0.003852434456348419, 0.009093280881643295, 0.00198124791495502, 0.04727081209421158, 0.01720844767987728, 0.02610754407942295, -0.02558060549199581, -0.016301242634654045, -0.009823713451623917, -0.025983653962612152, -0.007840237580239773, 0.011679720133543015, -0.055897559970617294, 0.12325585633516312, -0.012464969418942928, 0.015336067415773869, 0.05329597741365433, 0.06443749368190765, 0.008940907195210457, -0.06999721378087997, 0.040081094950437546, -0.02337673120200634, 0.017385143786668777, -0.0664871484041214, 0.0627591535449028, 0.0005723178037442267, -0.019924413412809372, -0.08336083590984344, -0.048963915556669235, 0.010268463753163815, 0.011917345225811005, -0.028424808755517006, 0.017645323649048805, -0.008863704279065132, 0.04587017744779587, 0.054345399141311646, -0.011248801834881306, -0.017833299934864044, 0.04344285652041435, -0.0003762642736546695, 0.0946749895811081, -0.060888949781656265, 0.011830968782305717, -0.022197846323251724, -0.031673748046159744, -0.05073271319270134, -0.03279322385787964, 0.017586102709174156, 0.027091559022665024, -0.0759926363825798, 0.05453968048095703, 0.041141752153635025, 0.017360031604766846, -0.04325718805193901, 0.027743680402636528, -0.056467920541763306, -0.041134607046842575, -0.02859250269830227, 0.03639579564332962, 0.044241584837436676, -0.03548474237322807, 0.07470609247684479, -0.005333538632839918, -0.03457466512918472, 0.030798474326729774, -0.04521998018026352, 0.003387944772839546, -0.015088479034602642, 0.0035295323468744755, -0.00747288390994072, -0.017458556219935417, -0.04085691273212433, 0.027031386271119118, -0.014727803878486156, -0.05417284741997719, -0.032221779227256775, 0.036664996296167374, -0.047694504261016846, -0.020445572212338448, -0.010693078860640526, 0.010968193411827087, -0.015976494178175926, 0.006511842366307974, -0.054091040045022964, 0.0359840914607048, 0.06621886789798737, 0.03160720691084862, -0.05287633091211319, -0.015247207134962082, -0.057931434363126755, 0.008352291770279408, 0.022638682276010513, -0.0030687497928738594, 0.01347621064633131, 0.008047159761190414, -0.04785605147480965, -0.04349444806575775, 0.01988886669278145, 0.04110473766922951, -0.035905566066503525, 0.06379522383213043, 0.018774699419736862, 0.04293696582317352, -0.005538174882531166, -0.026401212438941002, 0.018937380984425545, 0.032864827662706375, 0.03382889926433563, -0.007169212214648724, -0.02870151586830616, -0.0891958549618721, -0.015671782195568085, 0.029156068339943886, 0.05284808576107025, -0.05410127341747284, 0.03609483316540718, 0.050075042992830276, 0.07416684180498123, -0.01580297201871872, -0.007620264310389757, -0.010579598136246204, 0.007328353356570005, -0.0015283951070159674, -0.03341959789395332, 0.015075710602104664, 0.02044842764735222, -0.0046984534710645676, -0.026269234716892242, -0.04758310317993164, -0.047528576105833054, 0.006314282771199942, 0.011218279600143433, 0.02959039993584156, -0.005338803865015507, 0.0067953625693917274, -0.01049856934696436, -0.022441441193223, -0.023026321083307266, 0.0286250039935112, -0.00729129696264863, -0.056253183633089066, 0.04249834641814232, 0.020131997764110565, 0.018785720691084862, -0.007185046095401049, -0.07983829826116562, 0.020391052588820457, 0.003232809714972973, 0.01687522791326046, -0.016171682626008987, -0.02357815019786358, 0.0077623105607926846, 0.01417936384677887, -0.06300314515829086, -0.04107746481895447, -0.04889802262187004, -0.013877058401703835, 0.013995316810905933, -0.021392609924077988, 0.03307319059967995, -0.0530165359377861, 0.033617325127124786, -0.07824941724538803, -0.022221989929676056, 0.09048319607973099, 0.0056320056319236755, 0.0014402600936591625, 0.02193494141101837, -0.0047597805969417095, 0.035640131682157516, 0.03541712462902069, -0.012249352410435677, 0.03973260149359703, -0.001582646043971181, 0.0035556363873183727, 0.004978755954653025, 0.05679177865386009, 0.07695610076189041, 0.034908730536699295, -0.030557554215192795, -0.010768118314445019, 0.05617077648639679, 0.07683340460062027, -0.013271711766719818, 0.047867581248283386, 0.009195464663207531, 0.006490219850093126, -0.010151275433599949, 0.03248871490359306, -0.019833596423268318, -0.027003813534975052, 0.03882966563105583, 0.09310469776391983, 0.03819716349244118, -0.036988869309425354, -0.005829833913594484, 0.007982303388416767, -0.013684618286788464, 0.027827290818095207, -0.03390997648239136, -0.037832994014024734, -0.036736391484737396, 0.05085011199116707, 0.045987244695425034, 0.03763485327363014, -0.0472509041428566, 0.017604056745767593, -0.018859252333641052, 0.03437206894159317, 0.016172001138329506, -0.05116875097155571, -0.029622109606862068, 0.03307618945837021, -0.007037954870611429, -0.05487242341041565, 0.011300705373287201, -0.016496317461133003, 0.011735055595636368, -0.007798291742801666, 0.030882202088832855, 0.005391983315348625, -0.011330792680382729, -0.01878301426768303, -0.027357282117009163, -0.011263520456850529, -0.030828312039375305, 0.047677185386419296, -0.04167042672634125, 0.0305190347135067, 0.0224263034760952, -0.0020993174985051155, 0.055559054017066956, -0.011852088384330273, -0.01602417603135109, -0.012024070136249065, -0.0001608220482012257, 0.017444126307964325, -0.020286882296204567, -0.017462994903326035, -0.03369466960430145, 0.08546492457389832, 0.011099743656814098, -0.04003355652093887, -0.05866830423474312, -0.05928172916173935, 0.034431908279657364, -0.06367107480764389, -0.08258461207151413, 0.005506461951881647, 0.019110362976789474, 0.04948917403817177, -0.04507118836045265, -0.05403018742799759, -0.018564285710453987, -0.03859091177582741, 0.020218361169099808, 0.004773375578224659, -0.0284084714949131, -0.00932091660797596, -0.009370170533657074, -0.04011932760477066, -0.010897532105445862, 0.02578977681696415, -0.04875367134809494, -0.032704323530197144, 0.04952666535973549, -0.00308607192710042, -0.007136218249797821, 0.04756925255060196, -0.016565974801778793, -0.016710637137293816, 0.04954558238387108, -0.0039593977853655815, 0.08119019120931625, -0.024060549214482307, 0.02846752293407917, 0.03461884334683418, -0.021437188610434532, -0.033466558903455734, 0.05512307211756706, 0.022322991862893105, 0.011501696892082691, -0.03154274448752403, -0.008262990973889828, 0.042212046682834625, -0.02228621020913124, 0.012683749198913574, -0.023410357534885406, 0.02236081287264824, -0.0023165184538811445, -0.04881569370627403, 0.00019983339007012546, -0.009562603197991848, -0.039101555943489075, 0.027876999229192734, 0.0028058337047696114, -0.0032905815169215202, -0.051686324179172516, 0.03192153200507164, 0.010025755502283573, 0.00025015161372721195, -0.004289551638066769, -0.047675494104623795, -0.004886087961494923, -0.0002754011657088995, 0.08797771483659744, -0.03584932163357735, -0.03997676074504852, -0.009491072036325932, 0.08046655356884003, 0.014804291538894176, -0.03285598382353783, 0.0027087987400591373, -0.07740726321935654, 0.050811536610126495, 0.02108900621533394, -0.017094049602746964, -0.007676827721297741, 0.07052043825387955, -0.0360201932489872, -0.04770602658390999, -0.07822899520397186, 0.00811116024851799, -0.008785790763795376, -0.0026125868316739798, 0.0006881405715830624, -0.04405905678868294, 0.04822661355137825, -0.02549697272479534, 0.0004755092377308756, 0.014964555390179157, 0.013635307550430298, -0.014106658287346363, -0.006538716610521078, 0.015042543411254883, 0.07874610275030136, 0.006826414726674557, -0.0232635997235775, 0.0003646276891231537, -0.06008376181125641, 0.021797021850943565, 0.05214804410934448, 0.02493991144001484, -0.045305799692869186, -0.002170166000723839, -0.032679323107004166, -0.0007196145597845316, 0.03701841086149216, -0.023483648896217346, -0.00389622594229877, -0.029976431280374527, 0.022044332697987556, -0.00483052060008049, -0.06010429933667183, 0.01776840165257454, 0.06965038925409317, -0.0699113979935646, -0.005867649335414171, 0.031295645982027054, -0.036976687610149384, -0.0401788130402565, -0.05142659693956375, 0.03483707830309868, -0.018001755699515343, 0.05471530556678772, 0.055353131145238876, 0.006111466325819492, 0.05881858244538307, 0.020549554377794266, 0.07821843773126602, 0.06608937680721283, 0.018153807148337364, -0.039931170642375946, 0.03746499866247177, 0.021949680522084236, 0.05946271866559982, -0.0440853051841259, 0.021987371146678925, 0.0021499283611774445, 0.01241244561970234, 0.0003322803822811693, 0.016789885237812996, -0.032899875193834305, 0.030993469059467316, 0.028254467993974686, -0.08211854100227356, -0.028177857398986816, -0.011133288033306599, 0.017141932621598244, -0.051847562193870544, -0.011370516382157803, -0.0681292787194252, 0.03299974277615547, -0.031397946178913116, -0.03240719065070152, -0.0230037122964859, 0.020235145464539528, -0.03340870514512062, 0.03393203765153885, -0.030946867540478706, 0.0056004212237894535, 0.028104016557335854, -0.01848779432475567, -0.04329521954059601, 0.045910295099020004, 0.010601815767586231, 0.034672919660806656, 0.03889349102973938, 0.023536812514066696, -0.0012750758323818445, -0.03817468509078026, -0.03094724752008915, -0.003226829692721367, -0.05390544235706329, -0.0510842464864254, -0.028233889490365982, -0.0009708264842629433, -0.027932722121477127, -0.0010320879518985748, -0.02230466529726982, 0.008720282465219498, 0.06616348773241043, 0.027556393295526505, -0.04032744839787483, 0.02873343601822853, 0.024730408564209938, -0.03958553448319435, -0.0462728813290596, -0.003597827162593603, -0.013339605182409286, 0.043738242238759995, -0.04612249135971069, -0.030803583562374115, 0.08737220615148544, -0.08986850082874298, 0.01480946410447359, 0.0425315722823143, -0.03000950627028942, -0.0017192013328894973, 0.01473939511924982, -0.01774049922823906, -0.03623928502202034, 0.05224263668060303, 0.005763613153249025, -0.0669550970196724, -0.008449159562587738, 0.05279716104269028, -0.013352504000067711, 0.0986272469162941, 0.008344093337655067, -0.0005685932119376957, -0.041544344276189804, -0.0504499152302742, -0.0005576133844442666, 0.027958311140537262, -0.03512389212846756, -0.05182930454611778, -0.003829838475212455, 0.024437960237264633, -0.03934560716152191, 0.0058102053590118885, -0.015534219332039356, -0.015675533562898636, -0.0634453222155571, -0.007409983780235052, 0.009548565372824669, -0.03033147007226944, 0.02713608182966709, -0.008270314894616604, -0.013838411308825016, -0.005173246841877699, 0.025745216757059097, -0.026965290307998657, 0.003361846785992384, 0.028434615582227707, -0.06810422986745834, -0.01028088666498661, 0.034684330224990845, -0.034308988600969315, 0.08420261740684509, 0.009042595513164997, 0.012156250886619091, 0.018577905371785164, 0.04823083057999611, 0.042442794889211655, -0.06508883833885193, -0.04727207124233246, -0.04115453362464905, 0.019451959058642387, -0.008975978009402752, -0.04246026277542114, -0.004920002538710833, 0.016951292753219604, 0.004635486286133528, 0.008651486597955227, 0.027361663058400154, -0.04473390057682991, 0.03826899453997612, 0.06459131836891174, -0.017452755942940712, 0.043542686849832535, 0.025956790894269943, -0.003501012921333313, 0.009788074530661106, -0.043802667409181595, -0.010948914103209972, -0.016384603455662727, 0.0013766620540991426, -0.03957216069102287, -0.06718147546052933, -0.01323101855814457, 0.049055855721235275, 0.022714318707585335, -0.019099196419119835, 0.05396803840994835, -0.03483762592077255, -0.0027412837371230125, -0.04016276076436043, 0.020691171288490295, -0.028789479285478592, -0.013807964511215687, -0.018212521448731422, 0.02877996489405632, -0.025877319276332855, -0.032734256237745285, -0.003483876818791032, -0.07272253930568695, 0.0036682726349681616, 0.018167957663536072, 0.009349205531179905, -0.041758667677640915, -0.014483521692454815, -0.055033572018146515, -0.0855216532945633, 0.045305199921131134 ]
<p>Could I ionize a gas using an electron gun and knock off electrons in the gas to make plasma?</p>
g9814
[ 0.002201923867687583, -0.00004421553967404179, 0.004448420368134975, 0.0021684025414288044, 0.026774922385811806, 0.009372282773256302, -0.10955197364091873, 0.044240716844797134, -0.02548745460808277, 0.015913965180516243, 0.044672220945358276, 0.027992425486445427, -0.022705134004354477, 0.011427436023950577, -0.0002441079413983971, -0.02509940229356289, 0.1155654564499855, 0.01671411655843258, -0.014604237861931324, 0.04958952218294144, 0.010538918897509575, -0.09478246420621872, -0.007914021611213684, -0.10250268876552582, 0.0051324269734323025, -0.02214386872947216, 0.016709841787815094, 0.005883996374905109, -0.026845891028642654, -0.03761281445622444, -0.024233395233750343, 0.04334048926830292, -0.04638310521841049, -0.01253749243915081, -0.07343143969774246, -0.05882031098008156, 0.053693436086177826, 0.019608264788985252, 0.009830513969063759, -0.07251972705125809, -0.019915280863642693, -0.008668114431202412, 0.048422399908304214, 0.02013218216598034, 0.035213299095630646, 0.03418136015534401, 0.07682373374700546, -0.014824742451310158, 0.02470448799431324, -0.06818244606256485, -0.05781116709113121, 0.02524517849087715, -0.03341792896389961, -0.09667894244194031, -0.017413407564163208, 0.011998502537608147, -0.061009522527456284, 0.024431319907307625, 0.08633774518966675, 0.008542756550014019, 0.041593652218580246, -0.015526700764894485, -0.010299639776349068, -0.028357326984405518, -0.028845107182860374, -0.04911597818136215, -0.04186847060918808, 0.006008075550198555, -0.0017800724599510431, 0.026810942217707634, 0.019209830090403557, -0.025263875722885132, -0.021092848852276802, -0.049637891352176666, 0.0676446184515953, 0.07142630964517593, -0.008468428626656532, -0.00423364108428359, 0.037864286452531815, 0.01824500784277916, -0.01809392124414444, -0.02490043267607689, -0.034378781914711, -0.039829038083553314, -0.018298275768756866, -0.06495542824268341, -0.007154965773224831, -0.01982560008764267, -0.0010075249010697007, -0.03820621967315674, -0.021082168444991112, -0.0441487580537796, 0.019068626686930656, 0.007783503737300634, 0.0012510349042713642, 0.01992027461528778, -0.03874744847416878, 0.04233570024371147, 0.03320423141121864, 0.018002625554800034, -0.031287334859371185, -0.06074676662683487, 0.010605943389236927, -0.06466314941644669, -0.030773935839533806, -0.042873505502939224, -0.021141648292541504, -0.04756873846054077, 0.018252970650792122, -0.025009799748659134, 0.016173720359802246, -0.07884806394577026, -0.035622790455818176, -0.005405783653259277, -0.016311507672071457, 0.027237504720687866, 0.015304061584174633, -0.013809413649141788, -0.018488744273781776, 0.05922951549291611, 0.07518527656793594, 0.017487194389104843, -0.019209330901503563, -0.01791509985923767, -0.007856911048293114, -0.03887225314974785, 0.01675589010119438, -0.002395258517935872, 0.0390600860118866, -0.014972771517932415, -0.02991834096610546, 0.008743658661842346, -0.011065451428294182, 0.007637030445039272, 0.03044864721596241, 0.011754502542316914, 0.048120904713869095, 0.01457252912223339, -0.014405612833797932, -0.035007789731025696, 0.035823795944452286, 0.03149024024605751, -0.028065558522939682, 0.033776938915252686, -0.01809205301105976, 0.01443588174879551, -0.04001375660300255, 0.012680962681770325, 0.04987470060586929, 0.006976846605539322, -0.009632856585085392, -0.016474945470690727, 0.03016361966729164, -0.018191905692219734, 0.07730472832918167, -0.027471840381622314, 0.06491450220346451, 0.05544279143214226, 0.019811926409602165, -0.08346087485551834, -0.006974651478230953, -0.01538090780377388, 0.0035864789970219135, -0.018683675676584244, 0.033249713480472565, -0.010894037783145905, 0.03958689421415329, -0.0016093942103907466, 0.05079631134867668, 0.04152519628405571, -0.08551167696714401, 0.033087681978940964, -0.01790020614862442, 0.0044908723793923855, 0.018155548721551895, 0.0287533737719059, -0.035973455756902695, -0.009771998971700668, 0.02389667183160782, -0.043564748018980026, 0.07128619402647018, -0.007344382815063, -0.043712273240089417, 0.01310883741825819, 0.02068367414176464, 0.07122550159692764, -0.03822842240333557, 0.012934407219290733, -0.00993647426366806, 0.010912568308413029, 0.007277936674654484, 0.057833198457956314, 0.011335870251059532, -0.01161553617566824, 0.04141487926244736, 0.01167859137058258, -0.022378481924533844, 0.007842322811484337, -0.012400388717651367, 0.02177589014172554, -0.05607301741838455, 0.07887837290763855, -0.031096626073122025, 0.009846305474638939, 0.019811643287539482, -0.027225280180573463, -0.035035304725170135, -0.037776973098516464, -0.007458408363163471, -0.005625430028885603, 0.04698048532009125, 0.0008536605746485293, 0.031085800379514694, 0.06087762117385864, 0.0351739376783371, 0.023454591631889343, 0.004187224432826042, 0.041795920580625534, -0.03873628005385399, 0.024366602301597595, -0.021611744537949562, 0.030365444719791412, -0.0021356467623263597, 0.05039932578802109, 0.01103214081376791, -0.0007304212776944041, 0.051213208585977554, 0.015082755126059055, -0.02325569838285446, -0.057570695877075195, 0.03978319838643074, 0.030758367851376534, -0.025392986834049225, -0.09765590727329254, 0.008895419538021088, 0.024678843095898628, 0.018769396468997, -0.04296129196882248, -0.03353340923786163, 0.010335625149309635, -0.004469858482480049, -0.06748152524232864, 0.025078454986214638, -0.009961660951375961, 0.02122933231294155, -0.019035691395401955, -0.014221632853150368, 0.001590070896781981, -0.024258630350232124, -0.02063104324042797, -0.025734301656484604, -0.0019033298594877124, -0.07399921119213104, 0.02035972662270069, -0.041537635028362274, -0.050328727811574936, 0.01197548396885395, 0.04229620844125748, -0.027923237532377243, -0.0007943825330585241, -0.01521984115242958, 0.03600311651825905, -0.03770662844181061, 0.013422991149127483, -0.09536728262901306, -0.0022105895914137363, 0.03798992559313774, -0.015132596716284752, 0.05416174605488777, 0.0035367829259485006, 0.015863541513681412, 0.01239369623363018, -0.03352775424718857, 0.0874936580657959, 0.010596662759780884, 0.028531266376376152, 0.04145964980125427, 0.018067890778183937, 0.046403586864471436, -0.07855132967233658, -0.013628204353153706, 0.040918637067079544, -0.019037671387195587, 0.06242772936820984, 0.006414216477423906, 0.0003087418735958636, -0.014733705669641495, -0.0020335137378424406, 0.006618301384150982, 0.0426776222884655, -0.07713114470243454, 0.02268492430448532, 0.008575192652642727, -0.002683090977370739, -0.02857881225645542, -0.0014291411498561502, -0.020317960530519485, -0.012787056155502796, 0.0156332366168499, 0.00977836549282074, -0.05385557934641838, -0.07951610535383224, -0.03482547029852867, 0.025691429153084755, -0.002013801597058773, -0.065294049680233, -0.005796744488179684, 0.049170754849910736, 0.0021540801972150803, -0.013132010586559772, 0.009948082268238068, 0.0028220831882208586, -0.03654709830880165, 0.018061205744743347, -0.025959275662899017, -0.02468305267393589, 0.0453561395406723, -0.06479445844888687, -0.01683070883154869, 0.031381577253341675, -0.02060619555413723, -0.04171151667833328, 0.019355187192559242, -0.009577770717442036, 0.031506720930337906, 0.032050684094429016, 0.039803482592105865, -0.06481138616800308, 0.04963391274213791, 0.049401942640542984, 0.01483419444411993, 0.0354054793715477, 0.021014224737882614, -0.006639124359935522, 0.01803133450448513, -0.02404800057411194, 0.03634946048259735, 0.11726309359073639, -0.014635983854532242, -0.03254722058773041, -0.01423152256757021, -0.004075885284692049, -0.00253276783041656, -0.014153772033751011, -0.02868100255727768, 0.017386509105563164, 0.02250916138291359, -0.0033028367906808853, -0.011609334498643875, -0.028175707906484604, 0.03606269508600235, 0.008868998847901821, 0.021892182528972626, 0.008236662484705448, 0.040368251502513885, -0.059166260063648224, 0.02813834138214588, 0.06405052542686462, 0.01853158511221409, 0.01451926026493311, -0.0014381479704752564, -0.011204983107745647, 0.007597446907311678, 0.01706300675868988, -0.04792271554470062, 0.019684255123138428, -0.04217016324400902, 0.03068418800830841, -0.030478155240416527, -0.020041875541210175, -0.07154791802167892, -0.01655709557235241, 0.057297199964523315, 0.04110420495271683, -0.027182353660464287, 0.024191580712795258, 0.008433908224105835, 0.06255321204662323, -0.011621654964983463, -0.018378330394625664, -0.032435089349746704, -0.02395443618297577, 0.028874000534415245, 0.036934807896614075, 0.011308527551591396, 0.006737619172781706, 0.03681577742099762, 0.05081019178032875, 0.0040425509214401245, -0.06471318006515503, 0.013667170889675617, -0.03061685897409916, -0.055370088666677475, -0.0017694567795842886, 0.02100737951695919, 0.006006177514791489, 0.000891884439624846, -0.08954030275344849, -0.020239846780896187, 0.004021300934255123, 0.020609362050890923, 0.06262072175741196, 0.022810788825154305, -0.006963391322642565, 0.04129534587264061, 0.002493565436452627, 0.044010672718286514, 0.023809758946299553, 0.03727567195892334, -0.022819193080067635, 0.018846644088625908, 0.010910429060459137, 0.009420321322977543, -0.0014887576689943671, -0.056871287524700165, -0.0021809109020978212, -0.0038080215454101562, 0.06139807403087616, -0.026958605274558067, -0.03200751170516014, 0.05065377429127693, 0.035487230867147446, 0.05490105226635933, 0.040217138826847076, -0.04059412330389023, 0.025730358436703682, 0.021170083433389664, -0.04345415160059929, 0.01756824180483818, -0.009478127583861351, 0.020868228748440742, -0.033304162323474884, 0.0057390532456338406, -0.015761982649564743, -0.033931437879800797, -0.019616208970546722, -0.0853366032242775, -0.02224957011640072, -0.002816523425281048, 0.07698420435190201, 0.042820680886507034, -0.012134789489209652, 0.038285993039608, 0.004589333664625883, 0.04936874657869339, 0.01972591131925583, -0.034433893859386444, -0.012791791930794716, -0.009799720719456673, 0.028553754091262817, 0.00648052804172039, -0.08524228632450104, -0.036776360124349594, -0.03533349186182022, 0.019210446625947952, 0.025382502004504204, -0.053886592388153076, -0.018553409725427628, -0.020725712180137634, 0.03130044415593147, -0.007529111113399267, 0.027250239625573158, 0.07363437861204147, 0.055650465190410614, 0.03364398702979088, -0.02132730931043625, -0.044736478477716446, -0.0057168337516486645, -0.019110072404146194, -0.051233068108558655, -0.03046395815908909, -0.0120627973228693, 0.003508796915411949, 0.0337555930018425, 0.021801674738526344, -0.04092588648200035, -0.008574029430747032, -0.05077357590198517, -0.04308655858039856, -0.030511822551488876, -0.010606379248201847, -0.014211125671863556, -0.016359074041247368, 0.0006719125667586923, -0.05127747356891632, -0.007306107319891453, -0.04548941180109978, 0.03712968900799751, 0.049331266433000565, -0.06362605094909668, 0.00814697053283453, 0.07434304803609848, 0.04334786534309387, -0.018908021971583366, 0.027621589601039886, 0.03985626623034477, 0.002768805483356118, -0.03197396174073219, 0.009416535496711731, 0.030662138015031815, -0.03937170282006264, -0.03393267095088959, -0.054536983370780945, -0.011087512597441673, -0.006853229831904173, -0.008948351256549358, -0.029133524745702744, 0.005294779781252146, -0.006305665709078312, 0.02423875965178013, -0.017174886539578438, -0.03376295790076256, 0.022855490446090698, -0.020555276423692703, 0.002945918356999755, 0.019673792645335197, -0.03789800405502319, -0.02740301564335823, -0.010991296730935574, -0.06548881530761719, 0.06585118919610977, -0.06411248445510864, 0.017701366916298866, 0.014500903896987438, -0.023595014587044716, -0.03603062033653259, 0.02886253595352173, -0.020736871287226677, 0.05951346457004547, 0.029373880475759506, 0.05342869460582733, -0.014336667023599148, -0.015772918239235878, -0.019475940614938736, -0.05887444317340851, -0.027101358398795128, -0.0011818192433565855, 0.053285568952560425, 0.005458098370581865, -0.05079043656587601, 0.06053847447037697, -0.024029800668358803, 0.01890869252383709, 0.037648558616638184, 0.008334268815815449, 0.031779419630765915, -0.060109030455350876, 0.0582769475877285, 0.03852198272943497, -0.052189890295267105, -0.009108169004321098, -0.01707928441464901, 0.037698742002248764, -0.07288342714309692, 0.02731190249323845, 0.012235098518431187, 0.013971342705190182, 0.026278166100382805, 0.024521201848983765, -0.03579072281718254, 0.05501274764537811, 0.035088732838630676, 0.007648400031030178, 0.00931569840759039, -0.00890160072594881, -0.02578207291662693, -0.05478508025407791, -0.015913937240839005, 0.03519696369767189, -0.014993695542216301, -0.005079528316855431, 0.027926772832870483, -0.05147871375083923, -0.03214506804943085, -0.004333004355430603, -0.04514878988265991, 0.07980360835790634, 0.05851593241095543, -0.008410121314227581, -0.004052505362778902, 0.031397849321365356, 0.01902070827782154, -0.013434766791760921, 0.05020548403263092, -0.008248119615018368, -0.02252252958714962, -0.002342921681702137, 0.07955969125032425, -0.005742622073739767, -0.0011353571899235249, 0.02148517034947872, -0.054035212844610214, -0.011632120236754417, -0.011920169927179813, -0.04490756243467331, -0.004597638733685017, -0.05531859025359154, -0.04496332257986069, 0.008385413326323032, 0.010767554864287376, 0.04845239222049713, 0.05529802292585373, -0.08835469186306, 0.01067348662763834, -0.005214845295995474, 0.06801196187734604, 0.005930817220360041, 0.06566814333200455, -0.020724685862660408, -0.004458851646631956, -0.07629203796386719, 0.02880045771598816, 0.0038770136889070272, -0.03401239216327667, 0.014472376555204391, 0.04986688494682312, 0.007487159222364426, 0.02119084633886814, 0.058343298733234406, 0.056683044880628586, 0.013447027653455734, -0.01890200562775135, -0.015552990138530731, -0.05157390981912613, 0.04809052497148514, 0.02254733070731163, -0.005417135078459978, 0.013451970182359219, 0.046425189822912216, -0.037474822252988815, -0.015545422211289406, -0.012489864602684975, -0.0018478990532457829, 0.0019359340658411384, -0.004869076889008284, 0.014880967326462269, 0.05539604276418686, 0.0036847181618213654, 0.01322671677917242, 0.013566249050199986, 0.006060869432985783, 0.0022728051990270615, 0.04330102354288101, 0.029770273715257645, -0.019328411668539047, 0.038213763386011124, 0.014173613861203194, -0.06265588104724884, -0.04965934529900551, 0.015161102637648582, -0.04498870298266411, -0.03830832242965698, -0.02048623561859131, -0.0026710338424891233, 0.0027784041594713926, 0.004020568914711475, -0.008523981086909771, 0.040561024099588394, 0.032055385410785675, -0.032899558544158936, -0.043315593153238297, -0.015462787821888924, 0.04452495276927948, -0.029797764495015144, 0.043733272701501846, -0.021612321957945824, -0.06965699046850204, -0.022686460986733437, 0.006973730865865946, -0.03365321829915047, -0.015857838094234467, -0.053919531404972076, -0.03283318132162094, 0.04377596080303192, 0.06472427397966385, 0.00760498084127903, -0.005247298628091812, 0.03606386482715607, 0.008179261349141598, 0.004277977626770735, -0.047466568648815155, 0.023552246391773224, -0.0003953878185711801, -0.01427892129868269, -0.02958020009100437, -0.07005440443754196, 0.05769367888569832, 0.06411553919315338, -0.0033191698603332043, -0.018198145553469658, 0.02840222418308258, 0.009242991916835308, 0.015181747265160084, 0.0025110640563070774, 0.017890768125653267, -0.03876030817627907, -0.02076723240315914, -0.013909739442169666, -0.029250148683786392, -0.011538651771843433, -0.02549932524561882, 0.07356821745634079, 0.0318087600171566, -0.02617570385336876, -0.021169906482100487, 0.06781350076198578, 0.030830975621938705, 0.029369017109274864, -0.021340209990739822, -0.04603411629796028, 0.02687603421509266, -0.0015019528800621629, 0.0018084637122228742, 0.040080808103084564, 0.038745373487472534, -0.050639279186725616, 0.05153944343328476, 0.04962942749261856, 0.0626884251832962, 0.012251140549778938, -0.020964888855814934, 0.028869807720184326, 0.057646363973617554, 0.03067135438323021, -0.015155213885009289, -0.0008218915318138897, 0.044241275638341904, 0.00686881598085165, 0.008940252475440502, -0.04322728142142296, -0.036631111055612564, 0.016525015234947205, -0.00020492110343184322, 0.005000681150704622, 0.04578261449933052, 0.0013347417116165161, -0.022484589368104935, -0.07704661041498184, 0.06517840176820755, 0.01907566748559475, -0.011205418035387993, 0.008019253611564636, -0.029652630910277367, -0.0018684737151488662, 0.037290699779987335, 0.0070090037770569324, -0.029112957417964935, 0.011928251013159752, 0.02733340859413147, 0.03711014240980148, 0.04354049637913704, -0.06117758899927139, 0.0005584409227594733, 0.0028587987180799246, 0.02035566233098507, -0.022669559344649315, -0.06658922135829926, 0.022644853219389915, 0.0341433510184288, 0.02020111121237278, -0.020999813452363014, 0.024137265980243683, 0.027005411684513092, -0.021245602518320084, -0.04611148685216904, -0.06354118883609772, -0.0029737676959484816, -0.042025234550237656 ]
<p>In QM, the state vector $|\psi\rangle$ seem to have various dimensions under different representations: (only in space of continuous dimension)</p> <p>$$\langle x|\psi\rangle = [\frac{1}{\sqrt{Length}}]$$ $$\langle p|\psi\rangle = [\sqrt\frac{time}{{Mass Length}}]$$ etc, and $|\psi\rangle$ can equal to $|x'\rangle$ or $|p'\rangle$ in special cases (System in an eigenstate of a certain observable), therefore </p> <p>$$\langle x|\psi\rangle = \langle x|x'\rangle = [\frac{1}{L}]$$</p> <p>So what is the physical dimension of $|\psi\rangle$? Is this a valid question?</p>
g9815
[ 0.02963496372103691, 0.034663666039705276, -0.002417951822280884, -0.06933784484863281, 0.03386758640408516, 0.036398276686668396, -0.02620065212249756, -0.027115361765027046, -0.06425295770168304, 0.009328422136604786, 0.049030501395463943, -0.0321231484413147, -0.011694654822349548, -0.0016614618944004178, -0.020554861053824425, -0.057321060448884964, 0.095978282392025, -0.018248217180371284, -0.042864035815000534, -0.03627853840589523, -0.020128250122070312, -0.037310048937797546, 0.007810082286596298, -0.048061735928058624, 0.024601124227046967, -0.0054732817225158215, 0.08852576464414597, -0.014900214038789272, -0.04901525005698204, -0.005327010527253151, 0.00552657525986433, -0.006163510028272867, -0.0029804250225424767, -0.030073916539549828, -0.012509217485785484, -0.00870627909898758, 0.04072704538702965, 0.053944170475006104, 0.07560163736343384, -0.02856520377099514, 0.01910977065563202, -0.06078016385436058, 0.010439537465572357, -0.027426008135080338, 0.010552802123129368, 0.05683629959821701, -0.017401859164237976, 0.03414648026227951, -0.04744206741452217, 0.04848584160208702, 0.006464431528002024, 0.02773631177842617, 0.034295909106731415, 0.005013125482946634, 0.029307285323739052, -0.01217363029718399, 0.020353328436613083, 0.002825019648298621, 0.01093713752925396, 0.03111218474805355, 0.013638666830956936, -0.006162972655147314, -0.010362365283071995, 0.046124689280986786, 0.047147370874881744, -0.022785022854804993, -0.03126738220453262, 0.00522215012460947, -0.015421331860125065, 0.014687084592878819, -0.002484517637640238, -0.029930591583251953, -0.013218446634709835, 0.026538966223597527, -0.012331562116742134, 0.018762588500976562, -0.004675355274230242, 0.0241598729044199, -0.03360866382718086, 0.04227595031261444, -0.05699363723397255, -0.0023296840954571962, 0.045312099158763885, -0.04844564571976662, 0.050483137369155884, 0.03214814513921738, -0.036578789353370667, 0.018613846972584724, -0.014578788541257381, 0.03841597959399223, -0.0029855677857995033, -0.013519283384084702, 0.10876326262950897, 0.10941902548074722, -0.039105433970689774, -0.05353239178657532, 0.005773700773715973, 0.025494616478681564, 0.00005290248373057693, 0.061791833490133286, -0.023452885448932648, 0.058190587908029556, 0.04290353134274483, -0.05240832641720772, 0.03437227010726929, 0.009842139668762684, -0.024241089820861816, -0.03410680592060089, 0.004619129002094269, -0.023370565846562386, -0.03261294215917587, -0.006464269943535328, -0.0649329423904419, 0.01357556227594614, -0.05724215507507324, -0.006330398842692375, 0.056320007890462875, -0.08479585498571396, -0.027669742703437805, 0.0552881583571434, 0.08331712335348129, -0.008539661765098572, 0.07955390959978104, 0.018976980820298195, 0.008356812410056591, 0.010418632999062538, 0.031861819326877594, 0.03704337775707245, 0.016716530546545982, -0.007579493336379528, -0.02404487319290638, 0.025701826438307762, -0.05701485276222229, -0.052157849073410034, 0.005894471891224384, -0.009683463722467422, -0.003985756542533636, 0.0016699092229828238, 0.0024605100043118, 0.06765991449356079, -0.0041579813696444035, -0.055165667086839676, -0.021849460899829865, -0.010004677809774876, -0.005209920462220907, -0.023150481283664703, 0.013512208126485348, -0.05948692187666893, 0.0192475076764822, -0.02900519222021103, -0.014692997559905052, 0.10017261654138565, -0.028214214369654655, -0.04488048702478409, 0.03849276900291443, 0.039387185126543045, -0.014132955111563206, 0.0035744921769946814, -0.002467621583491564, -0.008538946509361267, -0.02096843719482422, 0.03459591045975685, 0.040584757924079895, 0.035564813762903214, -0.04126911982893944, -0.029417390003800392, 0.019020551815629005, -0.058229006826877594, -0.030049430206418037, -0.07511381059885025, 0.014119206927716732, 0.0039926436729729176, 0.019763199612498283, 0.01780666597187519, -0.011242367327213287, -0.008461756631731987, -0.04735979437828064, -0.031207095831632614, 0.030422253534197807, -0.05324394628405571, -0.022853489965200424, 0.018448149785399437, 0.009160389192402363, -0.045319173485040665, -0.018411854282021523, -0.015939803794026375, -0.017660532146692276, 0.019575441256165504, -0.02544666826725006, -0.030983630567789078, -0.05117262154817581, 0.017416315153241158, 0.007857903838157654, 0.04388587549328804, -0.009497747756540775, -0.02527390979230404, 0.017670385539531708, -0.02858053520321846, -0.032216545194387436, 0.004825753625482321, 0.03587617352604866, 0.02380816638469696, 0.04939403012394905, 0.004561380948871374, 0.042504556477069855, 0.0205901637673378, 0.006675856653600931, 0.005826917476952076, -0.010416666977107525, 0.026256771758198738, 0.07289610058069229, -0.03456655889749527, -0.009264903143048286, 0.02813960239291191, -0.02907676436007023, 0.008455505594611168, 0.05370700731873512, -0.0038682539016008377, 0.02166077308356762, 0.017635056748986244, -0.02951744571328163, -0.038830213248729706, 0.020585479214787483, -0.0019798928406089544, -0.008501669391989708, -0.009984404779970646, -0.07377200573682785, 0.013436115346848965, -0.011347109451889992, 0.040144193917512894, -0.056685976684093475, 0.012319444678723812, 0.03433704003691673, 0.011949875392019749, -0.009469599463045597, 0.03815412148833275, -0.024575786665081978, -0.024813586845993996, 0.02567950077354908, -0.013108287006616592, 0.04827819764614105, -0.029288185760378838, -0.003048837650567293, 0.0358390174806118, 0.022021474316716194, 0.034291140735149384, 0.013585265725851059, -0.008579022251069546, -0.028574857860803604, 0.05276865512132645, -0.06925638020038605, -0.004692454356700182, 0.02424568310379982, 0.018563224002718925, -0.007287696935236454, -0.02700403518974781, 0.0040742638520896435, 0.0032588981557637453, -0.043137237429618835, -0.03939162939786911, -0.05378323793411255, -0.021875785663723946, -0.039310794323682785, 0.06422922760248184, -0.03625492751598358, 0.0378149189054966, 0.010455592535436153, 0.08532168716192245, -0.02187272347509861, 0.01895139552652836, 0.007619730196893215, 0.07355169206857681, 0.028828904032707214, -0.009545891545712948, 0.009309960529208183, -0.041762806475162506, -0.019988873973488808, -0.06530100852251053, 0.013926355168223381, -0.07126561552286148, -0.02519034966826439, 0.026214608922600746, -0.038907479494810104, 0.05136988312005997, 0.04240866005420685, -0.06173325702548027, 0.006192308384925127, 0.021967990323901176, -0.040536656975746155, 0.0061966837383806705, -0.049585919827222824, -0.004117827862501144, -0.0012307773577049375, 0.010732621885836124, -0.03804575279355049, 0.06333262473344803, -0.010401364415884018, -0.08847661316394806, 0.021599510684609413, 0.03692714869976044, -0.0028700591064989567, -0.01778912916779518, -0.014289768412709236, -0.007616809569299221, 0.009056365117430687, 0.025217005982995033, -0.04549480602145195, -0.0009681100491434336, -0.03631836920976639, 0.005745410453528166, -0.028178861364722252, 0.0488145612180233, -0.014984196983277798, -0.0035473641473799944, -0.10914645344018936, -0.003984764218330383, -0.055831532925367355, -0.012012778781354427, -0.052665553987026215, 0.0018859555711969733, -0.005826223641633987, -0.07297507673501968, 0.058766815811395645, -0.010995046235620975, 0.013751406222581863, 0.006633609998971224, -0.0256951916962862, -0.0036585277412086725, -0.006891726981848478, 0.018736744299530983, 0.008705266751348972, -0.02638176828622818, 0.01415866520255804, -0.01579316519200802, -0.05170312523841858, 0.0031801387667655945, -0.0680016577243805, -0.01860996149480343, 0.02424905262887478, -0.001005094381980598, -0.015393161214888096, -0.025356199592351913, 0.005674015264958143, -0.0020340364426374435, -0.010785757564008236, 0.011022101156413555, -0.053003355860710144, 0.027511708438396454, 0.043217774480581284, -0.033233270049095154, -0.039134345948696136, 0.0441465750336647, 0.015184139832854271, -0.014008812606334686, 0.026364777237176895, 0.03185979276895523, 0.0271261278539896, 0.01867448352277279, 0.01862209104001522, -0.03617788106203079, 0.042017802596092224, -0.051540639251470566, -0.006149397697299719, -0.05408064275979996, -0.038588039577007294, 0.04228364676237106, 0.047029148787260056, 0.023961257189512253, 0.027986884117126465, 0.02878345176577568, 0.013726845383644104, 0.00802971888333559, -0.0365772545337677, -0.007061715237796307, 0.04864182323217392, -0.03774743527173996, -0.07427143305540085, -0.10255738347768784, -0.026453983038663864, 0.002520979382097721, -0.009471015073359013, 0.020063741132616997, 0.012667988426983356, -0.0032067508436739445, 0.012144802138209343, -0.0008093147771432996, -0.008551851846277714, 0.024872340261936188, -0.002650939393788576, -0.03006136231124401, 0.005630979314446449, -0.05428463593125343, -0.05179999768733978, 0.024240266531705856, 0.0206938236951828, 0.04406394064426422, 0.04387331008911133, -0.026589015498757362, -0.09815263003110886, 0.02933693490922451, 0.005052722990512848, -0.04238143190741539, 0.02328854613006115, 0.020395081490278244, 0.0024944995529949665, 0.010966368950903416, 0.03748328238725662, -0.023853614926338196, 0.016097696498036385, -0.019098902121186256, -0.03470996767282486, -0.01436682604253292, 0.012797453440725803, -0.06111161410808563, -0.006775691173970699, 0.02530410885810852, -0.0400521419942379, -0.0018388470634818077, -0.012457304634153843, 0.005558634176850319, 0.03474991396069527, -0.012563975527882576, 0.0034634601324796677, 0.03142924606800079, 0.06057101860642433, 0.02870888262987137, 0.05649761110544205, 0.022253505885601044, -0.05795155093073845, -0.012552878819406033, 0.0038125456776469946, -0.02678660675883293, 0.02829827181994915, 0.027340389788150787, -0.05821818485856056, -0.007655953988432884, -0.057835426181554794, -0.005653956905007362, -0.022304309532046318, 0.012250619009137154, 0.022952653467655182, -0.027383994311094284, -0.006620512809604406, -0.005610644351691008, -0.016368981450796127, -0.023184414952993393, 0.002773775951936841, -0.03414665162563324, -0.07272250950336456, -0.021362662315368652, 0.005567219108343124, 0.01695719175040722, -0.06621568650007248, -0.07380461692810059, 0.03492617607116699, -0.02230694331228733, -0.03920440748333931, 0.01493836659938097, 0.06882426142692566, -0.0015861964784562588, -0.044186949729919434, 0.009982945397496223, -0.03528669849038124, -0.03452875465154648, -0.03005582094192505, -0.020587364211678505, -0.08251025527715683, 0.05047837272286415, -0.057027366012334824, -0.008522831834852695, 0.055964406579732895, -0.04060160368680954, 0.0076796854846179485, -0.03674684464931488, 0.023234108462929726, -0.018363649025559425, -0.041360486298799515, -0.03367277607321739, -0.001200195518322289, -0.03362134099006653, 0.020839527249336243, -0.025303814560174942, 0.022751010954380035, 0.04572230577468872, 0.04675456881523132, 0.026595985516905785, 0.012106484733521938, -0.052828606218099594, -0.03258400037884712, 0.006955750752240419, 0.0390607975423336, 0.07225579023361206, 0.02229088917374611, 0.05528532713651657, 0.006771351210772991, 0.0005521286511793733, -0.016032278537750244, -0.0659608468413353, -0.02968135103583336, 0.05337633192539215, 0.022531261667609215, 0.04059223830699921, 0.06587012112140656, -0.011333528906106949, 0.003015676513314247, 0.009776529856026173, 0.0652654767036438, 0.0010734137613326311, -0.004495526663959026, 0.03242548182606697, 0.025898974388837814, 0.020388782024383545, -0.011577628552913666, -0.010161973536014557, 0.0033013534266501665, -0.018861878663301468, -0.006357809994369745, 0.0819791704416275, 0.04144037887454033, -0.049534641206264496, 0.018499262630939484, -0.05104761943221092, 0.05093961954116821, -0.03919633477926254, -0.029522212222218513, 0.047392264008522034, -0.02216884307563305, -0.053532540798187256, -0.016506806015968323, 0.08424393832683563, 0.04442986845970154, -0.049214594066143036, -0.006997706368565559, -0.006069047376513481, -0.01974230259656906, -0.024158040061593056, 0.01662980578839779, -0.026801282539963722, 0.031506530940532684, 0.00992548931390047, -0.039087794721126556, -0.0609298013150692, -0.032414767891168594, 0.06260796636343002, -0.006899927742779255, 0.03623824566602707, -0.013877401128411293, -0.006742808036506176, 0.015136472880840302, -0.009403529576957226, -0.014641070738434792, -0.01867850311100483, -0.055417198687791824, -0.04807201027870178, 0.032371729612350464, 0.02784792333841324, 0.009493405930697918, 0.0006502438336610794, -0.03590922802686691, 0.029633620753884315, 0.021032433956861496, 0.014965277165174484, 0.042352475225925446, -0.029962614178657532, -0.017973992973566055, -0.08253907412290573, -0.009090100415050983, -0.003681765403598547, 0.07104939967393875, 0.06333684921264648, 0.013619163073599339, 0.03667531535029411, 0.03258903697133064, 0.025386806577444077, 0.028400013223290443, -0.04510004445910454, -0.011698991060256958, -0.052532751113176346, 0.032577868551015854, 0.00790670420974493, -0.031191473826766014, 0.0484422892332077, 0.04546504467725754, -0.01409837044775486, 0.031001990661025047, 0.046609409153461456, -0.01213759183883667, -0.02827349863946438, 0.022800017148256302, 0.05276039242744446, -0.0451856330037117, -0.02090553566813469, -0.04096822440624237, -0.019553491845726967, -0.04185051470994949, 0.030675292015075684, 0.020586438477039337, -0.016972975805401802, -0.037447746843099594, 0.028938915580511093, 0.0453106127679348, 0.0861138179898262, 0.04801435023546219, 0.008626285009086132, -0.017944293096661568, 0.054482582956552505, -0.06314639002084732, 0.002384680090472102, -0.016567077487707138, 0.07560370117425919, 0.04681690037250519, -0.0003280890523456037, -0.030596699565649033, 0.02347427047789097, 0.01506715640425682, -0.06324752420186996, 0.060085494071245193, 0.03357301279902458, -0.022673705592751503, 0.06010963395237923, 0.04161912947893143, 0.039718177169561386, 0.04349396750330925, -0.05015180632472038, 0.03829526901245117, 0.07520503550767899, -0.012853998690843582, 0.020638102665543556, 0.03357406333088875, -0.031078431755304337, 0.00032701421878300607, -0.02934875898063183, 0.03560560196638107, 0.01280863955616951, 0.004604259971529245, 0.04424355551600456, -0.06005352735519409, 0.04380272701382637, 0.05223323032259941, 0.015291035175323486, 0.002801771042868495, 0.009267271496355534, 0.025373557582497597, -0.02052832394838333, -0.04775567725300789, -0.01372094452381134, 0.023964282125234604, 0.012322788126766682, -0.03022913821041584, 0.002457090187817812, 0.0652468129992485, 0.04054809361696243, -0.05746949836611748, 0.0026620905846357346, -0.03689133748412132, 0.001704227295704186, -0.010749033652245998, 0.013308457098901272, 0.025730185210704803, -0.060063254088163376, -0.024082336574792862, -0.017908789217472076, -0.028146933764219284, 0.005173561163246632, 0.03371896594762802, 0.09937375038862228, -0.0018121137982234359, -0.056705765426158905, 0.0402081236243248, -0.024014143273234367, -0.0016173183685168624, 0.008159751072525978, 0.030791128054261208, -0.03687600791454315, 0.057345617562532425, -0.009560402482748032, 0.0014208635548129678, 0.008812623098492622, -0.00616587046533823, 0.027129482477903366, -0.007770135998725891, 0.04184529185295105, -0.01647578366100788, 0.017784638330340385, -0.05921078100800514, 0.05031517148017883, 0.029402894899249077, 0.014260472729802132, -0.026869377121329308, 0.0017289622919633985, -0.005216827616095543, -0.030652517452836037, -0.009548966772854328, 0.04239695146679878, 0.04862508922815323, -0.05482572689652443, 0.05136493593454361, 0.041592106223106384, -0.017295485362410545, 0.017869720235466957, 0.06642896682024002, 0.029317514970898628, 0.026373669505119324, 0.04062101989984512, 0.03248181566596031, -0.03856449946761131, -0.014069381169974804, -0.0501474030315876, -0.02294427901506424, 0.0166847612708807, -0.06481996923685074, 0.030551066622138023, 0.015106642618775368, 0.08083216100931168, 0.027995515614748, -0.01889633946120739, -0.03897906094789505, -0.02186114341020584, 0.03504312410950661, -0.06691861897706985, -0.015165692195296288, -0.06599865853786469, -0.05605680122971535, -0.04615423455834389, -0.017217669636011124, -0.04925002157688141, 0.0034751207567751408, 0.012041021138429642, 0.038193490356206894, -0.0020328955724835396, 0.014694261364638805, 0.01205477211624384, -0.026023102924227715, 0.03563927859067917, -0.002198113827034831, 0.03804437071084976, -0.016921119764447212, -0.0026675318367779255, -0.008044987916946411, 0.0003085839853156358, -0.04620809853076935, -0.04077695310115814, -0.005233827978372574, 0.05902208387851715, -0.03248241916298866, -0.03305559977889061, -0.03363044187426567, 0.004174764733761549, 0.054204829037189484, -0.0561089850962162, -0.024505363777279854, 0.011553593911230564, -0.028061820194125175, 0.08262842893600464, 0.030486291274428368, 0.013121954165399075, 0.03481762856245041, 0.027392607182264328, 0.00035762376501224935, -0.004716780502349138, 0.03566136583685875, -0.0045157321728765965, 0.01073295995593071, -0.03499140217900276, -0.04164149612188339, -0.0004946247790940106, 0.012188387103378773, 0.04303085431456566 ]
<p>In the comments to this <a href="http://quantumfrontiers.com/2012/09/24/the-allure-of-elegance/" rel="nofollow">post</a>, it was hinted that proving that the force acting on a charge at a vertical distance from a uniformly charged plane is independent of that distance can be done by recalling the scale invariance symmetry. Can someone explain that to me?</p>
g9816
[ 0.06263675540685654, -0.0046351575292646885, -0.025888632982969284, -0.0427604615688324, 0.03314555436372757, 0.07489582896232605, 0.011595000512897968, 0.016338134184479713, -0.07398969680070877, 0.02691766433417797, -0.03801208361983299, -0.02702201157808304, -0.044982317835092545, -0.014453166164457798, -0.012226422317326069, 0.043726179748773575, 0.06187352165579796, -0.04538877680897713, 0.056326959282159805, -0.030052894726395607, -0.05040182173252106, -0.01799522526562214, -0.016237234696745872, -0.0373668447136879, 0.012537374161183834, 0.0075212325900793076, 0.0160908754914999, -0.05119545757770538, -0.017450300976634026, -0.04872078448534012, 0.05808825045824051, 0.018890380859375, 0.03250672668218613, -0.054523780941963196, 0.015804750844836235, -0.003471692791208625, 0.04691252112388611, 0.03522941842675209, 0.05301111936569214, 0.02290460653603077, -0.012572634033858776, -0.01568198762834072, -0.0418393649160862, -0.00504565704613924, 0.012701040133833885, 0.043354276567697525, -0.006397952791303396, 0.04264240339398384, -0.040970202535390854, -0.02108200266957283, 0.0012167677050456405, 0.03900521993637085, 0.03746088221669197, -0.0024309023283421993, -0.027088696137070656, -0.0023959274403750896, 0.04174423962831497, 0.01267669815570116, 0.012347397394478321, 0.06438103318214417, -0.00021095220290590078, -0.017397912219166756, 0.021232154220342636, 0.031501997262239456, 0.04228808358311653, -0.047284796833992004, -0.05657272785902023, -0.015370732173323631, -0.03111240267753601, 0.025560904294252396, -0.023435870185494423, -0.07863898575305939, -0.02753867395222187, -0.030340634286403656, -0.0738399401307106, 0.011845258995890617, 0.06244318559765816, -0.0061551230028271675, -0.004257779568433762, -0.05142426863312721, -0.025823792442679405, -0.008397238329052925, 0.036504484713077545, 0.028839025646448135, 0.09653248637914658, -0.0472010001540184, -0.003184365574270487, 0.002460707677528262, 0.0165982935577631, 0.0030625476501882076, 0.0009342502453364432, 0.003925949335098267, 0.050087668001651764, 0.009856022894382477, -0.022681111469864845, -0.06540653109550476, 0.03565602749586105, 0.054935142397880554, -0.05152212083339691, -0.013455251231789589, -0.10388439148664474, 0.018071146681904793, 0.019333869218826294, 0.003861947450786829, 0.0393962524831295, 0.01774968020617962, 0.04410164803266525, 0.02438955195248127, 0.009048623964190483, -0.05016816407442093, -0.015805331990122795, -0.031952258199453354, -0.05175894498825073, -0.01043292973190546, -0.0927366241812706, -0.04220551624894142, 0.05853625386953354, -0.04978000372648239, 0.0007320092990994453, 0.009777856059372425, -0.023775821551680565, 0.0089177954941988, -0.028766028583049774, 0.042595017701387405, -0.07605305314064026, 0.035666391253471375, -0.022417115047574043, 0.0068307737819850445, -0.015738539397716522, -0.06955813616514206, 0.03265020251274109, -0.01616590842604637, -0.028905116021633148, 0.015481729991734028, 0.02780499868094921, -0.017872177064418793, 0.011360415257513523, -0.016118530184030533, 0.06175867095589638, 0.0014539854601025581, -0.03565174713730812, 0.01559016015380621, -0.006903451401740313, -0.006562972906976938, 0.010506297461688519, -0.029701946303248405, -0.013573313131928444, -0.009754781611263752, 0.06190881505608559, -0.03098575957119465, -0.005762274377048016, 0.11122366786003113, -0.007489880546927452, -0.03274224326014519, -0.002353799296543002, -0.029474016278982162, 0.07944204658269882, 0.015038802288472652, 0.03978698328137398, -0.04342760518193245, 0.053866855800151825, -0.007501440122723579, 0.040861837565898895, -0.029774131253361702, -0.0473940372467041, -0.0027022389695048332, 0.03432208299636841, -0.04687897115945816, -0.0027207948733121157, -0.0660582110285759, -0.10075487941503525, 0.04931029677391052, 0.0360293872654438, 0.0011225963244214654, 0.007399653550237417, 0.023315800353884697, -0.046478573232889175, -0.050219468772411346, 0.030481494963169098, -0.025598883628845215, -0.0738268494606018, 0.013155333697795868, 0.032552558928728104, -0.03491275757551193, -0.04651070013642311, 0.05762676149606705, -0.006520617287606001, 0.03187871351838112, 0.02780047059059143, 0.008099793456494808, 0.005785165820270777, 0.02678414061665535, -0.07406692951917648, 0.07153201848268509, -0.02351403795182705, 0.0006161935743875802, 0.07102812081575394, -0.03818477690219879, -0.02207520790398121, 0.01765468530356884, -0.038344431668519974, 0.04564770683646202, 0.03332890570163727, -0.0034131016582250595, -0.0062249028123915195, 0.021185124292969704, -0.008405940607190132, -0.0533108115196228, 0.04987122863531113, 0.023714888840913773, -0.011326841078698635, -0.033288776874542236, -0.0075407675467431545, -0.02034078724682331, 0.006571842357516289, 0.012785702012479305, 0.010325314477086067, -0.009070618078112602, -0.0794881209731102, 0.03900079056620598, -0.059455547481775284, -0.02045959047973156, 0.0066919224336743355, 0.026149634271860123, 0.0006574660656042397, 0.022107038646936417, -0.035717252641916275, -0.045337289571762085, -0.015429051592946053, -0.04728078469634056, -0.02677101641893387, 0.027635671198368073, -0.0520610474050045, 0.023795627057552338, 0.04755101725459099, 0.11185526102781296, 0.018517347052693367, -0.002133749658241868, -0.011053258553147316, 0.005681232549250126, 0.013903636485338211, -0.07710456103086472, 0.006419655401259661, 0.00016734814562369138, 0.030105363577604294, 0.031238125637173653, 0.03786473348736763, -0.007392830681055784, 0.025709008798003197, 0.0019391720416024327, 0.020844558253884315, -0.025573840364813805, -0.02478259615600109, -0.012265491299331188, 0.024925919249653816, 0.01720356196165085, 0.035329338163137436, -0.04018490016460419, -0.038959138095378876, -0.038913097232580185, -0.02852250076830387, -0.006825862918049097, 0.018069975078105927, 0.012882583774626255, -0.04034236818552017, 0.02136245183646679, 0.040843091905117035, 0.03145383298397064, 0.026902180165052414, -0.011676360853016376, 0.01836397685110569, 0.10300200432538986, -0.03293841332197189, -0.0014710989780724049, -0.01819785311818123, 0.007545438129454851, -0.0064672911539673805, -0.006359065882861614, 0.04515907168388367, 0.014548455365002155, -0.05309413745999336, 0.016596538946032524, -0.07479388266801834, 0.020228799432516098, 0.053421974182128906, -0.008070041425526142, -0.04007432982325554, 0.007744485978037119, -0.028598709031939507, 0.028418445959687233, 0.004500147420912981, -0.022826524451375008, 0.030107013881206512, -0.021151911467313766, -0.009744217619299889, 0.009614531882107258, 0.02788023091852665, -0.06379443407058716, -0.03562811762094498, 0.0052243187092244625, 0.00640056561678648, -0.07726975530385971, 0.03009815327823162, -0.012299804016947746, 0.023340772837400436, 0.04827805235981941, -0.0011138750705868006, -0.01912139728665352, -0.030877266079187393, -0.004890302661806345, -0.0653626099228859, 0.028513193130493164, -0.03528386354446411, 0.019079329445958138, -0.007081326097249985, -0.04261885583400726, 0.02322186715900898, -0.0004603692505043, -0.01192633155733347, -0.05308285355567932, -0.003770175389945507, 0.013672898523509502, 0.009037109091877937, -0.014726275578141212, 0.03618432208895683, 0.051633067429065704, -0.09054507315158844, 0.060470253229141235, 0.04019540175795555, 0.0004996598581783473, 0.034532178193330765, 0.05880167335271835, 0.04711749032139778, -0.019917216151952744, -0.03555968403816223, -0.06503657251596451, -0.026432784274220467, 0.04698747396469116, 0.015988171100616455, -0.007756552193313837, -0.018493710085749626, -0.029100440442562103, -0.0385243222117424, -0.01235971786081791, 0.025733182206749916, 0.06980350613594055, -0.026912879198789597, -0.011234642937779427, -0.011592499911785126, 0.03154441714286804, -0.007604042999446392, -0.01268083043396473, 0.044483792036771774, -0.05008230730891228, 0.035652462393045425, -0.002534878207370639, 0.029015405103564262, 0.009914402849972248, -0.08420374989509583, -0.015281174331903458, 0.06303952634334564, -0.009403649717569351, 0.03836238011717796, -0.008364105597138405, -0.015560051426291466, 0.012277021072804928, -0.03629857301712036, 0.017187928780913353, -0.013559117913246155, -0.022392844781279564, -0.024706970900297165, -0.03410792350769043, -0.002684780163690448, -0.030427535995841026, 0.00879620760679245, 0.006507939659059048, 0.06669444590806961, -0.035143326967954636, 0.0009271875023841858, -0.004622220993041992, 0.03313012421131134, 0.0630984678864479, 0.01157377939671278, -0.0136174988001585, 0.051164980977773666, 0.02337741293013096, -0.10609393566846848, 0.01746164821088314, 0.043657347559928894, -0.041479095816612244, -0.01025399286299944, -0.038067858666181564, -0.041578393429517746, 0.02687382884323597, 0.005125506781041622, -0.040650952607393265, 0.03944911062717438, -0.006325766909867525, 0.020954227074980736, -0.006744890473783016, 0.02933335117995739, 0.0055656530894339085, -0.008548112586140633, 0.029302624985575676, -0.03183819726109505, 0.04774247109889984, 0.04582295939326286, -0.047946736216545105, -0.013883082196116447, -0.03239603713154793, 0.01722816564142704, -0.012473213486373425, 0.004344603978097439, -0.0885215476155281, -0.0022356456611305475, 0.010072494857013226, 0.04814331606030464, 0.013923869468271732, -0.0015974611742421985, -0.006189663894474506, 0.030788574367761612, 0.0780453160405159, 0.07834089547395706, -0.008519907481968403, 0.043938759714365005, 0.058442141860723495, -0.0028106439858675003, 0.025743506848812103, 0.02272908389568329, 0.026667483150959015, 0.011450504884123802, 0.01673491857945919, 0.00872346106916666, -0.019933687523007393, -0.0418107807636261, -0.01892896555364132, -0.035747792571783066, 0.043528441339731216, -0.02682056836783886, 0.015052623115479946, 0.04197629913687706, 0.0277458056807518, 0.04538622871041298, -0.014466754160821438, -0.04270631819963455, 0.005795180331915617, -0.04087225720286369, -0.022198032587766647, -0.015116861090064049, 0.0066757043823599815, -0.03252623602747917, -0.028096778318285942, -0.008750197477638721, -0.011426643468439579, 0.007830590941011906, -0.05039984732866287, -0.06795167177915573, 0.025291593745350838, 0.019596800208091736, -0.0070298356004059315, -0.03759068250656128, 0.021509718149900436, -0.01072983630001545, 0.006350147537887096, 0.022305047139525414, 0.03282671049237251, -0.03787018358707428, -0.00011644167534541339, -0.04919109866023064, -0.026787467300891876, 0.05841444432735443, 0.03353593870997429, 0.029452353715896606, 0.0030776234343647957, 0.08418254554271698, 0.045847147703170776, 0.07385546714067459, 0.029034586623311043, 0.001420974382199347, -0.02523055300116539, -0.048925504088401794, 0.035083651542663574, 0.02770768105983734, -0.041893113404512405, -0.030726775527000427, 0.010534453205764294, -0.017431160435080528, -0.007173983380198479, -0.04462317377328873, -0.009276831522583961, 0.01798221468925476, 0.014665172435343266, -0.02259855717420578, 0.026812616735696793, 0.023401567712426186, 0.005044678226113319, -0.0036311449948698282, 0.05148632451891899, -0.02167751081287861, -0.0020053479820489883, -0.013170752674341202, 0.008282595314085484, 0.047714851796627045, 0.005095263011753559, 0.013745611533522606, 0.046561628580093384, 0.061550725251436234, 0.03052239678800106, -0.002408794593065977, 0.032806605100631714, -0.046506933867931366, 0.023288916796445847, -0.01428662333637476, 0.029505256563425064, 0.02056637592613697, 0.0015345871215686202, -0.010759305208921432, 0.07423993200063705, -0.03702182322740555, -0.011694060638546944, 0.07626120746135712, -0.006142462138086557, 0.022146372124552727, -0.0453864261507988, -0.028028905391693115, 0.0515599325299263, -0.05855584144592285, -0.06111351028084755, 0.008021235466003418, 0.03436319902539253, -0.009212852455675602, -0.0021110239904373884, -0.006240176968276501, -0.07074732333421707, 0.034875329583883286, -0.00703566987067461, 0.038161881268024445, 0.014799552969634533, 0.007632572669535875, -0.015609413385391235, -0.0003972618724219501, -0.07969997823238373, -0.005646946839988232, 0.03608941659331322, -0.020957712084054947, -0.02702038176357746, -0.03316064924001694, -0.040687236934900284, 0.05011526122689247, -0.012327082455158234, -0.0452023483812809, 0.04302002489566803, -0.025842834264039993, -0.023649627342820168, -0.007235037628561258, -0.0073354290798306465, -0.0033546260092407465, -0.058239296078681946, -0.03562968224287033, -0.01334160752594471, 0.09936658293008804, 0.033768072724342346, 0.015498148277401924, -0.011731507256627083, -0.031501654535532, -0.027725202962756157, 0.03862797096371651, -0.01700609177350998, 0.05036598816514015, 0.00719873234629631, 0.009654155932366848, -0.002040442079305649, -0.0003160053747706115, -0.03034115955233574, 0.04310993850231171, -0.03193367272615433, 0.0051160636357963085, -0.014689803123474121, -0.04784630984067917, -0.008729160763323307, 0.011759498156607151, -0.020052988082170486, 0.0636601522564888, -0.044008705765008926, -0.03141048178076744, -0.004184604622423649, -0.03092184290289879, -0.04376380890607834, 0.03503074124455452, -0.054096583276987076, -0.0032489686273038387, -0.0393393374979496, 0.0023294510319828987, -0.0072760493494570255, -0.05967440828680992, -0.013929730281233788, 0.06326106190681458, -0.011326919309794903, -0.0355401486158371, 0.060435544699430466, 0.057613492012023926, 0.006430215667933226, 0.030059032142162323, -0.05013177543878555, 0.022332990542054176, 0.05560459569096565, 0.0025614432524889708, 0.004627490881830454, -0.024499254301190376, -0.007279743906110525, -0.03505922853946686, 0.06397777795791626, -0.02522878907620907, -0.008698043413460255, -0.016610588878393173, 0.011138936504721642, 0.0090279970318079, -0.029648980125784874, -0.031989626586437225, 0.04212840273976326, -0.006145555060356855, -0.0015756241045892239, 0.021302103996276855, 0.033315401524305344, 0.072372667491436, 0.0194464810192585, -0.023584462702274323, 0.018300266936421394, 0.045491110533475876, 0.01709415577352047, -0.0639813020825386, 0.04326348006725311, 0.022020475938916206, 0.03525032848119736, -0.001299515482969582, 0.042678944766521454, 0.012043338268995285, 0.011903421953320503, 0.040047939866781235, 0.030389858409762383, -0.04121313616633415, 0.010822185315191746, 0.017069604247808456, 0.00978158414363861, -0.06861433386802673, -0.008850875310599804, 0.013690096326172352, -0.002713071182370186, -0.0015537788858637214, 0.032731201499700546, 0.0703425481915474, 0.045369166880846024, -0.0030354084447026253, 0.04689967259764671, -0.07684134691953659, -0.014917947351932526, 0.008277726359665394, -0.02580409124493599, -0.016152389347553253, -0.06845292448997498, -0.03797552362084389, 0.0054962243884801865, 0.013166076503694057, -0.06365504115819931, -0.011734859086573124, 0.019639838486909866, -0.08053562045097351, -0.08644310384988785, 0.004698352422565222, -0.010372449643909931, 0.023197514936327934, -0.04052019864320755, 0.030947986990213394, 0.044965311884880066, 0.01976075768470764, -0.008410592563450336, -0.0495450496673584, 0.06949599832296371, 0.034222979098558426, -0.00900251604616642, 0.021321577951312065, 0.052251238375902176, -0.010454146191477776, -0.02774820849299431, -0.029483165591955185, -0.017814114689826965, 0.002915997989475727, -0.007952946238219738, -0.009440877474844456, -0.052003324031829834, -0.029631618410348892, -0.02863921783864498, -0.012643855065107346, 0.04179608076810837, 0.022700872272253036, 0.04745498299598694, 0.046369586139917374, 0.010612362064421177, 0.003003195160999894, -0.017613817006349564, -0.019150352105498314, -0.04298197478055954, 0.024593058973550797, -0.000048634206905262545, 0.00561218336224556, -0.019664254039525986, 0.010669012553989887, -0.03021547570824623, -0.026437314227223396, -0.05306191369891167, -0.03765447437763214, 0.008869174867868423, 0.017256958410143852, -0.009952598251402378, 0.08351407945156097, 0.016822416335344315, -0.027635952457785606, 0.026346098631620407, -0.02436564490199089, 0.0022154892794787884, 0.009863669984042645, 0.011938342824578285, 0.08168941736221313, -0.026612291112542152, -0.03553365543484688, 0.020937489345669746, 0.04317048564553261, -0.023628955706954002, 0.02361971326172352, -0.022093208506703377, -0.026047471910715103, -0.0028575926553457975, -0.0058862497098743916, -0.012802147306501865, 0.0022827053908258677, 0.04561460390686989, 0.030318569391965866, -0.024396073073148727, -0.012493331916630268, 0.02172788418829441, 0.024890361353754997, -0.010253948159515858, 0.005110134370625019, -0.01798909343779087, -0.04491002485156059, -0.030597709119319916, -0.01657942309975624, -0.0027103398460894823, 0.010133490897715092, 0.002504777628928423, 0.04552071914076805, 0.03697614371776581, -0.07493194192647934, 0.01651601865887642, 0.08479373902082443, -0.02718750759959221, 0.011319520883262157, 0.020118923857808113, 0.08475400507450104, 0.002305499743670225, -0.02409154362976551, -0.008817501366138458, -0.01194017007946968, 0.002569768810644746, -0.057202138006687164, -0.07997502386569977, -0.04767506942152977, 0.05019219592213631 ]
<p>I just came across this Wikipedia article on pn-junctions:</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P%E2%80%93n_junction#Equilibrium_.28zero_bias.29" rel="nofollow">pn junction</a></p> <p>What I don't get is why the negative charge density is narrower/smaller than the positive one in Figure A. I'm guessing the area is probably the same, so why don't they just make them the same shape ? Is there a good reason to why they are different, or...?</p>
g9817
[ 0.021303338930010796, 0.022149670869112015, -0.03153291717171669, 0.0012973619159311056, 0.05321910232305527, 0.03723553940653801, 0.00003369474507053383, 0.01868116483092308, -0.04233384504914284, -0.047264911234378815, 0.022838672623038292, -0.002370863687247038, 0.012098800390958786, 0.00016052079445216805, 0.03790108487010002, -0.01843908429145813, 0.0026384734082967043, 0.019306426867842674, 0.036536313593387604, 0.019036486744880676, -0.07842599600553513, -0.00623834365978837, -0.04044344276189804, -0.017859458923339844, 0.03626441955566406, -0.025233987718820572, -0.009780018590390682, -0.05000203475356102, -0.03978714346885681, -0.06085755676031113, 0.047977790236473083, -0.02072584442794323, -0.026043174788355827, -0.02675839141011238, -0.08103875815868378, 0.008476384915411472, 0.010877964086830616, -0.05956833437085152, 0.018742287531495094, 0.013271069154143333, 0.013038480654358864, -0.014468678273260593, 0.029597049579024315, -0.05460066720843315, -0.04693944752216339, -0.02511528506875038, -0.03852182999253273, 0.024032950401306152, 0.030161280184984207, -0.06401923298835754, -0.021383026614785194, 0.03914765641093254, 0.0066831368021667, -0.02055063471198082, 0.07073742151260376, -0.017743892967700958, 0.005487343762069941, 0.01296274084597826, 0.026172280311584473, -0.013839074410498142, -0.021752407774329185, 0.040458790957927704, -0.01898890919983387, 0.06588943302631378, 0.09575269371271133, -0.017320815473794937, -0.016792796552181244, -0.003989539574831724, 0.021982882171869278, 0.026993896812200546, -0.062264785170555115, -0.007701132446527481, -0.040604401379823685, -0.03610297664999962, 0.03305162489414215, 0.0171692855656147, 0.02721307799220085, 0.019295379519462585, 0.02775384858250618, -0.030281459912657738, -0.050182659178972244, -0.023902855813503265, 0.00816420093178749, -0.009864186868071556, 0.09872204065322876, 0.03084906004369259, 0.04802030697464943, -0.011161120608448982, 0.01174576859921217, 0.0034343188162893057, -0.007785316091030836, -0.01047244668006897, 0.04680898040533066, -0.014271700754761696, -0.07397724688053131, -0.002442673547193408, 0.004470646381378174, 0.07041007280349731, 0.010187044739723206, 0.06589830666780472, 0.03605948016047478, -0.029219068586826324, 0.02461429126560688, 0.04862841218709946, -0.054750777781009674, 0.027600117027759552, -0.05846105515956879, -0.0020972515922039747, 0.013955141417682171, -0.01359799038618803, -0.03410138562321663, -0.03415092080831528, -0.013459759764373302, -0.0035346064250916243, 0.018969114869832993, 0.013054747134447098, 0.04986821860074997, -0.03307045251131058, 0.006190193351358175, 0.030575210228562355, -0.015725115314126015, -0.033264994621276855, -0.03647034242749214, -0.022022679448127747, -0.010414894670248032, -0.011579398065805435, 0.019136618822813034, -0.015866145491600037, 0.024503935128450394, -0.02320130728185177, 0.052130647003650665, -0.0010122425155714154, -0.08529702574014664, -0.005673527251929045, 0.03860007971525192, 0.02173508331179619, 0.007008696906268597, -0.046623680740594864, 0.035219378769397736, 0.006584430579096079, -0.017924189567565918, 0.02086327038705349, -0.014663167297840118, -0.050264518707990646, -0.024143315851688385, -0.033777449280023575, -0.023377414792776108, -0.029159393161535263, -0.023151813074946404, 0.03980318456888199, 0.06762934476137161, -0.03459159657359123, 0.05633017420768738, -0.025083066895604134, -0.039760760962963104, -0.018250344321131706, 0.09319685399532318, 0.004690530709922314, -0.00500339362770319, -0.0013474299339577556, -0.007669955957680941, -0.019584449008107185, 0.009920905344188213, 0.009549044072628021, -0.04866090789437294, -0.027064114809036255, 0.039767201989889145, -0.04881461337208748, -0.003367988858371973, -0.030847696587443352, -0.0010454852599650621, 0.014461652375757694, -0.05126716196537018, 0.0186108760535717, 0.0591370053589344, 0.027800438925623894, 0.03175100311636925, 0.02016148902475834, 0.06479744613170624, 0.047528043389320374, -0.08931524306535721, 0.03893594816327095, 0.009638420306146145, -0.01200372539460659, 0.0038689090870320797, 0.02647068351507187, -0.0060046883299946785, -0.0248348917812109, -0.020859234035015106, -0.011664126999676228, 0.0161860603839159, -0.027516845613718033, -0.08317061513662338, 0.030640851706266403, -0.02786809392273426, -0.046390287578105927, 0.00904516689479351, -0.02564127929508686, -0.018676534295082092, -0.008884572423994541, -0.101931631565094, 0.013073991984128952, 0.036596670746803284, 0.021394366398453712, 0.02252586930990219, -0.03049353137612343, -0.0648607611656189, -0.025959620252251625, 0.052802570164203644, 0.014133731834590435, -0.0808778926730156, 0.017900627106428146, 0.004192359745502472, 0.02566123567521572, -0.0045904857106506824, -0.032067444175481796, 0.009893388487398624, 0.02346629463136196, -0.016887979581952095, -0.025198843330144882, -0.015058515593409538, -0.02910052053630352, 0.04640907421708107, -0.009083024226129055, -0.012536684982478619, -0.006174070294946432, 0.08526118099689484, 0.002113862195983529, 0.021500397473573685, -0.0077254935167729855, -0.06191101670265198, -0.03920473903417587, -0.07965468615293503, 0.03681520000100136, 0.030248653143644333, 0.04855974391102791, 0.040911704301834106, 0.024623539298772812, -0.058102335780858994, -0.04284541308879852, -0.024266965687274933, -0.019747108221054077, -0.040833085775375366, 0.08533453941345215, -0.01825738325715065, -0.06280069798231125, 0.01920551247894764, -0.06103888154029846, 0.00812739972025156, 0.033731549978256226, 0.0012995109427720308, 0.021434243768453598, 0.0018920659786090255, 0.006002411711961031, 0.02216879092156887, -0.012560639530420303, -0.018092649057507515, -0.012460589408874512, 0.01766924560070038, -0.06628303229808807, -0.004701163154095411, -0.0072226556949317455, 0.0050796098075807095, -0.017043692991137505, -0.02140778861939907, -0.025023914873600006, -0.04489657282829285, -0.006555762141942978, 0.03130729869008064, 0.01865074411034584, 0.02633476071059704, 0.05816847085952759, -0.013398407027125359, -0.011725977063179016, 0.04156343638896942, -0.027133125811815262, -0.004510127939283848, -0.008685900829732418, 0.0240654107183218, -0.04327992722392082, 0.04260067269206047, 0.06480582058429718, -0.015299388207495213, -0.009227528236806393, 0.048845741897821426, -0.01688781939446926, 0.00651831179857254, -0.04082738235592842, 0.003105883952230215, 0.04630560055375099, -0.003640983020886779, 0.01991286128759384, -0.0015733065083622932, -0.07599712908267975, 0.09628305584192276, -0.0388319306075573, -0.01485007256269455, -0.05158807709813118, -0.06336986273527145, -0.0010654969373717904, -0.027325225993990898, 0.006749775726348162, 0.02146061509847641, 0.01200762577354908, 0.067949578166008, 0.06069169566035271, -0.047176823019981384, -0.007439779117703438, -0.05629793554544449, 0.008923526853322983, -0.08354707807302475, -0.006986822001636028, 0.00949400570243597, -0.020705850794911385, 0.0015967069193720818, 0.000009255262739316095, -0.007445185445249081, 0.07470372319221497, 0.06989454478025436, -0.01277098897844553, -0.00653023412451148, 0.0032328260131180286, -0.0029244699981063604, -0.010603946633636951, -0.03136860206723213, 0.011882449500262737, 0.008653337135910988, -0.029517071321606636, 0.05365287885069847, 0.013362996280193329, 0.016458164900541306, -0.0053528351709246635, 0.023479865863919258, 0.002792422426864505, -0.03113202378153801, -0.031897325068712234, -0.030850496143102646, 0.0718805342912674, -0.004846471827477217, 0.02247324399650097, -0.02571261301636696, 0.037049226462841034, -0.09005073457956314, -0.04275890439748764, -0.015914110466837883, 0.012091990560293198, -0.005377043504267931, 0.012536252848803997, -0.023034406825900078, -0.04370817914605141, 0.05217655003070831, 0.010875742882490158, 0.04306453838944435, 0.021622130647301674, -0.039048030972480774, -0.002753600711002946, -0.03941434994339943, 0.0010104289976879954, -0.025682086125016212, 0.0641254186630249, 0.03372466564178467, -0.021689141169190407, 0.03435748815536499, 0.00821777991950512, -0.051283370703458786, 0.029398338869214058, -0.04876289144158363, -0.021050507202744484, -0.03750896826386452, -0.05702485516667366, -0.015148075297474861, -0.004681330174207687, 0.013566810637712479, 0.001441124128177762, 0.0676901713013649, 0.018726302310824394, -0.008437064476311207, 0.045421529561281204, -0.0654601901769638, 0.01680755242705345, 0.005971210543066263, -0.051216065883636475, -0.018352016806602478, 0.015324648469686508, 0.028445269912481308, -0.03472167253494263, 0.04624086990952492, -0.04823576286435127, -0.053375452756881714, -0.06741176545619965, -0.03650827705860138, 0.047169700264930725, 0.009260952472686768, 0.0010449286783114076, 0.008608159609138966, 0.043425410985946655, -0.0005315527087077498, -0.032714881002902985, -0.05314439907670021, 0.05465748906135559, -0.035697296261787415, 0.01911383680999279, -0.02838071994483471, -0.05504574999213219, 0.027640325948596, 0.003934603650122881, -0.032980550080537796, 0.016610438004136086, -0.0527142733335495, 0.011607409454882145, 0.0020364071242511272, 0.03327631577849388, 0.04277719929814339, -0.0025491369888186455, 0.015116606839001179, -0.03926808014512062, 0.0051579223945736885, -0.01066723931580782, 0.06174730136990547, 0.03863181918859482, 0.05789274722337723, 0.06594295054674149, -0.0353926382958889, -0.026113033294677734, 0.041969362646341324, 0.07728660106658936, 0.01022433489561081, 0.002579726977273822, 0.012961605563759804, -0.01294384989887476, 0.03599026799201965, 0.04517272487282753, 0.02097807452082634, -0.03727157786488533, -0.05967114120721817, -0.016375873237848282, -0.046123821288347244, 0.0420803464949131, 0.009947657585144043, 0.05313493311405182, 0.01313746627420187, 0.019477345049381256, -0.012933093123137951, -0.03271496295928955, 0.03787187114357948, 0.021471163257956505, -0.05289332941174507, -0.01581612415611744, -0.022683503106236458, -0.010288963094353676, -0.02431832253932953, -0.005354221444576979, 0.022009333595633507, -0.06408745050430298, 0.023010753095149994, -0.03268708661198616, 0.014575046487152576, 0.029707886278629303, 0.0013919990742579103, 0.0240748580545187, -0.008298266679048538, 0.026818836107850075, -0.03384576365351677, 0.0047734081745147705, 0.026620594784617424, 0.00966564379632473, -0.01179597619920969, -0.02230914495885372, 0.010082240216434002, -0.026865515857934952, -0.008545453660190105, 0.06545224785804749, 0.017258137464523315, 0.06590168178081512, 0.0343562550842762, 0.027718789875507355, 0.04703569784760475, -0.0056037153117358685, -0.027433792129158974, -0.03484295681118965, -0.05905529111623764, 0.03068465180695057, 0.03761759772896767, 0.04764299467206001, 0.017144862562417984, 0.02837134152650833, -0.023260448127985, 0.06202807277441025, -0.036323364824056625, -0.014031393453478813, 0.05391736701130867, -0.060919396579265594, 0.03751702234148979, 0.02707061916589737, -0.015229313634335995, -0.02018493227660656, 0.024179963394999504, 0.049680765718221664, -0.022774651646614075, -0.0016184495761990547, -0.016015859320759773, -0.03230307623744011, -0.011890704743564129, -0.06625368446111679, 0.0472857765853405, 0.04339715838432312, 0.08617408573627472, -0.041154645383358, 0.038570281118154526, -0.05512256175279617, -0.013938289135694504, -0.01437640655785799, 0.01657402701675892, 0.014164330437779427, 0.03921709954738617, 0.00892194639891386, -0.06536317616701126, 0.017110878601670265, -0.04114038124680519, 0.01500807423144579, 0.024102363735437393, -0.019122958183288574, 0.06598114967346191, -0.08361818641424179, -0.007618004456162453, -0.015125802718102932, -0.01471844594925642, -0.0007963708485476673, 0.06750240921974182, -0.004097540397197008, 0.007639183197170496, 0.01594511978328228, 0.05342398211359978, 0.014874829910695553, -0.044704340398311615, -0.022246232256293297, 0.007597567979246378, -0.007479441352188587, 0.0322662815451622, 0.038629937916994095, 0.029627816751599312, -0.0382298119366169, 0.002192358486354351, 0.03420378640294075, 0.014558094553649426, -0.03370507061481476, 0.0021262664813548326, -0.007317437324672937, -0.0353577695786953, 0.006839708890765905, -0.004303522873669863, 0.03859427571296692, -0.05042019486427307, -0.03473791480064392, 0.00030541824526153505, 0.022559083998203278, 0.03641042485833168, 0.018497062847018242, 0.04440150037407875, -0.03700495883822441, 0.05101512745022774, 0.018875615671277046, -0.06006797403097153, 0.045515723526477814, -0.006222762633115053, -0.014564470387995243, -0.035460785031318665, 0.025553269311785698, -0.0008703151252120733, 0.03483930975198746, -0.004642227664589882, -0.012223249301314354, 0.04031813517212868, 0.0028239956591278315, 0.01892281323671341, 0.00786250177770853, 0.008210597559809685, -0.018158914521336555, -0.003295641392469406, 0.0005464058485813439, -0.024066900834441185, 0.023222986608743668, -0.02434234879910946, -0.015876106917858124, -0.007213800214231014, 0.05302489176392555, -0.005683140363544226, -0.005048305727541447, 0.043612174689769745, -0.017067575827240944, 0.0032198086846619844, -0.01645626500248909, 0.04153281822800636, -0.019431831315159798, -0.050334151834249496, 0.0015342326369136572, -0.06556398421525955, 0.009104851633310318, -0.05671657994389534, 0.0001862428180174902, 0.043004848062992096, 0.045291025191545486, 0.01925542578101158, 0.028481220826506615, 0.03310724347829819, 0.02283453941345215, 0.034585628658533096, 0.05700789391994476, -0.0386519618332386, 0.03676195442676544, -0.050267186015844345, 0.06364551186561584, -0.0006674031028524041, -0.0074435328133404255, 0.03718829154968262, -0.01268793549388647, 0.03123883530497551, 0.008610296063125134, -0.031183261424303055, 0.0026949939783662558, -0.011679484508931637, -0.009039660915732384, -0.04976785555481911, 0.005949672777205706, 0.06403252482414246, 0.0827270969748497, -0.022378219291567802, -0.013397137634456158, 0.00016898887406568974, -0.02815457060933113, -0.005289947148412466, 0.027289869263768196, -0.011072732508182526, 0.07540304958820343, 0.014331444166600704, 0.021315371617674828, -0.019673746079206467, 0.022122547030448914, 0.08174184709787369, 0.00858992151916027, -0.03803608939051628, 0.023423586040735245, 0.05682135373353958, 0.012025181204080582, 0.00045393905020318925, 0.039783865213394165, -0.04199263080954552, 0.002405737526714802, -0.05481976270675659, 0.04711822047829628, 0.06544940173625946, -0.04830796644091606, 0.002748973434790969, 0.003403007984161377, -0.028687426820397377, 0.04031260684132576, 0.012171493843197823, 0.006915643345564604, 0.08177953213453293, -0.015857666730880737, -0.04965627193450928, -0.012592650018632412, -0.033709634095430374, 0.047830402851104736, 0.05748753622174263, -0.02390587143599987, 0.03600913658738136, 0.0071951765567064285, -0.004478100221604109, -0.06205107271671295, -0.017851997166872025, -0.03986291214823723, -0.049133945256471634, -0.04895671829581261, -0.005163414869457483, -0.03755834698677063, 0.004628741182386875, 0.03568147495388985, -0.017864227294921875, -0.015831345692276955, 0.06926221400499344, 0.0057491157203912735, 0.04441196471452713, -0.09502927958965302, -0.04849329590797424, -0.02513796091079712, -0.07654215395450592, 0.007273521739989519, 0.011923042125999928, 0.06459882855415344, 0.05798486992716789, -0.06876412034034729, 0.022269265726208687, 0.02641589753329754, -0.09150292724370956, 0.07565170526504517, -0.0019383212784305215, 0.07311797887086868, 0.001802046550437808, -0.018716001883149147, 0.015428432263433933, -0.03967579826712608, -0.022420190274715424, -0.027012953534722328, 0.02097097784280777, -0.011323727667331696, -0.03794072940945625, -0.0055106584914028645, -0.05097096040844917, -0.06817436218261719, 0.06498616188764572, 0.008821048773825169, 0.029933512210845947, 0.03057355433702469, 0.03856692463159561, -0.017289627343416214, -0.021697722375392914, -0.06133740022778511, -0.03304712846875191, 0.04259590059518814, -0.00791910756379366, -0.018619250506162643, 0.005984128452837467, -0.005126520525664091, -0.015604134649038315, -0.04385078698396683, -0.005947246216237545, 0.046843092888593674, -0.004060290288180113, 0.03543251380324364, -0.09052591025829315, -0.012765017338097095, -0.013287613168358803, 0.024016764014959335, -0.021895531564950943, -0.04622845724225044, 0.02645721286535263, 0.03284257650375366, 0.031279437243938446, 0.004774398170411587, 0.02241368032991886, -0.016742639243602753, 0.03506013751029968, -0.06305982172489166, -0.008794893510639668, 0.007012245245277882, 0.005496718920767307, 0.07805535197257996, 0.01914202608168125, -0.04516367241740227, -0.0003397782566025853, -0.03771153837442398, -0.05656207725405693, 0.04069530963897705, 0.017642976716160774, 0.002219568472355604, 0.04290638118982315, 0.042247284203767776, 0.026599334552884102, -0.013060360215604305, 0.01753322035074234, -0.014012828469276428, 0.018514495342969894, -0.008847328834235668, -0.026077108457684517, 0.03124970570206642, -0.014558778144419193, -0.02131468616425991 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/11820/what-really-cause-light-to-appear-slower-in-media">What really cause light to appear slower in media?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>This came to me as a question from one of my friend while I was convinced that the answer is NO. But I have read in Special Theory of relativity that we CAN make light take more time to travel a distance. <br/> And then there's also one more thing which is kind of misleading: </p> <blockquote> <p>Light speed is slow in optically dense media</p> </blockquote> <p>So is it possible to slow it down?</p>
g298
[ 0.022871002554893494, 0.08287981897592545, 0.0059236884117126465, 0.013738811016082764, 0.03941769152879715, 0.02536924183368683, 0.05509186163544655, 0.06906214356422424, -0.0197848379611969, -0.008997737430036068, 0.04007196053862572, -0.021101931110024452, 0.04444268345832825, -0.013253412209451199, -0.01367567665874958, -0.032111600041389465, 0.11450367420911789, -0.028062017634510994, 0.03732558712363243, -0.016293635591864586, -0.023996390402317047, 0.005462740082293749, 0.037696246057748795, -0.08770055323839188, -0.013944433070719242, 0.03585214912891388, -0.008025027811527252, -0.032319825142621994, -0.03067357838153839, -0.012688840739428997, 0.05083749070763588, -0.044501014053821564, -0.02012968808412552, 0.0024298601783812046, 0.05435822159051895, -0.03425377979874611, 0.02391214668750763, -0.003989381715655327, 0.006536416709423065, 0.07188323140144348, 0.011772316880524158, -0.011990570463240147, -0.02282734401524067, -0.03768770769238472, 0.024724246934056282, 0.013734052889049053, 0.007517231162637472, 0.02967618964612484, -0.01866246573626995, -0.07544276118278503, -0.0344059132039547, 0.020609907805919647, 0.04886981099843979, 0.02197500877082348, 0.04271513223648071, -0.01512873824685812, 0.0012438000412657857, -0.0065569500438869, 0.10520654171705246, 0.0576627254486084, -0.06370021402835846, -0.052627332508563995, 0.07400304079055786, 0.006268929690122604, 0.06699223816394806, -0.019135408103466034, -0.007310579996556044, -0.05565400794148445, 0.07171054929494858, -0.027316471561789513, 0.02655295468866825, -0.0005489077302627265, -0.06853383034467697, -0.06370441615581512, -0.03338010609149933, -0.0054121362045407295, 0.022236991673707962, 0.028532253578305244, -0.02259259670972824, 0.009346269071102142, -0.01583150029182434, -0.014255139976739883, -0.017967108637094498, -0.006902834866195917, -0.005950511433184147, 0.026982609182596207, 0.000016270978449028917, 0.02932259440422058, 0.022630121558904648, 0.038882240653038025, 0.03696824982762337, -0.0776839554309845, 0.03537403419613838, 0.039421144872903824, 0.010833613574504852, -0.003671002574265003, -0.03764034062623978, 0.028047559782862663, -0.0057908897288143635, 0.011504676192998886, -0.04864533618092537, -0.011224199086427689, 0.04686479642987251, 0.025185460224747658, -0.0002947188913822174, -0.022145584225654602, 0.0003186924441251904, -0.04804058000445366, -0.052787356078624725, -0.0028647691942751408, -0.0002940979029517621, -0.08525995165109634, -0.007189011666923761, 0.000184341159183532, -0.05932540073990822, -0.029391201213002205, 0.07527046650648117, 0.008001739159226418, -0.009258096106350422, 0.07223529368638992, 0.029527438804507256, 0.030519520863890648, -0.023091105744242668, -0.0121875936165452, -0.024102140218019485, -0.0036463658325374126, 0.02385542541742325, -0.00012534484267234802, 0.022372251376509666, 0.006303010508418083, -0.04663814976811409, 0.05565698444843292, -0.0077153402380645275, 0.027307426556944847, -0.04041905701160431, 0.012928687036037445, 0.01827177219092846, -0.0364057794213295, -0.010385855101048946, 0.022238396108150482, 0.05533888563513756, -0.045920658856630325, -0.00388916302472353, -0.0410677008330822, -0.020413627848029137, -0.009626312181353569, -0.013999823480844498, 0.029597893357276917, 0.008022408001124859, 0.018796704709529877, 0.07329927384853363, 0.04859480261802673, -0.026448525488376617, -0.03588109090924263, 0.03927017003297806, -0.019874321296811104, 0.0032890995498746634, 0.048522356897592545, 0.0033734028693288565, 0.025308357551693916, 0.06417807936668396, 0.015175575390458107, -0.024610601365566254, 0.0016289334744215012, -0.011549602262675762, 0.04052780196070671, 0.01838548667728901, -0.016755040735006332, -0.016233796253800392, -0.04037104547023773, -0.09038412570953369, 0.005538559518754482, -0.004919849336147308, 0.07410655915737152, 0.02589130401611328, 0.0018576649017632008, 0.0809871181845665, -0.025645742192864418, -0.08774581551551819, -0.00858915876597166, -0.08990422636270523, 0.0038328333757817745, -0.06434820592403412, -0.10249538719654083, 0.034113623201847076, 0.004815269727259874, -0.0021414835937321186, -0.04499426856637001, -0.07753536850214005, -0.0007119145011529326, -0.027449538931250572, -0.04127081111073494, 0.011226390488445759, 0.014882497489452362, -0.003437648992985487, -0.029357891529798508, 0.02117815427482128, -0.026152513921260834, -0.029194574803113937, 0.025093525648117065, -0.014255831949412823, 0.029124271124601364, 0.06196339428424835, -0.012867396697402, 0.03835416957736015, 0.031503643840551376, -0.0628223717212677, -0.006165688391774893, 0.04778461530804634, -0.036406781524419785, 0.048377059400081635, 0.0032768030650913715, 0.028711071237921715, 0.037017352879047394, 0.053218163549900055, -0.004383876919746399, -0.04118429124355316, 0.00934524554759264, 0.01508359145373106, 0.04070085287094116, -0.015922704711556435, 0.02197875641286373, -0.054270755499601364, -0.00985773466527462, -0.050016697496175766, -0.009994572028517723, -0.03263359144330025, -0.03346595913171768, -0.002749023260548711, 0.012686712667346, -0.02656320109963417, 0.03227217495441437, 0.010042062029242516, -0.02459917962551117, 0.07157039642333984, 0.04116463661193848, -0.022671308368444443, -0.04630925878882408, 0.015040010213851929, 0.027212316170334816, -0.0068784840404987335, 0.0023207752965390682, 0.015817545354366302, 0.016191119328141212, -0.0009042947203852236, -0.07224678248167038, -0.01572057418525219, -0.09599848836660385, 0.022938862442970276, 0.05535617470741272, 0.0508272722363472, 0.016984861344099045, 0.02216152288019657, -0.018854251131415367, 0.0005865638959221542, -0.021350447088479996, 0.005970780272036791, 0.06242920085787773, -0.045290809124708176, 0.0037132662255316973, 0.003062003990635276, 0.04489213973283768, -0.008081670850515366, -0.02608417347073555, -0.03666504845023155, 0.02814067155122757, -0.06904703378677368, 0.035552218556404114, -0.000757406756747514, 0.06585749983787537, -0.009289303794503212, 0.01869114674627781, 0.0025330837815999985, -0.0016006319783627987, -0.0033904071897268295, -0.0060049742460250854, 0.021084081381559372, 0.026816699653863907, 0.012907490134239197, 0.012447210028767586, 0.010314450599253178, -0.038362182676792145, -0.05022548511624336, -0.03194532170891762, 0.014570199884474277, -0.0413750484585762, -0.015948127955198288, 0.010861100628972054, 0.002382720820605755, 0.028215192258358, -0.029338758438825607, 0.05257216840982437, 0.02348402328789234, 0.01656694896519184, 0.007515292149037123, 0.07090197503566742, 0.01568269357085228, -0.05774001032114029, -0.04278290644288063, -0.003092064056545496, -0.004656209610402584, -0.030902251601219177, 0.04100034013390541, 0.03545227274298668, -0.0022192387841641903, 0.0054490515030920506, -0.019410740584135056, 0.018606441095471382, -0.0541064478456974, -0.0286109559237957, 0.0492444783449173, 0.060684435069561005, -0.04561571031808853, 0.0915195643901825, -0.011746685020625591, -0.0008679004968144, 0.04466719180345535, -0.000545293209142983, 0.0387350469827652, 0.010611479170620441, 0.052470311522483826, -0.002871087519451976, -0.07268444448709488, 0.008814141154289246, 0.038485586643218994, -0.04222111031413078, 0.0028143373783677816, -0.012610589154064655, -0.01622135564684868, -0.0005214328994043171, 0.006227743346244097, -0.05452420935034752, -0.053593117743730545, 0.014099789783358574, -0.09477157890796661, 0.009982001967728138, -0.024333693087100983, 0.037012726068496704, 0.05955856665968895, 0.004147580824792385, 0.034213803708553314, 0.010970989242196083, -0.07209981232881546, 0.08014407753944397, -0.00020354091248009354, 0.049136366695165634, -0.0021174554713070393, -0.022828981280326843, -0.04334660992026329, 0.022561440244317055, 0.04418957605957985, -0.0001606951846042648, 0.01853221096098423, -0.06739600002765656, -0.006722733378410339, 0.01141023263335228, 0.027135729789733887, -0.001967355376109481, 0.03942414000630379, -0.08620414137840271, -0.009455897845327854, -0.053762998431921005, 0.07951373606920242, 0.0022820434533059597, -0.04817413538694382, 0.019291559234261513, 0.004855395294725895, 0.0055752466432750225, -0.0234973281621933, 0.0439477413892746, 0.04531596228480339, -0.0013323838356882334, -0.041922010481357574, 0.04286031797528267, 0.08316649496555328, 0.0028866443317383528, 0.011544400826096535, 0.02938247099518776, -0.026602469384670258, -0.00004744711986859329, 0.026522362604737282, 0.0307483971118927, 0.06186889857053757, -0.028536977246403694, 0.04311235994100571, 0.0018404287984594703, -0.04506947100162506, -0.05429700389504433, 0.04314021021127701, -0.061572782695293427, -0.04698043689131737, -0.00878812000155449, -0.03402150794863701, -0.03435268998146057, -0.039930351078510284, -0.009927242994308472, 0.016995437443256378, 0.03197663277387619, 0.0010987812420353293, 0.009352832101285458, -0.025247249752283096, -0.017218297347426414, -0.028246380388736725, 0.05884937196969986, -0.03651198372244835, 0.022560982033610344, 0.010987524874508381, -0.00820751953870058, 0.002929884009063244, -0.006178948096930981, -0.006983484607189894, -0.02461804635822773, -0.031508225947618484, -0.03564257547259331, -0.007311566732823849, 0.022689566016197205, 0.00878735352307558, -0.004055554512888193, 0.011461048386991024, 0.03257198631763458, 0.03937609866261482, 0.04287919029593468, -0.02977733500301838, 0.01923978514969349, -0.015128022991120815, 0.09092360734939575, 0.037204064428806305, 0.007027984131127596, -0.026657892391085625, 0.008816560730338097, 0.027900027111172676, 0.016496840864419937, 0.010934021323919296, 0.03872848302125931, 0.02772885002195835, 0.059179455041885376, 0.001970387063920498, 0.02070237696170807, 0.06399906426668167, 0.0009761665132828057, -0.011488602496683598, -0.013262965716421604, 0.09665804356336594, -0.009668315760791302, -0.02432437054812908, 0.0641525611281395, -0.028384055942296982, 0.019785452634096146, -0.01914237067103386, -0.06140590459108353, -0.046442802995443344, -0.0012061642482876778, 0.024755800142884254, -0.040245622396469116, -0.00021806490258313715, 0.005204010754823685, -0.07405805587768555, 0.0550788976252079, 0.03134938329458237, 0.03844355419278145, -0.010959170758724213, 0.060470100492239, 0.04428531974554062, 0.0006003314047120512, 0.017150823026895523, -0.007548277731984854, -0.021647943183779716, -0.023983707651495934, -0.04375666379928589, -0.00982086081057787, -0.07602310925722122, 0.0019784222822636366, -0.016682442277669907, 0.017838377505540848, 0.028073132038116455, -0.028534410521388054, -0.06895394623279572, 0.007445587310940027, -0.037447258830070496, 0.0022787905763834715, -0.04953375458717346, 0.0016390678938478231, 0.005756988190114498, -0.0499357245862484, 0.0079152537509799, 0.007587442174553871, -0.09217994660139084, 0.08200947940349579, 0.003301996737718582, -0.09491642564535141, 0.025476573035120964, -0.012506338767707348, -0.018273035064339638, -0.0015452125808224082, -0.05269605293869972, 0.0340866893529892, 0.009614167734980583, 0.013825292699038982, -0.040846072137355804, -0.022444646805524826, 0.025214310735464096, 0.021991431713104248, -0.005548635497689247, -0.04298599064350128, 0.0011629849905148149, 0.021336335688829422, 0.005604524631053209, 0.019473226740956306, -0.023322129622101784, 0.06683481484651566, -0.03310312330722809, 0.03851138427853584, -0.058220453560352325, 0.017837485298514366, 0.05233539268374443, -0.05794968456029892, -0.004968427587300539, 0.04746747761964798, 0.04731672257184982, -0.07487313449382782, -0.030698563903570175, -0.05188649147748947, 0.00733221834525466, -0.03066728077828884, 0.0532887801527977, 0.014178957790136337, -0.0814167782664299, 0.004613528028130531, 0.02069087326526642, 0.03519503027200699, 0.03734226152300835, 0.011360644362866879, 0.04141426458954811, -0.04532822221517563, -0.00007527890556957573, 0.010136107914149761, 0.023246614262461662, -0.0009968242375180125, -0.055732108652591705, 0.0279777180403471, -0.04740571975708008, -0.05613745376467705, -0.014209489338099957, 0.08640667796134949, 0.05901802331209183, -0.020579352974891663, 0.048072829842567444, -0.049947839230298996, 0.05201083794236183, -0.026468563824892044, -0.016659200191497803, 0.0005675593856722116, -0.015674497932195663, 0.011510221287608147, -0.02970023639500141, 0.01956583373248577, -0.004806453827768564, -0.006231964100152254, 0.02205752581357956, -0.0010851166443899274, 0.029831770807504654, 0.05957512557506561, -0.009293042123317719, -0.03642468526959419, -0.03888769447803497, -0.08535590022802353, 0.044661153107881546, -0.0019915157463401556, 0.05195283144712448, 0.004819095134735107, 0.00012918401625938714, 0.025971435010433197, -0.013878709636628628, -0.012211031280457973, 0.0021740994416177273, 0.003256015945225954, 0.03284855931997299, -0.023579027503728867, -0.06704044342041016, -0.03527618199586868, -0.03362640365958214, 0.00817415863275528, 0.00042803416727110744, -0.034350380301475525, 0.007716752588748932, -0.013732933439314365, -0.042118608951568604, 0.03457556292414665, 0.0444926843047142, -0.09198245406150818, 0.0157810989767313, -0.007258265279233456, -0.04840557649731636, -0.025099532678723335, -0.06021319329738617, -0.037890348583459854, -0.057282380759716034, 0.05619955435395241, -0.0492604598402977, 0.0318082720041275, -0.0022585042752325535, -0.009686056524515152, 0.06900554150342941, -0.016423705965280533, 0.02354491874575615, 0.00363331101834774, -0.04796447604894638, 0.02221713773906231, 0.06163625791668892, 0.01598234660923481, 0.026696180924773216, 0.008511762134730816, 0.02312772534787655, 0.028965555131435394, -0.05139503255486488, -0.013306234031915665, -0.017290718853473663, -0.005867043510079384, -0.012098952196538448, 0.0007868572720326483, 0.050296489149332047, -0.054193999618291855, 0.016187965869903564, -0.008539454080164433, 0.0051563819870352745, 0.060600195080041885, -0.06936469674110413, 0.005591949913650751, 0.008202961646020412, 0.002234647748991847, 0.03673646226525307, -0.03490479290485382, -0.013890870846807957, 0.034589167684316635, 0.019396964460611343, -0.01450120098888874, -0.005145380739122629, -0.010913326404988766, -0.021747052669525146, -0.035035859793424606, 0.04368958994746208, -0.04103801026940346, -0.03221261501312256, 0.014278775081038475, -0.010708598420023918, 0.016199827194213867, 0.024309225380420685, -0.036431122571229935, 0.03724381700158119, -0.007446358446031809, 0.04388368874788284, -0.031735315918922424, -0.04168938472867012, 0.011560898274183273, 0.006223864387720823, -0.007855049334466457, -0.0378621406853199, -0.013772270642220974, 0.009304945357143879, -0.04924818500876427, -0.03439801186323166, -0.05529645085334778, -0.029859796166419983, 0.022135654464364052, 0.03214411810040474, 0.057393915951251984, -0.05710868909955025, -0.02209549956023693, 0.008019120432436466, 0.00039007721352390945, -0.00014999594714026898, -0.024687057361006737, 0.014637126587331295, 0.006648452021181583, 0.057002630084753036, -0.008687306195497513, -0.0332370325922966, -0.010953813791275024, 0.039762359112501144, 0.01848747953772545, 0.0007967548444867134, 0.06021804362535477, -0.03624298423528671, 0.01791590079665184, -0.007153295911848545, 0.026853332296013832, -0.044076357036828995, -0.00904243066906929, -0.056082844734191895, -0.030026284977793694, 0.010180558077991009, 0.0017062315018847585, -0.01646275259554386, 0.013866954483091831, 0.04209292307496071, -0.04482751339673996, 0.02455340139567852, 0.000147525395732373, -0.0321197547018528, -0.028354601934552193, -0.08804525434970856, 0.031572189182043076, -0.03843478858470917, -0.011045197956264019, 0.007633778266608715, 0.0044791921973228455, -0.028206519782543182, 0.01671329326927662, -0.03046119213104248, -0.011868382804095745, 0.014990313909947872, 0.034039899706840515, -0.04049272835254669, -0.010572404600679874, 0.03562801331281662, -0.019131042063236237, 0.010379413142800331, -0.029696671292185783, -0.04353240504860878, -0.013870432041585445, 0.0005628846120089293, -0.0010774806141853333, -0.014065352268517017, -0.017090482637286186, 0.007375760469585657, 0.015173769555985928, 0.08653182536363602, -0.050839971750974655, -0.016297558322548866, -0.006234775297343731, 0.016196325421333313, -0.01746385544538498, -0.006293497513979673, -0.003943714313209057, -0.032238829880952835, 0.02718527801334858, -0.02766755223274231, -0.010370546020567417, -0.01965922676026821, 0.028641121461987495, -0.022905739024281502, 0.007563856430351734, 0.010877085849642754, 0.006380998995155096, 0.041577041149139404, -0.004877040628343821, 0.021840354427695274, 0.033083606511354446, 0.024841254577040672, -0.014210528694093227, -0.02283293940126896, 0.04546249657869339, -0.024748733267188072, 0.006034936290234327, 0.054819151759147644, 0.0126589834690094, -0.00016840550233609974, -0.015295768156647682, 0.01696762442588806, -0.02052859030663967, -0.006426462437957525, -0.03591258451342583, -0.013229135423898697, -0.02079659141600132, 0.021505802869796753, 0.006455575581640005, 0.013467253185808659, -0.005927883088588715 ]
<p>A chain 64 meters long whose mass is 20 kilograms is hanging over the edge of a tall building and does not touch the ground. How much work is required to lift the top 3 meters of the chain to the top of the building? Use that the acceleration due to gravity is 9.8 meters per second squared. Your answer must include the correct units. </p>
g9818
[ 0.042262185364961624, 0.10249635577201843, 0.008172789588570595, -0.0002766411635093391, -0.015989556908607483, 0.0008279343019239604, 0.04425444081425667, 0.034568071365356445, -0.08208309859037399, 0.02791699208319187, -0.024232156574726105, -0.0034968694671988487, -0.08899907022714615, -0.06224008649587631, 0.022759320214390755, 0.04595955088734627, 0.11594165116548538, -0.05014640465378761, 0.018464474007487297, 0.017353443428874016, -0.016443800181150436, -0.017664659768342972, -0.03463181108236313, -0.08098529279232025, -0.022869281470775604, 0.0008362043299712241, -0.006638269405812025, -0.03784750774502754, -0.08637221902608871, 0.047481175512075424, -0.04159403592348099, -0.027842838317155838, -0.006383522879332304, -0.06333047896623611, -0.06116928905248642, -0.003254639683291316, 0.08969120681285858, 0.031064089387655258, -0.006709962151944637, -0.021022189408540726, 0.01573953777551651, -0.024999262765049934, -0.05246065557003021, -0.001074759871698916, 0.014764990657567978, 0.04855278506875038, 0.012138021178543568, 0.04903735965490341, 0.003085671691223979, -0.021209999918937683, -0.07724077999591827, 0.030437590554356575, -0.03425668925046921, 0.005943614058196545, -0.07432658970355988, 0.016702231019735336, 0.05476862192153931, -0.013962148688733578, 0.023172378540039062, 0.03687306120991707, -0.00032652707886882126, -0.04071686044335365, 0.03218813240528107, -0.01925825886428356, 0.03258190304040909, -0.01162915863096714, -0.0019640596583485603, 0.0028227372094988823, 0.029377056285738945, -0.03269775211811066, 0.03431810811161995, -0.014857622794806957, 0.012588425539433956, -0.021712878718972206, -0.03933262452483177, -0.02717551402747631, -0.014485418796539307, -0.013973022811114788, 0.039325740188360214, 0.04276638478040695, 0.03301076591014862, 0.047479454427957535, -0.02895135059952736, -0.04659833386540413, 0.030989181250333786, 0.021532854065299034, -0.038976967334747314, 0.024191590026021004, -0.049307264387607574, 0.03415309265255928, 0.04280967265367508, 0.02738608792424202, 0.08180385082960129, 0.0005770135903730989, -0.03821277990937233, -0.04948132485151291, -0.003052976680919528, 0.0603620707988739, 0.01432995405048132, -0.011777958832681179, -0.048588357865810394, -0.029484497383236885, -0.0013762717135250568, -0.023691369220614433, 0.015223736874759197, -0.01724776066839695, 0.03610222786664963, 0.028858259320259094, 0.009278958663344383, -0.041041821241378784, -0.024968834593892097, -0.009820133447647095, -0.012051431462168694, -0.025988342240452766, -0.060716401785612106, -0.028331497684121132, 0.08816689252853394, 0.020185543224215508, -0.01801127754151821, 0.027727816253900528, -0.02610100992023945, -0.01607610285282135, -0.010956655256450176, 0.0004573057813104242, -0.059226032346487045, -0.05905323848128319, -0.014149913564324379, 0.00748415756970644, 0.0033857456874102354, -0.06680967658758163, -0.015005627647042274, 0.04172161594033241, -0.013716502115130424, 0.0021191381383687258, -0.04029534012079239, 0.014960593543946743, -0.03125230595469475, -0.016369635239243507, 0.01308407448232174, 0.004582428839057684, -0.013611061498522758, -0.04205285385251045, 0.03950641304254532, -0.034180883318185806, -0.029764246195554733, 0.04306519776582718, 0.009427649900317192, 0.012526140548288822, 0.02632668986916542, -0.010035503655672073, -0.03257039189338684, 0.004671723116189241, 0.022361213341355324, -0.026648864150047302, 0.05108123645186424, -0.0022187321446835995, 0.014706260524690151, 0.0406024232506752, 0.02618936076760292, -0.0006228956626728177, 0.05960256606340408, -0.07178915292024612, 0.028103426098823547, -0.01607409678399563, -0.040678225457668304, -0.007662113290280104, 0.04468388482928276, 0.002114935079589486, 0.0032173963263630867, 0.011864044703543186, -0.05015841871500015, -0.04233449324965477, 0.03722100704908371, 0.03791114687919617, -0.06039860472083092, -0.013113415800035, 0.06377749145030975, -0.032513443380594254, 0.00406205840408802, 0.013786163181066513, 0.01386207528412342, -0.059213973581790924, 0.06130751594901085, 0.007462725043296814, -0.05818594992160797, 0.024509726092219353, 0.06975800544023514, 0.026753170415759087, -0.013022617436945438, -0.008672338910400867, -0.029306137934327126, 0.008893058635294437, -0.013239937834441662, 0.02947639860212803, -0.025163497775793076, -0.006367701571434736, 0.03216564655303955, 0.03490227833390236, 0.008670329116284847, -0.028031453490257263, 0.08199185878038406, -0.017869820818305016, 0.02436041831970215, 0.0024780877865850925, 0.04526541009545326, 0.021569201722741127, -0.016264578327536583, 0.006855950690805912, 0.01301658246666193, 0.004643224645406008, -0.03323366492986679, 0.01774599403142929, 0.021366843953728676, 0.03253690525889397, 0.03492794185876846, -0.02685840241611004, 0.0413796603679657, 0.006168846506625414, -0.003887107828631997, 0.03223830834031105, 0.00025180508964695036, -0.03014848753809929, 0.053539253771305084, -0.046468667685985565, -0.009092450141906738, -0.02582954801619053, -0.0032852294389158487, -0.04824697598814964, -0.0041970182210206985, -0.018356936052441597, 0.01616021990776062, 0.023211205378174782, -0.0006334461504593492, -0.025674311444163322, 0.01770772784948349, 0.02722555585205555, 0.029166603460907936, 0.009346773847937584, 0.004155204631388187, 0.006844950374215841, 0.028567161411046982, -0.002415554830804467, 0.0015176971210166812, -0.08419013768434525, 0.026876920834183693, -0.02809961698949337, 0.06180185824632645, 0.00494603393599391, -0.03684897720813751, -0.007237508427351713, 0.017810313031077385, -0.028191884979605675, -0.04476088657975197, 0.009375311434268951, 0.03682935610413551, 0.008893057703971863, -0.05433499068021774, -0.006864192895591259, -0.04906151816248894, -0.016971461474895477, 0.00992522295564413, -0.09724342077970505, -0.012223845347762108, 0.008683658204972744, -0.11020362377166748, 0.003426625858992338, -0.05585802346467972, -0.029290836304426193, 0.013162975199520588, 0.04622389376163483, 0.024674635380506516, 0.016418809071183205, 0.005922413431107998, 0.058783940970897675, -0.043429285287857056, -0.07538416236639023, 0.026669789105653763, -0.012320714071393013, -0.019858263432979584, 0.028804263100028038, 0.038741063326597214, -0.030047409236431122, -0.02035108208656311, 0.06287092715501785, 0.09952433407306671, -0.02223840542137623, -0.028582513332366943, -0.001527008251287043, -0.0458621084690094, -0.007872829213738441, -0.02499297261238098, 0.054206885397434235, 0.06148666515946388, 0.03269060701131821, -0.002144297119230032, 0.09507057070732117, -0.0011902143014594913, -0.013016312383115292, -0.03627210110425949, -0.010981123894453049, 0.010683692060410976, -0.06275799870491028, -0.018340785056352615, 0.020383622497320175, 0.0016347594792023301, -0.0010722180595621467, 0.012133074924349785, -0.0398804135620594, 0.013915829360485077, 0.01866856776177883, -0.04930482804775238, 0.03331039100885391, 0.04302537813782692, -0.033003922551870346, -0.044159919023513794, -0.039545245468616486, 0.045234110206365585, -0.021016934886574745, -0.0657656341791153, -0.011476660147309303, 0.011845092289149761, -0.023575028404593468, 0.012510322965681553, -0.03607485070824623, -0.017667226493358612, 0.040908485651016235, -0.017667941749095917, 0.026923473924398422, -0.051353421062231064, -0.06781578063964844, -0.018113460391759872, 0.008237970992922783, 0.008983176201581955, -0.02067599445581436, -0.06772276759147644, 0.0018572697881609201, 0.052216727286577225, -0.020126650109887123, 0.001048003789037466, -0.03431425243616104, -0.04404887929558754, 0.043133802711963654, -0.06931367516517639, -0.025355687364935875, 0.004567274358123541, -0.0074694533832371235, -0.04129064455628395, 0.00720242178067565, -0.029908087104558945, -0.010506727732717991, 0.04027983173727989, -0.005440761335194111, -0.043595049530267715, -0.03080437146127224, -0.008041968569159508, 0.0372704342007637, 0.042472343891859055, 0.03191264346241951, -0.012505295686423779, -0.005104224197566509, 0.02870500646531582, 0.04435916990041733, 0.04328738525509834, 0.04625115916132927, -0.0271516852080822, 0.0285340566188097, -0.039762597531080246, 0.05478113144636154, 0.029211951419711113, -0.021370278671383858, -0.004214406944811344, -0.054157186299562454, -0.018043246120214462, -0.06224805489182472, 0.05120342969894409, 0.0042485399171710014, 0.022830825299024582, -0.05323927104473114, 0.010540340095758438, 0.017986545339226723, 0.032470639795064926, 0.015586896799504757, -0.05941731482744217, -0.06449974328279495, 0.03732942044734955, 0.011929412372410297, -0.04368749260902405, 0.006784514524042606, 0.004205730278044939, 0.012335635721683502, 0.006070903968065977, -0.036636833101511, 0.024062415584921837, 0.03551849350333214, 0.015585284680128098, -0.05189402401447296, 0.021766239777207375, 0.05494002625346184, -0.020371653139591217, 0.025633586570620537, 0.013545040972530842, 0.048628974705934525, 0.00896253902465105, 0.045116107910871506, -0.04766273498535156, -0.0050760963931679726, 0.034992195665836334, -0.007431107573211193, -0.02233007922768593, 0.09791843593120575, 0.023740338161587715, -0.004412335809320211, -0.027704065665602684, -0.07214419543743134, 0.003771616145968437, 0.030270490795373917, 0.015060845762491226, 0.013690296560525894, -0.016270486637949944, -0.013235236518085003, 0.057335883378982544, 0.04487289860844612, 0.02748630940914154, -0.03015853837132454, -0.005118553526699543, 0.05706341192126274, -0.00045665676589123905, 0.006392110139131546, 0.005035818088799715, 0.03401648625731468, -0.003136335639283061, 0.017640378326177597, -0.02180824615061283, 0.016466611996293068, 0.0041186148300766945, -0.01366901770234108, 0.06021440029144287, 0.045199863612651825, 0.03341906890273094, -0.040090326219797134, 0.029631856828927994, 0.024884365499019623, -0.025851940736174583, 0.035522859543561935, -0.0066689117811620235, 0.025895655155181885, -0.05058678239583969, -0.09993876516819, -0.06045791134238243, 0.01557407807558775, 0.015822583809494972, 0.007129383273422718, -0.023154933005571365, -0.007320433389395475, 0.014115190133452415, 0.025925124064087868, 0.0025921151973307133, -0.016436900943517685, 0.013482938520610332, 0.07284869998693466, -0.028162436559796333, -0.017184384167194366, -0.02394256740808487, 0.027918964624404907, 0.018759192898869514, -0.01760570891201496, -0.027778731659054756, -0.0126957967877388, -0.029836086556315422, 0.04977201670408249, 0.026364613324403763, -0.02350914105772972, -0.015067464672029018, 0.03502418473362923, 0.04278048500418663, -0.0053010256960988045, 0.017488328740000725, 0.03494049236178398, 0.03664831444621086, -0.021815817803144455, -0.006229393184185028, -0.008397288620471954, -0.04303691163659096, -0.01930021494626999, 0.015622129663825035, 0.005011245142668486, -0.007080295123159885, 0.013014433905482292, 0.011644954793155193, 0.0005333188455551863, 0.009670376777648926, 0.05769425630569458, -0.03252733126282692, -0.03452124446630478, -0.04908492788672447, -0.028357040137052536, 0.008901967667043209, -0.02176731452345848, 0.04729664698243141, -0.021646754816174507, -0.02207072637975216, 0.0524604506790638, 0.0018083422910422087, 0.004547864198684692, -0.07236044853925705, 8.074061952356715e-7, -0.014217316173017025, 0.05079726129770279, -0.005086526740342379, 0.07341291755437851, -0.01968626119196415, 0.02507958561182022, 0.049248646944761276, -0.009806908667087555, -0.014972053468227386, -0.02505042776465416, 0.05670347437262535, -0.018253913149237633, -0.004892933648079634, 0.034502699971199036, 0.06837587803602219, 0.00492146285250783, 0.06252747029066086, -0.05914304777979851, 0.0027312871534377337, 0.008825107477605343, -0.030668159946799278, 0.025736110284924507, -0.009542305022478104, 0.025252262130379677, 0.03253781050443649, -0.04429011791944504, -0.05086692422628403, -0.047612641006708145, -0.014406507834792137, -0.0005762034561485052, 0.04061548039317131, 0.04392408952116966, 0.01169823482632637, -0.0422237366437912, -0.02739678882062435, -0.07483743131160736, 0.06111602485179901, 0.030926063656806946, -0.0060388436540961266, -0.03663955256342888, -0.007103367242962122, -0.04332711920142174, 0.026851395145058632, -0.01361879799515009, -0.044410377740859985, 0.030784202739596367, 0.026130251586437225, -0.013999899849295616, 0.0076612429693341255, 0.0427732840180397, -0.026700735092163086, -0.007802248001098633, -0.013429360464215279, -0.033212583512067795, 0.08669373393058777, 0.006673697382211685, 0.038954269140958786, 0.0776854008436203, 0.061063844710588455, -0.036374520510435104, -0.026268696412444115, 0.03156723454594612, 0.027629246935248375, 0.015789471566677094, 0.02091916650533676, 0.0073344218544662, -0.0464317761361599, 0.01634570024907589, -0.015491798520088196, 0.06162891909480095, -0.005570008419454098, -0.007583435624837875, -0.06648541986942291, -0.004741930402815342, -0.02524729259312153, 0.011508136056363583, 0.001385499956086278, -0.07858934253454208, -0.01414747629314661, -0.02090674638748169, -0.001659018686041236, -0.03331383690237999, -0.04468627646565437, 0.019901219755411148, -0.026448972523212433, -0.03307618200778961, -0.07655593007802963, 0.009358801878988743, -0.01123888697475195, -0.05621632933616638, 0.01643308624625206, -0.018944356590509415, -0.027809686958789825, 0.03657550737261772, 0.029592446982860565, 0.0022946076933294535, 0.04568629339337349, -0.051704104989767075, 0.06739407032728195, 0.047300875186920166, -0.005485510919243097, 0.028347209095954895, -0.02857082337141037, -0.04080336540937424, 0.040333110839128494, 0.055265557020902634, 0.05027437210083008, 0.0654439628124237, -0.020174719393253326, -0.014101441949605942, 0.06425781548023224, 0.0042002322152256966, -0.0011849362635985017, -0.029691388830542564, 0.009427669458091259, -0.0020356327295303345, 0.019013389945030212, -0.06772813946008682, -0.0031028222292661667, -0.04622882977128029, 0.034132760018110275, 0.04764445871114731, 0.004667215049266815, -0.02020767703652382, -0.024386856704950333, 0.06624935567378998, -0.0296634491533041, -0.014289876446127892, -0.03934302553534508, 0.0764763131737709, 0.00018374796491116285, 0.04896754026412964, -0.018011130392551422, 0.045466966927051544, 0.03587660193443298, -0.032896488904953, 0.0006863380549475551, 0.016043812036514282, -0.030255960300564766, -0.04685145616531372, 0.025068340823054314, 0.0011511269258335233, 0.010843305848538876, -0.023125823587179184, -0.042463820427656174, -0.022838063538074493, -0.03216157481074333, 0.04540096968412399, -0.024616481736302376, -0.033764105290174484, -0.008830857463181019, 0.019569896161556244, 0.0002715791924856603, -0.021898627281188965, 0.010320698842406273, -0.027816949412226677, 0.034801729023456573, 0.00036484687007032335, 0.005844253581017256, 0.025593262165784836, -0.008831779472529888, 0.004710216075181961, -0.022640809416770935, 0.039795733988285065, -0.0275785680860281, -0.028954096138477325, -0.06285612285137177, 0.00557636609300971, -0.00479477271437645, -0.023037130013108253, -0.043092306703329086, -0.008602425456047058, -0.014091307297348976, -0.01480929646641016, -0.0031558992341160774, 0.012559513561427593, -0.07957491278648376, 0.009583767503499985, 0.08051314949989319, 0.07108819484710693, 0.018899690359830856, 0.03316318616271019, 0.08074638992547989, -0.022054022178053856, -0.012432247400283813, 0.06976533681154251, 0.01999225653707981, -0.0583883635699749, -0.008358161896467209, 0.07097653299570084, 0.017444882541894913, -0.049100082367658615, 0.08159832656383514, -0.02074018493294716, 0.00026086074649356306, 0.01637422852218151, -0.019686970859766006, 0.06880785524845123, -0.011590421199798584, 0.02617730386555195, 0.027952348813414574, -0.02204543724656105, 0.003767804941162467, 0.01596914604306221, -0.043308354914188385, -0.024273058399558067, 0.003467254340648651, 0.03018929995596409, 0.0575212761759758, 0.03903115540742874, -0.030931221321225166, 0.037361904978752136, -0.03263850510120392, -0.022250453010201454, 0.003351292572915554, 0.016163725405931473, -0.0521993562579155, -0.08649000525474548, -0.05058525875210762, 0.005129956640303135, -0.005692208185791969, 0.014203844591975212, -0.013964139856398106, -0.030096327885985374, 0.022345397621393204, -0.01974901556968689, -0.05368044972419739, 0.0222188588231802, -0.045561179518699646, -0.0185434240847826, 0.035870302468538284, -0.023100130259990692, 0.010121453553438187, 0.058579497039318085, -0.023373665288090706, -0.004092899616807699, -0.07256890833377838, 0.044757090508937836, 0.033438246697187424, 0.007799960672855377, -0.01047454122453928, 0.04054354503750801, 0.05542797967791557, -0.042646296322345734, 0.0015260404907166958, 0.030781978741288185, 0.02502620220184326, 0.013779930770397186, -0.02586011216044426, -0.014636234380304813, -0.012199832126498222, -0.026141811162233353, -0.02204280160367489, -0.05777490884065628, -0.028837602585554123, -0.012470487505197525, 0.03450500965118408, -0.050194162875413895, 0.07593733072280884, -0.03774689882993698, 0.0006694219191558659, 0.020769326016306877 ]
<p>We were learning about Boyle's law (pressure is inversely proportional to volume of a gas) and in the experiment to prove the law, we were told that we cannot change the volume of a gas too rapidly without affecting its temperature.</p> <p>I have two questions about this:</p> <ol> <li>Why does temperature of a gas change when its volume changes very rapidly?</li> <li>This process (rapid changes in volume) is used in the liquefaction of gases. How is this done?</li> </ol>
g9819
[ 0.07311336696147919, -0.015550032258033752, 0.014374501071870327, -0.017620880156755447, 0.028437862172722816, -0.039377275854349136, 0.001917579909786582, 0.06922103464603424, -0.04380117356777191, 0.034107230603694916, -0.007602182682603598, 0.033924683928489685, 0.04210289567708969, 0.009099312126636505, 0.050872668623924255, -0.002847858238965273, 0.08166427165269852, -0.005688898265361786, 0.006633429788053036, -0.008869778364896774, -0.062324948608875275, -0.01739298179745674, -0.015223018825054169, -0.061910953372716904, -0.02727542258799076, -0.04777937009930611, 0.03528547286987305, 0.01943991519510746, 0.015491754747927189, 0.003488930407911539, -0.04401541128754616, 0.011046845465898514, -0.003972977865487337, -0.10842431336641312, 0.034263674169778824, -0.0014080812688916922, 0.04880683869123459, -0.03791474923491478, 0.034362442791461945, 0.01586199179291725, -0.016055505722761154, -0.027334444224834442, 0.07703450322151184, -0.017389651387929916, 0.006111571565270424, 0.004850991070270538, -0.053668197244405746, -0.00858704186975956, -0.01050443947315216, -0.025448841974139214, 0.0036289067938923836, 0.03163379430770874, -0.03680019453167915, -0.0025849363300949335, -0.04548431932926178, 0.037373147904872894, -0.001114305341616273, -0.030222829431295395, 0.054434679448604584, 0.001991586061194539, -0.006252193823456764, -0.036628179252147675, 0.043233342468738556, 0.006587127223610878, -0.00031519902404397726, -0.06031244993209839, -0.006819801405072212, -0.02380216494202614, 0.05095965787768364, 0.037922997027635574, -0.01457187719643116, -0.01836034283041954, 0.017970697954297066, -0.06582900136709213, -0.022128812968730927, -0.012423920445144176, 0.06624875217676163, -0.008041372522711754, -0.027642743661999702, -0.032813139259815216, -0.06496817618608475, -0.0028309652116149664, 0.016038576140999794, 0.032666660845279694, -0.012767968699336052, -0.03350836783647537, 0.024430325254797935, 0.018459592014551163, -0.009080799296498299, -0.019329044967889786, -0.0294022299349308, -0.015233698301017284, 0.09880437701940536, 0.028495339676737785, -0.016016270965337753, 0.011541124433279037, 0.021041689440608025, 0.040805596858263016, 0.03409610316157341, 0.01722140796482563, -0.011087587103247643, -0.03269821032881737, 0.03380334749817848, 0.020793750882148743, -0.0566018782556057, 0.02932759001851082, -0.026494184508919716, 0.028421374037861824, -0.03068333864212036, -0.006585533730685711, -0.04291892796754837, -0.06478170305490494, -0.06818154454231262, -0.047461189329624176, 0.017192892730236053, 0.02167782187461853, 0.02171969786286354, 0.05975646898150444, 0.022271886467933655, 0.0541655533015728, 0.021530669182538986, 0.027906153351068497, 0.043692659586668015, -0.06284526735544205, 0.037607740610837936, -0.08142706006765366, 0.019046522676944733, 0.03223692998290062, 0.017004577443003654, -0.01798327825963497, -0.007170549128204584, 0.0555039718747139, -0.08036545664072037, -0.008176550269126892, 0.030851999297738075, -0.009466880932450294, -0.003515138989314437, 0.021676860749721527, 0.0007319404976442456, -0.04194435104727745, 0.05892886593937874, 0.01897798478603363, 0.023022029548883438, 0.0196002759039402, -0.025340212509036064, 0.010557563975453377, -0.08300381898880005, 0.0409226194024086, 0.022143710404634476, -0.03321662172675133, -0.024078501388430595, 0.005895827431231737, 0.06996052712202072, -0.016697784885764122, -0.010198794305324554, 0.010343817993998528, 0.009437933564186096, -0.005629288498312235, 0.03362787887454033, -0.019500361755490303, 0.015603536739945412, -0.05817735940217972, -0.022549336776137352, 0.0361519418656826, -0.05699571967124939, 0.07558378577232361, 0.032863371074199677, -0.02949310839176178, -0.01052895188331604, 0.022255081683397293, -0.05057996138930321, 0.012652140110731125, -0.04712870717048645, 0.05076541379094124, 0.04429253563284874, 0.03936782479286194, 0.06527403742074966, -0.003150727367028594, -0.01720411144196987, -0.037284523248672485, 0.005693600978702307, -0.0524369440972805, 0.009015403687953949, -0.06550516188144684, 0.012233691290020943, 0.08530440181493759, -0.02052217163145542, -0.023194408044219017, -0.07093784958124161, 0.017558755353093147, -0.007869444787502289, -0.01878325082361698, -0.03654260188341141, -0.02472495473921299, 0.008577113971114159, -0.03448645770549774, 0.0017076927470043302, -0.02391904592514038, -0.0752544105052948, 0.02158050611615181, -0.047591350972652435, -0.05355491861701012, -0.017626341432332993, 0.04778682067990303, 0.005818378645926714, 0.012943017296493053, -0.06554699689149857, 0.004364066291600466, 0.03488628938794136, 0.01635044254362583, 0.03682224079966545, -0.0032772289123386145, 0.021184878423810005, -0.03206661343574524, 0.008202044293284416, 0.04382771998643875, 0.004786227364093065, 0.06981067359447479, 0.023149074986577034, 0.020052632316946983, 0.03683886677026749, -0.0020093007478863, 0.04607246443629265, 0.03182215243577957, 0.034158892929553986, -0.07986298948526382, 0.01110632810741663, -0.02436310239136219, -0.0253274105489254, 0.04190397262573242, -0.04730885103344917, 0.07583403587341309, -0.018650202080607414, 0.007771732285618782, -0.003915884997695684, 0.06093686819076538, 0.00047605091822333634, 0.03205878287553787, 0.08144453167915344, 0.055764611810445786, 0.01930950954556465, -0.039327848702669144, -0.008558625355362892, 0.038407716900110245, -0.02075900137424469, -0.03896281123161316, 0.02983718551695347, -0.047355178743600845, -0.012681625783443451, 0.04704205319285393, -0.03827160224318504, 0.021350357681512833, -0.03765871003270149, 0.004412010312080383, -0.00993821956217289, -0.006570638623088598, -0.02194899320602417, 0.06796453148126602, 0.03202066197991371, -0.014179217629134655, 0.03034869208931923, 0.013941832818090916, 0.07110732793807983, -0.012607332319021225, -0.030291028320789337, -0.02331450954079628, -0.03929521143436432, 0.0144035704433918, 0.00848408043384552, 0.006189597304910421, -0.004336307290941477, 0.005740608554333448, -0.05526195466518402, 0.05838697403669357, 0.004077989608049393, -0.006873749196529388, 0.031050221994519234, -0.10162314027547836, 0.05950731784105301, -0.03810388222336769, 0.03706101328134537, -0.037799011915922165, -0.08332979679107666, 0.055595096200704575, 0.011213276535272598, -0.03064231388270855, 0.01300916075706482, 0.004193626809865236, -0.01454688049852848, -0.023697379976511, -0.005924923811107874, 0.004504148382693529, -0.002547666197642684, 0.00802029762417078, -0.004733928944915533, 0.03608031943440437, -0.008781954646110535, -0.026385905221104622, -0.011719762347638607, -0.015386386774480343, 0.039032842963933945, -0.06293089687824249, -0.026942210271954536, 0.04722516983747482, 0.024481095373630524, 0.036391764879226685, -0.06534488499164581, 0.03691045939922333, -0.014242776669561863, 0.023251784965395927, -0.009543845430016518, -0.045375268906354904, -0.015377172268927097, -0.020437825471162796, -0.03261960297822952, -0.002021580468863249, 0.01723478175699711, 0.028338046744465828, 0.04916360601782799, -0.02899799309670925, -0.05258806422352791, -0.030560243874788284, -0.004198962356895208, -0.061649348586797714, 0.045136574655771255, -0.0022731332574039698, -0.015918610617518425, -0.05824807658791542, -0.010217633098363876, -0.03701530396938324, 0.017237702384591103, 0.02158988080918789, -0.0177829060703516, -0.05308392643928528, 0.02251562289893627, -0.03784146159887314, -0.0013115323381498456, -0.0009528183727525175, -0.010961649008095264, 0.027020195499062538, 0.0054829176515340805, -0.035767897963523865, -0.043185338377952576, 0.045043207705020905, 0.05727793276309967, -0.020682064816355705, -0.004601680673658848, -0.012244697660207748, -0.008262034505605698, 0.0327620729804039, 0.08077007532119751, -0.022740410640835762, 0.027512725442647934, -0.00409207958728075, 0.009709945879876614, -0.005795604549348354, 0.06467987596988678, 0.02986184135079384, -0.0033965688198804855, -0.037857647985219955, -0.0038980343379080296, -0.04686766117811203, 0.010614286176860332, 0.05779459327459335, -0.022468894720077515, 0.053049519658088684, 0.04775970056653023, -0.020673494786024094, -0.04188062623143196, -0.000551321601960808, -0.01029749121516943, -0.06663157790899277, -0.00860502663999796, 0.02377944625914097, 0.06760534644126892, -0.03135368973016739, -0.01212234329432249, 0.06892993301153183, -0.03190715238451958, 0.04649036377668381, 0.006220887415111065, 0.03035500831902027, 0.01344496849924326, -0.04681478068232536, -0.030389001592993736, -0.03518537059426308, -0.05174151062965393, 0.00913565419614315, 0.059471599757671356, -0.10300812125205994, 0.0155492527410388, -0.009762200526893139, 0.009528553113341331, 0.0014957872917875648, -0.0014842153759673238, -0.010394929908216, 0.048057667911052704, -0.029124528169631958, -0.021134797483682632, 0.009842993691563606, -0.026475155726075172, -0.009450046345591545, 0.021208610385656357, 0.006635961588472128, -0.029693808406591415, 0.056655555963516235, 0.07850153744220734, -0.0840105339884758, 0.01775386556982994, 0.010005655698478222, 0.012730205431580544, -0.03681321442127228, -0.033664047718048096, -0.026565678417682648, 0.002705572871491313, -0.013872619718313217, 0.004837093874812126, 0.004901006352156401, 0.017782840877771378, 0.00668983394280076, 0.02304767817258835, 0.0007595950737595558, -0.04974420741200447, -0.01760903373360634, 0.03735880181193352, 0.05810430645942688, 0.07080215960741043, 0.013216988183557987, 0.030335042625665665, -0.052761010825634, 0.01715567335486412, -0.013917669653892517, -0.02653316594660282, 0.02668232098221779, 0.020314384251832962, 0.018375935032963753, -0.01908124051988125, 0.03923562541604042, -0.06644934415817261, 0.08867507427930832, 0.03165500611066818, 0.032118409872055054, -0.04452674835920334, 0.0218561589717865, 0.0005681641632691026, -0.02423437125980854, -0.022624973207712173, 0.0018353768391534686, 0.007563766557723284, -0.0666571855545044, -0.017445256933569908, 0.0520821139216423, 0.04159202426671982, -0.026168502867221832, 0.03216453269124031, -0.01929304748773575, -0.03622477874159813, 0.0435018390417099, -0.031827762722969055, 0.030365031212568283, -0.06262865662574768, -0.003451516153290868, -0.03129102289676666, 0.047107286751270294, -0.0336754210293293, -0.0118806017562747, -0.0105243856087327, -0.06302746385335922, -0.01810625195503235, -0.0023895965423434973, 0.009430945850908756, -0.009930567815899849, 0.004469139035791159, 0.032146599143743515, 0.009936599992215633, -0.01636606641113758, 0.015152321197092533, -0.017802530899643898, 0.020330015569925308, -0.06600554287433624, -0.011353343725204468, -0.00421546958386898, 0.04435558617115021, 0.02412973716855049, 0.00007546237611677498, -0.027318783104419708, -0.02764747105538845, -0.05033392459154129, 0.04721604287624359, -0.002971971407532692, -0.0335136316716671, 0.07376473397016525, 0.04271453246474266, 0.09469813108444214, 0.007763462606817484, -0.005471298936754465, 0.013677516020834446, -0.015905166044831276, -0.04423343762755394, 0.0586107075214386, -0.05991673469543457, 0.03983452171087265, -0.019744375720620155, -0.008744888938963413, -0.040968287736177444, 0.0180270504206419, -0.029069947078824043, 0.023498598486185074, 0.022975997999310493, 0.0475420244038105, -0.0004138950607739389, 0.014387554489076138, 0.042028460651636124, -0.008073564618825912, 0.03559331223368645, -0.06044960767030716, 0.007168636657297611, -0.057350434362888336, -0.02678772434592247, 0.024710454046726227, 0.012808355502784252, -0.03749144449830055, 0.03203762695193291, 0.04093107208609581, -0.04283948987722397, 0.02473280392587185, -0.04577005282044411, -0.04060622677206993, 0.03463880717754364, 0.02777254581451416, -0.040105681866407394, -0.012797900475561619, 0.05239666625857353, 0.0009828880429267883, -0.07456947863101959, 0.0523994080722332, -0.013323596678674221, 0.03189673274755478, 0.021478742361068726, 0.03852261230349541, 0.02783912979066372, -0.06197007745504379, 0.015986209735274315, 0.05246971175074577, 0.008274845778942108, -0.005342246498912573, -0.001583861536346376, 0.03036668337881565, 0.01610349491238594, -0.022839520126581192, 0.014892327599227428, 0.008569842204451561, 0.034993357956409454, -0.002156463684514165, 0.02361893467605114, 0.004771753679960966, 0.031005384400486946, 0.015656206756830215, -0.02350492589175701, 0.01494649238884449, 0.043875012546777725, 0.003650168189778924, 0.03536441549658775, 0.018731465563178062, 0.02066662907600403, -0.08483550697565079, -0.0159588735550642, 0.02695603109896183, 0.03995898365974426, 0.019692739471793175, -0.007919042371213436, -0.02133331447839737, -0.024163495749235153, -0.08957376331090927, 0.059245072305202484, -0.012201973237097263, 0.006070601753890514, 0.02089410461485386, -0.019643226638436317, -0.010447733104228973, -0.04224050045013428, -0.011722338385879993, -0.031849455088377, -0.043434448540210724, -0.02752995304763317, 0.0003379982663318515, -0.005755557678639889, 0.045503564178943634, 0.000857068516779691, -0.016115205362439156, 0.0029368626419454813, -0.07790373265743256, -0.025462215766310692, -0.03521601855754852, 0.017258770763874054, -0.02647286094725132, -0.06902629137039185, 0.017828594893217087, 0.005050308536738157, 0.011467519216239452, 0.003172541968524456, 0.02034025825560093, 0.005816679913550615, -0.052341558039188385, -0.01392887718975544, -0.0447692833840847, 0.008186813443899155, 0.006359003018587828, 0.013971095904707909, -0.0014560798881575465, -0.060167763382196426, 0.013522282242774963, 0.03591245040297508, -0.04304961860179901, 0.027194874361157417, -0.018214037641882896, 0.031792476773262024, 0.04690049961209297, 0.03518513962626457, -0.008190128952264786, -0.005048509221524, -0.04762962460517883, 0.0808558389544487, 0.046655815094709396, 0.05088484287261963, 0.009890957735478878, -0.049258194863796234, 0.0006855817046016455, 0.02706308290362358, -0.02076980285346508, 0.040668752044439316, -0.026964690536260605, -0.08801708370447159, 0.01184337679296732, -0.006239950191229582, -0.015221314504742622, -0.09020420163869858, 0.002558109350502491, 0.021327901631593704, -0.00017865101108327508, -0.028597794473171234, 0.0054101888090372086, 0.03017779253423214, 0.04558456689119339, 0.02183366008102894, 0.011688302271068096, -0.016497058793902397, -0.028938785195350647, -0.05959000438451767, 0.022854162380099297, -0.015086091123521328, 0.000015126364814932458, -0.04474369063973427, 0.03923726826906204, 0.023706957697868347, 0.019455580040812492, 0.00351615808904171, 0.033753860741853714, -0.0325327031314373, -0.03756766393780708, -0.0648811012506485, -0.01736897975206375, 0.032713357359170914, -0.007419897243380547, 0.04827965050935745, 0.026481224223971367, -0.026250122115015984, -0.09107545018196106, 0.05712870508432388, -0.06175888702273369, -0.017088517546653748, -0.04641476273536682, 0.0014231824316084385, -0.0011682499898597598, 0.02570492774248123, 0.054775651544332504, 0.0011737084714695811, 0.04814404249191284, 0.05396893247961998, 0.053904224187135696, -0.05328729376196861, 0.010406490415334702, 0.009973571635782719, -0.07787635922431946, -0.053559720516204834, 0.013711065985262394, -0.017697012051939964, 0.06546935439109802, 0.0031883600167930126, -0.03766745328903198, 0.0036642691120505333, -0.007675149478018284, -0.0351136140525341, 0.02150999940931797, 0.021864410489797592, 0.012767958454787731, 0.02086540497839451, -0.046384669840335846, 0.0048791104927659035, 0.008276096545159817, 0.0016883990028873086, -0.02644793502986431, -0.0778718963265419, 0.008779684081673622, 0.037103768438100815, 0.02104121632874012, 0.03983461856842041, 0.0183247122913599, -0.05703439563512802, 0.01748625375330448, 0.008199512027204037, 0.05822816863656044, 0.01700815185904503, 0.016396572813391685, 0.051219839602708817, -0.01637638919055462, -0.004878579638898373, 0.009368881583213806, 0.0029299582820385695, 0.025388866662979126, -0.027611786499619484, -0.025410588830709457, 0.03602144122123718, -0.03856732323765755, -0.026931067928671837, 0.011402716860175133, 0.015394928865134716, -0.031515173614025116, 0.014132816344499588, 0.02825266681611538, 0.00972843635827303, 0.04594634100794792, 0.0067324088886380196, 0.009156109765172005, -0.038666289299726486, 0.04891457036137581, 0.06664540618658066, -0.026237385347485542, 0.01956668123602867, 0.06100025773048401, 0.04727008193731308, -0.002922074170783162, 0.029211711138486862, -0.012803339399397373, 0.001587506732903421, -0.06973163783550262, -0.03243327513337135, 0.03837846592068672, -0.013878745958209038, -0.032963670790195465, -0.014768348075449467, 0.001506403903476894, -0.045431677252054214, -0.005011301022022963, -0.012302734889090061, -0.05477229878306389, -0.03623531758785248, 0.019325263798236847, 0.007688392419368029, -0.053950101137161255, -0.06356409192085266, 0.048324111849069595, 0.002902529202401638, -0.033952757716178894, 0.011384688317775726, -0.02845226228237152, -0.012040271423757076, 0.030122840777039528 ]
<p>I was watching The Return of the King and just after Frodo and Sam destroy the One Ring, they run out of the mountain and hide on top of a rock as the volcano erupts and lava flows past them. Is this actually feasible or would they have been roasting alive?</p> <p>Here's an image for reference.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/JLD9T.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
g9820
[ -0.01605476252734661, -0.02148350514471531, 0.008981038816273212, 0.03617067262530327, -0.026401173323392868, 0.011648869141936302, -0.07436086982488632, 0.021968556568026543, -0.028478024527430534, 0.009301124140620232, -0.007739342283457518, 0.009052854962646961, 0.046769607812166214, -0.02610700950026512, -0.027976535260677338, -0.0029515663627535105, 0.04262711480259895, -0.018294604495167732, -0.01630842126905918, -0.008452269248664379, -0.07179678231477737, -0.021973183378577232, -0.02582940272986889, 0.03219742327928543, -0.040313057601451874, -0.046461302787065506, -0.004123672842979431, 0.01937408186495304, -0.023773271590471268, -0.03351554647088051, -0.004973231814801693, 0.008192635141313076, 0.01463303528726101, -0.04756718501448631, -0.02018919214606285, -0.04942282289266586, 0.06262137740850449, -0.025212282314896584, 0.00837739184498787, -0.016159983351826668, 0.006551400292664766, -0.041043441742658615, 0.018163954839110374, 0.08429337292909622, -0.0003474459226708859, -0.02265336364507675, 0.022865397855639458, -0.03583281487226486, 0.011057576164603233, -0.04776736721396446, -0.03007049858570099, -0.0097457030788064, -0.05474167689681053, -0.04954046756029129, -0.044808752834796906, -0.01167966052889824, 0.021439913660287857, -0.004691591951996088, 0.002277638064697385, -0.03615238144993782, -0.019436875358223915, -0.024803850799798965, 0.01523385290056467, -0.036648742854595184, 0.04656040668487549, -0.017197567969560623, -0.08968847244977951, 0.025339188054203987, 0.01160911750048399, -0.008267943747341633, 0.05256778374314308, 0.004952383227646351, 0.009282180108129978, -0.016118507832288742, 0.010226585902273655, 0.07040897756814957, 0.049828700721263885, -0.029558300971984863, -0.006443213205784559, 0.004578697495162487, -0.002337984275072813, 0.004542066249996424, -0.018039118498563766, -0.006447614170610905, -0.04202901944518089, 0.0198407843708992, 0.013950432650744915, -0.004522778559476137, 0.03582325950264931, 0.0014378625201061368, -0.05982496961951256, -0.027670595794916153, 0.07684114575386047, 0.01233227550983429, 0.05506855994462967, -0.012984557077288628, -0.052732910960912704, -0.0027644832152873278, -0.03455740958452225, 0.004924614913761616, -0.003689474891871214, -0.014502073638141155, -0.033661406487226486, 0.009003693237900734, 0.011126626282930374, -0.020251838490366936, 0.026246685534715652, 0.04741290211677551, -0.023986633867025375, 0.0034459345042705536, 0.004691154230386019, -0.007878188975155354, -0.030505964532494545, 0.019432751461863518, 0.01608005352318287, 0.027539147064089775, 0.022433383390307426, 0.004715695045888424, 0.020481806248426437, 0.0004536817141342908, 0.0136391781270504, 0.003589761210605502, -0.030326753854751587, -0.013887842185795307, -0.018725479021668434, -0.00012982117186766118, 0.010412592440843582, -0.03957398235797882, 0.06979844719171524, 0.020844077691435814, -0.013388555496931076, 0.026598645374178886, 0.023502130061388016, 0.013393182307481766, 0.09206251055002213, 0.023244913667440414, -0.002533581806346774, 0.08993114531040192, 0.013319358229637146, -0.02035350725054741, 0.11714627593755722, 0.00814822781831026, -0.01188527699559927, -0.029655305668711662, 0.022700387984514236, -0.014326145872473717, 0.04390958324074745, 0.06401477009057999, -0.016651513054966927, 0.029473423957824707, -0.02479875087738037, 0.04223969206213951, 0.056590884923934937, 0.003329592291265726, 0.02485967054963112, 0.06036018580198288, -0.04278113320469856, 0.07909087836742401, 0.009534330107271671, -0.032315369695425034, -0.0025140412617474794, -0.058995090425014496, 0.0378919392824173, -0.045865897089242935, -0.03842341527342796, 0.027755893766880035, 0.044835563749074936, -0.013706807978451252, 0.013028855435550213, -0.006421076133847237, -0.00003733740231837146, 0.027033425867557526, 0.014643901027739048, 0.02092650532722473, 0.002781868679448962, -0.02986130118370056, -0.011594114825129509, -0.013297504745423794, -0.0420968234539032, -0.0004339352890383452, 0.027053171768784523, 0.028919491916894913, -0.0072075012139976025, 0.03439246863126755, 0.10526920855045319, -0.017286960035562515, 0.017906920984387398, 0.03311445191502571, 0.003206070512533188, -0.06239242106676102, -0.00005253987546893768, 0.004152591805905104, -0.013010739348828793, 0.04328521341085434, -0.013168973848223686, -0.041152238845825195, -0.04017253965139389, 0.004679397214204073, 0.03282919526100159, 0.006293615326285362, 0.00881819985806942, -0.007252277806401253, 0.0053527867421507835, 0.0007881412748247385, -0.05190297216176987, -0.030027372762560844, -0.009333730675280094, -0.016032276675105095, -0.019607437774538994, -0.07107044756412506, -0.02052396535873413, 0.014916367828845978, -0.03560782968997955, -0.021864237263798714, -0.050376664847135544, 0.011768334545195103, 0.0034539552871137857, 0.03225254267454147, -0.054843127727508545, -0.005324717611074448, -0.025692284107208252, 0.04403509944677353, 0.01851552352309227, -0.005322279874235392, 0.08147282898426056, -0.03493762016296387, -0.016425203531980515, 0.011338170617818832, -0.037505142390728, 0.02108614519238472, -0.026369033381342888, 0.004976373631507158, 0.007336520589888096, -0.06440520286560059, 0.07070425152778625, 0.05367987975478172, 0.04941907897591591, 0.03764168918132782, -0.00453048525378108, 0.04249587282538414, 0.02119939960539341, -0.07433457672595978, -0.017977839335799217, -0.01657782681286335, 0.046620503067970276, -0.012811996042728424, -0.004609327297657728, -0.018860220909118652, -0.03365519270300865, 0.03823781758546829, 0.010489111766219139, -0.046304479241371155, 0.021964268758893013, -0.032020725309848785, -0.027556173503398895, 0.011915601789951324, -0.06396940350532532, -0.051375843584537506, 0.01697067730128765, 0.01493433490395546, -0.019481239840388298, -0.02825845405459404, 0.0008488243329338729, 0.017389459535479546, -0.02333354949951172, 0.00564667209982872, 0.028630785644054413, 0.03293238952755928, -0.051071248948574066, -0.002892333548516035, -0.049215491861104965, -0.040767740458250046, 0.06222943589091301, 0.027086462825536728, -0.07018908858299255, 0.040172889828681946, 0.015308749862015247, -0.03040185756981373, 0.027591872960329056, 0.01711093634366989, 0.011807654052972794, -0.007523096166551113, -0.029441678896546364, 0.030185405164957047, 0.05645280331373215, -0.03571103513240814, -0.03329164534807205, 0.013179376721382141, -0.023497700691223145, -0.04130614548921585, 0.030464181676506996, -0.021802159026265144, 0.0011370875872671604, 0.07575371116399765, -0.05941101908683777, 0.0389464907348156, 0.03433401882648468, -0.07620245963335037, 0.006774613168090582, 0.0036676793824881315, 0.04780702292919159, -0.05294949561357498, -0.040469828993082047, 0.026903657242655754, -0.016818374395370483, 0.05696349963545799, 0.020548628643155098, -0.008785230107605457, -0.007351073902100325, -0.04557451605796814, -0.023492058739066124, 0.07433298230171204, -0.020306838676333427, 0.05180468410253525, 0.045262277126312256, 0.01734679564833641, -0.023238468915224075, -0.014058951288461685, 0.14735183119773865, 0.07543046772480011, -0.04941394552588463, -0.02629958651959896, -0.03168840333819389, 0.031164539977908134, 0.05352432653307915, -0.015363282524049282, -0.10606744885444641, -0.03622719272971153, -0.0481921024620533, -0.008108282461762428, -0.011293561197817326, 0.04696768522262573, 0.0017968211323022842, -0.020379114896059036, -0.012979786843061447, 0.0008995711687020957, -0.014707324095070362, 0.0269461739808321, 0.004611686337739229, -0.05843554064631462, -0.0490170456469059, -0.02300175279378891, 0.02827843651175499, -0.01006241049617529, 0.03806855529546738, 0.04005492106080055, -0.023567786440253258, -0.03476203605532646, 0.013578403741121292, -0.01427682489156723, -0.020993920043110847, -0.058297500014305115, 0.0084915766492486, -0.021567538380622864, 0.0037386410403996706, 0.05085567757487297, 0.02425571344792843, -0.0024313058238476515, 0.0686972439289093, -0.009058341383934021, -0.02849358692765236, 0.009359532967209816, 0.07836452126502991, -0.06997212022542953, 0.006178580690175295, 0.014954840764403343, -0.07372657209634781, 0.03151081129908562, -0.0075086322613060474, 0.03235156834125519, 0.09032486379146576, -0.011041006073355675, -0.03483130410313606, -0.016419051215052605, 0.07492028921842575, -0.000588000868447125, 0.022634729743003845, 0.0027290310245007277, -0.013427487574517727, 0.046177830547094345, 0.03328666090965271, -0.018732255324721336, 0.061646029353141785, -0.0006299932138063014, -0.03834591060876846, 0.006434152368456125, 0.020877301692962646, -0.06314641982316971, -0.003456070087850094, 0.026763278990983963, 0.027294540777802467, -0.014160317368805408, 0.015059329569339752, 0.05529363453388214, 0.013235215097665787, 0.0013643092243000865, -0.010188378393650055, -0.05170739069581032, -0.016872670501470566, 0.053746916353702545, 0.0544193871319294, 0.016398495063185692, -0.03574743494391441, 0.03181628882884979, 0.002367495559155941, -0.014353781938552856, 0.04054730385541916, 0.027818726375699043, -0.006208968348801136, -0.005117467138916254, -0.039859555661678314, 0.044279806315898895, -0.012286528944969177, 0.008962899446487427, 0.051458731293678284, -0.016154995188117027, -0.0023343940265476704, 0.05875398963689804, 0.013902564533054829, -0.0006740426179021597, -0.027335606515407562, -0.004007484298199415, -0.02028103731572628, 0.0003600739873945713, 0.006671564187854528, -0.0452689528465271, 0.002988658845424652, -0.01920093037188053, 0.027930479496717453, 0.018933715298771858, 0.01313159242272377, -0.00702044740319252, 0.04189625009894371, -0.04407673329114914, -0.01735425740480423, -0.009664741344749928, -0.06989961862564087, -0.05881232023239136, 0.010783744975924492, 0.020719563588500023, -0.024698274210095406, -0.026945123448967934, 0.020068498328328133, 0.03894774988293648, 0.04548740014433861, 0.030912697315216064, 0.015863632783293724, -0.004020805936306715, 0.08714146912097931, -0.06876872479915619, -0.07221487164497375, -0.002741083735600114, 0.014863909222185612, 0.0022552998270839453, -0.036751966923475266, -0.038964711129665375, 0.0082748644053936, 0.01231755968183279, 0.013736761175096035, 0.07848845422267914, -0.03249837085604668, -0.01969805546104908, -0.0012667345581576228, 0.05509154126048088, -0.06164379417896271, -0.011653175577521324, -0.01528899371623993, -0.017976710572838783, 0.012973352335393429, 0.06335131078958511, -0.008048534393310547, -0.028365889564156532, 0.07602616399526596, 0.001984927337616682, -0.005873324815183878, -0.10050971806049347, 0.025516314432024956, 0.037180397659540176, 0.06279130280017853, 0.026799190789461136, 0.043291814625263214, 0.04410259425640106, 0.00599295599386096, -0.001716429484076798, 0.04443773999810219, 0.0376339815557003, -0.0012111298274248838, -0.01679643802344799, -0.03659118711948395, 0.05795350670814514, 0.034902382642030716, -0.05030154064297676, -0.009885219857096672, -0.027092220261693, 0.01790665276348591, -0.0019210251048207283, 0.007852161303162575, -0.014936360530555248, 0.0007063388475216925, 0.04789503663778305, 0.02177724987268448, -0.03105274960398674, 0.011804193258285522, -0.008987248875200748, -0.03560608997941017, -0.0021113536786288023, -0.04540567845106125, 0.006189777050167322, 0.01165115274488926, 0.009627915918827057, -0.06345884501934052, -0.014331762678921223, -0.006739411037415266, -0.02616625465452671, 0.0678451657295227, -0.09138540178537369, -0.031256575137376785, 0.006571398116648197, 0.0028387652710080147, 0.018161410465836525, 0.023647697642445564, -0.01819927804172039, 0.015190922655165195, 0.008543217554688454, 0.007516922894865274, -0.025813663378357887, -0.0455322228372097, 0.03156857565045357, -0.012002800591289997, 0.08675583451986313, -0.005422379821538925, -0.04834896698594093, -0.03979700803756714, 0.011917009018361568, -0.020698465406894684, -0.022928813472390175, 0.05006680265069008, 0.02995769865810871, -0.027040306478738785, -0.007648629602044821, -0.012376314029097557, -0.04004545882344246, -0.051268309354782104, 0.01723143644630909, -0.021329887211322784, -0.027611831203103065, -0.0232961717993021, 0.04071344807744026, 0.0704725980758667, 0.0640745609998703, -0.009447706863284111, 0.05137623846530914, 0.013082035817205906, 0.0033002453856170177, 0.03596371412277222, 0.029253516346216202, -0.008232072927057743, 0.03030569478869438, 0.05939048156142235, -0.0480877123773098, -0.011858281679451466, 0.00738184479996562, -0.0037794411182403564, 0.03247562050819397, -0.011904487386345863, -0.008949585258960724, -0.0010994750773534179, 0.02160561829805374, 0.005451283883303404, 0.010995454154908657, -0.0020678264554589987, -0.06333726644515991, 0.027460630983114243, 0.02229977585375309, 0.00027081629377789795, -0.024500256404280663, -0.0704675167798996, 0.0344388410449028, 0.037048887461423874, -0.009615120477974415, 0.04839126765727997, -0.004055879544466734, 0.06230616942048073, -0.07711353898048401, 0.04586208611726761, -0.015107386745512486, 0.01665666326880455, 0.056859198957681656, 0.06267616897821426, 0.03021157719194889, 0.05103641003370285, -0.012185199186205864, -0.023651396855711937, 0.05651819333434105, -0.020960068330168724, -0.009156744927167892, 0.014103129506111145, -0.006102296523749828, -0.0828835666179657, 0.04373164102435112, -0.01111704483628273, -0.01591881364583969, 0.01914827711880207, -0.039339397102594376, -0.09007956087589264, 0.013937149196863174, -0.00024138246953953058, 0.010713834315538406, 0.003701184643432498, -0.04463803023099899, -0.02731912024319172, 0.02607409469783306, 0.004531076177954674, -0.057180434465408325, 0.0022094964515417814, 0.0011482357513159513, 0.017644159495830536, -0.002623810665681958, 0.03549882769584656, -0.02749907597899437, 0.053301118314266205, -0.06118330359458923, -0.048534952104091644, -0.057256270200014114, -0.03979308158159256, -0.027840254828333855, 0.012892532162368298, 0.015809902921319008, 0.046783696860075, -0.02397446520626545, -0.009382453747093678, 0.03496938198804855, -0.006608337163925171, -0.11100463569164276, 0.029424328356981277, 0.04818039759993553, 0.027737891301512718, 0.007689521182328463, -0.11726433038711548, 0.03224126622080803, 0.008938683196902275, -0.010013019666075706, -0.01888061873614788, 0.04896634444594383, -0.052458640187978745, 0.035487256944179535, -0.008852120488882065, -0.022634068503975868, -0.022805912420153618, -0.03195422515273094, 0.002457122318446636, 0.04476456344127655, 0.0038188158068805933, 0.029084598645567894, -0.04295084625482559, -0.01635144092142582, -0.03724658489227295, 0.00022346778132487088, -0.041907425969839096, -0.018208736553788185, 0.03888997435569763, -0.024241456761956215, 0.003640909679234028, -0.055315788835287094, -0.0034584945533424616, -0.025243189185857773, -0.016021985560655594, -0.03692973405122757, -0.010111261159181595, 0.0319390669465065, 0.012804743833839893, 0.025322139263153076, 0.03916509076952934, 0.018138723447918892, -0.010939033702015877, -0.05511830374598503, 0.038407593965530396, 0.030016090720891953, 0.01032389048486948, 0.02327307127416134, -0.012161357328295708, 0.005825842265039682, 0.05997229367494583, 0.01451097335666418, 0.0013664854923263192, -0.014071501791477203, 0.033271174877882004, -0.016803141683340073, -0.009898042306303978, -0.00862776767462492, -0.049607571214437485, 0.053490523248910904, -0.0022940526250749826, 0.013571180403232574, -0.028677575290203094, 0.007208473514765501, -0.06060764566063881, -0.008852983824908733, 0.040936317294836044, -0.06104522570967674, 0.005271747708320618, 0.007177571300417185, -0.005354482214897871, -0.03601282835006714, -0.006778222508728504, -0.04053593799471855, 0.04887308552861214, 0.03007032908499241, -0.015398567542433739, 0.0235139150172472, 0.0030409942846745253, 0.0418686643242836, -0.037991952151060104, 0.04720698297023773, 0.04289565607905388, -0.014008223079144955, -0.04274746775627136, -0.002147062448784709, 0.025759924203157425, -0.019461739808321, -0.014989913441240788, -0.011307002045214176, -0.0033571829553693533, 0.00118450284935534, -0.03125465661287308, 0.005743977148085833, 0.023191051557660103, 0.013849488459527493, -0.00137620372697711, -0.02544759213924408, 0.014295192435383797, -0.016307758167386055, -0.03339269012212753, 0.004126161336898804, 0.07847810536623001, -0.10292724519968033, 0.03836292400956154, 0.021981939673423767, 0.009538942947983742, 0.0028810054063796997, -0.03012392297387123, 0.07500632852315903, -0.035019055008888245, 0.0017137409886345267, -0.005150245502591133, -0.062369782477617264, 0.014027666300535202, 0.015285296365618706, -0.06558170169591904, 0.004773811437189579, 0.0637660101056099, -0.06136256828904152, -0.03744782879948616, -0.03235039860010147, 0.061539486050605774, -0.011559263803064823, -0.08122898638248444, -0.04619431868195534, 0.03303048014640808, 0.03615415468811989, -0.009312653914093971, 0.034997813403606415, 0.0075834221206605434, -0.049236565828323364, -0.002944956300780177, -0.0629977360367775, 0.024239150807261467, -0.04083285108208656 ]
<p>Why are 11 dimensions needed in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-theory">M-Theory</a>? The four I know (three spatial ones plus time) have an intuitive meaning in everyday life. How can I think of the other seven? What is their nature (spatial, temporal, ...) and is there an <strong>intuitive</strong> picture of what they are needed for?</p>
g9821
[ -0.012878493405878544, 0.0592028982937336, 0.004750347696244717, -0.0349348746240139, -0.01772388070821762, -0.016150031238794327, 0.014318743720650673, -0.017986243590712547, -0.02495560050010681, 0.009947880171239376, -0.02231801487505436, -0.08259692043066025, 0.06024695560336113, 0.02991417609155178, -0.018234925344586372, -0.003223817329853773, 0.0005117402179166675, 0.052996400743722916, 0.05957842990756035, -0.004427235573530197, -0.0013687125174328685, 0.03395242989063263, -0.020602215081453323, -0.05085310339927673, -0.051882609724998474, -0.013094000518321991, 0.018353590741753578, -0.02477920986711979, -0.014587645418941975, -0.008551811799407005, 0.06333786249160767, -0.03272181376814842, 0.0068270000629127026, -0.09374576061964035, -0.03738807514309883, -0.006758878473192453, 0.04887757450342178, 0.10119844228029251, -0.04619310051202774, -0.014012978412210941, -0.02854621596634388, -0.032394666224718094, -0.03500726819038391, 0.03116595931351185, -0.004453869536519051, 0.07449270039796829, 0.01567123830318451, -0.0059605431742966175, 0.01947113312780857, -0.05179964751005173, -0.02741425111889839, 0.007046975195407867, 0.08460841327905655, 0.01576971635222435, 0.023868585005402565, 0.0054132407531142235, 0.022815093398094177, -0.031089702621102333, 0.053926657885313034, -0.01231660321354866, 0.027226900681853294, 0.035207949578762054, -0.04118487983942032, 0.07047577947378159, 0.061012011021375656, 0.03334713354706764, -0.014946670271456242, -0.013930737972259521, 0.00760183809325099, -0.032483309507369995, 0.04416101425886154, -0.1057073175907135, 0.0022104489617049694, 0.03345451503992081, 0.011922270990908146, 0.04456188902258873, -0.0049363113939762115, 0.02522871643304825, 0.009846819564700127, 0.006869990844279528, 0.05703647434711456, -0.0006654541357420385, 0.013562697917222977, -0.03456329554319382, 0.06899093091487885, 0.0228685662150383, 0.04329250380396843, -0.02650822512805462, 0.05102342739701271, 0.022545717656612396, 0.029927508905529976, 0.02334451489150524, 0.019890330731868744, 0.04814799875020981, -0.067561075091362, -0.00020603035227395594, 0.001756587764248252, 0.08249109238386154, -0.02290288545191288, 0.005555124022066593, -0.04006798937916756, -0.010941670276224613, 0.03101719543337822, -0.0225728340446949, 0.025438042357563972, -0.004455708432942629, 0.014581311494112015, 0.046486880630254745, 0.04366578906774521, 0.013165418989956379, -0.10180050134658813, 0.048306096345186234, -0.04376661032438278, 0.04431666433811188, 0.006909831427037716, -0.010965511202812195, 0.054767854511737823, -0.0521598644554615, 0.010436099953949451, 0.05777215212583542, 0.033943187445402145, -0.0032482317183166742, 0.0544385202229023, 0.0037071157712489367, -0.020567968487739563, -0.010949648916721344, 0.05824530869722366, -0.022988712415099144, 0.008397551253437996, 0.01490950770676136, 0.026553384959697723, 0.057779982686042786, -0.015192111022770405, 0.018847867846488953, 0.034349434077739716, 0.08738604933023453, -0.01958862692117691, 0.01473685260862112, -0.01723012886941433, 0.0352470800280571, -0.003388953860849142, -0.02389301173388958, -0.041071534156799316, -0.06335289776325226, -0.0439005121588707, -0.012320669367909431, -0.01843847706913948, -0.011000176891684532, -0.013901782222092152, 0.005121984519064426, 0.005920646712183952, 0.07273062318563461, 0.012451069429516792, -0.008044850081205368, -0.006779852788895369, -0.03564918786287308, -0.005557254888117313, -0.010148600675165653, -0.017032800242304802, -0.007018234580755234, -0.0003996547020506114, 0.044422175735235214, -0.033353541046381, 0.04884463921189308, -0.03782817721366882, -0.0833166316151619, 0.014796392992138863, -0.05607137084007263, -0.013196012936532497, -0.012703847140073776, 0.010107941925525665, 0.0040995050221681595, -0.024478698149323463, -0.00721234455704689, -0.06800702959299088, 0.03540812432765961, 0.03374211862683296, -0.04173766076564789, 0.024579623714089394, 0.004047603812068701, -0.00515857944265008, 0.00884986575692892, 0.011169151403009892, -0.03280247375369072, -0.03851183131337166, -0.023803753778338432, -0.019986659288406372, 0.014776207506656647, -0.03471623733639717, 0.018131211400032043, -0.01152923982590437, -0.02688377909362316, -0.00996667891740799, 0.052840184420347214, -0.00068548449780792, -0.03268083930015564, -0.00652652233839035, -0.001580026582814753, -0.0667034462094307, 0.05318064242601395, 0.012431981042027473, -0.00841452181339264, 0.03262931853532791, 0.04508139193058014, -0.010368219576776028, 0.0538819395005703, -0.05998746305704117, 0.02324504964053631, 0.020407449454069138, -0.025227174162864685, 0.04408936947584152, -0.05221671611070633, 0.019210847094655037, 0.007634570822119713, -0.06746317446231842, -0.024631069973111153, -0.01791117712855339, -0.02633046731352806, 0.016956588253378868, 0.018249092623591423, -0.0025853340048342943, -0.08149263262748718, 0.003296033013612032, 0.010399887338280678, -0.007038230542093515, -0.014382220804691315, -0.012895907275378704, -0.06408753246068954, 0.0036255987361073494, -0.001281917910091579, -0.06770291924476624, -0.04659540206193924, 0.02745662070810795, 0.06803988665342331, -0.01568133942782879, 0.030748974531888962, -0.013067653402686119, -0.016696546226739883, 0.029022540897130966, 0.06462989002466202, 0.0373869352042675, -0.006651099305599928, 0.005197104997932911, 0.0210117120295763, -0.006407825741916895, -0.052811577916145325, 0.06604016572237015, -0.05496970936655998, -0.044647835195064545, 0.07786201685667038, -0.052490439265966415, -0.0013738523703068495, -0.04634696617722511, -0.0015888515627011657, 0.010137384757399559, 0.01845804788172245, 0.04376909136772156, -0.000978102209046483, -0.08783439546823502, -0.029358340427279472, 0.05313554033637047, -0.032310571521520615, -0.008602782152593136, 0.010661449283361435, -0.0505649633705616, -0.0569055937230587, -0.027428822591900826, 0.04173530265688896, -0.0009269001893699169, 0.00042736914474517107, -0.054329000413417816, 0.05217566713690758, 0.0196695476770401, -0.0007809512317180634, -0.04063716530799866, -0.003276087576523423, -0.007828345522284508, 0.008181694895029068, 0.019541842862963676, 0.0348089337348938, -0.004386083222925663, 0.04592707380652428, -0.06957928091287613, 0.00023985328152775764, 0.025791563093662262, -0.009149936027824879, 0.08759067952632904, 0.03304118663072586, -0.02701721526682377, -0.0055914511904120445, 0.012796130031347275, 0.01636599376797676, 0.006784585304558277, -0.020015588030219078, -0.028676379472017288, -0.027340956032276154, -0.01640480011701584, -0.05052831396460533, 0.01883929967880249, 0.03132276237010956, 0.017200883477926254, 0.02102993056178093, 0.017541002482175827, -0.02416621334850788, 0.008794056251645088, 0.045369457453489304, -0.0040430123917758465, -0.023298852145671844, -0.054310958832502365, -0.02430778741836548, 0.023232370615005493, 0.0890672504901886, -0.004020247142761946, 0.026322489604353905, -0.0012411875650286674, 0.012814950197935104, -0.03363516926765442, 0.03561413288116455, 0.019947601482272148, -0.009009035304188728, 0.03069043718278408, -0.010344317182898521, 0.008469424210488796, -0.00855522882193327, 0.01179437804967165, 0.017855657264590263, -0.021599555388092995, -0.07773768901824951, -0.044095199555158615, 0.06765495985746384, -0.02675354667007923, -0.0008298447355628014, 0.002188504673540592, 0.04967525601387024, -0.06981614977121353, -0.004382491111755371, -0.05599524825811386, -0.03508817031979561, 0.0222049318253994, -0.05939768999814987, 0.0065367924980819225, -0.016312800347805023, -0.017964079976081848, -0.006221798248589039, 0.038334380835294724, -0.01461054664105177, 0.011589659377932549, 0.008553246036171913, 0.02264336496591568, -0.0035660911817103624, 0.0036967520136386156, 0.061228811740875244, 0.027668101713061333, 0.016688944771885872, -0.007680490147322416, 0.06362131983041763, 0.015105516649782658, 0.07824450731277466, 0.014835360459983349, -0.03552287071943283, -0.033395033329725266, 0.038618750870227814, -0.010299566201865673, 0.0018777434015646577, 0.012939033098518848, 0.07512512803077698, -0.03877028077840805, 0.04732175171375275, 0.04678931459784508, -0.0166676826775074, 0.07983841001987457, -0.005347392521798611, -0.10687965154647827, -0.03287679702043533, 0.06007329747080803, 0.003301388118416071, 0.0122169628739357, -0.03146214783191681, -0.05390951409935951, 0.003162199864163995, 0.05491184815764427, 0.020114807412028313, 0.004425768740475178, 0.014006149023771286, 0.06643515080213547, 0.012735794298350811, -0.07865104079246521, -0.008861408568918705, -0.10207414627075195, -0.012696965597569942, -0.0030810493044555187, 0.008080733008682728, -0.02657712809741497, -0.09123361110687256, 0.03159695118665695, 0.0025055992882698774, 0.015622884966433048, -0.00561490748077631, -0.022875741124153137, -0.029458725824952126, 0.0006997496820986271, 0.008922071196138859, 0.014428392983973026, -0.029273999854922295, -0.016243726015090942, 0.012214584276080132, -0.00268179876729846, -0.05122065916657448, 0.07888542115688324, -0.016170553863048553, -0.012795950286090374, -0.03086644411087036, 0.049771714955568314, -0.04576670378446579, 0.03309120982885361, -0.02394672855734825, -0.012689384631812572, -0.053889259696006775, -0.01125194039195776, 0.05868789926171303, 0.0846417248249054, 0.04668884724378586, -0.0026569541078060865, -0.04000511020421982, -0.027229204773902893, 0.06756012886762619, 0.0446341298520565, 0.05179745331406593, -0.036572087556123734, 0.009737218730151653, 0.025432709604501724, 0.023334071040153503, -0.03798694536089897, -0.021298527717590332, -0.03393224626779556, -0.029473884031176567, -0.05236067250370979, 0.08039048314094543, -0.020056499168276787, 0.008199111558496952, -0.023516586050391197, 0.025087175890803337, 0.008716977201402187, -0.011193912476301193, -0.0041775209829211235, 0.0164712592959404, -0.032448239624500275, -0.014873398467898369, -0.014469191431999207, 0.0010537529597058892, 0.018081434071063995, 0.05475679412484169, -0.05678276717662811, -0.0028748810291290283, 0.025534775108098984, 0.012075068429112434, 0.012932846322655678, -0.0180791188031435, 0.026666108518838882, 0.012932781130075455, -0.07633312046527863, 0.00465609785169363, -0.03529457002878189, 0.03083071857690811, -0.004292494151741266, 0.020873576402664185, -0.03817935287952423, -0.007510415278375149, -0.0008320128545165062, 0.04837213456630707, 0.026440272107720375, 0.02248857170343399, -0.0363907627761364, -0.0037866507191210985, -0.010290132835507393, 0.021539418026804924, -0.011075664311647415, -0.016881275922060013, -0.013755314983427525, -0.023114077746868134, -0.0054850042797625065, -0.035509731620550156, 0.04159213602542877, 0.03632022440433502, 0.01154910959303379, 0.0033614598214626312, 0.001263331389054656, -0.06449230760335922, -0.005110146477818489, 0.020334932953119278, -0.014575344510376453, -0.05445448309183121, -0.018466364592313766, -0.0013841745676472783, -0.0452113039791584, -0.009933185763657093, -0.0041256798431277275, -0.0007346380734816194, 0.0030231119599193335, -0.057915735989809036, 0.005948159843683243, -0.006865991745144129, 0.003239691723138094, -0.03966566547751427, -0.019573913887143135, -0.028961895033717155, 0.034310612827539444, -0.031368184834718704, 0.01862572506070137, 0.005154288839548826, 0.03473570942878723, -0.052404291927814484, -0.017321733757853508, 0.028719082474708557, 0.06273968517780304, -0.020884042605757713, -0.013052009977400303, 0.0343003012239933, 0.02749444916844368, 0.039677511900663376, -0.008041650988161564, 0.0206882506608963, 0.04147067666053772, -0.09236149489879608, -0.012345387600362301, -0.011118779890239239, -0.03222138434648514, -0.010170855559408665, 0.08944623172283173, 0.036562345921993256, -0.009006548672914505, 0.00694149499759078, 0.020543040707707405, 0.0064884331077337265, -0.035085536539554596, -0.009964593686163425, 0.039574213325977325, 0.028246989473700523, 0.07155844569206238, -0.0030217664316296577, -0.01538599468767643, 0.0026030021253973246, -0.06740321964025497, 0.05825664848089218, -0.009462312795221806, -0.05019121244549751, 0.04539109766483307, -0.012375700287520885, 0.05314064025878906, 0.0536256805062294, -0.06315921247005463, 0.0391763411462307, -0.009426509961485863, -0.04622761905193329, -0.035103511065244675, 0.030821023508906364, 0.008448904380202293, -0.0008250229293480515, -0.0223497673869133, -0.035334374755620956, -0.021182110533118248, 0.059588100761175156, -0.05578027665615082, 0.006462340243160725, -0.07090531289577484, -0.07398294657468796, 0.02081543393433094, 0.042236268520355225, 0.08990080654621124, 0.012754889205098152, 0.015766536816954613, 0.0039818971417844296, 0.03364130109548569, 0.05037246271967888, 0.0024591609835624695, -0.02288900874555111, 0.02965709939599037, -0.006683149375021458, -0.062619648873806, 0.04015806317329407, 0.011073233559727669, 0.01960226707160473, 0.04561033472418785, -0.026477189734578133, -0.0021788296289741993, 0.040877632796764374, 0.000323901156662032, -0.02171335741877556, -0.012377701699733734, -0.025216136127710342, -0.017850827425718307, 0.02198200672864914, 0.025647126138210297, -0.04943161457777023, 0.02613481879234314, 0.04631219804286957, 0.017353778705000877, 0.0076954299584031105, -0.05109864100813866, -0.019139422103762627, 0.00649153022095561, -0.007456053048372269, 0.03029819019138813, 0.06305278092622757, -0.014740514568984509, 0.10901542752981186, -0.06232522800564766, -0.034708984196186066, -0.044056542217731476, 0.01927589811384678, 0.011894549243152142, 0.05867850035429001, 0.012074765749275684, 0.03853944316506386, 0.000894181604962796, 0.004915512632578611, 0.0398167259991169, -0.049072422087192535, 0.021703744307160378, 0.008245776407420635, 0.04335566237568855, -0.012317782267928123, 0.01572425663471222, 0.016180209815502167, 0.005413406062871218, -0.012161397375166416, -0.014234241098165512, -0.015396318398416042, -0.016595404595136642, 0.006809397134929895, -0.05826088786125183, -0.06654294580221176, 0.03799613565206528, 0.05398843437433243, -0.02149391733109951, -0.008574182167649269, -0.09448561817407608, 0.03659268841147423, 0.006734072230756283, -0.020750612020492554, -0.05508808046579361, -0.059330493211746216, 0.0072784144431352615, 0.026894697919487953, -0.011514444835484028, -0.08900260925292969, 0.05280250683426857, -0.00021091036614961922, -0.02261221781373024, -0.03513902798295021, 0.03489895537495613, -0.019866639748215675, -0.006150758359581232, 0.035045724362134933, -0.054123494774103165, 0.0067070540972054005, -0.07778380811214447, -0.012631422840058804, 0.007074047811329365, -0.03102879598736763, -0.011790069751441479, -0.030197031795978546, -0.010918833315372467, -0.02727082557976246, -0.013258649036288261, 0.04645765200257301, 0.05149208754301071, -0.01804967224597931, 0.007594178896397352, -0.022035397589206696, -0.025477318093180656, 0.03782815858721733, -0.012015081942081451, 0.03167254850268364, -0.040726397186517715, 0.05283758044242859, 0.004997600335627794, 0.01552106998860836, -0.02602270431816578, -0.029492251574993134, 0.00026199306012131274, 0.05886177346110344, 0.009585874155163765, -0.03775203600525856, -0.04250074177980423, 0.03514152765274048, 0.03451651707291603, 0.04820369556546211, -0.04037327319383621, -0.024471933022141457, 0.022951116785407066, -0.03503928706049919, -0.01731080561876297, -0.04764552414417267, 0.03669973835349083, 0.028894895687699318, 0.014121297746896744, -0.008487310260534286, 0.013588218949735165, -0.014458314515650272, -0.0000098507953225635, 0.003921303898096085, -0.024552421644330025, 0.005620951764285564, 0.0544017069041729, -0.01734388992190361, -0.02415924333035946, -0.026545533910393715, -0.007884231396019459, 0.02965046837925911, -0.0958937332034111, 0.039911068975925446, 0.0035691603552550077, 0.03446228802204132, 0.025698775425553322, -0.028569340705871582, 0.00985320471227169, -0.00621340237557888, 0.010847638361155987, -0.049768880009651184, -0.039777856320142746, -0.04757803678512573, -0.034344397485256195, -0.02635202929377556, -0.04929071664810181, 0.016245022416114807, 0.009539623744785786, -0.03771759197115898, 0.006667597219347954, -0.003416637657210231, -0.031075315549969673, -0.019650006666779518, -0.0229340773075819, 0.06112973019480705, -0.014917370863258839, -0.00992897804826498, -0.04774221032857895, 0.0300592128187418, 0.02468109503388405, -0.013799686916172504, 0.03814311325550079, -0.010392085649073124, 0.021797917783260345, -0.01684211567044258, -0.0034885224886238575, -0.005013101268559694, -0.022082066163420677, 0.029427286237478256, 0.05431029200553894, 0.00646451348438859, 0.013622068800032139, -0.008622737601399422, -0.04438658431172371, -0.017059946432709694, -0.01039681863039732, -0.01862972602248192, 0.046688519418239594, 0.03073175810277462, 0.06683970242738724, 0.0018211290007457137, 0.04080600291490555, -0.00938982143998146, 0.021474072709679604, 0.024308133870363235, 0.010088250041007996, -0.000613704149145633, -0.04219787195324898, -0.028026839718222618 ]