question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>Given are $Z_1, Z_2$ i.i.d. standard normal.</p> <p>Find</p> <p>$P[Z_1 &lt; t &lt; Z_2]$</p> <p>I have difficulties with working out how I should split the condition.</p> <p>Is $P[Z_1 &lt; t &lt; Z_2] = P[Z_1 &lt; t, t &lt; Z_2]$ or is some additional condition required?</p> <h2>My question</h2> <p>How should I approach this problem?</p>
g74289
[ -0.004738654475659132, 0.01808934658765793, -0.016887033358216286, 0.009369287639856339, -0.022086279466748238, -0.024852758273482323, 0.04605038836598396, 0.06111814081668854, -0.006621697451919317, 0.022427020594477654, 0.0162009596824646, -0.00806520041078329, -0.058208003640174866, 0.016101161018013954, -0.02764262445271015, -0.011089933104813099, 0.009245922788977623, -0.01212664321064949, -0.0049419826827943325, 0.04135426506400108, -0.04934020712971687, 0.018757667392492294, 0.0012706207344308496, -0.008315649814903736, 0.04852188378572464, -0.03450523316860199, -0.021815100684762, 0.057014238089323044, -0.04794998839497566, 0.02391347661614418, 0.014665002003312111, 0.0195587370544672, 0.06908397376537323, -0.009929602965712547, -0.0048974864184856415, -0.003702276386320591, 0.06422766298055649, 0.032720837742090225, 0.005176744423806667, -0.027060430496931076, -0.025692179799079895, 0.01933152601122856, -0.0452604740858078, -0.0000324490902130492, -0.04666022211313248, -0.019692908972501755, 0.023207901045680046, -0.035953372716903687, -0.015451060608029366, -0.008816841058433056, 0.031204145401716232, 0.01025220938026905, -0.018268214538693428, -0.07128670811653137, -0.009633959271013737, 0.021567391231656075, -0.01705550216138363, 0.0052170823328197, 0.006612130906432867, -0.002050376497209072, 0.0015017562545835972, -0.01990373246371746, 0.02585754729807377, -0.022937357425689697, 0.021678712218999863, -0.021292729303240776, 0.02521343156695366, -0.012646779417991638, -0.024761974811553955, -0.07450971752405167, -0.031196869909763336, -0.014915810897946358, 0.06117016822099686, -0.029126103967428207, -0.07935430854558945, 0.019260181114077568, 0.055310867726802826, -0.01409638486802578, -0.004407150205224752, 0.07125379145145416, 0.0331270657479763, -0.029293429106473923, 0.019969098269939423, 0.03453501686453819, -0.004882199224084616, 0.03167159482836723, 0.014715434052050114, -0.021767588332295418, -0.006629673298448324, 0.031913213431835175, -0.01536057610064745, -0.023601114749908447, 0.010655642487108707, 0.04501636326313019, 0.02864222787320614, 0.014890007674694061, -0.05814583599567413, 0.07816243916749954, 0.024540923535823822, -0.029539911076426506, 0.05997741222381592, 0.007184796035289764, 0.029696663841605186, -0.009211129508912563, -0.036826927214860916, -0.012109067291021347, 0.05680643394589424, 0.018526460975408554, -0.0016644725110381842, -0.015208011493086815, 0.03295319899916649, 0.018013251945376396, -0.0037561263889074326, -0.05717384070158005, 0.005852459464222193, -0.005352448672056198, -0.006020239554345608, -0.008349927142262459, -0.03868018463253975, -0.019108103588223457, -0.04502213001251221, -0.03038151189684868, 0.05991477519273758, 0.0870671421289444, 0.04199688881635666, -0.0014937446685507894, 0.05051181837916374, -0.03148187696933746, 0.07445868849754333, -0.0005642268806695938, 0.05052533745765686, 0.020166965201497078, 0.04447413980960846, -0.008010027930140495, -0.07904137670993805, 0.034311842173337936, 0.02052941359579563, -0.023567700758576393, -0.036813486367464066, 0.022872623056173325, 0.0033426748123019934, -0.02034732885658741, -0.00832004752010107, -0.03694593533873558, -0.0431743748486042, 0.030855698511004448, -0.028134344145655632, -0.027935639023780823, -0.014806890860199928, 0.026716696098446846, -0.045126207172870636, 0.037261251360177994, -0.030326999723911285, 0.08100765943527222, -0.01952681504189968, -0.008917084895074368, 0.030137930065393448, -0.013827581889927387, 0.006096699740737677, 0.02986224927008152, 0.004044728819280863, 0.007439712528139353, -0.038151565939188004, 0.018772000446915627, -0.05008062720298767, 0.04715796560049057, 0.005540009588003159, -0.009086973965168, 0.017502814531326294, -0.03307896479964256, 0.00509562948718667, 0.03281901031732559, 0.036403220146894455, -0.0026694005355238914, 0.04419545829296112, 0.03021310456097126, 0.021739425137639046, 0.017870472744107246, -0.0027407011948525906, 0.03540489077568054, -0.018180957064032555, -0.003231554524973035, 0.008517584763467312, 0.01748592220246792, 0.013629594817757607, -0.03511626645922661, -0.009314008988440037, -0.06633385270833969, -0.03896882012486458, -0.007310792803764343, -0.020822161808609962, 0.06490594893693924, 0.05307096242904663, 0.03447143733501434, -0.06685429066419601, -0.03782624006271362, 0.043403901159763336, -0.03789156675338745, -0.06212245300412178, 0.019187383353710175, 0.0883503332734108, 0.032439254224300385, -0.06073030084371567, -0.018058504909276962, -0.03159874305129051, -0.07206159830093384, 0.014452679082751274, 0.01782456785440445, 0.01228961069136858, -0.012549370527267456, -0.05313597247004509, -0.055824801325798035, 0.004120093770325184, -0.011421261355280876, -0.050932373851537704, -0.05965908244252205, 0.01342309731990099, 0.04019768536090851, -0.07343807816505432, 0.007456883322447538, -0.025973690673708916, 0.04105756804347038, 0.07137440145015717, 0.016139699146151543, -0.0013020668411627412, 0.007783356122672558, 0.01076477114111185, -0.01350705698132515, 0.01950393244624138, -0.02260284498333931, 0.019728118553757668, -0.04423399642109871, 0.03410081937909126, -0.000301215099170804, 0.01324200164526701, -0.011199581436812878, -0.05620305985212326, 0.010040572844445705, 0.029786063358187675, 0.01160165574401617, -0.002568381605669856, -0.013390524312853813, -0.017424708232283592, 0.011847903952002525, 0.03511001914739609, -0.02567787654697895, -0.020885931327939034, -0.017822282388806343, -0.06654863804578781, 0.00787591002881527, -0.03203953057527542, -0.03219666704535484, 0.008770487271249294, -0.006457144860178232, 0.008106385357677937, -0.11576912552118301, 0.013746406883001328, 0.03330590948462486, 0.019103601574897766, -0.023445583879947662, -0.058300670236349106, -0.005726680159568787, 0.019879471510648727, 0.04369982331991196, -0.08467549085617065, -0.045268915593624115, 0.023783810436725616, -0.04064808040857315, -0.021927829831838608, -0.03310288116335869, -0.013559125363826752, -0.0016000865725800395, 0.029498159885406494, 0.04619820788502693, -0.005394832231104374, -0.022440366446971893, -0.02236887998878956, -0.013394699431955814, -0.02892100065946579, 0.01121994573622942, 0.03081682324409485, -0.03994469717144966, -0.005009376909583807, 0.050474509596824646, 0.009137630462646484, -0.011621211655437946, 0.003130646189674735, 0.04841555282473564, -0.06660936772823334, 0.04293329641222954, -0.048015046864748, 0.03414522483944893, 0.010132526978850365, -0.059852227568626404, 0.057185955345630646, -0.01630658283829689, -0.017913714051246643, -0.06248479709029198, -0.015998201444745064, 0.019313747063279152, 0.02080865018069744, -0.011990402825176716, 0.03268499672412872, -0.019048646092414856, -0.020482981577515602, -0.02980000525712967, -0.004945831373333931, 0.019777532666921616, -0.026758890599012375, -0.004961870145052671, 0.012477786280214787, 0.017601996660232544, 0.08616508543491364, -0.013477872125804424, -0.006547465920448303, 0.03879612684249878, 0.019021179527044296, -0.062359150499105453, 0.025573477149009705, 0.010076304897665977, -0.01714351400732994, -0.052015140652656555, -0.029114272445440292, 0.0262569822371006, -0.03421541675925255, 0.0018028448102995753, -0.02532915584743023, -0.021064870059490204, -0.04404793679714203, 0.023925576359033585, -0.005276009906083345, 0.03728507459163666, -0.030296117067337036, -0.0046393778175115585, 0.027098020538687706, -0.02297280915081501, 0.019603606313467026, 0.03757564723491669, 0.03928123787045479, -0.025513755157589912, 0.024878105148673058, -0.04026911035180092, 0.02771826833486557, -0.04304980859160423, -0.030247440561652184, -0.0671425610780716, -0.003717383835464716, 0.11775398254394531, 0.020106814801692963, 0.007463841699063778, -0.010607469826936722, -0.012918067164719105, 0.0160142220556736, -0.02450782060623169, -0.021981142461299896, 0.058887969702482224, -0.01406028587371111, -0.023611465469002724, -0.03665321692824364, 0.011551812291145325, 0.06474433839321136, -0.005441275425255299, 0.0030990042723715305, 0.07254926860332489, 0.030084194615483284, -0.02727966010570526, -0.011237028054893017, 0.0463835634291172, -0.01204405352473259, -0.02029000036418438, 0.07593537867069244, 0.046425703912973404, 0.07045125216245651, 0.0015631387941539288, -0.017666036263108253, -0.04245976358652115, 0.020279765129089355, -0.04443347454071045, 0.0497034452855587, 0.017007548362016678, 0.024824196472764015, -0.0178401879966259, -0.0812511071562767, 0.0671987310051918, 0.08499440550804138, -0.012171166017651558, 0.020752090960741043, 0.054352570325136185, 0.00890892930328846, 0.0022544933017343283, 0.02884669229388237, -0.0290472861379385, 0.013219978660345078, 0.036105379462242126, -0.05434674397110939, -0.01989411748945713, -0.025868184864521027, 0.04144475236535072, -0.07613615691661835, 0.00639760959893465, -0.05996185541152954, -0.008526278659701347, 0.052459344267845154, -0.028352199122309685, 0.006579289678484201, -0.01408329512923956, -0.006222139112651348, 0.022794242948293686, 0.0821545273065567, -0.049986619502305984, 0.015255071222782135, 0.007078253664076328, -0.016686877235770226, -0.010052303783595562, -0.0031329148914664984, -0.06568709015846252, 0.07240010052919388, 0.020234709605574608, -0.004968523513525724, -0.03899894282221794, -0.08068878948688507, -0.02622266486287117, -0.06412885338068008, -0.06467034667730331, 0.004625628236681223, 0.034886691719293594, 0.012464262545108795, -0.0038321330212056637, 0.028126636520028114, -0.036768727004528046, -0.046047843992710114, 0.03601507470011711, -0.02152593992650509, -0.018887145444750786, -0.015533843077719212, 0.010947274044156075, -0.03987939655780792, 0.01370242703706026, -0.05465318635106087, -0.013054433278739452, 0.013933323323726654, -0.019652441143989563, -0.035756390541791916, 0.017329078167676926, 0.03175518289208412, -0.007960607297718525, -0.0064152926206588745, -0.050534799695014954, 0.015237793326377869, -0.04231677204370499, -0.014209253713488579, 0.03947864845395088, 0.018385808914899826, -0.0040509505197405815, 0.0071315341629087925, -0.031707946211099625, 0.0302877239882946, 0.02310124970972538, -0.03438190370798111, 0.043549794703722, 0.014820369891822338, -0.0503801554441452, 0.02053079940378666, -0.028324712067842484, 0.030183760449290276, -0.018571265041828156, -0.057416874915361404, 0.01098769810050726, 0.04236858710646629, -0.00864598248153925, -0.006600415334105492, 0.02495572529733181, 0.04690331220626831, -0.042574167251586914, -0.07084202021360397, 0.030803700909018517, -0.018960997462272644, -0.01908227801322937, -0.05463092401623726, 0.0018368890741840005, -0.006180633790791035, 0.014388608746230602, -0.037546414881944656, 0.06118904799222946, 0.000050399452447891235, -0.015627173706889153, 0.029645804315805435, -0.08509249985218048, 0.03161841630935669, -0.036954909563064575, 0.034630101174116135, -0.015984391793608665, 0.019622819498181343, 0.016482917591929436, -0.0326506569981575, -0.04360904544591904, 0.020735466852784157, -0.04779599979519844, 0.005002791527658701, 0.010649544186890125, -0.023258443921804428, -0.018472367897629738, 0.04549155384302139, 0.07062471657991409, -0.006783165503293276, 0.02893408201634884, 0.06281067430973053, 0.038865815848112106, 0.002374769654124975, 0.053519222885370255, 0.051204778254032135, -0.012453597038984299, 0.10475044697523117, -0.019275184720754623, -0.021446198225021362, 0.03669223561882973, -0.019360657781362534, 0.04529493302106857, -0.07702318578958511, -0.07402805238962173, 0.021874601021409035, -0.042123809456825256, -0.02767639048397541, -0.06330253928899765, 0.03758614882826805, -0.04784674942493439, -0.08432210236787796, -0.007891625165939331, 0.0019639334641397, -0.006307960022240877, 0.007434083614498377, 0.006390631664544344, -0.035733260214328766, 0.013345644809305668, 0.05553625896573067, -0.01722600683569908, -0.03265514597296715, -0.08114713430404663, -0.05766906589269638, 0.017818359658122063, -0.0033967243507504463, -0.01589256525039673, 0.024996686726808548, -0.03674493357539177, 0.009727826341986656, -0.016896914690732956, -0.02165955677628517, -0.009139525704085827, 0.01612255722284317, -0.021437492221593857, 0.01314515806734562, -0.031097659841179848, -0.017585085704922676, 0.01628962531685829, 0.04915092885494232, -0.028068607673048973, 0.021406108513474464, 0.03113587200641632, -0.027577100321650505, 0.007705737836658955, -0.0022057469468563795, -0.018705110996961594, -0.017355939373373985, -0.006389839109033346, 0.011901121586561203, -0.07939287275075912, 0.014152999967336655, 0.007828532718122005, 0.004869695752859116, 0.01477651484310627, 0.015701021999120712, 0.018714891746640205, 0.05564677342772484, 0.02276785299181938, 0.0365561917424202, 0.023673754185438156, -0.05185779556632042, 0.032115478068590164, -0.011350116692483425, 0.009201708249747753, -0.04282267764210701, 0.029529713094234467, -0.034471143037080765, 0.001885895966552198, -0.02944340743124485, 0.07576272636651993, -0.032425880432128906, -0.032928913831710815, 0.032137781381607056, -0.025865396484732628, 0.03122197650372982, 0.006728047039359808, -0.04295237734913826, -0.06383443623781204, -0.0021100372541695833, 0.04724147543311119, 0.03694450110197067, -0.003719528205692768, -0.015138105489313602, -0.03477264195680618, 0.018576255068182945, -0.005186080001294613, 0.033633049577474594, 0.011221074499189854, 0.012721584178507328, 0.044493455439805984, 0.06301183998584747, 0.014199091121554375, 0.008200488053262234, -0.017695128917694092, -0.025622788816690445, -0.03704275190830231, -0.03253718838095665, 0.04294406622648239, -0.0004551102756522596, -0.04262372851371765, -0.0002525085292290896, 0.047575779259204865, 0.04421810060739517, -0.008816164918243885, 0.045613307505846024, -0.04280595853924751, -0.03625500202178955, 0.01828784868121147, 0.07800337672233582, 0.052355363965034485, -0.03464990481734276, -0.018577024340629578, 0.04297226667404175, -0.0049697537906467915, 0.060683149844408035, -0.00033664549118839204, -0.03731375187635422, -0.015946602448821068, 0.0036280604545027018, -0.042486585676670074, -0.0290210098028183, 0.06982745975255966, -0.052275896072387695, 0.09188047051429749, 0.0644555315375328, 0.051154810935258865, 0.03127918764948845, 0.00032359291799366474, -0.05044126510620117, 0.06063234061002731, 0.05968466028571129, 0.054098404943943024, -0.04889785125851631, -0.015525289811193943, 0.050711605697870255, 0.03963370993733406, -0.023915808647871017, -0.001433336641639471, -0.01339090894907713, -0.0057070497423410416, 0.010031607002019882, -0.03237111493945122, 0.02749599888920784, 0.024588672444224358, -0.030045263469219208, -0.005053434520959854, -0.02596401236951351, 0.009669044055044651, 0.012828543782234192, 0.05059787631034851, -0.0343727208673954, 0.006703373044729233, -0.028211265802383423, -0.03798666596412659, -0.06135213375091553, -0.05281687527894974, -0.030206460505723953, 0.006553207524120808, 0.037565506994724274, 0.02862868271768093, -0.00250113382935524, 0.04262910410761833, -0.006015552207827568, -0.06509584188461304, 0.040310416370630264, -0.02927720732986927, -0.06108278036117554, -0.006637391168624163, 0.007932229898869991, 0.030789338052272797, -0.039545390754938126, -0.06405189633369446, 0.07595998793840408, 0.10971217602491379, -0.016172470524907112, 0.011488135904073715, 0.07291151583194733, -0.002375323325395584, -0.05506677180528641, -0.005183928646147251, -0.0018334893975406885, 0.08182883262634277, 0.012719100341200829, 0.03923559933900833, -0.016102463006973267, -0.00934265274554491, 0.028409497812390327, 0.0007934234454296529, -0.03129303827881813, -0.018220148980617523, 0.009707245975732803, -0.05028042197227478, 0.01122661679983139, -0.0023384930100291967, -0.009601950645446777, 0.08375199139118195, -0.02919556014239788, 0.0031703924760222435, 0.04263262823224068, -0.010515114292502403, -0.06107908487319946, -0.0036870280746370554, 0.03764202818274498, 0.010241528041660786, -0.0419541671872139, -0.018207969143986702, 0.06117168813943863, 0.01995272934436798, -0.06785374134778976, -0.039618026465177536, -0.0003964250790886581, -0.009708386845886707, -0.0027712229639291763, 0.06531030684709549, 0.012304415926337242, -0.016753965988755226, -0.014619380235671997, 0.00994290690869093, 0.022583039477467537, -0.020880648866295815, -0.013352262787520885, -0.03656575456261635, 0.05313634127378464, 0.05305463448166847, -0.030676549300551414, -0.023788152262568474, -0.0244294423609972, -0.018038682639598846, 0.01596425473690033, 0.003914669156074524, 0.0176224447786808, 0.03611722216010094, 0.056839171797037125, -0.009934954345226288, -0.050700146704912186, -0.02719380520284176, -0.033989354968070984, 0.018397871404886246, 0.02909131534397602, -0.04756780341267586, 0.04199420288205147, 0.04651229828596115, -0.0062836091965436935, 0.015316409058868885, -0.04730616509914398, 0.022577941417694092, -0.017624950036406517, 0.05584680661559105, -0.016966789960861206, 0.00036516948603093624, 0.02336398884654045, 0.01431808341294527 ]
<p>I found an example for manually calculating the hazard ratio when there are two groups.</p> <pre><code>d2 &lt;- c(2, 2, 1, 2, 2, 0, 0, 4, 0, 2, 2, 0, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1) d &lt;- c(2, 2, 1, 2, 2, 3, 1, 4, 1, 2, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2, 2) r2 &lt;- c(21, 19, 17, 16, 14, 12, 12, 12, 8, 8, 6, 4, 4, 3, 3, 2, 1) r1 &lt;- c(21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 17, 16, 15, 13, 13, 12, 11, 11, 10, 7, 6) l &lt;- log(r2/r1) d1 &lt;- d - d2 dd &lt;- cbind(d2, d1) summary(glm(dd ~ offset(l), family = binomial)) </code></pre> <p>where d is the number of deaths in total, and $d_i$ is the deaths in group $i$ and $r_j$ is the number of people in risk group $j$. I understand how this works.</p> <p>I would like to do a similar exercise for when there are not two groups of people, but only one vector of continuous data (e.g. expression of a particular gene) and no grouping factor. How can it be done for this scenario ?</p>
g74290
[ 0.008474220521748066, -0.03724425658583641, -0.002158123068511486, -0.008713984861969948, 0.015318389050662518, -0.023725157603621483, 0.05485556647181511, 0.01760495826601982, -0.07778071612119675, -0.009803269989788532, 0.00504112197086215, 0.04702705517411232, 0.007630889769643545, -0.020318644121289253, 0.000044135053030913696, 0.030797015875577927, -0.018283812329173088, 0.020205235108733177, -0.006423970218747854, 0.054689835757017136, 0.0053202807903289795, -0.002457304624840617, 0.03645582124590874, -0.010828452184796333, 0.011720318347215652, -0.07078105211257935, 0.017828598618507385, 0.04931359365582466, -0.06672520935535431, 0.00840806309133768, -0.008998468518257141, 0.018259823322296143, 0.02174118161201477, -0.0512724332511425, 0.024370068684220314, -0.03348882868885994, 0.02589021623134613, -0.02796298824250698, 0.01617415063083172, 0.009526965208351612, 0.015747537836432457, 0.039220165461301804, 0.021500224247574806, 0.013021625578403473, -0.047104526311159134, -0.010016240179538727, 0.017543785274028778, 0.0158314760774374, 0.021360304206609726, -0.023045923560857773, 0.021362492814660072, 0.036128439009189606, -0.005123133771121502, -0.05478491261601448, -0.01872153952717781, 0.011738440953195095, -0.02862129919230938, -0.021499132737517357, 0.017773021012544632, 0.015475927852094173, -0.0032155027147382498, -0.002132302150130272, 0.010655581951141357, -0.06838687509298325, 0.03857482969760895, -0.028627485036849976, -0.013374539092183113, -0.01089875865727663, -0.061256043612957, 0.005638838279992342, -0.004153825342655182, 0.011114449240267277, 0.03887389600276947, 0.01726185344159603, -0.07080812752246857, -0.024257108569145203, -0.014060513116419315, 0.03526945412158966, 0.011478214524686337, 0.03981007635593414, 0.003373109269887209, 0.05626804754137993, 0.04124300554394722, -0.028862351551651955, -0.005663648713380098, -0.0022023837082087994, -0.010301358997821808, -0.04053186625242233, 0.012975690886378288, 0.008987479843199253, 0.022433510050177574, 0.0032658374402672052, 0.05318158119916916, 0.029369641095399857, 0.047273870557546616, 0.016834989190101624, -0.09365768730640411, 0.060712408274412155, -0.03240134194493294, -0.009618664160370827, 0.039835017174482346, 0.060980841517448425, 0.034907273948192596, -0.011128485202789307, -0.10040025413036346, -0.05994649976491928, 0.08834221214056015, 0.019213808700442314, -0.03639684617519379, -0.03366914764046669, -0.004981448873877525, 0.04562322050333023, -0.07610604912042618, 0.004256487358361483, 0.04539056867361069, 0.005566708743572235, 0.06307365000247955, -0.051676783710718155, -0.020078878849744797, 0.002016322687268257, 0.024232883006334305, -0.043898846954107285, 0.07549170404672623, 0.06751319766044617, -0.004460256081074476, -0.00010307919728802517, -0.04371931031346321, 0.0856732428073883, 0.03979767858982086, -0.04812819883227348, 0.006590387783944607, 0.0004956927732564509, 0.045606136322021484, 0.03565911203622818, 0.007603168021887541, -0.003114851890131831, -0.05822273716330528, 0.12241795659065247, -0.009527210146188736, 0.021922077983617783, -0.036873672157526016, 0.03679259493947029, -0.014782585203647614, -0.02262227050960064, 0.014175151474773884, 0.022935891523957253, -0.06696423888206482, -0.04596851021051407, 0.0035360248293727636, -0.00016241251432802528, -0.003901517018675804, 0.028675546869635582, -0.03613312542438507, 0.01174540538340807, 0.005616297945380211, 0.04498608782887459, 0.029027514159679413, -0.010971560142934322, -0.01745021343231201, 0.021876636892557144, -0.006506691221147776, -0.006757319439202547, -0.010950351133942604, -0.017621682956814766, -0.08901852369308472, 0.004658407531678677, 0.024733969941735268, -0.028414633125066757, -0.023868700489401817, -0.05757420137524605, 0.009074574336409569, 0.008548230864107609, 0.0039013801142573357, -0.0040017394348979, 0.0484643280506134, 0.02560119330883026, -0.010467893444001675, 0.030100714415311813, -0.004518408328294754, -0.0007404388161376119, 0.03668418154120445, 0.0014094182988628745, 0.05177336558699608, -0.004977960605174303, -0.0010548181599006057, -0.030477581545710564, -0.05167127028107643, 0.0339132621884346, -0.038947466760873795, -0.004036027938127518, 0.01934834010899067, 0.02202969789505005, 0.026781292632222176, -0.02988290973007679, -0.03343839943408966, -0.0029380545020103455, 0.029799068346619606, -0.0670318529009819, 0.03299450874328613, 0.014636906795203686, -0.002321663312613964, 0.011249970644712448, -0.06944628059864044, 0.01216522790491581, 0.011321873404085636, -0.0037075693253427744, -0.0017904150299727917, 0.0020545474253594875, 0.010495230555534363, -0.0760560929775238, 0.012199112214148045, -0.03337204083800316, -0.0011120096314698458, 0.059431370347738266, -0.03757181391119957, -0.08421686291694641, -0.030345125123858452, -0.04250985383987427, -0.016376061365008354, -0.067893385887146, -0.02974190190434456, -0.044284556061029434, -0.049485109746456146, 0.0011026785941794515, -0.012275196611881256, 0.02287200652062893, 0.02035168558359146, -0.009204450063407421, -0.029261555522680283, -0.0563928559422493, -0.007275084499269724, -0.011839224956929684, 0.014484670013189316, -0.055398937314748764, -0.01590021327137947, 0.060270797461271286, -0.019350815564393997, 0.039218366146087646, 0.036337610334157944, 0.02825169265270233, 0.04477739334106445, -0.015089703723788261, -0.051006216555833817, 0.06605080515146255, 0.04092353209853172, -0.024158895015716553, 0.025660859420895576, -0.007451531011611223, 0.01751203089952469, 0.06465350836515427, -0.12516853213310242, -0.02058061957359314, 0.011788561940193176, 0.00478837126865983, 0.021432140842080116, -0.01556636393070221, -0.048532240092754364, -0.015463645569980145, -0.0032550201285630465, 0.0422346293926239, 0.0025624241679906845, 0.003213829593732953, 0.0852225124835968, 0.004772283602505922, -0.04406173899769783, -0.01776067540049553, 0.03214476257562637, -0.044140059500932693, 0.003485330380499363, 0.041427645832300186, -0.0624551996588707, -0.02548643760383129, -0.020190972834825516, 0.01461400743573904, -0.02618914283812046, -0.0000034819561278709443, -0.00030543020693585277, 0.01565791480243206, 0.020994415506720543, 0.005893720779567957, 0.032786231487989426, 0.00031979300547391176, 0.018330153077840805, 0.05121029168367386, 0.029398420825600624, -0.019143879413604736, 0.025845782831311226, 0.044035062193870544, -0.021615194156765938, -0.009018871001899242, -0.036066435277462006, -0.012386972084641457, 0.058309491723775864, 0.029633374884724617, 0.034757111221551895, -0.040517471730709076, 0.018770063295960426, -0.000510995218064636, 0.0649971067905426, 0.0001739525905577466, -0.04409845918416977, -0.026419341564178467, 0.034547269344329834, -0.014429998584091663, 0.0474587120115757, -0.06741616874933243, -0.05265375226736069, -0.033311277627944946, 0.012992066331207752, -0.06428104639053345, 0.06614020466804504, -0.022387392818927765, -0.00726476963609457, -0.03032664582133293, -0.011450028046965599, 0.02129942551255226, 0.025637798011302948, -0.01897316239774227, -0.005345126613974571, -0.013034392148256302, 0.023834530264139175, -0.049953583627939224, 0.0455254428088665, 0.007855397649109364, 0.0060697998851537704, 0.024790016934275627, -0.04263211414217949, 0.06454651802778244, -0.018776025623083115, -0.004613010212779045, 0.020302459597587585, 0.03911242261528969, 0.027059603482484818, -0.003950810059905052, 0.03933059424161911, -0.0201418399810791, -0.030860859900712967, -0.003686119569465518, -0.004146381746977568, 0.023704346269369125, -0.04063700884580612, -0.04005025327205658, -0.029557807371020317, 0.013135626912117004, -0.06136518716812134, -0.033207863569259644, 0.06099661439657211, 0.08599958568811417, 0.05373949185013771, -0.04062200337648392, -0.03460044413805008, -0.0445343442261219, -0.0039751254953444, -0.005519050173461437, 0.021073345094919205, 0.00802325177937746, 0.005034362897276878, -0.02886301837861538, -0.020670635625720024, 0.03273778408765793, 0.012552464380860329, -0.0471317283809185, -0.04809068515896797, 0.04573057219386101, 0.06997092068195343, -0.028598738834261894, 0.050386395305395126, 0.04632566496729851, 0.02292659692466259, -0.025768671184778214, 0.04503698647022247, 0.0344005785882473, 0.03879822790622711, -0.03030787780880928, 0.002655134303495288, -0.043983180075883865, 0.03726913034915924, -0.00020431313896551728, -0.0443771556019783, 0.04544857516884804, -0.012580220587551594, -0.03922487795352936, 0.089125856757164, -0.04450337961316109, 0.015769124031066895, -0.04570913314819336, 0.018529871478676796, -0.00037996613536961377, 0.016299189999699593, 0.05290190503001213, -0.02104249969124794, -0.006396386306732893, -0.007241185288876295, 0.0422881655395031, 0.014937080442905426, -0.020272864028811455, -0.008808384649455547, 0.017341047525405884, -0.009407340548932552, 0.057831890881061554, -0.00777739891782403, -0.015550532378256321, 0.029580969363451004, 0.02621254324913025, 0.03709889575839043, 0.0014868698781356215, -0.027962764725089073, -0.02504422888159752, 0.03779510781168938, 0.05000627413392067, -0.02066570147871971, 0.04432307183742523, 0.021790143102407455, 0.006383675616234541, -0.0015451879007741809, -0.00016881668125279248, 0.09196161478757858, 0.0013510240241885185, -0.012912833131849766, 0.04691753163933754, 0.0025739313568919897, -0.006422601640224457, -0.0814259797334671, -0.01661161333322525, -0.04694342613220215, 0.03243613988161087, -0.009528297930955887, -0.04297300800681114, 0.04135765880346298, -0.02947457879781723, 0.055094119161367416, 0.07510033994913101, -0.05261460319161415, -0.005882588680833578, 0.018134616315364838, 0.030427871271967888, -0.07028292119503021, 0.0038390993140637875, 0.014861238189041615, 0.009855913929641247, -0.0038210093043744564, 0.005449737422168255, -0.007694987114518881, 0.03674910217523575, 0.005845542065799236, 0.07314532995223999, -0.003476481419056654, -0.05642576888203621, -0.03140147030353546, 0.03097628429532051, 0.04159361124038696, 0.03831387311220169, -0.024161970242857933, -0.019609004259109497, -0.006742301397025585, -0.009085522964596748, -0.023822691291570663, -0.01167325023561716, 0.010222055949270725, 0.029700079932808876, -0.012744256295263767, -0.03903236240148544, -0.0006337007507681847, -0.02547379583120346, 0.010972867719829082, -0.011862211860716343, -0.06463654339313507, 0.003797348588705063, 0.032574523240327835, -0.02996860444545746, -0.014249015599489212, -0.03034474328160286, -0.03774154558777809, -0.08189553022384644, 0.015184340067207813, -0.03648458793759346, -0.0072981975972652435, 0.059885747730731964, -0.012655033729970455, 0.02160860225558281, -0.005456534214317799, -0.018976574763655663, -0.019778860732913017, -0.02175104059278965, 0.05043633282184601, -0.002596848411485553, 0.037101805210113525, -0.016014210879802704, 0.057909391820430756, -0.004278910346329212, 0.004244795069098473, 0.05156893655657768, 0.0003490350500214845, 0.003251667832955718, -0.001411777688190341, -0.0031743114814162254, 0.0155552439391613, -0.023823203518986702, 0.004104378167539835, -0.07000619173049927, -0.03387352079153061, 0.021813007071614265, 0.014290060847997665, -0.020877651870250702, 0.01091512106359005, 0.0711028203368187, 0.02561461552977562, -0.003403726499527693, 0.017035720869898796, 0.07136881351470947, -0.009290583431720734, 0.008246497251093388, 0.06029893830418587, 0.01374796312302351, -0.022769639268517494, 0.01676199585199356, 0.051772646605968475, 0.005079373717308044, -0.020318591967225075, -0.03585942089557648, 0.06896115839481354, 0.029552850872278214, -0.04870690032839775, 0.07433396577835083, -0.020857073366642, -0.042351435869932175, -0.10512293130159378, -0.02104775607585907, -0.024463826790452003, 0.02017419971525669, 0.02568157948553562, -0.028593841940164566, -0.04431593418121338, -0.03554227203130722, -0.016858428716659546, -0.08780727535486221, 0.02361353673040867, -0.016767388209700584, 0.044602490961551666, -0.016157565638422966, -0.0074885389767587185, -0.02810252085328102, 0.008402565494179726, -0.012390757910907269, -0.0352957509458065, -0.009542613290250301, -0.04374672845005989, -0.024395152926445007, -0.047357529401779175, 0.0025024102069437504, 0.04016491025686264, -0.005210370756685734, 0.00680945860221982, 0.04813787713646889, 0.020118912681937218, 0.015523092821240425, 0.020177166908979416, 0.03268254175782204, 0.04114209860563278, 0.06070813164114952, -0.029668737202882767, -0.03631481155753136, -0.00024004273291211575, -0.01649746112525463, -0.013814886100590229, -0.02865959331393242, -0.022695202380418777, -0.022358305752277374, 0.025125162675976753, -0.0010717781260609627, 0.039970990270376205, -0.07552272081375122, 0.008951326832175255, 0.03032594732940197, -0.018848799169063568, -0.02916594408452511, -0.04468889161944389, -0.015115165151655674, 0.02155238948762417, 0.01846964843571186, -0.07442525029182434, 0.010974845848977566, 0.004138162825256586, 0.014179034158587456, -0.057419344782829285, 0.01593640446662903, -0.030348453670740128, -0.044174958020448685, 0.015297007746994495, 0.042632073163986206, -0.05779237672686577, 0.06332264095544815, -0.06711587309837341, -0.012366732582449913, -0.03669903054833412, -0.00607569282874465, 0.019405201077461243, 0.021323520690202713, 0.024323107674717903, -0.04937673360109329, -0.009097144939005375, -0.007697585970163345, 0.03889365494251251, 0.0031550657004117966, -0.0028530170675367117, 0.03507315367460251, -0.07715767621994019, -0.024110810831189156, 0.0413365438580513, 0.0017023460241034627, -0.023569399490952492, -0.015143399126827717, -0.005426990799605846, 0.047984834760427475, 0.051280029118061066, -0.01815132051706314, -0.013423004187643528, -0.028496695682406425, 0.01147447619587183, 0.053932834416627884, 0.010014976374804974, -0.07140348851680756, 0.0073525006882846355, -0.07884165644645691, -0.021461565047502518, 0.08491159230470657, -0.029356451705098152, -0.02451501227915287, 0.050545405596494675, 0.047573741525411606, -0.002060740254819393, 0.015010585077106953, -0.05256293714046478, 0.0003374166553840041, -0.01743735745549202, 0.08309970796108246, -0.04906357079744339, 0.08779921382665634, 0.007439720910042524, 0.02488761954009533, -0.021163808181881905, 0.02984604425728321, -0.006265363655984402, -0.019210124388337135, 0.026613369584083557, -0.04461317136883736, 0.023637836799025536, 0.028153497725725174, -0.03975722938776016, 0.048867546021938324, 0.044920507818460464, -0.048886220902204514, -0.027836475521326065, 0.019053945317864418, -0.02874080091714859, 0.026135919615626335, 0.023891674354672432, -0.045137837529182434, -0.03225770965218544, -0.007429416291415691, 0.022581016644835472, -0.032970208674669266, 0.002317580860108137, 0.009803501889109612, -0.02418609708547592, -0.003865052480250597, 0.005022971425205469, 0.003780846018344164, 0.025108393281698227, -0.05116602033376694, 0.011407083831727505, -0.026864068582654, 0.017851965501904488, 0.025956209748983383, 0.0031213220208883286, -0.014846503734588623, 0.02162734605371952, 0.046230778098106384, -0.02437661588191986, -0.03815721720457077, 0.01539667323231697, -0.0013708745827898383, 0.008353181183338165, -0.0182004664093256, 0.0022497009485960007, 0.030941953882575035, 0.026712210848927498, 0.014677995815873146, 0.044676635414361954, 0.015648430213332176, -0.03086521103978157, -0.065248042345047, 0.003348593134433031, 0.01602436788380146, -0.05151103064417839, 0.018835008144378662, -0.04435510188341141, 0.06429078429937363, -0.005451553035527468, 0.046909868717193604, 0.07668738067150116, 0.004413464572280645, -0.028276193886995316, -0.04505712166428566, 0.05122971162199974, -0.0065414803102612495, -0.010037308558821678, -0.0330447256565094, 0.011172518134117126, -0.09560418874025345, -0.013902230188250542, 0.053565941751003265, -0.011551889590919018, -0.04039551317691803, -0.01779601164162159, -0.06606875360012054, -0.019684065133333206, 0.029976220801472664, 0.04964689537882805, 0.049334075301885605, -0.026756465435028076, -0.05387407913804054, 0.014008105732500553, -0.004820977337658405, 0.00020420226792339236, -0.029709432274103165, -0.0748022124171257, 0.02758617512881756, -0.008613246493041515, 0.016529899090528488, 0.00017746516095940024, -0.008976377546787262, -0.03450207784771919, 0.017401205375790596, 0.006672789342701435, 0.00540921650826931, 0.00513325072824955, -0.006328415125608444, 0.02192201279103756, 0.07951341569423676, -0.05949809029698372, 0.05610380321741104, -0.023526053875684738, 0.009353230707347393, 0.023733194917440414, 0.004858291707932949, -0.0017868421273306012, 0.030775349587202072, 0.034703899174928665, -0.006014053709805012, -0.033385369926691055, 0.014535238035023212, -0.01595401205122471, -0.0026179198175668716, 0.13794302940368652, -0.03512372076511383, 0.0038907798007130623, -0.03922295942902565, -0.008442982099950314, -0.02978014573454857, -0.05001164972782135, -0.019539350643754005, -0.08684055507183075, 0.05241703242063522, 0.011631323024630547, -0.05133846774697304, 0.002407425781711936, -0.000885157729499042 ]
<p>I am reading a code for a Bayesian clustering method. Both prior and the likelihood are normally distributed. If I understood correctly, such cases are called "conjugate priors"</p> <p>My question is about calculating the posterior mean and variance. So it is implemented in the code as following</p> <pre><code>d = nrow (data.i)##number of attributes n = ncol (data.i)##number of replication for each attribute Smatrix = matrix (1, nrow=d, ncol=d)##correlation of attributes Imatrix = Smatrix - 1 diag (Imatrix) = 1 prior.precision = solve (sdWICluster^2 * Smatrix + sdTSampling^2 * Imatrix) #inverting the prior correlation matrix (prior.precision) prior.mean = cluster.mean # mean of each clusters sample.precision = sdResidual^(-2) * Imatrix sample.mean = apply (data.i, 1, mean)#mean for each cluster post.cov = solve (as.matrix(prior.precision + n*sample.precision)) # posterior covariance matrix post.mean = as.vector (post.cov %*% (prior.precision %*% prior.mean + n*sample.precision %*% sample.mean)) # posterior of the mean </code></pre> <p>it seems the code has take the following formula, </p> <p>$\mu_{po} = C_{po}\times((\mu_{pr} \times \tau_{pr})+(n\times\tau_{li}\times\mu_{li}))$</p> <p>$C_{po} = \tau_{pr} + n\times\tau_{li}$</p> <p>As I said, this is the case of conjugates of normal distributions with unknown mean but variance known; however, it does not fit to the formula I have from <a href="http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~plam/teaching/methods/conjugacy/conjugacy_print.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a>. (or may be it does by my eye is not able to catch). I appreciate if someone make some comments about the code and the formula</p>
g74291
[ 0.011160050518810749, -0.044538889080286026, 0.009480164386332035, -0.06836030632257462, -0.045803673565387726, 0.007917734794318676, 0.011151043698191643, 0.012367552146315575, -0.02546997182071209, -0.031726498156785965, 0.015994995832443237, 0.007018909323960543, -0.03440329059958458, 0.02203482761979103, -0.025121090933680534, -0.0007553014438599348, 0.06032923609018326, 0.018743790686130524, 0.013208753429353237, 0.025665516033768654, -0.07442072778940201, 0.03571975603699684, -0.026642849668860435, -0.03293444216251373, -0.017451412975788116, -0.012998069636523724, -0.020460085943341255, 0.03313053399324417, -0.03977596014738083, 0.0015241564251482487, 0.01491850521415472, 0.007206532172858715, 0.04452097415924072, -0.09293145686388016, 0.0303959921002388, 0.02193402126431465, 0.0341152660548687, -0.010221869684755802, 0.00853510107845068, 0.012628319673240185, -0.010499908588826656, 0.03128265216946602, 0.05911838263273239, 0.06758173555135727, -0.014856836758553982, 0.015449034981429577, 0.00902344286441803, -0.015920555219054222, -0.005911560729146004, -0.06357120722532272, -0.002970667788758874, 0.0719590112566948, 0.03160751983523369, -0.07322745770215988, 0.010883125476539135, 0.049474019557237625, 0.032168176025152206, 0.003966026473790407, -0.0569927804172039, 0.029497608542442322, 0.036006610840559006, -0.014331318438053131, -0.020310744643211365, 0.01528328750282526, 0.0389508455991745, 0.018080255016684532, -0.025999974459409714, 0.012162340804934502, -0.03135991841554642, -0.030668901279568672, -0.035336222499608994, 0.007037346251308918, 0.04541684314608574, -0.017842642962932587, -0.03795004263520241, -0.04203023016452789, 0.06691842526197433, -0.009931557811796665, -0.009692434221506119, 0.006830610800534487, -0.02882707677781582, 0.004637985024601221, 0.025945978239178658, 0.053029127418994904, 0.05644061788916588, -0.01791294850409031, 0.007201851811259985, 0.017037522047758102, -0.01603749580681324, -0.027629271149635315, 0.012224864214658737, -0.023951614275574684, 0.09463117271661758, 0.07080130279064178, -0.007575736381113529, -0.048771124333143234, -0.07975932210683823, 0.039235036820173264, -0.016775552183389664, -0.051926832646131516, -0.011067948304116726, 0.024247270077466965, 0.05006001517176628, 0.005036590620875359, -0.03440999239683151, 0.006003737449645996, 0.08369781821966171, -0.04469256475567818, 0.02099699154496193, -0.059341274201869965, -0.06043532118201256, 0.008999894373118877, -0.04320335388183594, -0.0056846183724701405, -0.03938507288694382, -0.02862156182527542, 0.057112179696559906, -0.04342871159315109, 0.03482985123991966, -0.011772362515330315, -0.013927727937698364, -0.020932761952280998, 0.016033489257097244, 0.0669618546962738, -0.03029506653547287, 0.046145960688591, -0.031911201775074005, 0.0063334619626402855, 0.06343955546617508, -0.062820203602314, 0.0001224695733981207, -0.013456221669912338, 0.011604325845837593, 0.1031649187207222, -0.030376428738236427, -0.01578293927013874, -0.007044470403343439, 0.05913599953055382, -0.015525571070611477, 0.04074975848197937, -0.06315848231315613, -0.045639947056770325, 0.02128147892653942, -0.03344227001070976, 0.016846932470798492, -0.0040280818939208984, -0.02629431150853634, -0.01424198318272829, -0.02724814973771572, 0.05071301758289337, -0.0009980524191632867, 0.016438055783510208, 0.01845715567469597, 0.034693725407123566, -0.034143172204494476, 0.008267039433121681, -0.04349786415696144, -0.01410366129130125, -0.005448668263852596, 0.015485978685319424, 0.028639916330575943, -0.0041097295470535755, 0.04503699019551277, -0.02305338717997074, -0.003566837403923273, 0.03297675773501396, 0.04991593956947327, -0.009650631807744503, -0.06777916103601456, -0.0381227545440197, 0.00710691511631012, -0.027270054444670677, -0.02626955881714821, -0.04524383693933487, 0.02400059625506401, 0.024678373709321022, 0.04249538853764534, 0.0029616570100188255, -0.017835116013884544, 0.05181054770946503, -0.02799254283308983, 0.0650859847664833, -0.008156798779964447, -0.014391602948307991, 0.029841309413313866, -0.03314768895506859, -0.005417538806796074, 0.008849970065057278, -0.02277296595275402, -0.035617657005786896, 0.02908133529126644, -0.03395732864737511, -0.017777010798454285, -0.010289059020578861, -0.03491022065281868, 0.02499421499669552, 0.031882427632808685, 0.04719701036810875, 0.03283001855015755, -0.012923488393425941, -0.053775571286678314, 0.0027494977694004774, 0.027839308604598045, 0.02307014912366867, 0.03443872183561325, 0.0008800927316769958, 0.010454808361828327, -0.007792886812239885, -0.020186619833111763, 0.05284617841243744, -0.04348662868142128, -0.03448505699634552, -0.07363791018724442, 0.04710489138960838, 0.030115816742181778, -0.008355233818292618, 0.04791278764605522, -0.0025814080145210028, -0.03559307008981705, -0.008858867920935154, -0.05364106968045235, -0.04856434836983681, 0.03453478962182999, -0.03267521411180496, -0.008415469899773598, 0.036378394812345505, 0.02954907715320587, -0.008055439218878746, -0.0049598501063883305, 0.009669285267591476, -0.002083749510347843, -0.015607733279466629, -0.011161621659994125, -0.01792054809629917, -0.0003064533229917288, 0.039831534028053284, 0.019748924300074577, -0.0009443268645554781, 0.04353183135390282, 0.03524887189269066, 0.020439861342310905, -0.012628822587430477, 0.04890487343072891, 0.0329643078148365, 0.03881290927529335, -0.026308581233024597, 0.051486529409885406, -0.03630443289875984, -0.010265638120472431, 0.027186688035726547, 0.04027707502245903, -0.001286999904550612, -0.028778521344065666, -0.05532141774892807, 0.02094639465212822, -0.017950234934687614, 0.014857923611998558, -0.03357677534222603, -0.034596964716911316, 0.0007100806105881929, -0.026448853313922882, -0.008385184220969677, -0.023345476016402245, -0.0469452403485775, -0.025254664942622185, 0.007956931367516518, 0.04100380465388298, 0.01730170287191868, 0.05556768178939819, -0.016299093142151833, 0.019030410796403885, 0.05141981691122055, 0.04089989513158798, 0.05165906995534897, 0.03659562021493912, 0.04443862661719322, -0.0262550488114357, -0.039572522044181824, 0.04343431442975998, -0.00921612698584795, -0.005186273716390133, 0.0035416577011346817, 0.012035761028528214, -0.028576843440532684, 0.0156454648822546, -0.057178474962711334, -0.0057391393929719925, -0.06724381446838379, 0.03710086643695831, 0.07868417352437973, -0.0028411431703716516, -0.00241015013307333, 0.013780833221971989, -0.020876619964838028, 0.020333802327513695, 0.028813352808356285, 0.050380777567625046, -0.07125228643417358, 0.01100346352905035, 0.04363756999373436, -0.08662940561771393, 0.028560223057866096, 0.021070947870612144, -0.028150079771876335, 0.05636714771389961, 0.028070000931620598, -0.007955371402204037, 0.04558534920215607, -0.03781832754611969, -0.0028084823861718178, -0.04878448322415352, -0.0034757652319967747, -0.009875975549221039, -0.07462552189826965, -0.0025411273818463087, -0.016276409849524498, -0.03570067882537842, -0.004303124267607927, -0.04366711899638176, -0.05562102794647217, -0.03538194298744202, -0.01564251445233822, -0.01578870788216591, 0.0015327822184190154, 0.04311696067452431, 0.04292821139097214, -0.05360626056790352, 0.04870995506644249, 0.024220751598477364, -0.04453537240624428, 0.011893980205059052, 0.019779473543167114, -0.021661311388015747, 0.012893984094262123, 0.0255690049380064, -0.06865331530570984, -0.03363965079188347, 0.08586312085390091, -0.033463023602962494, 0.061803460121154785, -0.002977261785417795, -0.050208114087581635, -0.05758420377969742, -0.0134237390011549, 0.01768609695136547, 0.0176409762352705, 0.04365991801023483, 0.04478505998849869, 0.0262331310659647, 0.02320324443280697, 0.04218309000134468, 0.013221953064203262, -0.003217753954231739, -0.02482336014509201, 0.02875664457678795, 0.10563436150550842, 0.01616443507373333, -0.0004900995409116149, -0.013917750678956509, 0.05010659992694855, 0.007906178943812847, -0.031081194058060646, 0.006171276792883873, 0.022969864308834076, 0.06946871429681778, 0.03347206115722656, 0.06308288872241974, 0.028788838535547256, 0.02252449281513691, -0.04359181970357895, 0.04626987501978874, -0.02650475688278675, 0.034614447504282, -0.01790778338909149, 0.018812263384461403, -0.005916131194680929, -0.004867625888437033, 0.01087239570915699, 0.0009317802614532411, 0.0026400440838187933, 0.0338396318256855, -0.002228760626167059, -0.026670318096876144, 0.016886604949831963, -0.026147322729229927, -0.0004736713890451938, 0.007894334383308887, 0.041686929762363434, 0.050688132643699646, -0.04197605699300766, -0.0413418710231781, -0.027555905282497406, -0.06561895459890366, 0.008719571866095066, 0.048059605062007904, 0.012268497608602047, -0.008750987239181995, 0.05442067235708237, 0.026213910430669785, -0.026983359828591347, -0.04233497381210327, 0.07927887886762619, 0.020285099744796753, -0.03677050396800041, 0.0020863309036940336, 0.03783557936549187, -0.032700855284929276, -0.03928479179739952, -0.03270784392952919, 0.018255269154906273, -0.03615238890051842, 0.023903118446469307, 0.01016808021813631, -0.011753680184483528, 0.0321231484413147, -0.033101636916399, 0.051839012652635574, 0.008635244332253933, -0.05864787474274635, 0.03823493421077728, 0.0034888610243797302, 0.02726566046476364, -0.02088000439107418, -0.04239095374941826, 0.03456813842058182, 0.057083163410425186, 0.035037312656641006, -0.039000898599624634, 0.04932146519422531, -0.05087875947356224, 0.026462074369192123, 0.015167678706347942, 0.009078577160835266, -0.004660140257328749, -0.03267185389995575, -0.013933386653661728, -0.025157593190670013, -0.012071452103555202, -0.03931761160492897, -0.015400242991745472, -0.04302166402339935, -0.02385174110531807, 0.011973162181675434, 0.007168857380747795, -0.013498985208570957, 0.058302994817495346, -0.0413472019135952, 0.04517069086432457, 0.023406200110912323, 0.022293411195278168, 0.02568637765944004, 0.022500164806842804, 0.015485471114516258, -0.02777819335460663, -0.0037695178762078285, 0.019023526459932327, 0.002851364901289344, -0.01111745834350586, -0.025447258725762367, -0.0054796552285552025, -0.0435146726667881, -0.008616339415311813, -0.005369802936911583, -0.02084960602223873, -0.03254484012722969, -0.030029963701963425, -0.05915774405002594, -0.02628750540316105, 0.07576774060726166, 0.023471305146813393, 0.0029290644451975822, 0.009718519635498524, 0.008866017684340477, -0.03222985565662384, -0.010830990970134735, 0.07137802243232727, 0.032120633870363235, 0.024598218500614166, 0.030651694163680077, 0.05683857947587967, -0.02937794290482998, 0.0454743392765522, -0.060629308223724365, 0.010416761040687561, -0.05279390141367912, 0.04670138657093048, 0.024285832419991493, -0.05213972553610802, 0.06954038888216019, -0.03627852723002434, -0.045246440917253494, 0.05364612117409706, 0.06144843250513077, -0.004232040140777826, 0.031184282153844833, -0.036262400448322296, -0.024904705584049225, 0.03058105893433094, -0.0028938432224094868, -0.06603964418172836, -0.06878327578306198, 0.04756858944892883, -0.015590785071253777, -0.03736834228038788, 0.0696546882390976, 0.023781942203640938, 0.05374212935566902, 0.012603041715919971, 0.013928157277405262, -0.00983571819961071, 0.022920750081539154, 0.040677573531866074, 0.051621951162815094, -0.0009498483268544078, -0.05907180532813072, -0.04930361732840538, 0.0201376061886549, -0.015826702117919922, -0.02068473771214485, -0.03355923295021057, 0.015800779685378075, -0.0020392462611198425, -0.0045128995552659035, -0.0011928911553695798, -0.05005152150988579, -0.03371627256274223, -0.026063818484544754, -0.06467103213071823, 0.010626327246427536, 0.02816706895828247, -0.06550746411085129, 0.036501020193099976, -0.028863150626420975, -0.07777902483940125, -0.044851746410131454, -0.02484251745045185, -0.05284663289785385, 0.012720068916678429, 0.029796548187732697, -0.018137522041797638, -0.04250643402338028, -0.04286867380142212, 0.02166883647441864, -0.011280053295195103, -0.061466559767723083, -0.04710456356406212, 0.05962032824754715, 0.007018100470304489, 0.04232746735215187, -0.007572446018457413, 0.03391014412045479, 0.0020889448933303356, -0.007776874583214521, -0.009180448018014431, -0.03909881040453911, 0.061028771102428436, 0.007616567425429821, -0.03885693475604057, 0.04618503153324127, -0.0057726274244487286, 0.007780526764690876, -0.05752848833799362, -0.0031340441200882196, 0.0029212073422968388, -0.03513599559664726, 0.0006150307599455118, 0.00017497717635706067, -0.006822298280894756, 0.013123109936714172, 0.01933613233268261, -0.006662674713879824, -0.07270009815692902, -0.003955218940973282, -0.001968568190932274, 0.016953760758042336, 0.017175592482089996, 0.013619853183627129, -0.039513103663921356, 0.022441282868385315, -0.05756274610757828, 0.032119933515787125, -0.02626202255487442, 0.0017562794964760542, -0.022926725447177887, -0.009896710515022278, -0.043370287865400314, 0.012015552259981632, -0.00035681179724633694, -0.039366014301776886, -0.06716150790452957, 0.03575468435883522, 0.04093840718269348, 0.011701472103595734, -0.005118308123201132, 0.0077985599637031555, -0.004176393151283264, 0.028627533465623856, 0.03013860434293747, -0.01853448897600174, -0.008525682613253593, 0.0024111405946314335, 0.019498204812407494, 0.05536145344376564, 0.015680592507123947, 0.03902023658156395, 0.03549864515662193, -0.049627769738435745, 0.047307100147008896, 0.0009179800399579108, 0.054570768028497696, 0.06119421869516373, -0.008928042836487293, 0.03379998356103897, 0.07608535140752792, 0.011764051392674446, 0.056144829839468, -0.10017820447683334, -0.019630521535873413, -0.04619639739394188, 0.05088323727250099, 0.04260920733213425, 0.019688837230205536, -0.02585536055266857, 0.040582720190286636, 0.01797151006758213, 0.025929540395736694, -0.022825609892606735, -0.07491399347782135, 0.05638786777853966, 0.03187613561749458, 0.02315543033182621, -0.027645951136946678, -0.02214733138680458, -0.017492244020104408, -0.0065630218014121056, 0.018049392849206924, 0.03492509946227074, 0.10507581382989883, -0.014728422276675701, 0.10946518927812576, 0.044077739119529724, 0.03434227779507637, -0.0009503980400040746, 0.025173025205731392, -0.022769836708903313, 0.03777690976858139, 0.07642015069723129, 0.04587303847074509, -0.10206364095211029, 0.009663623757660389, -0.003666129196062684, 0.014239848591387272, -0.00742265535518527, 0.023303840309381485, -0.006694559473544359, -0.011235862039029598, 0.07606291025876999, 0.022683795541524887, -0.008414496667683125, -0.02430805377662182, -0.023136714473366737, -0.04796914756298065, -0.022531205788254738, 0.012825624085962772, -0.017697950825095177, 0.007881365716457367, 0.04597831889986992, -0.0006786519079469144, -0.030918065458536148, -0.05023442953824997, 0.03320096433162689, -0.03687959536910057, 0.004364794120192528, -0.02538927085697651, -0.0033658358734101057, 0.0024072027299553156, 0.015817835927009583, 0.05033041164278984, -0.03862648084759712, -0.023498013615608215, -0.045843251049518585, -0.034146640449762344, -0.0460238978266716, -0.03241880610585213, 0.029367301613092422, 0.021322114393115044, -0.007397238630801439, -0.056764114648103714, 0.06904556602239609, -0.03760990872979164, -0.013553613796830177, -0.07202820479869843, -0.0053749470971524715, 0.01693568006157875, -0.013226140290498734, -0.004719926975667477, 0.032722730189561844, 0.004617270082235336, 0.02593942917883396, 0.0342826247215271, 0.013130360282957554, -0.008398271165788174, -0.01921205408871174, -0.0013358370633795857, -0.018140198662877083, -0.005274644121527672, 0.026493702083826065, 0.0025733059737831354, -0.027343695983290672, -0.0739249736070633, -0.024834904819726944, -0.0031769308261573315, -0.03951326757669449, -0.013961564749479294, -0.013405595906078815, -0.021974943578243256, -0.008828858844935894, -0.008901462890207767, -0.10341987758874893, -0.02479693293571472, -0.024079058319330215, 0.0123570142313838, 0.0008888104348443449, 0.0068066855892539024, 0.010381635278463364, -0.07661997526884079, 0.015572292730212212, 0.07221614569425583, -0.02378074824810028, -0.02313944697380066, -0.009314308874309063, -0.035842761397361755, -0.07521959394216537, -0.00892234779894352, 0.0331277996301651, 0.008199743926525116, 0.007537719793617725, -0.02310786023736, -0.01603739708662033, 0.010130688548088074, -0.02963007055222988, -0.02782735414803028, 0.02095578983426094, 0.014013342559337616, 0.012208557687699795, 0.0005817299243062735, -0.001137305865995586, 0.03392397239804268, -0.004018144216388464, -0.03886468708515167, -0.04937932267785072, -0.05345148965716362, -0.05125303566455841, 0.034544143825769424, 0.0377827063202858, -0.014018882997334003, 0.03970856964588165, 0.027517806738615036, 0.07773303985595703, -0.07019825279712677, -0.0010070583084598184, -0.041001323610544205, -0.06735667586326599, 0.03319591283798218, -0.030826468020677567, -0.02523454837501049, -0.056647639721632004, 0.007310036104172468 ]
<p>I am plotting a density estimate for misclassification rate of some classifier using the standard <code>plot</code> and <code>lines</code> functions. Even though I've set <code>xlim=c(0.32,0.38)</code> and <code>ylim=c(0,100)</code> within the <code>plot</code> command, the x-limits and the y-limits are a bit wider than I'd like. How can I get the bottom left of the plot to have coordinates (0.32,0) and the top right of the plot to have coordinates (0.38, 100)?</p>
g74292
[ -0.020037975162267685, -0.0027508880011737347, -0.00023714540293440223, -0.01891293190419674, 0.028643760830163956, 0.006419071927666664, 0.00532059371471405, -0.0025745993480086327, -0.0820121020078659, -0.03937166929244995, 0.006104092579334974, 0.0360599048435688, 0.03661806508898735, -0.035011883825063705, 0.04761642590165138, -0.009410884231328964, 0.023363888263702393, 0.028676247224211693, 0.02703595906496048, 0.033940449357032776, 0.036363862454891205, 0.02385582961142063, 0.009955800138413906, -0.02176516316831112, -0.01885068044066429, -0.03461769223213196, 0.015098894014954567, 0.006427851505577564, -0.050291758030653, 0.017916569486260414, 0.01658139005303383, 0.048965852707624435, -0.012109430506825447, 0.0035703021567314863, 0.024477455765008926, -0.012927333824336529, 0.029974374920129776, -0.00923093967139721, -0.033545877784490585, 0.03702479973435402, -0.036623597145080566, 0.023702358826994896, 0.05992406979203224, -0.000016313360902131535, -0.035490792244672775, -0.015053357928991318, -0.033362340182065964, 0.006649860180914402, 0.04199737310409546, -0.03998959809541702, -0.05328603833913803, 0.016047541052103043, -0.027610227465629578, -0.010450741276144981, 0.011430222541093826, 0.0068068127147853374, -0.027673957869410515, 0.02500765770673752, 0.011675038374960423, 0.01659241132438183, 0.010838844813406467, 0.010270128026604652, 0.04565001651644707, -0.02697443589568138, -0.009870651178061962, 0.032521337270736694, -0.08303878456354141, -0.01778843067586422, -0.11004171520471573, -0.00923926755785942, 0.008474906906485558, -0.04855051636695862, -0.04824676737189293, -0.04137057438492775, -0.10418367385864258, -0.038178540766239166, 0.009840767830610275, 0.000408545951358974, -0.020816635340452194, 0.02381100505590439, 0.02545832470059395, 0.02332106977701187, -0.007340926211327314, -0.019277259707450867, 0.032688189297914505, 0.07139995694160461, 0.01646839827299118, -0.03586215525865555, 0.02260063961148262, 0.026152634993195534, 0.01375906728208065, 0.028201036155223846, 0.010977888479828835, 0.07054371386766434, 0.013370719738304615, -0.025184234604239464, 0.0028074581641703844, 0.048534635454416275, -0.007313891779631376, 0.01398485153913498, 0.018559813499450684, 0.06993738561868668, 0.03908174857497215, -0.02091963216662407, -0.039393115788698196, 0.04639933258295059, 0.08207598328590393, -0.004727942869067192, 0.036545637995004654, -0.02794470079243183, 0.011384808458387852, -0.033969081938266754, -0.037064459174871445, -0.009966817684471607, -0.006995213683694601, -0.09204684942960739, 0.02637396566569805, 0.018029334023594856, -0.0021061787847429514, 0.07169661670923233, -0.026490282267332077, -0.060867197811603546, 0.04832399636507034, 0.0019829431548714638, 0.012726440094411373, 0.009024301543831825, 0.0006206995458342135, 0.044444259256124496, 0.07179049402475357, -0.021874306723475456, -0.015836358070373535, -0.014337034896016121, 0.04266700893640518, 0.014971769414842129, -0.051003873348236084, -0.004674326628446579, 0.0008811414591036737, 0.01894942857325077, -0.017490526661276817, -0.0031586734112352133, 0.005675041116774082, 0.003002108307555318, 0.02349080517888069, -0.0532398596405983, -0.021107330918312073, 0.008527416735887527, -0.05232393369078636, 0.04059543088078499, -0.011657901108264923, -0.001366917509585619, -0.015421776100993156, 0.03494534268975258, 0.007680863607674837, 0.045920949429273605, -0.0692511722445488, -0.011567279696464539, 0.0035303491167724133, -0.00009435569518245757, -0.041194140911102295, -0.012443412095308304, 0.015457039698958397, 0.010575123131275177, 0.02467891201376915, -0.015385790728032589, -0.018773216754198074, 0.016617441549897194, 0.0017144816229119897, -0.04217175394296646, -0.05285043641924858, -0.04888277128338814, -0.03375575318932533, 0.022350959479808807, -0.004854088183492422, -0.05584101751446724, 0.06077776849269867, 0.058693110942840576, -0.02600337564945221, 0.011457688175141811, 0.05507994070649147, 0.0366925373673439, -0.0370168574154377, -0.0022233508061617613, 0.0013166097924113274, -0.005364701151847839, -0.009803486987948418, -0.0059092384763062, -0.03679409623146057, 0.0034373453818261623, -0.08046888560056686, -0.015106815844774246, -0.0016722045838832855, -0.033234596252441406, -0.0344633124768734, 0.021727005019783974, -0.01940339244902134, -0.019927160814404488, 0.02833726815879345, -0.009827719070017338, -0.02332434244453907, 0.004773340653628111, -0.026383228600025177, -0.014911545440554619, 0.03892133757472038, 0.018026255071163177, -0.05197257921099663, -0.07534842193126678, -0.031025059521198273, -0.01641017012298107, -0.004687225446105003, 0.03386201336979866, -0.05185588821768761, -0.09400591254234314, -0.015543675050139427, 0.013772236183285713, 0.002205746481195092, -0.026365648955106735, 0.026553088799118996, 0.03555972874164581, 0.00425229175016284, -0.038023579865694046, -0.053239330649375916, -0.000662401202134788, 0.04969106242060661, 0.014565675519406796, 0.016401391476392746, -0.004426900297403336, 0.055768515914678574, 0.049664124846458435, 0.003021880518645048, -0.001968001015484333, 0.013532868586480618, -0.002523548901081085, 0.011888977140188217, -0.044636499136686325, -0.0141638508066535, 0.03407822921872139, -0.02796672284603119, 0.022318273782730103, 0.0070222788490355015, 0.005457124672830105, -0.010270335711538792, 0.0341954231262207, 0.02198980189859867, 0.01970682665705681, 0.05553033575415611, 0.021082624793052673, 0.0037250888999551535, 0.0011589850764721632, 0.014150472357869148, 0.0652611181139946, -0.058909133076667786, 0.05167635902762413, -0.005378643982112408, 0.029594765976071358, -0.019217392429709435, -0.06437534838914871, -0.059882752597332, -0.0006403703009709716, -0.04533122479915619, -0.12896038591861725, -0.028012579306960106, 0.06923812627792358, -0.01584254950284958, -0.013813781552016735, -0.027327103540301323, -0.007923671044409275, 0.004450025502592325, 0.043529678136110306, 0.05885020270943642, -0.0063323210924863815, -0.06019376963376999, 0.04159928858280182, 0.06136327236890793, 0.0398637093603611, -0.0034817999694496393, -0.024441447108983994, 0.022292576730251312, -0.016369663178920746, -0.0038100038655102253, 0.05170628800988197, 0.021653233096003532, -0.002942431252449751, 0.053752440959215164, 0.07517315447330475, 0.03597359359264374, -0.010780221782624722, -0.06269519031047821, 0.022726718336343765, -0.05217224732041359, 0.0005140476278029382, -0.01066107302904129, 0.009846172295510769, 0.06441187113523483, -0.05172500014305115, 0.0027733996976166964, -0.03129686415195465, 0.0179214496165514, -0.0033419355750083923, 0.043461792171001434, -0.024553032591938972, 0.012637016363441944, 0.026052488014101982, -0.037368133664131165, 0.026361841708421707, -0.017121559008955956, -0.04247400909662247, 0.01830751821398735, -0.020820219069719315, 0.012785287573933601, 0.00793334748595953, 0.07232190668582916, 0.0012305013369768858, -0.039260078221559525, -0.07981578260660172, 0.052947916090488434, -0.03554593771696091, 0.004246275871992111, 0.001963940681889653, -0.00534282298758626, -0.002787252189591527, 0.000996503047645092, -0.026339679956436157, -0.01890546642243862, 0.04054678976535797, 0.00800693966448307, 0.028207644820213318, -0.01890535093843937, -0.036658309400081635, -0.059200920164585114, 0.041608478873968124, 0.02830558642745018, 0.014565183781087399, -0.0039873141795396805, -0.016186548396945, 0.012667988426983356, 0.0018951831152662635, 0.05024885758757591, -0.011535083875060081, 0.06028330698609352, -0.03301037847995758, -0.041992299258708954, 0.010180921293795109, 0.004513856023550034, -0.03008193150162697, -0.005432228557765484, 0.014353872276842594, -0.024990767240524292, 0.057892847806215286, -0.0034790842328220606, 0.014949786476790905, -0.015162326395511627, -0.00758315296843648, 0.014124967157840729, 0.0289138276129961, 0.03128008544445038, 0.05828734114766121, 0.015962451696395874, 0.010570315644145012, -0.05233125388622284, 0.0036959191784262657, -0.007384145632386208, -0.0026680235750973225, 0.002035607350990176, 0.011030380614101887, -0.004274706821888685, 0.01630658470094204, 0.015011278912425041, 0.06440022587776184, -0.012492712587118149, -0.028334809467196465, 0.007766454480588436, -0.009961426258087158, 0.09131019562482834, -0.017148388549685478, -0.04561974108219147, -0.03994511812925339, 0.030387476086616516, -0.020144080743193626, 0.004272932186722755, 0.03487608954310417, -0.015968823805451393, 0.015009460039436817, -0.005090361926704645, -0.03953447937965393, -0.029215466231107712, -0.013903225772082806, 0.019443323835730553, -0.008727402426302433, 0.09719666093587875, -0.020551420748233795, 0.0017650749068707228, -0.04856380075216293, -0.006823526695370674, 0.03906111791729927, 0.014166675508022308, -0.06782199442386627, 0.02254515513777733, 0.021528853103518486, -0.10569827258586884, 0.03943836688995361, -0.0006393649964593351, 0.008815414272248745, -0.020208869129419327, -0.029277393594384193, -0.0018018964910879731, -0.09411430358886719, -0.03752032667398453, 0.012862185947597027, 0.02727627009153366, -0.0279388427734375, -0.005607300903648138, -0.07243181020021439, 0.03941570222377777, 0.0032035731710493565, 0.046777866780757904, -0.012081319466233253, 0.01887720450758934, 0.04036363959312439, -0.014716551639139652, 0.022852009162306786, -0.006665078457444906, 0.06573741883039474, -0.004819136578589678, -0.03056401200592518, 0.03375767171382904, 0.003584138350561261, 0.03335295990109444, -0.021725768223404884, 0.04623032733798027, 0.05835467576980591, -0.014956697821617126, 0.05183950811624527, 0.002012750832363963, -0.012786570936441422, -0.012957707047462463, -0.08180132508277893, -0.044824615120887756, -0.058528583496809006, 0.022024255245923996, 0.030280709266662598, -0.02469371072947979, -0.02858884073793888, -0.07190920412540436, -0.041999876499176025, -0.007353102322667837, 0.014010174199938774, -0.031798336654901505, -0.013830344192683697, -0.02498653531074524, 0.038943562656641006, -0.014323904179036617, -0.0058252387680113316, 0.0121938930824399, -0.038637347519397736, 0.053476329892873764, -0.04338998720049858, -0.013040225021541119, -0.0023030932061374187, 0.004182879813015461, -0.042021192610263824, 0.010707681067287922, -0.030094465240836143, -0.09098891168832779, -0.03972047567367554, 0.019031649455428123, -0.0021671000868082047, -0.049042049795389175, -0.03651810437440872, -0.03880167752504349, 0.0067602829076349735, -0.002881009830161929, 0.05064960941672325, 0.08405096083879471, -0.004939884878695011, 0.0042261239141225815, 0.04498568922281265, -0.02968413382768631, 0.020697662606835365, -0.08109395205974579, -0.037706825882196426, -0.07830091565847397, 0.024085747078061104, -0.0020139666739851236, -0.00431457394734025, 0.022989433258771896, -0.008957951329648495, -0.030011672526597977, -0.04130767285823822, 0.042532291263341904, 0.011626608669757843, 0.004409971181303263, -0.032212626188993454, 0.008474636822938919, 0.03683646768331528, -0.04825850948691368, -0.04423578828573227, 0.0007011151174083352, -0.04827391356229782, 0.023090114817023277, 0.02058100514113903, 0.017758749425411224, 0.013211620971560478, -0.01995679922401905, 0.006985156796872616, -0.006776093039661646, 0.0024139825254678726, 0.022581549361348152, 0.0034451887477189302, -0.0021373722702264786, 0.002222483279183507, -0.016774890944361687, 0.017163574695587158, 0.03768899664282799, -0.02074531652033329, 0.034127961844205856, -0.0565812885761261, -0.07639036327600479, 0.059423480182886124, -0.03342166543006897, -0.02841958962380886, 0.05294232442975044, -0.022219937294721603, 0.0606621690094471, -0.017820194363594055, 0.03155402094125748, -0.007249732036143541, -0.04296020418405533, -0.021624121814966202, 0.01932680420577526, -0.010339596308767796, -0.00043997110333293676, 0.04906565696001053, -0.01693151332437992, -0.02545466460287571, -0.040790438652038574, -0.019959252327680588, -0.010660341940820217, -0.006839343812316656, 0.06463004648685455, -0.025914451107382774, 0.06824211776256561, -0.016910307109355927, -0.043493129312992096, -0.001701702713035047, -0.014081270433962345, -0.051976848393678665, -0.023224860429763794, -0.011834927834570408, -0.015202343463897705, -0.020127123221755028, 0.021703394129872322, 0.017566820606589317, 0.018144818022847176, -0.07446750998497009, -0.0328097939491272, 0.017513016238808632, -0.017405850812792778, 0.02773451805114746, 0.009240800514817238, -0.015706932172179222, 0.034294866025447845, -0.008451499044895172, 0.03064241260290146, 0.07521611452102661, -0.028366323560476303, 0.004829784389585257, 0.0032392418943345547, 0.04910979047417641, 0.022269170731306076, 0.04342789202928543, 0.022228006273508072, -0.043157871812582016, -0.026912391185760498, 0.06613289564847946, 0.03890303894877434, -0.022579524666070938, 0.039975494146347046, 0.055690865963697433, 0.026971295475959778, -0.005074424669146538, -0.045338016003370285, 0.01648847572505474, -0.06921274960041046, -0.055796049535274506, -0.07006929069757462, 0.027474485337734222, -0.010396492667496204, -0.04270133003592491, 0.024493079632520676, -0.04128873348236084, -0.004397825337946415, -0.03740463778376579, 0.05816046521067619, 0.03610739856958389, -0.0016494799638167024, -0.040986962616443634, -0.0564962774515152, 0.06568668782711029, 0.039927709847688675, 0.009458073414862156, 0.028749369084835052, 0.036887411028146744, 0.07799139618873596, 0.03008931502699852, -0.06532076001167297, -0.028052927926182747, -0.034099042415618896, -0.005071297287940979, 0.028629060834646225, -0.002345205517485738, -0.036597006022930145, 0.010979048907756805, -0.00003552859925548546, 0.05439956486225128, 0.026670338585972786, -0.020943524315953255, 0.03296062350273132, 0.00005279801553115249, -0.04515553265810013, -0.05003151297569275, 0.010421059094369411, -0.05372282490134239, -0.05874616652727127, 0.03428434208035469, -0.0290895476937294, -0.007228050380945206, 0.06488899886608124, -0.030852485448122025, 0.05567769706249237, 0.011006724089384079, 0.0016137657221406698, 0.005711175501346588, -0.044246211647987366, -0.032558903098106384, -0.025159409269690514, 0.049125317484140396, -0.01644616201519966, 0.07373431324958801, 0.05226445570588112, 0.06755626201629639, 0.03573836758732796, -0.005229916423559189, -0.011652492918074131, -0.028982054442167282, -0.03590643033385277, 0.014078491367399693, 0.05669176205992699, -0.041573598980903625, -0.08308954536914825, 0.03423367813229561, 0.05809887871146202, -0.0016388542717322707, -0.05336672440171242, 0.06321483850479126, 0.05192258954048157, 0.05457509681582451, 0.0580328069627285, -0.02506883814930916, 0.0059277936816215515, 0.02499796636402607, -0.06273816525936127, -0.025457754731178284, 0.0034141228534281254, 0.0018689770950004458, 0.05640094727277756, 0.023322980850934982, 0.0030577313154935837, 0.0222938135266304, -0.0628512054681778, -0.048305921256542206, -0.02197073958814144, -0.013984831981360912, -0.01268820557743311, 0.037196170538663864, 0.06714140623807907, 0.041727472096681595, 0.032322049140930176, 0.0363190658390522, 0.014943433925509453, 0.025360513478517532, 0.004784341901540756, -0.006651214323937893, -0.013972165994346142, -0.05339207127690315, -0.003963754046708345, -0.03750564530491829, 0.014112502336502075, -0.00922588724642992, 0.05617109686136246, -0.009380207397043705, -0.016328617930412292, 0.0003829030611086637, -0.016128022223711014, 0.005506912246346474, -0.003217999590560794, 0.014126681722700596, -0.05000952258706093, 0.0368378609418869, 0.0737050324678421, 0.03153155744075775, 0.046985674649477005, -0.031603626906871796, -0.008024889975786209, -0.022734329104423523, 0.022731812670826912, -0.024885324761271477, -0.012467874214053154, 0.023344513028860092, -0.028372272849082947, -0.08221559226512909, -0.03401148319244385, 0.06053457409143448, -0.03721841052174568, 0.016350075602531433, 0.029569171369075775, 0.08401663601398468, -0.0211456511169672, -0.01187510322779417, -0.00892364326864481, -0.02616305649280548, -0.027864156290888786, 0.04135124757885933, 0.0036746198311448097, -0.028521878644824028, 0.003991351928561926, -0.008095783181488514, 0.0008288371609523892, -0.01625622808933258, -0.03420022502541542, 0.006225056480616331, -0.07934049516916275, 0.04411144182085991, 0.0008888345910236239, -0.03450863063335419, -0.04502809792757034, -0.029747340828180313, -0.052273452281951904, 0.012342123314738274, 0.01012797374278307, -0.006171667017042637, -0.004739993251860142, -0.009792249649763107, -0.01471501961350441, 0.03751891106367111, 0.02691483311355114, 0.07258016616106033, 0.030886095017194748, 0.04590795189142227, 0.08023545145988464, -0.021194318309426308, -0.005949131213128567, 0.059292618185281754, -0.08676182478666306, 0.07975300401449203, -0.020180759951472282, 0.016138603910803795, 0.03619896247982979, 0.035936709493398666, 0.05211230367422104, -0.029004061594605446, 0.03239208832383156, 0.04652513936161995, 0.03847016394138336, -0.014241683296859264, -0.020901713520288467, 0.0197532270103693, -0.019698714837431908, -0.026595134288072586 ]
<p>The structural form of the linear simultaneous equations model <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simultaneous_equations_model" rel="nofollow">simultaneous equations model</a> can be written as</p> <p>$ \mathbf{y}_{i}^{\prime}\Gamma+\mathbf{x}_{i}^{\prime}\mathbf{B}=\epsilon_{i}^{\prime} $</p> <p>which can be written in the reduced form model as</p> <p>$ \mathbf{y}_{i}^{\prime} =-\mathbf{x}_{i}^{\prime}\mathbf{B}\Gamma^{-1}+\epsilon_{i}^{\prime}\Gamma^{-1}\\ =\mathbf{x}_{i}^{\prime}\Pi+\mathbf{v}_{i}^{\prime}. $</p> <p>The reduced form model can be estimated with different estimation methods and if the model is identified the structural coefficients $\widehat{\mathbf{B}}$ can be obtained by using the relation $\widehat{\mathbf{B}}=\widehat{\Pi}\widehat{\Gamma}$.</p> <p>I wonder how to drive the variance-covariance matrix of $\widehat{\mathbf{B}}$. I'd highly appreciate if you point out me any reference. Thanks in advance for your help and time.</p>
g1034
[ -0.015742458403110504, -0.03899989649653435, -0.02833845652639866, -0.03945280238986015, 0.07495884597301483, -0.011284922249615192, 0.07506521791219711, 0.02211204171180725, 0.027386249974370003, 0.0003817306424025446, -0.02380554750561714, 0.025979798287153244, -0.025108106434345245, 0.026193078607320786, 0.005520203150808811, -0.021011725068092346, 0.060714300721883774, 0.017695259302854538, 0.003344838973134756, -0.02826327085494995, -0.025449678301811218, 0.021801820024847984, 0.03709862381219864, 0.03311162441968918, -0.018563592806458473, -0.009733433835208416, -0.019188689067959785, 0.04099205508828163, 0.0035742318723350763, 0.012310248799622059, 0.019941192120313644, -0.020688122138381004, 0.06215713918209076, 0.0018508649663999677, 0.027014655992388725, 0.025636451318860054, 0.024017686024308205, 0.04685259610414505, -0.006332261487841606, 0.038376566022634506, -0.02503008395433426, -0.03974681720137596, 0.052622660994529724, 0.006027999799698591, 0.01461232639849186, -0.01839672587811947, -0.01646675355732441, -0.004517164081335068, 0.0017572373617440462, 0.0020928364247083664, 0.03264707699418068, 0.029323771595954895, 0.0664856806397438, -0.024637596681714058, -0.07148532569408417, 0.0014010841259732842, 0.018723497167229652, 0.010012057609856129, -0.017818400636315346, 0.057137325406074524, -0.02756614424288273, -0.023760877549648285, -0.021794039756059647, 0.0108304088935256, 0.05776943266391754, 0.05104474723339081, -0.045268964022397995, -0.038232263177633286, 0.01757836528122425, -0.03960232436656952, -0.03632575273513794, 0.023954682052135468, 0.06593294441699982, -0.05913161486387253, 0.011043651960790157, -0.004801545757800341, 0.034763384610414505, -0.010346615687012672, -0.0048523289151489735, 0.02281372621655464, -0.0059324707835912704, 0.08901521563529968, 0.08551515638828278, 0.026782605797052383, 0.03018595650792122, -0.00996224582195282, 0.050718773156404495, 0.026134224608540535, -0.01893497444689274, -0.0557551309466362, 0.01963018998503685, 0.020907070487737656, 0.042676620185375214, -0.005852183327078819, 0.03586249053478241, 0.0024025412276387215, -0.09043316543102264, 0.026241684332489967, 0.016758859157562256, -0.0116227762773633, 0.0021948502399027348, 0.0782773420214653, 0.004737839102745056, -0.03735799714922905, 0.009581588208675385, 0.024474183097481728, 0.04225446283817291, -0.008837992325425148, -0.016596641391515732, -0.004885969217866659, -0.05987909436225891, -0.03254538029432297, -0.01137945894151926, -0.0033707295078784227, -0.04707992449402809, -0.09043185412883759, -0.000525006209500134, -0.03354199603199959, -0.024724610149860382, -0.008782233111560345, -0.033096399158239365, -0.022961752489209175, 0.014914372935891151, 0.0663314014673233, -0.04704514890909195, -0.02673373371362686, 0.007540040649473667, 0.08774567395448685, 0.045953597873449326, -0.02700888365507126, 0.07199325412511826, 0.004610895644873381, 0.04242433235049248, 0.0637839064002037, 0.01851833239197731, -0.027559887617826462, -0.08609161525964737, 0.07266268134117126, 0.006061103194952011, 0.02602570503950119, -0.07956615090370178, 0.010565732605755329, 0.03146142140030861, -0.05426295846700668, 0.03126206994056702, -0.03223945572972298, 0.0013731600483879447, -0.05662265419960022, -0.041343312710523605, -0.006066704634577036, 0.022198554128408432, 0.04296442121267319, -0.00626245466992259, 0.0541229248046875, 0.005916666239500046, -0.04767204076051712, 0.0038740457966923714, -0.04095267131924629, -0.0327073410153389, -0.032510410994291306, 0.008781460113823414, -0.04175552725791931, 0.05752764642238617, -0.0074731470085680485, 0.0033055725507438183, -0.0023045006673783064, -0.01891608163714409, -0.0764186903834343, -0.024676557630300522, -0.02754664234817028, 0.01340455375611782, -0.07487381994724274, -0.007714870385825634, -0.033422958105802536, 0.0890774056315422, 0.013443412259221077, 0.02042221836745739, -0.023101910948753357, 0.006019304506480694, 0.07535935193300247, 0.012294960208237171, 0.030534248799085617, 0.04099312424659729, -0.012667587958276272, -0.00591176887974143, -0.010091571137309074, -0.05152769014239311, 0.0859929695725441, -0.012481609359383583, 0.0021516161505132914, 0.026525169610977173, -0.02080392837524414, 0.018059002235531807, -0.025264017283916473, 0.00007881625788286328, 0.025266282260417938, 0.030687322840094566, 0.005549839232116938, -0.02910328283905983, 0.069877989590168, -0.04959406703710556, 0.027529962360858917, 0.0863010361790657, -0.002677334239706397, -0.02464759349822998, -0.01092614233493805, -0.004156316630542278, 0.0024775511119514704, 0.023964451625943184, -0.021474137902259827, -0.04943230375647545, -0.06700413674116135, -0.035917844623327255, -0.014460902661085129, -0.004544252995401621, 0.010233546607196331, 0.06151479855179787, 0.006320605054497719, -0.06073462590575218, 0.027709605172276497, -0.04691874608397484, -0.04774291068315506, -0.0120534123852849, 0.038961973041296005, -0.039140742272138596, 0.00011897611693711951, 0.05407939478754997, 0.011417003348469734, 0.035409167408943176, 0.025403037667274475, -0.04075939580798149, 0.04861393943428993, -0.020689068362116814, 0.0035815942101180553, 0.054705485701560974, 0.02144203521311283, 0.024517374113202095, 0.03154854103922844, -0.040462758392095566, 0.014288445003330708, 0.0030101793818175793, 0.02844243496656418, -0.005755504127591848, 0.07395707815885544, 0.022009804844856262, -0.0016636536456644535, 0.0379679910838604, 0.008717946708202362, 0.00988288875669241, 0.018924390897154808, -0.05283615365624428, -0.00831530150026083, -0.037617314606904984, -0.05818787217140198, -0.00746338302269578, -0.0619538351893425, 0.004989693406969309, 0.05837833136320114, 0.020335208624601364, -0.0062514482997357845, 0.008688301779329777, 0.038523685187101364, -0.051668714731931686, 0.029288260266184807, 0.024447685107588768, -0.016006190329790115, 0.02326083742082119, -0.027879830449819565, 0.002205577678978443, -0.0035754491109400988, 0.008032760582864285, 0.04823020473122597, 0.021223707124590874, 0.010841647163033485, -0.014642134308815002, -0.015598847530782223, -0.03839569538831711, -0.0027704285457730293, -0.003259807825088501, 0.017821943387389183, 0.001647594734095037, -0.027136577293276787, -0.02812090702354908, -0.02393418923020363, 0.05061715096235275, -0.007252343464642763, 0.003529808484017849, 0.010760465636849403, 0.02574886754155159, 0.04206868261098862, -0.08496175706386566, 0.037736713886260986, 0.011067272163927555, -0.017547868192195892, -0.04954678565263748, 0.020505858585238457, 0.04276645556092262, -0.12171221524477005, -0.00698130065575242, 0.01422625407576561, -0.045824695378541946, -0.004637453239411116, 0.006972300820052624, 0.028474509716033936, 0.0016347678611055017, -0.0023190511856228113, -0.005181015934795141, 0.07061895728111267, -0.04051338508725166, -0.002415301511064172, -0.02486535534262657, -0.01787894032895565, 0.03653557971119881, -0.034119635820388794, -0.00027356180362403393, -0.05888398364186287, 0.0073870341293513775, -0.009150507859885693, 0.005136200692504644, -0.0016572412569075823, -0.021100059151649475, -0.062406275421381, 0.015194011852145195, 0.03859904408454895, -0.018691986799240112, 0.030198220163583755, -0.06892573088407516, 0.044167425483465195, -0.02867688611149788, -0.002025829628109932, 0.06460508704185486, -0.02186458557844162, 0.0782608836889267, -0.005573616363108158, -0.03414153307676315, 0.01859697513282299, -0.060029592365026474, -0.03098510392010212, 0.03445833921432495, -0.04686804488301277, -0.042371757328510284, -0.04018985107541084, -0.0510297566652298, 0.04280031472444534, -0.06673132628202438, -0.04847150295972824, -0.045286379754543304, 0.024187104776501656, 0.03293773531913757, -0.03286945819854736, -0.0007626755977980793, -0.035090312361717224, 0.004304836969822645, -0.02464619092643261, 0.06454842537641525, 0.0060793496668338776, 0.01140541024506092, 0.03277361020445824, -0.007941343821585178, 0.009461536072194576, -0.0011841852683573961, -0.05155404284596443, -0.003746158443391323, 0.045688580721616745, -0.00597979873418808, 0.03568495064973831, 0.009461654350161552, 0.027369126677513123, -0.011413568630814552, 0.016669034957885742, -0.023661108687520027, 0.02031540870666504, 0.005047819577157497, -0.002945846179500222, -0.06146477535367012, -0.023258117958903313, -0.009009800851345062, -0.04989411681890488, -0.017011577263474464, 0.053850408643484116, 0.04860793799161911, -0.010890722274780273, 0.015937402844429016, 0.0474184975028038, 0.030879467725753784, -0.003129482502117753, -0.021882053464651108, -0.002310702111572027, 0.031910140067338943, -0.008216625079512596, 0.023434363305568695, -0.04003852978348732, -0.029909152537584305, 0.050324298441410065, -0.004896399565041065, -0.004686016123741865, -0.021939510479569435, 0.00967237539589405, -0.049216799437999725, 0.013376936316490173, -0.031335946172475815, 0.015512244775891304, 0.045772261917591095, 0.039194874465465546, -0.037166133522987366, 0.04942815378308296, -0.05240675434470177, 0.01381577830761671, -0.021212385967373848, 0.0064740171656012535, -0.04856665059924126, -0.02743898332118988, -0.0075018638744950294, -0.013364043086767197, 0.06977162510156631, 0.009668359532952309, 0.05012064054608345, -0.04730672016739845, 0.0007062628865242004, 0.03473363071680069, 0.05692046880722046, 0.05402315407991409, -0.014193668961524963, -0.02866949699819088, 0.05654732137918472, 0.004902041517198086, -0.002965521067380905, 0.026759512722492218, -0.00929989106953144, -0.034979645162820816, 0.015838146209716797, 0.006340642459690571, -0.015204853378236294, 0.07291048020124435, -0.05738671496510506, 0.018000217154622078, -0.04799763858318329, 0.046722233295440674, -0.007005309220403433, -0.03530735522508621, -0.031508903950452805, -0.01621490716934204, 0.021808132529258728, -0.03162163868546486, 0.01977551355957985, 0.004171293694525957, 0.00006130825931904837, -0.023364976048469543, 0.009184501133859158, -0.06642640382051468, -0.00419921800494194, 0.01376485824584961, 0.020788226276636124, 0.027006851509213448, 0.005882020108401775, -0.006623351946473122, -0.0003793805663008243, 0.04855585843324661, 0.05708417296409607, 0.05379730463027954, -0.014121920801699162, -0.08326701819896698, 0.00005313073779689148, -0.019270943477749825, 0.023786406964063644, -0.005342515185475349, -0.05097437649965286, 0.04069815203547478, -0.029815657064318657, -0.02875722013413906, 0.0050556594505906105, -0.004629354923963547, 0.052772343158721924, -0.0053340778686106205, 0.0094024408608675, 0.005814549047499895, -0.027827398851513863, -0.031012557446956635, 0.0027989267837256193, 0.018490370362997055, -0.035916831344366074, 0.005987241398543119, 0.007465857081115246, -0.027978891506791115, 0.03705080598592758, 0.02541513182222843, 0.002134680515155196, -0.06304951757192612, -0.010775454342365265, -0.006533837411552668, -0.004147897008806467, 0.07483915239572525, -0.024602597579360008, -0.0068443273194134235, 0.004065302666276693, -0.006790434010326862, -0.008707175962626934, -0.022202402353286743, 0.07119550555944443, 0.07182690501213074, -0.06355667859315872, -0.01947816275060177, 0.01878093183040619, -0.04842346906661987, 0.046760521829128265, -0.017204251140356064, 0.03436313942074776, 0.024525552988052368, 0.013094420544803143, 0.013094285503029823, 0.00576490955427289, 0.014286414720118046, 0.005025774706155062, -0.007216132245957851, -0.04830526188015938, -0.01725904643535614, -0.04011218249797821, 0.0019458747701719403, 0.018971404060721397, -0.06274937093257904, 0.032028067857027054, -0.08096375316381454, 0.017730973660945892, -0.012532844208180904, -0.03024153970181942, -0.009515074081718922, -0.04428377002477646, -0.017646394670009613, 0.005233274307101965, -0.042446933686733246, -0.06606662273406982, 0.005817679688334465, -0.062205780297517776, -0.06252413988113403, 0.02698484994471073, 0.004171823151409626, 0.017109079286456108, 0.008741320110857487, -0.03318622708320618, -0.005720851477235556, -0.050360579043626785, -0.007897780276834965, 0.06528164446353912, 0.02418208122253418, -0.011166765354573727, -0.02129645273089409, 0.031723763793706894, 0.014309112913906574, 0.016497494652867317, -0.010297357104718685, 0.03013399988412857, -0.04806694760918617, 0.023601191118359566, 0.06293361634016037, 0.02843743935227394, 0.00045515428064391017, -0.014158006757497787, -0.017054423689842224, -0.028601879253983498, 0.01968763768672943, -0.03573557361960411, -0.0026005622930824757, 0.0041577466763556, 0.026362141594290733, -0.021578937768936157, -0.03781206160783768, 0.06974770128726959, 0.004875595681369305, -0.009444027207791805, 0.05049724131822586, 0.013754370622336864, -0.036226317286491394, -0.028615402057766914, 0.02726113423705101, -0.012201224453747272, 0.038937877863645554, 0.006782041862607002, -0.03400738909840584, -0.04614211246371269, 0.0063306596130132675, 0.0008264729985967278, 0.017496898770332336, -0.005683267489075661, 0.0022415209095925093, -0.023555660620331764, 0.05530284345149994, -0.025598470121622086, -0.04688924923539162, -0.06273085623979568, 0.062070030719041824, 0.07867163419723511, -0.0036933335941284895, -0.0469173863530159, -0.043323103338479996, -0.0027611006516963243, -0.01741887629032135, 0.015121144242584705, 0.11353128403425217, -0.00023838786000851542, -0.028448686003684998, 0.005329696927219629, -0.007208479568362236, 0.058138567954301834, -0.011671972461044788, 0.08431337028741837, -0.017944583669304848, -0.041218969970941544, -0.0058065373450517654, 0.00403684563934803, 0.012535546906292439, -0.021319514140486717, -0.03935899958014488, 0.00707000819966197, -0.008821573108434677, 0.034920256584882736, -0.005557946395128965, -0.03397143632173538, 0.0517253652215004, -0.04132501408457756, 0.0007352874963544309, 0.02603084035217762, -0.01598951406776905, -0.04269750416278839, -0.009795047342777252, -0.0041258689016103745, 0.05829905718564987, 0.012446749024093151, -0.023607606068253517, 0.017367873340845108, -0.008601633831858635, 0.0038660699501633644, 0.019577879458665848, 0.010397951118648052, 0.04027999937534332, 0.019178584218025208, 0.027282074093818665, -0.029398225247859955, 0.0776650533080101, 0.02097496949136257, 0.045331474393606186, 0.037227850407361984, 0.06879626959562302, 0.04862591251730919, 0.04583568871021271, -0.03221098706126213, 0.0016220507677644491, -0.012667140923440456, -0.03180686756968498, -0.023431852459907532, -0.03412254527211189, 0.03118101879954338, 0.02948560006916523, -0.02718391641974449, 0.02277514897286892, -0.014999047853052616, 0.03612062707543373, 0.06268731504678726, -0.009947790764272213, 0.0376923605799675, 0.02419334650039673, -0.03069894015789032, -0.010166018269956112, -0.011962282471358776, -0.04426124319434166, -0.020495902746915817, 0.021958449855446815, 0.01282590813934803, -0.06098500266671181, 0.06239153817296028, 0.02595716156065464, -0.08442994207143784, -0.043667420744895935, -0.004674301482737064, -0.04969162493944168, 0.040491580963134766, -0.02071949653327465, -0.01060232799500227, 0.007480319123715162, -0.046333182603120804, -0.009109447710216045, -0.026842929422855377, 0.06516649574041367, -0.029659315943717957, -0.0009998551104217768, -0.003030674299225211, 0.006261153146624565, 0.029920954257249832, 0.027274668216705322, -0.018933963030576706, -0.007801664061844349, -0.10602591186761856, -0.00971781276166439, -0.019235024228692055, -0.014394370838999748, -0.007339231204241514, 0.016306938603520393, -0.0009002292063087225, 0.014966536313295364, -0.02326224558055401, 0.08579929172992706, 0.0549897737801075, -0.04901637136936188, -0.04982755333185196, -0.044300466775894165, -0.012357943691313267, -0.04504997655749321, -0.047603506594896317, -0.043187011033296585, 0.01531321182847023, -0.06711103022098541, -0.07246284186840057, -0.0010804006597027183, -0.026288224384188652, 0.018836701288819313, 0.1271485835313797, -0.013515076600015163, -0.06585810333490372, 0.025937329977750778, -0.05439946800470352, -0.017910292372107506, -0.026278022676706314, -0.05630252882838249, 0.021434878930449486, -0.06045391038060188, 0.034794025123119354, -0.059660088270902634, 0.006071228068321943, 0.04224048927426338, -0.0056624701246619225, 0.07481230050325394, -0.021481141448020935, -0.01981857232749462, -0.013313022442162037, 0.03303736075758934, -0.011004941537976265, -0.006455468479543924, 0.005407410208135843, 0.006598209030926228, -0.010291229002177715, 0.009091801010072231, -0.038619887083768845, -0.078237384557724, -0.007308742962777615, 0.020111702382564545, 0.003589675761759281, 0.016126861795783043, -0.035269711166620255, -0.020380744710564613, -0.010602138936519623, -0.004120880272239447, -0.004568044096231461, 0.018173739314079285, -0.029343130066990852, 0.054616816341876984, 0.04836994782090187, 0.03394700959324837, -0.022426949813961983, 0.044891297817230225, -0.021040476858615875, -0.01646341010928154, -0.044199138879776, -0.03486425429582596, -0.018961653113365173, 0.06936129927635193, -0.02361270785331726, -0.04666437581181526, 0.007219778839498758, 0.050230517983436584 ]
<p>I know there are methods to calculate a confidence interval for a proportion to keep the limits within (0, 1), however a quick Google search lead me only to the standard calculation: $\hat{p} \pm 1.96*\sqrt\frac{\hat{p}(1-\hat{p})}{N}$. I also believe there is a way to calculate the exact confidence interval using the binomial distribution (example R code would be nice). I know I can use the prop.test function to get the interval but I'm interested in working through the calculation.</p> <p>Sample situations (N = number of trials, x = number of success):</p> <pre><code>N=40, x=40 N=40, x=39 N=20, x=0 N=20, x=1 </code></pre>
g39847
[ 0.004858789034187794, 0.005009845830500126, -0.005736541468650103, 0.014947873540222645, -0.024426836520433426, 0.02627791278064251, -0.0019249782199040055, 0.009471570141613483, -0.05344115570187569, -0.025013066828250885, 0.00641233054921031, 0.049703553318977356, 0.005369808059185743, -0.04975278303027153, 0.0051736910827457905, 0.037580456584692, 0.022752387449145317, 0.0008558807894587517, 0.0142364501953125, 0.03645874559879303, -0.03344494104385376, -0.028484245762228966, 0.0020660455338656902, -0.04840004816651344, -0.01873374916613102, -0.014634132385253906, -0.043845731765031815, 0.05924990400671959, -0.0861290693283081, -0.025384914129972458, -0.025428136810660362, 0.016054900363087654, 0.01915080100297928, -0.004724483471363783, 0.001410655677318573, -0.006147722247987986, 0.027537234127521515, -0.015231359750032425, 0.025209886953234673, 0.025496724992990494, -0.0788319930434227, 0.015128265134990215, -0.008352115750312805, 0.016754912212491035, -0.05790785327553749, -0.03421838954091072, -0.07998653501272202, 0.04538784548640251, 0.008775439113378525, -0.03896857798099518, 0.04191254451870918, 0.019221745431423187, 0.041970521211624146, 0.017575597390532494, -0.007830898277461529, 0.06660369783639908, -0.02365177869796753, -0.032893501222133636, 0.003949655685573816, 0.01250586286187172, 0.020854253321886063, -0.034198012202978134, -0.03550233319401741, 0.00784736406058073, 0.02809726446866989, 0.04285425320267677, -0.010646487586200237, 0.012930959463119507, 0.0029477723874151707, 0.014428053051233292, -0.01008592639118433, 0.049658019095659256, 0.004593852441757917, -0.02245277166366577, -0.07954424619674683, -0.0418890155851841, -0.018574172630906105, 0.05218012258410454, 0.01644785702228546, 0.04277058318257332, 0.012863369658589363, -0.033900827169418335, -0.00427477341145277, -0.007181015331298113, -0.058210358023643494, 0.01846882328391075, 0.020570755004882812, -0.06440647691488266, -0.012619021348655224, 0.027166640385985374, 0.027550209313631058, -0.005168143659830093, -0.016204535961151123, 0.06118806079030037, 0.028482479974627495, -0.0015751286409795284, -0.024165693670511246, 0.04582475498318672, -0.029136348515748978, -0.017583109438419342, 0.04014298692345619, 0.015338378958404064, 0.008833503350615501, -0.04485976696014404, -0.06896515935659409, 0.05268935486674309, 0.02837209589779377, 0.020367424935102463, 0.02432887628674507, -0.010870839469134808, 0.022337937727570534, -0.024477507919073105, -0.06024757772684097, -0.05829625204205513, -0.02502983622252941, 0.010587281547486782, 0.07461368292570114, -0.0333811454474926, 0.01307012140750885, -0.0308747049421072, 0.01497471984475851, 0.043338142335414886, 0.028160490095615387, 0.052436698228120804, -0.030463755130767822, 0.0009314288618043065, -0.10227203369140625, 0.05115647241473198, 0.0022150175645947456, 0.00038821453927084804, 0.03020775131881237, -0.0426996685564518, -0.025310885161161423, -0.06008119508624077, -0.04094863310456276, 0.04067206010222435, 0.033628933131694794, 0.038535453379154205, -0.017765849828720093, -0.014184124767780304, -0.0757964700460434, -0.000404135265853256, 0.018113521859049797, -0.02362591214478016, 0.053425632417201996, 0.05663752928376198, -0.007251404225826263, 0.01951778121292591, -0.04070545732975006, 0.005653531290590763, -0.022005043923854828, 0.08313515782356262, 0.031309377402067184, -0.014941238798201084, -0.03182782977819443, -0.019611291587352753, 0.005895236972719431, 0.017327887937426567, -0.05230167508125305, 0.07338940352201462, 0.051368147134780884, 0.012193341739475727, -0.033415086567401886, -0.027463428676128387, -0.04440134018659592, 0.037813715636730194, -0.0018068626523017883, 0.005952456500381231, -0.0395219549536705, -0.07162284106016159, 0.05162303149700165, -0.02421962469816208, -0.02301884815096855, -0.023587072268128395, 0.027581993490457535, 0.013705527409911156, 0.02014242112636566, -0.004931112751364708, 0.01007140427827835, 0.05244838073849678, 0.04859700798988342, -0.004692808724939823, -0.006059334613382816, -0.008872805163264275, -0.026810046285390854, -0.024399468675255775, 0.09740403294563293, 0.02998817153275013, -0.017034761607646942, -0.046113576740026474, -0.017196085304021835, -0.045988570898771286, 0.00818285159766674, -0.00047114124754443765, -0.0071923318319022655, 0.0048594227991998196, 0.0760871097445488, -0.06337609887123108, 0.04372355714440346, 0.018749728798866272, 0.0023316217120736837, 0.028935769572854042, 0.048726651817560196, 0.033417318016290665, 0.035478249192237854, 0.007297550793737173, 0.009016681462526321, -0.06747371703386307, 0.012205887585878372, 0.07205718755722046, -0.007877139374613762, -0.050293050706386566, 0.02301395684480667, 0.02578531578183174, 0.03167342022061348, -0.013525750488042831, 0.015721507370471954, -0.013796797953546047, 0.03221960365772247, -0.0005143089219927788, -0.00014492562331724912, 0.00024489001953043044, -0.028287559747695923, -0.04995855689048767, 0.010072465986013412, 0.04892725497484207, 0.033568669110536575, 0.04168194532394409, -0.012855904176831245, 0.06239873543381691, -0.04714876040816307, 0.0012720661470666528, -0.0235555749386549, -0.02416199818253517, 0.008093335665762424, 0.018283851444721222, 0.018005643039941788, 0.022990083321928978, -0.016241513192653656, 0.029257291927933693, 0.00312294764444232, 0.029115239158272743, -0.009811023250222206, 0.07641521096229553, -0.020991215482354164, -0.007311643101274967, -0.04276536405086517, -0.0419875830411911, 0.011983467265963554, 0.005766344256699085, 0.005016588605940342, 0.06736436486244202, 0.0612945631146431, -0.0392254963517189, -0.03975632041692734, 0.005159292835742235, -0.01557530090212822, -0.011710918508470058, -0.03292333707213402, -0.07636144757270813, -0.03014414757490158, -0.01501829270273447, 0.02019404247403145, -0.023063654080033302, -0.03146681189537048, -0.03754516690969467, -0.03338867053389549, -0.014991965144872665, 0.016462700441479683, 0.04540210962295532, 0.01648597978055477, 0.018855860456824303, 0.01569165475666523, 0.0678236335515976, 0.004680464044213295, -0.020284125581383705, 0.010617967694997787, -0.021398218348622322, 0.033613331615924835, 0.0018804598366841674, -0.03234062343835831, -0.04145810380578041, 0.0002125799364876002, 0.020808402448892593, 0.0194636732339859, -0.03130953013896942, 0.0548703670501709, 0.00035221801954321563, 0.004647066351026297, -0.006164405960589647, 0.015416954644024372, -0.04292707145214081, -0.018388643860816956, -0.00767187774181366, 0.010393897071480751, -0.06237471103668213, 0.03604917228221893, -0.0004990077577531338, 0.08683492243289948, -0.009787723422050476, -0.009327924810349941, -0.03708236292004585, -0.03318165987730026, -0.0066820248030126095, 0.06200316548347473, 0.015130104497075081, 0.03396765515208244, -0.014918451197445393, 0.05286124348640442, 0.05474799871444702, -0.011715232394635677, -0.004178107716143131, 0.006745294202119112, -0.017273521050810814, -0.04682440683245659, -0.0205101128667593, -0.013226094655692577, 0.019799821078777313, -0.005731537472456694, -0.01065168809145689, 0.04467016085982323, -0.0611351802945137, -0.0015271431766450405, 0.02283257618546486, 0.029085781425237656, -0.0424790196120739, -0.0156558770686388, 0.08772096037864685, -0.061066944152116776, -0.026895074173808098, 0.0823129341006279, 0.004624615423381329, 0.06205665320158005, -0.013951650820672512, 0.0077905491925776005, -0.08086355775594711, 0.029802260920405388, -0.026431646198034286, -0.013469369150698185, 0.01888914965093136, -0.010328159667551517, -0.01909451000392437, -0.034734271466732025, -0.0004301692242734134, 0.00761589827015996, -0.04313190281391144, 0.017912641167640686, 0.05208210274577141, 0.05348951742053032, -0.024158425629138947, -0.03552963584661484, -0.048413924872875214, -0.04547794908285141, -0.06680148839950562, 0.05080842599272728, 0.05785162001848221, 0.0278159286826849, -0.003333618398755789, 0.011260020546615124, 0.0018863866571336985, 0.08948129415512085, -0.0673445463180542, 0.02844139374792576, 0.022545257583260536, 0.024782245978713036, -0.06069773808121681, 0.03545154258608818, 0.050367485731840134, -0.011172640137374401, 0.02706182561814785, -0.027980387210845947, 0.016955528408288956, 0.05670452490448952, 0.01658468507230282, -0.014226401224732399, -0.010710913687944412, 0.002226798562332988, 0.026523929089307785, -0.020017266273498535, 0.0368197001516819, -0.011123127304017544, -0.010521573945879936, -0.055367179214954376, -0.05128534138202667, -0.04922224208712578, -0.027012592181563377, -0.011939900927245617, -0.010860610753297806, 0.06758105754852295, -0.05224154144525528, 0.0010258996626362205, -0.0745067298412323, -0.02899383381009102, 0.03614373877644539, -0.010124226100742817, -0.04287121072411537, -0.0037789102643728256, -0.00006298730295384303, -0.014896513894200325, 0.043585777282714844, 0.008900042623281479, 0.005677933804690838, 0.009060417301952839, 0.004394556395709515, 0.010260284878313541, 0.02671113796532154, -0.011546905152499676, 0.033427368849515915, 0.015249214135110378, -0.007445298135280609, 0.0173737071454525, -0.01213676854968071, 0.03486206382513046, -0.030584098771214485, 0.05275559797883034, -0.027620971202850342, 0.027122214436531067, -0.013347283937036991, -0.01355556771159172, -0.009336383081972599, -0.009202557615935802, -0.0360955148935318, -0.04627722129225731, 0.008603422902524471, 0.014986834488809109, -0.018795659765601158, 0.0007391971303150058, -0.020955035462975502, 0.031850479543209076, -0.049235958606004715, -0.009446305222809315, 0.033654775470495224, -0.00626757089048624, 0.04193068668246269, -0.07934719324111938, 0.031099705025553703, -0.04615683853626251, -0.006095140241086483, -0.020116308704018593, 0.014428737573325634, -0.0026232951786369085, 0.01974117010831833, -0.011886347085237503, -0.03178135305643082, -0.008281844668090343, 0.07470419257879257, -0.02161109261214733, -0.03472200781106949, -0.00821286253631115, 0.04445267096161842, -0.02375205047428608, -0.0009400180424563587, 0.014094320125877857, -0.03995169699192047, 0.03756777197122574, -0.03389021009206772, -0.03254024311900139, 0.023541277274489403, 0.1190575435757637, 0.01422891765832901, -0.03340165317058563, -0.03928501158952713, -0.06746967136859894, -0.03598280996084213, 0.012782653793692589, 0.03634306788444519, 0.0003801568236667663, -0.02374468371272087, 0.028747426345944405, 0.0026216667611151934, -0.014083010144531727, -0.04481898620724678, 0.068578340113163, -0.02753289043903351, 0.04379471763968468, 0.005312033463269472, -0.00915899220854044, 0.04838968813419342, 0.011700229719281197, 0.05045964568853378, -0.036802247166633606, 0.02478385530412197, -0.025796152651309967, 0.04777109622955322, 0.029009997844696045, -0.02195504494011402, -0.015580990351736546, -0.10032865405082703, 0.08052453398704529, -0.024112394079566002, 0.013181805610656738, 0.036938589066267014, 0.02825559675693512, 0.019632186740636826, 0.07809478044509888, -0.060963716357946396, 0.05438971519470215, -0.020334647968411446, -0.010317782871425152, 0.024112937971949577, 0.009952112101018429, 0.01478399708867073, -0.034417774528265, -0.018531514331698418, -0.005359064321964979, 0.0016103156376630068, 0.07343810796737671, -0.024130912497639656, -0.049110058695077896, 0.008431806229054928, 0.01957227662205696, 0.0525972917675972, -0.01993251033127308, 0.04792125150561333, -0.002821301342919469, -0.012693192809820175, 0.004764013923704624, 0.028863510116934776, -0.10783862322568893, -0.01288370881229639, 0.07363760471343994, -0.008543548174202442, 0.003298356896266341, -0.02347346395254135, 0.05529079958796501, -0.03348833695054054, -0.06113919988274574, -0.030111683532595634, 0.012090514414012432, -0.02579953335225582, 0.025463253259658813, -0.0018140641041100025, -0.03691142052412033, -0.012268200516700745, -0.06393677741289139, -0.01454389002174139, -0.06719695031642914, -0.02296278066933155, 0.06856115907430649, -0.05717598646879196, -0.043839458376169205, 0.06398740410804749, 0.015345510095357895, 0.010558636859059334, 0.021250203251838684, 0.011224505491554737, -0.04377064108848572, -0.028782103210687637, -0.0211810190230608, -0.015603997744619846, 0.07300808280706406, 0.024287141859531403, -0.029709240421652794, -0.052087534219026566, -0.02932353876531124, 0.07686889171600342, 0.015500877983868122, 0.034037522971630096, 0.033560432493686676, 0.023790324106812477, 0.014132806099951267, -0.017322899773716927, -0.03969390690326691, 0.013932895846664906, -0.07917744666337967, 0.011128171347081661, -0.024451028555631638, -0.0065421718172729015, -0.02236139215528965, 0.012665431946516037, 0.023731237277388573, -0.056441277265548706, 0.054229240864515305, 0.02517741732299328, -0.00020295866124797612, -0.012016555294394493, -0.0031261153053492308, -0.02400154434144497, 0.05206551402807236, -0.07582652568817139, -0.020381996408104897, -0.02962241880595684, 0.008768599480390549, -0.0337589867413044, -0.027032185345888138, 0.03220062330365181, -0.010599426925182343, 0.02340617962181568, -0.02766331657767296, 0.010970557108521461, -0.01734531857073307, -0.017459075897932053, 0.033903636038303375, -0.022992653772234917, 0.04691031947731972, -0.01728683151304722, 0.01896749809384346, -0.033961303532123566, -0.014785579405725002, 0.023548515513539314, -0.03153785690665245, -0.004957274999469519, -0.01372943352907896, -0.005092239938676357, -0.033983998000621796, -0.03898878023028374, -0.025269068777561188, 0.03757334128022194, -0.024097880348563194, -0.00608418881893158, 0.020242158323526382, 0.012648491188883781, 0.01619679667055607, 0.03140459582209587, 0.02667834609746933, -0.013487137854099274, -0.0185020063072443, 0.02384147234261036, -0.04524356871843338, 0.001970351208001375, 0.033154480159282684, -0.0021130628883838654, -0.05172261968255043, -0.021260244771838188, 0.04605613276362419, 0.01804434508085251, 0.06357727944850922, 0.006511435378342867, 0.04524678736925125, -0.012062602676451206, 0.05810654163360596, -0.03074670396745205, -0.01965017430484295, 0.04261375963687897, -0.017558369785547256, 0.11746586859226227, -0.011978423222899437, -0.03787856549024582, 0.02164313942193985, 0.05629018321633339, -0.017148630693554878, 0.004674780182540417, 0.03631395101547241, 0.016102144494652748, 0.0029937061481177807, 0.007031392306089401, 0.032317161560058594, 0.03731389343738556, -0.05519469827413559, 0.030811026692390442, 0.030980989336967468, 0.008827438578009605, -0.04219096899032593, -0.007310277316719294, 0.008297824300825596, 0.024150900542736053, 0.010058320127427578, -0.0025157828349620104, 0.036835212260484695, -0.10182038694620132, 0.047663748264312744, -0.04233454167842865, 0.031610094010829926, -0.01650853268802166, 0.0073404149152338505, 0.021447451785206795, -0.015197984874248505, -0.007480311673134565, 0.008179162628948689, -0.09886820614337921, 0.06324195861816406, 0.026804959401488304, -0.04042917490005493, 0.008482336066663265, 0.003041404765099287, -0.006884878035634756, 0.00943273026496172, 0.0701603889465332, -0.03633637726306915, -0.011257424019277096, -0.08653493970632553, -0.03618936985731125, -0.02940007671713829, -0.038639627397060394, 0.011449526995420456, 0.004064267035573721, -0.002509618178009987, -0.030460834503173828, 0.02861252799630165, 0.03578959405422211, -0.05749351531267166, -0.04568818584084511, 0.010751021094620228, 0.045426975935697556, 0.0029120328836143017, -0.03427809104323387, 0.015518666245043278, -0.06854573637247086, 0.01104238722473383, 0.05111519247293472, 0.0513664074242115, 0.012748980894684792, 0.03806533291935921, -0.012038573622703552, -0.007832853123545647, -0.006351169664412737, -0.06809519231319427, -0.01702817529439926, -0.0016360585577785969, -0.03624015673995018, 0.09357711672782898, 0.04165683686733246, -0.03148418292403221, -0.05914422124624252, -0.015211068093776703, -0.007355908863246441, -0.047662075608968735, -0.03634090721607208, -0.015931157395243645, -0.07649265229701996, 0.004686354659497738, -0.06220617890357971, 0.01650334522128105, -0.02936522848904133, -0.05119473487138748, -0.01780637539923191, -0.06593378633260727, -0.010272995568811893, 0.00014783044753130525, -0.06581519544124603, 0.013960574753582478, -0.032560236752033234, -0.07665219157934189, 0.01921941712498665, 0.05832533910870552, -0.005864368285983801, 0.030113566666841507, 0.004160773474723101, 0.01764773763716221, 0.04120806232094765, 0.00299072265625, -0.01969839073717594, 0.052438508719205856, -0.02740315906703472, -0.0038723221514374018, 0.03805917501449585, 0.0015729706501588225, 0.04988152161240578, 0.018659690394997597, -0.001610634964890778, -0.04299559071660042, 0.025907572358846664, 0.031129296869039536, 0.06326638162136078, 0.05273759365081787, -0.009486754424870014, -0.001991443568840623, 0.019489070400595665, 0.03827599063515663, 0.017105884850025177, 0.013036543503403664, -0.0004435425216797739, -0.021954147145152092, 0.019686313346028328, 0.009001647122204304, -0.017156772315502167, 0.018338164314627647, 0.005388001445680857 ]
<p>Okay I have given this a go but I think it is totally wrong. Can someone please make this correct for me ? To understand the MA(q) model I really need to plug some numbers into it as I', finding these time series formula epically confusing as it is never explained what any of it actually is in the real world.</p> <pre><code> Model : y = c + u + .5 et-1 + .25 et-2 + .125 et -3 Ya t Yf t mean U e t Actual Y at time t Forecast Y at time t 1.69% error at time t (et 0 is made up) y = c + u + .5 et-1 + .25 et-2 + .125 et -3 Yf t - Mean u 0 1.69% 0.03 1 0.63% 1.69% -1.06% 2 1.13% 1.69% -0.56% 3 1.36% 1.69% -0.33% 4 0.97% 1.69% -0.72% 5 1.11% 1.69% -0.58% 6 0.88% 1.69% -0.81% 7 0.90% 1.69% -0.79% 8 1.06% 1.69% -0.63% 9 1.38% 1.69% -0.31% 10 0.96% 1.69% -0.73% 11 1.29% 1.69% -0.40% 12 1.39% 1.69% -0.30% 13 0.98% 1.69% -0.71% 14 1.42% 1.69% -0.27% 15 1.21% 1.69% -0.48% 16 1.04% 1.69% -0.65% 17 1.45% 1.69% -0.24% 18 1.11% 1.69% -0.58% 19 1.92% 1.69% 0.23% 20 1.89% 1.69% 0.20% 21 2.00% 1.69% 0.31% 22 1.40% 1.69% -0.29% 23 2.15% 1.69% 0.46% 24 2.11% 1.69% 0.42% 25 1.76% 1.69% 0.07% 26 2.55% 1.69% 0.86% 27 1.80% 1.69% 0.11% 28 2.23% 1.69% 0.54% 29 2.39% 1.69% 0.71% 30 1.55% 1.69% -0.14% 31 2.67% 1.69% 0.99% 32 2.50% 1.69% 0.81% 33 1.88% 1.69% 0.20% 34 2.18% 1.69% 0.49% 35 2.42% 1.69% 0.73% 36 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% 37 2.54% 1.69% 0.85% 38 2.03% 1.69% 0.34% 39 2.08% 1.69% 0.39% 40 2.58% 1.69% 0.89% 41 1.71% 1.69% 0.02% 42 1.56% 1.69% -0.13% 43 1.98% 1.69% 0.29% 44 1.85% 1.69% 0.16% 45 1.66% 1.69% -0.03% 46 2.19% 1.69% 0.50% 47 1.52% 1.69% -0.17% 48 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% 49 1.92% 1.69% 0.23% </code></pre> <p>FORECAST 50 1.80% 1.69% 0.11% FORECAST 51 1.81% 1.69% 0.12% FORECAST 52 1.81% 1.69% 0.12% FORECAST 53 1.79% 1.69% 0.10% FORECAST 54 1.79% 1.69% 0.10% FORECAST 55 1.78% 1.69% 0.09% FORECAST 56 1.77% 1.69% 0.08% FORECAST 57 1.76% 1.69% 0.07% FORECAST 58 1.76% 1.69% 0.07% FORECAST 59 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% FORECAST 60 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% FORECAST 61 1.74% 1.69% 0.05%</p> <p>I have tried to do this to the step that I am upto before estimating the first error term for t = 0 and parameters of the model but it does not look right. Hope you can follow this it is hard to get the formatting right. It just looks like it ends up being too similar to the mean to be useful. I want something which tries to predict the random patterns seen in the time series, for example you can see when the point goes up, it is very rarely higher in the very next point.</p> <p>The formula for the forecasting is basically to take the mean and multiply it by the last 3 error terms and multiply by the coefficients that I just made up. Thanks. Thanks.</p> <p>As a side note I really find the notations and explanation about this to be very confusing.</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
g31305
[ -0.0391019843518734, -0.013158497400581837, 0.006438216660171747, -0.03877720981836319, 0.018521372228860855, 0.016933366656303406, 0.07186049222946167, 0.0039049822371453047, -0.050107017159461975, 0.03507618606090546, -0.03324893116950989, 0.03824472054839134, 0.09975244104862213, -0.004785813856869936, 0.006434843875467777, 0.004008085932582617, 0.03795873373746872, 0.025677472352981567, 0.006713669281452894, 0.03431854397058487, 0.03295380622148514, 0.023390069603919983, -0.021252475678920746, -0.03247610852122307, -0.044551897794008255, 0.02191748097538948, -0.0009131015976890922, 0.10011128336191177, -0.06658652424812317, 0.03146521374583244, 0.052896469831466675, 0.020178930833935738, 0.015269956551492214, -0.039529044181108475, -0.03435177728533745, -0.01856287568807602, 0.06832583993673325, 0.07248395681381226, 0.0061690532602369785, -0.032332438975572586, 0.03150838240981102, 0.02706100419163704, 0.016993464902043343, 0.038952287286520004, -0.046201493591070175, -0.022949879989027977, 0.005923894699662924, -0.01575198955833912, -0.01270826905965805, -0.010389713570475578, -0.04051882028579712, 0.06470062583684921, 0.042806461453437805, 0.003217937657609582, -0.004727373830974102, 0.06259160488843918, 0.060613978654146194, -0.01782498136162758, 0.01865532249212265, 0.06512201577425003, 0.02981419302523136, -0.03757857158780098, 0.00292268511839211, -0.010454005561769009, 0.00724340183660388, 0.03474816679954529, 0.0008695280994288623, -0.013179152272641659, -0.03473808243870735, -0.0457390658557415, -0.0191960446536541, 0.0019157594069838524, 0.01074434258043766, 0.009881559759378433, -0.03289227932691574, 0.015943186357617378, 0.0039539397694170475, 0.04228499159216881, 0.026962460950016975, 0.046033427119255066, -0.03775595873594284, 0.06718263030052185, -0.00957625824958086, 0.013639216311275959, -0.0013095634058117867, -0.06416220963001251, 0.00008004820847418159, 0.013021890074014664, 0.010198209434747696, -0.018671922385692596, -0.011665393598377705, -0.017392145469784737, 0.025153469294309616, 0.025297774001955986, 0.023447873070836067, -0.01023852452635765, -0.07099508494138718, -0.01494656316936016, 0.002493998035788536, 0.0046131545677781105, 0.01955582946538925, 0.06407288461923599, -0.016849800944328308, -0.024404246360063553, -0.08422922343015671, 0.018728872761130333, 0.07162047922611237, -0.028881842270493507, -0.017475249245762825, -0.027369415387511253, -0.005267218220978975, 0.06391994655132294, -0.020805612206459045, 0.0018281545490026474, -0.045276153832674026, -0.026957860216498375, 0.021190935745835304, -0.0035263129975646734, 0.01898469775915146, -0.01391770038753748, 0.03242895007133484, -0.0204286128282547, 0.007073553279042244, 0.03170950338244438, -0.004063569009304047, -0.03428729251027107, 0.010613136924803257, 0.05720801278948784, 0.02134757861495018, -0.02537059783935547, 0.03546418994665146, 0.019830960780382156, 0.009137588553130627, 0.05256985127925873, 0.016042564064264297, 0.013639631681144238, -0.018343092873692513, 0.008313625119626522, 0.013242101296782494, 0.05387463420629501, -0.05873490869998932, -0.03248504176735878, 0.010160381905734539, -0.11732859164476395, -0.035311270505189896, 0.03029421530663967, -0.004631449934095144, -0.00015037882258184254, 0.040706075727939606, -0.03442072868347168, 0.027715809643268585, 0.08901045471429825, -0.052788060158491135, 0.09334398061037064, -0.030391572043299675, -0.008318949490785599, -0.008398598060011864, 0.0023279893212020397, -0.01998603716492653, 0.006856690160930157, -0.010174518451094627, -0.03761612996459007, 0.008565251715481281, 0.0027682918589562178, -0.047449126839637756, -0.010878439992666245, 0.033340562134981155, -0.04945995286107063, -0.05953403189778328, -0.007754080928862095, 0.020634040236473083, 0.011227142065763474, 0.009341970086097717, -0.06867578625679016, 0.02359001711010933, 0.052338793873786926, 0.07207515090703964, 0.03292699530720711, 0.04229896888136864, 0.01627984270453453, 0.07742439210414886, -0.004940201994031668, 0.05883113294839859, -0.07160013914108276, -0.07033002376556396, -0.07273949682712555, -0.009998164139688015, 0.07461974024772644, -0.028708573430776596, 0.020741520449519157, -0.025913046672940254, 0.007191559299826622, -0.04288041219115257, -0.008179457858204842, -0.006605679169297218, 0.03680885583162308, 0.04415394738316536, -0.06129373610019684, -0.035625308752059937, 0.029231710359454155, -0.001286566024646163, -0.02500327304005623, -0.036224763840436935, 0.006308989133685827, 0.019392728805541992, 0.029868973419070244, 0.0074886661022901535, 0.03887687996029854, -0.01427476853132248, 0.009060384705662727, -0.01532922126352787, -0.05256461724638939, -0.019776934757828712, 0.05564148724079132, -0.006067710928618908, -0.06091136857867241, 0.01566331461071968, 0.020750122144818306, -0.01177243608981371, -0.016961723566055298, -0.07547254115343094, -0.0334632471203804, 0.001482809311710298, 0.037552617490291595, -0.06459624320268631, 0.00992069486528635, 0.048625700175762177, 0.015681205317378044, 0.01648940145969391, 0.00888865441083908, -0.024899978190660477, 0.010428814217448235, -0.034090861678123474, -0.014924434013664722, 0.01828956790268421, 0.00022185097623150796, 0.020613865926861763, 0.015446387231349945, 0.017216365784406662, 0.049130287021398544, 0.00665565999224782, 0.047021862119436264, -0.018703661859035492, -0.02199518494307995, 0.015195174142718315, -0.0365232490003109, 0.0185393113642931, 0.02431735396385193, -0.009000076912343502, 0.08437666296958923, 0.01744847744703293, 0.03579303249716759, -0.04012192413210869, 0.0039986614137887955, 0.04388166218996048, -0.041829150170087814, -0.035170573741197586, 0.03389877825975418, 0.030818777158856392, 0.05407183617353439, -0.00809428934007883, 0.01855863444507122, 0.011499517597258091, 0.0070571498945355415, 0.00372513011097908, 0.0011314268922433257, -0.030074849724769592, -0.0031676171347498894, -0.007415240630507469, -0.008978561498224735, -0.00011569289927138016, -0.00599638232961297, 0.10653278976678848, 0.021402180194854736, -0.022684741765260696, 0.004396183416247368, 0.02579241618514061, -0.033008724451065063, 0.03155692294239998, -0.017797987908124924, 0.0275544673204422, -0.06727762520313263, 0.0767214298248291, 0.049902837723493576, 0.045018550008535385, -0.05819769948720932, 0.02183031663298607, 0.06853298842906952, -0.006963040679693222, -0.004734179936349392, 0.00043200404616072774, 0.029477199539542198, 0.02515004761517048, -0.005977631080895662, -0.027693992480635643, 0.002341595711186528, 0.053595948964357376, -0.048921529203653336, 0.049377791583538055, 0.05219953507184982, -0.017102878540754318, 0.05329291149973869, -0.019726721569895744, 0.006413745228201151, 0.03542245179414749, -0.03194115310907364, 0.04374084994196892, 0.00002554171260271687, 0.004274128004908562, -0.04370805248618126, -0.020654361695051193, -0.030499804764986038, -0.059656523168087006, -0.08580867201089859, -0.011960477568209171, 0.022024251520633698, 0.017727838829159737, 0.004366271663457155, 0.03973943740129471, 0.019110940396785736, -0.006640750914812088, -0.03740806132555008, -0.01420097891241312, 0.03526313602924347, -0.04750748723745346, 0.0037784685846418142, -0.021039720624685287, -0.030281955376267433, -0.07984647899866104, 0.004633587319403887, 0.0262155681848526, -0.011419756338000298, 0.04805069416761398, -0.006298634223639965, -0.01786656491458416, -0.041682060807943344, 0.04111209884285927, -0.024941101670265198, -0.004550376906991005, -0.014537844806909561, -0.03486165776848793, 0.020951664075255394, 0.0329141765832901, 0.039919085800647736, -0.03469303250312805, -0.08486627042293549, -0.02674766443669796, 0.03761107474565506, -0.01317645888775587, -0.001759568229317665, 0.009674392640590668, 0.022653518244624138, -0.026545114815235138, 0.04617166891694069, -0.012804733589291573, 0.026246225461363792, 0.0689733549952507, -0.013052884489297867, 0.05592798441648483, -0.01839246228337288, 0.026096055284142494, -0.015130077488720417, -0.0176168791949749, -0.00454935897141695, -0.009537107311189175, 0.035541243851184845, 0.015900058671832085, 0.061579275876283646, 0.03684964403510094, -0.018146000802516937, 0.003905477700755, 0.022720685228705406, 0.05039886012673378, -0.054448433220386505, 0.0010253970976918936, -0.021725457161664963, 0.0010080058127641678, -0.0072003742679953575, -0.050617340952157974, 0.05734262242913246, 0.05717860162258148, -0.028127063065767288, -0.026042338460683823, 0.01292207557708025, 0.01585419476032257, 0.0017041654791682959, 0.020777959376573563, -0.020352652296423912, -0.013080529868602753, -0.04869399592280388, -0.005051246378570795, -0.0006826778990216553, 0.006123288534581661, 0.0503619909286499, 0.01403124164789915, -0.06993860751390457, 0.04708055406808853, 0.040209271013736725, -0.05953512713313103, 0.029957473278045654, -0.02550421468913555, -0.0602559857070446, 0.04240429773926735, 0.0054066842421889305, -0.027584414929151535, -0.03440398722887039, -0.006554777733981609, -0.030928820371627808, 0.013368126936256886, -0.035409312695264816, -0.03572341054677963, 0.01651492714881897, 0.009627960622310638, -0.023698780685663223, 0.0746946856379509, 0.0173239316791296, 0.0891818180680275, -0.03359445556998253, -0.029994595795869827, 0.03771672770380974, 0.012405281886458397, 0.0581706166267395, -0.008968990296125412, -0.007223346270620823, 0.028147120028734207, 0.02944990061223507, 0.0520276241004467, -0.023707963526248932, 0.009541100822389126, -0.029031023383140564, -0.021769609302282333, 0.01750962808728218, -0.07090844959020615, 0.034905847162008286, -0.04945604130625725, 0.06051903963088989, 0.0027748141437768936, 0.03408714383840561, -0.017355602234601974, -0.04118660092353821, -0.043579891324043274, -0.04693217948079109, -0.027331870049238205, -0.0011890156893059611, -0.015999866649508476, 0.00021879967243876308, -0.036804381757974625, -0.023113515228033066, 0.022242683917284012, 0.0362725704908371, -0.06039935350418091, 0.020702049136161804, -0.006046972703188658, 0.035063471645116806, 0.03379920870065689, -0.0027529154904186726, -0.0007789343944750726, -0.0013755771797150373, -0.009776249527931213, 0.025546494871377945, -0.0547529011964798, -0.028389906510710716, 0.02514973282814026, -0.01931462250649929, -0.015579905360937119, -0.04321576654911041, -0.019824448972940445, -0.03800562769174576, 0.021589234471321106, 0.015720950439572334, -0.012578205205500126, 0.0024820766411721706, 0.011114911176264286, -0.015248168259859085, -0.013986608013510704, 0.03872222825884819, 0.00261968863196671, -0.009194723330438137, 0.05165776610374451, 0.03144478052854538, -0.01971139758825302, -0.0065247295424342155, 0.003594329347833991, 0.045684169977903366, -0.02698437124490738, 0.015744134783744812, 0.05606823042035103, -0.042706556618213654, 0.019199861213564873, -0.005297611001878977, 0.04633030295372009, 0.02684943564236164, 0.07760485261678696, -0.05872360244393349, -0.012426281347870827, 0.009335593320429325, 0.03004102036356926, -0.016824942082166672, -0.012500089593231678, -0.07127948105335236, -0.038926705718040466, 0.047398440539836884, -0.09180060029029846, 0.018751125782728195, 0.026878610253334045, -0.029327137395739555, 0.022899923846125603, 0.0287812277674675, 0.050097621977329254, 0.041193392127752304, 0.0438803993165493, -0.024463560432195663, 0.013054309412837029, -0.008577552624046803, -0.042672764509916306, -0.04338432103395462, 0.01704106293618679, 0.007806969340890646, -0.03248453512787819, -0.022224007174372673, 0.027480483055114746, 0.023524479940533638, 0.01395505666732788, -0.0459560826420784, 0.0049101244658231735, -0.07088886946439743, -0.044826213270425797, -0.05695072188973427, 0.0793517529964447, -0.035422440618276596, -0.007123883813619614, 0.00020777563622687012, -0.01506836898624897, -0.0211937315762043, 0.009898706339299679, 0.051333434879779816, -0.014474404975771904, -0.019979842007160187, 0.050147272646427155, -0.06924208998680115, -0.019279003143310547, 0.01784960739314556, -0.026700349524617195, -0.006562032271176577, 0.0160816740244627, -0.02917296066880226, -0.011832010932266712, 0.02473435550928116, 0.037445105612277985, -0.048480741679668427, 0.04721680283546448, -0.025603672489523888, -0.026195116341114044, -0.028831645846366882, 0.006694861222058535, 0.044861145317554474, -0.03786782920360565, -0.05830308049917221, -0.030120722949504852, -0.0019592856988310814, -0.03661251440644264, 0.02840849943459034, -0.014006477780640125, 0.043370332568883896, -0.04405615106225014, 0.013695434667170048, -0.0019458766328170896, 0.02181237004697323, 0.0017295420402660966, -0.02812808007001877, 0.04903537407517433, -0.031255047768354416, -0.0004601821128744632, 0.026598872616887093, -0.037292782217264175, 0.049082156270742416, 0.042997729033231735, 0.04521741345524788, -0.0333801805973053, -0.003909262362867594, -0.04658317565917969, -0.022319449111819267, -0.041682928800582886, -0.023124605417251587, -0.01139279268682003, 0.042299337685108185, -0.06399387866258621, -0.00833133701235056, -0.03905092924833298, -0.02099408581852913, -0.045227181166410446, 0.049922846257686615, 0.018682874739170074, -0.02179614081978798, -0.01521405391395092, 0.024927178397774696, -0.01417880691587925, -0.011713468469679356, 0.01658155769109726, -0.1001879945397377, -0.050230223685503006, -0.018651721999049187, -0.03382090479135513, -0.0647604689002037, 0.019578518345952034, 0.009857109747827053, -0.005947718396782875, -0.003657419001683593, -0.019909506663680077, 0.03518964722752571, -0.022894706577062607, 0.021725380793213844, 0.034933727234601974, 0.09372368454933167, -0.017824701964855194, -0.04121052846312523, -0.03339698165655136, 0.06727204471826553, -0.022883377969264984, -0.016845110803842545, 0.017861096188426018, -0.030261624604463577, 0.04156971722841263, -0.010831689462065697, 0.0019821524620056152, 0.030534779652953148, -0.003401062684133649, 0.026835482567548752, 0.016210930421948433, -0.04193202033638954, -0.013150603510439396, -0.028770487755537033, -0.028650252148509026, 0.004603414796292782, 0.012743832543492317, 0.034752506762742996, -0.029492229223251343, 0.031181810423731804, 0.0293580312281847, 0.0807022973895073, -0.03481542319059372, 0.038870472460985184, -0.007015141658484936, -0.053560394793748856, -0.03262142091989517, -0.051787275820970535, 0.056881051510572433, -0.016113726422190666, -0.06899979710578918, 0.006756320595741272, 0.020793013274669647, -0.026637660339474678, -0.03476792946457863, 0.011244785971939564, 0.06270939856767654, -0.007596449460834265, 0.00553329661488533, 0.04181135073304176, 0.0727095752954483, -0.03000755049288273, 0.004187592305243015, -0.020488496869802475, 0.0002380082878516987, 0.018765363842248917, 0.050934504717588425, 0.07389674335718155, -0.01204727590084076, -0.05619074031710625, 0.007400724571198225, -0.09805979579687119, -0.003858216805383563, -0.03194610774517059, -0.011662106029689312, 0.009828451089560986, 0.02502647414803505, 0.005414556711912155, -0.008117830380797386, 0.051981739699840546, -0.027616379782557487, -0.017388395965099335, 0.010284624993801117, -0.0039511327631771564, -0.04031818360090256, -0.030360624194145203, 0.017103947699069977, 0.06870335340499878, 0.03339993581175804, 0.011511096730828285, -0.038137633353471756, -0.002349335001781583, -0.0025569205172359943, 0.05323058366775513, 0.002764023607596755, -0.025551270693540573, -0.02302965521812439, 0.06849761307239532, -0.03549659624695778, -0.00972082931548357, -0.010404019616544247, 0.03852915018796921, 0.029100868850946426, 0.0348438024520874, 0.007737081963568926, -0.02476726658642292, 0.013621463440358639, 0.0002716153976507485, 0.0048898253589868546, 0.0032966500148177147, -0.0401579812169075, -0.024575255811214447, -0.017228567972779274, 0.033315256237983704, -0.00047254780656658113, -0.0000019675662770168856, -0.0019649495370686054, -0.04576381668448448, -0.01036415807902813, -0.05089424178004265, -0.07578922063112259, -0.06196453422307968, -0.0655963271856308, -0.012381245382130146, -0.005734573118388653, -0.0069464948028326035, -0.056870728731155396, -0.05305146798491478, -0.02728816494345665, 0.04358410835266113, -0.01799132488667965, -0.017564356327056885, -0.05686983838677406, -0.013447246514260769, -0.0848841443657875, 0.07171841710805893, 0.045039448887109756, 0.01564946398139, 0.008097638376057148, -0.06330237537622452, -0.024010222405195236, 0.011076138354837894, -0.027967413887381554, -0.041077759116888046, 0.045493852347135544, 0.047875020653009415, 0.004718130920082331, 0.004479197785258293, -0.030945466831326485, 0.02001577988266945, 0.009702199138700962, -0.059272848069667816, -0.030348319560289383, 0.024032602086663246, -0.07644437998533249, 0.005020612385123968, 0.02343026176095009, -0.05005757883191109, 0.01366947777569294, 0.02067720517516136, 0.04423459619283676, -0.04303266108036041, -0.0652422159910202, -0.04849512502551079, -0.019599685445427895, 0.05902412161231041, 0.03552374243736267, 0.01031344011425972, -0.018291514366865158, 0.04919861629605293 ]
<p>I am running a Monte-Carlo simulation and I sample from various normal distributions. I was just wondering, is there a way by which I can increase the probability of selecting a point from the tails (i.e., $[-5\sigma,-3\sigma]$ and $[3\sigma,5\sigma]$) as compared to the probability associated with the interval $(-3\sigma, 3\sigma)$?</p> <p>Edit:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/UzAEY.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
g74293
[ 0.0029765439685434103, 0.034422747790813446, -0.00979412067681551, -0.047939881682395935, 0.028479181230068207, -0.023517994210124016, 0.019090482965111732, -0.016913924366235733, -0.016533412039279938, 0.059455808252096176, -0.0038301488384604454, 0.06816652417182922, 0.06266798824071884, -0.009541718289256096, 0.0075209313072264194, -0.01745426282286644, 0.023938000202178955, -0.022041266784071922, 0.0256753321737051, 0.06912457942962646, -0.00017371268768329173, -0.03173920884728432, 0.037907034158706665, -0.03581428900361061, 0.05624871701002121, -0.040680091828107834, -0.05506064370274544, 0.04796480014920235, -0.02734682708978653, 0.03586725890636444, -0.0484531968832016, 0.048095762729644775, 0.07662176340818405, -0.0005158910062164068, -0.020734058693051338, -0.010519145056605339, 0.05377256125211716, -0.03139150142669678, -0.03621542081236839, -0.02791406586766243, -0.018641598522663116, 0.029678797349333763, 0.03010372817516327, 0.008557237684726715, -0.0059235477820038795, -0.041666027158498764, 0.009233731776475906, 0.039121370762586594, 0.03561892732977867, -0.0046990783885121346, -0.023404613137245178, 0.019882122054696083, 0.013340985402464867, -0.030383441597223282, -0.024400854483246803, 0.0017033248441293836, 0.02067900449037552, 0.011366202495992184, 0.05008138716220856, 0.04753844812512398, 0.055026642978191376, -0.05354979634284973, -0.04552023857831955, -0.029039960354566574, 0.03475749492645264, 0.05049803480505943, -0.009155483916401863, 0.01842060498893261, -0.033866334706544876, -0.030803628265857697, -0.03552521392703056, 0.011965231038630009, -0.02455189637839794, -0.06378225982189178, -0.05697648599743843, 0.0014984449371695518, 0.005311890970915556, 0.045680832117795944, -0.010684546083211899, 0.06881038099527359, -0.03595741465687752, -0.039339855313301086, 0.026776203885674477, -0.05804593116044998, -0.03242141753435135, 0.018661124631762505, 0.0873788371682167, -0.011925782077014446, -0.020959779620170593, -0.06684495508670807, 0.013667807914316654, -0.0002028815943049267, 0.04612058773636818, 0.08228834718465805, -0.020878691226243973, 0.01175795029848814, -0.03835582360625267, 0.04746633023023605, -0.0023049877490848303, -0.00828501395881176, -0.017834845930337906, 0.03147945925593376, 0.057888470590114594, 0.019129548221826553, -0.08216764777898788, 0.035806648433208466, -0.06451327353715897, 0.0026500255335122347, -0.014112885110080242, -0.02438727766275406, -0.05367228761315346, -0.04647635668516159, -0.018109936267137527, -0.010752442292869091, 0.005553176160901785, 0.007715087849646807, 0.04010835289955139, -0.001599989365786314, -0.021499095484614372, 0.07882299274206161, -0.03832050785422325, -0.007051019463688135, -0.009190897457301617, 0.04881938174366951, -0.016475077718496323, -0.02183198370039463, -0.00123712164349854, 0.023035552352666855, 0.014872393570840359, -0.00863298773765564, -0.004746877122670412, -0.01972752995789051, 0.006664265878498554, 0.01070056576281786, 0.032300904393196106, 0.0680016279220581, -0.002478967420756817, 0.020596353337168694, 0.0710664913058281, 0.05250462517142296, -0.013885089196264744, 0.04089519381523132, -0.014789761044085026, -0.050417449325323105, -0.054810017347335815, 0.0005617440328933299, 0.00041667273035272956, 0.02531672827899456, -0.06043248623609543, 0.04301181435585022, 0.04676926136016846, 0.018260275945067406, -0.028034120798110962, -0.020120158791542053, -0.02246895246207714, 0.025193123146891594, -0.03473816439509392, 0.024794533848762512, -0.03170046582818031, -0.03771299123764038, 0.015879683196544647, -0.007378205191344023, -0.006641749292612076, -0.016514983028173447, -0.005314209498465061, 0.02233494073152542, 0.0569579117000103, -0.03903861343860626, -0.02701040543615818, 0.040025509893894196, 0.02380608767271042, -0.02943372167646885, -0.015605136752128601, -0.00702985655516386, 0.05674721300601959, 0.011744803749024868, 0.00801578164100647, -0.023789186030626297, 0.010026659816503525, 0.02014576457440853, 0.02632935158908367, 0.005724925082176924, -0.03155944123864174, -0.0723404809832573, 0.0444890558719635, 0.01737683266401291, -0.008749168366193771, 0.03300588205456734, 0.005616118665784597, 0.047714125365018845, -0.015302617102861404, -0.031516339629888535, -0.048718806356191635, -0.06101437285542488, -0.021890264004468918, -0.06484369188547134, 0.06727626174688339, -0.025146331638097763, 0.0062025911174714565, 0.06182970851659775, 0.01774437166750431, 0.016893448308110237, 0.0248360987752676, -0.0005141900037415326, -0.013892611488699913, -0.07661233842372894, 0.02698138728737831, -0.0063731311820447445, -0.032324325293302536, 0.004882907960563898, -0.021709218621253967, -0.0030103535391390324, 0.014324662275612354, -0.012289565987884998, 0.05676412209868431, -0.02546836994588375, 0.007827415131032467, 0.05917302891612053, 0.029893778264522552, -0.04619801044464111, -0.017703622579574585, 0.005405781324952841, 0.04468931630253792, 0.009859741665422916, 0.011182398535311222, 0.036880314350128174, 0.0820889100432396, 0.004291880875825882, 0.01663706824183464, 0.04968950152397156, -0.07660920172929764, 0.0027876393869519234, 0.005285890772938728, -0.04268205538392067, 0.006260070018470287, -0.023704003542661667, -0.0012054783292114735, -0.02071765437722206, 0.00025843785260804, 0.05766661837697029, -0.017040042206645012, -0.031078975647687912, 0.024348272010684013, 0.06674189865589142, -0.033928513526916504, -0.03472403064370155, -0.03912731632590294, 0.0016957658808678389, 0.012156789191067219, -0.018084026873111725, -0.012073983438313007, 0.053160734474658966, 0.04414030909538269, 0.005009358748793602, 0.018332641571760178, -0.027117250487208366, 0.01109613012522459, -0.03886225447058678, 0.029064301401376724, 0.020818302407860756, -0.01389050018042326, 0.04042358696460724, 0.069887675344944, -0.012063832022249699, -0.01642206497490406, 0.00687828054651618, -0.015813274309039116, -0.08742142468690872, -0.023200441151857376, -0.02504950761795044, 0.0033709604758769274, 0.020085444673895836, 0.03125251829624176, 0.11824440211057663, 0.0357431024312973, 0.02035554125905037, 0.017932025715708733, -0.026057066395878792, 0.009968280792236328, -0.030886536464095116, -0.005879088770598173, 0.009976699948310852, -0.015247507020831108, 0.04258260503411293, 0.009211421944200993, 0.00919347908347845, 0.03728022798895836, -0.038747258484363556, -0.06927367299795151, -0.008419516496360302, -0.0015091801760718226, -0.01849023811519146, 0.011818374507129192, -0.05372631177306175, 0.046420443803071976, -0.026337357237935066, 0.031954433768987656, -0.06625158339738846, 0.05700594186782837, 0.06976139545440674, -0.03850652277469635, 0.014701813459396362, -0.008720429614186287, -0.025989027693867683, 0.019958728924393654, 0.03152858838438988, -0.010986097157001495, 0.04641714319586754, 0.014517289586365223, -0.01982700638473034, 0.015001988969743252, -0.04113053157925606, -0.03420741856098175, -0.003423459129408002, -0.046338342130184174, 0.0056716944091022015, 0.03984137624502182, 0.01851074956357479, -0.016827015206217766, -0.020608028396964073, -0.008786543272435665, -0.01971554197371006, -0.06077965721487999, 0.02793426439166069, 0.021329013630747795, 0.0017454398330301046, -0.05846394971013069, -0.002486114390194416, -0.03598112240433693, -0.05173582583665848, 0.06892851740121841, 0.011446721851825714, 0.023977382108569145, 0.03426454961299896, -0.03977986425161362, -0.04039529338479042, 0.016421321779489517, 0.0007259226986207068, 0.03783785551786423, -0.046116914600133896, 0.03887920081615448, -0.022504432126879692, -0.05088173598051071, -0.02398930862545967, -0.00009379818220622838, -0.009070545434951782, 0.057382456958293915, 0.06126004084944725, 0.07525396347045898, -0.00785951316356659, -0.004825725220143795, 0.02039233036339283, 0.01524302363395691, -0.018753429874777794, 0.0914108008146286, -0.009670473635196686, -0.0014373273588716984, -0.019667841494083405, -0.0026342812925577164, -0.007032550871372223, 0.001419306150637567, -0.05491233617067337, -0.020183036103844643, -0.015374976210296154, 0.035547178238630295, -0.034217577427625656, 0.0022540672216564417, 0.05028172954916954, 0.033344436436891556, 0.016036054119467735, -0.016278404742479324, 0.019630493596196175, 0.04574228450655937, 0.033920709043741226, 0.06512030214071274, -0.007397919427603483, 0.019202565774321556, 0.0574742816388607, 0.010716108605265617, 0.03153344616293907, 0.002543468726798892, -0.03258630260825157, -0.0724688321352005, -0.049950458109378815, 0.005013836082071066, 0.001999650150537491, -0.06735547631978989, -0.01755269058048725, -0.013024548999965191, -0.013246772810816765, 0.008871584199368954, -0.04252663254737854, -0.0893029123544693, -0.018778866156935692, 0.028549933806061745, -0.006514381151646376, 0.00021277960331644863, 0.03190077468752861, 0.010776191018521786, 0.05867576599121094, 0.005819864105433226, 0.000716487702447921, 0.0030385246500372887, -0.025972941890358925, 0.012588340789079666, 0.010140491649508476, 0.05375702306628227, 0.03653306886553764, -0.01249601785093546, -0.028489846736192703, -0.00835744570940733, -0.07773475348949432, 0.014606041833758354, 0.0042381128296256065, -0.012665115296840668, -0.03540581464767456, 0.010377367027103901, 0.013819542713463306, -0.002633939031511545, 0.03304102644324303, -0.0029908050782978535, 0.010568051598966122, -0.059960901737213135, -0.014801500365138054, -0.03701547160744667, 0.051162347197532654, 0.0664762407541275, 0.005409481935203075, -0.004405805841088295, -0.016576753929257393, 0.025384247303009033, 0.013690496794879436, 0.009158510714769363, 0.010038833133876324, -0.02830946445465088, 0.017461022362113, -0.03715165704488754, -0.04380088672041893, -0.006032298319041729, -0.0874662697315216, -0.01353098638355732, -0.00624797772616148, 0.0003466110210865736, -0.027119973674416542, 0.03331155702471733, 0.023798298090696335, -0.047895777970552444, -0.040880393236875534, 0.012085063382983208, 0.02620025724172592, -0.06926655024290085, -0.023685546591877937, 0.008973375894129276, 0.0065243844874203205, 0.025661775842308998, -0.021125761792063713, -0.01826508715748787, -0.004878198727965355, 0.006926683243364096, -0.016428573057055473, -0.048893995583057404, 0.04598802328109741, -0.009258102625608444, -0.0037349765188992023, 0.02878670021891594, 0.012486486695706844, -0.037081267684698105, -0.023854242637753487, 0.05680998042225838, 0.02592853084206581, 0.014859998598694801, 0.02077503874897957, 0.07620726525783539, 0.0018936832202598453, -0.002208540914580226, -0.039282117038965225, -0.020760545507073402, -0.018953882157802582, -0.018360832706093788, -0.037292975932359695, 0.0013693623477593064, -0.04959878697991371, -0.0084152827039361, 0.004023031331598759, -0.043785348534584045, 0.004996906500309706, -0.05062247812747955, -0.0677361935377121, 0.03049926459789276, -0.021502142772078514, -0.007272893562912941, 0.030614102259278297, 0.05000665783882141, 0.04235250875353813, 0.04959975928068161, -0.07509659975767136, 0.06687069684267044, -0.0190554391592741, -0.05863413214683533, -0.010536047630012035, -0.06714994460344315, 0.0031461447943001986, -0.016336806118488312, 0.026247922331094742, 0.004306634422391653, 0.031754232943058014, 0.028206095099449158, -0.00437092175707221, 0.013568757101893425, 0.0690028965473175, 0.011866548098623753, -0.048799604177474976, 0.0796288326382637, -0.03310480713844299, -0.08572321385145187, 0.019416039809584618, -0.038004904985427856, -0.004812162835150957, -0.0013254516525194049, -0.047322288155555725, 0.10225997865200043, -0.008319182321429253, 0.01624167151749134, -0.04150816425681114, -0.00831671617925167, -0.05521465465426445, -0.0563599094748497, -0.055449020117521286, -0.01426422968506813, -0.042097173631191254, 0.017949754372239113, -0.005864832084625959, -0.054821595549583435, 0.05174644663929939, -0.0035257618874311447, -0.08203758299350739, -0.024858854711055756, -0.01535572949796915, 0.010609231889247894, 0.030231958255171776, 0.01615721732378006, -0.049962639808654785, 0.0652732253074646, 0.06884486973285675, -0.019350403919816017, -0.01083823200315237, -0.011305917985737324, 0.00862473901361227, -0.014417636208236217, -0.046526115387678146, -0.029881741851568222, 0.04494086652994156, 0.004144085571169853, -0.006345293950289488, -0.039935335516929626, 0.07415167987346649, 0.05300996080040932, 0.04729537293314934, 0.04610489308834076, 0.04229839891195297, -0.05510994791984558, -0.09145723283290863, 0.021899143233895302, 0.05993402376770973, -0.0074026379734277725, -0.044830676168203354, -0.06332778185606003, -0.01026071421802044, 0.004137991927564144, 0.009478357620537281, 0.05348514765501022, 0.01910826563835144, -0.05107065290212631, 0.02357255108654499, 0.04905768111348152, -0.007683868985623121, -0.023043787106871605, 0.046109870076179504, 0.013013849034905434, -0.011365695856511593, -0.09142114967107773, 0.03362146019935608, -0.045235782861709595, -0.03411336615681648, -0.07435855269432068, 0.06524627655744553, 0.007340317126363516, -0.01032371073961258, -0.0037395069375634193, 0.0023345407098531723, -0.010809623636305332, -0.03987257927656174, -0.003423872170969844, -0.08430826663970947, 0.042170450091362, -0.04053482413291931, -0.012761029414832592, 0.02611236833035946, 0.006662083324044943, 0.05267507955431938, 0.04318014159798622, -0.035444363951683044, 0.029269427061080933, -0.01249837689101696, -0.004588560666888952, 0.018692251294851303, 0.002841684967279434, -0.0003352907078806311, 0.04278513789176941, -0.025615226477384567, 0.030814150348305702, -0.0009756017825566232, 0.007789203431457281, 0.04421579837799072, -0.0013232604833319783, -0.015780558809638023, -0.05504303053021431, 0.001624883385375142, -0.01145840622484684, 0.06340458989143372, 0.04507122188806534, -0.0030387009028345346, -0.048181433230638504, 0.004437130875885487, 0.03649376705288887, -0.003998845349997282, 0.00444791791960597, -0.05022173374891281, -0.021410400047898293, -0.02265678159892559, -0.0058168694376945496, -0.04890516772866249, -0.05837338790297508, 0.06589438766241074, -0.08755674213171005, 0.011886746622622013, -0.011222918517887592, -0.005999864544719458, 0.0015900544822216034, 0.06846684962511063, -0.0194057859480381, 0.027226613834500313, 0.019329819828271866, 0.005646333564072847, 0.0007942389929667115, -0.05572100356221199, 0.08843345940113068, 0.05671217665076256, -0.003768256865441799, 0.00689832353964448, 0.06000703200697899, -0.0006401861901395023, -0.00008353887824341655, 0.005398253910243511, 0.011234384030103683, 0.04059109091758728, 0.03338851407170296, 0.00794952642172575, 0.026266034692525864, 0.007171161472797394, -0.010881089605391026, -0.021745769307017326, -0.016891960054636, -0.0315733402967453, -0.015142570249736309, 0.02040865644812584, 0.014854393899440765, 0.02077057585120201, -0.04461120814085007, -0.009485622867941856, -0.010952906683087349, -0.05416543409228325, -0.08696363121271133, 0.03584188595414162, 0.032333195209503174, -0.02632109448313713, -0.023934712633490562, 0.04245464876294136, -0.015878258273005486, -0.01265675388276577, 0.04305785149335861, -0.027795379981398582, -0.024361995980143547, -0.09133053570985794, -0.01168804056942463, 0.02081773802638054, -0.01394677348434925, -0.02096434123814106, 0.027407469227910042, 0.026507070288062096, -0.03190159425139427, -0.020548630505800247, 0.00008442351099802181, 0.010342543944716454, -0.0010716492542997003, 0.004543724004179239, -0.03216290846467018, 0.0031993899028748274, 0.04517047852277756, 0.06341695785522461, -0.006742799188941717, -0.010388419963419437, -0.033715926110744476, 0.011290214024484158, -0.007257083896547556, -0.010285479947924614, 0.02903074212372303, -0.0015587130328640342, -0.021758178249001503, -0.05786051228642464, 0.02807353436946869, -0.016280490905046463, 0.021430397406220436, 0.05986253544688225, -0.02069518342614174, -0.041781216859817505, -0.010979307815432549, 0.005882116500288248, 0.031595826148986816, 0.02508705109357834, -0.04836559295654297, -0.04587557166814804, -0.03538686782121658, 0.012870636768639088, 0.02529633790254593, -0.03858337551355362, -0.053510911762714386, 0.030637260526418686, 0.00443350849673152, 0.05542635917663574, -0.014014988206326962, -0.07087681442499161, -0.04724255949258804, -0.005848086439073086, 0.01889856532216072, -0.0006747689913026989, 0.003929071128368378, -0.029269911348819733, 0.0365438349545002, -0.0026522669941186905, -0.0559883713722229, -0.00815522950142622, 0.07287582010030746, -0.0035792484413832426, 0.022587165236473083, 0.019111722707748413, 0.01574920304119587, 0.02566150203347206, 0.012791219167411327, 0.059732358902692795, -0.029229551553726196, -0.015239488333463669, 0.021144121885299683, 0.0917472243309021, -0.05692403018474579, -0.023690884932875633, 0.027483409270644188, 0.00877821259200573, 0.028670288622379303, -0.03161272406578064, -0.020775049924850464, -0.07103535532951355, -0.014152731746435165, -0.009158673696219921, 0.006677058059722185, 0.0009709576261229813, 0.04022466018795967, -0.004235429223626852 ]
<p>I am using logistic regression to predict y given x1 and x2:</p> <pre><code>z = B0 + B1 * x1 + B2 * x2 y = e^z / (e^z + 1) </code></pre> <p>How is logistic regression supposed to handle cases in which my variables have very different scales? Do people ever build logistic regression models with higher-order coefficients for variables? I'm imagining something like this (for two variables):</p> <pre><code>z = B0 + B1 * x1 + B2 * x1^2 + B3 * x2 + B4 * x2^2 </code></pre> <p>Alternatively, is the right answer to simply normalize, standardize or rescale the x1 and x2 values before using logistic regression?</p>
g74294
[ -0.0021914097014814615, -0.021025048568844795, 0.02980230376124382, 0.009033115580677986, 0.06487496942281723, -0.05538142845034599, -0.04830901324748993, 0.039209529757499695, -0.03766826540231705, 0.0165912713855505, -0.015596318058669567, 0.02537773922085762, 0.02980995550751686, 0.020003190264105797, -0.04148287698626518, -0.0067048086784780025, 0.022769922390580177, 0.011729978956282139, 0.00870861578732729, -0.021637680009007454, -0.02602406218647957, -0.00005891407636227086, 0.05042165890336037, -0.019617373123764992, -0.0788482278585434, -0.025543635711073875, -0.04188380017876625, 0.08457284420728683, -0.017694970592856407, 0.03223748877644539, -0.0016078302869573236, 0.07239566743373871, 0.04593577980995178, 0.02547743357717991, -0.030058471485972404, 0.025574080646038055, -0.027662133798003197, 0.0271186213940382, 0.014420885592699051, 0.005426370073109865, 0.04548002406954765, 0.010646863840520382, -0.0029975653160363436, -0.008676595985889435, 0.01625124365091324, -0.005148323718458414, -0.010607718490064144, -0.035338230431079865, -0.006168403662741184, 0.05818277969956398, 0.03148848935961723, 0.037488192319869995, 0.001047522877342999, -0.002709476975724101, 0.05461397394537926, 0.006366252433508635, 0.002551614074036479, 0.031678032130002975, 0.02680443786084652, 0.04246440529823303, 0.06918563693761826, 0.017896251752972603, 0.007584176026284695, 0.009478503838181496, -0.010073577053844929, 0.01721770502626896, -0.039633188396692276, -0.005886511877179146, 0.015489823184907436, -0.002630443312227726, 0.006636158563196659, 0.027045635506510735, -0.02153952233493328, -0.01846451312303543, -0.0647914782166481, -0.05029646307229996, 0.07131784409284592, 0.01621517725288868, -0.006389317102730274, 0.01110392902046442, 0.0030475652310997248, 0.02989964932203293, 0.037533048540353775, 0.060125868767499924, -0.05337590351700783, 0.0375964492559433, 0.040084924548864365, 0.020167391747236252, 0.014838163740932941, -0.007992473430931568, -0.006563996896147728, -0.025787783786654472, 0.015192040242254734, 0.048895880579948425, -0.0018361638067290187, -0.06127878651022911, -0.030693508684635162, 0.010665017180144787, -0.0014685196802020073, -0.04579450935125351, 0.030593715608119965, 0.08211717754602432, -0.024811245501041412, -0.0021460300777107477, -0.16428792476654053, -0.035738322883844376, 0.0559760220348835, -0.042346060276031494, -0.02072886750102043, -0.022532043978571892, -0.07954644411802292, 0.01892094872891903, -0.02689315937459469, -0.018443860113620758, -0.06847508996725082, -0.005222884006798267, 0.04197452962398529, -0.026865404099225998, -0.04501713812351227, -0.034791018813848495, 0.048838820308446884, -0.042456649243831635, 0.042351286858320236, -0.015340609475970268, 0.0018818461103364825, -0.0036410237662494183, -0.030585525557398796, 0.08848678320646286, 0.05405319109559059, -0.01722106710076332, 0.03819836303591728, 0.012586156837642193, -0.00039023393765091896, 0.011497451923787594, -0.02470959909260273, 0.0398382730782032, -0.026081092655658722, 0.03932458162307739, -0.009076516143977642, 0.015058036893606186, 0.005205838941037655, 0.0059385704807937145, 0.04721856117248535, -0.004620317369699478, -0.00368622038513422, 0.0156061090528965, -0.01855079084634781, 0.010300185531377792, -0.02458048053085804, 0.006645395420491695, 0.0008468771120533347, 0.0390508733689785, -0.014211158268153667, 0.022390378639101982, -0.046461623162031174, 0.049973972141742706, 0.009439815767109394, -0.0008541742572560906, 0.03462376818060875, -0.042366188019514084, 0.05366436019539833, -0.04026039317250252, 0.05364410579204559, 0.023549027740955353, 0.014249791391193867, 0.013573608361184597, 0.005299131385982037, -0.014689120464026928, -0.05228355526924133, 0.05187887325882912, -0.022897038608789444, -0.012479826807975769, -0.02929103933274746, 0.0011394793400540948, 0.07063878327608109, 0.028916476294398308, 0.03924531117081642, 0.01955312304198742, 0.02801142819225788, -0.011263515800237656, -0.049119558185338974, 0.04274875298142433, -0.022506598383188248, -0.035045839846134186, -0.011745688505470753, -0.0534057542681694, -0.026471996679902077, 0.03215006738901138, -0.03375277295708656, -0.027716103941202164, -0.06198011338710785, 0.03091716766357422, 0.00832991674542427, -0.0024326355196535587, -0.008399232290685177, -0.03539900854229927, -0.029780300334095955, -0.02595294825732708, -0.051906902343034744, 0.034897416830062866, 0.016049552708864212, 0.022324640303850174, -0.00687389774248004, 0.03653319552540779, -0.04141493886709213, 0.02581976354122162, -0.04173080250620842, -0.008800552226603031, 0.009558343328535557, -0.02800649031996727, -0.013844572007656097, -0.037534769624471664, -0.010502629913389683, 0.04751180112361908, -0.010849779471755028, -0.020789122208952904, -0.01002426166087389, 0.045930229127407074, -0.029286300763487816, 0.01120355911552906, -0.059134457260370255, -0.05939359590411186, 0.0025215502828359604, 0.024847758933901787, 0.001714544603601098, 0.00483542587608099, 0.04092666134238243, 0.024823257699608803, 0.037004951387643814, -0.019593048840761185, -0.011681449599564075, 0.013602444902062416, 0.021310580894351006, -0.052976157516241074, -0.05500776693224907, -0.004327564500272274, -0.012567301280796528, 0.013624466955661774, 0.011900115758180618, 0.01563831977546215, 0.053854018449783325, 0.007115987129509449, 0.050982408225536346, 0.033592019230127335, 0.07481270283460617, -0.03977367281913757, 0.08417961001396179, 0.0303635336458683, 0.0006414965610019863, 0.07312314212322235, -0.020533934235572815, 0.025075463578104973, -0.03373277187347412, -0.04039217531681061, -0.025998825207352638, -0.06598902493715286, 0.040302712470293045, 0.054698098450899124, -0.03686979040503502, -0.04918278381228447, -0.037215158343315125, 0.03235296905040741, -0.0027666063979268074, 0.017650874331593513, -0.021223025396466255, 0.013867931440472603, 0.027142537757754326, -0.00546385208144784, 0.008832323364913464, -0.015650058165192604, 0.018520670011639595, -0.03186880797147751, -0.009298929944634438, 0.03756905719637871, 0.03519294410943985, -0.016072073951363564, -0.03253400698304176, -0.040725480765104294, 0.03114989772439003, -0.01536038052290678, 0.034604597836732864, -0.05526987463235855, -0.01972699724137783, 0.00042594800470396876, 0.10547704994678497, 0.023747054859995842, 0.038470979779958725, 0.012354105710983276, -0.04254411533474922, 0.052645377814769745, 0.008773397654294968, 0.016148919239640236, -0.010091261938214302, -0.014437360689043999, 0.01582612842321396, 0.020319094881415367, 0.016361845657229424, -0.06052156537771225, 0.01342454832047224, 0.02938213013112545, -0.02347850427031517, -0.015910567715764046, 0.047655340284109116, -0.001999148167669773, 0.00518818711861968, -0.05929215997457504, -0.03078492358326912, 0.07639130204916, -0.02797122299671173, -0.004677155986428261, -0.04638776555657387, -0.022596167400479317, -0.051681313663721085, 0.01712987944483757, -0.037923965603113174, -0.04249212518334389, -0.0004887270624749362, 0.003208171110600233, 0.08005839586257935, -0.024742022156715393, 0.017814794555306435, -0.002066486980766058, 0.06477958709001541, 0.016851920634508133, -0.03943851217627525, 0.06321703642606735, -0.014241009019315243, 0.04648618772625923, -0.0315738208591938, 0.0485447458922863, 0.06856707483530045, 0.07941025495529175, 0.02580336108803749, 0.0010175594361498952, 0.028425248339772224, -0.029247673228383064, 0.01779792085289955, -0.011666818521916866, -0.0047258371487259865, -0.015193535014986992, -0.012503531761467457, -0.004883932881057262, -0.006052231416106224, -0.024789730086922646, -0.015373864211142063, -0.04276980087161064, 0.02881099097430706, 0.03160747140645981, -0.025085903704166412, -0.04134516417980194, -0.03687791898846626, -0.0021612041164189577, 0.04275926947593689, 0.010408471338450909, 0.0063019790686666965, 0.02996586076915264, 0.03799368813633919, -0.01814693957567215, -0.027373675256967545, -0.009474712423980236, 0.03027973510324955, -0.016822880133986473, -0.048381295055150986, 0.02023906074464321, -0.024164892733097076, 0.002754185814410448, 0.027536362409591675, 0.026992568746209145, 0.0003852863737847656, -0.0017597912810742855, 0.053211361169815063, 0.04505731165409088, 0.052566736936569214, 0.02415858954191208, 0.010111581534147263, -0.03348183259367943, 0.0991549864411354, -0.02190363220870495, 0.006759952753782272, 0.018765196204185486, 0.007065404672175646, -0.02037014625966549, -0.060453783720731735, -0.054806843400001526, -0.014821751974523067, -0.041987840086221695, -0.001207774505019188, -0.040604036301374435, 0.036016978323459625, 0.008306787349283695, -0.022591374814510345, 0.0014069725293666124, -0.007553307805210352, 0.06708218157291412, 0.059621412307024, -0.04900515079498291, -0.002412100089713931, 0.008886189199984074, -0.018587201833724976, -0.004804317839443684, -0.044548653066158295, 0.01855797879397869, 0.005046451464295387, 0.028803879395127296, -0.029259519651532173, -0.048341602087020874, 0.0064921071752905846, 0.0025908569805324078, -0.08265452086925507, -0.0045483228750526905, 0.04702376574277878, 0.010096431709825993, -0.03239212557673454, -0.057435233145952225, 0.07084497064352036, -0.05197573080658913, 0.05557550862431526, 0.027481799945235252, -0.023754272609949112, -0.008487919345498085, 0.06701557338237762, 0.023996759206056595, -0.029157143086194992, -0.03803246468305588, 0.02448507957160473, 0.02955978736281395, -0.01681704819202423, -0.04330112412571907, 0.03235119208693504, 0.012756060808897018, 0.03521008417010307, 0.03961210325360298, -0.03541885316371918, 0.02095111832022667, 0.000417939416365698, -0.0042090946808457375, -0.04029912129044533, -0.0022358237765729427, 0.024230875074863434, -0.014039655216038227, -0.03860462084412575, -0.02942809648811817, -0.04603526368737221, -0.004822788294404745, -0.014636818319559097, -0.023919586092233658, -0.009611855261027813, 0.02935446798801422, -0.016406411305069923, 0.014126986265182495, -0.027318032458424568, 0.05954231321811676, 0.03026570752263069, -0.03193318843841553, 0.012660539709031582, -0.05950599163770676, 0.07467973232269287, 0.0233930516988039, 0.0037631154991686344, -0.022858547046780586, -0.0067091747187078, -0.05371178686618805, -0.0561860166490078, -0.021125122904777527, -0.0051352414302527905, -0.00697057880461216, -0.05203771963715553, -0.001087307813577354, 0.0631333738565445, 0.012730279006063938, -0.03569207340478897, -0.05414656922221184, 0.03766262158751488, 0.017770621925592422, 0.028222398832440376, 0.06639977544546127, -0.028986645862460136, 0.014667757786810398, 0.000803413160610944, 0.013915259391069412, -0.05124678090214729, -0.006388598587363958, -0.021100280806422234, -0.019168609753251076, -0.04333613067865372, -0.03680771589279175, -0.01418472919613123, -0.06446584314107895, 0.01798136532306671, 0.021145746111869812, -0.026339957490563393, 0.05525035038590431, 0.03855844959616661, 0.04909995198249817, -0.034886233508586884, -0.014725474640727043, -0.013369987718760967, -0.06702768057584763, 0.021758032962679863, 0.0031616396736353636, -0.05343891307711601, 0.015513644553720951, 0.02268146723508835, -0.057320673018693924, 0.011257277801632881, 0.01770244911313057, 0.020538825541734695, -0.029033077880740166, 0.025490835309028625, 0.014292697422206402, -0.03822489082813263, 0.03245948255062103, 0.0814218670129776, 0.0038260421715676785, -0.013249877840280533, -0.02868521772325039, 0.03336930647492409, 0.03752274811267853, -0.017303967848420143, -0.04503917321562767, 0.05177271366119385, -0.045389290899038315, 0.0027262838557362556, 0.0012362574925646186, -0.02868490107357502, -0.020021051168441772, -0.015249663032591343, -0.0642857700586319, -0.002693686168640852, -0.023733749985694885, 0.001945745898410678, -0.006420738063752651, -0.022441215813159943, 0.028842244297266006, -0.008389336057007313, 0.017156727612018585, -0.053099311888217926, 0.04583118483424187, -0.026300333440303802, -0.015211854130029678, -0.022572282701730728, 0.019687170162796974, 0.03719031810760498, -0.017078537493944168, -0.00012389171752147377, -0.033398959785699844, -0.0014009148580953479, -0.0029883752577006817, 0.03299332782626152, -0.06274953484535217, -0.055344194173812866, -0.017328768968582153, -0.006708201952278614, 0.018548302352428436, -0.01930222474038601, 0.03918929398059845, 0.01568404771387577, 0.00882401317358017, 0.042555976659059525, -0.0015951547538861632, -0.02242029458284378, -0.02232644334435463, 0.0003420502180233598, -0.0500052236020565, 0.0065685962326824665, -0.07399880141019821, -0.0022567068226635456, 0.005667905323207378, 0.020769331604242325, 0.039233192801475525, -0.014656275510787964, -0.028169983997941017, 0.04604291915893555, 0.033778876066207886, -0.016589773818850517, 0.010583296418190002, -0.0051499041728675365, -0.00947679951786995, 0.05141524598002434, -0.053587619215250015, -0.025837257504463196, 0.048206690698862076, -0.03432667627930641, 0.009103263728320599, -0.05493583530187607, 0.07055342942476273, -0.0008720273617655039, -0.019658297300338745, -0.020221780985593796, 0.005946463905274868, -0.015946170315146446, 0.0015060815494507551, 0.02116871252655983, -0.050158172845840454, -0.009050844237208366, 0.038380950689315796, 0.03652309253811836, 0.07975761592388153, 0.009474532678723335, -0.0317956805229187, -0.004612185060977936, -0.01961253210902214, 0.024149933829903603, 0.009865720756351948, 0.04391324892640114, -0.003531289752572775, -0.03953585773706436, 0.07266812771558762, 0.05124937370419502, -0.007620793301612139, -0.009701854549348354, 0.010981961153447628, 0.03696673735976219, 0.0017018495127558708, -0.01924985647201538, -0.0060838814824819565, -0.006547730416059494, 0.05655288323760033, 0.03313053771853447, -0.007947884500026703, 0.03695433586835861, -0.02870211936533451, -0.007921864278614521, -0.014552655629813671, 0.026385994628071785, 0.028938809409737587, 0.029989050701260567, 0.012616382911801338, 0.05312097817659378, -0.05506545305252075, -0.043486520648002625, 0.020513786002993584, 0.003941567149013281, 0.026780273765325546, -0.021129805594682693, 0.0017758900066837668, -0.040818531066179276, 0.043350234627723694, -0.008817557245492935, 0.031023496761918068, 0.023506948724389076, 0.06075320020318031, -0.04208773374557495, 0.01996186189353466, -0.028098752722144127, 0.037470508366823196, 0.08283820748329163, 0.024454733356833458, -0.06963399052619934, 0.013286616653203964, 0.0405123196542263, -0.002734572859480977, 0.01439398992806673, -0.05883251130580902, 0.013272806070744991, -0.0018921270966529846, 0.05755861476063728, 0.04124830663204193, 0.019733581691980362, 0.06514471024274826, -0.01769266650080681, 0.024047845974564552, -0.03504178300499916, 0.011440002359449863, 0.05221793055534363, 0.05111205577850342, -0.046426255255937576, -0.05918334424495697, -0.031190859153866768, 0.00036562589230015874, -0.03746127337217331, -0.07985574007034302, 0.011293386109173298, -0.005419616121798754, 0.03230897709727287, -0.004676239099353552, -0.06705881655216217, 0.010745538398623466, -0.039417531341314316, 0.01995082199573517, 0.032692644745111465, -0.04367833584547043, 0.004018628038465977, -0.020616455003619194, -0.015209165401756763, 0.03254440426826477, 0.008913530968129635, -0.024898109957575798, 0.011480181477963924, -0.036174334585666656, -0.10497242957353592, -0.022784430533647537, 0.04194480925798416, -0.019277876242995262, 0.004530350212007761, 0.01104685477912426, -0.08029794692993164, 0.029801344498991966, -0.047313254326581955, 0.035682931542396545, 0.06272142380475998, 0.03178827837109566, -0.01921241730451584, -0.01518162339925766, 0.03917635977268219, -0.002575098304077983, 0.015478714369237423, -0.08900299668312073, -0.02428777515888214, -0.07642894983291626, -0.13722802698612213, 0.03219141811132431, 0.01147265825420618, 0.04487519711256027, -0.06454788148403168, -0.0020666010677814484, -0.06065481901168823, -0.09876476228237152, -0.01887834444642067, 0.00999103020876646, -0.06542976945638657, -0.018500300124287605, -0.002372186165302992, 0.0006947775837033987, 0.06777428090572357, -0.0547255277633667, -0.058567024767398834, 0.02827434241771698, -0.007665029726922512, 0.022073695436120033, -0.021555090323090553, -0.04815070703625679, -0.061074189841747284, 0.06218740716576576, 0.03628871962428093, 0.038917750120162964, -0.0373808778822422, 0.001586642232723534, -0.048613376915454865, 0.0009015126852318645, -0.03047061711549759, 0.026740238070487976, -0.0020890533924102783, 0.048340704292058945, -0.02458641119301319, 0.0826224535703659, 0.01103817019611597, 0.010913019068539143, -0.032473210245370865, -0.018091479316353798, -0.006573050282895565, -0.007394138723611832, -0.06593035906553268, 0.03985639661550522, 0.007256123702973127, 0.016083722934126854, 0.0072268471121788025, 0.005481059197336435, -0.013026720844209194, -0.055475395172834396, -0.030531147494912148, 0.029441557824611664, -0.023785851895809174, 0.010473460890352726, -0.02360478788614273, -0.04592924565076828, -0.022404899820685387, 0.05761340633034706 ]
<p>An online module I am studying states that one should <strong>never</strong> use Pearson correlation with proportion data. Why not?</p> <p>Or, if it is sometimes OK or always OK, why?</p>
g74295
[ 0.059067025780677795, -0.046740271151065826, 0.023248782381415367, -0.04804539307951927, 0.0017746944213286042, 0.042112722992897034, -0.029621966183185577, 0.01069153193384409, 0.0016564917750656605, -0.07003351300954819, 0.10383106023073196, -0.04123465344309807, 0.0028848086949437857, 0.010971778072416782, -0.11917903274297714, 0.0009207781404256821, 0.052838556468486786, -0.019035130739212036, -0.021707791835069656, 0.0801825001835823, -0.08497682213783264, 0.002939494326710701, 0.042460501194000244, -0.004273190628737211, -0.03133466839790344, -0.004212611820548773, 0.056346941739320755, -0.06638240069150925, -0.06682544946670532, -0.020679114386439323, 0.013870478607714176, 0.02418467029929161, 0.016006212681531906, -0.05424252897500992, -0.07198843359947205, 0.023837482556700706, -0.029012620449066162, 0.04976718872785568, -0.03572549670934677, 0.026225384324789047, -0.004245601128786802, -0.0011833924800157547, 0.02079256810247898, -0.041464194655418396, -0.04054468870162964, 0.03225289657711983, -0.013948148116469383, 0.044798534363508224, -0.03601203113794327, -0.008559190668165684, -0.013490097597241402, -0.01116979867219925, -0.012112774886190891, 0.0068716551177203655, 0.0626027062535286, 0.06244020536541939, -0.0038018962368369102, 0.025472041219472885, 0.002105157123878598, -0.029023587703704834, 0.0308376532047987, -0.01815699227154255, -0.0020860915537923574, -0.002807759679853916, 0.02323225885629654, 0.005387444514781237, -0.015903694555163383, -0.05714048817753792, 0.01978074386715889, 0.035508908331394196, 0.03883872926235199, -0.05276736617088318, -0.002899391343817115, -0.012652750127017498, -0.027568358927965164, -0.0070707225240767, -0.040416836738586426, -0.025711597874760628, 0.05333120375871658, 0.021652180701494217, 0.026583923026919365, -0.013720553368330002, 0.020747292786836624, 0.05117208510637283, 0.04996992275118828, -0.010648544877767563, 0.03755895420908928, -0.020340997725725174, 0.049090441316366196, -0.00015459295536857098, 0.021358689293265343, 0.0005487130838446319, 0.07220005989074707, 0.084447480738163, 0.004451070912182331, -0.04153081774711609, -0.01741878129541874, 0.0016657327068969607, -0.0014225097838789225, -0.013561009429395199, 0.009618869051337242, 0.039469506591558456, 0.0009426796459592879, 0.010024846531450748, -0.10418880730867386, 0.03123600222170353, 0.0908544510602951, 0.04689287766814232, -0.007271093316376209, -0.04839252680540085, -0.009929443709552288, 0.020858507603406906, -0.017267420887947083, -0.053922586143016815, 0.005114496219903231, -0.027194108814001083, 0.022576168179512024, -0.05184702202677727, -0.018866179510951042, -0.009074483998119831, 0.01148389931768179, 0.0035133284982293844, 0.017418358474969864, 0.012310975231230259, -0.015096594579517841, -0.052098460495471954, 0.049314387142658234, 0.004143242258578539, -0.04911937937140465, -0.03566175326704979, -0.004309763666242361, 0.0016673546051606536, -0.06988213956356049, -0.011725693941116333, 0.0372011698782444, 0.015520629473030567, 0.02285117655992508, 0.003260011551901698, 0.013572619296610355, 0.04451718181371689, -0.04910172149538994, 0.026527948677539825, -0.03437952324748039, -0.02074511907994747, -0.014726280234754086, 0.011445680633187294, 0.024236712604761124, -0.00002287419920321554, 0.011019409634172916, 0.04334362596273422, -0.025360876694321632, -0.01733235828578472, -0.028479410335421562, 0.016404878348112106, -0.05534175783395767, 0.005548753775656223, 0.008089955896139145, 0.023459533229470253, 0.03316141292452812, 0.07898010313510895, 0.0435815192759037, -0.002047492191195488, 0.025939397513866425, -0.015145901590585709, 0.007052790839225054, 0.016424091532826424, -0.021401649340987206, -0.04265042766928673, 0.00872459914535284, -0.03236950933933258, 0.009588081389665604, -0.014587332494556904, 0.0235653854906559, -0.048779234290122986, -0.0060800849460065365, -0.005673088598996401, 0.030073776841163635, 0.020329760387539864, 0.0745750367641449, 0.009506563656032085, 0.003997684922069311, 0.02583681046962738, 0.016662627458572388, 0.005220639985054731, -0.015528097748756409, -0.007094162050634623, 0.025167910382151604, 0.024217907339334488, -0.02929653786122799, 0.024731263518333435, -0.006902527529746294, -0.02650304324924946, -0.04269379377365112, 0.005055672954767942, -0.06593313068151474, -0.042687322944402695, -0.03269525617361069, 0.0001935337932081893, -0.04365595802664757, -0.056481365114450455, -0.012159166857600212, -0.01711764559149742, 0.02007240429520607, 0.026013052091002464, -0.020931731909513474, -0.015099918469786644, 0.011624010279774666, 0.03559872880578041, -0.016467904672026634, -0.013251962140202522, 0.07674434036016464, -0.005133101250976324, -0.03912661597132683, 0.05184409022331238, 0.011258228681981564, -0.015322567895054817, -0.020284239202737808, -0.02200906351208687, -0.00392350135371089, 0.07368063181638718, -0.026899805292487144, -0.023349275812506676, -0.028470657765865326, -0.05693426355719566, -0.05542198196053505, 0.01377948746085167, -0.00046467941137962043, 0.012176813557744026, -0.03900231793522835, -0.011519485153257847, -0.00006927065260242671, -0.02759876661002636, 0.02562677301466465, -0.020517339929938316, 0.02904120646417141, 0.022601399570703506, -0.016678335145115852, -0.006738038267940283, 0.028136180713772774, 0.05969235301017761, 0.007581853773444891, -0.031323473900556564, 0.03687240928411484, 0.05655217915773392, 0.009719043038785458, 0.014213666319847107, 0.013043847866356373, -0.02131671831011772, -0.0208436306566, 0.018072210252285004, -0.015031328424811363, 0.019175980240106583, 0.0603833943605423, -0.054239705204963684, -0.0019504150841385126, 0.026869680732488632, 0.02064819075167179, -0.00006545971700688824, -0.00015457476547453552, 0.011107337661087513, 0.04568134993314743, -0.009349082596600056, -0.03955591470003128, -0.003467115107923746, -0.025098172947764397, -0.011206614784896374, 0.02069038711488247, -0.026740804314613342, -0.018098097294569016, 0.015449072234332561, -0.04608752205967903, 0.07394319027662277, 0.032201096415519714, 0.0673278197646141, 0.018892250955104828, -0.020000988617539406, -0.03697753697633743, -0.017345676198601723, 0.01501182559877634, -0.01476422417908907, 0.047786880284547806, 0.0454019196331501, -0.020163683220744133, 0.06657865643501282, 0.07525569945573807, -0.04199471324682236, 0.03262113407254219, 0.013326569460332394, -0.006782337091863155, 0.03986716642975807, 0.007062056101858616, -0.007793923374265432, 0.03122476115822792, 0.05482848361134529, 0.08336543291807175, 0.005434772931039333, 0.046432770788669586, -0.0706934705376625, 0.02186669409275055, -0.013452875427901745, 0.010668717324733734, 0.030529070645570755, 0.0013292408548295498, 0.05725357308983803, 0.08451689779758453, -0.02897356078028679, -0.010124262422323227, 0.024382581934332848, 0.029317928478121758, 0.022236889228224754, -0.002176969312131405, 0.018662860617041588, 0.00884208269417286, 0.019087648019194603, -0.008107001893222332, 0.019283007830381393, -0.02700846455991268, 0.0036417506635189056, -0.02887502685189247, -0.0547463595867157, 0.028876451775431633, -0.0528486929833889, -0.026553694158792496, -0.047864701598882675, 0.005187180824577808, 0.027224579825997353, -0.02724393457174301, 0.06064816191792488, -0.0022792285308241844, 0.008422480896115303, 0.02284974232316017, -0.019653910771012306, 0.07702138274908066, 0.004760634154081345, -0.034658223390579224, -0.020586449652910233, 0.03573065623641014, -0.03916896879673004, -0.0182307418435812, 0.021137675270438194, 0.0025178680662065744, -0.05823774263262749, 0.041565991938114166, -0.003988250624388456, -0.019657280296087265, 0.025697167962789536, 0.0361383855342865, -0.0015883882297202945, 0.014845690689980984, -0.014737914316356182, 0.019691307097673416, 0.019562309607863426, -0.03812780976295471, -0.02389976754784584, 0.013259549625217915, 0.0055204108357429504, 0.032080359756946564, 0.019525853917002678, 0.008430412970483303, -0.029546361416578293, -0.0003138362371828407, -0.011181981302797794, -0.024676967412233353, 0.02302905172109604, -0.04099263995885849, 0.017348086461424828, -0.0176047682762146, 0.051766738295555115, 0.0010664314031600952, 0.008195729926228523, 0.02445697970688343, 0.02903304435312748, 0.004444931633770466, 0.009099461138248444, -0.001623206422664225, 0.0017787663964554667, 0.0018692173762246966, 0.000518602435477078, 0.0004136856005061418, 0.002838112646713853, 0.02448827400803566, -0.015032777562737465, -0.03802281245589256, -0.011766359210014343, 0.030227666720747948, -0.02660360373556614, 0.007194577716290951, -0.02391107752919197, 0.04134606570005417, -0.033784061670303345, 0.054902464151382446, -0.06612445414066315, -0.0033332963939756155, 0.06585279107093811, 0.03367768973112106, 0.0035654373932629824, 0.012505647726356983, 0.03871717303991318, 0.10162484645843506, 0.021299708634614944, -0.08864620327949524, -0.023505888879299164, -0.03914371132850647, -0.0035987875889986753, -0.021488131955266, 0.00582157215103507, -0.10245037823915482, -0.045645397156476974, -0.03873021900653839, -0.03371685370802879, -0.0179231408983469, -0.011617733165621758, 0.010989897884428501, -0.022867532446980476, 0.013724851422011852, -0.025392452254891396, 0.039002515375614166, 0.041336480528116226, 0.02107483334839344, -0.0036115909460932016, 0.01842792145907879, 0.021134110167622566, -0.00032129796454682946, 0.008576101623475552, 0.015834346413612366, -0.028958098962903023, 0.022426074370741844, -0.013568321242928505, -0.029512621462345123, 0.0150073803961277, 0.042023707181215286, 0.0542549192905426, 0.0002262072084704414, -0.05203412100672722, -0.005561275407671928, 0.001983534311875701, -0.004184107296168804, 0.07422757893800735, -0.024445688351988792, -0.0018333778716623783, 0.02768118306994438, -0.0196530818939209, 0.007462268229573965, -0.018351560458540916, -0.07834840565919876, 0.028747355565428734, -0.03780442848801613, -0.008844127878546715, 0.02083979919552803, -0.03799823299050331, 0.0009989775717258453, 0.023068776354193687, -0.01838580332696438, -0.06765531003475189, 0.019838618114590645, 0.05172565206885338, -0.021129414439201355, 0.02341139130294323, 0.044235315173864365, -0.02144891954958439, -0.04281340166926384, -0.0459817536175251, 0.009748409502208233, -0.031181706115603447, -0.005540664307773113, 0.004431816749274731, -0.020137900486588478, -0.007768493145704269, 0.02369709126651287, -0.0039793578907847404, 0.021552516147494316, 0.008668512105941772, 0.05244319885969162, -0.037615515291690826, -0.03655043989419937, 0.08444489538669586, -0.02188252843916416, 0.002154188696295023, -0.0046522547490894794, 0.03649595379829407, -0.01797410286962986, -0.000020362022041808814, 0.06263676285743713, -0.04045714810490608, -0.01427733339369297, -0.034038178622722626, 0.015171030536293983, -0.04971852898597717, -0.0133334556594491, -0.05584059655666351, -0.018764346837997437, 0.026418600231409073, 0.039585139602422714, 0.038063179701566696, 0.013439591974020004, -0.01567854918539524, 0.04992843046784401, -0.031834136694669724, 0.01761944778263569, -0.032167911529541016, -0.05668282136321068, 0.04873260483145714, -0.03277948871254921, -0.01614052802324295, -0.06249186396598816, 0.012742245569825172, 0.06937912106513977, -0.03937752544879913, -0.05088035762310028, 0.016640929505228996, 0.05389450117945671, 0.04094964638352394, 0.030933042988181114, 0.06034351885318756, -0.08328215777873993, 0.03874867409467697, -0.049752965569496155, 0.01844843290746212, -0.04447685554623604, -0.05507781729102135, 0.013347354717552662, 0.0016150783048942685, -0.02101321704685688, -0.01826845109462738, 0.0028664080891758204, -0.06792008876800537, -0.05198090523481369, -0.028019068762660027, 0.010332922451198101, -0.010242604650557041, 0.04898497834801674, 0.043441131711006165, -0.007940717041492462, 0.027450835332274437, -0.0445738211274147, -0.03306860849261284, -0.07985273748636246, 0.05100615322589874, -0.03488453850150108, 0.008958839811384678, -0.026629311963915825, 0.04489920288324356, 0.033183082938194275, 0.040848053991794586, 0.02379639819264412, 0.0006069657392799854, -0.012774018570780754, -0.06261899322271347, -0.01878613978624344, -0.017592573538422585, -0.002499455353245139, 0.05351046845316887, -0.043063677847385406, -0.04321138933300972, -0.028509952127933502, -0.0015247046248987317, 0.023257005959749222, 0.01773938722908497, 0.00915675237774849, 0.022485356777906418, -0.007957044057548046, -0.04302622377872467, -0.013002309016883373, 0.0892726480960846, 0.00040488794911652803, -0.01495015062391758, -0.02707255631685257, -0.020932309329509735, -0.045423101633787155, 0.039163097739219666, 0.008433109149336815, -0.05274539068341255, 0.02384040877223015, 0.002556024817749858, 0.02101890742778778, 0.02627050131559372, -0.09150221198797226, -0.008163917809724808, 0.02952195517718792, -0.10071344673633575, 0.05966276302933693, -0.0707683190703392, -0.026376500725746155, -0.010675664059817791, -0.009424909949302673, -0.03438115492463112, -0.00791921280324459, -0.022896405309438705, 0.03157182037830353, -0.007236992474645376, -0.04420353099703789, -0.01904536969959736, -0.007897994481027126, 0.004541801288723946, 0.008476261980831623, -0.056350816041231155, 0.03063337132334709, 0.026617754250764847, -0.06615899503231049, -0.09642461687326431, -0.005457648076117039, -0.02325429767370224, -0.02054985985159874, 0.024906126782298088, -0.00633558165282011, 0.030885564163327217, 0.05827564746141434, 0.020777853205800056, 0.027082284912467003, -0.003027167869731784, -0.0023981842678040266, 0.0165848508477211, 0.025301404297351837, 0.018237153068184853, 0.04310724884271622, -0.06693311780691147, -0.043621405959129333, 0.04106389358639717, -0.03006817027926445, 0.01635325886309147, 0.03740750998258591, 0.0028328716289252043, 0.02768021449446678, -0.02834317646920681, 0.009594559669494629, 0.06778376549482346, -0.003082413924857974, -0.00181410217192024, 0.006419462617486715, -0.031702302396297455, -0.002152017317712307, 0.015620552934706211, -0.04810724034905434, 0.0059226867742836475, -0.09636634588241577, 0.05221690237522125, -0.0036831742618232965, 0.023226439952850342, 0.005398288834840059, 0.017856035381555557, 0.010858933441340923, 0.0096359271556139, -0.023356053978204727, -0.0011629872024059296, -0.008811349980533123, -0.016152407974004745, 0.09148205071687698, 0.03234752640128136, -0.08378355950117111, -0.011124512180685997, 0.0770016461610794, 0.032321445643901825, -0.022314609959721565, -0.06934697180986404, 0.011390695348381996, 0.07376182079315186, 0.032503772526979446, -0.00014825904509052634, 0.0840916633605957, -0.06492962688207626, -0.05711446702480316, -0.044732023030519485, -0.05135669931769371, 0.006332166958600283, 0.02748749405145645, -0.009297573938965797, -0.031015416607260704, 0.035143814980983734, -0.01624767668545246, -0.011568446643650532, 0.013773414306342602, 0.02272688038647175, -0.02902325615286827, -0.045916810631752014, 0.04463570937514305, -0.0015457500703632832, -0.027601057663559914, -0.01891343854367733, -0.06679530441761017, 0.014630096964538097, 0.007932337000966072, -0.034729283303022385, 0.01553322933614254, -0.015665646642446518, -0.003457039827480912, 0.049727123230695724, 0.01545488927513361, 0.008450746536254883, 0.045211248099803925, -0.03487977758049965, -0.018465394154191017, 0.01144969742745161, -0.023946549743413925, -0.010273616760969162, -0.028775466606020927, 0.016477977856993675, 0.040435388684272766, -0.050123102962970734, 0.026249729096889496, 0.10388729721307755, 0.009342738427221775, 0.023849129676818848, -0.032913558185100555, -0.020648030564188957, 0.008678141981363297, 0.02733025699853897, 0.07687496393918991, -0.002804697025567293, -0.04649423435330391, -0.03057210147380829, 0.007582932710647583, 0.0067053590901196, 0.04792023077607155, -0.0012760001700371504, 0.009629623033106327, -0.0428977906703949, -0.016001557931303978, -0.08456293493509293, -0.012045694515109062, -0.024533430114388466, 0.0720018595457077, -0.004495111294090748, -0.040099870413541794, 0.03415238857269287, -0.017558323219418526, -0.048832423985004425, 0.03443010151386261, 0.034525975584983826, -0.038899023085832596, 0.05145472660660744, -0.03778062388300896, -0.056680966168642044, -0.02983352728188038, 0.11773624271154404, -0.050452448427677155, 0.0028662411496043205, 0.0048772068694233894, 0.03218803182244301, -0.0150651466101408, 0.05619916692376137, -0.01850830391049385, -0.005448253359645605, 0.01858506165444851, 0.04077407717704773, -0.01937994547188282, 0.020107809454202652, 0.017361069098114967, 0.05962842330336571, -0.014865200035274029, -0.03181839361786842, -0.04706672951579094, 0.07722638547420502, 0.006618086248636246, 0.05373380705714226, 0.03175768256187439, -0.004180774558335543, 0.010268431156873703, -0.022969838231801987, 0.038620732724666595, 0.0008459321688860655, 0.06107576563954353, -0.015511933714151382, -0.03855539858341217, -0.03660931438207626, -0.012097758240997791, -0.030079759657382965, -0.05318550765514374, 0.029123814776539803 ]
<p>I have data from a set of sensors, and would like to measure similarity between two samples of data ignoring local fluctuations.</p> <p>My problem is, my sensors are not regularly placed : some are quite alone, others are many in the same area, there is no regular pattern in their locations.</p> <p>I want to measure similarity in terms of large scale, local fluctuations (even of high amplitude) are much less important as long as they are balanced by other nearby fluctuations.</p> <p>I though about computing average values of a point and its neighbours, and making my indicator as the sum of absolute value of differences between the local averages of my two samples, but I have not idea whether it's a good approach or not.</p>
g74296
[ -0.017122499644756317, -0.058234792202711105, -0.012852084822952747, -0.058001164346933365, -0.023448824882507324, -0.01729729399085045, 0.02970953844487667, -0.01888992451131344, -0.024914108216762543, -0.01429344154894352, 0.025717899203300476, 0.014361172914505005, 0.03876488655805588, 0.0030730965081602335, -0.046242181211709976, 0.018309907987713814, -0.01046636700630188, -0.02111751027405262, 0.024975715205073357, 0.009318871423602104, -0.004841736983507872, 0.043893031775951385, 0.04565226659178734, -0.018493175506591797, 0.0010431383270770311, -0.03980522230267525, 0.014270396903157234, -0.021931666880846024, -0.04415927082300186, 0.04483911022543907, 0.007252768613398075, -0.00655424315482378, 0.05138644203543663, 0.00150130910333246, -0.01693747006356716, -0.009078297764062881, -0.03687896206974983, 0.019235210493206978, -0.009407839737832546, 0.02630457654595375, 0.022074345499277115, 0.03924061357975006, 0.051543910056352615, -0.002214607549831271, 0.0192011296749115, -0.02035580202937126, -0.03113698586821556, -0.0377301387488842, 0.005813403055071831, -0.023233044892549515, -0.00810502003878355, 0.002739953575655818, 0.0033544821199029684, 0.01506903488188982, 0.05532950162887573, 0.075772225856781, 0.029076652601361275, 0.03921369090676308, 0.04674803093075752, -0.024467410519719124, 0.06564181298017502, -0.019488295540213585, -0.035508669912815094, 0.03962979093194008, -0.026672199368476868, 0.0557125061750412, -0.05443691089749336, -0.01558048278093338, 0.0026814292650669813, 0.0054479679092764854, -0.039331018924713135, 0.02488536760210991, 0.0031111326534301043, 0.01101832464337349, -0.061298515647649765, 0.033217836171388626, -0.018416628241539, 0.028990454971790314, 0.003342704614624381, 0.05376892536878586, -0.04658947512507439, -0.02549223229289055, 0.04193560779094696, 0.03698113188147545, 0.037219420075416565, -0.0067979153245687485, 0.029495200142264366, 0.03214888274669647, -0.0003644404641818255, 0.03467985615134239, -0.008724791929125786, -0.0023336131125688553, 0.032317787408828735, 0.029413949698209763, -0.003477731253951788, -0.003171372227370739, -0.02396431937813759, 0.04463214799761772, -0.07989185303449631, 0.016309909522533417, 0.0011124579468742013, 0.05064551159739494, 0.01053360290825367, 0.045879390090703964, -0.03818066790699959, -0.03623582795262337, 0.037997160106897354, -0.017786692827939987, -0.005470901262015104, 0.011787314899265766, 0.02738117054104805, -0.06796050816774368, -0.02161123976111412, -0.040615618228912354, -0.01998990774154663, 0.020409109070897102, 0.058325886726379395, -0.014315255917608738, -0.03224492445588112, 0.0032599593978375196, 0.035187728703022, 0.008442401885986328, 0.032371699810028076, 0.04849882796406746, 0.0508439876139164, 0.04508645832538605, 0.04970833659172058, 0.04316333308815956, 0.044055141508579254, -0.018121493980288506, 0.02927262894809246, -0.05329921841621399, -0.008772236295044422, 0.0022098456975072622, -0.0014177355915307999, 0.0008977577672339976, 0.02159625105559826, 0.024997804313898087, 0.017424268648028374, 0.028759734705090523, -0.07012733072042465, 0.016039758920669556, -0.00862431526184082, 0.013853345066308975, 0.020349815487861633, 0.0011982772266492248, -0.02350754104554653, -0.06408967822790146, 0.024425139650702477, 0.0007685631280764937, 0.05147159844636917, 0.05864940211176872, 0.006018709857016802, -0.025999410077929497, -0.06194664165377617, 0.020692884922027588, -0.04340951889753342, 0.046871013939380646, 0.018250485882163048, -0.019862812012434006, -0.007998953573405743, -0.09378182888031006, 0.05630272254347801, -0.001656506210565567, 0.07225513458251953, 0.012948551215231419, -0.0010321204317733645, 0.005257704295217991, 0.004070785362273455, 0.0021137772127985954, -0.003023748518899083, 0.005407376680523157, 0.04680252447724342, -0.04999474436044693, 0.01490356307476759, 0.03417292609810829, -0.023567592725157738, -0.04271892085671425, 0.02723260596394539, -0.01155366562306881, -0.005470880772918463, 0.023879975080490112, 0.0007411291589960456, -0.07279127091169357, 0.020336318761110306, -0.00042737225885502994, 0.0049436516128480434, -0.041695091873407364, -0.0394427664577961, 0.04823039844632149, -0.010802317410707474, -0.04029448330402374, -0.06439758837223053, 0.032792262732982635, -0.003206135705113411, 0.01585821807384491, 0.05472199246287346, -0.01803155057132244, -0.04701346158981323, 0.01820221170783043, 0.017465267330408096, -0.02309039980173111, 0.03387763723731041, 0.02327321656048298, 0.03452936187386513, 0.03513282537460327, -0.019724972546100616, -0.032501865178346634, -0.033927492797374725, -0.0033725497778505087, -0.005345222540199757, -0.039301548153162, -0.04819674417376518, 0.007071040570735931, -0.011653399094939232, 0.032349444925785065, 0.002690304070711136, 0.002548361662775278, 0.02318260632455349, -0.0034814791288226843, -0.02225479669868946, -0.0006479898584075272, 0.05411059781908989, -0.04656136408448219, -0.02061324194073677, -0.0033824946731328964, 0.03820153698325157, 0.07284820824861526, -0.006268044002354145, -0.0294173713773489, -0.03415500745177269, -0.0422828234732151, 0.023584239184856415, -0.016602231189608574, 0.021869845688343048, 0.007952647283673286, -0.024404393509030342, 0.03301382064819336, -0.00013613360351882875, -0.034036677330732346, 0.023209890350699425, -0.05816304683685303, -0.03119363822042942, 0.017340293154120445, 0.028919363394379616, 0.03153267502784729, 0.01208003144711256, 0.060947541147470474, 0.010563401505351067, -0.006318769883364439, -0.016092509031295776, 0.052959639579057693, 0.02368745766580105, -0.01818103715777397, 0.04150976985692978, -0.07929151505231857, 0.08146973699331284, -0.02068287320435047, 0.049826573580503464, 0.003048754995688796, -0.03277365863323212, -0.00991814024746418, 0.044602032750844955, 0.011847134679555893, -0.0035924005787819624, -0.0314774215221405, 0.05693701654672623, 0.038280900567770004, -0.0004687048785854131, -0.008613310754299164, 0.024861125275492668, -0.0060809943825006485, 0.043251119554042816, 0.10107448697090149, -0.030563246458768845, 0.06511073559522629, 0.01659688912332058, -0.025303859263658524, 0.04754263535141945, 0.013912253081798553, 0.029367845505475998, -0.0012100201565772295, 0.0025980346836149693, -0.012497656978666782, 0.022303158417344093, -0.0013956844341009855, 0.05733708292245865, 0.017913369461894035, 0.016078900545835495, 0.04454493895173073, -0.01243167370557785, -0.020818224176764488, 0.010051323100924492, 0.02682683989405632, -0.04742557555437088, 0.02262517809867859, 0.055855195969343185, -0.012171135284006596, 0.015930069610476494, 0.023734282702207565, -0.011956365779042244, -0.025025146082043648, 0.009775751270353794, -0.015317179262638092, 0.08882281929254532, -0.008256177417933941, -0.03341375291347504, -0.043980129063129425, -0.007060043513774872, 0.007961568422615528, 0.021074537187814713, -0.06459565460681915, -0.016147004440426826, -0.017885519191622734, 0.011471953243017197, 0.028106248006224632, -0.002417067065834999, 0.04814337193965912, -0.0455298088490963, -0.03980005159974098, 0.043330300599336624, -0.06021054461598396, 0.003402771195396781, 0.03528417646884918, 0.03466351702809334, 0.04242238774895668, -0.01710488088428974, 0.053311873227357864, -0.04719652980566025, -0.021314067766070366, -0.014152437448501587, 0.005562282633036375, -0.0009913826361298561, -0.04260309413075447, -0.05868297442793846, -0.061625540256500244, 0.006148410029709339, -0.03487168624997139, 0.0022577254567295313, 0.04068155586719513, -0.024861546233296394, -0.03679824247956276, -0.026704935356974602, -0.0818854495882988, -0.038816336542367935, 0.009303132072091103, 0.057007741183042526, -0.03393688052892685, 0.01718030869960785, -0.03281760588288307, 0.026687849313020706, 0.004155377391725779, 0.03992675989866257, -0.011400342918932438, 0.00845280196517706, -0.03763757646083832, -0.0036440861877053976, -0.06044342368841171, 0.005681637208908796, -0.014563391916453838, 0.07732173800468445, -0.01655038818717003, -0.029857734218239784, -0.013747809454798698, -0.07078156620264053, -0.027520831674337387, -0.008321712724864483, 0.025356963276863098, 0.020427532494068146, -0.046215951442718506, 0.0004426748782861978, 0.06416820734739304, -0.029701605439186096, -0.02753225341439247, 0.058782923966646194, -0.048709992319345474, 0.05456233397126198, -0.0004942924133501947, -0.023152025416493416, 0.039532870054244995, -0.013420305214822292, 0.02763756737112999, -0.0851598009467125, -0.08616769313812256, 0.043828725814819336, -0.04478885605931282, -0.01726384647190571, 0.04181947559118271, 0.01655627228319645, -0.04764137789607048, 0.009810293093323708, -0.11270752549171448, -0.05420619249343872, 0.020190415903925896, 0.02120182290673256, -0.05165441706776619, -0.013597995042800903, 0.04291712865233421, 0.008546770550310612, 0.05776282772421837, 0.01608925871551037, -0.03494938090443611, 0.009335383772850037, 0.004037865903228521, -0.0074579291976988316, -0.07209771126508713, 0.003643541596829891, 0.016562508419156075, -0.01815822906792164, -0.013642779551446438, -0.02863292582333088, 0.014745155349373817, 0.05850004032254219, -0.07119540870189667, 0.0033942903392016888, -0.03059433214366436, 0.02346428669989109, -0.020784787833690643, 0.07252576947212219, 0.00870292168110609, -0.0624207928776741, 0.08001323789358139, -0.017238058149814606, -0.011153105646371841, 0.013824486173689365, 0.021183159202337265, -0.01670043356716633, 0.05922524631023407, -0.0072059109807014465, -0.014069783501327038, -0.007066075224429369, 0.008522121235728264, 0.02340407855808735, 0.023251984268426895, 0.010595428757369518, -0.026925040408968925, -0.02691666968166828, 0.011626619845628738, 0.006207653321325779, -0.06668922305107117, -0.05307033658027649, 0.038964223116636276, 0.004758463241159916, 0.04173365607857704, -0.011301834136247635, 0.09401560574769974, -0.048176877200603485, 0.039723124355077744, 0.016891594976186752, 0.05966952443122864, -0.009181633591651917, 0.03159958869218826, -0.008416591212153435, -0.021191611886024475, -0.02680763602256775, 0.021353891119360924, 0.027142252773046494, 0.029374463483691216, 0.02274608053267002, 0.012617920525372028, 0.025238068774342537, 0.01058977097272873, -0.09854734688997269, -0.035173434764146805, 0.012307681143283844, -0.007194892503321171, -0.07356499135494232, 0.0018013063818216324, -0.004510420840233564, -0.06614736467599869, 0.044003479182720184, -0.02705639787018299, 0.030930712819099426, -0.01804378628730774, 0.02019553631544113, -0.0038334091659635305, -0.010475230403244495, -0.03435497358441353, -0.000518098589964211, -0.0023196255788207054, -0.04306187853217125, -0.03393189609050751, 0.0697457492351532, 0.03169449418783188, 0.03542004153132439, -0.05235155671834946, -0.0157833993434906, -0.02728034369647503, 0.05896555632352829, -0.02717171423137188, 0.008004897274076939, 0.022706758230924606, 0.07769451290369034, 0.05506964772939682, 0.02353835478425026, -0.05904284864664078, -0.011869411915540695, 0.017274629324674606, -0.07089035958051682, -0.03094354085624218, -0.02015015110373497, 0.0802212581038475, -0.028909683227539062, -0.0021226864773780107, -0.019966714084148407, -0.007536804769188166, 0.01671011745929718, -0.02436857670545578, 0.04590115696191788, 0.08284644037485123, -0.020716480910778046, -0.004745783284306526, 0.025394108146429062, -0.002891011070460081, -0.044639475643634796, 0.024694520980119705, 0.036042023450136185, -0.00010626891889842227, -0.05674515292048454, -0.0883089080452919, 0.0391990952193737, -0.01728704199194908, -0.03183143585920334, 0.013088202103972435, 0.07090374827384949, -0.06235125660896301, -0.07647261023521423, -0.012760970741510391, -0.03142692521214485, -0.045303016901016235, 0.00008076780795818195, 0.02777201682329178, -0.04215385019779205, -0.02362672984600067, 0.012312011793255806, -0.022027064114809036, -0.04194030165672302, 0.007255083415657282, -0.009470032528042793, -0.0017649801447987556, 0.0017082082340493798, -0.016766952350735664, 0.035743243992328644, -0.0360427126288414, -0.018836790695786476, -0.02723677270114422, -0.004371128045022488, -0.07548203319311142, 0.037766654044389725, 0.04878142103552818, -0.022944651544094086, 0.030793221667408943, 0.04757526144385338, -0.020221468061208725, -0.030901998281478882, -0.0044623068533837795, -0.008469640277326107, -0.007664941716939211, 0.0035534913185983896, 0.02336154878139496, 0.0416799932718277, -0.020095277577638626, 0.019163981080055237, 0.022707369178533554, -0.017742568626999855, 0.01263505220413208, -0.019444433972239494, 0.0029885994736105204, 0.014296237379312515, 0.014488850720226765, 0.024334080517292023, -0.0276652742177248, 0.04449349269270897, -0.03183870017528534, 0.02387317270040512, -0.0023507641162723303, -0.033044204115867615, 0.01899595931172371, 0.05644316226243973, -0.015026241540908813, -0.047489602118730545, 0.040978699922561646, 0.009324643760919571, -0.0038251078221946955, -0.0323362834751606, 0.013989840634167194, -0.050289448350667953, 0.01220437977463007, 0.016225282102823257, -0.06386049836874008, 0.004904663655906916, -0.03137848526239395, -0.017147909849882126, -0.020327186211943626, 0.022195320576429367, -0.05149118974804878, 0.02140517346560955, 0.004985644482076168, -0.010510965250432491, 0.02567053958773613, 0.03776226565241814, -0.07129788398742676, 0.07092354446649551, -0.04556858167052269, -0.0465475395321846, 0.013001685962080956, 0.00263297650963068, -0.021869074553251266, -0.054444506764411926, 0.010254193097352982, -0.019806472584605217, 0.049183692783117294, 0.045920178294181824, 0.04670447111129761, -0.0198640376329422, -0.023135686293244362, -0.018854884430766106, -0.0047316644340753555, -0.07186663150787354, 0.005813442170619965, 0.008537126705050468, 0.022580761462450027, -0.03949945047497749, 0.04740408807992935, 0.011520336382091045, 0.08014612644910812, 0.0024283563252538443, 0.039394013583660126, 0.03478126972913742, 0.0006737850490026176, 0.008103172294795513, 0.03658602759242058, 0.029057517647743225, -0.014749693684279919, -0.04556373506784439, 0.048838060349226, -0.05576350539922714, 0.0810413733124733, -0.0006580202607437968, 0.05941149592399597, -0.020906247198581696, 0.03840002790093422, 0.031917158514261246, 0.024547861889004707, -0.015178789384663105, -0.021436626091599464, 0.04227235168218613, 0.03977585583925247, -0.025713006034493446, 0.04489976540207863, -0.01738784648478031, 0.03758247196674347, -0.002564553637057543, -0.014140792191028595, 0.027308935299515724, 0.06327391415834427, 0.060688525438308716, -0.005634444300085306, 0.046484313905239105, -0.019087715074419975, -0.0406096950173378, -0.057747237384319305, -0.016456732526421547, -0.03670182824134827, -0.01333751529455185, 0.07699316740036011, -0.006312417797744274, -0.053897518664598465, -0.00898057408630848, -0.06162311136722565, 0.019468240439891815, -0.08106392621994019, -0.0032356884330511093, 0.04280342906713486, 0.00389050948433578, -0.010829639621078968, -0.011912987567484379, -0.020404430106282234, -0.03103780746459961, -0.02424141764640808, 0.04351679980754852, -0.07037024199962616, 0.007249599322676659, 0.023657213896512985, -0.017415571957826614, 0.0745103731751442, -0.03849732503294945, -0.009916870854794979, 0.04906090348958969, -0.06739051640033722, -0.034470297396183014, -0.007294359616935253, 0.03097383864223957, -0.030998043715953827, -0.0362154096364975, 0.031818803399801254, -0.014235536567866802, 0.02229347638785839, 0.012747218832373619, -0.02052263729274273, -0.007505173794925213, 0.0579925961792469, -0.001853007124736905, -0.034069497138261795, -0.009822515770792961, -0.047314319759607315, 0.01683153212070465, -0.03508341312408447, 0.00828826054930687, -0.00872803945094347, 0.027736112475395203, 0.06261460483074188, 0.016165880486369133, -0.025693466886878014, -0.026065422222018242, -0.05857466906309128, -0.07430340349674225, -0.049386292695999146, -0.024002008140087128, 0.00839689839631319, -0.04951254650950432, -0.01849932037293911, 0.04440950229763985, -0.07611044496297836, -0.02523103915154934, -0.015067039988934994, 0.06866349279880524, 0.011779998429119587, 0.0440087765455246, -0.023417538031935692, -0.02731054276227951, 0.0025867093354463577, -0.07590193301439285, 0.013116390444338322, -0.05092877522110939, -0.005738423205912113, 0.05452672764658928, 0.03678999841213226, -0.065449059009552, -0.030783621594309807, -0.03444372117519379, -0.014337504282593727, 0.05117681249976158, -0.003091094084084034, -0.006580273155122995, 0.01580425165593624, -0.015850761905312538, -0.01036289893090725, -0.004071135073900223, -0.09268206357955933, -0.019515760242938995, 0.01113066729158163, -0.02955416962504387, 0.02240588515996933, 0.03514816612005234, 0.03433287888765335, 0.05105365812778473, -0.02112807147204876, 0.000998624018393457, -0.05459084361791611, -0.0246574804186821, -0.02254476025700569, -0.0839831680059433, 0.055137213319540024, -0.0025706603191792965, 0.009254955686628819, 0.012538152746856213, 0.027327394112944603 ]
<p>In <a href="http://surveyanalysis.org/wiki/Multiple_Comparisons_%28Post_Hoc_Testing%29" rel="nofollow">http://surveyanalysis.org/wiki/Multiple_Comparisons_(Post_Hoc_Testing)</a></p> <p>It states "For example, if we have a p-value of 0.05 and we conclude it is significant the probability of a false discovery is, by definition, 0.05."</p> <p>My question: I always thought false discovery is Type I error, which is equal to the chosen significance levels in most tests. p-value is the value calculated from the samples. Indeed Wikipedia states "The p-value should not be confused with the significance level α in the Neyman–Pearson approach or the Type I error rate [false positive rate]"</p> <p>So why the statistician in the link claims Type I error is also the p-value?</p>
g74297
[ 0.04006221890449524, 0.010208817198872566, -0.024454466998577118, -0.00494542857632041, 0.04389045387506485, -0.020435946062207222, 0.040418945252895355, 0.01162939053028822, -0.048822492361068726, -0.024127714335918427, -0.005055401008576155, -0.03658469393849373, 0.023006653413176537, 0.03734162077307701, -0.014672418124973774, -0.030397159978747368, 0.06489992141723633, -0.02513706497848034, 0.02320670336484909, 0.016862908378243446, -0.056022558361291885, -0.015100181102752686, -0.0632438138127327, -0.022175172343850136, 0.0060786050744354725, -0.03653467074036598, -0.029462803155183792, 0.0028821220621466637, -0.08920767903327942, 0.005526915192604065, -0.007671988103538752, -0.03369313105940819, 0.08270660787820816, -0.008132241666316986, -0.041252780705690384, -0.005265954416245222, 0.03392844274640083, 0.020208243280649185, 0.02414640784263611, 0.018952175974845886, -0.03535497561097145, 0.02849339321255684, 0.019399620592594147, -0.005164694972336292, -0.038112182170152664, 0.05149943009018898, -0.010813203640282154, 0.031081579625606537, 0.06509442627429962, -0.020179854705929756, 0.07854980230331421, 0.021977106109261513, 0.05694238841533661, 0.02828875556588173, 0.06169590726494789, 0.02196718193590641, 0.023458577692508698, 0.012569881975650787, -0.006230490282177925, -0.005148143973201513, 0.029791880398988724, 0.0473572313785553, -0.034409862011671066, 0.010234866291284561, 0.034422360360622406, -0.0021988144144415855, 0.021674038842320442, 0.011206735856831074, 0.0004663163563236594, -0.019820686429739, -0.027119167149066925, -0.04375852271914482, 0.027656536549329758, -0.01950851082801819, -0.014204896986484528, 0.012729148380458355, 0.016962289810180664, -0.03825044631958008, 0.015296711586415768, -0.02132098749279976, 0.031662505120038986, -0.03317343816161156, -0.0014062608825042844, 0.08143758028745651, 0.04643690213561058, -0.004120713099837303, 0.00633489154279232, -0.007259828969836235, 0.00852539949119091, -0.010026630945503712, 0.035769443958997726, 0.011972305364906788, 0.027712015435099602, 0.04206745699048042, -0.014454755000770092, -0.008585864678025246, -0.016172798350453377, 0.020161226391792297, 0.02580977976322174, 0.009564886800944805, -0.011933264322578907, -0.01752360351383686, -0.012535810470581055, -0.015441475436091423, -0.057435352355241776, 0.05433826893568039, -0.01077417191118002, 0.04873093590140343, -0.04314345493912697, -0.03369365260004997, -0.006333448458462954, 0.0003285523853264749, -0.039260946214199066, -0.005610539112240076, -0.07639451324939728, -0.0254009198397398, 0.019832337275147438, 0.014774501323699951, -0.00611345749348402, -0.000849407515488565, 0.0011361067881807685, 0.009834717027842999, 0.042068324983119965, 0.09740385413169861, -0.04562961682677269, -0.05490624159574509, -0.01281978003680706, 0.02021755464375019, -0.0005912530468776822, -0.010744001716375351, -0.042760126292705536, -0.035788409411907196, 0.0038705826736986637, 0.0188694279640913, 0.017257504165172577, 0.022189447656273842, -0.008645937778055668, 0.019708557054400444, -0.027552912011742592, 0.0027938091661781073, -0.06959477066993713, 0.005377832800149918, 0.044908490031957626, -0.03221343457698822, 0.008259382098913193, 0.02246667817234993, 0.010410293936729431, 0.0015686774859204888, 0.0020835280884057283, 0.009273850359022617, 0.0017705673817545176, 0.0541875846683979, 0.005223400425165892, -0.008593241684138775, -0.05752292275428772, -0.00013690679043065757, 0.0013644888531416655, 0.07050755620002747, -0.02580913156270981, -0.009771826677024364, 0.049673572182655334, -0.02864987589418888, 0.004922538995742798, 0.04574054852128029, 0.06498842686414719, 0.03858516365289688, 0.008939065039157867, -0.05266965925693512, -0.03234396129846573, -0.03718343749642372, 0.0258491113781929, -0.0028716339729726315, 0.03885969519615173, -0.036778900772333145, 0.005590344779193401, -0.002398766577243805, 0.02255372144281864, -0.037452563643455505, 0.028912847861647606, 0.01588488183915615, -0.028965065255761147, -0.02927444316446781, -0.031244534999132156, -0.01759084314107895, -0.011177025735378265, -0.019600210711359978, 0.0034656140487641096, 0.01116720400750637, 0.02133060060441494, 0.02850348688662052, -0.09287229925394058, -0.057934876531362534, -0.042635027319192886, 0.00932092871516943, -0.00525716133415699, 0.017027636989951134, -0.01972479186952114, -0.06870270520448685, -0.050043653696775436, -0.021308500319719315, 0.029458334669470787, 0.013060638681054115, -0.03796662017703056, -0.00891209114342928, -0.058655090630054474, 0.00977378524839878, -0.0031613900791853666, 0.01489153690636158, -0.04725421965122223, 0.036910224705934525, -0.02501111850142479, -0.02441982924938202, -0.012437678873538971, 0.06648822128772736, 0.010728725232183933, 0.02090652659535408, -0.01114672888070345, 0.06640994548797607, -0.0013286254834383726, -0.04896748065948486, 0.02919330820441246, -0.0063591934740543365, 0.07379551231861115, -0.018095767125487328, -0.01353482622653246, 0.06051672250032425, 0.02643953450024128, -0.060254089534282684, -0.018370673060417175, -0.021398382261395454, 0.014919780194759369, -0.04635993018746376, -0.07247097045183182, 0.037158720195293427, 0.02121542952954769, 0.030194805935025215, 0.027978701516985893, -0.03462207689881325, -0.02068789303302765, -0.0070016048848629, -0.058777403086423874, -0.01540331356227398, -0.006773278117179871, 0.03696497902274132, -0.01718076691031456, -0.030184371396899223, 0.018138278275728226, -0.07252787798643112, -0.014611170627176762, 0.11113487929105759, -0.007910232990980148, -0.022212063893675804, 0.025015240535140038, 0.01901991292834282, -0.006344244349747896, -0.027654727920889854, 0.050330497324466705, -0.013462521135807037, 0.008274302817881107, 0.03370938077569008, 0.015605980530381203, -0.06566177308559418, 0.0304902084171772, -0.02258036471903324, 0.01944097690284252, -0.0033787416759878397, -0.01987694762647152, -0.03746921569108963, -0.04750685766339302, -0.018281960859894753, -0.04355064406991005, 0.01080330740660429, 0.013887191191315651, 0.0008006253046914935, 0.0576532743871212, 0.01634146086871624, -0.025105636566877365, 0.004816172178834677, 0.031853001564741135, -0.03256231173872948, -0.03652617707848549, 0.018223170191049576, -0.021827826276421547, 0.0028175367042422295, 0.025556549429893494, -0.021501770243048668, 0.0385984443128109, -0.017743965610861778, -0.029383860528469086, 0.0231337770819664, 0.022853128612041473, -0.017428165301680565, -0.011301634833216667, -0.0037684624549001455, 0.057191234081983566, 0.02427196502685547, 0.05524362996220589, -0.07689159363508224, 0.03845337778329849, -0.0029064095579087734, -0.0067163859494030476, -0.01540455687791109, 0.022404851391911507, 0.0329652838408947, 0.09042549133300781, 0.0022848935332149267, -0.022926125675439835, -0.03117237240076065, -0.0064738900400698185, 0.04758187755942345, -0.05511509254574776, 0.030974866822361946, 0.016955817118287086, -0.07196327298879623, 0.03259335085749626, 0.03628166764974594, 0.02924833819270134, 0.04544785991311073, 0.00938087422400713, -0.044232212007045746, -0.04187668114900589, -0.021111177280545235, -0.04251541569828987, 0.03869876638054848, -0.015726305544376373, -0.004779518581926823, 0.013639281503856182, 0.008399258367717266, -0.006439178250730038, -0.023682910948991776, 0.08457046002149582, 0.02747928909957409, -0.032110489904880524, -0.008564169518649578, -0.029422428458929062, -0.039824821054935455, 0.01930166222155094, 0.0198946725577116, -0.025930915027856827, 0.02532469853758812, 0.0058885542675852776, -0.011971459724009037, 0.009458613581955433, -0.021945996209979057, 0.03601495921611786, -0.05726900324225426, 0.015850475057959557, 0.031001528725028038, 0.010177066549658775, 0.014921894297003746, 0.05071016773581505, 0.016129305586218834, 0.002302376786246896, -0.03727108985185623, -0.0013420662144199014, 0.048694219440221786, 0.043591681867837906, -0.024605218321084976, -0.012263630516827106, 0.024914611130952835, 0.057004209607839584, 0.024764882400631905, 0.016655031591653824, 0.035948898643255234, -0.010176531970500946, 0.03532271459698677, 0.0012783999554812908, 0.023447386920452118, 0.061448920518159866, -0.057647425681352615, 0.029680605977773666, 0.006791658233851194, 0.03717370331287384, -0.045814886689186096, 0.020264916121959686, -0.043614987283945084, -0.014399467036128044, 0.033207204192876816, -0.006833948660641909, 0.05352337285876274, 0.036832936108112335, 0.019917257130146027, -0.02639649249613285, -0.0038814584258943796, 0.07689586281776428, -0.021710798144340515, -0.03605002164840698, -0.026460224762558937, -0.004175873938947916, -0.03520304337143898, 0.020004013553261757, 0.04985819384455681, -0.06107896566390991, 0.011605062521994114, 0.02301652915775776, 0.05299000069499016, -0.030378516763448715, -0.009077705442905426, 0.05907674506306648, 0.060299184173345566, 0.014443811029195786, -0.03085774928331375, 0.04289306327700615, 0.03168259561061859, 0.05524656921625137, 0.015948625281453133, -0.007473493926227093, -0.007271669805049896, -0.03476662188768387, 0.014167333021759987, 0.016650650650262833, -0.03182824328541756, -0.00790606252849102, -0.056883618235588074, 0.025034256279468536, -0.02595393918454647, -0.0012337497901171446, -0.05764509364962578, 0.04941252991557121, 0.017491042613983154, 0.011344680562615395, 0.017461365088820457, -0.018323257565498352, -0.035290349274873734, -0.0007841280312277377, -0.01350837480276823, 0.0010011534905061126, 0.09223756194114685, 0.07115215808153152, -0.09941603988409042, 0.022139139473438263, 0.08989756554365158, -0.055131085216999054, 0.022504623979330063, -0.0098738307133317, 0.03539825975894928, 0.06345953792333603, 0.05778246000409126, -0.04390846565365791, -0.014229608699679375, 0.011263156309723854, 0.0314125120639801, -0.03743819147348404, 0.025797029957175255, 0.008572266437113285, 0.029109789058566093, -0.0485023632645607, -0.013964271172881126, -0.03280559182167053, -0.022984208539128304, -0.0670376867055893, -0.012488124892115593, -0.019138077273964882, -0.04719425365328789, 0.03827473893761635, -0.009187760762870312, -0.02390238270163536, 0.019693687558174133, 0.028493622317910194, 0.05512595921754837, -0.05147477984428406, -0.026844261214137077, -0.013711202889680862, 0.015332143753767014, 0.006860045716166496, -0.0003678546054288745, -0.0393049530684948, -0.03506172448396683, -0.026737356558442116, -0.017264097929000854, -0.043888628482818604, -0.022039737552404404, 0.028293412178754807, -0.03675595670938492, -0.010824001394212246, 0.10344311594963074, 0.019432159140706062, 0.047323718667030334, -0.036375097930431366, -0.0328296422958374, -0.02853453904390335, -0.012071623466908932, 0.011450669728219509, 0.017079228535294533, -0.021379847079515457, -0.0017229038057848811, -0.04448855295777321, -0.056630633771419525, 0.006841483525931835, -0.01766427606344223, 0.08782815933227539, 0.028994346037507057, 0.04638960212469101, -0.026995355263352394, 0.0329165905714035, -0.05935851112008095, 0.011676429770886898, 0.013318659737706184, -0.011056716553866863, -0.03866138681769371, -0.031501296907663345, -0.0010053209261968732, 0.020999116823077202, -0.04013880342245102, -0.04612945020198822, 0.009215659461915493, 0.026897158473730087, 0.004196058493107557, 0.0022254169452935457, -0.08022020012140274, 0.022732818499207497, 0.0040394701063632965, -0.003624669509008527, 0.0019952908623963594, 0.0356590561568737, 0.00564557733014226, -0.028375620022416115, 0.008298808708786964, -0.02109956182539463, 0.043925557285547256, 0.02069566212594509, 0.013421406969428062, 0.006208681035786867, 0.036348868161439896, 0.022801237180829048, -0.05137653648853302, 0.007473640143871307, -0.06959651410579681, 0.016289478167891502, -0.01625426858663559, -0.02913050726056099, 0.011575696058571339, 0.10638130456209183, 0.06665736436843872, 0.06206551566720009, -0.02229798398911953, -0.014805159531533718, -0.009601052850484848, 0.0039991093799471855, 0.015410063788294792, -0.0426681712269783, -0.02293790690600872, -0.0010338261490687728, -0.03622259199619293, 0.06380193680524826, -0.002322184620425105, -0.00362503994256258, -0.0020784432999789715, 0.008121659979224205, -0.07635995745658875, -0.006246638018637896, 0.0033383462578058243, -0.02022530697286129, -0.05768197029829025, -0.027598129585385323, -0.02565690129995346, 0.0019212234765291214, 0.04027381166815758, -0.007937825284898281, -0.01615629717707634, -0.01749148592352867, -0.07335769385099411, -0.061548590660095215, 0.03400098532438278, -0.0047121429815888405, 0.0031983519438654184, -0.06375135481357574, -0.036457691341638565, -0.021912120282649994, -0.0436997152864933, -0.013272559270262718, -0.024728555232286453, -0.0001677627005847171, -0.0102565111592412, 0.0783839300274849, 0.04253128170967102, -0.016534479334950447, -0.01239684596657753, -0.015088318847119808, -0.062134597450494766, 0.020823948085308075, -0.07966781407594681, 0.07095927000045776, -0.0010505924001336098, -0.031024307012557983, 0.011222616769373417, -0.034255251288414, -0.016975976526737213, -0.004972942639142275, -0.021361254155635834, 0.009492815472185612, -0.025808347389101982, -0.016265012323856354, 0.0030714606400579214, -0.04707833379507065, -0.06111171469092369, -0.010593459941446781, 0.01607128605246544, -0.008265317417681217, 0.0019209441961720586, 0.08386873453855515, -0.03149259090423584, 0.05769551545381546, -0.0327746719121933, 0.04947512969374657, 0.016649940982460976, 0.0013173316838219762, 0.03074014186859131, -0.019389281049370766, 0.0491449199616909, -0.053580936044454575, 0.025860590860247612, -0.0050775897689163685, -0.028403041884303093, 0.019177522510290146, -0.046896569430828094, -0.05363808572292328, -0.06504307687282562, -0.027809150516986847, 0.0009133046260103583, 0.06123385950922966, -0.003238741774111986, 0.021619973704218864, 0.020051319152116776, 0.05529273673892021, 0.061244700103998184, -0.04108051210641861, 0.028473781421780586, 0.02633950114250183, -0.02864464744925499, -0.04008317366242409, 0.0030380352400243282, 0.013634707778692245, 0.09215597808361053, -0.09157317876815796, -0.03962595388293266, -0.02812153846025467, 0.044412922114133835, 0.03917163237929344, 0.06003274396061897, -0.060031987726688385, 0.06318021565675735, -0.001505527412518859, -0.0631256252527237, 0.0315413661301136, 0.00013929058331996202, 0.028163312003016472, -0.013730545528233051, -0.10528717935085297, 0.013067658059298992, 0.0298368651419878, 0.025035765022039413, 0.01670468971133232, -0.027377590537071228, 0.02963033691048622, 0.05072937533259392, 0.08421094715595245, 0.09025586396455765, 0.048754915595054626, -0.07908130437135696, 0.012748769484460354, 0.030157161876559258, -0.02530071698129177, 0.010289809666574001, 0.016251908615231514, 0.013136179186403751, -0.028226429596543312, -0.0661410242319107, 0.02092484012246132, 0.0041231997311115265, 0.048922233283519745, -0.003503480926156044, -0.06319256126880646, 0.002339667407795787, -0.05331381410360336, 0.004403069149702787, -0.000869429437443614, 0.04284059256315231, -0.07075420022010803, 0.0029701555613428354, -0.048546675592660904, -0.02023516781628132, 0.007787666749209166, -0.020783858373761177, 0.017343223094940186, 0.037182584404945374, -0.03393523022532463, -0.023438014090061188, 0.03322742134332657, -0.015646303072571754, 0.02139359712600708, -0.08765851706266403, 0.029797501862049103, 0.0008158456766977906, -0.04789692163467407, 0.04950687661767006, 0.01700480841100216, 0.013106691651046276, 0.015361914411187172, 0.018162336200475693, -0.02954266406595707, -0.015191551297903061, -0.029284346848726273, 0.04974726587533951, -0.01760287955403328, -0.01086090225726366, 0.010350482538342476, 0.02471063658595085, -0.031753700226545334, -0.043193407356739044, -0.012677165679633617, 0.013308560475707054, 0.010079425759613514, 0.03374045342206955, -0.0376507043838501, -0.011980056762695312, 0.01576663739979267, -0.07089316844940186, -0.015829920768737793, -0.0314289815723896, 0.048418838530778885, -0.04339161887764931, -0.022644447162747383, 0.017284465953707695, -0.017955245450139046, -0.00652901828289032, 0.030994776636362076, 0.028053011745214462, 0.008417538367211819, 0.027807172387838364, -0.07142889499664307, -0.008503089658915997, -0.03665854036808014, 0.046829987317323685, -0.011471521109342575, -0.01614789292216301, 0.07638832181692123, 0.04315343499183655, -0.056979309767484665, 0.016152093186974525, 0.021741030737757683, -0.004961422178894281, 0.046062227338552475, 0.0026789577677845955, -0.044514574110507965, 0.0006519169546663761, -0.01864563301205635, 0.04517890885472298, -0.01679304987192154, -0.038533639162778854, 0.03544032201170921, 0.020509105175733566, -0.017815355211496353, 0.04626123234629631, -0.006359121762216091, -0.014490079134702682, -0.0029462126549333334, 0.028484830632805824, 0.044373612850904465, 0.019607676193118095, 0.050066616386175156, -0.050416000187397, -0.09076058864593506, 0.004351395182311535, -0.014773315750062466, -0.05855467915534973, -0.01566205732524395, 0.04826446995139122 ]
<p>I just used the standard formula to determine the sample size of a sample to match the mean of a pupulation with an error margin of 3 percentage points and with a 90% probability. I know would like to check that the mean of my sample is actually within the 3% margin of error of the mean in the population. To do so I am taking the population and appending the sample, identifying observations in the sample with a dummy called sample. Then I run the following regresion: reg var1 sample And I am testing wheter the coefficient for the dummy variable sample is less than 3 percentage points. To do so I am using a one sided t test.</p> <p>But this is only ok when the coefficient of the dummy variable "sample" has the "right" sign. I would like to test the joing hypoithesis that the coefficient of the dummy variable sample is greater than -3 and lower than 3. Does anyone have any insight on how to do this test? Thanks in advance.</p>
g49338
[ 0.007322774268686771, -0.0030351695604622364, -0.02195204421877861, -0.013928890228271484, 0.009746811352670193, -0.04344986379146576, 0.025208348408341408, 0.005570979323238134, -0.00735509255900979, -0.01786387339234352, 0.02638177201151848, 0.052376460283994675, -0.006046629976481199, -0.006691172253340483, 0.005762484855949879, -0.037742529064416885, 0.03959592804312706, -0.05212745442986488, 0.011233465746045113, 0.023764491081237793, -0.021191062405705452, 0.017974192276597023, -0.010480351746082306, -0.00062203110428527, 0.004606677684932947, -0.04150715470314026, -0.053831763565540314, 0.04984913021326065, -0.06941709667444229, 0.031201878562569618, -0.04456373676657677, 0.052521321922540665, 0.05632493272423744, -0.014038918539881706, 0.025309160351753235, 0.012699552811682224, 0.04438087344169617, 0.07000691443681717, 0.0017065779538825154, 0.0052326638251543045, -0.043140705674886703, 0.010626865550875664, 0.010715391486883163, -0.019746454432606697, 0.005094218999147415, -0.004215361084789038, 0.016899997368454933, -0.002750821178779006, 0.030699018388986588, -0.005070502869784832, -0.06285695731639862, 0.00415631290525198, -0.003750886069610715, -0.05617694556713104, -0.0007198848179541528, 0.04182138666510582, -0.005575380753725767, 0.007974712178111076, -0.005572895053774118, 0.009632735513150692, -0.02547084353864193, 0.05700315162539482, 0.005131623707711697, -0.0056289490312337875, 0.013320437632501125, 0.026135437190532684, -0.04713389649987221, 0.04369576647877693, -0.019262230023741722, -0.0015061924932524562, 0.01399830263108015, 0.00728631392121315, 0.0730985552072525, -0.030519729480147362, -0.047438956797122955, -0.08065740019083023, 0.010711376555263996, 0.02212393842637539, -0.024569690227508545, 0.053828779608011246, 0.02388707362115383, -0.03703055903315544, -0.015064028091728687, 0.02606218308210373, 0.017882773652672768, 0.005701340269297361, 0.005929999984800816, -0.03750908002257347, -0.007365275174379349, 0.026169342920184135, 0.006353143602609634, 0.02006448432803154, 0.018582120537757874, 0.04524047300219536, 0.004195528104901314, 0.004467519000172615, -0.031609442085027695, 0.001715568476356566, 0.014271784573793411, -0.028362058103084564, 0.03518430143594742, 0.04012416675686836, -0.07745283842086792, -0.03598535433411598, -0.08121518045663834, 0.04442312940955162, 0.04673229902982712, 0.016994599252939224, -0.0776882916688919, -0.03743341192603111, -0.021940700709819794, 0.0011930926702916622, -0.04111555218696594, -0.07623539865016937, -0.03998018056154251, -0.018132654950022697, 0.03831928223371506, 0.027625057846307755, 0.03406371548771858, -0.03285614028573036, 0.016275549307465553, 0.0015598044265061617, 0.0075515699572861195, 0.08055505156517029, -0.03527284413576126, -0.026929788291454315, -0.014969367533922195, 0.07488708943128586, 0.02662510611116886, 0.006564957555383444, -0.06086203083395958, -0.050167106091976166, -0.06436328589916229, -0.0532568097114563, 0.0397258922457695, 0.03232961520552635, 0.014116093516349792, 0.019053304567933083, -0.017717383801937103, 0.004992382600903511, -0.08966699987649918, 0.05499843508005142, 0.067931167781353, -0.029573887586593628, -0.04172587767243385, -0.03177382051944733, 0.017035480588674545, -0.00563301146030426, -0.04612104967236519, 0.019956720992922783, -0.00006813871732447296, 0.009862144477665424, 0.013324740342795849, 0.028097260743379593, -0.07302835583686829, 0.032443463802337646, 0.009118176996707916, -0.00097153295064345, 0.0181968342512846, 0.04608381167054176, 0.0058020856231451035, -0.08037494122982025, -0.0367189384996891, 0.043477244675159454, -0.004645583685487509, 0.029883835464715958, -0.015608514659106731, -0.05153548717498779, -0.062305767089128494, -0.003084628377109766, -0.003791141789406538, -0.05237703025341034, 0.027305996045470238, -0.08476830273866653, 0.05726867914199829, 0.08951622247695923, 0.025491973385214806, -0.00015745835844427347, 0.06050073355436325, 0.05135900899767876, -0.01582952030003071, 0.03606676682829857, -0.016791725531220436, -0.034788697957992554, -0.0038977491203695536, -0.016698459163308144, 0.009098205715417862, 0.0001645599550101906, -0.051337189972400665, -0.03273596614599228, -0.025820693001151085, 0.009186900220811367, -0.010508352890610695, -0.017312878742814064, -0.047686874866485596, -0.01960492692887783, 0.02964906208217144, -0.07907863706350327, -0.014020424336194992, -0.014599749818444252, -0.05502423271536827, 0.0063129304908216, -0.01001187413930893, 0.003057867055758834, -0.004064180422574282, -0.037085339426994324, -0.027541862800717354, 0.02733953669667244, -0.003823258448392153, -0.005829207599163055, 0.005510811228305101, 0.03792994096875191, 0.015845920890569687, 0.045010216534137726, -0.00575218303129077, -0.0027446208987385035, 0.026348894461989403, -0.0033167621586471796, 0.038020018488168716, 0.0014494310598820448, -0.019951393827795982, 0.011109079234302044, 0.035137780010700226, -0.02853473648428917, 0.0019410232780501246, 0.001624925876967609, 0.014480764046311378, 0.008652345277369022, -0.018172377720475197, -0.05194489285349846, 0.05482613295316696, 0.0006123423227109015, 0.027276022359728813, -0.06044009327888489, 0.030280286446213722, -0.03953627869486809, -0.004138943739235401, 0.000943632738199085, -0.03641896694898605, 0.015724442899227142, -0.018990620970726013, 0.06514707952737808, 0.0080094700679183, 0.08096285909414291, 0.04822835326194763, 0.007386324927210808, 0.012760762125253677, -0.05422890558838844, 0.016888875514268875, 0.041235581040382385, -0.035458825528621674, 0.06977936625480652, 0.003689415054395795, -0.0009852350922301412, 0.02037147246301174, -0.011719916015863419, -0.02978007309138775, 0.026664631441235542, 0.057096660137176514, -0.01830902323126793, -0.003014644607901573, -0.02564728632569313, 0.054245490580797195, 0.004397151526063681, -0.019900478422641754, -0.012678051367402077, -0.03417186066508293, 0.00820150040090084, 0.025204235687851906, -0.0021094318944960833, 0.02413322776556015, 0.0159032940864563, -0.008101456798613071, 0.008584084920585155, 0.04154196009039879, 0.02792532928287983, -0.011509304866194725, -0.07820875942707062, 0.05829223617911339, -0.02050447277724743, 0.010696710087358952, 0.020933380350470543, 0.028184037655591965, -0.005306832026690245, 0.03551540896296501, 0.005511266645044088, 0.014545710757374763, 0.009370260871946812, -0.024117449298501015, -0.015702813863754272, -0.033101875334978104, -0.019830504432320595, -0.01966571994125843, -0.0038340408354997635, 0.0722140446305275, -0.045069772750139236, 0.014841379597783089, 0.008347874507308006, 0.03724651783704758, 0.010433008894324303, -0.024480625987052917, -0.002584948902949691, -0.0060417247004806995, 0.004470503889024258, 0.024344712495803833, -0.04078557342290878, 0.02109694853425026, 0.01917383261024952, 0.0708639994263649, 0.05461797118186951, 0.008837544359266758, -0.020789142698049545, -0.004595290403813124, -0.07413837313652039, -0.04662704095244408, -0.017965558916330338, -0.008927591145038605, 0.01891951449215412, 0.004205037374049425, 0.00915409717708826, 0.029052142053842545, -0.02603731118142605, -0.018756456673145294, 0.09444272518157959, -0.030765274539589882, 0.010832592844963074, -0.018141670152544975, 0.027214007452130318, -0.04303020238876343, 0.014953788369894028, 0.009710441343486309, 0.004417730960994959, -0.04100419580936432, -0.0052778227254748344, 0.08815207332372665, -0.03255971148610115, 0.02908230945467949, 0.015970703214406967, -0.056407250463962555, -0.008660003542900085, 0.03271573409438133, -0.036451566964387894, 0.048116691410541534, 0.025263981893658638, -0.00478640990331769, -0.06325647979974747, 0.06726132333278656, 0.0483851321041584, 0.01881377585232258, 0.002195176435634494, -0.028564419597387314, 0.0025079974438995123, -0.06989406049251556, -0.08902031928300858, 0.04982442781329155, 0.0347936786711216, 0.07038597762584686, 0.01940891332924366, -0.002684075152501464, -0.021584346890449524, 0.0060778590850532055, -0.034537047147750854, -0.022839635610580444, 0.0022533307783305645, 0.003066836856305599, 0.0013177396031096578, 0.035744789987802505, 0.08159554749727249, 0.051434267312288284, 0.025461619719862938, -0.047343894839286804, 0.015594936907291412, 0.01505733747035265, 0.04431377351284027, 0.008903572335839272, -0.06308146566152573, 0.047966063022613525, 0.012907660566270351, 0.02393186092376709, 0.00921008549630642, -0.005595076829195023, -0.012103009968996048, -0.009953642264008522, -0.021635031327605247, -0.009760735556483269, -0.1061093658208847, 0.010259629227221012, 0.0024456041865050793, 0.04841979593038559, 0.03498440235853195, 0.01494353637099266, -0.029594268649816513, -0.07120224088430405, 0.02279670350253582, -0.009660999290645123, -0.021350359544157982, -0.005594335962086916, 0.02447156235575676, -0.0468895323574543, -0.021595945581793785, -0.06506548076868057, 0.03259476646780968, 0.06254655122756958, 0.047508664429187775, -0.056403882801532745, -0.03678493946790695, -0.01666654273867607, 0.03401009738445282, -0.022395489737391472, -0.00039967981865629554, -0.012558762915432453, 0.0351441353559494, -0.015874452888965607, -0.032755378633737564, 0.03669571876525879, 0.022847654297947884, 0.020382465794682503, 0.008153441362082958, 0.00018220418132841587, -0.0073974658735096455, -0.02217450924217701, 0.020735008642077446, 0.0015108590014278889, 0.0045711281709373, -0.021385986357927322, -0.0420796275138855, -0.04045431315898895, 0.0394701324403286, 0.0654960498213768, -0.024095596745610237, -0.029581675305962563, 0.034033287316560745, -0.028556976467370987, 0.00882179755717516, 0.036719292402267456, 0.024856455624103546, -0.03373178839683533, -0.029347114264965057, -0.01790151558816433, -0.0485999770462513, -0.012120543979108334, -0.023158786818385124, -0.06035454943776131, -0.0016350322403013706, -0.012230913154780865, 0.028373509645462036, -0.010728999972343445, -0.03364209085702896, 0.0074389283545315266, 0.0023090641479939222, -0.01098632998764515, 0.024200042709708214, -0.008717341348528862, -0.026286372914910316, 0.06575331836938858, -0.0040398589335381985, 0.021410787478089333, 0.006359063554555178, -0.017688332125544548, -0.002831303048878908, 0.024848835542798042, -0.004338896833360195, -0.046331316232681274, -0.0062759676948189735, 0.06897250562906265, -0.07990065962076187, -0.011226470582187176, -0.0655360221862793, 0.040197309106588364, 0.016505327075719833, -0.01636742614209652, -0.021438274532556534, 0.049584247171878815, -0.00030313091701827943, -0.027491508051753044, 0.011613762937486172, -0.009088845923542976, 0.010806435719132423, -0.03452291339635849, -0.008934925310313702, -0.01059842947870493, 0.006017917767167091, -0.024944987148046494, 0.010141110047698021, -0.005034599453210831, -0.03708639740943909, -0.03735904023051262, -0.10091888904571533, 0.045447077602148056, -0.05083407461643219, 0.05145574361085892, 0.012740151025354862, 0.0688759833574295, -0.044184599071741104, -0.03044237196445465, -0.09421389549970627, 0.01195450872182846, -0.0013190892059355974, 0.01250510010868311, -0.05056842416524887, -0.017186544835567474, 0.023066598922014236, 0.004952561110258102, -0.006956574972718954, -0.008607217110693455, -0.04460221901535988, 0.02916054055094719, 0.02117975614964962, 0.05255994573235512, 0.030439144000411034, -0.02258297987282276, 0.025278910994529724, 0.0493612177670002, -0.035790570080280304, -0.0015023228479549289, 0.046742893755435944, 0.02667529322206974, 0.09311947226524353, -0.057634688913822174, 0.016550231724977493, 0.07455439865589142, -0.02101960964500904, 0.003376021981239319, -0.07383004575967789, 0.03359976410865784, 0.0021756815258413553, -0.0075044650584459305, -0.048072438687086105, -0.018398014828562737, -0.0612148717045784, -0.02128755673766136, 0.029650285840034485, -0.018178725615143776, 0.005304916296154261, 0.014481982216238976, -0.030780233442783356, -0.018767893314361572, -0.03483585640788078, 0.05381099507212639, -0.059763241559267044, -0.007861126214265823, 0.007904166355729103, -0.015890834853053093, 0.004300836008042097, 0.026992928236722946, 0.007462105713784695, -0.03970892354846001, 0.004135543014854193, -0.0179912056773901, -0.04927967116236687, 0.02781056798994541, -0.03905624523758888, -0.08859799802303314, 0.008564047515392303, 0.010513223707675934, -0.029212746769189835, -0.004684693180024624, -0.00643084617331624, 0.02542070671916008, -0.016153691336512566, -0.028122734278440475, -0.04824371263384819, 0.007980601862072945, 0.013550056144595146, -0.017839519307017326, -0.035847410559654236, -0.0011563609587028623, -0.006281495094299316, -0.0038213212974369526, -0.08958546072244644, -0.024476638063788414, -0.09580065310001373, -0.001957161817699671, 0.015391062013804913, 0.0015277205966413021, 0.02159980498254299, 0.02078559249639511, 0.05969969555735588, 0.017513370141386986, 0.008882351219654083, -0.028409285470843315, -0.02094053290784359, -0.002058424986898899, -0.014864076860249043, -0.0440998449921608, 0.004630012903362513, -0.007941323332488537, 0.0036616474390029907, 0.004506287164986134, 0.019227901473641396, -0.0616670660674572, 0.023580217733979225, 0.012161838822066784, -0.004993843380361795, 0.022004656493663788, -0.01989719457924366, -0.017135348170995712, 0.02391449175775051, -0.043457869440317154, -0.03063981607556343, -0.03375812992453575, -0.004461474716663361, 0.05174550414085388, -0.10165137052536011, 0.000096368785307277, 0.024962028488516808, -0.0004390839603729546, 0.07514797896146774, -0.031255681067705154, 0.06232646107673645, 0.0024386856239289045, 0.05760258063673973, 0.05151155963540077, 0.0851043164730072, 0.014361645095050335, -0.01582455076277256, -0.06528785824775696, 0.032755687832832336, -0.07953891903162003, -0.03212914243340492, 0.0659211277961731, -0.05875043570995331, 0.007573741488158703, -0.00820907298475504, 0.0486738495528698, 0.046982381492853165, -0.007979639805853367, 0.007413333281874657, 0.03314835950732231, -0.0301466453820467, -0.006768426392227411, -0.017109910026192665, -0.07678382843732834, -0.034655191004276276, 0.010045811533927917, 0.06790915131568909, 0.02056611143052578, 0.04341717064380646, 0.0338992178440094, 0.07265312224626541, -0.010732664726674557, 0.0430934838950634, 0.04415314644575119, -0.0194566510617733, -0.012556621804833412, -0.016728470101952553, 0.042830828577280045, 0.05373052507638931, -0.03581893444061279, 0.05651851370930672, 0.024312958121299744, 0.05773549526929855, 0.008088164031505585, -0.030961599200963974, 0.004482840653508902, 0.08825220167636871, 0.015167668461799622, 0.06224871054291725, 0.04876423254609108, -0.014689353294670582, 0.01573759689927101, -0.014158743433654308, 0.022641725838184357, -0.02960376814007759, 0.008547709323465824, 0.052037447690963745, -0.015529019758105278, 0.0017858612118288875, -0.022094663232564926, -0.028204739093780518, -0.012328916229307652, -0.019707541912794113, 0.00800993386656046, 0.030559372156858444, 0.016960442066192627, 0.03750470653176308, 0.013904946856200695, 0.07580133527517319, -0.008225696161389351, 0.009642110206186771, -0.041234057396650314, -0.04132815822958946, -0.03514530882239342, 0.008637464605271816, -0.00734072457998991, -0.02116101048886776, 0.03855159878730774, -0.02927146852016449, 0.08569280803203583, 0.022397847846150398, -0.020245812833309174, -0.02972671203315258, 0.050473760813474655, -0.016101978719234467, -0.06559064239263535, 0.03450681269168854, -0.038514841347932816, 0.005055668763816357, -0.001614117412827909, 0.04176880419254303, -0.008756112307310104, 0.03026415780186653, -0.019948767498135567, -0.01483902893960476, -0.010009979829192162, -0.0007722137961536646, 0.0240497924387455, -0.013856576755642891, -0.07489063590765, -0.027448153123259544, 0.03872356191277504, 0.05186231806874275, 0.041326332837343216, 0.025978827849030495, 0.01911681517958641, -0.05898721516132355, -0.02312672697007656, -0.012933967635035515, 0.026651723310351372, -0.03933551535010338, -0.050497617572546005, -0.051117271184921265, 0.028467148542404175, -0.025301584973931313, -0.061332397162914276, -0.059374839067459106, 0.027215687558054924, 0.05803753808140755, 0.006981726735830307, -0.01641783118247986, -0.01516067422926426, 0.024207474663853645, -0.055156074464321136, -0.018223943188786507, -0.010937752202153206, -0.01512154471129179, 0.00785049982368946, -0.007396231405436993, -0.0019798781722784042, -0.010350851342082024, -0.05808843672275543, -0.005736531224101782, 0.05145729333162308, -0.001330704428255558, 0.0462740994989872, 0.01108631119132042, 0.019820382818579674, 0.103474922478199, 0.018934341147542, -0.03447837010025978, -0.05280957743525505, -0.036643531173467636, 0.0005068370373919606, 0.056511569768190384, 0.05326491966843605, 0.031177427619695663, 0.045480892062187195, 0.05994207784533501, -0.03480874001979828, -0.012569845654070377, 0.01573527231812477, 0.021919965744018555, -0.05484112724661827, 0.0379166342318058, 0.03384709358215332, 0.00392776308581233, 0.006991611327975988, 0.037644196301698685 ]
<p>I know correlation does not imply causation. I have read it nth time. (i.e. weight does not cause height etc. etc.)</p> <p>However, to find the effect of a moderator variable on X-Y relationship, a regression model is used such as the GLM in SPSS to test for interaction or multiple regression. See <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/18693/significant-interaction-between-covariate-and-factor-in-spss-glm">here</a>.</p> <p><strong>My Question: If the X-Y relationship is a correlation, then why is a cause-effect model used in this instance?</strong></p> <p>As far as I understand, it makes little sense to classify a variable as independent or dependent in a correlation analysis.</p> <p>I apologise if this seems like a 'silly' question. In my past life, I had often told my students that there are no silly questions; just questions!</p>
g37371
[ 0.06827069818973541, 0.008665945380926132, 0.002616114681586623, -0.013802322559058666, -0.006248563062399626, 0.028309492394328117, 0.022817060351371765, 0.0414254292845726, 0.01432789210230112, -0.06486514210700989, 0.027222925797104836, -0.001993864541873336, 0.04948000982403755, 0.029660068452358246, -0.023504560813307762, -0.035746343433856964, 0.05642540380358696, 0.026438072323799133, -0.0194667037576437, -0.021876703947782516, -0.004022623412311077, -0.049767933785915375, 0.0179867222905159, -0.02138974331319332, 0.010129972361028194, -0.038327790796756744, 0.020131146535277367, -0.01809821091592312, 0.024287335574626923, 0.00729281036183238, 0.06347200274467468, 0.030632488429546356, 0.06313785165548325, -0.044319998472929, -0.010998087003827095, -0.060884393751621246, 0.015095659531652927, 0.05142826586961746, -0.002847044263035059, 0.021142534911632538, -0.026108665391802788, 0.0311619583517313, 0.02961605228483677, -0.014023996889591217, -0.0958128571510315, 0.015629712492227554, 0.01990368962287903, 0.01927679032087326, -0.01642809808254242, -0.048989348113536835, -0.024134282022714615, 0.006809324491769075, 0.06147700920701027, -0.007604971062391996, 0.03733295947313309, -0.007179968990385532, 0.09510353207588196, 0.03511113300919533, -0.03732173144817352, 0.05025563761591911, 0.022871730849146843, -0.0009625540114939213, -0.030143864452838898, 0.019434550777077675, 0.04648787900805473, -0.036315739154815674, 0.012480608187615871, -0.056673355400562286, 0.005693428684026003, 0.021068917587399483, 0.019170813262462616, -0.03249345347285271, 0.001833404996432364, 0.00042313081212341785, 0.00172464142087847, -0.009706403128802776, 0.04099809378385544, -0.000007676690074731596, 0.014061219058930874, -0.032749276608228683, 0.03421057388186455, 0.01105873566120863, 0.08143550902605057, 0.04602392762899399, 0.0383351594209671, -0.044849101454019547, -0.03005174733698368, 0.03547295555472374, 0.028138289228081703, -0.013221990317106247, 0.036815088242292404, 0.04664958640933037, 0.033964402973651886, 0.09325661510229111, -0.07178957760334015, -0.019105061888694763, -0.04423738643527031, 0.016601765528321266, 0.05022848770022392, 0.015163945965468884, -0.01594110205769539, 0.04407312721014023, 0.01874992437660694, -0.007333847694098949, -0.004681515973061323, -0.005913685075938702, -0.009626961313188076, 0.03915950283408165, 0.0154134975746274, -0.01656537689268589, -0.09346231073141098, 0.04089711606502533, -0.05898287892341614, -0.03210216015577316, 0.0024508656933903694, -0.05342039093375206, 0.047203484922647476, -0.043038029223680496, 0.03011343628168106, -0.053335968405008316, -0.02565263770520687, -0.005378151312470436, -0.021907595917582512, 0.04752756655216217, -0.11018847674131393, -0.03247946873307228, -0.0011469973251223564, 0.0480596162378788, -0.01724863424897194, 0.012350127100944519, 0.03861405327916145, 0.013966161757707596, -0.03229077532887459, 0.08007646352052689, 0.0827050432562828, 0.02348705194890499, -0.024407660588622093, 0.0252193883061409, 0.016967352479696274, 0.021131480112671852, -0.06049074977636337, 0.025357555598020554, -0.031118866056203842, -0.041404545307159424, -0.058439161628484726, 0.06800846010446548, 0.026767604053020477, 0.001615577144548297, -0.028421582654118538, -0.006999576464295387, 0.02364656887948513, 0.028201980516314507, -0.05204709991812706, -0.04927021265029907, -0.049386344850063324, -0.008270060643553734, -0.04670410603284836, -0.06992964446544647, 0.03721461072564125, 0.004038010723888874, 0.034850846976041794, -0.008707278408110142, 0.05059395357966423, 0.01888161525130272, -0.02125549130141735, -0.07210233807563782, -0.02844027616083622, -0.053829364478588104, -0.06555978953838348, 0.010347200557589531, -0.007894719950854778, 0.0026988086756318808, -0.028485292568802834, 0.008941280655562878, 0.036232657730579376, 0.020010419189929962, 0.013996070250868797, -0.054963286966085434, 0.05106271058320999, -0.034818992018699646, -0.024824338033795357, 0.010428780689835548, -0.002022668719291687, -0.05074332654476166, 0.018524732440710068, -0.026761988177895546, 0.05446038395166397, 0.021272974088788033, -0.05750538036227226, 0.024920513853430748, -0.022939786314964294, -0.04348350688815117, -0.022269247099757195, -0.018098367378115654, -0.035023149102926254, -0.0727514922618866, -0.0005860847886651754, -0.030469536781311035, -0.029291434213519096, -0.010744161903858185, -0.06206553056836128, 0.008192609064280987, 0.027608029544353485, 0.059240274131298065, -0.02693936415016651, 0.008777066133916378, -0.01770777814090252, -0.008938468992710114, -0.06134690344333649, 0.00037169293500483036, -0.003521486185491085, -0.00240822765044868, -0.04468652606010437, 0.008417036384344101, 0.01758047565817833, -0.07498979568481445, -0.06512495875358582, 0.024973642081022263, -0.005024976562708616, 0.04590119794011116, -0.0072349198162555695, -0.024228431284427643, 0.007094726897776127, -0.034997325390577316, -0.010922138579189777, 0.03858231008052826, -0.005349607206881046, 0.004851064179092646, 0.0025125104002654552, -0.041143856942653656, -0.024505505338311195, -0.008935512974858284, 0.008814818225800991, -0.02476518601179123, 0.0283386018127203, 0.0029159870464354753, 0.0412893109023571, -0.007846863940358162, -0.008563606068491936, 0.08687158674001694, 0.020078912377357483, 0.03388235345482826, 0.016713617369532585, 0.023110993206501007, 0.05875954404473305, -0.02359653078019619, 0.017154743894934654, -0.06208522990345955, -0.00797207560390234, 0.009670221246778965, -0.031889908015728, 0.059003859758377075, -0.00788511335849762, -0.09036052972078323, 0.020601246505975723, -0.020656904205679893, 0.02737320214509964, 0.0675979033112526, -0.03259816765785217, -0.011931285262107849, 0.02018727734684944, -0.016039647161960602, -0.0018994039855897427, -0.0160182174295187, 0.0231151282787323, -0.024828242138028145, 0.017240090295672417, -0.08152728527784348, -0.05532381683588028, -0.0264397244900465, -0.07096060365438461, 0.0055327946320176125, 0.015282689593732357, 0.008429456502199173, 0.023400049656629562, 0.0323130264878273, -0.049078766256570816, 0.0012401569401845336, 0.057046327739953995, -0.02947057969868183, 0.055942557752132416, -0.0021162726916372776, -0.054778583347797394, 0.005236634518951178, 0.06952513754367828, -0.00038332169060595334, 0.05845269188284874, -0.0034645989071577787, -0.01638083904981613, -0.0002632102114148438, 0.046435944736003876, 0.004322408232837915, -0.038533326238393784, 0.0612763948738575, 0.03769737854599953, -0.021953396499156952, -0.0036525651812553406, -0.084368497133255, -0.02642868459224701, 0.07877739518880844, -0.012362772598862648, -0.009998134337365627, 0.020640622824430466, 0.021959424018859863, 0.03987792506814003, -0.01586013473570347, -0.03228428587317467, -0.020512178540229797, -0.04202013090252876, -0.029380803927779198, -0.03901715576648712, 0.0028997515328228474, 0.02582514099776745, 0.0408877357840538, -0.034824077039957047, -0.011099562980234623, 0.021926287561655045, 0.029072949662804604, -0.039739616215229034, -0.018948612734675407, -0.003520081052556634, -0.06745713949203491, -0.004328126087784767, 0.0044280835427343845, -0.02280515804886818, 0.0007827161462046206, -0.019434301182627678, -0.006778717041015625, -0.016455477103590965, -0.030945375561714172, 0.009677495807409286, -0.03359334543347359, 0.024896888062357903, -0.01510191336274147, -0.014988640323281288, -0.02762668766081333, 0.032771240919828415, -0.047479648143053055, -0.04530417546629906, 0.035989124327898026, -0.007948045618832111, -0.013669054955244064, 0.024037837982177734, 0.03203907981514931, 0.0018024769378826022, 0.035459429025650024, -0.029589809477329254, 0.0016125109978020191, 0.015292821452021599, -0.022031869739294052, 0.019640188664197922, 0.00048771323054097593, 0.0013521815417334437, -0.018753914162516594, -0.03380206599831581, -0.007221143692731857, 0.04620979726314545, -0.02179182879626751, -0.07392366975545883, -0.009891079738736153, 0.019857928156852722, -0.0026994168292731047, -0.021247517317533493, 0.012111390009522438, -0.011004915460944176, 0.04427038133144379, 0.06039123982191086, 0.053750552237033844, 0.02400296926498413, -0.0010308345081284642, 0.05209635943174362, 0.019591934978961945, -0.006317643448710442, -0.03223421052098274, 0.03719358518719673, -0.025608131662011147, 0.06401274353265762, 0.07213745266199112, -0.02320317178964615, 0.04908748343586922, 0.06137096509337425, -0.0033263962250202894, 0.01869441196322441, 0.0622783787548542, 0.06123710796236992, -0.061401449143886566, -0.021322188898921013, 0.019585689529776573, 0.0027035539969801903, -0.03443452715873718, 0.02422039583325386, 0.017939433455467224, -0.037327177822589874, 0.046785205602645874, 0.07213534414768219, 0.028446225449442863, -0.00115809531416744, 0.00649965088814497, 0.045917410403490067, -0.0049860249273478985, -0.023636668920516968, -0.0018802618142217398, 0.01215643621981144, 0.04426480457186699, -0.02223859168589115, 0.043981410562992096, -0.018475214019417763, -0.08687993139028549, -0.04264068603515625, 0.01011889148503542, -0.003550085471943021, 0.0221951212733984, 0.00021839064720552415, -0.029962904751300812, -0.009015161544084549, 0.008345725014805794, 0.03686085343360901, 0.04351310059428215, 0.04906129837036133, 0.00502368388697505, 0.04907183721661568, 0.02600039914250374, -0.004151435103267431, 0.01868377812206745, 0.03754934296011925, 0.003519639139994979, -0.00825191754847765, 0.005053904373198748, -0.007660247851163149, -0.03355592116713524, 0.030064741149544716, 0.06257854402065277, 0.023220408707857132, -0.02376951090991497, 0.006232794374227524, 0.05016505718231201, -0.02516893669962883, 0.033614929765462875, -0.022790679708123207, -0.03254670649766922, 0.06188690662384033, -0.04050353541970253, 0.045700933784246445, -0.0038434676826000214, -0.021538741886615753, -0.034802213311195374, -0.00033023746800608933, -0.01672496646642685, 0.014975389465689659, -0.027302483096718788, -0.0547875314950943, 0.028186660259962082, -0.016509341076016426, -0.05098108947277069, 0.01719767414033413, -0.006345927249640226, 0.053623002022504807, 0.012621399946510792, 0.043740540742874146, 0.024167368188500404, -0.007641461677849293, -0.04568064957857132, 0.0074044219218194485, 0.00006238945934455842, 0.017736246809363365, -0.01616010069847107, -0.012460067868232727, -0.04959222301840782, 0.023801488801836967, 0.05349268391728401, -0.03552825376391411, -0.023926887661218643, 0.030640844255685806, 0.029782980680465698, 0.021955719217658043, 0.05257410556077957, -0.005714814178645611, -0.0503242127597332, 0.0038383554201573133, -0.008101346902549267, 0.023933226242661476, -0.005684275645762682, 0.03292452171444893, -0.05013432726264, -0.02457636035978794, -0.019963977858424187, -0.04148658737540245, -0.04076164588332176, 0.02320309728384018, -0.055307481437921524, 0.02769499458372593, 0.016423866152763367, 0.012777616269886494, 0.030741380527615547, -0.02287442795932293, 0.004859894514083862, 0.03522259369492531, -0.0607498362660408, 0.02305646613240242, -0.0386071652173996, 0.009579967707395554, 0.018931394442915916, 0.0384996123611927, 0.006432160269469023, -0.04859943315386772, -0.006161932367831469, 0.07694016396999359, -0.03370086848735809, 0.013797566294670105, 0.054062388837337494, -0.01825743354856968, 0.041450899094343185, -0.0010395064018666744, 0.04642917215824127, 0.0010641342960298061, 0.0154950562864542, 0.00585261220112443, -0.009017596021294594, 0.031738944351673126, -0.01934855990111828, 0.06120392680168152, -0.03167014941573143, -0.026488110423088074, -0.010903612710535526, -0.02001720294356346, -0.004638551268726587, -0.06121277064085007, -0.035697612911462784, 0.0174376480281353, -0.020246565341949463, -0.0019253635546192527, 0.00044104084372520447, 0.017253458499908447, 0.09065189212560654, 0.03038981556892395, -0.04999959468841553, -0.04024234786629677, 0.007609531283378601, -0.03044833056628704, 0.015468641184270382, -0.04180171713232994, -0.0011691907420754433, 0.003123373491689563, -0.029417354613542557, 0.02784721925854683, 0.013781270943582058, 0.0655457004904747, -0.01124128419905901, -0.00780901126563549, -0.004590245429426432, -0.013169210404157639, -0.019933901727199554, 0.02876989170908928, 0.02880408987402916, -0.021908335387706757, 0.01742294430732727, 0.021895641461014748, 0.0365164615213871, -0.02936118096113205, -0.036387231200933456, -0.010577032342553139, -0.05281646177172661, -0.0036144396290183067, -0.0012917162384837866, -0.001222445978783071, -0.005889424588531256, -0.024870576336979866, -0.012405332177877426, -0.003441678127273917, 0.0564836747944355, 0.037431683391332626, -0.006968993227928877, 0.05467721447348595, 0.011179079301655293, -0.021010415628552437, 0.052592892199754715, -0.033830054104328156, 0.03695060312747955, -0.032869551330804825, 0.007567938882857561, 0.08621298521757126, -0.022960741072893143, -0.015316295437514782, -0.037558283656835556, -0.008964652195572853, -0.010082704946398735, -0.04178778827190399, 0.011589101515710354, 0.012492888607084751, 0.012558049522340298, -0.04949759319424629, -0.01541733369231224, -0.025714583694934845, 0.04713842272758484, -0.034365102648735046, -0.0637645497918129, 0.008690107613801956, 0.055544305592775345, -0.0015484668547287583, -0.03929229825735092, 0.008157067000865936, -0.030091457068920135, 0.04740435630083084, 0.04227732494473457, -0.0026113269850611687, -0.0005565362516790628, 0.013322632759809494, 0.008657676167786121, 0.013530047610402107, 0.05065184831619263, -0.03158468380570412, 0.02144884131848812, 0.06030503287911415, 0.033775586634874344, 0.036013323813676834, -0.02522009238600731, -0.05959506705403328, -0.043853167444467545, -0.10794759541749954, -0.026034850627183914, 0.009695300832390785, -0.005178048275411129, -0.013189295306801796, -0.006695645395666361, -0.0247938334941864, 0.06165590137243271, -0.03878893703222275, -0.03330576419830322, 0.0014095455408096313, -0.03688475117087364, -0.051948197185993195, 0.02319161407649517, -0.031208250671625137, -0.036480989307165146, -0.062118206173181534, 0.0799175500869751, -0.014238189905881882, 0.0449778288602829, 0.01375714223831892, -0.0009219679050147533, 0.012976743280887604, 0.03470483049750328, -0.05134258419275284, -0.03652205690741539, 0.03869827464222908, -0.02806108258664608, 0.05505005642771721, 0.021829819306731224, -0.07628069072961807, 0.050633206963539124, 0.00801223423331976, 0.008518178947269917, -0.007031113374978304, -0.057401008903980255, 0.07502920925617218, -0.00527555588632822, 0.01032597292214632, 0.007808789610862732, 0.03247096389532089, 0.045807428658008575, -0.0849972739815712, -0.014377103187143803, -0.04965519160032272, 0.022689569741487503, -0.07082414627075195, 0.07477706670761108, 0.013779927045106888, -0.04079360514879227, 0.02099921926856041, 0.002261812798678875, -0.048790138214826584, -0.06025118753314018, 0.0200864989310503, -0.03961442783474922, 0.009474191814661026, -0.032723318785429, -0.0011410540901124477, -0.05465034395456314, 0.012188822031021118, 0.0020326573867350817, -0.011123185977339745, 0.022047284990549088, 0.030495548620820045, 0.015755709260702133, -0.07502511888742447, 0.023206092417240143, 0.02287915349006653, -0.006034468300640583, -0.005508314818143845, -0.030862336978316307, -0.09072672575712204, -0.016084525734186172, 0.016696134582161903, 0.007660922594368458, 0.011466682888567448, -0.018256356939673424, 0.020964715629816055, 0.06226057931780815, -0.06008635833859444, 0.10051203519105911, 0.011406807228922844, 0.00919462088495493, -0.0947008803486824, -0.008024584501981735, 0.08978937566280365, 0.006559070199728012, -0.0019586458802223206, -0.010873698629438877, -0.024835048243403435, -0.012018606066703796, -0.04642510414123535, 0.01430569589138031, -0.02140602096915245, 0.004117464646697044, -0.012942226603627205, -0.015604122541844845, 0.035581544041633606, -0.03955783694982529, -0.009084712713956833, 0.016132310032844543, -0.043505001813173294, -0.023920578882098198, -0.01329981442540884, -0.017317622900009155, -0.05584142729640007, -0.028990769758820534, 0.05319540947675705, -0.028566421940922737, 0.011435754597187042, 0.07349203526973724, 0.004610180389136076, -0.016453994438052177, 0.009474875405430794, 0.02069789171218872, 0.034587111324071884, -0.03419935330748558, 0.05760728195309639, 0.03158343583345413, -0.0924587994813919, 0.03295104578137398, 0.01475599780678749, 0.0008760023047216237, 0.03018829971551895, 0.020361291244626045, -0.003099777502939105, -0.04584721848368645, 0.007329724729061127, 0.06283437460660934, -0.04817047342658043, 0.007008213084191084, -0.0006302946130745113, 0.07204044610261917, -0.03568478673696518, 0.024695176631212234, 0.002611749107018113, -0.018183555454015732, -0.06890267878770828, 0.017622726038098335, -0.028391068801283836, -0.010847954079508781, 0.020149750635027885, 0.009594056755304337, -0.04530894756317139, 0.014256291091442108, 0.005141478963196278, 0.013209116645157337, -0.031358007341623306, 0.040354758501052856 ]
<p>In <a href="http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=6-Y8OL3sW14C&amp;pg=PA102&amp;lpg=PA102&amp;dq=deviance%20of%20a%20%22bernoulli%22%20model?%20goodness%20of%20fit&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=kb3FoEbN30&amp;sig=gJ28_j0CN8-WsFoYp4gDrL2eooA&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ei=SsFhUe3YL-Wa0QWTo4CwBg&amp;ved=0CDsQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&amp;q=deviance%20of%20a%20%22bernoulli%22%20model?%20goodness%20of%20fit&amp;f=false" rel="nofollow">Ordinal Data Modelling</a> by Johson &amp; Albert, page 102-103:</p> <blockquote> <p>For Bernoulli observations [...] the asymptotic chi-squared distribution of the deviance statistic may not pertain. Indeed, for the linear logistic models with Bernoulli observations, the deviance function can be expresses solely as a function of the MLE of the regression parameter, <strong>which demonstrates the futility of using this statistic to measure goodness of fit for such data</strong>.</p> </blockquote> <p>Could someone kindly explain what this means, please? </p>
g74298
[ 0.012431532144546509, -0.0026171933859586716, -0.004767151549458504, -0.018638793379068375, 0.05887695029377937, -0.04152102395892143, 0.014484860002994537, 0.04832391440868378, -0.005344588775187731, -0.05317571759223938, -0.06280149519443512, 0.016469771042466164, 0.09885898977518082, -0.026912571862339973, -0.03023401089012623, 0.0105740400031209, 0.028605543076992035, 0.020332694053649902, 0.07056646794080734, 0.020297374576330185, -0.04009624198079109, -0.019165728241205215, 0.008792359381914139, -0.05694330483675003, -0.004000813700258732, -0.0934317484498024, 0.035719092935323715, 0.04140922799706459, -0.04083375260233879, 0.006710617803037167, 0.0013341447338461876, 0.02589256316423416, 0.029166225343942642, -0.010075252503156662, -0.03776006028056145, 0.008317929692566395, 0.044873230159282684, 0.016906535252928734, 0.04274572432041168, 0.011437066830694675, -0.02028823457658291, 0.029488539323210716, -0.024751368910074234, 0.015010281465947628, -0.010184032842516899, -0.04019166901707649, -0.026200035586953163, -0.008651352487504482, 0.01681228168308735, -0.027347996830940247, 0.012894982472062111, 0.012104018591344357, 0.07942461967468262, 0.05581531673669815, 0.06205342337489128, 0.030146127566695213, 0.06053970009088516, 0.022777941077947617, 0.044373735785484314, -0.04535319283604622, -0.01961025595664978, -0.02195434272289276, -0.016713924705982208, 0.012734995223581791, 0.033254459500312805, 0.01303789671510458, -0.026071270927786827, -0.01114752609282732, 0.04118962958455086, -0.009428958408534527, 0.06646785140037537, 0.024973221123218536, -0.009212476201355457, -0.09218094497919083, -0.05877566337585449, -0.0041494788601994514, 0.002184196375310421, -0.022225335240364075, 0.009564254432916641, 0.0496976263821125, -0.02608446590602398, 0.02698775753378868, -0.018887555226683617, 0.06208425015211105, 0.06928209215402603, -0.0041011120192706585, 0.00502789206802845, -0.005611851811408997, 0.00042156147537752986, 0.055265288800001144, -0.016076553612947464, 0.0011833132011815906, 0.029144909232854843, 0.04374679550528526, -0.06450197845697403, -0.059224534779787064, -0.06462313234806061, -0.00043686022399924695, -0.029440494254231453, 0.05853785574436188, -0.03894288092851639, 0.041159436106681824, -0.029063846915960312, 0.011453531682491302, -0.0617637075483799, 0.020010825246572495, 0.028000105172395706, 0.014127258211374283, -0.02291254885494709, -0.041278962045907974, -0.0457778163254261, 0.007564125582575798, -0.037136659026145935, -0.0336952842772007, -0.02928435429930687, 0.00738834124058485, 0.04507001116871834, -0.013864425010979176, -0.04155023768544197, 0.013359081000089645, 0.029281264171004295, -0.00778211560100317, 0.038858186453580856, 0.02261686697602272, 0.0021140878088772297, 0.0036287945695221424, 0.013291815295815468, 0.0965186357498169, 0.006686639040708542, -0.04068629443645477, 0.038633041083812714, 0.03926631435751915, 0.007140132132917643, 0.001892121392302215, 0.044193170964717865, 0.04683391749858856, 0.0406755730509758, 0.0009537322912365198, 0.024471715092658997, 0.03402719646692276, 0.010182857513427734, 0.04008391872048378, 0.0855645090341568, -0.019314613193273544, -0.02265109494328499, 0.02457789145410061, -0.03501217067241669, 0.044977109879255295, 0.006420942489057779, 0.023093923926353455, 0.015748199075460434, 0.06750436872243881, -0.0027931800577789545, -0.011085023172199726, -0.059133805334568024, 0.012384104542434216, 0.008814810775220394, 0.04334374889731407, -0.04045158997178078, -0.0326075404882431, 0.07357975095510483, -0.04179653525352478, -0.03195619955658913, 0.030704908072948456, -0.08296670019626617, -0.017871474847197533, 0.01608690805733204, -0.05264195427298546, -0.017791783437132835, -0.0003078911977354437, 0.007362292148172855, -0.003768330905586481, 0.0033847058657556772, 0.0185029748827219, 0.020223194733262062, 0.04963729903101921, 0.00580704677850008, 0.015857653692364693, 0.011742713861167431, -0.026288172230124474, 0.031837429851293564, 0.02507011592388153, 0.0027114006225019693, -0.040622130036354065, -0.06809239089488983, -0.07132846862077713, 0.013082966208457947, -0.021776698529720306, 0.030747463926672935, 0.03248870372772217, 0.020895402878522873, -0.05420079827308655, 0.008830230683088303, -0.03698204830288887, -0.008811344392597675, -0.013783466070890427, 0.005824993830174208, -0.001761157182045281, -0.005943185184150934, -0.019872251898050308, 0.0627913624048233, -0.0323205329477787, -0.007173164747655392, 0.030625993385910988, -0.012455232441425323, 0.0016035219887271523, -0.0552666075527668, 0.008335436694324017, -0.008449671790003777, 0.029925815761089325, 0.03178683668375015, -0.02091718092560768, -0.02323204278945923, 0.05390883982181549, -0.008967545814812183, -0.04938947781920433, -0.027368294075131416, 0.0809006467461586, -0.030846865847706795, -0.01743290200829506, -0.03090115822851658, -0.03306470811367035, 0.002605966990813613, 0.04846847429871559, 0.016183478757739067, 0.02866506017744541, -0.007362909149378538, 0.014362894929945469, 0.025360891595482826, 0.033703334629535675, -0.06377609819173813, -0.03555965796113014, 0.01120984647423029, -0.008501395583152771, 0.04446631669998169, 0.04004451259970665, 0.005121404770761728, 0.008101725950837135, 0.04261867702007294, 0.023280054330825806, -0.016326837241649628, -0.0015721237286925316, -0.05375822260975838, 0.021260825917124748, -0.0067964051850140095, 0.05071583390235901, 0.001161377178505063, -0.03171851858496666, 0.03328145295381546, 0.010001619346439838, 0.0027101708110421896, 0.09540348500013351, 0.019226593896746635, 0.00020575974485836923, 0.007905663922429085, -0.017235010862350464, 0.02947097085416317, 0.017698999494314194, -0.03256312012672424, 0.0009261916275136173, -0.0074766045436263084, 0.013414566405117512, -0.012877656146883965, 0.028263628482818604, -0.0030285182874649763, -0.03495895490050316, 0.01844707690179348, -0.025440068915486336, 0.03094497136771679, -0.005155170802026987, -0.042151205241680145, -0.0024077228736132383, 0.04133712127804756, 0.07542432099580765, 0.010663323104381561, -0.041397400200366974, -0.06000110134482384, 0.02500150352716446, -0.008261033333837986, -0.06589493900537491, 0.0015373957576230168, 0.0029461588710546494, -0.041424475610256195, 0.000930239271838218, -0.004590453114360571, -0.010816317051649094, 0.03035147488117218, -0.07731842249631882, 0.012104157358407974, -0.03287737816572189, -0.05693137273192406, -0.024801304563879967, 0.008949462324380875, 0.00264824740588665, -0.02616656757891178, 0.025384679436683655, -0.00010820211173268035, -0.03968549892306328, 0.03481598570942879, -0.0253815446048975, 0.008372428826987743, 0.03896842524409294, -0.02730078250169754, 0.04778333380818367, -0.018441541120409966, 0.002554964506998658, -0.009084387682378292, -0.019324587658047676, -0.06817807257175446, -0.026520375162363052, -0.023270851001143456, 0.006906763184815645, 0.001733572338707745, -0.022611429914832115, 0.015166198834776878, -0.06761372834444046, -0.04721396416425705, 0.038004856556653976, 0.022492261603474617, -0.06901520490646362, 0.07447763532400131, -0.03547714278101921, -0.05837671086192131, 0.017674602568149567, 0.027281247079372406, -0.015407501719892025, -0.03053385019302368, 0.008134417235851288, -0.024085819721221924, -0.028133807703852654, 0.02304009720683098, 0.05765962228178978, 0.025393182411789894, -0.0216265507042408, -0.057512082159519196, -0.06167256459593773, -0.037850745022296906, -0.008118612691760063, 0.033376529812812805, 0.02097920887172222, -0.010536819696426392, 0.016180606558918953, 0.006052871700376272, 0.050462912768125534, -0.011356719769537449, -0.057634882628917694, -0.03143604099750519, -0.012305928394198418, 0.031543485820293427, 0.03682619705796242, 0.014079459011554718, -0.0021338120568543673, -0.02458139695227146, -0.033563412725925446, 0.010891865007579327, -0.033297620713710785, 0.04523582011461258, -0.012196526862680912, 0.023197362199425697, 0.016380086541175842, 0.07894952595233917, -0.013637086376547813, -0.009442871436476707, 0.005815711338073015, 0.010799409821629524, 0.025468306615948677, -0.003967050928622484, 0.055547162890434265, -0.014593572355806828, -0.0020580224227160215, 0.03329373151063919, 0.009079348295927048, 0.04092298820614815, 0.07411646842956543, 0.03524702414870262, -0.019982682541012764, 0.07539419084787369, 0.047214072197675705, -0.06115106865763664, -0.032451875507831573, 0.05759219825267792, 0.02239263989031315, -0.010924308560788631, 0.026302389800548553, -0.03498043119907379, -0.0581265389919281, -0.01788213849067688, -0.059602443128824234, 0.011040505021810532, -0.06407167762517929, 0.016394145786762238, -0.017637919634580612, -0.025676622986793518, 0.025839418172836304, 0.06863876432180405, -0.0204598531126976, 0.032527267932891846, 0.012973584234714508, -0.033019158989191055, 0.060389455407857895, -0.03674960881471634, -0.021399522200226784, -0.029801353812217712, 0.027670104056596756, -0.011228745803236961, -0.02593277581036091, -0.0200306698679924, -0.037491459399461746, 0.017040066421031952, -0.0008196343551389873, 0.013574741780757904, -0.0392550453543663, -0.05665179342031479, -0.03608252480626106, 0.026152310892939568, 0.03881131857633591, 0.06551361083984375, 0.01270027831196785, -0.008937040343880653, -0.004290860611945391, 0.06826139241456985, 0.010666366666555405, -0.08737492561340332, 0.04185982793569565, 0.003856512252241373, 0.04460261017084122, 0.009616744704544544, 0.03815682232379913, -0.017620189115405083, -0.050126492977142334, 0.06587764620780945, 0.03069300577044487, -0.047213468700647354, 0.027798980474472046, 0.007465458009392023, 0.015918036922812462, 0.015184709802269936, 0.0801781490445137, -0.011322413571178913, 0.02910512685775757, -0.030719496309757233, -0.0407172292470932, 0.025327330455183983, 0.05067344009876251, -0.0038592200726270676, -0.037773873656988144, 0.007992461323738098, -0.03674283251166344, -0.007453159894794226, -0.006630443502217531, -0.020520398393273354, 0.04243214800953865, 0.014197951182723045, 0.004944781307131052, 0.048672012984752655, -0.01058010384440422, 0.013251629658043385, 0.011794176883995533, -0.0037570083513855934, -0.0070383609272539616, -0.011181887239217758, -0.09434281289577484, 0.031125154346227646, -0.01886766590178013, -0.04220737889409065, 0.026530452072620392, -0.024319717660546303, -0.038202814757823944, -0.02920403890311718, 0.008521112613379955, -0.0094168521463871, 0.02949894592165947, -0.0035499711520969868, -0.000953913782723248, 0.0037787780165672302, 0.05652268975973129, -0.04686999320983887, -0.010760431177914143, -0.010981235653162003, 0.02513296715915203, -0.04625965282320976, -0.04930785298347473, 0.0520717054605484, 0.016106046736240387, 0.02884853444993496, -0.034119732677936554, 0.053583964705467224, -0.09340585023164749, 0.022994138300418854, -0.020904233679175377, -0.014621789567172527, 0.06416527926921844, 0.05091354623436928, -0.024217402562499046, -0.020673075690865517, -0.018955102190375328, 0.06563041359186172, -0.04832768812775612, -0.04273126274347305, 0.00231245718896389, -0.040379319339990616, 0.017975764349102974, 0.031042687594890594, 0.00836853962391615, -0.045716792345047, 0.04389849677681923, 0.07288552075624466, -0.009008603170514107, -0.03561047092080116, 0.008149934932589531, 0.004760461393743753, 0.03566271439194679, 0.08899497240781784, -0.06581762433052063, -0.0013005250366404653, -0.04707508906722069, -0.03334394842386246, 0.03469699248671532, 0.04841889441013336, -0.02388429082930088, 0.0274185948073864, 0.007303295191377401, 0.01559508591890335, -0.048100244253873825, 0.02614118717610836, -0.08509787172079086, -0.09492650628089905, -0.020618394017219543, 0.02767624892294407, 0.06037561595439911, 0.013064535334706306, 0.05874171853065491, 0.05309561640024185, 0.04601379856467247, 0.029201118275523186, -0.01184890791773796, -0.03538781777024269, 0.016548387706279755, -0.02535608410835266, -0.03356803208589554, -0.03129188343882561, -0.0026581687852740288, 0.07998492568731308, -0.030449314042925835, -0.010852069593966007, -0.000014391370314115193, -0.02213926799595356, -0.006847746204584837, 0.03172848001122475, -0.017915969714522362, 0.004581401590257883, 0.07035277038812637, -0.02167867124080658, -0.021024981513619423, 0.047632697969675064, 0.012204991653561592, 0.022883392870426178, 0.013135015033185482, -0.03931570053100586, -0.05585930123925209, -0.01300900336354971, -0.03612954542040825, 0.0077148862183094025, -0.038184043020009995, 0.026109108701348305, -0.017875000834465027, 0.021847819909453392, -0.0065544662065804005, -0.016635160893201828, 0.043841343373060226, 0.02222159504890442, -0.024771712720394135, 0.03784779831767082, 0.03715196251869202, -0.0783722996711731, 0.010052659548819065, -0.032323695719242096, -0.04011242464184761, -0.004838775843381882, -0.06148768961429596, 0.02030319720506668, -0.0351867713034153, 0.013893540017306805, -0.019356878474354744, -0.0527188703417778, 0.06645280867815018, -0.025742748752236366, 0.0014029124286025763, -0.0067786104045808315, -0.017534248530864716, -0.05636926367878914, -0.0014199343277141452, 0.048182450234889984, -0.05087574943900108, 0.030925210565328598, -0.06152686849236488, -0.027428360655903816, -0.016314592212438583, -0.019307872280478477, -0.057208240032196045, -0.023473219946026802, -0.022282317280769348, -0.023329243063926697, -0.03248981386423111, 0.04255412518978119, -0.014456585980951786, -0.020567921921610832, 0.0028096975293010473, 0.007792068179696798, -0.005105055868625641, -0.03513757884502411, 0.079047292470932, -0.01818828657269478, 0.03494973108172417, -0.011435280553996563, -0.037585943937301636, -0.05867631733417511, 0.03879329562187195, -0.09431412070989609, 0.02131868526339531, 0.004439265001565218, -0.026713717728853226, 0.023914074525237083, -0.06931363046169281, -0.019290881231427193, 0.010000241920351982, -0.028958439826965332, 0.014814946800470352, 0.043631285429000854, -0.008744200691580772, -0.020548760890960693, 0.04144065082073212, -0.012458850629627705, 0.0250866562128067, -0.05029210075736046, 0.050444696098566055, -0.06403869390487671, 0.03796735778450966, 0.07210642844438553, -0.003206609282642603, -0.05011265352368355, 0.03811774030327797, -0.018555214628577232, -0.025883620604872704, -0.055156148970127106, 0.029757708311080933, -0.014118095859885216, 0.06575202941894531, -0.04536708816885948, -0.004926223773509264, 0.04169481620192528, -0.008630448952317238, 0.0041365064680576324, -0.04491857439279556, 0.03990771248936653, -0.02021821029484272, 0.026567932218313217, 0.05050859972834587, 0.015909144654870033, -0.10223241150379181, -0.02881013974547386, -0.04048831760883331, -0.006540657952427864, -0.03196633234620094, 0.05933862924575806, 0.02019154652953148, -0.010836377739906311, -0.02663758397102356, 0.015197915956377983, -0.054022081196308136, 0.023551709949970245, 0.005305052734911442, -0.036186184734106064, 0.0013487129472196102, -0.03443736955523491, -0.0038976515643298626, 0.006776900961995125, 0.0207623690366745, -0.02137664705514908, -0.021436702460050583, 0.06097867712378502, -0.00415204418823123, 0.008883882313966751, -0.021044457331299782, -0.022861260920763016, 0.0179977435618639, 0.009913299232721329, -0.05473054200410843, 0.04572160542011261, -0.0028069238178431988, -0.07259723544120789, -0.02569582685828209, -0.008555158972740173, -0.061399757862091064, -0.04700596258044243, 0.04572271928191185, -0.048122018575668335, 0.004664668347686529, 0.020490767434239388, 0.10287760198116302, 0.0018252369482070208, 0.023370876908302307, -0.04327896237373352, -0.07575591653585434, 0.07224208861589432, 0.017393095418810844, 0.01548168808221817, -0.043168727308511734, 0.01195872575044632, 0.0043424987234175205, -0.033989571034908295, 0.02103811874985695, -0.01353357918560505, -0.007177877239882946, 0.00297344708815217, 0.0013439473696053028, -0.014092965982854366, 0.021360987797379494, 0.02691750042140484, -0.051511410623788834, 0.0019186133285984397, -0.012707999907433987, 0.030527625232934952, -0.02302929200232029, -0.02869243174791336, -0.049634240567684174, -0.05337022989988327, 0.053864624351263046, 0.0021981995087116957, 0.008416568860411644, -0.02549024112522602, 0.005341731943190098, -0.0032224736642092466, 0.002508480567485094, 0.009146575815975666, 0.04134628549218178, 0.05100683495402336, 0.026205964386463165, -0.03875470161437988, 0.030421121045947075, -0.005734746810048819, 0.05034315958619118, -0.0014492059126496315, 0.011676195077598095, 0.00041416389285586774, -0.035202506929636, -0.041250258684158325, 0.015117396600544453, -0.018805071711540222, 0.026475757360458374, -0.03131965547800064, -0.009629946202039719, 0.0023965754080563784, 0.031189782544970512, -0.01397918164730072, 0.0040857382118701935, 0.03149384632706642, 0.0027820526156574488, 0.0464453287422657, 0.007868253625929356, -0.0019589760340750217, -0.02186795324087143, -0.014448588714003563, 0.04468779265880585, 0.033029913902282715, -0.05211253836750984, 0.008366541005671024, 0.07031489163637161 ]
<p>I would really appreciate some advice.</p> <p>I have two sequential measurements of severity of illness $(s_1, s_2)$ that are incompletely observed along with an outcome measure ($y$). I am trying to estimate if the change in the measurement $(d = s_2 - s_1)$ adds anything to a model based on the second measurement $s_2$ alone. </p> <p>There is an extra complication in that the severity of illness measurement is a score derived by categorising 10 continuous measurements of physiology ($x_1,x_2...x_{10}$), and weighting them. This is helpful because it is the standard clinical method in which to report severity, and it handles variables that are not always linearly associated with survival (e.g. very high or very low blood pressure is a bad thing --- you're best off in the middle).</p> <p>I have been trying to use multiple imputation assuming MAR in Stata 12.</p> <p>The final model would therefore be $y=\alpha + \beta_1s_2+\beta_2d+e$.</p> <p>However, I think there are several different imputation strategies and I am not sure which is correct.</p> <ol> <li>I use the raw physiology in the imputation model, and then derive the weights afterwards.</li> <li>I derive the individual weights ($x_1,x_2...x_{10}$) first, and then use these in the imputation model. </li> <li>I use the aggregate score in the imputation model. </li> </ol> <p>I am aware that using a transformation of a variable in the final model after the imputation (e.g. $x^2$ when you only included $x$ in the imputation) biases the effect of $x^2$ to zero. I am not sure if this is also the case with a categorisation and summation? In which case, I assume (2) would be the best option. Otherwise (1) seems best to me. I have already discounted (3) because it seems to lose a great deal of the richness of the data.</p> <p>Thanks in advance. </p>
g74299
[ 0.03249574825167656, -0.04796513542532921, -0.024710139259696007, -0.06784239411354065, 0.008479627780616283, -0.03169378638267517, 0.009078658185899258, 0.060160424560308456, -0.018846144899725914, 0.009807356633245945, -0.039136841893196106, 0.01805366575717926, 0.036710359156131744, 0.01195501908659935, 0.004822127986699343, -0.020463215187191963, 0.035359203815460205, -0.0427459292113781, -0.010656904429197311, 0.004531262908130884, -0.01377693098038435, 0.012578705325722694, 0.03296845033764839, -0.005278735887259245, -0.034525055438280106, -0.023665791377425194, -0.002138338750228286, 0.03965988755226135, -0.05047193542122841, 0.06090082228183746, -0.0405731126666069, -0.03345734253525734, 0.0038863737136125565, -0.016364743933081627, -0.02717328816652298, 0.0015307781286537647, 0.06719819456338882, 0.04720771685242653, 0.026661017909646034, -0.0243593268096447, -0.0013747198972851038, -0.00494620343670249, 0.09509865194559097, 0.0405907928943634, -0.04818832501769066, 0.019390976056456566, 0.005544012412428856, 0.0017307506641373038, -0.0007191242766566575, -0.0016109553398564458, 0.01804937608540058, 0.01499085407704115, 0.025034243240952492, 0.0049817063845694065, 0.013202432543039322, 0.004438976291567087, 0.0207793191075325, -0.01743820495903492, 0.023570215329527855, 0.015897413715720177, 0.04471573606133461, 0.0005317166214808822, -0.05974262207746506, -0.032901324331760406, 0.05790768191218376, 0.003645742777734995, -0.008561866357922554, 0.058870624750852585, -0.025371141731739044, -0.048279210925102234, 0.0242522694170475, -0.046924833208322525, 0.05964207276701927, -0.05829722434282303, -0.04116671532392502, -0.0005966651951894164, -0.05961945652961731, -0.013221848756074905, -0.022357864305377007, 0.012333401478827, -0.01637996733188629, 0.03051118552684784, 0.10851635783910751, 0.01226742658764124, 0.00038646248867735267, -0.017019644379615784, -0.036027222871780396, 0.013921855017542839, -0.012866307981312275, 0.03473502770066261, 0.037151038646698, 0.013996315188705921, 0.022062622010707855, 0.03026609495282173, -0.054385844618082047, -0.06404636800289154, -0.06452782452106476, -0.0029770173132419586, 0.016666313633322716, 0.0323304757475853, -0.003273625858128071, 0.021085010841488838, 0.0029931380413472652, -0.05736633390188217, -0.03111797384917736, -0.009331650100648403, 0.0973428338766098, 0.010569418780505657, 0.030249755829572678, -0.018389606848359108, -0.013298330828547478, -0.007632544729858637, -0.011948885396122932, -0.012616562657058239, -0.012380477972328663, -0.055643480271101, 0.018809858709573746, 0.025358911603689194, -0.036536093801259995, -0.030955856665968895, 0.024661900475621223, -0.006935719400644302, 0.0308208167552948, 0.022526461631059647, -0.044900938868522644, -0.051650770008563995, -0.07762368768453598, 0.08073050528764725, 0.07320749759674072, -0.03548673540353775, -0.047862712293863297, -0.00793897733092308, 0.02095646597445011, 0.008270936086773872, 0.020765002816915512, -0.06054360419511795, 0.04024159163236618, 0.06050010770559311, -0.043490245938301086, 0.009133365005254745, -0.007987585850059986, 0.03459113836288452, 0.011526317335665226, 0.0027729514986276627, 0.01875137910246849, -0.0022608889266848564, 0.04269129037857056, -0.019342131912708282, 0.0009741290123201907, -0.026974856853485107, 0.009334330447018147, 0.027503566816449165, -0.031226037070155144, 0.027914857491850853, 0.0010434656869620085, 0.020206112414598465, 0.003341863164678216, 0.027570370584726334, -0.04289678856730461, -0.0391274057328701, 0.0571054182946682, -0.0065665352158248425, -0.01710197702050209, 0.009424655698239803, 0.015959568321704865, 0.016401154920458794, 0.0361814871430397, -0.037452325224876404, -0.02640724554657936, -0.01287795603275299, -0.035751376301050186, -0.031947825103998184, 0.08963881433010101, 0.06316222250461578, 0.07587101310491562, 0.06252671033143997, 0.0007701842696405947, -0.0213011484593153, -0.017795929685235023, -0.008233197964727879, 0.03090338408946991, 0.025933383032679558, 0.01692761853337288, -0.03473292663693428, 0.010584411211311817, -0.06320661306381226, -0.022047633305191994, 0.08662000298500061, -0.07331433147192001, 0.013942008838057518, 0.02417132630944252, 0.020829422399401665, 0.02920311875641346, -0.0013955050380900502, 0.005482664331793785, 0.04119718819856644, 0.09565936774015427, -0.05149907246232033, 0.022817255929112434, 0.0026522295083850622, 0.04519765079021454, 0.058771975338459015, -0.01842387020587921, -0.023860257118940353, -0.008220884017646313, -0.003973586950451136, -0.017323903739452362, -0.029465820640325546, -0.030480599030852318, -0.027907991781830788, -0.022108977660536766, -0.016958530992269516, 0.021738465875387192, 0.04869217053055763, 0.00934530608355999, -0.0058250222355127335, 0.020854799076914787, 0.038233622908592224, 0.03052891418337822, 0.009813378565013409, -0.0041236355900764465, -0.06857593357563019, 0.016573168337345123, 0.02650689147412777, -0.008480026386678219, 0.038063134998083115, 0.006110014393925667, 0.051410749554634094, -0.04215067997574806, -0.028871433809399605, -0.022007711231708527, -0.05055484548211098, 0.0151396868750453, -0.0815802589058876, 0.02646970935165882, 0.03936779871582985, 0.014636906795203686, -0.0044375089928507805, -0.022619662806391716, 0.006341589614748955, 0.015629088506102562, -0.01923563703894615, -0.04908652603626251, 0.003831448033452034, 0.018185047432780266, 0.0018757513025775552, 0.0226933304220438, -0.00397453410550952, 0.09362354874610901, 0.038968734443187714, -0.08423611521720886, 0.01571260578930378, -0.03722033649682999, -0.057734325528144836, 0.04719708114862442, -0.04238012060523033, 0.04825230687856674, 0.02451447769999504, 0.011877120472490788, 0.08677877485752106, 0.02401398867368698, -0.03714688867330551, -0.026493674144148827, 0.04005821794271469, -0.09304942935705185, -0.03183966875076294, 0.040757857263088226, -0.07493478059768677, 0.012247436679899693, -0.0037782243452966213, -0.02404075488448143, -0.02325328066945076, -0.0035587402526289225, 0.0012328058946877718, 0.032657697796821594, -0.009871031157672405, -0.010355837643146515, -0.020915700122714043, -0.02102692797780037, -0.024632463231682777, 0.0454181469976902, -0.024563036859035492, -0.050032444298267365, 0.005883296951651573, 0.04541118070483208, -0.026132764294743538, 0.11844862997531891, -0.05964741110801697, -0.029388410970568657, 0.05738787353038788, 0.01121605932712555, 0.028120145201683044, 0.05777607858181, -0.016387149691581726, -0.009696487337350845, 0.006898144725710154, 0.001323205535300076, -0.03666457533836365, 0.04823813959956169, -0.04789336770772934, 0.01639561913907528, -0.018940148875117302, -0.011212429031729698, 0.006066751666367054, 0.005810311529785395, -0.01682407036423683, -0.029033102095127106, 0.010494976304471493, 0.010578886605799198, -0.06128690391778946, 0.020916739478707314, -0.04085766524076462, -0.00875808671116829, -0.04294513165950775, 0.024557380005717278, -0.025764405727386475, -0.02370600216090679, -0.0023640445433557034, 0.020643526688218117, -0.017960522323846817, 0.005260080099105835, 0.01166761014610529, 0.040243152529001236, 0.00576262129470706, -0.007901808246970177, -0.008906936272978783, -0.03906300663948059, 0.010404064320027828, -0.04670194536447525, 0.023213021457195282, 0.007068909704685211, 0.04581465199589729, -0.02915332466363907, -0.04435829818248749, 0.041844386607408524, -0.02012847363948822, -0.03230644762516022, -0.0228998102247715, 0.004127321764826775, 0.005101319868117571, 0.007365971803665161, -0.024397732689976692, -0.007867975160479546, -0.012140383012592793, -0.010722546838223934, -0.03879350423812866, -0.007981737144291401, 0.08356142044067383, 0.015346521511673927, -0.015597048215568066, 0.02201923541724682, 0.004698359873145819, 0.010406494140625, 0.05989683419466019, 0.013921874575316906, 0.059288762509822845, 0.05727813020348549, -0.02803110145032406, -0.0314752459526062, 0.019883781671524048, 0.00739525118842721, -0.08573800325393677, -0.06701181828975677, 0.05053707957267761, 0.0065017458982765675, 0.03869118168950081, 0.034790799021720886, 0.04554189741611481, -0.0017984427977353334, -0.061872418969869614, 0.04958691820502281, -0.03759307041764259, -0.03500485420227051, -0.0418679416179657, -0.022881006821990013, -0.01531930547207594, 0.07440566271543503, 0.038705550134181976, -0.015499386936426163, 0.0719112679362297, 0.007303908932954073, 0.030470849946141243, 0.035373054444789886, 0.04327724501490593, -0.013531296513974667, -0.045777566730976105, 0.004750469699501991, -0.011378541588783264, -0.012218940071761608, -0.019783539697527885, 0.034131407737731934, -0.029633035883307457, -0.03639864921569824, -0.001016444992274046, 0.0738205835223198, -0.00796023104339838, -0.012419650331139565, -0.024388451129198074, -0.01515427976846695, 0.09420765936374664, -0.08089745789766312, 0.022373110055923462, 0.055876001715660095, 0.006762628443539143, -0.04526180028915405, -0.041114773601293564, 0.002190244849771261, 0.01559416577219963, -0.04723417013883591, 0.06408515572547913, -0.009977644309401512, -0.003869142383337021, 0.0113733084872365, -0.006257388740777969, 0.005043070297688246, 0.021633625030517578, 0.05664821341633797, -0.09168873727321625, -0.004000937100499868, 0.031507741659879684, -0.0056360820308327675, 0.05500228330492973, -0.09686806052923203, -0.03255125507712364, 0.01533670723438263, 0.06682254374027252, -0.0037805186584591866, 0.011956075206398964, -0.03085632435977459, -0.028542499989271164, -0.05542465299367905, 0.04068100079894066, 0.0730305016040802, 0.05058004707098007, 0.05221271887421608, 0.002205043798312545, -0.015571100637316704, 0.03807159140706062, -0.027851326391100883, -0.04256094992160797, -0.05147267505526543, -0.03969861939549446, -0.07198086380958557, -0.0026228020433336496, 0.01576811447739601, -0.021593917161226273, -0.04501917585730553, -0.05136249586939812, 0.0293591246008873, 0.06982696801424026, -0.03096143528819084, 0.038787778466939926, 0.014613425359129906, -0.021927449852228165, -0.034258194267749786, 0.0017816905165091157, 0.0377122163772583, 0.06750433146953583, -0.003508299123495817, 0.03258020430803299, -0.020725347101688385, -0.010875193402171135, 0.013737797737121582, -0.013263149186968803, 0.005291835404932499, -0.024661770090460777, -0.058748647570610046, -0.01957855001091957, 0.030060788616538048, -0.02040690928697586, -0.0363244004547596, 0.0077564911916852, 0.024518247693777084, 0.0013849682873114944, 0.06798300892114639, 0.030369604006409645, -0.045114997774362564, -0.028641249984502792, -0.019948026165366173, 0.0269811749458313, -0.01666945405304432, -0.031398072838783264, -0.01761610433459282, -0.013901004567742348, -0.036916621029376984, 0.000048471039917785674, 0.02294166386127472, -0.08653981983661652, 0.048216041177511215, 0.05084041506052017, 0.013337858021259308, 0.08029353618621826, 0.07047976553440094, 0.032649874687194824, -0.013207309879362583, 0.04013315960764885, 0.039652373641729355, -0.025144509971141815, 0.002187998266890645, 0.027182871475815773, -0.03794575855135918, 0.0839056521654129, 0.03256731852889061, -0.028660250827670097, -0.020153716206550598, 0.024076228961348534, 0.0015399318654090166, 0.02006884105503559, 0.01779092289507389, 0.053168635815382004, 0.006119766738265753, 0.003758171107620001, 0.005356647539883852, -0.02030930481851101, -0.01401517540216446, 0.008855683729052544, 0.038366734981536865, 0.0626843273639679, 0.02805461920797825, -0.04150787368416786, 0.06415281444787979, -0.0325918085873127, 0.014515022747218609, 0.04177014157176018, 0.008687655441462994, -0.05758000165224075, -0.04591786861419678, -0.08012603968381882, 0.01010842900723219, -0.07577534019947052, 0.07178043574094772, 0.028383158147335052, -0.023058978840708733, 0.0007656008820049465, -0.030462821945548058, 0.013494741171598434, -0.046054910868406296, 0.05374057590961456, -0.034170329570770264, 0.03085671178996563, -0.05622530356049538, 0.006971446797251701, -0.005508887115865946, -0.02606666274368763, 0.024828694760799408, -0.018006926402449608, 0.01571592502295971, -0.06553895771503448, -0.022557765245437622, -0.011332834139466286, 0.007104663178324699, -0.00935874693095684, 0.013495190069079399, 0.027202611789107323, 0.03233301639556885, -0.030143722891807556, 0.019672434777021408, -0.01139887422323227, 0.013015375472605228, 0.0007479917840100825, -0.025696920230984688, -0.02345609851181507, 0.012784069404006004, 0.01529834046959877, -0.026201244443655014, -0.02567470818758011, -0.03154320642352104, -0.03184628114104271, -0.04012163355946541, -0.007658921182155609, 0.02995191141963005, -0.0011298597091808915, 0.051150672137737274, -0.015715476125478745, 0.009874874725937843, 0.019073231145739555, -0.012321528047323227, 0.01836424134671688, 0.07686535269021988, 0.011944273486733437, -0.08095302432775497, -0.01779547519981861, -0.03091512806713581, 0.03442821651697159, 0.0006733768968842924, 0.03548036515712738, -0.02260291390120983, 0.030217336490750313, -0.04033524543046951, 0.005525258835405111, -0.02063225954771042, -0.012712951749563217, 0.0025762091390788555, -0.011807803064584732, -0.050675563514232635, -0.027973808348178864, -0.0486331433057785, 0.030538802966475487, -0.03037719428539276, 0.05181855708360672, -0.0009715178166516125, -0.06719646602869034, 0.06399280577898026, -0.050202637910842896, 0.06623049825429916, 0.03214675188064575, 0.0035015924368053675, -0.013534296303987503, 0.03209271654486656, 0.002834449987858534, -0.0701628252863884, 0.03496461734175682, -0.010833265259861946, 0.026012040674686432, 0.004032527562230825, -0.015483587980270386, -0.03717740997672081, 0.04944314435124397, -0.06962695717811584, 0.04672457277774811, 0.022895075380802155, -0.023329446092247963, 0.017399877309799194, 0.002949633402749896, -0.00740872323513031, 0.015107323415577412, 0.00026616849936544895, -0.02037568762898445, 0.01322171650826931, 0.016203012317419052, -0.0641796812415123, 0.020040588453412056, 0.0066411118023097515, 0.018077002838253975, -0.03462079539895058, 0.04161049425601959, 0.0033836965449154377, 0.03491824120283127, 0.032807521522045135, 0.038905274122953415, 0.01604616455733776, 0.045845311135053635, -0.06735729426145554, 0.007413865532726049, -0.03884730488061905, 0.010236390866339207, 0.034211404621601105, 0.0036907512694597244, -0.04597843065857887, 0.03257010877132416, -0.018137888982892036, -0.0112171471118927, -0.007747006602585316, -0.003330659819766879, 0.005929897539317608, 0.04656815901398659, 0.030827727168798447, 0.015664465725421906, 0.06589572131633759, 0.05460228770971298, -0.03085104003548622, -0.007630216423422098, -0.04406736046075821, -0.026428207755088806, 0.012160861864686012, 0.01169770397245884, -0.0009210544521920383, -0.06092437729239464, 0.03404630348086357, 0.019446490332484245, 0.060601964592933655, -0.007918701507151127, -0.053710564970970154, 0.022073687985539436, 0.027156757190823555, 0.04103942587971687, -0.011935454793274403, -0.05745195224881172, 0.00984743982553482, -0.008825731463730335, -0.04022843390703201, -0.006196454167366028, 0.024983858689665794, 0.018445979803800583, -0.035397425293922424, 0.01185180526226759, 0.021322300657629967, 0.016185302287340164, 0.027838993817567825, -0.04026307910680771, -0.03932422399520874, -0.05991743505001068, 0.023454928770661354, 0.009038378484547138, -0.013605884276330471, 0.028528869152069092, 0.01609877496957779, 0.043630458414554596, 0.02285950444638729, 0.019921274855732918, 0.0523124523460865, 0.051956579089164734, 0.003908937331289053, -0.05417509377002716, 0.010694902390241623, 0.022483287379145622, -0.02239682525396347, -0.05858118459582329, 0.022776691243052483, -0.03785615414381027, -0.015486793592572212, -0.03538571670651436, -0.011524694040417671, -0.037739165127277374, -0.009793606586754322, -0.03586295619606972, -0.021709034219384193, -0.03909115865826607, 0.02780410274863243, 0.044176794588565826, -0.03980262577533722, -0.020077211782336235, -0.03257128223776817, -0.022677335888147354, -0.022433575242757797, -0.0652758926153183, 0.026088248938322067, 0.05188359320163727, -0.028878547251224518, 0.0022000428289175034, -0.013981510885059834, -0.04965370520949364, -0.05696699023246765, -0.008680988103151321, 0.03417849540710449, 0.01685350202023983, 0.02976677194237709, -0.021177932620048523, -0.008535999804735184, -0.026022067293524742, -0.07951231300830841, -0.05130496621131897, 0.03517335653305054, -0.016034187749028206, 0.002281700959429145, 0.006712905131280422, -0.006493677385151386, 0.023875512182712555, 0.03488212823867798, -0.02770056761801243, -0.04890778660774231, 0.005671205464750528, -0.02854073792695999, 0.0002559047716204077, -0.019414979964494705, -0.02286657691001892, -0.013869968242943287, -0.046943679451942444, 0.017006324604153633, -0.05542250722646713, -0.006656963843852282, -0.01637265831232071, -0.04942088574171066, 0.025891466066241264, -0.028691710904240608, -0.027105914428830147, 0.00811014138162136, 0.015209915116429329 ]
<p>This is a questions I got for homework in <em>test planning and variance analysis</em>. I apologize in advance for the way my professor phrases things :D I would love to hear hints or tips on how to approach this. So here goes:</p> <blockquote> <p>A statistician decides to perform the next a-parametric test to examine the $H_0$ of variance Analysis. First he will calculate the test statistic in the following way: Calculating the ranks of all observations with no affiliation to a group, and calculating F statistics of the anova test on the ranks instead of on the observations. Then, he will calculate the p-value using a permutation test, since under $H_0$ there is the same chance for all the permutations of ranks when dividing into groups. </p> <ol> <li><p>What is the SST calculated on the ranks of observations? Show that the SST does not depend on the observations, only on the number of observations.</p></li> <li><p>Prove that the p-value of this test will be equal to the p-value that is calculated with permutation on the Kruskal-Wallis test statistic. Clue: Show that the test statistic of Kuskal-wallis is SSB/(SST/N-1) when SSB and SST are calculated on the ranks of observation and N is the total number of observations.</p></li> </ol> </blockquote> <p>This is what I've got for (1). Not sure about it but it makes sense to me.. What I don't get is how to show that SST does not depend on the observations, because obviously we need them in order to calculate the SST.</p> <p>$k$ - number of groups<br> $n_i$ - number of observations in group $i$<br> $\bar{d}$ - mean of ranks of all groups<br> $\bar{d}_i$ - mean of ranks in group $i$ </p> <p>$$\operatorname{SSB} = \sum_{i=1}^k n_i(\bar{d}_i-\bar{d})^2$$</p> <p>$$\operatorname{SSW} = \sum_{i=1}^k \sum_{j=1}^{n_i} (d_{ij}-\bar{d}_i)^2$$</p> <p>$$\operatorname{SST} = \sum_{i=1}^k \sum_{j=1}^{n_i} (d_{ij}-\bar{d})^2$$</p> <p>And actually when I think about it, I'm not so sure what is difference between the test that is described in this question and Kruskal Wallis.</p>
g37119
[ -0.061301298439502716, 0.027376940473914146, -0.009374826215207577, 0.00045616526040248573, -0.012878365814685822, -0.010435161180794239, 0.066890187561512, 0.003168565221130848, -0.04634577035903931, -0.022180378437042236, -0.013289429247379303, 0.053412288427352905, 0.014059394598007202, 0.05269748345017433, -0.00864601880311966, 0.007241180632263422, 0.0937299132347107, -0.038310203701257706, -0.022888444364070892, -0.022253651171922684, -0.01619388721883297, -0.0058172112330794334, 0.0023242910392582417, -0.0013876308221369982, 0.0621187761425972, -0.0587131567299366, -0.02638622745871544, 0.03729665279388428, -0.10601839423179626, -0.003996419720351696, 0.021070696413517, 0.0016428476665169, 0.04851122573018074, -0.04933520406484604, -0.02556614950299263, 0.012243623845279217, 0.057040441781282425, 0.0051098293624818325, -0.024753523990511894, 0.007848473265767097, -0.05168253183364868, 0.05371736362576485, 0.016224918887019157, -0.006814298685640097, -0.027312111109495163, 0.00416646059602499, 0.01771670952439308, 0.02621123380959034, 0.03115810453891754, 0.027439214289188385, -0.023036058992147446, 0.05048603564500809, 0.0637039765715599, -0.011064962483942509, 0.018882226198911667, 0.03231177106499672, 0.03110017441213131, -0.00995176937431097, 0.07122255116701126, 0.03218774497509003, 0.012227118946611881, 0.01063672173768282, -0.013722571544349194, -0.010707264766097069, 0.03576299175620079, -0.028581053018569946, 0.023624613881111145, -0.027668150141835213, -0.003414446720853448, -0.017720213159918785, -0.010932940989732742, -0.021465547382831573, 0.04647252336144447, -0.013274221681058407, -0.08372250944375992, 0.010245298966765404, 0.02072468027472496, -0.0032299510203301907, -0.005612893495708704, -0.0019849662203341722, 0.0008867630967870355, -0.017726100981235504, 0.034821685403585434, 0.040712375193834305, 0.044019900262355804, -0.023733889684081078, 0.013940204866230488, -0.00970403105020523, 0.03744851052761078, 0.058383598923683167, 0.0013346236664801836, -0.005285685416311026, 0.054705291986465454, 0.05186636000871658, -0.04764535278081894, -0.002048811409622431, -0.044093918055295944, 0.057480793446302414, 0.002541235415264964, 0.010339795611798763, -0.015056349337100983, 0.07290979474782944, -0.00735230278223753, -0.026650475338101387, -0.027356574311852455, -0.021602902561426163, -0.02978876605629921, 0.058866459876298904, 0.0078831035643816, -0.021741313859820366, -0.070714071393013, 0.017581453546881676, -0.05272752046585083, -0.038138363510370255, -0.029219361022114754, -0.0014995021047070622, -0.007367679849267006, 0.016344385221600533, -0.03404898941516876, -0.0057018776424229145, 0.03446076810359955, 0.041149917989969254, -0.043471451848745346, 0.039417196065187454, -0.04531917721033096, 0.01669108308851719, -0.03266124054789543, 0.03410474956035614, 0.012064501643180847, 0.025788014754652977, 0.04289620742201805, -0.03150760754942894, -0.03541763499379158, 0.03925005719065666, 0.04916888847947121, -0.02052428387105465, 0.020010901615023613, 0.03609910607337952, 0.016631707549095154, -0.0035488144494593143, -0.06285581737756729, 0.04799928143620491, -0.004820970818400383, 0.008068924769759178, -0.009107248857617378, -0.002619757317006588, 0.04394201934337616, -0.054562900215387344, -0.056866902858018875, -0.0014986839378252625, -0.022679420188069344, 0.06783867627382278, -0.04554269090294838, -0.00885697826743126, -0.020636171102523804, -0.054268136620521545, 0.0279147420078516, 0.023105813190340996, 0.038483891636133194, 0.0392976738512516, 0.011027010157704353, -0.04197970777750015, 0.015315074473619461, 0.008472006767988205, -0.027178635820746422, -0.03368566557765007, -0.003499456448480487, -0.022459538653492928, 0.029210252687335014, -0.0743672251701355, -0.009228515438735485, -0.004841201938688755, 0.03798357769846916, 0.0053301346488296986, -0.037098228931427, 0.045919280499219894, 0.005490186624228954, -0.007166991475969553, -0.006026978604495525, 0.09003908932209015, 0.004950424190610647, 0.014911151491105556, 0.019857242703437805, -0.04810992255806923, 0.009144416078925133, 0.01591656357049942, -0.020898357033729553, 0.007914370857179165, -0.0560503713786602, -0.019924135878682137, -0.002458218950778246, -0.010974342003464699, 0.049015503376722336, 0.0023353020660579205, -0.02783559449017048, 0.021746039390563965, 0.011023045517504215, -0.05200740322470665, 0.03376535326242447, 0.011682076379656792, 0.011499840766191483, 0.006204287987202406, -0.036381687968969345, 0.05961668863892555, 0.03765714168548584, 0.013697918504476547, -0.027215810492634773, 0.014651303179562092, -0.041848018765449524, -0.008418823592364788, -0.0030134879052639008, -0.04752761125564575, 0.049762241542339325, 0.032154712826013565, -0.006599318701773882, 0.026723796501755714, 0.012531153857707977, 0.022392719984054565, 0.021593835204839706, 0.013457754626870155, -0.0004437754687387496, -0.04201376065611839, -0.010870386846363544, -0.007588389329612255, -0.03734678402543068, 0.07210423052310944, 0.024772150442004204, -0.03866155073046684, 0.00003241920785512775, 0.02327534556388855, -0.03904721513390541, -0.06552562117576599, 0.00011917951633222401, 0.0009641656070016325, 0.039807941764593124, 0.06320515275001526, 0.003762334119528532, 0.006956461351364851, 0.04629582539200783, 0.019257908686995506, -0.018831973895430565, 0.005347004625946283, -0.004888067487627268, 0.011394196189939976, 0.05849051848053932, 0.04280925914645195, 0.04464507848024368, -0.028127683326601982, 0.020120037719607353, 0.07773618400096893, -0.04270987585186958, 0.0382530502974987, 0.03477637842297554, -0.016070010140538216, 0.023624300956726074, -0.08032343536615372, -0.018390541896224022, 0.01123026106506586, 0.02057480625808239, 0.03972432017326355, -0.013505695387721062, -0.03760005906224251, 0.030003869906067848, -0.0030991805251687765, 0.041211653500795364, -0.009425959549844265, -0.050088584423065186, -0.011075837537646294, -0.007864928804337978, -0.017642201855778694, -0.00916728749871254, 0.043041810393333435, 0.04036569967865944, 0.04223254695534706, -0.024332484230399132, -0.027173254638910294, -0.020762227475643158, -0.052468422800302505, 0.01882440224289894, 0.006684040650725365, 0.014833490364253521, -0.018697049468755722, -0.04160916805267334, -0.021001942455768585, 0.024033518508076668, -0.03079621121287346, 0.05397966876626015, -0.036549683660268784, 0.011460863053798676, 0.0025066714733839035, 0.027130011469125748, 0.015867434442043304, 0.033884745091199875, 0.011068100109696388, 0.027286840602755547, -0.011410199105739594, 0.0235487911850214, -0.030871732160449028, 0.0022704212460666895, 0.03490971401333809, -0.03716830164194107, 0.04395106062293053, 0.008215276524424553, 0.005816238932311535, 0.11995208263397217, -0.012199857272207737, -0.01871837116777897, -0.0590185672044754, 0.020379893481731415, 0.048043105751276016, -0.022936811670660973, -0.01897028274834156, 0.008818000555038452, -0.09521719068288803, 0.0053222752176225185, -0.043434027582407, 0.015959184616804123, 0.0022600237280130386, -0.019361058250069618, -0.01635000668466091, -0.005918236915022135, -0.014842844568192959, 0.005084270611405373, 0.05586128681898117, -0.019297873601317406, 0.04940299317240715, -0.06062634289264679, 0.026751145720481873, -0.04175543785095215, -0.04052114859223366, 0.018289679661393166, 0.01682918891310692, 0.03009704500436783, -0.042466118931770325, 0.0032394849695265293, -0.06649889051914215, 0.03685559332370758, -0.03542815148830414, -0.0383245013654232, 0.06932032108306885, 0.01854529231786728, -0.06511474400758743, 0.026680519804358482, 0.06242956221103668, -0.01589268445968628, -0.02481743134558201, 0.0610739104449749, 0.026224594563245773, -0.02818269096314907, 0.004483281169086695, 0.022520696744322777, 0.010457763448357582, 0.04948946461081505, -0.039926689118146896, 0.042609695345163345, 0.04569617658853531, 0.0539902038872242, -0.008137318305671215, 0.03961192071437836, 0.025458024814724922, 0.024948550388216972, -0.040244944393634796, -0.03714844584465027, 0.031677983701229095, 0.05197332799434662, 0.027838194742798805, 0.007908172905445099, 0.06403997540473938, 0.04266810789704323, -0.0012968960218131542, 0.03910978138446808, -0.014071804471313953, 0.012250307016074657, -0.033677827566862106, 0.028728870674967766, 0.010367447510361671, 0.04546996206045151, 0.03529650345444679, -0.01471172459423542, 0.04690660908818245, 0.03747841715812683, 0.0025251738261431456, -0.002760299015790224, 0.007734659127891064, 0.014070427976548672, 0.020221227779984474, 0.008562247268855572, 0.011650525964796543, -0.002043577376753092, -0.044682033360004425, 0.04743229225277901, 0.030689353123307228, -0.08761116862297058, 0.0320584699511528, 0.004912391770631075, -0.024185238406062126, 0.040352948009967804, 0.05519413948059082, -0.030919324606657028, 0.09027045220136642, -0.009769080206751823, -0.042415544390678406, 0.06124310940504074, -0.011860929429531097, -0.03546837717294693, -0.039080243557691574, 0.003270405810326338, -0.007737219333648682, -0.017209570854902267, 0.044800352305173874, -0.014376161620020866, 0.07151398807764053, -0.0024722206871956587, -0.05525471270084381, 0.004234763327986002, 0.025692684575915337, 0.009454155340790749, 0.00398640101775527, -0.05515469238162041, -0.006126404274255037, -0.05474568158388138, -0.02115819789469242, 0.013372954912483692, -0.06910759210586548, -0.0008354303427040577, -0.03847098350524902, -0.017093295231461525, 0.05153380706906319, -0.01611897349357605, -0.05920856446027756, -0.015036286786198616, 0.013902990147471428, -0.030780253931879997, 0.007742684800177813, -0.030525103211402893, -0.03267247974872589, 0.014546333812177181, 0.020650425925850868, -0.036589063704013824, 0.01565781980752945, -0.01636778935790062, -0.0031924741342663765, -0.053627029061317444, 0.004206461366266012, 0.01607455313205719, 0.029931774362921715, -0.005718102678656578, 0.005355171859264374, -0.00216879416257143, 0.030429404228925705, -0.020556017756462097, 0.043785449117422104, -0.008828697726130486, -0.04480130597949028, -0.012206658720970154, -0.0681120753288269, 0.0021425383165478706, -0.00008655676356283948, 0.06537716835737228, -0.010063452646136284, -0.014261295087635517, -0.026250941678881645, -0.0033400757238268852, -0.015384652651846409, 0.03523163124918938, -0.0006723276455886662, -0.08653213828802109, -0.026519061997532845, -0.03705763816833496, 0.003294332418590784, -0.01627124845981598, -0.018482554703950882, 0.028838343918323517, -0.018750810995697975, -0.07005628943443298, 0.06263501197099686, 0.002879129955545068, 0.011284470558166504, 0.017892662435770035, -0.029311159625649452, -0.004843436647206545, 0.00907442532479763, 0.025780698284506798, 0.028350813314318657, 0.016033925116062164, -0.00036914361407980323, -0.02045617811381817, -0.10372793674468994, 0.01674230396747589, 0.01842300407588482, -0.03198165446519852, 0.009177963249385357, 0.0662173256278038, -0.0016786629566922784, -0.012280069291591644, -0.03207821771502495, 0.09205496311187744, 0.005204090848565102, 0.03937014564871788, -0.05277330428361893, -0.022360406816005707, 0.04162272438406944, 0.08431791514158249, -0.032363954931497574, -0.010069156996905804, -0.009341868571937084, 0.054387129843235016, 0.009548118337988853, 0.037075385451316833, 0.02942708693444729, -0.03764071688055992, 0.012433093972504139, 0.07788804173469543, 0.02390613593161106, -0.01762417145073414, -0.005767923779785633, 0.009701854549348354, -0.010540499351918697, -0.029487106949090958, -0.05826213210821152, 0.013762831687927246, 0.008332333527505398, 0.013150148093700409, -0.01688646711409092, 0.023035170510411263, -0.08032428473234177, -0.07517602294683456, -0.03776402026414871, 0.023010045289993286, -0.01987639255821705, -0.006439352408051491, -0.017916064709424973, -0.009358525276184082, -0.017869912087917328, 0.06256849318742752, -0.043492913246154785, 0.008541632443666458, 0.0093839131295681, 0.013967488892376423, 0.01816161349415779, -0.052135106176137924, -0.01311925146728754, 0.019643381237983704, -0.029862677678465843, 0.011820931918919086, -0.019943689927458763, -0.06044011935591698, 0.0036424363497644663, 0.0073718540370464325, 0.021460888907313347, -0.030377183109521866, 0.06519211828708649, -0.016853727400302887, -0.0066295526921749115, -0.022249236702919006, -0.0114999208599329, 0.008420998230576515, -0.0742160975933075, 0.028444837778806686, -0.06372008472681046, 0.010962688364088535, -0.07027174532413483, -0.0051050251349806786, 0.011941433884203434, 0.029681414365768433, -0.029961463063955307, -0.04439019039273262, -0.004265534691512585, -0.0020201969891786575, 0.02222953364253044, -0.005427125841379166, -0.0016715737292543054, -0.022389743477106094, 0.018233228474855423, -0.022508962079882622, 0.005505593493580818, 0.0002254306455142796, -0.008362485095858574, 0.05545582249760628, 0.010683126747608185, -0.025845874100923538, -0.019184423610568047, 0.0006730954628437757, 0.0233958438038826, -0.011999628506600857, 0.06381677836179733, 0.005942222662270069, -0.009556424804031849, -0.02522554248571396, -0.006098385434597731, -0.0618726946413517, 0.0008647983777336776, -0.025309178978204727, -0.000606269168201834, 0.048214588314294815, -0.005933117587119341, 0.03775964304804802, 0.004602266475558281, -0.019006846472620964, -0.016338257119059563, 0.007178265135735273, -0.05206695944070816, 0.0629763975739479, -0.038388099521398544, -0.007959102280437946, 0.024966580793261528, -0.025195682421326637, 0.004570473451167345, -0.009597018361091614, 0.006864308379590511, -0.06159744784235954, 0.0006835318054072559, 0.06781771034002304, 0.1179313138127327, -0.007759517058730125, -0.005405861884355545, -0.03234422206878662, -0.0012242367956787348, -0.022817838937044144, 0.0231022946536541, 0.0748075321316719, -0.0410616435110569, -0.017178241163492203, -0.037173543125391006, -0.006354044191539288, 0.073356993496418, 0.01194706466048956, -0.026512935757637024, 0.035808105021715164, 0.05359363183379173, -0.04441138729453087, 0.013083859346807003, -0.02610194683074951, -0.026927875354886055, -0.06361047178506851, 0.012130598537623882, -0.058975689113140106, 0.10841596871614456, 0.018703436478972435, 0.08734463900327682, -0.032088130712509155, 0.013675622642040253, -0.039350904524326324, -0.041471052914857864, -0.028274770826101303, 0.037221577018499374, 0.000525014940649271, 0.012014541774988174, -0.03071325272321701, 0.014738913625478745, 0.043348897248506546, -0.02928842045366764, -0.02173018641769886, -0.06219412013888359, 0.015884412452578545, 0.02044655941426754, 0.07596773654222488, 0.03867221251130104, 0.057721931487321854, -0.008607745170593262, -0.07612123340368271, -0.023218052461743355, -0.03983798250555992, 0.010248411446809769, -0.0029130405746400356, 0.04515004903078079, 0.011409569531679153, 0.013999903574585915, 0.016634423285722733, -0.02208651974797249, 0.030988553538918495, 0.027359236031770706, -0.04180532321333885, -0.010742882266640663, 0.039312854409217834, 0.0030717705376446247, -0.0011367487022653222, 0.08085371553897858, -0.07981214672327042, -0.0002999224525410682, -0.06109512969851494, -0.03879626467823982, -0.010073963552713394, -0.027862567454576492, -0.012590133585035801, -0.008393757045269012, -0.03393649309873581, -0.01736409217119217, 0.05753253772854805, -0.04938525706529617, -0.006711785215884447, -0.020526131615042686, 0.034222546964883804, -0.02149227447807789, -0.011977368965744972, 0.017581745982170105, 0.0077067166566848755, -0.017224330455064774, -0.011760926805436611, 0.03255925327539444, 0.054763734340667725, 0.004278516862541437, -0.07415512949228287, -0.01899552531540394, 0.020399153232574463, -0.06248455494642258, 0.03318953886628151, -0.05137120932340622, -0.06360829621553421, -0.006349195260554552, 0.021793600171804428, -0.010867567732930183, -0.02761242352426052, 0.029894787818193436, 0.035872623324394226, -0.007647817023098469, -0.05330252647399902, -0.018903901800513268, -0.06128201633691788, -0.019325681030750275, -0.019366102293133736, 0.022845422849059105, 0.02635098434984684, -0.033485811203718185, -0.030086681246757507, -0.08923676609992981, 0.022484106943011284, 0.07496964186429977, 0.0008255769498646259, 0.006889162119477987, -0.0400019995868206, -0.026942692697048187, -0.0819290280342102, 0.03531188890337944, -0.0007856687298044562, 0.03734065219759941, 0.040841009467840195, -0.02729816548526287, -0.0021127909421920776, -0.07427859306335449, -0.03300296142697334, 0.004623599350452423, 0.05827879533171654, -0.02573651820421219, -0.030491884797811508, -0.03188924118876457, -0.061303917318582535, 0.0018056686967611313, -0.014287437312304974, -0.022877536714076996, -0.05032443627715111, 0.05398353561758995, 0.008072737604379654, 0.05040820688009262, 0.007639613002538681, 0.02780052460730076, 0.024982284754514694, -0.027854345738887787, 0.03098185732960701, -0.0005667455843649805, -0.006536774802953005, 0.01162293367087841, -0.12678022682666779, 0.03546258062124252, 0.02074124664068222, -0.0847092941403389, -0.03789222985506058, 0.005175433121621609 ]
<p>In this <a href="http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/04/06/sampling-rate/" rel="nofollow">blog article</a> an example is given of one can use the DFT to detect frequencies much higher than the sample rate. In the comments sections I asked how it was done, since DFT normally requires evenly sampled data. The author of the blog responded concisely with: </p> <blockquote> <p>One can still define the DFT as proportional to</p> <p>$$ X(\nu) = {1 \over N} \sum x_n e^{-i 2 \pi \nu t_n} $$ </p> </blockquote> <p>How would one do that? I am asking for advice to do exactly that. I can replicate the example if I use the data compensated method of Ferraz-Mello <a href="http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/04/06/sampling-rate/" rel="nofollow">1</a> but the blog author says that normally DFT will work using that hint.</p> <p><a href="http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/04/06/sampling-rate/" rel="nofollow">1</a> <a href="http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-iarticle_query?1981AJ.....86..619F&amp;data_type=PDF_HIGH&amp;whole_paper=YES&amp;type=PRINTER&amp;filetype=.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-iarticle_query?1981AJ.....86..619F&amp;data_type=PDF_HIGH&amp;whole_paper=YES&amp;type=PRINTER&amp;filetype=.pdf</a></p>
g74300
[ 0.06901513785123825, 0.03015761449933052, -0.007925604470074177, -0.07824207097291946, 0.0369323305785656, -0.09220928698778152, -0.026010556146502495, 0.040607500821352005, -0.02044622227549553, -0.026705609634518623, -0.0172991044819355, -0.030282005667686462, 0.04726088047027588, 0.006299495697021484, -0.05890609323978424, 0.028111532330513, 0.030776724219322205, 0.04297328367829323, 0.013802783563733101, 0.01696571335196495, -0.011243308894336224, 0.06492863595485687, 0.0058912793174386024, -0.043805163353681564, 0.006479030940681696, -0.12442423403263092, -0.014769097790122032, 0.02291915751993656, -0.0886252149939537, 0.0077397823333740234, -0.04865477606654167, -0.012267217971384525, -0.005625192541629076, 0.018155185505747795, -0.0006331115146167576, 0.01990826614201069, -0.017259633168578148, 0.02307298220694065, -0.07475337386131287, 0.02336905337870121, 0.008753268048167229, -0.03160324692726135, 0.01836688444018364, -0.007083326578140259, -0.01689392514526844, -0.007262956351041794, -0.04496431723237038, -0.017225967720150948, -0.01973416469991207, 0.010694270953536034, -0.03510945290327072, -0.003307742765173316, 0.016658077016472816, -0.018697744235396385, 0.0048063755966722965, -0.024574609473347664, 0.0030838875100016594, -0.04142262414097786, -0.001984498929232359, 0.00787623506039381, 0.01622382551431656, 0.014054981991648674, 0.0002519495610613376, -0.014888137578964233, 0.0059128329157829285, 0.08768460154533386, 0.006181532051414251, -0.030483750626444817, 0.01702963560819626, -0.007446793373674154, -0.057358622550964355, 0.0050027379766106606, -0.04386790469288826, -0.011334048584103584, -0.034853655844926834, -0.03161847963929176, -0.019015977159142494, -0.004902270622551441, 0.022855183109641075, 0.014097264036536217, -0.01854011043906212, 0.017289845272898674, 0.016401903703808784, -0.00738475052639842, 0.018995951861143112, -0.010840073227882385, 0.0287531279027462, -0.021543806418776512, 0.05971277505159378, 0.052752088755369186, 0.01661604456603527, -0.047203321009874344, 0.08780141174793243, -0.0014948995085433125, 0.017416751012206078, 0.04889601096510887, -0.05205751955509186, 0.014123471453785896, 0.024996519088745117, -0.05729406327009201, 0.002443179953843355, 0.08098030090332031, 0.0014274062123149633, -0.012627946212887764, -0.08539621531963348, 0.00892370380461216, 0.054264675825834274, -0.010103996843099594, -0.05775250867009163, -0.04474416747689247, 0.0028150067664682865, -0.03762566298246384, -0.04887087643146515, -0.04441339522600174, -0.046931080520153046, 0.037258680909872055, 0.05287490785121918, 0.028563490137457848, -0.07524758577346802, 0.003240571590140462, 0.006590755190700293, 0.01502327248454094, 0.023124517872929573, 0.08850929886102676, -0.05358210206031799, -0.020176123827695847, 0.012018515728414059, 0.03259863331913948, -0.032273028045892715, 0.012151233851909637, 0.034447379410266876, -0.04859026148915291, 0.028067318722605705, 0.02244279533624649, 0.006694132462143898, 0.0227754358202219, 0.01697027124464512, 0.04673878103494644, -0.012265773490071297, 0.026921460404992104, -0.02040509693324566, 0.019597794860601425, 0.050060126930475235, -0.03712891414761543, 0.007509149145334959, -0.027978837490081787, -0.009798526763916016, -0.013495276682078838, 0.06337147206068039, -0.03405364230275154, 0.005772548262029886, 0.05944575369358063, -0.03343161195516586, -0.029409335926175117, 0.051987405866384506, 0.019790079444646835, 0.02579527720808983, -0.023622170090675354, -0.061115432530641556, 0.06665036082267761, -0.0018638065084815025, 0.0014622006565332413, 0.0008450836758129299, -0.020239856094121933, 0.0285002700984478, 0.011998718604445457, 0.009656643494963646, -0.013902274891734123, 0.0032762715127319098, -0.06115745007991791, 0.0006530274986289442, 0.02833792194724083, -0.03665871545672417, -0.025003153830766678, 0.0337647944688797, 0.03221490979194641, 0.04063250124454498, -0.037120599299669266, -0.038298942148685455, -0.01364822220057249, -0.026550300419330597, -0.006743045058101416, 0.041658565402030945, 0.0003911410749424249, 0.06417112797498703, 0.00744367903098464, 0.040757279843091965, -0.024423768743872643, -0.008090263232588768, 0.028667572885751724, -0.0876188576221466, -0.03290785849094391, 0.0006444252794608474, 0.05366084352135658, -0.037079136818647385, 0.007166316732764244, 0.026508521288633347, -0.08457712829113007, -0.04821913689374924, 0.04536886140704155, -0.013500966131687164, 0.01985142007470131, -0.02080579102039337, 0.007608181796967983, 0.013183992356061935, -0.04573972523212433, -0.014747058041393757, 0.012170250527560711, 0.0030910572968423367, 0.013413424603641033, -0.014799238182604313, -0.008784683421254158, -0.051986631006002426, 0.0676930844783783, -0.01817939057946205, 0.018436703830957413, -0.010025382041931152, 0.014607910998165607, -0.013263578526675701, 0.05231181159615517, 0.014036795124411583, -0.03589878976345062, 0.00841598492115736, 0.05364030599594116, -0.031251486390829086, -0.05243125930428505, 0.027547404170036316, 0.01532174926251173, -0.02530929632484913, 0.04230894893407822, -0.008641382679343224, -0.04644695296883583, -0.06550934165716171, 0.0005250912508927286, -0.00025817996356636286, 0.06921074539422989, 0.011657007969915867, 0.025068270042538643, 0.0002528595505282283, 0.02960815094411373, -0.024001212790608406, -0.00009567339293425903, 0.0002511093916837126, 0.019937768578529358, 0.01051320880651474, -0.013499449007213116, 0.011067597195506096, 0.015844251960515976, 0.009574967436492443, 0.07398701459169388, -0.007856946438550949, -0.005952107720077038, 0.02564810775220394, -0.049153003841638565, 0.02795824222266674, -0.04113110899925232, 0.029391255229711533, -0.001467373687773943, 0.030828122049570084, 0.014588778838515282, 0.0026592134963721037, -0.025015605613589287, 0.0522516630589962, -0.038842521607875824, -0.005668726749718189, -0.03575890511274338, -0.010097406804561615, -0.0038939642254263163, -0.01829444244503975, 0.004564001690596342, -0.019151126965880394, -0.001758971018716693, 0.017843695357441902, 0.029377596452832222, -0.027288367971777916, 0.01308352965861559, 0.016701126471161842, -0.024821598082780838, 0.007513427175581455, 0.033546749502420425, 0.022327587008476257, 0.023386092856526375, 0.02797345072031021, 0.05283227935433388, 0.04491821676492691, -0.0012221558718010783, 0.03195730224251747, -0.016592171043157578, -0.049529120326042175, -0.004744827281683683, -0.008827362209558487, -0.04099011421203613, -0.0244631078094244, -0.0006975609576329589, -0.008620284497737885, 0.021649379283189774, 0.02406703308224678, -0.08707667887210846, 0.015254409052431583, 0.04402437433600426, -0.015932152047753334, -0.02601216919720173, 0.06262201815843582, 0.09829293936491013, 0.023167897015810013, -0.0025534823071211576, -0.005051464308053255, 0.021083936095237732, -0.0020843225065618753, 0.03533775731921196, 0.009658686816692352, -0.012958289124071598, 0.019281510263681412, -0.07341426610946655, 0.02079770527780056, 0.026136869564652443, 0.042025353759527206, -0.035203952342271805, 0.027957521378993988, -0.02826746553182602, 0.04824061319231987, -0.022462360560894012, 0.021008381620049477, 0.005645516328513622, -0.00805392675101757, 0.06238524615764618, -0.051277484744787216, 0.048099152743816376, -0.004282700829207897, -0.001527866697870195, 0.1062542200088501, -0.01249657478183508, -0.04645668342709541, -0.054840367287397385, 0.006264470983296633, -0.026088619604706764, 0.004332967568188906, 0.05135422199964523, 0.08547776192426682, 0.00133785221260041, -0.03838295117020607, 0.006110158748924732, 0.0037659441586583853, -0.06580642610788345, -0.04493343457579613, 0.01738150790333748, 0.019627945497632027, 0.03891269490122795, -0.036730024963617325, 0.04838952794671059, 0.0038351062685251236, -0.0072097815573215485, -0.024279193952679634, -0.02877391129732132, 0.05314334109425545, 0.047085486352443695, 0.0889340415596962, 0.04248126223683357, 0.017075520008802414, -0.023013534024357796, 0.044273506850004196, -0.03142911568284035, -0.008383006788790226, 0.012713361531496048, 0.011038712225854397, 0.022118138149380684, 0.014485564082860947, 0.03012438304722309, -0.04196398705244064, -0.0024713685270398855, -0.04547059163451195, -0.034078679978847504, 0.0247708261013031, 0.043291281908750534, -0.025102442130446434, -0.03748863562941551, 0.054136890918016434, 0.039747390896081924, 0.018638186156749725, 0.004222121089696884, 0.010466192848980427, 0.023444123566150665, -0.024288248270750046, -0.055067773908376694, 0.03574914112687111, -0.037183728069067, -0.02121763676404953, -0.03402768447995186, 0.013540943153202534, 0.012281340546905994, 0.0027049703057855368, -0.01842503249645233, -0.05141996219754219, 0.05657641962170601, -0.03379436954855919, -0.04529647156596184, -0.038843024522066116, 0.050632815808057785, 0.0028978665359318256, 0.04189884662628174, 0.02775595895946026, -0.018308017402887344, -0.01839357428252697, 0.017827166244387627, -0.019560150802135468, -0.011447384022176266, -0.020463373512029648, -0.030735962092876434, 0.011841065250337124, 0.014513734728097916, -0.0784829780459404, -0.043053943663835526, -0.0014971246710047126, 0.011285366490483284, -0.01352335698902607, 0.05443050339818001, 0.02547241374850273, -0.009514950215816498, 0.03499406576156616, -0.010953505523502827, -0.01518985629081726, 0.07427845150232315, -0.037111442536115646, 0.019548669457435608, -0.02816089056432247, -0.0052042994648218155, -0.024991149082779884, 0.042134422808885574, 0.018102046102285385, 0.013607797212898731, 0.03881557285785675, 0.007527190260589123, -0.006730442401021719, 0.018810568377375603, -0.04642283171415329, -0.011796236038208008, -0.02319846861064434, 0.015198642387986183, 0.04256903752684593, 0.016231395304203033, -0.040688809007406235, -0.016885442659258842, -0.05605413764715195, -0.020388945937156677, -0.025438502430915833, 0.0797678753733635, -0.010725375264883041, 0.009469971060752869, 0.04310917854309082, 0.001860439428128302, 0.016473373398184776, 0.025407416746020317, 0.008906357921659946, -0.04544025659561157, 0.03545764833688736, -0.03254875913262367, -0.010111515410244465, 0.008828841149806976, 0.013819696381688118, 0.012697470374405384, -0.01955530419945717, 0.030910488218069077, -0.04352874681353569, -0.05303758755326271, -0.021161265671253204, 0.00312175159342587, -0.0035178549587726593, -0.035713665187358856, -0.012693425640463829, -0.0429106168448925, -0.012506207451224327, -0.07469908893108368, -0.00012987789523322135, 0.014985565096139908, -0.03545094281435013, 0.050603535026311874, 0.03966962918639183, -0.03504319116473198, 0.0015331252943724394, -0.023595072329044342, 0.004245976451784372, -0.04073430225253105, 0.021926652640104294, 0.004869082011282444, 0.021147195249795914, -0.04959283024072647, -0.03873380273580551, -0.07812996953725815, -0.01609082706272602, -0.04767756909132004, 0.0031510049011558294, 0.044198375195264816, 0.003646792843937874, 0.03095330484211445, -0.06068676337599754, 0.020236721262335777, 0.047204453498125076, -0.009771243669092655, 0.009585004299879074, -0.05402796342968941, -0.0699615627527237, -0.007477030623704195, -0.02375422976911068, -0.0297006294131279, 0.0072969370521605015, -0.0038716651033610106, 0.08874155580997467, 0.02411428466439247, 0.019658608362078667, 0.011389518156647682, 0.02907724678516388, 0.03229725360870361, 0.032821040600538254, -0.006985200569033623, 0.02684376947581768, 0.00464277621358633, 0.020634973421692848, 0.018939338624477386, -0.042495906352996826, -0.03234454244375229, 0.04977415129542351, -0.024379311129450798, 0.007744001690298319, 0.05464637652039528, 0.013024384155869484, -0.044102828949689865, -0.02836325578391552, -0.06664718687534332, 0.041061144322156906, -0.01186518557369709, 0.006742371711879969, 0.014098837040364742, -0.03704005107283592, 0.008445383049547672, 0.03964501619338989, -0.00792626291513443, 0.029963403940200806, -0.033173568546772, -0.03508198261260986, 0.024235282093286514, -0.017179936170578003, 0.04265279695391655, 0.10330277681350708, 0.010161207988858223, -0.03582422435283661, -0.07391054928302765, 0.014479851350188255, -0.026388375088572502, -0.014130951836705208, -0.04156472533941269, -0.011145542375743389, -0.04182371497154236, -0.0020834661554545164, 0.010446903295814991, 0.019616292789578438, 0.006048833951354027, 0.008114559575915337, -0.007468101568520069, 0.05027048662304878, -0.05536370724439621, -0.011623524129390717, -0.04480933025479317, 0.023777173832058907, 0.008971190080046654, -0.0008756282622925937, -0.008061745204031467, 0.01622035726904869, -0.028190093114972115, -0.036893926560878754, -0.018259918317198753, -0.0252562053501606, -0.054763197898864746, -0.0031178079079836607, -0.04469858855009079, 0.04133520647883415, 0.04624921828508377, -0.010748578235507011, 0.007729469332844019, -0.04572476074099541, -0.04385504126548767, -0.06392902135848999, -0.015224194154143333, 0.002390193985775113, 0.006641788873821497, -0.02515779621899128, 0.039788637310266495, -0.03417736291885376, 0.02949090674519539, -0.02654034085571766, -0.0352548211812973, -0.052124250680208206, -0.028304746374487877, -0.0444742776453495, -0.007200863678008318, -0.017595570534467697, -0.027797585353255272, 0.054886363446712494, 0.033055853098630905, -0.0698370411992073, 0.02907111681997776, -0.01482556201517582, -0.06497913599014282, 0.06459249556064606, -0.08060065656900406, 0.01887574791908264, -0.004345714580267668, 0.016847779974341393, -0.00481741689145565, -0.04304613918066025, -0.002282852539792657, -0.043278999626636505, 0.016252871602773666, 0.040483199059963226, -0.010171884670853615, -0.0625607818365097, -0.019967718049883842, -0.0035624485462903976, 0.0054847667925059795, 0.04141932353377342, 0.06506359577178955, 0.07146149128675461, 0.0019492998253554106, 0.0027863443829119205, -0.03132971376180649, 0.035833463072776794, 0.09444525837898254, -0.006978040095418692, -0.029395829886198044, 0.053729910403490067, -0.02034900337457657, 0.017896801233291626, 0.06594014167785645, -0.06775017082691193, 0.014335626736283302, -0.07842867821455002, 0.02594621852040291, 0.01626059040427208, 0.0527549684047699, 0.08203014731407166, 0.0652269721031189, -0.03121422789990902, 0.03458572179079056, 0.015141889452934265, -0.008054668083786964, -0.039548762142658234, -0.015364544466137886, 0.045730605721473694, 0.0776326134800911, -0.03809737786650658, -0.03855227679014206, 0.04605993628501892, -0.010909686796367168, 0.021307041868567467, 0.02270047552883625, -0.00807839073240757, 0.11924954503774643, 0.10174279659986496, 0.0351744182407856, 0.046298835426568985, -0.04038642346858978, -0.04821447655558586, -0.09281402081251144, 0.007055407855659723, 0.0032567617017775774, -0.016141073778271675, 0.01850799098610878, 0.015030722133815289, 0.002197290537878871, 0.01602124236524105, -0.00005628160943160765, 0.018546555191278458, -0.014385522343218327, 0.01860967092216015, 0.05071335285902023, 0.058329179883003235, -0.016865668818354607, 0.020084358751773834, 0.05905468761920929, -0.05841632932424545, -0.0027311041485518217, 0.01695236563682556, 0.010340024717152119, 0.0028396055568009615, -0.10026438534259796, -0.0014120350824669003, -0.04060499370098114, -0.08882496505975723, 0.02860528603196144, 0.06396613270044327, -0.008337358012795448, -0.04023155942559242, 0.020817795768380165, 0.02029111608862877, 0.0128423310816288, -0.044096413999795914, 0.031236477196216583, 0.031769510358572006, -0.017584186047315598, -0.013991788029670715, 0.03425274044275284, 0.0008640563464723527, 0.04391007497906685, 0.006204815115779638, -0.011850962415337563, 0.03718075901269913, -0.02241501584649086, 0.013240018859505653, -0.02766468934714794, 0.0006981986225582659, -0.04384224861860275, 0.05627989023923874, -0.024244725704193115, -0.042780112475156784, 0.0005214758566580713, 0.032920729368925095, 0.002865211572498083, -0.025751875713467598, -0.03888541832566261, -0.009451162070035934, -0.0264873206615448, 0.017495866864919662, 0.024656282737851143, -0.0064797112718224525, -0.04423417150974274, -0.0007687613251619041, -0.09270455688238144, 0.0008891529287211597, 0.046327464282512665, 0.04456564784049988, 0.04666823893785477, 0.00864860787987709, -0.04541575163602829, -0.006099267862737179, 0.007532733958214521, -0.010927027091383934, 0.05463365837931633, 0.04318290576338768, -0.0058983066119253635, -0.006355714052915573, 0.04038083553314209, -0.05327838286757469, 0.025240931659936905, 0.010460779070854187, 0.012743077240884304, 0.008236740715801716, -0.010878481902182102, -0.04939108341932297, 0.016200639307498932, 0.005022688768804073, -0.00560001190751791, -0.005814770702272654, 0.010004289448261261, -0.02716827392578125, 0.023148342967033386, 0.015998966991901398, -0.039285123348236084, 0.026651548221707344, -0.00530588161200285, 0.07581954449415207, -0.05660143494606018, 0.011870088055729866, -0.035638757050037384, -0.07045024633407593, 0.0018993830308318138, 0.0031789212953299284, -0.03218604996800423, 0.042741067707538605, -0.010342340916395187 ]
<p>I feel like every question I've asked on CrossValidated has lead back to looking at the number of observations I have per variable. I understand that there are many rules of thumb out there depending on your field, your expected effect size, etc. These come back to recognizing that too few observations can lead to overfitting.</p> <p>I understand how overfitting can be a problem when looking at a regression model with a single predictor. Having only two observations leads to a perfect answer, whereas using least squares to solve an overdetermined model leads to generalization. However, I have trouble making sense of how overfitting can still be a problem if you have 20 predictors and, say, 31 observations. It seems like you have mitigated the problem with 10 extra observations, but I suspect I am missing something in how least squares solves overdetermined systems.</p> <p>What I assume follows if it is true that a system is overfitted is that the relationships between predictors explained by the betas also do not hold.</p> <p>Finally, if overfitting is a problem by having not enough observations, can this be solved by using forward stepwise regression? Or is there a good possibility of missing significant predictors due to eventually reaching a point where there are too many predictors and not enough observations?</p> <p>To recap:</p> <ol> <li><p>Can someone explain why the case where the number of predictors is $N-1$ where $N$ is decently large (say, $N &gt; 10$) can still overfit? Why is it not that you need a minimum number of observations <strong>regardless</strong> of the number of predictors?</p></li> <li><p>Can overfitting be solved by using forward stepwise regression?</p></li> </ol>
g37123
[ 0.022488584741950035, 0.03907867521047592, 0.0007312434026971459, -0.034780241549015045, 0.020731890574097633, -0.0364699512720108, 0.069789357483387, 0.015411539003252983, -0.0073907445184886456, -0.05335594713687897, -0.01088700070977211, -0.030351927503943443, 0.010189976543188095, 0.03562665730714798, -0.0003374857478775084, 0.03370034694671631, 0.07727210223674774, -0.02241537906229496, 0.004036081489175558, -0.027209550142288208, 0.031012525781989098, -0.05374813824892044, 0.017982816323637962, 0.026237525045871735, -0.10743726044893265, 0.0016287380130961537, -0.018378229811787605, 0.0388546846807003, -0.049544259905815125, 0.02031063474714756, -0.015145016834139824, 0.020222190767526627, 0.007392710540443659, 0.000831984041724354, -0.027712740004062653, 0.006441393401473761, 0.03650529310107231, -0.02492057904601097, -0.00974247232079506, 0.0034026296343654394, 0.007797985803335905, 0.017723925411701202, 0.039698317646980286, 0.016218366101384163, -0.004844688344746828, -0.007290590554475784, 0.016756895929574966, 0.00973349530249834, 0.06719726324081421, 0.020308129489421844, 0.005907681304961443, -0.007958762347698212, 0.003892938606441021, 0.04638109356164932, 0.02240866608917713, 0.02362024039030075, -0.02044982835650444, 0.021151311695575714, 0.03366456180810928, -0.030436238273978233, 0.03434666618704796, -0.009581181220710278, -0.09403428435325623, 0.025038596242666245, -0.00047946081031113863, -0.0025331955403089523, -0.02196565270423889, -0.01888933964073658, 0.05233047530055046, -0.053918302059173584, 0.022426575422286987, -0.022599637508392334, 0.0006876063416711986, -0.061741117388010025, -0.03114226832985878, -0.01398514024913311, -0.009386349469423294, 0.056519269943237305, 0.02774651162326336, 0.034600552171468735, 0.010352603159844875, 0.006619918625801802, 0.020600883290171623, 0.03466560319066048, 0.014952237717807293, 0.044017184525728226, 0.03743881732225418, 0.01680493727326393, 0.01289947796612978, -0.022763514891266823, 0.016992326825857162, -0.004132571630179882, 0.048967283219099045, 0.012949729338288307, 0.02336142212152481, -0.02465604618191719, -0.07092354446649551, -0.03490637242794037, -0.008790066465735435, 0.006771612912416458, -0.001614960958249867, 0.05868896096944809, -0.04154522716999054, -0.01350620947778225, -0.04118482396006584, 0.03869486227631569, 0.026809727773070335, 0.04860616475343704, 0.0026011765003204346, 0.011274842545390129, -0.07057277858257294, 0.046632517129182816, 0.02214031293988228, -0.026050526648759842, -0.05369457229971886, 0.021295849233865738, 0.052935801446437836, 0.07444801926612854, -0.010867680422961712, -0.004445877857506275, 0.03623548522591591, -0.015126559883356094, 0.02778845652937889, -0.0030645939987152815, -0.02056390605866909, 0.030246537178754807, -0.04033515229821205, 0.05421650409698486, 0.006739020347595215, 0.07057277858257294, 0.019555265083909035, -0.006337479222565889, -0.041480597108602524, 0.021807242184877396, 0.042406853288412094, 0.06080193072557449, -0.008635698817670345, 0.037009675055742264, 0.00388155085965991, 0.015048254281282425, -0.008157403208315372, 0.015359128825366497, 0.023414071649312973, -0.045619383454322815, -0.00009415305976290256, 0.03301020711660385, -0.02726145274937153, 0.010166710242629051, -0.005554000847041607, -0.01702720858156681, -0.005176520440727472, 0.0009125827928073704, -0.014936724677681923, 0.016233710572123528, -0.05631832405924797, -0.0024185602087527514, -0.0370732918381691, -0.04544466361403465, -0.0204938817769289, -0.026967044919729233, 0.04780054837465286, -0.007957516238093376, -0.05331568047404289, -0.005907614249736071, -0.013166147284209728, -0.000876712379977107, -0.04966230317950249, -0.07412196695804596, -0.03641648218035698, -0.0387679785490036, 0.025838151574134827, -0.0039142705500125885, 0.10416357219219208, 0.02389552816748619, 0.07123314589262009, 0.06197287142276764, 0.07787159085273743, -0.016360050067305565, 0.03284633159637451, 0.009236096404492855, -0.004333477932959795, 0.0372326485812664, 0.00848014559596777, 0.012664257548749447, -0.014956185594201088, -0.04153544828295708, -0.03821539506316185, -0.012701654806733131, -0.02938315086066723, 0.0054402584210038185, 0.020329752936959267, 0.007654094137251377, 0.0016329658683389425, -0.0284914318472147, 0.006929865572601557, -0.005424151197075844, 0.06499207019805908, -0.02826850861310959, -0.07740653306245804, -0.004780929069966078, 0.042914316058158875, -0.015991756692528725, -0.029092086479067802, 0.09089435636997223, 0.0035262610763311386, 0.0771234855055809, -0.037616193294525146, -0.011886250227689743, 0.005275910720229149, 0.03117852844297886, 0.00019604898989200592, -0.02761487476527691, 0.0013127243146300316, 0.007512672804296017, -0.014990460127592087, -0.047783005982637405, 0.04910097271203995, 0.03614044189453125, -0.0216558538377285, -0.027636202052235603, -0.03267759457230568, -0.03720616549253464, 0.042285893112421036, 0.019147111102938652, -0.004413020331412554, 0.03979789465665817, -0.01445144321769476, 0.009405218996107578, 0.028033748269081116, -0.009815341793000698, -0.022633923217654228, -0.05533690005540848, 0.019410602748394012, -0.019379399716854095, 0.047993164509534836, 0.006219292525202036, 0.02659977413713932, -0.018115602433681488, 0.01967780664563179, 0.042601361870765686, 0.028979631140828133, -0.013562834821641445, 0.011610742658376694, 0.010013467632234097, 0.04463201388716698, -0.022623034194111824, 0.027349812909960747, -0.020588824525475502, -0.02510816417634487, 0.032398223876953125, -0.07461880892515182, 0.11137803643941879, 0.003001212375238538, -0.07565867900848389, -0.025523895397782326, -0.03939792141318321, -0.014012233354151249, 0.07396914809942245, -0.022159425541758537, -0.01727408543229103, -0.0033281936775892973, 0.027614178135991096, -0.04823238030076027, -0.05373907461762428, -0.033498894423246384, -0.041401851922273636, -0.03894234448671341, 0.0026934752240777016, 0.01843041554093361, 0.04580467939376831, 0.04569825902581215, 0.002680285833775997, -0.0027425673324614763, 0.054844990372657776, 0.037266116589307785, 0.0370950810611248, -0.07623366266489029, 0.04771773889660835, 0.05829370394349098, 0.04767560213804245, 0.019369134679436684, -0.06296399235725403, -0.06669978052377701, 0.00043398377601988614, 0.054961543530225754, -0.0009352141059935093, 0.0547383688390255, -0.0410882793366909, 0.05187155306339264, 0.0036628292873501778, -0.004145973827689886, 0.006566590629518032, 0.058366719633340836, -0.060995493084192276, -0.038694847375154495, -0.049066681414842606, -0.015395999886095524, -0.00580876087769866, 0.015006662346422672, -0.006187941879034042, -0.0657847672700882, 0.06937669962644577, 0.06679404526948929, -0.01181288342922926, 0.042859941720962524, 0.007042739074677229, -0.04385211691260338, -0.010428701527416706, -0.04912293702363968, -0.033434607088565826, 0.029410412535071373, 0.006962413899600506, -0.018954772502183914, -0.019571390002965927, -0.017016328871250153, -0.039955396205186844, -0.06329118460416794, 0.06036647409200668, 0.026533327996730804, -0.0553540475666523, 0.025608064606785774, 0.015933969989418983, -0.012170552276074886, 0.013294029049575329, -0.006356522906571627, 0.01067329104989767, -0.05129284784197807, 0.002297226805239916, -0.034801021218299866, 0.045966874808073044, 0.06136457622051239, 0.0012011061189696193, -0.020757291465997696, -0.009305041283369064, 0.044950101524591446, -0.06202468276023865, -0.029386017471551895, -0.036401279270648956, 0.03395575284957886, 0.00021064547763671726, -0.023816417902708054, -0.0029470876324921846, 0.0018660792848095298, -0.0035663286689668894, -0.01092478446662426, 0.007138676941394806, 0.0013838674640282989, 0.057810768485069275, 0.016818735748529434, -0.04180285707116127, 0.02918224036693573, 0.014973007142543793, -0.051365163177251816, 0.022470412775874138, -0.010727799497544765, 0.05019256845116615, 0.02427555061876774, 0.03276225924491882, 0.049825653433799744, 0.009999833069741726, 0.035110484808683395, -0.046943940222263336, 0.023548204451799393, 0.0001617108064237982, 0.04703840613365173, 0.037567753344774246, 0.03643711283802986, -0.007804251275956631, 0.03306751325726509, -0.030259868130087852, 0.016194645315408707, -0.004035809077322483, -0.0471869632601738, 0.0026298046577721834, 0.0316791869699955, -0.05501488223671913, 0.09000277519226074, 0.004361279774457216, -0.03273038566112518, 0.010101048275828362, 0.03962062671780586, 0.04034271091222763, -0.09069784730672836, 0.011791090480983257, 0.011055287905037403, -0.022362394258379936, 0.008143173530697823, -0.038508299738168716, -0.0574469156563282, 0.02222375199198723, -0.010587946511805058, -0.05364244058728218, -0.02807474322617054, 0.0601518452167511, 0.01578301191329956, -0.028980426490306854, 0.0426890030503273, 0.003237079828977585, 0.028040720149874687, 0.014079896733164787, -0.017973925918340683, 0.012320427224040031, 0.04435286298394203, -0.022557690739631653, -0.015146018005907536, -0.050375234335660934, 0.0027031174395233393, 0.04837309196591377, -0.08730825036764145, 0.008475270122289658, 0.03471696004271507, 0.05872562900185585, -0.02647535502910614, -0.06753236055374146, 0.04137300327420235, 0.01596144586801529, 0.028269287198781967, -0.017576953396201134, -0.01671881414949894, -0.054872285574674606, -0.011051642708480358, 0.04916541650891304, -0.05242159217596054, -0.024766290560364723, 0.020162707194685936, 0.0588400661945343, -0.033770494163036346, -0.04362739622592926, -0.01447807066142559, -0.03819960728287697, 0.04242247715592384, 0.03126564994454384, -0.022412573918700218, 0.03536183387041092, 0.008254051208496094, -0.014770523644983768, 0.04589412733912468, -0.006999630481004715, -0.03706156462430954, 0.004355565644800663, -0.0051653627306222916, -0.017109615728259087, -0.04078545421361923, 0.04181183874607086, -0.026184115558862686, -0.07451457530260086, -0.011016267351806164, -0.015923477709293365, -0.03467538580298424, 0.04356768727302551, 0.039180200546979904, 0.021504081785678864, 0.007852199487388134, -0.015941211953759193, -0.010239475406706333, -0.03934323042631149, 0.007868215441703796, -0.004430957138538361, -0.02387026511132717, 0.005700958427041769, -0.012316206470131874, -0.06375953555107117, 0.023051023483276367, 0.02452845498919487, 0.008625119924545288, 0.004499091766774654, -0.02340848557651043, -0.053488727658987045, -0.026644783094525337, 0.03204990550875664, -0.04362703859806061, 0.03411957994103432, 0.033253639936447144, 0.037622515112161636, -0.06045324355363846, -0.016282200813293457, -0.030276672914624214, 0.012712189927697182, 0.01708589866757393, 0.043400347232818604, -0.02562624402344227, -0.020843299105763435, 0.019398117437958717, -0.01614473946392536, -0.01952003873884678, -0.04032698646187782, 0.0041435048915445805, -0.08205604553222656, 0.022955799475312233, 0.0065969377756118774, -0.02918434701859951, 0.023764487355947495, 0.005957585293799639, 0.013879215344786644, -0.08887657523155212, -0.022251449525356293, 0.01082595344632864, -0.03010152094066143, -0.024416383355855942, -0.05703257769346237, -0.04153500497341156, 0.04384639114141464, 0.010716491378843784, -0.016810061410069466, 0.00550016388297081, -0.01632734388113022, 0.032053831964731216, -0.06298831850290298, 0.007646332960575819, 0.012435040436685085, -0.00008588981290813535, 0.0677671730518341, 0.06749524921178818, -0.06186104938387871, -0.0037750042974948883, -0.05397918447852135, -0.03461425006389618, 0.03654520958662033, -0.03373898193240166, -0.038758162409067154, 0.013223388232290745, -0.027952229604125023, 0.0247406717389822, -0.028385087847709656, 0.023020315915346146, -0.09625793993473053, -0.06728943437337875, -0.03068777173757553, -0.00897549744695425, -0.0003214221214875579, 0.03589784726500511, -0.02761818841099739, -0.008999492973089218, 0.05123758688569069, -0.036092594265937805, 0.04941631853580475, -0.015145454555749893, 0.025781936943531036, 0.0455479770898819, 0.0031731179915368557, 0.027806024998426437, 0.006594498176127672, -0.002834940329194069, -0.03449292480945587, -0.028815144672989845, -0.05265382304787636, -0.03674675151705742, 0.03231707960367203, -0.015455485321581364, 0.0032739010639488697, -0.002051254501566291, 0.035570766776800156, -0.04515732452273369, 0.00455398578196764, -0.01047452911734581, 0.010287566110491753, -0.010672674514353275, 0.01765519194304943, 0.009720071218907833, -0.02337866835296154, -0.07757608592510223, -0.03740959241986275, 0.008521441370248795, -0.0016028123209252954, 0.004617252387106419, 0.03616906329989433, -0.0456058569252491, -0.009460614994168282, -0.022754140198230743, 0.02843507193028927, -0.029472719877958298, -0.05303958058357239, 0.10415192693471909, 0.07302208244800568, -0.009260469116270542, -0.0016135433688759804, 0.009488102048635483, 0.021327177062630653, 0.007759514264762402, -0.028729289770126343, 0.022749025374650955, 0.007413637358695269, -0.044276509433984756, -0.04053633287549019, 0.05531667545437813, 0.07833729684352875, -0.05174996331334114, 0.0077755930833518505, -0.013250666670501232, 0.0035461767110973597, -0.014909487217664719, -0.04875561222434044, 0.04163121432065964, -0.030498186126351357, -0.00023881900415290147, -0.0031042895279824734, -0.0008134875679388642, 0.05220918357372284, -0.00886140950024128, -0.040890276432037354, 0.018418045714497566, -0.011234033852815628, 0.06765644997358322, -0.01672765053808689, 0.003958981018513441, 0.015007684007287025, -0.051236171275377274, -0.04111392796039581, 0.02467638999223709, -0.041183535009622574, -0.04448055103421211, -0.02986845187842846, 0.011951953172683716, 0.03581967577338219, 0.010321514680981636, -0.039566487073898315, 0.007619508076459169, 0.05300479382276535, 0.010786428116261959, 0.0619596429169178, 0.0361899770796299, -0.02605823427438736, -0.03837721794843674, -0.0008102252031676471, -0.01397483330219984, 0.016227612271904945, 0.061787303537130356, -0.014103922992944717, 0.10988619923591614, 0.026554640382528305, -0.005005606450140476, -0.005167659837752581, -0.04734816029667854, 0.039894089102745056, -0.021199338138103485, 0.045805834233760834, -0.06786855310201645, 0.027240697294473648, 0.0011125124292448163, 0.06082652136683464, -0.023503242060542107, 0.03120323456823826, -0.029897596687078476, -0.00787415262311697, 0.0009363036951981485, 0.025710739195346832, 0.05708388239145279, 0.0332392156124115, -0.0601249635219574, -0.030573131516575813, 0.004645257256925106, 0.03176187351346016, 0.006692671682685614, -0.04094303771853447, -0.029041258618235588, 0.04593287408351898, 0.014623289927840233, -0.004687617067247629, 0.07768858969211578, 0.06798463314771652, 0.005147905554622412, -0.04664987698197365, -0.07857734709978104, -0.02566736377775669, 0.050779715180397034, -0.004857359919697046, -0.013288282789289951, -0.04310455173254013, -0.03168020769953728, -0.050463225692510605, -0.015455220825970173, -0.07156726717948914, -0.032018765807151794, 0.04548702389001846, 0.03315111622214317, -0.018230563029646873, 0.041308771818876266, 0.02739332988858223, -0.04022534191608429, -0.009133429266512394, 0.010510271415114403, -0.03082629293203354, -0.00285115628503263, 0.03574115037918091, -0.037063706666231155, 0.03816445171833038, -0.03508967161178589, 0.019612303003668785, -0.01651698350906372, -0.05192222446203232, -0.0029353154823184013, -0.042879749089479446, 0.05000730976462364, -0.0312756672501564, 0.02400045655667782, 0.0713505744934082, -0.028106139972805977, -0.007399233989417553, 0.015255389735102654, 0.02206151746213436, 0.01019916869699955, 0.054985709488391876, -0.04941343143582344, -0.03131386637687683, 0.05651800334453583, -0.01416734978556633, 0.005355677101761103, -0.06418269872665405, 0.05500325188040733, 0.015964068472385406, -0.05371797829866409, 0.016002150252461433, -0.06364664435386658, 0.015205319970846176, -0.005426179151982069, 0.010200452990829945, -0.018580419942736626, -0.04915854334831238, -0.008214389905333519, -0.06107225641608238, -0.04192190244793892, 0.016262494027614594, 0.019274409860372543, 0.02303767390549183, -0.009595445357263088, -0.015882328152656555, -0.013465073890984058, -0.01906120777130127, -0.03489056974649429, 0.026758773252367973, -0.04629717022180557, -0.05018097907304764, -0.043520089238882065, 0.050707533955574036, -0.019446633756160736, 0.039879828691482544, 0.005851097870618105, 0.0019664084538817406, -0.09393175691366196, 0.0306483693420887, -0.02414066344499588, 0.02610831707715988, 0.0034137137699872255, -0.026288365945219994, -0.010556819848716259, -0.0010781059972941875, 0.005538650322705507, 0.05077170208096504, 0.04132033511996269, 0.04311303794384003, -0.03873323276638985, 0.047375526279211044, 0.04774564877152443, 0.04829281568527222, 0.004807745572179556, -0.024397481232881546, 0.03293639048933983, -0.0193815678358078, -0.0449613556265831, -0.0016991834854707122, -0.005101772490888834, 0.04842948913574219, 0.01156081072986126, -0.032047152519226074, 0.016372837126255035, -0.0004097485507372767, -0.024892283603549004, 0.0018814790528267622 ]
<h1>Problem</h1> <p>I want to estimate the probability of a user choosing a car or transit as a transport mode. Following is the output of the simple logistic regression:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/9qQZC.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I want to estimate the probability of choosing car (auto) if INVT for auto = 3, INVT for transit = 7, OVT for auto = 1, OVT for transit = 2.5, OPC for auto =2 and transit fare = 3.</p> <h1>What I tried</h1> <p>For the probability of choosing car when the user owns a car and work in suburbs, I am using INVT for auto, OVT for auto, OPC for auto and transit fare along with AO as 1 and DW as 0.</p> <blockquote> <p>The probability = Pr = exp(1.45 - (0.00897*3) -(0.0308*1) - (0.0115*2) -(0.00708*3) +(0.77 * 1) - (0.561*0))/(1+exp(1.45 - (0.00897*3) -(0.0308*1) - (0.0115*2) -(0.00708*3) +(0.77 * 1) - (0.561*0)))</p> <p>Pr = 0.893</p> </blockquote> <h1>Question</h1> <p>Is this the right approach to find this probability? Or should I also include the INVT, OVT and OPC for transit as well?</p>
g74301
[ -0.01404782384634018, 0.0017753422725945711, 0.015308859758079052, 0.0054088737815618515, 0.022660842165350914, -0.04244130477309227, 0.01750597357749939, -0.005073671229183674, -0.04588703438639641, 0.01512504369020462, -0.001743391971103847, 0.008520537056028843, 0.08737611025571823, 0.004914931952953339, -0.009053850546479225, 0.010176763869822025, 0.01480149757117033, -0.0053914389573037624, 0.02206665650010109, -0.02322075329720974, -0.024218762293457985, -0.02709709107875824, 0.000986613449640572, -0.02509644813835621, 0.015092235989868641, -0.02522851899266243, 0.013929060660302639, 0.03021996282041073, -0.03905720263719559, -0.00811484083533287, 0.020512355491518974, 0.016757279634475708, 0.03683646023273468, -0.05580167472362518, -0.053325772285461426, -0.044322140514850616, 0.09747424721717834, 0.021838564425706863, 0.002055995399132371, 0.0231121014803648, 0.0027631500270217657, -0.045571304857730865, 0.06238524243235588, 0.04380940645933151, -0.008872173726558685, 0.01338945608586073, -0.0006091787945479155, 0.0005610717926174402, 0.02675471268594265, 0.04903446510434151, -0.012197410687804222, 0.03463365137577057, -0.024503862485289574, -0.010289023630321026, 0.005727977957576513, 0.010583936236798763, -0.024371204897761345, -0.02486831322312355, -0.03328404203057289, -0.021808156743645668, 0.020778542384505272, 0.0097141582518816, 0.0061452048830688, -0.05287330597639084, 0.02900068089365959, 0.04506189748644829, -0.026646843180060387, 0.03935113549232483, 0.060880739241838455, -0.017223354429006577, 0.03513522446155548, 0.022569263353943825, -0.03107042796909809, -0.07969564199447632, -0.002462937729433179, 0.005519860424101353, 0.022607631981372833, 0.012719511985778809, 0.07689962536096573, 0.10034319758415222, -0.018389619886875153, -0.023300420492887497, 0.00042596255661919713, 0.059270963072776794, 0.026152420789003372, 0.06547591835260391, 0.014752417802810669, -0.05749789997935295, 0.010413242504000664, -0.04363645613193512, 0.0102398581802845, 0.008679629303514957, 0.0725635513663292, 0.05012328177690506, -0.038693077862262726, -0.07233462482690811, -0.13127227127552032, -0.020967744290828705, 0.047449201345443726, 0.019643399864435196, 0.012289164587855339, 0.01639135740697384, -0.012732068076729774, -0.04294316843152046, -0.05510594695806503, -0.03710683062672615, -0.012885581701993942, 0.02082652598619461, -0.02792777121067047, -0.028454717248678207, -0.023475997149944305, 0.018808823078870773, -0.00316266599111259, -0.05600618198513985, -0.03947240114212036, -0.010622546076774597, 0.032925549894571304, -0.008296934887766838, 0.05419212579727173, 0.009274311363697052, -0.012371329590678215, 0.010757680982351303, 0.04943036660552025, 0.040555886924266815, 0.03468120098114014, -0.0015705553814768791, -0.08253739029169083, 0.04852777346968651, 0.06354785710573196, 0.005225144326686859, -0.01590181328356266, 0.02190343290567398, 0.036356326192617416, -0.002272046869620681, -0.036731526255607605, 0.06594234704971313, 0.01002206839621067, 0.025624651461839676, 0.010801011696457863, 0.04033864662051201, 0.010552952997386456, 0.06901300698518753, -0.00039660747279413044, 0.0008886907598935068, -0.027032023295760155, 0.07354618608951569, -0.06003250181674957, 0.025329316034913063, -0.037051063030958176, -0.04331604763865471, -0.048528123646974564, -0.0039571416564285755, -0.0503360815346241, 0.04989629611372948, -0.03855001926422119, -0.0008558183326385915, 0.04728405550122261, -0.028391161933541298, -0.03396506980061531, 0.02895737998187542, 0.04113566502928734, -0.07553710788488388, -0.0308824572712183, 0.018488192930817604, -0.02709045074880123, -0.031248722225427628, 0.024689948186278343, -0.03663025051355362, -0.0049872309900820255, 0.009244725108146667, 0.02424454875290394, -0.05347460135817528, -0.0009819241240620613, -0.027922367677092552, 0.06423138827085495, -0.0636766254901886, 0.04720047116279602, 0.023665394634008408, 0.01171173807233572, 0.04265768453478813, 0.0333709679543972, 0.007113139610737562, 0.01750751957297325, -0.021076422184705734, -0.03897237405180931, -0.07926330715417862, -0.02066754549741745, 0.03756984323263168, -0.05181768536567688, 0.011373943649232388, -0.020981090143322945, -0.030621612444519997, -0.006642144639045, -0.007164310198277235, -0.04951706901192665, -0.02123231813311577, 0.06333480030298233, -0.02471703477203846, -0.013261674903333187, 0.00030767000862397254, 0.04980572313070297, -0.03259594365954399, -0.009063339792191982, 0.039528485387563705, -0.010280360467731953, -0.0014148501213639975, 0.04212106764316559, 0.000054318650654749945, 0.02940264157950878, -0.03492957353591919, 0.010601288639008999, 0.032473064959049225, -0.06431049108505249, 0.042984187602996826, -0.029750313609838486, -0.049195922911167145, 0.06498986482620239, 0.019848311319947243, 0.003046733560040593, -0.04744464159011841, -0.005170030519366264, -0.06006472557783127, -0.014006764627993107, 0.028941946104168892, -0.07097864151000977, 0.07395751774311066, 0.03303621709346771, -0.03529539704322815, 0.025363143533468246, 0.08823011070489883, 0.020205363631248474, -0.03210877627134323, -0.008905814960598946, -0.035423386842012405, 0.06896751374006271, 0.007901562377810478, 0.004182980861514807, -0.008948437869548798, -0.033200737088918686, 0.0037686408031731844, 0.010352281853556633, 0.010215401649475098, 0.0021914648823440075, -0.011874906718730927, 0.030526721850037575, -0.050556667149066925, 0.02079842984676361, -0.01107218861579895, 0.05112230405211449, 0.07545732706785202, -0.08984718471765518, 0.03541797026991844, -0.052279677242040634, -0.060004111379384995, 0.05444823578000069, -0.021913079544901848, 0.01467735506594181, 0.0031540258787572384, 0.012656555511057377, 0.04920551925897598, -0.0214194655418396, 0.006825917400419712, 0.03897702321410179, 0.0019883462227880955, -0.0007851477712392807, -0.05109171196818352, 0.001066748984158039, -0.031730636954307556, 0.016405578702688217, 0.012554311193525791, -0.05276020988821983, -0.026635050773620605, -0.046394139528274536, 0.018938519060611725, 0.0921068862080574, -0.020633425563573837, -0.04835626110434532, -0.03956971317529678, -0.0276404470205307, 0.031089523807168007, 0.0661088302731514, -0.03385104611515999, -0.01656174100935459, 0.012949938885867596, 0.02261359989643097, 0.00946188997477293, 0.09009048342704773, 0.01827624812722206, 0.0172077938914299, 0.02678997442126274, 0.025378404185175896, 0.024467792361974716, -0.004449609201401472, 0.00845719501376152, 0.054773006588220596, 0.02032654732465744, 0.030650274828076363, -0.024213138967752457, 0.026647139340639114, 0.018094031140208244, -0.025212399661540985, -0.041418176144361496, 0.03256566449999809, 0.016996663063764572, 0.039286255836486816, -0.033793143928050995, -0.04110295698046684, 0.032093122601509094, 0.02977166324853897, 0.005463524255901575, 0.02990332432091236, 0.0004257502732798457, -0.0195865910500288, -0.005791838280856609, -0.015480853617191315, -0.005006461404263973, -0.014700070023536682, -0.028499066829681396, 0.0114999795332551, -0.021359989419579506, -0.024668660014867783, -0.02062021940946579, 0.007254886906594038, 0.03803955391049385, -0.005811828188598156, 0.03785577043890953, -0.012651403434574604, 0.00840817205607891, 0.0036056635435670614, -0.0034726166632026434, 0.015047769993543625, 0.06176252290606499, 0.00888650119304657, -0.012577866204082966, -0.029099486768245697, -0.05197066441178322, 0.042411644011735916, 0.01669272594153881, -0.007966648787260056, 0.016771776601672173, -0.010050151497125626, -0.04788445308804512, 0.014947529882192612, -0.0006261314847506583, -0.022429564967751503, -0.007063813041895628, -0.003310936037451029, -0.002814930398017168, 0.04443221166729927, 0.018833184614777565, -0.03255472332239151, -0.006007303483784199, 0.015793612226843834, 0.04609301686286926, 0.0022196706850081682, 0.0004741629818454385, 0.007638429757207632, 0.019541701301932335, 0.026849878951907158, 0.008271047845482826, -0.0033133879769593477, -0.04577813670039177, 0.0110020712018013, 0.008516903966665268, 0.021630220115184784, -0.025473633781075478, -0.00942207220941782, 0.057721178978681564, 0.013314144685864449, 0.01471847016364336, 0.037715405225753784, -0.04995814710855484, 0.0056769829243421555, -0.0007467901450581849, 0.07995615154504776, -0.024294888600707054, 0.0547761395573616, 0.035300225019454956, 0.03003600426018238, 0.03899997100234032, 0.04416727274656296, 0.045639973133802414, 0.037541501224040985, 0.007086620200425386, -0.009350772015750408, -0.07787638157606125, -0.02999112568795681, -0.01466537918895483, 0.011464651674032211, 0.0038419689517468214, -0.02273038774728775, 0.037180110812187195, -0.03206733986735344, 0.04520048201084137, -0.012388411909341812, -0.01771414838731289, 0.05297743156552315, -0.002065999200567603, 0.03565188869833946, 0.06253045797348022, -0.06069757044315338, -0.04501555860042572, -0.002666001906618476, 0.011284295469522476, -0.031065208837389946, -0.013616637326776981, -0.009623868390917778, -0.02609584666788578, -0.03663742169737816, 0.04691228270530701, -0.04632432386279106, -0.06107955053448677, -0.0035801378544420004, 0.008109045214951038, 0.06297673285007477, 0.03581701219081879, 0.0632234588265419, -0.022237487137317657, -0.03854866325855255, 0.006163128186017275, 0.02926519513130188, -0.005305913742631674, -0.04129820317029953, -0.03560393303632736, -0.028153778985142708, 0.011879325844347477, 0.03824437037110329, 0.003983651753515005, 0.010407358407974243, 0.008944036439061165, 0.050171442329883575, 0.005582898389548063, -0.023232607170939445, 0.03628554567694664, -0.0010121687082573771, -0.009732469916343689, 0.03020431473851204, 0.021949077025055885, 0.010455723851919174, -0.07064004987478256, -0.020141957327723503, -0.04729500412940979, 0.027258045971393585, 0.011675913818180561, -0.013157510198652744, -0.014170519076287746, 0.018890440464019775, -0.057650115340948105, 0.01976086013019085, 0.0047800675965845585, -0.0004993450129404664, 0.05395020544528961, 0.005270290654152632, 0.019502930343151093, -0.002657999750226736, -0.00030547688947990537, -0.022658411413431168, 0.019012626260519028, 0.0686117634177208, 0.013318493962287903, -0.017542630434036255, -0.013502532616257668, 0.04517852142453194, -0.045863207429647446, 0.021702883765101433, -0.0014688546070829034, -0.04935590922832489, 0.01961803436279297, 0.04870028793811798, -0.05485885590314865, -0.012445619329810143, -0.028996191918849945, 0.0439218170940876, -0.02044156938791275, -0.024134015664458275, 0.02674640156328678, 0.023561527952551842, -0.011344324797391891, 0.01055276207625866, -0.02627456560730934, -0.07964278757572174, -0.005171471741050482, 0.027036430314183235, 0.008396610617637634, -0.036517173051834106, -0.013344197534024715, 0.007471440825611353, -0.09915176033973694, 0.025540366768836975, -0.022138675674796104, 0.02261042408645153, 0.08248051255941391, 0.050631795078516006, 0.05152067914605141, -0.002993023721501231, -0.034112244844436646, 0.010712878778576851, -0.025190837681293488, 0.006155307404696941, 0.026548441499471664, -0.0755683034658432, 0.02669224515557289, -0.010598392225801945, -0.04094618558883667, -0.03688592463731766, 0.027257857844233513, 0.025705359876155853, 0.03800486400723457, -0.007088637910783291, 0.013391153886914253, 0.025493601337075233, -0.000055279117077589035, -0.0027706464752554893, -0.01818081922829151, -0.042683083564043045, -0.03189826011657715, -0.04289655387401581, 0.018738841637969017, 0.01666748896241188, 0.04076380282640457, 0.10239773988723755, 0.003318742848932743, -0.018636438995599747, 0.013770628720521927, -0.006573861464858055, -0.12769030034542084, -0.053526870906353, -0.043528962880373, 0.005789509043097496, -0.04702378809452057, 0.011555046774446964, 0.04380695894360542, -0.019708869978785515, 0.0068724737502634525, -0.02824820578098297, -0.0167293269187212, -0.04113134741783142, -0.018002191558480263, -0.00543785747140646, 0.018441608175635338, -0.08453556895256042, -0.04864886775612831, -0.007766003254801035, -0.03218300640583038, 0.024707309901714325, -0.005589910317212343, -0.013135906308889389, -0.0336444191634655, -0.019741127267479897, -0.02542746625840664, 0.00418833177536726, 0.01025804877281189, -0.111487478017807, -0.04883810877799988, 0.013640169985592365, -0.01291074138134718, 0.007809760514646769, 0.012383252382278442, 0.02957606129348278, 0.04902113601565361, 0.010568131692707539, -0.05124202370643616, -0.008694064803421497, -0.058355662971735, 0.030060602352023125, 0.035532474517822266, -0.02838781848549843, 0.020419279113411903, -0.04207482561469078, 0.041005924344062805, 0.0481857992708683, -0.016435110941529274, -0.02664748765528202, 0.017220597714185715, 0.02426779828965664, -0.021110568195581436, 0.005689642857760191, -0.007446207106113434, 0.03776532784104347, -0.030472027137875557, -0.024546034634113312, -0.03655829280614853, -0.043110575526952744, 0.0025593049358576536, -0.008568324148654938, 0.07008402794599533, -0.0005927181337028742, -0.02084963023662567, -0.03829462081193924, -0.004098552744835615, -0.009711003862321377, -0.013815193437039852, -0.0075551713816821575, -0.029526181519031525, -0.02118644304573536, 0.0034904885105788708, -0.020381197333335876, -0.026301102712750435, -0.007605540566146374, 0.007229659706354141, -0.015262428671121597, 0.0029114217031747103, 0.007680928334593773, 0.004577367566525936, 0.04416411370038986, -0.03264758363366127, -0.01605677232146263, -0.0006943886401131749, 0.026334283873438835, -0.010433980263769627, -0.030282072722911835, -0.03173193335533142, -0.012106819078326225, 0.08218538016080856, -0.009261851198971272, -0.011977382935583591, -0.044549256563186646, -0.02413114160299301, 0.041482068598270416, -0.023983068764209747, 0.05042010918259621, -0.021057477220892906, 0.015798619017004967, -0.057508520781993866, 0.03317466378211975, 0.032805077731609344, -0.07522507011890411, -0.0598740354180336, 0.0432342030107975, -0.004250235855579376, -0.016856862232089043, -0.05551828071475029, -0.04062623530626297, 0.008151129819452763, -0.06780063360929489, 0.06023000553250313, -0.06331959366798401, 0.03683130443096161, 0.05740492045879364, 0.033902768045663834, -0.02504434436559677, 0.016767939552664757, 0.027380874380469322, 0.027131719514727592, -0.009930705651640892, -0.026350289583206177, 0.07222404330968857, 0.03599344938993454, -0.0037752469070255756, -0.006682667415589094, 0.059451401233673096, 0.026232006028294563, 0.06281223148107529, -0.0566474013030529, 0.020694755017757416, 0.02935292012989521, 0.04150953143835068, 0.07704520225524902, 0.022951412945985794, -0.02164643071591854, -0.009767548181116581, -0.06582716852426529, -0.06859951466321945, 0.03607656806707382, 0.04777294769883156, 0.06009290739893913, -0.06241318956017494, -0.01683487929403782, -0.04853682965040207, -0.05704983323812485, -0.040191616863012314, 0.001017377246171236, -0.04638043791055679, 0.027015507221221924, 0.03874049335718155, -0.01772073283791542, -0.034979600459337234, 0.01925118826329708, -0.04362952709197998, 0.0034907932858914137, 0.004744718782603741, -0.02976330555975437, -0.047086577862501144, 0.03607136756181717, 0.0599214993417263, -0.0015647311229258776, 0.04372404143214226, -0.05008239299058914, 0.03630131855607033, 0.003018480958417058, -0.055438823997974396, -0.03803587332367897, 0.019709324464201927, -0.0485222227871418, -0.013031142763793468, 0.018071599304676056, -0.05295331031084061, 0.04933847486972809, 0.02314804680645466, 0.07787717133760452, 0.03236643597483635, 0.03522485867142677, -0.03139984607696533, -0.025925349444150925, 0.010854367166757584, -0.025952598080039024, -0.022656934335827827, -0.035303231328725815, -0.0066860271617770195, -0.0020963074639439583, 0.014537900686264038, 0.02276977337896824, 0.004849232267588377, 0.023344872519373894, -0.008299420587718487, -0.04297519102692604, 0.01009688526391983, -0.022099046036601067, 0.04920708015561104, 0.04600850120186806, -0.08839101344347, -0.043830472975969315, 0.03753325715661049, 0.016834935173392296, -0.033291324973106384, -0.022963369265198708, 0.0024910562206059694, 0.0028906443621963263, 0.010672030970454216, 0.009744850918650627, 0.03155243769288063, -0.07484324276447296, -0.0634312629699707, 0.01907794363796711, 0.04741790145635605, -0.011531482450664043, 0.03456505015492439, 0.00752274552360177, -0.002732542110607028, 0.0771271362900734, -0.035620786249637604, -0.012818730436265469, 0.03241666778922081, 0.05109978839755058, -0.012380924075841904, 0.08518931269645691, -0.03512495383620262, -0.020978810265660286, 0.02349555678665638, -0.027493488043546677, -0.01156616397202015, 0.01795862801373005, -0.05200124531984329, 0.0051695555448532104, -0.04703139513731003, -0.01101369597017765, 0.017815766856074333, -0.009381512179970741, -0.03600544109940529, -0.014713763259351254, 0.0231885127723217, -0.037688855081796646, -0.011734569445252419, -0.06412411481142044, 0.016730211675167084, 0.03525146096944809, 0.010741987265646458, -0.028214426711201668 ]
<p>Context: I am working on a decision tree classifier, trying to classify businesses as to whether they are likely to have an event occur (default) in the next 90 days.</p> <p>One input I get is whether, and when, the business is scheduled to have a related event (let's call it "warning"). A business may have no warning scheduled, or it may have a warning scheduled some number of days in the future (e.g., we learn today that a warning has been scheduled for 15 days hence). If a warning is scheduled further out, we may presume that the business has more time to cope and fix it, so it is "worse" to have 15 days till warning, than it is to have 85 days till warning.</p> <p>I'm looking for a way I can massage/transform this data into a single, real-valued feature for use in a decision tree, that 1. preserves the natural ordering that intuitively exists here, and 2. won't make for too ugly of statistics?</p> <p>Possibilities:</p> <ol> <li>Just use the number of days until scheduled warning as a feature. Pros: preserves order (except for no warning) and natural interpretability. Cons: when "no warning" exists, "zero" is a particularly poor value to use, since it violates the ordering.</li> <li>Use "+infinity" or some arbitrarily large number of days when "no warning" exists, but otherwise use number of days. Pros: preserves order and interpretability (except for no warning). Cons: most values are going to be in the 1-90 range, so choosing a representative value for "no warning" skews the data.</li> <li>Use "zero" for no warning, and transform the number of days till warning with the inverse. Pros: smooth, well-ordered over the domain, output range of 0,1, "no warning" is interpreted as "zero" effect. Cons: loses native interpretability of values, unsuitable for other (linear?) models.</li> <li>Use two separate features, one a binary for warning, one the days till warning. Pros: properly separates the concerns (?). Cons: still doesn't deal with the question of what to put in for missing value in days till warning.</li> </ol> <p>If, as I suspect, this is something of a rookie problem, any pointers for standard approaches to this kind of problem are welcome, including "RTFM" responses, though specific sources, technique names, or search terms would be quite welcome.</p>
g74302
[ -0.03233872726559639, -0.003617126727476716, 0.0035173650830984116, -0.08732724189758301, 0.009441684931516647, -0.07468515634536743, -0.005982152186334133, 0.03320237994194031, -0.05158460885286331, -0.05071811378002167, 0.0211960356682539, 0.02615457773208618, 0.08500491827726364, 0.01811830699443817, -0.022504456341266632, 0.017558760941028595, 0.030094388872385025, 0.010322898626327515, 0.012809455394744873, 0.03168980032205582, 0.0498025082051754, 0.025165997445583344, -0.004560356494039297, 0.015910254791378975, -0.08347202837467194, -0.01278835628181696, -0.007018598727881908, 0.04228869825601578, -0.03424231708049774, -0.011646580882370472, -0.011654292233288288, 0.05381988734006882, 0.01853003539144993, 0.009712138213217258, -0.0433444045484066, 0.018559789285063744, 0.02786189317703247, -0.005321886390447617, 0.004564583767205477, 0.003751700511202216, -0.004801598843187094, 0.01751316897571087, 0.04036543145775795, 0.0033843640703707933, 0.02035708539187908, -0.02531410939991474, 0.03256619721651077, -0.03211862966418266, 0.0396326519548893, -0.04291081428527832, 0.022632842883467674, -0.012698840349912643, 0.0042590671218931675, 0.025858713313937187, 0.0505249910056591, 0.07130258530378342, 0.0096184853464365, 0.06989218294620514, -0.03130035847425461, -0.008414505049586296, 0.023380687460303307, -0.016286203637719154, -0.008418883197009563, -0.008613473735749722, 0.00207772315479815, 0.03491552174091339, -0.042359575629234314, 0.006369569338858128, -0.01241622306406498, 0.01532802078872919, -0.02863287925720215, -0.00959180947393179, 0.01297406479716301, -0.043957967311143875, -0.032836657017469406, 0.01589716412127018, -0.040535811334848404, 0.028904614970088005, 0.010576574131846428, 0.08253638446331024, -0.025922946631908417, 0.016943693161010742, -0.004740269389003515, 0.019970320165157318, -0.016774820163846016, 0.012397210113704205, 0.06650181859731674, -0.04340174421668053, 0.057497285306453705, 0.05557212978601456, -0.029779326170682907, -0.0015966309001669288, 0.06305401772260666, 0.01082089263945818, 0.007923868484795094, 0.06739167869091034, -0.06723427027463913, 0.05587379261851311, -0.003895821049809456, -0.048563603311777115, 0.02237517572939396, 0.016301490366458893, -0.029875440523028374, -0.051089268177747726, -0.035596247762441635, -0.053851038217544556, 0.08383304625749588, 0.032587409019470215, -0.011381649412214756, -0.02778407745063305, 0.016143158078193665, 0.037996914237737656, -0.06768064945936203, -0.018268480896949768, -0.003692228812724352, 0.005983015988022089, 0.03920108824968338, 0.004712888039648533, 0.004949179012328386, 0.034024666994810104, 0.07363169640302658, -0.09529174119234085, 0.046690523624420166, 0.04680455103516579, 0.0037690678145736456, -0.0024529106449335814, -0.02006167732179165, 0.11924760788679123, 0.05133175849914551, -0.04783263057470322, -0.03720042482018471, -0.003064023330807686, -0.00025093925069086254, 0.03477751836180687, -0.056468091905117035, 0.013456420972943306, -0.010267075151205063, 0.027126934379339218, -0.0008519467664882541, 0.007572640664875507, -0.0026347115635871887, 0.02222839742898941, -0.06018403545022011, 0.001955736428499222, -0.0006468329229392111, 0.02499847672879696, -0.0342121385037899, 0.013772809877991676, 0.002352129202336073, 0.021914705634117126, -0.031830914318561554, 0.0013069834094494581, -0.06393018364906311, 0.036075107753276825, 0.03069818578660488, 0.02177678793668747, 0.07159227132797241, -0.03144029900431633, -0.0467403270304203, 0.027796439826488495, 0.056450244039297104, -0.02185247652232647, -0.006287692580372095, -0.023760078474879265, -0.0069376155734062195, -0.01186476182192564, -0.007147350814193487, -0.07054855674505234, -0.0053798300214111805, -0.004194782581180334, -0.022522781044244766, 0.02959730103611946, 0.031138330698013306, 0.002468056743964553, 0.02469143271446228, 0.04981120303273201, 0.022207606583833694, 0.010678797028958797, 0.056475214660167694, -0.016268854960799217, -0.05117269605398178, 0.023981543257832527, -0.022640710696578026, 0.06022139638662338, 0.005880636163055897, -0.06373509019613266, -0.024809181690216064, 0.07434935867786407, 0.009739287197589874, -0.007937203161418438, -0.005430204793810844, -0.015058305114507675, 0.009230212308466434, 0.023896919563412666, -0.024832788854837418, -0.045783430337905884, -0.010800654999911785, -0.00991516001522541, -0.025439700111746788, -0.013231823220849037, 0.06326350569725037, -0.024820582941174507, -0.061498284339904785, 0.04899654909968376, -0.07214932143688202, -0.006981979124248028, 0.05526823177933693, 0.01187471579760313, -0.02790507860481739, 0.005089655052870512, 0.07101405411958694, -0.05327921360731125, 0.006600943394005299, -0.005263932980597019, 0.02585466206073761, -0.012142175808548927, -0.021303147077560425, 0.07626449316740036, -0.006305749993771315, 0.01351514458656311, -0.039489250630140305, -0.041913583874702454, 0.0626300498843193, 0.031141266226768494, -0.03177599981427193, 0.024305934086441994, 0.05076824128627777, 0.007317275740206242, 0.015416005626320839, -0.02639244683086872, -0.02506270632147789, -0.024581875652074814, -0.020677659660577774, 0.007806065492331982, 0.052992817014455795, 0.016896534711122513, -0.005584766622632742, 0.011540061794221401, 0.026706112548708916, -0.005282329861074686, 0.049542300403118134, 0.030788471922278404, -0.008779183030128479, 0.038331303745508194, 0.01600567437708378, -0.029117275029420853, 0.04238536208868027, 0.031680621206760406, 0.034286633133888245, 0.039717234671115875, -0.0821872353553772, 0.0055582863278687, -0.01494249701499939, -0.03752375766634941, 0.01089346595108509, -0.07278355956077576, 0.03942815214395523, 0.0027081489097326994, 0.04230654984712601, 0.012069622054696083, -0.00513454107567668, -0.021361563354730606, 0.02410820499062538, -0.025600364431738853, -0.011853734962642193, -0.05357711762189865, 0.026731589809060097, 0.010177146643400192, -0.0221107117831707, 0.016178593039512634, -0.03644823655486107, -0.0721510797739029, 0.03524726256728172, 0.017900297418236732, 0.00452729407697916, 0.05435249209403992, -0.02959669940173626, 0.011491063982248306, -0.03671741858124733, 0.06317134946584702, 0.03349127247929573, -0.06036163866519928, -0.027455927804112434, -0.003667251206934452, -0.0003593220899347216, 0.014640286564826965, 0.02278541587293148, 0.01858055591583252, -0.011534937657415867, -0.00872640497982502, -0.016930552199482918, 0.013903789222240448, 0.03964680805802345, 0.0366872176527977, 0.0010680458508431911, -0.05569552257657051, -0.043240781873464584, -0.0016952850855886936, 0.09278623014688492, 0.02814636565744877, -0.06492055952548981, -0.019600311294198036, 0.03106747381389141, -0.03302549943327904, -0.01889248937368393, -0.01767735369503498, -0.07477697730064392, 0.036079972982406616, 0.014223878271877766, -0.008985153399407864, -0.01392762828618288, 0.005499802529811859, -0.06449683010578156, -0.02499229647219181, 0.011622253805398941, 0.002930436749011278, -0.04086076468229294, 0.00976470299065113, 0.006774229928851128, -0.06002691760659218, 0.0019221205729991198, -0.035185132175683975, 0.04631299898028374, 0.019223496317863464, -0.00038681915611959994, 0.03995242342352867, -0.07349345833063126, 0.05968682840466499, -0.030082302168011665, 0.014283675700426102, 0.04345160350203514, -0.0024685023818165064, -0.028313638642430305, -0.031363677233457565, -0.0006366238230839372, -0.05319451913237572, -0.027917271479964256, -0.016330640763044357, 0.04485737159848213, 0.03662387281656265, -0.008084207773208618, -0.05597791075706482, -0.004917601123452187, 0.029055483639240265, 0.007108007557690144, -0.04639638215303421, 0.006338838953524828, 0.02522016130387783, 0.0710778534412384, -0.023579653352499008, -0.01672421395778656, -0.08403319865465164, 0.050477344542741776, -0.027988888323307037, 0.021274615079164505, 0.016373084858059883, 0.059934306889772415, 0.008200405165553093, -0.011689737439155579, -0.01539674587547779, 0.0062118880450725555, 0.0017607087502256036, -0.05007265508174896, -0.02012299746274948, 0.020824849605560303, 0.011693406850099564, 0.016178203746676445, 0.043510183691978455, 0.05365116894245148, -0.0059332046657800674, 0.05296594649553299, -0.03339754417538643, 0.0005886792787350714, -0.02659071795642376, -0.004111571237444878, -0.02128773182630539, -0.006621925625950098, 0.051757704466581345, 0.008188743144273758, 0.1233622133731842, 0.03666018322110176, 0.026472389698028564, -0.012133815325796604, -0.032407741993665695, 0.01953686773777008, -0.027241148054599762, 0.060348521918058395, -0.0295138917863369, 0.029816538095474243, 0.019358616322278976, 0.0006154350121505558, -0.019483810290694237, -0.027061300352215767, 0.03688019514083862, 0.043614599853754044, 0.019122498109936714, -0.02263340912759304, 0.02036035992205143, -0.06685220450162888, -0.009348270483314991, -0.0565146841108799, -0.03186686336994171, 0.02772299014031887, 0.005678771995007992, -0.04345548152923584, -0.03748926892876625, 0.0314614474773407, -0.04195992648601532, -0.037267956882715225, -0.01564691960811615, -0.051148172467947006, -0.04228727146983147, -0.045906923711299896, -0.02071635238826275, 0.006473726127296686, -0.018860023468732834, 0.07743848115205765, -0.004973363596946001, 0.02356460876762867, -0.012690819799900055, 0.010432528331875801, 0.08657503873109818, -0.05995726212859154, -0.022699857130646706, -0.014537966810166836, -0.04425694793462753, 0.08488882333040237, -0.0007936492911539972, -0.018225422129034996, 0.0310527216643095, 0.014231489039957523, 0.04907422140240669, 0.005278454627841711, -0.030901359394192696, 0.006729903630912304, -0.028367310762405396, -0.06722880899906158, 0.04773782566189766, 0.0032607580069452524, -0.06273321807384491, -0.0369691401720047, -0.05904100835323334, -0.005005726125091314, 0.01252562366425991, -0.027690082788467407, 0.009456854313611984, -0.006835866253823042, -0.007045150268822908, 0.027042146772146225, 0.05145622417330742, -0.0034722068812698126, 0.02267681621015072, 0.0286862850189209, -0.019877605140209198, 0.05451986566185951, 0.0174491535872221, 0.04059012234210968, -0.0014453864423558116, 0.018353095278143883, 0.006093753036111593, 0.009464745409786701, -0.03602040186524391, -0.015779590234160423, 0.02908874675631523, -0.0706898495554924, 0.03190504014492035, -0.049386296421289444, -0.0026381907518953085, 0.03189752250909805, 0.01611264795064926, -0.01690020225942135, 0.017771124839782715, 0.01761932298541069, -0.02454546093940735, -0.032692331820726395, 0.015043548308312893, -0.017215345054864883, -0.0271519273519516, -0.018213195726275444, 0.0016682803397998214, -0.04599183797836304, -0.02275441586971283, 0.04152778163552284, 0.03543686121702194, 0.0004205987206660211, 0.02566390484571457, 0.02380075305700302, -0.05377215892076492, 0.01797848753631115, 0.028133565559983253, 0.01413715723901987, -0.0036626788787543774, 0.06944431364536285, 0.0133636724203825, 0.012628160417079926, -0.034629542380571365, -0.0005842005484737456, 0.038760557770729065, -0.04314066842198372, -0.07345005869865417, -0.036100056022405624, 0.028947588056325912, 0.054404959082603455, 0.005546638276427984, -0.03511404991149902, 0.0526481457054615, 0.07023124396800995, 0.018734684213995934, -0.003275932976976037, 0.013009835034608841, 0.007535080891102552, -0.002338922116905451, 0.012022512964904308, 0.006896678823977709, 0.011608035303652287, -0.03733129799365997, 0.01499901618808508, 0.015543021261692047, -0.03577020391821861, -0.017669489607214928, 0.011395806446671486, 0.0012622980866581202, 0.04031393304467201, -0.04622756689786911, 0.04328020289540291, -0.05394122377038002, 0.00528262322768569, -0.061687249690294266, -0.053679898381233215, -0.05430103465914726, 0.028153667226433754, 0.04811010882258415, -0.07428176701068878, -0.05127086862921715, 0.005595913622528315, -0.011128258891403675, -0.018558302894234657, 0.05938758701086044, -0.0007169302552938461, -0.02467348612844944, -0.0182438176125288, 0.0023000575602054596, -0.020106540992856026, -0.021122926846146584, -0.0510052926838398, -0.033165279775857925, -0.05222397297620773, -0.0032065873965620995, -0.056467704474925995, -0.007597204297780991, 0.05891866609454155, 0.0008753114962019026, -0.017786351963877678, -0.017025839537382126, 0.04112667962908745, 0.026730448007583618, 0.007403263822197914, -0.019129306077957153, -0.0370069220662117, -0.01567675918340683, -0.020826073363423347, 0.04227091744542122, -0.002609053859487176, 0.07405517250299454, -0.017919909209012985, 0.061918359249830246, 0.048490677028894424, -0.03526961803436279, -0.023517640307545662, 0.02287767268717289, 0.024079354479908943, -0.0433834008872509, 0.08885323256254196, 0.03913469240069389, -0.0009748361771926284, -0.07691405713558197, 0.009846098721027374, -0.030572418123483658, 0.06138598173856735, -0.006006166338920593, -0.009754105471074581, -0.009047294966876507, 0.01984282396733761, -0.00673152320086956, -0.03678734600543976, -0.015452194027602673, -0.05249824374914169, -0.04046107828617096, -0.02405620738863945, -0.0018571303226053715, 0.006990604102611542, 0.0064072925597429276, -0.016963694244623184, -0.010284025222063065, 0.03972626104950905, 0.0398959256708622, 0.0009379996336065233, -0.01655801199376583, -0.00011654419358819723, -0.017984217032790184, 0.006703781895339489, 0.007604301907122135, 0.04502992331981659, -0.013251879252493382, 0.008543337695300579, 0.05830010771751404, -0.058025628328323364, 0.062172096222639084, 0.022165780887007713, -0.011989101767539978, -0.011322424747049809, 0.02512979879975319, 0.010279666632413864, 0.026412535458803177, -0.053070299327373505, 0.028278851881623268, -0.057506635785102844, -0.006463890895247459, -0.051526620984077454, 0.011031262576580048, -0.014415605925023556, -0.025312894955277443, 0.017521079629659653, 0.01933533512055874, 0.05461486428976059, 0.09710951149463654, -0.034654900431632996, 0.032332491129636765, 0.006925521418452263, 0.08448407053947449, -0.02999432012438774, 0.017081381753087044, -0.0167101938277483, -0.02046355977654457, 0.003473860677331686, -0.01285953912883997, -0.1377480924129486, 0.03842278569936752, -0.011110912077128887, 0.031157903373241425, -0.0026864269748330116, -0.004239179659634829, 0.002881336957216263, 0.019070859998464584, 0.010711231268942356, -0.032930683344602585, 0.06785822659730911, 0.017747363075613976, -0.002058575628325343, 0.047561947256326675, 0.012269857339560986, -0.0024448351468890905, 0.042054105550050735, -0.017924010753631592, 0.0025972912553697824, -0.008723708800971508, 0.0365353561937809, 0.018016058951616287, -0.001159754116088152, 0.008556356653571129, -0.025632638484239578, -0.06146584451198578, -0.024383774027228355, -0.01650780625641346, -0.0009605456725694239, 0.0021566194482147694, -0.031381867825984955, -0.013754874467849731, -0.04570699483156204, -0.040832437574863434, -0.006119535304605961, -0.06307952105998993, -0.003983500879257917, -0.031329765915870667, 0.01658174768090248, 0.06083590164780617, 0.012078753672540188, 0.028071150183677673, 0.011911356821656227, 0.010827231220901012, -0.02729707770049572, 0.018157416954636574, -0.013575529679656029, -0.031598832458257675, 0.007177783641964197, 0.08994215726852417, -0.014928300864994526, 0.07773540169000626, 0.04957141727209091, -0.04377750679850578, -0.05374618619680405, 0.01245246920734644, -0.017222309485077858, -0.04834536835551262, 0.03902178630232811, -0.051043666899204254, 0.018753092736005783, 0.012299533933401108, -0.020957348868250847, 0.027298524975776672, -0.0066508948802948, 0.05391870439052582, 0.01374263409525156, -0.00528623815625906, -0.03278924152255058, 0.00492343632504344, 0.01616613194346428, -0.0642300695180893, -0.023349987342953682, -0.017578402534127235, -0.011320175603032112, 0.04475764185190201, -0.03236667066812515, -0.011728011071681976, -0.020004233345389366, 0.014905180782079697, 0.05269883573055267, 0.005163225810974836, 0.0014886390417814255, 0.03498291224241257, -0.0650453194975853, -0.045254237949848175, -0.017270157113671303, 0.04147172346711159, 0.001931462436914444, -0.016072751954197884, -0.0586727112531662, 0.01988675817847252, -0.06092316284775734, -0.013494953513145447, 0.027271650731563568, -0.03474140539765358, -0.021243682131171227, 0.054857369512319565, 0.01741001568734646, 0.03114822320640087, -0.009615790098905563, 0.03430824354290962, -0.06400221586227417, 0.02140391431748867, -0.02214481122791767, -0.0012363025452941656, -0.002859523519873619, -0.03349602222442627, 0.02323806844651699, -0.011227578856050968, -0.034760527312755585, 0.034724146127700806, 0.0014837166527286172, -0.07286763191223145, -0.10593515634536743, -0.05235360935330391, -0.043042056262493134, 0.01154507789760828, -0.025215957313776016, 0.05122987926006317, 0.0034323232248425484, -0.02873927913606167, 0.05822287127375603, -0.029631711542606354, -0.005315359216183424, -0.001349139492958784, -0.06581411510705948, -0.0006003892631269991, -0.017729878425598145, -0.016872327774763107, -0.03788420185446739, 0.025237588211894035 ]
<p>I am working with matrices, of the size N*M, where each cell corresponds to the Pearson's correlation between two time series. I want to threshold each matrix such that it would retain only significant correlations. Now, my problem is that the time series are very large (>1500 data points) and thus rather weak correlations turn out to be (very) significant. I am already considering only correlations whose p val survives correction for multiple comparison (to correct for the number of tests done within each matrix), however this still leaves quite a few weak correlations in each matrix. I prefer not to choose a threshold arbitrarily, so I was wondering if anyone could direct me to established methods for determining statistical thresholds when working with very large time series </p> <p>Many thanks for your help! </p>
g74303
[ -0.011625290848314762, 0.04423200339078903, 0.004979209508746862, -0.0435742624104023, -0.01831451617181301, -0.03715688735246658, 0.024723654612898827, 0.060715314000844955, 0.011810744181275368, 0.045548100024461746, -0.006334883626550436, 0.0071832239627838135, 0.030761871486902237, 0.004297599196434021, -0.028008058667182922, -0.03580838069319725, 0.07491149753332138, 0.011672680266201496, -0.018660956993699074, 0.0025325757451355457, -0.025316961109638214, 0.01239704992622137, -0.01937229186296463, 0.008238920010626316, -0.024189036339521408, -0.019402332603931427, -0.002266279421746731, 0.01947810687124729, 0.022192655131220818, 0.07114148139953613, 0.011519632302224636, -0.03846265375614166, 0.0014655636623501778, -0.05374905839562416, 0.013128302060067654, 0.013888333924114704, 0.027728969231247902, -0.014904732815921307, 0.02850356698036194, -0.0035019791685044765, 0.03547791391611099, -0.024465324357151985, 0.044030025601387024, -0.022759733721613884, -0.002381039783358574, 0.013342725113034248, -0.03289567679166794, -0.031273312866687775, -0.04636308178305626, -0.042872365564107895, 0.010723943822085857, 0.03487416356801987, 0.01907256245613098, -0.023427089676260948, -0.04809201881289482, 0.06461919099092484, 0.032031457871198654, 0.08302243798971176, 0.02035771869122982, 0.05299008637666702, 0.02315336838364601, -0.07985572516918182, -0.030951673164963722, 0.004837732762098312, -0.021142050623893738, 0.017310427501797676, -0.0054681203328073025, -0.04575085639953613, 0.03826175630092621, -0.008138091303408146, 0.01373342890292406, 0.0013909883564338088, -0.012136884033679962, -0.02819530852138996, -0.01794777251780033, 0.031084725633263588, 0.006506805773824453, -0.008585639297962189, 0.03141108155250549, 0.02836977317929268, -0.046888567507267, 0.025327324867248535, 0.01661813259124756, 0.03888914734125137, -0.008746523410081863, -0.05367051437497139, 0.03313678875565529, 0.021377678960561752, 0.004700581077486277, 0.0003422663430683315, 0.07240187376737595, 0.02661685273051262, 0.03695249184966087, 0.024738123640418053, -0.015492589212954044, 0.042285092175006866, 0.010409809648990631, -0.028615677729249, -0.05248580873012543, -0.038308411836624146, 0.01124060433357954, 0.06535438448190689, 0.006632802542299032, -0.01416792068630457, -0.020844049751758575, 0.0035032143350690603, 0.02372661605477333, 0.004962190054357052, -0.004991271998733282, 0.007194543723016977, -0.019608905538916588, 0.006694804411381483, -0.070454441010952, -0.022301768884062767, -0.05994046851992607, -0.02535998262465, 0.02745807357132435, -0.03865252807736397, -0.04489351436495781, 0.019651494920253754, 0.037508219480514526, -0.028362536802887917, 0.039211682975292206, 0.08594418317079544, -0.026315659284591675, -0.015800716355443, -0.0251481793820858, 0.10671795904636383, -0.0158354714512825, -0.009363589808344841, 0.011295395903289318, -0.015872353687882423, 0.022375963628292084, 0.04381761699914932, -0.014944144524633884, 0.01789848320186138, -0.014760829508304596, 0.03130774945020676, -0.027556944638490677, 0.03366367891430855, -0.06289909780025482, 0.008171007968485355, 0.03252437338232994, -0.018002672120928764, -0.029547255486249924, -0.0002765640674624592, -0.01499301940202713, -0.00018666488176677376, 0.020646460354328156, -0.024473758414387703, 0.07248621433973312, 0.002091872738674283, -0.01476319134235382, -0.02471095323562622, -0.05447664111852646, 0.020971069112420082, -0.030273791402578354, -0.06291020661592484, -0.04729297384619713, 0.05275874212384224, -0.041593220084905624, -0.00191079534124583, 0.0729483962059021, -0.015928924083709717, 0.0485268197953701, -0.0033355418127030134, -0.007045621983706951, -0.0485018715262413, -0.04917764663696289, 0.009635989554226398, -0.06277551501989365, -0.02868533879518509, 0.0873737707734108, -0.001493473188020289, 0.007255461532622576, 0.014860284514725208, 0.04039813578128815, -0.01609599031507969, 0.03207293525338173, 0.043613482266664505, -0.0006051755626685917, 0.004044250585138798, 0.03121381811797619, -0.012890749610960484, -0.022761866450309753, -0.032109830528497696, 0.026830259710550308, 0.01118005346506834, -0.047682832926511765, 0.05025199428200722, -0.031275924295186996, -0.05089269205927849, -0.05833334103226662, -0.055625107139348984, -0.021779868751764297, 0.017276782542467117, 0.059575051069259644, -0.0672336220741272, -0.04239475354552269, -0.07523664087057114, -0.0053757051937282085, -0.0009685278055258095, -0.05823960900306702, 0.0751221552491188, 0.0015283804386854172, 0.025793669745326042, 0.03201361745595932, 0.024283498525619507, -0.05674963444471359, 0.013355985283851624, -0.019352102652192116, 0.002950113732367754, -0.04021977260708809, 0.03350013121962547, -0.012058994732797146, -0.015908004716038704, -0.049115609377622604, 0.032286543399095535, 0.0377318412065506, 0.0680587962269783, 0.00965049210935831, -0.0008482459234073758, -0.007080830633640289, -0.040721595287323, 0.007444826420396566, 0.04811784625053406, 0.048646315932273865, 0.018519040197134018, 0.04796035587787628, -0.0121862031519413, -0.012553643435239792, 0.043022606521844864, -0.03660116717219353, -0.060151055455207825, -0.016892988234758377, -0.015112076885998249, 0.03944867104291916, -0.01837233267724514, -0.024756327271461487, 0.0691356435418129, -0.029755551367998123, -0.0169740691781044, -0.024182217195630074, 0.010992677882313728, -0.047446299344301224, -0.023301197215914726, -0.017560841515660286, -0.030428867787122726, 0.04357607662677765, 0.05410710722208023, -0.026341384276747704, 0.017330767586827278, -0.004421847406774759, -0.0011552768992260098, 0.0053647286258637905, 0.031242763623595238, 0.03776004537940025, 0.044862162321805954, -0.011713934130966663, -0.022810837253928185, -0.028835203498601913, 0.018248122185468674, 0.016568193212151527, -0.011490276083350182, 0.05476979911327362, -0.028716739267110825, -0.006841850467026234, -0.07619800418615341, 0.013489536009728909, 0.020550863817334175, 0.015178618021309376, 0.01584290899336338, 0.058816052973270416, 0.023852337151765823, 0.04745945706963539, 0.006207372061908245, -0.004366268403828144, -0.0023425586987286806, 0.03966252878308296, 0.03622850030660629, -0.022745506837964058, -0.0008520869887433946, 0.002019905485212803, 0.015605462715029716, 0.06384436041116714, -0.0767153650522232, 0.07663997262716293, 0.016345441341400146, 0.010383013635873795, 0.06043773517012596, -0.007233018986880779, -0.009744704701006413, -0.036092206835746765, 0.02419852837920189, -0.01746668480336666, 0.03247666731476784, 0.011450770311057568, -0.09146968275308609, 0.023301610723137856, 0.0033173365518450737, 0.02273799479007721, -0.03803582862019539, 0.0676087811589241, -0.004716011229902506, 0.06667067110538483, -0.02448098547756672, -0.057698804885149, 0.03427046537399292, -0.00804848037660122, -0.014767074957489967, -0.0243450365960598, 0.000047773384721949697, 0.03658635914325714, -0.036251768469810486, -0.004192385356873274, 0.014938993379473686, 0.06109727919101715, 0.061251237988471985, -0.006734822411090136, -0.02254297398030758, 0.010621095076203346, -0.022382305935025215, 0.014317458495497704, -0.03600538894534111, 0.005113593302667141, 0.014101116918027401, -0.09727585315704346, 0.01066638808697462, -0.06922253966331482, 0.06901594996452332, 0.03826823830604553, 0.03993374854326248, 0.037786729633808136, 0.006295639090240002, -0.0683186948299408, -0.0869341716170311, -0.014681946486234665, -0.05481348931789398, 0.013512241654098034, -0.010111470706760883, -0.01850803755223751, -0.0007343603647314012, -0.01767553947865963, -0.03746380656957626, 0.005551500245928764, 0.022677989676594734, 0.0594678670167923, 0.04052069038152695, 0.00544940447434783, -0.06194774806499481, 0.009138396009802818, -0.03278973326086998, -0.02094343677163124, -0.04020240530371666, 0.00017180216673295945, -0.009838905185461044, 0.05801524594426155, 0.0004358776204753667, -0.005058201029896736, -0.04721440374851227, -0.0349806547164917, -0.00576042290776968, 0.022533684968948364, 0.023130884394049644, -0.02601107396185398, 0.030217815190553665, -0.02247799001634121, 0.003493374213576317, 0.0048101902939379215, -0.021574394777417183, 0.03873738646507263, -0.015859631821513176, 0.028195196762681007, -0.056970976293087006, -0.017503296956419945, 0.017940642312169075, 0.018917914479970932, 0.043336037546396255, 0.0361747182905674, 0.07429313659667969, 0.045886073261499405, -0.05266143009066582, -0.016060220077633858, -0.02268967591226101, -0.01076247077435255, -0.010654553771018982, 0.02616194635629654, 0.006697602104395628, -0.007864910177886486, -0.007320605218410492, -0.017078600823879242, -0.041173990815877914, -0.014161855913698673, 0.029281608760356903, 0.031644273549318314, -0.031480930745601654, -0.010880268178880215, 0.044695865362882614, 0.00857974961400032, -0.01666240394115448, -0.0395888052880764, 0.019445190206170082, -0.003161004977300763, 0.019339904189109802, -0.02797851525247097, -0.008843145333230495, -0.03603418171405792, 0.03236046060919762, 0.005965232849121094, 0.06386221945285797, -0.06229498237371445, -0.01782473735511303, 0.025796053931117058, -0.09017714858055115, -0.01643376611173153, 0.0008214851259253919, 0.00021455303067341447, -0.019640397280454636, 0.04902070388197899, 0.023574382066726685, -0.05039633437991142, 0.0748366117477417, -0.03218938410282135, -0.0105275958776474, -0.0025325347669422626, 0.005851767957210541, 0.002230648649856448, -0.014030433259904385, 0.019408129155635834, 0.013078120537102222, 0.062282465398311615, -0.036834679543972015, -0.02235831506550312, 0.006904998328536749, 0.0444817841053009, -0.0019283619476482272, 0.0430719368159771, -0.03111596219241619, -0.005053817760199308, -0.042633891105651855, 0.02088778093457222, -0.047231465578079224, 0.04100482165813446, 0.012501746416091919, -0.00780069176107645, -0.015065145678818226, 0.009483391419053078, 0.024102184921503067, 0.013769790530204773, 0.02521882764995098, -0.010805617086589336, 0.007521906867623329, -0.010373766534030437, -0.02253744937479496, -0.029780784621834755, -0.027323713526129723, 0.03245808556675911, 0.04258370399475098, 0.02264554798603058, 0.05528988689184189, -0.04997630789875984, 0.01356515847146511, -0.0709201991558075, 0.022417709231376648, -0.015810232609510422, -0.020886367186903954, -0.03388736769556999, -0.011122109368443489, 0.0024385603610426188, -0.021401628851890564, -0.02067830227315426, -0.002253690967336297, 0.02099815383553505, 0.0012998383026570082, -0.09948360174894333, 0.005930777173489332, -0.04226432740688324, -0.0554032139480114, 0.015776516869664192, 0.03924742713570595, 0.012408304959535599, -0.0005501395789906383, 0.033901624381542206, 0.05588342621922493, 0.03753470256924629, -0.003656111191958189, -0.029834715649485588, -0.08244229108095169, 0.00002783668605843559, -0.04480481520295143, 0.04041582718491554, 0.04512561485171318, 0.03752712905406952, 0.1011374443769455, 0.03719060868024826, -0.03466526418924332, 0.04149247705936432, -0.013726722449064255, -0.017789535224437714, -0.008455749601125717, 0.012326808646321297, 0.05332714691758156, -0.04579751566052437, 0.004059193190187216, -0.041785988956689835, -0.0696210116147995, 0.010896743275225163, -0.018448812887072563, 0.01678779534995556, 0.06003474071621895, -0.06781131029129028, 0.05782400444149971, 0.052064988762140274, -0.02259286306798458, -0.07982122153043747, 0.035444751381874084, -0.0018273708410561085, -0.015198418870568275, -0.087392657995224, -0.0834539383649826, 0.01585705578327179, -0.08753903210163116, 0.04832279309630394, 0.007296085357666016, 0.03199290856719017, -0.02243884839117527, -0.06431972980499268, -0.04402609542012215, 0.011094820685684681, -0.0398666188120842, -0.006938929203897715, -0.06649141758680344, -0.04439535364508629, -0.001982957823202014, -0.006369078531861305, -0.01319517008960247, -0.02874564193189144, -0.05220279097557068, -0.027370382100343704, -0.006360671017318964, 0.00702666537836194, 0.015701143071055412, 0.039573993533849716, -0.0127570116892457, 0.015307380817830563, -0.03972193971276283, 0.03910824656486511, -0.008803891949355602, 0.06085924804210663, -0.0031149310525506735, -0.0208269190043211, -0.01069103553891182, -0.042691752314567566, -0.021062053740024567, -0.0016871214611455798, 0.014300409704446793, 0.06244046986103058, -0.012108968570828438, 0.016662362962961197, 0.07012098282575607, -0.043249767273664474, -0.034867268055677414, 0.030819406732916832, 0.04026845097541809, -0.04831111431121826, -0.02844199351966381, -0.030927961692214012, -0.0014691066462546587, -0.011232763528823853, 0.04407922551035881, 0.05399070680141449, -0.04050363972783089, 0.0042088269256055355, 0.011368956416845322, 0.013699744828045368, 0.0396541990339756, 0.028789930045604706, 0.07670149952173233, -0.021795986220240593, -0.045605577528476715, -0.03913106396794319, 0.006050080060958862, 0.03664820268750191, 0.0013785309856757522, -0.029910672456026077, 0.022392740473151207, -0.021278273314237595, -0.023036174476146698, -0.026120290160179138, 0.0013217674568295479, 0.015341063030064106, -0.031450990587472916, -0.03924603387713432, 0.00545270461589098, 0.008407488465309143, -0.09129916876554489, -0.028417689725756645, 0.007469613570719957, -0.020739855244755745, -0.0328822024166584, 0.053875621408224106, 0.027779828757047653, -0.006733488757163286, -0.048432450741529465, 0.002320768777281046, 0.028328582644462585, -0.007781629450619221, -0.0227658748626709, -0.01883714646100998, 0.08115288615226746, 0.03282100334763527, 0.023233748972415924, 0.0554477833211422, 0.06658168882131577, -0.022363608703017235, -0.046209800988435745, 0.0045260656625032425, -0.005658439826220274, -0.06660652905702591, -0.0009943608893081546, -0.01819700561463833, -0.04011274874210358, 0.01740073412656784, -0.005736899562180042, -0.006432568188756704, 0.04212081804871559, -0.004008712712675333, -0.06381826847791672, 0.006187218241393566, -0.023033110424876213, -0.016277475282549858, -0.0488446019589901, 0.0174928680062294, 0.0027990536764264107, -0.02872137352824211, 0.0007524296524934471, -0.07202291488647461, 0.021897872909903526, -0.03462342545390129, 0.05907169356942177, -0.017929358407855034, 0.013596351258456707, -0.018090829253196716, 0.0101443687453866, 0.05444931238889694, -0.0005540712154470384, 0.0530463345348835, 0.06091085821390152, -0.021490952000021935, -0.0002428634325042367, 0.05499261990189552, -0.0065779294818639755, 0.002939782803878188, -0.05262521281838417, 0.000047848829126451164, 0.017466526478528976, -0.0007910447893664241, 0.016261860728263855, 0.08360350131988525, 0.006598335225135088, 0.006991072092205286, -0.0046594818122684956, -0.060224972665309906, -0.025683250278234482, -0.008089683949947357, 0.07630693912506104, 0.03611135110259056, -0.039962343871593475, -0.02386653423309326, -0.0400734506547451, 0.007658649235963821, -0.024693818762898445, -0.04359802231192589, 0.027445441111922264, 0.03666181489825249, -0.030243100598454475, -0.00320872338488698, 0.02383442036807537, -0.010324287228286266, 0.03136040270328522, -0.03269915655255318, -0.0667676255106926, 0.02695586159825325, -0.009469940327107906, 0.06122630462050438, 0.09516939520835876, -0.02140273153781891, -0.0024303977843374014, 0.03423745185136795, 0.026053495705127716, -0.054179079830646515, -0.020821593701839447, 0.02202242985367775, -0.013393839821219444, 0.053345903754234314, 0.015068921260535717, 0.048094093799591064, -0.05033119022846222, 0.05135186389088631, 0.022712765261530876, -0.0561094805598259, 0.00667780265212059, -0.057704754173755646, 0.018928945064544678, -0.012880658730864525, 0.0715344250202179, -0.030211860314011574, -0.014181921258568764, 0.011038742028176785, 0.030749913305044174, 0.014100879430770874, 0.06979075819253922, -0.016310177743434906, -0.024830438196659088, 0.02114415355026722, -0.03305791690945625, -0.029956111684441566, -0.044396113604307175, 0.03707193583250046, 0.01154982578009367, 0.04495145007967949, -0.02696092613041401, -0.05481977015733719, -0.02170836552977562, 0.0075656333938241005, -0.020332003012299538, 0.03519245237112045, 0.03557758778333664, 0.010988393798470497, 0.004005911760032177, -0.01025700569152832, -0.06293777376413345, -0.041531626135110855, 0.04770466312766075, 0.007602238561958075, -0.012043037451803684, -0.0192768145352602, 0.027215439826250076, -0.03434522822499275, 0.04417244717478752, -0.033093761652708054, 0.0033073441591113806, 0.01907939650118351, 0.016758764162659645, 0.042677123099565506, -0.013115597888827324, -0.006014075595885515, 0.03306827321648598, 0.02112010307610035, -0.04187470301985741, -0.05324425920844078, 0.02005932852625847, -0.017090098932385445, 0.09099188446998596, -0.018059901893138885, 0.000012102786058676429, -0.021676810458302498, -0.020856346935033798, 0.059203729033470154, -0.07897641509771347, 0.040878139436244965, 0.004538517910987139, -0.04541740193963051, 0.02319229766726494, 0.02191580832004547, -0.02284669689834118, -0.03710118681192398, 0.030339639633893967 ]
<p>Let's assume we have a training set with $y \in \mathbb{R}$. Thus all the data is between $y_{min}$ and $y_{max}$. If we built a decision tree model it cannot return $y_{pred}$ outside the given range (using any combination of input features). Thus decision tree cannot extrapolate in terms of predicted values. Can a neural net regression model extrapolate and return $y_{pred}$ values outside the $y$ range in a training set? Does it depend on the activation function or not?</p> <p>Below is my attempt to answer this question.</p> <p>The output neuron of the model is just $\sum \Theta_ia_i$, where $\Theta_i$ - weight of i-th neuron on the previous hidden layer, and $a_i$ - value of activation function of that neuron. If we use logistic function then $a \in (-1;1)$. Thus maximum possible $y_{pred} = \sum \Theta_i$, assuming that all $a$ reach their maximum value around 1. But if we will use linear activation function, which doesn't have restrictions on output values of $a$ ($a \in \mathbb{R}$) the model will return $y_{pred} \in \mathbb{R}$, which can be ouside $y$ range of the training set.</p> <p>Is my line of reasoning correct or there are some mistakes?</p>
g570
[ -0.052256420254707336, 0.04157886281609535, 0.011172364465892315, 0.036130115389823914, 0.026322880759835243, -0.057360757142305374, 0.03466789051890373, 0.014935504645109177, -0.055361345410346985, -0.038652557879686356, -0.04937731847167015, 0.07448285073041916, 0.039391130208969116, -0.0033504751045256853, -0.02380860224366188, -0.04158559814095497, 0.022739842534065247, -0.026484860107302666, 0.006526208017021418, -0.036816131323575974, -0.004466523416340351, -0.020894067361950874, 0.008702732622623444, 0.021102486178278923, -0.028186416253447533, -0.024892959743738174, 0.04153984785079956, 0.04019637033343315, -0.05626942962408066, 0.06597819924354553, 0.007997236214578152, -0.03503968194127083, 0.007021186873316765, -0.05191853269934654, -0.07995830476284027, 0.027903160080313683, 0.029171708971261978, -0.037508830428123474, 0.030879413709044456, 0.026029469445347786, -0.021091774106025696, 0.04812110587954521, 0.023920994251966476, 0.022524701431393623, -0.011435098014771938, 0.015906553715467453, 0.05196499451994896, -0.03106355480849743, 0.01907072588801384, 0.02130427584052086, -0.004587517119944096, 0.002836808795109391, -0.0503198616206646, 0.021383563056588173, 0.05544824153184891, 0.00603380985558033, 0.013595574535429478, 0.016300199553370476, -0.01947016641497612, -0.00016319946735166013, 0.02182129956781864, 0.02162386104464531, 0.0019788150675594807, -0.007724981289356947, 0.030780719593167305, -0.0024170908145606518, -0.08818843215703964, -0.00023904390400275588, -0.01803937368094921, 0.01389763131737709, -0.00022862668265588582, 0.018064120784401894, -0.017975926399230957, -0.050275545567274094, -0.0312773659825325, -0.00105730548966676, 0.013334839604794979, -0.001979473512619734, -0.015335366129875183, 0.04817955940961838, 0.01660955883562565, 0.007198786828666925, -0.04741552099585533, -0.03253721818327904, -0.01490570604801178, 0.06023511663079262, 0.037425726652145386, 0.012466195970773697, -0.0035703848116099834, 0.05363423004746437, 0.013628914020955563, 0.009008855558931828, 0.06662687659263611, 0.011972255073487759, 0.027916407212615013, -0.0033303459640592337, -0.047196533530950546, -0.030340047553181648, 0.025712810456752777, -0.004105136264115572, 0.008092307485640049, 0.03369452431797981, 0.048788029700517654, -0.07914479821920395, -0.015826871618628502, 0.003483247710391879, 0.07704310864210129, -0.017461376264691353, -0.032745279371738434, -0.002508307108655572, -0.06251411139965057, 0.00028745291638188064, -0.0024636161979287863, -0.026663057506084442, -0.13378456234931946, -0.04779837280511856, 0.015539003536105156, 0.03809758275747299, -0.014268657192587852, 0.021144209429621696, 0.06521444022655487, -0.022139577195048332, 0.020845714956521988, -0.008790932595729828, -0.043389692902565, 0.013983400538563728, -0.06270816177129745, 0.0629206970334053, 0.04906540364027023, -0.015243726782500744, 0.024719996377825737, 0.022171376273036003, 0.0035783154889941216, 0.06561215966939926, 0.001897808164358139, -0.007925854064524174, -0.017602913081645966, -0.009416734799742699, 0.009838244877755642, 0.019931426271796227, 0.012309565208852291, 0.004997818265110254, -0.045680154114961624, 0.014517548494040966, 0.018144192174077034, 0.01973397098481655, -0.00576498219743371, 0.07228771597146988, -0.045106809586286545, 0.01831456832587719, 0.014042211696505547, 0.04690206050872803, -0.038623835891485214, 0.00448469165712595, 0.06732386350631714, -0.04316107928752899, 0.02839823253452778, -0.011228804476559162, -0.02997637912631035, -0.06344330310821533, 0.04727967083454132, 0.020778553560376167, 0.06128424033522606, -0.0017351796850562096, -0.05129869654774666, -0.040722351521253586, -0.010090525262057781, -0.02779456041753292, -0.00441754050552845, -0.0016460003098472953, -0.030660027638077736, 0.01762072555720806, 0.015442234463989735, -0.030916007235646248, 0.0615663044154644, 0.026900433003902435, 0.02965017408132553, 0.03631024435162544, 0.020429983735084534, -0.0015800429973751307, 0.0017991047352552414, 0.054259419441223145, 0.007873629219830036, 0.0336950309574604, -0.04544895887374878, 0.0077417511492967606, -0.027841717004776, 0.049373798072338104, 0.001134419464506209, -0.0005907461745664477, -0.02380695752799511, 0.056634411215782166, 0.011272371746599674, -0.032315872609615326, 0.012497613206505775, 0.030298499390482903, 0.04233403131365776, -0.053566284477710724, 0.016553636640310287, 0.013974973000586033, 0.004770463798195124, -0.018865525722503662, 0.007457877974957228, -0.0018901372095569968, -0.03192907199263573, -0.023566946387290955, -0.031240832060575485, 0.00042446472798474133, 0.04527163505554199, -0.007479268591850996, -0.04672970995306969, 0.0011905505089089274, -0.009155547246336937, 0.04387962073087692, 0.02577298693358898, -0.07807465642690659, -0.022729801014065742, 0.017657361924648285, 0.034092556685209274, -0.005756892263889313, -0.060272809118032455, -0.03869442641735077, 0.08801788091659546, 0.024563176557421684, -0.04862389713525772, 0.02412279136478901, 0.03976879268884659, -0.0017654269468039274, 0.02917180396616459, 0.07293551415205002, -0.0221067126840353, -0.0031795634422451258, -0.011069674044847488, -0.017497727647423744, 0.05942143127322197, -0.03433110564947128, 0.023632939904928207, -0.03328908234834671, -0.005591378081589937, -0.008989281952381134, -0.003031810512766242, 0.01810363493859768, -0.033680614084005356, 0.050993405282497406, 0.0003951393882744014, -0.06008800491690636, -0.012755069881677628, 0.051195647567510605, -0.03615871071815491, 0.005765206646174192, 0.0008439600351266563, 0.09587550908327103, -0.0011817591730505228, -0.03712158650159836, -0.00998431071639061, 0.0028592138551175594, -0.015187586657702923, -0.01880238577723503, 0.023381393402814865, -0.03271310031414032, -0.024621928110718727, 0.018990853801369667, -0.03406939283013344, 0.06328742206096649, -0.008216115646064281, -0.015407867729663849, 0.00922375824302435, -0.03262530639767647, -0.01964402385056019, 0.009691298939287663, -0.053618479520082474, -0.004788857884705067, 0.04651208966970444, 0.04284121096134186, -0.014187049120664597, 0.03425752371549606, -0.03766932338476181, -0.002644588705152273, 0.02603152208030224, -0.00167054811026901, -0.02058386243879795, -0.049774169921875, -0.049195557832717896, -0.03702344372868538, 0.022241313010454178, -0.010730279609560966, 0.04324302449822426, 0.024229733273386955, -0.013546088710427284, 0.0232671108096838, -0.044789060950279236, -0.03590179234743118, -0.033094391226768494, -0.02587210200726986, -0.007861430756747723, -0.04104290530085564, -0.008479896932840347, -0.0014146066969260573, 0.047680649906396866, 0.031915146857500076, -0.06070738285779953, -0.05499642714858055, -0.02852245792746544, -0.011727143079042435, -0.028460638597607613, -0.08199218660593033, -0.0548960417509079, 0.059245262295007706, 0.015997955575585365, -0.005272659473121166, -0.043924760073423386, 0.030064744874835014, -0.012955035082995892, -0.05907292664051056, 0.0033494571689516306, -0.027668539434671402, -0.01275221910327673, -0.00453401543200016, 0.0647050142288208, -0.032338012009859085, -0.02423900179564953, -0.04047124460339546, -0.03737935051321983, 0.030604006722569466, -0.0325281023979187, -0.010653185658156872, -0.03167649731040001, 0.03952581435441971, -0.06837692856788635, -0.016865169629454613, 0.0736355409026146, 0.030476447194814682, 0.055190976709127426, 0.03426738828420639, 0.0020542244892567396, -0.05209208279848099, -0.00846382137387991, 0.04772070422768593, 0.06831654161214828, 0.06600411236286163, -0.03734319284558296, -0.027610203251242638, 0.007400549948215485, -0.0014526981394737959, -0.0011825674446299672, 0.03638526424765587, -0.05778703838586807, 0.026991257444024086, -0.00933106243610382, -0.038354404270648956, -0.02883130870759487, -0.0542316660284996, 0.01068403385579586, -0.012238135561347008, 0.07056228071451187, 0.04891502857208252, 0.06025681644678116, 0.007390009239315987, -0.0061195362359285355, -0.005815903190523386, 0.024305664002895355, -0.06526458263397217, -0.046214040368795395, -0.0069321454502642155, 0.006087192799896002, 0.014158549718558788, 0.05287802591919899, -0.0013824660563841462, 0.019704513251781464, -0.0017942840931937099, 0.05068342760205269, -0.00039621556061320007, 0.03205178305506706, 0.0353548601269722, -0.044358957558870316, 0.00924669113010168, 0.053138457238674164, -0.048408616334199905, -0.026410607621073723, 0.017712144181132317, 0.029833363369107246, -0.007827511057257652, -0.016106991097331047, 0.03552272170782089, 0.03860517963767052, 0.00018967740470543504, 0.015839433297514915, -0.021550344303250313, 0.03307804837822914, 0.019086558371782303, -0.028294965624809265, -0.017574012279510498, -0.012811032123863697, 0.031262218952178955, -0.03430784493684769, -0.02455718070268631, 0.06422708183526993, 0.012270699255168438, 0.010063490830361843, -0.0027835797518491745, -0.08134254068136215, -0.03495493531227112, -0.008482357487082481, -0.0028971252031624317, -0.03422814980149269, 0.0018079463625326753, 0.006015122402459383, 0.022861286997795105, -0.014532309025526047, -0.008086193352937698, -0.042896661907434464, -0.05332697555422783, -0.035938575863838196, -0.05622298642992973, 0.044458746910095215, -0.0044746603816747665, 0.1379341036081314, 0.010163424536585808, -0.024042455479502678, -0.016755014657974243, -0.0003155682934448123, 0.023190191015601158, -0.042777370661497116, -0.027925731614232063, -0.031104503199458122, 0.024201853200793266, 0.03198816627264023, -0.019538193941116333, 0.02996162138879299, -0.010663459077477455, 0.04975083842873573, 0.017200486734509468, -0.08095653355121613, 0.026174848899245262, -0.04088427871465683, 0.049471717327833176, -0.044906795024871826, 0.007880392484366894, 0.0366663858294487, -0.020367007702589035, 0.0012885552132502198, -0.019309027120471, 0.012664783746004105, -0.015534956939518452, 0.004206743091344833, -0.0052459086291491985, -0.026268145069479942, 0.0009287810535170138, -0.04021897166967392, 0.03022499941289425, -0.016174549236893654, 0.009346993640065193, 0.042223501950502396, -0.014600343070924282, 0.04085996001958847, -0.041793808341026306, 0.01090395636856556, 0.012701120227575302, 0.05659634619951248, 0.04365413263440132, 0.026123732328414917, -0.06743613630533218, -0.03878993168473244, 0.022281652316451073, 0.02136726677417755, 0.013682466931641102, -0.05890548974275589, 0.0027672145515680313, 0.03345995768904686, 0.04218784347176552, 0.045897725969552994, 0.07920842617750168, 0.08720599114894867, 0.001981260720640421, -0.055092062801122665, 0.04808803275227547, 0.019055085256695747, 0.043724026530981064, 0.009844504296779633, 0.004588039591908455, -0.046506501734256744, -0.036876462399959564, -0.05751742050051689, -0.0016127325361594558, -0.015503361821174622, 0.013465764932334423, -0.007908281870186329, -0.04988672956824303, -0.0488123893737793, -0.05025973916053772, 0.019333388656377792, 0.016616642475128174, 0.02130742371082306, 0.032635148614645004, -0.009018960408866405, -0.007282612379640341, -0.02131188102066517, 0.012247998267412186, -0.0018903739983215928, 0.00021942831517662853, -0.0765911117196083, 0.03536428138613701, -0.022869711741805077, -0.02668551541864872, -0.04743436723947525, -0.01319737359881401, 0.06441129744052887, -0.03342321887612343, -0.02469862625002861, -0.015483931638300419, -0.024641191586852074, -0.0023032533936202526, -0.025270778685808182, 0.005496103782206774, 0.009096072986721992, -0.052227750420570374, 0.011523490771651268, 0.04762691259384155, 0.001451927120797336, -0.00992121547460556, 0.0747993141412735, -0.019823968410491943, 0.025380045175552368, 0.020270980894565582, 0.02624106965959072, -0.05093444511294365, 0.04369058832526207, -0.04255468025803566, -0.03995785489678383, 0.02976979687809944, 0.05113517865538597, -0.0043186284601688385, -0.08008783310651779, 0.03584902733564377, -0.008723079226911068, -0.001293675391934812, -0.017391642555594444, 0.001992299221456051, -0.008383701555430889, -0.05860549956560135, 0.05955657362937927, -0.03287522494792938, -0.017201978713274002, -0.023903219029307365, -0.04899175092577934, 0.016406351700425148, -0.020887311547994614, 0.012712335214018822, -0.029877647757530212, -0.02133897878229618, -0.012351148761808872, 0.03367624431848526, -0.049924708902835846, -0.033891864120960236, 0.011630715802311897, 0.05555371195077896, -0.017464540898799896, -0.0033698866609483957, 0.024370882660150528, -0.029621828347444534, -0.038681793957948685, -0.003766559297218919, 0.031822483986616135, -0.009060810320079327, 0.03137541189789772, 0.04973263293504715, -0.008502260781824589, 0.025940943509340286, 0.023586321622133255, -0.0012502685422077775, 0.06841642409563065, -0.026893846690654755, -0.012340766377747059, 0.09192861616611481, -0.00007150295277824625, 0.006929432973265648, 0.057976651936769485, 0.010655034333467484, 0.058706868439912796, -0.02717548981308937, -0.05300780013203621, -0.02145383507013321, -0.03147011622786522, -0.019521668553352356, 0.007157845422625542, 0.0034386455081403255, -0.002021578373387456, 0.01259792223572731, -0.02455216273665428, 0.010919637978076935, -0.07301870733499527, -0.03029530495405197, 0.018572580069303513, 0.013786743395030499, -0.0008684297208674252, -0.004522762726992369, -0.016919592395424843, 0.04552575945854187, -0.007797704543918371, -0.08022692054510117, 0.0572153702378273, 0.0012066885828971863, 0.07458356022834778, -0.042202480137348175, -0.007202536799013615, 0.07008995115756989, -0.05955246835947037, 0.02676849253475666, 0.002560010878369212, -0.01175965927541256, -0.03921397030353546, 0.014742858707904816, 0.08233174681663513, 0.04323085770010948, 0.03337050974369049, -0.04008927568793297, -0.027798591181635857, 0.030644116923213005, -0.06607917696237564, 0.032650481909513474, 0.06461004167795181, 0.021196668967604637, 0.0305558480322361, -0.054336417466402054, 0.014754142612218857, -0.005337657872587442, -0.05377236753702164, 0.016644597053527832, 0.06611017882823944, 0.032392848283052444, -0.0003759883111342788, 0.04948803782463074, -0.0031386057380586863, 0.04551393911242485, -0.033064477145671844, 0.014006463810801506, -0.025285303592681885, 0.05563727393746376, -0.001987466821447015, 0.00036104617174714804, -0.0432015135884285, 0.048906028270721436, -0.06878218799829483, 0.014551233500242233, 0.03177155181765556, -0.007867863401770592, 0.08573919534683228, 0.011394956149160862, -0.023207781836390495, 0.025315728038549423, 0.052627116441726685, 0.03135169669985771, -0.009376496076583862, -0.0650559589266777, -0.01286764070391655, -0.030632859095931053, -0.006834715139120817, 0.020228547975420952, 0.005363335832953453, 0.009985962882637978, -0.04550694674253464, -0.08074040710926056, -0.04488486051559448, -0.004190149251371622, 0.06164469197392464, 0.014426963403820992, -0.02143448404967785, -0.04018209129571915, -0.011524238623678684, -0.0473606251180172, 0.02309209294617176, -0.08670401573181152, -0.010060515254735947, 0.013560827821493149, 0.018462518230080605, 0.007509199902415276, -0.03184579312801361, -0.01717146672308445, -0.03163675218820572, 0.015321713872253895, -0.006251650396734476, -0.016606831923127174, 0.006692257709801197, -0.048275623470544815, -0.048288360238075256, 0.033612851053476334, 0.012449082918465137, -0.041139040142297745, 0.07042215019464493, 0.00875859521329403, -0.06267870217561722, -0.005493422504514456, 0.08679376542568207, 0.005513146053999662, -0.02498367615044117, 0.04101508483290672, -0.05065952613949776, 0.059544339776039124, 0.0069742463529109955, 0.05461353063583374, 0.022985927760601044, -0.017789974808692932, -0.02084347978234291, -0.03592529892921448, -0.026358289644122124, -0.00990812387317419, -0.011984371580183506, -0.014393438585102558, 0.003056570654734969, -0.029522821307182312, -0.00836891308426857, 0.08739304542541504, -0.005395237356424332, 0.02563999779522419, -0.00451758224517107, 0.03800375014543533, 0.03429102152585983, 0.044778451323509216, 0.010393016040325165, -0.02989807166159153, -0.06139979884028435, -0.014687634073197842, -0.0473010279238224, 0.034671977162361145, -0.04191902279853821, -0.050938405096530914, -0.05309929698705673, -0.016015969216823578, 0.0024315686896443367, 0.017682339996099472, -0.0016143926186487079, -0.0728885680437088, -0.0837973803281784, -0.02682780846953392, 0.03649423271417618, 0.007353978231549263, 0.012587008066475391, 0.024477209895849228, -0.02343979850411415, 0.02411009557545185, -0.058169737458229065, 0.030279826372861862, 0.03172673285007477, -0.03926629573106766, 0.02966097742319107, 0.07421859353780746, -0.017712993547320366, -0.011784009635448456, -0.016324380412697792, -0.006733320187777281, -0.03602293133735657, -0.008164665661752224, -0.014726606197655201, 0.03751382976770401, 0.0005417345673777163, 0.027481133118271828, 0.010924860835075378, 0.02448546513915062, 0.04602234438061714, -0.004030488897114992, -0.043220821768045425, -0.0352829210460186, 0.02782159484922886, 0.018843336030840874, 0.04373859241604805, -0.008272655308246613, 0.00925583578646183, -0.013747057877480984 ]
<p>I was wondering what the following OLS scenario would imply: a variable is endogenous (i.e. correlated with the error term) yet is statistically significant.</p> <p>Alternatively, what if in, once again OLS, the variable is exogenous yet statistically insignificant (although the overall regression is indeed statistically significant - by say an F test).</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
g37130
[ 0.0036867763847112656, -0.0006119947065599263, -0.015258099883794785, -0.05537525936961174, 0.0337584912776947, 0.005346649792045355, 0.013276968151330948, 0.004073516000062227, 0.018385570496320724, -0.011602088809013367, -0.014194891788065434, 0.016632208600640297, 0.03910117596387863, 0.002828250639140606, -0.01249666977673769, 0.0032326553482562304, 0.06051119044423103, -0.03921874240040779, 0.02148725651204586, 0.01071519497781992, -0.051144037395715714, -0.02157151699066162, 0.03337671235203743, 0.015965798869729042, 0.04569267854094505, 0.0098303547129035, 0.0022825098130851984, 0.01135801337659359, -0.01743168570101261, -0.021454231813549995, 0.04482940956950188, -0.025464922189712524, 0.06888191401958466, -0.020924799144268036, -0.06175842136144638, -0.01376392599195242, 0.017113547772169113, 0.03329405561089516, 0.00007066995749482885, -0.010712149553000927, 0.033953890204429626, 0.052861690521240234, -0.0032126200385391712, 0.04186191037297249, -0.050197917968034744, -0.013632630929350853, 0.00321087590418756, 0.055377427488565445, 0.026255860924720764, -0.06133461371064186, -0.005453926045447588, 0.04283871874213219, 0.02312181144952774, 0.0370999239385128, 0.07177603244781494, 0.020845921710133553, 0.09106260538101196, 0.05131446570158005, -0.025040045380592346, 0.05690423399209976, 0.05372708663344383, 0.020459625869989395, -0.07330512255430222, 0.012321937829256058, 0.027993978932499886, -0.0065741585567593575, -0.013163692317903042, -0.024539031088352203, 0.038270093500614166, -0.04689152538776398, -0.003112567588686943, 0.01845119334757328, -0.002486306708306074, -0.039440978318452835, 0.007048195227980614, 0.019005319103598595, 0.028206253424286842, 0.01341753639280796, 0.0260024294257164, 0.024470582604408264, -0.032541822642087936, -0.0462784506380558, 0.014216348528862, 0.06449943780899048, 0.07449624687433243, -0.015426190569996834, -0.00181967846583575, -0.02166835404932499, -0.0504741370677948, -0.012898106127977371, 0.027374068275094032, 0.054493922740221024, 0.03412318602204323, 0.08948145806789398, -0.04904688894748688, 0.021246587857604027, 0.0014554967638105154, -0.02035941556096077, 0.011682504788041115, 0.026775892823934555, -0.027509763836860657, -0.007036634720861912, -0.01620367355644703, -0.025276824831962585, -0.006721642799675465, 0.02882641740143299, 0.03465304896235466, -0.003590008709579706, -0.11030752956867218, -0.019933443516492844, 0.0006586516392417252, 0.04514429345726967, -0.07758316397666931, -0.05434207245707512, -0.03136151656508446, 0.004603192675858736, 0.02752971276640892, -0.02910691313445568, -0.002464031334966421, -0.0022758422419428825, -0.010944971814751625, 0.012105084955692291, 0.005122479051351547, 0.056763119995594025, -0.054730989038944244, 0.05407949164509773, 0.017251040786504745, 0.032518789172172546, 0.052180126309394836, 0.017722537741065025, 0.0336192362010479, -0.00573703134432435, -0.02832995355129242, -0.017429986968636513, 0.027104360982775688, 0.03517439588904381, 0.007448547054082155, 0.04646743834018707, 0.012990185990929604, 0.021971143782138824, -0.0328691303730011, -0.004968952387571335, 0.015703823417425156, 0.04965914413332939, -0.07881394773721695, 0.001911141094751656, 0.05390481650829315, -0.016909172758460045, 0.0025386493653059006, -0.01946553960442543, -0.0001872484863270074, -0.042909640818834305, -0.03761174529790878, -0.03927941247820854, -0.05168710649013519, 0.031166834756731987, -0.08073560148477554, -0.09284959733486176, -0.029003547504544258, -0.0050970688462257385, 0.048106443136930466, -0.020770687609910965, 0.015679221600294113, 0.046447839587926865, -0.0358114019036293, 0.021403245627880096, -0.025808682665228844, -0.05769707262516022, -0.004453385714441538, 0.008760914206504822, -0.006311411038041115, -0.030613427981734276, 0.07834536582231522, 0.007771723438054323, 0.04418463259935379, 0.01645815372467041, 0.04210711643099785, -0.006544151343405247, 0.03013153001666069, 0.0018204750958830118, 0.009101161733269691, -0.006794474087655544, -0.01037635188549757, -0.0371563658118248, 0.023447329178452492, -0.08336349576711655, 0.0005204642657190561, -0.023774774745106697, -0.05904778465628624, 0.028718359768390656, -0.03645382076501846, -0.0260841753333807, -0.009982980787754059, 0.004377726931124926, -0.03973495587706566, -0.015029790811240673, 0.026418235152959824, -0.0395512618124485, 0.005948401056230068, -0.01622082106769085, 0.0025284348521381617, -0.033987876027822495, -0.04090743139386177, 0.01647842489182949, -0.0400247760117054, -0.026847174391150475, -0.008001196198165417, -0.040413398295640945, -0.05606493726372719, -0.01476231124252081, 0.023094311356544495, -0.02135598659515381, -0.03874391317367554, 0.03010009042918682, 0.020251045003533363, -0.06773556023836136, -0.030883368104696274, -0.0011778692714869976, -0.03482083976268768, 0.017111415043473244, -0.025426354259252548, 0.001092862687073648, 0.06165250763297081, 0.0020437168423086405, -0.02573631890118122, 0.008612001314759254, 0.009513046592473984, -0.004631475079804659, -0.026942472904920578, 0.03485410287976265, 0.0031205478589981794, -0.029801327735185623, 0.06304141879081726, -0.028450118377804756, 0.0003930576494894922, -0.016893967986106873, 0.019167784601449966, -0.031839653849601746, -0.009974819608032703, 0.04515886306762695, -0.02947208657860756, 0.030268186703324318, 0.0002511577040422708, 0.020833728834986687, 0.027280982583761215, 0.005327322520315647, -0.013828021474182606, -0.012790429405868053, -0.007162959314882755, 0.09274405241012573, -0.07076238840818405, 0.05601397156715393, -0.009187635965645313, -0.02454450912773609, 0.030918583273887634, -0.029258323833346367, 0.02074408531188965, 0.05033723637461662, -0.00038892438169568777, 0.009350941516458988, -0.0372789092361927, -0.03140024468302727, 0.007678076159209013, -0.016878962516784668, 0.013054479844868183, 0.005573643371462822, -0.009635156951844692, -0.06035841628909111, -0.013117363676428795, -0.0324246920645237, -0.07683971524238586, 0.01689208298921585, -0.020116353407502174, 0.07296314835548401, 0.06362135708332062, 0.024580545723438263, -0.04215708374977112, -0.039124030619859695, 0.041258808225393295, -0.037105459719896317, 0.06659849733114243, -0.01699190028011799, -0.02885589562356472, 0.020639562979340553, 0.008661839179694653, 0.005854476243257523, 0.03259311243891716, -0.019330663606524467, 0.011801573447883129, -0.0013947330880910158, -0.011774912476539612, -0.016691431403160095, -0.00757980439811945, 0.013856934383511543, -0.012573928572237492, 0.033005859702825546, 0.008385556749999523, -0.07248289883136749, 0.013373903930187225, 0.03409446403384209, -0.04835359752178192, 0.022660810500383377, -0.007377502508461475, 0.01918332464993, 0.048785217106342316, 0.00664425827562809, -0.05375141277909279, -0.008008742704987526, -0.012693443335592747, -0.05189027264714241, -0.04869319126009941, 0.022181371226906776, 0.038415804505348206, 0.0002829402801580727, -0.0483972504734993, -0.004482640419155359, 0.026261059567332268, 0.027248019352555275, 0.0020381296053528786, -0.007647152990102768, 0.02365945838391781, -0.02828810177743435, 0.0062012034468352795, 0.0540841780602932, 0.01739606074988842, -0.06015988439321518, -0.02173290029168129, -0.018741771578788757, -0.04922332614660263, 0.028128240257501602, 0.034663815051317215, -0.03309396654367447, -0.0508459210395813, -0.016559617593884468, 0.004807286895811558, -0.04461066424846649, -0.011132340878248215, 0.009697730652987957, 0.003798223566263914, 0.07256143540143967, 0.03576900064945221, -0.019410310313105583, -0.017409898340702057, 0.039023250341415405, -0.04256268963217735, -0.008064133115112782, 0.007716558873653412, -0.0043991683050990105, -0.01217443123459816, 0.022789614275097847, 0.024544358253479004, -0.033615611493587494, 0.0025531018618494272, -0.004862560890614986, 0.011619063094258308, 0.045461609959602356, 0.052603576332330704, 0.054056938737630844, -0.0027470013592392206, -0.04896599054336548, -0.003075627377256751, -0.04003334417939186, 0.0070755211636424065, 0.0071798949502408504, 0.028744159266352654, 0.04599827155470848, -0.012559441849589348, 0.0317874513566494, -0.01303458958864212, -0.0058988239616155624, -0.029117103666067123, 0.08847060054540634, -0.0010905670933425426, -0.029511872678995132, 0.023166583850979805, -0.02294338308274746, 0.04254185035824776, 0.0654112920165062, -0.005549206398427486, 0.04110771417617798, 0.07007543742656708, 0.050696324557065964, 0.014332986436784267, 0.019769448786973953, 0.026925254613161087, -0.08134470880031586, -0.05633595213294029, 0.02413700520992279, -0.013843278400599957, 0.03925993666052818, -0.010623293928802013, 0.01585737057030201, -0.01629423350095749, 0.07752103358507156, 0.030597252771258354, 0.010428942739963531, 0.06441550701856613, -0.007878473028540611, 0.07306244969367981, 0.06858522444963455, 0.0077832164242863655, 0.016002245247364044, 0.03529416397213936, 0.03992978110909462, -0.04164090007543564, 0.021412216126918793, 0.06995852291584015, 0.0026311140973120928, -0.08205550909042358, 0.008675276301801205, 0.007743204478174448, -0.01301734708249569, 0.013603575527668, 0.003590448759496212, -0.017167499288916588, 0.02421916462481022, 0.02773202583193779, -0.024173608049750328, 0.03007434494793415, 0.0333004929125309, 0.06732562929391861, 0.016699882224202156, 0.01339117530733347, 0.04339674487709999, -0.012158045545220375, 0.021467488259077072, -0.0033235258888453245, 0.008378155529499054, -0.013982567936182022, -0.026802998036146164, -0.005034398287534714, 0.02657313272356987, 0.016289379447698593, 0.021392066031694412, 0.01823345199227333, 0.016255255788564682, -0.04623665660619736, 0.05494525283575058, 0.02184923179447651, 0.002906269393861294, -0.005373266991227865, -0.05941539257764816, -0.03907255828380585, 0.04740360006690025, -0.012397687882184982, 0.007626284379512072, 0.05798393860459328, -0.04139934852719307, 0.05440584197640419, -0.0012979988241568208, -0.04753127694129944, 0.06382855772972107, -0.030200554057955742, -0.03517620638012886, 0.030930744484066963, -0.05460459366440773, 0.03991638869047165, 0.008942000567913055, 0.03873808681964874, -0.018037892878055573, -0.020181972533464432, -0.05794082581996918, 0.03211527317762375, 0.02553737163543701, 0.0035798277240246534, -0.07204587012529373, 0.03341192379593849, -0.016237478703260422, -0.007260449696332216, 0.00554600078612566, -0.05698952078819275, -0.033683836460113525, 0.04071526229381561, 0.01956966146826744, -0.04837176203727722, -0.005869124084711075, -0.01024660188704729, -0.0529012568295002, -0.014368466101586819, 0.030215397477149963, -0.027423013001680374, -0.1236545741558075, 0.006418631412088871, 0.010868886485695839, 0.001436380436643958, -0.021450217813253403, 0.003320815972983837, -0.08724338561296463, 0.03556639701128006, -0.001997077139094472, 0.06181274726986885, 0.01584380306303501, 0.026592984795570374, 0.03328639641404152, -0.03972117602825165, -0.04239579662680626, 0.0029014917090535164, -0.056034188717603683, 0.007627078797668219, -0.04670350253582001, -0.02516067586839199, 0.006338812876492739, -0.008721034973859787, -0.0048539708368480206, -0.04127642884850502, -0.016493963077664375, 0.09971732646226883, -0.08114954084157944, -0.01024616975337267, 0.01699203997850418, -0.019793709740042686, -0.012445284985005856, -0.0020714926067739725, -0.010794795118272305, -0.005203549284487963, -0.013317161239683628, -0.03346427530050278, -0.011045683175325394, 0.0037096855230629444, -0.031206736341118813, 0.04421869292855263, -0.05873480066657066, -0.0011879258090630174, -0.00680881179869175, -0.005366047844290733, -0.04594793543219566, -0.008299718610942364, -0.05068620294332504, 0.02655516192317009, 0.03358186036348343, -0.036646872758865356, 0.028263691812753677, 0.026195526123046875, 0.011873225681483746, 0.06414403021335602, -0.048787057399749756, -0.02863178215920925, 0.022698381915688515, 0.05611222982406616, 0.012702207081019878, -0.03379764407873154, -0.009073670022189617, 0.00026767223607748747, 0.004778389818966389, 0.01866568997502327, 0.00849833246320486, 0.025901608169078827, -0.03239167109131813, 0.017539937049150467, -0.04923225939273834, -0.020175596699118614, 0.043401651084423065, -0.0512126125395298, 0.028094718232750893, -0.05848109349608421, 0.04626108333468437, 0.06026460602879524, 0.031697873026132584, 0.00962985772639513, -0.04189501330256462, 0.026450863108038902, -0.0641276016831398, 0.01049767341464758, -0.0189225897192955, -0.02527358941733837, -0.05589213967323303, -0.02036195434629917, -0.03658166900277138, -0.029310129582881927, 0.06035434454679489, 0.001781460247002542, -0.009032298810780048, 0.04237920790910721, 0.020377956330776215, -0.014339342713356018, 0.014285676181316376, -0.02862013503909111, 0.008860627189278603, 0.07258687913417816, 0.015246372669935226, -0.0332760214805603, -0.07288113236427307, -0.019470373168587685, -0.012027038261294365, -0.052148256450891495, 0.013921097852289677, -0.05740197002887726, 0.024627553299069405, -0.001393805956467986, -0.019549457356333733, -0.0633125826716423, -0.015095547772943974, 0.011879561468958855, 0.01915709115564823, -0.037342511117458344, -0.06548933684825897, -0.018970858305692673, -0.03122657723724842, 0.017464475706219673, -0.017245806753635406, -0.004223967436701059, 0.005835569463670254, 0.06154456362128258, -0.0064049968495965, 0.007917794398963451, 0.03992225229740143, -0.0304835457354784, 0.0208553746342659, 0.0007483274675905704, 0.004645509645342827, -0.023615607991814613, 0.0268532857298851, 0.09016665816307068, 0.019285136833786964, 0.0027061335276812315, -0.03896365687251091, -0.054431408643722534, -0.01352046150714159, -0.046133894473314285, 0.0382954441010952, 0.010680553503334522, -0.027617016807198524, 0.03820285573601723, -0.03852362185716629, -0.010059325955808163, 0.03887680917978287, -0.04965362325310707, 0.024307595565915108, 0.0018146632937714458, 0.0006841441500000656, -0.044233281165361404, 0.05652172863483429, -0.008264124393463135, -0.03427702188491821, -0.07213468849658966, 0.03428937867283821, -0.04219912737607956, 0.02676982246339321, 0.06337989866733551, 0.019791655242443085, -0.035664647817611694, 0.10512985289096832, -0.021193861961364746, 0.04502662271261215, -0.024511881172657013, 0.02241319604218006, 0.011062520556151867, 0.029694851487874985, -0.0844588503241539, -0.012122725136578083, 0.016465110704302788, -0.012057519517838955, 0.025255709886550903, -0.017995713278651237, 0.01695391722023487, 0.049699485301971436, 0.022724932059645653, 0.030457772314548492, 0.05304289981722832, -0.060453031212091446, -0.0628952831029892, 0.003298314055427909, -0.03339101001620293, 0.03765414282679558, -0.01930234767496586, -0.006844021379947662, 0.05009414255619049, -0.09804576635360718, -0.012254252098500729, -0.02782357670366764, 0.02963089570403099, -0.030328210443258286, -0.03121067024767399, -0.013033054769039154, 0.01995992846786976, -0.05116866156458855, -0.023596161976456642, 0.03933215141296387, -0.03619471192359924, 0.04752395674586296, -0.021456582471728325, -0.02244124934077263, 0.02156681753695011, 0.002154611749574542, -0.032336898148059845, -0.00588600616902113, -0.023461030796170235, -0.06867661327123642, 0.024251332506537437, -0.004333648830652237, -0.05896609276533127, 0.015218300744891167, 0.028101079165935516, 0.04028644412755966, -0.005146249663084745, 0.07507810741662979, -0.02676132507622242, 0.04820945858955383, 0.01551422942429781, 0.00886464025825262, -0.03020869940519333, 0.04433088004589081, -0.009708794765174389, 0.0015607228269800544, 0.059858109802007675, -0.028956294059753418, -0.005918663926422596, -0.005153054371476173, -0.03567403554916382, -0.06733322888612747, -0.0466417632997036, 0.0640295073390007, 0.01622406765818596, 0.02832230180501938, 0.03611747547984123, -0.023888062685728073, 0.008511200547218323, -0.06277764588594437, 0.0647544115781784, 0.07276266068220139, -0.030545923858880997, 0.027543220669031143, -0.011363471858203411, -0.02745075151324272, -0.04027443751692772, -0.027202682569622993, -0.004006752744317055, -0.04533354192972183, 0.01980186626315117, -0.058688875287771225, -0.01387892384082079, -0.004883787129074335, -0.006665003951638937, 0.013063809834420681, 0.010460018180310726, 0.0413503460586071, 0.008999140933156013, 0.07608231902122498, -0.0654914379119873, 0.017732815816998482, -0.01321225706487894, -0.0015723532997071743, 0.04538401588797569, -0.019602568820118904, -0.008506637066602707, -0.02405904419720173, 0.0011606559855863452, 0.04039132222533226, -0.036602601408958435, 0.022372763603925705, -0.056261248886585236, 0.03243269771337509, -0.02940690889954567, 0.07843204587697983, 0.05837707594037056, -0.014110115356743336, -0.06921993941068649, 0.024968931451439857, -0.01873031072318554, 0.00989494752138853, -0.025288786739110947, 0.021222073584794998, 0.003510795533657074, 0.030701203271746635, -0.011906935833394527, -0.0743103101849556, -0.03744097799062729, 0.035382673144340515 ]
<p>I found several similar questions with no answer. But I'm gonna give it a shot anyway. </p> <p>I'm trying to find assets (stocks) which are co-integrated, since Engle-Granger's test may give cause to spurious regression it's suggested by several articles that you use Johansen's test as well to ensure a long-term co-integration. Even though I've not taken any course in time series analysis yet the Engle-Granger's test was not to difficult to understand. Johansen's test was on the other hand slightly more challenging, so I'm trying to understand how the interpret the results you're given in matlab.</p> <p>So when I run the test for a nx2 vector in Matlab I get a 1x2 matrix as result with the inputs true or false. So the question is when I can reject/not reject the hypothesis.</p> <pre><code>************************ </code></pre> <p>Results Summary (Test 1)</p> <p>Data: Effective sample size: 13 Model: H1 Lags: 0 Statistic: trace Significance level: 0.05</p> <h1>r h stat cValue pValue eigVal</h1> <p>0 1 23.6646 15.4948 0.0031 0.7486<br> 1 1 5.7169 3.8415 0.0170 0.3558 </p> <p>h = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 true true </code></pre> <p>pValue = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 0.0031234 0.016977 </code></pre> <p>stat = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 23.665 5.7169 </code></pre> <p>cValue = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 15.495 3.8415 </code></pre> <p>mles = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 [1x1 struct] [1x1 struct] </code></pre>
g47705
[ 0.048582665622234344, 0.0026149882469326258, -0.0049896240234375, -0.005039480049163103, 0.026260679587721825, 0.009208586998283863, 0.07979661971330643, -0.0035303260665386915, -0.07536981254816055, 0.040159761905670166, 0.008822971023619175, 0.02841181680560112, 0.034709133207798004, -0.0007900286582298577, -0.03439454361796379, -0.01957491785287857, 0.06355101615190506, 0.056907497346401215, 0.0046295286156237125, 0.023974889889359474, -0.027147017419338226, 0.04393497481942177, 0.029691331088542938, -0.04319065064191818, 0.05955357849597931, -0.04921383410692215, -0.01564290188252926, 0.008951469324529171, -0.05597490444779396, 0.018341204151511192, 0.037133216857910156, 0.011340429075062275, 0.10413608700037003, -0.0829990953207016, -0.04734931141138077, 0.0007531841401942074, 0.038796041160821915, -0.005682335700839758, -0.0028844813350588083, -0.02723146602511406, -0.02074309252202511, 0.00007176108920248225, -0.004677665885537863, 0.011941041797399521, 0.005997790023684502, 0.05232422053813934, 0.07990381121635437, -0.0024754113983362913, 0.06339733302593231, 0.015387684106826782, -0.020815696567296982, 0.044981323182582855, 0.028004592284560204, -0.02626492828130722, -0.03888527303934097, 0.04695722833275795, -0.031284149736166, 0.05880745127797127, 0.049186427146196365, 0.023313304409384727, 0.03716578707098961, -0.03648604825139046, -0.018923917785286903, 0.07240623235702515, 0.06901627779006958, -0.004247437696903944, 0.016844918951392174, -0.04269524663686752, 0.03262847661972046, -0.04712580516934395, -0.008869199082255363, -0.005907879211008549, 0.0333838127553463, 0.011811185628175735, 0.03307181969285011, -0.03848294913768768, 0.020266437903046608, 0.034821052104234695, -0.005784619599580765, 0.031158624216914177, 0.04274103790521622, -0.014138398692011833, -0.012097866274416447, 0.015142958611249924, 0.0806908831000328, -0.03803051635622978, 0.0177504513412714, -0.004567308817058802, 0.012079741805791855, 0.023435603827238083, 0.05683846026659012, 0.05041038617491722, 0.03951810672879219, 0.06997082382440567, -0.007154718041419983, 0.021096624433994293, -0.033696096390485764, -0.019145993515849113, -0.012071429751813412, -0.037592388689517975, -0.02248229645192623, 0.028818272054195404, -0.023806028068065643, 0.005231127142906189, -0.05493790656328201, 0.019904905930161476, 0.0145326629281044, -0.048459604382514954, -0.07440309226512909, -0.008477657102048397, -0.0419355183839798, 0.015111954882740974, -0.04572419077157974, -0.03365657106041908, -0.019335342571139336, 0.0016752195078879595, 0.06038913130760193, -0.017919236794114113, -0.03667059913277626, -0.04925573617219925, -0.00846936833113432, 0.0342801958322525, 0.0013355390401557088, 0.051459480077028275, -0.07140703499317169, -0.03022913634777069, -0.056385304778814316, 0.06006258353590965, 0.023503895848989487, -0.0011705114739015698, 0.00585600920021534, 0.040663301944732666, -0.009556669741868973, 0.06145068630576134, 0.04244902729988098, 0.014024888165295124, -0.03717067837715149, 0.0401722714304924, 0.0036651340778917074, 0.06321685761213303, -0.003095385152846575, -0.02241102233529091, -0.0037331318017095327, -0.016448581591248512, -0.0210939459502697, 0.009547751396894455, 0.02252102829515934, -0.01229107566177845, -0.006344428285956383, 0.04531089588999748, 0.02674366906285286, -0.009274721145629883, -0.04356032982468605, 0.049803007394075394, 0.031850848346948624, -0.012188068591058254, -0.02522183768451214, -0.10594503581523895, 0.01451863907277584, -0.0009740389650687575, 0.0010198629461228848, -0.01704219914972782, 0.04936952516436577, 0.009864644147455692, -0.0001791554386727512, -0.035494785755872726, -0.03901727497577667, 0.007523419335484505, 0.05741990730166435, -0.01765553653240204, 0.027657024562358856, -0.0016684229485690594, -0.012476993724703789, 0.012634332291781902, 0.01331092044711113, 0.04029758647084236, 0.024049729108810425, -0.03742411732673645, 0.03346485272049904, 0.03275980055332184, 0.008940257132053375, 0.05789520964026451, 0.009729664772748947, 0.014882497489452362, 0.03709288313984871, -0.07451897114515305, 0.00567575404420495, 0.054532140493392944, -0.07443506270647049, -0.04338746517896652, -0.006554306484758854, 0.015276138670742512, -0.051622845232486725, -0.019480694085359573, 0.023466072976589203, -0.07548868656158447, 0.018367743119597435, -0.06706514209508896, -0.03644424304366112, -0.014170479960739613, -0.012981416657567024, 0.03390403091907501, 0.02379528246819973, 0.051909189671278, -0.06912239640951157, -0.05737574025988579, -0.002505121286958456, -0.03836633637547493, 0.01885860227048397, -0.04095020517706871, 0.013097327202558517, -0.013763434253633022, 0.0076890732161700726, 0.058941978961229324, 0.03900202736258507, -0.042708903551101685, 0.04547479376196861, 0.03675631061196327, -0.023326372727751732, -0.0006210925639607012, -0.029818572103977203, -0.022222284227609634, 0.007493877317756414, -0.0530465804040432, 0.0274136271327734, 0.009391349740326405, 0.04262060672044754, -0.028580129146575928, -0.035543810576200485, -0.020512107759714127, -0.0012030538637191057, 0.009119718335568905, -0.05395657569169998, -0.02912515215575695, -0.0005639598821289837, 0.011952250264585018, 0.03038359060883522, 0.00896944385021925, -0.015011556446552277, 0.08290793746709824, -0.00945636723190546, 0.053810037672519684, -0.02832239307463169, -0.04560002312064171, 0.03793080523610115, -0.01835837960243225, 0.05422084033489227, -0.007893439382314682, 0.0021361897233873606, 0.023029018193483353, -0.0674864798784256, 0.04360092431306839, -0.010984388180077076, -0.020667660981416702, 0.008501647971570492, -0.009329556487500668, 0.02742745168507099, 0.0013902044156566262, -0.014111888594925404, 0.03395931050181389, -0.049126461148262024, 0.0043780687265098095, 0.00738541642203927, 0.050933755934238434, -0.0508141927421093, -0.055931031703948975, -0.003844666061922908, -0.06311432272195816, 0.05885457992553711, -0.04092933237552643, -0.05128716677427292, 0.028780372813344002, 0.02785400114953518, 0.07305470108985901, 0.055584438145160675, 0.013034648261964321, -0.02621397376060486, -0.03359294682741165, 0.015628207474946976, 0.01876538060605526, -0.04313615709543228, -0.062010757625103, -0.03050459362566471, 0.023966502398252487, 0.023767562583088875, 0.019564351066946983, -0.012676563113927841, 0.05230531841516495, 0.019896363839507103, 0.012301099486649036, -0.04333052411675453, 0.0074916742742061615, 0.0034080299083143473, -0.026244869455695152, 0.000057192857639165595, -0.0404067225754261, -0.004936650861054659, -0.04792909324169159, 0.032905466854572296, 0.012606768868863583, -0.01966673508286476, 0.052856314927339554, 0.02460302598774433, -0.06537016481161118, 0.018096070736646652, -0.055798862129449844, -0.01436422299593687, -0.044615477323532104, -0.010832560248672962, -0.04734223335981369, -0.015704339370131493, 0.036445971578359604, -0.0005609660292975605, -0.02454567514359951, -0.005848112981766462, 0.009173326194286346, 0.01674623228609562, 0.0055770473554730415, 0.03768792375922203, -0.018565576523542404, -0.029416214674711227, 0.005069295410066843, 0.010208294726908207, -0.037837088108062744, -0.06277276575565338, -0.01985601894557476, 0.021524127572774887, 0.016985783353447914, -0.022563640028238297, 0.009976332075893879, 0.034759584814310074, -0.024452637881040573, 0.0376986563205719, 0.03236406669020653, 0.011865041218698025, -0.038099370896816254, -0.014363601803779602, 0.01767650991678238, -0.009799976833164692, 0.05763908103108406, -0.060733500868082047, -0.0490821972489357, 0.00019235353101976216, 0.002775420667603612, -0.03142983093857765, -0.045865945518016815, -0.03147554025053978, 0.01572922058403492, 0.018207333981990814, 0.02513071335852146, -0.0643618106842041, -0.007550950627774, -0.000711265776772052, -0.04862948879599571, 0.009112033993005753, -0.022332189604640007, 0.013047496788203716, 0.042229536920785904, -0.03028290905058384, 0.0002536717220209539, 0.030239297077059746, -0.01186312921345234, 0.006172352936118841, -0.01011638157069683, -0.004445606842637062, -0.0025196559727191925, 0.0074211847968399525, 0.0781264454126358, 0.04094977304339409, -0.02867470122873783, 0.011582722887396812, 0.10017642378807068, 0.039792273193597794, 0.013913908042013645, -0.035631634294986725, -0.05609641224145889, 0.002599903382360935, 0.012522876262664795, 0.0374167375266552, 0.04667763411998749, 0.04828617349267006, -0.017353512346744537, -0.09364873915910721, -0.007400078698992729, 0.03538590669631958, -0.04970294609665871, 0.0346309095621109, 0.023023616522550583, -0.006596140097826719, -0.03145638480782509, 0.010534319095313549, 0.026659879833459854, -0.06580068171024323, 0.105474092066288, 0.01987319439649582, -0.030544180423021317, -0.03740180656313896, 0.04414862021803856, -0.043544407933950424, 0.010943320579826832, 0.01339657325297594, 0.010769424960017204, 0.01691882498562336, -0.008490340784192085, 0.036571212112903595, -0.017375629395246506, -0.008403090760111809, -0.014777086675167084, -0.028867388144135475, -0.012411697767674923, -0.027101557701826096, -0.040211230516433716, 0.021131929010152817, -0.05057556927204132, 0.08517469465732574, -0.006863991729915142, 0.0657382607460022, -0.010790764354169369, -0.03436198830604553, -0.01343577727675438, 0.037280526012182236, 0.08106984943151474, -0.047011442482471466, -0.005588075611740351, 0.04343895614147186, 0.04295261576771736, -0.010627146810293198, -0.025667423382401466, 0.012483692727982998, 0.0022927140817046165, -0.008362866006791592, 0.015823418274521828, -0.04692380130290985, -0.034495819360017776, -0.032337699085474014, 0.060997918248176575, 0.035379037261009216, 0.03796687722206116, -0.023063242435455322, 0.014400538988411427, -0.03064104914665222, -0.0440998375415802, 0.012900411151349545, -0.008381257764995098, 0.0067621925845742226, 0.0688595175743103, 0.0026504851412028074, -0.0504942387342453, 0.012007256969809532, 0.007992335595190525, -0.021083757281303406, -0.051486995071172714, -0.03784358501434326, 0.00862663984298706, -0.021302618086338043, 0.01608385518193245, -0.009194639511406422, 0.02415791153907776, 0.017227493226528168, 0.02321743406355381, 0.017569564282894135, -0.061435237526893616, -0.03173314407467842, -0.006769243162125349, 0.055130619555711746, -0.03796308487653732, -0.04233230650424957, -0.019394241273403168, 0.05706704035401344, 0.016565507277846336, -0.008277231827378273, -0.062323134392499924, 0.07482913136482239, -0.028315234929323196, 0.0008197774295695126, 0.026274720206856728, 0.0008623559260740876, 0.0008368105627596378, -0.01482749916613102, -0.013808433897793293, -0.01174697931855917, 0.009181132540106773, 0.025783706456422806, -0.012015433982014656, 0.03909934684634209, -0.052674200385808945, -0.015962881967425346, -0.014612216502428055, 0.016828758642077446, -0.04322737827897072, 0.03791150823235512, 0.05277218297123909, 0.03711384907364845, -0.006025809329003096, -0.0038379929028451443, 0.02645910531282425, -0.008697309531271458, -0.020111851394176483, -0.031135372817516327, 0.014088405296206474, -0.058180250227451324, -0.00048030365724116564, -0.04444311931729317, -0.006908594164997339, -0.018441740423440933, -0.020639119669795036, 0.05171243101358414, -0.050389621406793594, -0.0256244707852602, 0.012418029829859734, -0.03129018470644951, -0.003547936212271452, -0.0024676723405718803, -0.005408673547208309, -0.042152367532253265, -0.024388214573264122, -0.014569651335477829, -0.00636378163471818, 0.002549517899751663, -0.04426199197769165, 0.039253395050764084, -0.031185919418931007, -0.011799930594861507, -0.040341369807720184, 0.026788583025336266, -0.017185864970088005, -0.0002459065872244537, -0.07567088305950165, -0.011345314793288708, 0.046553127467632294, -0.024084214121103287, 0.016598816961050034, 0.01917169988155365, 0.059531036764383316, 0.009927776642143726, -0.037248533219099045, -0.0005251766997389495, 0.006118861027061939, -0.005505830980837345, -0.047862328588962555, -0.054634131491184235, 0.013877058401703835, -0.05754612758755684, -0.0036541814915835857, -0.05080058425664902, -0.0012770286994054914, 0.05781294405460358, -0.018816834315657616, 0.016882559284567833, -0.08492370694875717, -0.01238304190337658, -0.03074582852423191, -0.020493239164352417, -0.004713157657533884, -0.00044540298404172063, 0.03073708340525627, 0.011323949322104454, 0.008211986161768436, 0.010426091961562634, 0.054818734526634216, -0.018053818494081497, -0.04427456110715866, -0.04234521836042404, 0.017987683415412903, 0.036056872457265854, -0.02436710149049759, 0.032761089503765106, 0.006079690530896187, -0.008274940773844719, 0.02350079081952572, 0.0423484668135643, -0.06282057613134384, 0.03330535814166069, 0.018300142139196396, 0.022086136043071747, 0.03873651474714279, -0.03672907128930092, 0.00047614777577109635, 0.0446024052798748, -0.010181250981986523, -0.013822268694639206, -0.047430675476789474, 0.02584187127649784, 0.019197555258870125, -0.019957393407821655, 0.03200841322541237, -0.021725459024310112, -0.0031518556643277407, -0.025845469906926155, 0.010216672904789448, -0.0709347277879715, -0.018928971141576767, 0.01337413489818573, -0.0253912266343832, 0.010563233867287636, -0.023114215582609177, -0.017996640875935555, 0.08147907257080078, 0.05488404631614685, -0.028811050578951836, -0.05089574307203293, -0.02581719122827053, 0.09245222806930542, -0.03683457896113396, 0.01958417147397995, 0.024881592020392418, 0.0026620705612003803, 0.005247951485216618, -0.04876769334077835, 0.053701773285865784, -0.035653408616781235, -0.00419586431235075, 0.0031988166738301516, 0.029113218188285828, 0.08227536082267761, -0.03222504258155823, -0.04559635370969772, -0.007521907798945904, -0.030800843611359596, 0.0012070572702214122, 0.001070959260687232, -0.05177381634712219, -0.013245305977761745, -0.007791746407747269, -0.030276278033852577, 0.02720009721815586, -0.0007444065995514393, -0.006201018579304218, 0.03974119946360588, -0.015889642760157585, -0.01529688760638237, 0.055507391691207886, -0.01455773413181305, -0.020027946680784225, -0.04073932021856308, 0.027087654918432236, -0.0203221645206213, 0.06055113300681114, 0.04448188841342926, 0.06689321249723434, -0.030095193535089493, 0.06948129087686539, -0.040483854711055756, -0.016087161377072334, -0.017245370894670486, 0.048473555594682693, 0.04237428307533264, -0.01906190998852253, -0.04032878950238228, -0.006692364811897278, 0.044211022555828094, 0.021099114790558815, -0.014028534293174744, -0.07000508159399033, 0.006805730052292347, 0.032874442636966705, 0.033639587461948395, 0.0460084043443203, 0.06805887073278427, -0.01664801873266697, -0.05708487704396248, 0.017745142802596092, -0.07795238494873047, -0.020327573642134666, -0.004583083093166351, 0.07831864058971405, 0.01691579259932041, -0.04124081879854202, -0.005989507772028446, -0.013623679056763649, -0.006153237074613571, 0.013273426331579685, 0.0054180435836315155, 0.029669074341654778, 0.06370089203119278, 0.0020968285389244556, -0.057116299867630005, -0.018064385280013084, -0.01716727390885353, -0.0028220973908901215, -0.00767536461353302, 0.03261902183294296, 0.0543915219604969, 0.08472531288862228, -0.017965296283364296, 0.010621506720781326, -0.08035904914140701, -0.04460033401846886, -0.008503397926688194, -0.012114145793020725, -0.010891895741224289, 0.019711509346961975, -0.021090885624289513, 0.0726153627038002, 0.02574831247329712, 0.0029482815880328417, -0.0517006441950798, 0.04426576942205429, -0.052607495337724686, 0.07448084652423859, 0.007265671622008085, 0.05224603787064552, -0.04398669674992561, 0.018803216516971588, -0.00207540113478899, -0.012097641825675964, 0.014408706687390804, -0.015509768389165401, -0.04208436608314514, -0.018574070185422897, -0.02893243171274662, 0.0668414756655693, 0.029295053333044052, 0.07347774505615234, 0.00524439150467515, 0.024472352117300034, 0.02504567801952362, -0.05106491222977638, -0.019688095897436142, 0.06074206903576851, -0.06598979234695435, -0.05172283574938774, 0.00764460489153862, 0.0019155038753524423, -0.0018647469114512205, -0.07808954268693924, -0.07262937724590302, 0.06914636492729187, -0.056086380034685135, -0.039378147572278976, -0.04848290979862213, -0.036386631429195404, -0.04203088581562042, 0.016616255044937134, 0.012417393736541271, 0.01668035425245762, -0.0045009455643594265, -0.024389341473579407, -0.028807053342461586, 0.027667464688420296, -0.015848496928811073, -0.026968371123075485, -0.007568945176899433, 0.024051854386925697, -0.002085078740492463, -0.02263692207634449, 0.006744037847965956, 0.004844112321734428, -0.02411312237381935, -0.0036161195021122694, 0.022557228803634644, 0.02928217314183712, -0.012412847951054573, 0.014164251275360584, 0.014538666233420372, -0.0019470773404464126, -0.07565320283174515, -0.0013645895523950458, 0.03175168111920357, -0.018261276185512543, 0.024646034464240074, -0.045565005391836166, -0.017969509586691856, 0.012772518210113049, 0.06590959429740906, -0.0729956179857254, -0.01826290600001812, 0.00007293833914445713 ]
<p>I've been using igraph and statnet to do most of my network analysis, but I am trying to replicate results that I use MPNet (an expansion to <a href="http://sna.unimelb.edu.au/PNet" rel="nofollow">PNet</a>) in order to perform some simulations on a multi-level network. I'm hoping someone has experience with PNet or MPNet and can offer a suggestion.</p> <p>I've run a few simulations of small networks, and the output for any specific simulation doesn't really lend itself to being visualized easily in igraph and statnet outside of manually inputting the networks and visual attributes of each vertex. This is problematic for me because I want to simulate large-ish (n>20 in each level) networks. </p> <p><em>However,</em> it does appear that the output is intended to be visualized by the way it is written (see below), but I'm unsure what program it's intended for and cannot find much existing MPNet (or PNet) help online. </p> <p><strong>My question is this:</strong> is there a way to use MPNet output for a specific simulation to visualize the network that is being simulated without manually entering in each network and visual attributes into some package? Or in other words, did MPNet designers have a destination in mind with their output?</p> <hr> <p>The following picture is a quick MSPaint rendition of this 10 vertex multi-level simulated network (because we all need a little MSPaint in our lives): <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Lts6N.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I have four output text files for a specific simulation (sorry in advance for the huge amount of output):</p> <p>Network A: </p> <pre><code> *vertices 5 1 "" box ic Blue bc Black 2 "" box ic Blue bc Black 3 "" box ic Blue bc Black 4 "" box ic Blue bc Black 5 "" box ic Blue bc Black *matrix 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 Density 0.7000 Degree Distribution(s) Mean degree 1.4000 Stddev 1.9105 Skewness 0.8547 Clustering coefficent(s) Global 0.8000 </code></pre> <p>Network B:</p> <pre><code>*vertices 5 1 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 2 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 3 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 4 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 5 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black *matrix 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 Density 0.5000 Degree Distribution(s) Mean degree 1.0000 Stddev 1.6583 Skewness 1.2718 Clustering coefficent(s) Global 0.3750 </code></pre> <p>Network X:</p> <pre><code>*vertices 10 5 1 "" box ic Blue bc Black 2 "" box ic Blue bc Black 3 "" box ic Blue bc Black 4 "" box ic Blue bc Black 5 "" box ic Blue bc Black 6 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 7 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 8 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 9 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 10 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black *edges 1 6 1 9 3 7 3 8 3 9 3 10 4 6 4 7 4 8 5 8 5 9 Density 0.4400 Degree Distribution(s) Mean degree A 2.2000 Stddev A 1.4832 Skewness A -0.2648 Mean degree B 2.2000 Stddev B 0.8367 Skewness B -0.2459 Clustering coefficent Global 0.2667 </code></pre> <p>Network M:</p> <pre><code>*vertices 10 1 "" box ic Blue bc Black 2 "" box ic Blue bc Black 3 "" box ic Blue bc Black 4 "" box ic Blue bc Black 5 "" box ic Blue bc Black 6 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 7 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 8 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 9 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 10 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black *edges 1 2 1 c Blue 1 3 1 c Blue 1 4 1 c Blue 1 5 1 c Blue 3 4 1 c Blue 3 5 1 c Blue 4 5 1 c Blue 6 8 1 c Red 7 8 1 c Red 7 10 1 c Red 8 9 1 c Red 8 10 1 c Red 1 6 1 c Black 1 9 1 c Black 3 7 1 c Black 3 8 1 c Black 3 9 1 c Black 3 10 1 c Black 4 6 1 c Black 4 7 1 c Black 4 8 1 c Black 5 8 1 c Black 5 9 1 c Black </code></pre> <p>*Also, if someone has enough reputation and feels the need to add the tags PNet and/or MPNet to this post so that it could be more specific, I would appreciate it.</p>
g74304
[ -0.023834122344851494, 0.050798941403627396, 0.0006932152318768203, -0.07097696512937546, -0.028531977906823158, -0.05722784996032715, -0.012568320147693157, 0.002441020915284753, 0.018421096727252007, -0.007406781427562237, 0.021062670275568962, 0.001327137346379459, 0.06704364717006683, -0.02119741216301918, -0.023634137585759163, 0.006189130712300539, 0.031446974724531174, -0.0031068550888448954, 0.02670690231025219, -0.004949066322296858, 0.0013067855034023523, 0.009072566404938698, -0.002699373522773385, 0.0011368918931111693, -0.07689814269542694, -0.01574191451072693, 0.014509118162095547, 0.0026066459249705076, -0.10435671359300613, 0.027382303029298782, -0.057878684252500534, -0.04047749936580658, -0.025740155950188637, -0.03818182274699211, -0.049103088676929474, 0.06362469494342804, -0.029780464246869087, -0.022095778957009315, 0.012427501380443573, 0.0052673970349133015, 0.001622866839170456, -0.030106743797659874, 0.03311017528176308, 0.021833475679159164, -0.005255558993667364, 0.004491616040468216, 0.006376121658831835, -0.034701891243457794, 0.007938179187476635, 0.011002627201378345, -0.007192056160420179, 0.010802267119288445, 0.04716622456908226, -0.0032863966189324856, 0.0330764465034008, 0.049886833876371384, -0.007869178429245949, -0.017124034464359283, 0.0605134516954422, 0.02904561348259449, 0.0215394776314497, 0.02059987187385559, -0.03239427134394646, -0.004170109052211046, 0.007289614528417587, 0.014010162092745304, -0.053557656705379486, 0.013383355922996998, 0.010998043231666088, 0.00939949695020914, -0.06215089559555054, 0.01620974764227867, 0.035956162959337234, 0.001318529131822288, -0.02212517149746418, -0.013496814295649529, -0.033319100737571716, -0.013584599830210209, 0.03551549091935158, 0.07389727979898453, 0.027009574696421623, 0.036157988011837006, -0.06262402981519699, -0.0008032041369006038, 0.004885908681899309, 0.00725980568677187, 0.004053674638271332, -0.03082888573408127, 0.002478324808180332, 0.014766237698495388, 0.06300473213195801, 0.02101442776620388, 0.016426052898168564, 0.028558971360325813, -0.049383364617824554, -0.02031955122947693, -0.08056987076997757, 0.09357821196317673, -0.05106130614876747, -0.024234941229224205, -0.00909251905977726, 0.026824522763490677, -0.011396779678761959, -0.03719407692551613, -0.023237496614456177, 0.015230986289680004, -0.0154033238068223, 0.05138959735631943, -0.018867233768105507, 0.06588436663150787, -0.04890228062868118, -0.08140115439891815, -0.05505944415926933, 0.05003578960895538, -0.09841576963663101, -0.03763257712125778, 0.061303555965423584, 0.041459821164608, -0.01997651532292366, 0.07462330907583237, 0.06451138854026794, -0.02872314304113388, 0.05052787810564041, -0.013043757528066635, 0.0009012218215502799, -0.0486626997590065, 0.01598232053220272, 0.04621163755655289, 0.016037195920944214, -0.05271775275468826, 0.00044491307926364243, -0.03987280651926994, 0.004766945261508226, 0.09947801381349564, -0.03718917816877365, -0.0014202669262886047, -0.06864408403635025, -0.025331469252705574, -0.040063634514808655, 0.025413597002625465, -0.04960378631949425, -0.02601093240082264, -0.05003685504198074, -0.022502852603793144, -0.039993464946746826, -0.014794892631471157, -0.005655108019709587, 0.0052374862134456635, 0.008078675717115402, 0.04637054353952408, 0.03912260755896568, 0.03638498857617378, -0.06943167746067047, -0.04258127138018608, -0.035453926771879196, -0.011143958196043968, 0.0002590941439848393, 0.0056359474547207355, 0.00027954502729699016, 0.054537586867809296, -0.023389019072055817, -0.005005628801882267, 0.0029186317697167397, -0.006638992577791214, -0.012320483103394508, -0.025278260931372643, 0.05622323602437973, -0.05534697324037552, -0.04326571524143219, -0.04835346341133118, -0.019648510962724686, -0.018471330404281616, 0.004366462584584951, 0.026185190305113792, -0.014789681881666183, -0.004678694531321526, 0.04842521622776985, 0.029773112386465073, 0.005962871480733156, -0.000490320089738816, -0.014435962773859501, 0.021511375904083252, 0.035630661994218826, -0.048840075731277466, 0.05071026086807251, -0.026252692565321922, -0.03909195587038994, 0.05243590101599693, 0.027528421953320503, -0.009318500757217407, -0.0026876681949943304, 0.04458186402916908, 0.01184858474880457, -0.025735242292284966, 0.055723000317811966, -0.06679629534482956, 0.017029989510774612, -0.055990755558013916, 0.008901557885110378, 0.009069530293345451, 0.011930054053664207, -0.017859503626823425, -0.006386426277458668, 0.0765170231461525, -0.03924398869276047, -0.026652943342924118, -0.0264198686927557, 0.004510413855314255, 0.0053445822559297085, -0.015518128871917725, -0.03030218556523323, -0.028442570939660072, -0.013630151748657227, 0.05280729755759239, -0.004468612838536501, 0.04878314211964607, -0.028647180646657944, -0.008152623660862446, 0.0031361712608486414, -0.041206635534763336, -0.0069349780678749084, -0.06157490238547325, 0.013894599862396717, -0.021605808287858963, -0.015085328370332718, -0.016204988583922386, 0.013902505859732628, 0.026155570521950722, 0.014256362803280354, 0.08985280990600586, 0.0023444597609341145, 0.048014651983976364, 0.00946756824851036, -0.03325169160962105, 0.010414160788059235, -0.03922714665532112, -0.042726073414087296, 0.04868447780609131, -0.04587872698903084, -0.015104170888662338, 0.02261698804795742, -0.08262956142425537, -0.033618658781051636, 0.043127261102199554, 0.05161185562610626, -0.027378087863326073, 0.07419382035732269, -0.012666699476540089, 0.010077182203531265, 0.03875268995761871, -0.0396881066262722, 0.004371306858956814, -0.022237420082092285, 0.0234872754663229, 0.011438651010394096, 0.026047252118587494, 0.007017944473773241, -0.007720645051449537, -0.0036125166807323694, 0.02492520585656166, 0.01940804161131382, -0.043048590421676636, -0.04085100069642067, 0.053616397082805634, 0.014138231053948402, -0.004497426096349955, 0.017127424478530884, -0.06758464872837067, -0.0028930273838341236, 0.020809423178434372, -0.04419568181037903, 0.013442165218293667, -0.013026769272983074, -0.016079243272542953, 0.04286418482661247, 0.0758645087480545, 0.04842938110232353, 0.03202604129910469, -0.013073747977614403, 0.024480648338794708, -0.05967319384217262, -0.015188496559858322, 0.0107582937926054, 0.0009711579186841846, 0.022104866802692413, -0.06696660816669464, 0.038266222923994064, 0.003918596543371677, 0.019400136545300484, 0.02716967649757862, 0.007168823387473822, 0.0038197438698261976, -0.026109669357538223, 0.012779075652360916, -0.01984843611717224, -0.06853553652763367, -0.0662865862250328, -0.024899354204535484, 0.06684810668230057, 0.03855740651488304, -0.023518046364188194, -0.00788075104355812, 0.05107376351952553, 0.06872349232435226, 0.049183085560798645, 0.008714635856449604, -0.06356298923492432, -0.012888330966234207, -0.010598418302834034, -0.03123358264565468, -0.011516731232404709, -0.017592301592230797, -0.06807755678892136, 0.004033238161355257, -0.016921954229474068, 0.05225400999188423, 0.029872244223952293, 0.028761066496372223, 0.005580549128353596, -0.035532396286726, 0.013423011638224125, 0.0014994305092841387, 0.04598836600780487, -0.009282342158257961, -0.01674877479672432, 0.057882022112607956, 0.034556593745946884, -0.018794361501932144, 0.024491388350725174, 0.007102990057319403, -0.006387455388903618, -0.026446959003806114, -0.010463923215866089, 0.03134145960211754, -0.02451672963798046, 0.004038527607917786, -0.01525289099663496, 0.01831030659377575, 0.06068722531199455, -0.023341232910752296, -0.008882722817361355, -0.0737529993057251, -0.050190918147563934, -0.038617029786109924, -0.009504740126430988, -0.06952258199453354, 0.02376854605972767, 0.006405567284673452, -0.04261070862412453, -0.07132620364427567, 0.0026297271251678467, 0.0656934529542923, 0.02994862012565136, -0.015248841606080532, 0.038584139198064804, 0.005531990434974432, 0.008938224986195564, -0.04799257218837738, -0.007477120961993933, 0.09765682369470596, -0.05417264625430107, -0.008637437596917152, -0.03046967089176178, -0.002105174120515585, -0.03376900777220726, 0.015671657398343086, 0.0035252084489911795, 0.059246551245450974, 0.08271390944719315, 0.006462539546191692, 0.05181167274713516, 0.05427953228354454, 0.013180754147469997, 0.00023947213776409626, -0.003399620996788144, -0.04532467573881149, -0.024042461067438126, 0.01101405918598175, -0.01205530110746622, 0.07544311136007309, -0.009768381714820862, 0.023102490231394768, 0.016028746962547302, 0.03600388020277023, -0.007019763346761465, -0.022169115021824837, -0.0046758088283240795, 0.04532625153660774, 0.0380963534116745, 0.04176143556833267, 0.00792661402374506, -0.056190285831689835, -0.05277722701430321, -0.006276315078139305, 0.02209516242146492, -0.013532713055610657, 0.05168837308883667, -0.01606745272874832, 0.01393977738916874, 0.03870810940861702, -0.06631570309400558, -0.015600231476128101, 0.016016928479075432, 0.00885106436908245, -0.025311926379799843, -0.0574757345020771, -0.07960595935583115, -0.003625917946919799, 0.038692448288202286, -0.027423154562711716, -0.013048877008259296, -0.027874106541275978, 0.06424834579229355, -0.01727513037621975, 0.019357668235898018, 0.016138041391968727, 0.012246069498360157, 0.023242302238941193, -0.029643066227436066, 0.05539258196949959, -0.0017352583818137646, 0.050279755145311356, -0.01765739545226097, -0.041453391313552856, 0.05790430307388306, -0.006497022230178118, 0.03325272724032402, -0.014635687693953514, -0.01859961822628975, 0.027934230864048004, -0.010424114763736725, 0.033855732530355453, -0.01081313006579876, -0.02087068185210228, -0.027694838121533394, 0.019727077335119247, 0.024838900193572044, 0.008049133233726025, 0.0491950660943985, -0.03194202855229378, -0.03211069107055664, 0.00928910169750452, 0.055920153856277466, -0.06873635202646255, -0.04311805218458176, 0.012288404628634453, -0.06041882559657097, 0.018349159508943558, -0.061054885387420654, 0.012208121828734875, 0.0037524958606809378, -0.08010775595903397, 0.0018334389897063375, 0.03295792639255524, 0.0015345335705205798, 0.05125580355525017, 0.008761357516050339, -0.015745054930448532, 0.02522704191505909, 0.021626347675919533, -0.0063493684865534306, 0.034327585250139236, -0.043170224875211716, -0.019824421033263206, -0.024180611595511436, -0.006828551180660725, -0.0585516095161438, 0.028469683602452278, 0.05768084526062012, -0.008553908206522465, 0.004202245734632015, -0.008007313124835491, 0.047851771116256714, 0.013600636273622513, 0.027836456894874573, -0.003153757657855749, -0.006947167683392763, 0.014568816870450974, 0.016144488006830215, -0.0024383477866649628, -0.029827727004885674, -0.005734900012612343, -0.01360789593309164, -0.005070650950074196, 0.04819685220718384, -0.015814704820513725, 0.008564208634197712, -0.007907659746706486, 0.0141457449644804, 0.009786279872059822, 0.0022722086869180202, 0.003660098183900118, 0.021807996556162834, 0.03799930587410927, -0.012322145514190197, -0.07874196022748947, 0.0012337552616372705, -0.00939697865396738, 0.05512821674346924, -0.0709797665476799, 0.013918454758822918, 0.03653520345687866, -0.013198447413742542, -0.06390487402677536, 0.010783455334603786, -0.01667085289955139, 0.029927361756563187, -0.03520210459828377, 0.01183141116052866, 0.0596761591732502, 0.027364807203412056, 0.000011047189218515996, 0.02157830074429512, -0.05631576478481293, -0.026473117992281914, -0.06515638530254364, 0.030447905883193016, 0.021930638700723648, 0.01694505289196968, -0.04850441589951515, 0.05271802842617035, -0.0017652047099545598, -0.024578100070357323, 0.0005618685390800238, 0.033929552882909775, 0.0048548378981649876, 0.019457224756479263, -0.0643530786037445, 0.06603315472602844, -0.01185614988207817, -0.01759246177971363, 0.027925364673137665, -0.0663844645023346, -0.003474449971690774, -0.04417545720934868, -0.03660726547241211, -0.0053297304548323154, -0.021961912512779236, 0.022945083677768707, -0.013552956283092499, -0.005285670515149832, -0.02348758839070797, 0.00571284769102931, 0.05348004773259163, -0.0369449146091938, -0.023292778059840202, 0.07050018757581711, 0.03816073015332222, 0.02611330710351467, -0.00963615532964468, 0.0035775129217654467, 0.01907625049352646, 0.010220815427601337, 0.03109731152653694, 0.002776029286906123, 0.04147706180810928, -0.027347365394234657, -0.04653128609061241, 0.044550057500600815, 0.010517116636037827, 0.003786697518080473, 0.033752188086509705, -0.02437819540500641, -0.007553255185484886, -0.029787931591272354, 0.0820344090461731, -0.05533484369516373, 0.053063590079545975, 0.028000028803944588, 0.005493747536092997, -0.012815643101930618, -0.0626121237874031, 0.0004247739852871746, 0.06522247195243835, 0.017823996022343636, 0.03395327553153038, 0.09479612857103348, -0.019758330658078194, 0.041948024183511734, -0.01697634346783161, -0.042222317308187485, 0.006051963195204735, 0.0032854252494871616, 0.03535940498113632, 0.015149793587625027, -0.0011228208895772696, -0.038377486169338226, 0.00565221905708313, -0.044237617403268814, -0.05479821562767029, -0.04876198619604111, 0.012477187439799309, -0.018450545147061348, -0.015020082704722881, 0.040394194424152374, -0.03000815398991108, -0.030519763007760048, 0.01606377400457859, -0.05411810055375099, 0.028944972902536392, -0.031650617718696594, 0.03434218093752861, 0.0487336665391922, -0.0528714694082737, -0.04966922849416733, 0.05005491524934769, -0.013566559180617332, -0.003159399377182126, -0.04833563417196274, -0.007260178215801716, -0.017008446156978607, 0.06455786526203156, 0.015332150273025036, 0.03804777190089226, 0.0660172775387764, -0.06069221720099449, -0.007680289447307587, -0.04566225782036781, -0.01720595359802246, -0.07398384064435959, -0.012107003480196, -0.038266122341156006, 0.05113880708813667, 0.0009647540864534676, 0.04164387285709381, 0.05098497122526169, 0.009598122909665108, -0.004042583983391523, 0.06088564172387123, -0.025715451687574387, -0.010496088303625584, 0.035105571150779724, 0.006946449168026447, 0.015507777221500874, -0.023424871265888214, 0.04274934530258179, 0.020673487335443497, 0.02333950065076351, 0.08261417597532272, 0.08592715859413147, -0.006222364492714405, 0.007104435469955206, -0.017697706818580627, 0.012254729866981506, 0.008559917099773884, -0.037302497774362564, 0.04292083904147148, 0.06836371123790741, -0.05713937431573868, 0.019509725272655487, 0.08597393333911896, 0.0018047678750008345, -0.03301701322197914, -0.002239607973024249, -0.04296865686774254, -0.005533013492822647, 0.028367534279823303, 0.03312982618808746, 0.020885925740003586, 0.002881892491132021, -0.09592147916555405, 0.020589683204889297, -0.03785329684615135, -0.047192033380270004, -0.02894592471420765, -0.014175621792674065, 0.023213235661387444, 0.016156934201717377, 0.01511439774185419, 0.009862694889307022, -0.021283069625496864, 0.04425092041492462, -0.06641847640275955, 0.07898091524839401, 0.029405320063233376, -0.0653354674577713, -0.020283102989196777, 0.022189103066921234, -0.05011637881398201, 0.0029625052120536566, -0.015451103448867798, 0.03110472671687603, 0.06005069240927696, 0.0013441706541925669, 0.03547443076968193, -0.01791059412062168, -0.04800410941243172, 0.026351002976298332, -0.014720620587468147, 0.04474477469921112, -0.03413074463605881, 0.011968816630542278, -0.026580030098557472, -0.011192744597792625, -0.012026830576360226, 0.04475517198443413, -0.0693398118019104, -0.0014940883265808225, 0.07166071236133575, 0.07584622502326965, -0.002270110184326768, 0.006655563600361347, -0.02570849098265171, -0.0161085557192564, 0.019230805337429047, 0.030976057052612305, -0.03203687444329262, 0.00787121057510376, 0.02799133211374283, -0.08905187994241714, -0.024580495432019234, 0.017019223421812057, 0.029653873294591904, 0.06510845571756363, -0.07206413894891739, -0.016840053722262383, -0.004951422568410635, -0.01065045315772295, -0.01378975436091423, 0.007567232009023428, -0.03888493403792381, -0.00912038329988718, -0.02481347881257534, 0.051275137811899185, 0.031394269317388535, -0.013393253087997437, 0.020039595663547516, 0.008245669305324554, -0.03533385321497917, 0.013583134859800339, 0.005191889125853777, -0.04007849469780922, -0.010491170920431614, -0.016887569800019264, -0.01711587980389595, -0.03774586692452431, 0.013132608495652676, -0.030834786593914032, 0.018928026780486107, -0.00422773277387023, 0.015922201797366142, -0.021682223305106163, -0.0038003791123628616, 0.010564528405666351, 0.02781243622303009, 0.032892946153879166, -0.061822280287742615, 0.0090302349999547, -0.0033392240293323994, -0.03632786497473717, -0.012112006545066833, 0.010906780138611794, 0.01848604716360569, -0.026152271777391434, -0.03238387405872345, -0.01745113544166088, 0.07264760136604309, 0.05742752552032471, 0.047148447483778, -0.02881702594459057, -0.052024226635694504, -0.03806264325976372, -0.030607404187321663, 0.004074865486472845, 0.0031303567811846733, -0.013769043609499931, 0.03283386304974556, -0.012074694968760014 ]
<p>I have a set of data that represents periodic readings. The data shows an upward trend but I need to test for a statistical difference from zero. I believe I should use the t test, two tailed but what should I use for the second set of data? Zeros, the starting value?</p> <pre><code>0.2245 0.243 0.2312 0.1795 0.1923 0.17 0.2025 0.2059 0.2394 0.205 0.2201 0.2261 0.1817 0.2143 0.2126 0.237 0.1984 0.228 0.2292 0.2236 0.2096 0.2258 0.2155 </code></pre>
g48875
[ 0.031369831413030624, -0.044937506318092346, 0.0045173331163823605, -0.07192900031805038, 0.013515038415789604, -0.00320347654633224, 0.04682989418506622, -0.002928352216258645, -0.04536048322916031, -0.04813101515173912, -0.005316493567079306, 0.08052963018417358, 0.03771127387881279, -0.00916783045977354, -0.008423803374171257, 0.008258838206529617, 0.04602348804473877, -0.0022790643852204084, 0.06777308136224747, 0.03494018316268921, -0.0012092262040823698, 0.03286176547408104, -0.009894411079585552, -0.04717027768492699, 0.06914879381656647, -0.058238349854946136, -0.051168397068977356, 0.08867625147104263, -0.07879019528627396, 0.01979091390967369, 0.02441302314400673, -0.005803723819553852, 0.05086365342140198, 0.01691584475338459, -0.0030014561489224434, -0.002100348938256502, 0.01759684458374977, 0.0822877511382103, -0.021891292184591293, -0.014811194501817226, -0.03475872054696083, 0.022201120853424072, 0.026989538222551346, -0.013235801830887794, 0.018837906420230865, -0.0361049547791481, -0.03719659522175789, 0.027933908626437187, -0.008174327202141285, 0.001993409125134349, 0.045248884707689285, -0.026969026774168015, 0.04254331439733505, 0.01561132725328207, -0.0341528095304966, 0.012118875980377197, -0.027523191645741463, -0.013601464219391346, 0.037306878715753555, 0.017854899168014526, 0.024750230833888054, 0.003361604642122984, -0.029730675742030144, -0.04091823846101761, 0.015213833190500736, 0.04090750589966774, 0.04917043447494507, -0.01768174022436142, 0.01570161245763302, -0.036417022347450256, -0.006712771486490965, 0.004611221142113209, -0.003850531065836549, 0.011814459227025509, -0.054970499128103256, -0.04041963070631027, -0.03632963448762894, -0.03270116448402405, 0.005856694187968969, -0.00165691995061934, -0.025650663301348686, -0.012135911732912064, 0.02520260214805603, 0.01992993988096714, 0.04959338903427124, 0.024362262338399887, 0.07389974594116211, 0.009727702476084232, 0.0013396546710282564, 0.003968382719904184, 0.021016674116253853, 0.028407800942659378, 0.0563589446246624, 0.008544319309294224, 0.011699224822223186, 0.01278373971581459, -0.02182447537779808, 0.03546476736664772, 0.014464864507317543, 0.018442554399371147, -0.009987561963498592, 0.022566990926861763, 0.027106592431664467, -0.03417114168405533, -0.0516350120306015, -0.041711702942848206, 0.015293783508241177, -0.05062180757522583, -0.021337563171982765, -0.006467685103416443, -0.041783563792705536, 0.031115293502807617, -0.062411241233348846, -0.027781641110777855, -0.0027499620337039232, 0.021287383511662483, 0.05131424963474274, -0.02436966449022293, -0.07460768520832062, -0.03295129910111427, 0.0338466614484787, -0.026920972391963005, 0.007270301692187786, 0.10950186103582382, -0.036693014204502106, -0.053610507398843765, -0.03115040250122547, 0.030927075073122978, 0.05093526095151901, 0.02836245857179165, -0.03411131724715233, -0.012801003642380238, -0.023321833461523056, 0.006479298230260611, -0.030493484809994698, 0.02576467953622341, 0.012415762059390545, -0.008073746226727962, 0.021415526047348976, 0.016483865678310394, -0.01882840134203434, -0.048157110810279846, -0.004332352429628372, -0.012211337685585022, 0.03396691381931305, -0.006382787134498358, -0.004397631157189608, -0.005124800838530064, 0.029306204989552498, 0.028901314362883568, 0.05044139549136162, 0.026973482221364975, 0.017239052802324295, 0.021123064681887627, -0.04777567833662033, -0.01725628413259983, 0.03150835260748863, -0.0015167234232649207, 0.014284648932516575, 0.005790606141090393, -0.0338498055934906, -0.05200696736574173, 0.0413333922624588, -0.040459003299474716, -0.01436560694128275, 0.00807375181466341, -0.006062869913876057, 0.009388573467731476, 0.015056269243359566, -0.009044765494763851, 0.014403235167264938, 0.000542282301466912, -0.000169860475580208, -0.0338645838201046, 0.017268313094973564, 0.03661161661148071, 0.04024164006114006, 0.011612368747591972, 0.056001558899879456, 0.02915867231786251, -0.0018062409944832325, 0.009196029044687748, 0.019828887656331062, 0.056240517646074295, -0.0025541717186570168, -0.02778618037700653, 0.005584262777119875, -0.004382316023111343, -0.06741518527269363, 0.009735319763422012, -0.011552752926945686, -0.09137547761201859, -0.022495610639452934, -0.02910788729786873, 0.0071261730045080185, -0.03738569840788841, -0.018069792538881302, 0.01218140497803688, -0.008980153128504753, -0.007359127048403025, 0.009946510195732117, 0.05283869802951813, -0.03891950473189354, -0.00616871053352952, -0.033951640129089355, -0.03813808783888817, 0.012037934735417366, -0.05057944729924202, -0.025921819731593132, 0.004426242783665657, -0.028948387131094933, 0.007980359718203545, -0.016434544697403908, 0.04560831934213638, 0.0075606671161949635, -0.010017008520662785, 0.0032601405400782824, 0.04071629047393799, 0.007925080135464668, 0.060465797781944275, -0.022698303684592247, -0.02805074118077755, 0.04081157222390175, -0.03166704997420311, 0.021298691630363464, 0.02051982656121254, 0.07972032576799393, -0.02709217183291912, -0.018665997311472893, -0.0018814199138432741, -0.03398767113685608, -0.03125733137130737, -0.018007617443799973, -0.04580369591712952, 0.022384503856301308, 0.008854429237544537, -0.007411749567836523, -0.020446930080652237, 0.021741295233368874, 0.040875814855098724, 0.0000529580756847281, 0.055754970759153366, -0.009312989190220833, -0.0074590942822396755, 0.05544814467430115, -0.025553328916430473, -0.025600789114832878, 0.03442581370472908, -0.02580251917243004, 0.030734296888113022, 0.00425424799323082, 0.04705016687512398, -0.037738412618637085, 0.0429406613111496, -0.000028267268135095946, -0.057932112365961075, 0.008292023092508316, 0.007637823466211557, -0.014186682179570198, -0.03574399650096893, -0.0005856385687366128, 0.008044645190238953, 0.02269883081316948, 0.01988561823964119, -0.0029539375100284815, -0.023033253848552704, -0.04974541440606117, -0.01456051878631115, -0.026136141270399094, -0.015492661856114864, 0.034829720854759216, -0.004888255149126053, 0.09835206717252731, 0.04731970280408859, -0.008365479297935963, 0.014054886065423489, 0.045303091406822205, -0.024162963032722473, 0.007815955206751823, 0.00424033310264349, 0.02919822931289673, -0.044378526508808136, 0.05686797574162483, 0.07996644824743271, 0.02153659611940384, -0.015149952843785286, 0.022421300411224365, -0.03178611397743225, -0.051681507378816605, 0.015287719666957855, -0.007513472344726324, 0.022093284875154495, 0.03936999663710594, -0.006863323971629143, 0.03587755560874939, 0.0006425863830372691, 0.03485526517033577, -0.03454093262553215, 0.0625227615237236, -0.013813710771501064, -0.04186312481760979, 0.003098872024565935, 0.011898706667125225, -0.026986632496118546, 0.03862650319933891, -0.01931164041161537, 0.029298311099410057, -0.010711961425840855, 0.06240057572722435, 0.00272396975196898, -0.025239577516913414, 0.03483603894710541, 0.002285880036652088, -0.025930892676115036, 0.014483926817774773, -0.0016385805793106556, 0.0034393996465951204, 0.02603985369205475, 0.022005634382367134, 0.0032735061831772327, 0.007460092660039663, -0.009618276730179787, 0.039353229105472565, -0.003126476425677538, -0.03320591524243355, 0.03622927889227867, 0.010636878199875355, 0.04256497323513031, -0.11741906404495239, 0.007905231788754463, 0.021450191736221313, 0.05664878338575363, -0.000025792798624024726, -0.017666244879364967, 0.05357282981276512, -0.009147276170551777, 0.01426002662628889, -0.02617476135492325, -0.036983516067266464, 0.07340258359909058, -0.04373196139931679, -0.016900738701224327, -0.014412607066333294, -0.01679743453860283, 0.00998455286026001, -0.019258135929703712, 0.07082048058509827, 0.03887280821800232, -0.05478706583380699, -0.06348473578691483, -0.02457662671804428, -0.00895528681576252, 0.007833308540284634, 0.04556116461753845, 0.03805641829967499, 0.024177370592951775, 0.01086372323334217, -0.026872944086790085, 0.04214112088084221, -0.010310531593859196, 0.04771644249558449, -0.004106120206415653, -0.0447922982275486, 0.06295176595449448, 0.046130187809467316, 0.04691962152719498, -0.017365839332342148, 0.056709352880716324, 0.045385971665382385, -0.012338588014245033, -0.025578578934073448, 0.03152874484658241, 0.04552541300654411, -0.05809149518609047, 0.024072788655757904, -0.007520534563809633, 0.007631534710526466, 0.004624722991138697, -0.017798295244574547, 0.1181175708770752, -0.003859798889607191, -0.04481971263885498, -0.012060263194143772, 0.01249352190643549, -0.004363511223345995, -0.058117687702178955, -0.01574966125190258, -0.01291017234325409, 0.018300458788871765, -0.040211088955402374, 0.02491864189505577, -0.0017303685890510678, -0.02221040055155754, -0.029524723067879677, -0.003428188618272543, -0.04277193173766136, 0.05485137179493904, 0.08537602424621582, -0.006846072617918253, 0.01949263922870159, -0.05565587058663368, -0.011529071256518364, 0.017854424193501472, -0.0073198904283344746, -0.04219890013337135, -0.024922681972384453, 0.024725526571273804, -0.007688168901950121, -0.0035996995866298676, 0.02394968457520008, -0.029842911288142204, -0.06094229966402054, 0.022632235661149025, -0.03742285817861557, 0.024544134736061096, 0.013717499561607838, 0.10122114419937134, -0.026418600231409073, 0.019252976402640343, 0.025923848152160645, -0.0111307417973876, 0.07346047461032867, -0.012037917040288448, -0.05528852716088295, -0.042553093284368515, -0.014157318510115147, -0.017306162044405937, 0.011300703510642052, -0.010995691642165184, 0.007006150670349598, -0.022778619080781937, 0.03249184042215347, -0.024972327053546906, 0.0720839872956276, -0.0269975196570158, 0.03931503742933273, 0.0025309135671705008, 0.020209044218063354, -0.04060240462422371, -0.033917494118213654, -0.013627245090901852, -0.025055691599845886, -0.061780985444784164, 0.019656317308545113, -0.01666168123483658, 0.1375272572040558, -0.027800163254141808, -0.03904302418231964, 0.010747394524514675, 0.026976250112056732, -0.035051602870225906, 0.03325352445244789, 0.0029655785765498877, 0.0068570212461054325, -0.0031310829799622297, -0.0278952457010746, 0.04627753049135208, -0.044423844665288925, -0.00003552488124114461, 0.01830807887017727, -0.018371939659118652, -0.03471880406141281, -0.015897979959845543, -0.06989336758852005, 0.0011096940143033862, -0.031994033604860306, -0.05365825444459915, -0.025588015094399452, 0.08156636357307434, -0.052079979330301285, -0.023087970912456512, -0.04864358901977539, 0.04648248106241226, 0.002932594856247306, -0.023541748523712158, 0.045750692486763, -0.00488181272521615, -0.05966303125023842, 0.01936827227473259, 0.01314921397715807, -0.0001524805265944451, -0.0011922790436074138, 0.0019604142289608717, -0.005935517139732838, 0.009668323211371899, -0.03648288920521736, 0.01047760434448719, -0.06694044172763824, 0.10865707695484161, -0.033624764531850815, 0.0015281449304893613, 1.3753340688538174e-8, 0.09392416477203369, 0.011068247258663177, 0.012133774347603321, -0.05063512176275253, 0.03968391939997673, -0.03327687084674835, -0.03657473996281624, -0.08211877942085266, -0.05297919362783432, 0.0893096774816513, -0.04524661973118782, 0.03134436532855034, 0.031504303216934204, -0.02486715279519558, 0.05085424706339836, -0.03415771946310997, -0.0018742707325145602, 0.019674545153975487, -0.06890156120061874, -0.04555128887295723, 0.09058912843465805, 0.03278253227472305, -0.00041366362711414695, 0.028493622317910194, 0.056131135672330856, 0.014665473252534866, -0.0598670169711113, -0.06182252615690231, 0.017426982522010803, -0.03012956865131855, 0.05758613720536232, -0.03945154696702957, 0.021165775135159492, -0.005137082189321518, -0.031764622777700424, -0.023732390254735947, 0.011519558727741241, -0.08147852122783661, 0.05729319155216217, 0.017312778159976006, -0.0007988947909325361, -0.04346310347318649, 0.00896397139877081, -0.0055510737001895905, -0.030497612431645393, 0.027204109355807304, -0.03498077020049095, -0.0277269184589386, -0.07655344158411026, 0.0188499316573143, 0.040103379637002945, -0.04557042941451073, -0.05245598033070564, -0.08010926842689514, -0.030355097725987434, -0.017546309158205986, 0.004896511323750019, -0.008148816414177418, -0.029310712590813637, 0.06359830498695374, -0.025896379724144936, -0.011816807091236115, -0.04059446603059769, 0.045995455235242844, 0.037742841988801956, 0.03459640592336655, -0.008512835018336773, -0.03126408904790878, 0.004735665861517191, -0.028988061472773552, 0.016235226765275, 0.04939771816134453, 0.03283092752099037, -0.0339810848236084, -0.06103513389825821, 0.025238152593374252, 0.04174799472093582, -0.06097523495554924, 0.021261066198349, 0.008719131350517273, 0.014947411604225636, 0.03993673995137215, -0.0017112626228481531, 0.018667005002498627, -0.050466179847717285, 0.0408579558134079, 0.04180608317255974, -0.0064269439317286015, -0.0410517156124115, 0.011248759925365448, -0.032562389969825745, -0.01593274623155594, -0.005750821903347969, 0.030491987243294716, -0.012508407235145569, -0.0028976488392800093, 0.0023878957144916058, 0.008381303399801254, -0.0319499745965004, 0.013832874596118927, 0.022465424612164497, -0.03713836520910263, 0.046303294599056244, -0.007614341098815203, -0.05764435604214668, 0.0291912779211998, -0.012938079424202442, 0.02456841804087162, -0.02523908205330372, -0.03614415228366852, 0.041768692433834076, -0.0037234013434499502, 0.013717174530029297, -0.018435880541801453, 0.044279757887125015, 0.01819128915667534, 0.012028089724481106, -0.02381369099020958, 0.024581216275691986, 0.0005231746472418308, -0.011747626587748528, 0.006123732775449753, -0.018930720165371895, -0.02153845503926277, 0.03161247819662094, 0.03544354811310768, 0.014402510598301888, 0.051455024629831314, 0.08080115169286728, -0.013231662102043629, -0.013774167746305466, -0.05327465012669563, 0.08291206508874893, 0.017545290291309357, 0.0009825103916227818, -0.014665752649307251, 0.038695644587278366, -0.018408918753266335, -0.045080579817295074, 0.026799770072102547, -0.0440257228910923, -0.0013473237631842494, -0.08990103751420975, -0.031123651191592216, -0.02257736399769783, 0.07084685564041138, 0.032933350652456284, 0.04866301268339157, 0.02540106326341629, 0.07088195532560349, -0.02603023499250412, -0.03753379359841347, -0.008296584710478783, 0.03146032616496086, 0.02029387652873993, 0.03338789939880371, -0.018723810091614723, 0.011530838906764984, 0.030498644337058067, 0.002995444927364588, 0.0014999142149463296, 0.0016831452958285809, 0.0470455177128315, 0.024201735854148865, 0.018489249050617218, 0.014025496318936348, 0.034836411476135254, 0.009352508932352066, 0.01903454400599003, -0.08080709725618362, -0.040306609123945236, -0.0063015166670084, 0.011240058578550816, 0.05568859353661537, -0.025502782315015793, -0.008605136536061764, -0.006811041850596666, -0.04642106592655182, -0.04114839807152748, -0.01328384131193161, -0.05878014862537384, -0.014631783589720726, 0.05936074256896973, 0.020593732595443726, -0.03742498531937599, 0.02229195460677147, -0.06029319390654564, -0.005646681413054466, -0.017305990681052208, -0.06822916120290756, 0.025471096858382225, -0.09841488301753998, 0.0032003335654735565, 0.080820731818676, -0.04757975414395332, -0.006460829172283411, 0.05618377402424812, -0.031041380017995834, -0.008110015653073788, 0.004165532533079386, -0.03446214273571968, -0.017164532095193863, -0.03175174444913864, 0.002273642225190997, -0.07924558967351913, -0.0074639529921114445, -0.03205481916666031, 0.018935905769467354, 0.027506688609719276, 0.025024008005857468, -0.022533906623721123, 0.03440163657069206, -0.005299287848174572, 0.00043803476728498936, 0.011511423625051975, -0.02912784367799759, -0.02609441988170147, -0.047029465436935425, -0.02879507467150688, 0.05499103292822838, 0.06340394914150238, 0.028185419738292694, 0.011616336181759834, 0.004333031363785267, 0.014719869010150433, -0.02889903634786606, -0.002095324918627739, -0.015918554738163948, -0.03846161067485809, -0.021295398473739624, 0.016218479722738266, -0.022091826424002647, -0.04053497314453125, -0.07590869814157486, -0.04760855436325073, 0.052880849689245224, 0.03141723945736885, -0.03389072045683861, -0.025707654654979706, -0.011073472909629345, -0.03770991042256355, 0.018786247819662094, -0.04728085547685623, 0.03031724877655506, 0.02512480691075325, 0.04386121407151222, -0.009790685027837753, 0.014870744198560715, -0.024049142375588417, 0.01700720191001892, 0.035601843148469925, -0.0447947233915329, -0.038398586213588715, -0.0004709649656433612, 0.004759466275572777, 0.06178445741534233, 0.004973899573087692, -0.09427986294031143, -0.05484941601753235, -0.009660015814006329, -0.04795382171869278, 0.08815792202949524, -0.0449448861181736, 0.01341275405138731, -0.0014160084538161755, -0.0301157645881176, 0.019226139411330223, -0.02747378684580326, -0.014638707041740417, -0.0030798057559877634, -0.03413877636194229, 0.02148735150694847, -0.021663401275873184, -0.04483628273010254, -0.014738965779542923, 0.034680530428886414 ]
<p>is it possible for an algorithm A to have a better precision but worse recall (or better recall but worse precision) than another algorithm B?</p> <p>Although I know that precision and recall are different things, it seems to me that if algorithm A has a better precision (or recall) than algorithm B then algorithm A will also have a better recall (or precision) than B.</p> <p>Thanks Ahmet</p>
g46203
[ 0.05025202035903931, -0.033033158630132675, -0.002705696504563093, 0.002191731706261635, 0.04683446139097214, -0.009357541799545288, -0.015330785885453224, 0.0008558743866160512, -0.032759103924036026, 0.04148120433092117, 0.00323671568185091, 0.02258508838713169, 0.07361853122711182, -0.0018765912391245365, -0.05273854732513428, -0.0002345727989450097, 0.04194401204586029, 0.021856898441910744, -0.008315675891935825, 0.012013216502964497, 0.03509649261832237, 0.08493287861347198, -0.059268489480018616, 0.025195199996232986, -0.03476150333881378, -0.00465705431997776, -0.04507511109113693, -0.04820038378238678, -0.07665146142244339, -0.008373833261430264, -0.022368809208273888, -0.03411683067679405, 0.023066403344273567, -0.011491240933537483, -0.03259991854429245, -0.01260290015488863, 0.04606732353568077, -0.01579214259982109, 0.01886606216430664, -0.04153996706008911, 0.02984105609357357, 0.033702246844768524, 0.004990120884031057, 0.017440808936953545, 0.0077243768610060215, -0.007209758274257183, -0.004364756401628256, 0.030266322195529938, 0.03646431863307953, -0.04908856377005577, -0.018548140302300453, 0.007196065038442612, -0.023234978318214417, -0.0428905189037323, 0.024932069703936577, 0.03029819205403328, 0.035877030342817307, 0.030879298225045204, -0.01488620974123478, 0.010527355596423149, 0.010843872092664242, 0.04114648327231407, -0.013259923085570335, 0.06435634940862656, -0.006932185497134924, -0.008813859894871712, 0.00501261604949832, 0.003538439515978098, -0.005942877382040024, 0.03772140294313431, 0.0025011191610246897, 0.022533699870109558, -0.030279261991381645, 0.0016531788278371096, -0.023749379441142082, 0.028183162212371826, 0.006247899495065212, -0.09232642501592636, 0.005359739065170288, 0.10367340594530106, -0.034335166215896606, -0.021825367584824562, -0.005107592791318893, 0.06063506007194519, -0.006908649578690529, 0.007821555249392986, -0.022325042635202408, 0.03442903608083725, 0.02440270036458969, 0.013632796704769135, -0.01140549499541521, -0.0068973940797150135, 0.030924493446946144, 0.06983916461467743, -0.032604917883872986, 0.05326845869421959, -0.0061959754675626755, 0.007434764876961708, -0.01987891085445881, 0.057995595037937164, 0.0235640536993742, 0.012485985644161701, 0.0450533851981163, -0.01186608336865902, 0.022110924124717712, -0.059239357709884644, -0.0020635430701076984, -0.05526169762015343, -0.049130603671073914, 0.00936394277960062, 0.03347073495388031, -0.02354763261973858, -0.04755496233701706, -0.032131489366292953, -0.05091462284326553, 0.07273050397634506, -0.0014182351296767592, -0.020730750635266304, -0.011030688881874084, -0.016868380829691887, 0.03531994670629501, -0.03288647159934044, 0.021317701786756516, -0.010024779476225376, 0.02391161397099495, 0.03770693019032478, -0.01926518604159355, 0.03597026318311691, 0.02456846833229065, 0.026200734078884125, -0.009026827290654182, -0.029490716755390167, 0.0010377248981967568, -0.018359171226620674, -0.01976384036242962, -0.017346732318401337, 0.03146619349718094, 0.053478606045246124, 0.03227471932768822, -0.037882886826992035, -0.03777354210615158, 0.01829095557332039, 0.06949083507061005, -0.03280043974518776, -0.03387744352221489, 0.03411685675382614, 0.0011998419649899006, 0.013789949007332325, -0.07091550529003143, -0.02257421240210533, 0.035692643374204636, 0.02292868122458458, 0.0013829396339133382, 0.003470291616395116, -0.010599425993859768, -0.008521193638443947, -0.005863374099135399, 0.04701649397611618, -0.020813945680856705, -0.023069845512509346, 0.03280982747673988, 0.023615581914782524, 0.04721430316567421, 0.03555857762694359, -0.08124978095293045, -0.023193687200546265, 0.02166668511927128, -0.08521169424057007, -0.030601894482970238, -0.037382546812295914, 0.013055972754955292, 0.0023193107917904854, 0.031960032880306244, 0.05529263988137245, 0.014945815317332745, 0.019298192113637924, 0.006089882459491491, 0.0001310997031396255, 0.05300651118159294, -0.0605647936463356, 0.003174286801367998, 0.05144740641117096, -0.044616635888814926, -0.04161738604307175, -0.006811808329075575, 0.008710498921573162, 0.049335725605487823, 0.027260689064860344, -0.0874476209282875, -0.012173735536634922, -0.019067758694291115, 0.06645692139863968, 0.014444595202803612, 0.01818258874118328, -0.05729801207780838, 0.0019141924567520618, -0.03299681469798088, 0.002787050325423479, -0.023875921964645386, 0.06834577769041061, 0.011877222917973995, 0.011699963361024857, -0.019943343475461006, 0.027960391715168953, -0.015240611508488655, 0.047382041811943054, -0.057207196950912476, -0.025750543922185898, -0.0038698376156389713, -0.03762229532003403, -0.00794478040188551, 0.07480272650718689, 0.006225735414773226, 0.04277865216135979, 0.057319387793540955, 0.009504239074885845, 0.03308765962719917, 0.008158426731824875, 0.004194186069071293, -0.026705550029873848, -0.014012417756021023, -0.05921732634305954, 0.037755243480205536, 0.0009545327047817409, -0.03067614510655403, 0.028703929856419563, 0.03542763739824295, 0.05502862110733986, -0.09872276335954666, 0.03284691646695137, -0.018013063818216324, -0.026819560676813126, 0.04219401627779007, -0.024998148903250694, 0.010622270405292511, 0.011035759933292866, 0.08475548774003983, 0.0026841824874281883, -0.006254940759390593, 0.03311607986688614, -0.01854853890836239, 0.008177232928574085, -0.02197275497019291, 0.015361486934125423, 0.004310390911996365, -0.046386461704969406, 0.05089982599020004, -0.01981593482196331, 0.059021320194005966, 0.03613908961415291, -0.02352277562022209, 0.08438999205827713, -0.0036743036471307278, -0.057756226509809494, 0.00004418046955834143, 0.018290460109710693, 0.02740064635872841, 0.0060782963410019875, 0.008314108476042747, 0.0649610236287117, -0.014922171831130981, 0.008374232798814774, -0.02088722586631775, 0.015967553481459618, 0.05342880263924599, 0.0335489921271801, -0.03928552567958832, -0.005331055726855993, -0.007520408369600773, 0.01983415149152279, -0.021681364625692368, -0.00725623220205307, -0.04387093335390091, -0.04118214175105095, -0.005835789255797863, 0.021386643871665, 0.02736452966928482, -0.03023804910480976, 0.02878238819539547, -0.025468412786722183, -0.020795699208974838, -0.019154556095600128, -0.07292026281356812, -0.018490860238671303, 0.04715249687433243, 0.04294223710894585, -0.02397371456027031, 0.03362632170319557, 0.0011568058980628848, 0.07979049533605576, -0.04326169192790985, 0.007655980996787548, 0.03769285976886749, -0.01182006485760212, 0.03307119384407997, 0.029082344844937325, -0.021334253251552582, -0.05050841346383095, -0.024026133120059967, -0.026173079386353493, -0.010992642492055893, 0.029354315251111984, -0.027151191607117653, -0.017956165596842766, 0.09164619445800781, 0.01364039909094572, -0.03864460438489914, -0.01586923934519291, -0.014198034070432186, -0.03634602949023247, -0.030140964314341545, 0.002074967138469219, -0.028225883841514587, -0.012657382525503635, 0.047079797834157944, 0.03574472293257713, -0.004902330692857504, 0.022069431841373444, -0.05763445794582367, 0.04597079008817673, 0.06389844417572021, 0.006540494505316019, -0.0338982529938221, -0.01831504888832569, -0.0017423027893528342, 0.008008873090147972, -0.03278566524386406, 0.04356090724468231, -0.029818769544363022, -0.02120693400502205, -0.007571556139737368, 0.0181330107152462, -0.06046685203909874, -0.0037517754826694727, -0.010480879805982113, 0.017592795193195343, -0.00028218096122145653, -0.0025363522581756115, -0.040893640369176865, 0.005922561977058649, -0.013120446354150772, 0.0362665057182312, 0.0250881165266037, -0.05944628268480301, -0.02211504615843296, 0.06743501871824265, 0.06650783121585846, -0.030565496534109116, -0.027590859681367874, 0.02563914842903614, 0.0758577287197113, -0.008468047715723515, -0.0055425879545509815, -0.00712945032864809, 0.006792190484702587, 0.0626651868224144, 0.011448439210653305, 0.048351600766181946, -0.005967425648123026, 0.011518475599586964, -0.012390891090035439, 0.01850016415119171, -0.02023725025355816, -0.04831283167004585, -0.03502124920487404, -0.009899319149553776, 0.015253867022693157, 0.07541541755199432, -0.05819445848464966, -0.015504952520132065, -0.005199775565415621, -0.019321318715810776, 0.01034736167639494, -0.015233437530696392, -0.01946738176047802, 0.008457450196146965, 0.006702464073896408, 0.0333252027630806, 0.026975806802511215, -0.012058519758284092, 0.0005703439237549901, -0.0010541670490056276, -0.05150424689054489, 0.002148502506315708, 0.02622300386428833, -0.04397907108068466, 0.03394411504268646, -0.026011168956756592, -0.025163261219859123, 0.005411119200289249, 0.020218290388584137, -0.040942784398794174, -0.0234158206731081, 0.05560269206762314, 0.04453668370842934, -0.038032062351703644, -0.03980595991015434, 0.01769542694091797, 0.013792247511446476, 0.06715986132621765, -0.006303190253674984, 0.009158619679510593, 0.007756785023957491, 0.016793007031083107, -0.08986489474773407, -0.00866809394210577, -0.03637326881289482, -0.008107154630124569, -0.04183315858244896, 0.049918707460165024, -0.030532628297805786, -0.03770232945680618, -0.028800850734114647, -0.014410072937607765, 0.010306158103048801, 0.029004326090216637, 0.022106923162937164, 0.05579019710421562, 0.026900894939899445, 0.02735651656985283, 0.02256171964108944, 0.030770814046263695, -0.004485554061830044, 0.011467975564301014, 0.03910331800580025, 0.003089322941377759, -0.012398302555084229, -0.017729323357343674, 0.04726871848106384, -0.035867366939783096, 0.05340981483459473, 0.011154962703585625, 0.007448303047567606, 0.08115094155073166, -0.01066808681935072, 0.02821151353418827, -0.02011837810277939, 0.010426076129078865, 0.07671836018562317, 0.03487392142415047, -0.014553086832165718, 0.017758505418896675, -0.054292697459459305, 0.023853201419115067, 0.05016498640179634, 0.04791143536567688, -0.0009391913190484047, -0.0014810824068263173, 0.003569585271179676, 0.014673858880996704, -0.01682322658598423, 0.008900273591279984, 0.04318415746092796, -0.06972191482782364, -0.013450066559016705, -0.02513536810874939, 0.0059655592776834965, 0.04901936650276184, 0.008165429346263409, -0.0008877460495568812, 0.012126044370234013, 0.052102454006671906, -0.027329381555318832, 0.049454715102910995, 0.055343229323625565, -0.010580218397080898, -0.03814934194087982, -0.06899087876081467, -0.09893173724412918, 0.04055082052946091, 0.006963775958865881, -0.03893067315220833, 0.011190692894160748, 0.0751008614897728, 0.05161357298493385, -0.05246170982718468, -0.024742882698774338, -0.06595876812934875, -0.001557899871841073, 0.020258082076907158, -0.07773559540510178, -0.026976149529218674, 0.006140831857919693, 0.024908266961574554, -0.04749293625354767, 0.01668880693614483, 0.012118997052311897, -0.024459149688482285, 0.015579869039356709, -0.04917297512292862, 0.03378432244062424, 0.046158697456121445, 0.01611936278641224, -0.0007227030000649393, -0.001370857236906886, -0.007491594180464745, 0.011388042010366917, 0.04342805966734886, -0.0013539480278268456, -0.008093236945569515, 0.0004947531851939857, 0.014288509264588356, -0.007043835707008839, -0.08540104329586029, 0.026268422603607178, 0.0009287570137530565, 0.045062094926834106, -0.028189992532134056, 0.011880617588758469, -0.010837772861123085, -0.03319348022341728, 0.0209470484405756, -0.038596540689468384, -0.013967927545309067, 0.011667904444038868, 0.009959757328033447, 0.05528486892580986, -0.028139181435108185, -0.029657334089279175, -0.027566920965909958, 0.012469399720430374, 0.046083349734544754, -0.024148650467395782, 0.018080413341522217, -0.04137256741523743, -0.0354679711163044, -0.02155407890677452, 0.006199806462973356, -0.0018355849897488952, -0.021265480667352676, 0.08973897993564606, 0.04127000644803047, 0.013480075635015965, 0.007543948013335466, 0.02543685771524906, 0.002638960722833872, -0.006441168487071991, -0.038467586040496826, -0.0003285572456661612, 0.024806736037135124, -0.004372629802674055, -0.0072103929705917835, 0.012476002797484398, 0.11049455404281616, 0.018199443817138672, -0.06836385279893875, -0.02182871103286743, -0.037658583372831345, 0.035320743918418884, -0.04744424298405647, -0.04429740086197853, 0.032239459455013275, -0.0431770421564579, -0.034797005355358124, -0.02062712050974369, 0.1053195670247078, -0.04680600389838219, 0.008993993513286114, 0.018002120777964592, 0.03232595697045326, 0.011847086250782013, -0.039509374648332596, 0.014838231727480888, -0.0015800498658791184, -0.025075137615203857, -0.029086176306009293, -0.04324468970298767, -0.021817132830619812, 0.05561387166380882, 0.029471680521965027, 0.0035965286660939455, -0.02529134973883629, -0.02875116467475891, 0.005373659543693066, 0.013003005646169186, 0.010785478167235851, -0.01596946269273758, -0.01707598939538002, 0.004316408187150955, -0.07952471077442169, -0.008146348409354687, 0.004042408894747496, -0.016367198899388313, 0.009772520512342453, -0.00003792748611886054, 0.02002408169209957, -0.06438923627138138, 0.0983237698674202, 0.010559989139437675, -0.0008536505629308522, 0.02065224200487137, 0.018076054751873016, 0.03885318338871002, -0.0315275602042675, -0.053910188376903534, 0.01766783557832241, -0.06570599228143692, 0.008944069966673851, -0.09007186442613602, 0.014956214465200901, 0.06370818614959717, 0.012486532330513, 0.05259808152914047, 0.010966412723064423, -0.08463001996278763, 0.07587210834026337, -0.04377424716949463, 0.07852163165807724, 0.032059185206890106, 0.006786004174500704, -0.07504887878894806, 0.03899513930082321, 0.053667500615119934, 0.04264193773269653, -0.005082958843559027, -0.08691644668579102, -0.015411089174449444, -0.04316228628158569, -0.031906791031360626, 0.027357205748558044, 0.021442795172333717, -0.026543112471699715, -0.02051936462521553, -0.03632872924208641, -0.04787740483880043, 0.0071309953927993774, 0.025651412084698677, 0.05914715677499771, -0.006511862855404615, -0.012262231670320034, -0.0426376536488533, -0.049131933599710464, -0.024065768346190453, 0.0030175866559147835, 0.02242543362081051, 0.0077502368949353695, -0.10736869275569916, -0.010552842170000076, -0.0868922546505928, 0.004831000231206417, -0.009883691556751728, 0.033865299075841904, 0.00501608569175005, -0.00016575092740822583, 0.005307330284267664, -0.018451275303959846, 0.03862623870372772, 0.012105346657335758, -0.030711494386196136, -0.0058088041841983795, 0.02113303728401661, 0.032441820949316025, -0.08029382675886154, -0.02196679636836052, -0.028013182803988457, 0.02821800857782364, -0.034715745598077774, 0.019211454316973686, 0.03891947865486145, -0.01367201842367649, -0.01948906108736992, -0.017943857237696648, -0.02669270522892475, 0.01759563386440277, 0.007306796498596668, -0.030024942010641098, -0.014450914226472378, 0.001587288803420961, -0.02841663919389248, -0.0005646689096465707, 0.06684999912977219, -0.03309326246380806, -0.026316434144973755, 0.010392225347459316, 0.016414055600762367, 0.035690635442733765, -0.02410479448735714, -0.008613727055490017, -0.02879869006574154, -0.029024122282862663, 0.025284161791205406, -0.043353915214538574, 0.0327032133936882, -0.03952978178858757, -0.05355948582291603, 0.048338115215301514, 0.023537201806902885, 0.03297719359397888, 0.02432910166680813, -0.10561028122901917, -0.017165742814540863, -0.0589333139359951, 0.012206969782710075, -0.022942323237657547, -0.07324061542749405, 0.003783934051170945, 0.014570414088666439, 0.05236439034342766, -0.005639483220875263, 0.022034626454114914, -0.003955301828682423, 0.027944643050432205, 0.017234250903129578, -0.018852511420845985, 0.0059594945050776005, 0.026518674567341805, 0.005084460135549307, 0.047723591327667236, 0.011282556690275669, -0.04528990387916565, -0.02191169001162052, 0.002012573415413499, -0.030102917924523354, 0.021213384345173836, -0.04049607738852501, -0.061016056686639786, -0.028743930160999298, -0.09447988867759705, -0.07985781878232956, 0.019035272300243378, -0.03857475891709328, -0.013979895040392876, 0.0009585443767718971, -0.04375571012496948, 0.0033607177902013063, 0.005269794259220362, 0.01815301552414894, 0.016874918714165688, -0.031588129699230194, 0.020463254302740097, -0.0014305532677099109, -0.0025333717931061983, -0.08015953004360199, -0.013710171915590763, 0.0668068528175354, 0.005316769238561392, -0.0184898991137743, 0.061827369034290314, -0.034283313900232315, -0.03037036582827568, -0.016268450766801834, 0.054671045392751694, -0.01869775913655758, -0.06200402230024338, 0.02029246650636196, -0.06801782548427582, 0.0013361909659579396, 0.0020282051991671324, 0.01538078859448433, -0.05797969177365303, -0.014625558629631996, -0.0006577541353181005, -0.016734527423977852, 0.047166939824819565, 0.003916878253221512, 0.0982295349240303, 0.0017436601920053363, 0.028567520901560783, 0.037723563611507416, -0.019486211240291595, -0.01740083657205105, 0.0038771978579461575, -0.0043975431472063065, -0.009869604371488094, -0.04952434077858925, 0.04020592197775841, -0.025892702862620354, -0.003657333552837372 ]
<p>Suppose I have some kind of distribution which gives the probability of observing a given value (assume that this distribution is <strong>not</strong> normal).</p> <p>Now, I have a certain observation and I want to calculate how likely it is to observe a value that is equally or more extreme under this distribution. So, I am thinking of doing this empirically by turning my observation into a quantile and calculating the probability empirically under the distribution of: quantile_distribution &lt; quantile_observation and quantile_distribution > abs(1 - quantile_observation)</p> <p>I'm not sure whether that is a valid way to do it, but for the second part I'm going to assume it is.</p> <p>Now, here's where it gets a bit more complicated:</p> <p>My observation has some sort of measurement error associated with it. I can model this error with a probability distribution (this time it is roughly normal). Given this spread, how would I calculate a p-value as above (or would it be a distribution of p-values, which I have never seen)?</p> <p>I've been hacking something together where I take the p-value of observing the mean and the 95% CI values under the first distribution and then just take the maximum and report that, but obviously there has to be a better way to do it</p>
g37136
[ -0.012602563016116619, 0.006557985674589872, -0.01588224060833454, -0.011620597913861275, 0.01891958899796009, -0.011055488139390945, 0.0016362846363335848, 0.007708135060966015, -0.015686696395277977, -0.026252975687384605, 0.031394343823194504, 0.012216854840517044, 0.060567665845155716, 0.02500334568321705, 0.000430272746598348, 0.01368694007396698, 0.009059186093509197, -0.05210151895880699, 0.037070468068122864, -0.002203315496444702, -0.013605239801108837, -0.05542304366827011, 0.02707265503704548, -0.0379059799015522, -0.03507114201784134, -0.0724603682756424, -0.047857239842414856, 0.04432491213083267, -0.0752168670296669, 0.04093247652053833, -0.05451948195695877, -0.014819285832345486, 0.06129688397049904, 0.016786325722932816, -0.03572111949324608, 0.004594323690980673, 0.03016553819179535, 0.06870618462562561, -0.011002693325281143, -0.02470695599913597, -0.010733436793088913, 0.008544178679585457, 0.03580128774046898, -0.013185124844312668, 0.003477077931165695, -0.027499249204993248, 0.011153429746627808, 0.01780768856406212, 0.03263406828045845, 0.016025027260184288, -0.001873378292657435, 0.04746052622795105, 0.08970370143651962, 0.04324518144130707, 0.02442999556660652, 0.05085982754826546, -0.005196389742195606, -0.05111980065703392, 0.02365254797041416, -0.012560025788843632, 0.00047288445057347417, -0.045960452407598495, 0.014529919251799583, -0.0041389260441064835, 0.02326596900820732, 0.06555910408496857, -0.04956730827689171, 0.009290099143981934, -0.012488375417888165, -0.02282770909368992, 0.016922522336244583, -0.021486392244696617, -0.03800584003329277, -0.03761725127696991, -0.054954372346401215, -0.012680533342063427, 0.02569095604121685, -0.022828195244073868, 0.019186226651072502, 0.046460654586553574, -0.014316136948764324, -0.003729200689122081, -0.03814862668514252, -0.024418074637651443, -0.01873350329697132, -0.043188437819480896, 0.014446094632148743, -0.02990487404167652, -0.027111900970339775, 0.02114785648882389, 0.09721583127975464, -0.0353139191865921, 0.05529369041323662, 0.006870059762150049, -0.052771635353565216, -0.0112471217289567, -0.06630944460630417, 0.029145898297429085, -0.039608102291822433, 0.03646025061607361, 0.0035071405582129955, 0.03838483244180679, -0.0009322107071056962, -0.044631097465753555, -0.08767179399728775, -0.018405165523290634, 0.04857316240668297, 0.054653823375701904, 0.04592960700392723, 0.02154998853802681, -0.007565318141132593, 0.01078601274639368, 0.0014913453487679362, -0.10726815462112427, 0.0026128068566322327, -0.039656247943639755, 0.014414533041417599, 0.03773421794176102, -0.030247017741203308, 0.056386798620224, 0.008685268461704254, 0.05396007373929024, -0.009548979811370373, 0.1255076825618744, 0.0008382422383874655, 0.007408558391034603, -0.012102297507226467, 0.027007831260561943, 0.012358838692307472, -0.012489456683397293, 0.040028322488069534, -0.03867124766111374, 0.028133152052760124, -0.010455508716404438, -0.0014120329869911075, 0.06386272609233856, -0.0020362886134535074, 0.05897216126322746, -0.054460860788822174, 0.01156618818640709, -0.041016288101673126, -0.005355111323297024, -0.003368135541677475, 0.019481761381030083, -0.015816135331988335, 0.057702623307704926, 0.028644977137446404, -0.05516228824853897, 0.004052732605487108, -0.02386554703116417, -0.01734096370637417, 0.016877787187695503, -0.06714459508657455, 0.0431293286383152, -0.006033793091773987, 0.03346973657608032, 0.007696089800447226, -0.006643058266490698, 0.021258873865008354, 0.0022451882250607014, 0.048094019293785095, 0.005293221212923527, -0.022516457363963127, -0.030112454667687416, 0.004332211799919605, -0.02172168716788292, 0.025855932384729385, -0.017673667520284653, -0.0036077762488275766, -0.01591210439801216, -0.004256239626556635, -0.07961026579141617, 0.08426669985055923, -0.003095119260251522, -0.027476368471980095, 0.04820723831653595, 0.013481030240654945, 0.033716533333063126, 0.028994504362344742, 0.07796104997396469, 0.027123572304844856, 0.015761077404022217, -0.01509226392954588, -0.06098088249564171, -0.012510733678936958, -0.016329551115632057, 0.004272781312465668, -0.031420815736055374, -0.02067331224679947, 0.010066383518278599, 0.006782264448702335, -0.02532977983355522, 0.053144071251153946, 0.007931330241262913, -0.08707088977098465, -0.020821193233132362, 0.028893321752548218, 0.010886759497225285, 0.04125870764255524, 0.005503633059561253, 0.05471419543027878, 0.02971104346215725, 0.013827127404510975, 0.02280041202902794, 0.019047075882554054, -0.003151051700115204, -0.020701494067907333, 0.0067796348594129086, -0.03607578203082085, -0.01727820187807083, -0.014430517330765724, -0.023296337574720383, -0.009422937408089638, 0.07901846617460251, -0.004603447858244181, 0.06325118988752365, 0.03638836368918419, 0.017059875652194023, -0.014710956253111362, -0.020023494958877563, 0.02814236842095852, -0.014498318545520306, 0.035011183470487595, 0.030895818024873734, -0.016801293939352036, 0.06095768138766289, -0.00791993923485279, -0.019503511488437653, 0.053763262927532196, 0.020496021956205368, -0.0026641765143722296, -0.036749571561813354, 0.02598828449845314, 0.03902252018451691, 0.003008398460224271, 0.09885002672672272, -0.043833181262016296, 0.04244467616081238, 0.03121054545044899, -0.020517554134130478, 0.034591350704431534, -0.019975660368800163, -0.048071108758449554, -0.0017099608667194843, -0.017225895076990128, 0.0038005386013537645, 0.020890304818749428, 0.009046101942658424, 0.0725884884595871, 0.01672986149787903, -0.0017549332696944475, 0.013797887600958347, 0.08102503418922424, -0.059025779366493225, 0.02502632886171341, -0.02130734734237194, 0.030554067343473434, 0.0038465678226202726, -0.00301879714243114, 0.006543903611600399, -0.041270311921834946, -0.033698149025440216, 0.03223360329866409, -0.00023861569934524596, -0.02067543938755989, 0.019167067483067513, -0.015255984850227833, -0.011681931093335152, -0.03250802308320999, 0.02822696603834629, -0.005562976002693176, 0.055501583963632584, -0.00466257706284523, 0.05997897684574127, 0.0074735600501298904, 0.030656201764941216, -0.046344656497240067, -0.014774377457797527, -0.037349674850702286, -0.008934153243899345, 0.006592890713363886, -0.010534127242863178, -0.016253866255283356, 0.02712872065603733, -0.0014734647702425718, -0.020203962922096252, 0.041981156915426254, -0.011711730621755123, 0.0043962132185697556, 0.017677828669548035, -0.022314954549074173, -0.03838135674595833, -0.02224019169807434, 0.03366896137595177, -0.04466298222541809, 0.0025173849426209927, 0.038817573338747025, -0.0069025661796331406, 0.06544671952724457, -0.009463969618082047, -0.019318919628858566, -0.014266202226281166, 0.012621431611478329, 0.019560936838388443, 0.05743270367383957, -0.04100918397307396, 0.027460085228085518, 0.007437239401042461, 0.026484832167625427, -0.009477104060351849, 0.0007431873818859458, -0.03970040753483772, 0.01724051497876644, -0.042311035096645355, -0.02432146482169628, -0.009825970977544785, -0.0100710429251194, -0.021740594878792763, -0.011602259241044521, -0.07035341113805771, 0.03947989270091057, 0.0020713109988719225, -0.02644120715558529, 0.06914719194173813, 0.04262635484337807, -0.0016216416843235493, -0.018527572974562645, 0.020591603592038155, -0.02152593992650509, -0.032076895236968994, 0.08158250898122787, 0.048259586095809937, -0.00807045679539442, -0.0564056932926178, 0.002573734149336815, -0.061332397162914276, 0.0031282033305615187, 0.03793951869010925, 0.030154379084706306, 0.015954317525029182, 0.014822186902165413, -0.016600703820586205, -0.015029526315629482, -0.004800777416676283, 0.03474665805697441, -0.06549984961748123, 0.01682434231042862, 0.04001254215836525, 0.06344786286354065, -0.0018318878719583154, 0.02338024415075779, 0.00016166147543117404, 0.0005490189651027322, -0.030649323016405106, 0.09668275713920593, 0.030441032722592354, 0.06042100489139557, -0.045479513704776764, 0.04046481475234032, -0.040626153349876404, 0.034910157322883606, -0.0671943724155426, 0.002444902202114463, -0.0003275255730841309, -0.03152339905500412, -0.05722980946302414, -0.0020213283132761717, 0.03759276494383812, 0.01940620131790638, 0.029784537851810455, -0.003439006395637989, 0.011503794230520725, 0.07558808475732803, -0.06771383434534073, -0.008653581142425537, -0.05190660059452057, 0.040332816541194916, -0.012336757965385914, 0.028037644922733307, 0.038453295826911926, 0.04119085147976875, 0.00293395621702075, 0.007690552156418562, -0.009438751265406609, 0.036422256380319595, 0.0413055345416069, 0.004791625775396824, -0.026041949167847633, 0.04752977192401886, -0.06729841977357864, 0.02785561792552471, -0.049487337470054626, -0.06540996581315994, 0.0064160688780248165, 0.00669840257614851, -0.03070537932217121, 0.023781336843967438, -0.016587169840931892, -0.006813356187194586, 0.03748168423771858, -0.03544411435723305, -0.013389519415795803, 0.03765663132071495, 0.03313644230365753, -0.04137854650616646, -0.01932601071894169, 0.00652450043708086, 0.01128630805760622, -0.0051199602894485, 0.03850426524877548, -0.017411645501852036, -0.009039848111569881, 0.03271583095192909, -0.0763283520936966, -0.01766238547861576, 0.056234415620565414, 0.006302956957370043, -0.01672283001244068, -0.050320375710725784, -0.0005315490998327732, -0.01707715354859829, -0.0362907275557518, -0.0020034550689160824, -0.026504866778850555, -0.04191882908344269, 0.0326143316924572, -0.0012848384212702513, 0.013577999547123909, -0.0021464526653289795, -0.025095723569393158, 0.009795691817998886, 0.01797535829246044, -0.023296210914850235, -0.028214111924171448, -0.07099214941263199, -0.0019488156540319324, 0.007962320931255817, 0.03540877252817154, 0.028660833835601807, 0.024901263415813446, -0.003026205115020275, -0.0012059359578415751, -0.0957612693309784, -0.020165733993053436, 0.03364937752485275, 0.027029208838939667, 0.008069184608757496, -0.02085004933178425, 0.0466020368039608, 0.02739054337143898, -0.0003842751029878855, -0.01730475015938282, -0.054853472858667374, -0.003379425033926964, 0.027037441730499268, -0.047862280160188675, 0.008417094126343727, 0.015011057257652283, -0.014254344627261162, 0.04495302960276604, -0.026749609038233757, 0.01369902677834034, -0.028331605717539787, 0.024439621716737747, -0.0012241608928889036, 0.010548149235546589, -0.06127287074923515, -0.018817607313394547, -0.012042169459164143, -0.006398036144673824, -0.06924551725387573, 0.007428164128214121, 0.01479348074644804, -0.026709917932748795, -0.028400328010320663, 0.0210731141269207, -0.08253958821296692, 0.012315082363784313, 0.04159572347998619, 0.0027480716817080975, -0.042614150792360306, -0.004305625334382057, -0.015118679963052273, -0.012044127099215984, -0.014539116993546486, -0.02216246910393238, -0.03945106267929077, -0.08228608220815659, 0.04277162253856659, -0.003978122025728226, 0.03928743675351143, 0.027805455029010773, 0.02835669182240963, 0.0063206711784005165, -0.006185445003211498, -0.10332450270652771, 0.055770136415958405, 0.03010755404829979, -0.006590796168893576, -0.03494499996304512, -0.055183663964271545, 0.06155020371079445, -0.03792012482881546, -0.0020100499968975782, 0.02450733073055744, 0.033020202070474625, -0.00682858657091856, -0.024495180696249008, -0.003007686696946621, 0.06158959120512009, 0.013105322606861591, 0.0573243722319603, 0.00021688695414923131, -0.05602310970425606, -0.008391469717025757, 0.014356780797243118, -0.015305559150874615, 0.00655078049749136, -0.08529630303382874, -0.06759387999773026, 0.08265689015388489, -0.05497772619128227, -0.0015428338665515184, -0.04995959997177124, -0.008743220008909702, -0.09528633952140808, -0.06462917476892471, -0.009733308106660843, 0.034716758877038956, -0.08860330283641815, 0.020295627415180206, 0.025649484246969223, -0.06448754668235779, -0.0063305022194981575, 0.03095686063170433, 0.01843711920082569, -0.0065808724611997604, -0.013918839395046234, 0.023920409381389618, -0.0384388342499733, -0.007103075738996267, -0.00849027931690216, 0.026627421379089355, -0.0402216836810112, 0.0338151715695858, -0.027721190825104713, -0.04372141510248184, -0.012974658980965614, 0.023803096264600754, 0.007380344904959202, 0.03506535291671753, 0.08832386881113052, -0.04659675806760788, 0.014073808677494526, 0.0381552129983902, -0.022301694378256798, 0.008999282494187355, -0.04747485741972923, 0.019480669870972633, -0.03687949851155281, 0.023015109822154045, -0.04924596846103668, 0.02450702153146267, 0.0008755731978453696, -0.06548624485731125, 0.00230023474432528, -0.01967022567987442, -0.0363541804254055, -0.00855881068855524, 0.053180888295173645, 0.010911562480032444, 0.026651065796613693, 0.027385076507925987, -0.001777233206667006, 0.02632446400821209, 0.027226194739341736, -0.02864992804825306, 0.0190761536359787, -0.0016717687249183655, -0.015359314158558846, -0.07186371833086014, -0.023282809183001518, 0.0065584261901676655, 0.004086003638803959, -0.0526079423725605, 0.06830350309610367, -0.006061492022126913, -0.01946296915411949, -0.013607490807771683, -0.06597772240638733, 0.008982986211776733, -0.053955551236867905, -0.029302915558218956, -0.01412997767329216, -0.000690084882080555, -0.03933900222182274, -0.007345043122768402, -0.09515530616044998, -0.046809665858745575, 0.02010428160429001, 0.03313657268881798, -0.0819244384765625, -0.014258036389946938, -0.05197960510849953, 0.014517617411911488, -0.0038428092375397682, -0.004882660694420338, 0.03486684337258339, 0.008970996364951134, 0.0037948929239064455, -0.005787930451333523, 0.004356006160378456, 0.016177702695131302, 0.06208740547299385, -0.022496357560157776, -0.07416736334562302, -0.033441174775362015, -0.028568018227815628, -0.03345564380288124, 0.0404234454035759, 0.03829644247889519, 0.011189684271812439, 0.014657925814390182, -0.022207602858543396, 0.0044564842246472836, 0.02959398925304413, -0.012410694733262062, -0.03838249295949936, 0.10126302391290665, -0.012162706814706326, -0.0006337681552395225, 0.0006568548851646483, 0.015652401372790337, -0.030300529673695564, -0.0017745549557730556, 0.06733465194702148, -0.033894456923007965, 0.04498802497982979, 0.004495464731007814, 0.037463124841451645, 0.006542938761413097, 0.0971946120262146, 0.04999728873372078, -0.023830898106098175, -0.04105900973081589, -0.01192344818264246, -0.0248532984405756, 0.0419844388961792, -0.02640797197818756, 0.029124129563570023, 0.01733163185417652, -0.05570443347096443, 0.028467601165175438, -0.08886542171239853, 0.002721077296882868, 0.056978050619363785, 0.07743193209171295, 0.013500439003109932, 0.04838540032505989, -0.027727331966161728, -0.04839302971959114, -0.0577278696000576, -0.011626140214502811, -0.02659941092133522, 0.07274940609931946, 0.05333220213651657, -0.00687827356159687, -0.007111351005733013, -0.08748657256364822, -0.06471459567546844, -0.023844027891755104, -0.009412728250026703, -0.045532338321208954, -0.03142930939793587, 0.05966245010495186, -0.02757078781723976, -0.0230748038738966, 0.0515303760766983, -0.03690994530916214, 0.0021704877726733685, -0.02791074477136135, -0.04876265302300453, -0.011274767108261585, 0.023049844428896904, 0.00564435962587595, 0.0023482225369662046, -0.006031991448253393, -0.019084809347987175, -0.0022282020654529333, -0.00047254524542950094, -0.052392326295375824, -0.035956818610429764, 0.023899337276816368, -0.025605211034417152, -0.05009901151061058, 0.020947512239217758, -0.005291247274726629, -0.028268571943044662, 0.05683552101254463, 0.03592802211642265, 0.06271429359912872, 0.018138546496629715, -0.002272679004818201, 0.015287712216377258, 0.03879118338227272, 0.011344037018716335, 0.03696673363447189, -0.03877823427319527, -0.027245914563536644, -0.007107164710760117, 0.0772610604763031, -0.01491289772093296, -0.0063340552151203156, -0.013543141074478626, -0.013331681489944458, -0.012325559742748737, -0.054050005972385406, -0.012483651749789715, 0.03809843957424164, 0.029714694246649742, -0.05851360782980919, 0.014623729512095451, 0.02145247906446457, 0.029041755944490433, -0.004826117306947708, 0.012771492823958397, 0.002216045744717121, 0.005259433761239052, 0.017037292942404747, -0.01706526428461075, 0.024223851040005684, 0.010289314202964306, -0.05416662245988846, 0.028178900480270386, -0.019779743626713753, 0.023376384750008583, 0.0014853671891614795, 0.026380427181720734, -0.04395248368382454, 0.011268818750977516, -0.009318500757217407, 0.04147407412528992, 0.007400198373943567, -0.021025631576776505, 0.010293621569871902, 0.08428800106048584, 0.006961421109735966, 0.0167046207934618, 0.029486581683158875, -0.005379176698625088, -0.06129702553153038, 0.043211910873651505, -0.006320583634078503, 0.06662781536579132, 0.016842851415276527, -0.030073320493102074, -0.016257479786872864, 0.004727079998701811, -0.0002732770808506757, -0.008712668903172016, -0.022091588005423546, -0.032087188214063644, -0.0783810093998909, 0.04083840176463127, 0.005871630739420652, 0.0034241911489516497, 0.005276271607726812, 0.04289637878537178 ]
<p>How can I find the standard deviation in categorical distribution, where the elements have non-numerical attributes (e.g. colors)?</p> <p>For example, I have a bag of marbles with $n$ colors. There's an infinite number of marbles in the bag, and are biased towards a certain color with a probability of $\frac{x}n, x&gt;1$. From the bag, I pick $m$ marbles and get the probability distribution with respect to their colors. </p> <p>From this distribution, by picking $q$ colors with the highest probabilities, I want to convince others with a confidence interval $k$% (e.g. 95%), that one of the colors I chose is the one that the marbles are biased towards.</p> <p>In this scenario, what are some of the analysis techniques that can be used to find $q$, given $x,n,k,$ and $m$?</p>
g74305
[ 0.03326636180281639, 0.045864880084991455, -0.008664706721901894, -0.03448924794793129, 0.005877232179045677, 0.005662304349243641, -0.012177071534097195, 0.010650639422237873, -0.043376579880714417, 0.008548920974135399, -0.009694142267107964, -0.013159137219190598, 0.03594009950757027, 0.02981288731098175, -0.03984479978680611, 0.02849394455552101, 0.028943467885255814, 0.05399264395236969, 0.03504099324345589, 0.022732321172952652, -0.04186287894845009, 0.027549730613827705, -0.005607981234788895, -0.059161365032196045, -0.015853870660066605, -0.01701381616294384, 0.013497922569513321, -0.00029082695255056024, -0.05140051618218422, 0.021513113752007484, -0.07405224442481995, 0.019321363419294357, 0.04646218568086624, 0.022843437269330025, 0.040368661284446716, 0.00793516356498003, 0.08762627094984055, 0.015447264537215233, -0.00901208259165287, 0.023057177662849426, -0.06160683557391167, 0.03135617449879646, 0.036197613924741745, 0.03328673169016838, -0.009188530035316944, 0.0338657982647419, -0.024673722684383392, 0.04154559224843979, 0.006080894265323877, -0.035489413887262344, -0.01992417871952057, 0.06945636868476868, 0.01170186884701252, 0.008104180917143822, -0.023849738761782646, 0.02049463614821434, 0.04574893042445183, 0.005366295576095581, 0.018173538148403168, 0.0211095679551363, 0.03905121237039566, -0.04047267511487007, -0.08770309388637543, 0.027836883440613747, 0.016179120168089867, 0.045313481241464615, -0.02089199237525463, -0.001854846253991127, 0.011043278500437737, -0.009913627989590168, -0.0060266852378845215, 0.0163522120565176, 0.05176491290330887, 0.016907501965761185, -0.07323329895734787, -0.0546683743596077, -0.03664383292198181, 0.0333021841943264, 0.01253682840615511, 0.04776177182793617, -0.008273046463727951, 0.06832529604434967, 0.07404552400112152, -0.05186858028173447, -0.035869210958480835, 0.026090942323207855, 0.04126106947660446, -0.05056758224964142, -0.0599367618560791, -0.007642468437552452, 0.00013350341760087758, -0.0009885685285553336, 0.014592095278203487, 0.049556758254766464, -0.006054334808140993, -0.031379152089357376, -0.06252872943878174, 0.03166632354259491, -0.02512263134121895, -0.030535856261849403, 0.029489120468497276, 0.013952682726085186, 0.001394188031554222, -0.06974206119775772, -0.055169906467199326, 0.005303338170051575, -0.025453172624111176, 0.054932884871959686, 0.018478496000170708, 0.025193868204951286, -0.018046919256448746, 0.0028542380314320326, -0.04044598713517189, -0.05716860294342041, -0.02887318655848503, 0.004037588369101286, 0.011694783344864845, -0.006972339935600758, -0.03421509265899658, 0.023244909942150116, 0.0020087941084057093, 0.0521492101252079, 0.04954938963055611, 0.07047302275896072, -0.03773999586701393, 0.006804196164011955, 0.006627894006669521, 0.06894633919000626, 0.0006430138600990176, -0.060269977897405624, 0.06700335443019867, 0.03799573704600334, 0.07836880534887314, -0.0005032156477682292, -0.03347613662481308, 0.026218390092253685, -0.0035113783087581396, 0.08265268057584763, 0.01251516304910183, 0.04377304017543793, 0.004023477900773287, 0.0369165800511837, 0.012527442537248135, -0.045832451432943344, 0.04996233060956001, -0.02649856172502041, -0.020134542137384415, 0.02073272317647934, 0.010981815867125988, 0.01889204978942871, -0.02774921804666519, 0.013708380982279778, -0.012399580329656601, -0.051001664251089096, -0.032853320240974426, 0.021683160215616226, 0.012613383121788502, 0.03302323818206787, -0.054490961134433746, -0.04142087697982788, 0.08996357768774033, -0.0037607767153531313, 0.015020417980849743, -0.005191794130951166, -0.019679376855492592, -0.0327511802315712, 0.0438469722867012, 0.02069796249270439, 0.006063633598387241, -0.01891382597386837, -0.024234114214777946, 0.0095571493729949, -0.008041157387197018, 0.030053744092583656, 0.010807913728058338, 0.012836134061217308, 0.021613601595163345, 0.010974915698170662, 0.026839008554816246, 0.03612368553876877, -0.038068950176239014, 0.02129371464252472, 0.044161856174468994, -0.015580199658870697, 0.03048071078956127, -0.03059658594429493, 0.004430737346410751, 0.024291574954986572, -0.007664923090487719, 0.015191588550806046, 0.0094351377338171, -0.05457942932844162, -0.00615219259634614, 0.022525567561388016, 0.03108346089720726, -0.04347037523984909, 0.013033224269747734, 0.018986791372299194, -0.008728026412427425, -0.05672920495271683, 0.06330468505620956, 0.027392307296395302, -0.06421610713005066, 0.019017918035387993, 0.0177769772708416, -0.048470765352249146, 0.003951462917029858, -0.0361286960542202, -0.00039506377652287483, -0.029925337061285973, -0.01875973865389824, -0.03946923837065697, -0.05417320504784584, 0.022184178233146667, -0.005557766649872065, 0.008497413247823715, 0.01446087472140789, -0.0027305479161441326, 0.03937738016247749, -0.016341498121619225, -0.02041960135102272, -0.05164775997400284, -0.009913817048072815, -0.004778213798999786, -0.0077969967387616634, 0.07771997898817062, 0.03526961803436279, 0.05939202755689621, 0.031064406037330627, 0.036880675703287125, -0.07911474257707596, -0.04626160487532616, 0.039480339735746384, -0.03628090023994446, -0.0003457449784036726, 0.06051115691661835, -0.0093952352181077, -0.015940776094794273, 0.05032743141055107, -0.03368588909506798, 0.022459961473941803, -0.05006367713212967, -0.01676642708480358, 0.03357455134391785, 0.04899442195892334, -0.0024993065744638443, 0.05418222025036812, 0.01708434522151947, -0.0006903634057380259, 0.048128098249435425, 0.013223739340901375, 0.017346391454339027, -0.01775643788278103, -0.04678099602460861, 0.018462862819433212, 0.027482591569423676, -0.01125018484890461, -0.03255673125386238, -0.0005679808673448861, -0.025683805346488953, -0.018591180443763733, -0.053105566650629044, 0.01523618958890438, -0.004538239445537329, -0.0033163190819323063, -0.0454978346824646, -0.004731824621558189, 0.02906397357583046, -0.004133876413106918, 0.020811239257454872, -0.041869886219501495, 0.016490858048200607, 0.025255601853132248, 0.02021055668592453, -0.008438028395175934, 0.019829709082841873, -0.03325258567929268, -0.004326894413679838, -0.03655606135725975, 0.037734050303697586, 0.06315850466489792, 0.008965501561760902, 0.012880387715995312, -0.021212736144661903, 0.04030706360936165, 0.03392234072089195, 0.04153618961572647, -0.011966781690716743, -0.012680605985224247, 0.016876041889190674, 0.0426870696246624, -0.0007501632790081203, -0.04730028286576271, -0.03121182508766651, -0.00996454805135727, -0.02132568322122097, 0.010729070752859116, -0.02780935913324356, 0.05487949401140213, -0.020074496045708656, -0.06828106194734573, 0.034531861543655396, 0.003245448926463723, 0.017289921641349792, 0.0011200675508007407, 0.003971983212977648, -0.0033441137056797743, -0.007870837114751339, 0.06852206587791443, -0.05595846474170685, -0.015608825720846653, 0.041950710117816925, -0.005900667514652014, 0.0055705346167087555, -0.03423458710312843, -0.04319138452410698, 0.050798673182725906, 0.009805802255868912, -0.020436542108654976, -0.11196399480104446, 0.03916731849312782, 0.0005801492952741683, 0.03671400249004364, 0.00331873563118279, 0.023808971047401428, 0.007615692913532257, -0.04701096937060356, 0.06311009079217911, -0.016770299524068832, -0.03582296520471573, 0.0774235725402832, 0.01829107291996479, 0.05692636966705322, 0.02321000210940838, -0.0663839653134346, -0.08102191239595413, 0.01469455100595951, -0.01595791056752205, 0.04025232046842575, -0.050847623497247696, -0.017391689121723175, -0.046382348984479904, 0.005249122157692909, -0.0526646263897419, -0.05277246981859207, 0.03424296900629997, 0.004148487001657486, 0.0659637451171875, 0.031116969883441925, 0.020205622538924217, -0.022662566974759102, -0.017045551910996437, 0.041809722781181335, 0.0006289033917710185, 0.026905380189418793, 0.016895007342100143, 0.05526132881641388, -0.004730814602226019, -0.0011139570269733667, -0.00843026489019394, 0.019292600452899933, -0.039977382868528366, -0.03811595216393471, -0.002149897161871195, 0.014715739525854588, 0.014281057752668858, 0.05854116380214691, 0.015359988436102867, -0.0029613079968839884, 0.006226657424122095, 0.02796979807317257, 0.00249949237331748, 0.020668143406510353, 0.0057356758043169975, -0.015861956402659416, 0.017881037667393684, 0.008254701271653175, 0.0032708803191781044, 0.004282940644770861, -0.015839574858546257, 0.0015522893518209457, 0.036137837916612625, 0.015473256818950176, -0.0038420786149799824, 0.06763071566820145, -0.05117965489625931, -0.08259458094835281, 0.008973430842161179, 0.010671503841876984, -0.0403360091149807, 0.025554046034812927, -0.000009367233360535465, -0.07275286316871643, 0.048408348113298416, -0.06184558570384979, -0.06063477694988251, 0.03371516987681389, 0.013558643870055676, 0.022526459768414497, 0.0409514419734478, -0.07219275832176208, 0.0174089465290308, 0.022715818136930466, -0.014807425439357758, 0.083562470972538, 0.02838055044412613, -0.0035948557779192924, -0.013354003429412842, -0.006165040656924248, 0.03921045735478401, -0.027722615748643875, -0.06308024376630783, 0.03383464366197586, -0.04295111447572708, -0.006607090588659048, -0.005523361265659332, 0.04165332019329071, 0.023699520155787468, 0.018047524616122246, -0.010606636293232441, 0.01835169643163681, -0.022198082879185677, -0.07809395343065262, -0.003616553731262684, 0.00677050556987524, -0.04828477278351784, 0.04551021382212639, 0.016581997275352478, 0.026009486988186836, -0.0008043487905524671, 0.03831320255994797, -0.001749255578033626, 0.014864987693727016, 0.00818411260843277, -0.029208239167928696, -0.04944901913404465, -0.052440155297517776, -0.008010372519493103, -0.008483374491333961, -0.044929567724466324, 0.003766015637665987, 0.058773718774318695, -0.04231145977973938, -0.04435310512781143, 0.09260548651218414, 0.05233136564493179, -0.0042772614397108555, 0.027259910479187965, -0.016695460304617882, 0.0811147466301918, 0.03683643043041229, 0.03183659538626671, -0.06027747690677643, 0.01069148164242506, 0.027617506682872772, 0.004183685407042503, -0.06338146328926086, 0.020143253728747368, 0.05310095101594925, 0.03930133208632469, -0.006545858457684517, -0.00897881668061018, -0.057935312390327454, -0.027931930497288704, -0.05363135412335396, 0.012221585027873516, -0.013191621750593185, 0.02827104739844799, 0.09498430788516998, -0.004532639402896166, 0.0019801172893494368, 0.029400309547781944, 0.032019998878240585, 0.000818907399661839, 0.013647018000483513, 0.020227668806910515, 0.008311983197927475, -0.005104990676045418, -0.02169685997068882, -0.04052996635437012, -0.06145903840661049, 0.010957833379507065, 0.014158127829432487, 0.029892003163695335, 0.013588162139058113, 0.0015790992183610797, 0.025001592934131622, -0.08204182982444763, 0.06629743427038193, -0.023510193452239037, 0.05991016700863838, 0.016459306702017784, 0.0020489045418798923, 0.005929732229560614, -0.0020577493123710155, -0.05184553563594818, 0.09696321934461594, 0.00022930011618882418, 0.025355927646160126, 0.012364924885332584, -0.005551510956138372, 0.0052328272722661495, 0.02969169430434704, -0.007910890504717827, 0.02759001962840557, 0.049436911940574646, 0.057957593351602554, -0.045414648950099945, 0.008261721581220627, 0.054620422422885895, 0.03129878640174866, 0.01679193787276745, 0.07646619528532028, 0.008911767974495888, -0.05176385119557381, -0.006855878978967667, -0.013604911975562572, -0.04339149221777916, 0.0017495732754468918, 0.02040610834956169, -0.01856575347483158, -0.05079340562224388, 0.008665778674185276, -0.039511788636446, 0.012046162970364094, -0.07646006345748901, -0.04223689064383507, -0.05897706374526024, 0.0038182390853762627, -0.02688189595937729, 0.06358873099088669, -0.019645916298031807, -0.04743332043290138, -0.04122928902506828, -0.02147977240383625, -0.04505935683846474, 0.03366607055068016, 0.015756776556372643, -0.03254040703177452, 0.021819625049829483, -0.03828996792435646, 0.011416160501539707, 0.05051258206367493, -0.09250572323799133, -0.007095908746123314, 0.023258624598383904, -0.040154892951250076, 0.008846166543662548, -0.04120897129178047, -0.0060955798253417015, 0.011734315194189548, 0.06943158805370331, 0.07016590982675552, -0.057613126933574677, 0.009671039879322052, -0.01053602620959282, -0.002109598834067583, -0.01707637682557106, 0.019112346693873405, 0.0071040852926671505, -0.04115112125873566, -0.04257487878203392, 0.013184232637286186, 0.00390696432441473, -0.059204332530498505, 0.025447096675634384, -0.07527346909046173, 0.022549279034137726, 0.012193848378956318, 0.07135183364152908, 0.031135354191064835, -0.005179418716579676, 0.018290888518095016, 0.015882181003689766, 0.009353048168122768, -0.07108024507761002, -0.003958523273468018, -0.022184472531080246, 0.00974259339272976, -0.01634788326919079, -0.04292440786957741, -0.03653614968061447, -0.04309139773249626, 0.0061012799851596355, -0.10276913642883301, -0.02566179260611534, 0.007738766726106405, -0.01752162165939808, -0.07040543109178543, -0.03321206197142601, 0.008332507684826851, -0.03718230500817299, 0.0011825348483398557, -0.005237013101577759, -0.0460803359746933, -0.03862633928656578, -0.047092340886592865, 0.017468184232711792, -0.03386810049414635, -0.023672612383961678, -0.048668090254068375, -0.0013988143764436245, -0.012530933134257793, 0.026883909478783607, 0.0336921289563179, -0.009906058199703693, 0.018433773890137672, 0.00909718032926321, 0.0024232787545770407, 0.02622002363204956, 0.01469364482909441, 0.052766527980566025, 0.009952008724212646, 0.03872431069612503, 0.04594825208187103, 0.007144898176193237, -0.012162783183157444, -0.0022350242361426353, -0.07180964201688766, -0.04313836246728897, 0.04228437319397926, 0.005945704877376556, -0.03583689406514168, -0.08070562034845352, 0.01074950024485588, 0.007118201348930597, -0.01820400357246399, -0.012055567465722561, 0.03455516695976257, -0.013501990586519241, 0.02024477906525135, -0.028490455821156502, 0.04352260380983353, 0.04826768487691879, -0.031331948935985565, 0.0011323575163260102, -0.06934289634227753, 0.07395680248737335, 0.093887098133564, -0.009971427731215954, -0.04208683967590332, 0.017051611095666885, 0.01802813448011875, -0.008583636954426765, 0.0825999528169632, 0.0008569757337681949, 0.021604226902127266, 0.04727352038025856, -0.007788383401930332, -0.025339946150779724, 0.05386456847190857, 0.027435215190052986, 0.005750712938606739, -0.057750992476940155, 0.008998598903417587, 0.026527227833867073, 0.04854920506477356, -0.0029617680702358484, 0.04710577800869942, -0.04875057563185692, -0.07070442289113998, -0.07034779340028763, -0.000214225918170996, -0.05459526181221008, -0.05769960582256317, 0.012293780222535133, -0.06606249511241913, -0.01589927263557911, -0.034279413521289825, -0.011037386022508144, -0.00020907886209897697, -0.00495621794834733, -0.03687124326825142, 0.04467613995075226, -0.0010329884244129062, 0.015807585790753365, -0.014117722399532795, 0.04573114588856697, 0.009579573757946491, -0.01649734377861023, 0.05606405436992645, -0.009780817665159702, -0.008391243405640125, -0.04774283617734909, -0.04456089809536934, 0.016440920531749725, 0.02866118773818016, 0.01629084348678589, -0.005230917129665613, -0.006234418600797653, -0.06131838262081146, -0.06908378005027771, -0.010884193703532219, -0.02189251035451889, -0.05958719924092293, 0.015237859450280666, -0.01976737007498741, -0.0005966339376755059, 0.057416945695877075, 0.07151073217391968, 0.01929190754890442, 0.03160635754466057, -0.004784979857504368, -0.024337513372302055, 0.0013825168134644628, -0.060648780316114426, 0.0036674360744655132, -0.039393775165081024, -0.01837237924337387, -0.024453256279230118, -0.017878565937280655, 0.0008678225567564368, -0.035149190574884415, -0.0038358657620847225, 0.03255463391542435, -0.0008489968022331595, -0.03851170465350151, 0.01717430166900158, 0.0018946441123262048, -0.03695647418498993, -0.0440240278840065, -0.018872329965233803, -0.0030948303174227476, 0.02864028885960579, -0.01261744275689125, -0.02974580228328705, -0.07668159902095795, 0.0028740905690938234, -0.020630337297916412, 0.05399564653635025, -0.021986160427331924, 0.026216143742203712, -0.01902507059276104, 0.03062370792031288, -0.025710413232445717, -0.011816396377980709, -0.0028765941970050335, -0.0277510117739439, 0.00903469230979681, 0.018864830955863, -0.01758476532995701, 0.02417084574699402, -0.008315659128129482, -0.018417436629533768, 0.00037003785837441683, 0.024614611640572548, -0.03181835636496544, 0.009443172253668308, -0.04115280508995056, 0.026755016297101974, -0.001192991971038282, -0.03440077602863312, -0.015806272625923157, 0.05263392627239227, -0.05437665432691574, 0.028274524956941605, 0.056031547486782074, 0.021952787414193153, 0.06775730848312378, -0.041736915707588196, -0.019886953756213188, -0.055745720863342285, -0.016420094296336174, 0.0462457612156868, -0.02586127258837223, 0.0015016518300399184, -0.05386356636881828, -0.03885636851191521 ]
<p>I have recently interviewed for a statistical analysis job and was asked a question about why linear least squares regression fails when the data is heteroskedastic. The correct answer to this question, according to the interviewers, is that heteroskedastic data means that the equation of the regression line produced by least squares regression is an unbiased estimator of the true relationship, but that it is NOT efficient, essentially because the part of the dataset where the variance is smaller than average is effectively underweighted. </p> <p>My question is <strong>which textbooks could I use to find more detail about this topic, and other similar topics at this level</strong>, e.g. </p> <ul> <li>the relationship between data being normally distributed and least-squares linear regression being the maximum likelihood estimator for the straight line fit </li> </ul> <p>[I have a degree in mathematics but with minimal statistics background &amp; understand general probability concepts such as the central limit theorem, random variables, etc, and I know high school level statistics up to the British A-level S4 statistics, however I lack a certain level of statistics knowledge and don't know what I don't know or where to find out more... ]</p>
g37138
[ 0.05092933401465416, -0.025216901674866676, 0.003104760544374585, -0.03424294665455818, -0.02690153382718563, 0.03107520565390587, -0.009909066371619701, -0.030302660539746284, -0.01419044565409422, -0.040503762662410736, 0.020947987213730812, -0.007978186011314392, 0.023572614416480064, 0.04124705120921135, -0.01606214977800846, 0.058316558599472046, 0.08426542580127716, 0.009243045002222061, -0.015072062611579895, 0.005748458672314882, -0.013738280162215233, 0.013726707547903061, 0.0072923693805933, -0.027846839278936386, -0.08258538693189621, -0.036116622388362885, -0.052930064499378204, 0.04014338552951813, -0.03460300713777542, 0.017875147983431816, 0.012218852527439594, -0.012135242111980915, 0.04826220124959946, -0.052328500896692276, -0.038107436150312424, -0.039658237248659134, 0.04506096616387367, -0.03493689373135567, 0.029074309393763542, 0.015578087419271469, 0.05572206899523735, -0.032126665115356445, 0.0023428569547832012, 0.02438867837190628, -0.0021227477118372917, -0.012913528829813004, -0.06719480454921722, 0.05505334213376045, 0.023319030180573463, -0.01768319122493267, -0.02923714369535446, 0.037431441247463226, 0.03449335694313049, -0.015685690566897392, 0.04218433424830437, 0.020255090668797493, 0.025728974491357803, -0.010835487395524979, 0.006464981008321047, -0.05412566289305687, 0.03975294530391693, -0.01766921579837799, -0.06716929376125336, -0.032329317182302475, 0.022717177867889404, 0.025853388011455536, 0.012926681898534298, -0.029155872762203217, -0.020971601828932762, -0.003147362032905221, 0.005860143806785345, -0.043108951300382614, 0.0143779581412673, -0.07669854164123535, -0.003529002657160163, 0.007559316698461771, 0.0070704747922718525, -0.016496803611516953, 0.005469883792102337, 0.03870733827352524, -0.004629476461559534, 0.05531018599867821, -0.01461766567081213, 0.04300559312105179, 0.09496495127677917, -0.010457981377840042, 0.04649757593870163, -0.031316060572862625, 0.04775146767497063, 0.00970842968672514, 0.020091358572244644, 0.02358129620552063, 0.03384524956345558, 0.03277913108468056, -0.08055724203586578, -0.0006431291694752872, -0.08815574645996094, -0.08620524406433105, -0.005289455875754356, -0.00950341485440731, -0.04816979542374611, -0.03621551766991615, -0.025117745622992516, 0.02140507474541664, -0.04067756608128548, 0.050912853330373764, 0.051965851336717606, 0.00746607081964612, -0.050731755793094635, -0.017290392890572548, -0.02421383000910282, 0.03034149296581745, -0.053012870252132416, -0.05533115938305855, -0.013124190270900726, -0.06023501232266426, 0.03728608042001724, -0.013691731728613377, 0.04027543216943741, -0.013390325009822845, 0.033599626272916794, 0.04637117311358452, 0.026378072798252106, 0.0014026736607775092, -0.04688233882188797, 0.00023726432118564844, 0.008157989010214806, 0.06411804258823395, 0.0207937341183424, 0.08055382966995239, 0.03140302002429962, -0.027314074337482452, -0.022552499547600746, 0.018344860523939133, -0.007998146116733551, 0.0754854753613472, -0.01572134532034397, 0.03128192201256752, 0.036335304379463196, -0.015110890381038189, -0.00988259818404913, 0.018122367560863495, 0.0013844114728271961, -0.04392487555742264, -0.010730266571044922, 0.03734852373600006, 0.03644123300909996, 0.01783580891788006, -0.06741266697645187, 0.03744807094335556, 0.005788363050669432, 0.02204081602394581, -0.008552685379981995, -0.036144766956567764, -0.08033271133899689, 0.002321253763511777, 0.01577109657227993, -0.07520344853401184, 0.052045684307813644, -0.01374819315969944, 0.05005700886249542, 0.006258735433220863, 0.013899478130042553, 0.03227461874485016, 0.004471166059374809, 0.025394381955266, -0.0061805578880012035, -0.055920667946338654, 0.05277228727936745, -0.007759231608361006, -0.0023088217712938786, -0.05978751927614212, 0.07992685586214066, 0.041789259761571884, 0.020596789196133614, 0.05870626121759415, 0.10243189334869385, -0.0307619608938694, 0.05748426914215088, 0.011848230846226215, 0.048788849264383316, 0.023807020857930183, 0.0034004738554358482, -0.06294208765029907, -0.04166119545698166, -0.0032401832286268473, 0.007141842041164637, 0.014182341285049915, -0.05205389857292175, 0.0029655247926712036, -0.030138181522488594, -0.036229655146598816, 0.025874020531773567, -0.04918418079614639, -0.02623283676803112, -0.014262695796787739, 0.05079546198248863, -0.008341602049767971, -0.05223827064037323, -0.035772502422332764, 0.025389963760972023, -0.01623896323144436, -0.023482341319322586, 0.02258256822824478, -0.04577624797821045, 0.007676637731492519, -0.022222254425287247, 0.004573041573166847, 0.006727600935846567, 0.01844952069222927, -0.050623632967472076, -0.017548484727740288, 0.046898890286684036, 0.020208114758133888, 0.03779899328947067, -0.04607432708144188, -0.024519430473446846, 0.05228068307042122, 0.013438055291771889, 0.01748179830610752, -0.045020751655101776, -0.03972877562046051, 0.03925182670354843, -0.0029327699448913336, 0.00010170911264140159, 0.015463043935596943, 0.051298197358846664, -0.031345486640930176, -0.036305930465459824, -0.03147387504577637, -0.0492643341422081, -0.022497309371829033, 0.06033562868833542, -0.024227255955338478, 0.0078887315467, 0.012861278839409351, 0.06067737191915512, 0.0181171502918005, 0.019846748560667038, 0.06858164817094803, -0.024401545524597168, -0.0018866213504225016, -0.033043839037418365, 0.05294174700975418, 0.004540625959634781, -0.011290735565125942, 0.05854340270161629, -0.08757217228412628, 0.03426423668861389, 0.012427262030541897, -0.04089890047907829, 0.07424065470695496, 0.05644404515624046, -0.050623971968889236, 0.005769567564129829, -0.031464070081710815, -0.014820583164691925, 0.038438793271780014, -0.010746314190328121, -0.004665971267968416, 0.004854300525039434, 0.023458560928702354, -0.05841783434152603, -0.038199782371520996, -0.08592834323644638, 0.011609385721385479, -0.055982016026973724, -0.013907435350120068, -0.016673345118761063, -0.043073009699583054, -0.027847807854413986, 0.03251698613166809, 0.0066781784407794476, 0.09775438159704208, 0.04446969926357269, 0.02263537421822548, -0.08457370102405548, -0.009785650297999382, 0.005007516592741013, -0.029759613797068596, 0.058954138308763504, -0.04482436180114746, 0.005923480726778507, -0.022788114845752716, 0.028688691556453705, -0.004904711619019508, 0.041082851588726044, -0.042354781180620193, 0.01798917166888714, 0.034010715782642365, -0.07351192086935043, 0.010225226171314716, -0.014416503719985485, -0.011989738792181015, 0.03077002614736557, -0.011378850787878036, 0.02138923667371273, -0.06031213700771332, -0.019157931208610535, -0.015812460333108902, -0.03296776860952377, 0.05461392179131508, 0.017809011042118073, -0.02360686846077442, 0.029659250751137733, -0.0073227728717029095, -0.016664551571011543, -0.07694777101278305, -0.0182977132499218, 0.03147585690021515, -0.007407479453831911, -0.038767483085393906, 0.02488914504647255, -0.008207380771636963, -0.02595858834683895, -0.026959974318742752, 0.019608328118920326, 0.029066460207104683, 0.007361080963164568, 0.0273669995367527, 0.02355870231986046, -0.09398815780878067, -0.03003676049411297, 0.01412571407854557, -0.0006431838846765459, -0.03945981711149216, -0.043440911918878555, 0.0077590737491846085, -0.027451982721686363, 0.04231826588511467, 0.0251125767827034, 0.006790366023778915, 0.02382589690387249, 0.04798656329512596, -0.024831756949424744, -0.018727563321590424, 0.025561492890119553, -0.007832997478544712, 0.009661205112934113, 0.058409012854099274, 0.030654102563858032, 0.05080343782901764, -0.056044258177280426, 0.032323915511369705, -0.0024461469147354364, 0.01451274286955595, -0.037578653544187546, -0.04415777698159218, -0.015056696720421314, -0.00497821718454361, 0.06270400434732437, -0.004502714611589909, -0.026313593611121178, -0.051620736718177795, 0.008600063621997833, 0.011688337661325932, 0.0375206358730793, 0.05932604894042015, 0.05336357280611992, -0.0043574427254498005, 0.013156034052371979, -0.0028074709698557854, 0.03156590834259987, 0.006718237418681383, -0.013109295628964901, 0.016711007803678513, 0.04499520733952522, 0.07462706416845322, 0.005745463538914919, -0.011375367641448975, -0.01177230104804039, -0.01878649741411209, 0.009693880565464497, 0.01606716215610504, -0.007694341707974672, -0.01639486663043499, 0.035963937640190125, 0.03742404654622078, -0.03605452924966812, 0.02591586299240589, 0.04133124649524689, 0.04946989193558693, -0.014651050791144371, 0.03156454861164093, 0.049253709614276886, -0.0954040065407753, -0.025987857952713966, 0.019620710983872414, -0.022158820182085037, -0.011211859062314034, 0.013813149183988571, -0.04456095024943352, -0.05362171307206154, 0.043269168585538864, 0.019991252571344376, -0.04156661778688431, 0.021867169067263603, 0.022151410579681396, 0.01609358750283718, 0.009763975627720356, -0.012863764539361, 0.008661912754178047, 0.01454662624746561, 0.04272909089922905, -0.00938574131578207, 0.04845922067761421, -0.02507598325610161, -0.000769315636716783, -0.092987060546875, -0.03153085708618164, -0.011580219492316246, 0.025547156110405922, -0.06552355736494064, -0.028925525024533272, 0.07164712995290756, 0.01567523553967476, 0.0001953446480911225, -0.020309848710894585, -0.03449835628271103, -0.03336840122938156, -0.02523369900882244, 0.07429780066013336, -0.0873880609869957, -0.005370778497308493, 0.01988605409860611, 0.05671120807528496, 0.06978562474250793, -0.01269183587282896, 0.016635021194815636, -0.021408360451459885, 0.05882738530635834, -0.0007546929409727454, -0.013677123934030533, 0.022069228813052177, 0.045860134065151215, -0.03729677572846413, 0.04621797800064087, 0.0014047158183529973, -0.0027509238570928574, -0.037081148475408554, -0.06514482945203781, -0.002101726131513715, -0.00606623524799943, 0.0616239532828331, -0.05836121737957001, 0.01649244874715805, 0.0038173042703419924, -0.002673446899279952, -0.0487058162689209, 0.008539099246263504, -0.01787615194916725, 0.013902753591537476, 0.019489256665110588, -0.002147277584299445, 0.014908980578184128, -0.0016751205548644066, -0.00787571631371975, 0.07263655960559845, 0.007170266006141901, -0.015383188612759113, 0.029703857377171516, -0.026707954704761505, 0.010541114956140518, -0.020582053810358047, -0.027916142717003822, -0.04976982623338699, -0.03826671838760376, 0.044306088238954544, -0.03833957388997078, -0.006477922201156616, -0.009237737394869328, 0.050582557916641235, 0.02722431905567646, 0.01927483268082142, -0.0006521487957797945, 0.008708211593329906, -0.04927336424589157, 0.005205882713198662, -0.02029445953667164, -0.015053145587444305, 0.002193092368543148, -0.023658927530050278, -0.0034139170311391354, -0.0069235535338521, 0.012451313436031342, 0.014078590087592602, -0.03221499174833298, -0.04996546357870102, 0.020429713651537895, -0.018109923228621483, -0.014505431987345219, 0.04558030143380165, 0.04074078053236008, 0.003224886953830719, -0.02612157352268696, 0.0049850549548864365, 0.06490296870470047, -0.003443175693973899, -0.010274085216224194, 0.03250234201550484, -0.025399258360266685, -0.023505015298724174, 0.0007080828654579818, 0.00010074429155793041, -0.04207521677017212, -0.01304837130010128, 0.04117666557431221, -0.05427404120564461, -0.07541503012180328, 0.005685030482709408, -0.00108713551890105, 0.04920557513833046, 0.048276517540216446, -0.050052300095558167, -0.06934595853090286, -0.025045325979590416, 0.001268114079721272, 0.081819087266922, 0.047690242528915405, 0.039615653455257416, -0.0036461700219660997, -0.003490530187264085, 0.027503658086061478, 0.026048501953482628, 0.03659021854400635, -0.05009498819708824, -0.023179814219474792, 0.03924070671200752, -0.0037113495636731386, 0.012861543335020542, 0.006869738921523094, 0.03486904874444008, 0.015182586386799812, 0.006016083061695099, 0.03749751299619675, -0.02457524836063385, -0.017364930361509323, 0.03389741852879524, -0.024885086342692375, 0.021400464698672295, -0.02254418656229973, -0.06815344840288162, 0.04527619853615761, 0.03423826023936272, -0.000019865674403263256, -0.05219126492738724, -0.038203299045562744, 0.0003110420366283506, 0.04058341309428215, -0.06159007549285889, -0.04567193239927292, 0.008871619589626789, 0.02054428681731224, -0.022232558578252792, -0.047470707446336746, -0.042623598128557205, -0.018083076924085617, -0.020125461742281914, 0.026109332218766212, 0.028305387124419212, -0.010335234925150871, -0.039806436747312546, 0.017353065311908722, 0.020518766716122627, 0.008798695169389248, -0.052973423153162, -0.06682553142309189, 0.04177933931350708, -0.0032482885289937258, -0.017255153506994247, -0.027700373902916908, -0.08728218823671341, 0.03754664957523346, 0.059940438717603683, -0.009018121287226677, 0.005812814459204674, 0.03767331317067146, -0.042388297617435455, -0.012620851397514343, -0.024663260206580162, 0.0424761027097702, -0.053470905870199203, -0.012404282577335835, -0.03489702194929123, -0.03254849091172218, 0.03626500442624092, -0.02495548129081726, 0.015204801224172115, -0.041071031242609024, -0.009353180415928364, -0.019262991845607758, 0.01992451772093773, 0.004381151869893074, 0.033636726438999176, -0.019174471497535706, -0.10470309108495712, 0.01932648755609989, 0.05616026744246483, 0.00011438111687311903, -0.0896056741476059, -0.07892917841672897, -0.01802748627960682, 0.07699345052242279, 0.004927519708871841, 0.0439179353415966, -0.052880555391311646, 0.04541780799627304, -0.04552165046334267, -0.004067341797053814, 0.008297291584312916, -0.0051845102570950985, 0.0035888194106519222, 0.003974951338022947, 0.07693526893854141, 0.0212638508528471, -0.0550454817712307, -0.08803636580705643, 0.008382969535887241, -0.07184445112943649, -0.018109915778040886, -0.01999080553650856, -0.029669634997844696, -0.01944699138402939, -0.014742901548743248, -0.027135809883475304, 0.005481308326125145, 0.0013916343450546265, 0.028765207156538963, 0.05186324939131737, 0.022395562380552292, 0.021250233054161072, -0.04206988215446472, 0.016698436811566353, 0.007236530538648367, -0.010259371250867844, 0.04898901283740997, 0.002341674640774727, 0.07898946106433868, 0.017719708383083344, 0.04966757446527481, -0.031800776720047, 0.03520907461643219, -0.0014062526170164347, -0.033099059015512466, -0.015420704148709774, 0.021718569099903107, -0.010922238230705261, 0.05033396929502487, -0.026858428493142128, -0.02641671895980835, 0.04873694106936455, 0.0179827231913805, -0.015887171030044556, -0.045487795025110245, 0.03513859212398529, 0.052961573004722595, 0.026414785534143448, 0.010531586594879627, 0.06479158997535706, 0.02177388034760952, -0.02632104605436325, -0.009109883569180965, -0.03254329785704613, -0.003829058725386858, 0.019558696076273918, 0.034058406949043274, -0.010869191959500313, -0.00550523865967989, -0.010880554094910622, -0.021889671683311462, 0.01037145871669054, -0.07808929681777954, -0.00699663395062089, -0.0051386384293437, 0.0440649688243866, 0.022753439843654633, -0.02092602476477623, 0.016474248841404915, -0.03664199635386467, -0.023832164704799652, 0.040934059768915176, 0.005745118949562311, 0.014968997798860073, -0.024571062996983528, -0.011305991560220718, 0.0325656421482563, -0.006372407544404268, -0.029901640489697456, 0.027864551171660423, -0.026390649378299713, -0.00501000601798296, -0.04238274320960045, 0.014232003130018711, 0.013342076912522316, -0.023479938507080078, 0.041066497564315796, -0.07293534278869629, 0.03449935466051102, 0.015456244349479675, 0.05812051519751549, 0.014449412934482098, 0.0425310842692852, -0.06651520729064941, 0.04318041354417801, 0.06410744041204453, 0.008015338331460953, 0.023168647661805153, -0.04916032403707504, 0.024267110973596573, -0.011100620962679386, -0.01613098941743374, 0.009937851689755917, 0.012088078074157238, 0.00827738270163536, 0.04977647587656975, -0.005420280620455742, -0.012738972902297974, -0.005453444551676512, 0.014128820039331913, 0.008279587142169476, 0.01038278080523014, -0.0016022584168240428, 0.006910462863743305, -0.007884209975600243, 0.019106462597846985, -0.043129969388246536, -0.04820728674530983, 0.01792212389409542, 0.0026351308915764093, 0.03352266177535057, -0.014678623527288437, -0.0055582704953849316, 0.0017076946096494794, 0.03956138715147972, 0.004723928403109312, -0.020602913573384285, 0.03509914502501488, 0.04377997666597366, 0.0001698012201813981, 0.061203908175230026, -0.07065041363239288, 0.021681440994143486, 0.011951793916523457, -0.03873949870467186, 0.012711557559669018, -0.00046827475307509303, -0.045710913836956024, 0.02383195236325264, -0.037682656198740005, -0.05609463155269623, -0.04040549695491791, 0.007445613853633404, -0.022692939266562462, 0.09597168862819672, -0.014179757796227932, -0.049642160534858704, 0.007273996248841286, -0.00885054562240839, -0.008565491996705532, -0.005093427374958992, -0.017378807067871094, 0.01642671227455139, 0.00763725908473134, -0.011356637813150883, 0.030366795137524605, -0.04233131185173988, -0.01772882603108883, 0.025793857872486115 ]
<p>I am stuck in understanding how the output of convolution operation is obtained. Can somebody please show the steps? The question is an image is processed by applying 3*3 mean filter . What is the impulse response? </p> <p>The formula is $g(m,n) = \sum_{\alpha = 0}^{M-1} \sum_{\beta=0}^{N-1} f(\alpha,\beta)h(m-\alpha,n-\beta)$</p> <p>The image function $f$ =</p> <pre><code> 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 h = 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 </code></pre> <p>The result of the operation (obtained in Matlab) is g(m,n) = </p> <pre><code>0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 3 2 1 0 0 2 4 6 4 2 0 0 3 6 9 6 3 0 0 2 4 6 4 2 0 0 1 2 3 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 </code></pre> <p>I cannot understand the steps how to do it in paper, can somebody please show the few steps how to go about it ?</p> <p>Based on the reply and the formula, I have worked out one example, but the answers don't match with the formula and the other technique. For convolution at pixel f(0,0) the answer = 0. But I am getting 0 using the formula and 1 using the drag method. The cell to which this result will be mapped is g(0,0) and I have put the answer there. </p> <p>For convolution of pixel element at f(1,1) = 1 also, when I evaluated I am getting answer 2 instead of 4. The result should go to g(2,2). But how do I get values for g(5,0) since the original image f has no fifth row!! How to calculate values for fifth and sixth rows? Please let me know what is wrong in my understanding. Is my coordinate system incorrect? Shall really appreciate. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/FKado.jpg" alt="enter image description here"> </p>
g74306
[ 0.008649044670164585, -0.009427210316061974, 0.00541516812518239, -0.022649474442005157, 0.04397134482860565, -0.010310334153473377, 0.05548401176929474, 0.022419411689043045, -0.06978872418403625, -0.027020573616027832, -0.03733769804239273, 0.0377078503370285, 0.008956650272011757, 0.02360643818974495, 0.004876819904893637, 0.0037769402842968702, 0.0668148323893547, 0.04165290296077728, 0.00860346108675003, 0.005695868283510208, 0.014561538584530354, 0.08458418399095535, -0.016235074028372765, -0.013388383202254772, -0.0011869592126458883, 0.025986678898334503, -0.0008593476959504187, 0.04520556330680847, -0.07048392295837402, 0.008087032474577427, 0.013406380079686642, -0.007450066041201353, 0.01752081699669361, -0.014878174290060997, -0.028738684952259064, 0.018627220764756203, 0.09961631149053574, -0.015888893976807594, 0.03949134796857834, 0.007764882408082485, -0.016879700124263763, 0.014505873434245586, 0.04132326319813728, 0.028982313349843025, -0.004380489699542522, 0.007432090118527412, 0.006495938636362553, -0.03712873533368111, 0.0037093134596943855, -0.0031805792823433876, -0.05290022864937782, 0.07059714198112488, 0.0007894824957475066, -0.025022221729159355, -0.050531480461359024, 0.07162758708000183, -0.00586247444152832, -0.020468931645154953, 0.01246695127338171, 0.04704686626791954, 0.0019657257944345474, -0.05205146595835686, 0.020901666954159737, -0.016736071556806564, -0.0014724176144227386, -0.027218634262681007, -0.02893066592514515, -0.013703545555472374, -0.014685723930597305, 0.02883021906018257, -0.01968301646411419, -0.03455929085612297, 0.01086107175797224, -0.028938420116901398, -0.08663112670183182, -0.05005975067615509, 0.04189034923911095, -0.0037380217108875513, -0.03397151827812195, 0.041555192321538925, 0.05295712873339653, -0.030237890779972076, -0.005354816559702158, 0.03470930457115173, -0.018824515864253044, -0.031273141503334045, -0.024671997874975204, 0.0034399116411805153, -0.02533554658293724, -0.023214014247059822, -0.023633433505892754, 0.021992463618516922, 0.02926531806588173, 0.032166630029678345, -0.008182884193956852, -0.05106331780552864, -0.0354081429541111, 0.03983135148882866, 0.012486645020544529, -0.02602330967783928, -0.01712617836892605, 0.0022564860992133617, 0.057161811739206314, -0.03835039585828781, 0.01894957572221756, 0.019829370081424713, 0.08246933668851852, 0.027279894798994064, -0.014374378137290478, -0.04674013331532478, -0.08807585388422012, -0.019310012459754944, -0.02056947723031044, -0.024822374805808067, -0.041092950850725174, -0.02399377152323723, 0.025054654106497765, 0.014929079450666904, 0.006638071034103632, 0.0030980089213699102, 0.012637161649763584, -0.03598650544881821, 0.008239814080297947, 0.048438865691423416, 0.011922188103199005, 0.027591314166784286, -0.005768429487943649, -0.002632845425978303, 0.018528828397393227, 0.029928220435976982, -0.022335238754749298, -0.03300493210554123, 0.03985106199979782, 0.06597273796796799, 0.030156025663018227, 0.012233384884893894, -0.04288588836789131, -0.03235125169157982, 0.011440254747867584, -0.00017589640629012138, -0.06539305299520493, -0.0023628300987184048, -0.011138835921883583, -0.011782101355493069, 0.006370801944285631, -0.013634317554533482, 0.004387599881738424, -0.031489305198192596, 0.010609280318021774, -0.05456293746829033, -0.01063159666955471, 0.05959325656294823, 0.02715916559100151, -0.01841970533132553, 0.05234956368803978, -0.026358895003795624, 0.001556686474941671, 0.059895582497119904, -0.04249296709895134, 0.0020586997270584106, 0.06239144504070282, -0.024719299748539925, -0.006098264828324318, 0.012623714283108711, -0.06332471966743469, 0.00020092549675609916, 0.006819573696702719, -0.1162850633263588, -0.007633106783032417, -0.08480033278465271, 0.014164591208100319, 0.05301445722579956, 0.03187797963619232, -0.03677468001842499, 0.02783946320414543, 0.042932212352752686, 0.06564544141292572, -0.010012233629822731, 0.018665147945284843, 0.03984719142317772, -0.014767725020647049, 0.03202158957719803, -0.012423836626112461, -0.07286354899406433, 0.04000631719827652, -0.04265053570270538, -0.019206292927265167, -0.018147023394703865, 0.004425555933266878, 0.004834284074604511, 0.03262019157409668, 0.0351615734398365, 0.03294815495610237, -0.02150433324277401, -0.030192598700523376, 0.0525161549448967, 0.005555714480578899, -0.026692524552345276, -0.021371060982346535, -0.03648646920919418, -0.012018603272736073, -0.024003490805625916, 0.022358212620019913, 0.08391397446393967, -0.04953910782933235, 0.026537641882896423, -0.020130347460508347, 0.017013758420944214, -0.03519618138670921, 0.00021865444432478398, -0.04398014396429062, -0.004282459616661072, -0.01029896643012762, 0.018545331433415413, -0.024061664938926697, 0.01422172598540783, 0.0899931862950325, -0.009401592426002026, -0.02863519825041294, 0.05521959438920021, -0.012482082471251488, -0.03768731281161308, 0.010636376217007637, -0.020840667188167572, 0.0069957030937075615, 0.037984028458595276, 0.020591339096426964, -0.04185754805803299, 0.009064821526408195, 0.04757585749030113, -0.07310356944799423, -0.012010682374238968, -0.03866610676050186, -0.02611854299902916, 0.014217888936400414, 0.048726681619882584, 0.003411998273804784, 0.05198078975081444, -0.029250402003526688, 0.09111780673265457, 0.009968775324523449, 0.007814290001988411, 0.017726514488458633, -0.032615236937999725, 0.005845614243298769, 0.0012378402752801776, 0.046328894793987274, -0.0178535059094429, -0.006777804810553789, -0.030933260917663574, 0.004093272611498833, 0.02318553626537323, 0.017202362418174744, -0.014116538688540459, 0.0077973175793886185, -0.02226983569562435, 0.036517199128866196, 0.015426834113895893, 0.003858172567561269, 0.07248193025588989, -0.07567831873893738, 0.016605181619524956, -0.026769567281007767, 0.031454239040613174, -0.0033490166533738375, -0.02200937643647194, -0.0022805281914770603, -0.015314077027142048, 0.0333230160176754, -0.044099949300289154, -0.004095498472452164, 0.005495565477758646, 0.00218450790271163, 0.001300712814554572, 0.012092318385839462, 0.06829793751239777, 0.017558814957737923, -0.04319284111261368, 0.01228541973978281, -0.022926654666662216, -0.02873719111084938, -0.05583092197775841, -0.02770254574716091, -0.0034341251011937857, -0.000603859662078321, -0.03602873533964157, 0.04506180062890053, 0.025283297523856163, 0.06324582546949387, -0.03203332796692848, -0.06275162845849991, -0.0008751287823542953, -0.0639752522110939, -0.06553935259580612, -0.02674652636051178, 0.06097031012177467, 0.030953584238886833, -0.044151049107313156, 0.06189814209938049, 0.003727711969986558, -0.05939922854304314, 0.024669719859957695, -0.004136961884796619, -0.06633691489696503, 0.08077537268400192, -0.004903725348412991, 0.029179595410823822, -0.03872217237949371, -0.0454137921333313, 0.03384588658809662, 0.005362159106880426, -0.01644304022192955, -0.05371527373790741, -0.06985893100500107, 0.03461042419075966, -0.032458964735269547, -0.03662652522325516, -0.0070196278393268585, -0.014733806252479553, 0.041322674602270126, -0.052393991500139236, -0.023773543536663055, -0.04859131947159767, -0.040358949452638626, -0.017374025657773018, 0.047161802649497986, -0.00301619921810925, 0.026288745924830437, 0.07473114132881165, 0.013237870298326015, 0.012462452054023743, 0.034632571041584015, -0.03456316515803337, -0.012876628898084164, 0.03146562725305557, -0.04338381811976433, -0.00249256263487041, 0.06202155724167824, 0.048471298068761826, 0.002677375450730324, -0.007554361131042242, -0.052911706268787384, -0.07593752443790436, -0.04157726466655731, 0.012099532410502434, 0.0021714926697313786, -0.04077012091875076, 0.05395279452204704, -0.006338102743029594, 0.014482691884040833, 0.007762441411614418, 0.036382194608449936, -0.005190057680010796, -0.008401542901992798, 0.022292042151093483, 0.08975303918123245, -0.024222446605563164, -0.004400214646011591, -0.015420394949615002, 0.018526097759604454, -0.03155587986111641, -0.003396302927285433, -0.006958089303225279, 0.016837939620018005, 0.01569990999996662, 0.008901819586753845, 0.0176633782684803, 0.08216001093387604, -0.021935906261205673, -0.026943042874336243, 0.022316915914416313, -0.05739525333046913, -0.01183021254837513, -0.00883280485868454, -0.056992366909980774, -0.0622539296746254, 0.005638688337057829, 0.02753695286810398, -0.0007996189524419606, 0.040690287947654724, 0.06795758008956909, -0.007042215671390295, -0.011463900096714497, 0.029099537059664726, 0.007703910581767559, -0.024661144241690636, 0.03119623102247715, -0.015198969282209873, 0.040553946048021317, -0.010171633213758469, 0.01514431182295084, -0.0348978191614151, -0.021216413006186485, -0.020623449236154556, 0.04155763238668442, -0.0072149476036429405, 0.005266170017421246, 0.027063170447945595, -0.05631638318300247, 0.01948295347392559, 0.01741952821612358, 0.009879359975457191, 0.06056381016969681, 0.03602544590830803, -0.05078380927443504, -0.007067353930324316, -0.00642360420897603, -0.03661229833960533, 0.03827502578496933, 0.019310636445879936, -0.04250769689679146, -0.018311509862542152, 0.036798782646656036, -0.05294645205140114, 0.0459868349134922, 0.03281491994857788, 0.05931244418025017, 0.006129529792815447, -0.0397409163415432, 0.006774294190108776, 0.07153447717428207, 0.06726729869842529, -0.044811442494392395, -0.04117323458194733, -0.020302986726164818, 0.07331373542547226, 0.005270479712635279, -0.029407046735286713, 0.033582236617803574, 0.010963574051856995, 0.07311992347240448, 0.019105900079011917, 0.0035580634139478207, 0.07438856363296509, -0.07561434060335159, 0.04581340402364731, -0.05485665053129196, 0.011289386078715324, 0.005279621109366417, 0.009112441912293434, 0.02888346090912819, -0.022542797029018402, -0.017956538125872612, 0.03493284806609154, 0.008556405082345009, 0.06465758383274078, -0.0069313314743340015, -0.035441409796476364, -0.0010163134429603815, 0.0675923153758049, -0.011839702725410461, -0.007647830527275801, -0.050301507115364075, -0.018980037420988083, 0.007428836077451706, 0.047569457441568375, 0.007984094321727753, -0.03386591002345085, -0.03939671814441681, 0.02100394107401371, -0.007955142296850681, 0.05681931599974632, -0.024707689881324768, -0.017101261764764786, 0.02636581100523472, -0.00041138389497064054, -0.021829769015312195, -0.006365241948515177, 0.006986192427575588, -0.05928400531411171, 0.014276079833507538, -0.027492864057421684, 0.022137319669127464, -0.013764210045337677, 0.013898718170821667, 0.05089079961180687, -0.0006801037234254181, 0.048231929540634155, 0.03799154609441757, 0.0225380826741457, -0.023249881342053413, -0.02397734299302101, 0.021034853532910347, -0.032990895211696625, -0.007369703613221645, 0.04642847180366516, -0.008376264944672585, -0.002382300328463316, -0.009470553137362003, 0.012578246183693409, 0.0038780695758759975, 0.06016181781888008, 0.04842543229460716, -0.0039781988598406315, 0.011544864624738693, -0.05815734341740608, 0.031948272138834, 0.06363167613744736, 0.010240931063890457, 0.003637034213170409, 0.005048071965575218, -0.06350736320018768, -0.05549820885062218, -0.005532366223633289, -0.00010764646140160039, -0.0491131953895092, 0.034628480672836304, -0.037667714059352875, 0.04553098976612091, 0.046194590628147125, 0.020463239401578903, -0.028333228081464767, 0.0173433069139719, -0.023245567455887794, -0.09071005135774612, -0.0606684684753418, 0.03400032967329025, 0.032394133508205414, -0.042050935328006744, 0.01003812626004219, 0.05988030135631561, 0.010390168987214565, 0.0035479681100696325, 0.015995793044567108, 0.02579611726105213, -0.038835905492305756, 0.0276930034160614, -0.04919074848294258, 0.009079615585505962, 0.004308758303523064, -0.06610226631164551, -0.007274096366018057, -0.036007512360811234, -0.004373722709715366, 0.008356171660125256, -0.04483405128121376, 0.007656840607523918, 0.017589686438441277, 0.02100021205842495, 0.014402675442397594, -0.0045933774672448635, 0.03439792990684509, -0.056134000420570374, 0.018349584192037582, -0.020423127338290215, -0.003890254767611623, 0.010606255382299423, -0.013483027927577496, -0.002549329772591591, -0.017905475571751595, -0.00343354232609272, -0.004433156922459602, 0.006302875932306051, -0.012369698844850063, 0.01167837530374527, 0.05030865594744682, -0.03345073014497757, -0.04074636474251747, 0.01351524144411087, 0.012321238406002522, 0.020860858261585236, -0.008776722475886345, -0.016519447788596153, -0.03413195163011551, 0.02954949252307415, -0.009922538883984089, 0.0373099260032177, 0.03992445766925812, -0.06014598160982132, -0.04112793505191803, -0.06275538355112076, -0.048363760113716125, 0.006461990997195244, 0.010252258740365505, 0.020429352298378944, 0.0467107929289341, 0.015560244210064411, -0.04322297126054764, -0.02505902573466301, 0.036259569227695465, 0.025182757526636124, -0.008819409646093845, -0.0418408028781414, 0.010395140387117863, -0.011516939848661423, 0.05233992636203766, 0.020384661853313446, -0.006056416779756546, 0.007721700239926577, -0.04609609395265579, -0.015808207914233208, 0.014665573835372925, 0.00502858217805624, 0.04411643370985985, 0.027623053640127182, -0.04818791151046753, 0.021490000188350677, 0.00901707075536251, 0.0026199049316346645, -0.006251729093492031, -0.02220934070646763, 0.0306240227073431, 0.06096510589122772, -0.07887066155672073, -0.034519705921411514, -0.019519278779625893, -0.04469841346144676, -0.035628486424684525, -0.03197179734706879, 0.003633506828919053, -0.011486603878438473, 0.0149705084040761, 0.026127157732844353, 0.02866189181804657, 0.0017043479019775987, 0.012591888196766376, -0.02618391253054142, -0.0014934369828552008, 0.05191870778799057, -0.0009717414504848421, -0.04442624747753143, 0.006119471043348312, 0.03271951153874397, -0.0029509062878787518, 0.06815844029188156, 0.018397867679595947, -0.0034555888269096613, -0.010804715566337109, 0.03386061266064644, 0.054266028106212616, -0.02602815441787243, -0.008268987759947777, 0.0051409779116511345, 0.03989168256521225, -0.0714649111032486, 0.02162785641849041, 0.02121286652982235, 0.11966004222631454, 0.0023003106471151114, 0.06681428849697113, 0.017211373895406723, 0.03214676305651665, 0.012879655696451664, -0.03738654777407646, -0.07378873974084854, -0.021066242828965187, 0.03849909454584122, 0.008651716634631157, -0.12162492424249649, -0.028972696512937546, -0.021370800212025642, -0.007852313108742237, 0.013120429590344429, 0.03128800913691521, -0.0378141812980175, 0.0630236491560936, 0.048816096037626266, -0.020751431584358215, 0.014000638388097286, -0.043152548372745514, -0.054248418658971786, -0.060815442353487015, -0.083394356071949, 0.032153740525245667, 0.06318668276071548, 0.04816655442118645, -0.017517708241939545, -0.005437210202217102, 0.03554515913128853, -0.06310424953699112, 0.004904552362859249, -0.04014017432928085, 0.014151843264698982, 0.06888164579868317, 0.014553027227520943, -0.017847815528512, 0.010123081505298615, 0.04790084436535835, -0.06681469827890396, 0.015931718051433563, -0.028691649436950684, 0.040488000959157944, -0.029139883816242218, -0.05754558742046356, -0.0025050921831279993, -0.0029384589288383722, -0.037095651030540466, -0.016210105270147324, 0.007988914847373962, -0.017713487148284912, -0.022924495860934258, 0.04056030139327049, -0.02051352709531784, -0.01234893873333931, 0.016844898462295532, 0.012133910320699215, 0.004345298279076815, 0.018616795539855957, 0.009180781431496143, 0.07457105070352554, 0.09246938675642014, -0.03229893743991852, -0.004699411801993847, -0.01507138554006815, -0.07396113872528076, -0.015523618087172508, -0.0036656614392995834, 0.033050671219825745, -0.015895286574959755, 0.00015858424012549222, -0.04773624986410141, -0.0580858550965786, -0.0482112318277359, 0.006427606102079153, 0.023460811004042625, 0.05929180979728699, -0.051371101289987564, 0.0030853680800646544, -0.095198854804039, 0.021156208589673042, -0.008578152395784855, 0.001597320195287466, -0.01731931045651436, -0.04126688838005066, -0.032423779368400574, 0.04392135515809059, 0.00173485919367522, 0.014301320537924767, 0.02110608108341694, -0.016385339200496674, -0.015012485906481743, -0.07497037947177887, -0.0820218026638031, 0.004218305926769972, -0.012854862958192825, 0.0022509717382490635, 0.0681433156132698, -0.034342166036367416, 0.016751181334257126, 0.03794778883457184, -0.0043799374252557755, 0.025330722332000732, 0.00977590586990118, -0.0029841207433491945, 0.020545773208141327, 0.03515580669045448, -0.06743397563695908, 0.017345933243632317, 0.022467833012342453, -0.04165588691830635, -0.005728492047637701, 0.036430247128009796, 0.02035554125905037, 0.04741260036826134, -0.0027874361258000135, -0.003919599112123251, -0.009481226094067097, 0.001144072855822742, 0.09835053980350494, -0.04663420841097832, -0.035587381571531296, -0.02174544520676136, -0.019452279433608055, 0.02812635339796543, 0.023546438664197922, -0.038810502737760544, -0.05750320479273796, -0.03744816407561302 ]
<p>Imagine I have a time series for an animal population and a time series for a climatic variable during the same time period and at the same location. Unfortunately the data are observational (i.e., no experimental manipulation). Now imagine there is a decreasing linear trend in both variables (and no seasonality).</p> <p>I know before hand that these variables will be correlated because they share a time trend (e.g.,<a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/8037/38125">http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/8037/38125</a>). But is there anything more I can infer from this data? </p> <p>I am looking for a rather low-level conceptual explanation as to whether this is possible and why.</p> <p>I have 2 thoughts on how this might be accomplished, but haven't figured on my own if either would be valid.... 1) Regress population against both time and the climate variable, or 2) "Detrend" both 'population' and 'climate variable' and regress their residuals against each other</p> <p>I can provide more detail if necessary but wanted to keep this original post brief. Thanks for your help! </p>
g37141
[ 0.05837943032383919, -0.09274809062480927, 0.005575322080403566, -0.01557436678558588, 0.012871632352471352, 0.0016528457636013627, -0.002379543147981167, 0.0073292432352900505, -0.049615465104579926, -0.023516660556197166, -0.01310750376433134, 0.04574427753686905, 0.008795136585831642, -0.00624840660020709, -0.017949022352695465, 0.04323562607169151, -0.012609624303877354, -0.0005276994779706001, 0.044785987585783005, 0.03493296355009079, 0.023633163422346115, -0.0007633327040821314, 0.07409867644309998, 0.0019437893060967326, -0.014180590398609638, -0.01446016225963831, 0.015876302495598793, 0.04166560620069504, -0.05374367907643318, -0.026977121829986572, 0.08242698758840561, -0.0076921540312469006, 0.026717334985733032, 0.010663946159183979, 0.00019224302377551794, -0.017903313040733337, 0.007501878309994936, -0.04573262855410576, 0.0264228954911232, 0.02676074020564556, 0.05680150166153908, 0.01584341935813427, 0.04724357649683952, 0.037202827632427216, -0.009918714873492718, 0.034559447318315506, -0.05338384956121445, -0.043376196175813675, -0.011317315511405468, -0.04331519454717636, -0.00239212391898036, 0.07702475786209106, -0.017261184751987457, 0.004001478664577007, -0.0007774949190206826, -0.04572086036205292, 0.04878143221139908, -0.0013671990018337965, 0.0261381808668375, -0.03309166058897972, -0.005378081928938627, 0.025431538000702858, -0.008891730569303036, 0.02128767967224121, 0.03979668766260147, 0.01982799358665943, -0.0034963495563715696, -0.04022298380732536, 0.04778410866856575, -0.05904422327876091, 0.0075293052941560745, -0.028893783688545227, 0.006638329476118088, -0.013683347031474113, -0.007291292306035757, -0.0016844376223161817, -0.004141316283494234, -0.03123544529080391, 0.03897616267204285, -0.001043211668729782, -0.030975935980677605, 0.0361345112323761, -0.06853684782981873, 0.06636606156826019, 0.06095518916845322, -0.013203545473515987, 0.040390267968177795, -0.014157736673951149, -0.01716555468738079, -0.020824048668146133, -0.004115554038435221, 0.027943775057792664, 0.08117123693227768, 0.06732784956693649, -0.034492820501327515, 0.01574476808309555, -0.05365084484219551, 0.04527250677347183, 0.023056555539369583, 0.027622966095805168, -0.01793799176812172, 0.02796235866844654, 0.020488154143095016, -0.030391251668334007, -0.0721377357840538, -0.0660339891910553, 0.048130545765161514, -0.047983407974243164, -0.06436391174793243, -0.00019099113706033677, -0.04331723228096962, -0.014911987818777561, -0.03447675332427025, 0.006499794777482748, -0.009800930507481098, -0.09513208270072937, -0.007332625798881054, 0.005586619954556227, -0.02472284995019436, 0.005115034524351358, 0.01685379259288311, 0.056680161505937576, 0.006895014084875584, 0.054852839559316635, -0.036860447376966476, 0.011625959537923336, -0.007488420698791742, 0.015936609357595444, 0.05885911360383034, -0.002186661818996072, 0.007056723348796368, 0.033181291073560715, 0.02626059018075466, 0.06431595236063004, 0.016036979854106903, 0.006005515344440937, -0.05147872492671013, 0.05011479929089546, -0.026219245046377182, 0.04025130346417427, 0.02373376302421093, 0.028636161237955093, 0.013494549319148064, 0.016801442950963974, -0.04401780292391777, 0.032152242958545685, -0.03442206606268883, -0.019835742190480232, 0.0344909131526947, 0.011127474717795849, 0.017131876200437546, 0.06717647612094879, -0.03568277508020401, 0.03383832797408104, -0.029179111123085022, 0.028484124690294266, -0.0352148562669754, -0.040464457124471664, -0.040580980479717255, 0.01645883359014988, 0.01463337056338787, -0.0703050047159195, 0.03155268356204033, -0.015271402895450592, 0.018536487594246864, -0.01628471352159977, -0.011990683153271675, -0.02240297570824623, -0.04193183034658432, -0.014492052607238293, -0.033004745841026306, 0.004183484707027674, -0.022694755345582962, -0.0070688617415726185, 0.04330182075500488, -0.015161535702645779, 0.03527691215276718, -0.043730467557907104, -0.04180284962058067, -0.016709141433238983, 0.013903822749853134, 0.030789319425821304, -0.004402254242449999, -0.024878842756152153, 0.06181558594107628, -0.02090919204056263, 0.03209436684846878, 0.02883402816951275, -0.08462090790271759, -0.020111745223402977, 0.00711011653766036, -0.05167235806584358, 0.003123874543234706, 0.03545979782938957, 0.009329523891210556, -0.01231356617063284, 0.03198748081922531, -0.011636601760983467, -0.018457239493727684, 0.028864052146673203, -0.004845854826271534, -0.030487999320030212, -0.00409232173115015, -0.0030213159043341875, -0.06767415255308151, -0.000995551934465766, -0.00037884662742726505, -0.04574151709675789, 0.015856081619858742, -0.009237422607839108, -0.02052408829331398, -0.025974346324801445, -0.06573810428380966, 0.017936890944838524, -0.027633262798190117, -0.004634462296962738, 0.00005454458369058557, 0.0038599406834691763, 0.026515519246459007, 0.021610869094729424, -0.052789751440286636, 0.040189579129219055, -0.0377173125743866, 0.024743584915995598, 0.015213849022984505, 0.019358279183506966, -0.006433594040572643, 0.025894155725836754, -0.023995989933609962, 0.00031925621442496777, -0.010754500515758991, 0.03154920041561127, -0.035884834825992584, -0.03016199916601181, 0.044086795300245285, 0.04771975055336952, 0.06704523414373398, 0.003226563800126314, -0.025168366730213165, 0.043394722044467926, -0.046546824276447296, -0.026286786422133446, -0.028088727965950966, 0.04443329945206642, 0.08130358904600143, -0.045571014285087585, 0.02994481846690178, 0.009765475057065487, 0.04797360673546791, 0.019428908824920654, 0.002750556217506528, 0.04025762528181076, -0.007742019835859537, -0.0335693359375, 0.02321247197687626, -0.03966932371258736, -0.02562698721885681, 0.08865321427583694, -0.039342962205410004, -0.017230356112122536, 0.017931247130036354, 0.010042105801403522, -0.008608845062553883, 0.034890007227659225, 0.035676516592502594, -0.10446589440107346, 0.016564873978495598, 0.004483568482100964, -0.05136483162641525, -0.027172764763236046, -0.03343883901834488, -0.01756288856267929, 0.04573735594749451, 0.06903968751430511, -0.042074594646692276, 0.05191629379987717, -0.018623018637299538, -0.027130786329507828, 0.049714989960193634, -0.014189735054969788, 0.0952194556593895, -0.03352414816617966, -0.03615381196141243, 0.003445042297244072, 0.045351091772317886, -0.03172972798347473, 0.03968021646142006, 0.07494408637285233, -0.0012776211369782686, 0.026482826098799706, 0.015865754336118698, -0.015888068825006485, 0.011544019915163517, 0.033746570348739624, -0.001637123990803957, 0.02159920707345009, 0.007130651734769344, -0.054443441331386566, 0.04995259642601013, 0.04463527724146843, -0.014938325621187687, -0.08146155625581741, 0.019612319767475128, 0.018263893201947212, 0.07864412665367126, -0.022332079708576202, -0.04347996413707733, -0.012482602149248123, 0.014617825858294964, -0.03924175351858139, -0.012820955365896225, 0.03281627222895622, 0.016509177163243294, 0.01430638786405325, -0.02719215489923954, -0.007965638302266598, -0.002026157220825553, 0.026221470907330513, 0.05745772644877434, -0.016216091811656952, 0.023098058998584747, -0.0298150684684515, 0.00630551902577281, 0.04254328832030296, 0.03187732771039009, 0.027837960049510002, -0.07341324537992477, 0.02626379393041134, -0.07167303562164307, 0.015354501083493233, 0.01377067156136036, -0.0007522543892264366, 0.01648719795048237, -0.06461695581674576, -0.0017507373122498393, 0.008895915932953358, 0.008366434834897518, -0.0027121948078274727, -0.029084384441375732, 0.04336630925536156, -0.007742429152131081, 0.039345141500234604, -0.012771403416991234, 0.036855973303318024, 0.0032784088980406523, 0.025712644681334496, 0.028778400272130966, 0.008733435533940792, -0.012542429380118847, 0.024788670241832733, -0.002225333359092474, -0.0538078211247921, 0.07318370044231415, -0.010775490663945675, -0.007096530869603157, -0.05007365345954895, 0.010407083667814732, 0.008315631188452244, 0.021540623158216476, -0.036353595554828644, -0.0168099794536829, -0.054420940577983856, -0.00947536714375019, -0.011151811107993126, 0.0064857276156544685, 0.006272834725677967, 0.028144748881459236, 0.09231206029653549, 0.018253358080983162, -0.004634606186300516, -0.009571502916514874, 0.04923298954963684, -0.0330362468957901, -0.05155634507536888, -0.01765015907585621, -0.028274035081267357, 0.04160723090171814, 0.04985063150525093, -0.04365577548742294, 0.08438654989004135, 0.0625016838312149, -0.006602635607123375, 0.02499009296298027, 0.036013707518577576, -0.0013261274434626102, -0.07267097383737564, 0.003475555218756199, 0.009454315528273582, -0.018974443897604942, -0.022906722500920296, 0.019388282671570778, 0.01706327311694622, -0.0031956457532942295, 0.04019114747643471, 0.03440295532345772, 0.037318650633096695, 0.019924359396100044, 0.02118193730711937, 0.03273536264896393, -0.0044187018647789955, -0.02397712878882885, 0.01314197015017271, 0.020742420107126236, 0.041801176965236664, -0.03596414253115654, 0.012545375153422356, 0.04271305724978447, 0.013355487026274204, -0.06051013618707657, -0.05477213114500046, -0.04444814473390579, 0.01878003589808941, -0.027170943096280098, -0.02857915498316288, 0.010125077329576015, 0.014008023776113987, 0.062268100678920746, -0.013163074851036072, 0.03728405758738518, 0.019595012068748474, -0.04927923157811165, 0.06263422220945358, -0.028843220323324203, 0.02340966835618019, -0.014494601637125015, -0.020778369158506393, -0.03115806169807911, -0.03696339204907417, -0.04822835698723793, -0.04192623496055603, 0.029260223731398582, -0.006987228058278561, 0.023207416757941246, -0.021863168105483055, 0.041400063782930374, 0.032322704792022705, -0.006472651846706867, 0.024178802967071533, 0.005729751195758581, -0.0700647234916687, -0.016208961606025696, -0.07260797172784805, -0.01096637174487114, 0.04003605991601944, -0.06379379332065582, 0.09242693334817886, 0.007459688000380993, -0.05121832340955734, 0.023037822917103767, 0.0015288559952750802, 0.01778247207403183, 0.07059941440820694, -0.020554445683956146, -0.02280709333717823, 0.008911200799047947, -0.03595809265971184, 0.023036185652017593, 0.06628559529781342, -0.003529028035700321, 0.0006646712427027524, -0.010856912471354008, 0.0009233380551449955, -0.016779672354459763, -0.052999675273895264, -0.010826491750776768, -0.050179313868284225, 0.009550791233778, -0.05157831683754921, 0.04441259428858757, 0.026009250432252884, -0.03811022266745567, -0.011354579590260983, -0.01315344963222742, 0.04553660377860069, 0.03398535028100014, -0.060621149837970734, 0.027518056333065033, -0.07183577120304108, 0.06093911454081535, 0.00009852418588707224, -0.05036323890089989, -0.030986912548542023, 0.0036039266269654036, -0.01567811332643032, -0.030216805636882782, -0.012965083122253418, -0.037627212703228, -0.06619127094745636, 0.013020217418670654, -0.0019803063478320837, 0.00009825764573179185, -0.008117452263832092, 0.09838609397411346, 0.051048845052719116, -0.0243111290037632, -0.02603832632303238, -0.008184874430298805, -0.04311482235789299, -0.000766257697250694, -0.04549988731741905, 0.0064061651937663555, 0.016579603776335716, -0.011160792782902718, 0.037517715245485306, 0.007431210950016975, -0.005835670977830887, 0.09281394630670547, -0.00844630878418684, 0.02724335342645645, 0.08632195740938187, -0.02822972647845745, 0.0336897149682045, 0.01380817499011755, 0.006227994803339243, -0.002313207369297743, -0.009066523984074593, -0.012543629854917526, -0.01885468326508999, -0.007722380105406046, -0.0790584534406662, 0.028462301939725876, 0.030208420008420944, 0.008474530652165413, 0.025488603860139847, -0.0012936486164107919, -0.0779840275645256, -0.041066307574510574, 0.0031315244268625975, -0.03475005552172661, -0.03746297210454941, -0.01795538142323494, 0.01973101496696472, -0.001036170870065689, -0.031223103404045105, 0.0023648240603506565, -0.003645283868536353, -0.049443915486335754, 0.04164305701851845, 0.022666065022349358, -0.011834890581667423, -0.04314061626791954, -0.03601996973156929, 0.05113901570439339, 0.000018260077922604978, -0.0008520477567799389, -0.039278995245695114, -0.023213297128677368, -0.0051262578926980495, 0.025853566825389862, 0.018853718414902687, -0.009874197654426098, -0.008412941358983517, -0.02490074746310711, 0.0007596666691824794, 0.009692749939858913, 0.0244199950248003, 0.0537421815097332, 0.025052547454833984, -0.011096521280705929, 0.015874264761805534, 0.010176357813179493, -0.024809161201119423, 0.04479609429836273, 0.036520540714263916, 0.001936427317559719, -0.0047298152931034565, -0.04740811511874199, -0.001581008080393076, 0.03126547485589981, -0.01016417145729065, 0.07015442103147507, -0.04756193980574608, -0.008115643635392189, -0.014439426362514496, -0.017602983862161636, 0.0042218854650855064, -0.02512342296540737, 0.002269467804580927, 0.02182985097169876, -0.03134499862790108, 0.007712365593761206, -0.0863175317645073, -0.03784549981355667, -0.005382908042520285, -0.014656664803624153, 0.030497269704937935, -0.022542038932442665, 0.010721678845584393, -0.0014457820216193795, 0.010256714187562466, -0.02233145199716091, -0.017889369279146194, -0.011011640541255474, -0.021429674699902534, -0.040393099188804626, -0.062063779681921005, -0.0028596038464456797, 0.005054227542132139, -0.008747819811105728, -0.018827306106686592, 0.007154206279665232, 0.0059468927793204784, 0.07533036917448044, 0.008029185235500336, -0.03078368864953518, 0.00941590964794159, -0.003141637658700347, 0.025521105155348778, 0.0581330731511116, -0.0050665996968746185, -0.06371878832578659, 0.0211392380297184, 0.06567982584238052, 0.05126660689711571, 0.017773369327187538, 0.0004042048240080476, -0.04067181795835495, 0.049867551773786545, -0.0874616950750351, 0.012869439087808132, 0.07057429850101471, -0.030498456209897995, -0.04820062220096588, -0.04987451061606407, -0.0014400755753740668, 0.05967620387673378, -0.06272439658641815, 0.012782302685081959, 0.06774716079235077, -0.011985495686531067, -0.011529382318258286, -0.0018410655902698636, 0.008356305770576, 0.006354760844260454, -0.019844641909003258, 0.04466599225997925, -0.04644615575671196, 0.0788823664188385, -0.010800603777170181, -0.03988758102059364, 0.01942356675863266, 0.0542043037712574, -0.03932489827275276, 0.024492954835295677, 0.003028745064511895, 0.01952293887734413, 0.0012225030222907662, -0.03906356915831566, -0.01872675120830536, -0.01603630557656288, 0.010217039845883846, -0.02242457866668701, -0.009121913462877274, -0.013488599099218845, 0.050202626734972, 0.043203551322221756, -0.013843596912920475, -0.0013331122463569045, 0.05884739011526108, 0.051357969641685486, -0.08265653997659683, -0.06043888255953789, -0.06716939061880112, -0.005857374053448439, 0.013242258690297604, 0.07530838251113892, 0.022390499711036682, -0.04349740222096443, 0.017268674448132515, -0.037505850195884705, 0.021302638575434685, -0.056902121752500534, 0.018389767035841942, 0.023067735135555267, 0.014908909797668457, -0.008924344554543495, -0.004384494852274656, 0.0033451078925281763, 0.006023907568305731, 0.019531238824129105, 0.028756773099303246, -0.03799553960561752, -0.002663719467818737, -0.02092605084180832, -0.016208427026867867, 0.0780201107263565, -0.0007652954664081335, -0.01849242113530636, -0.005010281689465046, -0.061834365129470825, -0.0941937193274498, -0.001616384368389845, -0.03634706884622574, 0.020499739795923233, -0.033029232174158096, 0.03267292305827141, 0.02502564713358879, 0.00022098781482782215, -0.06318222731351852, 0.03795904293656349, 0.013955419883131981, 0.04642447084188461, -0.018819276243448257, -0.013506762683391571, 0.03699713945388794, -0.040891893208026886, -0.042067863047122955, -0.05281045287847519, -0.05039998143911362, -0.031582463532686234, -0.04483906924724579, 0.026311155408620834, -0.006213942542672157, 0.023085258901119232, 0.012551162391901016, -0.04532637074589729, -0.00563926761969924, -0.008301646448671818, -0.020498596131801605, -0.0064668054692447186, -0.10713434219360352, -0.0499335341155529, 0.041864246129989624, -0.09293331950902939, -0.0607483834028244, -0.00832004752010107, 0.0014864809345453978, -0.004322393331676722, 0.03550287336111069, 0.019381310790777206, 0.013975365087389946, -0.012234862893819809, -0.04691138491034508, -0.014861630275845528, 0.09185304492712021, 0.02111094817519188, 0.010603350587189198, 0.0611179918050766, -0.05689677596092224, 0.017779316753149033, -0.06409510225057602, 0.046236373484134674, 0.016687335446476936, -0.015744922682642937, 0.02153090015053749, -0.04182692989706993, 0.019141392782330513, 0.05974310636520386, -0.003240375081077218, -0.06383924186229706, -0.019744792953133583, 0.0063827261328697205, -0.07005546987056732, 0.002147120889276266, 0.0581807903945446, 0.01406448520720005, -0.047826796770095825, 0.03593623265624046, 0.003865811275318265, 0.00934902485460043, -0.0024750963784754276, 0.011515110731124878, -0.031282976269721985, 0.0034219599328935146, -0.035881802439689636, 0.024406492710113525, 0.007683902978897095, 0.03457837924361229 ]
<p>I was wondering if anyone could help me on how to interpret the coefficient from an analysis I have carried out in R (<code>survival</code> package). </p> <p>The data is right censored, the dependent variable (time to event) was modelled under the gaussian distribution and the independent variable is a categorical variable (3 categories). </p> <p>my output is as follows:</p> <pre><code>coeff se p-value -0.107 0.048 2.7x10-2 </code></pre> <p>Can anyone tell me how to interpret this coefficient under the following model?</p>
g37142
[ -0.048627082258462906, -0.060834258794784546, -0.009018173441290855, 0.01350825559347868, 0.028801552951335907, 0.0018685959512367845, 0.019068744033575058, 0.04427273944020271, -0.06026655063033104, 0.042111579328775406, -0.036920517683029175, -0.00125535624101758, 0.07363927364349365, 0.030367350205779076, 0.02350948378443718, -0.012930608354508877, 0.02577633038163185, 0.004405714105814695, -0.02720547281205654, 0.013892811723053455, -0.005260082893073559, -0.014400399290025234, 0.056664422154426575, -0.007731839548796415, 0.026218973100185394, -0.010261990129947662, 0.05292002484202385, 0.055007945746183395, -0.11093947291374207, 0.01901228539645672, -0.003819888224825263, 0.03799723833799362, -0.0017032137839123607, -0.06260865181684494, -0.028294337913393974, -0.041269659996032715, 0.03638535365462303, 0.06482832133769989, 0.004541683942079544, 0.028732676059007645, 0.0069594839587807655, -0.0037431013770401478, 0.06723342835903168, 0.010046256706118584, 0.02731354348361492, 0.06766725331544876, -0.033757492899894714, 0.019859226420521736, 0.015263237059116364, -0.03050641342997551, -0.0028980481438338757, 0.058036841452121735, 0.0036158179864287376, -0.005071606021374464, 0.07718081027269363, 0.01003274880349636, -0.02337011694908142, -0.019818652421236038, -0.016360659152269363, 0.0097566619515419, 0.016282226890325546, -0.004709895700216293, -0.10248307883739471, -0.03745085373520851, 0.07084773480892181, -0.015652067959308624, -0.004233529791235924, -0.02363653853535652, -0.01173247117549181, -0.03846796974539757, 0.013934576883912086, -0.0227641724050045, -0.04539624974131584, -0.02994249202311039, 0.0036509158089756966, -0.02088138461112976, 0.010303590446710587, 0.03173702210187912, -0.01155395619571209, 0.03707689791917801, -0.020445723086595535, -0.006619994528591633, -0.018001727759838104, 0.010338777676224709, 0.029896678403019905, -0.04189322143793106, 0.01628914661705494, 0.010350505821406841, 0.004362090025097132, 0.006977006793022156, 0.016454029828310013, -0.019103296101093292, 0.0006426155450753868, 0.04436806961894035, 0.017654458060860634, 0.006837386172264814, -0.11443765461444855, 0.025844918563961983, 0.010421216487884521, -0.0012572337873280048, 0.026000868529081345, -0.06133153662085533, -0.04758019745349884, -0.11466401815414429, -0.018834806978702545, 0.00037532791611738503, 0.03393484279513359, 0.012111791409552097, -0.031115883961319923, -0.055350471287965775, -0.02677815780043602, 0.04000142216682434, -0.07297483086585999, 0.018526770174503326, -0.003912174608558416, -0.061254825443029404, 0.06958355754613876, -0.025971312075853348, -0.03647810220718384, -0.07719267904758453, 0.030887501314282417, 0.07799793034791946, 0.025780437514185905, 0.022435922175645828, -0.06264970451593399, 0.01954025961458683, -0.04748239368200302, 0.06367521733045578, 0.061644282191991806, -0.011936583556234837, 0.01200956292450428, 0.017667032778263092, 0.024797672405838966, 0.08437437564134598, 0.028916658833622932, 0.06001460924744606, -0.034830763936042786, 0.07541754096746445, -0.0028646616265177727, 0.010753385722637177, 0.002970705274492502, 0.0024861814454197884, 0.003721292596310377, -0.026744654402136803, -0.0027293700259178877, -0.032296933233737946, 0.011262563988566399, -0.024789700284600258, -0.014086510054767132, -0.022422676905989647, 0.016172057017683983, 0.04393642023205757, -0.08046556264162064, 0.029235800728201866, -0.013775003142654896, -0.019695501774549484, -0.0312722772359848, -0.03746478259563446, -0.07853386551141739, 0.01929839327931404, 0.061473410576581955, -0.006269410718232393, -0.007569288369268179, 0.06213187426328659, -0.0966058000922203, 0.012976231053471565, 0.052296411246061325, -0.030504480004310608, -0.0577835738658905, -0.015095553360879421, -0.032304055988788605, 0.021035438403487206, -0.020890887826681137, -0.037337690591812134, -0.0007352895918302238, 0.023966502398252487, 0.006757795810699463, 0.016803758218884468, -0.022235549986362457, 0.059080950915813446, -0.02394065447151661, 0.011931326240301132, 0.04946640878915787, -0.07648955285549164, 0.0032954278867691755, -0.10675837099552155, 0.01865203119814396, 0.06907245516777039, -0.06622975319623947, -0.021218113601207733, -0.02224784716963768, -0.0018221341306343675, -0.050322867929935455, 0.003758384380489588, -0.029869137331843376, -0.025210324674844742, -0.02108394168317318, -0.06731078028678894, 0.020374353975057602, -0.00021970087254885584, 0.01190868765115738, 0.021271629258990288, 0.007355057634413242, 0.10768350958824158, -0.015371126122772694, -0.00039577329880557954, -0.04288756847381592, -0.002255135914310813, -0.008760753087699413, -0.016089050099253654, 0.03697653487324715, -0.05637185275554657, 0.0063463798724114895, 0.049829497933387756, 0.01893654279410839, -0.05057743191719055, 0.005036353599280119, 0.03498151898384094, 0.005839517340064049, 0.03719652444124222, -0.03552206978201866, 0.00018513300165068358, 0.04005780071020126, 0.005076304078102112, -0.05788176506757736, 0.04837720841169357, 0.01764034479856491, -0.010577878914773464, 0.03381306678056717, -0.0078063891269266605, 0.043238189071416855, 0.02193889580667019, -0.04448753595352173, -0.04336440563201904, -0.04264529049396515, 0.04269176349043846, -0.03442457318305969, 0.012917864136397839, -0.049958810210227966, 0.03683749958872795, -0.02454482764005661, 0.022666404023766518, 0.020757844671607018, 0.01418343372642994, 0.08118440955877304, 0.004724386613816023, 0.051442068070173264, -0.005145918112248182, -0.04297247156500816, 0.015358579345047474, -0.03489016741514206, -0.009627663530409336, -0.005865351762622595, -0.007917403243482113, 0.03616572543978691, -0.05734982341527939, -0.010910091921687126, 0.0016920615453273058, 0.019045162945985794, 0.017416413873434067, -0.01024099811911583, -0.0018965904600918293, 0.017732389271259308, 0.058767784386873245, 0.01168648898601532, 0.029706349596381187, -0.012313509359955788, -0.013306859880685806, 0.0092373201623559, -0.019248854368925095, -0.01168008055537939, 0.0021191579289734364, -0.039826102554798126, 0.014492292888462543, 0.031426072120666504, 0.010720261372625828, -0.04882050305604935, -0.00910892616957426, 0.028539635241031647, -0.07853511720895767, 0.03963684290647507, 0.011631413362920284, 0.05270449072122574, -0.014915338717401028, -0.0044094230979681015, 0.009384067729115486, 0.022740427404642105, 0.040025707334280014, -0.008704745210707188, -0.030651234090328217, 0.024992747232317924, 0.04630788788199425, -0.05390585586428642, -0.021783670410513878, 0.008268493227660656, 0.009805189445614815, -0.03493199124932289, -0.0755959302186966, 0.02531018853187561, 0.02479788288474083, -0.03767361491918564, -0.0136208925396204, -0.038900963962078094, -0.03238741680979729, 0.005492357071489096, -0.06341288983821869, -0.005728144198656082, 0.03576846793293953, -0.04088079556822777, -0.026604339480400085, -0.06573304533958435, -0.002368421759456396, -0.0422196201980114, -0.05909409373998642, -0.06887446343898773, -0.0014447274152189493, -0.03545775264501572, -0.07861064374446869, 0.055815279483795166, -0.02466573379933834, 0.049624331295490265, -0.020879605785012245, 0.01407900732010603, 0.019741280004382133, 0.01945999078452587, -0.020255710929632187, -0.03925679624080658, -0.01131105050444603, 0.03430532291531563, -0.029429998248815536, 0.01796889677643776, 0.03446943685412407, 0.07066326588392258, -0.027711542323231697, 0.020221587270498276, -0.0198210459202528, 0.007823122665286064, 0.03975303843617439, -0.02191648632287979, -0.04513196274638176, 0.030818814411759377, -0.028042146936058998, 0.029915159568190575, 0.05006050318479538, -0.021598510444164276, -0.026862608268857002, 0.02623763121664524, 0.05833020433783531, 0.030264338478446007, 0.009110642597079277, -0.04077267646789551, 0.03233489394187927, -0.0034176388289779425, -0.08078262954950333, -0.0012720997910946608, 0.028233425691723824, 0.005708515178412199, -0.06015681475400925, -0.01561078242957592, -0.009804468601942062, 0.021244356408715248, -0.034615132957696915, -0.011483385227620602, 0.0483679324388504, 0.028203913941979408, 0.056444112211465836, 0.059756722301244736, 0.04801175743341446, 0.03660591319203377, 0.01850840449333191, 0.05782915651798248, -0.006907906383275986, 0.005777712911367416, -0.026217082515358925, -0.010898968204855919, -0.0702875480055809, 0.03544297069311142, 0.014732055366039276, -0.010471771471202374, 0.05599185824394226, 0.026046324521303177, -0.01465816143900156, 0.059631481766700745, -0.020375119522213936, 0.007389431819319725, -0.09102568030357361, 0.015587396919727325, 0.019662201404571533, -0.013560882769525051, -0.01681903749704361, -0.005902494303882122, -0.03366031125187874, -0.032061636447906494, 0.049026839435100555, 0.033780287951231, 0.0033024149015545845, 0.0355607308447361, 0.05892183631658554, -0.03206796944141388, 0.006608395371586084, -0.022187775000929832, -0.007174634840339422, 0.01244521513581276, 0.01108996756374836, 0.0033625196665525436, 0.03278476744890213, 0.032543666660785675, -0.03280320763587952, -0.039816759526729584, -0.0003660464135464281, -0.018140874803066254, 0.008671102114021778, -0.02861056663095951, -0.035732243210077286, 0.056186847388744354, -0.0075592403300106525, 0.09018047899007797, 0.021863577887415886, -0.019494090229272842, 0.015190890990197659, 0.015562426298856735, 0.013933174312114716, -0.006941629108041525, -0.044552672654390335, 0.01286210585385561, 0.0026042459066957235, 0.037098102271556854, 0.03843950852751732, 0.008274286054074764, 0.0155740175396204, -0.023510510101914406, 0.041003402322530746, -0.027802035212516785, -0.040980566293001175, 0.015394795686006546, 0.01102464646100998, -0.02457764931023121, -0.005081820767372847, -0.025906778872013092, 0.008573584258556366, 0.02246682718396187, -0.07946974784135818, -0.022606244310736656, -0.02337356097996235, -0.013734700158238411, 0.023330258205533028, 0.014850516803562641, -0.01105379220098257, 0.02061520144343376, 0.04474320635199547, -0.025459961965680122, 0.008379698731005192, -0.003960530739277601, -0.000990901724435389, 0.05654756724834442, -0.02641204185783863, 0.045809436589479446, -0.013626481406390667, 0.01845010183751583, 0.016523733735084534, -0.04419254884123802, -0.05196293815970421, -0.042331669479608536, -0.04111820086836815, -0.02534843422472477, -0.03292917087674141, -0.018527213484048843, -0.00726283760741353, 0.047259412705898285, 0.029765821993350983, -0.05045630782842636, -0.0466456413269043, 0.038750190287828445, -0.044826433062553406, 0.03471118584275246, 0.06673707813024521, 0.019058354198932648, 0.012180455960333347, 0.04155988246202469, 0.07317864894866943, 0.04923219233751297, -0.015379133634269238, -0.02858126536011696, -0.033263370394706726, 0.010122578591108322, 0.018226679414510727, -0.007115147542208433, -0.04440350830554962, -0.039665598422288895, -0.05201592296361923, 0.001328053418546915, 0.07444160431623459, 0.035324763506650925, 0.04342186450958252, -0.017923157662153244, -0.03635624796152115, 0.04358799383044243, -0.03217081353068352, 0.009263085201382637, -0.0043815746903419495, -0.0015064729377627373, -0.04424016922712326, -0.005811844952404499, 0.06462152302265167, -0.013639742508530617, 0.0038888142444193363, 0.04015562683343887, 0.024400290101766586, 0.038635991513729095, 0.05367523804306984, 0.04253993555903435, 0.007049188017845154, 0.07061253488063812, 0.011984352022409439, -0.04688328504562378, 0.024418165907263756, -0.02532234601676464, 0.0673399493098259, -0.006758944131433964, -0.018623733893036842, 0.00758373411372304, 0.022275231778621674, 0.03255641460418701, -0.024227850139141083, -0.008711343631148338, -0.032988954335451126, -0.03447958827018738, -0.06061363220214844, 0.027283061295747757, -0.0655876025557518, -0.053202200680971146, 0.03531225025653839, 0.002798490459099412, -0.028266917914152145, 0.004185131751000881, -0.09775183349847794, -0.03556113317608833, -0.0046968297101557255, -0.023545585572719574, 0.015554188750684261, -0.03130507469177246, -0.01505175419151783, -0.02904767170548439, -0.03134153410792351, -0.014264185912907124, -0.0010856539011001587, -0.04191764071583748, -0.022098617628216743, 0.010118129663169384, -0.026623519137501717, -0.009518022648990154, -0.02324637398123741, 0.03538987413048744, 0.015180053189396858, 0.05664728954434395, 0.010349029675126076, 0.07328478246927261, -0.013553671538829803, -0.0011876617791131139, -0.030852850526571274, -0.0775391086935997, 0.030651524662971497, -0.0055276802740991116, 0.04705197736620903, -0.009066549129784107, -0.007384315598756075, -0.00217011128552258, -0.016506468877196312, -0.04586655646562576, 0.006137280724942684, -0.0034896463621407747, -0.014191227033734322, 0.039185505360364914, 0.06093935668468475, -0.026616860181093216, 0.0325888991355896, 0.006321650929749012, 0.02057034522294998, 0.02205415442585945, 0.039436712861061096, 0.014111756347119808, -0.005111652426421642, 0.027365878224372864, -0.00977837760001421, -0.034956492483615875, -0.007005807012319565, -0.006786937825381756, -0.003993725869804621, 0.0039344667457044125, -0.01908809132874012, -0.01941574737429619, 0.01635868288576603, 0.033911995589733124, 0.016824563965201378, 0.04080800712108612, -0.03562913462519646, -0.04853564500808716, -0.0027765356935560703, -0.019770946353673935, -0.0007299141143448651, -0.0234170351177454, 0.010464402846992016, 0.031062543392181396, -0.05936853215098381, 0.06040102243423462, -0.0377056747674942, -0.016858577728271484, -0.0009681330993771553, -0.009901287965476513, 0.0222525242716074, -0.010050909593701363, 0.03524534031748772, 0.06959487497806549, 0.03922674432396889, 0.031761717051267624, 0.0006852441583760083, 0.03506790101528168, 0.036120522767305374, -0.031350184231996536, -0.03944654017686844, 0.019468510523438454, 0.0007431613048538566, 0.0017012649914249778, -0.02152087353169918, 0.027912072837352753, 0.09661529213190079, -0.025377532467246056, -0.03053484670817852, 0.030916821211576462, 0.019905587658286095, -0.047344110906124115, 0.032193806022405624, 0.015058156102895737, -0.020757505670189857, 0.006775972433388233, 0.048743970692157745, 0.006787544582039118, 0.0722930058836937, 0.06431808322668076, 0.04697038605809212, 0.0124080590903759, 0.06090671569108963, -0.004170754924416542, -0.0710086077451706, -0.052435241639614105, 0.02434507943689823, 0.04011497274041176, -0.012247715145349503, -0.03203436732292175, 0.026233410462737083, 0.0037596558686345816, 0.050784770399332047, 0.060769859701395035, -0.07461800426244736, 0.033799584954977036, 0.046070873737335205, 0.04338957741856575, 0.017484750598669052, 0.03287064656615257, 0.007889174856245518, -0.03325556591153145, -0.01593240536749363, -0.03744053468108177, 0.011167669668793678, 0.007484307512640953, 0.04167115315794945, -0.007369703613221645, -0.00975071731954813, 0.003572925226762891, -0.07251821458339691, -0.04724647104740143, 0.026019427925348282, 0.017165567725896835, -0.013349215500056744, -0.013204325921833515, 0.014453685842454433, 0.018726186826825142, 0.000839355168864131, 0.00011421661474741995, 0.020656125620007515, 0.021968800574541092, 0.027280908077955246, -0.005484587047249079, -0.04210343211889267, -0.024427903816103935, 0.028629565611481667, 0.023777971044182777, -0.08166616410017014, 0.011466479860246181, -0.01821516640484333, -0.055608950555324554, -0.004044398199766874, 0.03665412962436676, -0.012121341191232204, -0.01689191535115242, -0.018290869891643524, -0.07654557377099991, 0.032542884349823, 0.009230109862983227, 0.04818084463477135, 0.037911757826805115, 0.04428304359316826, 0.00040482752956449986, -0.016521187499165535, 0.021682405844330788, -0.007889159955084324, -0.038681842386722565, -0.034626834094524384, -0.027999799698591232, -0.020129486918449402, -0.05734124407172203, -0.03830302879214287, -0.00012028566561639309, -0.0027636736631393433, -0.034119486808776855, 0.010400847531855106, -0.033883508294820786, 0.03722096234560013, -0.01964712329208851, -0.015609508380293846, -0.06555209308862686, -0.03491498529911041, -0.035052862018346786, 0.03155750408768654, -0.004612589720636606, -0.03764598071575165, -0.020003115758299828, -0.010454123839735985, 0.00910744909197092, 0.00954890064895153, -0.052720531821250916, 0.03408316895365715, -0.08308903127908707, 0.052816856652498245, 0.02075798064470291, 0.03523263707756996, 0.011306590400636196, 0.0320955254137516, -0.04304305836558342, 0.007608041167259216, -0.004481513053178787, 0.06985614448785782, 0.044096942991018295, 0.042519621551036835, 0.003960061818361282, -0.007169963326305151, -0.023864148184657097, -0.02572505734860897, -0.0015965482452884316, 0.0028385247569531202, 0.021219035610556602, -0.016877958551049232, -0.06381302326917648, 0.028817160055041313, 0.016364067792892456, -0.038354676216840744, -0.013248397968709469, 0.014693154022097588, 0.03769810125231743, -0.04906074330210686, -0.04801437631249428, -0.02391364984214306, -0.013664630241692066, 0.05534391105175018, -0.008208454586565495, -0.022461485117673874, 0.026531968265771866, 0.03912223130464554 ]
<p>I need some help My project aims to develop algorithms for spatial temporal analysis of Flickr, Twitter and Foursquare databases to detect any kind of significant changes, named as “Event” in real time. Event can be defined as any anomalous user activity, which happens at a time or within a specific period of time. For this, different clustering methods should be implemented and the best fit has to be selected. The detected events will be visualized for further exploration.</p> <p>This information will be integrated with some other VGI sources to provide a series of Volunteered Geographic services.</p> <p>Could you please suggest me which clustering algorithm is good for this project? And also please suggest me some books and study material...</p>
g49929
[ 0.06721395999193192, -0.01515814196318388, 0.004444589372724295, -0.008114376105368137, -0.026498468592762947, -0.04970145970582962, 0.03653595969080925, 0.07658993452787399, -0.008438966237008572, 0.07051896303892136, -0.029252082109451294, 0.002004972193390131, 0.09415225684642792, 0.054936524480581284, -0.02735625021159649, 0.02553599327802658, -0.025740109384059906, 0.008783149532973766, -0.1046435758471489, 0.019292043522000313, -0.023758791387081146, 0.05293688550591469, 0.019976984709501266, 0.036263469606637955, -0.07506653666496277, -0.034478019922971725, 0.02954556792974472, 0.04423414170742035, 0.013750990852713585, 0.005486848298460245, -0.016079045832157135, 0.009092736057937145, -0.02797359973192215, -0.05870061367750168, 0.05302835628390312, 0.014099864289164543, 0.02702835574746132, -0.05425474792718887, -0.052243031561374664, 0.0006076509598642588, 0.0030966405756771564, 0.01511736772954464, 0.029441025108098984, -0.0009763278649188578, 0.07306654006242752, -0.04631306603550911, 0.01936882548034191, -0.00878241565078497, 0.07451241463422775, -0.0016724837478250265, -0.06683748215436935, 0.018573923036456108, -0.02236820012331009, -0.027114763855934143, 0.03000359795987606, 0.030598590150475502, -0.013390022329986095, 0.02489563077688217, 0.024077773094177246, -0.018403228372335434, 0.07592588663101196, -0.01681634411215782, -0.0015932006062939763, 0.007158102933317423, 0.06744886934757233, 0.04217932000756264, -0.06430834531784058, -0.047240037471055984, 0.051035650074481964, -0.014832270331680775, -0.028457241132855415, -0.00009071960812434554, -0.0004589385644067079, 0.0792706236243248, -0.028666768223047256, -0.013840378262102604, -0.04352310672402382, -0.0025715965311974287, -0.04658651724457741, 0.009359875693917274, -0.013270273804664612, 0.023049701005220413, -0.046185340732336044, 0.022033458575606346, 0.11936454474925995, -0.05611268803477287, 0.008556685410439968, 0.010706101544201374, 0.0567161925137043, -0.04756442457437515, 0.013248685747385025, 0.015386508777737617, 0.09653258323669434, -0.007191142532974482, -0.04711420089006424, 0.044433414936065674, -0.06741541624069214, 0.05196664109826088, 0.0029977899976074696, -0.016759833320975304, -0.05031765252351761, 0.02505948580801487, -0.038261182606220245, -0.0021585964132100344, -0.05942967161536217, -0.11159363389015198, -0.04422878846526146, 0.0037486914079636335, -0.028915969654917717, 0.004942876286804676, 0.027521207928657532, -0.011905627325177193, -0.05318005755543709, -0.020722780376672745, -0.0007511823205277324, -0.010991830378770828, 0.04830552265048027, -0.00951079186052084, -0.005899329669773579, 0.04191596060991287, -0.009095351211726665, -0.03251294046640396, -0.028356846421957016, -0.007391245104372501, -0.014761538244783878, -0.059610601514577866, 0.015216111205518246, 0.031828783452510834, 0.010209592059254646, -0.026232784613966942, -0.015708625316619873, -0.00457552308216691, 0.01640334166586399, 0.07523859292268753, -0.006636148784309626, 0.006600250955671072, 0.005995977204293013, 0.028360502794384956, 0.04533395171165466, -0.007740688510239124, -0.0007267250912263989, 0.008654716424643993, 0.006736575160175562, -0.04374932870268822, -0.02049596980214119, -0.019838741049170494, -0.052224427461624146, 0.011546649970114231, 0.008195105008780956, 0.005712349433451891, -0.010260703973472118, 0.007963870652019978, -0.0010368290822952986, -0.05760987848043442, 0.018052760511636734, -0.04436410591006279, -0.05970006063580513, -0.01725734956562519, -0.007335621863603592, 0.0036589668598026037, -0.03136793524026871, -0.026270249858498573, 0.06611588597297668, 0.053778860718011856, -0.03831679746508598, -0.006520537193864584, 0.05300203338265419, -0.04868179187178612, -0.03038346767425537, -0.02180766500532627, -0.044954195618629456, -0.006670123897492886, -0.012564247474074364, -0.03365974500775337, -0.015524744056165218, 0.014109808020293713, 0.044312406331300735, -0.01640409789979458, 0.08510193973779678, 0.037663862109184265, 0.002290176460519433, -0.025526737794280052, -0.024897081777453423, -0.033462975174188614, 0.0023288519587367773, -0.061913277953863144, 0.03413510322570801, 0.005586665123701096, -0.040649715811014175, -0.018335333094000816, -0.03462385758757591, -0.042377833276987076, -0.010695276781916618, 0.0010667291935533285, -0.027394188567996025, -0.01796421967446804, -0.006968976929783821, -0.036835454404354095, -0.07168834656476974, -0.0019018069142475724, -0.01164268795400858, -0.02395460568368435, -0.05432023108005524, 0.08571714907884598, 0.0026050349697470665, -0.02057349681854248, 0.05252040922641754, -0.050169091671705246, -0.07372923195362091, -0.014499686658382416, 0.04341365024447441, -0.0497465506196022, 0.06108459457755089, 0.018908130005002022, -0.011804034933447838, 0.055232856422662735, -0.006888987962156534, 0.046957701444625854, 0.04181594401597977, 0.0064223106019198895, 0.002297136466950178, -0.01852235198020935, -0.011897520162165165, -0.0054607875645160675, 0.03528399392962456, -0.0034587427508085966, 0.02180902659893036, -0.038968611508607864, 0.013156871311366558, -0.025775179266929626, -0.0712430402636528, 0.044151756912469864, 0.006498305127024651, -0.014733388088643551, 0.042424608021974564, 0.026065068319439888, -0.05800962075591087, 0.028316207230091095, 0.028016721829771996, -0.028164871037006378, -0.0037781160790473223, -0.001284214435145259, -0.029558081179857254, -0.0378558412194252, 0.02905716374516487, -0.022686999291181564, 0.052535347640514374, -0.01505328994244337, 0.041185829788446426, 0.033530257642269135, -0.04335319995880127, -0.014326276257634163, 0.005389323458075523, -0.018954776227474213, 0.028677338734269142, -0.007474168669432402, 0.03305665776133537, 0.019081154838204384, 0.013363619334995747, 0.007357505150139332, -0.013718750327825546, 0.01100187562406063, 0.017007634043693542, 0.007186072412878275, 0.05096575617790222, -0.013300461694598198, -0.01627022959291935, -0.01584278792142868, -0.04036150872707367, -0.032989393919706345, -0.03191963955760002, 0.0022503456566482782, 0.002600907115265727, 0.01259008888155222, -0.026137439534068108, 0.09085724502801895, 0.01779072917997837, 0.02339218556880951, -0.008522995747625828, 0.05830782279372215, -0.009885060600936413, -0.03342907503247261, 0.0020550796762108803, 0.031566862016916275, -0.04449634999036789, 0.01820257678627968, 0.027559885755181313, 0.05726594105362892, -0.006757592782378197, -0.03788965940475464, -0.014450590126216412, 0.011837302707135677, 0.022165365517139435, -0.017478004097938538, -0.028027229011058807, 0.01584826223552227, 0.023862889036536217, -0.06097836419939995, 0.05502936989068985, -0.01604444347321987, 0.02218145877122879, -0.025511085987091064, 0.06658830493688583, 0.0318320095539093, 0.06448947638273239, 0.01657300814986229, 0.028056811541318893, -0.016829492524266243, 0.021681232377886772, 0.013429389335215092, -0.003034560941159725, -0.021479494869709015, 0.02104458585381508, -0.007527896203100681, 0.06825074553489685, 0.02189910039305687, -0.03171538561582565, 0.001629578066058457, -0.06464672088623047, 0.04176933690905571, 0.009585259482264519, -0.009717895649373531, -0.001675568986684084, 0.007652155123651028, 0.025962302461266518, 0.03683964163064957, -0.01718345284461975, 0.009351640939712524, -0.02980359084904194, 0.06359629333019257, -0.06690292805433273, -0.06048949807882309, 0.0032774328719824553, -0.03357318788766861, 0.03222848102450371, -0.025990523397922516, 0.0181605014950037, 0.004612745717167854, 0.007963379845023155, -0.01818806864321232, -0.0009853617521002889, -0.052164964377880096, -0.039735399186611176, -0.08764814585447311, -0.030322469770908356, -0.005986827425658703, 0.037057895213365555, -0.08011990040540695, 0.03341038152575493, 0.01335020549595356, -0.005442277994006872, 0.018094902858138084, 0.01967940293252468, -0.04709923639893532, 0.051388416439294815, 0.005030312575399876, -0.027351345866918564, 0.03024633787572384, -0.038461390882730484, -0.03307317569851875, -0.015749305486679077, -0.020446045324206352, -0.053481049835681915, -0.02230105921626091, -0.03892400488257408, 0.05450412258505821, 0.015539390966296196, 0.013885329477488995, 0.02646218053996563, 0.0017331476556137204, 0.09271499514579773, 0.016561174765229225, -0.03330758959054947, -0.03122456558048725, -0.02255341224372387, 0.028303755447268486, -0.03989852964878082, 0.011990688741207123, 0.01718471199274063, 0.01634278893470764, 0.008900593966245651, 0.010136159136891365, 0.07296773791313171, 0.02001928724348545, 0.020191607996821404, -0.0673203393816948, 0.07438080757856369, -0.007207117043435574, -0.028868915513157845, 0.00020706803479697555, 0.02027767524123192, -0.03570841997861862, -0.026744166389107704, -0.014509561471641064, 0.005695745348930359, -0.02352258935570717, -0.04626237973570824, 0.002681500744074583, 0.020392104983329773, 0.05038904398679733, 0.0073561109602451324, -0.02562408335506916, 0.044418416917324066, 0.02646053023636341, -0.010946854017674923, -0.027409031987190247, -0.04053744673728943, -0.038572560995817184, 0.03443605452775955, -0.04132981598377228, -0.02195807918906212, 0.016229616478085518, 0.03983263671398163, -0.07326299697160721, 0.034891076385974884, 0.012723119929432869, 0.08660921454429626, -0.05265721678733826, -0.004068966489285231, 0.0013903605286031961, 0.013357519172132015, 0.02918974682688713, -0.0063996585085988045, -0.03602283447980881, -0.004404264967888594, -0.007636121939867735, 0.04099510237574577, 0.027251115068793297, 0.004015380050987005, 0.062393564730882645, 0.032630741596221924, 0.009021338075399399, 0.01354866661131382, 0.023007331416010857, -0.02055702917277813, -0.013989686965942383, 0.06318015605211258, 0.021646929904818535, -0.0036651482805609703, -0.06399483233690262, -0.0012108712689951062, -0.049583643674850464, 0.0043748533353209496, 0.06417075544595718, -0.014783825725317001, 0.12994617223739624, -0.03156396001577377, -0.06081392988562584, 0.02007628232240677, 0.06930984556674957, 0.029833011329174042, 0.020662644878029823, 0.01631965860724449, -0.001593508175574243, 0.07373466342687607, 0.03154196962714195, -0.012743841856718063, -0.05239114910364151, -0.03345358744263649, 0.0511595718562603, -0.005350898019969463, -0.022433195263147354, -0.035372041165828705, -0.005286793224513531, -0.04063774645328522, -0.0810600146651268, -0.06107806786894798, -0.025705015286803246, 0.009463914670050144, -0.045601606369018555, 0.009737502783536911, -0.014364661648869514, 0.019407283514738083, -0.0008319958578795195, 0.029910976067185402, 0.039537154138088226, 0.013499582186341286, -0.0067007034085690975, 0.034021977335214615, 0.020539702847599983, -0.015581715852022171, -0.04072203114628792, 0.025211608037352562, 0.0015278669307008386, -0.006847714073956013, -0.013894136063754559, 0.05161957070231438, -0.045919936150312424, 0.068506620824337, -0.030635302886366844, 0.011023921892046928, -0.04451834410429001, 0.030913056805729866, 0.002337434096261859, 0.0408942811191082, -0.06163235381245613, -0.014889724552631378, 0.04591335728764534, 0.006575539708137512, 0.014249174855649471, 0.025249749422073364, 0.05142614245414734, -0.06263773143291473, -0.011966739781200886, -0.015894923359155655, -0.013916438445448875, 0.014156864956021309, -0.03919610753655434, 0.035129912197589874, 0.02855016477406025, -0.029657814651727676, 0.03753238916397095, 0.01660817489027977, -0.03847255930304527, -0.015874531120061874, -0.030599718913435936, 0.049559272825717926, 0.05063796043395996, -0.013912661001086235, 0.021420618519186974, -0.027308810502290726, 0.013563485816121101, 0.026017429307103157, 0.0242473017424345, 0.05865534022450447, -0.0033468096517026424, -0.013378570787608624, 0.024910032749176025, 0.03562765195965767, -0.021449875086545944, 0.011981588788330555, -0.01097725797444582, -0.0639873817563057, -0.04572933539748192, -0.023600898683071136, 0.012419520877301693, -0.006673067808151245, 0.026569435372948647, 0.035567838698625565, -0.00441772909834981, -0.0382249541580677, -0.07585311681032181, 0.013118280097842216, -0.05673016235232353, -0.06148010864853859, -0.08856555074453354, 0.002379321027547121, 0.049171533435583115, -0.018503863364458084, -0.010459274984896183, 0.0246206633746624, 0.010987082496285439, 0.09993170946836472, -0.015763763338327408, -0.014079764485359192, -0.0033872853964567184, -0.006605197209864855, -0.014653499238193035, -0.009584889747202396, -0.013447527773678303, 0.001887031365185976, -0.030088474974036217, -0.02392544597387314, 0.03224373608827591, 0.019968336448073387, -0.004789338447153568, -0.022926636040210724, -0.007044306956231594, 0.012968894094228745, -0.006843619514256716, 0.0027845106087625027, -0.027020733803510666, 0.01379475835710764, 0.009540604427456856, 0.057911790907382965, 0.003122644731774926, 0.07899541407823563, -0.024226879701018333, -0.06841818988323212, 0.016655823215842247, 0.043011054396629333, 0.0027907523326575756, 0.025979887694120407, -0.013819442130625248, 0.002834789687767625, 0.0378049872815609, -0.04157503321766853, 0.009000535123050213, -0.03563656285405159, -0.05228845030069351, -0.007233600597828627, 0.0320647694170475, -0.03622664138674736, -0.007803312037140131, -0.027992893010377884, -0.014145870693027973, -0.03744872659444809, 0.0328911617398262, -0.010828007943928242, 0.012432025745511055, -0.028464963659644127, -0.02998698130249977, -0.051298514008522034, 0.038389623165130615, -0.05306600034236908, -0.008570105768740177, 0.0355805903673172, -0.010801159776747227, 0.021459894254803658, -0.03730395808815956, -0.008782369084656239, 0.027812764048576355, -0.006294907536357641, 0.012401284649968147, 0.009315751492977142, -0.008661828003823757, 0.01078966073691845, -0.011558475904166698, -0.0012496613198891282, -0.035499535501003265, 0.0307984109967947, 0.003398432396352291, 0.026251565665006638, -0.015361320227384567, 0.016587087884545326, 0.04798620194196701, -0.006096750497817993, -0.025282489135861397, -0.042568374425172806, 0.04000333696603775, -0.01919795572757721, 0.05747314170002937, -0.029594266787171364, 0.05402852222323418, -0.06839600205421448, -0.008359689265489578, -0.06088903546333313, 0.08215726912021637, 0.041656494140625, 0.007476735394448042, 0.01662248745560646, -0.005437668412923813, -0.011277448385953903, 0.02102012000977993, 0.043552421033382416, -0.021982405334711075, 0.00978151336312294, 0.005656300578266382, 0.01274996530264616, -0.0181784238666296, 0.06152837350964546, 0.062627874314785, 0.0750688910484314, -0.024091636762022972, -0.0030826616566628218, 0.02729463204741478, -0.03057924471795559, 0.014337092638015747, 0.032722000032663345, 0.016968149691820145, -0.0395355261862278, 0.02259255386888981, 0.016511131078004837, 0.03429093584418297, -0.0002644431951921433, 0.03131871670484543, -0.00749867083504796, 0.04647817090153694, 0.012776401825249195, -0.07291341572999954, -0.03342088311910629, 0.05829591304063797, -0.006338267587125301, -0.03555082902312279, 0.01789969764649868, 0.028384892269968987, -0.006608746014535427, 0.008949772454798222, 0.015829788520932198, 0.0290901530534029, -0.020607048645615578, -0.01898839883506298, -0.02868593856692314, -0.013423907570540905, -0.026936016976833344, 0.06457065045833588, -0.04770256578922272, 0.0481821745634079, 0.04061894863843918, -0.02885150909423828, -0.059030741453170776, -0.010515057481825352, -0.05668167769908905, -0.03819767013192177, 0.017747769132256508, 0.023384859785437584, -0.0051352535374462605, -0.031202420592308044, 0.009089985862374306, -0.0021874140948057175, -0.015698231756687164, 0.05801381915807724, 0.04866311326622963, -0.010698311030864716, -0.04948839172720909, -0.007938474416732788, -0.0006200472707860172, -0.05287536606192589, 0.07879077643156052, 0.04688731208443642, -0.04452085867524147, 0.03339393064379692, -0.03815101832151413, 0.007022991310805082, -0.061811357736587524, -0.012787106446921825, -0.009641063399612904, 0.03388368338346481, 0.04227713868021965, -0.010274242609739304, -0.04474468156695366, -0.062198687344789505, -0.07570913434028625, -0.02278965525329113, 0.018677670508623123, -0.015538949519395828, 0.03175025433301926, -0.011269202455878258, 0.0360264778137207, -0.019545629620552063, 0.009132184088230133, -0.03467617928981781, -0.059616249054670334, -0.0022234776988625526, -0.028200292959809303, -0.020465826615691185, 0.02759082429111004, -0.024431169033050537, 0.002221370115876198, 0.01916462555527687, 0.008603578433394432, -0.02547178603708744, -0.035372909158468246, 0.007577559910714626, -0.03797019645571709, 0.002380868885666132, 0.05874442309141159, 0.00839963648468256, 0.01736685261130333, -0.04935775697231293, -0.02452073059976101, 0.0003497289144434035, 0.028533348813652992, -0.025316271930933, -0.06439714878797531, 0.07076103240251541, 0.007859185338020325, -0.016274068504571915, 0.0858558714389801, 0.013445134274661541, 0.028389673680067062, 0.004870980512350798, -0.05248584225773811, 0.019614489749073982, 0.044331587851047516, -0.021775053814053535, 0.048557765781879425, 0.00662753963842988 ]
<p>I obtained data of typical time point in two conditions in this shape:</p> <pre><code>weight condition time 0.1307857 Transf 1 0.1926429 Transf 2 0.2734286 Transf 3 0.4403571 Transf 4 0.6037143 Transf 5 0.9036429 Transf 6 1.5454286 Transf 7 0.1370714 Unt 1 0.2005000 Unt 2 0.2973571 Unt 3 0.4592143 Unt 4 0.8336429 Unt 5 1.3099286 Unt 6 2.1470000 Unt 7 </code></pre> <p>I am using the package <code>nlme</code> in <code>R</code> to test the difference between the two conditions in time</p> <pre><code>fm1 &lt;- lme(weigth~condition,random=~1|time,data=data_new) anova.lme(fm1, adjustSigma = F) </code></pre> <p>I got this:</p> <pre><code>numDF denDF F-value p-value (Intercept) 1 6 8.421439 0.0273 condition 1 6 4.208786 0.0861 </code></pre> <p>Questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>Am I doing things correctly with this procedure to test the differences between the two conditions in time?</p></li> <li><p>If yes, which is my p-value, the intercept one or the condition?</p></li> <li><p>If this is not the proper test, what are the alternatives?</p></li> </ol>
g74307
[ 0.00805151741951704, -0.06484673917293549, 0.00533133652061224, -0.061763912439346313, -0.007423990406095982, -0.02585972286760807, 0.03500157967209816, 0.019333260133862495, -0.0697186291217804, -0.010400986298918724, 0.012421304360032082, 0.019120000302791595, 0.0056068492121994495, 0.019316084682941437, -0.004086350090801716, -0.021320974454283714, 0.06889928877353668, -0.05925048142671585, -0.007725555915385485, 0.024832207709550858, -0.014930935576558113, 0.09234151244163513, -0.034767135977745056, -0.03804174065589905, 0.03603016212582588, -0.09353526681661606, -0.037210360169410706, 0.050055451691150665, -0.13754037022590637, 0.0555422306060791, 0.016242224723100662, -0.03438848629593849, 0.007979227229952812, -0.0876486673951149, -0.033793509006500244, -0.017780199646949768, 0.03186831250786781, 0.03478606045246124, 0.004153850954025984, -0.0017766449600458145, 0.007625216618180275, 0.0242314450442791, -0.007412861566990614, 0.04318764805793762, 0.044689327478408813, -0.02344559133052826, -0.027628527954220772, 0.014506284147500992, 0.007753418292850256, -0.02211901918053627, -0.0186922550201416, 0.03431984782218933, 0.02796991728246212, -0.011997341178357601, 0.006349477916955948, 0.06055444851517677, -0.014750534668564796, 0.01995457336306572, 0.011240972205996513, -0.008803486824035645, -0.010074914433062077, -0.033698711544275284, -0.013025748543441296, -0.0459790863096714, 0.02772911824285984, 0.008371379226446152, 0.013757646083831787, -0.03239581361413002, -0.045872438699007034, -0.05267569050192833, -0.04715979844331741, 0.032265882939100266, -0.04624499753117561, -0.05407768860459328, -0.0350438691675663, -0.004390833433717489, -0.009454138576984406, -0.03853655979037285, -0.005526527762413025, 0.0027607984375208616, -0.046772658824920654, 0.013840959407389164, 0.02738320082426071, 0.01126471720635891, -0.007310503162443638, 0.02159876935184002, 0.019298803061246872, 0.023242177441716194, 0.04270225390791893, 0.018002666532993317, 0.021587621420621872, -0.014890408143401146, 0.023081159219145775, 0.023505689576268196, -0.04518810287117958, 0.04038877412676811, -0.031141366809606552, 0.035066355019807816, -0.003550831228494644, 0.022794466465711594, 0.030237693339586258, 0.04258506000041962, 0.020131468772888184, -0.0034917201846837997, -0.043727483600378036, -0.053672220557928085, 0.028466664254665375, 0.009741384536027908, -0.041081249713897705, -0.03194250538945198, -0.03544173389673233, -0.01960654929280281, -0.05711601302027702, -0.00888537522405386, 0.0037028382066637278, -0.027103759348392487, 0.026886727660894394, -0.03497777134180069, -0.052329204976558685, -0.006977731827646494, -0.0285735335201025, -0.00160310510545969, 0.03866637125611305, 0.07719110697507858, 0.016727691516280174, -0.008638977073132992, -0.00950954481959343, 0.02398066595196724, 0.06844030320644379, 0.009180368855595589, -0.0095664132386446, 0.035233139991760254, 0.005470049101859331, 0.006575855426490307, -0.047301098704338074, 0.035204850137233734, 0.02787807025015354, 0.07942085713148117, -0.06821037083864212, -0.05974220857024193, 0.008152415044605732, -0.037342868745326996, 0.005944047588855028, -0.0007671248749829829, -0.022404199466109276, 0.008877749554812908, -0.05320372059941292, -0.030184179544448853, -0.0011506766313686967, 0.04419112578034401, 0.032653454691171646, 0.03963979706168175, 0.007565988693386316, 0.07762891054153442, -0.04704579338431358, 0.009770769625902176, -0.021315569058060646, -0.01690485142171383, 0.011604377999901772, 0.03380272164940834, -0.011991980485618114, 0.006529142614454031, 0.01755371131002903, -0.03583710640668869, 0.012565788812935352, 0.045610211789608, -0.035580217838287354, 0.046925079077482224, -0.0013853322016075253, -0.1146504208445549, -0.055426836013793945, -0.006444775499403477, 0.022975247353315353, -0.03342220187187195, 0.03070899471640587, 0.010505910031497478, 0.03557473421096802, -0.028786834329366684, 0.0035616736859083176, 0.03973744809627533, 0.028304416686296463, -0.006165764760226011, 0.026986217126250267, -0.035643912851810455, -0.04746747016906738, -0.03589992597699165, 0.042257510125637054, -0.030584517866373062, -0.10147969424724579, -0.03475072607398033, -0.05896984785795212, -0.07802457362413406, -0.048641469329595566, 0.015465418808162212, -0.01667875051498413, -0.014212409034371376, -0.059182748198509216, -0.007126138545572758, -0.009356159716844559, 0.04363231360912323, 0.02042919583618641, 0.014754856936633587, 0.01823054812848568, 0.07126115262508392, -0.008952671661973, -0.0024895218666642904, 0.027266399934887886, 0.0209782887250185, 0.009890804998576641, 0.01994755119085312, 0.0010925926035270095, 0.01993258111178875, 0.0024265106767416, 0.033853478729724884, -0.06099430471658707, 0.03727046772837639, -0.026891404762864113, 0.05808475613594055, -0.023716159164905548, 0.03658230975270271, 0.024532534182071686, -0.03694348782300949, 0.03427030146121979, -0.01604013890028, -0.014109759591519833, 0.029858101159334183, 0.04329099878668785, 0.002265079179778695, 0.001361157512292266, -0.023795101791620255, -0.01719098538160324, -0.026872094720602036, -0.033211853355169296, 0.05805888772010803, 0.031033365055918694, 0.03286081552505493, 0.002728197257965803, 0.018414609134197235, -0.024866025894880295, -0.004026859067380428, 0.03928344324231148, 0.04702901467680931, -0.009970167651772499, 0.061178095638751984, 0.006293488200753927, -0.018377289175987244, -0.0372905358672142, -0.05337698757648468, -0.00896588247269392, 0.044427912682294846, -0.05443285405635834, 0.03106682561337948, 0.015239231288433075, -0.029138799756765366, -0.01084866002202034, -0.0836917981505394, -0.0441158153116703, 0.0325835645198822, -0.03454028442502022, 0.04056265577673912, -0.024348342791199684, -0.025494767352938652, 0.008457442745566368, 0.05931996554136276, -0.04312899708747864, 0.0024764719419181347, -0.05355198681354523, 0.061560485512018204, -0.025731094181537628, -0.04399031773209572, -0.002324915025383234, -0.041861642152071, 0.07314181327819824, 0.06950526684522629, -0.003196829929947853, 0.023161139339208603, -0.039569735527038574, -0.03291124850511551, 0.048105720430612564, 0.0020704667549580336, 0.022383201867341995, -0.06090585142374039, -0.02186189964413643, 0.030270693823695183, 0.030483940616250038, -0.031060529872775078, 0.00038847108953632414, -0.028103912249207497, -0.02689547650516033, 0.00826138537377119, -0.009102057665586472, 0.04023859649896622, -0.03360511362552643, -0.06180000677704811, -0.009841568768024445, -0.0288387443870306, -0.011755314655601978, -0.04233482852578163, 0.04932193458080292, -0.021347951143980026, -0.028865836560726166, 0.005131211597472429, -0.02375170774757862, -0.004952274728566408, 0.05731114745140076, -0.016420410946011543, 0.026458244770765305, 0.022107601165771484, 0.04918164387345314, 0.01285344548523426, -0.059809714555740356, 0.02728326804935932, -0.01276376098394394, -0.05150064080953598, -0.009489649906754494, -0.0255777295678854, 0.019435372203588486, 0.030546247959136963, 0.016694650053977966, -0.0024143727496266365, -0.029509689658880234, -0.03509286418557167, 0.01953944005072117, -0.009202897548675537, -0.019244099035859108, 0.01363293081521988, 0.0726025402545929, 0.03145068511366844, -0.05493900179862976, -0.025484414771199226, 0.02713952399790287, 0.05345325917005539, -0.03565378859639168, -0.04478279873728752, 0.039236072450876236, -0.026045944541692734, 0.0377700999379158, 0.04485249146819115, -0.007761087734252214, -0.014555444940924644, -0.017555002123117447, -0.0442727655172348, 0.032031819224357605, 0.01686353236436844, 0.045108433812856674, -0.056101586669683456, 0.017933860421180725, 0.039722077548503876, -0.02652406319975853, 0.039861537516117096, 0.013426237739622593, -0.01740511879324913, 0.029522374272346497, -0.05483296141028404, 0.03671794384717941, 0.023122470825910568, 0.017884213477373123, -0.029066506773233414, -0.025709284469485283, 0.025369374081492424, 0.042615801095962524, 0.000727561884559691, 0.024996813386678696, 0.05619392916560173, 0.0338139571249485, 0.034814395010471344, 0.009315728209912777, 0.06676716357469559, 0.041991304606199265, 0.026131784543395042, 0.06004666909575462, 0.02015676721930504, 0.09452622383832932, -0.04815463349223137, -0.004098670557141304, 0.005941404495388269, 0.024137718603014946, -0.002126622013747692, -0.0017378272023051977, 0.08920667320489883, 0.014388161711394787, -0.013293059542775154, -0.026402659714221954, -0.001054233405739069, 0.024414723739027977, -0.03575945273041725, -0.014517056755721569, -0.014878603629767895, 0.02053302899003029, -0.06484389305114746, 0.007744023110717535, -0.0038120215758681297, -0.039105743169784546, 0.05253288522362709, 0.009354246780276299, 0.035341374576091766, 0.054433636367321014, 0.07219003885984421, -0.027736876159906387, -0.006438374053686857, -0.0016163033433258533, 0.021740300580859184, 0.018726572394371033, -0.023007575422525406, -0.016559738665819168, -0.0234988983720541, -0.01848624274134636, -0.027016831561923027, -0.017224309965968132, -0.013055199757218361, -0.015399436466395855, -0.005529706832021475, -0.03118234872817993, -0.022669628262519836, -0.04181552678346634, -0.04539523646235466, 0.05496615916490555, -0.00029219500720500946, 0.01704881526529789, 0.024352727457880974, -0.006483604200184345, 0.05151637643575668, -0.05567117780447006, -0.049350906163454056, 0.05240766331553459, -0.007022500969469547, 0.005275954958051443, 0.03182945400476456, 0.05494147539138794, -0.024145910516381264, 0.008128753863275051, 0.029040072113275528, -0.03202030807733536, 0.045722901821136475, -0.014027499593794346, 0.06318399310112, -0.07197701185941696, 0.048781219869852066, 0.0065820058807730675, 0.002264426788315177, 0.020302170887589455, -0.05064984783530235, -0.01625758782029152, -0.0019364767940714955, -0.0034183976240456104, 0.05509396642446518, 0.021366391330957413, -0.007258460856974125, 0.032455846667289734, 0.029491189867258072, -0.06052163615822792, 0.00806108582764864, 0.02993691898882389, 0.014846866019070148, -0.033674053847789764, -0.03318824991583824, 0.053705837577581406, 0.011954504065215588, 0.03662566468119621, 0.06598803400993347, 0.002182951895520091, -0.016685446724295616, -0.062190089374780655, -0.02830454707145691, -0.03077884390950203, 0.015946347266435623, -0.030227625742554665, -0.05633082613348961, 0.004916539881378412, 0.0004573497863020748, -0.001108206226490438, -0.052689265459775925, 0.03727041184902191, -0.035521142184734344, 0.01817053183913231, 0.07810816913843155, 0.023498091846704483, -0.026267599314451218, -0.02393781580030918, -0.03287035971879959, -0.027694523334503174, 0.03962798789143562, -0.0031616990454494953, 0.013850794173777103, 0.04908758029341698, 0.04182837903499603, 0.00654725031927228, -0.0719188004732132, 0.024532942101359367, -0.04139835387468338, 0.0057203685864806175, 0.0015894664684310555, 0.07013675570487976, 0.025123752653598785, 0.007103575859218836, -0.010326743125915527, 0.02644667774438858, 0.015040191821753979, -0.03731579706072807, -0.07748755067586899, -0.061818305402994156, 0.013592857867479324, -0.00245532114058733, -0.007521204184740782, 0.03952750191092491, 0.026564763858914375, 0.026192806661128998, 0.001378232380375266, -0.023775864392518997, -0.00698140449821949, -0.009056450799107552, -0.025549929589033127, 0.07312645763158798, 0.02148202434182167, 0.01400112546980381, 0.052130382508039474, 0.0598372258245945, 0.028612468391656876, -0.015711145475506783, -0.08255825936794281, 0.01646735891699791, 0.027359364554286003, 0.054925136268138885, -0.031163986772298813, 0.007208486553281546, -0.03947792574763298, -0.02112872153520584, -0.04597325623035431, -0.009302601218223572, -0.04115867242217064, 0.013300775550305843, 0.004520521033555269, 0.015392499975860119, 0.015008295886218548, 0.03920779004693031, 0.02479630522429943, -0.00026665316545404494, -0.008542693220078945, 0.017739221453666687, -0.02901408262550831, -0.024971172213554382, 0.0025124019011855125, 0.021963905543088913, 0.004121651407331228, -0.0994720309972763, -0.0058854795061051846, 0.0017481317045167089, -0.03343258798122406, -0.021775243803858757, -0.05428538843989372, 0.005200601648539305, 0.021963557228446007, -0.009466531686484814, 0.011351317167282104, 0.06833671033382416, 0.04018387570977211, 0.019420720636844635, 0.0062535651959478855, -0.04366930574178696, -0.015679586678743362, -0.0036008094903081656, -0.04838961735367775, -0.012888375669717789, 0.03994982689619064, 0.059769291430711746, 0.0015092958929017186, -0.012157321907579899, 0.02122822217643261, -0.0009876067051663995, -0.027475126087665558, -0.007178398314863443, -0.030814414843916893, -0.013509314507246017, 0.005381505936384201, -0.014591896906495094, -0.03102979063987732, -0.019280655309557915, 0.025726325809955597, 0.045600052922964096, 0.04514005035161972, 0.007829110138118267, -0.02430003136396408, 0.009967557154595852, 0.01864268071949482, 0.037980105727910995, 0.0399947315454483, -0.016650736331939697, -0.02587069571018219, 0.01355134230107069, -0.032707635313272476, -0.0923021137714386, 0.0074786352925002575, 0.042347345501184464, -0.009023768827319145, -0.002149818232282996, 0.0610649473965168, -0.0359034463763237, 0.02100728452205658, 0.0057352459989488125, 0.01684378832578659, -0.026221569627523422, -0.018701039254665375, 0.03826560452580452, -0.05041439086198807, 0.022650783881545067, -0.0036818189546465874, -0.021293163299560547, 0.05265527591109276, 0.03486677259206772, -0.030194874852895737, 0.008529339917004108, 0.023553762584924698, 0.002646882086992264, 0.04678301885724068, -0.04725231975317001, 0.006177636329084635, -0.011405067518353462, 0.04738789424300194, -0.005224159918725491, 0.048680756241083145, 0.07935239374637604, -0.008527598343789577, -0.06360921263694763, -0.016747398301959038, 0.01138678565621376, 0.11754561215639114, -0.04603053629398346, -0.016029896214604378, 0.021238813176751137, -0.01329879928380251, 0.05630604922771454, -0.021890349686145782, -0.02708393707871437, -0.028054529801011086, -0.019288500770926476, 0.003355981782078743, 0.02621367573738098, 0.062246520072221756, 0.05993786081671715, 0.060312457382678986, 0.04390532895922661, 0.053673651069402695, -0.012865235097706318, -0.06205471232533455, -0.022801047191023827, 0.02696525678038597, 0.013191134668886662, 0.029657792299985886, -0.021152464672923088, 0.08109620958566666, 0.06054189056158066, -0.0028287949971854687, -0.0004373510309960693, -0.021548088639974594, 0.05036996677517891, 0.008892660029232502, 0.011067434214055538, 0.004632872529327869, 0.005281294696033001, -0.005202618893235922, -0.024208232760429382, -0.03726540878415108, -0.048500631004571915, -0.0002688689564820379, 0.014031869359314442, -0.007796940393745899, -0.03485563024878502, -0.03982803598046303, 0.0064239599741995335, -0.08476501703262329, -0.005534689873456955, -0.023664094507694244, 0.03582114726305008, 0.005602945573627949, 0.03814942017197609, 0.06677699834108353, -0.019951852038502693, 0.03702712804079056, -0.07601967453956604, 0.015155754052102566, 0.016280967742204666, -0.04373244196176529, -0.0002419261436443776, -0.04079354926943779, -0.026420490816235542, 0.010453697293996811, -0.07259705662727356, -0.036303114145994186, 0.0032432673033326864, -0.017569605261087418, 0.009861409664154053, 0.07173062115907669, -0.008380577899515629, -0.003912815824151039, -0.08734602481126785, -0.044914305210113525, -0.020718907937407494, 0.015873748809099197, -0.002937691519036889, -0.013060961849987507, 0.01013160403817892, 0.01788489893078804, 0.020711734890937805, -0.01635626330971718, 0.01806034706532955, 0.03229198604822159, -0.028671354055404663, -0.03361165523529053, -0.03958900645375252, 0.00045068952022120357, -0.0002572211669757962, 0.05005441978573799, -0.0017954966751858592, 0.022896701470017433, 0.03379499167203903, 0.01870734989643097, 0.027582788839936256, -0.016730446368455887, -0.026640351861715317, 0.004340948071330786, -0.03075178898870945, -0.021057330071926117, 0.010913072153925896, -0.031895801424980164, -0.05084842070937157, -0.042482830584049225, -0.056367747485637665, 0.043872326612472534, 0.008504816330969334, -0.03584128990769386, -0.04884561523795128, -0.07475075870752335, -0.0514107421040535, -0.0036892651114612818, 0.027448471635580063, 0.017674732953310013, 0.047067850828170776, 0.02270457334816456, -0.005974415224045515, 0.03265015035867691, -0.0539737306535244, 0.06304515153169632, -0.004836196079850197, 0.02308591641485691, -0.01316000521183014, -0.023009464144706726, -0.019120657816529274, 0.0631449818611145, -0.014824575744569302, -0.04637347534298897, -0.08087300509214401, -0.011768575757741928, -0.08894364535808563, 0.023730438202619553, -0.027157973498106003, -0.021187473088502884, -0.0369909331202507, 0.03099013864994049, 0.0974612608551979, -0.020134858787059784, -0.0009361248230561614, 0.0011382633820176125, 0.022077258676290512, 0.049308378249406815, -0.027515390887856483, 0.009251238778233528, -0.007770325988531113, -0.0008847906137816608 ]
<p>I have four samples $x_1, x_2$ and $y_1, y_2$ with $n_{x1} \neq n_{x2} \neq n_{y1} \neq n_{y2} $. I calculated, using a Wilcoxon rank sum test, that $x_1$ is significantly different to $x_2$ and $y_1$ significantly different to $y_2$. </p> <p>However, I would like to test whether the difference $x_1 - x_2$ differs significantly to $y_1 - y_2$ but I have no idea how do to that given the unequal sample sizes.</p> <p>Any ideas or suggestions would be really appreciated. </p>
g74308
[ -0.024678992107510567, 0.011777185834944248, -0.002775403670966625, -0.0436193123459816, 0.009244445711374283, -0.06722934544086456, -0.0033375739585608244, -0.02131456881761551, -0.023170117288827896, 0.019155142828822136, -0.03734830021858215, 0.059663500636816025, -0.0060202390886843204, 0.02114071324467659, 0.040145143866539, 0.031212853267788887, 0.03855030611157417, -0.02826276235282421, 0.013488315977156162, -0.018663331866264343, -0.00971640832722187, 0.033197902143001556, -0.051048871129751205, -0.014890346676111221, 0.014244512654840946, -0.0854819118976593, -0.06232428923249245, 0.06768988072872162, -0.07524212449789047, 0.0424906387925148, -0.041818927973508835, -0.015689188614487648, 0.07225050032138824, -0.020894920453429222, -0.005160655360668898, 0.06971372663974762, 0.052002906799316406, 0.045974649488925934, 0.046433959156274796, 0.021306009963154793, -0.0302205178886652, 0.01851537451148033, 0.028271516785025597, 0.03164657950401306, -0.0010238519171252847, -0.01779305189847946, -0.02590097114443779, 0.022615378722548485, 0.06253427267074585, 0.022688541561365128, -0.023758316412568092, 0.020967159420251846, 0.025740284472703934, 0.044852521270513535, -0.020487045869231224, -0.0015553501434624195, -0.006629767827689648, 0.0180447306483984, 0.07981180399656296, 0.04391584172844887, 0.015731101855635643, -0.002529025310650468, 0.0193066094070673, 0.0025742894504219294, -0.011566893197596073, 0.04432859271764755, 0.011803018860518932, 0.04846081882715225, 0.004507042467594147, -0.06521132588386536, -0.06481344252824783, -0.010547325946390629, 0.04807118698954582, 0.01956433244049549, -0.05740804970264435, -0.032098859548568726, 0.023069623857736588, 0.02645188383758068, -0.04864441975951195, -0.0017697940347716212, 0.022655703127384186, -0.011745310388505459, 0.027455376461148262, 0.0694068968296051, -0.0008710980764590204, -0.030344005674123764, 0.057234711945056915, -0.01576230302453041, -0.007640447933226824, 0.021934600546956062, 0.02462776191532612, 0.02846420742571354, 0.02555343322455883, 0.0792871043086052, -0.0004443498037289828, 0.010255076922476292, -0.017267398536205292, 0.021251637488603592, 0.023457787930965424, -0.010554862208664417, 0.025421345606446266, 0.07754837721586227, 0.001643229159526527, -0.02582707069814205, -0.051386840641498566, 0.05445518344640732, 0.03333050012588501, 0.011241208761930466, -0.027105160057544708, -0.027352290228009224, -0.0538979098200798, -0.03229021653532982, -0.041442662477493286, -0.026965156197547913, -0.05606220290064812, 0.015603558160364628, 0.006201097276061773, -0.037769660353660583, -0.048102062195539474, 0.0029373893048614264, -0.01632832922041416, -0.05397608503699303, -0.012395840138196945, 0.057067424058914185, 0.018511075526475906, -0.0014464339474216104, 0.006651237607002258, 0.058533672243356705, 0.025011660531163216, 0.042995668947696686, -0.010425607673823833, -0.01719943806529045, 0.02873905375599861, 0.004761943593621254, -0.02234935574233532, -0.018192939460277557, -0.006308576557785273, 0.018351519480347633, 0.01947784051299095, -0.011366709135472775, -0.05669577419757843, 0.013717778958380222, 0.034834276884794235, 0.015784569084644318, 0.019095083698630333, -0.02588408999145031, 0.021907739341259003, 0.001477720565162599, -0.04578901454806328, -0.026405826210975647, 0.054693933576345444, 0.02580183930695057, 0.03351324051618576, 0.013418357819318771, -0.05750184878706932, -0.019251858815550804, -0.02698337659239769, -0.0056417337618768215, -0.013320032507181168, -0.021887196227908134, -0.05353771522641182, -0.05133183300495148, 0.024864036589860916, 0.0037927215453237295, 0.011500852182507515, 0.014208763837814331, 0.018143009394407272, 0.011246283538639545, 0.009938705712556839, -0.009218869730830193, 0.03439631313085556, -0.04468521103262901, 0.03549701347947121, -0.04544864222407341, 0.06104065477848053, 0.030737927183508873, 0.029998086392879486, -0.03220034018158913, 0.012367013841867447, 0.014166835695505142, -0.01332810614258051, 0.05011134222149849, -0.007898510433733463, -0.0128324618563056, 0.022209974005818367, -0.029196903109550476, 0.017311347648501396, -0.004201934207230806, -0.009815972298383713, -0.022368956357240677, -0.046229038387537, -0.009740221314132214, -0.021286621689796448, -0.061679501086473465, -0.008348206989467144, -0.0017786897951737046, -0.017566237598657608, -0.0447988361120224, -0.011954842135310173, -0.044312674552202225, -0.05173983424901962, 0.03451206907629967, 0.044867806136608124, 0.02845051884651184, -0.004914184100925922, -0.02804175205528736, -0.06811770051717758, -0.028402185067534447, 0.01814965531229973, -0.006825804244726896, -0.039862535893917084, -0.04709399864077568, -0.016992025077342987, 0.00719262333586812, -0.009647486731410027, 0.058213166892528534, 0.03425191715359688, 0.02355813793838024, 0.03265182673931122, 0.047711748629808426, -0.04487111419439316, -0.019633887335658073, 0.0764770433306694, -0.046599049121141434, 0.023478353396058083, -0.017977165058255196, 0.08675194531679153, 0.009021869860589504, -0.01902468502521515, 0.021468190476298332, -0.07464490830898285, -0.03788921609520912, -0.011197223328053951, -0.03331432119011879, -0.00007638287934241816, -0.04775997996330261, -0.03452808037400246, 0.05785120278596878, 0.025176994502544403, 0.012750016525387764, 0.0038632513023912907, -0.03048820234835148, -0.04674837365746498, 0.06796076148748398, 0.05628620460629463, 0.007139548193663359, -0.018456509336829185, 0.00705719692632556, 0.008517716079950333, -0.006563277915120125, -0.04215257987380028, 0.07654573768377304, -0.023093275725841522, 0.04827935993671417, -0.004877418279647827, -0.01567109487950802, 0.040300287306308746, -0.014271903783082962, -0.0001358672307105735, -0.010888156481087208, -0.046988580375909805, -0.01287708431482315, 0.032362911850214005, 0.03261982649564743, 0.0024218191392719746, -0.02519885078072548, 0.002336883684620261, 0.013243937864899635, -0.023101389408111572, 0.0035450647119432688, -0.01702517829835415, 0.005860548000782728, 0.009925918653607368, 0.0409754253923893, -0.02833230420947075, 0.003917369060218334, -0.008228619582951069, -0.017820065841078758, 0.043609894812107086, 0.014605552889406681, 0.00934021919965744, 0.01726432517170906, -0.0434768944978714, 0.04978818818926811, 0.06734953075647354, -0.011454813182353973, 0.0044851782731711864, -0.030255015939474106, -0.01008776854723692, 0.04661563038825989, -0.00648727361112833, 0.020805295556783676, 0.0506284199655056, -0.04073159396648407, 0.015262606553733349, -0.05786225572228432, -0.0022509910631924868, -0.04750874638557434, 0.03386489301919937, -0.018581155687570572, 0.0006120576290413737, -0.013529470190405846, 0.028811806812882423, 0.027598746120929718, 0.02866583690047264, -0.035001929849386215, -0.0034898798912763596, 0.03453393280506134, 0.07556680589914322, 0.00972356554120779, -0.017060939222574234, -0.006170380860567093, 0.03183600679039955, -0.07119103521108627, 0.03740089014172554, -0.06296666711568832, 0.07277794182300568, 0.07790473848581314, 0.03222987800836563, -0.021398672834038734, 0.052604395896196365, -0.053565800189971924, 0.01500113308429718, 0.08293082565069199, -0.03602045401930809, -0.004226873628795147, -0.02398817054927349, 0.0422278493642807, -0.07987222820520401, 0.014040771871805191, 0.04536711797118187, 0.02068900316953659, 0.01664731092751026, -0.04238587245345116, 0.03164266049861908, -0.05278407037258148, 0.030833100900053978, -0.052729859948158264, -0.016747914254665375, 0.022041261196136475, -0.05622374638915062, -0.017152514308691025, -0.019144251942634583, -0.019299617037177086, -0.07366247475147247, -0.026492703706026077, 0.025932416319847107, 0.005327077116817236, -0.01306291576474905, 0.015689857304096222, 0.037984754890203476, -0.0421544685959816, 0.06008662283420563, 0.019607393071055412, 0.05796327069401741, 0.011071920394897461, 0.011858014389872551, -0.040977589786052704, 0.016075732186436653, 0.04830744490027428, 0.07695705443620682, -0.033676326274871826, 0.013264894485473633, -0.025657184422016144, -0.0083329938352108, 0.015347372740507126, 0.022529125213623047, 0.010412000119686127, 0.018621370196342468, -0.0009489934891462326, -0.03430505469441414, 0.06005775183439255, 0.04295225441455841, 0.010372858494520187, 0.009561566635966301, -0.01793733984231949, 0.06229022145271301, 0.04379056766629219, 0.049241501837968826, 0.02004256471991539, 0.044364359229803085, -0.016071949154138565, -0.040167681872844696, -0.05109342932701111, -0.0395546555519104, -0.007240314967930317, -0.0423782654106617, -0.03165682032704353, -0.03726246953010559, -0.05916684493422508, 0.016155224293470383, -0.009041308425366879, -0.08009137958288193, 0.015289168804883957, 0.016155194491147995, -0.07813792675733566, 0.0058354577049613, 0.023154644295573235, -0.0651501715183258, 0.038937460631132126, -0.011436231434345245, -0.006720927078276873, -0.0030433950014412403, -0.006459704600274563, -0.04486565291881561, -0.05100467428565025, 0.0262873787432909, 0.03992244601249695, -0.033546000719070435, 0.024614082649350166, -0.011266295798122883, -0.017058471217751503, 0.04308676719665527, -0.0684131383895874, -0.01707652397453785, -0.012773687019944191, -0.007694212719798088, -0.025001486763358116, 0.04410788044333458, 0.008438232354819775, 0.02067648246884346, 0.03995305672287941, -0.04400094226002693, -0.053004104644060135, 0.05617779865860939, -0.008916359394788742, -0.011821102350950241, 0.12131160497665405, 0.05140816792845726, 0.022064201533794403, -0.06278854608535767, 0.04594096168875694, -0.030983587726950645, 0.014270847663283348, 0.01605924591422081, -0.01950071193277836, -0.005161651875823736, -0.008863833732903004, -0.023772597312927246, 0.012624939903616905, -0.0002633218828123063, 0.05203410983085632, -0.05416502058506012, 0.007900099270045757, 0.05259982869029045, 0.07603108137845993, -0.03269551694393158, -0.003462030552327633, -0.014752657152712345, 0.031007053330540657, -0.06034530699253082, 0.03196004405617714, 0.0036214927677065134, -0.03214477375149727, -0.013909471221268177, -0.0007639364339411259, 0.027894098311662674, -0.051845334470272064, 0.021681800484657288, 0.06445470452308655, 0.004626913461834192, -0.04389765486121178, -0.019858961924910545, -0.02559000626206398, -0.009442156180739403, 0.024680539965629578, -0.07005377858877182, 0.02376866713166237, 0.02055198699235916, 0.023964164778590202, -0.03564048558473587, -0.055854376405477524, 0.045874208211898804, 0.016342777758836746, -0.08910860121250153, 0.017527060583233833, -0.03433723747730255, -0.02378186210989952, -0.000288995768642053, 0.026284318417310715, -0.032991260290145874, -0.04035346210002899, 0.046561818569898605, 0.014613510109484196, 0.04976224526762962, 0.00043732274207286537, -0.042027994990348816, -0.0009644268429838121, 0.061111606657505035, -0.014627315104007721, 0.0160030797123909, -0.00964774377644062, -0.016075029969215393, 0.04848942533135414, 0.03138817101716995, -0.009670744650065899, 0.06894023716449738, -0.034110233187675476, 0.022352322936058044, -0.003489490132778883, -0.04109010472893715, 0.08663389831781387, 0.020103028044104576, 0.00510678393766284, -0.006171676330268383, 0.027454273775219917, 0.07988238334655762, -0.03931763023138046, -0.04497791454195976, -0.005129748489707708, -0.013094206340610981, -0.026301439851522446, 0.030050253495573997, 0.0468415729701519, -0.0020766856614500284, 0.027819836512207985, 0.021510813385248184, 0.057297464460134506, 0.01764090545475483, -0.03764646127820015, 0.056565407663583755, 0.0031153839081525803, 0.05511486530303955, 0.005223001353442669, -0.005876550916582346, -0.029041698202490807, 0.006221410818397999, -0.09166556596755981, -0.019023152068257332, -0.06785625964403152, -0.004691015928983688, -0.016969695687294006, -0.042481161653995514, -0.022855347022414207, 0.02810806967318058, -0.02790251187980175, 0.02714170143008232, -0.032876547425985336, -0.027956560254096985, -0.02009337581694126, -0.03759147226810455, 0.006538992282003164, 0.005665677133947611, -0.029916852712631226, -0.05729774758219719, -0.006740338634699583, -0.03681931644678116, -0.037956152111291885, 0.036121733486652374, -0.020899200811982155, -0.014369847252964973, 0.02881871722638607, 0.01510000228881836, -0.019133377820253372, -0.002284061163663864, -0.005118084140121937, 0.004306614864617586, -0.0029103278648108244, 0.006699133664369583, -0.01125215832144022, 0.040004219859838486, -0.06328718364238739, 0.008130836300551891, -0.04411245882511139, 0.009382498450577259, -0.025569885969161987, -0.011868194676935673, 0.025323158130049706, 0.004173805005848408, -0.0012393944198265672, 0.015092325396835804, -0.00014583829033654183, 0.02780161425471306, -0.04023599997162819, 0.014646881259977818, -0.02231232263147831, 0.009363013319671154, 0.004401923157274723, 0.03539019823074341, -0.02546676993370056, -0.024142494425177574, 0.03578327223658562, -0.026033489033579826, -0.003599621821194887, -0.013301074504852295, 0.09034114331007004, 0.01440183725208044, 0.044274237006902695, 0.011420969851315022, 0.003475687699392438, -0.02393188327550888, 0.004745078273117542, 0.004712126217782497, -0.017272941768169403, 0.01089069526642561, -0.026170916855335236, 0.037403520196676254, 0.04073328152298927, -0.013614138588309288, 0.0007805527420714498, 0.01115428563207388, -0.030571339651942253, 0.027632836252450943, -0.028709575533866882, -0.05389896035194397, 0.008719204925000668, -0.0016289753839373589, 0.008603416383266449, -0.01585792563855648, 0.0022537040058523417, -0.020910128951072693, 0.05307754501700401, 0.0419955737888813, 0.015238725580275059, 0.0013859017053619027, -0.058965932577848434, 0.004511676728725433, -0.008073905482888222, -0.009243404492735863, 0.00466716755181551, 0.051182329654693604, -0.022141961380839348, -0.03392751142382622, -0.07117199897766113, 0.07424791902303696, 0.06764987111091614, -0.008315131068229675, 0.0048388210125267506, 0.021116355434060097, -0.06616411358118057, 0.01963428035378456, -0.048901353031396866, 0.02707108110189438, 0.0060420832596719265, -0.06408259272575378, 0.006238250993192196, -0.04934721067547798, 0.042077288031578064, -0.01587517373263836, 0.07541167736053467, -0.019762959331274033, 0.006986957509070635, 0.03180788829922676, -0.0007636389345861971, 0.03569803014397621, 0.010095111094415188, 0.039383869618177414, 0.026655470952391624, 0.030945461243391037, 0.011740336194634438, 0.01219793502241373, 0.005405900534242392, 0.017439991235733032, -0.012881373055279255, -0.014899639412760735, 0.04502362012863159, 0.05903393775224686, 0.000891487579792738, 0.07682767510414124, -0.015188376419246197, -0.045964982360601425, -0.042138952761888504, -0.04998772218823433, -0.004795899614691734, -0.051282498985528946, 0.059310585260391235, -0.0020413435995578766, -0.03425852209329605, 0.013698333874344826, -0.033382389694452286, 0.002253240905702114, 0.0010390868410468102, -0.03364824131131172, 0.02246670611202717, 0.035305991768836975, -0.015946058556437492, -0.002834204351529479, 0.0035929931327700615, -0.02130522020161152, -0.01452508196234703, -0.060580719262361526, -0.041087158024311066, 0.014177403412759304, -0.046794723719358444, -0.02324664779007435, -0.004489298444241285, -0.07875799387693405, -0.05037683621048927, 0.0833696573972702, -0.014678021892905235, -0.02232607826590538, -0.0677119567990303, 0.024394743144512177, 0.003522251034155488, -0.012284807860851288, 0.03522602096199989, -0.025662917643785477, -0.011374284513294697, -0.00042315482278354466, 0.022174660116434097, 0.0016576428897678852, 0.02009306289255619, -0.013090561144053936, -0.0696660503745079, -0.010591555386781693, -0.05460425838828087, 0.014489556662738323, -0.05016488954424858, -0.011668129824101925, -0.06417711079120636, 0.01637125201523304, 0.06445909291505814, -0.0059862020425498486, 0.00034180062357336283, 0.03975409269332886, -0.08170358836650848, -0.01004475075751543, -0.04941655322909355, -0.00899236835539341, -0.032011549919843674, -0.012739947065711021, 0.007762466091662645, 0.0699557512998581, -0.03250214830040932, -0.026701798662543297, -0.08172420412302017, -0.025616081431508064, 0.049633514136075974, 0.00047675761743448675, 0.028126850724220276, -0.05189114436507225, -0.0006008452619425952, -0.046486541628837585, 0.0036119138821959496, 0.0027651989366859198, 0.02663276344537735, 0.043355390429496765, 0.06643673032522202, 0.035599395632743835, -0.04444792866706848, -0.04384182393550873, 0.017475349828600883, 0.011946896091103554, -0.010525127872824669, -0.0007143373368307948, 0.021074114367365837, -0.03447789326310158, 0.040485989302396774, 0.020278235897421837, -0.09439855068922043, -0.0528363361954689, -0.005062325857579708, -0.013972044922411442, 0.09626379609107971, 0.0023366333916783333, -0.009161488153040409, 0.054159015417099, 0.007092611864209175, 0.0070152790285646915, -0.047928567975759506, -0.04466840997338295, -0.009204043075442314, -0.10333644598722458, 0.06745843589305878, -0.033516813069581985, -0.014550318010151386, 0.013336596079170704, 0.03026563487946987 ]
<p>I perform a permutation test multiple times on different datasets, each time I am only concerned about significant $p$ values. To reduce computation time would it be correct to introduce this kind of stopping rule: After a certain number of $N$ permutations to check whether $p$ is greater than a particular value. So, for example if $p&gt;0.1$ after $N$=200 permutations then the lower bound of 95% confidence interval would be greater than $0.05$. Therefore, calculations could be stopped as a true $p$ is not significant. Just want to make sure I am doing it right. Thank you.</p>
g74309
[ 0.02217843383550644, 0.041312240064144135, -0.01809101365506649, -0.03324192762374878, -0.050872866064310074, -0.028178289532661438, 0.061087556183338165, 0.021719738841056824, -0.11738698929548264, -0.003154499689117074, -0.03816849738359451, 0.03995603695511818, -0.02775106392800808, 0.021414969116449356, -0.007239399943500757, 0.023362038657069206, 0.07142135500907898, 0.011907451786100864, -0.055849816650152206, 0.03135788440704346, -0.03370998799800873, -0.011886636726558208, -0.028828389942646027, -0.02528311312198639, -0.022926386445760727, -0.01530788280069828, -0.02573147416114807, 0.055529121309518814, -0.08383609354496002, 0.0024654516018927097, 0.006181381642818451, -0.025782661512494087, 0.02649373933672905, -0.02536756359040737, -0.09577607363462448, -0.0010487916879355907, 0.0633692666888237, 0.031449705362319946, 0.034780293703079224, -0.005523864645510912, -0.0063821859657764435, 0.028291935101151466, 0.07171398401260376, -0.01657121069729328, -0.03034169226884842, -0.0018219419289380312, 0.013952504843473434, 0.006003965623676777, 0.03051522932946682, -0.05908166244626045, -0.03231623396277428, 0.009474211372435093, 0.021540991961956024, -0.005314207635819912, -0.021241772919893265, 0.05179133638739586, 0.004732092842459679, 0.02450370229780674, 0.022358514368534088, 0.007660478353500366, 0.02693753130733967, -0.05231184512376785, -0.035766374319791794, -0.044029947370290756, 0.013612605631351471, -0.002103327540680766, -0.004491228144615889, -0.001961438450962305, 0.027624549344182014, 0.014890920370817184, -0.02008017711341381, -0.01385581586509943, -0.02482050657272339, -0.019004402682185173, 0.007329929154366255, 0.015220409259200096, -0.02234550379216671, 0.018387774005532265, -0.03309055045247078, 0.03548330441117287, -0.021624965593218803, -0.013844609260559082, 0.005498959217220545, 0.042985495179891586, -0.03597598895430565, -0.016672896221280098, 0.022527234628796577, -0.03304968401789665, -0.016939586028456688, 0.06546416878700256, 0.010526513680815697, -0.015472829341888428, 0.05279858782887459, 0.03630984574556351, 0.030258163809776306, 0.046905290335416794, 0.007164600305259228, 0.003659798763692379, -0.017087537795305252, -0.006750927306711674, -0.002685883780941367, 0.05082341283559799, 0.01635880395770073, -0.05393277108669281, -0.05318569764494896, -0.005664778407663107, 0.021530184894800186, 0.007543697953224182, -0.04421459510922432, -0.022378016263246536, 0.023264845833182335, 0.013437244109809399, -0.08604490756988525, -0.006517587695270777, -0.06523951888084412, 0.057762015610933304, 0.060557715594768524, 0.003224453888833523, -0.06353399157524109, -0.027747750282287598, 0.017106348648667336, -0.03653299808502197, 0.0056253415532410145, 0.03571074828505516, 0.010899722576141357, -0.05242548882961273, -0.05467135086655617, 0.079838328063488, 0.026907652616500854, 0.07200013846158981, 0.02725895680487156, -0.0009064363548532128, -0.039747145026922226, 0.022132379934191704, -0.0297386571764946, -0.015716655179858208, 0.0474570207297802, 0.020508764311671257, 0.022238628938794136, -0.012025694362819195, -0.06998411566019058, 0.024492047727108, 0.0008946983143687248, -0.025942059233784676, 0.03405439853668213, -0.06310246884822845, 0.014970719814300537, -0.009184100665152073, -0.019125821068882942, -0.0002847765281330794, -0.017261963337659836, -0.002103182952851057, 0.02981162816286087, -0.04165171831846237, -0.024361062794923782, 0.021135620772838593, 0.01244499534368515, 0.04291961342096329, 0.02272874489426613, 0.10788124799728394, -0.045081727206707, 0.03278633952140808, 0.011334124952554703, 0.0038655747193843126, -0.013562338426709175, 0.04622425138950348, -0.033831484615802765, -0.0017062819097191095, -0.015413532964885235, -0.026687832549214363, 0.02139972522854805, -0.020939312875270844, 0.009026692248880863, -0.06647057086229324, 0.008781199343502522, -0.005703920032829046, 0.09831096231937408, -0.03032715432345867, 0.009720015339553356, 0.035288333892822266, -0.04229218512773514, 0.009694855660200119, -0.009204354137182236, 0.013449551537632942, 0.010459459386765957, 0.02120794914662838, -0.006675264332443476, -0.031872522085905075, -0.008595668710768223, -0.002215988701209426, -0.017606759443879128, -0.01852336898446083, 0.023532725870609283, 0.00583700742572546, -0.020286060869693756, -0.004099399317055941, 0.015537422150373459, -0.031275905668735504, -0.043342225253582, -0.017529025673866272, -0.0030956396367400885, 0.04851676523685455, -0.03074629232287407, 0.043097350746393204, 0.0026054081972688437, 0.022958356887102127, -0.01466799434274435, 0.00700252503156662, -0.0516430027782917, 0.052831731736660004, 0.03881046921014786, 0.023969393223524094, 0.009988008067011833, 0.06640107929706573, -0.0077279480174183846, 0.019280049949884415, 0.02059170976281166, 0.09154916554689407, 0.025054749101400375, 0.06870613992214203, 0.025351768359541893, -0.06405182927846909, 0.028856366872787476, -0.01664762757718563, 0.002915056422352791, 0.05815414711833, 0.016987113282084465, -0.05080072209239006, 0.00014055737119633704, 0.019864728674292564, -0.03742483630776405, -0.005082771647721529, -0.012896319851279259, -0.02904561161994934, 0.045220278203487396, -0.007097648456692696, -0.04144158214330673, 0.005479985848069191, 0.029998499900102615, -0.037704505026340485, 0.01778600551187992, 0.00014178473793435842, -0.006835500709712505, 0.015357350930571556, 0.02016310580074787, -0.04549550265073776, -0.07954580336809158, 0.010858253575861454, -0.002340879524126649, 0.03945194184780121, -0.05983525514602661, 0.0051034665666520596, -0.02707439661026001, 0.07401027530431747, 0.01148812472820282, -0.022344836965203285, 0.006144172046333551, 0.011424517259001732, 0.034875478595495224, 0.05127008631825447, 0.014181068167090416, -0.03502517566084862, 0.02575220726430416, -0.018150534480810165, 0.03949639946222305, -0.026820819824934006, -0.0176252368837595, -0.02423165738582611, 0.03992997109889984, 0.04616197198629379, 0.01338213961571455, -0.01839713752269745, 0.05017390474677086, 0.07031239569187164, 1.8932502143798047e-7, -0.01988641545176506, 0.015664203092455864, -0.013195148669183254, 0.021222317591309547, 0.03287297859787941, -0.03612169250845909, -0.060485657304525375, -0.055753327906131744, -0.012404283508658409, 0.006220618728548288, 0.020750494673848152, 0.06101638451218605, -0.02526327781379223, -0.04654542729258537, 0.06647109240293503, -0.004339081700891256, 0.031975388526916504, 0.02492530271410942, 0.0006359851104207337, -0.01153468620032072, -0.006487220525741577, -0.04287373647093773, -0.030783504247665405, 0.029051482677459717, -0.015127296559512615, -0.007562433369457722, 0.010295364074409008, -0.03755920007824898, 0.03970342129468918, 0.06463481485843658, -0.0018993329722434282, 0.0013866981025785208, 0.03577680513262749, -0.0037859410513192415, -0.010464729741215706, 0.003646631259471178, -0.019700193777680397, 0.027242645621299744, -0.001445228117518127, -0.004974665120244026, -0.003941089380532503, 0.05002150312066078, 0.029017247259616852, 0.016023240983486176, -0.05811198055744171, -0.01461988314986229, -0.03673125058412552, -0.021112723276019096, 0.012756593525409698, 0.007124274503439665, 0.003365682205185294, -0.034267544746398926, 0.05806587263941765, -0.02124922163784504, -0.0022245789878070354, 0.05639571323990822, 0.03697613999247551, 0.013546277768909931, -0.012572876177728176, -0.021191781386733055, -0.04949371516704559, 0.012489264830946922, -0.01216370053589344, 0.025137724354863167, 0.01167814340442419, -0.05559505894780159, -0.0043490007519721985, -0.010067553259432316, -0.027494635432958603, 0.02156326361000538, 0.03368242457509041, 0.011660798452794552, -0.025135157629847527, -0.01423647440969944, -0.03494821488857269, 0.016420673578977585, -0.02675429917871952, -0.009629391133785248, -0.027025600895285606, -0.009741660207509995, 0.06246049702167511, 0.002131866989657283, -0.021229835227131844, 0.034952521324157715, -0.007231921888887882, 0.029933590441942215, -0.007358670700341463, -0.04667087644338608, 0.0007637084927409887, 0.02034005895256996, 0.04622361436486244, -0.025401610881090164, 0.09265930950641632, 0.023226507008075714, -0.05238878354430199, -0.020402221009135246, -0.001485037850216031, 0.007903065532445908, -0.02301938831806183, 0.01181576307862997, -0.0009468666394241154, 0.045535117387771606, 0.04645325988531113, 0.045058801770210266, 0.05092485621571541, 0.032439760863780975, -0.014384977519512177, -0.055276624858379364, -0.009614793583750725, -0.02289603091776371, -0.007874920032918453, 0.013401364907622337, -0.0112405214458704, 0.026045383885502815, -0.028286123648285866, 0.013379831798374653, -0.04300358146429062, -0.052837736904621124, 0.03423714265227318, 0.017877832055091858, 0.0006800511036999524, -0.06089296564459801, 0.014427379705011845, 0.056836437433958054, 0.07959632575511932, -0.0020336234010756016, -0.016205312684178352, -0.009663056582212448, 0.036151714622974396, -0.001451745512895286, -0.02107023447751999, 0.009036699309945107, 0.08968693017959595, -0.021409956738352776, 0.018254781141877174, -0.03303466737270355, -0.03395279869437218, -0.027158493176102638, -0.05410146713256836, -0.04670898616313934, 0.003927098121494055, 0.016369890421628952, -0.033237263560295105, 0.0005343452212400734, -0.00802510417997837, 0.021641645580530167, 0.02970210090279579, -0.05488306283950806, -0.005808894522488117, 0.018761610612273216, 0.008338634856045246, 0.004418544005602598, -0.006911041680723429, -0.02195337787270546, -0.01328085083514452, 0.01619977504014969, 0.031596798449754715, -0.040125321596860886, 0.04593092203140259, 0.021590961143374443, -0.0286859180778265, -0.0558769591152668, 0.031177299097180367, -0.04299711436033249, -0.02003558725118637, -0.010253353044390678, 0.008111225441098213, -0.018263982608914375, 0.03394942358136177, 0.027129393070936203, 0.02216416783630848, -0.031141990795731544, -0.012914137914776802, 0.06462458521127701, 0.02617083303630352, -0.03344383463263512, 0.02904745377600193, 0.01712658256292343, 0.0001342021132586524, -0.011941015720367432, -0.024327801540493965, 0.010145348496735096, -0.025218751281499863, 0.019651856273412704, 0.07271358370780945, 0.065126433968544, -0.029197297990322113, -0.018154682591557503, 0.001749505172483623, 0.039512552320957184, -0.029607895761728287, -0.04538080096244812, -0.03610207140445709, 0.00518885487690568, 0.021177535876631737, 0.002649856498464942, 0.014618637040257454, -0.0015355126233771443, 0.00502188503742218, -0.030158767476677895, 0.0035503229591995478, -0.0194949209690094, 0.028897542506456375, 0.034885477274656296, 0.00682494044303894, -0.018076209351420403, 0.0009141121990978718, -0.012103656306862831, 0.0006079749437049031, 0.008810710161924362, -0.043462492525577545, -0.0009358615498058498, -0.11146026849746704, 0.08257419615983963, -0.02895154431462288, 0.05237524211406708, -0.012978353537619114, 0.10139351338148117, 0.02080446667969227, 0.014783119782805443, -0.07165245711803436, 0.03127910569310188, -0.024694884195923805, -0.06644672900438309, -0.05553864687681198, 0.006549902260303497, 0.022788021713495255, 0.03521528095006943, -0.07630988955497742, -0.07522410899400711, -0.011058306321501732, 0.07635923475027084, -0.022539526224136353, -0.016057856380939484, -0.005527500994503498, -0.006973320618271828, 0.023725563660264015, 0.030982473865151405, -0.05887589231133461, -0.023278890177607536, -0.0019110768334940076, -0.021455325186252594, -0.008827135898172855, -0.07765309512615204, -0.03818665072321892, 0.03730635344982147, -0.08156555145978928, -0.02452121116220951, 0.012116977013647556, 0.093189537525177, -0.08040504157543182, -0.012881079688668251, -0.06431180983781815, 0.011509060859680176, 0.024210529401898384, 0.051193900406360626, -0.019548574462532997, -0.036761533468961716, 0.024210255593061447, 0.032729558646678925, 0.004927451256662607, -0.057497937232255936, -0.031603164970874786, 0.0022844637278467417, -0.012964488938450813, -0.026674579828977585, 0.024345722049474716, 0.037880998104810715, -0.01685277745127678, -0.008308314718306065, -0.034776944667100906, -0.019679265096783638, -0.04134698957204819, 0.003417423227801919, -0.04069659858942032, 0.010217603296041489, 0.05100756138563156, -0.03746045008301735, -0.032187558710575104, -0.020677894353866577, 0.026396144181489944, 0.03369757533073425, 0.03490682691335678, 0.06424815207719803, 0.011419263668358326, -0.013067238964140415, -0.062306713312864304, -0.007467665243893862, -0.013119015842676163, 0.05388167127966881, -0.030987868085503578, -0.038959331810474396, 0.00810230616480112, -0.04693528637290001, 0.003966659773141146, 0.0924602746963501, 0.0007609679596498609, 0.0521300807595253, 0.08072836697101593, 0.010482779704034328, 0.06242545321583748, -0.03658692166209221, -0.009534398093819618, 0.012600107118487358, -0.07156196981668472, -0.04693491384387016, -0.05060319975018501, -0.0026969246100634336, 0.011162247508764267, 0.03350156173110008, 0.05314042419195175, -0.02274557203054428, 0.026535620912909508, -0.018516965210437775, -0.024014798924326897, -0.016788622364401817, -0.028604762628674507, -0.010001500137150288, 0.02946663275361061, 0.0601780079305172, -0.031613901257514954, 0.04486173763871193, -0.0205036960542202, -0.02914441004395485, 0.011465132236480713, 0.07997109740972519, -0.04388181492686272, 0.03989649936556816, -0.05465773120522499, -0.01373325940221548, 0.032368626445531845, 0.009573082439601421, -0.01533445529639721, -0.02787833660840988, 0.03092985413968563, 0.06216069310903549, -0.05886794999241829, 0.07816202938556671, 0.049246806651353836, -0.05423738434910774, -0.02216414548456669, 0.003635882865637541, -0.007016877643764019, -0.0011794907040894032, 0.03500185161828995, 0.05075962468981743, 0.014862901531159878, -0.012235577218234539, 0.0010512742446735501, 0.03190147876739502, 0.07995811849832535, 0.03898489475250244, -0.04679030552506447, 0.0614609494805336, 0.0252421535551548, -0.004296358674764633, -0.018867257982492447, -0.026403386145830154, 0.013092619366943836, -0.050020232796669006, 0.0023470937740057707, -0.05596666783094406, 0.0422014482319355, -0.011193916201591492, 0.06682786345481873, -0.04832910746335983, 0.022030580788850784, 0.019424667581915855, 0.002158570336177945, 0.028577987104654312, -0.0012708520516753197, 0.04765172302722931, 0.048150647431612015, -0.027068208903074265, -0.015422089025378227, 0.059197910130023956, 0.0720253512263298, -0.028813010081648827, -0.0219205841422081, -0.01798040047287941, 0.056123100221157074, 0.05898661911487579, 0.04474341869354248, 0.0635925680398941, -0.04228154569864273, -0.011971849016845226, -0.022471938282251358, -0.02594411000609398, 0.010010343044996262, 0.01859341189265251, 0.06963460147380829, -0.048609524965286255, -0.02740573137998581, 0.04531313106417656, -0.07714380323886871, 0.020085357129573822, -0.012561125680804253, -0.05682092532515526, -0.008409257978200912, 0.06796441972255707, 0.0041829743422567844, -0.01844518445432186, 0.004254557192325592, -0.04854263737797737, -0.003607876133173704, -0.04335762560367584, -0.015321547165513039, -0.05804627388715744, -0.013619368895888329, 0.038222309201955795, 0.03470185771584511, -0.06365174800157547, -0.01918385550379753, 0.002445438876748085, 0.014092992059886456, -0.01748017780482769, -0.06371907144784927, 0.026496442034840584, -0.03076302446424961, 0.004656876437366009, 0.012922354973852634, 0.025912543758749962, -0.028716739267110825, 0.01757092960178852, 0.05183689296245575, -0.010797143913805485, 0.04508742690086365, 0.008305041119456291, 0.007532609160989523, -0.024586286395788193, 0.025678109377622604, -0.06704892218112946, 0.011131372302770615, -0.049667418003082275, 0.03078783117234707, 0.019687237218022346, 0.0600578673183918, -0.032180484384298325, -0.002097225980833173, -0.019654568284749985, -0.026586517691612244, -0.0502576008439064, -0.04436132684350014, 0.023556675761938095, 0.002245844341814518, -0.024601107463240623, -0.06871258467435837, -0.05134942755103111, 0.007964963093400002, -0.022151686251163483, -0.05919918045401573, -0.021393584087491035, -0.002882023574784398, -0.0009343753335997462, 0.017438489943742752, -0.005734945181757212, -0.07141435891389847, -0.054764825850725174, 0.0323367714881897, 0.024777891114354134, -0.001490257796831429, -0.005139646586030722, -0.04264458268880844, -0.04043558984994888, -0.0009938948787748814, -0.0013950648717582226, -0.010337806306779385, 0.02738179825246334, -0.026090430095791817, -0.008548487909138203, -0.004105042200535536, -0.020012618973851204, 0.036282360553741455, 0.052050892263650894, -0.05212583765387535, -0.06136755272746086, -0.04170634597539902, 0.016888638958334923, 0.07449197769165039, 0.008523685857653618, 0.046330031007528305, 0.03948303312063217, -0.02424491010606289, 0.012443833984434605, 0.025995418429374695, 0.05522288754582405, -0.0011800865177065134, -0.10385541617870331, 0.020551545545458794, -0.006438467651605606, -0.03851364552974701, -0.004077063407748938, -0.021389499306678772 ]
<p>I have read other posts on conducting Factor analysis (FA) with dichotomous variables and although it appears clear that FA done in the default way is not appropriate, I am still unclear about a few things. </p> <p>I have 7 variables that are yes/no responses. They are assessing peoples functioning (e.g., working yes/no, involvement with justice system yes/no etc). I want to combine these responses to have two variables that represent domains of functioning (e.g., occupational and social). I suspect three of them will be occupational and 4 of them social. I would like to do something analogous to a FA to confirm this.</p> <p>I only have access to SPSS (and am only familiar with this package) so am looking for advice on how to do this with SPSS. </p> <p>Do I do a FA with tetrachoric correlations instead of Pearsons (how is this done?)? Or can I do Latent Trait Analysis in SPSS?</p> <p>I am specifically looking for references with step-by-step instructions. </p>
g74310
[ 0.026948686689138412, -0.0692051351070404, 0.01365379337221384, -0.045829977840185165, -0.015828797593712807, -0.023426109924912453, 0.05161837860941887, 0.030168650671839714, 0.0231670793145895, -0.047867581248283386, -0.008428317494690418, -0.04886366426944733, 0.05355501174926758, 0.012244640849530697, -0.08169269561767578, -0.00220676651224494, -0.013206548988819122, 0.020463164895772934, 0.0018745313864201307, 0.008926313370466232, 0.06908788532018661, 0.004897450562566519, 0.022911319509148598, 0.018690025433897972, -0.027371250092983246, -0.054183099418878555, -0.03307167813181877, 0.04139108583331108, -0.07359779626131058, -0.05248337984085083, -0.011333458125591278, 0.017951026558876038, 0.03252989426255226, 0.017486510798335075, -0.0077063580974936485, -0.0092049241065979, 0.03447949141263962, 0.04425360634922981, -0.0682186558842659, 0.02093658037483692, -0.0168662890791893, 0.0013354200636968017, 0.02820734679698944, -0.026113172993063927, -0.03383500128984451, 0.034225646406412125, -0.03360464796423912, -0.05349572375416756, 0.03287958726286888, 0.014247649349272251, 0.029264001175761223, 0.0044768922962248325, 0.004485544748604298, 0.02925119735300541, -0.011940108612179756, 0.014489071443676949, 0.052866917103528976, 0.02503299154341221, 0.03604044020175934, 0.021879544481635094, -0.018198426812887192, -0.024307850748300552, -0.06710385531187057, 0.004737571347504854, 0.0009901169687509537, -0.0003448501229286194, 0.07189182192087173, -0.03406626731157303, -0.025940556079149246, -0.03253430500626564, -0.03861120343208313, -0.07266227155923843, 0.084225133061409, -0.0593809150159359, -0.012989400885999203, -0.014241396449506283, -0.017360005527734756, -0.0035406791139394045, 0.023249885067343712, -0.002872508717700839, 0.07713276147842407, 0.0015078670112416148, 0.05465035140514374, 0.028470303863286972, 0.05429176241159439, -0.044542696326971054, -0.033147040754556656, -0.06242966279387474, 0.05627522990107536, -0.02111990563571453, -0.03094327636063099, 0.08853542059659958, 0.039861831814050674, 0.013981563039124012, -0.04182590916752815, 0.02688843570649624, -0.03920883312821388, 0.04088924080133438, -0.017604637891054153, -0.06434396654367447, -0.056907687336206436, -0.023232217878103256, -0.00836966186761856, -0.004445542115718126, -0.056847624480724335, -0.07275638729333878, 0.018126968294382095, 0.06747602671384811, -0.025320807471871376, 0.0005794288590550423, -0.07091837376356125, 0.045031022280454636, -0.05308801680803299, 0.02737593464553356, -0.03280579298734665, -0.017940713092684746, -0.019234690815210342, -0.025265805423259735, -0.059296224266290665, 0.004666132386773825, 0.02260649763047695, -0.016097713261842728, 0.047654133290052414, 0.06178642064332962, -0.09059729427099228, 0.020124051719903946, 0.0022386854980140924, 0.04754384979605675, 0.013903651386499405, -0.032742228358983994, 0.0391957089304924, -0.005713213700801134, 0.04983435571193695, 0.05237961933016777, -0.00687361229211092, 0.01500133890658617, 0.008073226548731327, 0.05532780662178993, -0.03667003661394119, 0.04427128657698631, -0.03452690318226814, 0.0018646984826773405, -0.010741299018263817, -0.03483591601252556, -0.016791565343737602, 0.03215784952044487, 0.006411956623196602, -0.03218623995780945, 0.006769469473510981, 0.003334432141855359, -0.026537738740444183, 0.03781043738126755, -0.02853500097990036, -0.007960482500493526, -0.058923013508319855, -0.02360769920051098, -0.01504505705088377, -0.06314579397439957, 0.021285181865096092, -0.004215511493384838, 0.013067289255559444, -0.028646836057305336, 0.020018195733428, 0.004011392593383789, 0.05209454521536827, -0.013837515376508236, -0.046429701149463654, 0.00021348749578464776, -0.007951932027935982, -0.00047412049025297165, 0.04415547102689743, -0.0025468114763498306, -0.03597761318087578, 0.0016978334169834852, 0.04204455390572548, -0.027975259348750114, 0.007761616259813309, -0.04609278216958046, 0.0012789212632924318, 0.07523525506258011, 0.009298182092607021, 0.015791842713952065, 0.001871807617135346, -0.005843891762197018, 0.03887612000107765, 0.021675989031791687, -0.003644939512014389, 0.06587127596139908, -0.05498207360506058, 0.024647943675518036, 0.0013406591024249792, -0.019915197044610977, -0.017566906288266182, -0.007735713850706816, -0.028036901727318764, -0.05521337315440178, 0.03258278965950012, -0.062355879694223404, -0.002730374690145254, -0.0660463497042656, 0.003008292056620121, -0.008357325568795204, 0.012648108415305614, 0.08113417029380798, -0.02368422970175743, 0.021526893600821495, -0.05511591210961342, 0.009026867337524891, -0.027220716699957848, -0.0021369289606809616, 0.04046167805790901, -0.02324327826499939, -0.018160393461585045, -0.005637547466903925, 0.02020971104502678, -0.04836299270391464, -0.05132725089788437, -0.026158107444643974, -0.01976155675947666, 0.007021170575171709, -0.017394790425896645, 0.006566697731614113, -0.015314778313040733, 0.0073038190603256226, -0.005372760351747274, 0.03285260498523712, -0.003328305436298251, -0.030955739319324493, 0.0038690774235874414, -0.0025375927798449993, -0.007958433590829372, -0.08559584617614746, 0.03832567483186722, -0.015251025557518005, 0.02400776371359825, -0.02454323135316372, -0.007621383294463158, -0.002771696774289012, -0.04341684281826019, 0.06086962670087814, 0.012167778797447681, 0.04895763099193573, 0.02856604941189289, 0.047495074570178986, 0.05052918940782547, 0.010917938314378262, 0.011955022811889648, -0.012767340056598186, -0.04003617912530899, 0.01922701671719551, -0.017608318477869034, 0.04477367922663689, -0.04614938795566559, -0.05859118327498436, 0.03258056938648224, 0.001128263073042035, 0.034974776208400726, 0.02626555971801281, 0.010133926756680012, 0.01603313721716404, -0.0014926238218322396, -0.0020720602478832006, 0.014064399525523186, 0.04258937016129494, 0.01981288380920887, -0.021559588611125946, 0.010012676008045673, -0.05584044009447098, -0.038782749325037, -0.015887519344687462, -0.02363116294145584, 0.010527137666940689, -0.018741974607110023, -0.0018851017812266946, 0.009637456387281418, 0.0029982689302414656, -0.04985109344124794, -0.005646722391247749, 0.018000241369009018, 0.046790074557065964, 0.016312245279550552, -0.001893556211143732, 0.05637571960687637, 0.035066694021224976, 0.04563404247164726, 0.05305260419845581, 0.0835183784365654, 0.009261003695428371, -0.05521421134471893, -0.018554547801613808, 0.009131844155490398, 0.040245719254016876, -0.039019856601953506, 0.004259066190570593, -0.01093981135636568, -0.014215645380318165, 0.03840932995080948, -0.05040569603443146, 0.04913179576396942, 0.08675321936607361, -0.030317068099975586, -0.06356353312730789, 0.010145332664251328, -0.011877711862325668, 0.04303290694952011, -0.11209355294704437, -0.02397872321307659, -0.016667505726218224, 0.017549041658639908, 0.0030819689854979515, -0.02160191908478737, -0.01603270322084427, 0.005346778780221939, -0.026267442852258682, 0.028886375948786736, -0.027881719172000885, 0.0408443808555603, -0.005310648586601019, 0.006125761661678553, -0.016102276742458344, 0.02236265502870083, -0.016853079199790955, 0.02087017148733139, 0.04162993282079697, -0.02373976819217205, 0.012722446583211422, -0.003397094551473856, 0.030887272208929062, -0.06259065121412277, 0.017344458028674126, 0.0035139345563948154, -0.05219568684697151, 0.051333870738744736, -0.012547764927148819, 0.02675669454038143, 0.003761407919228077, -0.018836624920368195, -0.0334557481110096, -0.010078120976686478, 0.012984327971935272, 0.019807104021310806, -0.09330356866121292, 0.009988304227590561, 0.016847306862473488, -0.032029081135988235, 0.017890268936753273, 0.009256530553102493, 0.06262807548046112, 0.047364842146635056, 0.017298301681876183, -0.030703900381922722, 0.012448008172214031, 0.008753607980906963, -0.002755270805209875, 0.04267606511712074, -0.03510235249996185, 0.07705876231193542, 0.026598507538437843, -0.06550426036119461, 0.013199567794799805, 0.03399582952260971, -0.007333345245569944, -0.020225146785378456, 0.026486409828066826, -0.014445364475250244, 0.0245107002556324, 0.03314734250307083, 0.07931738346815109, -0.036268796771764755, -0.014832482673227787, 0.07708709686994553, 0.0053443280048668385, -0.0261386726051569, -0.041300926357507706, 0.003473464399576187, -0.04564309120178223, 0.01603766344487667, -0.0165678933262825, 0.025549236685037613, 0.0504913404583931, 0.009254233911633492, 0.05370265990495682, 0.029145216569304466, 0.021157119423151016, 0.05559339001774788, -0.04993213340640068, 0.023562278598546982, 0.04132036864757538, 0.04649776220321655, -0.0021897205151617527, -0.05907539278268814, 0.02366127073764801, -0.0685199573636055, 0.05689224600791931, 0.07978127896785736, 0.00722493277862668, -0.0273788683116436, 0.005107612814754248, 0.008603044785559177, 0.0575840063393116, -0.029004070907831192, 0.025022044777870178, 0.04519497975707054, 0.005433453246951103, -0.04966530203819275, 0.013472083956003189, -0.008395235985517502, -0.05854426324367523, 0.005841290578246117, -0.03032490983605385, -0.007110223639756441, 0.01538203563541174, 0.05134417861700058, -0.0479784831404686, 0.01083424873650074, -0.03163936361670494, 0.03680618479847908, -0.02681228332221508, 0.034769024699926376, 0.01376673299819231, 0.01978195644915104, 0.05621511861681938, 0.02717486023902893, -0.0035865893587470055, 0.05156479403376579, -0.006751528009772301, 0.04691171273589134, 0.0009189540287479758, 0.01127515360713005, 0.030253790318965912, -0.011666381731629372, 0.04290728643536568, -0.004634849727153778, -0.006212785840034485, 0.03843984752893448, -0.0024648464750498533, -0.02742871455848217, 0.018550930544734, 0.014845921657979488, -0.008551386184990406, -0.06290056556463242, 0.03727683052420616, -0.03154005855321884, 0.013862899504601955, -0.014110766351222992, 0.0008039910462684929, -0.051227718591690063, -0.0428520143032074, 0.010511877946555614, 0.024925243109464645, 0.014926201663911343, 0.02732538804411888, -0.051060207188129425, 0.00223180977627635, -0.037987034767866135, -0.0009210669668391347, 0.05967364460229874, 0.031085040420293808, 0.02503560483455658, 0.030196906998753548, 0.027695145457983017, -0.08979102969169617, 0.0067408401519060135, -0.03282865509390831, -0.05108237266540527, -0.004679225850850344, -0.0004331713425926864, 0.015492373146116734, 0.02550831064581871, -0.02839690074324608, -0.04997768998146057, -0.07842183858156204, 0.0035877202171832323, -0.025774428620934486, 0.0712134838104248, -0.02479023113846779, 0.007804188411682844, -0.0343889556825161, 0.02316863089799881, 0.005522093735635281, 0.02221546694636345, 0.0015066041378304362, 0.06459422409534454, -0.011852726340293884, -0.014210892841219902, -0.04807916283607483, -0.007935849018394947, -0.050414521247148514, 0.019738901406526566, -0.02394247241318226, 0.005903797224164009, 0.04394137114286423, -0.004486893769353628, -0.01447995100170374, -0.022818615660071373, 0.043132565915584564, 0.018930792808532715, -0.04350340738892555, -0.0071599772199988365, 0.029301604256033897, -0.01750939153134823, 0.02800457365810871, 0.0008980347192846239, 0.02186082862317562, -0.04965747147798538, -0.006249081809073687, 0.11336230486631393, 0.011453110724687576, 0.009381265379488468, 0.06645890325307846, 0.008528400212526321, 0.0608353465795517, 0.028912702575325966, -0.025596044957637787, -0.058511629700660706, -0.010300841182470322, 0.033252425491809845, 0.008494951762259007, -0.0494389533996582, -0.03352416306734085, 0.043130796402692795, 0.0006841284921392798, -0.06714511662721634, 0.02722007967531681, -0.029976705089211464, -0.029248960316181183, 0.03133532404899597, -0.037608396261930466, 0.012666667811572552, -0.018429957330226898, -0.013507525436580181, 0.055089958012104034, 0.017212171107530594, 0.039164792746305466, 0.03511647507548332, -0.07646071910858154, -0.025672316551208496, 0.00574200926348567, -0.033193569630384445, 0.022330395877361298, -0.03911997005343437, 0.003822468686848879, -0.012192253023386002, -0.036764200776815414, -0.037290845066308975, 0.019929904490709305, 0.04187077656388283, 0.0328126922249794, -0.040220584720373154, 0.043163370341062546, -0.041610926389694214, -0.030739054083824158, -0.011467265896499157, 0.013784806244075298, -0.02391459234058857, -0.04137006029486656, 0.02912306599318981, 0.000596865953411907, 0.07790660113096237, -0.041321467608213425, -0.018120184540748596, -0.07970622181892395, -0.025442421436309814, 0.003329658415168524, 0.005150674842298031, 0.04208245873451233, -0.017523955553770065, 0.009128442965447903, -0.08010173588991165, 0.01158031914383173, 0.01973867230117321, -0.06772223114967346, 0.024464881047606468, -0.015731237828731537, -0.02628164179623127, -0.02563498541712761, 0.020289884880185127, 0.02212100476026535, 0.05038909986615181, 0.0014172024093568325, 0.07490261644124985, 0.018339211121201515, -0.05291236191987991, 0.05374191701412201, -0.01860274188220501, 0.02337382361292839, -0.01146312989294529, -0.006096626631915569, -0.1007203683257103, 0.016821449622511864, -0.0017349926056340337, -0.00877645518630743, -0.01463767234236002, 0.022781258448958397, 0.04031084477901459, -0.014849334955215454, 0.034774500876665115, 0.10662976652383804, -0.004453734960407019, 0.002669829875230789, 0.011823245324194431, -0.037009790539741516, 0.02966696210205555, -0.03034006804227829, 0.017400791868567467, 0.04100443795323372, 0.039970699697732925, 0.024091217666864395, -0.029407663270831108, 0.02572428062558174, -0.025931093841791153, -0.04872572794556618, 0.03715379163622856, 0.08907653391361237, 0.09645280987024307, -0.03112633526325226, -0.033125605434179306, -0.01768265664577484, -0.018217874690890312, 0.019461965188384056, -0.0020455478224903345, -0.04043631628155708, -0.018688268959522247, -0.039705146104097366, -0.027345670387148857, 0.04385756701231003, 0.006600772030651569, -0.04730019345879555, -0.016927151009440422, -0.014882934279739857, 0.008849824778735638, 0.019621102139353752, 0.0058928546495735645, -0.0009543204796500504, -0.06383442878723145, 0.056801676750183105, -0.04002264887094498, 0.08573136478662491, -0.005052722524851561, 0.033446379005908966, 0.03868231922388077, 0.04896477982401848, -0.029498256742954254, 0.03741436079144478, -0.0022941569332033396, 0.006590170785784721, 0.023845160380005836, 0.008123204112052917, -0.023031678050756454, 0.039129387587308884, 0.01751975528895855, 0.017532188445329666, 0.03219994530081749, -0.014409392140805721, -0.0024351945612579584, 0.00784137099981308, 0.04813980311155319, -0.03211243078112602, 0.03206641972064972, 0.031691182404756546, -0.02201889641582966, -0.059998769313097, -0.028721686452627182, -0.0067669604904949665, -0.0507906936109066, 0.057923149317502975, -0.006463146768510342, 0.03171991556882858, 0.04030066728591919, -0.0513598658144474, -0.05985258147120476, -0.013690105639398098, 0.02734946273267269, 0.022113656625151634, 0.011437793262302876, 0.03326070308685303, -0.03478338196873665, 0.011201786808669567, 0.011998040601611137, -0.05089328810572624, -0.022287195548415184, -0.020147493109107018, 0.01859218254685402, -0.019890114665031433, -0.024126823991537094, 0.010999104008078575, -0.004842984955757856, 0.03292100876569748, -0.01599227450788021, 0.011825078167021275, -0.0836377963423729, 0.007699219044297934, 0.014742731116712093, -0.05968295782804489, 0.014903349801898003, -0.022130977362394333, 0.020609712228178978, 0.006742429453879595, -0.04362478852272034, 0.09278158843517303, -0.022692076861858368, 0.035771679133176804, 0.005519381258636713, -0.02428242191672325, 0.0159359872341156, -0.0424267016351223, -0.029138240963220596, -0.03187863156199455, -0.019191090017557144, -0.005708800628781319, -0.002744769910350442, 0.04841325804591179, -0.06839197874069214, 0.025815460830926895, -0.00959706399589777, -0.027601292356848717, -0.008758693933486938, -0.02254413068294525, 0.01352622453123331, 0.03500122204422951, 0.006607385817915201, -0.05451437085866928, -0.01414939109236002, -0.009055194444954395, -0.0014648999786004424, -0.07887445390224457, -0.0026943509001284838, 0.05402989313006401, -0.010390463285148144, -0.023081496357917786, -0.04702511802315712, -0.06955673545598984, -0.032560572028160095, 0.04299001395702362, 0.0015130266547203064, -0.014648261480033398, 0.04190002754330635, 0.0009228374110534787, -0.05190280079841614, 0.04609031230211258, -0.0015268765855580568, -0.01716781221330166, -0.04507707431912422, 0.008080299012362957, 0.00976153276860714, -0.03185464069247246, -0.012823188677430153, 0.06182529777288437, 0.034776151180267334, 0.0015783276176080108, -0.04806314408779144, 0.01282313372939825, -0.003829633817076683, -0.011140413582324982, 0.029472116380929947, -0.009774815291166306, 0.011058325879275799, 0.0076215509325265884, 0.030937980860471725, -0.028661120682954788, 0.04728859290480614, -0.004995550494641066, -0.036233335733413696, 0.06419606506824493, -0.03463508561253548, -0.07653505355119705, -0.027780655771493912, 0.05483345314860344 ]
<p>I have a time series data set. I can decompose it and get the trend but I would like to put confidence ranges around the trend (past) not the forecast-ed component. The decompose function also doesn't handle N/As very well so is there another way to define the trend with data that has N/As. I have been trying to use Holt-Winters and ARIMA but neither seem to be able to do this.</p>
g74311
[ -0.007534715346992016, -0.03207402303814888, -0.005242462269961834, -0.05895969271659851, -0.026363253593444824, 0.0033780341036617756, 0.02467496693134308, -0.024136079475283623, -0.04705067351460457, -0.04205215722322464, 0.026198411360383034, 0.0028428900986909866, 0.05278220772743225, 0.005563138052821159, -0.02741328999400139, 0.04599735885858536, 0.0013827320653945208, 0.00557980639860034, 0.0021788051817566156, 0.03479452803730965, 0.03479388728737831, -0.006380288861691952, 0.04123251885175705, -0.020266177132725716, -0.007773572113364935, -0.002988329855725169, -0.0054536364041268826, 0.04694436118006706, -0.0478319376707077, 0.01995168998837471, 0.08213793486356735, 0.02541373297572136, 0.01822035387158394, 0.03499716520309448, 0.016551075503230095, -0.024129593744874, -0.012232779525220394, -0.00157666124869138, 0.0067099351435899734, -0.03179556876420975, -0.006814119406044483, 0.03618849813938141, 0.05724240094423294, 0.03861592710018158, -0.008870567195117474, -0.02081792801618576, -0.04535122588276863, -0.07121217250823975, -0.013815689831972122, -0.02080347016453743, 0.051399875432252884, 0.016766175627708435, 0.03762881085276604, -0.026764335110783577, 0.01226088684052229, -0.0023215466644614935, 0.04789252206683159, 0.009833654388785362, 0.005009502172470093, 0.0010727673070505261, -0.025425046682357788, -0.032336339354515076, -0.001986519433557987, -0.05099070072174072, 0.04977269098162651, 0.03592908754944801, -0.015676839277148247, -0.02998882159590721, -0.010262901894748211, -0.012594521045684814, 0.038402508944272995, 0.042998868972063065, 0.0032023219391703606, -0.004857917781919241, -0.05813078209757805, -0.0006742857513017952, -0.044403593987226486, -0.009491945616900921, -0.005556289106607437, 0.07386190444231033, -0.06038839742541313, 0.05237169936299324, 0.001809474779292941, -0.03264901787042618, 0.04671107605099678, -0.03827719762921333, 0.045746948570013046, -0.014289001002907753, 0.06013796851038933, -0.007559475488960743, -0.03628232702612877, 0.06640029698610306, 0.07126206159591675, 0.02877568081021309, 0.058224815875291824, 0.012225637212395668, -0.0515492744743824, 0.040975939482450485, 0.001226799562573433, -0.021490903571248055, 0.008306165225803852, 0.05143852159380913, 0.0066788652911782265, -0.05567192658782005, -0.03553079813718796, -0.028057001531124115, 0.02044745720922947, -0.042852483689785004, 0.0047238669358193874, -0.02032286487519741, 0.01153782568871975, 0.012457677163183689, -0.10632672905921936, 0.016154538840055466, 0.025755533948540688, -0.017584195360541344, -0.003909580875188112, -0.029629679396748543, -0.026182929053902626, -0.041342079639434814, 0.03335349261760712, -0.01455149706453085, 0.03786158934235573, 0.05068235471844673, -0.015263750217854977, -0.042493030428886414, 0.002209757687523961, 0.09690696001052856, 0.030791688710451126, -0.09662067890167236, 0.0542210191488266, -0.010105024091899395, 0.005022902972996235, 0.05386348441243172, -0.015599498525261879, 0.02457989938557148, -0.045454204082489014, 0.015459423884749413, -0.08286706358194351, 0.04342491179704666, 0.01864711567759514, 0.03117627650499344, 0.03239018842577934, -0.06892964988946915, 0.009778982028365135, -0.01772519201040268, -0.036840759217739105, -0.01621626876294613, 0.04146084189414978, 0.03034602291882038, 0.015771515667438507, 0.0518186055123806, -0.06251697987318039, -0.038169682025909424, -0.007448893040418625, -0.011865431442856789, 0.01783568598330021, -0.007635749876499176, -0.04320099949836731, 0.006564290728420019, 0.00962864886969328, 0.03895179182291031, 0.03187938779592514, -0.04761368781328201, 0.015385281294584274, -0.02594231814146042, 0.012420604936778545, -0.010910038836300373, -0.026438627392053604, -0.027221830561757088, -0.006339987274259329, 0.037855517119169235, -0.01173726562410593, -0.006587715819478035, 0.04154226556420326, 0.038114313036203384, 0.007850340567529202, 0.0007385701755993068, 0.011467565782368183, 0.03982566297054291, 0.036638177931308746, 0.05594002455472946, 0.03854026645421982, 0.036712922155857086, -0.01680939272046089, -0.004293718840926886, 0.048721738159656525, 0.0059863608330488205, 0.002432158449664712, -0.021944349631667137, 0.015425599180161953, -0.014117390848696232, -0.027516581118106842, 0.027982881292700768, 0.0028309556655585766, -0.05032834783196449, -0.011079942807555199, -0.0870014876127243, -0.03479558974504471, 0.037588369101285934, -0.006912878714501858, -0.0040769209153950214, -0.044918883591890335, 0.027885358780622482, -0.0037383779417723417, 0.008036240935325623, 0.01633331924676895, -0.008038233034312725, -0.023459473624825478, -0.003121202578768134, 0.009524693712592125, -0.07408978790044785, -0.03906016796827316, -0.010875587351620197, 0.031795039772987366, -0.011486165225505829, -0.012338184751570225, 0.061267703771591187, 0.009244931861758232, 0.029752900823950768, -0.03648706153035164, -0.03721680864691734, 0.03735073655843735, 0.027277125045657158, -0.005926050245761871, 0.05366484075784683, 0.050643570721149445, 0.06116894260048866, 0.027515405789017677, -0.01965566724538803, -0.031050778925418854, -0.02602482959628105, -0.07246143370866776, 0.000776020111516118, 0.05254989489912987, -0.037505652755498886, -0.008181288838386536, -0.00909752119332552, 0.04740539565682411, 0.03475119173526764, -0.051199622452259064, 0.030344508588314056, 0.009112848900258541, -0.007450581528246403, 0.03413735330104828, -0.01887982152402401, -0.031308747828006744, 0.010711788199841976, 0.025083450600504875, 0.05292290076613426, -0.009113575331866741, 0.020200533792376518, -0.050441674888134, -0.011529210954904556, 0.00000801180794951506, -0.03756590187549591, -0.01722070574760437, -0.057694509625434875, -0.013005312532186508, -0.05146476998925209, -0.014473095536231995, 0.020335162058472633, 0.019986512139439583, 0.008382578380405903, 0.04856511950492859, -0.025681255385279655, 0.0044474429450929165, -0.01842733472585678, 0.029457900673151016, 0.04496628791093826, 0.000662465114146471, -0.009083540178835392, 0.0818193256855011, 0.03584122285246849, -0.02972300909459591, 0.015110832639038563, 0.018865710124373436, -0.04955446347594261, -0.007377699948847294, -0.008818223141133785, 0.006802673917263746, -0.021487845107913017, 0.03711661323904991, -0.002440886339172721, -0.0008647146751172841, 0.002089391928166151, 0.06121157482266426, 0.03646538406610489, -0.028932463377714157, 0.024019675329327583, 0.009672907181084156, -0.03290875628590584, 0.024256113916635513, -0.0023134551011025906, -0.013008905574679375, 0.02824138104915619, 0.024525592103600502, -0.046623457223176956, 0.09621056169271469, -0.06461223214864731, -0.03197896108031273, -0.07249818742275238, -0.007987224496901035, -0.02359701879322529, 0.056868597865104675, -0.009539764374494553, -0.01778319478034973, 0.004972852300852537, -0.00598043343052268, -0.013728037476539612, -0.0469977930188179, -0.034907951951026917, -0.004793359898030758, 0.004351943265646696, -0.027095714583992958, -0.005896055605262518, 0.011535960249602795, -0.0017144459998235106, 0.052411746233701706, -0.025543641299009323, 0.008604162372648716, -0.050203464925289154, 0.07060933113098145, -0.01478071603924036, -0.004529841244220734, 0.04034031927585602, 0.006215309724211693, 0.07966910302639008, -0.011899681761860847, -0.014955718070268631, 0.01895900070667267, -0.050621066242456436, 0.09640786796808243, 0.0030761559028178453, -0.022377967834472656, -0.013746680691838264, 0.01278515625745058, -0.015698222443461418, -0.012635895982384682, -0.05316092073917389, -0.04607870429754257, 0.018461627885699272, 0.02568787708878517, 0.040517400950193405, 0.019846610724925995, -0.011341841891407967, -0.008126425556838512, 0.03339213505387306, 0.000767464516684413, 0.0031737869139760733, -0.04267390817403793, -0.023986216634511948, 0.01955675706267357, -0.026314353570342064, 0.018084336072206497, 0.008631227537989616, 0.006862308364361525, -0.050803426653146744, 0.07643324136734009, -0.002779259579256177, 0.008497660979628563, -0.041384823620319366, -0.0011209761723876, 0.013403026387095451, 0.027457818388938904, -0.027347346767783165, 0.038215577602386475, 0.09849999099969864, -0.040451597422361374, 0.00059317029081285, 0.06122234836220741, 0.017473556101322174, 0.04471269249916077, -0.04268365353345871, -0.030954578891396523, -0.006210799794644117, 0.011186396703124046, 0.0057624951004981995, 0.020654955878853798, 0.06125602126121521, 0.004247862845659256, 0.003474571043625474, 0.004770276136696339, -0.015164736658334732, -0.058261629194021225, -0.005838919430971146, -0.0009488272480666637, -0.02510438673198223, 0.0033628088422119617, -0.027692388743162155, 0.012412387877702713, -0.028737617656588554, -0.002951705129817128, 0.051642872393131256, -0.009340601041913033, -0.05847024917602539, -0.007689758203923702, 0.06127142533659935, -0.05800732225179672, 0.03391093388199806, -0.0017619539285078645, 0.03929658979177475, 0.0033478266559541225, 0.03337835893034935, 0.014848947525024414, -0.01657634973526001, 0.010125129483640194, -0.058377087116241455, -0.022728633135557175, -0.08160854130983353, -0.03369481489062309, -0.02541361004114151, 0.022056469693779945, -0.007931663654744625, 0.04413844645023346, -0.030700458213686943, 0.09777915477752686, 0.0008166063344106078, 0.006253465078771114, 0.042919475585222244, -0.08107290416955948, 0.10650676488876343, -0.04321105778217316, 0.03175097703933716, -0.03399774432182312, -0.001574717927724123, 0.02977227047085762, -0.020328417420387268, -0.030399128794670105, 0.05412338674068451, 0.0326448455452919, -0.0031884852796792984, 0.03731571137905121, 0.013069667853415012, -0.02011466771364212, -0.015516082756221294, 0.0033864628057926893, -0.014871014282107353, -0.008001578040421009, -0.06823532283306122, -0.04209127649664879, -0.02508784458041191, 0.022769059985876083, -0.00046461145393550396, -0.03514533489942551, 0.06133818253874779, -0.020367251709103584, -0.006062258966267109, -0.0018154375720769167, 0.102585569024086, -0.01992146670818329, 0.003649910446256399, -0.020310482010245323, -0.01419450156390667, 0.05582387372851372, -0.030377916991710663, -0.017344273626804352, 0.014179186895489693, 0.019790878519415855, 0.048485103994607925, -0.030195245519280434, -0.05453745275735855, -0.017143206670880318, -0.045687466859817505, -0.03908734768629074, -0.032099317759275436, -0.06207837909460068, -0.02101259119808674, 0.09595958888530731, -0.01945166289806366, 0.009531675837934017, -0.0032571840565651655, 0.00504731759428978, -0.03575463965535164, -0.0035845621023327112, 0.05166241526603699, 0.039059948176145554, -0.04415995627641678, -0.0012881592847406864, 0.025692613795399666, -0.03660903871059418, 0.03910360485315323, 0.06269539892673492, 0.034813378006219864, -0.030237523838877678, 0.004104903899133205, -0.017209043726325035, -0.0740107074379921, 0.020222878083586693, -0.013556387275457382, 0.0004861142369918525, 0.03728911280632019, 0.05609475448727608, 0.014234485104680061, 0.008368248119950294, 0.01018612366169691, 0.013994237408041954, -0.02390788309276104, -0.031597234308719635, 0.002635637763887644, -0.010791822336614132, 0.006770995911210775, -0.022157128900289536, -0.002756392350420356, -0.01236102357506752, 0.012891970574855804, 0.058950141072273254, 0.04837195575237274, -0.025059744715690613, 0.01990519091486931, 0.04081925377249718, 0.024514146149158478, 0.09098116308450699, -0.03433665633201599, 0.03827127069234848, 0.019430283457040787, -0.0294963289052248, 0.02202514186501503, -0.026045987382531166, -0.05420559644699097, 0.003219273407012224, 0.02146112360060215, 0.03467462584376335, 0.028089428320527077, 0.05373592674732208, -0.01210020948201418, -0.047131214290857315, -0.08626575767993927, -0.006391229573637247, -0.038477640599012375, 0.07217281311750412, -0.02683534100651741, -0.0013672414934262633, -0.061839353293180466, 0.02174912393093109, -0.041381433606147766, -0.023192686960101128, 0.046696167439222336, 0.02050323411822319, -0.03806844353675842, -0.05246216058731079, 0.06157078221440315, 0.02996795065701008, -0.02717217244207859, -0.05473708361387253, 0.005259471479803324, -0.01593274064362049, -0.03159511089324951, 0.008541758172214031, 0.01745492033660412, 0.05286349356174469, -0.00407943781465292, -0.06593305617570877, -0.09300093352794647, -0.05148414149880409, 0.019182145595550537, 0.04434454068541527, -0.010428240522742271, -0.05998259037733078, -0.01654014363884926, -0.045748818665742874, -0.052366919815540314, 0.037632741034030914, 0.020128237083554268, -0.06555257737636566, 0.026925845071673393, -0.01795533485710621, 0.029160596430301666, -0.055640481412410736, -0.00014251928951125592, 0.02040109969675541, -0.05811857432126999, 0.08088811486959457, 0.04658989980816841, -0.008858989924192429, -0.04776940122246742, 0.0084461634978652, 0.0003103261115029454, 0.03246825560927391, -0.0007741159060969949, -0.031928349286317825, -0.06058594211935997, 0.0029042051173746586, 0.05206967517733574, -0.03811727091670036, 0.0000956157673499547, -0.0006629791459999979, -0.0027001171838492155, -0.00583140691742301, 0.00010730496433097869, -0.0542277954518795, 0.02689136005938053, -0.003622551681473851, -0.03645772486925125, 0.009786880575120449, 0.0046090115793049335, -0.022069832310080528, -0.01944233849644661, -0.014436570927500725, -0.003000593511387706, -0.04362349957227707, -0.022757498547434807, 0.026264172047376633, -0.01103831548243761, -0.009189307689666748, 0.01896713115274906, 0.035756953060626984, 0.01781841553747654, 0.009282032959163189, -0.025790084153413773, -0.012602439150214195, 0.009655175730586052, 0.05703599378466606, 0.07991120964288712, 0.0772223025560379, 0.01261967420578003, 0.005817607045173645, 0.044278379529714584, -0.10834585875272751, 0.020029259845614433, 0.015874765813350677, -0.012027926743030548, -0.03107348084449768, 0.044742535799741745, 0.03244269639253616, 0.05712907016277313, -0.012494160793721676, 0.03955188766121864, 0.014472787268459797, 0.006755336653441191, -0.001798400771804154, -0.024195395410060883, -0.022810136899352074, -0.030355919152498245, -0.046781934797763824, -0.022145966067910194, -0.004572070203721523, 0.05912988632917404, 0.05397333949804306, -0.008518078364431858, -0.028130149468779564, 0.020471107214689255, -0.022687561810016632, 0.0006571676349267364, -0.02999677136540413, -0.018941553309559822, 0.04874280467629433, 0.010883569717407227, -0.04337859898805618, 0.054631054401397705, 0.011023588478565216, -0.012420273385941982, -0.003250773996114731, -0.02450612187385559, 0.02677030861377716, 0.024844713509082794, 0.02215682715177536, 0.01741783879697323, -0.018794747069478035, -0.035355642437934875, -0.04901920258998871, -0.06464904546737671, 0.026916923001408577, -0.0218432005494833, 0.057811371982097626, 0.0234676580876112, 0.022271962836384773, 0.032462477684020996, -0.030156977474689484, -0.04170796647667885, -0.01729167439043522, -0.06685134768486023, 0.045555468648672104, -0.006085321772843599, 0.012990782037377357, 0.015216321684420109, 0.017673064023256302, 0.02324199676513672, -0.0011918263044208288, -0.011770079843699932, -0.0135940071195364, -0.019646193832159042, 0.016645433381199837, -0.009557054378092289, 0.058014869689941406, 0.06325952708721161, 0.022141803056001663, 0.004665701184421778, 0.0906091034412384, -0.04474359750747681, -0.04825989902019501, -0.019322995096445084, -0.0011664490448310971, -0.009851625189185143, -0.030711669474840164, -0.014192064292728901, -0.003724690992385149, -0.03328203037381172, -0.034791477024555206, -0.014109103940427303, -0.001495735952630639, 0.05219419300556183, 0.038079503923654556, -0.036197591572999954, -0.023925846442580223, -0.0007890822016634047, -0.021491268649697304, -0.07054723799228668, -0.0272148996591568, -0.02637030929327011, -0.04739510267972946, 0.0860629752278328, 0.0313374325633049, -0.06111873686313629, -0.0007165698916651309, 0.0411534383893013, 0.03865290805697441, -0.060319192707538605, -0.0593934990465641, -0.013052043505012989, -0.02424992062151432, -0.05298686400055885, 0.006554911378771067, -0.0025115860626101494, -0.014564908109605312, -0.07378228008747101, -0.024428581818938255, 0.06200513616204262, -0.007694000843912363, -0.047440383583307266, -0.042178574949502945, 0.0012130232062190771, -0.03847195580601692, 0.062496598809957504, 0.04315873607993126, 0.016990501433610916, 0.026443887501955032, -0.018436718732118607, -0.028875116258859634, 0.048211898654699326, -0.04618168994784355, -0.03252553567290306, 0.03429427370429039, -0.0012336584040895104, 0.008450784720480442, -0.002833489328622818, -0.009105958975851536, 0.06286312639713287, 0.03590960055589676, -0.02339794859290123, -0.09256848692893982, 0.03027488850057125, -0.02188017964363098, 0.015850858762860298, -0.019842825829982758, 0.050051067024469376, 0.015031611546874046, -0.011724746786057949, 0.033619217574596405, 0.0019152694148942828, -0.0052810595370829105, -0.030427170917391777, -0.035913169384002686, 0.009987995028495789, -0.048563744872808456, -0.02809460088610649, -0.032449766993522644, 0.03156448155641556 ]
<p>I have a data set and I have to fit this data set with a stable distribution. The problem is that the stable distributions are known analytically only in the form of the characteristic function (Fourier transform). How can I do this?</p>
g74312
[ 0.005412552040070295, -0.025748105719685555, -0.015723664313554764, -0.06995480507612228, 0.03286200016736984, -0.028595389798283577, -0.07098548114299774, 0.00017578707775101066, -0.05352608487010002, -0.030592992901802063, -0.0036700856871902943, 0.013322469778358936, 0.04759952053427696, 0.0394723080098629, -0.007894380949437618, 0.024121547117829323, 0.020398834720253944, 0.028174133971333504, 0.032188039273023605, 0.018281880766153336, -0.05228656902909279, -0.036352962255477905, 0.07991453260183334, -0.02831147611141205, 0.006737048272043467, -0.07513263076543808, 0.004177737515419722, 0.01546143926680088, -0.008153450675308704, 0.02044781483709812, 0.007448548451066017, 0.02465835213661194, 0.07214415073394775, 0.011894691735506058, -0.0035788652021437883, -0.030425535514950752, 0.014183975756168365, 0.05183448642492294, 0.03885839134454727, 0.026604939252138138, -0.004713679198175669, 0.005333744455128908, 0.016168668866157532, -0.002266042632982135, 0.01404579821974039, 0.003671834012493491, -0.03773567080497742, 0.004788953345268965, -0.036176566034555435, -0.01546858437359333, -0.01713939569890499, 0.025002118200063705, -0.0025600625667721033, -0.0041832709684967995, -0.043848756700754166, -0.023995637893676758, -0.011075220070779324, -0.0014005975099280477, 0.0011601339792832732, -0.038860298693180084, -0.03374064341187477, -0.06895024329423904, -0.05187669023871422, -0.034377455711364746, -0.013910111039876938, -0.006754628382623196, -0.018120409920811653, -0.061985600739717484, 0.019376732409000397, -0.02919335477054119, -0.003252733265981078, -0.016064181923866272, 0.062186673283576965, -0.008532282896339893, -0.03099534660577774, -0.06599093973636627, -0.023811915889382362, 0.03019055724143982, -0.04581029340624809, 0.03251131623983383, -0.03101002238690853, 0.032308999449014664, 0.012777895666658878, -0.05359727889299393, -0.04580124467611313, -0.06713277101516724, 0.09878318011760712, -0.033972956240177155, 0.025996264070272446, 0.01520618237555027, -0.032779768109321594, 0.009192419238388538, 0.018774325028061867, 0.013416614383459091, 0.05945870652794838, 0.011394339613616467, -0.057371869683265686, 0.05584568902850151, -0.011919299140572548, -0.020723477005958557, 0.03376876562833786, 0.038912735879421234, -0.0350135937333107, 0.008686261251568794, -0.03701634705066681, 0.008109591901302338, 0.013699689880013466, -0.0003247518325224519, 0.018194444477558136, -0.035772230476140976, -0.0010733730159699917, -0.01920439675450325, 0.009142139926552773, -0.02207794040441513, 0.006800963077694178, -0.030969668179750443, -0.009534535929560661, -0.040546853095293045, -0.010419309139251709, 0.029586348682641983, 0.009654687717556953, -0.03892301768064499, 0.06754370033740997, 0.0362241230905056, 0.015494831837713718, 0.0016887880628928542, -0.003112174803391099, 0.0537135973572731, 0.03940364718437195, -0.04701003432273865, 0.06787855178117752, 0.013617523945868015, -0.001764350337907672, -0.021093914285302162, 0.021552657708525658, 0.028008857741951942, -0.03248471021652222, 0.06710328906774521, -0.03332648053765297, 0.07008172571659088, 0.02940790168941021, 0.01096038706600666, 0.04369674250483513, -0.011448454111814499, 0.0009301903191953897, 0.01610911265015602, 0.0034393626265227795, -0.034990373998880386, 0.028019435703754425, 0.001184496795758605, -0.016021041199564934, 0.074571892619133, -0.02682356908917427, -0.03360723704099655, 0.02152125909924507, 0.01365632563829422, 0.06768707931041718, 0.04548292234539986, -0.008559216745197773, -0.029410120099782944, 0.047853805124759674, -0.00969571340829134, -0.07982666790485382, -0.031154043972492218, -0.0015503217000514269, 0.04077821224927902, -0.07225394994020462, -0.012477554380893707, -0.015619407407939434, 0.014975492842495441, 0.0200906191021204, 0.05690484121441841, -0.008467410691082478, 0.03339575231075287, -0.014023980125784874, -0.007440680637955666, -0.035827890038490295, 0.016872987151145935, 0.09821076691150665, 0.02151821181178093, 0.0014052033657208085, 0.016615767031908035, 0.015356503427028656, -0.08494868129491806, 0.07651197165250778, 0.0036483570002019405, 0.019512362778186798, 0.006898107007145882, -0.0662682056427002, 0.04605734720826149, -0.001651284983381629, 0.0032368116080760956, -0.011879216879606247, 0.010195829905569553, 0.002262975089251995, -0.030947882682085037, 0.03630246967077255, -0.03705316409468651, -0.020889030769467354, -0.016065817326307297, 0.07260336726903915, 0.05611385777592659, 0.034309692680835724, 0.04596338048577309, 0.027946172282099724, -0.006661812774837017, -0.00981163140386343, -0.005244019906967878, -0.03872746601700783, 0.001620778813958168, -0.010835389606654644, -0.11117840558290482, 0.033738188445568085, 0.008821098133921623, 0.0055581871420145035, -0.046426281332969666, 0.018016939982771873, -0.0034493226557970047, -0.039772599935531616, 0.009444925002753735, -0.023449718952178955, -0.01498874556273222, 0.01105176005512476, 0.014777038246393204, 0.013477054424583912, -0.012194814160466194, 0.02564551867544651, -0.018553929403424263, -0.02038716897368431, -0.02894526720046997, -0.07578302919864655, -0.06398700922727585, 0.041740644723176956, 0.0490441620349884, 0.018257105723023415, 0.04544670507311821, -0.07851988822221756, 0.02061484381556511, 0.045527853071689606, 0.06672225892543793, -0.02419881895184517, -0.013480541296303272, 0.013152516447007656, -0.015021206811070442, 0.02220163866877556, 0.045471303164958954, 0.00039723471854813397, 0.023087171837687492, 0.015006928704679012, -0.016443965956568718, -0.027153976261615753, -0.00111318938434124, 0.04617105796933174, -0.04718396067619324, -0.04846170172095299, -0.09519048035144806, -0.017201116308569908, 0.003865693463012576, 0.006201768759638071, -0.017415959388017654, -0.05062280222773552, 0.005342123098671436, 0.00700599467381835, -0.00715250987559557, -0.06560157984495163, -0.004915195982903242, 0.06349149346351624, -0.028428640216588974, -0.015092522837221622, 0.00886926893144846, 0.03209517523646355, 0.0010784141486510634, 0.033418841660022736, 0.06635444611310959, -0.005142710637301207, 0.024985281750559807, -0.011349971406161785, -0.03404833748936653, -0.05169887840747833, -0.052037011831998825, 0.040157925337553024, -0.05845004692673683, -0.002317076548933983, 0.018411019816994667, -0.017434462904930115, -0.024937748908996582, 0.06532445549964905, 0.017808400094509125, -0.01364208199083805, -0.005119893699884415, -0.009069799445569515, -0.007771370001137257, -0.023931480944156647, -0.022813769057393074, -0.04000873863697052, -0.018184926360845566, -0.0070840478874742985, -0.03377141058444977, 0.06449246406555176, -0.02077256143093109, -0.015239779837429523, -0.028008103370666504, -0.017061317339539528, -0.05727478489279747, 0.03022238053381443, -0.03607725352048874, -0.04107813909649849, 0.03231734409928322, 0.030841929838061333, -0.010397625155746937, -0.045551713556051254, -0.005354567896574736, -0.0787072628736496, 0.0020829373970627785, -0.041021380573511124, 0.017898259684443474, -0.0015407768078148365, -0.005841538310050964, 0.03401770815253258, -0.06538195163011551, 0.050467438995838165, -0.04798852652311325, 0.004868263378739357, -0.008101681247353554, 0.01924455352127552, 0.026320019736886024, -0.016028473153710365, 0.004898211918771267, -0.02369234338402748, -0.042026154696941376, 0.03996676951646805, 0.017250772565603256, 0.033885080367326736, -0.03666084259748459, -0.032189950346946716, -0.02904629148542881, 0.0028786056209355593, -0.0017002534586936235, 0.007878650911152363, 0.02970544621348381, 0.028922447934746742, -0.03368465229868889, -0.04079337790608406, -0.06294693052768707, -0.02402516081929207, 0.03070709854364395, -0.017091751098632812, 0.017742309719324112, 0.047350216656923294, -0.026911189779639244, -0.04785742983222008, 0.007655662950128317, 0.030839502811431885, -0.05689501762390137, 0.06958697736263275, 0.01097725797444582, 0.021831851452589035, -0.04359649121761322, 0.05804721266031265, -0.043694812804460526, 0.027626952156424522, -0.08386566489934921, 0.012001528404653072, 0.010762310586869717, 0.002817512257024646, 0.01631569303572178, 0.01928248442709446, 0.08563214540481567, 0.0020156120881438255, 0.02011684514582157, -0.003976838197559118, -0.03895856440067291, 0.07209867238998413, -0.055930450558662415, 0.011563754640519619, -0.05809802934527397, -0.03134928271174431, -0.04141191765666008, -0.059475839138031006, 0.04146266728639603, -0.013651778921484947, -0.0058417231775820255, -0.007740007247775793, -0.020766224712133408, 0.05829319357872009, 0.00032451190054416656, -0.03589607775211334, 0.029721660539507866, -0.005293236579746008, 0.0657891109585762, 0.025343675166368484, -0.08525621891021729, -0.013756264001131058, -0.04127974808216095, -0.008300691843032837, -0.04953683540225029, -0.028599973767995834, 0.04009883850812912, -0.05478367581963539, 0.013300850987434387, -0.03874386101961136, 0.03555124253034592, -0.03566337004303932, -0.004178658593446016, 0.07275445759296417, 0.017885174602270126, -0.0462687611579895, -0.05013912543654442, -0.01631097123026848, -0.02929096110165119, -0.003019479336217046, -0.035247765481472015, 0.02431541122496128, -0.029372617602348328, 0.015748724341392517, 0.008063968271017075, 0.0483461357653141, -0.1003355085849762, 0.04267391189932823, -0.009506615810096264, -0.03349633142352104, 0.033909354358911514, 0.020893750712275505, 0.023624110966920853, -0.006027676165103912, 0.029906224459409714, 0.06508156657218933, 0.0003538517630659044, 0.014729684218764305, 0.03660475090146065, -0.010627609677612782, 0.022847848013043404, 0.0843343511223793, 0.016855178400874138, -0.003378765657544136, -0.015622769482433796, -0.007624083664268255, -0.04951316863298416, 0.002818071050569415, -0.010381171479821205, -0.028271082788705826, -0.022172056138515472, -0.01849588006734848, -0.03900004178285599, -0.01822812482714653, 0.05794567987322807, -0.010821905918419361, -0.04294407367706299, 0.02024889551103115, 0.0652310773730278, 0.014180829748511314, -0.0008346366230398417, -0.018627697601914406, 0.02160482108592987, 0.03256979212164879, 0.06515555828809738, 0.018942808732390404, -0.02052154950797558, 0.04385722801089287, 0.002586368238553405, 0.0017835499020293355, -0.003136680694296956, -0.036939699202775955, -0.00669324304908514, 0.0047574457712471485, -0.0496290884912014, -0.017407018691301346, 0.012883893214166164, -0.01732552796602249, -0.046038005501031876, 0.04542756453156471, -0.014716623350977898, 0.05015091970562935, -0.0665387287735939, 0.018696460872888565, 0.014210916124284267, -0.05266553536057472, -0.02082000859081745, -0.05642629787325859, 0.014724225737154484, 0.060229673981666565, -0.014451653696596622, 0.054184313863515854, 0.03610322251915932, 0.01376680564135313, -0.011692923493683338, 0.038526006042957306, -0.023277539759874344, 0.039941005408763885, -0.05253438651561737, -0.043868985027074814, 0.02084786631166935, 0.08031127601861954, 0.059634774923324585, -0.024285893887281418, -0.09421547502279282, -0.01736062951385975, -0.08801848441362381, 0.010044246912002563, -0.0024153958074748516, 0.004876651801168919, 0.02340094931423664, -0.0068156723864376545, 0.02987116575241089, -0.03356599062681198, 0.029475100338459015, 0.02292438969016075, 0.07078421115875244, -0.03133320063352585, 0.015410604886710644, 0.012096512131392956, 0.015405893325805664, 0.05771913379430771, 0.0021481108851730824, -0.019709764048457146, -0.025187861174345016, -0.03875136747956276, 0.04223175719380379, -0.019794555380940437, -0.05176502838730812, 0.06762431561946869, -0.004518941976130009, -0.01266325544565916, 0.0010766246123239398, 0.03981372341513634, 0.024594539776444435, -0.07736516743898392, 0.0006281903479248285, -0.027229102328419685, 0.03500612452626228, 0.017741436138749123, 0.0020664522890001535, -0.037967074662446976, -0.053696826100349426, -0.02646511234343052, -0.031371016055345535, 0.026791835203766823, 0.01564147137105465, -0.035512786358594894, 0.026866624131798744, -0.03917975351214409, 0.043580930680036545, 0.01941661722958088, -0.02114371582865715, -0.02368834987282753, 0.026867177337408066, 0.00666964054107666, 0.03439606726169586, 0.016629930585622787, -0.02121228165924549, 0.03916377201676369, 0.0740070790052414, -0.05413835495710373, -0.026551062241196632, 0.006345972418785095, -0.0000338677637046203, 0.04943243786692619, -0.022164082154631615, 0.010172470472753048, -0.029337778687477112, 0.019112706184387207, -0.05051308497786522, -0.006435721646994352, -0.04337277635931969, -0.033065952360630035, 0.0050668674521148205, 0.001550072687678039, 0.037488099187612534, -0.02580631710588932, 0.026924528181552887, -0.06420531123876572, -0.042962562292814255, 0.04944099113345146, -0.0016843529883772135, 0.02596566267311573, 0.012672188691794872, -0.015520576387643814, 0.020695572718977928, -0.005352299194782972, -0.03798392415046692, -0.04350225627422333, -0.003449568524956703, -0.002924184547737241, -0.0018848360050469637, -0.08223112672567368, 0.006636493373662233, -0.01704266108572483, -0.03819611668586731, 0.0028669957537204027, -0.0399925671517849, -0.006747827865183353, -0.021862875670194626, 0.030972551554441452, -0.027340345084667206, 0.0485418327152729, -0.0076524061150848866, -0.010933059267699718, 0.041291072964668274, -0.006809993647038937, -0.06313591450452805, -0.006385555025190115, -0.031518224626779556, 0.056678373366594315, -0.012568543665111065, 0.030446764081716537, -0.04819771274924278, 0.05848933011293411, -0.018359346315264702, -0.0251275897026062, -0.0029598968103528023, 0.006777510512620211, 0.05574536696076393, 0.018387701362371445, 0.05788319557905197, -0.018494533374905586, -0.024413438513875008, -0.04150833934545517, 0.049614034593105316, -0.04954427853226662, 0.010935524478554726, 0.03898130729794502, -0.009899424389004707, -0.03230470418930054, -0.030187854543328285, 0.03897283226251602, -0.010494062677025795, 0.010833457112312317, 0.01160773541778326, 0.05953754857182503, -0.024731876328587532, 0.03646782413125038, 0.027057455852627754, -0.027615992352366447, -0.028827335685491562, -0.010713336989283562, 0.060070525854825974, -0.05423090234398842, 0.055714141577482224, 0.06785992532968521, -0.00017443417164031416, 0.01750347577035427, 0.06384853273630142, 0.09214390814304352, -0.007033320609480143, -0.036072783172130585, 0.005669979378581047, 0.02163703925907612, -0.029277974739670753, -0.047088686376810074, 0.04980342462658882, 0.08905033767223358, 0.028623420745134354, -0.01290913112461567, -0.0007839516038075089, 0.0246280487626791, -0.017493458464741707, 0.033096540719270706, 0.03752182424068451, 0.009823153726756573, -0.04378742352128029, -0.021381989121437073, -0.04300207272171974, 0.03428767994046211, -0.04987070709466934, 0.05611826479434967, 0.06884036213159561, -0.009985191747546196, -0.05570291727781296, -0.036738354712724686, -0.039235919713974, -0.016652872785925865, -0.008092057891190052, 0.01991240307688713, 0.047643717378377914, 0.05030246451497078, 0.0063253128901124, 0.07102904468774796, 0.02008264698088169, 0.00803439226001501, -0.01858358085155487, 0.005588281899690628, -0.023336755111813545, 0.01973840966820717, -0.043449755758047104, 0.0008345399401150644, 0.06584252417087555, 0.0021909999195486307, -0.04371011257171631, 0.07969678938388824, 0.054439667612314224, -0.01734474115073681, 0.01098798867315054, -0.0158787090331316, -0.029726367443799973, -0.013425888493657112, 0.035767119377851486, -0.0466238372027874, -0.001961446600034833, 0.025951851159334183, -0.005887135863304138, 0.05050273984670639, 0.009321345016360283, 0.03223356977105141, -0.03227468952536583, -0.00331856613047421, -0.04325694963335991, -0.024864383041858673, -0.04503108933568001, -0.04544198885560036, 0.014368537813425064, 0.09268369525671005, 0.020619813352823257, 0.013501948677003384, -0.013526388444006443, 0.030065512284636497, 0.04244806617498398, 0.0013933031586930156, 0.015105359256267548, 0.005931474734097719, 0.007382495794445276, 0.003093959530815482, -0.007133739069104195, 0.03394012153148651, -0.012959742918610573, 0.019624603912234306, -0.034745678305625916, -0.05892939493060112, -0.00974466372281313, 0.036956045776605606, 0.031968697905540466, -0.07139226794242859, 0.030601201578974724, -0.006407428532838821, 0.021316448226571083, 0.019265133887529373, 0.02539474330842495, -0.026927830651402473, -0.02327934093773365, -0.010230143554508686, 0.040034808218479156, -0.05506933853030205, 0.013997713103890419, -0.0010866309748962522, 0.01502624899148941, 0.0019236515508964658, 0.013263210654258728, -0.019038472324609756, 0.07170376181602478, 0.046520937234163284, 0.0006737351650372148, -0.038505665957927704, 0.0213351771235466, -0.017318429425358772, 0.03654277324676514, -0.027170458808541298, -0.017172586172819138, 0.04047650843858719, 0.02852061577141285, 0.03962922841310501, 0.014326550997793674, 0.008941251784563065, 0.009771422483026981, -0.03093677945435047, 0.0843968316912651, -0.03943409398198128, 0.003989552613347769, 0.0208201315253973, -0.037349749356508255 ]
<p>I have two sets of data. The one is daily temperature data and another is 16-day vegetation observation data (value of Jan 1, Jan 17 etc), throughout a year. But I need daily values of vegetation observation data. How to obtain daily value from 16-day vegetation data?</p>
g74313
[ 0.006339558400213718, -0.05605060234665871, -0.004754949826747179, -0.01682881824672222, 0.02077202871441841, -0.012270038947463036, -0.003250016365200281, -0.04236901178956032, -0.032236285507678986, -0.04075775295495987, 0.04338300600647926, -0.024872751906514168, 0.05053377151489258, 0.005815553013235331, 0.0008537736721336842, 0.04610568657517433, -0.00990011915564537, -0.05091002210974693, -0.011559903621673584, 0.02794419601559639, 0.02225831337273121, -0.014678715728223324, -0.013573476113379002, -0.040886249393224716, -0.013091318309307098, -0.03834904357790947, -0.05166395753622055, 0.05269446223974228, -0.11185668408870697, 0.0411972850561142, -0.009003886952996254, 0.015517844818532467, 0.005148768424987793, -0.006245818454772234, -0.013163347728550434, -0.02558097615838051, -0.022289425134658813, -0.018212636932730675, -0.0373193621635437, -0.02974388748407364, -0.013278987258672714, -0.0041745430789887905, 0.05154738202691078, 0.019823728129267693, -0.012596792541444302, -0.026605969294905663, -0.015044995583593845, -0.021553950384259224, 0.026738597080111504, -0.057870958000421524, 0.02526204288005829, 0.051952559500932693, 0.007826053537428379, 0.06313348561525345, -0.0046913702972233295, -0.0024650455452501774, 0.000032948810257948935, -0.030260534957051277, 0.057840075343847275, 0.0026001702062785625, 0.0605795793235302, -0.041995078325271606, -0.002316245576366782, -0.013258954510092735, 0.0361194983124733, 0.04712486267089844, 0.009907221421599388, -0.017964642494916916, -0.0008482252014800906, -0.019528493285179138, 0.0020603144075721502, 0.05137373507022858, -0.0372835248708725, -0.0350160151720047, 0.022691423073410988, -0.03170504420995712, -0.02767062932252884, -0.020689858123660088, -0.00103283382486552, 0.048315346240997314, -0.018395882099866867, 0.03226486220955849, 0.00990200974047184, 0.01191096194088459, 0.029504097998142242, 0.019982261583209038, 0.04329853504896164, 0.019550837576389313, -0.0015191154088824987, 0.0037400880828499794, -0.00978146679699421, 0.02160646952688694, 0.10914407670497894, 0.01807301677763462, 0.015256047248840332, -0.030744144693017006, -0.044700682163238525, -0.012536316178739071, -0.02597813867032528, 0.08061056584119797, -0.03157416358590126, -0.002955268369987607, 0.029918869957327843, -0.028494281694293022, -0.015888197347521782, -0.045728545635938644, -0.003309716237708926, 0.01881689578294754, -0.023941611871123314, 0.0035821879282593727, -0.061407141387462616, -0.0029110366012901068, -0.004968680441379547, -0.0156532172113657, 0.03832577168941498, 0.009874515235424042, -0.01888241060078144, 0.03667173907160759, -0.054819948971271515, -0.037235327064991, 0.034985918551683426, 0.03114888072013855, 0.008786223828792572, 0.027372116222977638, -0.004316781647503376, -0.045010969042778015, 0.004182552918791771, 0.004866522736847401, 0.07831419259309769, 0.033314790576696396, -0.036389730870723724, -0.010824545286595821, 0.005532250739634037, 0.02953558973968029, -0.00819404236972332, -0.005952170118689537, 0.05513441562652588, 0.009123699739575386, -0.008664293214678764, -0.02113405428826809, -0.008676297962665558, 0.00757859880104661, -0.02011321671307087, -0.03708093613386154, -0.05079180747270584, 0.023374315351247787, 0.006045952904969454, -0.0524417981505394, 0.018555615097284317, 0.060818932950496674, 0.06740926951169968, -0.00007037328032311052, -0.002862770576030016, 0.00508465338498354, -0.017297472804784775, -0.06567177921533585, 0.02949162758886814, 0.0073899622075259686, 0.005456129554659128, 0.009482027031481266, 0.015821881592273712, 0.033764924854040146, 0.04506651312112808, -0.03855821117758751, 0.011934703215956688, -0.030020594596862793, -0.043788861483335495, -0.05035056546330452, -0.04237140342593193, 0.0007133135804906487, 0.012306442484259605, -0.010834249667823315, -0.022643091157078743, -0.009409729391336441, 0.03501104563474655, 0.045337554067373276, 0.032674163579940796, 0.03223478049039841, 0.061185531318187714, -0.03640436381101608, 0.023224972188472748, -0.004767606034874916, 0.04093438759446144, -0.0322304293513298, -0.010477576404809952, -0.04264599457383156, -0.04463234543800354, -0.04472150281071663, -0.04456895962357521, 0.009568802081048489, -0.0320909209549427, -0.08323996514081955, 0.026566706597805023, 0.017944972962141037, -0.004089647438377142, -0.043931134045124054, 0.02281159535050392, -0.025207091122865677, 0.01512629073113203, -0.003321127500385046, -0.010142847895622253, -0.0054044113494455814, -0.03199775516986847, -0.0020382606890052557, -0.007487152703106403, 0.01589379459619522, 0.014077140018343925, 0.013639640994369984, -0.052156586199998856, -0.03552985191345215, -0.059007856994867325, -0.07342099398374557, -0.049490418285131454, 0.05094483867287636, 0.01986309513449669, 0.03601422533392906, 0.04005856439471245, -0.018643131479620934, 0.05347154289484024, 0.00818732101470232, -0.02380003035068512, 0.011696899309754372, 0.02746487781405449, 0.04571523517370224, 0.03427610546350479, 0.019797654822468758, 0.022646751254796982, 0.02246927097439766, 0.04671681299805641, 0.02973325178027153, -0.011093121021986008, -0.020381448790431023, -0.05376121401786804, 0.03998524695634842, 0.040926966816186905, 0.0653112456202507, 0.08087395131587982, 0.0293105598539114, 0.017660947516560555, -0.02621283382177353, -0.03272346034646034, -0.027409212663769722, 0.012951240874826908, 0.00545983063057065, -0.003290833905339241, 0.024515682831406593, -0.017763083800673485, 0.02918386645615101, -0.00948958471417427, -0.01953797973692417, 0.008308259770274162, 0.02030792273581028, 0.017296869307756424, -0.003791408846154809, -0.032898567616939545, -0.059825316071510315, -0.060165297240018845, 0.007170713506639004, 0.006348036229610443, 0.009273170493543148, 0.04772663488984108, -0.02718316949903965, 0.003771599382162094, 0.03943687304854393, 0.030979834496974945, -0.07312162965536118, 0.0014997649705037475, -0.026584871113300323, -0.07258889824151993, -0.003423873567953706, 0.0007263159495778382, -0.05423691123723984, 0.07388079166412354, 0.031464677304029465, -0.026504389941692352, 0.009021567180752754, -0.009178074076771736, -0.025201452895998955, -0.034308306872844696, 0.00035893486347049475, 0.04644515737891197, -0.056925687938928604, 0.016646096482872963, 0.07729043066501617, -0.015478384681046009, -0.02033587358891964, 0.004762520547956228, 0.037709951400756836, 0.008056542836129665, -0.01275663636624813, -0.03369681164622307, -0.043491560965776443, -0.05128181725740433, -0.03861682116985321, -0.01784568838775158, -0.05289255082607269, -0.0101518789306283, 0.022545253857970238, 0.05573077127337456, -0.027145566418766975, -0.016179393976926804, 0.0039798119105398655, 0.015344619750976562, -0.037331629544496536, 0.005420319736003876, -0.035954903811216354, -0.023072414100170135, -0.039043497294187546, 0.03845154494047165, -0.0895514190196991, 0.04177307337522507, -0.035707373172044754, 0.040794841945171356, 0.04090253263711929, 0.056244734674692154, 0.01854652911424637, -0.02271438017487526, 0.02565453201532364, -0.006318261846899986, -0.02000337652862072, 0.02786257304251194, -0.012487109750509262, 0.07604455947875977, -0.003464419860392809, -0.03167806938290596, 0.004612908232957125, -0.01559579186141491, -0.003560547484084964, 0.01167071983218193, 0.012870999984443188, 0.012851023115217686, 0.0324791744351387, -0.007514152675867081, -0.01803830824792385, -0.023790117353200912, 0.03561428189277649, -0.034115176647901535, -0.007179782260209322, 0.02429778501391411, -0.002403663005679846, -0.0589650422334671, 0.02510645240545273, -0.06897661834955215, -0.01085352897644043, 0.007806188426911831, -0.04409093037247658, -0.049712345004081726, -0.024258578196167946, -0.008140582591295242, 0.013374260626733303, -0.018173009157180786, -0.005588584113866091, 0.03016541339457035, -0.01582944765686989, 0.0031122835353016853, -0.014003319665789604, 0.012611362151801586, -0.012101540341973305, 0.011000752449035645, -0.03151567280292511, -0.006950254552066326, -0.05293947830796242, -0.03255316987633705, 0.05911165103316307, 0.032303713262081146, -0.02330464869737625, -0.02863348461687565, 0.09220544248819351, 0.043500080704689026, -0.038218025118112564, 0.050289660692214966, 0.014272818341851234, 0.055581122636795044, -0.08910471946001053, -0.02277824468910694, -0.03610841557383537, 0.02885556034743786, -0.05492839217185974, 0.023622533306479454, 0.07782192528247833, 0.003766273846849799, 0.025560302659869194, -0.005948886275291443, 0.009747229516506195, -0.00750133628025651, -0.03228430449962616, 0.015311076305806637, 0.027699995785951614, -0.00860640499740839, -0.07199818640947342, -0.012536684982478619, -0.06140194088220596, -0.07473618537187576, 0.010935149155557156, 0.03446657955646515, -0.026989463716745377, -0.006220840848982334, 0.09733295440673828, -0.05097976699471474, 0.0027944426983594894, -0.03325865417718887, -0.007817010395228863, 0.08411029726266861, 0.039171550422906876, -0.022574402391910553, 0.00716171832755208, -0.03603046014904976, 0.04132746160030365, 0.011731492355465889, 0.045021720230579376, -0.06298833340406418, -0.04806015267968178, 0.053603749722242355, -0.005422030575573444, 0.028903422877192497, -0.03386298939585686, 0.0802115872502327, -0.07682955265045166, 0.10538166016340256, -0.02729361318051815, -0.03205031156539917, 0.024642078205943108, 0.0005385400727391243, -0.05183929204940796, -0.010467000305652618, 0.06142734736204147, -0.032262180000543594, -0.007518241181969643, -0.04580465704202652, -0.000162439770065248, -0.01237310841679573, 0.008435730822384357, -0.015484786592423916, 0.05616254732012749, -0.03202014043927193, 0.037555668503046036, 0.015490006655454636, 0.029138367623090744, 0.026755942031741142, -0.018285609781742096, -0.04555344581604004, -0.01838536188006401, -0.049182940274477005, -0.012771368958055973, -0.015269430354237556, 0.04191775247454643, 0.002078460529446602, -0.03798907250165939, 0.009972697123885155, -0.0022372212260961533, 0.024097906425595284, -0.01852874457836151, -0.018705805763602257, -0.002796504646539688, 0.016872238367795944, -0.02401702292263508, -0.0064684501849114895, 0.009584633633494377, -0.026537347584962845, 0.07522737234830856, -0.012832057662308216, -0.03605597838759422, 0.032703377306461334, -0.008512130007147789, -0.028510000556707382, 0.02595517411828041, -0.05362662672996521, 0.021696705371141434, 0.04502873867750168, 0.007674107793718576, -0.007025886792689562, 0.008157116360962391, -0.0010625142604112625, 0.00963884312659502, 0.021531132981181145, -0.00918652769178152, -0.05063986778259277, -0.020159000530838966, 0.04237916320562363, 0.029817519709467888, -0.0234183631837368, 0.00890344101935625, 0.015040416270494461, 0.05589570477604866, 0.02445204183459282, 0.017173483967781067, -0.008912676014006138, -0.006300842855125666, -0.0014429412549361587, 0.062204569578170776, -0.08239666372537613, -0.025859449058771133, 0.09816543012857437, 0.08686763793230057, -0.017391091212630272, -0.05042022094130516, 0.0006935858400538564, -0.034179434180259705, -0.011981578543782234, -0.08012647926807404, -0.008069016970694065, 0.04430738836526871, 0.02432037703692913, -0.008211982436478138, 0.028806710615754128, 0.008955984376370907, 0.03902158513665199, 0.02771078422665596, -0.02713158167898655, 0.009762563742697239, -0.001494839321821928, -0.017021218314766884, 0.06629420816898346, 0.023531442508101463, 0.05104513838887215, 0.020962899550795555, -0.01958290860056877, 0.07910115271806717, 0.01204048190265894, -0.05266213417053223, 0.06913844496011734, 0.021347414702177048, 0.05051235854625702, 0.00452087726444006, -0.01875615492463112, -0.023368876427412033, -0.04822232574224472, 0.0031001607421785593, 0.020659223198890686, -0.08978608250617981, 0.03302469104528427, 0.06992130726575851, -0.008843827992677689, -0.01918705366551876, 0.05543374642729759, -0.033523641526699066, -0.04680202156305313, 0.035174790769815445, 0.0027983717154711485, -0.0018916919361799955, -0.027503471821546555, 0.006422780454158783, 0.020982470363378525, -0.01884581334888935, 0.04139771685004234, -0.043290168046951294, 0.010242030955851078, 0.003207287285476923, 0.062323588877916336, 0.05383770167827606, -0.022600723430514336, 0.03161574900150299, -0.019987978041172028, -0.08833979815244675, -0.008227989077568054, -0.03489435091614723, 0.017647171393036842, 0.03943051025271416, -0.04372182488441467, -0.018333643674850464, -0.0029733143746852875, -0.004794279579073191, 0.05093356594443321, 0.06470807641744614, -0.04418354853987694, 0.0528569296002388, -0.021296922117471695, -0.04959874227643013, -0.028960997238755226, 0.053469814360141754, 0.07525352388620377, 0.006285231560468674, -0.0005999841378070414, 0.021016119047999382, -0.03605500981211662, 0.004330782685428858, 0.015432751737535, 0.040177397429943085, 0.02352786622941494, 0.013190456666052341, -0.037168726325035095, -0.018430307507514954, 0.04103223979473114, 0.005399216432124376, -0.018385790288448334, 0.01179647259414196, -0.06582891941070557, -0.025594908744096756, -0.06860131025314331, -0.039926350116729736, 0.021391423419117928, -0.013185287825763226, -0.02519877441227436, 0.0066969133913517, 0.01942775584757328, -0.033772293478250504, -0.01315182913094759, 0.06582549959421158, -0.01672878861427307, -0.043025288730859756, 0.032332487404346466, -0.064072385430336, 0.09880540519952774, -0.03541409969329834, 0.012597556225955486, 0.0030805435962975025, -0.03240112215280533, -0.010370495729148388, 0.024091843515634537, -0.05202019214630127, -0.06030251085758209, -0.001583598437719047, -0.025098616257309914, 0.010380609892308712, -0.04371665418148041, 0.025462504476308823, 0.01477377861738205, 0.011875123716890812, -0.0102555425837636, 0.0036929051857441664, 0.0025369005743414164, 0.03800441697239876, 0.037515949457883835, 0.025944873690605164, 0.027867797762155533, 0.02808964066207409, -0.048223406076431274, -0.018583765253424644, 0.030374351888895035, 0.015514780767261982, -0.0012842481955885887, -0.009524147026240826, 0.009202344343066216, 0.01179049164056778, -0.011516335420310497, 0.01174834929406643, 0.013730887323617935, 0.09742617607116699, -0.02275718003511429, -0.00692150229588151, 0.00018145027570426464, 0.03670252487063408, -0.05270656943321228, -0.01173141598701477, -0.014514835551381111, -0.00795636884868145, -0.007559575606137514, -0.041694991290569305, 0.010426309891045094, 0.0137321250513196, 0.00851950328797102, -0.021668272092938423, 0.06367144733667374, 0.04072098806500435, 0.04201454296708107, 0.016282595694065094, -0.005770101211965084, 0.012143107131123543, 0.014685130678117275, 0.07869928330183029, -0.012778731063008308, -0.056989457458257675, -0.07015234231948853, 0.012376807630062103, 0.03956916928291321, 0.04527133330702782, 0.0821901261806488, 0.07007665187120438, -0.016938945278525352, -0.016611836850643158, -0.022595174610614777, -0.04313020035624504, -0.023295024409890175, -0.015053104609251022, 0.01267533004283905, -0.041410405188798904, 0.0070671518333256245, -0.021547548472881317, -0.044622890651226044, -0.049827128648757935, -0.005286785773932934, 0.002794551430270076, 0.03507575765252113, -0.02704409882426262, -0.016036301851272583, -0.0018766768043860793, 0.024525918066501617, 0.008640394546091557, 0.09962297976016998, -0.0044715749099850655, -0.04736386984586716, 0.009860449470579624, -0.007986433804035187, -0.004856681916862726, -0.057766448706388474, -0.06657417118549347, 0.041628990322351456, -0.07206489145755768, 0.022728417068719864, 0.021768437698483467, 0.07103824615478516, 0.007168781943619251, -0.002243025228381157, -0.04661974683403969, 0.040818456560373306, -0.03118058107793331, -0.0351700559258461, -0.011644202284514904, -0.023635579273104668, -0.030602965503931046, -0.03232891485095024, 0.032320208847522736, -0.05675461143255234, 0.03907342627644539, -0.005648685619235039, -0.031156999990344048, -0.008746463805437088, 0.035184383392333984, 0.031010691076517105, 0.03245004639029503, -0.06043858826160431, -0.004364549182355404, -0.014095108024775982, -0.034775812178850174, -0.04531450942158699, 0.00811290368437767, -0.08267481625080109, -0.007001451216638088, 0.06633902341127396, -0.03127099946141243, 0.024714870378375053, -0.01251715887337923, -0.021731948480010033, 0.0004130810557398945, 0.04104597121477127, 0.04143860191106796, 0.0189292561262846, 0.015424980781972408, -0.026813844218850136, 0.03963671252131462, 0.03589492663741112, -0.019660484045743942, 0.004788513761013746, 0.00021401217964012176, -0.00897158682346344, 0.0466984398663044, -0.047657519578933716, 0.07283810526132584, 0.0801670178771019, -0.02859351597726345, -0.06608018279075623, 0.03718850389122963, -0.02891385369002819, 0.032743632793426514, -0.017229413613677025, 0.008253097534179688, -0.007070289924740791, -0.05309233441948891, 0.0005714954459108412, 0.04210352897644043, -0.026346800848841667, 0.05111493170261383, -0.028674818575382233, 0.06119232624769211, 0.0069547067396342754, -0.0364830382168293, -0.014990267343819141, 0.04877033457159996 ]
<p>I came across an article where the authors did a Principal Component Analysis on gene expression data, and found out the genes that are most correlated to the 1st principal component, and they used that gene list for further analysis. Can somebody tell me how to find out entities (genes in this case) that are most correlated to the 1st principal component?</p> <p>Here's <a href="http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2164/10/135" rel="nofollow">the link to the original free article</a>, and this is how they've calculated it:</p> <blockquote> <p>Results of the gene set enrichment analysis of the genes most correlated to the 1st principal component. The correlations of the genes with the 1st principal component were transformed to SDs from the mean, then genes with values > 1.5 (positive correlation) or &lt; -1.5 (negative correlation) were selected.</p> </blockquote> <p>I can make a toy example of 6 samples and 20 gene matrix and do the PCA the following way but how to proceed next:</p> <pre><code>rm(list=ls()) set.seed(12345) my.mat &lt;- matrix(rnorm(120,0,0.5),nrow=6,byrow=TRUE) rownames(my.mat) &lt;- paste("s",1:6,sep="") colnames(my.mat) &lt;- paste("g",1:20,sep="") head(my.mat) #Ensure that input data is Z-transformed pca.object &lt;- prcomp(my.mat,center=TRUE,scale.=TRUE) summary(pca.object) par(mfrow=c(1,2)) plot(pca.object) biplot(pca.object) #The Rotation pca.object$rotation </code></pre>
g74314
[ 0.030796319246292114, -0.05075736343860626, 0.00804764125496149, -0.06565684825181961, -0.001712845521979034, -0.0716264545917511, 0.05512052774429321, 0.013910148292779922, 0.00022846086358185858, -0.017183056101202965, 0.03223849833011627, 0.03058689273893833, 0.009359265677630901, -0.006291865836828947, 0.013745393604040146, -0.018531950190663338, 0.031449660658836365, 0.012862348929047585, -0.021928662434220314, -0.01993299275636673, 0.011013498529791832, -0.013260331936180592, 0.04306836798787117, 0.0017711145337671041, -0.049471400678157806, -0.04883258789777756, 0.012862423434853554, -0.0021558254957199097, -0.06699752062559128, 0.013386729173362255, 0.034787509590387344, -0.04143736511468887, 0.0006926646456122398, -0.031048942357301712, -0.008506974205374718, -0.03400413691997528, 0.03010026551783085, 0.03571983799338341, -0.00047776696737855673, 0.03886856511235237, -0.015528982505202293, -0.06263178586959839, 0.0007168971933424473, 0.01732024736702442, -0.013281513936817646, -0.005623210687190294, 0.002604683395475149, -0.0016224689316004515, 0.02740548923611641, -0.04719281196594238, 0.027270184829831123, 0.05682491138577461, 0.028381893411278725, -0.03376094624400139, 0.02356947585940361, 0.05456412956118584, 0.05894862115383148, 0.0025376940611749887, 0.044179726392030716, 0.03035496361553669, -0.002404720289632678, 0.013465681113302708, -0.07195238769054413, 0.02268831990659237, 0.033577810972929, -0.005576139781624079, 0.042789068073034286, 0.006836463697254658, -0.057837747037410736, 0.03040826879441738, 0.042484790086746216, -0.01259701419621706, 0.06556522846221924, 0.04515146464109421, -0.008610228076577187, -0.032621290534734726, 0.0031425554770976305, -0.02771696075797081, 0.03398894518613815, 0.01833910122513771, 0.05195402726531029, 0.038062915205955505, -0.03402651846408844, -0.02196793258190155, 0.06368257105350494, -0.0014359221095219254, 0.019955985248088837, -0.008021602407097816, 0.01610342226922512, -0.015668164938688278, 0.036956436932086945, 0.03094366379082203, 0.10423179715871811, 0.01104388851672411, -0.007018774747848511, 0.030577976256608963, -0.03766857832670212, 0.008085436187684536, -0.03126735985279083, -0.08385441452264786, 0.03298084810376167, 0.017312249168753624, 0.016595683991909027, -0.04871761053800583, -0.0423700250685215, 0.0018883143784478307, 0.02227581851184368, 0.011165198870003223, -0.08543090522289276, -0.021100398153066635, -0.061666518449783325, -0.0025585824623703957, -0.06313702464103699, -0.03640904277563095, -0.01743995025753975, -0.043508611619472504, 0.08389684557914734, -0.01203935220837593, 0.031193215399980545, 0.025130216032266617, 0.015119263902306557, -0.038577958941459656, 0.025008032098412514, 0.10393929481506348, 0.02140946500003338, 0.01188079547137022, 0.00884418934583664, 0.017396725714206696, 0.03905581310391426, -0.01937609724700451, -0.018896861001849174, -0.04664284363389015, 0.036383356899023056, 0.028364475816488266, -0.00354176526889205, 0.008118984289467335, -0.0668589398264885, 0.06523865461349487, 0.01801866479218006, 0.04631754755973816, -0.027682160958647728, -0.012673888355493546, 0.02316548302769661, -0.01727716065943241, 0.022571586072444916, -0.020114444196224213, -0.01721331849694252, 0.001450587180443108, -0.013004329986870289, 0.061459772288799286, 0.043476302176713943, 0.0157172754406929, -0.04502391070127487, -0.059480588883161545, -0.011042952537536621, 0.01688225194811821, -0.019025715067982674, -0.03617585450410843, 0.02247186191380024, 0.020707927644252777, -0.014355175197124481, 0.0058279260993003845, 0.03933263197541237, 0.022265611216425896, 0.015979690477252007, -0.05341162532567978, -0.0020230584777891636, -0.0137201938778162, -0.042731139808893204, -0.04166660085320473, 0.026747683063149452, -0.019221113994717598, -0.0025874157436192036, -0.006684739142656326, 0.002089590998366475, 0.034034792333841324, 0.02504655160009861, -0.015818817541003227, 0.0624256394803524, 0.017400149255990982, -0.0049203066155314445, 0.004077449906617403, -0.022989021614193916, 0.032945018261671066, 0.04420994222164154, -0.01798303984105587, -0.05874323844909668, 0.09207756817340851, -0.05639713257551193, -0.01608048938214779, -0.031685516238212585, -0.006576303392648697, -0.02251964807510376, -0.043700505048036575, -0.009949571453034878, -0.009771234355866909, -0.0234055258333683, -0.07835329324007034, -0.03789125755429268, -0.030379556119441986, 0.003392332000657916, 0.0044707972556352615, -0.025000492110848427, 0.05722793936729431, -0.036489780992269516, -0.04061828553676605, -0.03062208741903305, 0.005866612773388624, -0.0743732750415802, -0.0007518396596424282, -0.018436986953020096, -0.015467042103409767, -0.0808115154504776, 0.0642792209982872, -0.017681092023849487, -0.021785918623209, -0.01290099136531353, -0.01557970978319645, -0.03370342031121254, 0.023617103695869446, -0.01894497498869896, -0.030437281355261803, -0.004867168143391609, 0.004782223142683506, -0.023189401254057884, 0.055196914821863174, 0.06944886595010757, -0.010533425956964493, -0.04413881152868271, 0.019670803099870682, -0.0575718954205513, 0.007477506063878536, -0.013561544008553028, -0.010901250876486301, 0.04048452898859978, -0.005602353718131781, 0.020406726747751236, 0.04188906028866768, -0.05348112806677818, 0.06325483322143555, 0.009534587152302265, 0.03620541840791702, 0.015234117396175861, -0.02008066326379776, 0.1270364224910736, -0.04664977639913559, 0.08535253256559372, -0.0007840044563636184, 0.012908084318041801, 0.03877585753798485, -0.021921245381236076, 0.017995348200201988, -0.01310818362981081, 0.000609099748544395, 0.0054463958367705345, -0.07396865636110306, 0.05197529122233391, 0.0490679070353508, 0.06930463016033173, -0.008616232313215733, 0.06535068899393082, 0.00831582397222519, -0.029177293181419373, -0.028646262362599373, -0.017492715269327164, 0.0014170486247166991, 0.002891932148486376, -0.0654517263174057, -0.021166717633605003, -0.003312196582555771, -0.12917935848236084, 0.05008748546242714, 0.03877333924174309, -0.011116305366158485, 0.0031003677286207676, 0.046105511486530304, -0.008747736923396587, 0.050885241478681564, -0.04071301594376564, 0.01359094213694334, 0.023912597447633743, 0.032786257565021515, -0.027378056198358536, 0.014498226344585419, 0.010770060122013092, -0.029976861551404, 0.0588073804974556, -0.038643863052129745, -0.004749496467411518, 0.008083831518888474, 0.034157056361436844, -0.016620885580778122, -0.003521246137097478, -0.011511876247823238, 0.030581191182136536, -0.003099239431321621, 0.06673168390989304, -0.05882231891155243, 0.03151492401957512, 0.10421242564916611, -0.020532552152872086, -0.005546443164348602, 0.06964659690856934, 0.007146875374019146, 0.029880540445446968, -0.015371195040643215, 0.005001924932003021, -0.010014801286160946, -0.012649604119360447, 0.006104482337832451, -0.030543820932507515, -0.0378560870885849, 0.02406582050025463, -0.028008457273244858, -0.008655587211251259, 0.029274756088852882, 0.004106009379029274, -0.024091968312859535, -0.004932962823659182, -0.040971823036670685, -0.03370858356356621, -0.03813288360834122, 0.022038592025637627, -0.00706670805811882, 0.01805553399026394, 0.006685252301394939, 0.0037817680276930332, 0.024884335696697235, 0.020341642200946808, -0.03771232068538666, 0.04119587317109108, 0.04564199596643448, -0.007679493632167578, 0.06385137140750885, -0.050626255571842194, -0.020428283140063286, -0.04938637837767601, 0.02057025022804737, -0.011115028522908688, -0.020814688876271248, -0.07512097805738449, -0.010936745442450047, 0.02375243604183197, -0.021178018301725388, 0.0362526960670948, 0.005808200221508741, 0.03693315014243126, 0.0535009391605854, -0.002339612925425172, -0.012856956571340561, -0.015405138954520226, -0.020686138421297073, -0.010663801804184914, -0.026199879124760628, 0.009912311099469662, 0.004389900714159012, 0.04012167453765869, -0.04605606570839882, -0.04601795971393585, 0.006998431868851185, -0.006377706304192543, -0.03403299301862717, -0.049569401890039444, 0.00469908956438303, 0.006531217135488987, 0.039106421172618866, 0.032657135277986526, 0.1094302162528038, 0.04288503900170326, 0.014082656241953373, 0.020294496789574623, 0.011842403560876846, 0.026166433468461037, -0.0625637024641037, -0.09947123378515244, 0.001393466372974217, -0.042706191539764404, 0.02264685370028019, 0.021050969138741493, 0.05196953937411308, 0.004674628376960754, 0.0005893564084544778, 0.031431544572114944, 0.04098992422223091, 0.03606266900897026, 0.03438979387283325, -0.010334689170122147, 0.015722449868917465, 0.020905660465359688, 0.027798760682344437, -0.026914019137620926, -0.00881548784673214, -0.06266745179891586, 0.05090496316552162, 0.0344558022916317, -0.029673635959625244, -0.034134794026613235, 0.10316552221775055, 0.03813203424215317, 0.013570585288107395, -0.07876960933208466, -0.021550936624407768, 0.02336398884654045, 0.004610456991940737, 0.015780022367835045, -0.012763011269271374, -0.038234174251556396, 0.009797018952667713, -0.038142140954732895, 0.020513378083705902, -0.03842916339635849, 0.058126650750637054, 0.06748277693986893, -0.012554063461720943, -0.007778183091431856, 0.014724459499120712, 0.007866558618843555, -0.02464844286441803, -0.03870072215795517, -0.015466920100152493, -0.024376338347792625, 0.005228104535490274, -0.06305234879255295, 0.017962809652090073, 0.03267721086740494, 0.03961537033319473, 0.01782018132507801, -0.02472746931016445, 0.01721804402768612, 0.02933342382311821, 0.04313008859753609, 0.03431907296180725, 0.02511797472834587, -0.018547741696238518, -0.06566513329744339, 0.006629558280110359, -0.016663232818245888, 0.042821068316698074, 0.018535995855927467, -0.041744835674762726, 0.009408066980540752, -0.029096081852912903, -0.01319816242903471, 0.023966873064637184, 0.002790390746667981, 0.032609160989522934, -0.009678030386567116, 0.016443809494376183, -0.0007161414832808077, 0.03472021967172623, 0.05186448246240616, -0.0006474559777416289, 0.012225781567394733, -0.04791281372308731, 0.04936099052429199, 0.0263461172580719, 0.01942923478782177, -0.0009457253618165851, 0.016448335722088814, -0.0019979365170001984, -0.04847616329789162, -0.027634404599666595, -0.0479339100420475, -0.019261281937360764, 0.05413553863763809, -0.011082206852734089, -0.02295038290321827, -0.006559883244335651, 0.008154308423399925, -0.00795598141849041, -0.003771282499656081, -0.030896397307515144, -0.015169398859143257, -0.02509262226521969, 0.00921357236802578, 0.029664000496268272, -0.012541016563773155, -0.029604697600007057, -0.0013756962725892663, 0.017945436760783195, -0.03403618559241295, 0.012608222663402557, -0.053096167743206024, -0.0374184250831604, -0.003347419435158372, -0.04729808121919632, -0.017605530098080635, -0.05712665244936943, -0.005113007500767708, 0.018437238410115242, -0.05769868940114975, 0.07199743390083313, 0.026367034763097763, -0.011798479594290257, 0.023760059848427773, -0.024247940629720688, -0.026597606018185616, -0.04855493828654289, 0.01548296120017767, -0.038669195026159286, -0.0033054533414542675, -0.00922964233905077, -0.009685401804745197, 0.015349490568041801, -0.040726080536842346, 0.000544996524695307, 0.035032957792282104, 0.007883327081799507, -0.017583314329385757, -0.010183695703744888, 0.003475503996014595, 0.038345810025930405, 0.02425313927233219, -0.026768701151013374, -0.05986521765589714, 0.015618421137332916, -0.003945088945329189, 0.06217026337981224, -0.05226040631532669, -0.04181600734591484, 0.05908787623047829, -0.044570669531822205, 0.04531697556376457, 0.0017301724292337894, -0.008601902052760124, 0.028940550982952118, -0.022034356370568275, -0.031789518892765045, 0.03006325475871563, 0.014930451288819313, -0.05552707985043526, 0.025981450453400612, -0.025703707709908485, 0.004693634808063507, 0.021328099071979523, -0.047441545873880386, -0.018020620569586754, -0.009098067879676819, 0.06595077365636826, -0.03505494073033333, -0.04036133363842964, 0.0321393683552742, 0.0016595195047557354, -0.021187955513596535, -0.05475691705942154, 0.003977770451456308, 0.011365421116352081, 0.012574339285492897, -0.005110368598252535, -0.004709723871201277, 0.005461547989398241, 0.004049263894557953, -0.016888780519366264, -0.015816189348697662, 0.03013668581843376, -0.006458986550569534, -0.0029049620497971773, -0.003222175408154726, 0.060070931911468506, 0.03198092803359032, -0.030665038153529167, -0.020440975204110146, 0.015847746282815933, -0.02868085727095604, -0.01930895447731018, 0.034574639052152634, -0.024280088022351265, -0.017158646136522293, -0.0022738652769476175, 0.032408080995082855, -0.004110199864953756, -0.06654444336891174, 0.0020014627370983362, 0.04957004636526108, 0.017322547733783722, -0.006320773623883724, 0.01561511866748333, 0.0004946892731823027, 0.0007625704747624695, -0.012748687528073788, -0.01217740774154663, -0.022192958742380142, 0.012773226015269756, -0.01696532778441906, -0.05365839600563049, -0.013761084526777267, -0.022421788424253464, 0.07022015005350113, -0.07587023824453354, -0.024303169921040535, -0.017649564892053604, 0.025186367332935333, -0.01669548824429512, -0.015130853280425072, 0.0007848288514651358, -0.05695769190788269, 0.0057080467231571674, 0.014286122284829617, -0.009213990531861782, -0.02611815743148327, 0.04892673343420029, -0.012965677306056023, 0.03506791219115257, 0.0390956737101078, 0.010978151112794876, -0.00388031592592597, -0.08639083802700043, -0.010507007129490376, -0.008580321446061134, 0.007917514070868492, -0.032548803836107254, -0.031028158962726593, -0.008228861726820469, 0.06802483648061752, 0.049316179007291794, 0.004973658360540867, 0.0032739900052547455, 0.018829861655831337, -0.006716362200677395, -0.005361948162317276, 0.03602062910795212, 0.023270554840564728, -0.07085558772087097, -0.10033038258552551, -0.021870221942663193, 0.11018592864274979, 0.01852649264037609, -0.023428360000252724, 0.025308795273303986, 0.020170090720057487, 0.003915814217180014, 0.03722725436091423, -0.04252323508262634, 0.0026113702915608883, -0.010589884594082832, 0.04255475476384163, -0.07408047467470169, 0.08259153366088867, 0.006916501093655825, 0.11195790767669678, 0.05378936231136322, 0.09182140231132507, -0.06403319537639618, -0.0012636471074074507, 0.0014933126512914896, -0.004313717596232891, -0.0001123403271776624, 0.024094143882393837, -0.04806367680430412, 0.003722553141415119, 0.07026191800832748, 0.04924958944320679, -0.0053153871558606625, -0.07180515676736832, -0.0002935563097707927, 0.032756272703409195, 0.07249747961759567, -0.011816620826721191, 0.04809848219156265, -0.03979167342185974, -0.06840408593416214, -0.06052234396338463, -0.030111396685242653, 0.008295110426843166, -0.05551949888467789, 0.027210375294089317, 0.02784893475472927, 0.026494255289435387, 0.015308253467082977, -0.0332297682762146, -0.04221904277801514, -0.06032443046569824, -0.04086944833397865, 0.013572518713772297, 0.013577393256127834, 0.008725879713892937, 0.016177808865904808, 0.0024522014427930117, 0.00437631830573082, -0.02540476992726326, -0.022065067663788795, -0.004559819120913744, -0.0033471377100795507, -0.012852438725531101, 0.007774109486490488, 0.00628272769972682, 0.011678245849907398, 0.038762498646974564, -0.014747354201972485, 0.04290920868515968, -0.07996901124715805, -0.018275652080774307, -0.010044560767710209, -0.006144825369119644, -0.02100359834730625, 0.017641281709074974, -0.029467079788446426, 0.04130394011735916, -0.044036321341991425, 0.021488642320036888, -0.0016862439224496484, -0.014795045368373394, -0.0469055213034153, -0.021644702181220055, -0.035632647573947906, -0.005366632714867592, -0.006519227288663387, -0.01508294977247715, 0.02750023454427719, -0.06785643100738525, -0.0378807857632637, 0.04687510430812836, -0.0029850886203348637, -0.016622470691800117, -0.032153308391571045, 0.049018848687410355, 0.0208633691072464, 0.0410601943731308, -0.027732033282518387, 0.05568018555641174, -0.04277358204126358, -0.03627875819802284, -0.044978249818086624, 0.006666019558906555, -0.006562741938978434, -0.034785378724336624, 0.05742674693465233, 0.07351768761873245, 0.04573851078748703, 0.02866332232952118, -0.05032685026526451, -0.07836496829986572, -0.03680717572569847, 0.07569729536771774, 0.02316717803478241, 0.01493436936289072, -0.047618117183446884, 0.003077368251979351, -0.01077160332351923, 0.011006178334355354, -0.042725495994091034, -0.059632252901792526, -0.026988588273525238, -0.029568927362561226, 0.024527456611394882, 0.0025669685564935207, -0.016135767102241516, 0.05680256709456444, 0.03793708235025406, 0.0060652028769254684, -0.004353368654847145, 0.048093944787979126, -0.03746173903346062, 0.022000957280397415, 0.007728663273155689, 0.03002859093248844, -0.02200520969927311, 0.05137080326676369, 0.03711557015776634, -0.0228916984051466, 0.027131816372275352, -0.008502811193466187, -0.026777643710374832, 0.05160857364535332, -0.004229922778904438, -0.058173805475234985, -0.018446195870637894, -0.02261980064213276 ]
<p>The only thing I understood about fuzzy neurons is that the neuron's activation function is replaced with some operation used in fuzzy. Other than that, I didn't understand much from science paper I found. Also, it is hard to just Google it because of it's name, which results in listing some fuzzy or ANN or hybrid systems, which is not what I'm looking for.</p> <p>Is there anything more to fuzzy neurons than I have described above?</p> <p>Also, I'm curious, <strong>when and how to use it</strong>?</p> <p>And is there <strong>any other change in neural network structure or calculation that needs implementing</strong> if I'm going to use fuzzy neuron. </p> <p>If someone has a good material on this subject, please link. I really have had a hard time finding anything on this subject. </p> <p>EDIT: Title of the paper I've mentioned: Combining neural networks and fuzzy logic for applications in char.recognition. ByAnne Magaly de Paula Canuto. University of Kent. Can't find link to it anymore, i found it last year. But this is the title. Fuzzy neuron is mentioned in section 1.4. </p>
g74315
[ 0.04037853330373764, 0.010882132686674595, 0.03164568543434143, 0.06735725700855255, 0.012614182196557522, -0.07448291033506393, 0.007573962677270174, 0.09197404980659485, -0.040243104100227356, -0.024149665609002113, -0.036210302263498306, 0.033439941704273224, 0.04902372881770134, -0.004754902329295874, 0.011498948559165001, -0.018497532233595848, -0.006657029967755079, 0.0811605229973793, -0.0018968190997838974, 0.03147966414690018, 0.009770642034709454, 0.0905938670039177, 0.013490580022335052, -0.01677871122956276, -0.06317138671875, -0.017912259325385094, -0.04944324493408203, 0.00718822842463851, -0.07200342416763306, -0.02892751805484295, 0.017502281814813614, -0.06111180782318115, 0.03837369382381439, -0.01842951402068138, -0.04945485666394234, -0.008731459267437458, 0.044005874544382095, -0.03141717240214348, 0.03242272883653641, -0.01722787320613861, -0.02135547064244747, 0.09664619714021683, -0.05244072526693344, -0.049794625490903854, -0.05163375660777092, 0.03808596730232239, 0.026412153616547585, -0.08090583235025406, 0.040052518248558044, -0.045575808733701706, -0.03450814262032509, -0.025991221889853477, -0.030832570046186447, 0.014759228564798832, 0.06651211529970169, 0.008707637898623943, 0.0250228438526392, -0.024939050897955894, -0.000265540205873549, -0.04604405537247658, -0.034514084458351135, 0.02520078793168068, 0.005017040763050318, -0.009714626707136631, 0.01715790666639805, 0.05558895692229271, 0.0005824925610795617, -0.013420148752629757, -0.02007477730512619, 0.017554741352796555, -0.004569401033222675, -0.07226061075925827, -0.009428493678569794, 0.020495589822530746, 0.03879614546895027, -0.023331793025135994, 0.0035017121117562056, -0.0031243760604411364, 0.0234647486358881, 0.06022389233112335, 0.009453676640987396, -0.000798265915364027, -0.03713053837418556, 0.043884050101041794, 0.04199442267417908, 0.0031256501097232103, -0.061177972704172134, 0.024152880534529686, 0.05644157901406288, -0.004552091937512159, 0.03269146755337715, 0.06755968183279037, 0.02652590349316597, -0.02644921839237213, 0.025860000401735306, 0.03074183315038681, -0.04126793518662453, -0.052604690194129944, 0.05339611694216728, -0.02158459648489952, -0.029297424480319023, -0.04459729790687561, 0.017778534442186356, 0.013530745171010494, 0.002682661172002554, 0.042461223900318146, 0.005021519493311644, -0.0007136242347769439, -0.0364869050681591, 0.029788849875330925, -0.05684991553425789, 0.009202787652611732, 0.042032741010189056, 0.031495627015829086, -0.07154779881238937, -0.0581807978451252, 0.01512267254292965, 0.024410296231508255, 0.019187506288290024, 0.05066675320267677, 0.06512576341629028, -0.007500242441892624, -0.009250439703464508, -0.011391106992959976, -0.0074076890014112, -0.04353690147399902, -0.008648589253425598, -0.02253413200378418, 0.0063844905234873295, -0.034425150603055954, 0.020876048132777214, -0.010753490962088108, 0.06681495904922485, -0.035063277930021286, 0.01220192201435566, 0.0764986127614975, 0.02150002121925354, -0.03844893351197243, 0.0018801034893840551, 0.013873404823243618, 0.03859324753284454, -0.025439679622650146, 0.049286410212516785, 0.020310210064053535, 0.023355072364211082, -0.03206567466259003, -0.018997201696038246, 0.03417930752038956, -0.02609158493578434, 0.04835846647620201, 0.012603888288140297, 0.0699610710144043, 0.01866549625992775, -0.08291848748922348, 0.06433819979429245, -0.03521253541111946, 0.030401645228266716, -0.008529816754162312, -0.009646288119256496, -0.03334108740091324, 0.06491194665431976, -0.0048346566036343575, 0.03641488030552864, -0.014518855139613152, -0.045245461165905, -0.016127467155456543, 0.027752693742513657, -0.07697654515504837, -0.008677532896399498, 0.01437778864055872, 0.00007746984192635864, 0.03310771286487579, -0.028595931828022003, 0.05406254902482033, 0.03567330911755562, 0.053767431527376175, 0.03131289407610893, -0.030952218919992447, 0.0565217025578022, 0.03693936765193939, -0.020108480006456375, 0.015924058854579926, 0.020836828276515007, -0.004612370859831572, 0.010679260827600956, 0.04888958856463432, 0.00908924825489521, -0.009997108951210976, 0.007842360995709896, 0.02278931438922882, -0.06899770349264145, 0.03275565057992935, 0.04997924715280533, 0.052929531782865524, -0.032633520662784576, 0.02876153029501438, 0.016330625861883163, -0.006918392144143581, -0.016145361587405205, 0.017448505386710167, 0.0023833822924643755, -0.008262607268989086, 0.03056769259274006, -0.0021019780542701483, -0.03663468360900879, -0.01561188604682684, -0.020964955911040306, 0.025766218081116676, -0.011798894964158535, 0.04432881623506546, -0.012612828053534031, 0.03321933001279831, 0.037116847932338715, 0.10525859892368317, 0.0006624506204389036, -0.010713137686252594, 0.006898590363562107, 0.009855031035840511, 0.04098081588745117, -0.021241208538413048, -0.00943717546761036, -0.010989146307110786, 0.07748571783304214, 0.02183680422604084, -0.05122537165880203, 0.016154231503605843, -0.003987815696746111, 0.0655817836523056, 0.017888231202960014, 0.023091720417141914, -0.07152474671602249, -0.0005310655105859041, 0.037033043801784515, -0.06848694384098053, 0.05168043076992035, 0.045841991901397705, 0.022609900683164597, 0.010309083387255669, 0.03625120967626572, -0.03034423477947712, -0.009375298395752907, -0.01953408308327198, 0.012937367893755436, 0.00039149835356511176, -0.021463582292199135, 0.0009468419593758881, -0.0276683047413826, -0.03254358842968941, -0.026127193123102188, 0.0004745640035253018, -0.01567983254790306, -0.025510767474770546, 0.020437821745872498, 0.04917604476213455, 0.0057155294343829155, 0.03153904899954796, -0.0340048186480999, -0.01877240464091301, 0.007797215599566698, 0.004480564501136541, 0.06789156049489975, 0.00239421334117651, -0.008480001240968704, 0.03909940645098686, 0.02094467729330063, -0.08037444204092026, 0.016920525580644608, -0.022794028744101524, -0.0003105191863141954, -0.009332148358225822, -0.07812925428152084, 0.005497816484421492, -0.0029966486617922783, -0.019249122589826584, 0.030900858342647552, -0.017008982598781586, 0.019355593249201775, 0.04924130439758301, 0.040779951959848404, 0.007412061095237732, -0.032343342900276184, -0.05903075635433197, -0.06569693982601166, -0.04596526175737381, -0.01938360370695591, -0.002437455579638481, 0.024530639871954918, 0.018828177824616432, -0.023758433759212494, -0.00016588579455856234, -0.005147377494722605, -0.020659934729337692, 0.020014220848679543, -0.03618647903203964, 0.005674248561263084, 0.026863524690270424, 0.005081033334136009, -0.020756185054779053, -0.04310190677642822, 0.018441341817378998, -0.0014953183708712459, 0.04111035540699959, -0.016569968312978745, 0.009448613040149212, 0.024531438946723938, -0.015793247148394585, -0.04931025207042694, 0.02017354592680931, -0.02571624517440796, 0.04691582918167114, -0.000653511902783066, 0.013673331588506699, 0.04088461026549339, -0.05123933404684067, 0.02732677012681961, -0.06114201247692108, 0.013285375200212002, 0.05489114299416542, 0.028746288269758224, 0.024367710575461388, 0.01723160594701767, -0.05483122169971466, -0.030199438333511353, -0.026758214458823204, 0.004024398513138294, 0.022689344361424446, -0.012327863834798336, 0.08641252666711807, -0.039009012281894684, -0.013562432490289211, 0.018717775121331215, -0.021240416914224625, 0.01700005494058132, 0.023902911692857742, -0.041216686367988586, -0.043386779725551605, 0.008380703628063202, 0.034752994775772095, 0.07562162727117538, -0.015531174838542938, 0.01655356027185917, -0.04738152399659157, -0.001756572164595127, -0.03633071482181549, 0.0075131747871637344, 0.019001657143235207, 0.02250029146671295, 0.0018816454103216529, -0.02546069398522377, -0.012363559566438198, -0.0027164416387677193, 0.025556934997439384, 0.03466438502073288, -0.0446125864982605, 0.04123048111796379, -0.007224045693874359, 0.058363933116197586, 0.061337973922491074, -0.05378924310207367, 0.018606852740049362, 0.04369940608739853, -0.006380618549883366, -0.018061572685837746, 0.03329957276582718, -0.054659124463796616, -0.009501274675130844, 0.03993121162056923, 0.05006882920861244, -0.041498273611068726, -0.009876552037894726, 0.07905776798725128, -0.03278202936053276, -0.01303897425532341, 0.013462080620229244, -0.048408761620521545, 0.015699198469519615, -0.009261862374842167, 0.017697855830192566, 0.0032569083850830793, -0.020243877544999123, -0.0003698767104651779, 0.046421896666288376, -0.0059867906384170055, -0.017066802829504013, 0.0637962818145752, -0.021428609266877174, 0.030168194323778152, -0.027818161994218826, -0.018960433080792427, -0.013863987289369106, -0.04428976774215698, 0.025812502950429916, -0.0442366898059845, -0.028922753408551216, 0.012130013667047024, -0.03648774325847626, 0.030231865122914314, 0.023539409041404724, -0.0313393697142601, 0.02907564304769039, -0.0430111326277256, -0.0007729615899734199, 0.021760106086730957, -0.011844171211123466, 0.0008377897320315242, -0.03872189670801163, -0.04444881156086922, -0.024981485679745674, -0.013534597121179104, -0.0030430196784436703, -0.08452155441045761, -0.03742703050374985, -0.0338025838136673, -0.02762126922607422, 0.008462979458272457, -0.013355015777051449, 0.06522452086210251, 0.01565830036997795, -0.018577026203274727, -0.039611201733350754, -0.024597181007266045, 0.06531038135290146, -0.02748769149184227, 0.023675182834267616, -0.060503046959638596, 0.023763097822666168, 0.008052603341639042, 0.014583872631192207, 0.00230336538515985, 0.0026075311470776796, 0.08462584763765335, -0.0019273029174655676, -0.007939532399177551, 0.03199870139360428, -0.0323450043797493, 0.037691954523324966, -0.00771028408780694, -0.005550754722207785, 0.06828933209180832, 0.013676980510354042, 0.07135045528411865, 0.050495538860559464, -0.018314851447939873, -0.01739349029958248, 0.018687158823013306, -0.01826743222773075, -0.08398928493261337, -0.015767419710755348, -0.07432293891906738, -0.026613252237439156, 0.07896021008491516, 0.027276499196887016, 0.011313441209495068, -0.007840079255402088, 0.005560190882533789, 0.012820704840123653, 0.0382302924990654, 0.01373599749058485, 0.022533170878887177, -0.011540782637894154, 0.03636208549141884, -0.012971054762601852, -0.0026660358998924494, -0.051607076078653336, -0.01160938385874033, 0.05149892345070839, -0.060570452362298965, 0.0002587501658126712, -0.014864656142890453, 0.018369929865002632, 0.005143158603459597, 0.009110542014241219, -0.025506800040602684, 0.025189006701111794, 0.08048689365386963, -0.019316747784614563, 0.051805585622787476, -0.006118259858340025, 0.012571342289447784, -0.006974838208407164, -0.09417729824781418, -0.004378504119813442, 0.05133729800581932, -0.014052549377083778, -0.011995730921626091, -0.029877524822950363, -0.03243473172187805, 0.0310653243213892, -0.05034748092293739, 0.0026199398562312126, -0.011941879987716675, 0.040589846670627594, 0.019091520458459854, -0.03571251779794693, -0.011179600842297077, -0.0011299115139991045, -0.005159157793968916, -0.0095311114564538, -0.0446699820458889, 0.013144743628799915, -0.05514846742153168, -0.0104423388838768, -0.06411987543106079, -0.01942758820950985, -0.05355031043291092, -0.012762456201016903, 0.05666811391711235, -0.0535714291036129, -0.025306466966867447, -0.004744202364236116, 0.04655499756336212, -0.018329434096813202, -0.004126102663576603, 0.041842300444841385, -0.04099053516983986, 0.003869180101901293, -0.04401339590549469, 0.022050408646464348, -0.05155433341860771, 0.008160591125488281, 0.02570808120071888, 0.021456072106957436, 0.01368333213031292, -0.040970318019390106, 0.0014875762863084674, -0.02571284957230091, -0.039508771151304245, -0.01238988060504198, 0.05913573503494263, -0.02238832414150238, 0.018498310819268227, 0.00015935298870317638, -0.015437901020050049, 0.06461768597364426, -0.00588702829554677, -0.024558426812291145, -0.007222140673547983, -0.017203817144036293, 0.012864727526903152, -0.027307886630296707, 0.03944246843457222, 0.03341980278491974, -0.02014254964888096, 0.05417456105351448, -0.057801563292741776, -0.050164595246315, -0.005281826946884394, 0.0011995595414191484, -0.05769360810518265, -0.021052923053503036, -0.03968348726630211, -0.014664878137409687, 0.019790802150964737, -0.04973997548222542, -0.009685022756457329, 0.014644225127995014, -0.019858190789818764, -0.038234859704971313, 0.081723153591156, -0.013854111544787884, -0.022048769518733025, 0.0007411714759655297, -0.017242897301912308, -0.030492326244711876, 0.04323088377714157, 0.02874898724257946, -0.04228057712316513, 0.021909385919570923, 0.06081486493349075, 0.04420255497097969, 0.05657237395644188, -0.009735471569001675, -0.06343784928321838, 0.011120474897325039, -0.00037693537888117135, -0.038375336676836014, 0.0358927845954895, 0.03302723914384842, 0.024845117703080177, -0.06804275512695312, 0.01803055964410305, -0.028397338464856148, 0.009004366584122181, -0.008359492756426334, -0.036383457481861115, -0.03616810590028763, -0.04337812587618828, 0.066804900765419, 0.028772586956620216, -0.025292962789535522, 0.03941229730844498, 0.020891889929771423, -0.023604238405823708, -0.011300657875835896, 0.004896759055554867, 0.017045529559254646, -0.002852552803233266, 0.043724991381168365, -0.030677221715450287, -0.032664716243743896, -0.023469867184758186, -0.01849358342587948, 0.04100093990564346, -0.03558148071169853, -0.020469384267926216, 0.05494660139083862, 0.02424020692706108, 0.017142092809081078, -0.046353574842214584, 0.001724504167214036, -0.04974384233355522, 0.04133844003081322, 0.027714913710951805, 0.02123125083744526, 0.06780155748128891, -0.14109958708286285, -0.04441899061203003, -0.04299863427877426, 0.018070457503199577, -0.009924418292939663, -0.012858380563557148, -0.028159691020846367, -0.013424118049442768, 0.029648274183273315, -0.03784961253404617, 0.03141696751117706, -0.06786859780550003, 0.016005652025341988, 0.02590656653046608, 0.013142471201717854, 0.019219817593693733, 0.008897357620298862, 0.02061300538480282, 0.020101945847272873, -0.058666449040174484, 0.015001670457422733, -0.03686172515153885, -0.056214649230241776, 0.041796959936618805, -0.026623301208019257, -0.011072668246924877, -0.0360838808119297, 0.021836599335074425, 0.007492317818105221, 0.05177256092429161, -0.035580262541770935, 0.04322132095694542, -0.017020931467413902, -0.013672902248799801, 0.03356637805700302, 0.001614580862224102, -0.028739970177412033, -0.07276327908039093, 0.018168658018112183, -0.02709224633872509, 0.015212097205221653, -0.007240870501846075, -0.01810966618359089, 0.02397639863193035, -0.02049892209470272, -0.049796607345342636, -0.06083150953054428, -0.04510953649878502, -0.03055255115032196, 0.01640872284770012, 0.003176457714289427, -0.01618567667901516, 0.008205040358006954, 0.055222287774086, -0.04470397159457207, -0.0103739183396101, -0.027051381766796112, -0.030328812077641487, -0.027406342327594757, -0.014528520405292511, 0.018212221562862396, -0.061053864657878876, -0.008409871719777584, 0.03623436391353607, -0.0339142270386219, 0.009951985441148281, 0.04945344477891922, -0.044303759932518005, -0.02401181124150753, 0.010867760516703129, 0.0006784807192161679, -0.011031254194676876, 0.07662079483270645, 0.07223952561616898, 0.00984638649970293, 0.00006060948362573981, -0.07197228074073792, -0.018261507153511047, -0.0230550616979599, -0.05715154483914375, -0.010582713410258293, 0.0009683601092547178, 0.06281924247741699, 0.036514248698949814, 0.06206377595663071, -0.008747943677008152, 0.007471716031432152, -0.03975548967719078, -0.019657617434859276, -0.021622207015752792, -0.0053529017604887486, -0.04804563522338867, 0.031709473580121994, 0.023776264861226082, 0.01844850182533264, -0.004142989404499531, 0.0279542189091444, 0.07359908521175385, 0.08171593397855759, -0.05474274232983589, 0.06134645640850067, 0.029483743011951447, 0.021031968295574188, 0.008478025905787945, -0.004225770942866802, -0.040978603065013885, -0.020819898694753647, 0.013554242439568043, -0.025448884814977646, -0.015980200842022896, -0.02543289214372635, -0.04835242033004761, 0.046736158430576324, -0.011323511600494385, 0.025007491931319237, 0.01870332658290863, -0.07439401745796204, -0.03557088226079941, 0.009743736125528812, -0.02918066829442978, -0.028444752097129822, -0.04358327016234398, -0.02678920328617096, 0.014811186119914055, 0.03164949268102646, -0.05683554336428642, 0.031605519354343414, -0.0485406294465065, -0.08866384625434875, 0.037047337740659714, -0.04551329091191292, -0.021919487044215202, 0.029968421906232834, 0.06544841825962067, -0.0387391597032547, -0.023673007264733315, 0.00840040110051632, -0.005288851913064718, -0.019841263070702553, 0.020808493718504906, 0.05103806406259537, -0.02326086163520813, 0.06414233148097992, 0.044069357216358185, -0.0285171065479517, 0.03295872360467911, 0.011700954288244247, 0.02362382411956787, 0.00021700424258597195, 0.05112491920590401, 0.041187405586242676, -0.03847736492753029, -0.037637606263160706 ]
<p>As title, I have a correlation matrix available with cor() function </p> <pre><code> corMatrix&lt;-cor(mydata) corMatrix is a 98 by 98 matrix storing positive and negative correlation values. </code></pre> <p>I want to assess which correlations values are significant among all the correlations. Permutation test has been suggested to do this.</p> <p>How to perform a permutation test on the correlation matrix ? How to obtain p-values for each correlation value estimated ? Any package suggested ? Or answer with working code will be well appreciated. </p>
g74316
[ 0.005823835730552673, -0.004649779759347439, -0.0122431805357337, -0.06351139396429062, 0.0031602391973137856, -0.015508943237364292, 0.05546507611870766, -0.002878518309444189, -0.06424811482429504, -0.043408118188381195, -0.0034682380501180887, 0.020144719630479813, 0.011321565136313438, 0.04649294540286064, -0.004961594473570585, -0.04784560948610306, 0.02987966686487198, -0.01050233468413353, -0.004466412588953972, 0.01813315600156784, 0.01869232766330242, -0.031895603984594345, 0.012848323211073875, 0.04399419575929642, 0.016717644408345222, -0.09636964648962021, -0.02222180925309658, 0.057505976408720016, -0.06009361892938614, 0.022010445594787598, 0.0347941517829895, 0.014027638360857964, 0.06761591881513596, -0.07436182349920273, -0.02866274304687977, 0.018552882596850395, 0.013662931509315968, 0.00733702490106225, -0.0017394976457580924, 0.01279208343476057, -0.07004406303167343, -0.04348193109035492, -0.01395801268517971, -0.004646691959351301, 0.012919421307742596, 0.025653550401329994, 0.051886919885873795, 0.0076529961079359055, -0.0521763451397419, -0.0007720594294369221, -0.02517985738813877, 0.034536659717559814, 0.08911817520856857, 0.0025244138669222593, 0.018407944589853287, 0.07002101838588715, 0.018326133489608765, 0.05489106476306915, 0.023753952234983444, 0.011576781049370766, -0.0016024246579036117, -0.09115943312644958, -0.016876960173249245, 0.0037246139254420996, -0.0015893721720203757, 0.0016959052300080657, -0.0024186125956475735, -0.035392552614212036, 0.0006830704514868557, -0.005380023270845413, 0.008518149144947529, -0.01276093628257513, 0.022284938022494316, 0.04440354183316231, -0.041355200111866, -0.0028725636657327414, 0.04716794937849045, -0.016225196421146393, 0.029048578813672066, -0.029103253036737442, 0.024744441732764244, 0.00779857998713851, -0.0028682369738817215, 0.025961367413401604, 0.053178612142801285, -0.011077405884861946, 0.007051391992717981, 0.0006260329391807318, 0.034302666783332825, 0.0005432823672890663, 0.004547100514173508, 0.009361853823065758, 0.032797712832689285, 0.06748831272125244, -0.0031220021191984415, 0.04495849087834358, -0.028939057141542435, -0.030560577288269997, -0.014480573125183582, -0.06705280393362045, -0.016116797924041748, 0.04717543348670006, 0.04163060337305069, -0.02233620546758175, -0.030884871259331703, 0.026329191401600838, -0.009505465626716614, 0.021554861217737198, -0.060564130544662476, 0.01778518408536911, -0.03911534324288368, 0.014219144359230995, -0.11724494397640228, 0.006194751244038343, 0.001966673880815506, 0.013646986335515976, 0.051108453422784805, -0.039237357676029205, -0.04947089031338692, -0.02496604062616825, 0.02681318111717701, 0.009193461388349533, 0.0005405374686233699, 0.06430704146623611, 0.0006714955088682473, -0.011889457702636719, -0.07800128310918808, 0.007812796160578728, -0.007952275685966015, 0.015665052458643913, 0.029634391888976097, 0.006658314727246761, -0.002719136653468013, 0.035921111702919006, -0.027882348746061325, -0.013319599442183971, -0.021551311016082764, 0.044831350445747375, 0.009902599267661572, 0.03686198592185974, -0.08673615753650665, -0.01660854183137417, -0.010950766503810883, 0.034165989607572556, 0.01727253757417202, -0.01791963540017605, 0.05786088481545448, 0.019802557304501534, 0.00022667676967103034, 0.0333985909819603, 0.014905748888850212, -0.022146984934806824, -0.05942772701382637, 0.0007607928127981722, 0.021783145144581795, -0.007528585381805897, -0.024451276287436485, -0.05744735524058342, -0.026141006499528885, 0.02947952412068844, -0.01939835026860237, -0.015707962214946747, 0.10050404071807861, 0.015175249427556992, 0.029779979959130287, -0.031744979321956635, -0.00727622676640749, -0.02306952513754368, 0.030223242938518524, -0.01466694101691246, 0.011135166510939598, -0.005275271832942963, -0.013841093517839909, -0.09055902808904648, -0.05568228289484978, 0.00811801478266716, 0.02990543469786644, -0.0500948466360569, 0.06923145800828934, 0.029840081930160522, 0.005530769936740398, 0.035170141607522964, 0.001460609375499189, 0.007078494876623154, 0.04661677032709122, -0.008712474256753922, -0.00024567899527028203, 0.038931749761104584, -0.09981945902109146, 0.033068012446165085, -0.010304095223546028, -0.0323580801486969, -0.03402336314320564, 0.004306613001972437, -0.003617697162553668, -0.06654287874698639, 0.0038168139290064573, -0.03284338861703873, 0.023207636550068855, -0.043356336653232574, 0.058618661016225815, 0.002627998823300004, -0.0031121419742703438, 0.10634094476699829, -0.0038554465863853693, 0.009309735149145126, -0.041167497634887695, -0.008998455479741096, -0.016678959131240845, 0.019087210297584534, 0.004259355366230011, -0.01406499370932579, -0.010505205020308495, 0.042182136327028275, 0.015900993719697, -0.000003899572675436502, 0.017153175547719002, 0.02026447281241417, -0.02940993569791317, 0.04686620458960533, -0.0038386203814297915, -0.037805430591106415, -0.0008856002823449671, -0.021152984350919724, 0.015139608643949032, 0.08835440129041672, 0.008368849754333496, -0.007862431928515434, 0.0012023483868688345, 0.01993750035762787, 0.001020868425257504, 0.017031848430633545, -0.027315741404891014, 0.04902912303805351, -0.005533629097044468, 0.06706499308347702, 0.002500459086149931, 0.024854063987731934, -0.07305643707513809, 0.05872427672147751, -0.02378511242568493, 0.0299738347530365, 0.04990086331963539, 0.03721601888537407, 0.03317258134484291, -0.030769335106015205, 0.01401732861995697, 0.006308299023658037, 0.011929667554795742, 0.04514840990304947, -0.03974141553044319, 0.051679521799087524, -0.027323340997099876, -0.01916629821062088, 0.033299896866083145, -0.020867757499217987, 0.04477261006832123, 0.0008695946307852864, 0.04690044745802879, -0.009440281428396702, 0.0028008390218019485, -0.07834949344396591, -0.026574477553367615, 0.04661392793059349, 0.05817580223083496, -0.047102369368076324, 0.004171747714281082, -0.06313586980104446, -0.009802625514566898, -0.020022690296173096, -0.03330567851662636, 0.02425345964729786, 0.05021341145038605, 0.009163066744804382, 0.032889269292354584, 0.012174057774245739, -0.005511963274329901, 0.0062219551764428616, 0.013136152178049088, 0.012274541892111301, 0.016659347340464592, 0.03176649659872055, 0.002666172105818987, 0.029080264270305634, 0.015236152336001396, -0.057719457894563675, 0.01101711019873619, 0.03545105457305908, 0.029558127745985985, 0.060828786343336105, 0.018988432362675667, -0.01188192144036293, -0.05497804656624794, -0.05025963485240936, 0.0060298447497189045, -0.03332247957587242, -0.00513576390221715, -0.08893018215894699, 0.026010412722826004, 0.007387756370007992, -0.0336538702249527, -0.013571067713201046, 0.017699047923088074, -0.02555294893682003, 0.05811166390776634, -0.014966613613069057, 0.0015892445808276534, 0.042701028287410736, 0.005955029278993607, 0.006457203067839146, -0.04999576881527901, -0.06649117171764374, 0.011128977872431278, -0.04116098955273628, 0.0055811139754951, -0.006570515688508749, 0.08696584403514862, 0.01973702944815159, 0.05498788505792618, -0.045763399451971054, -0.02849636971950531, -0.011948314495384693, -0.001610733917914331, -0.015257785096764565, -0.0031901004258543253, -0.003407459007576108, 0.035446297377347946, 0.05722770839929581, -0.03449150547385216, -0.0013973050517961383, 0.0004101639206055552, 0.008530942723155022, 0.0017030473100021482, -0.02320433035492897, -0.016889013350009918, -0.04255058616399765, -0.012137560173869133, -0.018729757517576218, -0.0360105074942112, 0.04935286566615105, -0.014705910347402096, -0.03909800946712494, -0.013680263422429562, -0.005599380005151033, 0.007156573701649904, 0.002721220487728715, 0.05610239878296852, 0.014078985899686813, 0.028763413429260254, -0.03175617754459381, -0.030313510447740555, -0.0317424014210701, 0.01958259381353855, -0.024231337010860443, 0.016919072717428207, 0.05038852244615555, 0.030144283547997475, -0.02538527548313141, -0.03180041164159775, 0.029388386756181717, -0.023103734478354454, -0.01057090237736702, 0.02106880210340023, -0.03447446599602699, 0.06707420945167542, 0.04870665445923805, -0.022917021065950394, 0.00548045989125967, 0.06301344931125641, -0.001520004472695291, 0.03318071365356445, -0.014061587862670422, 0.03525707125663757, -0.04862852022051811, -0.01335517130792141, -0.02974332496523857, -0.006041205953806639, -0.009805776178836823, 0.028758874163031578, 0.05376362428069115, 0.0017110018525272608, -0.009349378757178783, 0.023791398853063583, 0.044785868376493454, -0.02878895215690136, -0.010476221330463886, 0.01525818184018135, 0.04375849664211273, 0.029383460059762, 0.009158533997833729, 0.01079514529556036, -0.013819142244756222, -0.07220325618982315, 0.07719171047210693, 0.013002694584429264, -0.02824949473142624, -0.015104061923921108, 0.056686270982027054, -0.003558881115168333, 0.04041178897023201, -0.060441143810749054, 0.006306332536041737, 0.057209331542253494, 0.0019144852412864566, -0.05570496246218681, -0.09701237082481384, -0.056019969284534454, -0.005948265548795462, -0.010124233551323414, -0.004489758051931858, -0.04356347396969795, 0.020250318571925163, 0.04013353958725929, -0.013572230003774166, 0.02774980291724205, 0.006128995213657618, 0.05043166130781174, -0.025520145893096924, 0.04354928433895111, -0.02024570107460022, 0.019754251465201378, 0.01003596093505621, 0.0388907752931118, -0.010723856277763844, 0.029693881049752235, -0.010803361423313618, 0.0265788771212101, 0.02898506447672844, 0.030169827863574028, 0.0050076935440301895, -0.0186003427952528, 0.0036184475757181644, 0.0014708442613482475, 0.008022362366318703, 0.006921486463397741, -0.0034267909359186888, -0.05545927211642265, -0.005720629822462797, -0.011960863135755062, -0.058406829833984375, -0.014602924697101116, 0.0018506550695747137, 0.042807795107364655, 0.029776709154248238, -0.04542181268334389, 0.025268064811825752, 0.020662929862737656, 0.020953623577952385, 0.00649062916636467, -0.020720984786748886, -0.04857613146305084, 0.0005161854205653071, -0.0014882715186104178, -0.027766689658164978, -0.028072506189346313, -0.021736769005656242, 0.07635357230901718, -0.04042641818523407, 0.047812506556510925, 0.04414651170372963, 0.02670508623123169, -0.009449356235563755, -0.07406168431043625, -0.047560833394527435, 0.03922324255108833, 0.006075769662857056, -0.05984245613217354, -0.031839769333601, 0.0456954725086689, -0.01620994694530964, 0.016830476000905037, 0.0019251868361607194, 0.014054715633392334, -0.03879135474562645, -0.028275787830352783, 0.035105668008327484, 0.01078889612108469, -0.03286854550242424, -0.019457969814538956, 0.03741182014346123, -0.03332746773958206, 0.0712195634841919, -0.001104626921005547, -0.05145787447690964, 0.03972973674535751, -0.03948703408241272, 0.018587373197078705, -0.06748009473085403, -0.031605690717697144, -0.06602715700864792, 0.02643917314708233, 0.008581150323152542, 0.03276337310671806, 0.046181820333004, 0.03979658707976341, -0.037636905908584595, -0.01699618250131607, -0.047507356852293015, 0.023616855964064598, -0.012217803858220577, 0.022034989669919014, 0.019030671566724777, -0.01040353998541832, 0.005911218002438545, -0.0010829081293195486, -0.054381098598241806, 0.07271741330623627, 0.003677000990137458, -0.02438695915043354, 0.0014014671323820949, -0.04847409948706627, 0.05533881112933159, -0.003566067898645997, 0.04421281814575195, -0.06370964646339417, -0.0033512425143271685, -0.05976416915655136, -0.03248963877558708, -0.06303299963474274, -0.048036012798547745, -0.0006246230332180858, -0.006117402110248804, 0.037578828632831573, -0.07506038248538971, -0.01770908385515213, -0.036017026752233505, -0.017432214692234993, -0.017528610303997993, -0.014073730446398258, -0.026640715077519417, -0.019980236887931824, -0.007721835747361183, -0.028567837551236153, 0.024126233533024788, -0.010019426234066486, -0.07085737586021423, -0.041195183992385864, 0.032954514026641846, 0.007408709730952978, 0.03651715815067291, 0.003996823914349079, 0.02218654379248619, -0.016187293455004692, -0.00436368677765131, -0.007455662824213505, -0.016182800754904747, -0.04477155581116676, 0.0010810215026140213, -0.003718517953529954, -0.013389399275183678, -0.017110327258706093, 0.040789712220430374, -0.05071892589330673, -0.04755333811044693, 0.014924982562661171, 0.01998085528612137, 0.029973801225423813, 0.01762639544904232, 0.03264235332608223, 0.05416499078273773, -0.009070728905498981, -0.049958743155002594, 0.0073919412679970264, -0.0008435407071374357, -0.04961128532886505, 0.008830303326249123, -0.05919967591762543, 0.012221687473356724, -0.022621987387537956, 0.025934366509318352, -0.007486183196306229, -0.024156970903277397, -0.04224200174212456, -0.003300264710560441, 0.03597463667392731, 0.02523907832801342, -0.023881597444415092, -0.005550683941692114, 0.022179817780852318, -0.015034056268632412, -0.001615637564100325, -0.037284206598997116, 0.012023200280964375, 0.0499211847782135, -0.012649540789425373, 0.07328236848115921, 0.06221320852637291, 0.0003513968549668789, -0.0668753907084465, -0.022550132125616074, -0.06539426743984222, 0.0192889217287302, 0.029883937910199165, -0.009613540023565292, 0.03123176097869873, -0.04380391910672188, -0.0350622795522213, 0.08204998821020126, 0.011152711696922779, -0.013817236758768559, 0.020184190943837166, -0.009437592700123787, 0.06680767238140106, -0.012861068360507488, -0.008674273267388344, 0.001155925914645195, -0.018673023208975792, 0.0012025898322463036, -0.03626244515180588, 0.07981075346469879, -0.015004171058535576, -0.04254775494337082, 0.01912633888423443, 0.08133824169635773, 0.008731070905923843, 0.021806420758366585, 0.006684061139822006, 0.027208086103200912, -0.031852662563323975, 0.03823450207710266, 0.00006708167347824201, 0.035577304661273956, -0.04525752365589142, -0.032792605459690094, 0.03193406015634537, 0.05954543501138687, 0.0005782256484963, -0.04800635576248169, 0.05436180904507637, 0.015213684178888798, -0.0712321549654007, 0.057679738849401474, -0.008488638326525688, -0.024823632091283798, -0.04184311628341675, 0.06063438951969147, -0.025448806583881378, 0.03962842375040054, 0.020161202177405357, 0.0934535339474678, -0.013937345705926418, 0.022710032761096954, -0.026293369010090828, -0.04602309316396713, -0.010240302421152592, 0.011103390716016293, 0.026064619421958923, 0.013326315209269524, 0.0063650100491940975, 0.027741651982069016, 0.029318656772375107, -0.0021060523577034473, 0.03923669829964638, -0.018500635400414467, -0.0010449911933392286, 0.0674116462469101, 0.11748883873224258, 0.01153181865811348, 0.04430827125906944, 0.011241636238992214, -0.05233190208673477, -0.0488700307905674, -0.0879492312669754, 0.03567076101899147, 0.042503178119659424, 0.05132704973220825, 0.03198827803134918, 0.013122757896780968, 0.05129290372133255, -0.06437081098556519, 0.006185553036630154, 0.0005545227904804051, -0.03988269716501236, 0.01485983096063137, 0.05130412057042122, -0.0012162895873188972, -0.008479476906359196, 0.01304748933762312, -0.04509473219513893, 0.00999822560697794, -0.1001792624592781, -0.0215158611536026, 0.005445218179374933, 0.027897967025637627, 0.008128613233566284, 0.04515990987420082, -0.07928390800952911, -0.0053413850255310535, 0.006143088918179274, -0.06311525404453278, -0.0474417582154274, -0.08048875629901886, 0.008577275089919567, -0.0046966481022536755, -0.048941031098365784, 0.015847858041524887, 0.052841465920209885, -0.07423275709152222, 0.03468002378940582, 0.05902891233563423, -0.03664176166057587, -0.008662630803883076, -0.054810747504234314, 0.024276496842503548, 0.008351407013833523, -0.002110018627718091, -0.046097997575998306, -0.00481111416593194, -0.06306201219558716, -0.03207120671868324, 0.013023233972489834, 0.019679443910717964, -0.036274928599596024, -0.019010592252016068, -0.03800388053059578, 0.06176680698990822, 0.005257866345345974, 0.026955701410770416, -0.02988818846642971, -0.001331889652647078, -0.023108595982193947, -0.02734874002635479, -0.010919318534433842, -0.01290134061127901, -0.020040925592184067, -0.027345797047019005, -0.021933339536190033, 0.08129356056451797, -0.01722060889005661, -0.00403558649122715, -0.03780005872249603, -0.04078441858291626, -0.07472889870405197, 0.047208186239004135, -0.014520389959216118, 0.01682332530617714, 0.02954735979437828, 0.04193515330553055, -0.04015360772609711, -0.013098355382680893, 0.028275106102228165, -0.06176513060927391, 0.022378582507371902, -0.015119165182113647, 0.027776742354035378, 0.0044881016947329044, 0.0017839561915025115, 0.021517980843782425, 0.00555581646040082, -0.02749846689403057, -0.06633339822292328, 0.008285019546747208, 0.020919499918818474, 0.0598222017288208, -0.03908349201083183, 0.013819621875882149, 0.038201846182346344, -0.017702441662549973, 0.05492664873600006, 0.022784549742937088, 0.034786973148584366, 0.017677174881100655, -0.05031323432922363, -0.0017943590646609664, -0.04625757783651352, 0.015416602604091167, -0.06174422800540924, -0.027072355151176453 ]
<p>One particular assumption is that $e_{i} \sim N(0,\sigma^{2})$ but I was wondering why we use a QQ plot to test this assumption since we have $n$ iid distributions to look at. When we use a QQ plot, aren't we looking for the normality of all the residuals as opposed to one particular $e_{i}$? I am confused about this assumption. Does the QQ plot somehow imply that each $e_{i}$ is normally distributed?</p>
g74317
[ 0.041966512799263, -0.01969120278954506, -0.013143331743776798, -0.032322484999895096, -0.06069929525256157, 0.003476805053651333, 0.06894531100988388, -0.029818812385201454, -0.04192342609167099, -0.006615387741476297, -0.003915836103260517, 0.04699259623885155, 0.016449935734272003, 0.005554615519940853, -0.061864376068115234, -0.03554701805114746, 0.0059137530624866486, -0.02783649042248726, 0.050080928951501846, 0.014202686958014965, -0.03379613161087036, -0.05123298987746239, 0.03253103792667389, -0.02002590149641037, 0.06903316080570221, 0.0007753916434012353, 0.0019001344917342067, 0.03251545876264572, 0.004974217154085636, -0.024278784170746803, 0.006948518566787243, 0.0421576201915741, 0.046319447457790375, -0.04262223094701767, -0.06451091915369034, -0.007728219963610172, -0.0023348175454884768, 0.04661942273378372, 0.00833920482546091, -0.03360328823328018, -0.07790166884660721, -0.0027324703987687826, -0.0039903209544718266, 0.00592777831479907, 0.00029593741055577993, 0.048672154545784, -0.004709657281637192, 0.09085428714752197, 0.009212681092321873, -0.02800963632762432, -0.021187562495470047, 0.02618713676929474, 0.04817619174718857, -0.025621283799409866, 0.025135895237326622, -0.022638652473688126, -0.0008384712273254991, 0.025233494117856026, -0.0023333674762398005, 0.019294505938887596, -0.004968440160155296, 0.029174145311117172, 0.03510475531220436, -0.07447489351034164, 0.02575245313346386, -0.004128212109208107, -0.03167020156979561, 0.02898181602358818, -0.0333324633538723, 0.009215028956532478, -0.005904283374547958, -0.024010414257645607, 0.012826690450310707, -0.00278463470749557, -0.038666874170303345, -0.006140726152807474, 0.03236418962478638, 0.02805459313094616, -0.043530646711587906, 0.030792921781539917, -0.026741135865449905, -0.03755367174744606, 0.019490458071231842, 0.05421208590269089, 0.06124899536371231, 0.028354495763778687, 0.0807284489274025, -0.033946532756090164, 0.013223855756223202, 0.0041541242972016335, 0.06653138995170593, -0.002470129169523716, 0.01810305565595627, 0.08257296681404114, -0.026756012812256813, -0.06720423698425293, -0.04482700303196907, 0.02329386956989765, -0.05370977148413658, -0.003254050388932228, 0.01643223501741886, 0.06186485290527344, 0.03288203850388527, -0.026051146909594536, -0.06173498183488846, 0.030571062117815018, 0.021092433482408524, 0.043828267604112625, 0.056761108338832855, -0.011957326903939247, 0.015344791114330292, 0.02444283850491047, -0.08474719524383545, 0.02015763893723488, -0.06452660262584686, -0.0182420052587986, 0.03127953037619591, -0.02060128189623356, -0.043976809829473495, 0.02056841365993023, -0.007419892121106386, 0.012433881871402264, 0.0024857011158019304, 0.04115748405456543, -0.009623929858207703, 0.003406476229429245, -0.057893186807632446, 0.02720056287944317, 0.022816749289631844, 0.023052437230944633, 0.017750190570950508, 0.03399967402219772, -0.00235708593390882, 0.046414487063884735, 0.01676912233233452, -0.002574671758338809, -0.035044923424720764, 0.0173949021846056, -0.009583473205566406, 0.01589762419462204, -0.05045219510793686, 0.03556131571531296, -0.013417297042906284, -0.03120269812643528, -0.011991514824330807, -0.039143431931734085, 0.07953032851219177, 0.012214883230626583, -0.05789896473288536, 0.04762318730354309, -0.015005592256784439, 0.031379152089357376, -0.007854349911212921, -0.03643297031521797, 0.0011258372105658054, 0.030391935259103775, -0.0017560505075380206, -0.027456827461719513, -0.038454923778772354, 0.0425964891910553, 0.021378712728619576, 0.004576137289404869, 0.007750535383820534, 0.010782193392515182, -0.004200926050543785, -0.0008859583758749068, 0.03486934304237366, -0.013579165562987328, -0.010344861075282097, -0.012234273366630077, -0.0024432740174233913, 0.049580980092287064, -0.03073277696967125, -0.009161824360489845, -0.023858558386564255, -0.0067020319402217865, 0.029454287141561508, 0.003446679562330246, 0.04667441174387932, 0.07221151888370514, -0.00821726955473423, 0.05707995593547821, -0.03223660960793495, -0.01924828067421913, -0.039729803800582886, -0.02400599978864193, 0.02006939984858036, 0.0018502576276659966, -0.0005140030989423394, 0.020362161099910736, 0.004684261977672577, -0.008557603694498539, -0.052764322608709335, 0.009900339879095554, -0.028978031128644943, -0.02599247545003891, -0.01315338909626007, -0.01090529840439558, -0.024870246648788452, 0.03644043579697609, 0.027127090841531754, -0.009888552129268646, 0.0051945834420621395, -0.02666073851287365, -0.026318421587347984, -0.047965262085199356, 0.001104978146031499, -0.04901411756873131, 0.02269362099468708, 0.025006869807839394, 0.023539910092949867, -0.03712732717394829, 0.029924750328063965, 0.05184842273592949, 0.0790405422449112, -0.04194708541035652, 0.029287658631801605, 0.0018500220030546188, 0.004796452354639769, 0.0024704544339329004, -0.05267328768968582, -0.03461645171046257, -0.012002488598227501, -0.01569446362555027, 0.0348854623734951, 0.03837813436985016, 0.06658116728067398, -0.0079983314499259, 0.012843910604715347, 0.06584799289703369, -0.08978039771318436, -0.07247678190469742, -0.009292217902839184, 0.03534983471035957, 0.022965921089053154, 0.011602613143622875, -0.06006095930933952, -0.017795398831367493, 0.0751030445098877, 0.039079632610082626, 0.03437624126672745, -0.031160786747932434, -0.021667636930942535, 0.07258562743663788, 0.0011563376756384969, -0.010039428249001503, 0.012060215696692467, -0.01120462641119957, 0.012572921812534332, 0.04641878977417946, -0.03084009513258934, 0.034543201327323914, -0.0033539514988660812, 0.02350056916475296, 0.016162633895874023, -0.07444518804550171, -0.024016806855797768, -0.034509774297475815, -0.0410463772714138, -0.01584351249039173, -0.07613326609134674, 0.00016706492169760168, 0.02033478394150734, -0.016321618109941483, -0.05285564810037613, -0.013365144841372967, -0.005403998773545027, 0.004528988152742386, 0.0006917142891325057, -0.03584180399775505, -0.029507214203476906, 0.04943530634045601, 0.01158472616225481, 0.09856534749269485, 0.010123418644070625, -0.03362973779439926, -0.008041421882808208, 0.008726975880563259, -0.007901119999587536, -0.041523564606904984, 0.02013545110821724, 0.011419683694839478, -0.05952420085668564, 0.015545045025646687, 0.039661705493927, -0.029276615008711815, 0.016665896400809288, 0.004175808280706406, 0.006194200366735458, -0.016850629821419716, -0.03365464508533478, -0.036075688898563385, -0.0025940830819308758, 0.027112524956464767, -0.05883057415485382, -0.031839802861213684, -0.024873314425349236, -0.10668820142745972, -0.019129043444991112, 0.008871814236044884, -0.06114388257265091, 0.005097405519336462, -0.0024580908939242363, 0.005244208965450525, 0.01401382777839899, -0.009835760109126568, -0.04243023321032524, -0.05526517704129219, -0.03658146783709526, -0.011238212697207928, 0.028816595673561096, 0.04106534272432327, -0.02596849389374256, -0.02075236663222313, -0.038530778139829636, 0.003059257986024022, 0.04261031001806259, 0.007215062156319618, 0.06209346652030945, -0.02344238944351673, -0.03893265873193741, -0.021482864394783974, 0.02772960625588894, 0.030860774219036102, 0.015184720046818256, -0.021517224609851837, -0.01907922700047493, 0.009170309640467167, -0.026278235018253326, 0.010879335924983025, 0.021651454269886017, 0.06322292983531952, 0.01982557401061058, 0.0035422404762357473, 0.025905903428792953, -0.03293142467737198, -0.06603661179542542, 0.02613772265613079, 0.0157577246427536, -0.03563878312706947, -0.027418093755841255, -0.03447839990258217, -0.04940599575638771, -0.04397079721093178, -0.04823862388730049, -0.052759792655706406, 0.026657594367861748, 0.06177235394716263, -0.009131199680268764, -0.023144954815506935, -0.018656032159924507, -0.008946141228079796, 0.015823204070329666, -0.017875103279948235, 0.03521455079317093, 0.05123496055603027, -0.010344531387090683, -0.015642287209630013, 0.06357362866401672, -0.00919471774250269, 0.09164975583553314, -0.06256411969661713, -0.023375799879431725, 0.018533755093812943, 0.0051023284904658794, -0.050321273505687714, -0.01072211004793644, 0.006004860159009695, -0.010418964549899101, 0.02051449567079544, -0.01890428736805916, 0.07809565216302872, 0.024905582889914513, 0.03994821757078171, 0.03313824161887169, 0.008465229533612728, -0.0066581713035702705, 0.03511110693216324, -0.023859761655330658, -0.0007872206042520702, 0.016501884907484055, 0.006850000936537981, -0.025879355147480965, 0.021051164716482162, 0.015255430713295937, -0.02885914221405983, -0.010223482735455036, -0.005130432546138763, 0.009094072505831718, -0.054591644555330276, 0.005301946774125099, -0.03892436623573303, -0.04714563488960266, 0.0007644259603694081, 0.020028891041874886, -0.04622235149145126, 0.049130648374557495, 0.041526325047016144, 0.02390407957136631, 0.03392123058438301, -0.0003502890467643738, 0.004023479763418436, 0.06690040975809097, -0.04462183266878128, 0.06179061532020569, -0.03982734680175781, -0.02529776282608509, -0.013864364475011826, 0.001327446778304875, -0.06194194778800011, 0.026204152032732964, -0.01247597485780716, 0.008233019150793552, -0.022329779341816902, 0.07925181090831757, 0.035689983516931534, 0.0038855839520692825, -0.012139123864471912, -0.08036361634731293, -0.04408020153641701, -0.040570568293333054, -0.02700616605579853, -0.0217535812407732, -0.009009930305182934, 0.0011876238277181983, -0.006166224367916584, 0.04849850758910179, 0.02042326331138611, 0.05024036020040512, -0.06306327134370804, -0.050002571195364, 0.03150634467601776, -0.0016619825037196279, -0.01915455423295498, -0.005092319566756487, -0.04426461085677147, -0.011085367761552334, 0.06990084052085876, -0.018051469698548317, -0.03833828493952751, -0.017766984179615974, -0.02622947283089161, -0.04645462706685066, -0.009254047647118568, 0.006599005311727524, 0.02758677676320076, -0.007524949032813311, 0.012374061159789562, -0.008884928189218044, 0.004867292009294033, 0.00025013976846821606, 0.053038593381643295, -0.010068735107779503, -0.04005805775523186, 0.011059107258915901, -0.03305116668343544, 0.0011408169521018863, 0.00833403505384922, 0.04125066101551056, 0.032608818262815475, -0.03233262524008751, 0.00011710818944266066, 0.039857909083366394, -0.004380423575639725, 0.0038000529166311026, 0.00625851284712553, -0.08487050980329514, 0.0349842868745327, 0.015325645916163921, 0.011438647285103798, 0.026644403114914894, 0.008208946324884892, 0.06979253888130188, -0.06956330686807632, -0.005295712035149336, -0.015095902606844902, 0.018243558704853058, 0.026210179552435875, -0.024545269086956978, -0.03404684737324715, -0.01445939764380455, -0.04611831158399582, -0.0008594744722358882, 0.03913382440805435, 0.011634266935288906, -0.051506973803043365, -0.018644532188773155, -0.11533105373382568, 0.04005221277475357, -0.007461237255483866, 0.04825010523200035, -0.0634063184261322, 0.022641479969024658, 0.006562949623912573, -0.03424108773469925, -0.09527170658111572, 0.04662488400936127, -0.06932259351015091, -0.002609504386782646, -0.008360972627997398, -0.029812347143888474, 0.07078772783279419, -0.055428825318813324, -0.02027108706533909, 0.028720781207084656, 0.04289131239056587, 0.044596996158361435, -0.038304589688777924, -0.021489949896931648, 0.06530655175447464, 0.054604724049568176, 0.006322114262729883, 0.043154314160346985, -0.01754617691040039, 0.027503415942192078, 0.0015740576200187206, -0.07109837234020233, -0.039836712181568146, -0.017549464479088783, -0.023623263463377953, 0.004554401617497206, 0.04466049373149872, 0.04176587611436844, -0.018160633742809296, 0.010115326382219791, -0.03520260006189346, -0.01658237725496292, -0.04874841496348381, 0.024853555485606194, 0.05437905713915825, 0.014569609425961971, 0.0322701632976532, -0.020411398261785507, 0.0019952135626226664, 0.005046646576374769, 0.02458280138671398, -0.013155478984117508, 0.021985307335853577, 0.023246198892593384, -0.011910420842468739, -0.020325133576989174, -0.03926857188344002, 0.029577940702438354, 0.06385011970996857, -0.042202021926641464, 0.005171834956854582, 0.0004305057809688151, -0.010488869622349739, 0.044099319726228714, -0.04441794008016586, 0.03146560490131378, 0.032830558717250824, -0.04580356180667877, 0.015444829128682613, -0.01893642731010914, 0.025469845160841942, 0.03557128086686134, 0.025935303419828415, -0.016026675701141357, -0.01921175979077816, -0.00836198776960373, -0.06663738936185837, -0.007205788046121597, 0.003223319072276354, 0.015588167123496532, -0.031102405861020088, 0.026791764423251152, 0.04874078556895256, -0.04119104892015457, 0.04459922015666962, 0.03347175940871239, 0.003165407804772258, 0.02837374061346054, 0.08348576724529266, 0.057153984904289246, 0.0084559116512537, -0.017773961648344994, -0.029325788840651512, 0.024684272706508636, -0.03367645666003227, 0.014149474911391735, 0.012669702060520649, 0.053895920515060425, 0.002903614891692996, 0.04387654364109039, 0.06486411392688751, 0.03793022409081459, -0.039788972586393356, 0.07943624258041382, 0.024279557168483734, -0.019414201378822327, 0.01744394190609455, 0.03216397762298584, -0.04418580234050751, -0.027997154742479324, 0.002667064778506756, -0.004538453184068203, -0.008471185341477394, 0.032413050532341, -0.05345575511455536, 0.026143280789256096, 0.006209378596395254, 0.06979646533727646, -0.016039341688156128, 0.026054585352540016, -0.006039727479219437, 0.05613471567630768, 0.015616543591022491, -0.004630661569535732, -0.0013013203861191869, 0.006156085059046745, 0.017075171694159508, -0.041744913905858994, 0.007350024301558733, 0.05791063234210014, -0.06028030440211296, -0.04605642706155777, 0.015202638693153858, -0.04912478104233742, -0.001968621276319027, 0.04647587984800339, -0.022969262674450874, -0.056357964873313904, 0.00032403567456640303, 0.011287514120340347, 0.04291975125670433, -0.00951258186250925, -0.044385187327861786, 0.05973534286022186, 0.03976944461464882, -0.032932065427303314, 0.039673369377851486, -0.03984256833791733, -0.007972187362611294, -0.0632333979010582, -0.02513423003256321, -0.02610952779650688, 0.09226071834564209, -0.011259621009230614, 0.04611947014927864, -0.02066008746623993, 0.04234142601490021, 0.03499520570039749, 0.0017202910967171192, -0.04272262006998062, 0.04956590011715889, 0.06549622863531113, 0.04461686313152313, -0.06924817711114883, -0.03472190350294113, 0.03585236519575119, 0.08513268083333969, 0.008144637569785118, -0.03816702216863632, 0.013306165114045143, 0.03549593314528465, 0.049569059163331985, 0.034318890422582626, 0.01173060480505228, -0.025623491033911705, -0.04929663985967636, 0.01577507145702839, -0.009056269191205502, -0.012250017374753952, 0.020181188359856606, 0.013607426546514034, 0.026618214324116707, -0.025915371254086494, -0.01658530905842781, -0.03687234967947006, 0.03163561224937439, -0.029642613604664803, -0.020265378057956696, 0.028663044795393944, 0.01735590770840645, -0.028191769495606422, 0.04062847048044205, 0.010350113734602928, -0.03387371823191643, 0.015631556510925293, -0.024419549852609634, -0.01993797905743122, 0.02641480416059494, -0.0625920221209526, -0.04939340800046921, 0.03708435967564583, -0.05184358358383179, -0.10614815354347229, 0.01355025265365839, 0.02294427901506424, 0.011476543731987476, -0.03967662155628204, -0.0014285824727267027, 0.014426630921661854, 0.07281559705734253, 0.05210334435105324, -0.022877944633364677, -0.010108227841556072, 0.013494041748344898, 0.049919091165065765, 0.02165360376238823, 0.009181221015751362, -0.02791026048362255, 0.014026153832674026, 0.012890849262475967, -0.03638599440455437, 0.024015357717871666, -0.07731076329946518, -0.013552330434322357, -0.035886138677597046, -0.02480529621243477, -0.05172811076045036, 0.013126184232532978, 0.03747102990746498, 0.03796936571598053, -0.04174356162548065, -0.078947052359581, 0.0005521590355783701, 0.021947819739580154, -0.02929805777966976, -0.008014634251594543, 0.028461579233407974, 0.013318668119609356, 0.08589209616184235, -0.0009871566435322165, -0.026614338159561157, -0.0015909854555502534, -0.01686195842921734, -0.023834919556975365, 0.0734991729259491, -0.06076432392001152, 0.007859490811824799, -0.019819820299744606, 0.004964207299053669, -0.05626993998885155, -0.04818422347307205, 0.021704640239477158, -0.013895739801228046, -0.023841261863708496, 0.021372046321630478, -0.01916744001209736, 0.024046842008829117, -0.02196992002427578, -0.006660140585154295, -0.019037257879972458, -0.010330038145184517, 0.038927413523197174, -0.03734183683991432, 0.07689965516328812, -0.026424620300531387, -0.032203007489442825, -0.01482299529016018, -0.07635947316884995, 0.0940384790301323, 0.02709025889635086, -0.03575190529227257, 0.010758115909993649, 0.04416453093290329, 0.0363912396132946, 0.0148404436185956, 0.02292392961680889, -0.024102820083498955, -0.07334240525960922, 0.0028078926261514425, -0.03865582123398781, -0.022089602425694466, 0.015849808230996132, 0.02619660645723343 ]
<p>Reposted from Math.SE:</p> <p>Continuing from <a href="https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/593512/what-is-a-function-satisfying-these-constraints">this question</a>. Given two random variables $X$ and $Y$ where $X \sim \operatorname{Beta}(a, b)$ and $Y \sim \operatorname{Beta}(c, d)$, I'm looking for a random variable $Z$ with a distribution supported on $[0, 1]$ that satisfies the following constraints:</p> <ol> <li>The pdf of $Z$ has reflection symmetry: $f(x;a, b, c, d)=f(1-x;d, c, b, a)$</li> <li>If $\mathrm{E}[X] &gt; \frac{1}{2}$, then $\mathrm{E}[Z] &gt; \mathrm{E}[Y]$</li> <li>If $\mathrm{E}[X] = \frac{1}{2}$, then $\mathrm{E}[Z] = \mathrm{E}[Y]$</li> <li>If $\mathrm{E}[X] &lt; \frac{1}{2}$, then $\mathrm{E}[Z] &lt; \mathrm{E}[Y]$</li> <li>Increasing the expectation of $X$ or $Y$ must never decrease the expectation of $Z$.</li> </ol> <p>Is an answer to this question even possible? The answer to my first question does not seem to solve the problem (the expectations are OK, but the support constraint is violated).</p>
g74318
[ -0.030448751524090767, 0.01659277081489563, -0.02092442475259304, -0.06609805673360825, 0.03226084262132645, -0.0014250620733946562, 0.05376211926341057, -0.014185010455548763, -0.05916303023695946, -0.01656813733279705, -0.0316305011510849, 0.029951918870210648, -0.0011847477871924639, 0.00536780059337616, 0.008901764638721943, 0.08175663650035858, 0.0710221529006958, 0.002783610252663493, -0.03125246241688728, -0.04905523359775543, -0.03363127261400223, 0.0361754335463047, -0.011811268515884876, -0.02554270066320896, 0.10685285180807114, -0.01434685755521059, 0.019636662676930428, -0.0072517236694693565, -0.06648028641939163, 0.023637983947992325, -0.013909908011555672, 0.017989052459597588, 0.04661540314555168, -0.009927471168339252, 0.0025662805419415236, 0.01640545204281807, 0.07180272787809372, -0.021299483254551888, 0.021987976506352425, 0.0005940851988270879, -0.03156881779432297, 0.03586089611053467, 0.05004260316491127, -0.00914083607494831, -0.05893559381365776, -0.002487207530066371, -0.009801790118217468, 0.007150153163820505, 0.03707126900553703, -0.08586126565933228, 0.07947517931461334, 0.01883966103196144, 0.014270424842834473, -0.04964626580476761, -0.02816775068640709, 0.03229242563247681, -0.03792432323098183, -0.02473338134586811, -0.02322227507829666, 0.02122415602207184, -0.032138723880052567, -0.019820010289549828, -0.04625406488776207, -0.0008891337784007192, 0.004489836748689413, -0.005580720957368612, -0.040634434670209885, -0.030079970136284828, -0.043464574962854385, -0.012657011859118938, -0.02096734568476677, 0.03301791101694107, -0.015810923650860786, -0.06176583841443062, -0.041363079100847244, -0.03959369286894798, 0.01770244538784027, 0.009226729162037373, -0.07038484513759613, 0.002022051950916648, -0.033492788672447205, 0.017330238595604897, -0.006526046432554722, 0.031744584441185, 0.002573944628238678, 0.019855894148349762, 0.03880087658762932, 0.053773585706949234, 0.048157889395952225, 0.035179346799850464, 0.00981997512280941, -0.021049685776233673, 0.014349838718771935, 0.008693710900843143, 0.05327308550477028, 0.013614441268146038, -0.050706520676612854, -0.0010220338590443134, -0.02388482354581356, -0.01699039898812771, 0.014625176787376404, 0.016981353983283043, 0.059612955898046494, 0.017673121765255928, -0.05882976949214935, -0.011489391326904297, 0.07471854239702225, 0.012717276811599731, 0.026563094928860664, -0.045322682708501816, -0.023991070687770844, 0.004622175358235836, -0.04481356963515282, -0.05995766073465347, 0.007903162389993668, -0.05644605681300163, 0.05950433388352394, -0.005199909210205078, -0.0008023422560654581, -0.0016476208111271262, -0.013617665506899357, -0.026100298389792442, 0.02921636588871479, 0.06043615937232971, -0.014387902803719044, 0.03137146681547165, -0.01422798354178667, 0.08084520697593689, 0.04304492101073265, -0.043934497982263565, -0.028611738234758377, 0.034388743340969086, 0.027751129120588303, 0.018849309533834457, -0.018761418759822845, 0.00854726042598486, -0.06600118428468704, 0.06568952649831772, 0.030295372009277344, 0.006104836706072092, 0.011545134708285332, -0.04044370725750923, -0.01952078565955162, 0.008930916897952557, -0.005221614148467779, -0.061725690960884094, 0.016453132033348083, -0.0032816354651004076, -0.02626712992787361, 0.031122785061597824, -0.07887589931488037, 0.02576070837676525, -0.03679422661662102, 0.024239657446742058, -0.0000014182500081005855, 0.01471245102584362, 0.044526536017656326, -0.04098385572433472, -0.032120998948812485, -0.03479427471756935, 0.07210241258144379, 0.04800768941640854, -0.01828376017510891, 0.008073636330664158, -0.012570825405418873, -0.012397333979606628, -0.038238413631916046, -0.04210268333554268, -0.04065117985010147, -0.02162623219192028, -0.04193137586116791, 0.008189665153622627, -0.025940122082829475, 0.03656249865889549, 0.058947641402482986, 0.04426386579871178, -0.11662749946117401, 0.041016835719347, 0.03699766844511032, 0.02545517310500145, -0.03555639460682869, -0.009977983310818672, 0.01583600416779518, -0.03968741372227669, -0.00988743919879198, -0.05475348234176636, 0.036077361553907394, -0.018839236348867416, -0.08925431966781616, -0.020834224298596382, -0.0008579709683544934, -0.004609393887221813, 0.010608352720737457, -0.03141031414270401, -0.004589972086250782, 0.01126099843531847, 0.07525639235973358, -0.054518748074769974, -0.013592664152383804, 0.07466462254524231, 0.019666824489831924, 0.0496494434773922, 0.05698447674512863, -0.01682916469871998, -0.004478687420487404, 0.022340724244713783, -0.010971909388899803, -0.0443311370909214, -0.006174300331622362, 0.006410607136785984, -0.04247003793716431, -0.11526940762996674, -0.004100355319678783, -0.036897312849760056, 0.0543951615691185, -0.10951727628707886, 0.06697779148817062, 0.06562257558107376, -0.015761826187372208, -0.008665230125188828, -0.05100497230887413, -0.03698565810918808, 0.0421118400990963, -0.01425047405064106, -0.04536787047982216, 0.020140239968895912, -0.008439231663942337, -0.02360609918832779, 0.0037407593335956335, 0.020745012909173965, -0.0246176328510046, -0.0007950807921588421, 0.004234247375279665, -0.025059891864657402, 0.01943093352019787, 0.025225626304745674, -0.03378959372639656, 0.02772059477865696, 0.014846629463136196, -0.01171814650297165, -0.02639131434261799, 0.03980635851621628, -0.038588207215070724, 0.0617462694644928, 0.06378740072250366, 0.029357178136706352, 0.023601969704031944, 0.06581997871398926, 0.06348501890897751, 0.05659126490354538, -0.009695399552583694, -0.005231490824371576, -0.0020624352619051933, -0.03326393663883209, 0.014684048481285572, -0.055356066673994064, 0.014009684324264526, 0.003813611576333642, 0.048221293836832047, -0.019593622535467148, 0.0005313362926244736, -0.002830871380865574, 0.025456486269831657, 0.05851597711443901, -0.00788651779294014, 0.02915177121758461, -0.018700091168284416, 0.006155034527182579, -0.005546934902667999, 0.058158501982688904, 0.0579986609518528, 0.019591081887483597, 0.008493471890687943, 0.11151062697172165, 0.00028455175925046206, -0.01594112440943718, -0.016747649759054184, -0.033525675535202026, 0.01762952283024788, 0.0045947846956551075, 0.0012769612949341536, -0.060103628784418106, 0.006021862383931875, 0.0001074879037332721, 0.016049271449446678, 0.01093832217156887, 0.017472263425588608, -0.04270917922258377, 0.017553238198161125, 0.04878930747509003, -0.04515218362212181, 0.015102232806384563, 0.03931141272187233, -0.031454309821128845, -0.010073297657072544, -0.015052787959575653, 0.007968421094119549, -0.028386538848280907, 0.012603521347045898, 0.0012447525514289737, -0.04425473138689995, 0.007876407355070114, -0.022571876645088196, -0.012294581159949303, 0.022657085210084915, -0.03471171855926514, -0.02211732044816017, 0.041233185678720474, 0.05764377862215042, 0.006635252386331558, -0.028880521655082703, -0.028406210243701935, -0.03280009329319, -0.02854168601334095, -0.01557539775967598, 0.04041249305009842, -0.0565679594874382, -0.016010576859116554, 0.04095536470413208, -0.022325076162815094, -0.006385681685060263, 0.0013734331587329507, -0.0023124164436012506, 0.00021462580480147153, 0.036064740270376205, 0.03460364788770676, -0.054705388844013214, 0.07370692491531372, -0.014503728598356247, -0.03599434345960617, 0.035424597561359406, 0.010724126361310482, 0.058633431792259216, -0.06807945668697357, 0.015800949186086655, -0.012144861742854118, -0.00022438586165662855, 0.019425682723522186, -0.0067419810220599174, -0.005542886909097433, 0.002092124428600073, -0.01900404691696167, 0.006776068359613419, -0.006458982825279236, -0.020504284650087357, 0.02068192884325981, -0.05257551744580269, 0.02814171090722084, 0.07459325343370438, 0.05913421884179115, -0.006622749380767345, -0.013641184195876122, 0.05038215219974518, 0.0004675819945987314, 0.05826922133564949, -0.022600604221224785, 0.03551440313458443, 0.00008362188236787915, -0.004359554965049028, -0.004097551107406616, 0.03014340065419674, -0.028134571388363838, -0.028021296486258507, -0.006020831875503063, 0.04896421357989311, -0.0034107868559658527, 0.04131978750228882, 0.034001003950834274, -0.030352599918842316, 0.054473090916872025, 0.00184915482532233, -0.007719096727669239, 0.047369781881570816, 0.008507104590535164, 0.015126503072679043, -0.07412849366664886, -0.008446360006928444, -0.001308172824792564, -0.012497556395828724, 0.028697775676846504, 0.04252378270030022, -0.012312805280089378, -0.0027890095952898264, -0.017742250114679337, -0.014639747329056263, 0.0038704501930624247, -0.010335806757211685, -0.02897034026682377, -0.007749311160296202, -0.05964483320713043, 0.013974740169942379, -0.042078424245119095, -0.003337051486596465, 0.01716596633195877, 0.008622060529887676, -0.039539288729429245, -0.016106266528367996, -0.05940026044845581, -0.03313317149877548, 0.029652493074536324, 0.00732163991779089, -0.006945787463337183, -0.0012368082534521818, 0.022751813754439354, -0.03458895534276962, -0.02222219668328762, 0.02984047122299671, 0.020615465939044952, -0.01830546371638775, -0.05319295451045036, -0.00575660914182663, 0.002968846820294857, -0.00004931953299092129, -0.06623534113168716, 0.014483615756034851, -0.023521358147263527, 0.010240050032734871, -0.016788139939308167, 0.0028874333947896957, -0.020539814606308937, 0.003072577528655529, -0.005959974601864815, 0.030316133052110672, -0.004572075325995684, 0.05658473074436188, 0.025652386248111725, 0.026954341679811478, -0.05558767169713974, -0.005933241453021765, -0.046657782047986984, -0.0030391367617994547, 0.026022613048553467, 0.018480202183127403, 0.06413346529006958, -0.01875890977680683, -0.005290196742862463, -0.007302762940526009, -0.023257382214069366, -0.029813392087817192, 0.05127348750829697, 0.015812629833817482, -0.04715950787067413, -0.020786907523870468, -0.018760230392217636, 0.00899854488670826, 0.042368967086076736, -0.04353805258870125, -0.04112151637673378, 0.03940979391336441, 0.08187314122915268, 0.00006206473335623741, 0.0053342049941420555, 0.05526812747120857, -0.035151880234479904, 0.040927205234766006, -0.0810471847653389, -0.0037779011763632298, 0.08431858569383621, 0.01462908647954464, -0.008038759231567383, 0.0009807355236262083, -0.041174862533807755, 0.04678443819284439, -0.011128829792141914, 0.046921852976083755, -0.02331092394888401, 0.017435425892472267, 0.0041183652356266975, 0.012038122862577438, -0.03280826285481453, -0.03623521327972412, 0.04797789454460144, 0.04990444704890251, 0.029047304764389992, -0.025888238102197647, 0.01926512084901333, -0.009649806655943394, -0.007125779055058956, -0.02175491861999035, -0.04440287500619888, -0.004576107487082481, -0.0045991381630301476, -0.011163849383592606, -0.0021077876444905996, 0.011648542247712612, -0.026686999946832657, 0.03503284975886345, -0.020091913640499115, 0.029668226838111877, -0.03036777302622795, -0.003908080048859119, -0.003813947783783078, 0.009095595218241215, 0.00878034345805645, -0.03355073556303978, -0.022845204919576645, 0.05638463795185089, -0.00973956286907196, 0.0341002531349659, 0.040529705584049225, -0.05408873409032822, -0.019954895600676537, 0.08959648013114929, 0.024234890937805176, -0.008163273334503174, 0.061544835567474365, 0.04420928657054901, 0.025494104251265526, -0.042790621519088745, 0.052102744579315186, -0.006794044282287359, 0.00044261274160817266, 0.06856737285852432, -0.05646386742591858, -0.024521062150597572, -0.02035008743405342, -0.06807278096675873, 0.03597726672887802, -0.025876682251691818, -0.0733984038233757, 0.008076641708612442, -0.028515111654996872, 0.03710268810391426, 0.0024198845494538546, -0.025083789601922035, -0.016643531620502472, -0.0330602303147316, -0.06725145131349564, -0.02945437841117382, -0.02474859170615673, -0.008431006222963333, 0.0345630943775177, -0.024105681106448174, -0.08539104461669922, 0.00237646815367043, -0.05472384765744209, -0.026970500126481056, 0.022043997421860695, 0.018073517829179764, -0.023676928132772446, 0.03852465748786926, -0.030794931575655937, 0.04454299435019493, 0.05779876187443733, -0.0637911856174469, 0.014718577265739441, -0.05706509202718735, 0.02189813368022442, -0.003977261018007994, -0.05792300030589104, 0.01566212996840477, -0.01397591270506382, -0.07203078269958496, 0.02802089974284172, 0.006578100845217705, 0.0124632203951478, 0.022307701408863068, 0.026019752025604248, -0.013971815817058086, -0.034248676151037216, 0.004230592865496874, -0.04627535492181778, -0.00897326972335577, -0.042350463569164276, -0.011988997459411621, -0.01390252448618412, 0.009430968202650547, -0.008150111883878708, -0.0021330497693270445, 0.0747457817196846, 0.009723808616399765, 0.020009009167551994, 0.029925785958766937, 0.055168285965919495, 0.036673933267593384, 0.014459098689258099, -0.029058095067739487, -0.056812968105077744, -0.00790025107562542, 0.0008158631389960647, -0.05970378592610359, -0.02193576656281948, -0.013368033803999424, -0.0050118472427129745, -0.01887834630906582, 0.0477706678211689, -0.019285988062620163, -0.01284981518983841, -0.0004197866946924478, -0.05886419489979744, -0.021212531253695488, -0.039161961525678635, 0.03788202255964279, -0.008606728166341782, 0.020363518968224525, -0.017202278599143028, 0.006323348265141249, -0.011571928858757019, 0.003330024890601635, 0.029000932350754738, 0.05702529475092888, -0.021320253610610962, 0.10002662241458893, -0.03299245610833168, 0.015658428892493248, 0.03247827664017677, -0.06617065519094467, 0.0007705325842835009, 0.04516904801130295, -0.03805014491081238, 0.0013807228533551097, 0.034537237137556076, 0.06525101512670517, 0.10592440515756607, -0.0019465958466753364, -0.01161705981940031, -0.04736216738820076, 0.04905853047966957, -0.05985741317272186, 0.007760514970868826, 0.022672556340694427, -0.011289752088487148, -0.06114448979496956, -0.020055551081895828, -0.0108406450599432, 0.01048296969383955, 0.012029743753373623, -0.0548778735101223, 0.08492482453584671, 0.03307603672146797, 0.06111644208431244, -0.006253405939787626, -0.029645774513483047, 0.029068006202578545, -0.031382784247398376, 0.025802982971072197, -0.07477615028619766, 0.024412550032138824, -0.00007388764061033726, 0.027923882007598877, -0.016293363645672798, 0.0733053907752037, 0.024113314226269722, 0.04698549211025238, -0.0054065329022705555, 0.05336981266736984, 0.04504755884408951, -0.008794155903160572, -0.06942395865917206, 0.03128746151924133, 0.0818682536482811, 0.004228395409882069, -0.026190422475337982, -0.022769438102841377, 0.001651704660616815, -0.051873404532670975, 0.03186209127306938, 0.010596833191812038, -0.044458672404289246, -0.003766140202060342, -0.0316866934299469, 0.020584003999829292, -0.03493225947022438, -0.043063197284936905, -0.02175537310540676, 0.004114292562007904, 0.0023669125512242317, 0.017993200570344925, -0.03332314267754555, -0.03743404522538185, -0.030837014317512512, -0.03882123529911041, -0.01719691976904869, -0.004025457426905632, 0.06166569143533707, -0.018079040572047234, -0.032900646328926086, 0.060147494077682495, -0.017246384173631668, -0.031072860583662987, -0.008612525649368763, -0.014001294039189816, -0.003567479783669114, -0.04034508392214775, -0.03067328967154026, -0.013610944151878357, 0.010387788526713848, -0.018053721636533737, 0.0435933955013752, 0.02683599852025509, -0.05222148820757866, 0.024613751098513603, 0.033217404037714005, 0.03281329944729805, -0.022557875141501427, -0.025042664259672165, -0.016924066469073296, 0.05148182064294815, -0.01750802807509899, -0.01382443681359291, -0.008767100982367992, -0.023803958669304848, -0.030247464776039124, -0.03530643880367279, -0.017159100621938705, -0.02404492348432541, -0.018282847478985786, -0.02869809791445732, -0.005266005173325539, -0.06280775368213654, -0.03226548805832863, 0.010186928324401379, -0.05199659615755081, -0.013599131256341934, 0.07958494871854782, -0.002799211535602808, -0.05072174221277237, 0.08069100230932236, 0.06713100522756577, -0.01887882873415947, 0.012234512716531754, 0.015635576099157333, 0.02153976447880268, -0.014924250543117523, -0.02838853746652603, -0.05380532145500183, -0.03972984105348587, -0.02903537079691887, 0.08322257548570633, 0.024217728525400162, -0.011857204139232635, -0.03713551536202431, -0.0301672350615263, 0.03667806088924408, 0.025279706344008446, 0.042580440640449524, -0.0014844832476228476, -0.006797219626605511, 0.014805342070758343, 0.020739315077662468, -0.06548774242401123, 0.00324354344047606, 0.045419998466968536, 0.022988831624388695, -0.010389039292931557, 0.034497711807489395, -0.030413804575800896, -0.001975388266146183, 0.05490310117602348, 0.0030948114581406116, -0.023530129343271255, 0.017417963594198227, -0.045896269381046295, 0.02818925306200981, 0.061808031052351, -0.005158520769327879, 0.022453824058175087, 0.015411525033414364, 0.028912115842103958, 0.019607823342084885, -0.021831421181559563, 0.001133914920501411, -0.025807354599237442, 0.05679762363433838, -0.02051433175802231, 0.0007371364044956863, 0.031874917447566986, 0.07334521412849426 ]
<p>Here is the data I have:</p> <ul> <li>Response variable : It contains proportions and it takes discrete values 0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1. But there are 109 possible discrete values</li> <li>Predictor variable.1: Discrete and ordinal. It contains these values 10, 20, 30, 40.</li> <li>Predictor variable.2: Discrete and non-ordinal. It contains these values 'a', 'b', 'c'.</li> </ul> <p>Neither normality (checked with Kolmogorov-Smirnov and by looking at a qqplot) nor homoscedasticity (checked with Fligner and by looking at a plot) are respected.</p> <p>Which model should I use in order to infer whether any of the two predictor variable influence my response variable?</p> <p>What about a logistic regression? Would it work?</p>
g74319
[ 0.013866300694644451, -0.04941876605153084, -0.004528461489826441, -0.038910429924726486, -0.01062480453401804, -0.03213203325867653, 0.026267774403095245, 0.037025127559900284, -0.009501133114099503, -0.073125459253788, 0.049854665994644165, 0.00036490606726147234, 0.07020699977874756, 0.006882829125970602, 0.005886632949113846, 0.03900061920285225, 0.029573533684015274, -0.016627294942736626, 0.00143478496465832, -0.02253337949514389, -0.022183656692504883, 0.016534844413399696, 0.03181847184896469, -0.021317847073078156, -0.03346466273069382, -0.04212558642029762, -0.026811327785253525, 0.09550222009420395, -0.03284701332449913, 0.012381334789097309, -0.04752720519900322, 0.029879385605454445, 0.02726597711443901, -0.042657602578401566, -0.08102457970380783, 0.003233833471313119, 0.029232891276478767, 0.02702932432293892, -0.05625751614570618, 0.04940250888466835, -0.0381862111389637, 0.0021077487617731094, 0.017703447490930557, 0.028940167278051376, -0.025481168180704117, -0.013224725611507893, 0.015865638852119446, 0.02934793010354042, -0.017413673922419548, 0.02417885698378086, 0.00897379033267498, -0.016809895634651184, 0.006269501056522131, 0.007607751060277224, 0.01634531281888485, -0.003395075909793377, 0.032461151480674744, -0.0017082475824281573, 0.02395044080913067, 0.01690729521214962, 0.051344841718673706, -0.03163035213947296, -0.03227956220507622, -0.015590120106935501, 0.000947789172641933, 0.04210527986288071, -0.06748148798942566, -0.030732790008187294, 0.008246298879384995, -0.0070264521054923534, 0.029266996309161186, -0.016409823670983315, 0.024762887507677078, -0.012897693552076817, -0.025647055357694626, -0.049291908740997314, -0.02038845792412758, 0.020392199978232384, 0.027974694967269897, -0.010657133534550667, 0.00011417060159146786, 0.02988658845424652, 0.02666115202009678, 0.059199459850788116, -0.0032384030055254698, 0.013902067206799984, -0.026830485090613365, 0.014960012398660183, 0.06764723360538483, -0.005808917805552483, 0.016625097021460533, 0.027957243844866753, 0.0199408121407032, 0.043267298489809036, -0.008544581942260265, -0.009139151312410831, -0.06103871762752533, -0.004617032594978809, 0.0012134083081036806, 0.01238937210291624, -0.011988905258476734, 0.08409377932548523, -0.022220103070139885, -0.03784565255045891, -0.04136897623538971, 0.0006217324989847839, 0.05593828484416008, 0.027058249339461327, -0.022104457020759583, -0.04022536054253578, -0.07247650623321533, 0.010417851619422436, -0.06660908460617065, -0.05619062855839729, 0.014263119548559189, -0.04963890090584755, 0.021848658099770546, -0.03450300917029381, -0.008040003478527069, -0.022466499358415604, 0.057820502668619156, 0.01679033599793911, 0.04400714114308357, 0.038096923381090164, 0.0013427517842501402, -0.014921575784683228, -0.08235261589288712, 0.09908255934715271, 0.031058551743626595, 0.02401745319366455, 0.047156281769275665, 0.03913078457117081, 0.030064010992646217, 0.031738024204969406, 0.010109564289450645, 0.02719363570213318, 0.014237018302083015, 0.050373438745737076, 0.04426761344075203, 0.01660025306046009, 0.016978509724140167, 0.0348782055079937, -0.009899003431200981, 0.011864998377859592, -0.015674374997615814, 0.015920793637633324, 0.01740109920501709, 0.01434642355889082, -0.0680808499455452, -0.0022469100076705217, -0.019766904413700104, 0.030228188261389732, -0.001305092591792345, 0.019777636975049973, -0.03342418000102043, -0.002805655589327216, -0.0342438668012619, 0.017917906865477562, -0.013576497323811054, -0.03603620082139969, 0.05250919237732887, -0.05446900427341461, 0.02294110879302025, 0.007155057042837143, 0.05770060420036316, -0.00828357134014368, 0.030470196157693863, -0.0201493538916111, -0.024597683921456337, 0.0031110206618905067, -0.00189646752551198, -0.0009767980081960559, 0.013659313321113586, 0.026344167068600655, 0.10314971208572388, 0.06301028281450272, 0.041528064757585526, 0.035943884402513504, 0.06361161172389984, -0.03357924893498421, 0.0042912838980555534, 0.012198096141219139, -0.02366608753800392, -0.03193749487400055, -0.033215563744306564, -0.04668457433581352, 0.07003290951251984, 0.09904010593891144, -0.05438443273305893, -0.016981204971671104, -0.027123846113681793, 0.011011024937033653, -0.008505089208483696, -0.04357209801673889, -0.022999580949544907, -0.04294094443321228, 0.020768264308571815, -0.04000244289636612, -0.008212612010538578, 0.018403925001621246, 0.0030372519977390766, -0.00205330946482718, 0.023740403354167938, 0.03545558452606201, -0.02939854934811592, -0.003583642654120922, -0.008646180853247643, 0.008361314423382282, -0.0033438156824558973, -0.031222866848111153, 0.012964916415512562, -0.03205814212560654, -0.02456081286072731, 0.0388464629650116, 0.029839584603905678, -0.0508982315659523, -0.03959418833255768, 0.06316794455051422, -0.030341964215040207, 0.008423024788498878, -0.059023186564445496, -0.011713835410773754, -0.009319226257503033, 0.018297577276825905, -0.022395530715584755, -0.0020777611061930656, 0.06490123271942139, -0.042761895805597305, -0.016028380021452904, 0.007224289700388908, -0.0024616827722638845, -0.08866219967603683, 0.07832210510969162, -0.034069210290908813, 0.04987984895706177, 0.004872431047260761, -0.03525471314787865, -0.028661275282502174, 0.04026187211275101, -0.0006708988803438842, 0.025857435539364815, 0.03231504186987877, 0.03964480385184288, 0.028435267508029938, -0.0015245381509885192, -0.07153468579053879, 0.009576926939189434, -0.01043693721294403, 0.008879787288606167, 0.09055651724338531, -0.06022125110030174, 0.11683438718318939, 0.011679100804030895, -0.04550045728683472, -0.01543840579688549, 0.008793767541646957, -0.0032004094682633877, 0.008380605839192867, -0.006615309976041317, -0.010514265857636929, -0.03873655945062637, -0.035394493490457535, 0.007892676629126072, 0.03475021570920944, -0.03449125960469246, -0.044200021773576736, -0.011275303550064564, -0.01297916192561388, -0.004534009378403425, 0.02505137026309967, -0.0221334807574749, -0.04838079214096069, -0.019504880532622337, 0.0322786383330822, 0.07186563313007355, 0.02460671402513981, -0.03503258153796196, -0.04515112191438675, 0.011251683346927166, -0.013996146619319916, 0.10762245208024979, -0.03965010866522789, -0.03631382808089256, 0.02349078468978405, 0.03635858744382858, 0.07126206159591675, 0.0008285826188512146, -0.00284827733412385, 0.0428147055208683, 0.05747299641370773, -0.051122210919857025, 0.0181546900421381, -0.006398458499461412, 0.012257966212928295, -0.021218597888946533, -0.0028635701164603233, 0.012818201445043087, -0.01644076406955719, 0.03447791188955307, 0.05803649500012398, -0.0054038334637880325, 0.011964189819991589, 0.02940971404314041, 0.024088121950626373, 0.04227155074477196, -0.058238331228494644, -0.038626283407211304, 0.02690197341144085, 0.05864231660962105, -0.02882218547165394, -0.001645400421693921, 0.01162746176123619, 0.018946291878819466, -0.016175242140889168, 0.0034858977887779474, -0.04044651240110397, -0.031563397496938705, 0.03567441925406456, 0.04394221305847168, -0.004969674162566662, 0.01624322682619095, -0.04151869937777519, -0.0264100544154644, 0.05207357555627823, -0.024698829278349876, -0.01504475623369217, 0.012877214699983597, 0.03460478037595749, -0.03060733526945114, 0.02337653562426567, -0.01196412555873394, 0.057171132415533066, -0.027935093268752098, -0.009283952414989471, -0.016228480264544487, -0.032685212790966034, -0.012781774625182152, -0.04507194831967354, -0.016993382945656776, 0.06172577291727066, -0.03775797039270401, -0.008028783835470676, 0.022940335795283318, 0.004483625292778015, -0.04010118171572685, -0.004934569355100393, -0.013503504917025566, -0.01248041819781065, -0.025117456912994385, 0.005990303121507168, -0.0028674062341451645, 0.005095223430544138, -0.044313907623291016, 0.00648250337690115, 0.03134782984852791, 0.011117691174149513, 0.046312157064676285, 0.051594119518995285, -0.00812444370239973, -0.016454577445983887, 0.02115814760327339, -0.05127837136387825, 0.013202222995460033, 0.0009597048629075289, 0.051145702600479126, 0.04382074996829033, 0.03436505049467087, 0.06311293691396713, -0.02053862251341343, 0.017053792253136635, 0.025103121995925903, 0.008699878118932247, 0.04136417806148529, 0.0287548266351223, 0.058709438890218735, 0.02856619469821453, 0.037931762635707855, -0.014239409007132053, -0.022890238091349602, 0.03700941428542137, 0.006230400409549475, 0.013152125291526318, -0.004286387003958225, -0.0020831895526498556, 0.000846418144647032, -0.05767934024333954, 0.012065780349075794, -0.01668260619044304, 0.026994692161679268, -0.03614795207977295, 0.017700891941785812, -0.02263299562036991, -0.09189508855342865, 0.02789042331278324, 0.024676574394106865, -0.004190200474113226, 0.05744776502251625, 0.023020299151539803, 0.011369100771844387, -0.00030301621882244945, -0.032196737825870514, -0.024679820984601974, 0.0042344131506979465, 0.0034144327510148287, 0.014185738749802113, 0.003017307026311755, -0.02818966656923294, -0.02826395444571972, -0.02347559481859207, -0.022735513746738434, -0.00414759898558259, 0.005479042883962393, -0.007794651668518782, -0.00008045200229389593, 0.03207468241453171, -0.005703015718609095, 0.07701797783374786, 0.008845127187669277, -0.026655469089746475, 0.030721547082066536, 0.005599108058959246, 0.03973713889718056, -0.055816151201725006, -0.025426454842090607, -0.0019556814804673195, -0.0218905471265316, 0.014801550656557083, -0.02085963450372219, -0.032307568937540054, 0.02241750992834568, 0.06438332051038742, 0.05117698013782501, -0.004545813892036676, 0.06206117570400238, -0.015918875113129616, 0.010799512267112732, 0.023655537515878677, 0.004130127374082804, -0.009609787724912167, -0.06778492033481598, -0.0442030131816864, -0.06350217759609222, -0.03846004605293274, 0.004645488690584898, -0.046988099813461304, 0.06487900763750076, -0.032478686422109604, -0.0270428117364645, -0.04173569008708, -0.007329048588871956, 0.030900951474905014, 0.04863366112112999, 0.012421680614352226, -0.04033655673265457, 0.05304818972945213, -0.008119015023112297, 0.040035419166088104, -0.004200178198516369, 0.02047116868197918, 0.05481488257646561, 0.017138324677944183, -0.0528094507753849, -0.02799888141453266, -0.005083813332021236, -0.009155234321951866, -0.015363723039627075, -0.07740552723407745, -0.017278486862778664, 0.061488159000873566, -0.011902782134711742, -0.028062989935278893, -0.0005366954719647765, 0.05108872428536415, -0.020264020189642906, -0.017827108502388, 0.01016007550060749, -0.04616903141140938, -0.028707774356007576, -0.043430477380752563, 0.016818642616271973, -0.03567659854888916, -0.03743520379066467, -0.006205952260643244, -0.013817819766700268, -0.033012595027685165, -0.03355023264884949, 0.01741003803908825, -0.02032243087887764, 0.012390944175422192, 0.026825841516256332, -0.02140776999294758, -0.0018161255866289139, 0.06395310163497925, 0.030433570966124535, -0.07420296967029572, -0.041382018476724625, -0.013074258342385292, -0.03184330835938454, 0.024320615455508232, 0.034573134034872055, -0.021589748561382294, 0.05781722068786621, 0.043095991015434265, -0.016401149332523346, -0.05892857536673546, 0.015202872455120087, 0.05484873801469803, -0.007899455726146698, -0.005762163549661636, 0.0023372741416096687, -0.028010427951812744, 0.026512011885643005, 0.09221195429563522, -0.022903548553586006, -0.03129155933856964, -0.013995388522744179, -0.008181959390640259, 0.04340115562081337, 0.036427002400159836, -0.014090562239289284, 0.0321156270802021, -0.027523361146450043, -0.025920653715729713, 0.03317338228225708, 0.008145665749907494, -0.06726156920194626, 0.002835055347532034, -0.038265641778707504, -0.0006524603231810033, 0.006374150048941374, 0.06407200545072556, 0.03339535370469093, -0.03497641533613205, -0.004732734989374876, 0.013253028504550457, -0.04189865291118622, -0.008007879368960857, 0.022817961871623993, -0.015031065791845322, -0.043020766228437424, -0.03301152214407921, 0.021174365654587746, 0.03730019927024841, -0.007565552368760109, -0.03417250141501427, -0.014561799354851246, -0.029917195439338684, -0.03774489462375641, 0.022744454443454742, 0.04087786749005318, -0.03664499893784523, 0.023505428805947304, -0.01749889925122261, 0.014931068755686283, 0.0005007322179153562, -0.018520537763834, 0.045685216784477234, 0.018629971891641617, 0.009756622835993767, 0.00728914188221097, -0.01747206039726734, 0.008256842382252216, -0.001901137293316424, 0.0010648213792592287, 0.010542205534875393, -0.06506496667861938, -0.011520549654960632, 0.0002956021926365793, 0.015170439146459103, -0.002976000076159835, 0.027831677347421646, -0.04087696969509125, 0.027209019288420677, 0.07864011079072952, -0.039076339453458786, -0.016537373885512352, -0.05917859822511673, -0.02464049868285656, 0.0053628431633114815, -0.015407620929181576, 0.07470038533210754, -0.01651156321167946, -0.04905286803841591, -0.0009945459896698594, 0.015207807533442974, 0.10036690533161163, -0.001908596488647163, 0.008313711732625961, -0.0474429726600647, -0.01808391511440277, 0.0010887717362493277, 0.0009876876138150692, 0.02825726382434368, -0.06795628368854523, 0.0034767850302159786, -0.033010367304086685, 0.00878251250833273, 0.059224821627140045, 0.025076571851968765, -0.031073415651917458, -0.00814339891076088, -0.05714209005236626, 0.029407061636447906, 0.01700136996805668, -0.015349393710494041, -0.06325644254684448, -0.04226633533835411, -0.004420128185302019, 0.03248278424143791, -0.08517688512802124, -0.022317936643958092, 0.01773703098297119, 0.029656173661351204, 0.04102234169840813, 0.010091460309922695, 0.0037939243484288454, -0.05715763568878174, 0.044736940413713455, -0.012091554701328278, 0.011445995420217514, 0.040968433022499084, -0.02994343265891075, -0.03272804617881775, -0.009366859681904316, 0.007322473451495171, 0.04640638083219528, -0.075065977871418, -0.050040353089571, 0.06003550812602043, 0.028681116178631783, -0.02064003236591816, 0.010431274771690369, -0.0073572988621890545, -0.009391910396516323, -0.04621719568967819, 0.023457806557416916, -0.04054894298315048, 0.042805757373571396, 0.03074967861175537, 0.02260740101337433, 0.02598700299859047, 0.0044814893044531345, -0.023735739290714264, 0.01953224465250969, -0.019597630947828293, 0.0310892965644598, 0.05098729953169823, 0.04003503918647766, -0.05480355769395828, 0.03534935787320137, 0.048159800469875336, 0.024005025625228882, 0.061108849942684174, 0.017698360607028008, 0.03533697873353958, 0.01776847615838051, 0.060689885169267654, 0.031870000064373016, 0.03627069294452667, -0.0022483470384031534, -0.017241060733795166, -0.07619486004114151, -0.04826447740197182, -0.0262925885617733, 0.03369459882378578, 0.05367202311754227, -0.07307883352041245, -0.04894057288765907, -0.01995658501982689, -0.04950999841094017, 0.0049470942467451096, -0.1264258176088333, -0.0024729904253035784, 0.03593020513653755, 0.0053105601109564304, -0.03634681552648544, -0.007935648784041405, -0.010650919750332832, -0.045845355838537216, -0.02211405523121357, -0.027067171409726143, -0.005627891980111599, 0.007388133089989424, -0.017056019976735115, -0.011177260428667068, 0.03437774255871773, 0.05157114192843437, -0.07704579830169678, 0.0352206826210022, -0.012616444379091263, -0.11494603008031845, -0.0363876037299633, 0.025499362498521805, -0.022051481530070305, -0.042757995426654816, 0.013171281665563583, -0.07998454570770264, 0.030482634902000427, -0.012099227868020535, 0.06948161870241165, 0.012521320022642612, 0.0711154118180275, -0.045157138258218765, -0.04636700823903084, 0.020446259528398514, -0.06393351405858994, 0.020399102941155434, -0.05693556368350983, -0.040931154042482376, -0.03955214470624924, -0.004513269755989313, 0.014128496870398521, 0.011880910024046898, 0.065126433968544, 0.013271685689687729, -0.04408164322376251, -0.05723318085074425, -0.02646409161388874, 0.03493841364979744, -0.004719711374491453, -0.05835280567407608, -0.0436534509062767, 0.0132273118942976, -0.010971489362418652, 0.010794369503855705, -0.06072310358285904, -0.038050103932619095, 0.05221100524067879, -0.004286974668502808, 0.04422231763601303, -0.01414470374584198, -0.052196402102708817, -0.055983904749155045, -0.06386279314756393, 0.018773118034005165, 0.025915050879120827, -0.03705069050192833, 0.05842209234833717, 0.02719598449766636, 0.03913234919309616, -0.05830836296081543, 0.028923483565449715, 0.03242582455277443, 0.05302850902080536, 0.012670190073549747, -0.019038915634155273, -0.027809899300336838, 0.04008779302239418, -0.008509569801390171, 0.013286762870848179, -0.08904390782117844, 0.0162710789591074, -0.05176597088575363, 0.004483838565647602, -0.0031256377696990967, -0.012021799571812153, -0.01979636959731579, -0.023178882896900177, -0.015463345684111118, -0.019832277670502663, 0.010032556019723415, 0.015858342871069908, 0.006095157470554113, 0.05914737656712532, -0.022454360499978065, 0.032988447695970535, -0.05688753351569176, 0.05840548872947693 ]
<p>I am working on a machine learning experiment comparing the use of multiple different neural network classifiers by applying them on a large number of datasets, using stratified 10-fold cross-validation. I measure the performance as the average of the errors on the validation set (sometimes referred to as test set) of the 10-fold cross-validation procedure.</p> <p>My question is, would it be ok to use this same validation set to do an early stopping of the training procedure? This early stopping would be performed by applying the trained model after each epoch to the validation set and measuring the performance, and if it declines for a number of successive learning epochs, the learning would be halted and we would take the epoch that produced the last good performance. This would be applied to all the different techniques, and across all the different datasets.</p> <p>Is this ok? Or is it statistically inaccurate?</p>
g6992
[ 0.00011503022687975317, -0.03967546671628952, 0.026205895468592644, -0.05437786504626274, 0.007820709608495235, 0.027444520965218544, 0.040699128061532974, 0.04756557568907738, -0.08736255764961243, 0.026321353390812874, 0.03930393233895302, 0.01040565874427557, -0.014374985359609127, 0.027013013139367104, -0.017380446195602417, -0.02555108442902565, 0.04570230469107628, -0.036433931440114975, -0.021118290722370148, 0.04762721806764603, -0.04040716588497162, 0.03170699626207352, -0.020309999585151672, -0.01928207091987133, -0.0240610484033823, -0.0073924739845097065, -0.04030716419219971, -0.01025135163217783, -0.01816883124411106, 0.03538911044597626, 0.030999725684523582, -0.057431381195783615, 0.04223255813121796, -0.058850742876529694, -0.07360722124576569, 0.021722279489040375, 0.004302326589822769, -0.0026203820016235113, 0.006784226279705763, 0.0024970946833491325, 0.033603422343730927, 0.0214034765958786, 0.07990939170122147, -0.011200759559869766, 0.008432053029537201, 0.02774706855416298, 0.017350340262055397, -0.031021347269415855, 0.054392632097005844, -0.008677864447236061, 0.001625650329515338, 0.0007632510969415307, -0.009595627896487713, 0.07178176939487457, -0.009490471333265305, 0.03444422781467438, -0.00913988333195448, 0.059602491557598114, -0.027760757133364677, -0.009580960497260094, 0.029740042984485626, -0.005698610562831163, -0.0215643011033535, -0.04178685322403908, -0.024887192994356155, 0.010671009309589863, -0.024213682860136032, -0.011112792417407036, 0.0009589925175532699, -0.007303767837584019, -0.027885904535651207, -0.01802288554608822, 0.020440660417079926, 0.04506149888038635, 0.04045270010828972, 0.03201763704419136, -0.01308632455766201, 0.031975600868463516, -0.02807769738137722, 0.05665545165538788, 0.02107170969247818, -0.0103234788402915, -0.004949154332280159, 0.0016146627021953464, -0.01693381369113922, 0.01040662545710802, -0.04356364160776138, 0.028967788442969322, -0.07848695665597916, 0.06220218539237976, -0.0049931625835597515, -0.01674620248377323, 0.01515502855181694, 0.02334953285753727, 0.012301919981837273, -0.006478835362941027, -0.05796299874782562, 0.04310676082968712, 0.025666410103440285, 0.08366745710372925, -0.0021133089903742075, 0.01845022663474083, 0.036578498780727386, -0.005331811960786581, -0.026208480820059776, -0.029657850041985512, 0.00916273146867752, -0.00023328297538682818, -0.032563962042331696, -0.009337727911770344, -0.0599452406167984, 0.0013081083307042718, -0.0667586624622345, 0.01824534498155117, -0.08085331320762634, -0.02119387313723564, 0.024594435468316078, 0.04300050064921379, -0.05282159894704819, -0.05169733241200447, 0.04217155650258064, -0.036372411996126175, 0.034890804439783096, -0.006807067431509495, -0.0412001870572567, -0.034008562564849854, -0.051626093685626984, 0.015799539163708687, -0.0055922940373420715, -0.006580826826393604, 0.03627879172563553, 0.023336362093687057, 0.02609087899327278, -0.015365867875516415, 0.0032020381186157465, 0.02759883925318718, 0.023604609072208405, -0.08336221426725388, 0.02115626260638237, -0.012750686146318913, -0.0626126229763031, 0.040814485400915146, -0.004197242669761181, -0.00981986615806818, 0.010691105388104916, 0.01280613150447607, -0.02184845320880413, -0.038101326674222946, 0.013188358396291733, 0.09258875250816345, 0.023377886041998863, 0.029179824516177177, 0.005180292762815952, 0.02271866984665394, 0.028379609808325768, -0.015051951631903648, -0.048882272094488144, 0.01607745885848999, 0.03882495313882828, 0.016095364466309547, 0.012405275367200375, 0.0011708089150488377, 0.042406514286994934, -0.020222587510943413, -0.014613747596740723, 0.04780115187168121, -0.05886702239513397, -0.019886665046215057, 0.0016069402918219566, -0.011162017472088337, 0.007334262598305941, 0.03973367437720299, 0.014280092902481556, -0.03867446258664131, 0.019886178895831108, 0.04116096347570419, 0.0638485699892044, -0.023163024336099625, 0.01332936156541109, -0.010295839048922062, 0.023899735882878304, 0.029621068388223648, 0.008842464536428452, 0.024985866621136665, 0.006664012558758259, 0.039498910307884216, 0.00214039022102952, -0.009458226151764393, -0.060268644243478775, -0.03898629546165466, 0.053285084664821625, -0.03949999064207077, -0.0008751673740334809, -0.016596229746937752, -0.01703862100839615, -0.03436456248164177, -0.005380586255341768, 0.005533960647881031, -0.030836917459964752, 0.005547335837036371, -0.023719117045402527, 0.03657802939414978, -0.0212479867041111, 0.04718589782714844, -0.0471017099916935, 0.003656869987025857, -0.0056598857045173645, 0.006672940216958523, -0.03487109765410423, 0.02648397721350193, -0.004389532841742039, 0.010463288985192776, 0.006365515291690826, 0.036212608218193054, -0.05057834833860397, 0.03903863951563835, 0.02935168519616127, 0.04277212545275688, 0.043627552688121796, 0.1036149337887764, -0.04760102555155754, -0.014005632139742374, 0.014580224640667439, -0.04890673980116844, 0.0060431440360844135, 0.008449962362647057, -0.009532750584185123, -0.02102075330913067, 0.027003737166523933, 0.01888052187860012, -0.04655931517481804, -0.02458629012107849, -0.0539444200694561, -0.07770182192325592, 0.009295602329075336, -0.017891177907586098, -0.004439496900886297, 0.006809179205447435, -0.04943683370947838, -0.02125421166419983, 0.013200587593019009, 0.02068236656486988, -0.02664426527917385, -0.031626924872398376, -0.014583829790353775, -0.07238631695508957, -0.0666847750544548, 0.027411941438913345, 0.024826304987072945, -0.05763735622167587, -0.034862857311964035, 0.013682416640222073, 0.0006150290137156844, 0.019119014963507652, 0.009598764590919018, -0.04037248715758324, 0.028479719534516335, 0.03584188222885132, 0.015622327104210854, 0.07969705015420914, 0.05213753879070282, 0.04348248615860939, 0.0029386652167886496, -0.005032905377447605, 0.04443046450614929, -0.017274312674999237, 0.07285655289888382, -0.006766526028513908, -0.016925573348999023, -0.005829775705933571, -0.01729147508740425, -0.016833558678627014, 0.09096833318471909, 0.05943808704614639, 0.038273703306913376, 0.06582242250442505, -0.053767912089824677, -0.0008624782785773277, 0.009087426587939262, -0.008053318597376347, -0.08353796601295471, -0.10463475435972214, -0.017021195963025093, -0.03698054328560829, 0.03279383108019829, -0.013950166292488575, 0.0694611519575119, -0.01991010643541813, -0.012493307702243328, 0.007455967832356691, 0.0025705669540911913, 0.04593932628631592, 0.04788263514637947, -0.03256811574101448, -0.045247312635183334, -0.05469644069671631, -0.053783707320690155, -0.026128413155674934, 0.05494374781847, -0.009127321653068066, -0.02213861793279648, -0.03512316942214966, 0.0012117800069972873, 0.0029710805974900723, 0.04825500026345253, -0.03213416039943695, -0.07178426533937454, 0.051453880965709686, -0.04924337938427925, -0.02916800230741501, -0.01617361232638359, 0.0379696749150753, -0.027683326974511147, -0.03270889073610306, 0.004373734816908836, -0.08642112463712692, 0.025971360504627228, -0.005004074424505234, 0.04433107003569603, -0.011251185089349747, 0.0038080597296357155, -0.014811649918556213, -0.006285284645855427, 0.028518691658973694, -0.025362588465213776, 0.04671458527445793, 0.01852462999522686, -0.0011873963521793485, -0.048117488622665405, 0.03418176993727684, 0.026618996635079384, -0.004379752557724714, 0.03081703372299671, 0.027399925515055656, 0.006857844535261393, 0.006211985368281603, -0.015258898958563805, -0.005387260112911463, -0.012286325916647911, 0.05427142232656479, -0.03839787095785141, 0.016650313511490822, 0.013646378181874752, -0.002627532696351409, 0.032170336693525314, 0.005067361053079367, 0.02622736617922783, -0.05878289043903351, -0.07019408792257309, -0.03790624812245369, 0.0035040804650634527, -0.007505386136472225, -0.007192968390882015, -0.03563158959150314, -0.010126616805791855, -0.0025281866546720266, 0.029469244182109833, -0.0165714118629694, 0.032070085406303406, -0.00720941461622715, 0.041505541652441025, 0.005622494034469128, -0.008934392593801022, 0.012783603742718697, -0.017599860206246376, 0.054403677582740784, -0.014144237153232098, 0.07011140137910843, 0.0651819035410881, -0.01324494183063507, 0.03751632198691368, 0.03625234588980675, -0.015813026577234268, -0.03659462183713913, -0.02632364071905613, -0.005134458187967539, 0.03379777818918228, 0.020178230479359627, 0.04675648361444473, 0.035670891404151917, -0.011087136343121529, 0.031302765011787415, -0.04040979593992233, 0.030433453619480133, -0.02191145159304142, 0.014589274302124977, -0.0043640839867293835, -0.010051262564957142, 0.037377480417490005, -0.03227480128407478, 0.006965764798223972, 0.016124336048960686, -0.05998292565345764, 0.02726065367460251, 0.039439693093299866, 0.0068727293983101845, 0.04498158022761345, -0.005306719336658716, 0.059405457228422165, 0.041762374341487885, -0.05542357265949249, -0.009728150442242622, -0.027982359752058983, -0.024083076044917107, -0.012268781661987305, 0.006904613226652145, -0.04932639002799988, 0.06804534047842026, 0.0003849618078675121, 0.02380247786641121, -0.03878365084528923, -0.076756052672863, -0.04444237798452377, -0.0022340177092701197, 0.0024184337817132473, -0.03999354690313339, 0.03540434688329697, 0.009336275048553944, -0.038184646517038345, -0.010007382370531559, 0.017440147697925568, 0.038583360612392426, -0.03987354040145874, -0.060968589037656784, 0.018475113436579704, 0.01386680081486702, 0.017517395317554474, -0.025967642664909363, -0.056021202355623245, -0.021744361147284508, 0.03436771780252457, 0.001023482414893806, -0.052362434566020966, 0.036707039922475815, 0.027813540771603584, 0.058463599532842636, 0.001848319312557578, -0.0561496838927269, -0.007629236672073603, -0.015288115479052067, -0.005498957820236683, -0.011183394119143486, -0.02668783813714981, -0.004052996635437012, -0.01026744395494461, 0.0073655941523611546, -0.007680151145905256, -0.03253258019685745, 0.006321476772427559, 0.003323696320876479, -0.022808514535427094, -0.006023289170116186, -0.0061214640736579895, 0.06442523747682571, -0.013589989393949509, 0.020600492134690285, 0.07999050617218018, 0.06510864943265915, -0.006009227130562067, 0.032730210572481155, 0.06508491188287735, -0.02549525909125805, -0.03315971791744232, 0.02473284862935543, -0.03242221847176552, -0.04179621860384941, -0.04483630135655403, -0.00810601282864809, 0.0004958180361427367, 0.02202264592051506, 0.03604823350906372, -0.019853439182043076, 0.012365936301648617, 0.028742749243974686, -0.0148534644395113, 0.013960318639874458, 0.0022614081390202045, -0.004099790472537279, 0.0249653160572052, -0.023174850270152092, -0.00006228904385352507, -0.04831663891673088, -0.0014782965881749988, -0.041456785053014755, 0.0015022439183667302, -0.06298341602087021, 0.031935907900333405, -0.057183440774679184, 0.0641617625951767, 0.013905521482229233, 0.0014305714285001159, 0.012010423466563225, 0.07819189876317978, 0.04977051168680191, 0.005539437755942345, 0.00031392043456435204, 0.0011429800651967525, -0.002588564297184348, -0.026178916916251183, -0.04788423329591751, -0.02038702368736267, 0.02767045795917511, -0.023370439186692238, -0.07296193391084671, -0.05695473030209541, -0.01931043528020382, 0.009861641563475132, -0.03322814404964447, -0.014203364960849285, 0.025592654943466187, 0.02714872546494007, 0.01828775182366371, 0.0095014413818717, 0.04178880900144577, -0.003979512955993414, -0.046428803354501724, -0.02297791838645935, -0.005932192783802748, 0.011131071485579014, -0.07066638022661209, 0.03493092954158783, 0.002424645470455289, -0.0009359901887364686, 0.03908594325184822, 0.05423992499709129, -0.07341612130403519, 0.04057035967707634, -0.004603685345500708, -0.007377192378044128, -0.0028453762643039227, 0.10081349313259125, 0.03679323568940163, -0.029252979904413223, 0.04344303905963898, -0.028019333258271217, -0.005424112547188997, -0.03740358725190163, -0.052254967391490936, -0.0037305322475731373, -0.050313565880060196, -0.03518306463956833, 0.006443306803703308, 0.05263733118772507, -0.08616073429584503, -0.10809768736362457, -0.022483615204691887, -0.011877436190843582, 0.022659430280327797, 0.007664407603442669, -0.05337482690811157, 0.004737062379717827, 0.025818414986133575, -0.043512195348739624, -0.003498177509754896, -0.046852000057697296, 0.04353053867816925, -0.024687565863132477, -0.01917416788637638, 0.024819660931825638, -0.009541181847453117, -0.017981845885515213, -0.034472592175006866, 0.06017819792032242, -0.015398925170302391, 0.046688999980688095, 0.04773562029004097, -0.05454413592815399, -0.0006837876862846315, -0.02957901544868946, -0.01819419115781784, 0.1167634129524231, -0.03165106102824211, 0.021638385951519012, 0.08680285513401031, -0.006782009266316891, 0.007677586283534765, 0.015862228348851204, 0.056410204619169235, 0.02374883182346821, -0.01962367445230484, 0.008460160344839096, -0.028459971770644188, -0.0032096141949295998, -0.0355088971555233, 0.015743738040328026, -0.016125736758112907, -0.03365792706608772, 0.021459292620420456, -0.00006192445289343596, 0.023859374225139618, -0.0029364898800849915, -0.08435750007629395, 0.03321194276213646, -0.02457464300096035, 0.027222560718655586, -0.012378077954053879, 0.0013954007299616933, -0.00028420050512067974, -0.024038955569267273, 0.0011909243185073137, -0.0020221658051013947, -0.012237854301929474, 0.03634708374738693, -0.0810321792960167, 0.017308013513684273, 0.09364033490419388, 0.03556990996003151, -0.03261401876807213, 0.11001043021678925, -0.0014015058986842632, 0.019979849457740784, 0.002554219216108322, 0.03541301563382149, 0.05727332830429077, -0.03337598219513893, -0.031267259269952774, -0.016336703673005104, -0.05889628082513809, -0.02319663017988205, 0.05370420217514038, 0.0009559530881233513, 0.023401618003845215, 0.06093496084213257, 0.04112682119011879, -0.031649522483348846, 0.05561242625117302, 0.012629428878426552, -0.011295926757156849, 0.05394701659679413, 0.018661944195628166, -0.05448098108172417, 0.01442085113376379, 0.004426765721291304, -0.0022374505642801523, -0.10767523944377899, 0.0039789387956261635, 0.014681794680655003, 0.04213757812976837, -0.004677019082009792, 0.016981102526187897, 0.0453520230948925, 0.00590949272736907, -0.01397019624710083, -0.0016486168606206775, 0.05031297355890274, 0.022263163700699806, 0.04296426847577095, 0.06563874334096909, -0.0686902105808258, -0.022366903722286224, 0.0354490764439106, 0.04985009506344795, -0.02064884454011917, -0.04013001173734665, -0.05676984041929245, 0.03803223744034767, 0.0264153853058815, 0.06144407391548157, 0.015187839977443218, -0.003185800276696682, -0.00021364499116316438, -0.059428147971630096, -0.07053957134485245, -0.01902163028717041, 0.014081052504479885, 0.0004091046575922519, -0.05638318881392479, -0.11509042978286743, 0.014808207750320435, -0.03787178546190262, 0.03374646604061127, -0.015106676146388054, -0.01155020296573639, -0.005427051335573196, 0.029103467240929604, -0.024030975997447968, -0.033531926572322845, 0.012700490653514862, -0.011483343318104744, 0.052514705806970596, -0.02077578194439411, -0.028543692082166672, 0.002328981412574649, -0.02832670696079731, -0.03757896646857262, 0.05093972757458687, 0.01259095873683691, 0.045402947813272476, 0.08836635202169418, -0.032564036548137665, -0.013220952823758125, -0.03006492368876934, 0.023285971954464912, -0.009500137530267239, 0.014044415205717087, -0.005972220096737146, -0.006005870644003153, -0.0539277046918869, 0.026352006942033768, 0.06295321881771088, 0.025301454588770866, 0.041490133851766586, 0.003979196306318045, 0.017596889287233353, -0.030668064951896667, 0.0391937755048275, -0.045403532683849335, 0.020230963826179504, -0.013274087570607662, -0.07728856056928635, -0.027804110199213028, 0.06495378166437149, -0.011049174703657627, 0.07049529254436493, -0.045409053564071655, -0.0274888277053833, -0.0006439724820666015, -0.034218478947877884, 0.03824850544333458, 0.012494498863816261, -0.012172229588031769, -0.00531197153031826, 0.01654350385069847, 0.049834489822387695, 0.02710745856165886, -0.013543957844376564, -0.06147649511694908, -0.036334581673145294, -0.020565802231431007, -0.004388316068798304, -0.021355874836444855, -0.06856738775968552, -0.03156757354736328, 0.0013092473382130265, -0.015877576544880867, 0.02973213978111744, 0.001586154685355723, -0.02432045340538025, -0.010061606764793396, -0.0032396866008639336, -0.0381493866443634, 0.029972806572914124, 0.00852267351001501, 0.014076313935220242, 0.002322254702448845, 0.022660207003355026, 0.0070743863470852375, 0.03433937951922417, 0.04811666160821915, -0.049969837069511414, -0.04352053627371788, -0.031640682369470596, 0.0289468877017498, 0.03841792047023773, -0.06585140526294708, 0.047944482415914536, -0.010489251464605331, -0.004278755281120539, 0.043873947113752365, 0.009560681879520416, -0.006781867705285549, 0.024381296709179878, 0.0019667765591293573, -0.03019828349351883, -0.02719280682504177, -0.025095680728554726, 0.002973149996250868, 0.019732549786567688 ]
<p>I have developed two new sorting techniques using C language. I need to compare the performance of the both sorting techniques, to see which one is better than another. To do this, I used different input data, from n = 500 to n = 2500. For each data that need to be sorted, I run them 10 times and get the mean, standard deviation as well as coefficient of variation. An example of results are shown below:</p> <pre><code>n min max mean SD CV 500 24.07 24.52 21.28 0.11 0.47 1000 52.41 52.83 52.67 0.13 0.25 </code></pre> <p>Just to ask, can I only run each experiment 10 times or should I run more? If I run them 50 times, the results are very close and I obtain almost the same CV. The above results obtained when I run the first sorting technique. </p> <p>Can I say that 10 times is OK to get the results?</p> <p>I don't know how many samples should I use to test a particular data. Can anyone suggest any good reading books for this particular analysis?</p>
g37157
[ 0.004970758222043514, -0.0021736545022577047, 0.001200278289616108, -0.062006063759326935, 0.0024903290905058384, -0.06414134800434113, 0.037303805351257324, -0.05297505855560303, -0.057220082730054855, -0.017786569893360138, -0.0011183703318238258, 0.007827773690223694, -0.017850780859589577, 0.014366211369633675, -0.02543785609304905, -0.050082653760910034, 0.040894657373428345, -0.016639726236462593, -0.012501800432801247, 0.04174234718084335, 0.020211197435855865, 0.0592595599591732, 0.028886357322335243, -0.008030220866203308, -0.04830734804272652, 0.036989934742450714, -0.0660243108868599, 0.03188745677471161, -0.10498488694429398, 0.02368115447461605, 0.01872234418988228, 0.015122473239898682, 0.015949631109833717, -0.04020274430513382, -0.08039670437574387, -0.0018817110685631633, 0.0382482148706913, -0.01470909547060728, -0.024276534095406532, -0.0265803262591362, 0.002798924222588539, 0.04592262580990791, 0.0722808912396431, -0.023156538605690002, 0.02447131834924221, -0.024988435208797455, -0.028972797095775604, 0.002062371466308832, -0.023668773472309113, -0.045486416667699814, -0.006448647473007441, -0.016858207061886787, 0.005275037605315447, 0.010632360354065895, 0.0007124349940568209, 0.010085911490023136, -0.013336969539523125, -0.009450358338654041, 0.03234078362584114, -0.026509711518883705, 0.05565882474184036, -0.006239830516278744, -0.021105866879224777, -0.01564766652882099, -0.03441070020198822, 0.0085366852581501, 0.022759580984711647, 0.01066430751234293, -0.017010550945997238, -0.013054230250418186, -0.023901255801320076, -0.046597715467214584, 0.02310430258512497, -0.03945299983024597, -0.07351391762495041, -0.06542275846004486, 0.019822005182504654, -0.01287151500582695, 0.042066965252161026, 0.05857532098889351, 0.021751170977950096, -0.061877187341451645, -0.047758251428604126, 0.04345216602087021, 0.013191559351980686, -0.03205404430627823, -0.007575106341391802, -0.01819881610572338, 0.007730396464467049, 0.006799338385462761, -0.03821555897593498, -0.017108319327235222, 0.056884925812482834, 0.10524595528841019, -0.03323806822299957, 0.03054681606590748, -0.012347709387540817, 0.031962260603904724, -0.03789256885647774, -0.01147952675819397, 0.0031142402440309525, -0.010886747390031815, 0.025125443935394287, 0.019005687907338142, -0.05093856900930405, -0.01004475075751543, 0.026492411270737648, 0.003938691224902868, -0.06740105897188187, -0.04553109034895897, -0.0662086233496666, -0.024141360074281693, -0.06049008294939995, 0.02216612920165062, -0.07800468802452087, 0.07129870355129242, 0.019727591425180435, 0.03617214784026146, -0.007242346648126841, -0.03367993235588074, 0.01946873404085636, 0.0405774861574173, 0.025697464123368263, -0.012840276584029198, 0.00194370502140373, 0.0036342854145914316, 0.0072172521613538265, 0.030025653541088104, 0.03572864457964897, 0.010706568136811256, -0.03313755244016647, 0.007526200730353594, -0.020900575444102287, 0.039457716047763824, -0.06462693959474564, 0.03155382722616196, 0.000935735646635294, 0.04887143895030022, 0.02143857255578041, -0.014432682655751705, -0.023529816418886185, 0.024229275062680244, -0.0006096659344621003, 0.012072094716131687, 0.020473897457122803, 0.04588682949542999, -0.019870303571224213, 0.04395289719104767, -0.041375450789928436, 0.015810880810022354, 0.007610118482261896, 0.0073832739144563675, 0.012439158745110035, -0.00946236401796341, -0.04727448150515556, 0.006062627304345369, -0.01140813808888197, 0.02667306922376156, 0.02919861488044262, 0.028186816722154617, -0.037976257503032684, -0.0345766507089138, 0.05986850708723068, 0.0038944813422858715, -0.03461971506476402, 0.03104529343545437, -0.015227455645799637, -0.008552790619432926, -0.026048744097352028, -0.04058971628546715, -0.04919882491230965, 0.010044424794614315, 0.03459350764751434, 0.0013195821084082127, -0.017209723591804504, -0.005777114070951939, 0.04834984615445137, -0.01624141074717045, -0.016526220366358757, 0.04706358164548874, -0.02529684454202652, 0.03812785446643829, -0.01881686970591545, -0.042486291378736496, -0.009823312051594257, -0.025855790823698044, 0.00002708764441194944, -0.03872434049844742, -0.03825068101286888, -0.01838402822613716, -0.035808585584163666, -0.022569945082068443, -0.06982450187206268, -0.00037665842683054507, -0.007546692155301571, 0.03693736717104912, -0.05426400899887085, -0.021894946694374084, -0.03734002634882927, -0.025333045050501823, 0.023467248305678368, 0.042918361723423004, -0.009420123882591724, 0.04903598129749298, -0.03941987082362175, -0.022001616656780243, 0.01162115391343832, 0.0070014214143157005, 0.020880231633782387, 0.014048494398593903, 0.03489580377936363, -0.001854732516221702, -0.021645892411470413, 0.061959996819496155, -0.0036961904261261225, 0.049127187579870224, 0.0582941509783268, 0.026214316487312317, 0.023884650319814682, 0.039028771221637726, -0.012824516743421555, -0.053385719656944275, 0.0032855989411473274, 0.01922065019607544, -0.015345311723649502, 0.029352178797125816, 0.03550861403346062, -0.003186626825481653, 0.006498910486698151, -0.00932238344103098, -0.039569392800331116, -0.0064347838051617146, 0.03158171847462654, -0.07291589677333832, -0.029136743396520615, 0.008668494410812855, 0.013358003459870815, 0.006049373187124729, -0.009057321585714817, 0.01629110611975193, 0.03051568567752838, -0.009419145062565804, -0.027767391875386238, 0.0002536786487326026, 0.006167019251734018, -0.05440519005060196, 0.03543096408247948, 0.06854595243930817, 0.012494889087975025, 0.008520395494997501, -0.07722547650337219, 0.03977921977639198, 0.004598814062774181, 0.018481647595763206, 0.029118826612830162, 0.02622171863913536, 0.03278692066669464, 0.037036165595054626, 0.017207080498337746, 0.01964658498764038, -0.033335644751787186, 0.03150860220193863, -0.014839778654277325, 0.00752801401540637, 0.013904104009270668, 0.0685281753540039, 0.01565595343708992, 0.013247943483293056, 0.02006864733994007, 0.02932783216238022, -0.024513166397809982, -0.041148170828819275, -0.0010308868950232863, -0.0016305727185681462, 0.014720216393470764, 0.04417073726654053, 0.012631477788090706, -0.04932277277112007, 0.0151151642203331, -0.004400979727506638, -0.04888242110610008, -0.08251546323299408, 0.0022192304022610188, 0.007601628080010414, 0.0635564997792244, 0.05336018279194832, 0.035974085330963135, -0.03557153046131134, -0.026553925126791, 0.01849527657032013, 0.000022067228201194666, 0.06797321885824203, 0.015759602189064026, -0.0010098119964823127, 0.01061998587101698, -0.0017405456164851785, -0.015357056632637978, -0.04579908400774002, 0.04498887434601784, -0.00789535790681839, -0.05004305765032768, 0.039858587086200714, -0.004872852936387062, 0.043505825102329254, 0.014103570021688938, 0.003081714268773794, 0.03848126903176308, 0.0049007912166416645, 0.008021514862775803, -0.012255486100912094, 0.04887126386165619, -0.0035921474918723106, 0.00033392131444998085, -0.0466129407286644, -0.0010615468490868807, -0.02562321349978447, 0.05706686154007912, 0.026842085644602776, 0.011122499592602253, 0.017834022641181946, 0.04568861052393913, -0.048712294548749924, 0.029958676546812057, -0.07152111083269119, 0.01590290293097496, 0.07440841943025589, 0.016824202612042427, 0.04384336248040199, -0.07720387727022171, 0.012984603643417358, 0.042842939496040344, 0.05562387779355049, -0.026337649673223495, -0.020356016233563423, 0.030944520607590675, -0.07191448658704758, -0.007206349167972803, -0.022662751376628876, -0.02868831157684326, 0.026469344273209572, -0.017155949026346207, -0.019171202555298805, -0.061263684183359146, -0.01148360688239336, 0.020795250311493874, 0.02487824857234955, 0.06776797026395798, 0.026464024558663368, -0.05185680091381073, 0.001051932224072516, 0.03367387130856514, -0.0023335290607064962, -0.03127096965909004, -0.009164039045572281, 0.01826665550470352, -0.005721381865441799, -0.024364324286580086, -0.013600141741335392, -0.007620143238455057, -0.025109179317951202, -0.009692172519862652, 0.03397773951292038, -0.016711395233869553, 0.0788472518324852, -0.04363264515995979, 0.038361452519893646, 0.037320252507925034, 0.06835208088159561, 0.0008875367348082364, -0.027071047574281693, -0.017250822857022285, -0.009153063409030437, 0.030503595247864723, -0.05091863498091698, -0.02282586880028248, -0.007352614775300026, 0.03430112823843956, 0.07939426600933075, 0.030348902568221092, 0.04288078844547272, 0.02353118173778057, -0.056436385959386826, -0.03386444225907326, -0.04016408324241638, -0.04395448789000511, -0.06040092185139656, -0.00558886956423521, 0.016124766319990158, -0.02063583768904209, -0.03314414620399475, -0.010756414383649826, -0.06120597571134567, -0.07653624564409256, 0.012650628574192524, 0.004602652043104172, -0.047235459089279175, 0.035491619259119034, 0.042678628116846085, -0.002749824430793524, 0.011691911146044731, -0.03459026291966438, -0.006867783609777689, 0.019382258877158165, 0.024805651977658272, 0.005771222524344921, -0.02036498673260212, -0.03859483823180199, 0.04499324411153793, -0.030255932360887527, 0.041678424924612045, -0.04169556871056557, -0.024194642901420593, -0.011957726441323757, -0.05030154064297676, 0.04105376824736595, -0.04065845161676407, 0.05107535049319267, -0.037214115262031555, -0.03864055871963501, 0.0484149232506752, -0.028109677135944366, 0.02799316495656967, -0.05224752426147461, -0.026082050055265427, -0.04164120554924011, 0.012575296685099602, 0.020083758980035782, 0.01024443656206131, 0.004799391608685255, -0.0006563906790688634, 0.016075149178504944, -0.02226586639881134, -0.04938965290784836, 0.0415315143764019, -0.024151630699634552, 0.051389649510383606, 0.05155995488166809, -0.011471981182694435, -0.033215705305337906, -0.021174803376197815, -0.004920725245028734, 0.03530905023217201, -0.019744541496038437, 0.01454184576869011, -0.026491312310099602, 0.03949936106801033, 0.003999914042651653, -0.04304666444659233, -0.021178387105464935, -0.03888814151287079, 0.04380233585834503, 0.014380782842636108, 0.004288855940103531, 0.014586367644369602, 0.004120328463613987, 0.0038530025631189346, 0.05166362226009369, -0.018698137253522873, 0.013681815937161446, 0.0492161326110363, -0.017000170424580574, 0.011857535690069199, -0.030669696629047394, -0.056558914482593536, -0.00780046870931983, 0.023355156183242798, -0.039349231868982315, -0.04060453549027443, 0.05165247619152069, -0.00447763130068779, -0.015563687309622765, -0.05380085110664368, 0.07447601854801178, -0.037020206451416016, 0.043810758739709854, -0.0063380585052073, -0.040827590972185135, 0.020361080765724182, -0.00048687923117540777, 0.01725620962679386, -0.024659018963575363, -0.009379959665238857, 0.025287223979830742, 0.00844975933432579, 0.008600403554737568, -0.08787465840578079, -0.04450477287173271, -0.05980265140533447, 0.031937893480062485, -0.05767880752682686, 0.008333495818078518, 0.027947954833507538, 0.08036283403635025, 0.0250865425914526, 0.03892581909894943, -0.005996458698064089, 0.046378813683986664, -0.022041551768779755, -0.01915329322218895, -0.04838292673230171, -0.015298155136406422, 0.022360404953360558, -0.015341509133577347, -0.06235036998987198, -0.008444349281489849, 0.0032945885322988033, 0.06801437586545944, -0.005650004372000694, -0.0017349694389849901, 0.041953131556510925, -0.04050903022289276, 0.025324203073978424, 0.0881274938583374, 0.05665835365653038, -0.022620001807808876, -0.002125537721440196, 0.05025462806224823, -0.027892976999282837, -0.010642372071743011, -0.06333230435848236, 0.02659732475876808, -0.00873157475143671, 0.0318637490272522, 0.049897052347660065, -0.005181996151804924, -0.09556204825639725, -0.016061825677752495, -0.008966106921434402, 0.03633124753832817, -0.08515072613954544, 0.03771166875958443, 0.04342719539999962, -0.010589705780148506, 0.01755884289741516, -0.0708891898393631, -0.04068976640701294, -0.029298067092895508, 0.009032730013132095, 0.002335923258215189, 0.0011248515220358968, -0.03857281431555748, -0.012924800626933575, 0.02793658711016178, 0.01485380344092846, 0.0011035061907023191, 0.017451087012887, -0.011996883898973465, -0.06700727343559265, 0.043666474521160126, -0.031970616430044174, -0.04479696601629257, 0.04059051722288132, -0.012201863341033459, -0.0071767959743738174, 0.02626686356961727, 0.10156618803739548, 0.0016754934331402183, -0.019665440544486046, 0.010787904262542725, 0.07353779673576355, 0.029826462268829346, -0.05797109007835388, 0.013520720414817333, 0.009342975914478302, 0.011339914985001087, -0.05770209804177284, -0.06563780456781387, 0.008334951475262642, 0.03287360817193985, 0.010053149424493313, -0.016942882910370827, -0.07062041759490967, -0.008180435746908188, 0.02252163365483284, 0.02727210335433483, 0.026652423664927483, 0.06154339015483856, -0.02301451563835144, 0.028665345162153244, -0.08646351099014282, 0.02365109696984291, 0.014993049204349518, -0.026540163904428482, 0.035566288977861404, -0.019767889752984047, 0.07459969073534012, 0.05095357075333595, 0.05853314325213432, -0.005283045582473278, -0.03604992851614952, -0.01286237221211195, -0.0006740859244018793, 0.028517358005046844, -0.00706435926258564, -0.005533846560865641, -0.005388183984905481, 0.030007340013980865, -0.04691074416041374, 0.004159292206168175, -0.024432750418782234, 0.03111424297094345, 0.04423558712005615, 0.02809860371053219, -0.03202688694000244, -0.05503707751631737, 0.03780448064208031, -0.0035794158466160297, 0.02283470518887043, -0.019218062981963158, 0.025554899126291275, -0.003957880660891533, -0.012843193486332893, 0.05316106230020523, 0.04668469354510307, -0.03981219232082367, 0.0034977004397660494, -0.04609474539756775, -0.01959545537829399, 0.021553708240389824, -0.02808067947626114, 0.029492614790797234, 0.012468196451663971, 0.013650513254106045, 0.008760769851505756, -0.0027505403850227594, 0.08442582935094833, 0.028568826615810394, -0.04414713382720947, 0.0825115218758583, -0.03385591506958008, -0.011593783274292946, 0.040635157376527786, 0.040233466774225235, -0.011308697052299976, -0.04584740474820137, -0.018583297729492188, -0.05043868348002434, 0.044208865612745285, 0.004754961468279362, 0.05045836791396141, 0.013118926435709, 0.003910517785698175, -0.01905682124197483, 0.002806933131068945, 0.05212581157684326, 0.027711130678653717, 0.06601046025753021, 0.05518028885126114, -0.011636575683951378, -0.012880835682153702, 0.05195175111293793, 0.07613533735275269, -0.015902377665042877, -0.05430581420660019, -0.01679559051990509, 0.035418424755334854, 0.0930575504899025, 0.004307379946112633, 0.054332152009010315, -0.06113123148679733, -0.022876475006341934, -0.06332792341709137, -0.10012385249137878, -0.016218096017837524, 0.009357789531350136, 0.07274846732616425, -0.03266112133860588, -0.018512004986405373, 0.004671096336096525, -0.005447581876069307, 0.0019149347208440304, 0.03013021871447563, -0.03155134618282318, -0.007283512037247419, 0.02312006987631321, 0.014195741154253483, -0.02397693693637848, -0.007545812521129847, -0.039449453353881836, 0.025312980636954308, 0.03960150480270386, -0.05709538981318474, -0.00709934439510107, -0.016156429424881935, -0.003047239501029253, 0.03196621313691139, -0.08450315147638321, -0.026082104071974754, 0.012957957573235035, -0.05898120254278183, -0.02307966724038124, -0.06398730725049973, -0.00922164972871542, -0.006488686427474022, 0.013986308127641678, 0.0026766168884932995, -0.024093037471175194, -0.0335373617708683, 0.060989782214164734, 0.053884636610746384, 0.04148409143090248, 0.07410498708486557, -0.01376620214432478, 0.04194050654768944, -0.05518347769975662, 0.01585536263883114, -0.013336540199816227, 0.005567603278905153, -0.03667319193482399, -0.0262396652251482, 0.0046663046814501286, -0.014117882587015629, 0.0007513373275287449, 0.005052889231592417, -0.02688460424542427, -0.004235587082803249, -0.05151817947626114, -0.06864063441753387, -0.056607723236083984, 0.00367058371193707, -0.008442710153758526, 0.031175168231129646, 0.0430278517305851, 0.011563696898519993, 0.04915988817811012, -0.03562290593981743, -0.0029214234091341496, 0.05042307823896408, -0.04064755141735077, 0.0048600733280181885, 0.009674685075879097, -0.059978991746902466, -0.08287090808153152, -0.015885718166828156, 0.053433652967214584, 0.025919020175933838, 0.051657747477293015, 0.03789055719971657, -0.04916771128773689, 0.054523274302482605, -0.02315630577504635, 0.06075439229607582, -0.008705687709152699, 0.022453896701335907, -0.011451471596956253, -0.017803454771637917, 0.005183464381843805, 0.008698026649653912, -0.010732266120612621, -0.08247123658657074, 0.02150958776473999, -0.021084310486912727, -0.014482476748526096, 0.036657363176345825, -0.020709693431854248, 0.050272829830646515, 0.058449119329452515, 0.024654293432831764, 0.060509078204631805, 0.03270026668906212, 0.012398183345794678, -0.00010951253352686763, -0.04695732146501541, 0.028721271082758904, -0.04764534533023834, 0.010417690500617027, 0.00248690671287477, -0.03456439450383186 ]
<p>I am using a standard version of logistic regression to fit my input variables to binary output variables.</p> <p>However in my problem, the negative outputs (0s) far outnumber the positive outputs (1s). The ratio is 20:1. So when I train a classifier, it seems that even features that strongly suggest the possibility of a positive output still have very low (highly negative) values for their corresponding parameters. It seems to me that this happens because there are just too many negative examples pulling the parameters in their direction.</p> <p>So I am wondering if I can add weights (say using 20 instead of 1) for the positive examples. Is this likely to benefit at all? And if so, how should I add the weights (in the equations below).</p> <p>The cost function looks like the following: $$J = (-1 / m) \cdot\sum_{i=1}^{m} y\cdot\log(h(x\cdot\theta)) + (1-y)(1 - \log(h(x\cdot\theta)))$$</p> <p>The gradient of this cost function (wrt $\theta$) is:</p> <p>$$\mathrm{grad} = ((h(x\cdot\theta) - y)' \cdot X)'$$</p> <p>Here $m$ = number of test cases, $x$ = feature matrix, $y$ = output vector, $h$=sigmoid function, $\theta$ = parameters we are trying to learn.</p> <p>Finally I run the gradient descent to find the lowest $J$ possible. The implementation seems to run correctly.</p>
g37158
[ -0.026814328506588936, 0.013274423778057098, -0.004970528185367584, -0.028075650334358215, 0.0210790503770113, -0.017230505123734474, 0.04334023594856262, 0.012442332692444324, -0.09302100539207458, -0.011308401823043823, -0.020725691691040993, 0.06155018135905266, 0.03004501760005951, 0.03958529233932495, -0.006592789199203253, -0.03778398782014847, 0.03693707287311554, 0.014268036000430584, 0.0013029574183747172, -0.04250168800354004, -0.013905343599617481, 0.044440895318984985, -0.00907125324010849, -0.01847265474498272, 0.014091208577156067, -0.006057307124137878, -0.039504196494817734, 0.05953875929117203, -0.008997231721878052, 0.07823629677295685, -0.06298894435167313, -0.028195947408676147, 0.017378488555550575, -0.029712703078985214, -0.01766265742480755, 0.03483116254210472, 0.05837814882397652, -0.014781871810555458, 0.028446411713957787, 0.021283302456140518, -0.018163694068789482, 0.0011459409724920988, 0.030527496710419655, 0.026552436873316765, 0.000977447023615241, -0.002792886458337307, 0.015536128543317318, -0.015518886037170887, 0.011717338114976883, -0.00850200466811657, -0.028239445760846138, -0.047919586300849915, -0.019779015332460403, -0.01573900133371353, 0.07442481815814972, -0.014912815764546394, -0.010003441013395786, -0.013434342108666897, -0.01834867149591446, 0.009521177038550377, 0.04773939773440361, -0.004238562658429146, -0.0325457938015461, -0.009694177657365799, 0.00011698062007781118, 0.015022359788417816, -0.033170681446790695, -0.026371991261839867, -0.0015193051658570766, 0.07640331983566284, -0.017943747341632843, 0.0002507269673515111, -0.0014065020950511098, -0.05661972612142563, -0.03782093897461891, -0.016875019297003746, 0.009757556021213531, 0.0051149772480130196, -0.013050486333668232, 0.042627181857824326, 0.01398229505866766, -0.023547517135739326, 0.004541647154837847, -0.014848018996417522, -0.007991475984454155, 0.04372166097164154, 0.09375948458909988, 0.03330492228269577, 0.008789785206317902, 0.03262175992131233, 0.014112510718405247, -0.04025864973664284, -0.007114719599485397, 0.0731394812464714, 0.03756661340594292, -0.019973907619714737, -0.031883884221315384, 0.01858200877904892, -0.00010093823220813647, -0.03209374099969864, 0.06539572775363922, 0.05821211636066437, 0.009198208339512348, -0.05995196849107742, -0.10242099314928055, 0.009924898855388165, 0.053363390266895294, 0.013448154553771019, -0.03183421492576599, -0.034548480063676834, -0.05095912888646126, 0.02331298030912876, 0.0028335771057754755, -0.09251105040311813, -0.07744438201189041, -0.03528285026550293, 0.026086827740073204, -0.05040304362773895, -0.0359378345310688, 0.019359173253178596, 0.0525357648730278, -0.04463055357336998, 0.018888475373387337, -0.014766531996428967, -0.004132203757762909, -0.04999538138508797, -0.05230524390935898, 0.047755300998687744, 0.055021606385707855, -0.021175699308514595, -0.018782807514071465, -0.01917942613363266, -0.029601408168673515, -0.024480808526277542, 0.008276138454675674, 0.05775518715381622, -0.04249347001314163, 0.0297542717307806, 0.02142348513007164, 0.05212081968784332, 0.013692650943994522, 0.014279329217970371, 0.035006288439035416, -0.0113914730027318, -0.01568629778921604, 0.013653475791215897, -0.06440328061580658, 0.0198321845382452, -0.003731092205271125, 0.011278633959591389, -0.015156853012740612, -0.02034037932753563, 0.0071215759962797165, 0.045532409101724625, -0.03598291426897049, 0.02017723210155964, 0.024043498560786247, -0.004955577664077282, 0.012141064740717411, -0.005594232119619846, 0.07498060166835785, -0.024373207241296768, 0.015246991068124771, -0.019884800538420677, 0.00811554491519928, 0.007985414937138557, -0.00637237960472703, -0.038153696805238724, -0.0412534661591053, 0.020491981878876686, -0.008763795718550682, 0.002379427896812558, 0.04417470842599869, -0.0530688501894474, 0.0660683736205101, -0.010445874184370041, 0.04592958465218544, 0.005460241809487343, 0.03127605468034744, 0.03217354789376259, -0.05376475304365158, 0.032842159271240234, 0.012648327276110649, -0.03821372240781784, 0.0026923478581011295, -0.03946351632475853, -0.044521037489175797, 0.03336525335907936, -0.002896322635933757, 0.005891411565244198, 0.0476452000439167, 0.014330370351672173, 0.007826687768101692, -0.02165563963353634, -0.028522390872240067, -0.005802785977721214, 0.015175340697169304, -0.03923036903142929, -0.011490593664348125, 0.00346205523237586, -0.014727238565683365, 0.024219756945967674, 0.02648359164595604, 0.038323719054460526, -0.047554582357406616, -0.05547681078314781, 0.03750927373766899, -0.02260538749396801, -0.023792877793312073, -0.04585009068250656, -0.03345746174454689, -0.0286213681101799, 0.025937706232070923, 0.052008744329214096, -0.01811004802584648, -0.08169911801815033, -0.04060082510113716, 0.02404441498219967, -0.01087668351829052, -0.00862070731818676, -0.014003332704305649, -0.003161301137879491, 0.05240076780319214, 0.028294522315263748, -0.01996348425745964, 0.010146456770598888, 0.026856450363993645, -0.01415223442018032, 0.014190396293997765, -0.04413202032446861, 0.012519911862909794, 0.014513135887682438, 0.033843763172626495, -0.06020399183034897, 0.01692996732890606, -0.01142200082540512, 0.03834355250000954, 0.0019153920002281666, -0.07148607075214386, 0.029021117836236954, 0.0471402145922184, -0.03979373723268509, -0.020492402836680412, 0.05423351004719734, 0.0004260011774022132, -0.04648876190185547, -0.043597422540187836, 0.03664792329072952, -0.011277741752564907, 0.0410330556333065, -0.06966275721788406, 0.08679148554801941, 0.009943729266524315, 0.01706775836646557, -0.012201272882521152, 0.015136786736547947, -0.046836405992507935, -0.021250739693641663, 0.04463806375861168, -0.014971055090427399, 0.018925709649920464, -0.01619379036128521, -0.035425879061222076, 0.03052184358239174, -0.03212582692503929, -0.010534483939409256, -0.03751300647854805, -0.06248662993311882, 0.027203815057873726, 0.03433159738779068, -0.03468131646513939, -0.0027926741167902946, 0.02044508419930935, -0.005584826227277517, 0.025750352069735527, 0.013922041282057762, -0.011478608474135399, 0.07409756630659103, 0.005387697834521532, -0.019352011382579803, 0.012027813121676445, -0.0235268697142601, -0.05419572442770004, -0.025753062218427658, 0.025030439719557762, 0.0036982260644435883, 0.058994654566049576, -0.03892219439148903, -0.014452206902205944, 0.04321438446640968, -0.01614028587937355, 0.022354943677783012, 0.06777726113796234, -0.037263911217451096, 0.05562274903059006, -0.04499853029847145, 0.06428999453783035, -0.014339134097099304, 0.016264962032437325, -0.00897321105003357, -0.04208580031991005, 0.012532943859696388, 0.010124556720256805, -0.01624833233654499, -0.032169412821531296, -0.07870014011859894, -0.06286324560642242, 0.03458913043141365, -0.02016615681350231, 0.010718930512666702, -0.04324529320001602, 0.021915389224886894, -0.0055998568423092365, -0.04830215871334076, -0.007780501153320074, -0.024390380829572678, -0.02259850688278675, 0.0063646468333899975, 0.004402508493512869, -0.032587114721536636, 0.00512305460870266, -0.066190704703331, 0.016013480722904205, 0.02535651996731758, 0.026953529566526413, 0.0265564676374197, -0.017159495502710342, 0.006849359720945358, -0.023712148889899254, 0.05022016540169716, 0.11648273468017578, 0.009485356509685516, -0.01566961221396923, 0.00714328745380044, 0.025485403835773468, 0.010088820941746235, 0.026899732649326324, -0.02266194298863411, 0.019582288339734077, 0.020987531170248985, -0.05207114666700363, 0.019395960494875908, -0.06115748733282089, -0.01563143916428089, -0.02060273289680481, -0.044116102159023285, 0.0361330583691597, 0.06870309263467789, 0.005097770597785711, -0.013905128464102745, -0.02912803180515766, -0.02205386571586132, 0.03759950026869774, -0.039732709527015686, 0.007322927471250296, 0.04192948341369629, 0.05984463542699814, 0.016633326187729836, -0.016060424968600273, 0.03693757578730583, -0.0019344533793628216, 0.013794711790978909, -0.047071635723114014, 0.01666765846312046, -0.027067147195339203, 0.020246025174856186, -0.013271186500787735, 0.07404380291700363, -0.004646366462111473, -0.005274150054901838, 0.019336383789777756, -0.003925880882889032, -0.012738887220621109, 0.006823462899774313, -0.02211935818195343, 0.0019515270832926035, 0.043834906071424484, 0.03764702007174492, 0.006658371537923813, 0.013013334944844246, 0.0011099042603746057, -0.017767099663615227, -0.027737300843000412, 0.013721352443099022, -0.046891193836927414, -0.035900015383958817, -0.047435611486434937, -0.024661701172590256, 0.08029600977897644, 0.02780604362487793, 0.0015657007461413741, 0.036761216819286346, -0.02032099850475788, 0.031928420066833496, 0.009103899821639061, -0.020520200952887535, -0.01981322653591633, -0.019328001886606216, -0.008115490898489952, 0.03456740453839302, -0.01964106224477291, 0.0319361574947834, 0.04359525442123413, 0.01874208077788353, -0.03279099240899086, -0.03130246326327324, 0.021486306563019753, 0.0518202930688858, -0.04296618327498436, 0.009852057322859764, -0.021323928609490395, -0.060123395174741745, -0.019297080114483833, -0.0351128913462162, 0.02868720144033432, -0.007364135235548019, 0.0611371211707592, -0.018337229266762733, 0.022304890677332878, 0.023199718445539474, 0.038986220955848694, 0.06424528360366821, -0.0798642560839653, -0.04625237360596657, -0.017160380259156227, -0.01924338936805725, 0.0724470466375351, -0.001320177805610001, 0.035748615860939026, -0.03856564685702324, 0.027427170425653458, 0.03389211371541023, 0.03515694662928581, 0.033736515790224075, 0.11204519867897034, 0.03157055377960205, -0.011702603660523891, 0.00144916120916605, 0.020589012652635574, -0.007203513756394386, -0.019549652934074402, 0.01337229460477829, -0.009760651737451553, -0.032274164259433746, 0.0218434426933527, 0.0009321870165877044, -0.04707940295338631, 0.016860846430063248, -0.03559498116374016, 0.02694859355688095, 0.017486577853560448, 0.050487831234931946, 0.046158820390701294, -0.04703152924776077, 0.0751791000366211, 0.02627103216946125, -0.013746018521487713, 0.028236104175448418, -0.020054351538419724, 0.05219978839159012, 0.0587875135242939, -0.04338722676038742, -0.0015953611582517624, 0.019124027341604233, 0.00996797438710928, -0.06467628479003906, -0.026755504310131073, -0.019146138802170753, 0.0681733787059784, -0.027673715725541115, -0.039983659982681274, 0.03237689286470413, 0.0665782168507576, -0.014702883549034595, -0.05489698052406311, -0.030316902324557304, -0.014304530806839466, -0.0186355821788311, 0.02027997188270092, 0.02031560242176056, -0.021847672760486603, -0.05002325400710106, 0.023279689252376556, -0.06766263395547867, -0.04657498002052307, 0.002974769799038768, -0.020983988419175148, -0.018474014475941658, 0.04325020685791969, -0.06103317439556122, 0.0123167484998703, 0.028582049533724785, 0.02872881107032299, 0.008240489289164543, -0.06406521052122116, 0.018928436562418938, 0.04569079726934433, 0.0063571869395673275, 0.005085510667413473, -0.025163644924759865, -0.0948236733675003, -0.021474212408065796, -0.003928139340132475, -0.05063726380467415, 0.0023758909665048122, -0.02264360897243023, 0.0806383565068245, -0.0035325298085808754, 0.0467754565179348, 0.029178880155086517, -0.037398044019937515, -0.014186697080731392, 0.04067197069525719, -0.03944391757249832, -0.035594746470451355, -0.07578511536121368, -0.013489474542438984, 0.0768161192536354, -0.014735167846083641, 0.023786593228578568, 0.05198480933904648, -0.011219087988138199, -0.012281074188649654, 0.010807711631059647, 0.020716050639748573, -0.022125881165266037, -0.049041908234357834, -0.04421881213784218, -0.01168289314955473, -0.06319643557071686, 0.050114862620830536, 0.02729450911283493, -0.004910978488624096, 0.024314677342772484, 0.006742134224623442, -0.047971416264772415, 0.02271953411400318, 0.06339770555496216, -0.02934039756655693, -0.04810495302081108, 0.049562305212020874, 0.0008304009679704905, -0.0012658028863370419, -0.007998070679605007, -0.039454832673072815, 0.005648843478411436, -0.024261536076664925, -0.016806719824671745, -0.010617349296808243, -0.061734020709991455, -0.030030541121959686, 0.07144679129123688, -0.04271232336759567, 0.007006773725152016, -0.02002961002290249, -0.011130346916615963, 0.0187703724950552, 0.00665627233684063, 0.018986837938427925, 0.040558308362960815, -0.050606951117515564, -0.04136285185813904, -0.038883671164512634, 0.013377498835325241, 0.002400839002802968, 0.0260501429438591, 0.04824957251548767, 0.01560848020017147, -0.038841307163238525, 0.035795729607343674, 0.04605359211564064, -0.03623190522193909, 0.022758448496460915, 0.061218295246362686, -0.01537440624088049, -0.053208719938993454, 0.031134774908423424, -0.008771922439336777, 0.04158840328454971, -0.03884277120232582, -0.010656531900167465, 0.03692407160997391, -0.04697507619857788, -0.011895264498889446, 0.012912459671497345, 0.027039455249905586, -0.06876128166913986, -0.007299409713596106, -0.03292124718427658, 0.0020454241894185543, -0.018299566581845284, -0.010127760469913483, 0.0017674865666776896, -0.01685536839067936, 0.003928975202143192, -0.031226158142089844, -0.025584671646356583, 0.041016869246959686, -0.01788514107465744, -0.09374120086431503, 0.023157771676778793, 0.01716146059334278, 0.08633377403020859, -0.008130357600748539, 0.004734679590910673, -0.009927144274115562, -0.057297367602586746, 0.03740471228957176, 0.029142936691641808, 0.010752460919320583, -0.024477621540427208, 0.03653273358941078, 0.01825902797281742, 0.028138762339949608, 0.004224817734211683, -0.038733161985874176, -0.006858850363641977, 0.0006205000099726021, 0.00031281725387088954, -0.025287315249443054, 0.0073398700915277, -0.07590536028146744, 0.016581473872065544, -0.043447643518447876, 0.045402735471725464, 0.0384509339928627, 0.005286386702209711, 0.045577969402074814, 0.007844625972211361, 0.005708305165171623, 0.016395557671785355, 0.05653883144259453, -0.07809430360794067, -0.05178507789969444, -0.07170827686786652, 0.08180519938468933, -0.029515046626329422, 0.07988117635250092, -0.01646464318037033, 0.049816783517599106, -0.002027761423960328, 0.03974047675728798, -0.05949410796165466, -0.03989258408546448, 0.04740835726261139, 0.1055576428771019, 0.08435874432325363, 0.028390999883413315, -0.028066270053386688, 0.02114945836365223, 0.0646207332611084, 0.00577990198507905, 0.047909077256917953, -0.022632764652371407, -0.019705798476934433, 0.019747164100408554, 0.027617091313004494, 0.034784648567438126, 0.029189255088567734, 0.03760039061307907, 0.034294210374355316, -0.054321154952049255, -0.081680528819561, 0.03387158736586571, 0.035345252603292465, 0.04765845090150833, -0.01080418098717928, -0.004307314287871122, 0.008860526606440544, 0.015408467501401901, 0.013674609363079071, -0.015613515861332417, -0.034105103462934494, 0.026168299838900566, 0.02003328502178192, 0.026751751080155373, -0.047355592250823975, 0.008907247334718704, -0.07031112164258957, -0.003753304947167635, 0.026660285890102386, -0.025619113817811012, -0.02142512798309326, 0.0202316977083683, -0.008824975229799747, -0.004573366604745388, 0.0014313332503661513, -0.05646146461367607, 0.03993990272283554, -0.007255954202264547, -0.04996377229690552, -0.020881544798612595, 0.037977732717990875, -0.01939547061920166, -0.02333291433751583, 0.03852494806051254, -0.02125614695250988, 0.04730689153075218, -0.006110548973083496, 0.06714919954538345, 0.061498019844293594, 0.00948756281286478, -0.05770743638277054, -0.037898529320955276, 0.019718235358595848, 0.05174863338470459, -0.0024666704703122377, -0.04539395123720169, -0.018134210258722305, -0.0460096076130867, 0.012068039737641811, 0.039337240159511566, 0.00037280863034538925, -0.03757055848836899, 0.04214010015130043, 0.01356380432844162, -0.024607103317975998, -0.05644698813557625, 0.015397640876471996, 0.00974386278539896, -0.060578376054763794, -0.00343718403019011, -0.017115693539381027, -0.0009281898383051157, -0.02853434719145298, -0.027644651010632515, -0.024528002366423607, -0.008552162908017635, -0.014318256638944149, 0.005441331770271063, -0.03429564833641052, -0.05113590136170387, -0.0467224158346653, -0.022025147452950478, -0.021072624251246452, -0.029355958104133606, 0.04895096644759178, 0.06751426309347153, -0.03536896035075188, 0.06278205662965775, -0.04767816886305809, -0.0023200581781566143, 0.009196890518069267, 0.02881891280412674, 0.03497714176774025, 0.07699773460626602, -0.032862067222595215, 0.0318978950381279, 0.054311152547597885, -0.018156684935092926, -0.05223125219345093, -0.04446586221456528, -0.010842734947800636, 0.012511428445577621, -0.02438603900372982, 0.019595786929130554, 0.029705455526709557, 0.0009464293834753335, 0.015238173305988312, -0.08542982488870621, 0.003290734952315688, -0.020283348858356476, -0.034191571176052094, 0.0020343526266515255, 0.00020320492330938578, 0.007699751760810614, -0.028376102447509766, 0.0047640688717365265 ]
<ol> <li><p>If the items to be "summed" or combined to create an overall index are collectively the underlying construct (i.e. I am trying to measure compliance to an intervention which has different components), wouldn't combining all the components for IRT violate the assumption of unidimensionality since they represent the intervention itself? If so, do you have a reference for this?</p></li> <li><p>Are there any good references that say if Likert scores are summed into a scale and the Cronbach's alpha is relatively high (~0.8), this is appropriate to use as an index?</p></li> <li><p>Are there any other tests of validity I should do other than Cronbach's alpha if all I have done is sum the responses?</p></li> </ol> <p>Thanks in advance, any advice is appreciated!</p>
g74320
[ -0.032709427177906036, -0.055171526968479156, 0.0009384301374666393, -0.06434360891580582, 0.003547580912709236, 0.007864587008953094, 0.02048434503376484, 0.05438512936234474, 0.042199164628982544, 0.012899968773126602, -0.0006286819116212428, -0.023046866059303284, 0.020184259861707687, 0.007089204154908657, -0.06197372451424599, -0.015798088163137436, 0.06278533488512039, 0.03141004592180252, -0.0357169583439827, 0.0459161251783371, -0.03347504511475563, 0.007984733209013939, 0.04352753981947899, -0.03609083220362663, 0.0011324036167934537, -0.02340078540146351, 0.023073239251971245, 0.009738165885210037, -0.07361302524805069, -0.027665873989462852, -0.009692170657217503, -0.010039102286100388, 0.0039703138172626495, -0.03634406253695488, -0.04547163471579552, 0.06107403710484505, 0.05555581673979759, 0.0365511029958725, 0.006679241545498371, 0.028570111840963364, -0.07018903642892838, 0.09090039134025574, 0.05683593451976776, -0.025561995804309845, 0.000746718782465905, 0.010732640512287617, 0.011733337305486202, -0.043499257415533066, 0.020601673051714897, 0.026754379272460938, -0.01737486571073532, -0.01367597933858633, -0.0016106850234791636, -0.016634879633784294, -0.0004370062961243093, -0.009271131828427315, -0.034332796931266785, -0.017889531329274178, 0.011572107672691345, 0.005668042227625847, 0.026073923334479332, -0.03894896060228348, -0.013247562572360039, -0.007990272715687752, 0.03221594914793968, -0.0031904943753033876, -0.0008966480963863432, 0.052739743143320084, 0.018407508730888367, -0.025921925902366638, 0.026008501648902893, -0.07128141075372696, 0.06491870433092117, -0.015472935512661934, -0.031786054372787476, -0.0076504298485815525, -0.009242821484804153, -0.01029281411319971, 0.05375419929623604, 0.016624080017209053, 0.013849694281816483, -0.054484907537698746, 0.03624187037348747, 0.003123796544969082, 0.04426448419690132, -0.009721408598124981, 0.008828019723296165, -0.042121995240449905, -0.04116397723555565, 0.05013415962457657, 0.03577049821615219, -0.001479803235270083, -0.028706936165690422, 0.04068000987172127, 0.016338041052222252, 0.00023552082711830735, -0.05257341265678406, 0.01189289428293705, -0.020205754786729813, 0.024061592295765877, -0.023185808211565018, 0.05276107043027878, -0.012507257983088493, 0.012204525992274284, -0.025395363569259644, 0.00847034715116024, 0.026375511661171913, -0.00915035605430603, -0.04055098816752434, -0.028967615216970444, -0.08036576211452484, 0.005975405219942331, -0.04956016317009926, -0.08197345584630966, -0.01567806862294674, -0.037403471767902374, 0.0705898106098175, -0.012695594690740108, 0.0018400471890345216, -0.011003662832081318, 0.06524567306041718, -0.052817005664110184, 0.0259677916765213, 0.0499325655400753, -0.05114896968007088, 0.004925611428916454, -0.0011997258989140391, 0.06421498954296112, 0.03920184075832367, -0.01959463581442833, 0.020090332254767418, -0.04884263500571251, -0.03741609677672386, -0.0381813608109951, 0.06790602207183838, -0.018092211335897446, -0.021715072914958, 0.008133122697472572, -0.06457684189081192, 0.038918908685445786, -0.019542904570698738, 0.005112741142511368, -0.029858138412237167, 0.07201163470745087, 0.014876986853778362, 0.0021502263844013214, 0.019035499542951584, 0.0073447637259960175, -0.008327431045472622, -0.005608698353171349, -0.02799324505031109, 0.040772445499897, 0.0039505804888904095, -0.020972397178411484, -0.028773076832294464, 0.0019505496602505445, -0.032115887850522995, -0.014766420237720013, -0.013346771709620953, -0.001569258631207049, 0.003351259743794799, -0.03990159556269646, 0.010268536396324635, 0.02123969793319702, 0.016436489298939705, 0.019354943186044693, -0.021631712093949318, 0.03433513641357422, 0.07150488346815109, 0.03758593648672104, 0.07245386391878128, 0.024328267201781273, 0.02654329501092434, 0.03716381639242172, 0.08145767450332642, 0.0806998610496521, 0.06075825169682503, 0.016113081946969032, 0.04313202574849129, 0.00940108485519886, -0.01766054704785347, -0.01145627535879612, -0.008534584194421768, -0.02959980070590973, 0.00487838638946414, -0.00403639767318964, 0.030813783407211304, 0.00702629191800952, -0.07589597254991531, 0.04520191252231598, -0.003966682590544224, 0.04566817730665207, 0.025638073682785034, 0.05550955608487129, -0.04415694996714592, -0.060655947774648666, 0.047569356858730316, -0.02387823909521103, -0.04034152254462242, -0.03280525654554367, 0.05686080455780029, 0.03600888326764107, -0.014416433870792389, 0.03446050360798836, -0.06921396404504776, 0.05399365723133087, -0.04628293588757515, 0.02594832144677639, 0.024771342054009438, -0.005745317786931992, 0.06403744220733643, 0.0005138543783687055, 0.022808577865362167, -0.010797607712447643, -0.04437756910920143, -0.01046301145106554, 0.04408881813287735, -0.015310520306229591, -0.013067024759948254, 0.04905116185545921, -0.02025582641363144, 0.0035344643983989954, 0.008122016675770283, -0.06320524960756302, -0.007875526323914528, 0.015085822902619839, 0.008089285343885422, 0.07415199279785156, 0.04245729744434357, -0.027591707184910774, -0.014806042425334454, -0.01702858693897724, -0.005517822690308094, -0.08144952356815338, 0.05391119420528412, 0.0328952930867672, -0.005006709136068821, 0.013088110834360123, -0.024876099079847336, 0.04420957341790199, 0.016306381672620773, -0.004649011418223381, 0.013557747937738895, -0.023706631734967232, 0.007518295664340258, 0.050647713243961334, 0.014340991154313087, 0.018623391166329384, 0.008203890174627304, 0.06154486909508705, -0.08662901818752289, 0.048118602484464645, -0.05193055048584938, -0.017407001927495003, 0.012909193523228168, 0.003573588328436017, 0.0651765987277031, -0.03983576223254204, -0.009215380065143108, 0.024709198623895645, 0.02629852294921875, -0.07173589617013931, -0.02461913786828518, 0.029150493443012238, -0.011050068773329258, -0.055502984672784805, 0.049369074404239655, -0.05595735087990761, 0.025635739788413048, 0.0021719576325267553, -0.11961331218481064, 0.01896608993411064, 0.06454989314079285, 0.09049414098262787, 0.0027615330182015896, 0.00414580013602972, -0.06452049314975739, -0.031210780143737793, -0.008570127189159393, 0.002498824382200837, 0.00888277031481266, 0.06856989860534668, -0.03606994450092316, 0.033503174781799316, 0.04680867865681648, 0.04960424825549126, 0.03120156191289425, 0.01633395627140999, -0.0478486604988575, 0.06535325944423676, 0.0292277242988348, -0.014624579809606075, 0.008744455873966217, 0.005845651030540466, -0.024481065571308136, 0.015641987323760986, -0.024225786328315735, -0.08057451993227005, -0.008619249798357487, 0.017168056219816208, -0.02498863823711872, -0.011530254036188126, 0.010981286875903606, 0.0006895826663821936, 0.04572935029864311, -0.01595715619623661, -0.05665864050388336, -0.030960578471422195, -0.006587113253772259, 0.002652552677318454, -0.043544549494981766, -0.021779213100671768, -0.009049385786056519, -0.03050466626882553, 0.01859375461935997, -0.005622327793389559, 0.015770208090543747, 0.028392352163791656, 0.028205960988998413, 0.03315926343202591, 0.01653888449072838, 0.006483901757746935, 0.014687508344650269, 0.03081728145480156, -0.042011551558971405, -0.009288092143833637, -0.0035771848633885384, 0.033334795385599136, -0.004923161584883928, 0.002641705796122551, 0.012458360753953457, 0.030927596613764763, 0.061118971556425095, 0.021728454157710075, -0.0067490157671272755, -0.04706709831953049, -0.060853566974401474, -0.023075759410858154, 0.020825136452913284, 0.007181474938988686, -0.03041083551943302, -0.08575939387083054, 0.06553646177053452, -0.04640974476933479, -0.0021331156603991985, 0.016666660085320473, 0.02883942984044552, 0.038719285279512405, 0.001963032642379403, -0.00938475038856268, 0.015611734241247177, 0.05069420859217644, -0.031371261924505234, -0.0708615854382515, 0.026757843792438507, -0.0036021608393639326, 0.061326272785663605, 0.08636412769556046, -0.052757419645786285, -0.02054641582071781, 0.06566008925437927, -0.014312234707176685, -0.03844543546438217, 0.03684999793767929, -0.016444098204374313, 0.012885590083897114, -0.012208436615765095, 0.0370740182697773, -0.02997763268649578, 0.06728272885084152, 0.043553080409765244, 0.05588122457265854, -0.02025475725531578, -0.030954215675592422, 0.004013290163129568, 0.015585829503834248, 0.05652864649891853, 0.026995424181222916, -0.01624649204313755, 0.033787041902542114, 0.004628266207873821, 0.026984447613358498, -0.02994322031736374, 0.012720147147774696, 0.03282119706273079, 0.013782607391476631, -0.020181579515337944, 0.008496933616697788, 0.026526907458901405, -0.004473843611776829, 0.03222888335585594, -0.08389948308467865, -0.042774103581905365, -0.0017518209060654044, 0.06253881007432938, -0.039763499051332474, -0.009220412001013756, -0.03348611667752266, 0.0463935025036335, 0.09493552893400192, 0.013107719831168652, -0.060499951243400574, 0.02698395773768425, -0.009382235817611217, -0.036871518939733505, 0.06633166968822479, -0.004216581117361784, 0.016774587333202362, 0.010563256219029427, -0.04066186770796776, -0.03661508113145828, 0.0031392620876431465, 0.0496111623942852, -0.03160490468144417, 0.030256886035203934, -0.03061722032725811, 0.03264547139406204, -0.01607908308506012, 0.01887287199497223, -0.006086341105401516, -0.02912476286292076, 0.007269366178661585, -0.005064492113888264, -0.005139842629432678, 0.04049897938966751, 0.021760981529951096, -0.06100048869848251, 0.0027898026164621115, 0.005640564486384392, 0.0644807517528534, -0.004179380368441343, 0.06468601524829865, -0.018739501014351845, -0.018737275153398514, 0.00357210380025208, 0.007669177837669849, 0.0023210938088595867, 0.020715143531560898, 0.017639663070440292, -0.036186497658491135, -0.03711444512009621, -0.026260145008563995, -0.02595120668411255, 0.012212750501930714, -0.001075798412784934, 0.00413502799347043, -0.07138606160879135, 0.013618001714348793, -0.02048877254128456, 0.012010970152914524, -0.04836002364754677, 0.06788861006498337, 0.016833648085594177, -0.024014785885810852, -0.017576953396201134, 0.01610071025788784, 0.05702416971325874, 0.03894834965467453, 0.0011575226671993732, 0.027734879404306412, 0.03312712907791138, -0.0838569924235344, -0.02906060591340065, -0.06877721846103668, 0.03951667994260788, 0.003745950059965253, -0.02364070527255535, 0.023721711710095406, -0.07750478386878967, 0.0014113755896687508, 0.03535054624080658, 0.012894836254417896, -0.0035587141755968332, -0.01140011940151453, 0.005978104658424854, 0.024134712293744087, -0.03507810831069946, -0.026591727510094643, -0.02747020311653614, 0.004228839185088873, -0.03759808838367462, -0.00021871332137379795, 0.0034557569306343794, -0.01349774282425642, 0.0005386662087403238, -0.03481265902519226, -0.005350820254534483, -0.029562383890151978, 0.04014725610613823, -0.018874773755669594, 0.005170504096895456, 0.040829576551914215, 0.017163731157779694, -0.02646828256547451, 0.00021792022744193673, 0.0688433051109314, 0.026583312079310417, -0.05238638073205948, -0.00660316739231348, -0.01780317723751068, -0.012101159431040287, 0.06611035764217377, 0.042719561606645584, -0.00458438228815794, -0.06557834148406982, -0.040874190628528595, 0.04413905367255211, 0.02360423468053341, 0.015267866663634777, -0.01300546620041132, 0.026793191209435463, 0.012789685279130936, 0.0034649567678570747, -0.003586457809433341, -0.0620373971760273, 0.038661982864141464, -0.023205813020467758, 0.05102531239390373, -0.006212992127984762, -0.03777278587222099, -0.006830809637904167, -0.05112774297595024, -0.042765285819768906, -0.006845856551080942, 0.04423981532454491, -0.0008157630800269544, -0.028778761625289917, -0.022347429767251015, 0.014083093032240868, -0.012957822531461716, 0.07804374396800995, 0.01909147948026657, -0.01187114231288433, 0.02784312702715397, 0.02705405466258526, -0.04658326506614685, -0.043656568974256516, -0.04500465467572212, 0.003257242264226079, -0.002065052045509219, -0.06679496169090271, 0.06429452449083328, 0.02890372835099697, -0.06593205034732819, 0.03076978027820587, -0.029985742643475533, 0.040902309119701385, -0.07490269839763641, -0.04995715990662575, -0.056245021522045135, 0.035437434911727905, -0.0028105347882956266, -0.027117028832435608, -0.02843428961932659, -0.004572308622300625, 0.017848288640379906, 0.01229445356875658, -0.018146654590964317, 0.061276644468307495, 0.004832553677260876, 0.031364262104034424, -0.056703194975852966, -0.02427959442138672, 0.014234407804906368, -0.0349029041826725, -0.01014956645667553, 0.02505372278392315, -0.005271155387163162, 0.012515452690422535, 0.01586313359439373, 0.06334695219993591, -0.032969340682029724, 0.0735621303319931, -0.05129227787256241, -0.02882046066224575, -0.032795656472444534, -0.08707896620035172, -0.010604494251310825, 0.053593963384628296, 0.009555714204907417, 0.03470461443066597, -0.032828591763973236, 0.00448862137272954, 0.04063249006867409, 0.006594914942979813, -0.014868686906993389, -0.08065327256917953, 0.060084268450737, -0.07581385970115662, -0.023351389914751053, -0.00974965188652277, 0.00211872230283916, -0.0216982364654541, -0.03773552179336548, 0.04855813458561897, 0.030022798106074333, 0.038360387086868286, 0.024736521765589714, 0.001112435245886445, 0.02158612199127674, -0.05332722142338753, -0.02881050668656826, -0.002882159547880292, -0.05690964683890343, 0.016378294676542282, 0.011116663925349712, 0.013502257876098156, -0.011993447318673134, -0.009495585225522518, -0.014316282235085964, 0.015117776580154896, 0.051793232560157776, 0.032159510999917984, 0.04507105052471161, 0.00011630098742898554, -0.029009239748120308, -0.04394335299730301, -0.007342258468270302, -0.05419836565852165, 0.0024274419993162155, 0.029288601130247116, -0.08065355569124222, 0.01484703179448843, 0.009988038800656796, 0.00018450332572683692, -0.009364362806081772, -0.0474691279232502, -0.029351497069001198, -0.013192852959036827, 0.03732161596417427, -0.01703721284866333, 0.018402811139822006, 0.010185529477894306, -0.04527180641889572, -0.06067647039890289, 0.0507686547935009, -0.04758310690522194, 0.0016258861869573593, -0.007237971294671297, 0.037834249436855316, 0.02703181281685829, 0.043564748018980026, -0.004157738294452429, 0.03653111308813095, -0.0072804661467671394, 0.007346630096435547, 0.048706311732530594, 0.007324699312448502, -0.09958872944116592, -0.004309001378715038, 0.049643293023109436, 0.016392605379223824, -0.01690579764544964, -0.03582317754626274, -0.052355874329805374, 0.0014655125560238957, 0.015888389199972153, 0.037437282502651215, 0.0811915248632431, 0.0008586840122006834, 0.0010598018998280168, -0.03626817464828491, 0.0132756307721138, 0.013836061581969261, -0.03991774469614029, 0.04449738189578056, -0.031907957047224045, -0.015958184376358986, 0.061330974102020264, -0.07336493581533432, 0.02196149341762066, 0.0005197791615501046, 0.03012193739414215, 0.04197783023118973, 0.031589776277542114, 0.027114450931549072, -0.06160359084606171, 0.02283298783004284, -0.004556718748062849, -0.015296174213290215, -0.07725819200277328, -0.04481353238224983, 0.05211145803332329, 0.022090915590524673, -0.035247914493083954, -0.04329036921262741, 0.03889292851090431, -0.016207443550229073, 0.027371767908334732, 0.0005519631667993963, -0.05524776875972748, -0.003289168933406472, 0.017952341586351395, 0.0333390012383461, 0.006155875977128744, 0.01214069128036499, 0.009011507965624332, 0.008160006254911423, -0.015066338703036308, 0.0199313722550869, 0.013409075327217579, 0.0432807020843029, 0.02408747747540474, -0.06623798608779907, 0.015727056190371513, 0.013807253912091255, 0.00793516170233488, -0.04757346957921982, 0.007140501402318478, -0.015992725268006325, -0.050931043922901154, 0.03679885342717171, -0.019911589100956917, -0.00009783410496311262, 0.015932928770780563, 0.0014454115880653262, -0.02611175738275051, -0.004974927753210068, 0.022806670516729355, 0.04207531735301018, 0.011615555733442307, 0.014230532571673393, -0.004095241893082857, -0.023193923756480217, -0.02596926875412464, -0.03481154143810272, 0.0015737515641376376, 0.025627316907048225, 0.003920806106179953, -0.016714051365852356, -0.03644707426428795, -0.048457589000463486, -0.07447549700737, 0.02825971692800522, 0.011364373378455639, 0.007439804263412952, -0.007388778030872345, -0.06870618462562561, -0.04208569601178169, -0.047423116862773895, 0.025255665183067322, -0.011874029412865639, -0.031016966328024864, -0.007353220600634813, -0.03143221512436867, 0.0018168350216001272, -0.018694376572966576, -0.01971123367547989, 0.014027214609086514, -0.05864643305540085, -0.05177786946296692, 0.05409825220704079, 0.027272071689367294, 0.0002251470141345635, 0.0508887879550457, 0.018630430102348328, -0.022614920511841774, -0.07163843512535095, 0.02010253071784973, -0.007150142919272184, 0.02540084719657898, -0.03164650499820709, -0.04846377298235893, 0.03038671985268593, -0.043181754648685455, -0.04180603846907616, -0.008753901347517967, 0.008524862118065357 ]
<p>My memory is fuzzy on the advantages and disadvantages of various methods for detrending time-series data. I'm looking for a succinct summary of why and when one should or should not use the following:</p> <ul> <li>Differenced data</li> <li>Log-differenced data</li> <li>Error term, after regressing on <em>only</em> a linear or polynomial time series (e.g., 0,1,2,3,...,t)</li> </ul>
g74321
[ 0.07006824761629105, 0.007078082766383886, -0.011857978068292141, -0.016633469611406326, 0.014993872493505478, -0.034376904368400574, 0.03985339775681496, -0.0000036567441838997183, -0.06286551058292389, -0.023671800270676613, -0.03274216502904892, 0.039961833506822586, 0.056507788598537445, -0.01594819501042366, -0.01571880653500557, -0.017560040578246117, -0.0003292319306638092, 0.01690574549138546, -0.018664244562387466, 0.027387261390686035, 0.0008601457811892033, 0.09290050715208054, -0.010719356127083302, 0.007517235353589058, 0.0031681049149483442, -0.005551610141992569, -0.011297352612018585, -0.001899915630929172, -0.04756580665707588, 0.05620779097080231, 0.07800084352493286, -0.03737066686153412, 0.001154788420535624, -0.03433734551072121, 0.014311165548861027, 0.01392484549432993, 0.01231653243303299, 0.0481296069920063, 0.05324546992778778, 0.0030699551571160555, 0.06330037117004395, -0.04103923961520195, 0.034338947385549545, 0.05171333998441696, 0.003164766589179635, -0.0434940904378891, -0.03543613478541374, -0.025611579418182373, 0.023433510214090347, 0.03734167292714119, 0.024909915402531624, 0.02830861322581768, 0.007904205471277237, -0.006188805215060711, 0.01889851875603199, -0.049334071576595306, -0.021662501618266106, 0.04054475575685501, 0.02586248517036438, -0.04255834221839905, 0.014656583778560162, -0.06642099469900131, -0.03180687129497528, -0.0389561764895916, 0.010135541670024395, -0.0020873802714049816, -0.047751426696777344, -0.00680704927071929, -0.015858875587582588, -0.006167574319988489, 0.023170294240117073, -0.02244536578655243, -0.04238196834921837, 0.002488431055098772, -0.014324448071420193, -0.008252598345279694, -0.011544623412191868, -0.016189182177186012, 0.06178005039691925, 0.03349356725811958, -0.06496264040470123, 0.023933423683047295, -0.013843865133821964, -0.01809387095272541, 0.015433124266564846, 0.03716626018285751, -0.00747076328843832, -0.007045540027320385, 0.015350984409451485, 0.029711244627833366, -0.03279835730791092, -0.01198240090161562, 0.07580811530351639, 0.02337096817791462, -0.03988446295261383, 0.005726336035877466, -0.046707648783922195, -0.024424325674772263, 0.0489606074988842, 0.026020057499408722, 0.000296813523164019, 0.015993859618902206, -0.020167332142591476, 0.0027169156819581985, -0.04428790509700775, 0.001360938884317875, -0.007299673277884722, -0.03934408724308014, -0.049742985516786575, -0.013216696679592133, -0.0294493455439806, 0.060187745839357376, -0.02796146273612976, -0.013416648842394352, 0.014866907149553299, 0.029379038140177727, 0.05023777112364769, -0.03778969869017601, -0.031729549169540405, -0.017129959538578987, -0.0629764273762703, -0.05933897942304611, 0.02815960720181465, 0.06415445357561111, 0.02543026953935623, 0.005762043874710798, 0.011757178232073784, 0.03662317991256714, 0.04704137146472931, 0.014766755513846874, -0.03692123666405678, -0.026821646839380264, -0.03649188578128815, 0.033013030886650085, 0.010089908726513386, 0.02112177573144436, -0.022696811705827713, -0.011938244104385376, -0.0220742579549551, 0.03149053826928139, 0.032560739666223526, -0.038653671741485596, -0.012393545359373093, -0.05690137296915054, 0.003818143391981721, 0.031930793076753616, -0.03951840102672577, 0.03590018302202225, 0.05147090554237366, 0.06622897833585739, 0.03167854622006416, 0.025287089869379997, -0.021374501287937164, 0.00846017338335514, 0.0039503066800534725, 0.013153417967259884, 0.02368929609656334, -0.016393864527344704, 0.004343562293797731, 0.04813529551029205, -0.01960643380880356, -0.0476522222161293, 0.018061235547065735, 0.038116857409477234, 0.025511261075735092, -0.012261605821549892, -0.029036007821559906, 0.018741436302661896, -0.008624420501291752, -0.035242922604084015, 0.009819351136684418, 0.008209485560655594, 0.02050948515534401, -0.03252657875418663, 0.029992174357175827, 0.07488635927438736, 0.026405494660139084, -0.04663853719830513, 0.02206544205546379, 0.0314830020070076, 0.02322842925786972, 0.014493677765130997, -0.038519322872161865, 0.008539450354874134, 0.009362850338220596, -0.032630886882543564, -0.004840321838855743, -0.007259126286953688, -0.06673581153154373, 0.035516634583473206, -0.050586387515068054, -0.02187778614461422, -0.03175452724099159, 0.009137453511357307, -0.06209314614534378, 0.004011196084320545, 0.02372795343399048, 0.04197118431329727, -0.052526623010635376, 0.045690376311540604, -0.011583675630390644, -0.023380810394883156, -0.029669828712940216, -0.016647063195705414, -0.07598153501749039, -0.03582160547375679, -0.019335253164172173, 0.0014508874155580997, -0.04246808961033821, 0.001412992482073605, 0.031075622886419296, 0.055389195680618286, -0.003793767187744379, 0.014102890156209469, -0.05058155208826065, -0.03847912326455116, 0.02109568752348423, 0.04749740660190582, 0.04772055521607399, 0.008253034204244614, -0.06828445196151733, 0.013287468813359737, 0.038161154836416245, -0.03898029401898384, 0.011799759231507778, 0.01268535852432251, 0.0692557841539383, -0.0009192266152240336, -0.030401071533560753, -0.016794908791780472, -0.07408050447702408, -0.08345010876655579, -0.037773121148347855, -0.05829118937253952, 0.03776396065950394, 0.00004889119736617431, -0.010621227324008942, 0.0032862110529094934, 0.04970184713602066, 0.04819149151444435, 0.034097280353307724, -0.005293902009725571, -0.02283387817442417, 0.02655654400587082, -0.01581498421728611, -0.02387288585305214, 0.05899697169661522, 0.011242236010730267, 0.031024497002363205, -0.060972437262535095, -0.023124059662222862, 0.038822874426841736, 0.004471093416213989, -0.016605563461780548, 0.0008049414027482271, -0.05316736549139023, -0.03654203936457634, -0.015039877966046333, -0.001566711231134832, 0.07908084243535995, -0.00618017790839076, 0.020882846787571907, 0.02083580754697323, 0.011316162534058094, -0.006656371522694826, -0.05244262516498566, 0.05144685506820679, 0.043130286037921906, 0.04281621798872948, -0.012921477667987347, -0.06361210346221924, -0.005952568259090185, 0.06289162486791611, 0.060811687260866165, 0.02083977870643139, 0.04364878684282303, -0.011658699251711369, 0.029614517465233803, 0.0658264234662056, 0.012491396628320217, 0.014909445308148861, -0.09030688554048538, -0.04450570419430733, 0.03215063735842705, 0.06114961579442024, -0.05949321761727333, 0.044346075505018234, 0.033978238701820374, 0.002648002468049526, -0.0536358542740345, -0.08336741477251053, 0.007916552014648914, -0.006221376825124025, -0.019331028684973717, -0.010812117718160152, -0.013071557506918907, -0.0505453422665596, -0.024437949061393738, 0.03441411256790161, -0.0025102091021835804, -0.0063695767894387245, -0.0018906346522271633, -0.007063018623739481, -0.00514667434617877, -0.00031205188133753836, -0.014922698959708214, -0.00638075964525342, 0.005527556873857975, 0.010498452931642532, 0.000922418141271919, -0.028069622814655304, -0.0030188937671482563, 0.053760141134262085, -0.04201902076601982, 0.020295478403568268, -0.009708257392048836, 0.0552697516977787, -0.013640881516039371, 0.02882375568151474, 0.015248585492372513, 0.01376603078097105, -0.05987706035375595, 0.010557410307228565, 0.012328722514212132, -0.037725094705820084, 0.023162594065070152, -0.025171414017677307, 0.03930669650435448, -0.06170279532670975, 0.033064890652894974, -0.0036097331903874874, 0.00042605475755408406, 0.022266102954745293, -0.005056893453001976, 0.009251195937395096, -0.0525878481566906, -0.0220365971326828, -0.03580877557396889, 0.0060170055367052555, 0.02039782702922821, -0.05419882759451866, 0.055868763476610184, 0.00596562260761857, 0.01102454774081707, 0.04591745510697365, -0.053429946303367615, -0.02371968887746334, 0.02057144232094288, 0.0036072900984436274, -0.0042882803827524185, 0.045384448021650314, -0.024066274985671043, 0.03804804012179375, 0.016473054885864258, 0.005160699598491192, -0.027916686609387398, 0.05318307876586914, 0.03658246994018555, 0.05526014789938927, -0.02208949625492096, 0.0344020277261734, 0.0022566094994544983, -0.02374403178691864, -0.01003765407949686, -0.023395629599690437, -0.027440663427114487, 0.07311449944972992, 0.07061219960451126, -0.013805203139781952, -0.06531275808811188, 0.02651159279048443, 0.06153474375605583, 0.05316978320479393, -0.042993009090423584, -0.022713692858815193, -0.00976792722940445, -0.017575686797499657, 0.02074572630226612, 0.009880182333290577, 0.03481582552194595, 0.010602652095258236, 0.004466833546757698, -0.020290270447731018, 0.015070976689457893, -0.016232527792453766, -0.06829822808504105, 0.0053468020632863045, 0.009219535626471043, -0.04237782582640648, -0.003724911715835333, 0.0022079874761402607, 0.041372355073690414, -0.03589048236608505, 0.00941239669919014, 0.01900709792971611, -0.04233963415026665, 0.023088153451681137, 0.09858976304531097, -0.03295689821243286, 0.05281206965446472, -0.011095386929810047, 0.018789153546094894, 0.02629585564136505, 0.05989477410912514, -0.014392663724720478, -0.01344632264226675, 0.0432349257171154, -0.056875426322221756, -0.044482626020908356, -0.02127278596162796, -0.06816656142473221, -0.020571846514940262, -0.06881619989871979, -0.013219403102993965, 0.009451436810195446, -0.047061555087566376, 0.0397968553006649, -0.0006088864174671471, 0.010819215327501297, -0.009768752381205559, 0.06849303841590881, 0.033086907118558884, -0.11499074846506119, -0.0047696735709905624, -0.01259161438792944, 0.01649906300008297, -0.03246856480836868, 0.027233125641942024, -0.012340210378170013, -0.03334854170680046, 0.020121607929468155, 0.018256833776831627, -0.0809921994805336, 0.030510948970913887, 0.03158537298440933, -0.014868230558931828, 0.031000416725873947, 0.09876564145088196, -0.03656425699591637, -0.02942701056599617, 0.006819771137088537, -0.037273406982421875, 0.008552676998078823, 0.00664016418159008, -0.015612280927598476, 0.05978536978363991, 0.0076332357712090015, -0.027216672897338867, 0.006187424063682556, 0.060285598039627075, -0.015992527827620506, 0.08547908812761307, 0.030403712764382362, 0.017682194709777832, 0.024874242022633553, 0.0076823667623102665, 0.03404897078871727, 0.011365287005901337, -0.011992773972451687, 0.06507160514593124, 0.008120046928524971, -0.03189452737569809, -0.06440354138612747, -0.04830178618431091, -0.042142078280448914, 0.04289970546960831, -0.0806882455945015, -0.03160714730620384, 0.005110340192914009, 0.02742370031774044, 0.010334025137126446, 0.027534132823348045, 0.04919646680355072, -0.005948779173195362, 0.00954505242407322, 0.03019685111939907, 0.00558988144621253, -0.031520456075668335, -0.003728996030986309, -0.02391277253627777, -0.018204379826784134, -0.017570465803146362, 0.034071702510118484, 0.04333564266562462, 0.013869968242943287, 0.03543999418616295, -0.0068460553884506226, -0.08315525203943253, 0.04671362414956093, 0.04310852661728859, 0.01060523372143507, 0.07614699751138687, 0.05406473949551582, -0.0101917190477252, -0.028440991416573524, -0.004822317976504564, -0.017310990020632744, 0.01110475417226553, -0.030135419219732285, -0.02731999009847641, -0.05478079244494438, 0.040725450962781906, 0.0014047323493286967, 0.010300480760633945, 0.04813640937209129, -0.02350650541484356, 0.11567429453134537, -0.0416388139128685, -0.0528181828558445, -0.023425886407494545, 0.04569241404533386, -0.023693080991506577, 0.026999294757843018, -0.009701295755803585, -0.038561608642339706, -0.00681162578985095, 0.022782932966947556, 0.05047169700264931, -0.003578675677999854, -0.040735963732004166, -0.003229038789868355, 0.060831375420093536, 0.08149775862693787, -0.015264518558979034, -0.00028060973272658885, -0.08783669769763947, -0.027884073555469513, -0.031536515802145004, -0.042627960443496704, -0.04342649132013321, 0.024549346417188644, 0.022384030744433403, 0.03560804948210716, -0.0019310334464535117, -0.012786343693733215, 0.01016941200941801, 0.014026963151991367, 0.02846069075167179, 0.01766013726592064, -0.02813997119665146, -0.06325528025627136, -0.0023000615183264017, -0.013963417150080204, 0.008457710966467857, -0.04183002561330795, -0.05700979381799698, -0.004906735382974148, 0.007940555922687054, -0.01830148883163929, -0.03606399893760681, -0.0004382115148473531, -0.05326597020030022, -0.00795894954353571, -0.07461659610271454, -0.03507506102323532, -0.013156663626432419, -0.00610903138294816, 0.009667590260505676, -0.07835344225168228, 0.0540359802544117, -0.034426651895046234, -0.05508020892739296, 0.030807698145508766, 0.02665976621210575, 0.03665798157453537, -0.05078477784991264, -0.008509031496942043, 0.022222250699996948, -0.029353277757763863, -0.010680817998945713, 0.04551355913281441, -0.017686963081359863, -0.019521012902259827, 0.06015570089221001, 0.02224641852080822, -0.017779849469661713, 0.04529973864555359, -0.03885336220264435, 0.02775278501212597, -0.026431430131196976, -0.038431230932474136, -0.06909125298261642, -0.007779144216328859, -0.0009362149285152555, -0.03516341745853424, -0.01414027065038681, 0.02006334252655506, 0.04298520088195801, 0.026490842923521996, 0.01262632291764021, 0.0020299998577684164, 0.004939716774970293, 0.054236482828855515, -0.006135297939181328, 0.026141414418816566, 0.01793915592133999, -0.015520434826612473, 0.027940671890974045, 0.05312728136777878, -0.04706071317195892, -0.028670527040958405, 0.008764531463384628, -0.021706247702240944, 0.019444122910499573, 0.0004828641831409186, 0.02977006882429123, 0.01664445921778679, 0.034105025231838226, 0.05148744583129883, -0.040515005588531494, 0.016511449590325356, 0.007835384458303452, 0.00023268359655048698, 0.025839634239673615, -0.053043924272060394, -0.026286255568265915, -0.046582140028476715, 0.045594315975904465, -0.026628874242305756, -0.037890754640102386, 0.026224622502923012, -0.040136389434337616, 0.02277972549200058, 0.008065282367169857, 0.03689313679933548, 0.07892121374607086, -0.034203097224235535, 0.04747912287712097, -0.009769832715392113, 0.008212029933929443, 0.09301424026489258, 0.004261672496795654, -0.04414304345846176, -0.018978863954544067, -0.05869065970182419, 0.0365472212433815, -0.07306236028671265, 0.053760968148708344, -0.0266012754291296, 0.006757861934602261, -0.0340203195810318, 0.07328866422176361, 0.011473014019429684, -0.016356658190488815, -0.015419071540236473, 0.08742105960845947, 0.004578745923936367, -0.0017912788316607475, 0.006381924729794264, -0.03149862959980965, -0.006627259310334921, 0.01435576006770134, -0.03730548545718193, 0.011336748488247395, 0.001968388445675373, 0.028280990198254585, -0.025059528648853302, 0.0440608412027359, 0.05473962053656578, 0.017329873517155647, -0.05486816167831421, -0.026591286063194275, -0.04368891939520836, -0.04198294132947922, -0.01895439438521862, 0.03709083050489426, -0.03365616500377655, -0.0706062838435173, 0.06444418430328369, -0.00614368449896574, 0.024609532207250595, -0.026476141065359116, 0.04532694071531296, 0.011511542834341526, 0.039048608392477036, 0.08063880354166031, -0.0419759638607502, -0.0021487625781446695, -0.08183778077363968, -0.012295317836105824, -0.07368586212396622, -0.03578295558691025, -0.0036193577107042074, -0.09764385968446732, -0.013998636044561863, 0.06504222005605698, -0.029307836666703224, -0.030519362539052963, 0.0042276643216609955, -0.05512024462223053, -0.06041525676846504, 0.011945403181016445, -0.01207046676427126, 0.004390777088701725, -0.052446771413087845, -0.03469257801771164, -0.022977758198976517, 0.021541640162467957, 0.031216228380799294, 0.058794256299734116, 0.013498809188604355, 0.024899596348404884, -0.03157877177000046, 0.02177278883755207, 0.007283635903149843, -0.003735942067578435, -0.013039535842835903, -0.004841608460992575, -0.002861170331016183, -0.003545049112290144, -0.031363580375909805, 0.02102116495370865, -0.03084324114024639, -0.00966633576899767, 0.008642660453915596, -0.014497757889330387, 0.03444942459464073, -0.054975491017103195, -0.0200931616127491, -0.03195897117257118, 0.024812255054712296, 0.04840545728802681, 0.010232776403427124, -0.04535677656531334, 0.018764205276966095, -0.027070539072155952, -0.03395499661564827, 0.00788840465247631, -0.0011729922844097018, 0.03254131227731705, 0.000823661161120981, -0.02602914348244667, 0.012075468897819519, 0.02630438655614853, 0.0005425038980320096, 0.019592927768826485, -0.008860166184604168, -0.007722000125795603, 0.0016160426894202828, 0.01898503117263317, -0.028164122253656387, 0.05876896530389786, -0.0451928973197937, -0.0040933419950306416, 0.0002851502504199743, -0.012139366939663887, -0.00021862407447770238, 0.012925701215863228, 0.015466907992959023, -0.07896842062473297, -0.050692521035671234, 0.01248048897832632, -0.08072949200868607, 0.04902629181742668, 0.01779470220208168, 0.02439594827592373, 0.03492671996355057, -0.001013083616271615, 0.05500199645757675, -0.01915014162659645, -0.01756511814892292, 0.012424114160239697, -0.031751587986946106, 0.07146701216697693, -0.023777702823281288, 0.023684445768594742, -0.0029610537458211184, 0.023407667875289917 ]
<p>What is the best way of going about dealing with few instances in support vector regression, e.g. only approximately 40? Also - is there an optimal way of dealing with outliers in this case of few instances?</p>
g37160
[ 0.015554175712168217, 0.031733207404613495, 0.00044359112507663667, -0.009259985759854317, -0.06472095847129822, -0.03332960605621338, 0.028314225375652313, 0.0285350289195776, -0.03369758650660515, -0.016507748514413834, 0.014573070220649242, 0.006385105196386576, 0.010078714229166508, 0.043429095298051834, -0.012989933602511883, -0.0028410893864929676, 0.050201416015625, -0.01377403549849987, -0.01743938773870468, 0.024094359949231148, 0.000017640892110648565, -0.006898195017129183, 0.014671393670141697, 0.015168567188084126, -0.016585823148489, 0.05200200900435448, -0.08763998001813889, 0.05402344465255737, 0.038620710372924805, 0.019976649433374405, -0.0016243340214714408, 0.04890595003962517, 0.022381935268640518, -0.01104278676211834, -0.03342000022530556, 0.00047671733773313463, 0.05312179774045944, 0.00002100408892147243, -0.01944071799516678, -0.002827476477250457, 0.01648709364235401, -0.026514185592532158, 0.04646828770637512, 0.010617217049002647, 0.014956146478652954, -0.01915144920349121, 0.02326272241771221, 0.02497285045683384, 0.014705193229019642, -0.015961850062012672, -0.013283825479447842, -0.03420139104127884, -0.027460061013698578, 0.02880672924220562, 0.029411030933260918, 0.020295947790145874, -0.06103379651904106, 0.024232560768723488, -0.0007589463493786752, 0.07543507218360901, 0.02334211766719818, -0.03178361803293228, -0.054221976548433304, 0.0030009583570063114, -0.030829783529043198, 0.06486499309539795, -0.026085279881954193, -0.06702546030282974, 0.04093927517533302, 0.01326317060738802, 0.00760881369933486, 0.0006135668372735381, 0.011449172161519527, -0.04007929936051369, -0.06885576248168945, -0.024043168872594833, -0.04452509060502052, 0.03694610670208931, -0.005238980986177921, 0.06382793188095093, -0.027158459648489952, 0.011575972661376, 0.0224459171295166, -0.0045218560844659805, -0.010315600782632828, 0.036546338349580765, -0.00706125982105732, 0.04887758567929268, 0.05346899479627609, -0.0224587582051754, -0.004602606408298016, -0.018591970205307007, 0.01954035647213459, -0.03468902036547661, -0.018500642850995064, 0.0013681880664080381, -0.06328056752681732, 0.027980322018265724, -0.028991803526878357, 0.004885123111307621, 0.03169548511505127, 0.037268370389938354, -0.056834202259778976, -0.02781338430941105, -0.07211434096097946, -0.007043298799544573, 0.03568653762340546, 0.06022035330533981, 0.028983397409319878, 0.003780088620260358, -0.038196515291929245, 0.015542511828243732, -0.061767321079969406, -0.017628343775868416, -0.06561390310525894, 0.012023892253637314, 0.0564843975007534, 0.028190815821290016, 0.020134439691901207, -0.04489734768867493, -0.019217656925320625, -0.03195890411734581, 0.010636060498654842, 0.0589839331805706, 0.03267785906791687, 0.012351220473647118, -0.062256451696157455, 0.06896080076694489, 0.02682000771164894, 0.002845039591193199, -0.04896234720945358, -0.03076040744781494, -0.03758876398205757, 0.024121498689055443, 0.04256070777773857, 0.04410099238157272, -0.018257124349474907, 0.011822349391877651, -0.004286902491003275, 0.047264836728572845, -0.02504432015120983, 0.04366913065314293, -0.015859708189964294, -0.03782323747873306, -0.00463087297976017, -0.005411926656961441, -0.05047149211168289, 0.026342002674937248, -0.06167855113744736, -0.036965806037187576, -0.031547438353300095, -0.0264626182615757, -0.050668686628341675, -0.001154096331447363, -0.08041038364171982, -0.009037845768034458, 0.02867068536579609, -0.029711708426475525, 0.026259025558829308, -0.0017194915562868118, 0.011814085766673088, -0.0436980240046978, 0.0071181259118020535, -0.021717257797718048, -0.03278868645429611, 0.06135929003357887, -0.031763702630996704, -0.01675623469054699, -0.05129174888134003, -0.026271292939782143, 0.00629542488604784, -0.050881076604127884, 0.0350969098508358, 0.015044193714857101, 0.0615244023501873, 0.01773967780172825, 0.05415909364819527, -0.042797695845365524, -0.0010871923295781016, 0.05851062014698982, 0.037796422839164734, 0.0007481769425794482, -0.006887542083859444, -0.003777265315875411, -0.003600955940783024, -0.02966049127280712, 0.0308888740837574, 0.0005987569456920028, -0.016503673046827316, -0.007221189793199301, 0.018660588189959526, -0.03970670327544212, -0.03797653317451477, -0.005378793925046921, -0.018457911908626556, 0.007697703782469034, 0.013629896566271782, -0.04546673595905304, -0.07220198214054108, -0.03774585202336311, 0.014398105442523956, 0.0037513128481805325, -0.04533575102686882, 0.07967979460954666, -0.006267881952226162, -0.010390084236860275, -0.014007728546857834, -0.021356644108891487, -0.011502119712531567, -0.03090381808578968, 0.053784117102622986, -0.008297616615891457, -0.04128947854042053, 0.05253257974982262, -0.07676660269498825, 0.01896491087973118, 0.012141813524067402, -0.007676010485738516, 0.07384877651929855, 0.012993226759135723, 0.01654752902686596, 0.0011700473260134459, 0.005283196922391653, 0.02422807551920414, 0.01235857605934143, 0.04880119115114212, -0.01884535700082779, -0.007847212255001068, 0.02564811334013939, -0.002116640331223607, -0.0879269689321518, -0.03188427910208702, 0.024766312912106514, -0.09431743621826172, 0.02389581687748432, -0.03255138173699379, 0.006067348178476095, 0.015046755783259869, -0.09209538251161575, 0.005488724447786808, 0.01323728822171688, 0.035045213997364044, -0.015489558689296246, 0.028528816998004913, -0.023460671305656433, -0.023476118221879005, -0.07042998820543289, -0.05674465745687485, 0.02730480581521988, 0.019534647464752197, -0.0526396706700325, 0.04878338798880577, 0.055002305656671524, -0.04574154317378998, -0.025752374902367592, -0.005709086544811726, -0.016940690577030182, 0.05169347673654556, 0.027167130261659622, -0.043143872171640396, -0.0038945262786000967, 0.03656680881977081, 0.05289188772439957, -0.02010098658502102, 0.018949203193187714, -0.016031857579946518, 0.023048043251037598, 0.0011098202085122466, 0.024409661069512367, 0.04981178417801857, 0.003614033805206418, -0.0028677755035459995, -0.05246613174676895, 0.0625774934887886, 0.05485358089208603, 0.05858688801527023, -0.038392324000597, -0.0018448038026690483, 0.0443415492773056, 0.0031553725712001324, 0.07494454085826874, -0.07393675297498703, -0.00858454592525959, -0.04157127067446709, 0.07146711647510529, 0.016618089750409126, 0.03590506687760353, -0.023310262709856033, 0.05773032829165459, 0.03649194538593292, 0.0082187969237566, -0.01295470166951418, 0.029931437224149704, -0.04183114692568779, -0.034311823546886444, -0.007749739568680525, -0.04040943458676338, -0.04529111832380295, 0.02480766363441944, 0.021318605169653893, 0.016663219779729843, 0.010396013036370277, -0.013774428516626358, -0.0036777150817215443, -0.04412676393985748, -0.02714797481894493, -0.03938767686486244, 0.0056016575545072556, 0.02500132843852043, -0.045576613396406174, -0.00019409882952459157, -0.026046093553304672, -0.031806811690330505, 0.03792320191860199, -0.021345147863030434, -0.039539601653814316, -0.031137816607952118, 0.017010660842061043, -0.005031542852520943, -0.02032393030822277, -0.009772916324436665, -0.025749338790774345, 0.08628471940755844, 0.03779628127813339, -0.016489194706082344, 0.06551767140626907, -0.015276268124580383, 0.035025909543037415, -0.09536579251289368, 0.0446070171892643, 0.05530421435832977, -0.011758922599256039, 0.004791212268173695, -0.0055590346455574036, 0.026221048086881638, 0.004556781612336636, -0.0017921148100867867, -0.07451573014259338, -0.027207376435399055, 0.029140222817659378, 0.009721276350319386, -0.01977539248764515, -0.012693286873400211, -0.01805177889764309, -0.03862990066409111, 0.02741595171391964, 0.04022308066487312, 0.06602802127599716, 0.010565537959337234, -0.015025281347334385, -0.0567999929189682, -0.030593398958444595, -0.023341117426753044, 0.014473581686615944, 0.005020590033382177, 0.0001619869435671717, -0.029566137120127678, -0.006349959876388311, 0.03454667702317238, -0.049462415277957916, 0.023570096120238304, -0.04112289845943451, 0.015164196491241455, 0.029302608221769333, -0.008201968856155872, -0.008148684166371822, -0.0016847067745402455, 0.07271808385848999, 0.0024725834373384714, -0.019122865051031113, 0.04549369215965271, -0.020890017971396446, -0.0065689668990671635, -0.06308981031179428, -0.004086667206138372, -0.01848381944000721, 0.018167397007346153, 0.002471233019605279, 0.026593422517180443, 0.035775404423475266, 0.0385034941136837, 0.006825816817581654, -0.01766023598611355, -0.08848477154970169, -0.005341437645256519, 0.04623186215758324, 0.013285793364048004, -0.03384510055184364, -0.029180023819208145, 0.02844991721212864, -0.009639108553528786, 0.035206202417612076, -0.06215294823050499, 0.07198112457990646, 0.04732292890548706, -0.04313729703426361, 0.048488304018974304, -0.012201097793877125, 0.001846548169851303, 0.06267773360013962, -0.004962395876646042, 0.039142392575740814, 0.024643544107675552, 0.03502527251839638, -0.015007498674094677, -0.015367376618087292, -0.03648988530039787, 0.011035628616809845, -0.0681161880493164, 0.030741948634386063, -0.0503554530441761, -0.0025872543919831514, 0.014097858220338821, -0.06784696877002716, 0.020377350971102715, 0.02244197204709053, 0.08095534145832062, -0.02481359988451004, -0.004193887580186129, 0.03676127642393112, 0.0009629420819692314, 0.0003840973658952862, -0.04708791524171829, -0.01706433668732643, -0.00663058552891016, -0.008758386597037315, -0.009581499733030796, 0.02437901683151722, 0.012414931319653988, -0.00987462792545557, 0.06447089463472366, 0.014641286805272102, -0.01783652976155281, 0.02321196161210537, 0.03716375678777695, -0.02648182027041912, 0.02468585968017578, -0.021257180720567703, -0.004516351968050003, -0.012972723692655563, 0.011349557898938656, 0.0011019405210390687, -0.019084224477410316, 0.007575978524982929, -0.048444218933582306, 0.026466066017746925, 0.023378167301416397, -0.039339330047369, -0.009926685132086277, 0.035064466297626495, -0.015561159700155258, 0.022535599768161774, -0.03881027176976204, -0.028836702927947044, 0.014458710327744484, 0.0051702396012842655, -0.03201392665505409, 0.07592922449111938, -0.007674522697925568, 0.01568262279033661, -0.008479099720716476, 0.0008871509344317019, -0.01122372131794691, -0.03915614262223244, 0.03668959438800812, -0.028393004089593887, -0.020461082458496094, -0.00202572881244123, 0.01719684712588787, -0.023591957986354828, 0.004361540079116821, 0.016204271465539932, 0.0029037760104984045, -0.018589269369840622, 0.008508842438459396, -0.009014259092509747, -0.037686556577682495, -0.0008239198941737413, 0.023754138499498367, 0.04272560402750969, 0.021917957812547684, -0.052159421145915985, 0.00016099773347377777, -0.010425607673823833, -0.01989334635436535, -0.05492103099822998, 0.036401357501745224, -0.09268834441900253, 0.026900948956608772, 0.022452354431152344, 0.00688225869089365, 0.02833102084696293, -0.017396947368979454, 0.05857545882463455, -0.01731889881193638, -0.022539371624588966, 0.020094342529773712, -0.034750502556562424, -0.015367064625024796, -0.039570581167936325, -0.028162041679024696, 0.025423748418688774, -0.013730253092944622, -0.047513481229543686, -0.0028584033716470003, -0.007698781788349152, 0.11187681555747986, -0.04616089165210724, 0.015676304697990417, 0.08473272621631622, 0.005513044074177742, -0.008770477958023548, 0.054225627332925797, -0.006788667291402817, 0.022182682529091835, -0.03794291615486145, -0.02284182980656624, 0.04374737665057182, 0.027644082903862, -0.022424211725592613, 0.1153651624917984, -0.02474171854555607, -0.06169774755835533, 0.04416922852396965, 0.026566438376903534, -0.08435776084661484, -0.05199393630027771, 0.010389244183897972, -0.034066375344991684, -0.01710979826748371, 0.04151293635368347, -0.028126167133450508, -0.055634841322898865, 0.0015552651602774858, 0.011850751005113125, 0.014196094125509262, 0.006230037193745375, 0.02557516098022461, 0.037249594926834106, 0.009876346215605736, -0.06341636925935745, 0.017758985981345177, -0.019602734595537186, -0.010247430764138699, -0.06045730412006378, -0.03517569229006767, 0.014670484699308872, 0.016858041286468506, 0.04176973178982735, 0.011992505751550198, -0.027209507301449776, 0.037567850202322006, -0.023221982643008232, 0.041817497462034225, 0.0021066523622721434, 0.014548931270837784, 0.06203054264187813, 0.00892715621739626, 0.024361906573176384, 0.05947563424706459, -0.03400053083896637, -0.055273350328207016, -0.014049443416297436, -0.026798618957400322, -0.07123730331659317, 0.03222125396132469, -0.06000882014632225, -0.056076839566230774, -0.03079463541507721, -0.006581732537597418, -0.014049040153622627, -0.061553481966257095, 0.07600633800029755, 0.044325679540634155, -0.018984736874699593, 0.011982379481196404, 0.06906008720397949, 0.02944612316787243, 0.016687514260411263, -0.0019750401843339205, -0.019021576270461082, 0.037613123655319214, 0.01216238085180521, 0.0196534413844347, -0.016593599691987038, 0.09575287252664566, -0.012780554592609406, -0.043326351791620255, 0.000250467739533633, -0.006667203735560179, 0.04614347964525223, 0.039138179272413254, 0.0031431224197149277, 0.0738593190908432, 0.008382625877857208, -0.01092196349054575, 0.05599018186330795, 0.03659423068165779, -0.061702001839876175, -0.03768483176827431, 0.0033228090032935143, -0.005789401941001415, 0.07387857884168625, -0.012553708627820015, -0.03263425827026367, -0.0026608894113451242, -0.04084819182753563, 0.02357535809278488, 0.015841178596019745, 0.041681330651044846, -0.017046907916665077, -0.012577724643051624, 0.009694118052721024, 0.10127641260623932, -0.007782801520079374, -0.03841536119580269, -0.054893963038921356, 0.012696439400315285, -0.00455651106312871, -0.017235754057765007, -0.02399856224656105, -0.07283312827348709, -0.022877348586916924, -0.020995013415813446, -0.027448594570159912, 0.05345911905169487, 0.014842637814581394, -0.05780595541000366, 0.045956358313560486, -0.0060279760509729385, -0.0035298827569931746, 0.036909352988004684, 0.013176449574530125, -0.009387410245835781, -0.06956201046705246, 0.055950429290533066, -0.07674336433410645, 0.020420821383595467, -0.055326443165540695, 0.03787142038345337, -0.00011404799442971125, 0.003155680373311043, -0.02245635725557804, 0.009811795316636562, 0.03536660224199295, 0.0011548921465873718, 0.04096294939517975, 0.10143536329269409, -0.023513581603765488, 0.0014255003770813346, 0.07936174422502518, -0.026455705985426903, -0.01323223952203989, -0.06127452477812767, -0.013922094367444515, 0.027431249618530273, 0.02568218670785427, 0.02173425257205963, 0.04498063027858734, 0.010865247808396816, 0.004506648983806372, 0.015844732522964478, -0.05424252524971962, -0.032243676483631134, 0.016403503715991974, 0.06531127542257309, -0.00016931502614170313, -0.02264518104493618, -0.0015921371523290873, -0.052189551293849945, -0.011158652603626251, -0.012995355762541294, -0.05042719841003418, 0.010596550069749355, 0.05674375593662262, 0.008372608572244644, -0.005515086930245161, 0.030726542696356773, -0.019766852259635925, 0.05527224764227867, -0.009547334164381027, -0.029895372688770294, 0.015926646068692207, 0.019050465896725655, 0.01759457029402256, 0.026062646880745888, -0.03699371963739395, 0.02296614833176136, 0.011956753209233284, -0.04876461997628212, -0.03955743834376335, -0.03732196241617203, 0.019869502633810043, -0.003129356075078249, 0.014142723754048347, 0.05407458171248436, -0.009354465641081333, -0.056325651705265045, 0.008410923182964325, 0.07708427309989929, 0.000462293071905151, 0.06341423839330673, 0.03919463977217674, -0.003475068835541606, 0.03969351202249527, 0.03514784947037697, -0.059428755193948746, -0.046895790845155716, 0.054374344646930695, -0.06540104001760483, -0.0022909215185791254, -0.004616104066371918, 0.0062094880267977715, -0.01480728480964899, 0.047055598348379135, -0.0010708268964663148, -0.03506102040410042, -0.015003228560090065, 0.022734859958291054, 0.00768424803391099, 0.001284030731767416, 0.009134793654084206, 0.019965536892414093, 0.046341001987457275, 0.020248664543032646, 0.012002619914710522, 0.03743863105773926, -0.01926518976688385, -0.004115428309887648, -0.014835738576948643, -0.0064849029295146465, -0.07824985682964325, -0.08469174802303314, 0.0750586986541748, 0.006671348586678505, -0.021871745586395264, 0.025188975036144257, -0.008956153877079487, -0.03358602151274681, 0.018956383690238, -0.009818357415497303, 0.012725508771836758, -0.04265589639544487, 0.03320440277457237, -0.015818605199456215, 0.05378494784235954, -0.0000019833689748338656, -0.04099259525537491, -0.027468528598546982, -0.031403038650751114, -0.07262594252824783, 0.032681919634342194, 0.00962162483483553, -0.0019790981896221638, -0.03827084228396416, 0.010057665407657623, 0.0503486730158329, 0.005025528371334076, -0.024128850549459457, 0.020223984494805336, 0.009726699441671371, 0.0006155840237624943, -0.05798330157995224, 0.012163311243057251, 0.01583707705140114, -0.005071512423455715, 0.010409788228571415, -0.07028656452894211 ]
<p>I have two models - one is including a categorical covariate as a fixed effect, the other includes it as a random effect:</p> <pre><code>require(nlme) set.seed(123) n &lt;- 100 k &lt;- 5 cat &lt;- as.factor(rep(1:k, n)) cat_i &lt;- 1:k # intercept per kategorie x &lt;- rep(1:n, each = k) sigma &lt;- 0.2 alpha &lt;- 0.001 y &lt;- cat_i[cat] + alpha * x + rnorm(n*k, 0, sigma) plot(x, y) m2 &lt;- lm(y ~ cat + x) summary(m2) m3 &lt;- lme(y ~ x, random = ~ 1|cat, na.action = na.omit) summary(m3) </code></pre> <p>As you can see, both models <code>m2</code> and <code>m3</code> produce exactly the same coefficient estimate for x (including SE). Also the residual standard error is the same. The same result is produced when I simulate some missing data:</p> <pre><code># simulate missing data y[c(1:(n/2), (n*k-n/2):(n*k))] &lt;- NA m2 &lt;- lm(y ~ cat + x) summary(m2) m3 &lt;- lme(y ~ x, random = ~ 1|cat, na.action = na.omit) summary(m3) </code></pre> <p>So can we say in general that adding effect as random will have the same impact on the other coefficients and the overall inference as adding it as fixed? If not, can you please provide a simple example (or change the provided one) when this fails?</p>
g74322
[ -0.02561940811574459, -0.04934913292527199, 0.0032548862509429455, -0.04021817445755005, 0.021957842633128166, 0.006616386119276285, 0.025716707110404968, 0.008046972565352917, -0.03687022998929024, 0.01667194254696369, -0.028702909126877785, 0.022207772359251976, 0.03990059718489647, 0.022576136514544487, -0.022759951651096344, 0.037249594926834106, 0.05814826488494873, -0.029633279889822006, -0.02882319502532482, 0.03881751745939255, -0.047296635806560516, -0.0011313892900943756, 0.005228579510003328, -0.023521726951003075, -0.005737404339015484, -0.05923717841506004, -0.010925945825874805, 0.02993316389620304, -0.10130678117275238, 0.0519842803478241, -0.0028453466948121786, 0.00424746610224247, 0.016697421669960022, -0.09309902042150497, -0.054807279258966446, 0.03894062712788582, 0.04908598214387894, 0.030291981995105743, 0.018824303522706032, -0.0026049555744975805, 0.006447304505854845, 0.05780232325196266, 0.018083730712532997, 0.05096110329031944, -0.05612170323729515, 0.0008958342368714511, 0.017931601032614708, -0.0010460307821631432, 0.024365823715925217, -0.010971293784677982, -0.008997677825391293, 0.001675357692874968, 0.010474908165633678, 0.0030088128987699747, 0.005574401468038559, 0.05887198820710182, 0.013476717285811901, -0.013342790305614471, 0.019839884713292122, 0.041842617094516754, 0.04166829586029053, 0.006682355888187885, -0.02217068336904049, -0.0017336418386548758, -0.027065306901931763, 0.03942057862877846, -0.023389780893921852, 0.06448664516210556, -0.03605463728308678, -0.06413716822862625, 0.00848933681845665, 0.03431325405836105, -0.023900045081973076, -0.044745009392499924, -0.02260495163500309, 0.013677257113158703, 0.009942562319338322, 0.023918410763144493, 0.00005677037552231923, 0.027996184304356575, -0.020228426903486252, -0.005395615007728338, 0.043514903634786606, 0.04771833121776581, 0.007773513440042734, 0.020280664786696434, -0.020582102239131927, -0.001972413854673505, -0.022100813686847687, 0.019801119342446327, 0.031331758946180344, -0.015309534966945648, 0.011482528410851955, 0.06579507887363434, 0.054919883608818054, -0.026399338617920876, -0.0631326287984848, 0.00012667241389863193, -0.029862364754080772, -0.0022716622333973646, -0.034045591950416565, 0.04248744621872902, 0.03166168928146362, -0.018698204308748245, -0.04745201766490936, -0.00810306891798973, 0.06492289900779724, -0.013413853943347931, -0.011208047159016132, -0.031595777720212936, -0.08309325575828552, 0.019428525120019913, -0.03923828899860382, 0.016804035753011703, -0.03980957716703415, -0.08308719843626022, 0.09166194498538971, -0.007938970811665058, -0.002126806415617466, -0.0333741270005703, -0.03307396173477173, 0.03201553225517273, 0.041379839181900024, 0.07715870440006256, -0.009229217655956745, -0.013213207945227623, -0.028257595375180244, 0.08390150219202042, 0.05929897353053093, -0.0759635791182518, 0.016605552285909653, 0.03678494691848755, 0.02018383890390396, 0.09326329082250595, -0.015607398003339767, 0.021954553201794624, -0.02924339286983013, 0.08704160898923874, -0.013505319133400917, 0.04992661997675896, -0.038683440536260605, 0.020005663856863976, 0.0026767661329358816, -0.014330756850540638, -0.06484372913837433, 0.04709283635020256, 0.00961375329643488, 0.016437634825706482, -0.0428582988679409, -0.037727564573287964, 0.04431019723415375, 0.008515894412994385, -0.05437140539288521, 0.07207915186882019, 0.0023166032042354345, 0.029807057231664658, -0.02948472835123539, -0.003260355908423662, -0.01558724232017994, -0.03437618911266327, 0.05441834405064583, -0.02037471905350685, 0.08179032802581787, 0.013745524920523167, -0.011706257238984108, 0.03794640675187111, 0.06678822636604309, -0.013795735314488411, -0.058852411806583405, -0.02551356330513954, 0.0032005750108510256, 0.003691184800118208, 0.016628429293632507, -0.03182055056095123, 0.045350294560194016, 0.07508289813995361, 0.04997991397976875, 0.00010896253661485389, 0.04372537136077881, 0.034767039120197296, -0.03195309638977051, 0.048086315393447876, -0.029033031314611435, -0.05975550785660744, -0.030691521242260933, -0.057662125676870346, -0.031340811401605606, -0.0023235976696014404, -0.07983802258968353, -0.02923065982758999, -0.01679360866546631, 0.032591965049505234, -0.04097924381494522, 0.021451661363244057, -0.014683346264064312, 0.007191626355051994, 0.04424850270152092, -0.017176467925310135, 0.0015546621289104223, 0.05690203234553337, -0.01728101074695587, 0.03074566274881363, 0.001321536721661687, -0.033582426607608795, -0.027779601514339447, -0.005782391410320997, 0.004510464612394571, -0.025897497311234474, 0.004730214364826679, -0.036812394857406616, 0.02304846979677677, -0.009533017873764038, -0.017241360619664192, 0.02547394670546055, 0.04283933714032173, -0.007758485618978739, 0.01576857455074787, 0.013273864984512329, -0.029476922005414963, -0.0766608789563179, -0.022191530093550682, -0.013587619177997112, 0.03322106972336769, -0.005086911376565695, -0.03641895204782486, -0.003945463802665472, 0.08421526849269867, 0.03151432052254677, -0.032415587455034256, 0.052325379103422165, 0.009042882360517979, -0.011494984850287437, 0.0055978260934352875, -0.04455314949154854, 0.003801059676334262, 0.007933877408504486, 0.027361510321497917, -0.01908254437148571, 0.014743546023964882, 0.015679430216550827, 0.0144220981746912, 0.04211115464568138, -0.038688477128744125, 0.07642495632171631, 0.04570287466049194, 0.002569246105849743, 0.04182843863964081, -0.040013767778873444, 0.009295601397752762, 0.057602088898420334, -0.057058949023485184, 0.034827325493097305, 0.013602052815258503, -0.03521725535392761, 0.03569435700774193, -0.017909815534949303, -0.0025635994970798492, 0.01208040677011013, 0.03333026170730591, 0.04070272296667099, -0.025549257174134254, 0.029648462310433388, -0.020155085250735283, 0.013467224314808846, -0.042855873703956604, 0.0949752926826477, -0.009915304370224476, -0.018220379948616028, -0.021155068650841713, -0.0373164601624012, -0.09574770927429199, -0.005281240679323673, 0.03501228243112564, 0.08921121805906296, 0.034695934504270554, 0.08071047812700272, -0.021819917485117912, 0.005858602933585644, 0.0011425663251429796, -0.025946831330657005, 0.0037464124616235495, -0.0054185036569833755, -0.012507954612374306, 0.04814676567912102, 0.01445258129388094, 0.023573998361825943, 0.018540048971772194, -0.045762281864881516, -0.030913611873984337, 0.01705222763121128, -0.010932240635156631, 0.03955821692943573, 0.01634264923632145, 0.00307712540961802, 0.013797552324831486, -0.03003920614719391, -0.03958437964320183, -0.02093181572854519, 0.03699692711234093, 0.02077578566968441, -0.014576057903468609, 0.036731015890836716, -0.003059197450056672, 0.023180320858955383, -0.008445251733064651, -0.036677759140729904, -0.026105133816599846, 0.01554794516414404, -0.0061179171316325665, -0.059534952044487, -0.061413638293743134, -0.024592146277427673, -0.08233070373535156, -0.03539097309112549, -0.02746540866792202, -0.0005074599757790565, 0.044800255447626114, 0.030323222279548645, 0.03124215453863144, 0.018421653658151627, -0.008124646730720997, -0.020271092653274536, -0.01533556915819645, -0.026699692010879517, -0.013843539170920849, 0.0068786730989813805, -0.016624195501208305, 0.02837851271033287, 0.007997256703674793, 0.008062836714088917, 0.06479816138744354, 0.02155929058790207, 0.014486626721918583, -0.05337618663907051, -0.017225150018930435, -0.053235817700624466, -0.0010044582886621356, -0.0023523380514234304, -0.023220257833600044, 0.017022425308823586, -0.004315096884965897, -0.01674303412437439, -0.01375452522188425, -0.0038055262994021177, -0.028055736795067787, -0.046259213238954544, 0.010091526433825493, 0.008833597414195538, 0.0012476856354624033, 0.032386261969804764, 0.009952650405466557, 0.001901154755614698, -0.04326420649886131, -0.008988115936517715, 0.005818400997668505, -0.012128683738410473, 0.06170019879937172, -0.05868487060070038, -0.044141627848148346, -0.009912126697599888, 0.041613440960645676, -0.08061333745718002, -0.016310999169945717, 0.03818197548389435, 0.055557627230882645, 0.07311005890369415, 0.04924361780285835, 0.03545941412448883, 0.026624690741300583, 0.02507956326007843, 0.05491211265325546, 0.06458818167448044, 0.02931477315723896, -0.04089852422475815, 0.03378274291753769, 0.024660522118210793, 0.05229094624519348, 0.03049272485077381, -0.0437161847949028, 0.02070758305490017, 0.06454184651374817, 0.024910375475883484, 0.04212621971964836, 0.00754781998693943, -0.024696094915270805, -0.043657489120960236, -0.009857378900051117, 0.016861755400896072, -0.004201303236186504, -0.028318319469690323, -0.053086891770362854, 0.02795766107738018, -0.014447453431785107, 0.071833536028862, 0.022232452407479286, -0.041890379041433334, -0.02469225972890854, -0.014058315195143223, 0.02407100424170494, 0.024266181513667107, 0.0019649681635200977, 0.02115694060921669, 0.020440880209207535, 0.007993457838892937, 0.0022228851448744535, -0.045289065688848495, 0.04367252066731453, 0.011469267308712006, -0.0475127212703228, -0.0019891494885087013, -0.05209286883473396, 0.024132326245307922, -0.025466658174991608, -0.0639156773686409, 0.05186896398663521, -0.03080490231513977, 0.027984052896499634, 0.0033752063754945993, -0.02625735104084015, -0.011375823989510536, -0.0019274662481620908, 0.04841981828212738, -0.02610955573618412, -0.027825893834233284, 0.030405640602111816, -0.029861118644475937, 0.018122218549251556, -0.0208957027643919, 0.03939897567033768, -0.05899740383028984, -0.01113778818398714, 0.03536403179168701, -0.011544558219611645, 0.060713645070791245, 0.005678584799170494, -0.005782018881291151, -0.06391902267932892, 0.050763875246047974, -0.021415777504444122, -0.012337327934801579, -0.03035745769739151, -0.02114710584282875, 0.04032646492123604, -0.0193780567497015, 0.010170916095376015, 0.027598628774285316, -0.006160305347293615, 0.00632646307349205, -0.02547909878194332, 0.05344836041331291, -0.017093097791075706, 0.013378049246966839, 0.05743236839771271, -0.0057965596206486225, -0.007824049331247807, -0.03226536512374878, -0.04305015504360199, -0.0038805752992630005, 0.025362061336636543, 0.011555838398635387, -0.03267884999513626, -0.05053367465734482, -0.022658780217170715, -0.005969436839222908, -0.031044851988554, -0.02943919599056244, 0.030546749010682106, -0.06922527402639389, -0.008070606738328934, 0.019156701862812042, 0.031380556523799896, -0.0322849377989769, -0.0025901603512465954, -0.020196380093693733, 0.054571304470300674, 0.02712075412273407, 0.03181147575378418, 0.021229999139904976, 0.019923977553844452, -0.0019063415238633752, -0.04283585771918297, -0.04887579753994942, 0.016259631142020226, -0.02428084798157215, 0.00019555438484530896, 0.04363063722848892, -0.025491170585155487, -0.0281077828258276, 0.030576074495911598, -0.06023307889699936, 0.05143735185265541, 0.03361322358250618, 0.020941123366355896, -0.07258185744285583, -0.02250497043132782, 0.02108938805758953, 0.04309140518307686, 0.013476092368364334, -0.0265423022210598, 0.04789753630757332, -0.01982830837368965, 0.05439372360706329, 0.010853953659534454, -0.03634215146303177, 0.007877578027546406, -0.02042747102677822, 0.03177490830421448, 0.006694350857287645, -0.031723752617836, 0.015823179855942726, -0.03972792997956276, 0.026829594746232033, 0.036867134273052216, 0.032404083758592606, -0.018982356414198875, 0.08486144244670868, -0.03150712698698044, -0.0037782900035381317, -0.08028121292591095, -0.060649093240499496, 0.06316971033811569, -0.007081327494233847, 0.03101550042629242, -0.03402479365468025, 0.0207938514649868, -0.06102672219276428, -0.010436775162816048, -0.04158976301550865, -0.01671609841287136, -0.0440693162381649, 0.017311958596110344, 0.04938216879963875, -0.0150635140016675, -0.023133594542741776, 0.004545747302472591, -0.07227230817079544, -0.04057808220386505, 0.004518977366387844, -0.0047945426777005196, -0.016743680462241173, 0.0055542634800076485, 0.0008838310022838414, 0.03608851879835129, -0.028994886204600334, -0.0029841081704944372, -0.03902163356542587, 0.022310681641101837, -0.04210082069039345, 0.03510182350873947, -0.13082186877727509, -0.012385312467813492, -0.03317338228225708, -0.00793962087482214, 0.025378495454788208, -0.02723303623497486, -0.006244561169296503, -0.008237616159021854, -0.03613629192113876, 0.04251125454902649, -0.026781968772411346, -0.06236829236149788, -0.007656471338123083, -0.0010904729133471847, -0.027378058061003685, 0.011687641963362694, 0.0018569251988083124, -0.040324658155441284, -0.008706229738891125, 0.003988603129982948, 0.01282650139182806, 0.0005446334253065288, -0.045579176396131516, -0.01610674522817135, -0.0036747357808053493, 0.028960514813661575, 0.04017474129796028, -0.02761993184685707, -0.0021413015201687813, 0.010984347201883793, 0.0074273208156228065, -0.04089729115366936, -0.04601350426673889, -0.028475629165768623, -0.021965879946947098, 0.032770391553640366, -0.0006910940282978117, -0.050725385546684265, 0.01153082400560379, 0.0671016126871109, 0.007300510071218014, -0.06856843829154968, -0.0024006632156670094, 0.0310647152364254, -0.04964260384440422, -0.02144720032811165, -0.0023576144594699144, -0.041057486087083817, -0.009558800607919693, -0.05546760931611061, 0.02099326066672802, 0.00016045747906900942, -0.040447935461997986, 0.10331390798091888, -0.03868609294295311, 0.030324332416057587, 0.002848499920219183, -0.03919940069317818, 0.0033046354074031115, 0.005036159884184599, 0.04552140459418297, -0.06815320998430252, -0.009393041022121906, -0.012148021720349789, 0.03330483287572861, 0.022670002654194832, -0.06321200728416443, -0.09174437075853348, -0.012935022823512554, -0.04559493064880371, -0.012621594592928886, 0.005269757006317377, -0.03439480438828468, 0.000137891955091618, -0.0008937905076891184, 0.001709634787403047, 0.05062747746706009, -0.033504899591207504, -0.008116265758872032, 0.055269062519073486, 0.0101001663133502, -0.037735067307949066, 0.03516004979610443, -0.033167485147714615, 0.03178124502301216, -0.028904331848025322, 0.05933517962694168, -0.006891982164233923, 0.059429269284009933, 0.04341856762766838, 0.02192803844809532, -0.008592258207499981, 0.12888957560062408, 0.039356779307127, -0.023673344403505325, 0.002510310849174857, 0.000554349331650883, 0.0839696153998375, -0.014456627890467644, -0.07674174010753632, -0.014429820701479912, 0.005081431474536657, 0.02374103292822838, 0.013672929257154465, -0.0451439805328846, 0.04118635132908821, 0.01070016622543335, 0.07183302938938141, 0.024514062330126762, 0.044813286513090134, 0.025373082607984543, -0.07178137451410294, -0.01739201508462429, -0.04211278632283211, -0.03512857109308243, 0.06210814416408539, 0.03373585641384125, 0.01914934813976288, -0.027467859908938408, -0.006628377828747034, 0.013570887967944145, -0.013963388279080391, -0.014130252413451672, -0.009136981330811977, 0.023995904251933098, 0.034425221383571625, -0.006882308982312679, 0.014077618718147278, 0.058648522943258286, 0.008483746089041233, -0.03592216223478317, 0.044395361095666885, -0.001474448712542653, 0.025199607014656067, 0.0262990090996027, -0.001244531711563468, 0.025769313797354698, -0.003780085826292634, -0.05655817314982414, -0.022139009088277817, -0.03935444355010986, 0.042023204267024994, -0.008649691008031368, 0.014941358007490635, 0.025978948920965195, -0.05116579309105873, -0.0011220256565138698, -0.01443092618137598, 0.028103899210691452, 0.02980637736618519, 0.042275723069906235, 0.02266538143157959, -0.004920827224850655, -0.01514214277267456, -0.03843364119529724, 0.09078089892864227, -0.03051060065627098, 0.0002882760018110275, -0.04310668259859085, -0.02525363676249981, -0.06502441316843033, -0.05376460403203964, 0.020228587090969086, -0.009288378059864044, 0.017581047490239143, -0.017750725150108337, -0.021740838885307312, -0.03521955758333206, -0.022585563361644745, 0.004625813104212284, 0.019666409119963646, -0.051598262041807175, -0.02624136582016945, -0.01101439818739891, 0.023306451737880707, 0.008183986879885197, -0.028862206265330315, -0.045177921652793884, -0.0012198619078844786, 0.02478133887052536, 0.011200628243386745, 0.02018420584499836, -0.060265276581048965, -0.08410369604825974, 0.04144744202494621, -0.0013702887808904052, 0.030636601150035858, 0.02100704424083233, 0.023783225566148758, -0.013079896569252014, -0.0066102007403969765, -0.06526724994182587, -0.038651905953884125, 0.041260045021772385, 0.029382122680544853, -0.004015768878161907, 0.02829214744269848, -0.02634870819747448, -0.005565436091274023, -0.028006628155708313, 0.0159281138330698, -0.046354349702596664, -0.04184906929731369, -0.04692724719643593, 0.010343817062675953, 0.030828235670924187, 0.031230853870511055, -0.03198464214801788, -0.020830105990171432, 0.06969112157821655, -0.02518082596361637, -0.003061280120164156, -0.028984539210796356, -0.02607218734920025, 0.027034850791096687, -0.0044678798876702785, 0.02958439663052559, 0.0593196265399456, 0.037417471408843994 ]
<p>I have always been taught that random effects only influence the variance (error), and that fixed effects only influence the mean. But I have found an example where random effects influence also the mean - the coefficient estimate:</p> <pre><code>require(nlme) set.seed(128) n &lt;- 100 k &lt;- 5 cat &lt;- as.factor(rep(1:k, each = n)) cat_i &lt;- 1:k # intercept per kategorie x &lt;- rep(1:n, k) sigma &lt;- 0.2 alpha &lt;- 0.001 y &lt;- cat_i[cat] + alpha * x + rnorm(n*k, 0, sigma) plot(x, y) # simulate missing data y[c(1:(n/2), (n*k-n/2):(n*k))] &lt;- NA m1 &lt;- lm(y ~ x) summary(m1) m2 &lt;- lm(y ~ cat + x) summary(m2) m3 &lt;- lme(y ~ x, random = ~ 1|cat, na.action = na.omit) summary(m3) </code></pre> <p>You can see that the estimated coefficient for <code>x</code> from model <code>m1</code> is -0.013780, while from model <code>m3</code> it is 0.0011713 - both significantly different from zero.</p> <p>Note that when I remove the line simulating missing data, the results are the same (it is full matrix).</p> <p>Why is that?</p> <p>PS: please note I am not a professional statistician, so if you are about to respond with a lot of math then please make also some simple summary for dummies :-)</p>
g74323
[ 0.005891567096114159, -0.012938265688717365, -0.0037440629675984383, -0.018285930156707764, 0.013307245448231697, 0.009749197401106358, 0.041447266936302185, 0.027371244505047798, -0.026780525222420692, -0.03795137256383896, -0.030774250626564026, 0.021146275103092194, 0.028741585090756416, 0.027766495943069458, -0.01160180289298296, 0.02709520049393177, 0.06242811679840088, -0.021669117733836174, -0.04170888289809227, 0.05303071066737175, -0.04372240602970123, -0.018694067373871803, -0.01415408868342638, -0.023320896551012993, 0.004727507475763559, -0.0633816346526146, -0.010647856630384922, 0.03278546407818794, -0.0992092415690422, 0.07259976863861084, -0.013422324322164059, 0.0065104844979941845, 0.009758452884852886, -0.08817446976900101, -0.07541881501674652, 0.018224060535430908, 0.05953926593065262, 0.02379649505019188, 0.04470652714371681, 0.0030558449216187, -0.042519472539424896, 0.04653250798583031, 0.02815215475857258, 0.05028644576668739, -0.04314085841178894, -0.013938136398792267, -0.004781919531524181, 0.007218850310891867, -0.005308831110596657, -0.008591831661760807, 0.0006373350624926388, 0.005032587330788374, 0.04862464964389801, -0.004674124531447887, 0.01064105611294508, 0.0269742701202631, -0.020842045545578003, -0.0017249914817512035, 0.019856242462992668, 0.018222499638795853, 0.05205227807164192, -0.005299672484397888, -0.012864827178418636, 0.0012610178673639894, -0.028743334114551544, 0.01825243979692459, -0.037561703473329544, 0.07092873752117157, -0.029711471870541573, -0.028166212141513824, 0.009512944146990776, 0.06156541407108307, -0.05593625083565712, -0.0017572150100022554, -0.03263328969478607, -0.003183196997269988, 0.03557769954204559, 0.02649626135826111, -0.0064740837551653385, 0.013314161449670792, -0.03936058655381203, 0.003572074929252267, -0.00004839571556658484, 0.047578565776348114, 0.03026365116238594, 0.006013755686581135, -0.009428728371858597, -0.011801990680396557, 0.007106841076165438, 0.013937298208475113, 0.009482422843575478, 0.0033985807094722986, 0.0008929152972996235, 0.07334233075380325, -0.007577991113066673, -0.045618340373039246, -0.057998619973659515, -0.009103195741772652, 0.016153277829289436, 0.010782814584672451, -0.01042594388127327, 0.051851626485586166, 0.02211848273873329, -0.03733466565608978, -0.032628804445266724, -0.0023037316277623177, 0.07286902517080307, 0.001695157727226615, 0.009334494359791279, -0.01464556623250246, -0.07626748085021973, -0.013720117509365082, -0.06694965064525604, -0.01591789536178112, -0.031194055452942848, -0.07696633785963058, 0.1078699603676796, -0.0004295025719329715, 0.006087424699217081, -0.018226031213998795, -0.041369255632162094, 0.0037107435055077076, 0.03385649994015694, 0.08382374793291092, 0.009080003015697002, -0.023999188095331192, -0.033152490854263306, 0.08549340069293976, 0.023612743243575096, -0.05424017086625099, -0.01082572154700756, 0.008929220959544182, -0.01547660119831562, 0.06402678042650223, -0.012084000743925571, -0.007349723484367132, -0.0525391511619091, 0.05928950756788254, -0.008589424192905426, 0.039447296410799026, -0.026146162301301956, 0.03221579268574715, -0.00940549187362194, -0.030451767146587372, -0.049865394830703735, 0.00732450233772397, -0.005012467037886381, -0.0009365579462610185, -0.028705846518278122, -0.060703981667757034, 0.07509090006351471, 0.040186863392591476, -0.05676967278122902, 0.08240484446287155, -0.008058184757828712, 0.01077362336218357, -0.008073003962635994, -0.008294332772493362, -0.022486403584480286, -0.025255875661969185, 0.052357323467731476, -0.024779368191957474, 0.09267017245292664, 0.011353532783687115, -0.043431300669908524, 0.019700119271874428, 0.052683692425489426, -0.05456304922699928, -0.04895973578095436, -0.03701053187251091, -0.017454015091061592, -0.024203751236200333, 0.0034387223422527313, -0.028095699846744537, 0.013126328587532043, 0.08021438121795654, 0.0703514814376831, -0.012066913768649101, 0.06383136659860611, 0.0414939783513546, 0.011331248097121716, 0.042269688099622726, -0.025529412552714348, -0.08913346379995346, -0.03567606955766678, -0.04217144101858139, -0.013350923545658588, 0.008833777159452438, -0.08233898133039474, -0.05597597733139992, -0.004909791983664036, -0.010251302272081375, -0.020542461425065994, -0.03936571627855301, 0.015090443193912506, 0.009862956590950489, 0.019218547269701958, -0.0052162958309054375, 0.005460197106003761, 0.054792873561382294, -0.03548376262187958, 0.005634392146021128, -0.02720131166279316, -0.008105052635073662, -0.03031660057604313, 0.008027899079024792, -0.005572805646806955, -0.005686670076102018, -0.005554992705583572, -0.0243196003139019, 0.009760821238160133, -0.025120077654719353, -0.01716989278793335, 0.037640709429979324, 0.03954913467168808, 0.028842976316809654, 0.0017758166650310159, 0.014198381453752518, 0.000014843681128695607, -0.036619286984205246, -0.0004113137547392398, -0.029377300292253494, 0.029220085591077805, -0.005665818694978952, -0.02938711643218994, -0.005805222317576408, 0.07176439464092255, -0.0017982873832806945, -0.04473967105150223, 0.03257976844906807, -0.007710831239819527, -0.008809507824480534, -0.01563844084739685, -0.009059864096343517, 0.012789761647582054, 0.02939721569418907, 0.05691155046224594, -0.020691635087132454, 0.004082532599568367, 0.017300540581345558, 0.017071060836315155, 0.04599172994494438, -0.03764820843935013, 0.04426629841327667, 0.03218961879611015, 0.00998819898813963, 0.01841910369694233, -0.059011150151491165, 0.01573522575199604, 0.003510361537337303, -0.04375527426600456, 0.055794548243284225, 0.019084518775343895, -0.04534332454204559, 0.03558925539255142, -0.01882627233862877, 0.013673088513314724, 0.022452523931860924, 0.017970236018300056, 0.01474571693688631, -0.06668592989444733, 0.04183213785290718, -0.015383437275886536, -0.000037125253584235907, -0.01630454510450363, 0.1090797409415245, -0.009129561483860016, 0.0036986616905778646, -0.012583550065755844, -0.01824110373854637, -0.0589870810508728, 0.020549200475215912, 0.055256638675928116, 0.05019591003656387, 0.04540148377418518, 0.05286358669400215, -0.038026224821805954, -0.004743735771626234, 0.029238088056445122, -0.014143752865493298, -0.021545683965086937, 0.008721151389181614, -0.007103346288204193, 0.025212569162249565, 0.03831261023879051, -0.005347327329218388, 0.003301045624539256, -0.06827810406684875, -0.026728082448244095, -0.016871711239218712, -0.03392863646149635, 0.00760270282626152, -0.0006995490984991193, -0.03293389081954956, 0.012203829362988472, -0.044326674193143845, -0.03570704907178879, -0.0238516665995121, 0.0015447833575308323, 0.035674773156642914, -0.032611772418022156, 0.0902324691414833, 0.005352593958377838, 0.028774041682481766, 0.004247828386723995, -0.029959050938487053, -0.004991326481103897, 0.01011433731764555, -0.0006373192882165313, -0.0424177311360836, -0.056357868015766144, -0.030065396800637245, -0.0681847482919693, -0.011220840737223625, -0.04668187350034714, -0.00044750148663297296, 0.005579788237810135, 0.020957114174962044, 0.018712973222136497, 0.037355937063694, -0.004939816892147064, -0.06012527272105217, -0.016803227365016937, -0.006363408640027046, -0.020125262439250946, -0.005740234162658453, -0.022580059245228767, 0.036536991596221924, 0.016828659921884537, -0.005807482171803713, 0.05647987499833107, 0.00512321712449193, -0.01437757071107626, -0.05492802709341049, -0.04961872845888138, -0.06544731557369232, 0.002076346892863512, 0.021019671112298965, -0.025196189060807228, -0.0065561686642467976, -0.02335311658680439, 0.006430466193705797, -0.0015768769662827253, -0.0070579396560788155, 0.007759828586131334, -0.036737941205501556, 0.003762982552871108, -0.015856631100177765, -0.010094843804836273, 0.027820270508527756, 0.05107884481549263, -0.011364075355231762, -0.04888100549578667, -0.023165911436080933, 0.003835301613435149, 0.010796655900776386, 0.053053490817546844, -0.048112351447343826, -0.03290751203894615, -0.004660237580537796, 0.029162228107452393, -0.08635690063238144, -0.020038926973938942, 0.044106073677539825, 0.05654752254486084, 0.08897029608488083, 0.05298726633191109, 0.057038117200136185, 0.04341195896267891, 0.03180108591914177, 0.0239849966019392, 0.06054405868053436, 0.06073615700006485, -0.03260743245482445, 0.01977868564426899, 0.05375976487994194, 0.05494902282953262, 0.021219128742814064, -0.011514119803905487, 0.03870643302798271, 0.05875823646783829, -0.0005711428239010274, -0.0013426868245005608, -0.041150111705064774, 0.0038185683079063892, -0.032717086374759674, -0.002152425469830632, -0.0015971678076311946, -0.025938555598258972, -0.06180648133158684, -0.029322227463126183, -0.014310588128864765, -0.00003854711030726321, 0.05461429804563522, 0.037363406270742416, -0.038427602499723434, 0.016995610669255257, 0.0350174680352211, 0.009506870992481709, 0.02333226427435875, 0.017726730555295944, 0.014837038703262806, 0.0033470133785158396, 0.023486368358135223, 0.029608115553855896, -0.02448876202106476, 0.01912049390375614, 0.005369651131331921, -0.059087082743644714, 0.005893744062632322, -0.05994565039873123, 0.05056191608309746, -0.05520596355199814, -0.031432878226041794, 0.04937726631760597, -0.012816124595701694, 0.018874868750572205, 0.02809755504131317, -0.013939524069428444, -0.0028738300316035748, -0.010720008984208107, 0.033226728439331055, -0.059856195002794266, -0.020091641694307327, 0.05643993616104126, 0.018132850527763367, 0.002179797738790512, -0.012507719919085503, 0.06335891038179398, -0.06719040125608444, 0.013096514157950878, 0.033192817121744156, -0.07783666253089905, 0.0291412565857172, -0.015635112300515175, 0.022012092173099518, -0.013111620210111141, 0.05414118617773056, -0.02208574488759041, 0.0047863200306892395, -0.035125426948070526, -0.010325095616281033, 0.020246068015694618, -0.019353600218892097, -0.012514062225818634, 0.009654531255364418, -0.01105470024049282, 0.018636321648955345, -0.04123513400554657, 0.07883509993553162, -0.04636841267347336, -0.007530505768954754, 0.02065047062933445, -0.03734525665640831, 0.029878785833716393, -0.037097129970788956, -0.046027928590774536, 0.005461812485009432, 0.036280401051044464, 0.031304989010095596, -0.049802184104919434, -0.045584212988615036, -0.042696576565504074, 0.02827259711921215, -0.03469303250312805, -0.01154960785061121, 0.016557777300477028, -0.039905328303575516, -0.030927486717700958, 0.05592001602053642, 0.0038806740194559097, -0.005695075262337923, 0.005236529279500246, 0.007491761352866888, 0.03317777067422867, 0.02784678153693676, -0.008325531147420406, -0.006809759419411421, 0.03694288432598114, -0.02000315673649311, -0.02612023986876011, -0.032962728291749954, 0.03325365483760834, 0.008133350871503353, -0.006699729710817337, 0.012436650693416595, -0.02573002316057682, -0.04758594557642937, 0.03417371213436127, -0.041360337287187576, 0.03546490520238876, 0.07107556611299515, 0.01722574606537819, -0.06355025619268417, -0.0005920930998399854, -0.017799247056245804, 0.05864138528704643, 0.024776190519332886, 0.013218007050454617, 0.001148170791566372, -0.026955582201480865, 0.046410370618104935, 0.017141511663794518, -0.06323587894439697, -0.014248780906200409, 0.005884806625545025, 0.023253533989191055, -0.014652789570391178, -0.02662467397749424, 0.0011772887082770467, -0.04104983061552048, 0.008302287198603153, 0.09089742600917816, -0.00043665373232215643, -0.024708742275834084, 0.04975736513733864, 0.02092628926038742, -0.006609512493014336, -0.05420688912272453, -0.01647435873746872, 0.07116418331861496, -0.03619449958205223, 0.03446151688694954, -0.04521404579281807, 0.012406290508806705, -0.0545370876789093, 0.009268938563764095, -0.045184433460235596, -0.021169476211071014, -0.045702628791332245, -0.02115642838180065, 0.056425999850034714, -0.020499669015407562, 0.017666129395365715, -0.00015346668078564107, -0.034247986972332, -0.0169967208057642, -0.026020340621471405, 0.01372483465820551, -0.0029179288540035486, 0.01152203232049942, 0.020258469507098198, 0.043169669806957245, -0.010740438476204872, -0.0238514207303524, -0.037324972450733185, 0.044151563197374344, -0.030259011313319206, 0.039395980536937714, -0.10537588596343994, 0.0028508445248007774, -0.02159741520881653, 0.0014020283706486225, 0.038467247039079666, -0.03018149361014366, 0.012446739710867405, -0.008669712580740452, -0.010390687733888626, 0.006448626518249512, -0.005927915684878826, -0.027647007256746292, 0.012848109006881714, 0.04250284284353256, -0.026260703802108765, 0.04351753368973732, 0.029689956456422806, -0.0360492579638958, 0.0023315041325986385, -0.003422051900997758, 0.022238025441765785, -0.005928719416260719, -0.036946702748537064, -0.023145223036408424, 0.015204926021397114, 0.033755429089069366, 0.056230273097753525, -0.010666019283235073, -0.023752860724925995, 0.016933972015976906, -0.013704135082662106, -0.023505575954914093, -0.06059454008936882, 0.01022577565163374, -0.05781903117895126, 0.04269009083509445, 0.0025962768122553825, -0.029369940981268883, 0.03623354062438011, 0.08646135032176971, 0.008951300755143166, -0.05817690119147301, 0.01684708334505558, 0.05450230464339256, -0.057465810328722, -0.0109727056697011, -0.04492668807506561, -0.03691639006137848, -0.009248393587768078, -0.03197544068098068, -0.049465447664260864, 0.018914692103862762, -0.044490329921245575, 0.07013008743524551, -0.06551862508058548, 0.022972332313656807, -0.01929307170212269, -0.02565126307308674, -0.004008241463452578, -0.01831609383225441, 0.06324130296707153, -0.06688245385885239, 0.025445785373449326, -0.016226595267653465, 0.03793119639158249, 0.009309306740760803, -0.067160464823246, -0.12181563675403595, -0.004212765954434872, -0.07983990013599396, -0.013664308935403824, -0.001520925317890942, -0.02714891918003559, 0.011713482439517975, -0.0266168974339962, -0.00044691652874462306, 0.05196300521492958, -0.010911461897194386, -0.020440859720110893, 0.04193086177110672, -0.004947851877659559, -0.05315156653523445, 0.0223847609013319, -0.021666917949914932, 0.05254470929503441, -0.02839457243680954, 0.04251302778720856, -0.034072522073984146, 0.06348562240600586, 0.07096747308969498, 0.06279687583446503, 0.00939983781427145, 0.060503821820020676, 0.03398054465651512, -0.029839197173714638, -0.004083240870386362, 0.02252424694597721, 0.03880404680967331, -0.011469376273453236, -0.06944192200899124, 0.02486497163772583, -0.007118808105587959, 0.021947087720036507, 0.001430834410712123, -0.027000652626156807, 0.06639742851257324, 0.02376929111778736, 0.007572060450911522, 0.00130549818277359, 0.05440984293818474, -0.04008980840444565, -0.08497241139411926, -0.013187538832426071, -0.03958381712436676, 0.0150866424664855, 0.0662088692188263, 0.027329053729772568, 0.04968596622347832, -0.00763572147116065, 0.0036289335694164038, 0.0008262608898803592, -0.015542241744697094, -0.06280133128166199, 0.012064210139214993, 0.013843674212694168, 0.04472629353404045, 0.008488397113978863, 0.02330300584435463, 0.05645282194018364, -0.010071801953017712, 0.0015701610827818513, 0.039834704250097275, -0.021673668175935745, 0.03056778945028782, -0.034303028136491776, -0.024082092568278313, 0.01814570091664791, -0.035808876156806946, -0.020546087995171547, -0.02116709016263485, -0.05428170785307884, 0.02592487446963787, -0.011857504956424236, 0.018444906920194626, 0.020563781261444092, -0.03530537337064743, -0.019188927486538887, -0.01078018732368946, 0.042871247977018356, 0.015510757453739643, 0.04253073036670685, 0.05596164986491203, -0.0257194172590971, -0.0077037811279296875, -0.024810373783111572, 0.10594694316387177, -0.009990653954446316, 0.014121172949671745, -0.021580588072538376, -0.037816498428583145, -0.10131309926509857, -0.03476142883300781, -0.03256155923008919, 0.014348543249070644, 0.006428999360650778, 0.005068877711892128, -0.010929916985332966, 0.026864271610975266, 0.022287465631961823, 0.001155498088337481, 0.02118675224483013, -0.008937041275203228, 0.01816849410533905, -0.00681616086512804, 0.019831458106637, 0.0013929454144090414, -0.02833738923072815, -0.029685214161872864, 0.04656588286161423, 0.02654959447681904, 0.01777753233909607, 0.011982294730842113, -0.06790399551391602, -0.07519856840372086, 0.03899450972676277, 0.01304679736495018, 0.039967432618141174, 0.028587443754076958, 0.03523271530866623, -0.015692908316850662, 0.004341010935604572, -0.05200788378715515, -0.0013983917888253927, 0.035342104732990265, 0.029791373759508133, 0.005804621614515781, 0.019795821979641914, -0.014488810673356056, 0.009514947421848774, -0.048986371606588364, -0.007445827126502991, -0.03331591933965683, -0.05029149353504181, -0.07897321879863739, 0.0343414768576622, 0.016225522384047508, 0.007034556940197945, -0.014180446043610573, -0.0017415567999705672, 0.05527079105377197, -0.02340589463710785, 0.005683201365172863, -0.06233639642596245, -0.0350784957408905, 0.055764395743608475, -0.010175919160246849, 0.03209994360804558, 0.03922557085752487, 0.030329374596476555 ]
<p>I'm analyzing users' in-game data in order to model whether they're going to be paid user or not. </p> <p>Here's my model:</p> <pre><code>Logistic Regression Model lrm(formula = becomePaid ~ x1 + x2 + x3 + x4 + x5 + x6, data = sn, x = TRUE, y = TRUE) Model Likelihood Discrimination Rank Discrim. Ratio Test Indexes Indexes Obs 1e+05 LR chi2 1488.63 R2 0.147 C 0.774 0 99065 d.f. 6 g 1.141 Dxy 0.547 1 935 Pr(&gt; chi2) &lt;0.0001 gr 3.130 gamma 0.586 max |deriv| 8e-09 gp 0.011 tau-a 0.010 Brier 0.009 Coef S.E. Wald Z Pr(&gt;|Z|) Intercept -6.7910 0.0938 -72.36 &lt;0.0001 x1 0.0756 0.0193 3.92 &lt;0.0001 x2 0.0698 0.0091 7.64 &lt;0.0001 x3 0.0020 0.0002 11.05 &lt;0.0001 x4 0.0172 0.0057 3.03 0.0024 x5 0.0304 0.0045 6.82 &lt;0.0001 x6 -0.0132 0.0042 -3.17 0.0015 </code></pre> <p>And in my model, I created couple of use cases such as:</p> <pre><code> test1 test2 x1 8 9 x2 10 10 x3 250 250 x4 6 6 x5 2 2 x6 0 1 </code></pre> <p>Then the probability of user test1 is to turn out to be a paid user is %.07 and % 0.84 for test2.</p> <p>However I want to calculate the cumulative probabilities such as users whose' x1 values are greater than 8, x2 values are between 10 and 20 and so on.</p> <p>Is there any way to calculate this ?</p> <p>Thanks ! </p>
g74324
[ -0.024552471935749054, -0.028187613934278488, -0.011186977848410606, 0.013606386259198189, 0.029214512556791306, -0.04390378296375275, 0.05876725912094116, 0.03200698271393776, -0.054312944412231445, 0.011499022133648396, -0.01399909146130085, 0.07367847114801407, 0.046131234616041183, -0.01842324435710907, 0.003366675227880478, -0.040584273636341095, 0.0012316569918766618, 0.009984241798520088, 0.03450528904795647, 0.004436931572854519, -0.03571489453315735, -0.025160063058137894, 0.009127493016421795, -0.0649973675608635, -0.03733064979314804, -0.08640927076339722, -0.0568995475769043, 0.09816528111696243, -0.048187486827373505, 0.09090694785118103, -0.06327884644269943, 0.05942557007074356, 0.045597705990076065, -0.04556965455412865, -0.004057515412569046, -0.010137669742107391, 0.06272852420806885, -0.008971616625785828, -0.004455340560525656, -0.01870223507285118, -0.02481670118868351, -0.0004014437145087868, 0.03315562754869461, 0.05020931735634804, -0.042366113513708115, -0.007590579334646463, 0.037828732281923294, 0.04089896008372307, 0.04420667886734009, -0.008718359284102917, -0.05588433891534805, 0.010984274558722973, 0.027782194316387177, 0.007775531616061926, 0.007383158430457115, 0.0475260354578495, -0.031190166249871254, -0.02275092527270317, 0.015770653262734413, 0.006658521946519613, 0.008591556921601295, -0.035914596170186996, -0.005549553316086531, 0.06661349534988403, 0.021615969017148018, 0.0009634379530325532, 0.0029545887373387814, -0.004687485750764608, 0.014913263730704784, -0.06240104138851166, 0.0071200779639184475, 0.06769376993179321, -0.029353279620409012, -0.04473492130637169, -0.02813941240310669, -0.011837885715067387, -0.04311048239469528, 0.04763876646757126, 0.04244893789291382, 0.020082179456949234, 0.05305818095803261, 0.03774985671043396, -0.0022497952450066805, -0.00214158883318305, 0.015694428235292435, 0.005390551872551441, 0.038862235844135284, -0.014864258468151093, 0.01388695277273655, 0.005462075117975473, 0.033838897943496704, -0.003165317000821233, 0.04461420699954033, 0.08383139222860336, -0.0001435966551071033, -0.0027242437936365604, -0.06196131929755211, -0.026718858629465103, 0.0066361865028738976, -0.027972791343927383, 0.05088347569108009, 0.029208935797214508, 0.008007308468222618, 0.005342757795006037, -0.07918526977300644, -0.0018753024050965905, -0.030407246202230453, -0.005171285942196846, -0.03474411740899086, -0.00812058337032795, 0.006926828995347023, -0.027825478464365005, 0.006888601928949356, -0.006068532820791006, -0.047312866896390915, -0.021237513050436974, 0.01613769121468067, -0.0007332678069360554, -0.02985457144677639, 0.005560107994824648, 0.0028559097554534674, -0.014032475650310516, -0.007761132437735796, 0.03786341845989227, -0.028694607317447662, 0.002606090158224106, -0.0564928762614727, 0.08360035717487335, 0.05094389617443085, 0.03320835903286934, 0.018921416252851486, 0.04114789888262749, 0.02096092328429222, 0.026989784091711044, -0.023198122158646584, 0.06321366876363754, -0.01848289929330349, 0.07410704344511032, -0.04228350147604942, 0.04324379935860634, 0.017235087230801582, -0.019879154860973358, 0.03316834568977356, 0.008077865466475487, -0.02445295825600624, 0.02982804924249649, -0.04357356205582619, 0.00900478195399046, -0.014568903483450413, 0.03959018364548683, 0.017985688522458076, 0.016700977459549904, 0.026431653648614883, -0.01543106883764267, -0.0043016537092626095, -0.0015876037068665028, -0.05903321132063866, -0.03352920711040497, -0.08261027932167053, -0.00805772002786398, 0.023502307012677193, -0.03305116668343544, 0.04380986839532852, 0.00425488268956542, -0.020397769287228584, -0.010300470516085625, -0.017804620787501335, -0.01896457001566887, -0.02989686094224453, -0.02110365778207779, 0.02822519652545452, 0.00746077811345458, -0.01054549403488636, -0.06428387016057968, 0.07984055578708649, 0.03813702240586281, 0.04116688296198845, 0.004078373778611422, 0.017742732539772987, 0.036160774528980255, 0.007329417858272791, 0.024767322465777397, 0.06496971100568771, -0.005152413621544838, 0.0034899532329291105, -0.0811227336525917, -0.02079852484166622, 0.036610741168260574, 0.012333924882113934, 0.010156291536986828, -0.04448406770825386, -0.024436770007014275, -0.010433316230773926, -0.022418897598981857, -0.008275113999843597, -0.04199007526040077, 0.032319050282239914, -0.01162368431687355, 0.04433632642030716, -0.010138620622456074, -0.006068672519177198, 0.036555733531713486, -0.0007107513374648988, 0.02422204427421093, 0.042914554476737976, -0.032335396856069565, -0.014335237443447113, -0.033096130937337875, -0.020596066489815712, -0.019388899207115173, 0.0023766017984598875, -0.028181757777929306, -0.021647723391652107, 0.05717075616121292, 0.0053114756010472775, 0.0036882502026855946, -0.02825331501662731, 0.01939794234931469, 0.0011141749564558268, 0.011917955242097378, 0.00742741534486413, -0.03546258434653282, 0.03555694967508316, 0.07872425019741058, -0.043025486171245575, 0.03633831813931465, 0.018928663805127144, 0.05009319260716438, 0.009572385810315609, 0.052699413150548935, 0.004205065313726664, -0.04077907279133797, -0.007812343072146177, -0.028886523097753525, 0.01853456348180771, 0.03417116403579712, -0.05938044935464859, 0.025201037526130676, -0.023399628698825836, 0.025276781991124153, 0.026973526924848557, 0.006953722331672907, -0.030994001775979996, 0.020615823566913605, 0.022774839773774147, 0.00027192450943402946, -0.005251061636954546, 0.03839464858174324, -0.010419249534606934, 0.12120425701141357, -0.052126817405223846, 0.04859434813261032, 0.004203881602734327, -0.004930772818624973, 0.011686965823173523, 0.0272696390748024, -0.057998038828372955, 0.04491640627384186, 0.01300729252398014, -0.027314210310578346, 0.027622848749160767, 0.0032102600671350956, 0.0031116458121687174, 0.005736635997891426, 0.017028111964464188, -0.01998184062540531, -0.00425706384703517, -0.0697588250041008, 0.02612241357564926, 0.07066977769136429, -0.009758025407791138, 0.020851628854870796, 0.017145870253443718, 0.10086920857429504, 0.058857426047325134, -0.0077581582590937614, -0.019462989643216133, 0.016830410808324814, 0.045178212225437164, -0.010021611116826534, 0.03774208948016167, -0.05009027570486069, -0.013556485995650291, 0.07465741783380508, 0.032419245690107346, 0.011939411982893944, 0.009179706685245037, -0.02230890467762947, 0.03711346536874771, 0.04609698802232742, 0.07330112904310226, -0.0394601933658123, 0.020098432898521423, -0.014036919921636581, -0.014913875609636307, -0.0033651995472609997, 0.05728127807378769, -0.011144538410007954, 0.05782989785075188, 0.011061671189963818, -0.03362512215971947, -0.013563940301537514, 0.03924504294991493, 0.027960918843746185, 0.03352712467312813, -0.025141162797808647, -0.0020099820103496313, 0.04764391854405403, 0.021856268867850304, -0.05564579367637634, -0.04839317128062248, -0.026745403185486794, -0.056058648973703384, -0.059498533606529236, -0.026441507041454315, 0.02211994118988514, 0.014964991249144077, 0.022540664300322533, 0.012767430394887924, -0.04013971611857414, 0.0004950350848957896, -0.057956304401159286, -0.034730710089206696, 0.013966898433864117, 0.00027174680144526064, -0.04046927019953728, -0.05729515478014946, -0.009280920960009098, -0.023878641426563263, -0.044677477329969406, 0.05245338752865791, 0.02126450650393963, 0.05217720568180084, -0.005332254339009523, 0.011147660203278065, -0.05114176869392395, 0.007602539844810963, -0.02296099066734314, 0.0241218414157629, 0.038945216685533524, -0.00805988721549511, -0.016098041087388992, -0.034550558775663376, -0.025205116719007492, -0.06355967372655869, -0.01559913158416748, 0.026385696604847908, 0.06255311518907547, 0.025321196764707565, 0.006714566145092249, -0.023216543719172478, -0.002411940833553672, -0.03141267970204353, 0.005956848617643118, 0.03661428391933441, 0.08051229268312454, -0.017441414296627045, 0.030055368319153786, -0.008943801745772362, 0.01220159512013197, 0.0388600118458271, -0.06350302696228027, -0.049290671944618225, 0.025427721440792084, 0.020530937239527702, 0.050392936915159225, 0.029949979856610298, 0.04931654781103134, 0.05270844325423241, 0.02958803065121174, 0.003091271501034498, -0.021090878173708916, 0.058321937918663025, -0.025760134682059288, 0.04257373884320259, -0.039513468742370605, 0.039154261350631714, -0.01841248758137226, -0.012191873975098133, 0.0024378832895308733, 0.00991792231798172, 0.002804775722324848, 0.036321401596069336, -0.023091960698366165, -0.01076724473387003, -0.027907002717256546, 0.050796832889318466, -0.05443708971142769, 0.06406932324171066, -0.025596274062991142, -0.031246110796928406, 0.0035812361165881157, -0.08384009450674057, 0.0771624892950058, 0.00368630257435143, -0.03956671804189682, -0.010482865385711193, 0.019992029294371605, 0.04008646309375763, 0.024351047351956367, 0.015150804072618484, 0.06391096860170364, 0.027591753751039505, -0.007684966083616018, 0.005964368116110563, -0.045333344489336014, 0.0021838792599737644, -0.008311639539897442, -0.026288403198122978, 0.014501355588436127, -0.022784141823649406, -0.08616633713245392, -0.015457646921277046, -0.028540726751089096, 0.039742935448884964, 0.003189345123246312, 0.06690714508295059, -0.007458699867129326, -0.04413392022252083, -0.03015800379216671, 0.00697240000590682, -0.06197737529873848, 0.010220383293926716, 0.0025302565190941095, -0.011360619217157364, 0.029870888218283653, 0.05083613842725754, 0.0033397527877241373, 0.01188933290541172, -0.041155532002449036, 0.025802645832300186, 0.06308677792549133, -0.003273213282227516, 0.029319366440176964, -0.028267070651054382, 0.007899537682533264, -0.01211854163557291, 0.03081579878926277, 0.02489090897142887, -0.020561523735523224, -0.11862258613109589, -0.01652906835079193, -0.010519817471504211, 0.005480945110321045, 0.020246023312211037, 0.012305913493037224, -0.03661688044667244, -0.03345968574285507, 0.01918375864624977, 0.0049237534403800964, -0.01700798235833645, -0.0023560640402138233, -0.0474797748029232, 0.02226983942091465, -0.016343258321285248, -0.02678166702389717, 0.0073817819356918335, -0.01918635703623295, 0.035976871848106384, -0.011554673314094543, 0.02078198455274105, -0.045678090304136276, 0.0016057053580880165, -0.027406560257077217, -0.025007976219058037, 0.044519707560539246, -0.04222017526626587, -0.011913121677935123, 0.04799915850162506, -0.055154915899038315, -0.018414238467812538, -0.005877258721739054, 0.02455829083919525, -0.01637796312570572, -0.030057059600949287, 0.07226818054914474, -0.01832592859864235, -0.0087735028937459, 0.012889128178358078, 0.06067054346203804, -0.07183652371168137, -0.0015092466492205858, -0.06988700479269028, -0.020178381353616714, -0.028353743255138397, -0.005556825548410416, 0.01565018855035305, -0.033209268003702164, 0.01661708578467369, -0.02678740955889225, -0.029142417013645172, 0.012807514518499374, 0.048398908227682114, 0.022114606574177742, -0.03503015264868736, -0.03501633182168007, -0.01373467780649662, -0.028884509578347206, -0.012428277172148228, 0.05510161444544792, -0.09096594154834747, -0.023699602112174034, -0.0467996783554554, -0.0647166296839714, 0.03771613910794258, -0.0006283997790887952, 0.028769193217158318, 0.006887781899422407, 0.04670017212629318, 0.027404753491282463, -0.0007531578885391355, 0.019152803346514702, 0.0610751248896122, 0.0025026435032486916, -0.015520130284130573, -0.026022324338555336, -0.033918045461177826, -0.007792507763952017, -0.04040246084332466, 0.02394074574112892, 0.06135945022106171, -0.0009328228770755231, 0.0583454892039299, 0.02182074263691902, -0.05433228984475136, -0.06284923851490021, -0.045706942677497864, -0.048199787735939026, 0.041605908423662186, -0.04161817207932472, 0.0361720509827137, 0.01772465370595455, -0.051202911883592606, 0.025221925228834152, -0.014137811958789825, -0.028500081971287727, -0.0185577142983675, -0.029182851314544678, -0.014395229518413544, -0.03182084113359451, -0.012623850256204605, 0.017598792910575867, 0.006413123104721308, -0.056252941489219666, 0.022735197097063065, -0.03609758988022804, -0.06659039855003357, 0.007552147377282381, 0.008371301926672459, -0.032767344266176224, 0.027183271944522858, 0.049094174057245255, 0.014831592328846455, -0.04004479572176933, -0.00904789473861456, 0.015910277143120766, 0.004068220034241676, 0.007741002831608057, 0.01485731266438961, 0.025168074294924736, 0.03094506449997425, -0.08416999876499176, 0.017683645710349083, 0.00549309840425849, 0.0036784533876925707, -0.00253051589243114, -0.041751567274332047, -0.005365756340324879, 0.03086976706981659, 0.02290121465921402, 0.05098611116409302, 0.010376843623816967, -0.017430024221539497, -0.008412959985435009, -0.0393654964864254, 0.02030508778989315, -0.00914707500487566, -0.009889327920973301, 0.07992814481258392, -0.01799045316874981, -0.03731624037027359, 0.031259361654520035, -0.011003021150827408, 0.02185140550136566, -0.023834753781557083, 0.053875356912612915, 0.011867579072713852, 0.055176615715026855, -0.11498594284057617, -0.030476758256554604, 0.007298195734620094, -0.0031304359436035156, -0.012895796447992325, 0.004478928633034229, 0.023906860500574112, -0.012747139669954777, -0.012018339708447456, 0.013827165588736534, 0.017571305856108665, 0.011072221212089062, 0.020812412723898888, -0.009335553273558617, 0.04157367721199989, -0.008902064524590969, 0.023440079763531685, -0.023440459743142128, -0.0549296960234642, 0.041746970266103745, 0.020120734348893166, 0.0008392638410441577, -0.017775312066078186, -0.03486103564500809, 0.014983241446316242, 0.031233079731464386, 0.0031065228395164013, -0.017411500215530396, 0.03675312548875809, 0.008834490552544594, 0.03273910656571388, 0.017745839431881905, 0.04364067688584328, 0.006310023367404938, -0.04117783159017563, -0.06954380124807358, 0.037884872406721115, 0.028602993115782738, -0.004740464501082897, -0.02819790691137314, 0.039367448538541794, -0.03644341230392456, 0.020412147045135498, 0.025450045242905617, 0.03309083729982376, -0.0364687480032444, -0.020789071917533875, 0.06688425689935684, -0.001286976388655603, 0.009197338484227657, -0.015253440476953983, 0.054879333823919296, -0.012024376541376114, 0.0549515038728714, -0.002647691871970892, -0.01596023514866829, 0.022399146109819412, 0.0027991249226033688, 0.06276971101760864, 0.028713857755064964, 0.0014345627278089523, 0.0030437149107456207, 0.02435987815260887, -0.03620444983243942, 0.055399924516677856, -0.01752779819071293, 0.00903141126036644, 0.03127981722354889, 0.048050764948129654, 0.03928062692284584, -0.006443603429943323, 0.0019805661868304014, 0.02686566300690174, -0.08414160460233688, -0.05402376875281334, 0.0037986126262694597, -0.0014131012139841914, 0.03847654163837433, -0.005664289928972721, -0.006723078899085522, -0.013800050131976604, -0.09279238432645798, -0.027873065322637558, 0.01294796634465456, -0.08433721214532852, -0.025550005957484245, 0.012740220874547958, -0.024520443752408028, -0.01070830412209034, 0.009714363142848015, -0.025227978825569153, 0.007469153497368097, -0.04462992399930954, 0.03145585209131241, -0.05305662751197815, -0.03515951335430145, 0.0037552888970822096, 0.007204101420938969, 0.039579715579748154, -0.06557916104793549, 0.06366778910160065, 0.0025210650637745857, -0.06673584878444672, -0.07113833725452423, 0.006613063160330057, -0.0063880267553031445, -0.00813261792063713, -0.03208027780056, -0.11109121888875961, 0.030405310913920403, 0.011992750689387321, 0.08131823688745499, 0.04414750635623932, 0.030252210795879364, -0.019476834684610367, -0.03640052303671837, 0.0012755406787618995, -0.051610417664051056, -0.03689500316977501, -0.013334130868315697, -0.049141429364681244, -0.08557513356208801, -0.04090125113725662, 0.026896443217992783, -0.07478734105825424, 0.015186719596385956, -0.04807101562619209, -0.027466464787721634, -0.07172422856092453, -0.0031649176962673664, 0.016815004870295525, 0.010705405846238136, -0.07856189459562302, 0.007907283492386341, 0.0010897463653236628, 0.035422246903181076, -0.018763966858386993, -0.04716206714510918, -0.008339779451489449, 0.05742452293634415, -0.008691602386534214, 0.017894012853503227, -0.04673830047249794, -0.05563342198729515, -0.07548633962869644, 0.04109364002943039, 0.04189930111169815, -0.08355892449617386, -0.02302463911473751, 0.026243114843964577, -0.001055146218277514, 0.032232314348220825, -0.06929704546928406, 0.027346836403012276, 0.019929643720388412, -0.017220430076122284, -0.01415499858558178, 0.04243810474872589, -0.028208976611495018, 0.03603533282876015, -0.04262479394674301, 0.03419061005115509, -0.03101913444697857, -0.037271786481142044, 0.02118053287267685, 0.04582760110497475, 0.022473549470305443, 0.005803041625767946, -0.0028027889784425497, -0.02615128643810749, 0.00534615945070982, -0.04135747253894806, 0.0027760507073253393, -0.005946391262114048, -0.020996512845158577, 0.0276880394667387, 0.02145283855497837, -0.000019825632989523, 0.02960243821144104, 0.03582969307899475 ]
<p>I can think of different “types” of multiple testing when using linear models for example:</p> <ol> <li>Multiple inferences because we have several dependent variables</li> <li>Multiple inferences because we have several independent variables</li> <li>Looking at the data without making any test. Running a test on only the comparisons that might possibly yield to a significant p.value.</li> <li>Running multiple different tests on the same data. (try a LM, if it is not significant, try a GLM, if it is still not significant try a beta regression, etc.)</li> </ol> <p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_comparisons" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a> says:</p> <blockquote> <p>[...] multiple testing problem occurs when one considers a set of statistical inferences simultaneously or <em>infers a subset of parameters selected based on the observed values</em>.</p> </blockquote> <p>Does the first part of what wikipedia says encompass my first two points and the part that I put in italics (after the "or") is equivalent to my third point ? Is it correct that my point 4 has nothing to do with what we call multiple testing ?</p> <p>If my question is too blurry, I might rephrase it this way:</p> <p><strong>When does an issue of multiple testing occur ? How would you categorize (if needed) the possible events of multiple testing ?</strong></p>
g37166
[ 0.047974757850170135, 0.01224435679614544, -0.00460868701338768, -0.0002613411925267428, 0.05425189062952995, -0.013790249824523926, -0.01748797856271267, 0.019142886623740196, -0.02634376473724842, 0.006812893785536289, -0.012833578512072563, -0.012652816250920296, 0.0018485852051526308, 0.04921022802591324, -0.0016258490504696965, -0.03652985394001007, 0.07775703817605972, -0.027640512213110924, 0.06437786668539047, 0.023314688354730606, -0.032905273139476776, 0.07538696378469467, -0.06063632667064667, 0.006032024510204792, -0.055962756276130676, -0.009659182280302048, -0.022172579541802406, 0.006747420411556959, -0.09089306741952896, -0.0023383842781186104, -0.008823240175843239, -0.03618210554122925, 0.05193185433745384, -0.03451405093073845, -0.01861230656504631, -0.043145790696144104, 0.021055234596133232, 0.05729316547513008, -0.0008759542251937091, -0.012257915921509266, -0.010705200023949146, 0.026322443038225174, 0.018290378153324127, -0.0022873643320053816, -0.0009433574159629643, 0.0011390913277864456, -0.024770045652985573, 0.030273305252194405, 0.061913881450891495, -0.05159797891974449, 0.04894666001200676, 0.022930460050702095, 0.053079210221767426, 0.008484473451972008, 0.04720573127269745, -0.0008980006095953286, -0.01816042698919773, 0.0687803402543068, -0.002957209711894393, 0.014567818492650986, 0.012782569974660873, 0.009064619429409504, -0.0664718747138977, -0.023708824068307877, 0.005482702516019344, 0.03562866523861885, -0.02614698000252247, -0.012319892644882202, 0.08405448496341705, -0.06260507553815842, -0.016386669129133224, -0.0022190390154719353, -0.011816266924142838, -0.06145341321825981, -0.020614782348275185, -0.016920266672968864, -0.020719477906823158, 0.007359638344496489, -0.0349217914044857, 0.05020379275083542, 0.0007674699882045388, 0.055537108331918716, 0.011907392181456089, 0.08751343190670013, 0.057696372270584106, -0.020988591015338898, 0.018946103751659393, -0.03740735352039337, -0.0013853824930265546, 0.0001913494197651744, 0.027988476678729057, 0.02073776349425316, 0.010375290177762508, 0.06720368564128876, -0.05839568376541138, -0.015525946393609047, -0.07378681004047394, 0.03825955465435982, 0.011796741746366024, 0.039809700101614, -0.037375349551439285, 0.021171310916543007, 0.0033520141150802374, -0.05728670209646225, 0.0044964952394366264, 0.008730314671993256, 0.02508031390607357, 0.035409245640039444, -0.07243276387453079, -0.021280640736222267, -0.057570844888687134, 0.03872095048427582, -0.07440351694822311, 0.004054397810250521, -0.09327806532382965, -0.03496003895998001, 0.05158160626888275, 0.008287233300507069, -0.012094555422663689, 0.012524960562586784, 0.038358405232429504, -0.006487489677965641, 0.02239120565354824, 0.08409727364778519, -0.03555066138505936, -0.04241630807518959, -0.04648610204458237, 0.012971628457307816, 0.02056252770125866, 0.0038438444025814533, 0.0011446367716416717, 0.035408664494752884, 0.041717372834682465, 0.008571213111281395, -0.005633977707475424, 0.016618870198726654, -0.030502457171678543, 0.03358258679509163, -0.040598172694444656, 0.012067966163158417, -0.03261187672615051, 0.002636889461427927, -0.00025270393234677613, -0.019663110375404358, 0.049518659710884094, -0.03694132715463638, -0.019482268020510674, -0.015924381092190742, -0.01362041849642992, 0.019217459484934807, 0.015529670752584934, 0.04451911151409149, 0.007938315160572529, -0.02071245387196541, 0.0294719859957695, 0.02095135860145092, -0.0224856398999691, -0.022484363988041878, -0.017210539430379868, 0.02246209792792797, 0.015904003754258156, -0.050828076899051666, 0.017713813111186028, -0.01459283847361803, 0.028406264260411263, 0.0803755596280098, -0.006820014677941799, -0.005986069794744253, 0.015677815303206444, -0.05216353014111519, 0.019601861014962196, -0.024495022371411324, 0.005526338238269091, -0.02359180897474289, 0.06482069194316864, 0.04988042637705803, 0.06946241855621338, -0.07221421599388123, -0.002903048414736986, 0.050680387765169144, -0.06666681915521622, 0.0037421979941427708, -0.031747665256261826, 0.004260167479515076, -0.010258972644805908, -0.03843655064702034, -0.03482178971171379, -0.0034669367596507072, -0.0002802681992761791, -0.01614244468510151, -0.03690309822559357, -0.05122027546167374, 0.02303553745150566, 0.00043748843017965555, 0.018205460160970688, -0.038415610790252686, -0.028684131801128387, -0.037889402359724045, 0.009669652208685875, -0.0386539027094841, 0.05827876180410385, -0.008174331858754158, -0.0595579594373703, 0.0719815120100975, -0.007974773645401001, 0.05354372784495354, 0.01515343226492405, 0.029775118455290794, -0.014883686788380146, 0.029582016170024872, 0.06956572830677032, -0.04413175955414772, 0.05485500767827034, 0.026324737817049026, -0.004065844230353832, -0.016198549419641495, -0.012338902801275253, 0.04856937751173973, -0.010157939977943897, 0.014101086184382439, 0.0004993906477466226, -0.042937543243169785, 0.01761305332183838, -0.011692831292748451, -0.013702080585062504, 0.032423198223114014, -0.00839643832296133, -0.06903588026762009, 0.013670073822140694, -0.030740827322006226, -0.012578028254210949, -0.061684973537921906, 0.024311894550919533, -0.05700154975056648, 0.004692342132329941, 0.01189702469855547, -0.033824991434812546, -0.02370218187570572, -0.06544023007154465, 0.030894728377461433, -0.018223365768790245, 0.0191615279763937, 0.02468368224799633, 0.049790214747190475, 0.03487829864025116, -0.019926657900214195, 0.034609969705343246, 0.017907649278640747, 0.04647640138864517, 0.10268665850162506, -0.0794849842786789, 0.028163501992821693, -0.02210194431245327, 0.02270737662911415, 0.022224541753530502, -0.027598563581705093, 0.05560295283794403, 0.025636116042733192, -0.04013841971755028, 0.02413078211247921, 0.04849037900567055, -0.04473324120044708, -0.04032149538397789, 0.00819722656160593, -0.00032831355929374695, -0.0001782961917342618, 0.003868920262902975, -0.06232060492038727, -0.04407669976353645, -0.00916750356554985, -0.016195466741919518, -0.010894219391047955, 0.0094470689073205, 0.021340521052479744, 0.017169693484902382, 0.004607693757861853, -0.05271584168076515, -0.0052765668369829655, 0.01572939194738865, -0.022771069779992104, 0.010614175349473953, -0.03937568515539169, -0.01837102696299553, -0.031174104660749435, 0.054434437304735184, -0.025939445942640305, 0.06851474940776825, -0.04219817742705345, -0.014612846076488495, 0.012453454546630383, -0.059190813452005386, -0.011014394462108612, 0.0847579836845398, -0.06167113780975342, -0.053907573223114014, 0.0023046929854899645, -0.027395334094762802, -0.07265854626893997, 0.04135792702436447, -0.007724100258201361, -0.020900225266814232, 0.022926917299628258, -0.007099447306245565, 0.08478081971406937, 0.12582623958587646, 0.016417117789387703, -0.014702691696584225, -0.05298156663775444, 0.02508106268942356, 0.025519607588648796, 0.01448842789977789, 0.03566625714302063, 0.014952530153095722, -0.006843415554612875, -0.01127810962498188, -0.009385970421135426, 0.01776186004281044, 0.04373740404844284, 0.014601465314626694, -0.04377572238445282, -0.039927899837493896, -0.02109951712191105, 0.025380386039614677, 0.016544101759791374, 0.008636031299829483, 0.04176342114806175, 0.009471542201936245, 0.015316887758672237, -0.0501086562871933, -0.023340148851275444, 0.01370480190962553, 0.04183969646692276, -0.0055540865287184715, 0.008409411646425724, 0.014888842590153217, -0.033339936286211014, -0.028718706220388412, -0.03782201185822487, 0.034501831978559494, -0.01996530033648014, 0.05420698598027229, -0.027538325637578964, -0.06332273036241531, -0.023571442812681198, -0.017328361049294472, -0.03776068612933159, 0.02025594748556614, 0.07038847357034683, 0.008043264038860798, -0.007217634003609419, 0.02243475615978241, -0.005687941797077656, -0.04405532032251358, -0.016540534794330597, 0.031076962128281593, 0.010868287645280361, 0.024417022243142128, 0.007457532919943333, 0.00028362817829474807, 0.006655109114944935, 0.04003876447677612, -0.044618699699640274, -0.0030734525062143803, 0.004162140656262636, 0.03828617185354233, 0.021321997046470642, 0.05616193264722824, 0.02489876002073288, 0.04468519613146782, -0.023376481607556343, 0.0491434782743454, 0.005866202060133219, -0.05827337130904198, -0.0035468093119561672, 0.10070830583572388, -0.03691704571247101, 0.03864669054746628, 0.050111766904592514, -0.042626406997442245, 0.058954402804374695, 0.02903246134519577, 0.014465334825217724, 0.006420164834707975, 0.02312297560274601, 0.04357285425066948, -0.04426928982138634, 0.02574222721159458, -0.0055703772231936455, -0.033891938626766205, -0.00910623837262392, 0.06549710780382156, 0.04480352997779846, -0.08495691418647766, 0.036009982228279114, 0.05310815945267677, -0.02558821626007557, 0.01978551410138607, 0.008306829258799553, -0.008734017610549927, 0.06039267033338547, -0.005545387044548988, -0.04000736400485039, -0.000738820992410183, -0.004520572256296873, -0.06249692291021347, -0.027802567929029465, -0.015631532296538353, 0.037300046533346176, -0.02649407647550106, 0.004554086364805698, 0.0036517344415187836, -0.0455971285700798, -0.025531461462378502, 0.0018307911232113838, -0.0004138382792007178, 0.0083894869312644, 0.060195665806531906, -0.06695783138275146, -0.029098644852638245, 0.04408377781510353, -0.010508038103580475, 0.04879548028111458, -0.03392718732357025, -0.024397073313593864, 0.0311348345130682, -0.00966482050716877, 0.07538643479347229, 0.029662515968084335, 0.01689230464398861, -0.03558243811130524, -0.021007901057600975, 0.005644945427775383, 0.006441980600357056, 0.037101902067661285, 0.07884479314088821, -0.016769565641880035, -0.026542404666543007, 0.07533305138349533, 0.0009260469814762473, -0.0003134080325253308, -0.012639379128813744, -0.01042650081217289, -0.07517079263925552, 0.030199643224477768, -0.0015727849677205086, 0.030030718073248863, 0.006472396198660135, 0.020161649212241173, -0.013895612210035324, -0.013342066667973995, -0.10640455037355423, 0.03673941642045975, -0.038824304938316345, 0.023973584175109863, -0.03500858321785927, -0.005587355699390173, 0.07949289679527283, -0.01182026881724596, -0.02274194359779358, 0.03924816846847534, 0.03266572579741478, -0.0026710813399404287, 0.025997675955295563, -0.007234613876789808, 0.022437376901507378, -0.048781268298625946, -0.06418000906705856, -0.024055231362581253, -0.04245518893003464, -0.07643027603626251, 0.00007495824684156105, -0.0025936185847967863, -0.00048816754133440554, 0.029138455167412758, 0.040956780314445496, -0.008125988766551018, 0.023868948221206665, 0.009286513552069664, -0.019427575170993805, -0.018839094787836075, 0.03093896061182022, -0.05653049796819687, 0.012239208444952965, 0.007035485468804836, -0.013775773346424103, -0.0076281847432255745, 0.05604130029678345, -0.10819721966981888, 0.04883232340216637, 0.02269754745066166, 0.027433795854449272, -0.03180712088942528, 0.05682118982076645, -0.0025480869226157665, -0.03346182405948639, 0.010106693021953106, -0.009768728166818619, -0.026662718504667282, -0.021723542362451553, -0.05618970841169357, 0.005479229148477316, -0.011628014035522938, 0.06273069977760315, -0.027703167870640755, -0.023303275927901268, 0.019945945590734482, 0.034280650317668915, -0.041741013526916504, 0.009585217572748661, 0.04191410541534424, -0.02812488190829754, 0.011023096740245819, -0.06897646188735962, -0.013880377635359764, 0.0004966618726029992, -0.027767257764935493, -0.005391925107687712, -0.01134748850017786, -0.026214273646473885, -0.060396671295166016, 0.02993413433432579, 0.021900249645113945, 0.03263142332434654, -0.017325054854154587, 0.042906083166599274, -0.05242203548550606, -0.04817526042461395, -0.012370390817523003, 0.008702858351171017, 0.01862982288002968, 0.014483792707324028, 0.03658803552389145, 0.03960374742746353, 0.031169258058071136, 0.0023137496318668127, -0.024158693850040436, -0.036288872361183167, -0.02942998707294464, 0.04030211642384529, 0.050282977521419525, -0.055239517241716385, -0.01742892526090145, 0.022318268194794655, 0.0009402390569448471, -0.014019695110619068, -0.0005431985482573509, -0.013692748732864857, -0.0022029266692698, 0.01203424483537674, -0.007697820197790861, -0.023856395855545998, 0.013115712441504002, -0.04403494670987129, 0.009656873531639576, 0.005082489922642708, -0.011539098806679249, 0.002850529970601201, -0.018920496106147766, -0.006688952911645174, -0.04508510231971741, 0.0008083841530606151, -0.011739264242351055, 0.004025518428534269, 0.019936256110668182, -0.016514502465724945, 0.018791085109114647, -0.061228860169649124, -0.0557246059179306, -0.04048088565468788, 0.01585649698972702, 0.07932750135660172, -0.016269266605377197, 0.008261838927865028, 0.02021973393857479, 0.058204565197229385, 0.035289373248815536, 0.014888524077832699, 0.02615969441831112, 0.020279567688703537, -0.028031934052705765, 0.009413467720150948, -0.006834051571786404, 0.04409606382250786, -0.014955473132431507, 0.030713584274053574, 0.047945380210876465, -0.015217684209346771, 0.01831524446606636, -0.055961281061172485, -0.033290740102529526, -0.016102049499750137, -0.002349201589822769, -0.008504301309585571, -0.015496274456381798, -0.01518699899315834, -0.048966944217681885, -0.008011812344193459, 0.06848499923944473, -0.048409003764390945, 0.008472131565213203, 0.024193337187170982, -0.055877912789583206, 0.07049234956502914, -0.05214579030871391, 0.008903751149773598, 0.059064172208309174, -0.009892231784760952, -0.016921652480959892, -0.009286411106586456, -0.018002742901444435, -0.0430457666516304, -0.004442054312676191, 0.025974536314606667, 0.004624812863767147, -0.037601981312036514, -0.0010971736628562212, -0.1027674525976181, -0.06885365396738052, -0.010551979765295982, 0.015483812429010868, 0.04594727233052254, -0.04605434089899063, 0.013464251533150673, -0.011434824205935001, -0.003502992680296302, 0.055679213255643845, -0.004547618795186281, -0.013965120539069176, -0.013783920556306839, -0.006999450270086527, -0.019506407901644707, -0.051717180758714676, -0.019487101584672928, 0.03242013230919838, -0.0809180811047554, -0.047505468130111694, -0.058972619473934174, 0.01938171312212944, 0.00459326570853591, 0.030031392350792885, 0.010800610296428204, 0.009460539557039738, -0.02439846657216549, 0.0019705481827259064, 0.054025668650865555, 0.0036838760133832693, 0.05138477310538292, -0.003089084755629301, -0.02482597529888153, 0.0032593163195997477, 0.009774121455848217, 0.00038137371302582324, 0.006923073902726173, -0.0069701820611953735, -0.022834748029708862, 0.08252722024917603, 0.0547892265021801, 0.02716643549501896, -0.021790536120533943, -0.00015163986245170236, -0.04841932654380798, -0.013662321493029594, -0.07508102804422379, -0.016296908259391785, -0.04359233379364014, 0.012417444959282875, 0.0287821926176548, -0.08466404676437378, 0.031865183264017105, -0.0155040193349123, -0.025121517479419708, -0.006974177900701761, -0.029056482017040253, 0.048255447298288345, 0.02021450735628605, -0.016009721904993057, 0.023603733628988266, 0.034570660442113876, 0.00927047524601221, 0.018722327426075935, -0.04424452409148216, 0.0035472637973725796, 0.03796367719769478, -0.02038789913058281, -0.014104960486292839, -0.02262311428785324, -0.0168768260627985, -0.02147558704018593, 0.04599370062351227, -0.0376460887491703, 0.021521344780921936, -0.02184440754354, 0.040115464478731155, -0.03759795427322388, -0.01380868535488844, 0.041946567595005035, 0.05618254840373993, -0.01070796512067318, 0.015157997608184814, 0.039934899657964706, -0.05727844685316086, 0.06952887773513794, -0.0034409458748996258, -0.014161832630634308, 0.0002012364857364446, -0.0068738567642867565, -0.03203616663813591, 0.03212229162454605, 0.017395449802279472, -0.0035276326816529036, 0.0015775351785123348, 0.05276438593864441, -0.02700086496770382, 0.06350311636924744, -0.02661094255745411, -0.04807458817958832, 0.006544060539454222, -0.014156498946249485, -0.015994708985090256, -0.0463644415140152, -0.004294949118047953, -0.03400607407093048, -0.035086292773485184, 0.0071967788971960545, 0.03560155630111694, -0.044407229870557785, 0.032689545303583145, 0.011849080212414265, -0.01500574592500925, 0.032090924680233, -0.035907164216041565, -0.044427212327718735, -0.035904426127672195, 0.05184901878237724, 0.026044027879834175, 0.03165653720498085, 0.0474834069609642, 0.041688885539770126, 0.0002396858762949705, 0.008542321622371674, 0.03968995064496994, 0.028766576200723648, 0.006210078485310078, 0.013762496411800385, -0.030831027776002884, -0.018043506890535355, -0.03290597349405289, 0.03399381786584854, 0.054895225912332535, -0.039134182035923004, -0.06178436428308487, 0.0007922243676148355, 0.004766342230141163, 0.05539678409695625, -0.025554370135068893, 0.01144929975271225, -0.01982867531478405, 0.007256963290274143, 0.1026310920715332, 0.008430150337517262, -0.004990212619304657, 0.018635375425219536, -0.03677340969443321, -0.06565304845571518, 0.015439488925039768, -0.07331369817256927, -0.028184933587908745, 0.046609826385974884 ]
<p>I need to proof that $X$ follows a distribution $F$ with probability $1-p$ and a distribution $G$ with probability $p$ if, and only if, its distribution function is:</p> <p>$(1-p)F + pG$</p> <p>Can anyone give me some hints about how to proof this?</p> <p><strong>EDIT2</strong>: this is my <em>second</em> take based on comments:</p> <p>$$F_p(x)=Pr(X\le x)=\int_{-\infty}^x dF_p(x)=(1-p)\int_{-\infty}^xdF(x)+p \int_{-\infty}^xdG(x) = (1-p)F+pG$$</p> <p>but I am not sure if this is a valid proof</p>
g74325
[ -0.001116461120545864, 0.0401369109749794, -0.0028804289177060127, -0.018879525363445282, 0.012439531274139881, -0.03871713951230049, -0.016973083838820457, 0.042051758617162704, -0.01645124889910221, -0.03246881067752838, -0.02967742085456848, 0.016410550102591515, -0.009645223617553711, 0.00626554898917675, 0.03407512232661247, 0.012566652148962021, 0.032881706953048706, -0.002033798722550273, -0.0020884815603494644, 0.019776461645960808, -0.03608063980937004, -0.015657275915145874, 0.03508782386779785, -0.08586835861206055, 0.026636384427547455, -0.03530643880367279, 0.014015788212418556, 0.004349204711616039, 0.0025347252376377583, 0.0452246330678463, -0.01723409630358219, -0.03751833736896515, 0.04411286488175392, -0.0789959579706192, 0.03879907354712486, 0.021860161796212196, 0.06527041643857956, 0.02109179086983204, 0.04858721047639847, -0.010629222728312016, -0.03760712221264839, 0.027980277314782143, 0.0535581149160862, -0.006963622756302357, -0.0369570218026638, -0.004887383431196213, 0.007219440303742886, 0.08089076727628708, 0.015370400622487068, -0.03960238769650459, -0.023674698546528816, 0.050443604588508606, 0.021405356004834175, -0.008482581004500389, -0.08150267601013184, 0.05404854193329811, 0.02440420165657997, -0.017416946589946747, 0.019588110968470573, -0.006817010696977377, 0.02660408616065979, -0.04793119058012962, -0.001271876972168684, -0.002755663590505719, -0.026558393612504005, -0.024410653859376907, -0.02850872278213501, -0.015317978337407112, 0.006552429869771004, 0.017921319231390953, -0.012952666729688644, 0.004998862277716398, 0.0434785857796669, -0.0571410208940506, 0.010477771051228046, -0.019251883029937744, 0.05132218450307846, 0.01740896888077259, 0.0038052015006542206, 0.04579227417707443, 0.0024270417634397745, 0.0002740240015555173, 0.04113447666168213, -0.058996379375457764, -0.039915427565574646, -0.042489003390073776, 0.07446128875017166, -0.03879624977707863, -0.00924325454980135, 0.03433753922581673, 0.039878301322460175, -0.03173322230577469, -0.019304340705275536, 0.0054390463046729565, -0.001076559885405004, -0.0012209099950268865, -0.0559718944132328, 0.011538345366716385, -0.0226353220641613, 0.002122376812621951, 0.04815175011754036, 0.01345316506922245, 0.008716456592082977, -0.030453555285930634, -0.04535940662026405, -0.0051224688068032265, -0.020396441221237183, 0.0488833524286747, -0.027781467884778976, -0.01840578205883503, -0.04836611822247505, -0.02245042659342289, -0.013880609534680843, -0.07394660264253616, 0.029196342453360558, -0.0014230223605409265, 0.07390007376670837, -0.039661258459091187, 0.03124898485839367, 0.05222282186150551, -0.014556048437952995, -0.02093556523323059, 0.06173703074455261, 0.11519455164670944, -0.03772130236029625, -0.02568693831562996, -0.001463794382289052, 0.00939157698303461, -0.007484384346753359, -0.014460502192378044, 0.0327967032790184, 0.04873284325003624, -0.013989525847136974, 0.018881091848015785, -0.017351146787405014, 0.027408363297581673, 0.0347721092402935, 0.018467333167791367, 0.0029435816686600447, 0.006461306940764189, -0.05928921326994896, 0.00442033214494586, 0.050894297659397125, -0.0023273860570043325, 0.0031594561878591776, 0.04859457537531853, 0.0034451119136065245, 0.00805544201284647, -0.0052649169228971004, -0.005421418230980635, -0.043879974633455276, 0.00784571748226881, -0.06626643985509872, 0.029113344848155975, -0.008925008587539196, -0.002998374169692397, 0.04075498878955841, 0.02232871763408184, 0.003655018750578165, -0.03355351835489273, 0.05744953826069832, 0.021771036088466644, -0.027348365634679794, -0.012540489435195923, -0.01609552837908268, -0.0007608715677633882, 0.02581787109375, -0.019254855811595917, -0.047877732664346695, -0.041571639478206635, -0.03149770200252533, 0.019389009103178978, 0.032366152852773666, 0.012511310167610645, 0.021918216720223427, -0.043704837560653687, -0.022811753675341606, -0.023255998268723488, 0.0002408784639555961, 0.008061948232352734, -0.03404538333415985, 0.0374927781522274, 0.014024727046489716, -0.007799671497195959, -0.02268042229115963, -0.04447459056973457, 0.01314750500023365, -0.011966688558459282, -0.027831634506583214, 0.03587861731648445, -0.040746208280324936, 0.028000950813293457, 0.006931772455573082, 0.03629066422581673, -0.011710182763636112, 0.028546549379825592, 0.012949870899319649, -0.054187413305044174, 0.011582969687879086, -0.021790869534015656, 0.011326572857797146, 0.005128796678036451, 0.0509573332965374, 0.04611799120903015, 0.009359175339341164, -0.03790378198027611, -0.012889262288808823, -0.015598030760884285, 0.012737858109176159, 0.025941312313079834, -0.012055129744112492, -0.08818358927965164, -0.03568359836935997, 0.041850000619888306, 0.05486653372645378, -0.037563666701316833, -0.046065688133239746, -0.04902798682451248, -0.016587965190410614, -0.030256669968366623, -0.03987555205821991, -0.04148197919130325, 0.0161103717982769, 0.03766774758696556, -0.013915613293647766, 0.09326034039258957, 0.004498044494539499, -0.008476683869957924, -0.030085016041994095, 0.05819933861494064, -0.0009778736857697368, -0.04192359745502472, -0.043862201273441315, -0.02583492361009121, 0.02851961925625801, 0.04705055058002472, -0.02196408435702324, 0.032375264912843704, 0.016437213867902756, 0.03356302157044411, -0.0695679634809494, -0.022612720727920532, 0.034950315952301025, 0.04091142117977142, 0.045263953506946564, 0.006251852959394455, -0.021729104220867157, -0.002220493508502841, 0.030847545713186264, -0.016029417514801025, 0.007200015243142843, 0.0023570589255541563, 0.007763830479234457, -0.008893745951354504, 0.021512337028980255, -0.060588207095861435, 0.022602396085858345, -0.03166477009654045, 0.005068624392151833, -0.020333800464868546, 0.00888094212859869, -0.02498737722635269, -0.0298197902739048, -0.020143402740359306, -0.06378448009490967, 0.0128912553191185, -0.006182721350342035, 0.019965941086411476, 0.03896848484873772, -0.013514125719666481, 0.06296656280755997, 0.02895387075841427, 0.02462673746049404, 0.07627154886722565, -0.007885677739977837, 0.017948273569345474, -0.018243180587887764, -0.04310210049152374, -0.0003453207027632743, 0.0070575145073235035, 0.058914992958307266, -0.012673106044530869, 0.004967709071934223, 0.006159699056297541, 0.0029675462283194065, -0.059235550463199615, 0.07348684966564178, -0.017757652327418327, -0.052250705659389496, 0.04189902916550636, 0.018444597721099854, 0.0005693825078196824, 0.018602078780531883, -0.0035718712024390697, -0.035602010786533356, 0.013566494919359684, -0.007582380902022123, -0.0325368233025074, 0.020347589626908302, -0.08015114814043045, 0.007445449475198984, -0.03595492243766785, 0.005691496189683676, 0.004315458238124847, 0.0828968808054924, -0.04330994561314583, 0.027072539553046227, 0.05890120938420296, 0.007963142357766628, 0.02099534310400486, 0.04204024747014046, 0.06786099076271057, -0.035650093108415604, -0.026535427197813988, -0.03051530010998249, -0.03796358406543732, -0.02046140842139721, 0.007876251824200153, -0.03210302069783211, -0.08827158808708191, 0.0025554790627211332, -0.02931782603263855, -0.013564785942435265, 0.022984793409705162, 0.07349114865064621, -0.025291765108704567, -0.045446623116731644, 0.007428821641951799, 0.006709208246320486, -0.0279155932366848, 0.042283471673727036, 0.05909298360347748, 0.0023100594989955425, 0.0003673737228382379, -0.001571481698192656, -0.010117931291460991, 0.04660356789827347, 0.05028456822037697, 0.009830811060965061, 0.024850845336914062, 0.03408999368548393, -0.01597577892243862, -0.04579733684659004, 0.024712666869163513, -0.00719835190102458, -0.018665039911866188, 0.060443632304668427, 0.03970654681324959, 0.09523994475603104, 0.03817981854081154, -0.008027340285480022, -0.0038556777872145176, 0.051950596272945404, -0.03461453318595886, 0.03856305405497551, 0.00696238549426198, 0.07113389670848846, -0.03597334772348404, 0.055494777858257294, -0.048264775425195694, 0.02573906071484089, -0.04817056283354759, -0.008103967644274235, 0.06441550701856613, -0.00014544356963597238, 0.019789865240454674, 0.029539678245782852, -0.02458951622247696, 0.013731851242482662, 0.03886507824063301, 0.007076878100633621, -0.02962685376405716, 0.07912812381982803, -0.0037667083088308573, 0.04288474842905998, -0.07073531299829483, 0.041057247668504715, 0.034487534314394, -0.027423331514000893, -0.004216592758893967, 0.06300995498895645, 0.0056590307503938675, 0.05569613352417946, 0.041907940059900284, 0.04387161135673523, -0.009119365364313126, -0.01893468387424946, -0.007982736453413963, 0.05528717115521431, -0.002055360237136483, 0.025569317862391472, -0.005968928337097168, -0.03949171304702759, 0.04557911306619644, 0.023494236171245575, -0.022048991173505783, -0.009398899041116238, -0.010756024159491062, -0.06561877578496933, 0.009126671589910984, -0.03246684744954109, -0.02898702584207058, 0.02088366635143757, -0.09767347574234009, 0.017722515389323235, -0.06425822526216507, -0.05182284861803055, -0.08582780510187149, -0.00910140573978424, 0.00222518527880311, 0.02841821499168873, -0.030174488201737404, 0.021442392840981483, -0.002665294101461768, -0.05889201909303665, 0.02156568318605423, 0.022155199199914932, -0.019054260104894638, 0.019558770582079887, -0.005734695587307215, 0.043590445071458817, 0.05548160895705223, 0.017466392368078232, 0.024276813492178917, -0.036556072533130646, 0.005154818762093782, 0.06315678358078003, 0.020635535940527916, -0.029034841805696487, -0.037086356431245804, -0.04978349432349205, 0.04003235325217247, 0.058748893439769745, -0.029353167861700058, -0.027713268995285034, -0.005181418266147375, -0.00302642909809947, 0.026215685531497, -0.01723267138004303, 0.020741349086165428, 0.028174081817269325, -0.0382688082754612, 0.004614305216819048, 0.005783573724329472, 0.017439868301153183, -0.039273228496313095, -0.03849456086754799, 0.014168369583785534, 0.04022165387868881, -0.03194168210029602, 0.022530851885676384, 0.03648253157734871, -0.004784906283020973, -0.04554679989814758, 0.02995705045759678, 0.05013652145862579, -0.011376970447599888, 0.07897672057151794, -0.003738111350685358, 0.005735804792493582, 0.005586510524153709, -0.004348640330135822, 0.07869554311037064, -0.005089917685836554, -0.015247030183672905, 0.02869986742734909, -0.04333332180976868, -0.041291624307632446, 0.006065142806619406, -0.02045397274196148, -0.03491927683353424, -0.014460403472185135, 0.001456078258343041, 0.011620253324508667, -0.01560278795659542, 0.044929396361112595, 0.01181772630661726, -0.008485283702611923, 0.019914455711841583, -0.02728106826543808, 0.02452944591641426, 0.0178675539791584, -0.04405110329389572, -0.005949897691607475, 0.015996605157852173, -0.03209276124835014, 0.00041263349703513086, -0.022032666951417923, 0.007994374260306358, -0.04615394026041031, -0.007029149681329727, -0.002464404096826911, 0.04782600700855255, 0.05692926049232483, -0.03083127737045288, -0.08972930908203125, 0.03884872794151306, -0.016735853627324104, 0.036866724491119385, -0.02755824662744999, -0.08632232248783112, -0.016014864668250084, -0.002606000518426299, 0.005896919406950474, 0.031494978815317154, 0.05292005091905594, 0.011957844719290733, 0.012028287164866924, -0.0207725390791893, 0.05603910610079765, 0.019812779501080513, 0.009159705601632595, -0.004563343245536089, -0.06973090767860413, -0.015309084206819534, -0.00859049241989851, -0.03872919827699661, -0.012704080902040005, -0.03518257662653923, -0.03387407585978508, 0.09423130005598068, -0.011217472143471241, 0.051708854734897614, -0.014053262770175934, -0.006976349279284477, -0.07639771699905396, -0.1098257526755333, -0.0247502364218235, -0.005627843551337719, 0.02447417378425598, 0.041161954402923584, -0.015129937790334225, -0.05445490777492523, -0.01403936930000782, -0.05049121379852295, -0.03442190960049629, 0.06434458494186401, -0.0013724940363317728, 0.04522550478577614, -0.002104489365592599, 0.025882920250296593, 0.009356288239359856, 0.016180889680981636, 0.003726601367816329, -0.12043556571006775, -0.02384391613304615, -0.026005299761891365, -0.016519300639629364, 0.021678023040294647, -0.04469503462314606, 0.08319833874702454, 0.03710928559303284, -0.02211587131023407, -0.0459107831120491, 0.05101662874221802, 0.024348672479391098, 0.040046464651823044, -0.059057511389255524, 0.0533127561211586, -0.03080032207071781, -0.022536592558026314, -0.134762704372406, 0.0015644729137420654, -0.019628074020147324, 0.0060775489546358585, -0.034515753388404846, 0.05462227016687393, -0.04939371347427368, -0.04098225012421608, 0.05307827144861221, -0.017446182668209076, 0.018662624061107635, 0.0068598524667322636, 0.0028174356557428837, 0.049465298652648926, -0.014810253866016865, -0.032252393662929535, -0.014553749933838844, -0.000617370184045285, -0.0783458799123764, -0.04130832105875015, 0.023204950615763664, -0.004219153430312872, -0.005939301569014788, -0.07458456605672836, -0.0015019949059933424, -0.03338019549846649, -0.0496329590678215, 0.01796680875122547, -0.01788691245019436, -0.05508068948984146, -0.034120623022317886, -0.030185995623469353, 0.007651170250028372, -0.019974013790488243, -0.02912803553044796, 0.015644680708646774, 0.0052708894945681095, 0.020980384200811386, -0.02849196270108223, 0.02259111776947975, 0.02182355709373951, 0.027126455679535866, -0.12642693519592285, -0.0423029288649559, -0.002219183836132288, 0.0315120667219162, 0.020375307649374008, 0.02313019335269928, 0.02518816851079464, 0.045726411044597626, 0.05935422331094742, 0.02084617130458355, 0.0011180007131770253, -0.014932660385966301, -0.05803610756993294, -0.06546427309513092, -0.001890848041512072, -0.003550121793523431, -0.006198583170771599, 0.0571463368833065, 0.012845686636865139, -0.06576080620288849, -0.019481772556900978, 0.028888463973999023, 0.029001718387007713, 0.027922363951802254, 0.005988243501633406, 0.02813681960105896, -0.013490605168044567, 0.028645064681768417, 0.07279818505048752, -0.0428692102432251, -0.01843792200088501, -0.04901349917054176, 0.041248857975006104, -0.05575938895344734, 0.039208702743053436, 0.033747293055057526, 0.02436848171055317, -0.00851566530764103, 0.0422237403690815, 0.0054357885383069515, -0.006118264980614185, 0.033358193933963776, 0.011495579034090042, 0.011217751540243626, 0.00044064599205739796, -0.028856974095106125, 0.015404433943331242, 0.022601710632443428, -0.035694435238838196, 0.01259568240493536, -0.026022419333457947, 0.00768761383369565, 0.008458725176751614, 0.08993323892354965, 0.021865198388695717, -0.018796637654304504, -0.02554640732705593, -0.01144703384488821, -0.07430652529001236, -0.013449098914861679, -0.026922250166535378, -0.03741513192653656, 0.026794958859682083, 0.011814158409833908, -0.05133822560310364, -0.08167650550603867, -0.031065521761775017, 0.019901862367987633, 0.00883561372756958, -0.014855324290692806, -0.011396568268537521, 0.0023366089444607496, 0.03147900849580765, 0.049170736223459244, 0.017132842913269997, -0.024974564090371132, 0.012696415185928345, -0.047806207090616226, 0.029761729761958122, -0.05354272574186325, -0.016368290409445763, 0.021874018013477325, 0.022358320653438568, 0.0417935848236084, 0.015703534707427025, -0.01836351491510868, 0.013439563103020191, -0.0554116815328598, -0.06087510660290718, 0.0321221798658371, -0.01004284992814064, -0.015722885727882385, -0.011526891961693764, -0.04549279063940048, 0.012947315350174904, 0.006333630997687578, 0.050083477050065994, -0.035991787910461426, 0.013682061806321144, -0.07583358883857727, 0.018481813371181488, 0.035771533846855164, 0.02132834680378437, 0.0026316805742681026, 0.0016390590462833643, 0.023352235555648804, -0.05307547375559807, 0.06409242004156113, -0.053341712802648544, -0.03800472989678383, -0.03190196305513382, 0.05525793135166168, -0.0010996406199410558, -0.03433674946427345, -0.007248185109347105, 0.03414485976099968, 0.01227893028408289, -0.0017393536400049925, -0.008008703589439392, -0.00706034479662776, -0.030693713575601578, -0.026418423280119896, 0.03449298068881035, -0.019548475742340088, -0.022222837433218956, -0.005905063357204199, 0.07102034986019135, -0.03599405288696289, -0.006386543624103069, -0.0309761893004179, 0.015571687370538712, 0.00258182012476027, -0.027171973139047623, 0.026034614071249962, -0.008391554467380047, 0.04888005927205086, 0.04126475751399994, -0.020346326753497124, -0.03664566949009895, 0.004068343434482813, -0.0010235270019620657, 0.006092878524214029, 0.001329746562987566, 0.025998910889029503, 0.025446692481637, 0.03148286044597626, -0.030447522178292274, -0.034321416169404984, 0.0013158407527953386, -0.026224181056022644, 0.04805396497249603, -0.02498563565313816, -0.05425213649868965, 0.007816905155777931, 0.02841537818312645, 0.08643627911806107, -0.0235423743724823, 0.028012949973344803, -0.05620875209569931, -0.044891223311424255, 0.03219133988022804, -0.005924317054450512, 0.04612642899155617, 0.03854808211326599, -0.036247700452804565 ]
<p>In statistics people gather a lot of data (ie heights of people or gene expression levels) to get some insight. Then in order to perform statistical analyses they try to fit their data to a theoretical distribution (ie Normal Distribution) by computing some parameters.</p> <p>How do we know that our data follows such a distribution? If we were able to measure all objects in a population and draw a distribution we could probably get something different, a different shape than the theoretical distribution we thought of. Aren’t our calculations wrong then if we use a theoretical distribution?</p> <p>Please correct me if I am wrong and tell me what you think of this. I think this is a very basic concept in statistics and I have to clarify it.</p>
g74326
[ 0.04868483543395996, 0.015912719070911407, -0.013099593110382557, -0.033625900745391846, 0.008669638074934483, 0.01806955225765705, -0.0031958387698978186, 0.03958529606461525, -0.042779434472322464, -0.05078154802322388, 0.0007800518651492894, -0.03927520290017128, 0.08892282098531723, 0.005897094029933214, -0.015390272252261639, 0.00041725009214133024, -0.0254984013736248, -0.053323403000831604, 0.03578654304146767, 0.06757454574108124, -0.01607263647019863, 0.03136177733540535, 0.052470896393060684, -0.008778033778071404, -0.13900776207447052, -0.02622254565358162, -0.002889472059905529, 0.04712851345539093, 0.01701311208307743, 0.019190149381756783, -0.005462205037474632, 0.02410605549812317, 0.05186344310641289, -0.053517792373895645, -0.033764343708753586, -0.0536789707839489, 0.031520258635282516, 0.0343208983540535, 0.06313082575798035, 0.020924527198076248, 0.00813265796750784, -0.023306358605623245, -0.032163456082344055, -0.044730860739946365, -0.031861212104558945, 0.02569611370563507, -0.008611074648797512, 0.01364209596067667, 0.06550861150026321, -0.032765161246061325, -0.011744259856641293, 0.02265474572777748, -0.02173626236617565, 0.06228445842862129, 0.07238039374351501, 0.03685317188501358, 0.0625133067369461, -0.023965701460838318, 0.1138354167342186, -0.06395100802183151, 0.059839848428964615, -0.0013676463859155774, -0.04335097223520279, 0.03288453817367554, 0.03429647162556648, 0.00446245027706027, -0.02547968178987503, -0.009611818008124828, 0.052087295800447464, -0.04043804109096527, 0.009581645019352436, -0.03345979005098343, 0.018261684104800224, -0.022028880193829536, -0.06619886308908463, 0.01527613215148449, 0.025457823649048805, 0.051855091005563736, 0.012774311937391758, 0.054668571799993515, 0.008315403945744038, -0.022918103262782097, 0.026538319885730743, 0.041308045387268066, 0.01967429369688034, 0.01506448071449995, -0.018035994842648506, -0.01736626587808132, 0.03591342642903328, 0.05148087069392204, 0.02370150201022625, -0.003555432427674532, 0.12041604518890381, 0.032005321234464645, -0.08759364485740662, -0.029947808012366295, -0.0718996524810791, 0.0037105062510818243, -0.017978498712182045, -0.020319296047091484, -0.00559919374063611, 0.043646059930324554, -0.015446589328348637, -0.018529240041971207, -0.06278692930936813, 0.008949105627834797, 0.022458946332335472, 0.04053333029150963, -0.004538256675004959, -0.02805081196129322, -0.037221524864435196, 0.007275004871189594, -0.03732074052095413, 0.003304119221866131, -0.022739214822649956, -0.06503571569919586, 0.09497895836830139, -0.03986420854926109, -0.0004191985644865781, -0.007228940259665251, 0.0017283675260841846, -0.0018813514616340399, 0.018892252817749977, 0.06568671017885208, -0.017419299110770226, -0.003756662830710411, -0.0011607978958636522, 0.012910442426800728, -0.007026789244264364, -0.006438371259719133, 0.041139427572488785, 0.003907945938408375, -0.005191662348806858, 0.030959412455558777, 0.0452822670340538, 0.03570014610886574, -0.04594894126057625, 0.015113070607185364, 0.006234167143702507, 0.06217304244637489, 0.015162273310124874, 0.051746029406785965, 0.026530491188168526, -0.07825599610805511, 0.00709321815520525, 0.019590143114328384, -0.015638623386621475, -0.019348232075572014, -0.0229671411216259, 0.009769508615136147, -0.031356342136859894, 0.022489111870527267, 0.024932382628321648, -0.02845960482954979, 0.0035261160228401423, -0.01028137281537056, -0.025181259959936142, 0.08223071694374084, 0.02559192292392254, 0.007802007719874382, 0.041933801025152206, -0.060151152312755585, -0.00793446321040392, 0.01731298677623272, -0.0017660710727795959, -0.03460714593529701, 0.01300216093659401, -0.05287597328424454, -0.010184760205447674, -0.035316284745931625, 0.03232038766145706, 0.014719932340085506, -0.052525803446769714, -0.017775408923625946, -0.008573062717914581, 0.04036087542772293, 0.04011879488825798, -0.0000541280533070676, 0.04217391461133957, 0.032375771552324295, -0.038583990186452866, 0.047747716307640076, 0.017050381749868393, -0.09901206940412521, 0.01786496303975582, -0.03800485283136368, 0.018970981240272522, -0.018492190167307854, 0.01368374191224575, 0.007433683145791292, -0.03637257218360901, -0.0434594489634037, 0.03229433298110962, -0.013637308031320572, 0.012332065030932426, -0.03587234020233154, 0.013965305872261524, -0.05554686486721039, 0.0014516422525048256, -0.011786827817559242, -0.0021148337982594967, -0.01943487673997879, -0.030132407322525978, 0.04464224353432655, -0.00300635420717299, -0.014135080389678478, 0.04199584573507309, 0.00770191615447402, -0.013274796307086945, 0.026630442589521408, 0.018800558522343636, -0.02012624219059944, -0.01264165062457323, 0.0532633475959301, -0.04724324122071266, 0.01995091885328293, -0.019888577982783318, -0.0689188614487648, -0.007286173291504383, -0.023423589766025543, -0.018761763349175453, -0.07258065789937973, 0.012675914913415909, 0.03969963267445564, 0.02348381094634533, 0.03251905366778374, -0.03424748033285141, -0.048441555351018906, -0.021313538774847984, 0.007738858927041292, -0.01564171351492405, -0.04198959097266197, 0.02255379967391491, -0.009242109954357147, 0.011889457702636719, 0.02941746823489666, -0.04206611216068268, 0.02566933073103428, 0.007348169572651386, 0.03315476328134537, -0.005939011927694082, -0.07192198187112808, 0.020381733775138855, 0.014717812649905682, -0.017204008996486664, -0.002253113314509392, 0.04574885964393616, -0.02572949416935444, 0.012519910000264645, 0.05640562251210213, -0.0024533458054065704, 0.0005876101204194129, -0.006992132402956486, -0.028306232765316963, 0.023577159270644188, -0.036096494644880295, -0.014230427332222462, 0.006541423499584198, -0.014318029396235943, -0.032626375555992126, -0.028858797624707222, 0.023863863199949265, 0.0023334501311182976, 0.0009659068891778588, -0.009131082333624363, -0.0010059293126687407, 0.012732772156596184, -0.001303602592088282, -0.007883637212216854, 0.009010957553982735, -0.01081999484449625, 0.041636548936367035, 0.03550298884510994, -0.0008137989789247513, 0.06397753208875656, 0.016178609803318977, -0.05448649451136589, -0.035578519105911255, 0.052337292581796646, -0.031166791915893555, 0.016849182546138763, 0.0254337340593338, -0.06942883878946304, 0.005539560690522194, 0.023072442039847374, -0.021370768547058105, 0.017086170613765717, -0.040660176426172256, -0.02556414157152176, -0.029445916414260864, 0.01348801888525486, -0.023166732862591743, 0.018200691789388657, -0.03588567674160004, -0.015600238926708698, 0.07365620881319046, 0.01730610989034176, -0.04130890220403671, 0.013833819888532162, 0.02790173515677452, -0.05200819671154022, -0.0030652598943561316, 0.056221459060907364, -0.010760609991848469, 0.06432753801345825, 0.035326674580574036, -0.011250698007643223, -0.03155118599534035, -0.010363265872001648, -0.06060897558927536, -0.005302059929817915, 0.0006065710913389921, -0.012211713008582592, -0.023242436349391937, -0.03457757085561752, 0.011323402635753155, -0.012395280413329601, 0.02763749286532402, 0.0499633364379406, -0.06116604804992676, 0.007313871290534735, -0.022367626428604126, -0.00729109812527895, 0.029377467930316925, -0.0028674122877418995, -0.011245966888964176, -0.04414823278784752, 0.015627894550561905, -0.03455899655818939, -0.05147106572985649, 0.040627963840961456, -0.0005155203980393708, -0.07094694674015045, 0.013380330987274647, 0.00819441583007574, -0.04768103361129761, 0.04529137536883354, 0.011636209674179554, 0.010895419865846634, 0.013158599846065044, -0.011645312421023846, -0.06511280685663223, -0.028440674766898155, -0.030038965865969658, -0.03449512645602226, 0.02295594848692417, 0.015852002426981926, 0.005212805233895779, 0.010231561958789825, -0.01873081736266613, 0.01576663926243782, 0.010737735778093338, 0.0013099266216158867, -0.05818173289299011, 0.04135984554886818, 0.07286152243614197, 0.054223429411649704, -0.037192098796367645, -0.0005375901237130165, 0.007052203640341759, 0.020673073828220367, -0.02416631579399109, 0.028513535857200623, 0.01953122392296791, -0.0001357429864583537, -0.020710501819849014, 0.014536850154399872, 0.05482185631990433, 0.06988838315010071, 0.021063795313239098, -0.0016547463601455092, 0.0035412993747740984, 0.016680249944329262, -0.016602588817477226, 0.05251322314143181, 0.004434938542544842, 0.04561436548829079, 0.016904029995203018, -0.020263368263840675, -0.03748706728219986, 0.07091245800256729, 0.03195352107286453, 0.03331839665770531, -0.08172465115785599, 0.010944997891783714, -0.0557306706905365, -0.0640362948179245, 0.02574055828154087, 0.006146316882222891, -0.015866180881857872, -0.006960863247513771, -0.056628502905368805, -0.05654043331742287, -0.03966378793120384, 0.014753274619579315, -0.030287565663456917, 0.005321234930306673, 0.029090436175465584, 0.0028429189696907997, 0.025535698980093002, -0.046590253710746765, -0.02325848676264286, 0.00916903093457222, 0.024901168420910835, 0.037012480199337006, -0.0033158736769109964, 0.005586308892816305, -0.08378424495458603, -0.02271449938416481, -0.04171345382928848, 0.010058281011879444, 0.012950059026479721, 0.10300300270318985, -0.055223703384399414, -0.014280187897384167, 0.029482686892151833, 0.02168889530003071, -0.023366626352071762, -0.007538763340562582, 0.056982334703207016, 0.040145665407180786, 0.02478007785975933, 0.04733571037650108, 0.0015946801286190748, -0.04808775708079338, 0.08132310956716537, 0.036324407905340195, 0.011911815032362938, -0.0232623890042305, -0.03823435306549072, 0.019377561286091805, 0.02515615150332451, -0.010702131316065788, -0.044436488300561905, -0.007525549735873938, -0.012957775965332985, -0.03667008876800537, 0.03338877111673355, -0.03008904494345188, -0.022830883041024208, -0.04024273157119751, -0.028027532622218132, -0.037220507860183716, -0.022712502628564835, -0.014093582518398762, 0.02774575538933277, -0.06730841100215912, 0.017617810517549515, -0.006789700128138065, 0.07485797256231308, -0.01986554265022278, 0.053254034370183945, -0.025268204510211945, -0.05197520554065704, 0.0120316781103611, -0.00198817765340209, 0.0373782180249691, -0.0204362403601408, 0.011698763817548752, 0.029944390058517456, -0.03237146511673927, -0.05481920763850212, 0.00872694794088602, -0.048817649483680725, -0.04088294133543968, -0.03987163305282593, -0.027714461088180542, -0.018059158697724342, 0.001001600525341928, -0.009448221884667873, -0.07636135816574097, -0.017346510663628578, 0.02829168736934662, -0.022053193300962448, 0.025561640039086342, 0.032418083399534225, -0.03869101032614708, 0.023424355313181877, -0.02131667546927929, -0.06111124902963638, -0.012495709583163261, -0.013140112161636353, 0.0018422959838062525, -0.06827354431152344, -0.017431076616048813, 0.0030168357770889997, -0.026599304750561714, -0.032335493713617325, -0.005123690236359835, -0.009081996977329254, 0.02592291310429573, 0.007451098412275314, 0.05277732387185097, 0.049371667206287384, -0.07788851112127304, -0.10207000374794006, 0.001941260532476008, -0.003870378015562892, 0.024748122319579124, -0.06707731634378433, -0.018343281000852585, 0.04349983111023903, -0.005239745602011681, -0.015702486038208008, 0.024448584765195847, 0.06594464927911758, 0.06096295267343521, -0.008205853402614594, -0.01218368485569954, 0.06219291314482689, 0.05896920710802078, 0.023557143285870552, 0.033089011907577515, -0.007677028886973858, -0.04506346210837364, -0.040429744869470596, 0.013153520412743092, 0.0726965069770813, 0.02059870958328247, -0.014070588164031506, 0.02200331911444664, 0.029240090399980545, 0.000263307272689417, -0.023352239280939102, -0.024490760639309883, -0.028362514451146126, -0.06300750374794006, -0.016033966094255447, 0.048983462154865265, 0.019194385036826134, -0.02996298484504223, 0.02191345766186714, -0.007105862721800804, -0.033575914800167084, -0.02124444581568241, -0.008846919983625412, 0.005876780021935701, -0.028591208159923553, 0.04104694724082947, 0.008590532466769218, 0.006153599359095097, 0.02012677490711212, 0.04617632180452347, -0.00045984479947946966, 0.02871156483888626, -0.03101370483636856, -0.05164908990263939, 0.04571309685707092, 0.06964787095785141, -0.005891936365514994, -0.01223661471158266, 0.04487384483218193, -0.009470037184655666, 0.023866331204771996, -0.01877439022064209, -0.0008000664529390633, 0.0395437553524971, 0.007869047112762928, 0.0027574512641876936, 0.018672091886401176, -0.021195266395807266, 0.018624262884259224, 0.029130559414625168, -0.033540911972522736, 0.03295004367828369, 0.01281430758535862, -0.017820190638303757, 0.04189193621277809, 0.0002876942162401974, 0.045661915093660355, 0.00900245364755392, -0.08233768492937088, 0.064966581761837, 0.01668594963848591, 0.013610739260911942, 0.011176169849932194, 0.009379744529724121, -0.011622367426753044, 0.0293332040309906, -0.02988322265446186, 0.02989373356103897, -0.043819744139909744, -0.04343061149120331, -0.0525505356490612, -0.02680405229330063, 0.02881130576133728, 0.025204548612236977, 0.010518922470510006, 0.009298540651798248, -0.06257793307304382, -0.009905635379254818, -0.008746844716370106, 0.013765734620392323, -0.06668264418840408, -0.05548356473445892, -0.08286292850971222, 0.06724926829338074, -0.015074302442371845, -0.023598412051796913, -0.05466120317578316, 0.003694703569635749, 0.0030301373917609453, -0.005173158831894398, -0.03385369852185249, 0.03320442885160446, 0.008237883448600769, 0.03970184549689293, 0.011836757883429527, 0.006813213229179382, -0.052811309695243835, 0.003052924992516637, 0.03437924385070801, 0.012745369225740433, 0.014258336275815964, 0.015985757112503052, 0.01565968431532383, -0.02743457444012165, -0.01976434327661991, 0.016146600246429443, -0.01761721819639206, 0.07105714082717896, -0.0498046800494194, -0.0004997768555767834, -0.07809212058782578, 0.026819873601198196, 0.03430398181080818, -0.007084992714226246, 0.025385139510035515, 0.07547245174646378, 0.01464635506272316, -0.0075688776560127735, 0.024829799309372902, 0.024414490908384323, 0.07179936021566391, -0.01348466333001852, 0.05594181641936302, -0.03353327885270119, 0.08967504650354385, 0.0337972529232502, 0.05070766061544418, 0.02084191143512726, 0.026534145697951317, 0.02059023454785347, 0.018190773203969002, -0.049951013177633286, 0.0016421348555013537, -0.0013188584707677364, 0.04434878006577492, -0.06491106748580933, 0.013863069005310535, 0.027389610186219215, -0.03493770584464073, -0.01553418580442667, 0.008553081192076206, 0.03851044923067093, 0.06544958800077438, -0.00704283406957984, 0.01628049463033676, 0.030444126576185226, -0.1264508068561554, -0.033643368631601334, -0.006181764882057905, 0.003378974972292781, -0.04258798807859421, -0.030438145622611046, 0.006735775154083967, 0.008340595290064812, -0.0025945587549358606, -0.0727325826883316, -0.005568336695432663, 0.00036803417606279254, -0.035104863345623016, -0.014282820746302605, 0.02138826809823513, 0.016813835129141808, 0.001952330581843853, 0.011519539169967175, 0.016391528770327568, -0.06401626020669937, -0.013984408229589462, 0.05397697538137436, 0.030307920649647713, 0.024197248741984367, -0.024058187380433083, -0.03702906519174576, 0.04742182418704033, -0.040018558502197266, -0.03752008080482483, -0.04558638110756874, -0.016235198825597763, -0.008294519037008286, -0.027147071436047554, -0.00501568429172039, -0.03034321218729019, -0.023900561034679413, 0.04058057442307472, -0.003928294405341148, 0.023449648171663284, 0.018964828923344612, 0.050573479384183884, -0.0008496135706081986, -0.01649419404566288, 0.025431755930185318, -0.05872237682342529, 0.05811285600066185, -0.05841700732707977, -0.0031639381777495146, 0.02908867597579956, -0.035143934190273285, -0.05592167004942894, -0.017257247120141983, 0.014025924727320671, 0.07298889756202698, 0.05616805702447891, -0.05653805285692215, 0.010548537597060204, -0.016935696825385094, -0.028670059517025948, -0.014733033254742622, -0.007490901276469231, -0.052666980773210526, -0.03770646080374718, 0.034911129623651505, -0.02008041739463806, -0.021793074905872345, 0.01901055872440338, -0.021083833649754524, 0.025028204545378685, 0.00437577860429883, 0.03478763625025749, -0.05035973712801933, 0.008891919627785683, 0.010350632481276989, 0.041978903114795685, 0.04990580677986145, 0.03406979888677597, 0.023419080302119255, -0.018149016425013542, 0.0008273570565506816, -0.044626928865909576, 0.005711928941309452, 0.09670941531658173, 0.058501023799180984, -0.022764086723327637, -0.012895405292510986, -0.05455956235527992, -0.0167617816478014, 0.035584453493356705, 0.023499252274632454, 0.020343590527772903, -0.026174083352088928, -0.019954897463321686, -0.0482933484017849, 0.07637260109186172, -0.02862480655312538, -0.06219610199332237, 0.02607135847210884, 0.016998333856463432, 0.024218374863266945, -0.032373905181884766, 0.04373224452137947, -0.014363099820911884, -0.03029847890138626, 0.031667545437812805, -0.04647107422351837, -0.013294607400894165, -0.004263945855200291, 0.01786160096526146 ]
<p>I have a 5 x 2 design where one of the levels of the first factor is a control, all others are experimental conditions. I'm interested in the interaction between the two factors and especially, if the interaction is present for each of the 4 experimental conditions with the control condition.</p> <p>I conduct 4 separate 2 x 2 ANOVAs where I pair each experimental condition with the control condition in the first factor. This seems to call for p-value adjustment to avoid the multiple-testing problem but what do I have to adjust? Are all p-values adjusted (the two main effects and the interaction)? Or do I only adjust the interaction p-values? Or separately for the main effects?</p> <p>Thanks a lot</p>
g74327
[ 0.008553237654268742, 0.014399448409676552, -0.0060397908091545105, 0.0308856014162302, 0.02543751150369644, -0.017721028998494148, 0.023082634434103966, 0.031297970563173294, -0.012057243846356869, -0.0005237084697000682, -0.059897035360336304, -0.00024504007888026536, -0.01601680926978588, 0.05021456256508827, 0.04866272956132889, 0.029978718608617783, 0.09809830039739609, -0.005121708381921053, -0.015683842822909355, -0.007308808621019125, -0.01286711823195219, -0.02132227085530758, -0.04412831366062164, 0.0020396849140524864, 0.015060404315590858, -0.050026338547468185, -0.024678286164999008, 0.037388093769550323, -0.12163229286670685, 0.03648262843489647, -0.06358589231967926, -0.012959652580320835, 0.0040246048010885715, 0.006114124786108732, -0.04964490979909897, -0.034598689526319504, 0.058211181312799454, 0.007632891181856394, -0.04423553869128227, -0.007699788082391024, -0.020008500665426254, 0.03272205963730812, 0.008936116471886635, 0.026399854570627213, -0.00790415983647108, -0.003164933994412422, -0.02009551227092743, -0.024379370734095573, 0.008097103796899319, 0.05498942360281944, 0.016672903671860695, 0.013715961948037148, 0.0036084402818232775, -0.012152833864092827, 0.04697461798787117, -0.007569955661892891, -0.018684113398194313, 0.05042014271020889, -0.04245737940073013, -0.025594182312488556, -0.022371023893356323, -0.05050617456436157, 0.009716775268316269, 0.014330116100609303, 0.03692257031798363, 0.053075261414051056, -0.025212891399860382, -0.0034254335332661867, -0.06518639624118805, -0.01768721640110016, -0.03667553514242172, 0.006430563982576132, -0.036915965378284454, -0.01937035657465458, 0.02984101139008999, 0.006309941411018372, 0.023047197610139847, -0.04716116189956665, 0.006990076974034309, 0.04357035458087921, 0.008324984461069107, 0.017990127205848694, 0.07556574791669846, -0.01099453680217266, 0.028654631227254868, -0.018636833876371384, 0.01923307590186596, -0.030534518882632256, -0.035444870591163635, -0.05241302028298378, 0.05491206422448158, 0.03309798613190651, 0.02272196114063263, 0.012397184036672115, -0.00987329613417387, 0.003965608775615692, -0.01831880584359169, 0.07065818458795547, 0.051700446754693985, 0.02427615225315094, -0.004387651104480028, 0.02966311015188694, -0.013744366355240345, -0.03054242767393589, -0.08384232223033905, 0.0025256567168980837, 0.032008927315473557, 0.07199940830469131, -0.0029089406598359346, -0.03807247430086136, -0.10129118710756302, -0.011079304851591587, -0.03296949341893196, -0.009027276188135147, -0.0363345630466938, -0.07000059634447098, 0.009554876014590263, 0.006000061519443989, -0.04757009074091911, -0.012363573536276817, -0.015761656686663628, 0.0075808181427419186, -0.0007915789028629661, 0.08854910731315613, 0.013113709166646004, -0.016981367021799088, -0.03100823052227497, 0.06420191377401352, 0.05421758070588112, 0.0013190030585974455, 0.03882460668683052, -0.04540116339921951, -0.010514521040022373, 0.005902258213609457, -0.03486949950456619, -0.015437903814017773, 0.008317889645695686, 0.0660729706287384, -0.07015130668878555, -0.0568203404545784, -0.07616940885782242, -0.024007175117731094, -0.038740601390600204, 0.0036294565070420504, 0.04569447040557861, 0.013515294529497623, 0.01887780986726284, 0.009822436608374119, -0.024812286719679832, 0.01645772159099579, 0.046837218105793, 0.0019200193928554654, 0.015571924857795238, 0.05307605862617493, -0.05342186987400055, 0.020092787221074104, -0.042040590196847916, -0.017928162589669228, -0.001702705048955977, 0.0544271394610405, 0.008043819107115269, 0.0038200884591788054, 0.006824893411248922, 0.004315550904721022, -0.012297545559704304, 0.10334290564060211, -0.013264227658510208, -0.016820857301354408, -0.012038340792059898, 0.0022323548328131437, -0.02500075288116932, -0.04468097910284996, 0.04661232605576515, -0.03572274371981621, 0.08688167482614517, 0.03587787598371506, 0.044325970113277435, -0.019640471786260605, -0.012255392968654633, 0.0025263656862080097, 0.016781028360128403, 0.027359163388609886, -0.030895130708813667, 0.02368783950805664, -0.023258453235030174, -0.013744091615080833, -0.003301385324448347, -0.009924802929162979, -0.10069135576486588, 0.00006902181485202163, 0.030341414734721184, -0.05968746170401573, -0.037755660712718964, -0.0785561054944992, -0.010729938745498657, -0.056505024433135986, -0.010315349325537682, -0.058535195887088776, -0.006350541952997446, -0.019155098125338554, -0.023315459489822388, 0.02922065369784832, 0.01062779687345028, 0.019149212166666985, 0.0030797538347542286, 0.02011757530272007, -0.026629824191331863, 0.013031182810664177, 0.0027283942326903343, -0.05115622282028198, 0.005060725845396519, -0.017946504056453705, -0.005366036202758551, 0.07289960235357285, -0.013651920482516289, -0.013992411084473133, 0.041913360357284546, -0.024642392992973328, 0.0002982726146001369, -0.008309226483106613, 0.009597145952284336, -0.026323329657316208, 0.00719416281208396, 0.024556603282690048, -0.023536009714007378, -0.004774956032633781, 0.005684067029505968, 0.03839923068881035, -0.015060367062687874, -0.003350571496412158, -0.03747154027223587, 0.0117871705442667, 0.010611985810101032, 0.012089809402823448, 0.009394406341016293, 0.06065499037504196, -0.01199503242969513, 0.02298750728368759, -0.05021660402417183, 0.026085268706083298, 0.021100226789712906, 0.06119081750512123, -0.028692670166492462, 0.04022663086652756, 0.006548531819134951, 0.01736711524426937, -0.02815338410437107, 0.0026226607151329517, -0.014021098613739014, 0.03766043111681938, -0.051505155861377716, -0.0037623310927301645, 0.02079932391643524, -0.002889192197471857, -0.024811360985040665, -0.02878480777144432, -0.03182731196284294, 0.04524524137377739, -0.01580810546875, -0.021867429837584496, 0.014723309315741062, -0.0010360664455220103, 0.04807423800230026, 0.0239780955016613, -0.02941790781915188, -0.014046926982700825, 0.008592928759753704, -0.08874250203371048, -0.015138578601181507, -0.02407265082001686, -0.03353392332792282, 0.02437249757349491, 0.010736064985394478, 0.029769202694296837, -0.0041480399668216705, 0.01641746424138546, -0.023995205760002136, -0.02048451080918312, 0.04227854683995247, -0.02115868218243122, 0.045102495700120926, -0.03258474916219711, -0.0455152653157711, -0.020838197320699692, 0.05592750012874603, 0.0226640272885561, 0.1150747537612915, -0.02311132661998272, -0.042933329939842224, 0.013121453113853931, -0.04694899544119835, 0.02008419670164585, -0.020023290067911148, -0.031461410224437714, 0.01567794941365719, -0.03130761533975601, -0.01730049028992653, -0.05829378589987755, 0.0044201272539794445, 0.06750865280628204, -0.00596556207165122, -0.026362035423517227, 0.013788949698209763, -0.0022273517679423094, 0.02537139691412449, -0.010770379565656185, -0.03439631313085556, 0.021555079147219658, 0.026782652363181114, 0.04175608977675438, -0.04266895353794098, -0.027287397533655167, -0.005129034630954266, -0.04345282167196274, -0.03327544033527374, -0.01691446080803871, 0.0793445035815239, -0.0074223717674613, 0.013654076494276524, -0.027160510420799255, 0.0040077995508909225, -0.03611389920115471, 0.03353458270430565, 0.01946345716714859, -0.006135317962616682, 0.016605157405138016, 0.019162282347679138, -0.03187834471464157, 0.021045221015810966, -0.0035622490104287863, 0.07666756957769394, 0.0805617943406105, 0.0068459827452898026, -0.03709473833441734, 0.024734582751989365, 0.0067242649383842945, 0.02838292345404625, -0.02992449887096882, -0.02387389726936817, 0.05287480726838112, 0.0397341214120388, -0.06155369430780411, -0.009480799548327923, 0.002700095996260643, 0.03094664216041565, -0.05358275771141052, 0.01960413157939911, 0.044806107878685, 0.007676139008253813, -0.014415554702281952, 0.027186350896954536, -0.000290165189653635, -0.01277166698127985, -0.03305679187178612, 0.05287686735391617, -0.05762552469968796, 0.06525514274835587, -0.0042338245548307896, -0.06824977695941925, 0.02398287132382393, -0.03270172327756882, -0.006958376616239548, -0.06942207366228104, 0.03130097687244415, 0.014691004529595375, -0.011623464524745941, -0.001724365632981062, 0.023522688075900078, 0.01791510544717312, -0.02613437920808792, 0.08534719794988632, 0.02151528187096119, -0.011287922970950603, -0.06856197863817215, 0.021804628893733025, -0.028054354712367058, 0.06630934774875641, -0.004582737106829882, -0.03995348513126373, 0.09633760899305344, 0.06551520526409149, 0.04362955689430237, -0.016308773308992386, 0.002825946779921651, 0.0664997473359108, 0.02057158760726452, 0.013967382721602917, 0.002567195799201727, 0.02359749935567379, 0.024002080783247948, -0.01518126018345356, 0.033185672014951706, -0.04165136069059372, -0.015738170593976974, 0.03534647077322006, 0.0022351560182869434, 0.025965407490730286, -0.022600337862968445, -0.020481517538428307, 0.04154519364237785, -0.021746082231402397, -0.012294968590140343, 0.054371196776628494, -0.045308541506528854, 0.01623348332941532, -0.03027505800127983, -0.02423177845776081, 0.013705067336559296, -0.04379976540803909, -0.007314987946301699, -0.025369666516780853, 0.0019843534100800753, -0.01177087053656578, -0.03224772587418556, -0.0003274718765169382, -0.03894634544849396, 0.0035879132337868214, -0.043146587908267975, 0.008420479483902454, -0.01896447315812111, 0.019911527633666992, 0.028013501316308975, -0.0417475625872612, -0.06718025356531143, 0.02304987981915474, 0.003295361064374447, -0.03608153015375137, -0.011718018911778927, 0.04229011759161949, -0.04899117350578308, 0.018351241946220398, 0.013991094194352627, -0.009662332013249397, 0.006004929076880217, -0.0066400570794939995, 0.04879646375775337, -0.03272038698196411, -0.00367745035327971, -0.030808573588728905, 0.046544399112463, 0.02423412725329399, 0.018612071871757507, -0.07838588953018188, 0.008794187568128109, -0.012189450673758984, 0.07695019990205765, 0.015325859189033508, -0.045973144471645355, 0.024060504510998726, 0.027543971315026283, -0.061957601457834244, -0.02118757553398609, 0.01572396047413349, 0.006624652072787285, 0.04763013869524002, -0.011695445515215397, 0.04427337273955345, 0.0275073554366827, 0.02361297607421875, 0.004435122478753328, -0.004290154669433832, -0.0296256672590971, -0.0660916417837143, -0.01828470267355442, 0.032857924699783325, -0.03938421234488487, -0.04060712456703186, -0.008557965978980064, -0.06270917505025864, 0.006212856620550156, 0.013635198585689068, -0.07930798828601837, 0.026962807402014732, 0.035619910806417465, -0.02742088958621025, -0.025801464915275574, 0.03733952343463898, 0.03479824587702751, 0.005413608625531197, -0.029881639406085014, 0.02337970770895481, 0.01855764165520668, 0.014244901947677135, -0.015454258769750595, 0.03636611998081207, -0.07027661800384521, -0.024799644947052002, -0.061458662152290344, 0.007366572041064501, 0.018453368917107582, -0.0009662311058491468, 0.05185036361217499, 0.07173635810613632, -0.0036280869971960783, -0.01998159848153591, 0.024130195379257202, -0.029599031433463097, 0.01566113717854023, 0.05144651606678963, -0.0699956938624382, 0.026068631559610367, -0.011056818999350071, 0.0711231380701065, -0.02481505647301674, -0.05419030040502548, -0.0038426555693149567, 0.011826729401946068, -0.10789389908313751, -0.006045903544872999, 0.034957852214574814, -0.026460722088813782, 0.014265126548707485, 0.07422894239425659, 0.008463873527944088, -0.0629165768623352, 0.05476795881986618, 0.017992159351706505, 0.012023712508380413, 0.007576005067676306, -0.10082700848579407, 0.08957716822624207, -0.008198955096304417, -0.06485670804977417, -0.005487852729856968, 0.036978237330913544, 0.0027051004581153393, -0.008361921645700932, 0.030531613156199455, 0.05866424739360809, 0.05924765765666962, -0.041027382016181946, 0.049689218401908875, -0.023943917825818062, 0.07076959311962128, -0.012640556320548058, -0.05371583625674248, -0.019071107730269432, 0.0012442405568435788, 0.02641417644917965, 0.023879574611783028, -0.013202855363488197, 0.025947757065296173, 0.022675689309835434, -0.0058586434461176395, 0.009544122964143753, 0.007437610067427158, 0.009595475159585476, -0.01096061710268259, 0.005280154291540384, 0.004041545558720827, -0.025191010907292366, -0.01470717042684555, 0.0005183956818655133, 0.07141514867544174, 0.04863316938281059, 0.01888127066195011, -0.004528965335339308, -0.008726414293050766, 0.08588754385709763, -0.027469538152217865, -0.028565702959895134, -0.013754968531429768, -0.01659977436065674, -0.00011903711856575683, -0.00498166074976325, -0.009054671041667461, -0.008664469234645367, 0.021404849365353584, 0.023739786818623543, 0.012957679107785225, 0.04636066034436226, -0.043310727924108505, -0.008336330763995647, -0.002481898060068488, -0.01946929842233658, 0.03526073321700096, -0.0245272945612669, 0.044732436537742615, 0.013437759131193161, 0.0034769682679325342, 0.008488275110721588, 0.004539776127785444, -0.03250805661082268, 0.006982832681387663, -0.02443058229982853, 0.07127556204795837, -0.04323749244213104, -0.05211690440773964, 0.021726347506046295, -0.05507354065775871, -0.06685696542263031, -0.02948305755853653, -0.009462986141443253, 0.022046510130167007, 0.0269883144646883, 0.014566062018275261, 0.006728998385369778, 0.05658284202218056, 0.020122447982430458, 0.040603701025247574, 0.0285013597458601, -0.052407003939151764, 0.04612290859222412, -0.0025896502193063498, -0.009825866669416428, 0.03532837703824043, -0.030420608818531036, -0.011635047383606434, 0.015453849919140339, 0.05720774456858635, -0.05480320379137993, -0.022503670305013657, 0.0406804122030735, 0.01466218288987875, 0.009710030630230904, -0.009757664054632187, -0.043865397572517395, -0.030202392488718033, 0.015432030893862247, 0.005603704135864973, 0.017522776499390602, -0.02450721524655819, -0.003862743964418769, -0.06642763316631317, 0.010575361549854279, 0.035616278648376465, -0.015943601727485657, -0.028312548995018005, 0.027804572135210037, -0.025622783228754997, -0.03778940811753273, -0.007084277458488941, 0.03189665079116821, 0.009486020542681217, -0.047067806124687195, 0.07511856406927109, -0.04514750838279724, 0.06469927728176117, 0.02665599435567856, 0.033102814108133316, 0.0222301185131073, 0.08642464876174927, -0.04017721116542816, 0.03823217749595642, 0.003020194126293063, -0.03823520988225937, -0.006608003284782171, 0.005102361086755991, -0.05455143004655838, 0.045441918075084686, 0.07180999219417572, -0.004864123184233904, -0.031138679012656212, -0.04831588268280029, 0.014331594109535217, 0.02211974933743477, 0.004394781310111284, 0.008277763612568378, -0.0009226069087162614, 0.048419736325740814, -0.015432368032634258, -0.05965558812022209, -0.030993333086371422, 0.04233277961611748, 0.018423855304718018, 0.04191070422530174, 0.019657963886857033, -0.019224820658564568, 0.008280004374682903, -0.031717777252197266, -0.017825094982981682, -0.02011803723871708, -0.043255504220724106, 0.08952078223228455, -0.022618845105171204, -0.029504910111427307, 0.008854354731738567, 0.06694595515727997, -0.05661576986312866, -0.001179095939733088, 0.010332062840461731, -0.050372105091810226, 0.047206178307533264, -0.030391469597816467, -0.04035062715411186, 0.010171822272241116, -0.01459314301609993, 0.026281828060746193, -0.004948944319039583, 0.01691482402384281, -0.005852989852428436, -0.03891449421644211, 0.013488546013832092, -0.001377625740133226, -0.10278548300266266, 0.059319376945495605, 0.06140629202127457, -0.006504038814455271, -0.04122478514909744, 0.015334820374846458, 0.10312514007091522, -0.02821185812354088, 0.011790449731051922, -0.01272779144346714, 0.05174695700407028, 0.04048096016049385, -0.006430965848267078, -0.023563658818602562, -0.006957069970667362, -0.01025928370654583, -0.014213727787137032, 0.004109167028218508, 0.003923935815691948, 0.06064071133732796, 0.006094368174672127, -0.019811883568763733, 0.008631620556116104, -0.005683145020157099, -0.02587447315454483, 0.05032116547226906, -0.06781962513923645, -0.011116188019514084, -0.04027837887406349, -0.010473138652741909, 0.020763766020536423, -0.02096009999513626, -0.028786825016140938, 0.006163545418530703, -0.004005833528935909, 0.03275465965270996, -0.04156145825982094, -0.07632499188184738, -0.0874561071395874, 0.06962079554796219, 0.060526005923748016, 0.01705823838710785, 0.03979865834116936, -0.0006487394566647708, -0.025202127173542976, 0.0002295218437211588, -0.04330751672387123, -0.05089125782251358, 0.007275983691215515, -0.003050962695851922, -0.013079806230962276, 0.0064519476145505905, 0.02142026461660862, 0.06114216893911362, -0.0018068456556648016, -0.027215618640184402, -0.05665789917111397, 0.01731121353805065, -0.040422797203063965, -0.013598008081316948, 0.007653551641851664, -0.027990030124783516, -0.01538322027772665, -0.035672660917043686, -0.020623113960027695, 0.02343330904841423, -0.0035512843169271946, -0.008717254735529423, -0.08143536746501923, 0.01428078394383192, 0.03096049465239048, -0.0033561151940375566, 0.02236221730709076, -0.0011519861873239279 ]
<p>The company where I work did a survey with a complex sample. Originally, the sample was a 2-step stratified, but due to some problems, we lost one of them (so, let's consider that the sample is stratified only on 1 variable).</p> <p>The biggest part of the questions is like "What you think the company can do in respect of X?" and then there is a list of options (some questions allow only 1 answer, some more than 1, others are Likert-type response options).</p> <p>My question is: Wow can I analyze this data? It would be nice if there were a test like Chi-square for complex sample (probably there exists one, but I don't know)</p> <p>Any software is welcome, but I prefer R and SPSS.</p>
g74328
[ -0.0007393092382699251, -0.014905983582139015, -0.00021864772133994848, -0.0343356654047966, -0.02818196825683117, -0.06390305608510971, 0.029059888795018196, -0.005577933508902788, -0.0027940217405557632, -0.00981055572628975, 0.03958903253078461, 0.004057526122778654, 0.02469618432223797, 0.03508521616458893, -0.07570825517177582, -0.04016345739364624, -0.01134558767080307, -0.042173150926828384, 0.007042216137051582, 0.02108193188905716, 0.0368003249168396, 0.026713253930211067, 0.059308722615242004, -0.006542759481817484, -0.013011852279305458, -0.0427982360124588, -0.04502774402499199, 0.06027962639927864, -0.07373572140932083, 0.03173274174332619, -0.020908482372760773, 0.03303152695298195, 0.060607027262449265, -0.04655742272734642, -0.03492533415555954, 0.030027002096176147, 0.06196277588605881, -0.014193922281265259, -0.003596826223656535, 0.009824671782553196, 0.004671413917094469, -0.000556779617909342, 0.06698955595493317, -0.05313674733042717, 0.014017410576343536, -0.04245927929878235, 0.0011602949816733599, 0.019031336531043053, 0.06639686226844788, -0.015729321166872978, -0.040880318731069565, -0.035709138959646225, 0.03578726574778557, 0.025041982531547546, 0.032153934240341187, -0.006670513190329075, 0.011508410796523094, 0.013929802924394608, 0.02825726941227913, 0.013713487423956394, -0.040676672011613846, -0.003103615716099739, -0.012123985216021538, -0.00569858169183135, 0.02369711734354496, 0.01402044016867876, 0.024460671469569206, -0.08009060472249985, -0.08700978010892868, -0.04529150575399399, -0.0030194770079106092, -0.046913016587495804, 0.05223669111728668, -0.016305653378367424, -0.05844681337475777, -0.036053016781806946, -0.007948001846671104, -0.020618190988898277, 0.013511443510651588, -0.025734053924679756, 0.0009529844974167645, -0.0578659325838089, -0.049293551594018936, 0.03949972614645958, 0.0169456098228693, -0.013786089606583118, 0.06094735115766525, -0.0532333143055439, 0.08044842630624771, 0.036899812519550323, -0.03423777222633362, -0.010517025366425514, 0.036961957812309265, 0.044877614825963974, -0.006346199195832014, 0.027821054682135582, -0.04873454570770264, -0.008727080188691616, 0.05171338841319084, -0.007014806382358074, -0.03948713466525078, -0.0313531830906868, -0.023563425987958908, -0.027737103402614594, -0.06277657300233841, -0.014194927178323269, -0.007111591286957264, 0.02263728715479374, -0.01411367580294609, -0.020150667056441307, -0.020702335983514786, -0.0330035574734211, -0.09621138125658035, 0.020697273313999176, 0.04951375350356102, 0.028975237160921097, 0.042684175074100494, -0.020031815394759178, -0.06582459062337875, 0.019216716289520264, 0.03600490838289261, 0.017519457265734673, 0.01752370223402977, 0.0163404680788517, -0.03572753444314003, 0.029321011155843735, -0.03825695440173149, 0.05420774593949318, 0.028837719932198524, 0.024138301610946655, -0.011652161367237568, -0.0034012284595519304, 0.00534630473703146, 0.0036537405103445053, -0.028065308928489685, 0.016047298908233643, -0.03711863234639168, 0.04305281117558479, 0.019495220854878426, -0.02382749319076538, -0.06191219761967659, 0.02436818554997444, -0.01561838947236538, 0.016187209635972977, 0.009128449484705925, -0.0002945949381683022, 0.0229493398219347, 0.04109693691134453, -0.02583581581711769, -0.014718445017933846, 0.026354055851697922, -0.01931985840201378, -0.010681996122002602, -0.021146303042769432, -0.021028708666563034, -0.007363474927842617, -0.01584365777671337, -0.0008713541319593787, -0.020849056541919708, 0.004550888203084469, 0.02767048589885235, 0.01404618937522173, -0.02903348207473755, 0.013255814090371132, 0.06910037994384766, 0.010174902155995369, -0.07921692728996277, 0.0056403460912406445, -0.012258592993021011, 0.012346317060291767, 0.01905636303126812, -0.00238285050727427, 0.03763800859451294, -0.007247707340866327, 0.02367573045194149, 0.02125147543847561, 0.0001887753896880895, -0.028355520218610764, 0.06994358450174332, 0.01227280031889677, -0.025638999417424202, 0.04689236730337143, -0.015242311172187328, -0.022555069997906685, 0.019672276452183723, -0.054876722395420074, 0.039517611265182495, 0.049603331834077835, 0.005465329624712467, -0.03949890658259392, 0.031279511749744415, -0.04692485183477402, -0.004874482750892639, 0.008693603798747063, 0.06468631327152252, -0.06453442573547363, 0.03655696287751198, -0.022421468049287796, 0.000035400687920628116, -0.028062952682375908, 0.05640166625380516, 0.06281185150146484, -0.01467910036444664, 0.023818625137209892, -0.021497776731848717, -0.020816422998905182, -0.012996167875826359, -0.05360693112015724, -0.05254361405968666, 0.051790639758110046, 0.0542854443192482, 0.008543933741748333, 0.01223550271242857, 0.044094692915678024, 0.006150847766548395, 0.025382742285728455, -0.02314317412674427, 0.017963867634534836, 0.03566329553723335, 0.010673402808606625, -0.019671449437737465, -0.05025194585323334, 0.016141459345817566, 0.015645340085029602, 0.018390212208032608, 0.0327933095395565, -0.056740257889032364, -0.01915774494409561, 0.026737865060567856, 0.012610455974936485, -0.007041264325380325, -0.033774908632040024, 0.05195000022649765, -0.04687783122062683, 0.041170842945575714, 0.0063357874751091, -0.0401160791516304, 0.006952119525521994, -0.01529225055128336, 0.012115811929106712, 0.035490527749061584, -0.028565678745508194, -0.004968780092895031, 0.007208794355392456, 0.06196577101945877, 0.04683389514684677, 0.0013553572352975607, 0.04962918907403946, 0.051092199981212616, 0.05908612906932831, -0.020676175132393837, 0.0229167677462101, -0.008885405026376247, -0.05295894667506218, -0.015295727178454399, -0.05159611627459526, 0.08439404517412186, 0.018312638625502586, 0.0042762611992657185, 0.007264731917530298, -0.02612113580107689, -0.029046274721622467, 0.03011544607579708, 0.011053716763854027, 0.027580803260207176, 0.02454274892807007, -0.008509432896971703, -0.01934802532196045, -0.02951820194721222, -0.00008441075624432415, -0.046445634216070175, 0.030937831848859787, 0.04612044245004654, 0.07369990646839142, -0.025595208629965782, 0.03419531509280205, -0.06649166345596313, -0.0025882923509925604, 0.07312388718128204, -0.005073647014796734, 0.010894292034208775, -0.010583098977804184, 0.02843410335481167, 0.041272081434726715, 0.0012222243240103126, 0.08142249286174774, 0.026134559884667397, -0.004957956727594137, -0.005293397698551416, -0.016478940844535828, 0.007506099529564381, -0.02247587777674198, 0.032946743071079254, -0.01509793009608984, -0.04464643448591232, -0.0677957758307457, 0.0016918153269216418, -0.06918901205062866, 0.07568993419408798, 0.06478169560432434, -0.02777634747326374, -0.01111088041216135, 0.08568979799747467, 0.013203883543610573, -0.0035523702390491962, -0.05893615260720253, -0.022924114018678665, -0.0283641517162323, 0.040504492819309235, 0.005923938937485218, -0.07879290729761124, -0.02782062627375126, -0.04286657273769379, 0.008028745651245117, -0.01569841243326664, 0.010041995905339718, 0.021232105791568756, -0.0008290889672935009, 0.014286184683442116, 0.021981265395879745, -0.011248279362916946, -0.04930015653371811, 0.02216634526848793, 0.025553319603204727, -0.014643976464867592, 0.007931248284876347, -0.06559105962514877, 0.014340944588184357, -0.1020469143986702, -0.023061465471982956, 0.030492110177874565, -0.04803546518087387, 0.012218697927892208, -0.005205143708735704, 0.02073289267718792, 0.027219519019126892, 0.026733018457889557, -0.04873938858509064, 0.011662034317851067, 0.03888274356722832, -0.015948230400681496, -0.007817190140485764, 0.04375225678086281, -0.028946103528141975, -0.053920090198516846, -0.003869716078042984, 0.05828048288822174, -0.015940958634018898, 0.012611353769898415, -0.021562326699495316, -0.009253251366317272, -0.026051053777337074, 0.02049790322780609, -0.08105461299419403, 0.006331557873636484, 0.03577985242009163, 0.05585145950317383, 0.04336300864815712, -0.031127750873565674, 0.02568463794887066, 0.01213178038597107, -0.009955041110515594, 0.018428154289722443, 0.0058764065615832806, 0.030924329534173012, 0.05068023130297661, 0.025553520768880844, 0.05755317211151123, 0.006701451726257801, 0.015046034008264542, 0.007919329218566418, -0.010843804106116295, 0.0476229265332222, 0.011492280289530754, 0.022055627778172493, -0.02196156606078148, -0.03738626092672348, 0.029841376468539238, 0.06997817754745483, 0.03499355912208557, 0.0715697705745697, 0.009077144786715508, 0.05602375417947769, -0.03719763830304146, -0.03042183443903923, -0.03137451410293579, -0.02690245397388935, 0.017280634492635727, -0.015353737398982048, 0.014124254696071148, 0.02520783059298992, -0.07252032309770584, -0.11166628450155258, 0.07390044629573822, -0.05150897428393364, -0.03880104422569275, -0.06214243918657303, -0.008584506809711456, -0.07235243916511536, 0.024809984490275383, 0.013237572275102139, -0.02165951393544674, 0.010413438081741333, 0.019412105903029442, -0.026175476610660553, -0.04201870039105415, 0.006365048699080944, -0.06513042002916336, -0.029075752943754196, 0.007037653587758541, -0.020885197445750237, -0.03331474959850311, 0.026277320459485054, -0.018891479820013046, -0.009686115197837353, -0.01732863299548626, 0.011489680968225002, -0.023405376821756363, -0.020871635526418686, 0.012774940580129623, 0.005316789261996746, 0.01556404773145914, 0.024160372093319893, -0.01199321262538433, 0.03151797130703926, -0.05568956956267357, 0.030704133212566376, 0.027194244787096977, -0.021937543526291847, -0.00954771600663662, -0.0009549606475047767, 0.007450114004313946, -0.008237732574343681, -0.015461786650121212, 0.0459076464176178, -0.03577554225921631, -0.029602229595184326, -0.06774252653121948, -0.056800831109285355, -0.03553628548979759, -0.07528586685657501, 0.0338139571249485, -0.002469619270414114, -0.03806159272789955, -0.027356863021850586, 0.021601123735308647, -0.023060301318764687, 0.03148547559976578, -0.023622985929250717, 0.026960184797644615, -0.03790286183357239, -0.018118025735020638, -0.05593477562069893, -0.0017438316717743874, 0.028234533965587616, -0.011237680912017822, 0.02959355153143406, 0.0005111722857691348, 0.025525923818349838, 0.121024489402771, 0.04692336916923523, -0.03594924509525299, -0.026789577677845955, 0.023710178211331367, -0.00391242653131485, -0.04460132122039795, -0.06270627677440643, 0.024811791256070137, 0.0017758023459464312, 0.00008243380580097437, -0.050576698035001755, -0.0035434081219136715, 0.04598347097635269, 0.019187647849321365, -0.03540731593966484, -0.007215829566121101, -0.052572209388017654, -0.00930976215749979, -0.007382863201200962, -0.004628111142665148, 0.00009524555207462981, -0.03719086945056915, -0.01216896716505289, 0.010221018455922604, 0.02295253612101078, -0.01989963836967945, 0.028704287484288216, -0.005544095765799284, -0.011834431439638138, -0.04556495323777199, 0.017366578802466393, -0.00801199022680521, 0.03961313143372536, -0.0013459831243380904, -0.030743667855858803, 0.007230047602206469, 0.018702400848269463, -0.05565791204571724, 0.02639755792915821, 0.020818591117858887, 0.007222574204206467, 0.008476530201733112, 0.0008499874384142458, 0.004809829406440258, -0.03236248344182968, -0.03895927220582962, 0.017418142408132553, -0.009408671408891678, 0.004690526984632015, 0.06718991696834564, -0.012336268089711666, 0.031772274523973465, 0.03636273741722107, 0.032705407589673996, 0.0014375564642250538, -0.0002832130412571132, 0.004763638600707054, -0.014000034891068935, 0.020544469356536865, -0.026509854942560196, 0.03397739306092262, -0.004679183475673199, -0.010510765016078949, 0.03444338217377663, 0.02908310852944851, -0.03174145519733429, -0.007938998751342297, -0.07282178103923798, 0.025345565751194954, -0.04189924895763397, 0.0028388898354023695, 0.04102928563952446, -0.028034793213009834, 0.005066832527518272, -0.015142981894314289, -0.051863644272089005, -0.005487425718456507, 0.012019823305308819, 0.0054570455104112625, 0.005622506607323885, -0.0074372016824781895, 0.0033638235181570053, 0.03248874843120575, -0.0065972390584647655, -0.014502291567623615, -0.02715827338397503, -0.028051862493157387, 0.040035393089056015, 0.022865725681185722, -0.02214796468615532, 0.005915661808103323, -0.030731188133358955, 0.023236626759171486, 0.018889496102929115, -0.051217835396528244, -0.02940353937447071, -0.0035484000109136105, -0.039906539022922516, 0.02168043702840805, 0.0040048654191195965, -0.03644527122378349, -0.07184761762619019, 0.03960633650422096, -0.01795990765094757, 0.02194827049970627, 0.006027984898537397, -0.06606362760066986, 0.021622467786073685, -0.02024635672569275, 0.03471369668841362, -0.052744247019290924, -0.02101241983473301, 0.03899705782532692, 0.030874092131853104, 0.031490691006183624, -0.026638716459274292, 0.017721107229590416, 0.034864384680986404, 0.08724305778741837, 0.018868083134293556, 0.006363809108734131, 0.021369457244873047, 0.06007697805762291, 0.07716203480958939, -0.010250301100313663, 0.051806703209877014, -0.02346782200038433, 0.0600893497467041, -0.06119469925761223, 0.009104053489863873, -0.06393320858478546, 0.03898691013455391, 0.0098315654322505, -0.009517454542219639, 0.022730669006705284, -0.004617856349796057, 0.029676154255867004, 0.03327906131744385, -0.02111077308654785, 0.05990251898765564, -0.015148255042731762, -0.023529618978500366, 0.017753172665834427, -0.04002482071518898, -0.006501011550426483, -0.002929599955677986, 0.011200161650776863, 0.0005227739457041025, -0.029869839549064636, -0.015775330364704132, -0.05396703630685806, 0.018880197778344154, -0.026649758219718933, 0.10680723190307617, 0.016325298696756363, -0.013114465400576591, -0.031000910326838493, -0.0274728462100029, 0.01825197972357273, -0.07387740164995193, 0.007684759795665741, -0.030798843130469322, 0.011672900058329105, -0.057152826339006424, 0.027100492268800735, 0.02225780300796032, 0.0021111967507749796, 0.052932851016521454, 0.013757599517703056, -0.0030636382289230824, -0.010224576108157635, 0.04928866773843765, 0.0686262771487236, -0.06582196801900864, -0.06908019632101059, 0.05540222302079201, -0.019857903942465782, 0.027073686942458153, 0.06905310600996017, 0.04205174744129181, 0.047219932079315186, 0.027027644217014313, -0.027562744915485382, -0.0021338029764592648, -0.0008308780379593372, -0.007445293944329023, 0.03975957632064819, 0.03217872977256775, 0.011460493318736553, 0.02534603700041771, 0.05740564689040184, 0.04339376837015152, 0.00470791244879365, -0.11344312876462936, 0.03278453275561333, 0.012453642673790455, 0.07179462164640427, 0.06742610782384872, 0.022345755249261856, -0.03515117987990379, -0.06031130626797676, -0.02568662539124489, -0.03893688693642616, 0.010948232375085354, -0.07471992820501328, 0.07870294153690338, -0.022841164842247963, 0.034369148313999176, 0.0022669413592666388, -0.07487722486257553, 0.008182180114090443, 0.005629899445921183, -0.01581333763897419, 0.02854023687541485, 0.032596610486507416, -0.04265934228897095, 0.017153434455394745, -0.009212186560034752, 0.019429044798016548, 0.06114717200398445, 0.04635948687791824, 0.02033531479537487, 0.051886145025491714, 0.01432062964886427, -0.059466298669576645, -0.008844341151416302, -0.07184029370546341, 0.025537986308336258, 0.04385913163423538, -0.04259379580616951, -0.04622001200914383, 0.020057864487171173, 0.003931007348001003, -0.0003623627999331802, 0.012208571657538414, -0.07858218997716904, -0.012290196493268013, 0.014411108568310738, -0.005406305193901062, 0.04213787242770195, -0.010032291524112225, 0.06361261010169983, -0.0068963803350925446, 0.01626550406217575, 0.03927294537425041, -0.01274535246193409, 0.0003420267312321812, -0.06906475126743317, -0.025323422625660896, -0.03689926862716675, 0.005568225868046284, 0.10784885287284851, -0.03359997645020485, 0.009091883897781372, -0.01581559143960476, 0.01770160347223282, -0.0057726697996258736, 0.0015627859393134713, -0.02382982335984707, -0.023629169911146164, -0.020954128354787827, 0.02384771592915058, 0.018780041486024857, -0.0017995511880144477, -0.004532443825155497, -0.04654567316174507, -0.01077247504144907, 0.0842662900686264, 0.039497826248407364, 0.012216529808938503, 0.036494478583335876, -0.07348836958408356, -0.04751325398683548, 0.04971478134393692, 0.04210437089204788, 0.013221614062786102, -0.012410357594490051, 0.04248780012130737, -0.028249748051166534, 0.01178460381925106, 0.013465418480336666, 0.014617934823036194, -0.02266397327184677, 0.004584139212965965, 0.007079305127263069, -0.032749686390161514, -0.022596629336476326, 0.05676434934139252, 0.018962286412715912, -0.0459291972219944, -0.052021607756614685, -0.005607567261904478, 0.008460459299385548, -0.017913982272148132, -0.007052197121083736, 0.012502267956733704, 0.03682181239128113, 0.006546554155647755, 0.02635735459625721, -0.036543894559144974, -0.05199827626347542, -0.03457329794764519, -0.11193247139453888, 0.01606839708983898, -0.01562822423875332, -0.05286293849349022, 0.002171140629798174, -0.03532502427697182 ]
<p>I have data that involves 2 groups (equal sample size in each) and data for each group over 3 time points (they are actually 3 different monetary reward conditions). I want to investigate within group differences. All time/condition points are important, I don't have a "control" time point.</p> <p>Any opinions on the following:</p> <ol> <li><p>If I am comfortable that sphericity is assumed by Mauchly's Test not being violated, would a multivariate Lambda F test statistic be more appropriate or a sphericity assumed estimate (within-condition estimate from SPSS)?</p></li> <li><p>If I choose to go with the understanding that despite a test result saying it is OK, assuming sphericity may still be over-confident, any thoughts on potentially reporting ALL Greenhouse-Geiser estimates regardless of Mauchly's or Lambda? I have read that this may reduce the chance of a Type-1 error without having to assume sphericity or equality of covariance matrices. Perhaps too overcautious? Or, is potentially adjusting df's more invasive than assuming sphericity?</p></li> </ol>
g48906
[ 0.013076663948595524, -0.016860483214259148, 0.009654426015913486, -0.002112436341121793, -0.031452711671590805, -0.023041822016239166, 0.006541222333908081, 0.02296346426010132, -0.07094071805477142, 0.01929297298192978, 0.06826211512088776, -0.014646111987531185, 0.0012649385025724769, 0.06538718193769455, -0.021068399772047997, 0.008862627670168877, 0.05732152983546257, -0.002798255532979965, -0.0044249119237065315, 0.03225205838680267, -0.02162926457822323, 0.0006093350821174681, 0.002795662498101592, 0.020850758999586105, 0.011364300735294819, -0.06192847713828087, 0.009718299843370914, 0.0282009094953537, -0.068621926009655, -0.028799869120121002, 0.011298864148557186, 0.06422124058008194, 0.01704649068415165, -0.08503907173871994, -0.029060859233140945, -0.017557425424456596, 0.010865709744393826, 0.05734160915017128, 0.013813230209052563, -0.025742731988430023, 0.011374401859939098, 0.007777902763336897, 0.0393989123404026, 0.032633908092975616, -0.014357173815369606, 0.022344565019011497, -0.014938484877347946, 0.012314755469560623, 0.013874826021492481, -0.024608556181192398, -0.0036237272433936596, 0.026483772322535515, 0.007526164408773184, 0.0015201395144686103, 0.003448390169069171, -0.055711861699819565, 0.014296374283730984, -0.010920040309429169, 0.05208683758974075, 0.02423941157758236, 0.03325725346803665, -0.023710303008556366, -0.08473353087902069, -0.007654429413378239, 0.008406628854572773, -0.004125513136386871, 0.01456156000494957, -0.03249191865324974, -0.006274559069424868, -0.08872140944004059, -0.025145169347524643, -0.01837274804711342, 0.050353191792964935, -0.007160364184528589, -0.009600017219781876, -0.021783960983157158, -0.04650113731622696, -0.017116982489824295, 0.029436437413096428, -0.03980017080903053, -0.010223970748484135, 0.001173681579530239, -0.00020133258658461273, 0.022928325459361076, 0.05918489769101143, 0.016910746693611145, 0.03591582551598549, -0.05823582783341408, 0.025076130405068398, 0.019774189218878746, 0.022528132423758507, -0.06042708083987236, 0.05741136148571968, 0.03841300308704376, -0.02481691539287567, 0.018173130229115486, -0.003098190762102604, 0.024531984701752663, -0.023348825052380562, 0.05178916081786156, -0.03208426758646965, 0.020855974406003952, -0.009823222644627094, 0.04467290639877319, -0.034510254859924316, 0.0113859036937356, 0.005581097211688757, 0.002546710195019841, -0.04641611874103546, -0.02207479439675808, -0.05218929052352905, 0.04751569777727127, -0.056304462254047394, -0.03999730572104454, -0.014317155815660954, -0.06008400395512581, 0.055766746401786804, -0.02523759938776493, 0.02928420528769493, -0.03312957286834717, 0.025814807042479515, 0.012914911843836308, 0.04969499260187149, 0.04507630690932274, -0.03818342089653015, 0.08975960314273834, -0.029393741860985756, 0.03249732777476311, 0.03869285434484482, 0.008825133554637432, -0.03241947665810585, -0.0027887055184692144, 0.014428759925067425, 0.022697865962982178, -0.022000953555107117, 0.005533404648303986, -0.022625058889389038, 0.1169334426522255, -0.022103121504187584, 0.014222194440662861, -0.008533748798072338, 0.01106602605432272, 0.015646344050765038, -0.017359349876642227, -0.03409363329410553, 0.010239019058644772, 0.006913821678608656, -0.022159935906529427, 0.03721630573272705, 0.010767154395580292, -0.02352568320930004, 0.02524382807314396, -0.0049081528559327126, 0.04417866840958595, -0.06717418879270554, 0.024300985038280487, -0.007313529495149851, -0.01551196537911892, 0.027554737403988838, 0.0497739277780056, -0.01859254576265812, -0.0011231321841478348, 0.06554507464170456, -0.017893943935632706, 0.014279196038842201, 0.04982806742191315, 0.015940649434924126, -0.018305223435163498, -0.02645869180560112, -0.07358171790838242, -0.004110222216695547, 0.003279383759945631, 0.00811230018734932, -0.019930606707930565, 0.010770889930427074, -0.02089787647128105, 0.038668904453516006, -0.042237795889377594, 0.021886058151721954, 0.0505690760910511, 0.002594561781734228, 0.008408763445913792, -0.006988957989960909, -0.04177214577794075, 0.011505483649671078, -0.02416737750172615, -0.007874530740082264, 0.009017528034746647, -0.057222895324230194, -0.0006570647237822413, -0.006139323581010103, -0.02602088451385498, -0.043133385479450226, 0.002039716811850667, -0.0019022744381800294, -0.052757322788238525, 0.00782658439129591, -0.010688340291380882, -0.01996479369699955, -0.012829693965613842, -0.02657381072640419, 0.007039971183985472, -0.006016851402819157, 0.06206243112683296, -0.03325578570365906, -0.02175222337245941, -0.05116007849574089, 0.025177985429763794, -0.0038598747923970222, -0.025571176782250404, 0.016461173072457314, -0.00942663848400116, 0.002136773196980357, 0.030513493344187737, 0.01268036663532257, 0.020315853878855705, -0.015164944343268871, 0.07328524440526962, 0.00921047292649746, -0.036443520337343216, -0.0014083381975069642, -0.03564069792628288, 0.004643995780497789, 0.006300321780145168, 0.01521703228354454, 0.003134080907329917, -0.009975170716643333, -0.010548780672252178, -0.00044559387606568635, 0.022578559815883636, -0.006043116562068462, -0.014260781928896904, -0.02904113382101059, -0.050814833492040634, -0.040402259677648544, 0.021971601992845535, -0.023616023361682892, -0.017087610438466072, 0.028179500252008438, 0.06180810183286667, -0.002541416557505727, 0.014332152903079987, 0.0018215634627267718, 0.023344125598669052, 0.08474475890398026, -0.012035267427563667, 0.012579175643622875, -0.007416700478643179, 0.009321071207523346, 0.038412660360336304, -0.0520523265004158, 0.0800066590309143, 0.03713173419237137, -0.02572374977171421, -0.029628269374370575, -0.05967814475297928, -0.03199908509850502, -0.01172010786831379, -0.013263487257063389, 0.01597137190401554, -0.0031203848775476217, -0.0816706046462059, 0.07518716156482697, 0.015351679176092148, 0.0013339024735614657, -0.028693992644548416, -0.0389668270945549, -0.0021385722793638706, -0.030753105878829956, -0.0400809645652771, -0.007520869839936495, -0.00013692938955500722, 0.03144264966249466, 0.09918176382780075, 0.004021929576992989, 0.03752836957573891, -0.07963983714580536, 0.005919383838772774, 0.03788013011217117, -0.019440308213233948, -0.02994479052722454, -0.037944115698337555, -0.03433870151638985, 0.03339972347021103, -0.005866945255547762, 0.014067146927118301, 0.042750418186187744, 0.025697888806462288, -0.06963954120874405, -0.025141065940260887, -0.029192892834544182, 0.023395154625177383, 0.041096072643995285, -0.01853884942829609, -0.04287378117442131, -0.037170927971601486, -0.00041278867865912616, -0.006107738707214594, 0.07859978824853897, 0.0139606399461627, -0.014404485002160072, 0.015597506426274776, -0.021650895476341248, 0.04329472780227661, 0.08874671161174774, 0.03083561174571514, -0.01106270495802164, -0.0016151273157447577, 0.05685053765773773, -0.05835094302892685, 0.018643401563167572, 0.0027664275839924812, -0.03857652097940445, -0.06953529268503189, 0.02858707867562771, -0.0522017627954483, 0.011848862282931805, 0.028839489445090294, -0.04658085107803345, -0.05279940366744995, 0.021673453971743584, -0.04717271402478218, -0.006651262752711773, 0.05037469416856766, -0.03752623498439789, 0.0033067737240344286, -0.0217477697879076, -0.0378168523311615, -0.03568800166249275, 0.04717680811882019, 0.0514158234000206, 0.011366695165634155, 0.03328721225261688, -0.07069121301174164, 0.018728476017713547, 0.002774458611384034, -0.009681947529315948, -0.00940574798732996, -0.015054024755954742, -0.00033461209386587143, -0.07551649957895279, -0.07776793837547302, 0.0360364206135273, 0.015431595966219902, -0.04029358923435211, -0.010295623913407326, 0.02178102917969227, 0.007158922962844372, 0.001278979703783989, 0.0392814502120018, 0.010470028035342693, -0.008978616446256638, 0.021004697307944298, 0.005176866427063942, 0.0876280665397644, -0.03033311851322651, -0.029843732714653015, 0.006126110907644033, -0.012863111682236195, -0.012989901937544346, 0.014324406161904335, -0.011271120049059391, -0.036530155688524246, 0.0024205788504332304, 0.08510236442089081, 0.011775081977248192, -0.006864439696073532, 0.07613686472177505, 0.03740273788571358, -0.0007537549827247858, 0.07895345985889435, 0.03998653218150139, 0.05391864478588104, -0.002091753063723445, 0.041321396827697754, -0.022251484915614128, 0.041335076093673706, 0.0036110011860728264, 0.03315192461013794, 0.0018386425217613578, 0.026038749143481255, 0.007258987985551357, 0.010265192948281765, -0.0020977745298296213, -0.007552227936685085, 0.003559187287464738, -0.017250390723347664, 0.04399373009800911, -0.08672592788934708, -0.02133304812014103, 0.026964059099555016, -0.02163744904100895, -0.050071146339178085, 0.043730299919843674, 0.06443917751312256, -0.013602291233837605, 0.02224317565560341, 0.03566575422883034, 0.02288655750453472, 0.06203087791800499, 0.04277821257710457, -0.005393814295530319, 0.08952517062425613, 0.04042681306600571, -0.04047946631908417, -0.02466350421309471, -0.0195737536996603, 0.011009604670107365, -0.021105000749230385, 0.0014240746386349201, -0.029488729313015938, -0.053872015327215195, -0.03208407387137413, -0.06038358807563782, -0.0025834408588707447, -0.0434061735868454, 0.0748453438282013, -0.047362059354782104, 0.037946391850709915, 0.02572370320558548, 0.008665734902024269, 0.009165814146399498, -0.041063953191041946, -0.020792244002223015, 0.06932024657726288, 0.006575544830411673, 0.05596603825688362, 0.0036789511796087027, -0.03854339197278023, -0.026566291227936745, 0.010048624128103256, 0.03561047092080116, -0.05874684453010559, 0.052610844373703, 0.06041727587580681, 0.030840979889035225, 0.019548727199435234, 0.016287093982100487, -0.04520982503890991, -0.0150647247210145, -0.036766812205314636, -0.017195235937833786, 0.022242823615670204, -0.013183558359742165, 0.004487542901188135, 0.01110268384218216, 0.025570297613739967, -0.011804736219346523, 0.01769247278571129, 0.023119499906897545, -0.029899489134550095, 0.031826432794332504, -0.03197005018591881, 0.061285313218832016, -0.0012395671801641583, 0.020917003974318504, -0.0072378553450107574, -0.0076073226518929005, 0.013321280479431152, 0.040022119879722595, -0.001467028516344726, -0.028319096192717552, -0.03360142186284065, -0.014738294295966625, 0.026228558272123337, -0.047481510788202286, -0.09013409912586212, -0.015910575166344643, 0.009603369049727917, 0.052693746984004974, 0.006593324709683657, 0.011890868656337261, 0.09702392667531967, -0.057532574981451035, 0.008906886912882328, -0.008018330670893192, -0.003877191571518779, -0.011227394454181194, -0.029124166816473007, -0.0012727297144010663, -0.001845726277679205, 0.023628782480955124, 0.050531938672065735, -0.004446824546903372, -0.03491499647498131, 0.0022556299809366465, 0.024269284680485725, -0.07284214347600937, 0.042159292846918106, -0.025978902354836464, 0.016839535906910896, -0.020650025457143784, 0.031569335609674454, 0.019032109528779984, -0.035348646342754364, 0.019348911941051483, 0.0530087985098362, -0.06841056048870087, -0.020428212359547615, -0.060705628246068954, -0.07509630918502808, 0.07743396610021591, 0.030755477026104927, -0.03534925729036331, -0.020510388538241386, -0.00043093517888337374, 0.08971364796161652, -0.03407181054353714, 0.013841047883033752, 0.043750565499067307, -0.02660449780523777, -0.03667834773659706, 0.06936807930469513, 0.00879223644733429, -0.03509822487831116, -0.015007947571575642, -0.016119448468089104, 0.0650453194975853, 0.017963124439120293, -0.0191818755120039, 0.08424108475446701, -0.003897063434123993, -0.024937652051448822, 0.014959224499762058, 0.07189503312110901, -0.0020502242259681225, -0.03947405144572258, -0.03305933251976967, -0.04911661893129349, -0.04128718376159668, 0.02964177541434765, 0.020183902233839035, -0.005182004068046808, -0.03409117832779884, 0.09548430144786835, -0.021572908386588097, -0.006073045078665018, -0.02811962552368641, 0.004720418248325586, -0.02543598785996437, -0.10063065588474274, -0.05199902877211571, 0.008428498171269894, -0.043956458568573, -0.023147685453295708, -0.010684577748179436, -0.02438252605497837, -0.021542416885495186, -0.03151737153530121, -0.04158889129757881, -0.017087848857045174, 0.009214748628437519, -0.0007235815864987671, 0.005746006034314632, 0.02071855030953884, 0.029208537191152573, 0.013935045339167118, 0.007247666362673044, 0.0803891122341156, -0.028705567121505737, -0.011677580885589123, -0.039282768964767456, -0.020724691450595856, 0.010214533656835556, 0.0469827875494957, -0.035660866647958755, -0.03082975558936596, -0.02716224454343319, -0.029262475669384003, 0.04358398914337158, -0.0037794215604662895, -0.05877095088362694, 0.007632322143763304, -0.027728142216801643, -0.013865005224943161, -0.04233778268098831, 0.010833081789314747, 0.004738111048936844, 0.07403048127889633, 0.04977867379784584, -0.00854740384966135, -0.035452086478471756, 0.05947920307517052, -0.017300982028245926, 0.04077812656760216, 0.07499046623706818, 0.0019938868936151266, 0.031542956829071045, -0.009808599017560482, -0.02896229177713394, -0.0486421175301075, -0.02927955985069275, 0.042834460735321045, 0.01043738704174757, -0.0475996658205986, -0.01427145954221487, 0.0037417709827423096, 0.029454238712787628, -0.01935870386660099, -0.03059285134077072, 0.01608932390809059, -0.033551041036844254, 0.016327833756804466, -0.041304998099803925, 0.0606246143579483, 0.005427353084087372, 0.010872316546738148, 0.02227778732776642, 0.021614303812384605, -0.011673388071358204, -0.04120374098420143, -0.0076150367967784405, -0.005130419973284006, 0.041258759796619415, 0.00661828787997365, 0.022628210484981537, 0.008524433709681034, -0.056020792573690414, -0.03429558873176575, -0.034868061542510986, 0.08846328407526016, 0.012392637319862843, -0.008743046782910824, 0.04068509489297867, 0.0012542364420369267, 0.09218236058950424, -0.001074879546649754, -0.06559479236602783, -0.019548773765563965, 0.06209566816687584, 0.04544694721698761, -0.010529834777116776, 0.029418136924505234, 0.007484305649995804, -0.056228701025247574, -0.038153696805238724, -0.030770283192396164, 0.08868707716464996, 0.025883229449391365, 0.008370981551706791, -0.01828969456255436, 0.01229365449398756, 0.0024351379834115505, -0.053969379514455795, -0.03106115572154522, 0.00008700942271389067, 0.0326843187212944, 0.020475393161177635, -0.019947882741689682, 0.0008407733403146267, 0.009145612828433514, -0.0229741670191288, 0.035952355712652206, -0.07715021818876266, 0.030542004853487015, 0.02939593978226185, 0.02316131815314293, 0.03896230831742287, 0.03329315781593323, -0.03936368227005005, -0.04729664698243141, 0.017893187701702118, 0.021134743466973305, -0.010066354647278786, -0.004227900877594948, 0.06857322156429291, -0.03545069694519043, -0.0798325389623642, -0.0035692539531737566, -0.016385076567530632, 0.03837507590651512, -0.0030531890224665403, 0.01253793016076088, 0.027629127725958824, 0.017323322594165802, -0.02872793935239315, -0.007146636489778757, 0.03713497892022133, -0.007359679322689772, 0.0240333192050457, 0.014216065406799316, -0.04842541739344597, 0.059437789022922516, 0.008427026681602001, -0.05200612545013428, 0.08272197097539902, -0.041220199316740036, -0.01773722842335701, 0.0007193100755102932, 0.003263597609475255, -0.05318703502416611, 0.02207796275615692, -0.01432066224515438, -0.018092237412929535, -0.03559350222349167, 0.007866224274039268, -0.006441838573664427, 0.06910178810358047, -0.028595730662345886, -0.006476839538663626, -0.029503606259822845, -0.018097031861543655, 0.00899600051343441, -0.05262298882007599, 0.04957609251141548, -0.04355493187904358, 0.006070279981940985, -0.03371456637978554, -0.03403544798493385, 0.03088144026696682, 0.005138914566487074, 0.034184154123067856, -0.03095317631959915, 0.05107433721423149, 0.0648689866065979, -0.04369809478521347, -0.061588045209646225, -0.056175194680690765, 0.0360090546309948, 0.02790752798318863, -0.03188258036971092, 0.02009495720267296, -0.017768647521734238, -0.05974104255437851, -0.025235846638679504, -0.052403222769498825, -0.0790381208062172, -0.017874067649245262, 0.04737486317753792, -0.037208978086709976, -0.034248996526002884, -0.023368116468191147, 0.00909534003585577, 0.05585949495434761, -0.007829809561371803, 0.048010360449552536, 0.07192037999629974, 0.016329916194081306, 0.011739089153707027, 0.008486551232635975, -0.02023075707256794, 0.006956679280847311, -0.003359051188454032, 0.050379324704408646, -0.015599599108099937, -0.01676788367331028, -0.02142453007400036, 0.030941110104322433, 0.02589600160717964, -0.01943284273147583, -0.006308984477072954, 0.02539115957915783, -0.05731614679098129, 0.005962706636637449, 0.020663298666477203, 0.009486904367804527, 0.02841082774102688, -0.023155171424150467, 0.02238389290869236, -0.0444299653172493, -0.025875557214021683, -0.055977463722229004, -0.05803048983216286, 0.022965485230088234, -0.03124408610165119, -0.06718458980321884, 0.014652328565716743, -0.007520706858485937 ]
<p>I am trying to determine why people ask if a model of a health care risk (for inpatient stay, or acquiring a disease or any outcome) is a population risk model or an individual risk model. This is in a clinical setting where the outcome is some medical event and covariates are personal health history and demographics. The risk here is then the prob(outcome) as determined by some binary classifier.</p> <p>I understand there may be a different emphasis on the way quality of the model is assessed. For an individual risk model it is perhaps more important to have a small variance of an individual's score and this measure is not captured by AUC of the model or other traditional accuracy measures. Is that the main reason for the difference?</p> <p>If the model is created with observations of people's health history so rows in model are people, then is this necessarily an individual risk model? If not why not?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
g37174
[ 0.022039910778403282, -0.005582968704402447, -0.005643903743475676, -0.014291352592408657, 0.034232717007398605, 0.053531453013420105, 0.023179901763796806, -0.022065453231334686, -0.03667869791388512, -0.06010744720697403, 0.0689985454082489, 0.03497190773487091, 0.055597707629203796, -0.036714255809783936, -0.04428039491176605, -0.06688108295202255, 0.0073263137601315975, -0.002149451058357954, 0.027973439544439316, -0.016477694734930992, -0.009323852136731148, -0.012083836831152439, 0.05142045021057129, -0.007636211812496185, -0.04932890459895134, -0.03153958544135094, 0.030565541237592697, 0.01564982160925865, -0.03569053113460541, 0.000264507660176605, -0.030303552746772766, 0.026677969843149185, 0.05502863973379135, -0.03449661657214165, -0.01870003156363964, -0.054667193442583084, 0.007829808630049229, 0.02210564725100994, 0.006818239111453295, 0.046837590634822845, 0.009582990780472755, 0.04221818223595619, -0.0022047115489840508, -0.006686612498015165, 0.009559545665979385, 0.03811324015259743, -0.002553159836679697, -0.019127583131194115, 0.007080607116222382, 0.04637563228607178, 0.009775351732969284, -0.034446779638528824, 0.03973393142223358, 0.03831573575735092, 0.006196972914040089, -0.019326556473970413, -0.00342526170425117, 0.023905811831355095, -0.001841082819737494, -0.013544675894081593, -0.028966106474399567, 0.043609198182821274, -0.0067158909514546394, 0.017677361145615578, 0.02386167086660862, 0.028062989935278893, 0.017554784193634987, -0.037646062672138214, 0.029188362881541252, 0.024573711678385735, -0.04705214872956276, -0.02856174297630787, 0.026258205994963646, -0.013299651443958282, -0.0438021756708622, 0.016663633286952972, -0.05415898934006691, 0.029652396216988564, 0.04221609979867935, 0.039016153663396835, 0.012113052420318127, 0.01695176400244236, 0.013601088896393776, 0.03338388726115227, 0.050726767629384995, 0.015541932545602322, -0.039134953171014786, -0.06409949064254761, -0.0029248555656522512, 0.030494550243020058, -0.008330526761710644, -0.003283460857346654, 0.05402951315045357, 0.0795382410287857, -0.05306945741176605, 0.012884040363132954, -0.11663051694631577, 0.01220890786498785, -0.0007091398583725095, 0.03370688855648041, -0.02574271149933338, 0.01747736521065235, 0.01570148393511772, -0.007222271058708429, -0.043501898646354675, -0.061872728168964386, -0.006082795560359955, 0.03228837996721268, -0.016778714954853058, -0.009515965357422829, -0.0011211589444428682, 0.032534848898649216, -0.04916413500905037, 0.02144918031990528, -0.022454755380749702, 0.01493863482028246, -0.014942096546292305, 0.028158850967884064, -0.052225060760974884, -0.030536429956555367, 0.023806674405932426, -0.050328996032476425, 0.03660418838262558, 0.04540169984102249, -0.09727096557617188, -0.007410940248519182, -0.03392373397946358, 0.05459802225232124, 0.0031932122074067593, 0.02362958714365959, -0.002448499668389559, 0.005936654284596443, 0.011627881787717342, 0.037099696695804596, 0.04266642406582832, 0.005396469030529261, 0.058520812541246414, 0.014565986581146717, 0.05198514834046364, 0.022984713315963745, 0.030271118506789207, 0.055791500955820084, 0.007008783984929323, -0.008732952177524567, 0.0035562205594033003, 0.024698715656995773, 0.01656910590827465, 0.01833302341401577, -0.030748052522540092, 0.05066472291946411, 0.024331338703632355, 0.025351975113153458, -0.04754010960459709, 0.06723061949014664, -0.04122346267104149, 0.032021913677453995, -0.024509014561772346, 0.07937280833721161, -0.029371174052357674, 0.06741596013307571, 0.06191205978393555, -0.009894880466163158, 0.0010753480019047856, 0.001968976343050599, 0.001258016680367291, -0.05379798263311386, 0.023923685774207115, -0.03718779608607292, -0.01610678806900978, -0.016267621889710426, 0.04468021169304848, -0.011735235340893269, 0.003969745244830847, -0.003753162221983075, 0.08880175650119781, -0.0013637450756505132, 0.014306556433439255, 0.040056660771369934, 0.04596458747982979, -0.000704610429238528, 0.0058355084620416164, -0.05352649837732315, 0.004142439924180508, -0.06827645003795624, -0.045285239815711975, -0.019178636372089386, 0.016399241983890533, 0.027328209951519966, 0.017016500234603882, -0.03696137294173241, 0.013309813104569912, -0.04394081234931946, -0.005476389545947313, -0.01586669497191906, -0.03110625222325325, -0.00853519793599844, 0.012645968236029148, -0.009223821572959423, -0.01301074493676424, 0.0845193937420845, 0.030984552577137947, 0.005939085967838764, -0.000344240601407364, 0.05949417129158974, -0.026382500305771828, 0.03345435485243797, 0.02137479931116104, 0.009775676764547825, -0.04275485873222351, -0.06819798052310944, -0.041730690747499466, -0.020507510751485825, -0.04032391309738159, 0.009346632286906242, -0.009664110839366913, -0.0706879273056984, 0.021144071593880653, 0.05167384818196297, -0.023775944486260414, -0.026282725855708122, -0.03952425345778465, -0.05844421684741974, 0.012722614221274853, 0.013643104583024979, -0.0101006543263793, 0.06944636255502701, -0.03529304638504982, 0.029854975640773773, -0.0026512800250202417, 0.005668601952493191, 0.020145289599895477, -0.04610181972384453, 0.016542727127671242, -0.032732829451560974, 0.020636800676584244, 0.011656352318823338, 0.04435392841696739, 0.005628647282719612, 0.007516928482800722, -0.03506678715348244, -0.001624370808713138, -0.01704585738480091, 0.00045282315113581717, -0.04042910784482956, -0.0008258458692580462, -0.027042975649237633, -0.015968967229127884, -0.039319224655628204, 0.03364236280322075, 0.042134903371334076, -0.016929365694522858, -0.0025084526278078556, -0.002679650904610753, -0.0444989874958992, 0.018869716674089432, -0.13212761282920837, 0.057026732712984085, 0.04168234393000603, -0.036109279841184616, 0.05103088915348053, -0.039624668657779694, -0.036607902497053146, -0.009928005747497082, 0.008533972315490246, 0.06885293871164322, 0.002095234813168645, 0.023021915927529335, -0.04417942091822624, -0.003528557950630784, 0.018688790500164032, 0.05848364159464836, 0.03648576885461807, 0.0025741353165358305, 0.030422896146774292, 0.03205624222755432, -0.06368198245763779, -0.05806298181414604, 0.0074757118709385395, -0.010238130576908588, -0.05524951219558716, 0.02439723163843155, -0.011977721005678177, -0.04585757851600647, -0.013420193456113338, 0.028331007808446884, 0.05070621892809868, 0.04381830245256424, -0.04946039617061615, -0.0481281653046608, 0.02352159284055233, -0.03792726993560791, -0.023514026775956154, 0.010982164181768894, -0.03301873430609703, 0.01544437650591135, -0.0053954049944877625, -0.024640977382659912, -0.03395574912428856, 0.015412614680826664, 0.016833938658237457, -0.040143296122550964, -0.035596299916505814, 0.017019672319293022, 0.014483712613582611, 0.025102561339735985, -0.011830438859760761, 0.010460673831403255, 0.026876090094447136, -0.012384625151753426, -0.04024086147546768, 0.015571143478155136, 0.012168836779892445, -0.04416554048657417, 0.0215944591909647, 0.03244950994849205, -0.03631206229329109, 0.010517875663936138, 0.000017819402273744345, -0.012042198330163956, -0.029760826379060745, -0.000699403288308531, 0.00526517815887928, -0.027107002213597298, 0.022657856345176697, -0.0357108935713768, -0.004642515908926725, -0.03232255205512047, 0.008030171506106853, -0.006080144550651312, -0.045662686228752136, 0.03039734438061714, 0.00286774686537683, -0.017254872247576714, 0.02569715492427349, 0.05115694925189018, -0.09745031595230103, -0.0592084638774395, 0.0017414221074432135, -0.011781450361013412, 0.04043496027588844, -0.0009758585947565734, -0.04622625187039375, -0.0003672482562251389, -0.0005439703818410635, -0.03780260309576988, -0.03357120230793953, 0.05873728170990944, -0.03588361293077469, 0.03263702616095543, -0.049687303602695465, 0.001978070242330432, -0.04173455014824867, -0.04654010012745857, 0.008761350996792316, 0.03529108315706253, -0.018309932202100754, -0.004155132453888655, -0.02534954994916916, -0.0014483401319012046, 0.06476249545812607, -0.007959002628922462, -0.006913577672094107, -0.004578799474984407, 0.02467186190187931, -0.00011456555512268096, 0.04549170657992363, 0.05621962249279022, 0.0754416286945343, 0.026630107313394547, -0.03503144904971123, -0.0014150920324027538, 0.03775666654109955, -0.01594206690788269, -0.04008057713508606, -0.009078174829483032, 0.01181144081056118, 0.0008828165009617805, 0.04590537026524544, -0.022747445851564407, -0.003208081005141139, 0.022858072072267532, -0.020066533237695694, 0.008145567029714584, -0.014383352361619473, -0.0033685790840536356, -0.05381463095545769, 0.053159359842538834, -0.036790043115615845, -0.023961881175637245, -0.038174599409103394, -0.010034777224063873, -0.09338594228029251, -0.011843392625451088, 0.016755610704421997, 0.0790354460477829, 0.030276650562882423, -0.04883512109518051, 0.000672364782076329, 0.039822302758693695, 0.06557144224643707, -0.0242385882884264, -0.021063419058918953, -0.004972929134964943, 0.03822179138660431, -0.029653314501047134, 0.018769456073641777, -0.06172136217355728, -0.09877486526966095, -0.033828508108854294, 0.03868658095598221, 0.014759525656700134, 0.039108533412218094, 0.004737398121505976, -0.003959774971008301, 0.06086959317326546, 0.05343051999807358, 0.03329529985785484, 0.0300455205142498, 0.014642409980297089, 0.022325564175844193, 0.03771596774458885, -0.00025321257999166846, -0.009485585615038872, 0.028954733163118362, 0.02320196107029915, 0.05566596984863281, -0.02019667625427246, 0.027023708447813988, 0.017533641308546066, -0.042064119130373, 0.038571082055568695, 0.07452286034822464, -0.025485849007964134, 0.06924084573984146, 0.011261660605669022, 0.0037966619711369276, 0.04892624914646149, -0.020123854279518127, -0.03783687576651573, -0.09401925653219223, -0.03597192466259003, 0.007060550153255463, 0.04491838812828064, -0.004243264906108379, 0.032075654715299606, 0.024179263040423393, -0.030369075015187263, -0.013352599926292896, 0.014262011274695396, 0.01853041909635067, 0.011823576875030994, 0.043881114572286606, 0.0032092260662466288, -0.0977371335029602, 0.026932893320918083, 0.023433232679963112, 0.03516461327672005, -0.031674839556217194, 0.05847976729273796, 0.09103550761938095, 0.03496168553829193, -0.051493193954229355, 0.018331632018089294, -0.027047066017985344, -0.032472409307956696, -0.048139333724975586, -0.08365082740783691, -0.0426514707505703, -0.013893192633986473, -0.00687241880223155, -0.013324165716767311, -0.0230721328407526, -0.008413421921432018, -0.03138132020831108, 0.02892572060227394, 0.041911158710718155, 0.020500797778367996, -0.011195479892194271, -0.034726332873106, -0.02518717758357525, -0.023012567311525345, 0.022359196096658707, 0.010585367679595947, 0.026222482323646545, -0.00200627651065588, -0.0318404845893383, -0.003928705584257841, -0.05944241210818291, 0.021180082112550735, 0.007444973569363356, 0.01379178836941719, 0.030300328508019447, 0.06955374032258987, 0.029804416000843048, -0.003725441638380289, -0.012646066024899483, 0.004659202881157398, 0.03866242989897728, 0.02354372665286064, -0.04718492925167084, -0.030276048928499222, 0.06539429724216461, 0.030442772433161736, -0.06384951621294022, -0.020708711817860603, 0.07902374863624573, 0.05475177243351936, -0.03242526948451996, 0.0323445126414299, 0.03329731523990631, 0.0440322607755661, -0.042495522648096085, 0.008867943659424782, 0.010520986281335354, -0.00004384222847875208, -0.002572299214079976, -0.019440630450844765, 0.024268632754683495, 0.030834315344691277, 0.015406988561153412, -0.00030686514219269156, 0.00850356463342905, 0.024153975769877434, 0.00994445476680994, -0.027261363342404366, -0.01274863537400961, -0.02223934419453144, -0.04749953746795654, -0.004184871446341276, -0.02781342715024948, 0.0430435948073864, 0.05527103692293167, 0.003186875721439719, -0.01620742306113243, -0.020972177386283875, 0.005208889488130808, -0.04923255369067192, -0.0004525474214460701, 0.017884403467178345, 0.014966759830713272, -0.07608029991388321, 0.012074531987309456, -0.008468902669847012, -0.03322373330593109, 0.07990092784166336, 0.0205009113997221, -0.02141263149678707, -0.03791884332895279, -0.029264453798532486, 0.022856295108795166, 0.005998824257403612, 0.015546889044344425, -0.021812092512845993, 0.03924640640616417, -0.037041131407022476, -0.009312993846833706, 0.012860821560025215, 0.011322315782308578, -0.0006513478583656251, -0.01212273072451353, 0.03413180634379387, -0.01675683632493019, -0.02508271113038063, -0.041457779705524445, 0.028807541355490685, -0.013255725614726543, -0.019253181293606758, -0.028002237901091576, -0.06322754174470901, -0.0631369799375534, 0.058759935200214386, -0.04555881395936012, 0.05353114753961563, -0.013915163464844227, -0.03285402059555054, 0.020489219576120377, -0.01610073633491993, -0.01905502751469612, 0.012889735400676727, -0.013254372403025627, -0.033948544412851334, -0.03626784309744835, 0.001612536609172821, 0.02573557384312153, 0.07203561812639236, 0.06038089096546173, 0.003574277274310589, -0.032478149980306625, 0.025976041331887245, 0.058077372610569, -0.0035050807055085897, -0.013581577688455582, -0.022157400846481323, 0.013280053623020649, -0.01922941952943802, -0.000785376294516027, -0.001130282529629767, -0.017712291330099106, -0.02736097387969494, -0.05167718604207039, -0.03399483114480972, -0.01722201332449913, -0.015617810189723969, 0.0011812589364126325, 0.06176893040537834, 0.04861310124397278, -0.018848160281777382, 0.018926195800304413, 0.03180426359176636, -0.03888507932424545, -0.028888532891869545, 0.03167484700679779, 0.0047674644738435745, 0.01602664589881897, 0.03435521200299263, -0.015223084948956966, -0.06527373939752579, -0.019587654620409012, -0.03484824672341347, 0.05000527575612068, 0.004422827158123255, -0.05004321038722992, 0.017607741057872772, 0.01868554577231407, 0.02149144932627678, 0.03983936458826065, -0.07225655019283295, 0.055826857686042786, 0.02052624337375164, 0.049291230738162994, -0.04983280599117279, 0.06690732389688492, -0.07249730825424194, 0.08358597010374069, -0.055107057094573975, 0.02743586339056492, -0.07436272501945496, 0.048314739018678665, 0.013364270329475403, -0.06039537489414215, 0.04471030831336975, 0.03617614880204201, 0.002061061328276992, -0.011213663034141064, -0.015574827790260315, -0.0010966656263917685, 0.04839159920811653, -0.035881269723176956, -0.05437261983752251, 0.0021091203670948744, -0.05224708467721939, 0.0010235143126919866, 0.007140969391912222, -0.07046718150377274, 0.017561467364430428, 0.03238639980554581, 0.015613920986652374, 0.05227663740515709, 0.05010535195469856, 0.010007877834141254, -0.011397281661629677, 0.00896801520138979, -0.04975418746471405, 0.014532781206071377, 0.024739690124988556, 0.046222567558288574, -0.047092899680137634, -0.06340552121400833, 0.0034245834685862064, -0.019249195232987404, -0.0024510875809937716, -0.0038363542407751083, -0.012201896868646145, -0.023435937240719795, -0.0005712893325835466, -0.025600392371416092, -0.02589506469666958, 0.05142896994948387, -0.007810561452060938, -0.017344769090414047, 0.010030762292444706, 0.05554019659757614, 0.05583704635500908, 0.05785561725497246, 0.011089424602687359, 0.05567731335759163, 0.02759241685271263, -0.06189572066068649, 0.03202924132347107, -0.04142558574676514, -0.06084756553173065, -0.07726898044347763, 0.03320859745144844, 0.03051239810883999, -0.05915996432304382, -0.023919444531202316, -0.0331498347222805, 0.0715305507183075, 0.033402878791093826, 0.02286074496805668, 0.05024613067507744, 0.04611531272530556, 0.04594685509800911, -0.016598429530858994, 0.041949253529310226, -0.05707749351859093, -0.028877537697553635, 0.0020895812194794416, -0.03482688218355179, -0.06768997013568878, 0.015404843725264072, 0.03591112047433853, 0.026348812505602837, -0.05213106796145439, -0.023557843640446663, -0.06200999766588211, -0.027880867943167686, -0.018202682957053185, -0.0006572103011421859, -0.035570356994867325, -0.032439373433589935, -0.005366074852645397, -0.04161883145570755, 0.022032370790839195, 0.0159384086728096, -0.05199107900261879, -0.01287331897765398, 0.04115356132388115, -0.017311714589595795, 0.00012861400318797678, -0.048911202698946, -0.01239644642919302, -0.07101502269506454, -0.003264486091211438, 0.05278819054365158, -0.00582969281822443, 0.047985486686229706, 0.024133427068591118, -0.03960936889052391, -0.02246048115193844, 0.008801273070275784, 0.029410479590296745, 0.07044380158185959, 0.043754588812589645, -0.007942672818899155, 0.03793158009648323, -0.058499738574028015, 0.014989071525633335, -0.0225994773209095, -0.002302581910043955, -0.0837407261133194, 0.016898157075047493, -0.0649985745549202, 0.05630578100681305, 0.014585868455469608, 0.018814392387866974, -0.00665822671726346, -0.012034894898533821, -0.021251844242215157, -0.013075868599116802, -0.017835555598139763, -0.045621395111083984, -0.01498050894588232, 0.047104235738515854, 0.01104512345045805, -0.021051231771707535, 0.020940616726875305, 0.046801548451185226 ]
<p>Following cardiac surgery, patients are encouraged to exercise regularly (assume that regular exercise is defined as exercising on 3 or more days per week). A physician suspects that patients exercise regularly immediately following cardiac surgery but tend to reduce, even stop exercising completely, over time. An investigation is planned to estimate the mean number of weeks that patients exercise regularly following cardiac surgery. Assume that the standard deviation (s.d) in the number of weeks cardiac patients exercise regularly following surgery is 6.3 weeks.</p> <p>(a) If a sample of 40 cardiac patients is followed, and the number of weeks in which each patient exercised regularly is recorded, what is the probability that the sample mean will be no more than 1 week higher than the true mean?</p> <p>Under central limit therom, </p> <pre><code>standard error = s.d./sqrt(n) = 6.3/sqrt(40) = 0.99 X = true mean + 1 Z = (X - true mean) / 0.99 = (true mean + 1 = true mean) / 0.99 = 1/0.99 </code></pre> <p>(b) Find the probability that the sample mean is at least two weeks less than the true mean for a sample of 40 cardiac patients.</p> <pre><code>X = true mean - 2 Z = (X - true mean) / 0.99 = (true mean -2 - true mean) / 0.99 = -2/0.99 </code></pre> <p>(c) If the sample is increased to 100 cardiac patients, what is the probability that the sample mean will be no more than 1 week higher than the true mean?</p> <p>same as question Can anyone help me check my answers to see whether is correct or not? Please correct and explain if wrong...</p>
g37175
[ -0.009431775659322739, 0.019311636686325073, 0.010446998290717602, 0.038220107555389404, -0.06387359648942947, -0.014551959000527859, 0.07305361330509186, 0.05756900832056999, 0.0007111552404239774, -0.03510028496384621, -0.018638649955391884, 0.01879100501537323, -0.023125246167182922, -0.0769575908780098, -0.004815749358385801, 0.042213816195726395, -0.0010916416067630053, -0.03364735469222069, -0.019792042672634125, -0.0081155551597476, -0.06285872310400009, 0.040420811623334885, -0.01156928762793541, -0.0371469147503376, 0.013032208196818829, -0.07401067763566971, -0.021104279905557632, 0.06498300284147263, -0.05878136679530144, 0.017838215455412865, -0.02915455587208271, 0.015660520642995834, 0.05809647589921951, -0.06095908209681511, -0.00803286675363779, -0.04356294497847557, 0.13406528532505035, -0.006191636435687542, -0.022582584992051125, -0.01652226410806179, -0.021653281524777412, 0.022852512076497078, 0.03493694216012955, 0.006101010832935572, 0.01582571491599083, -0.02424168400466442, 0.029685700312256813, 0.0005588534404523671, -0.018561292439699173, -0.03977956622838974, -0.0059520225040614605, 0.017707301303744316, -0.04590215906500816, -0.01912749744951725, -0.031361550092697144, 0.06559136509895325, 0.0155330840498209, -0.009210716001689434, -0.0048247212544083595, 0.01657121628522873, 0.03200262412428856, -0.004202032461762428, -0.021837744861841202, -0.002826316747814417, 0.009550364688038826, 0.023271910846233368, 0.01021450012922287, 0.0332079716026783, 0.03238798305392265, 0.012719344347715378, -0.023773562163114548, -0.030686335638165474, -0.016051439568400383, 0.02879314310848713, -0.056620486080646515, -0.015418075025081635, 0.013880215585231781, 0.03133488819003105, 0.012100610882043839, 0.00249597174115479, -0.01646449789404869, -0.012509587220847607, -0.001612541964277625, 0.001758899656124413, 0.06546785682439804, 0.03090306743979454, -0.00248719472438097, -0.014722911641001701, 0.04195874184370041, 0.04010273143649101, 0.052103057503700256, -0.008834326639771461, 0.11170945316553116, 0.10213809460401535, -0.014838810078799725, -0.046998195350170135, -0.041847679764032364, 0.004864691756665707, 0.01990433596074581, -0.03011733666062355, -0.01330323051661253, -0.05072818323969841, 0.006328234449028969, -0.03386335074901581, -0.10671874135732651, 0.00707455538213253, 0.010041826404631138, 0.01880752667784691, -0.02778928354382515, -0.016016805544495583, -0.004870336037129164, -0.009112004190683365, -0.051045943051576614, -0.02462777867913246, -0.02929616905748844, 0.05637609586119652, 0.05492944270372391, -0.01487170159816742, 0.040021322667598724, -0.007357597816735506, -0.024456584826111794, 0.019078578799962997, -0.03472556546330452, 0.042726170271635056, -0.06934726983308792, -0.013966946862637997, -0.0663805678486824, 0.058503445237874985, 0.04394843429327011, 0.049442194402217865, -0.0248549934476614, 0.03222034126520157, -0.020348798483610153, 0.03293914720416069, -0.016505036503076553, -0.01530719455331564, 0.04117807373404503, 0.08833348751068115, -0.001175825484097004, -0.011876150965690613, -0.01601816900074482, 0.012033711187541485, 0.050098344683647156, 0.0005489186150953174, -0.02426997572183609, -0.003765917383134365, 0.02638310194015503, -0.012182648293673992, -0.05913344398140907, -0.010150682181119919, -0.04028184711933136, 0.045222170650959015, 0.009204809553921223, -0.01297792512923479, -0.003891391446813941, -0.01884867064654827, -0.06451033055782318, 0.01719452254474163, -0.03851054608821869, -0.03823951631784439, 0.07239370793104172, -0.023724203929305077, 0.019338330253958702, 0.026212284341454506, -0.06858301162719727, 0.006703909952193499, 0.029053734615445137, -0.02497045323252678, -0.005041736643761396, 0.0008151345537044108, 0.0509045235812664, -0.06423866003751755, -0.004467547405511141, -0.036096032708883286, -0.012946207076311111, 0.03385138139128685, 0.06352363526821136, -0.01809754967689514, -0.026706045493483543, 0.020934022963047028, -0.0030592516995966434, 0.07757332175970078, 0.03584715723991394, -0.023492049425840378, -0.012114167213439941, -0.054436277598142624, 0.020765230059623718, -0.020964449271559715, -0.033062927424907684, -0.02439776249229908, -0.01687016896903515, 0.002607873873785138, 0.0628039613366127, 0.004144027829170227, -0.021733224391937256, -0.0041607762686908245, 0.05414009094238281, -0.016107814386487007, -0.009090365841984749, 0.006840062793344259, 0.0294572114944458, 0.013017539866268635, -0.042342659085989, -0.03302381560206413, 0.03158027306199074, -0.04995328187942505, 0.012180637568235397, -0.04356531798839569, 0.008585006929934025, -0.03573020175099373, -0.04773662984371185, -0.00268567050807178, -0.06519174575805664, 0.08546485006809235, 0.06730996072292328, -0.0014871881576254964, 0.021186619997024536, 0.04414881765842438, 0.03887581825256348, -0.03484443947672844, 0.03708433732390404, -0.033291883766651154, 0.005679301917552948, -0.004648411646485329, -0.025782572105526924, 0.05059552192687988, 0.038170505315065384, 0.0006474999827332795, -0.05401119962334633, 0.044556405395269394, 0.006224160082638264, 0.01946510747075081, -0.009971830062568188, -0.051493313163518906, 0.012259778566658497, 0.017206134274601936, -0.012237896211445332, 0.022926749661564827, 0.028410030528903008, -0.021626614034175873, 0.03206300735473633, 0.02986946515738964, -0.0058680386282503605, -0.03009309433400631, 0.02786097675561905, -0.02953590452671051, -0.020812319591641426, -0.0040445332415401936, 0.03624105080962181, 0.024290481582283974, 0.05444609746336937, 0.048765864223241806, -0.02562514692544937, -0.03915074095129967, 0.06794223934412003, -0.01300203986465931, -0.04600759968161583, 0.03162166103720665, -0.017844252288341522, -0.022404184564948082, 0.012124435976147652, -0.008898761123418808, 0.02270335517823696, 0.008641478605568409, 0.013050301931798458, -0.007989843375980854, -0.018107762560248375, -0.020792156457901, 0.02866695635020733, -0.00011770494893426076, -0.030463773757219315, 0.008874126709997654, -0.0008556824177503586, 0.09036116302013397, -0.01290538813918829, -0.03156983107328415, -0.0008261420880444348, -0.002466794801875949, 0.06617085635662079, -0.02032163180410862, 0.018988491967320442, -0.020387249067425728, -0.005702085327357054, 0.021575093269348145, 0.0018361250404268503, 0.02375202439725399, 0.043563634157180786, -0.04430157318711281, -0.04503147304058075, 0.018038492649793625, -0.002279245527461171, -0.019711244851350784, 0.044614002108573914, -0.031087586656212807, 0.037514884024858475, 0.05661296844482422, 0.039560411125421524, -0.013014119118452072, 0.005638540722429752, 0.03870963305234909, -0.053505782037973404, 0.012295683845877647, -0.03767869621515274, -0.029629221186041832, 0.031273551285266876, 0.025791138410568237, 0.008239270187914371, 0.014590339735150337, 0.016928235068917274, -0.015175913460552692, 0.02124154008924961, -0.037088632583618164, 0.03035695292055607, -0.03851620480418205, -0.06405886262655258, 0.015233512967824936, -0.040930118411779404, 0.006121502257883549, 0.02610412798821926, 0.020061936229467392, 0.005713647697120905, 0.007498119957745075, -0.03513707220554352, 0.009286586195230484, 0.04521628096699715, -0.03683791309595108, -0.05974160134792328, 0.06732852756977081, -0.02474994771182537, -0.03404143825173378, -0.0034758851397782564, 0.039428211748600006, -0.06044834852218628, -0.01711510866880417, -0.013501116074621677, -0.05169397220015526, 0.0027464190497994423, 0.033735744655132294, 0.008844145573675632, 0.03085237182676792, 0.008618622086942196, 0.026673698797822, -0.008412555791437626, -0.02922455407679081, 0.06437636911869049, 0.02738400734961033, -0.03148002177476883, 0.03190974146127701, 0.007664096541702747, 0.05227172002196312, -0.002473055385053158, -0.019459903240203857, -0.026829354465007782, -0.012758352793753147, -0.0020005283877253532, 0.06925676017999649, 0.03508111089468002, -0.017475564032793045, -0.009188693016767502, -0.030962709337472916, 0.031239720061421394, -0.01746458001434803, -0.0727623850107193, 0.04835106432437897, 0.010387411341071129, 0.03446997329592705, 0.037079405039548874, 0.0562339648604393, 0.045952532440423965, -0.020883571356534958, -0.007016676943749189, -0.029137855395674706, 0.029585111886262894, -0.03576846420764923, -0.008543546311557293, -0.007272450253367424, 0.018920008093118668, 0.021350430324673653, 0.021274089813232422, 0.008172906935214996, 0.03739136457443237, 0.025613361969590187, 0.007430250756442547, -0.09077495336532593, 0.0005471857730299234, -0.0049710324965417385, -0.002246837131679058, 0.0014426971320062876, -0.027879495173692703, -0.02661263383924961, -0.014042217284440994, -0.06569408625364304, -0.058421190828084946, 0.046766459941864014, 0.009342842735350132, -0.06254038214683533, 0.013519249856472015, -0.007686169818043709, 0.024057870730757713, 0.03724389895796776, -0.004822371061891317, 0.023028850555419922, 0.06474651396274567, 0.0183709803968668, -0.035440634936094284, -0.000038901398511370644, 0.006828472018241882, -0.005994364153593779, -0.02389863133430481, 0.036722615361213684, -0.0006866013281978667, -0.0455983467400074, -0.004637936130166054, -0.07107922434806824, 0.08577670156955719, 0.02734200656414032, 0.05231090262532234, 0.03866337984800339, -0.05102333426475525, 0.04848421737551689, -0.001870066043920815, -0.025890527293086052, -0.000988463405519724, 0.01301683858036995, -0.0009341835393570364, 0.07309359312057495, -0.026513513177633286, -0.05310872942209244, 0.03779894486069679, -0.02542937360703945, 0.027198875322937965, 0.014390688389539719, -0.05530250445008278, 0.04690277948975563, -0.007661009673029184, -0.008193637244403362, 0.018993131816387177, -0.006775268353521824, -0.07028983533382416, -0.02207418531179428, -0.06692244112491608, -0.002922843908891082, -0.061321597546339035, 0.004693745635449886, 0.020336905494332314, 0.04235868155956268, -0.05898967385292053, -0.08399582654237747, 0.022681470960378647, 0.005811516661196947, -0.01037188433110714, 0.05716169252991676, -0.02876363694667816, -0.0017175930552184582, 0.02907365933060646, -0.025245418772101402, -0.009281103499233723, 0.016203735023736954, 0.030444934964179993, 0.10011753439903259, -0.020383130759000778, -0.037159740924835205, 0.00429771700873971, 0.021677395328879356, -0.021917682141065598, -0.0017319479957222939, -0.004839863162487745, -0.03589789196848869, 0.016096318140625954, 0.03900311887264252, -0.03455996513366699, -0.02168526127934456, 0.04569412022829056, -0.03471999615430832, -0.005826814565807581, 0.03332386165857315, 0.02249431610107422, -0.014524020254611969, 0.0208724495023489, 0.03695498779416084, 0.015864912420511246, 0.025940587744116783, -0.053172606974840164, 0.0060943663120269775, -0.0062146564014256, -0.05436544120311737, 0.032298050820827484, -0.08518218249082565, -0.0023712581023573875, 0.018779927864670753, 0.04458169266581535, 0.04948326572775841, 0.0680900514125824, 0.046354297548532486, 0.037387993186712265, -0.007218333426862955, 0.044066235423088074, 0.03259533643722534, 0.014743123203516006, -0.011036916635930538, -0.04487302899360657, -0.000185539509402588, -0.012403625063598156, -0.01982765644788742, -0.012024592608213425, 0.015546835027635098, -0.015791678801178932, 0.014769600704312325, -0.0342400036752224, 0.046182043850421906, -0.019665073603391647, 0.01631898246705532, 0.05518483743071556, 0.016332903876900673, -0.025218000635504723, 0.025536874309182167, 0.001905543264001608, -0.03001614287495613, 0.0431513786315918, 0.03706156834959984, 0.07536156475543976, -0.04441021755337715, 0.03633919358253479, -0.0073317876085639, 0.0010565487900748849, -0.10961396247148514, -0.018714645877480507, -0.011339648626744747, 0.044381946325302124, -0.03160350024700165, 0.04348597303032875, 0.06641973555088043, -0.010261842049658298, 0.0035160407423973083, -0.01671833172440529, 0.013076270930469036, -0.0469265915453434, -0.06165015324950218, 0.012215211987495422, -0.019962240010499954, -0.058638062328100204, -0.042608555406332016, 0.06241307407617569, 0.009479327127337456, -0.032714392989873886, -0.001807346474379301, 0.008029044605791569, -0.04660754278302193, -0.012152288109064102, -0.03245191276073456, 0.028054052963852882, -0.01994384080171585, -0.04921955242753029, -0.00787773821502924, 0.005902578588575125, 0.06817067414522171, 0.007075903937220573, 0.019469931721687317, -0.010971754789352417, -0.0014599316054955125, 0.019964631646871567, -0.0738476887345314, 0.03913802653551102, 0.01714434288442135, 0.019402818754315376, -0.04220852628350258, -0.021716555580496788, -0.021298430860042572, 0.013882732950150967, -0.006965450011193752, 0.02818603813648224, 0.030930638313293457, 0.030549360439181328, 0.015822336077690125, -0.006935126148164272, 0.04835231229662895, -0.00803877878934145, 0.0014326452510431409, -0.011524521745741367, -0.05321083590388298, -0.0723077580332756, -0.038140613585710526, 0.02661522664129734, -0.030462320894002914, -0.01661524921655655, 0.09264817833900452, 0.03593768551945686, 0.018506275489926338, -0.011107244528830051, -0.024499017745256424, -0.0007122843526303768, 0.013776997104287148, 0.01599818281829357, -0.008862635120749474, -0.02458515577018261, -0.018002718687057495, 0.005975347477942705, -0.013150000013411045, -0.017413919791579247, 0.028294824063777924, 0.017849529162049294, 0.024947982281446457, 0.01682862639427185, -0.008669883012771606, 0.005374798085540533, 0.02453206293284893, -0.005894943606108427, 0.012392872013151646, -0.012739407829940319, 0.018797077238559723, 0.0013153612380847335, -0.018788764253258705, 0.08677005022764206, 0.0337819866836071, -0.014167684130370617, -0.02963985875248909, 0.00004801317481906153, 0.025741983205080032, -0.0499977245926857, 0.02392829768359661, 0.02802661806344986, -0.03635518625378609, -0.012266094796359539, 0.0046638972125947475, 0.024083906784653664, 0.014644482173025608, 0.02091326378285885, -0.04770848900079727, 0.0759139358997345, 0.015195273794233799, -0.01323982235044241, 0.010514724999666214, 0.004321376793086529, 0.027021925896406174, -0.03859884664416313, 0.05177782475948334, -0.05203236639499664, 0.0834868848323822, 0.031540822237730026, 0.012088337913155556, -0.018477706238627434, 0.022537296637892723, -0.003456725971773267, -0.03388416767120361, -0.05063917115330696, -0.07039760798215866, 0.056295692920684814, 0.020844463258981705, -0.027205850929021835, 0.009732059203088284, -0.01849036104977131, -0.039970628917217255, -0.014875922352075577, -0.02522202953696251, 0.02009171061217785, -0.0032416617032140493, 0.058747921139001846, -0.007854213938117027, 0.021888991817831993, -0.07415176182985306, -0.021976036950945854, -0.03169635310769081, -0.03434331342577934, 0.011418566107749939, 0.012174021452665329, 0.049176398664712906, -0.011587792076170444, -0.01649383455514908, -0.04288308322429657, -0.1258293092250824, 0.04054858162999153, 0.023234998807311058, -0.030418818816542625, -0.023340614512562752, 0.057447802275419235, 0.02874622866511345, 0.01735902763903141, 0.001091535435989499, -0.009297110140323639, -0.0042667752131819725, -0.027660582214593887, -0.04008657857775688, -0.04083186388015747, 0.03851035609841347, -0.004154779016971588, 0.0734315812587738, -0.02746403031051159, -0.0576585978269577, 0.0398126058280468, 0.03882366046309471, -0.0757417380809784, -0.04765067994594574, 0.009516400285065174, -0.023716114461421967, -0.014699584804475307, -0.040017470717430115, -0.02965598925948143, -0.004820259753614664, 0.04226914793252945, 0.014886119402945042, 0.018439926207065582, 0.03812244161963463, -0.07048456370830536, 0.011132927611470222, -0.004789369646459818, -0.017729800194501877, -0.024311913177371025, -0.0549064576625824, -0.04163816198706627, -0.08283182978630066, 0.0011969726765528321, 0.009376992471516132, -0.01999261975288391, -0.03828587383031845, -0.004278466105461121, -0.04928142577409744, -0.02062464877963066, -0.07268374413251877, 0.06467587500810623, 0.026751771569252014, -0.04345647618174553, -0.006764369085431099, -0.05021873489022255, -0.014097177423536777, -0.0267561636865139, -0.03985689952969551, -0.044481340795755386, 0.0657011941075325, -0.011696532368659973, -0.020744554698467255, -0.0475115142762661, -0.06650681793689728, -0.08091750741004944, -0.027340678498148918, 0.06006290018558502, -0.03434383496642113, 0.03088672086596489, 0.04473124444484711, 0.04434683546423912, 0.03361109644174576, -0.042138103395700455, 0.04505272954702377, 0.04048504680395126, -0.010061283595860004, -0.03710038214921951, 0.03396265581250191, 0.0220078956335783, -0.02619294449687004, 0.052566058933734894, -0.007793561089783907, -0.0036199816968292, 0.020755447447299957, -0.0333605520427227, 0.02774595282971859, 0.03979669138789177, -0.03424377739429474, 0.06250020116567612, -0.015168075449764729, -0.02346263825893402, -0.019757265225052834, -0.026226280257105827, -0.043780628591775894, -0.04811250790953636, 0.031102528795599937, -0.017976704984903336, -0.008179533295333385, 0.03531642258167267, 0.015038598328828812 ]
<p>First, I need to prove that the distribution of a RV X, where X|lambda ~ Pois(lambda), and lambda ~ gamma(a, B), is a negative binomial. I know that it <em>is</em>, but why negative binomial instead of another 2 parameter distribution? How do I prove negative binomial is the best alternative in the circumstance of an overdispersed Poisson, basically?</p> <p>Then, I have to calculate V(X). I'm wondering if V(X) will help prove that negative binomial is best to use as an alternative in an overdispersed Poisson??</p> <p>I looked at <a href="https://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/37814/poisson-is-to-exponential-as-gamma-poisson-is-to-what/37884#37884?newreg=1c6cfdc8a1ce413489fc9274419b0b2a">this</a> post, and I desperately want to understand @probabilityislogic's math. I am new to notation associated with probability concepts (not <em>that</em> new, though), and I don't know how he/she jumps from line 2 to 3:</p> <blockquote> <p>$λ_i∼Gamma(α,β)$<br> On doing the integration/mixing over λi, you have:<br> $Y_i(t_i)|αβ∼NegBin(α,p_i)$ where $p_i=\frac{t_i}{t_i+β}$</p> </blockquote>
g74329
[ 0.04923127219080925, -0.026266636326909065, -0.0022967534605413675, -0.033821359276771545, 0.004072403069585562, -0.015589569695293903, 0.01160734798759222, -0.021689051762223244, -0.043465595692396164, -0.02170603722333908, 0.02305871993303299, 0.023850927129387856, 0.006160153076052666, -0.03225736320018768, -0.006055982783436775, -0.012564567849040031, 0.0876818522810936, 0.03939509391784668, 0.021830372512340546, -0.019361384212970734, -0.023573921993374825, -0.062446478754282, -0.014698279090225697, 0.00654652388766408, 0.04306310787796974, -0.12022893875837326, -0.05616244301199913, 0.003855568589642644, -0.054887205362319946, -0.0045521934516727924, -0.05826166272163391, -0.01334895845502615, 0.009851450100541115, -0.07921645045280457, -0.00419409666210413, 0.021559327840805054, 0.005926971789449453, 0.005948000121861696, -0.0008279531029984355, 0.04597541317343712, -0.015012959949672222, 0.07077594846487045, 0.04801756888628006, 0.014481591060757637, -0.047810304909944534, -0.0272829569876194, -0.025562521070241928, 0.07614000141620636, 0.0006682199891656637, -0.02706793136894703, 0.03728628158569336, 0.029564253985881805, -0.015355388633906841, 0.01546896155923605, 0.006060922518372536, 0.06706061959266663, 0.017850123345851898, -0.03543296828866005, 0.05264458805322647, -0.020802846178412437, -0.011386963538825512, -0.039932895451784134, -0.07390794157981873, -0.012537467293441296, 0.04717515408992767, 0.031128348782658577, -0.026783164590597153, -0.0032455874606966972, 0.03011283464729786, 0.018939821049571037, 0.011822737753391266, 0.03728095814585686, 0.029638484120368958, -0.06980884820222855, -0.04172716289758682, -0.014999118633568287, -0.026056978851556778, -0.017861777916550636, 0.05385327711701393, -0.01863357238471508, -0.024666383862495422, 0.01356187928467989, 0.03731473535299301, -0.07339548319578171, 0.013824843801558018, 0.022149814292788506, 0.05839307978749275, -0.04581233859062195, -0.049122318625450134, -0.026601560413837433, -0.023372070863842964, 0.003002301324158907, 0.020907260477542877, 0.003742136526852846, -0.0261661596596241, 0.04284481704235077, -0.048375509679317474, 0.050816066563129425, -0.031616855412721634, 0.004705555271357298, 0.05543996021151543, 0.00031959780608303845, 0.03290966898202896, -0.004125544801354408, -0.05251924321055412, 0.020123369991779327, -0.011855893768370152, -0.01102920901030302, -0.007012589834630489, 0.013613230548799038, -0.03047444298863411, -0.04192320629954338, -0.040513232350349426, -0.07095441222190857, 0.023852769285440445, 0.036826226860284805, 0.042311154305934906, -0.005485596135258675, -0.016093602403998375, 0.04252634570002556, -0.034299176186323166, 0.03871598839759827, 0.007675447501242161, -0.014140062034130096, -0.009758454747498035, 0.0066804117523133755, 0.006862377282232046, -0.0018870484782382846, 0.01677609048783779, -0.025272373110055923, 0.030513210222125053, -0.00006589965050807223, -0.03817029669880867, -0.047488391399383545, -0.0007980441441759467, 0.08013095706701279, 0.03489909693598747, 0.03327685594558716, -0.00398903526365757, 0.10002145171165466, -0.02493313141167164, -0.0025141816586256027, 0.014169659465551376, 0.028686944395303726, -0.03074072301387787, 0.037156734615564346, 0.010663172230124474, -0.033622752875089645, -0.0353182777762413, 0.025272389873862267, 0.006079448387026787, -0.001629308215342462, -0.008444457314908504, -0.02331104688346386, -0.030844254419207573, 0.04426295682787895, 0.03795436769723892, 0.032784491777420044, -0.040660079568624496, 0.008897003717720509, -0.011191155761480331, -0.015411226078867912, -0.08565118163824081, -0.026471128687262535, -0.006850230507552624, -0.00905501190572977, 0.019030394032597542, 0.00027311386656947434, -0.04855578392744064, -0.05131259188055992, 0.02551180310547352, -0.005863646976649761, 0.010427228175103664, -0.02777409553527832, 0.06472200900316238, 0.041468024253845215, -0.02204323373734951, 0.04223572835326195, -0.014268462546169758, 0.06006307527422905, -0.028171421959996223, -0.03371115028858185, 0.004336920566856861, -0.020570015534758568, 0.02011391520500183, -0.03210217505693436, 0.04371146112680435, 0.055261824280023575, -0.04424659535288811, 0.0008455378701910377, 0.03381827473640442, 0.003700477071106434, 0.032111141830682755, -0.004582669585943222, -0.029377104714512825, -0.02035517804324627, 0.07371973246335983, -0.03218897059559822, 0.03945174813270569, 0.028039608150720596, 0.016784343868494034, -0.00011665841157082468, 0.03708506375551224, 0.030892087146639824, 0.04723131284117699, 0.002805236028507352, -0.02778690867125988, -0.013128486461937428, 0.009501494467258453, 0.010336176492273808, -0.029330233111977577, -0.08260343223810196, 0.05933324992656708, -0.019357701763510704, -0.013088753446936607, -0.0644749104976654, -0.00804669875651598, 0.0047883931547403336, -0.012638021260499954, 0.02713238075375557, -0.027982234954833984, -0.05244849622249603, -0.008203865960240364, 0.024804573506116867, -0.012334156781435013, 0.05084771662950516, 0.016120152547955513, -0.034291498363018036, 0.03342443332076073, 0.04608586058020592, -0.016999920830130577, -0.018351588398218155, 0.010773290880024433, -0.06923168897628784, 0.016238849610090256, 0.015290535986423492, -0.02848813124001026, 0.05597557872533798, -0.02710901014506817, 0.028114577755331993, 0.025584427639842033, -0.01896561123430729, -0.019710157066583633, 0.06526906788349152, 0.016014795750379562, -0.016994671896100044, -0.006527270190417767, -0.02401505410671234, 0.00887194462120533, -0.0014529094332829118, -0.0491761639714241, 0.07687318325042725, -0.011094538494944572, -0.046496547758579254, 0.015030180104076862, -0.010125313885509968, -0.04687805846333504, -0.016120893880724907, -0.048608142882585526, 0.032140642404556274, 0.014307359233498573, -0.032246626913547516, -0.007872842252254486, -0.03436485305428505, -0.06283499300479889, -0.012662094086408615, -0.06769046187400818, 0.0360792875289917, -0.0029138762038201094, 0.04668672755360603, 0.06955472379922867, 0.011647052131593227, -0.00902795884758234, -0.013949017971754074, 0.012245004996657372, -0.003609831677749753, 0.0012932014651596546, 0.011651070788502693, 0.08869890868663788, 0.014616278000175953, 0.02819385752081871, 0.000835518934763968, 0.022162608802318573, 0.014036918990314007, 0.050175990909338, 0.036204587668180466, -0.005010607186704874, 0.008545982651412487, 0.025301950052380562, 0.05486636608839035, 0.005641075782477856, 0.007442932575941086, -0.031238624826073647, -0.016572745516896248, 0.04063239321112633, -0.02698531374335289, -0.009817942976951599, -0.05005402863025665, 0.0024352287873625755, -0.0401926152408123, 0.03716839849948883, 0.015226243995130062, -0.04679134860634804, -0.03491165488958359, 0.13321064412593842, -0.024508081376552582, -0.0539756640791893, 0.017353741452097893, 0.006025407928973436, -0.021953066810965538, 0.0055918013677001, 0.0026265005581080914, 0.01158375944942236, -0.042022887617349625, -0.026730148121714592, 0.02638331428170204, -0.027818161994218826, -0.00017864545225165784, 0.02940153144299984, -0.04503476992249489, -0.0045410688035190105, 0.0023351158015429974, -0.027799466624855995, 0.019308649003505707, 0.03242085501551628, -0.029619358479976654, -0.01681138575077057, 0.031193451955914497, -0.054304338991642, 0.03013576939702034, 0.07137082517147064, 0.018148351460695267, 0.06912576407194138, 0.003364927601069212, -0.037161294370889664, -0.059830185025930405, -0.028252115473151207, -0.006623390596359968, -0.006242871750146151, -0.024836895987391472, 0.002253701677545905, -0.02757328748703003, -0.04118494689464569, 0.021432774141430855, -0.04577236995100975, -0.05981602519750595, 0.044387850910425186, 0.023500485345721245, 0.05289924144744873, 0.02725612185895443, -0.038167260587215424, 0.03545606508851051, 0.020883960649371147, -0.03434814140200615, 0.00459812767803669, 0.027351906523108482, -0.01711731217801571, -0.026936376467347145, 0.057933688163757324, 0.0017499418463557959, 0.022450964897871017, -0.05221649259328842, 0.023580657318234444, -0.008058996871113777, 0.053853124380111694, -0.008468735963106155, -0.0009240383515134454, 0.0026666559278964996, -0.044603243470191956, 0.015337525866925716, -0.008624788373708725, 0.01355032529681921, 0.029139863327145576, 0.002374031115323305, 0.018275339156389236, -0.0819372832775116, -0.015203571878373623, 0.06817407160997391, 0.03225452080368996, 0.012331213802099228, 0.02986201085150242, -0.03396109119057655, 0.07780730724334717, -0.0031711903866380453, -0.00883547868579626, -0.007954009808599949, -0.03302283212542534, -0.01928367093205452, -0.008360592648386955, -0.05711865425109863, -0.007607226260006428, 0.025522246956825256, 0.00047156322398222983, -0.01837993413209915, 0.03112063743174076, -0.04464824125170708, -0.032180458307266235, -0.000026087232981808484, -0.04474712163209915, 0.03890938311815262, 0.005899742711335421, -0.01675918512046337, 0.06773704290390015, -0.019277697429060936, -0.006067105568945408, 0.0032367599196732044, 0.04370460659265518, 0.011269187554717064, 0.03932793438434601, -0.0043133338913321495, 0.013727866113185883, 0.023374084383249283, -0.02376815676689148, -0.027000464498996735, 0.046174678951501846, 0.00846700556576252, 0.04700716584920883, -0.019441526383161545, 0.00009013555973069742, 0.02726859785616398, -0.01738709770143032, -0.015765786170959473, -0.024714220315217972, -0.03603274002671242, 0.011352326720952988, 0.06727119535207748, 0.08122684806585312, -0.007495343219488859, 0.021802665665745735, 0.000422427779994905, 0.02518335171043873, 0.03468715772032738, -0.033081505447626114, 0.0847785547375679, -0.022114919498562813, -0.02087155357003212, -0.021106963977217674, 0.03315574303269386, 0.014196796342730522, -0.020059507340192795, 0.011420887894928455, -0.04288363829255104, -0.03807581588625908, -0.041047610342502594, 0.0403643473982811, 0.009140350855886936, -0.006351284682750702, -0.021796444430947304, 0.044743459671735764, 0.007692999206483364, 0.047822240740060806, 0.03363814577460289, 0.05564012750983238, -0.04085387662053108, -0.04394637420773506, 0.007990762591362, 0.014827514067292213, -0.00048343304661102593, 0.02250267006456852, 0.042666543275117874, 0.02024460770189762, -0.03865420073270798, -0.0071933981962502, 0.003123825415968895, 0.09275760501623154, -0.02119666337966919, -0.06430801004171371, -0.04122227057814598, 0.015816373750567436, -0.006673608906567097, -0.016613485291600227, -0.023570340126752853, 0.020344911143183708, 0.018566492944955826, -0.010265943594276905, 0.0016059600748121738, -0.09070508927106857, 0.017456501722335815, -0.03085499443113804, 0.046038296073675156, 0.00998637918382883, -0.0006070061353966594, 0.00016589979350101203, -0.04425283521413803, -0.03943054750561714, -0.0223302710801363, -0.012160004116594791, -0.05696507543325424, 0.06807931512594223, 0.027418479323387146, -0.01743280701339245, 0.0034646429121494293, 0.039399780333042145, 0.016870364546775818, -0.022598467767238617, -0.077423594892025, 0.02737736888229847, -0.009393689222633839, 0.026579631492495537, -0.00022241403348743916, -0.05366446450352669, -0.0291462242603302, -0.027674946933984756, 0.002211399842053652, 0.05264221131801605, 0.013757621869444847, 0.07594644278287888, -0.0037365062162280083, -0.025722280144691467, 0.05661545693874359, 0.03910444304347038, 0.03529105708003044, 0.01451049093157053, -0.024261899292469025, -0.0042155710980296135, -0.03543801233172417, -0.03791855648159981, 0.009474392980337143, -0.043646350502967834, -0.03208596631884575, 0.015703441575169563, 0.005816813092678785, 0.025237133726477623, -0.027945704758167267, -0.005846072919666767, -0.06550490111112595, -0.09550710767507553, -0.0016318337293341756, -0.03925633057951927, -0.07328669726848602, 0.012838495895266533, -0.0447998084127903, 0.047614842653274536, 0.02387927658855915, -0.05871676653623581, 0.01833409070968628, -0.023922855034470558, 0.0277499221265316, 0.042521100491285324, 0.0234252717345953, -0.019946841523051262, -0.08730055391788483, 0.049135055392980576, 0.0382331945002079, -0.0430147759616375, 0.03668747842311859, -0.08540462702512741, 0.009743155911564827, -0.0056586186401546, -0.07792531698942184, 0.03518461436033249, 0.03064514324069023, -0.02191147208213806, -0.040086131542921066, -0.04256920889019966, 0.02281906269490719, 0.03732115402817726, 0.015116313472390175, -0.002402595244348049, 0.05747472867369652, -0.04111986607313156, -0.07612543553113937, -0.0373910591006279, -0.025511041283607483, 0.04795248433947563, -0.06577026098966599, 0.007695970591157675, 0.004517450463026762, -0.017790749669075012, 0.07657407969236374, -0.0031196048948913813, 0.0014237372670322657, 0.07422182708978653, 0.03603255748748779, 0.03928232192993164, -0.01814238168299198, 0.03705275431275368, -0.0384984090924263, -0.014882726594805717, 0.012499821372330189, -0.026844380423426628, 0.010006017982959747, -0.000050090293370885774, -0.019495345652103424, -0.01722147688269615, 0.021792521700263023, -0.04626881331205368, 0.024615852162241936, 0.03291364014148712, -0.040686871856451035, 0.020290091633796692, -0.014180220663547516, -0.01726040244102478, -0.053813185542821884, -0.030412422493100166, -0.01955542527139187, -0.05001659318804741, -0.02566131204366684, -0.02478001080453396, -0.045407604426145554, -0.013416407629847527, -0.026278475299477577, -0.0353192500770092, -0.021145042032003403, -0.01686319150030613, -0.014400847256183624, 0.0016683483263477683, -0.0008636583224870265, -0.007111233659088612, -0.009116391651332378, 0.034752752631902695, -0.005056764930486679, 0.021532997488975525, 0.05102623999118805, 0.03014163114130497, -0.04225985333323479, -0.03128313273191452, -0.027257606387138367, -0.01157377939671278, 0.0646202564239502, 0.018700851127505302, -0.04364898055791855, -0.021232707425951958, 0.06480491161346436, 0.025012416765093803, 0.06729577481746674, 0.031218336895108223, -0.008096856065094471, 0.05329049751162529, 0.006927250884473324, 0.05193201079964638, -0.024539662525057793, -0.002242123242467642, 0.0574384406208992, -0.03408459946513176, -0.006073019467294216, -0.06098908931016922, 0.08230359107255936, 0.05435439944267273, 0.09620139747858047, -0.011015730910003185, 0.05886565148830414, 0.04489932954311371, -0.016710638999938965, 0.024922924116253853, 0.026084493845701218, 0.019992833957076073, 0.021354060620069504, -0.0234183631837368, 0.04091932997107506, 0.05122651904821396, 0.054761070758104324, -0.01019409392029047, 0.028272727504372597, -0.0358254574239254, 0.025964459404349327, 0.03777852654457092, 0.055161457508802414, 0.05595516413450241, -0.011024777777493, -0.026773743331432343, -0.05828340724110603, -0.04255745932459831, 0.028119361028075218, 0.05635262280702591, 0.018082424998283386, -0.01817997545003891, 0.02145989239215851, -0.012386199086904526, -0.0202790480107069, -0.049283821135759354, -0.030361393466591835, -0.043729159981012344, 0.02091217413544655, 0.012916360050439835, -0.0772331953048706, 0.019588671624660492, 0.04093725606799126, -0.03416181355714798, -0.0035914781037718058, 0.014490620233118534, -0.029715776443481445, -0.04188108816742897, -0.023124121129512787, -0.011619842611253262, 0.022062428295612335, -0.021992340683937073, 0.015201074071228504, -0.0340188667178154, 0.0034576538018882275, 0.0003259378718212247, -0.05051957070827484, -0.0025459593161940575, -0.0017933647613972425, -0.041613735258579254, 0.04630404710769653, 0.032658424228429794, -0.02531743049621582, 0.00932878814637661, 0.04218045994639397, 0.005552743095904589, -0.02666439488530159, -0.03702687844634056, -0.0036080616991966963, 0.015196428634226322, -0.022481700405478477, 0.06096639856696129, -0.0102040721103549, -0.016429733484983444, -0.04515063762664795, 0.08241067081689835, 0.002187702339142561, -0.05406847596168518, -0.01315651461482048, -0.0019868346862494946, -0.012388160452246666, 0.012018974870443344, -0.016771214082837105, -0.03428926691412926, -0.050254158675670624, -0.037273358553647995, 0.04814080148935318, -0.01135189551860094, -0.05799499526619911, -0.0005748497205786407, -0.00968365278095007, -0.04424271360039711, -0.0003829693014267832, -0.06027312949299812, -0.024420298635959625, -0.05911999195814133, -0.04268379136919975, -0.04659140855073929, 0.0036156876012682915, -0.01680060848593712, 0.0236011054366827, 0.02752107009291649, 0.01626766100525856, -0.017395908012986183, 0.026622001081705093, 0.010288332588970661, -0.011514906771481037, -0.04163219407200813, 0.024140117689967155, 0.045364946126937866, -0.06267048418521881, -0.0222154650837183, 0.06590418517589569, 0.017925668507814407, -0.032455310225486755, -0.019661588594317436, 0.053858205676078796, 0.027210548520088196, 0.07511614263057709, 0.08841342478990555, -0.010693864896893501, 0.08009038120508194, 0.00477955024689436, 0.0402536615729332, -0.0073668151162564754, 0.03698049858212471, -0.04237424209713936, 0.008105749264359474, 0.005062608513981104, -0.04608971253037453, 0.027668269351124763, -0.00864488910883665, -0.00790813285857439 ]
<p>How can I interpret McLeod-Li test results below</p> <pre><code>&gt; McLeod.Li.test(y = data, gof.lag = 12, plot = FALSE)$p.values [1] 7.602866e-09 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 [7] 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 </code></pre> <p>And also fitting result .In fitting results, sometimes it says false convergence and sometimes relative function convergence what does it mean?. </p> <pre><code> ***** ESTIMATION WITH ANALYTICAL GRADIENT ***** I INITIAL X(I) D(I) 1 2.654366e+00 1.000e+00 2 5.000000e-02 1.000e+00 3 5.000000e-02 1.000e+00 IT NF F RELDF PRELDF RELDX STPPAR D*STEP NPRELDF 0 1 2.042e+02 1 4 2.041e+02 7.06e-05 2.05e-04 3.0e-03 1.3e+02 1.8e-02 1.30e-02 2 5 2.041e+02 8.08e-05 1.08e-04 2.9e-03 2.0e+00 1.8e-02 6.01e-03 3 6 2.041e+02 1.03e-04 1.03e-04 2.4e-03 2.0e+00 1.8e-02 4.82e-03 4 10 2.037e+02 1.89e-03 1.87e-03 7.1e-02 1.7e-01 3.7e-01 4.86e-03 5 12 2.029e+02 3.77e-03 4.42e-03 1.9e-01 1.9e+00 7.4e-01 5.03e-01 6 15 2.028e+02 6.83e-04 1.23e-03 6.3e-03 4.0e+00 2.6e-02 4.34e-02 7 16 2.028e+02 1.07e-04 1.29e-04 7.5e-03 2.0e+00 2.6e-02 9.17e-03 8 17 2.028e+02 1.47e-04 2.09e-04 1.7e-02 1.9e+00 5.2e-02 5.64e-03 9 18 2.027e+02 1.32e-04 1.68e-04 1.7e-02 1.8e+00 5.2e-02 1.41e-03 10 20 2.027e+02 1.59e-04 2.20e-04 4.3e-02 7.8e-01 1.2e-01 3.48e-04 11 21 2.027e+02 4.71e-05 6.10e-05 2.9e-02 0.0e+00 8.2e-02 6.10e-05 12 22 2.027e+02 1.29e-06 1.37e-06 5.2e-04 0.0e+00 1.8e-03 1.37e-06 13 23 2.027e+02 1.92e-07 5.61e-08 3.6e-04 0.0e+00 9.3e-04 5.61e-08 14 35 2.027e+02 -9.82e-16 1.27e-19 3.3e-15 8.0e+08 9.1e-15 2.68e-10 ***** FALSE CONVERGENCE ***** FUNCTION 2.026871e+02 RELDX 3.290e-15 FUNC. EVALS 35 GRAD. EVALS 14 PRELDF 1.274e-19 NPRELDF 2.677e-10 I FINAL X(I) D(I) G(I) 1 1.240313e+00 1.000e+00 1.250e-03 2 1.234210e-01 1.000e+00 1.351e-05 3 4.425966e-01 1.000e+00 2.553e-03 </code></pre> <p>Another results</p> <pre><code>***** ESTIMATION WITH ANALYTICAL GRADIENT ***** I INITIAL X(I) D(I) 1 3.736575e+00 1.000e+00 2 5.000000e-02 1.000e+00 IT NF F RELDF PRELDF RELDX STPPAR D*STEP NPRELDF 0 1 2.061e+02 1 2 1.764e+02 1.44e-01 1.61e+00 1.3e-01 3.3e+02 1.0e+00 2.69e+02 2 5 1.229e+02 3.03e-01 1.99e-01 3.7e-01 7.8e-01 2.0e+00 1.12e+00 3 7 1.070e+02 1.30e-01 9.76e-02 1.3e-01 3.7e+00 4.0e-01 2.19e+02 4 9 6.528e+01 3.90e-01 3.24e-01 4.3e-01 8.1e+03 8.0e-01 5.81e+03 5 11 5.613e+01 1.40e-01 1.37e-01 1.1e-01 8.8e+00 1.6e-01 3.40e+05 6 13 5.456e+01 2.79e-02 2.88e-02 2.1e-02 3.2e+01 3.2e-02 4.02e+02 7 15 5.217e+01 4.39e-02 4.78e-02 4.3e-02 2.6e+00 6.4e-02 1.08e+02 8 17 5.161e+01 1.07e-02 1.94e-02 3.7e-02 2.6e+00 5.7e-02 6.86e+01 9 18 5.132e+01 5.52e-03 8.37e-03 3.4e-02 2.0e+00 5.7e-02 4.83e+01 10 19 5.129e+01 7.58e-04 4.77e-03 3.0e-02 2.0e+00 5.7e-02 1.14e+01 11 21 5.123e+01 1.02e-03 2.86e-03 1.1e-02 2.0e+00 2.7e-02 5.80e-01 12 22 5.121e+01 3.58e-04 5.08e-04 1.5e-02 2.0e+00 2.7e-02 2.63e-03 13 25 5.121e+01 3.94e-05 6.44e-05 1.3e-03 3.8e+00 2.4e-03 4.69e-02 14 26 5.121e+01 2.55e-05 2.88e-05 1.3e-03 3.1e+00 2.4e-03 1.50e-02 15 27 5.121e+01 2.39e-05 5.20e-05 2.3e-03 2.0e+00 4.8e-03 8.22e-03 16 28 5.121e+01 5.18e-05 1.27e-04 5.4e-03 1.9e+00 9.6e-03 2.78e-03 17 30 5.121e+01 6.65e-06 2.50e-05 1.2e-03 1.8e+00 3.0e-03 8.02e-05 18 31 5.121e+01 4.39e-06 6.27e-06 1.7e-03 1.3e+00 3.0e-03 6.91e-06 19 33 5.121e+01 5.81e-07 2.26e-06 5.6e-04 1.5e+00 1.1e-03 4.17e-06 20 34 5.121e+01 5.53e-07 5.82e-07 2.0e-04 0.0e+00 4.6e-04 5.82e-07 21 35 5.121e+01 3.22e-09 3.35e-09 4.8e-05 0.0e+00 8.6e-05 3.35e-09 22 36 5.121e+01 8.01e-12 8.10e-12 2.4e-06 0.0e+00 4.2e-06 8.10e-12 ***** RELATIVE FUNCTION CONVERGENCE ***** FUNCTION 5.120700e+01 RELDX 2.408e-06 FUNC. EVALS 36 GRAD. EVALS 23 PRELDF 8.103e-12 NPRELDF 8.103e-12 I FINAL X(I) D(I) G(I) 1 2.113519e-01 1.000e+00 1.349e-05 2 8.757729e-01 1.000e+00 2.232e-06 </code></pre>
g74330
[ 0.02432030439376831, -0.0681099072098732, -0.0034819827415049076, -0.05349564552307129, 0.01324896514415741, -0.006136227399110794, 0.09397238492965698, -0.008755700662732124, -0.022122979164123535, 0.05085879564285278, -0.04082413390278816, 0.03242523595690727, 0.08098723739385605, 0.055622681975364685, -0.027731535956263542, -0.012697950936853886, 0.05312452092766762, -0.0511949323117733, 0.06799289584159851, -0.009970164857804775, -0.07064271718263626, 0.11494448035955429, -0.027446942403912544, -0.03011338971555233, -0.010367469862103462, -0.02616090327501297, -0.018608614802360535, 0.04842435568571091, -0.04479779675602913, 0.03837057948112488, 0.026753529906272888, 0.0025818797294050455, 0.024665767326951027, -0.07153104245662689, -0.03150186315178871, 0.031032845377922058, 0.07996447384357452, 0.04254752770066261, 0.012546188198029995, -0.01171041838824749, -0.013659595511853695, 0.005339493043720722, 0.0660463273525238, 0.008743404410779476, 0.022369882091879845, -0.026590339839458466, 0.015695985406637192, -0.01446074154227972, 0.014924929477274418, -0.02133522555232048, -0.006641235202550888, 0.10433769226074219, 0.026462683454155922, 0.0374748669564724, -0.016162265092134476, 0.050121720880270004, -0.0029814448207616806, -0.0052358428947627544, 0.031245898455381393, -0.009788124822080135, 0.05225355923175812, -0.0906422808766365, 0.001603743527084589, -0.026572106406092644, 0.07326635718345642, -0.0237738024443388, 0.006788717582821846, -0.019546402618288994, -0.013656909577548504, -0.05405731126666069, 0.05838201195001602, -0.032746560871601105, -0.0023203149903565645, -0.0017953584901988506, -0.0793391615152359, -0.04381054639816284, -0.007896745577454567, -0.008814765140414238, -0.00917787104845047, 0.01967201940715313, -0.015381150878965855, 0.004655234050005674, -0.02157469652593136, 0.007553078234195709, 0.010818109847605228, -0.015405481681227684, 0.015191781334578991, 0.019265903159976006, 0.02889418601989746, 0.007858294993638992, -0.02282577194273472, -0.0009833015501499176, -0.011332782916724682, 0.020681636407971382, -0.01901998184621334, 0.01722104474902153, -0.05209629610180855, 0.034890465438365936, 0.04449055343866348, -0.019818058237433434, -0.01285927277058363, 0.0058638183400034904, 0.004747285041958094, -0.01397236343473196, -0.0973818302154541, 0.01435470674186945, 0.02295377291738987, -0.032102182507514954, -0.0455990694463253, -0.01944578066468239, -0.03994741290807724, -0.014924268238246441, -0.028396619483828545, -0.020005954429507256, -0.0009708546567708254, -0.02712784707546234, -0.04691570624709129, 0.0028325715102255344, -0.08757097274065018, -0.02179853618144989, 0.04888708516955376, -0.010418334044516087, 0.043291617184877396, 0.04262211173772812, -0.04055486619472504, -0.017856737598776817, 0.0029653767123818398, -0.020574459806084633, 0.005758254323154688, 0.02008373849093914, 0.0030566276982426643, -0.027255844324827194, -0.019021624699234962, 0.03510152921080589, -0.0036522620357573032, -0.035959672182798386, 0.010618164204061031, 0.04792575165629387, -0.04005999118089676, 0.014243979007005692, -0.05193599313497543, -0.05958380177617073, 0.0019357509445399046, -0.06904726475477219, -0.000968116510193795, -0.014404271729290485, -0.031638577580451965, 0.04517564922571182, 0.011449683457612991, 0.00892897229641676, 0.03558303415775299, 0.008417786099016666, -0.010522641241550446, 0.046590980142354965, -0.029679788276553154, 0.0036293466109782457, -0.04114129766821861, -0.0042315516620874405, 0.018581653013825417, -0.022290606051683426, -0.002601268934085965, -0.05698402225971222, 0.014720899052917957, 0.023063786327838898, -0.02281428873538971, 0.035631898790597916, 0.02111375704407692, 0.03194274380803108, 0.017212798818945885, -0.04124303534626961, -0.02548747882246971, 0.018691370263695717, 0.014977899380028248, -0.08387493342161179, 0.02795204520225525, 0.05054632946848869, 0.02887248620390892, -0.030206996947526932, 0.02627091482281685, 0.08419152349233627, 0.022070571780204773, 0.06229414790868759, 0.021584948524832726, -0.0718475803732872, 0.02576635777950287, -0.026783904060721397, -0.009207023307681084, -0.05057402327656746, -0.05590731278061867, -0.003088741796091199, -0.05840551480650902, -0.06536837667226791, -0.03852694109082222, 0.006524060387164354, 0.005301790311932564, -0.015475586988031864, -0.01142975501716137, -0.103363536298275, -0.059362612664699554, 0.013122815638780594, -0.004846054129302502, 0.020859792828559875, -0.002526924479752779, 0.022423716261982918, 0.030409399420022964, 0.0017845307011157274, -0.018981385976076126, -0.0009711658349260688, 0.03593708947300911, 0.0198182575404644, 0.0028076190501451492, -0.04118839278817177, -0.004148696083575487, 0.03999096155166626, 0.0006049199728295207, -0.03545629605650902, -0.01831088587641716, 0.05679699033498764, -0.027003644034266472, -0.005765572655946016, 0.01927713304758072, -0.044936854392290115, -0.016644824296236038, -0.008395904675126076, -0.027378810569643974, 0.0057386793196201324, 0.015844963490962982, 0.016783567145466805, -0.02637697197496891, 0.01862255670130253, -0.026696769520640373, -0.06715665012598038, -0.020851152017712593, 0.021695874631404877, 0.026635946705937386, 0.06515730172395706, -0.011573533527553082, 0.0015497617423534393, 0.009623334743082523, 0.018756600096821785, 0.03627585992217064, 0.05163758993148804, -0.03124513290822506, -0.01068921945989132, 0.03537098690867424, 0.07585666328668594, 0.041046153753995895, 0.0456295907497406, 0.020343029871582985, 0.027298012748360634, 0.017932215705513954, 0.07443773746490479, 0.027519527822732925, 0.04528585448861122, 0.005606424529105425, -0.029997169971466064, -0.020868513733148575, 0.014897995628416538, 0.03379844129085541, 0.025121673941612244, -0.028604356572031975, 0.08082722872495651, 0.013538297265768051, 0.03527421876788139, -0.03104109689593315, -0.01873931661248207, 0.03678803890943527, -0.05742175132036209, 0.02825649455189705, -0.05258161202073097, 0.008013908751308918, -0.008084548637270927, 0.07428067922592163, 0.10245125740766525, 0.037295710295438766, 0.023655446246266365, 0.008656883612275124, -0.024897875264286995, 0.005570671055465937, -0.07249851524829865, -0.052326202392578125, -0.04541618376970291, 0.031183145940303802, 0.052845876663923264, 0.04391045868396759, 0.026056332513689995, 0.010197476483881474, -0.027619266882538795, -0.05556587129831314, 0.038119327276945114, 0.008289371617138386, -0.06675664335489273, 0.027069760486483574, 0.0029348323587328196, -0.03356219455599785, 0.0004132360627409071, 0.02851458452641964, -0.05015731602907181, 0.04895617812871933, 0.01868915930390358, -0.03343803808093071, 0.006320824846625328, -0.060641512274742126, -0.0011029476299881935, 0.03893696889281273, -0.0036287333350628614, -0.018632235005497932, -0.03364479914307594, -0.0017520140390843153, -0.033417634665966034, -0.06591932475566864, -0.026359394192695618, -0.04047555848956108, -0.04364864528179169, 0.040012508630752563, -0.009628018364310265, -0.007711153943091631, 0.007970847189426422, 0.00860709510743618, -0.01724235527217388, -0.018999168649315834, -0.05867462232708931, -0.05237545445561409, 0.008245973847806454, 0.004564082715660334, 0.0016748860944062471, 0.017925893887877464, -0.033082883805036545, 0.0173020139336586, 0.0040271710604429245, 0.006909255404025316, 0.05296939238905907, 0.0029929764568805695, -0.011452578008174896, 0.0075134774670004845, -0.10263913869857788, -0.03524462506175041, 0.04117177799344063, -0.02074376493692398, 0.0437234565615654, -0.020664110779762268, -0.002590106101706624, 0.03994862362742424, 0.017939267680048943, -0.010670448653399944, 0.00039041522541083395, 0.04177239537239075, 0.013949235901236534, 0.01113689225167036, 0.0344865582883358, 0.010949851013720036, 0.004103497602045536, -0.013758126646280289, -0.02180643193423748, 0.020745132118463516, 0.037416890263557434, 0.0102865444496274, -0.04999709874391556, -0.012538839131593704, -0.010896315798163414, 0.052924007177352905, 0.005667745601385832, -0.038415249437093735, 0.04078184440732002, 0.04787742346525192, 0.03420833870768547, 0.04867079108953476, 0.05587727203965187, 0.03345015272498131, -0.01472082082182169, 0.03235749900341034, 0.027317196130752563, 0.01844988949596882, -0.014469947665929794, 0.0005537483957596123, -0.024642037227749825, 0.03329285979270935, 0.019591480493545532, -0.01514163613319397, 0.017210327088832855, -0.013808625750243664, 0.030780591070652008, -0.02710867114365101, -0.0017093407223001122, 0.001573374611325562, -0.02797280065715313, 0.01156518142670393, -0.013863877393305302, 0.01804538443684578, -0.011041269637644291, 0.012471696361899376, 0.012786097824573517, -0.059482332319021225, 0.02098545804619789, 0.011899671517312527, -0.026085317134857178, -0.0049470835365355015, 0.08277632296085358, -0.046874262392520905, 0.029169579967856407, -0.02708044834434986, 0.027482714504003525, 0.0022772091906517744, -0.002401130273938179, -0.015100640244781971, -0.04828505218029022, -0.05400605499744415, -0.037231042981147766, 0.0020363961812108755, -0.04762524738907814, -0.015814656391739845, 0.035409629344940186, 0.02488921582698822, -0.0009166221134364605, 0.019042372703552246, -0.034985750913619995, 0.058708567172288895, -0.07546669989824295, -0.036755118519067764, 0.03286682814359665, 0.017350807785987854, 0.01232735812664032, -0.033917129039764404, -0.016317659988999367, 0.007714643608778715, 0.0384674072265625, -0.021831491962075233, 0.037950094789266586, 0.06322674453258514, -0.04321905970573425, -0.014643487520515919, -0.007006542757153511, -0.03357355296611786, 0.002303489949554205, -0.05477502942085266, 0.061943355947732925, -0.03104175254702568, 0.03389737755060196, -0.01477045752108097, 0.023572275415062904, -0.02933896705508232, -0.03179306164383888, -0.005206282716244459, 0.025982726365327835, 0.01882670260965824, 0.04331254959106445, -0.024984415620565414, -0.010420641861855984, -0.006451228633522987, 0.007916034199297428, 0.024368571117520332, 0.0424087792634964, -0.02325717732310295, 0.04904378950595856, 0.020268389955163002, -0.04543760046362877, 0.05423538759350777, 0.017634836956858635, -0.00025518875918351114, 0.01653342880308628, -0.02343101240694523, -0.04017424210906029, 0.020500224083662033, -0.03909257426857948, -0.01815149188041687, 0.015321914106607437, -0.019477203488349915, -0.06782183051109314, 0.06717873364686966, 0.0066758692264556885, -0.03535604104399681, -0.018981091678142548, 0.11521920561790466, -0.08371355384588242, -0.034481920301914215, 0.04901406168937683, -0.01637670397758484, -0.013787895441055298, 0.0379042774438858, 0.016668640077114105, -0.030411824584007263, -0.005615288857370615, -0.01392433512955904, -0.01433656271547079, -0.0085195517167449, 0.0006563427159562707, 0.00835136417299509, -0.05413784831762314, 0.014612861908972263, -0.09708832949399948, 0.039759229868650436, -0.00624558050185442, 0.058487668633461, -0.04479784891009331, -0.03737887367606163, 0.003232332179322839, 0.000966527673881501, 0.049868110567331314, -0.009308123961091042, 0.041101302951574326, -0.05314501374959946, -0.04030587524175644, -0.03469104319810867, -0.008150141686201096, 0.014090834185481071, 0.049950070679187775, 0.014750282280147076, -0.03682095557451248, 0.033791109919548035, -0.029515810310840607, -0.00235882424749434, 0.004468580707907677, 0.06406033784151077, -0.00989551842212677, -0.009535706602036953, -0.015852805227041245, -0.01250552013516426, 0.0530293844640255, -0.0714707300066948, -0.0042287809774279594, 0.008741487748920918, 0.015445302240550518, -0.006174540612846613, 0.023825986310839653, 0.011220627464354038, -0.028622543439269066, 0.037937313318252563, -0.04646275192499161, -0.018888715654611588, -0.002606947673484683, 0.014047940261662006, 0.05973094329237938, 0.05697983130812645, 0.02458988130092621, 0.035511329770088196, 0.006804988253861666, 0.0021198627073317766, -0.04089862108230591, -0.013151348568499088, -0.05211404711008072, 0.013800805434584618, 0.03314090520143509, 0.016027268022298813, 0.013329843059182167, -0.053144585341215134, -0.017143676057457924, -0.03504779562354088, -0.030004985630512238, -0.0001119158259825781, -0.06493620574474335, 0.04004543647170067, -0.03221507370471954, -0.050339262932538986, -0.01627841778099537, 0.045737843960523605, 0.05413363501429558, 0.014818580821156502, -0.04286808893084526, -0.009599964134395123, -0.01215992122888565, -0.027250684797763824, -0.08207694441080093, -0.0377424880862236, 0.0007069476414471865, 0.013913404196500778, -0.00189388997387141, -0.014260552823543549, 0.008163133636116982, -0.007976049557328224, -0.003876311704516411, 0.006401778664439917, -0.11531805247068405, 0.07763539254665375, 0.03291889652609825, 0.029367590323090553, 0.044204529374837875, -0.07521374523639679, 0.023655936121940613, 0.039853550493717194, -0.032642100006341934, 0.006455690134316683, -0.0020658974535763264, 0.0023391100112348795, -0.002870680298656225, -0.012321257963776588, 0.04191473871469498, -0.03778202831745148, 0.04144791513681412, -0.04385654628276825, -0.007898098789155483, -0.04898180812597275, 0.045641425997018814, 0.04705148562788963, -0.050331853330135345, 0.07256234437227249, -0.049523383378982544, -0.027364052832126617, 0.010655965656042099, 0.00281746918335557, -0.04981761798262596, 0.044086210429668427, 0.019320448860526085, 0.05526210367679596, -0.028346791863441467, 0.006962503306567669, -0.01915406435728073, -0.0030723719391971827, 0.010656176134943962, -0.011543511413037777, 0.019890764728188515, -0.015469424426555634, 0.033056605607271194, 0.06729971617460251, 0.04049907252192497, 0.016559811308979988, -0.021823108196258545, 0.005951422266662121, 0.06464871764183044, -0.03967610374093056, 0.0029093569610267878, 0.018322084099054337, -0.03914380446076393, -0.0263117216527462, -0.015448012389242649, -0.011440472677350044, 0.0332944393157959, 0.00042921266867779195, 0.015172289684414864, 0.001787918503396213, -0.06024133786559105, -0.0013747654156759381, 0.04378839582204819, -0.010292479768395424, -0.022106610238552094, -0.08464416861534119, 0.018589066341519356, 0.02542346529662609, 0.04328185319900513, 0.06395471096038818, 0.09593231976032257, 0.01981418766081333, 0.05143265053629875, -0.027668079361319542, -0.054065488278865814, -0.061537496745586395, 0.016482751816511154, -0.03498784080147743, 0.006599385291337967, -0.059266842901706696, 0.021060919389128685, 0.06627858430147171, -0.014477922581136227, 0.02028762362897396, 0.04131849482655525, 0.06580039113759995, 0.030415019020438194, -0.02445286139845848, -0.006675131618976593, 0.05253616347908974, -0.07361478358507156, -0.02939501591026783, -0.017915954813361168, -0.0036797085776925087, 0.043707434087991714, 0.024455305188894272, 0.005233053583651781, -0.02269885316491127, -0.020635085180401802, -0.013694167137145996, -0.045465368777513504, 0.0017107466701418161, -0.011137587018311024, 0.04062826931476593, 0.008076884783804417, 0.03688317537307739, 0.0394652858376503, -0.02311696484684944, 0.02412433922290802, -0.0690191462635994, 0.020494338124990463, 0.02192876674234867, -0.02641923911869526, 0.029203448444604874, -0.008223759941756725, -0.030264170840382576, -0.0004208275058772415, -0.04784233868122101, -0.04813103377819061, -0.00916520319879055, -0.019863195717334747, -0.009734372608363628, 0.039034340530633926, 0.0061314720660448074, 0.022125177085399628, -0.011491097509860992, 0.017349950969219208, -0.024415014311671257, 0.016694335266947746, 0.03603528067469597, 0.08476989716291428, 0.0285490732640028, 0.020913083106279373, -0.023482006043195724, -0.0048158313147723675, 0.006972168572247028, -0.014186075888574123, -0.0064038620330393314, -0.01851702481508255, -0.02218443900346756, 0.02023482695221901, 0.01869666948914528, 0.03913675621151924, -0.01463688537478447, 0.04882463440299034, 0.04786042124032974, -0.004698450211435556, 0.002424665028229356, -0.018882934004068375, -0.025326762348413467, -0.006017186678946018, 0.027617409825325012, -0.0054295845329761505, -0.02605762891471386, 0.020357033237814903, -0.0019110430730506778, -0.057457566261291504, -0.015963034704327583, 0.05771857872605324, -0.023083901032805443, -0.01656765677034855, -0.1020992323756218, -0.009358860552310944, -0.05433786287903786, -0.05171884968876839, -0.014981359243392944, 0.0008544774609617889, 0.00944263581186533, -0.03570050746202469, -0.023769671097397804, 0.040162891149520874, -0.0016529957065358758, -0.019073208793997765, 0.06428498774766922, 0.03024657815694809, 0.05216410011053085, 0.01490745972841978, 0.021916260942816734, 0.03138679265975952, -0.01669028215110302, 0.014173286966979504, 0.024477001279592514, 0.030157199129462242, -0.02903258241713047, 0.035302650183439255, 0.015410786494612694, -0.01955447718501091, -0.02569943107664585, 0.016929350793361664, 0.036758266389369965, -0.029046792536973953, -0.0026602179277688265, -0.0938262790441513, -0.06717398017644882, -0.02695048227906227, 0.03704054653644562, -0.006258423440158367, -0.05328529328107834, 0.0036984398029744625 ]
<p>I have a list of objects and their frequencies of occurrence in R</p> <pre><code> Names &lt;- c("a","b","c","d","e") Freq &lt;- c(12,45,67,100,1 ...) </code></pre> <p>I want to rank the prominence of these objects based on the frequency. Is there a way to fit a distribution on the frequencies and weight them to get ranks instead of simply sorting them in descending order?</p>
g74331
[ 0.034719131886959076, 0.010821612551808357, -0.009051844477653503, -0.11784476786851883, 0.008470655418932438, -0.0015736898640170693, 0.012855310924351215, -0.0019792146049439907, -0.07271627336740494, -0.0038468397688120604, -0.020093776285648346, -0.025903386995196342, 0.04247937351465225, -0.018900824710726738, -0.026363259181380272, -0.0006697248318232596, -0.013388780876994133, -0.021662799641489983, 0.008535224013030529, -0.019470002502202988, 0.034419529139995575, 0.013456584885716438, 0.02568453550338745, -0.005017690360546112, -0.045295342803001404, 0.0086213368922472, -0.003228322137147188, -0.04419226199388504, -0.012606765143573284, -0.0017711329273879528, -0.04136074334383011, 0.004218003246933222, 0.06000082194805145, -0.03685559332370758, -0.002032736549153924, 0.04897694289684296, 0.02805577963590622, 0.004642465617507696, -0.02383623644709587, 0.02796606346964836, -0.00175106106325984, 0.00044369339593686163, 0.06588370352983475, -0.01968212239444256, -0.04025513306260109, -0.04758567363023758, -0.04233454540371895, 0.019216571003198624, -0.007877799682319164, -0.017738448455929756, -0.010008726269006729, 0.05246874317526817, 0.0066292136907577515, 0.018471354618668556, -0.0011621841695159674, 0.044609688222408295, 0.014988511800765991, 0.0044222623109817505, 0.02188703790307045, 0.033656880259513855, 0.0158750731498003, 0.023295054212212563, 0.025513874366879463, -0.01634969376027584, 0.01622018963098526, 0.033401746302843094, -0.001485425396822393, 0.010584008879959583, 0.006243933457881212, -0.04520415887236595, -0.114756740629673, -0.017934003844857216, 0.004620527848601341, -0.013401602394878864, -0.12312223017215729, -0.0001711294025881216, 0.017840905115008354, -0.0007801149622537196, 0.01671760156750679, 0.021939555183053017, 0.004229606129229069, 0.0006724352715536952, 0.019201621413230896, 0.02151511237025261, 0.030107615515589714, -0.039510101079940796, 0.05755182355642319, 0.008513949811458588, 0.05707806721329689, -0.02690325304865837, -0.005370838101953268, -0.02401682175695896, -0.004725801292806864, 0.056930579245090485, -0.02238215133547783, 0.012543738819658756, -0.029819626361131668, 0.009861535392701626, -0.023364432156085968, -0.0930093452334404, 0.01366823073476553, 0.025603026151657104, 0.020344102755188942, -0.03271159529685974, -0.07153169810771942, -0.03967477008700371, 0.016894953325390816, 0.009768344461917877, 0.004524226766079664, -0.005104429554194212, 0.026332752779126167, -0.007801199331879616, -0.015432680957019329, -0.009446781128644943, -0.02005739137530327, -0.033169567584991455, 0.06776126474142075, -0.030444471165537834, -0.0662742331624031, 0.023190634325146675, 0.030848005786538124, -0.05748187378048897, 0.04823119938373566, 0.06182260811328888, -0.027167655527591705, -0.01235491968691349, 0.02815910242497921, 0.03700859844684601, 0.04025374725461006, -0.07183542102575302, 0.03919040411710739, 0.006044780369848013, 0.04152549058198929, -0.026129966601729393, 0.004925202578306198, 0.04517457261681557, 0.011096680536866188, 0.015867816284298897, 0.003338078735396266, -0.012616281397640705, -0.032397959381341934, 0.013514963909983635, 0.020507588982582092, -0.02049986645579338, -0.01742812991142273, 0.0085820397362113, -0.03734451159834862, -0.029668603092432022, -0.007997561246156693, 0.018634257838129997, 0.011031311936676502, 0.017992867156863213, -0.09037140011787415, -0.03884374722838402, 0.011214595288038254, 0.0032288029324263334, 0.009933430701494217, 0.016259828582406044, -0.046703092753887177, -0.050713084638118744, -0.012054859660565853, -0.030900107696652412, 0.038789354264736176, 0.024234451353549957, 0.03945128247141838, 0.03580847755074501, -0.035526424646377563, -0.0306694395840168, -0.0010373808909207582, -0.03229775279760361, 0.003519752062857151, 0.02963419072329998, -0.0053407978266477585, -0.009779502637684345, 0.02910062111914158, 0.017801227048039436, 0.02711927518248558, -0.03706277906894684, 0.09712102264165878, -0.01323697343468666, 0.0043404861353337765, -0.00010150630987482145, 0.008932258002460003, 0.01754395291209221, 0.05966702476143837, -0.024532867595553398, -0.02843206375837326, 0.04758256673812866, 0.016547484323382378, 0.06189917027950287, -0.003408565651625395, 0.018997319042682648, -0.029186995700001717, 0.009202317334711552, -0.004789107013493776, -0.02642735093832016, -0.04833338409662247, 0.00034484174102544785, -0.0028495527803897858, 0.03500722348690033, 0.11253228783607483, -0.021495355293154716, -0.007090866100043058, 0.03382460027933121, -0.020885370671749115, 0.0452268160879612, 0.006119277328252792, -0.0006121066980995238, -0.014317336492240429, 0.02035827748477459, -0.03859300538897514, -0.053374603390693665, 0.04271038621664047, 0.0072155301459133625, -0.06041570007801056, 0.014326906763017178, -0.004651121329516172, 0.02854009158909321, 0.007831225171685219, 0.0495176799595356, -0.09313740581274033, -0.029163368046283722, -0.020617056638002396, -0.026475736871361732, -0.01289733313024044, -0.0013134563341736794, 0.04289502650499344, 0.004338093567639589, -0.027333706617355347, -0.032572098076343536, -0.02962581254541874, -0.02578619495034218, -0.019192175939679146, -0.015767740085721016, 0.030819037929177284, 0.040771715342998505, -0.0190602894872427, -0.03487691655755043, -0.026134563609957695, 0.021725555881857872, -0.007623997516930103, -0.018240606412291527, 0.05727094039320946, -0.03231561556458473, 0.036946576088666916, -0.013006940484046936, 0.023244600743055344, 0.0445466972887516, 0.009881452657282352, 0.04723028093576431, -0.037734292447566986, -0.04348044469952583, -0.048450663685798645, 0.03423771262168884, 0.014941665343940258, -0.009014460258185863, 0.0019067056709900498, 0.013238216750323772, 0.03551775962114334, -0.032448988407850266, -0.009607437998056412, 0.007287918124347925, 0.01117541454732418, -0.005214334465563297, -0.0433383509516716, 0.046500254422426224, 0.03969666734337807, -0.05918143317103386, 0.05939466878771782, -0.00571813527494669, -0.03075358271598816, 0.004651576746255159, 0.048105865716934204, -0.005829237401485443, -0.007728613447397947, 0.0349462665617466, -0.007155950181186199, -0.061340805143117905, -0.01831957697868347, 0.03291463479399681, 0.06315053254365921, -0.04839375242590904, -0.046242933720350266, -0.028735311701893806, 0.00528557738289237, -0.006838390603661537, 0.011854331940412521, 0.01860244758427143, 0.016990704461932182, 0.01721583679318428, 0.0780765563249588, -0.00028680654941126704, 0.03506065160036087, 0.03983005881309509, 0.012624358758330345, 0.05847017094492912, 0.03908846899867058, -0.018807655200362206, 0.02336808666586876, 0.04392887279391289, -0.004045211710035801, -0.010539109818637371, 0.07822711020708084, -0.030369386076927185, -0.034358784556388855, 0.035819731652736664, -0.017679641023278236, 0.03720807284116745, 0.006862216163426638, -0.032161105424165726, -0.03665876388549805, 0.012545478530228138, -0.01448540948331356, -0.020921917632222176, -0.003996250685304403, -0.033014316111803055, 0.032993946224451065, 0.005233097355812788, -0.02249038778245449, -0.02885032445192337, -0.04699688032269478, -0.0025505812373012304, -0.003932825289666653, -0.02628956362605095, 0.017056642100214958, 0.08253711462020874, 0.050283949822187424, 0.020761923864483833, -0.01365942507982254, -0.05222577229142189, 0.027165142819285393, -0.021845132112503052, 0.03816310688853264, -0.04165470972657204, -0.028113041073083878, -0.019018078222870827, 0.006564671639353037, -0.017027540132403374, 0.0008212723769247532, 0.04978341981768608, -0.014018367044627666, 0.007830359973013401, 0.0060272314585745335, -0.018906695768237114, 0.01266178023070097, 0.03417825698852539, 0.025189248844981194, 0.06458397954702377, -0.019588835537433624, 0.00888783298432827, -0.04486642777919769, -0.009022184647619724, 0.02997319959104061, -0.0011067291488870978, 0.041125934571027756, 0.10682717710733414, 0.06461045145988464, -0.06014346703886986, 0.007834114134311676, -0.013992796652019024, 0.032906077802181244, -0.01808166317641735, -0.03483564779162407, 0.005870805587619543, -0.008608431555330753, -0.04205373302102089, 0.0007296187686733902, 0.1104295551776886, -0.017201486974954605, 0.04271126165986061, 0.03849024698138237, -0.03608869016170502, 0.012799167074263096, -0.0418715663254261, 0.01847834885120392, -0.03843614086508751, 0.057790499180555344, 0.03023391403257847, 0.024106541648507118, 0.004993067122995853, -0.03544192388653755, -0.02448105439543724, 0.02074349671602249, -0.02327168546617031, -0.005136141087859869, 0.0005793722812086344, -0.053706273436546326, -0.0021218929905444384, -0.0028806820046156645, 0.027098987251520157, -0.035604361444711685, -0.07612576335668564, -0.04054826498031616, 0.034521762281656265, -0.023369796574115753, -0.03184894099831581, 0.012449841946363449, 0.05057743191719055, 0.007050236687064171, 0.07140851020812988, -0.03716026619076729, 0.04360072687268257, 0.009768818505108356, 0.016925416886806488, -3.094061895581035e-8, 0.07918569445610046, -0.05649218335747719, -0.027749668806791306, -0.04445693641901016, 0.04942037910223007, -0.01968594454228878, -0.008983987383544445, 0.01657724753022194, -0.025133874267339706, 0.017079196870326996, 0.0072592440992593765, 0.06481833010911942, 0.005717670079320669, 0.005583818536251783, 0.039443232119083405, 0.003738089930266142, 0.03355057165026665, 0.0273949783295393, -0.051667019724845886, -0.0381552055478096, 0.029018163681030273, 0.02590767852962017, -0.018221154808998108, 0.010121280327439308, 0.027241671457886696, 0.00901085790246725, -0.03104572370648384, 0.027337316423654556, -0.03303699567914009, 0.0046822624281048775, -0.01686977967619896, -0.03131721168756485, -0.043349143117666245, 0.028170425444841385, 0.0005716803134419024, -0.05184900388121605, -0.01342795044183731, -0.08423130959272385, 0.03706185519695282, 0.030629154294729233, 0.01896202191710472, -0.07832463830709457, 0.04950244724750519, -0.015507472679018974, 0.05483464151620865, 0.036778807640075684, 0.015512712299823761, 0.01688607782125473, -0.04197138920426369, -0.006065362133085728, 0.017937442287802696, 0.023439902812242508, -0.026497427374124527, 0.010370763018727303, -0.07644511759281158, 0.010280434042215347, 0.003426832379773259, -0.03449611738324165, -0.02890263870358467, 0.004609358962625265, 0.021707672625780106, -0.053170494735240936, 0.01043351087719202, 0.009551185183227062, -0.01278932485729456, -0.004877815954387188, -0.0578458271920681, 0.010627270676195621, -0.029597973451018333, 0.001438083709217608, 0.04001185670495033, 0.0071054850704967976, -0.016472797840833664, -0.00766957039013505, -0.011091631837189198, -0.05414332076907158, -0.031194549053907394, -0.03176609426736832, -0.007730222772806883, -0.08263269066810608, 0.005117336753755808, 0.03491245582699776, -0.04338746517896652, -0.007152848411351442, 0.013507109135389328, -0.022975625470280647, 0.04197420924901962, -0.058402299880981445, 0.06404178589582443, 0.03367200866341591, -0.06001213565468788, 0.058002572506666183, 0.015039444901049137, 0.048664867877960205, -0.019922923296689987, -0.00465813372284174, 0.005327056627720594, 0.0193118117749691, 0.011501234024763107, 0.03728099912405014, 0.050123363733291626, 0.09265416860580444, 0.057005416601896286, 0.011121571063995361, 0.001360300462692976, 0.021665839478373528, 0.03557828813791275, 0.006143512669950724, 0.05772683024406433, -0.08051592111587524, -0.07931506633758545, -0.019442429766058922, 0.05678395554423332, -0.006040988955646753, -0.029246987774968147, 0.00907069444656372, -0.05475422739982605, 0.02579406090080738, 0.03634278103709221, -0.05714121460914612, -0.021077105775475502, -0.037310849875211716, -0.040385033935308456, 0.08506622165441513, -0.04402800649404526, -0.030044814571738243, -0.01165738608688116, -0.02256724052131176, -0.06407749652862549, -0.0035858498886227608, -0.06684114784002304, 0.03247204050421715, 0.06226767227053642, -0.04181041195988655, -0.003039421746507287, -0.017473241314291954, 0.01634424552321434, 0.02563302218914032, -0.04680498316884041, -0.06478764861822128, -0.052396614104509354, 0.0233914814889431, -0.051592014729976654, 0.014042770490050316, -0.015075376257300377, -0.01348875928670168, 0.08602388203144073, 0.016982238739728928, 0.042589347809553146, -0.055151600390672684, 0.0253467820584774, 0.020127039402723312, -0.01583070680499077, -0.008448376320302486, -0.014382819645106792, 0.02095504105091095, -0.03183974325656891, 0.0009706348064355552, -0.0012440863065421581, 0.009962369687855244, -0.008510108105838299, -0.04705280810594559, 0.029964618384838104, 0.07365067303180695, 0.051161084324121475, -0.005721145775169134, -0.06157836690545082, -0.06095363199710846, 0.03235238045454025, 0.04077031835913658, -0.028195010498166084, -0.020426666364073753, -0.002233823062852025, 0.06324825435876846, -0.03182046487927437, -0.03192129358649254, 0.024091728031635284, 0.0009256877820007503, 0.033241596072912216, -0.060816675424575806, 0.01673281006515026, -0.006640761625021696, 0.05210922658443451, -0.037682268768548965, -0.045146673917770386, 0.07194773107767105, -0.01267638336867094, -0.024314681068062782, -0.030594324693083763, -0.03276854380965233, -0.015595822595059872, 0.010161557234823704, 0.053486455231904984, 0.00989158358424902, 0.06876609474420547, 0.0787004604935646, -0.007485775742679834, 0.06754489243030548, 0.0037001650780439377, -0.0015327890869230032, 0.00011167336924700066, -0.022318633273243904, -0.01808614656329155, -0.008726820349693298, 0.029545526951551437, -0.01863733120262623, 0.04713835567235947, 0.08024682104587555, 0.022246047854423523, -0.026933802291750908, -0.03846794366836548, 0.010974137112498283, -0.003785087028518319, 0.03452476114034653, 0.0039827036671340466, 0.024866467341780663, -0.03232678025960922, -0.029170595109462738, -0.023579398170113564, 0.04078609123826027, 0.03503622114658356, 0.0029772762209177017, 0.007458186242729425, 0.09809929877519608, 0.047025054693222046, -0.021506354212760925, 0.024247251451015472, 0.03305258974432945, -0.04974159598350525, 0.010730985552072525, 0.041874758899211884, -0.03511849418282509, -0.007221973966807127, -0.00215278216637671, 0.07191590964794159, 0.038120515644550323, 0.02228349633514881, -0.03880228474736214, 0.005033072549849749, 0.05931071937084198, 0.002480365801602602, 0.06936506181955338, 0.06615491211414337, -0.01666879467666149, 0.012141773477196693, 0.02270900271832943, 0.013996490277349949, -0.027492592111229897, 0.004339828621596098, 0.012175226584076881, -0.018281688913702965, 0.05683102458715439, -0.00027741710073314607, 0.016866227611899376, -0.014177477918565273, -0.0471305251121521, -0.049657851457595825, -0.03141982853412628, -0.0028021298348903656, -0.03551137074828148, -0.008158136159181595, 0.06112062558531761, -0.020043672993779182, -0.03780898079276085, 0.023721160367131233, 0.033793628215789795, -0.04437234252691269, -0.06551874428987503, -0.053944673389196396, 0.007744648493826389, 0.013517473824322224, -0.03697575628757477, -0.0330757200717926, 0.0024083356838673353, 0.011834497563540936, -0.02922706864774227, -0.06318405270576477, -0.030192486941814423, -0.04987303540110588, 0.04494629427790642, 0.08688583970069885, -0.03362719714641571, -0.006304752081632614, 0.07724805176258087, -0.032091978937387466, -0.05301765725016594, 0.012002009898424149, 0.019765714183449745, -0.05040518566966057, 0.021966110914945602, -0.059295181185007095, -0.00803377479314804, -0.038979172706604004, -0.017559271305799484, 0.0657215267419815, 0.038407426327466965, -0.013964101672172546, -0.03059796616435051, -0.026954639703035355, -0.03731252998113632, 0.020988477393984795, -0.06583067774772644, 0.005326246842741966, -0.04015679657459259, -0.02278801240026951, 0.007106078788638115, 0.015042285434901714, -0.009942259639501572, 0.004304257687181234, -0.01317503396421671, -0.01610505022108555, -0.05073873698711395, 0.014006026089191437, -0.10260972380638123, -0.044839296489953995, -0.026975907385349274, -0.028030263260006905, 0.018935028463602066, 0.003579242154955864, -0.0005403686664067209, 0.04364877566695213, 0.024831146001815796, -0.007652529049664736, -0.006350149400532246, 0.018601426854729652, -0.003656310960650444, 0.021050812676548958, -0.05375082418322563, 0.03141834959387779, 0.08092306554317474, 0.017609817907214165, -0.03833366557955742, 0.027570003643631935, 0.0018807965097948909, -0.013146912679076195, -0.03900217264890671, -0.0016550032887607813, 0.004962047096341848, 0.014539647847414017, 0.04849793389439583, 0.03342466801404953, -0.017707232385873795, -0.02746492065489292, 0.024321522563695908, -0.04772157967090607, -0.02515898458659649, 0.04562288150191307, -0.0025902448687702417, -0.008343592286109924, 0.022184288129210472, 0.013005745597183704, 0.029710136353969574, -0.001827423577196896, 0.022941576316952705, -0.048839021474123, 0.00022365541371982545, -0.0282259713858366, -0.04736299812793732, 0.048754531890153885, -0.07578940689563751, 0.013159267604351044, -0.06471826881170273, 0.011652708984911442 ]
<p>What is the difference between </p> <p>$ \lim_{n \to \infty} \ \mathrm{E}_{\theta}(T_n(X)) = \theta$ </p> <p>and </p> <p>$ T_n(X) \xrightarrow{p} \theta \ $ for $\ n \xrightarrow{} \infty$ ?</p> <p>(unbiasdness vs. Consisteny)</p> <hr> <p>Ups... there seems to be this question already :-( <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/31036/what-is-the-difference-between-a-consistent-estimator-and-an-unbiased-estimator?rq=1">Similar CrossValidated question</a> </p> <p>Shall I delete this question?</p>
g49379
[ 0.0406867116689682, -0.012801234610378742, -0.007698457222431898, -0.02177765965461731, 0.03214654326438904, -0.03684237226843834, 0.04137002304196358, 0.01011502742767334, -0.0756392627954483, 0.0456136129796505, -0.0020365507807582617, 0.031114645302295685, -0.030133143067359924, 0.014511706307530403, 0.0019847967196255922, -0.04070683568716049, 0.058272797614336014, -0.01690879836678505, -0.006736511830240488, 0.0393192321062088, -0.05033151060342789, 0.028519241139292717, -0.004262085072696209, 0.013145191594958305, 0.018056029453873634, -0.06599786132574081, -0.01338020246475935, 0.06622229516506195, 0.0011879908852279186, -0.013974230736494064, 0.0317353829741478, 0.012690787203609943, 0.06225999817252159, 0.006150810047984123, -0.04869822412729263, 0.06621904671192169, 0.1049700379371643, -0.002347751287743449, 0.09102662652730942, -0.03046005219221115, 0.03585188090801239, 0.028425555676221848, 0.03344256058335304, -0.030702153220772743, -0.00297898449935019, 0.00823674350976944, -0.011360513977706432, 0.0841469019651413, -0.0005849709850735962, -0.025475718080997467, -0.041869327425956726, -0.02172573283314705, 0.03283051773905754, 0.030256586149334908, 0.015812687575817108, 0.03317631781101227, 0.030220409855246544, -0.031132835894823074, 0.023590676486492157, 0.04511357098817825, 0.022671665996313095, -0.030781734734773636, -0.010428030043840408, -0.026151960715651512, -0.0038088378496468067, 0.009474732913076878, 0.04452385753393173, 0.00595786701887846, -0.0245936568826437, -0.043336596339941025, -0.039816081523895264, -0.05418911576271057, -0.0001589459425304085, 0.009475873783230782, -0.06096630543470383, 0.04120425507426262, 0.014716174453496933, -0.020937658846378326, -0.014067739248275757, 0.04821077734231949, -0.05264719948172569, -0.03044416382908821, 0.01906009577214718, 0.05381086468696594, 0.023713238537311554, -0.00028932138229720294, 0.06788887828588486, 0.0014152057701721787, 0.005720383953303099, 0.05381205305457115, 0.048848070204257965, 0.005135206039994955, 0.02201557718217373, 0.023101279512047768, -0.0373774953186512, -0.05121365189552307, -0.06266922503709793, -0.006440471857786179, 0.024620527401566505, 0.021576933562755585, 0.0058138263411819935, 0.018267091363668442, 0.008140401914715767, -0.002998580690473318, 0.0013453835854306817, -0.02956097200512886, 0.010791380889713764, 0.006600120570510626, -0.06456878036260605, -0.06736241281032562, -0.021027036011219025, 0.01858430542051792, 0.016141440719366074, -0.08122693002223969, -0.011767115443944931, 0.01645594649016857, 0.011426488868892193, 0.019906552508473396, 0.08696773648262024, 0.0014947406016290188, 0.00561051769182086, -0.04242226853966713, 0.052723415195941925, 0.04888171702623367, -0.07555700093507767, 0.034027814865112305, -0.04993479326367378, 0.02144760452210903, -0.028624821454286575, -0.010917965322732925, 0.07156828045845032, 0.03374379128217697, 0.003346431767567992, 0.023065321147441864, 0.0009182155481539667, -0.006486248690634966, -0.009465835988521576, -0.021297408267855644, 0.005362534895539284, 0.03299304470419884, -0.042024120688438416, -0.041670061647892, 0.01683611050248146, -0.05383403226733208, -0.004621837288141251, 0.013641512021422386, -0.006875263527035713, -0.03784151375293732, 0.033806413412094116, 0.033899541944265366, -0.003263039281591773, 0.06327023357152939, 0.013611620292067528, 0.02769373171031475, -0.01826000027358532, -0.02216457761824131, -0.025646544992923737, -0.014128276146948338, 0.012931274250149727, -0.02411184273660183, 0.011098088696599007, -0.003445408074185252, 0.06424019485712051, 0.027895379811525345, -0.0432579480111599, -0.05396090820431709, -0.04239029437303543, -0.0692824199795723, -0.015587945468723774, -0.03386659920215607, 0.048295050859451294, 0.044620878994464874, 0.055415865033864975, -0.016090814024209976, 0.027015065774321556, 0.0017281206091865897, -0.01534112449735403, 0.0034625085536390543, 0.025862861424684525, -0.008792907930910587, 0.013874826952815056, 0.06282960623502731, 0.011104556731879711, -0.02347024530172348, 0.012667887844145298, -0.056725990027189255, 0.04642404243350029, -0.057573139667510986, -0.0733819305896759, -0.013611018657684326, 0.00004432135392562486, -0.022153079509735107, -0.022313987836241722, 0.0781673714518547, -0.045908089727163315, -0.0022907087113708258, 0.0025260448455810547, -0.04920831695199013, -0.001841496443375945, 0.004504755605012178, 0.0248760636895895, -0.0054982006549835205, -0.006107167806476355, 0.037496332079172134, -0.06248965486884117, -0.0034797945991158485, -0.02379513718187809, -0.051183708012104034, 0.005409575067460537, 0.008592499420046806, -0.023638322949409485, -0.0025700144469738007, -0.00845396425575018, -0.02509506605565548, 0.011391676031053066, -0.05918505787849426, 0.029268447309732437, 0.03659584000706673, -0.009590884670615196, -0.037191443145275116, 0.01938101090490818, -0.042779382318258286, 0.06937103718519211, -0.04651026427745819, -0.08559741079807281, -0.0033409162424504757, 0.012923724949359894, -0.036858342587947845, 0.02119983546435833, -0.0010086160618811846, -0.02256053127348423, -0.03733517974615097, 0.00624507013708353, 0.008157707750797272, 0.013895510695874691, 0.057704441249370575, 0.07083258777856827, 0.02299823984503746, 0.06035365164279938, 0.010052749887108803, 0.011053004302084446, 0.01729687489569187, -0.033534981310367584, 0.04666454717516899, 0.022237636148929596, -0.0016798034776002169, 0.0008984453161247075, -0.016681119799613953, 0.013242751359939575, 0.018792079761624336, -0.035588402301073074, 0.07852227240800858, -0.026238098740577698, -0.05547614023089409, -0.033182282000780106, -0.01865476183593273, -0.029230784624814987, -0.02772536687552929, -0.004661468788981438, 0.03355566784739494, -0.03309324011206627, -0.012879997491836548, -0.0469471774995327, -0.010762103833258152, -0.011201114393770695, 0.017059283331036568, 0.0051389723084867, -0.014642749913036823, 0.0019858910236507654, -0.06322444975376129, -0.007328543346375227, -0.005541957449167967, 0.050577402114868164, 0.06027882546186447, 0.017089486122131348, 0.01175946556031704, -0.06321059167385101, -0.004133857786655426, 0.05205816775560379, -0.04048449173569679, -0.030118100345134735, -0.029743991792201996, -0.030744202435016632, 0.0625394731760025, -0.002075875410810113, -0.0004416301962919533, 0.0399542972445488, 0.0008999855490401387, -0.058437421917915344, 0.05595484748482704, 0.014573542401194572, -0.02894965559244156, 0.0510585680603981, -0.028062613680958748, -0.0102424630895257, 0.013960092328488827, 0.006660918705165386, -0.052117202430963516, 0.022846760228276253, -0.026316393166780472, -0.022031784057617188, 0.025198809802532196, 0.0050251237116754055, 0.002234639599919319, 0.06363052129745483, 0.022728431969881058, -0.03147583082318306, -0.014362890273332596, 0.01818450167775154, 0.0179330725222826, 0.01835475116968155, -0.008354023098945618, -0.04165377840399742, -0.038834359496831894, 0.011808998882770538, -0.02112407051026821, 0.007889390923082829, 0.0003818776458501816, 0.027637016028165817, -0.006824837997555733, -0.03259146586060524, -0.06204543635249138, -0.020152078941464424, 0.005109825171530247, -0.059271037578582764, -0.04527309164404869, -0.07127562910318375, 0.034780941903591156, -0.01148255169391632, -0.02745937556028366, 0.027511978521943092, 0.029192036017775536, 0.03935160115361214, 0.018440021201968193, -0.012203337624669075, -0.030204059556126595, 0.036413535475730896, 0.0346190445125103, 0.04238200932741165, 0.07334230095148087, -0.001935184234753251, 0.009042033925652504, -0.003736990736797452, 0.0051443795673549175, -0.007959932088851929, -0.006262857001274824, 0.005729351658374071, -0.015358775854110718, 0.01569155976176262, 0.054115179926157, 0.06873103976249695, 0.008320637047290802, 0.007426489144563675, -0.05431634932756424, 0.04585075005888939, -0.010753226466476917, -0.006404961459338665, 0.033082522451877594, 0.03584413230419159, 0.0058731031604111195, 0.04989885911345482, 0.003199594561010599, -0.013709517195820808, 0.013994015753269196, -0.0034275429788976908, -0.016393501311540604, 0.01794690638780594, 0.07616371661424637, 0.018954038619995117, -0.020190047100186348, 0.006277001928538084, 0.06485103815793991, 0.02774958312511444, 0.005425948649644852, 0.016742952167987823, -0.05746769532561302, 0.024065542966127396, 0.009459111839532852, 0.03826628252863884, 0.025399908423423767, 0.05835019797086716, -0.026342742145061493, -0.027816584333777428, -0.01029602624475956, 0.03924357146024704, -0.03800765797495842, -0.016521915793418884, -0.01195766031742096, -0.0279827993363142, -0.040436673909425735, 0.01667327992618084, -0.04507588967680931, -0.05861615762114525, 0.05036883428692818, 0.030511168763041496, -0.04140331968665123, 0.024396000429987907, 0.002248826902359724, 0.022443359717726707, 0.024993659928441048, 0.0045764632523059845, -0.016517046838998795, 0.032806217670440674, -0.012706189416348934, -0.007711269427090883, 0.022075997665524483, -0.008541633374989033, -0.05105757713317871, -0.0442584753036499, -0.0628296360373497, -0.01899869367480278, 0.019496573135256767, -0.00413523381575942, 0.005422326736152172, 0.05765354260802269, 0.05447268858551979, 0.039958495646715164, -0.00854991190135479, 0.06455199420452118, -0.004270629491657019, -0.033318858593702316, 0.0032116894144564867, -0.047674234956502914, -0.032490115612745285, 0.03019706718623638, 0.07788374274969101, -0.004154116380959749, 0.04792206734418869, -0.007845224812626839, -0.05198196321725845, 0.04205527529120445, 0.020911384373903275, 0.017695222049951553, 0.04378535971045494, -0.045658279210329056, 0.008218337781727314, 0.023083854466676712, 0.04538118094205856, -0.011165778152644634, -0.05519768223166466, -0.01259307935833931, 0.0012887621996924281, -0.0038822919595986605, -0.01738794334232807, -0.0047783260233700275, -0.050782836973667145, -0.016479995101690292, -0.030132604762911797, 0.000566741859074682, 0.03284149616956711, -0.06772135198116302, 0.01872962899506092, 0.04204501956701279, -0.012048779986798763, -0.012744165025651455, -0.0341813750565052, 0.010031837970018387, 0.0224518533796072, 0.028543082997202873, -0.006717312149703503, -0.021722892299294472, -0.058856647461652756, -0.023834478110074997, 0.009373113512992859, -0.028159109875559807, 0.0007877000025473535, -0.06854178756475449, 0.026154864579439163, 0.011682115495204926, 0.06251206248998642, 0.003443386871367693, 0.039013538509607315, 0.02632540836930275, 0.02084992080926895, -0.01684229075908661, 0.006359132472425699, 0.03218777850270271, -0.016469193622469902, -0.042430330067873, 0.009757624939084053, -0.0697590634226799, -0.026937054470181465, 0.015074209310114384, 0.021092388778924942, -0.008438930846750736, 0.043099191039800644, -0.007821516133844852, -0.10524716973304749, 0.04223852977156639, 0.021507686004042625, 0.021007642149925232, 0.1004948541522026, 0.03742449730634689, -0.023473508656024933, -0.03339910879731178, -0.012740977108478546, -0.014281732961535454, -0.008483439683914185, 0.0091801006346941, 0.01160825602710247, -0.058853086084127426, 0.0338832326233387, -0.05516503006219864, -0.015256989747285843, 0.009005585685372353, 0.011689630337059498, 0.1241525262594223, 0.04466185346245766, -0.00503462553024292, -0.020395852625370026, 0.02325122058391571, 0.021807076409459114, 0.056285757571458817, 0.011295794509351254, -0.03918373957276344, 0.021734904497861862, -0.012992235831916332, 0.07224950194358826, -0.0035581018310040236, -0.010186503641307354, 0.04568619653582573, -0.03707985207438469, 0.020428890362381935, -0.013994955457746983, 0.010845448821783066, -0.016100868582725525, 0.018263814970850945, -0.0531066432595253, -0.013228309340775013, -0.03729390352964401, 0.09773866832256317, 0.013622201047837734, -0.006908501964062452, -0.03037215583026409, -0.020006245002150536, -0.011604450643062592, 0.032393526285886765, -0.026192449033260345, -0.0007148858276195824, -0.044582705944776535, -0.03320114314556122, 0.040817853063344955, 0.034248385578393936, 0.011739099398255348, -0.04521886631846428, -0.04850071668624878, -0.06505049020051956, 0.025445586070418358, 0.008425388485193253, 0.012102530337870121, -0.04800517484545708, 0.0013821597676724195, -0.03436725586652756, -0.06192825362086296, -0.014859848655760288, 0.0358489528298378, 0.0023244305048137903, 0.03545200079679489, -0.026935948058962822, -0.0016104122623801231, 0.002864051843062043, -0.10645971447229385, 0.0038684564642608166, -0.02432587929069996, 0.005581569857895374, -0.008733835071325302, -0.0012338705128058791, -0.007670903578400612, -0.05644909664988518, 0.019710224121809006, 0.044838111847639084, 0.013129672035574913, 0.04597307741641998, 0.0068283407017588615, 0.03666795417666435, 0.07929987460374832, -0.009338084608316422, -0.022942906245589256, 0.013311920687556267, 0.03167225047945976, -0.008029527962207794, -0.008207281120121479, -0.03177816793322563, -0.02177339792251587, 0.00736642861738801, 0.0378684364259243, -0.06375007331371307, -0.010179776698350906, 0.03243079036474228, -0.023264847695827484, -0.008141400292515755, -0.046074118465185165, 0.02206978015601635, -0.047572650015354156, 0.010754210874438286, 0.03936398774385452, -0.04950390383601189, 0.0067935665138065815, 0.006037049926817417, -0.0210571251809597, -0.004015808459371328, -0.043605491518974304, 0.04574569687247276, -0.007381468545645475, -0.0030089702922850847, -0.007243764121085405, 0.020141417160630226, 0.03963903337717056, 0.0034418641589581966, -0.012467441149055958, -0.011898737400770187, 0.010044420138001442, 0.017347967252135277, 0.012120077386498451, -0.06919877976179123, -0.032889366149902344, -0.06780621409416199, -0.016589265316724777, -0.03607773408293724, 0.08271870762109756, 0.030597027391195297, -0.034416940063238144, -0.07777287811040878, 0.05464410409331322, 0.043531350791454315, 0.01832270435988903, 0.030270125716924667, -0.004702076315879822, -0.02053612843155861, -0.01533183641731739, -0.015908710658550262, 0.0003369572514202446, -0.022747624665498734, 0.08887150138616562, 0.0019239329267293215, 0.02796066924929619, -0.06897161155939102, 0.05112947151064873, 0.027855975553393364, 0.06172709912061691, -0.038658708333969116, 0.08531639724969864, 0.03127388283610344, -0.02301228605210781, -0.05421917885541916, 0.059224363416433334, -0.0013731970684602857, 0.015055393800139427, -0.08575084060430527, 0.014562992379069328, 0.0163380429148674, -0.03815743699669838, 0.015689799562096596, 0.0015308527508750558, -0.022494906559586525, 0.004709191620349884, 0.007509549614042044, -0.03193249553442001, 0.038233160972595215, -0.030097858980298042, 0.020377743989229202, -0.04540400952100754, 0.008978142403066158, 0.06534601002931595, 0.036562249064445496, -0.023380333557724953, -0.046876922249794006, -0.07948146015405655, -0.03215565159916878, -0.03725815936923027, 0.07194184511899948, -0.0015102282632142305, 0.0015256423503160477, -0.04073382914066315, 0.022788817062973976, 0.006772810127586126, -0.01195437740534544, -0.001569413230754435, -0.022686559706926346, 0.008353004232048988, -0.026281502097845078, -0.025358470156788826, 0.012473736889660358, -0.002833005739375949, 0.014854796230793, 0.024365106597542763, -0.020719939842820168, -0.005475481040775776, 0.037184495478868484, -0.04134287312626839, -0.026283135637640953, 0.019479161128401756, 0.03510156646370888, 0.02365783229470253, 0.033273812383413315, 0.03435337170958519, -0.042821239680051804, 0.028831887990236282, -0.015107881277799606, -0.0009081308962777257, 0.0465206503868103, 0.0002659399760887027, -0.009030142799019814, -0.01768730953335762, 0.08558988571166992, 0.040177274495363235, -0.018509438261389732, -0.028915654867887497, 0.007458431180566549, -0.06551666557788849, 0.0037837133277207613, -0.04288720339536667, -0.006560949143022299, -0.06597873568534851, 0.05205513536930084, -0.06678461283445358, -0.06564714014530182, -0.05966384708881378, 0.006819578353315592, 0.003328126622363925, 0.012985892593860626, -0.022772962227463722, 0.006020617671310902, -0.069918692111969, -0.0005292985588312149, -0.06951391696929932, -0.06492804735898972, 0.030205082148313522, -0.013505768030881882, -0.006818522233515978, -0.04593251645565033, -0.0241987444460392, -0.030640458688139915, 0.05558079481124878, -0.05646556243300438, 0.019529659301042557, 0.04604579135775566, 0.034318700432777405, 0.0035055179614573717, -0.004191056825220585, 0.011031040921807289, -0.0003716356004588306, 0.06197844445705414, -0.014012620784342289, -0.048283156007528305, 0.04014206305146217, -0.022272178903222084, 0.03411714732646942, 0.035306066274642944, -0.07948899269104004, -0.044267453253269196, 0.058233216404914856, -0.06266700476408005, 0.09098679572343826, 0.019597576931118965, 0.04142482206225395, 0.023080991581082344, -0.011853690259158611, 0.027014711871743202, 0.015735799446702003, -0.008769667707383633, -0.07837428152561188, -0.005918870214372873, -0.01266978308558464, -0.0009109630482271314, -0.016818417236208916, -0.048207446932792664, 0.014015469700098038 ]
<p>I have been trying to estimate the MLE for my joint posterior. I'm using R and the package stats4. I have 14 parameters and two of them are $\geq 0$, which I did not know how to implement (and I was creating NaN due to the minus log posterior required in for the mle function) and I just made it return very high value (1000) if either of the parameters were negative. Is this the right way to solve this problem? As I was forced to change my prior each time (because MLE told me that my prior estimates were way to high) and I find these nonegative parameters going down to were low numbers (0.001 and 0.01) which did not seem right and at each iteration way below my repeatly suggested prior.</p> <p>Also, since I didn't have the exact posterior due to the structure of the model and I tried to scale it such that the point estimate from the mle function plugged in the log joint posterior had the value 0. Is this approximation okay for this function?</p> <p>Regards, Raxel. </p>
g74332
[ -0.004662214312702417, -0.055324263870716095, 0.018574897199869156, -0.0508679635822773, -0.02384530007839203, 0.016165463253855705, 0.015304452739655972, 0.047634873539209366, -0.07980171591043472, -0.002905148547142744, -0.01854684017598629, 0.03770119324326515, 0.021262766793370247, 0.014078979380428791, 0.04447975754737854, -0.045657142996788025, 0.05801950767636299, -0.01666146330535412, -0.029848363250494003, 0.013943521305918694, -0.03096056915819645, 0.06272082030773163, 0.028845038264989853, -0.05139024183154106, -0.003111449535936117, -0.05414222180843353, -0.022168630734086037, 0.0796625092625618, -0.07141832262277603, -0.0199001245200634, 0.004356252495199442, -0.07578245550394058, 0.0232177022844553, 0.005521903745830059, -0.006867164745926857, 0.01064369548112154, 0.051052529364824295, -0.0014485152205452323, -0.015263384208083153, -0.01908179000020027, -0.009345625527203083, -0.040538012981414795, 0.08503910899162292, 0.05674098804593086, -0.017686042934656143, 0.05790184810757637, 0.0016104393871501088, -0.006820014212280512, 0.03635473549365997, 0.008357915095984936, 0.01576782763004303, 0.003980595618486404, 0.015171468257904053, -0.04440705478191376, 0.047699082642793655, 0.07225748896598816, -0.01920871064066887, 0.021488312631845474, 0.011111660860478878, -0.008064118213951588, 0.009917085990309715, -0.03509080410003662, -0.050375230610370636, 0.021114271134138107, -0.01482517272233963, 0.05015081539750099, -0.01434794720262289, 0.03060021996498108, 0.0017351857386529446, -0.008038722909986973, -0.015728797763586044, 0.04218824952840805, -0.00914926826953888, -0.045694950968027115, -0.048615049570798874, -0.033285386860370636, 0.032745301723480225, -0.03042827919125557, -0.07987555116415024, 0.010844679549336433, -0.07182318717241287, 0.026083705946803093, 0.04339151084423065, 0.012699754908680916, -0.018993115052580833, -0.0013338258722797036, 0.07474783807992935, 0.032995838671922684, 0.012460705824196339, 0.03002753295004368, -0.04345434159040451, 0.014297558926045895, 0.04254620149731636, -0.00899102445691824, 0.02139710634946823, -0.07119646668434143, -0.07279600203037262, 0.04297826066613197, -0.025868307799100876, 0.014734606258571148, 0.028391409665346146, 0.04035119339823723, -0.013399533927440643, -0.025603514164686203, -0.03795081004500389, 0.02038593217730522, 0.048344649374485016, -0.010212767869234085, 0.016522927209734917, -0.06291364133358002, -0.0412537083029747, 0.004286380484700203, 0.011425372213125229, -0.037058405578136444, -0.045818109065294266, -0.012574171647429466, 0.017508842051029205, -0.05458766594529152, -0.017920002341270447, 0.023729830980300903, -0.016366031020879745, -0.002796383108943701, 0.02488003857433796, 0.02381771430373192, -0.010427125729620457, -0.006237832363694906, -0.02138267457485199, 0.05456957966089249, 0.036351338028907776, -0.007141470909118652, -0.05662472918629646, -0.035501595586538315, -0.005143006797879934, 0.026999743655323982, 0.03331027925014496, 0.03744391351938248, -0.027015123516321182, 0.02971397154033184, 0.002218609442934394, 0.05715738609433174, 0.018237585201859474, 0.01803748682141304, 0.028146106749773026, -0.06182613968849182, 0.0038822456263005733, -0.0023874803446233273, 0.021269207820296288, -0.0021245437674224377, -0.05533067137002945, 0.06428797543048859, -0.004114645533263683, 0.008159850724041462, 0.028638778254389763, 0.04958333820104599, 0.01676560379564762, 0.046697042882442474, 0.02717151865363121, -0.05622665956616402, -0.023501694202423096, 0.03132972493767738, 0.01646648347377777, 0.006434671580791473, 0.02098405919969082, -0.004566955845803022, 0.03540889918804169, 0.048769112676382065, -0.009690538980066776, -0.009616992436349392, -0.030152764171361923, -0.007482883986085653, 0.037330400198698044, 0.0051179383881390095, 0.051755283027887344, -0.047546181827783585, 0.07217955589294434, 0.016555864363908768, -0.00457929540425539, -0.012689228169620037, -0.016016889363527298, 0.04606960713863373, 0.00963171198964119, 0.03235435485839844, 0.01502963062375784, 0.007717710454016924, -0.0959945023059845, -0.04401204362511635, -0.013763150200247765, 0.03934985771775246, 0.008897573687136173, -0.09241677075624466, 0.014692128635942936, -0.017910858616232872, -0.07229943573474884, -0.027765316888689995, -0.009852896444499493, 0.05742136389017105, 0.05378580838441849, -0.0688304752111435, -0.010700305923819542, 0.01715061254799366, -0.054558251053094864, 0.03335532173514366, 0.032267358154058456, 0.016257911920547485, 0.014882202260196209, -0.021666597574949265, -0.03158510848879814, -0.05831938982009888, -0.031609490513801575, 0.02813521772623062, -0.008602975867688656, 0.017342230305075645, -0.0014378920895978808, 0.019925769418478012, 0.02436988241970539, 0.008724436163902283, 0.06989873945713043, 0.03510317951440811, 0.04642534628510475, 0.012751688249409199, -0.0355195552110672, -0.028877031058073044, 0.09954804927110672, 0.06288038939237595, 0.03531961515545845, 0.021181989461183548, 0.044088929891586304, 0.05914309620857239, -0.016759909689426422, 0.002611675998196006, -0.03173898160457611, 0.011915624141693115, -0.0031812316738069057, 0.004716480150818825, 0.03334678336977959, -0.03356596827507019, -0.04739151522517204, 0.01656857691705227, -0.03615470975637436, 0.05822829157114029, 0.006649448536336422, 0.03363768756389618, 0.009160335175693035, 0.03479035943746567, 0.014115295372903347, 0.00480151129886508, -0.026413142681121826, -0.01556885801255703, 0.009607076644897461, 0.08211454749107361, -0.0014755601296201348, 0.08690623939037323, -0.023524852469563484, 0.001768863177858293, -0.026382017880678177, -0.020905721932649612, 0.0236717090010643, -0.003765143919736147, -0.042167142033576965, -0.031166253611445427, -0.020917223766446114, 0.017257973551750183, -0.10148876905441284, 0.005399079993367195, -0.0014692718395963311, 0.021098412573337555, -0.007408974226564169, -0.02170918509364128, 0.02676873281598091, 0.04763247072696686, 0.03743976354598999, -0.011922148987650871, 0.029428761452436447, 0.054280586540699005, 0.03856785595417023, -0.0050124675035476685, 0.005832511465996504, 0.045128822326660156, 0.03874595835804939, -0.018404701724648476, 0.004994564224034548, -0.024839498102664948, -0.007217878010123968, -0.04449434205889702, 0.007993227802217007, -0.021573321893811226, 0.046273600310087204, -0.06585237383842468, 0.0310392864048481, 0.0639808401465416, -0.08787302672863007, -0.00045166819472797215, 0.02820046804845333, -0.006901253014802933, -0.030130604282021523, -0.011079920455813408, -0.03680456802248955, -0.05743527039885521, 0.017310474067926407, -0.047656238079071045, -0.04293667525053024, -0.027149410918354988, -0.038385290652513504, -0.06013432890176773, -0.015870708972215652, -0.07136504352092743, -0.05064027011394501, 0.029276765882968903, 0.033737245947122574, 0.037196990102529526, -0.006489964667707682, -0.015920741483569145, 0.004941907245665789, -0.03564219921827316, -0.007419718895107508, 0.03879663720726967, -0.07174132764339447, -0.044797539710998535, -0.017291035503149033, -0.03621232882142067, 0.06019244343042374, -0.0691860169172287, -0.02493886463344097, -0.0018120359163731337, 0.025460846722126007, 0.0328587181866169, -0.0022067090030759573, 0.050641827285289764, -0.026017630472779274, 0.03738333284854889, 0.06634975224733353, -0.01486397348344326, 0.03527439758181572, -0.003514497308060527, 0.07178037613630295, -0.0192268006503582, -0.01628086529672146, -0.05617604777216911, 0.013009589165449142, 0.006272162310779095, -0.07192491739988327, -0.02312297746539116, -0.04431374371051788, 0.03387690335512161, -0.011490525677800179, -0.025305241346359253, 0.004528101067990065, 0.03832044452428818, 0.03548678383231163, -0.02765101194381714, -0.02451072260737419, 0.0057860929518938065, -0.03969220444560051, -0.0041217864491045475, -0.013505369424819946, 0.026676664128899574, -0.0017870237352326512, 0.02574709802865982, -0.03466549515724182, 0.042567867785692215, 0.07356435060501099, -0.03604112192988396, -0.011448470875620842, 0.07652776688337326, 0.06648494303226471, 0.021795103326439857, -0.018760589882731438, 0.05641499534249306, 0.008540508337318897, 0.02972479909658432, 0.006196560803800821, 0.01836603507399559, 0.015903471037745476, 0.026725780218839645, 0.026484526693820953, -0.038563117384910583, 0.0362725593149662, -0.00488666957244277, -0.03847256302833557, 0.053001366555690765, 0.021738823503255844, -0.019598109647631645, -0.030376939103007317, 0.025835594162344933, -0.040109504014253616, 0.02476852759718895, -0.017180800437927246, -0.031608760356903076, 0.029819559305906296, -0.058781061321496964, -0.0031068946700543165, -0.024790948256850243, -0.02742083929479122, 0.008620223961770535, 0.055467236787080765, 0.0016663442365825176, 0.04924456775188446, -0.053046077489852905, -0.00212069577537477, -0.0035596294328570366, -0.018795350566506386, 0.030034810304641724, 0.0419335663318634, -0.009008113294839859, -0.05525379627943039, -0.015045218169689178, -0.07396872341632843, 0.021071450784802437, -0.026547871530056, 0.030651496723294258, -0.047829777002334595, 0.02634338103234768, 0.01646880991756916, -0.013460693880915642, 0.04157182574272156, -0.022822491824626923, 0.030358992516994476, -0.012408786453306675, -0.034540239721536636, 0.05200590193271637, 0.008215601556003094, 0.08280964195728302, -0.04134158790111542, -0.045986756682395935, 0.02649104781448841, 0.06296419352293015, 0.04615449160337448, -0.012910258956253529, 0.056177977472543716, -0.022016217932105064, -0.005877601448446512, 0.032545894384384155, -0.0449196919798851, 0.023196596652269363, -0.021438850089907646, 0.0049133519642055035, 0.01911160536110401, 0.010664571076631546, 0.010223670862615108, -0.02826365828514099, -0.10493283718824387, -0.018569879233837128, 0.05447393283247948, 0.011150894686579704, -0.006269719917327166, 0.015858937054872513, -0.015551093965768814, -0.012497573159635067, 0.019702505320310593, 0.029802290722727776, -0.008143296465277672, -0.025676360353827477, 0.014534116722643375, -0.0005098020192235708, 0.05054524168372154, 0.03992971405386925, -0.015101922675967216, 0.05122964456677437, 0.038133569061756134, 0.021830132231116295, 0.047800514847040176, 0.030398698523640633, -0.06756843626499176, -0.0034623946994543076, -0.020078321918845177, -0.01881294883787632, -0.06549341231584549, -0.012859444133937359, 0.0578889325261116, 0.018846405670046806, 0.00940055213868618, -0.018994804471731186, 0.048998214304447174, -0.04379834979772568, -0.06166757270693779, -0.017457330599427223, 0.015360696241259575, 0.014166089706122875, 0.0315544530749321, 0.0668918713927269, -0.02362247370183468, 0.019294539466500282, -0.003936584107577801, -0.04876520857214928, -0.0008431260357610881, 0.03339652344584465, 0.0057349614799022675, -0.03496141731739044, 0.01971452683210373, -0.00012315945059526712, -0.003094717627391219, 0.043554361909627914, 0.045845068991184235, -0.02858278714120388, 0.01828031986951828, 0.023951521143317223, -0.019314050674438477, 0.05865304172039032, -0.04513413459062576, 0.039561185985803604, -0.05641557648777962, 0.009247386828064919, 0.0008997054537758231, -0.004932657815515995, 0.019719071686267853, 0.017778782173991203, 0.0835103988647461, -0.006689111702144146, 0.013710097409784794, 0.05315275862812996, 0.03663918748497963, -0.03161502256989479, 0.05067156255245209, -0.06346480548381805, -0.06145280972123146, -0.05271417275071144, -0.00842114258557558, 0.05145465210080147, -0.007754916325211525, 0.0036678805481642485, 0.05896512418985367, 0.004915321711450815, 0.01999153196811676, -0.013374739326536655, -0.03334815427660942, -0.07894618064165115, 0.028169957920908928, 0.020097937434911728, -0.08131036162376404, 0.02126343920826912, -0.006806124467402697, -0.020888756960630417, -0.024981999769806862, -0.000595784280449152, -0.0353851318359375, 0.028872737661004066, -0.053620658814907074, -0.05028777942061424, 0.0216048713773489, -0.009275276213884354, 0.017086211591959, 0.005343120079487562, -0.015761571004986763, 0.011856677941977978, -0.08095249533653259, -0.010787321254611015, 0.013730882667005062, -0.019130408763885498, 0.038579680025577545, -0.07355751097202301, 0.016796018928289413, 0.05176179111003876, -0.030297840014100075, 0.006808470468968153, -0.04853913560509682, -0.010144305415451527, -0.0047554620541632175, 0.0022648493759334087, 0.05223248526453972, -0.037522464990615845, -0.004102902952581644, -0.1351635754108429, 0.013042762875556946, 0.05740297585725784, -0.04329938441514969, -0.02553803287446499, -0.011173274368047714, -0.021761411800980568, -0.005798570811748505, 0.020861102268099785, 0.014531640335917473, -0.05533292517066002, 0.04824283346533775, -0.006047448609024286, 0.02628505602478981, 0.04319467023015022, -0.0020570706110447645, -0.01706160604953766, 0.007229657378047705, 0.005957223474979401, -0.02099595218896866, 0.027061037719249725, -0.04671502113342285, 0.026894107460975647, -0.0011716984445229173, 0.027770938351750374, 0.01597275771200657, 0.018101291730999947, -0.03627607226371765, 0.022961102426052094, 0.005283722188323736, 0.08337618410587311, -0.05391058698296547, -0.004008117131888866, 0.05615592002868652, -0.050266560167074203, 0.0012692464515566826, -0.00487638171762228, -0.019134560599923134, -0.03443737328052521, -0.005305732600390911, -0.02715640515089035, 0.022903356701135635, -0.01229003630578518, 0.007564069703221321, 0.006655788980424404, -0.034259941428899765, 0.05030597001314163, -0.018021253868937492, -0.0018912958912551403, 0.015878116711974144, -0.02028154768049717, 0.05674537271261215, 0.07877171039581299, 0.049955155700445175, -0.018471432849764824, -0.001959000714123249, 0.039370570331811905, -0.024829385802149773, 0.013401546515524387, 0.012123449705541134, -0.029185378924012184, -0.016102313995361328, -0.007513643242418766, 0.024935146793723106, 0.023722952231764793, -0.031313493847846985, -0.015868807211518288, 0.01729532517492771, -0.026691734790802002, 0.011061757802963257, -0.022502578794956207, -0.08266127109527588, 0.01237687561661005, -0.015007550828158855, 0.0009887776104733348, 0.010972973890602589, 0.03142213076353073, 0.06252369284629822, 0.04214960336685181, 0.005389147903770208, -0.0035430549178272486, -0.04540378972887993, -0.00009896911797113717, -0.05258945748209953, -0.06681528687477112, 0.0122492341324687, 0.05252501368522644, -0.013744844123721123, 0.026934748515486717, -0.02831117808818817, -0.020142454653978348, -0.041551850736141205, -0.024706117808818817, -0.007483734283596277, 0.008324136026203632, 0.05023392662405968, 0.03345872461795807, 0.06194422021508217, 0.002803788287565112, -0.09903644025325775, 0.004500718787312508, -0.04011926427483559, 0.005759845022112131, -0.017659109085798264, 0.009816166013479233, -0.0032957158982753754, -0.027607383206486702, -0.02723490633070469, 0.021642616018652916, 0.006631931755691767, 0.013979058712720871, 0.013014017604291439, 0.03365154564380646, -0.003928953316062689, 0.0000513071718160063, 0.0022673234343528748, 0.0023936033248901367, -0.087797611951828, 0.007515476085245609, 0.028518090024590492, 0.006114872172474861, -0.00739058293402195, -0.012918924912810326, 0.007156045641750097, -0.04521939158439636, 0.0483819916844368, -0.020045064389705658, -0.0011975457891821861, -0.028577953577041626, -0.04692423343658447, -0.0340115949511528, 0.026704609394073486, -0.022585246711969376, -0.013402585871517658, 0.013467087410390377, 0.013459422625601292, -0.03468840941786766, 0.018143514171242714, 0.0549270398914814, -0.004254918545484543, 0.00571669964119792, -0.0022989034187048674, -0.013039108365774155, -0.0032505090348422527, 0.02926977537572384, 0.03407018259167671, -0.010086243972182274, 0.0011497684754431248, -0.07089775800704956, 0.002246318617835641, 0.03316377475857735, -0.03344263508915901, -0.017191516235470772, 0.009772447869181633, 0.011008432134985924, 0.007531730458140373, -0.05031846836209297, -0.014120897278189659, -0.09496969729661942, -0.039328500628471375, -0.036904025822877884, -0.027402417734265327, 0.03629808500409126, -0.06028416007757187, -0.04573637992143631, -0.026564912870526314, 0.03917006030678749, -0.04794941842556, 0.04996337741613388, -0.014764049090445042, -0.03366212546825409, -0.07692686468362808, 0.024534180760383606, 0.027622582390904427, -0.01660638116300106, -0.0009014915558509529, 0.051319267600774765, -0.004713540896773338, 0.015555834397673607, -0.032790280878543854, -0.03260346129536629, 0.03445836901664734, 0.023456204682588577, 0.0037133905570954084, 0.004561013076454401, -0.008980252780020237, 0.0319831557571888, 0.014617608860135078, -0.0501025915145874, -0.07599791139364243, -0.008437071926891804, -0.01635235920548439, 0.05463917553424835, -0.0060924384742975235, 0.03477045148611069, 0.048921242356300354, 0.008210851810872555, 0.00205592205747962, -0.05483904108405113, 0.010778151452541351, -0.061400577425956726, -0.014840949326753616, 0.018064111471176147, 0.002621730789542198, -0.03344668075442314, 0.009544937871396542, 0.025734035298228264 ]
<p>Recently I attended a workshop on probability, I was asked the following question but I did not find a way to solve it. A discussion on this question can help to learn something new.</p> <p>We were told that, We are guests in a game show and close to win a great fortune. The quiz master asks us to choose one of three (closed) doors. She explains that behind one of them awaits you a million Euros. Once you fixed your choice the quiz mastress opens one of the other doors and shows you that this was only a goat. She gives you a final chance: you may either retain your door or switch to the remaining closed one.</p> <blockquote> <p>(i) Say door 3 is opened. How can we Calculate the conditional probability that our door is the winning one given that the door 3 is a fail, and its complement.</p> <p>(ii) How to Calculate the unconditional probability that our door is the winning one, and its complement.</p> </blockquote> <p>Thank you in advance.</p>
g49611
[ -0.015466888435184956, 0.03727004677057266, 0.022353651002049446, 0.006918045692145824, -0.012080523185431957, 0.004808666184544563, 0.05722741782665253, 0.022876262664794922, -0.015376687981188297, -0.01871662586927414, -0.012965237721800804, 0.06254903972148895, 0.025645671412348747, 0.01055457815527916, -0.019513670355081558, 0.026188600808382034, 0.0760720744729042, -0.02000601775944233, 0.0365886390209198, 0.060272328555583954, -0.03397073224186897, 0.039995431900024414, -0.04922104254364967, -0.0058598811738193035, -0.07012549042701721, -0.07421687245368958, -0.008389027789235115, 0.024221325293183327, -0.06436187028884888, 0.013392342254519463, -0.07102614641189575, 0.016452742740511894, 0.037209007889032364, -0.0553646981716156, -0.006024348083883524, 0.03625090792775154, 0.07564789056777954, 0.010116798803210258, -0.02584739401936531, 0.019707011058926582, 0.015201002359390259, -0.013011684641242027, -0.0026155211962759495, 0.010121768340468407, -0.022455142810940742, 0.0017519069369882345, -0.009053247049450874, -0.024813544005155563, 0.10460802912712097, 0.001047910307534039, -0.04424197971820831, 0.05863343924283981, 0.02930592931807041, -0.027474960312247276, -0.050216685980558395, 0.03783850744366646, 0.009544824250042439, -0.03345419466495514, 0.02636486478149891, 0.037524253129959106, 0.0426531657576561, -0.08777990192174911, 0.05830693244934082, 0.02619430422782898, 0.028836041688919067, 0.006950036156922579, 0.01579444482922554, 0.09080658107995987, -0.004374723415821791, -0.023264549672603607, -0.028473779559135437, -0.07124050706624985, 0.045282505452632904, -0.04817386716604233, 0.01927386224269867, 0.04362337291240692, 0.007164838258177042, 0.007421571761369705, 0.05829084292054176, 0.05842164531350136, -0.08937469124794006, -0.037275563925504684, 0.026282988488674164, 0.027144774794578552, 0.0015855584060773253, 0.058958809822797775, -0.03815489262342453, -0.025539502501487732, -0.07864535599946976, 0.0010738957207649946, 0.05262509360909462, 0.020386185497045517, 0.06006702035665512, 0.01628742553293705, -0.016946375370025635, 0.11385592073202133, -0.06775928288698196, 0.058041542768478394, 0.022097840905189514, 0.0033875491935759783, 0.04178453981876373, -0.03731926530599594, 0.010634015314280987, -0.018717575818300247, -0.07241685688495636, 0.04665732756257057, 0.01699236035346985, 0.033035919070243835, -0.05004081130027771, 0.03417614847421646, -0.0695992261171341, -0.02798389457166195, -0.005604017525911331, -0.04865507408976555, -0.009406854398548603, 0.010243374854326248, 0.03167368099093437, 0.0306698065251112, 0.021408824250102043, 0.010627702809870243, -0.02799336612224579, 0.055339615792036057, -0.02634432166814804, 0.011024368926882744, -0.005704811308532953, 0.0012191026471555233, -0.04665002599358559, 0.05538233742117882, 0.052668411284685135, 0.00234519736841321, -0.002158518647775054, 0.06957213580608368, 0.08926687389612198, 0.05497923493385315, 0.0091685950756073, 0.056431062519550323, 0.021768007427453995, 0.024885110557079315, 0.017562679946422577, -0.016692031174898148, -0.059561677277088165, 0.06016850098967552, 0.010061850771307945, 0.04989442601799965, -0.030116098001599312, 0.016476407647132874, 0.05472612380981445, -0.013486355543136597, -0.03448747470974922, -0.0008680368191562593, 0.0017619251739233732, 0.01403485331684351, -0.017329614609479904, -0.012522458098828793, 0.012727814726531506, -0.036149270832538605, -0.013340843841433525, -0.018195535987615585, -0.02773984707891941, 0.014241822995245457, 0.01551991980522871, -0.025542443618178368, -0.04253583773970604, -0.004320736043155193, -0.04073454067111015, -0.006667091976851225, 0.046316735446453094, -0.007139763329178095, -0.03080063685774803, -0.010997198522090912, 0.016495266929268837, -0.0433933362364769, 0.033724986016750336, 0.03529379889369011, 0.01297091320157051, -0.009197507984936237, -0.013172028586268425, -0.0429435595870018, -0.03486664965748787, -0.0012652284931391478, 0.029270220547914505, 0.009304980747401714, 0.05889268219470978, 0.009255942888557911, 0.004361363593488932, -0.011714638210833073, 0.05283200368285179, 0.06305854022502899, -0.06501493602991104, 0.007858864031732082, -0.027672696858644485, -0.047112368047237396, 0.01591729372739792, 0.013206716626882553, -0.0037039287853986025, -0.0029905447736382484, 0.036736056208610535, 0.01682938076555729, 0.011198467575013638, 0.0033345860429108143, 0.04712768271565437, 0.02769027091562748, 0.025853130966424942, 0.03159669041633606, -0.021746471524238586, 0.06089947745203972, -0.0027017537504434586, 0.024598173797130585, 0.012884012423455715, -0.03465785086154938, 0.00518251396715641, -0.021665092557668686, -0.03654666617512703, -0.003785941516980529, -0.008062805980443954, 0.013217576779425144, 0.008175688795745373, -0.0029519449453800917, -0.000023628615963389166, -0.07671137899160385, -0.009930593892931938, 0.0248784888535738, 0.03210417181253433, 0.03588122874498367, -0.04872078076004982, 0.11156292259693146, -0.033006977289915085, -0.024754110723733902, -0.01385870948433876, 0.030225206166505814, -0.024760492146015167, -0.039387378841638565, -0.043744418770074844, -0.026736849918961525, 0.03188823536038399, 0.021234190091490746, 0.011838935315608978, 0.08970004320144653, 0.0250520221889019, 0.03675638884305954, 0.029037540778517723, -0.02492828667163849, -0.04430672153830528, 0.009258369915187359, -0.0166030190885067, -0.08240045607089996, -0.027852721512317657, -0.02711033634841442, 0.033032048493623734, 0.09345695376396179, -0.03458595275878906, -0.030701447278261185, -0.01473337970674038, -0.04438029229640961, -0.031969957053661346, -0.009164410643279552, -0.062214646488428116, 0.0003799053083639592, 0.02260459028184414, -0.008096028119325638, 0.018634403124451637, -0.044220805168151855, 0.036665014922618866, -0.004615762270987034, 0.02008998766541481, -0.02860102429986, -0.03181616961956024, -0.01687696948647499, 0.012345418334007263, 0.04730943962931633, 0.025207454338669777, 0.0857105404138565, -0.022201308980584145, -0.006448700558394194, 0.03575107455253601, -0.02761664427816868, -0.014673789031803608, -0.006461158394813538, 0.03256197273731232, 0.021216735243797302, 0.005270129535347223, 0.023424608632922173, -0.021193120628595352, 0.005121193826198578, -0.03052685596048832, -0.004730380140244961, 0.03751961514353752, 0.03947442024946213, 0.03547417372465134, 0.05504951626062393, -0.02091413550078869, 0.05946812033653259, -0.005712492857128382, 0.033352021127939224, 0.05576491728425026, 0.02139722742140293, -0.02469446510076523, 0.0127235883846879, -0.016504179686307907, -0.011212531477212906, -0.052859168499708176, -0.008604301139712334, -0.028477298095822334, -0.02683287113904953, 0.009013628587126732, 0.03375892713665962, 0.0008916478836908937, 0.023820798844099045, 0.030690783634781837, -0.012000836431980133, -0.041118718683719635, 0.022040976211428642, -0.01968132145702839, -0.07384806126356125, 0.005398578010499477, -0.008405916392803192, -0.007273232098668814, 0.07436194270849228, -0.01799963042140007, -0.041228748857975006, -0.0503520593047142, 0.0535057857632637, -0.043510012328624725, -0.025696150958538055, 0.027493875473737717, 0.02856755629181862, -0.04992733523249626, 0.018555419519543648, -0.01983007602393627, -0.03765714168548584, 0.023607078939676285, 0.06279158592224121, -0.03119768761098385, -0.028830645605921745, -0.018347015604376793, -0.024691812694072723, 0.07814384996891022, -0.03778024762868881, -0.011315406300127506, 0.06998252868652344, 0.11791583895683289, 0.0012649731943383813, -0.01922297477722168, 0.01245896890759468, -0.053049106150865555, 0.02151935175061226, 0.05508102849125862, 0.006728199310600758, 0.04108741506934166, 0.003808140754699707, -0.018717946484684944, -0.05127320811152458, 0.018988873809576035, 0.03852156549692154, 0.0205704178661108, 0.06794638186693192, -0.0889856144785881, -0.012473667040467262, -0.036336977034807205, 0.0878017470240593, 0.007516082376241684, -0.0363859124481678, -0.03188692405819893, -0.024481136351823807, 0.039950404316186905, 0.042677510529756546, 0.02987818419933319, 0.034330107271671295, 0.048225823789834976, 0.005554657429456711, 0.027785688638687134, -0.032861024141311646, -0.0003858325944747776, 0.027461916208267212, 0.04895121604204178, -0.028015052899718285, -0.03949439898133278, -0.003736549522727728, -0.014721809886395931, 0.022404812276363373, 0.0034952887799590826, 0.0662575289607048, 0.05042344331741333, -0.044817909598350525, 0.04010091722011566, -0.016580792143940926, 0.005572252906858921, -0.04925227537751198, -0.010514918714761734, -0.044289812445640564, -0.019950145855545998, -0.0030803955160081387, -0.07092038542032242, 0.06913664191961288, 0.016641007736325264, 0.017546439543366432, 0.015379033982753754, -0.014893325977027416, -0.031423166394233704, -0.004279275890439749, 0.008485366590321064, 0.025021428242325783, -0.0002931295020971447, -0.04911265894770622, 0.019511913880705833, 0.00831820722669363, 0.00401923805475235, 0.010310599580407143, 0.025252511724829674, 0.011319124139845371, 0.025536352768540382, 0.028306152671575546, -0.04875773936510086, 0.011810009367763996, 0.015795614570379257, 0.00928196869790554, 0.06646728515625, -0.005708749871701002, -0.014361082576215267, -0.0344635471701622, -0.004054993391036987, 0.013234448619186878, -0.011473791673779488, -0.03846859559416771, -0.006160067394375801, -0.030781831592321396, 0.020429691299796104, -0.018494702875614166, 0.05090256407856941, 0.05021587759256363, 0.02795453928411007, 0.011117148213088512, -0.006437996402382851, 0.021005850285291672, -0.004780156537890434, -0.03519109636545181, -0.01777666248381138, -0.03624238818883896, -0.006345811299979687, -0.03831709921360016, 0.008635509759187698, -0.029755854979157448, -0.04324767366051674, -0.02456614188849926, -0.003029279178008437, 0.009850350208580494, 0.005830512847751379, -0.01907220482826233, 0.05575830489397049, -0.031522028148174286, -0.016507688909769058, 0.0033443670254200697, -0.02913614735007286, 0.007760302629321814, 0.008376582525670528, 0.019758766517043114, -0.042746372520923615, 0.03506786376237869, 0.04670442268252373, 0.023702004924416542, -0.02868037298321724, 0.0001082299932022579, -0.009213508106768131, 0.04639559984207153, 0.02373068779706955, 0.04088505357503891, 0.007888752035796642, 0.008682239800691605, -0.0005284592625685036, 0.017008081078529358, -0.00554233742877841, 0.05020058527588844, 0.014517685398459435, 0.012518287636339664, -0.04064968600869179, 0.016061309725046158, -0.0202214103192091, 0.02407149225473404, 0.05860373005270958, -0.022187715396285057, 0.015035868622362614, -0.04084872454404831, -0.011496064253151417, -0.03514419496059418, -0.005565389059484005, -0.024094315245747566, -0.019828952848911285, -0.07331926375627518, -0.026693204417824745, -0.08500935137271881, 0.03859725594520569, 0.007665589917451143, 0.03466092050075531, 0.012556291185319424, -0.028163526207208633, -0.054416194558143616, 0.01655513606965542, 0.012588463723659515, 0.03441021963953972, -0.03006887435913086, -0.06667329370975494, 0.009767814539372921, -0.011829515919089317, 0.032427120953798294, -0.003650795668363571, 0.04020824283361435, -0.0793677270412445, 0.007908524945378304, 0.034301694482564926, 0.07329386472702026, -0.021264059469103813, -0.007574319373816252, 0.007264460902661085, 0.00494103878736496, 0.0007582852267660201, -0.002660206751897931, -0.022741151973605156, -0.07920078933238983, -0.010966835543513298, 0.059466321021318436, 0.04078513756394386, 0.03123471327126026, -0.005840759724378586, -0.013245399110019207, -0.03139470890164375, -0.039830293506383896, -0.08568843454122543, -0.08284949511289597, -0.02706855535507202, -0.013738849200308323, -0.015766281634569168, 0.018382616341114044, -0.024813994765281677, -0.018887579441070557, -0.05175463855266571, 0.007325655315071344, 0.011663146317005157, -0.04324987158179283, -0.006490415893495083, -0.007133764214813709, -0.029726309701800346, 0.0046417610719799995, 0.03823770582675934, 0.03754563257098198, 0.006118411663919687, -0.04602400213479996, -0.055206261575222015, -0.027581697329878807, -0.034733615815639496, -0.01883538067340851, 0.020876849070191383, 0.004705466330051422, -0.012622863985598087, -0.02892824448645115, 0.05640358850359917, -0.06896965205669403, -0.01703391969203949, -0.026432666927576065, 0.025704775005578995, -0.00018794226343743503, -0.014315442182123661, -0.04349223151803017, -0.014164384454488754, -0.005894164554774761, 0.02212025411427021, -0.029023021459579468, -0.09119570255279541, 0.011753253638744354, -0.027460599318146706, 0.03517855703830719, -0.008514209650456905, -0.052388086915016174, -0.054061222821474075, -0.020127149298787117, 0.019723592326045036, 0.009413951076567173, -0.02023005299270153, -0.06257379800081253, 0.003367508063092828, -0.024902204051613808, -0.030489925295114517, -0.0425424724817276, -0.0026138764806091785, -0.03727138414978981, -0.05874849483370781, 0.060238830745220184, -0.016614923253655434, 0.006227248348295689, -0.04954899102449417, 0.029193812981247902, -0.008322956040501595, 0.004393764305859804, 0.021785033866763115, -0.004319973289966583, 0.03116137906908989, 0.017053578048944473, -0.021002912893891335, 0.015181130729615688, -0.018134597688913345, 0.01576906442642212, -0.032754719257354736, 0.03586844354867935, 0.02390439063310623, 0.013026916421949863, 0.013073100708425045, 0.05897536873817444, -0.004443562589585781, 0.03859664127230644, 0.007608832325786352, -0.02507168985903263, 0.01826166734099388, 0.03202648088335991, 0.052453674376010895, 0.01688586361706257, -0.0369732566177845, 0.006249226629734039, -0.016758223995566368, -0.03533705696463585, 0.02435409091413021, -0.013413829728960991, -0.0015061378944665194, -0.004977799486368895, -0.001247155829332769, -0.03677574172616005, 0.005323241464793682, 0.025602249428629875, -0.030749471858143806, -0.06472369283437729, 0.04075859114527702, -0.00011407536658225581, -0.013185912743210793, -0.046395380049943924, -0.004879805259406567, -0.017565174028277397, -0.05696358159184456, 0.026899462565779686, -0.05309385433793068, 0.055262934416532516, -0.05975613743066788, 0.07938112318515778, -0.00026788140530698, -0.008153824135661125, 0.016492657363414764, 0.04082988575100899, 0.04209885373711586, -0.03724061697721481, 0.03217366710305214, -0.017615150660276413, -0.010232599452137947, -0.006892222911119461, 0.021662721410393715, 0.005975134205073118, -0.018407726660370827, -0.016687963157892227, -0.04481227323412895, 0.021333122625947, 0.0574614517390728, 0.0019839454907923937, -0.030530698597431183, 0.0074167815037071705, -0.005585733335465193, -0.06905937194824219, -0.051794666796922684, 0.01075667329132557, -0.02126462571322918, 0.009056254290044308, 0.005753879435360432, -0.041999027132987976, -0.031415581703186035, -0.03235543146729469, -0.0227753147482872, 0.015940533950924873, -0.10925645381212234, 0.03271793946623802, -0.03642920032143593, -0.03605533763766289, 0.034450702369213104, 0.05767537280917168, 0.029177334159612656, -0.03738255426287651, 0.005034109111875296, 0.03312167897820473, -0.06484944373369217, -0.01732746511697769, 0.04425632208585739, -0.01715806871652603, -0.015375516377389431, -0.01402661669999361, 0.054921627044677734, -0.01763436198234558, 0.014691963791847229, -0.03261392191052437, 0.05488993600010872, -0.0038777317386120558, -0.032703105360269547, -0.045496080070734024, 0.009651224128901958, 0.042983993887901306, 0.03177672624588013, 0.020643554627895355, 0.020881444215774536, 0.04826949164271355, -0.024182254448533058, 0.012439783662557602, -0.014495749026536942, 0.002120689256116748, -0.05411039665341377, 0.03507903963327408, -0.042260199785232544, -0.025145119056105614, 0.039180345833301544, 0.004645812325179577, -0.0486360564827919, 0.02571522444486618, -0.0077394116669893265, -0.04063153639435768, 0.013102661818265915, 0.017997071146965027, 0.05831921473145485, 0.013302305713295937, 0.009181053377687931, -0.05661039799451828, -0.03237428143620491, 0.04942120984196663, -0.034208036959171295, -0.04321281239390373, -0.04949089139699936, -0.029880378395318985, -0.01485474780201912, 0.07925498485565186, -0.0018374331993982196, -0.0499277301132679, -0.015045659616589546, 0.0017576355021446943, 0.07197073101997375, -0.042203389108181, -0.0012106053764000535, -0.04276242107152939, 0.005463612265884876, 0.04775852710008621, -0.03254508599638939, -0.006899268366396427, 0.044449906796216965, -0.01859072782099247, 0.00692373001947999, -0.009899073280394077, -0.10026834160089493, 0.004418809432536364, 0.020916776731610298, 0.04781371355056763, -0.04249121621251106, -0.03947332128882408, -0.0292869471013546, 0.026476098224520683, 0.044705722481012344, -0.0128805972635746, -0.02416708506643772, 0.00855532567948103, 0.05097099021077156, -0.0140386912971735, -0.02437835931777954, -0.0038729349616914988, -0.022164838388562202, -0.0573914498090744, -0.011268029920756817, -0.03408351540565491, 0.02788890153169632, 0.02763952687382698 ]
<p>Let $X_1, X_2, ..., X_n$ be a random iid sample from a population with mean $\theta$.</p> <p>Now I am wondering about the intuition behind $E(X_1| \overline X ) = \overline X$, the sample mean.</p> <p>If we just consider $X_1$ (or any $X_i$ for that matter) we have that $E(X_1) = \theta$ as the expected value of any random observation from a population will be the population mean.</p> <p>Now given that we know $\overline X$ how come that changes what we expect to get for $X_1$? $X_1$ is still the same random observation from the population as before...but it seems that knowing the sample mean 'overrides' what we expect to get for an observation...is this correct?</p>
g74333
[ -0.018572857603430748, 0.020228495821356773, -0.010465344414114952, -0.019813891500234604, 0.021293284371495247, -0.02541072480380535, 0.04207896441221237, 0.0064172702841460705, -0.04838424175977707, -0.05690377578139305, 0.011104023084044456, 0.04353964328765869, 0.02767866477370262, -0.0000623694431851618, 0.020525122061371803, 0.0009939164156094193, 0.04739699885249138, 0.014409284107387066, 0.05007120966911316, 0.025981370359659195, -0.070368193089962, -0.026197072118520737, -0.0035591975320130587, 0.010615560226142406, 0.014745060354471207, -0.09026028215885162, 0.025326712056994438, 0.03629719093441963, -0.03789419308304787, 0.02446841262280941, -0.02737407758831978, -0.025962769985198975, 0.048188794404268265, -0.04950738698244095, -0.058400582522153854, -0.02146395854651928, 0.05643601343035698, 0.005076524335891008, 0.04037722200155258, -0.021701477468013763, 0.007064185105264187, 0.0654238909482956, 0.048383790999650955, -0.022033248096704483, 0.013120791874825954, 0.014709451235830784, -0.035285450518131256, 0.03456263616681099, -0.02048308029770851, -0.012584155425429344, -0.0038468081038445234, 0.01283313985913992, 0.017247209325432777, 0.021397238597273827, 0.00260614394210279, -0.011631427332758904, 0.045492541044950485, -0.04889106750488281, -0.0006944600027054548, 0.016220062971115112, -0.04216890409588814, -0.02446790039539337, -0.046453043818473816, 0.03622071444988251, 0.023134445771574974, 0.057191118597984314, 0.019028693437576294, 0.027750946581363678, 0.021022411063313484, 0.03726792335510254, 0.01373333390802145, -0.03584860637784004, -0.024924559518694878, -0.04549504444003105, -0.019440244883298874, -0.020729180425405502, 0.0220931489020586, 0.03197338804602623, 0.021167419850826263, 0.016947196796536446, 0.021177472546696663, 0.012053931131958961, -0.0231034979224205, 0.057505302131175995, 0.04126368463039398, 0.04896453768014908, 0.062133800238370895, -0.005856527481228113, -0.0029460974037647247, 0.02476775459945202, 0.0306701622903347, -0.07723305374383926, 0.012787410989403725, 0.028606515377759933, 0.010948413982987404, -0.029536595568060875, -0.04143057391047478, -0.04223925992846489, -0.014150183647871017, -0.012048278003931046, 0.0036614977288991213, 0.03822626173496246, 0.013409717939794064, -0.042896389961242676, -0.039167437702417374, 0.036718983203172684, 0.07686644792556763, 0.05555817484855652, 0.01894313283264637, -0.05513821914792061, -0.026287157088518143, -0.01457916758954525, -0.008965280838310719, 0.0070508322678506374, -0.04273759946227074, -0.007420543115586042, -0.01274221483618021, 0.11379364132881165, -0.01556339580565691, 0.006540635600686073, 0.03470125049352646, -0.015837514773011208, 0.022675957530736923, 0.09123009443283081, -0.042910486459732056, 0.04324847087264061, 0.005118050612509251, 0.011552727781236172, 0.022140460088849068, 0.0062831188552081585, -0.04815332964062691, 0.0065742614679038525, 0.0012834703084081411, 0.007267757318913937, 0.00960599072277546, 0.03449864685535431, -0.04523808881640434, 0.07048729062080383, 0.014660358428955078, -0.024713097140192986, 0.00678759953007102, 0.051107048988342285, 0.020958390086889267, -0.055864367634058, -0.03491976484656334, 0.017118578776717186, 0.029111817479133606, -0.047538403421640396, -0.018322449177503586, 0.030905941501259804, -0.014815691858530045, 0.03694387152791023, -0.025392824783921242, 0.02855909988284111, -0.023972179740667343, 0.009349430911242962, -0.010194165632128716, 0.027876820415258408, -0.05069064721465111, -0.03064802661538124, 0.02773864194750786, 0.002289588563144207, -0.031095001846551895, 0.01742354780435562, -0.02672751620411873, -0.04921892285346985, 0.05000404641032219, -0.06103689223527908, -0.06128089874982834, -0.02465558797121048, 0.018604200333356857, -0.018589701503515244, 0.02735191024839878, -0.030384840443730354, 0.0011907094158232212, 0.026252953335642815, 0.03414135426282883, -0.030529413372278214, 0.03475143760442734, 0.024169757962226868, -0.018064239993691444, -0.011065184138715267, 0.021878857165575027, -0.05477277934551239, 0.030624667182564735, 0.03565597906708717, -0.02543957531452179, 0.0024863407015800476, 0.0025370826479047537, 0.014172048307955265, 0.018379289656877518, -0.0025441579055041075, -0.020446984097361565, 0.019523801282048225, 0.004334866069257259, 0.014353007078170776, 0.015644187107682228, -0.049192242324352264, -0.038759369403123856, 0.02661566250026226, 0.02618740312755108, -0.011583360843360424, -0.039956919848918915, 0.037796471267938614, -0.07775361835956573, 0.012750884518027306, 0.030480550602078438, 0.002040599472820759, 0.011721543036401272, 0.06286783516407013, -0.010729752480983734, -0.04396861791610718, -0.045485008507966995, 0.012657752260565758, -0.0055316658690571785, 0.03708906099200249, 0.06786522269248962, -0.0011938068782910705, 0.003987960051745176, -0.0386163592338562, 0.009683441370725632, -0.036800701171159744, 0.0534532330930233, -0.004738937132060528, -0.00033948427881114185, 0.008139004930853844, 0.02109632082283497, -0.0402958020567894, 0.01987237110733986, 0.05624674633145332, -0.04228543862700462, -0.030306866392493248, -0.01553651038557291, 0.020684707909822464, 0.027457769960165024, 0.02335156500339508, 0.004559173248708248, 0.006161717232316732, 0.025743354111909866, -0.030149249359965324, 0.018371200188994408, -0.06769323348999023, -0.03653039410710335, 0.0025242287665605545, -0.014162350445985794, 0.005497730802744627, -0.0005831739981658757, 0.01075727865099907, -0.007493200711905956, 0.01276099868118763, -0.03416876494884491, 0.017544269561767578, 0.02809182181954384, 0.0015902684535831213, 0.05178764835000038, -0.07406309992074966, -0.0251251682639122, 0.004559856373816729, -0.00401128176599741, 0.02155662328004837, -0.029871976003050804, -0.01661905087530613, -0.02341148443520069, 0.0025840525049716234, 0.00999407283961773, 0.003913777880370617, 0.027690624818205833, 0.028612598776817322, -0.01828560046851635, -0.02114974707365036, -0.011959774419665337, 0.036075230687856674, -0.019997572526335716, 0.09949196130037308, 0.04321015253663063, -0.05400259420275688, -0.061108432710170746, -0.034479137510061264, 0.0814414769411087, -0.03564174473285675, -0.027003783732652664, -0.017518039792776108, -0.06215427443385124, 0.06461869925260544, 0.04371865466237068, -0.04182339087128639, -0.008004668168723583, -0.03527381271123886, -0.008537630550563335, -0.008996766060590744, -0.0036094558890908957, 0.010743140242993832, 0.02951519750058651, -0.03174334391951561, 0.02336750738322735, -0.06568535417318344, -0.038466256111860275, -0.0019881546031683683, 0.02963872067630291, 0.02767403982579708, -0.0649203285574913, 0.009226699359714985, -0.04015948995947838, -0.012937412597239017, 0.08370506763458252, 0.010257352143526077, -0.014248179271817207, -0.029732467606663704, -0.02963395044207573, -0.01802658662199974, 0.024289211258292198, -0.04864518716931343, -0.04336368292570114, -0.010937376879155636, -0.056644976139068604, 0.002992294728755951, -0.06774713099002838, 0.014434196054935455, -0.0066317287273705006, -0.02323991432785988, -0.016889335587620735, 0.03185329586267471, -0.039348844438791275, 0.06001061946153641, -0.013624051585793495, -0.04571269825100899, -0.06957907974720001, 0.03368409723043442, -0.01855788193643093, 0.04084853082895279, 0.05160517618060112, 0.048114944249391556, -0.01949443109333515, -0.03361629694700241, 0.0027261516079306602, 0.012744927778840065, -0.07059798389673233, 0.05428073927760124, 0.010090691037476063, -0.016671476885676384, 0.00363183137960732, -0.013684287667274475, -0.011077691800892353, -0.003416880499571562, 0.009763968177139759, -0.04563945159316063, 0.06213555112481117, -0.015108685940504074, 0.0021066816989332438, 0.022414684295654297, 0.047115977853536606, 0.03933408483862877, 0.015125089325010777, -0.005010839551687241, 0.049752574414014816, 0.04721818491816521, 0.08129493147134781, -0.0002487341989763081, 0.012723560445010662, 0.013082839548587799, 0.0413089394569397, -0.05348377302289009, -0.0019289341289550066, -0.010232612490653992, 0.027822641655802727, 0.0006551414262503386, 0.010260541923344135, 0.03313163295388222, 0.030641837045550346, -0.01197859924286604, -0.050916727632284164, -0.022069599479436874, 0.02108941040933132, 0.0027904585003852844, -0.01897847279906273, -0.041395533829927444, 0.08573867380619049, 0.05645546689629555, 0.027292679995298386, 0.019448058679699898, 0.03718157485127449, -0.03444897383451462, -0.04003450274467468, -0.05432324483990669, 0.022012142464518547, 0.002954430878162384, -0.00011264416389167309, -0.028402745723724365, -0.05910775065422058, -0.06286149471998215, -0.023397190496325493, -0.07674520462751389, -0.02329936809837818, 0.00626767473295331, 0.025708191096782684, -0.02819773368537426, 0.019041448831558228, -0.015224761329591274, 0.010387939400970936, -0.023596826940774918, -0.019742436707019806, -0.03473604843020439, 0.014853563159704208, 0.012644262053072453, 0.004743814002722502, -0.008746782317757607, 0.0564161017537117, -0.01631665974855423, -0.008183115161955357, -0.04617629200220108, -0.01762494072318077, 0.0018135816790163517, -0.020229319110512733, -0.05008132755756378, 0.04211015999317169, 0.03434491902589798, 0.0268668532371521, -0.007754040881991386, -0.044249095022678375, -0.03447086364030838, -0.06495321542024612, -0.06882401555776596, 0.03936675190925598, -0.00684007816016674, -0.03866814821958542, 0.07264373451471329, -0.02475292980670929, -0.010230889543890953, -0.009890994988381863, -0.04957892373204231, -0.04741992801427841, 0.031873177736997604, -0.013175064697861671, -0.014716589823365211, -0.006462624296545982, -0.017167914658784866, 0.019765062257647514, 0.029145890846848488, -0.07340256869792938, -0.052466101944446564, 0.027889609336853027, -0.01638803258538246, -0.06527018547058105, -0.012547122314572334, 0.043259184807538986, -0.015439026057720184, -0.025927100330591202, 0.01000366173684597, 0.01586829498410225, 0.04164065420627594, -0.010551964864134789, 0.025173058733344078, 0.00026693689869716763, -0.019192427396774292, 0.07968446612358093, -0.0920405313372612, -0.01569032296538353, 0.023582201451063156, -0.016520416364073753, 0.0017808352131396532, -0.03728241100907326, -0.05756236985325813, -0.008769171312451363, 0.009461643174290657, 0.022163020446896553, -0.007513709366321564, -0.07133491337299347, -0.04201351851224899, 0.01181601919233799, 0.05723951756954193, -0.03497235104441643, 0.0029928910080343485, 0.04184628278017044, -0.0035966059658676386, -0.0007334852707572281, 0.01127623300999403, -0.06750492751598358, 0.014479207806289196, 0.0017230095108971, -0.07265409827232361, -0.06618456542491913, -0.030126472935080528, 0.039689287543296814, -0.01849343627691269, 0.014167232438921928, -0.011219856329262257, -0.010942671447992325, -0.03704417124390602, 0.025644153356552124, 0.02392820082604885, -0.013882176950573921, 0.02015017904341221, 0.047216884791851044, 0.04483157396316528, -0.02385547012090683, -0.08679652959108353, -0.004565338604152203, -0.0014765314990654588, 0.036407049745321274, -0.036316730082035065, -0.05910590663552284, 0.04281989857554436, -0.00855168141424656, 0.01615029200911522, -0.00735133420675993, 0.023813733831048012, 0.012532772496342659, -0.03163282573223114, -0.07777190953493118, 0.03136936202645302, -0.006755021866410971, 0.018803730607032776, 0.053030043840408325, 0.004535046871751547, 0.013214224018156528, 0.039345867931842804, -0.05224640294909477, -0.023567726835608482, -0.02652141824364662, 0.006301323417574167, 0.04132731631398201, 0.0038604747969657183, 0.021461348980665207, -0.020966483280062675, -0.017008334398269653, -0.040859442204236984, -0.0064814528450369835, -0.013923116959631443, -0.0027904538437724113, -0.0009204141679219902, -0.008672588504850864, 0.024610068649053574, -0.01763993129134178, -0.023291362449526787, 0.027708156034350395, 0.035446178168058395, -0.026820814236998558, 0.03689108416438103, 0.05759984999895096, 0.04489913582801819, 0.05081288143992424, 0.010450029745697975, 0.0511527955532074, -0.018592458218336105, 0.039423618465662, 0.030507780611515045, -0.04552944377064705, 0.03874677047133446, -0.0011115201050415635, -0.05997949466109276, 0.031348492950201035, 0.004356450866907835, -0.0018316125497221947, 0.03467218577861786, -0.04027921333909035, 0.0553143136203289, 0.05039139464497566, -0.0005321959615685046, 0.038295675069093704, 0.02205442264676094, -0.029802855104207993, -0.011617816984653473, -0.003632195992395282, 0.010296504013240337, 0.05679634213447571, 0.01744653284549713, 0.022550353780388832, 0.0019402719335630536, -0.016894495114684105, 0.020414212718605995, 0.04169587045907974, -0.02535862661898136, 0.047366753220558167, 0.028534790500998497, 0.030751582235097885, 0.060598988085985184, -0.02142798714339733, 0.005874347873032093, 0.004237534012645483, -0.05099980905652046, -0.01830347627401352, -0.04258270561695099, 0.028505608439445496, -0.008616589941084385, 0.025769758969545364, 0.06398162990808487, 0.01060378085821867, 0.00406257389113307, 0.09729401022195816, -0.0214981846511364, -0.033706728368997574, -0.05542255938053131, 0.008491621352732182, -0.06153569743037224, -0.03135867044329643, -0.007879470475018024, 0.01809328980743885, -0.09995821863412857, 0.0161436740309, -0.029625173658132553, 0.04043135046958923, -0.014091973192989826, 0.0476832389831543, -0.03352082148194313, 0.016329141333699226, -0.022053834050893784, -0.009807541035115719, 0.020819198340177536, 0.00028261946863494813, -0.0038368517998605967, -0.0020271074026823044, 0.0027160882018506527, 0.016939377412199974, 0.0835433304309845, 0.010281219147145748, -0.05808192864060402, -0.05704987794160843, 0.006218318361788988, -0.05532484129071236, 0.028733519837260246, 0.017388908192515373, -0.053179364651441574, -0.0161002054810524, 0.0007548902067355812, 0.01800580509006977, 0.02568325586616993, 0.06571072340011597, -0.009092649444937706, 0.08880163729190826, 0.0533231720328331, -0.012285720556974411, -0.015593187883496284, -0.04064304009079933, 0.0689496099948883, -0.03192021697759628, -0.012505220249295235, -0.026540318503975868, 0.07658259570598602, 0.07196105271577835, 0.0814625695347786, -0.011092943139374256, 0.07800900191068649, 0.045305781066417694, -0.049765441566705704, -0.05582193285226822, 0.031172441318631172, 0.0825883075594902, 0.03895813226699829, -0.09601951390504837, -0.014442737214267254, -0.0038344520144164562, 0.04923107847571373, -0.02133791334927082, -0.027545621618628502, -0.003029047278687358, 0.03629917651414871, 0.030500825494527817, 0.005469409748911858, 0.09944868087768555, -0.018742423504590988, -0.04723444581031799, -0.0004975476185791194, -0.06277839839458466, 0.014000562019646168, 0.014186952263116837, 0.018549419939517975, 0.05389103293418884, -0.04213164746761322, -0.07313153892755508, -0.006366419140249491, -0.05349808931350708, -0.029645025730133057, 0.012098226696252823, -0.003432651050388813, 0.00201996136456728, 0.0016585960984230042, 0.009967709891498089, 0.05895553156733513, -0.06193206459283829, 0.028489895164966583, 0.03983926400542259, -0.013530866242945194, 0.04107898846268654, -0.027810992673039436, -0.09234986454248428, 0.04156477749347687, -0.054611098021268845, -0.03862525522708893, -0.025316011160612106, -0.03633757680654526, 0.01626759022474289, -0.06889501959085464, -0.0034008617512881756, -0.012997264973819256, 0.010557642206549644, -0.0034865671768784523, -0.03811514377593994, 0.02597413957118988, 0.005624180659651756, 0.013763533905148506, 0.0017204077448695898, 0.004931210540235043, -0.040885742753744125, 0.0029048705473542213, 0.014523745514452457, -0.06473057717084885, 0.03360047936439514, -0.0853208377957344, 0.026044584810733795, -0.022763608023524284, -0.00757884606719017, -0.03856992721557617, 0.047337763011455536, 0.037123534828424454, 0.0010968107962980866, -0.026610642671585083, 0.004667289089411497, -0.020529774948954582, 0.06095565855503082, 0.02383919060230255, -0.03557214140892029, 0.05508546903729439, 0.010444460436701775, -0.01777120865881443, -0.02387584000825882, -0.004792849998921156, -0.000746005738619715, 0.030799664556980133, -0.0005861367681063712, -0.015377773903310299, -0.03636958822607994, -0.006480529438704252, -0.032099682837724686, 0.002479597693309188, 0.001401113928295672, 0.08155276626348495, 0.06851179152727127, 0.0009686616831459105, -0.07003825902938843, 0.0018830465851351619, -0.045606207102537155, 0.024877222254872322, 0.044651541858911514, -0.004527502693235874, -0.017849136143922806, 0.009848713874816895, 0.023241747170686722, -0.0177303534001112, -0.008833612315356731, 0.018286241218447685, -0.03591461479663849, 0.01444393489509821, -0.008968313224613667, 0.03022877313196659, 0.0409013032913208, -0.03264864161610603, 0.05247782915830612, -0.04530677944421768, 0.0012109004892408848, -0.045085370540618896, 0.01850944384932518, -0.047507502138614655, -0.05943477898836136, -0.008049754425883293, -0.044743262231349945, 0.013897636905312538, 0.010132125578820705, 0.04957553371787071 ]
<p>There is a situation explained below where I intend to apply MLE.</p> <p>The problem statement is that I am estimating a measure $X$. This measure is obtained my Maximum Likelihood estimation technique. </p> <p>I will apply this measure to an AR(2) model to find the parameters of AR model. The way the measure is applied and calculated is explained briefly. </p> <p>Considering a linear auto regressive (AR) model whose parameters are needed to be found that is corrupted by $\eta(t)$ white noise. </p> <p>Question : What is the effect of noise on MLE?</p>
g74334
[ -0.0010798446601256728, -0.07153740525245667, 0.011352667585015297, -0.020554106682538986, 0.04108629748225212, 0.013104467652738094, 0.0019906428642570972, 0.05957959592342377, -0.0442572720348835, 0.04481254145503044, 0.00008339826308656484, 0.024681048467755318, 0.06954196840524673, 0.05289742723107338, 0.003541170386597514, 0.0017746153753250837, 0.06932274997234344, -0.002201480558142066, -0.0270113255828619, -0.04109638184309006, 0.06496324390172958, -0.0006058220169506967, 0.034533802419900894, -0.021131515502929688, -0.004533033352345228, 0.001829245244152844, 0.0410299114882946, 0.07054564356803894, -0.04659675434231758, 0.011755907908082008, 0.015254393219947815, -0.031002452597022057, 0.05960601568222046, -0.029654163867235184, -0.02490018866956234, -0.03464072197675705, 0.07014890760183334, 0.030426297336816788, 0.00012036234693368897, -0.02238607592880726, 0.030648279935121536, 0.05065033212304115, 0.039997465908527374, 0.01771112158894539, 0.007740504574030638, 0.02661818452179432, -0.023894572630524635, -0.023424560204148293, 0.0022873729467391968, 0.0454426147043705, 0.040970638394355774, -0.035247866064310074, 0.040817148983478546, 0.009687494486570358, 0.009445145726203918, 0.024441475048661232, -0.052471939474344254, -0.012167928740382195, 0.034782737493515015, -0.00254834839142859, 0.04234669730067253, -0.009508345276117325, -0.06915897130966187, 0.014047077856957912, -0.04757578670978546, -0.021857885643839836, -0.04304944723844528, -0.013070655055344105, 0.062015142291784286, -0.00046934219426475465, 0.014330944046378136, 0.04430314153432846, 0.013722806237637997, -0.05041756480932236, -0.022400500252842903, 0.012883368879556656, 0.013032607734203339, -0.0009561291662976146, -0.0013045676751062274, 0.06478637456893921, -0.06206712871789932, -0.04060942679643631, 0.03509827330708504, 0.0006308649899438024, 0.0030067982152104378, -0.012370583601295948, 0.004818249493837357, 0.007114070933312178, -0.027051374316215515, -0.02425404265522957, -0.011555634438991547, -0.037787649780511856, 0.016892196610569954, 0.014754842035472393, -0.01580384373664856, -0.016393795609474182, -0.09465425461530685, 0.007303336169570684, -0.05441158637404442, 0.034458741545677185, -0.03290415182709694, 0.04127383232116699, 0.002173769986256957, -0.01591639034450054, -0.02092937007546425, 0.005251947790384293, 0.042768917977809906, -0.0017225194023922086, -0.004184118006378412, 0.003234029049053788, 0.01640491560101509, -0.012132334522902966, 0.02876441553235054, -0.047076813876628876, -0.06893225759267807, -0.01775730960071087, 0.06425411999225616, -0.022495029494166374, -0.014366811141371727, -0.012960496358573437, 0.06717345118522644, 0.000050995880883419886, 0.05969015508890152, -0.003755927784368396, 0.0259994063526392, 0.038264378905296326, 0.006101734470576048, 0.057799648493528366, 0.07104364782571793, 0.00656883092597127, -0.003904452547430992, -0.019267825409770012, 0.05868794769048691, -0.01912068948149681, 0.00780058465898037, 0.014151650480926037, -0.06522323191165924, 0.03626115247607231, 0.030324338003993034, 0.031015198677778244, -0.025474432855844498, 0.02895464561879635, 0.0874532088637352, -0.013487081043422222, -0.009656477719545364, 0.002582064364105463, 0.03229084238409996, 0.008001693524420261, -0.021562565118074417, 0.001031590043567121, 0.002506235148757696, 0.007843687199056149, -0.03142652288079262, 0.01637510024011135, 0.01942642405629158, 0.06367556005716324, -0.03971075639128685, -0.002892402932047844, -0.014758405275642872, -0.004398011602461338, 0.02821318246424198, -0.031673915684223175, 0.06457286328077316, 0.03281555697321892, -0.008145478554069996, 0.030136186629533768, -0.020911049097776413, -0.0418747253715992, 0.0025440570898354053, 0.008901464752852917, 0.08184034377336502, -0.052642855793237686, 0.02813941240310669, -0.02760005183517933, 0.026073459535837173, 0.0758989229798317, 0.018313400447368622, -0.04615480452775955, 0.043384358286857605, -0.028883781284093857, 0.025260422378778458, 0.0430881604552269, 0.013401648961007595, -0.072322778403759, -0.02267954684793949, -0.0392572358250618, -0.020689774304628372, -0.013390474021434784, -0.02846943587064743, 0.007542668376117945, 0.018715446814894676, -0.008349062874913216, 0.012230763211846352, -0.025139084085822105, -0.034512463957071304, 0.003367529483512044, 0.028946883976459503, -0.08447669446468353, 0.00004438382529770024, 0.016058050096035004, 0.011455723084509373, -0.033022183924913406, 0.022876953706145287, 0.009473156183958054, -0.0032458824571222067, -0.009573404677212238, -0.05183001980185509, -0.04978324845433235, -0.04225020483136177, 0.016274573281407356, -0.004695743788033724, 0.020100634545087814, 0.026780275627970695, -0.03673027455806732, -0.010427486151456833, -0.002388837980106473, 0.027786891907453537, 0.06654148548841476, 0.04987426474690437, 0.005128988064825535, -0.04369985684752464, -0.030480246990919113, 0.05053006485104561, 0.04678163304924965, -0.0021090891677886248, 0.05676696449518204, 0.00659119663760066, -0.010853534564375877, -0.07230600714683533, 0.025161296129226685, -0.034006960690021515, -0.03759455308318138, 0.029218414798378944, 0.04467950761318207, 0.05676612630486488, 0.00869019515812397, -0.039612043648958206, 0.012372097931802273, -0.00941979419440031, 0.02077629417181015, -0.020830992609262466, 0.05346325784921646, -0.02054370567202568, -0.030264105647802353, -0.014033988118171692, 0.023270145058631897, -0.0003530146786943078, 0.004021724220365286, 0.042169488966464996, 0.038621898740530014, -0.032473526895046234, 0.07485353946685791, -0.0092332623898983, -0.08569172024726868, 0.06680558621883392, -0.014759683981537819, 0.035574477165937424, 0.040765028446912766, 0.021171774715185165, 0.0891888290643692, -0.01859126053750515, 0.026007717475295067, -0.04287499189376831, -0.019605861976742744, -0.007446787785738707, 0.011850978247821331, 0.038756776601076126, 0.008869389072060585, 0.00527958432212472, -0.015432307496666908, 0.0009978319285437465, 0.03871869295835495, 0.04099953919649124, 0.04296816140413284, 0.05543564632534981, 0.01054408773779869, -0.014718272723257542, -0.014172498136758804, 0.039779018610715866, -0.0095297796651721, -0.05767436325550079, -0.017982665449380875, -0.03249817714095116, -0.05601014941930771, 0.006420161575078964, -0.002956581534817815, 0.04917985945940018, -0.000301209045574069, 0.0444166325032711, 0.01097935065627098, -0.059178490191698074, 0.014489023014903069, 0.009680970571935177, -0.01190286036580801, -0.01968744769692421, 0.022477328777313232, -0.07321842759847641, -0.036863964051008224, 0.07894200086593628, -0.01593826152384281, -0.001608212711289525, 0.05250761657953262, -0.02626033127307892, -0.05783203989267349, 0.012384026311337948, -0.05808979272842407, 0.02000977098941803, 0.022401951253414154, 0.03900965303182602, 0.04833587259054184, -0.046490378677845, -0.016008133068680763, 0.009432331658899784, -0.011632997542619705, -0.013509138487279415, -0.005685674492269754, -0.046367038041353226, -0.037450868636369705, -0.04854146018624306, -0.03443896770477295, 0.055363547056913376, -0.07122325152158737, 0.015837404876947403, 0.011785841546952724, -0.00023746619990561157, -0.00866003055125475, 0.02353096567094326, 0.032554034143686295, -0.03132333233952522, -0.008562789298593998, 0.03199612349271774, -0.0010808673687279224, 0.0039007305167615414, -0.061466097831726074, 0.003668653080239892, -0.0126662477850914, -0.019477659836411476, 0.04088796675205231, 0.015565700829029083, -0.0258941613137722, 0.01732141524553299, -0.009290623478591442, -0.008947856724262238, 0.015275157056748867, -0.016323864459991455, -0.028979264199733734, -0.014017865061759949, -0.049639102071523666, 0.007915458641946316, -0.035166267305612564, 0.030828148126602173, 0.009018206037580967, -0.016070935875177383, -0.03930457681417465, -0.017933286726474762, 0.020145971328020096, 0.01873299852013588, -0.0004605424765031785, 0.007274062838405371, -0.02218853123486042, 0.023121392354369164, -0.05562207102775574, -0.017469992861151695, 0.022278327494859695, 0.015894116833806038, -0.025564510375261307, 0.018365008756518364, 0.04907825589179993, 0.02555224858224392, -0.0007782243192195892, 0.01878281682729721, 0.014426552690565586, -0.01055779680609703, 0.07827944308519363, 0.05085719749331474, -0.011959871277213097, -0.010562218725681305, 0.015261039137840271, -0.043086837977170944, 0.055420465767383575, 0.00203560758382082, 0.026410220190882683, -0.043025750666856766, 0.03044421225786209, 0.014359895139932632, -0.08536490052938461, -0.05797133967280388, -0.008522337302565575, -0.028351955115795135, -0.1015237495303154, -0.007743417751044035, -0.061679910868406296, -0.0153916385024786, 0.03446236997842789, 0.02839265577495098, -0.05608689412474632, 0.027788931503891945, -0.027444802224636078, 0.05028097331523895, 0.02052794024348259, 0.005964403040707111, 0.018406495451927185, 0.026359444484114647, 0.05659754201769829, -0.026324406266212463, -0.04257148504257202, -0.03482521325349808, 0.01676817052066326, -0.013815495185554028, 0.04067417234182358, -0.043327122926712036, -0.02662859857082367, -0.028026163578033447, -0.06934479624032974, -0.0043742479756474495, -0.050743717700242996, 0.06158339977264404, 0.027489468455314636, -0.04271063208580017, 0.049918729811906815, 0.034086402505636215, 0.014070762321352959, -0.058854326605796814, 0.0002786657714750618, -0.002906718058511615, 0.03490584343671799, 0.001531091402284801, -0.03085472248494625, 0.04008960723876953, -0.039849136024713516, 0.00921920407563448, 0.008874064311385155, -0.06428361684083939, 0.07592540979385376, -0.00852056872099638, 0.04128461331129074, -0.014075305312871933, 0.03506390005350113, 0.036694105714559555, -0.047331202775239944, -0.03675144165754318, -0.05110940337181091, 0.016897257417440414, -0.005415008403360844, -0.04544761776924133, 0.027423076331615448, 0.007943175733089447, -0.031335920095443726, 0.03809026628732681, 0.0556468591094017, -0.04879916459321976, -0.025427570566534996, 0.002214750275015831, 0.013235698454082012, 0.06835218518972397, -0.026771262288093567, -0.013203788548707962, 0.05682068690657616, 0.012681095860898495, 0.026386529207229614, 0.0899091362953186, -0.019171718508005142, -0.03946257755160332, 0.037534285336732864, 0.0230309646576643, -0.024734623730182648, -0.07191068679094315, 0.0005372656742110848, -0.008199373260140419, -0.007164401933550835, 0.02029777318239212, -0.006171088665723801, -0.002233243780210614, 0.04698732867836952, -0.004908834118396044, 0.009525642730295658, -0.0695224404335022, 0.007582247257232666, 0.01739359460771084, 0.021844232454895973, -0.01259373314678669, -0.05683821067214012, -0.019095340743660927, -0.025084100663661957, -0.010521986521780491, 0.008388139307498932, 0.014668355695903301, -0.02402995526790619, 0.05506918951869011, -0.04492839425802231, 0.06571942567825317, 0.14522923529148102, 0.043442945927381516, -0.0014986045425757766, -0.01606244035065174, -0.013853135518729687, 0.003011033171787858, 0.03487178683280945, 0.004342534113675356, 0.0023853278253227472, -0.017531663179397583, -0.036003705114126205, 0.040444616228342056, 0.008822484873235226, -0.05642792955040932, 0.01959996111690998, 0.05623685568571091, 0.008549362421035767, 0.02381475456058979, 0.06253258138895035, -0.002248176606371999, 0.03433847054839134, 0.01422603614628315, -0.006461205892264843, -0.07124215364456177, -0.04721017926931381, -0.02800765447318554, 0.07952655106782913, -0.04143920913338661, -0.01846705935895443, 0.05753621831536293, -0.00337854097597301, 0.021393612027168274, -0.012816482223570347, -0.0027737971395254135, -0.04751706123352051, 0.02848941460251808, -0.006422794423997402, -0.03443225473165512, 0.02761893719434738, -0.022019987925887108, 0.009056156501173973, -0.02361096814274788, -0.03046676702797413, 0.006511448882520199, -0.015203862451016903, -0.0015709807630628347, -0.03789342939853668, -0.05612733215093613, -0.01838800311088562, 0.007531399838626385, 0.009066754020750523, -0.0011212696554139256, -0.02903095632791519, -0.012104439549148083, -0.001750912400893867, 0.02396581880748272, -0.018292266875505447, 0.0033463025465607643, -0.06458146870136261, 0.027678437530994415, -0.027692072093486786, -0.019245505332946777, -0.04101981967687607, 0.0012233757879585028, -0.02174985408782959, -0.0009440166759304702, -0.001858134986832738, -0.046861566603183746, 0.03177995607256889, -0.016838636249303818, -0.04887573421001434, 0.03599340096116066, 0.02272278442978859, -0.004048225004225969, -0.03901286423206329, 0.036094315350055695, 0.01254867110401392, 0.031034385785460472, 0.056130241602659225, -0.0036664127837866545, 0.01126403920352459, 0.0733555406332016, 0.005398149602115154, -0.01771867834031582, 0.024000389501452446, -0.03878537937998772, -0.040559254586696625, -0.0007361968164332211, -0.005284484941512346, -0.025435375049710274, -0.025574995204806328, -0.018422823399305344, 0.0304957814514637, 0.06905318051576614, 0.044068120419979095, 0.025644218549132347, -0.03684132173657417, 0.024368219077587128, -0.01599000208079815, -0.019464261829853058, -0.008576597087085247, 0.03099016845226288, -0.0047785318456590176, -0.018593547865748405, -0.006640922278165817, -0.040307484567165375, -0.024958187714219093, 0.0033011490013450384, -0.06517685204744339, -0.02012312225997448, -0.025551697239279747, -0.0020609509665519, -0.03682112321257591, -0.011104903183877468, -0.025655074045062065, -0.04480810835957527, -0.036410097032785416, 0.044314347207546234, -0.025290001183748245, -0.05939314886927605, 0.00916251540184021, 0.07219915837049484, 0.05128752812743187, 0.014305773191154003, 0.015250162221491337, -0.008283142000436783, -0.03095325268805027, -0.06119612604379654, -0.010240988805890083, 0.05299638211727142, -0.016886714845895767, 0.006016350816935301, 0.017400985583662987, 0.015125628560781479, 0.035522185266017914, -0.040361255407333374, -0.02525089681148529, 0.02675151452422142, -0.029522540047764778, -0.017207328230142593, -0.012068361975252628, -0.00046309735625982285, 0.028945649042725563, -0.04750783368945122, 0.05063975229859352, 0.03659304976463318, 0.02591634728014469, 0.07080166786909103, 0.08368571847677231, 0.015887003391981125, 0.10508276522159576, -0.015783535316586494, -0.019240852445364, -0.02535678632557392, -0.03901107609272003, 0.061460427939891815, 0.054934754967689514, -0.060870129615068436, -0.035874173045158386, -0.037763990461826324, 0.024655833840370178, -0.002510296879336238, -0.029532600194215775, 0.02982959896326065, 0.0702480748295784, -0.019771363586187363, 0.054592784494161606, 0.0586688406765461, 0.005606233607977629, -0.04300853610038757, -0.03768112137913704, -0.0627189353108406, -0.006411540787667036, 0.07343731820583344, 0.008745978586375713, -0.015054955147206783, -0.07851292937994003, -0.02582290582358837, -0.0441405363380909, 0.009525361470878124, -0.05258921533823013, 0.03540158271789551, 0.027552448213100433, -0.013254592195153236, 0.0027057945262640715, -0.016122428700327873, 0.009483348578214645, -0.06800282746553421, 0.03636180981993675, 0.04343601316213608, -0.010135425254702568, 0.022238006815314293, -0.06339206546545029, -0.04054148495197296, -0.03047177754342556, -0.0032380125485360622, 0.04005061462521553, -0.007832749746739864, -0.061087675392627716, -0.06237025186419487, 0.003940652124583721, 0.0584956631064415, -0.024476371705532074, -0.05716508999466896, 0.02858741395175457, -0.06486740708351135, 0.022633548825979233, -0.0028533663135021925, 0.019311973825097084, 0.03958786651492119, -0.015942389145493507, -0.03130481019616127, -0.0320260114967823, 0.008868161588907242, -0.017100077122449875, 0.025233276188373566, 0.004282173700630665, -0.00435568206012249, -0.028983889147639275, -0.03504950553178787, 0.037763845175504684, -0.010760655626654625, -0.021452926099300385, -0.004427956882864237, -0.040836986154317856, -0.026098668575286865, -0.0016291845822706819, 0.024530703201889992, -0.0642472356557846, 0.011154670268297195, -0.0718759074807167, -0.020227747038006783, -0.0039406935684382915, 0.00001188779242511373, -0.06412005424499512, -0.018469586968421936, 0.05475281551480293, 0.026244232431054115, 0.02978695183992386, 0.006073501892387867, -0.07324566692113876, -0.045991986989974976, -0.04481566324830055, 0.012226083315908909, 0.006751446519047022, 0.06283950060606003, -0.012171486392617226, -0.00830079521983862, 0.02736208774149418, -0.09066338837146759, 0.01275358535349369, 0.04703176021575928, 0.02629205211997032, 0.03957062214612961, 0.0013866920489817858, -0.015108401887118816, 0.013446428813040257, -0.03953380510210991, 0.00024975152336992323, -0.03401431441307068, -0.001204946544021368, -0.048026375472545624, 0.038999829441308975, -0.059706155210733414, 0.02682330831885338, -0.00977263506501913, -0.020236624404788017, 0.0010032892460003495, -0.04113571718335152, -0.006472115870565176, -0.06113465875387192, -0.04855763167142868, 0.05095481127500534, -0.019692331552505493, -0.04831657186150551, 0.062320053577423096, -0.011122212745249271 ]
<p>I'm struggling with mathematics behind linear regression. In the following lines I pasted the text from the book <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0387310738" rel="nofollow">Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning</a> (p. 46) where author derives the regression function $\mathbb{E}_{t} [t | \mathbf{x}]$. I want to understand the procedure from the equation (2) to the final result. Could somebody please provide me some useful pointers (and/or links) which concept from the calculus of variations should I study.</p> <p>The average, expected, loss is given by</p> <p>$$ \mathbb{E}[L] = \int \int L(t, x (\mathbf{x})) p (\mathbf{x}, t) \, d\mathbf{x} \, dt. \tag{1} $$</p> <p>A common choice of loss function in linear regression is the squared loos given by $L (t, y(\mathbf{x})) = \{ y (\mathbf{x}) - t \}^{2}$. In this case, the expected loss can be written as</p> <p>$$ \mathbb{E}[L] = \int \int \{ y (\mathbf{x}) - t \}^{2} p (\mathbf{x}, t) \, d\mathbf{x} \, dt. \tag{2} $$</p> <p>Our goal is to choose $y (\mathbf{x})$ so as to minimize $\mathbb{E} [L]$. We can do this using the calculus of variations to give</p> <p>$$ \dfrac{\delta \mathbb{E} [L]}{\delta y (\mathbf{x})} = 2 \int \{ y (\mathbf{x}) - t \} p (\mathbf{x}, t) \, dt = 0. \tag{3} $$</p> <p>Solving for $y (\mathbf{x})$, and using the sum and product rules of probability, we obtain</p> <p>$$ y (\mathbf{x}) = \dfrac{\int tp (\mathbf{x}, t) \, dt}{p (\mathbf{x})} = \int t p (t | \mathbf{x}) \, dt = \mathbb{E}_{t} [t | \mathbf{x}] \tag{4} $$</p>
g74335
[ 0.013461077585816383, -0.03261737897992134, -0.016989853233098984, -0.03985585644841194, 0.027887485921382904, -0.061156898736953735, 0.08947579562664032, -0.009485289454460144, -0.06237450987100601, -0.05324225127696991, -0.03763021528720856, 0.04994255676865578, 0.11316104233264923, -0.011285636574029922, 0.007042539305984974, 0.024185068905353546, 0.0339922234416008, 0.0038908501155674458, 0.035361677408218384, -0.03365149721503258, 0.0004471348656807095, 0.06479775905609131, -0.013186143711209297, -0.0034299956168979406, 0.017739813774824142, -0.03540213406085968, -0.028651641681790352, 0.035773344337940216, -0.06103850528597832, 0.03588557615876198, -0.0029864979442209005, -0.03991757705807686, 0.06943288445472717, -0.03707650676369667, -0.024937203153967857, -0.03634997829794884, 0.06990503519773483, -0.024873249232769012, 0.03007655404508114, 0.046857770532369614, 0.008382019586861134, -0.00007924477540655062, -0.0063493079505860806, 0.04857379198074341, 0.02371751144528389, -0.03836829215288162, -0.028994601219892502, -0.03377709537744522, 0.026344679296016693, 0.026925140991806984, 0.006755787879228592, -0.017225319519639015, -0.003517945297062397, -0.050396934151649475, 0.0001635618245927617, -0.017558258026838303, 0.00946598220616579, -0.0399475023150444, -0.007727473974227905, -0.02964421734213829, 0.07240999490022659, -0.013960231095552444, -0.047664228826761246, -0.040991101413965225, 0.01558916550129652, -0.011350368149578571, 0.007350104860961437, 0.0060934931971132755, -0.020146086812019348, -0.008257272653281689, 0.02747960388660431, 0.013906346634030342, 0.04952649399638176, -0.004629934672266245, -0.025343745946884155, -0.07875050604343414, 0.023012779653072357, 0.01123744435608387, 0.009507647715508938, 0.050293855369091034, -0.004671377595514059, 0.039431896060705185, 0.011581153608858585, 0.07753073424100876, -0.04243198037147522, 0.016772489994764328, -0.012768893502652645, 0.022481486201286316, -0.02150789089500904, 0.030919797718524933, -0.03189863637089729, 0.016500236466526985, 0.05028770491480827, 0.02500072494149208, -0.015084007754921913, 0.004938601981848478, -0.04701421409845352, -0.0532541424036026, 0.0503908209502697, 0.022885475307703018, 0.051923420280218124, 0.040397465229034424, -0.03936799243092537, 0.0023436914198100567, -0.01795882172882557, 0.062338609248399734, 0.08800522983074188, 0.044601280242204666, -0.047299228608608246, -0.03435568884015083, -0.035778358578681946, 0.017694072797894478, -0.046268947422504425, -0.0498943030834198, -0.059387754648923874, -0.06721137464046478, 0.012284094467759132, -0.00018110759265255183, 0.024234818294644356, 0.02578781358897686, 0.020832868292927742, -0.07889269292354584, 0.028669919818639755, 0.02645648643374443, 0.0268519539386034, 0.052009567618370056, 0.006335253827273846, 0.012601885944604874, 0.08980590105056763, 0.018736671656370163, -0.01958157680928707, 0.04129783436655998, -0.005685936193913221, 0.034688498824834824, -0.018346287310123444, 0.059549205005168915, -0.004732906352728605, -0.007711872458457947, 0.03601904213428497, -0.03997982665896416, -0.06424417346715927, 0.03921055048704147, -0.0012511787936091423, -0.02135668508708477, -0.03104935958981514, 0.012727154418826103, 0.003936521243304014, -0.013032287359237671, 0.00818412471562624, -0.03804907202720642, -0.01994526945054531, 0.011821212247014046, -0.012932630255818367, 0.0009833258809521794, -0.04680471122264862, -0.02235468104481697, 0.00876547209918499, -0.012158973142504692, 0.010407905094325542, 0.021164748817682266, 0.04815563187003136, -0.06228300556540489, -0.010574797168374062, 0.028871383517980576, -0.06429615616798401, -0.006199806462973356, 0.02481517568230629, -0.022403130307793617, 0.027315642684698105, -0.030170857906341553, 0.03651285544037819, -0.019469354301691055, 0.043732598423957825, -0.034674108028411865, 0.03851534053683281, 0.026276996359229088, 0.006848050281405449, -0.05990671366453171, 0.03667038306593895, -0.03474074974656105, 0.02846413478255272, 0.009565327316522598, 0.04197745770215988, -0.036002278327941895, -0.0037415705155581236, -0.026902759447693825, -0.006488359067589045, -0.00514285359531641, -0.040153343230485916, 0.007878175005316734, -0.027563484385609627, -0.006237056106328964, -0.020769914612174034, 0.009977960027754307, -0.01060759648680687, 0.05802203342318535, 0.035399530082941055, -0.016831090673804283, -0.07557946443557739, 0.009920488111674786, 0.006614679004997015, 0.03742368519306183, 0.031013157218694687, -0.010599448345601559, -0.040714163333177567, -0.02269882895052433, 0.003175404854118824, 0.00724596343934536, -0.03534967079758644, 0.02223387360572815, -0.0006721827667206526, -0.04362983629107475, 0.0024466251488775015, 0.02426382526755333, 0.0034838374704122543, -0.014489959925413132, 0.030402207747101784, 0.03374480828642845, -0.0017978427931666374, -0.019757293164730072, -0.02645592764019966, -0.027260221540927887, 0.03334050625562668, -0.012631876394152641, 0.014350772835314274, 0.062218908220529556, 0.03994143009185791, -0.013822727836668491, -0.009905717335641384, 0.03090633824467659, -0.06704529374837875, -0.01663847640156746, -0.022920044139027596, -0.031158896163105965, 0.02358141727745533, -0.00030637276358902454, -0.0020469753071665764, 0.019156403839588165, 0.043407779186964035, 0.038364432752132416, 0.007258698809891939, 0.04819153994321823, -0.020323384553194046, 0.03900410979986191, -0.03709881380200386, -0.03724116086959839, -0.010078276507556438, 0.019790733233094215, 0.004175400827080011, 0.06010790914297104, -0.04141014814376831, 0.04089415445923805, 0.0014540031552314758, -0.05293487757444382, 0.03262752667069435, -0.054981522262096405, -0.0038135102950036526, -0.03594730794429779, 0.04919416084885597, 0.01954345777630806, -0.03917485103011131, 0.037600502371788025, 0.01515181828290224, 0.03427867591381073, -0.05732756108045578, -0.04249925538897514, -0.017518578097224236, 0.01803615689277649, 0.002621471881866455, -0.041336461901664734, -0.02946455217897892, 0.005268678069114685, -0.014209715649485588, 0.04025222733616829, 0.013371058739721775, -0.026974625885486603, 0.006172908470034599, -0.05994873866438866, -0.0013293229276314378, -0.006769626867026091, 0.09080934524536133, -0.08559704571962357, -0.026117699220776558, 0.028713855892419815, 0.0203409343957901, -0.00010772021778393537, 0.0071310619823634624, 0.04494819417595863, -0.03831503540277481, 0.09155002236366272, -0.0563199408352375, 0.005286432337015867, -0.006589590571820736, -0.06255100667476654, 0.016804834827780724, 0.010733083821833134, 0.01812347210943699, 0.026998573914170265, -0.04696943610906601, 0.022410854697227478, -0.022371551021933556, 0.021489759907126427, -0.014362904243171215, 0.0025525230448693037, -0.00035819949698634446, -0.009551865048706532, 0.0016112987650558352, -0.015145906247198582, 0.013952730223536491, 0.007224066648632288, 0.052942413836717606, -0.038181766867637634, 0.03677499294281006, -0.0712854415178299, -0.027130145579576492, -0.012087473645806313, -0.007626433856785297, 0.02915174514055252, 0.006539446767419577, -0.019703688099980354, 0.01018782239407301, -0.05993097275495529, -0.02984139323234558, 0.02194121479988098, 0.022201810032129288, -0.007370390929281712, -0.04014589637517929, 0.04963381960988045, -0.009856843389570713, -0.013580480590462685, 0.02467191219329834, 0.053089674562215805, -0.004475741647183895, -0.04425061494112015, 0.0022925413213670254, -0.011955838650465012, 0.0341782383620739, -0.005453779827803373, -0.017086749896407127, -0.015037890523672104, 0.03111463412642479, -0.008876527659595013, -0.028948737308382988, -0.041246943175792694, 0.03260568156838417, -0.042025528848171234, -0.0052881184965372086, 0.019703121855854988, 0.01359764114022255, -0.005220412742346525, -0.005940632428973913, -0.05276837572455406, -0.014731177128851414, 0.013515696860849857, 0.027791956439614296, 0.013903571292757988, 0.026143668219447136, 0.029210947453975677, 0.02571047469973564, -0.024384472519159317, 0.01624247245490551, -0.0558340810239315, -0.01998594030737877, 0.01568513922393322, 0.024148467928171158, -0.0006074010161682963, 0.12487898766994476, 0.03725604712963104, -0.07278487831354141, -0.03595488518476486, 0.015120730735361576, 0.06548354029655457, 0.03409932181239128, 0.04178313910961151, -0.02884497307240963, -0.005768101662397385, -0.009856733493506908, 0.04862885922193527, -0.06081502139568329, 0.010063227266073227, -0.028286298736929893, -0.0033489789348095655, -0.046831849962472916, -0.017432160675525665, 0.07799910753965378, -0.07809720188379288, -0.007052525412291288, -0.027509089559316635, -0.0022146273404359818, 0.022739093750715256, 0.0001497636258136481, 0.012209735810756683, -0.05045313760638237, 0.03243494778871536, -0.02897157333791256, -0.04326882213354111, 0.07904962450265884, 0.02803085558116436, -0.031997039914131165, -0.006453898269683123, -0.031378064304590225, 0.00841519795358181, 0.018038030713796616, 0.0024253707379102707, 0.021110720932483673, -0.07978470623493195, 0.025103261694312096, 0.042697325348854065, 0.021078355610370636, 0.002877443330362439, -0.036874692887067795, -0.025809271261096, -0.005132706370204687, -0.012705056928098202, 0.009707207791507244, 0.0031024685595184565, 0.07534613460302353, -0.013254934921860695, -0.005739952903240919, -0.01901855878531933, 0.029095495119690895, 0.010410040616989136, -0.0953938215970993, 0.027326902374625206, 0.011455695144832134, -0.022034816443920135, 0.0299758929759264, 0.0383291132748127, 0.007341440301388502, -0.04153168946504593, -0.011568986810743809, 0.035779986530542374, -0.026578672230243683, 0.02061646059155464, -0.022670626640319824, -0.014812112785875797, 0.03192519396543503, 0.02915831282734871, -0.010931120254099369, -0.028950905427336693, -0.01267215982079506, 0.010460362769663334, -0.02854386530816555, -0.0012285512639209628, -0.000144948236993514, 0.048340070992708206, 0.009248591028153896, -0.05639977753162384, 0.03243882581591606, 0.03484776243567467, -0.005590980872511864, 0.06999383866786957, 0.06655032932758331, 0.008836125023663044, 0.045992013067007065, -0.022686827927827835, 0.014932440593838692, 0.049688100814819336, 0.061669349670410156, 0.028615817427635193, 0.006030563730746508, -0.056998223066329956, -0.04050833731889725, -0.002564959926530719, 0.02293900027871132, -0.021327415481209755, -0.06582906097173691, 0.0491739921271801, 0.023953460156917572, -0.0173922348767519, 0.00007170061871875077, 0.017541086301207542, 0.05452950671315193, -0.0005119522102177143, -0.002820080379024148, 0.02549070678651333, -0.028753645718097687, -0.014224863611161709, 0.01416654884815216, 0.0330694355070591, -0.04216672480106354, -0.060202647000551224, 0.016152288764715195, -0.005500787869095802, -0.013065416365861893, -0.010370311327278614, -0.011431817896664143, -0.03735950216650963, 0.027819795534014702, 0.012932266108691692, 0.022212626412510872, 0.026382403448224068, 0.04286958649754524, -0.03132273256778717, -0.011819207109510899, 0.006512774620205164, -0.010458891279995441, 0.009385896846652031, 0.02236904390156269, 0.008002348244190216, -0.05261336639523506, 0.011967252008616924, -0.017927708104252815, -0.011767277494072914, -0.01879904605448246, -0.026097718626260757, 0.054560765624046326, -0.03469770401716232, -0.00040803011506795883, 0.030368393287062645, 0.0026219140272587538, 0.017865756526589394, 0.0373862124979496, -0.016060471534729004, -0.06016428768634796, -0.017920108512043953, 0.017618561163544655, 0.05414741113781929, 0.05740121379494667, 0.028544900938868523, 0.036292217671871185, 0.017177026718854904, -0.007943693548440933, 0.005975858308374882, 0.08027312159538269, -0.089903824031353, -0.0148283950984478, 0.006142053287476301, -0.03317055106163025, -0.018507584929466248, -0.00637702364474535, 0.05924149602651596, -0.023377273231744766, -0.004882314708083868, -0.0004979191580787301, -0.02813280001282692, 0.01623903028666973, 0.010883479379117489, 0.019403014332056046, -0.0491391196846962, 0.01482135709375143, 0.003642312716692686, -0.0020372753497213125, 0.024325842037796974, -0.005441530607640743, -0.0006126422667875886, 0.04945099353790283, -0.005022777710109949, -0.033214036375284195, -0.049077484756708145, -0.028116239234805107, 0.008613954298198223, 0.04851284995675087, -0.04665650427341461, -0.0071053714491426945, -0.001282551558688283, -0.024745238944888115, 0.014643778093159199, 0.012433545663952827, 0.03624490648508072, 0.010798112489283085, -0.04047617316246033, -0.048472680151462555, -0.040200527757406235, 0.05120634287595749, -0.024898741394281387, 0.02112102322280407, 0.021725783124566078, 0.02492591366171837, 0.021756542846560478, 0.027554813772439957, -0.060325875878334045, -0.014062898233532906, 0.04468425363302231, 0.010820344090461731, 0.035701923072338104, -0.025710541754961014, -0.06975320726633072, -0.01328690629452467, -0.061986640095710754, 0.011500278487801552, -0.023636162281036377, -0.05098183825612068, -0.06340852379798889, -0.0354251004755497, 0.04285043478012085, -0.05151968449354172, -0.04594406485557556, 0.0006007374613545835, 0.011165612377226353, -0.05725651979446411, 0.0006166144739836454, 0.01158483698964119, 0.049123603850603104, 0.019986983388662338, 0.002870894270017743, -0.0028196494095027447, 0.003760688938200474, 0.08229248225688934, -0.04909513518214226, -0.02121097594499588, -0.02083682268857956, 0.09082190692424774, -0.011392672546207905, 0.0048753926530480385, 0.005690313410013914, 0.002853219397366047, -0.004637834150344133, -0.029959017410874367, 0.024082696065306664, -0.05511141195893288, 0.026740120723843575, 0.02204791083931923, 0.04638009890913963, -0.019564900547266006, -0.03307518735527992, -0.05517876148223877, 0.056952618062496185, -0.034789763391017914, -0.019185664132237434, 0.02577117085456848, -0.04977230727672577, -0.03586312755942345, -0.034978583455085754, 0.022319385781884193, 0.030195381492376328, 0.017834721133112907, -0.008952928707003593, 0.03733042627573013, 0.00023441383382305503, 0.023256849497556686, -0.01690719835460186, -0.04616400599479675, 0.021110346540808678, -0.07204047590494156, 0.07419823855161667, -0.048766013234853745, 0.06794007867574692, 0.015715358778834343, 0.05376750975847244, -0.023999983444809914, 0.08268661051988602, 0.004285928327590227, -0.0045204865746200085, -0.06693556904792786, 0.03198270499706268, -0.014095806516706944, -0.017031986266374588, -0.09818948060274124, -0.011624732054769993, 0.07867515832185745, 0.08899756520986557, -0.014672040939331055, -0.024569904431700706, 0.04672291874885559, 0.030000772327184677, 0.03371226787567139, 0.005328135099261999, 0.013669607229530811, -0.06982001662254333, -0.0396265834569931, -0.08542191982269287, -0.05620021000504494, -0.0024167634546756744, 0.022710006684064865, 0.047453925013542175, -0.024529198184609413, -0.09354961663484573, -0.004454770591109991, -0.058907464146614075, -0.021988164633512497, -0.011873852461576462, -0.007872435264289379, 0.10098457336425781, 0.01821712777018547, 0.010248083621263504, 0.0012406063033267856, -0.010580488480627537, -0.08025218546390533, 0.024013632908463478, 0.004142371006309986, 0.01209130510687828, -0.0052719516679644585, -0.04389038309454918, -0.020195649936795235, 0.02401307038962841, -0.05816882476210594, 0.02229510433971882, 0.0038082501851022243, 0.0018742687534540892, -0.08865536749362946, 0.03070267289876938, 0.022455528378486633, -0.026420945301651955, -0.031727731227874756, 0.04575471952557564, -0.02152024582028389, 0.02076864056289196, 0.04596380516886711, 0.09521500766277313, 0.03183095157146454, -0.017626171931624413, -0.044330984354019165, -0.021042997017502785, -0.01326617319136858, -0.03875075653195381, -0.022642316296696663, -0.0678478553891182, 0.02465270832180977, -0.060795098543167114, 0.004095111042261124, 0.022260628640651703, 0.005563464481383562, 0.014529408887028694, 0.04355359822511673, 0.05582039803266525, 0.03491121530532837, 0.0021448377519845963, -0.059598974883556366, 0.0019014745485037565, -0.008910421282052994, 0.03475618734955788, 0.019576532766222954, -0.07556772977113724, 0.016066767275333405, -0.03975396975874901, -0.03322301059961319, -0.034300051629543304, -0.05390135198831558, 0.013634249567985535, -0.03817017748951912, -0.01651390641927719, -0.02138124778866768, -0.018207186833024025, 0.02449687197804451, 0.03483014553785324, -0.001387314754538238, 0.05934116989374161, -0.02320306934416294, 0.060771338641643524, -0.011616438627243042, -0.01463887095451355, 0.015709353610873222, 0.033252421766519547, -0.01410674024373293, 0.00022512569557875395, -0.008731769397854805, 0.002530778059735894, 0.011148691177368164, -0.06963994354009628, -0.01630505360662937, -0.012886433862149715, -0.07550360262393951, 0.07910176366567612, 0.006360465195029974, 0.0029856525361537933, -0.015211093239486217, 0.04833356291055679, 0.040458373725414276, -0.026598956435918808, -0.006008008029311895, -0.04183822497725487, -0.01670612394809723, 0.04999084398150444, 0.025185277685523033, 0.005156209226697683, 0.016590295359492302, 0.06655619293451309 ]
<p>I have a list of parameters which correlate with 1-2 covariates that I want to control for.</p> <p>Following normalization, I wanted to do comparisons between groups, correlation analysis and probably use some of them as features in a prediction model.</p> <p>The problem is that I don't think I can use the normalized values following ANOVA for regression analysis (and so on), since they will be by default correlated as a result of the ANCOVA.</p> <p>Do you agree (or not)? What else would you suggest? </p>
g74336
[ -0.0101944450289011, -0.0642346665263176, 0.004924412816762924, -0.013397565111517906, -0.004756495356559753, 0.012343947775661945, 0.04616595804691315, -0.00044619350228458643, -0.00746770529076457, 0.010400064289569855, 0.026153534650802612, 0.016391940414905548, 0.01197251956909895, 0.05106448009610176, -0.0429365411400795, -0.009188198484480381, 0.03575093299150467, 0.016851162537932396, -0.0036244825460016727, 0.010748832486569881, -0.0016731772338971496, -0.057928819209337234, 0.0532187819480896, -0.017999593168497086, -0.033250998705625534, 0.0027676550671458244, -0.054414547979831696, 0.043791983276605606, -0.03543776273727417, 0.019126009196043015, -0.006867386866360903, 0.0015673476736992598, 0.0394761748611927, -0.02537248097360134, -0.039430420845746994, -0.005959255155175924, 0.02826325222849846, 0.02183607406914234, -0.005572849418967962, 0.004675961099565029, 0.06015065312385559, 0.037848856300115585, 0.02660265378654003, 0.014993729069828987, -0.04704229533672333, -0.019856557250022888, 0.0358956940472126, 0.00004643548891181126, -0.02285667136311531, 0.003745557740330696, 0.020562315359711647, 0.03456166386604309, -0.013222122564911842, -0.028865857049822807, 0.032608985900878906, 0.024311186745762825, 0.005030542612075806, 0.004614914767444134, -0.0034674450289458036, -0.007104907184839249, 0.000435947731602937, -0.04663712531328201, -0.006520723458379507, -0.0066047171130776405, 0.0337885245680809, 0.019814597442746162, -0.03645214065909386, -0.03606211394071579, -0.03385951742529869, -0.0013484020018950105, 0.003533401992172003, 0.02365259639918804, 0.02520786039531231, 0.016441037878394127, -0.026322199031710625, -0.011408728547394276, 0.027984686195850372, -0.05005347728729248, 0.02887941338121891, 0.013950368389487267, 0.00740065285935998, 0.04908814653754234, 0.04761763662099838, -0.009809649549424648, 0.09554378688335419, -0.011837571859359741, 0.049426786601543427, -0.008047947660088539, 0.04570847004652023, 0.01690524071455002, 0.009154361672699451, 0.04428155720233917, 0.06153380498290062, 0.011927369982004166, 0.02263829857110977, 0.0805121660232544, -0.07446027547121048, 0.02477419376373291, 0.047805305570364, -0.05251181870698929, -0.01809096522629261, 0.061353057622909546, -0.016010956838726997, -0.022308379411697388, -0.07963917404413223, -0.029089873656630516, 0.026990260928869247, 0.003612031927332282, 0.017212307080626488, -0.05691961199045181, -0.058997057378292084, -0.0031698057428002357, -0.040441062301397324, 0.007334137801080942, -0.011204053647816181, -0.08838864415884018, 0.031168188899755478, -0.0486706979572773, 0.022367235273122787, -0.0029415814206004143, 0.01350263599306345, 0.008628720417618752, 0.03688769415020943, 0.05811021476984024, 0.014795606024563313, 0.029374130070209503, -0.009149512276053429, 0.04688648506999016, 0.04296492040157318, -0.03444802016019821, 0.009487232193350792, -0.010574313811957836, -0.03215617313981056, 0.07998090982437134, -0.02912355586886406, 0.009740696288645267, -0.032865043729543686, 0.06580974161624908, 0.03593577817082405, -0.0009157737949863076, -0.05151202902197838, -0.010811603628098965, -0.0025947957765311003, 0.020157748833298683, -0.03311798349022865, -0.004015055485069752, 0.03212197124958038, -0.02777996100485325, -0.013326113112270832, 0.07310673594474792, -0.00825512409210205, 0.027690494433045387, -0.01727912575006485, 0.038410309702157974, -0.05348432436585426, 0.02128344401717186, -0.04251722991466522, -0.01781110092997551, 0.006651183124631643, 0.02730899676680565, 0.02876855805516243, -0.02205696702003479, 0.022663753479719162, 0.008445956744253635, 0.017682425677776337, -0.01273066271096468, 0.004014407284557819, -0.04275772348046303, -0.03538097068667412, 0.001969850156456232, 0.0014506812440231442, 0.027742834761738777, -0.009197468869388103, -0.04420286417007446, 0.10063247382640839, 0.05318217724561691, -0.020600788295269012, -0.017424633726477623, 0.011572625488042831, 0.011549186892807484, 0.034978631883859634, 0.058115750551223755, 0.04553409293293953, 0.015060726553201675, 0.023998120799660683, -0.0047472878359258175, -0.026123953983187675, 0.03737498074769974, -0.08911703526973724, 0.030039403587579727, 0.04538867622613907, 0.007460789289325476, -0.06431902199983597, -0.02709914930164814, -0.05936281010508537, -0.03162309154868126, -0.002053035655990243, -0.013387491926550865, -0.03310764953494072, 0.008486885577440262, 0.027574699372053146, 0.033554140478372574, -0.018824230879545212, 0.018090745434165, -0.02652805484831333, -0.04566958174109459, 0.06273020803928375, -0.016214419156312943, -0.02143026515841484, 0.02313278615474701, -0.01192986685782671, -0.02402574196457863, -0.04233555123209953, 0.03336599841713905, -0.018899254500865936, -0.01612480916082859, 0.012696916237473488, 0.006314693484455347, -0.04407035931944847, 0.027896080166101456, -0.07968540489673615, -0.0076030557975173, 0.019307097420096397, 0.004611130803823471, 0.011243973858654499, 0.006959450896829367, 0.023208726197481155, 0.006017289590090513, 0.05525423213839531, -0.059650734066963196, -0.03176587447524071, 0.014045126736164093, 0.05515318363904953, -0.04756845161318779, 0.04447769373655319, -0.004400849808007479, -0.021439172327518463, 0.039303164929151535, -0.051992375403642654, 0.10600326955318451, 0.0025075990706682205, 0.01135397981852293, 0.07304608076810837, -0.00019264165894128382, 0.011858080513775349, -0.019331537187099457, -0.02499520219862461, -0.02367713674902916, 0.006373169831931591, 0.046652939170598984, -0.04384038224816322, 0.09308512508869171, 0.009027347899973392, -0.009140104055404663, 0.01749332994222641, -0.04057786986231804, -0.00917377695441246, 0.07232514768838882, 0.04091602563858032, 0.004980472382158041, 0.006756252609193325, 0.008522269316017628, 0.058091044425964355, 0.00884853396564722, 0.013583366759121418, -0.03461041301488876, 0.0007732875528745353, -0.02002144418656826, -0.009464285336434841, -0.026758721098303795, 0.01022393349558115, -0.015179957263171673, -0.014445445500314236, 0.06888828426599503, 0.043972257524728775, 0.02875308319926262, -0.0266311913728714, -0.023024749010801315, 0.06681130081415176, -0.06431564688682556, 0.04804735258221626, -0.0024442633148282766, 0.018751053139567375, -0.0510517880320549, 0.012483937665820122, 0.033526040613651276, 0.057424966245889664, 0.009823249652981758, -0.0064025865867733955, 0.03186748921871185, 0.009217976592481136, 0.03574199229478836, 0.0013649045722559094, 0.04916183277964592, 0.03672768920660019, -0.020086580887436867, 0.04323739558458328, -0.04269927367568016, 0.017651408910751343, 0.11087716370820999, -0.0346108004450798, 0.007414386607706547, 0.008813084103167057, -0.023340722545981407, 0.00893410760909319, -0.058881208300590515, -0.05496327206492424, 0.03758031129837036, 0.0014377593761309981, 0.022545715793967247, -0.013792183250188828, -0.07649821043014526, 0.01953383907675743, -0.014895048923790455, 0.022880537435412407, -0.005254102870821953, 0.013934825547039509, -0.01167081855237484, 0.0015231946017593145, 0.00712315971031785, -0.016157548874616623, -0.038430772721767426, 0.011989635415375233, 0.02346942014992237, -0.028174908831715584, 0.0520898774266243, -0.05302318185567856, 0.007770085241645575, -0.018460039049386978, -0.02469705045223236, 0.0533633753657341, 0.040131572633981705, 0.010846172459423542, -0.008163453079760075, -0.006090679671615362, -0.07226262986660004, 0.024387529119849205, -0.03280472755432129, -0.026379304006695747, 0.03194046393036842, 0.00905194878578186, -0.07266347110271454, 0.08334369212388992, 0.012026450596749783, 0.007465037051588297, -0.008068053983151913, 0.025067051872611046, -0.004036549478769302, -0.025026384741067886, -0.027593038976192474, 0.0024397626984864473, -0.004127125255763531, 0.04592625051736832, -0.05504711717367172, 0.03040674887597561, 0.03692811354994774, 0.09960556775331497, -0.0298005323857069, -0.032670676708221436, -0.011489883065223694, 0.021635891869664192, 0.011814453639090061, -0.010501649230718613, -0.014631657861173153, 0.024909790605306625, 0.022912127897143364, -0.022927971556782722, 0.0757521241903305, -0.010785851627588272, -0.006038136314600706, 0.060026515275239944, 0.023499466478824615, 0.033466316759586334, -0.05379462614655495, -0.030663516372442245, 0.03161579743027687, 0.049957696348428726, 0.060051050037145615, -0.027864307165145874, 0.04763828217983246, 0.05044236779212952, 0.007954484783113003, -0.03682230785489082, 0.02420383132994175, 0.018963653594255447, -0.05038582533597946, -0.012997385114431381, 0.040574461221694946, -0.007436901330947876, -0.009770396165549755, -0.00411761412397027, -0.030652692541480064, -0.01293458603322506, 0.01891009882092476, 0.019025500863790512, -0.02908114530146122, -0.0214471947401762, 0.026116834953427315, 0.07170719653367996, 0.018223071470856667, -0.04921238124370575, -0.03805725648999214, 0.04144245386123657, -0.005473085679113865, 0.040416788309812546, -0.042399026453495026, -0.0005527619505301118, -0.008806397207081318, -0.1009083092212677, -0.036689452826976776, -0.021027151495218277, 0.005987974349409342, 0.024859746918082237, 0.000687435909640044, 0.06279165297746658, -0.025801151990890503, 0.017297863960266113, -0.018069181591272354, 0.013334938324987888, 0.00639070849865675, -0.013558082282543182, 0.02357238158583641, 0.03336123749613762, -0.04899570345878601, 0.004623787477612495, -0.014626859687268734, -0.014772342517971992, -0.035524096339941025, -0.004113227594643831, -0.0033906414173543453, 0.06276431679725647, -0.02519688569009304, 0.025263097137212753, -0.01658792234957218, 0.003420115215703845, 0.030463598668575287, -0.0021648744586855173, 0.005739517509937286, 0.0006611153366975486, -0.09822983294725418, -0.007994486950337887, -0.0023582116700708866, 0.01464567705988884, -0.018827714025974274, -0.037502747029066086, 0.04444276541471481, 0.014389759860932827, 0.06973981112241745, 0.00799794401973486, 0.033486559987068176, 0.0078563392162323, 0.014016854576766491, 0.030264731496572495, -0.021635716781020164, 0.011072643101215363, -0.025872720405459404, -0.0007198174716904759, 0.022584877908229828, 0.04081052541732788, -0.013843907974660397, -0.004173914436250925, -0.009041941724717617, -0.07595713436603546, -0.029474053531885147, 0.04552728310227394, -0.10490269213914871, -0.03980829194188118, -0.007873092778027058, 0.030996471643447876, 0.009743456728756428, 0.0033608251251280308, -0.06278977543115616, 0.027265816926956177, 0.010484347119927406, -0.026974158361554146, 0.007947186008095741, 0.029374921694397926, 0.029973480850458145, -0.014589527621865273, -0.007490774616599083, 0.03482217714190483, -0.021985018625855446, 0.022491885349154472, -0.04898970201611519, -0.00027573242550715804, -0.05214162915945053, 0.00899847224354744, -0.02362142689526081, 0.021057214587926865, -0.004543161951005459, -0.04599934443831444, 0.03490642458200455, 0.07187000662088394, 0.027753395959734917, -0.008467467501759529, -0.02247893437743187, -0.03945336118340492, 0.0011079995892941952, 0.022551588714122772, -0.008475867100059986, -0.02359228953719139, 0.047639887779951096, 0.034063421189785004, -0.006196186412125826, 0.010366607457399368, 0.016055816784501076, 0.043500449508428574, -0.01716698333621025, 0.008432256057858467, 0.05071302875876427, -0.028233950957655907, 0.044039856642484665, 0.08771396428346634, 0.006059369072318077, -0.06906235218048096, 0.012961417436599731, 0.00027750025037676096, -0.02288743108510971, -0.004189080558717251, -0.1130552589893341, 0.046908099204301834, 0.008177138864994049, 0.012935935519635677, -0.0032041403464972973, 0.01295784953981638, -0.02068730816245079, -0.0019324839813634753, -0.06537085771560669, 0.060967154800891876, -0.040890127420425415, -0.015065263956785202, -0.01543292123824358, -0.045218680053949356, 0.004533033352345228, -0.004159184638410807, -0.03457344323396683, -0.06371738016605377, 0.05785873904824257, -0.03856103494763374, -0.036310818046331406, -0.0554535947740078, 0.00158170354552567, 0.05416615307331085, -0.0000847664414322935, -0.02036822959780693, 0.020810957998037338, 0.00837816670536995, 0.016413666307926178, -0.05411617457866669, -0.057040534913539886, -0.01651167683303356, -0.038240522146224976, -0.01746249943971634, -0.009312363341450691, 0.005059972405433655, 0.01399201899766922, 0.013480303809046745, 0.007213169708848, -0.001735900528728962, -0.008637760765850544, -0.08943899720907211, -0.05251682922244072, 0.03577336668968201, 0.06458678841590881, -0.03303736075758934, -0.029252121224999428, -0.013361622579395771, -0.003034026827663183, -0.03613279014825821, 0.009010503068566322, -0.0022467044182121754, -0.05756993219256401, 0.05144570767879486, 0.027365410700440407, -0.03868251293897629, -0.024602409452199936, 0.012013182044029236, 0.01678868941962719, 0.004438539035618305, -0.03189442679286003, 0.008724763058125973, -0.024579696357250214, -0.03649809584021568, 0.0032158936373889446, -0.023713244125247, 0.0003634712193161249, -0.002691833768039942, 0.01559421606361866, -0.0299054142087698, -0.006579652428627014, -0.06628575176000595, -0.008182560093700886, -0.012119300663471222, -0.026114849373698235, 0.03190019726753235, -0.043942973017692566, 0.01716199517250061, 0.024790985509753227, -0.006452413275837898, -0.017503289505839348, 0.0031790127977728844, 0.008831139653921127, 0.029038026928901672, 0.01012415625154972, 0.037550486624240875, -0.007779557723551989, -0.01553881261497736, -0.024799110367894173, -0.03192410618066788, -0.0021527756471186876, -0.02551346644759178, -0.02103825844824314, 0.057374779134988785, 0.05238876864314079, 0.01886751875281334, 0.035774849355220795, -0.07249847799539566, -0.007757334038615227, 0.015507330186665058, 0.028847496956586838, 0.03378062695264816, -0.04310221970081329, -0.008734216913580894, 0.02716187573969364, 0.0004869530675932765, 0.05120355263352394, 0.0073035405948758125, -0.011020644567906857, 0.04637078568339348, 0.0158640518784523, -0.08091100305318832, 0.03365650027990341, -0.049864571541547775, -0.03551783412694931, -0.09223352372646332, 0.09118366986513138, -0.03396059200167656, 0.06721960753202438, 0.017803402617573738, -0.02453000657260418, 0.008703182451426983, 0.06955496221780777, -0.04175041988492012, 0.06737425178289413, -0.02540072612464428, -0.007966704666614532, 0.023549959063529968, -0.004742235876619816, -0.06768999248743057, 0.05244084447622299, 0.013338454067707062, 0.032337214797735214, 0.009026178158819675, -0.056559573858976364, -0.03716026246547699, 0.017066460102796555, 0.061722517013549805, 0.022751158103346825, 0.05236288532614708, 0.03599606454372406, -0.012317785061895847, -0.0018793896306306124, -0.02154357358813286, -0.002026622649282217, -0.0066275144927203655, 0.028266189619898796, -0.04569905996322632, -0.015506362542510033, 0.021219899877905846, -0.014591623097658157, -0.004021797329187393, -0.036935992538928986, 0.026573071256279945, 0.05112067610025406, 0.04618660733103752, -0.02668858878314495, -0.023132337257266045, -0.010533802211284637, -0.04493606835603714, 0.01295837014913559, -0.01053218450397253, -0.022924667224287987, 0.06751350313425064, -0.03018670529127121, -0.021638860926032066, 0.06610117852687836, -0.0020805520471185446, 0.0003145617956761271, -0.03144665062427521, -0.012101033702492714, -0.10346969217061996, -0.04912422597408295, 0.03325885534286499, -0.011044449172914028, -0.023556476458907127, 0.004464791156351566, -0.013734599575400352, 0.007424229755997658, -0.06376278400421143, 0.026698939502239227, 0.041984815150499344, 0.022753136232495308, -0.11381705850362778, -0.05051851272583008, -0.04639624059200287, -0.023561064153909683, 0.01837371103465557, -0.06959498673677444, -0.027008017525076866, 0.009227149188518524, -0.044936832040548325, 0.0033244946971535683, -0.0146302105858922, 0.06036842241883278, -0.01822957769036293, -0.00058682297822088, -0.0011288352543488145, -0.03703402355313301, -0.01948886178433895, 0.025931261479854584, -0.1384591907262802, -0.04481828585267067, 0.0006304520647972822, -0.010269352234899998, 0.023069042712450027, -0.015684843063354492, -0.029685748741030693, 0.05701480805873871, -0.016868719831109047, 0.007662368007004261, -0.06209715083241463, -0.06397730857133865, -0.05395067483186722, 0.0021738389041274786, 0.011040473356842995, 0.03539867326617241, -0.017285987734794617, 0.03091145120561123, -0.0462041050195694, 0.003153199329972267, -0.08116784691810608, 0.015896081924438477, 0.056097693741321564, 0.01627865806221962, 0.018644841387867928, -0.01807480677962303, 0.04622586816549301, 0.04896841198205948, -0.047651562839746475, -0.0437101386487484, -0.03660563379526138, 0.033742062747478485, -0.004567996598780155, 0.031627003103494644, -0.009839586913585663, -0.009858512319624424, -0.047430261969566345, -0.03420187905430794, 0.01802481897175312, -0.013553238473832607, 0.01806034706532955, 0.005692237988114357, -0.07378687709569931, 0.031620223075151443, -0.012445398606359959, -0.0185580775141716, -0.03293697163462639, -0.009826303459703922 ]
<p>Let us suppose that I have a number of features. I design pdfs for every feature and every class, some of them by smoothing some histogram of training samples, others just by introducing the prior knowledge on how the feature should look like.</p> <p>Now I want to know which is the most likely class for a given observation, based on the pdfs. I can state the following:</p> <p>$$P(p_i\in C_i | F_i) = \displaystyle\frac{P(F_i | p_i\in C_i ) P(p_i\in C_i)}{\displaystyle \sum_{C_j} P(F_i | p_i\in C_j ) P(p_\in C_j)}$$</p> <p>being $p_i$ a particular observation with feature $F_i$, $C_i$ the class I'm assigning to it. What I've doing so far is just replacing $P(\cdot|\cdot)$ by its density function $\delta$ given that $P(\cdot|\cdot)$ is about $2\epsilon \delta(\cdot|\cdot) $ for a neighborhood $[F_i-\epsilon,F_i+\epsilon]$ and I can cancel out the $2\epsilon$, so I suppose it's just legitimate to directly take the value at the density function.</p> <p>Now, there's one feature in particular in which I want to convey that I just don't care about its value in a very wide range, for one of the classes. It's an area, so say the area can be between zero and a large value. In other words, in this class we can find any area. In another class, there is a shorter dynamic range of the values the feature should take. The problem that I find is that the result of the formula before is always lower for the 'don't care' class because the uniform distribution extends far away and hence the value of the pdf is low at every point. My desired behavior would be that since I don't care much about the area, there should be a more fair competition among the two classes, and probably some other features in the classification process will make the final decision, but this way I just say that the problematic class is very unlikely for any input of this feature.</p> <p>I could tune $P(p\in C_i)$ to be higher for the problematic class. However, in other features this is not what I expect. Any clues on how to handle this or pose this problem?</p>
g74337
[ -0.0025292271748185158, -0.03538313880562782, -0.0077942232601344585, -0.06882667541503906, 0.0036116205155849457, -0.01901925727725029, 0.057499468326568604, 0.02086111530661583, -0.07599488645792007, -0.04587254673242569, 0.03525318205356598, 0.06301114708185196, 0.05171903595328331, 0.02169768139719963, -0.0015104572521522641, 0.04238929972052574, 0.016291264444589615, 0.025074128061532974, -0.01020618062466383, 0.014422627165913582, -0.0465494804084301, 0.01061770599335432, 0.03686492517590523, -0.020405005663633347, -0.025553792715072632, -0.045212775468826294, -0.023911381140351295, 0.01760086975991726, -0.059404198080301285, 0.05166023597121239, -0.011300880461931229, 0.03190958872437477, 0.014062171801924706, -0.024152694270014763, -0.022732803598046303, 0.04694798216223717, 0.05924198776483536, 0.032774847000837326, -0.023225629702210426, 0.03227130323648453, 0.011140485294163227, 0.0007890803972259164, 0.07409583032131195, 0.007500622887164354, -0.0001450295385438949, -0.003395577659830451, -0.048167500644922256, -0.003029355313628912, -0.012566729448735714, -0.009454349987208843, 0.0009939383016899228, 0.0052157011814415455, -0.010938802734017372, -0.04722125828266144, 0.00908903032541275, 0.017601361498236656, -0.04409441724419594, -0.011366713792085648, -0.013889751397073269, -0.05798245966434479, -0.0005853623733855784, -0.03307201340794563, -0.02264932543039322, 0.03882448002696037, -0.00015420795534737408, 0.03470867499709129, -0.018675286322832108, -0.05070303753018379, -0.05911053717136383, -0.03166896849870682, -0.01879613660275936, 0.011192315258085728, -0.011322921141982079, -0.009492157958447933, -0.028574584051966667, -0.017555834725499153, -0.03543549031019211, 0.06276768445968628, -0.0035556324291974306, 0.06390558183193207, -0.014713953249156475, 0.013008966110646725, 0.008795329369604588, -0.011972038075327873, 0.018378492444753647, 0.02637479081749916, 0.015564365312457085, -0.007502361666411161, -0.008344840258359909, 0.03339735418558121, -0.044239964336156845, -0.04530688747763634, 0.07229262590408325, -0.012414952740073204, -0.011550490744411945, 0.039035458117723465, -0.03653477132320404, 0.04343392327427864, 0.0004939817008562386, -0.052678048610687256, 0.02666432037949562, 0.031409408897161484, 0.025563620030879974, -0.031310148537158966, -0.06059395149350166, -0.016090743243694305, 0.05962064862251282, 0.021351812407374382, -0.022935591638088226, -0.0670257955789566, 0.009531375020742416, 0.00022955055464990437, -0.028954820707440376, -0.049538809806108475, -0.038085661828517914, -0.04571101441979408, 0.030809862539172173, -0.013777424581348896, -0.023919543251395226, -0.011113779619336128, 0.00035410202690400183, -0.047162242233753204, 0.05112338066101074, 0.06565665453672409, 0.04438873380422592, -0.012435133568942547, -0.01437332108616829, 0.10379871726036072, 0.05409448221325874, -0.029779357835650444, -0.04478706046938896, -0.020953387022018433, 0.039464227855205536, 0.031349729746580124, -0.02020443230867386, 0.04654854163527489, -0.033328842371702194, 0.04064907506108284, 0.034264422953128815, 0.041105516254901886, -0.019400397315621376, 0.06613112986087799, 0.046976812183856964, -0.017842736095190048, 0.03281940892338753, 0.004469138104468584, -0.05014011636376381, -0.019738368690013885, 0.018914593383669853, -0.02588503807783127, 0.02668433077633381, -0.005050056613981724, -0.06296756863594055, -0.006007547024637461, -0.0038405926898121834, 0.027508065104484558, 0.015678856521844864, 0.02367359772324562, 0.005248282104730606, 0.014677565544843674, -0.021862847730517387, 0.005040518008172512, -0.022793618962168694, -0.004928132053464651, 0.003117029555141926, 0.0030473426450043917, -0.007061811629682779, -0.052326831966638565, -0.0640164166688919, -0.017815012484788895, -0.002632801653817296, 0.011632372625172138, 0.05245932191610336, -0.010878761298954487, 0.07035311311483383, -0.020522089675068855, -0.015506274998188019, 0.0030721540097147226, 0.05566825345158577, 0.008397766388952732, -0.04006657376885414, 0.007079157046973705, 0.022767702117562294, 0.02667299099266529, 0.03422249108552933, 0.0033791435416787863, -0.011862101033329964, -0.0008525007287971675, -0.01211453415453434, -0.003714208025485277, 0.02666538953781128, -0.00984127912670374, -0.010892469435930252, -0.010576240718364716, -0.033675193786621094, 0.006554177030920982, 0.018541881814599037, -0.04773475602269173, -0.06097331643104553, -0.031998343765735626, -0.039613526314496994, 0.011219281703233719, 0.026463383808732033, 0.043333422392606735, -0.05429316312074661, -0.008538645692169666, 0.06686872243881226, -0.009264918975532055, -0.08373530209064484, -0.0016568955034017563, -0.011948637664318085, -0.1018616259098053, -0.019491562619805336, 0.07442177832126617, -0.0030494744423776865, 0.009269258007407188, -0.00042692915303632617, 0.02006036974489689, -0.006183283869177103, -0.006626229267567396, -0.029187913984060287, -0.0015571612166240811, 0.028159914538264275, 0.006360188126564026, -0.04676689952611923, 0.005566103849560022, 0.03876042738556862, -0.0038398075848817825, -0.02440696209669113, 0.019343696534633636, 0.008991832844913006, -0.007803597953170538, -0.005575168412178755, 0.00952958595007658, 0.03049459308385849, 0.005728892050683498, 0.01707541197538376, -0.019040891900658607, -0.010166826657950878, -0.018009359017014503, -0.034734245389699936, 0.02030208148062229, -0.04341089725494385, -0.002942824736237526, 0.012506434693932533, -0.046921417117118835, -0.026070335879921913, 0.05093192309141159, 0.031153058633208275, 0.09618732333183289, -0.06772931665182114, 0.031441010534763336, 0.04906638339161873, -0.010385080240666866, 0.002701450139284134, -0.0158152524381876, -0.0036632998380810022, -0.04399211332201958, 0.07081131637096405, 0.015317128971219063, -0.03310047462582588, 0.03195174038410187, 0.042309850454330444, -0.013290815986692905, -0.022853922098875046, -0.004599115811288357, 0.0019217372173443437, 0.03808325529098511, -0.007641992997378111, 0.018735656514763832, 0.0030850612092763186, 0.040228575468063354, -0.004366088192909956, 0.0650210827589035, 0.016758993268013, 0.05835588648915291, -0.01855284348130226, 0.026622993871569633, -0.034149881452322006, 0.03706562519073486, 0.040814358741045, -0.03440511226654053, -0.0013240622356534004, -0.014846793375909328, 0.0682154968380928, -0.02775256335735321, 0.047507427632808685, 0.025693269446492195, 0.00820562057197094, 0.025799918919801712, 0.017657890915870667, 0.018497271463274956, 0.0465618297457695, 0.017389317974448204, 0.02568434178829193, -0.00719538563862443, -0.02379586733877659, 0.0028379675932228565, 0.045417044311761856, 0.00033068552147597075, -0.049011748284101486, -0.038990866392850876, 0.037665314972400665, -0.007442296016961336, 0.02542467787861824, -0.04376446455717087, -0.010936710983514786, -0.003459626343101263, -0.010096228681504726, -0.04149450361728668, -0.00532967783510685, 0.011531203985214233, -0.06794749200344086, -0.06592574715614319, -0.010691532865166664, -0.031467754393815994, 0.001473620650358498, -0.01586008071899414, -0.033593758940696716, -0.041961438953876495, 0.030006589367985725, 0.0217241570353508, -0.021115288138389587, -0.00008522970892954618, 0.005564537830650806, 0.049402039498090744, -0.07268121093511581, 0.031073465943336487, -0.014151322655379772, 0.011205694638192654, 0.07512513548135757, 0.032964639365673065, -0.014059117063879967, -0.03274645656347275, -0.01811043545603752, -0.04711418226361275, 0.05069180950522423, 0.02132696472108364, 0.05853281170129776, -0.018635252490639687, 0.0038637486286461353, -0.010374978184700012, -0.00005244234125711955, -0.05340764299035072, -0.027586432173848152, -0.01175777893513441, 0.02303094044327736, 0.030086366459727287, 0.03296781703829765, 0.0017490799073129892, -0.019032221287488937, -0.019824350252747536, 0.02798633463680744, -0.01563171111047268, 0.08307995647192001, -0.008927161805331707, 0.021284189075231552, -0.06915374845266342, -0.013196287676692009, -0.013383802026510239, 0.0007214928045868874, -0.0766877755522728, -0.015168538317084312, 0.0074136704206466675, -0.037140849977731705, -0.024377232417464256, 0.022972537204623222, 0.07035016268491745, -0.03173040971159935, -0.013645865954458714, 0.037202317267656326, -0.03628169000148773, 0.031172586604952812, -0.01740982197225094, 0.01204320415854454, -0.02716921642422676, 0.018725266680121422, 0.004338198807090521, -0.031191280111670494, 0.03321243077516556, 0.03487955406308174, -0.004145625978708267, -0.01928103156387806, -0.05414881557226181, 0.006735216826200485, 0.04332755133509636, -0.039965298026800156, -0.0016938801854848862, 0.06899862736463547, 0.03728503733873367, 0.004571841564029455, -0.022497666999697685, -0.08115153014659882, 0.042740628123283386, -0.007989947684109211, -0.02895967848598957, 0.041799239814281464, 0.007615271490067244, -0.006962215527892113, -0.0011396129848435521, -0.07988165318965912, -0.012553003616631031, 0.026063406839966774, 0.022152218967676163, -0.046028174459934235, -0.044848714023828506, -0.004157185088843107, -0.031568802893161774, -0.03431040421128273, -0.06302081793546677, -0.051400136202573776, -0.05081505700945854, -0.018542278558015823, -0.031450968235731125, -0.052287470549345016, -0.01613398641347885, 0.02488297037780285, 0.013337284326553345, 0.005457199644297361, 0.005410205107182264, -0.004418747965246439, 0.04223550856113434, -0.034835316240787506, 0.0040485188364982605, -0.0024685051757842302, -0.01616804674267769, 0.09259731322526932, -0.012551961466670036, 0.009800623171031475, -0.031068328768014908, 0.011153255589306355, 0.010976974852383137, 0.009273231029510498, 0.012186984531581402, 0.022007621824741364, 0.013229025527834892, -0.028192805126309395, -0.02881736494600773, -0.021229878067970276, 0.03750577196478844, -0.037031352519989014, -0.05146634578704834, -0.049156226217746735, -0.011079219169914722, 0.005368960089981556, 0.03964768722653389, 0.017759304493665695, -0.011677218601107597, -0.021190643310546875, 0.07984272390604019, -0.012883379124104977, -0.0351305790245533, 0.02179870940744877, 0.0031027263030409813, 0.08206544071435928, -0.008631941862404346, -0.034985579550266266, -0.012234453111886978, 0.01856333576142788, 0.0007959168870002031, 0.040298230946063995, 0.0320257693529129, -0.0387902669608593, -0.021134817972779274, 0.01625259406864643, 0.01228442694991827, -0.06517666578292847, -0.003995298873633146, 0.00655259657651186, -0.006650680210441351, 0.0008100593695417047, 0.03851750120520592, 0.06056704744696617, -0.00526166008785367, -0.046704791486263275, 0.023412983864545822, 0.02305903285741806, -0.059394367039203644, -0.007665746379643679, -0.013149452395737171, -0.05122430995106697, -0.018914947286248207, 0.022119218483567238, 0.03935651108622551, -0.015460635535418987, -0.004329051356762648, 0.020143093541264534, -0.02650005742907524, 0.02674776315689087, -0.04919411987066269, 0.02240857668220997, 0.043076932430267334, 0.03658068925142288, 0.023494478315114975, -0.03957704082131386, -0.04506516829133034, 0.045996058732271194, 0.045439284294843674, 0.033633578568696976, -0.03832334652543068, -0.06589099764823914, 0.01771150343120098, 0.0148220369592309, -0.038634248077869415, -0.0179428830742836, -0.006635517347604036, 0.0921223908662796, 0.0049692681059241295, 0.0012608964461833239, 0.02771005779504776, -0.018815862014889717, 0.044362522661685944, 0.04075895622372627, -0.012776952236890793, -0.04503246396780014, -0.027549054473638535, -0.04473099485039711, 0.062062788754701614, -0.05855666100978851, -0.09027741849422455, 0.08247046172618866, -0.016436394304037094, -0.017836369574069977, 0.07608986645936966, 0.036396317183971405, -0.05292512848973274, -0.028524594381451607, -0.07175087928771973, 0.009161227382719517, -0.01919710822403431, 0.006227456498891115, 0.045679815113544464, -0.042551178485155106, -0.037055108696222305, -0.012106548994779587, -0.023359645158052444, -0.015502274967730045, -0.000682306825183332, -0.010951722972095013, -0.018511474132537842, 0.04528918117284775, 0.00983001384884119, -0.003417522180825472, -0.008180366829037666, -0.05035078525543213, -0.05277284234762192, -0.04978756606578827, -0.012616061605513096, 0.025549139827489853, -0.031343456357717514, 0.05322654917836189, 0.033633626997470856, -0.026284143328666687, 0.03171754255890846, 0.010989906266331673, -0.023291001096367836, 0.026332134380936623, -0.002222157549113035, 0.011098106391727924, -0.03705328702926636, -0.04253441467881203, -0.05574781075119972, 0.015953578054904938, 0.016699330881237984, 0.037209875881671906, 0.06107361242175102, -0.025143342092633247, -0.03581678494811058, 0.0101259620860219, 0.004640601109713316, 0.01974806934595108, -0.057000622153282166, 0.039316676557064056, 0.001134291640482843, -0.017539044842123985, 0.015289999544620514, 0.028163783252239227, 0.010480359196662903, 0.03814177215099335, -0.06247161701321602, -0.0647505670785904, 0.001119132968597114, 0.008833101019263268, -0.06049434095621109, -0.06826366484165192, 0.05185447633266449, -0.00024502110318280756, -0.03028830699622631, -0.015215937979519367, -0.005550040397793055, -0.005239582620561123, -0.0711485892534256, 0.008150615729391575, 0.04039569944143295, 0.005858285818248987, 0.017305901274085045, 0.0005748629337176681, -0.03783869743347168, -0.02722998335957527, -0.0011511484626680613, 0.03766758367419243, 0.009660770185291767, 0.06637842208147049, -0.027079330757260323, 0.0008234782726503909, 0.036167699843645096, -0.006325335707515478, 0.046663798391819, -0.028009578585624695, -0.020835822448134422, -0.013871978968381882, 0.03643443435430527, 0.030884595587849617, 0.04111068695783615, -0.02527482621371746, 0.018452374264597893, -0.016874583438038826, 0.022324103862047195, -0.03683166578412056, -0.030091896653175354, -0.01709992066025734, -0.044607896357774734, 0.012569164857268333, -0.0226841289550066, 0.06604364514350891, 0.07116443663835526, -0.01267636101692915, -0.018427347764372826, 0.10132957994937897, 0.03249664604663849, 0.05810811370611191, 0.07442452013492584, -0.07296057045459747, 0.019129417836666107, -0.05951246619224548, 0.028089139610528946, -0.08510732650756836, 0.06287665665149689, -0.0012369273463264108, 0.0740005373954773, 0.0011917001102119684, 0.040520474314689636, 0.03244634345173836, -0.019711226224899292, -0.03564383462071419, -0.016360081732273102, 0.07381845265626907, 0.039144180715084076, 0.006389108952134848, 0.018243031576275826, 0.06960131973028183, 0.04858612269163132, 0.038496412336826324, -0.07774215936660767, -0.020155267789959908, 0.06755239516496658, 0.05748497322201729, 0.01613970287144184, 0.04167497530579567, -0.026297995820641518, -0.02877323143184185, -0.06280061602592468, 0.023425763472914696, 0.018747782334685326, 0.009389474987983704, 0.05381004884839058, -0.014082933776080608, -0.010892805643379688, -0.08450876176357269, -0.022178612649440765, 0.037837523967027664, -0.03131292387843132, -0.027898505330085754, 0.057787466794252396, 0.09998077899217606, 0.033366668969392776, -0.007777221966534853, 0.04206901788711548, -0.019262859597802162, -0.024571862071752548, 0.021541515365242958, -0.030712012201547623, 0.012065639719367027, -0.046993374824523926, -0.01234965119510889, 0.03650600090622902, -0.022684289142489433, 0.007207885384559631, 0.023044200614094734, 0.01338278315961361, -0.06611928343772888, -0.06719228625297546, 0.04398959130048752, -0.004321937914937735, 0.0028553379233926535, 0.02323131263256073, 0.018395934253931046, -0.0015108749503269792, 0.016747288405895233, -0.01409935113042593, 0.011829606257379055, 0.02246585674583912, 0.030980417504906654, -0.056109972298145294, -0.03291477635502815, -0.002433359157294035, 0.012563236057758331, -0.01955408602952957, 0.019042644649744034, -0.03173526003956795, 0.06037545204162598, 0.0026148618198931217, 0.004021311178803444, 0.008161770179867744, -0.03932126611471176, 0.014420161955058575, -0.01922396942973137, -0.004960507154464722, -0.0032748973462730646, 0.028936445713043213, -0.03686373680830002, 0.017618410289287567, -0.020211609080433846, 0.018036168068647385, 0.03509305790066719, -0.050408151000738144, -0.006186428479850292, -0.008785536512732506, -0.03324688598513603, 0.02688073180615902, -0.06353271752595901, -0.05724111571907997, -0.02284364402294159, 0.03247709572315216, -0.02402033843100071, 0.06423582881689072, 0.03369320556521416, -0.0003292779147159308, -0.03508241847157478, 0.03499520197510719, -0.05770914629101753, 0.01735597476363182, 0.03860015794634819, 0.036268770694732666, 0.02500436082482338, -0.006123888306319714, -0.011978479102253914, 0.015825046226382256, 0.0677579790353775, -0.035112835466861725, -0.12540405988693237, 0.0230657160282135, -0.034048400819301605, -0.017850812524557114, -0.021351134404540062, 0.0776626318693161, 0.06186920404434204, 0.006921753287315369, 0.053125813603401184, -0.06365679949522018, -0.02955426648259163, -0.05303720757365227, -0.057236235588788986, 0.03523905202746391, 0.026139242574572563, 0.035560593008995056, 0.003516180207952857, 0.027853969484567642 ]
<p>Below is a function I wrote to try and tune the $\lambda$ and $\alpha$ elastic net GLM implemented with <code>cv.glmnet</code>. I've noticed that the qualitative outcome (in terms of the alpha that yields the lowest prediction error score) changes depending on the random seed, and I suspect this is mainly because the random seed determines how the folds are partitioned. In one of my datasets, I have only 598 samples and am fitting a Cox regression. That is where this effect is strongest (and, indeed, where the error bars about the prediction errors on the $\lambda$ search grid are largest). When I fit a binomial regression to a larger data set with about 30K observations, I get less jumping around. The number of folds doesn't seem to matter much.</p> <p>I'm thinking of just choosing $\alpha$ = 0.5 in such cases, because the absolute difference in the cross-validation error scores are often quite small, and elastic net has inferential properties that make it more desirable that LASSO or ridge on their own.</p> <p>Is this the right way of thinking? Thanks.</p> <pre><code>cvglmnet2a &lt;- function(x, y, family, nfolds, seed) { set.seed(seed) cvfit0 &lt;- cv.glmnet(x, y, family = family, alpha = 0, nfolds = nfolds) cvfitp5 &lt;- cv.glmnet(x, y, family = family, alpha = 0.5, nfolds = nfolds) cvfit1 &lt;- cv.glmnet(x, y, family = family, alpha = 1, nfolds = nfolds) plot(cvfit1); plot(cvfitp5); plot(cvfit0) plot(log(cvfit1$lambda), cvfit1$cvm, pch = 19, col = "red", xlab = "log(Lambda)", ylab = cvfit1$name) points(log(cvfitp5$lambda), cvfitp5$cvm, pch = 19, col = "grey") points(log(cvfit0$lambda), cvfit0$cvm, pch = 19, col = "blue") legend("topleft", legend = c("alpha = 1", "alpha = 0.5", "alpha = 0"), pch = 19, col = c("red", "grey", "blue")) mins &lt;- c(alpha1 = min(cvfit1$cvm), alphap5 = min(cvfitp5$cvm), alpha0 = min(cvfit0$cvm)) mins } </code></pre>
g37185
[ 0.045313697308301926, -0.013214115053415298, 0.008903507143259048, -0.03999583423137665, 0.035957954823970795, -0.03694711998105049, 0.03403239697217941, -0.01297738403081894, -0.05876815319061279, -0.048186492174863815, 0.03896309435367584, 0.004742449149489403, 0.05904855206608772, -0.013161960989236832, -0.041309915482997894, 0.04466394707560539, 0.05405896157026291, -0.010104982182383537, 0.012657870538532734, -0.04559050127863884, -0.03525904193520546, -0.008711923845112324, 0.0302235409617424, -0.06602568179368973, 0.009691569954156876, -0.0062241521663963795, -0.018993692472577095, 0.010213157162070274, -0.055285245180130005, 0.09737706184387207, -0.030065376311540604, -0.023415639996528625, -0.012704527005553246, -0.07585636526346207, -0.09152122586965561, 0.05073726549744606, 0.025609668344259262, 0.014049967750906944, -0.0128086032345891, -0.0026750853285193443, -0.0023944128770381212, 0.026036441326141357, 0.015360280871391296, 0.046495579183101654, -0.03366468846797943, 0.03692765533924103, 0.021046899259090424, 0.018831638619303703, 0.03858029469847679, -0.040514200925827026, -0.0076762475073337555, 0.04398573189973831, -0.024684548377990723, -0.007570992223918438, 0.04657447338104248, 0.05548686161637306, -0.00955922994762659, 0.05877024307847023, -0.010465442202985287, -0.01835562288761139, 0.029431870207190514, -0.03919891640543938, -0.019528163596987724, -0.032191675156354904, -0.046888913959264755, 0.01785723678767681, -0.050771333277225494, -0.04038843512535095, 0.019409313797950745, 0.01197563111782074, 0.008793416433036327, 0.020513352006673813, -0.008159806951880455, 0.011436689645051956, -0.013967618346214294, 0.001234814990311861, -0.06164048612117767, 0.04409163445234299, -0.001806609216146171, 0.04828298091888428, 0.027674324810504913, 0.056293752044439316, -0.11062152683734894, 0.010889516212046146, -0.011502714827656746, 0.007145149167627096, -0.004393197596073151, -0.013576523400843143, 0.008814138360321522, 0.056685712188482285, 0.03361359238624573, 0.02035689726471901, 0.030354006215929985, 0.05991987884044647, -0.058121465146541595, 0.008891858160495758, -0.05170022323727608, -0.01740734465420246, -0.002567955758422613, 0.02450772561132908, 0.04123799875378609, 0.038497816771268845, 0.02121327631175518, -0.021573016420006752, -0.06685194373130798, -0.026841316372156143, -0.004854653961956501, 0.001617320696823299, 0.003443203866481781, -0.011395023204386234, -0.055230651050806046, 0.06429281830787659, -0.04621695354580879, -0.0037850402295589447, -0.055282801389694214, -0.039372798055410385, 0.07852931320667267, 0.0037244230043143034, 0.022661687806248665, 0.03174213692545891, 0.07760688662528992, -0.00727710360661149, 0.06134716048836708, -0.02562738209962845, 0.029277442023158073, -0.01946907676756382, -0.021641120314598083, 0.050638239830732346, 0.015064611099660397, -0.009781246073544025, 0.03068925254046917, 0.02035488188266754, 0.03079640120267868, 0.018155649304389954, 0.010451194830238819, 0.01741667278110981, 0.01577627845108509, 0.028702320531010628, -0.0008082914282567799, 0.03726954758167267, -0.024461237713694572, 0.0012192892609164119, 0.02546561509370804, -0.033985111862421036, 0.01971898041665554, 0.022624900564551353, -0.0158886406570673, 0.011781468987464905, -0.02073369175195694, -0.04309213533997536, -0.03894379734992981, -0.0006414758390747011, -0.022759297862648964, -0.0012950150994583964, -0.01899663358926773, 0.037778668105602264, -0.003110539633780718, -0.04148257151246071, -0.004193452186882496, 0.03489586338400841, 0.024956442415714264, 0.0017806439427658916, 0.06905237585306168, -0.026220722123980522, 0.011354257352650166, 0.003780507715418935, -0.002095927018672228, 0.010105343535542488, -0.03909626603126526, -0.008675632998347282, -0.013206726871430874, 0.002644140971824527, 0.01969815045595169, 0.013742043636739254, 0.024936014786362648, 0.08367320150136948, 0.035365696996450424, 0.027688656002283096, 0.09474118798971176, -0.003726121736690402, 0.027996115386486053, 0.02411956898868084, 0.009927140548825264, -0.034581951797008514, -0.0025620246306061745, -0.05942922830581665, -0.023080388084053993, 0.01330347266048193, -0.05926961824297905, -0.028456110507249832, 0.0219833143055439, 0.030298037454485893, -0.0527237132191658, -0.0019609013106673956, 0.04157829284667969, -0.00664789043366909, 0.04112318530678749, -0.008449745364487171, -0.050101425498723984, 0.04358329623937607, -0.029293013736605644, -0.006280026864260435, 0.009667296893894672, 0.03555949777364731, -0.028245793655514717, 0.013574385084211826, -0.03262442722916603, -0.013593140058219433, -0.04714163765311241, 0.0025385685730725527, 0.021179571747779846, 0.002841708716005087, -0.06323734670877457, 0.050196681171655655, 0.003702052403241396, -0.0240810327231884, 0.0010989997535943985, -0.0015630844281986356, -0.004548763856291771, -0.01789521984755993, -0.03673239052295685, -0.06718771159648895, 0.00608472665771842, 0.003990690223872662, 0.008222907781600952, -0.031570207327604294, 0.03235727176070213, -0.012807561084628105, 0.05393374711275101, -0.0285547636449337, 0.00673323031514883, -0.01906249299645424, 0.0036916574463248253, -0.06206606328487396, 0.0141094159334898, -0.020789755508303642, -0.039284877479076385, 0.01187972817569971, 0.0354105606675148, 0.02920745126903057, 0.014131594449281693, 0.02851705439388752, -0.06449433416128159, -0.004849713761359453, -0.007879618555307388, 0.019882209599018097, 0.002077187178656459, -0.019927801564335823, 0.0026309352833777666, 0.05224614217877388, -0.009256371296942234, 0.043333858251571655, -0.01000088918954134, -0.008091255091130733, -0.05627564713358879, -0.048937488347291946, 0.007351126987487078, -0.0025403399486094713, 0.0007757703424431384, 0.0027612936682999134, -0.005229725502431393, 0.004532868042588234, 0.013534007593989372, -0.030897436663508415, -0.008970475755631924, -0.007555740419775248, 0.05753941088914871, -0.020914088934659958, -0.03656179457902908, 0.02134571596980095, -0.057364437729120255, 0.029921935871243477, 0.05305014178156853, 0.04641052708029747, 0.030107127502560616, 0.05762812867760658, -0.061095450073480606, 0.05761757865548134, 0.006445800885558128, -0.016453634947538376, -0.05980885773897171, -0.06245237588882446, -0.054572850465774536, 0.012502753175795078, 0.03889182209968567, -0.012342066504061222, 0.04736625403165817, 0.012241742573678493, 0.02198624610900879, 0.07608518749475479, 0.003543436760082841, -0.005826319567859173, -0.0020047142170369625, -0.009171656332910061, 0.029504947364330292, -0.04326917976140976, -0.029432928189635277, 0.015627726912498474, 0.010923909954726696, 0.03183101862668991, -0.052311740815639496, 0.017486484721302986, -0.006004145834594965, 0.04039767012000084, -0.007322607096284628, -0.03386588767170906, -0.049819331616163254, 0.017724717035889626, 0.046369560062885284, 0.01415724866092205, 0.040195032954216, -0.012761147692799568, 0.01230285968631506, -0.03915396332740784, -0.012301585637032986, -0.011887759901583195, 0.00003146384551655501, 0.0020314822904765606, -0.019799673929810524, -0.03196405619382858, -0.014304356649518013, -0.09030557423830032, -0.046853311359882355, 0.009983204305171967, -0.03333484008908272, 0.011848891153931618, -0.015491093508899212, 0.020947111770510674, 0.014910765923559666, -0.0035926373675465584, 0.03153606876730919, 0.053553782403469086, 0.0050734649412333965, 0.004422993864864111, 0.04098351672291756, -0.08904984593391418, -0.043947044759988785, -0.030740203335881233, 0.004686243832111359, 0.02520454116165638, -0.06559797376394272, -0.05840376764535904, 0.026363980025053024, -0.002078544581308961, -0.003258363576605916, 0.02156635746359825, -0.018030840903520584, -0.014768675900995731, -0.016896899789571762, 0.003026550868526101, -0.041548583656549454, -0.0537804514169693, -0.05439053848385811, 0.02549912966787815, 0.049143824726343155, -0.03451893851161003, 0.013975381851196289, -0.05920729041099548, 0.01001515332609415, -0.022606246173381805, 0.04619594290852547, -0.06218123063445091, 0.02363118715584278, -0.020558416843414307, 0.011563459411263466, 0.007114398293197155, 0.021601306274533272, 0.07719844579696655, 0.02709505520761013, 0.05855005234479904, 0.055402494966983795, 0.019238894805312157, 0.04723913595080376, 0.011192383244633675, 0.010784273035824299, 0.011950567364692688, 0.05436422675848007, -0.002161340555176139, -0.011119426228106022, 0.003772159805521369, 0.04376499354839325, 0.0018548679072409868, 0.01577804610133171, -0.004061173647642136, -0.029811132699251175, -0.013689936138689518, 0.014064406044781208, -0.0017795211169868708, 0.0017687842482700944, 0.005219331942498684, 0.00715113990008831, 0.004512068349868059, -0.05457557365298271, 0.007214841898530722, -0.007051503751426935, -0.011706826277077198, 0.03711691498756409, 0.0518643893301487, -0.03675041347742081, 0.08591818064451218, -0.030979126691818237, -0.0213013906031847, -0.0345422700047493, 0.0020079882815480232, 0.05018719658255577, -0.025422928854823112, -0.042377445846796036, 0.029112711548805237, -0.04307179152965546, -0.03524523600935936, 0.01824023388326168, -0.07352107018232346, 0.0041076927445828915, -0.06715913116931915, 0.06802702695131302, -0.053796350955963135, 0.015237897634506226, -0.025875220075249672, -0.006379301194101572, -0.01832297071814537, 0.028825953602790833, 0.03402799740433693, -0.06392482668161392, 0.0020490377210080624, 0.015643347054719925, 0.008335859514772892, 0.030778465792536736, -0.034165963530540466, 0.05809851735830307, -0.005982888396829367, 0.053797200322151184, 0.04122776538133621, -0.04199964925646782, 0.015969421714544296, -0.020240964367985725, 0.017039358615875244, 0.0012941646855324507, -0.0127042755484581, -0.024925075471401215, -0.009483514353632927, 0.005298401694744825, -0.06533059477806091, -0.05558526888489723, -0.03013557940721512, -0.026222525164484978, 0.021154165267944336, -0.05305255204439163, -0.011334252543747425, 0.00047375806025229394, 0.06068016216158867, 0.059844110161066055, -0.04010245203971863, 0.05065641924738884, 0.01449083536863327, 0.03737388923764229, 0.013375514186918736, 0.04757574200630188, 0.020230380818247795, 0.08863775432109833, 0.030842481181025505, -0.04570229351520538, 0.010396284982562065, -0.08125511556863785, -0.016580188646912575, 0.008325513452291489, 0.04942420870065689, -0.028943337500095367, -0.026392068713903427, 0.05481048300862312, 0.025961611419916153, 0.029185758903622627, 0.023212624713778496, 0.012555117718875408, -0.05425615981221199, -0.033092863857746124, 0.023864123970270157, 0.05492224544286728, 0.023560820147395134, 0.025400446727871895, 0.008057999424636364, -0.053139522671699524, -0.03391985967755318, -0.005406705662608147, -0.0622844435274601, -0.001694060512818396, -0.023647191002964973, 0.017299022525548935, -0.05612485110759735, -0.003641345538198948, 0.03358878940343857, 0.028647763654589653, 0.011676919646561146, -0.0025369536597281694, 0.06949412077665329, -0.008815349079668522, -0.044400908052921295, 0.02577468752861023, -0.034418582916259766, 0.01347152516245842, -0.019318049773573875, -0.029076214879751205, 0.1277838796377182, -0.036928724497556686, -0.07562118768692017, -0.00803224928677082, 0.01041853241622448, 0.06367967277765274, -0.03206126019358635, -0.028460294008255005, 0.015448348596692085, -0.04427897930145264, -0.021214867010712624, 0.05520329996943474, -0.019920039921998978, -0.0082706268876791, -0.05472616106271744, -0.007108638063073158, 0.019367141649127007, -0.026576420292258263, -0.019298138096928596, 0.059301916509866714, 0.021411778405308723, -0.009614046663045883, 0.021712185814976692, 0.0355021208524704, -0.005379943177103996, -0.03831969201564789, -0.0371837355196476, 0.0010004619834944606, -0.04215754568576813, 0.009754110127687454, 0.005211739335209131, -0.02861044928431511, 0.01293986663222313, 0.005180105566978455, -0.034576673060655594, -0.011756939813494682, 0.0023195715621113777, 0.005990140605717897, -0.09163908660411835, -0.04137379676103592, 0.04850991815328598, -0.01676422730088234, -0.03764203563332558, -0.09445101022720337, -0.009226805530488491, -0.038910772651433945, 0.011589267291128635, 0.04151692986488342, -0.09999868273735046, -0.026529625058174133, 0.014335875399410725, 0.0059126513078808784, 0.06041432544589043, -0.019115416333079338, 0.017843110486865044, -0.012935396283864975, -0.05044304206967354, -0.005104135721921921, 0.05665917694568634, -0.03253648430109024, -0.06071065366268158, 0.01635936088860035, -0.006786890793591738, 0.01911018416285515, 0.0007521091611124575, -0.04135133698582649, -0.024436572566628456, -0.0042720879428088665, 0.024092506617307663, 0.0035747853107750416, -0.03824580833315849, 0.016502244397997856, 0.061459098011255264, -0.04535891115665436, -0.012247258797287941, -0.0416414849460125, 0.008571763522922993, 0.022655747830867767, -0.062052223831415176, -0.030569467693567276, -0.016127489507198334, 0.041904158890247345, 0.0009787825401872396, -0.014007571153342724, 0.05094446241855621, -0.07388798147439957, -0.009926296770572662, 0.03646934777498245, -0.026825258508324623, -0.046102408319711685, 0.02515936642885208, 0.05199967697262764, 0.018428510054945946, -0.02609753981232643, 0.019702361896634102, -0.010415690951049328, -0.00040468733641318977, -0.053818073123693466, 0.014666423201560974, 0.0529702752828598, 0.010844998992979527, 0.0668141096830368, -0.017810001969337463, -0.025163251906633377, 0.014231901615858078, -0.028040330857038498, -0.02964155189692974, 0.03812405467033386, 0.009025138802826405, -0.01675167866051197, 0.03579651191830635, 0.05896091088652611, 0.025681281462311745, 0.007084597833454609, -0.04777676239609718, -0.07150287926197052, -0.002295542974025011, 0.023160628974437714, 0.03294334188103676, 0.05952081084251404, 0.01729777082800865, -0.04530394822359085, 0.029052667319774628, 0.008248218335211277, 0.02887495793402195, -0.005734434351325035, -0.04016571119427681, 0.09679581224918365, -0.030035581439733505, -0.03804950788617134, 0.083139568567276, -0.013551916927099228, 0.05804912745952606, -0.06831371784210205, 0.05917864665389061, -0.0845475122332573, 0.02838481031358242, 0.07018035650253296, 0.03906514123082161, 0.018217606469988823, 0.07259627431631088, -0.0011288393288850784, -0.011896864511072636, 0.02367546223104, 0.02248629555106163, 0.008803113363683224, 0.01496063731610775, -0.04741062968969345, 0.026646513491868973, 0.039864566177129745, 0.05132569000124931, 0.021114407107234, -0.05691174417734146, 0.028722181916236877, 0.047708068042993546, -0.01564175635576248, 0.04422169551253319, 0.003171842312440276, -0.010589954443275928, -0.07687152177095413, -0.018445318564772606, -0.020618412643671036, 0.0009410252678208053, -0.00041955700726248324, -0.007558585610240698, 0.003313498804345727, 0.0005724779330193996, -0.03609516844153404, -0.01763942651450634, 0.02066768705844879, -0.021849660202860832, -0.008794626221060753, 0.006431329529732466, 0.08054517209529877, -0.0624578483402729, -0.06909849494695663, -0.039038415998220444, -0.010288560763001442, 0.04249289631843567, -0.034675482660532, 0.0016997059574350715, 0.07439174503087997, 0.029873507097363472, 0.003539792727679014, 0.05728078633546829, -0.05538813769817352, 0.0021985783241689205, 0.03703687712550163, 0.0010784572223201394, -0.022834358736872673, -0.060328587889671326, -0.009293696843087673, 0.006543932482600212, -0.03490564972162247, 0.043058861047029495, -0.05722765624523163, 0.021322833374142647, 0.01678190752863884, 0.051848750561475754, 0.027485935017466545, -0.0018210327252745628, 0.000658604665659368, -0.032707300037145615, 0.017189471051096916, 0.014153796248137951, -0.058985162526369095, 0.016157854348421097, -0.02043939009308815, -0.07110876590013504, -0.03894248977303505, 0.011501717381179333, -0.03332637995481491, 0.03830835223197937, 0.06032698601484299, 0.038668062537908554, -0.002622614847496152, -0.0018755561904981732, -0.035443734377622604, 0.05453671142458916, -0.005571617279201746, 0.008211958222091198, 0.0003011835506185889, 0.045247338712215424, 0.04540783911943436, 0.024002496153116226, -0.016033025458455086, -0.008996916934847832, -0.027910394594073296, -0.0017893043113872409, -0.020961295813322067, -0.08347819000482559, -0.03723655268549919, -0.03071640059351921, 0.0012791738845407963, -0.007480144035071135, -0.0034585639368742704, 0.03153000399470329, -0.018180614337325096, 0.014849250204861164, -0.03281809389591217, 0.02320249006152153, -0.03883956000208855, 0.02819840796291828, 0.027156276628375053, 0.06099154055118561, -0.025984125211834908, 0.003768176306039095, -0.02742990478873253, -0.06637220084667206, 0.022374426946043968, -0.04202020540833473, -0.030763180926442146, 0.020637547597289085, -0.028129614889621735, 0.047845613211393356, -0.005770535208284855, 0.020156364887952805, -0.009763103909790516, 0.005014771595597267, -0.01744232513010502, -0.007294276729226112, -0.024292539805173874, 0.047658827155828476, -0.0086890934035182, 0.019567329436540604, 0.04005548357963562, 0.057248957455158234 ]
<p>In many econometrics model, the changes in the response variables in certain intervals are more difficult than other intervals. But I believe this is often not considered when estimating the model. </p> <p>For example, suppose $Y_{st}$ represents the proportion of students in a certain school $s$, passing a standardized test in year $t$. Let $R_{st}$ be the academic resources students (ex. books in library), and $I_{st}$ represent average parental income of the students. In this case $Y_{st} \in [0,1],$ and we would like to estimate effect of $R_{st}$ on $Y_{st}.$</p> <p>We could model this is as follows, </p> <p>$Y_{st} = \alpha_{0} +\alpha_{1}R_{st} + \alpha_{2}I_{st} + \delta_{t}+ u_{st}$, where $u_{st}$ is additive error term, and $\delta_{t}$ are time dummies. In this context of pass rates, intuitively it is more difficult for a school to increase the pass rates from 95% to 100%, then it is for them to go from 45% student passing, to 50% student passing. Consequently, the effect of $R_{st}$ on $Y_{st}$ should be given less weight on the latter situation (45% to 50%), than the former (95% to 100%). Suppose we were comparing two schools in which the same $R_{st}$ increase lead to these results, clearly the 95% to 100% school invested more efficiently. </p> <p>My idea is to use a multiplicative dummy variable with $R_{st}$, $\beta_{t}$, where $\beta_{t}$ takes on different values depending on the initial value of $Y_{st}.$ Is there a standard way to take this into consideration in the model? Are there other additional factors that could improve this model?</p>
g74338
[ -0.02281121537089348, 0.017842726781964302, -0.038611676543951035, -0.028266780078411102, -0.004145052749663591, -0.02683134377002716, 0.06867849826812744, 0.01004984974861145, 0.0013241865672171116, 0.029345225542783737, 0.0034765852615237236, 0.029447373002767563, 0.05268651247024536, 0.01744912378489971, 0.00044794738641940057, 0.018886767327785492, 0.05358143150806427, -0.07609335333108902, 0.007038540672510862, -0.023686464875936508, 0.021693116053938866, 0.0013450009282678366, 0.01051732525229454, -0.002481333212926984, 0.0032472098246216774, -0.01373019814491272, -0.04842415452003479, 0.03548717498779297, -0.07045046240091324, 0.04137391969561577, -0.07163815945386887, -0.021034961566329002, 0.05194548889994621, 0.009931454434990883, -0.0717548131942749, 0.015972109511494637, 0.05637160316109657, 0.0056231277994811535, -0.024790320545434952, 0.0020749454852193594, -0.025545304641127586, -0.003035989124327898, 0.05498515069484711, 0.0564260259270668, -0.03801627457141876, -0.045536477118730545, 0.013347713276743889, 0.005548916291445494, 0.010101165622472763, -0.026535453274846077, 0.008667019195854664, -0.029195617884397507, 0.004161729943007231, 0.04500269889831543, -0.036627404391765594, 0.01868598163127899, -0.011392989195883274, 0.015281228348612785, 0.021640494465827942, 0.07438363879919052, 0.04610570892691612, -0.02418900467455387, -0.032992277294397354, -0.035385191440582275, 0.04224669188261032, 0.038499616086483, -0.013787518255412579, 0.015660740435123444, 0.0338401161134243, -0.005700963549315929, -0.002708320040255785, 0.01992710679769516, -0.054570943117141724, -0.04886014759540558, -0.03511352837085724, -0.015389068983495235, -0.008961217477917671, -0.02501421980559826, -0.002704099752008915, 0.07198911905288696, -0.028467899188399315, 0.04741647467017174, 0.013645933009684086, 0.06514807045459747, 0.028659945353865623, 0.0040657189674675465, 0.045826733112335205, -0.00980101153254509, 0.033076249063014984, -0.02244468592107296, 0.008933540433645248, 0.026593610644340515, 0.03806033730506897, 0.04612787067890167, -0.011287262663245201, -0.05473450943827629, -0.057107049971818924, -0.007671168074011803, 0.01364421658217907, 0.035980429500341415, 0.019420279189944267, 0.00036481372080743313, 0.014114528894424438, -0.031655509024858475, -0.031360600143671036, -0.04379567503929138, 0.04853687435388565, -0.009273502044379711, -0.045794934034347534, -0.01889594830572605, -0.0029369427356868982, 0.006821261253207922, -0.017120428383350372, -0.046756964176893234, -0.0033690521959215403, -0.030830534175038338, 0.01835673488676548, -0.02159644104540348, -0.03216671571135521, -0.003977547865360975, -0.0052877929992973804, -0.00005121306094224565, -0.018278377130627632, 0.07122179120779037, -0.024169987067580223, -0.029462618753314018, -0.09669245034456253, 0.0934717208147049, 0.04111183062195778, 0.015431401319801807, 0.011245817877352238, -0.0018770511960610747, -0.02552231028676033, 0.02547050081193447, 0.013345756568014622, 0.06310350447893143, 0.0027798956725746393, 0.03920987993478775, 0.007472185418009758, 0.07198332250118256, -0.06028908118605614, -0.007482198067009449, 0.0232438612729311, -0.016784120351076126, -0.05076796934008598, 0.01175813376903534, 0.017922276630997658, 0.016179926693439484, -0.0017781155183911324, -0.01851113699376583, 0.03445376083254814, 0.0325561985373497, 0.004326913505792618, 0.05569307878613472, -0.0564841590821743, 0.04766721650958061, 0.015138515271246433, -0.04148377105593681, -0.004376176744699478, 0.02309970185160637, 0.016938697546720505, -0.028106683865189552, -0.02033945545554161, 0.034012824296951294, -0.03295161575078964, 0.06259013712406158, 0.008667435497045517, -0.01872113347053528, -0.03680812194943428, -0.02064288966357708, 0.03986499831080437, 0.0019067645771428943, -0.016077857464551926, -0.029499979689717293, 0.012443928979337215, 0.040061499923467636, 0.06523431092500687, -0.023260779678821564, -0.00715962890535593, 0.02089625410735607, -0.03451220691204071, -0.033038180321455, -0.038490694016218185, -0.03423826023936272, 0.027538703754544258, -0.03874169662594795, 0.010402865707874298, -0.0055124880746006966, -0.067348912358284, -0.0065143294632434845, 0.00007296255353139713, 0.010068792849779129, 0.053177088499069214, -0.011728323996067047, -0.04718935489654541, -0.01648329570889473, 0.07184294611215591, -0.018418969586491585, 0.014548189006745815, 0.07075157761573792, -0.01885800063610077, 0.010285243391990662, 0.042034365236759186, -0.02166782133281231, 0.004368944093585014, 0.032074909657239914, -0.02152770757675171, -0.03490376099944115, -0.03761029615998268, -0.010278022848069668, 0.042522821575403214, -0.013324377126991749, -0.007298580836504698, 0.025530582293868065, 0.030216297134757042, -0.003000720404088497, -0.007274959236383438, 0.0352129302918911, 0.02273424342274666, 0.003492087358608842, -0.029665280133485794, -0.05583073943853378, 0.06788157671689987, 0.005128645803779364, -0.019422216340899467, 0.019930994138121605, 0.014784236438572407, -0.023207999765872955, -0.022969834506511688, 0.06854641437530518, -0.03576763719320297, -0.007699985988438129, 0.0011094415094703436, -0.04985954985022545, 0.032512910664081573, 0.006417446304112673, 0.019930191338062286, -0.00850625615566969, -0.0070921373553574085, 0.028172798454761505, 0.03179442510008812, 0.07053448259830475, -0.011823371984064579, 0.019943684339523315, -0.0056871892884373665, -0.037732359021902084, -0.013827220536768436, -0.006458132993429899, -0.0019563136156648397, 0.042290542274713516, -0.051299504935741425, 0.08667308837175369, -0.03294069319963455, -0.04016679897904396, 0.0303813349455595, -0.02906936965882778, 0.01678190566599369, 0.01693577505648136, 0.023112703114748, 0.022923890501260757, -0.011638049967586994, 0.021042577922344208, 0.02741052396595478, 0.03414485603570938, 0.02345246635377407, -0.01902857981622219, 0.001898043556138873, -0.04765595868229866, -0.026061484590172768, 0.0036646395456045866, -0.011416422203183174, 0.0030805107671767473, -0.000024093567844829522, 0.04784815385937691, 0.009284772910177708, -0.01882484182715416, -0.03936522454023361, -0.06078337877988815, 0.0501352995634079, -0.0043342458084225655, -0.015735331922769547, -0.00928964652121067, -0.04942373186349869, 0.015509453602135181, 0.056016456335783005, 0.01549705769866705, 0.06849333643913269, -0.006452230736613274, -0.02167653478682041, 0.020476756617426872, -0.08389223366975784, 0.030978210270404816, 0.028803763911128044, -0.0035220561549067497, 0.03311523050069809, 0.045139286667108536, 0.03949350491166115, -0.05465085804462433, 0.005015883594751358, 0.04599495604634285, -0.05128837376832962, 0.02351566031575203, -0.04612940549850464, 0.022979533299803734, -0.0006450819782912731, -0.028732599690556526, -0.0004762581083923578, 0.01705949194729328, 0.004123561084270477, 0.0048564039170742035, -0.01277981512248516, -0.03748251125216484, -0.0055690654553473, -0.03695858642458916, -0.037110283970832825, -0.04305851086974144, -0.018047131597995758, 0.026264125481247902, 0.03655453398823738, 0.013778657652437687, 0.05475578084588051, -0.05322469398379326, 0.0026948878075927496, 0.047843459993600845, -0.05335052311420441, -0.008713189512491226, -0.05560877546668053, 0.0008118455298244953, -0.11606646329164505, 0.018242748454213142, 0.012369783595204353, -0.02423328347504139, -0.04070980101823807, -0.026307756081223488, -0.01964433118700981, 0.015870437026023865, 0.04878074675798416, 0.01746376045048237, 0.02505437843501568, 0.026360876858234406, 0.0018535710405558348, 0.020274585112929344, 0.000974259281065315, 0.048793867230415344, -0.04260079562664032, -0.042725175619125366, 0.03160163015127182, -0.016284093260765076, 0.027389053255319595, 0.008652528747916222, 0.01226442214101553, -0.0030900738202035427, 0.0042495219968259335, -0.03160193935036659, 0.04993836581707001, -0.0016722604632377625, 0.08658240735530853, 0.03662135824561119, -0.011570656672120094, -0.017343072220683098, 0.06924843043088913, -0.067491315305233, -0.03567017987370491, 0.08439547568559647, -0.009042598307132721, 0.06152108684182167, 0.05819898471236229, 0.05745702236890793, 0.033285368233919144, -0.00839577242732048, 0.008591463789343834, 0.10053828358650208, 0.03336303308606148, 0.035870231688022614, 0.003246493171900511, -0.05416421219706535, 0.020870212465524673, 0.030384749174118042, -0.018809664994478226, 0.012274548411369324, 0.04110635071992874, -0.0224376879632473, -0.04124175012111664, -0.03358398750424385, 0.01338693592697382, -0.07937340438365936, 0.018645158037543297, -0.04129122942686081, 0.014943004585802555, -0.013610782101750374, -0.016980133950710297, -0.015976790338754654, -0.027601437643170357, 0.022431695833802223, 0.03683305159211159, -0.02616317942738533, 0.0032684849575161934, -0.025507090613245964, 0.021842865273356438, 0.04099367931485176, -0.013965681195259094, -0.020665138959884644, 0.023506172001361847, 0.020541323348879814, -0.07068320363759995, 0.03222714364528656, 0.017263872548937798, -0.011524545960128307, -0.03187228739261627, -0.0494510754942894, -0.049387626349925995, -0.056655433028936386, -0.050419583916664124, -0.028760012239217758, -0.012011268176138401, 0.03396163135766983, 0.0627632737159729, 0.015427062287926674, 0.003561426419764757, 0.005043545737862587, 0.0005541144637390971, 0.054981499910354614, -0.057717107236385345, -0.008383980952203274, 0.03464271128177643, 0.036308158189058304, 0.0426628477871418, -0.0025436461437493563, -0.002550726057961583, -0.06422293931245804, -0.017338039353489876, 0.055766183882951736, -0.053026098757982254, 0.09362576901912689, 0.016056496649980545, -0.002741373609751463, -0.04656166955828667, -0.004344890359789133, 0.00693803746253252, -0.0678124949336052, -0.024796200916171074, 0.029541729018092155, -0.048305656760931015, -0.018455781042575836, 0.02623751014471054, 0.042908668518066406, -0.043709736317396164, -0.04717327654361725, 0.02252197451889515, -0.002574456622824073, -0.06158142536878586, 0.06526820361614227, 0.03260955959558487, -0.0066179693676531315, 0.013615094125270844, -0.05520248785614967, 0.018929151818156242, 0.032441381365060806, 0.04761845991015434, 0.061644092202186584, -0.017900699749588966, 0.03187352046370506, -0.03267594054341316, -0.020350690931081772, -0.035366401076316833, -0.025197388604283333, -0.02157578058540821, -0.031616080552339554, 0.02297387830913067, 0.01733417622745037, -0.0025719315744936466, -0.003065885044634342, 0.023558538407087326, 0.04191502556204796, 0.031520817428827286, -0.0011231970274820924, -0.05918367952108383, 0.01989966817200184, 0.019628793001174927, -0.03769199550151825, -0.055932097136974335, -0.0697660818696022, -0.001503844396211207, 0.020214034244418144, -0.012639319524168968, -0.023892126977443695, 0.0064889416098594666, -0.08857032656669617, 0.06966681778430939, -0.03953523188829422, 0.03774087503552437, 0.027261216193437576, 0.03369199484586716, 0.017267905175685883, -0.030627939850091934, 0.011668059043586254, 0.040429431945085526, 0.03190086409449577, 0.05176951363682747, -0.002196339890360832, -0.07689756900072098, 0.06926193833351135, 0.017437642440199852, -0.04139561578631401, -0.013364771381020546, -0.006833371706306934, -0.003586904611438513, -0.011699654161930084, -0.02050868794322014, 0.0761735737323761, -0.00300229643471539, 0.04808748513460159, -0.00982295535504818, -0.01504901796579361, -0.08318371325731277, -0.019523391500115395, -0.035472605377435684, 0.023153387010097504, 0.04091990739107132, -0.042327988892793655, 0.10034377872943878, -0.018497774377465248, -0.02652529999613762, 0.03252917900681496, 0.06172647327184677, -0.008293005637824535, 0.00006725545972585678, -0.054529573768377304, -0.01659471169114113, -0.06671746075153351, 0.042051464319229126, 0.004094503819942474, -0.100673146545887, 0.024165403097867966, 0.025913884863257408, 0.0319952555000782, -0.0470861941576004, -0.010594218969345093, -0.0017265782225877047, 0.002378711011260748, -0.06436531245708466, 0.040863581001758575, 0.07078175991773605, -0.010172765702009201, 0.021792054176330566, -0.030843842774629593, -0.02389531582593918, -0.04839730262756348, -0.00937233678996563, -0.0356900654733181, -0.006951385643333197, -0.01597437635064125, 0.02184118703007698, -0.001365612493827939, -0.032786957919597626, 0.036542635411024094, 0.0022328596096485853, 0.016781868413090706, 0.018439851701259613, -0.017199566587805748, -0.042479682713747025, -0.0362897664308548, 0.023209141567349434, 0.04024036228656769, 0.037639010697603226, -0.03500891849398613, -0.004560426343232393, -0.06166818365454674, 0.017904506996273994, -0.02012489177286625, 0.0264109019190073, -0.0703127458691597, 0.02057448960840702, -0.01617911458015442, -0.033907875418663025, 0.01431966107338667, -0.0038421216886490583, -0.033802710473537445, 0.03503374382853508, -0.0031205429695546627, -0.057739805430173874, -0.005796425510197878, -0.03282526135444641, 0.01557608786970377, -0.04111207649111748, 0.03321819379925728, 0.012636230327188969, 0.008026189170777798, -0.0075240288861095905, -0.026624629274010658, -0.05398111417889595, -0.05136122554540634, 0.030800066888332367, -0.025794239714741707, -0.005910816136747599, 0.007792362943291664, -0.020716790109872818, 0.022535061463713646, 0.009879528544843197, -0.026021907106041908, 0.01258397288620472, -0.02618218958377838, 0.08587870001792908, -0.08397369831800461, 0.055096909403800964, -0.030923450365662575, -0.02784840762615204, -0.009982257150113583, 0.009169591590762138, 0.022765090689063072, -0.02590886875987053, 0.004212398547679186, 0.07120217382907867, 0.10804363340139389, -0.0009358834940940142, -0.01444727648049593, -0.018821587786078453, 0.008425185456871986, -0.04472547769546509, -0.01244447287172079, 0.024216312915086746, -0.044256873428821564, 0.02894323132932186, -0.04551728814840317, 0.048085350543260574, -0.01724483259022236, -0.03409469500184059, -0.06613347679376602, -0.018577372655272484, -0.04544275254011154, 0.005605337209999561, -0.006949741393327713, -0.014424961060285568, 0.03379187732934952, -0.059010099619627, 0.06308156251907349, -0.016240408644080162, 0.04305736720561981, -0.05118044838309288, 0.042923375964164734, -0.020100325345993042, 0.027505621314048767, 0.017936374992132187, 0.01956593245267868, -0.010169989429414272, -0.009099050424993038, 0.04057282209396362, 0.0674825981259346, -0.04112740978598595, 0.007601514458656311, 0.02706163562834263, 0.005383751355111599, -0.03353995457291603, -0.017534490674734116, 0.03614726662635803, 0.011509525589644909, 0.049740877002477646, 0.01999483071267605, 0.09837859123945236, 0.018216900527477264, 0.0085024144500494, -0.08716775476932526, -0.021111829206347466, 0.038060497492551804, 0.02301117032766342, 0.044157546013593674, -0.011776706203818321, -0.0037809202913194895, 0.0319083072245121, -0.01633167639374733, 0.045302215963602066, -0.03472011163830757, -0.030767297372221947, 0.022244703024625778, 0.02394040860235691, -0.006659925915300846, -0.029986372217535973, 0.002217489294707775, -0.0133413877338171, -0.042383529245853424, 0.005495248828083277, -0.04059257730841637, 0.004907726775854826, -0.046125102788209915, 0.004456913098692894, 0.03565225750207901, 0.002536062616854906, -0.005093483719974756, 0.02521793358027935, 0.01736212708055973, -0.048019327223300934, 0.026267312467098236, 0.008857609704136848, 0.03733982518315315, -0.041324641555547714, 0.03900047019124031, -0.0031633961480110884, 0.03821558877825737, -0.014848489314317703, 0.052197955548763275, 0.004491119645535946, -0.007774950936436653, -0.025514429435133934, -0.03339076042175293, 0.04760220646858215, 0.014168160036206245, -0.02046969160437584, -0.06576451659202576, -0.025305718183517456, -0.04891008511185646, 0.011468105018138885, 0.022551923990249634, 0.004902692046016455, 0.022806407883763313, 0.002411643275991082, -0.06459235399961472, -0.03684850409626961, -0.027329610660672188, -0.026460910215973854, 0.002814838197082281, -0.02807152271270752, -0.0766812339425087, -0.0227388683706522, -0.0020955309737473726, 0.04537079483270645, -0.08590696007013321, -0.004558578599244356, -0.012998027727007866, -0.006421507336199284, 0.03492723032832146, 0.00896320678293705, -0.03941923752427101, -0.042131077498197556, -0.015982644632458687, 0.0413496159017086, 0.008082888089120388, 0.046795185655355453, -0.007668440230190754, -0.04618231579661369, 0.04055172577500343, -0.056084904819726944, -0.024918608367443085, 0.0298295971006155, 0.07853534817695618, -0.005056733265519142, 0.047969602048397064, 0.032126955687999725, 0.05168505012989044, -0.0075946468859910965, -0.01838354766368866, -0.0835384726524353, 0.015546491369605064, -0.014464357867836952, 0.04004671424627304, 0.006779679097235203, 0.03221500664949417, -0.01556061115115881, -0.01727372780442238, -0.045286644250154495, -0.03631133958697319, -0.04157660901546478, 0.041373319923877716, -0.05940958857536316, -0.018205871805548668, 0.0019799654837697744, -0.0046159145422279835, 0.008580300956964493, 0.005317795556038618 ]
<p>I have a list of numbers I need to group by similarity (differences being 1 between each). For example, in a list of [198, 202, 207, 218, 219, 220], 190 would be put into a list, 202 would be put into another list, 207, into a list, and 218 219 220 into another list.</p>
g74339
[ 0.0035494561307132244, 0.028927259147167206, 0.01701764576137066, -0.08969175815582275, 0.04808039590716362, -0.019701402634382248, -0.0391010046005249, 0.005875305272638798, -0.05288955569267273, -0.028229204937815666, -0.015072710812091827, 0.0042119817808270454, -0.022535674273967743, -0.000755488348659128, -0.010107739828526974, -0.0038277406711131334, 0.052926234900951385, 0.0013819161104038358, -0.019399307668209076, 0.004968800116330385, 0.02722596563398838, 0.026621658354997635, -0.0009311492322012782, -0.017619093880057335, -0.017263304442167282, -0.0210501067340374, 0.02820608764886856, -0.02536335587501526, -0.04415663331747055, 0.03262842819094658, -0.014358359389007092, 0.021097827702760696, 0.010834623128175735, -0.03971510007977486, 0.006540680304169655, -0.02336416207253933, -0.010106849484145641, -0.03081517294049263, 0.06534827500581741, 0.06880288571119308, -0.011876808479428291, 0.03211696818470955, 0.02772793546319008, 0.002112369518727064, 0.03020258992910385, -0.06754182279109955, 0.0009688333375379443, -0.01770721934735775, 0.06264182180166245, -0.004983675200492144, 0.03614494204521179, 0.06281065195798874, -0.020124221220612526, -0.005782744847238064, -0.01104625966399908, -0.003957325126975775, 0.022114692255854607, 0.005540742073208094, 0.025031263008713722, 0.07886210083961487, 0.010167308151721954, 0.02029399760067463, 0.008316817693412304, 0.008650091476738453, -0.02148384414613247, 0.057925861328840256, 0.00639698002487421, 0.0000045445481191563886, -0.019243810325860977, 0.005396498832851648, -0.06795278936624527, 0.0404263474047184, 0.04481734335422516, 0.06864175200462341, -0.062146395444869995, 0.007932066917419434, 0.03347593545913696, -0.01616821251809597, 0.010304436087608337, 0.06048641353845596, 0.030991269275546074, 0.027952926233410835, 0.005210021045058966, 0.015899229794740677, -0.018794983625411987, -0.024652745574712753, 0.010677539743483067, 0.0306855496019125, -0.009882382117211819, 0.0612272173166275, -0.02164815366268158, -0.022721808403730392, 0.0037614016328006983, 0.03956746682524681, 0.015615950338542461, 0.03320804238319397, -0.043940503150224686, 0.03744399920105934, -0.03878401592373848, -0.06410830467939377, 0.03961729630827904, 0.037318769842386246, 0.043009188026189804, -0.11127602308988571, -0.06027783825993538, -0.004138566553592682, 0.08135783672332764, 0.008831626735627651, 0.00716327503323555, -0.001326107420027256, 0.03704925626516342, -0.017581921070814133, -0.04173411428928375, -0.05727851018309593, 0.05093545466661453, -0.024332750588655472, 0.022646017372608185, -0.0483730286359787, -0.006919334642589092, -0.05928010120987892, 0.049235161393880844, -0.05323029309511185, 0.02606004662811756, 0.03853011131286621, 0.009886404499411583, -0.03647352755069733, 0.02883521094918251, -0.0004753297253046185, 0.06503962725400925, -0.0763869658112526, 0.004265410825610161, -0.0733378678560257, -0.006025254726409912, -0.026722770184278488, -0.09271072596311569, -0.025632724165916443, 0.026670120656490326, -0.004094674717634916, -0.010116050951182842, 0.012933040037751198, -0.016735628247261047, -0.00565394526347518, 0.0017570402706041932, -0.005779902916401625, -0.01910478062927723, -0.01642497628927231, -0.1332710236310959, -0.0329391211271286, 0.016210004687309265, 0.021572815254330635, -0.009637058712542057, 0.004109544679522514, -0.020036591216921806, 0.0367102324962616, 0.0023705509956926107, -0.01737700030207634, 0.04454205557703972, 0.07625144720077515, 0.026399560272693634, -0.0011017569340765476, -0.03222432732582092, -0.04636427015066147, -0.01844239979982376, 0.005877922289073467, -0.009494790807366371, -0.005975573323667049, 0.03455985710024834, -0.021579043939709663, -0.00512113980948925, -0.01936526596546173, -0.008932162076234818, 0.006412464659661055, -0.02255345694720745, 0.005431856960058212, 0.0194172952324152, 0.019696971401572227, 0.017026137560606003, -0.023875229060649872, 0.044147275388240814, -0.015426737256348133, -0.058573223650455475, -0.004936165641993284, 0.028044279664754868, 0.013056405819952488, 0.00816418882459402, 0.04624895751476288, -0.056093402206897736, -0.04180119186639786, -0.052406083792448044, 0.014596791937947273, 0.004499256610870361, -0.025467246770858765, -0.022933105006814003, -0.03738494589924812, 0.017923271283507347, -0.016231928020715714, 0.014179328456521034, -0.02216498740017414, -0.022868219763040543, -0.016041548922657967, -0.005318396259099245, -0.024266427382826805, 0.009324471466243267, 0.02328404039144516, 0.0490211546421051, 0.003715777536854148, -0.003014463698491454, -0.01906571537256241, 0.03559696301817894, 0.04478173702955246, -0.023439845070242882, -0.034698035567998886, 0.04142117500305176, -0.0103374645113945, -0.04473387449979782, -0.014443382620811462, 0.01389424316585064, 0.041224297136068344, -0.02658899687230587, 0.027265332639217377, -0.02033008262515068, -0.001649982761591673, 0.027960404753684998, -0.01860092580318451, -0.0050738053396344185, 0.02149190567433834, 0.010444383136928082, 0.03604627400636673, 0.00042052051867358387, -0.028154069557785988, -0.027166983112692833, 0.03502510115504265, -0.03201226145029068, -0.07833734154701233, -0.0042437599040567875, -0.0025445139035582542, -0.019965816289186478, 0.015331419184803963, -0.029446059837937355, -0.003731146454811096, 0.006546386517584324, -0.02715979889035225, 0.026421429589390755, 0.011739351786673069, -0.028390994295477867, -0.03654065355658531, 0.0020252654794603586, 0.0070700617507100105, -0.01310100220143795, 0.04497483745217323, -0.05763477832078934, 0.04871265962719917, -0.04118642956018448, 0.013485061004757881, 0.039188873022794724, -0.043958574533462524, -0.009160461835563183, 0.030453164130449295, 0.10946761071681976, -0.03445746377110481, -0.009790637530386448, -0.0377783440053463, 0.05522463098168373, 0.018055828288197517, -0.038773294538259506, -0.026658538728952408, 0.05164409428834915, -0.02849431522190571, 0.0286264568567276, -0.04953571781516075, -0.008584740571677685, 0.016379036009311676, 0.05800318717956543, -0.002732945140451193, -0.060169775038957596, 0.006228947080671787, 0.033053841441869736, -0.0167620200663805, -0.05371352657675743, 0.003659922629594803, 0.03602943196892738, -0.026035713031888008, -0.011628719046711922, 0.02198747545480728, 0.029158202931284904, -0.009884404018521309, 0.006838700268417597, 0.01635660044848919, -0.008860116824507713, 0.05525503307580948, -0.03190694749355316, -0.0064886524342000484, 0.07021168619394302, -0.02139412984251976, 0.12487231194972992, 0.008180040866136551, 0.04692536219954491, 0.0019681404810398817, -0.04240981116890907, -0.017754830420017242, -0.04792244732379913, -0.004015632439404726, 0.059780143201351166, 0.007794550154358149, -0.0015117247821763158, -0.015298636630177498, -0.020582571625709534, 0.013290002942085266, -0.009992539882659912, 0.0020653139799833298, -0.03931745886802673, 0.007397971116006374, 0.010977708734571934, -0.03416333347558975, 0.030160225927829742, -0.02406943030655384, -0.006916537880897522, -0.0034084527287632227, -0.0045110615901649, -0.02193077839910984, -0.02130081132054329, -0.05477997288107872, 0.061763644218444824, -0.025496434420347214, 0.05006064847111702, 0.08859820663928986, -0.012414064258337021, -0.01608099229633808, -0.06190858781337738, -0.010391360148787498, -0.03457540273666382, -0.017895404249429703, -0.03752908855676651, -0.012191693298518658, -0.017229897901415825, 0.029014727100729942, 0.0032887489069253206, -0.06228714808821678, 0.030717164278030396, 0.035948608070611954, -0.004809210542589426, 0.008626822382211685, -0.013429462909698486, -0.006386640015989542, -0.022457320243120193, 0.01958528906106949, 0.0714326724410057, 0.0580042265355587, 0.026085611432790756, 0.009870361536741257, 0.023537620902061462, -0.003519970690831542, 0.0034343095030635595, -0.052627742290496826, 0.020769134163856506, -0.02126006968319416, 0.008934244513511658, -0.05674215033650398, -0.014163726009428501, 0.05197817087173462, 0.059159066528081894, 0.011492006480693817, -0.03273918479681015, -0.0393734835088253, -0.03186895325779915, -0.000049433969252277166, 0.010116050019860268, -0.010817715898156166, 0.03639807552099228, -0.03279222548007965, 0.04373931884765625, 0.0021081070881336927, 0.017575692385435104, -0.018021441996097565, 0.02267257682979107, 0.029681697487831116, 0.09569370001554489, 0.05391949415206909, -0.019858064129948616, 0.01508629135787487, 0.005387232638895512, -0.03224989399313927, -0.019793525338172913, 0.009336065500974655, 0.04058445617556572, -0.03503783792257309, 0.027144672349095345, 0.027120282873511314, 0.0051085809245705605, 0.03311406075954437, -0.009785189293324947, -0.03858713060617447, -0.014037738554179668, 0.0003068795194849372, 0.007004032842814922, -0.05099094286561012, -0.06579218059778214, 0.029267240315675735, -0.0386333093047142, 0.0783182829618454, -0.05550618842244148, -0.09461196511983871, -0.007000860292464495, 0.0249041561037302, -0.033630482852458954, -0.033221855759620667, -0.024479106068611145, -0.02815200202167034, -0.008989561349153519, -0.02145090512931347, -0.07115951180458069, -0.015637006610631943, 0.03308270126581192, 0.006358466576784849, 0.0031726923771202564, 0.03764267638325691, 0.07225161045789719, 0.03744695708155632, -0.009648177772760391, 0.04282129928469658, -0.05621698126196861, 0.06699830293655396, -0.03716646507382393, -0.021660752594470978, 0.00748216500505805, -0.029169384390115738, 0.027372263371944427, 0.01517868135124445, 0.02390616573393345, -0.015596000477671623, -0.013877011835575104, 0.020897511392831802, 0.00882018357515335, -0.03479444608092308, 0.02737998217344284, -0.07485692203044891, -0.056576378643512726, -0.010419337078928947, -0.005231095477938652, 0.010010160505771637, 0.000561530701816082, 0.06065744534134865, -0.013401846401393414, 0.01868414133787155, 0.029396772384643555, 0.05326002836227417, -0.06607665121555328, 0.054100148379802704, -0.023743731901049614, 0.08775760978460312, -0.0013950614957138896, -0.026387717574834824, -0.057408690452575684, -0.05079637095332146, 0.013338925316929817, 0.0506182499229908, 0.01173652708530426, -0.03887477144598961, -0.0029584323056042194, -0.006424267776310444, 0.016524937003850937, 0.014149480499327183, 0.006139629054814577, -0.046823907643556595, -0.007179674692451954, -0.01797046698629856, -0.050637926906347275, 0.04334643483161926, -0.00864703580737114, 0.055681176483631134, 0.0582534596323967, -0.03920254111289978, -0.08013178408145905, -0.0116727938875556, 0.021611681208014488, 0.0000734985587769188, 0.003632166190072894, -0.03799901530146599, -0.015490712597966194, -0.06417856365442276, 0.01922968588769436, -0.017483755946159363, 0.03723122552037239, 0.0017867630813270807, 0.00478853564709425, -0.02704944647848606, -0.016539858654141426, 0.0029357625171542168, 0.06803853809833527, -0.05794632062315941, 0.01434039045125246, 0.009065879508852959, 0.024450860917568207, 0.008573693223297596, 0.024011915549635887, -0.034838903695344925, 0.03212425485253334, 0.016371527686715126, 0.03153229504823685, -0.0383504293859005, 0.02677704580128193, 0.05225837230682373, 0.035892076790332794, -0.03829997405409813, 0.10007371753454208, 0.01422768086194992, 0.10248949378728867, 0.034369878470897675, -0.005204048939049244, -0.012041336856782436, 0.004464668221771717, 0.025841278955340385, -0.004016619175672531, 0.018210530281066895, -0.022563286125659943, 0.08185014128684998, 0.038258835673332214, 0.007097546476870775, 0.019996989518404007, -0.03926219046115875, 0.02590017206966877, -0.06439728289842606, -0.03601393476128578, 0.00083438481669873, -0.006720440462231636, -0.005372392944991589, -0.07510338723659515, -0.010406311601400375, -0.0028010853566229343, -0.07740329205989838, 0.01453831885010004, 0.01091958861798048, -0.002717995084822178, -0.09455111622810364, 0.0014403419336304069, -0.04226772487163544, 0.015440840274095535, 0.013705084100365639, 0.012664767913520336, -0.022868772968649864, -0.008191502653062344, -0.02213585563004017, -0.00006990805559325963, -0.0269780270755291, -0.011819494888186455, -0.034742292016744614, 0.0017466776771470904, -0.017139364033937454, -0.008489985018968582, 0.06350123137235641, 0.02026182785630226, -0.011079230345785618, 0.0005864040576852858, -0.04123598709702492, 0.025566745549440384, -0.011265712790191174, 0.000815312669146806, -0.030949870124459267, 0.05892849713563919, 0.02559226006269455, -0.010271112434566021, -0.03395943343639374, -0.04842612147331238, -0.01627217046916485, -0.00418701209127903, -0.04513242468237877, 0.005049360450357199, -0.008421148173511028, 0.04502377286553383, 0.010277200490236282, 0.0483337827026844, -0.07970879971981049, 0.0024682984221726656, 0.015044927597045898, 0.027473414316773415, -0.012038230895996094, 0.03985963016748428, -0.021720480173826218, 0.026322653517127037, -0.005349540617316961, -0.01461582351475954, -0.023250168189406395, -0.02141554281115532, -0.04019133001565933, -0.06833447515964508, 0.01928948238492012, -0.04789947345852852, -0.029009146615862846, 0.023327404633164406, -0.05963988974690437, -0.011132095009088516, 0.014416282065212727, -0.0013965022517368197, 0.013304398395121098, 0.05020774528384209, -0.007931552827358246, 0.012971987016499043, 0.04769663140177727, 0.030315769836306572, 0.0006537586450576782, 0.029109586030244827, 0.014414120465517044, 0.09719642996788025, 0.012388341128826141, -0.037006255239248276, 0.04194960743188858, -0.07248731702566147, -0.023767052218317986, 0.03195341303944588, 0.009042524732649326, -0.0001482666120864451, 0.046456579118967056, 0.010379767045378685, 0.013853441923856735, -0.04812338203191757, -0.007753571029752493, -0.02470412105321884, -0.033532947301864624, -0.027259042486548424, -0.01324395276606083, 0.021034441888332367, -0.029543988406658173, -0.07988428324460983, 0.011071473360061646, 0.0747329592704773, 0.059986572712659836, -0.001956347841769457, 0.08734989911317825, 0.06766806542873383, -0.03391455113887787, -0.03322652727365494, -0.032762426882982254, 0.004083629697561264, -0.017738468945026398, 0.004017516504973173, 0.013463583774864674, -0.06388980150222778, 0.0896320566534996, -0.023784948512911797, 0.07610955089330673, 0.0015888455091044307, 0.008844088762998581, -0.03880837932229042, 0.03383104130625725, -0.017334388568997383, 0.0032361289486289024, -0.012572304345667362, 0.011465676128864288, -0.04875238239765167, -0.0043118479661643505, 0.04506770521402359, 0.05225279554724693, -0.06663443893194199, 0.029649175703525543, -0.004986239597201347, -0.0017210716614499688, 0.027215199545025826, -0.0328681655228138, 0.046566933393478394, 0.030077137053012848, -0.0012487118365243077, -0.033920768648386, -0.017535028979182243, 0.022213205695152283, -0.0022807021159678698, 0.03334873169660568, -0.029751600697636604, -0.01981828361749649, 0.049785129725933075, -0.03659121319651604, -0.025774531066417694, 0.0001866786478785798, 0.008373599499464035, 0.02038484439253807, -0.025745170190930367, 0.018556587398052216, 0.060108646750450134, -0.0352649949491024, -0.0108724944293499, 0.015191148966550827, -0.037105824798345566, -0.03370658680796623, 0.014440247789025307, -0.029916731640696526, 0.049361441284418106, 0.08531928807497025, 0.02381027303636074, 0.000028571892471518368, 0.03619520738720894, -0.08078312873840332, -0.04014794901013374, -0.03370969370007515, -0.01986102946102619, 0.01125305611640215, 0.005185762420296669, 0.022495092824101448, -0.005459621082991362, -0.01738262176513672, -0.02973363921046257, 0.01699644885957241, 0.04248819127678871, -0.009992927312850952, -0.00836649164557457, -0.04344632849097252, -0.010357338935136795, -0.03271383047103882, -0.06864418834447861, 0.014199687168002129, -0.00008480067481286824, -0.054776206612586975, 0.021324338391423225, 0.05728217959403992, 0.0326731875538826, -0.04706630855798721, 0.027009164914488792, -0.030459284782409668, -0.020913254469633102, -0.022781310603022575, -0.024348711594939232, 0.014867661520838737, -0.007468929514288902, 0.009010436944663525, 0.03312857821583748, -0.04916295036673546, 0.006794694345444441, -0.021216146647930145, 0.058274779468774796, -0.000658984063193202, -0.028006093576550484, -0.032651256769895554, 0.005095288157463074, 0.11141928285360336, -0.06710097938776016, 0.048643842339515686, 0.03706289827823639, -0.020880255848169327, 0.017750941216945648, 0.00025027309311553836, 0.03147182986140251, -0.002177249873057008, -0.0014250556705519557, -0.004516130313277245, -0.0007288001361303031, 0.010577446781098843, 0.06444599479436874, -0.03708748146891594, -0.04357633367180824, -0.011707533150911331, 0.034872256219387054, -0.013825683854520321, -0.04737304151058197, 0.0063036102801561356, 0.014206179417669773, 0.06547053158283234, 0.06889656186103821, 0.020900730043649673, 0.030831199139356613, 0.037534262984991074, -0.0009908166248351336, -0.03849645331501961, -0.047389596700668335, -0.03329659253358841, -0.054249949753284454, 0.09139461070299149, 0.03257297724485397, -0.03346005827188492, -0.04722006618976593, -0.016726957634091377 ]
<p>I am struggling already a couple of days with this simple OLS, can you help?</p> <p>Outcome years in function of predictor score, very simple linear model. The residual plot does absolutely not look good though. </p> <p>Is it correct that based on the residual plot versus the outcome variable, to say that "if I predict the outcome to be 12, I most of the time over estimate the years of eduction?"</p> <p>In blue my fitted OLS, in red a LOESS curve. What am I doing wrong or how to improve OLS?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/YNXxI.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I have tried to both transform the predictor and the outcome, no luck. Is there something else you can suggest?</p> <p>The specific problem I have is that I am making wrong predictions when the outcome age is 12 years (ref table below, vertical are my predictions, horizontal the true values). How to solve this issue? </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IRIKi.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
g74340
[ 0.02122439071536064, -0.030492516234517097, -0.006245281081646681, -0.07373476773500443, -0.06475894153118134, -0.010733981616795063, 0.023206181824207306, 0.017441226169466972, -0.0189371220767498, -0.017459414899349213, 0.008671574294567108, 0.02475370280444622, 0.09228993207216263, -0.04485224559903145, 0.0357128269970417, -0.008367056027054787, 0.04246211051940918, -0.035348813980817795, 0.021295052021741867, -0.027768462896347046, 0.04033714160323143, -0.03884575515985489, 0.036939024925231934, -0.023617230355739594, -0.03012600727379322, -0.05744485929608345, -0.03313729539513588, 0.08299668878316879, -0.08541415631771088, 0.045202627778053284, -0.011112120002508163, 0.025126252323389053, -0.005060350522398949, 0.0011956804664805532, -0.05339803174138069, -0.017592936754226685, 0.02951299585402012, -0.0009293474140577018, 0.034434884786605835, 0.004019433632493019, -0.03162740170955658, 0.03936609998345375, 0.02308179810643196, 0.08585619926452637, 0.015381102450191975, -0.0210052989423275, -0.006860619410872459, -0.022287804633378983, 0.008136610500514507, -0.02107786014676094, -0.038355160504579544, 0.028437871485948563, 0.01853020116686821, -0.0075930263847112656, -0.031064653769135475, -0.04087599366903305, -0.028788335621356964, 0.0016195219941437244, -0.02879590168595314, 0.0036332595627754927, 0.021791357547044754, 0.008183052763342857, -0.04289105162024498, -0.03339563310146332, 0.0322902649641037, 0.02447427064180374, -0.032080333679914474, -0.015783287584781647, -0.014553719200193882, -0.04813573509454727, 0.03522893041372299, -0.022094225510954857, 0.02855791710317135, 0.007122502662241459, -0.010641956701874733, -0.03849088028073311, -0.04301292449235916, 0.02114245668053627, 0.011381042189896107, 0.07155004888772964, -0.034598659723997116, 0.04597818851470947, -0.059859685599803925, -0.024611935019493103, 0.012277210131287575, 0.016306553035974503, 0.03636857494711876, -0.015616760589182377, -0.016916127875447273, -0.02011973410844803, -0.006261307280510664, 0.05227316915988922, 0.016168439760804176, 0.053964368999004364, -0.03063322603702545, -0.021969744935631752, -0.0585651658475399, 0.037765949964523315, -0.004170594736933708, 0.012674299068748951, -0.035814497619867325, 0.06106102094054222, 0.0008486232254654169, -0.04604238644242287, -0.016442012041807175, -0.003335109679028392, 0.03225387632846832, -0.01434462983161211, -0.044599682092666626, -0.0467473566532135, -0.060130488127470016, 0.044386934489011765, -0.06285669654607773, -0.008453749120235443, -0.010011415928602219, -0.028855100274086, 0.03902478143572807, 0.03621580824255943, -0.010358059778809547, -0.00447066780179739, 0.09402839839458466, 0.004196861758828163, 0.04399433732032776, 0.0166426133364439, 0.027303023263812065, 0.007216888479888439, -0.0767868235707283, 0.030193829908967018, 0.06678176671266556, 0.0059118811041116714, -0.026284892112016678, 0.05964399129152298, -0.020130306482315063, 0.06319206207990646, 0.05985109880566597, 0.01145981065928936, 0.015274782665073872, 0.019520996138453484, -0.0025147292762994766, 0.042401090264320374, 0.024763459339737892, -0.029807783663272858, 0.04064586013555527, -0.004820607602596283, -0.0312788262963295, -0.023905396461486816, 0.029612990096211433, 0.027102185413241386, 0.012230630032718182, -0.019084230065345764, -0.034526925534009933, 0.0019486801465973258, -0.042677927762269974, 0.03874778375029564, -0.04297752305865288, -0.023806337267160416, 0.010848268866539001, -0.011918500065803528, 0.00839788094162941, -0.009449459612369537, 0.02441764809191227, -0.028616705909371376, 0.028268752619624138, 0.00824627373367548, -0.023527085781097412, -0.013848338276147842, -0.0040092188864946365, -0.05035890266299248, -0.04275588318705559, 0.008981970138847828, 0.010047264397144318, -0.0036124074831604958, 0.03243591636419296, 0.00048702105414122343, 0.029453154653310776, -0.0016353428363800049, 0.04064791649580002, -0.001192268799059093, 0.018069418147206306, 0.025796234607696533, 0.005204895045608282, -0.022437456995248795, -0.0028815180994570255, -0.019469598308205605, -0.00154897291213274, -0.04709099978208542, 0.026645757257938385, 0.0897631123661995, -0.06738606095314026, 0.006294684950262308, -0.015107603743672371, 0.021143801510334015, -0.04075843468308449, -0.01387722697108984, -0.031310517340898514, -0.01892186515033245, 0.05966855213046074, -0.020309368148446083, -0.05895455554127693, -0.009512512944638729, 0.04745086655020714, -0.0028100397903472185, 0.010291172191500664, 0.028126003220677376, -0.030711442232131958, 0.006221652030944824, 0.026509668678045273, 0.008187614381313324, -0.07849626243114471, 0.03210954740643501, 0.018500370904803276, -0.01445594523102045, -0.016953106969594955, -0.010428324341773987, 0.03495456278324127, -0.009935255162417889, 0.007516092155128717, 0.0490945540368557, -0.004454430192708969, 0.01051491592079401, -0.015078457072377205, -0.011997506953775883, -0.0073627810925245285, 0.06600409746170044, 0.0004276507825125009, -0.023428410291671753, 0.08400217443704605, 0.020154234021902084, 0.015202403999865055, 0.023864200338721275, -0.023260364308953285, -0.021906256675720215, 0.039264824241399765, -0.002849826356396079, 0.058831896632909775, 0.005070833954960108, 0.027667544782161713, 0.003250274108722806, 0.0014223731122910976, 0.062192339450120926, 0.03682069107890129, 0.04415101557970047, -0.01361039374023676, -0.007190609350800514, 0.041802845895290375, -0.00598174799233675, 0.08364597707986832, -0.00528109073638916, -0.014695326797664165, 0.04331529140472412, -0.02826092019677162, 0.11917753517627716, -0.037907958030700684, 0.007212753873318434, -0.055883314460515976, -0.08830663561820984, -0.026678137481212616, 0.024904849007725716, -0.002714187139645219, -0.019626788794994354, -0.03930532559752464, 0.034921783953905106, -0.007610435131937265, -0.01683376543223858, -0.08155888319015503, -0.006563903763890266, -0.03367943689227104, -0.027765654027462006, -0.04413018748164177, -0.014017079956829548, -0.034820832312107086, 0.005443516653031111, -0.010779426433146, 0.06822101771831512, 0.03558797016739845, -0.029216252267360687, -0.03489871695637703, 0.03616010397672653, -0.017020680010318756, 0.015008318237960339, 0.06977073103189468, -0.032401081174612045, -0.024518195539712906, 0.05032491683959961, 0.017553193494677544, 0.01400234829634428, 0.06910328567028046, 0.002932816743850708, 0.029678180813789368, 0.06806089729070663, -0.0181024968624115, -0.006105803418904543, 0.030808381736278534, -0.0024714248720556498, -0.041748736053705215, -0.015109201893210411, 0.017240580171346664, -0.02503875643014908, 0.006792137864977121, 0.006955076474696398, -0.03133953735232353, 0.022885512560606003, -0.04873719811439514, -0.006782613229006529, 0.017690135166049004, -0.09756362438201904, -0.050316888839006424, 0.017642753198742867, -0.007591937202960253, -0.041798900812864304, 0.06416667997837067, -0.0015043531311675906, 0.01030789315700531, -0.0502389594912529, -0.03827904909849167, -0.03692302480340004, -0.0156552791595459, -0.0027709766291081905, 0.00604785094037652, -0.0346861332654953, 0.010973149910569191, -0.01524414960294962, -0.016325945034623146, 0.04755449667572975, -0.0441625639796257, -0.07371442019939423, -0.017964869737625122, -0.04443102329969406, -0.07627460360527039, 0.03604419156908989, 0.04704485088586807, 0.09976495057344437, -0.010636520572006702, 0.0019225149881094694, 0.01577046886086464, -0.03573106601834297, -0.06285963952541351, -0.041105132550001144, -0.01674855314195156, -0.0012167440727353096, 0.007640085648745298, -0.03728724643588066, 0.0008467832230962813, -0.0031152882147580385, -0.02098558284342289, -0.047759294509887695, -0.06729018688201904, -0.004314256366342306, -0.023897146806120872, 0.003997965715825558, -0.02477194368839264, -0.003121967427432537, -0.025696007534861565, -0.0009102736948989332, 0.029443051666021347, 0.011927611194550991, 0.009268313646316528, 0.04611534997820854, 0.028796939179301262, 0.005848132073879242, 0.025400863960385323, 0.018065879121422768, -0.07033909857273102, 0.030413325875997543, 0.021909207105636597, 0.07792948186397552, 0.03626985847949982, 0.07101131975650787, 0.008091221563518047, -0.02219233289361, -0.02118484117090702, 0.026501473039388657, 0.04634520784020424, 0.003982127644121647, -0.027698641642928123, -0.006896485574543476, -0.0031359095592051744, 0.03517249971628189, 0.0071676368825137615, 0.06484244018793106, 0.04397016391158104, 0.0013871685368940234, -0.029110942035913467, -0.004032895900309086, -0.02388724684715271, -0.0259302519261837, 0.02246127650141716, -0.04654117301106453, -0.003481105901300907, -0.011591973714530468, -0.008951322175562382, 0.006022245157510042, 0.00009907718049362302, 0.017772741615772247, 0.010526527650654316, -0.03131375089287758, 0.03309249505400658, 0.04118243232369423, -0.06300536543130875, -0.015295084565877914, -0.02578320913016796, -0.02115190401673317, 0.036089763045310974, -0.013010861352086067, -0.014484362676739693, -0.03196458891034126, 0.011077117174863815, -0.007657332811504602, -0.04158882424235344, -0.029571980237960815, 0.02091040462255478, 0.036025308072566986, 0.010378953069448471, -0.05193562060594559, 0.04303489625453949, -0.0075072734616696835, 0.050778184086084366, -0.004793907515704632, -0.04288671165704727, -0.004093474708497524, 0.025422368198633194, 0.11599129438400269, 0.015488938428461552, 0.000498202396556735, 0.03131682425737381, -0.03399573266506195, -0.05073472857475281, -0.014022938907146454, 0.03140070289373398, -0.03313380107283592, 0.02564198151230812, 0.0484967976808548, -0.00855936761945486, -0.012171217240393162, -0.02918417751789093, 0.007368141319602728, 0.04503776505589485, 0.004256126005202532, -0.012180466204881668, -0.053596850484609604, 0.0007291901274584234, -0.08645699918270111, -0.025610847398638725, 0.03618559241294861, -0.013256638310849667, 0.022926000878214836, -0.03768076375126839, -0.028598057106137276, 0.010220587253570557, 0.0481870211660862, 0.03617735207080841, 0.04070969298481941, 0.01660495437681675, -0.02315780706703663, 0.012870102189481258, -0.023545727133750916, 0.038536783307790756, 0.013186316937208176, 0.05203195661306381, 0.04873533919453621, -0.005437440704554319, -0.029068157076835632, -0.039879146963357925, -0.052506234496831894, -0.02295452170073986, -0.026777347549796104, -0.04692293703556061, -0.03876155987381935, 0.020943675190210342, 0.0069974795915186405, -0.06728202104568481, 0.019489465281367302, 0.04364781454205513, -0.029102467000484467, -0.04868495091795921, 0.022589590400457382, -0.016346169635653496, -0.04373034089803696, -0.008162086829543114, 0.0626339390873909, -0.05801914632320404, -0.036717385053634644, 0.032859496772289276, -0.007954397238790989, -0.011275291442871094, 0.011682026088237762, -0.009099503979086876, -0.03442470729351044, 0.05278356000781059, -0.013445168733596802, -0.024132709950208664, 0.023185888305306435, 0.046549029648303986, -0.021392451599240303, -0.004575550090521574, -0.004459299612790346, -0.014231428503990173, -0.018669726327061653, -0.0017556563252583146, 0.021288622170686722, -0.05490231141448021, 0.030624862760305405, -0.016586478799581528, 0.0011508065508678555, 0.006023915018886328, -0.008187948726117611, 0.05652916803956032, 0.01024512480944395, 0.022958870977163315, 0.08451471477746964, 0.021653955802321434, -0.015582405962049961, 0.10344218462705612, -0.00736111169680953, -0.03668946027755737, -0.05415172874927521, -0.03732377290725708, 0.08894415944814682, -0.007546503562480211, 0.008525215089321136, 0.060723043978214264, 0.02598254568874836, 0.007356021553277969, 0.00415571266785264, 0.04179694503545761, -0.01220808643847704, -0.010309364646673203, -0.06485548615455627, 0.04774411395192146, 0.003151375101879239, 0.038557905703783035, -0.006387495901435614, -0.0407252162694931, -0.02782110683619976, 0.0064438399858772755, 0.02718397043645382, 0.002127528889104724, -0.03065500594675541, 0.038953784853219986, -0.06274358928203583, 0.00566832022741437, 0.03086107410490513, -0.027654778212308884, -0.013460279442369938, -0.0205221064388752, 0.024694141000509262, -0.01978049799799919, 0.015585494227707386, 0.018514079973101616, -0.013050810433924198, -0.004326165653765202, 0.02829025313258171, -0.0030405137222260237, 0.013924231752753258, 0.0009914690162986517, -0.015282922424376011, 0.03297112137079239, -0.007379831280559301, 0.021914873272180557, 0.0363304577767849, 0.038712289184331894, -0.05889814347028732, -0.011587546207010746, 0.03130996599793434, 0.018166860565543175, 0.005394968669861555, 0.01624145545065403, 0.02557470090687275, 0.0028501739725470543, 0.007259403355419636, 0.03230493515729904, -0.08357242494821548, 0.022683141753077507, 0.06790458410978317, -0.06153799965977669, -0.021341929212212563, -0.02254658378660679, -0.051847197115421295, 0.03540261834859848, 0.015873776748776436, 0.0011608522618189454, 0.007605050224810839, 0.017789650708436966, 0.0008257132722064853, -0.0033946114126592875, 0.035474054515361786, -0.016924424096941948, -0.021012743934988976, -0.02282995916903019, 0.0023424953687936068, -0.042377594858407974, 0.043512776494026184, 0.03780690208077431, -0.033045779913663864, -0.007238324731588364, 0.018145576119422913, -0.06460809707641602, 0.01177088264375925, 0.012931138277053833, 0.019641514867544174, 0.008541717194020748, -0.0236385315656662, 0.05935611575841904, 0.021815935149788857, 0.04718886315822601, -0.018248464912176132, -0.022795382887125015, 0.012325701303780079, 0.034343477338552475, -0.033469121903181076, -0.05900082737207413, 0.008488510735332966, 0.0165170319378376, 0.05591558292508125, 0.04690897464752197, 0.006266190204769373, -0.034384213387966156, 0.06195390596985817, -0.05039060860872269, -0.011789866723120213, 0.030970364809036255, 0.025962557643651962, -0.02267126366496086, -0.004417147021740675, 0.005518557969480753, 0.027165083214640617, 0.008661721833050251, -0.01728467084467411, 0.03328146040439606, -0.01557856984436512, -0.07467883080244064, -0.005528855603188276, -0.02580021135509014, -0.027244484052062035, -0.04808248579502106, 0.027435721829533577, -0.06023024767637253, 0.05023467168211937, -0.01713087409734726, 0.053011205047369, -0.017507625743746758, 0.04999181628227234, 0.007242097519338131, 0.051495835185050964, -0.023537393659353256, -0.05130098760128021, 0.00920090265572071, 0.0016948891570791602, -0.10315527766942978, -0.014416255056858063, 0.09139925986528397, 0.012064332142472267, 0.05366837605834007, -0.03439302369952202, 0.05021040886640549, 0.028180032968521118, 0.018695484846830368, 0.03634762763977051, 0.09537094086408615, 0.05594613030552864, -0.04606562480330467, -0.09939169138669968, -0.0394226536154747, 0.006461423356086016, 0.013577098958194256, 0.056881777942180634, -0.015382697805762291, -0.057909443974494934, 0.024096837267279625, -0.10191653668880463, -0.02585972659289837, -0.07582731544971466, -0.010598263703286648, 0.0018071832600980997, 0.019235672429203987, 0.032046884298324585, -0.011558819562196732, 0.03767887502908707, -0.016325635835528374, 0.002243214286863804, -0.04395274072885513, -0.0010306000476703048, -0.00018431759963277727, -0.04251399263739586, -0.0032858552876859903, -0.009595440700650215, -0.0292043574154377, -0.01465311273932457, -0.007136914413422346, 0.06664964556694031, -0.029739676043391228, 0.02288956195116043, 0.0031872238032519817, 0.00519761024042964, -0.009755267761647701, 0.007779317442327738, -0.06316905468702316, 0.050231292843818665, 0.057372286915779114, 0.0738791972398758, 0.06185397133231163, 0.07386533170938492, -0.009383752010762691, -0.02695143036544323, 0.00997365452349186, -0.0305927786976099, -0.0618700310587883, -0.022800330072641373, -0.013256169855594635, 0.003874456509947777, -0.0551103837788105, 0.03140861168503761, -0.00810268335044384, 0.026524310931563377, 0.04447556287050247, 0.022571638226509094, -0.020892273634672165, -0.02420223318040371, -0.017530590295791626, -0.009342093952000141, -0.07321804761886597, -0.015902072191238403, -0.011395324021577835, 0.046853162348270416, 0.019560541957616806, -0.00734057417139411, 0.007799380458891392, -0.02759857289493084, -0.07073594629764557, -0.01881803758442402, -0.030887817963957787, 0.017294522374868393, -0.06964471936225891, 0.008961930871009827, -0.008975624106824398, -0.020950909703969955, -0.05341460555791855, 0.03544190153479576, -0.06396648287773132, 0.03215014189481735, -0.00026155132218264043, -0.04277200624346733, -0.04344992712140083, 0.04477997496724129, 0.04582779109477997, 0.061280202120542526, -0.03781818598508835, 0.004865758586674929, 0.023397749289870262, -0.02316921204328537, -0.00005432896796264686, 0.07728969305753708, -0.06427976489067078, 0.03674739971756935, 0.05884695053100586, -0.016467725858092308, 0.012154565192759037, 0.00637329276651144, 0.024975115433335304, -0.030669139698147774, -0.03321842476725578, -0.016471222043037415, 0.0038855408784002066, -0.004729518201202154, -0.03210488334298134, 0.05797630921006203, -0.027643544599413872, 0.009650837630033493 ]
<p>This question is about three-way interaction and the possibility of applying without second lower terms with keeping the main variables in the equation not like the other questions. In fact the other answers suggest there is possibility of applying . I am not here to find the best solution because I know it and I already included in my question, but to know whether is it possible regardless if it is preferable or not. thank you and please open my question for discussion </p> <p>The widely known regression equation for assessing the three-way interaction is</p> <p>$$ Y= B_1 X+B_2 Z+B_3 W +B_4XZ+B_5XW+B_6ZW+B_7XZW+B_0 $$</p> <p>All lower order terms is included in the regression equation for the B7 coefficient to represent the effect of the three-way interaction on Y. </p> <p>Is there possible way to skip the lower order terms and include only the higher term? as in:</p> <p>$$ Y= B_1 X+B_2 Z+B_3 W +B_4XZW+B_0 $$</p> <p>And how many observations do I need to perform such equation if X &amp; Z are continuous variables and W is dummy variable ?</p> <p>I will be thankful if anyone can provide me with any suggestions </p>
g49556
[ 0.039967864751815796, -0.02627963200211525, 0.02111244387924671, 0.0013103617820888758, 0.020616907626390457, -0.021970253437757492, 0.02601512335240841, 0.02931792289018631, -0.01536264456808567, -0.017564212903380394, -0.006942201405763626, 0.05368974804878235, -0.06990820169448853, 0.03855614736676216, -0.013776152394711971, 0.0038078641518950462, 0.03151841089129448, -0.028195681050419807, -0.010621354915201664, -0.008594567887485027, -0.022644056007266045, 0.0010811550309881568, 0.009590459056198597, 0.015381128527224064, -0.07148313522338867, -0.08642736077308655, -0.025201356038451195, 0.03642392158508301, -0.011697198264300823, 0.028537007048726082, -0.019096270203590393, 0.0212941262871027, 0.05601654574275017, -0.0002109186607412994, -0.05460038036108017, 0.001863322569988668, 0.06096518412232399, 0.0499950647354126, -0.015740027651190758, -0.012378226965665817, -0.029676204547286034, 0.00005251873517408967, 0.030498750507831573, 0.024184521287679672, 0.005392033606767654, -0.01181124895811081, -0.010366526432335377, -0.02317170239984989, 0.008800892159342766, -0.002417022828012705, -0.0006598409381695092, 0.01999916508793831, 0.008422312326729298, -0.016959067434072495, 0.029763756319880486, 0.002657628385350108, 0.019621489569544792, -0.027229566127061844, 0.03621785715222359, 0.02218492515385151, -0.011078800074756145, -0.058383598923683167, 0.02425564080476761, -0.05089322850108147, 0.028632570058107376, -0.03718665614724159, -0.04603654891252518, 0.010945451445877552, -0.03335654363036156, -0.04727844521403313, 0.04185878857970238, 0.03259959816932678, 0.01955433562397957, -0.06790897995233536, 0.014422201551496983, 0.02850489690899849, 0.0002561756409704685, -0.032141197472810745, 0.004066615831106901, 0.046857114881277084, -0.023160841315984726, -0.005607765633612871, 0.027865324169397354, 0.05874330922961235, 0.011327546089887619, 0.005805699620395899, 0.04798034951090813, -0.03800787776708603, -0.003746246686205268, -0.04552782326936722, -0.0290325079113245, 0.06164167821407318, -0.00568968104198575, 0.02959803305566311, 0.014565149322152138, 0.01296495832502842, -0.03518911451101303, -0.00609079422429204, 0.04044800251722336, -0.009564464911818504, -0.03610282391309738, 0.0016580680385231972, -0.022578150033950806, -0.0023155822418630123, -0.0720154270529747, -0.06181759759783745, 0.03823874518275261, 0.08178423345088959, -0.0300741083920002, -0.025978107005357742, -0.023921193554997444, 0.024359453469514847, 0.0411473773419857, 0.026237813755869865, -0.004503976088017225, -0.03703305870294571, 0.0013762392336502671, -0.0073468745686113834, -0.0075743854977190495, -0.008759609423577785, 0.027003465220332146, -0.0117553835734725, 0.025890791788697243, 0.05956600233912468, -0.008968722075223923, -0.06673714518547058, -0.0731053426861763, 0.07141165435314178, 0.07990245521068573, -0.03902971372008324, -0.008107027038931847, -0.005443844012916088, 0.0706973522901535, 0.03020412102341652, -0.009864870458841324, 0.0428294762969017, -0.0137126874178648, 0.020784031599760056, -0.011502622626721859, 0.012890213169157505, -0.01318263914436102, -0.011466323398053646, 0.045026663690805435, -0.014344273135066032, -0.024364452809095383, 0.027891064062714577, 0.026966266334056854, -0.006871086545288563, -0.04066290706396103, -0.04447789117693901, 0.023079194128513336, 0.038577690720558167, 0.025162717327475548, 0.007820924744009972, -0.06854657083749771, 0.016199490055441856, -0.023098072037100792, -0.045893825590610504, 0.047491732984781265, 0.03685781732201576, 0.0037975499872118235, -0.030343666672706604, 0.01821347512304783, 0.04213675856590271, -0.007273978553712368, 0.020702358335256577, -0.007334801834076643, -0.07833060622215271, -0.02766169235110283, 0.019864864647388458, 0.0020289341919124126, -0.008591103367507458, -0.005632336251437664, -0.02464482933282852, 0.01069094892591238, 0.040875501930713654, 0.041910625994205475, -0.004868112038820982, 0.007124742027372122, -0.008364895358681679, -0.0047196331433951855, 0.019707482308149338, -0.015281452797353268, -0.030017443001270294, 0.003364389995113015, -0.027937285602092743, -0.01706557720899582, 0.05942903459072113, -0.021283356472849846, -0.016084184870123863, -0.06793419271707535, 0.032186124473810196, 0.031967222690582275, -0.0034100175835192204, -0.046849142760038376, -0.009433026425540447, 0.036652952432632446, -0.008888036012649536, -0.01809791661798954, -0.020698469132184982, -0.039531052112579346, 0.000723951612599194, 0.05808404088020325, -0.026567991822957993, -0.028741035610437393, 0.014756645075976849, -0.0038754362612962723, 0.011850892566144466, -0.025405308231711388, -0.07776135206222534, -0.02524624392390251, -0.02581460028886795, 0.03289906308054924, 0.03834002465009689, -0.019883479923009872, -0.02848481759428978, 0.020796507596969604, 0.045910101383924484, -0.00006600165943382308, -0.003903383621945977, -0.05200645327568054, -0.0344279408454895, -0.0097713153809309, 0.0321749784052372, -0.03930094093084335, -0.01066469307988882, -0.008409075438976288, -0.0009041904704645276, -0.00871356576681137, -0.021187929436564445, -0.04356909170746803, -0.02453683130443096, 0.028169170022010803, -0.07074345648288727, 0.06031585857272148, 0.053300727158784866, 0.027700090780854225, 0.004832153208553791, 0.027117697522044182, 0.07802844047546387, -0.0015094452537596226, 0.046075575053691864, -0.021961908787488937, 0.05340227484703064, 0.05895567312836647, -0.03885722905397415, -0.005472211167216301, 0.009682814590632915, 0.020488791167736053, 0.030112342908978462, -0.044832270592451096, 0.04248638451099396, -0.053743667900562286, -0.08572988212108612, -0.003970001358538866, -0.005523801781237125, -0.026953911408782005, 0.049154020845890045, 0.0031779480632394552, -0.015334737487137318, -0.01113598607480526, -0.004010462202131748, 0.08920124173164368, 0.028830712661147118, 0.029433313757181168, -0.04898472875356674, -0.026359526440501213, -0.058557912707328796, 0.0008584064780734479, -0.003318085568025708, -0.06012188643217087, -0.009918407537043095, -0.03840656951069832, 0.012052149511873722, 0.008087183348834515, 0.010817584581673145, -0.05065706744790077, 0.0006715234485454857, -0.00010330929944757372, 0.02863886021077633, -0.004286878276616335, -0.03984251990914345, -0.02628684602677822, -0.014739771373569965, 0.06862232089042664, 0.06659509241580963, 0.032133277505636215, -0.013564756140112877, -0.008741411380469799, 0.02840900979936123, -0.017841337248682976, 0.029384825378656387, 0.016424288973212242, -0.03490918502211571, -0.017776036635041237, -0.07708116620779037, -0.027014968916773796, -0.07574252784252167, 0.014132597483694553, 0.033148203045129776, -0.021441755816340446, -0.009142773225903511, 0.0005655543645843863, -0.005389833822846413, -0.005195924546569586, -0.08778949081897736, -0.040237851440906525, 0.020373202860355377, 0.056745678186416626, -0.02843419834971428, -0.012223925441503525, 0.02830340340733528, -0.049668069928884506, -0.017017394304275513, -0.06682565808296204, -0.05494287982583046, 0.03480733558535576, 0.051363490521907806, 0.01977991685271263, 0.008582768961787224, 0.028612220659852028, -0.010144748724997044, 0.007118678651750088, -0.0036702377256006002, -0.0419558621942997, 0.05090395733714104, 0.014536467380821705, 0.0033644482027739286, -0.05038030073046684, 0.04552708566188812, 0.05780699476599693, 0.013095643371343613, 0.05900375917553902, -0.04382733628153801, 0.023335538804531097, 0.008102168329060078, 0.02415502443909645, -0.025526603683829308, 0.023424534127116203, -0.03164023533463478, 0.025550147518515587, -0.04300103709101677, -0.010661546140909195, 0.05173750966787338, -0.04209745302796364, -0.06127087399363518, -0.044444408267736435, 0.1389002650976181, -0.03203580901026726, -0.008126325905323029, 0.027460256591439247, -0.02384556643664837, -0.031530994921922684, -0.04770103096961975, 0.026955727487802505, 0.022264597937464714, 0.019099805504083633, 0.03566661849617958, 0.004532636143267155, -0.013308992609381676, -0.033172786235809326, -0.015555493533611298, -0.012073618359863758, 0.036421194672584534, 0.01463798712939024, -0.004133217502385378, -0.006044400855898857, 0.11012236773967743, 0.0052992189303040504, -0.026607539504766464, 0.010712777264416218, 0.0027690043207257986, 0.002472068415954709, -0.03986204415559769, -0.0023524262942373753, -0.052833788096904755, 0.07674548029899597, 0.045271456241607666, -0.03539867326617241, 0.09025513380765915, -0.023938434198498726, -0.005490281619131565, 0.0038508151192218065, 0.05662607401609421, 0.03323240578174591, -0.04735871031880379, -0.018764818087220192, -0.04057859256863594, -0.022488540038466454, 0.09785212576389313, -0.035349637269973755, 0.024733100086450577, -0.016572820022702217, 0.04761062562465668, 0.02351542003452778, -0.012651126831769943, -0.00879040826112032, -0.01512072142213583, -0.01732458360493183, -0.061395060271024704, -0.0748722180724144, -0.022759104147553444, 0.0692959576845169, 0.013308160938322544, -0.026026079431176186, 0.016454551368951797, 0.016849761828780174, 0.052734728902578354, 0.00014376982289832085, -0.01137328427284956, -0.0014406174886971712, -0.023219186812639236, -0.028463782742619514, 0.01646193116903305, 0.03778112679719925, -0.062107667326927185, 0.03259023651480675, 0.0011065870057791471, -0.027263086289167404, 0.015843668952584267, 0.06126056984066963, 0.02474260702729225, -0.07220491021871567, -0.011665740050375462, 0.0031816058326512575, 0.010158492252230644, -0.01801321469247341, -0.029963118955492973, -0.012136543169617653, 0.021028874441981316, 0.0026710752863436937, 0.06795186549425125, -0.02973569557070732, 0.00024675423628650606, 0.007314617745578289, 0.000880766601767391, -0.015352005138993263, -0.006887034513056278, 0.027224844321608543, -0.011216660961508751, -0.014826087281107903, 0.008390537463128567, -0.042547836899757385, 0.01580970175564289, 0.002483901334926486, 0.009562593884766102, -0.039019837975502014, -0.05484406277537346, 0.03218004107475281, 0.009172728285193443, -0.0033981625456362963, 0.010188497602939606, -0.030995389446616173, -0.007916213944554329, 0.041054967790842056, 0.00769239803776145, 0.01443927176296711, -0.01201749499887228, 0.018008502200245857, 0.026134803891181946, 0.002630486385896802, 0.03608504310250282, -0.015820791944861412, 0.009148995392024517, 0.05997565761208534, -0.08552829176187515, -0.03905631974339485, 0.0031908696983009577, -0.05016957223415375, 0.022491373121738434, -0.019805993884801865, 0.015226461924612522, 0.039829034358263016, 0.02116781286895275, -0.023981131613254547, -0.02773304283618927, -0.03112242929637432, 0.039148103445768356, -0.03685813024640083, 0.01270410604774952, -0.0269357617944479, -0.03001774474978447, 0.03750693053007126, 0.05517992004752159, -0.07722248136997223, -0.031032506376504898, -0.010912219993770123, -0.026710418984293938, 0.009087946265935898, 0.015378373675048351, 0.03892572596669197, -0.018179599195718765, -0.014334037899971008, -0.009228883311152458, -0.06305502355098724, 0.03690239414572716, 0.01376282423734665, -0.0804438591003418, 0.029991982504725456, 0.006154069676995277, -0.05927184596657753, -0.00294284475967288, 0.0017219259170815349, -0.0458260215818882, -0.05668211728334427, -0.014842845499515533, 0.06607677042484283, -0.03587213531136513, -0.01073637418448925, 0.06221446767449379, -0.008045781403779984, 0.006781286094337702, 0.04310638830065727, 0.020795729011297226, -0.044014934450387955, 0.0166014414280653, 0.041863877326250076, 0.07718019187450409, 0.01060533244162798, -0.0068109361454844475, 0.09788715094327927, -0.020796125754714012, -0.023854298517107964, -0.026185499504208565, -0.03446992114186287, -0.055127378553152084, -0.011412560008466244, 0.003203262574970722, -0.0016417589504271746, -0.07085784524679184, -0.02817782200872898, 0.07321367412805557, -0.030248325318098068, 0.025070881471037865, 0.0266711562871933, -0.03902348875999451, -0.008697195909917355, 0.050036363303661346, 0.031661488115787506, -0.0038897229824215174, 0.015612517483532429, -0.005459522362798452, 0.0244887825101614, 0.031666483730077744, -0.010776815935969353, 0.019327692687511444, 0.053428467363119125, -0.031295355409383774, 0.0009743261034600437, 0.012346901930868626, 0.008018777705729008, -0.015393557958304882, -0.05975845828652382, 0.07589013874530792, 0.010731121525168419, -0.011485184542834759, -0.009255332872271538, 0.042473893612623215, 0.07375311106443405, -0.009372769854962826, -0.037242282181978226, -0.039087023586034775, -0.007327419240027666, 0.0011338508920744061, -0.020950010046362877, -0.04944896325469017, -0.019192464649677277, 0.029807206243276596, -0.022147122770547867, 0.007043158635497093, 0.021444890648126602, -0.06084628403186798, -0.036030348390340805, 0.08336349576711655, 0.024504603818058968, -0.0038475028704851866, 0.010315957479178905, 0.006620773579925299, 0.025554899126291275, 0.02898152731359005, -0.013240368105471134, 0.022232066839933395, -0.014186411164700985, -0.06315280497074127, 0.004665553104132414, 0.06056937575340271, -0.0017376189352944493, 0.032830461859703064, -0.05466833710670471, -0.0021178724709898233, -0.024538910016417503, -0.0003484899934846908, 0.01073299627751112, -0.019909460097551346, 0.03850347176194191, -0.035859767347574234, 0.02105889283120632, 0.03859744593501091, -0.01610889472067356, 0.0007125373231247067, -0.03443581238389015, -0.029378948733210564, 0.08287142962217331, 0.029181960970163345, -0.00622458616271615, 0.07247107475996017, -0.02513163909316063, 0.00647154962643981, 0.05770670622587204, -0.03049231506884098, -0.06183653697371483, 0.014985006302595139, 0.04450703784823418, 0.03652937337756157, 0.018165383487939835, -0.028012756258249283, -0.046976976096630096, 0.033243872225284576, 0.014615343883633614, -0.017581386491656303, 0.009489838033914566, -0.08917195349931717, -0.050090204924345016, -0.03320448473095894, 0.05688788741827011, -0.0007871571579016745, -0.039046790450811386, -0.044082432985305786, -0.00762969022616744, 0.04227681830525398, -0.008704750798642635, -0.06290733814239502, -0.04267534613609314, 0.013036442920565605, -0.007112705148756504, 0.06954425573348999, -0.009514311328530312, -0.01239277608692646, -0.021887023001909256, -0.039171554148197174, 0.012787419371306896, 0.06259369850158691, 0.0037552788853645325, -0.00042958837002515793, -0.054731208831071854, -0.0019746259786188602, 0.062264956533908844, 0.021072272211313248, -0.07027691602706909, 0.03538525104522705, 0.05544865131378174, -0.003704602364450693, -0.0013882758794352412, -0.06310098618268967, 0.027991320937871933, 0.02034033089876175, -0.014382582157850266, 0.027001990005373955, 0.020260967314243317, 0.053422264754772186, 0.006935231853276491, -0.029538534581661224, -0.02226751297712326, 0.03184952214360237, -0.0041406042873859406, 0.023222049698233604, -0.002866697032004595, -0.012209882028400898, 0.005114314146339893, -0.00988524965941906, -0.01055885013192892, -0.09133066236972809, -0.04302709549665451, -0.006361676845699549, 0.007841022685170174, -0.0224656630307436, -0.0044128806330263615, 0.024749120697379112, 0.0007255485979840159, 0.03142264857888222, 0.002859639236703515, 0.005377661436796188, -0.00286385091021657, -0.002818438922986388, -0.05334823951125145, 0.005466538947075605, 0.09446264058351517, 0.07078147679567337, -0.0006346243899315596, -0.004583839327096939, -0.08271907269954681, -0.025802744552493095, 0.046822890639305115, -0.04756152629852295, -0.023699814453721046, 0.020623091608285904, -0.011152478866279125, 0.032600998878479004, -0.02743634581565857, 0.06498413532972336, 0.0727369487285614, 0.01922573707997799, -0.06459590792655945, -0.09981878846883774, 0.039189234375953674, 0.049361418932676315, -0.022958602756261826, -0.03605984151363373, -0.0025993979070335627, 0.008704673498868942, -0.04359760135412216, 0.06942921131849289, 0.017287636175751686, 0.05914180725812912, -0.014749386347830296, -0.03590766340494156, -0.006181302946060896, -0.01255666185170412, -0.021598435938358307, 0.024764224886894226, -0.05662185326218605, -0.01341234054416418, 0.011636542156338692, -0.05651106685400009, -0.01754113659262657, -0.03767424076795578, -0.07399053871631622, 0.008060786873102188, 0.03478746861219406, 0.044653914868831635, -0.024448618292808533, -0.05431773141026497, -0.0546984001994133, 0.06702806800603867, 0.009905591607093811, 0.032514020800590515, 0.02066083624958992, 0.033413682132959366, 0.009112861007452011, 0.023254849016666412, -0.01828240603208542, -0.017128225415945053, 0.02234594151377678, -0.010507798753678799, 0.017799220979213715, 0.061301786452531815, 0.007576095871627331, 0.0444224588572979, 0.06135409325361252, -0.01951235719025135, 0.009816776029765606, 0.05319181829690933, -0.0023266803473234177, 0.010116003453731537, 0.03224347531795502, 0.01153155043721199, 0.006769521627575159, 0.04337519779801369, -0.04629456624388695, 0.03661360591650009, -0.031005525961518288, -0.03226770833134651, -0.036688536405563354, 0.02675585262477398, 0.003323762211948633, -0.036506231874227524, -0.021059684455394745, 0.02691689319908619 ]
<p>Which statistical tools are best suited for this problem:</p> <p>Team A goes and measures 3 magnitudes in 200 locations (let's imagine the volume of a room, the insulation coefficient and the average temperature outside the room). For each room they calculate the energy this room will consume to keep the desired temperature for a week.</p> <p>So after the measurement campaign they have measured these 3 magnitudes in 200 different rooms (each room is only measured once). So the data looks like:</p> <pre><code> (Room_volume, r_coefficient, T, estimated_energy) </code></pre> <p>Team A is assumed to be very good at getting their results. Now team B measures the same 200 rooms, and calculates all the estimated energies for each room.</p> <p>How should we measure the performance of team B vs team A (where A is assumed to be accurate)? </p> <p>Forgetting the physics, as it's just an illustrative example, how do you compare the accuracy of a measurement campaign measuring 3 values from which a 4th one can be calculated deterministically? Note that none of these values are distributed in any special way among the 200 samples (they don't look gaussian)</p> <p>I started looking at the distribution of errors, so:</p> <pre><code> {Estimated_energy_Ai - Estimated_energy_Bi} with i = 1..200 </code></pre> <p>And seeing how many results are within a standard deviation. What other tools are appropriate?</p>
g74341
[ 0.013900067657232285, -0.04584405943751335, -0.011652580462396145, -0.012659136205911636, -0.014155465178191662, -0.017978399991989136, -0.002283253474161029, 0.03463177755475044, -0.08169163018465042, -0.027124404907226562, 0.022415870800614357, -0.007660682778805494, 0.01235681027173996, -0.0006825904129073024, -0.007811295334249735, -0.020443569868803024, 0.033027008175849915, -0.03015938028693199, 0.011520139873027802, 0.04582839831709862, 0.02240394614636898, 0.004876377526670694, 0.02168888784945011, -0.05729660019278526, -0.05378288775682449, -0.05429641902446747, -0.0017589774215593934, 0.03873448818922043, -0.05135625600814819, -0.027335621416568756, -0.04358042776584625, 0.03089379519224167, 0.05695495381951332, -0.08291438966989517, -0.044063396751880646, 0.007977857254445553, 0.0477348268032074, 0.04377397522330284, 0.005550737958401442, -0.013505661860108376, -0.029197843745350838, 0.006943651475012302, 0.0668547973036766, 0.004628940485417843, 0.04258821904659271, 0.03590609133243561, 0.00611543282866478, -0.024313854053616524, 0.03728846088051796, 0.003424183465540409, 0.008298391476273537, 0.00011038241791538894, 0.03875036537647247, 0.034042924642562866, 0.036863360553979874, 0.020817307755351067, -0.0277874618768692, -0.011345960199832916, 0.03557216003537178, 0.005607264116406441, 0.056762270629405975, -0.020681144669651985, -0.030297480523586273, -0.034788090735673904, 0.011867322959005833, 0.01490597054362297, -0.018467342481017113, -0.007429192308336496, 0.01597192883491516, -0.04470894858241081, 0.006654670462012291, -0.016193464398384094, 0.02363636903464794, -0.024215802550315857, -0.07083677500486374, -0.019331471994519234, -0.028641797602176666, -0.02284771017730236, -0.03581872954964638, 0.04060402885079384, -0.03361912816762924, -0.022718558087944984, 0.042351141571998596, -0.01800522208213806, 0.06093258783221245, 0.030999744310975075, 0.00941468682140112, 0.017362723127007484, 0.012804154306650162, 0.050403445959091187, -0.003302255179733038, 0.06136353686451912, 0.08609574288129807, 0.035476021468639374, -0.05805031955242157, 0.023663058876991272, -0.07528147846460342, 0.026285992935299873, 0.0376359261572361, 0.03963867947459221, 0.02760286070406437, 0.004946561995893717, -0.04214954748749733, 0.002740441355854273, -0.10834397375583649, -0.0415666326880455, 0.0010170520981773734, 0.03885994479060173, -0.008428898639976978, -0.01443893276154995, -0.054719001054763794, -0.0055056666024029255, -0.029055926948785782, -0.05463843047618866, -0.06081058084964752, -0.040678903460502625, 0.07376562058925629, -0.04391735792160034, -0.03170023858547211, -0.031559497117996216, -0.02310243248939514, 0.030547788366675377, 0.0667591392993927, 0.0032119995448738337, -0.024480203166604042, -0.04035807028412819, -0.08555971831083298, 0.033658117055892944, -0.02796752192080021, -0.02091359533369541, -0.024913208559155464, -0.04810907319188118, -0.011814910918474197, -0.015516434796154499, -0.02933950535953045, 0.04746483638882637, -0.01665400341153145, 0.06840524822473526, -0.013272964395582676, 0.04661274328827858, -0.019637852907180786, -0.008763711899518967, 0.007459131069481373, -0.03127191215753555, -0.0018718276405707002, -0.01621745154261589, -0.05565651133656502, -0.03831084817647934, -0.004022395703941584, 0.05127827078104019, 0.05620083212852478, 0.044924963265657425, 0.009260001592338085, -0.01219839695841074, 0.025826405733823776, 0.004969972185790539, -0.027480345219373703, 0.013473876751959324, -0.02589792013168335, 0.013485683128237724, -0.020016323775053024, -0.040201734751462936, 0.07239183783531189, 0.016671068966388702, 0.02460211142897606, 0.02191269025206566, 0.095946304500103, -0.015209315344691277, 0.02322634682059288, 0.006278965622186661, -0.032907549291849136, -0.010457533411681652, 0.030358005315065384, -0.013267750851809978, -0.04145072400569916, 0.07534468173980713, 0.024607356637716293, -0.061051417142152786, 0.013541766442358494, 0.03786168247461319, 0.022822031751275063, 0.07694689184427261, 0.054637979716062546, -0.03551863133907318, -0.059111885726451874, -0.019704097881913185, 0.013923640362918377, 0.012532378546893597, -0.00568789429962635, -0.0030439437832683325, -0.005988078657537699, 0.001895277644507587, -0.021650120615959167, 0.0025719008408486843, -0.03179716691374779, -0.0183468759059906, 0.05342436209321022, -0.035758089274168015, -0.005463643465191126, -0.06856365501880646, 0.03581139072775841, 0.004341386258602142, -0.0007099652430042624, 0.038037605583667755, 0.02869393676519394, 0.04896353930234909, -0.013568079099059105, -0.02782439813017845, -0.0035071633756160736, -0.023263556882739067, -0.03048437088727951, 0.05082787945866585, -0.020951852202415466, 0.049207571893930435, 0.04330648109316826, 0.019368084147572517, -0.027412783354520798, -0.037956319749355316, 0.019990956410765648, 0.0005203316686674953, -0.06499715149402618, -0.0009060336742550135, 0.027734490111470222, -0.007438064552843571, 0.02370031736791134, 0.00857507437467575, -0.02651011012494564, 0.0027124243788421154, -0.043788835406303406, 0.03307410702109337, -0.04267982766032219, -0.005690081976354122, -0.004945899825543165, -0.04432818666100502, 0.024460140615701675, 0.08687722682952881, -0.02649237960577011, -0.012271944433450699, 0.05698743835091591, 0.05820498242974281, 0.025707270950078964, 0.008904779329895973, -0.02198505774140358, 0.02174539491534233, 0.018084855750203133, -0.007391592487692833, 0.04999108612537384, -0.01755383424460888, -0.021704409271478653, 0.03800143674015999, -0.006812626030296087, 0.08522862195968628, -0.03187820315361023, -0.04573049023747444, -0.033929478377103806, -0.00797576829791069, 0.06286906450986862, -0.0007576470961794257, 0.017368879169225693, 0.011151512153446674, -0.03094099834561348, -0.03494914248585701, 0.07698556035757065, 0.07644540071487427, 0.08791662752628326, -0.01508970744907856, 0.007643148303031921, -0.024489669129252434, -0.04676012694835663, -0.009165536612272263, 0.011622928082942963, 0.03581736981868744, 0.0499417707324028, 0.021563291549682617, 0.02421329915523529, 0.02350425533950329, 0.05653010681271553, -0.01785121113061905, 0.045847464352846146, -0.024298274889588356, 0.01943587139248848, -0.04821110516786575, -0.028019387274980545, 0.07693426311016083, 0.07473184168338776, -0.02350420504808426, 0.03479553759098053, 0.011738975532352924, -0.006456213537603617, -0.027066221460700035, 0.014627354219555855, 0.023046346381306648, -0.021283254027366638, -0.0031442097388207912, -0.06180603429675102, 0.0029976426158100367, 0.008570621721446514, -0.04214423894882202, 0.04630645364522934, -0.008338035084307194, -0.03324762359261513, 0.04355432838201523, -0.0006841181311756372, 0.005370712839066982, 0.024482984095811844, 0.003878844203427434, -0.017124410718679428, -0.007648254744708538, 0.017757324501872063, -0.04019371047616005, -0.017583660781383514, -0.035524044185876846, 0.0006418684497475624, -0.00943221990019083, -0.007400618400424719, -0.05177263915538788, 0.013101541437208652, -0.008968635462224483, 0.014622759073972702, 0.0002882836270146072, 0.014399898238480091, -0.009480785578489304, -0.017832601442933083, -0.02332880161702633, 0.024339357390999794, 0.02442914806306362, -0.027411453425884247, 0.015204115770757198, -0.06929078698158264, 0.005305101163685322, 0.026846634224057198, 0.04882185906171799, 0.012411043047904968, 0.005088424775749445, 0.003568828571587801, -0.044101323932409286, 0.0023551317863166332, -0.020735880360007286, -0.012671849690377712, -0.010311491787433624, -0.046171728521585464, 0.004218135494738817, -0.02684042975306511, 0.011920733377337456, -0.0023424425162374973, -0.025709625333547592, 0.03085814230144024, 0.02607022039592266, 0.00023826895630918443, -0.03663314878940582, 0.017802245914936066, -0.024978822097182274, -0.008382589556276798, -0.003294117981567979, 0.013239020481705666, -0.0003742844855878502, 0.04290245100855827, -0.02894425019621849, 0.014312994666397572, 0.008598851971328259, 0.0345679335296154, 0.04085581377148628, -0.04879876226186752, -0.060494519770145416, -0.037035975605249405, 0.010950356721878052, 0.024905387312173843, 0.057725612074136734, 0.03660093992948532, -0.03564600646495819, 0.022641537711024284, 0.019789107143878937, -0.02720697410404682, -0.009614285081624985, 0.0042733256705105305, -0.021895524114370346, 0.02724379487335682, -0.024063505232334137, -0.007381145842373371, 0.04142176732420921, 0.029412047937512398, 0.011004500091075897, 0.004165224265307188, -0.04229359328746796, -0.0020735629368573427, -0.06713995337486267, 0.014959526248276234, 0.008873413316905499, -0.014999276027083397, -0.0405299998819828, -0.07957929372787476, -0.0582459382712841, -0.06353945285081863, 0.019484709948301315, 0.017164234071969986, -0.03162000700831413, 0.023181835189461708, 0.012059559114277363, 0.01551384199410677, 0.09833863377571106, -0.04812316969037056, -0.021210849285125732, 0.07612159103155136, 0.012199182994663715, -0.005182786379009485, -0.04898177087306976, -0.01039731316268444, -0.007677935995161533, -0.051787279546260834, 0.052051085978746414, -0.010168992914259434, -0.04892181605100632, 0.02557559683918953, -0.07119867205619812, 0.04573051258921623, -0.025733700022101402, 0.0093141570687294, -0.02848629653453827, 0.017260313034057617, 0.029322998598217964, -0.05442824214696884, 0.009671150706708431, 0.009155630134046078, -0.04209614172577858, -0.022204061970114708, 0.03997812047600746, 0.029752157628536224, 0.04230179637670517, -0.026287702843546867, -0.009773681871592999, -0.00003774429569602944, -0.015096394345164299, -0.025317350402474403, 0.03576747328042984, -0.01386676263064146, -0.003723905421793461, 0.05117045342922211, 0.014986398629844189, 0.0018651837017387152, -0.04062342643737793, -0.02398793026804924, -0.014389949850738049, 0.001985556213185191, -0.04843110218644142, -0.05167737975716591, 0.07409340888261795, -0.024141879752278328, -0.011248021386563778, -0.03274550288915634, 0.05600780248641968, -0.004124303814023733, 0.06134632229804993, -0.020147398114204407, 0.041650861501693726, 0.005721355322748423, -0.0029761746991425753, 0.0385306179523468, 0.08594582229852676, 0.0270221084356308, -0.007819980382919312, -0.036721378564834595, -0.037267670035362244, -0.06179400160908699, -0.023504765704274178, -0.02861059457063675, 0.002783521544188261, -0.007073554676026106, -0.028327621519565582, 0.028921406716108322, 0.013897853903472424, 0.03335806354880333, 0.024145636707544327, 0.024791834875941277, 0.012239516712725163, 0.02409457415342331, 0.004336558282375336, -0.00445295125246048, -0.01515206042677164, 0.02619149163365364, -0.013401484116911888, 0.011896342970430851, -0.006194681860506535, -0.008554505184292793, 0.019891390576958656, -0.013281398452818394, 0.022655704990029335, -0.036926716566085815, -0.09139163047075272, 0.05389267951250076, -0.017854897305369377, 0.02333354577422142, 0.08803220838308334, 0.023788338527083397, -0.020215081050992012, -0.026282615959644318, -0.02371070347726345, 0.02228725329041481, 0.023397555574774742, 0.045421451330184937, 0.0039844936691224575, 0.01591111533343792, 0.06992314755916595, -0.05072116479277611, -0.014023560099303722, 0.015489566139876842, 0.031971387565135956, 0.05227246135473251, -0.04414144530892372, -0.03230445832014084, 0.06404639780521393, -0.0144936703145504, 0.011417101137340069, 0.04610161855816841, 0.0016268448671326041, 0.016497071832418442, -0.032843515276908875, 0.0234525129199028, 0.04240713268518448, -0.05233348533511162, -0.078923799097538, 0.06166648864746094, 0.012696050107479095, 0.05368046462535858, -0.0024668180849403143, 0.04303190857172012, -0.02320442907512188, -0.02759137563407421, -0.01776745356619358, 0.042776480317115784, -0.044116854667663574, 0.02652093954384327, 0.04134567081928253, -0.056197162717580795, 0.006087206304073334, -0.011138839647173882, -0.007835591211915016, -0.04910140484571457, -0.04354739561676979, -0.001459802035242319, -0.010695204138755798, 0.009518229402601719, 0.02647007629275322, 0.06893748790025711, 0.015215312130749226, 0.0025833521503955126, -0.02627742476761341, -0.004785982891917229, 0.003975812811404467, 0.01760409213602543, -0.035692110657691956, -0.014404411427676678, 0.020274898037314415, 0.04971827566623688, -0.02187804877758026, 0.06507968157529831, -0.002146902261301875, 0.00952980574220419, -0.02801094762980938, -0.013172282837331295, 0.07062645256519318, -0.008708635345101357, -0.05612814798951149, 0.04376642778515816, 0.02096335031092167, 0.012207779102027416, -0.04980740696191788, -0.04562964290380478, -0.042417678982019424, -0.05569838732481003, 0.02717561647295952, 0.023695360869169235, -0.0578504279255867, 0.010124224238097668, 0.0019686371088027954, 0.059080298990011215, 0.01900346204638481, -0.022936249151825905, -0.027721630409359932, 0.046353891491889954, -0.040753211826086044, 0.00771771976724267, -0.03799484670162201, -0.004025096073746681, 0.0006368902395479381, 0.031192786991596222, 0.11023081094026566, -0.027512215077877045, 0.001483795465901494, 0.0279556754976511, -0.10730817914009094, 0.011222776025533676, -0.03632604330778122, 0.031104201450943947, -0.039581913501024246, -0.05150728300213814, -0.017035264521837234, -0.02734587900340557, -0.01982029154896736, -0.041862547397613525, 0.03067290410399437, -0.040277108550071716, 0.0007834470015950501, -0.013821948319673538, -0.06596251577138901, 0.03588533774018288, -0.03463369607925415, 0.03477347269654274, 0.01953704282641411, 0.026414524763822556, -0.05930604040622711, -0.050151266157627106, 0.061065830290317535, 0.016350483521819115, 0.005641319788992405, -0.006991494446992874, -0.01982695795595646, 0.004851550795137882, 0.006185527890920639, 0.0432584285736084, -0.005183534696698189, 0.051095519214868546, -0.05278847739100456, 0.0027723954990506172, -0.05941860377788544, 0.04232575371861458, 0.03781461715698242, -0.00339546799659729, 0.03848518058657646, 0.03703613951802254, -0.0025399515870958567, -0.0019219552632421255, -0.004924791865050793, 0.02090502716600895, 0.07508233934640884, -0.09735462814569473, 0.018065927550196648, -0.05896063894033432, 0.03517243638634682, -0.014993397518992424, 0.08982633799314499, -0.018328415229916573, 0.028224902227520943, -0.040084559470415115, 0.019248541444540024, -0.014663313515484333, -0.0013453946448862553, -0.0030067800544202328, 0.028154855594038963, 0.000007448785709129879, -0.005031975451856852, -0.045021723955869675, -0.013340722769498825, -0.0025643857661634684, -0.03530305251479149, -0.04385732114315033, 0.04385809227824211, 0.036194808781147, 0.028015149757266045, 0.04752153530716896, -0.02368481084704399, -0.030502786859869957, -0.09182853996753693, -0.005703783594071865, 0.034826163202524185, 0.05914461240172386, 0.06404002755880356, -0.023989254608750343, -0.026673732325434685, 0.0014668477233499289, -0.04726461321115494, 0.05263357609510422, -0.017517395317554474, -0.03281166031956673, -0.002890858333557844, -0.006926822941750288, -0.020633121952414513, 0.007401900365948677, 0.038631998002529144, -0.02234373241662979, -0.02105027437210083, 0.0004634402575902641, -0.0554722435772419, 0.023380110040307045, -0.0405125766992569, -0.03222908079624176, 0.07732176035642624, -0.0034419093281030655, -0.020632021129131317, 0.014509796164929867, -0.05633782595396042, -0.0407877191901207, -0.009778465144336224, 0.06372709572315216, -0.023805541917681694, -0.012651233933866024, 0.020127585157752037, -0.0004020643827971071, -0.011760350316762924, 0.027713656425476074, 0.02963610552251339, 0.03266766667366028, 0.012003583833575249, 0.06848787516355515, 0.04970189183950424, 0.03398974612355232, 0.04591502249240875, -0.039109569042921066, -0.03651901334524155, 0.031068040058016777, -0.08750893175601959, 0.015585372224450111, -0.03922503441572189, 0.025833453983068466, 0.011134696193039417, -0.03350386023521423, 0.012946748174726963, -0.089751236140728, -0.02571483701467514, 0.07913856953382492, -0.03699731454253197, -0.008923525922000408, 0.02954155020415783, -0.020693551748991013, -0.004555404186248779, 0.008419882506132126, -0.02823021449148655, -0.027071349322795868, 0.0006931669777259231, 0.034027326852083206, -0.016148218885064125, -0.04292634129524231, -0.007379806600511074, -0.08814814686775208, 0.04314969852566719, 0.008832501247525215, 0.022837277501821518, 0.07535203546285629, 0.030637653544545174, 0.020394038408994675, 0.05377374216914177, -0.011754227802157402, 0.013485483825206757, -0.019524138420820236, -0.012257344089448452, 0.030263209715485573, -0.015293039381504059, -0.03994607552886009, 0.019923267886042595, -0.026708990335464478, -0.03497008606791496, -0.021259745582938194, 0.028563350439071655, -0.03469531238079071, -0.007265728432685137, -0.07792080193758011, 0.015769749879837036, 0.05104045197367668, -0.04332014545798302, -0.005848399829119444, 0.0074968598783016205, -0.026865465566515923, -0.03277387097477913, -0.026909681037068367, 0.0059783668257296085, -0.03534415364265442, 0.009204253554344177, -0.002004216192290187, 0.0055734929628670216 ]
<p>I want to perform a repeated measures ANOVA in SPSS using the descriptive statistics. So my input is: </p> <pre><code>Descriptive Statistics Mean Std. Deviation N M1MI 3,8000 1,03280 10 M1MA 5,3000 2,16282 10 M2MI 7,0000 1,88562 10 M2MA 2,2000 1,54919 10 M3MI 6,2000 1,03280 10 M3MA 4,2000 1,75119 10 M4MI 4,7000 ,67495 10 M4MA 4,9000 1,19722 10 </code></pre> <p>Does anyone know how I have to adjust my syntax? </p> <p>My design is as follows:</p> <pre><code>Dependent variables: Progress1, Progress2, Progress3, Progress4 Within subject factor 2: M (I/A) </code></pre>
g37190
[ -0.041534166783094406, -0.008267881348729134, -0.013462306000292301, -0.07519732415676117, -0.04425140470266342, -0.020423179492354393, 0.012157423421740532, 0.02841314487159252, -0.04320686683058739, -0.016466425731778145, -0.04986653849482536, 0.05002062767744064, 0.02281038835644722, 0.034913886338472366, 0.02871389500796795, 0.010281812399625778, 0.059573978185653687, -0.02675972878932953, 0.04544049873948097, 0.03777191787958145, -0.008587373420596123, 0.009710722602903843, 0.04423941671848297, -0.051551152020692825, 0.04819337651133537, -0.05452254042029381, 0.016118282452225685, 0.05182701349258423, -0.08424468338489532, 0.02237841673195362, -0.010677189566195011, 0.0002896354126278311, -0.02567659690976143, -0.030588502064347267, -0.019619692116975784, -0.045650236308574677, 0.027668042108416557, 0.03212135657668114, 0.006744911894202232, 0.0360206700861454, 0.012000593356788158, 0.022307395935058594, 0.018044400960206985, -0.036030109971761703, -0.010250958614051342, -0.04651029035449028, -0.005290959030389786, -0.03951282054185867, -0.019658776000142097, 0.050743233412504196, 0.050096165388822556, -0.011409292928874493, -0.03383282572031021, -0.004347984679043293, 0.044650327414274216, -0.007475443184375763, -0.020907340571284294, -0.024646544829010963, -0.014810647815465927, 0.034054551273584366, 0.023509187623858452, -0.06000052019953728, -0.004424219019711018, 0.0018319536466151476, 0.05929066985845566, 0.031357552856206894, -0.033996276557445526, 0.010728137567639351, -0.11387370526790619, -0.009238316677510738, -0.011203721165657043, 0.0200031828135252, -0.007318499963730574, -0.023634852841496468, -0.015226039104163647, -0.024882128462195396, -0.030355149880051613, -0.013448086567223072, -0.0005924733122810721, 0.03264167532324791, -0.015593555755913258, 0.02652912028133869, 0.054273489862680435, -0.03492829203605652, 0.07295180857181549, 0.005704060196876526, 0.06980283558368683, 0.01918569765985012, 0.009460510686039925, -0.04239792004227638, 0.0034605967812240124, 0.0026057299692183733, 0.05116559565067291, 0.06570941209793091, -0.023536456748843193, -0.08409790694713593, -0.08795305341482162, 0.033687081187963486, 0.035812485963106155, 0.016668954864144325, -0.06278765946626663, 0.03428250923752785, -0.007229342591017485, -0.010022158734500408, -0.06560011953115463, -0.024199163541197777, 0.038452472537755966, -0.014930549077689648, -0.004241849761456251, -0.04161815717816353, -0.012601977214217186, -0.02928096614778042, -0.04834730923175812, -0.01876240037381649, -0.06632760167121887, 0.0035657286643981934, 0.06218545138835907, -0.05556248500943184, -0.04895755276083946, -0.04921851307153702, -0.056774187833070755, -0.056599460542201996, 0.06068605184555054, 0.0897221639752388, -0.06981948763132095, -0.00036873292992822826, -0.02008695900440216, 0.027367275208234787, 0.0840502455830574, -0.010674972087144852, 0.06582023203372955, -0.008834886364638805, -0.00849601998925209, 0.03632489591836929, -0.03940316289663315, -0.010855724103748798, -0.001618772279471159, 0.07393953204154968, 0.006583905313163996, 0.014087321236729622, -0.049336422234773636, -0.009418109431862831, 0.004248696845024824, -0.02344406582415104, 0.04697831720113754, -0.026693839579820633, -0.013157163746654987, -0.025727683678269386, 0.0419979952275753, 0.011803138069808483, 0.051509007811546326, 0.0730784684419632, -0.05248493328690529, 0.03798702731728554, -0.05736660957336426, -0.02034221775829792, 0.03306034952402115, -0.0014045301359146833, -0.04829205945134163, 0.027964120730757713, 0.07781359553337097, 0.0038559120148420334, -0.02547895535826683, -0.030710596591234207, 0.028118446469306946, 0.07607296109199524, -0.013756274245679379, 0.026871195062994957, -0.0797693207859993, 0.012393815442919731, -0.015264462679624557, -0.02906418964266777, -0.01698916405439377, -0.03661634400486946, 0.04503025487065315, 0.022723525762557983, 0.0025043205823749304, -0.004785069264471531, 0.02890450321137905, -0.0212458074092865, 0.005209744442254305, 0.01172187551856041, 0.020486420020461082, -0.02315259352326393, -0.03909677639603615, 0.03357947617769241, -0.027892306447029114, -0.007492002099752426, -0.09200684726238251, 0.00029240819276310503, 0.00014352846483234316, -0.012867428362369537, -0.01812291517853737, -0.021719107404351234, -0.011718315072357655, -0.050169698894023895, -0.0016904075164347887, -0.03551265224814415, -0.036227352917194366, 0.013123304583132267, -0.009090658277273178, 0.06145497038960457, -0.060595665127038956, 0.020939165726304054, 0.025912700220942497, 0.003394433530047536, -0.008069541305303574, -0.02265745960175991, -0.0320625901222229, 0.05972424894571304, 0.065897636115551, 0.02242794819176197, -0.000485139898955822, 0.021207990124821663, 0.01708986982703209, -0.009470723569393158, 0.004500238690525293, -0.02492954581975937, -0.019813617691397667, 0.033644892275333405, -0.03376145288348198, -0.031070033088326454, 0.02930521033704281, 0.07834771275520325, -0.012713431380689144, 0.026028571650385857, 0.035365186631679535, 0.028608715161681175, 0.03148619458079338, -0.019218146800994873, -0.04072306677699089, -0.012118831276893616, -0.0034493796993047, -0.027748633176088333, 0.01478932611644268, 0.0045430888421833515, -0.045990679413080215, 0.025157129392027855, -0.03439014405012131, 0.0076676951721310616, 0.001590693718753755, 0.018799250945448875, 0.033167093992233276, 0.005744685418903828, 0.04541157931089401, -0.02741912379860878, 0.05786994472146034, 0.04297260940074921, 0.00613532867282629, 0.05189451202750206, -0.003977273590862751, -0.014730280265212059, 0.0024823052808642387, -0.016534535214304924, 0.04961718991398811, 0.010528337210416794, 0.0032717071007937193, 0.0532311387360096, 0.004376259632408619, -0.0017322846688330173, -0.020377695560455322, -0.014917734079062939, 0.03558434918522835, -0.00381066813133657, 0.0034323681611567736, -0.004574588034301996, 0.0031854063272476196, -0.039559368044137955, 0.02967834286391735, -0.005998723674565554, 0.03478016331791878, 0.002514638239517808, 0.06442395597696304, 0.018163377419114113, -0.030780645087361336, 0.026891782879829407, -0.020274559035897255, -0.011711454950273037, 0.03223129361867905, 0.011274347081780434, 0.042257603257894516, -0.008062200620770454, 0.017637962475419044, 0.006661625578999519, 0.0022549941204488277, 0.014365864917635918, 0.06243208423256874, -0.05361148342490196, -0.08667271584272385, 0.01368526741862297, 0.03556238114833832, 0.04378792271018028, -0.026958584785461426, -0.00888169463723898, 0.059295784682035446, -0.008847109042108059, -0.03949921578168869, -0.014018244110047817, 0.04963311553001404, 0.0457875095307827, -0.052776649594306946, 0.006786398123949766, -0.0023298049345612526, -0.012662897817790508, 0.022446591407060623, -0.023602556437253952, 0.02567100152373314, 0.03046770766377449, 0.08227900415658951, -0.015946164727211, -0.014392344281077385, -0.06486714631319046, 0.008102108724415302, -0.03042708896100521, -0.07404554635286331, 0.004942133091390133, 0.04433906823396683, 0.003047375474125147, -0.013484959490597248, -0.007203527260571718, 0.019495109096169472, -0.01411772333085537, 0.041829612106084824, 0.047904547303915024, -0.017443161457777023, 0.007297157309949398, 0.016617227345705032, 0.006326430942863226, -0.051770225167274475, 0.0008726241067051888, 0.005514553282409906, 0.043998926877975464, 0.016241345554590225, -0.07352474331855774, 0.026103025302290916, -0.0018174415454268456, -0.010422647930681705, -0.02334856241941452, -0.045393504202365875, -0.006975181400775909, 0.007105620577931404, -0.08501502871513367, -0.026674732565879822, 0.030126990750432014, -0.007048578001558781, -0.003987262491136789, 0.028700271621346474, 0.0020164751913398504, 0.022839991375803947, -0.021788213402032852, -0.03194804489612579, 0.030008649453520775, -0.018272968009114265, -0.013221974484622478, 0.02291616052389145, 0.019384780898690224, 0.06696028262376785, -0.014794466085731983, -0.06759205460548401, -0.003594154492020607, -0.005644838325679302, -0.05233105644583702, -0.09805382788181305, 0.02286292053759098, 0.025521090254187584, 0.07724584639072418, 0.03343985974788666, 0.05621208995580673, 0.02415687032043934, 0.016682621091604233, 0.017057402059435844, -0.03680203855037689, 0.036682285368442535, -0.07708124071359634, -0.02698597125709057, -0.07509840279817581, 0.07491657882928848, 0.0426180325448513, -0.01649422012269497, 0.05841778963804245, 0.05163896456360817, -0.01355042215436697, -0.026828758418560028, 0.00042562599992379546, -0.019494013860821724, -0.053562432527542114, -0.03968852385878563, 0.02028302662074566, 0.0020670522935688496, -0.020963577553629875, -0.10719013214111328, 0.019351374357938766, -0.05727453529834747, -0.028673669323325157, 0.03115515224635601, 0.0034735891968011856, 0.01057218387722969, 0.04892519488930702, -0.0329916812479496, 0.04120766744017601, -0.02876821905374527, 0.0015514683909714222, 0.06770458817481995, 0.007515557110309601, -0.0537482313811779, -0.04089660197496414, 0.013537059538066387, 0.02585628256201744, -0.07075262814760208, 0.024387691169977188, -0.051773861050605774, -0.01358729973435402, 0.03466474264860153, -0.03756244108080864, -0.0004379946331027895, 0.00411901855841279, 0.08343092352151871, -0.03128603845834732, -0.03291026130318642, 0.01927122101187706, 0.049756377935409546, 0.0525374636054039, 0.031038951128721237, -0.03688022494316101, 0.08467206358909607, 0.015203333459794521, 0.005803728010505438, 0.03534954786300659, 0.06679242849349976, -0.010373336263000965, -0.010298545472323895, 0.042136792093515396, -0.0021486037876456976, 0.0486723892390728, -0.01843005232512951, 0.036717161536216736, -0.020569970831274986, -0.032364051789045334, -0.015241657383739948, -0.037152789533138275, -0.06736809760332108, -0.028633952140808105, -0.029455797746777534, -0.015670305117964745, 0.035566288977861404, 0.03109542652964592, -0.0252358578145504, -0.008632027544081211, 0.016840599477291107, 0.07187294960021973, -0.03370210528373718, 0.02568049542605877, 0.0030239576008170843, -0.01745455712080002, 0.041310928761959076, -0.02674422599375248, 0.002954669762402773, -0.0051855528727173805, 0.031095469370484352, 0.03388671949505806, -0.03302143141627312, -0.03420979529619217, -0.03471852093935013, -0.018838878720998764, -0.05182591825723648, -0.042099907994270325, 0.00898243859410286, -0.022544806823134422, 0.03802182525396347, -0.005759252700954676, 0.020944632589817047, -0.04999412223696709, -0.009922676719725132, -0.004956515040248632, 0.03847557678818703, 0.05375688895583153, 0.03689054027199745, -0.02095757983624935, 0.020517749711871147, -0.006334969308227301, 0.03707185015082359, -0.037916552275419235, -0.0034642594400793314, -0.051564887166023254, 0.021381059661507607, -0.03504357114434242, 0.0017053846968337893, -0.07317427545785904, 0.009500831365585327, -0.0382336787879467, 0.01483010221272707, 0.018555201590061188, 0.08010083436965942, 0.02887915074825287, -0.0034624668769538403, 0.012399394996464252, -0.003517832839861512, -0.006502025295048952, 0.02262044884264469, -0.058300092816352844, 0.0036917258985340595, 0.05230124667286873, 0.0475568063557148, 0.017654579132795334, 0.01725960336625576, -0.003845828352496028, 0.021392732858657837, 0.0268434789031744, -0.028630036860704422, -0.008355613797903061, -0.007104082498699427, 0.03982453793287277, 0.07486826181411743, -0.035546474158763885, -0.02245963364839554, 0.01799941249191761, 0.01631760038435459, -0.004001430235803127, -0.02884378284215927, -0.06317553669214249, 0.04193469509482384, -0.03486568480730057, -0.039266180247068405, 0.00020248134387657046, 0.004454620648175478, 0.0013066373066976666, -0.036047838628292084, -0.06027920916676521, 0.042777664959430695, -0.035360902547836304, -0.01124781183898449, 0.02495618350803852, -0.01540767215192318, 0.0026361048221588135, 0.005212053656578064, -0.06009543687105179, -0.035617467015981674, 0.004600923974066973, -0.026585066691040993, -0.048204295337200165, -0.03423966467380524, 0.04749478027224541, 0.026109758764505386, -0.060786131769418716, 0.018120449036359787, -0.00902602169662714, 0.04571301117539406, 0.00479661813005805, 0.000322285428410396, -0.06433948874473572, -0.0877046138048172, 0.027828287333250046, 0.0381537489593029, -0.029247531667351723, -0.022181931883096695, 0.04464352875947952, 0.02642030641436577, -0.02732223831117153, 0.031548693776130676, -0.05763266980648041, -0.04698466509580612, -0.0327492281794548, -0.006998214405030012, 0.009880664758384228, 0.014635715633630753, -0.052403174340724945, -0.05205368250608444, 0.028381910175085068, -0.012497073970735073, 0.043352771550416946, 0.0200372114777565, -0.02385304495692253, 0.02919948473572731, -0.05087345466017723, -0.02660507522523403, -0.004488328937441111, -0.027352115139365196, 0.03545542433857918, 0.04611872881650925, -0.017075255513191223, -0.0018862993456423283, 0.0220706257969141, 0.003147277282550931, -0.01902870088815689, -0.043096281588077545, 0.03001713939011097, -0.0027110064402222633, 0.018158117309212685, -0.05598766356706619, -0.028486397117376328, -0.028713209554553032, 0.02105346880853176, -0.010259349830448627, 0.012570314109325409, -0.014733579941093922, 0.031107667833566666, -0.0517486110329628, 0.045142460614442825, 0.02365766651928425, 0.03300062566995621, 0.0319361612200737, 0.007458861451596022, 0.010136489756405354, 0.0026983553543686867, -0.0038181340787559748, 0.025863008573651314, -0.016852593049407005, 0.042002756148576736, -0.018280215561389923, 0.022535232827067375, 0.008858957327902317, -0.0012848841724917293, 0.06658504158258438, 0.05953293293714523, 0.029346084222197533, 0.013433237560093403, -0.0008779647760093212, 0.0563008189201355, -0.002545083872973919, 0.023943576961755753, 0.04252209514379501, -0.0045328824780881405, 0.04029466211795807, -0.005377510096877813, -0.005953290034085512, 0.03663886711001396, -0.014424370601773262, -0.02287539839744568, 0.003955229185521603, -0.02211429551243782, -0.010598337277770042, 0.04732527211308479, 0.006826597731560469, -0.00019719862029887736, -0.03663845732808113, 0.05789506062865257, 0.014901755377650261, 0.07066012173891068, 0.04710100591182709, 0.02815738506615162, -0.061725519597530365, 0.05395137518644333, -0.045440923422575, -0.015541636385023594, -0.03544384613633156, -0.007813489064574242, 0.030429592356085777, 0.02438509650528431, -0.05026765912771225, 0.021837230771780014, 0.06075043976306915, 0.03317859023809433, 0.043819915503263474, -0.012480027973651886, 0.0361473374068737, 0.010500479489564896, 0.06566333770751953, -0.022285927087068558, 0.03873659297823906, 0.007822064682841301, -0.005460327956825495, -0.04977947100996971, -0.004176598507910967, 0.007239168044179678, -0.0008642399916425347, 0.10916800051927567, 0.002818357665091753, -0.0006644924287684262, -0.013222740031778812, 0.005293568130582571, -0.010895137675106525, 0.047019943594932556, 0.04638513922691345, 0.04205985739827156, -0.005244747269898653, -0.01229327917098999, -0.012096360325813293, 0.08735343813896179, -0.03616379201412201, -0.013613268733024597, 0.031227726489305496, -0.043067604303359985, -0.015473471954464912, -0.012839068658649921, -0.041461311280727386, -0.0009438698180019855, -0.014741739258170128, 0.013310149312019348, 0.027315104380249977, 0.008911862038075924, -0.023582305759191513, 0.009998119436204433, -0.0327044352889061, 0.008727381005883217, 0.008689727634191513, -0.002872373443096876, 0.012245560996234417, 0.011897574178874493, -0.06020790711045265, 0.0334826298058033, 0.055040646344423294, 0.07067547738552094, -0.006480347830802202, -0.007129322271794081, 0.023007838055491447, -0.027879931032657623, -0.05262116342782974, -0.03795430809259415, -0.011629162356257439, -0.03801840543746948, -0.044323574751615524, -0.015374711714684963, 0.013728607445955276, 0.064031682908535, 0.005225329659879208, -0.053829796612262726, -0.029700402170419693, -0.04517807438969612, -0.06105649843811989, -0.012920194305479527, -0.05363653972744942, 0.030899662524461746, -0.014653786085546017, 0.007981717586517334, -0.002859917003661394, -0.066818468272686, -0.052835769951343536, 0.02313023805618286, 0.0134068438783288, -0.053400669246912, -0.020848292857408524, -0.036049406975507736, -0.07065373659133911, 0.03304389491677284, 0.06370709836483002, 0.03176276758313179, 0.0006629372946918011, -0.042548973113298416, -0.01731099933385849, -0.001100751687772572, -0.04404793307185173, 0.03597753494977951, 0.009672742336988449, 0.025827530771493912, 0.05306277051568031, -0.04759426787495613, 0.011401420459151268, 0.020989960059523582, 0.0003046104102395475, -0.04691349342465401, -0.01909429393708706, -0.024024931713938713, -0.02547927014529705, 0.016335848718881607, -0.039091043174266815, -0.007239112164825201, 0.06612424552440643, 0.025234675034880638, -0.002276904182508588, -0.01228958647698164, -0.0007765247137285769, -0.01276688277721405, -0.05215713381767273, 0.05236300453543663, -0.009887725114822388, -0.04119936749339104, -0.017328625544905663, 0.024809058755636215 ]
<p>I am in a situation where I have to compute:</p> <p>$$E(u(x_1)|\bar{X},S^2)$$</p> <p>where $X_1$ is a normally distributed random variable and $u(.)$ some function. I know that by the student's theorem the sample mean and the sample variance are independent and moreover that $\frac{(n-1)S^2}{\sigma^2}\sim \chi^2 (n-1)$. </p> <p>Can I simplify the expectation with the information I possess? Is perhaps the bivariate normal distribution of use here?</p> <p>Thanks.</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>: Yes, an iid sample on $X$ is assumed here, hence the subscript $1$ on $u(x_1)$. If the expectation cannot be simplified, what is the conditional distribution of $X_1$ given $\bar{X}$ and $S^2$?</p>
g74342
[ -0.020460758358240128, 0.041020140051841736, -0.021952912211418152, -0.0107208751142025, -0.040911491960287094, 0.00207571592181921, 0.022781243547797203, 0.05120084807276726, -0.020281292498111725, -0.002252876991406083, 0.001424634363502264, 0.04341001436114311, -0.03474178537726402, -0.0017004088731482625, -0.013286935165524483, 0.007532039657235146, -0.0074261147528886795, -0.002418720629066229, 0.06270189583301544, -0.009787827730178833, -0.10472390800714493, -0.006249823607504368, 0.027928370982408524, -0.019863834604620934, 0.0941576212644577, -0.013745042495429516, -0.04380330443382263, 0.0417771115899086, -0.046235065907239914, 0.011900195851922035, -0.013402027077972889, -0.024885646998882294, 0.08747128397226334, -0.02755436860024929, -0.018779350444674492, 0.038768358528614044, 0.07779525220394135, -0.021903380751609802, 0.012229494750499725, -0.03330275043845177, -0.02753402851521969, 0.016403617337346077, 0.026261692866683006, -0.027838023379445076, -0.03667449951171875, 0.029334349557757378, 0.0004171132168266922, 0.015044573694467545, 0.012304012663662434, -0.05261717364192009, 0.0010922543006017804, 0.05261406674981117, 0.021077405661344528, -0.03210867941379547, 0.010166325606405735, 0.005383095238357782, 0.02849731221795082, -0.0343649722635746, -0.0029976037330925465, 0.05345778539776802, 0.010074756108224392, -0.061777520924806595, -0.07003501057624817, 0.004197846166789532, -0.003972338046878576, 0.04498566687107086, 0.004952752031385899, 0.04539472237229347, -0.03890098258852959, 0.022522781044244766, -0.005368445534259081, -0.017486272379755974, 0.05035818740725517, -0.05578100308775902, -0.03670777007937431, -0.062357064336538315, 0.016103876754641533, -0.018764439970254898, -0.001018586684949696, 0.028325706720352173, -0.014886516146361828, -0.02495574578642845, 0.013155133463442326, -0.0006942615145817399, -0.006906109396368265, -0.01964087039232254, 0.04357660561800003, 0.0023786413948982954, 0.020317530259490013, 0.05602915212512016, 0.03890987113118172, -0.01180030032992363, 0.01483581867069006, 0.033369727432727814, 0.02709909714758396, -0.04441765323281288, -0.07546662539243698, 0.023588597774505615, 0.0036870879121124744, -0.008765310049057007, 0.013105344958603382, -0.019260769709944725, -0.027483636513352394, 0.016478819772601128, -0.02621181309223175, 0.05329345911741257, 0.08806421607732773, 0.019147660583257675, -0.0075156777165830135, -0.06828479468822479, -0.039646781980991364, -0.02608371153473854, -0.02275289222598076, 0.016693847253918648, -0.013840967789292336, -0.010194103233516216, 0.061036430299282074, 0.018915539607405663, -0.0025121874641627073, 0.01812548004090786, -0.03165886178612709, -0.006368913222104311, 0.06289906799793243, 0.07341793179512024, -0.02118116430938244, 0.03484778478741646, -0.034351859241724014, 0.0523359514772892, 0.05387594550848007, -0.05144842714071274, -0.019766198471188545, 0.010807312093675137, 0.021517770364880562, 0.03035668283700943, 0.011683708988130093, 0.029433388262987137, -0.08008027076721191, 0.04332877695560455, -0.0008562922012060881, 0.016775745898485184, 0.019214726984500885, 0.03246120363473892, 0.004754364490509033, -0.031066404655575752, -0.016401663422584534, 0.006384570617228746, 0.02365179918706417, -0.005753564648330212, 0.013395409099757671, 0.013630415312945843, -0.016665758565068245, 0.03579610213637352, -0.03667106479406357, 0.011619707569479942, -0.03696653991937637, 0.04901408031582832, 0.04806011542677879, 0.03546416386961937, 0.01402848307043314, -0.041029270738363266, 0.0826752781867981, 0.014582732692360878, -0.05040867254137993, 0.026788873597979546, -0.016399182379245758, -0.013785237446427345, 0.05880836397409439, -0.04262477159500122, -0.03139706328511238, -0.023116448894143105, -0.002604527398943901, -0.033247463405132294, -0.03038700856268406, -0.01028349343687296, -0.006309432443231344, -0.014548205770552158, -0.0037941117770969868, -0.010765072889626026, 0.02799881063401699, 0.09487118571996689, -0.06637704372406006, -0.004071930423378944, -0.01416353415697813, -0.07377724349498749, 0.028734833002090454, -0.012133076786994934, 0.0030828258022665977, 0.01759260892868042, 0.01526052039116621, 0.011932721361517906, -0.016746893525123596, -0.0017222127644345164, -0.03803754970431328, 0.030630765482783318, -0.06550691276788712, -0.0012686792761087418, 0.031013941392302513, 0.005471278913319111, 0.012509816326200962, 0.10308916121721268, 0.005223942920565605, 0.04030191898345947, 0.05357448384165764, -0.004905289970338345, 0.011796954087913036, -0.024528324604034424, 0.022569093853235245, -0.03262477368116379, 0.0028360055293887854, 0.0020896277856081724, 0.025711920112371445, -0.07173357903957367, -0.020159417763352394, 0.041053395718336105, 0.08998965471982956, -0.06596235185861588, -0.009394562803208828, -0.035160571336746216, -0.023314179852604866, -0.02920880727469921, -0.04591944441199303, -0.044288478791713715, 0.029085760936141014, 0.025186238810420036, 0.023922082036733627, 0.07444431632757187, -0.011804267764091492, 0.013413403183221817, 0.02359195053577423, 0.01075592078268528, -0.039336685091257095, -0.012134069576859474, 0.04910898953676224, -0.012444259598851204, 0.058272529393434525, 0.02216949686408043, -0.00995228998363018, 0.030719449743628502, 0.015112289227545261, 0.042873136699199677, -0.008481311611831188, -0.053868018090724945, 0.04736780747771263, 0.03995896875858307, -0.03334410488605499, 0.004859843757003546, 0.02702382579445839, -0.009424982592463493, 0.020192964002490044, -0.004904631059616804, -0.052560172975063324, -0.010599141009151936, 0.015481211245059967, 0.05332547426223755, -0.011755756102502346, -0.06504788249731064, -0.011860270984470844, -0.06675142049789429, 0.0037164664827287197, -0.031202012673020363, -0.02058989368379116, -0.0348806232213974, 0.0448915958404541, 0.018928153440356255, -0.024871839210391045, 0.033434946089982986, 0.03750663623213768, 0.0425112321972847, 0.06056036055088043, -0.010472261346876621, 0.029162229970097542, 0.0401870459318161, -0.014876040630042553, 0.06636164337396622, 0.01685928925871849, -0.037733227014541626, -0.05871324613690376, 0.012801678851246834, -0.02969694510102272, -0.003568289102986455, 0.031860724091529846, -0.012518585659563541, -0.041046153753995895, 0.028342440724372864, 0.022507647052407265, -0.03314193710684776, 0.03724962845444679, 0.02077021449804306, -0.0037056973669677973, 0.03215635195374489, -0.01581818424165249, 0.01682778261601925, 0.06093230098485947, 0.06296518445014954, 0.016527624800801277, 0.0011287949746474624, 0.01532005239278078, -0.027321692556142807, -0.028238477185368538, 0.03732801973819733, -0.04890783876180649, -0.03871576860547066, -0.0034113565925508738, 0.026573557406663895, -0.0036186864599585533, -0.03173963353037834, -0.009100505150854588, -0.0138646699488163, -0.04207564517855644, -0.03925377503037453, -0.050773896276950836, -0.03176480904221535, -0.01472780853509903, -0.01786665804684162, -0.07138779014348984, 0.0010533550521358848, -0.0016141432570293546, 0.002749738050624728, 0.011018444783985615, 0.01477593183517456, 0.014538885094225407, -0.05857057869434357, -0.018320713192224503, 0.029015030711889267, 0.04251430556178093, -0.004191278479993343, -0.049524758011102676, -0.007000144571065903, -0.030161086469888687, -0.03761964663863182, 0.03654087334871292, 0.02433917485177517, -0.017232291400432587, -0.02170739695429802, 0.023350197821855545, -0.017112838104367256, -0.02842501550912857, 0.023926755413413048, 0.02370346710085869, 0.04539500176906586, 0.002666858956217766, -0.011046528816223145, -0.06965145468711853, -0.03801066800951958, -0.04334525763988495, -0.07223407924175262, -0.0037911368999630213, 0.021242408081889153, 0.010027210228145123, 0.008441000245511532, -0.0035628266632556915, 0.05833277851343155, 0.05353004112839699, -0.017249204218387604, 0.005725053604692221, 0.0556170828640461, 0.051567960530519485, 0.027592971920967102, 0.010944579727947712, -0.0068122451193630695, 0.04811161011457443, -0.06853078305721283, -0.03619818016886711, 0.06880849599838257, -0.037960417568683624, -0.02755291573703289, 0.029636703431606293, 0.008805125020444393, -0.014411931857466698, 0.03031616471707821, -0.011050918139517307, 0.008527170866727829, 0.053056638687849045, -0.0042798700742423534, 0.016667408868670464, -0.050337355583906174, -0.008913680911064148, 0.05227714404463768, -0.01624438352882862, -0.006986530032008886, 0.041449110954999924, -0.0011718453606590629, 0.0025559545028954744, 0.004964448045939207, 0.012159137986600399, -0.017634175717830658, 0.0012716578785330057, 0.021974284201860428, 0.023032555356621742, -0.04085178300738335, 0.029375186190009117, -0.09012887626886368, -0.07320187240839005, 0.040833503007888794, 0.01279489602893591, -0.059621285647153854, 0.05613156035542488, -0.028758171945810318, -0.05057302489876747, 0.053050559014081955, 0.006956313271075487, 0.02249188721179962, 0.028463127091526985, 0.00617560837417841, -0.07285414636135101, 0.00202977959997952, 0.01928647793829441, -0.03182727470993996, -0.004028869792819023, -0.006636069156229496, 0.027830157428979874, -0.07313372194766998, -0.012762542814016342, -0.036903027445077896, -0.005972791463136673, -0.013678578659892082, 0.010458673350512981, -0.0002596723788883537, -0.06414561718702316, 0.008992007933557034, 0.027471911162137985, -0.019403953105211258, 0.007579196244478226, -0.0036056542303413153, -0.006855376064777374, 0.021037591621279716, 0.03069612942636013, 0.02109442837536335, 0.022370213642716408, -0.06470204889774323, 0.015737781301140785, 0.06323082745075226, 0.02616824395954609, -0.011987116187810898, -0.02016114816069603, 0.005701701622456312, 0.006763102486729622, -0.0399601124227047, -0.05047333240509033, -0.042449865490198135, -0.06378377974033356, -0.01277057733386755, -0.06353051215410233, -0.03903010115027428, 0.013791634701192379, 0.0033583969343453646, -0.02467203699052334, -0.03264472633600235, 0.0686509907245636, 0.03902712091803551, -0.02866275981068611, 0.06845127791166306, 0.016147177666425705, -0.005221434403210878, 0.054159361869096756, -0.005647702608257532, -0.03671649098396301, 0.03788948059082031, 0.030539153143763542, 0.01330708060413599, 0.012233219109475613, -0.025179624557495117, 0.0038576980587095022, -0.0007597467047162354, -0.03819337114691734, -0.005792415700852871, -0.11104542762041092, -0.01185522973537445, 0.013753477483987808, -0.013799665495753288, -0.010980123654007912, -0.001550409011542797, 0.037617653608322144, -0.040370892733335495, -0.032142262905836105, 0.013447798788547516, -0.016175884753465652, -0.011308183893561363, 0.06298300623893738, 0.02269178256392479, -0.04143979772925377, -0.05881715565919876, -0.016315707936882973, 0.013515214435756207, 0.03401138633489609, -0.03628281131386757, -0.01034260168671608, -0.050061799585819244, 0.02585996314883232, -0.026285381987690926, -0.006499167997390032, 0.03434276208281517, 0.037486009299755096, 0.03969452530145645, -0.03157326951622963, -0.10076519846916199, 0.02985524758696556, -0.062321946024894714, 0.04395689070224762, -0.027930889278650284, -0.11923269927501678, 0.0106574185192585, -0.01011448260396719, 0.01639586314558983, 0.05229421332478523, 0.06461285799741745, -0.02257702685892582, 0.03577462583780289, -0.004213646985590458, 0.1127743050456047, 0.023479927331209183, 0.003869781969115138, 0.08200381696224213, -0.05139898881316185, -0.06492321193218231, -0.012414784170687199, -0.031051602214574814, -0.019691433757543564, 0.0021785537246614695, -0.008721011690795422, 0.08730240166187286, -0.007391948252916336, 0.04068351909518242, 0.02830446884036064, -0.018450027331709862, -0.053007710725069046, -0.08557701110839844, -0.03276683762669563, -0.009033921174705029, 0.00896882638335228, -0.020277542993426323, 0.010414703749120235, -0.026887530460953712, -0.012954873964190483, 0.003999173175543547, -0.02373136766254902, -0.007996947504580021, 0.029639579355716705, -0.03989539295434952, 0.034175802022218704, -0.03619438409805298, -0.03376565873622894, 0.02650625631213188, -0.00029718250152654946, -0.01682114042341709, -0.006686921697109938, 0.0018951015081256628, -0.02342761866748333, 0.05379236489534378, -0.06757231056690216, 0.05842146277427673, -0.02297215349972248, -0.019178500398993492, -0.011879565194249153, -0.007242369465529919, 0.03043973259627819, 0.03324821591377258, -0.034407809376716614, 0.04939430579543114, -0.03452054783701897, -0.030975161120295525, -0.08248771727085114, -0.014564859680831432, 0.0000305378925986588, 0.006766621023416519, -0.028146637603640556, 0.02224726602435112, 0.015908675268292427, -0.015068203210830688, 0.06760367006063461, -0.016223877668380737, 0.027487212792038918, 0.018064182251691818, -0.008062971755862236, 0.07290726155042648, 0.004345971625298262, 0.02216397039592266, 0.01607639715075493, 0.04294610768556595, -0.08149947971105576, -0.029524631798267365, 0.032615821808576584, 0.023142457008361816, 0.011553112417459488, -0.007625487167388201, 0.04548182711005211, -0.009969728998839855, -0.017539719119668007, 0.006281686946749687, -0.009860964491963387, 0.0027427554596215487, 0.03889809921383858, 0.00162981147877872, 0.003284107893705368, -0.059389349073171616, -0.022200847044587135, 0.020999927073717117, -0.04329562559723854, -0.026265619322657585, -0.010107018053531647, 0.030089590698480606, -0.021649856120347977, 0.03235717862844467, -0.01890227198600769, 0.013480343855917454, 0.014731333591043949, 0.028881030157208443, 0.0398995578289032, -0.0035178440157324076, -0.030267376452684402, -0.004730870481580496, 0.03953627124428749, 0.009526552632451057, 0.06667418032884598, -0.025792744010686874, -0.07774436473846436, -0.0711638554930687, -0.04303866997361183, -0.01976514793932438, -0.022295251488685608, 0.06572423875331879, -0.014160417020320892, 0.007251646835356951, 0.02478557825088501, 0.020255854353308678, 0.021677695214748383, 0.006316114217042923, 0.01181594654917717, 0.08068280667066574, 0.0532994344830513, 0.029292335733771324, 0.052717164158821106, 0.009985322132706642, -0.00032663840102031827, -0.044778741896152496, 0.0021313985344022512, -0.007987447082996368, 0.08887998014688492, -0.020501449704170227, 0.021189851686358452, 0.021286213770508766, 0.019590791314840317, 0.01549170259386301, 0.021365484222769737, -0.037388719618320465, 0.03818207606673241, 0.08608885109424591, 0.03648624196648598, -0.03901473432779312, -0.008407320827245712, 0.04660973697900772, 0.040247101336717606, 0.009627690538764, -0.02253413200378418, -0.024616990238428116, -0.002154237823560834, 0.05871608853340149, 0.01309255976229906, 0.013925218023359776, -0.029258720576763153, -0.054987818002700806, -0.011783127672970295, -0.04389018565416336, -0.056439828127622604, -0.009054102003574371, 0.0448039174079895, 0.04278457164764404, -0.010577003471553326, -0.046653810888528824, -0.03890617564320564, -0.0249414574354887, -0.05944960564374924, -0.01035360898822546, 0.014490300789475441, 0.007748710922896862, -0.045928530395030975, 0.017662903293967247, 0.035239823162555695, -0.05661705881357193, -0.012753628194332123, 0.001761091174557805, 0.022599127143621445, -0.05358779430389404, -0.013549767434597015, 0.026042034849524498, 0.009246732108294964, -0.007294428069144487, -0.04690002277493477, 0.08091073483228683, -0.003424877068027854, -0.013295963406562805, -0.05660989508032799, -0.009638750925660133, -0.0070173307321965694, 0.020751070231199265, -0.016920221969485283, -0.0035081496462225914, 0.0331161804497242, 0.004275035113096237, 0.02130480296909809, -0.010889611206948757, 0.011068550869822502, -0.09698338061571121, 0.005660297814756632, 0.010399325750768185, -0.04778756573796272, 0.011611551977694035, -0.08341250568628311, -0.02707374468445778, -0.08023708313703537, 0.016596628352999687, -0.014830589294433594, -0.011475003324449062, 0.020531849935650826, 0.019280867651104927, -0.011288522742688656, -0.019617125391960144, 0.007980503141880035, 0.027019044384360313, 0.04816502705216408, -0.007039299234747887, 0.005338521674275398, 0.0023373865988105536, 0.05511435866355896, 0.03652865067124367, -0.021849654614925385, -0.025276683270931244, 0.014491413719952106, -0.013046544045209885, 0.05463232845067978, -0.02104952000081539, -0.04118925705552101, 0.007857557386159897, 0.054321419447660446, 0.01283574290573597, 0.0185457281768322, 0.038868505507707596, -0.019402893260121346, -0.0003120356996078044, 0.030986234545707703, -0.024678779765963554, 0.01913818158209324, 0.0320708304643631, -0.03924843668937683, -0.05594459921121597, -0.005301850847899914, -0.025280427187681198, -0.015182050876319408, 0.03944925591349602, -0.014169258065521717, -0.07481357455253601, -0.005509963259100914, -0.022894077003002167, 0.04377240315079689, 0.022605346515774727, -0.01495135948061943, 0.04278012737631798, 0.013905847445130348, 0.05311210826039314, -0.006256058346480131, -0.017087923362851143, -0.030100200325250626, -0.08085284382104874, 0.01767212152481079, 0.013705487363040447, -0.03695856034755707, 0.04733816534280777, 0.04175500571727753 ]
<p>I have a data set with ~80 records, with ~8 features. I want to predict one of the features in future records. The feature is numeric and discrete. It ranges between -30 up to 140 with steps of 5. Until now I wanted to predict another feature which is boolean, so I used logistic regression. Which method should I use here? Maybe some kind of particle filter?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
g20432
[ 0.02628648839890957, 0.011455962434411049, 0.017583109438419342, -0.04498695954680443, 0.0024425401352345943, -0.06359578669071198, 0.005564939696341753, 0.023455576971173286, -0.07070114463567734, -0.08116219192743301, 0.036451779305934906, 0.08688357472419739, 0.07667706906795502, -0.02710370346903801, -0.015986202284693718, -0.02789677493274212, 0.015047241933643818, -0.04875260591506958, -0.008978468365967274, 0.0028913409914821386, 0.0402793250977993, 0.05510164797306061, 0.01156274601817131, -0.0005461149848997593, -0.010060695931315422, 0.023885738104581833, -0.007265396881848574, 0.12860055267810822, -0.007086468394845724, 0.054130248725414276, 0.0065283081494271755, -0.010244098491966724, 0.02790963649749756, -0.006420972757041454, 0.009278485551476479, -0.05232888087630272, 0.011196216568350792, -0.013856744393706322, 0.010366378352046013, -0.024887260049581528, 0.030562615022063255, 0.01381696853786707, -0.02909211628139019, 0.019387634471058846, 0.0504174530506134, -0.023809295147657394, 0.0040321857668459415, -0.026182327419519424, -0.007212728261947632, 0.05593540519475937, -0.023617824539542198, -0.04119880124926567, -0.052869927138090134, -0.03239932283759117, 0.07353490591049194, 0.04128306731581688, 0.005171429365873337, 0.007516723126173019, 0.0003578633477445692, -0.05661338195204735, 0.07478740811347961, -0.0254338551312685, -0.021180151030421257, -0.017291013151407242, 0.014597535133361816, 0.028433065861463547, -0.05134454369544983, -0.02774486131966114, 0.04680175334215164, 0.016898538917303085, 0.007685299031436443, 0.04371620714664459, -0.011915560811758041, -0.0106593556702137, -0.024795008823275566, -0.0022972244769334793, -0.09785166382789612, 0.04267106205224991, 0.012788649648427963, 0.0603167861700058, -0.025359194725751877, 0.007342834956943989, 0.022093048319220543, -0.04246518388390541, -0.03936739265918732, 0.007514229975640774, 0.002773913089185953, -0.005763294640928507, 0.01681874878704548, -0.009217184036970139, -0.07097305357456207, -0.040302734822034836, 0.058207884430885315, 0.007816753350198269, -0.019089091569185257, 0.02178817242383957, -0.030273418873548508, 0.03947438672184944, 0.00979861430823803, 0.000150737541844137, 0.03920833393931389, 0.043382808566093445, 0.023679330945014954, -0.04800876975059509, -0.05870826169848442, -0.03423134610056877, -0.02778160385787487, 0.01781580224633217, -0.01100743655115366, -0.05153058096766472, -0.0362708680331707, 0.006730996072292328, -0.013262594118714333, -0.03201521560549736, -0.06982295960187912, -0.025487598031759262, -0.02780623361468315, 0.015193103812634945, 0.0032716079149395227, -0.05310732126235962, 0.022385351359844208, -0.03439885750412941, 0.0887451022863388, 0.035438377410173416, -0.05026808753609657, 0.00437508337199688, -0.06860728561878204, 0.0629279762506485, 0.056572526693344116, -0.00954203587025404, 0.012475446797907352, -0.0034895753487944603, 0.016683781519532204, 0.016556376591324806, -0.007824333384633064, 0.05703612044453621, -0.03135509788990021, 0.004786567762494087, 0.015764350071549416, 0.05161208286881447, 0.06507057696580887, 0.0407806821167469, 0.04308526962995529, 0.010278269648551941, -0.0184923205524683, -0.03112543188035488, -0.07291237264871597, 0.013648725114762783, -0.010615779086947441, 0.05415833368897438, 0.007514822296798229, 0.002158381510525942, -0.038565266877412796, 0.04041961953043938, 0.008057891391217709, -0.017114251852035522, 0.0042189001105725765, 0.04146565869450569, -0.014250010251998901, 0.01669982075691223, 0.027861103415489197, -0.028527572751045227, -0.0026966140139847994, 0.05461074784398079, 0.002871041651815176, -0.0302325040102005, -0.008885441347956657, -0.041351642459630966, -0.08906151354312897, -0.00458111148327589, 0.02531220018863678, 0.011568191461265087, 0.008542240597307682, -0.01980864629149437, 0.0859583392739296, 0.03161284700036049, -0.000001052603465723223, 0.01379008125513792, 0.08326397836208344, -0.037940673530101776, 0.02473597042262554, -0.052821602672338486, 0.016786059364676476, 0.02712922729551792, -0.07134728878736496, -0.038834087550640106, -0.015465043485164642, 0.029153572395443916, -0.006229703780263662, 0.005267968401312828, 0.003286644583567977, -0.059586282819509506, -0.027624476701021194, -0.024218035861849785, 0.03615310415625572, 0.04440699890255928, 0.019239582121372223, -0.04276234284043312, -0.008155983872711658, -0.022817930206656456, 0.020343422889709473, 0.06490613520145416, -0.013750052079558372, 0.04340853542089462, -0.007575932890176773, 0.023174820467829704, 0.07432988286018372, -0.00235539092682302, -0.009386788122355938, -0.005409472156316042, 0.0149459233507514, 0.017992226406931877, -0.045683734118938446, -0.009070714935660362, 0.0067822979763150215, -0.025050071999430656, -0.0363658107817173, 0.038566604256629944, 0.03202657401561737, 0.008527644909918308, -0.07154771685600281, -0.009285642765462399, 0.03988830745220184, 0.03358609229326248, 0.02121312916278839, 0.02436497062444687, 0.06215415149927139, -0.032464902848005295, 0.03610682487487793, 0.005623376928269863, -0.04924967512488365, -0.05969992280006409, -0.022157592698931694, -0.02598627656698227, 0.041706327348947525, 0.02505359798669815, 0.017592355608940125, -0.008419545367360115, 0.009483687579631805, 0.01780654862523079, -0.03481804206967354, -0.018923107534646988, 0.01930968463420868, -0.018891723826527596, 0.016483353450894356, -0.030463309958577156, -0.04158037155866623, -0.011844645254313946, 0.03469451144337654, 0.025350896641612053, 0.01628193072974682, 0.02801409922540188, -0.022724810987710953, -0.016647087410092354, -0.008424983359873295, -0.017621032893657684, 0.012222895398736, 0.005580015946179628, 0.027970802038908005, -0.032690826803445816, -0.01674344576895237, 0.00965314544737339, -0.03164025396108627, -0.027739325538277626, -0.00380471209064126, -0.03312736749649048, -0.06363314390182495, 0.04283624887466431, 0.05068645998835564, 0.06406760215759277, 0.01674741320312023, 0.011487577110528946, 0.04488316550850868, -0.013940121047198772, 0.021400436758995056, 0.03424049913883209, -0.020129123702645302, 0.025583416223526, 0.021564839407801628, 0.04791991412639618, 0.008088639006018639, -0.03227889537811279, 0.010661745443940163, 0.022220712155103683, 0.027135420590639114, 0.01919684000313282, 0.03327824920415878, 0.009820815175771713, 0.0474960096180439, 0.08680859208106995, 0.010935225524008274, 0.006542150396853685, 0.02253326028585434, 0.0075233569368720055, -0.017636563628911972, 0.03599875420331955, 0.033358290791511536, 0.028005365282297134, 0.0697663351893425, 0.00730798440054059, -0.036376990377902985, -0.034418363124132156, -0.016543544828891754, -0.010020623914897442, -0.038003697991371155, -0.07168494164943695, -0.01784270629286766, 0.030891671776771545, 0.05435093119740486, -0.07552994042634964, -0.04456637427210808, -0.015206859447062016, -0.021196499466896057, 0.014428146183490753, -0.007172719109803438, -0.060164328664541245, -0.023277096450328827, 0.04255194962024689, 0.010860845446586609, -0.0017943365965038538, 0.013761874288320541, -0.015026641078293324, 0.015568569302558899, 0.011874096468091011, 0.0013867784291505814, 0.037985384464263916, -0.027733903378248215, 0.06305976957082748, -0.028981221839785576, 0.027394436299800873, 0.042083948850631714, 0.06849192827939987, -0.021346811205148697, -0.033648066222667694, 0.00916979555040598, -0.04905657470226288, -0.032301146537065506, -0.04465097934007645, -0.0054602185264229774, -0.00297474954277277, 0.013953398913145065, 0.025746338069438934, 0.021689986810088158, -0.028784573078155518, 0.0019380729645490646, 0.002694371622055769, 0.040419064462184906, -0.007278382778167725, -0.01291649229824543, 0.02817281149327755, -0.07867836952209473, -0.030314208939671516, -0.02236657403409481, 0.0212392657995224, 0.023699935525655746, 0.022710829973220825, 0.03362145647406578, -0.00917096808552742, -0.000212098952033557, 0.03257329389452934, -0.01351773738861084, -0.04385041445493698, 0.029685869812965393, 0.006075599696487188, -0.011784511618316174, -0.008883596397936344, 0.014787829481065273, 0.043435417115688324, -0.000021710213331971318, 0.02572447434067726, 0.01865014247596264, -0.04918397590517998, 0.04805565997958183, -0.0028079922776669264, -0.08295182138681412, 0.010363413952291012, 0.044906675815582275, -0.03075026161968708, -0.019003480672836304, 0.07426110655069351, -0.001352053601294756, 0.010132567957043648, -0.00017899902013596147, 0.023807479068636894, -0.06187543645501137, -0.031913142651319504, -0.030182387679815292, -0.011716530658304691, 0.02034825086593628, 0.022001437842845917, -0.02404996007680893, 0.020457886159420013, -0.06563238054513931, -0.01307658664882183, -0.036638129502534866, -0.0606297105550766, -0.025083506479859352, 0.019314896315336227, -0.0056595574133098125, 0.0009632012224756181, -0.03265979886054993, -0.0063412124291062355, -0.020873447880148888, 0.06295302510261536, -0.00030314759351313114, -0.05229588970541954, -0.03302938863635063, 0.010099111124873161, -0.0013809255324304104, 0.01296907290816307, 0.014884225092828274, 0.019608814269304276, -0.03768647462129593, 0.009782671928405762, 0.05530226603150368, -0.01134544052183628, 0.02652238868176937, 0.01686582900583744, 0.0008639582665637136, 0.025508208200335503, 0.021799398586153984, 0.0050697955302894115, -0.00979567226022482, -0.014930222183465958, -0.07580631971359253, -0.07130295038223267, 0.0221982654184103, -0.01919330656528473, -0.04456821829080582, 0.030004791915416718, 0.06504637002944946, 0.015845928341150284, 0.009503569453954697, 0.06346030533313751, 0.008219079114496708, 0.024891884997487068, 0.06331372261047363, -0.033084746450185776, 0.01431059930473566, -0.03807462751865387, 0.013435338623821735, -0.06873923540115356, 0.015560159459710121, 0.010452810674905777, -0.026549125090241432, 0.05200079828500748, -0.04068345949053764, 0.028296425938606262, 0.015157176181674004, 0.06715022027492523, 0.02745055966079235, 0.010000668466091156, -0.039315368980169296, 0.01616811938583851, 0.05486499145627022, -0.01486225612461567, 0.018628930673003197, 0.03218711167573929, -0.002030028263106942, 0.011736561544239521, -0.026539210230112076, 0.010166211053729057, -0.012546323239803314, 0.01608615182340145, -0.019036103039979935, -0.009977222420275211, -0.043720319867134094, -0.0582500658929348, 0.049344323575496674, 0.018968071788549423, -0.03869803994894028, 0.018049869686365128, 0.0491463877260685, -0.006732359062880278, -0.05344811826944351, 0.019655203446745872, -0.05954468995332718, -0.045025020837783813, -0.003993025049567223, 0.004169951193034649, -0.04156893119215965, -0.007074571680277586, -0.004256422631442547, 0.006458154413849115, -0.04358837381005287, -0.021512258797883987, 0.03509777411818504, -0.01709139347076416, -0.000027561392926145345, 0.06977078318595886, 0.011544162407517433, 0.05782461166381836, 0.08331509679555893, 0.005176974926143885, -0.04081448167562485, -0.0715361014008522, -0.003112301230430603, -0.012910286895930767, 0.0075613148510456085, 0.05095537751913071, -0.05449870601296425, 0.0008949636830948293, 0.05175958201289177, -0.023872314020991325, -0.003572660032659769, 0.018037768080830574, 0.04612540826201439, 0.00927602406591177, 0.03955201059579849, -0.037212688475847244, -0.028631290420889854, 0.038916654884815216, 0.02969435602426529, -0.01215540710836649, -0.05259442701935768, 0.010907759889960289, 0.001979672582820058, 0.05077464506030083, -0.004698238801211119, 0.011277020908892155, 0.07361973822116852, -0.02200191654264927, 0.011127560399472713, 0.04941582679748535, -0.022058498114347458, -0.06579878181219101, -0.0671594887971878, -0.005801178980618715, -0.011781533248722553, 0.015514005906879902, 0.034688591957092285, -0.05135193467140198, 0.02812226116657257, 0.02381463721394539, -0.01681247353553772, 0.02130082994699478, -0.0172661654651165, 0.04755950719118118, 0.008076648227870464, -0.05164996162056923, 0.00014788660337217152, 0.001101490342989564, 0.05074544623494148, -0.04980321228504181, -0.03167448565363884, -0.031796734780073166, -0.016117451712489128, 0.026142029091715813, 0.048014964908361435, -0.030550755560398102, 0.0235300213098526, 0.06043072044849396, 0.027948535978794098, -0.0073717678897082806, 0.043525468558073044, 0.00045257326564751565, 0.04503602534532547, 0.017178595066070557, -0.00796337891370058, 0.028167566284537315, -0.0353681705892086, -0.03855693340301514, 0.00925643090158701, 0.011418717913329601, 0.033834826201200485, 0.015989145264029503, -0.03881824016571045, 0.028948502615094185, -0.023668821901082993, 0.0032371163833886385, 0.026255276054143906, -0.0651186853647232, 0.02841266430914402, 0.07726854830980301, -0.062126561999320984, -0.020065639168024063, 0.0462837740778923, 0.020474450662732124, 0.018092269077897072, -0.00818964745849371, -0.01696164160966873, -0.022289158776402473, 0.010384643450379372, 0.0046462262980639935, 0.024779226630926132, 0.060104984790086746, 0.0036853081546723843, 0.0071389577351510525, -0.03554854169487953, 0.00456228107213974, -0.03339105099439621, -0.015035664662718773, 0.03252588212490082, -0.09225081652402878, 0.030079897493124008, 0.024655157700181007, -0.014455546624958515, 0.023087644949555397, 0.022524187341332436, -0.05188051983714104, -0.003752864897251129, -0.01912965439260006, -0.009244630113244057, -0.018453925848007202, 0.028778983280062675, -0.012871206738054752, -0.05812687426805496, 0.002288033254444599, 0.017450908198952675, -0.03804509714245796, -0.02808152511715889, -0.007462373003363609, 0.06295397132635117, 0.03701813519001007, -0.0068190996535122395, -0.030207345262169838, -0.0034359097480773926, 0.020984195172786713, -0.0347675122320652, -0.017109612002968788, 0.02987539954483509, -0.01354599092155695, -0.038919150829315186, -0.032739270478487015, 0.019439704716205597, 0.05426057428121567, -0.03513608127832413, -0.014640666544437408, 0.048147380352020264, 0.00043692372855730355, -0.03325202316045761, 0.0014938372187316418, 0.039169277995824814, 0.024935532361268997, -0.05877852067351341, 0.03330273553729057, -0.00859987922012806, 0.03623875603079796, 0.00480428384616971, 0.04793670028448105, 0.02859477512538433, 0.03679407387971878, 0.003916821908205748, 0.006796145346015692, 0.01584349386394024, -0.00026591631467454135, 0.06521819531917572, 0.0435481071472168, 0.01878545433282852, -0.06271692365407944, 0.02155616506934166, -0.008741236291825771, 0.04485940560698509, -0.025701437145471573, 0.0002126178878825158, -0.013809455558657646, 0.03701971098780632, -0.04797527194023132, 0.02964802086353302, 0.0010382396867498755, -0.043896716088056564, -0.10348564386367798, -0.07941723614931107, -0.047645874321460724, 0.031110497191548347, 0.019921330735087395, -0.09336443245410919, -0.07757949829101562, -0.02686390094459057, -0.06945184618234634, -0.03510080277919769, -0.10218199342489243, -0.009737883694469929, 0.03103405050933361, -0.017959220334887505, 0.04193039983510971, -0.019194981083273888, -0.03163411468267441, -0.0874970555305481, 0.03780502825975418, 0.0300485510379076, -0.02655179239809513, -0.005101852118968964, -0.06175978109240532, 0.009747193194925785, 0.09156237542629242, -0.03998168557882309, -0.033330630511045456, 0.039420560002326965, -0.09232316166162491, -0.10696776211261749, -0.030365947633981705, 0.03491555154323578, -0.0547022707760334, -0.026946285739541054, -0.01834297738969326, -0.002117594238370657, -0.0014996492536738515, -0.011325179599225521, 0.046939145773649216, -0.008950499817728996, 0.10139734297990799, -0.022199835628271103, -0.02108209952712059, -0.009017632342875004, -0.010436294600367546, 0.002387477783486247, -0.04408617690205574, 0.05158999562263489, -0.007719017099589109, -0.019272927194833755, -0.014898196794092655, 0.016941562294960022, 0.045289646834135056, -0.020627718418836594, 0.016178356483578682, 0.014897448010742664, -0.05790073797106743, 0.03329586237668991, 0.02456783875823021, -0.06254880875349045, -0.0000991183624137193, -0.031191719695925713, 0.005743910558521748, -0.021281445398926735, -0.023111093789339066, -0.05075608566403389, 0.06665114313364029, -0.01029267068952322, 0.0002777411136776209, -0.002215617336332798, -0.056741274893283844, -0.05645313858985901, -0.016178203746676445, -0.017177658155560493, -0.002125938655808568, -0.017826957628130913, 0.01677607372403145, -0.012241621501743793, 0.039457350969314575, -0.06492356210947037, 0.08936458826065063, 0.004287145100533962, 0.03690032288432121, 0.032478801906108856, -0.023675238713622093, -0.01771974377334118, 0.02376675046980381, 0.01129732932895422, -0.025583824142813683, -0.02176392450928688, 0.0018104958580806851, -0.029618043452501297, 0.00014391285367310047, -0.08322222530841827, 0.02269001305103302, -0.022294582799077034, 0.015206272713840008, 0.010754651390016079, -0.04293983802199364, 0.0021150149405002594, 0.02700066566467285, -0.010641959495842457, 0.01621340773999691, 0.008936908096075058, 0.038282282650470734, 0.005586894229054451, -0.02371627651154995 ]
<p>I am looking at a Semivariogram. I know it shows me the relationship between distance and semi-variance. I also know that at the end of the range the distance no longer auto correlates. What I am wondering is, what does the semi-variance tell me at the point where to distance no longer auto correlates (at the sill)? So in my case at about 900 m the distance no longer auto correlates. The sill at this value is about 4300. What does this value tell me?</p>
g74343
[ -0.004898170940577984, -0.02937580831348896, -0.005582891404628754, -0.02289886586368084, 0.0006927226204425097, -0.0045501734130084515, 0.05065558850765228, 0.05308122932910919, -0.022993629798293114, -0.024091793224215508, -0.027241943404078484, 0.042590972036123276, 0.005408036522567272, -0.012399885803461075, 0.0066644069738686085, -0.030911844223737717, 0.07563065737485886, -0.045972779393196106, 0.03568907454609871, 0.0222316887229681, 0.014883526600897312, 0.016331680119037628, -0.04222673922777176, -0.026320360600948334, 0.045571647584438324, -0.01779847778379917, -0.007983258925378323, 0.06746970862150192, -0.011232366785407066, 0.05397140607237816, 0.04735212028026581, 0.010209138505160809, 0.09482694417238235, -0.03418094292283058, -0.034877002239227295, 0.006260869093239307, 0.07082922756671906, 0.013033739291131496, 0.016604125499725342, 0.07986250519752502, 0.018300019204616547, 0.0012238738127052784, 0.0319630429148674, 0.018143752589821815, 0.005382257979363203, 0.013899068348109722, -0.04788699746131897, 0.053465474396944046, -0.026885218918323517, 0.00413215346634388, -0.04333525896072388, 0.010735359974205494, -0.007296055555343628, 0.020540650933980942, 0.03245559334754944, -0.0019037387100979686, 0.0568278543651104, 0.04300053045153618, -0.02050969935953617, 0.016874171793460846, 0.02573048695921898, -0.011656651273369789, 0.006760475691407919, 0.01592952199280262, 0.0806519091129303, -0.03893649950623512, 0.008743868209421635, -0.09707653522491455, -0.06637506186962128, -0.003149531316012144, 0.01051317434757948, -0.023548921570181847, 0.013885372318327427, 0.001423395937308669, -0.0654410719871521, -0.04712151363492012, 0.038262128829956055, 0.032338570803403854, 0.04366876929998398, -0.008743462152779102, -0.02115669474005699, -0.02301078289747238, 0.009223989211022854, -0.007607198785990477, 0.10257876664400101, 0.023850923404097557, -0.006463207304477692, 0.019760679453611374, -0.03144491836428642, 0.07038863748311996, 0.00808717217296362, 0.032794851809740067, 0.024349579587578773, -0.0018597582820802927, -0.017239443957805634, -0.04088436812162399, -0.026848655194044113, 0.10064507275819778, -0.0036898197140544653, 0.00883737113326788, -0.02865424193441868, 0.02651328779757023, 0.053847964853048325, 0.009826685301959515, -0.045178089290857315, -0.025700515136122704, -0.00047656847164034843, -0.009418997913599014, 0.041802700608968735, 0.004993982147425413, -0.004439374897629023, -0.020482568070292473, -0.07290256768465042, -0.01153175625950098, 0.009594546630978584, -0.04596570134162903, 0.016489723697304726, 0.017379002645611763, 0.036635421216487885, -0.013089500367641449, 0.046368662267923355, 0.006652712821960449, -0.013131158426404, 0.032039493322372437, -0.02854611724615097, -0.01322888769209385, -0.020887065678834915, 0.016052618622779846, -0.05844532325863838, 0.03720876947045326, 0.025091463699936867, 0.0011162046575918794, -0.031608887016773224, 0.06506777554750443, -0.004270313307642937, 0.0029535226058214903, -0.020217537879943848, 0.0001511067384853959, 0.016760582104325294, 0.04576956853270531, -0.02574247680604458, -0.010715561918914318, 0.021784009411931038, -0.040734145790338516, -0.05449299141764641, -0.007776682730764151, 0.07178962230682373, -0.032308656722307205, -0.00005053424320067279, -0.005345746409147978, 0.03530057519674301, 0.018559468910098076, -0.03906181827187538, -0.03537565469741821, -0.017755325883626938, -0.030377477407455444, -0.04966049641370773, 0.013384059071540833, 0.023616135120391846, -0.007413287181407213, -0.0005647228681482375, -0.03365132585167885, 0.049226272851228714, 0.01944020204246044, -0.01772230677306652, 0.024485282599925995, -0.03562578931450844, -0.040948815643787384, 0.000606924295425415, -0.03341960161924362, -0.0334225594997406, 0.010006487369537354, 0.03346159681677818, -0.0462297648191452, 0.01978435553610325, 0.05230862647294998, 0.04602101445198059, -0.017484107986092567, 0.013074093498289585, 0.033370986580848694, 0.05142523720860481, 0.03591499105095863, 0.027205998077988625, -0.043427906930446625, 0.0020022145472466946, -0.00123279367107898, 0.013740817084908485, -0.021376948803663254, -0.08929482847452164, 0.030067743733525276, 0.06324262171983719, -0.09089930355548859, -0.05183067172765732, -0.04369752109050751, -0.10512025654315948, 0.026212895289063454, 0.05694584921002388, -0.008167749270796776, -0.0001854513684520498, -0.008678173646330833, -0.041315190494060516, 0.011848684400320053, -0.02888595126569271, 0.07302077859640121, -0.047467734664678574, -0.024486226961016655, -0.019476033747196198, -0.034017615020275116, -0.04058503732085228, 0.012759491801261902, -0.04707659035921097, -0.037562157958745956, -0.05344812199473381, 0.012794233858585358, -0.001527557265944779, 0.07162939012050629, 0.018641171976923943, 0.040174614638090134, 0.010710092261433601, 0.027039503678679466, 0.026250218972563744, -0.050496071577072144, 0.03999270871281624, 0.03302329406142235, 0.06779339164495468, 0.0030820718966424465, 0.03026253916323185, -0.0009543430060148239, 0.0006150914705358446, -0.0013277387479320168, -0.017172766849398613, 0.0036331918090581894, 0.00196491414681077, -0.03580767661333084, 0.04446103796362877, 0.015522112138569355, 0.01696019619703293, -0.04027819260954857, 0.03238959610462189, 0.007892311550676823, 0.011340612545609474, -0.020462069660425186, -0.008703001774847507, 0.10433836281299591, 0.03244322910904884, 0.03671252354979515, 0.01830310933291912, 0.01719115860760212, 0.01414309348911047, 0.04361352324485779, 0.008035392500460148, 0.05920501798391342, -0.0036620006430894136, 0.000298492843285203, 0.035359907895326614, 0.001535726711153984, -0.021154960617423058, 0.001348972786217928, -0.024534033611416817, 0.03214104846119881, -0.04935041442513466, -0.02371017076075077, 0.04286221042275429, -0.0269960705190897, 0.06119583174586296, -0.0012722988612949848, 0.03272470831871033, -0.01527123712003231, 0.013375692069530487, -0.035950206220149994, 0.010637070052325726, 0.08774886280298233, 0.05663120374083519, 0.04209335520863533, 0.0007842997438274324, 0.011526091955602169, -0.02114824391901493, -0.016773905605077744, 0.033194053918123245, 0.0183965265750885, -0.046166736632585526, 0.00713455630466342, -0.0028596161864697933, -0.018345311284065247, -0.007222464308142662, -0.023564105853438377, 0.07419943809509277, 0.054136332124471664, 0.00173181330319494, 0.0158366821706295, -0.0005616892594844103, -0.04901165887713432, -0.008471383713185787, 0.018814556300640106, 0.022438274696469307, 0.01848466508090496, 0.024536922574043274, -0.034684158861637115, 0.048560693860054016, -0.016465552151203156, -0.028780948370695114, -0.0002712370187509805, -0.025647522881627083, -0.055633194744586945, 0.029289325699210167, 0.025963876396417618, -0.00010671179916244, -0.0006032788660377264, -0.03749025985598564, 0.04536958783864975, -0.020366167649626732, -0.010929878801107407, -0.0018163787899538875, -0.07181738317012787, -0.031475458294153214, 0.019263790920376778, 0.010241435840725899, 0.02104235254228115, -0.0658794716000557, 0.03808661550283432, -0.03300439566373825, -0.043194789439439774, -0.00016214702918659896, -0.0030625206418335438, 0.022545641288161278, 0.022007210180163383, -0.010744910687208176, 0.014773163013160229, -0.037764888256788254, 0.017730247229337692, -0.03583627939224243, 0.0036987613420933485, 0.005525213200598955, -0.012529508210718632, -0.010802678763866425, -0.048226457089185715, -0.025005409494042397, 0.026684684678912163, 0.015267820097506046, 0.07688014954328537, -0.010683448985219002, 0.02310941554605961, -0.03399628400802612, 0.04663504287600517, -0.0035069044679403305, 0.06785685569047928, 0.010007434524595737, -0.0003423866874072701, -0.052986323833465576, -0.05305358022451401, -0.0139162577688694, -0.024159278720617294, 0.013821269385516644, -0.008407640270888805, -0.03399667143821716, 0.061436161398887634, 0.005921653006225824, -0.051104120910167694, -0.025972522795200348, 0.01313638873398304, -0.059322290122509, -0.031225640326738358, 0.02112085372209549, 0.00274287979118526, -0.0139092355966568, 0.006654755678027868, -0.019574899226427078, 0.024548383429646492, 0.006906730588525534, 0.008224328979849815, -0.011557461693882942, -0.014604324474930763, -0.010540944524109364, 0.023807376623153687, -0.041699860244989395, 0.04225601255893707, -0.016173046082258224, 0.04494652897119522, -0.056192412972450256, 0.04490058869123459, 0.004599668085575104, 0.040840767323970795, -0.01933496631681919, -0.004260109271854162, -0.00860530510544777, -0.06677854806184769, -0.07572657614946365, 0.01242113672196865, 0.05904589965939522, -0.0736992210149765, 0.001988598145544529, -0.015538341365754604, -0.01927337236702442, -0.022414088249206543, 0.03650614619255066, -0.05573837831616402, 0.004184698686003685, 0.05799588933587074, 0.0649435818195343, 0.04066286236047745, -0.07034569978713989, 0.06539318710565567, -0.02841319516301155, 0.010563121177256107, -0.008443960919976234, -0.026373036205768585, -0.0015318536898121238, -0.029148658737540245, 0.010999398306012154, -0.0022417616564780474, -0.03761261701583862, -0.009839435108006, -0.0159162487834692, -0.08217914402484894, 0.0006273947074078023, -0.0026006021071225405, 0.005136512219905853, 0.0046080308966338634, 0.01345540676265955, 0.009008227847516537, 0.024564456194639206, 0.0018548885127529502, 0.02159900963306427, -0.028371062129735947, -0.019244952127337456, -0.06425818800926208, -0.06680302321910858, -0.03936813399195671, 0.03452315926551819, 0.031847815960645676, 0.023501548916101456, -0.013060061261057854, -0.030341867357492447, -0.019303644075989723, -0.042705047875642776, 0.03299464285373688, 0.02859394997358322, -0.022002536803483963, -0.01003509946167469, -0.012408934533596039, 0.010946027003228664, 0.021335730329155922, 0.026312749832868576, -0.009762178175151348, -0.04295099526643753, 0.02813492901623249, -0.02911338582634926, -0.014297076500952244, 0.021817700937390327, -0.022294485941529274, -0.012663153000175953, 0.030662402510643005, -0.04002728313207626, -0.028720993548631668, 0.03282768279314041, -0.04117058962583542, -0.0061537292785942554, 0.01661575399339199, 0.018149778246879578, 0.011210472323000431, -0.037557005882263184, -0.008893117308616638, 0.0067934016697108746, 0.017778180539608, 0.0032726225908845663, -0.019395509734749794, -0.04716705530881882, -0.012989967130124569, 0.006307207979261875, 0.02019982412457466, -0.051196955144405365, 0.04490901529788971, 0.005285173188894987, 0.005112751852720976, 0.007549125701189041, 0.031444255262613297, -0.013139103539288044, 0.05948137864470482, 0.009032352827489376, -0.01605243794620037, -0.027420027181506157, -0.00020375488384161144, 0.012138099409639835, -0.01472941879183054, 0.03322944790124893, 0.028975393623113632, -0.020608587190508842, -0.08527296781539917, 0.03127378970384598, 0.04592014104127884, 0.0520094558596611, 0.0351782888174057, 0.0366324856877327, -0.0029988186433911324, -0.033296648412942886, -0.038834892213344574, -0.004902865272015333, -0.0007579101948067546, 0.04124060273170471, -0.04175935313105583, -0.030330833047628403, 0.0064003015868365765, 0.03469643369317055, -0.00916973315179348, -0.0410941056907177, 0.00427520927041769, 0.03834253177046776, -0.032196927815675735, 0.0033769081346690655, -0.019971758127212524, 0.014258080162107944, 0.02461344376206398, -0.007752627599984407, -0.01606297306716442, -0.05125262588262558, -0.029890870675444603, 0.024499943479895592, 0.07112176716327667, -0.011604764498770237, -0.02835068851709366, 0.048759762197732925, -0.024383436888456345, 0.04576973617076874, 0.0035461520310491323, -0.023587273433804512, -0.004905057605355978, -0.020202867686748505, -0.011953840032219887, 0.08720747381448746, 0.030768778175115585, -0.05855102837085724, 0.005091964732855558, 0.01713285595178604, -0.02576121687889099, 0.005201417952775955, -0.021086035296320915, -0.0029214960522949696, -0.004714014008641243, 0.021958867087960243, -0.051177386194467545, -0.016012705862522125, -0.002356377663090825, -0.039255641400814056, 0.04127394035458565, -0.006786779034882784, -0.0218365378677845, -0.05599821358919144, -0.047733135521411896, 0.03980278596282005, 0.008252451196312904, 0.005860002711415291, 0.013998989015817642, -0.011759461835026741, 0.04493378475308418, -0.02545398473739624, -0.024075306951999664, 0.0157282967120409, 0.06157331168651581, -0.0065155960619449615, -0.007123262155801058, -0.00677845161408186, 0.007839790545403957, -0.012566073797643185, 0.044722579419612885, -0.009408380836248398, -0.06138932704925537, -0.011725693009793758, -0.016654158011078835, 0.06385663896799088, 0.027089469134807587, 0.010884854942560196, -0.008278122171759605, -0.0010804234771057963, 0.01561224926263094, -0.020352259278297424, 0.014208619482815266, -0.013835239224135876, -0.03172994405031204, -0.025000128895044327, 0.002675904193893075, -0.031126799061894417, -0.03602387756109238, 0.03048655204474926, 0.0019403266487643123, -0.02291792444884777, -0.0022696233354508877, 0.04408998414874077, 0.006763204000890255, 0.020524030551314354, -0.007239028345793486, -0.027682743966579437, -0.0013979163486510515, -0.02114495262503624, -0.0034733647480607033, 0.008481821045279503, -0.10710017383098602, -0.00046754186041653156, -0.0023854358587414026, 0.001869396772235632, -0.02009088732302189, -0.022233663126826286, 0.02099766954779625, 0.06829451024532318, -0.04057838022708893, 0.012273024767637253, 0.004390415735542774, -0.019965946674346924, 0.00984285306185484, -0.00769761111587286, -0.04453049600124359, -0.013584153726696968, 0.03766721859574318, 0.057487696409225464, 0.10679958760738373, 0.030309848487377167, 0.028610559180378914, -0.05806373432278633, -0.02577945776283741, -0.10977156460285187, 0.020951220765709877, -0.016447488218545914, -0.04117149859666824, -0.03528040274977684, 0.033827632665634155, 0.035358525812625885, 0.04854247719049454, -0.021525880321860313, 0.03232434019446373, 0.030440857633948326, 0.004208357539027929, -0.04831141605973244, 0.005212502088397741, 0.012299633584916592, -0.0035765888169407845, -0.021106770262122154, 0.024341635406017303, -0.007518946658819914, 0.062045298516750336, 0.0908675417304039, 0.10598745197057724, 0.06405338644981384, 0.0012798578245565295, -0.018137171864509583, 0.029094671830534935, -0.008210867643356323, -0.04702499508857727, 0.008510888554155827, 0.0071585699915885925, -0.01717136986553669, 0.020538857206702232, 0.07240836322307587, 0.013525908812880516, -0.059654224663972855, 0.06816209852695465, -0.019183021038770676, -0.0012576942099258304, 0.01155148260295391, -0.005808651447296143, -0.00452601071447134, -0.016332756727933884, -0.05892033129930496, -0.05421961098909378, -0.05908257141709328, 0.03323652595281601, -0.001962514827027917, 0.045513734221458435, 0.016337372362613678, -0.07064925879240036, -0.007618849165737629, -0.0452648364007473, -0.0462171845138073, -0.08098403364419937, 0.0011311486596241593, 0.024319956079125404, 0.013791610486805439, 0.09818106889724731, -0.055532779544591904, 0.014211452566087246, -0.029137587174773216, -0.007358770817518234, -0.056322354823350906, 0.012651014141738415, 0.03864172846078873, -0.051278986036777496, -0.00839474331587553, 0.04309859871864319, -0.013088018633425236, -0.0440070703625679, 0.053610142320394516, -0.03520569950342178, -0.07325366884469986, -0.041332270950078964, -0.01676126755774021, -0.022021600976586342, -0.022454041987657547, -0.017366444692015648, 0.03446296229958534, 0.03470347821712494, 0.023570086807012558, 0.014796080067753792, 0.10563801229000092, 0.019925517961382866, -0.05181271582841873, -0.0056696003302931786, 0.026394912973046303, 0.022405825555324554, 0.00613319780677557, -0.0033394324127584696, -0.020538296550512314, 0.004098834935575724, -0.00127062585670501, -0.00023756416339892894, 0.0678127259016037, -0.07105214148759842, -0.006399460136890411, -0.015465669333934784, 0.04440169781446457, -0.06507132202386856, -0.09522606432437897, -0.03924458101391792, 0.012191573157906532, 0.008211103267967701, 0.016744162887334824, -0.07852569222450256, -0.042673394083976746, -0.0007753489189781249, 0.036213986575603485, 0.0046804179437458515, 0.03287454694509506, -0.045446135103702545, 0.024111222475767136, -0.01827152632176876, 0.004858747590333223, -0.04507104679942131, -0.06468109786510468, 0.007348276674747467, 0.04632365331053734, 0.02825647033751011, -0.08980508893728256, 0.04052736237645149, -0.05737743154168129, -0.015733884647488594, 0.08987187594175339, 0.017833949998021126, 0.056949347257614136, -0.03230177238583565, 0.07493874430656433, 0.024855660274624825, 0.01221601851284504, -0.0057520936243236065, -0.042344752699136734, 0.03165418282151222, -0.01663755066692829, 0.02086607553064823, 0.06022554636001587, -0.021565398201346397, -0.02209262177348137, -0.04433121904730797, -0.00854554958641529, -0.058151327073574066, -0.034239429980516434, -0.06213623657822609, -0.052845489233732224, 0.044894758611917496, 0.0017395344329997897, -0.052434101700782776, -0.04128294438123703, -0.031762927770614624 ]
<p>I'm trying to estimate how many people visited the farmers market once, twice, thrice, etc. in a given time period, using sampled data. We have interview data from approximately 50% of visitors as they entered the market which lets us identify them uniquely. For the purposes of this analysis, I'm assuming that the interviews randomly captured ~50% of visits; in reality the interviews were not random, but I want to start with a simpler problem first.</p> <p>Within this dataset, I can identify how many people visited once, twice, thrice, etc. But, intuitively, I think the nature of sampling will lead me to underestimate the number of people who visited more than once. I've tested this intuition by randomly cutting the dataset in half a few times - starting from the full dataset (50% of visits), going down to 6.25%, and find that the larger datasets have more multiple-visit people in it (see below).</p> <p>However, I am unsure what happens as I go from 50% of the visits to 100% of the visits. Can you help me come up with a statistical framework to do that projection?</p> <p>PS - I feel that the Birthday Problem is informative here, but I can't think of how to apply it!</p> <pre><code> % of visits from people who visited at most. % of visits sampled once twice thrice 6.25% 83% 96% 99% 12.50% 82% 96% 99% 25% 77% 94% 98% 50% 67% 88% 95% 100% ? ? ? </code></pre> <p>I'm trying to think about how to apply the mark-recapture framework Gael mentioned. I agree that there is a similarity if I simplify it to the percentage of all visits from individuals who visited only once -- in essence, the population size in terms of this framework. What I'm struggling with is how to think about my sampling technique. I know how many total visits there (say, 25,000). I know that out of the 12,500 visits we "marked" in a continuous 50% sampling of visits, there were about 10,000 unique individuals, with 7,000 being marked once, and the remainder being "marked" 2, 3, or more times. I can't fit this into the simple two-stage mark-recapture model, and I'm thinking I need to do some kind of a Poisson regression (based on the wikipedia entry).</p>
g48928
[ -0.020005857571959496, 0.03218258172273636, -0.03201435133814812, -0.038352712988853455, -0.01686495915055275, -0.053768910467624664, -0.015413391403853893, 0.017544494941830635, 0.00353081151843071, 0.019582943990826607, -0.009934742003679276, 0.02541108801960945, 0.008663138374686241, -0.01875588856637478, -0.03043495863676071, -0.0008105193264782429, -0.00008415692718699574, -0.03074895776808262, 0.03688444197177887, 0.05865246057510376, -0.004881697706878185, 0.02094283513724804, 0.043343909084796906, -0.047647472470998764, -0.0661357045173645, -0.030118312686681747, 0.0358976311981678, 0.06558927893638611, -0.05525347217917442, -0.0054168193601071835, -0.028972992673516273, -0.0011721915798261762, -0.019150391221046448, -0.01957148127257824, -0.009057448245584965, -0.006763142067939043, 0.03167363628745079, 0.026709217578172684, -0.0408046618103981, -0.015347902663052082, 0.011307669803500175, -0.03092329390347004, 0.0717778131365776, 0.055586155503988266, -0.008559911511838436, 0.0313008688390255, -0.005972329527139664, -0.034096091985702515, 0.01886422373354435, -0.018547389656305313, -0.021782778203487396, 0.0139307314530015, 0.010411628521978855, 0.06406916677951813, -0.017425192520022392, 0.019305218011140823, 0.0456983745098114, -0.029165176674723625, 0.04481484740972519, 0.014148206450045109, 0.02967298962175846, -0.02982642687857151, -0.013928650878369808, 0.07860282063484192, -0.03740298002958298, 0.03676407039165497, -0.0391426607966423, 0.008785209618508816, 0.04020726680755615, -0.05221495404839516, -0.037731803953647614, 0.01048092357814312, 0.0043280720710754395, -0.05800873786211014, -0.030293259769678116, 0.00013481445785146207, -0.024664010852575302, 0.011164696887135506, 0.010053561069071293, 0.05552813783288002, 0.03066195547580719, 0.02368682250380516, -0.03943802788853645, 0.007109534461051226, 0.022368285804986954, 0.008568421006202698, -0.005581503268331289, -0.04471375420689583, 0.001256289309822023, -0.020898185670375824, 0.015348452143371105, -0.0025025485083460808, 0.04353775829076767, 0.035981062799692154, 0.0033518648706376553, 0.02992665208876133, -0.058838844299316406, -0.028476843610405922, -0.03389006480574608, 0.009531227871775627, -0.008415603078901768, -0.022506147623062134, -0.08093038946390152, -0.06077725067734718, -0.05681125819683075, -0.012261138297617435, 0.035023536533117294, 0.047320663928985596, -0.005984341260045767, -0.012771425768733025, 0.003444122849032283, -0.04075988382101059, -0.061426613479852676, -0.003099162597209215, -0.059757400304079056, -0.0034799976274371147, 0.06259623169898987, 0.009245275519788265, -0.044039398431777954, 0.030762741342186928, -0.04313534498214722, -0.04904093220829964, 0.05385845527052879, 0.0394267775118351, -0.012088501825928688, -0.01313825137913227, -0.0466475747525692, 0.040763724595308304, 0.005052509251981974, 0.008099062368273735, -0.009819041937589645, 0.013367936946451664, 0.041343219578266144, 0.026249339804053307, 0.00888890027999878, -0.019272413104772568, -0.02161143720149994, 0.08964399993419647, 0.027500521391630173, 0.05526047572493553, -0.04615994915366173, -0.004973985720425844, 0.033834606409072876, -0.013464278541505337, -0.012148873880505562, 0.023921970278024673, -0.005564942490309477, -0.008497912436723709, -0.02258162386715412, 0.011445864103734493, -0.007992216385900974, 0.052686020731925964, -0.018465373665094376, 0.004904783330857754, 0.016988571733236313, -0.028876744210720062, 0.037614576518535614, -0.033400990068912506, -0.09316382557153702, 0.07239317893981934, 0.06451784074306488, -0.0041715423576533794, 0.10713924467563629, -0.02393139712512493, 0.03732534497976303, 0.021876387298107147, 0.014616324566304684, -0.08872475475072861, -0.042869433760643005, -0.04903256148099899, 0.04669101536273956, -0.039652787148952484, -0.006681795697659254, -0.04461312294006348, -0.0007516553159803152, -0.0010165785206481814, 0.04156215116381645, -0.055996380746364594, 0.03633802756667137, -0.005249218549579382, 0.06917070597410202, -0.015979979187250137, 0.0194824431091547, -0.0018536197021603584, 0.032197050750255585, -0.05964482203125954, 0.023392073810100555, 0.08582340180873871, 0.046792224049568176, -0.016693519428372383, 0.005624856799840927, -0.07590419054031372, -0.01014637853950262, 0.0007092278683558106, -0.03884817659854889, -0.01998550444841385, 0.04774092882871628, -0.06021648272871971, -0.010751192457973957, -0.018713686615228653, -0.05611983686685562, -0.015458542853593826, -0.059537116438150406, 0.016721541061997414, -0.029901983216404915, 0.029026230797171593, -0.022994305938482285, 0.014738407917320728, -0.08289434015750885, 0.009329762309789658, -0.006300017237663269, -0.08542247116565704, -0.047857966274023056, 0.06113624572753906, -0.027676086872816086, 0.001284102094359696, 0.024894915521144867, -0.0037685660645365715, 0.030377978459000587, 0.006314894650131464, -0.0027531799860298634, 0.021921537816524506, 0.02568533830344677, 0.038438983261585236, 0.053587496280670166, 0.05186942592263222, 0.0450175441801548, 0.03949551284313202, -0.00857795774936676, 0.04768471047282219, -0.019057786092162132, -0.017564984038472176, -0.03186170756816864, -0.03520561382174492, 0.038320090621709824, 0.0010914657032117248, 0.01228290144354105, -0.00874029565602541, -0.04343625158071518, -0.0321168415248394, -0.018943417817354202, -0.017097942531108856, 0.0067086475901305676, 0.04872000962495804, 0.03814759477972984, -0.008002595975995064, -0.009882665239274502, 0.018449245020747185, 0.08211160451173782, 0.03233959525823593, -0.02824150212109089, 0.032122135162353516, -0.00012350379256531596, -0.04621845483779907, 0.06299197673797607, -0.03943352773785591, 0.028552521020174026, 0.04378141835331917, 0.002078918507322669, -0.00007355979323619977, 0.004349893424659967, 0.004700981080532074, 0.03954542428255081, 0.009535775519907475, 0.03139417991042137, -0.05079335719347, -0.01033893320709467, 0.01170816458761692, -0.019959505647420883, -0.029182199388742447, -0.021964697167277336, 0.00016995515034068376, 0.03977011516690254, 0.04522532969713211, 0.0009112165425904095, -0.01085241325199604, -0.03471689671278, 0.0017151805805042386, 0.018717437982559204, 0.04489387199282646, -0.017868880182504654, -0.024799495935440063, 0.01614653319120407, 0.01382316555827856, 0.06746325641870499, 0.016665594652295113, 0.0381530299782753, 0.00834359135478735, -0.010048034600913525, 0.014944816008210182, -0.05140787735581398, 0.009305588901042938, 0.025734560564160347, -0.04212420433759689, -0.005800324492156506, 0.010771351866424084, -0.021944144740700722, -0.06001027673482895, 0.06968289613723755, -0.01810508221387863, -0.014231275767087936, 0.013868381269276142, 0.025714918971061707, 0.010571533814072609, -0.013219613581895828, -0.015122468583285809, 0.05088825151324272, 0.005001879297196865, -0.03647364303469658, 0.0048593683168292046, -0.013709036633372307, 0.002690706867724657, -0.011714691296219826, 0.005323812831193209, -0.06402280926704407, -0.04610557481646538, 0.024894265457987785, -0.015743056312203407, -0.006267881486564875, -0.00027921219589188695, 0.07591677457094193, 0.0013353690737858415, 0.009494470432400703, 0.03565872460603714, 0.015685971826314926, 0.03756043687462807, -0.10428473353385925, 0.031931739300489426, -0.016887230798602104, -0.004691094625741243, 0.028863027691841125, 0.05364741384983063, 0.01280317921191454, -0.08261813223361969, 0.014903982169926167, -0.0020874221809208393, -0.03069062903523445, -0.0018589384853839874, 0.07276491075754166, 0.03357561677694321, -0.02145269513130188, 0.0034005690831691027, 0.006093734409660101, -0.03131547197699547, 0.023871155455708504, 0.0034788018092513084, 0.04184466972947121, -0.033768437802791595, 0.03828782960772514, 0.00374642014503479, 0.05857621878385544, -0.05345519259572029, -0.04061328247189522, -0.01089912373572588, 0.05532924830913544, 0.017019040882587433, 0.04951174557209015, -0.017146339640021324, 0.0030824383720755577, -0.04833913967013359, 0.049753010272979736, -0.03488218039274216, -0.04489705339074135, -0.030386103317141533, 0.03669887036085129, -0.03272203728556633, 0.052524082362651825, 0.04256594926118851, 0.04391323775053024, -0.008831878192722797, -0.03742450475692749, -0.02618541195988655, 0.04228722304105759, -0.03922552987933159, -0.022522183135151863, -0.03833929821848869, 0.007828679867088795, 0.023984424769878387, 0.07098128646612167, 0.09006650745868683, 0.015395987778902054, 0.003056831657886505, -0.08407638967037201, 0.0019657837692648172, 0.01636229082942009, -0.0512421540915966, -0.00475958501920104, -0.044833362102508545, 0.011099745519459248, 0.004725434351712465, -0.04465470835566521, 0.0010924089001491666, -0.023592714220285416, 0.018420539796352386, 0.02761860564351082, -0.06368382275104523, -0.016773995012044907, 0.002777387388050556, 0.03104487620294094, 0.038056764751672745, 0.002232386963441968, -0.048853807151317596, 0.010001292452216148, 0.006859923712909222, -0.030444355681538582, 0.03950008377432823, 0.009964792989194393, -0.01721770316362381, 0.005694072227925062, 0.03906536474823952, -0.07522863894701004, 0.022815415635704994, 0.02713298611342907, -0.06066364049911499, 0.02387235127389431, -0.018569350242614746, 0.07519058883190155, -0.025636926293373108, -0.01119072176516056, 0.0022786951158195734, -0.019439704716205597, 0.031454723328351974, -0.044735297560691833, 0.03860831260681152, -0.0061542317271232605, 0.04254535213112831, 0.00738966278731823, 0.01336704008281231, 0.03970680758357048, -0.02991528995335102, 0.05421184003353119, 0.059045035392045975, -0.0005761031061410904, 0.04538968950510025, -0.018831197172403336, -0.011779576539993286, 0.03192070126533508, -0.02267645299434662, 0.012502755969762802, -0.011300977319478989, -0.0773414671421051, -0.0340179018676281, -0.08686894923448563, 0.01651896722614765, 0.019994253292679787, -0.004460758995264769, 0.00020409582066349685, 0.01095918845385313, 0.03920919448137283, 0.008841481059789658, -0.008538744412362576, -0.0036577272694557905, -0.05681534856557846, 0.019084574654698372, 0.02692648582160473, 0.01718052476644516, 0.008449799381196499, 0.017270566895604134, -0.012045258656144142, 0.020568469539284706, 0.00021175621077418327, -0.007470767945051193, -0.03857003524899483, -0.0648760050535202, -0.055909134447574615, -0.0407758504152298, -0.00874127633869648, 0.014504355378448963, 0.028675056993961334, -0.004509826190769672, -0.040900323539972305, 0.023274673148989677, 0.003007942344993353, -0.02036815509200096, -0.04020093381404877, 0.04598615691065788, 0.001354873995296657, 0.027594516053795815, 0.0544738844037056, 0.009530989453196526, 0.016469808295369148, -0.0018084985204041004, 0.028946956619620323, -0.01134464517235756, -0.016225602477788925, -0.06622102111577988, 0.04783553257584572, -0.11531301587820053, -0.003047988982871175, 0.01962434872984886, -0.028607364743947983, 0.0019838677253574133, 0.02561439387500286, 0.042639318853616714, 0.003128166776150465, 0.003205103101208806, 0.024544762447476387, 0.006451178342103958, 0.01959352195262909, -0.009506587870419025, -0.04160165786743164, 0.028017796576023102, -0.03271600604057312, -0.02874794416129589, 0.007180898450314999, 0.0028507662937045097, 0.019637972116470337, -0.02967691980302334, -0.011567375622689724, 0.03821546956896782, 0.0036244161892682314, 0.050997983664274216, -0.011120383627712727, -0.05624498054385185, -0.009374060668051243, -0.034632276743650436, -0.019865989685058594, -0.00541860843077302, -0.01961156353354454, 0.013369833119213581, 0.09096590429544449, 0.044990286231040955, 0.017175331711769104, 0.0238848477602005, -0.0070784008130431175, -0.007021962199360132, -0.022490479052066803, -0.0241998303681612, -0.001724265981465578, -0.054159197956323624, 0.0240747332572937, -0.00879374984651804, -0.03921204432845116, -0.06936774402856827, 0.014083686284720898, 0.030100297182798386, -0.02747518941760063, 0.022527771070599556, 0.01697108894586563, -0.02936728298664093, -0.047971803694963455, 0.05601176992058754, 0.07253487408161163, -0.03424916788935661, -0.014434135518968105, -0.05606997758150101, 0.00791159924119711, -0.040325116366147995, 0.08843526244163513, 0.015574382618069649, 0.027167636901140213, 0.022201094776391983, 0.013891072943806648, -0.006207377649843693, -0.019367024302482605, 0.011172489263117313, 0.010246731340885162, 0.006574447266757488, 0.027971653267741203, -0.021321456879377365, -0.01880844682455063, -0.02459738403558731, 0.016223283484578133, 0.029232224449515343, 0.03325461968779564, 0.02725057117640972, -0.007144284900277853, -0.022428354248404503, -0.02581549808382988, 0.008100675418972969, 0.02879827469587326, -0.10911571979522705, 0.01348041370511055, -0.036094143986701965, -0.004767138976603746, 0.028613312169909477, -0.06400032341480255, -0.006030641030520201, -0.017471715807914734, -0.020627692341804504, -0.055566322058439255, -0.03520584851503372, 0.04198690131306648, -0.041694339364767075, -0.020753486081957817, 0.0721118152141571, -0.01675255596637726, 0.008014955557882786, -0.012389612384140491, -0.004918216727674007, 0.018827112391591072, 0.019978491589426994, 0.020850595086812973, -0.06981943547725677, -0.0035386981908231974, -0.014061043038964272, 0.014289680868387222, -0.043649476021528244, -0.036359913647174835, -0.051717985421419144, 0.008871247991919518, -0.00895831361413002, 0.04899762198328972, -0.07783818989992142, 0.008027061820030212, -0.0002998566487804055, -0.01167029794305563, -0.06446034461259842, 0.02683131955564022, -0.006799623835831881, -0.03309854492545128, 0.016569139435887337, 0.0023990997578948736, 0.06272820383310318, -0.015697086229920387, 0.0025951883289963007, -0.03042020834982395, 0.04512982815504074, -0.009305106475949287, 0.017901821061968803, 0.025579288601875305, 0.00251935631968081, 0.003160192398354411, 0.007817121222615242, -0.003928137477487326, 0.0580187663435936, 0.0003990487311966717, -0.013782505877315998, 0.05011891946196556, -0.026644177734851837, -0.027343550696969032, 0.0013877530582249165, 0.0027206100057810545, 0.05983902886509895, -0.0465054027736187, -0.004228123929351568, -0.04485404118895531, 0.08772823214530945, -0.01036254595965147, -0.05165454372763634, -0.03331810608506203, -0.01732807047665119, -0.04000292345881462, -0.003836250863969326, 0.010060732252895832, -0.09043031930923462, 0.005668070167303085, 0.06382504850625992, 0.0132805947214365, 0.0361398383975029, 0.020649738609790802, 0.03028576634824276, -0.007105941418558359, 0.011238906532526016, 0.03180452063679695, 0.06966236233711243, -0.0005898798699490726, 0.05169955641031265, 0.04485834762454033, -0.01070195809006691, -0.06785333156585693, -0.01783784106373787, -0.07765372842550278, -0.02363961935043335, -0.03526177629828453, 0.013476705178618431, 0.024892223998904228, 0.022574428468942642, 0.03169761970639229, -0.03368525207042694, -0.052977778017520905, -0.023805078119039536, -0.011226039379835129, 0.038346994668245316, -0.008990418165922165, 0.0211542509496212, 0.04830188676714897, 0.08167660236358643, -0.026228053495287895, -0.011723165400326252, 0.03439848870038986, 0.026672806590795517, 0.022601304575800896, -0.0745801106095314, -0.008729122579097748, 0.014400055631995201, -0.05693509057164192, 0.038277167826890945, 0.009331978857517242, -0.014515460468828678, -0.02145160548388958, -0.030135514214634895, 0.031351663172245026, 0.018328020349144936, -0.0330415703356266, 0.031014252454042435, 0.017258279025554657, -0.034122418612241745, -0.037372685968875885, 0.09782296419143677, 0.011072027496993542, 0.06227190047502518, 0.07022597640752792, -0.01942949928343296, 0.04646202176809311, -0.04338981956243515, -0.015293324366211891, -0.07822361588478088, -0.00707824993878603, -0.036230847239494324, -0.0283966101706028, 0.028304487466812134, -0.04469529539346695, 0.0564693883061409, 0.014285968616604805, -0.03871573880314827, -0.06057591736316681, -0.031288985162973404, 0.03135323151946068, -0.06941592693328857, 0.007998130284249783, 0.05119924619793892, 0.009677027352154255, -0.015574846416711807, 0.009318577125668526, -0.022044774144887924, -0.07437031716108322, 0.03149964287877083, 0.015780799090862274, 0.034530557692050934, -0.05102810636162758, -0.03501833602786064, -0.09040114283561707, 0.02097303606569767, 0.07363789528608322, 0.020057043060660362, 0.06903453916311264, -0.007436190266162157, 0.002244394039735198, -0.007562203798443079, -0.05149585381150246, 0.018943672999739647, 0.03822222724556923, 0.034518852829933167, 0.013240865431725979, -0.008920280262827873, 0.01703794300556183, -0.001598361530341208, -0.03073592483997345, -0.009266701526939869, -0.029355987906455994, -0.038876134902238846, -0.01285618543624878, 0.032928191125392914, 0.006663669366389513, -0.005051255691796541, 0.06191582232713699, 0.017304973676800728, -0.007451987825334072, -0.0075302342884242535, -0.0007478534244000912, -0.01400720700621605, -0.0576968751847744, 0.07262448221445084, -0.00529340049251914, -0.005758970510214567, 0.016486218199133873, 0.04557338356971741 ]
<p>It is standard advice to set a random seed so that results can be reproduced. However, since the seed is advanced as pseudo-random numbers are drawn, the results could change if <em>any</em> piece of code draws an additional number.</p> <p>At first glance, version control looks to be a solution to this, as it would at least allow you to go back and reproduce the version extant when you wrote down the results in your notes or paper. However, since it only takes one draw to mess things up, if you update R the results could change as well.</p> <p>I realize that this is probably only problematic in rare cases, but I'm curious if there are any best practices here. This is something I've been struggling with in my own work.</p>
g48930
[ 0.006530520040541887, -0.026480115950107574, 0.016120733693242073, -0.06822682917118073, -0.007591685280203819, -0.029194768518209457, -0.04641886427998543, 0.025162482634186745, -0.009398262947797775, -0.01827477104961872, 0.07233543694019318, -0.03596002608537674, 0.07275650650262833, 0.04746535047888756, -0.03962092474102974, 0.011754073202610016, 0.0768309161067009, -0.054068662226200104, -0.015055009163916111, 0.008129696361720562, -0.0060937716625630856, 0.011715508066117764, 0.03675888106226921, -0.003804548177868128, -0.02170007862150669, -0.039062220603227615, -0.04153723269701004, 0.006653628312051296, -0.10387597978115082, -0.04150693491101265, 0.010111259296536446, 0.04287032037973404, 0.010670860297977924, -0.00472859013825655, -0.0034349532797932625, 0.023126965388655663, -0.03754724934697151, 0.014490200206637383, -0.013739628717303276, 0.003711426630616188, -0.05521519109606743, -0.018437551334500313, 0.04781502112746239, 0.001590391038917005, -0.04838187247514725, 0.025211738422513008, -0.01682005077600479, 0.009975864551961422, 0.06393427401781082, 0.020917566493153572, 0.007862255908548832, 0.0044217356480658054, 0.00015256433107424527, 0.009100447408854961, 0.018987560644745827, 0.03838764876127243, -0.08323254436254501, -0.021069416776299477, 0.04333805665373802, -0.012271353043615818, 0.052128519862890244, 0.01197365578263998, -0.03785917907953262, -0.011166691780090332, -0.015441049821674824, 0.04725991562008858, 0.01316374447196722, -0.01331874169409275, -0.0275972131639719, 0.019974874332547188, -0.003044534707441926, 0.01691351644694805, -0.022038187831640244, -0.018607979640364647, -0.03778420016169548, -0.013713489286601543, -0.016228174790740013, -0.001541707431897521, -0.011687058955430984, 0.07181861251592636, -0.04361070692539215, -0.02988317981362343, 0.02909196726977825, -0.0013951226137578487, 0.05696801096200943, 0.014641293324530125, 0.02373228780925274, -0.06575081497430801, 0.009715731255710125, 0.0053632259368896484, -0.00462178373709321, -0.01375356875360012, -0.006049852818250656, -0.030277471989393234, 0.034445539116859436, -0.0004588328883983195, -0.03664243221282959, 0.022931940853595734, -0.04605957865715027, 0.03362888842821121, 0.030968904495239258, -0.017025979235768318, 0.00944689754396677, -0.06070934981107712, -0.07519198954105377, -0.002997524803504348, 0.10384958982467651, 0.011395194567739964, -0.011513406410813332, -0.015397470444440842, -0.040197521448135376, -0.030643004924058914, -0.03945062682032585, -0.013977056369185448, 0.0206267312169075, -0.016039183363318443, 0.032481107860803604, 0.04659903049468994, -0.053238630294799805, 0.003978039138019085, -0.02180268056690693, -0.001887615886516869, 0.04673022776842117, 0.026930930092930794, 0.007440626621246338, -0.018790610134601593, 0.03917592391371727, -0.040353745222091675, 0.04441465437412262, -0.007671087980270386, -0.07748128473758698, -0.01884729415178299, -0.037506841123104095, 0.058391306549310684, -0.03924597054719925, 0.01573902554810047, 0.022527167573571205, 0.06896227598190308, 0.039896972477436066, -0.045669544488191605, -0.011470399796962738, -0.03239670768380165, -0.03213433548808098, 0.02082778327167034, -0.012023882940411568, 0.01304634939879179, 0.015775714069604874, 0.05496430769562721, -0.011760271154344082, 0.030721202492713928, -0.0023611055221408606, -0.07157210260629654, -0.061195578426122665, -0.0018939891597256064, 0.007132942322641611, 0.027844734489917755, 0.008332527242600918, 0.004000243730843067, -0.019335897639393806, 0.05011167749762535, 0.06224095821380615, 0.007501028478145599, -0.01791277341544628, -0.01430016104131937, 0.026323417201638222, 0.02757686749100685, 0.001655826810747385, 0.004030595067888498, -0.0545639805495739, -0.06251642107963562, 0.023443544283509254, -0.004824891220778227, 0.040381673723459244, -0.04737725481390953, 0.005354779772460461, -0.006578728556632996, 0.030477089807391167, 0.02724047563970089, 0.035588961094617844, -0.006292852107435465, -0.01760619319975376, -0.04712408408522606, 0.0032706994097679853, -0.007778188679367304, 0.04460623487830162, -0.05985523387789726, -0.04554300755262375, -0.013476081192493439, -0.027155132964253426, -0.045139215886592865, 0.008673791773617268, -0.0727664977312088, -0.03423961251974106, 0.023252306506037712, -0.023362725973129272, -0.023256706073880196, -0.025843797251582146, -0.007828354835510254, -0.03605198860168457, 0.08564508706331253, 0.011604881845414639, 0.045705292373895645, -0.01002691499888897, -0.012908201664686203, 0.018969865515828133, -0.015343643724918365, -0.008477950468659401, -0.0359441339969635, 0.024421371519565582, -0.019474035128951073, 0.05707197263836861, 0.011188407428562641, 0.04081542044878006, 0.05594075098633766, 0.01845797523856163, 0.021876033395528793, -0.003314547473564744, -0.014221806079149246, -0.007171162869781256, -0.01001984067261219, -0.003374366322532296, 0.01404398214071989, -0.024997040629386902, 0.026198184117674828, -0.008130757138133049, 0.055651240050792694, -0.03297629952430725, -0.005794228985905647, -0.021146373823285103, -0.012027029879391193, 0.03520669415593147, -0.03319263085722923, -0.06097069010138512, -0.04413650929927826, 0.045044802129268646, -0.013851162977516651, -0.06186329200863838, 0.028291432186961174, 0.051944274455308914, 0.04147845879197121, 0.04638715088367462, -0.026641933247447014, 0.019620666280388832, 0.03299446403980255, 0.017108077183365822, 0.014066213741898537, 0.03818322718143463, 0.013362185098230839, -0.001853823778219521, 0.07083191722631454, -0.01154282595962286, -0.0057585821487009525, 0.0062482161447405815, 0.014750526286661625, -0.07004985213279724, -0.04363451898097992, -0.025190476328134537, 0.01738687790930271, 0.03173036500811577, 0.02872389741241932, -0.017116079106926918, 0.03755337372422218, 0.00505300797522068, 0.023902272805571556, 0.010081653483211994, 0.0630960687994957, -0.017663761973381042, -0.031178489327430725, -0.02182161435484886, 0.029623279348015785, -0.02451818622648716, -0.03520659729838371, 0.013085487298667431, 0.09121893346309662, -0.011165007017552853, 0.034452810883522034, 0.0010008730459958315, 0.005809491500258446, 0.015176147222518921, 0.025736872106790543, -0.004073805641382933, -0.08487486839294434, -0.016568126156926155, 0.024601290002465248, -0.006901513785123825, -0.05038049444556236, -0.027027186006307602, -0.0654471218585968, -0.034934062510728836, 0.006487217266112566, -0.01289940532296896, 0.045439451932907104, 0.02052435651421547, -0.020808812230825424, 0.03191273286938667, 0.03423064947128296, -0.09491036832332611, 0.025765422731637955, -0.011475887149572372, 0.028007131069898605, -0.000253391481237486, 0.020746860653162003, -0.018833808600902557, 0.05264405161142349, -0.002606914844363928, 0.00120477844029665, -0.022786607965826988, 0.0834256112575531, 0.06411271542310715, -0.007825003936886787, 0.02979733981192112, -0.029223497956991196, -0.05369040369987488, 0.012347334995865822, -0.0006900405278429389, 0.04342279210686684, -0.05362885445356369, -0.009760420769453049, 0.027529871091246605, -0.025767022743821144, -0.0052504707127809525, 0.011770696379244328, 0.05907469615340233, -0.0008501443662680686, 0.0003246902779210359, 0.022010674700140953, -0.004416586831212044, 0.04837543144822121, -0.02911360003054142, 0.02485371194779873, 0.04967790096998215, 0.011289797723293304, -0.030571483075618744, -0.0618305504322052, -0.009621942415833473, -0.01469655241817236, 0.0020866149570792913, -0.0017013954930007458, 0.020004477351903915, 0.013109362684190273, 0.03711041808128357, -0.0016325602773576975, 0.015037511475384235, -0.010985651053488255, 0.07776755839586258, -0.005964483600109816, 0.08456598222255707, 0.007978546433150768, -0.020354731008410454, 0.021582361310720444, 0.016084495931863785, -0.0507524274289608, 0.018594635650515556, -0.01329492125660181, 0.09860929846763611, -0.009372308850288391, -0.07545223087072372, -0.00009213719022227451, -0.031297773122787476, 0.01449465099722147, -0.004700568504631519, -0.05337013304233551, -0.001194494660012424, -0.013088558800518513, 0.023998064920306206, 0.12918716669082642, -0.021084804087877274, 0.0036843321286141872, 0.012847312726080418, 0.04913125932216644, 0.025195099413394928, -0.013612394221127033, 0.0762893334031105, -0.018895626068115234, 0.003537751967087388, 0.02834387496113777, -0.004585690330713987, 0.033841729164123535, 0.04590951278805733, 0.07444575428962708, 0.03417685627937317, -0.05257640779018402, -0.059993937611579895, -0.033663660287857056, -0.08216361701488495, 0.019479287788271904, -0.03566259890794754, -0.0758381336927414, 0.0392080657184124, -0.011012728326022625, -0.007466625887900591, 0.0037680058740079403, 0.013834199868142605, 0.0035206277389079332, -0.0002749697014223784, 0.01196538656949997, -0.010072721168398857, 0.02679118514060974, -0.03071305714547634, 0.0376410149037838, -0.032059259712696075, -0.006825627759099007, -0.03357641398906708, 0.06231274455785751, -0.01169410441070795, -0.04070020467042923, 0.003222846193239093, -0.01678243838250637, -0.0091546680778265, -0.029210692271590233, -0.009398054331541061, 0.004156115464866161, 0.03300983086228371, -0.015380799770355225, 0.008617160841822624, -0.05366469547152519, 0.04328456148505211, 0.014234456233680248, -0.04342387244105339, 0.007553366478532553, -0.016431637108325958, -0.0011053174966946244, -0.06990723311901093, -0.013155356980860233, 0.014678366482257843, 0.011883484199643135, -0.032316043972969055, -0.00013228239549789578, 0.04878758639097214, 0.045603904873132706, 0.05528753995895386, 0.013375584967434406, 0.01180706825107336, 0.009446708485484123, 0.01779194548726082, -0.037628814578056335, 0.015579444356262684, 0.02733481116592884, -0.031567007303237915, -0.035474926233291626, 0.027706198394298553, -0.016736121848225594, -0.01548356655985117, -0.02145451307296753, -0.0523485392332077, 0.07635127753019333, -0.034207284450531006, 0.045948781073093414, 0.026690823957324028, 0.08944986760616302, 0.011299502104520798, -0.05690563842654228, 0.026582833379507065, -0.02653501369059086, 0.018969612196087837, 0.014066041447222233, -0.014851194806396961, -0.004069845657795668, 0.0025715508963912725, -0.023447535932064056, -0.02694929763674736, -0.015306372195482254, 0.0016873899148777127, 0.028086772188544273, -0.023235322907567024, 0.060250576585531235, -0.0017273458652198315, -0.017572013661265373, 0.06276057660579681, 0.010090907104313374, 0.011127385310828686, -0.04534120857715607, 0.029863007366657257, 0.009485219605267048, -0.002088231034576893, 0.021139614284038544, 0.01681729033589363, -0.008265542797744274, -0.0062665874138474464, 0.010287635028362274, -0.06863170862197876, 0.005169250536710024, 0.015300074592232704, -0.027090037241578102, 0.012214510701596737, -0.008328462950885296, -0.002798394300043583, -0.022395599633455276, -0.010990208014845848, -0.043253783136606216, 0.019069010391831398, 0.045109063386917114, 0.053629014641046524, 0.01792166382074356, -0.04068406671285629, -0.07179508358240128, 0.017125945538282394, 0.03895918279886246, 0.03989127278327942, 0.021521180868148804, -0.007126349490135908, 0.03104516863822937, 0.03112010844051838, -0.05402873456478119, -0.013671673834323883, -0.014758415520191193, -0.02580898068845272, -0.00787762738764286, -0.0385991707444191, -0.009129616431891918, -0.02024863474071026, 0.01573934778571129, 0.0018701782682910562, 0.011185639537870884, -0.030210183933377266, 0.024318013340234756, -0.032858192920684814, 0.02425127662718296, -0.058081068098545074, -0.0497676245868206, 0.07021985948085785, -0.008689546026289463, 0.0045382180251181126, -0.024384768679738045, -0.03571536764502525, -0.02913029119372368, -0.0674896389245987, -0.049980297684669495, 0.005486324429512024, 0.005281555932015181, -0.024509713053703308, 0.0228958111256361, -0.04622015357017517, 0.007978778332471848, -0.06612148880958557, -0.006052475888282061, -0.0342986136674881, -0.03515910729765892, -0.004124939441680908, 0.0004654511285480112, 0.08218280971050262, 0.051238127052783966, 0.05041080340743065, -0.020585834980010986, -0.033652327954769135, -0.06954359263181686, 0.007259862031787634, -0.03069118596613407, 0.02738427370786667, -0.08925005048513412, 0.015519659966230392, 0.03433319553732872, 0.005253287963569164, 0.05143778398633003, 0.01876010186970234, -0.014730088412761688, -0.035116154700517654, -0.060716982930898666, 0.04051847383379936, 0.04456552863121033, -0.05498851090669632, -0.010901019908487797, 0.04404711350798607, 0.006612681318074465, 0.011087853461503983, -0.005514573771506548, -0.01359141431748867, -0.08898937702178955, -0.029288090765476227, 0.028565259650349617, -0.03845272958278656, -0.04665133357048035, 0.006118971388787031, -0.005893617868423462, 0.022680560126900673, -0.01838974468410015, -0.04734335467219353, 0.004730301443487406, 0.042501240968704224, -0.02649541199207306, -0.0664062649011612, -0.04650965332984924, 0.014401125721633434, -0.0031447287183254957, -0.0024024464655667543, -0.005715792998671532, -0.03601715341210365, 0.044322408735752106, 0.06333567202091217, -0.03735220804810524, -0.056031499058008194, 0.06415635347366333, 0.01619669981300831, 0.07207401096820831, 0.013491868041455746, 0.07039419561624527, 0.008332963101565838, 0.040838319808244705, -0.013775786384940147, -0.049238741397857666, -0.012743856757879257, 0.021243177354335785, 0.07899515330791473, -0.034139323979616165, -0.07056048512458801, -0.009303485043346882, -0.021798787638545036, 0.01657777465879917, 0.03752702847123146, 0.036830779165029526, -0.035545915365219116, -0.000011114389053545892, -0.00042396620847284794, 0.05979765206575394, -0.028461286798119545, -0.03456287086009979, -0.015147059224545956, -0.0025131208822131157, 0.014649316668510437, -0.026315629482269287, 0.05589752644300461, -0.035254038870334625, 0.030167831107974052, 0.0006615179590880871, -0.03178149461746216, 0.021750854328274727, -0.007664591073989868, -0.028077738359570503, 0.024106459692120552, -0.009618749842047691, -0.03577229753136635, 0.04178967699408531, -0.062182266265153885, 0.00033909687772393227, -0.02965058945119381, 0.011575455777347088, -0.024907011538743973, 0.03804675489664078, -0.014825942926108837, 0.030697939917445183, -0.01229789387434721, 0.035706400871276855, 0.003351725870743394, -0.034834448248147964, 0.0011047192383557558, -0.05754769220948219, 0.03944315016269684, 0.0897536352276802, -0.09780055284500122, -0.010547598823904991, 0.023107288405299187, -0.002367437584325671, -0.06965036690235138, -0.07249993085861206, 0.029073569923639297, 0.0747968852519989, 0.006651059724390507, 0.015933021903038025, 0.028126176446676254, -0.05980720371007919, -0.05935588851571083, 0.00033339651417918503, 0.000995455775409937, -0.037562932819128036, -0.043206486850976944, 0.03304310515522957, 0.018700793385505676, 0.02664719708263874, -0.00926356390118599, 0.04879288002848625, 0.017320891842246056, -0.002006521914154291, 0.012677855789661407, 0.00931895337998867, 0.08161050826311111, 0.04665578901767731, 0.005258349701762199, 0.012185725383460522, -0.03006884455680847, 0.02927163615822792, 0.02969011850655079, 0.012690565548837185, 0.054266780614852905, -0.027498895302414894, -0.005627752747386694, 0.03399575874209404, -0.08015204966068268, 0.03189786151051521, 0.0145560959354043, -0.02265865169465542, 0.032081469893455505, 0.02904593199491501, -0.008157477714121342, 0.03798411414027214, -0.03617199510335922, -0.006517693400382996, -0.00922419223934412, -0.03509749844670296, 0.010238760150969028, 0.032781556248664856, 0.06977693736553192, 0.00856088101863861, 0.0336175374686718, -0.05038744583725929, 0.05459600314497948, -0.07736297696828842, -0.03697570413351059, 0.007244429085403681, -0.04380662366747856, -0.08611419796943665, -0.0585923045873642, -0.010848989710211754, 0.01696213148534298, 0.023242734372615814, -0.023015446960926056, 0.056105565279722214, 0.036287013441324234, -0.047397591173648834, -0.016963370144367218, 0.050716277211904526, -0.0009175363229587674, 0.037727441638708115, -0.028175611048936844, 0.012868196703493595, 0.042013708502054214, -0.034793004393577576, 0.028855610638856888, 0.02071763388812542, 0.02166745252907276, 0.003478361526504159, 0.09359286725521088, -0.07156094908714294, -0.025481613352894783, 0.08385460823774338, 0.01633056253194809, 0.03729161247611046, -0.012720534577965736, 0.004066813737154007, -0.00245875702239573, -0.015107505023479462, -0.03052542544901371, -0.01420701015740633, 0.025829588994383812, 0.05062885209918022, 0.03074357658624649, -0.01556337159126997, -0.035887621343135834, 0.03426458314061165, -0.03134239837527275, 0.011425327509641647, -0.03103872388601303, -0.026285024359822273, -0.05856139957904816, -0.008175370283424854, 0.036787424236536026, 0.008336815983057022, 0.002110878238454461, 0.0418095737695694, 0.0006437709671445191, -0.02260620705783367, 0.028929343447089195, -0.03623068332672119, -0.05164754390716553, 0.0025641138199716806, -0.031459953635931015, -0.029731493443250656, 0.014831900596618652, 0.0066464669071137905 ]
<p>Given an analysis of every pair of competitors in a race, how may I determine the probability of any given competitor winning the race?</p> <p>For example, what is the probability of competitor 2 winning the following race? P(Cx Win) means the probability of Competitor x winning.</p> <pre> Cx Cy P(Cx Win) P(Cy Win) ---------------------------------- 1 2 0.3 0.7 1 3 0.4 0.6 1 4 0.9 0.1 2 3 0.8 0.2 2 4 0.7 0.3 3 4 0.9 0.1 </pre> <p>I have tried to calculate a 'rating' for each competitor by adding their individual win probabilities. For example the rating for C1 would be 1.6. The rating for C2 would be 2.2 etc. I've tried different ways to use this rating to find the probability of the competitor winning, however my gut feel tells me something is wrong.</p> <p>Is there a mathematical solution to this problem?</p>
g5024
[ -0.019211817532777786, -0.0069417268969118595, 0.02645842358469963, 0.01426696963608265, 0.04035080224275589, -0.03747236728668213, 0.03764261305332184, 0.03738657385110855, -0.09694619476795197, -0.037974368780851364, 0.03475840017199516, 0.024074736982584, 0.023056000471115112, 0.004340647719800472, -0.00514879310503602, 0.04080117121338844, -0.003371631260961294, -0.033555369824171066, 0.019517572596669197, -0.016171805560588837, -0.034294065088033676, 0.015980679541826248, 0.020720617845654488, -0.01910225674510002, -0.0384170338511467, -0.10145615041255951, -0.039845336228609085, -0.03318613022565842, -0.07969734817743301, 0.043378379195928574, -0.03931489586830139, 0.049959249794483185, 0.03503453731536865, -0.0969260185956955, -0.030839798972010612, 0.002883296459913254, 0.039675138890743256, -0.009952733293175697, -0.01357182301580906, 0.030409973114728928, -0.010635669343173504, 0.05132583901286125, 0.021036317571997643, 0.03113657422363758, -0.026679376140236855, 0.04548521712422371, -0.017276069149374962, 0.008798609487712383, 0.045348070561885834, 0.021161194890737534, -0.030125882476568222, 0.04357805848121643, 0.0649697408080101, -0.01545710302889347, -0.0034943963401019573, 0.0686815157532692, 0.0035885449033230543, 0.001639448688365519, 0.027760077267885208, 0.045085106045007706, 0.0026053048204630613, -0.07754909247159958, -0.006682238541543484, 0.01707412488758564, 0.04129309579730034, -0.04355470463633537, -0.004374002106487751, -0.004407169762998819, 0.010546846315264702, -0.04533620923757553, -0.025137335062026978, -0.044153984636068344, -0.00925966165959835, -0.031535446643829346, -0.044443946331739426, -0.026868518441915512, 0.009481416083872318, 0.055707789957523346, 0.04287831112742424, 0.03271333500742912, 0.07812603563070297, 0.009756683371961117, -0.0010894488077610731, -0.008192038163542747, -0.03976421803236008, -0.03545455262064934, 0.009145462885499, -0.04224448651075363, -0.08003150671720505, 0.019729847088456154, 0.014318441972136497, 0.06622323393821716, 0.08278701454401016, 0.0787174254655838, 0.007701082620769739, -0.0140640027821064, -0.11758042126893997, 0.03148442506790161, -0.019659381359815598, -0.017251506447792053, 0.01307598128914833, 0.037215664982795715, 0.014281334355473518, -0.062081366777420044, -0.043705474585294724, -0.018359724432229996, 0.007178307045251131, 0.10076606273651123, 0.01771671697497368, 0.0030428534373641014, -0.011133897118270397, 0.010622912086546421, -0.01085417065769434, -0.08454306423664093, -0.0024003279395401478, -0.009913460351526737, 0.0028126086108386517, -0.014877932146191597, -0.035539597272872925, 0.044545117765665054, -0.024608613923192024, 0.007845907472074032, -0.03149030730128288, 0.029015449807047844, -0.01915845461189747, 0.042682942003011703, -0.009718778543174267, 0.031339697539806366, 0.04034591093659401, 0.014265461824834347, 0.019028427079319954, -0.005817857105284929, 0.043158676475286484, 0.048662275075912476, -0.007255328819155693, 0.035667531192302704, -0.001839303644374013, 0.08597784489393234, 0.01924283057451248, -0.0010141192469745874, -0.035634543746709824, 0.041908010840415955, 0.001373052946291864, -0.06423591822385788, -0.026460586115717888, 0.0322427824139595, -0.01790868490934372, -0.04237226024270058, -0.032685525715351105, 0.056003671139478683, -0.0041931308805942535, 0.03346244990825653, -0.02662588655948639, -0.007069620303809643, -0.023340513929724693, 0.01927216723561287, -0.031750213354825974, 0.018217716366052628, -0.0881953239440918, -0.024688301607966423, 0.12003805488348007, 0.017084715887904167, 0.06530565768480301, -0.007245821878314018, -0.08140748739242554, 0.05202607065439224, 0.0010931356810033321, -0.010396271012723446, -0.03642038628458977, -0.010285649448633194, 0.0009078727453015745, -0.04087163135409355, -0.018846211954951286, 0.0395759753882885, 0.05468693748116493, 0.008710702881217003, 0.024439256638288498, 0.01945783756673336, -0.007970678620040417, 0.07386910915374756, 0.01121528260409832, 0.04058268293738365, 0.034144289791584015, 0.010428857058286667, -0.01360800676047802, -0.08793199062347412, 0.031031806021928787, 0.07715368270874023, -0.028012720867991447, -0.003324676537886262, 0.025309765711426735, 0.03368719667196274, 0.011876596137881279, -0.03690829128026962, 0.006721011828631163, 0.010652090422809124, 0.02219530940055847, -0.01671360805630684, 0.022910624742507935, -0.06540923565626144, 0.028741491958498955, 0.02103414386510849, -0.03301253542304039, 0.05535928159952164, 0.0368041917681694, 0.006008305121213198, 0.027196025475859642, -0.04847817122936249, 0.002123539336025715, 0.012167044915258884, -0.059946950525045395, -0.03693452477455139, -0.024999460205435753, 0.03999822586774826, -0.03914327919483185, -0.027694491669535637, -0.0027493522502481937, 0.015402671881020069, 0.01736196130514145, -0.017894191667437553, 0.006553569342941046, -0.016546469181776047, -0.025613034144043922, -0.010796166025102139, -0.09018814563751221, 0.07510699331760406, -0.03797862306237221, 0.012963462620973587, -0.02266440913081169, 0.06790351867675781, 0.06606937199831009, -0.031236758455634117, -0.006284107454121113, -0.03889627009630203, 0.05076497048139572, 0.022033436223864555, -0.023759808391332626, 0.036686502397060394, -0.021941302344202995, 0.062479764223098755, 0.02124643512070179, -0.054842233657836914, -0.03829798102378845, 0.04721695929765701, -0.0019512505969032645, -0.017745157703757286, 0.0040214634500443935, 0.022875884547829628, -0.029857195913791656, 0.06483592092990875, -0.02451416105031967, 0.010939332656562328, 0.005280309356749058, -0.03016222082078457, 0.005817218217998743, 0.0009774487698450685, -0.017289936542510986, 0.018004579469561577, -0.011010359972715378, 0.013825630769133568, -0.03478517383337021, -0.03879707679152489, 0.059860553592443466, 0.012600179761648178, 0.01466659177094698, -0.025884265080094337, -0.028850477188825607, -0.04371940344572067, 0.022760841995477676, -0.0006821419228799641, -0.027805030345916748, 0.013928724452853203, -0.026256829500198364, 0.009360366500914097, 0.030587418004870415, -0.05456382781267166, -0.0028285651933401823, -0.03692634031176567, 0.030669819563627243, 0.013697613030672073, 0.04610663279891014, -0.04641333222389221, -0.03337045758962631, -0.002643349813297391, -0.02534543350338936, -0.05171804875135422, 0.059216320514678955, -0.02974780835211277, -0.005846139509230852, 0.0629882663488388, 0.08398649096488953, -0.047500789165496826, 0.016184857115149498, -0.017841316759586334, 0.010366417467594147, 0.039608243852853775, 0.06589695066213608, 0.013397611677646637, 0.06625110656023026, -0.006640691310167313, -0.036247167736291885, -0.01947386935353279, 0.04350263997912407, -0.05678670108318329, 0.016912637278437614, 0.022462571039795876, -0.051071446388959885, 0.014001278206706047, 0.0419025793671608, -0.03477314114570618, -0.0029264739714562893, -0.005016547627747059, -0.03120964951813221, -0.038187235593795776, -0.005228935740888119, 0.09163762629032135, -0.016349084675312042, -0.017067398875951767, 0.03830432891845703, -0.04520316794514656, -0.006377276964485645, -0.0031575076282024384, -0.0571470744907856, -0.016213808208703995, 0.01595507748425007, -0.0574650801718235, -0.030761536210775375, 0.04245492070913315, 0.01067254040390253, -0.027138030156493187, 0.02390335313975811, 0.027245553210377693, 0.005121000111103058, -0.020327867940068245, 0.0033926591277122498, -0.030962884426116943, 0.010190775617957115, -0.03767537698149681, -0.04213346168398857, 0.06565875560045242, -0.020176034420728683, -0.020369552075862885, -0.025720860809087753, -0.025627557188272476, 0.0037470338866114616, 0.02907751500606537, 0.04844082146883011, 0.05274859443306923, 0.028709493577480316, -0.060558777302503586, -0.031838949769735336, -0.0032032481394708157, -0.008682663552463055, 0.01763589307665825, 0.02967979945242405, 0.018760409206151962, -0.016886817291378975, -0.04679669067263603, -0.0037020284216850996, 0.04803252965211868, 0.02162490040063858, 0.005735588259994984, -0.04774738848209381, 0.06180684268474579, 0.06097802147269249, -0.010764628648757935, 0.03691026568412781, 0.04476914554834366, 0.038903553038835526, 0.018721086904406548, 0.03947411850094795, 0.03682059422135353, 0.04333724081516266, 0.011759167537093163, 0.03212916478514671, -0.05604288727045059, -0.003481779946014285, -0.035804349929094315, -0.0016435828292742372, -0.006045330781489611, -0.002506818389520049, 0.03317053243517876, 0.010148979723453522, 0.005462992936372757, 0.05193844065070152, -0.03083338774740696, 0.012415699660778046, -0.007981926202774048, 0.045556601136922836, -0.0009092569234780967, -0.0028666257858276367, -0.01930694654583931, -0.09050995111465454, 0.06383071839809418, -0.019523123279213905, -0.00009709986625239253, 0.00852831732481718, 0.0018062422750517726, -0.007112129591405392, 0.0292445607483387, -0.06509318947792053, 0.05847136676311493, -0.02775396779179573, -0.006764607969671488, -0.03342652693390846, 0.018741149455308914, -0.008522599935531616, 0.008514120243489742, 0.046982292085886, 0.049191758036613464, 0.019813699647784233, 0.03399232402443886, 0.021898504346609116, -0.0009845700114965439, 0.0333675853908062, 0.06381332129240036, 0.048224255442619324, -0.06581348925828934, 0.0313214473426342, -0.0018168282695114613, -0.028749382123351097, -0.03693479672074318, -0.023127775639295578, -0.0006874526152387261, -0.03475178778171539, 0.012886350974440575, 0.027060238644480705, 0.02487102337181568, 0.06148720532655716, 0.030763307586312294, 0.05023236200213432, 0.004311231430619955, -0.05978026241064072, -0.00830116681754589, -0.03903374448418617, -0.046349890530109406, 0.04985235631465912, -0.0047402395866811275, 0.017470426857471466, 0.021198777481913567, -0.03562427684664726, -0.011774715036153793, -0.03447860851883888, -0.01534254103899002, 0.061637572944164276, 0.012666276656091213, -0.03455299139022827, -0.015004854649305344, -0.025252535939216614, 0.05437620356678963, 0.025175904855132103, 0.043868936598300934, 0.02415236085653305, -0.0018840325064957142, -0.02037218026816845, -0.010723038576543331, 0.0035363014321774244, -0.03771594911813736, 0.07304499298334122, 0.013593321666121483, 0.005508237052708864, -0.05239279940724373, -0.03755919262766838, -0.0016892022686079144, -0.009768066927790642, 0.02354450896382332, -0.019704636186361313, -0.008603190071880817, 0.05743218585848808, -0.021392887458205223, -0.009052752517163754, -0.0062759146094322205, 0.0362214520573616, -0.011219075880944729, -0.06957995146512985, 0.006871722172945738, -0.038383401930332184, -0.01344302948564291, 0.028009627014398575, 0.016478050500154495, -0.01440946664661169, 0.05663112923502922, -0.038261596113443375, 0.023496968671679497, -0.0032855148892849684, 0.013927258551120758, 0.029479142278432846, -0.057247262448072433, 0.027136340737342834, -0.008397429250180721, 0.011345680803060532, 0.07605601847171783, 0.013895341195166111, 0.022319065406918526, -0.05420392006635666, -0.08321459591388702, 0.030940016731619835, 0.025132842361927032, 0.0438401959836483, -0.004807985853403807, -0.03379448130726814, 0.020604077726602554, -0.004503353498876095, -0.02292107790708542, 0.030376579612493515, -0.01917205937206745, 0.004755709785968065, -0.03617873787879944, 0.004435146693140268, 0.017839429900050163, 0.052797842770814896, 0.024568799883127213, 0.051968932151794434, 0.04123031347990036, -0.034770675003528595, -0.03475044295191765, -0.0021066758781671524, -0.0423407256603241, 0.028271595016121864, -0.010875036008656025, 0.044766973704099655, 0.02464822307229042, 0.01378452405333519, 0.03993747755885124, -0.022528164088726044, -0.06839773058891296, -0.04724685102701187, 0.00009628919360693544, 0.014330807141959667, -0.032983746379613876, 0.029451213777065277, 0.048374831676483154, -0.023057356476783752, -0.022630203515291214, -0.0598837286233902, -0.07009696215391159, -0.018653715029358864, -0.049919139593839645, 0.021475881338119507, 0.019360899925231934, 0.017804592847824097, 0.048441506922245026, -0.031242933124303818, -0.007125285919755697, 0.01984226331114769, 0.010987729765474796, -0.06264691054821014, -0.04529046639800072, -0.007851999253034592, -0.043358661234378815, 0.00755292410030961, 0.0646926611661911, 0.0451512485742569, -0.009634989313781261, 0.015887612476944923, 0.005346598103642464, 0.04286114126443863, -0.056927718222141266, 0.03315284848213196, -0.006795825436711311, 0.017346525564789772, -0.07973161339759827, -0.00906715914607048, 0.002412267494946718, 0.014751876704394817, 0.015532521530985832, -0.08773373812437057, -0.0046214391477406025, -0.053911566734313965, 0.027519797906279564, 0.011274184100329876, -0.03601592034101486, 0.009171712212264538, 0.003094858257099986, -0.028784381225705147, 0.013496817089617252, -0.02060224674642086, -0.00958325807005167, 0.009304304607212543, -0.055816296488046646, -0.022037506103515625, -0.011923485435545444, -0.042214129120111465, -0.029695041477680206, -0.018807265907526016, 0.08359165489673615, 0.026343943551182747, 0.004713626112788916, -0.036322496831417084, 0.011785277165472507, 0.028520680963993073, 0.010457897558808327, -0.03578278049826622, 0.00857457797974348, -0.021134736016392708, 0.03138084337115288, -0.037509504705667496, 0.03950195387005806, -0.01826014369726181, 0.08398185670375824, -0.009737605229020119, -0.012748954817652702, 0.020110953599214554, -0.013644701801240444, -0.013213829137384892, 0.004774334374815226, -0.026034345850348473, 0.0025064542423933744, -0.0644056648015976, -0.003083957126364112, -0.01250333059579134, 0.03928856551647186, 0.006532937288284302, 0.04307153820991516, -0.006495096255093813, -0.014377270825207233, 0.029724478721618652, 0.0033889550250023603, 0.004653504118323326, -0.020810125395655632, 0.01800745353102684, -0.014702445827424526, -0.02271195687353611, -0.05974235013127327, 0.059014879167079926, -0.017584731802344322, -0.0692358985543251, -0.0270945243537426, 0.06227812170982361, -0.0041574835777282715, 0.022086726501584053, -0.05207578465342522, 0.045090820640325546, 0.006456297822296619, -0.06504065543413162, -0.0053759971633553505, -0.01228009257465601, 0.024714399129152298, -0.008824244141578674, 0.031057389453053474, 0.007584225852042437, 0.05196123942732811, -0.0527387335896492, -0.009997059591114521, -0.021937290206551552, -0.009136835113167763, 0.0538816899061203, 0.011462438851594925, -0.005317972972989082, -0.008940182626247406, 0.019444897770881653, -0.028262419626116753, 0.014257673174142838, -0.02271813526749611, -0.04869137331843376, 0.00010318874410586432, 0.03414156287908554, 0.010568901896476746, 0.046485718339681625, -0.005401243455708027, -0.017696237191557884, -0.0531950443983078, -0.02562984824180603, 0.01345251128077507, 0.016201570630073547, 0.0034505075309425592, -0.0041871205903589725, -0.001075860927812755, 0.01844608411192894, -0.05751698464155197, -0.007983244955539703, 0.009178586304187775, -0.0776519924402237, 0.017299937084317207, -0.015601699240505695, -0.033860158175230026, 0.00908344704657793, -0.00707216328009963, 0.030871551483869553, -0.022849129512906075, -0.02162429504096508, -0.022711774334311485, -0.03677956387400627, 0.022016925737261772, 0.014002952724695206, 0.05577392131090164, -0.01059047132730484, -0.047303445637226105, -0.0070044551976025105, -0.006004256661981344, -0.03069983422756195, -0.07300160080194473, 0.010581155307590961, -0.04990397393703461, -0.07014226913452148, 0.00766329700127244, -0.0309443399310112, 0.06356356292963028, 0.03637794405221939, 0.04642516374588013, 0.08267717808485031, -0.017018968239426613, 0.026055313646793365, 0.02241169847548008, -0.008276157081127167, -0.028439056128263474, -0.022275837138295174, -0.055056266486644745, -0.03428655117750168, -0.0013754290994256735, -0.02197805792093277, -0.031783659011125565, -0.012831023894250393, -0.01809600554406643, -0.05548575520515442, -0.046517517417669296, -0.008692469447851181, 0.028790241107344627, 0.0011983069125562906, 0.009084980003535748, -0.022461282089352608, -0.03545216843485832, -0.01635824143886566, 0.07501596957445145, -0.009273475036025047, -0.05399491265416145, -0.0019138394854962826, 0.004714439157396555, 0.0008132336661219597, 0.006107856519520283, 0.006273059174418449, 0.00576857291162014, -0.07542850822210312, 0.057841259986162186, 0.039230719208717346, -0.0012325647985562682, -0.03004332445561886, 0.020017435774207115, -0.011113589629530907, 0.06886735558509827, -0.004559622146189213, -0.00855069700628519, 0.008448944427073002, -0.0057413592003285885, -0.0023496365174651146, 0.03540550172328949, -0.07740695029497147, 0.037969108670949936, 0.01480174995958805, 0.0728517547249794, 0.008744873106479645, -0.02543347142636776, -0.025048932060599327, 0.000028878763259854168, 0.02052348107099533, -0.009377695620059967, -0.005812719464302063, 0.03387323021888733, 0.010063542053103447, -0.039780814200639725, -0.03215654566884041, 0.02865656092762947, -0.06303758174180984, -0.0009137031156569719, -0.041937921196222305, -0.0024741394445300102, -0.026349028572440147, 0.07048094272613525 ]
<p>Diallel Analysis using the Griffing and Hayman approach is so common in plant breeding and genetics. I'm wondering if someone can share R worked example on Diallel Analysis. Is there any good referenced book which covered worked examples? Thanks</p> <p>References:</p> <p>Griffing B (1956) Concept of general and specific combining ability in relation to diallel crossing systems. Aust J Biol Sci 9:463-493 [<a href="http://www.publish.csiro.au/?act=view_file&amp;file_id=BI9560463.pdf" rel="nofollow">pdf</a>]</p> <p>Hayman BI (1954) The analysis of variance of diallel tables. Biometrics 10:235-244 [<a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/3001877" rel="nofollow">JSTOR</a>]</p> <p>Hayman BI (1954) The theory and analysis of diallel crosses. Genetics 39:789-809 [<a href="http://www.genetics.org/content/39/6/789.full.pdf" rel="nofollow">pdf</a>]</p>
g37194
[ 0.01782374456524849, 0.03584020957350731, 0.028088418766856194, -0.021794158965349197, -0.0313284769654274, -0.026624426245689392, 0.046611614525318146, 0.03842215612530708, -0.014082704670727253, 0.04875532537698746, 0.023242799565196037, 0.02099023200571537, 0.0802118182182312, 0.009312139824032784, -0.01354942936450243, -0.050106845796108246, 0.03224959596991539, 0.009523407556116581, 0.04634929448366165, 0.04690917953848839, 0.0011488607851788402, 0.09004499018192291, -0.026580937206745148, -0.028872758150100708, -0.0031103806104511023, -0.05303020030260086, -0.06925737112760544, 0.002772302832454443, -0.06147927790880203, -0.05678761377930641, -0.009624377824366093, -0.02643394097685814, 0.0486564002931118, -0.03015608713030815, -0.033100780099630356, 0.007620114833116531, 0.03137502446770668, -0.005231721326708794, 0.011786375194787979, 0.027957316488027573, -0.01713814027607441, 0.015306897461414337, 0.037934646010398865, 0.018140479922294617, -0.017913278192281723, 0.0024398555979132652, 0.010037182830274105, 0.03954168036580086, 0.013646716251969337, 0.017087511718273163, -0.007679701317101717, -0.011271257884800434, 0.00441244151443243, -0.05422087758779526, 0.06444696336984634, -0.009064380079507828, 0.02760268747806549, -0.00572936562821269, -0.019104458391666412, -0.052249398082494736, 0.01993502490222454, 0.04905557632446289, -0.06693067401647568, -0.0036664267536252737, 0.09701210260391235, -0.03732930123806, 0.03371806815266609, 0.013676663860678673, -0.0183916874229908, 0.0026175174862146378, 0.028819946572184563, -0.055688388645648956, 0.009753357619047165, -0.08698435872793198, 0.01334682572633028, -0.040716249495744705, 0.02046104148030281, -0.016410069540143013, 0.02384822629392147, 0.013571982271969318, -0.02951866202056408, -0.02966504916548729, -0.019188614562153816, 0.06842228025197983, 0.08220529556274414, 0.03776319697499275, 0.0405142642557621, -0.04770564287900925, 0.030426228418946266, 0.0015263240784406662, 0.049950841814279556, 0.03913796693086624, 0.058961350470781326, -0.009095516987144947, -0.0727996751666069, 0.023067230358719826, -0.07633264362812042, 0.010989942587912083, 0.05313257873058319, -0.01048582699149847, -0.003525559091940522, 0.022224033251404762, -0.01749187521636486, -0.04074926674365997, -0.032447755336761475, 0.005053414031863213, 0.06339326500892639, -0.010404353961348534, -0.04525098577141762, 0.006694719195365906, -0.07127436995506287, -0.00042047243914566934, -0.025178775191307068, 0.009524582885205746, -0.013523460365831852, -0.08792051672935486, 0.012925416231155396, -0.008423005230724812, 0.026194145902991295, -0.03423317149281502, 0.043742816895246506, -0.014524822123348713, 0.01026496384292841, 0.010901182889938354, -0.009712361730635166, -0.029821472242474556, -0.0201252531260252, -0.038707733154296875, 0.013861827552318573, -0.014832214452326298, 0.0656624585390091, -0.0346604622900486, 0.0023187180049717426, 0.007468042429536581, -0.02767324261367321, -0.014887407422065735, 0.04623265936970711, 0.05383656173944473, 0.011617123149335384, -0.053857818245887756, -0.027171505615115166, -0.012172326445579529, 0.004976562224328518, -0.01907191053032875, 0.04719415307044983, 0.05525895580649376, 0.014657258056104183, -0.02416706643998623, -0.04332922399044037, 0.002057002391666174, -0.0017572903307154775, 0.0012308686273172498, -0.007832460105419159, 0.005046703852713108, -0.033986251801252365, 0.02253737486898899, -0.007696960121393204, 0.04617560654878616, -0.02491891011595726, 0.011348397471010685, 0.007888506166636944, -0.07941147685050964, -0.014650428667664528, 0.0019925071392208338, -0.034661222249269485, 0.010157981887459755, -0.004466294776648283, -0.046278323978185654, -0.011901158839464188, -0.05397317185997963, -0.008244452066719532, 0.0380886048078537, -0.005872588604688644, 0.02721506915986538, 0.01806403324007988, 0.016380855813622475, 0.09273629635572433, -0.08054099231958389, -0.024594876915216446, -0.026707852259278297, -0.025385119020938873, -0.009325584396719933, -0.03340558707714081, 0.0007824675994925201, -0.00537989754229784, -0.005285330582410097, 0.026993712410330772, -0.07100153714418411, -0.011987801641225815, -0.035639628767967224, -0.03564923256635666, 0.020465074107050896, 0.05630694702267647, -0.021708963438868523, -0.017658166587352753, -0.011100102216005325, 0.03828875347971916, 0.012032464146614075, 0.01835762709379196, 0.024044370278716087, -0.04619305580854416, 0.0559227392077446, -0.048280756920576096, 0.059184927493333817, -0.06758257746696472, -0.03141339123249054, -0.011102374643087387, -0.011863796971738338, -0.017138663679361343, 0.06495734304189682, 0.0027298778295516968, 0.03890319913625717, -0.02449641562998295, 0.01764535903930664, 0.003310276661068201, 0.033290691673755646, -0.04321891441941261, -0.022353002801537514, 0.016262760385870934, -0.037548214197158813, -0.029477735981345177, -0.019233034923672676, -0.017105156555771828, 0.08699347078800201, 0.043134767562150955, -0.004388402681797743, 0.04910515993833542, -0.021025128662586212, -0.011824309825897217, -0.00878666341304779, -0.027185946702957153, -0.010649935342371464, 0.022143090143799782, -0.10854942351579666, -0.028197074308991432, 0.014596392400562763, 0.024526042863726616, -0.020711077377200127, 0.019353510811924934, 0.02182922326028347, 0.016553252935409546, 0.01081517431885004, -0.06382302194833755, 0.0947997197508812, 0.013647962361574173, 0.007723798975348473, 0.06669913977384567, 0.02331753633916378, -0.018412522971630096, 0.046392448246479034, -0.05177932605147362, 0.01977119781076908, -0.02243879623711109, 0.013370487838983536, -0.03882841020822525, -0.0016305532772094011, 0.04674810171127319, 0.0009492223034612834, 0.0430041179060936, -0.0008103067521005869, 0.0024770074523985386, -0.004116962663829327, 0.004278840497136116, 0.03591049090027809, -0.055230531841516495, -0.05165727809071541, 0.07590331882238388, -0.0003677264612633735, -0.025651073083281517, 0.02780061401426792, -0.07892121374607086, 0.025971556082367897, 0.015214735642075539, -0.024177227169275284, -0.004212971776723862, -0.01289102341979742, -0.05366218090057373, -0.0695778876543045, 0.014738806523382664, 0.029684729874134064, 0.017116213217377663, -0.09821862727403641, -0.0009911104571074247, 0.0707632303237915, 0.014207388274371624, -0.01383049413561821, 0.005205365363508463, 0.007273603230714798, -0.011650551110506058, 0.05446784198284149, 0.00253512361086905, -0.021141860634088516, 0.019605528563261032, 0.006948045454919338, -0.03854632377624512, 0.02490176633000374, 0.013408640399575233, -0.021620359271764755, -0.014426352456212044, 0.03103717416524887, -0.00807857234030962, 0.018206287175416946, 0.013497434556484222, 0.03937557712197304, -0.017937973141670227, 0.016472483053803444, -0.06439376622438431, -0.05021913722157478, 0.021571677178144455, -0.007990286685526371, -0.017428433522582054, -0.04038001224398613, -0.08833630383014679, -0.02883712202310562, -0.0014688466908410192, -0.00563989020884037, -0.03310753405094147, -0.00624573091045022, -0.0063194879330694675, 0.04248535633087158, 0.013007714413106441, -0.08174052834510803, 0.06862005591392517, -0.024105140939354897, 0.04026172310113907, 0.04467565938830376, -0.04900647699832916, 0.07803750038146973, -0.05268843099474907, 0.008512883447110653, 0.02865087240934372, -0.03221765160560608, -0.021019697189331055, 0.019029440358281136, -0.021401772275567055, -0.036914531141519547, -0.04478026181459427, 0.007516129408031702, -0.007184349466115236, 0.02195732668042183, 0.0017586753237992525, -0.013514199294149876, -0.04442116618156433, -0.03042467311024666, -0.0416194312274456, 0.046351008117198944, 0.02472694031894207, -0.013287877663969994, 0.007057785987854004, 0.0073693981394171715, 0.006200391333550215, 0.03595241531729698, -0.0018297270871698856, -0.022046372294425964, 0.012364083901047707, 0.009146763943135738, -0.00896318070590496, 0.0014052349142730236, -0.03186171129345894, -0.03315853700041771, 0.02705521695315838, 0.047210462391376495, -0.027065584436058998, 0.02528022788465023, 0.07876983284950256, -0.011179708875715733, 0.004655926488339901, 0.09903554618358612, 0.04236447811126709, -0.010804933495819569, 0.023185042664408684, 0.08272328227758408, -0.012696605175733566, 0.00837648194283247, -0.0167174581438303, -0.0023775286972522736, -0.008346104994416237, 0.015163599513471127, -0.020912032574415207, -0.017220180481672287, -0.015536263585090637, -0.01585707627236843, 0.014991698786616325, 0.026812179014086723, -0.018817603588104248, -0.054967205971479416, -0.018433760851621628, 0.02634197100996971, -0.010028664954006672, 0.010656156577169895, -0.027195019647479057, -0.04480598494410515, -0.037331949919462204, -0.029510214924812317, 0.014576230198144913, 0.018960250541567802, 0.036836542189121246, 0.024159274995326996, 0.01137166004627943, 0.07830237597227097, -0.05070184916257858, 0.001500468933954835, -0.00300674163736403, 0.04000581428408623, 0.0006038866704329848, 0.022997010499238968, -0.04665401205420494, 0.0042647612281143665, 0.033793751150369644, 0.03718079254031181, 0.018592583015561104, 0.052330467849969864, 0.03615676239132881, -0.010137271136045456, 0.02659142203629017, 0.017411189153790474, 0.032463427633047104, -0.023275334388017654, 0.0015877638943493366, -0.0025779567658901215, -0.015316168777644634, 0.02456105500459671, -0.06860022991895676, 0.03048880770802498, 0.022292111068964005, -0.025892499834299088, 0.01692955754697323, 0.009966295212507248, 0.0017956363735720515, -0.037483371794223785, 0.032567281275987625, -0.02155085653066635, -0.04311021789908409, -0.03610829636454582, 0.008178920485079288, -0.005319538060575724, -0.01547492016106844, 0.037071872502565384, -0.009245311841368675, 0.037995584309101105, 0.026166921481490135, -0.00956890732049942, 0.004123280290514231, 0.05455819144845009, 0.023457584902644157, 0.033533111214637756, -0.028084931895136833, -0.036390580236911774, 0.015760209411382675, -0.010853801853954792, 0.08323429524898529, 0.020379675552248955, -0.014967438764870167, 0.05028687044978142, 0.02924855425953865, 0.0125577999278903, -0.03158599138259888, 0.024666795507073402, 0.03178881108760834, -0.019490307196974754, 0.015444920398294926, -0.04731336608529091, -0.017300503328442574, -0.006378612481057644, -0.008660056628286839, -0.021655093878507614, -0.054223690181970596, 0.05366576835513115, 0.0047734021209180355, -0.054917942732572556, -0.08396235853433609, 0.03182153031229973, 0.02780480496585369, 0.009024286642670631, 0.004719021264463663, -0.04414578154683113, -0.034995537251234055, -0.04897797107696533, 0.006670443806797266, -0.02245507203042507, -0.02982732467353344, 0.03061007708311081, 0.021493691951036453, 0.028404954820871353, -0.023042364045977592, -0.01815108023583889, -0.007117645349353552, -0.025774192065000534, 0.011422771029174328, 0.0031053463462740183, 0.048280052840709686, 0.00565362349152565, 0.05538899451494217, -0.04894059896469116, -0.006190876010805368, -0.024025022983551025, 0.0587582029402256, -0.02408638782799244, -0.01141755748540163, -0.009972045198082924, -0.006651395466178656, 0.004412030801177025, -0.020316625013947487, -0.058031510561704636, -0.007227426860481501, -0.020006215199828148, 0.04778444766998291, -0.0013109532883390784, 0.03200038522481918, 0.002032666699960828, -0.02251170203089714, -0.003541379701346159, 0.07495362311601639, 0.004539955407381058, -0.03858312591910362, -0.012594877742230892, -0.03348560258746147, 0.03531206399202347, 0.00607649190351367, -0.04399684816598892, 0.06349658966064453, 0.0046217539347708225, -0.062225110828876495, 0.04449758678674698, 0.006271799094974995, -0.06369253993034363, -0.02498403936624527, 0.014408105053007603, -0.0335809700191021, -0.04156901314854622, 0.0068034157156944275, 0.038534339517354965, 0.043608974665403366, 0.06791091710329056, -0.023228978738188744, -0.055442165583372116, 0.004658008459955454, 0.0033083490561693907, -0.004618415609002113, -0.008898432366549969, 0.00400881702080369, 0.07284938544034958, -0.022704580798745155, -0.011267147026956081, -0.05617700517177582, -0.007319185882806778, -0.05437178164720535, -0.011210874654352665, 0.03340143337845802, 0.00804009661078453, -0.012096162885427475, -0.022368403151631355, 0.03654179722070694, -0.06713942438364029, 0.012364111840724945, -0.043699122965335846, 0.059052977710962296, -0.029065418988466263, -0.0029693234246224165, 0.03852768614888191, 0.02103709988296032, -0.037052564322948456, 0.03766821697354317, -0.008140468038618565, 0.010022681206464767, -0.0449901781976223, -0.03192894905805588, -0.023968476802110672, 0.028271719813346863, 0.05389193817973137, -0.00814058631658554, -0.07123924046754837, -0.04054996371269226, 0.03660089895129204, -0.01928008534014225, -0.0667111873626709, -0.024325832724571228, -0.0057373554445803165, 0.0042788139544427395, -0.048468541353940964, 0.07474993914365768, -0.004963490180671215, -0.02756958268582821, -0.0037061653565615416, -0.06950312107801437, -0.01610134355723858, -0.03348412364721298, 0.07081031054258347, -0.042311906814575195, 0.013461279682815075, 0.005148003343492746, 0.016893355175852776, 0.005113618914037943, -0.011684748344123363, 0.0487801618874073, -0.04981108009815216, 0.012440964579582214, 0.02510181814432144, 0.009461100213229656, -0.026508018374443054, 0.025287369266152382, 0.02328876033425331, 0.02913636714220047, -0.010670352727174759, 0.05121375992894173, 0.03025677613914013, -0.04654273763298988, -0.025519536808133125, 0.0288101676851511, 0.003181792562827468, 0.04133761674165726, -0.0044945478439331055, 0.021464860066771507, 0.03810616582632065, -0.05031995475292206, -0.09801476448774338, -0.07985782623291016, -0.07642170786857605, -0.05589659884572029, -0.013002831488847733, 0.06436905264854431, -0.052982330322265625, 0.02912473864853382, -0.10147582739591599, -0.026153888553380966, 0.03625853359699249, -0.057460010051727295, 0.024730131030082703, 0.0008778064511716366, -0.025867020711302757, -0.008480875752866268, -0.05829915776848793, -0.027039149776101112, -0.02220100536942482, -0.04099370539188385, -0.006272445432841778, -0.020733023062348366, 0.005669773556292057, 0.007334413472563028, 0.06403535604476929, 0.014701633714139462, 0.07734977453947067, 0.01450789999216795, 0.01378423348069191, 0.1116967648267746, 0.009423976764082909, -0.0037773221265524626, 0.03522702306509018, 0.00971006229519844, 0.0023391349241137505, 0.04092269763350487, -0.0014267441583797336, -0.010212703607976437, 0.0193162988871336, 0.01488055381923914, 0.05583816394209862, -0.006138783413916826, 0.02769302949309349, 0.015870312228798866, -0.029237564653158188, 0.0021577770821750164, 0.017534902319312096, -0.007665036246180534, 0.037835828959941864, -0.051029570400714874, 0.03404861316084862, 0.031503770500421524, -0.01288038119673729, 0.015683695673942566, 0.04572897031903267, -0.014707036316394806, -0.006384990643709898, -0.027526814490556717, 0.041534341871738434, 0.06491141021251678, 0.010185030288994312, -0.0008580194553360343, 0.011803725734353065, 0.005254619289189577, -0.09454067051410675, -0.002431598724797368, -0.016394324600696564, -0.01978095807135105, -0.03360617533326149, 0.04879717156291008, -0.012455029413104057, 0.009395874105393887, 0.01678965426981449, 0.033714938908815384, 0.05140962451696396, -0.049799174070358276, -0.05094725638628006, -0.01993461512029171, -0.015449613332748413, -0.04936499893665314, 0.002144850557669997, 0.01034584827721119, 0.05001495033502579, -0.01584658771753311, 0.06589870899915695, 0.05086502432823181, 0.00834896694868803, -0.049953997135162354, -0.02092830464243889, -0.01809767819941044, -0.03134049102663994, -0.021291419863700867, -0.020815035328269005, 0.04822438210248947, 0.0008888785378076136, 0.03576068952679634, 0.066453717648983, 0.011518821120262146, 0.02205878309905529, 0.014737594872713089, -0.021985311061143875, 0.010946285910904408, 0.01236962340772152, 0.02471208944916725, -0.0034650531597435474, 0.034157250076532364, -0.044120121747255325, 0.05823269858956337, -0.052811384201049805, -0.057802699506282806, -0.012211299501359463, 0.0118250772356987, 0.075511135160923, -0.009847630746662617, 0.04695329815149307, 0.04660232365131378, -0.011527638882398605, -0.022486532106995583, 0.03938509523868561, 0.02520805411040783, -0.019069885835051537, -0.026378503069281578, -0.018373217433691025, -0.06821726262569427, 0.04920438677072525, -0.0221105869859457, 0.004369590897113085, -0.006230195518583059, -0.037417639046907425, -0.004906422458589077, -0.043977122753858566, -0.02498108521103859, 0.07048865407705307, 0.023248691111803055, 0.021739276126027107, -0.05010106414556503, 0.021134980022907257, 0.008262555114924908, -0.031671494245529175, 0.024871880188584328, 0.02426624856889248, 0.03129159286618233, 0.08734722435474396, 0.02272699400782585, 0.02148788794875145, 0.02038721740245819, -0.025241518393158913, -0.0052182371728122234, 0.0016879078466445208, -0.009826689958572388, 0.058393433690071106, -0.08771376311779022, -0.02436862140893936 ]
<p>I've been aching to get my feet wet with a machine learning project, and I've found one that should be relatively simple, and actually has non-negligible business value for my organization. The marketing guys have to remove bot activity from our tracking data by hand for their metrics. I wanted to pull some data from GA, and have them construct a data set (bot, not-a-bot). There are probably 5-10 (numerical) categories that we have to train the algorithm, and the data set can be made as big as the marketing guys have an appetite for.</p> <p>I've done a bit of reading, and played with RapidMiner/Knime/Weka a bit. I plan to do everything in Python, with <code>scikits-learn</code>, possibly working in R where I have to. My questions:</p> <ol> <li>Is this a "not actually that easy at all" problem?</li> <li>Given the number of categories, about how large should the training set be? </li> <li>Given the problem, what algorithms should I start with? </li> <li>Has anyone else done any learning around bot detection? How did it work? Am I barking up the wrong tree?</li> </ol> <p>Thanks in advance community!</p>
g74344
[ -0.02508879452943802, 0.008387488313019276, 0.015652837231755257, -0.04277491569519043, 0.006220462266355753, -0.03255602717399597, 0.04367881268262863, 0.041182614862918854, -0.025493435561656952, 0.018710849806666374, -0.019381096586585045, 0.04546119645237923, 0.07518093287944794, -0.011310226283967495, -0.04704074561595917, 0.03357930853962898, -0.020630517974495888, -0.026732701808214188, -0.011087954044342041, 0.033820316195487976, 0.10098541527986526, 0.0493764691054821, 0.051820240914821625, -0.020555926486849785, -0.03579607233405113, -0.020668191835284233, 0.020023789256811142, 0.01445083599537611, 0.015562730841338634, 0.0031461280304938555, -0.05365702509880066, 0.03825368732213974, 0.025159399956464767, -0.06909533590078354, -0.042828068137168884, -0.02593739703297615, 0.024261247366666794, -0.028443310409784317, -0.002270130207762122, 0.0464286133646965, -0.0584096722304821, 0.007763538043946028, 0.0625838041305542, 0.05127308517694473, 0.025084415450692177, 0.013690074905753136, -0.007245904766023159, -0.026075880974531174, 0.009057288989424706, 0.03235793113708496, 0.007027382496744394, -0.02788216806948185, -0.003168497933074832, 0.013760585337877274, -0.026765385642647743, 0.018196288496255875, -0.03578886762261391, 0.015716779977083206, 0.01577690616250038, -0.06400548666715622, 0.06888556480407715, -0.0414770245552063, -0.034011777490377426, 0.017826344817876816, -0.03807932883501053, 0.025572519749403, 0.03863278776407242, -0.04077301546931267, 0.020912276580929756, 0.0069139436818659306, -0.030499247834086418, 0.02622838504612446, 0.03603969141840935, 0.04364427551627159, -0.0655578076839447, 0.000876238860655576, -0.0692753866314888, 0.0063817137852311134, -0.03448526933789253, 0.017613017931580544, -0.0014816571492701769, -0.03320124000310898, -0.052619967609643936, 0.05180474370718002, -0.010691946372389793, -0.05411865562200546, -0.08524693548679352, -0.02544321119785309, 0.014420732855796814, 0.03620988503098488, 0.03549264371395111, -0.007229782175272703, 0.0534091591835022, 0.0156584270298481, 0.0036443802528083324, 0.008331027813255787, -0.05610732361674309, -0.011787417344748974, -0.024928614497184753, 0.010258683003485203, 0.020691974088549614, 0.035568855702877045, -0.03896832838654518, -0.036315180361270905, -0.037042293697595596, -0.05339730158448219, 0.009394862689077854, -0.03186795115470886, 0.005786568857729435, 0.0252140611410141, 0.011130530387163162, -0.0034563017543405294, -0.10084010660648346, -0.03577820584177971, -0.04266778752207756, 0.06287849694490433, 0.03648129478096962, 0.028967829421162605, -0.01612485945224762, -0.033707574009895325, 0.0032281694002449512, -0.016284221783280373, 0.06485188752412796, -0.03067336231470108, 0.0032406053505837917, -0.04977785050868988, -0.04459673538804054, 0.07941155135631561, 0.0320327989757061, 0.0024276915937662125, 0.07790935039520264, -0.05417649447917938, -0.032590772956609726, 0.03609390929341316, 0.00925468560308218, 0.059273675084114075, -0.03229127079248428, 0.029239216819405556, 0.03786453232169151, -0.03734750300645828, -0.004865789320319891, 0.07376648485660553, -0.021198643371462822, -0.027762213721871376, -0.022710071876645088, 0.0456402488052845, -0.05190575495362282, -0.01289306115359068, 0.022031977772712708, 0.030666960403323174, 0.03859072923660278, 0.04553582891821861, 0.01186475157737732, 0.0134230712428689, 0.06312301754951477, 0.013907424174249172, 0.005115963984280825, -0.03916293382644653, 0.032767750322818756, 0.036595746874809265, 0.016504887491464615, -0.0534818060696125, 0.08440247923135757, -0.003184048691764474, -0.03390122950077057, 0.019076041877269745, 0.028434371575713158, -0.013773479498922825, -0.010798449628055096, -0.004798421170562506, -0.00025398825528100133, 0.024501226842403412, -0.0024505334440618753, -0.000686689920257777, -0.03132317215204239, 0.051649365574121475, -0.012171517126262188, 0.00990104116499424, 0.04215157777070999, 0.02996000275015831, 0.027324479073286057, -0.036019545048475266, 0.036432620137929916, 0.039134640246629715, -0.038207996636629105, -0.05697621405124664, -0.04443514347076416, -0.0055345529690384865, 0.007428667042404413, -0.02809102088212967, 0.0382048673927784, -0.036442700773477554, -0.017941001802682877, 0.00844724103808403, 0.007938599213957787, -0.0347115695476532, -0.041420113295316696, -0.034537531435489655, -0.015199960209429264, -0.03774227574467659, 0.06764329224824905, -0.013204235583543777, -0.06104753911495209, 0.022590244188904762, -0.02909236028790474, -0.03976083919405937, 0.018418744206428528, -0.047443050891160965, -0.02303883619606495, -0.019992245361208916, 0.04671604186296463, -0.05870797112584114, 0.012837679125368595, -0.00265344581566751, -0.03004380129277706, 0.02788270264863968, -0.04107842221856117, 0.039573706686496735, 0.036477912217378616, 0.03864876925945282, 0.02337745390832424, -0.03703933581709862, 0.030179763212800026, -0.019126590341329575, 0.020734567195177078, 0.05403020977973938, 0.031036226078867912, -0.00792878307402134, -0.00032003753585740924, -0.0007138581131584942, -0.0005693729035556316, 0.03399062529206276, 0.017314495518803596, -0.06735248863697052, 0.03810963034629822, -0.008636117912828922, -0.016245122998952866, 0.01677500642836094, -0.03328736126422882, -0.0029029552824795246, 0.001029847888275981, -0.0036379441153258085, -0.008121591061353683, 0.015932859852910042, 0.07310417294502258, -0.06554324924945831, 0.0382842980325222, 0.045025233179330826, -0.017050864174962044, 0.001888895989395678, -0.053790297359228134, 0.05174139514565468, -0.025935642421245575, -0.04438517987728119, 0.02473372593522072, 0.0009977559093385935, 0.04429791495203972, 0.03417602926492691, 0.024402771145105362, 0.04332605004310608, 0.004829695913940668, 0.02856356091797352, 0.03522419184446335, -0.011403042823076248, -0.004040126223117113, -0.06358319520950317, 0.002066368469968438, -0.031565722078084946, -0.014205168932676315, 0.014008287340402603, -0.039913639426231384, -0.02484246715903282, 0.0330876000225544, -0.04869614914059639, -0.006014075130224228, 0.020051274448633194, 0.048376068472862244, 0.010181616991758347, -0.0019702466670423746, 0.02422427572309971, 0.029923683032393456, -0.14304643869400024, -0.04956965148448944, 0.004480106756091118, 0.013471477665007114, 0.007177483290433884, 0.012611396610736847, 0.00516204908490181, 0.053377989679574966, -0.022401118651032448, 0.030951710417866707, -0.02130454033613205, 0.016380250453948975, -0.04682321101427078, 0.00040843590977601707, -0.023471182212233543, -0.049874383956193924, 0.02895454131066799, 0.06485868245363235, -0.009554235264658928, -0.01069337036460638, 0.009391526691615582, 0.0668233186006546, -0.07265259325504303, 0.03338707610964775, -0.041175346821546555, -0.048723675310611725, 0.051907703280448914, -0.027224179357290268, -0.022672273218631744, 0.017393987625837326, 0.06841172277927399, 0.012261854484677315, 0.03035644441843033, 0.032632194459438324, 0.01943608932197094, -0.039445582777261734, -0.03095684014260769, -0.010349779389798641, -0.002413440030068159, 0.010076751932501793, -0.07005033642053604, 0.037784576416015625, -0.014055423438549042, 0.01955857314169407, 0.025867750868201256, -0.05815505236387253, 0.013198059052228928, 0.0019072442082688212, -0.016398834064602852, 0.07540396600961685, -0.010826569981873035, -0.0004076922487001866, -0.024113958701491356, -0.019989989697933197, 0.0012380187399685383, -0.007098372094333172, -0.015702182427048683, 0.024563413113355637, -0.012037997134029865, -0.04863931983709335, -0.013477830216288567, -0.03536534681916237, -0.0737168937921524, -0.034577760845422745, 0.0033370337914675474, 0.06558962166309357, -0.002105878898873925, 0.04600853845477104, -0.022601556032896042, 0.007965968921780586, -0.0422433540225029, 0.010667536407709122, -0.07112382352352142, -0.028143370524048805, -0.024571452289819717, 0.0003390116326045245, 0.017110221087932587, 0.02686827816069126, -0.07728485018014908, 0.025136427953839302, 0.010256478562951088, -0.03490421921014786, 0.03611644729971886, 0.03319502994418144, -0.04974769055843353, 0.011004126630723476, -0.01606503501534462, 0.03021501749753952, 0.029339682310819626, 0.06152082979679108, -0.06612097471952438, -0.0026519589591771364, -0.06509542465209961, -0.027106046676635742, 0.022365864366292953, -0.041797738522291183, -0.00011453286424512044, 0.04463900998234749, 0.01971602812409401, -0.06465673446655273, 0.06191515550017357, -0.015559125691652298, -0.05366826802492142, -0.027690723538398743, -0.02506854571402073, 0.017818430438637733, 0.03455313667654991, 0.04238010570406914, -0.012562661431729794, -0.06241345405578613, 0.021011387929320335, -0.0014365726383402944, 0.04423419013619423, 0.04192280396819115, -0.0357716865837574, 0.004480257164686918, 0.04375406727194786, -0.04341651871800423, 0.04834585264325142, -0.03067518025636673, -0.030189262703061104, 0.058859679847955704, -0.05026055499911308, -0.01407598052173853, -0.008812797255814075, -0.04731136932969093, 0.030019156634807587, 0.047761254012584686, 0.021065866574645042, -0.08780144900083542, -0.08542445302009583, -0.0237185750156641, -0.022684914991259575, 0.0061913407407701015, -0.03657868131995201, 0.028062298893928528, 0.04790234565734863, -0.07395224273204803, -0.02454112283885479, -0.023109041154384613, -0.02428663708269596, -0.029728686437010765, -0.05111975967884064, -0.02715838886797428, 0.011267159134149551, 0.024978922680020332, -0.008649282157421112, -0.009235390461981297, -0.0052870106883347034, 0.06787703931331635, -0.021817265078425407, -0.03230594843626022, 0.01526762917637825, 0.01164536364376545, -0.0023471235763281584, 0.032142192125320435, 0.0015330491587519646, 0.015962647274136543, 0.0005779959610663354, 0.007747728377580643, -0.0235780980437994, -0.020826883614063263, 0.0027366948779672384, -0.027121586725115776, 0.008077907375991344, 0.02938460186123848, 0.043551500886678696, -0.0381021648645401, 0.06057804822921753, 0.037575289607048035, 0.018183419480919838, -0.0031773352529853582, -0.0014634908875450492, 0.029366660863161087, 0.00403279485180974, 0.02587956190109253, 0.011806581169366837, -0.031230639666318893, 0.05431949719786644, 0.0015826037852093577, -0.02863854169845581, -0.05110713839530945, 0.0031044785864651203, -0.017593292519450188, -0.048417169600725174, -0.0035608538892120123, -0.008434465155005455, 0.039883870631456375, -0.0024608077947050333, -0.01322493888437748, 0.001855934038758278, 0.047865334898233414, -0.020590592175722122, -0.019205937162041664, 0.05994655564427376, -0.0001870356354629621, -0.025626927614212036, 0.03519812598824501, 0.011609804816544056, -0.004510149359703064, -0.021632986143231392, 0.010700272396206856, -0.03927922993898392, -0.00043044958147220314, -0.0057223220355808735, 0.006231405306607485, -0.0333414301276207, 0.016629496589303017, -0.004688984248787165, 0.015102513134479523, 0.0247284397482872, 0.026052165776491165, -0.009315378963947296, -0.03603615611791611, -0.006614351645112038, 0.01924995705485344, 0.018525490537285805, 0.022583521902561188, -0.017116595059633255, -0.02089996263384819, 0.0061599258333444595, -0.03253917396068573, -0.03112025372684002, -0.04444701224565506, 0.006285352166742086, 0.024719132110476494, -0.008839581161737442, 0.016860567033290863, 0.06251548230648041, 0.03316006436944008, 0.06993383914232254, 0.036839552223682404, 0.03249308466911316, -0.025781454518437386, -0.01830507256090641, -0.019137023016810417, 0.06086840108036995, -0.011577405966818333, -0.0004403492494020611, -0.011941680684685707, 0.0016147157875820994, 0.008060676045715809, 0.012099618092179298, 0.026633907109498978, 0.007413904648274183, 0.005176341161131859, 0.027356183156371117, -0.040320537984371185, 0.03785519674420357, 0.0244075208902359, -0.003313773777335882, -0.016459990292787552, -0.021739376708865166, -0.015344163402915001, 0.0469089150428772, 0.06038869917392731, -0.010622624307870865, 0.023610856384038925, 0.01614907570183277, 0.05535568669438362, -0.006223876029253006, 0.030488766729831696, -0.08300910145044327, -0.05680278316140175, -0.05893000587821007, 0.02741496078670025, -0.05055714771151543, 0.009501826949417591, -0.05021904036402702, 0.0802348330616951, -0.014356035739183426, 0.04826383665204048, 0.01693335734307766, -0.01628182828426361, 0.01603183150291443, -0.041634585708379745, -0.00395671371370554, -0.0009680047514848411, -0.0023801170755177736, 0.003125008661299944, -0.08575039356946945, 0.02620973438024521, 0.04349001124501228, -0.004782530944794416, 0.06241073086857796, -0.042132388800382614, -0.031813330948352814, 0.053615752607584, 0.06437643617391586, -0.036456264555454254, 0.01578378677368164, -0.027122903615236282, 0.05298532545566559, 0.0357394739985466, -0.030249452218413353, -0.01264107134193182, -0.0010376718128100038, 0.02961195446550846, 0.041673820465803146, 0.03739998862147331, -0.014156961813569069, -0.00604281947016716, -0.0020960133988410234, 0.025618309155106544, -0.005867654457688332, -0.07360892742872238, 0.0012533869594335556, -0.05872461199760437, -0.028612583875656128, -0.003165001980960369, -0.004579728469252586, 0.0014811340952292085, -0.08628049492835999, -0.005771979223936796, -0.07983271032571793, 0.015376684255897999, -0.03784559294581413, 0.015031799674034119, 0.021594231948256493, -0.048413362354040146, -0.0057836477644741535, 0.043700139969587326, -0.01197964046150446, -0.03822285681962967, -0.025806786492466927, 0.03247600793838501, -0.026150133460760117, 0.03157750144600868, -0.0648072212934494, -0.038140688091516495, -0.011855154298245907, 0.0004048174887429923, 0.05570283532142639, 0.04237518087029457, -0.03203872963786125, 0.0485721081495285, -0.03780214115977287, 0.08556080609560013, 0.0125419357791543, -0.035693760961294174, -0.008122243918478489, 0.025252167135477066, 0.027263641357421875, 0.03395887091755867, 0.054798536002635956, 0.021747350692749023, 0.005787200760096312, 0.0245415847748518, 0.05527357757091522, -0.00326507817953825, 0.031017225235700607, -0.01105891540646553, 0.027339432388544083, -0.05566692352294922, -0.0025234250351786613, -0.03623106703162193, 0.07862790673971176, 0.010716577060520649, 0.05897420644760132, -0.00011121792340418324, -0.035865504294633865, -0.022495493292808533, 0.020339103415608406, 0.04121415317058563, 0.0033717150799930096, 0.04442305117845535, 0.07850319147109985, -0.019347013905644417, -0.019577043130993843, -0.01570248045027256, 0.01972850039601326, 0.02099304459989071, -0.08712413907051086, -0.09613833576440811, 0.040340855717659, -0.06089160218834877, 0.041397061198949814, 0.024494947865605354, 0.014005166478455067, -0.03960195183753967, -0.04073939844965935, -0.013248919509351254, -0.04058333486318588, 0.050814662128686905, 0.03832545131444931, -0.04094910994172096, 0.05605195090174675, -0.011295867152512074, -0.0735308825969696, -0.04484422877430916, -0.0038114700000733137, 0.004235898144543171, 0.0335904061794281, 0.06989746540784836, 0.02264440432190895, 0.0013379385927692056, -0.019687702879309654, -0.016230279579758644, -0.009850125759840012, -0.04471655935049057, 0.018338603898882866, 0.018252743408083916, 0.005213270895183086, -0.008351822383701801, 0.050214480608701706, -0.05741602182388306, -0.002314275596290827, 0.10021107643842697, -0.0365305170416832, 0.0015845708549022675, -0.004524479620158672, 0.01925233006477356, 0.026267394423484802, -0.004059385508298874, -0.014646700583398342, -0.009655846282839775, 0.00974967796355486, 0.06091363728046417, 0.07227235287427902, 0.019325105473399162, 0.042629655450582504, -0.035282474011182785, -0.03175875172019005, -0.0171158816665411, 0.06328774243593216, 0.0050306241028010845, -0.03314381465315819, 0.025722583755850792, -0.03449304401874542, -0.03372371569275856, 0.0769762396812439, -0.05155893787741661, 0.0271004606038332, 0.010105249471962452, 0.009387887082993984, -0.022183597087860107, 0.04798116534948349, 0.0049943155609071255, 0.002058629645034671, -0.018381353467702866, 0.036612898111343384, 0.000491696409881115, 0.0473053939640522, -0.022208301350474358, -0.014909197576344013, 0.028872650116682053, 0.018485045060515404, -0.04228192940354347, 0.023196348920464516, -0.021552102640271187, -0.05065338313579559, -0.09745892882347107, 0.023678123950958252, 0.010035568848252296, -0.028580192476511, -0.03712407872080803, -0.00605759909376502, -0.031710267066955566, -0.0020156658720225096, -0.01229148730635643, 0.023041006177663803, 0.03030337020754814, -0.0074018752202391624, -0.010055126622319221, -0.0423283688724041, -0.036366645246744156, 0.03815429285168648, -0.042404334992170334, -0.03338942304253578, -0.01223342027515173, -0.0010639936663210392, -0.027222076430916786, 0.00883146096020937, -0.04772653803229332, 0.024641547352075577, -0.05521645396947861, 0.004480944946408272, 0.055483244359493256, -0.010592515580356121, 0.029428742825984955, 0.020386479794979095, -0.036942195147275925, 0.03572125360369682, -0.00917698722332716, 0.0019517216132953763, 0.0291459821164608, 0.0058802152052521706 ]
<p>For given cost function $S(\beta) = (Y - X \beta)^T(Y - X \beta) + \lambda \beta^T \beta$, where $\lambda$ is regularization parameter, the $\beta$ that minimizes the given cost function is $\beta = [X^T X + \lambda]^{-1} X^T Y$.</p> <p>is it right? </p>
g48943
[ 0.031053362414240837, -0.0008883931441232562, -0.005883888341486454, 0.020395459607243538, 0.08991064876317978, -0.06289359927177429, -0.004087633453309536, 0.0009223414235748351, -0.033191293478012085, 0.02610998973250389, -0.08774694800376892, 0.04868010804057121, -0.022916538640856743, 0.03836708888411522, -0.004038393963128328, -0.024270085617899895, 0.052545227110385895, -0.039177462458610535, -0.017684446647763252, -0.001761095249094069, 0.017078552395105362, 0.01535702869296074, 0.03731384500861168, -0.04581265524029732, 0.058133065700531006, 0.061605021357536316, -0.07443138211965561, 0.08801659941673279, -0.07639672607183456, 0.02326061576604843, 0.01706244796514511, 0.015533491969108582, 0.01166105829179287, -0.01394104864448309, -0.03533943369984627, 0.02470042183995247, 0.06417503207921982, -0.009703285060822964, 0.009774422273039818, -0.030568670481443405, 0.00008417498611379415, 0.042152319103479385, 0.04783766716718674, 0.005116236861795187, 0.004247448407113552, -0.03979172930121422, 0.01501451525837183, 0.07293450832366943, 0.033423226326704025, -0.011775343678891659, 0.022346965968608856, 0.0009671348379924893, -0.015669818967580795, -0.023559343069791794, -0.027090417221188545, 0.02519877441227436, 0.009683416225016117, 0.0016540660290047526, -0.07265844941139221, 0.029782840982079506, 0.021928368136286736, 0.024691279977560043, 0.013637343421578407, -0.017125459387898445, -0.03611378371715546, -0.08721544593572617, 0.004170835949480534, -0.012668668292462826, -0.020664552226662636, 0.06039861962199211, -0.0045215957798063755, 0.041809309273958206, -0.014133114367723465, -0.022763265296816826, -0.05703246220946312, 0.016472890973091125, 0.06399616599082947, -0.0011540292762219906, -0.04949294775724411, -0.0018369090976193547, -0.012046492658555508, -0.012392044067382812, 0.010372431017458439, 0.028633415699005127, 0.016704842448234558, 0.012810085900127888, 0.07090932875871658, -0.016239214688539505, 0.025011111050844193, 0.02822468988597393, -0.08031866699457169, -0.04680373892188072, 0.01912051998078823, -0.032443057745695114, 0.028504496440291405, -0.016925008967518806, -0.021185964345932007, -0.018308069556951523, 0.06228378787636757, -0.01333831250667572, 0.0010746546322479844, 0.05817633494734764, -0.020520050078630447, 0.052717119455337524, -0.05599411204457283, 0.019709952175617218, 0.026754263788461685, -0.015120257623493671, 0.0026892542373389006, -0.060318171977996826, 0.003415819723159075, -0.04062782973051071, 0.020337404683232307, -0.03354109451174736, -0.010360152460634708, -0.0383325070142746, 0.05762902647256851, -0.056982651352882385, 0.004290624056011438, 0.02272738330066204, -0.016168342903256416, -0.017752869054675102, 0.012917396612465382, 0.04143437743186951, -0.021681183949112892, 0.07888475805521011, -0.03618217632174492, 0.054308559745550156, 0.0353766530752182, -0.02761094458401203, -0.06357783824205399, 0.010412192903459072, -0.023684287443757057, -0.04685581848025322, 0.024608854204416275, 0.0036037529353052378, -0.04060739651322365, 0.016737446188926697, -0.024616118520498276, -0.03975735232234001, -0.0676923394203186, 0.023418597877025604, 0.03813276067376137, -0.038148947060108185, -0.004141109064221382, -0.017965015023946762, 0.012859382666647434, 0.0140990586951375, -0.03287098556756973, 0.04107998311519623, -0.0103823933750391, 0.026032818481326103, 0.05188726633787155, 0.05679459497332573, -0.014096459373831749, -0.005640016868710518, 0.05783582106232643, 0.023986278101801872, 0.057462211698293686, 0.010461140424013138, 0.0022895492147654295, -0.007775614503771067, 0.05526167154312134, 0.01612040400505066, -0.03732147440314293, 0.005860559176653624, -0.038297832012176514, -0.043564654886722565, -0.047417473047971725, -0.0406934879720211, -0.01831260323524475, 0.03499166667461395, 0.08135660737752914, 0.01983029395341873, 0.025146951898932457, -0.012554151006042957, -0.05296419560909271, 0.06469345092773438, -0.014663456939160824, -0.00006252874300116673, -0.008033557794988155, -0.00966486893594265, -0.00810064747929573, -0.0246247760951519, -0.03501678258180618, -0.038717206567525864, -0.013533072546124458, 0.015646565705537796, -0.022475095465779305, -0.02719489298760891, 0.01276465505361557, 0.008380782790482044, -0.0337771438062191, -0.036794986575841904, -0.030185390263795853, 0.04541398584842682, 0.07491786777973175, -0.0770721286535263, -0.020932232961058617, -0.004261620808392763, -0.03373187407851219, 0.04122735187411308, 0.03515725955367088, -0.022094624117016792, -0.05992628261446953, -0.01718304120004177, 0.015423269011080265, -0.009556809440255165, 0.01499923411756754, 0.0003090499376412481, -0.017841137945652008, -0.08720942586660385, 0.03361202031373978, 0.025890011340379715, -0.038300830870866776, -0.03732702136039734, 0.003021483076736331, 0.05008750408887863, -0.013250110670924187, -0.01876799389719963, -0.06406910717487335, -0.0414336733520031, 0.04589998722076416, 0.038698773831129074, 0.013601196929812431, -0.006095250137150288, -0.003813988994807005, 0.03868916630744934, 0.05047258734703064, -0.012546340003609657, -0.032663434743881226, -0.06402434408664703, 0.009064042940735817, -0.01708185113966465, 0.07555121183395386, 0.030414598062634468, -0.022882334887981415, -0.027322174981236458, -0.017353590577840805, -0.03584164008498192, 0.02127154730260372, 0.035822395235300064, 0.018822213634848595, 0.09221021831035614, 0.04258938506245613, 0.06055941432714462, -0.04570135846734047, -0.01428153645247221, 0.032630037516355515, 0.018591610714793205, -0.002900530816987157, 0.04063165932893753, 0.003106340765953064, 0.015297397039830685, -0.02490384504199028, -0.05936582013964653, 0.03781786561012268, 0.00015132743283174932, 0.02996843121945858, 0.008462532423436642, -0.0037612193264067173, 0.005924558266997337, -0.051296260207891464, -0.04426859691739082, -0.019920632243156433, 0.05181826651096344, 0.002956549869850278, -0.06222081929445267, 0.03896259516477585, 0.011077175848186016, 0.0228806771337986, 0.0017249620286747813, 0.028528032824397087, 0.01861213520169258, 0.057472050189971924, -0.014783700928092003, -0.03153141587972641, -0.0032381450291723013, 0.03409202769398689, -0.005405271425843239, 0.03760472685098648, -0.06667178869247437, -0.04252464324235916, -0.01546403393149376, -0.01198140624910593, 0.029119811952114105, 0.029822317883372307, 0.04200691357254982, -0.006946183275431395, 0.05337869003415108, -0.02984836883842945, 0.002127530984580517, -0.006811118219047785, 0.02710016816854477, 0.016658451408147812, -0.02729117125272751, 0.03353104367852211, -0.05805952474474907, -0.017631972208619118, -0.03669707104563713, -0.03891877084970474, 0.0075467368587851524, -0.042349204421043396, -0.013467809185385704, 0.022563040256500244, -0.056851115077733994, 0.0010596431093290448, -0.0009139127214439213, -0.028858527541160583, 0.01764650270342827, 0.0014848185237497091, -0.022742627188563347, 0.037204060703516006, -0.01223667897284031, 0.02779463119804859, 0.0014573613880202174, -0.040886543691158295, -0.02479660138487816, 0.010642717592418194, 0.05836983397603035, 0.010000352747738361, -0.06732992082834244, 0.00345818349160254, -0.022845715284347534, 0.010423391126096249, 0.024616917595267296, -0.012365764938294888, -0.003268143627792597, 0.018582234159111977, 0.002267114818096161, 0.06740408390760422, -0.014392266981303692, 0.018954742699861526, 0.019969159737229347, 0.01282147690653801, -0.041986845433712006, -0.02429918758571148, 0.05562974512577057, 0.00206302129663527, 0.0456266850233078, -0.03573000431060791, -0.04589388146996498, 0.08539548516273499, -0.04133816808462143, 0.015154046006500721, -0.027361007407307625, -0.01338738389313221, 0.07613608241081238, 0.024789731949567795, -0.0012241244548931718, 0.026448996737599373, -0.005868238862603903, 0.008898479864001274, -0.024806909263134003, 0.026604698970913887, 0.06137824431061745, 0.038810860365629196, 0.029703393578529358, 0.002128602471202612, -0.00377388927154243, 0.06968224793672562, 0.0017144671874120831, 0.004460994619876146, 0.0006501282914541662, -0.016607066616415977, -0.038443200290203094, 0.004417980555444956, 0.06292250007390976, -0.04628962650895119, 0.0002964851737488061, 0.024899376556277275, 0.06602742522954941, 0.0821135863661766, 0.03992478922009468, -0.007615766022354364, -0.04636096581816673, 0.01627713069319725, 0.06235714629292488, -0.03734894096851349, 0.0053067561239004135, 0.011783629655838013, -0.086937814950943, -0.013204229064285755, 0.009949788451194763, 0.01800299808382988, -0.030689457431435585, -0.015833372250199318, -0.08360124379396439, 0.061275284737348557, -0.04841630905866623, 0.029421228915452957, 0.014261975884437561, -0.015410127118229866, -0.023898610845208168, 0.004309978801757097, -0.006124305538833141, 0.004976877011358738, -0.06753399223089218, -0.013193476013839245, 0.035570450127124786, -0.012309612706303596, 0.03855861350893974, 0.04175829514861107, 0.016435300931334496, -0.01908484473824501, -0.07270821183919907, -0.006173253059387207, -0.008209487423300743, 0.0048709530383348465, -0.06972675770521164, -0.029941659420728683, -0.03224046155810356, -0.05085807293653488, -0.02327102981507778, -0.012615611776709557, 0.00281395111232996, -0.018291478976607323, -0.0836515799164772, 0.027731996029615402, 0.009955435059964657, 0.0188343096524477, -0.044918492436409, -0.02806621603667736, -0.01221437193453312, 0.03779586777091026, 0.02730972319841385, 0.06017780303955078, 0.0384974479675293, 0.015494591556489468, -0.08568963408470154, 0.01760103553533554, 0.06458362191915512, -0.05168241634964943, 0.06092476099729538, -0.028573855757713318, 0.028598852455615997, -0.017452767118811607, -0.01653534732758999, -0.03385661542415619, -0.03499465435743332, -0.03901880979537964, -0.016341423615813255, -0.01627315767109394, -0.006978252436965704, -0.07789893448352814, -0.03371976315975189, -0.011603813618421555, -0.08400912582874298, -0.0007322223973460495, -0.020281029865145683, -0.0478554330766201, 0.0329781211912632, 0.06913568824529648, -0.02035459876060486, 0.038191456347703934, -0.023950258269906044, 0.0013036823365837336, 0.04566594958305359, 0.05275481194257736, 0.06075293943285942, -0.020662611350417137, -0.04367782175540924, 0.04080527648329735, 0.06525596976280212, 0.09135431051254272, -0.004506431054323912, -0.04212084412574768, 0.03606162220239639, 0.0058717671781778336, 0.0052375150844454765, -0.009391449391841888, 0.005397757049649954, 0.033875755965709686, -0.010152319446206093, -0.05865101143717766, -0.019724905490875244, -0.0507672019302845, 0.007858834229409695, 0.0269310362637043, -0.005851847119629383, -0.024884959682822227, -0.036926474422216415, -0.034497179090976715, -0.04675379768013954, -0.07078035920858383, 0.030726615339517593, -0.013772260397672653, -0.08139044791460037, 0.05223586782813072, -0.0001420461485395208, -0.007571290712803602, 0.05068128928542137, 0.07840641587972641, -0.02841746062040329, -0.0026514341589063406, 0.01601262018084526, 0.06663539260625839, -0.007514688652008772, 0.054840847849845886, 0.024930864572525024, -0.03194715455174446, 0.018069978803396225, -0.008658033795654774, -0.03197691962122917, -0.02402975782752037, 0.006369456183165312, 0.01299960445612669, 0.07398819923400879, -0.04427963122725487, 0.009829407557845116, 0.004945589695125818, 0.005842745304107666, 0.013184985145926476, -0.01304601039737463, -0.09965915977954865, -0.03118763118982315, 0.026252062991261482, 0.06863238662481308, -0.038990043103694916, -0.05858772248029709, 0.0581081248819828, -0.009443799033761024, -0.0025804447941482067, -0.009570403024554253, -0.012594042345881462, -0.04351666197180748, 0.019288791343569756, -0.015031510032713413, 0.009004518389701843, -0.0032003833912312984, -0.040237486362457275, -0.01530587486922741, -0.05141524598002434, 0.0021059021819382906, 0.008843961171805859, -0.025038667023181915, 0.010643518529832363, 0.04679400101304054, -0.025048771873116493, -0.008237970992922783, -0.02606850303709507, -0.007613015826791525, 0.04430423304438591, -0.013971301726996899, -0.020208679139614105, -0.027248723432421684, -0.021918099373579025, -0.02812773734331131, -0.055547699332237244, -0.04407871142029762, 0.04043199121952057, -0.04078579694032669, -0.027834922075271606, 0.006279749795794487, -0.020433641970157623, 0.05428149551153183, 0.05828750878572464, 0.01965400017797947, 0.006677747238427401, -0.020165441557765007, 0.010583175346255302, -0.05376065894961357, -0.02526414394378662, -0.030402222648262978, 0.01910773292183876, -0.0617193803191185, 0.04335635527968407, -0.08000294864177704, -0.00122893787920475, 0.00574108399450779, -0.015515053644776344, -0.01268375851213932, -0.009521699510514736, 0.009640771895647049, 0.01937759667634964, 0.044995542615652084, -0.01096970122307539, -0.03395441547036171, 0.03786647319793701, 0.00316593237221241, 0.008964882232248783, 0.05171141400933266, -0.012804108671844006, -0.01893186941742897, 0.06046378239989281, 0.05890773609280586, -0.0104426434263587, -0.05839432030916214, -0.026125431060791016, -0.02164372429251671, 0.02176007814705372, -0.004020201042294502, 0.021243734285235405, -0.00925974827259779, 0.029497835785150528, 0.029441948980093002, 0.019742662087082863, 0.015664996579289436, 0.00971874687820673, -0.04334365576505661, 0.06056636944413185, 0.0005832249880768359, 0.020802773535251617, -0.05346181243658066, 0.01799032837152481, 0.022045185789465904, -0.013492814265191555, 0.058912135660648346, -0.003631326137110591, 0.015933861956000328, -0.07332130521535873, 0.028948912397027016, -0.03855912387371063, 0.06584646552801132, -0.03792843595147133, -0.04496695473790169, -0.02808912843465805, 0.01846301555633545, -0.015316902659833431, 0.02232585847377777, 0.07756560295820236, -0.023949861526489258, 0.0014194217510521412, -0.003413102589547634, 0.05083689093589783, 0.04575265198945999, 0.005381881259381771, -0.021962737664580345, 0.01797652803361416, 0.01446574367582798, -0.0017603427404537797, 0.03212656080722809, -0.048292748630046844, 0.029926732182502747, 0.00795066263526678, 0.05452205240726471, -0.0416872575879097, 0.052680615335702896, -0.027210362255573273, 0.03083077073097229, 0.05198168009519577, 0.026001665741205215, 0.003521932754665613, -0.004779055714607239, -0.0036432198248803616, 0.02867022342979908, -0.027447901666164398, 0.0015056602424010634, -0.022287163883447647, 0.03543895110487938, 0.009709835983812809, 0.09351102262735367, 0.00024215907615143806, -0.011231097392737865, -0.008697634562849998, -0.049279265105724335, -0.05179065465927124, 0.007110076956450939, 0.006877804175019264, -0.0007415444124490023, 0.025184161961078644, -0.02364344894886017, -0.06280218809843063, 0.02793728932738304, 0.045927394181489944, 0.0013180322712287307, -0.022690612822771072, 0.0079661188647151, -0.026488972827792168, -0.07120079547166824, 0.030923213809728622, -0.004286288749426603, -0.028594329953193665, -0.008925432339310646, 0.05351272597908974, -0.017258629202842712, 0.05216812714934349, -0.026450492441654205, -0.053456854075193405, 0.030996711924672127, 0.06284509599208832, -0.01712900586426258, 0.011772907339036465, -0.031521573662757874, -0.02467338927090168, -0.038843777030706406, 0.011697260662913322, 0.013648208230733871, 0.006631864700466394, -0.04433167353272438, -0.04932740703225136, 0.004618286620825529, 0.005277097225189209, 0.0016133864410221577, 0.02646017074584961, 0.03263084962964058, 0.03189858794212341, -0.006312158890068531, 0.0008376505575142801, 0.01880449429154396, 0.00016248303290922195, -0.0024780617095530033, -0.032595522701740265, 0.006278247106820345, 0.07866369932889938, 0.04259653016924858, 0.011155305430293083, -0.02907497063279152, -0.037852682173252106, -0.04204251617193222, 0.010821796953678131, -0.03342371806502342, -0.05301876366138458, 0.01987943798303604, 0.02863266132771969, 0.029183119535446167, -0.0014904061099514365, -0.02957831136882305, -0.007751561235636473, 0.0007401764742098749, 0.006712008733302355, 0.025914456695318222, 0.02202240377664566, -0.06686792522668839, -0.033322762697935104, 0.007684568874537945, -0.04049502685666084, -0.0011618887074291706, -0.005471782758831978, 0.05530814826488495, -0.04212005436420441, -0.03893740847706795, -0.041975535452365875, 0.007982875220477581, -0.03616929426789284, -0.009632670320570469, 0.023414893075823784, 0.04539554566144943, 0.045777443796396255, 0.02391624078154564, -0.049552664160728455, 0.004246323835104704, -0.013813470490276814, 0.04774974286556244, 0.03545544296503067, 0.015749765560030937, 0.013597688637673855, -0.007355294190347195, 0.05702918767929077, -0.033003952354192734, 0.011050276458263397, -0.008211955428123474, -0.03402964398264885, -0.008965902030467987, -0.004560114815831184, 0.008667407557368279, 0.02491689659655094, -0.07181484252214432, -0.052471231669187546, -0.0014068960445001721, -0.06293131411075592, -0.024232210591435432, 0.02153807319700718, 0.048394735902547836, 0.01476770918816328, 0.028654620051383972, 0.03545612469315529, 0.016028236597776413 ]
<p>I'm looking for a dataset (preferably with a story, at any rate a real dataset) where a SVM with a linear kernel performs well...in other words i'm looking for a dataset where the class boundary is likely to be linear. Ideally, there should be between 10-20 continuous variables and not too many discrete ones....</p> <p>It's not really important to me how many classes there are (as long as it's a classification problem). Also, it can't be the iris dataset. </p> <p>Any proposals?</p> <p>P.S.: @modo: i don't think this is a question about obtaining a particular dataset: it's more that i have not read svm/machine learning papers since i was a master student so i'm not familiar with some comon good examples...i'm just sure they exist.</p>
g74345
[ 0.02021637000143528, 0.03128325566649437, 0.0005349294515326619, -0.015282212756574154, -0.07691477239131927, -0.06063048914074898, -0.034206584095954895, 0.04943281412124634, -0.02463429421186447, -0.0217952411621809, 0.08284810185432434, 0.005387578625231981, 0.02327241376042366, 0.0068307979963719845, -0.05174204334616661, -0.0012143346248194575, -0.015440168790519238, 0.001519345911219716, -0.012690376490354538, 0.014919538050889969, 0.002812531078234315, 0.03753609582781792, 0.04916292801499367, 0.009761936031281948, 0.017496258020401, 0.0409323051571846, -0.02685794048011303, -0.015461060218513012, 0.009977119043469429, 0.047378670424222946, -0.013304355554282665, -0.03893681615591049, -0.00852440856397152, -0.07980215549468994, -0.058093756437301636, 0.015694914385676384, -0.02556901052594185, -0.03864401951432228, 0.008241552859544754, -0.020626043900847435, 0.04417118802666664, -0.016324544325470924, -0.023360725492239, 0.04956449195742607, 0.00665135495364666, -0.009002991952002048, 0.004292292986065149, -0.02333151176571846, 0.035464026033878326, -0.03739714249968529, 0.013697533868253231, -0.0021006306633353233, -0.014100980944931507, 0.015454704873263836, 0.04500453919172287, -0.0289386585354805, -0.034383442252874374, 0.08416518568992615, -0.011212578974664211, -0.05843260511755943, 0.05139756202697754, 0.007027897983789444, -0.005755130667239428, -0.03445040434598923, -0.007984405383467674, 0.04009132459759712, -0.039818648248910904, -0.03339564800262451, -0.028462305665016174, -0.006617244798690081, -0.00032372650457546115, 0.020349403843283653, -0.007564497645944357, 0.014369753189384937, -0.08191681653261185, 0.0005224868073128164, -0.05514754727482796, -0.014525968581438065, 0.028908492997288704, 0.053269315510988235, 0.06146690994501114, 0.024280089884996414, -0.049841489642858505, 0.015615259297192097, 0.03657009080052376, -0.048293132334947586, -0.00007980118243722245, 0.015071851201355457, 0.0022618079092353582, -0.038670022040605545, -0.02386757731437683, -0.005044508725404739, -0.019743885844945908, -0.014804402366280556, 0.01727253571152687, 0.02206563949584961, -0.030065204948186874, 0.06397008895874023, -0.002849639393389225, -0.022549986839294434, 0.0021221041679382324, 0.0018990543903782964, 0.05483999475836754, -0.00989040918648243, -0.005585790146142244, -0.032257553189992905, -0.00024267738626804203, -0.028219817206263542, -0.006901043467223644, -0.06341110169887543, 0.03273402154445648, -0.00900072231888771, -0.09458554536104202, -0.019672874361276627, -0.012932737357914448, -0.06456110626459122, 0.04128683730959892, 0.0011894230265170336, -0.00026530641480349004, -0.02976968139410019, 0.021868908777832985, -0.01929933950304985, -0.021483730524778366, 0.030990947037935257, 0.015575467608869076, 0.01759178563952446, -0.02830197662115097, 0.014290701597929, 0.0019723144359886646, -0.027093039825558662, 0.033679284155368805, -0.012551787309348583, -0.0161273293197155, -0.029008636251091957, 0.004083303734660149, 0.023992011323571205, 0.009408561512827873, -0.014158164151012897, 0.04951256141066551, 0.014998828992247581, 0.016593830659985542, 0.055140670388936996, 0.010023949667811394, 0.004358870908617973, -0.008430317044258118, -0.04467703402042389, -0.0055613527074456215, 0.012031781487166882, -0.01729349046945572, 0.03289109840989113, 0.030751198530197144, 0.02921249344944954, -0.02533995918929577, -0.011418180540204048, -0.08158618956804276, -0.009330341592431068, -0.0038898978382349014, -0.04560534283518791, 0.021868029609322548, -0.058298200368881226, 0.007219082675874233, -0.020351259037852287, 0.01703447289764881, -0.023798195645213127, -0.03774543106555939, -0.015239513479173183, -0.03267059102654457, -0.004886025562882423, 0.005575353745371103, 0.05145726352930069, -0.012440765276551247, 0.049339305609464645, 0.029540827497839928, 0.04232759773731232, 0.005453022662550211, 0.007373403292149305, -0.005316402763128281, -0.028216203674674034, 0.07629840075969696, 0.03727224841713905, 0.05011368915438652, -0.036513254046440125, 0.03352847695350647, -0.04812981188297272, 0.0026856656186282635, -0.010625362396240234, 0.001546048908494413, 0.07708363980054855, -0.01326220203191042, -0.00387833034619689, -0.0050471872091293335, 0.04222843796014786, 0.06907565891742706, -0.054023921489715576, -0.01594066619873047, -0.018422354012727737, 0.03450441360473633, -0.05944490060210228, -0.04381363093852997, -0.0278384480625391, 0.04370947554707527, 0.06898719817399979, -0.058157432824373245, 0.05053405091166496, -0.09329991787672043, 0.007263947278261185, 0.0684473067522049, -0.020801246166229248, -0.057755496352910995, -0.00017582009604666382, 0.00041727579082362354, -0.07126342505216599, -0.03351595625281334, 0.013233605772256851, 0.016144316643476486, 0.03000490367412567, 0.02112468145787716, 0.0027545250486582518, -0.012085741385817528, 0.01393381878733635, -0.01799229346215725, -0.029505040496587753, -0.0009069672669284046, 0.0562802329659462, -0.007807835936546326, -0.014896588400006294, 0.046498484909534454, -0.009324880316853523, 0.04259137809276581, 0.042170729488134384, -0.06258170306682587, -0.030602671205997467, 0.080509252846241, -0.06937975436449051, 0.049544353038072586, 0.014538781717419624, -0.011647098697721958, -0.02049337886273861, -0.021984584629535675, -0.011669263243675232, 0.05008530244231224, 0.0069810678251087666, -0.000022347765479935333, 0.022195281460881233, 0.0385005921125412, -0.07128024846315384, 0.02943057008087635, -0.0062166969291865826, 0.07971698045730591, -0.011334600858390331, -0.07947921007871628, 0.004025885369628668, 0.017522472888231277, 0.028891000896692276, -0.023990049958229065, -0.05610889196395874, 0.008315392769873142, 0.025554923340678215, 0.013775254599750042, 0.0029861554503440857, -0.021864406764507294, 0.045056410133838654, -0.033628832548856735, -0.06077136844396591, -0.01027359813451767, 0.011321180500090122, 0.07480035722255707, -0.027035683393478394, 0.0025357119739055634, 0.04030632972717285, -0.002140555763617158, -0.009289296343922615, 0.058238159865140915, -0.0068257832899689674, 0.019863896071910858, 0.017566731199622154, -0.006418176461011171, -0.0001914781896630302, 0.022553643211722374, -0.0221708957105875, -0.023466438055038452, -0.10874960571527481, 0.03571268171072006, -0.038481876254081726, -0.01556571014225483, -0.008911234326660633, 0.02985190786421299, 0.035787053406238556, -0.0037217852659523487, 0.03392941504716873, -0.043847084045410156, -0.017953546717762947, 0.019895097240805626, -0.0024745820555835962, 0.026235872879624367, 0.004027273040264845, 0.017743371427059174, 0.03190881386399269, 0.07705078274011612, 0.0011965555604547262, -0.011007294058799744, -0.020380835980176926, -0.005503672640770674, -0.056259337812662125, 0.009190026670694351, -0.06538160145282745, -0.009822950698435307, 0.047117363661527634, -0.015223934315145016, -0.030195077881217003, 0.03643147274851799, 0.017613744363188744, -0.03824898600578308, 0.022264989092946053, 0.038097064942121506, -0.050087735056877136, -0.029335131868720055, 0.033548206090927124, -0.011970861814916134, -0.02193521521985531, 0.07776712626218796, -0.04734373092651367, 0.03439980000257492, 0.009772846475243568, -0.01038527674973011, 0.030183879658579826, -0.06771127134561539, 0.023842711001634598, -0.014195801690220833, 0.03700987994670868, 0.07462691515684128, 0.004753388464450836, 0.029609868302941322, -0.009122475981712341, 0.015413068234920502, -0.005431674886494875, -0.015044093132019043, 0.0017582770669832826, 0.07601041346788406, 0.05030187591910362, -0.03156374394893646, 0.03974239155650139, -0.03652407228946686, 0.010756665840744972, -0.02790009416639805, -0.007924051955342293, -0.01309160515666008, -0.006151268258690834, 0.025346927344799042, -0.024413270875811577, -0.005566817242652178, -0.07130180299282074, 0.01842266134917736, -0.016005652025341988, -0.018781686201691628, 0.03797971084713936, -0.00720461318269372, 0.0010224578436464071, 0.041233982890844345, -0.05838704854249954, 0.02257143333554268, 0.0067640794441103935, -0.014701143838465214, -0.01962430588901043, 0.016356147825717926, 0.01630500890314579, 0.02002425119280815, 0.051846154034137726, 0.0046917651779949665, -0.028024565428495407, 0.0831228718161583, 0.02193598821759224, 0.025282928720116615, 0.010261708870530128, -0.06879562884569168, 0.01489635556936264, -0.03480714187026024, 0.04658475145697594, -0.0188605859875679, 0.03107028268277645, 0.042620204389095306, 0.04623831436038017, 0.01898167096078396, 0.03786840662360191, -0.0053756688721477985, -0.007693796418607235, 0.07799390703439713, 0.06190388277173042, 0.05985400453209877, 0.02565399929881096, -0.004280317109078169, -0.05024385824799538, -0.048976220190525055, 0.06460388004779816, -0.0014438247308135033, -0.04284399002790451, 0.0094064399600029, -0.0003273712645750493, 0.013781329616904259, 0.012072212994098663, -0.009499098174273968, -0.004359012935310602, -0.03379092738032341, 0.0013527589617297053, -0.02896221913397312, -0.044240087270736694, -0.036731936037540436, 0.04635532200336456, -0.052405670285224915, 0.020153502002358437, -0.06736724823713303, -0.05546530708670616, -0.07882522791624069, -0.07126029580831528, 0.008426283486187458, 0.01084886398166418, 0.043987009674310684, 0.0033085367176681757, 0.036700617522001266, -0.011553928256034851, -0.03952571377158165, 0.04978421330451965, -0.0637824758887291, -0.015531337819993496, -0.019521528854966164, -0.005787120666354895, 0.012506257742643356, -0.020471544936299324, -0.0345483161509037, 0.0023344187065958977, 0.039485637098550797, 0.02097097598016262, -0.03363095223903656, 0.048643749207258224, 0.06544186919927597, 0.04046527296304703, -0.024819187819957733, -0.05571572110056877, -0.08459378033876419, -0.058167241513729095, -0.04102601855993271, -0.029356129467487335, 0.06941661238670349, -0.03391830250620842, 0.000822572794277221, 0.038474731147289276, 0.01461426168680191, -0.020331572741270065, -0.044961411505937576, 0.0676509365439415, 0.014883685857057571, 0.0388878770172596, -0.03291841968894005, 0.019325915724039078, 0.01465008407831192, -0.005674952641129494, -0.0079563083127141, 0.015913890674710274, 0.021308422088623047, 0.06823263317346573, 0.02037724107503891, -0.043440524488687515, -0.017628563567996025, -0.02941206842660904, -0.026822242885828018, -0.022498155012726784, -0.11684570461511612, 0.003628995968028903, 0.051317717880010605, -0.002878723433241248, 0.013086926192045212, 0.0656990110874176, -0.020167959854006767, 0.03110283799469471, -0.01565677672624588, 0.043334346264600754, -0.05553489550948143, -0.014617322944104671, 0.04158664494752884, 0.009187057614326477, -0.020552190020680428, -0.04390965402126312, 0.025790804997086525, 0.05595074221491814, 0.02410687506198883, -0.013375874608755112, 0.01145167089998722, 0.02486519329249859, 0.04996641352772713, 0.016762686893343925, 0.0066949366591870785, 0.011722767725586891, -0.01157413050532341, 0.02480817772448063, 0.0035519369412213564, -0.013563591055572033, 0.007842718623578548, -0.0668327584862709, 0.009811557829380035, 0.0466294139623642, -0.04809626564383507, 0.008591712452471256, 0.011760721914470196, -0.03914843872189522, -0.006259315647184849, 0.003111108671873808, 0.04466182366013527, -0.0004367821093183011, -0.039351146668195724, 0.05377626046538353, 0.007204051595181227, 0.017414581030607224, -0.03316190838813782, 0.015203631483018398, -0.02301361970603466, -0.026004236191511154, -0.03752736374735832, 0.008596778847277164, 0.03374696895480156, -0.007842285558581352, 0.005734145641326904, -0.07531249523162842, -0.0017145229503512383, 0.05006448179483414, 0.03583398833870888, -0.02563907951116562, -0.02816879190504551, 0.0016908319666981697, -0.006703273393213749, -0.01169575285166502, 0.0660407766699791, -0.032447777688503265, -0.04240759462118149, -0.09227412939071655, 0.013669567182660103, 0.008283945731818676, -0.017501072958111763, 0.03928277641534805, -0.0034331860952079296, 0.005775291472673416, -0.03509795293211937, -0.00004713220914709382, -0.002701185178011656, -0.037804558873176575, -0.0074028875678777695, -0.028763869777321815, -0.0033855123911052942, 0.012092058546841145, 0.010052090510725975, -0.08498535305261612, -0.015898311510682106, 0.027334773913025856, -0.01681695505976677, -0.0018939689034596086, -0.024720730260014534, -0.015935823321342468, 0.0061285593546926975, 0.01784360222518444, 0.00931498408317566, -0.013044808991253376, 0.01063563022762537, -0.010507352650165558, 0.05062690004706383, -0.026081694290041924, -0.036834362894296646, 0.0005753723089583218, -0.010275047272443771, -0.07009109854698181, 0.05899925157427788, 0.023485897108912468, 0.035247575491666794, -0.03737424686551094, 0.033870525658130646, 0.03586450219154358, -0.03309362381696701, -0.03997734934091568, 0.01772519201040268, 0.0021790878381580114, 0.047654543071985245, -0.040263812988996506, 0.012294693849980831, -0.01610652171075344, 0.07905082404613495, -0.03348580747842789, 0.0013910880079492927, 0.006732587702572346, -0.040422867983579636, -0.014601259492337704, -0.035464633256196976, 0.009419815614819527, 0.06866656243801117, -0.026488102972507477, 0.022702137008309364, -0.029420031234622, 0.01739679090678692, -0.0301247239112854, 0.04125872626900673, 0.015009136870503426, 0.0011246871436014771, -0.048970118165016174, 0.02474159374833107, 0.019604017958045006, 0.04907575622200966, 0.029376264661550522, 0.006898305844515562, -0.004071093630045652, 0.011765895411372185, 0.008955634199082851, 0.029415667057037354, 0.023801133036613464, -0.05500243231654167, 0.06226782500743866, -0.03475070372223854, 0.05126965418457985, -0.021030142903327942, -0.0369010865688324, -0.005686566233634949, -0.06932038813829422, -0.019402869045734406, -0.008221035823225975, 0.0009173324797302485, -0.04086847975850105, 0.00897426437586546, 0.0051017021760344505, -0.039514731615781784, -0.03129824250936508, 0.005147140473127365, 0.021796230226755142, 0.06106145679950714, 0.0249616838991642, -0.00820467434823513, -0.018474431708455086, 0.03061794675886631, 0.005173464771360159, -0.053580883890390396, 0.025578558444976807, -0.11700734496116638, 0.008384373970329762, 0.025841088965535164, 0.00837086234241724, 0.09127901494503021, -0.020756985992193222, -0.026439493522047997, -0.005226889159530401, 0.09101744741201401, 0.024308735504746437, 0.016335608437657356, 0.03032410331070423, -0.019546791911125183, -0.05824729800224304, 0.006607630755752325, 0.06407693773508072, 0.025158409029245377, -0.04011349007487297, -0.09886977076530457, 0.02361035719513893, -0.0037927916273474693, -0.004760710056871176, 0.0651739165186882, -0.0031188400462269783, -0.04608239233493805, -0.022784242406487465, -0.039437294006347656, -0.07064922153949738, 0.016786212101578712, 0.045198533684015274, -0.044747475534677505, -0.002885592170059681, 0.06083902716636658, -0.009988557547330856, 0.03788520768284798, -0.03920245170593262, 0.013800019398331642, 0.04382862523198128, -0.014972801320254803, 0.05051156133413315, 0.0264841727912426, -0.002915759338065982, 0.026742082089185715, -0.03528236597776413, 0.006657662335783243, 0.010744123719632626, 0.02626742050051689, 0.020972318947315216, -0.02554173767566681, 0.019961226731538773, 0.002443962963297963, -0.06776534020900726, 0.06055782735347748, 0.02177988551557064, 0.019353562965989113, -0.016373712569475174, -0.004318414721637964, 0.02217778190970421, 0.0007043681107461452, -0.008497321978211403, -0.04387407377362251, 0.017308354377746582, 0.0498691089451313, 0.07240709662437439, -0.05914246663451195, 0.06580546498298645, -0.07257646322250366, 0.015378608368337154, -0.01388542726635933, 0.06413152068853378, -0.04783458262681961, 0.0037577070761471987, 0.020008325576782227, -0.06797675043344498, -0.018101369962096214, 0.012993949465453625, -0.019971420988440514, -0.012747550383210182, 0.01599457859992981, 0.022064130753278732, 0.004568442236632109, 0.041026391088962555, 0.04430753365159035, 0.016459153965115547, -0.0042305574752390385, -0.009045187383890152, 0.045674879103899, 0.01425626128911972, 0.049880560487508774, -0.004015007056295872, -0.02125999517738819, -0.05287718027830124, -0.006675502751022577, 0.034438230097293854, -0.021432511508464813, -0.036739688366651535, -0.0054298886097967625, -0.010911224409937859, -0.03832680359482765, -0.04946976527571678, -0.02554243803024292, 0.03514949232339859, -0.03135971352458, 0.10419618338346481, 0.011792036704719067, -0.0430927649140358, 0.0334075503051281, -0.017278915271162987, 0.05466800555586815, 0.004134928807616234, 0.02499006688594818, -0.0047236233949661255, 0.031185248866677284, -0.07592876255512238, -0.07902413606643677, 0.014604395255446434, -0.043095335364341736, 0.0423722118139267, 0.001994363497942686, 0.03736116364598274, -0.0013411464169621468, 0.0052078054286539555, 0.03520188480615616, -0.03350382670760155, 0.011611717753112316, -0.05748942866921425, -0.02122643031179905, 0.025259314104914665, -0.02199716866016388, -0.0022927906829863787, -0.0005696699372492731, -0.021496618166565895 ]
<p>I have multiple logistic regression models with all of the same IVs/controls and a variety of DVs (all health outcomes from the same sample). The primary IV is the sum of types of childhood abuse (emotional, physical or sexual). I made dummy variables that represent any one type of experience, any two types of experiences, or all three types of experiences (so each is mutually exclusive). This is the same type of model the CDC uses for their ACEs study which is where I borrowed the method from.</p> <p>Question 1: Can I compare the one experience dummy to the two experience dummy within the same model? That is, talk about the odds ratios in comparison to one another without standardizing the coefficients? My sense is yes and I've seen it done all over the place but I recently was given a dissenting opinion saying that since I am only comparing each IV to the dummy referent of 0 experiences, I can't compare them to one another without standardizing first. </p> <p>Question 2: What's the best method to make comparisons across models (with all the same IVs)? I'm testing the dummy IVs against a variety of physical and mental health outcomes and I'd like to compare the odds ratios for each DV based on any one type of experience, two experiences or three experiences. It would be nice to say, one experience increases the odds of this outcome by 3.2 times, this outcome by 2.1 times, etc. Therefore, I can say that one type of abuse increases the risk of depression more than anxiety disorder or two types of abuse increases the risk of PTSD over depression etc (assuming no overlap in confidence intervals). </p> <p>I've read Menard's 2011 piece on standardized LR coefficients and that makes sense as to what mechanism to use within a single model (as I would apply in question 1 if necessary), but I can't tell if this can be applied across DV models if I'm using all the same IVs/controls from the same sample. If I standardize each IV coefficient, then are they comparable across models? It's a random sample and each model has the same number of valid cases (1073) with no missing data. </p>
g48944
[ -0.022887175902724266, -0.06988131254911423, 0.010905224829912186, -0.02964857406914234, 0.022577086463570595, -0.03612441569566727, 0.017754895612597466, -0.00971688237041235, 0.0045257266610860825, -0.022973617538809776, -0.000029923594411229715, 0.022577455267310143, 0.020222052931785583, 0.013721741735935211, -0.022319678217172623, 0.014751095324754715, -0.02810392715036869, -0.06219734624028206, -0.018032995983958244, -0.06438926607370377, -0.004908871836960316, -0.025084661319851875, 0.010924614034593105, 0.021368347108364105, -0.06804908066987991, -0.04021623358130455, -0.05920540168881416, 0.045026745647192, -0.04293718561530113, -0.004541224800050259, 0.026549560949206352, 0.013247298076748848, 0.0529656782746315, -0.014325128868222237, -0.028959175571799278, -0.03683052211999893, -0.04442062973976135, 0.008282001130282879, -0.03477391228079796, 0.004130700137466192, 0.0012566031655296683, 0.05951295047998428, 0.03275664895772934, 0.03541981428861618, -0.016389882192015648, 0.014704177156090736, -0.04434504732489586, -0.027769040316343307, -0.00041135476203635335, -0.003195601049810648, 0.02977660484611988, 0.0043652355670928955, 0.006351020652800798, 0.0018109744414687157, 0.05289090424776077, -0.03689326345920563, -0.025762179866433144, 0.05239184945821762, 0.01073185633867979, 0.01847214810550213, -0.013888622634112835, 0.003970790654420853, -0.061281248927116394, -0.02738812379539013, 0.013161057606339455, 0.0038693707901984453, -0.017578383907675743, 0.040364671498537064, -0.01275518536567688, -0.02858593501150608, -0.011266844347119331, 0.005960037931799889, 0.03774973750114441, -0.04062085971236229, -0.03617792949080467, -0.020487137138843536, 0.019889188930392265, -0.01709848642349243, 0.018360523506999016, 0.06434503942728043, -0.009105289354920387, 0.02350454404950142, 0.027109481394290924, 0.044437188655138016, 0.0726228877902031, 0.038906682282686234, 0.01774163730442524, 0.004003655165433884, 0.019412755966186523, 0.016540121287107468, -0.02968069724738598, 0.0570024773478508, -0.010361376218497753, 0.07600724697113037, -0.01722020097076893, -0.015359202399849892, -0.049027442932128906, 0.0819815844297409, 0.018000954762101173, 0.010039943270385265, -0.03829250857234001, 0.009092382155358791, 0.01509309932589531, -0.03336446359753609, -0.07998599112033844, -0.024628818035125732, 0.0049023437313735485, 0.010376074351370335, -0.03532468155026436, -0.049299728125333786, -0.09318381547927856, 0.00702931871637702, -0.0006875668768770993, -0.03159226477146149, -0.02242249995470047, -0.05473257601261139, -0.010989563539624214, -0.02510114014148712, -0.017511440441012383, -0.03588869422674179, 0.018022075295448303, 0.043207257986068726, 0.04261569678783417, 0.03538935258984566, -0.0031262864358723164, -0.02446974627673626, -0.05558038130402565, 0.07814595103263855, -0.0010338330175727606, -0.02768765762448311, -0.005680226255208254, -0.020907411351799965, 0.017214274033904076, 0.02403527870774269, 0.0004262043221388012, 0.005084776785224676, 0.026329025626182556, 0.05124489590525627, -0.020602764561772346, 0.02916649356484413, -0.03743058070540428, -0.02353523299098015, -0.02227458730340004, -0.013944629579782486, -0.03834396228194237, 0.013754255138337612, -0.020571067929267883, -0.03947218880057335, -0.047647956758737564, -0.013146485202014446, 0.058312974870204926, 0.05035480856895447, -0.019285347312688828, 0.006247603800147772, -0.08093464374542236, 0.034978579729795456, -0.03790004923939705, 0.002468598075211048, 0.021577946841716766, 0.06057312339544296, -0.04541858285665512, -0.03347644954919815, 0.002364299027249217, 0.04470007121562958, 0.04504182189702988, 0.007950346916913986, 0.014725897461175919, 0.018496964126825333, -0.013222108595073223, -0.007223275024443865, 0.006797729060053825, -0.04960900545120239, 0.030360601842403412, -0.029687965288758278, 0.033252812922000885, 0.008737532421946526, 0.02608729898929596, -0.07853032648563385, -0.011856205761432648, 0.006471762899309397, -0.018634086474776268, 0.01734188199043274, -0.02861330471932888, -0.008408819325268269, -0.011104744859039783, 0.015981599688529968, -0.0018711695447564125, 0.03295687958598137, -0.009673332795500755, 0.0020848813001066446, -0.019320165738463402, -0.007921241223812103, -0.03320050239562988, 0.027936914935708046, -0.085039883852005, -0.06378939002752304, 0.014801749028265476, -0.034749407321214676, -0.02142373099923134, -0.007231979165226221, 0.023630797863006592, 0.04401377961039543, 0.013363235630095005, 0.022171173244714737, -0.03534536063671112, 0.045097243040800095, -0.03456762060523033, -0.013309291563928127, 0.011664684861898422, -0.023951740935444832, 0.015080420300364494, 0.04034515470266342, -0.0048254854045808315, 0.03585444390773773, -0.008550148457288742, -0.038761913776397705, 0.04467981681227684, 0.003985000308603048, -0.04560786113142967, -0.0005375940818339586, -0.06888269633054733, -0.025070933625102043, 0.03873144090175629, -0.014390280470252037, -0.03868136554956436, 0.005507456138730049, 0.020494816824793816, -0.0346844382584095, 0.03799690306186676, -0.004302182700484991, -0.012850160710513592, 0.000345440988894552, 0.055979423224925995, -0.07498154789209366, -0.008597156032919884, 0.01679590344429016, 0.01693062111735344, -0.0029311086982488632, -0.038814760744571686, 0.05057153105735779, 0.03548794984817505, 0.011447552591562271, -0.019389010965824127, 0.07975136488676071, 0.026159755885601044, -0.06271851062774658, 0.004675561562180519, -0.022972311824560165, 0.06258457899093628, 0.08437126874923706, -0.09814354032278061, 0.0931166261434555, -0.025608325377106667, -0.02420450560748577, -0.009281974285840988, -0.02481253258883953, 0.04712831974029541, 0.02341495454311371, 0.020713435485959053, 0.04631954804062843, 0.03420800343155861, 0.008413147181272507, -0.02586495503783226, 0.058791633695364, -0.05919523909687996, -0.034053560346364975, 0.012471124529838562, -0.030356252565979958, -0.026092562824487686, -0.009316136129200459, -0.035464685410261154, -0.009855637326836586, -0.026644805446267128, 0.0396084263920784, 0.04964505508542061, 0.03200234845280647, -0.03445833548903465, -0.029033757746219635, -0.00517996633425355, -0.05821012333035469, -0.016633884981274605, -0.027880975976586342, -0.004073673859238625, -0.0066757807508111, 0.13215918838977814, 0.018047941848635674, 0.115871861577034, -0.025215337052941322, -0.08523452281951904, 0.01856139488518238, -0.05902798846364021, 0.06995484977960587, 0.00012285863340366632, 0.01583900861442089, -0.02047177590429783, 0.012939073145389557, 0.03576917573809624, -0.054004352539777756, 0.028004756197333336, 0.03800356015563011, -0.04144897684454918, 0.0037779638078063726, 0.008486061356961727, 0.06760571897029877, 0.04143880680203438, -0.033758871257305145, -0.036484427750110626, 0.04007498174905777, 0.01663552224636078, 0.002705808961763978, 0.0007855402072891593, -0.05507490411400795, -0.057453569024801254, -0.02278832159936428, 0.00890463124960661, -0.040740616619586945, 0.029247388243675232, -0.0067562563344836235, 0.025330444797873497, 0.015784213319420815, 0.029940839856863022, 0.0017059759702533484, 0.016586916521191597, 0.016765154898166656, -0.024630632251501083, 0.024429280310869217, -0.02149892970919609, 0.06783290207386017, -0.09435564279556274, 0.045802757143974304, 0.013330945745110512, 0.08373324573040009, 0.008490262553095818, -0.003252170281484723, -0.0002537412801757455, 0.006576968356966972, -0.04229111224412918, 0.013874828815460205, 0.003475446719676256, 0.036965105682611465, 0.039227209985256195, -0.01050596497952938, 0.0012854075757786632, 0.0026173568330705166, -0.023051537573337555, -0.04370630905032158, 0.05188024789094925, 0.049447715282440186, 0.027290305122733116, -0.029651278629899025, 0.002263406291604042, 0.00372668681666255, -0.024739615619182587, -0.01153306569904089, 0.013776690699160099, -0.014825763180851936, 0.02054668217897415, 0.05011575669050217, -0.011522375047206879, -0.00011166075273649767, 0.016382373869419098, -0.008516536094248295, -0.0021851095370948315, -0.046678900718688965, -0.03000483289361, 0.02182263694703579, 0.10131993144750595, 0.0016512757865712047, 0.04457274079322815, -0.055471863597631454, -0.007006916683167219, 0.09593629837036133, -0.004252647049725056, -0.03515880927443504, 0.03022797964513302, -0.05212807282805443, 0.06671613454818726, 0.06444622576236725, -0.0330546610057354, 0.020634915679693222, 0.06475336849689484, 0.04979153722524643, -0.02453494258224964, -0.01783393695950508, -0.010220440104603767, -0.047855861485004425, 0.01599055901169777, 0.02372262254357338, 0.009121210314333439, -0.006023511756211519, 0.009571561589837074, 0.005436773877590895, -0.05541825667023659, 0.06458565592765808, 0.06812217086553574, 0.0022158795036375523, -0.013869519345462322, -0.015858154743909836, 0.0014726961962878704, 0.01458826009184122, 0.006573711521923542, -0.00746718468144536, 0.0197864081710577, 0.01251264289021492, -0.05190522223711014, -0.011360903270542622, 0.01429336704313755, 0.009799166582524776, -0.02780095674097538, -0.0050212121568620205, 0.003909057006239891, -0.0075882612727582455, 0.0009979780297726393, -0.007109314668923616, 0.06366079300642014, -0.012868647463619709, 0.053890787065029144, 0.014802548103034496, -0.025017237290740013, -0.019907861948013306, -0.010276257060468197, -0.024730227887630463, -0.05330677703022957, -0.01786472275853157, 0.0764627754688263, -0.016154903918504715, 0.01033877395093441, 0.0027542905882000923, 0.03457794710993767, -0.0047797709703445435, 0.05040144547820091, 0.016076844185590744, -0.015187989920377731, 0.04813432693481445, 0.04574024677276611, 0.011482113040983677, 0.0027515750844031572, 0.0580361932516098, -0.016674965620040894, -0.0399320051074028, -0.02384430170059204, 0.047195903956890106, 0.014688894152641296, 0.026955438777804375, 0.012790504842996597, 0.048861999064683914, -0.012859845533967018, -0.026571305468678474, -0.014340483583509922, 0.05610472336411476, -0.007021477911621332, 0.05417007952928543, -0.0075116935186088085, -0.012126149609684944, 0.009733619168400764, -0.02350451797246933, 0.1037650927901268, 0.029194338247179985, 0.023450111970305443, -0.018402986228466034, 0.03687932342290878, 0.0059155672788619995, -0.020067468285560608, -0.04452924057841301, 0.015883248299360275, -0.020189417526125908, -0.036327164620161057, 0.004959398414939642, -0.04304194822907448, 0.0017882221145555377, 0.056320421397686005, -0.042407575994729996, -0.04386627674102783, -0.002034060889855027, 0.07984597235918045, -0.023983541876077652, -0.004062975756824017, -0.014831447042524815, -0.05816667526960373, -0.00018022452422883362, -0.04405631124973297, -0.007866932079195976, -0.0012366730952635407, -0.017306458204984665, -0.036786388605833054, -0.04399781674146652, -0.038700222969055176, -0.08961286395788193, 0.02715037204325199, -0.02109110914170742, -0.02094157785177231, 0.03312062844634056, 0.02828695811331272, 0.008127480745315552, 0.00944183673709631, 0.05515827238559723, -0.008375302888453007, -0.0042199986055493355, -0.011905638501048088, -0.0022088082041591406, -0.01431987900286913, 0.02825336903333664, 0.056818004697561264, -0.053759828209877014, -0.01421501487493515, 0.02381138689815998, 0.03565894439816475, -0.028541898354887962, 0.01856241188943386, 0.10626393556594849, -0.0035987740848213434, 0.0084639647975564, -0.0049951160326600075, 0.016185149550437927, -0.054841283708810806, 0.015470907092094421, 0.025282319635152817, 0.03445329889655113, 0.07111611217260361, -0.04337061941623688, 0.03640906512737274, 0.027796711772680283, -0.013868068344891071, 0.027700373902916908, -0.05544820427894592, -0.05392489209771156, -0.02466777339577675, -0.0573657751083374, -0.035843562334775925, -0.04605266824364662, -0.0050871605053544044, 0.046120867133140564, 0.003991699777543545, 0.02607431821525097, -0.012847710400819778, 0.01977093704044819, -0.07918847352266312, -0.033485375344753265, 0.012426639907062054, 0.03556230664253235, -0.00859452411532402, -0.040043219923973083, 0.02596133016049862, -0.041284069418907166, -0.02836497500538826, 0.0021422591526061296, -0.016328193247318268, -0.04576599970459938, -0.044047918170690536, 0.010995520278811455, -0.060802724212408066, -0.019803736358880997, -0.023846222087740898, 0.027605900540947914, 0.007911874912679195, 0.004590243566781282, -0.024166500195860863, 0.02620740793645382, -0.018398363143205643, 0.04041839390993118, -0.024171853438019753, -0.010189616121351719, -0.010705852881073952, 0.02368757873773575, -0.017390035092830658, -0.04294973984360695, -0.02495245821774006, -0.03563115745782852, 0.0014527823077514768, -0.023864848539233208, 0.06666985899209976, -0.08962123095989227, 0.04235231876373291, 0.010937245562672615, 0.007879102602601051, -0.029734479263424873, 0.04014985263347626, -0.025102147832512856, 0.01797465607523918, -0.01273084431886673, -0.009219983592629433, 0.0071845329366624355, -0.014828438870608807, 0.03571594879031181, 0.005814659409224987, 0.05042131990194321, -0.01192660816013813, -0.043037090450525284, -0.04568752646446228, -0.011366191320121288, -0.03973011672496796, -0.03703945502638817, 0.029354281723499298, -0.05933631584048271, -0.018539948388934135, -0.014617971144616604, 0.01795620657503605, 0.0148864034563303, 0.0029827046673744917, -0.04527801647782326, 0.02230658195912838, -0.030751725658774376, 0.026549149304628372, -0.021709667518734932, 0.011800946667790413, 0.005902457516640425, -0.04167095571756363, -0.014454066753387451, 0.02844950743019581, 0.0004667368484660983, -0.03820117935538292, -0.0003642905212473124, 0.00655998894944787, 0.02667897939682007, 0.02085210382938385, -0.035990457981824875, -0.06289608776569366, -0.0037024246994405985, 0.022942475974559784, 0.044420480728149414, -0.0027344028931111097, -0.04172796010971069, 0.02606678381562233, -0.015700459480285645, 0.025244928896427155, 0.02191750332713127, 0.002117638010531664, 0.003697377862408757, -0.007749869488179684, -0.00850662961602211, -0.053226593881845474, -0.0027496740221977234, -0.03915523365139961, 0.01952190324664116, -0.05302441120147705, 0.05988505110144615, 0.003925468772649765, 0.03740860894322395, -0.04116198047995567, 0.004900612868368626, -0.016347233206033707, 0.03733028471469879, -0.008395716547966003, 0.03822212666273117, 0.03796974942088127, -0.017596185207366943, 0.1005234643816948, -0.002333084587007761, 0.0035218277480453253, 0.03573772683739662, 0.05302610993385315, 0.016083544120192528, -0.00795468594878912, -0.039026033133268356, 0.007221491541713476, 0.039690300822257996, 0.09270477294921875, 0.019741229712963104, 0.03686589375138283, 0.040560536086559296, 0.015884168446063995, -0.010253380052745342, -0.04810722917318344, -0.032539159059524536, -0.02030204050242901, 0.028160084038972855, -0.013273240998387337, -0.08294124156236649, 0.04072484374046326, 0.0023898871149867773, 0.081301748752594, 0.022546708583831787, -0.02599121816456318, 0.013412189669907093, 0.00021292720339260995, -0.01817069575190544, 0.008520224131643772, 0.01562496181577444, 0.00239976542070508, 0.02927452325820923, 0.0008650051895529032, 0.008094527758657932, 0.0113124530762434, 0.0375448614358902, 0.029344381764531136, 0.058389417827129364, 0.002953676739707589, -0.040531057864427567, 0.001142573542892933, -0.019919460639357567, -0.053268369287252426, -0.11161483824253082, 0.016775812953710556, 0.017357463017106056, -0.05696796253323555, 0.00902983732521534, -0.02932732366025448, 0.044559091329574585, -0.019623061642050743, 0.0606255829334259, 0.0161629319190979, 0.02457503415644169, -0.040783435106277466, 0.029390400275588036, 0.026451900601387024, 0.018325746059417725, 0.0009097043075598776, -0.020809900015592575, 0.010733614675700665, -0.021747900173068047, -0.03373878821730614, 0.030830416828393936, 0.00038255067192949355, 0.030468294396996498, -0.05573965236544609, -0.05042233690619469, -0.042561452835798264, -0.04983385279774666, 0.04500596225261688, 0.056293535977602005, -0.046092793345451355, 0.012798616662621498, -0.014186786487698555, 0.018516043201088905, 0.06510254740715027, -0.08000193536281586, 0.008290988393127918, 0.01711929962038994, -0.059025973081588745, -0.0042928485199809074, -0.0512811616063118, -0.07616933435201645, -0.08152107149362564, 0.015319901518523693, 0.06532298773527145, 0.03773786127567291, 0.04137246310710907, 0.02526821941137314, -0.052842285484075546, 0.0015329682501032948, -0.05278196558356285, 0.030923331156373024, -0.013664357364177704, 0.04482370242476463, -0.032188531011343, 0.0603390671312809, -0.01173880510032177, -0.03700774163007736, 0.01891143061220646, -0.05261891335248947, 0.0044564418494701385, -0.024253927171230316, 0.025054607540369034, 0.052098680287599564, 0.02307792939245701, 0.010104481130838394, -0.01104433462023735, 0.011608755216002464, -0.02543633058667183, 0.029362095519900322, -0.03634004294872284, 0.03919273987412453, -0.01374243013560772, 0.0333833172917366, -0.038536351174116135, -0.029743796214461327, -0.005649518687278032, 0.07713480293750763 ]
<p>I'm trying to do a simple scatterplot and trend line in R, but it doesn't look right. Have I messed up something blatantly obvious? Any ideas as to why the line doesn't fit the data?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/AISqZ.png" alt="the trend line does not fit the data"></p> <p>Here is the code I used.</p> <pre><code>&gt; plot(x, y, pch=".") &gt; model &lt;- lm(x ~ y) &gt; summary(model) Call: lm(formula = x ~ y) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -0.23043 -0.04340 -0.00533 0.03761 0.47882 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 0.051154 0.001384 36.97 &lt;2e-16 *** y 0.462881 0.003739 123.80 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 0.06365 on 71514 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.1765, Adjusted R-squared: 0.1765 F-statistic: 1.533e+04 on 1 and 71514 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 &gt; abline(model, col="red") </code></pre>
g74346
[ 0.026433190330863, -0.0600895956158638, -0.014309152029454708, -0.03209540620446205, -0.04296817630529404, 0.023190855979919434, 0.0022828704677522182, 0.02684907242655754, -0.06626808643341064, -0.022646203637123108, 0.029178103432059288, 0.03630204498767853, 0.06543081998825073, 0.004310838412493467, 0.011809363029897213, 0.017606163397431374, 0.03997107222676277, -0.014017804525792599, 0.05324839800596237, 0.002225941512733698, -0.02933560684323311, 0.006928193848580122, 0.024961521849036217, -0.06305773556232452, -0.0023296987637877464, -0.012564411386847496, -0.022557653486728668, 0.05597185716032982, -0.08935144543647766, 0.02674354985356331, 0.022000513970851898, -0.020088376477360725, -0.03437430039048195, -0.05513744428753853, -0.019922249019145966, -0.021761514246463776, 0.020010506734251976, 0.026985179632902145, 0.017648911103606224, -0.005676142871379852, 0.016401728615164757, -0.007126561366021633, 0.017511483281850815, -0.00615503266453743, -0.018364669755101204, 0.004872321616858244, 0.013608877547085285, -0.009103131480515003, -0.003334974404424429, -0.020787512883543968, -0.0061315735802054405, 0.0534449964761734, 0.004594821482896805, -0.032472629100084305, 0.011937828734517097, 0.031564582139253616, 0.0247651357203722, -0.004808759316802025, -0.009281455539166927, 0.05599586293101311, 0.019325748085975647, 0.010997609235346317, 0.016696566715836525, -0.04289424046874046, 0.004696246236562729, 0.04552752524614334, 0.0031532763969153166, -0.04865431413054466, -0.05043542757630348, -0.031787313520908356, 0.023824971169233322, -0.027353569865226746, 0.003097838955000043, -0.0017535531660541892, -0.09881174564361572, -0.04569060727953911, -0.03557770326733589, -0.024165567010641098, -0.02050560712814331, -0.016181565821170807, -0.027545025572180748, 0.054565802216529846, -0.06442751735448837, 0.0744704082608223, 0.01575135812163353, 0.021708738058805466, 0.04024598374962807, -0.018551934510469437, 0.01586824283003807, -0.023555459454655647, -0.021635636687278748, 0.01761944778263569, 0.021028168499469757, 0.038805704563856125, -0.018346363678574562, -0.07154245674610138, -0.09281717985868454, 0.0076967948116362095, -0.014249380677938461, 0.02764231339097023, -0.017990848049521446, 0.051598481833934784, 0.02198919840157032, -0.029360437765717506, -0.02065436728298664, -0.01758364960551262, 0.06024862453341484, -0.03324326127767563, -0.042336605489254, -0.05667809024453163, -0.01620377041399479, -0.022034065797924995, -0.03624802827835083, 0.0154456477612257, -0.03213522583246231, -0.046967729926109314, 0.029943782836198807, -0.027189237996935844, 0.012426448985934258, 0.012765892781317234, 0.048236969858407974, -0.013451921753585339, 0.07849711924791336, 0.03588886931538582, -0.03395823761820793, -0.032128822058439255, -0.045858774334192276, 0.031037209555506706, 0.06489984691143036, 0.017850298434495926, -0.021420221775770187, 0.01229953859001398, -0.029698466882109642, 0.01069412287324667, -0.013350806199014187, -0.005751881282776594, 0.014660404995083809, 0.016780007630586624, -0.04293035343289375, -0.00504632294178009, -0.0029178850818425417, -0.013196932151913643, 0.03450342267751694, -0.12680523097515106, -0.05887490138411522, 0.011605980806052685, -0.014106353744864464, 0.0026067171711474657, -0.004798413719981909, -0.010800611227750778, 0.004586742725223303, 0.06280563026666641, -0.08122921735048294, 0.08428730070590973, -0.059706516563892365, -0.005963921081274748, 0.018658386543393135, -0.030972324311733246, 0.013661070726811886, -0.018537381663918495, 0.018048670142889023, 0.00816167239099741, 0.009911329485476017, -0.0034570719581097364, 0.0020778756588697433, 0.010266336612403393, -0.014250063337385654, -0.023609545081853867, -0.01915234886109829, -0.0034689493477344513, 0.021415194496512413, -0.005514810793101788, -0.01330267172306776, -0.06445293128490448, -0.00580989196896553, 0.013110577128827572, 0.08768150210380554, 0.01422443613409996, 0.04611745476722717, -0.0040679629892110825, 0.002683768980205059, 0.020664116367697716, 0.016428936272859573, -0.05943871662020683, -0.02075045183300972, -0.02659396454691887, 0.02935701422393322, -0.009203010238707066, -0.07094096392393112, -0.03859645500779152, 0.020716462284326553, 0.03883608430624008, -0.02063535712659359, 0.03129185363650322, 0.04031148925423622, -0.019035890698432922, -0.014267757534980774, -0.060463063418865204, -0.044279031455516815, 0.0692095160484314, 0.025942770764231682, 0.010090651921927929, -0.009665228426456451, 0.0573081448674202, -0.09464766830205917, -0.05183859169483185, -0.017766065895557404, -0.02859547920525074, -0.021638108417391777, -0.0019824791233986616, -0.0033482362050563097, -0.001954343169927597, -0.010733494535088539, 0.045034151524305344, 0.02413754165172577, -0.018075641244649887, -0.0012571160914376378, 0.015226584859192371, -0.04876048490405083, 0.010069898329675198, -0.050835974514484406, 0.004418325610458851, -0.010294115170836449, 0.019497280940413475, 0.03689626231789589, 0.037993110716342926, 0.04611857235431671, 0.04888125881552696, -0.0010488301049917936, -0.033113330602645874, -0.008982486091554165, 0.011761540547013283, -0.021358774974942207, -0.01447419822216034, 0.051905013620853424, -0.007094294298440218, -0.011291777715086937, 0.005946139805018902, -0.020157363265752792, 0.02076702006161213, 0.018849855288863182, 0.042812276631593704, 0.011124299839138985, 0.04998631402850151, 0.11300797760486603, 0.028132960200309753, 0.03136187791824341, -0.024556472897529602, 0.018238095566630363, 0.09294947236776352, -0.006117990240454674, 0.059709835797548294, -0.00309386826120317, 0.00992809608578682, -0.01739903725683689, -0.0611160509288311, -0.006860669702291489, 0.030201198533177376, 0.004248744808137417, -0.004634236916899681, -0.06385817378759384, 0.08993573486804962, -0.023738393560051918, 0.020539790391921997, -0.013069914653897285, 0.02481789141893387, -0.005954183172434568, 0.051519956439733505, 0.006509087048470974, -0.03867664188146591, -0.05251536890864372, 0.00497280340641737, 0.061633069068193436, 0.06237179413437843, 0.004162671975791454, 0.03277818113565445, 0.04615172743797302, -0.04410942271351814, 0.006900120060890913, 0.005746456328779459, 0.030552636831998825, -0.08976365625858307, 0.00729596521705389, 0.023613691329956055, 0.06602814793586731, -0.04074207320809364, 0.024196553975343704, 0.03751828521490097, -0.0690891295671463, 0.04221633821725845, -0.008669096045196056, -0.011438618414103985, -0.005325498525053263, -0.03484151512384415, -0.010479644872248173, -0.029656806960701942, 0.0038742837496101856, -0.022021031007170677, 0.07245608419179916, 0.04340510442852974, -0.020643379539251328, -0.007757847663015127, -0.006636851467192173, -0.007916949689388275, 0.06240924075245857, -0.07522373646497726, 0.0031352750957012177, 0.008290092460811138, -0.0055599031038582325, -0.005572011694312096, 0.008968408219516277, -0.03088395856320858, -0.04433706775307655, 0.019267171621322632, -0.031510502099990845, 0.00601703068241477, 0.0004886756069026887, 0.024617159739136696, 0.028686456382274628, 0.013995139859616756, 0.008751876652240753, -0.05360960215330124, 0.005150629673153162, 0.028464484959840775, -0.02006569504737854, 0.01971013844013214, -0.00903069507330656, 0.0049301073886454105, -0.039732951670885086, 0.01958361268043518, -0.01710735447704792, -0.008715122938156128, -0.027444642037153244, -0.045636605471372604, -0.016230644658207893, -0.007689315360039473, 0.004964016377925873, 0.023086152970790863, -0.030960772186517715, -0.017511196434497833, 0.017508946359157562, 0.012308965437114239, 0.036347538232803345, -0.036104753613471985, 0.02057069167494774, -0.06677479296922684, 0.015843767672777176, 0.03972778469324112, 0.008362572640180588, 0.013008465990424156, 0.0218375101685524, 0.05123462155461311, 0.037237998098134995, -0.047397151589393616, -0.01331713143736124, 0.01896258443593979, 0.02318154275417328, 0.013233297504484653, -0.00010274563828716055, 0.03036734089255333, 0.05863402411341667, -0.025559687986969948, -0.0702807828783989, 0.06274832785129547, 0.013502432033419609, 0.03054380789399147, -0.0011715894797816873, 0.0731586366891861, 0.07298306375741959, 0.01599588617682457, 0.017122769728302956, 0.022942006587982178, 0.053550492972135544, 0.03545204922556877, -0.0254565067589283, -0.03624371066689491, 0.007050749380141497, 0.024479543790221214, 0.0069893901236355305, 0.07641907036304474, 0.027954036369919777, -0.04978347569704056, -0.048499416559934616, 0.026175249367952347, -0.053246088325977325, -0.006369531154632568, 0.01373845525085926, -0.016637258231639862, 0.0029747062362730503, 0.006880149245262146, -0.027085568755865097, -0.03170565143227577, 0.004314999561756849, 0.03118297830224037, -0.00647348677739501, -0.015699781477451324, -0.008800959214568138, 0.068407341837883, -0.07395963370800018, 0.05365603417158127, -0.06300128996372223, 0.00016824684280436486, 0.04978721961379051, -0.04092198982834816, 0.013888902962207794, -0.017529411241412163, -0.00022511470888275653, -0.022275589406490326, 0.0022102436050772667, -0.0015560530591756105, -0.06968140602111816, 0.02981432154774666, 0.029537910595536232, -0.04981999844312668, 0.03801751136779785, 0.03929967060685158, 0.002642878098413348, -0.01425219140946865, -0.044838715344667435, 0.00026881613302975893, 0.000819014385342598, 0.05737641081213951, 0.023747200146317482, -0.04269960895180702, 0.02443835884332657, -0.04003088176250458, -0.013878822326660156, 0.0014111964264884591, 0.021976543590426445, 0.000894184922799468, -0.03214878961443901, 0.013078520074486732, -0.025322960689663887, 0.0426972433924675, -0.02568516507744789, -0.00892627239227295, -0.046476852148771286, 0.007434534374624491, -0.026818817481398582, 0.04382722079753876, -0.025453317910432816, -0.07096870988607407, 0.0026840853970497847, 0.0001974783226614818, -0.016450878232717514, 0.014493152499198914, -0.03659139201045036, 0.006839111912995577, -0.034792572259902954, 0.04342380538582802, -0.020669758319854736, -0.0083282720297575, 0.011039597913622856, 0.0490712970495224, 0.06589381396770477, -0.0441516675055027, 0.0120013989508152, 0.03135837987065315, 0.07474397867918015, 0.05000367388129234, -0.011166027747094631, -0.02941259555518627, -0.05951002240180969, -0.03895411267876625, 0.019943412393331528, -0.029996614903211594, 0.016473621129989624, -0.054059937596321106, 0.05695193260908127, -0.03689034655690193, -0.030134597793221474, -0.03366268053650856, 0.004237370099872351, -0.02545328624546528, 0.018060702830553055, 0.07041946798563004, -0.0010265508899465203, 0.03950830549001694, -0.008204049430787563, 0.031653519719839096, -0.0324745811522007, 0.016300171613693237, -0.0002400604571448639, 0.001552613452076912, 0.027843115851283073, 0.03249170258641243, -0.03208627179265022, -0.015210086479783058, 0.028409967198967934, 0.011056442745029926, 0.04998243227601051, -0.011697769165039062, -0.009210370481014252, -0.04324391484260559, 0.018376195803284645, -0.01999795064330101, 0.011492065154016018, 0.006458871532231569, -0.0014062433037906885, -0.028631556779146194, -0.001137767219915986, -0.0022170725278556347, -0.044384147971868515, 0.007607600186020136, -0.023685593158006668, -0.00970347411930561, 0.013051184825599194, -0.02207843028008938, -0.0034177089110016823, 0.05896268039941788, 0.010578228160738945, -0.007095945533365011, 0.09447014331817627, -0.06728149950504303, -0.03100600652396679, -0.04769735038280487, -0.012539045885205269, 0.004413246642798185, -0.026712454855442047, -0.05988316982984543, 0.02284596674144268, 0.0184668879956007, -0.00608851807191968, -0.031169796362519264, 0.03559877350926399, 0.010161632671952248, -0.0005741050699725747, -0.06805703043937683, -0.006181912962347269, -0.014459741301834583, -0.02871272899210453, 0.04178832843899727, -0.01961853913962841, 0.00648684985935688, 0.026393244042992592, -0.01851595565676689, -0.04087669029831886, -0.02654305100440979, 0.010665953159332275, -0.04555506631731987, 0.013646162115037441, 0.013056527823209763, -0.006106655113399029, -0.0209667906165123, -0.023183954879641533, -0.024912625551223755, 0.01888100802898407, -0.010019104927778244, 0.055832039564847946, -0.02236410416662693, 0.049948401749134064, 0.04151834174990654, -0.06336497515439987, 0.0516463965177536, -0.002317140344530344, 0.005891643930226564, 0.026106327772140503, -0.01755744218826294, -0.04086390510201454, 0.011844835244119167, -0.023542936891317368, -0.01921321637928486, -0.018042899668216705, 0.02476327493786812, 0.012237481772899628, 0.023002877831459045, -0.0033230462577193975, 0.03426658362150192, -0.02606610208749771, -0.016424987465143204, -0.010743613354861736, -0.06282516568899155, 0.04849473759531975, 0.017997970804572105, 0.03145838901400566, 0.04302573204040527, -0.023861944675445557, 0.020848430693149567, -0.02027020789682865, 0.012162594124674797, -0.016982093453407288, -0.00892874039709568, 0.01467896718531847, -0.02956312894821167, 0.006160545628517866, 0.006832583341747522, -0.039151765406131744, -0.017463281750679016, 0.024073263630270958, -0.010723209008574486, -0.03059629164636135, 0.054908379912376404, 0.045495036989450455, 0.0030138231813907623, 0.0054649002850055695, -0.0562593936920166, -0.009630993939936161, 0.00712979631498456, 0.007003519684076309, -0.035569626837968826, 0.009454507380723953, 0.013237143866717815, 0.09370674192905426, -0.031176118180155754, 0.009702019393444061, -0.06503038853406906, -0.008103957399725914, -0.024587243795394897, -0.0021104984916746616, 0.024806836619973183, -0.03249664604663849, 0.02921249531209469, 0.01215878315269947, 0.10600345581769943, 0.052535053342580795, -0.04637742415070534, -0.0357743538916111, 0.03781311586499214, -0.09308814257383347, -0.0823894590139389, 0.016653969883918762, 0.004950646311044693, -0.07143015414476395, -0.02901274710893631, -0.003204310778528452, 0.008275040425360203, 0.02025175653398037, 0.017590193077921867, 0.06704331934452057, -0.035938896238803864, -0.008315539918839931, 0.008117154240608215, -0.04994657635688782, -0.012737968005239964, -0.006766804028302431, 0.03423875570297241, 0.004355786368250847, 0.09089281409978867, 0.061875663697719574, 0.06283720582723618, 0.014123215340077877, 0.033274825662374496, -0.03136976808309555, -0.03289571776986122, -0.03551872819662094, -0.04162793606519699, 0.014491643756628036, 0.027767982333898544, -0.06864107400178909, 0.03432285785675049, 0.0753704234957695, 0.04026739299297333, 0.012089592404663563, -0.040940869599580765, 0.09528922289609909, 0.0311297420412302, 0.05599405616521835, 0.06508743762969971, 0.06896784901618958, -0.06665359437465668, -0.10725408792495728, -0.039785053580999374, -0.027404310181736946, -0.010957467369735241, 0.021991925314068794, 0.06325056403875351, 0.03633150830864906, 0.011575479060411453, 0.01873941533267498, -0.07930415123701096, -0.010770846158266068, -0.004850882105529308, 0.05379233881831169, 0.02423292025923729, 0.049824588000774384, 0.018953515216708183, 0.024645738303661346, -0.01501565333455801, 0.036385852843523026, 0.06773916631937027, 0.036426570266485214, 0.0017875531921163201, 0.0019138085190206766, -0.0020076751243323088, -0.002681519603356719, 0.05053022503852844, -0.015122161246836185, 0.0015101103344932199, 0.029653584584593773, 0.02287137135863304, -0.0026436932384967804, 0.015997264534235, 0.0037352193612605333, -0.03156919777393341, 0.009552068077027798, 0.007011923473328352, -0.07420868426561356, 0.011779501102864742, 0.02393750101327896, 0.04192321002483368, 0.05225669592618942, -0.04824771359562874, -0.009790699928998947, 0.014108235016465187, 0.030986784026026726, -0.026893142610788345, -0.010455443523824215, -0.07769135385751724, -0.021543007344007492, -0.046388980001211166, -0.057947851717472076, 0.03416390344500542, 0.035749565809965134, -0.010202952660620213, 0.01636057160794735, 0.058288849890232086, 0.018732868134975433, -0.06311053037643433, -0.04722145199775696, -0.07537020742893219, -0.07145368307828903, 0.007055674213916063, 0.025230975821614265, -0.0016510903369635344, -0.029437769204378128, -0.023071106523275375, -0.019704263657331467, 0.01097174920141697, 0.005854874383658171, 0.005293829832226038, -0.004824894014745951, 0.0035727841313928366, -0.08365736156702042, -0.016338275745511055, -0.011280554346740246, 0.0065425001084804535, -0.021101979538798332, 0.08994414657354355, -0.013381128199398518, 0.025378471240401268, 0.012562098912894726, -0.0013823006302118301, -0.00669697904959321, 0.026692133396863937, -0.00303168804384768, -0.01120159961283207, 0.018839292228221893, 0.005001891404390335, 0.024311179295182228, -0.041225988417863846, -0.01889309287071228, 0.04221184924244881, -0.0518832728266716, -0.02654356136918068, 0.0387861393392086, -0.03226847946643829, 0.014893165789544582, 0.019951531663537025, 0.04362013563513756, -0.006231144070625305, -0.02029198780655861, -0.0888989120721817, -0.05636715888977051, 0.0482979454100132, -0.0395311564207077, -0.005862932652235031, -0.030819619074463844, 0.0027785170823335648 ]
<p>I am using two-samples paired permutation tests with Matlab. Now I have three within subject steps, forcing me to use a three-samples paired permutation test. Is there anything like that or any permutation test in general, I could use for that?</p>
g74347
[ -0.014514252543449402, -0.009798182174563408, 0.02374149113893509, -0.04530184343457222, -0.04785770922899246, 0.0040187533013522625, -0.02649497427046299, -0.01587870717048645, -0.024632493034005165, -0.030522093176841736, 0.02974351868033409, 0.005618622526526451, -0.024953002110123634, 0.003406926989555359, -0.07555653899908066, -0.025701291859149933, 0.08253920823335648, -0.024013038724660873, 0.00440673204138875, 0.06442196667194366, -0.00047672606888227165, 0.01964222453534603, 0.015807662159204483, -0.031227651983499527, 0.014018877409398556, -0.0639825239777565, -0.029341120272874832, 0.02988274022936821, -0.038227010518312454, 0.011811559088528156, 0.07187427580356598, -0.020716194063425064, 0.0853622779250145, -0.050666578114032745, -0.03907394036650658, -0.01806296408176422, 0.00512370141223073, 0.004968577064573765, 0.023737752810120583, 0.008063956163823605, -0.019814414903521538, 0.007416802924126387, 0.0261522326618433, 0.000928006018511951, 0.03136516734957695, 0.004968159832060337, 0.01367244403809309, 0.02862369269132614, 0.00925624929368496, 0.010609826073050499, -0.00016953155864030123, 0.005490025505423546, 0.03662853315472603, 0.011261673644185066, 0.04541328176856041, -0.007357903756201267, -0.0017932862974703312, -0.007088194601237774, 0.03361697867512703, 0.03719590604305267, -0.023069191724061966, -0.0222769882529974, -0.03549720346927643, -0.04544256255030632, 0.006578546483069658, 0.017074113711714745, 0.020763203501701355, -0.011674067936837673, 0.018817611038684845, 0.009191538207232952, -0.012211495079100132, 0.0009102040203288198, 0.07608836144208908, -0.0052581606432795525, -0.02452807128429413, -0.04942653700709343, -0.006247657351195812, -0.06482450664043427, 0.012007137760519981, -0.006755081936717033, -0.020808564499020576, -0.016868552193045616, -0.018112152814865112, 0.014047225937247276, 0.018666638061404228, -0.02666020765900612, 0.06487148255109787, 0.007253746967762709, -0.004578773397952318, -0.04339437186717987, -0.012529517523944378, 0.01741507463157177, 0.047831229865550995, 0.05174494907259941, -0.041260894387960434, 0.03151293843984604, -0.021496746689081192, 0.0705408900976181, 0.024394454434514046, 0.010881326161324978, -0.028560219332575798, 0.038931429386138916, 0.03206806629896164, -0.0003975482832174748, -0.017138194292783737, -0.01810842752456665, 0.025275200605392456, 0.010423214174807072, -0.05358845740556717, -0.06394866108894348, -0.036267202347517014, 0.020163418725132942, -0.08263669162988663, -0.009335130453109741, -0.028939489275217056, 0.021535659208893776, 0.008622371591627598, 0.03208014741539955, -0.03233638033270836, -0.014307988807559013, 0.041656628251075745, -0.012738680467009544, -0.019582409411668777, 0.04371015354990959, -0.06223244592547417, 0.0002642907784320414, -0.06142023950815201, 0.037665363401174545, 0.02945760451257229, 0.045817989856004715, 0.028956338763237, -0.03024171106517315, -0.017981503158807755, -0.0009491457021795213, -0.004828468896448612, 0.00676677655428648, -0.015010885894298553, 0.04272513836622238, -0.014797335490584373, -0.028920497745275497, -0.03959336504340172, -0.012112554162740707, -0.025210143998265266, 0.07137767970561981, 0.08216070383787155, -0.026667481288313866, 0.05427511781454086, 0.02130863256752491, -0.010699857957661152, 0.07554636895656586, 0.035610128194093704, -0.008909509517252445, 0.05482722818851471, -0.05786857381463051, 0.016840558499097824, -0.01508226990699768, 0.0487930104136467, 0.0010257083922624588, 0.03093702346086502, 0.06081387773156166, -0.05079445615410805, -0.06277910619974136, 0.018519097939133644, 0.01109737902879715, 0.03625556081533432, 0.041508130729198456, -0.03894718363881111, 0.05647798255085945, 0.03314664587378502, 0.015546077862381935, 0.009106885641813278, -0.03395462408661842, -0.007600195240229368, 0.016938310116529465, -0.04707074537873268, 0.034391503781080246, 0.023428848013281822, -0.031200146302580833, -0.020979098975658417, 0.05231570452451706, 0.001215848489664495, 0.005139253567904234, -0.0845397412776947, -0.012841776013374329, 0.0439242422580719, 0.03329082205891609, -0.02462136372923851, 0.06703920662403107, -0.03470649942755699, 0.03375634923577309, -0.048556581139564514, -0.029672665521502495, -0.0018166240770369768, -0.07421663403511047, -0.03098883293569088, -0.05361907184123993, 0.005898390430957079, -0.029983919113874435, 0.030091941356658936, 0.010956892743706703, 0.05168890580534935, 0.008157940581440926, -0.00814731977880001, 0.020945807918906212, -0.013833687640726566, -0.0037366957403719425, -0.00457906536757946, 0.002851645229384303, 0.0211810152977705, 0.023625126108527184, 0.038462359458208084, 0.05571965500712395, 0.059789370745420456, 0.038936175405979156, 0.019837919622659683, 0.02260085754096508, -0.0034564356319606304, 0.014824516139924526, -0.0006602677167393267, 0.03442000597715378, 0.050360336899757385, -0.05230934917926788, -0.034227389842271805, -0.03693673387169838, 0.06216597184538841, 0.009083347395062447, 0.051185499876737595, -0.03210914507508278, -0.06203370913863182, 0.04776688292622566, 0.0012213302543386817, -0.015081029385328293, 0.041034307330846786, -0.034119825810194016, 0.02775970846414566, 0.04033426567912102, -0.009768336080014706, -0.0036547353956848383, -0.027086766436696053, 0.0157417394220829, -0.04258905351161957, 0.003389101242646575, 0.025159673765301704, -0.005750917363911867, 0.02714737504720688, 0.011568712070584297, 0.027693413197994232, -0.01653311587870121, 0.07955268025398254, 0.04293875768780708, -0.008477305993437767, 0.007649479433894157, -0.01955113746225834, 0.011275050230324268, -0.011690245009958744, 0.022450003772974014, 0.05043955147266388, -0.030093727633357048, 0.014257952570915222, -0.00894966907799244, -0.00044770175009034574, -0.045955296605825424, 0.05393056571483612, 0.02346428483724594, 0.024952813982963562, -0.09050443768501282, 0.022098569199442863, -0.028522012755274773, 0.030343415215611458, 0.028992289677262306, -0.01645827665925026, 0.091432124376297, 0.0379001684486866, 0.019122712314128876, -0.020902005955576897, -0.021858705207705498, 0.003781195729970932, -0.03323343023657799, 0.0425647534430027, 0.014401596039533615, 0.020237814635038376, -0.0018725660629570484, 0.013059644028544426, 0.013837743550539017, 0.04217967763543129, 0.02898002415895462, 0.05003083124756813, -0.014005101285874844, -0.015261901542544365, 0.07858872413635254, -0.03635130822658539, -0.035890884697437286, 0.05078267678618431, -0.03759070113301277, 0.000022429987438954413, -0.05081981047987938, -0.0025228005833923817, -0.04873119667172432, 0.03593830391764641, 0.006704516243189573, 0.03701092302799225, -0.02708848938345909, 0.036692917346954346, 0.02099170722067356, 0.06596504896879196, -0.005829164292663336, -0.01358094997704029, -0.016255080699920654, 0.05525776743888855, 0.03230860456824303, -0.031714629381895065, -0.002201003720983863, -0.05215035006403923, 0.035320576280355453, -0.002185558434575796, -0.007761490065604448, 0.01810443587601185, 0.006802103482186794, -0.042360369116067886, -0.059959299862384796, -0.009906798601150513, -0.020983589813113213, 0.02430734783411026, -0.016375677660107613, -0.014954148791730404, 0.017574522644281387, 0.024929946288466454, 0.0015365325380116701, -0.04694078862667084, -0.02631269209086895, 0.11168716847896576, 0.04557086154818535, -0.008732861839234829, 0.021399017423391342, 0.019751625135540962, 0.005442632827907801, 0.00010039783228421584, -0.0533781424164772, 0.045752838253974915, -0.002218726323917508, 0.00469494191929698, -0.0691894143819809, 0.02986236847937107, -0.05415235459804535, -0.013329880312085152, 0.02163422480225563, 0.044406708329916, 0.03526168689131737, 0.048341717571020126, -0.010447966866195202, 0.014997091144323349, -0.05374020338058472, -0.0021977846045047045, -0.03956688195466995, 0.034854307770729065, 0.03350771218538284, 0.026850080117583275, 0.004199806600809097, 0.00844438187777996, -0.017395582050085068, -0.015625767409801483, -0.03666701540350914, 0.018184935674071312, -0.001891987631097436, 0.04326203465461731, 0.007571037393063307, -0.018986433744430542, 0.07080702483654022, 0.09566161781549454, -0.03217274695634842, -0.02228108048439026, 0.03509502857923508, -0.028838524594902992, -0.049399781972169876, 0.05609740689396858, -0.060217197984457016, 0.01663820818066597, 0.08017236739397049, -0.040753863751888275, 0.030389493331313133, 0.041638150811195374, -0.015685543417930603, -0.00657780934125185, -0.00019664540013764054, -0.01928163878619671, 0.036726951599121094, 0.02377587929368019, 0.04755533114075661, 0.006398835685104132, 0.03363429754972458, 0.012605912052094936, 0.005127298180013895, -0.0567469447851181, 0.031568434089422226, 0.039924491196870804, -0.03120700642466545, -0.05204382166266441, 0.012539250776171684, -0.03584227338433266, 0.05651368573307991, 0.032936032861471176, 0.016535408794879913, -0.0030784555710852146, 0.03726900741457939, -0.07473760098218918, -0.009449968114495277, -0.037509702146053314, 0.003876827424392104, -0.04922109097242355, 0.008179640397429466, -0.009822702035307884, -0.016623467206954956, 0.008696101605892181, 0.029540129005908966, -0.003336002817377448, -0.024007299914956093, -0.018993167206645012, -0.04989006370306015, -0.0009513084078207612, 0.055336300283670425, -0.04861845076084137, 0.029357697814702988, -0.006771717220544815, -0.014295820146799088, -0.016173237934708595, 0.034009408205747604, 0.01965339668095112, -0.007143778260797262, -0.005252983421087265, -0.024654250591993332, -0.044623419642448425, 0.007990967482328415, -0.043959833681583405, 0.0052043236792087555, 0.03111790306866169, -0.05393105372786522, -0.06966783106327057, -0.0015163676580414176, -0.05153608322143555, -0.03321930393576622, -0.016039764508605003, 0.00892168004065752, -0.05226270481944084, 0.011511591263115406, -0.023325355723500252, 0.043230604380369186, -0.011732228100299835, -0.014554168097674847, 0.028187904506921768, -0.035586439073085785, -0.05649145320057869, -0.00932929664850235, -0.053296416997909546, 0.007018249481916428, -0.05221855640411377, 0.08574230223894119, 0.01194166112691164, -0.02724739909172058, 0.0187502633780241, 0.05670043081045151, 0.010001727379858494, 0.014688272029161453, -0.00021271138393785805, -0.008598396554589272, 0.005351988598704338, 0.03194728121161461, -0.07730471342802048, -0.005581099074333906, -0.008315949700772762, -0.010803314857184887, 0.012926080264151096, -0.028291204944252968, 0.020209340378642082, 0.03712185472249985, 0.026809899136424065, -0.01328482385724783, 0.007345522753894329, -0.020396897569298744, -0.08573117107152939, 0.015519383363425732, -0.01028423011302948, -0.0027872598730027676, 0.031270258128643036, -0.03246689960360527, 0.014991789124906063, -0.03498305752873421, -0.04865613579750061, -0.015865623950958252, 0.051803335547447205, -0.0396665520966053, 0.039245594292879105, -0.02635345235466957, 0.03964822366833687, 0.0010097484337165952, -0.022092921659350395, -0.0007430012919940054, 0.011296432465314865, -0.043479207903146744, 0.0070760189555585384, -0.03363238647580147, -0.025887874886393547, 0.01856205426156521, 0.04422522708773613, -0.0383104532957077, 0.03525402024388313, -0.06677919626235962, 0.02410345897078514, -0.03741788864135742, -0.028316983953118324, 0.01608537696301937, -0.040037594735622406, -0.01906186155974865, -0.00893235020339489, 0.0043644653633236885, -0.02624146081507206, 0.043140482157468796, 0.00036837076186202466, -0.013547219336032867, -0.026002047583460808, -0.07047204673290253, 0.06524841487407684, -0.03703559562563896, 0.011150979436933994, 0.03348231688141823, 0.043135691434144974, 0.004628978669643402, -0.06750310957431793, 0.004545215051621199, -0.012948935851454735, 0.013412488624453545, -0.025297099724411964, -0.022930007427930832, 0.005910265725106001, 0.013705561868846416, -0.005686958320438862, -0.049041882157325745, -0.032335180789232254, 0.0581410676240921, 0.012412793934345245, 0.004542785231024027, -0.03442944213747978, -0.017113113775849342, 0.042439334094524384, -0.008267560973763466, -0.039616215974092484, -0.04859049618244171, -0.013698909431695938, -0.018492817878723145, -0.026163490489125252, 0.0035748863592743874, 0.004879137501120567, -0.022802814841270447, -0.022267526015639305, -0.08364452421665192, 0.03018980473279953, 0.03257216513156891, -0.006512054242193699, -0.027083834633231163, 0.050855036824941635, 0.026227064430713654, 0.0011777194449678063, -0.045735206454992294, -0.011129639111459255, -0.004077522084116936, -0.015239128842949867, -0.0868535041809082, -0.0822712779045105, 0.06466935575008392, -0.04922403395175934, -0.01622394472360611, 0.01040557585656643, -0.003788308473303914, -0.031032351776957512, -0.02599841170012951, 0.0024752879980951548, 0.005419460125267506, -0.015939094126224518, 0.008361795917153358, 0.049103595316410065, -0.023424018174409866, -0.027635948732495308, -0.03043205849826336, -0.014059353619813919, 0.049473345279693604, -0.04937836527824402, 0.09238020330667496, 0.0673416331410408, 0.03421424701809883, -0.011532163247466087, -0.03234320878982544, -0.05949437618255615, -0.020600473508238792, -0.032173022627830505, -0.02933933585882187, 0.06424295157194138, 0.022343244403600693, -0.0033219086471945047, 0.05437218397855759, 0.03905736654996872, 0.03506339341402054, -0.006119278259575367, -0.03178953379392624, 0.035767119377851486, -0.04609880968928337, -0.05242034047842026, 0.041007135063409805, 0.026858987286686897, 0.006091222167015076, -0.04337373748421669, -0.004743597004562616, -0.02067226730287075, -0.07978416234254837, 0.006247670389711857, 0.12710987031459808, -0.02216891013085842, -0.005385132506489754, -0.01576399803161621, -0.04911702498793602, 0.032651934772729874, -0.0032146070152521133, 0.0389418825507164, -0.04153725504875183, 0.03510269895195961, -0.03299012407660484, -0.057937875390052795, 0.029675692319869995, -0.009009826928377151, 0.014547448605298996, 0.043303802609443665, -0.020058495923876762, -0.054370712488889694, -0.01948544941842556, -0.021496621891856194, -0.025131046772003174, -0.039708808064460754, 0.02312445268034935, 0.0016168950824066997, -0.009759427048265934, -0.024394897744059563, 0.06848189234733582, -0.07155179977416992, 0.02154793031513691, 0.0163059514015913, -0.054095491766929626, -0.009324885904788971, 0.0167376771569252, 0.08441639691591263, 0.05519996955990791, -0.0025350437499582767, -0.04619062691926956, 0.011084415949881077, 0.03932818025350571, 0.01985359378159046, -0.02281799726188183, 0.01711857132613659, 0.07545304298400879, 0.09627572447061539, 0.012307566590607166, 0.052522748708724976, -0.012896309606730938, -0.07475022971630096, -0.013567633926868439, -0.04156261309981346, -0.04161475598812103, 0.02802373841404915, 0.06938561797142029, 0.008049402385950089, -0.04849505051970482, 0.07025054097175598, -0.043601006269454956, 0.027790281921625137, 0.03906203433871269, -0.01319795660674572, 0.08760124444961548, 0.0035595393273979425, -0.03127552196383476, 0.017634540796279907, 0.02918236330151558, -0.0238619614392519, -0.03406417742371559, -0.03433196619153023, -0.008430691435933113, 0.010365357622504234, -0.012245307676494122, 0.014373128302395344, -0.022040242329239845, -0.07841194421052933, -0.01688937470316887, 0.01745513267815113, -0.03284737467765808, 0.03208278864622116, 0.05650121346116066, 0.03601197525858879, -0.03851073980331421, -0.004297755192965269, 0.04174736887216568, 0.009057189337909222, -0.051248565316200256, 0.01897989958524704, 0.01771647110581398, -0.04052172228693962, 0.030165281146764755, -0.05431818589568138, -0.013232387602329254, 0.008245005272328854, -0.027454935014247894, -0.009613849222660065, -0.006770384032279253, -0.0025580727960914373, -0.024501612409949303, -0.02594340406358242, 0.04116811230778694, -0.004017648287117481, 0.03435138985514641, -0.03096310794353485, -0.03657333552837372, -0.0687490701675415, 0.01197371818125248, -0.04848605394363403, -0.012152074836194515, -0.026441380381584167, -0.015294160693883896, 0.03331313654780388, 0.025489971041679382, -0.0675002783536911, -0.060820940881967545, 0.008112343959510326, 0.05894869938492775, 0.00460416916757822, 0.022615797817707062, 0.013517098501324654, -0.07909256219863892, -0.002934857504442334, 0.03767358139157295, 0.009583755396306515, -0.0016699067782610655, 0.01706782914698124, -0.005343200173228979, 0.0003012040106114, -0.017645729705691338, 0.04572100192308426, 0.04010141268372536, -0.014288275502622128, -0.07300729304552078, 0.02270396798849106, -0.03903031721711159, -0.02353532798588276, 0.05566685274243355, 0.029615331441164017, -0.034225139766931534, -0.026613997295498848, -0.0071773468516767025, 0.0351923331618309, 0.011441914364695549, -0.05921827629208565, 0.041734419763088226, 0.054543476551771164, -0.028625166043639183, 0.05889714136719704, 0.003577945753931999, -0.03468811884522438, -0.01293481606990099, -0.06454823166131973, 0.018151817843317986, 0.04622327536344528, -0.0351804718375206, 0.007740403991192579, -0.04152572900056839 ]
<p>I'm looking to generate a set of 5 random variables and enforce a dependence structure between them and onto a dependent variable Y. I understand how to generate correlated random variables for multivariate normal, but not when mixing different types. Below is a little more than I need, but I'm hoping someone can give me a general way of solving this problem...</p> <ul> <li>X_1 and X_2 need to be highly correlated Bernoulli variables. </li> <li>X3 needs to take one of 5 categorical values, call them "A"..."E". </li> <li>X4 needs to be normal, and negatively correlated with X1, X2. </li> <li>X5 needs to approximate test scores from 0 to 100 with a high skew, so gamma probably. X5 needs to be positively correlated with X1, X2, X4.</li> </ul> <p>Each of these variables must impact a "success/occurrence" Bernoulli distributed variable Y.</p> <p>How would I begin? I would like to enforce correlation both between the values of X, and also between each X and Y. (The categorical correlations seem particularly confusing to me.)</p>
g47462
[ -0.012576228007674217, -0.009178927168250084, -0.01705283485352993, -0.05000011622905731, -0.034702714532613754, -0.024154216051101685, -0.007129919249564409, -0.004173075780272484, -0.023223813623189926, -0.04119221866130829, -0.022987231612205505, -0.003571408335119486, -0.030123671516776085, 0.03351181745529175, -0.01400007214397192, -0.004685088060796261, 0.0341787151992321, 0.00829450972378254, 0.01202095951884985, 0.03647920861840248, -0.002200298709794879, 0.04756590723991394, -0.030776236206293106, 0.0014417326310649514, 0.00484862457960844, -0.061358742415905, 0.024536361917853355, -0.02566877193748951, -0.05990193784236908, -0.028020614758133888, 0.00710343150421977, -0.0031903013586997986, 0.03871281072497368, -0.009237571619451046, 0.00452046561986208, 0.01812015101313591, -0.028604762628674507, 0.0006370225455611944, -0.0004808702797163278, 0.044698767364025116, -0.038971271365880966, 0.07961078733205795, 0.03555437549948692, 0.011765888892114162, -0.041536588221788406, 0.0008083435241132975, -0.009367530234158039, 0.013865371234714985, -0.0010354507248848677, -0.017940860241651535, -0.008750790730118752, 0.04200971871614456, 0.008868294768035412, -0.05797453969717026, 0.040753912180662155, 0.011865442618727684, 0.01592298224568367, 0.0017751464620232582, -0.022656727582216263, 0.03469615802168846, 0.017708338797092438, -0.044043075293302536, -0.09026308357715607, -0.021777857095003128, 0.010030806995928288, 0.0672706589102745, 0.01146142277866602, -0.02588442713022232, -0.02460075542330742, -0.006842841859906912, -0.04259767010807991, -0.03192770108580589, 0.009115274995565414, 0.0052915308624506, -0.0008440093952231109, 0.01620285026729107, 0.03529739007353783, 0.00895986519753933, 0.02068990468978882, 0.0034789631608873606, 0.012397101148962975, 0.024938000366091728, 0.07880228012800217, 0.031439490616321564, 0.029093431308865547, -0.030546048656105995, 0.0076302411034703255, 0.00013402930926531553, -0.030498474836349487, -0.023453300818800926, 0.056161411106586456, 0.009252349846065044, -0.01997176557779312, 0.06873361021280289, -0.050573647022247314, 0.02734510600566864, -0.08413802087306976, 0.055020108819007874, 0.020975805819034576, -0.008445216342806816, -0.02414405345916748, 0.014936607331037521, 0.03042694181203842, -0.049017079174518585, -0.07236013561487198, -0.015331326983869076, 0.01967533864080906, 0.01134952437132597, 0.018782759085297585, 0.013028783723711967, -0.08976263552904129, 0.010357438586652279, -0.054735176265239716, -0.033453572541475296, 0.01437344029545784, -0.04494732245802879, 0.0244904812425375, 0.020239390432834625, -0.005768760573118925, -0.0018984805792570114, 0.032259806990623474, 0.053550176322460175, -0.01126166433095932, 0.003278204472735524, -0.026235036551952362, -0.02277943678200245, -0.06610766053199768, 0.015606668777763844, 0.06352860480546951, -0.033726513385772705, 0.09098312258720398, -0.06076288968324661, -0.015614834614098072, 0.05964619293808937, -0.038120336830616, -0.002677635056897998, -0.011878760531544685, 0.0014042238472029567, -0.009966706857085228, 0.04219553619623184, -0.0525408498942852, 0.02045259438455105, -0.03361696004867554, 0.04297074303030968, -0.04655486345291138, 0.039358846843242645, 0.029240451753139496, -0.07615463435649872, -0.009724462404847145, 0.01738092117011547, 0.037354808300733566, 0.0027191026601940393, -0.04449259862303734, 0.013748884201049805, 0.0004942747764289379, 0.05490146577358246, 0.009716835804283619, -0.010230380110442638, -0.029648082330822945, 0.0003284724662080407, 0.03569643199443817, -0.016396623104810715, 0.0014360814820975065, -0.033963412046432495, 0.02858317829668522, -0.024188010022044182, 0.030337760224938393, 0.02056911401450634, -0.05191059038043022, 0.052452147006988525, -0.022962471470236778, 0.008589747361838818, -0.03817228600382805, -0.018143201246857643, 0.026768816635012627, 0.10410737246274948, -0.02122553065419197, 0.013726935721933842, 0.026533113792538643, 0.03229159489274025, -0.04737912118434906, -0.01239427737891674, 0.008680419065058231, -0.002642962848767638, 0.03881383687257767, -0.010264038108289242, 0.017168818041682243, 0.003498415695503354, -0.017351821064949036, -0.0034272170159965754, 0.07129697501659393, -0.019583720713853836, -0.03185600787401199, -0.06982289254665375, -0.022010769695043564, -0.021175142377614975, 0.017593761906027794, -0.03001660481095314, 0.05650888383388519, -0.016312267631292343, -0.022403884679079056, 0.01524316892027855, 0.003225855529308319, 0.06508997082710266, -0.007340865675359964, 0.004446044564247131, -0.05621928349137306, 0.020148230716586113, -0.062301237136125565, 0.00021640385966748, -0.031077781692147255, -0.011837473139166832, -0.05052075535058975, -0.008054441772401333, 0.03944273665547371, -0.081357441842556, -0.037466466426849365, 0.00848311185836792, -0.029279610142111778, 0.02241518162190914, -0.010093889199197292, -0.020734498277306557, 0.029804347082972527, 0.018483201041817665, -0.019688643515110016, 0.024611465632915497, 0.0023813354782760143, 0.009622635319828987, 0.027747681364417076, -0.01993630826473236, 0.002487714169546962, 0.06300480663776398, -0.014733916148543358, -0.06350585073232651, 0.005455964244902134, 0.015814103186130524, -0.010060538537800312, -0.01664922572672367, -0.048918407410383224, 0.015016434714198112, 0.00022261332196649164, 0.04482052102684975, 0.009344876743853092, 0.019969813525676727, 0.024627480655908585, -0.026944821700453758, 0.049990251660346985, -0.022252876311540604, -0.04449320212006569, 0.054412320256233215, -0.030749214813113213, -0.023514680564403534, -0.014167091809213161, -0.04922717064619064, -0.011980830691754818, -0.059109579771757126, 0.037830401211977005, 0.05270287021994591, -0.01673705317080021, -0.043439172208309174, -0.01885368488729, -0.026339972391724586, -0.0022414117120206356, 0.03254394605755806, 0.03199915215373039, -0.04200107976794243, 0.0706479623913765, -0.06443922966718674, -0.04947422444820404, -0.0021457315888255835, 0.03428969904780388, 0.046320840716362, 0.026615211740136147, -0.01471996121108532, -0.026874955743551254, 0.003641893621534109, -0.07628515362739563, 0.05186672508716583, -0.0009542459738440812, -0.008163154125213623, 0.11243708431720734, -0.008677694946527481, 0.05759730935096741, -0.007651664782315493, 0.03409212827682495, 0.007893349044024944, 0.052515268325805664, -0.059548310935497284, 0.03611220046877861, 0.03711956366896629, -0.02415871061384678, -0.007137566339224577, -0.028241848573088646, 0.022423962131142616, 0.04390600323677063, -0.04919745400547981, -0.019187211990356445, -0.021821314468979836, -0.044545792043209076, 0.004851338919252157, -0.0569157637655735, -0.0014766926178708673, 0.03075363300740719, -0.0018019800772890449, -0.03425665572285652, -0.027491513639688492, -0.04291548207402229, 0.026967747136950493, -0.07141637057065964, -0.0022956549655646086, -0.03042854182422161, -0.038500845432281494, 0.0006529585807584226, 0.0049919444136321545, -0.020496664568781853, -0.007085764780640602, 0.09277810156345367, 0.05402538925409317, 0.034367240965366364, -0.08265569061040878, 0.010785781778395176, -0.05710812285542488, 0.03453469276428223, 0.03685612604022026, -0.01870003342628479, 0.05369944870471954, -0.04191712290048599, 0.02874452993273735, -0.06639190018177032, -0.01840212568640709, 0.05770186334848404, 0.02100287191569805, 0.03752078488469124, 0.01946457289159298, -0.014341115951538086, -0.03742567077279091, -0.012225622311234474, -0.03466137871146202, -0.05757232755422592, 0.020136285573244095, 0.016209552064538002, -0.022222358733415604, 0.0033684903755784035, -0.008863445371389389, -0.026200922206044197, 0.006078830920159817, 0.016212934628129005, 0.042702775448560715, 0.0022718284744769335, -0.011682017706334591, -0.019801665097475052, 0.0004096613556612283, 0.06462683528661728, -0.0196706410497427, -0.002473516156896949, 0.02124135196208954, 0.029784569516777992, -0.025003431364893913, -0.02939395233988762, 0.0007739878492429852, -0.00760337058454752, 0.011991655454039574, -0.06021812558174133, 0.008997326716780663, 0.026773937046527863, 0.07541614770889282, 0.049426183104515076, 0.054033126682043076, 0.034370556473731995, 0.010444543324410915, 0.0422736220061779, 0.009722557850182056, 0.01310340128839016, -0.05131230875849724, -0.007770020514726639, -0.0003003136080224067, 0.06065509095788002, 0.009550381451845169, -0.010757998563349247, 0.028003262355923653, 0.017177585512399673, 0.007983467541635036, 0.018209179863333702, 0.05558038875460625, 0.016451681032776833, -0.03683903440833092, -0.030379431322216988, 0.06882978230714798, 0.07986333966255188, -0.015023496933281422, -0.0007751089287921786, -0.05926813930273056, -0.05590808019042015, 0.0666247233748436, 0.048852138221263885, -0.018905913457274437, 0.02614382840692997, 0.05427669733762741, 0.03013000078499317, 0.04501551389694214, 0.004923918284475803, -0.024936813861131668, -0.0019156710477545857, -0.03871714323759079, -0.04551829770207405, -0.012986434623599052, 0.0009597752941772342, 0.001628543483093381, 0.016359196975827217, -0.04295872151851654, 0.02114379033446312, -0.005659807473421097, 0.011816177517175674, 0.02097810059785843, 0.05386865884065628, -0.03341434895992279, 0.06846491247415543, 0.044791143387556076, 0.021670548245310783, 0.06887462735176086, 0.024756023660302162, 0.07745298743247986, -0.025834567844867706, -0.0012346766889095306, 0.049179062247276306, -0.0020801995415240526, 0.00368337775580585, -0.015053282491862774, -0.000832948659081012, -0.012668182142078876, 0.005294333677738905, 0.048276111483573914, 0.0008066624868661165, 0.004426974803209305, 0.021835103631019592, -0.05594582110643387, -0.061576806008815765, -0.01671282760798931, -0.011075818911194801, 0.009807854890823364, 0.005214723292738199, -0.05121733248233795, 0.012060246430337429, 0.007504661101847887, 0.013393588364124298, 0.060218386352062225, -0.03381198272109032, 0.023922119289636612, 0.05030133202672005, 0.0019422726472839713, -0.025739192962646484, 0.010238442569971085, -0.024011116474866867, -0.031219422817230225, 0.008250219747424126, 0.006915291305631399, 0.042363595217466354, 0.01347169280052185, 0.028867147862911224, 0.013908425346016884, -0.0008833468309603631, -0.01773722469806671, 0.0012651620199903846, -0.03860438987612724, 0.006681225262582302, -0.03218838945031166, -0.020047442987561226, -0.023648127913475037, -0.00045311576104722917, 0.027878237888216972, -0.005055249202996492, 0.0019823017064481974, 0.030289234593510628, 0.008897213265299797, 0.005845534149557352, 0.05144686996936798, -0.02766633965075016, -0.019819293171167374, -0.014258990995585918, -0.010575835593044758, 0.024739762768149376, -0.014306465163826942, -0.01799340359866619, -0.00864449143409729, -0.010303827002644539, -0.022395659238100052, 0.020356476306915283, -0.08529386669397354, 0.031153228133916855, -0.006755123846232891, -0.05026673898100853, 0.0009251896408386528, 0.08188918977975845, 0.043006088584661484, 0.0007020548800937831, -0.043123576790094376, 0.04241718724370003, -0.08237998187541962, 0.03929610177874565, -0.07472635805606842, -0.00621678214520216, 0.022643443197011948, 0.04703371226787567, 0.01324367243796587, -0.055989064276218414, -0.021054619923233986, 0.10111991316080093, -0.03591397404670715, 0.027576318010687828, 0.05814871937036514, -0.05625484138727188, 0.04507605358958244, 0.07368817180395126, 0.0026007879059761763, -0.043950725346803665, 0.036598678678274155, -0.07195373624563217, 0.020769450813531876, 0.026541488245129585, -0.06012821942567825, 0.047027844935655594, -0.034721970558166504, -0.036894917488098145, 0.021049566566944122, -0.00791851431131363, -0.0009232403826899827, -0.057146105915308, -0.033938802778720856, 0.0010903155198320746, -0.019606824964284897, -0.01709093153476715, 0.008662084117531776, 0.025827711448073387, -0.048822544515132904, -0.007576374337077141, -0.062436364591121674, 0.01012677326798439, 0.004262120928615332, -0.009006491862237453, 0.08513325452804565, 0.029842933639883995, -0.021305182948708534, 0.010745345614850521, -0.003143477952107787, 0.03712533041834831, -0.032097551971673965, 0.03194955736398697, -0.009009935893118382, -0.04019279032945633, -0.02397303096950054, -0.04237145557999611, 0.014850540086627007, 0.06749607622623444, 0.0543883815407753, -0.027724971994757652, -0.0028295903466641903, 0.025826504454016685, -0.01589326374232769, -0.013606737367808819, -0.009266426786780357, 0.0225343257188797, -0.05053315311670303, -0.013312938623130322, 0.018206382170319557, -0.02805200405418873, -0.00895628146827221, -0.07782542705535889, -0.021097837015986443, -0.018414175137877464, 0.07525742053985596, 0.04001350328326225, 0.01918470859527588, 0.012127316556870937, 0.04204774275422096, -0.0013571239542216063, -0.001415122183971107, -0.00031992828007787466, -0.01793084666132927, 0.06738357990980148, 0.028941180557012558, 0.00928610097616911, -0.04291997104883194, -0.021241843700408936, -0.037320032715797424, -0.015561887994408607, 0.02708354778587818, 0.0257565900683403, 0.037561092525720596, -0.06575091928243637, -0.08449335396289825, -0.006620979867875576, 0.033530477434396744, -0.0016432944685220718, -0.014260311610996723, 0.0063934726640582085, -0.053281672298908234, 0.006517084781080484, -0.008884923532605171, 0.007982195354998112, -0.0311751551926136, -0.005734564736485481, 0.015295707620680332, 0.019508956000208855, -0.005548600573092699, 0.012985500507056713, 0.008470006287097931, -0.04778340831398964, -0.030576767399907112, -0.034164734184741974, 0.01520230807363987, -0.016433682292699814, -0.03683597594499588, -0.019231341779232025, 0.05985846742987633, -0.007635736837983131, 0.03643399477005005, -0.05474875867366791, -0.010796056129038334, 0.01068140659481287, 0.027943147346377373, -0.03564653545618057, -0.021929746493697166, 0.023843642324209213, 0.07265985012054443, -0.022125110030174255, 0.08636756986379623, -0.018006395548582077, -0.0692322850227356, 0.04114110767841339, -0.021518394351005554, 0.03048074059188366, 0.00027149144443683326, 0.05338020250201225, -0.00023441029770765454, -0.025130465626716614, 0.027248205617070198, -0.0917813703417778, 0.07850442081689835, 0.0760531798005104, 0.06196087226271629, 0.03973972797393799, 0.05786836892366409, -0.01058085635304451, 0.030486982315778732, 0.08185268938541412, -0.011065990664064884, 0.07227543741464615, 0.009049708023667336, -0.042335640639066696, 0.03833186626434326, 0.01622856967151165, -0.021347926929593086, 0.005680389236658812, -0.008714637719094753, -0.01217135600745678, 0.012037932872772217, 0.0736406147480011, 0.018022961914539337, 0.0015089360531419516, 0.04055052250623703, -0.027760066092014313, 0.007366490550339222, -0.037019021809101105, -0.05204841494560242, -0.059531427919864655, 0.07757208496332169, -0.00123748613987118, 0.001415648264810443, 0.03225291892886162, 0.0031835311092436314, -0.020599789917469025, -0.033625487238168716, -0.012563900090754032, 0.03440507501363754, 0.0032604793086647987, -0.06873419135808945, -0.04234602674841881, 0.050089046359062195, -0.006646040827035904, -0.006544262170791626, -0.0219041146337986, -0.013302654959261417, 0.0006299933302216232, -0.03643162548542023, -0.039146456867456436, 0.02961692586541176, 0.03373847156763077, -0.0001519181241746992, 0.06308367103338242, 0.02430080808699131, -0.08955451846122742, -0.029369188472628593, 0.04261947050690651, 0.012911158613860607, -0.037416037172079086, -0.002228938741609454, 0.05189395323395729, -0.010353496298193932, 0.03164583072066307, 0.05320088937878609, -0.03769795969128609, 0.029837852343916893, -0.05755405128002167, -0.03332863748073578, -0.007352935615926981, 0.02340513840317726, -0.04033103957772255, -0.06229720264673233, -0.03633004054427147, -0.036142122000455856, -0.0524805523455143, 0.0021019955165684223, -0.06603537499904633, 0.004138788674026728, -0.008020877838134766, 0.030200786888599396, -0.005407773423939943, 0.020308110862970352, -0.005421353969722986, 0.031649399548769, -0.04725094512104988, 0.019024280831217766, 0.02270449325442314, -0.01559426635503769, -0.012468385510146618, -0.05516158416867256, 0.03653555363416672, 0.033530689775943756, -0.03062260150909424, 0.015151076950132847, -0.04888293892145157, -0.0381610207259655, -0.029773147776722908, 0.008604729548096657, 0.00945365708321333, 0.043158628046512604, -0.05996822193264961, 0.008519908413290977, 0.009027301333844662, -0.010780934244394302, -0.026324082165956497, -0.023135803639888763, -0.01521666906774044, -0.028684129938483238, 0.01266049686819315, -0.01716267503798008, 0.001894078915938735, 0.07470931112766266, -0.00047818891471251845, -0.020491737872362137, -0.04949409142136574, -0.009448797442018986, 0.0013892247807234526, 0.043142110109329224, 0.020686645060777664, -0.030071301385760307, -0.039700545370578766, 0.040632639080286026, 0.09330105781555176, -0.004818830639123917, -0.030285701155662537, 0.028735371306538582, -0.04023326188325882, 0.02898101694881916, -0.045316681265830994, 0.002722566481679678, -0.03830632194876671, 0.022460386157035828 ]
<p>Let's say I have a sample of "events" done by a certain number of subjects, and some (although not most) of these subjects have underwent more than one event. I'd like to fit a logit model to these data to find out which characteristics contribute to a subject, over the course of an arbitrary period of time, undergoing another event within an arbitrary interval after a preceding event -- let's say three days. </p> <p>The way I see it, I can set my data up in one of two ways:</p> <ul> <li><p>take all of the events underwent by each subject, and define the dependent/indicator variable to be yes/no to "did this subject have another event within 3 days of a preceding event, over the course of the last year (for example)?" In this case, each row of the data for the model would correspond to every subject and be an aggregate of their event history.</p></li> <li><p>partition each subject's event history into pairs and define the dependent variable to be yes/no to "did this subject have another event within 3 days of this particular event?" In this case, each row would correspond to every event in the data. However, there are three outcomes: 1) the subject has another event within 3 days; 2) subject has another event within greater than 3 days; and 3) subject doesn't have any further events. Could I collapse 2) and 3) into one outcome, or would I be better off considering using a multinomial logit model instead?</p></li> </ul> <p>I'm leaning towards going with the latter option, but I'm worried that those subjects who undergo relatively more events will be over-represented in the final model (how would I deal with that, if I should?). However, I do think I gain significantly more information that way. Anyway, with that said, I'd love to hear insights on the pros/cons of each approach to setting up these particular data for a logit model.</p>
g74348
[ -0.0020157909020781517, 0.010301618836820126, -0.019370809197425842, -0.06503299623727798, -0.029938291758298874, -0.02610788866877556, -0.0223670843988657, -0.0047358302399516106, -0.006887027528136969, 0.0005021968390792608, -0.007906741462647915, -0.035594310611486435, 0.07428789883852005, 0.00005116446845931932, -0.007326341234147549, -0.015462127514183521, 0.060676220804452896, -0.004952621180564165, -0.024491192772984505, 0.01118504162877798, 0.018101071938872337, 0.08489003032445908, -0.005725546274334192, 0.036276061087846756, -0.011878972873091698, -0.048367153853178024, 0.053052809089422226, 0.03991110995411873, -0.013928790576756, -0.0022608106955885887, 0.012720972299575806, 0.018681956455111504, -0.0022490492556244135, -0.06965874880552292, -0.009466615505516529, 0.0024867146275937557, -0.018523508682847023, 0.02592884935438633, -0.04020039737224579, 0.027657577767968178, -0.033908743411302567, 0.011605951003730297, 0.0550205297768116, 0.014187741093337536, -0.05658040940761566, -0.06313241273164749, 0.02778453752398491, -0.042391277849674225, -0.010228999890387058, -0.007873952388763428, 0.018017901107668877, 0.023353181779384613, -0.02869332768023014, -0.023572010919451714, 0.04437682777643204, 0.05359712988138199, -0.01881786808371544, 0.032048776745796204, 0.007855989970266819, 0.013724150136113167, 0.04923534765839577, -0.03969331085681915, -0.0384061373770237, -0.03583764284849167, 0.04603748023509979, 0.021114977076649666, -0.06254757195711136, 0.021488862112164497, 0.08922740072011948, -0.02512500248849392, 0.003941540140658617, 0.04544803500175476, 0.011776367202401161, -0.07082683593034744, 0.008312410674989223, 0.022307533770799637, -0.06027718260884285, -0.012292363680899143, 0.016088664531707764, 0.0459098294377327, 0.0007392308907583356, 0.03765133395791054, 0.0511665977537632, 0.0009517937432974577, 0.007564786821603775, 0.013606197200715542, 0.02226012945175171, -0.02534649893641472, 0.01830066554248333, 0.02106303535401821, -0.0060244663618505, 0.02819294109940529, 0.05730026960372925, 0.02117026038467884, -0.08483576029539108, -0.02379739284515381, -0.047393493354320526, 0.021765543147921562, 0.03726326674222946, 0.07573933899402618, -0.027665546163916588, 0.005042040254920721, -0.015042741782963276, -0.024427929893136024, -0.03433391824364662, -0.06457293778657913, -0.04623014107346535, 0.03982025012373924, 0.02607467956840992, -0.007921681739389896, -0.04383482784032822, 0.0714196264743805, -0.016524549573659897, -0.011206582188606262, -0.012619114480912685, -0.003322687465697527, 0.004138049203902483, -0.008522359654307365, -0.06028950959444046, -0.010852297767996788, 0.004610230680555105, -0.03440810367465019, 0.028594456613063812, 0.04345869645476341, -0.04319089278578758, 0.001687859301455319, -0.00735359825193882, 0.11766080558300018, 0.01324535347521305, 0.024065814912319183, 0.030662307515740395, -0.018512003123760223, -0.015355641022324562, 0.06785232573747635, 0.011358501389622688, -0.008694028481841087, -0.03665892779827118, 0.0702214390039444, -0.023167071864008904, 0.052826907485723495, -0.030608415603637695, -0.018605198711156845, -0.06511063873767853, -0.02399863861501217, 0.0013903690269216895, 0.06428951770067215, 0.003752464195713401, 0.019255105406045914, -0.014036290347576141, 0.0967322587966919, -0.05294033885002136, -0.006343729328364134, -0.04205476492643356, -0.022826839238405228, -0.011333522386848927, 0.018552910536527634, -0.010890448465943336, -0.0766139030456543, -0.06003547087311745, 0.017288673669099808, 0.020547540858387947, -0.06541818380355835, 0.03488341346383095, 0.01303799543529749, -0.013893553987145424, 0.009395139291882515, 0.03520960360765457, -0.030886175110936165, -0.0009356778464280069, -0.009680818766355515, 0.06176367029547691, -0.021719614043831825, 0.00237621134147048, -0.02569694072008133, 0.03333938121795654, 0.0591668076813221, 0.012098018079996109, -0.0006293421029113233, 0.07905757427215576, -0.0059695192612707615, -0.04167503863573074, -0.0034590577706694603, -0.04524249583482742, -0.03106214664876461, 0.050362251698970795, -0.10880012810230255, -0.013478653505444527, 0.03965224325656891, -0.045053981244564056, 0.045509614050388336, -0.012972581200301647, -0.013812449760735035, 0.05919969081878662, -0.030973907560110092, -0.057722751051187515, -0.03957097604870796, 0.04737100377678871, -0.020748259499669075, -0.04762048274278641, -0.024486372247338295, 0.028738105669617653, -0.0020487152505666018, -0.00014904073032084852, 0.046584602445364, -0.04350951686501503, 0.04300544783473015, 0.02396239899098873, 0.03519854322075844, -0.022590594366192818, -0.026950249448418617, 0.029383596032857895, -0.0006163007928989828, 0.009306849911808968, 0.0009457088308408856, 0.00026929390151053667, -0.037966594099998474, -0.0005982511793263257, 0.009729682467877865, 0.00607090862467885, -0.024042289704084396, 0.007208691444247961, -0.024986902251839638, 0.029298266395926476, -0.02704095095396042, 0.007827739231288433, 0.0398612916469574, 0.0462968684732914, 0.00008983372390503064, -0.01879211701452732, 0.014696257188916206, -0.021240290254354477, -0.003444807371124625, 0.012975719757378101, -0.07769163697957993, 0.07206197082996368, 0.024124013260006905, -0.031075380742549896, -0.027397893369197845, 0.009903641417622566, 0.006628008559346199, 0.005484391935169697, -0.008281010203063488, -0.035101518034935, -0.019533399492502213, 0.015873081982135773, -0.05084628611803055, -0.025737198069691658, 0.030080486088991165, 0.020990552380681038, 0.06699066609144211, -0.08962418138980865, 0.038701627403497696, -0.05684103071689606, -0.08093837648630142, 0.02391785755753517, -0.04263834282755852, 0.003856613067910075, 0.061120495200157166, -0.04748012498021126, 0.04157835617661476, 0.0019214039202779531, 0.00024094240507110953, -0.001208845293149352, 0.03547833859920502, 0.030953124165534973, -0.017818938940763474, 0.04630080983042717, -0.11459607630968094, -0.02180160954594612, 0.04992171749472618, -0.023929471150040627, -0.03093520738184452, -0.041616812348365784, 0.05936111882328987, 0.03156488016247749, 0.06361708045005798, -0.0826437920331955, 0.002576508093625307, -0.018393635749816895, -0.05907450616359711, 0.048593174666166306, -0.025941137224435806, -0.016445260494947433, 0.0005212404066696763, 0.034469857811927795, 0.03156980499625206, 0.055748794227838516, 0.02618134766817093, 0.04138355329632759, 0.004192760214209557, 0.0017359512858092785, 0.014574485830962658, 0.009081929922103882, 0.0010723610175773501, -0.003593689063563943, -0.07642710953950882, -0.020440874621272087, -0.007596057374030352, 0.04609741270542145, -0.027320807799696922, -0.044108692556619644, -0.004326156340539455, 0.01486004889011383, 0.00892744492739439, 0.0336136594414711, -0.01721632108092308, -0.07747936993837357, 0.02128995582461357, -0.006289416924118996, -0.01314996276050806, -0.05405699834227562, -0.02266569435596466, -0.014166191220283508, -0.0033257869072258472, -0.03712460398674011, -0.038724835962057114, 0.017606843262910843, 0.049333903938531876, -0.0379873551428318, -0.032946258783340454, 0.02379697933793068, -0.03354628384113312, 0.06399127095937729, 0.07658908516168594, -0.004574969410896301, 0.021488633006811142, -0.03761807829141617, -0.021578004583716393, -0.05030247941613197, 0.03411811217665672, -0.021612992510199547, 0.03713349997997284, 0.046873074024915695, 0.021406488493084908, 0.01553848385810852, -0.010463897138834, -0.03913566470146179, -0.026473039761185646, 0.018552780151367188, 0.047527801245450974, 0.015895867720246315, -0.020448336377739906, 0.0016994173638522625, -0.0254979245364666, -0.0177883580327034, -0.038602448999881744, -0.034254204481840134, 0.04375655576586723, 0.046865250915288925, 0.005051095504313707, -0.01206297893077135, 0.006050014868378639, -0.040677111595869064, -0.02728108875453472, 0.04139280691742897, -0.010274567641317844, 0.00663384422659874, 0.03129056468605995, -0.050625789910554886, 0.010393709875643253, 0.02070426382124424, -0.061510831117630005, -0.03576638177037239, -0.02435750886797905, -0.03876824676990509, 0.01235391478985548, 0.04080236703157425, 0.037403833121061325, 0.09281687438488007, 0.020218225196003914, 0.07728633284568787, 0.0032582920975983143, -0.03627363219857216, -0.026029003784060478, 0.043434519320726395, -0.08308775722980499, 0.06732700765132904, -0.006101404316723347, -0.020831789821386337, 0.036331284791231155, -0.006044299807399511, -0.01755659095942974, 0.029122749343514442, 0.05581554397940636, -0.03892262279987335, 0.016787691041827202, 0.04912993311882019, 0.024557922035455704, -0.036374282091856, -0.00017654322437010705, -0.029785457998514175, -0.026810724288225174, -0.09796208143234253, -0.00195406679995358, 0.027248723432421684, -0.002555285580456257, -0.0569676011800766, -0.018535705283284187, -0.0443686842918396, 0.0571109764277935, -0.009816194884479046, 0.0071344985626637936, 0.002711597830057144, 0.010912231169641018, -0.03055260330438614, 0.02229449339210987, -0.057282064110040665, -0.046679701656103134, -0.0428883396089077, 0.008013184182345867, -0.008463023230433464, -0.011008749715983868, -0.025312500074505806, 0.006913370918482542, 0.026185225695371628, -0.028154877945780754, 0.09122880548238754, 0.01915687881410122, -0.011397654190659523, 0.02221590466797352, 0.04175286367535591, 0.011722247116267681, -0.05103746056556702, -0.022872980684041977, -0.0033415034413337708, -0.012582759372889996, 0.005248663946986198, -0.012294786982238293, -0.04781926050782204, 0.03172161430120468, 0.009702019393444061, 0.04826602712273598, 0.024381892755627632, -0.0008070419426076114, 0.044270288199186325, -0.03910769149661064, -0.025214875116944313, 0.04194660112261772, 0.01569206453859806, 0.0032909116707742214, -0.020608844235539436, -0.050834089517593384, -0.051177624613046646, -0.016238348558545113, 0.0148550346493721, 0.0002933102077804506, -0.02075495943427086, -0.03168809786438942, 0.033737875521183014, 0.030105557292699814, -0.0024489210918545723, 0.021279696375131607, 0.01720859855413437, -0.02277887426316738, 0.0205466877669096, -0.000558270956389606, 0.03704587742686272, 0.042698077857494354, 0.018055161461234093, 0.06284409761428833, -0.0022448147647082806, 0.0034708362072706223, -0.0386313758790493, -0.022017542272806168, -0.0071699549444019794, -0.03637982904911041, -0.023515578359365463, -0.009386942721903324, -0.002071861643344164, -0.004302456509321928, 0.02452540211379528, -0.0008971627685241401, 0.04085712879896164, -0.02058829367160797, -0.00969269871711731, -0.023653099313378334, -0.02854340523481369, 0.017971158027648926, 0.021758340299129486, -0.031600985676050186, 0.03295358642935753, -0.017727084457874298, -0.006083398126065731, 0.007588629145175219, 0.020053116604685783, 0.0255103949457407, 0.020225215703248978, -0.08188570290803909, 0.013206533156335354, 0.02435908652842045, -0.00926143117249012, -0.012619572691619396, 0.0941440612077713, 0.04856332018971443, -0.06439220905303955, -0.033429499715566635, 0.06877686828374863, -0.04482429847121239, -0.017606113106012344, -0.01880194991827011, -0.04649383947253227, 0.0899491161108017, 0.03990554064512253, -0.020685099065303802, -0.06356033682823181, -0.018506577238440514, 0.09192502498626709, -0.0032386360689997673, 0.010646811686456203, 0.030108295381069183, -0.011470915749669075, 0.029560543596744537, -0.05556146427989006, -0.0453486405313015, -0.02834869548678398, 0.0003760741092264652, 0.008635830134153366, 0.06242915987968445, 0.0054527693428099155, -0.01638537459075451, -0.018221119418740273, -0.03620051220059395, 0.0059571582823991776, 0.03914908692240715, 0.06254872679710388, -0.05363396555185318, -0.06815765053033829, -0.03960694000124931, -0.007066375110298395, 0.00858286488801241, 0.027166161686182022, 0.0034785752650350332, -0.012441219761967659, -0.008645179681479931, 0.030194178223609924, 0.029660310596227646, -0.05073638632893562, 0.0010762576712295413, 0.012083051726222038, -0.04258941113948822, -0.051206618547439575, -0.04061487317085266, 0.01313598733395338, -0.025608260184526443, -0.006981042679399252, -0.03844691812992096, -0.015757836401462555, -0.013281860388815403, -0.03592105954885483, -0.004656085278838873, 0.009142491035163403, -0.04122482240200043, -0.010390851646661758, -0.010744093917310238, -0.020568734034895897, -0.000809014483820647, 0.033733051270246506, -0.005430815275758505, 0.0006048535578884184, -0.006074727512896061, -0.03927099332213402, 0.011823387816548347, 0.03800541162490845, 0.02791641652584076, 0.005800626240670681, 0.002488610800355673, -0.05268179252743721, -0.027004756033420563, -0.03313986957073212, 0.04459192976355553, 0.08577463775873184, -0.04841874539852142, 0.0738525316119194, 0.013221190311014652, -0.013734708540141582, -0.01612825132906437, 0.004671646747738123, -0.012641651555895805, 0.05735855549573898, -0.009060132317245007, -0.008931330405175686, -0.07163162529468536, -0.00006897905404912308, 0.07297040522098541, -0.0074440231546759605, 0.059239961206912994, 0.002332522766664624, -0.04309997707605362, -0.047945670783519745, -0.0033138981088995934, -0.01740516722202301, -0.006880412343889475, 0.02838508039712906, -0.03851988539099693, -0.010867998003959656, 0.034112125635147095, -0.0339924581348896, 0.005468685645610094, 0.011678536422550678, -0.020331062376499176, 0.025061750784516335, -0.02062675915658474, 0.061641570180654526, -0.0076668779365718365, 0.02615383081138134, 0.0676392987370491, -0.06995334476232529, -0.025557996705174446, 0.07085727900266647, -0.03812585026025772, -0.010972189716994762, 0.03512599691748619, -0.010829608887434006, 0.06826543062925339, 0.015766574069857597, 0.01968345418572426, -0.029148371890187263, -0.005457751918584108, -0.011532376520335674, 0.06370764225721359, 0.04198635742068291, -0.000268519768724218, 0.0037552525755017996, 0.0134497731924057, -0.03015008196234703, 0.06457635015249252, -0.025645924732089043, 0.009328508749604225, -0.005392902530729771, 0.04945942014455795, 0.016694961115717888, -0.00778661435469985, -0.012233982793986797, 0.005371807608753443, -0.03961305692791939, 0.03969919681549072, -0.040537331253290176, 0.041084714233875275, -0.019775670021772385, 0.03482229262590408, 0.021396169438958168, 0.02816907875239849, 0.028706643730401993, 0.012469255365431309, 0.046112485229969025, 0.01646827533841133, 0.06439696252346039, -0.002587309805676341, -0.016848469153046608, 0.010127917863428593, -0.00789373368024826, 0.03104223497211933, -0.02089083008468151, 0.016501465812325478, 0.009585081599652767, 0.05869641900062561, 0.017466293647885323, 0.04464789479970932, 0.07440423965454102, 0.04523804038763046, -0.01220010407269001, -0.03549819067120552, -0.006299798842519522, -0.05259186774492264, -0.01042945496737957, 0.051985468715429306, 0.016558228060603142, -0.04858352243900299, 0.01004417147487402, -0.043448060750961304, -0.004568183328956366, -0.05827055126428604, -0.011059051379561424, -0.05424581468105316, -0.006490555126219988, -0.021982602775096893, -0.010750815272331238, 0.027188250795006752, -0.02203183062374592, 0.016682064160704613, -0.006483863573521376, -0.009213542565703392, 0.0007420067558996379, -0.04459777846932411, -0.03526094928383827, 0.031224863603711128, 0.019199620932340622, 0.024019384756684303, 0.024988528341054916, 0.017158063128590584, -0.061406221240758896, 0.006195205729454756, 0.030584007501602173, -0.021967465057969093, -0.012459548190236092, 0.01750386878848076, -0.03246663138270378, 0.021120287477970123, 0.05546613037586212, 0.06975346803665161, 0.016697581857442856, 0.03291183337569237, -0.022433951497077942, -0.038684941828250885, 0.017102770507335663, -0.01040329597890377, -0.022521551698446274, -0.03393757343292236, 0.038978565484285355, -0.03202652558684349, -0.05989359691739082, 0.051512233912944794, -0.05781364068388939, 0.0013598804362118244, 0.0026592726353555918, -0.04417368769645691, -0.08201583474874496, -0.030594728887081146, 0.0049720266833901405, 0.05941928178071976, -0.05129857733845711, -0.026324398815631866, -0.02122052013874054, -0.011457109823822975, 0.04497108608484268, -0.05746997520327568, -0.015589884482324123, 0.023970307782292366, -0.02978537417948246, 0.02075590379536152, 0.02427588775753975, -0.04284840077161789, -0.05619177967309952, 0.015620599500834942, 0.04592655226588249, 0.004130968824028969, -0.009291118010878563, 0.029923247173428535, -0.0327884666621685, 0.0329311229288578, -0.007489869371056557, 0.0129475649446249, -0.027261782437562943, 0.03680451214313507, -0.04815126955509186, 0.018538733944296837, -0.01108370628207922, 0.05055816471576691, -0.0019923073705285788, -0.011204407550394535, -0.08745821565389633, -0.01879732497036457, -0.0043867286294698715, 0.04854614660143852, 0.036339253187179565, 0.0343596413731575, 0.003708858275786042, -0.00687951548025012, 0.045869022607803345, -0.016682026907801628, -0.034291867166757584, 0.051384296268224716, -0.011564907617866993, 0.00641060434281826, 0.018611455336213112, 0.03569509834051132, 0.034182433038949966, 0.016695402562618256 ]
<p>I am trying to use the <code>glmnet</code> MATLAB package to train my elastic net model on some huge data. My features are of size 13200, and I have around 6000 samples of these. I directly tried to use <code>lassoglm</code> in MATLAB with these features and corresponding target taking cross validation to just 3 folds and alpha = 0.5. It's already 6 hours and it hasn't finished. I have to do it for several others as well.</p> <p>Any suggestions what I should do?</p>
g37201
[ 0.03086078353226185, -0.007666889578104019, 0.009088830091059208, -0.005806380417197943, 0.02858818508684635, 0.022275837138295174, 0.015804171562194824, 0.010905178263783455, -0.04018901288509369, -0.0029345997609198093, 0.022036761045455933, -0.005367708392441273, 0.07033097743988037, -0.0006021412555128336, -0.029540738090872765, 0.02413076162338257, 0.1248723641037941, -0.013854220509529114, 0.004285605624318123, -0.016986442729830742, 0.01238161325454712, -0.007812321651726961, 0.029730023816227913, -0.1321694254875183, -0.0185246579349041, 0.00718764727935195, -0.0007291622459888458, 0.03758276253938675, -0.03180136904120445, 0.05785592272877693, -0.018528832122683525, -0.031117964535951614, -0.015301764942705631, -0.0586317777633667, -0.05462022125720978, 0.035631418228149414, -0.007835769094526768, 0.013915305957198143, -0.023366698995232582, 0.044595394283533096, 0.026402810588479042, -0.0005301395431160927, 0.00828630942851305, 0.024151479825377464, 0.0033576395362615585, 0.052724290639162064, 0.02122492529451847, -0.010830195620656013, 0.016249854117631912, 0.009555351920425892, 0.020537998527288437, 0.03977803885936737, 0.03341119736433029, -0.02512953244149685, 0.02933788299560547, 0.04159858077764511, -0.04777956381440163, 0.06692197173833847, 0.049188531935214996, -0.0479685477912426, 0.02354518696665764, -0.04667345806956291, -0.026400916278362274, -0.03018958680331707, -0.06808063387870789, 0.002505764365196228, -0.04059864953160286, -0.05405412241816521, 0.03140779212117195, 0.01170677226036787, -0.003912405110895634, 0.00020234247494954616, 0.027497656643390656, -0.003248713444918394, -0.03010009415447712, -0.0661652460694313, -0.05144580826163292, 0.04087983816862106, -0.015219233930110931, 0.08042562007904053, 0.026354961097240448, 0.019355086609721184, -0.08658291399478912, -0.021588467061519623, 0.03761100769042969, -0.008212742395699024, -0.03305685147643089, 0.016359813511371613, -0.031340692192316055, 0.025719720870256424, 0.03315921127796173, -0.01542077586054802, -0.009535427205264568, 0.07371274381875992, -0.010887245647609234, 0.006011228077113628, -0.04067891463637352, 0.04130898788571358, 0.03143347054719925, 0.009091511368751526, 0.056113503873348236, 0.016507906839251518, -0.010829415172338486, -0.011064790189266205, -0.07143644243478775, -0.004112699069082737, -0.01621127501130104, 0.013027975335717201, -0.0339425653219223, -0.028660502284765244, -0.05486278608441353, 0.006352624390274286, -0.02200423739850521, 0.026462538167834282, -0.07410647720098495, -0.047977153211832047, 0.07150863111019135, -0.005012891720980406, -0.02113507129251957, -0.012366142123937607, 0.04308589920401573, -0.0672110766172409, 0.07752670347690582, -0.061302393674850464, 0.009039172902703285, -0.029231693595647812, 0.015943285077810287, 0.06351857632398605, -0.00006088287045713514, 0.023170849308371544, 0.03202349320054054, 0.03472492843866348, -0.04081404581665993, 0.006560239940881729, 0.04385954141616821, 0.009380405768752098, -0.039633575826883316, 0.0018219458870589733, -0.02780132368206978, 0.054084327071905136, -0.01808466762304306, -0.007849594578146935, 0.028404153883457184, 0.00041435289313085377, 0.052969228476285934, -0.0129594961181283, -0.01596052385866642, -0.02389547973871231, 0.023168284446001053, -0.01812678948044777, -0.006341703236103058, 0.059609219431877136, 0.020570071414113045, -0.06448373943567276, 0.015352522023022175, -0.02802244760096073, 0.021984867751598358, -0.03317906707525253, 0.007131971884518862, 0.0355304479598999, 0.04355722293257713, -0.017985163256525993, 0.010759628377854824, -0.01508509274572134, 0.02669479139149189, 0.023109065368771553, 0.0073282141238451, 0.03261147066950798, 0.03563891723752022, -0.0020989696495234966, -0.017156710848212242, 0.016471529379487038, 0.03399026021361351, 0.03407951071858406, -0.028228290379047394, 0.06886475533246994, 0.022823426872491837, -0.006444672588258982, 0.05851378291845322, -0.010975396260619164, 0.006109106354415417, 0.027325566858053207, 0.02713444083929062, 0.032763075083494186, 0.0023855508770793676, 0.01703067123889923, -0.029726797714829445, 0.017456570640206337, -0.05547814071178436, -0.024324556812644005, 0.03801544010639191, 0.05027969926595688, -0.02396363951265812, -0.016767049208283424, 0.07149109244346619, -0.017084060236811638, 0.08152510225772858, -0.0024967938661575317, -0.02732272259891033, 0.005202614236623049, -0.010059580206871033, -0.004471052438020706, 0.01732730306684971, 0.09342259168624878, -0.07390857487916946, -0.04240906238555908, 0.011360624805092812, -0.0183480866253376, -0.016863981261849403, -0.009537659585475922, 0.0021319459192454815, 0.014179326593875885, -0.06698592752218246, 0.015164922922849655, 0.004628234542906284, -0.004686852917075157, -0.01165188942104578, 0.012788413092494011, -0.032939113676548004, 0.05947086960077286, -0.030448254197835922, -0.033498119562864304, 0.04364773631095886, -0.036840565502643585, 0.029816171154379845, -0.04365626350045204, 0.02609250508248806, 0.024511469528079033, 0.045873235911130905, -0.056417644023895264, 0.042575653642416, 0.031307004392147064, -0.009127830155193806, -0.04435787722468376, 0.0014164471067488194, 0.002343215513974428, -0.04036734253168106, 0.024200433865189552, -0.013494224287569523, 0.002060017781332135, 0.007488732226192951, 0.04989612102508545, 0.0007505847024731338, -0.036012232303619385, 0.010067651979625225, 0.008459667675197124, 0.018733134493231773, 0.008252479135990143, 0.04939579218626022, 0.046041905879974365, -0.04028604179620743, 0.02058619074523449, -0.007064729928970337, -0.0035028366837650537, -0.02503059431910515, 0.013153254054486752, 0.06405654549598694, -0.023005962371826172, -0.016751619055867195, 0.0011153564555570483, 0.0015816474333405495, 0.02810079976916313, 0.019969824701547623, 0.029555991291999817, -0.022083308547735214, -0.06515577435493469, 0.040749430656433105, -0.03620181605219841, -0.012852728366851807, -0.029797088354825974, -0.0010168597800657153, -0.0015685224207118154, 0.058651287108659744, 0.0363759770989418, 0.04071798548102379, 0.02814618870615959, -0.02692210115492344, 0.007716420106589794, 0.029159193858504295, 0.00469061778858304, -0.052517976611852646, -0.07897692173719406, 0.03559710457921028, -0.037755336612463, 0.0630979910492897, -0.048873335123062134, 0.026760511100292206, 0.01282966136932373, -0.007652003318071365, -0.019870588555932045, -0.016241731122136116, -0.005078302696347237, -0.030799012631177902, -0.04509938508272171, -0.0335095040500164, -0.02635374292731285, -0.0795975774526596, 0.014314621686935425, 0.01789102517068386, 0.014843837358057499, -0.017483269795775414, -0.013993018306791782, -0.00006391263741534203, 0.030928967520594597, 0.0005370993749238551, -0.0600813627243042, -0.0034633248578757048, 0.0025601587258279324, -0.04517176374793053, -0.00015231940778903663, 0.02548927441239357, 0.01913047954440117, -0.012281927280128002, -0.04350416734814644, -0.013881265185773373, -0.012111451476812363, -0.020374450832605362, -0.019446909427642822, 0.013889784924685955, -0.016335980966687202, 0.01261728536337614, -0.1276978701353073, -0.01413741521537304, -0.02429211139678955, -0.05425272509455681, 0.02091260999441147, -0.012291965074837208, 0.02422146685421467, 0.049052055925130844, -0.015199299901723862, 0.011499890126287937, 0.023634031414985657, -0.005697874817997217, 0.012871153652668, 0.02729092538356781, -0.05090317130088806, -0.047407567501068115, 0.0104212686419487, 0.057773757725954056, 0.010203464888036251, -0.09173236042261124, -0.044719431549310684, 0.006409040652215481, -0.0571475625038147, 0.022295229136943817, 0.01591312326490879, -0.0461566224694252, -0.05358527600765228, 0.010542074218392372, -0.01720387302339077, -0.03910330310463905, -0.0004325273330323398, 0.012098295614123344, -0.022755876183509827, 0.030076153576374054, -0.04487936943769455, 0.012872145511209965, -0.029176898300647736, 0.02011139877140522, -0.027409464120864868, 0.03796164691448212, 0.023489847779273987, 0.024825692176818848, -0.021730558946728706, -0.017872678115963936, 0.01095631904900074, 0.0015570097602903843, 0.07761435955762863, 0.11048489063978195, 0.04826882854104042, 0.03708486258983612, -0.007396651431918144, 0.006605235859751701, -0.003057749243453145, 0.03864750638604164, -0.02560843527317047, 0.06375811994075775, 0.012690773233771324, 0.018292564898729324, 0.019147980958223343, 0.0624886192381382, 0.005834902171045542, -0.021515270695090294, -0.03703393414616585, -0.048302967101335526, -0.008274919353425503, 0.020090529695153236, 0.06507039070129395, 0.0004934744792990386, 0.04068130627274513, 0.02458985149860382, -0.050955358892679214, -0.027411920949816704, -0.005055582150816917, -0.009911622852087021, -0.01782490685582161, 0.013122939504683018, 0.009357405826449394, -0.019723063334822655, 0.02257312461733818, -0.06713621318340302, 0.04125721752643585, -0.020310446619987488, 0.010487692430615425, 0.00759888906031847, -0.0002878726809285581, -0.019285093992948532, 0.04801773652434349, -0.02383766695857048, -0.02260233461856842, -0.008583358488976955, -0.09698988497257233, 0.020507005974650383, -0.015739532187581062, 0.06297683715820312, -0.07306007295846939, 0.014634629711508751, -0.02275392971932888, -0.06065506115555763, -0.051377441734075546, 0.025835713371634483, 0.045344434678554535, -0.04933127388358116, -0.011278524994850159, -0.014150960370898247, 0.06701140850782394, 0.048743125051259995, -0.0031891940161585808, -0.0240861214697361, 0.015087345615029335, -0.025688165798783302, 0.047429028898477554, -0.05192356929183006, 0.049033503979444504, -0.06233646720647812, 0.0637192353606224, 0.0021391205955296755, -0.033765360713005066, 0.013877958990633488, -0.00791889801621437, -0.020196862518787384, -0.022384071722626686, -0.003931668121367693, -0.02892446145415306, -0.05496698245406151, 0.04800449311733246, 0.0007530791917815804, -0.05733510106801987, -0.017279982566833496, 0.041487935930490494, 0.034835219383239746, -0.03529476001858711, -0.03680134192109108, 0.055913202464580536, 0.04501543194055557, 0.07262303680181503, 0.02580946683883667, 0.07789158821105957, 0.03826416656374931, 0.033214785158634186, -0.008498180657625198, 0.027108164504170418, -0.09616350382566452, 0.0036235039588063955, -0.0024618729948997498, -0.05704127252101898, -0.011215610429644585, 0.015277771279215813, 0.05374409258365631, -0.011361293494701385, 0.0175359845161438, 0.01703724078834057, 0.005011949688196182, 0.015055563300848007, -0.03950471058487892, 0.021747438237071037, 0.008388224989175797, 0.050595950335264206, 0.037739042192697525, 0.03842255100607872, -0.010141922160983086, -0.03922311216592789, -0.04241431504487991, -0.08302074670791626, 0.024207985028624535, 0.016679152846336365, 0.01786484383046627, -0.0056938366033136845, 0.033988822251558304, -0.02645796909928322, 0.04142335429787636, -0.015755321830511093, 0.010101310908794403, 0.02842962183058262, -0.014087473042309284, -0.005833884701132774, 0.0030784548725932837, -0.008410099893808365, -0.030681200325489044, -0.053461261093616486, 0.0020626261830329895, 0.03115052916109562, -0.07927956432104111, -0.042251985520124435, 0.001049922197125852, 0.031291306018829346, 0.015316177159547806, 0.03554923087358475, 0.0034816081169992685, 0.004009169060736895, -0.05016273260116577, -0.016107255592942238, -0.00031025512726046145, -0.029427941888570786, 0.0005194457480683923, -0.048858921974897385, 0.013733886182308197, -0.0008523454307578504, -0.020749781280755997, -0.03862062469124794, 0.06490674614906311, 0.0323609784245491, 0.05201127007603645, 0.02090022712945938, 0.01499576773494482, 0.028836747631430626, -0.0015971929533407092, -0.017078658565878868, 0.007865065708756447, -0.01286979392170906, -0.008029686287045479, -0.020979508757591248, -0.06801584362983704, -0.006815009284764528, 0.001060117268934846, -0.046481579542160034, 0.0001047956247930415, -0.04779193550348282, -0.05199320241808891, -0.08491798490285873, 0.022483093664050102, -0.003104196395725012, 0.0036451914347708225, 0.001730363816022873, -0.07055442780256271, -0.04770733416080475, 0.03761407732963562, 0.013817518018186092, 0.062465850263834, -0.05171094462275505, 0.008573897182941437, -0.016361720860004425, 0.013124174438416958, -0.018281063064932823, -0.005676891654729843, -0.011140287853777409, -0.039591044187545776, -0.02777424268424511, -0.017986014485359192, 0.018173430114984512, 0.01864837110042572, -0.04997076466679573, 0.0008714621653780341, 0.023230092599987984, -0.024196894839406013, -0.026224959641695023, -0.06118254363536835, 0.03099595382809639, -0.011960788629949093, -0.03895711526274681, 0.011821489781141281, 0.00903336238116026, -0.0001235662493854761, 0.03190279379487038, -0.02290540747344494, 0.017685553058981895, 0.06220197677612305, 0.01308146957308054, 0.035586774349212646, -0.04842948913574219, -0.03608422353863716, -0.025368420407176018, 0.04380641505122185, 0.005454081576317549, -0.05500839650630951, -0.00907552894204855, -0.03368784114718437, -0.035202186554670334, -0.017534753307700157, 0.0012701019877567887, -0.03465130180120468, -0.03666286543011665, 0.022317852824926376, 0.011919330805540085, -0.018104301765561104, -0.025370044633746147, -0.01776188425719738, 0.018297234550118446, -0.015066297724843025, 0.0013527428964152932, -0.028236525133252144, 0.06867143511772156, 0.05565327778458595, -0.0028750295750796795, -0.043920278549194336, 0.043987423181533813, -0.021447867155075073, -0.05153517797589302, 0.041243866086006165, 0.002725841710343957, 0.020899763330817223, 0.012763270176947117, 0.00022395103587768972, 0.06466000527143478, 0.0027500770520418882, -0.05253792554140091, -0.011154064908623695, -0.0023013155441731215, 0.030165940523147583, -0.018480749800801277, 0.015965847298502922, -0.011196941137313843, 0.03390607610344887, 0.050043873488903046, 0.006573539227247238, 0.007533024065196514, -0.035997889935970306, 0.0011878586374223232, 0.07009363919496536, -0.04377225413918495, -0.012668476440012455, 0.03134862333536148, -0.07248998433351517, 0.012352925725281239, -0.07262751460075378, 0.09524383395910263, 0.0046067191287875175, 0.03986819460988045, 0.04603472724556923, 0.06940697133541107, 0.001534753362648189, 0.02950521931052208, 0.023035435006022453, -0.04573873430490494, 0.020155329257249832, 0.07276948541402817, -0.0024796409998089075, 0.03143659979104996, -0.020519321784377098, 0.0492127425968647, 0.030175011605024338, 0.0463760606944561, -0.005786325316876173, -0.038148101419210434, 0.0014037122018635273, 0.07279889285564423, 0.03617976978421211, -0.02856271341443062, 0.0019019736209884286, 0.04054490104317665, -0.07877154648303986, -0.060428187251091, -0.005469546187669039, -0.0666913092136383, 0.03602367267012596, 0.02543707564473152, -0.020705074071884155, -0.0448116809129715, 0.008837450295686722, -0.03259696066379547, -0.018095189705491066, -0.008078056387603283, 0.007152507081627846, 0.014909887686371803, 0.05650854855775833, -0.05800042301416397, -0.006870499812066555, -0.048202093690633774, -0.04097014665603638, 0.026344679296016693, -0.05234980955719948, 0.03493884205818176, 0.023707080632448196, 0.05260210484266281, 0.04380442202091217, 0.044284429401159286, -0.017735743895173073, 0.02401084080338478, 0.07428216934204102, 0.018386397510766983, -0.005605385638773441, 0.014064819552004337, 0.004418170545250177, -0.02976864203810692, 0.011619864962995052, 0.01450345478951931, -0.08173273503780365, -0.006325975060462952, 0.041893403977155685, -0.003970823250710964, 0.01902114227414131, 0.02692406252026558, -0.034979239106178284, -0.03414740040898323, -0.03526635095477104, 0.05907707288861275, -0.08095469325780869, 0.023301389068365097, 0.01607760600745678, -0.03791406750679016, -0.032219987362623215, 0.04799537733197212, -0.034493159502744675, 0.037310823798179626, 0.031046757474541664, 0.08595581352710724, -0.026068728417158127, -0.015600570477545261, -0.040972352027893066, -0.028654634952545166, 0.004186785314232111, 0.009760506451129913, -0.02082211896777153, 0.04725715517997742, -0.0010201510740444064, -0.03923392295837402, -0.03832576796412468, -0.013490353710949421, 0.0013297839323058724, 0.0003231510054320097, -0.010659290477633476, -0.08374977111816406, -0.033285949379205704, -0.06648040562868118, -0.005509555339813232, 0.009596123360097408, 0.037955231964588165, -0.010158821009099483, -0.012651005759835243, 0.013265128247439861, 0.0036107152700424194, 0.034019116312265396, -0.03740724176168442, 0.014441903680562973, 0.027737654745578766, 0.05221030116081238, -0.04542844370007515, 0.05608740076422691, -0.018318604677915573, -0.011137169785797596, 0.0035835413727909327, -0.02095773257315159, 0.024884214624762535, 0.04082715883851051, -0.07532998919487, 0.010023802518844604, 0.04260938987135887, 0.002487677615135908, -0.010331226512789726, 0.007875504903495312, -0.05113440379500389, -0.008804971352219582, 0.010739396326243877, 0.02087893895804882, 0.006034138612449169, -0.0017343999352306128, 0.013054581359028816, -0.004421492572873831 ]
<p>I am very new to Bayesian inference and can't figure out what may be an elementary problem. Also, please forgive me if I am screwing up the notation -- this is my first foray into Bayesian statistics.</p> <p><strong>Set-up:</strong> At time $i=0$ I start with a random variable $X_0\sim \mathcal{N}(\mu_0,\sigma^2_0)$. Over time I observe the Brownian motion process such that for $j&gt;i$, $X_j-X_i\sim \mathcal{N}(0,(j-i)D)$. Starting at time 0, I collect a sequence of $n$ observations $\{Y_i\}_{i=0}^{n-1}$ of $\{X_i\}_{i=0}^{n-1}$, which are subject to Gaussian noise such that $p(y_i|x_i)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi N_0}}e^{-\frac{(y_i-x_i)^2}{2N_0}}$. Noise is independent from observation to observation. I am interested in the mean and variance (of the estimator) of $X_{n-1}$ given $\{Y_i\}_{i=0}^{n-1}$ in terms of $n$, $\mu_0$, $\sigma^2_0$, $D$, and $N_0$.</p> <p><strong>What I've done:</strong> Using Bayes rule and the properties of Gaussian distribution, I've found that for the first observation ($n=0$):</p> <p>$$p(x_0|y_0)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi S}}e^{-\frac{(x_0-M)^2}{2S}}$$</p> <p>where $M=\frac{y_0\sigma^2_0+\mu_0N_0}{\sigma^2_0+N_0}$ and $S=\frac{\sigma^2_0N_0}{\sigma^2_0+N_0}$. I am not completely sure if the above is correct, but I am pretty confident that it is, as it looks like the mean squared error of the estimate of $X_0$ has decreased with the observation. However, I am having trouble extending this to $n&gt;0$ and would appreciate any guidance.</p> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong> I've misspecified the Brownian motion process. I think it's correct now.</p>
g48959
[ -0.009476523846387863, 0.01157767791301012, 0.0013952582376077771, -0.002561658388003707, 0.010645211674273014, 0.0015291408635675907, 0.026288172230124474, -0.022154292091727257, -0.02498696930706501, -0.016747163608670235, -0.014492740854620934, 0.052198030054569244, 0.02973756194114685, 0.052093204110860825, -0.020317599177360535, -0.009435650892555714, 0.00157667335588485, 0.024122780188918114, 0.028018394485116005, -0.012052120640873909, -0.01444503664970398, 0.016188282519578934, 0.0061937677673995495, 0.017110485583543777, 0.011132858693599701, -0.05448789522051811, -0.021345511078834534, 0.07606347650289536, -0.031787898391485214, -0.015281306579709053, 0.054881658405065536, -0.06662949174642563, 0.06768164038658142, -0.002734843408688903, 0.011288083158433437, -0.008800875395536423, 0.05442492291331291, -0.026850666850805283, 0.028105314821004868, -0.013579507358372211, -0.0038775017019361258, -0.009569980204105377, 0.06062103435397148, -0.016392560675740242, -0.010893253609538078, 0.01448185183107853, -0.015110019594430923, -0.005573994945734739, 0.03198652341961861, 0.015918202698230743, 0.026681410148739815, 0.04139276221394539, 0.08597748726606369, -0.0008764113299548626, 0.0018031348008662462, 0.02778562717139721, -0.03889462351799011, -0.02021338790655136, 0.014100602827966213, 0.018646247684955597, 0.027321558445692062, -0.03282516449689865, -0.06166082248091698, -0.016805201768875122, -0.01867098920047283, 0.06005018949508667, -0.026030469685792923, -0.0029384831432253122, 0.025425590574741364, 0.015992600470781326, -0.006302706431597471, -0.015356563031673431, -0.028282582759857178, -0.023199182003736496, -0.010533996857702732, -0.031694650650024414, 0.01744326762855053, 0.019046923145651817, -0.013944311067461967, 0.005161447916179895, -0.031744927167892456, 0.016594350337982178, -0.01843123883008957, 0.0027887849137187004, 0.031047053635120392, -0.04767636954784393, 0.01155862770974636, 0.021244507282972336, 0.03572160750627518, 0.0042790514416992664, 0.033386535942554474, -0.036436401307582855, 0.014215043745934963, 0.0549280121922493, 0.026779795065522194, -0.027608901262283325, -0.11577601730823517, 0.02547764591872692, 0.01751304604113102, 0.03619953617453575, -0.0036577226128429174, -0.04383888095617294, 0.015287219546735287, -0.0876239612698555, -0.019286133348941803, 0.041134800761938095, 0.010240753181278706, 0.011632801964879036, 0.0019654056522995234, -0.008816632442176342, -0.013830031268298626, 0.03863059729337692, 0.014281896874308586, -0.08102835714817047, -0.043384850025177, 0.0073945592157542706, -0.01335922721773386, 0.05228573456406593, -0.0012500484008342028, 0.013013268820941448, -0.002440857235342264, 0.0236496739089489, -0.02091349847614765, 0.05222642794251442, -0.04976266250014305, -0.004604749381542206, -0.022424042224884033, 0.05090713128447533, 0.0013703268487006426, 0.05101984739303589, -0.031880445778369904, -0.020917829126119614, 0.05835915356874466, 0.02160339243710041, 0.01944090984761715, 0.01394300814718008, -0.016885828226804733, 0.0014607018092647195, 0.058981429785490036, 0.040603820234537125, -0.022130688652396202, 0.023253021761775017, 0.04521667957305908, -0.06808881461620331, -0.03543971851468086, 0.05924440175294876, 0.02384062483906746, -0.04662557318806648, 0.0015160535695031285, -0.0349324531853199, -0.05724962428212166, 0.06069237366318703, -0.04977916553616524, 0.045178573578596115, -0.019045811146497726, -0.0022720005363225937, -0.02996094711124897, 0.015454170294106007, 0.01236330159008503, -0.016864297911524773, 0.061195582151412964, -0.004383285995572805, 0.02986931800842285, 0.0036199765745550394, -0.07508507370948792, -0.020664023235440254, 0.04151926562190056, -0.08152133971452713, 0.022585438564419746, -0.011926710605621338, 0.0006710305460728705, -0.07156647741794586, 0.011342954821884632, 0.03607100248336792, -0.026994148269295692, 0.022862428799271584, 0.026101188734173775, -0.04360290616750717, 0.029906755313277245, 0.034484997391700745, -0.03127068653702736, -0.022819818928837776, -0.023454446345567703, -0.05742814391851425, -0.007707704324275255, -0.04076635465025902, -0.012090005911886692, -0.028250275179743767, -0.045034199953079224, -0.04526643827557564, -0.02624066360294819, -0.033899977803230286, -0.007699525915086269, 0.02222321182489395, 0.0007324052276089787, 0.021538110449910164, 0.025172732770442963, -0.12024272978305817, 0.011996963061392307, 0.010125604458153248, 0.009019728749990463, 0.0038152080960571766, 0.0033689250703901052, 0.016799291595816612, 0.0038374278228729963, -0.004690734203904867, 0.03802870213985443, -0.02706250175833702, -0.05761890113353729, 0.05071844905614853, -0.021227063611149788, 0.020875288173556328, -0.05655834823846817, 0.040952809154987335, 0.010793152265250683, -0.05135422199964523, 0.023633569478988647, 0.04637642949819565, 0.06524054706096649, -0.01947927474975586, -0.0028548389673233032, -0.007867062464356422, 0.015843050554394722, -0.019015567377209663, 0.03757122904062271, 0.020226817578077316, 0.00020640295406337827, -0.01488236803561449, 0.024070119485259056, 0.0705312117934227, -0.08634258806705475, 0.009213383309543133, 0.0062098694033920765, 0.0172655638307333, 0.03913002461194992, 0.06584861874580383, -0.020684566348791122, 0.004483812488615513, 0.034796420484781265, 0.025520196184515953, -0.06704279780387878, 0.0024445177987217903, -0.00997971836477518, -0.051445070654153824, 0.031384989619255066, 0.034992605447769165, 0.011830375529825687, 0.0012066777562722564, 0.013784491457045078, -0.01804308593273163, 0.002089626155793667, 0.03631142899394035, 0.007185007911175489, -0.036307886242866516, 0.0023221480660140514, -0.03064057044684887, 0.027708319947123528, 0.0399334691464901, -0.017032887786626816, -0.022587643936276436, -0.031026368960738182, -0.039484262466430664, 0.030499842017889023, 0.02243071049451828, 0.041847191751003265, -0.020372016355395317, -0.03458831459283829, -0.010145055130124092, 0.028164412826299667, -0.03455286845564842, 0.0028496291488409042, 0.006310734432190657, -0.0022876134607940912, 0.07407283782958984, -0.010054836980998516, 0.022564304992556572, -0.026951096951961517, 0.04415787383913994, 0.020796028897166252, 0.04666033759713173, -0.019517894834280014, -0.012807182036340237, -0.03704893961548805, 0.03089687041938305, 0.02129046805202961, -0.05859929695725441, 0.05496708303689957, -0.012564822100102901, -0.005453862249851227, 0.00589949544519186, 0.044981714338064194, 0.004046301357448101, 0.04785899817943573, 0.024328075349330902, -0.0020124181173741817, 0.017752911895513535, -0.04365203529596329, -0.05217922106385231, 0.05906197801232338, -0.005278423428535461, -0.013492402620613575, -0.0066908723674714565, -0.01834540255367756, -0.00678708590567112, 0.05593964457511902, -0.02883746661245823, 0.022245675325393677, -0.033958759158849716, -0.0423431470990181, 0.026043688878417015, 0.0011933681089431047, 0.005167393945157528, -0.007962672971189022, -0.022609394043684006, 0.0036317091435194016, -0.06096263229846954, 0.0037677837535738945, -0.007986506447196007, -0.031046994030475616, -0.02258080616593361, 0.06122385337948799, 0.005441504064947367, -0.036157719790935516, 0.015198446810245514, 0.026282282546162605, -0.04802729934453964, -0.04783119261264801, -0.020229600369930267, -0.04160599038004875, 0.021582096815109253, 0.05476008355617523, 0.032905757427215576, 0.0005381975788623095, -0.03808797895908356, -0.014639905653893948, -0.04008694365620613, -0.0157527606934309, -0.026513202115893364, 0.018468573689460754, 0.030900688841938972, -0.0040904018096625805, 0.06368033587932587, -0.06501062959432602, 0.0069702318869531155, -0.012543200515210629, -0.027558663859963417, 0.008880413137376308, 0.036904070526361465, 0.0035638781264424324, -0.03785606473684311, -0.0074715628288686275, 0.0374639518558979, 0.020671825855970383, 0.0025054332800209522, -0.07786676287651062, 0.00698857381939888, 0.048738446086645126, -0.01836567372083664, 0.012765131890773773, -0.05210942402482033, 0.024163439869880676, -0.04132138192653656, -0.0012199836783111095, 0.07608560472726822, 0.022694982588291168, -0.05942769721150398, 0.04408934712409973, 0.0767362043261528, 0.07507801055908203, 0.0019908156245946884, -0.006043769419193268, 0.0005561779835261405, 0.021614598110318184, -0.011784359812736511, -0.020251212641596794, 0.015551744028925896, 0.06300216168165207, 0.020448632538318634, -0.037722546607255936, 0.05076325312256813, 0.04804949834942818, 0.03457440808415413, -0.03531219810247421, 0.04517938569188118, 0.005944599397480488, -0.006204573437571526, -0.012155822478234768, -0.0022371578961610794, 0.000505354895722121, -0.08842041343450546, 0.036658789962530136, -0.04593122750520706, -0.05714862793684006, 0.03575349971652031, -0.00034992018481716514, -0.07800031453371048, 0.06451325118541718, 0.03414522483944893, 0.00016139329818543047, -0.003732172306627035, 0.014038029126822948, 0.03822658210992813, 0.04121800884604454, -0.007567151915282011, -0.032893549650907516, -0.010918268002569675, -0.006398849654942751, -0.009335318580269814, -0.02827361412346363, 0.0142356026917696, -0.04292498156428337, -0.05024225637316704, -0.06778348982334137, -0.04881754890084267, -0.019483525305986404, -0.004725748207420111, 0.026524033397436142, 0.010403726249933243, -0.05650225654244423, 0.02388003095984459, 0.02983253449201584, 0.014021300710737705, -0.01876349188387394, -0.0464189313352108, -0.058128103613853455, 0.03629560023546219, 0.019211387261748314, 0.018569719046354294, 0.052521396428346634, -0.0516793392598629, -0.03863256797194481, -0.0029739816673099995, 0.032855160534381866, 0.04854965582489967, 0.013875189237296581, 0.054454781115055084, 0.0658266618847847, -0.009591493755578995, -0.03133508563041687, 0.03961164131760597, 0.027057597413659096, -0.040351349860429764, -0.005557428579777479, -0.036418817937374115, 0.08013255894184113, -0.008057650178670883, -0.005860410630702972, -0.047933049499988556, 0.0887363851070404, -0.008648792281746864, -0.04110577329993248, 0.025046750903129578, 0.03745931759476662, 0.03417118638753891, 0.09262750297784805, -0.0007256694952957332, -0.06352045387029648, 0.07665835320949554, -0.05352669954299927, 0.026579057797789574, -0.017754266038537025, -0.004335807170718908, -0.012014806270599365, 0.052376605570316315, -0.01824036054313183, -0.021717604249715805, -0.08527804166078568, -0.046368278563022614, 0.019801922142505646, 0.027234261855483055, -0.02592775784432888, 0.019739089533686638, 0.06523817777633667, -0.010959596373140812, -0.03038964420557022, 0.03389954939484596, -0.03709270432591438, 0.03762335702776909, 0.07534132897853851, -0.00548574049025774, 0.004042332526296377, -0.04878310486674309, 0.0037140189670026302, -0.007654559798538685, 0.03214079886674881, 0.01080583967268467, -0.022524913772940636, -0.05149613320827484, -0.038348328322172165, -0.022182824090123177, -0.024423211812973022, 0.03809191659092903, 0.04361429810523987, 0.02944173663854599, -0.0018674696329981089, -0.010022677481174469, 0.03442055359482765, -0.032881733030080795, -0.037866152822971344, 0.0028715941589325666, -0.09633463621139526, 0.02086954563856125, 0.013365565799176693, 0.025880904868245125, 0.03086788021028042, 0.025174321606755257, 0.003547974629327655, -0.02380569651722908, -0.020374324172735214, 0.05601805821061134, -0.011833627708256245, 0.028554944321513176, 0.03563963621854782, -0.07961612939834595, -0.03026437573134899, 0.008877625688910484, 0.05141362547874451, 0.031617410480976105, -0.02672593481838703, -0.02078896574676037, 0.08443976193666458, 0.003824958810582757, 0.01968304067850113, 0.01500778179615736, -0.012191710993647575, -0.057078126817941666, -0.025754723697900772, -0.037001680582761765, 0.02268248237669468, 0.005128760356456041, -0.010197654366493225, 0.001710120472125709, -0.025558369234204292, 0.001773125259205699, 0.01252778246998787, -0.024511786177754402, -0.03071078658103943, -0.00598754221573472, -0.0686778873205185, -0.036774907261133194, -0.028245626017451286, -0.018583297729492188, 0.04370290786027908, -0.014915280044078827, -0.0916697308421135, 0.011275174096226692, -0.053135208785533905, -0.023256152868270874, 0.08550343662500381, 0.02890617400407791, 0.017985142767429352, 0.023953458294272423, -0.05538498982787132, -0.023875515908002853, -0.043116431683301926, 0.044290896505117416, 0.001563059282489121, -0.024682993069291115, 0.0010111775482073426, -0.03335998207330704, -0.01392862293869257, -0.028802596032619476, 0.0015282215317711234, 0.004771580919623375, 0.006456722039729357, -0.029660429805517197, 0.0197947658598423, 0.01038514543324709, -0.06539467722177505, 0.06193314120173454, 0.035021234303712845, 0.041817259043455124, 0.04901402071118355, 0.03570420667529106, -0.0296632032841444, 0.02911762334406376, -0.027531210333108902, 0.013562820851802826, -0.024791959673166275, -0.032021451741456985, -0.07899637520313263, 0.0673956573009491, 0.002663013990968466, -0.02568557858467102, -0.02458835579454899, 0.03323482349514961, -0.02801000326871872, 0.01584947668015957, 0.018811224028468132, 0.03436728194355965, -0.04588112235069275, -0.04031110554933548, -0.02132892608642578, -0.029090743511915207, 0.013449307531118393, -0.009482870809733868, 0.0036854606587439775, -0.08037834614515305, -0.03303954005241394, 0.04776202514767647, -0.02081107348203659, -0.09462535381317139, 0.011750027537345886, -0.05289377644658089, -0.002217378932982683, -0.021915119141340256, -0.049891065806150436, 0.02219192124903202, 0.034445494413375854, 0.02746032364666462, 0.0071292598731815815, -0.01382499746978283, 0.03333766758441925, 0.05426069721579552, -0.01014992967247963, -0.02525717206299305, -0.004608717747032642, 0.02274075709283352, 0.030325422063469887, -0.028891300782561302, 0.0303498487919569, 0.027426254004240036, -0.003751296317204833, -0.011133119463920593, -0.007810479961335659, 0.006101030390709639, 0.005717703141272068, -0.07881509512662888, 0.07469907402992249, 0.0029877251945436, 0.019002003595232964, 0.04019780829548836, -0.010779489763081074, 0.006069301161915064, -0.04068411514163017, 0.01851074770092964, -0.030369538813829422, 0.06969226151704788, 0.06119455024600029, -0.0009124500793404877, 0.015778103843331337, 0.006241261027753353, -0.018320804461836815, -0.032434698194265366, -0.04982035979628563, 0.023265764117240906, -0.018703455105423927, 0.035076212137937546, -0.05388403683900833, -0.005785175133496523, 0.03550711274147034, -0.0013023148057982326, 0.021215151995420456, -0.0912012904882431, 0.013436851091682911, 0.03589195758104324, 0.06795128434896469, 0.008383654057979584, 0.07882977277040482, -0.017317762598395348, -0.006327851675450802, -0.010039189830422401, -0.062321532517671585, -0.002521240385249257, 0.036583319306373596, 0.06802371144294739, -0.06719164550304413, -0.030995821580290794, -0.10367056727409363, -0.05217459425330162, 0.028087129816412926, -0.05799900367856026, -0.02551940269768238, 0.011540455743670464, -0.020821450278162956, -0.007594666909426451, 0.004614906385540962, 0.04066972807049751, -0.0793493464589119, -0.014331193640828133, -0.004192594904452562, -0.019599705934524536, -0.015047162771224976, 0.024889549240469933, -0.003138503059744835, 0.03490135073661804, -0.026888269931077957, -0.03592953458428383, -0.05798507109284401, 0.0035636285319924355, -0.03911340981721878, 0.011774163693189621, 0.025372149422764778, -0.0048448434099555016, 0.029703307896852493, 0.012983309105038643, 0.0009550855029374361, -0.01005709171295166, 0.04574250429868698, 0.06405604630708694, 0.039274267852306366, -0.00041353143751621246, -0.047913387417793274, 0.0015217011095955968, 0.01379911508411169, -0.0347101204097271, -0.027243992313742638, -0.03385872393846512, 0.028165264055132866, -0.02703690528869629, 0.01224507112056017, -0.0014063806738704443, -0.04445107653737068, 0.005989440251141787, 0.029817095026373863, -0.03418147936463356, -0.0644824430346489, 0.019681742414832115, 0.050024136900901794, 0.002457287162542343, -0.031501758843660355, -0.0020323998760432005, -0.03232971206307411, -0.027230147272348404, 0.01913152076303959, -0.019785480573773384, -0.017376312986016273, 0.022356241941452026, 0.047049231827259064, 0.012087038718163967, -0.029763488098978996, -0.025310523808002472, -0.03141022473573685, -0.0071337479166686535, -0.014575743116438389, -0.017919806763529778, 0.055308207869529724, 0.024909786880016327, 0.006458517163991928, 0.007278967183083296, -0.06752581149339676, 0.03608669713139534, 0.0858241468667984, 0.009778075851500034, 0.025021035224199295, -0.014157131314277649, 0.022375063970685005, 0.029951151460409164, 0.04952135309576988, -0.040894340723752975, 0.03222668915987015, 0.00012038655404467136, -0.03581884503364563, 0.021141476929187775, 0.017862072214484215, 0.04609420523047447, 0.019827838987112045, 0.03861622512340546, 0.0023236835841089487, -0.024451784789562225, -0.029062658548355103, -0.07631663978099823, -0.08662810921669006, 0.01152943167835474, 0.035782020539045334, -0.019123166799545288, 0.07094213366508484, 0.03539273142814636 ]