Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
key
string
lang
string
entity
string
none_reason
string
candidates
int64
010090260092
hbo
e30c3e56c80
21
010090270102
hbo
e9d6cd247c6
21
010100190052
hbo
null
not_listed
105
010100190092
hbo
null
not_listed
105
010100300042
hbo
null
not_listed
105
010130100242
hbo
null
not_listed
30
010250180092
hbo
null
not_listed
75
010420140041
hbo
null
proposition
29
010440090032
hbo
null
not_listed
22
010440100092
hbo
null
not_listed
22
010470140131
hbo
null
not_listed
102
010480200092
hbo
null
not_listed
32
020010160101
hbo
null
not_listed
25
020010160151
hbo
null
not_listed
25
020120040071
hbo
null
not_listed
24
020210220162
hbo
null
not_listed
22
020220080191
hbo
eec80608440
22
020320330092
hbo
null
not_listed
35
020370170152
hbo
eaa2b62e90b
39
030100030051
hbo
null
proposition
23
030130540062
hbo
ed6eca24d24
11
030130540083
hbo
ed6eca24d24
11
030130570162
hbo
ed6eca24d24
11
030130570192
hbo
ed6eca24d24
11
030140320042
hbo
null
not_listed
20
030140350032
hbo
null
not_listed
20
030140350102
hbo
null
not_listed
20
030150230123
hbo
null
not_listed
19
030230020151
hbo
null
not_listed
20
030240120042
hbo
e2c842e2824
30
030270240073
hbo
null
not_listed
25
030270240092
hbo
null
not_listed
25
040050070162
hbo
null
not_listed
40
040150250121
hbo
null
proposition
29
040160050212
hbo
null
not_listed
33
040240230073
hbo
null
proposition
37
040330540172
hbo
null
not_listed
108
040350160071
hbo
null
not_listed
65
040350170101
hbo
null
not_listed
65
040350180111
hbo
null
not_listed
65
040350230122
hbo
null
not_listed
65
050030200242
hbo
null
not_listed
62
050240060071
hbo
null
not_listed
24
050290140042
hbo
null
not_listed
46
050290140142
hbo
null
not_listed
46
050320320122
hbo
e369992f524
44
050320350132
hbo
null
not_listed
44
050330020072
hbo
e2c842e2824
60
050330020182
hbo
e2c842e2824
60
060020210041
hbo
null
proposition
29
060130120133
hbo
null
not_listed
127
070060040082
hbo
null
not_listed
87
070110330042
hbo
null
not_listed
57
070140040071
hbo
null
proposition
26
080020190172
hbo
ead557df9f6
20
090100240092
hbo
e0d33265d9c
45
090110070132
hbo
null
not_listed
44
090150070062
hbo
null
not_listed
69
090170290081
hbo
null
proposition
60
090170520102
hbo
null
not_listed
60
090270080162
hbo
null
not_listed
43
100050250122
hbo
null
not_listed
52
100220150033
hbo
null
not_listed
59
110180460122
hbo
null
not_listed
39
120090360071
hbo
null
proposition
63
120130210021
hbo
null
not_listed
50
120150120011
hbo
null
proposition
77
120180360101
hbo
null
not_listed
84
120250080051
hbo
null
not_listed
57
130210170111
hbo
e062c23bb85
51
130290080022
hbo
null
not_listed
35
140080110272
hbo
null
not_listed
39
140220120022
hbo
null
not_listed
43
140240260032
hbo
e619f575fec
51
140250200061
hbo
null
proposition
61
140340140014
hbo
null
not_listed
57
150060150101
hbo
null
not_listed
40
150070080051
hbo
null
not_listed
54
150070090051
hbo
null
not_listed
54
150100090091
hbo
null
not_listed
159
160070030121
hbo
null
not_listed
157
160080100122
hbo
null
not_listed
177
160120290092
hbo
null
not_listed
240
180030140072
hbo
null
not_listed
14
180040070041
hbo
null
not_listed
12
180060190072
hbo
null
not_listed
14
180060210052
hbo
null
not_listed
14
180060290102
hbo
null
proposition
14
180080190021
hbo
null
proposition
13
180090220021
hbo
null
proposition
13
180090240121
hbo
ec7ca2dfa3b
13
180130160021
hbo
null
proposition
8
180130190021
hbo
null
not_listed
8
180140210082
hbo
null
not_listed
7
180150090081
hbo
null
proposition
12
180150280072
hbo
e3f2565e330
12
180170030061
hbo
null
not_listed
9
180220170082
hbo
null
not_listed
18
180220190062
hbo
null
not_listed
18
180240160062
hbo
null
not_listed
14
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

entity-mentions-model v0.1

Made by a language model (claude-opus-5-5, effort medium). No person has checked it.

For pronouns that bcv-commons/entity-mentions v0.1 leaves without an entity (neither ACAI nor MACULA's reference chain reaches them; bcv-commons/reference-status v0.2 lists them as unresolved), the entity the model reads them as referring to, or why it gives none. Use it beside entity-mentions, not in place of it.

Scope. Personal, demonstrative, reflexive, reciprocal and relative pronouns and pronoun suffixes. Interrogatives (מָה, מִי, τίς), indefinites (τὶς) and words of quantity or quality (ὅσος, τοιοῦτος) are left out: they refer to no entity (Hebrew 1,228, Greek 1,159 words).

No English. Entities are entity-mentions' neutral codes; reasons are codes.

How it was made

436 calls, one per chapter (up to 25 words each). The model got, in Hebrew or Greek only: each word's verse and the three verses before it, the words marked, every word entity-mentions links to an entity tagged with a candidate number, and the candidates (the entities entity-mentions has in this chapter and the one before: type, gender, lemmas). It picked one candidate per word or none with a reason. An answer naming no listed candidate is dropped. Run cost USD 13.46 (reported by Claude Code; the user's subscription).

Table (data/answers.parquet, 1,612 rows)

column
key MACULA word key (Tanakh 12 digits, Greek NT Nestle 1904 11 digits)
lang hbo or grc
entity the entity code (entity-mentions), or empty
none_reason where entity is empty: proposition (it points at a statement, event or matter), not_listed (an entity that is not among the candidates, often one entity-mentions does not have, such as "someone" or a group the text gathers), unclear
candidates how many candidates the model had
Hebrew and Aramaic Greek NT
words 434 1,178
an entity 79 159
none: proposition 52 471
none: not listed 301 544
none: unclear 2 4

How far it agrees with blind judges

A sealed sample (seed 1119, 60 words per language, drawn before scoring; rules registered before judging) was judged blind by Claude subagents, two per word, each from the word's verse and the three before it with the same candidates. Judges are the same model family, so this measures agreement, not truth. Scored on the choice (candidate or none), once.

Hebrew Greek together
words 60 60 120
model = judge A 0.917 1.000 0.958
model = judge B 0.917 1.000 0.958
judges agree 0.950 1.000 0.975
model = judges, where they agree (n) 0.947 (57) 1.000 (60) 0.974 (117)

Most answers on every side are none, which makes these figures easy to reach. Where the model or a judge chose an entity (17 words; a count not registered beforehand), all three named the same entity for 11; the others were Hebrew words, most of them in the Psalms and Isaiah.

Sources and licence

bcv-commons/entity-mentions v0.1 (CC BY-SA 4.0; ACAI, © Mission Mutual / BiblioNexus, CC BY-SA 4.0) for the entities and candidates; bcv-commons/reference-status v0.2 (7612f663) for which words are unresolved; MACULA Hebrew and Greek (CC BY 4.0) for the text and keys. Nothing comes from BHSA or TBTA. This dataset: CC BY-SA 4.0.

Provenance

Code 014b4da: shoresh/macula/pronoun_model.py (prepare, run, collect, sealed sample), shoresh/macula/release_entity_mentions_model.py. Raw answers sha256 998b8a50a10a (in build.json in full).

Downloads last month
44