date
stringlengths
10
10
nb_tokens
int64
60
629k
text_size
int64
234
1.02M
content
stringlengths
234
1.02M
2019/06/22
943
4,020
<issue_start>username_0: I am a PhD student since 9 years. I am working on medical technology where I need intra-operative surgical data. When I joined, I was told that they will have collaboration with hospitals and other universities around the world so, I can have my experiments there. After 4 years I got a chance...
2019/06/22
622
2,560
<issue_start>username_0: I am thinking of doing a PhD. Problem is, I am not a student and the only professors I do know are the ones from the university I took my bachelor and Master's degree. However I was thinking of changing institution or even moving to a relevant scientific field and thus I do not want to contact ...
2019/06/22
564
2,451
<issue_start>username_0: I sent an informal query to a professor in UK and she replied me with her strong interest in my research works and considering me as a potential postdoc. She mentioned that she wants to apply for research grant this year and will inform me when she gets that. But she did not provide some detail...
2019/06/22
520
2,254
<issue_start>username_0: My advisor invited me to host a panel at a conference next week because she is on vacation and of course I said yes right away without thinking. But now I realize I should asked more questions, because I don’t really know what to do. What are some good tips on how to be a great host for a pan...
2019/06/23
567
2,349
<issue_start>username_0: I worked with my professor on a project for two months at the beginning of this year. After a while, I finished writing up the paper and sent it to him to check. He didn't reply. I've sent 5 follow-up emails within the span of 3 months after that with no reply. I am afraid to send another follo...
2019/06/23
647
2,611
<issue_start>username_0: I would like to submit a paper which is exactly 15 pages. The [journal overview](https://www.ams.org/publications/journals/journalsframework/abouttran) of *Transactions of the AMS* says: > > Papers of less than 15 printed pages that meet the above criteria should be submitted to the Proceedin...
2019/06/23
531
2,283
<issue_start>username_0: After my PhD I received the diploma with the (external and one internal) examiners final recommendation that was used to award my PhD. Because my Ph.D. wasn't graded and this recommendation is very positive, I want to share it on my LinkedIn profile. Is there anything that prevents me from doin...
2019/06/23
1,762
7,228
<issue_start>username_0: I'm currently doing my bachelor's degree in mathematics in Germany (Heidelberg to be precise) and I'll soon be applying for master programs / grad school. I basically consider two options: **I)** First do a master's degree and then a PhD in Europe and try to get a postdoc position in the US af...
2019/06/23
1,049
4,391
<issue_start>username_0: I've been offered a few adjunct teaching positions recently, and the colleges have said that degree certificates don't count in verifying my credentials and that only academic transcripts are acceptable. Given that I finished my degrees 20+ years ago, **what is the reason for this?** I eventu...
2019/06/24
252
902
<issue_start>username_0: The academic promotions procedure at my Australian university includes specifically publications in A/A\* journals. What defines A/A\* and where can I find out which journals are in this category?<issue_comment>username_1: A and A\* labels on journals are obsolete. The current custom is to refe...
2019/06/24
2,172
8,977
<issue_start>username_0: Disclaimer! I am a first year CS/Applied math master student so I do understand very little in how academia works. I am trying to fix it before I go into PhD. --- I have discovered a scientist who works in the field I am interested in. This scientists is very successful career-wise. The scien...
2019/06/24
546
2,192
<issue_start>username_0: I applied to a pretty broadly-themed conference in my research areas, and submited two very different contributed talk abstracts. I suspected one would be downgraded to a poster, or simply rejected. Instead, the organisers told me I could present both talks. Looking in the abstract book, I see ...
2019/06/24
1,060
4,882
<issue_start>username_0: In computer science, I need to compare the accuracy of my proposed method to the previous ones. There are two possible options: 1. Implement the methods described in related papers on my own machine 2. Use the claimed results of the authors Sometimes, when I implement the other papers, the re...
2019/06/24
5,444
21,313
<issue_start>username_0: I find it hard to write a literature review, even though I have Google, the Internet, and all free, very easy to search for information tools. I have to search for days to find a piece of information that is related to my research. I really would not be able to do that without the help of the i...
2019/06/24
542
2,323
<issue_start>username_0: I'm an undergraduate in Mechanical Engineering interested in a career in academia, especially Physics. A middle aged person in India (from where I am) I recently met told me he couldn't find employment in academia in India or abroad after completing his doctorate in a Physics field, because he ...
2019/06/24
752
3,173
<issue_start>username_0: I am a fairly new Assistant Professor at a liberal arts university. I know from Facebook that a professor at my undergrad just retired and I specialize in some of the same classes this person taught. I would love to work at my undergrad. Is it appropriate to email my former advisor and ask to...
2019/06/24
240
1,033
<issue_start>username_0: I have published my paper in a new journal in our field. The reason for submitting for this journal was the editorial board which consists of some of the top professors from best global universities (including University of Cambridge, University College London, Technical University of Munich, e...
2019/06/25
1,013
4,314
<issue_start>username_0: I'm guessing that if the grad student / postdoc is directly supervising the undergrad, friending would not be very appropriate. However, would it be ok for an undergrad to friend other grad students / postdocs in the lab? This is for a university in the U.S.<issue_comment>username_1: I don't t...
2019/06/25
1,060
4,320
<issue_start>username_0: I submitted a short note to a math journal providing a counterexample to a result in literature that had first appeared in that very journal. After eight months, I heard from the journal. It was a rejection. The associate editor based his rejection on one referee who had clearly misunderstood ...
2019/06/25
6,839
29,152
<issue_start>username_0: I just graduated with a software-engineering master’s degree with a good grade from a top-five university in the UK. I also have a bachelor's in computer science. I always revised just for exams and just enough to get that first-class degree, without actually learning anything. I basically rev...
2019/06/25
537
2,181
<issue_start>username_0: I submitted my manuscript to a journal one month ago and the status is "with editor" up to now. As the editor of my paper is one of the leading scientists in the field of my research paper (mathematics), I would like to know that can an editor do the review of paper by him/herself without sendi...
2019/06/25
1,063
4,072
<issue_start>username_0: I'm 36 years old and work as systems administrator and lab instructor for a computer science department at a small liberal arts college. I'm also an adjunct math instructor for a community college. I have 1 BA and 2 masters, all from Ivy League Universities. I started college late, at the age o...
2019/06/25
913
3,608
<issue_start>username_0: We are free to grade our students in oral or written exams. Obviously, if only 1 or 2 students take the course, oral exams (~15-30 mins) are the way to go from an effort minimization perspective (no exam creation, room reservation, grading, post-exam inspection/review), as well as written exams...
2019/06/25
1,779
7,680
<issue_start>username_0: Question is: For a first year math PhD student, should the student read their graduate level math textbooks page by page, sentence by sentence? I often hear professors say that that's a bad idea, and that it's better to look at problems first, and then go back to read as necessary. From under...
2019/06/26
417
1,841
<issue_start>username_0: Recently, I have gone through a special issue of a journal and in the special issue, in notification to the author section, it's mentioned that > > Reviews returned to authors. Papers will be either accepted, rejected, > or returned to the authors with requests for changes > > > There i...
2019/06/26
493
1,923
<issue_start>username_0: If you post an assignment question on a 3rd party site and get no answers about the subject matter, is it still considered cheating?<issue_comment>username_1: At my university, the answer is definitely **yes**. The rules here clearly state that even the attempt to cheat is misconduct (e.g. brin...
2019/06/26
528
2,151
<issue_start>username_0: I've been teaching a few years now and the number of older editions of textbooks is beginning to pile up in my office. There is no policy at my university for disposal of old textbooks. These books were purchase with department funds and it troubles me to throw them away. They content is still ...
2019/06/26
1,439
6,254
<issue_start>username_0: I would like to submit a part of my master's thesis which is more or less close to an end. I wrote the entire thesis without having much feedback from my advisor as he's in a different city and we had literally no chance to meet except a few times. The feedback he had provided was too little an...
2019/06/26
1,390
6,214
<issue_start>username_0: I am currently reviewing an applied math paper that I don't think is great; indeed, I am hesitant to accept it even with major revisions. The language is poor, I'm not convinced by the arguments, and the numerical results are difficult to interpret based on how they are presented. However, base...
2019/06/26
1,330
5,202
<issue_start>username_0: I was accepted to a Masters Program at EPFL 5 days ago. I am currently collecting all the necessary documentation to apply for a visa. However there is a chance it will take longer than I have to get to Switzerland (have to be there by September 30). My only idea right now is to use my passport...
2019/06/26
848
3,420
<issue_start>username_0: The era in which we live is full of competition, I want to know why competitive exams have taken such an important status? I have read about Mr. <NAME>, Mr. <NAME> etc. they are so famous not because of their research and contributions to Mathematics but because they cleared Olympiads at young ...
2019/06/26
1,011
4,332
<issue_start>username_0: I am planning to submit my paper to an international conference. The level of the conference might be high considering my paper and for my academic background at the moment. My paper can fit in one of the poster sessions though. However, the scientific committee includes one academics who bel...
2019/06/26
395
1,885
<issue_start>username_0: As a PhD Candidate, I've written several successful recommendation letters for students who I've taught in my classes. Is it worthwhile to include this information on a CV, say under "Service"? I've never seen this included before on a CV, but I was hoping there might be a way for me to highlig...
2019/06/27
1,062
4,501
<issue_start>username_0: As part of my Toastmasters club, I am preparing a speech where I have to research a topic I am not familiar with. One suggestion is that I could interview an expert (e.g. a professor) in a field related to the topic I choose. If I do interview a professor, should I compensate the professor for ...
2019/06/27
1,014
4,288
<issue_start>username_0: Lets say I decided to write a small textbook, similar to how people have all sorts of "Learn to Program" books, but for other subjects like Calc, Chemistry, or similar. If I used examples problems, say from <https://www.math.ucdavis.edu/~kouba/ProblemsList.html> or <http://tutorial.math.lamar....
2019/06/27
3,213
14,246
<issue_start>username_0: I am a second year mathematics PhD student (Austria) in computational geometry, although I have obtained my Master's in algebra. However, I have the impression that I must have done my stuff severely wrong since I started my PhD. I haven't published anything so far, or developed to an extend ...
2019/06/28
1,743
7,281
<issue_start>username_0: I notice that, quite often, exams have a rule similar to this: > > You may not leave the exam theater during the first ten minutes and last ten minutes of the exam. > > > I'm wondering what the purpose of this rule is. In the first ten minutes presumably nobody would have finished the exa...
2019/06/28
909
3,632
<issue_start>username_0: The altmetric score is a summary of the online attention a publication has received. More tweets, hits and chatter makes a bigger score. But what does the popularity contest mean? I've heard of researchers being officially judged by their Research Gate scores, but this one is new to me. Hav...
2019/06/28
875
3,600
<issue_start>username_0: Recently, I have completed my PhD in Biomedical Engineering from a 25 - 30th ranked USA university and got a Post-doc offer from a 9-12th ranked USA University. To keep me, my PhD advisor offered me a non-tenured tracked Research assistant professor (RSP) position with 1.5 times of offered Post...
2019/06/28
1,081
4,716
<issue_start>username_0: I am a PhD candidate in the very early process of writing my dissertation, and I'm presenting my first chapter at an international humanities conference soon. I received an email from the managing editor of a well known University Press that was impressed by my topic and wants to meet to discus...
2019/06/28
1,195
5,062
<issue_start>username_0: Since a short time ago, I refuse to try solving math questions of which there is no solution available, unless I'm working on an own/open problem in my thesis. In subjects however, I refuse, because it is frustrating to get stuck for days and knowing that a solution exists. So knowing that I mi...
2019/06/28
640
2,680
<issue_start>username_0: I have enough work done for my PhD dissertation, but I also have one on-going project which I don't plan to include it in my dissertation. My advisor suggests that I have to finish all the work before I graduate. Is it so? My advisor doesn't currently have funding and I am not being paid now....
2019/06/28
667
2,824
<issue_start>username_0: How to prepare for a meeting/discussion with a major University Press editor when they solicited/sought you out on short notice (4 days)? Because I didn't solicit them, I don't have a full manuscript -- just my conference paper, abstract, and general research ideas. What is expected in these im...
2019/06/28
274
1,180
<issue_start>username_0: Assume I am submitting my paper to Journal X, which rejected the paper. After making modifications I am going to submit the paper to Journal X again. At the same time can I also submit the paper to another Journal Y (which has a lower impact factor than Journal X). As the Journal X has rejected...
2019/06/28
851
3,514
<issue_start>username_0: I am a social scientist about to finish my PhD program, and I'm hoping that I will get an academic job that will enable me to PI my own studies. However, I think there is a chance that this will not happen. I love doing research, so I'm wondering - is there a way I can affiliate with a universi...
2019/06/28
967
4,220
<issue_start>username_0: I wonder in some good journals, there are articles that are quite short. Maximum 10 pages. How come such papers, with quite a short introduction with a brief lit-rewiew, are published? They are because of the quality, to do point conclusion and precise findings?<issue_comment>username_1: In mat...
2019/06/29
534
2,176
<issue_start>username_0: I am submitting the final version for an ACM sponsored conference and I am dubious about what would be the correct format to include multiple authors (with multiple I mean more than tree). The ACM template has the following author heading: [![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur...
2019/06/29
510
2,179
<issue_start>username_0: My question is about "soft-skills", i.e. knowing how to handle Latex, giving a speech or giving a lecture, or other knowledge that could be useful for a career in mathematics. Skills that (all) mathematicians need, but which are not necessarily something that one learns studying the mathematic...
2019/06/29
410
1,874
<issue_start>username_0: I have been asked to review a paper that has been accepted for publication in english because I am a native english speaker. This request is coming from the director of a center. I am still a student. I don't technically work under this person or this center but I do have an affiliation. The re...
2019/06/29
988
3,998
<issue_start>username_0: I am submitting my Aerospace engineering PhD thesis in August. However, my colleagues have pointed out that I am very late with postdoc applications for this year. I should started searching much sooner. Now, I am still being funded by my PhD supervisor, and she has said that I can stay in her...
2019/06/30
1,302
5,390
<issue_start>username_0: I'm currently scheduled to start graduate school next semester. I've been going to the lab that I'll be working in for the past few months now. I had a question regarding graduation after talking with some of my seniors from the lab. Just for some background info, I'm currently attending schoo...
2019/06/30
803
3,544
<issue_start>username_0: I have applied for an integrated MS and PhD program. I have sent am email for that purpose. The professor had an interview of me via skype. Then he sent me 6 of his papers and told me read those. At the same time, he told me to apply for scholarship via the general admission process of his univ...
2019/06/30
472
1,877
<issue_start>username_0: The manuscripts version made online in journals are often updated. For example, from the "Accepted" to "Final" version. Many times the version retrieved by sci-hub is outdated, is there any way to force sci-hub to get the last published version?<issue_comment>username_1: From my understanding ...
2019/07/01
731
2,832
<issue_start>username_0: As a marker, there are always some students who will email requesting to meet as they disagree with the marking. According to the professor, the marker should solve students' marking issues but I am uncomfortable with those students who insist that marks should be given in their way. Some of th...
2019/07/01
792
3,195
<issue_start>username_0: I am a junior postdoc (1st year) part of a program committee in an international conference. As a member I have been assigned with several papers that I would like to delegate to subreviewers. I have in my network researchers who are also postdocs but, they could be regarded as senior. Is it r...
2019/07/01
6,583
26,546
<issue_start>username_0: I'm taking the last and hardest exams of my master degree. During the exams we aren't allowed to use anything else but our brain. Cheating is pretty easy though: one has the lecture notes and all the past exams with solutions on the phone and can easily consult them without being caught, theref...
2019/07/01
400
1,681
<issue_start>username_0: I'm comparing my method against existing methods by doing some experiments on one dataset. The existing methods do not provide results on the considered dataset. My question is: Can I use default parameters from the existing methods? The fact is that there are plenty of existing methods and it ...
2019/07/01
573
2,385
<issue_start>username_0: This is probably a silly question, but I really need some advice. I'm an undergraduate student and I want to take a different major in grad school. Luckily, my university offers you a possibility to take a different major in grad school provided that you pass certain exams and show that you'll ...
2019/07/01
5,761
24,417
<issue_start>username_0: I am a second year PhD student at a technical / interdisciplinary lab in Europe wondering when to quit and leave a seemingly unbearable situation behind. My supervisor (a young-ish professor) mostly works alongside an older professor (his own PhD supervisor back in the day). I am one of his fi...
2019/07/01
2,424
10,425
<issue_start>username_0: Some months ago I was promoted with a managing position inside the university (in my case, associated chair of my school, being for instance the head of admission committee and the director of doctoral studies). At least in my country, these jobs have a teaching reduction. However, my intentio...
2019/07/01
565
2,304
<issue_start>username_0: I understand this question is not strictly academic, but what I hope to find here is some feedback from someone who already had similar experience. I live and study Electronics Engineering in Parma, a small town in northern Italy. I'm considering to move in order to get my Master Thesis done. ...
2019/07/02
2,307
9,832
<issue_start>username_0: I published my PhD thesis three years ago. I have just come to know that a master’s student has copied three chapters from my PhD thesis half a year later. My PhD supervisor was also the supervisor of his master’s project. Each and every word and mathematical symbol is exactly the same. That p...
2019/07/02
729
2,890
<issue_start>username_0: I'm an undergrad who is applying a scholarship for Phd. I have already sent heck a lot of documents ranging from my academic background, letter of purpose, research statement etc.; it took more than two months to prepare them. There I - more than once - explained my future plans extensively. N...
2019/07/02
333
1,354
<issue_start>username_0: According to this [site](https://research.moreheadstate.edu/c.php?g=107001&p=695202), when you're using the APA reference style, if a source has 3-5 authors, all authors should be mentioned in the first in-text citation, while only the first author need to be mentioned in the subsequent citatio...
2019/07/02
730
2,979
<issue_start>username_0: I did my Ph.D. from Germany where I received a tax-free fellowship, and now I got a postdoc offer in Bremen with salary range TVL-13. The 'Stufe' depends on the previous experience of the employee, but since I was not paying tax and was on a student visa during my Ph.D., will my previous resear...
2019/07/02
521
2,151
<issue_start>username_0: I have been struggling with finding the right title for a section in a scientific paper (in computer science but I think it can apply to many other fields). I know it's not the first time I encounter this problem, so I guess it's worth asking the question. For now the outline of the paper rese...
2019/07/02
1,670
6,583
<issue_start>username_0: I'm curious about the correct way to cite a paper which is flawed when I publish in academic journals. In the past I've added annotations to the bibliography (or included text in the main article) stating what the problem was. But now I wonder if instead if such annotations should sometimes sta...
2019/07/02
1,603
6,500
<issue_start>username_0: I have a plot like this in my paper, but one of the co-authors says The x-axis is backward. I think as long as keeping all figures in the same style, it is ok. But I am not sure if there is really such a rule that years should increase from left to right? My field is environmental science. [![...
2019/07/03
1,840
7,822
<issue_start>username_0: My PhD involved using a commercially available software to carry out simulations. Now I am pursuing postdoc at another lab. My current advisor wants me to develop new complex models for which I don't have any academic experience in. I have 3-4 months before he starts expecting outcomes. I am p...
2019/07/03
470
1,930
<issue_start>username_0: > > Is it okay to mail an Associate Editor in his personal e-mail? > > > I have submitted a manuscript in a journal and I want to know the status of my manuscript. The publisher of my journal is "World Scientific". There is no option to mail the Associate Editor of the journal to whom I h...
2019/07/03
2,005
8,077
<issue_start>username_0: I recently finished my Ph.D. in the U.S. and will be leaving soon for a job in industry. I have got a precious gift for my advisor as I really admire him and he is one of my role models and totally deserves it. Now for giving him the gift I was thinking maybe I should take him out to dinner o...
2019/07/03
1,038
4,311
<issue_start>username_0: I've studied in this college for Diploma and have now proceeded to the Bachelor's Degree. I am facing some problem that may cause me to extend my course. The system of the faculty is like this: When you want to take certain subject, you need to pass all the prerequisite subject for that subjec...
2019/07/03
597
2,483
<issue_start>username_0: I just submitted a part of my thesis to a conference. But in the document, although in fact it is a paper to be submitted to a journal, I have mistakenly left a few words as “in this thesis, my thesis,.. etc”. Because of the deadline and some timing constraints, I could not find time to replace...
2019/07/03
755
3,170
<issue_start>username_0: This might be a strange question, but I was curious how much weight goes into when you took a course. I took some math courses 4-5 years ago and did well in them. Will the fact that I took courses from that long ago carry less weight when applying to grad school?<issue_comment>username_1: Maybe...
2019/07/04
705
2,925
<issue_start>username_0: I recently got acceptance in an SCI journal, and my professor has told me that he will be a corresponding author (CA) even though I have done almost all the work. Does not being the corresponding author hurt my chances, as I am looking to start an academic career very soon. Should I ask my pro...
2019/07/04
1,108
4,728
<issue_start>username_0: I’m quitting my PhD. The decision has been made. The reasons boil down to diminished interest in the research subject and disappointment with the university’s managerial practices (nothing is done on time or well). A while ago I informed my supervisor about these concerns and gave him the heads...
2019/07/04
1,442
6,082
<issue_start>username_0: Today`s publications lack of the possibility to be extended by others after being published. A data base paper could for example benefit when contributors would gain authorship by opening data with a meta description. Blockchain is a technology which offers the inheritance of documents. Each ...
2019/07/04
1,492
6,770
<issue_start>username_0: I have been dealing with an awkward situation regarding evaluation of my submitted paper. The publisher is one of the big well known OA, and the journal is one of their leading journals (in terms of niche visibility and impact factor). We were invited to submit a paper by a colleague who'd be p...
2019/07/04
466
2,067
<issue_start>username_0: My wife and I are taking the IELTS exam in a few days and this question just occurred to me - When taking the test, do students receive the whole listening/reading/writing package or do they receive individual sections as they finish the previous section? I ask because during my practice sessi...
2019/07/04
1,196
5,042
<issue_start>username_0: I have been applying to PhD programs for the past 2+ years and keep getting rejected. I have pretty good degrees that I worked hard for from good universities (not the top unis). For the past year I’ve been doing everything I could think of to improve my CV; working for free as a research ass...
2019/07/04
2,009
6,813
<issue_start>username_0: My goal is to find articles related to invasive species management on a monthly basis. I have a list of species for my region (i.e keywords) and a list of journals. Although I enjoy combing through new issues of each journal, I'm wondering if there is a more automated, and less time consuming m...
2019/07/05
411
1,750
<issue_start>username_0: There are so many ways to compose CVs now. I try to keep my CV updated in `LaTeX`, Markdown/HTML, ASCII, and Word just in case someone needs a specific file format. If an application doesn't specify a specific CV format (and they tend not to), what is the best format, in terms of style vs. por...
2019/07/05
650
2,572
<issue_start>username_0: A journal I am submitting to requires camera-ready figures. What does this term mean nowadays? Does it imply high resolution? My figures are in png format and have 96 dpi. Enlarging it can produce some jagged edges. Should I update them to eps or pdf format?<issue_comment>username_1: There isn'...
2019/07/05
670
2,694
<issue_start>username_0: How do you search arXiv by sub-subject? For example, underneath the subject Computer Science, you have the subject 'Artificial Intelligence', and under the subject Quantitative Finance, you have the subject 'Computational Finance'. How do I search for papers specifically within these subjects...
2019/07/06
1,236
4,821
<issue_start>username_0: I have to give a presentation to a general scientific audience (specifically, an interview talk). As part of the presentation I would like to highlight some of my previous work. I work in mathematics, where paper authorship is always alphabetical. The standard practice in talks is to replace ...
2019/07/06
1,467
6,198
<issue_start>username_0: I have always wanted to get a PhD. I'm in my thirties now and have a full time job. I don't necessarily need to get a PhD for my job, though it could open doors to a few research jobs that I can't apply for now. A few friends and colleagues have gotten their PhDs in about 5 years, they tell me ...
2019/07/06
2,777
11,663
<issue_start>username_0: I am a final year PhD student in materials science. My colleagues publish papers at a rate of 2-3 papers a year. By the end of their PhD, they would have around 8-10 papers (first authors) in their name. While I on the other hand, am struggling.... struggling hard. How do people produce so man...
2019/07/06
871
3,375
<issue_start>username_0: I aced my undergrad studies and got the best offer I could ever dream of for grad school. And three \*\*\*\* might have ruined it. They ran into me and asked for help with "studying". Turns out it was blatant cheating and I helped them anyway. I had my doubts, but my compassion instinct took ...
2019/07/06
1,272
5,548
<issue_start>username_0: I'm a masters degree student trying to figure out how publications and co-authorship work. I know that the school/PI retains legal ownership of any monetary profits that may result from the work, so please don't mention this in your response as it is **irrelevant** to what I'm asking. I WANT TO...
2019/07/07
2,130
8,981
<issue_start>username_0: 3-4 months ago I found a big mistake in a theorem's proof of a paper that had just been published (stats/cs community). I immediately notified the authors, who claimed to be aware of the mistake but admitted not knowing how to fix it. This week I noticed that the authors didn't notify the comm...
2019/07/07
286
1,347
<issue_start>username_0: I am reviewing a software library tool at the moment. During the review, I found some minor bugs while running their examples. However, it seems like nobody else has these bugs (at least I cant find them on the Github issue page). Otherwise, the library seems to be great. Should I recommend an ...
2019/07/07
3,467
14,847
<issue_start>username_0: I notice that past a certain age (sometimes as early as 50), some professors tend to be significantly less productive, to the point that they essentially do not publish or have graduate students and only teach classes (as that is really the only 'required' activity of a professor). I've also ...
2019/07/07
1,026
4,253
<issue_start>username_0: UPDATE: My program is Computer Science and Engineering. **I chose the current advisor for mainly three reasons:** 1. I'm interested in a general research area, and he's in a group doing the stuffs. 2. He has good publications in top conferences and journals in recent years. 3. Applying for ot...
2019/07/07
1,012
4,258
<issue_start>username_0: I teach secondary history classes. My principal is pushing for all teachers to introduce students to a annotation system which should be the same in all classes. But the system doesn't seem appropriate for my student's needs, e.g. here are some of the 20+ items: * Underline key words. * Put a ...
2019/07/07
3,310
13,455
<issue_start>username_0: As a Ph.D. student from a (pretty rich!) European research group, I'm about to attend a conference in New Zealand. The second leg of a potential flight takes 16 hours to reach the destination, and it seems to be the hell of discomfort to spend all that time on an economy seat (I once had a 10-h...
2019/07/08
506
2,041
<issue_start>username_0: First of all, I studied in Japan. After I complete all graduate courses. There will be 3 years to submit my thesis. During this time, I drop school and work in a company. So my professor removed all my information from the lab (%100) like I was not there, even Alumni name list. I would like to ...
2019/07/08
1,587
7,103
<issue_start>username_0: My paper is about a specific application of blockchain. I've developed a basic prototype for it and so far, I've described it in detail, and put screencaps of the interface for it. Should I also include actual code of relating to different parts of the application?<issue_comment>username_1: Dep...
2019/07/08
395
1,723
<issue_start>username_0: I've got an interview for a Ph.D. position and I need to give a ten-minute presentation for my recent research. I have completed two projects and right now I am doing another research which has a close correlation to the advertised position. These three projects have no correlation. I would lik...
2019/07/08
558
2,345
<issue_start>username_0: If there is a tree of papers on or involving *X*, all of which give a brief introduction to *X* and I need a citation for my use of *X*, do I need to give the root of the tree as a citation of *X* or can I cite any of the nodes in the tree that explain *X* for my use of it? Concretely I need t...
2019/07/08
2,273
9,701
<issue_start>username_0: I am a math professor at an R1 university. I have taken up a new graduate student (my n'th for n<=10), who is mathematically quite strong, but whose writing skills are a couple notches below what I have had to deal with so far. We have a new result, which he currently is writing up. He is rel...