Question
string
Complex_CoT
string
Response
int64
Depth
int64
Facts: Batman is grumpy [PERIOD] Rules: tense [AND] curious [IMPLY] foolish [PERIOD] fearless [AND] sincere [AND] exuberant [IMPLY] outrageous [PERIOD] fearless [IMPLY] hilarious [PERIOD] witty [AND] bossy [AND] tense [IMPLY] wrong [PERIOD] popular [IMPLY] sincere [PERIOD] exuberant [AND] dishonest [AND] bossy [IMPLY]...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “foolish ⇒ dishonest” because missing: foolish. Cannot apply rule “curious ⇒ dishonest” because missing: curious. Cannot apply rule “outrageous ∧ wrong ⇒ dishonest” because missing: outrageous, wrong.
0
3
Facts: Batman is innocent [PERIOD] Batman is condemned [PERIOD] Batman is amused [PERIOD] Batman is outrageous [PERIOD] Batman is gifted [PERIOD] Batman is sleepy [PERIOD] Rules: jittery [IMPLY] condemned [PERIOD] inexpensive [IMPLY] perfect [PERIOD] outrageous [AND] jittery [AND] gifted [IMPLY] innocent [PERIOD] perf...
Proof chain: outrageous ⇒ inexpensive inexpensive ⇒ perfect perfect ∧ condemned ⇒ popular
1
3
Facts: Batman is talkative [PERIOD] Batman is modern [PERIOD] Batman is rational [PERIOD] Rules: inexpensive [AND] proud [AND] famous [IMPLY] agreeable [PERIOD] modern [AND] worrisome [AND] glamorous [IMPLY] easy [PERIOD] easy [AND] shy [AND] outstanding [IMPLY] elegant [PERIOD] shy [AND] rational [IMPLY] outstanding ...
Proof chain: modern ⇒ inexpensive inexpensive ⇒ outrageous outrageous ⇒ agreeable
1
3
Facts: Batman is dishonest [PERIOD] Rules: elegant [IMPLY] inexpensive [PERIOD] frightened [AND] horrible [IMPLY] jittery [PERIOD] lucky [AND] fine [IMPLY] hypocritical [PERIOD] hypocritical [IMPLY] inexpensive [PERIOD] foolish [IMPLY] joyous [PERIOD] inexpensive [AND] foolish [AND] weary [IMPLY] elegant [PERIOD] jitt...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “elegant ⇒ inexpensive” because missing: elegant. Cannot apply rule “hypocritical ⇒ inexpensive” because missing: hypocritical. Cannot apply rule “alert ∧ combative ⇒ inexpensive” because missing: alert, combative.
0
3
Facts: Batman is worrisome [PERIOD] Batman is polite [PERIOD] Batman is strange [PERIOD] Batman is combative [PERIOD] Batman is thoughtless [PERIOD] Rules: elated [AND] thoughtless [AND] stupid [IMPLY] wandering [PERIOD] mysterious [AND] light [AND] stupid [IMPLY] polite [PERIOD] elated [IMPLY] worrisome [PERIOD] comb...
Proof chain: strange ⇒ mysterious worrisome ∧ mysterious ⇒ diplomatic polite ∧ diplomatic ⇒ lonely
1
3
Facts: Batman is wide-eyed [PERIOD] Batman is crowded [PERIOD] Batman is witty [PERIOD] Batman is fragile [PERIOD] Batman is alert [PERIOD] Batman is tame [PERIOD] Batman is talented [PERIOD] Batman is proud [PERIOD] Batman is bored [PERIOD] Batman is modern [PERIOD] Rules: wide-eyed [AND] clean [AND] average [IMPLY] ...
Proof chain: tame ⇒ elated elated ∧ modern ⇒ clean wide-eyed ∧ clean ∧ bored ⇒ helpful
1
3
Facts: Rules: old-fashioned [AND] outrageous [AND] worried [IMPLY] zealous [PERIOD] outrageous [AND] careless [IMPLY] zealous [PERIOD] bossy [AND] worried [AND] outrageous [IMPLY] thoughtless [PERIOD] outrageous [AND] spotless [AND] worrisome [IMPLY] careless [PERIOD] careless [AND] old-fashioned [AND] worrisome [IMPL...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “careless ∧ spotless ⇒ old-fashioned” because missing: careless, spotless. Cannot apply rule “outrageous ∧ disobedient ∧ worrisome ⇒ old-fashioned” because missing: outrageous, disobedient, worrisome. Cannot apply rule “zealous ∧ bossy ∧ worrisome ⇒ old-fashioned” because missing...
0
3
Facts: Batman is wrong [PERIOD] Batman is horrible [PERIOD] Batman is thoughtless [PERIOD] Batman is diplomatic [PERIOD] Batman is supportive [PERIOD] Rules: diplomatic [IMPLY] curious [PERIOD] powerful [AND] diplomatic [IMPLY] sincere [PERIOD] enchanting [AND] sincere [AND] ambitious [IMPLY] powerful [PERIOD] dishone...
Proof chain: diplomatic ⇒ pleasant pleasant ⇒ different different ⇒ sleepy
1
3
Facts: Batman is wandering [PERIOD] Batman is tense [PERIOD] Rules: tense [IMPLY] good [PERIOD] tense [AND] good [IMPLY] spotless [PERIOD] inquisitive [AND] tense [IMPLY] busy [PERIOD] tense [AND] spotless [IMPLY] troubled [PERIOD] inquisitive [AND] worrisome [AND] troubled [IMPLY] tense [PERIOD] troubled [IMPLY] spot...
Proof chain: tense ⇒ good good ⇒ inquisitive inquisitive ∧ tense ⇒ busy
1
3
Facts: Batman is different [PERIOD] Batman is straightforward [PERIOD] Batman is comfortable [PERIOD] Batman is witty [PERIOD] Batman is sleepy [PERIOD] Batman is lucky [PERIOD] Rules: adorable [AND] embarrassed [AND] sleepy [IMPLY] wide-eyed [PERIOD] supportive [AND] aggressive [IMPLY] shiny [PERIOD] disgusted [AND] ...
Proof chain: sleepy ∧ different ⇒ attentive straightforward ∧ attentive ⇒ aggressive straightforward ∧ aggressive ∧ different ⇒ muddy
1
3
Facts: Batman is different [PERIOD] Rules: attractive [AND] good [IMPLY] shy [PERIOD] good [AND] intellectual [AND] shy [IMPLY] bright [PERIOD] helpful [AND] shy [IMPLY] uptight [PERIOD] friendly [AND] good [IMPLY] helpful [PERIOD] helpful [IMPLY] shy [PERIOD] different [AND] bright [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] intelle...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “intellectual ∧ bright ⇒ confident” because missing: intellectual, bright. Cannot apply rule “long ∧ attractive ⇒ confident” because missing: long, attractive. Cannot apply rule “bright ∧ shy ∧ friendly ⇒ confident” because missing: bright, shy, friendly.
0
3
Facts: Batman is bad-tempered [PERIOD] Batman is mean [PERIOD] Batman is stormy [PERIOD] Batman is attentive [PERIOD] Batman is broad-minded [PERIOD] Batman is witty [PERIOD] Batman is naughty [PERIOD] Batman is old-fashioned [PERIOD] Rules: bad-tempered [AND] bored [IMPLY] condemned [PERIOD] versatile [AND] mean [IMP...
Proof chain: naughty ∧ broad-minded ⇒ worrisome worrisome ∧ witty ⇒ different different ⇒ versatile
1
3
Facts: Rules: attentive [IMPLY] aggressive [PERIOD] serious [AND] pleasant [AND] aggressive [IMPLY] strange [PERIOD] grumpy [AND] attentive [IMPLY] strange [PERIOD] grumpy [AND] modern [AND] serious [IMPLY] stubborn [PERIOD] stupid [AND] pleasant [AND] distinct [IMPLY] serious [PERIOD] hypocritical [AND] stubborn [IMP...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “attentive ⇒ aggressive” because missing: attentive. Cannot apply rule “modern ∧ serious ∧ attentive ⇒ aggressive” because missing: modern, serious, attentive. Cannot apply rule “distinct ∧ attentive ∧ strange ⇒ aggressive” because missing: distinct, attentive, strange.
0
3
Facts: Batman is attentive [PERIOD] Batman is bright [PERIOD] Batman is alert [PERIOD] Rules: bright [AND] sincere [IMPLY] tired [PERIOD] jittery [AND] attentive [AND] foolish [IMPLY] tame [PERIOD] sincere [IMPLY] disgusted [PERIOD] disgusted [AND] bright [AND] jittery [IMPLY] tame [PERIOD] jittery [AND] sincere [AND]...
Proof chain: alert ⇒ disgusted attentive ∧ bright ⇒ foolish disgusted ∧ foolish ∧ alert ⇒ sincere
1
3
Facts: Batman is horrible [PERIOD] Batman is elated [PERIOD] Rules: scared [AND] attentive [AND] zealous [IMPLY] old-fashioned [PERIOD] attentive [IMPLY] scared [PERIOD] elated [AND] courageous [IMPLY] old-fashioned [PERIOD] zealous [AND] courageous [AND] elated [IMPLY] grumpy [PERIOD] grumpy [IMPLY] attentive [PERIOD...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “horrible ∧ attentive ⇒ zealous” because missing: attentive. Cannot apply rule “attentive ⇒ zealous” because missing: attentive. Cannot apply rule “friendly ∧ stormy ∧ old-fashioned ⇒ zealous” because missing: friendly, stormy, old-fashioned.
0
3
Facts: Batman is worrisome [PERIOD] Rules: bright [AND] fragile [IMPLY] beautiful [PERIOD] outrageous [IMPLY] ugliest [PERIOD] nervous [AND] fragile [IMPLY] outrageous [PERIOD] bright [AND] outrageous [AND] beautiful [IMPLY] fragile [PERIOD] difficult [AND] ugliest [IMPLY] bright [PERIOD] outrageous [IMPLY] difficult ...
Proof chain: worrisome ⇒ outrageous worrisome ∧ outrageous ⇒ bright bright ⇒ beautiful
1
3
Facts: Rules: perfect [IMPLY] friendly [PERIOD] hypocritical [IMPLY] friendly [PERIOD] strange [AND] perfect [IMPLY] hypocritical [PERIOD] impatient [IMPLY] strange [PERIOD] friendly [AND] perfect [IMPLY] impatient [PERIOD] strange [AND] perfect [AND] impatient [IMPLY] hypocritical [PERIOD] perfect [AND] strange [IMPL...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “perfect ∧ strange ⇒ disobedient” because missing: perfect, strange. Cannot apply rule “hypocritical ∧ impatient ∧ perfect ⇒ disobedient” because missing: hypocritical, impatient, perfect. Cannot apply rule “perfect ∧ impatient ⇒ disobedient” because missing: perfect, impatient.
0
3
Facts: Batman is perfect [PERIOD] Batman is inquisitive [PERIOD] Batman is strange [PERIOD] Rules: perfect [AND] hypocritical [AND] strange [IMPLY] horrible [PERIOD] troubled [IMPLY] old-fashioned [PERIOD] strange [AND] cute [AND] horrible [IMPLY] inquisitive [PERIOD] proud [AND] perfect [AND] cute [IMPLY] strange [PE...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “horrible ∧ supportive ∧ selfish ⇒ hypocritical” because missing: horrible, supportive, selfish. Cannot apply rule “tense ∧ inquisitive ⇒ hypocritical” because missing: tense. Cannot apply rule “lonely ⇒ hypocritical” because missing: lonely.
0
3
Facts: Batman is talented [PERIOD] Batman is aggressive [PERIOD] Batman is comfortable [PERIOD] Batman is zealous [PERIOD] Rules: difficult [AND] zealous [AND] wandering [IMPLY] disgusted [PERIOD] grumpy [AND] talented [AND] disgusted [IMPLY] aggressive [PERIOD] quaint [IMPLY] disgusted [PERIOD] quaint [IMPLY] wanderi...
Proof chain: aggressive ⇒ wandering aggressive ∧ zealous ⇒ grumpy wandering ∧ grumpy ⇒ adorable
1
3
Facts: Batman is difficult [PERIOD] Batman is strange [PERIOD] Rules: hilarious [AND] reserved [AND] easy [IMPLY] gleaming [PERIOD] modern [AND] helpless [IMPLY] frightened [PERIOD] shiny [IMPLY] lonely [PERIOD] inexpensive [AND] distinct [IMPLY] precious [PERIOD] victorious [AND] precious [AND] tense [IMPLY] foolish ...
Proof chain: difficult ⇒ lonely strange ⇒ gleaming Cannot apply rule “lonely ∧ gleaming ∧ naughty ⇒ easy” because missing: naughty.
0
3
Facts: Batman is tame [PERIOD] Batman is fine [PERIOD] Rules: versatile [AND] fine [IMPLY] tame [PERIOD] polite [AND] straightforward [AND] charming [IMPLY] jittery [PERIOD] quaint [AND] hypocritical [IMPLY] charming [PERIOD] clean [AND] confused [IMPLY] comfortable [PERIOD] polite [AND] stupid [IMPLY] straightforward...
Proof chain: tame ⇒ disgusted disgusted ⇒ gleaming gleaming ⇒ clean
1
3
Facts: Batman is polite [PERIOD] Rules: light [AND] sensible [AND] homely [IMPLY] bossy [PERIOD] bossy [AND] homely [IMPLY] sensible [PERIOD] light [IMPLY] bossy [PERIOD] bossy [AND] light [AND] polite [IMPLY] homely [PERIOD] polite [IMPLY] light [PERIOD] polite [AND] homely [IMPLY] sensible [PERIOD] bossy [AND] homel...
Proof chain: polite ⇒ light light ⇒ bossy bossy ⇒ sensible
1
3
Facts: Batman is mean [PERIOD] Batman is perfect [PERIOD] Batman is confident [PERIOD] Batman is nervous [PERIOD] Batman is mysterious [PERIOD] Batman is pleasant [PERIOD] Rules: frantic [IMPLY] joyous [PERIOD] glamorous [AND] confident [AND] nervous [IMPLY] elated [PERIOD] thoughtful [AND] reserved [AND] frantic [IMP...
Proof chain: nervous ⇒ glamorous glamorous ∧ confident ∧ nervous ⇒ elated elated ⇒ hilarious
1
3
Facts: Batman is weary [PERIOD] Batman is condemned [PERIOD] Rules: thoughtless [IMPLY] witty [PERIOD] pessimistic [AND] inquisitive [AND] inexpensive [IMPLY] combative [PERIOD] disgusted [AND] gleaming [IMPLY] popular [PERIOD] pessimistic [AND] combative [AND] inquisitive [IMPLY] fragile [PERIOD] agreeable [AND] inex...
Proof chain: weary ⇒ supportive supportive ⇒ witty witty ⇒ stubborn
1
3
Facts: Rules: gleaming [AND] sensible [IMPLY] excited [PERIOD] mean [AND] lonely [AND] thoughtless [IMPLY] difficult [PERIOD] excited [AND] impatient [IMPLY] sensible [PERIOD] charming [AND] mean [AND] sensible [IMPLY] spotless [PERIOD] mean [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] gleaming [AND] excited [AND] mean [IMPLY] difficu...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “difficult ⇒ impatient” because missing: difficult. Cannot apply rule “selfish ⇒ impatient” because missing: selfish. Cannot apply rule “wandering ∧ difficult ⇒ impatient” because missing: wandering, difficult.
0
3
Facts: Batman is joyous [PERIOD] Batman is confident [PERIOD] Rules: helpless [IMPLY] hilarious [PERIOD] gifted [IMPLY] stupid [PERIOD] tame [AND] worried [AND] helpless [IMPLY] lucky [PERIOD] dishonest [IMPLY] sensible [PERIOD] stupid [AND] helpless [IMPLY] popular [PERIOD] helpless [AND] sensible [AND] weary [IMPLY]...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “enchanting ⇒ blushing” because missing: enchanting. Cannot apply rule “outstanding ∧ joyous ∧ confident ⇒ blushing” because missing: outstanding. Cannot apply rule “confident ∧ tame ⇒ blushing” because missing: tame.
0
3
Facts: Batman is sincere [PERIOD] Batman is modern [PERIOD] Batman is shy [PERIOD] Batman is careless [PERIOD] Batman is bored [PERIOD] Batman is outstanding [PERIOD] Rules: sincere [AND] modern [AND] stormy [IMPLY] pessimistic [PERIOD] tense [AND] shy [AND] bored [IMPLY] outstanding [PERIOD] sincere [AND] frantic [AN...
Proof chain: careless ⇒ stormy bored ∧ stormy ⇒ thoughtless thoughtless ∧ shy ⇒ tense
1
3
Facts: Batman is easy [PERIOD] Batman is worrisome [PERIOD] Batman is bright [PERIOD] Rules: frightened [AND] selfish [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] outstanding [AND] worrisome [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] attractive [AND] outstanding [AND] easy [IMPLY] condemned [PERIOD] blushing [AND] inquisitive [AND] easy [IMPLY] cond...
Proof chain: easy ∧ bright ⇒ excited easy ∧ excited ⇒ talented talented ⇒ outstanding
1
3
Facts: Batman is thoughtful [PERIOD] Batman is shiny [PERIOD] Batman is lonely [PERIOD] Batman is good [PERIOD] Batman is powerful [PERIOD] Batman is smart [PERIOD] Batman is vivacious [PERIOD] Batman is cooperative [PERIOD] Rules: uptight [IMPLY] inexpensive [PERIOD] good [AND] uptight [AND] thoughtful [IMPLY] gorgeo...
Proof chain: smart ⇒ gorgeous smart ⇒ excited cooperative ∧ gorgeous ∧ excited ⇒ difficult
1
3
Facts: Rules: cooperative [AND] amused [IMPLY] busy [PERIOD] busy [AND] cooperative [IMPLY] amused [PERIOD] amused [AND] busy [AND] cooperative [IMPLY] versatile [PERIOD] amused [AND] adorable [AND] busy [IMPLY] versatile [PERIOD] versatile [AND] amused [IMPLY] busy [PERIOD] cooperative [AND] adorable [IMPLY] amused [...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “amused ∧ busy ∧ cooperative ⇒ versatile” because missing: amused, busy, cooperative. Cannot apply rule “amused ∧ adorable ∧ busy ⇒ versatile” because missing: amused, adorable, busy. Cannot apply rule “cooperative ∧ amused ⇒ versatile” because missing: cooperative, amused.
0
3
Facts: Batman is modern [PERIOD] Batman is quaint [PERIOD] Batman is tense [PERIOD] Batman is powerful [PERIOD] Batman is intellectual [PERIOD] Rules: worrisome [AND] intellectual [AND] hilarious [IMPLY] muddy [PERIOD] combative [AND] quaint [IMPLY] light [PERIOD] jittery [IMPLY] powerful [PERIOD] quaint [IMPLY] power...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “jittery ⇒ hilarious” because missing: jittery. modern ⇒ worrisome Cannot apply rule “tense ∧ homely ∧ worrisome ⇒ hilarious” because missing: homely.
0
3
Facts: Batman is hilarious [PERIOD] Batman is ambitious [PERIOD] Batman is sensible [PERIOD] Rules: alert [IMPLY] stormy [PERIOD] rude [AND] lucky [AND] blushing [IMPLY] stormy [PERIOD] blushing [AND] crowded [AND] courageous [IMPLY] victorious [PERIOD] alert [IMPLY] adorable [PERIOD] impatient [IMPLY] crowded [PERIOD...
Proof chain: sensible ⇒ courageous courageous ⇒ alert alert ⇒ stormy
1
3
Facts: Rules: straightforward [AND] excited [IMPLY] reserved [PERIOD] impartial [IMPLY] impatient [PERIOD] worried [AND] polite [AND] spotless [IMPLY] aggressive [PERIOD] easy [AND] worried [IMPLY] helpless [PERIOD] worried [AND] spotless [IMPLY] polite [PERIOD] worried [AND] smart [AND] clumsy [IMPLY] easy [PERIOD] r...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “aggressive ∧ reserved ∧ worried ⇒ spotless” because missing: aggressive, reserved, worried. Cannot apply rule “impartial ⇒ spotless” because missing: impartial. Cannot apply rule “shiny ⇒ spotless” because missing: shiny.
0
3
Facts: Batman is intellectual [PERIOD] Batman is amused [PERIOD] Batman is powerful [PERIOD] Rules: attractive [AND] crowded [IMPLY] shy [PERIOD] vivacious [AND] adorable [AND] popular [IMPLY] stubborn [PERIOD] intellectual [AND] clumsy [AND] victorious [IMPLY] talkative [PERIOD] popular [IMPLY] jittery [PERIOD] cruel...
Proof chain: powerful ⇒ jittery jittery ⇒ stubborn stubborn ⇒ frail
1
3
Facts: Batman is wide-eyed [PERIOD] Batman is plain [PERIOD] Batman is enchanting [PERIOD] Batman is silly [PERIOD] Batman is average [PERIOD] Batman is fearless [PERIOD] Batman is exuberant [PERIOD] Batman is beautiful [PERIOD] Batman is strange [PERIOD] Batman is adorable [PERIOD] Rules: crowded [IMPLY] attractive [...
Proof chain: adorable ⇒ blushing strange ∧ blushing ⇒ crowded crowded ⇒ attractive
1
3
Facts: Batman is anxious [PERIOD] Batman is helpless [PERIOD] Batman is fancy [PERIOD] Batman is tense [PERIOD] Batman is frightened [PERIOD] Batman is difficult [PERIOD] Batman is wide-eyed [PERIOD] Batman is wandering [PERIOD] Batman is aggressive [PERIOD] Batman is busy [PERIOD] Batman is messy [PERIOD] Batman is a...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “wide-eyed ∧ lucky ∧ frightened ⇒ cute” because missing: lucky. Cannot apply rule “confused ∧ anxious ∧ fragile ⇒ cute” because missing: confused, fragile. Cannot apply rule “fancy ∧ fragile ∧ frightened ⇒ cute” because missing: fragile.
0
3
Facts: Batman is powerful [PERIOD] Batman is intellectual [PERIOD] Batman is proud [PERIOD] Batman is combative [PERIOD] Batman is hypocritical [PERIOD] Batman is thoughtless [PERIOD] Batman is tender [PERIOD] Batman is busy [PERIOD] Rules: hypocritical [IMPLY] anxious [PERIOD] inquisitive [AND] smart [AND] precious [...
Proof chain: busy ∧ proud ⇒ cooperative hypocritical ⇒ anxious cooperative ∧ anxious ∧ combative ⇒ precious
1
3
Facts: Batman is friendly [PERIOD] Batman is naughty [PERIOD] Batman is elegant [PERIOD] Batman is broad-minded [PERIOD] Batman is pessimistic [PERIOD] Batman is versatile [PERIOD] Batman is dull [PERIOD] Batman is scared [PERIOD] Batman is popular [PERIOD] Rules: friendly [AND] naughty [AND] versatile [IMPLY] popular...
Proof chain: friendly ∧ pessimistic ∧ versatile ⇒ strange dull ∧ strange ⇒ frantic versatile ∧ broad-minded ∧ frantic ⇒ disobedient
1
3
Facts: Batman is agreeable [PERIOD] Batman is difficult [PERIOD] Rules: exuberant [AND] agreeable [IMPLY] lucky [PERIOD] busy [AND] disobedient [AND] lucky [IMPLY] horrible [PERIOD] hilarious [AND] attentive [AND] exuberant [IMPLY] precious [PERIOD] agreeable [AND] inexpensive [IMPLY] exuberant [PERIOD] disobedient [A...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “blushing ∧ impartial ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: blushing, impartial. agreeable ⇒ busy Cannot apply rule “busy ∧ difficult ∧ precious ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: precious.
0
3
Facts: Batman is worried [PERIOD] Batman is stormy [PERIOD] Rules: stormy [IMPLY] silly [PERIOD] shiny [IMPLY] ugly [PERIOD] attentive [AND] silly [IMPLY] fine [PERIOD] impartial [AND] fine [AND] thoughtful [IMPLY] bright [PERIOD] scared [AND] diplomatic [AND] unpleasant [IMPLY] ugly [PERIOD] wide-eyed [AND] scared [I...
Proof chain: worried ⇒ distinct distinct ⇒ shiny shiny ⇒ ugly
1
3
Facts: Batman is rational [PERIOD] Rules: horrible [IMPLY] powerful [PERIOD] rational [AND] bad-tempered [AND] famous [IMPLY] modern [PERIOD] horrible [IMPLY] confused [PERIOD] impartial [IMPLY] helpful [PERIOD] bad-tempered [AND] worried [IMPLY] plain [PERIOD] adorable [AND] plain [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] outrageous ...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “powerful ∧ wrong ⇒ combative” because missing: powerful, wrong. Cannot apply rule “plain ∧ impartial ∧ polite ⇒ combative” because missing: plain, impartial, polite. Cannot apply rule “frantic ∧ plain ∧ worried ⇒ combative” because missing: frantic, plain, worried.
0
3
Facts: Batman is ambitious [PERIOD] Batman is tender [PERIOD] Batman is cooperative [PERIOD] Batman is fearless [PERIOD] Batman is rational [PERIOD] Batman is attractive [PERIOD] Batman is frantic [PERIOD] Rules: strange [AND] tender [AND] hypocritical [IMPLY] tired [PERIOD] wide-eyed [AND] inexpensive [AND] lucky [IM...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “tender ∧ innocent ∧ wide-eyed ⇒ courageous” because missing: innocent, wide-eyed. Cannot apply rule “stubborn ∧ innocent ∧ tired ⇒ courageous” because missing: stubborn, innocent, tired. Cannot apply rule “stubborn ∧ disgusted ∧ dull ⇒ courageous” because missing: stubborn, disg...
0
3
Facts: Batman is muddy [PERIOD] Batman is friendly [PERIOD] Batman is helpful [PERIOD] Batman is hypocritical [PERIOD] Batman is embarrassed [PERIOD] Batman is messy [PERIOD] Rules: friendly [AND] hypocritical [AND] messy [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD] spotless [AND] worried [AND] ugly [IMPLY] loving [PERIOD] hypocritical [AN...
Proof chain: embarrassed ⇒ agreeable embarrassed ∧ agreeable ∧ helpful ⇒ mysterious mysterious ⇒ worrisome
1
3
Facts: Rules: cute [IMPLY] popular [PERIOD] average [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] clean [AND] hurt [AND] famous [IMPLY] average [PERIOD] powerful [AND] popular [IMPLY] average [PERIOD] average [AND] wandering [AND] hurt [IMPLY] famous [PERIOD] busy [AND] famous [AND] popular [IMPLY] exuberant [PERIOD] frantic [IMPLY] avera...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “busy ∧ famous ∧ popular ⇒ exuberant” because missing: busy, famous, popular. Cannot apply rule “famous ∧ excited ⇒ exuberant” because missing: famous, excited. Cannot apply rule “wandering ∧ clean ∧ busy ⇒ exuberant” because missing: wandering, clean, busy.
0
3
Facts: Rules: gifted [IMPLY] confused [PERIOD] gifted [IMPLY] clumsy [PERIOD] ambitious [AND] wide-eyed [AND] confused [IMPLY] gifted [PERIOD] confused [IMPLY] thoughtful [PERIOD] thoughtful [IMPLY] gifted [PERIOD] cute [AND] fine [AND] ambitious [IMPLY] gifted [PERIOD] thoughtful [IMPLY] confused [PERIOD] wide-eyed [...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “gifted ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: gifted. Cannot apply rule “clumsy ∧ thoughtful ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: clumsy, thoughtful. Cannot apply rule “confused ∧ gifted ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: confused, gifted.
0
3
Facts: Rules: good [AND] embarrassed [IMPLY] confused [PERIOD] embarrassed [AND] pleasant [AND] reserved [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] crowded [AND] impartial [IMPLY] gifted [PERIOD] attractive [AND] gifted [IMPLY] confused [PERIOD] attractive [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] old-fashioned [AND] wandering [IMPLY] courageous [PE...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “good ∧ embarrassed ⇒ confused” because missing: good, embarrassed. Cannot apply rule “attractive ∧ gifted ⇒ confused” because missing: attractive, gifted. Cannot apply rule “crowded ∧ talkative ∧ inquisitive ⇒ confused” because missing: crowded, talkative, inquisitive.
0
3
Facts: Batman is inexpensive [PERIOD] Batman is bossy [PERIOD] Batman is scared [PERIOD] Batman is messy [PERIOD] Batman is gleaming [PERIOD] Rules: modern [AND] easy [AND] polite [IMPLY] supportive [PERIOD] polite [IMPLY] supportive [PERIOD] polite [AND] sleepy [IMPLY] messy [PERIOD] easy [IMPLY] enchanting [PERIOD] ...
Proof chain: inexpensive ⇒ curious scared ⇒ sleepy curious ∧ messy ∧ sleepy ⇒ naughty
1
3
Facts: Batman is supportive [PERIOD] Rules: outrageous [IMPLY] vivacious [PERIOD] silly [AND] loving [IMPLY] dull [PERIOD] supportive [IMPLY] strange [PERIOD] silly [AND] vivacious [AND] strange [IMPLY] outrageous [PERIOD] frantic [IMPLY] smart [PERIOD] supportive [AND] strange [IMPLY] lucky [PERIOD] silly [AND] dull ...
Proof chain: supportive ⇒ strange strange ⇒ outrageous outrageous ⇒ vivacious
1
3
Facts: Batman is straightforward [PERIOD] Rules: adorable [IMPLY] dishonest [PERIOD] straightforward [AND] scared [IMPLY] frail [PERIOD] charming [AND] scared [IMPLY] aggressive [PERIOD] aggressive [AND] grumpy [AND] dishonest [IMPLY] adorable [PERIOD] modern [IMPLY] adorable [PERIOD] diplomatic [AND] scared [AND] cha...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “aggressive ∧ grumpy ∧ dishonest ⇒ adorable” because missing: aggressive, grumpy, dishonest. Cannot apply rule “modern ⇒ adorable” because missing: modern. Cannot apply rule “fancy ∧ dishonest ∧ scared ⇒ adorable” because missing: fancy, dishonest, scared.
0
3
Facts: Batman is worrisome [PERIOD] Batman is inexpensive [PERIOD] Batman is jittery [PERIOD] Batman is uptight [PERIOD] Batman is ambitious [PERIOD] Batman is bright [PERIOD] Batman is diplomatic [PERIOD] Rules: diplomatic [IMPLY] blushing [PERIOD] busy [IMPLY] outstanding [PERIOD] inexpensive [AND] disgusted [IMPLY]...
Proof chain: diplomatic ⇒ blushing blushing ⇒ outstanding jittery ∧ outstanding ⇒ sensible
1
3
Facts: Rules: gleaming [AND] silly [AND] clumsy [IMPLY] cruel [PERIOD] thoughtless [AND] cruel [IMPLY] gleaming [PERIOD] cruel [IMPLY] fancy [PERIOD] fancy [IMPLY] diplomatic [PERIOD] diplomatic [AND] gleaming [IMPLY] cruel [PERIOD] thoughtless [IMPLY] cruel [PERIOD] thoughtless [IMPLY] clumsy [PERIOD] cruel [IMPLY] m...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “gleaming ∧ silly ∧ clumsy ⇒ cruel” because missing: gleaming, silly, clumsy. Cannot apply rule “diplomatic ∧ gleaming ⇒ cruel” because missing: diplomatic, gleaming. Cannot apply rule “thoughtless ⇒ cruel” because missing: thoughtless.
0
3
Facts: Batman is fancy [PERIOD] Batman is vivacious [PERIOD] Rules: sleepy [AND] dull [IMPLY] fancy [PERIOD] silly [IMPLY] fancy [PERIOD] dull [IMPLY] unpleasant [PERIOD] sleepy [AND] charming [AND] unpleasant [IMPLY] fancy [PERIOD] fancy [IMPLY] vivacious [PERIOD] sleepy [AND] vivacious [IMPLY] dull [PERIOD] dull [IM...
Proof chain: fancy ⇒ silly silly ⇒ dull dull ⇒ charming
1
3
Facts: Batman is shy [PERIOD] Batman is confident [PERIOD] Batman is exuberant [PERIOD] Batman is quaint [PERIOD] Batman is cooperative [PERIOD] Batman is helpful [PERIOD] Batman is gorgeous [PERIOD] Batman is frail [PERIOD] Batman is disobedient [PERIOD] Batman is popular [PERIOD] Batman is serious [PERIOD] Batman is...
Proof chain: disobedient ⇒ perfect exuberant ⇒ plain perfect ∧ quaint ∧ plain ⇒ worrisome
1
3
Facts: Batman is anxious [PERIOD] Batman is tender [PERIOD] Batman is zealous [PERIOD] Batman is exuberant [PERIOD] Batman is stormy [PERIOD] Batman is frantic [PERIOD] Batman is fearless [PERIOD] Rules: anxious [AND] muddy [AND] exuberant [IMPLY] foolish [PERIOD] anxious [IMPLY] careless [PERIOD] impartial [AND] fear...
Proof chain: anxious ⇒ careless frantic ⇒ witty careless ∧ zealous ∧ witty ⇒ impartial
1
3
Facts: Batman is wrong [PERIOD] Batman is calm [PERIOD] Rules: talkative [AND] anxious [AND] wrong [IMPLY] zealous [PERIOD] zealous [AND] calm [AND] ugly [IMPLY] talkative [PERIOD] average [AND] anxious [AND] ugly [IMPLY] zealous [PERIOD] calm [AND] worrisome [IMPLY] ugly [PERIOD] ugly [AND] anxious [AND] calm [IMPLY]...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “zealous ∧ calm ∧ ugly ⇒ talkative” because missing: zealous, ugly. Cannot apply rule “gorgeous ∧ zealous ∧ worrisome ⇒ talkative” because missing: gorgeous, zealous, worrisome. Cannot apply rule “anxious ⇒ talkative” because missing: anxious.
0
3
Facts: Batman is worrisome [PERIOD] Batman is precious [PERIOD] Batman is attractive [PERIOD] Batman is gifted [PERIOD] Rules: exuberant [AND] worrisome [IMPLY] courageous [PERIOD] attractive [AND] exuberant [IMPLY] wandering [PERIOD] exuberant [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] attractive [AND] elated [IMPLY] exuberant [PER...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “exuberant ∧ worrisome ⇒ courageous” because missing: exuberant. Cannot apply rule “exuberant ⇒ courageous” because missing: exuberant. Cannot apply rule “attractive ∧ elated ⇒ courageous” because missing: elated.
0
3
Facts: Batman is uptight [PERIOD] Batman is elegant [PERIOD] Rules: cruel [IMPLY] plain [PERIOD] rude [AND] plain [AND] impatient [IMPLY] uptight [PERIOD] impatient [AND] loving [AND] uptight [IMPLY] rude [PERIOD] loving [AND] uptight [AND] elegant [IMPLY] impatient [PERIOD] rude [AND] mean [AND] plain [IMPLY] cruel [...
Proof chain: elegant ⇒ cruel cruel ⇒ plain plain ⇒ mean
1
3
Facts: Batman is gorgeous [PERIOD] Batman is innocent [PERIOD] Batman is precious [PERIOD] Batman is bad-tempered [PERIOD] Batman is beautiful [PERIOD] Batman is alert [PERIOD] Batman is reserved [PERIOD] Batman is thoughtless [PERIOD] Batman is supportive [PERIOD] Batman is fearless [PERIOD] Rules: reserved [AND] tam...
Proof chain: alert ∧ reserved ∧ gorgeous ⇒ messy alert ∧ messy ⇒ homely homely ⇒ confident
1
3
Facts: Batman is helpless [PERIOD] Batman is perfect [PERIOD] Rules: inexpensive [AND] helpless [IMPLY] muddy [PERIOD] gifted [IMPLY] helpless [PERIOD] gifted [AND] muddy [IMPLY] hurt [PERIOD] perfect [AND] wrong [IMPLY] rational [PERIOD] helpless [AND] rational [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] inexpensive [AND] unpleasant...
Proof chain: helpless ⇒ inexpensive inexpensive ⇒ hurt perfect ∧ hurt ⇒ rational
1
3
Facts: Batman is shy [PERIOD] Batman is cooperative [PERIOD] Batman is strange [PERIOD] Batman is wrong [PERIOD] Batman is gorgeous [PERIOD] Batman is selfish [PERIOD] Rules: gorgeous [AND] modern [AND] grumpy [IMPLY] distinct [PERIOD] courageous [IMPLY] impatient [PERIOD] gorgeous [IMPLY] enchanting [PERIOD] selfish ...
Proof chain: gorgeous ⇒ modern wrong ⇒ courageous modern ∧ courageous ⇒ messy
1
3
Facts: Batman is busy [PERIOD] Batman is reserved [PERIOD] Batman is muddy [PERIOD] Rules: cooperative [AND] cruel [IMPLY] busy [PERIOD] cruel [AND] cooperative [AND] hilarious [IMPLY] proud [PERIOD] hilarious [IMPLY] talkative [PERIOD] busy [AND] muddy [IMPLY] ugliest [PERIOD] ugliest [AND] busy [AND] cooperative [IM...
Proof chain: busy ∧ muddy ⇒ ugliest muddy ∧ busy ∧ ugliest ⇒ hilarious hilarious ⇒ talkative
1
3
Facts: Rules: jittery [AND] rude [IMPLY] confident [PERIOD] plain [AND] jittery [IMPLY] condemned [PERIOD] foolish [AND] confident [IMPLY] rude [PERIOD] condemned [AND] gorgeous [AND] foolish [IMPLY] jittery [PERIOD] confident [AND] plain [IMPLY] ugliest [PERIOD] foolish [AND] rude [AND] confident [IMPLY] plain [PERIO...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “foolish ∧ confident ⇒ rude” because missing: foolish, confident. Cannot apply rule “confident ∧ gorgeous ∧ plain ⇒ rude” because missing: confident, gorgeous, plain. Cannot apply rule “plain ∧ ugliest ⇒ rude” because missing: plain, ugliest.
0
3
Facts: Batman is tired [PERIOD] Batman is witty [PERIOD] Batman is enchanting [PERIOD] Batman is outrageous [PERIOD] Batman is perfect [PERIOD] Batman is unpleasant [PERIOD] Batman is wide-eyed [PERIOD] Batman is spotless [PERIOD] Batman is ugliest [PERIOD] Rules: spotless [AND] fearless [AND] perfect [IMPLY] unpleasa...
Proof chain: outrageous ⇒ adorable adorable ⇒ excited spotless ∧ excited ⇒ horrible
1
3
Facts: Rules: nervous [IMPLY] clean [PERIOD] pessimistic [AND] wandering [IMPLY] wide-eyed [PERIOD] excited [AND] frantic [IMPLY] condemned [PERIOD] helpful [AND] wandering [IMPLY] sensible [PERIOD] condemned [AND] careless [AND] wide-eyed [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] clean [AND] careless [AND] frantic [IMPLY] nervous [PE...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “pessimistic ∧ wandering ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: pessimistic, wandering. Cannot apply rule “curious ∧ wandering ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: curious, wandering. Cannot apply rule “pessimistic ∧ careless ⇒ wide-eyed” because missing: pessimistic, careless.
0
3
Facts: Batman is elated [PERIOD] Batman is wide-eyed [PERIOD] Batman is smart [PERIOD] Batman is glamorous [PERIOD] Batman is exuberant [PERIOD] Batman is friendly [PERIOD] Rules: joyous [AND] talented [IMPLY] versatile [PERIOD] impartial [IMPLY] agreeable [PERIOD] agreeable [AND] elegant [AND] joyous [IMPLY] victorio...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “joyous ∧ talented ⇒ versatile” because missing: joyous, talented. wide-eyed ⇒ gleaming Cannot apply rule “gleaming ∧ perfect ∧ friendly ⇒ versatile” because missing: perfect.
0
3
Facts: Rules: tired [AND] inexpensive [IMPLY] worried [PERIOD] tender [AND] attractive [IMPLY] tired [PERIOD] gorgeous [IMPLY] tired [PERIOD] worried [IMPLY] tired [PERIOD] tired [IMPLY] tender [PERIOD] worried [AND] inexpensive [AND] tender [IMPLY] attractive [PERIOD] tender [IMPLY] worried [PERIOD] attractive [IMPLY...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “tired ∧ attractive ⇒ gorgeous” because missing: tired, attractive. Cannot apply rule “worried ∧ attractive ∧ tired ⇒ gorgeous” because missing: worried, attractive, tired. Cannot apply rule “attractive ⇒ gorgeous” because missing: attractive.
0
3
Facts: Batman is agreeable [PERIOD] Batman is friendly [PERIOD] Batman is outrageous [PERIOD] Rules: ugliest [AND] distinct [IMPLY] inexpensive [PERIOD] glamorous [AND] tidy [IMPLY] tired [PERIOD] light [AND] inquisitive [IMPLY] impartial [PERIOD] stupid [AND] impartial [IMPLY] distinct [PERIOD] friendly [AND] glamoro...
Proof chain: outrageous ⇒ tense tense ⇒ fearless fearless ⇒ enchanting
1
3
Facts: Batman is frantic [PERIOD] Batman is careless [PERIOD] Batman is combative [PERIOD] Batman is curious [PERIOD] Batman is diplomatic [PERIOD] Rules: talkative [IMPLY] shy [PERIOD] frantic [AND] combative [IMPLY] spotless [PERIOD] amused [AND] witty [AND] shy [IMPLY] careless [PERIOD] curious [AND] ugliest [IMPLY...
Proof chain: frantic ⇒ shy shy ∧ careless ∧ diplomatic ⇒ proud Cannot apply rule “proud ∧ jittery ⇒ ugliest” because missing: jittery.
0
3
Facts: Batman is thoughtful [PERIOD] Rules: adorable [IMPLY] light [PERIOD] homely [AND] adorable [IMPLY] sincere [PERIOD] sincere [AND] thoughtful [IMPLY] adorable [PERIOD] sincere [IMPLY] thoughtful [PERIOD] light [IMPLY] talkative [PERIOD] talkative [IMPLY] sincere [PERIOD] talkative [AND] thoughtful [IMPLY] light ...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “homely ∧ adorable ⇒ sincere” because missing: homely, adorable. Cannot apply rule “talkative ⇒ sincere” because missing: talkative. Cannot apply rule “thoughtful ∧ adorable ⇒ sincere” because missing: adorable.
0
3
Facts: Batman is fine [PERIOD] Batman is naughty [PERIOD] Batman is impatient [PERIOD] Batman is rational [PERIOD] Batman is frantic [PERIOD] Rules: busy [IMPLY] cruel [PERIOD] cruel [AND] naughty [IMPLY] fine [PERIOD] distinct [IMPLY] adorable [PERIOD] fine [AND] loving [IMPLY] adorable [PERIOD] gleaming [IMPLY] gift...
Proof chain: rational ⇒ distinct distinct ⇒ helpless helpless ⇒ dishonest
1
3
Facts: Batman is gleaming [PERIOD] Batman is disobedient [PERIOD] Batman is naughty [PERIOD] Batman is unpleasant [PERIOD] Batman is thoughtless [PERIOD] Batman is attentive [PERIOD] Batman is easy [PERIOD] Batman is attractive [PERIOD] Batman is serious [PERIOD] Batman is wrong [PERIOD] Batman is hypocritical [PERIOD...
Proof chain: attentive ⇒ bored frightened ∧ serious ∧ hypocritical ⇒ disgusted bored ∧ disgusted ⇒ helpless
1
3
Facts: Rules: excited [AND] shy [IMPLY] easy [PERIOD] silly [AND] joyous [AND] mean [IMPLY] excited [PERIOD] joyous [AND] easy [AND] mean [IMPLY] excited [PERIOD] joyous [IMPLY] excited [PERIOD] grumpy [AND] excited [AND] shy [IMPLY] joyous [PERIOD] mean [IMPLY] calm [PERIOD] grumpy [AND] witty [AND] silly [IMPLY] cal...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “mean ⇒ calm” because missing: mean. Cannot apply rule “grumpy ∧ witty ∧ silly ⇒ calm” because missing: grumpy, witty, silly. Cannot apply rule “shy ∧ grumpy ∧ wandering ⇒ calm” because missing: shy, grumpy, wandering.
0
3
Facts: Batman is wide-eyed [PERIOD] Rules: tidy [AND] fine [AND] wide-eyed [IMPLY] disobedient [PERIOD] wide-eyed [AND] victorious [AND] tidy [IMPLY] disobedient [PERIOD] hurt [IMPLY] disobedient [PERIOD] wide-eyed [AND] victorious [IMPLY] tidy [PERIOD] disobedient [AND] tidy [IMPLY] wide-eyed [PERIOD] troubled [IMPLY...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “tidy ∧ fine ∧ wide-eyed ⇒ disobedient” because missing: tidy, fine. Cannot apply rule “wide-eyed ∧ victorious ∧ tidy ⇒ disobedient” because missing: victorious, tidy. Cannot apply rule “hurt ⇒ disobedient” because missing: hurt.
0
3
Facts: Batman is innocent [PERIOD] Batman is frightened [PERIOD] Batman is weary [PERIOD] Rules: frightened [AND] muddy [AND] difficult [IMPLY] aggressive [PERIOD] frightened [IMPLY] weary [PERIOD] frightened [AND] polite [IMPLY] difficult [PERIOD] frightened [IMPLY] bright [PERIOD] polite [AND] bright [IMPLY] elated ...
Proof chain: frightened ⇒ bright weary ⇒ aggressive bright ∧ aggressive ⇒ muddy
1
3
Facts: Batman is shiny [PERIOD] Batman is cruel [PERIOD] Batman is comfortable [PERIOD] Batman is ugly [PERIOD] Rules: tense [AND] comfortable [AND] gorgeous [IMPLY] combative [PERIOD] tense [AND] selfish [IMPLY] confused [PERIOD] tense [AND] selfish [AND] comfortable [IMPLY] anxious [PERIOD] combative [IMPLY] cruel [...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “selfish ∧ combative ∧ outrageous ⇒ clean” because missing: selfish, combative, outrageous. Cannot apply rule “shiny ∧ anxious ⇒ clean” because missing: anxious. Cannot apply rule “impartial ∧ combative ∧ outrageous ⇒ clean” because missing: impartial, combative, outrageous.
0
3
Facts: Batman is shiny [PERIOD] Batman is innocent [PERIOD] Batman is intellectual [PERIOD] Batman is impartial [PERIOD] Batman is versatile [PERIOD] Batman is straightforward [PERIOD] Batman is mean [PERIOD] Batman is nervous [PERIOD] Batman is foolish [PERIOD] Batman is joyous [PERIOD] Batman is dishonest [PERIOD] R...
Proof chain: shiny ⇒ light intellectual ∧ light ⇒ stubborn stubborn ⇒ cooperative
1
3
Facts: Batman is worrisome [PERIOD] Rules: bored [AND] scared [IMPLY] crowded [PERIOD] worried [AND] sleepy [AND] crowded [IMPLY] worrisome [PERIOD] bored [IMPLY] crowded [PERIOD] sincere [AND] scared [AND] worried [IMPLY] bored [PERIOD] sleepy [IMPLY] bored [PERIOD] sleepy [IMPLY] scared [PERIOD] worried [IMPLY] scar...
Proof chain: worrisome ⇒ bored bored ⇒ scared scared ⇒ sleepy
1
3
Facts: Rules: uptight [IMPLY] serious [PERIOD] stormy [AND] precious [IMPLY] anxious [PERIOD] confused [IMPLY] precious [PERIOD] sleepy [AND] confused [AND] stormy [IMPLY] versatile [PERIOD] polite [AND] lucky [AND] confused [IMPLY] precious [PERIOD] frantic [IMPLY] serious [PERIOD] stormy [AND] polite [AND] frantic [...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “uptight ⇒ serious” because missing: uptight. Cannot apply rule “frantic ⇒ serious” because missing: frantic. Cannot apply rule “confident ∧ stormy ⇒ serious” because missing: confident, stormy.
0
3
Facts: Batman is lonely [PERIOD] Batman is joyous [PERIOD] Batman is silly [PERIOD] Batman is reserved [PERIOD] Batman is scared [PERIOD] Batman is charming [PERIOD] Batman is tame [PERIOD] Batman is average [PERIOD] Batman is zealous [PERIOD] Batman is impatient [PERIOD] Rules: reserved [AND] serious [AND] average [I...
Proof chain: charming ⇒ attractive attractive ⇒ rude rude ⇒ troubled
1
3
Facts: Batman is zealous [PERIOD] Batman is diplomatic [PERIOD] Batman is adorable [PERIOD] Rules: unpleasant [AND] zealous [IMPLY] diplomatic [PERIOD] zealous [AND] smart [AND] horrible [IMPLY] adorable [PERIOD] unpleasant [AND] charming [AND] gorgeous [IMPLY] diplomatic [PERIOD] charming [IMPLY] smart [PERIOD] gorge...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “gorgeous ∧ zealous ∧ adorable ⇒ horrible” because missing: gorgeous. Cannot apply rule “charming ⇒ horrible” because missing: charming. Cannot apply rule “smart ∧ hypocritical ∧ adorable ⇒ horrible” because missing: smart, hypocritical.
0
3
Facts: Batman is wandering [PERIOD] Batman is clumsy [PERIOD] Rules: alert [IMPLY] light [PERIOD] amused [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD] helpless [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD] light [IMPLY] troubled [PERIOD] light [IMPLY] perfect [PERIOD] unpleasant [AND] amused [AND] helpless [IMPLY] alert [PERIOD] unpleasant [AND] clumsy [IMPLY] wa...
Proof chain: clumsy ⇒ troubled troubled ∧ wandering ⇒ helpless helpless ⇒ alert
1
3
Facts: Batman is tidy [PERIOD] Batman is average [PERIOD] Rules: average [AND] enchanting [IMPLY] tense [PERIOD] tense [AND] modern [IMPLY] elegant [PERIOD] friendly [AND] ambitious [AND] troubled [IMPLY] average [PERIOD] friendly [AND] troubled [IMPLY] perfect [PERIOD] blushing [AND] helpful [IMPLY] exuberant [PERIOD...
Proof chain: average ⇒ perfect perfect ⇒ troubled tidy ∧ troubled ⇒ ambitious
1
3
Facts: Rules: impartial [AND] hilarious [AND] modern [IMPLY] spotless [PERIOD] shiny [AND] scared [IMPLY] distinct [PERIOD] shy [IMPLY] ambitious [PERIOD] fine [IMPLY] impartial [PERIOD] different [IMPLY] fine [PERIOD] scared [AND] amused [IMPLY] different [PERIOD] fine [IMPLY] distinct [PERIOD] shiny [AND] cruel [AND...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “different ⇒ fine” because missing: different. Cannot apply rule “impartial ∧ silly ⇒ fine” because missing: impartial, silly. Cannot apply rule “scared ∧ careless ⇒ fine” because missing: scared, careless.
0
3
Facts: Batman is impatient [PERIOD] Batman is supportive [PERIOD] Batman is horrible [PERIOD] Batman is fine [PERIOD] Batman is precious [PERIOD] Rules: crowded [AND] talkative [AND] proud [IMPLY] rational [PERIOD] comfortable [AND] proud [IMPLY] easy [PERIOD] hurt [AND] troubled [IMPLY] talkative [PERIOD] worried [AN...
Proof chain: impatient ⇒ cooperative cooperative ∧ impatient ⇒ hurt hurt ⇒ clumsy
1
3
Facts: Batman is busy [PERIOD] Batman is amused [PERIOD] Batman is bright [PERIOD] Batman is foolish [PERIOD] Batman is precious [PERIOD] Batman is rational [PERIOD] Rules: vivacious [IMPLY] bright [PERIOD] cruel [AND] gorgeous [AND] busy [IMPLY] bright [PERIOD] supportive [IMPLY] bright [PERIOD] bright [AND] tidy [AN...
Proof chain: amused ⇒ talented talented ∧ busy ⇒ comfortable Cannot apply rule “tidy ∧ comfortable ∧ cruel ⇒ versatile” because missing: tidy, cruel.
0
3
Facts: Rules: ugly [AND] silly [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] reserved [AND] wide-eyed [AND] careless [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] different [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] ugly [AND] careless [AND] old-fashioned [IMPLY] long [PERIOD] confident [AND] pessimistic [AND] different [IMPLY] cooperative [PERIOD] impatient [AND] ugly [AND] d...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “dull ∧ courageous ∧ different ⇒ innocent” because missing: dull, courageous, different. Cannot apply rule “wide-eyed ∧ careless ∧ pessimistic ⇒ innocent” because missing: wide-eyed, careless, pessimistic. Cannot apply rule “different ∧ ugly ⇒ innocent” because missing: different...
0
3
Facts: Batman is inexpensive [PERIOD] Batman is frantic [PERIOD] Batman is dull [PERIOD] Batman is rational [PERIOD] Batman is excited [PERIOD] Batman is modern [PERIOD] Batman is blushing [PERIOD] Batman is impartial [PERIOD] Batman is pessimistic [PERIOD] Rules: blushing [AND] homely [AND] dull [IMPLY] gifted [PERIO...
Proof chain: impartial ⇒ innocent dull ⇒ mysterious innocent ∧ mysterious ⇒ polite
1
3
Facts: Batman is intellectual [PERIOD] Batman is excited [PERIOD] Batman is naughty [PERIOD] Batman is hurt [PERIOD] Batman is supportive [PERIOD] Batman is friendly [PERIOD] Batman is polite [PERIOD] Batman is strange [PERIOD] Rules: strange [IMPLY] grumpy [PERIOD] straightforward [IMPLY] ugliest [PERIOD] hurt [IMPLY...
Proof chain: hurt ⇒ old-fashioned old-fashioned ⇒ gifted gifted ⇒ loving
1
3
Facts: Batman is light [PERIOD] Rules: bad-tempered [AND] tame [AND] rude [IMPLY] different [PERIOD] bad-tempered [AND] inexpensive [AND] different [IMPLY] inquisitive [PERIOD] rude [AND] inquisitive [AND] bad-tempered [IMPLY] light [PERIOD] bad-tempered [AND] different [IMPLY] inquisitive [PERIOD] inexpensive [IMPLY]...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “bad-tempered ∧ tame ∧ rude ⇒ different” because missing: bad-tempered, tame, rude. Cannot apply rule “bad-tempered ⇒ different” because missing: bad-tempered. Cannot apply rule “inexpensive ∧ inquisitive ∧ light ⇒ different” because missing: inexpensive, inquisitive.
0
3
Facts: Batman is excited [PERIOD] Batman is selfish [PERIOD] Batman is unpleasant [PERIOD] Batman is gifted [PERIOD] Batman is frightened [PERIOD] Batman is vivacious [PERIOD] Batman is charming [PERIOD] Batman is easy [PERIOD] Rules: fearless [AND] outstanding [AND] easy [IMPLY] excited [PERIOD] selfish [AND] easy [I...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “frightened ∧ vivacious ∧ outstanding ⇒ curious” because missing: outstanding. Cannot apply rule “tired ∧ charming ∧ vivacious ⇒ curious” because missing: tired. Cannot apply rule “modern ∧ gifted ∧ easy ⇒ curious” because missing: modern.
0
3
Facts: Batman is worrisome [PERIOD] Batman is polite [PERIOD] Batman is excited [PERIOD] Rules: helpful [AND] polite [IMPLY] confident [PERIOD] diplomatic [AND] outrageous [IMPLY] loving [PERIOD] gifted [IMPLY] excited [PERIOD] diplomatic [AND] precious [IMPLY] outrageous [PERIOD] confident [AND] diplomatic [AND] thou...
Proof chain: excited ⇒ gifted worrisome ∧ gifted ⇒ outrageous outrageous ⇒ sleepy
1
3
Facts: Batman is smart [PERIOD] Batman is glamorous [PERIOD] Batman is tame [PERIOD] Batman is dull [PERIOD] Rules: bad-tempered [IMPLY] tame [PERIOD] strange [IMPLY] clean [PERIOD] glamorous [AND] mean [AND] tidy [IMPLY] plain [PERIOD] dishonest [IMPLY] clean [PERIOD] wandering [AND] plain [IMPLY] rude [PERIOD] mean ...
Proof chain: glamorous ⇒ plain glamorous ∧ plain ⇒ messy messy ⇒ strange
1
3
Facts: Rules: talkative [IMPLY] glamorous [PERIOD] talkative [AND] glamorous [AND] frantic [IMPLY] rude [PERIOD] talkative [AND] frantic [IMPLY] glamorous [PERIOD] rude [IMPLY] glamorous [PERIOD] frantic [AND] hurt [IMPLY] talkative [PERIOD] rude [IMPLY] talkative [PERIOD] frantic [AND] talkative [AND] hurt [IMPLY] ru...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “talkative ∧ glamorous ∧ frantic ⇒ rude” because missing: talkative, glamorous, frantic. Cannot apply rule “frantic ∧ talkative ∧ hurt ⇒ rude” because missing: frantic, talkative, hurt. Cannot apply rule “glamorous ∧ hurt ⇒ rude” because missing: glamorous, hurt.
0
3
Facts: Batman is hurt [PERIOD] Batman is shiny [PERIOD] Batman is dull [PERIOD] Batman is talkative [PERIOD] Batman is homely [PERIOD] Batman is clumsy [PERIOD] Batman is popular [PERIOD] Batman is selfish [PERIOD] Batman is glamorous [PERIOD] Batman is pessimistic [PERIOD] Batman is rational [PERIOD] Batman is comfor...
Proof chain: comfortable ∧ tender ⇒ innocent homely ∧ rational ∧ dull ⇒ blushing innocent ∧ blushing ⇒ powerful
1
3
Facts: Batman is pleasant [PERIOD] Batman is different [PERIOD] Batman is thoughtless [PERIOD] Batman is impartial [PERIOD] Batman is selfish [PERIOD] Rules: selfish [IMPLY] bossy [PERIOD] impartial [IMPLY] different [PERIOD] ugliest [AND] disobedient [IMPLY] good [PERIOD] frightened [AND] different [AND] pleasant [IM...
Proof chain: pleasant ⇒ impatient impartial ⇒ joyous impatient ∧ joyous ∧ pleasant ⇒ ugliest
1
3
Facts: Batman is smart [PERIOD] Rules: stubborn [IMPLY] plain [PERIOD] plain [IMPLY] fancy [PERIOD] plain [AND] stubborn [AND] fancy [IMPLY] smart [PERIOD] smart [AND] plain [IMPLY] stubborn [PERIOD] curious [IMPLY] smart [PERIOD] fancy [AND] plain [AND] curious [IMPLY] smart [PERIOD] smart [AND] curious [IMPLY] fancy...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “plain ⇒ fancy” because missing: plain. Cannot apply rule “smart ∧ curious ⇒ fancy” because missing: curious. Cannot apply rule “plain ∧ curious ⇒ fancy” because missing: plain, curious.
0
3
Facts: Batman is messy [PERIOD] Rules: zealous [AND] busy [IMPLY] versatile [PERIOD] reserved [IMPLY] talented [PERIOD] alert [AND] reserved [AND] talented [IMPLY] bored [PERIOD] bored [AND] alert [IMPLY] messy [PERIOD] scared [AND] zealous [AND] busy [IMPLY] versatile [PERIOD] messy [AND] fine [IMPLY] versatile [PERI...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “scared ⇒ weary” because missing: scared. Cannot apply rule “busy ∧ scared ∧ alert ⇒ weary” because missing: busy, scared, alert. Cannot apply rule “versatile ∧ excited ⇒ weary” because missing: versatile, excited.
0
3
Facts: Rules: foolish [AND] condemned [IMPLY] supportive [PERIOD] wrong [AND] foolish [IMPLY] horrible [PERIOD] loving [AND] inexpensive [IMPLY] supportive [PERIOD] foolish [IMPLY] condemned [PERIOD] mysterious [AND] helpful [AND] gleaming [IMPLY] charming [PERIOD] foolish [AND] helpful [IMPLY] frantic [PERIOD] charmi...
Proof chain: Cannot apply rule “unpleasant ⇒ inexpensive” because missing: unpleasant. Cannot apply rule “elegant ⇒ inexpensive” because missing: elegant. Cannot apply rule “attentive ⇒ inexpensive” because missing: attentive.
0
3
Facts: Batman is good [PERIOD] Batman is combative [PERIOD] Batman is difficult [PERIOD] Batman is uptight [PERIOD] Batman is wandering [PERIOD] Batman is pleasant [PERIOD] Batman is tame [PERIOD] Rules: inexpensive [IMPLY] rational [PERIOD] talkative [IMPLY] tidy [PERIOD] good [AND] fearless [IMPLY] unpleasant [PERIO...
Proof chain: tame ⇒ fearless fearless ⇒ old-fashioned old-fashioned ⇒ inexpensive
1
3
Facts: Batman is exuberant [PERIOD] Batman is helpless [PERIOD] Batman is elated [PERIOD] Batman is talkative [PERIOD] Batman is joyous [PERIOD] Batman is tidy [PERIOD] Batman is excited [PERIOD] Batman is fine [PERIOD] Rules: thoughtless [IMPLY] amused [PERIOD] thoughtless [IMPLY] supportive [PERIOD] ugliest [IMPLY] ...
Proof chain: excited ⇒ supportive supportive ⇒ amused amused ⇒ friendly
1
3