cris177/Arguments2 · Datasets at Hugging Face

If officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene then the arson occurred on elm street, and officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene, therefore the arson occurred on elm street. stringlengths 74 421	If officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene then the arson occurred on elm street stringlengths 36 192	Officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene stringclasses 788 values	The arson occurred on Elm Street stringclasses 788 values	modus ponen stringclasses 2 values	Officer Smith found a broken window at the crime scene stringclasses 394 values	The arson occurred on Elm Street.1 stringclasses 394 values	Officer Smith did not find a broken window at the crime scene stringclasses 394 values	The arson did not occur on Elm Street stringclasses 394 values	True bool 1 class
If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.	If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	modus tollen	A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.	If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	modus tollen	A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.	If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	modus tollen	A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.	If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	modus tollen	A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house, since if a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	modus tollen	A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house, because if a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	modus tollen	A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house, as if a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	modus tollen	A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, hence the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, thus the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, so the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, since if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis was found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, because if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis was found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, as if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis was found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
John davis was not found with a bag of cash, since if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
John davis was not found with a bag of cash, because if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
John davis was not found with a bag of cash, as if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	modus tollen	John Davis was found with a bag of cash	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis was not found with a bag of cash	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, hence the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, thus the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, so the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, since if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and laura's mail was tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, because if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and laura's mail was tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, as if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and laura's mail was tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that laura's mail was not tampered with.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
Laura's mail was not tampered with, since if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
Laura's mail was not tampered with, because if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
Laura's mail was not tampered with, as if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	modus tollen	Laura's mail was tampered with	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura's mail was not tampered with	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, hence the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, thus the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, so the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, since if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, because if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, as if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
No bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, since if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
No bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, because if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
No bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, as if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	modus tollen	A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson occurred on Elm Street	No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, hence the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, thus the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, so the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, since if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, because if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
The arson occurred on elm street, as if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	John davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
John davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck, since if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
John davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck, because if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
John davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck, as if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.	If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street	The arson did not occur on elm street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	modus tollen	John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck	The arson occurred on Elm Street	John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, hence the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, thus the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true
If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, so the arson occurred on elm street.	If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	modus ponen	Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson occurred on Elm Street	Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently	The arson did not occur on Elm Street	true

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

modus tollen

A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

modus tollen

A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

modus tollen

A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that no neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house.

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

modus tollen

A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house, since if a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

modus tollen

A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house, because if a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

modus tollen

A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house, as if a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If a neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside laura's house then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

modus tollen

A neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No neighbor reported seeing a flickering light inside Laura's house

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, hence the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, thus the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, so the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis was found with a bag of cash, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, since if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis was found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, because if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis was found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, as if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis was found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that john davis was not found with a bag of cash.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

John davis was not found with a bag of cash, since if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

John davis was not found with a bag of cash, because if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

John davis was not found with a bag of cash, as if john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If john davis was found with a bag of cash then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

modus tollen

John Davis was found with a bag of cash

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis was not found with a bag of cash

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, hence the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, thus the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, so the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura's mail was tampered with, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, since if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and laura's mail was tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, because if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and laura's mail was tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, as if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and laura's mail was tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that laura's mail was not tampered with.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

Laura's mail was not tampered with, since if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

Laura's mail was not tampered with, because if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

Laura's mail was not tampered with, as if laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If laura's mail was tampered with then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

modus tollen

Laura's mail was tampered with

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura's mail was not tampered with

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, hence the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, thus the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, so the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, since if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, because if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, as if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

A bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that no bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

No bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, since if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

No bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, because if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

No bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office, as if a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If a bloodstained letter was discovered in laura's office then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

modus tollen

A bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson occurred on Elm Street

No bloodstained letter was discovered in Laura's office

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, hence the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, thus the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, so the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, which implies that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, which shows that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck, which establishes that the arson occurred on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, since if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, because if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

The arson occurred on elm street, as if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and john davis had scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

John davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, therefore john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, hence john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, thus john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so it can be concluded that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, so john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which implies that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which shows that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street, and the arson did not occur on elm street, which establishes that john davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

John davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck, since if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

John davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck, because if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

John davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck, as if john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street and the arson did not occur on elm street.

If john davis had scratches on his arms and neck then the arson occurred on elm street

The arson did not occur on elm street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

modus tollen

John Davis had scratches on his arms and neck

The arson occurred on Elm Street

John Davis did not have scratches on his arms and neck

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, hence the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, thus the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, so it can be concluded that the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street, and laura had a history of changing her locks frequently, so the arson occurred on elm street.

If laura had a history of changing her locks frequently then the arson occurred on elm street

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

modus ponen

Laura had a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson occurred on Elm Street

Laura did not have a history of changing her locks frequently

The arson did not occur on Elm Street

true