Search is not available for this dataset
If officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene then the arson occurred on elm street, and officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene, therefore the arson occurred on elm street.
stringlengths
74
421
If officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene then the arson occurred on elm street
stringlengths
36
192
Officer smith found a broken window at the crime scene
stringclasses
788 values
The arson occurred on Elm Street
stringclasses
788 values
modus ponen
stringclasses
2 values
Officer Smith found a broken window at the crime scene
stringclasses
394 values
The arson occurred on Elm Street.1
stringclasses
394 values
Officer Smith did not find a broken window at the crime scene
stringclasses
394 values
The arson did not occur on Elm Street
stringclasses
394 values
True
bool
1 class
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, because if a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, as if a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, therefore no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, hence no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, thus no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so it can be concluded that no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which implies that no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which shows that no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which establishes that no hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
No hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom, since if a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
No hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom, because if a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
No hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom, as if a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a hidden camera was found in laura's bedroom then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
modus tollen
A hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No hidden camera was found in Laura's bedroom
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, therefore the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, hence the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, thus the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, so it can be concluded that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, so the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, which implies that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, which shows that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs, which establishes that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, since if john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, because if john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, as if john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, therefore john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, hence john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, thus john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so it can be concluded that john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which implies that john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which shows that john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which establishes that john davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
John davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs, since if john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
John davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs, because if john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
John davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs, as if john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a collection of disturbing photographs then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
modus tollen
John Davis had a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a collection of disturbing photographs
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, therefore the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, hence the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, thus the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, so it can be concluded that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, so the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, which implies that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, which shows that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and laura's dog was found locked in a closet, which establishes that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, since if laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and laura's dog was found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, because if laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and laura's dog was found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, as if laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and laura's dog was found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, therefore laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, hence laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, thus laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so it can be concluded that laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which implies that laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which shows that laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which establishes that laura's dog was not found locked in a closet.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet, since if laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet, because if laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet, as if laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If laura's dog was found locked in a closet then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
modus tollen
Laura's dog was found locked in a closet
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
Laura's dog was not found locked in a closet
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, therefore the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, hence the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, thus the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, so it can be concluded that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, so the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, which implies that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, which shows that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, which establishes that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, since if a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, because if a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, as if a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
A cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, therefore no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, hence no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, thus no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so it can be concluded that no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which implies that no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which shows that no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which establishes that no cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
No cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, since if a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
No cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, because if a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
No cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen, as if a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If a cryptic message was left on laura's computer screen then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
modus tollen
A cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
No cryptic message was left on Laura's computer screen
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, therefore the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, hence the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, thus the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, so it can be concluded that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, so the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, which implies that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, which shows that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone, which establishes that the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, since if john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, because if john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, as if john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
modus ponen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, therefore john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, hence john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, thus john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so it can be concluded that john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, so john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which implies that john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which shows that john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed, and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed, which establishes that john davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
John davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone, since if john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true
John davis did not have a recorded argument with laura on his phone, because if john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed and the cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed.
If john davis had a recorded argument with laura on his phone then the cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
modus tollen
John Davis had a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is sleeping soundly on the bed
John Davis did not have a recorded argument with Laura on his phone
The cat is not sleeping soundly on the bed
true