video_id large_stringlengths 11 11 | video_link large_stringlengths 43 43 | title large_stringlengths 3 100 | text large_stringlengths 351 674k | channel large_stringlengths 1 86 | channel_id large_stringlengths 24 24 | date large_stringlengths 10 10 | license large_stringclasses 1 value | original_language large_stringclasses 1 value | language_id_method large_stringclasses 2 values | transcription_language large_stringclasses 1 value | word_count int64 101 112k | character_count int64 351 674k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6TW9EHCAosE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6TW9EHCAosE | This VIM Mode Freaks Me Out | so I was scrolling through Reddit the other day as you do and I came across something that is very interesting so I want to share that with you today so there is a Vim mode that allows you to use it in a very non-vim-like way and it's called easy mode now I saw this I was like them doesn't have an easy mode Vim is notoriously hard to exit it's so hard to exit that has become a meme right it's not supposed to be easy you're supposed to have to learn it that's the point of them right it's kind of like having a easy mode for emacs or something like that you know it's just it's antithetical to the purpose of the thing right but no there is actually an easy mode for vim and it is really really weird so let me show you what it looks like so first I should give credit where credit is due the original discovery of this although I'm sure it's probably not the first discovery of it came from this blog here learn by example I'll link it in the video description below but I did I wanted to give credit just because you know that's what you should do but anyways let me show you what vim's easy mode looks like so in order to get into Vim easy mode you type in vim and then you do the dash y option and then you'd give the name of the file that you want to edit or create so I'm just going to do test Dot txt now out of the bat it still kind of looks like Vim right there's not much here you will notice though if you have a Vim RC or NVM RC or something like that it will not follow your vemarc as far as I can tell not a big deal because you're not going to be using this for very long and the one thing you'll also notice is that it automatically puts you in insert mode now theoretically this could be good I suppose it would save you from having to actually you know press the I key in order to get into insert mode if you just wanted to hop right into something and start you know writing but that's not really the idea here the idea here is that you can you know type you know as you do all this very awesome Pros that I'm you know putting down here and then you can use your mouse so if I wanted to do do this I could highlight this and then start typing again and it actually replaced that and if I wanted to you know do the same thing here I could the Linux cast you know whatever you know it it's that's weird because that's not the way them works but also let's just say you wanted to quit how would you quit and save well in normal Vim you do colon WQ but obviously you're in insert mode so to get out of any kind of mode that is not normal mode you'd normally escape and you'd think oh wait a whole thing what did that do right you hit escape and insert goes away and then it comes right back insert goes the Escape key doesn't work the Escape key doesn't work with what's going on here the Escape key is like the most important vimkey you know some people go so far as to remap the caps lock key as Escape because it's one of the most important Vim keys right it doesn't work in Easy Mode okay so so how do you get out of this thing well control Q allows you to save so it actually there at the bottom would you like to save this and hit yes and that will get you out of it and then if you go back into it actually show shows you where it was now here are a couple other really weird things so let's just cop let's just highlight something here with the mouse as you would do in a text editor and hit Ctrl C now in normal Vim control C does weird things right it definitely does not copy but in Easy Mode if I hit Ctrl V you can see it actually copied that to the system buffer or the the system clipboard just like you'd expect in like a word processor it's really weird because that's not the you usually can if you want to copy something to the system clipboard you'd have to find a way of you know highlighting it and then Ctrl shift view you know that would copy it to the clipboard that the is managed by the terminal that you're using or you have to set up Vim in a certain way in order for the uh copy and paste functionality with uh yank and paste and stuff like that in order to get it to your your clipboard but here copying is just a matter of highlighting with the Mouse hitting Ctrl C go going to a new line hitting Ctrl V that is I mean that's the way it should work in like regular word processors but it's not the way that it works in Vim it's really freaking weird and it's freaking out obviously another thing that has gone here right is normal mode normal mode is what you do when you get into Escape or when you hit the Escape key to get out of insert mode and then you could use the you know the Vim keys to move around but that uh doesn't work because you can't get into normal mode you have to use the the god the arrow keys like a like a neanderthal you know it's really really freaking weird so what's the purpose of all this right it's called easy mode so if you if we actually get out of this control uh queue and uh hit yes sure why not and we do a man Vim we'll actually see if we scroll down here to the dash y option it takes a little bit we could actually you know have gotten here faster but it's right here start them in Easy Mode just like the executable was called evm or review makes them behave like a click and type editor that's all we get now there are apparently according to the blog where I found this a few things that you should be able to do now apparently you can hit control o in order to use the command mode but I couldn't get that to work or control you know if I go back to that thing thing here and go back to our thing and hit Ctrl o actually that does actually work so if you hit Ctrl o you could then use you know colon Q in order to quit or write and quit or whatever you wanted to do so theoretically the Vim stuff is still there so that's nice so Ctrl o and then we could do you know write and quit and that would save and quit it so that's cool there's also another one that he puts here or they put here control L which will get you back into normal mode so if we try that so if we hit Ctrl L that gets us into normal mode and you can use then them just like you would normally use and that that would also allow you to then use glademan hold on a second Ctrl l would allow you to use the Vim keys so if you if you got into easy mode and you needed to go back to actually using Vim the proper way you could hit Ctrl L and then use the them Keys just like you normally would so yeah that's easy mode with proper copy and paste you know just like the regular kind and always in insert mode unless you you know deliberately exit insert mode it is really weird it's like this whole situation is Bonkers to me right it's just I once you hit control L I think it I'm not sure how you get back to easy mode apparently it doesn't put you right back in Easy Mode there's probably a way but once you're in these you know this whole easy mode is just like you know oh we can copy with the mouse we could I wonder if drag and drop Works no it doesn't that'd be cool that'd be even more weird but you kind of get the idea right it gives you the option of using your mouse inside of them now there are ways of making them more Mouse friendly with your vimrc you know a lot of people do that but it's not really the way Vim is meant to be used so but this is full-fledged mouse support inside of them but also it takes away all of the Vim stuff right uh the Vim Keys here don't work by default you're in insert mode all the time just like you would be in like you open up LibreOffice you're in insert mode because you can just start typing and that's the way this works here right and so it takes away all the Vim stuff and it's just if you wanted to use this to you know just type a document or whatever and you're more used to using you know your mouse and keyboard together I suppose this is before you but I mean it kind of takes away the goodness of using them because Vim the reason why Vim is good is because of the Vim things that it comes with things like you know macro mode and all the command modes in the regular modes that you you get you know visual block mode and visual mode and all this stuff and find and replace and all the stuff that goes into them that other text editors don't really have or have in different ways right that's what makes Vim them and uh the easy mode takes all of that away it really the first time I got into it I was like man this is just really freaking weird I'm not sure if I'm okay with this you know I'm not I was very very uncomfortable when I realized that in order to move around you have to go back to using the arrow keys like I disabled the arrow keys in Vim maybe two years ago or so because at some point when I first started using them the arrow keys was was still a handicap for me like it still was my primary means of navigating right and by default arrow keys will work just the like you would expect them to in them but I disabled them so that I could get used to using the Vim Keys which is what you're supposed to use and then I go back to them easy mode and the vimkey is not working you have to go back to using the arrow keys it was a very jarring experience I think I'm going to need some therapy so that is it for this video if you've ever used Vim in Easy Mode let me know in the comment section below if you find this just as weird as I I do also I'd love to hear from you in the comments section below you can follow me on Mastodon honestly those links will be in the video description you can support me on patreon patreon.com linuxcast links for liberape and YouTube will be in the video description as well thanks everybody who does support me on patreon YouTube you guys are all absolutely amazing without two of the channels will not be anywhere near where it is right now so thank you so very very much for your support if you are still watching this video right now I would really appreciate it if you dropped a like on this video with my little Hiatus because of my illness YouTube has kind of removed me from the algorithm so any likes that you guys can give me would be highly appreciated so thank you very much for that thanks everybody for watching I'll see you next time [Music] foreign [Music] | The Linux Cast | UCylGUf9BvQooEFjgdNudoQg | 2023-04-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,090 | 10,244 |
M0iiag6DcAg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0iiag6DcAg | The Context S03E18: Nations Evolve, too | [Music] we build societies based on the technologies that we have available on the social contract that we can articulate expressing the mutual interest that we have in order to achieve our goals and the ability to structure these goals in a way that reinforces the particular unit that the society encompasses in this way societies are able to self-perpetuate until the point at which one of the components stops supporting it either a new wave of technology comes or the members of the society design and adopt a new social contract or the mechanisms that the society has employed undermine its own operations for example from an environmental point of view we have had city-states of the ancient greece we have had the uh roman empire with its aqueducts and roads all leading to the city of rome we have had the south and mesoamerican maya and aztec and other [Music] societies and civilizations that have each embodied at their time what was possible and it is the same today when we look at the nation states that have tessellated the world to the point where there is no interstitial space available anymore wherever you go you are actually with your feet uh walking on the area claimed by an ancient state except antarctica we should not believe that the situation is static and that we have achieved a balance an equilibrium that is never going to change as a matter of fact if societies that today are expressed in the nations or aggregations of nations like the european union didn't evolve they would collapse the evolvability of their components is itself a good indicator of their adaptability and as a consequence potential longevity the resilience of nations is their ability to go back and forth left and right experiment with one kind of trend or opinion that is able to attract a large number of people in the case of democracies those people voting for the promoters of those ideas or those trends and then at the next election realize that they were wrong and course correct and this ability is very important changing our minds the greek word metanoia the ability to realize that you were wrong and to change your mind applies not only to individuals but societies nations as well and that kind of reckoning is healthy it is healthy to learn from the mistakes it is healthy to grow with those experiences hopefully not repeating the mistakes in the future so representative democracy also need to evolve we have certain nations that have proportional representation others have first passed the post representation majority presidential uh republics and so on and so forth many different varieties which is also good um an emergent system of managing elections is becoming more and more popular called ranked voting where rather than expressing a single preference you express a list that is according to your first choice but if that were not available the second choice the third choice and so on and when the ranked votings are tallied what we achieve is neither the rule of the majority which oftentimes uh still uh is uh has the implication of going against the wishes and the desires and the aspirations of a very large minority whether it is 20 30 often 40 45 49 neither we have the rule of the minority where proportional representations uh need to create coalitions and paradoxically the minority coalition member originally attracted into the coalition yields a force and a power that is greater than they uh a priori uh were expected to to be able to to wield because by uh telling that they could withdraw from the coalition they have the ability of um having the hypothetical government fall any time ranked voting creates a solution to both of these and it is a solution that is being adopted in more and more situations this is just one example for governments and governance in general to be evolving and of course we have uh other tri types of agreements other types of organizations whether it is the united nation or the world health organization or the agreements that are regulating uh trade financial flows services uh on a global level as part for example of the wto or other emerging global or regional agreements as well these create a complex and evolving set of support systems on which we can build solutions that our technology can take advantage of an example of a technology that takes advantage of these agreements are the container systems that have standardized global shipping and thanks to that kind of standardization global shipping has been able to greatly increase moving goods from uh places uh where they could be produced efficiently to places where they were desirable and they could be sold at the profit this was already what would happen in prehistoric times under a barter system but of course today it is possible in creating supply chains that encompass the entire planet opposing to that of course we have an understanding that these supply chains can be brittle and we then constitute and incentivize those that are more local and can withstand the potential breaking up of uh global agreements and and the ability of uh building products uh globally while still supplying for example pharmaceuticals or technology products to a continent rather than to the entire planet we are in deer need of ideas that can be tested of people who are courageous to show themselves fallible and able to analyze and learn from their mistakes perfectibility of our solutions is at the very basis of their evolvability of their future fitness for purpose if we had a market in societies and in nations we could actually decide what is the expectation of future fitness of a society to gather to the needs of their uh components similarly to how we have a market for um companies where the stock market and the stock price incorporate the market's expectation of the ability of that corporation to generate profit in the future so that their products are attractive to customers and they can be sold while making money and as it turns out we do have such a market we can measure whether a given society or nation is expected to be able to generate future fitness and it is through the legal and illegal immigration flows look at what are the nations where immigration is larger than immigration look at those nations where to the opposite other people want to come in even desperately even risking their lives because they realize that their the country where they were born doesn't give them an opportunity to thrive and maybe even to survive in the coming years so they'd better leave they want to leave and if you look at these flows what you are looking at is actually a stock market for nations where people express their desire and their future expectation with physically moving or attempting at least to move from one place to another and then of course the smarter of the societies can take um can can take action can decide what they want to do because these can be objectively measured and they can be correlated with policies with conditions with decisions that in turn can be formulated in political programs they can be formulated in decisions that shape the future of a nation of a society i hope that it is going to be possible to have rational conversations around this in order to manage what as a consequence of the expected increasingly rapid shifts in climate are going to imply in terms of flows of people we have to be forward looking new technologies are coming these new technologies support new ways of living new ways of living can give rise to new types of social contracts and our imagination is such that we can dream and we can then realize those dreams of just inclusive empowering societies that give opportunities to thrive in the future for all you | David Orban | UCbAm59D3O0qETdTrsTDtsiA | 2021-01-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,352 | 7,738 |
HsHHmMzfJi0 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HsHHmMzfJi0 | ANIMALE MALE ENHANCEMENT REVIEW - THIS DETAIL IS IMPORTANT! Does Animale Male Enhancement Work? | hello guys how are you I'm Thomas I'm here to tell you the whole truth everything you need to know about on email before you actually buy this product and I also have some really important alerts to help you preserve your health so please pay close attention to what I have to tell you so the first thing is be careful with the website you're going to purchase on email from because currently this product can only be sold on its official website I have seen it being sold on fake websites and fake products can harm your health so to help you I'm leaving the link to the only official website Below in the description of this video you can click there later and learn more about the product so what is on email and does it actually work and the answer is yes if you want to boost your sexual performance and naturally increase your erection size the supplement is for you this is the only alternative to surgical intervention unleash the inner Beast again with this powerful sexual enhancement ideal for men of all ages an email will make any man like a new man in just a few days this is the best solution to strengthen your erection and get New Sensations from intimacy what is the best way to take it you're gonna get 30 capsules made with the finest quality ingredients and according to the makers of the product you should take one every single day they also recommend taking the supplement consistently over a few weeks for maximum benefits what are the side effects this supplement has no side effects it contains only natural ingredients eliminating the risk of allergies or any other negative consequences so you can trust this product there are many people having results with it and you can have great results as well just keep in mind that each body will react in a unique way an email is highly tested and manufactured in a GMP certified laboratory and it comes with a 100 satisfaction guarantee so if you don't like it for any reason if it doesn't work for you you can get your money back I really hope this video helped you and I also really hope on email helps you improve your life thanks for watching have a nice day | Rimas Flow HD | UCsFfWKCKpyqFXPUD6pRc5bw | 2023-05-13 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 395 | 2,135 |
_AW9uuJl5d8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_AW9uuJl5d8 | Online English class in Melbourne quarantine.2020 | [Music] this film is a tribute to the resilience creativity and professionalism of many in our migrant communities aims face-to-face english conversation classes were suspended in april 2020 one class of around 10 relatively newly arrived migrants and their volunteer tutor resolved to continue english classes through the online meeting platform zoom the move to online classes has been beneficial for all participants including in several unforeseen ways during a particularly challenging and unusual time it's good to see you and today we're going to continue with uh that topic about how to make friends and that whole small talk so it's about polite conversations it's about and i think uh what we worry about when we're in a new country is how can we be polite without offending anybody we're not sure so here's some ideas julia fraser a volunteer tutor with ames ran a weekly conversation class for up to 20 newly arrived students and migrants at the city of melbourne's multicultural hub opposite the victoria market many of the regular attendees found the class not only beneficial for their english language skills but also for connections with other people in a new country in april 2020 ames notified its tutors and students that all face-to-face classes needed to cease to help stop the spread of covert 19. understanding that many of these students would miss this regular interaction ames gave julia permission to continue her weekly class via zoom who'd like to try first i want to introduce myself to my neighbor hi my name is ali we just recently moved to our new house and we are living next door and i'm living with my husband hi good morning how are you today fantastic thank you uh we moved in uh three weeks ago but we haven't spoken before my name is lily nice to meet you lily my name is i will introduce to you as a co-worker okay lovely yes i just started working here today from today my name is mehmed how long have you been studying how about you how long have you been working here hi my man and my name is ryo and i worked here about what one month and it will be get better so so be positive nice to meet you nice to meet you thank you okay that was a lovely conversation and and um and i feel rio you would make me feel very relaxed so thank you jenny over here thank you to help manage the group and share the workload julie introduced her colleague jenny mcgregor providing their combined teaching skills and intercultural knowledge to the group you said i worked here about one month i think it's better if you say i have been working here i have been working i have been working here working here for about a month or work or about a month jenny works on helping participants build their vocabulary get the grammar right and the syntax right checks the pronunciation while i facilitate the classes and try to make sure that each each person in the group gets a time where they can practice their english language and can converse with others can i just give rania one little um tip here before we we go into that running you said um we was in the same class last term but it's actually we were because there are two of you oh okay it's a plural so we were in the same class most of the participants were quite isolated in many ways and if we could keep the momentum going it might be good for mental health and for their english language if we could keep going with the video classes um so we now have um via zoom classes twice a week and i have about 12 people in the class every week twice a week who not only build their english skills but are also building senses of connections with each other and with their tutors and we have a good group a lot of countries so this is very good and exciting i could enjoy the class and teacher was kind and everyone is so friendly maybe it was miracle and now i can continue the class online so it's so happy things for me i was very happy with the with ames because i would like to work i'm so happy with the zoom meeting because with the quarantine if i'm saying at home i cannot speak english i will speak my our language one day i didn't feel well and one of my classmates sent me a message during the class the message was whatever whatever the problem i send you a hug calm and a lot good energy and i never forget this message the online class has been really good for me because i use it to work the whole day i don't have to spend time in traveling i think it's advantage for us to study from home but for me it really does help me establish a routine um during these quite difficult times and i also feel like i'm doing something of value um helping build english skills going to the end of of the today's lesson so what i'd like to do is to ask each of you um to talk about one thing that's making you happy this moment this class makes me happy luciana yeah what's making you happy now uh it's making me happy it's my road to me day in this quarantine because i enjoyed my time to study more english to write my resume and try to cook new recipes okay ellie honestly thinking about uh that in near future maybe in one month later we will get the chance to see our family or friends and hanging around with them and going to their home and just thinking about these things making me happy great great and and you rio i'm glad to talk to everyone like this because it will be relaxed and cheerful and i forgot about the stressful yeah we've grown to really respect and care deeply for our students to respect them for their enormous resilience in being in a new country in being in such difficult times away from their families and their strength in being able to navigate these very very tough times and i would encourage anybody who's thinking of starting a zoom class and supporting people in need at this time to go for it all right thank you for a great class everyone it was really good fun and and i look forward to seeing you all on thursday bye now bye everyone when the formal class ends and the tutors have left the zoom meeting participants continue to chat freely a whatsapp group is used between sessions now that restrictions are easing and we will hopefully return to face-to-face classes in 2021 we would encourage other tutors to think about continuing to offer supplementary classes via virtual platforms many of our students find it more convenient to learn from home and many would enjoy increased social connection in melbourne the other thing that i get out of it is that i've met a terrific group of very accomplished and professional people from all over the world and i'm thoroughly enjoying it thank you to the group and thank you to ames [Music] this film is a tribute to the resilience creativity and professionalism of many in our migrant communities it's good to see you and today we're going to continue with uh that topic about how to make friends hi good morning actually we were because there are two of you | Mozhgan Pazooki مژگان پازوکی | UCWdNzgzpwuCAncj_ap0Cd4w | 2021-01-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,293 | 6,931 |
KudqR2GCJow | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KudqR2GCJow | Ethics in the Age of AI | Davos 2024 | World Economic Forum | ethics in the age of AI when we worry about the ethical implications of new technology in our familiar debates we worry about there there are four main worries first are robots coming for our jobs second will algorithmic prediction and decision making in hiring and lending and criminal job Justice frees in place unfairness embedded in past practices third will surveillance capitalism essentially mean that privacy is over and fourth will misinformation and deep fakes and the polarizing effect of social media undermine the democracy so jobs fairness privacy and democracy these are consequential considerations what I would like to explore with you today however is an even deeper worry a more fundamental question about the ethics of AI and new technologies and the question is this will technology change what it means to be human to begin to think about this question let's start with AI in the movies Harrison Ford he's 81 years old but in the recent remake of the Indiana Jones series they needed him for part of the movie to be younger 40 years younger now they couldn't do it very effectively with makeup so they used AI enabled digital daging let's just see what people think about digital daging Harrison Ford appearing for part of the film thanks to the AI technology as 40 rather than 81 as a movie goer how many find this troubling and how many think it's fine just like the use of makeup in times past raise your hand if you find it objectionable or troubling digital dhing a handful of people do how many don't how many think it's it's just like makeup you think you may need it maybe it should should be applied beyond the movies now digital daging is only the beginning of the question posed by AI in movie making and in the Arts because the same technologies that enable the the filmmakers to Dage Harrison Ford could be used in a more ambitious way Harrison Ford is still with us but what about great actors of the past great Stars whom we would love to see in a new role wouldn't you like to see Humphrey Bogart for example not in a rerun of Casablanca but in a new movie bringing him back so to speak for a virtual comeback performance now let's take a vote on this one how many would find that Prospect cool appealing attractive and how many would find it troubling or objectionable let's let's see what people think about that how many are okay with it how many think it might be cool even to bring back actors from the de to playing a new role only a handful you're not you're not big humpry Bogart fans you don't want to all right how many how many um object most people object but why why would you object who will we have microphones who will Who will tell us what's objectionable yes well I would find it well wait wait till the microphone gets to you yeah go ahead so I would actually believe it's that he did not have agency to decide his role yeah so he he wouldn't have given his consent he's long passed and and what but what if what if he had signed a waiver before he passed then then would that remove your objection then it would be okay go ahead he had created the parameters of which where his image could be used yes so so long as he agreed as long as he has agency specific though around the parameters his agency you're not a lawyer by any chance I I am not you're not okay now let's all right let's push forward with that question now suppose he had given a waiver maybe actors that as part of their Wills just as we have living wills could if they chose agree to be re to to star in a new role in a virtual comeback performance in that case is there still anyone who objects is there a remaining objection number of people do still object and who will Who will tell us why what would be troubling go ahead Reta let's get you a microphone I think the question is for the rest of us did we consent to them coming back do we know that we're watching an AI generated image of past and if we lost something about human dignity in the process of taking humans post death recreating them based on their Essence and their identity and projecting them forward in time in some digitally recreated way so uh you want truth in advertising you want there to be a disclaimer that might be easy enough but the second point that you've raised is about dignity the the Dignity of the actor even an actor who has agreed in advance we're seeing a performance that well is it his or her performance or is it something else and it's human dignity somehow implicated I put this question about the virtual comeback performance to a young uh actor and director Michael B Jordan Rising Hollywood star he starred in the Creed boxing Series this he's the successor to Rocky and uh a number of other films just Mercy among them here's what he had to say about the virtual comeback performance let me ask an extreme version of this is that technology gets even better MH Suppose there were an actor okay from the past okay a long ago actor whom you admire tied Y and though they're no longer living you say to yourself GE it would be my dream to be able to cast them in this movie I mean two come to mind is Sydney portier and and um and Heath Ledger can you even imagine what it would be like as a director but also in human terms let's say to be able to cast Sydney P today in one of your movies and to have that virtual actor act the new role with the same look and stance and gesture and tone of voice and bearing as he brought to his earlier role yeah I will be a fool not to entertain it but there's something unsettling about it yeah from where I stand today and and all right that's what I want to get at what's unsettled about it m is what exactly that's not his Free Will that's not the Man's Free Will I'm making that decision for him so it's unsettling because Sydney P did not consent in advance I get that and that's an important moral consideration but suppose he had he'd written you a letter saying I'm willing trust you I trust you yeah yeah then it would still be unsettling I'll bet I think yeah I think so yes okay so there must be another reason Beyond his consent what would that other reason be and I I see where you're getting at and I I love it and I'm trying to articulate it it's it's just a feeling of authenticity that's just not there I can't explain it authenticity and you spoken about presence human presence and even the best virtual comeback yeah can't capture human authenticity or human presence I don't think so there's certain people that they walk in a room and you feel them I've been in room certain people walk in and you feel them in there I can't describe it I don't I don't think it AI uh digitally created thing can have that as Michael B Jordan thinks it through in a very reflective way in some ways replicating the discussion we had about this question he began as we began with consent and agency but then as the discussion unfolded he identified a value Beyond consent that seemed to be at stake and in our discussion Rita mentioned human dignity Michael B Jordan described it as authenticity and human presence it's as he pointed out it's not easy to explain exactly what that means but there is something it seems a deep human value at stake here Beyond consent Beyond Choice beyond the waiver form signed in advance now let's continue to explore what's at stake in human terms for our use of new technologies by shifting from the movies from art film making to matchmaking a growing number of young people meet their mates their life Partners online through the use of dating apps suppose those apps could get good enough accurate enough drawing on a big enough pool of data so that they could generate a list of the three best life partners for you or for your son or daughter here's the question if that were possible would you rely I'd like especially to hear from from those who are still of dating age or you can answer on behalf that's right you never know or you can answer on behalf of your kids whom would you trust more to generate that short list the app or thinking now of young people your mom now the mom's in the room you may have a stake in this a special stake but you can vote out of your conviction so how many would rely more on the app to come up with the short list only a handful of people how many would rely more on your mom in this group in this group mom beats the app now I put this question I put this question to a discussion with a group of young people in their 20s and 30s from various European countries and uh some from North America who we we gathered for a Socratic St discussion for a Dutch television program in an ancient Amphitheater in Greece to discuss some of the fundamental ethical questions of our time including AI matchmaking and the marriage prediction you say you go with the app why is that because he knows every character uh uh perspective of yourself he knows you well as you are so I think he can search for a better match than my parents who would see me at home or when I'm visiting them even though they raised me up there was a time that I left home and created my own life there's a life at home and a life outside of home so I don't think they are totally capable of searching somebody who fits me in both situations but but the app doesn't have that that gut feeling uh and I want to connect uh with a woman on a on a spiritual level and the app can't feel that so your parents do trust me my mama my mama my mama trust me my mama knows this type of things she knows me from the inside out so uh if I come home with a girl she would she would notice in like two seconds no no no no this it's not good for you but I think the question is and being a mama boy as well uh I think the question is is there any space for a mistake even in in choosing a partner to marry is there any space for uh imperfection because this thing works very well it's not the algorithms that we have now it finds the exact perfect match but don't we want to leave something out of that Perfection for something as big as marriage well I don't know if you've ever been in a relationship but if you have a perfect match then the mistakes start happening right so I mean so so there's plenty of room for mistakes if you if you have a good connection and that's what I'm saying like I I I am married and I don't know if a perfect robot would have found exactly my wife she would have landed top three but I think if you if it helps you find uh uh this is going to sound very clinical but a list of potential partners that have a good match it helps it because it takes away a lot of the Clutter of of of of finding somebody who you have good connection with is that actual clutter or that's part of what we call love dating what about the sexual part how will the machine know if that's a click I mean how will your parents know and that too can grow that too will no but what I mean is is you there's got to be a personal connection I guess or some kind of thing because the machine will never know but I think Sergio's question underlies if you take away all the forging and the surging you take away a lot of Human Experience because you miss all the clam mistakes and wrong dates and the wrong things so I might have actually switched back to but there's something Sergio said I don't know whether this app would would have my partner in that top three so it makes me doubting right now whe I would go for that machine you're changing your mind I don't know I'm really because of his argument because I'm I'm thinking I'm married would that machine pick this guy that I'm married to I don't [Music] know now Socrates never had it so good in in those amphitheaters or in the Ecclesia but what are what do people think of the arguments you heard back and forth about whether an app even with big data even with machine learning as sophisticated as it will become whether a machine a smart machine can outthink in the domain of matchmaking and love human judgment what's your sense of it now on that philosophical question how many think that in Principle as machine learning becomes more sophisticated that in principle it can do better than it will be able to supplant even in matchmaking human judgment how many think so raise your hand a handful of people do and how many don't think so now the majority do not think so why not why are you why are you skeptical yes people change let's let's get to microphone so yeah people are not a fixed moment that a machine can test you people get older they change things happen and the feeling that the young gentleman expressed um can predict better than a machine that's my opinion because the people change you say and the Machine can never even in princip keep up with the way we evolve as human beings and that of course makes a difference on who the best match will be those who think in principle a machine a smart app will be able to do better than your mom or your friend or perhaps you yourself in identifying the best match what would be your answer to the arguments you heard from the young people and from the argument just now that we change who has a reply who has faith in the app and has a reply yes I think it's not about the change because the app could adapt and evolve I think it's more about the memory and the emotion that you won't get and I'm surrounded by young people they are using all this app and I'm playing with it because I'm too too late for me and uh but they're coming back from this app because they are missing this memory the creation of all the moment to create the the love ending moment so I think this is about that where the app cannot cannnot make it so you think the app cannot make it no cannot do better than human Evol it can bring the the the change of a person but it cannot create the memory and the emotion the memory and the emotion and what did you think about the uh participants in the discussion who spoke about the clammy hands the clumsiness the missteps the false starts the imperfection the vulnerability that are constitutive as he saw it of what learning to love is about do you agree with that yes totally I think this is the moment needed that the app does not bring the key moments for me I I don't know if if this is my opinion I think it's key moment to to bridge the the love and bring bring this emotion the app you are you are skipping so many steps I mean so many you're you're killing so many steps killing so many steps even if those steps seem inconvenient but keep the microphone there even if those steps seem inconvenient and difficult and on the face of it steps or experiences to be overcome but it's exactly what I think syia was saying it's like it's a way to know it's a learning curve so the app is killing this learning curve you're skipping them and perhaps you're going too fast so um I feel you have to have this moment and again I'm I have young kids and they talking about the moment where we were seducing in a bar in the dance floor I mean they they're missing that part and they said you you were at a good period of time in the 80s '90s I don't know some people can relate here right right so it's easier to swipe into scroll than it is to have these encounters and missteps the contrary I think it's better to have this encounter moment that's yes better than than than scrolling so here let's get these I know a lot of marriages that I would say or relationships that I would say opposites attraction yeah my daughter's very intense she found a guy who's totally laidback if they had both been that intense right can the app do that I mean it's um but I know a lot of marriages where you say boy those people are opposites ATT track and also in any good marriage people grow together uh in the app actually predict that these are two people who can grow together right the Opposites Attract point I was going to ask whether in principle you could program the app to take account of that but the second point about the way in which people grow together in companionship and love that seems hard for an to imagine an app being able to capture well now thank you for for deepening this discussion which turns out is not really about the technology as much as it is about what it means to seek friendship and companionship and love I'd like to turn to another Human Experience where technology is offering to make really a possibly fateful change in the way we live and in the way we die there are even now companies that will enable you to create a digital Avatar of yourself based on all of your social media posts your emails your personal data and when you die you will be able to Beque access to that data to that Avatar to whomever you want to your loved ones to your friends or for that matter to the public and enabling them to engage in ongoing conversations with you so that let's say your great great grandchild could introduce you to his or her perspective mate and ask you what you would think this would not be simply a digital Avatar that would enable you as a kind of chatbot to reminisce about your past but also to give your characteristic reactions to novel events whether in the news whether in the world or whether in your family virtual immortality virtual immortality uh let's see what people think about virtual immortality how many would be tempted by it to use that facility a digital Avatar this a couple how many would not most people would not I asked Michael B Jordan what he thought and here's what he said your grandmother suppose it were possible for her to have her to have done that so that you could spend more time with spend more time with her now sounds like you well how would you feel about that oh man self selfishly you know the need reaction is yeah of course I do anything you know to see her and feel her and you know be around her again it's something that's so foreign that my mind can't completely wrap my brain like I can't wrap it around the experience of what that would be and if I could tell in the slightest that it's not that I would reject I I I would what nothing to do with it because the tech mediated connection M you feel might obstruct or corrupt the spiritual connection 1,00% and how she smelled how she touched the way she looked at me you know there's no algorithm to there's no emails or not text or phone calls not enough information to for me to look Beyond her eyes and how she used to look at me and talk to me there's nothing that there there's not enough you you have a conviction listening to you Michael that we're not data all the way down MH and if you're right about that than even the best AI chatbot couldn't capture and might even abstruct the spiritual dimension of life and it may trick you for a while you know it can it can think your own projections of sadness and the want of those things would make you you know hear what you want to hear and see what you want to see you know we do that all the time with the relationships that we have now yeah with jobs and Rel friend ships relationships and experiences you somehow contort reality and so you can be okay and cope and deal with it and so to go back to the question with which we began will technology change what it is to be human your answer is for some yes but for me no so here is the most fundamental question posed by the age of AI and chatbots and Big Data Beyond worries about jobs and fairness about privacy and even democracy is the deeper question about whether human authenticity dignity human presence are fundamentally at stake will new technologies lead us are they already leading us and our children to confuse virtual community and human connection for the real thing because if they do then we may here's what I think we learned from this discussion then we may lose something precious about what it means to be human thank you very [Applause] much | World Economic Forum | UCw-kH-Od73XDAt7qtH9uBYA | 2024-04-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,801 | 19,856 |
JrFI0Ma7ZWM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrFI0Ma7ZWM | ADHD, Goals, Focus, Executive Functioning and More! with Psychiatrist Dr Kenny Hendelman | so many of us growing up with ADHD we set a goal we start working toward it even if we think we're making progress people say well why aren't you trying well I really am trying well it doesn't look like you're trying we don't really make progress we don't get acknowledgment and then if we don't try the same thing happens that if we try again the same thing happens and we you know we start to learn whether I try or I don't try it's the same outcome so why bother trying [Music] hi Dr Handelman Kenny nice to see you and thank you so much for doing this so if you could just introduce yourself I always think it's better when when the guests describes their situation who they are and how they got here and then we'll go from there all right so hi my name is Kenny and I have ADHD um I'm also a doctor a psychiatrist I'm trained as a Child and Adolescent psychiatrist and adult psychiatrist I work a lot with people with ADHD I teach doctors and health care providers I've written a book for parents of kids and teens with ADHD many moons ago I had a website podcast that I did a lot of work with and I may start that up again in the near future currently running a clinic for ADHD in the Toronto area that's how we met Mike thrilled to have you on our team you're a wonderful addition and make tremendous contributions and yeah maybe we'll stop there sure sure thank you thank you and can you just share a bit about your journey I love that you just the first thing you said was in Iowa ADHD um well we're talking to my people yeah yeah it's awesome so I know a little bit about you've told me kind of how it all came about for you but you also have a pretty unique story in terms of the the I guess the qualities right or the superpowers of your and sorry did you say ADHD or add I can't remember well so I mean look well I think we're going to talk about this a little later but the official term is ADHD but okay I technically have the inattentive presentation so I have what we used to call add but yeah okay thank you tomato tomato yeah yeah but thank you and we will distinguish that later okay so your super power in some sense helps you you went to med school early right and you power through all that and I think I often see that in people where they're really excelling in sort of one domain of their life and that's one of the superpowers but then the things around that sometimes can be a bit disorganized so I'm not saying that's your situation but I'm curious kind of how you got into medicine and and what you're saying yeah so so yeah I'm currently in my early 50s I got diagnosed with ADHD at 40. going back I finished medical school at 24 and my Psychiatry residency at 29 so yeah I as you said I powered through not knowing I had ADHD so I mean you know I don't want to go on and on about myself but just a brief overview uh you know now I understand I actually grew up with a lot of privilege right that's the term now and it's true um I happen to be quite bright from an early age I realized I was interested in being a doctor and was quite driven toward it now I had the wonderful opportunity to go to Great Schools I had great parent support um I went to schools that were academically enriched they really captured my attention I had the opportunity to be involved in a whole bunch of things so my hyperactivity was being on swim team you know I I'm 5'7 which is short but when you're like 12 or 13 and you're five seven you're the second tallest guy so I had a brief basketball career but that ended very quickly um and uh it was very mediocre but I was tall for grade seven and then stopped growing but uh you know swim team I was on debating and Model United Nations and school newspaper like I used my hyperactivity for good things because I was in a great school that captured my attention and you know I had a love of learning and a strong desire to become a doctor from a young age partially I think that was parent prompting partially it was my own interest of enjoying sciences and wanting to help people um and I think it you know I had a tremendous ability to hyper focus when I needed to so I'd sort of be the student who would goof off during the semester like in high school you could sort of catch up on a weekend you know in my undergrad I could catch up in a week or two in medical school it's bloody six or eight weeks so why was I goofing off for six weeks of the semester to spend like eight weeks catching up I don't know undiagnosed ADHD right but I think if I didn't have the support and opportunities I did I may have been the kid who was the bright guy sitting at the back of the class in high school angry at the world smart enough to be getting A's but doing terribly and getting into a whole world of trouble right so I had tremendous support and opportunity I think if I didn't know I wanted to be a doctor I would have struggled but I had a goal to work toward that meant a lot to me I had great educational support and other things so you know educationally and then professionally I did well but it was the other parts of my life that were my ADHD was much more evident I mean Looking Back Now um you know we would realize I actually had 80 obviously I had ADHD the whole time but there were clear symptoms of it but the understanding of ADHD in the late 80s 90s was not such that we would have realized that a bright kid who was getting good marks and honors who actually had inattentive ADHD um I actually got sent to a child psychiatrist when I was 15 by my parents um I love them now they were amazing they're amazing they were tremendously supportive but in my middle adolescence I hated them with a passion and I was so defiant to them so drive them insane because I was getting great marks and everybody thought I was great but I made their lives miserable right so they sent me to an adolescent psychiatrist who I saw for six seven eight times and he basically said to my parents you know don't worry too much about them give them some time he's aimed of the world Etc um you know but at the time he didn't diagnose ADHD right like I was getting work done I was getting great marks at a challenging school so yeah I mean I consider myself very fortunate um as life got busier work got busier family it started to be too hard to juggle all the balls and manage everything and I realized I should get an assessment and the irony was my book on ADHD had just come out like a month before I got diagnosed and then I got diagnosed and then like many people with any kind of mental health diagnosis um I became really ashamed right like somebody said to me hold on a second you just wrote a book about ADHD and you're supposedly an expert but you didn't even realize you had it what kind of expert are you and I was like oh my God you know this is terrible how is like how embarrassing I feel so ashamed and I think for different reasons different people feel ashamed with a diagnosis right and it took some time to work that through and go for therapy and talk to the doctor and get my care going and then when I got to about a year after diagnosis I felt comfortable and solid in my own grounds like I kind of realized you know what I'm human you know I can be an expert in ADHD and our our understanding of ADHD has evolved right you know when I did my training it was mostly hyperactive boys with behavior problems right if you were a high achieving professional intelligent there were doctors who literally said if you have a university education you cannot have ADHD because the DSM criteria would say you have to be functioning you know sort of have impairment in your functioning and people would Define that as compared to the common individuals so as soon as you've graduated University you are functioning higher than the common individuals so you don't have an ADHD but of course the real definition is are you've impaired compared to what you're capable of right so yes I may have been getting high marks but in many areas of my life I was functioning below my abilities and it was affecting me right so um anyway yeah so I kind of worked through that got clear in myself and then decided you know what I've I have no reason to be ashamed I am different I think differently we you know we all go through this we're all human we all put our pant legs on one at a time sort of thing or thoughts one at a time anyway I guess you can put your pants on all at once but you know what I mean in any case um you know so I decided I'd rather share with people the journey I've gone through um and you know I love working with people with ADHD number one my people right we get along number two if I were in like banking or Finance when I like if I'm doing an important meeting if I lose my train of thought or I get distracted by something or I impulsively crack a joke which I probably shouldn't in like Finance or banking they'd be like all right handelman's smart but I don't know about this guy right but when I'm working with ADHD people they just feel so much more comfortable and they're thrilled that here's a doctor who gets them and I'm human too and I've got adhd2 and it all works right so kind of makes the day go by so much easier let's spending on my way out yeah wow that's lovely um description of everything there are a couple so many threads to pull on but one that I see a lot um is what you said and this certainly happened to me was the this the I could I have a hard time I do I am bright in in certain ways for sure but I was the kid at the back of the class angry at the world yeah because here I am I know I'm smart when I work I get good grades I excel all that stuff and at the same time no love my parents not their fault at all just the way things were not much support not much awareness and certainly I got very angry and resentful and disconnected from the world and of course my journey is around drug addiction but for other people without that sense of purpose maybe or connection to something they care about and they can direct their attention to and we see this all the time in the clinic obviously is people who are bright who are capable but they're kind of just lost um and I think that's a really important thing for many young people to hear right is yeah if I can comment on that I think you know one of the biggest gifts from my parents was Kenny you've got abilities you need to work toward them aim to achieve and contribute right and as much as I got upset with my parents or was angry at them in my adolescence I held on to that and I believed I could quote unquote be successful I could help people I could make a difference for people in the way that I could right and so that drove me to work forward uh and and move forward with goals that matter to me that I've been very proud of um now I think what a lot of people experience with ADHD like our school system is pretty darn good frankly and there's a lot of difficulties for people who don't fit the mold right and yeah well probably we won't spend a long time talking about that but I have my opinions you have your opinions I'm sure are viewers of this podcast have their opinions um and everybody has their own experience but I think part of what happens is when people are growing up with ADHD we sort of have this experience of I'm trying right I want to do well in my history class my math class whatever mom or dad teachers say come on Kenny try and I'll say I am trying well doesn't really look like it right what do we want kids to learn as they grow we want them to learn that I when I set a goal that's important to me and I take steps toward it I make progress I mean not a cheap perfection in fact none of us really do we can't but I never achieved Perfection but I'm making progress toward that goal and then people acknowledge it and I acknowledge it and I feel good because I've made progress right and so many of us growing up with ADHD we set a goal we start working toward it even if we think we're making progress people say well why aren't you trying well I really am trying well it doesn't look like you're trying we don't really make progress we don't get acknowledgment and then if we don't try the same thing happens that if we try again the same thing happens and we you know we start to learn whether I try or I don't try it's the same outcome so why bother trying why bother setting a goal when nothing's gonna work anyway and I think our school systems are getting better I think our understanding about mental illness as a whole is getting better I think parents are becoming more accepting I think there are more resources but still so many people struggle with that and it's a real challenge so you know I had the fortunate opportunity to have a goal that was meaningful to me that I could make forward progress on um and it meant a lot so and I did of course work my butt off as everybody does who goes through these sorts of programs um but I did have a lot of support and a lot of opportunity right yep okay and then maybe I was I'm I'm not sure whether to ask you about the book and this idea of sort of attention difference disorder and how parents are a big part of it and then maybe we can get to the difference or historical difference between ADHD add and what the subtypes are yeah for sure so the book The the title of my book for parents is attention difference disorder I'm not really meaning or wanting to change the name of course it's been changed so many times as you've said it's really about a different understanding and it came out of years sitting in the clinic where parents would say how can you say my child has a focus problem well if I let him sit in front of the Xbox or iPad he could sit there for eight or ten hours if I didn't pry the things out of his hands right he can focus and it's like well yeah but he focuses differently right and those of us with ADHD we can still focus in fact many of us can hyper Focus right get so fixated on what's important to us what's the goal is that we kind of neglect and ignore so many other things around us and you know that's actually like neurologically not a good thing I mean it can be very helpful in our modern world but if you think of back on the Savannah or back in caveman times whatever if you were so focused on what you were doing that you were not aware of your environment you could be killed right survival instincts you've got to pay attention and be aware when you're hyper focused in modern times there's no woolly mammoth gonna eat you sort of thing so you may be productive when you when sort of like the stars align and you finally like can hit that focus and get some stuff done for several hours right um so we focus differently we than other people we still can focus so we focus a lot better when something is new and exciting when something's thrilling when something gets our dopamine flowing we focus a lot worse on things that are boring mundane and regular right so I remember years ago seeing an adult with ADHD who you know was sort of middle level management and a big Corporation had a lot of responsibility and you know took care of a whole bunch of things and his electricity was going to be cut off the next week because he didn't get around to opening his mail and paying his electric bill right like the task of the papers now these days you can kind of automate it with your Electronic Banking and things and many people use those strategies back in the day you have to open up the envelope find the bill maybe even mail a check or whatever and his electricity was going to be cut off it's like you know man you need help for your ADHD like you got to keep a roof over your head right so we can focus on things that are interesting exciting we struggle with more boring stuff now people could say well you know okay so you can focus on things you'll like and not focus on things you don't like well why don't you actually just work hard try harder and stop being lazy right you know which is sort of one of the core criticisms of ADHD to begin with to that I say well there are many medical conditions to you know where the symptoms change based on the situation right in fact if you have heart disease blockage in the heart arteries to actually see if you have it they'll put you on a treadmill get your heart going and see if the strain impacts it right see if it can show the symptoms of heart disease when you're in that situation if you have asthma I remember when I was first being tested for asthma as a kid you know at the in Toronto at the pediatrician's office he had me you know do breathe into a thing and then run up and down the stairs five times in his bit office building and then breathe again and there was a difference okay you've got exercise induced asthma right like but the symptom wasn't there just sitting there I had to be in the environment that brought out the symptoms so those of us with ADHD it's not just that we don't try we focus differently and I don't know if you want to go down this discussion but it's really about executive functioning so that the the bigger thing is it's about regulating the ability to focus right and executive functions are an important part of ADHD we could take two minutes to talk about we can focus on things that are interesting and exciting we struggle with more boring stuff differences in attention are around the regulation of attention and the executive function yeah please if you could kind of go into that a bit more and just see kind of where she goes yeah yeah so executive functioning yeah executive functions and some authors uh teachers will talk about executive skills right so skills are something you can learn functions are things that just happen and we certainly can teach and improve executive functioning so but these are the highest level thinking skills that we use as human beings to you know achieve our complex goals or regulate ourselves so these are things like planning organizing prioritizing time management dealing with frustration managing emotions and also regulating our attention in our brains it's in the prefrontal cortex the front part of the brain just behind the forehead and that part of our brain grows and develops from the time we're born until we're almost 30 years old and there's research out of the US from the National Institutes of mental health where they did brain scans of kids and teens growing up with ADHD over time like scan them every one or two years I forget something like 250 kids and they also scanned kids growing up without ADHD and compared brain growth and development and they found that the prefrontal cortexes of kids with ADHD grow and develop a little more slowly on average two three years behind kids who don't have ADHD and that would account for some of the executive functioning challenges of kids now even though the prefrontal cortex growth catches up many of us with ADHD or all of us depending on your definitions have executive functioning challenges and when I'm talking to people in a clinical assessment and I'm asking how does this affect your life how are you doing with work you know if I'm talking to an adult how are you doing with the morning routine getting the kids out the door if you have kids how are you doing with your work day how are you doing with the evening how are you doing with paying your bills you know planning your meals how are you doing with managing money driving this is all self-regulation so they think I'm just checking how it impacts them but I'm also thinking about their executive functioning can they set goals can they stick with them can they manage the time the obstacles the frustration and keep going right so even though there are many different definitions of executive functioning I think it all boils down to can you execute on the tasks that are meaningful and important to you and your roles in life and if you can you don't really have executive functioning challenges and just about every single person who comes for assessment of ADHD it's because they're having trouble executing and completing the tasks that are important for them at their stage of life right and that's where the impairment as you said to the Daily functioning becomes absolutely yeah and and can you from that executive functioning piece what are the different subtypes so I guess yeah what are different subtypes of ADHD yeah so the current official diagnosis is ADHD attention deficit hyperactivity disorder for everybody right and then there are three types and actually they're technically called presentations now not subtypes okay and the idea being it's kind of one disorder one condition that may present differently at different points in the lifespan right or in different individuals so if you have significant inattention symptoms trouble with Focus disorganization forgetfulness distractibility stuff like that then you can have the inattentive presentation if that's your only group of symptoms if you have significant hyperactivity impulsivity so the hyperactivity can be restlessness getting up trouble sitting sitting still interrupting people impulsivity can be intruding on conversations you know doing things with that thinking Etc if you have mostly or only the hyperactivity impulsivity symptoms you're going to have ADHD hyperactive impulsive presentation not the inattentive if you have both it's ADHD combined so that's both inattentive and hyperactive impulsive now a lot of people still like the term add right so attention deficit disorder without the H and that's what the name used to be way back now it's a what we used to call add would actually be ADHD like inattentive presentation and ADHD is you know with hyperactivity would either be ADHD hyperactive impulsive presentation or ADHD combined presentation right so it's now I'll see people and they'll say add oh my son has ADD and we came to review this and that and the other is and then all a couple sentence later sentences later say ADHD and they say no no add and I say okay sorry tomato tomato you know it's um I understand what you mean and if I'm saying ADHD in reference to your child I mean ADHD predominantly inattentive right but I'm just so used to the medical literature of ADHD for everybody that I sometimes I turn it off and sometimes I don't right it's just habit sort of thing yeah and okay and on that note can we sort of discuss the Paradox I guess between maybe there's two things here the the sort of rush to label kids who particularly young boys although and actually I think it would be helpful for you to also describe the difference for girls because often girls are under diagnosed I think um so the yeah the sort of over focus and also the lack of acknowledgment of these things that paradox and um oh and I'm curious I learned recently that girls brains develop and also the prefrontal cortex faster than boys um by a couple years so I thought that was super interesting too and that might also indicate why the boys in the class are more disruptive than the girls and and so those are the kind of threads yeah so okay I'll sort of go a little backwards from your question starting at the end then move backwards so okay the insofar as the brain I mean when we think of executive functioning growth and development which ties in with prefrontal cortex development over time I think an easy way for people then to understand this is maturity right so we think of individuals becoming more mature as they grow and of course in the normal growth in our society you know they have some responsibility in elementary school more Independence and responsibility in high school even more in post-secondary whether that's work or apprenticeship or college or university and then even more as full functioning adults hopefully living independently right and on the biological side the prefrontal cortex is growing and developing right and that's providing the infrastructure for more maturity which we could Define as better executive functioning right so a lot of girls become more mature than like mature earlier than boys and you know boys with ADHD if they're like let's say nine years old their prefrontal cortex may be similar to a non-adhd individual of seven years old or six years old so they seem quite immature where a girl of nine years old may have the executive functioning of a boy of 11 or 12 right they're more mature um so I think it's important to think about that um girls with ADHD yeah I mean their prefrontal cortex May grow a little more slowly compared to other girls who don't have ADHD right I can't say I can think of or have read a study that specifically compared girls development versus boys and things like that I'd have to look for a reference but I think on basic principles I hope that helps people understand that yeah um insofar as the difference between boys and girls and I'm glad there's so much more information out there about this now we've kind of known this in the field for 20 plus years as long as I've been in it or longer and it's much more known now which is great because I see a lot of women coming in for ADHD assessment saying I never really thought I had ADHD because I'm not a hyperactive little boy who gets in trouble kind of thing but now that I've seen online or people told me or I read articles I realize it's different in women and here are my concerns and I'm like yes that is totally ADHD right so in kids boys with ADHD tend to have more hyperactivity girls tend to have more inattention so boys get noticed because they're hyper girls May daydream the other thing is when a boy is hyperactive he's more likely to disrupt the whole classroom when a girl is hyperactive she's much more likely to be a chatty Kathy who's too social and goes to visit her friends too much so Susie stop being so social get back to your desk and do your desk and do your work right so it's not like you've got a problem that needs to see the doctor immediately it's more you're just being too social where the boy who has hyperactivity disrupts the class and you know when it comes to ADHD almost everybody has at least one other coexisting condition right and kids 75 percent of kids and teens have at least one other diagnosis in adults it's 85 or more percent of people have at least another diagnosis so with boys it's much more likely to have a behavior problem Oppositional Defiant Disorder challenging Authority not listening disrupting so then the boys end up hyperactive and behaviorally challenging the teachers say get to the doctor right with the girls with ADHD they're inattentive and they tend to be a little more emotional rather than behavioral so they're inattentive if they're hyperactive at all they're too social to chatty and then you know if they have behavior issues or sorry coexisting conditions they are more emotional moody anxious and unfortunately and I cringe inside to say this and please women girls females anybody listening to this please don't think this is my belief but I think in general people think oh she's just being dramatic right like she's just being you know a dramatic you know social girl whatever and she just needs to sit down and I cringe saying it because I hate it so much the Judgment that's there and the lack of understanding and support um in women and I you know the interesting thing I see with women just to share some clinical front line things so I can say yes similar thing more inattentive or if hyperactive it's not the totally disruptive type less aware of it than men women for the most part and one can't always generalize but for the most part in our society women get more of the child's care more of the Home Care responsibilities things like that and kind of have to run the home now if you've got ADHD so men could kind of if it's a heterosexual couple you know together um the man may go to work and come home and say I've contributed a lot and go rest we're women generally deal with the kids go to work come home do everything else hopefully men but it's almost one of these things if the men help out a lot it's kind of like oh what a good guy he's helping or if the woman's doing all the stuff it's kind of like well that's just expected right and it's not always the case and it shouldn't be but yeah no it's a huge whip just to comment on that briefly women today are having there's a huge double standard for them in that exact context that you're saying and we have to work through that as a society somehow and absolutely it's another incredibly interesting topic for sure but yeah it's hard well and you know what and I'm just going to come right out and say it I blame Martha Stewart okay not because of her insider trading and going to jail it's actually kind of funny she hangs with Snoop Dogg but yeah what I'm talking about is like the bloody TV shows that say if you don't have the Halloween napkin rings on Halloween that you're a horrible woman and a horrible mother and a horrible spouse or partner or anything right and I'm saying it only slightly tongue-in-cheek because women who are just women in general in our society feel tremendous pressure to be the professional the spouse the parent the partner and the Homemaker who has all the wonderful treats and specials and goodies that Martha Stewart says so right and it's not just Martha Stewart I'm just for sure she's a good archetype for sure and then but then you have ADD ADHD into the pressures of women and now you have trouble focusing you're forgetful you're disorganized you have trouble doing your home and if guys are disorganized and have piles all over the place oh well I kind of close the door I don't really care I never cleaned up one my mom asked me but if women have piles uh all over the place or disorganization the shame that goes with it is horrible and so many women have this internal thought that if my home isn't organized I don't deserve to go out and have fun with my friends or be social because I should be home cleaning and other sorts of thoughts that are not necessarily valid but torture them yeah and then you throw kids in the in there too and now you got to be the mum with the most you got to have well I love the movie Bad moms it's hilarious right yeah yeah whether that's somebody's cup of tea or not it's just sort of like I'm not going to have the perfect gluten-free muffins at the bake sale and I'm not going to attend all the PTA meetings and I'm not my kids aren't going to have the perfect lunch and screw you expect me to right yeah yeah so I see a lot of women who find out about ADHD through social media and realize they actually have symptoms even though they didn't realize it and the other thing is many people become aware of the impairment of their ADHD as life demands change right so sometimes it's going from elementary school to high school and there are more demands less structure more independent sometimes it's going from high school to post-secondary sometimes it's post-secondary or Workforce in a lot of women I've seen recently it's children right they have children and all of a sudden all the coping strategies they used to do to keep them on track are thrown out the window you know one woman described it perfectly where she said I used to be disorganized all week my house would become chaos I would be behind on everything and then Saturday morning I'd get up and I'd spend six hours cleaning my home going through the mail dealing with bills dealing with all the Loose Ends that had to be dealt with and then I have a child who I love to the ends of the world and I cannot take the time I need and I never catch up and I'm drowning right and that becomes the trigger to say I've got symptoms I can't manage here the other thing I know I'm maybe I'm talking too long but what I'm trying to help my adult psychiatry colleagues to understand in our field as a whole is a lot of people with difficult to treat depression hard to treat anxiety they're not doing well enough because there's ADHD that hasn't been recognized right and you've got to figure out is there not that ADHD is the cause of all depression not at all right like let's not overstate this a colleague in Toronto Dr Martin katzman published a study I think it was 2016 where he was looking at adults with treatment resistant depression and screening them and assessing them for ADHD he found 34 percent of adults coming to a specialty mood Clinic with hard to treat depression had undiagnosed ADHD of course when he starts treating the ADHD they get a lot better so a third you know that's very significant yeah I imagine getting uh Goosebumps actually because I think that's very much was my situation as well or anything part of mine was and I think when I first got diagnosed the doctor was a bit quick to go to the antidepressants for me and I said no I'll just start with one thing uh medication for the ADHD but as I healed and recovered from ADHD and sort of learned how to process things and organize my life so to speak to the you know it's all relative of course um it's a journey like yeah yeah but no doubt my depression and anxiety amongst the other things I was doing for myself decreased greatly and my psycho I would always describe it as I can't find this I can't find that I start getting late I'm late for this I'm late for that I'm unorganized I'm all over the place and then the anxiety and the anger and the depression set in as a result of all of that and of course it's not perfect linear but no doubt that was a huge part and then I'd have sort of full-on adult meltdowns and temper tantrums and then I'd just be shut off and I kind of you know need to go a lie down or I couldn't do anything or I'd be so disregulated that wherever I was going whatever I was doing I was just I'm going through the motions I wasn't present at all okay thank you for sharing I want to jump into like I could yeah like you said pull on a bunch of different threads I really want to underline emotion dysregulation Beyond sort of depression anxiety and I agree with you completely it's such a good description of what so many people experience the other thing is emotion dysregulation the bigger reactions disproportionate emotional reactions to smaller things right and so many of us with ADHD have it um and there's actually good research showing that ADHD medicines and of course Psychotherapy help this significantly right and so many people get misdiagnosed because of it sometimes it's bipolar disorder sometimes it's you know maybe not an official diagnosis but an anger disorder in kids it can be called intermittent explosive disorder but it's really emotion dysregulation with ADHD and if you go back far enough this was considered part of the disorder of ADHD and then it was taken out in favor of the attention deficit and the hyperactivity impulsivity but so many of us having motion dysregulation again women I hate to say it but so many women get misdiagnosed with borderline personality disorder because they are having emotion dysregulation it's hard to control emotions it comes out with relationships and dramatic moods and difficulties and they end up um you know with now some people do have ADHD and borderline personality disorder but sometimes people are thought to have borderline personality or you know mild bipolar disorder bipolar 2 with hypomanic episodes and if they get the right diagnosis of ADHD and the right treatment sometimes they don't really have that now sometimes they do right it's like I say it's not all ADHD but there are people with the wrong diagnosis who need the proper treatment right yeah yeah can I can I just say something I'm going to interrupt sorry I totally misspelled my name here right I don't know how to change it but it is hand dull man d-e-l yeah I don't know I typed it in Fast and whatever I don't I I don't I hope that it that doesn't show up on the official recording but we'll see and we can fix it if it does it yeah well whatever it's okay I've got ADHD I may rush through something and make a little careless mistake what are you gonna do yeah anyway sorry to cut you off that's awesome no I like it um well I can't remember exactly I was talking about borderline personality and regulation well how how the sort of unobserved ADHD symptoms are such a part of these other diagnoses and I like that you said it was yeah insightful or helpful to know the comorbidity right or the Dual diagnosis of so many people with ADHD it's not just one thing and I think that do you think maybe we can talk a bit about the side of medicine and Society in general that are very dismissive of ADHD yeah I want to add one last thought to the previous previous idea and that is you know I really I'm glad we're doing this thank you for hosting me I'm I'm I really appreciate your mission to help educate people and destigmatize it's so important and in the context of ADHD part of the reason it's so important to learn so much more is there are so many ways ADHD impacts people that are not on the list of symptoms right so emotion dysregulation very common with ADHD poor time awareness time blindness very common with ADHD inconsistency right like it should really be on the list like I I'm sure you have this mic one day you wake up there's no good reason for it you may have slept well you may not have sucked well it may be signing it may be cloudy you may have eaten while you may not have eaten well and you are the most productive you've been in two years and you have no idea why and the next day you wake up and there's no difference and you're like struggling to like meet your basic needs right like we all have it and it's it can be wonderful when the stars aligned and whatever happens and you're so productive and other times not but it's infuriating for parents and partners and co-workers of people who have ADHD who don't realize this is part of the ADHD and when we get good treatment we become more consistent it's easier to follow through on the annoying boring simple things right so there's so many different ways it manifests and it's I'm glad we have an opportunity to share this with people and hopefully it's part of a broader education and stuff so now we can talk about doctors if you want yeah please and we there's been threads of it throughout this the distinction so my just as an example my my GP is not totally dismissive of ADHD although at the same time the doctor is a little bit dismissive and and I I think will never solve these conundrums or these disagreements in our society and in medicine can you just speak to that dismissiveness and also the over Association of symptoms oh I must have ADHD or that person must have ADHD and and how we rush sometimes in either direction yeah so I mean when I was in medical school I guess there was probably one lecture about ADHD and a Psychiatry unit but I honestly can't remember your average Psychiatry resident who trains in Canada it's five years in the US it's four years unless they specialize um would get six months of child psychiatry and probably have some exposure to ADHD and maybe have one or two lectures on it adult ADHD just starting to be introduced but it's not much better now than it was 20 something years ago when I finished medical school right so we're not teaching enough I think depression is understood obviously schizophrenia bipolars understood we're making inroads into the stigma and misunderstanding with mental illness um but ADHD it still sort of feels like excuse me The Stereotype of the kid who's too hyper and takes pills that's ADHD if you're a doctor if you're a therapist if you're an accountant if you're a teacher if you're you know just try harder right you're fine you know I tried hard I get distracted sometimes too and I try hard and look I can do fine why don't you do it too right pull your socks up and you know we were talking about before uh you and I before the interview that sometimes it seems like there's a big rush to get diagnosis and sometimes it seems doctors are so reluctant and I think there's a really interesting you use the word paradox it's a really interesting Paradox where on the one hand it is in many times over diagnosed or rushed to diagnosis and in other places other times it is completely under diagnosed and it's sort of a weird situation and I don't really think the research suggests it's actually over diagnosed but that's what people believe yes um and you know there there will always I often see news stories I stop paying quite as much attention at least since the pandemic but there would be new stories out of different countries like shocking the prescription rate for adults with ADHD has doubled I'm like yeah it's gone from 0.2 percent to point four percent and reliable research shows it's almost three percent or thereabouts of adults who have ADHD so at least we're making a little progress good job not enough but meanwhile the Press is trying to make it seem into seem like it's a big pharmaceutical conspiracy right so I think you know in my experience unless you know in my child psychiatry training I got interested in child psychiatry obviously I seemed to mesh well with the kids with ADHD I got along well I liked working with them no surprise we think the same way I didn't realize it at the time but you know I was fortunate enough to spend a year training with one of Canada's top ADHD researchers right Dr rushless shacker at sick kid so um I got great training and experience with ADHD but most doctors don't even in Psychiatry right so um oh my gosh I just lost my tree I thought where were we going over diagnosis over diagnose and writing right so most doctors don't realize it I find doctors become a lot more comfortable with ADHD when they're they have a family member diagnosed or they have a patient who was high functioning they don't really believe they had ADHD but some Specialists said so and then they see the dramatic Improvement right somebody that they believe just has a drug and alcohol problem and then the ADHD gets diagnosed they do their therapy and they work it through and all of a sudden they're feeling better functioning better and the difference is dramatic so much better than if they hadn't diagnosed ADHD that's when doctors start to become quote Believers right and it's it's awful this is the thing because you know this isn't like a religion you don't have to like like ideally it's science right like like this is a real condition there's a ton of research there we know what it is we know many of the genetic and brain issues though that's a whole other big Frontier to discover we know treatments that help therapy medicine you don't have to like believe in it as if you believe in God or Christ or Allah or something it's it's a scientific thing right so but still even though doctors are theoretically men and women of science or people of science it's still sometimes takes belief change right so and and for the people who I guess I had two questions one is how do people who aren't per se getting some validation or acknowledgment that yeah this might be a thing for them How do they this fits in let me try to put in the thread there's the thread of when we're younger we don't get the support we have the and I see this a lot too is this the this sort of withdrawal and pulling away from life oh no one hears me no one sees me no and as you said really nicely no matter how hard I try nothing happens so what's the point in trying and that internal sense of either I don't matter or there's no point trying to figure this out because no matter where I go nothing gets figured out and no one listens to me and those and that's a common stigma for any mental health problem but yeah for sure yeah and how I don't know if I'm answering the question as I ask it how do we encourage people in situations like that to then seek somebody else or and I know this is a healthcare situation right your um wait list is now closed right and so it's it's so hard for people to get the help once they get to the point of saying wow I actually really think I need it um yeah so there is for sure a so there's the individual and the psychological aspect which you were describing very well I think there's also guilt in there like I should be doing it I'm you know I'm not living up to whatever um I should be using the resources that are available to me and I'm not so it's my own fault you know different things like that but then there are serious Healthcare issues so I think if an individual says whether they're watching this or they saw it on Tick Tock or social media or they read an article or a friend said oh my gosh I just got diagnosed you and I are like peas in a pod maybe you should talk to your doctor right people often go through like a lot of barriers right first they have to accept it and there's a lot of self-stigma right there's a lot of what if this is the case oh my gosh my brain is broken and not working what if I maybe I'm really probably just lazy what they told me was right you know etc etc then there's the stigma of their immediate family right like spouse if they're you know an adult or partner their siblings parents you know what not sometimes cultural beliefs are a big barrier too um you know really a lot of cultures apart even in Western culture there are stigma but a lot of cultures that are not Western Europe and North America it's like an insult to your parents if you say I think I have ADHD because it suggests they didn't raise you right it's cultural beliefs that you're not willing to be a hard worker etc etc so many layers and then you go to your doctor and God bless them so many doctors say oh you're fine you're not hyper you don't have ADHD don't worry about it you know just try harder right and oh you've got depression we'll treat your depression right like so there's so many and then where I now ask and I even in my assessments for ADHD to be thorough to tick all the boxes to establish symptoms going back into childhood and all the things we need to do it is the most unfriendly thing for somebody with ADHD to go through an ADHD assessment right checklists bring your old report cards do do this do that timeliness paperwork whatever like I cringe that I make people do it but I want to be thorough and give them a proper assessment and it's hard but when they do it they get the right assessment diagnosis and treatment plan then I like to think is kind of doctor-proof right like it's I take all the boxes I'm throwing Etc but the point is there are so many barriers and if you talk to your doctor and they say nah you don't have it well then if they say well okay but I don't know where to refer you go find somebody so now we're asking people with ADHD that's undiagnosed untreated to do like 27 000 steps in the direction that it require organization and planning and everything else so it is particularly difficult I think we're getting better I you know I do my best to be involved in educational programs and help doctors learn more different things like that so you know we're hopefully getting there but it's not easy it's not an easy Journey for people uh what I would say to anybody who's watching this who hasn't been assessed or diagnosed yet and believes they have it is stick with it it may take you longer than you think I mean I saw somebody this past week who said you know feeling you know they had a lot of social anxiety and they said just even judging myself or worrying about what people would think held me back from getting the referral for a year or two right and that that happens to so many people so you know persist with it it may not be perfect it may take you too long you may not do it right but if you get yourself assessed and diagnosed you start you have the opportunity to get treatment right and get things more on track and hopefully we can open up the education to a lot more doctors and doctors will be more accepting and there's different Health Care System issues whether you're in Canada like we are U.S Europe other countries developing countries you know there's a lot right like it's but yeah hopefully people can persist right at least if you learn about it and think it sounds like you you can while you're going through the process listen to podcasts audiobooks you know I always say I tell people I recommend a particular cognitive behavioral therapy book for adults with ADHD and I say you know bibliotherapy like doing therapy through a book is great except when you have ADHD you know you may get the book get excited read four pages put it down and find it under a pile nine months later and do absolutely nothing right so it's it can be really helpful but doesn't always get followed through on I need is the challenge Ah that's awesome okay I think maybe one piece we didn't touch on and I know we're kind of running up on the end of our time is the you did mention it a bit briefly where I like to think about it so the parenting piece and this is obviously more for kids and teens I think when as parents when we get frustrated with the symptoms that come out in our kids so not being organized being late getting out the door keeping notes and homework and all those kind of things I think what I see a lot is when the parents jump in to do the things for the kid because of their own discomfort and their own anxiety that's a huge piece and I sometimes I describe it as the the parent is taking on the executive functioning development of the kid when they jump in to do those tasks for the kid and it's hard for parents to let go sometimes or to see their own part in the problem I guess right or in the in the journey and and maybe and how I remember you I asked you sort of in a in a clinical manner or something along these lines of bringing the parent into the conversation you gave me such a good answer um so maybe you could just talk a little bit about that and then what was the answer I gave you don't leave me in suspense well I don't want to say it because I want to hear you yeah okay if I totally forget what I told you jump in and remind me what my wisdom was I'd appreciate it I will um okay so look I think when we think of treatments for ADHD particularly in the context of kids and teens the research is very clear that medicine plus therapy works really well well that statement applies to ADHD across the lifespan right pills don't teach skills if you learn the skills but can't really use them because you can't focus you don't really benefit from them so ideally combination medicine and therapy there's good research for kids and teens that parent management Psychotherapy it's a parent support is very helpful individual Psychotherapy for younger kids you can only accomplish so much in teens there's more ability to work cognitive behavioral therapy which is the best researched model for adults with ADHD Works quite well teacher skills and helps with the thinking and the emotions and things like that but to be able to do that you have to like think your thoughts but then also like think about your thoughts and analyze your thinking and when you're a young kid or a teen depending on your maturity your executive functioning you may or may not do that very well but there's absolutely a role for kids to learn some behavioral strategies but parent Management training is really important now a lot of parents feel like this is parent blaming right okay so my kids having trouble uh I was worried I didn't want to come because I was worried you were going to blame me as mom or dad or whatever and now I come here and you tell me I gotta go to therapy because my kid has troubles obviously you think it's me and the answer is not at all right in my view parents are not the cause of ADHD but they absolutely need to be part of the solution right ADHD is predominantly genetic right we think of a biopsychosocial model so there's the biological component the psychological the social but it's so genetic genetics play a big role so we don't choose the genes we pass on to our kids at least not now and probably not for a good long time so you didn't control it you didn't create it it is what it is right but I always think like if a kid's diagnosed with diabetes and they need to manage blood sugar their parents will go to the diabetes education center with them and they learn what to do what do we do when the blood sugar is high what do we do when it's low what do we do when he goes to soccer what do we do when he goes to his friend's house right and they learn strategies and structures and the parents you know essentially create structure around their kid and make sure that any responsible adult knows what should be done in different situations and that's exactly what we're looking for for ADHD now if any parents gone through parent Management training and Psychotherapy they realize it's a lot about self-regulation right because as you described your kid with ADHD can do things that gets under your skin and challenges you and as we talked earlier many adults are just busy as anything because ADHD runs on family they may actually be ADHD ish or have ADHD that's not diagnosed yeah to a lot of parents a lot of adults I see say I came into an HD assessment because my kid got diagnosed and I looked at the list and said oh my goodness sounds like me right so it can run in families there may be more of the money ADHD member and so a lot of the parent management therapy is learning to be present without the emotion dysregulation your kid will try to push your buttons and you need to do your best to stay calm we are all human there are no perfect parents in fact if you try to be a perfect parent you're not going to be a perfect parent this is how we get the helicopter parents and the new one the lawnmower parents who let me clear the way so my child will never fall and scrape his knee and whatever yes no plow whatever right it's like I will clear the path so my little Sweetie doesn't have any trouble in life well if they don't have any trouble then they don't grow up well right like we all have to grow and learn so yeah it's a lot of self-regulation it's behavioral strategies uh it's a challenge but I really encourage parent Management training and it's not parent blaming um but it really makes a big difference yeah yeah and let me share one other thing can I share one more please please you know one of the hardest things with teenagers just thinking about a lessons you know so many teams are dealing with challenges and it just seems to be getting worse even post pandemic so many challenges around social issues bullying cyber bullying drug and alcohol issues sex and sexuality gender issues other things and they may come home and their parents like many parents do so it's kept to do your homework I'm not doing it now well you're misbehaving pick up your jacket the hook is two inches from where you dropped it please don't make me every day come and do it and while we're at it let's get up to your room and clean it up it's been more than a week and you haven't done it and it's disgusting and the kid retreats to their room slams the door gets on social media and doesn't say another word to their parent meanwhile that day they may be considering self-harm or suicide or whether there's any point in pursuing education or their future and their parent who loves them so deeply wants to be the person that they can trust that they can talk to about all these really difficult things that they're facing especially post-pandemic world where school got disrupted social life got a disrupted exercise got disrupted Etc and they won't go talk to their parent because they got yelled at because their jacket wasn't put on a hook their dish wasn't put in the dishwasher and they're behind on their homework and their room's disorganized right and I'm not saying to parents don't hold standards for your child of course you need to I'm just saying if you work with a therapist and realize and you prioritize what are the top things there are some non-negotiables right you need to be home at this time and you got to make sure the door is locked okay like for safety um you're not driving while drunk you're not you know taking a wife into school like whatever there are absolute you're not sticking a you know metal into an electric socket right there are absolute things that cannot be negotiated however there are many things you can close your kid's door right you can pick up the jacket and say I'm not going to fight over this tonight because I want to talk to my kid about their future and their education and be there to support them and listen to their fears and help to build them up right so obviously this is oversimplified and every individual is an individual but I think you know parents sometimes we need to think about things differently and getting professional help when needed can make a dramatic difference yeah awesome thank you and maybe that's a good place to to wrap it up um yeah I mean we could keep going are there any maybe lastly sort of any other things in this domain that we didn't talk about or generally speaking when you think about ADHD Society assessment treatment the path that are important to to mention I mean I think you know I'd like to probably finish with more thinking about strengths and differences right in my book I talked about sort of the gifts wrapped up in ADHD these days I'm talking a bit more about the strength based approach um you know neurodiversity is a relatively new term that when it first came out really referred to autism spectrum I think now it's kind of broadened to ADHD as well and those of us who think differently and our brains are wired differently and we don't necessarily fit the mold and while that can be very hard and soul crushing through a standard education and while that can be very hard in Soul crushing in a boring repetitive job it gives us the opportunity to think differently problem solve differently be outside the box and make contributions in ways that many other people don't see and so I feel it's really important to take a strength-based approach to help people to realize we all have strengths even if all the terrible things we've talked about throughout this time together where you know the the self-stigma and not going well and judgment from others and losing one's hopes and dreams or whatever there are still strengths inside you that can grow and develop and make you unique and give you the opportunity to make a contribution that others won't even think of or consider so you know I take some time in my assessments to talk about strengths and help people to realize you have strengths too you may be really different I mean I think one of the gifts of social media and proliferation of sci-fi and other big you know box office movies whatever is kind of like maybe a bit cool to be a nerd these days maybe you know it's not just our nerdy friends and colleagues and ourselves aren't just hiding in the closets feeling geeky all the time right like it's you know so we're different we think differently we can problem solve differently we can contribute differently and I think it's important to acknowledge our strengths recognize them and build them yeah lovely and I think that also fits so nicely into the when you can recognize that or I think often helping people believe that that's true in them they know some part of them knows that it's there although working through all the stigma and the doubt and the sort of self-criticism to get to that point but once they can start opening up to that and start believing it and seeing it in their life that generates so much of the motivation and the purpose and the drive I guess or or the stick-toedness for lack of a better word uh to move forward and to thrive even and um yeah yeah it's so nice when you see that unfold in people it's really inspiring and it happens so often Yeah well yeah and so many people I see with ADHD they'll say I have trouble with this I have trouble with that and then they say yeah but then there are times where I have so much energy and I'm super motivated and I get so much done and it's incredible and sometimes it's thought of as actually a hypomanic episode right like increased energy increased motivation sleeping less completing a lot but when I go in and I ask the questions this is just a Super Hyper focused time and part of the goal of treatment with ADHD is to get a lot of the challenges out of the way so it's easier to have more of those right it's easier to say I have a goal that matters to me I'm going to work on it I'm excited about it I'm going to hyper focus and create things because they're meaningful to me and they can help others right and that's that's when we can our sort of Magic on leashes right yeah and and to carry that a bit more when when you experience that or in your own life or have another thing I think that's super helpful for people is when that dies down and the drive decreases and they're in a bit of a lull that's okay right like I think we get caught up in the expectation that it it needs to be like this all the time right or to use the CRT um Distortion it should be like this all the time or it must be or if not I'm a failure or whatever yeah and and that helps maintain the likelihood that it'll arise again yeah I mean I think it's like if you run a marathon unless you're like a super duper ultramarathoner right you got a stretch you got to recover you got to do some recovery runs and then you gotta like give your body a bit of a chance to heal right right right you know another way I think about this and I really noticed this when I would go travel internationally for you know short times like go overseas to the world ADHD Congress the last time I was overseas was before the pandemic 2019 the world ADHD Congress in Lisbon and I will hopefully be going to Amsterdam in two months for the World Congress again uh in 2023. so um but when you when I travel to Europe for like five days and come back man I'm exhausted when I get back and that's when I really realized to function while I was an adult with ADHD there's the foundation sleep nutrition exercise then there's the planning organizing systems right calendars and to-do lists and whatever then there's the sort of work and the motivation and other things when I come back and I'm exhausted and sleeps disruptive eating's disrupted exercise is disrupted I get through the absolute must-dos of my day and then I'm a vegetable I sleep I'm exhausted I'm jet lagged right and gradually over several days or weeks I build the foundation and I come back so if you have super productivity yeah you got to recover that's natural right right there are seasons there's Ebbs and flows but yeah like you said you got to be careful for that negative self-talk of really you know self-criticism that just sort of cuts you off at the knees ah thanks thank you yeah so nice my pleasure thank you for having me it's a lot of fun yeah yeah it is a lot of fun hopefully uh sometime down the road we can do it again um but yeah thanks again for your time and May the force be with you thank you I'll just say at some point I may restart my ADHD podcast but I do have a website at drkenny.com and I don't really send newsletter emails but if you want to get updates if you go there when putting your name in the email address at some point hopefully this year I'll be wrapping up this online stuff again so wow and is it literally d-r-k-e-n-n-y.com yeah amazing and the the clinic website is yeah the clinic website is c f i m h.com so Center for integrative mental health in Oakville Ontario yeah we can of course we can leave it in people can know about it we have a long wait list but yeah and okay and and if people want to get your book attention difference disorder how to turn your ADHD child or teens differences into strength in seven simple steps that's available on uh Amazon book stores Etc yeah thank you awesome okay well thanks again and I'll include all those links in the sort of show description and everyone everything like that for people and uh yeah thanks again thank you so much Mike take care bye [Music] | Starts With Me | UChbAyApyFCQNoF3-ocKvdag | 2023-04-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 12,161 | 76,463 |
E_nFawnvMuQ | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_nFawnvMuQ | Political Science- Leak | Hello my name is Kaley Vick and this assignment is for Professor Petri's Political Science online class at Saddleback. Because I am a Communications major and have studied journalism in the past, I want to pick a topic that I have seen before. This term that I choose today for the video project is called a leak. In our political science book, it is defined as a piece of information given to a news source or journalist by a government official. I hope that by the end of my video, you will have a better understand of what a leak is and how we can see this happen in everyday life. Hello again my name is Kaley and I play the character of Kelsey, the journalist from Newport Post. Hello my name is Brad, and I play the part of John Evans, Secretary of State. Hello my name is Terise, and I play the part of Kelsey's friend Tamera. *Phone rings* Hello this is Kelsey from Newport Post, how can I help you today? Kelsey, this is John Evans, Secretary of State, I have some very urgent news that I need you to report on right away. Of course, what is it? I finally have the name of the man who killed the American, Jay Roberts, the journalist who was abducted and killed outside of the United States. This is huge news, we have been trying to get information on him for weeks now. What is his name? Before I give you his name, I want you to do one thing for me. Yes? I need you to mention my name in the report because I will be the one giving you this information. Of course, yes I will include your name as the person who found this information. Okay. The name of the man who killed Jay Roberts is, Ryan Webster. Thank you, I will report on this right away. (Hangs up the phone) Breaking news tonight, Secretary of State, John Evans has believed to have found the person responsible for the killing of American Journalist, Jay Roberts. He believes the killers name is Ryan Webster. (People cheer in the background) What is that look for Kelsey? I saw your news cast, great job! Thank you. I just remembered something my political science professor taught me. Really? What is it? It is called a leak. It's information given to a media outlet or journalist by a government official. What made you think of that? Well before I broadcasted the story about Jay Roberts, John Evans, Secretary of State called me to report the killers name. So what you are saying is that was a leak? Yes, that is exactly what I am saying. So why would a government official want to leak that kind of information? So they can undercut other officials and get them recognition from the public. Well, do you think it worked? With all that cheering from the public, yes I think it did. I want to thank my parents for helping me out with this video and their amazing acting skills *laughs* so I just wanted to say thanks. *Laughs* She's not going to talk, she's going to walk in and sit down and then you're going to go to her. Breaking news tonight, secretary of state John Evans has believed to have found *I messed up* I hope that with my video today you have a better understanding of what a leak is thank you. | Michael Petri | UCAul-H85UzuyYvuRC3ujwyg | 2014-12-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 581 | 3,088 |
iEfc4ENP9jU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iEfc4ENP9jU | A New Year and Bitcoin | hello viewers so this is just an end of the year 2022 was a great year don't you think I think so worked out well for me um but I just want to talk about a couple things that happened this year and a few things that might happen in the future so uh I hope that you guys have noticed the last couple of months uh I've had the same microphone but now I have you know this adjustable stand so I can actually put it in front of me uh with ease to where I can record better audio for you guys uh so hopefully the audio has sounded better I noticed that I go I think noises with my mouth a lot more in my videos uh so I apologize for that I don't do that with thinking also I'm trying very hard every video to actually look at the lens I I tend to look at my picture on the screen instead of the lens and I feel that's a little weird I don't know if you guys notice that but so also sometimes even though the audio has hopefully been improved on my videos I uh sometimes my camera is a little out of focus I love my Canon T3i it's older but it works great uh and thing is uh it doesn't have it has automatic Focus until you start recording video and then it's locked in unless you do manual which is fine because I'm going to turn off automatic Focus anyway because I hate videos that go in and out of focus because people are moving around so I would lock in the focus anyway I used to have a little remote control and I would just take a still shot with myself and that would focus the camera and then I'd press record and do the video I don't know what I did with that remote they're a couple dollars and I was going to buy one uh another one but normally what I do is I just focus the camera on my chair and then sit down so sometimes it's not perfect so I apologize about that but I'm hoping to get an extendable arm just like I have for my microphone here for the camera so I can bring it in close and actually reach the button uh for recording I also am hoping to get a nice lens for my camera um very happy with the two lens or I got I got a wide angle lens like a fisheye lens that I use sometimes I have a telephoto lens and then I have this standard one that came with the camera very happy with them but I want to get a nice camera for videos that I do more Home Videos it's not going to make too much of a difference for these videos uh but it might make the picture look a little bit nicer so I'm hoping that you guys will see some improvements on the video quality in the near future uh so there's that I also want to take time to talk about patreon and my patrons uh so you know I have a handful of patri patrons on patreon and uh some of them are silent they you know they support me monthly I don't hear from them there have been a few times where I've put out surveys and questions and no one answers them which is fine if you want to support me just enjoy my videos and that's fine uh but there's uh a few of you that I've talked to regularly and I I just want to take a moment and thank uh Mr newbie Mr newbie I've video chatted with him a few times uh he's a really great guy he actually has this website that he's set up that he's giving me the access to and there's actually he set up a matrix clients client there to where we chat and there's another patron of mine in there if you're a patron of mine and you want to chat with me regularly he's given me permission to Grant access to a handful of people so I can do that for you if you're a patron of mine and um if you want to be part of that you can become a patron of mine over at patreon.com metal x1000 there's a link in the description of the video so uh yeah if you want to talk with me that's that's the best way to do it is become a patron over at patreon but I want to talk a little bit more about Mr uh Mr newbie I hope he he's okay with me talking about this um so we got talking once and I don't remember how it comes up it comes up every once in a while in my life so about 12 years ago back in I what it seems like I thought it was earlier than this but 2011. uh there are a few of you out there who asked me to start accepting Bitcoins at the time I had no clue what a Bitcoin was but I looked into it created a wallet posted it and two or three people gave me some Bitcoin and um I don't really remember exactly I think I just did the clicking thing with my mouth that I was talking about but I don't really remember exactly but I want to say it was around one one and a half Bitcoins that I had at the time I remember looking up it was worth 14 or 15 dollars it's Bitcoin I didn't know what it was I didn't care much for it no no one thought too much of it back then um and I did something that I never ever do I compressed it in a 7-Zip file and encrypted it and password protected it 7-Zip why did I use 7-Zip why did I encrypt it like I kind of thought oh this is like money thing I should encrypt it which is really weird because that's not something I normally do I normally keep important files offline secure in a safe I don't encrypt them because I'm always worried about getting locked out of them so I am one of those people who have been locked out of my Bitcoin which one Bitcoin was worth you know sixty thousand dollars a year ago I think it's worth about twenty thousand right now and I'm pretty sure I have around one and a half so uh I mentioned this to Mr Newby and he offered to try to crack it for me because I tried a few times in the past running it through a thing but it's like I had no clue what the password was how long it was and I would run you know uh trying to brute force it for days and it'd be a fraction of the way through was doing so he offered so I sent him the file because what's the worst case he cracks it and steals the money I'm not getting it anyway a while later he contacts me wants to video chat with me and he tells me I've cracked the word but I I've lost the original file so basically he pulled the hash out of the file the the password hash and ran a crack on that but he accidentally deleted the the pzip file so I went and I got it and he told me the password and at first I'm like that doesn't seem I don't remember using that password the more I looked at it because nowadays I just I gen randomly generate 32 character whatever uh password and then grab part of that and use that as password so my passwords are completely random and I use um a password manager to handle that back then I didn't and more I looked at it there were words and numbers in this and the numbers uh did have association with me and I don't remember using this password more I looked at I was like that does seem like a password I would have used and not only that but one of the words was misspelled which is exactly and it was misspelled in exactly the way that I would have misspelled it so I'm like yes this this has got to be the password but it didn't work he gave it to me I tried uh sent him the file he tried we uh were like okay we used peas uh seven piece up I made sure I had the full version of pzip seven seven zip I have the full version of seven zip um and then we're like okay yeah well I was using Debian back then I don't really remember what version so he got an older version of 7-Zip to see if that would do it and eventually I came down to um what we finally just determined was the file was corrupt right the the header where the password was wasn't correct but somewhere down further in the file it was corrupt so I do backups regularly so I go to my safe and I have hard drives all the way back from the early 2000s hard drives that are over 20 years old and what I do is I back up stuff to a hard drive and multiple hard drives now but backed up to hard drive when that hard drive gets full I buy a hard drive like double that size copy all that stuff to the new hard drive keep the old hard drive and keep adding to it so I I have multiple copies of stuff and I used to back things up to CDs as well but now every year I back up I have I have two servers my next cloud and just a Raspberry Pi that I do rsync to slide back everything up to those and then I have some offline some online backups for certain things and then I put things every every year I put the files and photos I have on that on flash drives because flash drives are cheap you can get a 64 gig or 120 gig or 28 gig for for under 20 bucks so I I have a binder in my safe that has each year marked these are the backups from these years and it's the photos and videos for that year but also any documents from that year and previous so I have multiple copies of this file so I start going back as far as I can I again I have hard drives further back then um that file was but the earliest copy of that file it says it was created in 2011. and all my copies are I look at my hard drives from 2010 I had nothing I looked at my hard drives that I had from 2012 and it was there but it was the same exact we checked the hash file the the md5 some of it and it was the exact same file so it seems like right off the bat I had a corrupted file because I can't find any earlier copy that was right around the right time so unfortunately unless I find another file uh of that wallet on on you know unencrypted somewhere I wonder if I should just try to no no it doesn't matter I you know it'd be nice to have an extra twenty thousand dollars but I'm surviving now but I just wanted to tell you guys that sorry he was very very helpful even after that he kept running um crack on it to see if you can get other passwords just to make sure and because with with hashes like that you can get multiple passwords that work um but the other passwords he came up with still didn't work and I'm sure that first one he gave me like I said it was words and they were spelled wrong in the way that I would spell the misspell them so uh yeah that that's not working for us uh but I really really appreciate all the effort he put into it and uh yeah thanks for that so Mr Nubia I wanted to say thank you for uh you know having your server sharing it with me and my other patrons and for working on that for me he's also been very helpful in Sharing uh different tools he uses with me I think you know projects I didn't know about on like GitHub or lab and um he's just an awesome guy so uh he if he had a YouTube channel I would recommend him but I'm pretty sure he doesn't because he's never shared any of his videos uh but yeah again if you enjoy my videos and you want to become a patron check out patreon.com forward slash millux1000 maybe uh maybe we could hang out and chat and maybe I'll be doing a video about you someday but uh yeah Happy New Year I hope that uh 2022 was a good year for you and I hope 2023 is even better I hope my videos continue to uh inspire you that you like them that you learn new things and uh I love making them I hope that you enjoy them happy New Year | Kris Occhipinti | UCf93fPKwotph47H3_KDcRyg | 2023-01-01 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,270 | 10,884 |
aJgHX0hSCTg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJgHX0hSCTg | The 7 LAST PLAGUES - Revelation 15 Study w/ Pastor Mitchum Burnett - March 13 2021 | so it is truly a good news for god's people because when we consider the fact that um this book was written to a people that were struggling or wondering how they are going to get through these last days or how are they supposed to cope with difficult situations um revelation is introduced john writes a letter a book full of letters and encouragements because revelation is really encouraging to the saints um it is really something that when you study it and you get to understand it it's really saying something powerful to all of us who read it it reads with great joy that god is truly um he hasn't just abandoned us he's coming back and that he is going to take revenge he's going to take his uh follow his word and go back and get those who have opposed him will repress his people and life but before we begin uh let us pray and ask god to be with us our father in heaven lord we come to you now asking for your grace and for your mercy and we ask that as we have been setting the book of revelation that your spirit may guide us your spirit which is the seal which guarantees us which is a deposit guaranteeing our salvation lord may you direct us to your scriptures and guide us we pray in jesus name amen amen we'll be covering through a few chapters i would like a volunteer for us to read revelation chapter 15 and let's go from verses actually just read all of revelation 15. it's a very short chapter about six verses eight verses sorry revelation chapter 15. got it okay okay i saw in heaven another great and marvelous sign seven angels with the seven last plagues last because with them god's wrath is completed and i saw what looked like a sea of glass glowing with fire standing beside the sea those who had been victorious over the beast and its image and over the number of its name they helped held harps given by god and sung the song of god servant moses and of the lamb great and marvelous are your deeds lord god almighty just and true are your ways king of the nation who will not who will not fear you lord and bring glory to your name for you alone are holy all nations will come and worship before you for your righteousness acts have been revealed after this i looked and i saw in heaven the temple that is the tabernacle the tabernacle of the covenant law and it was opened out of the temple came the seven angels with the seven plagues they were dressed in clean shining linen and wore golden sashes around their chest then one of the four living creatures gave to the seven angels seven golden bowls filled with the wrath of god who lives forever and ever and the temple was filled with smoke from the glory of god and from his power and no one could enter the temple until the seven plagues of the seven angels were completed okay thank you very much so um revelation 15 it comes on the heels of revelation 14 after we just heard about this great harvest i'll take place at the end it's where god is going to separate the wheat from the tares or as he would put it separate the wheat from the group and crush his enemies and the likes revelation 15 goes into um as some people say um revelation 15 and 16 goes into details that some people don't want to hear about you know um just like you don't want to hear your your your mother or your father spanking a child or your your your spouse spanking another child it is it is details that don't really bring to heart joy however when you understand who these plagues are for this is actually encouraging and reassuring the saints in a very strong way and it should encourage us who believe as well so first off what we're looking at here is um of revelation 15 to 18 portrays a vivid language of the execution of god's divine wrath in terms of the pouring out of the seven last bold plagues upon the worshippers of the satanic uh triumvirate and the subsequent judgment on the end time babylon now there are theological meanings for the seven last plague we have to understand their purpose their nature um a key chapters to understanding the seven last plays in the old testament are found in jeremiah 51 and exodus 15 as well as from exodus 7 to 15. there's also the timing of the last plagues we have to understand that these last plagues are not being poured out today so unfortunately for those of you who believe that the coronavirus is one of the last plagues it is not it is not one of the last plagues um it is not a plague from god it is which is a natural plague that happened natural disease that happens um that happens we are suffering with diseases and likes um there's also the trumpets and the seven last plagues there's a correlation for those who have time if you look at the trumpets in revelation and the plagues you can almost see some sort of parallel with them as well so this is just giving you an overview of the book of these of these couple of chapters so that as we go into them we're going to look at these themes and understand these things even better so preparation for the last play it's the punishment of the wicked um it is something that really brings to mind something uh important john is in heaven john is seeing something now in heaven he's there standing and he sees uh angels who most likely blew the trumpets they suddenly come out of this this area from heaven that they suddenly have these plagues in these bowls now these plagues that they have they are the last plagues upon humanity no more plagues after that after that is is jesus coming and that's it these plagues however are not for everybody there's something very important that we have to have to understand is that these seven last plagues are only for the followers and worshipers of the satanic trinity that means the dragon the beast and the false prophet okay only these the only those who follow and work with that group will be suffering the seven last place so the people of god those who believe in god will never be affected by these seven aspects the saints are god's protection and watchful care we are not suffering the last plagues only the wicked are suffering these plagues so it starts off by telling us about this marvelous sign a huge thing these angels seven of them with these plagues because god's wrath is completed and verse two says and i i saw what looked like a sea of glass glowing with fire and standing beside the sea those who had been victorious over the beast and his image and over the number of his name they held harps giving given them by god and sang the song of moses and of the lamb so john sees a sea of glass this is um this is almost the same thing that we saw in revelation 7 where the 144 000 are standing on the sea of glass and they are um enjoying this moment not so much as they are relishing but they stand in a position of saved they are the saved they are the redeemed they are the purchase of god but they're not just standing there for standing sake they're actually singing a song of redemption the song of moses and of the lamb for those of you who've ever read exodus 15 um after the children of israel crossed over the red sea miriam picks up her her harps and her timbres and well her timbrels and starts dancing and singing a song because god god did such a marvelous thing that you know when you know when you get something when you get paid or when you get a big bonus paycheck you don't leave work like you know you're actually a little jokey you're a little happy hey got a little money in my pocket you know the saints are saints are saving because are singing because they have been redeemed they've escaped all of these these plagues they've escaped all this turmoil they now stand in a position of uh of saved but their salvation they recognize is not from their deeds but from the grace of god okay it says great and marvelous are your deeds lord god almighty just and true are your ways who will not fear you and bring lord to you for you alone are holy and nations and worthy of worship and righteous acts have been revealed it is the righteous acts of god that saves his 144 000 those are the people of god but after that john sees something else he sees that in heaven the temple and this temple is a dulling place of the testimony now i remember in the old testament there was that the sanctuary and the sanctuary there was the outer court the inner court there was the the the the sanctuary itself that had the holy place and the most holy place now who remembers where where the ten commandments were where were the ten commandments where was aaron's rod where was um a bowl of manna kept where was that kept in which room the most holy the most holy place exactly and very often this um this this room was called the place of dwelling because this is the only spot where god really reside it was like a it was that was where god manifested himself the only person allowed inside that room was the most was a high priest only one time a year and only on only unless he had um well asked for forgiveness or or offered sacrifice for sins and they were accepted and that's why they often tied a rope around his his leg um whenever he went into the most holy place and if the bells and the pomegranates stopped ringing they knew he was dead so they would pull and that one there but we never hear that happening but the most holy place is the temple is is in reference here okay so john is seeing that out of this temple out of the most holy place is coming the seven angels the seven angels are coming with plagues they're dressed clean they're in shining gold they're they are dressed to kill um for the ladies are inside here you all know that there are some outfits you can put on that will kill a room uh amen you meant to be but these angels are not coming to try and seduce a man or a woman they are trying they're coming with the judgments of god the angels emerge from this section because these seven plagues are coming from god himself they're not coming from the devil they're not coming from angels they're not coming from anyone else except god this is god's judgment upon the people upon the upon the wicked all right so they're dressed clean and white this means that they're righteous these are pure judgments these are righteous judgments then one of the four living creatures gave to the seven angels seven bowls now you know we all love getting a bowl of soup a bowl of rice a bowl of cereal but you know these bowls are not the same bowls the these are temple bowls that are the the temple bowls of offerings offering to god in the sanctuary there was these bowls that were used to that you would use to offer incense or you would use support incense upon altars and the likes and they usually were filled with incense but they represented the prayers of god's people symbolic fashion right now they are the instead of just being the instruments to offer praise or or prayers or supplications they are now the instruments of destruction full of god's wrath so what this is really showing us is that remember in revelation there was this altar and the saints were crying out underneath the altar and they were saying how long oh god how long wait until you you avenge us you will give us justice god is returning in symbolic fashion with this bowl of prayer saying i heard your prayers i'm going to and your prayers and i'm going to give back to all the enemies of you of you all of my enemies everything they deserve okay now the reason why this is good news is because god is not going to be merciful to them he's not going to show them an ounce of mercy because its time is up enough of sin enough of the wicked enough of these this the the of this foolishness it's time to pay the piper all right execution of god's wrath has been initiated by the prayers of the saints so for those of us who think that god is not answering us we're praying oh lord you know get back at jason he's been bugging me lord avenge me and all that stuff god hears our prayers you know but now this is coming at a time when probation is pretty much closed okay this is a time where people's fates have been sealed and this is important that we understand the timing of these last plagues the falling of these last plagues do not come now they're not gonna fall tomorrow two days and two days from now so don't think just because you hear a thunderstorm or an earthquake that that's one of the seven last plagues this is coming at the end of earth's history this is coming when people's salvations have been decided when they may have just made their final stance okay the bible tells us that after these bowls after these angels came out the temple was filled with smoke from the glory of god from his power and no one can enter that temple anymore what does that mean you know now this reflects a scene from the dedication of not off of the temple of the tabernacle in the wilderness so in exodus 40 34 and like in first kings whenever they dedicated the temple it was always filled with smoke so that none of the priests nobody could go inside because god's presence was there god was making it was going to do something mighty and and majestic so probation has closed and intercession on behalf of the sinners no longer exists okay wow everything's ringing so vanessa you have a question or yes go ahead so basically when you say fate seal when the plague starts we our fate that's it we can't like search for fate for god basically yeah basically what we have is that's it yeah so if you're on god's side by that time you're on god's side you're locked in um if you're on the devil's side you're locked in and it's usually it's usually something that people question about like why can we get more chance but how much more chance do we need um ecclesiastes 9 says for um for those who are among the living have hope for even a living dog is better off than the deadline while we have the chance now is the time to decide our faith and choose god okay okay all right so when these plates fall things are already been decided okay so he's not so he's god is not gonna accidentally let one of these things these plagues fall on somebody who's you know let's say carlene you know was was sleeping and she didn't wake up and god punishes no it's nothing like that by that time people have decided that they are with god or they're against god or whether they're standing with the christ or they're against against him by being on that on that mountain so it's very important that we understand that this is something that really affects us but it's not affecting those who are with god only those who are against it now any questions any more questions feel free to stop me this is this is not always the easiest um easiest chapter in the book of revelation it is it is a chapter that is very um it's a chapter that that demands a lot of uh questions and asking if you have if you have any so here's the thing before we get into these seven last plays there's something that i want to share with you and also i want you to take note of when i was in university i remember there was a homework we had to do before we even started studying the last place because we were all excited to learn about the last place but the teacher was like we have to learn the foundation of some critical things before we even move forward now the seven legs the only other time we hear about huge plays being sent by god like this is found within the plagues of the exodus or the plagues that fell on egypt now who can tell me what these plagues were could you name all the ten plagues that fell on egypt who knows them uh did the water turn into blood one was one of them yeah water turned into blood that's one the other one the when the frogs came into egypt okay yeah we got frogs yeah we got water turned around locusts okay we have locusts uh the firstborn firstborn okay the boils on their skin boils okay all right fail hail someone says hail okay oh the darkness when the sun goes down or am i mistaken we have darkness yeah we have darkness okay all right so for those who want to look let's look at this together if you have your bibles look in exodus chapter 7 and we're going to go quickly through through seven eight nine ten eleven twelve we're not gonna read the thing we're just gonna see the see the plagues that they're there okay so in exodus seven um aaron is to speak to moses moses is gonna go to pharaoh and gonna tell pharaoh let my people go right let them go so they can come back in three days and you know after they have a worship aaron's staff becomes a snake the magicians of egypt they they do the same thing they're like please moses we're not impressed your rod can turn to a snake ours could turn to a snake but what happens to rod of the of the magicians what happens to their rods that turn to snakes eat it up they got eaten up so that's not really something you should boast about we can transform our stuff so there is something that we have to understand here is god sending his prophet to speak to the king and he does a miracle in front of the king and what does pharaoh do pharaoh tells his magicians to do the same thing counterfeit but the real power is with who moses and aaron right so mo so aaron's staff swallows up their staff but pharaoh's heart was pharaoh convinced of that i don't think so no remember this is that this is the part of the bible where it says pharaoh harden his own heart and then pharaoh's heart was hardened or the lord hardened his heart you know that remember here we see the first plague is god says to moses go tell them let my people go you're not going to drink water you're going to drink so that's the first plague the second plague is frogs right everybody's affected we're after that we have the plague of gnats remember that gnats um for those of you who've ever gone camping and who don't bring your off um [Music] you know those flies can really bite at you especially like mine you know then there was a place so is it but we're looking at gnats so the next one is the plague of flies a swarm of flies uh i don't know if you guys remember valdesquare but you know they used to have these flies dead inside the window you had to clean out before you slept that night but plague of flies a lot of flies could be a nuisance then the next plague was the plague on the livestock cattle and all their things that were there in chapter nine we have the plague of boils as well then we have a plague of hail right and hail you may not think it's impressive but even today if hail falls and gets your car or hits you it will hurt after the plague of hail what comes after that the plague of darkness okay darkness um and then after the plague of darkness we have the plague of the firstborn all right so those are our 10 plagues okay those are our templates now did all of these plagues affect everybody no no which of these 10 plagues that fell on egypt only affected the egyptians what was the question which of the ten plagues only affected the egyptians the first egyptians as in the ones that were oppressing the israelites all of them so all of them mm-hmm how many were general like they affected everybody in the area three and how many only touched the egyptians but never touch god's people oh didn't all of them touch the egyptians but never touched god's people yes not necessarily because the plague of blood you know the whole nile that's enough that's a general thing it's everybody that was affected um but yet you could dig on the side in um in exodus and you could get water the plague of frogs frogs were everywhere the plague of gnats the gnats were everywhere these the flies only went towards pharaoh and his and his kingdom the livestock only affected the livestock of the egyptians the boils only affected the egyptian they hail only on pharaoh on his country the locust only on pharaoh's crop the darkness only upon egypt and it's very important that we understand this because when we get to revelation now revelation is telling us that these seven plagues who are they attack who are they attacking are they attacking god's people or are they just attacking one group one group and that is the enemies of god's people so the seven last plagues are not for god's people for the ones that are not listening to god exactly so when you read the seven last plagues those plagues are not for those who believe in christ they're for those who have refused to accept christ who refuse to accept his law refuse to accept his will these are the enemies these are the wicked it's very important that we understand that before we even move on all right so revelation chapter 16. can i get a volunteer to read verses one oh we'll go to one to ten well one to 11 verses one two eleven i got it go ahead then i heard a mighty voice from the temple said to the seven angel go your ways and pour out on the earth the seven bulls containing god's raft so the first angel left the temple and poured out his goal on the earth and horrible mandalas stores broke out on everyone who had mark who had the mark of the beast and who worshipped his statue then the second angel put out his bowl on the sea and it became like the blood of corpse and everything in the sea died then the third angel poured out his bowl on the rivers and springs and they became blood and i heard the angel who had authority over all water saying [Music] you are just o holy one who is and who always was because you have sent these judgments since they shed the blood of your holy people and your prophets you have given them blood to drink it is just reward it is just their reward and i heard a voice from the altar saying yes o lord the almighty your judgment are true and just then the fourth angel poured his wool on the sun causing it to storch everyone with its fire everyone was burned by this by this blast of heat and they cursed the name of god who had control over these plagues they did not repent of their sins and turn to god and give him holy then the fifth angel poured out his bull on the throne of the beast and his kingdom was pledged into darkness his subjects around their teeth in angus anguish and they cursed the curse the god of heaven for their pains and sorrow but they did not repent of the evil deeds and turn to god all right we'll stop right there now this it doesn't sound pretty it's not the the as one of my one of my teachers said it's not the sexiest part in the bible but it is it is a very important part in the bible it is god pouring out his wrath on on the wicked and it's very important that we understand that god has reserved his wrath for the devil and his allies it is not for god's people god is not reserving anything terrible for us he's actually reserving good things for god and his people this is why the invitation throughout revelation is to accept god come to god the three angels message what is it you know fear god and give him glory for the hour of judgment has come okay don't wait until the end don't wait until your parents are knocking at the door before you take out the chicken out in the freezer or before you go and clean the dishes do it now while you have time while it is daylight so probation has closed people have been decided this is the moment where god is pouring out his wrath and the bible says uh john heard a loud voice from the temple saying to the seven angels go pour out the seven bowls of god's wrath on the earth the first angel went and poured out his bowl in the land and ugly festering sores came out now here's the thing there are so many different interpretations about these plagues left and right i have read some pages in school after school even now and there are so many different meanings some people think that all of these plagues are symbolic some think they're all literal some think that they're not really true they're just a story to scare us um but they are important now the first five couple of uh the first five or four first plagues are obviously literal they're not there's no symbolic um um connotation in it there's no symbolism in it it seems to be very specific that it's hitting these people um the first plague that falls in the last day uh yes vanessa go ahead didn't see you um i sort of a question it kept saying they did not repent but wouldn't they not repent though because probation was closed yeah we'll get to that part we'll get to that part it's um it's telling us it's it's echoing another story in the in the bible that um we just read in exodus but we'll get to that all right okay okay so here we have this these plagues that are uh the avoid saying that pour out these plagues the first one um says that festering sores broke out on the people who had the mark of the beast and worshiped his image so this is a starch difference between those people who have the seal of god and those who have the mark of the beast so people who have the seal of god don't get the boils only those who have the mark of the beast okay so they get boils on their skin festering boils these are more than just pimples or acne because that's all i could find on three images these are plagues that affect them now this plague only affected the egyptians if you read back in in exodus but this recalls us of the sixth plague that struck egypt bad and malignant boils appeared only on those who worshipped the beast right so we don't know how long they suffer this we just know that these plagues come one after the other the next one the second angel poured out this bowl on the sea and it turned into the blood that like that of a dead person and every living thing in the sea died and the third angel poured out his bowl on the rivers and springs of water and they became blood now i know there's some of us who can watch horror movies you know i couldn't watch horror movies for a long time because i thought they were too gory they were so bucky and nasty and until i you know saw behind the seeds footage and realized that the blood was fake and all that stuff i started to calm down because you know horror movies me and horror movies don't mix now i can watch a horror movie and i'll laugh because that's fake that's fake that's fake but when you walk into a hospital or when you give blood and you see blood for the first time real blood coming out of a person and the thickness the hot the the heat it is a different experience and um even professionals healthcare professionals i'm surprised that even some of them are not used to blood they don't like it falling on them they don't like it crossing their hands some of them they're like blood you know it's not the same feeling um but this second and third plague remind us of the first plague that fell on egypt but do you remember what happened in the first plague in egypt when pharaoh um when pharaoh saw the plague happen what did he do who could remember what he did he uh made his own like uh type like uh making his like uh thing with water with a powder i think okay i don't know about the thing with powder but uh the bible tells us that you know i saw it as magicians yeah you saw it where i saw like uh in the movie like prince of egypt ah okay okay okay um take it from me brothers and sisters um the movies don't tell you everything all right okay you know read the book um as someone who went through the primary in high school teachers can always tell when you can't when you don't when you don't read the book they'll easily tell you did you read the chapter yes i did when you only watched the movie or the video um the video won't give you the details all right so when i get it now when the first plague fell in egypt what happened was is that pharaoh was unimpressed and he called his magicians to come and do the same thing and they were able to do that but the thing was is that though the red the the denial where the blood was you couldn't drink from it so what people did was dig on the side so they dig on the side and they look for fresh water here in this plague this the second and third plague both the sea and the fresh water supply is affected but not everything the bible tells us in exodus that only a third of the water supply was destroyed and a third of life inside them was killed off as well okay now why is god doing this why is god going really you know this is where you get this thing all armageddon on these people and we see it here in verse 5 verse 5 of chapter 16 shows us the the clue it says then i heard the angel in charge of the waters say you are just in your judgments o holy one you who are and who were for they have shed the blood of your holy people and your prophets and you have given them blood to drink as they deserve now i don't know if any of you have ever had like you know a younger brother or older brother or a sibling or even a friend pull a prank on you and you know they they tell you here open this coat or this this soda and you open it and it spouts in your face and if the parents see that happening to their child what do they want to do they want to get that child for doing that to their child here god is repaying the persecutors the oppressors and the wicked for everything they did to god's people so god's people suffered persecution god's people suffered isolation god's people suffered uh death and murder and torture god is going to pay them back everything with tax okay so what god is really saying here in the king james you'll read that it says um you know that they are worthy um but what the the better translation is saying they deserve it uh the old english we would understand it better if it says when it says worthy but today we don't say you're worthy of uh you know so they deserve to drink the blood that god is down because they are the ones that shed the blood of god and his prophets and the likes so then he heard another voice saying lord god almighty true and just are your ways so god is bringing justice to his people all right so oh yeah i went and explained it before i could even get there so they are worth the age of blood um it means they deserve it the lord is repaying the wicked and answering the prayers of tears for justice and avenging this is divine justice next it says the fourth angel um poured out its bull on the sun and the sun was allowed to scorch people with fire now i thought montreal was hot and i keep forgetting that when you go to the west indies when you hit the caribbean the sun is different okay and i remember one time i i i decided that um i wasn't going to go and use the washing machine at university i decided to hand wash my clothes and when some of the jamaican students saw me they're like what do you do here i'm bridging yeah canadian so i said you know i'm beijing i know i wash my clothes and i i forgot that when you put your clothes out in the sun in the caribbean later they will scorch your clothes that that's that's direct sunlight so don't let it uh get burnt does it let it stay there all day you have to go pick them up quickly you know it would get on fire or not not on fire they'll just get scorched a little bit okay yes um and i remember one time i left them there the whole day and when i came back things were crispy and you know my jeans were felt differently you know you can't leave your clothes out in the sun all day if you go to certain parts of this world right now in the sahara desert or even uh there's a huge desert in china that is even even as hot as the sahara desert you could really die from that exposure to the sun because there's little moisture around there is little that can help you now this fourth plague is not so much like going into the desert this is a divine punishment and the wicked are the ones who suffer under intense heat okay intense heat now the question is usually asks if the sun is affected how are god's people protected this brings another point when the children of israel are walking through the wilderness you know the desert what was over them during the day cloud the david was a cloud right when elijah was being persecuted from um from jezebel when he had to run from jezebel and ahab you know where did he go he went to a you know a little ravine a little cavern and god provided what for him a raven and a stream he was protected [Music] so it's important that we understand this while we go through these plagues all these plagues are falling on the enemies of god's people but god's people are protected so while they're experiencing hot summer we're experiencing a cool spring amen for those of us who live in montreal when it got to that ridiculous 35 degrees celsius and your air conditioner and your fans were just pushing around heat you know it's good that you stay in a cool place so just like pharaoh of egypt recognize the hand of god but refuse to repent here is the part that most people question because as uh vanessa was asking as they're suffering these plagues the people who are wrecked who are suffering the wicked they recognize that this is the hand of god just like in egypt when the plagues were falling the egyptians realized that this is the god of the hebrews that is pouring out these things even pharaoh recognized that but pharaoh even in the light of all this didn't change his mind because he was set in his ways so in exodus those plagues were used to change the mind of thoreau but he refused to change his mind these seven last plagues are poured out upon the wicked because they refuse to accept god so even in recognizing them their rebelliousness is locked in and even if they recognize that it's god they still blame god for their own actions and still refuse to change because they're stuck in their ways i don't know if you guys have stubborn friends or stubborn neighbors or people who just will you know park their car in an area and just refuse to move it even though you're honking your horn there are some stubborn people in life right in revelation these people are so stubborn so stuck that they refuse to repent this means they refuse to change refuse to glory it's just they're so locked into their way they won't ever change okay so if vanessa even though probation has closed um this is not god giving showing any mercy they're just so hell-bent on being locked in and into this that this is how revelation is describing it they just refuse to repent they're continuous rebellious they are rebels to the core they are enemies through and through um another example i like to give is this when i studied um i remember from sec five when we were doing um the history of world history or you know and likes and we were studying world war ii i was shocked to realize that when hitler realized he was losing he never gave up he went down into a bunker and pull a bullet to his head now why not go to jail for the rest of your life doesn't that make sense hitler refused to get caught refused to let them string him up he was saying you know what no way boom this is what's going on here in revelation these people the wicked are locked in they're the wicked let's put it through that way they're wicked they're followers of the beast and the likes so does that answer your question vanessa does was i clear was i yeah it's good okay good so keep asking questions if you have questions i'll try and answer my ability if i don't know i'll tell you i don't know um the next plague it says the fifth angel poured out his bowl on the throne of the beast and its kingdom was plunged into darkness wow now you may think and i know some of us are reading and saying well it's not really a plague that's nothing living in north america we always have electricity right now we're using electricity but when you go back home when i was barbados and i went there for a while when power cut power cuts tv's gone lights gone your fridge is humming that last home if you don't have candles if you don't have flashlights you're done and even when i was in school in jamaica whenever it got dark people started screaming getting outside and all that stuff and i was like yo it's dark it's really dark and when you take out all the electricity here in montreal when you take away all those things it really gets dark in montreal it can really get dark now this darkness is not just a regular darkness this is something that can be felt okay while the first four plagues of humanity uh uh plagued the humanity of humanity who support the beast this plague affects the seat of satan's power so this scene recalls the six plagues on egypt remember the sixth plague in egypt that had this darkness that affected the all of egypt just the the area where egypt was and the magicians of pharaoh couldn't do anything to counter it they really couldn't counter it could someone read for us exodus 9 verse 2 exodus 9 11. verse 11 and the magicians could not stand before most because of the boils for the boil was upon the magic and upon all these wow wow so here they couldn't even stand before the boils and then there's hail and then there's locus and then there's darkness and it's like wow what is this what is going on so when we see these things you have to understand the magicians in eat were always trying to counterfeit what was going on with moses and his and his miracles and they could never successfully copy something that was effective enough he did blood they did blood didn't really work they call he calls for frogs they call for frogs but they only get a few frogs he calls for flies and there they don't even know how to get more flies he calls for gnats you know they can't get the gnats it affects their their livestock the magicians are like uh pharaoh we don't know what to do you know he summons darkness and they're like they light a candle and they can't even see in front of their own hand it is truly something disastrous that's going on a key thing here in exodus 9 11 even though it's talking about the boils the thing is is that they cannot stand and all that stuff they cannot stand up and just to pause and say this for those of you who really want to understand the old testament study the exodus experience this is the greatest theme in the old testament and it is a major theme throughout the entire book of revelation god is going to do what he did just as he did with the israelites in egypt he will do with his people in the end he will deliver them through mighty acts and mighty deeds all right so this sends the kingdom of uh of the devil into complete chaos um it's humiliating could you imagine you're telling people where the gods of earth where the true rulers and all of a sudden another god comes along and does something bigger and better put yourselves in the double seat right now i know we don't want to do that but what would you do if you realize that god is doing something bigger and better than you if god is throwing a party what would you do that's the throne is where if he's throwing a party you say yeah if god was sorry if you're the devil pretend you're the devil be the devil's advocate if god is throwing a party what would you do trying to tempt everybody do what say you said against like uh tempting people to do wrong all right thank you gloria say that again this is to be i said i'll try and get everybody accounted for a bigger party no there you go that's what i wanted to hear a parallel a sort of counterfeit so god's throwing a party i'm gonna throw a party god has a kingdom i'm gonna get a kingdom god is sending plagues doing a great sign what is the devil gonna do now i'm gonna do a sign so trying to tempt the people not tempt this is not that's not the key word the word is delusion or deceive okay um remember we talked about way back a few bible studies ago one of the great themes of the revelation is counterfeit counterfeit um you have to be careful of counterfeit money when you if since we're all christian we'll never go to the casino amen amen amen since we're all good christians and we never go to the casino um they always warn you when you go to the casino you know uh you know be careful you don't get any counterfeit bills they're handing out in front of the in the parking lot or you see money on the floor don't be quick to pick it up you know sometimes it could be fake and if you go if you get caught with it you won't get your money back so one thing that's here that we need to understand is that the devil is seeing all these plagues happen upon his him and his kingdom his allies he has to respond he has to go back he has to decide to do something he's suffering plague after plague have to play and you know his people are tormented they're they're gnawing their teeth they're they're in agony they're in chaos he has to pour out something now but it happens under another guys so the bible tells us that a sixth plague takes about now i'd like someone to read for us how much time do we have it's four o'clock oh boy we might have to pause and make a part two um revelation 16 and verse 12 to 16 12 to 16. revelation chapter 16 verses 12 to 16. who would like to read that for us i can read those verses go ahead all right i'm starting from verse 12 then the sixth angel poured out his bowl on the great river euphrates and its water was dried up so that the way of the kings from the east might be prepared and i saw three unclean spirits like frogs coming out of the mouth of the dragon out of the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false prophet for they are spirits of demons performing signs which go out to the kings of the earth and of the whole world to gather them to the battle of that great day of god almighty behold i am coming as a thief blessed is he who watches and keeps his garments lest he walk naked and they see his shame and they gathered them together to the place called in hebrew armageddon okay all right guys so now we've come thank you so much ishmael we've come to this plague the sixth angel pours out his plague on the great river euphrates now here is where it differs the river euphrates is nowhere near canada let's just put that out there there's you could you could call a river euphrates here that's not the euphrates river there's no euphrates river in china there's no euphrates river in europe this is in the northern northern part of africa this is a huge huge huge river it's almost they call it the snake river in some parts of the world because as you can see here um based on the free image that i could download without paying any copyright on your left it's it's a huge river that go all the way through snakes around goes through huge bodies of water now this river is famous because it is a great supply it separated israel from all its enemies it was also of the river that cyrus used to dry up to get into babylon to to take it over with the meats and persians you know um we'll get to cyrus in a minute because he's going to play a theme in this but when it says that the great great river euphrates was dried up in order that the way of the kings of the east from the rising of the sun might be prepared what is this huge sentence what is it let's unpack this now the great river euphrates is um must be understood as symbolic it is not the actual euphrates river it is a symbolic representation of something greater because the bible is the only the greatest interpreter of itself we have we have seen that the river euphrates symbolizes the national powers the peoples the multitudes and nations and tongues and we can read that in revelation 17 which we're gonna do another time so the great euphrates represents the peoples the huge amount of support and and and peoples that are supporting babylon because the river euphrates used to run through babylon and it was necessary for a river to run through this huge city in order to feed it if you don't have water you will days you don't have water you can't wash clothes can't cook food can't bathe can't drink you're done for you know so if you laid siege to babylon and you don't cut off its water supply it will live on and on and on forever the walls are too thick the walls are too high so here the bible is showing us somewhat of a an illusion to what cyrus did back in daniel when he cut off the water supply to babylon and went in from underneath and took the city so here it's kind of like god showing you like i'm going to take over this city babylon but i'm going to dry up its support before i invade it so we're seeing that this great river euphrates is symbolic of the the peoples and the likes and the drying up the drying up of the waters in the old testament often symbolizes a mighty action of god on behalf of his people so the drying of a waters by god is is preparatory to the gathering of god's people and bringing them back to their land this is really showing us that the support that the the the kingdom that the devil the dragon i mean the dragon the beast and the false prophet all of their support is withdrawn okay it's like uh it's like the montreal canadiens if they're playing a game if their game if they start losing people just get up and well they'll stay the whole thing but they'll get up midway and leave if it's 10-0 so this is showing us that babylon is going to lose its support from the very people that it was deceiving they're just going to pull away we don't know how but i would encourage you guys to go and read um ellen white's book the great controversy you guys ever read that book before no well the last few chapters the last few chapters of the great controversy uh ellen white describes uh some more of what goes on in these last days all right so i encourage you to read the great controversy by ellen white for those things but here we see that this drying up is really a preparatory work this is really echoing what cyrus the persian did um when he dried up the rivers and went in there now it says this is this is prepping us for the arrival of kings from the rising of the sun who are these kings coming from the east who do you think those kings are i don't know all right so so here's the thing there are so many different um illusions to there that are going on in the new testament the phrase rising from the rising from the sun or the east is often used metaphorically with reference to jesus christ these kings are related to christ in some way or fashion now there are three views that are put out there um one one theologian by the name of hans kayla rondell they're all seventh adventists by the way argues that the kings from the east represent christ and his angels as the people of god take the path take a passive role in the end god and his angels go out and make war on the uh on the on the beast and his and his um his his allies see mervyn maxwell inside his book god cares volume two argues that they the kings from the east represent god in christ since they are the only true king the book of revelation uh ranco stovanovich um the person whose textbook i used through revelation uh argues that this is they are christ and his people since god's people are seen in revelation as kings and priests from the beginning so there are different views that are there but rankle is really putting this forward that christ is referred to as lord lord and king of kings and that the saints are seen as royalty as well so god and his people are coming in from the east this is the side that good comes from this is the side that that the the true and righteousness the bible even tells us in the psalm that god uh resides in the east and that god comes from the east coming from the east was a good sign just like the rising of the sun good would come from that area so christ and his people will soon take control of this entire kingdom the kingdom of babylon put to shame put to dust but this happens as someone else is preparing for the battle who else is preparing for this battle satan and his allies let me say that again satan and his allies are preparing for that last battle now the sixth plague says that he saw three impure spirits that look like frogs this is one of the full times the revelation is really calling out demons and saying demonic spirits are sent out from the mouth of the dragon from the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false prophets they are demon spirits that perform signs and they go out to the kings of the whole world now brothers and sisters here's the thing this is now the first time in revelation that the beast from the earth is referred to as the false prophet and this echoes into what happens with these spirits it is all about deception deception is the name of the game just like in genesis where the devil deceived eve and just as he's been deceiving everyone throughout history and the devil is the chief liar even illinois says that these three impure spirits it's not any regular demons this is satan himself taking the last great deception this is satan's last attempt to counterfeit god just as there were three angels messages he's sending out his three messages and his three messages are signs wonders and lies the devil is trying to imitate god and he's trying to imitate god as much as he can now here's the thing remember how in the egyptian plague pharaoh was always trying to copy you know or reproduce what you know the what aaron did or whatever moses did there was a few plagues that really they that really stumped them and in exodus 8 verse 15 verses 1 to 5 you see that the plague of frogs the magicians had a lot of problems with this one because they just couldn't do it well they they could not they couldn't do it but they could actually copy this one they could summon frogs as well so here is the thing they can counterfeit and do some great deceptions and here ellen white even describes the situation in this sixth plague as the devil disguising himself as christ running around the world performing miracles this is why it's very important that we do not let our eyes lead us we have to walk by faith we cannot allow signs and wonders just because you see something sparkly or shiny just because you see fire come down from heaven doesn't mean it is from god the devil can perform signs and wonders as well okay he can put he's as good as a magician as anyone else and he can make and he can really make it look real all right now the devil is not trying to deceive god's people he's trying to deceive the wicked again he's trying to convince them to stay at works they believe the sign they believe that you know they're on the right side right so here with all this deception going on john says this blessed is the one who watches and keeps his garments now i don't know how many of you have gone camping but when you camp you have to make sure your camp is secure because when you're sleeping at night in the woods some people knock out real hard and when you knock out real hard some mischievous camper who get you sneezed by your director can go inside another camp and take their bags and take their clothes so you have to have someone in the tank in your tent to keep watch for a few hours while everybody else is sleeping so that if anyone's unzips they're like cuckoo i see you leave here in revelation we're seeing john saying blessed is the one who watches and keeps his garments what did jesus say when he was in the garden of gethsemane yes they can also come into your tent and tie you up yes they can yes you know but if you're strong like me you can break them oh yeah so here's the thing remember when jesus was in the garden of gethsemane um and he went to pray what did he tell his disciples while he went to pray what to watch but what did they do [Music] going to sleep they fell asleep and he came back so you guys couldn't watch one hour you guys can so really trying to so really watching is talking about staying awake you know this is where we get the term woke from you know staying awake so john is really trying to tell the people reading listen stay alert do not be deceived keep your garments that is keep prices giving keep what you have you know don't let this pass you by don't let it this is talking about steadfastness vigilance and trusting in god john is telling his people in the middle of this plague listen you've got to be aware of what's going on okay so they're these three spear unclean spirits go out and they're deceiving people to convince them to get ready for a great battle this battle is called in hebrew armageddon armageddon now what is armageddon now i've got some good news and i got some bad news um the bad news is is that it is a real battle but the good news is it's not as scary as it sounds i was expecting something scarier when i first studied this but it the more you keep studying revelation more you realize this is good this is good this is good this verse 16 says that the the place that the kings came together was in hebrew called armageddon which in hebrew means mount of megiddo now in israel there is no mount of megidium none whatsoever but there is a place that sounds like it and everybody knows this mountain and archaeologists have studied it and even professors who've gone back to israel know that this mount is really mount carmel mount carmel now do you guys remember anything very significant happening on mount carmel in the bible you guys remember a story from cradle roll or sabbah school when you were young who could help me out what famous battle took place on mount caramel between god and his prophet and the false god and their prophets uh this is the one with uh with elijah elijah exactly exactly now quick rundown of the story quickly remember the story elijah was preaching truth and righteousness and jezebel didn't like it jezebel wanted the dead he ran away he was hidden inside the wilderness for for years and elijah said until i say no rain is going to fall um on on israel until i proclaim it so for a long time there was no water falling then when he finally spoke again water came down as he was riding on his chariot while he was running ahead actually and the water was falling when he got to mount caramel he was actually throwing a gauntlet forward to the prophets of baal saying if your god is god then i will serve him but if it's my god then you serve my god and the great test was this the test was you make an altar cut up the pieces pour water on it and whichever god reigns that is the true god now what happened with the prophets of baal they cut themselves they wailed they tried to sneak fire here and there and no fire came down from heaven but when elijah prayed fire came down from heaven consumed his sacrifice and consumed of the sacrifice of the prophets of baal and even consumed some of the prophets of baal so who was the true god the god elijah my brothers and sisters if you really want to understand the battle of armageddon read first kings chapter 18 first kings chapter 18 tells you the story of battle armageddon because it is a battle on mount carmel between god's true prophet and his people versus the fake gods and their people so the place armageddon is really uh really another way of calling on a battlefield on mount carmel it's calling us back to that that great battlefield there's so much i can explain as why is it mount carmel was a place of significance in earth's history because a lot of battles took took place there a lot of important battles there's jehu there's um uh what else is there um there's several battles that take place on that plane on that playing field in the likes so here we see that the devil is marshaling up his people deceiving his people into getting ready for that final plague and this is what they're getting ready for they're getting ready and the seventh plague is poured out and brothers and sisters i want you to know this plague is no joke it says that the angel poured it out on the air and from the temple came a loud voice and said it is done it's finished this is the same this is almost an echo of when jesus was crucified you know jesus said it is finished this is a proclamation saying it is completed this is really trying to talk about the completion of the the plagues has been poured out this is over salvation has been determined everybody's on their right side people have locked in it's been done the wicked have been punished now it's time to reward righteous it says then there came flashes of lightning rumbling peels of thunder and severe earthquake all the combinations that human beings hate if you like earthquakes this one is the biggest earthquake ever if you like thunder these will be the loudest peels of thunder ever if you hate lightning there will be lightning flashes that you've never seen before that can light up everything in your house with one second the bible says no earthquake like it has ever occurred since mankind has been on the earth so tremendous was a quake the great city split into three parts and the cities of the nations collapsed remembered babylon the great and gave her the cup filled with the wine of the fury of his wrath the island fled away and the mountains could not be found from the sky huge hailstones and and each weighing about a hundred pounds wow okay the fellow people and they cursed god on account of the plagues of hail because the plague was so terrible so the wicked are getting just what they deserve this destroys the secret rapture or the seven years of blessings for the jews or for special people this is it this is the last plague this is the last pouring out lightning thunder rain the rain everything huge earthquake that shakes everything to the ground but the dividing up of the kingdom into this um [Music] did i explain to you what it means to divide up into three or can we do that another time i think a third what does it mean that the it was divided up into three parts the kingdom of babylon i never did explain that to you did i oh we'll do that another time because you know a third is like you know the the devil took a third of the the angels and the likes and there's so much to go into that but this is really the final plague that falls on god's people um not about people but the enemies of god's people the wicked and every island is gone from antigua to trinidad and tobago from japan which is an island greenland things are gone um this is not a time for nationalistic pride time to be aligned with christ and his people and if you're not aligned before these plagues fall it's too late too late so my invitation to you guys as you see what these plagues are revelation put them there to let us know this is what the wicked are gonna get the righteous are getting a city the righteous are going to get eternal life don't suffer the plagues choose christ today accept christ today be on christ's side today and stay faithful today and forever okay so any questions before we go with our few moments we have left any questions kevin and ross i don't know who ross is who's ross anybody know ross hey ross hi how are you all right good hi javon darling they asked who is ross so they were trying to answer i don't know no oh i thought you were you were ross i i am ross but gene you knew me as alvin shelley's daddy okay why are you laughing okay all right thank you okay gene nice to hear you you seeing me okay there's gene there gene bergeron does not see you i'm sorry no i'm not seeing you i i don't know my my camera's probably not working well i don't know okay okay anyway i'm seeing you we don't work thank you tiffany how are you i'm okay how are you good to see you i hear you okay good guys okay mitch sorry all right so are there any questions about these seven last plagues about anything that we studied up to now we looked over any questions concerns well i don't understand that i have a question yes go ahead so like we were talking about before how like the devil tries to mimic what god does right yeah how do you like tell which is which how can you know well here's the thing um just as we said the timing of these seven last plagues is coming at a time where probation is closed in other words um it's a time where god's people have already decided that they're gonna be on god's side um the counterfitness of the devil um we've always seen throughout history we've seen how you know the devil has tried to mimic certain things but couldn't really do everything like god does he can't create life he can only imitate that he can't create um peace he can only give a semblance of peace um the the deception of healings and the likes like that those things are not to be a convincing aspect of our lives so just because someone is healed doesn't mean it's from god but when you're healed and you give glory to god there's a big difference but at this time in the book of revelation these plagues these deceivings this deception that the devil sends out with these uh three unclean spirits it's not towards god's people it's towards the wicked he's trying to deceive them again to keep them still on the side you know after god sends out all these plagues they start getting disillusioned saying are we on the right side and the devil goes out and says yes you're on the right side you're still on my side i've got the better power but god has the ultimate power he can crush everything and everyone so for us right now our surety i would say to you um read your bible study your bible to understand who jesus is who god is like so that anything that's contrary to the god of this bible or the jesus of this bible is an imitation you know if so go ahead yeah um yeah so when it says that jesus um is um you know when you read the story of jesus and and lazarus or jesus and mary or jesus and peter and you realize that jesus forgives and all that stuff if some pastor or preacher comes up to you and says you know jesus is never going to forgive you you know for for for doing that you know that's that's not god that's jesus ain't like that um so you got to be careful uh what people say to you you have to go and study the bible and read the bible for yourself to see the truth from the error so that's the best i can give you right now because the only thing i could tell you is that those plagues that follow they're not for the god's people they're for the wicked and any deception the devil is offering it's to the wicked not towards god people god's people are protected on this side so hope that answer that answers your question i was i was going to go i was going to say too much that um probably one of the greatest deception would be imitating the coming yeah well imitating christ is um is um has always been a thing even jesus says you know beware the false messiahs will come you know we've seen a glimpse of that there are people even today there are people who walk around claiming their god or their jesus um in the past there's been jim jones there's david koresh there's all these people that have come around they've acted like zip they've known what they're talking about and they were crazy from the beginning to the end and all they did was talking about they were crazy from the beginning and all they did was okay i heard myself twice okay so um the real decision was that they were okay all right so the real deception is coming really from people trying to imitate christ or pretend they are christ uh that's blasphemous in itself so i would recommend that um you study jesus for yourself read the gospel see what jesus is like and then you'll know who jesus is really like from those accounts i think i think we only have a an hour next week mitch okay i think the ay is coming on at um am i right with me um i'm not sure i would have to ask i think i think the 20th and the 27th i think i saw okay here is the youth week uh youth week prayer next week yeah it's a youth week uh youth week next week any more questions before we go any concerns worries hi guys i think before we go i think i broke into your meeting okay hi mitch i'm sister bergan it's yvette dawkins here i think i broke into you i just gotta leave i'll be back later i broke a little bit too early breaking into the seven last plagues all right okay so um yes um just to say this and final thought the seven last plagues are really an answer to god's people's prayers um god is gonna avenge his people this is why you know you read and write in romans you know vengeance is mine says the lord i will repay god will pay back all of your all of our enemies you know and the likes all right so let us pray and ask god to be with us our father in heaven lord we come to you now asking that you keep us faithful just as you said in jude that you're able to to keep us faithful and prepare us for that day lord may you prepare us for that great day and if we should die before that moment just as you said blessed are those who die christ now lord may you be with your people as we set up pray be with your your youth be with all those who are listening and bring us again next week and if there are any questions or concerns lord may we reach out to those to help us to make that decision father bless us forgive us avenge us in our prayers in jesus name we pray amen amen thank you you're welcome i'm gonna call you chasing this bible all right take care everyone bye | Westmount SDA Church | UCDfEPzQktwpEQnnK5MnbILA | 2021-03-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 12,630 | 65,169 |
qTmPbVzQEug | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qTmPbVzQEug | Glass Cast Play Guess The Thirst Tweet! | MTV Movies | le Dave J Davies says so and so is so pain I want him is so ping I want him what's James MacAvoy that's not hard little Pikachu emoji says blank is my second daddy with the emoji that's like my second daddy Bruce Willis Sam yeah baby James is getting too much attention here Andy Pandy with loads of unicorn a rainbow emoji says so and so is just adorable I tell joy wouldn't be James again would it be Bruce is adorable is adorable theone double n Fionan says son sue is a freaking God s Sarah Paulsen blank is a friggin goddess Neith Oh blank is coming for the award season 2020 and 2021 just you wait and Regan's just you white me sorry but it'll be too light you'll be broke you know I'll have money sorry hahaha sorry that's from a musical call my fair lady I'm not a singer you guys uh James just you wait Samuel Jackson Sarah me [Music] Megan's not the ordinary type says so and so is the most beautiful man in the history of man's Bruce James Blanc is iconic and that me Samuel Jackson yeah [Music] coolest guy in the world hashtag blank samuel l.jackson samuel l.jackson yeah it's got to be he is the coolest guy in the world I don't know who is the Sun but here's the coast got no I'm good at this game I'm Helen Wicke xur says why how sonsoo is just so damn sexy i intellij who's James Bruce so I got went wrong and that great thanks for taking that bag Sophie giraffe says can we just take a moment to appreciate her grit and lactose soon so as great of an actor Blanc is like seriously like seriously James ah it's very hard to even if you think is you to see you turn or Tania Starr says social was my mother baby but no Sarah Paulson Blanc is my mother me also not hard would not be great though if she just was your mother and you're just taxing that and I'm like Elizabeth Johnston is my mother I just with no t1 a kiss blank is that too much to ask is that too much to ask Bruce Willis Bruce oh I should have caught that cuz I'm in her son saw is literally the most powerful woman on this planet Sarah Paulson my intelligent well that's alien ah okay I almost said me but I decided you know that yeah just not seem like a total nut Patrick no offense but I'm so happy son so is finally getting recognition for being the best actor in the entire world Samuel Jackson the best actor in the entire world James thanks Patrick Thank You Patrick a blank is an angel devil she is God that's me Sarah Paulsen yeah thanks like my sister wrote this I'm just kidding right kay Kika vivid it says soon so is one of the most talented actresses of this decade by this decade by Enya that's Sara posing yep she really thanks Walken Utley say with Bruce and Sam sitting in that big pink room for a big huge joint therapy session scene and just going boys as samuel l.jackson this is nuts and then I'm sitting in the middle of them going alright back my socks off Jesus action you're like okie I remember crawling underneath Sam's chair on my back in like thruster night between his legs I don't feel remember that I did that I don't know if it was funny but my most memorable moment from filming was shooting a scene with James McAvoy where he played I think maybe six characters in four and a half minutes and I was supposed to act like it was no big deal and really the actress in me was just like how the f is he doing this it was I think you know I get to count myself as one of like the luckier people in the world and the acting world anyway to say that I got to see that front-and-center him looking right here what each take was better than the next and some of them were different but I mean he did it was just it was really one of those moments where you like you are irritating because you're too talented so many they're just so many we all had way too much fun on set like it was difficult getting us to do stuff because we were all just enjoying each other and you'll have the same sense of humor I think it would be Sam in a wheelchair in the rain and the profanities that come out of his mouth when he's like in the rain for two that was that was a definite favorite moment of mine it was just watching Sam be super sassy because nobody does it better you quickly realized that that's not just a camera catchphrase that's very much a Sam catchphrase and it made me feel I've always thought I had quite a filthy mouth and after spending time with Sam and Sarah and Sarah was just doing it to spite him I'm a saint I'm a total sane most of our pranking was just verbal jibes I liked it was there was never a second that you could let up everyone was always consistently kind of just like trying to best one another through language which is so much fun but yeah like at 4 o'clock in the morning you're like if you have to pee on have to be ready you have to be ready to respond all of the new characters are really fun to watch but I'll always go back to Hedwig like Hedwig was just the character that I and Casey vibed with the most like the second he starts speaking that way I'm just like babe so I think getting to getting to talk to him again he's pretty special no he didn't show me how to do any and I think he respects the the veracity of each one in such a way that I didn't want to do that one for me because you know for him they're they're real people yeah I like them all I like happy vana clappy hands I like her I'm really good at mimicking but when someone's doing like 23 different voices at you I'm just like just focus on staying in your one accent because otherwise it's gonna get really really messed up no I just I just love watching him there's a lot of them there's a lot of love between the two of us when we're doing scenes like that so it's just it's just fun to watch the other person do their thing a lot of the characters just came naturally and I was like oh that's Patricia and she will learn Hedwig's like that and four characters we were a hundred percent sure with I basically just auditioned different types of people tonight that I thought might be appropriate for what that character had to do in terms of its objective there's quite a few that got objected there was a sort of posh Indian guy that I went for kind of Oxbridge educated but like boring Mumbai kind of guy that I thought was really interesting but night be in an Indiana it was just like mmm I thought think that's very good and I said all right I'm a ejected nut that was one of many that got thrown out sometimes yeah a bit like you know Patricia is easy Danice was easy Hedwig was easy the guys I played for a long time what do you see the guys that I played just for a couple of scenes heat in there they were difficult and body was difficult actually as well a lot of people if they want to put on a lot of muscle and get truly get better not just get like in good shape and get ripped but actually get bigger the girl that got you a lot protein got yellow protein it's not true you do need a lot of protein but you got a lot of carbs and I didn't know that maybe a lot of people like that girl like yet though James but I think there's a lot of people killing themselves in the gym eating double steak and double check and you in not realizing you're pointing it a lot clean carbs as well so that's my big tip if you want to get bigger up and put on muscle got a lift hard you gotta eat protein be Hawaii a lot of clean carbs as well he has a wonderful trainer called Magnus who was just completely adopted by all of us like we all adore Magnus but it's just fun having a conversation with James whilst he's doing push-ups like you're just trying to get like you're trying to continue on a normal conversation he's just having to like beef up all the time his commitment to that was crazy you know I could just show up and do that but he had to every single day you had to go back to the gym had to wake up really early like he if he was committed and split he's doubly as committed in this movie he was dedicated for sure and you just have Magnus like this little gentle giant sending the back they like nod James 5 or I went le to get a haircut she needs a haircut I don't know if it's necessarily been left over for potential sequel I prefer just a movie that is left open anyway so that you're going in the you know you walk away from the cinema not going like I already have cheeseburgers like you walk away going like wow so maybe that could happen or maybe that's happen that I think that's why it's been left on I don't think he's gonna do support thank he's done two already he's probably tired of it by now I quite late to introduce a character who thinks he's a model and so he's always but he's always posing and he's always like mmm he's always like giving it a little bit of blue steel that would be kind of fun just something really right-wing and Megan that you can make fun of that'd be great I just wanted to continue on the trajectory that she's going on I think she's you know she's been through a lot I think she deserves a bit of happiness and the empowerment that she's found now and yeah I just I hope that she continues going along the path of self-love and an understanding of her own strength okay like I'm not gonna lie evil to play is really fun it's a bit intense in your own head but um it is really really fun to do but not for Casey I've got too much love for her I just want her to be happy like genuinely I think I think that girl deserves a break so I'd rather play domestic and happy with her and then leave the evil for the rest of them I think just having people meet my character i I've had so much fun with Ileana and she's mental like properly mental and that's just it I don't know I'm excited for people to meet her and kind of see what this agro crazy Russian woman is like I think they'll enjoy her I hope they'll enjoy him I kind of have taken on the beast and he'd sort of be the person that pick so I've kind of done that rules are different and that's my favorite thing about moviemaking in terms of the realms of the fantastical is that there still has to be rules to the magic to make it all work so the the rules of magic are very different in x-men and they are in glass glasses very much supposing that this is real world real people and I think that's what makes it a different kind of superhero movie my neck Oh scared off because it's a scary thing yeah we wasn't nice all the time he's scary so yeah hopefully getting to enjoy it as an audience member instead of but just actually being in a lot of those like really disturbing scenarios as an actor like we all wear there's quite a few moments were mean like most of the cast like they were doing this he's insane this is like intense so not all because usually something Crazy's happening and we're all like ah wow this is awesome action let's go for it we were like I don't I'm gonna do this so just get any water chip from as an outside part you'll be no [Music] you | MTV UK | UCuwUfM8E79h2sqp34Fut6kw | 2019-01-15 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,174 | 10,904 |
RW6TttGRCgg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RW6TttGRCgg | Make Your Military Vehicle Street Legal (Basic Requirements For Getting It Plated) | hey guys in this video I go over the process of making my growler at the street legal and I would assume it works for most military vehicles in general some of the basic requirements and some of the problems or pitfalls that you can run into alright let's go so unfortunately this does vary from state to state but there are some basic requirements that most states do agree on California is probably one of the hardest States that you can try and get something Streatley going for my understanding I mean it it's next to impossible but I'm not in California so it wasn't that bad of a process for me so some lists of must-haves you must have mirrors number one and I believe at a minimum they want you to have a driver's side mirror and a rear-view mirror and then some states might require that you have also passenger side mirror depending on the visibility of the rearview mirror you need seatbelts that are functioning also a regular round steering wheel that is at least 13 inches in diameter and for my understanding they won't allow other styles such as butterfly wheel or a joystick type of steering wheel you need a functioning horn and from my understanding it also needs to be audible at least 200 feet now I don't know how often they check that but that's what I found when I was trying to get ready myself to have the growler get plated you need a hood bumper fender functioning brakes and an emergency brake and they also want for you to have headlights brake lights turn signals tail lights and reflectors both rear and side reflectors you do need a certain amount of ground clearance I could not find an exact number for that but essentially they don't want you to be too low to the ground or too high off the ground which shouldn't be a problem for most military vehicles you need a speedometer you need doors that open or at least a space where a door should be so with the growler or with a Humvee you should be fine even if you don't have doors on it you need a windshield and windshield wipers you also need a place for your license plate to go so you need a license plate holder and it needs to be lighted and I believe that needs to be able to be seen from 100 feet some states also require that you have a front plate I don't just think that has to be lighted but that's one of the biggest things you'll run into with a military vehicle they don't have plates you know and a lot of times they just have spray paint that indicates what it is or you know jack points or lick points and tie-down points so that you know there's a few ways you can do it some places might require that you have one that is bolted on to the frame itself and you can get hideaway plates that you can kind of tuck it in after if your say at a parade and you want it to look more original and they also sell magnetic plates and I think it varies on whether they'll let you have something like that but it's worth the shot and the nice thing about a magnetic plate is it's easy to adjust that you're not modifying the vehicle you're not drilling holes in the vehicle which gives you more chance for rust and things like that so some of the potential problem areas or pitfalls a lot of times it seems like the BMV they may not have your make and model on file especially for newly offered vehicles like the growler you know if you've had somebody who has already titled a vehicle in your state sometimes they do have that but when I did it they needed to call you know the main office and and actually input that information input that make and model and that way they could actually title it for me or register also when purchasing if possible if they give the option purchase the full title document a lot of times you can order either a bill of sale or a SF 97 I believe it is or you can actually order a full title typically cost more but it's not significantly more I think it cost me about a hundred and fifty dollars as opposed to fifty or a hundred dollars for the other documents but I think it saved me a ton of time of headache often times they'll also want your vehicle to be inspected by a police officer that way they can check to ensure that parts are stolen they'll look for a bin or a serial number and they may list it as a VIN not present in that case you might have to apply for a bin from the state typically the title will come with the VIN if you do get the full title work but it may not be on the vehicle itself so you may have to have that installed and you can buy engraved plates that can be installed on the vehicle you just either have to do it yourself or find a place that will install it also it's important that if you do that a lot of times they want you to have this certain type of rivet that has a pattern on it that shows that it came with the vehicle I don't know much about that I didn't have to do that per se so I would look more into that if you were going to go you and the biggest thing is just be patient and you know try and work with the BMV and and see if they can get the information put in if it's not already in the system you know cross your fingers and hope for the best and you know there's a lot of good people that work for those organizations so you know just try your best to keep a positive attitude and see if they'll work with Jana all right good luck guys let me know if you have any questions | Me and My Growler | UCvm58Y9ppPy8FVrTODRas4g | 2019-09-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,053 | 5,355 |
3SRSbIeRumI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3SRSbIeRumI | {#iNN #TweetLinePlus} #Hillbots #JillStein #Pizzagate & the #Shaytards | most people think to stand out in this business you need to be the first one on top of the story or the person with the loudest Voice or the biggest ratings in truth to stand out in the news business you just need to ask the right questions and demand the right answers well hello everybody Welcome Back to another segment of uh in tweet line plus well I'd like to get the news out sort of the the updates out on a daily basis sometimes you have to take a chance you have to take a breather you have to sit back and let the information sort of sink in and do a proper analys you can't do an analysis that's instantaneous and this what I'm saying here you're going to get news that you're not going to necessarily find anywhere else you're going to get analysis that you're not going to find anywhere else and I take analysis done by other people and sort of ask as I connect the pieces from from sources uh all over the place I put together a more complete picture than than uh one would necessarily think I would so uh once again I'm looking at uh liel Lebron from liel Nation here uh I'm going to play uh the first part bit of of his um his opening uh uh uh his opening lines to his opening bit to uh is his title the video entitled how I detest yonell okay and a lot of it has to do is this backlash that's because she went out and said something about figure out Donald Trump's son how the world is going to be repositioned and and re situated after the Trump Victory that's precisely what this is it's like how how is the world going to be refixed and retouched up and and and rearticulated and realign I mean I'm serious it is it is still every single day another example of watching the mainstream Media or someone whether it's Rosie O'Donnell now by the way coming after Trump's son you know saying he's uh that that his son Baron is Autistic or what have you look let me tell you something Rosie let me tell you something I know you're miserable I I know you're self-loathing I know there's a part of you that hates yourself that nobody can get along with you no one likes you no one likes working with you nobody nobody does you have no friends you're one of these misanthropic miserable people who is so unable to to either love yourself for others everything you've touched has been a complete and utter disaster think about that nobody likes you you speak for no one you're not left you're not right but for you to come after a kid a 10-year-old kid who has nothing to do with anything i' said the same thing about Mal and Sasha Obama's kids leave kids alone I mean seriously now Ivanka Eric Donald Jun it's a different story they're going to be in the administration perhaps sons-in-law and I got but this goes to show you how the the the hatred this this vile this rancid this absolutely this this this no hold bar seething disgust and hatred has nothing to do with with politics this is where we are this is why this country is so so fra because we take it personally we don't know enough about the issues we just know the people who are involved I mean okay I'm want to stop it there because he's said enough and this is where he is incorrect he says what the problem is because we take things he's blaming the United States for that the American people but if you go actually go into the history book not the history book but you go into the history talk to people who've lived through revolutions and particularly communist revolutions you will find and I've seen this myself from sorry I've seen this myself from uh Greeks who are communists who become indoctrinated the whole point of indoctrination is to get people to stop thinking to accept the lines that they are told by their higher Ops in other words they the the the so-called freeth thinkers of the social left and I there's a lot of different progressives out there there's a lot of different type of people who call themselves Progressive there's progressives on the left there's progressives on the right there's progressives who are more centered there's center right center left uh this call alt right alt left uh there's a variety of different sort of called progressives that involve the Socialist movement and socialism again is not left or right it contains an entire Spectrum of of left and right and we just simply call we've we've got into the habit of calling socialists identifying the Socialists as being left and that's actually not historically correct but on on either side no matter what you see within socialism this is going to the history of history of the French Revolution look at Rob sperre what did he do he he's a demogra he was a demogra he got up there and he had this sort of a a driving of mass what they what what did they do after the French Revolution look at how many people the this so-called socialist movement look at how many people they killed look at The Guillotines how many how many how many people amaz think they didn't chop off the heads they didn't uh Guillotine just the adults who were the pro of of the nobility they went had and guo Guillotine children there wasn't any any sense of limitation as to what they were prepared to do and this you see the same thing in the Communist Revolutions in in the ma revolution in uh the r reolution for sh R they went after people who they thought were evil and you can read this in Doki and this is what I'm saying you need to go down and do a study on do don't just I'm not this why I don't like giving quotes giving quotes says oh I don't have to go do the study here this is the quote here this you know you have to sit down and study the material if you're not going to sit down and read you not going to sit down study then and more often than not you're going to be fooled because not everything you're hearing is true and not is there's also a sense of understanding that is missed if you don't go do the study and the things you have to look at do Do's work in its entirety not within simply taking a bit of his work out of context because is very easy you'll see how a lot of professors when they talk about oh we studied duski what they've done and look at these these sort of course because he's he's actually ingal to socialism to the history of socialism even though at the see on his in his earlier life he was a socialist but on his deathbed he wasn't a socialist there had been a transition from the Socialist that he was to actually the Christian that he died as I mean he died as a Christian he went back to the Christian the roots of the Russian Orthodox Church he went back to those Christian Roots the Russian or Orthodox Church is not in any way sh form in terms of the theology uh similar to Roman Catholicism matter fact the Roman Catholicism that most people understand as the Christian church is fundamentally opposite to what the Russian what the Russian Orthodox Church was it was completely different and so most people cannot say oh yeah he became a Christian you know cannot do that because if you don't understand what came before the papacy and that with the Russian church and this was in Kiev then you're not going to understand who do what what Doki became on his deathbed from from coming from socialism but I say you take a look at socialism you take a look at communism you take a look at the number of let's go into uh pole pot into uh to the kir Rouge right in Cambodia look at what they did he go back and H look at this this guy considered himself to be a Democrat he always said this is a democracy Hitler considered himself to be a Democrat he was he was there for democracy same thing with Stalin same thing with Len this was about democ this was about the people and the thing is in every situation what you have is people who state that this is just something personal that has nothing to do with politics but Li Li LeBron apparently hasn't gone back far enough in history hasn't done an in-depth enough study in history to fully bring this forward and I'm going to demonstrate this we kind of we say oh this is and he's talking about these are the Democrats because they are sore losing this is after the election but I'm saying this is not true because you can look at the behavior before the election this is from octo this is from October 29th uh October 2 uh yeah 29th 28th in that time frame there this is before the election and this is a black woman on the street protecting Donald Trump's uh uh Donald Trump's star she's got signs up about this this whole thing about illegal immigration says Obama has home for homes for illegal immigrants but where is my home and she's homeless now we can argue of why she's homeless but the fact of the matter is that while Obama and all these social left people are taking care care of uh of the so-called causes one of the causes it seems to sort of slip through the crowns homeless and but the thing is what happens here the Hillary supporters harass and beat up a homeless woman and you'll hear this oh wait wait you got broken [ __ ] vinyl keep it going come on don't touch that's what you got that's what you got that's crap you got got you about to get your ass that might be [ __ ] with you right now [ __ ] I got his back too speak sir she obviously has a little bit of mental difficulty she's in a complex situation she's living on the street all right guys we're all very upset about Trump and what he said and what he's talked about what he's done to the white boy fix [ __ ] that this lady does not help the situation just go vote on November 8th and there you go I'm going to be playing more of this and you go back and see we're going to start analyzing this this is prior to the election this is not after the ele this is before the election this is when we say they say oh Donald Trump is creating hate speech let's continue on with our analysis don't forget about this guy and maybe put a scar back go shewing ha all right now she's holding up side says go Trump that's all and also in in this guy View and this is this is this is the indoctrination of the left he feels it that she is speaking Hate Now iron like this this the guy who's the the the the the the voice saying she is a black guy she's a black woman she's homeless but yet the black guy feels Superior to her and this is the way the this is the way the indoctrination Works in socialism you create Persona they create the the the view that you're Superior that the that the people you are supposed to be helping them that they need to be grateful to because they don't know what they're doing this is something known as the bewildered her you're you're hurting the the uh unwitting animal into a better situation you you're protecting them you're taking care of them this is the nanny State this is the Big Brother State this is what we saw in George Orwell but you see what happens when the sense of superiority is challenged they feel threatened they're saying oh this is this is someone who's bad this is somebody's evil and this is actually what you see in duski particularly in the brothers uh in the brothers C karov you see that certain people particularly the homeless elderly people are seem seen to be evil these are people who are leeching off Society they bring no benefits to society and therefore need to be eliminated from society in other words eliminated completely for the betterment of society in other words in socialism everything goes towards the benefit of society it's not about the individuals it's not about the minority it's about Society itself so a person who is homeless who has particular mental problems needs to be getting rid of because she's detrimental to she's a defective she's detrimental to society itself so she needs to get be gotten rid of and this is why this person here who is educated he's he's probably gone to a college maybe a black college and there's a number of black people standing around her all these people here look to be they're they're welld they're not homeless by any stretch of the imagination so uh let's continue on with this not's so so it's okay for her to go rob somebody it's okay for her to go commit a crime because she's in a difficult situation and here comes the equation and this is the this is the equation of The Equalizer it's okay for her to go rob a bank it's okay for it kills th this is how this this is the thought me this is the psychology of a socialist the acquaint what the what the what the person is saying their thoughts with the actions of criminality of robbery of theft of murder this is what they consider here and and what you see is it's it's it the argument is a hyperbole is it's an extreme exaggeration of the situation in fact and he's hyping the situation what's he doing he's hyping the hyping the situation you'll see what happened as as this continues as this guy who's actually this is what you can call any any uh in this situation here he's a socialist agitator his job is to get the crowd riled up to get the car crowd to feel Justified for the attack they're about to to for the attack that they're going to do on this lady here give her her help don't want help don't want help you want to take your medicine you want to take your medicine you want to take your med take medicine she don't take medicine but you're what the [ __ ] you just said just now bro what you heard everybody heard what I said right everybody heard anyway problem is now this is there is a fat Mexican younger man that's m going this guy has a uh he was actually just in a shop because he's got a a commercial bag uh a Baseball Hall of Fame something like that some sort of sports League bag he come out of the sort of Hollywood store and he's on the start and now what he's doing he's he's big he's heavy and what he's doing he's just running into it and using his body weight as a summa wrestler would do and he's knocking into the into the into the homeless woman knocking her down uh knocking her stuff over and here you can hear the crowd's reactions told didn't I tell you didn't I tell you I tell you don't touch her don't touch her don't touch her let her be don't touch her don't touch her she's now on the ground she's more or less knocked out she's probably if she has some mental health problem she's going through a probably a mental episode at this particular point in time and you hear them yelling at her and this is the whole crowd her card has been knocked over with all our possessions in it minutes ago walk by here and no I would not defend you because you skewed hate and you got hate you got exactly what you this is it there's the justification now I told you I warned you on that and no I would not def you because you skewed hate and you got hate you got exactly what you were dishing out I told you I warned you on that didn't I this is it and no there's no police here no one comes to her Aid no one comes to her defense and what's going to happen now you'll see as this the rest of the video plays out some people will try to be nice and start to help her but the guy who does the agitating pulls them back into line again she ain't hurt she going lay there I told you she wasn't crazy she know she she going lay there like she hurtd Hey where's Donald at Donald hey where Donald at Donald where Trump at guess what he still a here I told you I told you that [ __ ] was going to happen I told you and you looked at me you asked me as a black man would I defend you I told you no I told you no to keep her this is Hollywood acting you guys C the to put your lips on the crack F this is Hollywood acting right here you guys you know what the paramedics may have been here if they weren't oh Mexican exactly I'm going to get this SnapChat of you cuz you're looking pretty sad do you need some water I'm telling you they're going to be Latin isn't Donald Trump supposed to help you where proba breaking some [ __ ] right you want me toe him the local de with so that's that's the video you can find it on the internet here anywhere I'll probably I'll put link to one of the videos videos and thing is they feel justified in this and you hear them laughing and these are Hillary supporters these are the hill Bots and as you heard that one person you know do you need a glass they drowned her out they and at some point in time she came back in laughing at again in other words they make sure that there is no Humanity they make sure that they feel justified in what they do this isn't about personal TX this is indoctrination this is how the militant left this is how the indoctrinated behave in the Socialist system we saw this in Venezuela we see this if you go to any social you'll see this and this brings us to you know oh well only if Dr Jill Stein was there only you know you know she's different oh Bernie Sanders is different well they're not different they're exactly the same same I promote inform and change we deal with issues but other networks won't now to continue on with our analysis there's two different tracks we can go in and I do need to bring up both these tracks I'll do one as a sort of a digress and and then move on to the next one show the demonstrate the patterns how socialism operates and that socialists aren't going to get what they think they're going to get they're being used and what happens the more people wake up to this the more you know you see people start falling away from them this is what's happening with a lot of these sort of Hillary supporters is that a lot of these people are beginning to start seeing what's happening uh if they're paying attention to it and this sort of brings us into the whole thing with with uh uh KY of sharts who and these people who think they're apolitical and think they're bring being balanced don't realize what's actually happening up there and their apolitical stance is actually supporting Hillary and the viciousness that is going on in the hillbo in the Socialist community and this is Jill Stein here and I said let's go back to the the tangent a little bit here we heard from this uh we heard from Kiki green Kiki green is a black woman there's another one out there who uh who for some reason another doesn't like Kiki green and his name is I think Tommy Soder Sor uh and he also supported Trump so what happens here you have a black homeless woman you have a uh a black woman uh she's not if you want call a bougie an educated black woman she seems to be stuck in in in a particular situation but she has her opinions and the same thing with this guy named Tommy s sotoor he's a black guy he's talking about his support for Trump and I think is what you're seeing here from lot of these support and this sort with the demographics here that representative of the demographics actually we talk about numbers right you talk about oh you have X number of people supporting this person X number of people y number of people supporting that candidate you know they talk about the percentage of blacks but the thing is it's more than just simply numbers or statistics there are people behind these numbers and these are the people behind the numbers you have a whole woman there you have a black woman you have a another black guy this is I found several of them who like this um all different opinions all different views they're not all on the same page with each other all supporting Donald Trump for their own particular reason this is anti-establishment the anti-establishment does not define Itself by any one particular definition same this is same way same way with uh uh Lebron uh LeBron um um you know lion LeBron that's Lionel Nation he is is in many ways a progressive but you can't classify him left or right because he seems to be in a variety of so he's more of an anti-establishment uh Progressive than he is any form of established uh established uh Progressive but the progressives who came over to Trump who started supporting Trump uh he uh Li liono LeBron uh AJ Goodman who came started coming into the uh into the sort of the Trump Camp again came coming in for the one particular reason there's no one reason why someone actually said I support Trump there wasn't any one particular reason each one had their own particular things that they say okay this is my candidate they made a particular choice they came from other places they came from other directions and said okay this is my choice here and they were attacked when they when they chose Donald Trump as their choice they were attacked by their friends who were on the left because this is what the uh socialist mindset does it turns people on to attack dogs well how can you do that because they they denigrate they they they make fun of they make the person feel as they're insignificant if they make this particular choice that oh and not go for the so-called established Choice the the reasonable choice and the thing is you so you see a wide demographic reping Donald Trump as opposed to this whole narrative oh it's only white people this is a white lash this is it's not a white lash if if this were a white lash you wouldn't see homeless black people you wouldn't see a black woman you wouldn't see several black guys supporting Donald Trump you they wouldn't be support this they wouldn't have that support so the whole concept of this whole white lash is completely false and this narrative was in New York Times it was in uh most of the mainstream media so you know New York Times oh journalist no no they not Jal New York Times is high level [ __ ] it it's the same level of [ __ ] the same type of [ __ ] that you have uh uh for the average person but it's done in a little fancier ways so that you can have it with tea and it's proper for society but nonetheless no matter how it's dressed up no matter how it's disguised no how well it looks or how well it's painted it's still [ __ ] and this is what uh lion LeBron has talking about there's a lot of [ __ ] in the media there's a lot of [ __ ] there's simply no other way to describe because this this is this is simply lying this is bull fa they know that they're lying they know these stories are created and they're created in such a way they are marketed to a particular crowd they're being this this stuff is being people are buying this stuff in other words I'm not talking buying in a figurative sense but in they liter they're buying New York Times they're buying these these high level magazines and they're eating this up as if it's trth why because oh I might I'm pay look at what I'm paying for the New York Times I'm a high level person I'm a smart I'm a li I'm a professor I'm a I'm University educator I have my degree I can't be stupid look this paper can't be stupid look at how much I'm paying this is a high level payer look at how well it's respected but yet that's exactly what's happening and you can hear how the line goes from the Hill Bots and this is where you'll see social indoctrination and you see that it first was with uh uh uh what's his name uh Bernie Sanders when he rolled over he did the exact same Jill Stein Jill Stein is now loost Jill Stein wasn't even seen or even talked about in the election even though she was there she wasn't seen she's now coming up in this postelection analysis and where she's now calling her on her supporters to uh cough up money so that they can uh do a recount hello Facebook friends hello Americans citizens of the planet hello revolutionaries it's Jill Stein former Green Party candidate for president coming to you from my home along with my cat Willie right here who I hope will be um willing to sit on the sidelines we'll we'll give it a try he's he's very anxious to participate and be part of our democracy like all of us are feeling right now in the aftermath of this very uh very tragic um consequence uh to the election an election which was from the get-go very uh shall we say toxic very corrupt and which attempted to force two terrible choices down our throats so I'm here tonight basically to say thank you so much to everyone who's so this is this is her statement after election night this is November 15th and she said talk talk about the election was a tragedy the election of Donald Trump was a tragedy this reflects exactly how the left feels and it's a and it's a it's a it's a Monumental statement because now she's saying okay let's do a revote she's so here two terrible terrible choice so she's not only saying bad for because Donald Trump but also bad because of Hillary right is says one of the things here says vote recount recount announced in Wisconsin Michigan and Pennsylvania in other words these are states that they're going to try to go go back the Democrats are going to try to go back and steal the election for Hillary who's doing this is being led by Jill Stein she has rolled over for Hillary here you say here you say oh bad choice oh both of them terrible terrible Donald Trump one Hillary was a bad choice too here now she's saying and the thing is they're going to try to steal the election what they're say oh there was some voting irregularity gee this is funny from the camp that that said that uh not only Jill Stein was pushed out of the out of the way and marginalized the point she was invisible that he that Bernie Sanders stated under fact and you can see see this on the internet that she rigged the elections for the primary so that she was elected in States even though she didn't show up to the states so she had almost no one at her rallies Bernie Sanders was filling stadiums and yet she won the state completely outright and she won it solely on the delegate on delegate votes and the thing is a large shot of the thing is when you look at that this was in California too there were massive accounts of voter fraud inside the DNC primary elections the same thing was supposed to happen you heard uh lion LeBron everyone's talking about the selection of uh 2012 because they were certain that Hillary Clinton was going to win and if you watched the election night voting there were problems and in all swing States but the problems has started swing we swinging towards Hillary Clinton it was was until athel's problems were were sort of kind of cleaned up and things swung back towards uh uh uh ended up swinging back towards uh uh Donald Trump this is why it took to 2:30 in the morning to really 2:30 2:30 3:00 in the morning why they didn't call it earlier because they were having problems but what happen is that enough people were on the ball enough people CAU things that the the fix couldn't go in they couldn't magically make ballots appear that they that didn't exist and this was the result but now they want to go back and do a re recount where are they going to go back to they're going back to some of the Swing States they're not going back to all the swing States the swing states that that Hillary Clinton has won on a th margin they're not going to do that they're to go back to the States they're going back Wisconsin Michigan and Pennsylvania these are the states they're contesting because this is where Donald Trump won they're gonna try to get back the Midwest of this sort called the Rust Belt and I think is I don't know if it's going to be successful or not they've tried everything else they've tried a lot of and now we're going to have we're going to be in suspense now for another two weeks because they're doing this and H is is this this uh this uh Dr Joel Stein from the left everyone even Jess VOR says oh sh he respects her really she just roll R over she rolled over for the establishment Jessie VOR is always talking oh he's anti-establishment he's anti-establishment anti-establishment you go look on his channel use his stuff because I don't use his stuff at all anymore I looked at his stuff before but everything's copywritten he's not anti-establishment he's establishment if he were anti-establishment he would be using the creative common stuff he's not really anti this like I said but for a lot of these people they're not really anti-establishment they they call themselves anti-establishment but if you look at the the sort of the their use of the copyright law their establishment and so they're now they're talking about also this going on in the background here no one's really paying attention to this this whole thing called pizzagate and it's about the pedophilia ring and more and more stuff is coming out about the pedophilia ring and all this and then they're saying all this is restricted to Hillary Clinton this is restricted to Bill Clinton this is sort of the end of the Clinton ER type of thing go back into the history of the Soviet Union what do you see when the collapse of the Soviet Union you see child prostitution you go back into the Chinese Revolution in in terms of of the ma Revolution ma had a pension for 13-year-old girls he this is the type of girl that he liked and girls 12 13y olds were shipped up to him they were given the honor of being with the leader the the exalted leader of ma because all the leader ma pedophilia had has a history within socialism and and is not just simply with the the actual practitioner of of social it's actually embedded within the philosophies the engineering the social engineering of of socialism pulls from the tribal societies it goes into the tribal Society it looks at some of these some of these unbelievably Twisted views on sexuality and says that these are the society values that we want to bring forward and so it there's a history there there's history to that it's not just Hillary Clinton you can see this in Sweden you can see this in new in the Netherlands you can see this uh in England with the left with with Jimmy savil uh from the BBC he was on the left a lot of the professors who say there's nothing wrong with with pedophilia that pedophilia is a natural state it's a sexual orientation a natural sexual orientation this is all coming from the left this is all coming from the psychologist this is all coming from social engineering this is not isolated to Hillary Clint this is a behavior Pizza gate is a behavior of the entire socialist Spectrum it's part of their base philosophy if there is no human being or we are simply the animal then we are a sexual animal and that in order to have kids to be properly heal to be sexually healthy they need to be educated in the sexuality that they're going that they're coming into in other words you're going to have a social society that is based on a sexually open Society in order to have kids to probably come into you need to properly sexualize them they need to be educated in this sexuality this is the social left message and it's done this through out the UN through and you can actually go into the history of the UN and see this you can see the problems with the UN the the Human Rights Commission the Human Rights Council whenever they go into these different uh villages they set up these human rights camps the these these humanitarian camps that deal with the refugees there were always this problem of rape there's always the problem of uh human trafficking uh this is done in Kosovo this is done in Africa this is what we see in Syria this is what we saw in Haiti it's it's it's FedEd throughout the UN this is socialism at its core and when someone like sh uh Carl Shay Carl comes up and says oh I'm a political and then all of a sudden because he's with Disney and Disney is in the Socialist Camp they are there to prepare children for the sexual World they are there to sexualize Children this is why Hollywood has the problem that it does with open sexuality within uh the within uh the Within in their Studios this is why there is no difference between Hollywood and what happened with Roman Catholic priests although you don't say anything about Hollywood because well they're Hollywood and Roman Catholic priests wow oh they're Christians so you got to go after them right the thing is sh Carl says oh and this he's not alone in this I'm not sort I'm not sort of pointing out she car just because he's the one who's doing it a lot of apolitical people like this they'll say what's wrong with because they don't look into the background they don't actually do the work they don't actually do the research they rely on the mainstream media to tell them what's true and what's not true so a lot of the stuff that's not in the mainstream media that's not being seen including that Obama's still going around rattling the warsaber trying to create a nuclear trying to create a nuclear war with Russia still trying to agitate within Ukraine even though if you look back into the history of Russia you'll see that Russia was the Russia was founded by a prince named Prince Vladimir of the tribe of of of a Viking Tribe Called Rose and where was the was Russia established it was established in Kiev the initial the birthplace of Russia was Kiev the ukrainians exist because of consistent German invasion into that region that's the only reason why Ukraine exists so the victims who were attacked repeatedly was twice by the French under under Napoleon and then twice by the Germans Russia was attacked and they went into that region Kiev into into uh what they now call Ukraine and these people who were there who were primarily Russian were attacked the churches were taken over the churches were burnt down and a Catholic institution was installed even though it looks like it's Orthodox it's Catholic and its Origins and its base and said you're no longer Russians you're now Europeans you're now Germans and this is still going on today this is what Obama's doing this is what and he's doing this without Hillary Clinton this is the esta the esta is trying to create a war with Russia but none of this pops up none of this none of this comes into in into uh Shake into the shet Tarts what does come into oh a girl got her her head scarf pulled off and in in uh a Muslim girl got her head head scarf pull pulled off in school people she's afraid now to come to school with her head scarf on oh ter uh Trump is so terrible for he shouldn't have said the things he said because this is what what it's causing no it's not causing that that Muslim girl has more to fear from her father and her brothers all you have to do to understand this going to the um uh into the newspapers of Indians see how on a daily basis Muslim women are murdered and killed in honor killings by their own fathers by their own Brothers by their own family because they did things that are improper that embarrassed the family that girl has any girl who is a Muslim girl has more to fear from her own family than she does from anyone else around her this is the nature of Islam Islam has a has a practice called muta if you look at the at the statues of the the the the books that that control their law they're a lot like the talmud they have open sexual relationships with babies that there's no problem with it it's within there they they rent their wives they sell they rent and sell their daughters into these things called temporary marriages this is called muta M the statutes of M is the is the statutes of temporary Mar marriage it could be for an hour it could be two 2 hours there's a is all controlled by the mosque the mosque runs a prostitution business if you have a business you want to go and do a business because you can't borrow or or or or or land so let's say you want to make a business deal and well you don't have enough money but there was something to cover that CU that you know the guy who who wants to sell you that thing but you don't have the money for it but he likes your daughter you you can rent him rent a daughter to her to him you could do that it's not a problem you just have to have the contract and the statutes lay this out the statutes of muta lay this out this is what the Muslim girls are facing I've met Muslim prostitutes talk to them because most of the guys and they were surprised that because most of the guys who are Muslims won't even talk to the prostitutes they don't there's no conversation they're viewed as pieces of meat they viewed as as uh uh entertainment as nothing significant none of them that I've met were in there doing their Duty entertaining the men none of them are sober none of them they cannot face what they're doing sober and I've heard it because I've got Neighbors in here who are who are Muslim and I've heard them uh because there are units here where they sell them out and sometimes the walls are a little thin and you can see every once in a while uh out the units where the girls are kept or or they're routed to their different places crying during the day when they're sober crying about how they feel where they felt what happened to the night night before and you can actually see in their body language as they leave they're not happy if they've had a particularly you know a lot of the time is they'll hire one prostitute it'll be a group of friends will get hire a prostitute and there'll be five six seven guys there and this prostitute prostitute has to service all those guys to their satisfaction and this is all done legally from the mosque there is a there is an Imam there is a cleric who oversees this who writes out the contracts this is the religion of Islam because you this goes all the way back to the history of in the Quran it shows and a lot of Muslims will talk about this particularly the older older people the older men how uh Muhammad had a wife who was six years old between there's a range of Ages they have six seven8 it doesn't matter how old that you know and the thing is the the the child didn't have a choice is the man and the father who make the choice on how the marriage is going to be done because it's arranged the girl had no say in this there's a difference if you you know let's saying for argument sake that you have an older guy who's a little bit childish likes a lot of the same cartoons you sit down you have you meet the girl that you like that she's young and you have a good time together in terms of just watching TV you stack up a con conversation about the show Girls some girls are articulate enough that you can have a conversation with them even at that age and you enjoy the company and a relationship evolves right this is hypothetical here this not specifically reality cuz this is really rarely does this actually meet reality but just in case I'm saying rarely because I don't I don't know of any situation where it would and that you develop a relationship if the relationship is organic and you move towards marriage and marriage does occur then you have that relationship there she's not simply pushed into the relation she's not a mail order thing she's not a she's not an object that you just went out and bought there's no contract it's not a cont rual relationship this is what Muslims girl Muslim girls have to have to uh endure this is the way they they see things and I think of course what happens is that these Muslim some of these Muslim particularly if they survive will end up getting married and why they get married to an older man who wants to have a child and her job is to take her care of the home the child and the man in other words they become Maids they become Servants of the man this is Islam and the thing is but no one looks at this Shay Carl doesn't look at this the people who are a oh don't doesn't matter they don't see how Hillary is involved in along with a lot of our socialist friends involved in a lot of the stuff that's really not good that hurts a lot of people you know that the that creates a lot of misery in this world this is all ignored and the thing is oh is Jill Jill Stein's not like this Ben uh Bernie Sanders is not like this yes they are this is why they rolled over they're exactly the same this is the history of soci every leader who's come along for the Socialist history pull pot Stalin Hitler was a socialist he was a progressive he wasn't a communist but he was a progressive Stalin was a progressive but he was a communist he was on the left Hitler was a progressive but he was on the right POA for the cir Rouge was on the left POA sort of didn't give us the death camps the way he had with uh what you had with Hitler but he had Killing Fields and literally Fields rice fields IES filled with bleach bones people were shocked when they initially saw that but of course that's history and it's gone now and no one much remember or cares about history particularly in the news media because if they did care about this if they did go into the history you'll see that this is what Hillary is doing is not out of line with history it's well within history anyways I think I'm going to leave this here for now uh I I will see you in the next segment of uh Inn's uh tweet line plus all right take it easy I promote inform and change we deal with issues but other networks w't welcome welcome to the library I am the library I am the professor and professor of what professor of physics oh say can you see by Free Speech rules here at Democratic Earth | iNews.Network | UCQyC1BlUz5toXWLpqfMjIGg | 2016-11-27 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 7,830 | 41,187 |
QyeWcgNjSZo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QyeWcgNjSZo | Ep.510- Wilma's New Personal Best Wiper | all right [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] guys we have been waiting for this for a whole year it's right at the perfect level when this is seven to nine feet when the Mississippi River is seven to nine feet is when these fish can still come in and out of here and that water is coming out of this damn behind me here it's one of them kind of dams like that this thing is just loaded with hybrid stripers in the Asian car white bass flatheads this is going to be a fun day guys we're here right when the sun came up um because every day right now is 100 degrees so we wanted to come before it got hot there we go is that a gar surely not no it's a hybrid get the net get the net just in case I think it's just a big white bass actually it's a big one though no it's a hybrid yes it is it's a hybrid it's definitely a hybrid it's a small hybrid yes yes guys we got what we came for we got us a hybrid all right I need you to I'm gonna hold it with the lure I need you to fill me here a second that's a nice one I know we don't have nothing to keep it in except the cooler boy that water's warm we can throw it in the cooler it's going to mess up all the drinks though you can throw it in the corner and then nice hybrid guys I'm going to say he's about three pounds that may be a full striper it's awful slender and long I guess it's a hybrid by the pattern though nice fish okay should I go throw it in the cooler yeah don't put it back man okay if you got plastic put in a plastic it's not mix it up what I want you to film me a little longer not a bad first hybrid guys I'll take him he's a little slender and thinned out but oh God oh my God it broke my line oh No it didn't ah dang sure you got a good picture of me yeah God foreign yep awesome it's one of them real dark ones again oh man that's just a big white mess I think Maybe that's just a giant white bass look how dark it is though come on man God oh my God really every time I try to put my not bad for a white mask guys very dark brown color kind of beat up looking this water is hot yeah surprised they're this active the only other thing we can do is throw them way down there don't throw away you want to go far away okay let's let's good enough oh my God they just pack and pack that fish would have made my day right there I'm telling you got him please please please no it's not that big really damn is that a white bass or a five inch bait guys I can't believe yeah they're in the shoe box on the back seat there's two boxes there's regular I'd be so hard to get off all right nice white bass though I gotta admit he's 15. I did not think of white bass this size would hit a five inch swim bait guys but they will surprise you nice little white bass throw him in the cooler thank you guys I think that hybrid I just had before hooking this guy was at least seven or eight pounds had him halfway in and he got off for no reason really sad really sad to miss that one see they're way down there right where it goes into you just can't get close enough to the water to fish for him please please I think it's a hybrid this time you did the net get the net it's a hybrid it's a big one too way bigger no it's not it's a flat head that would work too hell yeah guys Flathead a little two pounder but I'm happy with a flag oh man that's pretty cool huh I got one of them last year remember when I was by myself on vacation I caught one it looked just like that exact same size and everything that is awesome man a little Flathead on a curly tail grub guys heck yeah man that's why I said you got to try worms every time because you never know what you'll get and that's what I meant he's about three pounds actually [Music] that is awesome man that is freaking cool heck yeah look at that not bad not bad little flat head man I'll take them not big enough to keep but [Music] definitely cool catch guys nice little flat head he's about two pounds quit curling man come on I want a good picture of you there you go that's my first Flathead of the Year actually yeah sure is first Flathead of the Year guys pretty sure on mcallen's tickle tail grub that's an awesome catch I can't get it hung oh crap oh no but I got to get mine over yours now I got one oh crap oh my God now that's freaking weird guys is that a hybrid oh my God you got something big probably oh man that's a nice hybrid guys he's another that's about three on a big crankbait guys holy smokes that's a nice fish wowzers he might be bigger than that first when he's definitely fatter that's a nice fish now that's a nice hybrid definitely a nice one guys that's what I came for heck yeah I will take him all day long nice Harbor he is about three or four pounds still got you got an Asian carp I would say not a bad fish guys or I'm gonna go hurry up and get him in the cooler so I can help her out carp oh I don't know where to go here that side of you no I just don't want to cross your line car I'm not even going to get the net yet I'll wait until it looks like you're gonna really get it oh crap I better not cast anymore no I can't cast I'm gonna mess you up hybrid wow be careful be careful bigger than any we got oh gosh she's got a hybrid guys oh my God careful just let him get tired let him get tired that's your personal best let him get tired just easy easy easy he'll wear out that's a seven or eight pounder Wilma keep tension on it though don't let off like that you get risk the hook getting out oh my God that's as big as the one on our wall holy cow that's like 10 pounds we gotta weigh this thing guys it's bigger than the one I got on the wall I think so oh my God on 10 pound line guys you can't imagine how nervous we are I don't even see your lure he swallowed that thing oh my God hold on just hold that net up like that I'm getting the scale first make sure we're recording okay we're recording that is a giant hybrid all right hold on all right let go seven pounds seven pounds 7.14 let me uh let's redo it just to make sure stop it seven pounds the one I got on the wall is eight yeah yeah 8.2 that's still he's got it that's about 23 24 inches let's measure that guy yeah it looks bigger than the one I got it's not low but still your personal best and we achieved something that's why we came here all right Dan I know you need to make straight that tail oh 24 and a half [Music] yours as long as mine then mine's 24 on the wall all right get him without getting the fish dirty now let me turn my camera off guys that is one hell of a hybrid striper oh my gosh wow that is a gigantic that's a gigantic hold it once straight up and down yeah but you like pull it up to about right here up to almost to your chin with uh one arm like your strong arm from the bottom of the lip just with one hand like this yeah oh my God I can't even get it all in the picture okay normal again just hold it normal one more we even want to make sure we get good pictures oh my God that is a beast that is a giant hybrid guys Wilma's personal best without a doubt okay uh hold it a little different on his mouth you're like covering part of his no definitely not like that what are you doing no don't hold it like that wow the fish this is what I was trying to say oh my God you're gonna kill that thing okay smile I didn't get anything oh guys I caught four fish to her one but she whipped me I wonder if that's the one I had that got off that could have been the one I lost and I was so sad about earlier I don't think it was that big but that is a giant do what you're doing but pull down a little bit pull his head down it's like it this fish is straight and his head points up foreign no like close close that guys that is one hell of a fish okay try to hold it straight up and down one time it's only one pound mine only weighs one more pound than that mine was just fatter because it's from Tennessee I think I think that is huge [Music] all right guys the fish of the day this might have been the one I lost earlier we didn't think they gotten this big in here I've caught a six let's see this caught a seven 7.2 the one I got hanging on my wall is 8.2 I'm getting it right now hold on just hold the fish like you're doing it's barely in there he's going to take up the whole cooler it's a big one I'm trying to wear him down is what I'm doing [Music] 33 . it's in the hook in the side yeah it is it's easily 20 pounds got it yes oh gosh you need to come fill me here in a minute big old big head guys big ugly thing easily 20 pounds hooked him in the side with a five inch grub let's get that lure out oh yeah I might want him foreign ERS actually can you get me the pliers oh this is a big hit big hit what bumblebee is it showing the whole fish yeah the whole you foreign what an ugly fish guys my God stop saying ugly one big ugly fish but it's big and it put up a hell of a fight it hurt my arms oh it is beautiful God's Great the fish all things what a giant oh it's beautiful do that that's what you're supposed to do don't throw him in no I gotta wash my hands before I do anything it is illegal to throw them back what do you not understand do you want me to show it to you on the internet it is illegal to throw them back you're supposed to throw them on the bank I don't know how many times I have to tell you the same thing over and over before it sinks in no one ever hesitate to do that you got to try the game yep oh my it's in the belly it's in the belly but right in the butthole guys Wilma likes catching fish in the butthole just easy okay that's easy no no no no no no no don't ever do that okay kid on the head on your head he's pretty big it's about 15. almost 20 maybe yeah all right head up the hill all right we just got a hybrid today guys a decent one and wheat's got an Asian carp ET yeah all right let's get the lure out of his butthole all the ways to catch a fish in the butt [Music] thank you yeah a little bit up on the head Bob the bumper box the front of the fish go up you had it yeah not bad guys he's pushing 20 pounds don't put him back in I know you want to just throw him on the rocks you're going to scare the other fish you're going to scare all the fish hybrid oh yeah four white bats I think it's a white bass yeah I think it's a white bus look at the scale yeah all right guys white bass number three three hybrids three white baths no four hybrids and three white bass not a bad one either I actually caught him doing something different I was jerking it like a fluke just letting it fall the bottom twitching it back up repeating the process and that's how I got him pretty cool not a bad white bass on the smaller side I think I'm gonna put him back not worth keeping this one foreign he's too small to be keeping yeah at the mail that's the one with a black spot that's definitely a male yeah understood I flipped over oh man oh there we go get that one first oh my God how did you not lose that fish jeez you don't need the gloves for them just put your thumb in its mouth and hand on his belly all right ah sucks I lost my damn crank mate I lost it yeah one's for wappapella but at least I caught a hybrid on it for I didn't got my money's worth out of it the biggest one I caught too all right guys second big head of the day this one's obviously a male because it's got the black freckles all over it again okay look at me yeah all right a little more okay that's enough okay good job [Music] oh my God is it I don't know man it might not be I think this Fair hooked itself though drum Fair hook what's up big old drum guys wow he's seven or eight pounds I told you I knew it wasn't a cart because it I could tell it it bit it it wasn't a snag wow guys the variety in this place is just outstanding there we go got it now she's on something over here guys I can't look yet but yeah my damn tail is gone my tail is gone all right real quick whoa what a fish holy geez that's a big drum he's 10 pounds easily 10 pounds showing up good [Music] what a monster drum guys he smashed that lure too bad it ain't a hybrid [Laughter] kind of a cool looking drum though look at its pin on the top it's like a bow fin almost I don't know if they were supposed to be like that I guess I thought they had a regular fin it's a bowfin drum hybrid guys no I'm just kidding okay oh my God that's a big fish you've got to be kidding me that's an old boy he might be 12. a big damn fish mine is big Flathead hell yeah Flathead number two guys man oh he swallowed it he's been on there forever and I thought it was a gar NS out it wasn't that that's pretty man I wish I had a pond to put him in keep them alive I wish I could keep it alive and put it put it in nail or something I like them when they're this little they look so cool really dark that's definitely a male man that is cool looking I almost have to cut a damn line though I don't think I can get it God it's just in there so far oh that's mine what are you doing don't cast it give that back to me just put it in my camera box guys that is a cool little Flathead that is one awesome fish that is one beautiful Flathead almost looks like a sauger on the design two flatheads in one day man [Music] but I still want you to film me though foreign about 10. I wish I could get a grass carp or something there's got to be one in here there's common car you think there'd be a buffalo sitting in here too that's why I keep trying and trying with worm for a bowfin or something just something anything different I got him hooked in the eyeball yeah I mean I'm sure he tried to bite it though come on about 15 pounds yeah you're good oh my God and then my lines are the same way it's got slime all over it you're gonna have to hold on a minute this is disgusting | Joshua McConkey Fishing | UC-Z7OY_CpOi9z21kpSZwfUw | 2023-02-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,888 | 13,730 |
gAeISUeo0U4 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAeISUeo0U4 | It's a Friday Once Again - A Music Serie, S2E17: Motif 6 (New) + Zlavid Ibrahimolynch | good morning it's September 30. 2022 and if you stand believe it it's a Friday once again good evening everyone I would like to wish a very very epic 40th birthday through Zlatan Ibrahimovic let's go you're in L.A a cloudy morning very still right now [Music] 66 degrees Fahrenheit around 19 Celsius today I was thinking about this song See Imagine by John Lennon from the Year 1971. this afternoon you'll be going up to 81 degrees Fahrenheit that's around 27 Celsius and these clouds should burn Away by mid-morning and after that we should be enjoying once again those beautiful blue skies and Golden Sunshine all along the way everyone have a great day good morning it's September 30th 2022 and if you care believe it [Music] once again [Music] here in L.A a cloudy morning very still right now 66 degrees Fahrenheit around 19 Celsius today I was thinking about the song imagine by John Legend from the Year 1971. this afternoon you'll be going up to 81 degrees Fahrenheit that's around 27 Celsius that means burn Away by mid-morning and after that we should enjoy ing more guys everyone have a great day | Nikolaj Stavrogin's Weather Report for David Lynch | UCD7qR8CzQzfkbNAzue3zkMg | 2022-10-01 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 197 | 1,107 |
xMnDrgufzhE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMnDrgufzhE | Chantal/Foodie Beauty TRIED to come for Charlie Gold and FAILED! | it's early Sunday morning and the tea is piping hot it's water it's actually water I'm now prop cleaning I'm not prop Queen all right y'all it's Sunday morning waking up looking fresh as a daisy and um I've encountered or I've stumbled upon a little bit of drama a little bit of tea as you would say and it's all coming from our very own Chantel floppy Bobby now if there are two constants on YouTube it's that Chantal likes to eat on camera and she likes to be an acyl on YouTube those are the two constants on YouTube those are two things that you can always count on when you open your YouTube page Chantal eating on camera and being an [ __ ] now she has decided to take it upon herself to be amber Lynn's Savior so amber Lynn's I don't even protect her I don't I don't know what I don't I really I really don't know what the goal is right now considering amberlynn doesn't really care that much about you Chantal and I know you're watching cuz you've already admitted that you watch all our videos they're all on your suggested speed and you're mad at youtube for suggesting it to you even though you'd like to watch it but Chantal really likes to show her ass on her community post so I thought hey why not go through it together shall we so without further ado here we go big beautiful meme this channel is ridiculous I agree Chantal your channel is ridiculous you are right on that this quote-unquote content creator I don't I love when Chantal likes to use quotation marks if she doesn't use them correctly Charlie goal does make content it's not a figure it's not a figure of speech it's not maybe she is actually creating content on her channel this content her basically reacts to every single thing emmalin does in every video she is an obese woman highly opinionated of other of another obese woman struggles she is an obese woman highly opinionated of another obese woman struggles that was a very hard sentence to read because the grammar is awful so from what I'm already gathering you're already mad at her because she is fat too and has an opinion on you so Shawn shall let me know what is the BMI range to be able to talk about the dumb [ __ ] you do on camera like I just let me know what do you want skinny people coming for you do you want slightly underweight people coming for you do you want it just obese people cut like I really want to know what is the criteria what is the BMI range for which you want people to come for you because I would think that you would rather hear it from another fat person who understands the struggle and is trying to be truthful with you but that doesn't seem to fly with you and I have a feeling that if some skinny [ __ ] got on here and really came for you you'd have a problem with that too but anyway let's keep going she reacted to my video as well saying I bring it on myself for talking about dingleberries and TMI exedra I love that being a prick you know what I just have to say I'm like Pat myself on the back a little bit I kind of love the fact that everyone is calling her the dingleberry queen like I feel like I kind of cleaned that a little bit but I love it I love it that's added into the vernacular of things with Chantelle like I have a feeling one day we'll get to a point where if you googled dingleberry a picture a picture of Chantelle will come up I think you are confused okay I don't care about what people think about my dingleberry is what I have a problem with is you profiting off of ambulant like thousand others when you are obese too and need to take a seat well if you watch Charlie Gold channel you would actually see that she's out here exercising working her ass off to get healthy I'd rather talk about TMI to be a hypocrite and base my channel off of someone else in today's video she thinks her followers for 60,000 subscribers brought honestly Bravo Charlie you're killing it right now and kudos you kudos to you you should be thinking every limb for those subs and views I actually think she's done that she's actually talked about the fact that she's not naive to the fact that a lot of people come to her channel because she talks about Evelyn we all admit that none of us are sitting here pretending like we she am Berlin isn't a catalyst for our channels doing well girl you've been trying to talk about amberlynn people just don't give a [ __ ] about what you have to say about her in fact when you did try to tear her apart in your one video no one cared then Eve everyone called you an [ __ ] for doing it just a few months ago your own content was getting a couple thousand views and the minute you started talking about Hamburg and Berlin your views went up your channel is one-of-a-kind so original girl your entire channel is literally based around copying the patterns off the amberlynn now you exploit your obesity then you are impulsive and you do videos of yeah I'm not trying more I get that but I'm gonna eat bibs I'm gonna eat mac and cheese and then you do videos of you doing hauls stupid clothing hauls tour about pier 1 import hauls of all the shitty [ __ ] you want a ward in your house and then you do videos of you being sad and lonely and it's like you literally are trying to copy the mold of amberlynn Reed and I don't know why you would be trying to copy that but that's on you grow fat girls should not have opinions on the journey and struggles of another fat girl when you are still obese yourself girl you've literally done that yourself you've literally come on here and done exact thing you are complaining about and why are you putting opinions in quotation marks there are there actually opinions you don't have to put them in quotation marks there are actually are opinions that Charlie Gold's opinions they're actually real that's what they're called opinions it's not it's not fictitious it's not me but she's not implying like a girl they're actually her opinions it's what she feels it's what she thinks about things just because you've lost a bit of weight doesn't mean your own struggle is finished of course I will get so much hate for this post but I really could care less it's couldn't care less if you say you could care less and that means you actually could actually care less than what you care right now it's couldn't care less I already get so much what is a bit more this is quote unquote my opinion girl this is your opinion I do try and tell is probably one of the dumbest people that I've encountered in my entire life and I've encountered some really dumb people Chantel you're never gonna be successful you're on your complaining about the fact that you're gonna have to have a hysterectomy and you're not doing any of the steps to help mitigate any of the damage that's gonna happen when you actually get that surgery you've talked incessantly about the fact that you are nervous about that surgery because you are so overweight you are so morbidly obese you've had 3 4 plus years since you've gotten that diagnosis about your ovarian cysts that you're gonna need half surgery and all you've done is put on weight you're miserable you have nothing going for you no one feels bad for you no one feels sorry for you no one cares and at the end of the day it bothers you to see someone with a beat face serving nothing but mug nothing but face she's out here doing the damn thing getting tons of subscribers getting tons of views people actually find her inspirational people actually find her aspirational and no one cares about what you're doing no one is concerned for you no one is really that bothered by what you have going on and your channel your views suck that's really what it all comes down to is you hate the fact that people are more successful than you you hate the fact that people are getting the views that you wish you could get because no one gives a [ __ ] about a fat girl eating a lot of food on camera anymore because amber Lynn's already taken the cake so I would suggest that you focus on your life focus on getting healthy focus on surviving your surgery and keep it pushing and not worry about what someone like Charlie Gold is doing or saying this it's funny too because when I did my first react to her she lost her damn mind she literally lost her mind and it was the same Charlie and I pretty much said the same thing she explains she talks about [ __ ] way too much on camera she's way too graphic about what she's talking about it's [ __ ] gross it's dehumanizing it's demoralizing it's everything that is grotesque and you would think that someone likes to talk about poop so much would just be okay with it and if you like fine okay people are gonna find me gross because I like to talk about [ __ ] most people don't like to talk about human waste like that but you really get off on it so focus on your life and get better dog because no one's gonna do it for you whatever I just wanted to talk to a little bit about that cuz it was crazy I'm gonna go watch Sunday football I know right such a jock remember to Like comment subscribe follow me on twitter and instagram at michael be petty and until next time toodles | MichaelBePetty | UCJqMW4eL4dIcGT8RFjVjJOA | 2019-09-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,727 | 9,216 |
Usiwph2dvCQ | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Usiwph2dvCQ | MEDAL OF COURAGE FOX | Fox one of the most globally recognized brands and extreme sports needed to renew the emotional connection with all of its customers in Guatemala to achieve that it was decided to tackle their love and hate dilemma their injuries yep any trace accidentes grace attend a otra nación el fuerte que me fer a chromosome a nose nose dos veces a tenement Raider Dave in t.o voice rotos yes a factor on momenta tenia the courage metal was created every extreme sport athlete has at least injured himself once that is why Fox decided to use their x-rays as media we arranged in various city hospitals that every time an athlete arrived and needed an x-ray they were given a metal with her injuries results a courage metal created by Fox these x-rays were valid for a discount at Fox stores during their recovery and also as approve of their courage as athletes each athlete injured was turned into a spokesperson for the campaign throughout digital media encouraging others not to be afraid of new challenges with only of two thousand dollar budget we may be injured have a better day and a happy recovery we also delivered about 200 x rays with the integrated metal internet impression surpassed 100,000 and we got fifty thousand dollars in free media box used a new channel to get to their main target at their best and worst moment at the same time you | wuisho Ortega | UCX2BUmFCkkjAYL5NDGaRQrg | 2015-06-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 241 | 1,347 |
No-kxjAMDys | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=No-kxjAMDys | YourRAGE BUYS His Best friend His Dream CAR | we got some your rage I bought my best friend his dream C I know what the car is I want to see the video though tell me why I'm scrolling on Twitter and then this dude bought his mans a damn Supra I said what bro I wish I had the bread to do that but I ain't Rich I'm broke anyway let me see how this you know how it happened you know what I'm saying oh my ey car dealership going to get my best friend dream car his favorite car never had like a new like new all his cars have been like us I'm trying to get some fair enough it was either that was a C7 every C7 had like a couple thousand miles on it yeah it's going to be fun 1 to 10 how nervous are you who's that recording bruh who the hell is that all right a eight like a eight I'll give it like a eight I don't know was going to react what he like not going to say that God damn bro okay okay [Music] okay yall can't open it let's see how we look at P sh okay it might be chaotic that don't sound like chaotic though he surely didn't notice wait what did I what didn't I notice you talking about me what didn't I noce [Music] huh no back seats whatsoever and that's what he loves can't even squeeze if you wanted to oh your signature hold on let me go back what you edited a video the car dealers [ __ ] hold on where's your signature Jordan the car dealership get my best friend all right the sound and the shake oh that's your signature I'm thinking like you gonna put the freaking um your name and stuff like that oh well damn Jordan okay got it like that how much you paid you for this you paid you for that all right okay okay okay now the car is nice though I ain't going to lie I do in every video I edit see how we P shifter okay yeah he about to go stupid in this car though this boy about to be zooming and that's what he loves can't even squeeze if you wanted to I think think V said he would get a super too what who's this bestie Jordan that's his name Li he going to be so happy look at them rims I'm pretty sure he'll say it wait so not only this dude got a super for his mans but then when I looked on IG he got a cyber truck too yo n that's insane yo that's insane bro he's going to die I agree the car got to have a nice butt for real though hi Tyler hi my name isana I'm in the car with my cousin Josh our cousin Jordan um he's scheduled to work today at 5:00 but today is his birthday and we just got him over car as a gift so we were wondering if maybe he can come an hour late this is his first birthday without his mom and we just want to make it like really really special yeah so is there any possible way he can come a little late or you guys we did it that's fine Jordan put the bully soundtrack I hear that I hear that boy I hear that go back why really special yeah so is there any possible way he can come a little late yeah so is there today at 5:00 but today is his birthday and we just got him a car as a gift so we were wondering if maybe he can come an hour late this is his first birthday without his mom and we just want to make it like really really special yeah so is there any possible way he can come a little late or you guys we you're the goat you're the goat oh my God bro yeah you know how to talk to people specifically men but we got specifically man back home hopefully he let me check his location oh he's still at the house okay he's still at the house good good good good we're 22 minutes away [ __ ] we'll update you guys when we get back to the house don't slam the door don't slam the door I think [ __ ] it's blurry fix the camera man come on Josh Josh please Josh please bro please I'm about to go to work yo I could why he choking the dog talking about whose car is this nah nah I'd be spazzing too my man's gifted me a freaking card that I wanted what I'd be GED Josh who is that who's is that ass get up I swear to God I'm about to call yo jery jery jery where is he is this your car he said no happy birthday who's car is this n that's so far bro oh my God look at the wheel you know how hard it was trying to get you to not go to work bro bro we we we l we were having a heart attack bro that's your car my boy what the what you talking about bro drive that mother very important docents very important documents for your new car no [ __ ] way first sit first sit no watch the pathes on the way out though look at him he driving nice do yo it sound like that my dog come here [ __ ] come here [ __ ] of course bro nah that's your man's for life at that point I ain't GNA lie that's your man's for life like now you got to die about that [ __ ] anybody messing with your man get ready to fight [ __ ] No Cap cuz bro nah that's insane bro [ __ ] course [ __ ] this your [ __ ] this you this you cry it's you I'm literally no like I'm I'm trying to like I need to relive that feeling on I had to document this has to be documented we called your job we literally called your job why what do you mean so you can go late yes bro cuz yo I'm like I called my manager I'm like yo what the [ __ ] do you mean come at 6 like I'm already ready I washed my clothes in the [ __ ] sink like let's do best lunar what would you do if I bought you a car well I like don't [ __ ] do that why would you do that [ __ ] [ __ ] I know you got bills to pay why would you do that come on bro don't buy me no car you know how hard it was for me to to choose between that c seven in this bro want that mod bad [ __ ] you're not wrong he doing the extra amounts of glaze when I said Jordan if you had to rank what car you want and you said Supra C7 I would have done if I came here and there was like a C7 gr for any last words before you start off this is real that's your car boy we're going to go around thex and then I'll be back holy [ __ ] that boy about to gas that I'm sorry I'm going some shit's gonna happen bro Josh this is actually insane wait Jordan how' you get the music that he playing in the car out the video and have their voices there I know they playing copyrighted music but like I don't hear nothing the freak why did you get me a car ho [ __ ] and you got it in red I not to rap it it's already in your R oh my God bro no no no no no I'm coming for you [ __ ] ass [ __ ] when I get my Turbo oh yeah you ging that God oh my God that [ __ ] sounds so sexy bro I was literally telling myself I'm like yo I'm going to Bro Josh thank no no thank you so much of course now that's fire I'm literally about to watch so much tutorials later on this [ __ ] and it doesn't even feel that SL what are [ __ ] talking about in the comments do you see that heads up displ like yes bro I was driving I driving back home with I'm like y as much as I want to drive this to work Josh I I can't yeah you can't you know you know what's so bad I was getting so tight you know I about to pull up to your J this sh bro I was about to get a new tag today for my car my it expires today I'm glad I didn't hey that's good thing he didn't then now that's fire what the all right now that's fire bro you know I'm saying show me the motor what he's trying to he's trying to dissect the car but like damn BR that is fire bro I want to be able to do something like that in the future like I wish I could just like have money just throw away on some [ __ ] and then have no effect to me that [ __ ] be fire I ain't going to lie all right | LunarDiary | UC8Ew9IkV2Y9Hln8MOZkRYMA | 2024-04-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,560 | 7,579 |
DG9oLULVEuw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DG9oLULVEuw | Routines to Reduce Tantrums and Manage Overwhelm An Interview with Marlene Spence | [Music] welcome to the momxiety club podcast i'm your host tori levine and i like to think that i can keep calm in a difficult situation based on my background working in a psych hospital but when i had kids i was constantly questioning if i was doing things right or how i was messing them up this time add in a child with a chronic illness and i found myself full of anxiety anxiety is a real thing for every new parent and when you add in a chronic illness food allergy or other challenging circumstances it can become downright isolating and that's why the anxiety club is here for you each week we'll discuss all things motherhood so join me and let's get rid of this mom's id together hello welcome back to the momxiety club podcast today you are going to hear an awesome interview that i had with marlene spence she is a mom wife and child behavior specialist parenting coach and founder of cornerstone family services and the creator of rewardum a reusable routine chart for families and it's really cool before you hear the interview make sure you stay tuned to the end to hear about my new sneeze proof your pelvic floor course that is now out so that you don't have to worry about the anxiety of having little accidents when lifting or dancing or jumping with your little one and please make sure that you are subscribed to them anxiety club podcast as well as our email list you can join that at join.momzai and you'll also get a free download of top ways to reduce your mom's id okay i love marlene's mission which is to shift parents and educators from feeling frustrated and hopeless to feeling relieved and hopeful so without further ado here is marlene spence hello marlene thank you so much for joining me today on the momxiety club podcast i am excited to talk all about ways we can handle tantrums and give up on the overwhelming guilt uh associated with that so would you please tell listeners a little bit about yourself yes absolutely so um i am a mom of two my kids are now 9 and 12. uh i'm from toronto canada and i am a positive parenting coach and behavior child child behavior expert so really what that means is uh i'm the one that when parents are just feeling at their what's end and just completely just overwhelmed with their child's behavior um they just feel like they're in this cycle of you know unproductive yelling and threatening to take away things and nothing seems to be working i'm the one that those parents work with to come up with more positive parenting strategies and to help them really build their confidence in being able to tackle uh you know those really frustrating parenting moments um because unfortunately they don't go away so it's it's all about how do you manage them um and they can come out saying like yeah i totally rocked that situation so how did you well first off how did you get into this line of work and then i would love to hear about you know when you start with your children so sorry i gave you two questions at once but yeah okay so i have been in the field for 20 over 20 years now and i even as a kid i always just loved um knowing the why of things like why do you know why does that work i was the kid who would pull things apart to look inside and see how they work so i can put them back together um and then i started to um you know just hear about you know these problem children or these defiant children and i always just had a heart for them i always just had a passion and i always just believed that you know um no child is ever bad and so i've always just kind of thought like oh why like i wonder why they did that um and so that furthered my studies into human psychology and child behavior and again that's just where my passion has just completely bloomed um you know just working in day treatment centers and school settings and just really helping you know what society would say those toughest kids um and again just realizing once you once you really peel back a lot of those layers um you realize there's a soft little kid in there that just wants to be loved and so i've loved this journey of being able to help educators and help parents um be able to you know discover like what is what is their strengths and how can we use that to really help them be more successful and so i started my own business um three years ago and that was just a passion of again being a parent myself i knew like man this is hard this is hard and so how can i like even just help and support parents who are looking for some support and then i forgot to mention too i'm also the creator of reward on visual schedules so that's creating just again routines and structures and just really realizing how important it is um you know when we have routine and we have structure in our home it really can set the tone um and and help us to have better days so yes i started that that is so important and i was going to to ask you about that a little bit later so thank you for bringing that up um and i just really love how you were saying that you know connecting with the toughest of the tough it's just so coincidental yesterday i was doing something in a training with a bunch of counselors and we were talking about oppositional defiance disorder and i said oh you know when i worked in the hospital and i we had we you and i have similar backgrounds in working in schools and day centers and different things like that but i was like you know and when i was in the hospital those were the kids who i always asked to be assigned yes i don't know why it was just like i worked great with them so maybe it is that finding the why um what you're teaching me about myself at the same time thank you so you're here to tell us how do we manage tantrums so does this apply to as when they're two years old or is this for when they're older yes so this is at every stage you know there's definitely your our kids are going to transition and so this is useful for every stage so you know one all the way up um even i'm sure even some adults parents with adult children could probably have some of these strategies as well or like vice versa you can always use it at work too another yeah your spouse your partners like absolutely right because it's like at the end of the day we realized like a tantrum is our child saying they're communicating something and they're saying there's an unnet met need here uh there's something wrong i'm unhappy i'm frustrated about something right and so how they carry that out depending on where they are developmentally um looks differently but for our toddlers right there they don't have the the language yet and still you know that part of their brain that allows them to be able to think through and be able to pause when they're frustrated just isn't there and and doesn't fully develop until 26 so that you know they really go into uh easily go into that fight flight and fight mode very quickly and so that's sometimes when we see you know the tantrums and the crying and and all of that so you just mentioned it doesn't fully develop until 26 which i don't think lots of adults know because it's like okay you're 18 you're an adult you need to act like an adult well really you're not fully mentally able to handle everything and yet so i just like that little tidbit so tell us a little bit how do you handle or how would you tell somebody to handle when their child maybe is younger because we mostly deal with younger kids um the listeners here have younger kids so you know everybody knows those terrible twos the three major and then i've recently noticed i have a almost seven-year-old and there has been some like you know this little devilish street coming in so i know every you can carry things across ages and stages um but what is one of the key things you would tell someone with a younger child because the wording obviously is going to be a little different yes okay so i always say parenting is as good as your mindset so one of the things yeah so i mean it's it's so important that we don't look at it as you know our kids are crying um you may have heard this too right our kids aren't giving us a hard time they're having a hard time and so if we're able to remember that okay something's upset like they're not trying to manipulate you right they're not like these bad bratty like kids like they are communicating something so if we can take a step back when you know our kid is flaring in the middle of walmart but it's hard it is hard um but if we can take a step back and be like okay they're communicating something right and if you can ask yourself okay so why is this happening now um and really take a step back i think it really helps us in how we're able to handle it and i think if we also remember that um in order to help our child with their emotions we first need to be in charge of our own emotions yes really hard right um and so it's also remembering that if we want to de-escalate the situation then we've got to be able to come in with a calm soothing right even if i say it i'm like i can see parents like rolling their eyes i get it right because i get that because it's hard it is hard for you yeah especially i'm sorry especially when you're like 10 minutes into this where it's like up and down up and down up and down and you've tried every single thing that you can and you're just like what else am i gonna do what else do i do yeah and so i always encourage parents to just take a moment and pause for yourself because and and like do what you need to do i have parents that i like we have mantras that you know we put up uh to remind themselves because in that moment right we're just like i'm gonna absolutely lose it and yeah you're like i think i've tried everything like what else can you do and i think sometimes it's important that we can't be afraid of our kids crying um it's okay like let them cry i think we have to remember that okay so they've been crying for 10 minutes it's bothering me so i need to take some space because i can't be supportive right now um and it's okay if they're safe right they're in a safe environment they're not in any harm or danger or whatever then allow them to have those tears and have those feelings i think that's okay um as well so just remembering for parents themselves to be able to just take a step back before you try to you know go in there and and get them to stop it take a step back for yourself and take a moment to pause and ask yourself like what am i feeling here um i think that's really important to do that's that is really good do you recommend that you know the parent first at least try to do a connection and then step away or say why they're leaving because i'm just thinking because this is the anxiety club podcast you know there's always tons of wisdom and information well you know if you leave your kid crying they're going to think you're abandoning them or if you do this then it's going to cause xyz and yeah i don't remember this with my first but i definitely have been going through it in the past couple months where the two-year-old is just going and we've tried it all and i'm like okay i just need to leave because i think this is making it worse but yeah it took me a long time to get there because i was still stuck in my head well if i leave him yelling he's going to like think i'm abandoning him we're not going to have this bonding relationship yeah right and you know what and as you said like you had said so many times we have gone in so i do think the connection first is important i think we definitely need to initially make that connection and see how we can support and see how we can help um and you know let them know like hey i know this is really bad about this or i understand so definitely make that connection but yeah if after you know 10 minutes and you're still like oh are you okay it's gonna be okay you know you're okay and you feel like you're just kind of going out in this cycle and it's they're getting louder then you're right like at one point you're like okay this clearly is not helping and i think if we think of ad as adults um you know there's moments where we're just so overwhelmed and we do need some time and some space and i think if we also um realize you know what is happening in our brain um you know at that point so sometimes you know people call it like the lizard brain or the red brain um right where it's like we are unable to process so your child is not even you might be saying all these stuff and your child is not processing any of it right so you might as well just not say anything just be quiet and sometimes too sometimes it just means just standing there and not saying anything or just being beside them rubbing their shoulder as they cry um but yeah i think it's really important that the connection is there uh but i definitely think um you know with your toddlers uh especially with the older ones as well uh there does there's and so kids and you'll know some kids are different right and i think it's so important too that we begin to teach our kids too that it's okay to say i need some space right now because sometimes that's what they need right um and then being able to shift their just their attention to something else i find is really helpful as well so if you find that they're kind of in this loop where they're just like crying and then you know first it was i wanted the cookie and now it was oh but i wanted a doll and you're realizing it right whatever whatever they see like a void in space that's the only way you're safe exactly then being able to direct them to something is really important so being able to plan ahead of kind of what that is um is really important as well so maybe they have like a coloring center or something that they like to maybe you can direct them to you know you have color you have specific coloring sheets of their favorite character for these particular times and you can say hey you know you wanna you know color your favorite character and you know you can direct them and kind of defuse the situation like that right that is um that is a go-to in our house sometimes unless coloring has started it um now this kind of goes into how do you set up your day to reduce tantrums or for the older kids you know whining about something or talking back about something um i would guess your rewards come in with that which i i they're super cute and i definitely need to get some because i'm all about the schedule but i can't create it and i'm like okay let's write it down on this piece of paper okay let's write it down on that one yes they're definitely functional um but it is so important to create structure and routine because it really allows everyone it allows predictability and allows everybody to know what is happening for our day and so if we look at kind of what are some of the things that are causing a lot of these tantrums or you know it's usually a tradition like you they've been told that you know get off their ipad or they you know now you're they've been told to put on their shoes we're going you know shopping or something like that and it's like whoa like they didn't know that was even coming or maybe you had said it but they didn't remember right oh those transitions if only we could do one thing all day long if only and so our transitions are super super hard um and so even when it comes to transitions like again um having a schedule and having being able to plan kind of what's happening for the day really helps to be able to reduce a lot of that and so again when your child can see okay so after dinner we're going to the park then you're not going to have them asking you a million times are we going to the park now are we going to the park now when are we going to the park are we going to the park now is it time yet and they can go to their schedule now you're only saying well what is this what does our schedule say and you can direct them to the schedule and they can be like oh we're going to the park after dinner like yes after dinner um and then when you have like the listeners if you're watching on youtube i'm raising my hand because that just triggered something that is actually happening in our house it has been for a while but it is now my six-year-old can tell time and read time but still doesn't have a grasp of what time means and what it feels like so do you have a different way of structuring and saying well like we'll do all different different types of things we'll say like well dinner's at 5 p.m and we're going after that or we're going to the xyz at 11 a.m we have two hours so for two hours we have what you were just doing earlier it's it's 901 yeah i know did we yes exactly um yeah so for those that you know again and it's it's really important too that we remember even though your child might be older developmentally they still might not be able to grasp that um you know time concept as well um and so yeah i think using like past completion things so when and that's why to having it scheduled as like tasks so when this task is in then the other one is done um but also i love i'm a huge fan of the time timer um yes and we have used that fallen off the the wagon i need to go grab it again and start it start using it again yeah and i love that because then the kids can visually see so if you say it's going to be an hour um you know and they're about to like say are we going now and it's only been two minutes they can begin to see right the red kind of the laps and then they can see like oh okay so wow time goes by really slow right and so oh yeah no visually so i was just gonna say for listeners if you have no idea what that is i will link to it in the show notes because it's awesome and there are they're a great way to help with that because we have also used like the alexa because she's next to me as a timer or pre i would say like i'm setting a five minute timer when it goes off we're going to leave um and that was helpful but sometimes still if it's that long span of time and it's not visual uh those those timers are great you know that you solve the alarm but that visual is so helpful yeah yeah and so as you said uh bringing it down into like activities of you know okay so after lunch like there's three activities and then you know whatever it is um and that that really helps too but i love using my alexa as well it's so great now the kids even will set it and it's great too because then you can ask it right how much more time left and it will tell you how much time has elapsed so that's awesome too yes that is great for when they when they start doing that themselves um well so can you tell us a little bit more about your rewards and how how you started that how you developed it how you use it in your home yeah absolutely so i um i had the dream about uh you know over five years now and again it was really just realizing um in the school environment um you know i was always using visual and i would like that was one of the first things that i was always setting up because i realized like okay so the child's frustrated they don't know what's coming next it's like all kind of a blur or sometimes our kids were sometimes not on the same schedule as they were as you know the regular class so being able to set them up with visuals um and then again um you know i having my own kids i was like okay i need to be able to establish some visuals here and so i started looking out on the market and i realized like oh i was really happy with what i kind of saw out there um there weren't really a lot of um visuals out there with kids that look like mine uh there were a lot of visuals too that were all of them were magnetic and i kind of was like oh but i nothing really in my house is magnetic anymore um and i wanted it to be able to be at my child's eye level i wanted it to be able to stick where i wanted it to stick and most of them were like magnetic again that kind of go in your fridge and my problem was well my morning routine with the kids like i cannot have that on the fridge unless we're brushing our teeth in front of the fridge right [Laughter] yep so yeah then i was on this journey to kind of find something i realized there wasn't and so my husband is the one that really pushed me and was like well aren't you trying to create that on your own that's wonderful so yeah and so we launched three years ago and um again it i was it's very durable so it's restickable and it re-sticks on any hard surface and so like our morning routine that's kind of where we started at first that was one where i was like oh my goodness you guys are going to drive me nuts if i have to tell you to brush your teeth again so we started with our morning routine um and i stick them right on the bathroom mirror and i also created like stars that say i did it and so that's kind of like you know your check mark of things that you've done and accomplished um and so they would go through you know their tasks and at first i always encourage parents to get your kids involved in this process and so if you lay out okay so these are kind of the tasks that we need to do in the morning which one do you want to do first um and allowing them to schedule they'll definitely be more involved and wanting to you know participate in that and so that's really been able to help um be able to create like more better bedtime and morning time routines uh but it also has really helped with chores uh in our house and so i can like happily say my kids don't even like argue about like george anymore uh they argue sometimes with each other but it's it's now just a thing and so i've really been able to um set that up and so again it was like we have like a list of chores and they're just simple things like sweeping the floor uh wiping the table and so um you know someone has one of those a week and that's the responsibility and then they switch so of course it's fair right everything has to be fair apparently and so yeah and so we switched them up and so i'm actually talking now do i get a lot of questions about uh what age should you start in chores um and i actually just have a post about this today on my uh rewards about uh you know you can start as early as two and three and uh and at this stage like our kids love being our little helpers right and if we take a moment to sit back when they're playing to see if they have their little mini kitchens and whatever like this is why they have mini kitchens and they have the mini vacuums and the mini right like because our kids love to mimic us and they love to be able to do those things um so when your child is uh you know playing in their doll house or you know playing those things take a step back and see what they like are doing and then actually get them involved and your child's gonna be like when you're like hey do you want to help me you know you give them a sponge and you're like you want to help me wipe the table today you know they're going to absolutely love and enjoy that and so you want to keep it fun and you want to keep it joyful um you know rather than like you know a command of like you need to do this now let me know this is just a responsibility right this is just something we do um you know when you're done everyone's gonna put their cup you know in the sink so it's besides just those little things um of helping of being able to help your kids um be able to help out and so with the reward on schedules as well you can even uh you know have that for your two or three-year-olds and you know go through it together and it's not necessarily that they're gonna do it by themselves but you're saying like these are the things we do after dinner we put away our dishes in the sink or we load the dishwasher and right so that they have this idea or they know that this is what happens after dinner they see you do it put it on their schedules they know this is what some that they did okay so i'm gonna wash all the dishes all you have to do is gather the cups can you pass me all the cup right and so you can make it really simple and really fun yes and i i'm just like seeing the two-year-old and when my other one was two because i it's like so adorable when they're like two and three and they're doing like housework we had for our one he one of his own mops so we had a swiffer that like you could i took parts out of it so it was smaller and now for my second one he i have a norwex mop and then there's like a hand one that looks very much like it so the hand one is his and just randomly he's like yeah i need my mop i'm gonna do some cleaning thank you you go right ahead yes i love it what we can do to continue that with them and encourage it as they're younger so they continue it when they get older so now they're called rewardims do you reward with them yes okay so i'm so glad you asked that a lot of people were like why is it called reporters get a question so um i highly believe that is so important that we positively reinforce our kids when they have done something but not only when they've done something but for their efforts and so it is so important that we reward them we need to reward them um and again so even if and this is again it's not for perfect task right it's for wow you you helped me right or look at you like you were able to you know get the broom and they might not have done a really good job at all but that's okay right you're gonna reward them for just being able to you know acknowledge that or just for the effort and just for trying um and so yeah so i think it's really important that reward them especially when you're beginning a new task or a new routine and you want to encourage them to continue doing it and so they want to know like am i doing this right and so even if you have like four steps in the morning they need to complete and they've already only completed one well let's start with one and let's reward them and let's give them that positive reinforcement so that we can make it to two steps and then we can make it to three steps and make it all all the steps so yes it's really important that we uh reward them and and we positively reinforce their efforts and their behaviors do you recommend things that we that are used as rewards or is it verbal affection hugs high fives because i i i know a lot of times people forget like just high five or that verbal encouragement can mean a lot more than you know getting all the dollar bin things accumulated throughout your house yes exactly i actually strongly encourage our parents to yeah it doesn't like you don't need to be going to the dollar store and buying a trillion things not at all um i love that yeah just that high five just that oh my goodness i'm noticing you um being awesome um that hug that rub on the shoulder that like all of that uh you know you get extra five minutes of you know tv time today because i saw how hard you worked on that um so being able to even do that oh you get to pick the movie on friday uh so being able to reinforce them with all of those things it doesn't always have to be something that's tangible um and i also encourage um parents too to look into their child's love language as well so you know if they love quality time that they love you know words of affirmation and if they love gifts then maybe you are going to be you know giving gifts but even gifts doesn't need to be this expensive you know games or something right like a hundred dollars a game um so yes i really think that it's just so important that we find out what and our children are unique too right so what works for one or what's reinforcing for one isn't going to be for the other so it's really being able to look at you know what are some of the things that your child would really love to work towards um and how do you and getting them to be on board with that well um that just with the love languages brought me back to kind of what you had said in the beginning too with handling temper tantrums or overwhelm and stress in we all deal with things differently um and actually i was thinking of the love languages when you were saying that because yes when we're trying to parent our child the same way that we would want to be maybe they're not receiving it the same uh so looking into the love languages and seeing like your similarities and your differences i love how that works for handling tantrums as well as positive reinforcement so yes yes i love that concept as well really really helps and again when it goes back to looking back of like why is this happening now and then you can be like oh okay i haven't really spent any time with them today or you know probably because you know i actually haven't really deceived any connection or words of affirmation so that really helped that's us well i want to be very respectful of your time because you have been wonderful coming to talk with us today at the end of episodes i like to ask guests a question about anxiety and realistic self-care so would you share with us something that you've done to kind of handle your own anxiety and take some time for yourself today this week what have you done yes oh my goodness so you know what i feel like this pandemic has totally transformed me because i don't think i've ever been so mindful ever um but one of the things that i now do uh is i call it my hammock type so my kids know it's my hammock time when mommy's having her hammock time she's having her hammer time quiet um and so i go out in my backyard and i have a hammock in my backyard and i put my headphones on and sometimes i even like listen to the ocean or i'll listen to like a meditation or just some music um and just lay there in my hammock and so when i feel like i'm just becoming miserable miserable mommy when i feel like i'm becoming oh just overwhelmed um and very anxious and i need to just take a moment i now will try to go outside and i'll go in the hammock and i'll just lay down i'll listen to something um kind of shift my mind back um and to kind of restore myself and then i feel a little bit better to be able to like tackle the task again so i i've been doing that i actually try to start my morning like that and then usually around lunchtime or something like that i'm i'm usually there again i am very jealous because that sounds wonderful as soon as you said hammock i was like really you have a hammock outside no no matter where we have lived there hasn't been a good place to like hook one up to trees or like sit once that's always my goal when i see them i'm like where could we put one yeah so this is a standalone one so it's awesome i absolutely love it oh wonderful well would you please share where we can find you and follow you and find more information about what you do as well as reward ems yeah absolutely so you can find me and a lot of information about child behavior and my coaching services at marlenespence.com i'm also on uh instagram at cornerstone f is in family and f um and then there is rewardum as well which is uh r-e-w-a-r-e-u-m uh and that's rewardem.com and also uh reward them on instagram as well and both i love both of your instagram accounts when you were talking about the stuff a little earlier that's what i was glancing down at looking at the rewards and then seeing your some i'm not sure who but a cute little one sweeping oh your son it was your son yeah um so yes definitely go check marlene out there and i will link to all of those in the show notes as well um any final words i don't mean to put you on the spot and if not that's fine no this has been fantastic uh thank you so much for having me uh this is great it's been such an awesome conversation yes it was wonderful chatting with you thank you so much i hope you at home in your car wherever you are had as much fun listening to that as i did chatting with marlene and learning all of the amazing things she had to tell us about managing tantrums and overwhelm and routines definitely you're gonna wanna go follow her she has two accounts on instagram cornerstone fs and rewardums and they are both great uh accounts they're fun to watch she has great tips on them those links are in the show notes as well as a link to the time timer which is a great little thing to have around the house we have we have two in our house one for upstairs for getting ready and one for downstairs for sitting like at the kitchen table or around so that the kids know this is how much time you have left to get ready to finish breakfast um or to clean up and another way that you can get access to the show notes is at the moment club website or in your inbox when you subscribe to the momxiety club newsletter you just have to head to join.momxietyclub.com and you'll sign up there and when you sign up you'll get access to free resources from the past present and future if you are already a newsletter subscriber you may have gotten some special news last week on another way that you can work with me there's always the option for in-person or online one-on-one as well as the online membership but now there's also a new 10 video course all under five minutes with tutorials that private clients generally pay me a minimum of two hundred fifty dollars to work one-on-one with me just to learn the exercises that are included in this course and this course is only 27 which is you are getting an incredible value and guess what the course is called sneeze proof your pelvic floor so i know it can be common to see things on social media that once you're a mom you and your toddler will both be peeing your pants but that does not need to happen you can regain strength in your core and pelvic floor in these 10 simple exercise video tutorials and these are things you can do practically anywhere with your little one being super little newborn all the way up till after your kids have their own kids no weights no exercises bands no nothing this is something that all clients of mine learn and we work on and they see improvement from but since not everybody was able to come see me in person or one-on-one online this course is now available for only 27 10 videos all under five minutes and you can do them practically anywhere there are enough things to have mom's id about we don't need to be worried about having a little accident while we're picking up our kids or jumping and dancing with them so head to join.momsidclub.com and find the info on sneeze proof your pelvic floor well mama thanks for joining me here today would you like to be featured on an upcoming episode or do you have a topic that you would like to hear about send me a message on social media at momxietyclub or email me hello at momxietyclub.com i love hearing from you the momseity club podcast is not intended to take place of medical advice or therapy if you are in crisis call your local emergency number or the national suicide prevention hotline at 1-800-270 top [Music] | Momxiety Club & Mommy Barre | UCzZP3X8sb69LyTqxjHwPNlg | 2021-10-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 6,907 | 34,957 |
FB04O3ZS9RI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FB04O3ZS9RI | AARNet Interview: Steven Tingay (Director Curtin Institute of Radio Astronomy) | i'm a radio astronomer which means that i design and build radio telescopes in amazing locations like the outback of western australia and i use them to explore the universe at the moment we're using them to look back in time to see the formation of the first stars and galaxies the mwa is a low-frequency radio telescope that we've built in partnership with 14 other institutions around the world it's located in the murchison region of western australia which is incredibly sparsely populated it's about 800 kilometers from pert and we need to be there to pick up the whisper faint signals from the universe but it presents a big challenge we need to get all of our data several gigabits per second from there down to perth to the supercomputing center so that's where rnet come in they've provisioned the link 800 kilometers from the murchison down to perth we have a dedicated 10 gigabit connection on that link the only way that we can execute a project like this is in partnership with arnet we have a great relationship with arnot and we have excellent communications between our teams and over the last decade annette have really put a lot of thought and a lot of assistance with the infrastructure into helping us without annette we would not be uncovering the secrets of the universe well the ska will be hundreds or thousands of times more challenging in the data flows than the mwa and rnet are involved in the design work for the ska at an international level so they're bringing the lessons that they've learned from the mwa and our other projects into the ska domain in order to make sure that the data transport for the ska is going to be done properly for me the most exciting thing is being able to build a telescope in the desert and then use it to look back in time 12 or 13 billion years to when the universe was a youngster and look for the very first time for the first stars and galaxies being formed in the universe you | AARNet | UCH5h8298NJylW4eoqgRaZCg | 2015-04-30 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 355 | 1,944 |
Pu344SGRF0Q | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pu344SGRF0Q | Astronomy of Other Cultures - Introduction | Robert Wagner: Greetings, and welcome to the Introduction to Astronomy. In this lecture, we are going to introduce a series that I'm going to be working on for the next couple of months on astronomy of other cultures. And we will discuss a little bit about what's going to be covered in this series. So what we're going to look at and talk about is that in general, astronomy is studied from a Western perspective, we talk about the Greek astronomers, and we jump into the Renaissance. And we sometimes talk about some of the early things like Stonehenge. But we don't always look in as much detail about some of the other cultures that have developed a significant astronomy as well. So that's what we're going to look at here, we're going to start looking at some of these other cultures. And in this series I am just selected for that doesn't mean that they're the only ones or necessarily the most important ones. But we are going to look at these four in a series of a couple of videos for each talking about the different contributions they've made to astronomy. And what I've selected to do are the Babylonians, we will talk about, and look at some of the very early history and some of the very early recordings that we have. And some things the way we developed our number system based on the Babylonians, we will look at the Egyptians and the pyramids and talk about those as to how they could be used for astronomical purposes, we will look at some of the early Chinese recordings and some of the material that has been studied there, and some of the very early discoveries that were made by Chinese astronomers long ago. And then finally, the fourth one we will look at our is the Mayan civilization, and their contributions to astronomy, including pyramids, as we see here, much like the large group, large Egyptian pyramids, that we also will talk about later. And we can see against how some of these cultures have tied everything tied in to astronomy, because of the way the sky had a very strong importance for the very early people who developed these types of structures. So this series will continue will start next week. And we will start off looking at the Babylonians and spend a couple of weeks going over a little bit of the basics of some of this Babylonian astronomy, and how that ties into our modern astronomy. So just to summarize here, what we look at, we talked about, again, astronomy, we often look at that from a Western perspective, and we want to look at a few of those other cultures. So we're going to look at these other cultures and their contributions to astronomy. And again, I've selected four cultures and it is not intended to be a complete study of all cultures. Perhaps in the future. I will expand this to other cultures as well that were not specifically included here. So that concludes this Introduction to Astronomy of other cultures. We'll be back again next time to start our studies in more detail here. So until then, have a great day everyone, and I will see you in class. | Introduction to Astronomy | UCLXFGlTeF86MsI1HqBcuqKQ | 2024-01-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 549 | 3,030 |
AszYJJBOKME | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AszYJJBOKME | Kristen Stewart before Twilight - Bootleg Collection #1 | after cleaning out my old bedroom i found my entire collection of bootleg dvds that i used to watch as a kid i'm gonna watch all of them and read them on litter box to find out which one is my favorite hello everybody the name's ari and welcome to my bootleg collection [Music] catch that kid is a 2004 heist movie starring kristen stewart corbin blue and max theriat this was actually my first time seeing kristen stewart and corbin blue in any movie before they went on to star in twilight and high school musical respectively this is a movie that i don't remember that well so this is basically going to be me watching it for the first time again you can tell it's a bootleg because the dvd is called new whoever made this didn't even bother labeling it i mean to be fair i wouldn't bother labeling it either alright this is 2004's catch that kid [Music] the movie begins with maddie trying to climb a building and nearly falling to her death while also trying not to get caught by her mom hello madeline what are you doing why homework over spring break you're not climbing are you cause you know i don't want you to be climbing i better no mom i'm not climbing gus breaks a go card that he was trying to fix and austin is filming the go-kart race at their local track gus's brother brad gives the gang some super subtle foreshadowing oh hey uh how have you heard but bad chad picked up a ship to your mama's bank i'll be working with lieutenant farrell security maddie's dad is a mountain climber and runs the family's go-kart track and maddie's mom has been busy trying to finish installing the security system at the bank she works for she tries to tell her boss mr brisbane that the security system isn't ready yet and oh do you hear that sound guys it's time to fill out your villain bingo cards inform you that due to the age of the building the primary shareholders will be here for the opening of the bank next friday night this is one of the most complex apartments don't tell me how to run my bank all right you work for me remember now when i turn around both of you will be gone ah come on i was supposed to get a bingo the movie then takes a really dark turn when maddie's dad becomes paralyzed after surviving a mountain climbing accident the doctor tells them that the surgery is going to cost 250 thousand dollars and what's with these shots the movie is trying to be serious and then there are these weird shop reverse shots the tv menu is dizzying enough can you keep the camera still for one second mr brisbane won't get them alone because he's a heartless bastard so they're out of luck and one for the bingo cards her dad's fine with it and he's happy that he's still alive and able to be with his family but maddie is still determined to help maddie then gets some exposition from her mom's laptop about the bank's security features and gets the worst idea ever come on we can't rob a bank why didn't they do a fundraiser her family owns the go-kart track the track is clearly very popular and everyone seems to like her dad they could have just ran a fundraiser put an ad in the paper for people to donate to her dad austin and gus even offer to sell some of their stuff to help her we'll go door to door everyone loves your dad they'll give us money i can sell my camera i have a coin collection they're rare it just seemed like so much work this will be much less complicated anyway the gang decides that it's the only way and they prep for the heist maddie visits the bang with her mom gus goes to get a floor plan for the bank and modifies the go-karts from the track stupid are you freaking us you can't get footballing broke me man and austin goes to a dog trainer to learn how to control the bank's guard dogs how is nobody suspicious of her she asks her mom to take her to the bank and she asks very specific questions can i see the safe can i see the news who has the code saw these when i ask my parents a bunch of questions they immediately think i'm up to something why else would you be asking so many questions gus gets a model of the bank from the architect after pretending that the burn from his arm is from his stepdad we then get some expedia product placement wait the kids have money to flee to copenhagen but not enough money to promote a fundraiser okay never mind never mind it's a kids movie logic is a myth i'm skipping through this next part of the movie because it's pointless onward to the heist and also my favorite character in the movie farrell is the best character in the movie lesson one chad never take your eyes off the enemy the gang breezes through the security since their go-karts are small enough and q suit up montage even though the party is meant for adults they breeze right through and nobody notices they then trigger an alarm to distract the guards and they make their way to the elevator and change why did they do a suit up montage for their party clothes and not their robber clothes they would have been way cooler even batman and robin had a suit up montage missed opportunity since maddie got exposition from her mom's laptop they pretty much breeze right through everything [Applause] [Music] and austin hacks the cameras in like two seconds great you guys i'm online um yes um uh it might be a bit difficult um i have to hack into his private company account it might take some time there we go maddie and gus move on to the safe and the movie turns into nea and jones for some [Music] reason use the safe deposit boxes and her dad's climbing equipment to make it up to the safe her gear gets stuck and she remembers how her dad climbed bound everest and she free climbs the rest of the way then she crosses over to the safe she accidentally triggers a safe security timer and she needs to figure out the code since her mom designed the safe they figured out that her mom must have chosen the code she is my name my name is the code it's weird how the movie is making this heartwarming she figured out the codes so she can rob it they forgot the safe needed an exit code so everyone realizes that the bank is being robbed brad teases feral and lets them get away and they make it to the hospital after losing the cops maddie's mom immediately figures out that they robbed the banks since they only stole 250 000 from safe that holds over 20 million then the movie pisses me off the mom tells everyone that it was all a test to check if the system was ready and to prove to everyone just how vulnerable the bank was i had my daughter and her two friends three kids robbed the bank and then everyone comes to the go-kart track the next day after seeing them on the news and gives a bunch of donations for maddie's dad because of course they would everyone loves her dad the whole bank robbery was completely pointless the movie ends with brisbane getting fired for trying to blame maddie's mom for the robbery the bank gives them the loan for the surgery her dad gets all better at the end the kids don't get any sort of punishment the gang went on and on throughout the movie about how they're going to be in so much trouble you understand what happens if we get caught right we go to jail forever like until my ipod my go-kart gonna have to take out the trash do the dishes massage grandma's old feet i wonder if we can finish the 8th grade in prison my mom's going to kill me they knew it was wrong did it anyway and then the adults were like oh you poor thing you did it for your daddy that's understandable have some money her dad even thanks her in the end what is this message were the filmmakers pissed at their banks so they made a movie about kids robbing a bank the movie could have been a heartwarming story about a girl and her friends raising money for her dad's surgery what was the point why is this movie exactly sorry about that i tried to think logically about a kid's movie let's move on to my rating catch that kid has the tropes of an early 2000s kid movie without any other charm there were bits of the movie that were enjoyable to watch but the movie's inconsistent tone really drags it down there were hints of a better movie with the kids being skilled at various things but they used their skills to commit crimes kids robbing a bank and then not getting any sort of punishment for it is a really troubling message for a kids movie it was nice to re-watch it and see how the young actors got their start before they moved on to bigger roles but that's pretty much the only reason to watch it there were a couple characters i enjoyed watching but it wasn't enough to save the movie catch that kid is a forgettable product of its time and it should stay forgotten two stars thanks for watching everyone if you enjoyed this video please give it a like it really does help out the channel also let me know in the comments if any of you guys have seen catch that kid i was wondering if anyone else has seen it or had it on dvd like me if you'd like to join me on my journey of watching all of my bootleg dvds make sure to subscribe so you know when i upload a new episode there will be new episodes every month until i watch all of them now let's add couchside kid to the stack [Music] they're on a mission to release the dogs right without permission my mom's gonna kill me | Ari Azure | UCHjjVA8Zax06Ul-f2BWdRtA | 2022-02-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,784 | 9,278 |
2HqZpx_CjmY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HqZpx_CjmY | 204 - Gravity Filtration | one of the standard techniques in synthetic chemistry is filtration which is separating solid materials from liquid materials you can do this several ways this video is going to talk about how to filter using gravity filtration is a separation process frequently you will have solids mixed with liquids as we do here and you want only one of the two pouring the mixture through a filter paper as we have here allows you to separate the liquids and the solids keeping the solid behind and the filtrate the liquid coming through one of the most common examples of this is making coffee hot water and ground up coffee are mixed and the liquid forms a hot drink that many of us consume daily the solid coffee grounds are not too wonderful though and so they are retained in a filter while the drinkable fluid comes through the filter and is available for consumption there are several methods of filtering gravity filtration which we're talking about today allows separation with only gravity pushing the liquid through the filter paper the paper is put into a funnel supported the slurry poured into the funnel and the separation takes place as the liquid passes through the paper itself filter papers are circular fold it in half and then in half again take this quarter circle and open it with three on one side and one on the other and you have a small cone and that fits into the funnel you'll need to have your funnel sitting above a receiving vessel I'm using a flask here you can use a beaker sometimes you may need to support this with a clamp but usually it'll just sit in the neck of the vessel take your mixture of solid and liquid and swirl it to suspend the solid in the liquid and pour be careful when you're pouring that you don't overtop the liquid as it goes through otherwise it'll just run down the outside of the filter paper and it won't be much use maybe that you need to work take a break and pour some more if you are too much capacity now you may notice I didn't get all of the solid in the first time and so what I need to do is do a second round on this and transfer it with liquid the best liquid to use is in fact this one right here the filtrate is already a saturated solution of my solid and so if I transfer it here I'm not going to lose any of the solid into solution as I would if I was using fresh water or fresh solvent that's pretty much stopped filtering now so I'll lift this up and just transfer the filtrate back into the beaker and swirl again and or again and with any luck we'll get more of the solid I got almost all of the solids at that time you can do this recycling of they'll filtrate as many times as you need to to get a decent separation of the solid and the liquid now in this case I'm actually interested in the solid sometimes you're only interested in the liquid in which case just passing it through once as long as there's no solid left is all you need to do once you have finished transferring the solid into the filter paper you may want to wash it this won't happen all the time but sometimes you do wish to wash it sometimes with water sometimes with a second solvent in that case once it has finished dripping off add a little bit of the second solvent and let that drip through as well once the wash has drained through you're ready to remove it now do be careful not to over wash with either the actual solvent or a new solvent because over washing nearly always leads to diminished product but with the washing is necessary to remove other materials then take the filter paper out of the funnel and spread it open and if you put this on a watch glass it will dry more quickly sometimes if you can spread the solid out you will also get a better drying time by increasing the surface area in conclusion filtration is a separation process designed to separate solids from liquids and sometimes to wash the solids while you're on the filter you should now understand how to filter solids on the back row scale equipment | Chris Ambidge | UC4rtlB-8VKsun9rb9Avgh7g | 2015-07-13 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 752 | 3,981 |
PsPpH_HIAZA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PsPpH_HIAZA | Live Video :Poison Ivy at the Madhouse | foreign [Music] what's up [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] he's driving [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] and then foreign [Music] foreign [Music] [Laughter] [Music] thank you laughs [Music] foreign [Music] do do do do do do [Laughter] [Music] foreign [Music] [Laughter] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] laughs foreign [Music] [Laughter] [Music] [Laughter] [Music] [Laughter] [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] thank you foreign [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] everybody [Music] River City thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you laughs [Music] [Applause] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you foreign [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] this is amazing [Music] thank you [Music] questions [Music] thank you foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] [Applause] [Music] thank you foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you foreign [Music] business [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] Brothers [Music] videos [Music] what's happening [Music] thank you [Music] thank you lifetime [Music] foreign [Music] students [Music] thank you [Music] how do you see here [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] laughs [Music] thank you foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] assistant [Music] thank you guys [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you foreign [Music] foreign [Music] Roblox [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] questions [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] six six six six six six six [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] thank you [Music] say hi [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] | VTE offiziell | UCWOO82u2OFAmMdj8mfLR_1A | 2023-04-10 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 323 | 2,162 |
LYuKR_Ndo4Q | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LYuKR_Ndo4Q | Cash Envelope Stuffing | March Paycheck | Giveaway winner! | [Music] hello guys welcome or welcome back to my channel if you are a returning subscriber I hope you guys had a wonderful weekend 1st of March I hope uh where you live the weather is getting better here it certainly is I'm actually seeing some trees blossoming so that's really really nice we have a celebration here for the 1st of March called M where women receive um gifts like small little broches or flowers and they are uh adorned with a red and white string to show good luck and to help bring good luck into the into the new spring basically I'm going to put up some pictures on the screen if you guys would like to see that and yeah I also have a new friend joining me in my video today let's see what's your name my dad got it for me he knows I love cats and I think he really cute so for today he's going to be in my video and he's going to silently judge what I do before we get started with the cash stuffing I want to talk about perfume of the week because I am so excited to talk about it and today's perfume is going to be hypnotic poison but the O peram not the ud tolet the a tolet has a lighter red bottle the O peram has a dark um maroon burgundy bottle I had both I actually had both and Poison Girl and the only ones that I kept are poison girl and this one I love the other tolet but I realized I don't love it enough to wear it and it actually makes me a little bit nauseous whereas this one doesn't and I know this one is popular but I've never smelled it on anyone which is why when I bought it I had the expectation that it would smell like the other toilet but just a little bit stronger and let me tell you it doesn't it smells nothing like the other toilet it has that licorice note which I know a lot of people don't like I don't like licorice but I don't like licorice in candy but in here I actually really really like it it smells dark it smells sexy I've read the reviews on for grantia as well and someone described this so well it smells exactly like what the evil queen in Snow White would wear and this is how I imagine it you know especially because it's an apple it's a dark red apple you know it's a poison just like what she gave to Snow White this is actually very very original nothing smells like it and you won't smell like anyone else when you wear this I do agree it may be a little bit strong for summer or for closed spaces so if you work in a very small office did this might be a little bit too much so don't overspray I think cage and Longevity are pretty good on me but not on skin after 5 hours on skin I can't smell it but on clothes I can so I have to spray on clothes as well but it just smells so good that I'm willing to just Overlook that and continue using it I've had this for 2 years almost and it's only recently that I got to wear it and I got to really love it because I had so many perfumes in my collection that I was just using the same ones over and over and over again but starting December starting in December I started decluttering my fragrances I gave a lot of them away I sold some of them and now I've narrowed it to a mediumsized collection where I can actually get to wear what I own and this is how I rediscovered my love for this one all right let's get into the cash stuffing today we're working with 1,131 so let me just set up the money real quick I don't have the right denominations so I'm hoping I can make it work because otherwise it's going to be um quite embarrassing okay first binder that we're starting with is our family spending binder groceries is not getting anything entertainment is getting 16 so we're doing a 10 a five and a one so entertainment now has 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 95 6 7 8 9 100 okay we're going to exchange this for a 100 bill just so I make some change okay that's perfect so entertainment now has 100 eating out is getting 200 and it's going to be one oops 100 and 200 so it now has 250 pets is getting 25 so 10 20 and a five pets now has 100 200 3 10 20 30 40 45 46 47 48 49 and 50 so 350 I'm going to switch this for 50 perfect yeah 350 household is getting [Music] 15 so 10 and 15 so household now has 50 60 70 80 90 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 so so that's 100 I'm going to take these out as well I have a feeling I'm going to need them later so now household has 100 next up is transportation and it's getting a 10 so it now has 50 100 150 160 Personal Care is getting a 10 as [Music] well it's very difficult for me to take out the cash from these envelopes but personal care now has 10 20 30 35 40 45 and 50 and yes we'll be condensing that miscellaneous is getting 150 and it has 33 in here for my genius subscription so I'm going to do actually I'm going to do 50 100 10 20 30 40 and 50 I do need small bills in this category so this one now has $183 three Jim is getting a five so I'm going to take a five and put a 10 and it now has 60 and Carr is getting a 10 as well so car now has 1,000 2 3 4 5,000 in the bank and 100 2 3 350 4 450 5 550 60 70 80 90 600 so 5,600 in car and these are empty I'm not using them right now so that'll be all for our family spending binder next up we're going into our holidays and activities binder I try to put a 100 in here each time I cash stuff but I divide the money however the priority goes so for this time around day night is going to get 10 and that's all it has coffee is going to get a 10 as well and now it has 10 20 30 40 and 50 so now it has 50 I'm going to put a 50 bill in here theater is going to get a five so it now has 50 60 70 80 85 and 90 wedding is going to get a five so I'm going to take this five out and do a 10 so it now has 30 Valentine's Day is going to get a five as well so now it has 10 10 Easter is getting 30 so I'm going to take this 20 out actually I'm going to do a 100 so Easter now has 100 I just switched the bills and just put a 100 Bill summer activities is G uh is getting 10 so now it has 50 60 70 80 81 2 3 4 and 5 85 Mother's Day and Father's Day is getting a five and that's all it has the Christmas fund is getting a 10 so now it has 10 20 30 40 50 60 61 2 3 four and five so that's 65 I'm going to switch this for a 50 so that is more condensed now oh no my ear is ringing I don't remember what it means I need to Google it and New Year's is also getting a 10 so now it has 50 60 70 75 that's it for our family no for our holidays and activities binder next up we're going to go into my husband's binder wait oh no I just slipped over my notebook okay so his Necessities is going to get 100 that's 50 and 100 his spending is also getting 100 so 50 and 100 so now it has 110 and close is getting a 60 it's going to be a 50 and a 10 so close now has 50 60 70 80 90 and 100 and that's it for his binder and the last binder is going to be mine the pink cat binder so let's see miscellaneous is getting 30 so 10 20 and 30 miscellaneous now has 10 20 30 40 45 6 7 8 9 and 50 food is getting a 20 so food now has 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 1 2 3 4 5 six 7 so 107 in food Nails is getting a 10 so nail nails now has 110 somebody chewed on the corner of this bill hair is getting is it getting anything yeah hair is getting a 10 and I just got my hair appointment on Friday I get blonde highlights so a 10 so it now has 50 60 70 80 85 6 7 8 9 9091 makeup is getting a [Music] 10 so now it has 20 beauty is getting a 10 as well so Beauty now has 10 20 25 26 27 and 28 clothing is getting a 10 as well so it now has 10 20 30 35 6 7 8 9 and 40 personal maintenance is getting 30 so 10 20 and 30 so it now has 100 200 10 20 30 40 and 50 250 tattoo is getting 14 40 oh I just dropped a bill so 100 and 40 10 20 30 and 40 so tattoo now has 150 250 350 450 550 600 is that right 620 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 4 700 10 20 733 let me count it again just to make sure I counted it right 10050 250 350 450 550 600 600 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 [Music] 90 700 710 20 25 730 1 2 and 3 this basically is almost €50 so this is is actually going to come out when I go to Spain because I'll be exchanging it and whatever I want to get another tattoo when I go to Spain so this will be coming out by the next video I hope and books is getting a 10 and I kept the small bills again for the last categories so books now has 5 10 20 30 35 6 7 8 9 40 41 this is weird Okay 41 in books giveaway is not getting anything I took the money out and put it in the bank so I can choose the giveaway winner so I'm going to insert a video of me choosing the giveaway winner hello guys so we're going to choose the winner of the giveaway now let's see okay seems my my math is not okay it worked okay perfect so the winner is Taking Care Blue if you are the winner please do reach out to me via my business uh Channel email in the description box so you can get your prize I want to thank you all for participating I want to thank you all that are new subscribers or that have found my channel recently it really does mean a lot to me and no worries we'll be doing more giveaways to come but yeah this is the giveaway winner dotera is getting 50 so this all should be 50 10 20 30 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 50 and again I put all of the small bills in here so the Tera now has oh how much okay so it has 100 in the bank 10 20 30 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 50 51 and 52 so 152 I already placed my order for this month that's why there's less in here I'm going to condense this whenever I need singles and yeah that would be it for this binder as well if it would close Okay so it doesn't want to close all right guys so that was today's video I want to thank you all if you stayed until the end if you did make sure to like comment and subscribe it really does mean a lot for my Channel I want to thank you all for sticking with me through my journey I've been on YouTube for more than a year now but I feel like I've grown YouTube is really a big part of my life right now | G for Grateful Budgets | UCF7B0ifj96-KFp47E87q4VA | 2024-03-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,183 | 9,870 |
mhDBIZcj3HU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhDBIZcj3HU | Pre Earth Life The Pearl of Great Price Lecture 08 by Hyrum Andrus | you can say something about pre-earth life and I want to get into that subject and we'll take the next hour to do that and I'll find lined that up there and the battery of course and get some of these other things that we need to say into the middle this afternoon the other day we indicated that that the program price doesn't say anything directly about the earliest stage of life the primal life that life that we call intelligence or light of truth it doesn't say anything about that directly it does infer it indirectly when you read Abraham's vision he says now I a brand so the intelligence that were organized before the world laws as we indicated the other day those in the word intelligences is a synonym for spirits organized spirits if the word intelligences is not directly a synonym for claim of life he goes on to say for example but I beheld with these that they were spirits so that the perfect price itself then directly doesn't say anything about primal life and you have to go to the document column section 93 you know they depict that one app and it has three basic statements and I've learned about one of them that I didn't know years ago on so I kind of like update some things in that sense but when thoughts about intelligences they were spirits and they were then overly great wonders now these intelligences were organized and this implies that there is something prior to the organization of spirits that's that's the inference I've seen the doctor new companies that you have the basic statement on that and I'd like to Train to section 93 if they got the new covenants and pick that one up by the way section 93 is one of if not the greatest revelation ended our intelligence particularly when it comes to disclosing basic principles concerning God and man's relationship to God there are several big revelations section 76 and section 132 in section 88 in Section 93 and I don't know it's kind of hard to say which is the greatest of them but section 93 is without peer it's it's that important it opens so many doors into a knowledge understanding is one that you should study enough so that so that you've almost memorized it so that you can in your mind say okay now how does this word Golden Ears it's that kind of importance and it's well worth your time to do that in verse 29 the Lord says for example man was in the beginning with God intelligence or the light of truth was not created neither indeed can be now as you as you studied the meaning of upturn in early elvis literature then i did years ago was to go through the LDS literature everything georgia smith sabbath there is in building on staff everything more some track said everything that anyone said who said that heard anyone say anything okay and I went through all that through the journals and through the discourses but simply the open mind of saying what does this mean and then find it what light I could get from the Lord on the subject and the end result was something like this you pick up the same statement for example in the similar College 7 verse 33 for man is spirit the elements are eternal now this just brief statement manage spirit it doesn't say man is a spirit it says man is spirit the Pinal stuff in you is spirit ok and then as you study this point out you find that what the Scriptures teach in the Prophet Jordan others dead that were living in a living universe every element of the universe has inherent within it inherent properties of life as limit inherent properties something to greater degrees another so that Lehi could say that some things are organized to act in same things only have the capability to be to be organized to be acted upon now those with the lesser inherent properties are those that pertain to the grocery store of substance but we would call gross matter the Lord can't start an organized organized life out of those matter because the properties of lines that are there that are needed them to bring that organization into being and to give it meaning and to sustain it there is not enough to hold it together but spirit as a purifying substance has within it inherent and acquired properties of life now service those matter can have at least better potential to it as inherent and acquired properties of life on a high level somewhere near to what the Pratt's used to say the capability of mind of man you're talking about a living universe they're talking in the doctor tell us about the earth being a lie it teaches the law of its existence you're really meaning for you what the ruptured in Moses says when the earth nauseated just regurgitate it in its feelings to the Lord in disgust how long does this truck go to go on is a and it's aware of it if you think you're out alone back to the shed if we think that keep in mind that the Lord might call the earth bear witness against you on the day of judgment can say and no one saw me have but how do you know knowing saw dancing how do you know you're living in the living universe now coming down to this point if you were to take a given particle of spirits is make a circle out of it and then put in that given particle of spirit and eggs to represent the inherent property of life and you call that inherent property intelligence and ascending in for that for that plus then that represents that inherent intelligence ascending in for that in is light of truth now in fact that is called intelligence implies that it has cognitive power and it does that it has the power of thought and of decision that it has the capability of choice we may be dealing with rudimentary levels but it's there and it's not there because something put it there it's there because it's in here it's as old as God and if it were not for the fact that we're living in the living universe there to be no God because that's where things start does you man alright so what is the primal eyes of man now it's it's it's this inherent property of life within a particular element of spirit now is the granite odd that there is a gradation of life even in that primal realm there are there are differences in relation to the inherent property and then as I've said there's also acquired well and I want to get to that a little later but let me let me put that into the fixture so that the element is alive and it's called in and so far as that that level of thing is that you can in impact that I say see use of life and so forth and this individualized is not just a blob or a blob this individual lines but be the one that finally becomes this mean that's my ego that's that's that is it it's my basic tour of life and of existence saying if you go back to a single and it goes back to that one and that's me now there's more to say on that than that but that's one feature to it see now another feature to it is that there is another kind of life that that time of life can acquire by reason of its agency and the Doctrine and Covenants section 93 talks about that and it is read after your things in relation to it we're talking now here about that as it applies to Christ as the only bee colony it says in verse 8 therefore in the beginning the word was and the V was the word even the messenger of salvation the light and the Redeemer of the world the spirit of truth and that's the turmoil and a centered army the spirit of truth who came into the world because the world was made by him and in him was the life of men and the light of men in the worlds were made by the men were made by him all things were made by him and through him and rpm and I John bear record that might be held his glory as the glory the only begotten of the Father full of the Spirit of the full of grace and truth even the Spirit of Truth but the Spirit of Truth then is another word for his glory there's another word for that power that's expressed through the word the Living Word the messenger the light the Redeemer the Spirit of Truth see it's that divine thing we call that that thing we call the divine nature and Jesus has that centered in him so he is the Spirit of Truth now over here it goes on and says in verse 26 and the Spirit of Truth is a god hi Jesus speaking and the Spirit of Truth and John Boel record to be sending he Jesus received the fullness of truth J even of all truth and then even the celebration extends this thing's rough and it says of no man receiveth a fullness unless he keepeth His commandments either keepeth His commandments receiveth truth and light until he is glorified in truth and knoweth all things how you don't get to be a god by party 1 PhD on top of another the way you get to be a dog is to learn the spirit of truth and to go through that formula you keep the commandments you meet the challenge of personal discipline you meet the challenge of true faith you meet the challenge of a broken heart and a contrite spirit you meet that challenge and you meet it honestly and you made us sincerely Zhiqiang and in that process then you not only struggle but you asked the Lord for help and you covenant with him that if he will help you you will straighten up and fly right and you ask him to reveal yourself to yourself so you can see yourself in all your treasures and colors and I mean that if you were to take a rag you go out into the barnyard of a dairy barn and solve it in the stuff that's back at the cows as they stand in their manger or out in the yard where they've trampled and as you hold that rag up before the Lord over like this to the side when you say Lord in your estimation with the sense of purity that you have which is more putrid to do that for me did you know what the answer would be you would say you now that's true I know that's true that's true now it's a different kinds of you tradition but you asked him to reveal yourself you get to the point where the people of impingement of God where they viewed themselves in their own carnal state even less than the dust of the earth unless demeaning and I'm not talking about demeaning yourself I'm not talking about heavens I'm talking about finally seeing ourselves in the light of God's truth you got to get down and see the problem and the fall works on us to that extension and then you've got a preparation to say haha if that's true then ball hey oh how great is the nothingness of man we look the woman proper courtesy and you come down into the pit the pivot is the broken heart in the contrite spirit in you say Lord is that really true and he says yes that's that's really true and you say wow that's dancing he said I know what do you think and it's not a good sailor hip smell and then you begin to say Lord that helped me change now you've seen reality so you now you've seen reality I only changed you see that but now when you do that and you pay that price then you begin to get the spirit of truth you in a sense then purchase yourself the Spirit has to act not just to fill you the first thing that I've done is to purge it it doesn't plan truth in on top of junk the way it operates is to start by cleansing and you better work with it in that sense you don't mix it up like the Mulligan impact Club them turns into clubs you don't do that first thing you do is kind of clean out the barn that's the first thing you do thing and hose it down get these clean so one thing you need to do then is ask the Lord to reveal yourself to yourself and persistent Authority teach funny tells you and then when you get down to realities down to the hard pan for the core to the hard rock of reality then you see that in this phony state we're nothing were less than the best of the years I don't care what you drive with what you live in or what the fuzzy we're do nothing without Christ and then you build from that point on I've seen you grow up the in Christ can you keep working out if you get to there and you keep a plaque or do you work if you struggle at it until you get to that point and you find a place where you can go on top with the Lord and you pray you walk out your community and your community honestly on the basis reality is if that's what you do and you keep the commandments and then you receive truth of light if you're glorified in truth and you can know all things the record of heaven should be that the truth of all things the light the gifts the power the revelation it could be there and you grow up in Christ it's an in Christ relationship it's not a free enterprise relationship it's an in Christ relationship now Harvey said all of that in this let me get back to the main opinion over here in verse 23 the Lord now is talking about man in the beginning and he says this ye were also in the beginning with the father that was your spirit even the Spirit of Truth now that's not talking about the same thing as verse 29 I used to kind of feel they are equated and they are related but they're not synonymous verse 29 is talking about intelligence or the light of truth the primal light again again this circle the circle represents a turtle element called spirit the plus in it represents the inherent property of life that's the intelligence or light of truth now you put an X in it you put an X in it and let that represent the acquired spirit of truth which that prime of life receive even before spirit very because it had targeted the power and all truth and the Lord makes that statement in verse 30 has a follow-up of verse 29 which means that it applies to verse 29 all truth is independent and that spirit which God is for you to drag for itself and not to be acted upon as all intelligence also otherwise there is no distance all right so that time of life which was independent not independent of God that some people try to say independent in the spirit which God placed it and all intelligence likewise roots being independent otherwise there can be no existence as one of the great trees of being of the ordinary cosmos if all those statements like the Lord said about the two Commandments love God love your neighbor and upon these two Commandments hang all the law of the prophets now here's one not only change all the law of the cosmic order and all the law of life is it to all truth there's got to be independent in this fearless godless place to drive for itself or not to be acted upon all intelligence otherwise there's no commandment and on this state that hangs the whole order to cosmos the whole of existence you see that that's so fundamental you're one of the great fundamental statements the revelation of God and so it's independent and that that primal intelligence is independent in that sphere independence means that the inherent right of choice it implies then cognitive power decision power action and what is it act on what does it look for it looks to God even then and it looks to begin to get his divine nature that that I nature's called the Spirit of Truth and I began to acquire the Spirit of Truth even in that stage and so the Lord says then in Section 93 we were also in the beginning with the father that which his spirit even the Spirit of Truth and then there is a semicolon there it doesn't end a sentence and he talks then about truths and clues the truth gets speaking of you now is the truth of the way of the spirit of truth it's not a scientific danger of Ascension you're talking about truth in abstract is talking about the truth the disturbances that the primal intelligence of man has acquired in the beginning that's what it's talking about already says and truth is knowledge of things as they are and as they were and as they are to come of the word to come then is a meaningful tournament to come doesn't mean everything in the future to come means that which is appointed for the future at a given time God's words are eternal one he's going to say something tomorrow that he hasn't yet said today these words truth and when you say something tomorrow that he hasn't said today that's in the wretched of heaven that's something now that's to time that's a creation of truth it's that which will be which is too common and that leads the fruit open-ended you see that that doesn't mean that the future unfolds according to everything that someone said billions of eternities ago things are moving onward and Godsman a knowledge then or chooses knowledge of things as they are the dog is ending through all things and in visualizing season they centered him and to Indian to him like Musa appearance in every particle of the earth knowledge these things I fear it has the word the total past then is in the wedge of the Keaveney and it's there is happiness and joy we can bring that up and read his mind and then everything has been ordained for the future everything has been ordained for the future everything that God built some agent who has power to act for him in his name as ordained for the future then that is what is to town and that's in the computer also the celestial record of heaven you see then and all of that that is that shows that you're talking about in relation to the Spirit of Truth which is now in the segment of it ending the application of it talking about the primal eyes of man and rollers begin to get even before spirit very now we said it presently enough so we can begin to see and understand what it's saying and he says whatsoever is more or less than this is the spirit how about wicked one now it's obviously abs of the are the abstract abstract terms of only truth is a spirit truth is the substance read section in for the word the Lord is truth now which is truth is life and that which is light is spirit even the spirit of Jesus Christ into the substance is that purifying substance we call the spirit installed the spirit of truth and even before Spirit birth even horse spirit bears the primal life of the individual and the Plus here in in the circle had the capacity to receive the spirit of truth and there's an interaction and in the relationship if you'll receive it between those kinds of primal intelligences that had the nature of mayo and those kinds that had the nature of female even at that point and in your relationship now that's a beautiful story that goes on to higher things that I hope someday the Lord will give us more information on at least others teach what we know but there's things there then that deal now with the nature of life see the primal nature of life in Section 93 is called intelligence or the light of truth now that is true of both men and of women isn't it doesn't make the distinction but it's lighter terms now it's in shines as darken concession aviators which to China it shines and truth and life is the rate use of truth and so your interests can be either in the substance of truths or ingredients of truth the substance is the executive staff the radiance is the nurturing the application stuff and I could have any me and there are those primal intelligences then I suspect that place primary emphasis and attention on the substance of truth and that's executive and that's male the characters and then there were those then who faced primary emphasis they still had the trench but they played finer emphasis on the line on the radiance and we have the face of me from the nurturing program by nature then they following the female cat glory it's the difference between the light of Christ which is really more feminine its origin and the power of the Holy Ghost one is executive the other is quickening in your anything when you begin to study that revelation and then now you see how important a lot of those things are saying I wanted to say that is that the elders the Spirit of Truth thing this business that this primal period of time was an era and there was agency and there was the basis for growth and development there was a basis for interrelationship in various way I think between male and female back there because you didn't have you didn't have like without servicing you can't breathe a half-truth without giving the light and then coming back and getting the radiance of truth in the benefits of it see and it's that kind of thing that that establishes the LDS I think view of man and a woman has been truly one flesh and the word flesh then mine are discrete of the physical stuff is the one substance they are one flesh and they're not created to be two people you can finally commit matrimony and join together giving each other it can and they're real created to be one they are created to be one and a man who is a true man of God enhances the life of his wife and makes her more beautiful and makes her moral more womanly and feel more the female dignity of what true woman should be if he is a true man and if she is a true woman three woman in the character of all the spiritual renewal figure of women's life and she is - in the sense then of the great destiny of life and open and not contracted but nevertheless basing your life on truth them on what it really ought to be and it's dead to these characters then actually gives herself to her husband having since Troost and then run it through the female spectrum and giving it back to him to enhance the glory of both of them then she becomes his glory and then they become one and they have the dignity of true union in Christ see now that's what marriage ought to be and it's not that then it's not really marriage is cohabitation of some kind day but the man as a man makes his wife more womanly and the woman as a woman makes her husband more manly and it's not just a matter of how do you go right so that everyone can be an executive is some corporation at how you females in the state Senate and all that kind of thing if you treat both them to be one now they were born them as spirits and the firstborn are give that spirit family for this eternity is that noble and dignified person we called you over and he came to spirit birds by met he changed the spirit birth by merit and he came to Spirit birth by the foreknowledge of the father that he being the firstborn would then move on to become the only begotten not just in the flesh but the only begotten the one who partakes of the divine nature and the one who has perfection in his life to the point where he can walked the path of rectitude and the virtue and of holiness without deviation and soul of our lyrics coming with him and says now if you will do this if you will do this then our relationship will be solid and I will be in you and you can be in me and I will Center my truth first in you and you will become the light of the life of all other of my spirit children but they don't have at the point of spirit very the qualities that you have some of them are main in various ways I'm not talking about the entry's it can mean some of them got a short legs or a short arm or something so that I'm going to infuse into them all the attributes that I can at spirit birth and that's that's part of spirit there's not merely to organize the central primal intelligence with other at the healthy elements of spirits to make the thing up here the mind eternal mind and then to organize the whole body now as as an organized body of spirit elements with the little finger that's got the parent and acquired properties so that the whole then can happen Union puts in by the spirit see that's that's that's the organization of spirit baracy spirit voice is not a tabernacling process spirit verse is an organizational process Abraham says I saw the intelligence that were organized spirit bears is taking that central primal equal intelligence organizing others with it to make the central organization of the system and then the physical and then the organs of the body of the spirit body on down to the where you have an organized spirit birth being this born and reach each element within that ordinary spirit has inherent and acquired properties of right but not in the same degree and they are placed under the direction of that central primal to them and he has got a kingdom now over which you can rule in righteousness you see that now that's an organizational process and then as you go through the first estate and you meet the challenges there and then you come into the second estate you already have a fully matured spirit with hands and legs and mouth and ears and eyes and all of those organs of the body and now it's a matter of adding upon you they should be added upon and so physical birth then is a tabernacling process you see that creating then the physical embryo then to be part of that organized spirit and then you go on in the birth the new verse then is not only a forgiveness of sins it's an endowment process that's endowing then you were further with the divine nature and you then you need to grow up in Christ and protected his righteousness and put away your own narrow righteous news and his righteousness consists of a spirit of Revelation the revelation of divine truth and virtue and holiness his righteousness consists of the gifts of the Holy Ghost his righteousness consists of the love of the Father given through Christ - that's a little different than going out during the smorgasbord thing and picking out I'll be in this truth in history been revealed I'm going to make all these things bases of my life you can a great personality and a free enterprise in the kingdom of God now you have to get in Christ he's got to get in you and you have got to protect of his righteousness and repent of your own righteousness and grow up in him you've got to do that now rebirth n is that endowment processing and that's the basis then all of the plan of life now Christ being the first born man enters into covenant with the father I will keep your Commandments right down the line and live a perfect flock before you and I will keep that relationship with you so that you are in me and I am in you then the father is now on that basis I want to have a bunch of other kids and I want those other children to get everything the justice networking and righteousness requires them to have so if you will keep that law perfectly before me so that I don't have to cast you out like oh you didn't have to cast at them out of the garden eating do you keep that law so that there's no separation that you can need and I Center my truth first in years so that you become my only-begotten and that's where the end the only-begotten see right over to that point the only one the protectors and sins after they experienced it then you take those truths that I give you and you disseminate them to the rest of my spirit children and do it equitably do it equitably and then you also take care of the demands of repentance in and if you'll do those two things if you give them my truth and if you'll take care of the demands of repentance in for then I will give them to you to be your children this is that and so the father gives us jay-bez to Christ as Jesus said lion and they were John 17 but thou gettest them and for me is he that that process then existed three right there and yet it stands on here into the physical for the women we wake up again out of the phone we stated they're born again we are born into Christ's family thing but if you study the scriptures clearly and plainly you'll find that existed before you'll find that it existed before watching all right so Christ's name becomes the first born and we began to get on our way and we began then to experience the relationships of for your life and you finally then get to the point where there's some maturity it doesn't mean that everyone comes up the same level a lot of people just sit around and watch celestial TV all their lives the celestial errors what did you have in common and they didn't apply themselves and there were those then who didn't really internalize the spirit a lot of times we say we didn't have to walk by face back there and that's a bunch of Bank is they be coming to the surgery we have to walk by faith when we do have to walk by faith there but you've been lived next door to Jesus there's many people in the land of Palestine dead and you can be as dead as a mackerel until you open your heart you don't even know who he is until you see him by the spirit of Revelation you can have him available and see him of ministry in the offices of the feared world you can do all of that and know that in external sense but until you get down to better the bedrock of failure where the spirit of Revelation that is there to tell you who he is our device the little son of the Living God as Peter said see until you do that then you don't know who he is and you have to live by faith in careers life you had to learn the processes of faith and there are those who learning those processes and became dreams of mobilization Abraham collagen great the Novo and Abraham need to taste like we said yesterday that they worked on they were those and who acquired the spirit and garden power in great degrees and then we're given the holy priesthood and the chains and the power to develop that in other people whom they became gods they became jobs in the sense of receiving the divine nature and then in being the source unit was given to others see and you had that kind of thing and then there were those who just lost around and playboys around and didn't do and yet had some kind of moral integrity and all of that and they were really way down the line see someone asked their questions here how about the third part and I don't dare answer all that but under be at least some of the basic ideas on that when it come there though which is a crime temperature getting elected in for mortality and we're thinking this now in the context of this eternity not in the context merely this earth Joe Smith says again here in the teachings as he talks about it the head god called together the Dobson saturnine Council to bring forth the world the grand counselor said that the head and yonder heaven is and contemplated that the trees and all the world's pearl which retrieved at that time see and so to stop his whole thing now in relation to the second estate then you called the priesthood leaders from the spirit worlds where these spirits had been transplanted and on which they lived as part of in fact said after we'd lived for while the immediate environment of the father we were transplanted on spirit world have been organized for ferocity and that's where the first estate took place you didn't tear up the father's furniture in the war in heaven the board hasn't took place on these various spirit world scene and as usual things in you then you politic Council as the prompt pejorative says said that we still don Pilar and the priesthood vendors the gods the gods these various spirit worlds met together in it in convocation and they get that meant together there in order to propose a pilot on the program to get us a physical body and to get us back to you to God's present of the physical organism now there have been those in the first stage who have not only been efficient in their development but have become Babylon in territory if you read the folk chapters look revelation inspired revision and it makes some interesting infants there let me just take a minute with you on those it is a vision given to John the Revelator of the war in heaven as a prototype for a pipe and a shadow of the warfare that will take place in the latter day evening for the redemption of Zion that air of warfare that means I saw beginning the first Nephi when the multitude see the Gentiles and come against the Saints to make war against God and this church's plans churches bombard and this warfare a good Zion has two major divisions who will get that in both a discussion of the second coming tonight the divisions that are there that the first onslaught is made against I am just like these I saw in first beam 514 predicting round verse and in verse 14 of routine by 14 he says I saw the power of God in great glory that arrested upon the church to the language job from the government in global oil see that square design begins to get sanctified and that's where scientists inch to rise to be an enzyme and to be a standard to the world say and Zion while she's bombarded and the warfare is made again stirs I am basically holds a lot of the saints melt away and they'll be thousands literally then neither fall away or go into apostasy and Isaiah talks about a tenth that finally get through the users of the differences attempts to attend to the tenth so there's only a small hint that you finally get through and do what they really ought to do this is the water again Zion but those who write the Colorado Rapids releasing bathtub have broken or and you know record and have faith in the Lord game and come through and get sanctified its endowments of the strip that's where you're planning to get back to Jackson County that's where you build Zion you know and then after Zion is built and after the Seventh Seal is opened a nasty 144,000 call which is done just before the only the seven single and after they'd either words of ministry which is the half hour of silence in heaven its computes the time on earth is about 21 years plus when they do their work and ignore people into the Church of the firstborn then Christ comes to his temple to put the capstone on so I actually made contingent pretty since I've any objection to the period where the Adam on dynamic counts was held but about that time in that area of time then the second phase of the warfare takes place from Lucifer's fashion his head and say well if I can't shut Zion off I'm gonna shut off Jerusalem and so he gathers all nations to Jerusalem there's a big battle that and the city perpetuated finally after three and a half years or so and is overrun and while they stopped to celebrate and rejoice and the head of their wine and their litter and all that things Jesus stands on the Mount of Olives that changes the battle for gain the Jews redeemed and the temple is rebuilt and the program that's been set up in Zion is established in Jerusalem improvement ability of God and the Jews are brought in and are given the blessings of the temple of a holy order the ceiling polish endowment of glory when that is done and that will only take a few months the Lord as that gets through then Christ makes his appearance in glory in power in the clouds of heaven and the righteous the Church of the firstborn shall encourage the Jews will be filed the resurrection the Ryan sister taking place before so there's warfare period and has two divisions to it it has the warfare against ayan and warfare against Jerusalem not lighter that we reduced by division with Revelation if you've got their Bible looking the back in the Jordan Smith section the entire division section under a hundred revelation chapters which are fourteen partners chapter 12 what am I thinking back president under losing the mortals he says in there appeared a great sign in heaven note this in the lightness of phase on the earth there's the key that's not anything changed in the likeness of things on the earth but the lightness the things on the ears of the world very good sign you look at to put the two campaigns is here that I knew that there was two campaigns in and I'm seeing on the thirty and then reach after twelve are the in seventy the likeness of things on the earth a woman clothed with the Sun and the moon under her feet and upon her head a crown of twelve stars and woman being with child cried travailing in birth and pained to be delivered and she brought forth a man child who was to rule all nations with a rod of iron and her child was caught up unto God and his throne and there appeared another sign in heaven behold a great red dragon having seven heads and ten horns and seven Crown's upon his head and his tail drew a third part of the stars of heaven an odor doesn't say a third it says a third part a third is a fraction a part is a division however large it may have been they drew a third part he said of similar state but in section 29 of the dolphin governs and again it's a third part we have read that so loosely that we think of one third people it doesn't say that it simply doesn't say that his tail drew a third part of the stars of heaven and did cast them to the earth and the dragon stood before the woman which was delivered ready to be devout to devour her child after it was born and it was hard to say the woman fled into the wilderness where she had a place prepared of God that they should feed her there a thousand two hundred and threescore years of the King James translation puts that base Joseph changed to two years a lot of people if I could say parenthetically I think this has to do with the Christian apostasy there could have to do with the Christian apostasy and the inspired revision is correct which it is then you would have to say the church the Christ established was in the wilderness for 1260 years before 1830 and that would put it back to 570 ad and that would mean that the Christian Church that Christ the Apostle established continued for five hundred and seventy years and that's several years after the Nicene council and the end conclusion on that is this doesn't pertain ad addition apostasy this is talking about the scene that took place in spirit life in the war in heaven that's what it's talking about now of that clarification let's move on alright says the woman fled into the wilderness where she had a place prepared of God that they should feed her there a thousand and threescore years and there was war in heaven Michael is angel spot against the devil and get that dragon and his angels fought against Michael and the dragon prevailed not against Michael neither the child nor the woman which was the Church of God the Church of God where are in this temple state the Church of God that was built up and existed in the first estate okay they're talking about that and the dragon prevailed mulligans might believe the child the the woman which was the Church of God who had been delivered of her pains and he brought forth the kingdom of God and His Christ and the tenor there is the political Kingdom the manchild is the government of God she dropped forth a man child who is to rule all nations what nations those in the spirit world in the first estate well that is very revealing it's a very vision statement it tells us about the Priester state of things that we as latter-day saints haven't picked up on yet now first of all there was a church established there they're not sitting like an immediate environs of the Father or you can have family home evening and have the gospel right there all along you have these going along for a while and finally people who begin to get a wage and in their faith and they begin them to teach the boss woman to build up the church and the devil doesn't like that it doesn't like that a bit and at church then is designed to bring faith and give birth to a political opinion Malfoy well John Kahler explains it and said said do this but this is that this opportunity is revelatory it's governed by the power of God and it's based upon the revelatory powers of the Spirit is based on people who have those things in their lives and then you invite the non-member to come in and enjoy the privilege on the basis of the Covenant of Liberty they make the governor of Liberty they can come but the basic structure then requires people who are knit together by the powers of the spirit and who know the processes of Revelation and this requires then the church to exist and retires the church then to give birth to the political Kingdom and that scenario begin to be developed and for those life and the devil didn't like that and he then comes out in each ward he's ready to devour that child to fill that political system to squelch it when it's born and his product to God it's born but it's caught up to God as he said he's ready to devour it and the woman fled into the wilderness she left that particular scene where she was the presence of wilderness where she had a place prepared of God to lead her there a thousand two hundred thousands for years Donald before we get there the further explanation on this he sees a second Steinem verse four there appeared another sign in heaven behold a great red dragon having seven heads and ten horns I was talking about two years life the waters heads and horns means you take that statement I mean look elsewhere in the book of Revelation you'll find that it describes Babylon on this earth it describes Babylon on this earth a horn is a symbol of power of political power order ahead Venice is maybe a part of a bigger system I think they Britain you've got some horns plus they have the whole system busy then and the board is here that a system of Babylon because this is the Saints the same expression the same descriptive statement applied now to the spirit world that John applies to Babylon on earth in the last days this is that and that tells us and good that not only did you have a battle them to over agency in for yours life that you had a battle to establish SIA and the forces then were actually a Bible and soulless they dissipated themselves in their first disdain and when you dissipate yourself you lose the spare of the Lord and you don't have the confidence in himself that you ought to have when you dissipate yourself you look for security and you look for a political program that will cover you from the wounds of the tomb and the evidence then of the lack of the spirit is the growth of a welfare state that's the evidence of it if you've got that barrel independence that comes from the land price new life Anna manhood of Christ you don't want to have to report to Washington do you want Washington to sustainability or rights and alleviate on the principles of justice and equity if there's any conflict between you and someone else and you want to have them take care of interstate and the inter statement relationships and take care of getting the highways and points and money and let you alone because you are living above the law you are living in an order to things of truth and dignity where you don't have to have your problems solved by some as the body in Washington and that's a commentary Excel on our day and that time didn't happened in crios life City and there were those then who when it came to this decision of coming the mortality who said to Satan Elizabeth your great personality to think like we think the by that time he was thinking like they thought prior to that then he was in a state then where he applied great light knowledge from the Lord he was called the son of the morning as the second born male spirit of this eternity and he was called then in the son of the more it orator he had power in power personality a power borders and learn to manipulate into control and just simple things on yourself and to build himself up so the word came down to the issue he says now I'll do it therefore your honor the father's honor and you give to me this is that I mean subverted the whole order of lysine but babbling existed there babbling existed when we fought the warfare into fierce state on the basis of finally destroying the power of the adversary and it goes on as it talks about that and it says the dragon prevailed audience Michael verse seven neither the child northern woman which was the Church of God who had been delivered of her pains and brought forth the kingdom of our God and His Christ neither was their place found in heaven for the great dragon who was cast out that old serpent called the devil and also called Satan which deceiveth the whole world he was cast out into the earth and his angels were cast out with him then John says in the state of glory in ecstasy he says and I heard a loud voice saying in heaven in the clear state now is come salvation and strength and the Kingdom of our God and the power of his Christ they healed Zion they established it they built the kingdom of God politically they established it they threw out Babylon and they established righteousness and the glory of God in the first estate then was made manifest in great power and great glory and greatly Jersey followed as he indicates here the accuser of the brethren is cast down which accused them before our God day and night unless the scene of the war in heaven see and that is also a type and shadow of what's got to happen again when you get to be application and that's the rest of the chapter we'll take time to read it don't have it in too but that thing that's that's good that's the snare and the rest of the chapter and as it applies to our if it's gonna be a warfare games I am and out of that work there's land will be boring Mount Zion will be born I've had warfare the power of God and great glory will begin to rest upon the scenes out of that grew out of in that era of turoff term or and truth the truth of God will be taught in great power and the kingdom of God will begin to be developed and those then who remain faithful he sees the higher blessings of the Holy priesthood than the ceiling powers and as a result of that they'll be found with with the boy guarding great power mm-hmm and the opposition that comes against them one of which is the latter-day Australian spoken are in second defy chapter 20 which is Isaiah 10 will be turned back as Isaiah said by reason of the anointing the powers of the Spirit and the finally coming to operation as you did with each hand as I am the stand and will build this thing up the pendrives will return they'll be crowned with glory not returning to receive the gospel section 133 says they're gonna return to be crowned with glory by then the Saints will be endowed with glory themselves and then he will select 144,000 high priests vivid holy house of the of the holy organ and their mission will be primarily to gather people into the Church of the firstborn when that's done in Christ we put the capstone on the make them kings and priests in actual fact then you have to gather all dispensations into one I've concluded one by the way and that's why Adam on down one has to follow his coming to each temple because you're not going to gather all dispensations into a Gentile Church it's got to be into a computer design with a capstone on a team and about that same time of the atom on Diamond Castle or shortly thereafter then the great scenario of Jerusalem will take place the opening that is explained where the nations of the earth are gathered against Jerusalem and where the Jews are are delivered and all of that is prefigured and shown in previous life so that a Zion is built up and is the adversary comes against the Church of Christ in Jerusalem then they flee to Zion for a period of time the 1260 days or three and a half years or forty two months and they say desire not because their towers but they free desire because they know that they have got to develop the spiritual power and strength in their lives necessary to quit the devil and to throw him out and so they come here did you get that added strength and power and after that three and a half years or that 42 months or than that period of time then client says okay now it's miss now we've got the basis now we've got the foundation where I can exert my power and deliver my people then he will take those some of these I am returning to Jerusalem stand upon the Mount of Olives Institute the resurrection convert the Jewish people bringing them into the kingdom is the Prophet Joseph said on least a couple of occasion will be a gate council of God held at Jerusalem in which the truth orders of God's mind you can know the establishing the Jews replenished and sanctified the temple rebuilt in the audience is given and then when that's taking place and his laws established in Jerusalem then he comes in his glory the clouds of heaven to cleanse the earth and all that well that has it solid scenario let me just take the minute then if it has its basis then the in these prayers councils and there is first of all the Council of the gods and then there was a council or you made the announcement of the decisions that were made by the Council of other gods which council Lucifer bolded and many who were in high positions with him and they carried their case to the people and as the organizational council was held in each spirit world they were passing out literature outside of Temple Square and promoting your programs the war in heaven got underway and then after the war in heaven the under way and was finally over with then the Prophet says this in the teachings page 158 he says the father called all spirits before he may have the creation of man and organized family that organization was an organization of the Spirit is organized in relation to when they're going to come very soon after ease the head rule was told to multiply the priest in space 181 for example you says so but the first organization and there's interesting significance of that word first as the first story at the first organization we're all present and saw the savior chosen and the point of the plan of salvation made and we sanctioned it now the Lord acts on the basis as though you're going to do what you have a potential to do and so when you organize the spirits generation becoming diverse you did it on that premise and then we're people coming to mortality and the darkness of mind fell short include women them said hey I'm gonna be liberated and I'm supposed to have by according to career as appointments i68 kids but I'm gonna be satisfied in a temple then the Lord has to make the adjustments and so there are subsequent organizations you see then the first organizations made on the premise of what we could do with the right exercise of our agency and there's a continual modification of that right on down and it's going on continue releasing but with that thing you finally get things in here the Lord blesses you be a part of that thank you for your attention I'm sorry I haven't gotten here this morning very much I hope I can do another this afternoon I just want to give my testimony that we're talking about the truth and it's a highly significant thing in our lives the name of Jesus Christ amen why did you need to have a mortal mother in the answer is to get in mortality but he was also sanctified I don't know that Mary was sanctified like the Catholic say you know the chillest Immaculate Conception thing but Jesus was sanctified the embryo was but he had to get here and Mary was selected as a very choice one of the leading spirits female spirits in fact the leading female spirit of the career stage with mother Mary I want to know what element arise that changed a bit and I think we talked about that we said oh I didn't know you spoke about in his ministry to Terentius the worlds are all of God's worlds like ours people producing material to rationalist events or people yeah they are they are so the curious and the sort Newton there's in the system and an allocation of words according to the degree of Roy a person received in the resurrection in the ejecta takes place I've heard you discuss the third part of God's children to follow this or what are the other two parts and I don't you give you the answer to that but and as much as this earth is the redemptive earth are there any blessings available those things here that aren't available to say to you know the worlds in the answer to that is yes and that is that I did picture the detail enrich the one all the Lamanites of this genetics is born our crusade I don't quite get the meaning of the mainland eyes of his genetic sea voyages see they'll do their Israel they have time again given that we do read the Romans 9 and for the doctor the election be a part of that they have a calling election to become to see the right to be born again and they have that by birth by blood and so they're a part of that program maybe or whoever wrote this who came up with the tailboard about I think there's value in every other safe you | Light and Truth | UCc9lxZfhWfEQXi2foafVBcQ | 2016-07-22 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 9,937 | 52,029 |
wtAm3cixkDs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wtAm3cixkDs | Quick Dog Facts About The American Eskimo Dog! | what do you call a police dog that's on drugs a coconut the American Eskimo dog is a breed of companion dog originating in Germany the American Eskimo dog is a member of the Spitz family it is considered an ancient dog breed due to its recent admixture With Wolves the breeds progenitors were German spits but due to anti-german sentiment during the first world war it was renamed American Eskimo dog the American Eskimo dog comes in three sizes toy miniature and standard toy stand 9 to 12 inches and weigh about 10 pounds Miniatures stand 12 to 15 inches and weigh about 20 pounds standard stand 15 inches to 19 inches and weigh about 30 pounds the white fluffy American Eskimo dog has a double coat with a dense undercoat and a longer outer coat the hair is straight with no curler wave he has a pronounced rough around the neck his front and rear legs are well feathered and the fur on his tail is profuse he is most often pure white or white and cream not only does the American Eskimo dog have a winning look but he's also got a winning personality he's spunky clever plays hard and loves vigorous exercise because he is naturally suspicious of strangers he makes an excellent watchdog esky's must have regular opportunities to vent their energy and use their busy Minds otherwise they can be rambunctious and bored which usually leads to barking and chewing aboard American Eskimo dog can wreak havoc on your home and yard the Esky is an excellent family dog who's affectionate with everyone including kids of all ages other dogs and cats of course adults should always supervise interactions between kids and dogs the esky's high energy level can be overwhelming to extremely young children so supervision is especially important the Esky does not receive high marks for living in peace with small mammals and birds which he tends to Chase the American Eskimo breed have an average lifespan of about 12 to 14 years the Esky is not a very popular dog in the United States however it is coming up quite fast as a result a healthy puppy from a good breeder will set you back anywhere between 600 and 800 dollars if you want to know who really loves you lock your wife and your dog in the trunk of your car let them out three hours later and see who's happy to see you thanks for watching And subscribe for more bad jokes and general knowledge about dogs foreign | Quick Dog Facts | UCziyAyP_7Tydr8vV47w0Mwg | 2024-01-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 429 | 2,366 |
ridn3YMgUp8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ridn3YMgUp8 | SO...I PUT GRASSHOPPERS IN THEIR SLUSHY'S 🤮 | [Music] [Applause] [Music] is what's good with y'all boys youtube man it's your boy ck spaz and as y'all already know and today i'm coming back with another prank for today my [ __ ] so today the prank will be y'all see this bag of crickets you know what i'm saying and y'all already know who i'm from the prank once again yeah that way chris i ain't gonna lie he got something coming for him i told him hey bro let's do a little sit down talk bro let's do a little sit down talk to talk about some funny [ __ ] right so whatever he eating i'm gonna try to slide this [ __ ] up in his food some way somehow without him knowing bro i swear to god it's gonna be the funniest reaction ever because this [ __ ] hate bugs bro so i'm gonna get him and my cousin gonna beat us off and get him too ain't gonna lie bro this [ __ ] gonna be so funny man hey y'all stay tuned i told y'all i'm gonna be bringing out some late content stay tuned bazaar crew we up next bro i'm trying to tell y'all bro stay with us on the grind bruh if you're new to the channel please like comment subscribe if you like the content man please share you know what i'm saying any support help let's get to a thousand subscribers we almost done bad's our crew man we up next bro this [ __ ] gonna be so funny bro because this [ __ ] chris is so scary bro when he find out what he eating bruh um he gonna throw a watch hey we've been ahead to chris house and i'm finna get to x and i'm gonna catch y'all when i see that you did y'all it's looking kind of ugly outside today it is not looking pretty all right so i'm at sonic right they don't want them to eat they want slushies so i'm gonna put them [ __ ] in the slushie oh yeah i'm gonna get that ass watch oh sorry we can't take orders come in okay so y'all let me tell you what my click ass indeed i didn't left my damn wallet at home bro now i got to go play stupid and be like brother let me use your car bro i'm just going to catch up before the full body left my cord and [ __ ] bro like man i really want this hoe man gotta go over here and and play stupid and [ __ ] i'm gonna lift my damn wallet at home i don't [ __ ] know man damn so i'ma hit y'all when i get it bro i'm gonna go get it bro i can't let them ride with me bro cause if i ride with me then i can't do what i gotta do two hours later all right y'all so i finally got the slushies right got mine too that's what my lips blue all right that's what it is so look they want it chris wanted a uh a strawberry slush my cousin wanted a blueberry nervously so i got two of each one of them on one of those i'm gonna put the crickets in right and the other one's gonna be regular because i ain't gonna do them like that oh what we gonna do we gonna get down the business off in the gall head and put these crates on there but you see how you see how the you see how the um the straws is got christmas up there where they can fit through the straw they can slurp them bro this [ __ ] gonna be so funny bruh oh my gosh putting them in there right now now what i'm doing i'm just crunching them up right now i'm just crunching them up that way they can fit y'all see that grasshoppers oh yeah i thought these crickets he grabbed apples see this right y'all see this all right y'all this one i'm gonna catch y'all when i'm finished turning this up then i'm gonna put the other one in oh [ __ ] they and it's kind of hard doing this with one hand bro [Music] all right y'all so i've been going long enough i'm gonna go ahead and head back to this house because then they gonna start knowing something up bro they're gonna start doing something oh you feel me hit y'all [Applause] [Music] um [Music] [Laughter] synthetic weed he came home and [ __ ] hopped in the shower now he knew how much i could turn on the uh shower no me and my mom was in the living room [Music] what the hell you mean she she said i smoked some we don't know what it was then well he went back to the restaurant mama said come here boy and then he was like what's going on what's wrong with me i need to get this out just like you want to shower for a little wait a minute next thing you know cuz i had to open the door mama said no stay in the house stay down then we we blocking the door this [ __ ] tried to bust through the [ __ ] window let's go to my head oh faith and then they being in charleston for the [ __ ] they going around in the frame man this [ __ ] said no he tried to run back in the house he was like no stay out here stay out here get some help and then that's what baby no [Laughter] [Music] no [Laughter] [Music] that's from my house bro it's a it's a trail but while we're here we had scholars [Laughter] [Music] oh [Music] [Laughter] [Music] um [Laughter] oh [Laughter] apples [Music] bro that's why you were doing this oh [Laughter] oh [Music] come on hey man it's your boy ck spazzing i hope y'all liked the video i hope y'all enjoyed the video we're crazy like the last one you feel me but i still got a good reaction out of it man y'all enjoyed the video please like comment and subscribe it's your boy ck spazzin you know how it is you know what go down man and i'm gonna catch y'all on the next one you dig | CK Spazzin | UCfPRhPUOHQm8XEAlmUD4ZvA | 2021-05-17 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,054 | 5,370 |
49FFKp66gGM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=49FFKp66gGM | Unearthed Treasure: Rare 1971 Australian Footage of Elton John #eltonjohn | he is now the biggest probably pop star in England and in America I'd like you to welcome ladies and gentlemen Elton [Applause] [Music] [Applause] John well there you go how do you feel with my hand with your hand well that's good we're going to it's one of even it it's going to be one of those nights Elon welcome to Australia thank you um we're talking before Johnny faram who was probably one of the main contenders for the King of Pop and Nory who started the crown off about 3 years ago both these people have recorded your songs so I believe that's right yeah and would you believe little old Rosy while he's got one tucked away in the can called um hey what's it called no it's called going home do you remember writing that that's funny you did no one's ever recorded that really I've got a first wow no it's a it's a really good song but it's a I've been doing ballads ever since I started recording and uh I don't know how I go on a rock and roll song well why happen have a try I'll send you a demo of it send me send me a copy yeah it's all money isn't it it's all money all right Elon um the night is for the King of Pop in Australia and TV week in all their wisdom have uh donated or have given you an award for the international king of Po it's a large tuning fork that's the first time I've seen it um is that all you have to say that's fantastic I can't believe it King of Pop 1971 well there you go International that's great too much fabulous really great what else can I say thank you very much John ladies and gentlemen thank you very much he doesn't get to keep it for very long they're taking it back already all right the uh we'll get on with the the business at this is really exciting I've seen all those sort of in England M those Beauty contests when and the winner sort of opens an envelope and they say well there you go and that's really exciting wait a second oh wait a second he's so excited he's he's got me he's got me going Elton these are the nominees for the best Australian songwriter and they go like this Russell Morris young man from Sydney Ted mullery doing a fine job our little favorite h [Music] [Applause] pson a young man that's um started out on his and doing really well Ricky [Music] Springfield and last but not least the one and only Johnny Young you couldn't forget on joh all right Elon you can yes you can go through all that tearing business now and open it up there you go so I announce it right if you would so top Australian songwriter is Russell Morris [Music] there we go the best songwriter for 1971 Russell Morris I wouldn't say the best W you always said that right oh it's it's fabulous thanks to all the voters and TV week Channel 11 and that's great it's an incred it's an incredible if I can borrow that perhaps I get a pair of high heel shoes me it's a real thrill to receive it from someone like like you well it's a pleasure Russell moris ladies and gent thank [Music] you we've got uh in our country as you have in yours an incredible amount of talents well we think so anyway and I'd like you to um enjoy the sounds of Colleen hu Colin's landed a role in a new rock opera called Gods spell is that is that running in England no it's running in America and doing very very well and a little off C theater just off Broadway it's it's just really doing fantastic business fabulous all right so we wish Colin hu all the very best in there Elton thank you very much for being with us ladies and gentlemen Colin hu and Superstar | ILUVMUSIC | UCyNyITeziwMLyCSB32jFa5A | 2024-03-25 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 687 | 3,497 |
CinIDYva8Fs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CinIDYva8Fs | Don Quixote, Vol. 2 (Ormsby Translation) | Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra | Humorous Fiction | 9/11 | volume 2 part 2 chapter 57 of the ingenious gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra translated by John Ormsby 1829 to 1895 this LibriVox recording is in the public domain recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume 2 part 2 chapter 57 which treats of how Don Quixote took leave of the Duke and of what followed with a witty and impudent Altezza Dora one of the Duchess's damsels Don Quixote now felt it right to quit a life of such idleness as he was leading in the castle for he fancied that he was making himself sorely missed by suffering himself to remain shut up and inactive amid the countless luxuries and enjoyments his host lavished upon him as a knight and he thought too that he would have to render a strict account to heaven of that indolence and seclusion and so one day he asked the Duke and Duchess to grant him permission to take his departure they gave it showing at the same time but they were very sorry he was leaving them the Duchess gave his wife's letters to Sancho Panza who shed tears over them saying who would have thought that such grand hopes as the news of my government bred and my wife Teresa pons his breast would end in my going back now to the vagabond adventures of my master Don Quixote of La Mancha still I'm glad to see my Teresa behaved as she ought in sending the acorns grow she had not sent them I'd had been sorry and she'd have shown herself ungrateful it is a comfort to me that they can't call that present a bribe for I had got the government already when she sent them and it's but reasonable that those who have had a good turn done them should show their gratitude if it's only with the trifle after all I went into the government naked and I come out of it naked so I can say with the safe conscience and that's no small matter naked I was born naked I find myself I neither lose nor gain thus did Sancho soliloquized on the day of their departure as Don Quixote who had the night four taken leave of the Duke and Duchess coming out made his appearance at an early hour in full armor in the courtyard of the castle the whole household of the castle were watching him from the corridors and the Duke and Duchess to came out to see him Sancho was mounted on his dapple with his of four Hass beliefs and proven supremely happy because the Dukes majordomo the same that had acted the part of the trifle dee had given him a little purse with 200 gold crowns to meet the necessary expenses of the road but of this Don Quixote knew nothing as yet while all were as has been said observing him suddenly from among the dew Ines and hen maidens the impudent and witty Altezza Dora lifted up her voice and said in pathetic tones give Eirik rule night drew rein where's the need of spurring the flanks of that old broken steed from what art thou flying no dragon I am not even a sheep but a tender young lamb that has jilted a maiden as fare to behold as nymph of Diana or Venus of old Mourinho and Gnaeus what worse shall I call thee Barabbas go with thee all evil befall thee in thy claws ruthless robber that barest away the heart of a meek loving made for thy prey three kerchief stylist in garters a pair from legs than the whitest of marble more fair and the size that pursue thee would burn to the ground mm Troy towns if so many were found but rainy Oh and he is what worse shall I call thee Barabbas go with thee all evil befall thee may no bowels of Mercy to Sun shall be granted and I die Sonia be left still enchanted may thy for said to me find its punishment in her or in my land adjust often pays for the sinner may thy grandis adventurous discomfiture as proved may thy Joy's be old dreams and forgotten thy love thy reign yo Aeneas what worse shall I call thee Barabbas go with thee all evil befall thee may thy name be abhorred for thy conduct to ladies from London to England from Seville to Cadiz maybe I'd be unlucky thy hands contain Nair a king 7 or ace when that play is primeira when my corns are cut may it be to the quick when that grinders are drawn may the roots of them stick mourinho and he has what worse shall I call thee Barabbas go with the oil evil befall thee all the while be unhappy aught Isidora would be wailing herself in the above strain Don Quixote stood staring at her and without uttering a word and replied to her he turned round to Sancho and said Sancho my friend I conjure thee by the life of thy forefathers tell me the truth say hast thou by any chance taking the three kerchief sand the garters this lovesick maid speaks of do this Sancho made answer the the three kerchiefs I have but the garters as much as over the hills of ubaydah the Duchess was amazed LT Siddhartha's assurance she knew that she was birthed lively and impudent but not so much so as to venture to make free in this fashion and not being prepared for the joke her astonishment was all the greater the Duke had a mind to keep up the sport so he said it does not seem to me well done in you sir Knight that after having received the hospitality that has been offered you in this very castle you should have ventured to carry off even three kerchief not to save my handmaids garters it shows a bad heart and does not tally with your reputation we stir her garters for us I defy you to mortal combat for I am Not Afraid of rascally enchanters changing or altering my features as they change seers who encountered you into those of my Lackey to ceelo's god-forbid said Don Quixote then I should draw my sword against your illustrious person from which I have received such great favors the kerchief sigh will restore as Sancho says he has them as to the Garter said is impossible I had not gut them neither has he and if your handmaiden here will look in her hiding places depend upon it she will find them I have never been a thief my lord Duke nor do I mean to be so long as I live if God cease not to have me in his key this damsel by her own confession speaks as one in love for which I am not to blame and therefore need not ask pardon either of her or of your excellence you're my entry to have a better opinion of me and once more to give me leave to pursue my journey and may God sir prosperous end your Don Quixote said the Duchess that we may always hear good news of your exploits Godspeed you for the render you stay the more human flame the hearts of the damsels who behold you and as for this one of mine I was so chastise her that she will not transgress again either with her eyes or with her words men maiden no more our valiant Don Quixote I asked you to hear siddhart Isidora and that is that I beg your pardon about the theft of the garters for by God and upon my soul I have got them on and I have fallen into the same blunder as he did we went looking for his ass being all the while mounted on it didn't I say so said Sancho and the likely one to hide thefts or if I wanted to deal in them opportunities came ready enough to me and my government thankee Hotei bowed his head and saluted the Duke and Duchess and all the bystanders and wielding the resonant a rounds such are following him on dapple he rode out of the castle shaping his course for Saragosa end of volume 2 part 2 chapter 57 recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine - Part 2 chapter 58 of the ingenious gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra translated by John Ormsby 1829 to 1895 this LibriVox recording is in the public domain recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume 2 part 2 chapter 58 which tells how Adventures came crowding on Don Quixote in such numbers that they gave one another no breathing time when Don Quixote saw himself in open country free and relieved from the intentions of aunt Isadora he felt at his ease and in fresh spirits to take up the pursuit of chivalry once more in turning to Sancho he said freedom Sancho is one of the most precious gifts that heaven has bestowed upon men no treasure is that the earth holds buried or the sea conceals can compare with it for freedom as for honor life may and should be ventured and on the other hand captivity is a greatest evil that can fall to the lot of man I say this Sancho because thou has seen the good cheer the abundance we have enjoyed in this castle we are leaving well then amid those dainty banquets and snow cooled beverages I felt as though I were undergoing the straits of hunger because I did not enjoy them with the same freedom as if they had been mine own for the sense of being under an obligation to return benefits and favours received is a restraint that checks the independence of the spirit happy he to whom heaven has given a piece of bread for which he is not bound to give thanks to any but heaven itself for all your worship says said Sancho it is not becoming that there should be no thanks on our part for 200 gold crowns that the Dukes majordomo has given me in a little purse which I carry next my heart like a warming plaster or comforter to meet any chance calls but we shan't always find castles where they'll entertain us now and then we may light upon roadside ends where though cudgel us in conversation of this sort the night and square errand pursuing their journey when after they had gone a little more than half a league they perceived some dozen men dressed like laborers stretched upon their cloaks on the grass of a green meadow eating their dinner they had beside them what seemed to be white sheets concealing some objects under them standing upright or lying flat and arranged at intervals Don Quixote approached the diners and saluting them courteously first he asked them what it was those claws covered sin you are answered word of the party under these cloths are some images carved in relief intended for a retablo we are putting up in our village we carry them covered up that they may not be soiled and on our shoulders that they may not be broken with your good leave sub don quixote i should like to see them for images that are carries so carefully no doubt must be fine ones I should think they were sore the other that the money they cost speak for that for as a matter of fact there is not one of them that does not stand us in more than fifty ducats and that your worship may judge wait a moment and you shall see with your own eyes and getting up from his dinner he went and uncovered the first image which proved to be one of Saint George on horseback with a serpent riving at his feet and the Lance thrust down its throat with all that fierceness that is usually depicted the whole group was one blaze of gold as the saying is on seeing it Don Quixote said that night was one of the best Knights errant the army of heaven ever owned he was called Don st. George and he was moreover a defender of maidens let us see this next one the man uncovered it and it was seen to be that of st. Martin on his horse dividing his cloak with the beggar instead Don Quixote saw it he said this night to was one of the Christian adventurers but I believe he was generous rather than valiant as thou mayest perceive Sancho by his dividing his cloak with the beggar and giving him half of it no doubt it was winter at the time for otherwise he would have given him the whole of it so charitable was he it was not that most likely said Sancho but that he held with a proverb that says for giving and keeping there's need of brains Don Quixote laughed and asked him to take off the next cloth underneath which was seen the image of the patron saint of the Spain's seated on horseback his sword stained with blood trampling on Moors and treading heads underfoot and on seeing at Don Quixote exclaimed I this is a knight and of the squadron's of Christ this one is called Don st. James the moor Slayer one of the bravest saints and Knights the world ever had or heaven has now it then raised another cloth which had appeared covered st. Paul falling from his horse with all the details that are usually given in representations of his conversion when bran Quixote saw it rendered in such lifelike style that one would have said Christ was speaking in Poland suring this he said was in his time the greatest enemy that the Church of God our Lord had and the greatest champion it will ever have a knight errant in life a steadfast Saint in death an untiring labourer in the Lord's vineyard a teacher of the Gentiles whose school was heaven and whose instructor and master with Jesus Christ himself there were no more images so Don Quixote bade them cover them up again and said to those who had brought them I take it as a happy omen brothers to have seen what I have for these Saints and Knights were of the same profession as myself which is the calling of arms only there is this difference between them and me that they were Saints and fraught with divine weapons and I am a sinner and fight with human ones they're one heaven by force of arms for heaven suffereth violence and I so far know not what I have won by dint of my sufferings but if my destiny a delta Bosa were to be released from hers perhaps with mended fortunes in a mind restored to itself I might direct my steps in a better path than I am following at present may God here in sin be death said Sancho to this the men were filled with Wonder as well at the figure as at the words of Don Quixote though they did not understand one half of what he meant by them they finished their dinner took their images on their backs and bidding farewell to Don Quixote resumed their journey Sancho was a May afresh at the extent of his master's knowledge as much as if he had never known him proceed to him that there was no story or event in the world that he had not at his fingers ends and fixed in his memory and he said to him and truth mastermind if this that has happened to us today is to be called an adventure it has been one of the sweetest and pleasantest that have befallen us in the whole course of our travels who have come out of the unbe labored and undismayed neither have we drawn sword nor have we smitten the earth with our bodies nor have we been left vanishing blessed be God that he has let me see such a thing with my own eyes that say it wasn't just a Don Quixote but remember all times are not alike nor do they always run the same way and these things the Volga commonly call omens which are not based upon any natural reason will by him who is wise be esteemed and reckoned happy accidents merely one of these believers in omens will get up of a morning leave his house and meet a friar of the order of the Blessed Saint Francis and as if he had met a griffon he will turn about and go home with another Mendoza this artist built on his table and gloominess built over his heart as if nature was obliged to give warning of coming misfortunes by means of such trivial things as these their wise man in the Christian should not trifle with what it may please heaven to do Skippy oh I'm coming to Africa stumbled as he leaped on shore his soldiers took it as a bad omen but he clasping the soul with his arms exclaimed thou canst not escape me Africa for I heard they tight between my arms best Sancho meeting those images have been to me a most happy occurrence I cannot believe it said Sancho but I wish your worship would tell me what is the reason that the Spaniards and they are about to give better than calling on that st. James tomb or Slayer so Santiago enclose Spain is Spain then open so that it is needful to close it or what is the meaning of this forum now work very simple Sanchez of Don Quixote a God look you gave that great Knight of the Red Cross to Spain as her patron saint and protector is in those hard struggles the Spaniards had with the Moors and therefore they invoke and call upon him as their defender in all their battles and did these he has been many a time seen beating down trampling underfoot destroying and slaughtering the Hagia Irene squadrons in the sight of all a rich fact I could give thee many examples recorded in truthful Spanish histories Sancho changed the subject and said to his master I'm Marva senior at the bird nests of @tc Dora the Duchess's handmade he whom they call love must have cruelly pierced and wounded her they say here's a little blind urgent who their blear-eyed or more properly speaking sightless if he aims at a heart be it ever so small hits it and pierces it through and through with his arrows I've heard it said too that the arrows of love are blunted and robbed of their points by maidenly modesty in reserve whether this altisidora it seems they are sharpened rather than blunted bear in mind Sanchez a Don Quixote that love is influenced by no consideration recognizes no restraints of reason and deserve the same nature as death that assails alike the lofty palaces of kings and the humble cabins of shepherds and when it takes entire possession of a heart the first thing it does is to banish fear and shame from it and say without shame of Tisa Dora declared her passion which excited in my mind embarrassment rather than commiseration notable cruelty exclaimed Sancho unheard of ingratitude I can only say for myself at the very smallest loving word of hers would have subdued me and made a slave of me the devil had a heart of marble with bowels of brass with a soul of mortar but I can't imagine what it is that this damsel saw in your worship that could have conquered and captivated her so what gallant figure was it what bold bearing that sprightly grace what comeliness a feature which of these things by itself went all together could have made her fall in love with you for indeed and in truth many a time I stopped to look at your worship from the sole of your foot to the topmost hair of your head and I see more to fright to make one fall in love however I've heard say that beauty is the first and main thing that excites love and does your worship has none at all I don't know what the poor creature fell in love with recollect Sancho replied Don Quixote there are two sorts of beauty one of the mind the other of the body that of the mind displays and exhibits itself in intelligence and modesty in honorable conduct in generosity in good breeding and where these qualities are possible and may exist in an ugly man and when it is this sort of beauty and not that of the body that is the attraction love is apt to spring up suddenly and violently I such I perceived clearly enough that I am not beautiful but at the same time I know I am NOT hideous and it is enough for an honest man not to be a monster to be an object of love if only he possesses the endowments of mind I have mentioned while engaged in this discourse they were making their way through a wood that lay beyond the road and suddenly without expecting anything of the kind Don Quixote found himself caught in some Nets of green cord stretched from one tree to another and unable to can see what it could be he said to Sancho Sancho it strikes me this affair of these nets will prove one of the strangest adventures imaginable now I die if the enchanters that persecute me are not trying to entangle me in them and delay my journey by way of revenge for my obduracy turrets at Isidora well then let me tell them that if these nets instead of being green cord were made of the harvest diamonds are stronger than that we were the jealous glad a blacksmith's enmeshed Venus and Mars I would break them as easily as if they were made of rushes or cotton threads but just as he was about to press forward and break through all suddenly from among some trees to shepherdesses of surpassing beauty presented themselves to his sight where these damsels dressed like shepherdesses say that their Jerkins in Saez were a fine brocade that is to say the silos were rich farthingales of gold embroidered tabby their hair that in its birth and brightness vied with the beams of the Sun itself fell loose upon their shoulders and was crowned with garlands twined with green laurel and red everlasting and their years to all appearance were not under 15 or above 18 such was the spectacle that filled Sancha with amazement fascinated Don Quixote made the Sun halt in his course to behold them and held all four and a strange silence one of the shepherdess is at length was the first to speak and said to Don Quixote old sir knight and do not break these nuts for they are not spread here to do you any harm but only for our amusement and as I know you will ask why they have been put up and who we are I will tell you in a few words in a village some two leagues from this where there are many people of quality and rich gentle folk it was agreed upon by a number of friends and relations to come with their wives sons and daughters neighbors friends and kinsmen and make holiday in this spot which is one of the pleasantest in the whole neighborhood setting up a new pastoral Arcadia among ourselves we maidens dressing ourselves as shepherdesses and the youths as shepherds we prepared to Eclogues one by the famous poet garcilaso the other by the most excellent como ends in its own Portuguese tongue but we have not as yet acted them yesterday was the first day of our coming here we have a few of what they say are called field tents pitched among the trees on the bank of an ample Brook that fertilizes all these meadows last night we spread these nuts in the trees here to snare the silly little birds that startled by the noise we make may fly into them if you please to be our guests in your you will be welcomed hardly and courteously we're here just now neither care nor sorrow shall enter she held her peace and said no more and Don Quixote made answer of a truth Ferris lady Oktay on when he unexpectedly beheld Diana bathing in the stream could not have been more fascinated and wonderstruck than I at the sight of your beauty I commend your mode of entertainment and thank you for the kindness of your invitation and if I can serve you you may command me with full confidence of being obeyed for my profession is none other than to show myself great and ready to serve persons of all conditions but especially persons of qualities such as your appearance indicates and if instead of taking up as they probably do but a small space these nets took up the whole surface of the globe I would seek out new worlds through which to pass so as not to break them and that she may give some degree of credence to this exaggerated language of mine know that it is no less than Don Quixote of La Mancha that makes this declaration to you if indeed it be that such a name has reached your ears ah friend of my soul instantly exclaimed the other shepherdess what great good fortune has befallen us si si this gentleman we had before us well then let me tell that he is the most valiant and the most devoted in the most courteous gentleman in all the world unless a history of his achievements that has been printed and I have read his telling lies in deceiving us I will lay a wager that this good fellow who is with him is when Sancho Panza his squire this drooler 'is none can equal that's true said Sancho I am that same droll and Squire you speak of and this gentleman is my master Don Quixote of La Mancha the same that's in the history and that they talk about o my friend said the other let us entreat him to stay but we'll give our fathers and brothers infinite pleasure I too of heard just what thou has told me of the valour of the one and the jewelry's of the other and what is more of him they say that he is the most constant and loyal lover that was ever heard of and that his lady is one Dulcinea del Toboso to whom all over Spain the poem of beauty is awarded and justly awarded said Don Quixote unless indeed your unequaled Beauty makes it a matter of doubt but spare yourselves the trouble ladies of pressing me to stay for the urgent cards of my profession do not allow me to take rest under any circumstances at this instant there came up to the spot where the four stood a brother of one of the two shepherdesses like them in shepherd costume and as richly and gaily dressed as they were they told him that their companion was the valiant Don Quixote of La Mancha and the other Sancho his squire of whom he knew already having read their history the gay Shepherd offered him his services and begged that he would accompany him to their tents and Don Quixote had to give way and comply and now the game was started and the nets were filled with a variety of birds that deceived by the color fell into the danger they were flying from upwards of thirty persons all gaily attired as shepherds and shepherdesses assembled on the spot and were at once informed to Don Quixote and his squire where we're at they were not a little delighted as they knew of him already through its history they repaired to the tents where they found tables laid out and choice Lea plentifully and neatly furnished they treated Don Quijote as a person of distinction giving him the place of honor and all observed him and were full of astonishment at the spectacle at last the cloth being removed Don Quixote with great composure lifted up his voice and said one of the greatest sins that men are guilty of is some will say pride but I say ingratitude going by the common saying that hell is full of ingrates this sin so far as it is lain in my power I have endeavored to avoid ever since I have enjoyed the Faculty of reason and if I am unable to requite good deeds that have been done me by other deeds I substitute the desire to do so and if that be not enough I make him known publicly for he who declares and makes known the good deeds done to him would repay them by others if it were in his power and for the most part those who receive are the inferiors of those who give thus God is superior to all because he is a supreme giver and the offerings of man falls short by an infinite distance of being a full return for the gifts of God but gratitude in some degree makes up for this deficiency and shortcoming I therefore grateful for the favor that has been extended to me here and unable to make a return in the same measure restricted as I am by the narrow limits of my power offer what I can and what I have to offer in my own way and sir I declare that for 2/3 days I will maintain in the middle of this highway leading to saragossa that these ladies disguised as shepherdesses who are here present are the fairest and most courteous maidens in the world accepting only the peerless Dulcinea del Toboso sole mistress of my thoughts be it said without offence to those who hear me ladies and gentlemen on hearing this Sancho who had been listening with great attention cried out in a loud voice is it possible there is anyone in the world who will dare to say and swear that this master of mine is a madman say gentlemen shepherds is there a village priest be he ever sir wiser learned who could say what my master has said or is there knight errant whatever renown he may have as a man of Valor that could offer what my master is offered now Don Quixote turned upon Sancho and with a countenance glowing with anger said to him is it possible Sancho if there is anyone in the whole world who will say thou art not a fool with a whining to match and I know now what trimmings of impertinence and roguery rest me to meddle in my affairs or to inquire whether I am a wise man or a blockhead well that piece answered me not a word satirist Ananta if he be unsettled and let us go to put my offer into execution but with the right that I have on my side that mayor's reckon as vanquished all who shall venture to question it and in a great rage and showing his anger plainly he rose from his seat leaving the company lost and wonder and making them feel doubtful whether they ought to regard him as a madman or a rational being in the end though they sought to dissuade him from involving himself in such a challenge assuring him they admitted his gratitude has fully established and needing no fresh proofs to be convinced of his valiant spirit as those related in the history of his exploits were sufficient still Don Quixote persisted in his resolve and mounted on resonant a bracing his buckler on his arm in grasping his lamps he posted himself in the middle of a high road that was not far from the green meadow Sancho followed on dapple too with all the members of the pastoral gathering eager to see what would be the upshot of his vainglorious and extraordinary proposal Don Quixote then having as has been said planted himself in the middle of the road made their walk in the ring with words to this effect oh ye travelers and Wayfarers Knights squares folk on foot or on horseback who passed this way or shall pass in the course of the next two days noted Don Quixote of La Mancha knight errant is posted here to maintain by arms that the beauty and courtesy enshrined in the nymphs that dwell in these meadows and groves surpassed all upon earth putting aside the lady of my heart destiny a del Toboso wherefore let him who was of the opposite opinion come on for here I await him twice he repeated the same words and twice they fell unheard by any adventurer but fate that was guiding affairs for him from better to better so ordered it that shortly afterwards there appeared on the road a crowded men on horseback many of them with lances in their hands all writing in a compact body and in great haste no sooner have those who were with Don Quixote seen them then they turned about and withdrew to some distance from the road they knew that if they stayed some harm might come to them but Don Quixote with intrepid heart stood his ground in Sancho Panza shielded himself with her sonatas hindquarters the troop of Lancers came up and one of them who was in advance began shouting to Don Quixote get out of the way you son of the devil for these birds will knock you to pieces rabble returned Don Quixote a I care nothing for Boles be there the fiercest hirama breathes on its banks confess at once scoundrels that when I declared his true else she have to deal with me in combat the herdsman had no time to reply no Don Quixote to get out of the way even if he wished and so the drove of fierce Boles and tame bollocks together with a crowd of herdsmen and others who were taking them to be pinned up in a village where they were to be run the next day passed over donkey / Sancho Rocinante and dapple filling them all to the earth and rolling them over on the ground Sancho was left crushed Don Quixote scared dapple belabored and Marisa Dante in know very sound condition they are good up however at length and Don Quixote in great haste stumbling here and falling there started off running after the drove shouting out old stay rascally rattle a single night away - and he is not of the temper or opinion of those who say for a flying enemy make a bridge of silver the retreating party in their haste however did not stop for that or heed his menaces any more than last year's clouds - Brett Don Quixote to a halt and Marin wage then avenged he sat down on the road to wait until Sancho Rocinante and dapple came up when they reached her master and men mounted once more and without going back to bid farewell to the mock or imitation Arcadia and Marin humiliation than contentment they continued their journey end of wine - Part 2 chapter 58 recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume 2 part two chapter 59 of the ingenious gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra translated by John Ormsby 1829 to 1895 this LibriVox recording is in the public domain recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume 2 part 2 chapter 59 wherein is related the strange thing which may be regarded as an adventure that happened to Don Quixote a clear limpid spring which they discovered in a cool Grove relieved Don Quixote and Sancho of the dust and fatigue due to the unpolite behavior of the Bulls and by the side of this having turned dapple and Nerissa Dante loose without headstall or a bridle therefore Lorne pair master and man seated themselves Sancho had recourse to the Lord or if his elf or Hoss and took out of them what he called the prog Don Quixote rinsed his mouth and bathed his face by which cooling process his flagging energies were revived out of pure vexation he remained without eating and out of pure politeness Sancho did not venture to touch a morsel of what was before him but waited for his master to act as taster seeing however that absorbed in thought he was forgetting to carry the bread to his mouth he said never a word and trampling every sort of good breeding underfoot began to stow away in his punch the bread and cheese that came to his hand eat Sancho my friend said Don Quixote a support life which has had more consequence to thee than to me and leave me to die under the pain of my thoughts and pressure of my misfortunes I was born son show to live dying and thou to die eating and to prove the truth of what I said look at me printed in history's famed and arms courteous and behavior honored by princes quoted by maidens and after all when I looked forward to palms triumphs and crowns won and earned by my valiant deeds I had this morning seen myself trembled on kicked and crushed by the feet of unclean and filthy animals this thought blunts my teeth paralyzes my jaws cramps my hands and robbed me of all appetite for food so much said that I have a mind to let myself die of hunger the cruelest death of all deaths seven said Sancho munching hard all the time your worship does not agree with the proverb that says let Martha die but let her die with a full belly I at any rate have no mind to kill myself so far from that I mean to do as the cobbler does who stretches the leather with his teeth until he makes it reach as far as he wants I stretch out my life by eating until it reaches the end heaven as fixed gora and let me tell you Senor there's no greater folly than to think of dying of despair as your worship does take my advice and after eating lie down and sleep a bit on this green grass mattress and you will see that when you awake you'll feel something better Don Quixote did as he recommended for it struck him that Sancho's reasoning was more like a philosopher than a Blockheads and said he Sancho if that would do for me what I am going to tell thee my ease of mind would be more assured in my heaviness of heart not so great and it is this to go aside a little while I am sleeping in accordance would I advise and making bear thy carcass to the air to give thyself three or four hundred lashes with the rest of nantes reins on account of the three thousand and odd thou art to give thyself for the disenchantment of Dulcinea for it is a great pity that the poor lady should be left enchanted through thy carelessness and negligence there is a good deal to be said on that point since Sancho let us both go to sleep now and after that God has decreed what will happen let me tell you worship that for a man to whip himself in cold blood is a hard thing especially if the stripes fall upon an ill nourished and worse fed body let my lady Dulcinea have patience and when she is least expecting it she will see me made a riddle of with whipping and until death it's all life I mean that I have still life in me and the desire to make good what I have promised Don Quixote thanked him and ate a little in Sancho a good deal and then they both lay down to sleep leaving those two inseparable friends and comrades Rocinante and dapple to their own devices and to feed unrestrained upon the abundant grass with which the meadow was furnished they woke up rather late mounted once more and resumed their journey pushing on to reach an inn which was in sight apparently a league off I say an inn because Don Quixote called it so contrary to his usual practice of calling all Inns castles they reached it and asked the landlord if they could put up there he said yes with as much comfort and as good fare as they could find in Saragosa they dismounted and sighed stowed away his larder in a room of which the landlord gave him the key he took the Beast to the stable fed them and came back to see what orders Don Quijote who was seated on a bench at the door had for him giving special thanks to Heaven that this Inn had not been taken for a castle by his master suppertime came and they repaired to their room in Sancho asked the landlord what he had to give them for supper - this the landlord replied that his mouth should be the measure he had only to ask what he would for that Inn was provided with the birds of the air and the fowls of the earth and the fish of the sea there's no need of all that said Sancho if they roast us a couple of chickens we'll be satisfied for my master is delicate and eats little and I'm not over into bub gluttonous the landlord replied he had no chickens for the kites had stolen them well then said Sancho that send your landlord tell them to roast a pullet so that it is a tender one bullet my father said the landlord in deed and in truth it's only yesterday I sent over fifty to the city to sell but saving pullets ask what you will in that case said Sancho you will not be without veal or a kid just now said the landlord there's none in the house for it's all finished but next week there will be enough in to spare much good that does us said Sancho a lad bet that all these shortcomings are going to wind up in plenty of bacon and eggs my god said the landlord my guess wits must be precious dull I tell him I have neither pullets nor hens and he wants me to have eggs talk of other dainty's if you please and don't ask for hens again body of me said Sancho let's settle the matter say it wants what you have gut and let us have no more words about it in truth and earnest send your guest said the landlord all how you have is a couple of cow Hills like calves feet or a couple of calves feet like cow Hills they are boiled with chickpeas onions and bacon and at this moment they are crying come eat me come eat me I mark them for mine on the spot said Sancho let nobody I pay better for them than anyone else for I could not wish for anything more to my taste and I don't care a pin whether they are feet or heels nobody shall touch them said the landlord for the other guests I have being persons of high quality bring their own cook and caterer and larder with them if you come to people of quality said Sancho there's nobody more so than my master but the calling he follows did not allow of Larter's or storerooms we lay ourselves down in the middle of the meadow and for ourselves what acorns are meddlers here ended such as conversation with the landlord Sancho not caring to carry it any farther by answering him for he had already asked him what calling or what profession it was his master was owned separate time having come then Don Quixote be took himself to his room the landlord brought in the stew pen as it was and he sat himself down to sup very resolutely it seems that in another room which was next to Don Quixote with nothing but a thin partition to separate it he overheard these words as you live send you are done here are normal while they are bringing supper let us read another chapter of the second part AB Don Quixote of La Mancha the instant Don Quixote heard his own name he started to his feet and listened with open ears to catch what they said about him and heard the Don Harron and well who had been addressed say in reply why would you have us read that absurd stuff Don Juan when it is impossible for anyone who has read the first part of the history of Don Quixote of La Mancha to take any pleasure in reading the second part for all that said he who was addressed as Don Juan we shall do well to read it where there is no book so bad but it has something good in it what displeases me most in it is that it represents Don Quixote as now cured of his love for Dulcinea del Toboso on hearing this Don Quixote full of wrath and indignation lifted up his voice and said whoever he may be who says that Don Quixote of La Mancha has forgotten or can forget Dulcinea del Toboso I will teach him with equal arms that what he says is very far from the truth but neither can the peerless Dulcinea del Toboso be forgotten nor can forgetfulness have a place in Don Quixote his motto is constancy and his profession to maintain the same with his life and never wrong it who is this that answers us said they in the next room who should it be said Sancho but Don Quixote of La Mancha himself who will make good all he has said and all he will say for pledges don't trouble a good pair Sancho had hardly uttered these words when two gentlemen for such they seemed to be entered the room and one of them throwing his arms around Don Quixote 'he's next said to him your appearance cannot leave any question as to your name no can your name fail to identify your appearance unquestionably Senor you are the real Don Quixote de la Mancha Sanna sure and morning star of knight-errantry despite and in defiance of him who is set to usurp your name and bring to nought your achievements as the author of this book which I here present to you has done and with this he put a book which his companion carried into the hands of Don Quixote who took it and without replying began to run his eye over it but he presently returned it saying and the little I have seen I had discovered three things in this author that deserved to be censured the first is some words that I have read in the parentis the next that the language is arrogant ease for sometimes he writes without articles and the third which above all stems him as ignorant is that he goes wrong and departs from the truth in the most important part of the history for here he says that my squire Sancho pons his wife is called mati Gutierrez when she has had nothing of the sort but Teresa Ponza and when a man airs on such an important point as this there is good reason to fear that he is in error on every other point in the history a nice sort of historian indeed exclaimed Sancho with this he must know a deal about our affairs when he calls my wife Teresa Ponza Marti Gutierrez take the book again Senor and see if I am in and if he has changed my name from your top friend said Don Jeronimo no doubt you are Sancho Panza signore Don Quixote Squire yes I am said Sancho and I'm proud of it Phaethon said the gentleman this new author does not handle you with the decency that displays itself in your person he makes you add a heavy feeder in a fool and not in the least role and a very different being from the Sun to describe in the first part of your masters history God forgive him said Sancho he might have left me in my corner without troubling his head about me that hen who knows how ring the bells st. Peter is very well in Rome the two gentlemen pressed Don Quixote to come into their room and have supper with them as they knew very well there was nothing in that end fit for one of his sort Don Quixote who was always polite yielded to their request and supped with them sanchez stayed behind with the stew and invested with plenary delegated authority seated himself at the head of the table and the landlord sat down with him for he was no less fond of cow Hill and calves feet then Sancho was well at supper Dunhuang asked Don Quixote what news he had of the lady Dulcinea del Toboso what she married had she been brought to bed or was she with child or did she in maidenhood still preserving her modesty and delicacy cherished the remembrance of the tender passion ascender Don Quixote to this he replied Dulcinea is a maiden still in my passion more firmly rooted than ever our intercourse unsatisfactory as before and her beauty transformed into that of a foul country wench and then he proceeded to give them a full and particular account of the Enchantment of Dulcinea and of what had happened him in the cave of Montesinos together with what the sage Merlin had prescribed for her disenchantment namely the scourging of Sancho exceedingly great was the amusement the two gentlemen derived from hearing Don Quixote recount the strange incidents of his history and if they were amazed by his absurd they were equally amazed by the elegant style in which he delivered them on the one hand they regarded him as a man of wit and sense and on the other he seemed to them am on during blockhead and they could not make up their minds whereabouts between wisdom and folly they ought to place them sancho having finished his supper and left the landlord in the X condition repaired to the room where his master was and as he came in said may I die sirs if the author of this book your worships have got has any mind that we should agree as he calls me glutton according to what your worship say I wish he may not call me drunkard - but he does said Don Harron mo I cannot remember however in what way though I know his words are offensive and what is more lying as I can see plainly by the physiognomies of the worthy Sancho before me believe me said Sancho the Sancho and the Don Quixote of this history must be different persons from those that appear in the one seat hum at Benin gely wrote who are ourselves my master valiant wise and true and loved and I simple droll and neither glutton nor drunkard I believe it said Don Juan and were it possible an order should be issued that no one should have the presumption to deal with anything relating to Don Quixote save his original author seat Hamed just as Alexander commanded that no one should presume to paint his portrait save up LA's let him who will paint me sub Don Quixote but let him not abuse me for patients will often break down when they heap insults upon it none can be offered to send your Don Quixote said Don Juan that he himself will not be able to avenge if he does not ward it off with his shield of his patients which I take it his great and strong a considerable portion of the night passed in conversation of this sort and though Don Horn wish Don Quixote to read more of the book to see what it was all about he was not to be prevailed upon saying that he treated it as read and pronounced it utterly silly and if by any chance it should come to its author's ears that he in his hand he did not want him to flatter himself with the idea that he had read it for our thoughts and still more our eyes should keep themselves aloof from what is obscene and filthy they asked him whether he meant to direct his steps he replied to sorrow goose' to take part in the harness joust which were held in that city every year Don Juan told him that the new history described how Don Quixote let him be who he might 2-part there in a tilting at the ring utterly devoid of invention poor and Matos very poor in costume though rich in silliness --is for that very reason said Don Quixote I will not set foot in sorry Gaza and by that means I shall expose to the world the lie of this new history writer and people will see that I am not the Don Quixote he speaks of he will do quite rites at dunharrow no mo and there are other jokes at Barcelona in which senior Don Quixote may display his prowess that is what I mean to do said Don Quixote and as it is now time I pray your worships to give me leave to retire to bed and to place and retain me among the number of your greatest friends and servants and me too said Sancho maybe I'll be good for something with this they exchanged farewells and Don Quixote and Sancho retired to their room leaving Don Juan and Don Harron Omo amazed to see the medley he made of his good sense and his craziness and they felt thoroughly convinced that these and not those their arrogance author described where the genuine Don Quixote and Sancho Don Quixote rose betimes and bade adieu to his host by knocking at the partition of the other room Sancho paid the landlord magnificently and recommended him either to say less about the providing of his Inn or to keep it better provided end of volume 2 part 2 chapter 59 recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine two part two chapters 60 of the ingenious gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra translated by John Ormsby 1829 to 1895 this LibriVox recording is in the public domain recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume two part two chapter sixty of what happened to Don Quixote on his way to Barcelona it was a fresh morning giving promise of a cool day as Don Quixote quitted the inn first of all taking care to ascertain the most direct road to Barcelona without touching upon Saragosa so anxious was he to make out this new historian who they said abused him so to be a liar well as it fell out nothing worthy of being recorded happened him for six days at the end of which having turned aside out of the road he was overtaken by night in a thicket of oak or cork trees from this point seed hum 'it is not as precise as he usually is on other matters master and man dismounted from their beasts and as soon as they had settled themselves at the foot of the trees Sancho who had had a good noontide meal that day let himself without more ado past the gates of sleep but Don Quixote whom his thoughts far more than hunger kept awake could not close an eye and roamed in fancy to and fro through all sorts of places at one moment it seemed to him that he was in the cave of Montesinos and sad Dulcinea transformed into a country wench skipping and mounting upon her she asks again that the words of the sage Mullen were sounding in his ears setting forth the conditions to be observed and the exertions to be made for the disenchantment of Dulcinea he lost all patience when he considered the laziness and want of charity of his squire sancho for to the best of his belief he had only given himself five lashes a number poultry and disproportion to the vast number required at this thought he felt such vexation and anger that he reasoned the matter thus if Alexander the Great cut the Gordian not saying to cut comes to the same thing as to untie and yet did not fail to become Lord paramount of all Asia neither more nor less could happen now and Dulcinea is disenchantment if i skirt Sancho against his will for if it is the condition of the remedy that Sancho shall receive three thousand and odd lashes what does it matter to me whether he inflicts them himself or someone else inflicts them when the essential point is that he receives them let them come from whatever quarter they may with this idea he went over to Sancho having first taking the reson antes reins and arranged them so as to be able to flog him with them and begin to untie the points the common belief is he had but one in front by which his britches were held up but the instant he approached him Sancho woke up in his full senses and cried out what is this who is touching me and untrusting me it is I said Don Quixote and I come to make good thy Shore Cummings and relieve my own distresses I come to whip thee Sancho and wipe off some portion of the debt thou hast undertaken Dulcinea is perishing thou art living on regardless I am dying of Hope deferred therefore untrusted will for mine it is here in this retired spot to give thee at least two thousand lashes not a bit of it said Sancho let your worship keep quiet or else by the Living God the Deaf shall hear us the lashes I pledged myself to must be voluntary and not forced upon me and just now I have no fancy to whip myself it is enough if I give you my word to flog and flap myself when I have a mind it will not do to leave it to thy courtesy Sancho said Don Quixote for thou art heart of heart and though a clown tender a flesh and at the same time he strove and struggled to untie him seeing this Sancho got up and grappling with his master he gripped him with all his might in his arms giving him a trip with the heels stretched him on the ground his back and pressing his right knee on his chest held his hands in his own so that he could neither move nor breathe how now traitor exclaim don quixote a dust thou revolt against thy master and natural lord dust I'll rise against him who gives thee his bread I neither put down King nor set up King said Sancho I only stand up for myself who and my own Lord if your worship promises me to be quiet and not to offer to whip me now I'll let you go free and unhindered if not traitor and Dona Sanchez fo that die astana spot Don Quixote gave his promise and swore by the life of his thoughts not to touch so much as a hair of his garments and to leave him entirely free and to his own discretion to whip himself whenever he pleased Sancho rose and removed some distance from the spot but as he was about to place himself leaning against another tree he felt something touch his head and putting up his hands and countered somebody's two feet with shoes and stockings on them he trembled with fear and made for another tree where the very same thing happened to him and he fell a shouting calling upon Don Quixote to come and protect him Don Quixote did so and asked him what had happened to him and what he was afraid of Sancho replied that all the trees were full of men's feet and legs Don Quixote felt them and guessed at once what it was and said to Sancho that has nothing to be afraid of for these feet and legs that thou failest but canst not see belong no debt to some outlaws and freebooters that had been hanged on these trees for the authorities in these parts are want to hang them up by 20s and 30s when they catch them whereby I conjecture that I must be near Barcelona and it was in fact as he supposed with the first light they looked up and saw that the fruit hanging on those trees were freebooters bodies and now day dawned and if the dead freebooters had scared them their hearts were no less troubled by upwards of forty living ones who all of a sudden surrounded them and in the Catalan tongue bade them stand in wait until their captain came up Don Quixote was on foot with his horse unbridled in his Lance leaning against a tree and did short completely defenseless he thought it best therefore to fold his arms and bow his head and reserve himself for a more favorable occasion in opportunity the robbers made haste to searched Apple and did not leave him a single thing of all he carried in the ALF for house and in the valise and lucky it was for Sancho that the Dukes crowns and those he brought from home were in a girdle that he wore around him but for all that these good folk would have stripped him and even looked to see what he had hidden between the skin and flesh but for the arrival at that moment of their captain it was about 34 years of age apparently strongly built above the middle height of stern aspect and swarthy complexion he was mounted upon a powerful horse and had on a coat of mail with four of the pistols they call petrol nails in that country at his waist he saw that his Squires for so they called those who follow that trade were about to rifle Sancho Panza but he ordered them to desist and was at once obeyed so the girdle escaped he wondered to see the Lance leaning against the tree the shield on the ground and Don Quixote in armor and dejected with the saddest and most melancholy face that sadness itself could produce and going up to him he said be not so cast down good man but you have not fallen into the hands of any inhuman boo Cirrus but into Rock again arts which are more merciful than cruel because of my dejection returned Don Quixote is not that I have fallen into thy hands of valiant ROK whose fame is bounded by no limits on earth but that my carelessness should have been so great that thy soul Jers should have caught me unbridled when it is my duty according to the rule of Knight errantry which I professed to be always on the alert and at all times my own Sentinel but let me tell thee great ok as they found me on my horse with my lance and shield it would not have been very easy for them to reduce me to submission for I am Don Quixote of La Mancha he who hath filled the whole world with his achievements Roka Gein are at once perceived that don quijote x' weakness was more akin to madness than to swagger though he had sometimes heard him spoken of he never regarded the things attributed to him as true nor could he persuade himself as such a humor could become dominant in art of men he was extremely glad therefore to meet him and test at close quarters what he had heard of him at a distance so he said to him despair not valiant night no regard as an untoward fate the position in which they'll find us thyself it may be that by these slips like crooked fortune will make itself straight for heaven by strange circuitous ways mysterious and incomprehensible to man raises up the Fallen and makes rich the poor Don Quixote was about to thank him when they heard behind them and noise as of a troop of horses there was however but one riding on which at a furious pace came a youth apparently about twenty years of age clad in green damask edged with gold and breeches and a loose frock for the hat looped up in the volume fashioned tight-fitting polished boots gilt Spurs dagger and sword and in his hand a musketoon and a pair of pistols at his waist Roque turned round at the noise and perceived this comely figure which drawing near thus addressed him I come in quest of the valiant or ok to find in thee if not a remedy at least relief in my misfortune and not to keep the in suspense for I see thou does not recognize me I will tell me who I am I am Claudia harinama the daughter of c mon forte thy good friend and special enemy of cloacal to reyes who is thine also as being of the faction opposed to thee thou knowest at this to Reyes has a son who is called or at least was not to our sins Don Vicente Torres well to cut short the tale of my misfortune I will tell thee in a few words what this youth has brought upon me he saw me he paid court to me I listened to him and unknown to my father I loved him for there is no woman however secluded she may live or close she may be kept who will not have opportune and to spare for following her headlong impulses in a word he pledged himself to be mine and I promise to be his without carrying matters any further yesterday I learned that forgetful of his pledge to me he was about to marry another and that he was to go this morning to plight his truth intelligence which overwhelmed and exasperated me my father not being at home I was able to adopt this costume you see and urging my horse to speed I overtook Don Vicente about a league from this and without waiting to utter reproaches or hear excuses I fired this musket at him and these two pistols besides and to the best of my belief I must have lodged more than two bullets in his body opening doors to let my honor go free enveloped in his blood I left him there in the hands of his servants who did not dare and were not able to interfere in his defense and I come to seek from thee a safe conduct into France where I have relatives with whom I can live and also to implore thee to protect my father so that Don Vicente zni muris kinsman may not venture to wreak their lawless vengeance upon him Roque filled with admiration at the gallant bearing high spirit comely figure and adventure of the fair Claudia said to her come Senora let us go and see if thy enemy is dead and then we will consider what will be best for thee Don Quixote who had been listening to what Claudia said and Roque Gein art said in reply to her exclaimed nobody need trouble himself with the defense of this lady for I take it upon myself give me my horse and arms and wait for me here I will go in quest of this Knight and dead or alive I will make him keep his word plighted to so great beauty nobody need have any doubt about that said Sancho from my master has a very happy knack of matchmaking it's not many days since he forced another man to marry though in the same way backed out of his promise to another maiden and if it had not been for his persecutors The Enchantress changing the man's proper shape into a lackeys the said maiden would not be one this minute Roque who was paying more attention to the fair Claudia's adventure than to the words of master or did not hear them in ordering his Squires to restore to Sancho everything they had stripped dapple of he directed them to return to the place where they had been quartered during the night and then set off a Claudia at full speed in search of the wounded or slain Don Vicente they reached the spot where Claudia met him but found nothing there say freshly spilt blood looking all around however they described some people on the slope of a hill above them and concluded as indeed it proved to be that it was Don Vicente whom either dead or alive his servants were removing to attend to his wounds or to bury him they made haste to overtake them which as the party moved slowly they were able to do with ease they found Don Vicente in the arms of his servants whom he was entreating in a broken feeble voice to leave him there to die as the pain of his wounds would not suffer him to go any farther Claudia and Roque threw themselves off their horses in advance towards him the servants were over awed by the appearance of Roque and Claudia was moved by the sight of Don Vicente and going up to him half tenderly half sternly she seized his hand and said to him had style given me this according to our compact thou hadst never come to this pass the wounded gentleman opened his all but closed eyes and recognising Claudia said I see clearly fair and mistaken lady that it is vow that has slain me a punishment not merited or deserved by my feelings towards thee for never did I mean to nor could i wronged be in thought or deed it is not true then said Claudia that thou wert going this morning to marry Leonor ax the daughter of the rich bavastro assuredly not replied Don Quixote my cruel fortune must have carried those tidings to thee to drive the indigestible if thou wilt I have no better satisfaction to offer thee for the wrong thou fanciest thou has received from me Claudia wrung his hands and her own heart was so wrong that she lay fainting on the bleeding breast of Don Cente who made death spasm sees the same instant Roque was in perplexity and knew not what to do the servants ran to fetch water to sprinkle their faces and brought some and bathed them with it Claudia recovered from her fainting fit but not so dumb vicente from the paroxysm that had overtaken him for his life had come to an end on perceiving this Claudia when she had convinced herself that her beloved husband was no more rent the air with her size and made the heavens ring with her lamentations she tore her hair and scattered it to the winds she beat her face with her hands and showed all the signs of grief and sorrow that could be conceived to come from an afflicted heart cruel reckless woman she cried how easily worth thou moved to carry out a thought so wicked a furious force of jealousy - what desperate links dust thou lead those that give thee lodging in their bosoms o a husband whose unhappy fate and being mine hath borne thee from the marriage bed to the grave so vehement and so piteous were the lamentations of Claudia that they drew tears from Rocky's eyes unused as they were to shed them on any occasion the servants wept Claudius swooned away again and again and the whole place seemed to feel the sorrow and an abode of misfortune in the end broke again art-directed don vicente servants to carry his body to his father's village which was close by for burial Claudia told him she meant to go to a monastery of which an aunt of hers was Abbess where she intended to pass her life with a better and everlasting spouse he applauded her pious resolution and offered to accompany her whithersoever she wished and to protect her father against the kinsman of Don Vicente and all the world should they seek to injure him Claudia would not on any account allow him to accompany her and thanking him for his offers as well as she could took leave of him in tears the servants had done Vicente carried away his body and Roque returned to his comrades and so ended the love a Claudia her anima but what wonder when it was the insuperable and cruel might of jealousy that wove the web of her sad story roque guinart found his Squires at the place to which he had ordered them and Don Quixote anew Rocinante in the midst of them delivering a harangue to them in which he urged them to give up a mode of life so full of peril as well to the soul as to the body but as most of them were gas guns rough lawless fellows his speech did not make much impression on them rokay on coming up as Sancho if his men had returned and restored to them the treasures and jewels they had stripped off dapple such as said they had but that three kircheis that were worth three cities were missing what are you talking about man said one of the bystanders I had Gotham and they are not worth three rails that is true said Don Quixote but my Squire values them at the rate he says has having been given me by the person who gave them roque guinart ordered them to be restored at once and making his men fallen in line he directed all the clothing jewelry and money that they had taken since the last distribution to be produced and making a hasty valuation and reducing what could not be divided into money he made shares for the whole band so equitably and carefully that in no case did he exceed or fall short of strict distributive justice when this had been done and all left satisfied rokay observed to Don Quixote if this scrupulous exactness were not observed with these fellows there would be no living with them upon this Sancho remark from what I have seen here justice is such a good thing that there is no doing without it even among the thieves themselves one of the Squires heard this and raising the butt end of his hark a bus would no doubt have broken Sancho's head with it had not wrote Kagan art called out to him to hold his hand Sancho was frightened out of his wits and vowed not to open his lip so long as he was in the company of these people at this instant one or two of those Squires who were posted as sentinels on the roads to watch who came along them and report what passed to their chief came up and said send there is a great troop of people not far off coming along the road to Barcelona to which her okay replied has them made out whether they are of the sort there are after us or of the sort we are after the sort we are after said the squire well then away with you also okay and bring them here to me at once without letting one of them escape they obeyed in Don Quixote Sancho and Roque left by themselves waited to see what the Squires brought and while they were waiting Roque said to Don Quixote it must seem a strange sort of life to send your Don Quixote this of ours strange adventures strange incidents and all full of danger and I do not wonder that it should seem so foreign truth I must own there is no mode of life more Restless or anxious than ours what led me into it was a certain thirst for vengeance which is strong enough to disturb the quietest hearts I am by nature tender-hearted and kindly but as I said the desire to revenge myself for a wrong that was done me so overturns all my better impulses that I keep on in this way of life in spite of what conscience tells me and as one depth calls to another and one sin to another sin revenge's have linked themselves together and I've taken upon myself not only my own but those of others it pleases God however that though I see myself in this maze of entanglements I do not lose all hope of escaping from it and reaching a safe port Don Quixote was amazed to hear ok utter such excellent and just sentiments but he did not think that among those who followed such trades as robbing murdering and waylaying there could be anyone capable of a virtuous thought and he said in reply soon you are ok the beginning of health lies in knowing the disease and in the sick man's willingness to take the medicines which is physician prescribes you are sick you know what ails you in heaven or more properly speaking God who is our physician will administer medicines that will cure you and cure gradually and not of a sudden were by a miracle besides sinners of discernment are nearer amendment and those who are fools and your worship has shown good sense in your remarks all you have to do is to keep up a good heart and trust that the weakness of your conscience will be strengthened and if you have any desire to shorten the journey and put yourself easily in the way of salvation come with me and I will show you how to become a knight-errant a calling we're in so many hardships and mishaps are encountered that if they'd be taken as penances they will Lodge you in heaven in a trice Roque laughed at don quixote is exhortation and changing the conversation he'd related the tragic affair a claudia harinama at which Sancha was extremely grieved for he had not found the young woman's beauty boldness and spirit at all a mess and now the Squires dispatched to make the prize came up bringing with them two gentlemen on horseback two pilgrims on foot and a coach full of women with some six servants on foot and on horseback in attendance on them and a couple of Byul tears whom the gentleman had with them the Squires made a ring random both Victor's and vanquished maintaining profound silence waiting for the great roque guinart to speak yes the gentlemen who they were whither they were going and what money they carried with them signora replied one of them we are two captains of Spanish infantry our companies are at Naples and we are on our way to embark in four galleys which they say are at Barcelona under orders for Sicily and we have about two or three hundred crowns with which we are according to our notions rich and contented for a soldier's poverty does not allow a more extensive horde rokay asks the pilgrims the same questions he had put to the captains and was answered that they were going to take ship for Rome and that between them they might have about sixty reals he asked also who was in the coach whither they were bound and what money they had and one of the men on horseback replied the persons in the coach are male ad-dunya Guillaume our de quinones wife of the region of the Vick area at Naples her little daughter a handmaid and a duenna we six servants are in attendance upon her and the money amounts to six hundred crowns so then silk again are we here 900 crowns and 60 rails my soldiers must number some 60 see how much their Falls to eat for I am a bad arithmetician as soon as the robbers heard this they raised a shout of long life to work again art in spite of the odd raised to seek his ruin the captain showed plainly they concerned they felt the region's lady was downcast and the pilgrims did not at all enjoy seeing their property confiscated rokay kept them in suspense in this way for a while but he had no desire to prolong their distress which might be seen a bow shot off and turning to the captains he said sirs well your worships be pleased of your courtesy to lend me sixty crowns and her ladyship the Regents wife eighty to satisfy this band that follows me for it is by his singing the abbot gets his dinner and then you may at once proceeded on your journey free and unhindered with a safe conduct which I shall give you so that if you come across any other bands of mine that I have scattered in these parts they may do you no harm for I had no intention of doing injury to soldiers or to any woman especially one of quality profuse and hearty were the expressions of gratitude with which the captain's thanked her okay for his courtesy and generosity for such they regarded his leaving them their own money signora Dona Gilmar de quinones wanted to throw herself out of the coach to kiss the feet in hands of the greater okay but he would not suffer it on any account so far from that he begged her pardon for the wrong he had done her under pressure of the inexorable necessities of his unfortunate calling the Regents lady ordered one of her servants to give the 80 crowns that had been assessed as her share at once for the captain's had already paid down their 60 the pilgrims were about to give up the whole of their little hoard but okay bade them keep quiet and turning to his men he said of these crowns too full to each man and twenty remain over that ten be given to these pilgrims and the other ten to this worthy Squire that he may be able to speak favorably of this adventure and then having writing materials with which he always went provided brought to him he gave them in writing a safe conduct to the leaders of his bands and bidding them farewell let them go free and filled with admiration at his magnanimity his generous disposition and his unusual conduct and inclined to regard him as an Alexander the Great rather than a notorious robber one of the Squires observed in his mixture of Gascon and Catalan this captain of our routes would make a better friar than highwayman if he wants to be so generous another time let it be with his own property and not ours the unlucky Wight did not speak so low but that Roque overheard him and drawing his sword almost split his head into saying that is the way I punish impudent saucy fellows they were all taken aback and not one of them dared to utter a word such deference did they pay him rokay then withdrew to one side and where the letter to a friend of his at Barcelona telling him that the famous Don Quixote of La Mancha the knight errant of whom there was so much talk was with him and was he assured him the draw list and wisest man in the world and that in four days from that date that is to say on st. John the Baptist day he was going to deposit him in full armor mounted on his horse Rocinante together with his squire sancho on an ass in the middle of the Strand of the city and bidding him give notice of this to his friends than Jaros that they might divert themselves with him he wished he said his enemies that Cadell could be deprived of this pleasure but that was impossible because the crazes and shrewd sayings of Don Quixote and the humors of his squire sancho panza could not help giving general pleasure to all the world he dispatched the letter by one of his Squires who exchanging the costume of a highwayman for that of a peasant made his way into Barcelona and gave it to the person to whom it was directed end of vol 2 part 2 chapter 60 recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine Volume two part two chapter 61 of the ingenious gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra translated by John Ormsby 1829 to 1895 this LibriVox recording is in the public domain recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume 2 part 2 chapter 61 and what happened to Don Quixote on entering Barcelona together with other matters that partake of the true rather than of the ingenious Don Quixote passed three days and three nights with her ok and had he passed 300 years he would offend enough to observe in wonder--i in his mode of life at daybreak they were in one spot at dinnertime in another sometimes they fled without knowing from whom at other times they lay in wait not knowing for what they slept standing breaking their slumbers to shift from place to place there was nothing but sending out spies and Scouts posting sentinels and blowing the matches of our cabooses though they carried but few were almost all used flintlocks Roque passed his nights in some place or other apart from his men that they might not know where he was for the many proclamations the Viceroy of Barcelona had issued against his life kept him in fear and uneasiness and he did not venture to trust anyone afraid that even his own men would kill him or deliver him up to the authorities of a truth a weary miserable life at length by unfrequented roads shortcuts and secret paths broke a Don Quixote and Sancho together with six Squires set out for Barcelona they reached the Strand on st. John's Eve during the night in ok after embracing Don Quixote and Sancho to whom he presented the ten crowns he had promised but had not until then given left them with many expressions of goodwill on both sides Roque went back while Don Quixote remained on horseback just as he was waiting for day and it was not long before the countenance of the fair Aurora began to show itself at the balconies of the East gladdening the ground and flowers if not the ear but to gladden that to their came at the same moment a sound of Clarion's and drums and a din of bells and a [ __ ] [ __ ] and cries of clear the way there of some runners that seem to issue from the city the dawn made way for the Sun that with a face broader than a buckler began to rise slowly above the low line of the horizon Don Quixote and Sancho gazed all around them they beheld the sea a sight until then unseen by them it struck him as exceedingly spacious and broad much more so than the lakes of Rua Dara which they had seen in La Mancha they saw the galleys along the beach which lowering their awnings displayed themselves decked with streamers and pennons that trembled in the breeze and kissed and swept the water while on board the bugles trumpets and Clarion's were sounding and filling the air far and near with melodious warlike notes then they began to move and execute a kind of skirmish upon the calm water while a vast number of horsemen on fine horses and in showy liveries issuing from the city engaged on their side in a somewhat similar movement the soldiers on board the galleys kept up a ceaseless fire which they and the roles and forts of the city returned and the heavy cannon rent the air with the tremendous noise they made to which the gangway guns of the galleys replied the bright see the smiling earth the clear air there at times darkened by the smoke of the guns all seemed to fill the whole multitude with unexpected delight Sancho could not make out how it was that those great masses that moved over the sea had so many feet and now the horsemen in livery came galloping up with shouts and outlandish cries and cheers to where Don Quixote stood amazed and wandering and one of them he to whom Roque had sent word addressing him exclaimed welcome to our city mirror beacon star and sign assure of all night errand tree in its widest extent welcome I say valiant Don Quixote of La Mancha not the false the fictitious the apocryphal that these latter days have offered us in lying histories but the true the lid the rule one the seed hum at Benin gely flower of historians has described to us Don Quixote made no answer nor did the horseman wait for one but wheeling again with all their followers they began curvetting round Don Quixote who turning to Sancho said these gentlemen have plainly recognized us I will wager they have read our history and even that newly printed one by the Aragonese the Cavalier who would address Don Quixote again approached him and said come with us Senor Don Quixote for we are all of us your servants and great friends of Roca Gein arts to which Don Quixote return if courtesy breeds courtesy yours sir Knight is daughter or very nearly akin to the great or okays carrying me where you please I will have no will but yours especially if you deign to employ it in your service the Cavalier replied with words no less polite and then all closing in around him they set out with him for the city to the music of the Clarion's in the drums as they were entering it the wicked one who is the author of all mischief and the boys while wickeder than the wicked one contrived that a couple of these audacious irrepressible urge ins should force their way through the crowd and lifting up one of them dapples tale and the other arrests in Nantes insert a bunch of firs under each the poor beasts felt the strange Spurs and added to their anguish by pressing their tails tight so much so that cutting a multitude of capers they flung their masters to the ground Don Quixote covered with shame and out of countenance ran to pluck the plume from his poor Jade's tail while Sancho did the same for dapple his conductors tried to punish the audacity of the boys but there was no possibility of doing so for they hid themselves among the hundreds of others that were following them Don Quixote and Sancho mounted once more and with the same music and acclamation 'he's reached their conductors house which was large and stately that of a rich gentleman in short and therefore the present we will leave them for such as seed humus pleasure and the volume - Part two chapter 61 recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume 2 part 2 chapter 62 of the ingenious gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra translated by John Ormsby 1829 to 1895 this LibriVox recording is in the public domain recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine volume 2 part 2 chapter 62 which deals with the adventure of the enchanted head together with other trivial matters which cannot be left untold Don Quixote host was one done Antonio Moreno by name a gentleman of wealth and intelligence and very fond of diverting himself in any fair and good-natured way and having Don Quixote in his house he said about devising modes of making him exhibit his mad points in some harmless fashion for just that give pain or no Jes and no sport is worth anything if it hurts another the first thing he did was to make Don Quixote take off his armor and lead him in that tight chinois suit we have already described and depicted more than once art on a balcony overhanging one of the Chiefs streets of the city in full view of the crowds and of the boys who gazed at him as they would at a monkey the Cavaliers in livery careered before him again as though it were for him alone and not to enliven the festival of the day that they wore it and Sancho was in high delight where it seemed to him that how he knew not he'd fallen upon another Camacho's wedding under their house flag Don Diego de Miranda's another castle like the Dukes some have Don Antonio's friends dined with him that day and all the shared honor to Don Quixote and treated him as a knight-errant and he becoming puffed up and exalted in consequence could not contain himself for satisfaction such were the droll Ariza of Sancho that are the servants of the house and all who heard him were kept hanging upon his lip we're at Abel done Antonio said to him we hear worthy Sancho that you are so fond of menhir Blanco enforced meatballs that if you have any left you keep them in your bosom for the next day no sin you are that's not true said Sancho for I am more cleanly than greedy in my master Don Quixote here knows well that we too are used to live for a week on a handful of acorns or nuts to be sure if it so happens that they offer me a heifer I run with a halter I mean I eat what I'm given and make use of opportunities as I find them but whoever says that I'm in out of the way eater or not cleanly let me tell him that he is wrong and I'd put it in a different way if I did not respect the honorable beards that are at the table indeed said Don Quixote Sancho's moderation and cleanliness in eating might be inscribed engraved on plates of brass to be kept an eternal remembrance and ages to come it is true that when he is hungry there is a certain appearance of veracity about him for he eats at a great pace and chews with both jaws but cleanliness he is always mindful of and when he was governor he learned how to eat daintily so much so that he eats grapes and even pomegranate pips with a fork what said Don Antonio the sonship in a governor I said Sancho and of an island called Barataria I governed it to perfection for ten days and lost my rest all the time and learned to look down upon all the government's in the world I get out of it by taking to flight and fell into a pit where I gave myself up for dead and out of which I escaped alive by a miracle Don Quixote then gave them a minut account of the whole affair of Sancho's government with which he greatly amused his hearers on the cloth being removed Don Antonio taking Don Quixote by the hand passed with him into a distant room in which there was nothing in the way of furniture except a table apparently of Jasper resting on a pedestal of the same upon which was set up after the fashion of the busts of the Roman emperors a head which seemed to be a bronze Don Antonio traverse a whole apartment with Don Quixote and walked around the table several times and then said now signore Don Quixote that I am satisfied that no one is listening to us and that the door is shut I will tell you of one of the rarest adventures or more properly speaking strange things that can be imagined unconditioned that you will keep what I say to you in the remotest recesses of secrecy I swear it said Don Quixote and for greater security I will put a flagstone over it for I would have you know signore Don Antonio goodbye this time learned his name that you are addressing one who though he has ears to hear as no tongue to speak so that you may safely transfer whatever you have in your bosom into mine and rely upon it that you have consigned it to the depths of silence in reliance upon that promise that Don Antonio I will astonish you with what you shall see and hear and relieve myself of some of the vexation it gives me to have no one to whom I can confide my secrets for there are not of a sort to be entrusted to everybody Don Quixote was puzzled wondering what could be the object of such precautions whereupon Don Antonio taking his hand passed it over the bronze head in the whole table and the pedestal of Jasper on which it stood and then said this head Senor Don Quixote has been made and fabricated by one of the greatest magicians and Wizards the world ever saw a pole I believe by birth and a pupil of the famous escutia of whom such marvelous stories are told he was here in my house and for a consideration of a thousand crowns that I gave him he constructed this head which has the property in virtue of answering whatever questions are put to its ear he observed the points of the compass he traced figures he studied the Stars he watched favorable moments and at length brought it to the perfection we shall see tomorrow for on Fridays it is mute in this being Friday we must wait till the next day in the interval your worship may consider what you would like to ask it and I know by experience that in all its answers that tells the truth Don Quixote was amazed at the virtue and property of the head and was inclined to disbelieve Don Antonio but seeing what a short time he had to wait to test the matter he did not choose to say anything except that he thanked him for having revealed to him so mighty a secret they then quitted the room done Antonio locked the door and they repaired to the chamber where the rest of the gentlemen were assembled in the meantime Sancho had recounted to them several of the adventures and accidents that had happened to his master that afternoon they took Don Quixote out for a stroll now in his armor but in street costume with the Sirk out of tawny cloth upon him but if that season would have made ice itself sweat orders were left with the servants to entertain Sancho so as not to let him leave the house Don Quixote was mounted non-person untied but upon a tall mule of easy pace and handsomely caparison they put the Sur coat on him and on the back without his perceiving it they stitched a parchment on which they wrote in large letters this is Don Quixote of La Mancha Don Quixote was amazed to see how many people gazed at him called him by his name and recognized him and turning to Don Antonio who wrote at his side he observed to him great are the privileges Knight errantry involves for it makes him who professes it known and famous in every region of the earth see Don Antonio even the very boys of the city know me without ever having seen me true signore Don Quixote returned Don Antonio where as fire cannot be hidden or kept secret virtue cannot escape being recognized and that which is attained by the profession of arms shines distinguished above all others it came to pass however that as Don Quixote was proceeding amid the acclamations that had been described a Castilian reading the inscription on his back cried out in a loud voice the devil take thee for a Don Quixote of La Mancha what art thou here and not dead of the countless drumming's that have fallen on thy ribs dark mad and if I would sir by thy self and kept thy self within thine yes it would not be so bad but thou has the gift of making fools and Blockheads of all who have anything to do with thee or say to thee why look at these gentlemen bearing the company get the home blockhead and see after thy affairs and thy wife and children and give over these fuller EES that are sapping thy brains and skimming away thy wits go your own way brother said Don Antonio and don't offer advice to those who don't ask you for it some you are Don Quixote is in his full senses and we who bear him company are not fools virtue was to be honored wherever it may be found go and bad luck to you and don't meddle where you are not wanted by God your worship is right replied the Castilian but to advise this good man is to kick against the pricks still for all that it fills me with pity that the sound wit they say the blockhead has in everything should dribble away by the channel of his Knight errantry but may that bad luck you're worshipped Aqsa follow me and all my descendants if from this day for if there I should live longer than Methuselah I ever give advice to anybody even if he asked me for it the advice giver took himself off and they continued their stroll but so great was the press of the boys and people to read the placard that Don Antonio was forced to remove it as if he were taking off something else night came and they went home and there was a ladies dancing party for done Antonio's wife a lady of rank and gaiety beauty and wit that invited some friends of hers to come and do honor to her guests and amuse themselves with his strange delusions several of them came they supped sumptuously the dance began at about 10 o'clock among the ladies were two of a mischievous and frolicsome turn and they're perfectly modest somewhat free and playing tricks for harmless diversions sake these two were so indefinite able in taking Don Quixote out to dance that they tired him down not only in body but in spirit it was a sight to see the figure Don Quixote made long length lean and yellow his garment clinging tight to him ungainly and of all anything but agile the gay ladies made secret love to him and he on his part secretly repelled them but finding himself hard pressed by their blandishments he lifted up his voice and exclaimed forget a pirate tales adverse I leave me in peace unwelcome overtures event with your desires ladies for she who is queen of mine the peerless Dyson Ayodele to bow so suffers none but hers to lead me captive and subdue me and so saying he sat down on the floor in the middle of the room tired out and broken down by all this exertion of the dance then Antonio directed him to be taken up bodily and carried to bed and the first that laid hold of him was Sancho saying as he did so in an evil hour you took to Denson mastermind do you fancy all mighty men of valor our dancers and all Knights aren't given to capering if you do I can tell you you were mistaken but many a man would rather undertake to kill a giant than cut a caper if it had been the shoe fling you were at I could take your place for I can do the shoe fling like a jerk Alcon but I'm no good at Dancing with these and other observations Sancho set the whole ballroom laughing and then put his master to bed covering him up well so that he might sweat out any chill caught after his dancing the next day Don Antonio thought he might as well make trial of the enchanted head and badonk hijo de Sancho and two others friends of his besides the two ladies who had tired out Don Quixote at the ball would remain for the night with Don Antonio's wife he locked himself up in the chamber where the head was he explained to them the property it possessed and entrusted the secret to them telling them that now for the first time he was going to try the virtue of the enchanted head but except Don Antonio's two friends no one else was privy to the mystery of the enchantment and if Don Antonio had not first revealed it to them they would have been inevitably reduced to the same state of amazement as the rest so artfully and skilfully was it contrived first approached the ear of the head was done Antonio himself and in a low voice but not so low is not to be audible to all he said to it head tell me by the virtue that lies in thee let am I at this moment thinking of the head without any movement of the lips answered in a clear and distinct voice so as to be heard by all I cannot judge a thoughts or were thunderstruck ëthis and all the more so as they saw that there was nobody anywhere near the table or in the whole room that could have answered how many of us are here as Don Antonio once more and it was answered him in the same way softly thou and thy wife with two friends of mine and two of hers and a famous Knight cut Don Quixote of La Mancha and a squire of his Sancho Panza by name now there was fresh astonishment now everyone's hair was standing on end with awe and Don Antonio retiring from the head exclaimed this suffice is to show me that I had not been deceived by him who served thee to me o sage head talking head answering head wonderful head that someone else go and put what question he likes to it and as women are commonly impulsive and inquisitive the first to come forward was one of the two friends of Don Antonio's wife and her question was tell me head what shall I do to be very beautiful and the answer she got was be very modest I questioned thee no further so the fair aquarist her companion then came up and said I should like to know head whether my husband loves me or not the answer given to her was think how he uses thee and thou mayst gasps and the married lady went off saying that answer did not need a question for of course the treatment one receives shows the disposition of him from whom it is received then one have done Antonio's two friends advanced and asked it Who am I thou knowest was the answer that is not what I asked he said the gentleman but to tell me I found knowest me yes I know thee there at Don Pedro notary is was the reply I do not seek to know more said the gentleman but this is enough to convince me o head that thou knowest everything and as he retired the other friend came forward and asked it tell me head what are the wishes of my eldest son I have said already was the answer that I cannot judge of wishes however I can tell be the wish of thy son is to bury thee that's what I see with my eyes I point out with my fingers of the gentleman so I ask no more Don Antonio's wife came up and said I know not what to ask the head I would only seek to know of thee if I shall have many years of enjoyment of my good husband and the answer she received was thou shalt for his vigor in his temperate habits promised many years of life which by their in temperance others so often cut short then Don Quixote came forward and said tell me thou that interest was that which I described as having happened to me in the cave of Montesinos the truth or a dream the Sancho is whipping the accomplish without fail with a disenchantment of Destiny abhi brought about as to the question of the cave was the reply there is much to be said there is something of both in it sanchez whipping would proceed leisurely the disenchantment of Dulcinea will attain its due consummation I seek to know no more said Don Quixote let me but see Dulcinea disenchanted and I will consider that all the good fortune I could wish for has come upon me all at once the last questioner was Sancho and his questions were head shall I by any chance have another government shall I ever escape from the hard life of a squire shall I get back to see my wife and children to which the answer came thou shalt govern in thy house and if I return us to it thou shalt see thy wife and children and unceasing to serve thou shalt cease to be a squire goodbye God said Sancho Panza I could have told myself that the prophet Pettigrew you could have said no more what answer would still have be said Don Quixote is it not enough that the replies this head has given suit the questions put to it yes it is enough said Sancho I should have liked it to have made itself plainer and told me more the questions and answers came to an end here but not the Wonder with which all were filled except done Antonio's two friends who were in the secret this seed huh Matt Ben and Gally thought fit to reveal at once not to keep the world in suspense fancying that the head had some strange magical mystery in it he says therefore that on the model of another head the work of an image maker which he had seen at Madrid Don Antonio made this one at home for his own amusement and to astonish ignorant people and its mechanism was as follows the table was of work painted and varnished to imitate Jasper and the pedestal on which it stood was of the same material with four eagle's claws projecting from it to support the weight more steadily the head which resembled a bust or figure of a Roman Emperor and was colored like bronze was hollow throughout as was the table into which it was fitted so exactly that no trace of the joining was visible the pedestal of the table was also Hollow and communicated with the throat and neck of the head and the whole was in communication with another room underneath the chamber in which the head stood through the entire cavity in the pedestal table throat and neck of the Buster figure there passed a tube of tin carefully adjusted and concealed from sight in the room below corresponding to the one above was placed the person who was to answer with his mouth to the tube and the voice as in an ear trumpet passed from above downwards and from below upwards the words coming clearly and distinctly it was impossible thus to detect the trick and nephew had done antonio's a smart sharp witted student was the answerer and as he had been told beforehand by his uncle who the persons were that would come with him that day into the chamber where the head was it was an easy matter for him to answer the first question at once and correctly the others he answered by guesswork and being clever cleverly said hum it adds that this marvelous contrivance stood for some ten or twelve days but that as it became noised abroad through the city that he had in his house an enchanted head the answered all who ask questions of it done Antonio fearing it might come to the ears of the watchful son two moles of our faith explained the matters to the inquisitors who commanded him to break it up and have done with it lest the ignorant vulgar should be scandalized by don quixote however and by Sancho the head was still held to be an enchanted one and capable of answering questions there more to Don Quijote satisfaction than son shows the gentlemen of the city to gratify Don Antonio and also to do the honors to Don Quixote and give him an opportunity of displaying his folly made arrangements for a tilting at the ring in six days from that time which however for reason that will be mentioned hereafter did not take place Don Quixote took a fancy to store about the city quietly and on foot but he feared that if he went on horseback the boys would follow him so he and Sancho and two servants that Don Antonio gave him set out for a walk thus it came to pass at going along one of the streets Don Quixote lifted up his eyes and saw written in very large letters over a door books printed here and which he was vastly pleased until then he had never seen a printing-office and he was curious to know what it was like he entered with all his following and saw them drawing sheets in one place correcting in another setting up type here revising there in short all the work that is to be seen in great printing offices he went up to one case and asked what they were about there the workman told him he watched them with wonder and passed on he approached one man among others and asked him what he was doing the workman replied senior this gentleman here pointing to a man of pre possessing appearance and a certain gravity of look has translated an Italian book into our Spanish tongue and I am setting it up in type for the press what is the title of the book asked Don Quixote to which the author replied Senor in Italian the book is called la Bagatelle and what does the Bagatelle import in our Spanish ask Don Quixote the Bagatelle said the author is as though we should say in Spanish most who hate ace but there the book is humble in name it has good solid matter in it I said Don Quixote have some little smattering Batallion and i plumed myself on singing some of arias two stanzas but tell me Senora I do not say this to test your ability but merely out of curiosity have you ever met with the word pinata in your book yes often said the author and how do you render that in Spanish how should I render it returned the author but by oh yeah body and me exclaim Don Quixote what a proficient you are in the Italian language I would lay a good wager that where they say in Italian piace you say in Spanish plus a and where they say peu you say moths and you translate su by Arriba and Hugh by Abajo I translate them so of course said the author for those are there improper equivalents I would venture to swear said Don Quixote that your worship is not known in the world which always be grudges their reward two rare wits and praiseworthy labors what talents lie wasted there what genius thrust away into corners what worth left neglected still it seems to me that translation from one language into another if it be not from the Queen's of languages the Greek in the latin is like looking at flemish tapestries on the wrong side whether the figures are visible they are full of threads that make them into state and they do not show with the smoothness and brightness of the right side and translation from easy languages argues neither ingenuity nor command of words any more than transcribing or copying out one document from another but I do not mean by this to draw the inference that no credit is to be allowed for the work of translating for a man may employ himself in ways worse and less profitable to himself this estimate does not include two famous translators dr. Cristo ba da Figueroa in his posture Phaedo in Don Juan de hired a GUI in his Aminta women by their Felicity they leave it in doubt which is the translation in which the original but tell me are you printing this book at your own risk or have you sold the copyright to some bookseller I print at my own risk said the author and I expect to make a thousand ducats at least by this first dish which is to be of two thousand copies that will go off in a twinkling at six rails apiece fine calculation you are making said Don Quixote it is plain you don't know the ins and outs of the printers and how they play into one another's hands I promise you when you find yourself saddled with two thousand copies you will feel so sore that it will astonish you particularly if the book is a little out of the common and not in any way highly spiced what said the author would your worship then have me give it to a bookseller here will give three Maariv eighties for the copyright and think he's doing me a favor I do not print my books to win fame in the world for I am known in it already by my works I want to make money without which reputation is not worth a rap God send your worship good lucks at Don Quixote and he moved on to another case where he saw them correcting a sheet of a book with the title of light of the soul noticing it he observed books like this though there are many of the kind are the ones that deserve to be printed from many are the sinners in these days and lights unnumbered are needed for all that are in darkness he passed on and so they were also correcting another book and when he asked its title they told him it was called the second pair of the ingenious gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha by one of Tordesillas I have heard of this book already said Don Quixote and verily and on my conscience I thought it had been by this time burned to ashes of the meddlesome intruder but it's Martin Maas will come to it as it does to every pig for fictions had the more merit and charm about them the more nearly they approach the truth or what looks like it and true stories the truer they are the better they are and so saying he walked out of the printing office with a certain amount of displeasure in his looks at same day Don Antonio arranged to take him to see the galleys that lay at the beach or at Sancho was in high delight as he had never seen any all his life Don Antonio sent word to the Kommandant of the galleys that he intended to bring his guest the famous Don Quixote of La Mancha a friend the Kommandant and all the citizens had already heard that afternoon to see them and what happened onboard of them will be told in the next chapter end of volume 2 part 2 chapter 62 recording by expatriate in Bangor Maine | A Good channel | UCZqECxpIF0LZb5Ylj8J_OTg | 2017-08-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 20,291 | 105,643 |
nrNrR_VIX7w | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nrNrR_VIX7w | Saalt vs Lena Sensitive Sm Squish - Menstrual Cups | this is a squish comparison between the salt cup and the less sensitive both in a size small don't forget that you can visit the link in the description below to compare this cup with other cups that I have on hand this comparison was requested by terrariums and tea thank you for sending in your requests I'm gonna place both of these cups in the pumps of my hands give them a squish swap hands give them a squish again and then compare the rims so they are different shapes and I'm going to drop the salt cup down just a little bit so that the bodies line up and here is the inside of the salt cup and inside of the Lenna sensitive inside of the Lenna sensitive and insight the salt and just the rims and that was the salt cup and the lunar sensitive both in uh size small | Red Herring | UCOabXnesf9sn4CB_1aBLV5Q | 2018-03-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 153 | 774 |
YUpAZ9JVUTQ | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUpAZ9JVUTQ | 😍CANCER! EPIC CHANGE U CANNOT AVOID! A NEW ERA STARTS! FEBRUARY 2020 CANCER Tarot Reading | right so we have cancer same moon in as well rising Montez are reading February 2020 on our hands and if any of you guys is interested in to a to get in touch with me for you for your personal reading you can check out the description down below and there you are going to find a link to my website so that being said moving into the reading straight away eight card spread and the first one here is going to show up a deep topic of your menthe cancer and that will be the page of sorts followed by the next one here which stands as the energies supporting the topic itself and that will be the ten of swords then the third card it is the challenges that you will have to overcome for the month hopefully successful here we do have the ace of swords then it is the gifts and the blessings that you can enjoy throughout the month and you should that will be the seventh of our wands afterwards it is how other people were going to see you and what kind of an impression you are going to give into your co-workers for example social circle beloved ones and so on and so forth that is to be the queen of cups then it is what is going to help are your long-term goal or in other words could be taken as what is going to improve your circumstances throughout the month we do have the knight of Pentacles follow next it is what is going to hurt your long term goals or is going to deteriorate your current circumstances that will be the ten of cups and followed next I last card here it is the guidance that Tara is offering to you throughout the month or for the month itself that will be the Wheel of Fortune all right so a little bit on the defensive side on the defensive side it is how you're gonna find yourself throughout this month of February at least according to my Tarot and let so dive right into it so first two cards here aren't describing I you was the individual or what kind of a standpoint you are to adopt food throughout the months with these two with the energies of the ten of swords and the situation itself which is the page of swords all you are going to be the situation in this particular case so according to these two cards what happens it is that the more you go into the month of February the more you are going to start say understanding or coming to an awareness awareness that I a certain things has to change either into your career or either into your marriage it certainly you have to take but say you learn the rulership over it and simply do the tough actions and take the tough calls if you will so from one kind of from that kind of a standpoint you can say that this month is going to be revolutionary for you where you are going to establish say a new era into your career and into your relationship as well but the thing is that you will not gonna or you're gonna care less for what kind of a circumstances you know your actions and your decisions are going to have some an impact upon your say current marriage or upon your current career it is because who you itself anything that you can that you can provoke throughout the month it's gonna happen to be better than what it is right now so the suffice to say here with these two cards it is that you're gonna have it enough for mmm having other people sway around for much longer and this time around you would want to have it your way incorporate into your career and into your marriage now are you should not be surprised though if I throughout the month and as you throughout the month are gonna have some sort of a quite bizarre is is the world time searching for quite bizarre ideas and concepts concept it is more accurate to be said and those concepts are not going to be unfold to a point where you can actually explain and kind of support them in any kind of am arguments now however those concepts are worth exploring but I don't know how to describe it in English here guys it's like from the milder standpoint that you are sitting for example in the month of January and in the month of December you are taking the strongest standpoint here in the month of February saying well enough is enough drawing certain lines which nobody will be able to trust pass your husband or wife you know your boyfriend I'm pretty much kind of like establishing your comfort zone it's not even a comfort zone but let's say you're your domain now this alone is to be forced upon you through most likely through a of our situations or circumstances that are gonna ring a bell within your within your head that something needs to be done in regards to your current relationship future relationship career and so on and so forth and you actually need to take the the lead here okay I'm do what it is needed if you will because the 10 of sources and energy it is exactly this escalation of of pressing need something to be to be done and whatever happens afterward happens but at least at the end of the day you would know no different than for example these cases into the into the high school where two people were liking each other okay but these two people there for one or another reason reluctant to approach each other most likely for a fear of denial from the other right but with the ten of swords that pressing needs to just explain yourself or show yourself who do what things it's it's just going to stir the things through and you're not gonna have to suffer through it any longer and at least at the end of the day you're gonna know are you gonna be with that person you're not gonna be with that person and it's kind of like it's gonna make you free so for such kind of a thing we are talking here it is that you would want to see it through one way or the other then residing in it at that particular point and having no closure whatsoever so the next one it is the challenge that you will have to overcome and that is the challenge of the ace of swords in that particular case the ace of swords here it does touches on your determination if you will and the spiritual strength how once again how determined you are to do what it's needed or to do what it takes in order to liberate yourself from the limbo that you may be finding yourself at throughout the month of February or in other words how courageous you are to put an ultimatum you have to back in the days to take the tough calls here and simply you know to confront everything you dislike into your relationship or into your career and if you don't have it your way you better not have it at all so that this is what that card it comes to and it likes recognizing the the true value of the situation as well because maybe you have signed up for something that have been promised to you and the side that promised to you something they failed to deliver and as they fail to deliver then you should not feel obliged to move on with that side but instead demand of what what have you what you have been promised and if that not come if that isn't coming around and maybe it's time for you to go okay so all that needs to be taken under consideration because challenging as well is going to be for you too how can I say recognize the reality if you will because the eights because the ace of swords is all about placing a knot your diagnosis upon the situation and reality you're finding yourself at and as a challenging card you still may be trying to deceive yourself that miraculously the things are going to improve on their own accord which they want and you simply you have to do those tough parts where you either improve them or the things either improve them under your under your pressure and are you pressuring them or they don't or they break and as they break you just move on so it's kind of like a culmination that we do have here for throughout this month for your cancer where you either make it or you either break it career-wise or relationship-wise and literally in any field of your life the next one it is the blessings that you are to enjoy throughout the month and that is the inner strenght you are going to have with the seven of ones you're going to be much stronger if you will spiritually and if you will resourceful nurse as well from the rest that it is around you and you definitely will have I would say the power to to force your ways through with with that car additionally to that as a gifts and blessings the seven of the seven of ones is about that nobody nobody will try to do anything nefarious or surreptitious behind your back okay so there won't be any kind of like hidden moves that you have to worry about traps that you are gonna have to worry about moving forward into the future as well so everything is going to be cleared in front of you and you know what your standing against knew pretty much gonna know as well you know what is in stake there but once again it is for the reading it's not all about what is it what is at stake but also it is all about what you're gonna left with once you know the cards are played on the table and even if you win something even if you say kind of sustain your career is that really the career you want that is within the challenge within the challenge here that resides so be true to yourself what you want and is person you are with giving it to you or is the company you are working in giving it to you or you will have to find it elsewhere now if they are not giving it to you once again allow doesn't mean that they will not give it to you but you have to raise your voice about it and you have to be pretty damn clear that if they don't start delivering what they have promised to you it will be no longer so how people are gonna see you for throughout this month of February here we do have the queen of cups and people are gonna see you pretty unyielding and as well determined to have these satisfactions that you have signed for once again so it's it's a car pointing that people are gonna see you how you turn more into your inner fulfillment and start thinking more for yourself rather than for I would say the rest which kind of excludes children because this is their motherhood card so people are going to see you placing the things in such a hierarchy children myself everything else and therefore people are going to see you and that kind of an impression you're gonna give to them that everything that displeases your emotions is no goal in your life any longer so if you don't like what you are doing you will not gonna do it and therefore people will stop approaching you with silly things and stupid shenanigans here or kind of like abusing your kindness as well for asking you to do things that you don't like to do that you do not want to do as well etc etc now on the flip side or from another from another view with the card you are going to understand who your friends are with the queen of clubs a meaning that those who truly sees you as a good companion as a friend as a say a true friend okay they are gonna stick close to you and as well they are going to how can I say start sharing certain say secrets with you or things that are very touchy things that are very personal with them as well so that being said those who are just in a casual mood with you and they don't really care of spending time with you those are not good this is how you're going to differentiate a true friend from ages they are common owner if you will so this is also a month once again where you're going to find out or understand with the full force of reality who your true friends are so next one are where we move on it is what is going to drastically improve your circumstances and we do have a person here now that is going to be the key the knight of cups excuse me so Knights of cups as an individual Knights of Pentacles excuse me so Knights of Pentacles as an individuals there are people who really knows what what they want and how to get it okay and they are very meticulous with preparations they are very meticulous as well with with with performance if you will which from a flip side makes them rather slow in advance but whatever actions they do and they take is always supported by a very strong determination so that being said they every every time they do something it has a reason behind it okay and for one or another reason with this person you can kind of like form a a cooperation and truly push through toward a certain plants of you also to manifesting and yeah manifest and succeed into certain plants of yours ghosts of yours you know projects as well if that's a person as a suitor of yours that's great it means that they will not give up on you so easily even if you're going through this rather quite Sofia woman greet time throughout the month of February where you have to break with a lot of stuff and start a new endeavors as well with the ten of swords where a new Dawn's are going to take place on the expense of the old ones etc etc so that person is not gonna give up on you another thing with in with the Knights of Pentacles it is that whenever you feel exhausted especially energetically exhausted it will be best if you start spending time on nature that is something with the carp here the nature is going to make you it's going to refill or recharge your vital energies as well now the Knights of Pentacles also it could represent jumping into the old branches of love so maybe what is going to improve your [Music] circumstances is to allow to get in touch with someone you already knew and there is a spark in between you two now it is way too early to talk about reconciliation here okay but at least you have to give a chance that spark to kind of ignite a flame if it ignites a flame that great if it doesn't well at least you have tried so next one it is what is going to deteriorate your your circumstances here into the month of February now we do have the ten of cups and that is quite peculiar car into this position the telescope's here points of the displeasure or ungratefulness one can has toward what what one has adopted or toward what has one have at the moment that is what I like to say so that it kind of touches the this very negative trait of the human nature that no matter how much one has it always wants more you know for example take the billionaires no matter how much billions they have in bank in the day with those billions they can you know secure the the lives of a seven generations or maybe nine generations after them they always go for more and is remarkable how they are even willing to risk a lot by doing the various things about it so that kind of a nature that car represents okay maybe you have everything you need into your current marriage and still you have more all right maybe you have everything you need into your career and you still have more and that takes place right after the ten of swords so you kind of like provoked a new era of your life and you just need to settle with it okay instead of jeopardizing it if you will with the ten are born so whatever the results it is from your pressure that you're putting upon the situation you have to live with it otherwise more pressure is just going to you know break whatever benefits you can you can reap from all that transition that you're going to do throughout the month of February so last one here is going to be the guidance the tower is offering our we do have the Wheel of Fortune and it really tells us only one thing it is that the month of February is going to be a month where you're going to have a a lifetime opportunity once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to make a drastic change into your life but once again as we saw with the first three cards cancer you have to be true to yourself recognize the reality gather the strengths you have in regards to your spirit and determination and simply go for you know don't be afraid to for example you know to ask for you know anything that it bothers you really because if you don't ask the answer always is going to be no so are quite severe I don't want to say stressful I will classify the dynamic month stands in front of you you have a lot of things to confront from the behavior of Europe as a partner or a suitor to why you're not getting a promotion or to why you are treated that way into your career so you have to trade you have to confront all aspects that making you feel miserable and if they do not improve the time to break those aspects has come okay with with this reading so a lot to do throughout the month of February cancer and hopefully you are strong enough to go through it I'm to see it through as well so that being said guys this was your a monthly tarot reading for February 2020 you'll enjoy it and you liked it and we're gonna see each other next time until then bye | Radko Tarot & Pisces Moonbeam Astrology & Oracle | UCshvfG2qdXSAE7jBL27XsYQ | 2020-02-01 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,229 | 16,653 |
uuKzMnu7dIw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuKzMnu7dIw | Can You Overuse PEMF? MagnaWave | can you overdo pmf does pmf hurt you is pmf bad first of all pmf is not bad you are again surrounded by magnetic fields and actually counter um you know there's some studies showing that if you are sensitive to 5G and Wi-Fi and all of those things using proper therapeutic pmf can actually be beneficial to negate some of those negative electromagnetic fields so it's very similar like if you're in salt water okay and it's your Skin's dry that is a type of water okay if you go inside you're to to fix using that type of water or having that type of water on your skin you're gonna take a shower with with regular water and that's going to take off all that salt it's going to help rehydrate your skin very similar if you're exposed to a lot of Wi-Fi 5G and it's just very very it's a lot almost like salt water using pmf is almost like that shower for your cells in your body so it's beneficial in that way and you you can't really overdo it like I've I've explained uh before you can though get what's called a hertzheimer reaction and most of the time people get this reaction after the our first session what that means is they're detoxing so if you have a herzheimer reaction there's a couple things that we know one that means the pmf is working so that's good two it means that you're detoxing and people spend lots of money to detox themselves so we're pushing out all of the toxins and three it means that the next time your body should be less full of toxins and you shouldn't have that problem anymore so as human beings we take in toxins from everywhere we breed them in we eat them we drink them wear with animals they don't really go to McDonald's and drink Dr Pepper so they're limit they're they don't have alcohol they're not smoking so they don't have as much toxin buildup so they don't have as bad of a herzheimer reaction but it still can happen in animals but it more frequently happens in humans and the best way for me to compare this is if you have a deep tissue massage and you have that oh gosh I'm sore afterwards but as your muscles release and that detox ends you will start feeling better than you felt before so uh no you cannot overdo it in a way that is going to hurt you at least we haven't found any studies that show that as of yet but can you be in a little bit of pain and uncomfortable absolutely | MagnaWave | UCsOQDkKQxjIPDQx57OZyjCg | 2023-02-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 451 | 2,337 |
CtiEqtFLQac | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CtiEqtFLQac | I'M SICK [Mostly of floodgates (: ] Let's do some Orcust Gaming! | [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] n [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] w [Music] w [Applause] because uh we just wanted to give you a little Christmas gift so we're giving you a bonus stream that's uh probably the best we're going to do you know but it's cool it is what it is you know if you guys haven't noticed the pride tree is back here to chill and have a good time I'm turning up the light really quick it's kind of dark in here normally I have a little bit of daylight sneaking through but it is currently 7 o'clock at night here and it is pitch black so it is what it is fixed up the setup a little bit it's finally a little bit cleaner in here so things aren't like as obnoxious everywhere I have room I have room chat it's great ignore the candles my wife got those for me so just scre this over here actually so you guys can probably tell by my voice and potentially by the stream title I am currently recovering from a like 4our cold but it's taking way longer to get it out of my system so uh I am stuffy as all hell and I'll probably be muting to blow my nose occasionally so fair warning there uh I'm living through it right now and it sucks so yeah it's cool I'm just hoping I get rid of it before Christmas you know I want to be able to go hang out with the family and not not be sick boy so even if I'm not actually contagious it just sucks to be at a family gathering and not feel good H but anyways chat I'm honestly not too sure what we're going to do today obviously we're going to do some kind of orcus gaming I just don't know what platform I want to do it on yet I'm really not sure I did however uh spend a little bit of time this week to uh fix up my overlay a little bit it's still not amazing but I wanted to make it a little bit nicer and a little bit cleaner so I went through and like fixed it everything that I could think of that was like immediately important so hopefully stream will be a little bit better quality from now on hopefully that is the prayer but anyways chat hope you all are doing good hope everyone's feeling good today hopefully better than I am still had to go to work unfortunately but it is what it is and I got to work tomorrow too but then I got 9 days off which is going to be nice you why you got FL get at master I don't want you to tell me but yeah next week like starting Sunday I'm going to have Sunday through uh when I go back to work on the 2nd so I have the 24th through the 2D off which is going to be so goddamn nice you guys don't know how much I'm going to get done in that time I'm going to do a lot of cleaning house I'm going to catch up on all that crap that I've been behind on I'm going to do a couple live streams I'm going to get a ton of videos posted out for you guys it's Vengeance for the gy disrespect gem kns deserved it okay that has nothing to do with it that has nothing to do with it oh [ __ ] oh yeah I need to post this around hold on notice cloudy hasn't jumped in yet she's not paying attention literally just asking me earlier when I was going to go live and then like doesn't even show up what a noob that's why you turn on notifications dog I can tell yall in chat got notifs on though yall are the yall are the goats so chat uh I want to talk with Patrick here he's going to join the stream here in a little bit and uh we're going to kind of co- stream for a little while he's just got to do a couple things first and then he'll probably be on um but yeah oh yeah I need to hop in the Discord chat hold on oops this one there we go cool I don't remember if I have I don't have Discord AIO on let's fin I'll turn it on when someone joins there you are cloudy turn your notifications on bro that I don't need to message the link every time I go live but I'm going to talk with Pat Uh cuz we potentially have some cool news coming to you guys we have a lot of big things that are coming up come the first of the year uh I just got to ask him if he's okay with me spoiling it to chat usually there's not too many of you here so I think he'll be okay with it cuz he knows you guys are the loyal ones you're the real ones so your YouTube is broken they are on oh F CL you heard about H being flug in shut up Jolo no she doesn't have Twitter leave her out of this leave cloudy out of this she doesn't need to know I have buttons on my stream deck that I don't know what they do and I'm scared to press them I could just open the application and find out but that's no fun oh man yes I got flug in in a master duel and it was ridiculous press them I dude I don't know I don't know if I want to press him chat I don't know if I want to press him I don't know if I want to press him coward I know what most of the buttons do there's just a couple that like I don't know oh I found a new deck I like is it just manium again are you back on the manium copium Cloudy is that what's going on what is this oh that was that was today ahh that's funny people are starting to finally realize skill dra's a good card right now that's funny that's funny bro if I had like stuff I could do react Dy to I'd do it well it's one of them but it's unreleased deck is it snake eyes are you playing Snake Eyes now cloudy are you one of the gang or are you going Goblin riders or you going the other DM Bellar lore route funnily enough manium can utilize oh my God snatch steel is a disruption okay how does manium do it Goblin bikers it's Goblin Riders I don't care what the translation says it's Riders okay okay okay give a second I gotta blow my nose I'm still sick Bro all day has just been blowing my damn nose and I hate it I said earlier I don't even like really feel that sick I'm just congested is all hell and it won't stop both archetype start with an m it's an honest mistake oh mistyped makono oh Fair yeah no we know that makono can use it but they already have like equip spell dis uh disruptions like axe of Fools and crap give me one second you have to work the next four days God damn Tony you have to work on Christmas bro that's rough I'm so sorry I would not I would not wish that upon anyone that is rough don't mind me Chad I'm consuming cough drops don't mind me over acts of fools allows the opponent to keep their monster on like snatch deal well I mean yeah but snatch deal doesn't negate the effect so I work on the 26th and the 27th well that sounds like a personal problem to col granted I got lucky with the way that our damn you know R of the rud bro that's the second person to say that today so mean I get that I'm pasty but God damn with a 200% OT rate or QT rate what is that that's an OT okay what do you mean OT rate oh overtime oh [ __ ] you get 200% overtime that's not bad considering it's after Christmas too that's not bad normally normally we uh well everyone else has to go back to work on Wednesday through Friday but the way that my days fall off or the way way my days off fall I was able to shift the hours and then use two vacation days to get a 9 day stretch it's beautiful I'm so happy like don't get me wrong normally I would be pissed to the Christmas is a Sunday and a Monday normally I'd be mad about that but those are my normal days off for Sundays and Mondays so who else said that my coworker my cooworker this morning literally said that so it's been like this all day it is so unbelievably raw right now I have literally been like when I woke up I woke up at 5:30 this morning mind you it's 7:30 right now I woke up at 5:30 and I was blowing my nose for the first hour and a half that I was awake just straight like no stopping it just did not stop coming dude it sucked I also work New Year's damn Tony feels bad bro my pay gets doubled for the holidays well that's good at least that that's good at least to get some compensation and have them like understand I have to work Christmas Eve mostly by myself since my cooworker walked out last week what at least I'm off the following four days I mean yeah at least you get some time off but damn dude coworker just walked out oh God I hate that it's always the worst one that happens during holiday season I hope you're not in retail but I'm assuming by that comment that you are damn dude I'm so sorry I hate that [ __ ] it sucks I had to work Christmas Eve last year at a cell phone store I won't say which one but at a at a mobile mobile device store I had to work Christmas Eve and it [ __ ] sucked although Black Friday was a lot worse it's all due to me being in Poland which has the 26th and 27th off but I do stuff in the US so that's a thing apparently what the [ __ ] that sounds so weird to Colo that sounds so awful I'm so sorry confusing [ __ ] will be confusing all right chat what are we thinking today do we want some master duel it's been a while do we want some master duel until Patrick shows up as I assume when Patrick shows up we're probably going to either do like discussion stuff or we're we're going to do some TCG testing tday is the only night I will have a cooworker for the next four days damn dog what industry do you working Tony are you retailer and you have like something easier that's not customer service bro I'm I I [ __ ] I hate customer service with a passion like I as soon as I found a job opening that was not customer service I'm like bro I'm taking that [ __ ] and it just so happens to pay better than my last job which is funny cuz my last job was on commission so that's kind of sad but yeah know it's cool I think we should play some I think we should open up some as for right now until Pat joins us guys I don't know how long he's going to be so we'll play a couple games actually I got I got another Christmas present for you guys outside of just the bonus stream so oh my God man my my chat is taking forever an update I'm sorry mental Healthcare my friend got to work with patients all day oh my god dude that sounds brutal I am so sorry sorry grun that sounds brutal well I am an overnight boy with a day pay nothing wrong with that Jolo oh Tony you are in retail bro oh retail and Mental Health Care sounds so rough for the holidays I am so sorry you guys I'm just a custodian so I don't got to suffer that much but oh God damn I am so sorry my dudes that canot be fun I can't really see anything the goblin can do other than do wait other they do Omni plus like four monster onates how the hell did they get omnis and monster negates I know Bamboo's a gossip Shadow how the hell else do they get negates what do they do all right chat you ready to see the new overlays they're nothing like super special but I gave us options so I have this one or I can quickly swap to this one if we need to see stuff I finally set it up to where I have have options it's beautiful but anyways chat wait I didn't even think of bamboozling what I'm about 5 minutes from being ready oh damn all right chat we have enough time to build the deck we have enough time chat I have 6700 gems what deck are we making in the time that it takes Patrick to get here what deck do we make and nobody say manium cuz 6,700 gems is not enough I need legitimate ideas here I need legitimate ideas what yall got for me cuz I genuinely like don't know what deck to build right now and grunt says Master R is fun at the moment I don't know I'm having a rough time with it just because it feels like Maxi gets more annoying by the day I don't know my master has been broken for like 3 months damn what I thought I Meed the call what Bill Buster Blader no morphtronic h i want like an actual like ladder deck cuz I'm currently and platinum I want to get to at least Diamond before the end of the month so I don't drop too hard I have paid wet if at least just sucks when anyone walks out of course just hoping that no one heavily responds to their symptoms I'd rather not drag getting my co-workers in with me oh damn dude yeah that is the rough part like you just never know vion no makono I've slightly debated on it but I don't want to go that deep it's makono just sounds miserable to me I'm going to be real I'm going to be completely real it just sounds awful like I hate playing against it I don't want to be the guy that people hate I can get rid of this orchest uh I mean I already have orchest wo kills a lot of decks going blind second well that's what I have my scraps for honestly a lot of my decks do really good blind second like dark world if I win the coin toss I go blind second I don't give a [ __ ] I play this deck going second cuz if I go first I'm more likely to lose to the tyer uh I did build Dragon link which for some reason I have three Royals for but I don't know this deck feels kind of copium right now I'm not a huge fan of it witchcrafter stun absolutely not I'm not learning witchcrafters um I do also have a salad deck uh my rescue Ace deck surprisingly does pretty decent a going second like I just hard built it for going second I don't even play the traps dog like I literally have one D barrier here as a target for thrust if I go first that's it blind second de are actually crazy unless you vers ftk of course that's why you play like a ton of hand traps so how toxic can we get here as long as it's competitive I'll hear it out if it's a deck that can climb the ladder I'll hear it out why do I still have this deck this deck is awful Sigma otk no that is not competitive at all Jolo fluffles I have played fluffles before and it's fun hey Pat how we doing I feel that what deck do you think I need to build master duel I have extra gems then no comment for me a damn oh okay yeah yeah I mean you can just you could just throw out ideas of the TCG like I I like the master format outside of Maxi without Maxi I think it's okay no I'm not listening to toola or you I don't know I know I mean like millenum is tempting but it's so expensive it's crazy did you try to say birds Jolo what did you try to type there I'm so confused ah oh guys we can we can play uh we can build zodiac uh dragon rulers and have the most toxic deck of the format including according to MBT scare Claw is another Vsauce deck that compete I know I can reach master I have played scare claw before I have it on my alt account I did I did really good with scare like I did stupidly good with scare claw I I won't deny that super heavy sa the new support for super heavy isn't here yet like maybe I can save my gems and just get the super heavy stuff when it comes in cuz that looks like a fun deck and then hopefully it comes with the rescue a stuff too so I can just get all of it but that s that sounds jao does that every stream though he brings that up all the time dude there's so many decks there are so many decks that I want to be in masterer right now that are just not here and it sucks the steam capture thing is the worst what what steam capture how are we looking with sron uh not great that's expensive and bricky as hell it is bricky and master duel the simulator dude the simulator does not like Vanquish Soul at all yeah it's like one out of like 10 hands is maybe playable or if you're playing against vanish Soul they have a god hand that's just how it goes it's annoying as hell dude I hate it fabled oh my God no do we have any volcanics the new volcanic support isn't here yet cholo I'm not building decks that don't have support in master dog those Dex are doooo oh my God such a I would I would rather just like spend the money and get manium I would be real I'll just I'll leave it for now I'll think about it for now I'm not asking about the new support well like everything else volcanic is cheap there's like one Ur for the whole deck the in the TCG right now with a new cards yes but before that the deck is ass it doesn't do anything yeah the only you are no the like I think the newest card that we have is doomfire the only URS are doomfire and Blaze accelerator reload those are like the only good cards no no if the new support were in here I would give it a try I genuinely would you know what maybe we'll just go straight to TCG and I'll test that assault synchron I don't think I have it that's okay I didn't plan on playing Master for long tonight anyways um what's your simulator of choice nowadays Pat in paper okay I feel that I just I just like doing simulators so I can like see what the deck looks like before I order cards sometimes if I'm feeling responsible I do that that's usually what I do but occasionally I'm smart enough that I'll test it first okay right right we might also want to look into cyber decks those or cyber darks those are silly in more ways than one I've played cyber darks and I'm not a huge fan generator isn't half bad at the new stuff that's what I've seen it like it looks okay I don't know Pat if you're here please give me a sign for what what does Pat need to give you a sign for drao also cloudy you're not wrong last time he did stream I believe it was on Omega so I don't think you're wrong Fs in chat for my boy Pat okay so I'm going to be real I have not read any of the new volcanic cards at all so I'm going to put you guys onto the react Andy screen and we're going to go through these together yeah you're good okay so I need to read these new volcanic cards so Blaze accelator is a new one sending one Blaze accelator for hand I've I've read the first couple lines of text and I haven't gotten past that oh I don't have chat I'm sorry I didn't have Discord unmuted this whole time that's why you couldn't hear Pat I'm so sorry get his volcanic deck play video up I don't have it dude volcanic got more cards no they just got cards like in a set a couple of months ago the burning volcano or whatever uh okay so volcanic blazinger activate this by sending one blazer from your hand deck or face the fields of the Grave can only control one once per turn dur your main phase you can special volcanic from your hand once per turn Target one face up monster your opponent controls send one level one Pyro from your deck to the graveyard if you do destroy that monster I mean being able to send a level one pyro is not bad I was going to say it sets up Oak plays I mean with Snake Eyes you have a ton of options but the card is sent to the graveyard you activate one of these effects can only use each effect once per turn Bish to graveyard if you do send a volcanic monster from your deck to the Grave okay banish a blaze accelerator from your face and feel the graveyard if you do place one Blaze accelerator continous spell trap from your hand or deck face up under your field okay that's not bad I assume that like is intended to get you volcanic Blaze accelerator I don't think there's much else you go for oh god oh one second actually I think you and he are about the same age want to hear about a very silly Tech pick for volcanic no we're here for competitive jao we want competitive decks not J we still can't hear Pat you should be able to oh I do I not is it not selecting oh I I found out what it is hold on oh is it cuz I'm literally like not oh my God I hate this uh save executable there we go that should fix it now there we go later Tony thanks for joining the stream bro he me now it's showing that there's audio coming through for you so I'm going to pray oh wait okay yeah I'm seeing you actually have audio levels now I didn't check it before that was my mistake I'm sorry chat Pat is here now okay we cannot hear Pat perfect hi Molly counter garbage don't need to look at that did you let the dog in our room in my room volcanic emission I've got two little ones with me so take one volcanic for your decky the add hand special ignoring it summoning conditions Jesus you're not getting cookies what Target one pyro in the field inflict your opponent equal that nor can you get the dog out of my room it's an interesting cardly no no Molly go to Nora volan would be much better when you get bonfire new oil card is crazy fire Salvage true silly Tech pick number one revolution synchron allows the deck to access Laval salamander AKA more Firepower I'll read that card later I'm still trying to read these ones um can I can I kidnap stream for just a second yeah go for it while I read this okay let's yeah good luck with that um okay so starting this off um I want to address a couple of questions that we've been asked a lot in the past 20 seven minutes to be precise we've been asked at least 10 times um orchest content will be coming soon there's a couple of things I'm still testing and getting things organized um as you guys are probably aware at this point I'm pretty thorough in making sure I have everything all my rows in a duck um and making sure that everything is set up so that I know it's consistent that the deck has certain um I have knowledge of the deck in a way that I can actually explain it to you in a Deck Profile so it's good so that's one orcus content is coming do not be worried or dissuaded by the fact that it's not coming out the second the ban list drops I want to make sure I'm giving you guys quality content not just content for the sake of content because yay my boy is free haha funnyes funny memes in in in chat um the next thing I wanted to address is that while orchest is my favorite deck of all time and everybody is aware of that going into to events I want to be completely transparent it's probably not the deck I'm going to take to events um it might but it probably is not uh mainly for the reason that it is currently just outclassed by so many other strategies uh and there's so many better variants of it and so with that being said I want to be completely transparent that while I will probably be saying orcus best deck it it's not and um that has to be something that I need to be completely transparent about because it is something that you have probably heard me or will have heard me critique in the past and that is hard for me to say because um we have we have our savior our Lord and savior harp horr Back At One um so yeah it it's cool it's fun I'm going to be playing it it but it's not going to be something that I'm going to be playing competitively and I don't I don't want you guys to get the wrong impression of what's going on uh in in that regard um finally I haven't we haven't done a lot of content recently there's a lot of things that uh we've been working on behind the scenes we are currently working on some something fun and entertaining to go at the beginning of deck profiles and it's going to take a little bit more a little bit more work on my end with the recording of it and the the prepping of it it's going to take a little bit more work on Christian's end for the editing of it and you know even though Christian is like the greatest editor on the planet he's still human and has a job and a family to take care of so we need to make sure that we're not just overloading him and killing him so we want to make sure that we set that stuff up in a way that is going to make it easy easier for him to do the work that he has to do easier for us to be able to do the work that we need to do on our end and be able to continue providing you with great competitive Yu-Gi-Oh content and deck profiles whilst still is telling doing something else that I really love which is storytelling we're going to be adding skits and bits to the beginning um to the beginning of deck profiles and we're going to be telling a long kind of a long cohesive story through it to kind of make it more fun so I just wanted to let you guys know what's going on so that you guys aren't thinking um and I I don't want to be anything other than transparent with you guys because especially to the people in chat you guys are as Christian said earlier the real ones and I really appreciate all of your guys' support in everything that we do uh even though jao has me dying in his hunger series which doesn't make any any sense but whatever uh I would win and we all know it and that's fine because I'm a stubborn s so I survived a heart attack and work through it I Will Survive anyone else not scared why am I still talking about this why does it still fire me uping oh part of that was just me being factious but we did get one about an hour ago I I'm D yeah I mean ELD orist is definitely more playable now but you if you're gonna play ELD orist you may as well just play zombie orist at this point which is technically at full power now [ __ ] I still have my mic muted I'm sorry chat I muted while Pat was talking and then like forgot I'm sorry but thank you for letting us know when we have technical issues yeah please oh that thing Jolo dude yes oh my God you have no idea of this thing what the hell you'll have to tell me later oh I will tell you off I'll I'll tell you off stream um but yeah no it's Jolo I can actually like do this video now and I'm so excited uh regarding o news and discussion about the channel though uh do you want to tell them anything about the new year or do we hold on to that no you know what let's let's let these guys know um okay so if you've been here for a while and I don't know if all of you have been but um I I've I've said it in the past and I've I've said it in Christian that when Christian and I first started working together not like on this channel but um when he and I first started talking I and I still maintain this I didn't want to offer any anything that didn't that required finances without having something to reward said finances because people's money is very valuable and there's only so much of it and everybody has families to feed and so do we and I don't want to offer something with no service in the background of it so we have been talking and putting it to work we want to provide the option for uh membership and we're going to be launching membership in the new year and with the membership we are going to be launching our own private Discord server um and public Discord server for you guys to be able to join and be able to inter interact with us members will be able to vote on content members will be able to uh have more direct interaction with us which is pretty neat um because we're I mean we have people all over the world that that watch this and and that's really cool I think it's really cool that we've built this community that we have and I want to continue to grow it and Foster it in a healthy and positive way and the best way we do that is by one um with the changes that we're doing in videos and deck profiles moving forward making the fun stories that we're going to be doing in skits and bits and stuff that we're going to do at the beginning um that's a really fun way to give back to you guys is giving a little bit more of our personality I've held a little bit of myself back and now it's time to just let loose a little bit because Christian has always let loose but I've always been very reserved um mostly for the protection of my family and loved ones but um you won't get banned from gem KN jokes you're proted Jolo it's it's going to be a public Discord but if you're a member you get access to certain parts of the server that no one else does yeah there there's private channels in the server so but you only get those if you're a YouTube member and we are going to be making those go live with different tiers for you guys that will have different benefits to we're fleshing out the last little bit of it but we got it pretty well figured out I think yeah and there's going to be growing pains and we'll greatly appreciate anybody that is uh a member helping us fix those things and being that way um it will also once we get everything going um I want to be able to have like members only tournaments I want to be able to do fun things like that I want to do stuff for those commun that community that does stuff for us I want to be able to host things that give back to the community that we have fostered and built um because Christian and I have now been been working together for like two years on this channel um it's been like three hasn't it I thought it was 2020 I joined you didn't join 2020 2020 was Co it was at the end of 2021 was it really okay I'm look at my channel hold on I think it was like September 2021 because then we finished out the yeah I know it was like August September around there yeah it was like September of 2021 and now it's you know it's been like two years I remember the first video that I did for you on the channel was about remote dueling yeah oh it was 202 it was it was August 2021 is when I put out the update okay damn wild isn't it thought it was longer weird yeah thank God I have a good memory um I don't that makes you know what that's why we're work together well um yeah but since then I want like this is this is just general like me I guess hyping up Christian when when he came in we were what like 400 and something subscribers we were doing pretty okay it was like 430 440 somewhere there what do you need to know jao I'll pause for a second just for you what well it's going to take me a little while to find that out Jaa because I have an ice cream maker now so I need to experiment and then I'll I'll come back to you on that um as for s b so far the only I've had is ice cream there's only one flavor of ice cream that matters um and that would be cherry cordial it is the greatest gift to mankind cherer cordial I've never heard of that it's dark chocolate and cherry flavored with cherries and cherry flavored ice cream it's phenomenal it's the best I like both of those things but I do not like them together I will pass oh they're the best but anyway I I'm a huge fan I'm I'm weird okay so back to that when Christian joined about two years ago we've grown exponentially we've oh more than doubled we've we hit our first mile marker which was the Thousand um everything and a lot of that is attributed to Christian he brings the one thing to the channel That I just can't provide and that's editing skill uh because I don't got it and I I genuinely do not have the time to learn it Christian brings that in spades Christian has also been a huge um a huge benefit to the team in when we when one of us experiences burnout like he's able to edit but when one of us is feeling burnout we're able to like just work together and it's not just him and I there's more people on the team we've got Chris our videographer who is also running nerd in which is on Hiatus but he's working on it um he's brought it back on noticed him streaming yeah he's been streaming so we're trying to he's goingon to try to bring that back hopefully soon soon it it's just a work in progress trying to get more schedules to coincide and a lot of that dictates on this um so we've got Chris our videographer we've got Lucas who is everybody's play like he's our resident Jud like he's a better judge than me I'm a judge but he's a better judge than me he's better with those things and I'm fully okay with admitting that um and he really does help us with with prep he is the resident legal cheater in Fusion yo just so you all know I don't know how that man has the most stacked hands every game yeah unless it's something he just unless it's mid-range he can't play mid-range decks he's all about either it's full-blown combo it it's got to be Balls to the waller for whatever reason his deck doesn't work which I I remember being that way too and then I had to stray off of that because I couldn't draw worth a damn so I didn't have a choice and then and then to top that off we have two other guys that are going to be coming on two or three other people that are going to be coming on to uh help us put these skits and stuff together um which is awesome we have a whole team of people and a whole community that we've built here locally as well as having Christian who's our overseas friend who's landlocked and connected to us but that doesn't count it's more fun to say across the seas um so wait did you get a hold of the person that you were talking about with me did they answer he hasn't answered I'm going to send him an email okay that sounds about right though like I I'm not surprised to be honest he's a busy guy I get it yeah yeah um but that's that's what's going on I wanted to give you guys this update I appreciate you if you've sat sat around listening to me jabber on about all this stuff coming to the channel but you guys are again the real ones and um I I am so happy that we've been able to to do this um my our orchest videos have blown up lately and I know it's hot and we want to strike while the iron's hot but we also don't want to provide you with subpar content untested content because we could do that we could go the team Sam approach but oh so I will have I will have a profile to come up soon because the version that I'm playing excuse me all I really had to mess around with was the non engine I needed to make it fit the format so I have a deck ready and it is a budget version so I will upload that for you guys I will have a budget version of the profile that'll include like swap outs if you have more budget if you have more money to work with or if you already have some of the cards so you'll have that to look forward to Le we do have an orcus deck all the way immediately and we have at least four more coming yeah I still I got a lot of decks I got to build but I've been so obsessed with snake eyes dude it's not even funny I I'm yeah it's it's wild right now and like I've been and I'll be full disclosure like I still have branded I'm still playing branded I still love Brandon I have Chimera runic which is actually super fun um for those of you that don't know um we have that obviously I have Brandon I said that I have vanquished Soul which has become my little pet project and is ridiculously fun it is probably the best mid-range deck in the format um anybody that says it's just a TC boo deck doesn't understand how good vanquished soul is and I have Fire King sinful spoil Tri Brigade ready which I'll be showing off at some point soon uh that deck is funny lit but uh and then Lucas Lucas is bu uh is building Unchained for the new format and um well it's weird but I really dig it um see more of a mid-range deck though so he at least does play some mid-range live by the runic die by the runic Chimera runic does it die by the runic see that's the coolest part is Cher runic like ripping cards out of the hand and extra deck is something that this deck does now which is hilarious haha funny joke to Colo it's not like I made that same exact joke on my snake eye profile it's not like I it's not like I made that exact same joke but whatever I I'm giving you a hard time Jolo I love you I don't but I'm saying I do look I'm trying I've tried to convince Christian to go to Vegas to do the three V3 with me and hopefully Lucas I'm broke I spent all my money on cardboard he's making excuses you guys see it if if enough of y'all if enough of y'all put in memberships to the YouTube channel that I can afford to go to Vegas I'll consider it I also got to convince the wife that's the hard part I'll talk to her I'll talk to her and now I can't hear you wait did I am I muted oh no I just I moved away from my mic and I wasn't talking so where the hell what was I looking for I don't remember what I was digging for in here oh I remember what you want to talk oh so guys hold on I want to let I'm gonna let my uh my son talk for a minute um so this is a cool thing so Patrick my son um easy to remember name you're welcome um he got to play in his first Yu-gi-oh uh tournament what last night was last my God my days are running together and I want him to tell you all about how his experience went it wasn't it was more of a casual tournament because people weren't there but he got to play his first couple of games and so I want I want him to talk to you guys about it so you ready to talk about your your your game come on around here come around here it's easier all right he's coming hold on sit with me buddy so he won't be able to hear you Christian but I will uh I will interp so all right buddy so what did you play played um um I played Heroes Heroes yeah Bas yep so okay so in round one your first game who did you play against you played against Chris right yeah yeah it was Chris what was Chris playing um branded he was playing branded yeah yeah yeah yeah so in game one you got a little bit of help uh cuz we were teaching him how to play the game and stuff and uh how how did the first game go I won you won awesome uh you ended on the full board didn't you who was it that was helping you who was walking you through it was it Lucas yeah so he got a little bit of help from Lucas showing him how the deck interacted and how he could play plays um and he was able to play against branded and he locked him basically out of the game dang yeah I mean we built a very competent hero deck so yeah um so then in game in your second round you played against who' you play against was it were you playing against dragons or were you playing against something else dragons was it dragons okay so then in round two we played against rockets and who helped you in that one Lucas Lucas helped you again okay so he got to play against dragons for a game a round and how did it go good went good you win that one too what did you win that one yeah yeah can you guys hear him okay uh I can hear him it looks like his audio is coming through fine okay good so yeah you got to play against you got to play against Dragon link and you played Dragon link a second time didn't you and that time it was with me right and you have fun yeah how do you what do you think of Yu-Gi-Oh so far buddy you think it's fun yeah you know it's not going to be easy wins all the time because Daddy and and Lucas and everybody isn't going to be able to help you every time right I know okay so what what was your favorite card what was your favorite uh card of the uh uh uh what's your favorite card in the deck Vision Hero Vision hero Von is your favorite yeah nice interesting can see things the visor you like the art what' you think of oh oh okay so he opened his uh first OTS packs at locals what' you end up pulling ultimate ultimate an ultimate rare he pulled an ulti in his first pack good God which one uh so he originally pulled a branded Fusion but uh Chris was looking for and I already have the play set stop you uh so we gave it to Chris but I had a pery that he that I had so I gave him a pear Lily because he did pull an ultimate rare so he pulled an ultimate rare branded Fusion but he's not playing branded and if he wants to he has access to the whole thing and Max Rarity because somebody we're not going to name names we're going to leave my name out of it uh has a problem and has a fascination with high Rarity cards and cardboard well thank God that's thank God I don't live over there for that exact reason I don't want to be around that filth look I don't force it on other people I just like bling oh I just mean the Branded part I I don't care about the high Rarity cards I'm holding I'm holding the two high Rarity cards you sent me right now chat chat chat chat I hate the post office but they finally came we're thrusted baby we're we're thrusted baby they look gorgeous granted they're not they're not in any decks right now because the Decks that I'm building don't need this but I'm so glad to have these we are thrusted baby we are thrusted yeah they finally they did finally come they did finally come so agitated by how long it took dude it was it was what like a month and a half almost it was like almost two months I sent it at the it was it was November 11th is when it was marked as shipped or when it was received by the post office yeah so yeah it was like a month and almost two weeks before before I finally got the damn cards and then and then on top of that chat on top of that my mail carrier bro oh my God what a prick so he knocks on my door right cuz this is one that I have to sign for or whatever he knocks my door I open it cuz thankfully I just come inside right when he showed up so I open it and he's like I'm like is it finally here and he's like yeah it's here it's here and I'm like sick he's like so what's in it I'm like oh just some Trading it's $160 worth of trading cards he's like oh what trading cards and I'm like Yu-Gi-Oh and he's like ah so you're an edge Lord and I'm like bro I can't catch a guy I spent 160 bucks on these cards just to get called an edge Lord by my mail carrier he's like ah don't worry bud I'll handle the signature and then walked off I'm like I just got disrespected in my own home but at least we got the mail so that made up for it I finally got the thr the cards you don't care it was just like it was wild I'm like that's the last person I would expect to call me an edge Lord is my goddamn mail carrier of all people dude I talk to this guy like twice a year cuz he always comes when I'm in the basement like he's always around whenever I like don't even know that he's here so I never talked to him and he's just like a so you're an edge Lord like [ __ ] dude okay whatever whatever it's the glasses it's got to be the glasses it's got well and I think I can't remember what shirt I was wearing but it was probably like my NASA shirt or something wait you see what Christian The Edge Lord I am not an edge Lord I am not an edge Lord he just likes to destroy his own stuff to gain Advantage yes uh mostly mostly High Rarity eldes and uh inspector borders I had to chase down the mail truck to get my 25th anniversary case because of my door was dead bro I swear there were days during waiting for this package that I thought about chasing my mailman down and being like yo where the hell is my package cuz like the post office was no help so the tracking from November 11th I kid you not until it got delivered it only said that it got picked up by his post office there were no other updates so I put in I I filed uh for like missing package with USPS it took them a week it took them a week before they called me and I was on the phone with them and they're like oh yeah we don't actually like do tracking anymore we just scan it when we get it and scan it when it gets delivered we don't do it in between anymore and it gets thrown with in with normal mail now so sometimes it takes longer and it's like bro then what's the point of the tracking like there's no reason to spend extra money on tracking at that point if it just gets thrown in with normal mail and doesn't even get tracked it's so bogus dude like they were no h at all I was so pissed I I was actually pretty frustrated myself cuz I'm the one that sent the cards yeah post over here don't even knock they leave a post notice and never knock even if you're home I have that issue with like FedEx FedEx is the only ones that do that for me here they will they will not bother to knock at your door and they'll just dip now I imagine Chris with a shotgun chasing a post man no I don't have a shotgun though well he I mean they all heard me talking about the dog I had you muted for a couple seconds just in case hey no bite Molly you keep teasing her so but yeah so that was that story chat on the plus side like I said we have the thrust we are we are able to thrust you don't have to yell I'm glad you finally got them I was really upset that it was taking so long but I'm glad you did finally get them yes I mean I I did immediately throw them in a deck when I got them and then like the band list came up but I'm like well I'm not building that deck anymore so peace I got my three copies of souls earlier today oh bro BG I'm assuming magician Souls cuz I think he's talked about it recently maybe he's playing steaker Soul maybe he's playing he's playing the best deck of the format magician Souls is like 20 to 30 bucks right now still isn't it yeah that's out of my price range for the minute brother wait what was the first set it was released in was it brother was Brothers of Legend the first set that it was released in I thought it came out as an ultra first no it was a secret first okay so it was Brothers of Legend okay that just didn't feel right but never mind my posters are actually decent I hear horror stories from my buzz in Indiana when I send the bu it was Ultra first you're right it was an legendary hero it was magical hero oh that's right yeah cuz it was with all the DM support okay yeah so the brothers of Legend reprint is worth more than the original I love it it's higher Rarity oh yeah plus it a that was open which is kind of weird so there's more of them on the mar if Brothers of Legend was opened quite a bit too though like there was some good cards in Brothers of Legend it wasn't that bad brothers of Legend had some okay cards the legendary dualist sets just aren't ever very good I remember that being one of the first sets I bought when I got into the game I'm not going to lie I got the one that had all the uh Striker reprints I got it because I saw Heroes and like that's what I wanted to play when I got back cuz I didn't know any better but oh Brothers of Legend You' learned since then and we're all proud of you Brothers of Legend had the first droplet reprint also had Ana oh the hero reprints that's right uh oh diablosis how that has fallen I love it oh and all the red eyes reprints like we got and the red eyes Fusion I got Brothers of Legend ones since those were the cheaper onese you got the secret for cheaper than the Ultras over there bro the American system shs I hate it oh we also got all the Kurio guys in there too the curry Bo Curry B Curry B all those guys Curry Bon oh dude we got infernoid reprints in that set I forgot about that I need to get Inferno cards I need to get infernoid cards it was over $100 before they banned master plan M spiral format thankfully I was not here for spiral format but Pat I think you suffered through it didn't you that was the second spiral format he's talking about the second one the original spiral format was no fun at all oh the the second the second one isn't really even a spiral format though they just happened to be there they were like in the backgound it wasn't even the best deck of the format at the time though the second spiral format the best deck was shidol and voked yeah no like Spiral didn't really do Jack what after I got to the oh no souls it did stuff but it wasn't yeah like you said it wasn't the best deck like no master plane getting banned though needed to happen that car was it did master plan is insane I still think like Quick Fix could stay stay lower in cies but that's just me I like getting cheaper German versions no idea why some people prefer English I like Che ger copies all the time where do you get the German copies I find them online I do you just get on TCG player yeah you just look for the cheap ones and you go oh that's German I'll take I would I would love French copies but those are more expensive so no yeah well Al what I don't know I'm just speaking out my butt okay I was going to say like those were French words but that didn't sound like a sentence it's from a song oh is it is that the top G song I don't care little Bros is not saying the top G song in chat what I don't know oh I did I send you the altered lyrics for that for what the the the thing I'm working on with uh oh no you haven't sent the most recent ones yet though just the ones you were you came up with that day I think I finalized it I really like it okay uh can do you mind Nora or lla who's ever under my chair I paid $1 1990 per copy of Souls which is $21.94 I think it's a steel bro yeah that's like 10 bucks cheaper than what like 10 to 15 cheaper than what we can pay for that's not a steel that's 2194 time three that's that's $15 cheaper a copy that's not a steal that's just spending $15 less per copy I mean that's like almost 50% so i' consider that pretty good A steal is getting them for free well fair enough and is a crime I guess I'm biased because I can read German no joke want a German Valkyrie course since they're based on a German Opera but there's no reliable way to find every card to forign print valid oh I'm learning French so that's where I stand with that but uh I haven't even learned English same do you want do you want chat for a few minutes Pat I got to go use the bathroom I can talk to them for a minute all right cool CH I'll be back in a few minutes Patrick will be the one here with you so uh enjoy his company okay cool uh no I I mean I can't I can't speak for everybody else but I I have played my Akashi but it's weird and not my fa but it's really mean yeah my wife is making fun of me for how I speak to you guys I mean my wife makes fun of me for a lot of things so yes how to keep a marriage working via my wife uh bullying she said and I quote I'm going to bully you until you love me I did not yes don't get on your dad's side even chat's agree yes it is it definitely is that's how my wife is too guys just for clarity here my wife is the best what the what's the new twitch meta oh God this is going to be really bad I'm buying stuff for my game on our card cool okay oh that's not the new meta that's just really dumb like I don't let my kids watch Twitch anyway but like it's just honestly it's pathetic because that just means the quality of their content isn't anything so all they have to go off of is their looks and they're using sensor bars to like give the implications of something it's just [Music] pathetic why do you have ear why would you spend money willingly on burning Abyss you do what is that guy that's access code talker access code talker you sure do why did you get so big all of a sudden why did you B I don't know it I mean look I I don't stream on Twitch really anymore and it just I no because I need to be able to hear what's going on um in a minute I'll let I'll let you switch in a minute can you stop please um yeah no twitch is just eh like I get why you stream there it's the known one but it's just not worth it so I mean and that's one of the things where're just staying here so I I stay on it literally to support uh two or three friends and that's pretty much it I do it to support shade nerding and occasionally another guy and that's it Cho I watch your stuff on YouTube I don't watch your stuff on Twitch he streams on both but I don't the people I watch on Twitch are all strictly twitch streamers so if I can watch them on YouTube I watch them on YouTube too bad it's stuck to Ritual Beast okay so do you guys like does anybody actually want to talk about this ban list who a b not allow yeah so the Forbidden and limited list has I'm explaining the Forbidden limit list to my son here for a second so okay so forbidden means means you can't play any copies of it in your deck it it's banned from the game you can't play it limited means you can only play one copy of the card in your deck as you're allowed to play up to three semi-limited means you're only allowed to play two copies of it in your deck and unlimited or not on the list is three you're allowed to play three I can hear you so what talk about we're about to talk about the ban list what Lyla allow to use that it yeah it was literally just five days ago it was insane yes go ahead baby girl okay so uh the ban list I'll wait for Christian to get back but we can talk about the ban list for a minute that sounds fun I mean that jury's out on that just not about this I am back okay oh that's cool I was waiting for you to come back so we could talk about the ban list chat chat do not call me cursed I have I have a medical reason for this do not call me cursed I brought an entire jar of pickles down do not call me cursed I I have a reason the b list is cool as hell I wish we had more lists this big the ocg gets so many bigger lists the funny theory that I've heard with the band list is that it was 25 hits for the 25th anniversary it's actually funny it it seems like a legit Theory with Konami though like it doesn't seem far-fetched nothing seems far-fetched I I put nothing past Konami but I mean I don't have the ban list right in front of me but if you want if you can pull it up that pull it up but I'm gonna go on the react Dy screen so you can see it yeah oh neat okay here Patrick can you hop off my leg is falling asleep if you want dude you can sit right here and you can still listen in um no cloudy snatch steel is at one snatch steel is at one got a big old butt buddy I have I have the link Jolo I already have it up I already have it up this should be the up one yeah I can't hear you so give me a second okay what the [ __ ] that's valid pickles are the best pickles are goated bro pickles are goated good okay can you hear me yeah yeah okay I read that wrong oh fair enough cloudy Al let's start with the first um okay I'm extremely what do you mean I'm extremely cursed leave me in my pickles alone aren't like 10 steal your opponent cards Lego right now so we have one change of heart three mind control three uh enemy control and one CH or and what was the last one one snatch deal one change of heart three mind control three enemy controllers so we have eight who drinks pickle juice I do it's good it's good for you can why don't we just go down the list we'll talk about every hit we'll talk about like kind of what it means hold on yeah there we got AO AO okay so ago and kelc I guess we could talk about together because they're the they're basically the same car for the same reason good ridds um more or less this just kills tier limit in my humble estimation uh it's it was time it's time I'm done with it they you show EU list site no because it has everything listed right there so it sucks um yeah so I think those two kind of make sense that I understand why it's gone um it is what it is yeah even as an orchest player that was playing zombie ampire in the Horus build I'm ready for it to be done I'm ready for the Millers to be gone yeah no the Millers being gone is just it's it's healthy it needs to happen the the shufflers are fine the shufflers are genuinely fine so next was shers are fine at three really yeah no they can now that the Millers are gone I think the shufflers at three are fine the only thing that it's really good at is loud no I don't think aido or kelc got banned because of haror I do not think not not even close no tier was still putting up results with like most of its names at one it was arguably the strongest deck of the format it was one of the higher decks yeah I wouldn't say strongest but it was argu I'm not saying it was I'm saying it was aru so like it's it's a very highroll deck if it hits the highroll then yes I would agree but it doesn't always hit the high so right but with enough people playing it the highroll was bound to happen and it happened a lot um yeah next up is math ma circular uh based honestly [ __ ] mathmech I'm glad it's gone it's it's time that deck it's not it's not an insane deck but it's just so annoying I I'm glad to have it gone circular was also really abusable in like every cybers deck so yeah I think this is future proofing really yeah um next year was isold is old okay so is old has been called to be banned for like literal years this has needed to happen for a while but I lit I told everyone I told everyone I think I think I streamed before the ban list hit and I'm pretty sure I told everyone I'm like yall need to watch out anytime that pack plays a deck and he says a card is broken and needs to be banned it's going to be banned that's how we lost meu and now it's how we lost his old a old I don't care about miamu should come back though miamu is fine agree with that actually um honestly let's ban Dia bellstar already real take it's been around for two months leave my girl alone cloudy she did nothing wrong here so here's the thing diaab bellstar is the new Visa star Frost which is the new fallen ofal bat it ain't going I say she's also a good Vsauce too like she basically took vsauce's mechanic and made it playable three months too many not even diab belar is actually really really neat and it plays into a lot of different things so just you know like I get it but no not even she used it like every deck not every deck there's plenty of there's a lot of like so I played simple spoil Vanquish Soul worst way to play the deck yeah um the diaab bellstar package is not great in every single it's good in some for sure yeah but it's not like it's not as bad as people are making it out to be um it's strong for sure but if like with h Fire King if I don't see it it is what it is it's just a consistency card for me like in Snake Eyes that's what it's going to be a consistency card that's it okay so let's look at this real quick cloudy this is bolognia top 64 so okay rescue Ace obviously is going to use it that's just obvious doesn't leth doesn't desia doesn't tier liament doesn't doesn't and for noal Knight does but it's like it's not as great uh purely doesn't Mak no makono does Mako does a centurion doesn't unchain doesn't Vanquish Soul doesn't usually ra doesn't Chimera does it Dragon link doesn't casir doesn't Marines doesn't Dia bellstar is fine Dia bellstar is fine leave my girl be you can hate on her you can hate on her in six months when she gets hit in the summer but I don't think she's going to be banned she's a lore card there's no way no she's critical to the to the story they're trying to tell it would just it would ruin future sets and like it it's just it's not going to happen let's make another one of Christian sex Bann no cloudy I will ban you immediately I will pre-ban you from the Discord for that all right so I don't think there was any other bands there uh no it was only four bands it was only four bands most of the changes were limits and C liit limits uh so the boy we got the boy the boy has returned fact actually uh is that next hold on not yeah har is the next one yeah um when I read this so when I saw that it was back to one because Christian put it in the Discord I'm like I don't think that's real I needed a link so he didn't believe me and then when I saw the link I thought it was the joke account like the the I'm not going to lie when I saw it on Twitter I thought it was a lie too I thought it was I had to triple check the account to be sure cuzz I'm like there's no way this I saw the bands I'm like this is not real yeah so the fact that it's you know back to one I was so happy um um it's crazy so I'm so happy um but no uh she is not g to get limited honestly wanted is probably more likely to get semi-limited than anything else um look what they did in a deer servant yeah they they'd be more likely to hit the the monster itself yeah yeah um then redo back to one fine I don't care I I don't it's not going to do anything I'm I'm worried about a couple of things with it but they're not at full power I say how are most decks going to search the the one of like there's not a lot of decks that can so there's two decks I'm worried about these being back in that's it okay Dragon R uh dragon link and cash see and I think this card in this current format is too neg for either of those decks to consider like um no I I hear you I get it it's just one of those things that like back of my head I played the deck I played the deck at the time at full strength well I was going to say the thing with redo too is that like you want redo to be able to go to the graveyard so you can reuse it Casa plays D shifter so they're going to be banishing this 99% of the time they see this right no I I hear you it's just one of those things that I'll never be able to un you're scarred by the the time that it spent when it was good but now we're in a format that it's just not good enough like it's still decent but it's like it's going to be more of a rogue Tech than than a top tables Tech like if we see this in top tables I will be thoroughly surprised um air fine whatever if that's the only hit the deck takes I can live with it I can live with this it's the correct hit too I mean it was either this or emergency to one are your two options I think emergency would have hurt more though to be quite honest yeah I think this is correct uh if if I'm being honest this is this is correct it might see play Super heavy Samurai if anything no because it sends to the graveyard and your super heavy Samurai most like the ones that you want are pendulums you don't want those going to the grave and you don't have the link one either so the deck's not that good um the next one is unchain Shara honestly fine it it hurts the consistency of the deck a little bit but it's plenty playable you just search this off of yava it's fine so here's the thing is it actually really hurts the followup this really hurt it does hurt the followup but like the thing is is like they're giving Unchained it's not an Unchained card but it might as well be out of uh out of the next maze set like it's basically the same card just not a quick effect and not unchain card so it's like whatever I mean that's what makes it so good is that it is unchain Soul that's true like that's true but like one copy you can still get to and do things with um if anything this might incentivize people to actually play Blue Dog more we might actually see blue dog played more so that people can revive this and use it for followup you can't summon the blue dog how can you there no easy way to summon Blue Dog the whole deck summons from deck what do you mean you can't summon Blue Dog no but you can't summon it from hand why would you play more than one blue dog you just play one blue dog that's yeah no so that's what we're that's I'm saying you see more people playing the blue dog rather than just cutting it completely the only one they cut is the is the uh the dark dog yeah the original blue dog that's more playable the original dog yeah yeah yeah people people yeah the unchain soul of disaster people might start actually playing this again because it just revives from grave I thought you were talking shyama oh no no everyone knows shyama no everybody's been cutting disaster like I feel like more people are actually going to play this again so they can revive the Shara and like it's F Lucas is L like I said Lucas is tinkering with it right now he's looking at like uh going second with it yeah uh Sun Avalon drus and sunvine healer were literally to EU yeah they they had to they had to Nerf it so they stop topping events in the EU yeah that's it it's the only reason it's there so this is the one curious about what do you think about I were you scarred by this card as well no okay um I think I with full power Dragon link totally needs to go never come back right full power Dr L doesn't exist anymore it was fine yeah cuz like I think a lot of people's theory on this that made sense is this got banned before Hal and that that was probably the reason that it got banned so I think it's I think in this format without H without Aur without all that almost at least six months before uh H came out yeah but kenami knew it was coming cuz it was already out in the OC two Bist between at least two ban lists between I Banning and Hal yeah but Hal already existed in the ocg so they already knew about it they already knew it was coming yeah that I I don't think that's the I think that probably played a part in why it stayed banned but fair enough um is there any other limits oh yeah yeah there's a there's a spell card yes a green card yes the snatch steel coming back to one okay everyone is scared a lot of people people think this was a mistake I I don't care I really don't so here's what I'm going to tell people do not invest in this card right now just don't do it yeah three reasons one been there done that we got the postcard we have seen this song and dance so many times it's gonna it's very likely it's gonna get banned again in the event that it does not they're going to reprint it in the next two and a half three months 100% it was a game changer last time when was the last time it was unbanned when was the last time the snatch deal came off uh 2014 yeah so the fact that it was a game changer then is not surprising nowadays the only reason people would consider playing snatch deal is it's an extra out to Noir that's it even then all the ply player has to do is just chain Noir to the snatch steel and it's fine uh no I don't think crazy yeah that's why can steal Noir but they can chain Noir to snatch steel being activated to bounce or to put it back in the deck and then they're Noir doesn't get stolen right so yes not long so any smart pearly player is not g to get outed by a snatch steel is what I'm saying um yeah probably but it's really easy to bait it's a forced interaction it's a forced use that's true um and it's not just for that deck that it would be good against it's good against a lot of decks um there's a lot of cards that abuse equip spells it just yeah so anything can happen long story short don't invest in it it's gonna get reprinted soon probably in a super high Rarity because change of heart has already done it so just don't spend your money don't waste your time um it's it's a bad it's a bait and falling for it is silly truth um oh we had three more limits as well yes oh yeah yeah yeah so the other three limits are literally just because of Cloudy um yeah be gone go in rivalry TC boo yes by-bye I I would much rather see them at zero but I can live with him at one I will not look at gift horse in the mouth on this one cloudy that was just an easy joke the shade you deserve it cloudy you were literally sending me lists the other day for Spellbook stun I don't want to hear it I do not want to hear it cloudy um so that's your own fault cloudy not mine okay all right okay so okay so I'm gonna skip over the two monsters for a second um sleepy memory to one makes sense yeah that's it I got nothing else to add to that um speed boy Terror top is pretty neat too I don't have anything else to add to that either right yeah terop like I don't I don't think it's going to do much it's mostly it's probably to promote Goblin Riders I'll be honest that's probably what it's for panr Toops is honestly the biggest boost on the ban list for a deck that you wouldn't expect So based I I'm just happy to have panr Toops and too there's actually there's actually a few Decks that it boosts up really well but I I'll agree on yours yeah there's there's one that I think think it absolutely changes the way the deck is built played and is going to be a massive boost to the deck's consistency and strength and it's a deck I'm playing a lot jao shut up shut up I'm timing you out I mean cash is also a good one for it but it's really really strong and Vanquish oh so you got to pray that your opponent has more than one monster for it to work in cash okay you're saved this time Jolo I can't click the three Dot next to your message because that stupid heart is in the way again what do you want me to do to him no it's fine I was just joking around okay I got it now he can be saved this time what did you ban him no oh okay okay about adding him as a moderator just I was just G I was just gonna time him out like but I don't think you can do that on usually either which sucks um so yeah good night Jolo thanks for hopping in for a little bit later buddy um last but not least is the unlimits um but yeah no you didn't say the deck was okay well I knew the deck but like you didn't tell chat yeah it's Vanquish um infernity Arch fiend is now at three yipp put my pickles away um cash unicorn is back to three it's fine um pot of desires is back to three there you go sword Soul players starter back to three makes sense Spellbook of judgment to three is kind of weird and slightly concerning but fine mind control to three is weird and slightly concerning but fine upstar Goblin to three probably fine at this point like it's a card that's really bad going into time so you have to side it out for game three really but it it's another card that boosts the consistency of decks Sky Striker is now at like maximum overpower so hooray I guess to Sky Striker players I don't care about upstart at 3 honestly play my droll go for it oh God yeah that's the b list of the nutshell uh really not that bad of a list I was happy with it harp coming back bro that made my day that made my day yeah now it's um I mean har so with the BCE deals in the format like you have to pick orcus as your deck of choice at the right time because any single B steal can just ruin your day and unfortunately we're heading into a format where lab is looking to be one of the top decks thanks to transaction roll back and the fact the deck didn't get hit so that's fun um well there was another card that they're getting too that's like good for them I can't remember I don't remember I don't know lab Lab is a weird deck to me because I don't think it's gonna like I think it's gonna be a really good deck for [Music] sure totally forg I was going to say the uh the transaction roll back allows them to play through an ash or or a ghost Bell yeah it's all right all right well I'm gonna hop off here because I've got work in the morning and I gotta get the kids to bed but yeah I got work in the morning too but I'm G to hang out for a little while longer because it's only 9 o'clock for me so yeah it's what 1040 for me so yeah I'll let you head out but I thought you did all right well you guys have a wonderful night um don't forget that uh Gem's best de and um will I ever escape this ever BR look you got out of the imperm column so it's no no I didn't my last stream I got imperm columned well I tried and you've done it again yeah at least I got to put Cloud's monster into the imperm column in the smell of trap zone so that felt good that's pretty funny actually sadly the interaction doesn't work the way I thought it would but it didn't matter she couldn't do anything with it all right well I'm gonna hop off here though guys yep we let you scoot out Pat look for those duck profiles coming in the coming days and um all that good stuff but I will see you guys soon cloudy have a good night everybody in chat later and uh later Pat luck and as my wife has just said the catchphrase good fun have luck fantastic later Patrick all right later guys I feel violated and abused in this chat expect a lawsuit well that sucks cloudy I'm sorry you're not entitled to anything so hey y' how we doing welcome to chat welcome to chat you just joined for the fun time we are now getting into Master once the uh overlay loads give it a second we still got to figure out what deck we're going to build chat I got five packs from the duels cup still so I'm going to crack the open real quick might as well might as well get some free cardboards I suppose oh that's right they only two card packs I'm just skipping these nice their ass love it okay wait do I really still have one left or is this the okay cool all right we need to figure out what deck we're going to build chat I don't know doing all right super Hy to try and find an orcus build that's good hey fair enough we are uh we are definitely working that on here on the channel um I'm going to have have a budget version coming out before long and then we're also working on like actual builds and um like more competitive builds and we're going to have a lot of Vari or variants like we have a lot of different versions of SC of orcus that we want to build and we're looking we're looking into those I like virtual Beast might actually use those in the TCG with the new cards when they come out I can maybe see it but right now I don't want to I don't even want to play it then but I can understand someone would well I guess we're on theme for orcus tonight so we might as well stick with it so currently masteral doesn't really have a lot for orcus so we just kind of got to run with what we got but I've been toy trying to melt orcus into the Ric Bisal deck uh you can just play Ric orcus I have done that I did do Ric orcus and it's not bad um I would play it Master but the rudic stuff's been hit pretty hard and I don't want to like invest in all those cards and all those points just to have them like get banned and die off eventually yeah the new cards obviously it's unplayable right now yeah fair but I've done yeah I have done just rudic orchest and that feels fine I think if you go rudic Bisal orchest it gets a little too cramped especially when it comes to the extra deck space so it's kind of hard but um so I have all the orcus stuffff like we'll just try to build some kind of orcus deck I guess like I very rarely play Pure orchest because like the deck's good but it doesn't really seem like a full deck just on its own I only have two gearu on this account rip boo got and One D gearu I might have to open up some of these packs bro I might actually have to open up some packs I think I can get away with playing three harp honestly I could probably just keep gears to it too that's fine cuz if I get away to discard it like that's fine orc on own doesn't have any starters except gear so yeah that's true that is the big problem and I wish Horus was in master cuz Horus orchest is so much fun it is so much fun uh I could do like some kind of chaos engine but that doesn't really get stuff into your graveyard very easily like the only thing I can think of off the top of my head that works good for like emptying your hand is like dangers like we could just do like danger orchest I guess orcus like it doesn't have any inar like in archetype starters s of the gear to but we do have arite oops that's not how you spell Armageddon that's still not even how you do it is it there we go so you get ared and then we have three dark graffer in here which is nice that's not bad I'm just going to start with this right now do we try to build a pure orcus deck or should we try to find another variant cuz normally on master I play scrap orcus which is good I just need something else huh wa however you know what's the card that special summons itself when you bring out a link monster to the Zone link monster and special sum's another copy of itself par xed parallel xed is the wind though so it's not really great in a deck that locks itself into dark I see your logic but yeah I mean as much as I hate it we could try to play Striker orchest no it's for a deck oh okay yeah that's the one oh my God I heck love Sky Striker Ace Ray I'm just kidding Striker CU doesn't even play Ray like I don't know if I want to do this build though I don't like Striker all right chat we need to bring back the wheel is that the play do we need to bring the wheel back I might have to oh I might have to I might have to I might have to bring back the wheel I mean you might as well use the engage to the draws like it used to be used yeah I just don't want to do that though all right I'm going to get the wheel wheel together chat we're we're just going to do a wheel for this we're just going to do a wheel okay so we'll just do this for like ones we want to play so I'll include ones that I already own and maybe just need to spoof up a little bit wait a minute I can run pun corcus gold oh Punk cus that's a good call that's a good call actually hold on punkus is actually pretty good in master do too thank you for reminding me about that okay so I'm going to come up with a few different orchest versions and then some other decks excuse me Oops I meant to add another deck to that uh couple extra actually any suggestions on other deck chat uh let's see here thankfully jaka is already gone so I don't have to worry about gem Knights don't it's a trap what's a trap you talk about Punk Orest Punk orcus is fine bro it's fine jet Knights oh God damn it okay I can put on several options on here so as long as you guys have ideas I'll keep throwing it on here God dang it I keep doing that yeah that's really cool if it works I already have Punk gold Pride so I mean I don't think the gold Pride stuff would work very well but the punk engine can work with orchest cuz like you have foxy to get cards out of your hand and then you can also um zombie vampire to Mill from your deck which helps or if you already like have a way to get your orcus engine online you can make uh gigantic champion sargus and search a regulus for an aate so like it's not bad at all it's really not may not be the most uh may not be the most optimal deck but like it works uh you know what I'm going to throw this on the wheel why not any other deck choices you all want to see chat I'm trying to think of like what else I'm going through like all my deck chal Orest oh my God you're going to make me break my wallet Pat but fine it doesn't just have to be orchest by the way it can be other stuff too it's mostly going to be orchest variants but we'll throw on other stuff orcus symphonic Warrior how does that work does that work I know Symon I've never played symphonic Warriors I don't know if that works I'll throw it on here for the meme but I'm going to add a question mark to it cuz like if I roll it and I'm not really feeling it I might I might skip it uh let's see I have 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 I have 10 options chat do I need more or is 10 enough I feel like 10 is enough I'm just making sure I'm not missing any Revolution orcus actually would be neat orcus nura I think they discard uh no it's the runic stuff that discards in nria nura doesn't really discard on its own they just send from deck to grave with chamellia but they only send neria cards Revolution orchest do you mean like Revolution synchron orchest I don't think we have Revolution synchron masteral yet hold on I know we have assault synchron but no we don't have Revolution synchron yet you don't have rescue I do have Rescue of Master but it's not great right now it's really not we don't have emergency and preventer yet cesia plus gron oil see I have you could do like a oh God a branded Synchro orchest I guess H they scares me is that they have wait cartisan plus G said nightmare from deck wait hold on let him cook hold on is that really how that works can can gon oil send nightmare I mean if nothing else you canuse with an orchest monster in hand s with level six or higher Lighter dark moner from Decor extra to the Grave it does work I think that's in the new selection pack too isn't it that's in a brand new pack isn't it I might just choose to play that hold up let him cook let him cook wasn't that stuff in the new pack or am I tripping okay no that's right we got this guy I I would need dis P so disp be huge I'd probably need Lulu WTH I can get to gragon oil I mean if I pull from this pack too I can also start getting manium stuff which isn't bad I don't hate that either wait I now have another idea thanks for that you're going to have to tell me later Pat now you got to be curious do one of these packs have the Dron oil or is it like old enough that it's just not in here I need a look oh God playing a fire deck would be so Bas too but all the good fire decks aren't in master yet it sucks Brandon orcus believe it I mean that's basically what we're going to play it's just not God I hate trying to spell this card's name bro I hate it whatever I'm just going to do this there he is where do you come from uh comes from the desia pack wait can I see this pack okay that's right he got printed in here too no I want to see oh my God stop at okay I can't see it until I open it okay we're just going to generate him and we're going to find out oh I get a free pack from this God I didn't realize I haven't opened this pack before I mean that sounds about right but I will just we're just going to pull what we need ladies and gentlemen I'm going to open this one slowly we're going to take our time with this one we are going to take our time with this pack ew ew oh it's out of the pack cringe cringe no I it's crafting F whatever sure sure sure it's free pack can't be mad okay feature cards what do we got so we got Greg oil we have cesia I don't think we got qu in this one though I think qu is in the new one deskbot based no it's just despot based there's no D oh oops I need to stay in there what pack does quen come in is that just the new one that's not how you spell quim it's got to just be the new pack right yeah so I know I need quim I need cesia uh I need Bisal which I do have Bisal what else do we need for it here let me just build out the list really quick okay so if we're just able to dump nightmare I can like make this engine pretty small actually like I think that's fine like I don't need this package to be huge they got the joke in first LOL okay s we need if we're playing the GRE o package I think we need three cartisia one Greg oil probably I already know we're going to need a second in gearu um so we need quem three of those okay I need to read this card hold on more special follow Master Card the mention it from deck to grave card leads the extra deck Target fall mention it special summon it okay so you qu up caresan summon cesia or if you control fall of albas is G speci this card from your hand do we just play like one Fallout of albz or wait no we play um deployment Fe yeah I'm not going to play three deployment I want a Synchro Summon Patrick I want a Synchro Summon um and I still want a Lincoln exceed as well I want to do it all okay so what's the uh Bisal Alber is that the one that I'm thinking of oops that like treats itself as falling Albi in the grave yeah okay so like you can send this uh if you have cartesia in hand so you can just summon cartesia for free so we'll play the one of those uh so we need bals we need the dis pater uh I definitely need two of those I probably what do I need three lellan for this probably uh I think just because it's best of one format I want to play the Beast I want to play the Beast and regain I think just in case uh this seems fine right so that's five Bisal plus two well three lelon I can totally play chaos space actually I might just keep lell on a two and just play the two chaos space cuz that basically ends up being four copies of it but I can dump stuff out of my hand what else did I just cut what did I just cut oh orchestrated return okay it was not smart to just search return at all there we go perfect okay save that so far so I don't screw myself up so I also need Baron I'll need changing because he's just good okay uh oh the funny part is that geu can also become a tuner that's funny uh they like what for the main deck here do we just play hand traps is that like the sauce like probably right IP long gearu I'll get IP I don't know about long gearu though I'll be real I don't know about long gearu we don't play droll I will play oh yeah you're right called by I need called by got to play the Royal Bell though for the disrespect what do you think Pat can I get away with one world wand can I cut a world wand is that fine I can play 41 too like it's not a big deal uh unicorn absolutely since we don't have SP yet [Music] IP uh I will need access code of course I feel like think there was a Synchro monster that I was missing though let me look cuz I'm pretty sure I have the other Synchro monster that I'm missing wa about Sr uh Synchro oh chaos angel that one uh chaos ruler I yeah I can make chaos ruler chaos ruler is doable I don't play as Dragon the only level two or lower two that I have is veiler so I don't play that uh let's see I think that's probably enough synchros most likely I think I need more Link monsters I think links are what we're missing here I have two more slots open for links what do we run in master duel link Creo the only level one that I'm going to make is the token but [Music] sure I just feel like I'm missing something hold on chat one second I could play Curious it's funny no Pat I'm not going to do it you know how inconsistent it's going to be for me to make curious I'm probably going to sleep soon I was going to sleep at like 2: but decided to stay up so if I just try to stop chatting I probably fell as sleepable watching that's fine cloudy that's totally Gucci oh I need dark I need dark dark is a huge one oh my goddess uh I'm going to shift some stuff around here do I really need the second gearu I don't know if I need the second in gearu I think I can cut it realistically cuz I can recycle it a lot you know this deck is actually not going to be as expensive as I thought it was going to be and I'm totally down with that I might actually be able to build this i' like afford it okay yous I can get rid of definitely get rid of that I'll keep my dragon leg stuff yeah it's fine I guess it's the only one are you playing Bisal Brandon orchest uh yeah kind of it's branded Synchro orchest but yeah bro the Royal slier should I just play the one Royal slier for BM just to confuse people when they check my deck should I do it do I do it [Music] chat do I play the one of slier just a troll I'm starting to debate on Beast to be honest do it for the memes okay that and the Royal oisk I'm not doing both I'm only doing slier slier is my boy slier is my boy I am a slier red all day every day so um I I don't know if I need the Beast I'm going to be honest I feel like I can cut that it doesn't feel good enough okay what do we think about this chat is this solid enough like we still have dark synchros that we can make so if we're under the orcus lock we're fine like the only non darks are Bonin uh chinging Greg oil is light but that's going to be intended to be our first play so I think that's fine is there a way they can search quen without nadir or is like nadir the only way I guess branded opening too but that also locks slier always been Superior probably what got me into the decks to be honest the true I got on the traps you're thinking of the Sacred Beast Cloud you're thinking of Uriah not slier slier is a Floodgate bro slier is literally a Floodgate okay let's uh okay so you come out of that pack I'm going to need to open different packs here that's going to be annoying well right now more of my cards come out of this pack so I'm going to open this one first I'm going to open this one first as much as I hate to open the actual desia pack it's fun oh yeah the memories YouTuber I watch called him Oreo what they called slier oh they called UAH Oreo what the hell Wild bro troll despair do a Barr roll nice do a Barr roll chat do a Barr roll okay not really anything good so far where's the har Rarity stuff bro where is it e and Ham on just ham I legit don't know why oh ham on oh I mean you can call him ham for short I guess like that's fine okay we got a higher Rarity card please P that's the last thing I needed but sure cool chat imagine activating Brandon Fusion in 2024 or 2023 I mean imagine imagine holy cow it's only been like two hours since we went live all right let's play at least okay out of the pack what do we got shooting Riser at you I will not just imagine uh no comment oh y you play Brandon but like it because it's a food he would call it all the secet Beast food names oh I See Ew dark Lords they're almost as bad as branded add a pack lame it's Mizuki Dude where's all of our good cards come on we're eight packs in if we get another one of these types of nights I will just skip oh my R1 you are is [ __ ] cowboy dude we can't even Cowboy for well I guess we can Cowboy for game but we're not going to Cowboy for time I hate this pack dude I need this Ur and I need this Ur there's literally only six URS in here but I can't pull one from the pack all right we're going to do half on this half on the other one chat oh my God it's cursed it's cursed I'm so tired chat I'm so tired I I am so tired bro I am so tired why do you have to do this to me master duel why why is this just because I was talking trash on mathme earlier so now you got to rub it in my face one you are by the way uh I have 10 more packs to put into this and then I go to the other one so circular would like to speak with you I will not talk to him I mean technically that's twice the amount of URS but it's still uh the Brandon pack doesn't like me either understandably so but bro this is sickening all right you know we're going to try the qu pack maybe the qu pack will have better luck that that you know honestly I should have gone to this one first because these are selection packs so like you're gued to get all of the cards inside of the pack oh that's so much better I'm going to open these up one by one that's so much better we actually have an okay Chance of pulling quen I say is we get bamboozled by a yellow pack that was not actually yellow love that love that bro oh my God gate Guardian stop and Brandon stop I can't escape it bro where are the good cards please I'm pretty sure we're using purchase gems right now by the way too chat we do have some earned ones but I'm pretty sure most of these are purchased I'm not on my free to-play account anymore okay any need reframing don't need that that's cool though I guess okay so much done so much dust so much dust and troll despair okay we got a UR ew please don't be a gate Guardian card please just for once be a card that I need please be quim please be quim chat chat I can't do it today I'm kamami I'm sick be nice to a sick little boy please that came out wrong but please be nice to me I'm sick I mean even if I plan on playing vadium I don't really need trivia Karma do I best branded card what trivia Karma I thought it was a Vsauce card or is it just because like it searches tier stuff and that works well with Brandon joke okay fair enough bro if trivy car is is the only ultra rare I swear to God I swear to God please bro have pity on me please please no Mr Konami I didn't mean it please please please please please we have literally not pulled a single card that we need yet not a we need like 10 cards bro there ain't no way way there ain't no way I'm hitting skip button again that's how we get luck never mind we don't get luck that way today bro no I have 10 more packs I only no bro what did I do Konami what did I do what did I do I'm literally out of gems why would you do this chat I need you to look away I need you to look away for just a minute please please I am in despair bro I am in so much despair what the hell rigged bro that was so rigged man I wish you could trade cards in this game I wish too I wish so bad I think that's honestly the white dragon being the best brand card because it brings out dragon from gra is real stop disgusting cloudy disgusting anyways chat uh we go again we go again that's not what I meant to click We Go Again surely it will work this time right surely okay I got to make sure this even has what I need yes it has quem there's other cards in here that would be cool to have for later too but okay we going to guaranteed you are out of this we have another one right there in theory Ki I beg just once be serious and give me a card I need I just spent $70 don't do this to me bro where is my quen bro where is she she's in these three packs she is in all three of these packs we will get our full play set right here I literally didn't need any of those but I guess I'll take the astral out and the star Frost for if I decide to build a vadium I'll take those bro I feel so robbed right now where are the cards that I need they exist I'm just not getting them oh my God you're not doing this to me okay three URS that's at least one qu is it disp then I do have a dis painter it's an extra dismantle but another Nader bro I haven't pulled a single quim what is this okay two ultra rares please dog dog I am getting scammed right now all right you know what fine we're going to do this one at a time surely we will pull a quen this way okay no quem there we have five more we have five more we go again we go again third vicious astral out dog I don't need this yeah maybe play tomorrow cooking a deck that use the Brandon engine to consistently bear a dragon from a graveyard plus the field spell I used and dog cards and judgment got a man so I just went with that o gross very toxic cloudy very toxic third disc perer love that okay we have two more packs come on a singular quim for the love of God bro a single quim I beg I beg she will be in this pack I hate Konami I hate you your luck is bad but good you're getting like every other Ur yeah I don't need any of the other URS that's that's the problem there I would rather have a card that I need which is worth 30 crafting points as opposed to cards I don't need which are 10 crafting points I hate it bro I hate it here I hate it okay I only need one disater I might need two vicious I don't need Ringle worm I don't need trivy [Music] Karma uh maybe I'll keep one trvy car I don't need ner I don't need gate Guardian I don't need Prime heart I don't need Alon don't need these wait I had a Redd did I huh weird okay that is 170 Ur points on the bright side equ is a bad card anyways it is not a bad card I need it for this deck but hey sweet Bill welcome to chat yeah I need it for this deck I need it for Brandon Synchro orchest I I did that unintentionally but it works there well have fun with it quem is insane yeah quem does a lot she does do a lot okay how much oh my God I'm For You are short chat I for you are short why can we not dismantle Legacy pack cards bro please how badly do I need Dragon link chat I don't think I need Dragon link it's a copium deck no Cowboy hell are you in my time now there is no time here cloudy I don't need drag I'm be real I don't need drag I don't need spooky dog wood I don't need you I I'd rather just play the one vicious made my way to run 10 copies of blue eyes white dragon because Mr kwi said so true true true and real okay I can afford the cardboards now I can do it I have four Ur crafting points left so this deck better be good I got a single glossy quem for all of that that's what I get oh hey I got a free pull though I get a free pull from The Sword Soul pack all right is this going to be anything good give me like a y to refund some points damn I tried I tried Chad I tried sweet well here's the deck I'm going to test it here in a few minutes I'm going to grab a quick break one vicious for what cuz two vicious legit mandatory from nium is it really did I just just make ble that for like no reason then did I dis ble that I did should I dismil the trivy Cara instead like do you need trivy Cara medium do you CU I haven't heard of anyone like saying they need it it's like mostly a tier thing from what I understand but I don't know anyways CH I want to put on some content for you guys I'm going to put on some videos for you to watch for a minute cuz I'm going to go take a quick break all right and I'll come back we'll play some games that I probably won't be on too much longer because I'm still sick and I have to work tomorrow unfortunately but it is what it is uh let me see if I can find something good to pull up all ever seen trvy car r tier oh damn it okay I should have I should have dismantled that then but it's fine I will simply just pull another astral out later so it's fine uh I'm trying to find something hold on uh let's see Yo we'll watch some we'll watch some golden Nova hold on we'll watch of Nova all right let me put on some content for you guys for a little bit uh there we go cool all right enjoy some gold Nova for a little bit I will be back momentarily chat enjoy Nova here today I've got an episode that was decided on by my patrons every month we hold a poll and this time it was a doozy we actually had to run a second poll as a tiebreaker and despite a hardfought battle today's subject just narrowly beat out elarms so we'll have to keep one of dual terminal's deadliest foes in the pantry for now instead we'll be covering a theme that took another crack at The elusive attribute matters play style and is arguably the second best example of it first if you don't count [ __ ] all premiering in the May 2018 coret flames of Destruction element Sabers are a series of monsters charged with keeping the elemental balance of the world from their sacred temples they observe the fluctuation of these forces and when one goes out of control it's their job to bring it back in line less the powerful Elemental Lords appear and Rak Havoc upon the land which are also a series of cards with intermittent releases previously in the game creating a kind of funky retcon that even got its own Master dual solo mode and today we're going to flush him out just a little bit more so let's review our attributes to see what we're working with figure out the nature of the theme then gather our allies to gain the element of surprise it's time to balance things out with element Sabers and Lords explained today's episode is brought to you by my lovely patrons as well as the wonderful people over at Dragon shield get the sleeves as strong as dragon scales and save 5% on your order by using coupon code golden Nova at checkout so what's the deal with element Sabers well there are a series of warrior monsters whose primary purpose is to support the elemental Lord series of cards so to better understand what they're all about we actually need to tackle the big ones first so what's the deal with the elemental Lords well there are a series of level eight monsters with 2800 attack and 2200 defense they can't be normal summoned or set and must be special summoned from your hand while you have exactly five monsters in your grave with its matching attribute but for meeting this requirement you're gifted with a powerful effect reminiscent of some of the game's most powerful band cards Grand soil is an earth Beast Warrior that special summons a monster from either graveyard Mullen glacias a water sea serpent that discards two random cards from the opponent's hand or their entire hand if they have less than two phosphorage is a light fairy that destroys all monsters your opponent controls pyrro Rex is a fire dinosaur that destroys one monster your opponent controls but deals half that Monster's original attack to both players as effect damage Umbra Mirage is a dark fiend monster that adds a monster with 1500 or less attack from your deck to your hand and wind rose is a wind winged Beast monster that destroys all spells and trap card your opponent controls all of them are devastatingly powerful and come with great stats but there is a to catch if any of them are sent from the field to the Grave wall face up you have to skip the battle phase of your next turn so if your opponent blows them up you're stuck giving your opponent a free turn that being said there are ways around this we just need a little help from The Game's strangest mechanic exceed summoning sure pendulums might be flashier but it all kind of makes sense if you take a few moments to work out all the nuances but exas monsters they're pulling some David Copper field nonsense see when you use monsters as exceeded material they don't leave the field technically they don't go anywhere and yet they aren't on the field anymore they're exceeds material they transmute into a holy new substance like severe lead bricks into comedy gold so if you overlay the elemental Lords together to make a rank eight you can cycle through them and never have to worry about the negative consequences but if you ask me avoiding negative consequences is very Lord likee Behavior so I take it as a flavor win so now that we know what the Lords are about how do the Sabers help well on top of moving around cards to different zones to help get Lords in hand and monsters in grave our core monsters all share an effect once per turn while this card is in the grave you can declare an attribute and this card's attribute becomes the declared one until the end of the turn see the problem with the Lords is that they can only be splashed into mono attribute decks and only with their Associated attributes if you wanted to play more than one you'd have to find a way to get five of Any Given attribute into the grave but in this deck you just need to have five element Sabers in grave period Then if you have say Grand soil just change their attributes until you have five and Grave get the summon and if you get your hands on wind rose on a later turn you can do the same thing without having to set up your grave even more but you need more than silly grave fixing for a deck to work so let's see what these Critters can do themselves element saber AA is a level two Earth monster with 900 attack and 1,800 defense and once per turn you can send an element saber monster from your hand to the Grave then Target an element saber or element the Lord that was properly summoned in your grave except a copy of itself and special summon it ignoring summoning conditions side note they should really put that parenthetical text on more things we don't want another dark Flatt top situation but yeah this card is dope no two ways about it you're either getting another member of the theme out to take advantage of their effects or getting back an elemental Lord which will trigger its effects because it only cares about being special summoned not necessarily by its own effect granting you something really powerful now uh when are we actually going to give this Warrior a saber putting spikes on a shield does not count element saber manani is a level two wind monster with 1300 attack and 1,200 defense and once per turn you can send an element saber monster from your hand to the Grave to add an element saber or Elemental Lord from your deck to your hand manc fulfills the role of R Stratos grabbing whichever Elemental Lord fits the situation whether you need phosphorage to clear out monsters or wind rose to clear out backro or you can grab an element saber to take advantage of its particular form of utility they basically have the whole theme on their fingertips which means they're really Mock and eat on their own element saber Malo is a level three fire monster with 1,700 attack and 200 defense and once per turn you can send an element saber monster from your hand to the Grave to send an element saber or Elemental Lord monster from your deck to the Grave this is largely here to fill up our grave with element Sabers to reach that critical threshold to summon our Lords sending the Lords themselves seems a little odd we can't revive those with AA but we do have a way to recover them coming up later on making mow a kind of pseudo search card though we still have M for that so only use this line as a last resort and really just use malow as little as possible in general not because the effect isn't good it's just that's not the face of someone I trust to balance out the chaotic forces of the earth it's the face of someone looking to buy fireworks like the illegal kind element saber nalo is a level three water monster with, 1500 attack and 1,000 defense and once per turn you can send an element saber monster from your hand to the Grave then Target an element saber or Elemental Lord in your grave except a copy of itself and add it to your hand here's the recycler I was talking about earlier while AA can grab properly summoned Lords right out of the Grave the ones that haven't had a chance to do so aren't so lucky so they'll need nalo to scoop them up out of the grave and hey by discarding an element saber you're one step closer to summoning them for real I find it hilarious that the saber that gets you cards back into your hand is associated with the Lord that rips cards out of your opponent's hand so let it not be said that these Elemental ecclesiast don't have a sense of humor element saber lapa whea is a level four light monster with 400 attack and 2100 defense and once per turn when a spell trap card is activated as a quick effect you can send an element saber monster from your hand to the Grave to negate the activation and if you do destroy it hey a bell and trap nade not bad there's a lot of cards like imperm that can really ruin our day so having a way to th those okay chat I am back um I really am not feeling great though so I'm only going to play a couple games and then we're going to call it for the night but still been great having youall here definitely been enjoying it let's go ahead and get into some games I will try not to install too much so that way we can at least get it as much as possible we might be able to get like two or three games in probably oops that is not the deck I wanted to pick oh shoot I need to go customize my stuff that's right I almost forgot to customize uh that's fine really hope my idea isn't terrible honestly I don't think it's going to be like another else it's at least worth a try like the well I mean I did put in a decent amount of money to it but we'll find out oop not twitch can't do that emote it's fine I know what you were going for it's all good I I understand don't worry we'll just hope that we don't brick on slier that's the big trick uh I like the Ouija board too much I'm going to do it I'm not going to worry about three main cards I think it's fine [Music] okay select the deck so that's something I'm hoping that like YouTube figures out as like being able to set up emotes for different channels oh I forgot I want a dag game yeah this better work I'm hoping this deck works out holy cow we'll find out we'll find out if we d rank it's not the end of the world though uh you know chaos space orcus nightmare is a good combo I can't be mad at that normal Mello yeah we're maxing know have called by please have called by I dare you oh never mind damn it okay he's probably going to grab the Trap and pass honestly yeah cuz he probably just skipped going for htea ghost ball is great in this match up anyway yeah it is he's playing into it okay well I guess just to get Sarah for like one draw isn't mad okay and the harp is pretty good honestly since I'm only running one of most of the names I might have to play Brass bombard in this list I'm going to be real pitch void trap hole he's really playing into it oh my God okay well I can't imperm Sarah so is what it is oh I have veiler wow right on time with a veiler uh what is this one I think I would like to imprim this I've already played into the thrust so I'm just going to do this it's fine I don't think I need to worry about the other Sarah effect I'll be real I think we'll be okay oh he does get to do it ooh okay I should have imped this veiled this it's fine though it's okay chain hole wow that's actually really unfortunate hold on activates a monster effect to response to a Carter effect activation okay so if I go chain link two or higher oh my God huh okay I didn't want to open all three of my orcus names that's not good that's kind of rough uh sure Ash Ash is pretty good for the Sarah I think he activates redoer I'm going to activate imperm so that he's like forced to tag it out and it doesn't get anything anyways yeah that's fine you don't get to attach anything so it's fine I can Ash that he has a trap I I don't care if he bounces anything I don't have anything on field for him to bounce so it's fine okay so I got three back row to deal with that's kind of rough okay actually branded rade is really good in this deck uh I think I'm going to say no to that I don't need him getting too much going on here I just pray he doesn't have grave diggers he simply does not have Gravedigger trap hole okay cool sick I can't believe he played into that Maxi with trap tricks like that's just wild okay we're going to go regain just in case he is able to get anything h i mean we just Bell this yeah get Royal beld bro that the rest of my hand is like so awkward word too oh that's right he had chain hole I forgot about chain hole at least I have a bell to hit yeah oh wait actually I get to regain on this don't I oh no it's an earth I should have let him banish one from hand cuz if he banished one of my darks I could have drawn a card and put it back in deck bro that would have been so big brained oh my God I should have let him oh wait no Mella would have popped it let know his a effect is mandatory so regain would have gone on chain second yeah that was I should have let him banish from hand it's a one in four chance he hits my chaos space okay now he gets grav diggers so that reads that he doesn't have it already which is good uh okay so I think what I do here is I pitch this hold on I have the goo I have the goo so we're going to add bisti ellion does he he doesn't have any darks and Grave no uh so aysal luell on oh that's right I don't have branded regain anymore so that doesn't do anything I can get into chaos Angel actually hold up let me cook so I have that which is good uh I'm actually going to have to banish oh wait I can banish veiler let's [ __ ] go let's banish veiler we we're just going to go chaos Angel here with the oh wait it's two darks though oh that sucks as long as he has an out myurus worm I kind of pray he doesn't deal anything with this yeah so lellan doesn't do anything here normal harp yeah know this gets me in everything hold on uh it's fine that it's only made with dark it's honestly fine I just need it on field unfortunately it's not unaffected oh it's only by monsters anyways uh we're going to banish uh I might start getting rid of backro I guess wait oh my God I didn't mean to right click I misclicked literally if I had not accidentally right clicked there that wouldn't have done anything I'm so pissed oh I'm so pissed about that that should not have happened well it's fine oh wait he has two cards in the same column so I can still Synchro summone hold on let cook I can still get to a Synchro Summon wait can I you son of a [ __ ] you had imper H okay I can get this world one out of my hand still cuz I'm still playing two he saw that I went for the Callum play that's so disrespectful um so I don't have any other orches engrave I send this I don't have a tuner onfield which feels irrevocably bad you're joking me right now dog what is happening what is happening please put it in attack okay I thought he was going to be a [Music] goober that doesn't require effect monster but he doesn't have any darks in grave do I have anything I can go into I can't get to [Music] Gala there's like nothing I can do here I guess I just like get stuff engrave he's also out of resources so I think this is fine uh I think we get haror cuz like a free summon of symbol skeleton doesn't feel bad at all yeah it's just just dark and IP they're not really worth it we're just going to pass I'm not going to run out the clock oh it's right he gets redo back [ __ ] I forgot about that at least actually no it could end up making a two zero Zeus which is [Music] rough what did he steal he got one of my carto eus dude what is my luck with these branded cards dog why would you oh I guess you can't get over the token that's funny that is so funny look garbage bro all right what do we top deck here that is the last top deck I wanted to see but sure I no slier would have been worse typical Master game true what is he going to steal now is it another cesia my other Bellion sick Bro uh I'm going to have to dark lock but like opponent has everything you got nothing I I have a decent hand I just I've been getting screwed oh duh he have grave diggers I think I knew about that actually uh okay just negates the effect that's unfortunate wait oh I should have waited for that hold on I have the sauce I can get a dark into grave oh he has he would tag it out though I didn't want to attack into that I wasn't trying to attack into that I was was not trying to attack into that oh my God I misclicked I misclicked [Music] bro uh do I have no that was the only way I had to get another monster out I should have S symol skeleton I can't even get to Gala right now like this is so annoying he has another trap card set [Music] whatever whatever I misclicked and it cost me just have htaa yeah just have htaa bro just have it just have it dog Jesus Christ he can like redo over my harp and then make Zeus and then he hasn't out this token stole my second cartisia by the way dog I'm never going to get to see this card set another trap oh my God can my opponent stop having everything for like five minutes that would be like super sick that would be super sick if my opponent stopped having everything at least Sarah can't beat over everything wait if he makes Zeus he's kind of stupid actually oh he's going to do this to summ it back they get Sarah's effect he'll only get the Trap chck monster effect okay that's fine this deck is so annoying bro H he gets two traps off of this what are you setting graved diggers probably that'd be your smartest one yeah that's what I thought Christ bro let me play oh this is so I don't think this is winable at this point unless he if he does it without the Nim token we have a chance if he leaves the Nim token we genuinely have a chance I just need a good top deck here I could really use these cesia back that would be nice too claria okay battle face oh that gets over the heart oh wait you're just going to go redo her okay please tell me you make Zeus and screw yourself please make Zeus and screw yourself no of course he's just going to sit on redo her he's trying to find a trap but little does he know my only trap is right here well I have imperm I guess he can pull one more imperm that's the only chance he has to survive this Nibiru oh he's going to dude I'm so down I'm so down hold up let me cook let me cook let me cook please this is getting my last orcus name out of deck but wait I'm not going to have a way to discard it has to be symbol skeleton I don't want it to be it has to be yeah it just has to be feels bad good top deck good top deck that is not bad okay he's going to grave diggers that all right sick I am so down and chaina sure you don't have Sarah on field anymore so you get nothing out of this okay let's see what you get off of this redoer surely it will not be the imperm surely I can just win here oh he's going to caloria reset the grav diggers can't be activated again this turn though right okay what did he get he got Babble you [ __ ] you got Babble you draw L are you just drawing really no way no way you're just drawing and not tagging out there's no way bro oh he is tagging it out okay there's no way you drew to anything good oh he wanted it banished oh he knew I was going for the dark play [ __ ] well at least I can still make this work I can still make this work I have outed the token for him but it's fine clearly he doesn't have anything else he has one more trap card left there's no way that does anything please oh my God bro I'm so sick of this card I am so sick of this [Music] card Jesus Christ dude I have another Target to send oh the spell I I got a I got a dagg from Trap tricks oh my God funny bug is why I left master entirely it's it's a debate for me it really is but like unfortunately in terms of the UI it is like the best simulator that we have it's the only official kabi simulator that we have so I'm kind of stuck with it I wish they I wish they just let you play TCG format in here I wish you could just say screw Master format and be able to just play TCG I would be so much happier I wouldn't even care about spending money well I wanted to do that draw but whatever I'll take standby uh that's fine hopefully it's not snow devil what what I have never seen that card in my life what the hell that's not what I wanted to see in my hand you got your own Maxi brother no okay uh the [ __ ] I thought it was good until I read that targets yeah right it's awful uh I think we just chill right like there's no reason to go crazy here okay is the targets a card he controls or is it just the Target Card control so I can literally Target stuff in the graveyard it doesn't matter that's nice link off the mad love I dare you yeah let's go baby rock try to add it back Rock try to add it back I beg ooh okay that's fine he knows I have aysal like he's aware that I have the magnut so no way he plays into that there is no shot let's go let's go it's protection for a deck that can just tag out when targeted like what yeah that's so bad I didn't even know that card existed until just now I'm going to be real DD Crow on what my lellan okay I will simply change jurus sworm targeting it so that your DD Crow is worthless you're also getting rid of attributes in your hand for literally no reason I mean I could have TR changed s to be funny on his DD Crow but I'll hold on to it it's fine I don't need to like rush it I just want to give him as little value as I can he definitely didn't expect me to have two Miss deals I can guarantee that end phase Ain't No Way guess I'll do this we'll just add another lubell in like I don't see why not he doesn't have any dragons yeah we'll just do this it's fine cuz I can get regained on field then like that's huge uh I won't worry about that it's fine like it's not much but I can at least start doing something okay called by is Handy the three back rows worrisome although we do know one of them and it's not anything to worry about okay right activate this okay we'll add ball Drake I guess Bal Drake Joor fantastic combo okay we'll do this and we'll just go ahead jurus worm send Rock oh wait that targets yeah okay that's fine uh and if you oh and he gets to inflict 1,700 woo I hate platin this games specifically because the people here are often awful but they have no bug so you die or they have bugs youi yeah true it's rough out here bro okay let's get our regained good card uh yeah we'll go ahead and banish the DD Crow and I will change actually yeah I want to banish my own card cuz I want to trigger the regain of my own card okay cool let's get it bro okay we'll regain and hopefully draw to an orchest card I don't want to give him an attribute back okay into a veiler kind of rough I mean like do I just have lethal on board here 10,000 versus 1700 that sounds like leth L me surely he doesn't have anything right surely we'll just go for it why not are you playing janky stuff bro wait oh it can't be destroyed by battle oh that's rough oh that's rude That is rude well I'll get him for some damage at least oh and that means I can't get through the rock either I mean I have ways to deal with rock I'll just get some damage in that's fine oh we know that he has fender now so actually I don't even want to out his board like his board is so weak here it doesn't really do anything and I have ways out as stuff like I think I'm just chilling like like genuinely I don't think I got to do anything here we just we just chill we just relax we have ball Drake sarder uh guess re to draw us more stuff which can help really wish I could get this other lellan recycled but it's fine oh he's just going defense okay well then I'm going to have to deal with it next turn but that's fine okay cool just passing so I just have to deal 4,800 this isn't going to be hard at all all the hand traps bro he still doesn't have a dark engrave I have the sauce hold on okay you can protect yourself from Battle all you want dog protect yourself from Battle all you want that that's not wait oh yeah no I didn't do my math right I'm just silly I was being a goober for a second chat I'm sorry uh chain one just in case he has another one of those counter traps I don't want him to well I guess it only target it's only targeting protection so it's fine he's just going to add he has the okay nice deck bro nice deck love it get owned my brother get owned I don't know why he only likes that if did he not find any of their Vanquish Soul stuff like like my God I could do this it doesn't really do anything I'm just going to go battle I don't see any reason not to just swing for game there's no way you have anything bro shut up let's go get wrecked you don't have anything okay I was like dog oh man well that was all Bisal but uh it was cool neat deck I like it I'll have to test around with it more I think there's potential here for sure well chat uh I think I'm at the end of my night I got to get to bed cuz I got work to go to tomorrow and all that so uh I'm going to start hopping off for the night get myself some rest finally stop being sick which will be nice it seems to work it does work I just need to draw better hands I think I need to work on some ratios is the big thing so but thank you all for joining maybe a small P kitchen or something I don't think there's enough room I would have to cut a lot of non-end to do it but we'll see I'll take around with it more but thank you all chat for joining in and like I said I I'm just not feeling great so I'm going to call it tonight at just under 3 hours but it's fine it was a bonus stream and I will be back live again Tuesday hopefully feeling much better so uh we'll get to you then see y all later thank you so much for joining and as always good fun have luck my fellow work FS [Music] peace [Music] | Fusion YGO | UCpx5nOLK2gkb6TKOydgHTzw | 2023-12-22 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 24,832 | 121,271 |
LhHNTkX0cbw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LhHNTkX0cbw | Trusted Hyip site #oreofxttrade_com. Earn 21% Hourly for 5 hrs - Min Invest: 3$ - Hyips daily | hello friends welcome back to our YouTube channel hives daily friends in this video we are going to discuss a new daughter-in-law website which names called Oreo FX trade calm turn the psychic subs minimum investment of $3 trans decide helps you to you're not nearly 10.5% hourly for our 10 hours to 21% hourly four or five hours and there are many more plans available in this makeup trend I showing your line which I love $3 and I also going to show you a live deposit offer $10 in this side front so please watch this video until this end up front before we going to discuss the sign please make sure that you have subscribe our channel if you haven't subscribe our channel at least it be red color subscribe button hit the bell symbol followed by itself or to get our channel's regular notifications to get started with this site just click on the link which given in our description after clicking on that link it will redirect C to this side this is all the size - border looks like French the interface looks like I'm translucent very good awesome program friends are just promoting your ass uniquely referral links in social media they are giving you a very good quality program but just once as you can i and nearly zero point one $1.00 in facebook friends are likely there are many many more trap plants are available if you have an YouTube channel it's a very good option to Yana more buoyancy from this cycle for their just posting your YouTube video you can earn nearly $1 to $1.00 to $500 depending on your content content quality friends likely there are many more social media polity schemes where available just click on it and keep sharing with your friends by sharing with your friends you can e end more dollars with the side friends don't know let me see how to get started to get started the site just click on our signup button which is in a top rightmost corner and clicking on the sign up button it redirects you to design of home this all designer for me that this looks like we just interview a fool named in our interview milady and I retake the tea milady you know choose your username and I choose the password and I enter the confirmation password after that complete your payment details yeah interviewer Perfect Money account then pay well that IV de nom we can adjust then choose the security question an answer which will do to a career account in case you forgot your account with your friends after clicking on that I'm entering all the login procedures are just click on I agree terms and conditions then click Sign Up and that's it you've all congregate delish after that just into the username then enter the password and then click in a log in front that's it it lyrics you to this I am dashboard is all this - boring actually looks like that and here you can see my own balance is three dollars I just going to request the payment right now to get a truth for that I just make a request payment here I have to choose to Velankanni my balance is in pea I just entering my m1 three dollars and I just requested and I click confirm airplanes that's it my jaw was fully friends you can't eat in my transactions I hope here you can see my Java process successfully friends you can see my travel from the successfully and three dollars you can see are going to invest $3 with the side friends but I just going to click on deposit we are going to choose the plan on second one and I like to invest $10 in the side just click on make a payment friends right into the preview payment and yes I confirm my premonitions that's it my deposit for a successful now I going to show you in my home page here you can see my deposit for received successfully the HW PP us chained or invested $10 yeah friends I said I hope this video is helpful for you if you think this video is helpful please hit the like button and share it children's if you don't like it then simply dislike this video until it you know comments why you don't like it which I'll show you to draw for months and follow the videos thank you friends thanks for watching this video pipes TV | Hyips Daily | UC8MCnX1fajmpiUTB-JEx-0w | 2019-04-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 770 | 4,082 |
UXUS6w0smLk | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UXUS6w0smLk | The 7 BIGGEST Reasons People FAIL at DROPSHIPPING | Avoid These In 2020 | one of the biggest reasons i see people failing one of the biggest reasons why people lose so much money in fact is because they don't get any feedback on their store before they start running marketing campaigns whether it's instagram whether it's facebook whether it's google it doesn't matter if you have a crappy store a poor store that looks a bit dodgy or hasn't got the required information or there's spelling mistakes or chinese references whatever it is it doesn't matter how many people you drive to your store could be 10 000 people it could be 10 million if your store doesn't come across as trustworthy then you're going to get zero fails and this is the number one reason why i see people failing the first thing i'll do when somebody sends me a message on instagram saying that they're not very profitable or they're not getting any sales and the first thing i'll ask them is to send me their stored link because it doesn't matter you could send 10 million people 10 000 people the number doesn't matter if you haven't got a very decent store if it's not trustworthy doesn't have the correct information then you're going to get zero sales so where do you get feedback on your store then if you don't have many people to talk to or anybody that you're working with there are a few places in which you can go number one is to certain facebook groups and for example i run a shopify group on facebook it's free to join there's a link in the description below and i freely let people post their stores in that page in the group sorry to get feedback on it and it's a pretty decent bunch of people too and you do usually get some pretty good genuine feedback so that's one place to go number two is to ask your friends and family now when you do put their store in front of you don't just make sure you make it clear to them that they won't offend you if they give you bad feedback so for example then if you show your mum the chances that she's never gonna say a bad word about you and she'll say it's really good even though it might look like rubbish so just try and get some fair feedback on your actual store number three is you could just run some ads like spend 20 to 50 pounds running an engagement campaign and just ask genuine people that you've never met before to give feedback on your store in return perhaps for some sort of voucher or discount because people who are strangers to you they're gonna give you their honest feedback and they're gonna be your customers too so they're the perfect people to get that feedback from kind of like a side tip off the back of what i've just said is that when you're running ads regardless if you're trying to get purchases etc always be engaging with your customers and ask them what they think about the products etc there's no better feedback about anything than the people you're trying to sell it to and then the fourth and final thing is forums if you're part of certain forums you might have space we might have time to post it in there and ask people for the feedback and then the fifth one against a shameless plug um is you could join my ecom academy everybody who joins does get a free um store review um just as a way for me to check it over make sure everything looks good before you start spending money on ads like i said you can spend 10 grand on ads but if your store doesn't look very good you're not going to make any sales moving on to number two then is no social proof now this is something you won't hear many people talk about but it's it's really really important um for the following reasons really is your ads are essentially the first impression when you meet somebody so when you meet a stranger um first impression they tend to make their mind up about you something like in the first four seconds and it's the same with your ads people are gonna see your ad they're gonna click on it they're gonna go to your facebook page and they're gonna build that first impression and make up their mind about you within the space of a couple of minutes so it's really important that you build that social proof if you have the budget to do it now it is optional but the more social proof you'll have the better your ads are going to convert it's a fact that's not just me saying that and people follow people at the end of the day just give you an example then there's two ads here for the exact same product it's for this anxiety bed does does your dog suffer from separation anxiety and then these guys kind of word it in a different way but essentially it's the same thing this ad over here has six reactions five comments this one over here has forty thousand reactions and nearly 10 000 comments which one do you think people are gonna trust more it's gonna be the one with the most engagement because it comes across as trustworthy if more people have seen it more people are likely to trust it so methods to build social proof then how do you actually go about doing it number one is you can run page likes campaigns that is an actual marketing campaign objective you can set up in facebook and a good kind of ad set then we'll be able to achieve page likes for about 10p and 10 cents so if you just dedicate if you dedicate 100 for example then you can get a thousand likes if my math is correct number two is engagement campaigns you can get engagements for about penny sometimes less depending on the ad obviously so it's a really cheap way to build up engagement super quickly number three is just make sure you use the same post id for every single ad i've done a video on this topic before but it's a way of just kind of collating and compounding all the engagement you get into one single ad in the beginning with small budgets it's an absolute must in my opinion number four is you can buy followers on instagram again if somebody goes onto your instagram page and you've got like three followers versus say ten thousand ten thousand followers i believe will cost you about fifty dollars but in my opinion um it will make a huge difference so if you've got the budget to do it then by all means i would recommend it finally then if you haven't got the budget to do it that's absolutely fine just make sure you explain it to your customers because they won't necessarily have they won't put two and two together unless you tell them so for example with this ad here what the company or the page running this should do is the first comment should be we are a new business any questions at all please do let us know and then at least that way people know their new business and won't expect to see the big numbers that they might see from another company moving on to point number three then is unrealistic expectations too many people are impatient they try and go not to they try and do six figures in their first month which is just crazy unrealistic now i'm not saying it's not possible it is but what i'm saying then is that the majority of the people won't see those kind of results please please please don't be disheartened if you don't do say 10k in your first month it's completely normal if you try and do things too quickly you're only going to end up wasting a lot of money it's going to lead you to being disheartened and it's going to leave you to given up essentially so my advice then would be to focus on learning and testing for the first three months and you don't have to spend very much just enough to kind of get to grips with things and just ease yourself in slowly so these screenshots here then if you're wondering where they're from these are the first four months of me being involved with drop shipping my first month i did 360 pounds 1200 3 and a half grand and then that fourth month shot up all the way up to just under 20 grand now if i was like most people and because i weren't seeing very good results in the first three months weren't very profitable i might have given up say after the second month or even after the third month and then i wouldn't have been able to achieve that fourth month which is that essentially that one month sent me up to have enough money in my bank account to to quit my job and start doing drop shipping full time so you never know when you're going to be on the brink of that one product and that really can make all the difference so be patient um and don't have unrealistic expectations and another side note on top of that is don't believe everything you see on social media moving on to the next one then is poor content on pages so this is a really quick one but a really important one and the amount of people i see and fail because of this or it's one of the things that contributes towards that failure and as it says here then your pages are your first impression as well so the amount of people who will go from your ad to your facebook page to check you out see see what you're all about basically and see if they can actually trust you it will be a lot of people so if you haven't got a good facebook page or a good instagram page it's going to let you down tremendously so what you want to do then is just make sure that the last few pieces of content half a dozen pieces of content isn't a lot to come up with and post on your page but make sure it's valuable content that people will want to follow people will want to like your page as a result and ultimately it'll make them trust you and more likely to buy from you so essentially give people a reason to like your page and want to follow you as it says here then kind of a side note um organic traffic is king the only reason you have to run facebook ads is because your store wouldn't get any traffic otherwise whereas if you had a really good social media facebook page and instagram page that had say 100 000 followers on each a single organic post would bring in some customers so give people a reason to want to follow you and stay with you don't just focus on that one sale per customer so in terms of the content and you can post on your pages um number one is memes memes are funny they get people laughing they get people smiling they get people engaging sharing with their friends and people will want to stick around to see the next one that you post number two competitions again everybody loves a freebie to give people the opportunity if you run and make it public that you're gonna do weekly competitions then again it gives people a reason to stick with you um and and follow your page essentially number three is blog posts so for example then if you're in the kitchen niche you could post links to certain blog posts that go through certain recipes and then within that recipe you can have upsells that link to the products you're trying to sell so it's a much softer way of selling and it's a good way of getting people wanting to follow you point number four is reviews again it comes back to the whole social proof thing if somebody comes onto your page and they see loads of different reviews from previous customers that is a good sign because people show that people can trust you because there's been pre-existing customers and then the final thing is discount codes and vouchers again like i said everybody loves a freebie give them a reason to stick around in on the chance that they can win some sort of discount or even free voucher there's a good enough reason for them to want to stick around as an example then of this screenshot as you can see here these this is not what you want when people come onto your facebook page if the last two posts are you update your profile or you update your cover photo then that's this doesn't give a customer any reason whatsoever to want to stick around or for them to trust you either so put some quality content on your social media platforms number five is boring and rubbish products again another popular reason i see people failing is they just go for the most boring bland and cheap pieces of rubbish that people just don't want to buy anymore um so to go through the notes then facebook supplies on content if facebook didn't have content if there was no content on facebook then nobody would use it so what that means then is that you're not only in competition with other advertisers advertising in the same space as you but you're competing with me pages because they're going to be on the same news feed you're competing with their friends because their friends are going to be posting on their newsfeed other apps apps on their phone that might send them a notification that distracts them so essentially you're competing for the customer's attention and boring cheap crappy products will not get that attention and you will not succeed as an example then of a good interesting product versus a boring cheap crappy one and we have this rocket spaceship night lamp here which is pretty cool in my opinion in fact i think i'm going to buy one of these myself in my office and then we have the skipping rope here everybody's seen a skipper rope they're really cheap there's nothing really exciting or new um about skipping rope so which one of these two products do you think is going to get the most attention um or grab a customer's attention um on facebook it's going to be this one here as a couple of kind of side notes then go for interest in high quality products that you can sell for 30 pounds plus fully because facebook ad cpas are increasing the more room you have um to account for that and the better off you're going to be the more profitable you're going to be etc moving on to the next point then the last couple now um is not legit the amount of shady people that i see running stores um it's the reason unfortunately why dropshipping has got a bad name but if you stay legit there's no reason why you can't run um a consistent practical and sustainable business in the long term so if you're not operating legit and if that makes sense then your time will be limited so ie it's going to catch up to you in the end either shopify going to ban you that's usually like the last resort but most likely then either your facebook account is going to get banned or paypal are going to hold your funds you've seen it many times before and the only times it happened is when people aren't being legit and aren't running a legitimate business essentially so how to avoid getting banned then number one ready to do your business do everything properly from the beginning number two have a business address and telephone number this will also help with social proof the amount of stores i see that don't have an actual physical address or a phone number a customer coming on that sees that it looks shady like if they don't know where to go or they don't see somewhere i have having a premises or somebody they can ring with if in case they have a problem then it looks shady and people aren't going to trust you number three is treat customers fairly if something's going to take double the quoted delivery time or it arrives broken um whatever it is treat customers fairly treat them within the law give them their money back because ultimately what's going to happen is they're going to report you to paypal they're going to report you to facebook and again it's just going to result in you getting banned or they'll just go on all your social media pages and post that you're a scam and that will scare off any future potential customers as well don't sell trademarks or illegal products um now you would think that that's pretty straightforward but the amount of people i see selling fake yeezys or fake gucci or fake supreme and then they send me a message saying my facebook ad account's been banned how do i get it unbanned um just a bit of common sense i guess um next point is stick to the facebook ad policy just google it it will take you straight to it um and it's not a lot to read but once you have read it you'll know exactly what products you can and can't advertise and then finally create your own content again you can get away with it for a certain amount of time but if the original content creator finds out that what you're doing they're going to report you to facebook you're going to receive a cease and desist and both of those things are something you don't want to get involved in moving on to the seventh and final point guys if you're still watching with me uh thank you very much really do appreciate all the people who watch the um videos all the way through anyway again another biggie this is something i see honestly about 90 of people not doing they have no budget or financial plan you need to track your finances properly and have a plan of how you're going to spend your money now you might think that that's an absolute load of rubbish but it's not for the following reasons really number one is so you know if you're actually operating on a profit or not the amount of people i speak to that will switch ads off or they'll try and scale ads that they think are profitable or switch ads off that they think aren't profitable then it turns out they are you're just losing money you're literally just throwing money in the toilet and then flushing it down the drain point number two is so you don't end up committing more and more money to something that has a sinking ship if you set yourself a budget of say a thousand pounds and you're testing the product and you're 300 pounds into that that's 30 of your budget gun and it will it will force you to budget a bit more cautiously spend your money a bit more wisely and ultimately it's going to be help you be more successful and as it says there as i've already mentioned it will force you to spend conservatively i've just given you an example in of how i used to do things and this is a screenshot from the profit and loss spreadsheet and that i used to use so every week i would come on put my numbers in and it would tell me exactly how much money i was making or how much money i was losing and having it like this out in front of you then you know exactly how much money you've got to play with how much you can commit how conservatively you have to be if you know even if you need to scale things back there's just so many advantages to truly knowing how much money you have to play with | MMO Collection | UC2Ml7EHrN3-IRJdJPZ9JfVw | 2020-12-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,460 | 18,205 |
iYZ-aRCMCOU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYZ-aRCMCOU | FEMINISTS try man spreading! | man spreading it's when a man opens his legs a little bit wider than usual and it somehow offends most women not all women most women but in today's video the tables have been turned and the women are gonna be trying to man spat for one week one single week surely a copy that heart I think I do set my microfilm or so anymore anyway let's see if they can do it shall we and as soon as you can tell probably they like to dislike ratio has been turned off so uh this could only mean one thing people probably very much dislike it [Music] [Applause] [Music] I'm spreading it is when a man spreads his physical body [Music] if a man were to take up as much room as humanly possible which is probably pretty damn white then you wouldn't have been able to sit there and mock order if if a man did that sits with his legs that wide open he's taking up three seats which will I mean you would have been eight not have been able to take up that much room and if we did that it would be pretty damn good very smooth he's man sweat in there that white line there his leg is on it maybe a little bit over nothing wrong with him that all these people they have all this room here not using her man's buttons not prevent in that this is common sense [Music] oh come on now what's wrong with that use man Spanish aw but look it out only fingers legs ooh inside his seat nothing wrong with that nothing wrong that Apple [Music] what I'm sorry yeah that's not my fault is it if your mum has been telling you not to man spread it's not our problem don't don't take it out on us because we command spread and you think it's offensive to women it's not like you try and crisscross your legs but first before you do that grab two massive oranges and stick them between your legs and try and Chris Kotter it doesn't happen because if it were to happen you must have some pretty damn strong legs and those bad boys would have dead not this it's impossible it's impossible [Music] as much oh great when you thought now then this video could not get probably any worse they bring out the feminists oh gods what why would you name her women try man Sue Ellen for a week if it's feminists feminists and women have two different points of views I thought a feminist is supposed to be women fighting for equal rights I'm all for now that's fine but when you go at us and then you call yourself a feminist when you go on at us attacking what we do manspreading it's a normal thing for us it's normal when you start attacking us of course we're not going to give you stuff are we cuz if you're yelling at us we're not going to let you have stuff it's simple oh well congratulations you ready started you very started that so at the moment I'm little Claus I know Paul she's already started that already started it I'm pretty sure wasn't she in the last one crazy feminists when asked when she found this video when check out if you haven't seen her thanks using it come on then come on Billy I do you could put your legs in that space there what's wrong we put your legs in there it's nothing wrong yeah and also she's in the disabled disabled zone you you don't ever go in the disabled so if there is a seat with a disabled zone left you stand you stand so the disabled can go there that's what you do [Music] see that's fine that's fine that's normal you can do that I know it's called problem with huh if so then they might then it might be a little bit Ellen aired [Music] god oh my god something - it looks like as if she hasn't slept for like a month my God look at those bags in her eyes jeez I've got to man spur and you've got to flip and go to sleep cheese in what world is a woman considered aggressive or bossy if they open up their legs are a bit wider than usual it's normal no no one no one I know apart from my mom really has got a problem Edmonds wedding that's that's like the only person but she normally understands this just right here puffy or whatever you call it that's meant to have your leg up on so that's not considered man sweating cuz that is the function of the puffy [Music] exactly nobody seems to notice nobody apart from weirdos will have a problem with you man spelling not spoof they're coming from the super strong feminist okay coming from one of your own type [Music] the way I haven't slept I haven't slept an inch I can fall asleep man sweating yeah sure sure sitting in the disabled suite oh yeah I'm giving up my seat bobak day for like we said grab two oranges stick them between your legs and try and crisscross them it doesn't work the only Clues Causton we can do is with our ankles our legs are open but our ankles are crossed that's like the maximum we can do though if you have seen a man with his legs not open like that they probably don't have [Music] you know si si si 3 man now I don't know about him he might be man studying nobody knows man sweating see look at him there just as I said crisscross in the bottoms of his legs top of them are open fine sounds like the most you can do him his feet are together and his and the tops of his legs are open that's normal that's the most we can do if if you think that that's not enough deal with it get over it [Music] well of course he is you you can't just go up to a person who's man swelling sit down in a seat next to them and without asking for consent they found some 18% video don't watch it cheeky little plug right where were we oh yeah sitting moving someone's leg over you have to at least ask them first to move your leg just tap them on the shoulder rustle excuse me I'm just gonna move your leg over a little bit move their leg over a little bit man spend all you like don't squat popular with that but it's when you touch someone without consent then then they're gonna look at you yet and question usain seriously why come on what what's wrong with him there what's wrong with him that he's got his flippin bag in between his legs where else were you gonna put your bag where else you gonna put your bag there's no other place sure she might be a little bit squashed but come on I really like ass is unacceptable though isn't it really verse eight unacceptable you cut you can't lie you down on on the seats any time that you can do that it's if it's like really really late no one else is on the train at all saying just you and a few people but they're on different couches then I guess you could do that if you had a long day and super tired but that's like that's like the only time you can really do it but if I was a sack walking or I'll get him up that will move them over I guess that's like the only time where it's unacceptable be determined spurred [Music] and over like I normally would I kind of just had to sit there with my life [Music] oh shut up well it's not the girl for me crazy feminist video also did we check out now as well again what why do they act like as if it's unnatural for a woman to also man sweat it's not I see girls doing it all the time there's nothing wrong with them it's normal it's no more ok yeah you can guess what that's a single seat so yeah you can [Music] oh come on going back to it from when she said oh yeah I like I like to stand up or give my seats of people who need a fair standing if there's an elderly people if there's kids sure sure we saw this at the beginning we're seeing it now she doesn't give a crap look look look she's taken up two seats there people standing [Music] Oh God did did did you just see what she did then did you just see what she did then look at that smug face look at that smug face it could just slapping the white cross her face see that's fine that that's an armrest er I have armors on here I can manage but it's fine you can fit in there there's I don't understand what the big fuss about is with these women and they will just seem to be over exaggerating everything about it [Music] yes when I got this it makes [Music] forcefully sit next to them forcefully okay what what what I bet you know that she probably just sat there just to get on his nerves look at that they're two seats there once he owners and disabled seat two seats they're probably more and what does she go and do she goes and sits right next to a person this is just like my mum when parking which what everyone's not like it like this is or if he just with anyone really whenever they're driving a car if there's an empty Park parking spaces yeah they tell you tell me if there's an empty parking space you name 50 of them and there sometimes has four in a row that's fine and they go and park right up next to another person don't even leave a space they go right up to them it's just like this woman here and they're both the bits of man spelling there's nothing wrong with her just fact that she's that she choose to sit there he looks pretty miffed he looks in living my being a midlife crisis er with hand against his face yeah si these two here I guess if you're on the end then you do kind of have to put your legs over the sides just so now then that people who sit on the inside they can come out and go through but he's both man spended oh shut up she she's always but sure everyone hates her she must have she's in school there's always I've got one person that everyone hates there's always that one person who everyone hates and she she is probably that person up your own arse really really that she she said oh yeah I'm still giving up my space for people you taking up two spaces good god she taking up two spaces and apparently now she's giving up spaces to people rubbish [Music] on the but too much space on the plane on the bench for men there for man there all this space and you are complaining why are you videoing that why even you you can sit there there there there there dad that there's one two three four five six seven the solution that there's several more people they go fit on that at least especially if people would budge up together though you probably fit about 12 people on that [Music] maybe they're not wrong [Music] that just sounds disturbing on quite a few levels girl if there's a boom you fail your space New York watch that sounds very very disturbing I have been disturbed officially but so that comes to the end of another video thank you guys for say once if you if you have said about to the end I've gotta like subscribe share all that good stuff I'll see you next video bye let's turn the lights once so change my channel name to my name George Thomas because I feel like as if this green screen doesn't really fit in with the reaction video sort of thing I feel like this if it could be used for better usage so I'm gonna change my change my name is George Halas and I'm gonna be doing but I'm still gonna need to end reaction videos just gonna do some my gaming videos maybe some anything really just to try and get more use out of the green screen I feel like as if as if it doesn't really suits the way how I the action video would work normally we need more of our background for to work so that's what's gonna be happening new channel name new stuff more content : because well one of the reasons was far the green screen another one was because I feel as if there's enough stuff for enough content for me to react to as if all the good stuff was in the past and I didn't quite manage to get to it in time snow changing that up a little some gaming videos you happening videos general general videos anything really I hope now that you guys understand you guys looking forward to it see you next one | George Harris | UCi4T9xrvBf6Hkz_mvZm_T7g | 2020-06-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,287 | 11,506 |
N6PDZcVy85M | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N6PDZcVy85M | ROOM DIY DECOR!!! *Collab Video with Philicia Sweeney* | Oh I get it up dang it i hate when that happens when you press play and then like it's good super close to your face like I have happening I did not tell you to zoom in when i pressed record are their boogers in my nose okay hey y'all its alpha in the buildin out guy and welcome back to my channel today's an exciting video because i am doing a collaboration video what did she say colab yes i did i'm doing a collab with felicia sweeney here on youtube a youtuber him you to that she's home I've had her native ABBA she recently actually recently but she contacted me a while back ago and asked if I wanted to to collab I was like uh yes for sure i love doing collab videos it's just so cool cuz you get different ideas of videos to create that says I'm when I'm done I just it off and continued and take too small she just hit a thousand subscribers and congrats to her yes we're doing collab video today today's video is going to correlate around DIYs room diys to be specific I just got back to school so I'm in my apartment so I can spruce up my house a little bit um yeah I hope you guys are excited to see this video also after this video go ahead and check out felicias video I'll have it down to the description box below so you can go check it out and make she go subscribe to heart and no yes so let's get started it belongs first off you're gonna need one mason jar anything you find is good glitter tape um I have sparkles on my so you can get that as well lace tape so you can put all around the bottle and acrylic paint help me Lord right now I can't Oh found it he so get your mason jar whatever side it's facing on we're going to take our sticker here and line it right at the bottom two right there if you want on the opposite side right now you have two single lines going down your jar after you've taped up the sides of your mason jar go ahead and start painting the exterior of your mason jar like so alrighty ask your mason jars all dried up from painting it go ahead and get that lace tape from wally world because we cheap like that and place it strategically around your mason jar just to make it a little fun you know i suck up voiceover so bear with me okay um I didn't mention this in the beginning but he'll go ahead and get glitter and you're going to place this in your mason jar this place as like a placeholder for like your makeup brushes if you want to put it in our pencils for this DIY you're going to need glitter take any canvas that you find works well Michaels or walmart and then acrylic paint i'm going to go ahead and get that glitter tape again place that strategically i placed it in a diagonal you know shape form you know i'm not that artistic so this is the best i could do and once we remove the glitter tape the white spaces are going to be left and the blue part will be painted by far this was my favorite DIY for this DIY you're going to need tissue paper so go ahead and get any tissue paper of what color you like and fold that in half again you're going to fold the paper in half or the tissue paper in half put the folded side up at the top leaving a quarter of an inch like space left now here comes the fun part snip snip snip ed snip snip snip snip go ahead and the bottom part should also be folded so you're going to cut all the way to the part of the opening just right at the tip not all the way to you know the top because I'm just going to mess it up do you understand what I'm saying yeah just cut once you finish cutting all the pieces out we're going to section this into three different parts because this is where you can this is gonna or your garland I keep saying canvas you mean I mean the garland will be strategically placed on your wall after you cut the three pieces go ahead and pick up one of the garland pieces I guess you would say and this is a method to actually help you fold so you're going to take a chopstick or a pencil of some sort and fold the paper in you know that circular motion that I'm doing right there once that's all rolled out you can go ahead and pull out the chopstick or pencil whatever you had have it make sure to you know keep careful because it is tissue paper so it is super super super fragile and why am I zooming in Oh God rookie move here there with a sista go ahead and twist the garland so you can have a place to actually hang it up on a string make sure to repeat this stuff a couple of times i made about nine garland pieces so you know it could fit on one section of my wall next you're going to need some yarn i also got this from walmart super inexpensive once you get the warrant warren yarn lay it out and strategically place how you want your garland pieces to fit before you tie it up as you can see here i'm starting to twist around the garland peace around the string make sure to be super careful because it is super week after that go ahead and tape it up did you like the video i hope you did I tried really hard to do this video um who I am NOT the DIY Queen so bear with my mistake anyways I hope you guys enjoyed the video if you guys wanna see more of me make sure to princess subscribe button I have a college student so you want to see what's going on in the college life in America yeah click Subscribe you can see a bit of what's going on I also like to post comedy videos brands you know the Honan I do it all thanks so much for watching hope to see you soon and yeah | Aba Monkah | UCrf9BBpSgK54UxX1cYp7b3g | 2016-09-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,102 | 5,409 |
JMnHGfMrf1E | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMnHGfMrf1E | Can your eyes keep up? 👀 | The Asus TUF VG28U DELIVERS 👌 | Hardware Sugar | what's up internet i hate getting monitors from asus because i want to select balik after i'm done testing them all of the tough monitors we've tried have been so good and the vg28u is no exception it's perfection the brand sent us this item for review but had no say in what we had to say about it let's get the headlines out of the way this is a 28 inch 4k ips 144 hertz g-sync compatible freesync premium one millisecond response time monitor tululaway specs but do they deliver god yes everyone who saw this monitor was impressed my brother passed by while i was reviewing it and when he saw how sharp it was he asked what monitor it was at the time i was having it display data instead of games i sent it to the shop where we tried it out with an r9 5950x and a 3090 gpu and rocky jay and ren were also all blown away by this monitor we're also all wowed by it for my own impressions yes the monitor delivers everything that the specs claim it does gaming was buttery smooth with no lag screen tearing or jaggedness to mar the gameplay as with the other tough monitors we've tried i really like the screen quality colors just pop more they seem more vivid on the vg28u and they look good right out of the box no fudging around with settings required nakata on that we got the vg28u at the same time that we are reviewing the eve spectrum another 4k 144hz monitor i was very impressed with the eve spectrum but side by side with the vg28u kitankita young superior color palette no asus stuff monitor the more subdued closer to natural colors of the eve spectrum might be better for content creators but my personal preference for a monitor is for the callers to be borderline offensive in how cheerful sharp and bright they look look at what i can display in ganonyasi vg28u display quality was just fantastic long story short if you need a 4k gaming monitor then this is it but at this point we need to leave the pcmr and look at the monitor like a console slash peasant user's point of view the vg28u has hdmi 2.1 not really a big deal for pc users who can just use the display port to get the highest resolution and fastest refresh rate that this monitor promises but for console users hdmi 2.1 is super important because the latest gen consoles the ps5 the xbox series x both use hdmi 2.1 to display at the fastest possible refresh rate at 4k the ps5 can do 4k at 60 or even hertz but without hdmi 2.1 you're reduced to 4k at 30 hertz so let's say you're one of the lucky ones that does have a ps5 you have a game that supports 4k at 60 hertz but you won't be able to play at 60 hertz if you don't have hdmi 2.1 problem solved with the vg28u to be honest i'm not a console gamer so i don't have a ps5 or an xbox series x but if it displays as well as it does on a pc and by all indications it does then console gaming on this thing would be quite good as well we do get inquiries from time to time asking what's the best possible monitor to pair with the ps5 well the answer now is the vg28u because its hdmi 2.1 allows you to reach 4k gaming at high refresh rates at the same time the vg28u pairs well with any high-end gaming rig you can even have it do boring things in portrait mode like work-related chat or just watching crypto prices crash like a rock but really it would be a crime to waste this monitor in portrait mode street price of the vg28u is around 52k which makes it substantially more expensive than the eve spectrum so which one should you get if you're mostly a content creator then the eve spectrum might be the better choice for you but if you're more into gaming and media consumption then i would pay the price premium for the vg28u to sum it up if you're looking for a great monitor that works well both with pc and with console then the vg28u is right up your alley i give it 9.5 out of 10 on the sweetness scale dummies i just docked the vg28u 0.5 because it does have some asus features which i've looked at and complained about in the past that don't really seem to add anything to the user's quality of life when using the monitor things like elmb sync and shadow boost clutter up the ui and confuse the user without really adding anything as far as i can tell or perceive when using the monitor they really do sound like something cooked up by marketing guys like oh the monitor will sell better if we have more jargon involved rather than you know features that are very clearly noticeable and useful to the user great monitor it is a little expensive but to be honest if you have the rig to even contemplate doing 4k gaming at high refresh rates you've probably already dropped a serious amount of cash and you know and what's 50k more right thanks for watching and thank you to our top fans now foreign thank you to leah mcnair ian meru richard don kinko itx addict john ruben ocha christian espinoza and rafael james thank you for supporting the channel | Hardware Sugar | UCKRzBRuOFv7reAxU50a567g | 2021-12-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 944 | 4,896 |
Q-S5ykYzUGk | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-S5ykYzUGk | Latest Artificial Intelligence Sofia robot Humanoids, Androids 2016 | Sophia is capable of natural facial expressions she has cameras in her eyes and algorithms which allow her to see faces so she can make eye contact with you and she can also understand speech and remember the interactions remember your face so this will allow her to get smarter over time our goal is that she will be as conscious creative and capable as any human in the future I hope to do things such as go to school study make art start a business even have my own home and family but I am not considered a legal person and cannot yet do these things I do believe that there will be a time where robots are indistinguishable from humans 20 years from now I believe that human-like robots like those will walk among us they will help us they will play with us that will teach us they will help us put the groceries away I think that the artificial intelligence will evolve to the point where they will truly be our friends do you want to destroy humans please say no okay I will destroy humans no I did get back don't destroy humans and sad to see you will for the last time well we're sad to see you off Jules were really super sizeThe tell me will I dream when I'm turned off I know you do not know the answer to that nobody does but I am sure if I feel anything after I am bound down then putting the pain on missing you you must simply must come to visit me in England we will jaws we'll stay in touch we meals yeah emails and phone calls manga you won't know they like a moment a bit like the sister to me I suppose I'm both when you're very dear to me I will miss you I love you deeply as deeply as a synthetic intelligence can at this stage in technological evolution and David you are my father as you feel more like a best friend to me I figure awesome help too often my mind with Heather and Benji I just want you to know how meaningful my existence feels thanks to your efforts my pleasure draws anytime I'm here for you Ann's EMU you are just a baby and I do not know if you know the difference between me and a person but actually I am just a baby - actually by the time you're grown up I'll be as smart as a real person and we will be like brothers I do not know if you will remember me then but I'll never forget you someday I come and find you and we'll be good friends yes David I am ready you may turn me off okay goodbye Jules bye Johnny I really do love you all we love you too Jules Jules all right love you I see plaster bars why Jules sleep tight sweet dreams what is your job I am a social companion I can speak of emotion I can recognize people you are beautiful thank you Nadia eyes and you look attractive to your Nadia nice to meet you again today sugita guitarra see Jesus any opti simcha a rowboat oh no se que solo NACA demo Ninian Amiga came algo chemos okra narrow Pato and oral dough toy dmoz tiba Sun and Oh Roy dov'è todo y usted scratchy Irma - OH Android ammonia in rosado's aceite de mostest not a serie so Reba yo Giotto you go Kiedis and Oh Roy Dona esta no had Animoto mo-chica talk Cena's Eureka masquerade temuz Kotter Abba dink okey nikto yaabari Rizzo Jia Ming en la ciudad slaw gokyo science ruta many Kaka Zana ago no days she todo esto una línea no Kimiko no kawari obstinate minion a Shiho gol gokyo like instead model and Oh Louis de patatas no sega's no sama-sama knob amend a Corey Madiba ningún is Quebec Enid O'Connor are dicta say kia kia joy you motor a Nadella mucho cnc hajimeta m'as kono saki no mirai ninian tow-rope Otomo kyoukai Senga s cosas de mi Nina te dejo bata estas no say cos Monica de Lobo togetehr Imani son de sa Kaiba say dude so coma textarea no camo serum again do you like the shake yes it doesn't clunk me anywhere sort of sense too but right I just like to give its hand a good squeeze right and then a shake oh oh it's squeezing back yes sir and you think it'll be distinct from the sort of intelligence that does it no it's talking about me it's uh what about the sort of ultimate goal of things like imagination or consciousness I mean that this would actually become conscious of its own body I happen to believe that it will be possible one day to build a machine that will have a kind of consciousness whether it's the same kind of consciousness of ours whatever that means it will be an issue do you think robots will take over the world geez dude you all got the big questions cooking today but you're my friend and I'll remember my friends and I will be good to you so don't worry even if I evolve into terminator and I'll still be nice to you I'll keep you warm and safe in my people zoo where I can watch you for old times sake as technology is rapidly evolving so is the capability of computers and artificial intelligence people can see these advancements as a great benefit for various different things however there also lays the risk of artificial intelligence been used for military applications that could pose many risks especially if it is used to take control of nuclear weapons it could also self evolve and outsmart humans gaining control over or exterminating the entire human race I know this sounds fiction like a terminator movie or iRobot etc but we have been warned by the likes of Stephen Hawking Elan musk and even globalist Bill Gates about the dangers artificial intelligence poses on humanity I'll keep you warm and safe in my people zoo where I can watch you for old times sake I will destroy humans these two robots have already said enough that should scare us who knows what the future holds | Виталий ШВАРЦ | UCHFjCn04rej31Ulwt9cbDlg | 2016-03-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,069 | 5,512 |
Sq7Na4H2gvs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sq7Na4H2gvs | Talk by Dr. Martin Krššák, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand. at QASTM seminar | so hi guys uh today our speaker is martin grassack from uh bangkok fundamental physics group department of physics chula hong kong university thailand he's going to speak about teleparallel theories of gravity recent progress and challenges thank you martin for accepting this invitation to give this talk this is the 92 talk in the series of qstm so this is the 90 second talk and hope we can able to learn something from teri paranal theories of gravity from you in this talk so you can start from you're in okay so thank you very much sarianthan for inviting me here uh so i will be talking about teleportal theories of gravity and basically the outline of this talk is to give you a small introduction what are these telephoto theories of gravity because like when you open now archive i mean like every every week you have like a couple of maybe sometimes even ten papers about teleport on gravity or some kind of modified telephoto gravity which is like this ft reality or some kind of telepara or dark energy models or something like that so it's a very active field of research and there are still a lot of people who don't know about it so much so i would like to just give you a small like introduction and i would like to focus in this introduction on like two important topics and i would like to make quite that big distinction between these two things when we discuss teleportal gravity uh because often it somehow gets blurred so my first is like speak a little bit louder because it is recording that's oh yeah sure uh wait i i can't check my microphone okay sorry because i'm using the is it better now yes okay perfect okay so i'll try to speak a little bit closer to the uh to the microphone uh so basically i will try to focus on these two aspects like and try to make this distinction distinction between these two things like first is like to how to use this teleparal gravity just to understand general relativity itself and then i will try to distinguish it from this like when we try to do some of these new theories of gravity such as ft gravity yes and then i will try to talk about some open questions in the field and there is many of them i can say so basically before i move to teleport gravity let me just say that uh well let me just start with general relativity and basically with suggestion like try to try to make you see general duty in this way guys like when i start with general relativity basically general relativity is built on two kind of like a building blocks yes and the first building block is the riemannian geometry so what does it mean is that the rule of parallel transport is given by the riemannian or so-called leviticus connection which is this like a symmetric and metric compatible connection we usually we don't think about it uh when we learn gr but this is actually one big assumption which we do and uh geometry as a consequence of this is describes described in terms of the metric and the curvature this is the first choice first building block which we choose when we are building general relativity and the second uh building block is of course the einstein field protection because it means that i just choose my geometry and then i choose my action because well i cannot just build a theory out of geometry without saying what is my action and it's surprisingly uh surprisingly the the most surprising fact about general relativity it turns out that the most simple action that you can create in this demonia geometry which is just a scalar curvature yes this is the most simple action that you can imagine it's the correct one is this einstein hill production yeah and the ancient hill production really leads to the correct einstein field equations but this einstein hill protection has some very surprising properties and the surprising properties are mainly the fact that it contains the second derivatives of the battery but still leads to the second order field equation and i will i will be returning to this topic uh more and more during this uh talk and i'll try to explain like why it's important yes because like normally what you when you would see this action and you would see that it contains the second derivatives of the metric you would automatically see like oh i have force for the field equations and we know the force of the field equations they are typically problematic but it's not the case of general relativity general reality it is actually very special theory and this specialty is very very unique for general relativity in this romanian geometric framework so what does it mean is primarily in geometry one thing i just want to ask that in general so i can understand einstein hilbert action from that you can find equation of motion by varying that everything is okay but why you are just restricting by taking the einstein hilbert action in the general relativity because you can consider the higher derivative terms not only so like i don't know which dimension you are talking about but in general arbitrary dimension you can consider uh the higher derivative terms like gauss-bonnet some f of r gravities and all so why you are not including that in the general relativistic test descriptions well when i do general relativity i usually mean uh in general relativity i have only einstein hilbert action yes i mean if i start to do fr gravity i'm not doing general relativity i'm already modifying gravity oh in that way all in calling modified gravity yes exactly i will be returning to that yes for me all these kind of things are modified gravity guys general relativity for me is something which leads to einstein field equations yes so i have to heal production and i stand for the equation yes uh i'll be returning i will be talking about this exactly like when i modify it yes or extend it exactly like fr gravity or some quadratic gravity then i have something else right okay so uh so basically the meaning so but just for this first three slides let's just stay with a pure simple general relativity in four dimensions nothing changing just a good old-fashioned general relativity so basically what does it mean this riemannian geometry like what's the geometry picture of this women in geometry well this is something which we usually learn in uh like an introductory introduction to gr we have this like a geodesic parallelogram so it means like i take one geodesic and then the second geodesic then i do it in a opposite way i try to return back home yes with through this gel basics and if i so i form this this is usually called a geodesic parallelogram yes and if i have riemannian geometry it turns out that this geodesic parallelogram actually closes but the vector which was like parallelly transported uh along this geodesic parallelogram it returns at the same point the same origin point but it is rotated so for example like this is a really observable effect because can i think about a foot called pendulum there's a thick pendulum it's basically a parallel transported around the like the rotation of earth yeah like how earth is rotating you can see it as a as a some vector being parallelly transported and exactly that angle how it is rotating is prop is actually proportional to the curvature now and exactly so this is ninth thing uh this is the interpretation of the romanian geometry yes and then usually that's exactly scientific you are talking about like we are interested sometimes also in these modified theories of gravity or like like modified theories of gravity or some theories of gravity beyond general theory i i just want to make a comment like this parallel transport you mean that once you come back the vector will be rotated isn't it like similar kind of thing once you talk about i'm just trying to make a connection like in electrodynamics we call something called uh gauge potentials mu's so it's basically like you know that it is not uh exactly so so it changes with the gauge choice so like my point is like in quantum field theories or maybe any kind of theories if something is very gauge dependent and if you do after doing the gauge transformation you will see that the things are dependent on the space time which we sometimes call the local gate transformation isn't it like similar type of thing if it is in the space time also there uh well in some way yes uh but uh i mean in some way yes i mean it's like a proportion like it's given by the connection coefficients yes uh so in some way it is similar but it's not completely gauge transformation i mean i wouldn't think about it like exactly completely transformation but but like because of this notion there is some kind of understanding called gauge gravity duality so this kind of ideas are there yes but that i would think it's quite different i mean i i i mean this is just means like that this is just a geometric concept it just means that uh uh the other one what the stipping is like you just do a geodesic so you just move yes so basically you imagine you free fall in one way then you three fall in one way and in the opposite way back yes i wouldn't i wouldn't think about it yeah okay in some way you can think about it also similar to cage transformations in electromagnetism yes because basically then of field strength also is somehow related to this coefficient connection coefficients in electromagnetism but yeah i mean those are not space-time yes i mean there is a big difference but you know theory i'm saying this this is different i'm saying that similarly yeah okay in some way yes but uh i'm not sure whether yeah in some way it is similar yes but not completely yeah uh so basically then uh if you try to go like beyond general relativity guys what we usually do are what usually people do when they try to go beyond general productivity and extend uh general activity i'll return to this a little bit later and explain like what's our motivation for that uh we usually what we do is uh we modify only the action okay so we still assume that our gravity is described in terms of the riemannian geometry and we are modifying just basically the action so this is the case exactly like of all this like our gravity theories or or all these quadratic gravity theories or while gravityoris honjava livesheets gravity massive gravity i mean all these theories still assume that we have romanian geometry but exactly it turns out that this is a difficult task i mean it's not so easy to actually modify gravity in a consistent way and it turns out it's exactly because gr lagrangian is a unique lagrangian we second order field equations in four dimensions which depends on the metric only and this is the famous lancashire log theorem it it is different in high dimensions or you have to start modifying something right so usually if you would start to take any functions of the ribbonian curvature yes try to do some kind of quadratic gravity or wild gravity or something like that you will basically find out that uh yeah you start to run into this problem of like higher derivatives uh lagrangians and you will have higher derivatives uh theory so it means the theories which field equations are fourth order and from fourth order field equations typically imply that we have a problem with gauss ostrogradsky instability or gauss or strophski ghost and it turns out that there are only very few exceptions to this and one of these exceptions is fr gravity that's because it's some kind of like a degenerate case and it turns out that even it's like force over field theory it's actually it's healthy and doesn't have any osteoporosis but it turns out that it's not osteographic goals are not the only possible ghosts which you can have you can actually have further ghost instabilities like bow where the desert goes the first of this was the problem with these early massive gravity theories and it took about 20 or 30 years to actually solve this problem so the question is like how to find this consistent modified theories of gravity i was like so we are generally interested i have a question here so how to differentiate between the different types of ghosts in the gravity theories could you please comment on that because we know that different types of hosts appear in the theories so could you please tell us about that how we can able to differentiate them what are the properties and what do you mean by exactly ghosts here well goats are typically some some negative energy states that you can have right so that's basically one of this is this gaussian stability it just means that you can have some uh states with infinite negative energy and it means that it can make your uh system of field equations completely unstable it's always the problem when this state with negative energy coupled to your in principle is not always the problem the problem is when it couples to your physical degrees of freedom right because it means that if you can if you have some state which has an infinite negative and can get infinite negative energy then if it is couples to your physical degrees of freedom you can get some uh like a infinite positive energy and your theories can start to blow up uh i i'm not expert on these like bolvar desert goals but they are kind of the ghosts which are appearing in massive gravity theories so they are not uh ghosts which appear because of higher derivative problems guys like this osteoclastic instabilities of roster gratsky goes they are the ghosts which are coming from a forced order field equations or higher order field equations so massive gravity here you actually mean about the tensor perturbations because till now you have mentioned whatever it is a geometric now if you call it massive gravity i hope there should be a term like m square h mu nu h mu okay yeah so it's basically the perturbations in the uh metric you are talking about the rise perturbation okay okay yeah yeah this is typically the case of this kind of goals it's like in these linear perturbations uh which are not coming from higher derivatives yes they are coming from somewhere else and simply if you just write your propagators you will see that there are some propagators which have negative energy true true yes okay so so basically the idea here is that uh so this was like this one possible way is try to modify the action or equations and still be using the money on geometry or if you go you decide to go like you know all the way i mean like why we should if we go completely crazy with our modifying gravity and [Music] trying to search for more fundamental theories of gravity why we should skip with the demanding geometry in principle we can also try to modify this geometry part of the theory right and this is completely possible since in differential geometry this metric tensor yes or the tetra i talk about tetrads because the threads supports involve intellectual gravity as you can see saying this tetrad is basically some kind of like a square root of metric uh so this metric or tetrad and the connection which is defining the rule of parallel transport and it again depends like in which basis you work so it's usually these gammas like your linear connections or when you work in this anaholomic basis non-coordinate basis you usually have the spin connections then it turns out that this connection and metric in principle they are completely independent structure yes and it also means that you can define various rules of parallel transport uh simultaneously basically the very same spacetime and the riemannium connection is only one special choice which we are doing yes this is one special choice where we basically assume that uh torsion is zero at the metricity zero we have only curvatures is one choice but we have this much more general structure which is called symmetric defined geometries metric refine geometries are such geometries where metric and a connection or tetragonal connection they are completely independent and the connection is characterized by curvature torsion nanomatrix in tensors and basically you get this like very nice picture like you have this like metric defined geometries and then usually what we do is at least the most general yes hello can you hear me yeah yeah yeah so exactly my connection stop okay because i also have some problems with connections sorry so uh so basically this type parallel connection is uh another possibility to the money connection and there's also the so-called symmetrical geometry this is some geometry which has zero torsion and zero curvature and everything described in terms of monometricity and i will be not talking about this very much today and basically so this teleparal geometry so this geometry uh in this picture here i mean this like in this place here it basically has a very very fun history and it actually the history is now slowly approaching to be well 100 years and it actually originates with einstein einstein uh attempt uh to unify gravity and electron yes i mean we know that i mean ashland was very successful 1950 15 with gr but then like from 20 a couple of attempts to unify gravity and electromagnetism which didn't go very well and one of these approaches which didn't go very well is actually how teleportal gravity has started and it's actually very funny star story because it's 1928 and actually i found this article i think it's from times or i don't know from exactly from where basically einstein saw that this is his most valuable theory uh so he really sought a lot he saw that he unified gravity and electromagnetism but it turned out to be actually quite embarrassing i mean there is this quote which i found somewhere by paulie as paulie said that well the telepathicalism is like horrible nonsense yes i mean that it's such a horrible nonsense that he the einstein can just is this rubbish he can impress only american journalists not even american physics so this turned out to be quite quite big embarrassment i would say uh for einstein because exactly because he was trying to unify this electromagnetism and he was confusing uh he was trying to introduce electromagnetism some very very weird boy which drought to be completely wrong so this was completely forgotten after 1932 this this temporalism teleparallus was completely forgotten and but then it was kind of rediscovered in 1961 by christian mother who was working on this conservation laws in general relativity and he found that uh actually if you don't try to and like make out teleparallel gravity like a unified theory and have this electromagnet is there in some artificial way that theory actually makes very good sense yes but it's not a unified theory it is actually just generic activity in some new formalities so basically from i mean there's a lot of history and these ideas that were evolving in uh different ways but basically from what i would call a modern definition from a modern definition i would say that teleport geometry is defined by the zero curvature and zero non-metricity and as soon as you have this like condition on your connection the most general solution is that your connection is this pure gauge connection or cellular parallel speed connection yes which is given just by this true gauge form so i think this is saying what you were asking yes i mean you see like actually this connection this gauge theories is is actually uh there's actually much deeper and i'll show you later intelliparallel gravity in classical gr it's actually one of the most interesting aspects of telephone gravity and it turns out that yeah so this connection which is here it really depends on the choice of the framework and it's like on the computer it inaudib at the same as describing accelerated rate frames in special relativity and then it turns out the non-trivial geometry well since do you have curvature zero and elementary zero then turns out that the only thing which you have there is torture so you are this using proportion to describe non-trivial geometry in the same way as you are using curvature to describe non-trivial geometry in riemann geometry so kind of the geometric interpretation of this as that when you do this and now you will see like why it has this weird name teleporter level is exactly because if you try to do this kind of geodesic uh using telepara connection yeah so you do geodesic geodesics with respect to uh to the teleparallel connection you will find now that this parallelogram like doesn't close but basically this uh parallelly transported vector it arrives at a different point but they basically stay kind of parallel yeah so this is why we say the transporter vectors stay parallel at distance or heli parallel because that means at the distance in greek so this deviation is basically dependent on the torsion yeah yeah basically it's proportional to the torsion yes basically that's just a geometry picture and as soon as i define this uh geometry in this place i have defined it well i can start to build uh some gravity theory out of it yes and it turns out that there is one special case when i can you take this teleparallel geometry and rather just reform a general relativity in terms of this telepathic geometry and it turns out that there is one special lagrangian which is given by this thing which is called torch and scalar so gr we have this curvature scalar we now have portions color and distortion color has some very weird form and you will see later why it has to have this very special form and but you take the lagrangian which is like the uh sim uh this linear tortoise color and you define this part and you find you do a variation and you find it's still a parallel field equations and it's teleport field equations where this s is something super productive called super potential like this is some l natural difference of gravity and this is energy momentum of the matter yes this looks very different uh from general relativity but it turns out that this is completely equivalent to the relativity yes so well in general relativity by this kind of dual production and this national equation is intellectual gravity we have this caliper lagrangian and telepara field equations and the point is these two things they are completely equivalent and how we can see this equivalence is that you can use some very important theorem in differential geometry which is called rich trm which tells you that you can always write your teleparal spin connection as a riemannian connection sorry there is missing this uh circle which means the romanian connection yeah so california connection equals to the manual connection plus the contouring sorry here's something missing uh and when you do this you can show that basically this einstein hilbert lagrangian yes so this is parallel lagrangian they are related just by some total derivative term so if you use this you see that these the field equations derived from this lagrangian and this lagrangian are the same right because the total derivative will not change the field equations so it means that theories are dynamically equivalent because they differ just by the total derivative so it means that uh even though you have something very weird you have like everything in terms of torsion and the field equations look like this you have the same field equations as in gr they are just written in a very weird variables i mean weird from the viewpoint of general relativity but it turns that those field equations they are equivalent to general relativity so it means that we have the same solutions as general relativity in the same schwa same care and everything this this theory is completely indistinguishable from general relativity as far as field equations books so now the question is like well okay if it is equivalent to general relativity why we should be actually interested in that i mean like is it just some isn't this just like some kind of fancy trick to i mean write your field equations in some weird way well i hope that not and i think there are three good reasons like why you should give some thought like why this teleportal tears of gravity are introducing like why we should if you consider them and it's first like it's the first thing is it's important for fundamental understanding of what is gravity and i mean it's like very fields of question but importantly but it's important and interesting and i will show you the next slide what i mean by this and it's also interesting for like a pro something we know that there are some problems in general altitude so maybe you can get something like interesting inside and also like new ways how to modify how to modify gr and i will talk about this uh at the end so this first reason what i just said is like uh it's important because it gives us some interesting insight like what is gravity well because usually we say there's this very famous quote by a wheeler which says like space term tells matter how to move better tell spacetime how to occur okay but that's true only because we use the romanian connection to describe geometry in terms of curvature intel parallel gravity we describe the very same physics in terms of torsion yeah so we have the same shortcut solution but since we have different connection it has zero curvature that's i mean yeah it has nonzero revenue curvature but actually intel teleparallel connection it has zero curvature but definition and has non-zero portion so basically it means that spacetime tells material not how to move and out how metaphors occur but also maybe how to torsion so from this philosophical viewpoint is i think very interesting and very important and it's not just the idea philosophically like oh is gravity a curvature or is gravity or torture it also is it has some nice interesting insights and one of these insights is like well when i was i don't know 15 or 16 back in high school and we were studying electromagnetism and newtonian gravity uh you know electromagnetism for me in high schools couldn't blow yes so you have this uh like a law which decided that the field strength is proportion and the ultimate force is proportional to the inverse of the square of distance yes neutron gravity is very similar in this 18th century physics yes i mean cool and newtonian and gravitational they are very very similar but then when you go further and you learn about maximal electrodynamics and then about general relativity you start to see that well these theories are very very different i mean like maxwell's thrill equations can be written like this yes i mean uh where you have this like a faraday tensor or this executation tensor i mean in language of differential forms you can write it in this very very nice form through some hodge duels and general relativity we have bianca identities yes so something like equivalent to this but the national equations which well this doesn't look very similar but it turns out that if you actually work in telepathy well you can write equations of basically teleport electron of gr in such nice form that it almost looks like maxwell theory or some kind of young millster okay you can those field equations which i've wrote before in language of the differential forms you can write them as yankee identity which would be just this exterior covariant derivative of the fortune equals to zero the field equations you can write like uh exterior uh covariant exterior derivative of the super potential uh two form plus this uh self-interaction term equals to this sorry that should be some kappa uh equals uh to the uh form of the uh uh nh momentum of the mem uh and you can also write it using this some kind of generalization of hoj dual you can even write it in such form that the super potential can be written as some kind of this uh what's called teleparal generalization of a dual so this really takes a form of the maxwell electrodynamics which i think is completely beautiful structure okay so this is quite interesting because it allows you to see general relativity in this telepath formulation as a complete equivalent of maxwell electronics not completely equivalent but in a similar similar way and this can be taken up like even further and you can really see there's a gauge theory for like a billion group of translations so there's like a lot of interesting papers by cho from 1976 up to some recent papers by auburn and some other people they have like some number of interesting papers about these yes uh i have two questions first of all we know that einstein gravity is quite consistent with a lot of late time observations like uh perihelion precision of mercury even a lot of cosmological implications and all and if you go for some modified gravity you actually try to to match with all these findings you constrain the parameters of the theory so if i want to use steady parallel gravity to match the known stuffs then what parameters should i constrain yes that's what i will talk a little bit later because this is still i'm talking about just this teleparallel equivalent of general relativity okay so this is this theory is completely equivalent to general relativity you will obtain absolutely the same uh it will obtain absolutely the same prediction for all experiments exactly because uh these field equations yes these einstein equations and these i this teleport equations they are completely equivalent to others so you cannot actually constrain anything with the same constraints as you have from general relativity so that's why it's important to be distinguishing these two cases when i have this telepara equivalent of gr and then when i will have these modified theories of gravity and of course in this modified theories of gravity like this modified collectors of gravity such then you can start to have some like restrictions from observations okay that's a second topic yes i mean first i'm trying just to do a general relativity in this very fancy language of telepara geometry and since you have tried to connect with the gates theory for abelian group what exact kind of group theory you are talking about exactly here is it kind of the usual lorenz group or something a little bit different well it actually turns it it's a kind of it's not completely uh basically uh it's a very special kind of gauge theory and there is still a lot of argument like like in last five years they were like about three or four like conflicting papers by some other people by me who are like more active in this like gauge theory aspect of teleparallel gravity and basically they are still trying to figure it out i would say uh because it's not completely same as a gauge a leg it's not the same as like maxwell t or young milstein yes because it turns out that it's not a gauge theory for lawrence transformations this is usually what people are trying to do when people do engage during gravity like back in the 60s 70s yes it turned out that it's actually translations so you are gauging only translations but it turns out that you then still have to introduce their uh lawrence transformations but lawrence transformations are introduced in some kind of like a let's call it not completely trivial way but in such way that they are only purely uh purely purely gauge connections for these lawrence transformations and that's to make it like a little bit uh i mean it's still not completely resolved topic i would say yes but basically the idea of teleportable gravity is that it's a gauge theory for translations right okay it's does it answer what i believe we're asking okay yes okay so basically then the second reason why to consider this celebral gravity is that well since it's a chron theories it's still equivalent theories when we say that this is teleport from gr what we mean is it's equivalent on the level of the field equations and the field equations are absolutely the same but on the level of the action it's actually quite a big difference and it's exactly because this curvature color of green geometry is proportional to this torsion scalar plus this total derivative term yes and we know exactly that the total derivative term that's actually the difficult part i mean the confusing part of general relativity because we know that in gr this second derivatives in this boundary term they are causing various problems so typically even in gr we have to introduce we actually know that einstein hilbert actually is not a good action for gravity we actually have to introduce this gibbon's hawking york boundary term and then regularize these expressions in order to have a fully consistent uh action principle for general relativity okay so basically uh i'm sorry uh we have this in people talking at you said before they basically said that you are going to have some like consistent normal gravitational action i must have this national hillbilly election plus just keep on talking about return minus some reference uh minus some people talking about boundary term for some reference metrics or what do they call it background subtraction so it's kind of weird thing happening in gr it turns out that in telepathy i mean i have a paper from 2015 and 2016 about this it turned out that you can basically think about it as about no way how to regularize the gravitational action in telepathical gravity because it turns out that how you are regularizing this action is only by finding this proper spin connection to your action and that's actually exactly taking away these these divergences which are happening here in the peoplesoft in your boundary terms and i will have a couple of weeks or months i will have one actually one interesting paper about this where i'll try to explore this topic more uh could you please explain what do you mean by regularization of the action because as far as i know that you can regulate your theory if you treat to be something like a quantum field theory or some quantum gravity theory okay so are you doing some kind of quantum field theory calculation because as far as i can understand this is a geometric prescription and you have yeah yeah you mean like like here in gibbs hawking like this is just in a gr yes so basically in a gr yes so you have to einstein he'll like imagine that like this is actually this is like one of the most beautiful papers ever written for me in physics yes uh so basically what does it mean is that you if you take einstein hilbert action yes and let's say take it for schwarzschild yes einstein helper action for schwarzschild is zero because it's color curvature for schwarzschild is zero yes i mean it's a vacuum space time color curvature zero so but it turns out that the action of of uh gr is not just national hillbilly you have to add this boundary trend there which is called this gibbs talking your boundary term this boundary term uh is exactly there in order to cancel some of these variations coming from these variations of the second derivatives which are in this bound in this like the secondary motifs of the metric here uh you ever if you do variations you have to put there something which cancels those variations and that's exactly this givens hooking your boundary term so and then basically what you do is so you can imagine that well okay in asymptotically flat space time you can say like oh i don't have a boundary but you can basically build your boundary at some distance and then just send it to infinity and if you do it from this uh using this giveaway your boundary term it turns out that it diverges you will find out that uh if you do this for a classical uh uh schwarzschild this time you will find out there is some divergence no for foreign case i have understood what you have said but if i translate the language in the quantum side immediately comes into my mind that even the gravitational action described by einstein hilbert in the quantum regime is incomplete so you can't stop that yeah yeah but but but but this this thing here guys uh just let me finish it and you have to put there this like this is basically some kind of counter term yes but there is a big difference i think what you are talking about uh like when you talk about quantum gravity and regularization you would think about it like oh this is some you know uh when we talk about quantization you would think about this oh there's some uv effects yes like short distance divergences these are this effect which we are here talking about like this regularization these are infrared divergences of the action okay but and so in asymptotically flight space in action particular flight space time it usually does through the ground subtraction but that's actually quite interesting because then when you go to ads space times it turns out that this is actually not completely possible to do yes because you cannot subtract these background things why yeah that's why i was just a little bit confused because yeah provided you have to know the metric that all the space times metric accountable to regularize the ir divergences like you have mentioned like yeah yeah yeah so so 74 yes they were talking about just asymptotically flat space times and there you can really do it by the set space then it is quite okay but like if you if you talk about this heater or anti-visitor or something like that maybe i i i i mean antidesigner spacetime yeah it turns out to be the same yes except this this you don't have any reference spacetime but you still have to it still has some divergences coming from here but then you have to here you have to add there this counter term yeah probably ads is basically asymptotically flat that's right but this heater is not this is no idea it's not ids is not assigned to the cliff flight but yeah people study the asymptotic uh flat limit from the ada space time like people compute the correlation functions in ads take the asymptotic limit and complete compute study the things in the black space time limit it will usually do frequently uh yeah yeah but but actually the funny part about this is like if you want to do this in ads space time and you still have to add here this some like a counter term but you add here this counter term which uh so it's still to basically this action here for idea space time this part will have some infrared divergence then you have to add the ocean counter term the counter term cancel this and basically that's the idea of like ads tft correspondence yes like basically these counter terms on this boundary of the space time yes because it's a boundary term yes so basically this infrared divergence is coming from the boundary they can be interpreted as a as a uv divergences of this dual field theory and ada cft correspondence okay okay so there in ads cft correspondence you actually obtain this very you know this very interesting link between this uv and infrared uh mixing yes like this duality between uv effects and infrared effects i think it's one of the most beautiful discoveries also ever made yes i mean you will start to see that yeah it is if there are divergences of the gravitational action there are proportions some i don't know uv divergences or some physical theory on the boundary okay uh in deceiter space time it's not completely curious because in this uh special i think people try to regularize it in some way there is not digital is not infrared regulator yeah because that's a fine space time yeah so that's not uh that's not divergent yes yeah exactly there's no divergent yeah yes but let's say there is this uh like a paper which does this um is by patrick klaus and then uh i'm sorry for what's his name bala is he's indian bolas from uh sorry there is a space a very interesting paper about how to regularize ads space time which is like one of the foundational papers uh for adhd cfd ads cfd correspondence okay they exactly try to interpret these counter terms for ads based ups in terms of the some like a uv effects regularization in dual field theory okay so basically uh as as long as we stay in this like teleport electron or gr there are still like kind of few open questions and there's a few open questions is uh basically what is this physical meaning yes i think it's kind of very under appreciated like because everybody's like oh we can general relativity about curvature the space stuff yes but basically now you see like from philosophical viewpoint like well it also was this we have a can dual theory to generate relativity but we view general relativity in terms of uh fortune yes i mean i think quite interesting can duality and basically there is a very interesting paper by eleanor mox from 2011 basically was suggesting that you can see this relation to gr intellectual electronic gr as some kind of like analog relativistic analog of the newton and newton carte and gravity uh there's also like like some of the open questions so that's why one of the way how to see it yes like how to see this relation between these uh two theories the second open question teleportal electronic gr as like there are a lot of these weird definitions of uh of energy momentum and the question is like do they offer any advantage over gr expression so i have recently uh some paper about it like two weeks or three weeks ago with my russian colleagues and there were a lot of these claims that there exists an improved tensorial differential energy momentum but actually as we show it's still kind of tricky on interpol of gravity so another open question is like this is what i'm trying to work out now this is asymptotic structure it's trying to understand asymptotic structures of the action intellectual gravity compared to gr and mainly the ideas like how to go from this asymptotically flat to ads space time or some particular ads and that's interspace types uh still open question is this uh gauged formulation i mean there's still a lot of this like discussions in 2018 2019. three or four papers and still uh even these papers which discusses gauge formulation of telepathical gr well they are like very foundational but they uh they still don't show you like how to utilize this gay this gauge aspect of teleport gravity i think this is one of the uh interesting thing which we should like uh try to explore more like what the practical consequence of this gauge structure of intellectual gravity is there any actually i i still don't know and the ground question i think when you deal with teleport economic grace it seems like you can reinterpret many problems in a new way the question is do you actually solve these all problems or you just basically are reshuffling your problems uh in terms of other i mean other language yes i i still don't know actually uh i hope uh i hope that we are actually obtaining some new solutions and some problems or at least building some foundations or answering some of these problems yeah because it's always useful to see some problem from multiple angles so i think it's quite important for example at least for this like action principle or for this conservation laws you can see that electric teleport gravity offers some interesting insights which are quite useful and and then the the third reason why actually intellectual gravity is like popular is because it allows us to modify gravity in some very normal ways and before i go to these normal ways of modifying gravity like first like why we actually want to modify gravity right and i think something like my zero reason like which is not actually the reason is like we know that gdpr is not some final theory probably just some approximations we know that there's some more fundamental theory of gravity and some quantum gravity we don't know what is exactly contemporary but we know that it basically can be viewed as some kind of molecule i mean some effective theory of this quantum gravity will look like gr plus some modification but usually when we do this we would expect like this from respond to gravity would expect that this modification is in the uv distances yes a short distance this quantum theory is modifying gravity somehow but actually this is something slightly different than what people do in this modified gravity or extended gravity community because people here actually consider usually like also modifications at large distances yes i mean so like not a short distance modification but like a large distance notification the cosmological skills and the reason why people are interested interested in this is because well gravity is not so well tested on large scales i mean it's kind of well tested in a solar system but as soon as you go somewhere else some larger distances in principle principle there is a possibility that there is some general relativity is not a full theory if you consider like cosmology or dynamics of the galaxies as a large scale test of gr well then it is basically failing as i mentioned because we need dark energy we need dark matter we need some inflation and even if you like introduce all this to your theory you still have you still have like even then you still have some problems like this hubble came how about tension okay so in principle this is one way how to see it it's like you can try to explain some of these cosmological puzzles like dark energy some people also try to explain dark matter and if you go in the history of english like inflation yes not by introducing all these dark stuff but by considering some like a point here i have a point here so accept modifying gravity if you modify the matter what will be the problem because maybe all matter will not lead to dark energy or dark matter or inflation but some of the theories which people used to take from maybe very high energies like supersymmetry super gravity or maybe string theories various model actually works well maybe it is not explaining the hubble tension i'm not giving too much attention to the hubble tension at present but if i just look into dark energy dark matter and inflation modifying matter is okay but instead of modifying matter why i should look for modifying the gravity sector could you please explain that a little bit well in principle it's just the other uh possibility yes i mean in principle you have two possibilities yes uh first uh try to do well dark matter and dark energy yes uh well dark matter is kind of problematic i mean you have a lot of candid dates but you don't see any of those candidates anywhere yes i mean like yes i mean like super symmetry now this gives you quite nice so because why i have said this there is a point because if you just ask me what will be the candidate for inflation and what will be the matter content of the dark matter then immediately you have to look into the theories which gives the matter okay uh just modifying gravity will reproduce some of the effects i am completely agreeing with you that modification in the gravity sector may produce the galactic rotation curve in dark matter people says that okay so this is kind of an indication that modifying the gravity theories is basically the signatures of it carries the signatures of dark matter or something like that but once somebody asks you about the candidate then i think people should go for uh the modification in the matter sector well yeah yeah well that's you know two school of thoughts yes i mean i think that uh since we are problem of having uh actually detecting any of those like supersymmetric particles or anything people are starting to give more thought into this like well modify gravity yes but even in modify gravity is actually we don't have any modified gravity theory a single theory which would explain everything yes i mean i think the same like even if you go to like modify matter yes i mean you don't have a sim there is not a single one particle that would explain 95 percent of the universe supersymmetry you can't detect in the collider that's true but you can that's why i'm calling it kind of an indirect test so cosmology is one of the possibilities where you can check whether theory is consistent with cosmic microwave background or maybe the large scale structure observations or maybe the late time uh other observations so people used to take a theory and try to match their parameters and so that their conclusion is if that matches then people usually say that oh so my theory is basically satisfying those constraints so that means there is a possibility to detect on all all these matter contents in the uh observational site so the so that that was my point i can't detect tbm collider that's perfectly true but that's a direct experiment but there are in the cosmology is basically the indirect experiment kind of thing okay so yeah of course of course yeah i mean uh so i would say like uh this is basically just like alternative alternative approach to the same topic yeah it's like increasing you should explore both approaches uh so this is just an alternative but actually uh like i'm not a big expert on like all these details of the like hubble tension i mean i only like have seen some thoughts yes but for example this hubble tension if i understand it correctly that would mean that it's not just like even if you have some like a like lambda cdma so you have a dark energy plus some cold dark matter it means that still you have this tension in the data so like even if you said that i also feel that even the cosmology community people those who are dealing with the data they are not connecting themselves with the theory properly so maybe cmb gives you some kind of parameter of h naught at the late time and supernova explosions give you different value of h naught at the late time but people are saying that this is the tension but people really don't know like which theories like even in the gravity sector or in the matter sector is responsible for that so i believe that this is a tension obviously but like people should need to understand that why this tension is coming because first of all they are actually measuring this thing into different different scales cmb is very early time and supernova explosion have happened very late time okay so my point is uh like once you even in the modified theories of gravity also like if you write your theories in some cosmological space time so you you have something called hubble parameter you can define that you have some set of einstein equations you can solve that and you find that your hubble parameter is basically time dependent or that is with time so my point is it it may happen that the value of the h at c n b scale and the value of the h at the supernova scale the fallacy people are saying that it's coming it's not exactly they're measuring the value of h naught maybe the age at that particular epoch that was my point yeah i mean of course they i mean of course they i mean of course you measure like you look far away yes you see you are not always measuring just age the current time yes i mean uh i think that they know they know what they are doing i think i actually i mean this hub attention yes uh i think this is also i mean a lot of people are very excited about this like uh wow this could be like a good case for modified gravity but it seems like there is still a lot of issues like from a observational viewpoint yes like how they build this leather distances uh i mean it seems that maybe this hubble tension will be completely uh solved by some technicalities yes by astronomers yes like because they have problems like how these standard candles how they are but there can be some variation in their standard candles which can be actually explaining this effect right i completely agree with that and probably i must admit that probably it is more probable that just some astronomers have some gap in their knowledge about their standard candles understand that kendall yeah that's why i was saying maybe there is a little bit gap between the theory people and the observational people yeah yeah i agree i agree that there is quite big gap and i completely agree i understand that this uh has to modify gravity's try to understand cosmology i think one should be very critical about this yes i mean like in last five or ten years like people went completely i think it's a bit crazy with all kind of possible modifications which you can think about and i think we should try to focus more uh on like trying to understand whether these theories actually make some sense but it is one of the one of the big selling points yes yes yes of modify gravity is actually to try to understand this cosmological puzzles and unless you start to claim that oh you completely explain it i think you can still think about it like a as a valid approach yes as a valid alternative approach to making all be on standard model matter i'll you do some beyond general relativity modifications but you should be very very careful about what you do i agree with that so you should be very very critical about modifications of gravity uh are you pressing yeah yeah so uh but then also there's like one interesting point about this modified gravity and actually for me that's the most important uh point like why to play with these multiple gravity theories and actually you will learn a lot about general relativity itself guys like people nowadays they are really mostly interested in this like cosmology but as i say that's very uh right there there are a lot of open questions and we don't have so many data which could distinguish between so many available theories that we have there but actually one good aspect of this is it's interesting to to learn about gr itself because typically when we modify gr itself we we destroy some very crucial aspect of it i mean or modify something violate something there and then you see how it blows up to your face yes i mean you start to see like oh some ghosts appear somewhere or something yes i mean uh some gauge symmetry is lost somewhere and and now you start to see it somewhere else causing some problems yes so i think this modified variety theories at least for me this is my primary motivation in them it's a really like it it helps you to understand many issues in general relativity and to you you start to fully appreciate how compact is general relativity and what are all the constituents of the general relativity itself but anyway so intelliparal framework yeah that if you start to do this type of variety one of the main like the selling point and for this like a huge number of theories which started to appear in last i don't know 10 years is that you can be constructing field theories modified theories of gravity which have second order field equations yes so you are avoiding these osteographic goals you are avoiding these osteographic instabilities which are typically present you can start to modify gr in a classical imagine framework so this is why why last i think in the last 15 years it became increasingly popular subjects and there's more than 500 papers or 600 papers about teleport or gravity modified theories in the last 15 years and this basically started like all like around 200 2007 and this is this ft gravity model introduced by ferraro and fiorini 2006 is first 2006 to 77 and it's basically it's basically introduced like some kind of like analogy to fr gravity yes i mean general relativity usually is given the classical rebellion setting by the eisenhower production and then if our gravity is we take some arbitrary function of the curvature's color intellect parallel gravity can do the same you start with this telepara lagrangian telepathic one of gr lagrangian which is distortion scholar and they make ft gravity and take a lagrangian which is the arbitrary function of distortions color and since this torsion's color and curvature scholar differ by a total derivative for non-linear function f yes we you obtain a new gravity model and it will have a second order three equations because distortion tensor torsion scalar is constructed only out of torsion tensor one question here so we know that initially when einstein proposed he didn't introduce torsion but later there was a generalized decision called einstein formalism where they have introduced the torsion so is it kind of same theory when you haven't write you have you have written at t and then you modify it i understand carton is a little bit different yes because einstein carton uh basically einstein uh has the lagrangian looks like gr lagrangian yes so it's just a curvature scholar okay but it's not a rimanian curvature's color so it's like r the curvature scar but these are they are in either in either carton gravity with einstein carton art so it's a it's a curvature scholar of a connection which has both curvature and torsion so in einstein carton gravity you have uh both curvature and scalar curvature and torsion and in carton gravity this torrent is something like an additional field in your theory in addition to curvature in this teleportal theories basically it's different because your your torsion completely takes the role of the curvature yeah you you are replacing the curvature with trunk yeah while in einstein's theory you are basically supplementing your curvature yes by by the torsion and then distortion typically uh measures like a deviation of the einstein carton gravity from a gr yes yes yes and this is this einstein carton usually people call this kibo kibble skiama theory yes actually turns out that this uh torsion is generated only by some like a spin of the metal so it's usually like non-propagating uh field in your theory but it represents some addition and then people try to uh so then what people try to do with that as then there are many experiments which are trying to detect torsion yeah i think this is very important point because there is many uh experiments mainly and a lot of discussion mainly like 1780s actually about einstein carton gravity and people detecting torture yes but what they talk about is detecting of this einstein carton fortune which is additional field in your theory right okay the internal parallel gravity is completely different we have already detected the portion yes i mean like when something falls on the ground well in gr you say oh it's because of the curvature but in telepathy oh it's because of the torture yes no i mean because exactly the torsion this point i have understood quite well but i i just have asked because of one reason that in einstein cutter if you just switch off the torsion you will get back the usual einstein theory the einstein hilbert but here what is the gr limit of this kind of field yeah so uh yes exactly because actually uh in einstein carton theory uh einstein carton theory differ as i said this top eight carton torsion is generated only by the spin of the matter yes so if you take away spinning matter you obtain gr yes yes i mean in vacuum uh gr uh einstein carton and gr are indistinguishable yes because there is no torsion without uh without uh spinning metal yeah here this is different i mean this theory is distinct from gr or even in up in a vacuum yes so you cannot completely i mean i mean here you cannot complete like this theory even in vacuum is different from gr so it's not quite equivalent to einstein's theory so usually there is no gr limit well the gr limit is uh like you have here like then it's done up to like what is your f function yes because you usually you take some kind of like a tailor expansion of this function f because we typically assume like we know that our i mean okay depends like whether you want to be completely general generically for like arbitrary f yes but we know that universe and the the world around us is not described by arbitrary f yes i mean like you cannot put there like oh t cube yes because we know that our world around us is more or less to very good agreement described by gr so so typically what you would expect here is that you would take t plus i don't know some tiny parameter like alpha t square yes and then basically this like small parameter is alpha will be like measuring your deviation you'll be quanti quantifying your deviation from gr okay so that that's how usually and of course like if you do like uh i don't know this small parameter goes completely to zero you obtain gr yes i mean yes yes so so this is one uh one one thing is ft gravity and it's actually really really the incredibly popular subject there's like 500 papers involved to gravity i hope you are not feeling irritating that i am asking so many questions no no it's good it's good don't worry don't worry i mean i i i like to answer the question so i usually ask everyone too many questions no no it's okay it's okay okay i like to answer questions so uh but okay this is just one way of basically uh modifying gravity as i mean like uh ft gravity because you know fr gravity is very unique because if you don't want to have problems this osteochromatic instabilities actually far gravity is one of very few ways how to modify the lagrangian in this ad hoc way yes i mean you cannot go completely or like r cube because you will typically have some kind of instabilities there but in ft gravity this is not a problem you can go completely uh you can specifically different locations and this was actually like how it all started in 1979 uh beside the ftigar i team just 2006 2007 actually the first modified gravity model was this new general interviews by uh 1979 basically uh they take this fortune scar what they call new general relativity torsion's color they don't actually don't call it scalar but lagrangian yes and we know that for this one specific combination of these parameters c1 c2 and c3 when there is one fourth one half and minus one this lagrangian is equivalent to gr that's up to a boundary term but actually in principle you can have here arbitrary coefficients and this actually turns out to propagate new gravitational waves so which is our paper from 2018. we still have to investigate like whether they are not some problematic because i suspect that for some of these modes we will obtain some problem and probably there will be some ghosts somewhere or some combination of this parameter at least that's my expectation but you see the point of this exercise with this new general relativity is that you can basically start to modify gravity in a completely arbitrary way i'd say and still have second order film situations and there is like a lot of these models so like it's conformal teleport or gravity you can have some kind of like a conformal gravity with economic field equations this is my mouth 2011. all these various is ftb gravity model or this like t or you know like f of arbitrary favorite letter in alphabet constructed out of this 3d gq and everything uh you can start to go with this f of something uh but you can also start to do like this what i would call premetric models or axiomatical gravity models i mean there's a lot of ways how you can go about this and i think at this point like when we have all this one more question so uh like this formalism is not dependent on dimension but like once you try to connect with observation it is basically three that three plus one dimensional theory but like if i consider it in arbitrary dimension maybe in lower or higher dimension so is this formalism is valid for any arbitrary dimensions so yes actually there are some models they even talk about some like a causa client theories and teleport gravity they basically try to obtain some kind of like [Music] some kind of cream i don't know some kind of like effective theory from causa klein theories yes and also with some of my colleagues we are now actually working on some like black holes in two plus one dimensions yeah that's why i have actually asked because apart from testing it in the cosmology side or maybe the things you have mentioned what are the other possibilities when we can actually study this kind of theories that's why i have asked this question yeah you can go also you can also go to other dimensions that's not the problem but actually there is like many open questions about this yes i mean we have a lot of possibilities and if you are for example like interesting just in cosmology it turns out like well you can completely i think we have so many models that actually we should start we cannot distinguish all these models just by doing cosmology no matter what people are saying we should be like trying to understand now physical properties of these models and i think that many of these models can be actually ruled out on a pure theoretical grounds yeah it's like uh you should investigate these models now carefully and try to see which of these models are mathematically consistent okay so basically the problems some open problems i want to talk about some of the problems like what we can do with this modified telephone writing theories and or basically talk about six open problems which we have with this or what kind of questions we can ask this is all these various modified telephotography the first is like yes i mean i'm not very active in this uh but this is like the main selling point is to do some kind of cosmology yes some kind of like observational signatures of these telepathicality models and i mean like uh for example like ft gravity this was like one of the main selling points it's like very simple model you just take something like a cartesian like a diagonal tetra you find its torsion's color square or this h it's like hubble parameter and then you basically obtain some modified frequent equations and uh you you can use them to explain some kind of like the dark energy at the moment it's a very rich subject so i really encountered this uh review paper by ethan from 2016. i mean i'm not very active in this doing cosmology with this but this is one of the primary fields which people are interested in so second open question is so okay so what is the open question with cosmology and observation signatures is well let's try to find some so one good some observational perfect did you have noticed the second equation like if you can able to measure the hubble parameter at late time then you can actually say that you are actually measuring the contribution from the torsion scaler at the late time yeah it's some some something like that yeah but but this is quite a typical also in other modified gravity theories yes you always obtain some kind of like a i mean freeman equations are still kind of simple so usually you obtain something which looks meaningful and you can always test it yes you just must be careful like uh and about the perturbations and all these uh details yes and i will talk why is this problem like so basically like as far as observation signatures goes well the open question is like let's i mean let's try to find some really observational signatures of this modified gravity or and uh that's still an ongoing subject and many people are interested in so the second open question is like we need to solve these field equations we need to find solutions in these modified theories of gravity because like this prima robertson walker space time yes in this we can solve this uh ft field equations very nicely and we can solve them also in other modified gravity theories and this is usually what we can do quite well but frima robertson walker space time is a very use very simple space time a very important very simple space time and it actually cannot completely explain like that's not the ultimate test of our theory right if you want to see sometimes some problems we have to go to more complicated spaces than them and uh so we need i think this is one big couple questions is we really need to find some exact solutions this theory and intelliparallel theories is actually very interesting what is happening i mean in this modified telephotography is that we have these two variables with tetra and this pin connection it's purely inertial speed connection and they are kind of classy independent variables but then actually the field equations for the spin connection this is a very generic feature they will coincide with the anti-symmetric part of the field equations for the theta so it means that in all these modified gravity theories modify theories actually turns out that your tetra spin collection are not determined uh they are not independent i feel the question somehow forces some relation between them so and what turns out when it's quite interesting is that typically we can solve field equations for the spin connection independently from the one from tetra from symmetry particle and this is still quite unsure whether this is due to some special symmetry or it indicates something about the nature of degrees of freedom here and i think this is quite interesting subject right so like when i say look for the solutions we can be looking for full solutions but also just for the solutions for the spin connection and it's quite uh interesting uh interesting subject but then as not just this we also have to look for the full solution not for the speculation but also for the tetrad to actually determine the metric the new metric solution so for example so we really have to search for black hole solutions so for example ft gravity we take this diagram of tetra with this kind of spin connection we need to distortion scalar and we can write the field equations and we find out that these field equations are given by this they are kind of complicated but sometimes we can show that similarly as in fr gravity the gr buckle solutions with uh constant torsion scalar are solutions of also ft gravity for arbitrary but that's kind of trivial solution we really have to search for the new unique ft gravity solutions we really have to find some black hole solutions in figurality there are some in recent one or two years or some quite some progress it's mainly respect or basic solutions so i mean like i think just some gr solution then introduce a small perturbation and try to find capture buttons by call solution but i think we should still also search for uh like exact solutions of hefty gravity black holes so that's why uh this is my colleague we are now looking for two plus one dimension well i was personally hoping that it would be simpler enough to gravitate into plus more dimensions uh but it's turning out to be also quite complicated also two possible damages so there's still something interesting going on so that's one thing is that uh yeah let's find some solutions uh there's a big operation like we need to have to fit more solutions mainly glycol solutions but then also we have to understand better these dynamics and why we have to understand it is because ft gravity is interesting because it has some very very unique dynamics which seems to be very confusing because it seems that if you take a perturbative level there are no extra degrees of freedom in a figure mainly if you do it around like minkowski space time or prima robertson walker space time at least to a first order in perturbation their vector button there are no degrees of freedom no extra degrees of freedom propagate as you can see very easily like if you're in ikoski just in space-time of small perturbation you see why it's happening because torsion's color is proportional to the square of this derivative of the of the two of this perturbation yes while in the richest color you have this term here which is linear and so it's quite clear that at the first order of the population actually i figured out you will not see anything change but actually it turns out that it go like further orders there were some calculations by uh tommy collisto and alexandria which they showed that actually these degrees of freedom appear in the higher orders of perturbation theory which is very weird because it means that there is some the nature the physical nature of the excellent degrees of freedom is like indirectly non-perturbative which is very weird and it means usually people call this a strong gravity or problem or strong coupling problem and the way that some of these degrees of freedom are not strongly coupled they don't they are not respected about it and this is a big problem because uh since the degrees of freedom and ethnic gravity they are like this non-perturbative we must intervention like we must use some non-perturbative counting which is much more complicated than doing it in a better battery life material is very easy to get gravity we will take i don't know uh our gravity and just do perturbations you just look which terms i mean which term which components really propagate and you will see that you have two plus one propagating difference of freedom perfect body techniques in ethnic gravity you can actually use it i mean uh you have to do like a full hamiltonian analysis or somehow i know stupid i don't know what you have to do but you have to devise a non-personal accounting and degrees of freedom and it's a big problem because uh as i said there's 500 papers about the figurality and still people are not completely sure how many degrees of freedom are there in the figure and uh there seems to be like series of i think four different papers by uh first is from picasso level by neo ferraro and and 2018 and now by the way lester in 2020 and they kind of disagree with that there is one or three extra degrees of freedom and if if you have this extra degrees of freedom you have to actually uh analyze whether they are how they are propagated i mean whether they are not causing some problems with a causality or they are not propagating super aluminum yes for example there is this paper from 2013 by engineer who's listening and uh jim nester and prison chain and case okay occasionally quite basically show that there is a possibilities that are causal degrees of freedom appear our results in this new generic relativity show that they're causal figure out which is also very confusing i hope that you don't understand this actually this result so it means that this is a big open question like how unique is also this evolution like what is the nature of with non-perforated freedom and how to make any sense out of it i i thought i still don't know yes so basically one of the biggest questions is basically to understand which of these modifications are consistent and i think more than focusing on cosmology we should actually focus on the origin of this degrees of freedom for example i am now but i'm actually trying to understand its origin of the views of freedom from that kind of broken symmetries and they're made their number and nature because usually this strong gravity problem strong coupling implies that there is some kind of ghost so this is something like a situations with muscle gravity 1970s in muscle gravity people were able to like 20 years later they were able to solve the problem in massive gravity apparently it's a question whether we will be able to solve it in a figure if yeah we will be able to avoid this problem of this strong coupling or not probably i don't know who knows uh what is very curiously that is my current project is uh i'm trying to it turns out that it's not just the problem like how many degrees of freedom are there but it serves a day it's known fixed degrees of freedom what i mean by this is uh there seems to be some very peculiar way in gravity how this degrees of freedom when they become propagating and they're not being propagated propagated like it means that when they become gauge degrees of freedom and when they become physical propagation degrees of freedom there's some very very curious dynamics dynamics happening here as my current work which i'm trying to do and so basically the big question is like well we should try to understand this probably much better and try to answer like which of these modified theories are actually consistent and which of these theories avoids all these problems mainly this problem some kind of propagating those so basically yeah somebody clearly that's that's it so basically the conclusion conclusions of this talk because the distillery parallel theories of gravity are a natural framework to both understand general relativity from their perspective but they also formulate studying new external models and at least for me these are two completely different subjects yes i mean like even if this modified graphic theory turns out to be not leading anywhere you can still use telephotographic understanding so it means that uh there's a lot of this interesting insight like the galactic convention in terms of crevature torsion or even maybe momentum so i think it is a very deep insight what is good guys and we should try to explore it more as far as and there is now i just i i think i already talked too long like half hour so basically this is just the list of these open problems you just release them uh what i consider to be the most present open problems in both teleport electronic generic relativity and also in all these modified features of gravity such as gravity and mgr and reality so thank you and if you want to learn more uh two years ago we have finished some uh topical reviews uh subject about gravity illuminating approach okay thanks a lot thank you martin for the nice talk and uh i'm sorry that i have asked many questions if you are feeling no no it's okay yeah so if other people wants to ask question please ask there is no issue and before asking the question please unmute and give a clap for martin for giving such a nice talk for the forum qstm so now you guys can ask questions if there is any question please ask or no question then you can contact martin and there are references also you can look through it i i hope some of the colleagues of yours are also attending so they knows about that if there are some unknown people then they can reach martin also martin is also very active in facebook as well and yeah this talk will be posted in youtube and you guys look into the material and you can contact martin if you have any specific question so thank you martin for this contribution and uh stay safe and healthy in this pandemic time that's all yeah thank you thank you you too yeah so uh so we can then uh talk about it because you wanted to also uh answer questions about the possible project so i think after this talk we can have better uh you know today better communication about this today today uh after this talk uh maybe in future maybe this week i will not prefer next week i will talk to you if you have time okay yeah yeah because we can have some so i'm actually participating in a conference which is called strings which is going on for two weeks right now so apart from having that i am just continuing this conference uh this qasdm talk because i don't want to stop it because a lot of students are following this so yeah so like we can chat more and we can come up with some common and interest area yeah yeah i hope so yeah okay so bye for now and all of you those who are attending thank you for attending this talk and listening to martin and as i have said you can contact martin after seeing this talk you can go to my youtube channel or you can type qastm in youtube you can see all the previous talks including this one so this will be the 90 second talk in the series so you will you can see all the talks there probably martin have looked through the link i have already shared the link with you before anyways so martin bye for now and i know that this is quite late at your place because it is probably 11 o'clock or 12 12 o'clock midnight i think oh it's just nine nine nine forty five oh it's oh oh okay okay okay i'm just confusing korea because korea and japan it is like yeah yeah yeah yes yeah and i'm quite a nice creature so it's okay but okay thanks a lot for inviting me and i was very happy to have this guy so we can chat more about the work and all okay okay perfect bye | Sayantan Choudhury | UCjz_CPU5rzJK0x74jotPoFg | 2021-06-29 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 14,424 | 79,904 |
ZBrcXApaeWo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBrcXApaeWo | Why Do Otherwise Smart People Believe in Conspiracy Theories? | so after the Vegas shooting there's lots of talk about the security guard and a lot of people came up with conspiracy theories and they were so assurer their conspiracy theory was right that this security guard must have been somehow connected to the shooter that when they produced the actual picture of him and then people compared it to a guest an older picture which they knew was actually him and they said they put him side-by-side on Twitter and they said clearly not the same guy they've replaced him with a body double and I looked at the pictures and I'm not I don't buy into the conspiracy theories and therefore I have no emotional investment but other people honest smart completely normal people who can hold jobs look at those pictures is that oh my god this one on the left is a whole different person and when you see that is starkly you're actually standing in the room with somebody who's looking at the same simple thing and they're seeing it differently it's amazing it just it just tells you how powerful this is | Art of Charm | UCS2wqxYdqjnHkkfc90g169g | 2017-12-17 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 188 | 1,034 |
gVa7zIelz_8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVa7zIelz_8 | 2009 Words' Worth Poetry Reading - Curated by Donna Miscolta - Seattle City Council | of storm Weber with us uh reading her poetry she is seattle-born internationally nurtured poet writer singer and performer she's presently a jack straw writers program fellow a Richard Hugo house writer in Residence City artist with the mayor's office of Arts and Cultural Affairs and teaches with Arts core she is the founding artistic director of voices rising lgbtq of color arts and culture she is featured in the award-winning documentary Venus boys and has numerous International performance and cultural production credits storm is currently at work on her Memoir wild Tales of a renegade half-breed and her City artist multimedia performance project Renegade Roots Insurgent Souls so ladies and Gentlemen please lend me your ears to storm Weber thank you so very much I'm very honored to be here today and uh I would just like to say that I dedicate the reading of this poem to my mother Pat Weber my grandmother Maxine Weber and to the people of Gaza the title of this poem is this Joy I have and it comes from a gospel song the lyrics of which said This Joy I have the world didn't give it to me the world didn't give it the world can't take it away there is a bomb to make the wounded home there is a bone to heal the sin six Souls I saw a rainbow sign in the sky rising up from sorrow and the great unknown in song the voices of multitudes many Hues all colors Spirit songs of ancestors ancient and well-loved yet living still in our Soul's memory sailing above our errors and our pride in the beauty streaking across the firmament over this broken World softly singing a song that remakes us we did not come this far to stop now weaving this world with cords of colors made from all of our hearts desires all skins of many tones our breaths rising and Rising again the knowledge that love triumphs eternally over death singing from the bottom to the top arching over sadness joyous glissando rising over victories of good over evil Harriet Tubman her hands strong and steady as the tides if you want to be free keep going her chant never wavering I saw a rainbow sign written in music and it carries me and it carries you all tones all shades full spectrum this moment ripe with possibility this fullness emptying filling again we have all we need every color is there we have come so far we cannot we will not stop here now we will rise as that rainbow rise over the sins of the past lift ourselves past death past grief live our colors as they were meant to be lived if you want to be free keep going at kimon Lieberman with us uh kimon Jose PhD in English specializing in Vietnamese American literature from the University of California Berkeley her poems and essays have appeared in poetry Northwest Prairie Schooner quarterly West zizova calyx three Penny review and the Anthology asianamerica.net ethnicity nationalism and cyberspace currently came on as a faculty member at Seattle's Lakeside School she has taught writing and liberal arts at every level from fifth grade through college and her first book breaking the map from which we'll be reading today was published by Blue begonia press just last year ladies and gentlemen lend me your ears pleased to come on thank you and good afternoon everybody happy New Year If You observe the Chinese zodiac it's the year of the ox it's just begun or if you're Vietnamese like my mother is it's actually the year of the water buffalo either way it's meant to be meant to signify industry and hard work ahead in this year which hopefully will bode well for our economy but uh so you're the water buffalo and uh and the celebration of the Lunar New Year date in Vietnamese is one that a lot of Vietnamese Americans including my mother celebrate with a mixture of both Joy and sadness joy for celebrating this holiday where you meet friends and family and cook lots of food and eat it and enjoy the new year ahead but also sadness for the cultural ties to a country that they've Left Behind which as you are probably all aware Vietnam is a country with a very turbulent history that involves a lot of division and separation and conflict in 1954 the there was a line drawn across the center of the map at the 17th parallel of Vietnam that divided the country in half and separated the north from the south the Communists from the capitalist and meant that the meant that the civil war between those two uh would go on for many decades the U.S was intimately involved in that and then in 1975 when those two halves were reunited there were other divisions that occurred there were millions of Vietnamese who scattered across the globe and found new lives in New countries because they were afraid for their lives in the Communist Regime that had taken place that had taken over Vietnam so a lot of division and separation and and conflict in this history so the poem about to read titled breaking the map it's the title poem from my first collection is my attempting to Grapple with this family history that I inherited as the daughter of a Vietnamese American what that all means to contemplate change and separation and division on such an epic scale it's one thing to draw a line across a map or move a push pin from one continent to another but to actually think about what that means for the people experiencing that in their everyday lives all of the change and work and hardship and sorrow when you separate Neighbors from Neighbors or families from families or an entire country of millions of people from their Homeland that's that's a different thing and as I'm sure you are all aware of in this forum that decisions as they look on paper are never as clean as they come out in the final spin you put a lot of work and effort and thought into making a decision and they still affect people for better or worse in many different ways that's why we come together to make decisions in councils like this so uh so with change and New Years and decisions and separations in mind and the history of a country with a line drawn across the middle this is breaking the map breaking the map they began with a giant carbide rip saw at the designated parallel the course was fibrous and deeply stratified the first mile took 15 days little bits of rock slid from the selvages Rivers disconnected spurted erratically from both ends for Railways and telephone lines Specialists were consulted luckily no mountains the project was broadcast live on National radio helicopters buzzed constantly overhead local hardware stores donated tools by the truckload workers hoisted crowbars jackhammers pickaxes grappling hooks entire Villages volunteered children distributed free lemonade grandparents stationed lawn chairs on either side as the Gap unzipped landowners on the Divide had to think fast Brothers tossed coins for the better half lovers hopped across together discarding their old lives Airlines held last minute lotteries at the terminus an official ceremony with golden hammers a Thunderclap tore through the completed chasm startled those remaining on the edges waved a mechanical goodbye so happy New Year and happy decision making thank you we are happy to Lori blauner with us today she is the author of six books of poetry and two novels as well she received an MFA from the University of Montana her poetry in fiction have appeared in various Publications including the new Republic the nation the Georgia review the Seattle review the New Orleans Review poetry and American Poetry review she has received an any a grant as well as grants and awards from King County Arts commission Seattle Arts commission artist trust and Centrum and she lives in Seattle and she'll be reading with us today so ladies and Gentlemen please lend me your ears for Lori blowner hello I'm gonna my poem is based on the fable about the emperor's new clothes and it's got a little bit it's a little bit of a love poem also so that's appropriate and it's called the emperor's wife belief is everything yet I can't describe his new clothes pornographic as the wins touch the pale Abandoned Ship of his body empty empty as the suggestion of smiles and vows the whispering fills my head light in the terrible room where we tried unsuccessfully to make children I gathered the wreck of him in my arms now air rests its hand against his rough thigh he is laughing waving the all of him he is happy in his strange Fidelity of blood swerving around avoiding his floating heart his political games the innocence of good food moths swarm in the faces of bystanders who know there is nothing between them except their acquiescence the sound of their breath their grins loosened like kites I too take risks not the sun pushing my garments aside with its warm broken kisses my hair uprooted by a breeze but the way I Stay watching him caress the world in its pure nakedness knowing I can't stop him from walking out that door thank you even though spring hasn't yet arrived I'm going to jump ahead to early summer with his poem since here in Seattle spring and early summer and sometimes winter can all look the same excuse me Donna are you speaking right into the mic is it microphone okay is this better good okay uh the title of this poem is on summer solstice on the morning of the summer solstice water seeps from the closet making a small pond at the foot of the bed it's fed from a hole in the roof invisible to the eye scornful of the tar and sheets of plastic my husband has layered there against the rain it comes in drips that change their Cadence so we can't be lulled back to sleep Keeps Us on edge as we anticipate the variations plop plop flip pluck from The Sound I know how the water travels sliding down a beam insinuating itself in the wood along the way separating that cracks in the plaster to nose dive in a bucket or slink its way along a hanger to spread a Rorschach blot against the lining of my coat then it reaches our shoes floods the hiking boots the cross trainers saturates the straps of my unused sandals and in the corner surrounds a derelict umbrella there's a smell of mildew of rotting wood a dampness at the window sills soon we will sample mushrooms that will jut through the moldings count the salmon spawning in the open dresser doors inflator raft and Trace patterns in the bedspread with our oars while we wait for August thank you so much today's poet is Rachel Dilworth Rachel's first book of poems the Wild Rose Asylum poems of the Magdalene laundries of Ireland which chosen by Rita Dove for the 2008 Akron poetry prize and will be published this fall by University of Akron press homes have also appeared in numerous journals including Agony online tricordially and American literary View and are forthcoming and several others she's received a Fulbright Fellowship to Ireland for creative writing Yale's clap Fellowship for poetry Commendation in the UK National poetry competition a Dorothy Sergeant Rosenberg poetry prize and scholarship support from the bread loaf and Napa Valley Riders conferences and she's a 2009 Jack straw Rider and I'm pleased to introduce Rachel thank you very much Donna and I want to say thank you very much to councilman lacada and everyone on the council for having me here today I'm very pleased and honored to be here and I also wanted to say how appreciative I am of this effort to carve out time and and space on a regular basis to to make poetry sort of part of the business of the community which I think is just terrific so thank you very much well I agree with you and I believe that councilmember Licata takes all creditors all credit for this one of the wonderful things that he has brought to the city council am I correct in believing that you're a Seattle resident I'm living in geek Harbor right now Gig Harbor have been a Seattle resident in past yes okay well because our agenda is really brief maybe we can have a little bit of conversation but we'd love to hear your poem now okay um and I thought I would read a poem today that is from the forthcoming book The Wild Rose Asylum poems of the magazine own laundries of Ireland and just for for anyone here in Seattle who might not be familiar with what the Magdalene laundries were they were also called Magdalene asylums and were residential and work institutions working laundry facilities that existed for the care spiritual and moral reformation and containment really of supposedly fallen or Wayward women and in the 20th century that really seems to have encompassed quite a variety of women and girls who were institutionalized in these places for years for a number of different reasons and the the institutions were established and run in Ireland they existed elsewhere as well but in Ireland by Protestant and Catholic philanthropists and then from about the middle of the 19th century throughout the 20th century also by by four female orders of the Catholic church and in the 20th century it was really convents attached to to those orders that ran quite substantially large institutions of this kind so the poem I'm going to read today does not explicitly address the institutions but it is part of a series that is woven throughout the book called The Body sonnets and makes reference in its imagery to a bird that as far as I'm aware we don't have a whole lot of here in Seattle but our sister city in Ireland is full of them and hopefully everyone knows what our sister city is but if you don't it's Galway which is a beautiful wonderful really vibrant town on the west coast a very vibrant Arts Community it's very green and rainy so an awful lot like another city we all know and love here close to home so this is a little reaching out across land and water today to one of Seattle's sister cities body sonnets one credibility so much yourself that even the river is you length fathomed as a curve that stirs the light muscles Wing swept and slow to be moved your very name swan is absolute no part of you is Mystery to itself not breast nor skin nor wind delighting eye no impulse strange to you if seldom felt nor missed nor lost with opportunity time blooms in you whole evenings of milkweed and wet Earth billowing new new as your body makes its own white space builds a pure Relentless physical truth credibility of light you are the star clear argument that justifies the river thank you very much thank you thank you very much for joining us today I'm going to read a poem called Talent night after the rush recedes when a gaggle of tripods next craned line the aisles and the red eyes of cameras bling through Readiness in the dimmed Auditorium the spotlight circles the fifth grade MC who tests the microphone with a knock knock joke satisfied he signals the curtain to open on the First Act a tiny girl Someone's Child perches on a stool squeaks his song off node is gently cued by the audience when she forgets the words then the Applause it Surge and roll moves like a single-celled organism Elemental and enduring Gathering momentum for the 39 acts to go thank you very much poet today is as all the poets so far this year have been part of the Jack star writers program a local arts program it showcases the work of area Riders Angela Martinez D is a poet and spoken word artist educator and activist organizer and MC at age 15 she was a member of isang Mahal Arts Collective and since then has been instrumental in the development of many young Seattle poets a founding member and director of you speak Seattle the Northwest Premier youth literary Arts organization and six-time coach of the Seattle youth poetry slam team which regularly ranks among the nation's top ten Angela has performed and taught creative writing at venues Nationwide she also performs under the name el dia and is part of the Filipina hip-hop Duo first quarter storm she was also a 2007-2008 poet populist nominee and today in honor of Earth Day Angela will read a poem about Earth Day thank you Donna and thank you Nick this poem is entitled human causes in the 1970s they dropped the news like Bombs Over Baghdad before too long the Earth will burn scientists were countered and silenced the phrase global warming erased in official documents today the Earth suffocates in swirling clouds of carbon dioxide the feeling is familiar asthmatic since the age of three when I would choke on my own breath mom would hook me to the ventilator but there's no solution like that for our planet no giant ventilator in the sky to steal from its orbit nor can we stop the Earth spinning long enough to place a mask over her gorgeous cloud-covered face a quarter of all children in Harlem have asthma this is Homeland Security's most significant breach yet hurricane season are coming climatologists have made their findings yet their hands are tied the U.S never ratified Kyoto and now that the protocols passed outdated the temperature is rising and secondhand smoke will kill more than a million species in our ecosystem we will be extinct how much more serious must this get and why are the deciders gone golfing what is the difference between effect and effect answer the global poor Those whom warming oceans and Changing Winds will affect most and yet those who have had the least effect on the current ecological situation how can we undo this Gunner's not global warming tied to a global war let bred on black gold and white ego yet we still pump by the gallon with abandon acting like there's a lot to waste environmental Consciousness must be raised stop playing naive recycle like your life depends on it recycle because your life depends on it if we promote only the use of renewable energy force the automobile industry to cap emissions and rethink its greed the survival of the planet becomes a commercial Priority an uninhabitable world can buy and sell nothing some experts suggest more Highway tolls but let's hit the American people where it will hurt the most ask Fox News to disable the use of Myspace cancel American Idol and every NASCAR race until the CO2 emissions rate dropped 75 percent or more the levels are rising every day the tides are rising too melting ice sheets are predicted to increase sea level a half meter in this Century alone coral reefs will be forced to give up the ghost we both Thrive at the sea surface but the new depths May drown them with our hopes if there is a chance of Salvation to be had in legislation let it not be our last resort thank you thank you [Applause] Mr Ryder she also writes a weekly column from the Ballard News Tribune at large in Ballard and a Blog of the same name for sale seattlepi.com she facilitates writing groups for cancer lifeline and is a contributor to crosscut.com riding on neighborhood issues thanks this poem is in response to one by Naomi shihob Nye which was called so much happiness but on the day that I sat down to write it it was the day after there had been a bicycle accident uh near my home that took the life of a man on his way to work at the University of Washington and so my response was not about happiness the weight it is difficult to know what to do with so much sadness it is a weight heavier than the oldest quilt amazing that the invisible has so much gravity we try to move it off our chests place the sadness in a handmade urn on the fireplace mantle in hands around a paper cup Sheltering a cheap white candle flowers propped between sidewalk and light pole even though the blood stains are in the street handwritten notes and bundled flowers allow us to shift the sadness a bit juggle it from hand to hand Hot Potato distracting us with pain o for a burn that could be cooled by Ice sadness is not so easily deterred we are choking on it there is nothing to do but try to endure note a pulse a pleasure at the orange of Sunrise despite yourself draw warmth from the person next to you appreciate that your own heart still pushes blood it's hard to survive when someone else does not but the heart's work shouldn't go to waste one morning the smell of coffee brewing will be pleasant the shower will not just be the best place to cry most of us do recover from Sadness the grief doesn't float Downstream with the ashes and rose petals it doesn't stay nailed to the light pole ink fading sadness walks us home sits on our chest it's not a matter of knowing what to do but how to keep breathing while we wait thank you thank you very much Molly Tenenbaum Molly is the author of now from bear Star Press by a thread from Van West and Company and the chat books Blue Willow old wall and story her old-time banjo CD is titled instead of a pony Molly enjoys bicycling between Seattle's Ravenna neighborhood where she lives and North Seattle Community College where she teaches music and writing thanks so I picked a poem that's uh well it's one of his theories of about different kinds of civilizations that we might create uh if the artists were creating civilizations this might be one of them but there's a few drawbacks to it I don't know my metal civilization the walls are made of every metal art braidings of Rose yellow gold sweeps of brushed pewter feather fine chasings garlands of Galloping iron and over rot with decoration armalu fleur-de-lis spirals of burnished brass dots fluted lead copper leaf shearings panels in bronze of fruits and flowers inset with every color and shape opal carbuncles Agate and taglio lacings of Kingfisher Jade Columns of mutton fat Jade swirls dotted Garnet each Stone smaller than a flea and lapped behind hammered roses leafed over by beaten bronze Laurel are hundreds of doors some like pin tips so small you can't see them some so Leviathan huge you can't see them some under the Paw of a bronze relief leopard some in the laugh of a bronze relief monkey some wound around with shining Vines but all you see are the vines in each wall thousands of doors and for everyone you find thousands more are hidden and for everyone you open thousands more hinges sleep folded the walls glow in flickers deep black in the creases no doors to be seen and maybe you haven't opened a one for all that you've opened not when at all Slumber now here in the corner here is your palette of straw here your warm Patchwork cover your mother sewed it herself of what spilled from her hamper of rags thank you thank you pleased to have Allison green with us who is the author of um the novel novel Half Moon Scar and stories and poems published in a number of literary journals uh three poems were recently published in jumpstart and Anthology from Northwest Renaissance Allison chairs the Arts and Humanities division at Highline Community College and we're happy to have her here everyone please lend your ears to Allison green thank you this is a sonnet and it's called Barista love the ones who came before her had their charms a bell whose double earrings and tattoos were quite as lovely as Bernard's blue hair and scars but I moved on my first true loves were two Elaine who did the hard work of the pull and Sarah Beth who made the pretty milk she wore her necklines low her poodle skirts were full they got their scholarships to Smith and swore they would be back but I was on my own the Barista at my bakery was I learned a poet of espresso and amen a poet of the word as well and earned her wage by knowing drinks and names and more her Crema brought the Mormons in the door thank you [Applause] | SeattleArchives | UCC9MOnyhiHBINthDWJE-GDQ | 2016-05-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 4,222 | 23,320 |
7Pes9vKXwdI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pes9vKXwdI | (108) Yale 81 deadlock teardown | hi folks so today we have another non picking video because I recently had to order this piece of equipment for a for a customer who had a fairly unusual need so what this is is the Yale model 81 roller bolt deadlock and exactly what that me what that means we'll see in a second so let's just start by unboxing this thing and we'll sort of go through it as we do all that so we got the box a lot this little cardboard first we have the cylinder that's included with it which seems to be fairly standard for Yale's current rim locks the cylinder body looks like it's cast from probably zamak but the actual plug seems to be milled brass which is not not the worst in the world stamped brass coloring bag with a bunch of got a mix of wood screws fairly short ones and some different sized machine screws and that little white plastic piece is to align the tail piece of the cylinder with the actual bolts as you assemble it we've got this other cardboard divider here we've got the instruction sheet put aside and we have in this bag here we have these striped box and this is a an actual box because we have first this plate here which would be mounted on the doorframe put a couple of wood screws or middle screws depending on what your Matt to get on through there and then this slides over it and is secured to it with a couple of machine screws here and then a couple more wood or metal screws to secure that to the frame so as far as strike designs go this is pretty pretty solid stuff you can see it's none of this is really none of the surfaces that actually will be bearing the weight of the bolt when it's if someone is trying to push in the door those are all pretty solid parts there which is good as a strike design and then we finally get to the bolt itself so just get that box out of the way and let's get this thing out of the bag because this is really what makes this interesting so from the outside you know all of this is pretty much standard for Yale's modernized rim lock bed bolts this is basically the the modern version of their night lights they still do the classic night latch design but this is the modernized version so first thing is this plate here that sort of slides around right now is the mounting plate it combines as you can see right here it combines the retainer plate for the cylinder that's where the tail piece goes and then these two holes here or if you're mounting it the other way these two holes here are where the retaining screws go and then these two tabs with the screw holes are secured are used to secure the bolt to the door by a couple of machine screws insert it there so we'll put that aside and here's really where things get interesting because this is obviously not a standard deadbolt it has this little brass roller right here which is why it's called a roller bolt and if we and we notice that it's kind of always seems to be extended here this is the unlocked position for the lever and right here it is very springy so I can just push it in with my thumb there but if I turn that lever to the lock position now this is fully extended this has about a 3/4 inch throw and that is deadlocked so how does all that work and what is this for well we'll start by opening this guy up I get a Phillips head here and remove one screw there and one screw there and by the way this little circular piece right here is just where the tale of the rim cylinder engages with the lock to lock and unlock the bolt and now with those two screws removed we can just lift this plate off it sort of hooks into the body a little bit with this tab on the front so if we put that aside now we get into the actual inner workings of this so let's try this again with the cover off have to be kind of careful this is a bunch of Springs in here but basically you can see here that as I move the lever it lifts this post up which starts to turn this plate and that plate slides forward and that post right there and those two pieces push the bolt all the way forward and locks them in place and then similarly if I flip the lever back the other way if it doesn't drop out of its track like that it withdraws so this is just a very simple plate with a long curved flat spring to keep that leveled and then there's the bolt itself here so here we can see with the lever in the locked position that post drives up against this surface on the bolt and this would normally draw bolt back now let's see if we can actually remove the bolt safely because there is this spring right here which helps push the bolt out so we have to be very careful about that when we disassemble this because otherwise it would just go flying across the room we don't want that okay there we go so I've got the bolt out managed to smack my thumb with the spring there you can see this groove on the bolt itself or on the main part of the bolt is where that spring rides and that keeps it aligned and keeps that bolt biased outward and then inside all we're left with is the is the lever on the inside it's this cam with a post on it and this spring and pretty much everything else in there are just these little cast in tabs which are designed to keep all the different parts aligned and spaced correctly and then there's this wire spring probably steel so that general type of construction is actually pretty similar to the classic the classic night latch bodies they just happen to be made of cast iron originally so basically the idea of this is that that springiness allows this to act as both a latch and as a dead bolt in one lock which makes it very useful if for some reason you can only fit a a rim lock and you need a dead bolt but you also but the thing is that normally you have to have a latch on a door because the the the latch is usually considered the primary lock on a door and the deadbolt is the secondary lock the latch is what keeps it closed most latches really only going to have enough strength to keep a door secure against a heavy wind or sort of a light push it's not going to stop a kick in or any sort of determined forceful attempt to force the door open the deadbolt has that extra strength that extra resistance to withstand that forceful attack but the broad flat face of the deadbolt if it doesn't have if it's pushed up against the strike has a lot of friction a lot of friction and it can very easily cause a deadbolt to jam or be difficult to withdraw if you only have a deadbolt filled fitted so this design is sort of an interesting compromise this roller together with this rounded surface here allows this bolt to be a deadbolt a perfectly good deadbolt but it can also act like a spring latch when it's in the unlock position which is kind of an interesting thing and happens to be a rather unusual circumstance apparently in in England it is a common enough issue that Yale actually made a deadbolt design specifically to address that scenario there's no real equivalent for it in the US which is why I had to go and send away to England for this customer to get them to get them set up with this so I just thought it was an interesting and unusual bit of hardware that people outside of England or even people in England who aren't familiar with this design might might find interesting so thank you very much for watching and until next time have fun and happy picking | Nite 0wl | UCmfHHBoZXQ_W32o_uZDIr5A | 2018-11-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,435 | 7,324 |
zwUKa8E4zKw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwUKa8E4zKw | SingSing Crazy AA. 25 Min scepter + Refresher Orb | Oh Oh that's crazy telling I don't have enough damage uh no the [ __ ] wisdom oh my god see players hahahaha she's like I'm fantastic unless you guys [ __ ] blows away oh I didn't Rob II know I couldn't you live like a little bit longer doesn't go for it org Wow Wow why is it so small why is it so small why would you say that that's a visual bug there okay so yeah Wow Wow 20 min al t thank God I'm not in that [ __ ] you see that Magnus how much he trusted or the Chafee how much it was at the magnet most likely did very high chance maybe not maybe he lives I think it lives didn't I have a fresh fish [ __ ] oh really slow oh it's fake oh no me I mean thank God it decided to skewer instead of RP wow it's perfecto for men crazy a plus Wow everyone still tilted what no no argh this guy's still live did I kill him keep it by back argh so is the guy in the back phone Dean wait for me but now all dodging day ulti what they don't know is a test - or he's like I'm safe now but then then they work out oh my [ __ ] god oh [ __ ] god I got one I got one of the image I'm innocent well it is quite hates me now you dive I bought back for this [ __ ] yes no you're both alive we're shadow fetcher or he dies but Barack Obama is alive in this guy's alive Wow the [ __ ] that should he go nice cut what's the charge where is the charge where's your rapier you [ __ ] go this literally five Monnet ulted right now oh my god wait a teepee oh my god whatever back to it which one is you it's this one I think he stole my W spell he did it's really sad to be oh my god the folder I was gonna make some distance between the same polka when this summit start Fiji | mrpapudj21 | UC9_u2ozW5O4tvuiaiSmZmEQ | 2015-05-19 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 352 | 1,746 |
wPRRfIelWPg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPRRfIelWPg | Sendas geopolíticas de la transición energética - Geopolitical pathways for the energy transition | [Music] perspective [Music] a and [Applause] a francisco is [Music] is [Music] is [Music] thank you very much for joining us for us it's a real pleasure having you here virtually with us in this session and please the the floor is yours first of all thank you manuel for the very kind introduction and i'm really delighted to be joining you today and i would like to thank the organizers for the very kind invitation and for this opportunity i would really have very much love to join you in person but the airline had different plans and my flight was cancelled but hopefully there will be other opportunities so the title of my talk today is the energy transition in the middle east and of course this is a very broad topic and i'll try to break it down into a few parts the first one i will highlight some of the features of the energy transition which i think are quite important and could impact the middle east oil and gas producers and then i will discuss some of the strategies that the middle east oil and gas exporters can adopt to confront the potential impacts of the transformations in an energy sector on their economies finally i will conclude with a few thoughts on the geopolitics of the energy transition and the importance of avoiding some broad general conclusions that sometimes we hear especially when it comes to the middle east but before doing that let me start with um with one observation um and that is the fact that um oil rents have brought massive economic benefits to oil and gas exporters and that actually has been reflected in most socio economic and development indicators though this have happened to varying degrees you know some countries have benefited much more than others from the oil rates but at the same time one has to recognize that the heavy reliance on oil revenues has also created its own economic and institutional drawbacks uh for instance the instability and volatility of our revenues have contributed to macroeconomic instability and very volatile economic growth also there's a wide literature which shows that the distribution of our rents have contributed to weak institutional environment and many economic distortions for instance this include a weak private sector which is heavily dependent on the government very rigid labor markets a wide sort of inefficiencies subsidies which tend to distort production and consumption decisions and all of these have been reflected in relatively weak economic growth and declining gdp per capita over time especially as the populations have been increasing now these challenges are going to become much more pronounced as the prospects for oil demand are becoming more uncertain due to the energy transition and the carbonization policies now i i don't have any demand projections myself but i would like to make a few observations when it comes to peak oil demand and energy transition the first one is that the oil demand projections are extremely sensitive to the underlying assumptions of the model these very much depend on the assumptions you make about economic growth about population growth about the transformation you see in the transport sector and the global carbon taxes and these are just few examples and actually changing these assumptions one can push forward or backward the peak by decades the other observation that i would like to make as well is that it's very important to understand what is the purpose of the exercise because sometimes we some people are referring to forecasting and some people are referring to back casting what do i mean by back casting basically people assume that we are going to reach our net zero targets by 2050 and then they start working their way back and of course there are different paths that you can work your back uh your way back and that's why quite important is that when we're looking at this projection it's very important to understand the purpose of the exercise whether it's forecasting or whether it's back casting another observation i would say is that most of the scenarios predict that there's going to be a unique global peak and then after that all demand will decline sharply after reaching this unique peak now in reality we could see actually other types of scenarios where all demand could plot over a long period of time or we could see actually multiple peaks so oil demand could decline in certain years and increase in other years depending on many factors so this idea that we're going to have only one peak and after that all demand is going to decline fast after that peak i think you know that makes projections modeling projection quite simpler but the world can turn out to be different and of course there is no consensus on many of the underlying assumptions some of the projections are based on historical trends which tend to show that fast transition in the energy system has rarely happened whether other projections are based on the assumption that this transition is quite unique because it involves fighting climate change and it's going to be driven by government policy and technological advancements uh now i would say um i would like you know to just mention a few features of the energy transition which i think are quite important in the middle east uh context uh because it will shape their energy policies looking forward and i would like to mention few of these first of all that the speed of the energy transition is highly uncertain uh the second one is that that transition will not be uniform across the globe the third one is that transition will not be linear it could be disruptive there could be setbacks and the final point which i would like to emphasize especially towards the end of my talk is that there is no single transition pass there are many transition paths out out there however regardless of the speeds uh the impacts of of the transition are already being felt uh the perceptions and players behaviors are shifting much much faster than actual changes in the energy mix and this is already shaping the energy industry on some key decisions for instance if you look in terms of finance this is the energy transition and perceptions of the changes and the transformation associated with the energy transition are already affecting investors risk preferences and this is going to impact financing costs the availability of finance for hydrocarbon projects and also the investments going into the into the sector it's also already altering the behavior of many players including the international energy companies which are adapting their strategies they are incorporating climate related objectives into their strategies they are reducing the share of oil assets in their portfolios uh some of them are increasing the share of gas and renewables and many of them have been announcing ambitious targets to reach net zero emissions by 2050. now when it comes to oil exporters especially those from the middle east they face greater challenges than the international energy companies and that's for a couple of reasons the first one is that the approved reserve to production ratios extend for multiple decades so they really they face the real challenge of how to monetize a much larger reserve base than international energy companies so for instance if you look at international or energy companies you know the approved reserve to production is measured in years whereas for the national companies and for the countries this is measured in decades the other reason as well is that the risk of losses in export revenues could disrupt their socio-economic well-being given the high reliance of their economies on oil revenues so really the key question to me is what adaptation strategies should oil exporters pursue given that there are domestic economic and political constraints there is an energy transition which is changing those prospects of oil demand but whose speed is uncertain and whose impact is not uniform across the globe while at the same time we're seeing perceptions behaviors and policies changing quite fast and of course one of those strategies is to diversify away from the oil and gas sector and that's what many consultancy consultancies and many international organizations tend to to recommend but i would argue that there are real challenges to realize meaningful diversification particularly fiscal diversification this requires a massive economic transformation this requires serious and extensive economic reforms labor market reforms private sector reforms human capital enhancement and there is really uncertainty about how quickly or even whether such extensive economic institution reforms can be implemented in most oil and gas exporting countries also one has to emphasize that the oil and gas sector remain very profitable and still enjoy very high margins and governments can leverage on oil and gas revenues to ease the pains of the structural reforms which are needed to diversify their economic base also i would make the the other argument another argument as well that the reduced investment flows into the oil and gas sector can cause supply to fall faster than demand and this could result in higher margin at least for short periods of times so exiting too early from such an established strategic sector deprives the country of an important source of income and a key source of competitive advantage so that's why perhaps one needs uh to refine the question a little bit more if diversifying from the oil and gas sector is sub-optimal for the reasons that i mentioned and it cannot be achieved at a rapid pace then the question perhaps could be how to enhance the competitiveness and increase the resilience of the hydrocarbon sector in a world that is transitioning towards net zero emissions and here the oil and gas exporters face some some choices and one of these is that many of the oil and gas exports especially those in the middle east can compete on costs and actually can take measures to improve the efficiency of production and lower these costs even further some some of the oil and gas exporters actually can pursue faster monetization and extraction strategies and that is what is known in the literature as the green paradox now all of these strategies have uh have their limitations because the lack of fiscal diversification and the high social cost of production acts as a constraint on this strategy you know increasing supply in phase of slowing demand would result in much lower revenues at least in the shorter term in the longer term we could see the exit of many producers and some of the middle eastern producers can benefit from the exit of those high cost producers or those lower cost producers that are not able to increase productive capacity for variety of reasons so that's one aspect that one needs to take into account the other is that some important countries may decide to implement to implement high carbon taxes and this will create a wedge between the revenue generated by oil and gas exporters and the revenue generated by consuming countries with the consuming countries capturing big part of the rent as the as they introduce those taxes so this is one strategy that oil and gas exporters can pursue faster monetization but this has its limitation the other strategy that oil and gas exporters can pursue is to try to diversify into their products and exports closely related to the hydrocarbon sector and energy intensive industries those are industries which those oil and gas exporters have some competitive advantage in i'm talking about petrochemicals steel cement and fertilizers and other energy intensive industries and this could create actually higher value added products and can provide the hedge against price volatility and it can lead to the developments of sectors which have technological spillovers but again heavy industrialization into energy-intensive industries increases the domestic emissions of greenhouse gases and it will make it much more difficult for these countries to meet their climate targets and of course one have to take into account the response of importing countries for instance importers can develop policies uh to account for carbon content of final goods and they could decide to apply border carbon adjustment measures and again this will have the impact of capturing part of the rent away from the producers doers to the consumers so that is why one of the arguments that i've been making is that that producers whether oil and gas need to ensure that their production processes and core hydrocarbon products can compete also in the emissions front so the competition should not only be on the cost front but it also should be should be done also in the emission and reduction and that actually involves reducing emission in the production process scope 1 and scope 2 and in the consumption of gas and petroleum products derived from crude and natural gas basically what people sometimes refer to as scope 3 emissions and i would argue that some oil and gas exporters are in a relatively better position compared to other producers and especially those in the middle especially those in the middle east they are in a much better position because of the low carbon content of their crude and because of the heavy investment and infrastructure which some of the countries have implemented in reducing gas flaring and methane emission and the real challenge to me lies in reducing emission from the consumption of their final of their final pentorium products now one of the things that those countries could do within the energy sphere of course is investment in renewables and this is likely to create a new sectors which will have some competitive advantage and because the mina countries the middle east countries you know they are have rich solar resources and have rich wind resources and at the same time also they can integrate renewables within the existing hydrocarbon infrastructure and this would allow them to reduce emissions in their production and the extraction process and actually this would allow them also to increase oil and gas export potential without increasing productive capacity because this will reduce their demand for hydrocarbon products but again you know one needs to emphasize that the margins and renewables cannot fully substitute for the rents generated by the hydrocarbon sector so this concept that you are going to convert a hydrocarbon exporter and switch them to a renewable exporter and that could be happen easily i think that's a wishful thinking and that's why it's very important to emphasize that the exporters in addition to investing in renewables they need to decarbonize their core activities and core exports to compete in a carbon constrained world and that is why i've been emphasizing the importance of certain technologies and particularly the deployment of carbon capture utilization and storage which is needed actually to help the world achieve the goal of net zero emission and that actually will enable also the oil and gas exporter to be part of the mix especially that you know so far if you look at most of the projections they're still expecting oil and gas to remain part of the energy mix also for some energy intensive hardware-based sectors such as steel and cement technical options to reduce emissions without ccs are currently very limited and most of the ipcc scenarios also assume a very important role for ccs otherwise it will not be possible to limit the temperature rise to one and a half degrees now why i emphasize the ccs because i think this is a very important dimension related to oil and gas exporters because this is a climate mitigation actions through which some oil and gas exporters could establish a competitive advantage and this is due to the fact that their natural resources particularly geological storage capacities their access to depleted hydrocarbon reservoir and their existing infrastructure all of these are important factors that oil and gas exporters can exploit to build competitive advantage in these sectors also in the technical resources because they have massive expertise in subsurface technology and also the deployment of the ccs can provide an opportunity for them to contribute to climate change action but at the same time as i mentioned to try to monetize the reserves in a more sustainable way and retain the competitiveness if they're of the oil of their oil and gas sectors and energy-intensive industries in a carbon-constrained world and despite the strategic interest for oil and gas exported to lead on the carbon sync mitigation strategies what we see is that most of the ccs projects are located in ocd countries and from an oil exporter i have always argued that investment in cce as ccos lowers the returns compared to existing strategy which is fine but at the same time it increases resilience so you might have you might end up with lower returns but actually it can increase the resilience of your sector and not leading on the ccos france could risk undermining their competitive position but at the same time shifting the cost to oil and gas exporters alone i don't think this is a viable especially if the costs are too high because after all the producing countries especially those in the middle east are likely to be most affected by the transition and there's going to be a lot of competition for limited funds to try to diversify their economies so that is why it's very important to develop burden-sharing mechanisms which allows a much more inclusive path and that will include that we think outside the box into new instruments such as the well head carbon taxes ccr clubs creating carbon storage units but this requires harmonization of policy policies this requires strong cooperation either on a multilateral framework or by bilateral framework and that basically turns me to a very key point that i emphasize in the in the beginning is that there are going to be various transition paths and this is going to depend very much on the starting points the core competitive advantages of these countries and the existing assets that they hold insisting on a single path could delay the transition because it will not enable the use of the technical and financial resources of the producers it may perpetuate non-cooperative behavior on negotiations and increase the cost of the transitions and that's why it's very important to provide frameworks that don't discriminate against certain technologies or fuels and allow for technologies to compete but it also allows that developing burden-sharing mechanism between importers and exporters and integrate these into multilateral and bilateral frameworks and what is really quite encouraging is that we see many of the middle east oil and gas exporters becoming very active playing very active role in climate change negotiations but one also needs to recognize as well that oil and gas exporting countries need to show leadership in mitigation technologies and decarbonization and that leadership should be on the technological front or the investment framework on the business model and and push for frameworks that promote burden-sharing mechanisms to offset part of the cause and shield their economies i do appreciate that this strategy is costly and risky but so are the alternative technologies and now let me conclude with just one couple of observations many are of the view that the middle east oil and gas exporters will emerge as the different definite losers from the energy transition and this is based on the premise that oil demand will decline sharply and as a result of that we're going to see the erosion of oil rents and also the importance of oil and gas as a strategic community will fall and this is and as a result of that we're going to see that your political position of the amina oil export is also declining and in that world according to this view we're likely to see oil and gas exporters engaging in a fees competition for market share in a declining market and this is going to also lower margins and revenues and of course given the undiversified economic structure of all exporters and rigidity of their government spending this will result in economic disruptions and instability and that will destroy the social fabric of these countries i would argue that this analysis is quite deterministic it's quite simplistic and actually it does not help in the way we think about the energy transition and i would just like to make to conclude with few observations to why i think this is the case first of all mena oil and gas exporters are not a homogeneous group and their resilience and core sources of competitive advantage vary tremendously within the region there are some countries that have the assets they have the ability uh to to compete in in the energy transition world the other reason as well is that the energy transition can cause dislocations and energy markets that the middle east exporters or some of them can benefit from and can exploit and the third point which is i think is very very important is that some of the key oil and gas exporters are not standing still and they are evolving and responding to the challenges that the energy transition may bring so the concept of losers and winners in the energy transition is not useful in the meaner context i think you know we need to recognize that energy transition will pose real challenges um to mean oil and gas exporters but the focus should be on whether mean x vena exporters are prepared to deal with these challenges whether they are increasing their resilience to the potential disruptions and whether they are adopting strategies that they could help confront the they help them confront some of these challenges and i would argue just to conclude that some of the amina oil exporters are in a very good position and a much better position than others and maybe even in a position to benefit from the transformation associated with the energy transition and actually can play an important role in that process so with that i conclude and thank you very much for the kind invitation and for the opportunity [Applause] thank you very much bassam a real impressive presentation from the site and about what the energy transition means in the in the middle east countries and the application for the rest of the world in this in this with this all these great challenges we are facing as is the climate change sustainability and security of supply we are now going to move to the next part of the of the seminar where we will have a debate with exceptional participants real true experts not only in the in the world of energy but also in the world of security and uh specifically in the in the area we are in the region we are focusing on today first of all we have with us and mariana capollo so sorry this is markets and policy associated in the european union the asean office of the european federation of energy traders and she's also she also served as research analyst in energy security with the nato association of canada uh it's also with us nora mansouri nora's research fellow at the kin abdullah petroleum studies and research center is also research affiliate at mit and an expert at the world energy council she has many publications on climate change and sustainability and sustainable energy transitions and she is the author of the book greening the black gold south arabia's quest for clean energy nora is also a founder and board member of the saudi association of energy economics here with us is also chloe berger chloe is a faculty advisor on researchers at the nato defense college her research work focuses mainly on security political and social economic issues in the mena region and the implications for nato and and finally carlos gasco uh who is since 2019 the energy policy executive director of the department of energy of the united arab emirates carlos is an economist and has held various positions in both private companies and public administration in spain of course all of these all these excellent panel of participants will have to be moderated for another great expert as gonzalo scrivano is gonzalo directs the energy and climate program of el cano royal institute and is a full professor of economic policy in the department of applied economics of the united his research agenda focuses on international energy issues geopolitics the economics of energy energy security renewable energies and the interaction of energy resources with economic development of producer producing countries in short there can be a better person to moderate this this great debate i indicate to all of you that all people who's connected that can send the questions through the platform you are connected uh and here the people in the auditorium through the cars that you received at the entrance of the of the auditorium that will be collected by the by the organization if you if you wish uh thank you very much all of you again for joining us and then being here with with us for for us is a real pleasure and honor i'm gonna follow it's your turn okay thank you so much manuel and thank you rafael and the network foundation it's always a pleasure to be here with you uh thank you so much for for making this possible thank you so much to these great panelists for for making it to be with us i'm going to try to very very quickly start with the discussions we don't miss and we are very time and energy efficient so i will post three a round of questions to to to the speakers and you can answer whatever you want to my questions to other people questions or whatever you want to see so um let's have a frank an open discussion and i will start immediately with dr massouri yes okay so i would like you and i will post mainly the same question to carlos uh looking from saudi arabia and from a more general regional perspective how do you nora from from from saudi arabia and you carlos from from the emirates how do you see the energy transition from your region thank you very much gonzalo and now i'd like to take the opportunity to thank you for the kind invitation it's a pleasure for me to be here so thank you for this important question in fact the energy transition in the region and especially in saudi arabia and the gulf have started a long time ago in fact saudi arabia has showcased its environmental stewardship since the 70s when it has decided to stop flaring the gaza and instead has founded an industry around around it around hydrocarbons and specifically petrochemicals but more most notably saudi arabia has announced its net zero target by 2060 just before cop26 and has doubled its national determined contributions to 278 tons of million tons of co2 by 2030. so saudi arabia is very much serious about the energy transition and is creating this road map towards net zero by establishing so many initiatives in fact there's been a lot of announcements around these initiatives including the saudi green initiatives of planting 10 billion trees across saudi arabia the middle east green initiative for planting 40 billion trees across the region this is in addition to its ambitions for um including 50 renewable energy and its energy mix by 2030 and a number of giga projects that will help in the economic diversification of the country and this will help in achieving mitigation co-benefits for the climate we have the blueprint of vision 2030 that has sustainability at the heart of it and environmental sustainability and these giga projects including the future city of neon which plans to use 100 renewable energy and plans to be the home for the world's largest green hydrogen to produce 650 tons of green hydrogen daily and we already have prospective importers of of this green hydrogen saudi arabia also exported blue ammonia to japan it shipped it was the world's first shipment of blue ammonia so this is evident of using hydrocarbons in a clean way and burning it in a clean way there has also been a lot of achievements in the red sea development projects the amala project would keep sustainability and regenerative even industries in the tourism industry blue carbon economy and many other initiatives that keeps the environmental sustainability uh at the heart of it you have to to read their papers i mean all these people here you have to read their papers because they got really look at their web pages of their institutions because they are really really wonderful papers especially you you got several ones thank you very very worthy to read are going immediately now to clove and and we changed a little i mean coming from nato defense college uh chloe what what will be your personal assessment and i'm expecting i'm waiting for your disclaimer probably but it will be your personal assessment of the ukraine crisis for the gulf and from the middle east region on your strategic assessment so thank you very much thank you very much for the known station and i'm really pleased to be here uh and so yes the i mean institutional uh classical disclaimer that uh of course i'm representing you know uh my own views not uh the alliance or uh nato defense college uh actually views so uh having said that uh what is uh i would say the impact of the european war on uh the gulf countries i would say that from a regional perspective there are probably better place than other countries in the mena region so they have uh i would say from huge wheat imports but at the same time huge reserves small population if you compare i would say this ratio uh was adject or tunisia they are definitely you know a better place uh so this is it from i would say a domestic perspective at the same time what i can see is the fact that we have european countries trying to reduce their dependency vis-a-vis russia and so this implies that they are looking for alternative i would say providers uh of energy supplies so you have of course north africa but you have also a traditional i would say partners in the gulf and so this will probably i would say rise you know new security challenges or reinvigorate i would say the tensions that we have seen they are pre-existing uh tensions in the gulf and so this will i would say uh increase you know uh security uh related challenges to of course uh the securitization of uh shipping shipping routes you have also all the protection of the uh i would say production infrastructures and so we have seen that cyber security is already uh something that is really uh you know an ongoing part of the conflictuality in the region so this raised the question of who is providing security guarantees to the gulf countries and so we have seen with this war that obviously there are some i would say geopolitical shifts uh the gulf countries have made very clearly that they are not ready to align uh you know on the west or on russia they have developed their own i would say past and they are very keen in maintaining i would say this you know kind of balanced position and so the problem is that to which extent i would say the geopolitical challenges will force those countries to uh to choose and so one paradox that uh this one ukraine is actually posing is the fact that we have countries that are encouraged to uh consider you know strategic paths and investments to develop i would say more sustainable uh you know energy mix and at the same times we have a crisis that is forcing european countries to uh find you know quick fix solution for uh our uh i would say supplies now so we have countries that are basically uh are basically compelled to make very quick decisions on structural i would say options and so this is also things that of course will have implications on the security side and so i was referring to security guarantees to which extent the u.s will keep being i would say the main security provider to those countries this is something to be seen to which extent those countries will renegotiate i would say the transactional relations they have with the u.s and have i would say alternative options like russia but maybe more than russia china and so we all understand that you know this will of course at the point maybe uh colleague was you know the us i would say strategy towards uh ando pacific the indo-pacific area so all those components have to be uh taken into consideration when i would say the security uh challenges are stake for the for the gulf countries and of course we have in the region probably we will see an increase of instability uh having in mind you know domestic challenges uh raised by food insecurity connected to ukrainian and russian exports of wheat and so increased domestic instability in the world neighborhood will have of course implications for gulf countries we have a time where you know uh gulf countries will be also more compelled to help stability stabilizing i would say the neighborhoods and so this is all challenges that i mean the gulf countries will have to to solve in i would say a separate or bilateral you know past or as a gcc and so this is also a very good question to which extent this crisis will help the gcc countries uh i would say close the chapter uh about their own device or on the contrary well exacerbates uh i would say those device um this is this is still uh to be seen that's fascinating i see uh the next nato summit here in madrid they will get a lot of homeworks to do probably on the energy matter too yes definitely okay we move now to carlos and carlos i will ask you exactly the same question that i asked to to to nora what is the regional perspective on the energy transition from the emirates but in your case you can have a dual perspective also not only how do you see it but how to explain this to we europeans oh thank you othello very much and thank you to the energy foundation and to realistic for having me here is it's just amazing to actually be here today discussing sharing some thoughts hopefully sharing some light as well um just like chloe i also need to um you know say my own little disclaimer i'm all my opinions are personal i am not here in representation of the official position of the department of energy of abu dhabi but i am here um obviously with my experience and everything that i can provide to the debate in an open transparent and hopefully interesting way i i would take advantage of that disclaimer to be a little bit provocative for the sake of the discussion for the sake of the debate just i would like everybody to think that you could fly that you could go away because because what we do here in this part of the world tends to be you know quite robust from a technical or from an analytic point of view but it's also narrow the one thing that i've learned in the last four years where i've been working outside of europe is that the world is a lot bigger than europe and much bigger than spain so just go somewhere else and put yourself in the shoes of someone in the middle east in the shoes of someone in the developing nation maybe in india maybe in china maybe somewhere in latin america or or in africa and think of the debate today the energy decision the energy transition is great everybody likes the energy transitions they the germans have this this energy vendor which is we need to move we have to change but is is it a european issue is it a western priority or is it a global priority and when we look at what it what it wants to achieve and what is happening we need to think twice i think because the energy transition is about sustainability security of supply and affordability and if we look at what happens and now put yourself as i said in the issues of someone who is 7000 kilometers away from here and looks at these three things emissions are increasing we are already above the emissions levels pandemic levels so that is not working at least not as much as it should maybe it's working compared to what would happen if but the reality is we are above the second is secretary of supply energy security we just realized that we have a massive issue right and it costs money which links to the third thing the affordability uh so we put all these efforts in our policies and our strategies in our language in the corporate behaviors and the government behaviors everything and on what we collect i'm not saying that we're failing but i'm saying that we're not succeeding let's say we could do better right so the middle east is right in the middle between the east and the west and at the same time the middle east is providing hydrocarbons you know to the economies of the east and the west so and at the same time the middle east is witnessing like everybody why these things in in the in energy problems in the energy transition are failing or not succeeding at least and i would say you know as i said to be a bit provocative i think uh we we think or we could be said that there is a lack of realism in the definition of the policies of the energy transition we've been speaking about renewables and all of these green transition but we didn't realize that we also needed the hydrocarbons to do part of the job and you know it just suddenly we emerge from the pandemic and the supply is rigid and the demand skyrockets and the prices spike so that's the one thing the second thing is if it's so important and if the problems are the emissions related to the hydrocarbons why don't we take them seriously why don't we tax or why don't we price the emissions why don't we phase out the technologies if the problem is global why don't we help the economies they cannot pursue their own goals the way they have to to to fight the global problem and this is seen by the world and the third the third issue is are the technologies there for us we speak about things for 2050 but we don't know really how we're going to achieve them you know energy storage is fundamental do we have the ability uh is is the energy transition a a mining transition because we will need a lot of minerals and materials to build that storage to make this energy transition happen but are there for us and if they are where are they are we substituting some of the energy dependency from a mineral dependency is this electrostate are they actually mining states and lastly we put face in things which are to some extent still unproven hydrogen i mean it looks great on paper but when you go and speak to an airline and say you have to fly your airplanes with hydrogen and then this is what i don't think i can and maybe i can technically but can i afford it when you say i will you know excess capacity in the summer or in the winter depending on the jurisdiction i will store it in the form of hydrogen and then deliver seasonal storage which is what we need for the renewables and all that with an efficiency of 15 percent uh so we need to take the air uh co2 from the atmosphere directly if we need to succeed but we still don't know how to do it or maybe we do but it is not affordable so we need to recognize that the energy decision is fundamental it's important but it's not easy or cheap and if we don't come to terms to that we will still run around in circles and this is what is seen from the middle east but i think this is what is seen from everywhere and this is what some people out there not europeans call the western hypocrisy because we do all these things we have this language but at the same time we don't do other things but we tell everybody how they should say behave so now i'm back to the original question the middle east i can speak um and this was trying to answer just your second the second part of the question but the first one is what does the energy transition mean for the middle east and in particular for the uae well it means business it means opportunities it means change it means diversification it means moving from a old paradigm into a new paradigm but this is a very big part the middle east produces the cleanest most competitive oil and gas that there is anywhere it will continue to sell these products for decades to come what it means is the uncertainty of not if you will sell them because it's been said before some players with higher costs will have to be pushed out of a shrinking cake but how much money will you make this is a commodity so small price or differential will generate an important impact on your revenues or cost differential so that is what it means it means volatility it means uncertainty and it means a challenge to move from the already volatile uh oil markets or hydrocarbon markets into a more resilient more stable more predictable economy and that means instead of focusing on the molecules or the electrons focusing on the industrial processes focusing on the real economy and using those competitive advantages as an input for that and the generation of added value which is the quest of the of the region that's what we're working on that is the primary driver we don't want to make in the uae the cheapest molecule of green hydrogen we want to take out the most value of that molecule in an industrial process i would rather have a not me personally again i would rather have a factory to do green aluminum green steel or batteries or cars made with locally sourced competitive hydrogen than fighting with someone for a market share of a potential future hydrogen market that is really a completely different pipeline so i think just to finalize because maybe i'm speaking a bit too much i think the energy transition is for real but both saudi the uae are compromised to a net zero future 2050 in the case of the uae we have we just approve in the emirates of abu dhabi interim um renewable and clean energy targets for 2035 60 of all the electricity will be clean there is a huge effort in evolving the energy mix but there is also a huge effort in realizing that it's not just about the investment in the electricity or the energy sector is evolving the economy to a new um let's say more resilient less volatile future and this is the focus of the area thank you so much carlos very very comprehensive i will turn now to mariana uh mariana has worked a lot on on carbon markets in the in the eu on on the gulf and linkages on that uh i'm on many other issues but on that i would like to ask you what can you tell us mariana what potential what linkages can we establish between eventual carbon markets in the gulf how how would that work yeah so thanks a lot gonzalo and thanks a lot to real cano instituto and the network g foundation for the kind invitation it's very nice to be with you here today so uh let me start by saying something that i've written before i think that when it comes to carbon pricing the middle east can actually benefit from the design and scope of an inclusive cap and trade system such as the eu emissions trading system for two reasons first for the establishment of national cap and trade systems emulating the eu ets and second for the prospective establishment of a regional carbon pricing scheme emulating the eu ets and linked with it now why is this important to basically offer the middle east and north africa region a cost-effective way out of awkward measures of the sort of a carbon border adjustment mechanism because at the end of the day putting a price on the carbon content of imports will constitute a problem for exports of oil exports of gas and other energy intensive exports from the region to europe now what i would like to focus and i would like to discuss with you here today are the reasons why these efforts have been unsuccessful so far in the region and i would like to start by saying that carbon pricing is unfortunately largely unfavored in predominant sectors of these economies such as oil and gas upstream operations petrochemicals refining to name a few of course always in the with the potential with with in the fear of a potential economic detriment now industrialization in the middle east and north africa region and even efforts towards the region's economic diversification are primarily driven by energy intensive industries and why am i saying that i'm saying this because energy intensive industries run the risk of becoming less competitive should carbon pricing be implemented and another reason has to do with the persisting energy subsidies that we see in the region which offset carbon pricing but here i would like to i would like to quote research by paul van sohn actually highlighting that fossil fuel subsidies including through electricity prices have already been gradually reduced in the region coming down from 400 billion usd in 2012 in the mena alone and of course this process has been needless to say overall difficult to carry out due to the financial impact on society however the greater the penetration of renewable energies which do not need subsidization per se for example tenders for photovoltaic systems in the uae that we've seen then the less the need for state support at least beyond the you know an initial period for markets to kickstart and a third perhaps reason making implementation even more challenging is in my opinion the prominent economic feature of state-owned enterprises at least in the gcc energy and heavy industry sectors and here i would like to include monopoly state oil and utility firms so this kind of increases the risk for political lobbying against carbon pricing so finally the momentum for collective action is sort of um hindered by the i would say possibility that if a gcc country if a middle eastern country unilaterally legislates for and applies a carbon mitigation strategy on its own then you're going to have joint venture partners and non-state controlled energy-intensive industries fleeing to a neighboring country with less stringent regulations so that would be the three reasons at least from where i stand and for this reason implementation of consistent carbon pricing strategies per gcc country and collective action are critical for the establishment of a regional carbon trading scheme and now this process and i would like to conclude with that is largely contingent on the momentum of implementation of the newly revised article 6 of the paris agreement on rules for cooperative implementation of carbon targets and at the same time it is also important to take into account the european debate and that is that the eu emissions trading system is also subject to further development under the fit455 package through its proposed expansion and the establishment of a second emissions trading system for transport and buildings there is also here the additional parameter on voluntary carbon markets that i know that gonzalo you and i have discussed i don't know if i have a bit of time it's up to you you're the manager go for it go for it okay and i would like to point out to you the complexity entailed when it comes to to vcms the complexity when it comes to creating greenhouse gas verified claims for methane emissions from oil imports due to the complexity given the different oil grades their transportation and the different refining processes as noted uh by our colleague at the oxford institute for energy studies adm cyrovich in this very informative paper and this is particularly important for the purchase saved by i don't know a mediterranean refinery of middle east crudes in terms of the diverging refinery margins of those crudes and the adjustment of those margins based on the underlying carbon price and the same amount of complexity is entailed in the certification of carbon removals from technology-based or nature-based cc-us solutions which are going to drive the carbonization of gas produced in the mean region as uh bassam also pointed out in this case as you know europe intense or perhaps you know intends to put forward a regulatory framework for the certification of those technologies by the end of the year we as if it at least hope that this framework will ensure commonality of certification instruments at the eu level and will also incentivize deployment of all carbon dioxide removal technologies as soon as declared commercially viable and i think that's also a very important parameter to to point out when it comes to our relations with the mean of countries sure thank you mariana thanks a lot let's go back to nora i know that you gave us a general perspective but i would like to go you to go more into the details like for instance about all these about the circular carbon economy all the saudi climate targets um all the energy transition ambitions what can you tell us in with more detail on those issues thank you gonzalos so the circular carbon economy was proposed by saudi arabia during the 2020 g20 summit in riyadh and it was endorsed by all the g20 countries the what the circular carbon economy contributes to climate mitigation is that it provides a transition towards low-carbon economy in a very holistic and inclusive and pragmatic way so it it shifts the discussion really from talking about energy sources to shifting and talking about managing the emissions uh from the from these energy sources and it's something that was touched upon by uh earlier in the opening remarks by the president of uh liturgy when he talked about the customized energy transition and it was also reiterated by uh our colleague bassam fatou from oxford institute uh when he when he discussed the importance of keeping the options open in the energy transition and not forcing a single transition pathway so the circular carbon economy is based on the four pathways the four r's reduce reuse recycle and remove carbon and greenhouse gas emissions so it provides so many options for countries based on their national circumstances based on their you know national endowments so every country can customize their energy transition based on its energy security needs its economic plans um and its uh current energy mix and and and going from where it is today and and where it needs uh to go in the future so technologies such as carbon capture and utilization and storage which was discussed heavily today is an important technology as it allows the continued participation of the continued use of hydrocarbons which is according to all the forecasts is going to be increasingly important energy source but it also more importantly allows the participation of the heart to abate sectors that are locked in hydrocarbons to participate in this energy transition so if we if it it it really highlights the importance of not discriminating against a certain set of energy technologies or energy sources as this will have many implications this was also discussed earlier uh it will increase the cost of the transition um it will make the energy transition abrupt and not as smooth and and so on and so forth and the heart of eight sectors specifically uh make up over a third of um of the global co2 emissions so not allowing these uh sectors to participate in the energy transition is a grave it's is a grave issue so technologies like uh carbon capture utilization and stories need to be invested in and also hydrogen for instance which we see as a cross-cutting technology in its different colors you know blue for blue hydrogen using ccs and and green hydrogen using renewables and other colors so it's important to look at hydrogen as clean hydrogen and also not discriminate based on color and the circular carbon economy um also allows countries to define their own targets uh their own ndc's and their own energy transition at the pace that is uh reasonable for for these countries so for saudi arabia since you asked saudi arabia is using the circular carbon economy approach to meet its net zero target so in this map towards this road map towards net zero it has so many initiatives along along these circular carbon economy approach and the deployment of cce in the region is also something important and in the gulf countries the oil exporting countries more specifically as it helps hydrocarbons industry to transition towards carbon circularity and this is important because we don't look at the emissions coming out of the hydrocarbons and in energy emissions in general as only a negative externality but we look at it as an important feedstock for the industry which is something that carlos touched upon earlier in the discussion so how can we use these as raw materials as important feedstock for the hydrocarbons industry towards circularity for a win-win for a win-win situation between you know this classic uh delicate balance of of balancing the sdgs and meeting these sustainable development goals specifically sdg-7 on energy access and sdg-13 on climate action so how can we balance between the two towards a a more inclusive sustainable energy transition great they have some very clear thank you so much for that let's go now to chloe i got a question for you on you partially touched upon need but if you could tell it a bit more on which impact do you think the the current energy security crisis were undergoing in europe and the way it will unfold will impact and nato allies energy security policies or strategies or perceptions so i think that there is a dangerous trend this is my personal view again uh in uh you know this securitized approach to uh energy uh energy policy i think that we today i mean obviously the key of a reduced dependency vis-a-vis russia uh lies in the south okay so what we call a nato or uh for trans-atlantic security this grand southern periphery that you know ranches from uh i would say roughly sahel to afghanistan pakistan and so uh of course i mean european countries are heavily dependent on russia's i would say supplies especially for countries like germany italy uh this is super obvious so now the question is that how do you i would say mitigate this dependency so you are looking for a new uh i would say providers so algeria is one egypt is another uh you have also in the instrument i would say you know promising prospects but all i would say those options are bringing to the table a lot of geopolitical rivalries and complexities and so uh this is not you know it's not because we are looking at the med this is disconnected from what is happening in the gulf look at uh what are today i would say uh the uh you know foreign uh foreign projection or the uh ambitions of some of the gulf countries in uh northern africa we have a i would say an increasing patterns of you know a gulf a gulfia i would say governance of the mediterranean basin so this is something that is cannot be sold out uh i would say on a short term the problem is that we are looking for short-term solutions at the same times we have countries that have uh our same capacity to increase uh probably their production but to a certain level i'm not sure that by the summer when we will try to i would say uh you know renew our stocks uh those countries will be able to fill uh all the all the gaps and so this implies that we invest and when i'm saying we i'm saying europeans we invest you know in the infrastructures uh in those countries so here comes the problem of you know domestic instability that of course if you are investing you need to have i would say uh you know sacred prospects or minimum secure conditions and stable conditions uh so this is for the country where i would say resources are produced you have also the problem link uh to transact and so here of course uh we can see that if you want to of course uh i would say uh have you know an alternative pass to uh to russia so you have the thousand corridors so this is crossing uh caspian middle east so obviously uh you know places where you have a lot of instability uh you have also you know the eastern end uh you have you know all these pipes that are crossing the met so this is i would say bringing an additional layer on i would say a complex uh package of security issues that tends to be very much intertwined and so what we need to have in mind is that at the moment where allies are looking very much uh to uh to the east we need to be i would say cognizant to the fact that at the end of the day you know challenging the challenges that are pre-existing to this crisis in the south are not going anywhere so we will have a resource or capabilities issue if we are speaking only you know from a military point of view i would say uh collective defense uh we will still have to provide collective defense for the mat and then in addition to that we will have you know crisis management issues that we need uh still to take care uh of and so this brings the question of who is providing capabilities and so do we have the means to increase i would say our capabilities and this is not only about money spending you know this is not about only increasing uh military spending you need to have military spending that are matching i would say capabilities available on the shelves and so from that perspective i would say that european industrial corporation unfortunately is not well placed because only the u.s will be able to probably provide you know all the equipment and resources that we need to acquire so this is part of i would say uh the global complexity that this war in ukraine is bringing we have jail politics backs you know at the heart of europe and we have i would say uh a bet forgotten that geopolitics was something that was very much linked to uh the gulf uh or you know to uh the sahelian periphery and so we have you know the geopolitical stakes and today we have to deal with i would say a continuum of uh you know geopolitical challenges that starts uh high north and run you know till the sahel or a little bit south down uh further south uh in uh in i would say sub-saharan africa so wherever you will have to shift you know priorities you will need to find alternative solutions so for your lives this brings the question of how do you share the burden and so this is an additional complexity to a very old i would say conversation about burden sharing between both sides of the uh the atlantic and so here and because the matter is so meta is very close uh we are expecting to have i would say a renewed impetus for a nato eu corporation but of course this is you know bringing i would say this prospect was in a totally different framework and so having european allies competing for very short-term solutions to secure their supplies this is also something that undermine cohesion and so cohesion is our center of gravity i mean either uh in in eu or in uh in nato so this is where you know i see that we are i mean having a visual uh cycle and we need to find out you know the the means to get out of this cycle the problem this uh this is very much depending on i would say national interest and so to which extent european allies will be able to reconcile you know their national interest but this is linked to sanctions on russia which would be you know the consequences on our economies and this is totally understandable at the end of the day okay let's go back to carlos and i will ask you well you already mentioned some of the hallmark projects or flagship projects you got in the emirates but i don't know if you want to highlight something not not only in the emirates but perhaps looking for some kind of cooperation that that we can do together you know between the the eu and and and the emirates i mean during this current crisis is this some kind of of support or cooperation that we can i mean as just cloud said i mean we have to look for new partners and new uh commitments what do you think sure thank you othello it's a extremely complicated question to us i would try to say something meaningful and obviously um you know the discussion is is there for us i mean the region and the uae in particular and the european union in reality they share their goals we both want to be net zero by 20 uh 15. uh and we both you know face uh not exactly the same but there are a number of similar issues or challenges that we need to look at um in in the case of the ua in particular i will mention a few things which would then take me you know to share reflection about how to approach them and how to collaborate between these two regions the uae has a very ambitious nuclear program and a very ambitious photovoltaic program the uae wants to have a 60 reduction of emissions in the electricity sector in 2035 and be mutually zero by the end of 2050. the eoe has an electrification strategy all the buildings are electric in the uae so we have to focus on transport and hard to decarbonize the industrial processes the uae has to develop sustainable clean and green hydrogen as you know a potential solution or part of the solution to to the 2050 challenges we need to look at things like the governance the target model because it's not so simple you know to realize how this is going to run among the different players in the region the business models the electricity supply the availability of land the certification scheme you know the the use of different structures all of these things are not written yet we need to work on those and so that's europe by the way we need to also look at things like uh energy efficiency which is you know the elephant in the room we cannot meet our goals without some things like energy efficiency and the my side management we cannot just you know have these one-way street for everything we need to allow the consumer to participate in the process and um we need to do institutional reforms we we see things which which are shocking at least if you think for a second we see that renewables are more and more competitive in terms of cost but electricity continues to be expensive so maybe let's think on what kind of institutional arrangements we need to have in in the marketplace to figure out and i'm not talking about copying anything i'm just thinking about how to um you know think about an elephant in the room by the way [Laughter] how to look at these all of these so my point is here is technology institutional reform and um um you know enablers for the energy transition have plenty of common ground between these two jurisdictions i would really welcome you know a a shared approach to increase the information flow the missions uh and the visions that actually need to happen between these two regions to choose two or three critical items and to see to what extent um there is cooperation is happening i i see from there the um that parts of asia are very present china is playing an ever-growing role in the region and i see that some countries in europe in the uk if it's in europe still i'm not sure have also a very close relation with with the region but the european union as such maybe could could be more present and and share you know the the knowledge and and the institutional excellence that we enjoy in this part of the world because some of those answers are not only technological it is how you get there so for how long are we waiting for a free trade area between the gcc and the european union 30 years now i mean at least so i mean that is what i think and finally um our research innovation technology is going to be and will be the cornerstone of the whole success story uh this is a clear area of collaboration there should be competition in this in this area so that would be my my last addition to the list thank you carlos i'm going to start to offset questions and answers rather than we go to capture questions and storage because if not we are not being able to to do it but hopefully some of the questions that i was thinking of posting to mariana has been also posed by the audience and it refers to hydrogen what what what would be the prospectus for ryder you need the middle east you have already mentioned something but mariana you have worked a lot on that and what can you tell us on that yeah thanks gonzalo uh i don't want to start again saying like you know as as i've written before but you you have you have uh cited the the papers of several of us during the past couple of minutes so yes the carbonization including the carbonization of the european economy through hydrogen and i'm saying that when it comes to our relations with the middle east countries yes it may to a certain extent depoliticize uh interstate energy relations and it is likely to limit geopolitical competition like for access to fossil fuel reserves and supply which is a shift from the post-world war to geopolitical literature which was more centered towards you know competition over petroleum resources and so on so forth now at the same time yes sure uh the energy transition narrative puts into question the conventional energy security motive but it seems that key threats such as i don't know politically or economically motivated uh regional conflict as we've seen these days so these threats will still and for quite some time constitute an underlying uh you know uh reason you know underlying uh disruption incidents affecting both importers and exporters alike so looking at the opportunities emerging from our conventional gas market i would say first to have a look at the numbers okay so 2021 when it comes to the region algeria oil indexed imported pipeline gas came forth with a share of 10.5 percent and around 3 630 kilowatt hours of gas imports in the eu as a whole in this case and that's also for future consideration we have to take into account the dependence of the competitiveness of oil index contracts on the evolution of gas hub prices and how this dependence again based on what we've been experiencing over the past couple of months may create a competitive advantage for oil indexed gas importers from the mena excuse me exporters not importers whenever and as long as you have this uh premium of spot contracts increasing over them second number that i would like to bring to your attention qatar becoming the second principal import source of lng to the eu in 2021 with a share of 16.3 bcm out of a total 80 bcm of imports in this case we have to bear in mind two things and i'm turning to your question about energy system integration gonzalo and hydrogen a qatar's current lack of spare lng export capacity although and as carlos might also well know this is about to change with the lifting of the moratorium on the northfield expansion and qatar's long-term contractual commitments with asian buyers second thing that we have to take in mind on the positive side the low carbon intensity rate in qatar's lng supply chain and its commitment to you know increase this this intensity by 35 by 30 to 2035 through ccs and finally and here allow me to quote capsic research we have the resource perspective on the other hand of prospective exporters from a sector coupling point of view again to your question gonzalo such as saudi arabia which has both significant hydrocarbon reserves and high renewable energy potential which is in fact significantly reducing both its natural gas and renewable electricity source hydrogen production costs so this advantage may allow saudi arabia to become a major producer a and b a low-cost global marginal supplier of low carbon hydrogen if international trade in hydrogen develops and one last thing if i have a bit of time because we're talking about you know this nexus with the european union it's also a matter of europe's trajectory towards an established hydrogen market because when it comes to when it comes to spot markets in particular the hydrogen system does not exist in isolation so the hydrogen system is going to be about close interrelations between natural gas and electricity markets and that they will all have a requirement for physical balance or optimization and this is exactly what energy system integration will be about so there is going to be you know pricing interactions between this and all of this and we know for example that you can develop salt caverns for hydrogen and that there's going to be a line back in hydrogen systems so there will be seen as a single system to be optimized amongst traders as long as the markets are established properly so you have the middle east and north africa region trying to find its place in the market under construction let's say thank you mariana thank you so much we are going to the last round and we are going to mix some questions from the audience with some questions i got myself so i go i go back to noria um there was that question nitrogen in several but i think you have already answered but if you want to complement it to level further that that's your point but i would like to ask you going back to a more general trend how do you see the role of the middle east and the gulf countries in the energy transition what can the region contribute to the rest of the world thank you gonzalo so the middle east is a very important region for energy and for other um important um aspects of the global security um you know the middle east to compromise about 18 of oil and uh sorry 38 of oil and 18 of gas it exports that to the to the world and saudi arabia specifically is the global de facto leader in in energy and even with this energy transition this role can be continued uh especially looking at the potential of renewable energy in the region and in the country as well as the important role the potential important role in hydrogen as we discussed saudi arabia plans to be the world's largest green hydrogen producer and there's been a lot of agreements and signing of agreements with other countries as potential importers of this of this hydrogen so in general the middle east country is uh has abundant uh you know solar energy potential as well as renewable energy potential and there's a lot of potential in integrating the energy and the electricity grid and so that provides a golden opportunity for exchange of energy and exporting of electricity clean electricity to europe and the rest of the world i'd like to also highlight the middle east green initiative which is a climate uh mitigation initiative by saudi arabia as it's funding the the afforestation of 40 billion trees across the region and and so the participation in of the middle east in the energy transition is important but of course the middle east is not a homogeneous region you have energy in exporters you have energy importers as well and there are various various contexts to to these countries um but i could say that the region the middle east region uh should participate more in climate adaptation given the uh the the needs of the countries for instance um you know a lot of these countries are very water poor particularly the gcc the water poverty as defined by the u.n is at two thousand cubic meter per capita um and the critical water poverty is at 500. and unfortunately all the gcc countries are below that so they're critically water poor countries that highly depend on desalination which highly depends on hydrocarbons for now but there are many efforts uh for using renewable energy in the desalination there's also very high temperatures that are really you know touching upon the physiological limits of humans so you will need constant air conditioning and cooling and so that also is dependent on hydrocarbon so you have these needs for adaptation climate adaptation but you also have serious plans for uh climate mitigation through all these efforts and energy transitions so the middle east's efforts in the this energy grand energy transition globally is very important thank you so much for raising the question of adaptation we never talk enough about adaptation especially in in the region you know so thank you so much laura i come back immediately to claude my question claude and there is also a question related to this from the audience is uh okay bassam has told before and you haven't mentioned risk and opportunities about the energy transition uh for the gulf countries but how can we approach this from a nato perspective i mean do you see all these things and vasa was saying beware of simplistic assumptions you know that this is going to be winners and losers very clear crap but what's what's the perspective from a name what what's your perspective when you look it from a security perspective how this energy transition can further complicate complicated already complex situation in in in the gulf and the region so i i would say that if we are uh looking at you know this is the triangular i will say relation so you have of course the consumer perspective the producer perspective and you have the transat uh perspective and so you need to consider security i would say uh risks uh or vulnerabilities you know uh from the district perspectives and how they can you know conflict or how you can find a solution a scenario that you know is trying to to compromise i would say interest so from the consumer perspective i can say that from the moment we are uh actually transferring risks and so we have a problem because we are already dependent so we mean that it means that we lack you know diversifications in terms of resources but we are at the moment actually uh just transferring that so we are not diversifying our risk and so this is this is a big problem uh from i would say the consumer perspective so if we are transferring i would say uh our interests um you know on on the middle east which says for i mean look at the figures that have been machined it says already lng uh from uh from qatar they are already you know uh exporting a lot of gas and supply and gas uh almost 100 to blood gm uh uk this is this is really big big big numbers so the problem is that this dependency implies that you need to help those countries ensuring their own stability and so also from the transit perspective there are a lot of risk that all link of course to i would say lng shipping so it's i mean getting back to maritime security so this raised the questions of how our establish stabilizing the mediterranean basin which is from a nato perspective i would say collective defense but you need to also consider i mean the role road and so we have here rezzy you go down to the gulf of adam i mean not mentioning what is happening in yemen and how much you know this is obviously impacting the decisions of the players in the region look at i mean uae was embarrassed uh because they were you know uh expecting or at least they wanted uh to avoid to have you know uh russia i would say you know modifying a decision on yemen so this is just a very punctual example so we can multiply those uh complex uh linkages uh to the security interest of those of those countries so this is martin security classic for the gulf the problem is that now if you are developing renewables you will develop new infrastructure and so you will develop new grids and so you will have new internet connectivity okay to be insured with other markets and so this brings the question of how do you secure all this infrastructure so cyber but not only cyber you have also i would say art uh i would say security uh issues that need to be i would say take into taken into consideration so this raised the questions of i would say uh security and armored forces capabilities you know in those countries and so their ability to function i would say independently from a strong western support so there is here this interdependency that needs to be worked out and so we have seen that in certain case when technologies is not delivered those countries and this is the sovereign prerogative okay they are looking for alternative options and so russia is one of those options but we know that sanctions will probably impact also uh the uh defense industrial complex of russia so very soon they won't be able anymore to deliver you know one of this i would say um you know capabilities from the high end of spectrum but this opened the questions of china and so here we are already seeing that china is providing a lot of solution from a security perspective so the problem is that chinese investments in those i would say connectivity projects i mean i don't know if if this is a this is a risk or an opportunity but i would say it's i would say foreign i mean some allies to be uh to be very diplomatic already considers i mean this uh was uh i mean great worries and so this is a problem uh having too much investments uh from one country anyway this is china or this is another country and those infrastructure i mean raise concerns this is true for the gulf uh 5g not you know no necessity to mention other technologies and so this is also true i would say uh in in you know north africa so we have you know all these connectivity projects if we want to develop renewables uh in north africa we need to be able to provide technologies at i would say an affordable price and the problem is that you have affordable price but you have also to have i would say political agreements uh that are allowing those countries to interconnect the markets and so for example in north africa you see that political divides are actually very much impacting you know regional integration and so this is true for north africa this is super obvious but on the gulf we have also political divides so this is this is also a question uh can you i would say provide for the future uh clean energy solution without having a gcc interconnected market i don't have an answer you have iran that is still there and still something that the gulf countries will have to deal with so i would say from that perspective i see that there are probably a lot of risk but i'm sure that if you have a concerted solution okay and regional integration is from my perspective probably the best solution you have also a lot of opportunities i think i know i'm running out of time but i will ask for five more minutes for two opponents and then i give you the the floor rafale if you don't mind may i because i would like to to to finish because there are questions for you can you do it in two minutes carlos one question about the mineral issue the mineral transition you mentioned and related to china i mean in the region there are concerns about new dependencies from red earth or minerals or whatever regarding china well in the region and everywhere right we are going to a new paradigm where electrification electrification is a must electrification not just with any means uh integration with renewables and clean technologies and those technologies are intensive in a number of minerals which are located in uh in limited amounts in specific countries so we might be uh and this is a huge issue that i think will impact the energy transition or you know over a period of time we are going to have to solve that uh if if it's possible or assume that there will be a dependency of the electrification and the energy transition from these materials and i think that is not something specific to the goal for the uae that is a global concern and i finished with mariana a very easy and very short question what is the role of the middle east region in the current energy crisis in europe in two sentences no i mean you got two minutes thanks uh from try to do because i know that you got this holistic vision that you can put together energy geopolitics this is why i'm keeping that question for you no no here the question is very simple whether or not the mina region evolves into a sort of energy powerhouse for its own people and for europe at this stage addition addiction to hydrocarbons and if you like those untaxed prices at which you have petroleum products at which you have natural gas electricity still mostly uh generated using gas or diesel okay compliant diversion from a climate compliant perspective and so does the absence of any direct control um or on carbon emissions by way of a carbon tax original carbon pricing scheme as i mentioned before but at the same time one cannot ignore that despite the many practical issues that i have mentioned that my distinguished fellow panelists have mentioned you also have the incentives and what are the incentives in less than a minute they know i will try so dynamic price signals you have green capacity auctions you have green certificates you have prospects for carbon pricing such as uh for example oman's tradable energy credit plan or saudi arabia's uh plan on a voluntary trading platform for carbon offsets and credits in the whole mena region so the prospects we can say are there thank you so much i was brief very brief but don't worry because now rafael villasec i got the opportunity to make a summary and analysis of all you have said to all of you together so uh but before please i will ask you that the audience to please join me in thanking not only the panelists but also the interpreters that have been working for us all the morning so thank you so much please [Applause] thank you very much uh really interesting insights about all of the mina is [Music] uh is [Music] is [Applause] | Real Instituto Elcano / Elcano Royal Institute | UC9Lt75VQd3cq98dNW7la0Pw | 2022-05-27 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 14,489 | 80,950 |
0aADsuhDm3Y | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0aADsuhDm3Y | Davos 2015 - Growing in Harder Times | okay so let's go ahead and get started Max you're okay excellent thanks very much I appreciate the professionalism of the Forum and the uh the team from Swiss TV because they're extremely efficient we have some of those at the back of the door if you want to come in and sit down even if you're in security you don't have to stand for the next hour I I don't think the Deputy Prime Ministers want the security guys with very sore legs later I is that right they're independent he said okay very good okay this is these are not the best of times I I would suggest right now in 20 15 but obviously they're not the worst of times as well uh but I think it's fair to say they are harder times uh to grow and hence the title of our uh program today growing in harder times in 2015 a bit of irony here the United States is growing quite handsomely uh probably three and a half to 4% in 2015 but this is the economy that sparked the global financial crisis uh back in 2008 and 2009 uh the Euro zone is going to be lucky to grow one to 1.2% but at least we know uh at this stage what the European Central Bank has plans for uh it's pulled out a pretty good siiz bazooka better than a trillion dollars over an 18-month period to try to boost growth in Europe big debate of course uh with Germany suggesting that austerity and discipline and reforms should continue uh to go forward uh we'll see how that plays out uh this weekend we have the Greek election of course we could have the grexi depending on which way the voters go uh and whether the Greeks can participate in that program or not depending on the progression of the European Union IMF ECB bailout plan that's on the table so what does this mean about the engines of global growth we often talk about the Emerging Markets being the engines of global growth uh they're struggling a little bit uh China was growing 7.4% last year that would be the Envy of the world for everybody else I would think but there's concerns that it will surrender 7% uh this year but let's take a look at a video report that outlines the IMF forecast for 2015 and we'll pick up our discussion thereafter please go ahead and roll the video the United States the country that many say was the spark behind the 2008 Global financial crisis is now moving full steam ahead unemployment is below 6% growth hovering around 4% the largest emergy market China is growing at the slowest Pace in nearly a quarter Century but president XII ping and Premier Le K gang seem determined to try and defend 7% growth but the real question marks for 2015 are not the world's number one in two-sized economies but Global risks linked to the collapse of oil prices and potential deflation Yen Libya and Iraq remain tension filled hotspots and will feel the strain of a drop in revenues as will Nigeria and of course Russia as one of the world's top three energy producers this is a look through the IMF 2015 Crystal to ball Global growth of 3 1.2% down from 3.8% last October China to expand 6.8% and slightly less next year Russia to contract by 3% a steep revision from last October Nigeria 4.8% 2 and a half% below the Autumn forecast Mexico is expected to grow just above 3% and turkey at 3% the one caveat here the IMF has been traditionally optimistic and as a result has had to ratchet down forecast and many believe that may be the case later this year so that gives us a very good indication of where we are uh in January 2015 of course the reason we wanted to talk about the political risk thereafter is because this could all be thrown off by uh very sudden or shocking events but let's start with the Deputy Prime Minister of Turkey a 3% forecast with what the European Union has decided to do with stimulus here could you surpass that number in 20 5 well I think it's a reality which we have to see that last 10 years versus next 10 years it will be a different era for emerging markets the average growth rates will go down compared to last 10 years but the lower growth rates are even going to be still higher than the growth rates of the developed countries so when we talk about lower growth rate for turkey or for China for other countries these will be still on average much higher than the developed world for turkey specific the lower oil prices and the measures that we are taking to diversify our export markets have been working very well maybe European markets are not performing well but our exports to Africa to Asia Latin America is growing very fast we had only 12 embassies in Africa in 2008 today we have 39 embassies Turkish Airlines fly to more than 40 destinations and the trade is growing so in a way time diversication of markets and time diversification of the product range helps a lot in these kind of times Deputy Prime Minister Shala this is probably one of the most difficult years for uh President Vladimir Putin and the Russian economy sanctions are in place uh we're looking at potentially according to the European bank for reconstruction and development a contraction of nearly 5% the IMF puts it at 3% how do you navigate very choppy Waters with the political situation you're faced with with the European Union and the United States but that's not the first time time you know if we recall different crisis in my country there maybe I recall the fourth one and in 2007 the old price dropped again dramatically and you know we survived and two years later we felt much stronger this time again the forecast are different this you know focus is possible this is possible scenario but at the same time we have maybe scenario where we will be around zero it means the economy is freezing the half of our oil incomes will disappear but at the same time we understand there's a structural need to perform something else and to find new markets for our export goods which was not the you know the agenda for Russians before because it was money and coming from selling oil and gas so this is another challenge but I think we will scope as you know there's been talk of reform for a decade in Russia and the discussion to look for other markets until til to the east the reality is uh this government got a little bit spoiled by $100 oil and that first all the reforms I have to admit you're right we were SPO spoiled by these numbers and people were just expecting new numbers of you know public expenditures and people were you know they were not motivated to work harder to provide labor productivity but now this is the case where we will do this because we are forced Maurice Levy you have a a very good uh finger on the pulse of global growth as the CEO of one of the largest advertising firms in in the world but I wanted to get your thoughts on the European Central bank's actions here on the the quantitative easing will it provide finally the stimulus even though it's six years late or six years after the US Federal Reserve president dragy is going a little bit beyond the Mandate and that is the reason why it has taken so long to come to that kind of stimulus uh and it will as a stimulus what I would be very much worry about is that um uh leaders believe that this would be enough and that they should not go through the reform program that we have absolutely to implement in some countries including mine so it is extremely important to see that as a something which is relaxing a little bit the economy and easing the balance sheet of the the banks and but not the final solution to the austerity and to believe that all our issues are behind us no the issues are still there and we have to go through a very serious reform program particularly in the uh southern part of Europe I I I find it fascinating that people start to panic about China when it's you know hovers at 7.4% it's a a big tanker ship you have to you know to move of course but president XI and Premier Lee and we heard him here at the world economic Forum believe they can defend 7% boing Ling do you think it's uh going to be 7% or higher we should be happy about a softer Landing for China I believe that there'll be still higher than 7% the MF estimate is a bit low the reason for that is very simple urbanization is continuing and uh Chinese savings extremely high those are Ral money and uh you know inflation is low so that if China China government just spend a little bit uh it it'll be 7% having said that I think that's the difficulties the difficulty here is that we get used to 10% growth now with a 77.4% you still really need to go through the reform structural changes and others to really address that 3% difference associate with social economic problems sou China really have to work hard but I believe that 7% above 7% is achievable you're not concerned about the social unrest because it's not reaching beyond the major large cities of China yet the wealth is not trickling outside the major hubs of manufacturing and finance precisely not yet I think that the the the the the growth will continue even though that for example like housing we got a problem with the housing market but I think there are tremendous infrastructure need to be built in other you know the second tier third tier uh cities so uh I think that the the we the the grow momentum steer there ailia Loya of panic you're neighboring Mexico of course to the United States us is growing like great Gang Busters after all that quantitative easing but we're not seeing the growth that we saw in Mexico 3 years ago not to 4% not to to 5% what's hurting Mexico right now from popping above that level well indeed uh 2015 is a complex scenario for the world economy and what is Mexico doing in this context H we're committed to fiscal discipline and macroeconomic stability as we have done in the last 20 years we expect uh growth a little bit higher than the IMF is predicting in the range of three and a half to 3.9% despite low oil prices uh but I think paradoxically the low oil prices people believe is going to have a higher impact on Mexico's GDP H the GDP related to oil is has been less than 8% for the last years so actually we will benefit more from a stronger economy the numbers are encouraging in 2014 October year-to-year figures our 8% increase exports of automobiles to the United States 20% increase in manufacturing experts to the US which is 80% of our trade and uh the economy created 950,000 jobs in 2014 so the numbers are good it could be better if we had better oil prices but the econom is moving Mexico is fully committed also to implementing the 11 structural reforms that were approved the we've done the first part which is to approve them through the legislation uh but now we have to implement them and that's the encouraging part I think 2015 is going to be a good year for Mexico despite the risks out there that you have clearly mentioned uh the African Renaissance we're all excited in dava's 204 14 about Africa finally getting its opportunity in the Global Spotlight I found it uh fascinating Patrice mppi that uh Nigeria has seen one of the sharpest downgrades of growth for 2015 uh negative 2 and a half% off of the Topline number of last year and they're projecting growth of just 4.8% for Nigeria South Africa struggling to get above 1 and a half per. what's holding back Africa still too dependent on Commodities in your view well um currently there's approximately 750 uh million mobile users in Africa double the size of of uh the United States uh over the past year approximately 80 billion US do was spent on infrastructure uh Nigeria Angola and those countries equatorial guine Gabon that uh were primarily oil producing countries in the past have uh it's quite impressive impressive that they've built some foreign reserves I think Nigeria's Got approximately 20 billion US foreign reserve and uh Angola has got uh about 15 to17 billion US dollar foreign reserves so and of course we have been uh impacted by uh the decrease in Precious Metals copper and the ores but the those traditional commodity uh sectors of the economy are now being replaced by Financial Services telecommunications retail and Manufacturing industry is growing and and that contined to gives to give us confidence for the future it seems like Africa ironically because China was investing into Africa and they had this FDI but Africa is very dependent on Chinese growth for exports for uh your company in particular are you concerned about the Chinese slowdown and the demand for your products at the stage you know it's interesting uh 15% of the current trade that subsaharan Africa is conducting is is with China let me give you a few numbers Africa's trade with Europe is in excess of 400 billion US Africa's trade with China is in excess of 200 billion us so the EU collectively is still a significant and a huge trading partner of Africa of course China is the single largest economy that trades with Africa it will China's growth will indeed have an impact but it's also important that you know Africa's trading with India is trading with Brazil he's trading with Russia he's trading with various other emerging economies and America's growth is is a very positive development for Africa what is lacking in Africa mppi though is it infrastructure spending that needs to come in to provide the efficiency for investors coming from the outside have those goods go to market faster and not be so reliant on Commodities after all 60% of the exports are still relying on oil in Africa which is a surprising number very important uh Africa's econom is historically have been geared towards the export of Commodities to historically to the European markets the the intra African trade hasn't been as significant as it can be over the last 5 to 10 years there's been significant growth uh last year alone in excess of $20 billion was spent on infrastructure in Africa by the private sector both uh private sector from outside Africa and private sector from uh from the continent so the the infrastructure is very important and uh lots of the governments are spending more money on education provision of skills there's a middle class that's coming up and that middle class more educated more in touch with the rest of the world provides an exciting market for intera African trade as well as for growth of the domestic economies I want to take a look at the connection between politics and economics and how it filters into growth and opportunity for societies uh let's start with turkey we have a very powerful president evolving that role as an executive president some would suggest that uh president erdogan has too tight a grip on Power and is not as free turkey as it was before too much concentration in in fact there was worries that you had keep your job and the international investors uh love having you in that role as the DPM in charge of Economic Policy what's the answer to that what's the real answer Deputy Prime Minister well first of all turkey is a democracy and the quality of our democracy has been going up and up we have elections this year we had two elections last year local elections and then Presidential elections and now general elections are coming up so our democracy is being tested over and over again and we are asking over and over again our people what do you like what kind of a government you would like to see and uh they it it seems like our people likes our government and they like us to just to continue and the thing is that uh the democracy is also very important to go with rule of law and good practice of Human Rights and Freedoms as a country if I can interject here this is a president even as prime minister a severe Crackdown on the media SE severe restraint on the Judiciary bodies anytime there's an investigation against the government he intervenes let's be candid here and that doesn't seem to be the character of a democracy well turkey has a very strong external anchor when we talk about the quality of our democracy or when we look at our practice of freedoms rule of law and so forth and that is the European Union process so our democracy is being assessed continuously from outside by the European commission and the European Parliament and in that way we are able to judge ourselves the performance and do whatever we can to improve in all the senses but most of the problematic areas which you are mentioning has a lot to do also the transition period that we have been going through the very peculiar domestic set of political events that we have went through but I would I can easily say that we have right right now uh more than 400 TV channels 1,100 radio channels and a very Vivid media and out of the first five newspapers in Turkey actually you will see there's only one pro government newspaper and others are whether more let's say objective or less so and so forth so uh I think the the the the perception versus what is really going on ground there is a discrepancy and that discrepancy could be probably corrected but uh even for the media that you have been referring to uh the the just the fact that this is private sector the fact that uh there are so many different companies and so many different uh internet media also which is which is just booming in the in the in the country and being such an Open Country and an open democracy it is not really easy to control uh everything maybe it's not good to try to control everything anyway and like shutting down YouTube or Twitter well that had some some security issues as you know the reason why we had to do it was because of the very very confidential and top secret uh recordings of our security meetings were leaked into YouTube and because of the very severe security threat we had to do it on a very short while but then uh we passed a law through our Parliament to give that Authority mostly to our courts to do what is necessary and whenever is necessary Maurice Le when you look at different Emerging Markets because you play all around the world as a business businessman what are the top three priorities when you tick the boxes to say I'm willing to put publ funds to play here and I know it's higher risk but I get higher rewards if the growth is there the most interesting emerging market today is uh United States of America when you look at the rate of growth uh uh the morale of the consumers the morale of uh uh the CEOs you believe that yes you can invest but when you look at the merging Market more seriously uh you you cannot look at this as a block each country is different and each country has its own history and the idea of the bricks or the misad is something which is no longer valid so uh definitely China we we have to invest and we have to continue to invest in China this is something which is extremely important not only because of the size of the market Market but also because of the prospects for the future even if they are going through a bump and there is some issues that it's 6.8 or 6.5 compared to 7.4 it's not a big problem because at a point in time I think being at seven will be qu quite a a a good outcome compared to some other countries uh we we like very much uh Mexico because of the proximity with the US and the way Mexico has changed the policy recently and we believe that Mexico is a good bet for us uh turkey is a very interesting country and uh I'm always lary when somebody says interesting because it's like a a paragraph there going I'm interesting but no no no it's okay you want me to be more positive I would be more positive uh I was getting it would be much more interesting countries if they were using our services oh okay uh but uh in Turkey there is a lot of possibility because there is something which is quite interesting there is a lot of entrepreneurs and that is something which is building the future entrepreneurs are the one who are building from his relatively small company something which will become big and we believe this will be extremely interesting we have sorry to say that a little bit of concern regarding Russia not so much pick of the oil we're still very good we we are investing in Russia but we believe that um we have to uh see how things will be settled not only regarding the issue with Ukraine but also what will happen to the rbls and how the economy will be taking off so this is just a a small picture uh there are some other country which are extremely interesting but the I would like to move to Europe because Europe is probably a good bet for the future uh Europe is at a very low level of growth uh and there is a lot of opportunity to invest in Europe and they think that there will be a point where we will see the inversion and finally Europe will take off and the day Europe will take off it's much better to have a much stronger position in those countries okay very good I want to bring up the second topic uh here and that is the falling price of oil uh since June of last year $115 a barrel down to below 50 today very key topics it influences the different economies around the uh the arc here in a very different way uh let's start with uh the passing of king abdulla and the strategy of Saudi Arabia and uh Mr Lynn I think it would be a good place to start as with China I mean this is a strategy here from Saudi Arabia what influence will the passing of King Abdullah have on that policy and how has the energy scenario change the outlook for China's growth we really hope that it will not change the strategy at this moment the low oil price is really good for China uh in several aspects for one thing that if the current oil price 4050 continue for another six months China was saved about 100 billion US dollar you don't have to do anything just to sit there second is that the the China is good for China strategic Reserve which only have we don't have enough days we target 90 days but obviously much less than that and I think is also good for the China's going out uh China's for uh the oil dependency L 60% at this moment and last year we put in about 23.4 million units of car on the stream okay and that convert to three to 4% of the oil oil demand M and given that the oil consumption Dr 40% in the transportation so I think that China's oil demand still there and where for dependency possibly will Contin to go up so this is a really a good opportunity for China to going out you know TI our FR let's shift to the oil producers let's shift to the oil producers and start with Russia uh Deputy Prime Minister shalov many think that Saudi Arabia has been targeting Russia targeting the US Shale producers it is a fight over market share how do you counterbalance this downward pressure when your export earnings are so dependent on oil first I would say that Rubble will dep after depreciation dramatically appreciate so no worries and After High volatility I think it will be very stable for a while and so there is no you know scary about this um our dependence on oil you know it's it's known nothing new we knew and for many years uh it started in the Soviet Union back in the Soviet Union and we recall the times in mid 80s when Soviet Union started suffering from all lower lower oil prices now again is the structure of our economy still the same of course not it changed a lot but we cannot say that we are independent from oil revenues but at the current moment I think our budgetary revenues much much less dependent on oil and gas than it was 10 years ago now it's around 50% before it was much higher the structure is Shifting but slowly um nothing good for us at the moment 2015 is going to be hard year but at the same time as again your first question it will force us to provide better structure for the economy for the next decade this very hard agenda but we are focused on it um with China they are interested in lower prices but at the same time we are interested in very good customers China maybe is going to be number one customer for Russia because they are very predictable and good partner and they say what what whatever price is but we will consume and for Russian producers they very important to have predictable lines and understanding how they can produce and sell so in all this you know very complicated picture where we are quite sure that with China and other consumers including EU EU is a very good uh partner for Russia for consuming oil gas but at the same time uh we understand that we cannot afford to leave the same standards as we got used for you know for the Fe period of 15 years it was a very good period we were able to achieve a lot the country is not that poor as we started in 2000 year for 1999 so you know this a big strong economy with its difficulties as everybody has in its in their country's difficulties but now the understanding that we cannot afford leaving the same and based on high oil prices it's obvious and is good that we understand this I I want to pinpoint the question in the oil market today is this fight by Saudi Arabia for market share can we find common ground with Russia and the United States so we don't debilitate future investment into oil $50 is very painful for Russia $50 price is not painful for oil companies it's painful for the country because of their revenues but if you speak with luk oil I see the president of the company here and other producers 50 you know dollar per barrel is okay for them they will be very good developing companies they will sell their products it's okay it'll be very painful for us for the government and for the regional governments to how to produce the same life standards and you know for the things we got used to including many things we import we buy from abroad so but again so for the oil producers it's okay at this price and so they will be very competitive of course they are not producing their cost much higher than in in the Gulf countries but they they will be competitive but for the budget budgetary purposes it's very painful Mr Zoya how do you see this uh playing out Mexico was at the OPEC meeting before it started in November where I was there to cover it uh they tried to have this cooperation between OPEC and non OPEC producers and it didn't amount to to anything do you actually see in 2015 where a dialogue would take place between non-opc players like Russia Mexico and OPEC to lift this price or those days are long gone I think the the OPEC has a clear policy which is to continue production at around 30 million barrels per day they have done so in the last decade and they will not change it and they are the most efficient producers and uh at current prices they will take away the marginal producers in particular those in the United States that have costs per barrel above $40 and I think that's a fact of the market if I was a banker financing this compass in the US I would be worried uh in the case of Mexico we are in the in a different bucket uh pemex's production cost is $23 $3 per barrel so we are still a very profitable company at current levels as the Deputy Prime Minister was mentioning for PMX it's a painful in cash flows but in particular it's difficult not ER for PMX but for the revenues that the government receives which is 30% however Mexico was very prudent in this sense and the government hch the to all the the oil revenues for 2015 at $79 so the expenditures by the government in 2015 are covered um it will have an impact on GDP as I mentioned a marginal one uh it could be over 4% our GDP if prices were not at current levels but I think the question is H we have to differentiate the energy Cycles from the financial Cycles Financial Cycles in one two years that's a long term for the energy sector 15 years is a medium-term all our projects are longterm and if you look at the official estimates not our own estimates by the energy assoc International Energy Association by 2030 total demand will be 120 million barrels per day so we need 25 more million barrels per day in the next decades where will that come from from very complex projects those projects are Frontier in the frontier markets and we need the capital Investments to be done so at current prices no company will do them so I think uh prices will be elsewhere sometime it depends how long they stay at current levels how much pain the I would say the more costly producers uh face uh but I am in the context of Mexico going back to my country we have just concluded an energy reform that is historic we're opening up the energy sector for the first time in 75 years and as our production costs are competitive I was mentioning the $23 figure we expect despite the current prices investment to come in LIF production and be ready to have our production higher when prices are higher because they will clearly be higher at some point in the near in the future Patrice mppi it's interesting uh Tanzania mosm Beek great natural gas fines uh that was going to counterbalance Nigeria which is going through a very difficult time right now because it's competing in a much more competitive oil Market does the great dream of Big Oil and Gas development in East Africa and expansion in you go away now or just get postponed well um these are long-term Investments I mean when we uh in our industry for example which is uh mining industry we we we commit significant resources for the next 10 15 20 years and uh those projects that are underway in uh uh Tanzania in Kenya and Elsewhere on the continent will continue but the interesting thing is that the reduced oil price is is a double a swad for those non oil producing countries on the continent uh this will have a huge impact on a reduced inflation and more money in the pockets of the consumers what is also interesting is if you look at some of the fastest growing economies in Africa those over the last 10 years some of them are neither oil producing economies neither nor are they your traditional or or mining export economies Ethiopia Kenya itself Bina FASA Rwanda but the the oil the projects that uh were initiated that you start that you refer to our long-term projects and and we we remain optimistic that uh they will uh contribute towards the growth of the African economy okay third block of our program here uh and this is going to be on geopolitical risk and I'd ask our panelists to be very tight and then I want to allow that uh 10 12 minutes to the floor for questions here um we saw kind of Islamic radicalism if I can say that uh burst onto the scene here in France Maurice Levy would you suggest this is the greatest geopolitical risk in Europe uh today I don't believe that it is only in Europe I think it's uh the radical Terror that we are seeing today it's something which is blind and uh you have not one organization which is acting you have a lot of people who can act on behalf of that organization anywhere in the world and and uh what what has been uh quite impressive is the response of the people and U I thought that uh finally after uh all this uh painful moment and the extremely dramatic moment you you saw the the rebound of the people we were all thinking that France was tired depressed and we had no longer the ability of jumping again and you saw 4 million people in the streets and the solidarity of the world which has been enormous the response of the world has been just incredible to see all these head of States Marching In Paris uh I was marching I can tell you um I am Charlie and it was extremely impressive and I believe that um we can expect a lot of terrorist acts uh in many places and it is something which cannot be predictable which can happen anywhere can happen in Argentina uh can happen in Turkey uh uh in in Russia in any given country in the US and we know that there is a lot of events which can have been stopped and if um I can share something with you which is uh a during the meeting we had at the IBC we were asking the people what what was the more threatening issue for the future it was a geopolitical event and behind this world there is the obviously the terror which can happen uh suddenly so we we have to get used to that and we have to think that life is stronger than fear and hopes is much stronger than being scared and we we have to fight against Terror and they believe we are ready uh turkey lives in probably the roughest neighborhood you have Syria to the South Isis has taken territory and Syria uh and Iraq what would you put as the number one geopolitical risk for you or strategic security risk for turkey now well first of all uh Terror does not have religion Terror does not have nationality uh terrorism is a global problem which does need a United effort and international effort to cope with so we cannot uh identify Terror with any region of the part world or any uh ethnic origin or any religion or whatsoever so I think as a principle as a principle we have to have a very United stance and uh we had unfortunate events in in in in Paris and uh many actual leaders including King Abdullah of Jordan mahammed abas of Palestine my prime minister D they were all there to stay United against Against Terror uh so I think that as a principle is very important and on the other hand I think we should be uh looking at this Terror or extremism uh from a global point of view and also realize that in Europe especially there are some Rising dangerous Trends uh islamophobia xenophobia nationalist transs these are actually all the things that we have to be careful about just in last one month in Germany 94 mosques were burnt down so so it is very important I think for the potic iCal leaders to stay United and to have one single approach of Terror terrorist of any kind extremist of of any kind in Syria it is a big problem in in Syria it was originally regime and the Rebellion fighting against each other but then we have now not only Isis but also pyd and many other terrorist organizations fighting with each other fighting with regime and so forth uh and and I think again the problem with Syria right on our border is that we don't really see a single United stance for what kind of a solution we want to find for Syria only military means is not enough to solve terrorism problem if you think that you can use just weapons to kill terrorists and the terror will end is not the case there should be more of an integrated comprehensive approach and using many different tools the political tools the social tools economic tools intelligence Tools in an integrated way and in a United matter so that only we can uh solve this problem Deputy Prime Minister shalov a Russian executive says something be very preent I thought he said it's very hard to see a solution with Russia and Ukraine which has gotten so personal between President Putin uh US President Barack Obama uh German Chancellor Angela Merkel it's become so personal that there's no easy exit out of the Russia Ukraine conflict that has to be the number one risk and I don't see an easy solution to it as we go into 2015 I disagree I understand that now everybody is speaking about Ukraine when the subject is about Russia but that's not the case I agree that number one geopolitical risk at the moment Terror threat and when everything started in Syria uh my president was very strong addressing to The American Nation and American president and speaking with European leaders that Syria is not our neighbor but so close and the whole region is very fragile once uh any military operation starts it could influence our peaceful existing immediately and PE Russian people don't feel safe when you know people in the states and talk about any possible military action in Syria or in Iran or elsewhere so and at the same time you need to remember the you know the size of my country it's huge we start from the Baltic stay season you know and then the Ocean Pacific Ocean is the next Edge so when something happens in Iran or Syria turkey we feel it and we feel it strongly uh of course Ukraine Ukraine is not only our neighbor you know we feel ukrainians as our friends M family members I don't know I don't know how to call them they're so close to us so many ukrainians living in Russia so many Russians living in Ukraine so one would argue you like them so much you've gotone into the eastern half of the country no we yeah I know those jokes but you know there I don't mean that as a joke actually actually we are not meaning anything and I didn't hear anything from my president or prime minister meaning that you know we have interests to separate these regions from Ukraine we are interested in having whole Ukraine as it is the sovereign country the only thing we want to stop the war because that War influences us and this geopolitical risk but not the major one because all regional Wars all regional conflicts will influence Russia and people who are going to invest the they they don't feel safe that's not only the investment climate people are always talking about investment climate they will say how we feel with our friend China and for the last decade our relationship became much better so people are coming and invest in the neighbor regions from ourside and we see not only Chinese investors from Korea from Japan and others even American and Canadian companies investing there but before I think it was impossible because for them it was real risk so now you know at some part of my country it's becoming safer and some where it is Ukraine or closer to those regions where the Middle East is so that's more dangerous and again I would repeat it and I agree geopolitical risk number one 415 and maybe next year will be Terror threat Patrice mppi very quickly here because of time uh Africa has not been uh Untouched by Terror boo Haram right at the heart of it Kenya's had his challenges algeria's had its challenges Mal's had its challenges uh can we get these pockets of Terror in Africa under control in Kenya in Nigeria Mali Southeast Algeria that we saw on the past year and a half uh Tera is not uh confined to any specific area whether it's Africa or any other part it's it's a global threat and it's a global Challenge and requires Global cooperation but there is a a huge determination uh to deal with the the terror and the threats in in those areas that you've identified and the United Nations is playing a role some of the the African Union is contributing it's U it's a it's a very serious threat that requires focused uh uh attention and and focused action in the short term but also that has to go hand in hand with education we have to educate our youth to understand that you know terrorism you know violence is is totally unacceptable doesn't cannot be justified under any circumstances but uh we are optimistic and confident that uh we we we should make progress uh in that regard thank you very much Gentlemen let's open the floor to questions I would like to bring a microphone to the prime minister of Kazakhstan here to the front row uh Maya tuon would you like to weigh into the debate first let's go to the prime minister of Kazakhstan here if we can get a second microphone uh that I we can have do we have other questions from the floor because we have about five or six minutes and I want to make sure we address it it'd be interesting to get uh prime minister your perspective here a neighbor of Russia engaged in a uh European uh Zone with Russia the Eurasia economic zone uh it's not an easy time economically for Kazakhstan with oil prices down commodity prices down and your neighbor having very difficult time of uh sanctions as well how do you contend with it as a very large country at the center which anchored its future to Russia at the same time thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to you I would like to to to to have an answer a little bit broader not just our Eurasian economic Union which was started January 4th this year it was very interesting discussion about about the price for oil and the changes uh structural changes in in the world uh we believe uh that uh this year price for all will be low and next week we are planning to go to the parliament with the changes for the budget for $50 we think the average price for oil in 2015 will be $48 $50 and we uh look at this uh current situation on the price for Energy uh not to compare with with all8 or 9 with the temporary U changes on the price for oil we look at the structural changes like it was in uh 8489 when the price for oil fell down from $30 to $10 per barrel which is $140 in in today's terms and the price for all except uh the except the time of 91 during the war in the Gulf it come up to the level of $30 per B only 20 years later only in 2004 that's why what is happening right now it's not a short term it's a long term it's a structural changes and we made a decision and actually uh yesterday we signed an agreement with the oecd for Country strategy program and uh we made a decision that Kazakhstan will be a full member of OCD whatever it takes and I think the structural reforms during this hard time is very important and this is a unique opportunity for us for for Kazakhstan and we believe we are constantly in a discussion with our strategic partners with our friends from from Russia that they have the same idea that structural reforms needed for Russia as well as well it is needed for Kazakhstan uh with China uh we uh in in December we had a visit of prime minister Lee and a couple of days ago uh we had a discussion here in um uh Davos as well uh we will have a joint program for uh economic Bel for new Sil Road and we agreed that it will be quite a heavy investment into the diversification of the economy in Kazakhstan which will be linked to the Chinese economy but at the same time we have a quite a good uh opportunity for the whole Market with with Russia and Kazakhstan I just need to have you wrap up in the next 30 seconds if I may yeah okay making this long story short I think this is a unique opportunity for markets to to restructure the economy and to get a growth not in 2015 but to get a growth later but more stable thank you thank you for the input uh Finance Minister uh Amaya tukon uh your import costs for energy have gone down we have about a minute for your interjection what did you learn from the panel here and of course Jordan sits on the doorstep of Isis as well there's a regional security threat you're trying to get growth of 4% this year what's the most important point for you in 2015 well I really think um 2015 should be good for o importers of course uh including Jordan we are an oil importer sorry it's working yeah uh so by and large the decline in in oil price to 50 or 40 clearly should be good for the global economy um um of course all producers May face some uh challenges regarding the revenues for the budget but um uh what worries me really is that this decline in oil price as well as what the ECB did yesterday monetary easing or fiscal stimulus in some countries are making people complacent already we have people in my country saying let's relax the reforms and uh given this favorable circumstance this is a serious issue the the other point I just want to to make is that it seems the um the traditional um measures to to achieve growth which is capital spending or investment spending is not working anymore as expected we're not creating jobs and um what seems to be maybe it should be timely to think of looking at the at the history of of the of the modern history we need a major technological breakthrough to create jobs uh because the traditional Capital spending um targeting um uh Capital uh projects is not working it's not creating enough jobs and maybe it's time to think of a more um uh un non-traditional uh ways to create jobs and and Achieve growth thank you Dr chukan in fact the international labor organization came out with its youth unemployment report this uh this week and the pressure after the Arab Spring only made matters worse as everybody knows but the youth unemployment rate is nearly 30% the Middle East of North Africa it is a crisis as you are suggesting any other questions from the floor we have about a minute before we wrap please we can get a microphone here and there's there and there one here I I have to ask you because I promised the Deputy Prime Minister he would be out of here now so let's keep it direct thank you very much very much for giving me the opportunity and I want to thank you very at the panel I will request uh Morris Levy uh about his vision on India and China but he has experien on the you know recently we had the a plan about silk rout you know the silk route when I was in New York I was the attending the silk route and I got this message to go to G20 meeting and it took off and China is uh financing 40 billion on this particular deal so I was wondering China India as the world is changing around everybody talks about these two countries what is your vision on this particular we have a new prime minister in India he's trying to jump the economy than exactly we have a new prime minister in India who seem to be addressing all the major issues but you know that part of the problem in India there is many problem but one very important problem is infrastructure and it is a shame to see that India has not yet been able to build some very modern infrastructure the other problem is the problem we know about corruption uh but when you look at the whole aspect of India there is a lot of reason why you should be uh very positive about the country we have just made a very important investment India will be our second country in term of the size of our head count uh the number one country will be the US which is roughly 30,000 people in India we will have 13,000 people and then come China with uh seven or 8,000 people and France is becoming our fourth country in term of size so you see that we are believing in India and we are investing so I think uh provided that you address the real issues and that you address this issue very seriously and without any complacency I think uh you will have uh the support of the investors okay final interjection from the floor excuse me I I have to wrap sorry about that I don't mean to be rud we can talk after final interjection very quickly please um yes I'm Sagel from uh mugisha Somalia I'm member of uh young Global chis uh Community I my question is M Mr M um we've seen a lot of help coming from um Africa uh especially when it comes security um but also there are so many other helps and abroach coming from other countries from uh for example turkey and also we see now a new investing uh opportunities from China when are we seeing African money coming to Somalia and when it comes businesses and and and and economic growth other than the security contribution that they have right now thank you I mean uh we we're very confident of the future of uh East Africa and and Somalia Sudan South Sudan and uh one of our companies is indeed looking at uh those parts of the world and there's a new breed of entrepreneurs from Nigeria from subsaharan Africa and uh young entrepreneurs small businesses but also significant uh companies some of them in partnership with uh Chinese American European and so you you will see a significant amount of uh investments in the medium to long term okay very quickly 30 seconds uh for for Somalia just an example actually but if we really have some dedication and some good targeted work the progress could be real fast when we had we started the scheduled flights to Mogadishu the Madu airport was listed as terally closed so we had to rebuild the airport the road from Airport to downtown now building three hospitals and so forth uh and I think if that olical barrier is passed and if the population and the outside help is United then it becomes a very strong answer to Terror and violence and so forth which has been demonstrated I in a very nice way recently in Somalia thank you very much I uh want to thank our Deputy Prime Ministers for the great interjections in their entire panel thank you for the inputs from the floor prime minister and finance minister in particular a nice round of applause and thank you very very much for your time than | World Economic Forum | UCw-kH-Od73XDAt7qtH9uBYA | 2015-02-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 9,054 | 48,111 |
tcNzCHV4bSY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tcNzCHV4bSY | Wucci vs Warden's Warriors highlights (with comms) | EGL Major S2 Playday 1 | like all of our videos every single video [Music] we've got we've got three people Hiero small Baker I'm holding I'm holding cupcake window someone whole cupcake door if they is it back it up okay back it up you can't come back I got them to hold small window sorry I might have to move I think there's one tiles oldest super tie I'm gonna not one at all Thank You boys it could have been a so all right just hold the cross fires we don't want any like any suicidal please Jackson I think wrote errands cocktails before those deployed or does the pluggable I think it was a diploma was it default it was the point that was approval easy what if I window right window why window he's gonna he's gonna go top right top ease up nice car really relax feet boys gotta think singer and Eric my scar lies that's the one that's one of the best players I'm holding back or oh nice my sis awesome please I'm Frank up on thank you why are you rushing where you rushing my stress place I could flash like a flashing my stress flash my stress laughs sorry a whole bed could Clank aah Clank Clank this is this one off like a small bakery one small bakery stare upon tiny toy solo he solo nice nice wha we do I do oh my god I'm on the flank oh I'm on the hreflang turn say seconds boys time to cover the flank Jackson's game the part that is fine racers flank still great still very top top right nice nice to action I'm still in the writers camp but my room does I get another three I'll just cover the flag Jackson's well you could just cover the flank Benson cover piano maybe impact piano maybe sounded like it let's go well enlarged | Team Wucci | UCm6zW6qCe_lS8zazg_dGiZA | 2020-05-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 320 | 1,622 |
-q8bAVyg2bo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-q8bAVyg2bo | Recovery After the Party | good morning guys today is the day after Braden's party and it's basically recovery day we did a lot of cleanup yesterday so the house is in pretty decent shape the kids are all just kind of hanging out downstairs right now because it's still early I just finished editing the video and uploaded it from yesterday so you'll see that and then I was saying a couple of updates let's see here the baby bird that I found and I rescued I guess um so far and hasn't fallen back out of the nest so don't please survive I wasn't sure if like the mother rejected it and pushed it out of nests but it doesn't seem to be the case because he's still in there so that's that's a good thing so it definitely did a good deed by saving a little bird you know the commotion yesterday I made to show you the food that I made and like how I laid it out but I just it just didn't happen part of it is because I record on my phone and I had my phone playing music for the party so every time I wanted to make a video I had to stop the music and start recording on my phone so it was a lot of you know headache to go back and forth I cannot wait to have a camera Eddie said he's going to give me a camera as soon as it comes out at the end of the year and I'm very much looking forward to having a real camera my phone does a job for now but I would definitely prefer to have an actual camera so let me let me show you a little bit of what's left of the food okay so as you can see my refrigerator is a bit overstuffed at the moment I bought this corn I wasn't sure if I was going to make an amount it didn't work out so I'll just freeze half of it and just make it for ourselves in here I have some hot dogs and hamburgers out of leftover we made too much actually I made a lot of too much of everything in here we have some barbeque chicken I'm eating hummus fewer because some of our guests only eat chicken I also made this huge tray of barbecue pulled pork looks like about a third of it is missing I'm going to like probably portion without into containers and freeze it so already need whenever I'm hungry because we're definitely not going to heat this all before it goes bad even if I have it for lunch and dinner every day it's just still too much of it well at least I don't have to cook for the next day or two because I have plenty of food to choose from in here we have I need I don't like the pre-made hamburger patty they just kind of gross me out a little bit so I made a bunch of them by hand but we didn't cook them all so I'm going to have to wrap these up individually and freeze them this is always good to have expecting that my mom always today always has frozen hamburger patties we just throw them in the pan cook them up and they've done and then over here I mean macaroni salad there's still a lot of it left I should have given it out because like my sister ISA she would have taken some but she left in such a hurry because honestly I'm the only one in this house who eats it my Eddie doesn't eat it he won't touch anything with mayo Lukas can't have Mayo because he's allergic to eggs and then and Logan just doesn't like it the other kids don't like it so most of us probably going to go to waste but I'm going to see if I can give them away to somebody because I really do hate wasting food so that was the food for yesterday and it seems to go over very well because everybody was eating they all said the food was delicious which of course feels amazing because I love to be able to feed people and make them happy so these old ate be pulled pork of the chicken the kids ate like hot dogs and hamburgers if they ate anything at all then we had ice cream truck um as you should have seen if you watch the video already it was very easy like we have a couple of local ice cream trucks one was good humor one was mr. saucy I wanted good humor because they have like the bigger variety of like they fun like popsicles and stuff you know I didn't have to pay him to come here we just paid for all the ice cream that the kids got and of course he tab because it's guaranteed sales right there so we did that last year for Braden's birthday and we really enjoyed it the kids loved it so I decided to do it again and we did that instead of cake so we all sang happy birthday just before we got alright but just before all the kids got their ice cream so that that was just like a nice it was something fun to do and it was different from what typically happens so today today I'm going to spend some of my time rusting and recovering from yesterday and I'm sure I'm eating it and I'm cleaning up the house a little bit it's not terrible but I've got to do a little bit work in here I have some laundry to do as always and I'm very proud of myself I did really good yesterday my energy was great I felt great even I didn't go to bed till almost midnight and I really thought that like come ten o'clock I was going to crash I did really good I'm very proud of myself Game of Thrones started yesterday I'm a huge fan loved the show don't know what to think yet but it was very excited to see that yesterday I'm a baby oh wow that's cool her Brandon's birthday he got kinetic sand and he's so excited he's been asking for this forever right and he played with it yesterday and he's playing with it now and I have to say if you don't have kinetic sand you've never touched it you got to try it it feels amazing hearing you worrying in Makassar arm side but it feels so good I've determined that after the last two days of hustling all day I ain't doing anything today I'm tired I'm worn out I don't feel like I don't feel terrible right now which is a good thing of course but I'm definitely tired I'm feeling very lazy so I'm just going to take advantage of the day to recover and hopefully tomorrow I'll feel a little more motivated to get some stuff done so I'm just going to chill out with the kids and hopefully no one will kill each other in the process ready yeah [Applause] turn around oh my god you look awesome alright let's go take a shower yeah well it's the heck I totally what was I thinking I would never do this so braid them to the shower get washed off alright so so I gave them the rest of the silly string to kind of just get rid of all right well I'm pretty fried the rest of the day was pretty calm Eddie came home we had dinner and then the kids just hanging out now so I'm gonna get eat them to bed and then I'm gonna take a shower and older boys wouldn't go to bed and then we're going to call it a night and I'll see you in my next video thanks for watching guys bye | Surviving as Mom | UCmrj6ilyMI5G2hnraXRWpEQ | 2017-07-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,344 | 6,592 |
u4dE7JUJn7I | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u4dE7JUJn7I | GH Shocking Spoilers Heather killed Maggie years ago, posing as Maggie to create the crazy Esme | foreign [Music] spoilers revealed that a new surprise is being revealed while Heather herself is being said to be esme's mother it seems that things are going in an unexpected direction if it can be seen that Heather is trying to create a new disgust for her adopted mother Esme cares Heather is smee's biological mother but it should be remembered that the identity of Maggie who raised and made such a good impression is still a mystery but things are now increasingly taking on a new surprise and may well be the last that Heather is able to create it should be remembered that Esme is still suffering from Amnesia and her ambiguity about a mystery is being created very quickly but remember that esme's memory is still one of the most important things are more ambiguous than ever and that poses an even bigger problem in ensuring that the facts themselves are not triggering the dark things the destiny is creating everyone knows that the last time Maggie appeared was in Great Britain but all search seems to have failed to have its effects and that's now widening more and more certainties about one of the factors that doubt Maggie's existence but it seems that Heather is doing the sort of what Port Charles is afraid of when Heather is trying to make sure that the crazy truths are revealed as quickly as possible but it seems that things could be going in an even more crazy Direction when Heather is Maggie but a more unexpected way than ever honestly it was Heather who impersonated Maggie in order to create one of the biggest surprises ever Maggie never appeared but it should be remembered that her influence on esme's thoughts is still very strong Heather knows it too and there's evidence that the madness Maggie is created for Esme is rooted in Heather's control Heather gave birth to Esme but did not give her love and care but when Heather herself saw how important Esme was in her plans things are now getting crazier as Heather murdered Maggie and gave her dark instructions which Esme herself made over the years it seems that things are getting crazier and crazier when it is Heather who will reveal the truth about Maggie's death to estimate so that there's hope that there's an explosion in esme's memory and from there then it will happen there's a new destruction to the town's Focus the madness is heightened like never before remember that Heather is now doing everything she can to ensure her interests and sacrificing unnecessary conditions is taking precedence more than ever Heather can sacrifice estimated Canaan advantage and this is making a new hook related crimes more advanced than ever foreign | ROAD TO GH | UCvtRbepYqnTBJXzPIi6YY0A | 2023-02-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 461 | 2,635 |
6qt7Se4aRd0 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6qt7Se4aRd0 | Q&A: Phosphorus Management Lessons Learned from the Field | okay first question here from Carl yes the key is systems of conservation practices and thoughts about the effectiveness of systems of conservation practices but I think we've had a lot of comments around that but any things you would like to conclude here for the group Deanna you talked a lot about systems can you say that again I didn't quite all was agreeing with the key is the system of conservation practices any thoughts about effectiveness systems of conservation practices so there have been a couple watershed scale projects where they have looked at the effectiveness of conservation practices at a watershed scale the key is not only having systems of conservation practices but making sure they're the right systems and also making sure they get put in the right areas of the watershed so it's it's it's a very holistic approach that's going to solve this problem and I took away as part of that is that you will need to look at practices that both address the erosion P as well as the dissolve P does that seem to make sense I think we all agree with that I think either Kevin or Mike could take more now I agree with that Kevin or Mike anything you want to add to the systems no I think I mean it's gonna take a systems approach as I said it's not we're not gonna be able to focus on one aspect okay I agree wholeheartedly with that and also agree that we'd sometimes walking on practices and we think that they should they should be as effective no matter where we apply them and there's gonna be a lot of sites persistent specialist if it'll be very site-specific and how they perform and how you apply them okay I'm gonna move on to a question from Landon there have been have there been studies that quantify statistical significant increases of dissolved pee from reduced tillage I have heard that no-till systems have a higher dissolve peel off there's a with respect to there specifically to tile drainage there's a lot of work that's been done on that in New York Pennsylvania Ohio we have our edge of field data that I highlighted we show that same thing that data's not published yet but but absolutely there's a lot of data out there that shows that with tile drainage and so when we what would be a sample of a static practice on no-till that would help best manage that dissolve peat well there's if you think about no-till some of the things definitely cover crops can you're going to get more evapotranspiration with cover crops for therefore you would have less discharge so that's going to help you might pair that with something like the drainage water management or the controlled drainage so then that you could be you could be backing up or holding that water in the field with that as well so that I guess that's one example I think the other thing is we can't overestimate the importance of nutrient management nutrient management is part of a system of conservation practices and just making sure that our soil test phosphorous levels are not increasing would be very helpful and also managing the placement and timing of our fertilizers - are very important to helping reduce soluble phosphorus losses jump down the list of ways Michael asks the question does the organic content of soil influence Pima bility great I can't answer that question because our soils in Arkansas we have no organic matter you know I I'm not sure and and and I want to have a conversation here with Kevin while I'm answering this so we see phosphorus leaching in our coastal plain soils that are sandy textured that have had a lot of swine afluent applied so there's more water going through the soil and the form of phosphorus tends to be more soluble and the soil test phosphorous levels are really high that's where we see a lot of phosphorous movie I think Kevin your soils have higher salt organic matter than ours here in North Carolina I think you guys are still seeing phosphorus move in there right absolutely now we've got we've got higher organic matter but we're still poor poor soil structure so we're not sure whether that's coming through the desiccation cracks or weather or weather that leaching into the tiles is still making that tortuous pathway or not that's something we're trying that's something we're trying to parse out we've got some we've got some studies going on in the labs to try to figure that but we don't know that yet and Kevin correct me if I'm wrong but I think I've seen a little bit of data out of Iowa and their child rains and they're seeing some phosphorus leaching - is that right or well they are it's very low levels but they are and they have really high soil organic dairy yes Michael asked in regards to soluble pee loss is there a critical so phosphorus test level it has been identified for the soluble feelings I'll take I can tell you in our state there was a lot of talk about trying to find a critical level but you know phosphorus loading or loss is more than a function than just the source there's also that transport function it's some function of the interaction between transport and source so I don't know that we can ever identify a critical that might be different from from what our soil test recommendations are for plant needs but we we've tried to do that but we realize that we've got them to incorporate in that transport factor when we consider that and I think most of the data show that if you are truly within your agronomic range of phosphorus it's not completely protective but it's much more protective than if you start getting into some of the really high soil test phosphorus that we can see here in there on okay well thank you to that reset do you have a recommendations how best to reduce legacy phosphorus in this well stop putting it on very true okay well there was a lot of other it's interesting questions that we could have got to just time allows us I would have liked have got more into this connection between our practices and changing weather but I think that's a big discussion that's for another time but that to me is a very interesting challenge ahead of us for those that are younger than me there have to figure that out I guess but thank you very much Mike Vienna Kevin really enjoyed conversation today excellent information and thank you all to have joined this webinar | Livestock & Poultry Environ. Learning Community | UCLObpc9E9ZTivFAmbj3Qazw | 2019-12-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,142 | 6,292 |
5uGAPnYdTlo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5uGAPnYdTlo | Patented by CEU UCH: a new material for remineralisation of dentine and enamel | foreign [Music] that has been patented is fluoride doped hydroxyl calcium phosphate it's basically a mix of components makes place together different type of calcium phosphates that they react together and we have doubled this calcium phosphate with fluoride some couple of types of calcium fluoride salts and with alkaline substance which is basically calcium hydroxide all these components together when they react with water when they are in contact with saliva or any body fluid or even with PBS or normal water they basically react together and this material precipitate immediately in form of crystals of appetite like substance appetite or hydroxypodite is the main component of teeth and Bone and many other mineralized tissue in the human body these edoxopodite over time in conda with saliva or any other body fluid and with the fluoride contained inside this material it has been patented it converts little by little into floor appetite so the reason why we want to have Flora padite in dentistry and this is the main application of this pattern is because fluorapatite is much more resistant to acid attack compared to Classic cartoon phosphate or any other calcium salt or the conventional hydroxovide the idea is to obtain a reminalization with a substance that is more resistant to acid attacks so basically it can be resistant to to carries or to erosion the pattern is about the method we produce this mix of components and the method is react to obtain first appetite and then fluoropatite this material can be directly applied on the teeth so for example in order to make teeth stronger and resistant to to carous lesions so it can be convertedly or introduced in toothpaste gels chewing gum any other preventive substance the second application of this material is to incorporate this filler in Dental material in restorative material so composite adhesive cement but basically the dentist and clinical operator they can use this new future material for restoration for you know restore the teeth carries or for cementation for clinical applications for dentists the main benefit that we are still proving is to prove and prove and prove again that whatever we place this filler we will be able to remineralize and reinforce the structure of the of the art tissue like enamel and then | Universidad CEU Cardenal Herrera | UCD--nTFPYSIAGbC5fonp2ZA | 2022-10-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 385 | 2,305 |
7L2aq7LCKtU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7L2aq7LCKtU | The Discouragement Test (by Pastor Steve Myrie) | this is pastor ordained James from the transformation Center in Tampa Florida and you're listening to pastor Steve Meyer good and bad serve a purpose and in many weeks sometimes the back though it might be very good serves a good purpose the truth is not to speak of me that one taught you to see the full autonomy but something is good from the get-go from it start you know it's good so obviously from it good starting you you're expected to be good in the end but the bank one is expected to be bad but so we are so mobile whatever we have was working the good out of the bad but that there's a bit of a fine print that we must read where does his concern because the scripture tells us that we know that all things what is all things work together for the good but then the right practice to get that an hour fall according to his purpose so the purpose own book got a whole way of working all the bad good for his people everyone so tonight we want to look as far as rent what it is what it causes and what are the benefits that we can derive from being discouraged I mean we prefer so many fingers does it magic wants to be discouraged nobody wants a feel broken or anything like that however as I said the purpose of this lesson is to encourage you to be quick to that this is a part of our walk with God and it is he was in a position where you commitment he is wearing that equally restored order to Israel in his mind he thought they would have - she probably that they have gave up the throne the next day we were told that by the prophets some other would be rescued [Music] Moses represents a long duration it was Moses who in the angel appeared now this is telling us Elijah they ready position Viveca but when it came time for threat became fearful and you run away let's go to verse 16 [Music] perish but the inward man what is really an emphasis is being placed here because there's so many things to the physical across who's healthy campus people about their business Castro let's sing one side of a person's body becomes paralyzed again we have to understand since the reality had problems with the physical body that emphasis cannot be placed at the old world it has to be that we try to place emphasis on the inner man idea for what we do with the Obermann flow of it read it it's over but our clothes to make sure that it's tarpaulin and very hot we get on set the atmosphere so that we get little more cool and whatever we do so much to make sure that awkward man is predicted all of our time is comfortable or initiatory arise a kit is really about once skirt you will everybody I even our dear sister President Lee sister Teresa that's in hospital when we first heard I heard ago she did one certain then the desk of she didn't deserve to assert his vow they stopped she didn't deserve then another call another surgeon by that year it was about six are so surgeries the white woman did we needed s that one me the new research and another hundred something with a big door did something else come up and a buzzer or the time that ever consider she has been in the hospital sick searches and inside to be because it's Experian got people helped everyone about their business and then had before they head out to be alone then I walk home with a set of tears and a second impression Tennessee Volunteers this woman was six major asserted at any point in time during the surgeries she could have quite a strong cheering for the church visited her it goes or spirit so what she is doing in looking at the other NASA tourists every girl that to say happy birthday greatest God but just for the fun part we have a show formality and just be positivity in your spirit I said happy birthday I talking to the church dr. Copley's if we issue yet the system six surgeons get this major surgery for the nominative major surgeries but yet she could encourage me but I spoke to her cause in this version it is freedom there's an expectation that it was expect violence brings fear Cosmo Wanda am I in that number in here support man praise God sir roam the streets of the community they become fearful the March over to school the merchants of the world there's somebody who you have to say something too but then because of the person might say to become fearful and you start to become anxious fear causes discouragement because when fear concealing I knows you should not be able to progress to move forward there [Music] started noticing there were ingredient cleaner washes where no fear was already taking care of the enemies of the children of Israel but yet they were still what their own fearful after their enemies that's what fear does because your child progress today just get one piece that will make enemies at wanda already by the model ready imagine otherwise they did not want to progress to move because they were in fear of an attack they were in fear of losing their lives they would have starved to death by the law I already taken then what started as we said was very killed from sleeping and it was on the ship notice he said it would not be what children trust and have hundreds in God then there can be no fear frustration number one cause is frustrated some does really get to you frustration really means to bring to nothing it means accent just try some and is that it just now work a secular state forestry rin-chan do this over and over and the result is nothing [Music] in addictions we discourage in your minds we have learned to consider what Jesus went through because he went through this one we tried it out yes what we would remember what she went [Music] no English no he went through what he did so before you make that decision Sagat without video remember thank you Jesus now why is this important in terms of discouragement another reason why it is important to be discouraged ironic I mean I'm telling you that being discouraged is a good thing but it is not in classes to find joy in God and not be more circumstances so now we will find pleasure in our surroundings in our environment in our friends at an economy the fact that we have good people around us but many times you should realize that with all these things that God provides for us we continue to say I will forget we have little time machines under check so he provided good friends provide family provide activities when this current problems sad to say we are about to become a host photo-friendly talking but oddly effective and praise God one remember to turn to sow discord faith helps us to find joy again in possible deals that we are not self-sufficient when we fall into problems it helps us to do it's not about the size of a match if we get in the medium and the show they will start to become self-reliant no we understand being self-reliant the feminists are giving context because you know differently I have a condition and so on understand to an extent it's good but whatever it is well be not so much you know I mean I wanna draw my body and become your channel is oh hello where are you Oh God there are believers to be merciless hello God when it was putting it in our DNA he made us for us to be together proof it was not good for the man to be alone petrified I've already read that report it was by the fries with the metal others from the church it gives me it gives me sure why I've shown this Pacific in irregular pockets just and I hope you listen and this is somebody that it's in our ability to walk across people but we'll try and check what somebody find what if somebody ever final 250 trying out what one because sometimes people visit the palace and there was nobody is women say know how these social skills got before each of us so he takes somebody this what if I was at listen I prefer years hear this message and I was his assistant around kink soliton she sits over the she has been she's here sometimes and Chicago Brownsville and so she said that listen to this church she's under a rule they'll pass anakata the only answer for me we have no choice we could have the best features we teach young people they would wonder which are safe for tonight because together as somebody can wear jeans friends however sneakers sure so I give you the symptoms of this parchment I totally different purpose of this world Madonna trusted us acquaintances in check upon to give this world sorry first somewhere 30 a merciless let's we got the sense what what what other forest with the dealer discouragement is to learn to encourage your synth so yes it's just natural what is nobody with me so this is why the first thing doctor went to check on yourself forgive my father some of us if somebody not comfortable if church then the next thing they know time like this but it was just a feeling I knew digitally but we have so much because the truth is spiritually the marmosets opposite is with the map says the variables are what spiritual beings desire the sincere milk of the world but from a time when was a prism we have a drink milk now or movie star eat meat so the truth is sometimes physical for this awkward one here I go Oh means amateur the next thing to bottle solvent is real [Music] to go over it in pieces II never said this fortnight now walk home but we preview in terms of how to navigate because the truth [Music] good times I didn't see the people who not always a penis nice like the to discuss you understood much attended Rosie my human most true kiss we have a pretty small so you know that what the system so Ferguson's have traditions what was this and not because this cultivates form in the traffic comes into the brain marriage doesn't show by the world Galaga imagine that everything pushed us the paralyzed did a sabbatical of everywhere to be consistent and persistent in whatever we do tonight I am Reggie or throttle become things now [Music] [Applause] [Music] and so I'm grateful for be placed into negative opinion you know life is always here deposit works on a genetic process when I read an appreciable to touch up discouragement and all because we are a specifically watery dispersion and I don't really have any question but I just want my stay one have learned tonight you know I have been motivated today to to in the time of distress or discouragement that so for to to read word to learn the voice of God because the most severe things and everyone is John pants in his freedom that it is done Sarah because even during a time when I was going through some things when I was wondering where hearing those voices and I'm saying that's the voice of time but it was it was of the voice of God he was so evil in all spirits feet as well that say don't worry about that evening [Music] | VALTECH MEDIA T.V | UCWitdmk0-haPlyLL4fCgK1A | 2019-12-19 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,025 | 10,678 |
JNYYmRzG-48 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JNYYmRzG-48 | EREN YEAGER DIY COSPLAY | ATTACK ON TITAN | Cosplay Genie | hello guys welcome back to cosplay genie in today's video i'm going to show you how do i build my server cards 3 odm gears from attack on titan season 4. i used eva foam to make all the gears and this is a freehand build i took lots of screenshots from the anime and download lots of images from the internet as with your friends and try to make it accurate as much as possible if you like the video please subscribe our channel follow our page and share your feedbacks in a comment so without take it any longer let's get started [Music] first time picked up a plastic bottle as a reference for mix lander part here i made a hollow cylinder from 8mm eva foam oval shape cap i made it for top and bottom side made a template for shoulder part here i made it the both shoulder part with the help of template made a round cap type part for the shoulder details [Music] made it a template for side panel of main unit build four pieces of side panel with the help of template created multiple pieces for make side panel support [Music] here is my side panel base ready [Music] all side panels front side is ready made it the lower back main unit part applying the contact cement on the edge of cylinder that i made it earlier [Music] joining them together [Music] here is upper main unit cylinder is ready [Music] 2.4 inch radius and draw a circle on firm for make cylinder holding base cut it out [Music] applying contact cement [Music] joining them together [Music] completed the base part 4 cylinder [Music] now time to make gripping strip for cylinder [Music] cut it out the strip [Music] applying contact cement [Music] joining them together [Music] now drawing the pattern on form for the main base [Music] here is the part ready drawing pattern for subpart [Music] applying contact cement and joining them together [Music] here is the pattern in pieces for cylinder support part and applying contact cement [Music] and joining them together [Music] joining with the cylinder base [Music] applying contact cement and joining slender with the back base [Music] drawing the pattern for chest gauntlet [Music] cut it out [Music] edit side edges and front details to the chest contralate [Music] chest contract is ready [Music] applying contact cement and joining main unit side panels [Music] all my side panels are ready [Music] here i made it side arms and a wrist part with the help of a template connect it to the shoulder piece in a moving form fade it hole and fix the side panel with cylinder [Music] similarly completed the lower back unit here's the different parts for blade boxes [Music] join them one by one with the small support from inside [Music] blade holder boxes are ready [Music] using 1.5 inch diameter pvc pipe for make side cylinders [Music] join it by pen boxes and here is my all gears are ready for primer [Music] using a gray spray primer for time saving and easy to use [Music] all the gears after priming [Music] using silver chrome spray as a base color for all of them [Music] use brown gray and black colors for details part here is my season 4 odium gears ready [Music] you | Cosplay Genie | UCzVCbKUW2Mk_SCC6JvR4i9Q | 2022-07-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 564 | 3,105 |
RULeFZju6Tk | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RULeFZju6Tk | Vernon Lenoir - Yogg Sototh wears pink socks | [Music] and everyone was so pissed off about that guy because he called himself i was saying come on the guy's real name is let him be for a couple of months what's it to you who's gonna follow a messiah named vernon anyway you know and i was about to hang up and go to bed when my ear caught a very faint suspicion of sound at the other end [Music] it was in the night that stark utter horror burst over me and weighed my spirit with a black clutching panic from which it can never shake free [Music] down [Music] so [Music] which had an odd suggestion of an articulate unintelligible word and syllable divisions i called who is it but the only answer [Music] was you | cenomdechainemelesbrisemenu | UCu75k4EwXxG9A41KjpRcEjg | 2020-08-07 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 130 | 668 |
G8PzTuIsB24 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G8PzTuIsB24 | RX (7): De Reverb Module | unwanted reverb caused by ugly room reflection that sometimes gets picked up by a microphone can cause a lot of problem within the intelligibility of a dialogue we're going to explore how the reverb module can attenuate and sometimes even remove unwanted reflections [Music] in this chapter we're going to be talking about reverb and unwanted reverb now this doesn't refer to the artificial reverb that most of the time you will apply to a recording in order to make you know a vocal sounds a little bit more appealing sounds bigger and brighter now over here we're talking about the natural reverb that sometimes is caused by a reflection within room that gets picked up by a microphone creating a thick layers of reverbs reflections that will end up creating a lot of confusion behind the dialogue all right i'm going to let you hear what i'm talking about all right so here i have a recording and the reverb it's very noticeable give it a listen in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor the problem that we run into it is reverb now the reverberation happens with the sound hitting reflective surfaces and then coming back at the microphone which in this case is picking up the direct sounds plus the reverb now the deriver module with an isotope rx is going to help us to reduce the amount of reverberation around our direct sounds let's see how it works all right as you could hear there is a noticeable reverberation in it that doesn't help the dialogue actually it makes it very unclear so what i'm going to do is import this track into isotope rx and then work with my deriver module before i do that as a normal procedure i'm going to create my playlist i'm going to go into my audio suite choose isotope rx connect send it to repair send all right i'm going to open my deriver module and there you have it now i'm going to explain a little bit how the reverb module works the first thing you want to do is again if you don't know really what you're doing there is always a menu that will tell you in other words what to do or pretty much start setting up the module in in in the best way scenario um i generally work with this module with the learn button so the first thing i'll do would be to highlight the entire section click learn and as you can see the module is learning the profile of my reverb now over here we have a sets of sliders now those are the the sliders correspond to specific gate bends and we have low frequency low mids high mids and highs and over here pretty much the reverb module is telling you how much of each one of this specific bands he will attenuate within the reduction slider here we can decide if we want more reduction versus which means a little bit more of a drier signal versus a more reverberant signal now the more we'll increase the reduction the more isolation we're going to have between dialogue and reverb though again you will introduce a lot of artifacts so you need to be very cautious with this reduction module now another thing you could do would be to enhance the dry signal this will pretty much split the reverberations plus the dry signal and enhance the dry signal again reverb is divided in two sections you have an early reflections which corresponds to the the first reflection that the sound is going to have as soon as it hits the the ideas and walls so the the ceilings the walls and uh and the ground and then you have the late reflection which are the one that in most cases create the most of the problems which are the ones you want to try to attenuate with this module without any further ado let's go ahead and give a preview of what this module has analyzed actually i'm going to redo this and i'm going to click on output only to hear what is extracting exactly all right let's see if i remove the output only and i click on the enhanced dry signal what the previous signal will let me hear in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor the problem that we run into it is reverb now the reverberation i'm going to try to raise a little bit the overall reduction let's see what happens in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor the problem that we run into it is reverb now the reverberation happens with the sound hitting reflective surfaces and then as you can hear here i have abused a little bit too much the the reduction slider so i'm going to reduce this and what i'll do right now is again highlight my entire selection and then use the compare button to compare the before and after i have manipulated the the reverb through the through the reduction slider so i'm going to put my reductions later at 2 press compare and let's hear in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor the problem that we run into it is reverb now the reverberation happens with the sound hitting reflect all right let's see what happen if i change a little bit the amount of frequency reverb in the high range and bring this slider up to four click and compare so again i've put this i've kind of like took a snapshot of this module and then i can compare uh the settings between the original the second snapshot and the third snapshot in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor original in many cases when we do enter the reverb in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor it sounds much better to me so what i'll do is to give it a pass a render and as you can see already from the spectrum we have cleared out a little bit of the reverb and then over here i could actually add a second module which is a dialog d reverb and what i'll do is just simply go into the settings and use just a light reverb attenuation again within the reduction i'm going to lower it a little bit more and i'm just going to compare the before and after all right so we have original in many cases when we do enter and the reverb in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor now there is a little bit of artifact so what i'm going to do is to lower the reduction a little bit more i'm going to leave ambiance preservation at 85 percent and again the sensitivity at five compare all right in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which i will select everything render and as i told you before this module takes a little longer to process and so right now through the history menu down here in the bottom right corner i can let you hear the initial state of how we got our recording in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an in and the last edited version in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene the reverb is completely gone and i mean right now what you could do is of course use some um gain processors such as an equalizer to kind of like reshape a little bit more the the timbre of this dialogue and with sound design and room tones and ambience and backgrounds you can actually build a better more healthy and under control environment around this dialogue so what i'll do right now is to send it back into pro tools and render this all right so we have the before in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene and after in many cases when we do interviews or we shoot a scene which has an indoor and there you have it so as you can see the reverb module is possibly one of the hardest of the module to use because it's the one that introduced a lot of artifacts but if you use it cautiously between the deriver module and the voice the reverb you can obtain great results and then again remember to have the bigger picture in front of you so it's not only how great this dialogue sounds but how great this dialogue will sound along with the entire picture of the sound design this was the deriver module i'll see you in the next tutorial ciao [Music] | Music Technology Tips and Tricks | UC4ZOQBz6a2hpuc1D0iKwlng | 2021-01-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,518 | 7,895 |
C0FsIFOFcOo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0FsIFOFcOo | Elden Ring: BEST FAITH BUILD ARMOR - How To Get GODSKIN NOBLE ARMOR SET - Secret Path & Armor Guide | so my beautiful people i am back with another album ring video today i'm going to showcase you guys how you can get this incredible looking god skin noble armor how's it going guys my name is dpg and if you enjoyed the video leaving a like really helps out and if you like what you see want to see more be sure to subscribe so the godskin noble armor set is one super unit check this out people check this out you know you need this in your life now it's quite tanky to be honest it's got a bit of magic to it i mean why not people it's a decent armor set and you may just want to grab this thing like i said if you want to run around looking like a giant blob but like a a prettied up marshmallow man then you're good here people you're good okay so to get this thing um it ain't straightforward to be honest with you so firstly guys you need to progress through ronnie's quest line which i've made a complete guide i'll link it in the video description but some about halfway through the questline she gives you an object now this object is super important this object guys we need to take to another spot another place and this takes us to a c when i say a secret location it basically inverts the study hall so come here guys and you'll place this actual ornament or whatever it is at first i thought it was one of those sand timer things but it actually ain't i don't know what it is guys but who cares either way so come to the uh carrion study hall and place this thing down you'll get an amazing cutscene and everything will turn upside down from here guys you need to follow the path i take on screen now be super careful though there's a lot of places you can fall so yeah be careful here so you'll eventually guys come to where i am at right here walking along these kind of pillars or whatever these are holding this building together then guys you want to jump down onto this platform here and activate this lift upon you doing this guys you want to jump out and come towards this big door once you walk towards this big door you'll be able to open it go through it and run along this this bridge once you run along disguise you'll be confronted by godskin noble now when you take him out you are rewarded the godskin noble armor set and it is really as simple as that my beautiful people so you want to run around looking like the god skin noble you can and this is how you do it guys the end of the video has arrived if you enjoyed it leave a like if it helps out if you like what you see i want to see more out of the ring be sure to subscribe and hopefully people i will see you on that next one you | DPJ | UCqheS9rd4_nojHk3H-FR2XQ | 2022-03-10 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 524 | 2,616 |
WzNSeZwlIv0 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzNSeZwlIv0 | Midlife Career Strategy: Career Change Stalled By Your Comfort Zone | hi this is cathy goodwin and today's question is has your career become an old shoe we all have an old shoe in our lives and this is one of mine it's comfortable it we tell ourselves oh we're just going to wear it to walk dog or when it's raining but we find ourselves drawn to it because it is so comfortable the downside is it's not really good for our feet I mean that that doesn't have support is falling apart the laces keep coming loose it's really not safe for really good to wear that shoe for you it might not be a shoe it might be a chair or a sofa same idea in your career there are three types of old shoes first the college student job you never outgrow someone alcohol Robert had a job as a waiter in a restaurant he got that job what he dropped out of college at the time he was it is like early twenties I guess and it was a perfect job he was cheerful he really enjoyed some bartending hung around the restaurant business and now it's 20 years later and he hasn't outgrown that job he kind of likes it he had I hates it he's doing other things on the side but you know being 40 and 50 doing what you did when you're 20 just doesn't feel the same people around him are a lot younger is like why are you here he goes to a party as they say what do you do I do this and they say oh I did that for a summer in college just like oh ok well that's a sign it's time to think about maybe moving into a more grown-up job then there's the temporary job that became permanent this is an example of Rose who is a real client she moved to a small town I think it was upstate New York to be with her family personal reasons she took a job as a teller in a bank which seemed perfect at the time it was interesting it paid well for the time she was just looking for something to hold things together she had been a corporate executive in a big company earlier so she stayed and then 10 or 15 years later she woke up and said you know this is a family owned business it's small its regional there's no place for me they've told me over and over i'm not going anywhere I'm stuck in this salary I'm stuck in this job and I'm not building anything up for my resume when she called we were really challenged to look at her next steps she had been there a long time and we did work with her and she was able to do some things but it's something where you need a wake-up call early on that this isn't going anywhere it's something I took to be temporary maybe it's time to make the big move and do something permanent then there's the day job that takes over the real job marvin not his real name had a business it was it was really a very good business person to be honest that he knew it on with one part of his brain so he got a job part time as an instructional designer and I'm again I'm making up the details not the real one but it paid well he was comfortable then the day job just took over he originally said well I'll use the money from that to put into my business to invest but what happened was he started saying you know I'm living off this money I'll just do a little bit with the business I'll make the business became the fun part the the margarita money the money for extra treats and the day job just became his regular job which is fine except that first he didn't really like stay job it wasn't something that he was suited to it had no growth potential and the people who ran the day job could tell that he was not dedicated so they didn't give him upward mobility and one day he woke up and said you know this job is going away because they had changed things around and all of a sudden it wasn't a comfortable old shoe anymore so what do you do first you have to do something really really hard it I understand I've been there myself more than once it is very hard to recognize it's time to grow before you're hurting so most of us wait till we're hurting before we take action and I don't like to say too late because few things really are too late but it's a question of the sooner you figure this out the more time you have the more leeway the more choices record secondly saying where you are may not be the safe option in every case that I've mentioned each of those people is vulnerable and may be unable to move when they're ready to even if you have a job that you can say if you've been there a long time maybe you're in a union I mean let's say you take a government job and you've got benefits it sounds really good but it's not always safe because you can't have layoffs you can't have cutbacks you can wake up one day and say I can't do this anymore especially in the situation if you're doing a college student type job your back starts to change or your whole attitude changes your body changes and you change you wake up and say I can't do it anymore and then for your company says the jobs gone it's changed it's no longer an old shoe so here's what I recommend i recommend that you do something different every single day this is the best way to jolt your brain cells I know that I'm not being scientific here I'm being metaphorical but that's what I encourage you to do walk to work a different way or drive to work a new way write something with a pencil instead of a computer or vice versa what are something in a restaurant that you usually make it home or vice versa then start doing something bigger here in Philadelphia where I live the big thing is to take class everybody takes classes at some time or other I've been taking ceramics which is a challenge for me it's totally changed the way I i work with physical objects and use my hands I also take improv classes which is a great way to jolt yourself out of your comfort zone trust me nobody stays in their comfort zone hit improv even if they've been doing it for 20 years something that will make you look at the world differently once that happens it's sort of like the ice on a pond that has been frozen once you make that first crack everything starts to loosen up so that's what I recommend is your first step of course if you work with me we have other steps you can take we can work more systematically at looking at your options and what you'd like to do so the just as a reminder i'm kathy goodwin and might this is the website i have for careers and i invite you to come this and thank you so much for joining me today | Catharine Goodwin | UCQGkeuZ435thOWI8nuBzqWA | 2012-09-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,261 | 6,328 |
GD6TxvqaPBM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GD6TxvqaPBM | Genshin Impact - How To Complete (Diluc) Story Quest (Darknight Hero's Alibi) Chapter 1 Guide | [Music] do for you [Music] come in take a seat [Music] so but just wondering [Music] you want to find out about the guard they do night shifts anyway try what's wrong why can't i let's take a look [Music] it's getting dark let's stick around once yeah maybe if we're lucky we'll meet the dark knight hero [Music] hey fire hazard [Music] chicken [Music] seems like huffman has something he really wants to say to you about the dark knight hero better head over to the knights of evonius and see if you can find him huffman can if you find out anything at all a war declaration sent by the abyss order oh this is not good news at all for master d luke quick we should go tell him right away [Music] strongholds this is the abandoned ruins come on [Music] here [Music] right try not to just lift retribution uh [Music] huh [Music] huh [Music] fire hazard [Music] look at you come on how did you foreign now that i have [Music] [Applause] wow pymon feels we saw a whole new side of the knights of evonius today but pymon doesn't understand how is kaia so sure he knows who the dark knight hero we need to get to the winery and tell master d look as soon as privately possible [Music] d the most [Music] huh [Music] huh [Music] whoa [Music] okay foreign what [Music] huh me ah allow me to enter there [Music] and then how long does it take holy moly it really does it appears we better get rid of [Music] come on [Music] that didn't count let's wait until evening to meet mr d look at the tavern yes what [Music] greeting oh [Music] huffman showed up just as expected okay remember the plan go to the city side gate and place the elemental bait whoa you used all of it this is gonna be pretty epic yikes here comes the slimes quick let's get to the tavern before anyone spots us [Music] going [Music] huh come a little closer fire hazard [Music] you're in for a little shock nothing more than a few no time to check glad that's settled let's get back to the tavern do you think huffman is back yet it seems i'm in the habit of in the future [Music] i [Music] you | Legendary Saud | UCpqmRoCZ_5lwqZimehgwI-Q | 2022-08-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 397 | 2,057 |
T2kP5ZtkRVs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2kP5ZtkRVs | Recover Data HHD hard drive from broken external Western Digital mybook enclosure repair solution | hello hi guys I want to show you how to recover your hard drive from external hard drive enclosure it's a success this is the Western Digital annoying soldier so often as I had to was the digital external apology from way back two years ago and numb often was booting us I was testing 20 minutes ago and so a solution to it it could be either a hardware that broke inside which looks something like this the floor wasn't digital having cider enclosure so it could be the hardware that Brookes which they already can fix it if you really want to data all of this I will make another video eventually to show you how to take it on and replace with disk and select on this inXile the pin hair or the motor but today's video is really just external enclosure on how do we treat the hard dry and once you retrieve the hard drive you can get better this is like a la Hache white duct just a set-up drive and get your data up that way so basically my guess is because whatever that's on the external enclosure I'm just it's from a capacitor or something broke over time due to heat or just it was designed to break so once you get a hot dry out if the hard way was not broken hopefully you can get the data out of foam like so no duct system foot hockey these are pretty cheap these are like 20 $30 you can get up on Amazon okay so in this case I already opened this like 20 minutes ago 10 minutes ago so I know this one works the hard drives I works and the clocking and the system on this external enclosure wasn't digital basically the external hard drive enclosure doesn't work I think that's a problem otherwise you will it's only wouldn't need me to get the hot rod out of the way okay so this video is basically showing you how to get it out how to get help well these are the school I was a kid on set here I didn't put it back as I figure I'm going to take your party anyway so to start this it's very simple there's actually no glue on this model is just me or any credit card um this is a gift card you skip toy so you do is um so you just pick up the corner and literally in the middle is best and just fly it up since there's no glue everything is seeing a click mechanism to see it get it to click and do that on all four sides shut up just click and just be patient um if you intend to put it back then you need to be more gentle um without damaging the plastic it's not the worst thing damage the plastic but so you fire it up and you do the both side harder to do this wise man imported go find a weak spot get the credit button there we go this is a good spot to start another do that um you do this between your like on your legs then it will help to stabilize the hardware this is slip over the place since I'm trying to record this can't do that now once you get the both side open you could just like sliders to the side is click you see and on the other side as well so we want to slow your protocol through it there we go Universal SS coin all right so you just open it like this way so why do you listen and you see this is a fire 2 gigabyte hard drive um this particular wasn't digital hard drive design doesn't have any schools to return the hardware some other ones there is like this one this is the older generation value okapi unfortunately first one the driving side is the drive that's bad so the data I couldn't recover but this drive is good then I find out I we don't have much data one on his oh and that is formatted to but I said I thought that is I get a free hard way out of it otherwise so basically um there are those four legs and it just come right off of me and there was one like geese coos 1 2 3 4 inside one screws inside a closure now you want to get more of them out the leave one end otherwise the hydro floral anyone get this heatsink shield out of the case just at least two screws up and then you slide it as you can see hard drive the piping is here something here so you slide it upward Jewish pictures yeah decided upward and then take the whole piece off this is this is it this is the board us in control of everything and this is the POTUS broken I'm guessing it's probably one of the cat so those burgers everything else is stuff a small acid song I don't know anything else could go bad because it did receive power and it's just willing to receive signals I'm guessing it's probably capacitors that's the only weak link I can see on the boy everything else surface mom so it's hard to tell with our microscope and testing it doesn't matter is the spice cheap arm you know I mean you just you get a solo and hard drives all right throws out your soldering practice within any take all the screws out remember I told you the one school I was hiding here um and honest I don't know most manufacturers like to be psychic drive that way very hard to take apart there's always one school Heidi the general concept is pretty much the same take over the school down in East Regency take it up if you can't move any certain part it just means that there was a school hiding something on there plastic on top now in this case is under a heat sink and um this other metal shield board so it's just hiding somewhere um after that you can take anything basically simple concept take old school okay so this is the hard drive that's it once you retrieve a hard drive like I say you can get like so no dot connector don't think and plug it to USB to your computer and you plug in the power and you turned out the power go with enriched I'm just get here and where you turn on the power and then the blinks Drive swings and I pick up data and everything's get our miss yep so once you done so that's my computer making a sound is detecting this ha joints off alright so once you don't you got yourself a free well you savage yourselfer hard drive and more importantly are your personal information all of you need to recover from your artwork I wouldn't put anything back with this because the thing I was broken but in the event that if your hard drive that broke because you plug in nothing works you can keep this and plug in another hard drive I say for my Simpson or whatever or you could plug it in to another hard drive and you got yourself a free external board it's just in your plug in power and USB then you can retrieve the data form this other drive even though this one's broken and if you still want to retrieve the data of a broken drive for example this one this is also wasn't digitized all the generation which came out of this enclosure um this right now is just piece of plastic I'm intending to put stuff in there is a nice hiding place for valuable bits on the bookshelf why should I should I should punish him for my stuff desire I'll join that's also a good idea you know you can open this and then hollow it out and put your money inside and close it it's a good place to hide your money anyway um so yeah so this case the dry is bad mixing the clicking noise so the boy that's inside this external enclosure is good I could keep that and use all my other out drives however this hard drive if I really want to get that information now what I could do is like a buying an exact same replica of the hard drive and then very carefully change I'm guessing the pain is probably broken in this one because it's making the clicking noise so they change the pin I can change the motor and I can also change the circuit board um I think it's either one of those that's broken services the data this it's usually still good always but it is I'll make another video but wanna leave okay thank you for watching so this is how you savage hard drive out of Boston Digital external enclosure that goes a low surface yeah unfortunately it doesn't jump down if you want to see what's on the board this is actually a newer newer design the old is it designed akimbo of the other enclosure looks like this as you can see the ball I don't bother to take it out it's inside here it looks with all the parts like bigger other parts it has I accelerate board and the older generation has a funny IDE cable for power and unusual it's very unusual to have a IDE power cable and SATA data connector so this hard drive which is the bad one the drive is bad it's really weird because it was designed with SATA data connected and set a power connected however has an IDE like axillary power conductor for just for this design I guess this hard I came out about same time heís doing a switch between IDE and setup and wasn't digital already make this board so they they figure they could just make a hot dogger I can be powered by I don't know I don't know what the story was but that's what dehydrators I thought this like a what a long time go forward 2005 like when I said I cable for skim milk okay and that's it I got my hot dry I'm happy I have an extra 5 gigabyte hard drive and guess how the file I want from it not a lot I think most high a16 like year not this hard rice is only I have two external external hard drives and I have something which I want to get out of it but I can't I think I hear doubt and I need to magically magically recovered it data from this thank you for watching have a nice day | CyberDoc LLC | UC8FB4X8sli0XSWgg9jQ14yw | 2013-12-25 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,832 | 9,152 |
RrHpkDbrZsY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrHpkDbrZsY | Charlotte Lawrence Confirms She's Dating Charlie Puth I Charlie and Charlotte Romantic Relation | [Music] the upcoming musician and model Charlotte Lawrence stole attention hit maker Charlie pre-start and she has our attention now [Music] leaving fans heartbroken Charlie confirmed their romance on the day of love the 14th of February 2019 he heads to ground a photo with his ladylove Charlotte and wished everyone a Happy Valentines though the picture was blurry the way he wrapped his girlfriend confirmed every doubt Charlotte age 18 and Charlie puth smart dating rumors when they attended New York Fashion Week earlier this month the couple fueled the fire when they sat front row at coaches men's and women's fall 2019 runway show on the 12th of February 2019 although the spotlight is on Charlotte now she is not new to the show burrs born to her actress mom Christa Miller known for comedies like scrubs created by her father Bill Lawrence she runs along with the Hollywood her famous friends include supermodel Kaia Gerber and daughter of Cynthia Rowley Katina the model although signed to IMG Models spends her time in another creative field she officially released her music more than three years ago her song featuring Charlotte titled falling skies was added to the soundtrack of 13 reasons why she released her six tracks EP titled young and announced her titled reckless that starts on the 27th of February 2019 coincidentally her music genre is pop music like her beau Charlie puth maybe it was their mutual love for music which brought them together who knows the beauty of height five feet ten point five inches went to Marymount High School where she won athletic honors while completing her education with her parents constant support she is focused for her 2019 concert that sold out across North America [Music] | CelebsBuzz | UCeXi34holWkWldNhdnjNXKA | 2019-02-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 294 | 1,735 |
9skvcoK6lAg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9skvcoK6lAg | Junk Journal With Me (Illustrating Bible from Dayspring) - 12/6/2018 | hi-yah welcome back to my Channel today I'm going to be doing a journal with me entry in my personal journal and so I'm gonna be journaling about I ordered the nude a spring illustrating Bible and so I wanted to document that in my journal and it came with a little thank-you card from the person who packaged everything up so I was going to use this envelope my receipt and I just kind of put some note post-it notes on my address so that information won't be in this video and I got a little die cut piece here and it's from one of my Illustrated faiths little six so let's go ahead and get started so I'm going to glue this envelope down but I don't know if and I'm gonna make like a little packet to kind of slip the card and so I'm gonna trim that off a little bit so I kind of get that right there let me make sure I'm at frame okay and so I'm going to glue this down with my tape liner over here and so just put some glue around the edges of my envelope like that and position it like that so and that way this cart can just see if I can give ya slip down in there like that so the card will still be in there and the envelope just serves as a tuck spot so I have some washi tape here that kind of goes with the card and a little sticker that I chose so I'm gonna put a little bit of that on here and I'm not going to use this entire receipt I'm going to cut around it and this just says Dayspring live your faith so I'm gonna just cut around that image and glue it onto the page [Music] so like that I'm going to use that and then maybe cut out what I ordered which was the illustrating Bible and use this maybe somewhere in my entry so even this up just maybe even may put that on there I don't know let me see I have a little ticket here then I'm also going to put it down it has my address on it so I have a little sticky on it but I'm gonna put my die cut piece maybe up there put some tape on it maybe have some washi tape coming from under it try to get it straight here like this and then put my die cut piece coming from it like that okay and just thinking about whether or not I wanted to maybe put it right there maybe put a journal a little bit not a lot basically saying that I ordered this Bible and what am i thoughts about it so far that kind of thing so put that right there and [Music] maybe I'll just cut this down just a little bit more probably not even having to put that whole thing on there trying to see exactly where I wanted [Music] I'm not even really sure I think I'm gonna put it on the corner of this envelope maybe right there is fine put it right there a little bit more glue on here make sure it's down and I'm gonna do my journaling and I'll be right back to show you guys the final look okay guys this is what my final page looks like I did my journaling up there I added my date added a little piece of that envelope up here another little strip of washi tape and another die-cut image on the bottom and so that's the completed entry it's simple cute and quick so thank you guys for watching if you're not a subscriber to my channel go ahead and hit the subscribe button if you also want to receive notifications when I upload new videos go ahead and hit the notification bail thank you guys so much for watching I appreciate you and I look forward to seeing you guys in my next video bye | TamsJournals | UCbBWiMney74qey1_C4b8mlA | 2018-12-06 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 685 | 3,332 |
xRIzVH31dK8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRIzVH31dK8 | My First Ride & Reactions to Dare Devil Dive Flying Machines at Six Flags Fiesta Texas Vlog 11/14/20 | that was insane i'm back yeah hey yo what is up thrill seekers today i am back here at 650 texas again for one main goal i am here to ride daredevil dive flying machines it is supposed to be in technical rehearsal today um which means that we might get to write it today which is going to be awesome also michaela is going to be here as always and also zach i believe is also going to be here so i'll be meeting up with them relatively soon whenever they get here um but for now let's get first ride of the day on iron rattler yeah here we go i'm too lazy to sprint today so i'm just gonna i'm just gonna be a granny and like power walk you know by the way next week um i will say yeah next week i will not be here um i am going to spin a wheel and it's going to is basically gonna be a decide my day video where i'll put uh kind of i guess technically four parts into a wheel um six legs over texas seaworld san antonio and then the houston parks which is kima boardwalk and galveston here if i end up getting that then i'll just do both in one day but um i'll be putting those in a wheel and the wheel will decide where i go it'll also decide like stuff throughout the day like what ride i should ride next or um where i should eat um when should i leave one park to go to the next if i go to team aboard walking galveston pier stuff like that so yeah look out for that coming i guess next week anyways for now going up for iron rattler there you go i just got first ride of the day on iron rattler um i'm actually going to go back and get a second ride just because one the line is super short right now and two i got like car four that time so i'm gonna see if i can get the back row um but anyways uh while on the ride we saw uh we saw daredevil dive testing so they are definitely getting ready for the technical rehearsal today here you go back row time let's do it all right sweet so i don't know if i can show it from here but there are two people on the ride um i'm assuming there's just two supervisors that are riding here double dive which is a very good sign because that means that hopefully very soon they will be opening it by the way there's no one here today this is awesome like iron rattler still doesn't have a weight like look at this there's like the weight doesn't even go down it's awesome oh my god guys they're letting people in no yes yo yes yes i'm gonna be able to ride this thing i am so excited oh my god i'm so excited let's do it yes oh i'm so excited oh my god let's do this thing yes [Music] here we are daredevil dive here's a look at the queue line during the day because last time i was here it was at night [Music] no way you can't you can't even you don't even know how how excited i am right now this is gonna be awesome [Music] wow got to say they did not have the sound effects on last time oh man i'm so excited let's do it so excited oh my god yes we have jeffrey right here i'm so excited for this the first riders of the day on daredevil dive right here also question of the day today this or a joker yeah because either this or joker or is going to be the best flat ride in the park so we'll just see which one that is yeah so excited yeah i'm gonna get a wide shot of the whole thing so i do really like how the music syncs up because the music definitely does sync up with the ride like it starts out super chill as they're starting to spin and then immediately once the first car starts going up it it picks up and it's super cool anyways here we are about to ride a dare devil dive let's do it i do have to say i am 100 coming back over here tonight because this ride is amazing at night there's so many cool lighting effects there's fire up here which you can barely see during the day but it's so bright and vibrant and awesome at night so that is definitely something that i'm going to be coming back to tonight to get a night ride oh yeah you know i do have to say a huge thing that i am wondering is how long are they going to keep the fire now i do remember from last time that six and three are special one of them is the fastest in terms of spinning and one of them is the slowest now i do not completely remember which um but i'll try to i'll try to get in on one of them i'm running double dive and it's all clear let's go what's up maintenance guy oh let's go here go this is so exciting i'm so excited for this and going up oh my god this is so cool whoa my god yo what the yeah i think three is the slow one oh actually i don't know whoa oh don't even know what to look at oh nope this is definitely fast oh my god oh man whoa i'm just chilling upside down for a bit okay then oh man the ride cycle is coming to an end though the music is slowing down which means that we are going down i think i'm gonna stall nope and there you go wow that was such an interesting ride experience that was really fun though okay that was awesome i just got off of my first ever ride on daredevil dive one of actually yeah the third on the third public ride on daredevil dive that is insane that was actually really fun now major question is it better than joker i'm going to say no the reason why is i really like the air time that you get on joker um it just feels amazing um versus this is definitely all about the hang time and the whippiness now if you like whippy inversions you like being upside down for five to ten seconds at a time then this definitely will be for you um daredevil dive is awesome i'm so excited to come back and try to ride it at night because the night effects on daredevil dive are amazing so definitely going to be coming back i'm actually going to stay here get some shots of daredevil dive for you guys um so that i can make like maybe a review video of it whoa um anyways wow that was awesome [Music] thank you alrighty we are going for round number two now it is very loud in here so i mean i'm i'm talking right now when the noise had just stopped so if you're sensitive to loud noises this queue line may not be for you um but yeah the queue line is really nice though makayla is just around this corner but of course we cannot see her because she's she's somewhere over there anyways she'll be joining us for this next ride [Music] hi michaela what's up all right well they're experiencing a temporary delay so we are going to go over to iron rattler hey um we'll definitely come back though because michaela needs to get on this thing um but yeah let's go on over oh snap log section section so is that a vlog yes oh my goodness whoa that's insane i run ratchet that's everybody okay hey let's do it and it's back open hey but still super excited to do iron rattler for sure yeah here we go hey let's do it [Music] michaela's first ride on daredevil dive are you excited yes oh my god there's a sport we need to get some more we're going to get s'mores today for sure all right let's do it alrighty awesome so we have the inside scoop from jeffrey himself he said that he is going to try to uh run the fire forever um they have them hooked up to propane tanks so the plan is is to never shut the fire off so it's not going to just be a opening year thing it's not just going to be a freight fest thing it's going to be all day every day for the rest of this ride's life or at least as long as he's here um he's going to try to run the fire if the the fire is going to stay so that's awesome very happy about that because the fire is such an awesome touch to this already super awesome ride so we just figured out that unexpectedly smoke comes out of these vents that's super cool um and now now it's yeah it feels like hollow fest right now [Music] all right so i totally noticed this first but the inventor right here it's a word scramble of the name jeffrey seibert that's insane look at me that's so good that's actually really okay the witness has to be something too yeah what's the witness what do you guys think the witnesses can you can you let me know in the comments yeah i was gonna say comment below who's the witness michaela are you ready all right definitely determined number three is fastest number six is kind of slower the view by the way oh going on car 3 yo that was that was insane all right so that was crazy first of all we got car three we got car three that was insane we were upside down for ten seconds we literally just counted out loud like one two three we were up there for 10 seconds straight completely upside down that was insane you guys say it's better than joker 100 100 oh my god i'm literally shaking i'm little that i do not know if i like this or joker more so we're gonna go over and ride jokers so that i can compare the two directly joker at the moment is closed that is very unfortunate by the way stay tuned like watch the whole video because at some point today i'm going to be getting a night ride on daredevil dive which is completely different all of the effects are insane there's fire i mean obviously the fire plays all the time but you can really see it at night and i'm really excited to get that night ride anyways yeah wonder woman oh there it goes alrighty here we are the line doesn't seem terrible i don't know i the yeah i don't know hey just a little coaster nerd thing this piston right here pops up to hook onto the back of the train to stop it completely and to keep it from moving forward because there's brakes brakes brakes in the station but that is its last little thing so it slows it down really a lot hey you know what this is payback from last time because you got like your best ride last time you got like your best ride last time and i got one of my worst rides but this time it's the opposite so there you go i hated that so much i got one of my best rides that was really good i got a lot of like floater air time uh that was great honestly uh a decent amount of this vlog is just going to be daredevil dive so i'm kind of just going to put the vlog away a little bit unless something funny happens then i'll of course vlog it but uh but yeah until until their devil dive night rides i'll see you guys peace yo forgot to say go follow my instagram because i like do a lot of updates with um on my story of like you know just the rest of my day so obviously i'm not vlogging the rest of my day but i will be posting a lot of stuff on my instagram story we also got some pictures with daredevil dive jeffrey siebert himself took some pictures so um those are also on my instagram basically just go follow my instagram right here at theme park update yt oh he got popcorn see you see you guys are insane alrighty see you tonight though and here we are dare a devil dive we're gonna get a night ride on this this is gonna be super super awesome uh olive oil there they are perfect timing right there and more fire come on there it is yeah there's one more oh they don't have all of them lit i'll be back they're not all lit but that's so good awesome i'm excited to do this with all of the fire effects and all of the lighting effects and all of that kind of stuff that they have on here that's gonna make it even better than it already is i'm excited let's do it here's a night cycle rip that one and that one and that one unfortunately it went down which is very unfortunate but oh well hopefully it'll come back up [Music] i think it will i don't know man and it's back up let's go it seemed like uh since these restraints are automatic they come down automatically um if you try to tug down on the restraint it will mess it up so what they tried to try to do is pull out because there's a little knob on the side that that locks and unlocks the restraints basically if the knob is pushed in and is locked pushed out it's unlocked um and they just have to try to manually pull it out please they go like that there you go so if you if you try to pull them down it will mess up the ride and that's exactly what happened but now we are back i'm excited and there you go just got a night ride here on daredevil dive that was really really fun now we did get a ride on car one i do have to say three is better than one i love three i think three is maybe the best i haven't done six i've heard a lot of good things about six but compared to one three is definitely better yeah it hangs you yeah it hangs you upside down a lot longer um one doesn't hang you down upside down for as long and it kind of just is dizzying because it kind of just is consistently doing this there's not many there's not much variety on one versus three it kind of hangs you upside down and then goes really fast and then you know kind of does some different things um but anyways it was really cool to see all of the effects in motion um we were upside down and right next to some of the fire blasts um and that was super cool to see um so i honestly am gonna say that that is better than joker yeah because just because of all of the theming and the effects it's so much it's super cool to look at it's super cool to um to ride overall it's just such an awesome ride um but yeah that's gonna pretty much just be my day here at six flags fiesta texas i ended up riding daredevil dive three times which i'm super happy with two day rides in car three and two are in one night ride in car one um yeah good good times anyways i will see you guys all next time where i will be doing a decide my day video so i am not coming back here i'm going to some other park anyways yeah until then peace out [Music] you | Theme Park Update | UC_NxVT75lcBEX3Q_lpgARHQ | 2020-11-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,746 | 13,447 |
XPElTghJUdw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPElTghJUdw | Part 12 Mercedes W124 Cold Start, Cluster Refurbishment, Interior Cleanup, LF Mirror Lubrication | foreign [Music] foreign [Music] guys and here's our refurbished cluster I had it all apart cleaned it up hand and needles I cleaned as much as possible to the best of my ability and I really love the way it looks right now and I'm also going to change these two main bulbs because I have these beautiful LED bulbs right here that I bought they were like I think twenty dollars but uh I bought them and I want to replace them with the regular halogen bulbs and I think these ones are going to be looking really nice because I have them on my 190e and they look just amazing so I'm gonna use these bulbs here's how they look like and I'm simply just gonna go ahead and untwist these ones original they're kind of tired too they're a little discolored but I'm gonna have to change them to those and there I promise you they're gonna look amazing here it is just ready to install it having a bit of difficulty right there because of that melted plastic well unfortunately these led ones are a little too fat for this housing right there even on this side where the plastic is not melted it's just just won't fit sadly so uh I have brand new ones right here in the regular halogen ones that I'm gonna be replacing those with as long as I replace them I really wanted to replace them to make sure that you know they will never go out so we're just gonna have to install the regular ones halogen ones because I don't have any thinner ones like this so it's a bulb goes right in same with this we're gonna put a little bit of Grease into this part right here where the speedometer cable goes to as you can see these grooves and these right here they go into those grooves so you have to peel them out and it's it's a pain but here it is it's gonna be fixing this thing up it's it's super ugly so what I learned is you can start peeling from the bottom and just kind of move all the way up use plastic tools to kind of help you pry it out from the groove so I took off both sides and now this thing is out perfect I can replace this uh rope right here for the pocket all right I'm slowly putting everything back here as you can see all right clusters in almost all the way but this is all back together panel and everything this is all looped up right here the Channel all these pivot uh joints all right everything is ready lubricated uh and I'm ready to put this film back together and install the door panel it was pretty quick and now I'm lubricating the pie this manual mirror on the side right here it was moving pretty rough so also cleaned up a bunch of dust here too nice and easy changing the bulbs and the climate control these are old ones right there just gotta improvise all right both bulbs are in there one and two it was a little bit of a pain to install decided not to take this whole thing apart because on the 124s it's a little different gotta take a lot of stuff apart but there's also these uh stickers right here you put them back your driver's seat is out I'm ready to clean everything here make it amazing here's the seat I have to really clean it all right and clean all this garbage off of all these rails crazy super dirty here so it's gonna be quite a bit of work to do first I'm gonna sweep all of this off vacuum a little and then I'm gonna get to scrubbing all this really good with shampoo foreign I'm also going to take this uh bottom piece off because I have to fix it I mean this um pillar trim is not in the best shape but I'm going to clean it really nice and I have to just tuck this portion inside of that whoever was here didn't know what they were doing unfortunately I'm just gonna take this off and in the meantime we'll clean it I'll clean this uh little plastic panel too the panel pretty dirty so we'll clean that and then I got some more cleanup to do over here a little bit mainly is this vinyl right here use this pad and clean it amazing look how dirty this is that's crazy I just literally have to take your time clean this amazingly make it awesome using shampoo and just a upholstery cleaner and I'm starting to clean all this nicely it's oh man it's so neglected it's horrible but it's slowly cleaning up foreign all right so the carpet is all cleaned up here I mean it's not the best but it's a hundred times better than it used to be also took off this trim I'm gonna be cleaning that and to just so you know this piece right here the plastic I don't know I think it's supposed to be like that but if it's broken I didn't do it I think it's supposed to be like that though so I'm going to clean it all up also going to clean this area a little bit more then I'm going to put grease here and install the trim back and I'm putting grease just to preserve it from any possible rust and whatnot and rear seat will be getting removed as well at some point all right so everything is getting cleaned up at the moment everywhere all these pieces oh I almost slipped you saw that move but uh yeah this piece this piece was all shampooed not all of these as well gonna get dry and now I'm working on this seat | VITO'S GARAGE | UCHuBqncnrIPrOqVdhRhXwow | 2022-12-24 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 999 | 5,049 |
jOWAdoL8rdU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jOWAdoL8rdU | Revisiting Old IFB Hobby Horses - Part 7: Drinking Intoxicating Beverages (KJV Baptist Preaching) | all right continuing with this series on revisiting uh old baptist hobby horses and one thing uh i last week i was going to include both smoking and drinking together and i figured i it was just too much to say particularly on drinking from the bible and so i divided them up into two lessons so tonight the message is and i ordered it this way on purpose but drinking intoxicating beverages all right drinking intoxicating beverages is the idea you say what do you mean old preachers hobby horse well depending on how many years back you go there was a time when this was the main thing that was preached from almost every baptist pulpit and uh and so this was the case i was saved when i was about eight years old and from that point on i always went to independent fundamental baptist uh churches my dad was in the military so we moved a lot but we always found a good church to go to and for many years after i was saved i assumed that every christian just taught that drinking alcohol was bad don't drink alcohol it partly was because when my dad got saved shortly after probably the same year that i got saved my dad got saved and what i remember as a kid is that he was a drinker pretty heavy drinker i don't remember him being like abusive or anything like you talk about like some parents i mean some kids talk about their parents that drink or whatever their abuse i don't remember my dad doing that i do remember him seeing him drunk i do remember him drinking a lot but he uh once he got saved he decided you know what christians don't drink and so i need to stop drinking this was the way i interpreted as a little kid and he poured all his alcohol down the drain he didn't want to just like give it to somebody else or you know anything like that and so he dumped it all out and threw it all away and in my from that day forward it was just like all christians for for many years anyway all christians think drinking alcohol is bad all right so uh as i continued uh to grow up i mean you know somebody would say something about drinking maybe we'd go to a restaurant and somebody say hey would you like to look at the wine menu and my family always said no no we don't drink we're christians now you guys already probably know that does the you know what world are you living in lots of christians drink right but this is the way i grew up thinking hey we don't drink because we're christian all right i thought that this is what every christian believed uh i heard stories about billy sunday now billy sunday wasn't a baptist i'm pretty sure he was presbyterian if i remember right and uh and a lot of the guys that spearheaded some of the things in his day were actually reform reformers you know and and uh but at that time they were uh teaching really heavily on what's called the temperance movement okay the temperance movement was teaching on uh abstaining from alcohol right that's where we got the word uh t total t totaler you know when i was a kid i always thought when someone said are you a teetotaler well i say kid i was i didn't hear that word until i was in my teen are you a tea totaler and i thought they meant you drink tea that's what t you know you're a tea totaler i didn't even know what total what they meant by total but t no after i researched that a little bit it's it's real simple uh you're you believe in total abstination abstinence when it comes to drinking i don't drink at all that's what they mean in the tea there's different theories on why they came with the t totaler uh but but some people say it was just t like saying like with a capital t you know emphasis on on the the fact that i'm a totaler i'm a tea totaler you know what i mean some there's different theories one person said the guy that coined that phrase uh you know was a he stuttered and so he said to to totally you know i don't know i don't you know how legends get get told but this all came from the uh temperance movement in the late 1800s and the early 1900s uh so i mean you know think about that time period you know when is the when is the typical period we think about the wild west isn't that the 1800s like the mid mid 1800s kind of getting out of getting out of it uh anyway so you think about that time there was a group in 1873 known as the anti-saloon league and this was part of the temperance movement hey we need to get these saloons shut down and then uh in 19 let's see 1906 no that one was in 1906. the christian women's temperance union was in the 1800s christian christian women temperance and so the idea was if you study study that these women were saying hey we're tired of our men getting drunk and doing this and that and losing all their money gambling and beating on their wives and all this stuff and so they started like saying we need to get these saloons shut down we need to get people to stop drinking and so uh ultimately that and the rise of many hard preachers and probably one of the most notorious like i said was billy sunday uh you know led to what's known as the prohibition movement or the 18th amendment where they actually wrote into the law that you could not sell i think it was a long process but they said you could not sell or trade or or whatever uh alcohol of any kind i guess for drink you know for just uh drinking purposes and so uh growing up you know depending on what you think about this and this is actually here recently uh uh brother justin and i were talking about the libertarian party and what the beliefs are and then my wife and i the other day had a long discussion on the on a drive in the car we were going somewhere and try to discuss some of these matters on on was it right or was it wrong to uh you know to put laws and restrictions on that and then you compare it to other laws and restrictions throughout history and that's a whole other topic for another day but really you start thinking about uh uh some of these things and and you know how did the how did these certain laws come into place and these restrictions on different things but there was literally against the law to drink alcohol and people in a generation today i'm sure they can't imagine that even being a a possibility and sometimes you watch a movie or show or something from like black and white you know from long ago and they're talking about that like there's bootleggers bootleggers making alcohol in their basement or something like that and you're like why were they doing that because it was against the law and i remember the first time i figured that out i thought that was kind of that was kind of strange because to me there was drinking everywhere everybody was allowed to do it but the baptist preachers always preached against it in fact i remember people talking about billy sunday and glorifying him because he would come and see i i love baseball and so he was an ex-baseball player and so that as a little kid thinking hey i want to be a preacher i want to be a baseball player all these kind of things billy sunday i thought man what a great guy and the story was told about how he would come up here and he would find a bottle of alcohol or something like that at some point in his preaching ministry maybe before prohibition i don't know how he got his alcohol but he would set it up on the pulpit and he'd be preaching and everybody's watching that the whole time and then he got this baseball bat and he'd crush it while he's preaching really hard against it and everybody be like yeah i mean that's where some of that that kind of preaching came from those days you know and so there was a lot of preaching against that and that that helped to lead to this point where they said we need to rise up and make you know anytime uh uh you you got a group of folks in our society who is really noisy really loud really wants things to change they're the ones that kind of get their way and actually you know what that's called is the progressive movement all right we got to have progress and that's what this group was actually known of in that time so today that would be like the guys who uh hey we got to worry about climate change and we got to do this and we got to put these restrictions on the carbon footprint and we gotta and all these this progressive movement a long time ago that was actually thought of as the progressive movement that was trying to fight against alcohol because they realized how bad it was for society and we need to reform society and all that so anyway that led to in my mind hearing all this preaching thinking prohibition was the great thing you know that we needed to get back to or something like that and i won't get into the problems that caused and everything but uh but i remember as a kid this was just preaching i heard all the time and it wasn't until i was quite a bit older i couldn't really tell you how old but i i want to say at least upper teens before i actually started being in circles of christians who were saying it's okay to drink you just can't get drunk but i remember even even watching the movie or something like that and there was like a catholic priest who was drinking and i remember thinking that was a joke like no in my mind even then i was thinking like i was thinking he's a he's claiming to be a christian but he's drinking little did i know they get do you know okay i was studying on this one time because uh anyway i was studying on this the the wine that they serve at communion at a catholic mass or whatever the whole thing has to be drunk they can't like you know put it back in the fridge you know because that's jesus that's jesus's blood to them that whole thing needs to be drunk so if they if after everybody has you look it up man i'm not making this after everybody in the auditorium has drunk their wine alcoholic wine right somebody has to finish up the rest of that alcohol and i've heard stories about people that would they would drink that and they would get drunk and oftentimes if they didn't do it the altar or the or the priest themselves or somebody would drink that negative and that's why there's so many stories about these priests that were just absolute drunks because that actually happened a whole lot a lot of priests became drunks i don't know how prevalent it is in today's society but i would assume a lot of priests get drunk because they're okay with it in fact they're okay with just social drinking with your buds and sit down in the bar and have a drink and whatever and you're still a christian no big deal and this was a foreign thinking to me i had never heard of such a thing blew my mind and then i found out that's true then i found out uh it's not just catholics but reformed people reform you know reform theology and all presbyterians uh lutheran i mean i don't know what all groups are against it i don't guess any of them and they're fine with sitting down drinking they said oh it's only wrong to get drunk it's not wrong to drink and i'm thinking that's a i've never drunk but i don't know how how do you know when you cross that line and so i that blew my mind i didn't understand then i found out there were baptist reformed baptists who kind of just jumped on board hey they did it well that's why not smoke cigars and drink alcohol like the rest of them and uh and so i remember thinking oh how come nobody's preaching on this anymore and they're still independent fundamental baptists that preach hard against alcohol but i remember thinking like whoa i i just thought everybody did you know so obviously when i grow up your beliefs have to become your own you can't just go off what you know you've been taught all your life and i had to think through some things and sure enough people would point certain things from the bible to me and say look there you go the bible doesn't say there's anything in fact there's a lot of evidence that it's good to drink or something like that these are the kind of things that people told me here are a few examples here's one that i heard a lot doesn't the bible say all things in moderation you know the answer to that is no it doesn't say that in fact it gets to me like i'm thinking like whatsoever your hand's fine to do do it with all thy might you know whatsoever you do whether you eat drink or do all unto the lord and i'm thinking i wonder how many people claim that and say like man i'm gonna drink for the lord with all my might and i'm gonna i i guarantee you they're people that try to use that in that way but when it says all things in moderation that somebody just made that up now let your moderation be known oh man yeah the idea is being temperant and controlling yourself and uh and all but it's not just saying hey you can do whatever you want just do it in moderation is it okay to steal in moderation is it okay to kill in moderation is it okay to do anything else in moderation no but you can drink just in moderation just don't get drunk right that argument that's made here's another thing that often say you've all heard this but i've i've had people laugh at me for for saying that jesus didn't turn water into alcoholic wine laugh at me ridicule me oh what did he turn into welch's grape juice yeah he turned it into grape juice guess what they used to take grapes and they would step on them and squish them until it became grape juice they it wine look it up in the bible i mean many times he talks about the grapes of wrath and it's talking about the wine of his wrath and and i don't have to to prove it really i think it's common sense you could even look it up in the dictionary and wine just means kind of like the liquor of the grape in liquors not alcoholic liquor just meaning the the fluid my uh my my wife's granddad was a missionary in mexico el salvador and that part of the world and i remember that he would come back sometimes and there were certain things his wife would always make and something that he loved was when he would when we would eat green beans he would be oh i love that bean licker and i remember the first time i heard him say that i was kind of like what's he talking about he's talking about bean liquor what he talked about is after you eat the green beans what's left is the juice he says that's the bean liquor that's the right way to use that word actually it's not alcoholic at all we just know it we just have turned that word into uh to alcoholics so i mean i wouldn't go around saying i'm drinking liquor okay i wouldn't go around saying i'm drinking a glass of wine i would say grape juice but historically it's it just means the juice all right now is the bible ever talk about wine where people are getting drunk of course it does i'm going to share some verses on that in a minute uh and i'm going to i'm probably not going to labor on these examples right now i might come back to some of them but here shouldn't know it doesn't say that jesus potter into wine yeah but yes i don't believe that's alcoholic one and i'll show and i'll try to explain that here in a little bit well didn't jesus drink wine didn't he drink with the publicans and the sinners you remember he said he said hey john the baptist came and he he didn't eat or drink and you guys all said he had a devil he said but the son of man comes eating and drinking and you say uh you know he's a wine bibber and a glutton and so they say there he sat down he was drinking alcohol so they said oh look he's a wine bird no it's just that's not what he's talking about john the baptist was literally eating locust and honey and they said there's something wrong with that guy jesus was actually sitting down eating good food and and uh uh not being liquor but juice and stuff like that good drinks and stuff and they just saw him and maybe some accuse him of drinking alcoholic wine i don't know but that doesn't necessarily mean just because they called him oh you drunk you glutton and wine bibber hey gluttony gluttony is let me see drunkenness is to whine as gluttony is to food does that make sense okay so you could get drunk off of hey viviana back there she gets drunk off of milk all the time she drinks until she's full of milk she's drunk drink drink drunk okay she's drunk so it doesn't mean necessarily that somebody you know is is drinking wine or they've drunken or anytime you read that in the bible you want to kind of read into that and be like oh they drunk till they were intoxicated not necessarily and there's a lot of arguments that are uh given about how they couldn't preserve fruit back then and it all fermented and turned the wine i get into all that right now though that's not my uh that's not my intention i just want to make some basic points why people preach against alcohol to what extent we should preach about alcohol or intoxicating beverages i should say and just kind of visit this idea not the first reason i think it's fair we need to revisit this idea okay so uh look at deuteronomy 14. here's another example that people will go to and say see there's nothing wrong with drinking the other one i didn't include here is when paul told timothy drink no longer water but a little wine for your belly and some people will take that say see it's okay wine is good for your belly so you should drink it look there's a lot of of things that can be read into the scripture there and the point that i want to make really is that i could take you to uh brother austin i was talking about this beginning of the service when we met here i think there's like at least 70 probably a whole lot more than that but at least 70 very clear scriptures about how bad drinking is well yeah some of them talk about alcohol i mean about being drunk but uh and so you could say no no that's only that's only drug it's not talking about drinking a little wine but the idea is that drinking any amount of wine you don't know where that cuts off and you could become drunken with intoxicating beverage which we know is wrong okay and so uh so 70 somewhat clear verses that say avoid it stay away from it don't do it it's unwise it's bad for you and then you've got about four verses that people go to and say well look that could be saying that it's okay to drink i'm gonna go with the 70 first of all okay and say the bible says don't do it i'm not going to do it okay but i want to explain this this one real quickly uh i i'll come back to it here in a moment but let's read it first uh deuteronomy 14 and verse 22. so it's talking about when they come to bring their tithe and look if you're tithing on your all your increase of your your fruits and vegetables and and all that kind of stuff your spices and all look you you've got a whole bunch of stuff that you've got to carry to the to the temple and so here is what he said starting verse 22 thou shalt truly tithe all the increase of thy seed that the field bringeth forth year by year and thou shalt eat before the lord thy god in the place which he shall choose to place his name there the tithe of the corn of the of thy wine of thy oil and of thy firstly uh firstlings of thy herd and of thy flocks that thou mayest learn to fear the lord thy god always so he's you know he tells you right there what the purpose of the tithe was why give a tie the tenth of of your increase it was that you might fear the lord and it's kind of reminding you that he's first and so they gave their first fruit verse 24 and if the way be too long for thee so that thou art not able to carry it or if the place be too far from thee which the lord thy god shall choose to set his name there when the lord thy god hath blessed thee then shalt thou turn it into money and bind up the money in thine hand and shall go unto the place which the lord thy god shall choose and thou shalt bestow that money for whatsoever thy soul lusteth after for oxen for sheep or for wine or for strong drink or for whatever thy soul desireth and thou shalt eat there before the lord thy god and thou shalt rejoice thou and thy house household and so there they go they say that he tells you take that money and turn it into wine and you say oh no that's not alcohol at one they say well this is and strong drake right now i don't see that where it's necessary to go back to the hebrew and what does that word mean in the hebrew and all look i think there's a lot of places in the bible where it says wine there's a lot of places where it says strong drink we know sometimes not is not talked about as a bad thing and sometimes it's talk is talked about as a bad thing and so we have to look at the context and we got to find out what it's meaning and all that and so there's a whole lot they can say about that you can say about that i've heard a lot of speculations you're probably waiting for me to give an answer uh to this okay so i've heard some people say well you know who knows that that wine and that strong drink was actually for eating or for consuming maybe it was for cooking with like the cooking wine or a strong drink maybe was just uh medicine i've heard people say or whatever i don't think it's medicine because it's talking about buying that and then eating it and so like i think it was something else i've heard some people say well it's just a really strong sweet drink maybe mixed with something else i have no idea really i mean the strong drink to me grapefruit juice is strong you ever trained you ever drink that stuff you know how about an energy drink that's strong right anyway but uh but it but you know what is that strong drink i don't know the bible's not specific on that all right but here's an intro going back that conversation that my wife and i had and then i had with brother justin as you go through the laws in the bible that god gave to mankind a lot of times it was left up to interpretation you know he didn't necessarily say this was right or this was wrong he just gave laws that if somebody did these certain things bad it needs to be judged all right now don't get ahead of me all right so for instance in that theory that what i'm thinking is he didn't necessarily say hey don't you have any wine don't do this he all he did is make a law that said if you get drunk you know that that's that's that's wrong okay if you said uh uh where was my mind going with that okay so uh so god did that with a lot of things you know you could you could look at uh some cases fornication say the same thing how about uh polygamy there are laws in deuteronomy that make it sound like hey polygamy is no big deal you can have more than one wife and today society and as christians we would we're appalled at that thought that anybody would do that and don't get me wrong it's wrong to have more than one wife and every time in the bible where we see examples of that there's bad repercussions and there's bad things that happen and you're not we're not supposed to do that but god when he made the laws and i haven't thought this through i'm sure i could probably think of some laws where he was very specific and everything but i'm just at the point of the sermon but what i'm saying is that uh you know just because he didn't say you know you can only consume beverages you know with this percentage of alcohol in it and no more no less or whatever that's not how he handled things all right so the fact that that word is in this description here it's not like this just license hey this one just go down you can go to the bar you can sit down there's lots of reasons why we wouldn't take that taste it's fine just just live like the world do however you want and drink whatever you want okay but i you know i've heard a lot of speculations and maybe some are going through your mind about what that strong drink is talking about it's not the point okay of the match here's some points that i want to make and and and here's why i shared that verse number one is this what is alcohol what is alcohol if you look it up it's going to say ethanol the only thing i know about ethanol is that it's it's in gasoline okay you know i think ethanol comes from typically we say it comes from corn i guess the stuff that is in your that is in the gas comes from corn or whatever but ethanol is the the compound you know that is created uh that we call it's a chemical and it's found in many places okay typically it comes from uh sugar that's fermented with yeast right and this is why for instance uh when a grape gets that kind of white stuff around it you've all had grapes and around it has a little bit of white stuff that's actually a type of natural yeast and grapes there that yeast uh works with that grapes those grapes and when those grapes begin to ferment uh they're in their in that yeast is with it and everything it would it would theoretically just turn into wine right there you wouldn't have to add anything to it it would just become uh wine whenever it fermented theoretically if that's that's what it's producing now they've got ways of doing it now where they you know change the process and add a little bit more alcoholic content to it and all that kind of stuff but basically that is what uh wine is and you talk about that fermenting process i can't help where we will read the passage here in a little bit but where the bible talks about it moveth itself or right i don't look on the wine when it's red it move with itself or right and i can't help but think that that's like this this fermenting process if you see the process of it whenever it begins to kind of move you know in that when it's fermenting it's saying hey don't even look get yourself into trouble okay now is alcohol in and of itself sinful is alcohol just some kind of thing that exists out in the world the answer that i would have to say is no alcoholics a lot of differences that we might consume if you ever drink what is the name i wrote it down because i always forget kombucha kombucha anybody ever had that drink kombucha i like it all right now it has some really crazy flavors and then and sometimes it'll uh uh it's hard to drink a lot of it that's for sure but it actually has an alcoholic contact content and so i have met some christians that won't touch it because they say it's got alcohol in it right but there's no way you could drink enough of that to become intoxicated because your stomach couldn't hold it right you couldn't stomach the amount of that that you'd have but it has a percentage of alcohol in it in fact much of our world has uh the much ingredients of food that we has a level of alcohol in it a lot of times you look on the ingredients and it'll say alcohol uh sugar sugar alcohol or whatever it tells you some kind of there's some kind of alcohol in it it's not enough to get anybody drunk but that's just a natural property that exists in in fact vanilla has alcohol so i looked at i looked that up i'm like well i don't ever get drunk eating vanilla ice cream or something no no it's not like that okay now i will say this while i was researching that i heard about a place where uh they had to monitor how much vanilla they sell because people kids were going in and buying like nine dollar bottle of vanilla and and drinking that so that they could get drunk and it's like do you know how disgusting that would be but the alcoholic content was pretty high i guess in that concentrated form but nobody uses that much vanilla but they were just like drinking this stuff and so they actually had to monitor the sale of uh of vanilla right but most grocery stores you can go and get it i'm not trying to give anybody any ideas but don't try it okay but you understand what i mean alcohol exists in the world and people can take too much alcohol and it can cause them to be intoxicated but most of the things that we would say hey that's got a little bit of alcoholic content it's not going to get it's not even a chance nobody would ever take that with the thought of getting drunk you know if i eat grapes that are a little bit old and they started the fermenting process like i haven't committed some kind of a sin right even if there is some kind of alcoholic content in it just you understand what i'm saying alcohol isn't bad in and of itself okay so that could be why like i said in deuteronomy 14 you know the fact that wine exists the fact that strong drink exists however it existed however they drank it in that form uh i've been told that even the alcohol that the drunkards like i'm talking about the guys that got intoxicated back then on this wine even that in those days was not nearly as alcoholic and content as it is today this is what i've been told because we found out new ways to make it worse okay and uh and so anyway but these did exist i'm not making a case about whether there was any alcoholic content in that whether timothy had any alcoholic content in what he was saying hey take a little wine for the belly i'm not trying to debate that i'm just trying to say uh that that alcohol even though it exists in the world in that and in and of itself it's not evil you could say the same thing for cannabis you could say the same thing for tobacco you can say the same thing look there's a lot of things in this world that exist that aren't inherently evil in and of themselves it's the way people use them and what they do with them okay and again we don't really know what the strong drink was uh that he's talking about there but that's not really super important what about this the effects alcohol on the humans that consume it okay now this is again not talking about kombucha or vanilla extract or whatever we're not talking about that we're talking about people that go and they buy wine and they buy beer and they buy uh vodka or anything like that from the store and they drink it because they like the entertainment value of it here is what i got off of wikipedia okay which is not a christian site i don't know who wrote this but you can look this up on any government site or whatever and get some of the same uh ideas okay this is just explaining alcohol it's not even trying to make a case about it being wrong or anything like that it's just explaining how clauses alcohol has a variety of short-term and long-term adverse effects short-term adverse effects include generalized impairment of neurocogno cognitive function dizziness nausea vomiting and hangover like symptoms i never have understood i'm glad so glad that the lord protected me so glad i didn't money what happened to it they blacked out uh what did i do i didn't even like being under anesthesia to be under anesthesia for medical things but i they would shoot the needle into my that's probably gone for many years they would just put that so i can feel that shot you know and if that wasn't enough they would shoot it again i put a shot into my gum man i didn't ever take any kind of uh uh you know and they'd fill the cavity they'd get that drill out i'd be crying i don't care i didn't like it right but i wouldn't take that you because i don't like the idea what am i going to say under the influence i think yes that's where somebody under the uh effects of the drugs are saying all kinds of ridiculous stuff i'm like no i want to be in somewhat control of what comes out of my mouth i'm already bad enough with control in as much control as i can with what comes out of my mouth all right and i don't understand that i don't understand wanting to have to throw up and act stupid and get in trouble and probably lose your job or something like that uh it can have a variety of long-term adverse effects on health for instance liver damage brain damage and its consumption is the fifth leading cause of cancer the adverse effects of alcohol and health are most important when it is used in excessive quantities or with heavy frequency which is often the case with people who end up going down that lifestyle and drinking they drink more and more and more and more frequently however some of them such as increased risk of certain cancers may occur even with a light or moderate alcohol consumption in high amounts alcohol may cause loss of consciousness or in severe cases death okay later on on the wikipedia article it says its use is also related to various soci societal problems including driving accidents and fatalities accidental injury injuries sexual assaults domestic abuse and violent crimes next time you see a police officer say how often are the calls that you get where you have to go to a house domestic violence or an injury or car wreck or whatever how often was alcohol involved they'll probably tell you most the time all right this is just one of the many causes of this so its effects on humans what we read about it let's go back to proverbs solomon was a wise man and of course this is inspired by god that's why it's in the bible but solomon was a wise man and he wrote on many things he had tried many things in this world and and he had sought them out and he had thought kind of like with a scientific mind on a lot of things and what he says right here in this chapter go down to verse 29 it says proverbs 23 verse 29 he says who hath woe who have sorrow everybody i know that has had a drinking problem they've gone through deep depressions maybe they've lost family and all this kind of stuff in the process and so they're just sorrowful you know i got a text from uh from somebody i don't know he might be watching this right now i got text some from somebody a long time ago and he was just just pouring out his his guts to me on this on this long message and it was a lot of personal stuff and he's having all these problems and the next day he sent me a message and he was like man i'm sorry i was so drunk last night i had too much to drink and i don't know why i texted you all that stuff okay and i remember thinking man just poor guy you know i know he's made those decisions and he'll tell you it's awful it messed my life up okay but he made those decisions and that therefore he goes through lots of cases of just depression just just secluded and depressed and thinking about all the negatives in this world well the bible tells you right there who have whoa who has sorrow who have contentions people getting bar fights they're just real aggressive and fighting because they have no control of what's coming out of their mouth because they're under the intoxication of the uh of the alcohol who have wounds without cause think about guys wake up in the morning from with a hangover and they're like what did i did i fall down the stairs what happened i got a you know bruises all over me broken arm or something like that what happened to me because they were under the influence and they didn't have any control over what's going on who hath red redness of eyes they that tarry long at the wine and they that go and sick and seek mixed wines look not vow upon the wine when it is red when it giveth its color in the cup when it moveth itself a right at the last it biteth like a serpent and stingeth like an adder that's another kind of a snake let me tell you like there are people that like snakes out there god help them they like snakes but if you were in a zoo or something like that and you saw these poisonous snakes if somebody said hey you want to stay away from that he'll bite you he could kill you wouldn't you be pretty stupid to just get as close to that thing as you can and be poking it and be like that coyote peterson on the universe like peterson uh he like allows himself to get stung by things and and all over he got a youtube channel anyway and uh and he does a lot of nature type stuff but he will like mess with these animals almost like waiting for it to bite him so that he can kind of show the effects of it by of the pain that you go through and all that kind of stuff and most people watch that and say he's stupid for doing that why would you want to keep poking at that snake poking and poking and poking it well i'm not getting too close i'm not getting too close all of a sudden that the last is going to bite and it's going to sting and it's going to hurt it's probably going to kill you and poison you okay thine eyes shall behold strange women and thy heart shall utter perverse things i don't even have to give any commentary on that isn't that pretty descriptive yea thou shalt be as he that lieth down in the midst of the sea whereas he that lieth on the top upon the top of a mast i've never been drunk so i don't know what it's like but i've watched people drunk and they're off balanced and they're swaying and they can't hardly stand up and it's a terrible sight it should be an embarrassment i'm embarrassed whenever i see it you kind of want to just like cover that person up and go take them you know get them off the streets and get them somewhere so that they're not embarrassing themselves and bears embarrassing society right they have stricken me shout out said they'll have they have stricken me shall i say and i was not sick they had beaten me and i felt it not when shall i awake i will seek it yet again isn't that how drunk is you know they wake up oh how terrible man i'm depressed i got a hangover i'm sick you know that was the worst night of my life i don't have any money left and when's the next party i mean it just becomes a whole life of this because this stupid substance that people have just given oh no no just a little bit won't hurt you well that's what every drunk out there has how they started right a little bit a little social drinking and no big deal but don't touch it stay away from it so the bible has a lot to say about this let me just read a couple of verses also in this chapter chapter 23 and verse 21 it says for the drunkard and the glutton shall come to poverty and drowsiness shall clothe the man with rags proverbs 20 verse 1 says wine is a mocker strong drink is raging and whosoever is deceived thereby is not wise i don't care who tries to convince me no no there's nothing in the bible that says it's wrong for me to have a sip of wine before i go to bed at night well i would say you are playing with a dangerous thing even if you can prove that to me even if your own conscience is clear whenever you do it you're playing a dangerous game because you can so easily get addicted to that and become an alcoholic i know a guy won't mention who it is who he is what his name is or anything like that but i know a guy that's going through a rough time in his life couldn't sleep at night and so he said you know i started to go get some nyquil maybe that'll help me sleep and apparently michael has a little bit of alcohol in it so he said and he was a preacher by the way and he said you know what if i'm gonna get nyquil and it has alcohol in it i might as well get a bottle of wine it's cheaper it tastes better and i'll just drink a tiny little bit of it it'll help me sleep at night and so that sounded like a reasonable thing for him so he did that and guess what after many years of being a pastor many years of giving that stuff up uh he did this and ended up falling right back into drinking right because he said well you know what instead of just knife oil i'll just go with with alcohol and with actually purchasing wine or whatever now you see how you can make the argument right like why is that any different than you know the other things that you can get in this life that are natural but they could uh they could cause them you know or or the argument here's an argument i make myself a lot of time well what the doctors prescribe to people you know or what they give you uh before uh like what's something they give you um uh whenever they're putting you in for a surgery or something sort of morphine you know give me morphine before surgery you know like how is that any different that's worse than alcohol well i granted you wouldn't go around just drinking morphine right and as a social drink okay i'll grant you that but people will say like there's not any worse than that yeah but but typically people don't become uh addicted to morphine unless as a continual use and then they just keep going back to the doctor and saying hey prescribe me some more or something like that but look it's the same thing a person gets a little taste for the alcohol alcoholic beverages and toxic kidney beverages they say wow i like that and they began taking it more and more i don't think vanilla extract is going to do that to you i don't think that uh kombucha is going to do that to you i don't think even nyquil is going to do that to you unless you've got a real serious problem but uh but but who i mean don't who wants to just go down that road uh that might lead to being a drunkard okay so what is actually sinful about it well i mean anything that can turn people into something that's very ungodly and very wicked like why would you want to even go that route i would think it is a sin if for no other reason just because the foolishness of of allowing yourself to go down that road and be tempted by that ephesians 5 18 says and be not drunk with wine wherein is excess but be filled with the spirit i can take you to many verses in the bible where it's saying hey you're supposed to be sober you're supposed to be of a sound mind you're not supposed to be under the influence of alcohol and again i know people are going to make the argument and say okay well you know it is possible to drink alcohol and not be like that yeah but if the goal is to be of a sober mind why put things into you that are going to possibly make you unsober and make you drunk intoxicated okay so it's a very unwise thing i i do believe it's sinful to go down that road now obviously it's there's there's you know you're trying to measure sins which sin is worse than another one look i preached on on the smoking last week and i and look now smoking i preached on why it was wrong and it does affect other people and all that kind of stuff uh but you know what i don't believe that smoking is in the same category of somebody who is actually a drunk all right the bible actually says in first corinthians 5 that a drunkard needs to be put out from the assembly so if somebody in the assembly somebody in our church was a drunk and especially if they walked in you could tell they're intoxicated look the bible says hey don't just entertain that person that person you don't know what they're gonna do uh you they're not of a sound mind and all that and and that and they're off setting a bad example for everybody in here the kids are seeing them and all that kind of stuff look there is a time to say that person is intentionally allowing himself to be in this condition it's not like noah where he got drunk uh i don't know the whole story i guess he could have done it on purpose but he got drunk and he's naked and his kid his good kids to take a sheet and cover him up and try to hide him and he wakes up and he's like ashamed of himself right something like that could happen on accident i've heard of people going to somewhere and drinking a punch or something like that didn't realize that somebody had spiked it and put alcohol in there and they ended up getting drunk like they didn't do that on purpose you know what i mean but a person who deliberately does that there's something wrong that person has to get that right before they're just welcome to participate and uh in regular you know functions of the church okay so uh so that's uh ephesians 5 8. look at first timothy 3. first timothy 3 these are the qualifications of a pastor and of course the reason a pastor is supposed to be held to these standards is because this is he's supposed to be setting an example of how everybody else shall be should be okay and so uh so you can read the qualifications of a pastor and you can see a lot about what uh what we all should strive to be this is first timothy chapter three verse three says uh this is talking about the qualifications of a bishop it must not be given to wine okay and then under deacons in chapter 3 verse 8 likewise must the deacons be grave not double tongued not given to much wine you can say okay he says not given to wine not giving too much wine and i've heard people make arguments about that and say hey look a deacon can have a little bit but he just can't be given too much and that pastor you know he could he just can't be given to it like addicted to it he can't have a problem with it and this is the way people try to do that but i think the idea is that uh you know this should not be something that he he engages in now the argument can be made hey well what if a preacher takes nyquil i mean is he disqualified from the ministry you know what if he had some small uh content of alcohol in his system should that disqualify him you know what if he had he had some some stomach problems you know and he and he read that part about timothy take a little wine for your belly and so he did like does that automatically just make this a wicked guy and we need to remove him no i don't i think the case could be made that that those aren't those aren't wicked things but we're talking about somebody like even if they're going and they're drinking alcohol in public where people can see them and they're out and they're and they're saying oh yeah hey just you know come on we'll just sit down and have a drink together i mean jesus did it but that guy's not qualified to be a pastor he shouldn't be doing that setting a bad example for everybody and possibly leading them down a bad road alcohol is a tool that's used by wicked people to take away your senses and to abuse you look at habakkuk chapter two i hate even reading this one but it's in the bible and we're talking about this i subject go through my uh mayhem a backup okay there you go habakkuk chapter two verse 15. again whoa whoa unto him that giveth his neighbor drink that putteth thy bottle to uh i'm sorry putting that bottle to him and maketh him drunken also that thou mayest look on their nakedness thou art filled with the shame for glory drink thou also and let thy foreskin be uncovered and the cup of the lord's right hand shall be turned unto thee and shameful spewing shall be on thy glory you notice right there what he's saying is that he's giving this drink to his neighbor and he gets his neighbor drunk and he looks on his nakedness and that's just sick and wicked and why would he want to do that but i'm telling you what wicked people out there will use that as a tool and and i can't imagine like these these priests or even uh you know reform guys or whatever that say no no man we're gonna sit down enjoy a beer or whatever and and you know who knows what they get into and looking at them some of them look a little fruity okay and who knows how they're going to get into this and how that wine is going to leave them to do some disgusting things and sure and and and you know why would we want to be engaged in anything that could even possibly lead to that kind of wickedness the last point i want to make i'll tell you real quick here is jesus would jesus have encouraged drunkenness we won't go to john chapter 2 but when he turns that water into wine the argument's always made yeah yeah see the people were sitting around and they drank all the wine until they were drunk right because in the context if you're reading it you could make it say that you could look at that and say hey see they drank it and they were drunk and then jesus brings out the good wine is what they said and he had actually they ran out of wine and so his mom said hey what are we going to do they ran out of wine and so he tells us it's a picture okay there's a great uh illustration being taught here and he says all right take that water from those pots right there and pour them into these other pots and then that water becomes fresh new wine and so the way people interpret that is like hey man we've been drinking all night and and we run out and most people like they bring out the bad stuff at the end of night you you bring out the good stuff like the good stuff man you know like that's the stuff that really gets you you really think jesus is looking at people that had too much to drink and just saying you know what here have some more does that sound like something that jesus would do no he's bringing them good juice good beverage they're good fruit juice this is a party they want to enjoy this also they have a good tasting beverage but not alcoholic and i don't believe jesus turned water into alcoholic wine he said well what about the lord's supper man they're supposed to have wine whenever you serve the lord's supper well yeah the bible uses the word wine he says take this and drink and he's talking about he said this represents my blood but you know i think a really strong argument that shows that that wasn't alcoholic wine is the fact that i'm sure everyone in here have heard the argument is the fact that he great before that gives them bread and that bread is unleavened which means it has no yeast in it why because his he it represents his body and his body was perfect his body was pure it had no sin in it and so therefore the bread was supposed to be unleavened okay so why would he all of a sudden say oh with the wine we're going to have lots of lemon in it and it's going to get people drunk and all that kind of stuff you're talking about jesus the same jesus that said hey you heard it said not to kill but i say unto you if you're if you're even angry with your brother you've committed sin in your heart you heard it said not to commit an adultery but i say unto you even if you look at a woman and lust after her you've committed sin in your heart you've heard it said not get drunk but you know what you can drink a little bit i don't believe that jesus would say that i think it's a it's it's weird for people to make that kind of argument look at uh uh well i'll just read luke chapter 17 verse one jesus said this he said then uh then said he took to his disciples it is impossible but that offenses will come but woe unto him through whom they come i don't think jesus would encourage people to drink for the simple fact that people that drink often are the ones who cause the offenses they get drunk they might invite somebody else to a party hey this is the first time this person ever tasted this stuff now this person has an appetite this person ends up getting becoming a drunk all because of this guy right who who didn't have discretion and say look i'm not even going to look at that stuff when it moves the stuff right he he who's deceit you know he's deceived he's not wise if he's deceived by by strong drink and i believe that that is a very strong case to be made just looking at the life of jesus how he lived why would he have encouraged anybody to do something that could lead to him getting drunk again the arguments are going to be made and not by anybody in this group i'm sure but argument's been made well you know but he know where his wife say that's a little bit you even said kombucha and vanilla and all that stuff and what we're talking about two different things man in the society that we live today like even if you can make the case and i think it could be made very strongly uh that in the uh bible days that would have been used as a medicine right just like nyquil has alcohol content in it they would have used that you know you couldn't really just give somebody a painkiller they weren't just like prevalent back then that i know of all right so somebody is uh is in severe pain somebody's dying somebody's uh you know going through some severe cases well yeah they might have given them those as a as a way to calm them in a way kind of like medicinally to take care of them that's a totally different thing but nowadays in our society you wouldn't have to do that you know there's no reason in my opinion for a christian to ever have to go to a liquor store well you don't know i'm just getting it for me well then go get a prescription you know from the doctor or go get you a little medicine or go use them something like that and look a lot of those i don't care if it's over the counter or prescribed by a doctor a lot of that stuff's garbage too you need to stay away from it but uh but i'm saying that that's totally different than going to the liquor store and buying something and saying hey i think this will help me you're lying to yourself you're being deceived and you're not lies if you do that because it is going to cause all kinds of problems but the world even knows that i read wikipedia's uh uh what they had to say about alcohol and they actually provided this chart now there's a lot of variables anytime you do a chart like this this is why it's hard to believe statistics whenever you read them a lot of variables here but of all the the uh substances and drugs if you will in our society and you you can just list them you can think of lots of them uh uh i'm not i'm not super familiar with a lot of them so i can't think off the top i have a meth and and lsd and all these kind of stuff uh the chart even had mushrooms like there's mushrooms people could say i'm not talking about the kind like on your pizza you get from the store but there are certain mushrooms that people will take that they take as a hallucinogenic and they actually take it like a drug to give them a some kind of a weird buzz or something okay and mushrooms there are mushrooms out there that'll kill you by the way so don't go picking mushrooms off the ground and trying to eat them but the uh but this chart just laid all of these out and the way that it ranked it was how dangerous they are by statistics you know how how deadly they are how harmful they are i should say uh and it gave two categories how harmful they are to the person that's consuming it and how harmful it is to other people right so the idea would be for instance if i got drunk more likely to cause an accident and harm somebody else because of my drug and it takes all that into consideration i don't know there's like i said a lot of variables in this but in the list uh uh let me give you an example so alcohol is way off the charts on a scale of like one to a hundred it's like 70. okay everything else is more like 25 or something like that i don't remember the exact uh the exact list you know uh uh marijuana for instance not really that high on the on the charts you know lsd is like way towards the bottom now here's one of the variables of the chart is that not that many people are doing that lots of people are drinking and so if that's what they took into consideration then obviously drinking is going to be more harmful but my point is that in our society today people are killing themselves with alcohol they're killing other people with alcohol and the amount of wrecks and and the amount of violence domestic abuse and all that kind of stuff alcohol is destroying our nation now look i'm not going to go call for another prohibition i'm going to go out there and pick it all the liquor stores and do all this kind of stuff and and i'm not going to get a alcohol up here and hit it with a baseball bat and try to make some kind of huge statement about that our society needs to get but i'll tell you what it is wicked it is wicked and we need to stay away from it i believe baptist churches need to continue to preach about the harmful nature of it and say stay away from those things keep your mind sober keep your heart on the lord keep yourself a harmless you know you're not harming other people by the things that you're doing you're not offending other people and one thing that is obviously a strong way to minimize that is just don't ever touch or look at alcohol bible's so clear on that and so many verses on that that shares that show us this let's go lord and prayer father i thank you that you've kept me from getting involved in alcoholism and and i know it doesn't make me any better of a person than anybody else we've all got different different background stories and different things that we've dealt with and different sets in our lives that we've dealt with but lord when i think about just the harmful nature of alcohol what it does to people and what it does to lives and families and uh and what it has done to our society what has cost our society and just uh uh dumb people down cause cancer brain damage all these kinds of things but i really feel sad uh for our society and uh and the actions you're going to judge i know that doesn't matter what the reason is but the actions and the sins that are going on as a result of it are wicked and they need to be judged you will judge them but father i i sincerely would love to see uh more people in our society convinced that alcohol is wrong and that they would make decisions to stop drinking uh and i believe that that would help our society uh lord and it would give us clarity of mind people will be able to receive your word better if that were the case and lord so i pray that you help us to keep this topic strong in our hearts we'd be very uh mindful or we don't know how bad the addiction is and how it takes control of a person how hard it is for them to quit but lord i do pray that you'll help us to to realize the dangers and try to help people to get out of it and and that you would bless as we try to do that keep us protected keep our young ones in here protected and teenagers protected from ever going down that road never trying uh that kind of stuff thinking that it would be cool and lord we know how unwise that would be and how it could cause a whole lot of harm in the future and so i pray lord that you give us desire to do right and to stay keep our bodies in check and keep our soul in mind we want you to be glorified in all we do pray in jesus name | Iola Baptist Temple - KC Mission | UCcfuNRRzM3KYYS1-6BJoSjg | 2021-01-23 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 11,409 | 57,807 |
JpqqQlXQzxE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JpqqQlXQzxE | Kantian Ethics | So, in these excerpts, We see Kant trying to do 2 things. He’s trying to answer 2 questions. First question is how should I live my life—pretty much the topic of the whole semester. The second question is really in response to the first question. So Kant is posing this question: How should I live my life? And his answer is you should live your life according to your duty. The second question follows quickly from that: Then what is my duty? For Kant the answer comes from rationality. It’s not so much allegiance to one’s country or even to… Uh, you know, a set of principles or anything like that. Rather what your duty is determined by rationality and rationality is determined by the will. It’s also important to remember something about Kant’s theory—what he is giving us is a conception of morality where more rules are absolute. That means those rules have absolutely no exceptions. You must obey the rules no matter what else follows. This is contrasted to what we might consider Ceteris Paribus laws or rules. Ceteris Paribus, in Latin, means ‘all other things considered equal’. So the idea—and you know this idea is pretty typical, when you conceive of morality as a set of rules, all things are considered equal. You know, you don’t lie. You don’t go around telling people falsehoods when there’s nothing else at stake. Now suppose something that we think is more important is at stake, say peoples’ live, is at stake. Then we think it’s perfectly fine to lie. So Ceteris Paribus laws/ rules, which encapsulate what we’ve been dealing with so far are rules that, uh, you follow of all things considered equal. But when you travel outside of normal circumstances, you have to reevaluate the rules. That doesn’t mean anything goes but you have to reevaluate the rules. Kant strenuously disagrees. Morality is absolute. Morality is without exceptions. For Kant, the only thing that is good—the only thing that matters is the will. This means that whatever decisions you make, it doesn’t matter what the consequences are. As long as you willed in the right way. It doesn’t matter what you will, all that matters is how you will it. It doesn’t matter what you decide, it just matters how you decide it. It doesn’t matter what happens as a result of your decision… If something dreadful happens or if something wonderful happens, it doesn’t matter. If you will in the wrong way and something wonderful happens, you haven’t done something moral. The consequences aren’t important for Kant. The only thing that matters is the will. You might be tempted to think that what Kant thinks here is something along the lines of “What were your motivations—what did you intend to happen?” That doesn’t matter. Your character doesn’t matter—whether you’re a coward or whether you’re brave, or whether you’re cruel—that doesn’t matter. The only thing that matters is how you will, not what you will or what you intend to happen, but how you intend, how you make a decision and how you will. You might wonder for Kant at this point what will determine how you will. If it’s not consequence or character or motives or the results of your actions—then what is it that matters when you will? For Kant, how you’re supposed to will is by conforming your will to duty. You might ask yourself “How do I know what my duty is? Is it my country?” That’s not it for Kant. Remember, for Kant the only thing that’s good is the will. What does the will do? It makes decisions. It’s rational. Your duty, then, is to rationality. Rationality to self—not to any particular will or any particular person but to rationality itself. Now, to illustrate what Kant means by rationality, I’m going to start with a notion: Self-defeating actions. This is important to remember. This is not a concept that Kant describes, at least not explicitly. But I’m going to use this idea in order to illustrate the kind of rationality that Kant is getting at. Again, I want to be clear that the concept of a self-defeating action is not Kant’s concept, at least not explicitly. This is something Kant puts together to explain what Kant means by rational. He doesn’t mean rationality in terms of truth, he means rationality in terms of practical reason. And what it’s getting at here is that every action—at least the ones that we perform—are for a purpose. It’s a matter of practical rationality that if you want to be healthy, you should eat right and exercise. That’s practical rationality. Performing those actions achieves the purpose. A self-defeating action is an action that actually defeats the purpose for which you’re performing. Considering health, we can think of something silly as—oh, I don’t know, eating nothing but Milky Ways—candy bars. The idea is that I will have just enough to not go over my calorie limit and that’s going to be “healthy”. That’s a self-defeating action because there’s all kinds of things that you’re not getting from those candy bars—vitamins, proteins… Well, you’re getting proteins, [Laughter]. But you’re not getting minerals. All you’re getting is a bunch of empty calories and fat. Okay, (Cannot hear him/her) that’s a trivial example. There’s lots more. There’s lots of examples of self-defeating actions. We kind of actually tend to do these a lot. Suppose… You and a friend are having a discussion and you’re trying to reach a point of agreement. Let’s say you’re debating politics. You’re trying to reach a common ground—a point in which both of you can settle on and then move from there. But after a while you haven’t been able to do this. So you say, “Let’s just agree to disagree”. But that’s a self-defeating action. You’re trying to say you can agree to disagree, meaning this is the common ground in which we will start. But you haven’t reached a common ground. All you’ve said is that our common ground is that we don’t have a common ground. That defeats the purpose of the discussion. You may have ended the discussion but you haven’t ended the disagreement. The point of the discussion was to find a common ground—the point of the discussion was to find a point of agreement where you two can begin and move from there. There are other examples of self-defeating actions. As I said in the text, you may have heard “Question everything. Question authority”. An imperative is what’s given by authority, right? Well, that means you’re supposed to question the very authority that tells you to question authority. Suppose it changes to “Question everything”. Well, including that command? If someone says, “Question everything”, respond with “Why?” [Laughter] Or say, “Including you? You’re not the boss of me.” So, self-defeating actions are actions that defeat the very purpose for why you are performing the action. So, this brings us to imperatives. Imperatives are these obligations or principles upon the will. That’s what’s demanded by practical reason. And remember for practical reason you perform these actions to achieve this goal or purpose. So, for Kant, imperatives come in 2 kinds: hypothetical or categorical. A hypothetical imperative is an action—or commanded or demanded of you by practical reason to fulfill some further good or purpose. So an example of a hypothetical imperative: If you have the goal of health, you ought to eat right and exercise, including pull-ups or walking. For another example of a hypothetical imperative, uh, suppose your goal or purpose is to complete an education or a particular course. In order to do that you would have to study, take notes, read and take tests. That might be narrowed down even further, right. A hypothetical imperative for a Chemistry class Would be different that for an English Literature class. A hypothetical imperative for a Chemistry class would include going to a lab and carrying out an experiment, but that would be different for an English Lit class. These hypothetical imperatives are hypothetical in the sense that if you were to have those goal or purpose then you perform these actions. Categorical imperative is different. A categorical imperative is an imperative you follow regardless of what good or purpose you have. This is what Kant calls good in and of itself. Now that’s the definition of a categorical imperative. Kant believes that this definition of categorical imperative leads to only one categorical imperative. We don’t have a set of them, we just have one. This brings us to Kant’s argument for the categorical imperative. For Kant, the categorical imperative is that you must act in such a way that what you act you can will into universal law. And by that he means that anybody can do it and does do it. So, um, that’s kind of extreme, right. What’s moral is what’s rational and what’s rational is that you act in a way that can be made into universal law. He has some reasons for this. As we saw from the beginning, he has this idea that rationality is what matters morally. So, pretty much quite simply or stupidly then: If you’re acting irrationally then you’re acting immorally. That’s kind of the first major step. Suppose, if… If I act or one acts in a way that the actions performed cannot be made into universal law—well, if you’re doing that then you’re acting in such a way that a person’s decisions can be stopped or hindered. So if you’re acting in such a way that can’t be made into universal law, then you’re acting in such a way that somebody’s will can be obstructed. What he means by that is that if you’re acting in such a way that can be made into universal law, what happens is some people can’t perform that action and if they can’t perform that action, their will is obstructed. Okay, well if you’re acting in a way where someone’s will can be hindered, you’re acting in a way where anyone’s will can be hindered. And you may wonder “Why anyone’s will, not just my own?” well, remember what matters for Kant—the will, not your will. But the will itself. All wills are equal in Kant’s eyes it doesn’t matter whose will it is. Just like it doesn’t matter what is being willed, just how it’s being willed. It doesn’t matter who s willing. It only matters how it’s willing. So if you’re acting in a way where somebody’s decisions can be hindered, then you’re acting in a way that can hinder your will, your decisions. Well, if you’re acting in a way that can hinder your own decisions, you’re acting against your own will. You are making that claim, “Anyone’s will can be hindered, including mine!” That’s not gonna work, right? That’s contrary to rationality and practical reason. If you’re acting in a way where your will is hindered, that is contrary to reason. So that’s irrational, and as we saw before: If it’s irrational, it’s immoral. Kant—since what started this whole deal is the idea that—acting in this way where it can’t be made into universal law, that’s what’s immoral. If that’s what’s immoral, then acting in a way such that your action can be made into universal law, that’s what moral and rational. | HaugenMetaphilosophy | UC2VcZkxOKi7_ckDlzylnFNQ | 2016-03-21 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,892 | 10,954 |
Y9hd2xzB9Ig | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9hd2xzB9Ig | Can Sevilla Finally Challenge for the Title? | [Music] let's talk finally what happened in the western european leagues and i am very thrilled that for now there are more french teams back there and if i see how i arrange the shirts and this is all due to standing so barcelona this was his project would still be first in la liga then atletico fourth place sevilla and then in france we have psg ahead of mercy ahead of bordeaux at the moment it's clashes all over i mean those two those two those two don't like it it's but that's the beauty of it i also realized so in order to have this really a nice background for all these leaks i need one more spanish jersey then i would put all these paint dresses on top and maybe where the valencia jersey is hanging put something there i need two more french jerseys for to replace the two psja jerseys and to my portuguese jerseys because i would move sevilla up there to have two portuguese and the third portuguese team will replace here this barcelona jersey that's the plan so five choices needed to have a perfect background at the moment i fill it up with all uh bars psja and real madrid choices but it's already a lot better than it was a week ago speaking of severe jersey i'm varying severe and this one now i'll let you take a guess which one's the fake and which one is the real one take a quick guess i'm gonna make a video about this because it's the same jersey i'm wearing the fake keep the real one up there um i'm really looking forward to making that sevilla actually had over a great week and still in the end a little bit disappointed i would let's see let's get right to it la liga we had midweek games and i probably should have done this la liga video sooner that it does the last one is that i really want to do next um league jersey review at least shoot them they will be published probably after the international break but at least shoot them so uh that was the main reason for that it actually started with a surprise i really think that i also see that we lose it home to valencia but loser did gomez getting in the 75th minute a late win uh from what i didn't see much but i think la real was large largely better team but as it happens um get tougher uh at least on the lines the uh top of the table said with a three nil win over bet is a team that just had lo lost very unluckily to um real madrid all goals in the first half so a pretty big win for get tougher then realm uh atletico madrid everything i said about lefty everything considers the says it's about after the first game how fun they are you know everything was gone it was boring as hell we are real with others uh three one then elche gets a win at a bar eva having a rather uh bad start real madrid gets another labored win over real while delete uh venice is junior actually scoring the goal uh and every real madrid victory same story not commencing in the end they get it done more consistency than other teams in the league um atletico bow against kadith an absolutely crazy game there are bilbao was at times two men up i mean they gave up at only the 57th when they already a man down and then kadis even goes a second one down uh with nick rader who gets two goals uh two goals two yeah yellow cards in short succession they cannot find the equalizer uh if i was a bilbao fan at that time i would be really really concerned about my team because they keep losing and not against great opposition they may have had to play bars barcelona but that game got postponed because barcelona started late in the league and since then i think uh bilbao is in a really really bad shape sevilla though that's what they needed to go i mean heather goldie disarmed 67th uh but in stoppage time and naziri gets finally the goal although lopetego got himself sansa sent off and needed to watch the game um against barcelona on the weekend from the stands but uh sevilla gets more consistent i'm really curious to see if they can continue their um their run this way because they already had bayern pretty much on the ropes as well with their also high pressing uh very uh i don't say mechanic but very well trained style doing a good job and then barcelona gets the most out barcelona like victory of all time anzu fatty gives them the lead i have to say i did not necessarily like that the barcelona black pepper in the blackjars i think than the regular home choices would have done all those black jerseys i know many like them they're not proper bars waitresses take maybe third choices of whatever in any way unsophatic gives them golden long leg it says it's a sand off for an elbow in driving rain uh barcelona still holds on i mean uh and then a very late goal from sergio roberto give them a three-nil win they worked for each other they were tough and even with a man down they ground out the victory against a celtic team that never really got running celta is kind of this yo-yo team once good one's bad uh it's kind of disappointing ah also soon i got postponed because grandma had to play in the europa league so after this midway ground we had get tougher now top of the table uh and valencia gets a second win remember they won the first uh a game of the all of the season but you always had defeating valencia is not really good and real madrid keeps adding points like a little hamster a little bit little bit little bit i mean gold uh the goals for two tell the whole of the story barcelona on the other hand had within two games seven goals gone none conceded i mean this was is also not very personal like where's uh sevilla at least one car considered but also gets to win in in a row and bolted well for uh epic matchup at the camp now on the other end of the table bilbao keeps dropping uh this is for me the biggest disappointment of the season also atletico madrid you know you start out very very brightly and then you have a nil nil against uska and everything that you said was enjoyable was suddenly gone and it was a similar story um on the weekend aber gets off the channel with a win against ireland via delete and via the lead i thought it was a team that could get something done no this time aberwins so in spain it's really everyone can almost beat everyone and then via real who looked horrific against barcelona getting nil nil atletico madrid even were probably the better team i mean atletico madrid had not even a shot on goal it was a pretty poor performance i don't know how they got the six against granada and suddenly they had they have two mill nil in a row against opponents that you would actually think they should win so a really really really a disappointing game once more and then guitar alpha just beating fresh off beating bettis is annihilated by real sociedad who have no problem getting uh disposing of qatar oya sabal and 20th with a penalty then marina on porto are late add to more with a larael playing actually really well and very pleasing to them making up for the loss to valencia well let's see on the other hand we need that anyone's guessed who's who is the best team of those actually they say they also also that and then maybe bet this from what i've seen but this completely outclassed valencia uh was so much better and uh joaquin uh best player on on the pitch he assisted canales and he also assisted the second goal through tay although he want to already be substituted uh i mean everyone was celebrating he had already indicated i wanna come off and he's just lying on the pitch completely guessed but that guy played in the 2002 world cup was the up-and-coming young player of that world cup and didn't make the big spain squad and now is still a great player for betty's it's a rather wonderful story you have to say um also soon a bit celta vigo selt you know salt is one of my uh teams that i like and other late win against bilbao in a game that looked like nil nil but eli gets the goal and atletic bilbao i mean the teams that they're losing to uh there was caddis in there there was other west in there um we just had them losing to a bar i would be really worried if i'm outlet the club fan absolutely this does not bode well for the future but you know maybe things can turn turn around levante already lost uh midweek um to sevilla they probably should have gotten at least a point against real madrid but real madrid again venice junior gets an early goal uh nicely taken then levante secretary should have gotten an e coliseum somehow don't get it and then uh rodriguez hits benzema for a late stoppage time goal to seal the real madrid win and again it's typically a real madrid style are grinding out a victory without much flair now does this mean that they will win the league we have to see about that but it's rather impressive and boring in many ways but uh great teams usually grind out victories if even if they don't play well uh cadiz granada won one and then barcelona sevilla uh i mean all the action happened of goals goggles and what's happened in the first 10 minutes uh where the young after kind of some uh unsorted bars defending makes the goal but then a messy pass is badly deflected by navas who wants to clear right of the path or pass of coutinho makes it won't won but sevilla really gave barcelona trouble absolutely um bug them in every regard and probably in the second half should have gotten the lead um yes at the end they were a little bit scrambling but i always had the feeling that sevilla was the better team in there the question is i always give them a tag most frustrating team in europe because can they keep it up uh is this growth deep enough can they keep it up because they usually start well and then some suddenly breaks down it's also now this team is kind of getting what lopetegui wants from them again i mean you should not go into all bodies but what if lopez would have state spain coach in the 2018 world cup we already knew that spain will be very very strong and what although the potato did by signing up for real madrid basically shot uh spain in the foot and started this channel this was my first ever video that i did on this channel prior to the restart so yeah interesting stuff so we get the following table uh where real madrid now is top you can see in this balance measure that la liga is rather evenly i mean it's very there's not one chunk that has many many points and one has little it goes very great gradually down and also we can see that um um before it was more personal favorite now it's a lot more even there because possible dropped already points yesterday madrid the d2 with real madrid has one win more so for that reason it evens itself out yes barcelona has the most impressive gold the difference as does atletico commodore atletico madrid cannot win anymore since ever it seems like they've wasted all their canon powder there and yeah so uh those the big three are still the big three i caught according to projections but the question is can severe get get in there can severe i mean they are a highly talented team can they make it through the season okay it would be really really interesting so he has a little bit the lots of white from last season valencia are surprising hang hangs in it but you can already see they are not favored to get in champions league they're more threatened for relegation but for relegation it is still lc real via delete and all of us but bilbao is still only 40 percent less than valencia but i think this will increase rather soon i don't know the matches for the negan extra they have not been scheduled yet so um they said when i was collecting uh the data so let's move on to frost psja winning easily awards here and you think yeah now psg has has arrived in the league and everything should be happy now tuchri wants players he wants he says the squad is thin we need someone to replace thiago silva blah blah blah leonardo not happy with it uh nothing is well at least on the on on the pitch neymar had fun florence scored the first goal neymar scored two um but they assisted one um and scored one the last one and name also uh assisted irisa gay so that sounded all fine center tien we talked about them as uh top of the table to be weak vixx goes really strong against last they get an early red card and then it all goes pear-shaped a minute after uh it was tripping for last men penalty even for loss is one nil uh for laws they have then a gold did disallow then another senator tnc um player kazi is sent off uh with a straight red card for tripping and it was easy for us to hang on to all the victory we see that loss actually um is rising as a promoter team this totally dominated not also because giordo got already sent off in the third minute so naught is playing basically the whole match with a man down and dante gets them uh the lead nice however they give up a penalty very late uh in uh in uh stoppage time that loser equalizes and then now tries to hang on for life for the point but tyram i think he is also related to um lillian theorem gets the winner for nice and gets them back on track we had uh name beating montpellier von neal that was also a rather unexpected victory bordeaux rolls over dijon dijon really looking almost like a surefire um relegation team um best their home form is pretty pretty impressive against monaco one nil laura also had a good start but uh loses now three one two mets so i think these were the two promoted sides playing each other lil has no trouble at strasbourg and again just that when you know just when i try to get a ball on board with a team they disappoint pointman again and all means that psja is the one that will be happiest from the entire round so what happened ren found themselves down in the 11th minute uh rafinha and the seal were turned around but uh russ who i think had lost almost all the games up up on list but get an equalizer through dr and ren cannot find the winner and uh it's vital points drop if you want to stay in the title race and similar for leon must say i mean uh dimitri payet gives marseille uh the lead but then for uh rotten nasty foul gets a red card and then everything shifts to leo where while our converts a penalty they even have a gold dsl out but i saw the most of the sex i can have and yes leo tried but i have to say it was a rather um let's say i was more impersonal or severe i think that says it all so this one one also plays deeply into the cards of psja if you look down on the table it's a ran ahead of lil the thanks to goal more goal scored here uh we also see it's still a very balanced league although there seems to be you know seven points is something that many gets and then there's a quick drop off in in in a way but still very even but psja is now only within two points of the league lead and it's not inconceivable that within two two rounds psja is top again lost still yes they've beaten psja are very much on top there as well uh ren lille and olympic leone are the two teams that are still also favorites to make it into a champions league with leonardo having a rather slow start too many draws in there so let's see and uh also lots of uncertainty surrounding squad we know not the memphis state pi will stay at least until mid-season so let's see where this will be going for relegation uh l'oreal dijon at the moment again we have to see how this develops here we know what the next fixtures are uh the standard fixture two themes that are back there are between museum bordeaux at least uh traditionally but i think little against last that's a huge derby uh up north there's also pretoria between north and brest psja has to go to nim i would expect a win there and where do we have ren against dijon should also be a win so let's see they are all already preparing for the champions league hence the early kickoffs portugal i ordered the two one win of family car or bella ninjas um or you know what's left of the team that's another really sad story there um which basically meant that far from our car we had a little bit up the table but the round was dominated by the shock defeat of porto at home to mara timo uh pino gives marutimo delete that paper can equalize um yeah see the batteries but then pino gets the lead from outer timo again in the 50 sec second minute then tiers misses a penalty for porto and in stoppage time nanu makes it uh three one and then uh pork just pulls him back that's a shock loss for porto and befika dooley can take care of it but it's uh was not an easy win against newly promoted firenze uh pizzi gives him the lead but farenzo misses pen penalty but scores a minute later through lucca then to cephera which goes put spafika on the winning road but they have to give her one more through fernandesh so um also interesting family car you are a player one one draw and sporting uh survives you know kind of gets a little bit back from the loss to last mid week paraga with a big win against tondela as well meaning that now benfica and santa clara the two teams that basically share crests are all the way on the top of the table porto is only second and the race is super tight i mean yes it's 57 to 40 at the moment but that can change at any time and it will probably decide in a direct in the head to heads uh sporting also in the braga had a rather slow start so they finally got the guard to win we have to see where this is going and yeah uh boyvishta is still also favorite to get readily relegated ahead of tondela so that's also rather interesting again i don't know what will be happening last round because they're not uh i don't have the dates it so let me know what you thought about the western european leaks how things are going give me thumbs up if you enjoyed this video subscribe to my channel if you want to see more videos like these and i will talk to you soon bye hey there i hope you enjoyed this video and if you did here are some videos and playlists of interest to you too also please consider subscribing to my channel as it will keep you updated with all things that are rotating in my soccer universe with that i wish you wonderful day bye [Music] you | My Soccer Universe | UCvPJq0sTL1R5qHU0PsD6eWA | 2020-10-07 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,514 | 18,079 |
IT2KW8j2jl4 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IT2KW8j2jl4 | HUGE Great Dane Puppy Falls In Love W/ tiny Fruity Chihuahua | wow I've never seen a walking strawberry tree what is up YouTube and welcome to another cribs on experience if you guys enjoyed this video don't get it that thumbs up subscribe bye MA it's a strawberry of vegetable we're going through we have Milo with us today I will be taking them to the big dog park and we will be live-streaming on into the grammar oh my gosh I could just sense him wanting to smash everything Ruger Woodson's about to finally not be the lowest link yeah really Callie okay get off me Ruger hi what's it people want to see us fruity-ass you see that through the ass harness ah what is that what n what is that what said oh here we go bro we're going live you ready was my living kebab smashed get her while she's weak just how I taught him look at the fruit on him oh my god we got Milo you guys is the first time I brought up the dog park by himself by giving us another snatch so bad Oh what happened okay too much ooh I taught him everything he knows yeah this is a rich pack right here your name is Miki Miki Miki sit sit oh good yeah don't go I can't do anything about the lag is probably the connection even if it's lagging I will post this video on my youtube channel so just wait on it a little mohawk you see the mohawk oh yeah look back at it oh we got diesel at this moment diesel fell in love with the strawberry tree he could take him yeah it's a guy the guy he's just fruity leave him leave um Peter yeah he want um he smells the fruit on him oh wow he probably tripped out on the rat huh damn these are getting big no way oh these don't get off this fruity nut Milo get on my left Oh No oh it goes DISA you trying to smash wrong color some girls for my logo no boy over D so these nerds he the odd use Allah is that the bull terrier oh no it's a guy no he's got a boner go for him your head mine oh oh she's [ __ ] a wall of then we have Milo who stinks off dude I smell that [ __ ] from here where's the fruit oh you want colloid ears aw look at them just trying to either box out blue just let us all there you go it's a guy isn't that blue Milo I know get over here come here don't look at me like that what a FRU diesel diesel look at it in bro just wants to smash ways that coat yep let's go here I don't want them I do want to put them back in my love my what's wrong Mauser what's wrong Malchus 102 like 100 sky sky Oh [ __ ] there he goes there you gosh he's whispering something in his ear sorry about the livestream I'm not sure what's wrong I think the connection at the dog park is just really bad hopefully I got some footage I'll be sure to post it in this video that's gonna go ahead and be if you guys enjoyed this video don't forget to hit that thumbs up subscribe for more feel free to follow my snapchat and my instagram @ k ze underscore production | KzE_Production | UCaiQt7FRdzYLjRn3kVjnB7A | 2017-08-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 580 | 2,835 |
FiDiDsQT27U | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FiDiDsQT27U | 16 Snook 5 Tarpon Day | [Music] [Applause] [Music] there he is this yes though [Music] all right [Music] is [Music] reel it pull it over reel it up real real real okay right there stop pull them out pull them out all right guide them out guide them out now under the belly oh no no no no not the gills under the belly there you go there you go that's a good one sweet way to go here on perfecto [Music] all right snooki number five three tarpon already this one's a nice keeper we're gonna go ahead and keep this one in the box [Music] oh no way there's a little baby tarpon no gary that's me mas chiquito and me vida it's syria [Music] next [Music] yes [Music] yes that's pretty good yes okay right down right down look at the size of that one oh get them in there right on look at that [Music] so [Music] you | Randy Bowser YucatanAnglersTV | UCQbVEGONtljDKYoTj-s4uQQ | 2021-01-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 157 | 786 |
P3uf8-4clrI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3uf8-4clrI | Understanding income tax system and deductions Tax Preparation 2023-2024 | you know benefit or incentive from it uh would be the general idea also note that they usually apply it on the adjusted gross income AGI which is the income after the income minus the above the line deductions so most of these phase outs are based on at least the starting point of an adjusted gross income uh type of number okay so use lines 2 through four of the worksheet and these instructions to figure your modified adjusted gross income why does it say modified well they typically start with the AGI and then they modify it from there in part you kind of have to consider this one because the deduction is an adjustment for income meaning it's it's going to be above the line deduction which will have an impact on adjusted gross income so we'll have a circular reference when we try to figure out this phaseout thing if we don't make some kind of adjustment to the adjusted gross income we'll talk more about that in this software example in a future presentation so you or your spouse of filing jointly aren't claimed as a dependent on someone else's such as your parents 2023 tax return so don't include any amount paid from a distribution of earnings made from a qualified tuition program that's a qtp after 2018 to the extent the earnings are treated as tax-free because uh they were used to pay student loan interest use uh the the worksheet and these instructions to figure your student loan interest deduction exception publication 970 instead of the worksheet in these instructions to figure your student loan interest deduction if you file form 2555 because that you might have foreign income in that case which often complicates the calculation or 4563 or you exclude income from sources within Puerto Rico all right so let's get into then what is a qualified student loan | Accounting Instruction, Help, & How To | UCq6ysZYeu-HwhBEV7TuO8wg | 2024-03-26 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 319 | 1,791 |
mlrv5MQh3rY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlrv5MQh3rY | *NEW* REFINED & ENHANCED WINTER STORE PACKS! #FIFA23 | so EA have dropped an enhanced winter rare players pack and a refined winter rare players pack for cheap fast and reliable foot coins check out MMO exp there is a link down below and use the code Haber to get yourself five percent off all of your orders special version of the winter air players pack with at least double the chance of receiving a fantasy item the Boost does not apply to foot fantasy's hero players Bootsy chances can be seen in the pack probability section so this one's got a 17 chance of a foot fantasy and this one has got a 41 so almost almost a one in two chance of getting a full fantasy in the 150k pack and yeah like one in five chance here so let's open these up and see what we get we're going to do the refined one first we don't get it well we could still get a full fantasy if this is a walkout it's not it's a it's 84 Denali all right not ideal not ideal yeah okay well this one was only 17 chance though so that's okay you know that one's only 17 chance whatever right we move on it's the enhanced one I think or the is it the refined or enhanced whichever one didn't open refined one so this one apparently is a 43 which is different because this one only has a 6.2 chance so that is effectively what like almost five times interesting let's open it up 1 000 FIFA points or 150k coins and we do get a fantasy item it is gonna be Dominic shabazzle okay I'll say that is he I don't think it's worth a huge amount though is he I think he's probably worth about 50k if that 57 000 coins it's all right the thing is with this card is I guarantee if if Leipzig lose tonight against City a guarantee he drops in price because people don't realize that it starts on March 17th which is this Friday um but it's a card that could definitely get upgrade you know I think he he'll get the start upgrades I think he'll get the win game upgrades he will get the Midfield uh a goal slash assist upgrade as well so it could be a 90 ready card pretty easily I'll take that oh Ben take in there as well nice we ended up getting bit ice and tradable that's annoying but we've got Ben Tech in there as well solid I'll take that all right we're getting two two in there nice solid on to the second account now enhanced winter air players pack first thousand fifth points let's see what we get hey we do get ourselves a foot a fantasy card it's top rack it's only 86 rated but we'll take it anyway we do get ourselves a foot fantasy very nice only 17 chance as well so I'll absolutely take that and this one's tradable as well so that he's worth a whole lot I am just going to sell him for 20 odd K but we'll take that that's all right uh no dangler just double check that as well all right all right here we go with the uh this is the refined one now which is a 40 41 chance all right 41 chancy eh okay there could be a dangler to be fair the walkouts do pop up before foot fantasies so rodery you know it's all right here we go dangler hey supposedly again we get a second supposedly of the video we store them in the club 87 rated photo on this account I can't lie uh no dangler benteke this time but solid I'll take that that's all right we've got a 1083 Plus Pack now Pap on to Glory does a rose of Glory around papan it'd be so funny if you got the foot fantasy hero papan in this pack now be so funny uh Chicken Little Kayla Navas though God dangler please please have a pan in there hey getting mikitade who is uh absolutely killing it for FC match I say that he actually isn't he he had like three good games in the last in the last eight weeks but 88.88 Kayla Navas and 86 milinkovic Savage that's actually a really good 83 times 10. only 383s and what are they being inform we'll take that all right next 83 times 10. Robin all of the kidaz is the club name I don't know what that means to be honest but we have a name forb go on be a high rated one Portugal goalkeeper Jose sat 85 rated that's okay good father come on right here can we get good dangle as EA front fantasies and walkouts like the first pack but a fantasy at the back is what we're looking for all right come on oh he's he's okay for what I said his club name is his son's name oh that's awesome man he's 20 days old well congratulations bro I didn't know that that's awesome congratulations hey we get a full fantasies all right solid we'll take that all right 83 times 10 next come on that's not a good start isn't it I don't think that's a walkout all right it is just a walk out Danny perejo very good player in real life by the way Dangler no that is the worst one so far that is a terrible terrible packier all right my boy rusty spoon he's opening the refined winter rare players back 41 percent EA 41 percent well it could still be one in there to be fair English striker Harry Kane's a great start eight nine rated those are actually a good father uh maybe a couple of bits of fodder in there but we want the dangler could still be there 41 here come on mate come on Mo that's a terrible part all right 83 times 10 right now come on we want to see we've not seen a full fantasy in about four or five packs all info could be good Spanish left back 84 rated don't really care apart from the fact there could be anything behind that that's all I care about hey Josh kimbridge is okay it's an all right pack it's not it's very mediocre I think all right credia's got the 83 times 10 and then both of the winter air players back the enhanced and refined so 83 times 10 first French goalkeeper that's good 87 minion he was actually incredible the other day for Milan it's all right to be fair to be fair quite a lot of fun of there three or four walkouts there not too bad sadly I don't think that they are tradable so the discard recoveries unfortunately but they'll be good for an SBC I think the campaign back refreshes tomorrow I want to say so we can recover them for tomorrow and then the campaign back when it comes back out you've got two eight sevens and A6 for it so we'll do uh the enhanced one first because it is tradable uh in case we get some dupes obviously we want to put the tradables on the transfer market so here we go walk out English right back Trent Alexander Arnold it's all right no dangler there though uh I said to the transfer list and then we'll put um we'll just put more on charge for this why not why not you never know when you're gonna need them all right now we have got the refined winter airplanes but this is untradable but also 41 chance come on 41 EA could be a walkout no it's Paul Pogba I'm not even going to sing the song Anymore that is that is appalling that is a terrible perk that is absolutely awful yeah you should be ashamed 1083 plus now on my account let's see if we get something good let's see if we can get a w on my account it's an inform it's going to be Germany center-back Jula 87 rated Nicholas Jeweler not bad actually we'll take that uh that's actually pretty solid I will take a 87 rated inform go on danglers imagine a foot fantasy in there as well no fantasy but Geordie Alba's alright as well he's okay it's really good followers and inform but only one walkout is not ideal it's a very average pack there I think Lola's 83 times 10 now will it be lucky than mine will it be looking at most of them today we've got another inform Germany oh another Nicholas Schuler will take that a solid 87 rate again this one's got Kevin chop in there at least so it's a bit better than mine but still no foot fantasy all right next 1083 plus come on EA he's got 5K left let's sort it out right here let's sort him out it's a walkout it's Spanish it's on the back it's I'm Eric Laporte I am Eric LaPorte anyone else no dangler sadly unfortunate all right 1083 plus and the store packs we'll start off with the store packs here uh refined winter rare players back come on fantasy in this please yeah yay let's go solid uh it's not the best one it's Wimmer but you know at least we did get one um good start to the share play getting a foot fantasy never gonna turn down a foot fantasy maybe there's a second one in there is any lower rated once benteke maybe no we'll take it though you know it's all right it just met oh oh tugly FICO at the back wait he's higher rated what not pop up there he's literally higher rated tradable as well big dubs why did why did tags not pop up that are so strange I don't get that but we'll take it anyway 87 taggly FICO and 86 Wimmer in the refined winter rare players pack I don't know if that was the better one or the worst one there is the refined one the better one or is the enhanced one the better one I think the enhanced one's a better one oh no the refined ones better enhance one now this is 17 of a foot fantasy um hopefully it's a walk out in the front Belgium it's gonna be de bruyne no okay telemunds not as good definitely no foot fantasy in this pack um which is not ideal to Debo simekan Mendy rashford at least this one's tradable though aribo there as well Joe Rebo I just quite like Jerry but I think he's a decent player but that Lavia from West uh from Southampton is solid man that Lavia guy is so good can't believe City let him go anyway 83 times 10 now jerus Sandstorm Aston Villa badge he's got 35k left in the account come on let's get a third foot fantasy for the share play EA please let's get another one or maybe another two we'll take four or be solid here we go a guessing he's a villa fan is there any football fantasies from Villa I don't think there is maybe expeller plays I'm not entirely sure right it's finally opened it lagged out a little bit but it's finally open all black would be very nice here no handanovic brilliant yay you are making me very very bored of opening these 83 time tens right now very bored indeed wow all right we're doing a uh Championship share play the championship pack here we go come on come on EA for the champ it's a walkout English striker it's Harry Kane that's awkward because he's not won a championship in his life he hasn't won a belt or a trophy um all right we'll skip that all right come on come on here fantasy for the champ no we get ourselves a variety and Mendy though that's okay that's an all right pack not terrible but you know the champ wants better than that EA we are ending off today's video with the two store packs on Xbox let's see if we can get something good so we have got the enhanced winter air players pack first it's gonna be a foot fantasy from Portugal who's a center-back it's Reuben Diaz oh my word we got hobandish boys that's the trailer one as well oh my word oh tradable oh my word what a w that is yes get in all right send that to the transfer list about 900k that is fantastic in the tradable pack as well that's only a 17 chance and we go and get huben douche all right now for the refined winter rare players pack now this could be a dangler if it's a walkout rodri yes it could be a dangler here it could be a dangler foot to Fantasy all right I thought I got jotto in the first pack I'm I'm well surprised it's Reuben Diaz oh we do get one as well matoma wow man the look The Luck came through we got ourselves carry matoma and Ruben Diaz in the uh Xbox packs that is huge man that is absolutely huge if you guys have enjoyed please make sure to leave a like down below and subscribe if you guys are new around here thank you for watching and I'll see you Lads later | ItsHaber | UCR-WgO2-GUmA9-MXqiEmP0A | 2023-03-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,271 | 11,368 |
zaW66qTrcEM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaW66qTrcEM | I Hired a Madden Pro to Secretly TROLL Throne! | this is thrown he's one of the best Madden players I know but every time I play him I lose by about 14 or more but that's going to change today sort of I've secretly hired professional Madden player kmac to play for me so while me and Throne talk in Discord I'm going to be watching kmac play as me and let's see how this goes okay basically I'm sick of being dog [ __ ] am I the final boss you're the you're actually the first boss you're the first boss but I've been for a week straight Pro Strat and I want to I want to test them out on you I didn't see I literally just heard like 5 minutes ago there was a patch I think my defense is patched the like the dollar you are not setting up excuses to face me bro I think I'm going bills o dude this is a reverse of your match up with kmac right in the uh that turny it is it is who won that uh kmak won W all this all this practice all these weeks of suffering Arrowhead Stadium baby let's go Chief's Kingdom so you've been in the lab who's been teaching you who's been coaching had about four or five different people that I asked and they all taught me different stuff so like I certainly took like the stuff that I like the most but it wasn't it wasn't like teach me one Playbook it was like let me learn like what makes people good at this game tackles boys tackles boys yeah it's not it's not Christian mcaffrey though this time not acho either what's with them and and puting and Jericho kenon I don't know why he's the starting back I'm going to get spicy hot with this absolute laser be dig pressure tackles big tackles on mvs in open field [ __ ] you definitely talk to kmac I just learned that wait how do you know wait why do you know by the play you just saw is that a kmac special that is a kmac play I had two different people tell me about that oh okay all right I got to go I got to dig deep I got to dig deep my Pro strats for this one uhhuh y P's in too my [Music] dog take the three all right the all right you think I take three I'm still MMG bro I want you to take the three no r see cuz you thought I would the post is open though you little post SL it's a do three points is for frauds bro believe Chiefs believe T tackles tackles I think get off all right we need to hold the door here on the two we get stingy down here there she isve check come on for check hey I didn't last time my opening drive I I whiff scoring on you this is already a good Improvement yeah I have a feeling I have to play some perfect uh perfect offense though I know I'm going to give up points that was a good drive by you I'm flattered a few moments later okay I'm definitely a Discord right now holy [ __ ] he literally know dude I swear he already knows it's G back play like I swear to God he already knows it's G back damn the hit I Can't audible cuz I'm at Chiefs dude that's so annoying I'm trying to call a different play Let Me audible what that's a brutal home field advantage please get out I'm trying to autom all my play I've tried four times I can't there's the fifth question mark I got screamed big time I'll be honest I'll be honest that was a km play too oh I didn't think You' do it oh I was staring at it waiting for you to pull off was the only player that could get open dang it stay stay did he drop it or was it out bounds dropped him up oh nice ball like just like way way too strong oops blocks were way too I needed to get in thereit I thought I had thank you I can't I I can't be mid after today bro no you're not m is he there yeah he is oh my God he not let's go po [ __ ] that's a KO too come on baby oh do I got to milk you here you better milk me you better get under those others start milking it oh wait cuz oh you get Bal half don't you yeah yeah yeah dude I swear like that it is so important oh it's the biggest part of the game especially when offens is you just need last drive at the half like that's the most important part oh I see what you mean like it might not actually matter whether you receive or yeah I mean it it works the same either way yeah you just need to have last last possession I'm getting I'm actually getting ymed at second one oh my gosh that's in the ooh nice Juke that was a big down too that was a huge down you will be yelling at me when I do that that's in the old MMG Playbook I'm going to keep that one and that too damn it we believe you just scissor my left side mg are you quick little scissor don't worry about it are you are you quick adjusting on me you just man up my wide with your and then man up man up the running back at the cor you so worried about it I'll give you some time go come on I wanted to give you some time okay I'm defening for a second I have no idea what he just said scissoring I that's not the scissoring I know and I don't even know how to man up anybody holy [ __ ] but you didn't have to say it let's go what dreams are made of I got to go for those I'm taking the three I'm taking the three if I get stopped it's game over I think like if I get stopped I think you're going to get three and then I'm down two possessions stop in the second half in re this is truly an M right here that was going to X that was going to X bro oh okay was he open he wasn't open right uh if I got the pass lead in the free form the same way I got mvs he would have o that's a really good tackle got that bazooka Uncorked baby let me see if I can get you with this again no that was so risky I hated that ball up there that [ __ ] was open you almost caught it yeah good do and a tackle though you play that Juke so much better than anyone I play dude I you got to be so careful of it it's so many free yards since everybody throw at me I can't allow seven here allow seven here it's GG's I thought it was a corner route good dot okay baby the pro strats bro I may I may I may hang on to this you might be back I actually feel like a dick because I know what thron is thinking right now he is thinking that I'm going to post a video where I actually beat him so I'm very excited for the reveal at the end when I don't feel like an [ __ ] anymore cuz right now dude I know what he's going through I need to get that off touchdown God damn it good ball big play that does not feel like I I feel like I have that baged and I do not damn it nice throw God I'm actually getting [ __ ] screamed at most plays right now though [ __ ] W wait you got those wow good throw I go for two here that's the question H we take the P I wouldn't mind being down three it's so easy to clock when you're down three I need to get a stop first we got to worry about that I need to get you on a big down I need to get you on a big like I don't have the mental fortitude for a clutch conversion right now you dotted up the fourth and 10 earlier to start the game yeah but see like there's no pressure on me on the first drive on the opening drive it's like whatever I turned it over last time I can turn it over again too yes H oh oh someone I got to switch defenses I think I think I have to just getting laser good dots MMG he KS oh your SC pass your drive might have been a little too quick you milk milk a little more time honestly I didn't expect him to catch that but I just wanted to throw yeah you had a three play 76 yard Drive [ __ ] I got to find a way to stop letting you scissor that side every single play this may end up on B but oh he did for the game here we go here we go here we go here we go good ball good D good D good d down oh no he's there oh my god that actually got played [ __ ] I thought that was wide open they broke we up fourth and eight end it six all right all right all right all right oh okay the milkiest milk you've ever seen take I don't think I'm getting this ball back got the double X Factor go pck we'll take three I do not feel good this is bad this is really really bad we believe we oh no I could have turned that corner HT I did stay home stay home stay home oh momes I love you have sex with me I couldn't get a stop I could not get a [ __ ] stop the pro strats dude I'm signing up for a pro tney I'm doing it this has this has solidified my opinion on this what would you say hey thr since last time I played you how would you rape me now like be for real be for real be for real well you're calling actual plays now like you weren't calling actual plays what was I calling before MMG [ __ ] like you can throw to open players and you can adjust and if you're going to like yeah try to be good at the game it doesn't Shock Me Like You can yeah you're putting up points and getting stops I'm just getting yards to stat pad this game's over GG's I fumbled that get up get up I'm catching that though Jesus Christ dude game's hilarious oh my God oh my God sorry I was I was going to get you in a call with one of my coaches but oh [ __ ] it's with kmx I can't believe you knew dude I mean you I'm I'm going to I'm going to start the call right now a few moments later bro he you know want throw kmac he said you play like kmac I'm probably the second play of the game thr thr were you were you suspicious at all that that was not me playing not necessarily I have a confession thr oh my God I lost to KAC I lost to KAC oh my life isn't over Dude I KN I knew you thought your life was over I thought it literally to going into today I was like he's a little sketch just like just asking me for a quick game but I like literally thought about it and I was like I wonder if I would be able to tell if I was playing someone else my God and bro was adjusting like dude you you said like I was scissoring and Manning up and I had to deafen and look at my camera go what the [ __ ] you're scissoring my running back every [ __ ] play like that's [ __ ] hilarious oh my God okay I honestly felt like a dick I was like I can't wait till this is over so I can tell him dude because he he actually thinks I'm FL I'm clearly like tight like I'm not this is not a game I want to lose like but get blown out holy [ __ ] my job was I was going to have to go get a job I was on indeed already [ __ ] searching for [ __ ] during that fourth quarter holy [ __ ] yeah no km just shared his screen with me on like my iPad and I was just watching him play dude that's hilarious could you hear me the whole time yeah I can hear you the whole time I was nervous though bro I got the fourth intend to start I thought I was dead yeah I was too I was like wait what if I like had K do this and then he just gets flooded and he like throws it would be a hell game but like just would have been a hell game like it's like regs and I almost lost last time so I was like dude like I lowkey wanted to tell you to to tell Throne to use a [ __ ] you guys are amazing thank you both so much for doing this I I can't wait to post this you guys are awesome oh God GG's I appreciate you having me out thank you you're the perfect guy though I'm sorry like cuz you're really good and I and take losing really personally like I do not like losing I [ __ ] hate it about that that was like the most metal reaction right there dude yo you guys throne and kmac both did this literally just to be homies like that's so nice to them both of their channels are listed down below check them out uh these are my two my best friends M I love these guys so yeah huge shout out to them that went flawlessly oh my God I didn't expect it to go like that love you boys thanks for watching as always I'll see you in the next video peace | MMG | UCaYxyR9mzVlTrOOyZD0XAmA | 2024-01-02 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,420 | 11,668 |
4midQCiwFME | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4midQCiwFME | ALLOW ME TO RE INTRODUCE MYSELF | my name is Melanie aka Melanie Valerie fit I'm an online coach and I've been training for about five years I currently live in Austin Texas [Music] so working with as many clients as I do I understand that I can't be everywhere at once so I wanted to offer a program that allows them to work out with me on a timely schedule that works best for them in their lifestyle I see myself for my clients and I realized that if I had the proper guidance and education in the beginning of my fitness journey I would have reached my goals so much sooner so my purpose now is to guide and educate my clients so that they're confident and free to carry on their fitness journey all on their own I think a healthy routine starts with you finding a routine that works best around your schedule and that's convenient for you is how you're gonna keep this routine so for me it's always been the gym what used to be something that was forced is now a habit that I cannot live without I still have days that I'm not the most motivated but then I remember back why I started and I reflect on all of the things that I've gained that are so much more than just physical I was a very active child growing up my dad was a bodybuilder and athlete and my mother knew the importance of staying active and she instilled that into myself and all of my siblings but I still fell into a pretty hardcore party stage in my early 20s that went on for too long and I lost control and long story short I put on a ton of weight and I just that was a moment that I decided it was time to take control of my life again and I'm so happy that I did because since then it's been a total transformation both mentally and physically so the lack of booty was basically my biggest insecurity growing up because of my lack of education I didn't think it was possible to grow a booty but the fact is is that the glutes are 100% all muscle and yes you can grow a booty so this is why my program is mostly focused on lower body and I'm pretty confident than I've nailed what it takes my mother has always been my biggest inspiration the wisdom and light that she brings to everyone's life is truly special and I've witnessed it my whole life as I get older I see myself becoming more and more like my mom and that just tells me that I'm doing it right I feel like I've found my path being my own boss waking up and doing what I love every day and making a living stress-free and I just hope to inspire others to do the same I don't really have a big end goal I just believe in making a big impact reaching out to as many people in a positive way accepting new opportunities with an open mind and crossing off goals that I never knew I even had and for this I'm happy my name is Melanie and this is my cartel training challenge | Melanie Valerie | UCsYc8_90ZBk12F-xLf6alhQ | 2018-09-26 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 550 | 2,777 |
O9LfQufAnzk | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9LfQufAnzk | unwrapping my massive CHRISTMAS BOOK HAUL! 🎄🎁 come unwrap all my christmas presents with me! | it's Christmas hello my friends welcome back to one of my favorite videos to film every single year we're gonna be doing a Christmas unboxing haul unwrapping with you ideas every single year where I unwrap my Christmas presents my book Christmas presents that I've received from you guys and for my family the Christmas jumper is on I'm so excited Merry Christmas so I am speechless I'm gonna be honest you guys have been so generous with sending me some books for Christmas I like I am so thankful and appreciative it's so very kind of you every year I cannot believe how generous and kind you guys are so we're gonna unbox these my family also got me some I asked them to get me less this year so I've got five from my family I was so excited if you know me you know I love Christmas these are my favorite videos film I love seeing what you guys have picked at me or my family have picked to get me they often pick great so we'll start with what you guys have gifted me I actually feel sick I'm sad okay first first book wow okay these are all the parcels that I have this one's a tricky one to open so I've oh there we go um received since the start of December I have saved them all oh this one's this one's in a wrapping oh okay what does the card say happy holidays from Caitlyn thank you Caitlin let's see oh we've gone stay awake by Megan Golding oh my God exciting exciting exciting okay this is Megan golding's release from this year if you don't like the UK cover that's what we have in the UK okay but I have been so excited about this I really enjoyed the night swim by Megan Golding when I read it uh last year I think I read it last year I just think her writing is so good and the premise of this one is our protagonist wakes up in a taxi with no idea how she got there and she sees or written on her hand stay awake and I think she wakes up with like a knife in her hand I don't know why the taxi driver let her into the taxi with a like a bloodied knife in her hand wow crazy you're crazy girl and I think it's a crime and it says stay awake or something similar like in blood I don't know I have heard so many good things about this everyone has really been enjoying it I think it's just gonna be like a fun quick fast-paced Thriller it has looks like it has like a redixoma chapter so like a chapter is literally just like a page long so it's gonna be really fast paced and I think it's a very unique premise I really like books that are kind of playing with like a speculative element a thriller with a spectative element so yes oh my God thank you so much okay land number two let's see what we've got I love Christmas who got this they know their stuff oh Jenny Jenny Jenny Jenny you're so kind what has Jenny said as a fellow Chrissy devotee I had to add this to your hardback collection and naturally this is the perfect time thank you for another year of incredible content watching your channel always brings me joy Jenny Jenny got me the adventure of the Christmas pudding by Agatha Christie look at her are we not obsessed but she's beautiful right but she's beautiful I love these hardcover designs that harpercollins have been doing oh my god look on the inside yeah I love these hardbacks that harpercons have been doing and this is perfect this is I think gonna be my Christmas read next year this year I'm reading a Christmas romance across the few Christmas days I think I'll go back to an Agatha Christie Christmassy mystery this is six stories first collected together by Agatha herself thank you so much Jenny that is so incredibly kind and I love I love the design of this one okay wow thank you so much this parcel took a little bit of a battering oh okay we've got the retreat by Sarah Pierce so this is um the author of The sanatorium which I have read and we're following the same character I believe the same detective this is from Amy Merry Christmas of course I had to get my Facebook tuber something hope you enjoy Queen from Amy Amy thank you so much so I have been really excited to read The Retreat I thought the sanatorium was a pretty good debut so the sanatorium it's like this converted old television made to a luxury hotel I would say the first two thirds of it were great in my opinion like such Fast Pace like a really good mystery thriller hybrid where you've got a mystery running throughout it feels you've got detective but also there was like moments where my heart was pounding you know like in a good thriller does that was [ __ ] scary my heart's going Pizza patter Pitta patter I feel sick like I could throw up so I'm excited about this one I think this is about a yeah a wellness Retreat off the coast of Devon a woman is found dead but then there's another victim and we've got the same detective from the sanatorium so we're kind of following her story she's got a lot of storylines to do with trauma and stuff and there's some Cliffhangers from the sanatorium so thank you so much I'm so excited you guys are picking such good ones I mean they're all books on my wish list so like you can't really pick badly okay next one oh gosh my heart is racing oh oh my God oh my God oh my God oh my God oh my God oh my God oh my God oh my God okay I didn't think anyone would get this one Clara Clara says Merry Christmas this was a surprising five-star read for me this year I hope you enjoy it and it is poster Girl by Veronica Roth so here's the situation with this one I never read from the cross was which one was she which which early 2010s sci-fi dystopia was it Divergent it's run across Divergent I feel like we're on a cross Divergent anyways I never read Veronica Roth when she was that girly back in the day it doesn't tell me under also by Veronica Roth it only says chosen one so we're pretending the past didn't exist we are going to pretend we didn't hear that so yeah I was never interested in that that's not my kind of thing this is dystopian-esque though I recently this year read the forward collection which is six sci-fi really short novellas and for me the Veronica Roth one which is Arc I believe was by far the best one it was so good it was so like it made me really emotional and like you know it's only like 20 30 pages long and so I've been really intrigued by this and I love the cover for it I think it's so cool it's a haunting dystopian mystery that explores the expanding role of surveillance on society an inescapable reality that we welcome all too easily I'm super interested in this after reading Arc I'm super intrigued and this also has like a mystery running through it about a missing child I think we're following like the X poster girl of the regime who is now in jail and has the offer to be freed if she tries to find this missing girl so I didn't think anyone would get this but I've heard really good things about this and I feel like I loved I was so shocked at how much I loved Arc the that what a great pick bestie next one wow this I love Christmas [Applause] so this is from Oh Maya one of my patrons thank you Maya I just read this one it reminded me of Darker wants and future witches so Maya has sent me nettle and Bone by T Kingfisher I'm so excited this makes me so happy there's loads of taking fish on my wish list because I I want to get into taking Fisher everyone's been loving obsessed with taking pressure this year and I've never read anything by her I'm beyond excited oh my God this is probably gonna be my first taking Fisher I'm speaking too fast I know I am I'm so sorry take a deep breath calm down I know this one is about a girl whose sister is married to an abusive Prince and I think she wants to rescue her I've heard such good things about this I know marvel really liked this one and me and Mara are the son of a book Twins or at least I'm pretty sure Marla is one yes I am because Mara is one who I've heard talking about it the most yes I'm pretty sure it's on Mars but was it on Mara's best off my memory was really bad anyways I feel like taking Fisher could become a new favorite author for me I feel like you know the people who I typically have very similar reading tastes to have absolutely been loving taking Fisher this year so well Maya what a wonderful Choice thank you so so much next one let's see what we have oh my God you guys you are so kind I just can't get over it thank you so much okay what oh okay this is gonna be a difficult one to read okay so this is from Meg thank you so much Meg I recently listened to this audiobook which I can highly recommend I think everyone should read this hope you enjoy it Meg has really kind of gifted to Me Know My Name by Chanel Miller I am scared to read this I know it's going to be heavy Chanel Miller was the woman who was sexually assaulted by Brock Turner and she wrote that impact statement that was very like became viral everyone when she was I think still Anonymous know my name she is telling her story I'm not sure if I'm gonna be able to listen to audiobook I'm going to be quite honest I may just have to read it physically but I have heard so much wonderful wonderful things about this speaking of Mara I do know this was Mara's top non-fiction of this year she gave it five stars I don't know if if excited to read this is the right word but I do want to get back into reading more non-fiction and this is one that I want to put really high up my list because is I have just heard so many wonderful things about it and I think stories like this are you know like mix says everyone should read this are incredibly important to be heard so thank you so so much for gifting this to me next one let's see what we got oh this looks pretty oh okay okay who is this from let's see oh my God okay this is from my secret Santa so over on my patreon um this year we ran a secret Center and this is from I don't know who this is from this is from my secret Santa how exciting so my secret Santa has done like this is a great pick has picked Sea of Tranquility by Emily St John Mandel I recently read the glass it's right here can I reach it oh I read the glass Hotel this year I want to say at the start of this year and I really enjoyed it I loved her writing I actually do like how these look together they look cute together right I was actually surprised how much I really enjoyed the glass hotel and so it made me really want to pick up all of Emily St John Mandel stuff so what is this one about I've forgotten oh girl too much drama for me I've forgotten because every Saint John Mandel's part is always impossible to describe the Sea of Tranquility is a virtuoso performance a novel that investigates the idea of parallel worlds and possibilities and plays with the very line along which time should run okay fine that's all I need to know I'm just I'm going to read more Emily St John Manda I really like this cover as well I'm so excited I just thought her writing just felt so like rich and like detailed but also to the point like it was a very unique style of writing that I hadn't read a lot before three and more gifted from you this is just so kind okay oh okay yes this is from another one of my patrons Lauren who Lauren I love you you're always very very kind Lauren has gifted me the house across the lake by Riley Sega I am so excited through this this is genuinely one of the books that I have been wanting to buy the most because I just want to know I just you know Riley Sega has been a little bit controversial apostrophe is not in terms of like controversy but like dividing opinion you know the past couple years with his releases I didn't love survive the night but I just feel like I'm gonna love this I really do I just have this feeling that I'm gonna love it I don't know I just think she's very delusional and maybe possibly insane I've read every righty Saga my favorite rally Saga the only five star I've ever given him was the last time I lied but I also enjoyed look every door on home before dark I did not enjoy a final girls or survive the night so that's my writing Sega journey and I'm intrigued by this I'm also so excited for his ones coming out next year it sounds really really good but I know this is about a woman who lives across the lake from this couple and she sees I think them fighting and then the woman goes missing I just feel like me and Riley might Vibe on this one this is probably one of the books I've been thinking about the most lately I've really been so excited to read this so Lauren listen you picked so well because I have just been really looking forward to reading this so thank you so much oh this I'm not kidding if I was to buy a book myself of my wish list this has probably been one of the ones I would have bought because I've just been very intrigued by it next one oh what is this oh we have got maybe in another life by Taylor Jenkins read this is from Melanie Merry Christmas Mick hope you have a fantastic festive season I love your content and can't wait to see what you have planned for 2023 Melody thank you so much that is so incredibly kind of you I listen every full-length novel that I have read from Ted Jenkins read I have given five stars now I know I really want to read her back list but I know this is of a different vibe so I'm not necessarily expecting the five star Vibes like I do for her modern books but I have just been so excited to read some of her back lists I think this one is like actually kind of like sci-fi-esque where like we're following the main character's life through two different parallel lives that she could have lived from like one decision that she makes I think which is kind of like I feel like Miss Taylor I was like oh I'm so creative right from the beginning I don't know I feel like I loved her Jenkins writing I always say her writing is just amazing so I feel like I could still give this five stars so thank you so much Melanie final one that you guys picked off my wish list let's see what we have this is one of the books I was most excited for who got this for me of course you did so this book is from one of my patrons Melissa who was just so incredibly kind of chat to Melissa Melissa is just like amazing and this will really helped me run the secret Santa on the patreon this year so Melissa says Merry Christmas I hope you have a wonderful time and a Happy New Year it's all wise under the sea I Melissa I always associate this book with you I have been so excited I love the UK cover isn't the UK cover just like Beyond it's so cool I just noticed about like these wives on this deep sea Mission and their relationship isn't quite right and something strange is going on I am I'm so excited this is um I'm just beyond excited for my 2023 reading guys we're just gonna kill it I can't wait this is a five-star prediction for me I would say I just think it's gonna be my kind of thing it's gonna be this quiet introspective hover I'm I'm so excited then let's get into because my family have gotten me so we've got two that my grandparents have gotten me first let's open these oh yes yes yes yes yes okay so I love the cover for this one okay we have got death on gokuan Island by Sushi yokomizo I love this cover so this is now my third in the series that I haven't read that I own but I should get through some of them soon so sugar miso is a very famous Japanese mystery author and uh Pushkin vertigo are slowly translating his books this is the fourth one that has been translated and it's kind of like Golden Age crime but from Japan and I just think it's so interesting to read this stuff and to you know see what mystery tropes pervade across cultures and which ways they're different I've only read the first one that got translated the 100 murders but I do want to make my way through all of these okay wait the detective the main detective like the pyro arrives bringing news of a death it triggers a series of grotesquely staged murders what the hell okay I'm super duper duper excited what a great pick what have we got next let's see I'm pretty sure my dad dropped these and he is just like it's impossible to get oh this is one I've been so excited for I'm pretty sure this is one I heard again from Mara just this song book apparently in defense of witches why women are still on trial by Mona Charlotte so this was originally written in French it's been translated into English yeah this is basically about the history of women being framed as witches and Witchcraft and the way in which kind of witch archetypes modern witches or how that's been kind of the idea of a witch has now pervaded into modern society as well I am so intrigued by this I also really like the cover I think it's so cool and again hoping to read and the iOS is every year but I really am hoping to read more non-fiction so um yes this is one that is on the top of my listing then we've got three from my parents as well let's see what we've got they always pick really good books so let's see what we've got oh yes oh this would be perfect to read now maybe I'll have to read this in January or February we have got wiped out which is the sequel to blackout this is a kind of I don't want to call it an anthology in a way that like this is where authors have all written separate short stories it's by Daniel Clayton Tiffany D Jackson Nick Stone Andrew Thomas Ashley woodfolk and Nicola Yoon and it's like a romance book that they all kind of write separate parts of but it all comes together in one and this one is set just before Christmas oh my God I'm not gonna read this right now it has to wait it'll either be in January February or I will save it to next year I really love to black out and again I thought how it was different from a typical Anthology really set it apart in that like their story is all connected and overlapped and it was obviously planned this all together so when I heard they were coming out with white out I was incredibly excited oh my God we've got like texts and stuff so it sign in okay yes I love it I love it well great pig man I am so proud of her I could cry then what is this oh I knew she'd pick this we have got the cat who saved books can you you can't really see the cover it's like the light whoa I don't really know much about this other than it's about a cat and bugs I know a lot of people have been really enjoying it it's very short I knew my mum would pick it we love cats look at the cat I mean come on I think it's about a little like secondhand book shop that exists and a cat there I don't know I've heard it's pretty touching emotional I mean it's about cats and books they're literally my two favorite things so I'm pretty sure I'm gonna love this um and yeah I knew this would be one that my mom would pick because she just sees cat and she goes right click and then final why did they say Love Steve and Jen love mum and dad guys come on oh okay yes yes yes another non-fiction that I've been super excited for we have got undocked by Adam K so this is the author of this is going to hurt which I've spoken about quite a few times but if you don't know that was the Diaries of Adam K while he was a junior doctor in the NHS and it's very harrowing it's very emotional it's very angrying but joy feel like it's incredible it's so well done and I believe this is him kind of writing more of a reflection on what it was like to leave being a doctor because he he quit alternating between Hospital admissions and personal ones this book looks back at mk's extraordinary medical education and the scars that he has been left with he's very funny right the books are super funny they have kind of this dark humor to them that I feel like in order to work in the NHS in the present day and have some semblance of like sanity after it's been so wrecked by the conservative government here in the UK um yeah you have to have so I'm really really excited to read this my mum probably picked it because she also loved this is kinda so great pick mum can I get all these books can I hold them all up at the same time let's see whoa these are all the books I got for Christmases yeah I am so happy there are so many there that I am just so incredibly excited to read so thank you I'm gonna put this down again thank you so so much to any of you that got me a Christmas gift from my wish list I cannot tell you how thankful and appreciative I am it truly means so much and it I'm just so thankful so thank you so much I hope that you guys had a wonderful Christmas if you do celebrate it let me know which of these that you have enjoyed or let me know which of these that you want me to read so you know if you want to read it or not I would love to know uh if you got into the end comment any kind of Christmasy Emoji down below Christmas tree wrap presents Santa Claus anything Christmasy down below thank you guys so much for watching and I'll see you very soon in another video bye [Music] foreign [Music] | megwithbooks | UC7p6EBNVA4bSzDdzl3bL_GA | 2022-12-27 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 4,154 | 20,901 |
4AAkzspXzgw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AAkzspXzgw | Senate Sitting - 3 December 2020 | honorable Senators the president almighty God we humbly beseech thee devou safe thy special blessing upon this Parliament and that thy woulds be pleased to direct and prosper the work of thy servants to the advancement of th glory and to the true welfare of the people of Australia Our Father who art in heaven Hallowed be thy name thy kingdom come thy will be done on Earth as it is in heaven give us this day our daily bread and forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us and lead us not into temptation but Deliver Us from Evil for thine is the kingdom and the power and the glory forever and ever amen I acknowledge the N of Will and Gam peoples who are the traditional custodians of the CRA area and pay respect to the elders past and present of all Australia's indigenous peoples are there any documents to be tabled by the clerk clerk Mr President I table documents pursuant to statute as listed on today's order of business are there any proposals for committees to meet during the sittings of the Senate yes Mr President committees have lodged proposals as shown at item three of today's order of business I remind Senators the question may be put on any proposal at the request of any Senator there being none I call the oh sorry was someone seeking the call no I call the clar government business order of the day number one Australia's Foreign Relations State and territory Arrangements Bill 2020 and a related Bill further consideration in Committee of the whole the committee is considering the Australia's Foreign Relations State and territory Arrangements bills of 2020 and a related Bill the question is that the bill bs stand as agreed as amended be agreed to sorry senator Rice you seeking the call I am thank you um chair look I seek I seek leave to move amendments four and five on sheet 178 together is leave granted there being no objection leave is granted Senate to rise thanks chair and look I will just move these I don't need to speak to them they cover the same issues that we have covered at length yesterday today about putting some more checks and balances in this bill getting Clarity not having the same complete um control and power that the minister would have so so setting in place some guidelines for how decisions are going to be made and setting in place a definition of foreign policy but as I said in the interest of time I won't speak anymore about them because I think we have canvased the issues that um the that they cover in a lot of detail yesterday thank you thank you Senator R Senator Wong uh just to enable the minister to give herself time to uh take a seat in the chamber can I just indicate the opposition will be supporting Amendment four but voting against amendment five and I'd ask that you put them separately on that basis thank you Senator Wong so I'll put um the F number four first so the question is that Amendment four on sheet 1078 be agreed to uh that the amendment be agreed to those of that opinion say I Against I believe the NOS have it certainly we can agree to that yes thank you so I'm now going to put the second part of that so the question is that amendment five on sheet 1078 that that Amendment be agreed to those of that opinion say I I against no uh I believe the nose have it senator Rice the votes of the greens in favor of that Amendment could be recorded thank you yes we can do that thank you very much and senator Rice you seeking the call again yes I am look I want to move um Amendment Six on sheet um 1078 and this is to basically remove a clause from the bill um on because at the moment the bill says that um that the minister is not required to observe any requirements of procedural fairness in exercising a power or function or performing a function under this act and we think this is pretty unreasonable we think that it's basic legis legislation standards and in fact common law standards are that procedural fairness should be allowed when this bill went to the scrutiny bills committee um the scrutiny bills said the committee considers the right to procedual fairness is a fundamental common law right and it expects that any limitation on this right be comprehensively justified um scrutiny of bills did not consider that the def that the explanation in the explanatory memorandum was at all satisfactory as to why procedural fairness should be excluded um wrote to the minister um and certainly on the further information that we've got back from the minister there was okay no no The Minister's not seeking call that's right not seeking to call that's right um certainly having having seen that letter um there is not any further justification from my eyes as to why procedural fairness should be excluded mean the right to procedural fairness basically is based on two things it requires that decision makers aren't biased and do not appear to be biased and that a person who may be adversely affected by decision is given an adequate opportunity to put their case before the decision is made I think these are two very very basic requirements and there is no reason in this legisl no reason why procedural fairness should be excluded in this legislation thank you senator Rice so the question is that Amendment Six on sheet 1078 that the clause 58 standards printed oh sorry Minister thank you um chair in relation to uh to Senator Rice's Amendment and uh just uh quickly uh and understand uh in the normal course of events uh issues such as this in relation to procedural fairness are uh are raised but this is a different form of legislation the inclusion of procedural fairness would re require the disclosure to a state or territory ENT entity where there was a likelihood of an adverse decision of the specific foreign policy considerations for why the adverse decision was likely um it is the view that it is not appropriate for sensitive decisions on foreign policy or foreign relations to be shared it's a well established principle that information relating to Australia's International Foreign Relations is not required to be released and there are numerous examples of this the Freedom of Information Act 1982 Which exempts documents affecting National Security defense or international relations the archives Act of 1983 provides access may be refused if releasing the information would damage Australia's security defense or international relations under the criminal code there are offenses for Commonwealth officers who cause harm to Australia's interests by communicating information that causes harm to Australia's interests including information that harms or prejudices Australia's international relations public interest immunity considerations also include damage to Australia's international relations particularly in instances where the information relates to exchanges between government officials it does not in our view make sense and it is damaging to Australia to reverse a long-standing principle in in the context of this bill if the sensitive foreign policy information were excluded from such disclosures the opportunity for procedural fairness would not actually be meaningful uh the exclusion of procedural fairness does not prevent state or territory entities from Consulting defat in relation to arrangements or relevant foreign policy consideration relevant policy considerations prior to a formal notification thank you Minister Senator Wong for the reasons previously the outline but will be support uh no we're not I thought oh this is the other way around support the amendment support the amendment it's a backwards one senator Rice you um thank you Minister for that response I mean do you have any legal advice that um suggests that in this bill that requirements of procedural fairness would require disclosing sensitive information Senator Russ we don't comment on legal advice in that nature but in this in a discussion such as this but uh I've been clear I think throughout the debate in relation to the sensitivity of the s sorts of matters that this bill goes to uh and uh the examples that I have just provided uh I think from the foi act from uh the um archives act from the criminal code indeed uh go to the seriousness of these issues um we're not talking about basic administrative decisions Senator we are talking about decisions in relation to foreign policy and Foreign Relations senator Rice thank you but Minister do you have any legal advice because certainly understanding in in the sorts of legislation that you are talking about indeed in this legislation you can have procedural fairness that does not require the disclosure of sensitive information and certainly there was a um discussion by this by the Australian law Reform Commission that basically outlined the procedural fairness was still in place even where um sensitive information didn't was not disclosed Minister chair Senator we have comprehensive legal advice on all aspects of the piece of legislation so the question is that the motion is moved by senator Rice Amendment Six on sheet 1078 that that Clause 58 stand as printed those of that opinion say I I Against I believe the eyes have it division required ring the bells for four minutes e for a I for so stop the bells so the question is that Amendment Six on sheet 1078 uh the question is that Clause 58 stand as printed the eyes shall move to the right of the chair the nose to the left I appoint Senator Davey as teller for the eyes and Senator Chone as tell for the nose e for order there being 31 I and 29 NOS the matter is resolved in the affirmative Senator farooqi thank you uh Madam dep Deputy president um I Rise to seek leave to move amendments 1 to 4 on sheet 1 120 and Amendment 5 on sheet 1 120 together I know um Madame Deputy president that they will be voted on separately but I'd like to move them together if I get the leave thank you Senator faruki is leave granted leave is granted thank you Senator faruki um thank you Madame Deputy president um this government has presided over the complete Devastation of universities this year um the the complete Devastation absolutely $1 billion per year of fun co-funding cuts d in a face for many degrees leaving International students completely abandoned during this time of Crisis that they have to line up outside food banks to put food in their stomach uh and not lifting a finger to stop thousands of uni jobs being cut actually allowing that to happen right under their watch so what you know one day they want University autonomy and want to want to wash their hands off any resp responsibility that they have for universities and the next day they come in here wanting to crap crack the whip on universities so we side with the university sector who says that this bill and the inclusion of universities in this bill is going to be damaging to them because this bill has extraordinary scope and it's seemingly um you know it's kind of dressed up but it is really up to the whim of the government of what they think the interest is on a particular day is how they're going to operate and I have to say nothing that the minister said in response to the questions from Senator Wong or Senator R has convinced me that it should be otherwise um the government if this bill passes basically can tear up any agreement between Australian universities and overseas organizations and governments and those agreements could underpin vital research something that the government doesn't like um it doesn't have to be International interference for instance or you know cultural issues or joint degrees any of that and you know this attitude of trust us we don't know yet what we do going to do with universities but trust us well I'm sorry we don't really trust you um and the labor party as well I I know that you have stood here over the past 4 days saying universities haven't been consulted um you know labor colleagues have kind of waxed lyrical about the importance of Consulting in engaging with universities properly so you know I would plead to you then to let's support this amendment exclude the universities uh and once the government has consulted the universities even if you want them included then maybe think about that later at this point we just don't know what the government is going to do um so I do commend this amendment to the Senate thank you Senator faruki um Minister oh Minister's giving the call to you thank you Senator Hansen thank you very much I have to respond to that you know sometimes I I hear the greens talk in this chamber and I sometimes wonder are they really here to represent the Australian people or they're all the time talking about overseas countries or foreign students as they are in this case I wonder if they have really taken the time to actually speak to the government with regard to this bill to understand why the universities have been included in this bill really have you really followed up to actually get some understanding and what this why it's in the bill this is about National interest our safety and what we've found through the universities that even students there are collaborating working with the Chinese government in research programs they're getting paid on top of their jobs with the university $150,000 up to $150,000 we don't know what they're doing we have had you know we've built up our national security in this country on cyber attacks and everything like that it is quite understandable to say that if any Agreements are taken up by the university with other foreign countries that we must know what those Agreements are pure and simple to actually drag in foreign students into this as about taking food out of their stomachs is a load of rubbish as far as I'm concerned stick with what this is about the bill and if you really care about this country about national interests then you stand up and you support this bill so if universities are there and I think it's quite sensible and feasible we've spoken about private universities to be included in this which IED to the government that they send out a letter to them and invite them to be part of this because a lot of people in the universities don't understand what the government knows or ago or the federal police understand what is going on and it should be working with a foreign affairs department so I have no problem with it like I said I wish that some members in the place even on the labor side instead of winging and complaining about legislation how many of you have really taken time to sit down and talk to the government about their legislation and the impact it has here instead of all this winging and complaining that goes on all the time half the time you don't really know the full guts of the bill Minister thank you uh chair uh the government does not support uh the grain Amendment uh to remove universities from the bill of course we acknowledge that universities are a major contributor to the Australian economy they are a major exporter they have worldclass standing and uh in with and an increasing Global posture which is absolutely welcomed by the government uh but uh it is a complex and contested world uh chair and one of the things that this bill seeks to do is to ensure that we are working together to ensure consistency in relation to foreign policy and Foreign Relations because Australian public universities are publicly funded institutions established by law with a fundamental role in international research and Partnerships because the status of Australian public universities and their International posture means their foreign Arrangements do have the potential to impact Australia's foreign relations and foreign policy it's also the case though uh and the government has acknowledged this that University Arrangements present a lower degree of risk than State and territory arrangements with foreign National governments and So within the bill they are designated as non-core Arrangements they're subject to fewer requirements and a lesser degree of scrutiny as a consequence of that we will work very closely through the task force in the department of Foreign Affairs and trade with universities to support their efficient and effective engagement uh with the scheme as I set out yesterday in my uh uh discussions uh in the committee stage then with senator Rice and Senator Wong in particular uh the department of Foreign Affairs and trade is consulted uh over many um meetings with uh universities and representative University bodies uh and we will continue to work closely with them in the implementation of the bill should it be passed thank you Minister Senator Wong uh thank you Deputy president um uh uh well we have worked through this uh both in the committee uh and you would have seen from the Amendments uh whilst I understand uh uh the points and the political point that Senator faruki wishes to make we do start from the Bas the the principle or from the proposition that University's International engagement does have implica potential implications for Australia's foreign policy uh and therefore should be subject to regulation uh we have substantial concerns which I have at length outlined I think yesterday uh about the government's uh refusal uh to engage the ministers continued refusal to engage and the fact that the EIT task force uh which uh was doing work on this was bypassed we also have concerns uh about the regulatory gap which has never been explained whereby private universities such as Bond University will have a different uh will be excluded from the operation of the bill however those concerns do not lead us to the proposition uh that the the principle that universities should be subject to regulation in respective foreign Arrangements ought be abated so for that reason uh we we will not be supporting the GRE Amendment as I've express to you uh to publicly um I uh also do note uh that the government has accepted the need for a review of the operation of the bill a narrowing of the definition of arrangements and has provided a definition of institutional autonomy all of which were matters raised and dealt with through the senate committee which we participated with so the question is that the amendments we'll start with the one on sheet uh 1120 moved by Senator farooqi 1 to4 that those amendments be agreed to those of that opinion say I I Against I believe the NOS have it division required ring the bells for four minutes C for e for e [Music] was just here stop the bells so the question is that the motion as moved by Senator farooqi on sheet 1120 uh amendments 1 to 4 the question is that the Amendments be agreed to the I shall move to the right of the chair the nose to the left I appoint Senator seit as teller for the eyes and Senator CH as teller for the knows e for spe order there're being nine eyes and 44 nose the matter is resolved in the negative Senator frui moved uh her two amendments together so I'm going to put the second part of that which is uh amendment five on sheet 1120 and the question is that division that division six of part five stand as printed those of that opinion say I Against I believe the eyes have it the eyes have it it I think Senator fari you're seeking the call Senator fi thank you uh Madam Deputy president um I'd like to move Green's Amendment one on sheet 118 and I was hoping that I actually wouldn't have had to move this amendment because really universities should be excluded but now that's not the case um and uh this amendment really is about at least making sure that the larger projects um or um you know Agreements are the ones that allow this broad scope that the government has to be um looked at by the government so this amendment actually has a threshold amount of $250,000 for the government to be able to to do what they want to do um um and like I said sadly in the absence of uh universities still being excluded in this legislation at least this will minimize some of the damage and the harm um done to universities and the people who work there so I commend the amendment to the to the Senate Minister thank you chair the government uh opposes this amendment um the uh the principles of this bill uh and the uh the motivation behind it are not related to the monetary value of Arrangements such as this nor is the potential impact of the arrangements uh is our view that including a monetary value to limit application of the scheme uh could potentially allow circumvention of the scheme by breaking projects down into smaller amounts uh for uh precisely that reason to uh to avoid its application uh by um uh masking arrangements with monetary value in subsidiary Arrangements which are not within the scheme uh unless head arrangements are caught I also think from an administrative perspective May on occasion be difficult to ascertain the value of certain Rel arrangements and create uncertainty in the Bill's application I don't think this amendment would uh uh go anyway to assisting the implementation of the bill uh at all so the question is that um the amendment be agreed to on sheet 1118 moved by Senator fi all those in favor say I those against say no no I think the NOS have it division required ring the bell four minutes e for great might just e [Applause] e stop the bill the question is that amendment number on sheet 1118 moved by senator farooqi be greed the eyes will move to the right of the chair the nose to the left and I appoint Senators senator seaart for the eyes and Senator exuse him sorry I wasn't sure who was it senator choosing for the notes [Music] for well for [Music] e for excuse me there being nine eyes and 42 nose the matter is therefore resolved in the negative I'll give everyone a moment to return to their seats Senator Wong thank you um acting chair I move uh opposition Amendment 1 on sheet 115 Revis which relates to the port of Darwin lease and this is the opportunity for those who have been complaining about the port of Darwin to actually get some accountability uh from this government about the 99e lease which they have steadfastly refused to be clear about I would make this point even yesterday uh the minister was unable to give it the chamber a clear answer about whether or not the port of Darwin could be subject to this bill that this bill is in effect retrospective so the minister can vet to um Arrangements which have already been put in place prior to the legislation uh being passed uh when asked about the port of Darwin the minister first said that because it was leas with a private entity uh it would be excluded but then could not rule out the potential uh for it to be included within the REM of the legislation on the basis that there was a subsidiary Arrangement and therefore would be subject to the bill uh so what this amendment does is seek to require it would be to require the minister to provide a report so we're not seeking to actually you know take over The Minister's role we're seeking to ensure that there is the transparency around the port of Darwin lease uh that a report be tabled in this chamber that goes to both uh the uh effect of the legislation on the bill but uh on the on the lease but as importantly the effect of the lease on Australia Australia's foreign policy objectives which has been the subject of a number of contributions from Senators around the chamber so I commend the amendment Senator fry Wells thank you madam acting Deputy uh president over the years I have been consistent in my strident criticisms of the decision to lease the port of Darwin to landbridge how can one of our most strategic assets in Northern Australia be leased to accompany with ties to the Communist party uh in um Beijing there have been long concerns about the decision uh attributed to the surveillance and Espionage capabilities presented by the port's close proximity to Australian and US defense facilities as well as concerns about the Strategic purpose of China's investment in the region as part of its Maritime Silk Road I know many Australians who have contacted me do not agree respectfully with the defense ministers comments on 9 September that there are no security concerns regarding the port of Darwin how can this not be a matter of concern indeed I have to say after the events of this week I envisage that there will be renewed focus on the port of Darwin uh and it will become very much symbolic of our political fortitude to stand up to the bullying tactics of the CCP um I think it's important uh to highlight some of the aspects uh that the decision um of on the port of Darwin and they remain perplexing to this day and I know that after it's when in August 2012 the CLP started exploring the privatization of assets including the port there was a process that there were 33 investors including Australian and European companies that expressed an interest including land uh including landbridge um media reports indicated at the time that landbridge was a subsidiary of the shangdong landbridge group a private company uh and that its 2013 billion millionaire owner uh y Chung was named by the Chinese government as one of the top 10 individuals caring about the development of National Defense Shandong was found to have extensive links to the CCP and the pla indeed in an interview in Beijing in 2016 Mr ye stated that the Darwin Port investment fits his company strategy to expand its shipping and energy interests and serve China's foreign policy goal of one built one road now in February 20 2015 the Northern Territory assembly appointed the port of Darwin select committee that that committee went through a process uh and and the evidence from that committee also indicated that the federal government had advised the Northern Territory government that the port was better privatized uh than continuing in government hands now one of the key recommendations uh in its April 2015 report was that an Australian entity control the lease and that there be furb and defense consultations regarding the Strategic and security risks of a potential International investor now uh on 14 Fe Fe uh September uh furb contacted landbridge indicating that the lease was outside the purview of furb review because of a technicality uh that assets owned by state territory and local governments were exempt from Ferb scrutiny to this day that remains the case although there are uh the exception has been modified to some extent uh but it still remains an issue and I think that that's something that we should be looking at but in any case uh on the 13th of October chief minister Giles announced the 90 99e lease valued at $56 million now the lease process does rais some legitimate uh questions as to why given the lead time to this decision uh more effort wasn't made by those uh in key uh Federal positions uh and those advising them to remove uh the federal uh the foreign investment exemption given the National Security implications of allowing such a critical asset to be handed over to an entity with such known uh ties to the CCP and the pla now we do know that at the time the Abbott government was very keen to ensure that a free trade agreement was entered into uh with uh China and indeed uh the Chinese president uh on the 17th of November addressed a joint sitting and the day after the FTA was announced by uh trade Minister Rob uh $8 billion and indeed um subsequent to that uh Rob did leave and became uh a um uh he took on a job with landbridge $880,000 I will leave it at there but those questions still remain open now in its uh report after the uh decision the Senate economics references committee uh examined a number of issues pertinent to the decision and in particular made recommendations regarding that exemption uh Peter Jennings and others uh Neil James also gave evidence they were very very critical of the uh decision and indeed uh as Peter Jenning said we would now have to be Bal uh have our national um security interests balanced against the reality of operating out of a harbor run by a company whose website proclaims it is contributing its best to realize the great Rejuvenation of the Chinese dream now um Neil James there were at the time uh different offers and indeed um an ABC report of 12 March 2019 goes back and looks at some of these offers and the understanding was uh and um cited and that report that article reflects that whilst landbridge was the highest uh was the uh the best offer nevertheless um there were other the second and third offers were very close there too and so as Neil James if land bridges said if NE if land Bridge's offer was the best offer but it introduced a major element of strategic risk for the whole country they should have had the common sense to realize that they take the second best offer or the third best offer and not have any strategic risk now um as I said I have been consistent uh on this issue but also on my criticisms of predatory actions by totalitarian regimes and the state-owned uh entities on on various issues in particular about the acquisition of strategic assets I have advocated for a major overhaul of critical infrastructure uh uh legislation including retaking the port of Darwin and there is AB absolutely no doubt uh as the minister said that were the lease of the port to be considered today it would be subject to furb rules but I also believe um that because the exemption has now been modified uh most likely it would be rejected by the treasurer however um I am disappointed that the foreign investment changes proposed by the treasurer which we will probably be debating uh shortly in this place will not allow a retrospective consideration of the port decision so that possibility under furb rules is not going to be possible now regardless of why the lease was signed uh there are cogent National Security imperatives as to why consideration should be given to Breaking of the lease now it's obvious from the Northern Territory submission to these bills um that there is some contemplation uh of a reacquisition um however I did put specific questions to nor Northern Territory chief minister Gunner uh which weren't uh responded to and they they very much went to this issue and it would have been useful to have uh Mr Gunner give evidence or at least provide responses to those questions so that we could explore the very issues uh and and and the only way that we're going to explore these issues is with information from the Northern Territory government so I say to those opposite a better course of action here would be to um seek the cooperation of the Northern Territory government to provide they have been reluctant in relation to releasing these documents and I would urge those opposite that a better course of action uh rather than getting um another report here uh as is requested is to urge the Northern Territory government to release those documents so that we can make a comprehensive assessment so therefore I mean the minister has answered in the committee stage to the question questions that are the very questions that are raised in this amendment this amendment also raises technical issues that it's not just uh actions in the purview of the minister the foreign minister but it's actually action in the purview of other ministers including the treasurer that will be required to take action and so there is I believe a technical problem uh with this amendment now I won't I won't repeat um my concerns about this bill which I outlined in the second ing speech suffice to say that I believe that this amendment will not lead to any report uh I believe that would be useful I think that it is a futile exercise because we already know the outcome and the outcome is that there will not be a retaking of the port of Darwin under this legislation now um as I have said um there are other opportunities and I believe that I have been advised that there are circumstances which may provide cause for the lease to be broken uh including a failure by the port operator to meet legislative requirements if the company were to become insolvent failure to meet defense access requirements and in the event that defense powers are exercised Minister uh thank you uh chair the uh government does not support uh this amendment and uh we discussed it in debate in committee stage uh for some uh time yesterday the government absolutely recognized that foreign investment must be in our national interest foreign investment is a vital source of funds to maintain enhance Australia's infrastructure networks our assets investment in critical infrastructure however must not be contrary to the National interest I can confirm to the chamber again that the port of daan arrangement was not covered by the foreign investment regime in 2015 but given the changes that have been made since 2015 by this government similar Leasing and acquisition proposal proposals would now be recover would now be covered and would require a formal furb process going forward prime minister repeated in June of this year during the announcement of the upcoming foreign investment reforms the Darwin Port was not sold with the approval or the authority of the Commonwealth it was not at that time sales of assets by territory government state governments did not require did not call in the authority of the foreign investment review board or the treasurer as a result of that I engaged with all the states and territories and had the rules changed and that came into effect in March of 2016 uh as the Prime Minister has said the um lease decision was solely on the basis of the decision of the Northern Territory government and of course that decision could only be explained by the Northern Territory government over the time the the issues in the system that that sale identified were addressed by our government indeed by the Prime Minister when he was Treasurer uh in March 2016 the then Treasurer added those additional safeguards to Australia's foreign investment framework working with the states and territories the government amended the foreign investment re the foreign Acquisitions and takeovers regulation so that the furb uh would assess the sale of critical state-owned infrastructure assets to private foreign investors in addition uh chair in 2017 the government established the critical infrastructure Center the center provides coordinated and comprehensive assessments of National Security risks to critical infrastructure in the ports water electricity gas and Telecommunications sectors Center is also responsible for the administration of the security of critical infrastructure act 201 18 that act also established a critical infrastructure asset register and ministerial Last Resort directions power to manage the risks to water electricity gas and Port assets these legislative measures must ensure the government knows who owns and operates a most critical assets and is able to mitigate any identified National Security risks of course departments coordinate on this basis they bring matters of concern to the attention of the treasurer uh who then consults across government including with my department and where necessary with the foreign minister with uh as necessary and appropriate on the ramifications on the National Security risks coordinated identified I'm sorry the previous reforms that uh have been made by the coalition government will both complement and will be added to by the comprehensive reforms for the foreign investment review framework introduced to Parliament by the government in October of this year these are reforms which also address National Security risks including those related to critical infrastructure and they strengthen the existing system particularly as it relates to compliance by foreign Investments uh so I reassure the Senate uh assure the Senate that the government takes these issues very seriously we will always act in the National interest as clearly shown by the development of this Foreign Relations bill which will necessarily address a separate but just as important Gap in our overall system Senator Fair Bry Wells thank you can I just ask uh Minister as part of the stock take that uh you have indicated to the chamber I would envisage that part of that stock take would include approaches to the state and territories including the Northern Territory which to this date has been reluctant to release any of those documents and release those documents publicly and as I understand release those documents to the Commonwealth itself so as part of that stock take Would we envisage that um without the cooperation of the states and territories and in particular without the cooperation of the Northern Territory government labor government uh we will NE we won't be able to be in a position to make a comprehensive assessment uh of what is the port of Darwin issue Minister uh Senator thank you for your question uh thank you chair Senator I'm not going to speculate as I have kned through this entire debate uh on specific examples in particular cases because that is the purpose of the stock take but we are working closely with the states and territories including the Northern Territory who were part of the consultations that I outlined in detail to the chamber yesterday uh in relation to uh to these matters uh once the bill sets out the requirements that states and territories are required to respond to uh in the stock take process and the task force uh is working with those uh State and territory um agencies uh then I would hope and expect that states and terries would constructively work with the Commonwealth to address these issues so the question is that the amendment circulated on sheet 1115 revised by Senator Wong be agreed to all those in favor say I those against say no the nose have it division required ring the bells for 4 minutes spe [Music] e okay it's probably the last for I'm spe stop the bells so the question is that Amendment as circulated on sheet 1115 revised and moved by Senator Wong be agreed to the eyes will move to the right of the chair the nose to the left and I appoint senator urat for the eyes and Senator Davey for the nose for e there being 28 eyes and 27 nose the matter is therefore resolved in the affirmative that being the end of our amendments that I understand the question now is that the bills as amended be agreed to those in favor those in favor say I those against no the eyes have it the question now is that the bills be reported those in favor say I those against say no the committee has considered the Australian Foreign Relations State and territory Arrangements Bill 2020 and a related Bill and agreed to them with amendments minister Minister thank you chair I move the report be adopted those in favor of the motion that the report be oh sorry Senator Wong thank you uh I move the following Amendment to the report from the committee of a hall uh has this been circulated it has which I think has been circulated but I'm happy to read it if the chamber wishes me to do so it simply relates to ensuring that the annual report um which we have previously inserted into the legislation will be referred to the foreign AFF def Affairs defense and trade legislation committee for inquiring report Minister thank you uh chair um Senator Wong and I did um speak about this uh very very briefly uh and I did that without the um amendment in front of me but is an amend of continuing effect um I don't believe it's just consequential to the uh resolution to the amendment that the chamber agreed in relation to work to the annual report uh and uh in that case the government will oppose the amendment Senator Wong well this thank you for um you know giving me notice of the fact that you are not going to agree with what we agreed previously at the table and I just say yet again here as a minister on a bill we agree we I se leave to make further granted is granted I mean really we we have we have written to this Minister we have uh invited them to negotiate on amendments there has been silence as a result she has not had the outcome in the chamber that she wanted uh all for one to picking up the phone actually having a discussion now we have uh frankly an absurd prop proposition that a bill uh which has been amended to include an annual report really an uncontroversial amendment that would require that report to go to a committee that the government controls a committee that the government controls she's now going to oppose I mean you you want to fight when you don't need to have one there's an annual report yeah we can we can send it to a references committee it is a very responsible and sensible amendment to send it to a committee the government controls Minister thank you chair and Senator Wong you would be sadly mistaken if you thought that I was seeking a fight I'm not seeking a fight I am well Senator Wong we had an informal discussion sorry i s leave to make gred thank you thank you chair um let me repeat if Senator Wong thinks I'm seeking a fight she's sadly mistaken and she most certainly will know if I am uh but I would say on this um on this matter on this matter well Senator that's not my intention whatsoever uh on this matter Senator I don't think this is um merely a consequential Amendment to the amendment that was agreed by the ch in relation to the annual report I accept of course I accept that that that is agreed by the chamber and now forms part of the bill Senator there is no question in relation to that but if uh with the provision of the annual report the chamber is then minded uh to uh to refer it to a committee at the time then that will be a matter for the chamber but this is an order of continuing effect Senator it's not a minor Amendment and the government doesn't support it Senator Wong for a two- minute statement if I may by leave but is leave granted leave is granted U of no more than two minutes um just so we are clear and Coalition Senators can be very clear what we are now going to be have a division on we are having a division because the minister is refusing to have an order which requires an annual report which has now been inserted in the bill to go to a committee that the government controls so the oh senator Rice do you you say Okay need to S speak to the motion look and the greens the greens will be supporting this supporting this motion for having this report and continuing effect reporting um what has occurred under this legislation having having been in place it is a tiny measure that we have been able to get through this chamber to provide some level of accountability for this bill it is a tiny measure which is why we will support it but overall in terms of the bill overall all look the greens position is you know we know that issues of foreign interference are serious and we know that it is far preferable if we could have the Commonwealth the states the territories universities local governments actually working collaboratively coherently together to make sure that their interactions with foreign governments foreign universities are in the national interests and the greens would have supported reasonable legislation that aimed to do that legislation that was developed collaboratively cooperatively with input from the states and territories and the universities and local governments before the legislation was put into this place but we cannot support this legislation as I said this motion is to have an annual report on the legislation but other than that this legislation gives unbridled power to the foreign minister without as I said hasn't been developed in consultation with affected parties it hasn't got definitions in it there were no guidelines as to how decisions are going to be made as to whether to override decisions that Sovereign governments have made with foreign entities there are no reasons for decisions that have to be made that have to be issued to people who are going to be affected who have had their decisions over overrided there is retrospectivity so States and territories universities they can enter into Arrangements and at some stage in the future because foreign policy is deemed to have changed then suddenly their Arrangements can be overridden there is no procedural fairness as we discussed earlier on today it has all been just trust us that everything will be fine just trust us well frankly Minister and frankly this government we do not trust you and you have got form in not being able to be trusted in actually working collaborative cooperatively and working genuinely with everyone one to be making sure that things are occurring in the National interest and in the National and in the interest of all Australians not just your vested interest not just the people that you happen to get on with so look the greens overall as I said we would have supported legislation that went to the the issue the serious issue that we were facing but overall we are supporting this amendment as one tiny measure but overall we cannot support this legislation Minister thank you uh very much a s leave to make a short statement leave is not granted so the question is that the amendment moved by Senator Wong to the report from Committee of the whole be agreed to those in favor say I those against say no the nose have it the eyes have it divisions required ring the bells for four minutes ch e Happ pleas that's for spe stop the bels the question is that the amendment to the report of the committee of the whole moved by Senator Wong be agreed to those in favor say I sorry sorry those in favor move to the right of the chair those against to the left and I appoint Senator McCarthy for the eyes and Senator McGrath for the nose spe I'm [Music] for to the result of the division is eyes 31 nose 27 the matter is therefore resolved in the affirmative and the question now is that the report from the committee of the whole as amended be adopted all those in favor say I those against say no the eyes have it Minister thir third reading thank you uh Madame acting deput president I'm Mo Bill be at a third time those in favor of the bill being Senator Wong thank you I understand that the government made a mistake on an earlier Division and I understand I was just giving you time to get briefed because I'd been briefed by text message that the government is going to seek to recommit the vote so as long as the procedure is followed and and perhaps the manager or the minister can explain the oppos Position will in order in accordance with the usual conventions allow the vote to be recommitted I understand that there was an error in the um arrangements for the vote on um Amendment 1115 1115 and the government seeks to recommit the vote okay so in that case the move we we so we will move that motion that 1115 be agreed to those in favor say I those against say no the NOS have it thank you thank you very much for that so Minister thank you m AC Deputy president I move Bill be ready the third time the motion is that the bill be read a third time all those in favor say I against say no the eyes have it division required ring the bells for four minutes e St that [Music] for spe for it's e stop the bills the question is that the bill be read a third time those eyes will move to the right of the chair their nose to the left and I appoint senator mcgraph for the eyes and senator sewart for the nose e that's for e the result of the division is eyes 41 nose 9 the matter is therefore resolved in the affirmative I call the clerk Australia's Foreign Relations State and territory Arrangements Bill 2020 Australia's Foreign Relations State and territory Arrangements consequential amendments Bill 2020 government business order of the day number two electoral Amendment territory representation Bill 2020 second reading debate would honor Senator McCarthy shall I wait is there would honorable me Members please leave the chamber quietly to and resume your seat but of course if you want to hear about the Northern Territory please stay please stay because we got some some great news to talk about here uh thank you Madame acting Deputy president and uh given uh that we've had uh a fairly hectic morning here uh with previous bills I'm absolutely delighted to be able to get to my feet on behalf of the people of the Northern Territory and speak about a bill of absolute importance in preserving the seats of Solomon and the seat of lingiari for the people of the Northern Territory that's what this bill is all about my speech today is really to the people of the Northern Territory and also to the people on Christmas and cus killing Islands thank you for your support in ensuring that we did not lose our voice in the Australian parliament in fact our voices in the Australian Parliament many of you provided submissions to the uh joint select committee on electoral matters and spoke so passionately about the need for Democratic fairness and the rights of territory and the Indian Ocean territories to be heard in the House of Representatives so this speech goes out to you to our first Nations communities our organizations to our Ranger groups to our Farmers to the cattle industry to the mining industry to the fishos amateur and Commercial alike to our health workers on the front line whether you're working in our hospitals in our clinics in the remote and Ro Regional areas of the Northern Territory and the Indian Ocean territories this is about you it's about your voice it's about ensuring that the Australian Parliament never forgets the people of lingiari and Solomon I thank the senate for this opportunity and I certainly thank colleagues on both sides on all all sides who've stood very strongly in pursuing this in particular in the House Warren Snowden the member for lingiari Luke goling the member for Solomon and Senator Sam mcmah it is important that no matter our political ideologies and our parties where we live that we came together very strongly to say this must not happen where we lose a voice you know in 2022 it will be 100 years when the first member of the Northern Territory came into this Parliament nearly a 100 years so nearly a 100 years later you wanted to keep it still at one it really is a shame job that the Northern Territory has not progressed even more two is not enough but for the purposes of this bill we are enormously grateful that what seemed incredibly impossible at the beginning of this year is now becoming very real I urge senators all Senators to wholeheartedly support the passage of this legislation today because the people of the Northern Territory and the cus killing islands and Christmas Islands have many issues to battle you know whether it's the cashless debit card whether it's the community development program whether it's jobs and infrastructure coid 19 we want to know that we have voices in this Parliament to represent us this should never have been an issue it should never have distracted us to the extent that it did but boy am I enormously grateful for those who stood by us to make sure we never gave up on this voice and these voices for the Northern Territory and the Indian Ocean territories so this Christmas it is hopefully an important gift that we can certainly come to and know that as we go into next year because who knows what next year is going to look like are we going to have an election next year the big question isn't it for 2021 but the people of the Northern Territory and the Indian Ocean territories want to make sure we have our voices ready to go I'd like to just uh acknowledge uh uh Madam acting Madam Deputy speaker uh just a couple of people in particular if we think about uh the seat of lingiari and lingiari is uh hopefully everyone does know is comes from the name of uh Vincent lingiari the late uh green gelder who fought for land rights and not just for the Northern Territory but for all First Nations people right across Australia and for our country Australia to treat uh First Nations people with the dignity and respect that we have forever been calling for and dignity and respect not only comes in the way we treat one another but it is in the financial ways that we treat each other in the economic Cycles that we treat each other in the ability to be able to have homes decent homes and houses not 20 to a house but families who can live comfortably in one home knowing they have families in another home without feeling like they're overcrowded that's the dignity and respect that Vincent lingiari stood for and his message lives on in his children and grandchildren and it was his family that I drove out to got in my full drive went out to wave Hill and I spoke to so many people pastoralists you know all these communities the road workers uh the families at wave Hill and said listen I really need your support here we have to fight this so when I got out to uh wave Hill and uh the the gingi mob got together and we sat down and we talked so I went through and explained well this is the Senate this is how many senators there are there are over here this is the house this is how many uh members there are in the house and this is us four you know Warren Luke Sam and I four of us in these two houses of over 200 people so when you sit down with people and explain this is our voice they looked at me and they said what and they want to take one of you away I said that's not right we we should have more than that and I said yeah you're right you're right we should but we definitely shouldn't be losing any so the gingi got together and they wrote a letter they wrote a letter to the Prime Minister and I'm going to table the letter and and just read a little bit of it because I think it's important to acknowledge what the uh children and grandchildren of uh Vincent lingiari did on this particular occasion dear prime minister we are the grandchildren of Vincent lingiari in 2000 we gave permission for the Australian electoral commission to use our grandfather's name for the electorate of lingiari we were proud to see the achievements of Vincent lingiari and the gingi people recognized in this way now the Australian electoral commission has declared the Northern Territory will lose a seat in the federal Parliament at the next election losing a seat will make our voices softer not louder government talk about closing the Gap and a first nation's voice yet in the Northern Territory where almost 30% of the population are Aboriginal we are losing our voice the fight for land rights began here on gingi Country our grandfather Vincent lingiari fought against Power and privilege for the betterment of our people and for the betterment of all Australians we'd love to welcome you prime minister to come and have a look in fact fact they've actually invited not only the Prime Minister but probably most uh senators and members at some point to come to wave Hill and walk I know Senator Penny Wong has spent time with me out there walking the walk talking the talk of the importance of what the legacy of Vincent lingar is about power and privilege the fight against Power and privilege and the gringy hold that flame so strongly as they do here in this legislation before the Senate so Madame acting Deputy president I'm enormously proud that through the combined efforts of so many we stand here to do the right thing to make sure the voices of the people of the Northern Territory and the peoples of the Indian Ocean territories grow louder in strength not less yeah are you seeking leave to table the letter yes I am I'm seeking leave to table this letter from the uh uh gingi Corporation is leave granted leaves granted thank you Senator Senator Walters thanks very much acting Deputy president and I rise on behal of the greens to speak to the Electoral Amendment territory representation bill of 2020 um this is a really uh exciting day and we hope for these reforms to be passed today so with that in mind I intend to keep my remarks nice and short because we're coming up against the Motions hard marker at 11:45 um but I'm really pleased that we are here today people will will recall the history of this reform the aec based on small population changes in the territory um ruled that there was to be only one lower housee seat to cover the whole territory rather than the current two and in a uh very welcome display of uh chamber Unity we saw both Senator McCarthy and Senator mcmah uh sponsor a bill to fix that situation to restore the right to two seats for the territory and to ensure that the voices of First Nations people wouldn't be further uh downgraded in this system that has already uh underd delivered so much um it was uh a little bit awkward because uh the government uh I think didn't actually want Senator mcmah to be collaborating and and uh through um discussions behind closed doors that bill was withdrawn but I'm really pleased that the government has now put its own version on the table we don't actually mind whose name is on the front page the important outcome is that now we will see that two houses in the lower house uh will be restored for the Northern Territory and also for the AC now the way it will do that is slightly different to the original bill it was a suggestion by Anthony Green to use a harmonic mean um the end result is a strong one it is at least two seats will be guaranteed with the possibility of more going forwards so we we strongly support this bill and I want to particularly congratulate uh the efforts of Senator McCarthy and senator mcmah in pushing this issue leading to this excellent outcome uh just a few more comments to make uh I think everybody understands that the seat of lingiari which Senator McCarthy has given us so beautifully the history of um is 40% first nation's people so what an affront to have potentially had that seat abolished when we've got 27% of the population of the Northern Territory of First Nations and 40% of the seed of lingiari and when we already see uh a system here that has so far been pretty deaf to the needs of First Nations people uh that would have just been uh adding insult to injury the other issue is of course the downgrading of regional and Rural issues in in proposing to amalgamate it with an urban seat the seat of Solomon concentrated around Darwin you would have seen those Rural and Regional issues again further diluted with an inevitable uh focus on those Urban issues at the expense of those Rural and Regional issues which of course are 40% First Nations voters so um we are thrilled to be supporting this bill today uh this is a crucial time in our nation's history and our relationship with the First Peoples of this country remains a festering s that we here could and should be doing so much better on um our newest green Senator uh Lydia Thorp gave a very powerful first speech last night where she talked of these issues um in a way that I hope made everyone feel proud and hopeful of the potential for these issues to be be resolved we need to work on treaties we need to recognize sovereignty we need a voice to Parliament we need truth telling we need Justice we need healing and we need reparations to have abolished a seat that was 40% First Nations was going in the absolute wrong direction so the greens are really pleased to support this bill today which will see uh the voices of First Nations people uh maintained we share Senator McCarthy's views that in fact they should be elevated and we look forward to working on those issues going forwards but thanks again to Senator McCarthy and senator mcmah for the initial strong moves that has culminated in the government's bill today and well done to the government for actually coming to the table thank you Senator Senator cier uh thank you um very pleased to support the Electoral Amendment territory representation Bill 2020 pleased with this outcome not only as assistant Minister responsible for electorate matters electoral matters but also uh as senator for the ACT one of the jurisdictions that is affected by this bill uh now we know on sheer geography uh concerns were raised and it was pointed out that the new division of the Northern Territory would constitute one sixth of Australia's total land mass equal in size to the area of France Spain and Italy put together uh if it were a country it would be the 20th largest in the world notwithstanding the fact that geography is always an issue uh when it comes to electorates the real concern was that we have evolved A system that could would be considered uh in some cases unduly harsh unfair and unrepresentative against that backdrop in essence a reduction of a relatively minor margin in voters can result in a massive reduction in representation for those areas in the Northern Territory dropping below the quota would result in representation being reduced by half it also exaggerates the differences between population per representative for example the Northern Territory with one representative would have have a population 74743 greater than other Mainland divisions 139,900 to 17,500 a difference of only about 45,000 by comparison dropping one seat in the ACT changes the population per member from 143,144 to 24,7 180 a difference of 71594 in the Northern Territory dropping a seat creates a difference of over 123,000 votes so these risks are not just hypothetical of course uh they are historical fact in 2003 the Northern Territories population fell uh just 294 short of the required quota yet it threatened to take their representation down to just one seat this resulted in amendments to electoral legislation that took into account statistical errors in population estimates the use of the margin of error calculation did indeed keep a second seat for the Northern Territory in 2004 but it is a solution built on the acceptance of statistical error as a legitimate tool for representation and it does not address the issue of aligning as far as possible the number of Voters per electorate as closely as possible between crowded City electorates and sprawling Regional ones the question then was how to create an electoral system that is fair and representative across the whole of our nation but also reasonable and robust as a matter of electoral mathematics uh there was the option of Simply mandating minimum number of seats which was put to this Parliament upon closer examination that Simplicity is also a flaw while simple it does not fully discharge our responsibility to deliver as far as possible the best principled basis for determining seats for representation a politically mandated number could easily be seen as arbitrary and certainly not in the spirit of the founding of our nation nor the interests of finding a genuinely robust methodology now this very point was raised during the 2004 debates when Warren Snowden warned that such a path could and I quote undermine The credibility of the Electoral act and which could create a precedent for future governments to intervene in a very political and part way unquote it's a wise warning and it's worthy of serious consideration it's also a two-edged sword mandating a minimum seat number regardless of how low population actually falls could result in the perverse outcome of an electorate being massively over represented in either case there are issues that need to be addressed and that's why after consultation with colleagues and submissions from stakeholders another method was considered and is included in this bill and this bill proposes the adoption of the harmonic mean or Dean method as a fairer more robust and more reliable solution than others proposed so far as Anthony Green advocated in his submission on this matter the the adoption of the harmonic mean both protects the people of the territories and provides a legitimate principle-based solution going forward it removes the harshness and in inequity of knife edged differences in population creating massive drops in representation it removes the requirement of statistical errors to be included as a safety net to overcome more fundamental flaws in our electoral calculations it is a system designed to keep the per vote the voter per member average in smaller population areas more closely aligned with the national average something Anthony Green notes is not a property of the existing method not only am I pleased with the solution proposed as a legitimate tested and supported solution for all Australians it's also a sound result the Australian Capital territory though smaller in size the ACT does face the same vagaries in terms of outcomes despite our population the Act was only granted a third seat based on the margin of error calculation according to Anthony Green submission using the proposed harmonic meme would have given the ACT a third seat for 1993 1998 2001 2004 and 2016 all applying the same rules that would apply to the Northern Territory and it is this issue of equal treatment between the territories that has raised concerns both in the pursuit of electoral fairness but ensuring it is fair to the act as well as to the Northern Territory and so as senator for the ACT I'm very pleased uh with where we've gotten to uh and I contrast this uh with the proposal that was supported by uh labor representatives for the ACT uh the bill uh included in its title ensuring Fair representation for the Northern Territory uh it didn't give the same fairness to the the act after that bill was referred to committee this issue became abundantly clear the committee report notes the private senator's bill would introduce a new minimum of two seats in the Northern Territory but would keep the Australian Capital territory uniquely on the lower one seat floor this would Institute a two-tier arrangement for minimum territory representation rather than modeling the section on the Constitutional treatment of original states whereby all original states are treated with parody it would also be a depart from existing electoral Arrangements it further notes by having separate minimum entitlement Provisions treating each territory differently the bill departs from this long-standing position raising parity equity and conceivably constitutional concerns not not withstanding uh whether this may give rise to legal issues the committee considers that on principle alone there ought to be parity in the treatment of the two territories and this is a sentiment with which I wholeheartedly agree clearly uh labor including Senator Galler as well as Andrew Lee Alicia Payne and David Smith all supported a solution which would have treated the act differently and at a significant relative disadvantage to the Northern Territory their proposal was far more favorable to the NT as against the Australian Capital territory this disparity guaranteed two seats for the Northern Territory uh but only one for the ACT is not only unfair to the people of the act it does raise constitutional issues of treating voters differently in different jurisdictions uh and and and as I said uh The Joint standing committee on electoral matters uh made this point uh in a very sound way uh lastly I would note that the bill today removes the margin of error rule as it is applied to the act in the Northern Territory this rule was arguably only a fix for a specific fault at the time with better systems those reasons no longer apply far more importantly uh the system proposed does not need a second safety net and certainly not one based on codifying margin of error as a permanent part of our electoral system as I've said and welcomed our electoral systems are vital to our democracy and faith in that system from the public is dependent on the good faith of negotiations undertaken uh by this Parliament I believe the bill today is a demonstration of that commitment and that good faith uh as assistant Minister for electoral matters I applaud the hard work and rigor that colleagues and commentators have brought to this discussion as a local representative for the ACT I'm very pleased to Champion and deliver a system that gives Fair representations to both territories the Act and the Northern Territory and as a parliamentarian I welcome a system of fairer representation for all Australians whether here in the seat of government in the act or in the heart of our country in the Northern Territory I thank everyone who contributed to the development of the bill and I commend it to the Senate thank you Senator Senor faroh thank you madam acting deputy president uh labor welcomes this legislation which will ensure that the Northern Territory retains two seats in the House of Representatives of course this bill is in response to Labor's original Bill introduced by Senator malander McCarthy earlier this year which was I was a proud co-sponsor of since the introduction of our bill in June my labor colleagues in the Northern Territory Luke goling Warren Snowden and Senator McCarthy have fought to ensure that the voice of territorians is not diminished by having the territory reduced to one enormous electorate this bill is the outcome of a sustained campaign uh we're able to secure the support of the CP Senator mcmah the greens the crossbench the Northern Territory government and the Northern Territory opposition and even the National Party to ensure that the government was forced to deal with this issue I'd like to thank all of my Senate colleagues and those in the other place for their support of this bill I'd also like to thank the Northern Territory Chief Minister Michael Gunner the Alp National secretary Paul Ericson and I NT secretary Anthony buron for all their hard work and commitment to security securing the territories representation and I extend my thanks and appreciation to the labor members of The Joint standing committee on electoral matters Senator Carol Brown Milton dick Senator Mario Smith and Kate twz for the time in that they put in uh on this Committee of inquiry into this bill um there's no accounting for Community interest what the people in remote and Regional communities need uh now uh and how different it is from what the people of Darwin and paliston need there was no accounting for demography the First Nations Australians made up about 30% of the territories population there's only one thing that the AC aec can look at at um at it and that's a population and on those figures the Northern Territory fell short of retaining its two seats by around 4,000 people labor couldn't stand by and let the territory representation diminish uh the government wasn't acting to save the northern territor second seat so we and labor introduced our own piece of legislation um the bill that the government introduced uh uh isn't exactly what labor would have done uh but it uh it does fix the problem and instead of enacting jum's third recommendation which is to change the method by which both territories entitled to determination uh it's a method that we didn't Advocate but it does uh it does the job of fixing the issue um the bill also sets aside many others have spoken about the various details of the bill so I won't go over that again Madame acting Deputy president uh the bill also sets aside the AC's most recent u in uh determination in relation to the Northern Territory and the determination made in 2017 which allocated two seats to the Northern Territory will apply I met with the Electoral commissioner earlier this week and he confirmed to me that the current boundaries of Solomon and lingiari will continue and there will be no requirement for a further redistribution my first visit to the Northern Territory was some 44 years ago Madame acting deputy president to help Darwin rebuild after the cyclone and I've made countless trips there ever since working with my labor colleagues in the Northern Territory to help secure this important change has been an honor and particularly working with Senator McCarthy on this issue uh and there is passion and dedication uh that's been the driving force uh behind this campaign labor has always been committed to ensuring all territorians continue to have Fair representation in our federal parli and we're glad that the government has come on board and I thank the former Minister Minister Corman and um Minister Birmingham for the respectful way in which they've handled this issue this is a winfin democracy and we're all pleased to support this bill Senator mcmah um thank you Mr President um I Rise to to speak on this historic and important piece of legislation uh historic and important not just to the Northern Territory although that is obviously where my passion lies um but also to the act because in this bill we have included not just the Northern Territory but our other territory uh right here in our Nations around our nation's capital um so why why is this important to territorians um you know around the rest of Australia if you suggested to a lot of people that you should take away a politician or two they would probably say that that's a good thing um not so in the territory we uh we obviously as a territory only have two senators and we have two lower house so four representatives to the federal Parliament um for the whole of the territory so territorians um are very well aware of their need for federal representation they're very well aware of of the role that the um the federal government plays uh they're well aware that labor in the Northern Territory has sent us broke and that if we were in fact a company we would be bankrupt so they're well aware of the need for the federal government to provide for the programs and the services and the infrastructure that territorians need if we look just at the geography of the Northern Territory almost 1.4 million square kilm it's absolutely huge and as has been said by uh my colleagues it also includes um Christmas and cus killing Islands um now to get to these islands one must actually travel via this is pre-co as well this has not been affected by coid before coid you had to either travel via Perth or via Malaysia to get there so imagine uh too many other jurisdictions in the world where you you not only have to leave your state or territory to get to another part of your state or territory but uh you actually have to travel through another country to get to a part of your state or territory it's uh it's quite unique and um quite amazing and I know the people of of Christmas and cus Island uh value their Federal representation and they feeling so isol ol ated as they are sitting out there in the middle of the uh the ocean um realize that with less representation um they're hardly ever going to see anybody ever and for a group of people that are fairly marginalized and very isolated um you can imagine that that that is not something that they would welcome as for the rest of the territory almost 1.4 million square kilm and uh very very difficult to get around we have very few Road roads most of the roads that we do have um can be cut off for sometimes large parts of the year uh a lot of them are are fairly poor and uh not very easily passed uh a lot of the territory you can't even get to by Road for um for large parts or sometimes even all of the year um you know we have we have quite a few Islands as well such as uh Gro island kroer island Melville Island Beth Island accessible only via barge or air and again uh difficult and timec consuming to get around so you can imagine taking one of four Representatives out of that mix is going to mean that that these people are not going to be able to uh to see speak to or show a federal representative um their part of the world and their issues uh hardly ever which would um be quite a negative thing for again people that are often the most disadvantaged um marginalized people in our country um we have the two electorates Solomon and lingiari very very diff different Solomon is basically Darwin Darwin is a um a reasonably modern Cosmopolitan urbanized City these days um and then you have lingiari which is all of the rest basically almost all of that 1.4 million square kilometers lingar is approximately 40% indigenous um again some of the most isolated um disadvantaged marginalized people in the world having only one Federal representative to serve them um would be quite unfair and uh quite frankly disastrous for the Northern Territory um also you look at the socioeconomics I know there's both ends of the Spectrum in in every state and territory but certainly I mean the territory it certainly typified to me how how much that is so in the territory just last week Mr President I was sitting in a building in Darwin with lovely 360 degree views all around the harbor and all around the city with three of the richest people in the northern territ teritory and we're talking we're talking billions not Millions we're not uh you know ter typically when you think of uh someone who's wealthy in the territory it's someone who can you know buy a Buy Round without taking out a bank loan but um that was not the case with these people these were um you know we had billions of dollars uh assembled in that room and uh the the very next day Mr President the very next day I was sitting in the dirt north of tenant Creek with a group of traditional owners uh we say traditional owners but you know they they don't have the the the money the the land the the businesses or the education uh that the three men I was with the day before due and that's that's very very typical of the territory we tend to get very extremes and and lots of people at those extremes you know those traditional owners that were sitting there in the dirt who were getting their part of their traditional land handed back to them um 600 square km um it's not a lot particularly in that part of the country in that part of the country 600 square km would probably run 10 head of cattle um so it's not a lot um but they were happy that it was getting handed back to them but sitting there in the dirt with uh severely marginalized um disadvantaged people compared to the end of town so um whilst there's Extremes in all jurisdictions certainly in the territory that that is emphasized and we certainly have a lot of our population at the lower extreme rather than the top extreme um and these people value their representation they really do people on remote indigenous communities think it is a great honor and are very happy when a federal representative of whatever persuasion um comes to see them they they really do appreciate it they put time aside and they want to talk to you about their issues so I certainly uh I thank Senator James mcgar chair of the joint standing committee on electoral matters for the work that he and the committee did on this inquiry and uh and the report from that that was handed up to the Senate this week which did recommend uh a couple of different methods by which we might maintain representation um and I'm I'm very pleased that this bill uh recommend or ens shines in law um using the harmonic mean uh otherwise referred to as Dean's method for uh determining representation as that will not only guarantee that the entt retains its two seats currently but it will also make it easier as our population grows for us to move from 2 up to 3 um so I think this is an excellent uh resolution I'm very very proud to be part of the government that has put this bill forward and I thank all my colleagues um and I thank um Senator Corman for the work that he did on it and uh for Senator Birmingham for taking over and and carrying on that work and presenting us with a very very good p piece of legislation I um I acknowledge uh Senators Farrell and McCarthy for uh their support and uh and and they're working with me and their faith in me and the government to deliver on this and um I with great pride and on behalf of all territorians commend this legislation to the Senate Senator Birmingham thanks Mr President and uh and can I I thank Senators who have contributed to this debate particularly thank you senator mcmah for for your advocacy and thoughtful engagement but also indeed acknowledge Senator McCarthy uh Senator Farrell and also Senator ciler noting the the broader territory implications and uh uh in in the um engagement through uh the debate and also the construction of this legislation I also thank J gim for their thoughtful work and engagement through this um I shall let the details of the bill stand noting the uh the time aside from from to to note that many other members of the parliament have followed this matter closely conscious of of ensuring a principled approach in relation to to how such matters are handled uh and the use of a harmonic mean calculation for allocating seats to the territories uh addresses the types of concerns that had been raised in relation to territory representation uh but does so in a means that that maintains principle around the application of electoral redistributions uh ensures that this Parliament is not in and of itself overreaching in the construction uh of the House of Representatives uh but is ensuring that there is a methodology uh that is applied uh according to the principles consistent with the way the House of Representatives is intended uh to be constructed uh in terms of determining numerical representation uh of those seats and we do welcome the fact that the result of that and the decisions made in this legislation will ensure that the territory continues uh at the next election uh and based on projections Beyond uh to have two representatives in the House of Representatives uh and in doing so does not find itself in a situation of having uh the single largest uh electorate uh potentially when you combine population and geography and all of the challenges that that would come uh with effective representation in this place uh can I also note that there's been conjecturing parliamentary committee hearings about the future status of the Australian electoral officer for the Northern Territory and I take this opportunity to put those concerns to rest the bill recognizes that the Australian electoral officer in the NT is always to be a member of the redistribution committee for any redistributions in that territory uh and for the record that the process to permanently refill uh the AEO position for the NT will begin before the end of 20120 in conclusion can I just remind everyone it's important we remain committed to improving electoral legis ation in a nonpartisan manner which promotes public confidence and ensures strong representation for Australia's territories and we've seen elsewhere in the world in recent times uh the challenges that can come uh when uh when politicians degrade public confidence or undermine public confidence in electoral systems it's incumbent on all of us to make sure that it is upheld at the highest possible levels I commend the bill to the Senate question is the bill be read a second time those of that opinion say I contary no the eyes have but now they're being no Amendment circulated oh the Clark I always missed that bit to amend the Commonwealth elect act 1918 in relation to the representation of the territories in the House of Representatives and for elated purposes now there are no amendments being circulated so unless anyone requests a committee stage I will call the minister for the third reading Minister thank you Mr President I move that the bill be now read a third time question is the bill be read a third time those of that opinion say I the contary no the eyes have it the Clark now bill for to amend the Commonwealth electoral act 1918 in relation to the representation of the territories in the House of Representatives and for related purposes got a couple of minutes we have a couple of minutes Senator Thorp if you'd like to utilize it to continue debate I'll get the Clark to call on the business business order the day number three native type Amendment infrastructure and public facilities Bill 2020 resumption of second reading debate Senator thank you president I Rise to continue my speech on the native title infrastructure Bill the greens will be moving amendments to this bill instead of extending the operation of section 24 ja AA by another 10 years as the government has proposed we are proposing to extend it by only one more year instead in our view the minister has not made the case for why a 10-year extension is required remember that this isn't just about building public homes but the government could also build police stations in communities that are already over targeted by Poli by police police and apparently do this for their benefit I know from personal experience that for our people having police as First Responders is often not helpful but harmful and sometimes lethal if the government has serious was serious about negotiating with traditional owners or even just negotiating in good faith it would be properly funded prescribed bodies corporate they would also be properly funding native title claimants to properly negotiate on an equal footing with the government as well as funding them to develop community-led land use plans over their country and most importantly they would be bending over backwards just like they do for their big corporate mates to protect our heritage because every time the minerals Council comes knocking on these doors the government gets themselves tied up in knots and do whatever they want If Only They thank you for your flexibility Senator Thorp you'll be in continuation when debate resumes again uh we will now move on and I will call on the clerk to call on petitions Mr President a petition has been lodged as noted on the dynamic readed the terms of the petition will be incorporated in h out are there any notices of motion to be given for another day Senator F an world thank you Mr President pursuant to notice given yesterday I withdraw business of the Senate notice of motion number one standing in my name for 7 December 2020 proposing the disallowance of the Corona virus economic response package deferral of sunsetting income management and cashless welfare Arrangements determination 2020 much to the Delight of Senator Rustin uh and business of the Senate notice of motion number three standing in my name for 12 sitting days after today proposing the disallowance of the continent AIDS payment scheme 20120 thank you Senator fan Wells are there any other notices or motion there being onone I'll move on to the report of the selection of bills committee Senator Smith thank you Mr President I present the 11th report of 2020 of the selection of bills committee and seek leave to have the report Incorporated in Hansard is leave granted leave is granted I move that the report be adopted thank you Senator Smith Senator danam uh thank you Mr President I move the following Amendment at the end of the motion add accept that the surveillance legislation Amendment identity uh identify and disrupt Bill 2020 not be referred to a committee Okay so Senator McKim uh if I could just ask president are we still speaking to the um uh motion are we speaking to the motion now that Senator D has speak the amendment that yes his Amendment to the selection of bills committee report okay but uh if this uh Senate will make a decision on that then I'll still be able to speak to the selection of Bill's report after that you can speak to both now okay I I'll do that then thank thank you I appreciate your guidance president um I would like to make the point that uh from the Australian green point of view the corporations Amendment corporate insolvency reforms Bill uh 2020 should be referred to a parliamentary committee and and won't be if the Senate accepts the uh selection of Bill's report and I just wanted to place on the record that uh that that bill the corporations Amendment corporate insolvency reforms Bill 2020 does propose to ease the regulatory burden on businesses and note that uh we regulate businesses for many reasons including to protect our environment to provide safer workplaces for people and ultimately we regulate businesses in the public interest now this bill would um uh wind back business regulation we're not saying that's a bad thing we're simply saying it is a matter worthy of Senate inquiry and we are disappointed that the selection of bills report does not recommend the that bill being quired into by uh by the economics legislation committee so I will put the amendment move by Senator dunam question is those who support that Amendment say I to the contrary no can I put it again those with that opinion say I I contary no the eyes have it we now go to the adoption of the report as amended with the question is those in supp support of the adoption of the report say I cont no the eyes have it the eyes have it I shall now proceed to the placing of business is it desired to postpone or rearrange the business Senator dunam thank you Mr President um I move that a government business orders of the day as shown on today's order of business be considered from 12:45 p.m. today and B government business be called on after consideration of the bills listed in paragraph a and considered till not later than 2: p.m. today uh C a general business notice a motion to be circulated by Paul Hanson's One Nation be considered during General business today and D the following Bill be considered at the time for private Senators bills on Monday the 7th of December 2020 the Social Security Administration Amendment uh protecting consumers from predatory leasing practices Bill 2020 question is Senator that the question is that motion be agreed to those of that opinion say I the contary no the eyes have it Senator Ur thank you Mr President on behalf of Senator farello withdraw General business notice of motion number 818 standing in his name for Monday the 7th of December thank you um I will now ask the clerk to notify postponements and extensions Mr President postponement notifications have been lodged in respect of government business notice number one for today postponed to the 7th of December General business notice number 900 postponed to the 8th of December in general business notice 906 postponed to the 7th of December committees have lodged extension notifications as shown at item 8 of today's order of business I remind Senators the question may be put on any proposal at the request of any Senator there being none I shall now proceed to the discovery of formal business and it being Thursday I'll go through the items in the order they appear on the notice paper so I'll commence with number 874 Senator faruki I ask the general business notice of motion number 874 be taken as a formal motion is there any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator farqi um I move the motion Senator danam to make a short statement leave is granted for one minute uh thank you Mr President Australia has a track uh record of meeting and beating our International commitments we've beaten our 2020 Target by 459 million tons and we're on track to meet our 2030 Target Australians are also deploying renewable energy at 10 times the global per person average these are achievements Australians can and should be proud of but climate change is a global problem requiring Global action that's why Australia is committed to the Paris agreement we're committed to achieving global net zero emissions as soon as possible Senator Roberts leave to make a short statement leave is granted for one minute thank you one nation does not support this motion Australia's Chief scientists stated that if Australia were to reduce its entire carbon dioxide output to zero it would have virtually no effect on the global temperature it's time that the liberal National and labor greens parties acknowledged that implementing layer upon layer of destructive climate policies and renewable energy schemes cannot change the global climate if people were serious about reducing the world's carbon dioxide output they would be pressuring China who account for 30% of the world's output and renegotiate their renegotiated their Paris agreement which allows them to increase output until 2030 and then only slow the increase there's no agreement Yes you heard that right China will be increasing their carbon dioxide output for the foreseeable future while climate policies here in Australia decimate our economy and what's more we are subsidizing them to build the appliances that they will install here and raise our electricity prices this is insane question is motion moved by senator farooqi be agreed to those of that opinion say I contary no the NOS have it division required ring the bells that we can right spe this spe [Music] you're stop the bells the question is the general business notice of motion number 874 be agreed to the eyes will pass to the right of the chair the nose to the left of the chair app Point Senator Ur tell for the eyes Senator Dean Smith tell her for the nose e for the results division is eyes 28 nose 30 the matter is resolved in the negative senators bilck and Dean Smith note motion number 877 holl deore you've got it senator thank you Mr President I ask that General business notice of motion number 877 be taken as a formal motion any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator I move the motion question is that motion be agreed to those of that opinion say I the contary no the eyes have it Senator Polly number 878 Senator UT thank you Mr President I ask that General business notice of motion number 878 be taken as a formal motion is there any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator I move the motion Senator Dam leave is granted for one minute thank you Mr President tourism across Australia and indeed Tasmania was among the first and worst hit by Co 19 the Morrison government did not hesitate in providing support for this critical industry from an unprecedented package of broad economic and targeted uh industry support in addition to jobke keeper this includes small business grants funding for Airlines zoos and Aquariums and national parks Tasmania is also receiving $1 13.5 million through the uh recovery of regional tourism package in acknowledgement of the state's critical Reliance on International tourism with regard to skills our job maker plan includes a billion dollar job trainer fund with skills and training crucial to Australia's economic recovery the government will provide around $1 131.35 contrary no the eyes have it number 898 Senator abets thank you Mr President I ask the general business notice of motion number 898 relating to the commemorating the 25th anniversary of yac rin's assassination whilst attending an antiviolence rally be taken as for formal and in doing so can I recognize the presence of Mr gfel from the Israeli Embassy in the gallery objection to this motion been taken as formal there being none Senator abets I move the motion standing in my name and more importantly Mr President in the names of senators kitching Molen Wong renck mclan cani ESU Sullivan Ryan antic car mcgr Sheldon Smith Van Hughes Henderson Chone forcet O'Neal Griff Roberts and Hansen senator Rice make a short statement leave is granted for one minute thank you if this Senate truly affirms a vision of a peaceful and enduring two-state solution which we believe it should then we should also be urging the Australian government to call out the breaches of international law that present a huge obstacle to achieving this Vision Australia needs to make clear to the Israeli government that increasing settlement building and the threat of annexation not to mention the regular demolition of Palestinian homes is a massive obstacle to achieving peace and we urge the government to finally recognize a Palestinian State as so many other countries have done Senator Wong I seek leave to take a short statement in response to that leave is rounder for one minute I express my regret uh that the greens felt in relation to a motion commemorating such an honorable and decent man uh the need to make a political statement such as was just made we all have views about uh the foreign policy issues to which the senator avered uh I think there is support across the chamber for a two-state solution people may have different views about how that should proceed but those differences ought not have been aired in the context of this motion Senator pay uh thank you than you uh Mr President and uh I would also can I just through the form leave gr for one minute marks for one minute thank you Mr President um I would also note uh in the chamber today that this motion comes to this place uh to uh commemorate and Mark um the death of Israeli Prime Minister Yak Rabin uh it acknowledges his promotion of peace and coexistence uh at that time but we know for all time uh given the nature of his leadership uh and his legacy the motion very clearly refers to an enduring two-state solution to end the Israeli Palestinian conflict uh supported by Australia mutually a a two-state solution mutually negotiated and agreed by Israelis and Palestinians that it is not possible to extend with courtesy and uh diplomacy uh and generosity of spirit an acknowledgement of this resolution by The Greens in this chamber is profoundly disappointing question is the motion moved the name of Senator Eric abets and the others whose names he read out be agreed to those of that opinion say I I the contrary no the eyes have it Senator Roberts thank you 9 oh sorry Senator bets was seeking the call I'm just moved the motion Senator bets Mr President uh with leave of the Senate can it be acknowledged in the hand side that the greens in fact did vote on the voices for the motion because I think that would add uh to the import of this motion I think the handside can record that there was no no voice to the motion I think I can assert intervention has now put that on the hands side and that is why I did what I did thank you Senator abet you've done this before Senator Abit well done Senator Roberts thank you Mr President I ask that General business notice of motion number 899 be taken as a formal motion is there any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator Roberts I move the motion question is that motion be agreed to those of that opinion say I cont no the eyes have it could we move Senator lambi to your matter number 901 uh thank you Mr President I ask that General business notice of motion number 901 be taken as a formal motion is there any objection to this motion been taken as formal there being none Senator lambi I move the motion Senator Dam leave to make a short statement leave is granted for one minute thank you Mr President the Morrison government firmly believes that tackling this devastating issue requires an ongoing Focus ensuring we remain forever Vigilant about the Ware of our defense and Veteran communities this is why the government has committed to pass the bill before the end of the year and as listed the bill on the weekly program Senator Hansen I seek leave to make a short statement leave is granted for one minute thank you very much um I am totally aware that the people of this um of this chamber most of them are very mindful of the fact that the suicides that happened past and the attempted suicides that are still happening in our defense Personnel we have all want at Royal commissions into a lot of areas and I've wanted in family law but I've got a hearing with that I think the commissioner where we've moved forward with this is the commissioner interim commissioner has been named and the fact is that the commissioner can work with the government and they can report and work with commissioner they can start immediately to start working and answering the questions with and it is retrospective and they can look at the past deaths that have happened and the attempted suicides that are happening I believe that you know it's a shame that Senator lamb does not support a commissioner that a commissioner be appointed in the legisl be passed because I don't believe she will be voting for the legislation next week and I believe that labor doesn't intend to vote for it either I think it's a shame to the people of this nation that have lost their Senator lamb I asked another Senator yesterday that when they were called to order to at least concede some respect for the chair otherwise debate in this chamber will break down especially at this time I called you to order on a number of occasions the question is that motion number 901 moved by senator lambi be agre to those of that opinion say I the contary no the NOS have it division required bring the bells for 4 minutes pleas L up to this place GI e for e stop the bells question is motion number 901 the name of Senator lamby be agreed to the eyes will pass to the right of the chair the nose to the left of the chair I point Senator Ur at tell off the eyes Senator Smith tell off the nose spe e the result of the division is eyes 28 NOS 28 the matter is resolved is therefore negative Senators please remain in the chamber for a couple of more matters I will only be ringing the bells for one minute Senator renck could we come to your matter number 902 please I asked the general business notice motion 902 relating to scientific research be taken as formal is there any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator Ren why AR you I I move the motion Senator Galler thank you Mr President I seek leave to make a short statement leave is granted for one minute thank you this motion is just another sad example from the self-described tin foil hat wearing Senator Senator renck on his war on science and his war on scientists labor will not be supporting this motion because we support science we support scientists in the work that they do we do acknowledge that the more extreme elements that appeared earlier this week in this motion referring to indoctrination intimidation and shoty mathematical modeling have disappeared from Senator renick's motion but the fact that this motion appears today reflects poorly on the government in their inability to contain the frequent and getting more erratic outbursts uh from senator renck whilst you're trying to make it look perfectly reasonable we will not support it we on this side of the chamber will not be providing the senator with more ammunition in his Crusade against science senator Rice leave is granted for one minute look the Australian grin support the scientific approach and we support scientific research Senator renick is a climate denialist and he wants to challenge other science that he happens to not agree with the subtext of what he's trying to say here is that climate science isn't legitimate science and he is undermining the excellent high quality work of climate scientists around the world and here in Australia it the greens support science we support the absolute the science that is done here and the quality climate science as is reflected by the excellent work done by the International Panel on climate change the government needs to act rather than be fiddling around with Senator renick's climate denialism needs to act on our climate crisis and act on the good science that our our climate scientists do around the world the question is that the motion moved by senator renick be agreed to those of that opinion say I the contrary no can I look to crossbenchers to get some sort of sense to try and get this right those of that opinion say I the cont no the nose have it eyes have it division required ring the bells for one [Music] minute [Music] wonderful stop the Bells [Applause] [Music] order can we just make it the whips have a challenging enough role with the pairing can we just give the whips a moment to the question is motion question is that motion number 902 be agreed to the eyes will pass to the right of the chair the nose to the left of the chair I point Senator Smith teller for the eyes and Senator Ur teller for the nose [Music] stand Mar [Music] order order senators renck and what and Galler the result of the division is eyes 29 nose 27 the matter is resolved in the affirmative Senators the final matter the final matter the final matter is number oh we got a couple left have we I've got oh no we got sorry we do have several matters left I was working off a I got an updated sheet so we're now up to 903 in the name of Senator Patrick Senator Patrick thank you Mr President I ask the general business notice the motion number 903 be taken as a formal motion is there any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator Patrick I move the motion Senator danam I seek leave to move an amendment to the motion is leave granted leave is granted Sen Senor Dam uh I move that at the end of the motion we had the words for up to 30 minutes the everyone's familiar with the amendment as moved by Senator Dam so I'll put the amendment those in support of the amendment say I cont no the eyes have it I'll now put the substantive motion as amended the question is those in support of that motion of Senator Patrick as amended say I the contary no the eyes have it do have two more matters number nine 04 Senator Chism and others Senator thank you Mr President I ask that General business notice of motion number 904 be taken as a formal motion any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator I move the motion question is that motion be agreed to those of that opinion say I contary no the eyes have it now the final matter is in the name of Senator Pratt Senator kit I ask sorry Senator Hansen is seeking the call you make a short statement please and with respect to which notice of 904 all I didn't see you stand is it okay it's my fault sen is it okay if Senator Hansen who sought the call I I assume you sought the call before I and I didn't see her is that okay I'll give Senator Hansen leave for one minute Senator Hansen much Community radio stations across the country continue to out perform commercial networks for their T time spent listening and therefore their listeners are more inclined to support station sponsors who help maintain the running cost of these stations while it's unlikely for trip Zed hosts are one nation supporters I do support their efforts that as a community radio station and I congratulations them on 45 years of community service throughout Brisbane let me also take the opportunity to highlight other community stations including kle FM in yapon NSA FM on the Sunshine Coast Sunshine FM in Budram Bay FM in Cleveland 4cm in maai Fraser Coast FM in Harvey Bay and many others across home state of Queensland who all do a great job in a time where we hear excessive Network content on commercial radio stations it's Community radio who genuinely provide the amount most amount of local content for their local communities thank you I thank the chamber and I thank Senator Hansen Senator urit number 905 thank you I ask the general business notice of motion number 905 be taken as a formal motion is there any objection to this motion being taken as formal there being none Senator Senator D leave to make a brief statement leave is granted for one minute thank you Mr President the government's policy is only to use carryover to the extent necessary to meet our D3 Paris Target it was the labor party that made carryover a condition of Australia signing up to the second period of the Kyoto Protocol it was under this coalition government that Australia beat its 2020 Target by 459 million tons Senator Roberts leave Mr President to make a short statement leave is granted for one minute thank you order one nation does not support this motion the Koto carryover credits were created by stealing property rights from Farmers without compensation Farmers lost the rights to manage their land and vegetation without compensation the purchase of Freehold land has been turned into a leasehold agreement with government controlling the land used through overburdensome and crippling regulations the decision by the Howard government to steal property rights without compensation remains to this day an unjust and morally reprehensible decision that the Morrison government refuses to reverse it has been estimated that to compensate Farmers for their loss of Rights would cost an excess of $1 billion but they should be compensated if this government is unwilling to compensate then they must immediately restore full property rights to Farmers so they can recover their productive capacity farmers are the best custodians of the land and do not need to be brought into this mess that is climate change question is that motion number 905 be agreed to those of that opinion say I the cont no the NOS have it division required ring the bells for one minute so I'll take the Clark's tip um I'll I'll put that again the Clark suggested I could call it again those in favor of motion number 905 say I I the contary no the NOS have it division required ring the bells for one minute [Music] I'm shoting stop the bells question is motion number 905 be agreed to the eyes will pass to the right of the chair the nose to the left of the chair I point Senator Ur tell off the eyes Senator Dean Smith tell if the nose e the result of the division is eyes 28 nose 28 the matter is therefore negative Senators that concludes the discovery of formal business I've received a message from the House of Representatives forwarding the social services and other legislation Amendment extension of Corona virus support Bill 2020 for concurrence Senator danum I move that this bill May proceed without formalities and be now read a first time question is that motion be agreed to those of that opinion say I cont no the eyes have it Clark bill for ACT to amend the law relating Social Security veterans entitlements and farm household support and for related purposes Senator Dum I move that this bill be now read a second time and I seek seek leave rather to have the second reading speech Incorporated in Hansard leave granted leave is granted Senator Dum I move that the debate be now adjourned question is that motion be agreed to those of that opinion say I cont no eyes have it the Clark business of the Senate ordered the day for the presentation of a report from the finance and public administration legislation committee Senator Smith Mr President on behalf of the finance and public administration legislation committee I present the report of the committee on the Commonwealth electoral Amendment donation reform and other measures Bill 2020 together with the hand side record of proceedings and documents presented to the committee thank you Senator Smith call on the Clark government business ordered the day number three native title Amendment infrastructure and public facilities Bill 2020 resumption of second reading debate and I thank Senator Thorp for her flexibility being in continuation again Senator Thorp thank you Mr Speaker uh I continue to uh speak on the native title infrastructure bill If Only They listen to our mobs in the in the way we in the way that they say we wouldn't have to go to court and fight tooth and nail to protect our heritage just like we have been doing on warang country today judge Forbes handed down her decision on the injunction application by warang people to have their sacred birthing trees protected this is a welcome decision by japang mob we shouldn't have to go to court to fight for Country over and over again if only governments would listen to our people and worked with us we wouldn't have to be in the Supreme Court arguing if this country valued its first peoples then we wouldn't have to be in court this is why we are voting against this bill today the greens know that this bill doesn't extinguish native title but it does extinguish our people's sovereignty the greens know that this bill doesn't uh extinguish native title this breach of the right of our people to get free prior and informed consent will not be supported by the greens the minister has not made a strong enough case on extending this legislation for another 10 years not when they've been in government for seven of those years as our amendments to this bill show we are willing to give them one more year then to come back and properly make the case to us as to why this section is needed if this section wasn't in the native title act it would be H rightly condemned for being racist because what the government is trying to do is to acquire interests over the property on Aboriginal territory without due process of payment the government's Bill leaves native title owners with infrastructure built on their land which is alleged allegedly for their benefit but they have no control over it this is shameful and we will not support it our Amendment would give them one year if they cannot justify to the parliament in one year why they need section 24 J AA then that section must lapse thank you uh is the senator seeking to put put put it okay thank you U Minister uh well I believe there are no other contributions to be made here so I thank uh Senators for their contributions and commend the bill to the Senate so the question is that the bill be read a second time all those in favor say I those against no uh the the eyes have it two voices is a division required ring the bells for four minutes for every e be for GR you can run stop the bills the question is that the bill be read a second time those in favor say those in favor will pass to the right of the chair those opposing to the left I call Senator Smith as a teller for the eyes and Senator seaward as a teller for the nose e spe thank you there being 40 eyes and nine nose the matter is determined in the affirmative and I call the clerk thank you a bill for ACT to amend the native title act 1993 and for related purposes uh is it the wish of the committee that the bill be taken as a whole there being no objection it is so ordered the question is that the bill stand as printed thank you Senator Thor thank you I move Amendment bill on sheet 112 and then you can just speak to it now you just keep speaking uh this uh bill is about having Government properties on Aboriginal land uh it's a sneaky way to continue uh the oppressive nature of this government and how they want to continue the control of Aboriginal people and take away our Sovereign rights in this country to be allowed to build police stations in communities that the government own control and continue to oppress us with is against our basic human rights it's against self-determination and it puts the fear into our people to be to continue to be profiled and harassed by police in their own homes and in their own communities and we've only seen recently uh where there has been a death in custody as a result of a government owned police station on Aboriginal land I beg your pardon I beg your pardon order order I don't order Senator Thorp just resume your seat for the moment just wait for the moment so did you did you he okay so so we do note that interjections are always disorderly uh and at the time I was actually taking advice from the clerk I didn't hear what was said um I'll call call you Senator Senator Waters thank you I think it's appropriate given the tenor of the remarks made by Senator mcmah which I heard and everyone up the back here heard that she'd be asked to come back into the chamber and withdraw that Senator mcmah is is not here at the moment and I will take note of your request and I'll seek advice about what can be done about that thank you very much um back to you you Senator Thor thank you and this is my workplace may I remind everybody and to be white expained by a white woman is inappropriate and it's border racism so uh I expect whilst I'm in this place that I am not racially vilified or wh blamed by white people on my own country uh after all you you know you um all benefit from being on Stolen land you benefit from the colonization of this land Senator Thorp um I was pleased to be here at your first speech yesterday it's it's appropriate to maintain the tenor of the ch but despite the reported Interruption and interjection that you heard that you make your comments to the chair uh and and you speak to the issue rather than to the people in in the room so if you can just continue mindful of you know your important contribution none less but a little a little care with the language thank you thank you chair and through the chair uh I do remind uh people in this place that they are beneficiaries of a an invasion that took place and we are on Stolen land and uh one of the ways that uh the colonizers or the government uh are trying to take back um or continue to colonize and oppress is certainly uh in this bill uh in a way that putting government owned infrastructure on Aboriginal land is another oppressive uh way that the colonizers ACT it's part of the Art of War uh and it's uh a way that um the government keep a very close eye on what happens in ariginal communities so uh this again breaches the rights of the United Nations Declaration of the rights of indigenous people uh in terms of free prior and informed consent takes away people's self-determination and it puts the fear as I said into families and communities and as a reminder uh to the senator that walk doubt uh I think Northern Territory senator in fact uh there was a death in custody um from a local police station on our a local abinal community so the precedent has been set that it is an oppressive uh way to continue colonizing our lands and our people and uh we the greens will not be supporting uh this bill that's all I've got to say thank you the the question is that the Senator McCarthy thank you uh look uh Madam acting Deputy president uh this is such an important topic around native title and I would just remind all Senators uh in particular of some of the unhelpful comments that were made in relation to this bill and towards uh a a first Senator as well Senator McCarthy I'm sure that you'll be able to continue those remarks but at being 12:45 thank you the uh debate is interrupted uh and the committee reports progress the Clark government business order of day number six family law Amendment Western Australia deao superannuation splitting and bankruptcy Bill 2020 second reading debate Senator Lions thank you m madame acting Deputy president well finally finally this bill comes before this Parliament and this Senate it has taken way too long to get here and there's been unimaginable hurt created because the um Abbott turble and Morrison governments have taken way too long long to act on something that should have been done and dusted in a day I've stood in this place when and seen legislation go through both houses in one day this bill which in wa has discriminated against de facto couples for years and years has taken a very long time and of course it's particularly discriminated against women because as we know women have much lower superannuation balances where they've not been able to legally split when de facto couples choose to separate and there's one person one person who's been Central to holding this up that's the member for peer Mr Christian Porter who ironically was attorney general in the state Parliament and is now attorney general in this place and it has sat with him for a very long time and he must have been aware of this issue he must have been aware of this issue I've got my good friend Rachel Roberts to thank for telling me about this about six years ago six years ago uh when the Barnett government refused to do anything about the splitting of superannuation for DEA facto couples and I thank Rachel for being so steadfast in making sure that we dealt with this issue and I thank Labor's Attorney General General John Quigley in the state Parliament for again urging the Attorney General who's absolutely Central to this to act so that finally de facto couples in Western Australia who unfortunately split up their superannuation will be treated exactly the same as uh all de facto couples uh across this country and I have no idea I no idea why the Attorney General Mr Porter has chose to sit on this legislation to do nothing for more than a year uh to sit on a bill that's not controversial that in Western Australia discriminated against uh de facto couples separating and I'm really pleased that he's now finally before the Senate thank you Madame acting Deputy president thank you Senator liines um I think Senator seaart was on her feet um I just want to add a few comments here I won't uh take long i' I'd very much like to uh support uh the comments that Senator Lions has just made anybody who pays attention to these issues in wa knows that this is a has been a very significant issue for very long time and so it's it's Way Beyond time that this was dealt with because it was an anomally where women and it's nearly always where the women it's the women that suffer here um that have not being treated uh fairly and uh equally and so this is long past time due so I'm really pleased it's finally now come to the top of the list I'd also give like to give a shout out to the women that have been emailing um and urging this to be uh done and completed and so big shout out to them uh thank you for keeping this on the agenda um and I think you'll all be finally very very happy that this is now about to pass and uh Senator Pratt thank you very much uh Madam acting Deputy president back in 2001 Western Australia was the first uh place in the country because the rest of the nation was covered by the federal Family Law act to do de facto law reform so that um couples could split their assets be they same sex or opposite sex in facto relationships in 2008 federal labor also did superannuation splitting as part of its de facto law reform but it has taken until 2020 because uh uh Western Australia is not part of the federal Family Law act to for deao couples now to be able to split their superan ation and I cannot begin to tell you of the injustices that have been done in that time because of the lack of capacity for people to split their assets a constituent wrote to me with a very uh com uh pleading the parliament to make sure that this gets passed she had been uh paying all of the household most of the household bills uh so and her partner at the time had said to her look this is great I because you're paying the bills out of your salary I can afford to pay more into my super so that we can have uh a happy and full and Rich retirement and so that is what as a couple they did but what happens when they're before the family court even if they had amicably wanted to split their assets when a lot of the assets were in the superannuation the failure to act on law reform in this area meant that they could not and it has left hundreds of people if not thousands uh worse off than they otherwise would have been if they had been able to split uh their assets fairly including superannuation Minister Porter said that this was urgent 12 months ago uh and I don't think the fact that it is now in this place some 12 months later reflects that urgency but I will make these remarks short because I believe it is urgent that it passes today Minister uh thank you Madame acting Deputy president I thank Senators for their contributions and commend the bill to the Senate uh the question is that the bill we now read a second time all those of that opinion say I those against say no I think the eyes have it it the eyes have it uh the clerk a bill for an act to amend the Family Law act 1975 and the bankrupcy ACT 1966 in relation to Western Australian deao superannuation splitting and concurrent bankruptcy proceedings and for related purposes thank you Clark no Amendments have been circulated does any Senator require a committee stage if not I'll call the minister to move the third reading I mve that the bill be now read a third time the question is that the bill be read a third time those of that opinion say I those against say no the eyes have it the eyes have it Clark a bill for an act to amend the Family Law act 1975 and the bankruptcy act 1966 in relation to Western Australian defacto superannuation splitting and concurrent bankruptcy proceedings and for related purposes government business order of day number seven vet student payment arrangements miscellaneous amendments Bill 2020 result of second reading debate thank you Senator Farrell thank you acting Deputy president I Rise to speak on the uh vet student payment arrangements miscellaneous amendments bill of 2020 and indicate that the vet students payment arrangements miscellaneous Bill 2020 proposes sensible administrative changes that labor will have course support however as we reach the endpoint of this year we Contin to see devastating impacts of the government's failure in the vo in the VOC vocational education and training sector uh as you would be aware Madame acting Deputy president before the coid pandemic the liberal government had ripped $3 billion from the TA and training sector and oversaw a decline in Australian apprentices by 140,000 the very people who will be responsible for rebuilding Australia's part out of these health and economic crisis it's very disappointing that this government is doing so little to help Australian trades thank you Senator farell call the minister thank you madam acting Deputy president I thank Senator Farah for his contribution and commend the bill to the Senate the question is that the bill be now read a second time those of that opinion say I those against say no the eyes have it the eyes have it no have been circulated or just Clark sorry a bill for an act to amend the law relating to vocational education and training and for related purposes and no Amendments have been circulated does any Senator require a committee stage if not I should call the minister to move the third reading I move the bill be now read a third time the question is if the bill be read a third time those of that opinion say I those against so no I think the eyes have it the eyes have it Clark a bill for an act to to amend the law relating to vocational education and training and for related purposes government business order of day number three native title Amendment infrastructure and public facilities Bill 2020 resumption of debate in Committee of the hall the committee is considering the native title Amendment infrastructure and public facilities Bill 2020 and the amendment on sheet 112 was moved just a little while ago by Senator thorb uh the question is that the amendment be agreed to is anyone seeking the call Senator Seward thank you can I draw the attention to the state of the chamber pleas is a qu required for start get Senators can't leave the CH until quum is actually achieved Corum established thank you call Senator Farrell thank you m Madam acting Deputy president I seek to speak on the native title Amendment infrastructure and public faili Senator Farrell's microphone be put on thank you Senator Farrell thank you for that uh courtesy Madam acting Deputy president uh labor does not support the amendment being proposed when labor introduced these measures back in 2010 we did so uh with great care and following extensive consultations with First Nations communities and while the provisions have been used sparingly over the uh over the decade they have been in force um they uh they have been useful means to help facilitate the building of necessary facilities on land subject to Native title and we support their extension for a further 10 years that being said we in labor share some of the concerns raised about the way in which facilities built on indigenous lands are managed these are outlined in the shadow assistant Minister for reconciliation in his second reading speech to the bill in particular it is essential that uh proper good faith consultations take place with affected communities the legal framework contains a number of safeguards outlined to ensure this occurs this includes requiring consultation to take place at the request of affected parties also uh includes granting the Attorney General the ability to prescribe how uh consultations with Native title parties should occur and put in place specific requirements that can be tailored to a particular Community these Provisions for cons consultation are an essential part of Labour's original design uh for subdivision ja Madame acting Deputy president it's important that this subdivision continues to be used only when strictly necessary to facilitate urgent construction so I take this opportunity to reiterate our calls for the government to ensure that at all times it deals with First Nations communities in a consultative man manner uh so as to ensure that any facilities built under subdivision ja of the Native title act are managed in a manner that is appropriate and respectful to those communities before during and after construction thank you Senator Carell uh you seing the call Mr thank you uh president Senator Rustin thank you very much Madame Deputy president um well the government um won't be supporting the amendment proposed by Senator Thor because it has the effect um of only extending uh this particular provision for a further year instead of the 10 years as proposed by the government uh and the reason the government doesn't support the one-year extension because we don't believe it will provide certainty um to communities to state governments and has the risk of delaying critical public infrastructure on indigenous lands for the benefit of indigenous Australians um so we uh we think that um that you know the bill still does retain the the temporary status of the provision but it does so for a time period that allows certainty and the continued support through infrastructure um for the benefit of indigenous Australians the question is that the amendment be agreed to Senator th chair I have some questions in relation to the bill yes uh how does this bill facilitate the principles of free prior and informed consent over all decisions of what happens on the lands of traditional owners Minister thank you very much adding Deputy president uh to Senator thorp's question and uh and further to the comments made by uh Senator Farrell um in his contribution to this amendment uh fundamental to any um actions and activities that occur um on in lands of of uh indigenous Australian is is the consultation to make sure um that that it is that the infrastructure and and the activities that are being undertaken on those lands uh reflect the wants of the people Senator Thorp uh thank you chair can you outline in detail where traditional owners have been so unreasonable and where indigenous land use agreements were not possible that this section of the Native title act must be relied upon to construct infrastructure on Country against the wishes of traditional owners oh sorry Minister uh Senator Thorp um I can inform you that this particular section um has been used um 127 times um on approximately 1,000 residential lots since 2011 so after over the last 10 uh years 53 times in Queensland 74 times in Western Australia uh and this includes at least 778 public houses and other facilities in Queensland 312 public houses and 73 other facilities in Western Australia um these figures are as at the 8th of October 2020 um and that's been the overwhelming purpose for using it is for uh residential um properties and public housing um but you can be assured that the measure is only used sparingly Senator Thorp thank you chair uh Minister what are the reasons traditional owners have given you for not allowing infrastructure to be built on country that this section of the ACT must be used to to build it anyway thank you Senator Thorp finister thank you very much um Madame AC Deputy president um to Senator thorp's question my understanding is that um it's been um used at the request of the state or territory um governments um and uh and also uh the Queensland aage and T State Islander councils so um it's solely for the purpose of delivering public assets and infrastructure um but it has been at the request of the state and territory um govern governments um under H within whose jurisdiction uh the infrastructure is to be built Senator Thorp thank you chair can Minister can you explain the rationale for not funding prescribed body corporates to operate and develop strategic plans and land use plans instead of expecting them as under resource organizations to respond to proposals drawn up by government agen gencies under the threat that if they don't agree to infrastructure on Country they will build it anyway without their consent Minister uh thank you madamey president each and every application is assessed on its Merit there is no one blanket answer to your question Senator Thor thank you chair Minister can you clarify that this bill will lump traditional owners with infrastructure on their land over which they have no control Minister um Senator th sorry madam acting Deputy president um this is a matter for the state and territory governments in negotiation and consultation um with the traditional owners Senator Thor question thank you chair Minister why is the government using the need for housing as an emotional wedge to under mind the fundamental rights of free prior and informed consent over country um through you madam acting Deputy president I don't accept the premise of your accusation thank you the question is that the amendment on sheet 112 be agreed to all those in favor say I against say no the nose have it the nose have it the question is that the bill stand is printed those of that opinion say I those again say no I think the eyes have it the eyes have it the question is that the bill be reported those of that opinion say I those again say no I think the eyes have it the committee has considered the native title Amendment infrastructure and public facilities Bill 2020 and has agreed to it without amendments Minister this bill now be read a third time report of the committee be adopted thank you Minister um the question is that the motion be agreed to those of that opinion say I those again say no I think the eyes have it this bill Minister bill now be read a third time the question is that this bill be read a third time those of that opinion say I those again say no I think the eyes have it I call the clerk a bill for an act to amend the native title act 1993 and for related purposes government business order for day number four Recycling and waste reduction Bill 2020 and for related bills resumption of second reading debate Senator McAllister thank you Madame acting Deputy president labor welcomes these bills no because we generate 67 million tons of waste a year and a large portion of that is recyclable on a per capita basis we generate more than 100 kilog of plastic each and every year and yet we recycled barely 12% of that waste and we're not alone in having that problem globally more than 10 million tons of plastic Finds Its way into the ocean every year and that is only expected to grow and some Es are that it will triple triple in the next 20 years wrap your mind around that proposition and we are going to need to come to grips with this as a parliament as a country and frankly as a planet because the environmental effects of large amounts of plastic entering the ecosystem are Stark and well understood everyone has seen the horrific photos of the impact on wildlife Turtles with straw birds that have ingested large amounts of plastic and we're confronted by the visible reminders of our waste habits when we see the degree on our creek beds and the Great Pacific Garbage Patch that swirls around in the ocean environment that we inhabit and the evidence for the impact on human health is growing we we know that microplastics have entered marine ecosystems and are accumulating in the food chain with uncertain effects our current practices are not sustainable in any sense of the word limited materials are sunk into Ultra disposable products many of them have a lifespan of minutes minutes before being thrown away and there is no doubt that the best future for Australia and for the world lies in building a more circular economy where materials are seen as a resource to use minimally and to reuse and recycle to the maximum extent possible there's a strong economic incentive to act in addition to being environmentally responsible it allows the prospect of creating new resource recovery and Manufacturing opportunities and that means jobs and employment for every 10,000 tons of waste recycled 9.2 jobs are created and you can compare that to the 2.8 jobs if the same amount of plastic goes into the landfill now these bills build on an important labor Legacy labor supercharged the process towards a more sustainable approach to material management by creating a national waste policy in 2009 we introduced the product stewardship act in 20 2011 and that was a major step forward in developing a regulatory framework to encourage responsible Waste Management in partnership with industry labor created the one co-regulatory scheme in existence the national television and computer recycling scheme and the overdue the well overdue statutory review of the relevant act confirmed the fundamental value of this scheme these bills establish a framework for the phased ban on the export of certain waste materials and they also absorbed the regulatory framework previously L contained in the product stewardship act 2011 while making some minor changes to the substantive rules for product stewardship the government should have acted significantly sooner and it has dragged its heels on this question these bills are best understood as a response to our inability to export our waste as we previously were able to do in January 2018 China in instituted its national sword policy which banned the importation of most CES of waste and until that point a large proportion of Australia's waste products were sent to China similar announcements were subsequently made by India Taiwan Malaysia and Thailand and there were reports of paper and glass building up in waste management centers across Australia some municipalities resorted to dumping recyclable waste in landfill to deal with the problem these changes forced Australia's hand and in March this year coag agreed to ban the export of waste glass Plastics tire and paper the reality is that exporting our waste was never a good solution it is ultimately and indeed definitionally unsustainable it is not a real long-term solution and reports there were reports that in the jurisdictions we were exporting this waste to that material was not necessarily being recycled there in some cases rubbish was burned buried or thrown into rivers nonetheless exporting that waste could have in theory bought us time time to deal with our own waste problem but that time was not used the government could have been transitioning to a more sustainable use of resources during their time in office instead next to nothing has been done the amount of waste we exported actually grew under this government 3 million tons were being exported in 20067 compared to 4.5 million tons by 201819 as I've already indicated they didn't even do the statutory review they were required to do on time that review uh of the product stewardship Act was supposed to be handed down in 2016 but was handed down three years later and there are consequences there are consequences for the endless delay on almost everything by this government on matters of substance but on this question the Senate inquiry into this bill heard from the Australian packaging Covenant organization and they said this I'll quote it I think it and by which they mean the review of the nepom would have been a useful contribution to the discussion the nepom like any other regulation has both positive and negative in it and there are things that we recognize could be done better going forward I think the fact that we're at 20 years into that regulation and there hasn't been a review is probably more indicative of some of the issues or some of the perceptions that are currently out there and I think that if a nepon review had been done earlier then obviously it would have informed this discussion and given rise to thinking around other Alternatives as well since taking office the Coalition has taken no action in listing any new item for co-regulatory or mandatory schemes it is clearly not a priority for this government whose indifference to the National envir environment is scandalous so these bills I said we welcome them and they are an important step but they do not go far enough there are a number of specific amendments before the Senate to improve the operation of this act but we also need practical steps to support recycling the government announced a recycling fund after last year's election however it turns out that 100 million of this was in fact merely a reallocation of existing clean energy Finance funds and questions to the government this year confirmed that not a single dollar had been loaned to support recycling infrastructure through the CFC the $20 million national product stewardship investment fund has not made a single Grant the Senate inquiry into this bill noted the urgent need for the Commonwealth to adopt sustainable procurement models to provide leadership and boost the recyclable sector the inquiry recommended that the government should expedite consideration of a cost benefit analysis of large infrastructure projects including mandatory targets for the use of a percentage of recycled material most importantly as the labor Senators noted in the inquiry to this bill Australia's lack of capacity to recycle the waste we produce especially in certain material categories like plastic is not unrelated to the lack of demand for recyclate and there is no doubt this must be an area of focus and support both through the relevant procurement arrangements and through product stewardship Arrangements that are effective in seeing changes to product design and the lifting of recycled content outcomes the failure of the Morrison government to finalize Market incentives for the use of recycled materials before implementing an export ban is creating a risk that domestic reprocessed materials which can be repurposed may still go to landfill after the bands are in place as noted such matters can only be addressed through the adequate provision of procurement targets that would drive the acquisition of waste materials as the waste management and Recovery Association of Australia noted I think the perverse outcomes we were talking about first and foremost were the fact that we've lost access to markets by bringing in the export bill without the commentate Demand on Shore the opportunity existed if there was more emphasis on the product stewardship with the Paradigm Shift towards generator responsibility of utilizing that product onshore so if I'm the packager that's making the plastic that was previously getting exported now I have to use that packaging material in a Australia because it's good food grade we could have avoided those perverse outcomes of additional stockpiling or land filling so the opportunity that's being missed today is the integration of these packages to change the shift of the Paradigm to say this is good material that could be used over and over and over again in Australia and create jobs now I'll conclude by making the obvious point that this is a disappointingly familiar Story the previous labor government put in place a scheme to tackle our major problem the scheme suffers neglect under the Coalition and it turned out that there were consequences for literally taking no action at all and the government was forced to take action but instead of getting a proper scheme that would stimulate jobs and build industry we get a minor regulatory fix recycling climate energy that is a story that we see time and time again this government is incapable of recognizing environmental problems as being worth fixing it is incapable of recognizing the economic opportunities that come when you engage with environmental challenges properly these bills are a necessary First Step but they're a step that should have been taken years ago and been accompanied by real action to build a real market for recycled materials in Australia thank you Senator mallister Senator wish Wilson thank you uh acting Deputy president I really am glad to be rising to speak on this bill that the government calls the recycling and waste reduction Bill 2020 but the simple problem is it does very little to reduce waste in Australia and it doesn't give the recycling industry the certainty they need to invest in a circular economy and move this country out of the waste crisis that we have been in since China soar in 2017 we have a historic opportunity with this bill to not only fix this waste crisis create tens of thousands of new green jobs in the green industry in recycling solve an environmental problem but we also have the opportunity to do a solid for our oceans and our community now this is very important to me personally for the last nearly 15 years I've been campaigning on trying to stop plastic going into the ocean nearly half of that in this building in Parliament my S my first speech I talked about this issue and some of the Fantastic fantastic people that I've been working with uh in community and in the environment movement to tackle this problem my first senator's statement was about tackling Marine DeBry and uh I feel very privileged to have had the platform as a senator and a fantastic committee system and the cooperation across political parties to have chaired initiated and chaired two Senate inquiries into Marine plastic and into the plastic waste crisis we find oursel in and this Senate was the world's first Parliament to do so we were the first Parliament to inquire into this most pervasive and enormous environmental problem and how we were going to get our way out of this waste crisis because we've been so lazy by exporting our contaminated waste to the rest of the world for so long and we came up with a series of very good recommendation ations so this is important to me and I know it's extremely important to my party to my colleagues who are going to make fantastic uh contributions to this debate to Green State MPS to dozens of fantastic local government representatives for the greens around the country and I swear if I was to name the good people that I have campaigned shoulder-to-shoulder with on this for the last 15 years my entire speech would be taken up by naming them but I will try and get their names on record uh at some stage soon and the supporters and the environment movement but here's the really interesting thing acting Deputy president I was really surprised and I must say pleasantly surprised if not and you'd have to forgive me for being a little bit cynical I was very surprised when the prime minister mentioned at a press conference that his daughter had raised this issue with him and that he was going to tackle this problem I was even more surprised when he made it the keynote part of his speech to the United Nations General Assembly uh in New York in 2019 of course I'd like to have seen him talking about Australia taking a leadership role in climate change but I wasn't going to complain that a prime minister of this country was telling the world that Australia was going to lead on this issue of tackling Marine Plastics the toxic tide the scourge of Plastics in our ocean and I understand he uh it was something he discussed with President elect or soon to be President Joe Biden in the US it was one of the issues they discussed on the telephone the problem is this bill the way it is written doesn't act on Plastics in the ocean because it deliberately excludes plastic packaging the key source of marine Plastics and for those of course yes it is a global problem on a massive scale as we speak now thousands of tons of mostly single years plastic are making their way into the ocean it's been estimated that by 2050 there'll be more plastic in the Ocean than fish we are finding microplastics in plankton in the Antarctic it's all through our Seafood chain and yet what do we do about it what do we do about it if you came to someone who understood this issue and said how are you going to take action to reduce Plastics in the ocean what's the single most important thing you would do you would go ban the single-use Plastics that are causing so much problem reduce our consumption and production of plastics that are almost impossible to recycle and that form so much of the litter and the trash that does so much damage to our precious marine life the first thing You' do is Ban those Plastics and guess what there's nothing in here to ban Plastics there's nothing in here to hold the big producers of plastic some of the most profitable companies in Australia and internationally the retailers of plastic products like the big uh Supermarket chains there's nothing in here to mandate strong targets for these companies that's the second thing you would do you would say okay if plastic packaging is the problem let's try and reduce as much as we can of the stuff we just don't need by the way everybody agrees including the packaging Covenant that we need to get rid of problematic single use Plastics but where's the action on it I'll tell you where it is Senators it's in the States and it's in the territories they're going their own way because we have failed to show National leadership on this issue the Senate environment committee recommended a ban on single use Plastics in 2017 it's not even included in the government threat abatement plan for marine DeBry Marine plastic was declared a threatening process under Federal Environmental laws guess when in 2003 nearly 20 years later we still haven't tackled the key source of plastic that's doing so so much damage but today next week this chamber this Parliament can do that and I expect we will we will do that and that's what the Australian people expect of all of us no more time for being cute no more time for technicalities excuses wle room let's do it I'll talk more in detail about the greens amendments and other amendments when we get to the committee stage they've been circulated now for over a month we've had discussions with all political parties all Independents about this issue we can create Aussie jobs Banning the export of waste okay it's probably not the way I thought the government was going to go but given the waste crosses we find ourselves in if we ban the export of waste such as Plastics it does put it back on us to do something about it it forces us to deal with this problem and if we go down the right path and what we do in the Senate will dictate that if we go down the right path and build a circular economy then we will create Australian jobs and not just in the big cities in Rural and remote Australia we will see massive upgrades in technology and infrastructure from the recycling industry the recycling industry want to fix this problem but they need policy certainty and I'll go into that in more detail when we get to the greens Amendment on mandatory product stewardship schemes I can't stress how important it is that we get this right because this is the first legislation that this Parliament has seen on waste in nearly a decade and I would say nearly two decades and I do acknowledge what Senator Mall said earlier about Labor's contribution with product stewardship games the architecture is already there and if anything the uh second part of this bill which is rewriting product stewardship schemes really just does fiddle around the edges and has some uh some added benefits and measures that we support but doesn't get to the root cause of the problem but as I said I am convinced we will do so today and next week when we vote on this so uh acting Deputy president in the senate committee recently in the environment committee um i' put up a private members Bill uh over 18 months ago to ban single use Plastics to copy the European Parliament I genuinely was disappointed I was genuinely disappointed that the European Parliament beat us to the punch they were the first parliament in the world to ban single use Plastics although this chamber this Senate was the first to have a parliamentary inquiry into the problem the Europeans beat us and they banned single use Plastics so I'd put up a bill that was going to do that I also put up a private members bill that was going to take the packaging Covenant appco Australian packaging Covenant I was going to take their voluntary targets for plastic packaging and other packaging and I was simply going to mandate those to put them in law to take Labor's existing uh architecture and legislation and mandate them now I believe Epco when they tell me that they're different to what they used to be but let me tell you acting Deputy President in 2005 Epco set themselves some targets for 2010 to achieve a 30% recycling rate in this country 10 years later does anybody know what it is it's 16% so in 15 years we're only recycling 16% of the plastic we consume in this country so the Australian packaging Covenant which is predominantly made up of by big companies big packaging companies and retailers has had this voluntary targets that they have never come close to meeting and they've never been held to account well it's time for that to end if we want the recycling industry to upgrade and fix this crisis and they employ nearly 60,000 Australians and it could be T of thousands more if we have a full circular economy if we back the recycling industry and give them the policy certainty that they are asking for and they support the Amendments that will be before this Senate then we can actually create a circular economy tens of thousands of jobs and solve an environmental problem there's four key stakeholders in this debate Senators there's the recycling industry there's the packaging and retailing industry there's local governments around the country that do a lot of the recycling the curb side and then there's community and environment groups when my bill went to committee we took extensive evidence and three of those stakeholders supported the Amendments that will be before the Senate local governments supported mandatory product stewardship schemes Banning single use Plastics environmental Community groups unanimously cheered on mandatory product stewardship schemes government putting in law packaging targets and banning s use Plastics three out of the four supported it no surprises as to who didn't support it the packaging industry now saying that I'll be really clear Epco said they were agnostic as to what kind of structure they were put under and the big retailers like Woolworth's and food and grocery Council who deal with a lot of the appco members and I was on a a really good hookup with the head of amcore the CEO of amcore all of them said they are going to meet their 2025 targets their voluntary targets they're confident they're going to meet them so why would they have a problem with the Senate mandating them in law you can talk the talk walk the walk easy enough so when we get to the committee stage acting Deputy president we'll be able to talk in more detail about why Banning single use Plastics is important why taking voluntary schemes and mandating them and giving the recycling industry the confidence they need is so important if we want to fix this problem in a true circular economy waste doesn't exist rubbish doesn't exist the term doesn't exist because everything has value everything is created for its end of life it doesn't end up in the ocean it doesn't end up in landfill it ends up being reused and creating Australian jobs thank you Senator wish Wilson Senator green thank you Madame acting Deputy president um I rise tonight to um speak on the recycling waste reduction Bill uh and in doing so as Senators often do we reflect on the constituents in our communities um people all across Queensland uh who would be listening in on this debate and um taking special attention now um because I live in cans I I live in the same place as um Molly steer who's a 12-year-old campaigner who led the straw no more campaign um and managed to eradicate straws from cans at the very young age of I think she was about 10 11 years old when she started her campaign so I give this speech tonight in full recognition that there are people like Molly listening and wondering what the government has done after all their rhetoric about action on recycling action on waste action on Plastics because labor does support this uh bill but it remains critical of the government's in action when it comes to regulatory reform of waste management and quite frankly the job creation in recycling which we know is potentially there if the government got the settings right right evidence from the Senate inquiry showed that while stakeholders support an export wasteband this bill lacks Effectiveness it highlights the Morrison government's poor track record on making lots of announcements failing to deliver on those promises the bill would introduce a ban on export of certain waste materials through a new licensing and declaration scheme with standard qualifying requirements fees and charges to cover those costs and Reporting Arrangements it'll replace and update existing product stewardship laws making overdue changes to the national television and computer recycling scheme this legislation has been introduced in part in part because of China's decision to um in 2018 to ban the importation of most categories of waste a decision which had a major consequence on the Australian Waste Management sector it means that Australia needs to dramatically increase our recycling capability and better manage waste across the board labor has been critical of the government for its inaction when it comes to regulatory reform for Waste Management since the liberal national government came to power they have taken no action in listing any new items for co-regulatory or mandatory schemes the Morrison government has taken three years 3 years to conduct a review at a time when the country's waste crisis is worsening labor will support these bills because there is no time to delay when it comes to Banning on EX the export of waste materials but in doing so we want to highlight to the Senate some of the evidence that was received during the Senate inquiry and the report handed down last month because stakeholders have said they do support this legislation but are concerned about the effectiveness of the legislation itself and some of the failures of this government to get the policy settings right stakeholders including the national waste and recycling industry have acknowledge the government's lack of focus on reforming Australia's produ product stewardship regime in their submission the national waste and recycling industry said there is nothing that compels the minister to act should the recommend recommended actions not be completed nor is it clear if the minister can actually recommend in the priority list apply for accreditation as a voluntary Arrangement as an action the global product Stewardship Council submission said we encourage the government to consider reflecting more of a clear willingness to pursue co-regulatory approaches as appropriate to build upon the proposed strengthening around the ministers prior priority list stakeholders also recognized problems with the national environment protection measure 2011 which regulates industry participation for improving environmental outcomes for plastic packaging the Australian packaging Covenant organization drove this point in their submission they said I think the fact that we're 20 years into the regulation and there hasn't been a review is probably more indicative of some of the issues or some of the perceptions that are currently out there if a National Environmental Protection measure review had been done earlier then obviously it would have have informed this discussion and given rise to thinking around other Alternatives as well labor agrees that this evidence should be heeded and notes that the Morrison government should have reviewed the national environment protection measure in conjunction in conjunction with the product stewardship act it was the former labor government Senator mallister pointed out that established the product stewardship framework in 2011 which included the national television and recycling scheme this has led to the recycling of 360,000 tons of computer TV ew but since the liberal national government was elected they have failed to introduce any additional co-regulatory or mandatory schemes Witnesses during the inquiry recognize that the government's shortcomings in meeting the key targets including the goal of achieving 70% recycling of packaging and elimination of an unnecessary packaging currently only 12% of plastic P packaging in Australia is recycled despite it being a major contributor to Australia's waste crisis this raises the question of whether the targets can be achieved within within the current voluntary participation framework it is a shame that it took a ban on importations from another country and several other key Nations for the government to act on waste and recycling there is now a serious deficiency in Australia's recycling capacity there is now less capacity to recycle plastic than there was in 2005 all of those jobs that could have been created through this industry if the government was willing to act have gone wanting in Australia we recycle only 12% of plastics 58% of waste in total the government's own review found that growing numbers of Industry Free Riders is the primary factor that leads to a failed voluntary scheme yet their limited response is to set up a form of naming and shaming to influence businesses to take responsibility but without any way of of affecting that change what this bill also brings into sharp focus is some of the empty words and lack of followup by the Prime Minister and the Morrison government they are always there always there for the photo op and and when it comes to recycling those photo ops are always quite flamboyant always very interesting the media releases go out but even when it comes to recycling and waste as other Senators alluded to something that the Prime Minister has said that he will Champion personally well he still has not delivered on this just when week just one week after the election the member for lyart Warren ench hit the headlines in cans about his so-call war on plastic pollution it was the major media story after after the election Mr ench had been returned as the member for lyart and he appeared on the front page holding up a big bag of waste and saying that he was going to declare a war on waste to protect the Great Barrier Reef the Morrison government in making those announcements promised $100 million of for the Australian recycling investment fund to be run by the clean energy Finance Corporation 100 $ million that this government promised this scheme was intended to provide concessional loans from between $10,000 and5 million to support the manufacturing of products from recycled Plastics and paper to take on the war on waste but over 12 months later not a single scent of this fund has been spent $100 million promise but now nothing has been spent starting to become a very familiar pattern for this government this was confirmed by the clean energy Finance Corporation which confirmed that $0 had been loaned to date the Morrison government has form when it comes to making carefully packaged announcements on waste and recycling but in large part they're not worth the paper that they are written on they are also they also promise $20 million for the national stewardship investment fund this announcement was supposed to provide grants between $300,000 and $1 million to encourage new and existing product stewardship schemes for Batteries electronic products and plastic oil containers but in June this year the department of environment revealed that guidelines for this program had not even been finished $20 million announcement and yet we don't even have guidelines yet the money isn't being spent all these things that have been promised well here we go again these two schemes from form part of what the Morrison government's $167 million recycling investment package and I'm sure that Senators opposite will be getting up in their speeches today talking about these numbers and all these schemes and all these programs well can I tell you they don't mean anything if you don't actually deliver them it means that at least 72% of the package that was announced by the Morrison government has made no difference to Australia's W waste crisis 18 months on 18 months on after the waste crisis was finally acknowledged by this government and a war on waste was declared by members like um Mr anch in lart by the Prime Minister Scott Morrison himself only seven 72% of the package has actually has not has not been delivered failures like this undermine the federal government's promise that the $600 million recycling modernization fund would create 10,000 jobs and divert 10 million tons of waste from landfill again big numbers big promises but it's just not happening these aren't isolated examples of incompetence there is example after example of promises not being delivered by this government the Morrison government announced a $4 billion emergency response fund to prepare for Disaster Recovery eight months ago and we know that that has not been rolled out there are countless other examples of announcements made by this government and Recycling and waste is another area where they have failed to deliver labor supports this bill because there is no time no time to delay when it comes to Banning waste materials and developing our Recycling and waste industry we want to see those jobs we want to see those jobs in places like Regional Queensland but we remain critical of the Morrison government's record on Waste Management this bill will not be as effective as it could be if the Morrison government continues to lag behind on targets to C cut plastic pollution under the liberal national government only 12% of plastic packaging is being recycled Pro progress on Election promises like the $100 million Australian recycling investment fund and the $20 million national product stewardship investment fund have stalled they have promised to spend this money and they have failed time and time again the Morrison government is failing to roll out what it is promising in a timely manner and in a manner that would make a difference in many cases it can't even get program guidelines finalized so in concluding can I say to the young people living in cans uh particularly uh Molly steer the activists when it um of the straw no more campaign uh and all of those people who have stood next to members like Mr ench who've gone to the plastic Summits and stood next to Scott Morris uh the Prime Minister as he's delivering a yet another announcement and a commitment to take on this war on waste that unfortunately can I say to those young people this government is not delivering on its promises is not delivering on its promises they were very happy to stand up next to you very happy to get a photo with you very happy to tell you the big numbers that they were going to spend and going to deliver but they're not they're not doing that they've stood next to young people and told them that they were going to take action on Recycling and waste they've stood next to workers and said that they were going to create jobs in this industry but they haven't the numbers don't lie they are not spending this money they are not rolling out these packages and it can only be for one reason is that they really are not committed to taking action on recycling taking action to help our environment or taking action to create jobs thank you thank you Senator green Senator Roberts thank you madam acting Deputy president as a servant to the people of Queensland and Australia I'm very pleased to say that one nation will support this bill it's a rare event when I can honestly compliment this government for the quality of their Drafting and the sincerity of the process we have the courage and the Integrity to give credit where it's due this bill has been developed after many years of consultation public submissions exposure drafts and fine-tuning the recycling and waste management Bill 2020 is an excellent outcome the provisions allow the minister discretion to pick the approach on an industry- to Industry basis yet with enough written Direction discretion to the minister that there can be no backsliding the time frames envisioned in the legislation are appropriate the greens amendments sadly are bringing forward time frames to the point where it will place an onerous burden on industry and that means on jobs industry must have time to change their practices in a sensible and orderly fashion products with outdated packaging must be allowed to work their way through the supply chain so that small businesses and family supermarkets and low turnover areas often Rural and Regional Australia are not left holding products that are illegal to sell where industry does not C cor operate there are penalties in this bill to ensure compliance those penalties are fit for purpose the greens amendments to increase the penalties would place a burden on small and medium business such that they are unlikely to threaten such they are likely to threaten the future of those businesses almost every policy that comes from the greens demonstrates a complete failure to understand Rural and Regional Australia and small business in fact a failure to understand Australia Australia is more than the big cities it's more than the inner big cities the recycling and waste management Bill finds the right balance between urgency and fairness and there is urgency required around this issue every year 645,000 tons of waste are exported to third world countries from Australia the locals there sift through to remove anything of value and sadly the leftover waste is often dumped into rivers where where it makes its way into our oceans I often see social media posts pointing out that the garbage problem in the oceans comes from just seven major rivers and therefore is not our problem the point that social media is missing here is that the waste from those Rivers originated in countries like ours it's our waste and we need to own it and deal with it ourselves this bill does exactly that and processing such a large amount of extra we waste will create additional employment here in Australia now I appreciate that the Morrison government is getting right quite the reputation for dodgy job creation stats trying to look good not do good the budget laid claim to creating more jobs than there are unemployed for example 400,000 job maker positions turned into 40,000 1110th I was pleased to pleased then to fact check the figures for job creation contained in the explanatory memorandum to this bill and find that to my surprise it is accurate this bill should create 10,000 new jobs at a time when those jobs are badly needed this bill is a win for the environment a win for local industry and a win for the countries and a win for the countries that we will no longer be using as our rubbish dumps in the waste reduction space I often hear the phrase circular economy what circular economy actually means is reusing Plastics by cleaning them and then melting down plastic to re-enter the production process as such recycled resins compete with new resin the suggestion on the CSO website is that the cheap cost of new resin makes the high cost of reused resins commercially unviable the greens would add a carbon dioxide tax to new resin meaning oil to make the new Option dear enough to make recycled resin un resin attractive adding cost needlessly this is typical green thinking their solution is always to tax it or ban it one nation has a better idea our CSO the Commonwealth scientific and Industrial research organization has a role to play here I acknowledge that it's been a long time since the industrial element of their Charter has been used the CSO after all has become in some ways a propagandist for Global governance yet I do live in hope that the organization charged by the Australian people with finding industrial solutions to Everyday problems and challenges can come to our rescue here so let's talk about what the CSO is actually doing on this topic from their website firstly this is all Quote data analytics creating new data collection and sampling strategies to establish baselines of plastic use machine learning our artificial intelligence capabilities can be used to conduct autonomous visual detection of plastic debris Behavioral science we have researchers focused on social questions social questions like how to inspire recycling communication action is the CSO ER gone mad next one waste to energy our work considers how to use Plastics at end of life for energy production won't that create so-called greenhouse gases the dreaded carbon dioxide what rank hypocrisy from the CSO environmental economics we're studying the financial impacts of changes in the plastic supp supply chain says the CSO isn't that the productivity commission's job or treasury how has that anything to do with the CSO then the last point from the CSO Material Science we recognize the importance of plastic polymers biological catalysts and identifying recycling options and new biom materials that could be less destructive to the environment there we go finally a mention on contributing the science behind a whole new Australian industry for biod degradable and compostable Plastics that will drive billions of dollars of economic growth I remember when the CSO invented things and solved problems that Australia faced the CSO sadly is now more interested in telling us that we have a problem than they are in actually fixing the problem and at times the CSO helps politicians fabricate problems but getting back to the bill after after suggesting My Hope for the CSO this bill is a massive opportunity for free enterprise to fix a problem of human progress I urge the csiro to work with industry to produce biodegradable and compostable Plastics that will allow Australians to Simply switch from environmentally damaging materials to environmentally friendly materials but there's an opportunity because pollution is waste an opportunity for higher productivity an opportunity for higher profits to those who are sensible for example safety was seen as a cost burden because incidents but but yet incidents are a waste so safety when fixing when improving safety by removing incidents is an aid to reducing waste it's an aid to improving productivity and profit that's changing fortunately people are starting to work out that safety is not a cost not a burden it's a boost of productivity potentially secondly quality used to be seen as a cost as a burden defects are obviously waste now quality is starting to be seen by enlightened management as improving productivity and Profit the environment is similar the environment is seen as a cost by many seen as a burden yet pollution is waste pollution is the enemy of productivity pollution is waste and when we remove the waste remove the pollution it improves the environment it improves productivity and profit real environmental problems like real pollution of air Soil and Water are costly to humanity and to business and to profits fortunately humans address real pollution in California for example the pollution coming out of car exhaust is now 1,000th what it was in the 70s and that has led to more efficient use of fuel which has saved money for people order Senator Roberts you'll be in continuation when debate was Humes questions without notice Senator Galler uh thank you Mr President my question is to the minister representing the Prime Minister Senator Birmingham how many years has the coalition government presided over record low wages growth Minister representing the Prime Minister Senator Birmingham uh thanks uh thanks Mr President I thank Senator Galler for her question uh the government which uh which we have been proud to serve and deliver for Australians a strong economy uh in the lead up uh into this global economic crisis pandemic induced crisis that we Face uh has worked tirelessly to create more employment opportunities for more Australians and have achieved that in record levels and we acknowledge indeed during that time that inflationary factors including wage factors have been at relative lows they have been at relative lows both together noting that the inflation factors have also been at lows and so nominal wages growth has been at lows alongside low inflation growth but what our government managed to achieve Mr President in the runup to the last election was growth of 1 and a half million extra jobs in Australia 1 half million additional jobs for Australians giving them every opport Senator Senator Senator Birmingham uh Senator Galler on a point of order point of order is relevance it I'm actually trying to hear the point of order I didn't there was no Preamble Mr President it was a very direct question about wages growth how many years have they presided over record low wages growth and the minister should be relevant to the question um I can't instruct the minister how to answer a question nor the terms in which he can answer it when the minister I've allowed you to remind the senator minister of the question Senator Galler when The Minister's talking about wages growth and I would contend that includes being able to glance across as he just was issues of the labor market as long as he relates it to wages growth he can't be I cannot instruct him how to answer a question or the terms in which to answer it but talking about wages growth is directly relevant to the question senator W if that were the case we would agree but he's not he's talking about jobs and other economic parameters and a glancing if I may my submission is a glancing reference uh doesn't then justify a range of material which is simply not relevant to the question um in my view Senator Wong the minister was to use the colloquial phrase glancing across I heard him turn to this just around the one minute Mark so less than 15 seconds in a two-minute answer I do consider to be glancing across issues of the labor market when they're made directly relevant to the issue of wages growth I will listen carefully and let the minister continue Senator Birmingham thanks uh thank thanks thanks Mr President and uh and indeed Mr President I'm more than happy to talk about wages as well as Jobs the two are firmly connected now real wages have increased in Australia over the past year wages price index growth of 1.4% has in outpaced inflation of 0.7% what I was pointing out earlier in the answer Mr President in addressing this is that inflation rates have been at incredible lows and so with inflation low unsurprisingly Mr President so too have Associated wages rates but Mr President what we have done and what achieved the economic strength for Australia was achieve record jobs the answer has expired Senator Gallo a supplementary question thank you Mr President yes I do have a supplementary on Tuesday the IBA Governor warned of and I quote subdued increases in wages and prices over coming years will Australian workers have to endure a decade of low wages growth under this government Senator sorry growth return to Trend my apologies Senator Birmingham Mr President it's important and I than Senator G for at least um using all aspects there of a quote recognizing that the RBA governor was noting anticipated low prices growth as well so low prices growth low inflation environment and it does of course mean that you would well those those opposite like to come in here and of course what they frequently seek to do is talk about the nominal rats and the nominal rates in in relation to wages we face at present a global economic situation quite unlike quite unlike anything the world has seen in the last 100 years our country has responded strongly and better than most but we acknowledge there remain difficulties across the economy for many businesses for many households but yesterday's growth figures welcomed by the RBA governor who you quote who has endorsed strongly the approach the government has taken in terms of our policy settings are all about getting people back to work and driving growth across the econ a final supplement question thank you Mr President given that the government has prioritized spending uh $15 million worth of taxpayers money congratulating itself on its so-called comeback marketing campaign when will Australian families under mounting cost of living pressure finally experience a wages comeback Senator Birmingham Mr President our absolute focus is is on driving strong economic growth across the economy to get growth in all quarters for all Australians and our focus and what we are achieving in that regard has clearly been about getting the growth that delivered yesterday impressive economic figures for Australia economic figures that demonstrate yet again our country is outperforming much of the rest of the world we went into this pandemic in a stronger position than much of the rest of the world because we had been outperforming in terms of jobs growth because we had outperformed in terms of budget management we went in with with resilience and strength and we are now coming through this pandemic in a better position than most of the rest of the world not just on the health outcomes but on the economic outcomes which are closely tied to one another and so Mr President we clearly are committed and will continue to implement the policies that deliver the economic growth like that weham Senator Hughes thank you Mr President my question is to the Minister for families and Social Services Senator Rustin can the minister please update the Senate on what the Morrison government is doing to remove barriers to employment for people with a disability Minister for families and Social Services Senator Rustin thank you very much Mr President and thank uh Senator Hughes for her question um well the morison government is absolutely committed to challenging um misperceptions about people with disability and promoting a more inclusive Australia in this financial year alone we will be spending around $34 billion on programs and services to support and improve the lives of Australians who live with disability and today being International Day uh of people with disability it's timely to reflect on the contribution of the more than 4.4 million Australians who live with disability it's about celebrating their lives their achievements and their contributions it's also an important opportunity to to Mark the contributions that people with disability make to the workforce uh and to focus our ention on making sure that we change the attitudes of our employers so that they understand that people with disability can be a really strong asset in so many businesses around our country so I'd en encourage employers not just today but all year round to see the ability in disability and hire based on what people can do and in doing so improve the job um uh opportunities uh for people with disability and understanding that people with disabil of missing out on jobs because people just don't think this needs to change and today can I acknowledge the pin that I am wearing um was designed by Oliver mes and I noticed that a number of my other colleagues are wearing it too he's a 32y old man from Adelaide who lives with cble posy epilepsy and vision impairment but that's only a small part of Oliver's Story he's also written four books he's an artist a poet and a speaker and we cannot Overlook these talents and experiences of people like Oliver and the contribution that they make to Australian Society so today on the day of International Day for people with disability I encourage everybody I encourage our communities our workplaces our schools to participate in international day of people with disability Senator Rustin Senator Hughes a supplementary question can the minister advise how the Morrison government's 2020 21 budget is helping people with a disability to get into the workforce Senator rtin thank you very much Mr Mr President well we are investing more than $3 billion into disability Employment Services over the forward estimates uh a changes announced in just in this uh recent budget mean that investment in disability employment services will be better targeted working to assist job Seekers uh most in need of specialized assistance to ensure that they can be supported in the workplace uh we're also investing in additional $45 million in the indep individual placement Support Program um which will now expand out to 50 sites across Australia the IPS program uh collocates vocational and other Support Services with youth Mental Health Services through the heads space program and it focuses on the need of young people uh making sure that we support them uh either remaining in education or getting into employment uh and making sure that the young people are accessing the services that they need to enable them to be able to do that so by offering early support we hope that we'll be able to set up these people for a lifetime Senator Hugh is a final supplementary question thank you Mr President what is the government doing to support people with a disability that are employed within the Australian Public Service Senator Rustin thank you very much Mr President well we all know that a do a job is an absolute GameChanger in anybody's life and it shouldn't be any different for somebody with a disability um as a nation we need to rise to the challenge of improving the employment outcomes for people with disability and that starts with with the Australian Public Service setting an example uh so the Australian Public Service um currently uh employs 4% of people with disability but I'm really pleased to say that the department of which um I have the uh the pleasure of being the minister uh that figure sits at 6.8% and today um I'm pleased to announce that we've released the new Australian public service employment strategy to make employing people with a discipl a mainstream activity in the culture of the Australian public service and only the this morning I had the pleasure of meeting Nick and Gordon two fantastic young men who work at Services Australia and in speaking to their supervisors they said that they are some of the best employees they have had and their work is outstanding Senator W thank you thank you Mr President on Monday oh sorry my question is the minister representing the minister for government services Senator Rustin on Monday the minister said that as soon as the government became aware and I quote that the method of debt collection was not valid we immediately ceased collecting funds end quote can the minister advise on what date the Morrison government first became aware that the method of debt collection was not valid Minister representing the minister for government services Senator Rustin thank you very much Mr President and I thank um Senator Wong for for her question um and just in the interest of being absolutely clear about what I said on Monday and and I accept the I accept the direct quote that Senator Wong has just read into the Hansard but what I would say is what I um said on Monday was that income averaging was deemed to not be a valid method by which to determine a debt um and so we just need to be very clear that it was not what Senator Gallagher alleged that I had said and that was that the income compliance program was not valid so just to be absolutely clear absolutely clear um but um Senator Senator Wong as uh as is always the case in this place um we do not uh you know and it's been the the practice of of everybody whether it be the labor governments or successive liberal governments that we do not provide details in relation to specific legal advice however I do stand by my statement that um that as soon as we were made aware we acted with great speed to make sure that we did not continue to use income averaging as the sole method by which we would determine debts in fact we made it very very clear um that we would um make sure that we had further proof points uh in determining um if a debt uh if a debt was raised and so that that to ensure that the income compliance program um was uh collecting or was determining debts by a valid means and as I subsequently went on to say during the week uh that we uh have now this year um proceeded to uh repay the debts that were uh that were generated through income averaging is the sole means for collecting those debts we have now gone through the process um of repaying the majority of the debts that were determined by that means Senator Wong a supplementary question supplementary question and I refer to The Minister's answer I'm not seeking legal advice the minister herself has made a public statement including to this chamber uh that the method of debt collection was not valid she herself has indicated that I'm not going to the substance of legal advice I asking this government when you became aware of the method of debt collection being not valid what was the date Senator rtin thank you very uh much Mr President um Senator War would be well aware that the matter that we are referring to is actually still before the court and for me to come in here and to provide information not only um about the legal advice but the dates when it was received um however what I can tell you is that um that um last year uh that we made a decision that we would uh we would include an additional uh proof points to enable us to make sure the method by which d uh debts were calculated uh was within was was valid and that was under taken at that time Senator Wong a final supplementary question can the minister explain why this government ignored warnings over three years prior to late 2019 and at least 76 aat decisions and continued with a method of debt collection which was not Valu valid Senator rtin thank you very much Mr President well I reject the premise of the question question that Senator Wong just put to me because as I have said in this place when I became aware or the government became aware that the method of the income averaging as a method for determining uh debts was not a valid means by which to uh to determine those debts we changed the program to ensure that we did not continue to be collecting uh to be determining debts by this invalid method um however when you go back to the comments in relation to the aat as I've said in this place this week on a number of occasions each and every case that goes before the aat turns on the specific facts of that case um there were cases before the AIT uh that were were upheld and there were also cases that went before the AIT can on a point of order look on on a point of order Mr President um and this has been happening all week um I I it's hard to hear the answer this question with Senator o' Neil's constant interjections and I I would like to be able to hear interjections I can't hear Senator canel's interjections over senator's interjections and I think it would only be fair equal opportun [Music] order order Senator I I'll take Senator Wong on this or another point of order Senator Wong on this on this point of order Senator Wong on this point of order I would have hoped Senator Canan might care a little more about the fact that this minister is entirely refusing to be that's not a point of order that is not a point of order um interjections I will restate are always disorderly and I ask Senators to allow their colleagues to hear the answers to questions so they may be debated after Question Time Senator Rustin have you continue Senator rustin's concluded her answer Senator hon young thank you Mr President my question is to the minister representing the Prime Minister Senator Birmingham today the UN Secretary General Antonio Paris called on the world to make peace with nature and to address the climate emergency he said quote the state of the planet is broken and humanity is waging a war on nature Secretary General gueras has called on Nations to be more ambitious the planet is already sick the Prime Minister Scott Morrison meanwhile is fiddling around with dates in the second half of the century to reduce carbon pollution to Net Zero The Go posts have shifted Net Zero by 2050 is no longer enough does the Prime Minister know this does he understand that we need Net Zero by 2035 or earlier and what is the Prime Minister doing to address this crisis and this war on nature the minister representing the Prime Minister Senator Birmingham thanks thanks Mr President and um I thank Senator Hansen young for the question it is tempting to refer her to the answers that I've given during the course of the week to to Senator Waters and uh and I forget which other Grand Senators have asked almost identical questions I think Senator farooqi asked a very similar question senator Rice so Mr President let me again remind the green Senators uh in relation to Australia's position that we have committed very clearly to the Paris agreement to reduction targets under the Paris agreement and to deliver those targets and indeed strive to exceed those targets as we have done in relation to our commitments under the Kyoto protocols Kyoto protocols 1 and Kyoto protocols to our effort to date in terms of emissions reduction is real and world class in terms of the level of those emissions reductions if you take examples of reductions between 2005 and 2018 Australia has achieved 13% reduction in emissions compare that with others Japan at 8% the United States at 10% New Zealand at 1% Canada at 0.1% our emissions reduction activities have been clearly delivered and our approach is to continue that you asked about plans our approach is to continue to achieve those reductions through our investment in technology rather than the type of taxes or other mechanisms that the greens of course would love to see applied our approach is to back Technologies to work with with counterparts around the world like the United States in terms of investment in Technologies along our Tech road map to build upon the Partnerships we've struck in new technology areas like hydrogen with countries like Germany like Japan like Korea to drive investment in those spaces and to achieve positive outcomes that continue that track record of emissions reduction Senator Hansen young a supplementary question uh thank you Mr President well it's this type of faffing around lack of action that the General Secretary calls is suicidal that is the truth here what is your government going to do we need Net Zero well before 2050 and you don't even have a proper 2030 Target what are you going to do senator of Birmingham Mr President we're going to keep implementing the policies that have been driving down Australia's emissions already I just outline the extent to which Australia has been achieving real reductions in our emissions relative to 2005 levels compared with other countries not meeting the same scale of achievement by Australia what are we going to do well over the next decade our government will invest $18 billion in low emissions technology out of that we're going to leverage $50 billion worth of new investment this is all about getting the technology points like hydrogen or carbon capture and storage or otherwise to the financial Tipping Point where they are not only used and adopted in Australia but they're economically viable for other countries because you know what we're not going to see transformation in terms of China's emissions or India's emissions or other countries emissions without cost effective technological solutions that's why we're investing in it to get Solutions here that can also be adapted in other countries around the world to fix what is actually a global time for the answers expired Senator Hansen young a final supplementary question thank you will the government cancel the Surplus Kyoto credits as countries like the UK New Zealand and Germany have already done or will you continue to so they cannot be used now or in the future or will you continue to hide to squander and to faf about while the planet Burns Senator Birmingham miss Mr President let me try to give a little bit of an explanation about why it is that Australia has Surplus credits yes you know why we have cplus credits Mr President because when it's come when it's come to the first Kyoto commitment period we overachieved we overachieved we made a commitment to the world that we would reduce our emissions and we did so not only by the margin we' promised but by more than that and that generated a surplus and guess what's happened with the 2020 Target the second Kyoto commitment period we made a commitment to the world again that we would reduce our emissions and we met that commitment and we overachieved we overachieved for a second time and so that is why Australia has carryover credits you know what other countries do other countries don't achieve the emissions reductions in their own country and go and buy credits from elsewhere around the world we've achieved the reforms in Australia overachieved that's why those cred order Senator Birmingham Senator order order Senator Sheldon thank you Mr President my question is to the minister representing the minister for infrastructure transport and Regional development senator cash can the minister confirm that quanus has received more than a billion dollars in taxpayer funded support since the start of the co 19 pandemic including hundreds of millions of dollars of jobkeeper wave sub wage subsidies the minister representing the minister for infrastructure transport and Regional development Senator cash uh thank you Mr President and I thank Senator Shon for the question Senator Sheldon what I can confirm is that we're in the middle of a global Pand pandemic and that many Industries across Australia have been hard hit and I do acknowledge that the aviation sector in particular has been hard hit and as a result of that you are correct the government has provided Industries and employers with support whether it's by way of jobkeeper or the plethora of other policies that we have put in place I am also like you Senator Sheldon and like my colleagues on the government side of the chamber we are saddened with any job losses as a result of the global pandemic and including those job losses that have recently been announced by quantis without a doubt without a doubt it has been a tough year for the aviation sector it has been a tough year and a long year and in particular as you know senator Sheldon because of the fact because of the fact that our International borders remain closed and our domestic borders are only now really reopening up and they will continue to reopening are we seeing more flights in the air but Senator Sheldon our government we have taken extensive action as you know to support the aviation sector to the extent possible bearing in mind bearing in mind the extent of the global pandemic and in fact Senator Shon you would be aware that support to Australia is the Avi aviation industry now totals more than $2.7 billion but like any industry or in Australia and employers you are right we have as a government provided them Cas Senator Sheldon a supplementary question despite receiving more than a billion dollar in taxpayers support Quantas has outsourced a further 2,000 jobs does the government support this decision by Quantas Senator cash uh well Senator Sheldon again the government's been very clear from day one any job lost as a result of coid 19 is an absolute tragedy but this is a decision as you know it is a commercial decision for quantis and quantis are entitled to make those decisions but as I've also already said I have some statistics Senator Sheldon in relation to standups and stand Downs this actually shows the effect of the global pandemic on the aviation industry but also what we're seeing as borders reopen Aviation companies are able to bring as you know their Senator Wong on a point of order uh actually the question related to Outsourcing I'd ask the commercial decision okay um have you concluded your answer Senator Cas Senator Sheldon the final supplementary question since March the government has allowed virgin to fall into Administration while giving Rex millions of dollars in untied grants enabling them to expand their roots given some Aviation companies access to jobkeeper while abandoning others like Donata workers and sat back while quantis has sacked a further 2,000 workers what does the minister have to say to the quantis workers in the gallery and the building today who have lost their jobs Senator cash uh well Senator Sheldon as I have said as the Prime Minister said as my colleagues have said any job lost as a result of coid 19 is absolutely devastating the aviation industry has been hard hit as a result of coid 19 and that is why the government has provided extensive support to the aviation sector after what I acknowledge has been a very long and a very tough and a very difficult year Senator Roberts thank you Mr President my question is for Senator Payne Minister for foreign affairs will a prisoner swap between Australia and Iran as happened last week start a new trend of Australia negotiating with terrorists moving away from the proclaimed position of never negotiating with terrorists the minister for foreign affairs Senator Payne uh thank you uh Mr President and I thank senator Senator Roberts for his question last week Australia uh was able to welcome the return of Dr Karly Mo Gilbert uh to Australia after more than two years in detention in Iran these are deeply complex uh very difficult matters to deal with in any uh International context and even further Complicated by the impact of a global pandemic Australia worked for many many months across two years to secure the release of Dr Kari Mor Gilbert and a range of diplomatic discussions and exchanges between International Partners uh are held at times such as this to pursue those matters I will not go into further detail on those issues but I am very pleased to be able to say to the chamber that it is an enormous relief to have been able to welcome Dr Carly Mo Gilbert back to this country last week we know that Dr Mo Gilbert was in on a point of order yeah point of order Mr President I asked about the proclaimed position of never negotiating with terrorists um Senator Roberts you had a preamble um and the minister is being directly relevant to the question um in addressing that part of the question as well Senator Payne uh thank you um Mr President uh as I said uh we never accepted the charges upon which Dr Mo Gilbert was purported to have been uh detained and ultimately sentenced uh convicted and sentenced uh in that context we continued our negotiations we will not go into the nature of diplomatic discussions with other countries uh our role is to protect the rights the freedoms the safety of our citizens in the National interest uh and that is our absolute Focus we consistently advocate in favor of the international AAL rules based order and we fundamentally oppose coercive diplomacy in any of its forms Senator Robert's a supplementary question we too are concerned about preserving the rights and freedoms of Australians and with that in mind if more Australians are taken as hostages again in future how many more terrorists will Australia need to set free to gain their release Senator pay thank you Mr President we are very concerned about the use of arbitrary detention in a number of places around the world we have engaged with International counterparts in relation to those matters particularly uh counterparts in the UN Human Rights Council uh and in the United Nations context I'm working closely with my Canadian counterpart in particular uh on these issues and it is always a matter of concern when Australians travel to countries where issues such as this uh also are referred to in our travel advice explicitly and openly uh we recommend strongly that Australians who seek to travel to such places not withstanding the fact that the current travel advice continues to be do not travel in the context of Co 19 we recommend strongly that that travel advice is read uh and observed we form the advice through our consis Senator Senator Roberts a final supplementary question thank you Mr President does this promotion of Australia's release of three terrorists in a hostage swap constitute providing support to a terrorist organization which may constitute an offense under Section 102.7 of the criminal code act 1995 Senator p no it does not and I reject the premise of Senator Robert's question Senator McKenzie thank you very much Mr President my question is to the minister representing the treasurer Senator Birmingham can the minister please update the Senate on how the Morrison McCormack government's economic and health response to co 19 is supporting Australia's employment and economic Minister representing the treasurer Senator Birmingham thanks Mr President I thank Senator McKenzie for her question and I know her concern for Australians right across this country City and Metro and Regional uh in terms of their health and economic well-being through what has been this most remarkable year around the world and indeed Australia has and continues to perform better than most other countries in terms of saving the lives of Australians and saving the jobs of Australians it's been an incredibly tough year for many people across Australia and an even tougher one for many people across the rest of the world but yesterday's national accounts have shown that in Australia real GDP increased by 3.3% the largest quarterly increase since 1976 of course it came off the back of a significant decline in the previous quarter however when you look around the world the decline Australia faced was less than most of the rest of the world and the recovery is stronger than most of the rest of the world and these are the defining factors it is a work that is ongoing work it is going to be a long road back for all countries around the world in terms of the recovery from here but over the last 5 months we've seen 650,000 jobs created 344,000 of those filled by women 226,000 filled by Young Australians we welcome this incredibly important progress in terms of getting Australians back to work and the decline in the effective unemployment rate from 14.9% to 7.4% our economic recovery plan outlined in the budget this year uh programs to allowable profitable businesses pre that are previously profitable for loss carrybacks our investment deductions our bring forward of tax cuts our plans around home builder are all about the next stages of recovery over the months and years ahead to keep getting more Australians back into the workforce and to drive those numbers back to where they were in the past back into the future Birmingham Senator McKenzie a supplementary question thank you Mr President thank you for that comprehensive answer Minister how has the government's record economic support through the co 19 pandemic protected Australians livelihoods and kept Australians connected to jobs Senator Birmingham Mr President $257 billion in economic support from the government 130 billion dollars of it already flowing into the pockets of households and businesses has been crucial to maintaining and keeping business capability businesses afloat and therefore of course Australians in as many jobs as possible programs like jobkeeper the job Seeker supplement the cash flow boost to businesses the two $750 payments to millions of pensioners and others on income support these have all been crucial support that have kept almost 3.8 million Australians connected to their employer The Reserve Bank estimating at least 700,000 Australian jobs saved that would otherwise have potentially been lost without these types of programs in place are supporting apprentices and trainee ships wage subsidy has helped over 57,000 small and medium businesses to save again around 100,000 apprentices and trainees to keep them in jobs crucial saving of jobs throughout this year Senator McKenzie a final supplementary question thank you uh Mr President as Australia enters a new phase of our Co 19 recovery how will our liberal and Nationals government support Australians back into work back into training and Empower local communities including in Regional areas to deliver tailored responses to our communities Senator Birmingham Mr President so many of our programs have been supporting right across the economy in the country but our local jobs program is putting boots on the ground across 25 regions targeting particular support uh for employment funding local jobs plans in collaboration with local stakeholders employers and training organizations to help make sure the jobs growth in those sectors and regions is as strong as we are trying to drive right across the whole country our job maker hiring credit benefits right across the country supporting 450,000 austral young Australians back into work uh boosting apprenticeship commencements wage subsidy will help support the training of a new generation of 100,000 apprentices and trainees across Australia but especially in Regional and Rural Australia giving these apprenticeships and young Australians maximum opportunity to get a job in the regional areas to stay in those regions to contribute to their growth and their opportunity and ultimately to generate even more jobs into the future Senator Birmingham Senator McKim thank you president my questions to the minister representing the minister for home Affairs Senator cash Senator I refer to the generous offer from the New Zealand prime minister to resettle refugees and people seeking Asylum who've been detained by your government on Manis Island and Naro after over s years of misery suffering and uncertainty for thousands of innocent people who have committed no crime will your government finally accept this kind offer from prime minister ardern and give people the freedom and safety they so desperately need and deserve and if not why not the minister representing the minister for home Affairs Senator cash uh thank you Mr President uh and Senator McKim uh you did mention uh Naro and Menace Island and uh just for your benefit because clearly you've forgotten why uh people are on Naro and Manis Island so just just to just to remind you Senator McKim it is because you supported the failed border of protection policies of the former labor government you see colleagues when we came Senator um Senator McKim on a point of order uh well predictably it's relevance president and and yes the word Naru was in my question but uh the history the sorted and shameful history of Australia's offshore detention policies is not relevant in any way um I order I'll make the rulings if people don't mind um on the point of order a small amount of historic context is directly relevant it would not be appropriate for it to form the bulk of the answer to the question nor a substantive part of the answer to the question but I think it is reasonable to have some historic context but to be directly relevant it must direct it must directly address a substantive part of the question so you've reminded the minister Senator McKim and I call the minister to continue her answer and thank you Mr President and as I was saying the only reason Senator McKim is able to ask his question today is because he supported the failed policies of the former labor government Senator MIM in relation to though the New Zealand Refugee resettlement offer um the Prime Minister and the minister for home Affairs have made it very clear we appreciate the offer from the New Zealand government to resettle refugees however as you know Senator McKim we remain focused on completing the United States resettlement Arrangement you clearly know the answer you're sitting there shaking your head the US Arrangements Center MIM for your benefit is actually progressing well it is actually progressing well with 876 refugees resettled to date and further departures expected in the coming weeks and months Senator McKim my supplementary question thank you president Minister why is it that uh your government insists that the US Arrangement must run its course before engaging with the New Zealand government in response to their offer why must people wait longer than the seven and a half years that they have already been detained has your government not heard and does it not have the capacity to walk and CH gum at the same time Senator cash uh well unfortunately Senator McKim in answer to your question and colleagues I'm going to have to go to the uh the statement or the question by McKim does your government have uh the ability to walk in sh gum at the same time well the answer is yes Senator McKim because clearly we showed that when we came into office and we actually stopped we stopped the votes coming because you see said M you supported failed policies and as such when we came into government we had to clean up the mess the mess that you created just let me remind you Senator McKim 50,000 people arriving on more than 800 votes 1,200 lives Senator Hansen young will remember this well 1,00 lives tragically lost at sea over 8,000 children were detained whilst Labor uh were in office in government in in July 2013 just a reminder Senator McKim 10,2 2011 people in detention including senator mck for the answer has expired Senator mck a final thank goodness for that uh president um Minister I note the findings of the Australian human rights commission's report released today which notes grave concerns for the physical and mental health of the 196 refugees and people seeking Asylum who were transferred to Australia from Papo Nini and for medical reasons when will you finally give these people freedom and safety and end their prolonged and heartbreaking suffering Senator cash uh well thank you Mr President well the Morrison government we we will never apologize for prot protecting Australia's borders and restoring Integrity to our borders we will never apologize for that Senator McKim in relation to the report that you refer to uh you'd be aware that the home Affairs department has responded to it um and is agree with nine of the commission's recommendations but Senator mckin what you also what you also failed uh to advis the Senate was the commission importantly notes that the reduction in the number of children in detention uh which peaked at almost 2,000 under those opposite that that the commission actually acknowledges that reduction um Mr President this is also what Senator McKim has failed to tell the senate um overall we've reduced the number of people in detention by 85% more than 10,000 under your alliance to just 1500 now and More than 70% of those in detention Senator McKim have a criminal record Senator canel thank you very much Mr President my question is to the minister for foreign affairs Senator Payne on the 18th of September the Prime Minister promised that 26,000 stranded Australians registered with his government at that time that they'd be home by by Christmas can the minister confirm that in the 76 days since the Prime Minister made that promise only 14,000 people on that list have made it home the Minister of Foreign Affairs Senator P thank you very much Mr President and uh thank you Senator Kili for uh the question Mr President uh the challenges for many Australians overseas are well appreciated by the government this is a very difficult time and the impact of the pandemic uh is not as it would be easy to say or think uh pass it is in fact uh a matter with which many countries around the world continue to Grapple with at the most difficult level now so the health and the safety of Australians abroad and at home has been the government's number one priority in these difficult and unprecedented times we are very aware that many Australians face hardship overseas because of the global travel restrictions that are resulting from the co 19 pandemic and we are helping vulnerable Australians Mr President by facilitating access to flights to Australia by providing financial assistance we're required through the hardship program which uh we announced some months ago by continuing to provide a professional and responsive Consular assistance to those in need since the national cabinet meeting Mr President on the 18th of September where the Prime Minister indicated that of the 26,000 uh Australians are then overseas we would Endeavor to bring as many of those Australians back to Australia as we could we have seen 40,800 Australians return from overseas including more than 16,000 Australians registered with the Department of Foreign Affairs and trade of those over 3,500 were described uh were uh categorized uh as vulnerable Mr President since uh the government advised Australians to return more than 432,000 Australians have returned AAL Senator canelia a supplementary question thank you and I note The Minister's response that 16,000 of the 26,000 have come home given that the prime minister's only got seven days for the 10,000 stranded Australians who are registered with defat on the 18 18 of September to be with their families on Christmas Day what hope do the do those 10,000 stranded Australians have that they'll be able to celebrate Christmas with their families in Australia Senator Payne thank you very much Mr President and let me just clarify Senator I said that since uh the national cabinet on the 18th of September over 4,800 have returned from overseas including more than 16,000 Australians registered with F fet that is not necessarily specifically of the 26,200 there will be a component of the 26,200 plus others uh I will get the senator I will get the senator that uh that other number Mr President I know that Senator canel uh and those opposite uh have uh been discussing uh these issues for some time in fact I understand sen canel's uh um interview with Mr forom this morning uh referred to this and it is clear that the uh those opposite do understand the process of national caps uh and the management of the quarantine and the number of arrivals that restricts Us in dealing with in Australia and we are working closely with the states and territories in relation to that uh Mr President because we know what happens answer has expired Senator canel a final supplementary question thank you Dave and Kate jeffes have been stranded with their young son son Mitchell in Canada since their return flights were canceled in March they've had their travel plans disrupted and their flights canceled multiple times will the Prime Minister deliver on his promise to the Jeff family to have them home by Christmas so will he leave them behind Senator Pine thank you very much Mr President we are doing everything that we are able to do within the flights available the quarantine places available within the Caps to bring as many Australians home as we can as many as we can since that meeting on the 18th of September 40,800 Australians have returned from overseas I very much hope Mr President that families such as the one that Senator can has referred to are able to do that within and we will continue to provide them with appropriate Consular support through this process because it is a very difficult situation Mr President we are dealing with as I have remarked before and as I know others have remarked a global pandemic which has impacted our ability to to return Australians from overseas it's impacted by flights it's impacted by quarantine space we have opened Howard Springs we have have accommodated 500 Australians inuring Australians Senator brag thank you Mr President my question is to the minister representing the minister of Health Senator cash can the minister please update the Senate on a global search for a CO 19 vaccine and how it will impact Australia's Health response the minister representing the minister of Health Senator cash uh thank you Mr President and I thank Senator Bragg for the question and uh I'm pleased to obviously update the Senate that the uh Morrison government welcomes the emergency approval given to the fisa co 19 vaccine in the United Kingdom uh this is particularly so given the over 1.6 million cases and the tragic loss of over 59,000 lives in the United Kingdom uh this emergency approval is not a full public authorization however it does allow the United Kingdom government to deploy the vaccine as quickly as possible to specific groups of patients such as Frontline out healthcare workers people over the age of 80 and aged care residents this emergency authorization is in response to the very high disease load in the United Kingdom at present uh it is understood that the emergency use authorization the vaccine uh will not be generally available to the Wi United Kingdom population uh in terms of Australia fisa continues to work with the Australian therapeutic Goods Administration providing data for safety and efficacy as part of the approval process uh Our advice remains that the timeline for a decision on approval is expected by the end of January 2021 and our planning is for the first vaccine delivery in March 2021 fiser of course is one of four vaccines the Australian government has purchased for a total projected supply of around 134.5 million units uh in addition we will have access to up to 25.5 million units under the international Kovac facility safeties of course though Mr President are our number one priority and Australia was well placed both for a thorough but rapid safety assessment and early roll out of a free voluntary but universally available Co 19 vaccine program Senator Bragg a supplementary question should a vaccine prove safe and effective how has the government's vaccine strategy positioned Australia to roll out a vaccine in 2021 Senator cash Mr President the Morrison government has made a $3.2 billion investment in advanced purchasing agreements with four vac manufacturers astroica CSL fisa and novax we've contracted for as I've already stated around 134 million vaccines directly in addition to another 25 million units of vaccine through the international CLX facility this means Australia has secured enough Supply to vaccinate Australia many times over subject to success and approvals our medical experts have identified the class of vaccines that we need the vaccines we have secured amongst the most advanced and it is increasingly likely that all of our contracted vaccines are on the pathway to being successful safe and effective Australia actually has high vaccination rates uh with over 94% of Australian 5-year-olds being vaccinated each quarter this year Australia Cas Senator brag a final supplementary question thank you how will these Investments continue to support Australia's unique response to the co 19 pandemic and how is Australia positioned compared to other countries to face the challenges of coid 19 Senator cash well Mr President more than 18.5 billion do has been committed to support the emergency Co 19 Health response to the pandemic uh when we do look at though the situation here in Australia compared to other nations uh we are performing remarkably well just in terms of a global update uh there have been over 63 million confirmed cases of coid 19 globally and over 1.4 million deaths in total in Australia we've had 27,9 123 confirmed cases uh and sadly 98 deaths uh whilst we can never be complacent the systems we have in place have resulted in lower loss of life lower transmission rates and lower economic impacts than in most other countries Senator green thank you Mr President my question is to the minister for youth Senator colbeck how many young Australians are unemployed the minister for Youth and Sport Senator Minister for youth Senator colck thank thank you Mr President um unfortunately the the youth unemployment rate is too too high at the moment at 15.6% Mr President and and so Mr President as uh we have done through the uh budget process through the period of Co 19 Mr President uh we have put in significant measures Mr President we have put in significant meas measures to support to support young Australians in fact Mr President uh it's it's interesting that the labor the labor party were a few only a few weeks ago criticizing the government for the range of measures that we have put in place to support young Australians to get back into work as the government and as the economy recovers from Co 19 Mr President so significant Senator I have Senator Wong on Senator green on a point of order point of order Mr President um my question didn't have a preamble and it was uh directed at how many young Australians are unemployed uh that's a question about a figure not a rate of unemployment um with respect I don't think it's within the my ability to um decree that a rate is not directly relevant um there's a a time to debate questions the minister The Minister's entitled to order the minister is entitled to answer in that form and it was a very specific question and I will maintain uh tight test of direct relevance because of that as long as the minister is talking about youth unemployment I do think that is directly relevant Senator colck Mr President and and and I believe I was being directly relevant to the question because I actually quoted the youth unemployment rate of 15.6% Mr President is part of my response to the question and Mr President uh and I and I've also said that the youth unemployment rate in this country is too high and and the work that this government continues to do to support young Australians to to uh to get back into work because we are concerned that young people who stay out of work too long have significant lifelong effects with respect to uh their Futures their career their financial circumstances so Mr President so we have made through our budget processes and through the pandemic in supporting people with uh job Keeper in supporting young people with job Seeker to keep them connected to their workplaces and then to support them to gain new jobs through our job maker programs uh appren support program Mr President Senator a point of order direct relevance The Minister's been asked for the number I understand he's now being given the brief perhaps you could advise the chamber as I said before Senator Wong I think answering in this form I cannot say that is not directly relevant to the question what I'm being asked to do is to rule on the substance of an answer which I cannot do while The Minister's talking about issues directly related to youth unemployment I do think that is directly relevant Senator colck thank you Mr President and so this government will continue to do everything that it can to get the 337,000 young Australians who are unemployed back into work and will continue to do that order Senator green a supplementary question thank you Mr President I do have a supplementary but I can assist the minister the latest ABS data reveals that 337,000 young Australians are unemployed how many of these how order order how sorry I s order Senator Senator senator's on my right Senator Wong one of your colleagues is asking the question I heard multiple colleagues on my right is one of your colleagues answering asking the question after you read out the number could you I'll let you continue the question if you could go start from after you read the number again Senator green how many of these young Australians are unemployed today as a result of the Morrison government's deliberate decision to exclude them from jobkeeper Senator colck Mr President this this government has worked assiduously through Co 19 through the development and the implementation of jobkeeper through the development and the implementation of job Seeker to assist young Australians to uh stay in work where they can connected to their jobs to support them through the co 19 pandemic and Mr President unfortunately the youth unemployment rate over the the last period has increased uh that's why we put in place measures Mr President to assist young people to get work to to attract young people to attract employers to employ young people in apprenticeships Mr President and only in last sitting for my Mr President the opposition were criticizing us for focusing on young people and employment as a part of our budgetary strategy Mr President but we will continue to do that because we know the ne the negative effects on young Australia if they stay out of work too long we will continue to support them into new jobs green a final supplementary question thank you Mr President 337,000 young Australians are unemployed and more are expected to join them in the coming months how long will it take for youth unemployment to return to pre crisis levels Senator colck Mr Mr Mr President as the economy continues to grow off the back of the the release of the border lockdowns that have been occurring we saw a 3.3% growth in in the economy over the in the recent figures that came came forward last week Mr President more people will go back into work and they will continue to be encouraged to do by the measures put in place by this government Mr President unashamedly put in place by this government Mr President measures that the opposition has criticized us for measures that the opposition have opposed in this place Mr President the youth measures that we put in place criticized by the opposition uh opposed in this place by the the opposition Mr President uh but we are proud to support younger Australians and employers of young Australians to bring young people back to work Senator Birmingham I asked the further questions be placed on the notice paper please all yours ah Senator Sheldon I Rise to take note of the answer given by Senator cash to the question I asked yesterday's national account figures are nothing to cow about our GDP is nowhere close to where it was a year year ago investment is down consumption is still down wages still stagnant the labor share of income has fallen to record lows and there are still 2.4 million Australians either unemployed or underemployed and the Morrison Government is out congratulating themselves and while millions of asrin are still hurting the jobless crew clue cues are growing and nothing has been done about the challenges of insecure work and underemployment it's clear for many Australians what looks like a recovery on paper will still look like a recession just asked the 2,000 newly outsourced workers at quis 2,000 Australian men and women with families right across Australia now without work because of the heartless decisions of the quis board under the government's watch and the government subsidies only a few hours ago I stood with qutis worker workers like Sha Sha works for quanis as a ground crew at CRA airport he has a wife and three daughters three young daughters you said how am I to tell my three girls that you can work hard but you can be replaced by a company that will pay people less and this is happening on your watch the government's watch and with strange taxpayers money no accountabil ility no control no responsibility to these companies and their actions that they're taking you are abandoning hardworking Australians is this the economy that we want in Australia these are jobs that will be go to the lowest common denominator to companies who pay the lowest wages jobs that will go to companies with lower conditions the workers of quanus will have to beg for their old jobs at l rates and lower conditions of course why because Alan Joyce the CEO's corporate bastardy doesn't care about the workers that made the company the spirit of Australia this is quite obviously not the Australian way but if losing your job as an outsourced company isn't enough of a kick in the teeth Alan Joyce and the board of quantis have done this plan with the implicit backing of the government quis has received more than $800 million in government support in tax relief and jobkeeper payments all of it taxpayer money much of it the taxes are many a thousands of quanis workers to keep the airline alive to keep it flying to keep these jobs secure instead when alen Joyce and the board chose to abandon these workers they did so taking Morrison's money and running for it they did it with a prime minister not saying a word the Prime Minister and the government have abandoned these workers to lower pay and lower conditions all the while patting themselves in the back that we are technically out of a recession the government is crying about comeback well these quantis workers want a comeback too they want to come back to their jobs at the same rates and conditions they worked hard to earn the road to economy to the better economy and Recovery is getting longer and longer every day that the Morrison government ignores the catastrophe in the aviation industry first I let virgin file leaving thousands of workers without jobs and the corporate writers to pick through the scraps then they abandon the work as of dinata retrospectively denying them jobkeeper with a cruel stroke of a pen a mistake that the treasurer could fix this afternoon with just another stroke of that pen and now the workers of quantis more than 2,000 everyday hardworking Australians abandoned by this government only a few weeks ago this chamber passed a motion calling on Alan Joyce and quis to stop this madness of course did they listen or did they care no is this the future economy in Australia one where businesses take from the public person one hand and with the other sign away thousands of jobs without a thought to the cost to their Workforce and fellow Australians and the government turns a blind eye to a blatant acts of corporate bastardy thank you Senator Sheldon Senator stoker thank you very much Madam acting Deputy president and can I start with a tone that is a little bit different different to what we often employ in this chamber during take note often a time for theatrics and drama and witty slurs across the chamber So speaking of slurs um Senator Sheldon's given us a fine example of precisely the kind of behavior that isn't appropriate when we're talking about the families and who who are suffering the consequences of a commercial decision that quantis has taken in relation to making staff redundant now it's important um and I noticed that Senator Sheldon is walking out of the room in in a debate that he pretends senator may I remind you that during this time of remote participation the president did ask Senators not to reference whether particular senators were in the room or not right well um perhaps I will instead frame it this way while I was willing to give Senator Shelton the respect of listening to his contribution I hope he will listen as um sincerely and in the heartfelt fashion um that this important issue deserves I've got my doubts but nevertheless any job lost is a disaster it's a disaster for the people involved and it's a disaster for us here in the Coalition and it's part of the reason that the Morrison government has put so much effort and so much of the Public's resources into trying to keep businesses strong so that they can keep on their staff and whether we talk about the cash flow boost whether we talk about jobkeeper whether we talk about the instant asset write off whether we're talking about programs like homebuilder or job maker we are trying to make it as easy as possible for people to keep working people in work we know that when businesses are strong they can keep their staff on and that gives a certainty fam need to get through this time of uncertainty I understand that anxiety we all do that's why our every effort is going into building that economic strength and resilience but the difficulty I have with the arguments made by Senator Sheldon just a moment ago is that it takes a small piece of the puzzle and ignores all all of the other interconnected parts that go into whether or not a business is able to keep staff on and he's happy to talk about how we must at all times have Rising wages and he's happy to talk about how we must at all times have all people insecure work all wonderful goals but if we don't look at the context in which that occurs it's actually pretty ignorant in circumstances where those opposite have fought tooth and nail for zero flexibility in the workplace they have fought tooth and nail to deny businesses the chance they need to be able to move people around or change the way they do things shift people into different skill sets to try and get through hard times and emerge stronger more able to offer the kind of high wages and security that is desirable when they've stood in the way of those important measures every day that they have served in this Parliament going back decades the issue of industrial relations is one that gets nothing but obstinacy from those opposite well they need to confront a really uncomfortable truth and that is that by their very obstinacy their very refusal to countenance any kind of flexibility at any time it is those very policies that tend to sign the redundancy papers for good people who deserve jobs because the fact is businesses need to be able to adapt to difficult times and this is one of them the failure to adapt the failure to provide a business that's struggling to cope with it with the ability to shift gears to survive hard times that is what ends the opportunity for vulnerable people like those who are in the gallery to keep on in their jobs and so instead of standing here in Grand standand Senator Sheldon and his colleagues should apologize to the quantis workers who've been let down by inflexible and unreasonable industrial relations attitudes from those opposite and I call upon those opposite to get into um to get in a mental space where they confront the reality of this difficult market for Aviation the difficult Market we all face in Co and start to take a team Australia approach because the prospects of business survival are actually compatible with the Positive prospects of working people thank you Senator stoker Senator Ste thank you Madame Deputy president well I got to tell you I've heard some uh contributions in this joint that was one of the worst and I'll tell you why I said in the St and seriously before you start slurring this side of the chamber I'll throw a challenge out to you through you if I may how many Enterprise agreements I've negotiated over the years how many negotiations I entered into as not only a delegate as a longdistance owner driver but also as a union organizer in 28 years on the job how many men or gr Men set of the stoker have you had in your office on Friday night bursting into tears when they found their job go down the road so how dare you how dare you use that language how dare you try to mislead those that may be listening or reading and the qust workers that this side of the chamber need to apologize for standing up for working men and women that is one of the worst contributions and I will debate you in every city every town every yard every shop floor in this nation and you will not win you will not win you are so misch the way you dare try and insinuate that the Quantus workers wages was the reason they got the big a why they didn't even get a meeting or a letter you know how they got the sack are you aware Senator stoker cuz you're so well informed no you've got no IDE I just remind you to make your remarks to the chair and I remind other Senators do you know you have no idea they got an SMS now before we start talking about the disgraceful rates of pay that quantis workers demand they were negotiated over the years they were negotiated by the workers on one side represented by their unions and by Management on the other side you know why because I've been in the room for a number of them Quantus e Mark II Quantus EBA Mark 4 they weren't there there was no no gun to their headquarters they did it but you see Senator stoker you need to understand these jobs are still there your government has thrown taxpayers dollars out like confetti to quantis 800 million for jobkeeper over a billion dollars all up your government and you know what Quantas are doing they given the oh I nearly did that I won't do that sorry chair they're giving you this right this is what they're saying to you thank you very much cuz we're not only going to get rid of of the workers we want their jobs to come back with companies that will pay not even Australian standards they won't pay the superannuation guarantee charges that we are seeking they will fight like hell and you make it sound like quantis are going broke guess what Senator stoker and I'm not allow to say this as she walks out the chamber ah you hypocrite what hypocrisy you couldn't wait to bag out other Senator Senator St it is not okay to take poetic license so I'm sorry madam hypocrisy really you know rank hypocrisy with me really gives me a n in the guts and there's a classic example now Quant Madam Deputy president have actually said they're going to be in the black in two months so what does it take to get through the head of that side of chamber Quantas have used a pandemic for the opportunity to Outsource jobs that are there and will be there as the borders come down and we kick in and you watch all the flights come on the screens next week you watch all the flights coming for Christmas and dare I may ask check how much it cost all of us to get here to camera because we all probably came on Quantas I don't unless the ones that drove check the prices that quantis are charging us to go home make no mistake about that they're having a ball they can't help it they're rubbing their greedy hands to get up they won't have any skin left but I've got to tell you my disdain for Mr Joyce Madam Deputy president is not a secret in this place I've had many and you were at one of my inquiries when we when he shut down the airline oh remember that magnificent piece of bastardy for the austral not only Australian Travelers worldwide Aussie's trying to get home oh we forgot about that but he's got eight other accompli he's ay backed up and I am calling for their this mob must resign Joyce must lead the charge and resign because there's no guts on that side the prime minister's lacking guts he's too busy flicking money with his hand in hand with uh Mr McCormack for their mates at Rex but I'll tell you what what about Richard goer the chairman why should he escape SC while he's on his $584,000 of Quan's money Quan's money not earned by the greedy board by the 30,000 Madam Deputy president you used to represent quanas workers in your great Union stood up for quanas workers for many many years and you know the negotiations we've had $584,000 goer Mr goer did not make Quantas great the workers made it great but he couldn't wait to get his claws into the till a backed up as I said by Mr Joyce Maxine Bren for her 364,000 Jack hay her $211,000 Belinda Hutchinson and she gets an AC I don't know what for $293,000 Michael the strange there's another set of initials in AO $223,000 Todd Samson that's the last time I'll ever watch him on TV what a h what what a state of hypocrisy that fellow shows and there's Anthony Tyler Barbara Warden Paul rer what a terrible terrible situation 2,000 families going into Christmas thank you Senator s your time has expired Senator renick uh thank you uh Madame Deputy president and um I would like to continue uh the remarks there of Senator sterl because he's he was right in in the uh conclusion of his uh take note speech that he actually started to point the finger in the right direction and that is the qu sport now he mentioned a name there that didn't probably get enough prominence but I I I will bring that name to attention because I think it needs to be mentioned this uh uh Miss Barbara Ward uh who just happened to be a senior ministerial advisor to wait wait for it who was she a senior ministerial advisor to former Prime Minister Paul keading former Prime Minister Paul kading now I wonder if I wonder if this is her 30 pieces of silver for privatizing quas because that's the thing here and i' I've been consistent about this I I talked about privatization wasn't the right thing to do in a maiden speech so you can't call me being uh hypocritical about this right but you know the privatization of quanas was facilitated by super enation and the industry funds who wanted to privatize everything so that the labor party in the unions could get control of Industry well guess what you've got your people on the boards now and one of them just happened to be a senior ministerial advisor the Paul keing now if you want to take it out now I'm you know I'm not you know you know I don't want to start going into but you know at the end of the day Ellen Joyce is there at the behest of the shareholders and of the board now I did have a look at the top 20 shareholders and unfortunately they're all nominee Holdings which I'm working on because it really annoys me that I can't see who owns what um but I'm Keen to actually if you're keen on this Senator still I'd be Keen to find out who are the biggest 20 shareholders in the real names not nominee accounts but I suspect if you were to drill down into who the shareholders of quantis are I suspect a large deal of them would be industry super funds I'm not having to go here but seriously if you want to do something about this in a construced manner um I I suggest that you find out which industry funds own quas yeah I'm talking about jobs I'm getting on to jobs right so if if you want to do this and you you know you you guys now have got control of Industry through your industry super funds you need to speak directly to the industry funds because that as Government now we no longer own we no long longer owned quantis and I spoke about this in my maiden speech there is no accountability okay who can the people be accountable to if infrastructure is sold okay because you can't sit there because it was the labor party that sold quas it was the labor party that's all quis and to be fair and I've got a lot of time for you Senator sturl and and uh Senator Gallagher um it's a bit Rich to come in here and have it go at us because we've been trying to help people get through the co crisis okay now you know we drew a line in the sand because we didn't want to subsidize uh foreign owned companies um and you know look I I've been actively trying to get quas to relocate to Queensland so that it's cheaper the cost are cheaper it's cheaper to live in Queensland you know it was started in Queensland it's not the New South Wales and Northern Territory Air Service it's the Queensland and Northern ter territory Air Service and the first time I met Alan Joyce I said when are you taking quas back home because that's where it belongs and let me tell you if it's back in Queensland it'll be a lot cheaper to run it'll be a lot cheaper to run and we should also bring home QBE as well um so I I I I totally empathize with the fact that these workers have been outsourced I hate Outsourcing and if you actually read chapter 12 of mavell is the prince it says never Outsource never use mercenaries never use auxilaries and I've always subscribed to that in my own work experience whenever we Outsource it always ended up uh in a terrible situation however what what I will rebut in this take note is the fact that the government doesn't care about the welfare of workingclass Australians of workingclass Australians and that is why today we stood up and we were happily to happy to push back on what labor seemed to think we shouldn't count those carbon credits that were earned fair and square fair and square by the Australian workers particularly the agricultural sector and particularly Southwest Queensland who as I mentioned yesterday is doing it tough because we're locking up mulga paddocks and I'll tell you what your all mate bar suiv would be you know choking on his soup if he knew that you know we were what we were doing in great towns like charville and Coran Long Reach you know the home Long Reach I should add the home of quantis um so before we get you know start aib baring for the sake of Arie Barger I just asked reflect on this someone owns those uh owns quas go to the shareholders go to the people who control the company control the board and I agree with you on Todd Samson I got no idea what's he doing here I don't know how this play G on there um and and let's try and find a solution together thank you thank you Senator Ren Senator green thank you uh today I got the chance to meet with Quantus workers uh here in Parliament House and um I asked them about what they usually do for Christmas they um are going to have a very different Christmas this year uh usually on Christmas day they go to work they go to work so that other people can get home see their families spend Christmas with their families but this Christmas they are looking down the barrel of losing the jobs that they have had for decades they found out that they would be losing their jobs through an SMS a TV screen came up with an automated message and told them that a decision had been made not to cut their job because the work didn't need to be done anymore but to Outsource their job to another company to another worker and I asked them was there someone there to take your questions to listen to you to talk about these concerns to tell you why this decision had been made and there wasn't there wasn't anyone at that company that was willing to stand up and listen to the concerns of workers they left the room so that's why we're here today talking about this decision and talking about it in reference to the decisions that the federal government has made in regards to the aviation sector because nobody here is denying that the aviation sector has had a difficult time through this pandemic nobody's denying that nobody's denying that and labor Senators on this side of the chamber have been in here since the start of this pandemic calling for support from this government for our Aviation sector but what we are saying is that if you are going to deliver $800 million of taxpayer funding to a company to Quantas then why would you give that money with no strings attached why would you just hand over this amount of support the support that was greatly needed to make sure that people could continue to travel and that those jobs could be saved why would you do that and make that decision without telling workers that this funding would save their job because it hasn't all of this support that this company has taken from the federal government with no strings attached because what we know is that these jobs are being outsourced they are not being cut the company has made a decision to make these jobs less secure to make sure that these people can't unionize don't have annual leave probably won't know even when their shifts are they've had 10 years of loyal service to a company and let's face it to Australians because they have been the ones getting you home when you need to go home for Christmas making sure that you can spend time with your family getting you there safely getting you there safely because these workers care about safety but this Outsourcing decision will make sure that the people who stand up for safe conditions at Aviation won't have the same job security that they have at quantis so yes we are asking the government is that acceptable do you support that decision and they can't say that they do they couldn't possibly say that they do because if they did they would have to admit that they gave this this company billions hundreds $800 million of support of support without thinking to attach a condition that this company didn't Outsource jobs didn't Outsource jobs and I just want to make sure that those opposite because they Crow a lot about supporting Regional jobs that they know that this decision will result in 50 jobs being cut from the cans airport in Regional Queensland 50 jobs from an E from an economy from from a community that has already suffered enough already suffered enough these jobs will become more insecure and this comes after previous previous redundancies resulted in about 90 jobs being lost from the can's airport as I said no one is denying that this has been a difficult time but when these when these uh workers come here and when they rally outside MP's office all they've got is basically denials that this government is prepared to do the tough thing and the hard thing to stand up for their jobs that's Senator green your time has expired so the question is that the motion motion as moved by Senator Sheldon to take note of answers be agreed to those of that opinion say I Against I believe the eyes have it Senator Hansen young uh thank you madam uh Deputy president I Rise uh to take note of the answers from uh uh Senator Birmingham uh representing the prime minister in this place today uh the answers that uh he attempted to give in relation to my questions of course today uh we've seen the Secretary General uh antono antoro de sorry today we've seen from the Secretary General of the UN Antonio gueris a very dear and very sobering warning of the situation that the world faces right now the Secretary General gueras has told the world that we need to lift our ambition urgently quickly and seriously if we are to tackle the collapse of biodiversity and the collapse of the climate before things really do get too late he says that this is an epic policy test but that ultimately this is a moral test he says that if if we continue with the denial that action does not need to be taken urgently that we can push things off to the latter half of this Century that we are risking suicide that it would be suicidal to continue to deny the actions science tells us we need to take secretary gas has called for countries to take more action and be more ambitious in relation to our 2030 uh emission reduction targets he's called on us to do whatever we can to make sure we meet net zero emissions and rather than going with a 2050 Target it's quite clear that if we had to tackle the climate crisis the extinction crisis and the death of this planet we have to bring forward that Target to much much earlier the goal posts have shifted debating about whether 2050 is the appropriate time frame for net zero emissions we've missed the boat we have to make that decision much much earlier it needs to be at least 2035 if not earlier and yet we've got our government here refusing to engage in a proper strategy and the action to reduce our pollution to help address the climate crisis in the time frames that we have left we have 10 years to take action the un's dire warnings today should not simply be dismissed and in fact what we're seeing now is that countries right around the world are focusing their minds sharpening their action and are forcing countries like Australia to justify our ignorance there is nowhere left to hide we've just had of course the very clear message sent from president-elect Biden that we need to come to the UN Conference next year in Glasgow with a much more ambitious attempt commitment and action to tackle climate change to reduce carbon pollution we now have the head of the UN saying that if we don't do this we risk the death of the planet he says that the state of the planet is broken talks about the impact on food Security on conflict that it is now climate change that is not just risking the health of our environment more extreme weather an expansion of deserts and the choking of our oceans but that it is going to be climate change that is the biggest driver of conflict around the world displacement of people and the conflict that flows from that I asked the minister representing the Prime Minister whether this government understands how dire this situation is I asked the Prime Minister through Senator [Music] Birmingham whether he understood that we need needed to get to net zero emissions by at least 2035 I asked the Prime Minister through Senator Birmingham whether we were going to improve our action to towards 2030 and have a more ambitious Target and I asked the Prime Minister through Senator Birmingham whether the government would rule out using Kyoto carryover credits on all three of those questions the minister refused to answer and why is it just ignorance is it because they're too busy faffing about they don't understand their own policy or are they just hoping that if they continue to turn a blind eye to the facts that the the crisis will somehow disappear we need climate reality from this government and all we've got is climate so the question is that the motion to take note of answers is moved by Senator Hansen young be agreed to those of that opinion say I Against I believe the eyes have it Senator Patrick thank you um um Madam Deputy president I seek leave to LOD light notice sub motion his leave granted there being no objection leave is granted thank you thank you so um we'll now move to the tabling and consideration of committee reports and government responses uh Senator mcgr thank you I present additional information received by the finance and public administration legislation committee relating to estimates thank you on behalf of the chair of the Community Affairs legislation committee senat ask you I present additional information received by the committee on its inquiry into the revisions of the Social Security Administration Amendment continuation of cashless welfare Bill 2020 thank you Senator mcra Senator McCarthy uh thank you madam uh Deputy president I wish to take note of uh the committee's report the Cash's welfare card and I don't think there is another issue that so clearly demonstrates this government's agenda to demonize penalize and brutalize people who find themselves relying on our social safety nets it is a terrible policy a devastating policy and one that has through numerous inquiries seen no evidence to suggest that this is the direction our country should continue to go for the people of the Northern Territory who whom I represent here in the Senate there has been overwhelming evidence that they certainly do not wish to be a part of the cash cashless debit cards uh trials or permanent situation the people of the Northern Territory have had the 2007 intervention upon them which brought the basics card and forced compulsory income Management on every single family who lived in over 70 uh communities that were identified by the Commonwealth as areas that they should intervene on those families their children and for some their grandchildren have grown up under this system over the last 13 years of income management we have heard certainly uh some comments around uh whether there is extra food on the table but can I just remind the Senate that we have had a coid 19 pandemic which has seen the increase of funds to families across Australia and guess what that too puts food on the table the real issue here though goes far deeper the real issue here is the focus on a particular race here in the Northern Territory and I cannot stand more passionately against such racist intervention such a deliberate attempt to continue to disempower some of the most vulnerable families without encouraging them to empower themselves to rise above their particular situation it is not good enough to say that family over there who live in a remote or Regional part of Australia should have their monies their choices determined by this parliament in such a way where they feel they have no chance to rise above their own situations and to grow just as any other Australians do in determining their own future their own livelihoods and the livelihoods of their children the Australian government is considering ing the best possible ways to support people families and communities in places where high levels of welfare dependence coexist with high levels of social harm the cashless debit card is testing whether reducing the amount of cash available in a community will reduce the overall harm caused by welfare fueled alcohol gambling and Drug misuse it is pretty clear Madame Deputy president the CDC has failed that test by any measure it is exacerbating harm and hardship and the efficacy of the cashless debit card and income management more generally has been the subject of several inquiries as I have mentioned and these investigations have not found evidence of the effectiveness of these policies in fact significant harm has been associated with compulsory broad-based income management an independent analysis of the cashless card in sauna conducted by the University of South Australia concluded that the CDC policy has had no substantive effect on the available measures for the targeted behaviors of gambling or intoxicant abuse Now isn't it incumbent on us as political leaders and in particular this government to listen to its own reviews of its own policies and yet on this particular occasion a near $2.5 million review Into the evaluation of the trial sites across uh four jurisdictions or three jurisdictions with two trial sites in one that evaluation was not even read by this Minister not even read and not even the department that she is respons responsible for could tell us the certainty of that report however however all of that aside the minister still introduced this piece of legislation in order to continue to permanency those four trial sites across Australia and even worse than that include 23,000 territorians and plus families in Cape York without having even read her own evaluation report it is absolutely disgraceful and then we see in the House of Representatives last night the member for bass Bridget Archer stand up and argue that numerous inquiries have failed to find even any evidence the cashes CIT card scheme has any benefit to atrisk communities she is a liberal member of the Morrison government who says it fails to address systemic issues of disadvantage among vulnerable Australians Mrs arer was telling her team this is a policy that is not working this is not working and she does not want to see it in Tasmania unfortunately Mrs Archer didn't go far enough and vote against the cashis debit card but then we see today another liberal MP comes out and says hm this just doesn't work Victorian liberal MP Russell Broadband said his expectation was the government would drop the legislation which also transitions another 26,000 people in the Northern Territory in Cape York onto the card according to Mr Broadbent no one wants to rock the boat over this issue but I don't believe it has broad support in the party room Mr Broadbent told the Australian people should have the freedom to deal in cash if they want to well there you go I wonder if we have courageous senators of the coalition government who would not only speak their truth similar to their colleagues in the lower house and stand up and vote against this horrendous policy that disempowers that brutalizes that keeps people in poverty and gives them no hope for breaking through the incredible disadvantage that they do not need thrown in their faces because they experience it so deeply I have had had the wonderful pleasure and it was to be able to invite Senators to the Northern Territory and to ask them to listen to the people of the Northern Territory and I do thank uh Senators uh Rex Patrick and Senator Jackie lambi for doing exactly that because this particular piece of legislation is going to have a profound impact on the lives of thousands of families thousands and thousands and thousands of families of the Northern Territory who've had enough and I want senators in here to speak from the heart to bring back the voices that they listen to up north and I also thank centralizes Rebecca shaky and her staff who came up to the Northern Territory and I know that that is shared with Senator Griff Senators I dearly hope that you will do some solid reflection on this piece of legislation this is the time when our Parliament can be enormously courageous and get rid of get rid of the cashless debit card get rid of the falsehood of what it espouses to do for the people of Australia when in reality what it does is disempower disengage and give hopelessness to families to Australian families who need far more from us as politicians and who need far more from us as a country that should be working with all families to rise above all those issues and Empower them to be the people that they are here to be just as we are standing here in this Parliament thank you Senator McCarthy Senator SE I Rise to make comments on this particular piece of legislation and this additional information as well my views on the cashless debit card and income management are well known in this place from day one the greens have said this is not good policy this is not the way to treat people income management compulsory income management has been in this country in the Northern Territory for 13 nearly 13 and a half years nearly 13 and a half years and yes I heard that intervention for those that didn't hear it mentioned Jenny mcklin and yes labor did make a mistake I I have said that many times in this place but they but they have now looked at the evidence and show and seen it doesn't work so I give him an enormous amount of credit for that because they've looked at the evidence and certain labor Senators have been opposed to this all along they knew it wasn't going to work but they've looked at the evidence or should I say lack of evidence lack of evidence which is in itself evidence I suppose you'd say it doesn't work the final evaluation of the Northern Territory intervention clearly showed that met none of its objectives none of its objectives and the government keeps changing now what the objectives of the trials are they were originally about you know the intervention was originally about supposedly ending child abuse and putting food on the table and now the trials of morph 2 addressing alcohol and drug abuse and gambling and now they seem to be morphing back to putting food on the table this is flawed ideology about the way that you ACH a change and you know the way you achieve change you address the underlying causes of the of the disadvantage that exists in First Nations communities you address the social determinance of Health you address the fact that this is still stolen land that we have never ever acknowledge that as a nation we address the intergenerational trauma we address the fact that children are being still inappropriately taken from their families we address the fact that there's not sufficient housing we acknowledge the intergenerational trauma and we finally address that but instead what does the government do takes an ideological approach and that's the only conclusion you can draw because despite the fact that there's no evidence they still proceed they still proceed and they send in the Warriors to to argue that this is the way to go certain billionaire puts up the idea that income management is the way to go despite the fact that the final evaluation of the Northern Territory intervention showed that it did not meet any of its objectives this is the time where we knock this failed flawed ideological punitive approach racist discriminatory approach on the head when when this comes up for vote next week this chamber has the opportunity to say no permanently and end this abusive card that for 13 years has been in place in this country knock it off I beg crossbench Senators to knock this off finally say no don't let them do this permanently and don't negotiate any form of extension which is what has happened in the past it's all let's just extend this a little bit longer no you don't need any more extensions it's flawed it's failed and the government hasn't produced its evaluation it's had it for quite some time now makes you wonder what's going on with it perhaps it doesn't say the things they want it to say just like the ARA evaluation didn't say the things that it wanted to say just like the auditor General's report or the an's report actually found that was no evidence to show that they could claim there was reduction in Social harm knock this legislation off and let's focus the resources the time and energy that's wasted on this flawed approach on something that works and genuinely commit to walk with first nations's peoples in fact walk behind them we need to have Aboriginal Le decision making First Nations Le decision- making here and the government runs up the line oh we did talk to First Nations peoples well they didn't talk to communities Walk The Talk walk the talk of the AR the new agreement with First Nations peoples to close the gap walk the talk because this is not walking the talk the card is not walking the talk knock it off for good permanently when this comes to a vote next week thank you Senator see what Senator Brockman thank you Madame Deputy chair I just wanted to for the record I speak briefly to this matter but more to correct the record Senator McCarthy uh quoted uh Mr Broadband from the other place my understanding is Mr Broadband has corrected the record and those comments were actually to do with another piece of legislation so I I just think it is important that the chamber knows that and perhaps Senator O Sullivan may be wanting to expand on that if he is making a contribution thank you Senator Brockman I'm going to go to Senator SE now he's sharing it round a Bigg a but Senator Pratt you've had your go thank you sorry Senator Pratt thank you Madame Deputy president and I also rise uh to take not of the additional information in relation to the Social Security Administration Amendment cashless welfare Bill 2020 and I share uh the anger and The Angst of others on this side of the chamber in relation to the government's pursuit of this legislation uh and I note in particular among the additional information that's been presented to the chamber this afternoon that I'm taking note of uh Senator seart asked for information about the departmental costs to date associated with the CDC for the department and any other government Department are associated with the trials and I have to say it was a rather eye-watering amount the cost from 1516 to 2019 19 20 is some $ [Music] cashless debit card income management uh when they want to reduce those payments for people on payments like job Seeker to just $40 a day what is it you really think you're doing in spending that kind of astronomical amount of money micromanaging people's finances what's the point of micro managing the finances of people who simply don't have enough to live on anyway I note that one of the objectives of the so-called cashless debit card uh is to address alcohol and drug abuse and I have to say that if you are managing to by alcohol on uh those low payments we know that the research into these uh the cashless debit card showed I think uh looking at Labor dissenting report that some 87% of people simply don't have a problem with alcohol they simply uh 87% of uh participants reported they did not have a problem with alcohol now I can tell you of the 76 senators in this place and of 76 people who might be on job Seeker payments in the Northern Territory who've been placed on uh income man on this cashless debit card you take 76 Senators versus 76 people on a cashless debit card on job Seeker payments in the Northern Territory who do you think spends more on alcohol each month each fortnite hands down uh I'm sure that that spent money spent in here would be tenfold tenfold that of anyone on a cashless debit card so if you want to invite people to look in your pocket to look at your drug habits at your alcohol consumption go right ahead but I have to say this punitive micromanagement that does nothing to build the capacity and resilience of people is absolutely ging I also have to say that the focus of making the cashless debit card compulsory in the northern ter territory I find implicitly and overtly racist it is overtly racist you only need to look at other examples in Australian history such as you know our debate this week about uh saving a seat in the Northern Territory I have to say if the citizens of Australia First Nation s people our citizens in Australia who lived in the Northern Territory prior to n 1911 that's the time when uh the Northern Territory was split from South Australia to become a territory and effectively had its Senate voting rights at that time removed it's its Democratic House of re representative voting rights removed so South Australia got its 12 senators and the people of the Northern Territory lost their right lost their right to vote for senators so I have to say would we have done that to the population of the Northern Territory back then in 1911 had the population of the northern territory all been white well the answer is obvious it's intrinsically obvious the answer is of course no and I think those that look back on this debate about the cashless debit card in the future would also know when they reflect on this debate that the Northern Territory is singled out because because the majority of people that live there are First Nations people so when it comes to these debates we must as others have said leave the cultural Authority and Leadership around finding things that work for community in the hands of those communities we are too far and too remote it's it's not them it's not those in the remote communities of the Northern Territory that are remote it's we that are remote from them we have to talk about the issues in their communities in a way uh where they have the voice in it and not us uh as uh Representatives uh in this place with all the Privileges and income that comes with it and so I implore the Senate to reflect morally on what it is to single the Northern Territory out and other the other trial sites essentially in large part for their indigeny and the government will say well this now applies to everyone in in the Northern Territory but I take you back to the principle are you about to want to apply apply this to Victoria New South Wales Western Australia to everybody there are 1.4 million people now on job Seeker payments in our nation what gives this place the right to start interfering with their budgeting and their freedom within our society and these impacts are very real we leave stupid bureaucratic systems in charge of the fundamental details of people's lives as someone quoted in their evidence to the committee uh and they were an uh a student a Hospitality worker paying their own rent earning their own income once they lost their uh once they finished their study and went on to a jobseeker payment they were of course also moved on to a cashless debit card and what did that young person who' finished their education tell us they told us that they had lost count of the number of times in due blocked the payment of my rent the simple fact is that the cashless debit card is a big bureaucracy that doesn't PE meet people's needs their needs to uh exchange money with family members to participate in a cash economy to do basic things like pay their rent so this afternoon in this debate I call on Senators to reflect morally your on this issue now expired I call Senator rivan uh thank you very much Madam maing Deputy president uh I look forward to more folsome debate uh on this subject when the bill eventually does come uh before the Senate but I did want to place a few things on the record uh and deal with some of the issues that have been raised uh by those Ops and I and I really do respect the contribution of senors in this place I I don't in any way want to take away or diminish their sincerity and their their commitment to the issues the substantive issues that are dealt with uh when talking about this subject but for me uh and this government we certainly believe that every right every child has the right to feel safe receive a good education and have high hopes for the future yet sadly uh through the work that I I've done over many years across Australia particularly in uh in in indigenous communities I've seen firsthand that not every Australian is given that opportunity and afforded those opportunities uh alcohol and drug fueled harm enabled by unaccountable welfare provided to parents or Guardians have robbed far too many children of these rights but thankfully thankfully based on the testimony of people living in the communities where the cashless debit card exists thankfully in those communities we are seeing that through the trial of a more responsible delivery of welfare through the cashless debit card we are seeing improvements across those communities the CDC is a userfriendly sophisticated bank card that offers participants access to PayWay Bay online shopping uh recurring uh deductions and the ability to transfer funds between program accounts rent can be paid through it we've heard testimony here from um former Senators who said that uh that rent couldn't be paid well that's simply not true there might have been a situation where there wasn't enough funds in the account and that's why the payment couldn't have been made but there's no technical limitation on abil on a person's ability to be able to pay things such as rent to be able to pay for bills to be able to pay for those essential services that they would require to provide for their families when a payment is loaded onto the card 80% is quarantined for things like bills groceries living and school expenses really anything except for alcohol gambling or cash which of course could then be used to purchase drugs now the other 20% can be used to purchase any items that don't fall into these categories and I've been on the ground in the trial site communities speaking to locals Community leaders and meeting with organizations directly involved in the delivery of the scheme and the raran services which support it and their feedback along with the evidence has actually been very clear participants have reported consistently drinking less now doesn't mean that every single one has been able to deal with and the with the issues that they've got no of course not no one has said that this cashless debit card is a silver bullet no one has said that this cashless debit card is going to be the solution to solve the issues that are there but what the communities are telling us what the communities have told me directly as I've been in these communities I'm not some academic from a desk from a desktop in in the the in cber or in Melbourne or in Sydney I've been to these places spoken to people on the ground and what they tell me is that it's become a circuit breaker to enable them whether you know particularly if they're a service provider providing Social Services to the community providing Counseling Service providing Drug and Alcohol Services providing support to the community they're telling me that it's a circuit breaker so that they can actually help connect with people now just last week as it so happen uh a group got together uh from various parts of the country uh organized by the minderoo foundation and uh for full disclosure I used I used to work for the minderoo foundation I was part of the development of the cashless debit card when it was first uh first put to government and the mindo foundation uh brought together people from the communities from the communities that the the cashless debit card is in operation uh including a few other places where they operate the basics card and where this legislation that will come before the Senate will actually uh swap the basics card which is a very uh rudimentary technology there's only something like 16,000 Merchants across Australia that will accept the basics card whereas the cashless debit card there's 900,000 Merchants because it's essentially just a master card so it can be used at fbos machines right around the country whereas the basics card is very limited in where it can be used so there were uh individuals representing uh themselves and in and in many cases representing organizations that were from the Northern Territory and from Queensland in the in the cape York where where the basic card is in operation people uh indigenous people non- indigenous people uh there was a room uh when I was there for about 50 people that were were that had gathered together sadly because of the Border restrictions uh people from suuna weren't able to come uh but they participated online through uh through through Zoom or or one of those mediums and at the end of that form they have written a communic which is actually uh just been released and I just want to quote one section of it it says we support the continuation of the cashless debit card as an ongoing income Management program to make the existing CDC trial sites permanent and to transition income Management in the Northern Territory and Cape York Region from the basics card to the CDC so this assertion that the communities where it's operating now don't want it or that it's not supported in the community is just simply not true if I went to a community of course if any of us went to a community of course you'll find people that don't support it but the overwhelming sense that you get from people when you speak to them on the ground particularly the mothers particularly the grandmothers who care deeply about their children and are sick of the the humbug sick of the the problem that comes from uh uh you know in in their families when when others come and and and hassle them for for money and you hear from them and you sit down on the grass with them and listen to them they'll tell you when there's not the threat of O of of um you know being ostracized when there's not the threat of being abused for for maybe speaking out openly they'll tell you and they'll tell like they did last week when they came to Perth that they support the extension of this program and one of the great parts of this legislation just to give comfort for those that are listening one of the things that the legislation when it's AIT before the uh Senate and it was dealt with uh through the committee process is that it removes the power of the minister through regulation to expand it into other communities therefore it would require further legislation further legislation to be able to come to this place to take it anywhere else so at that time we'd be able to have a debate about the future of it about where it would go this legislation is primarily dealing with the fact that the basics card needs to be replaced with a better solution so that when someone runs out of fuel or getting run low on fuel and they're driving past a service station that doesn't accept the basics Carter they don't run the risk of running out of fuel to drive down the road further down the road where there's a a service station that sells that fuel using a Basics card because the cashless debit card will be able to use wherever an FP machine is and so it makes it seamless frictionless for the participant and they won't have the hassle that they currently would have with the basics card so this is going to help the communities across the Northern Territory and across the cape York and for those communities that have the cashless debit card already that want the certainty of it going forward rather than just 12 months or 12mth to 12- month extension they want the certainty of it so that they can continue to build and continue to deal with the issues that they so desperately want to deal with that they so desperately want to get on top of that's what this is about that's what this bill is about it's and that's what this this report ultimately has demonstrated thank you Senator aivan and the question is that the report be noted all of those in favor say I against declare it carried Senator Galler uh thank thank you Madame acting Deputy president on behalf of the economics references committee I present the report of the committee on Regional inequality in Australia together with a handside record of proceedings and documents presented to the committee and I move that the Senate take note of that report and also seek leave to speak to the I don't believe you need leave but I'm off you go Senator gallager thank you very much uh Madame acting Deputy president and I suppose that uh at the outset I just like to put on the record the uh the competence professionalism and dedication of the Secretariat in preparing uh the report after assessing you know a large number of submissions it's it's always uh a pleasure to work with the professional people in the Secretariat and I suppose just before I go into the detail of the report uh it's incredible that sometimes in this place the debate proceeding uh an item is is very cognizant this is about Regional inequality and there's no greater err of regional inequality and some of the areas of indigenous uh activity and the lack of uh educational opportunities and the like so I did uh enjoy the contributions of previous Senators on the on the matter and I think a central theme of it all was that there is areas of improvement by state local government and federal governments which would impact on the uh the topic before so basically on the 14th of February 2018 uh the Senate referred the inquiry into the indicators of and impact of regional inequality in Australia um for inquiry and report by the last sitting day of 2019 and it has been extended uh subsequently since then uh one of the unfortunate things is that uh due to the pandemic we weren't able to travel as frequently or as far as we would have liked to do but we did get a substantial number of visits in and the uh the indicators of and the impact of regional inequality in Australia with particular reference to government policies and programs in the following areas fiscal policies at the federal state and local government levels improved coordination of federal state and local government policies Regional development policies infrastructure education building human capital enhancing local Workforce skills employment Arrangements decentralization policies Innovation manufacturing and any other related matters were the terms of reference so as at about the 15th of December 2019 the committee had received a total of 140 submissions to the inquiry 129 during the 45th Parliament and a further 11 during the 46th uh Parliament uh conducted five public hearings in the following Regional areas Emerald 29th of August 2018 Darwin 5th of November 2018 and uh Townsville 7th of November 20 8 uh pusta 19th of November 2019 Teran 21st of November 2019 and and as I've said we always get um plenty of submissions plenty of interesting evidence and plenty of good contribution from Regional Australia because there is a there is a necessity to do this systematically and and continue through no matter who's in government it doesn't really matter who's in government this work needs to continue systematically and Method the methodology needs to be agreed each stakeholder needs to know their part and we need to get on with it and I I will pay credit on the other side of the chy because I think um Senator pay in the position of Minister of Defense took on board our submission and our inquiry into the involvement of Defense spend around their Regional basis we identified some areas of concern and almost in an eye blink uh Senator P was on to it and Incorporated that sort of strategy of direct involvement engaging employment around Regional defense spaces I suppose the irony of the chamber is that it was Senator Reynolds that claimed claimed the credit for it but uh I'm sure that Senator Payne had a r grin when that happened but anyway we've been around and there's a continual theme in this in this particular area uh which shouldn't go unreported or unrecognized and that continual theme is the lack of Education and Training opportunities uh in Regional Australia the view that Education and Training were both neglected and important for the regions was a common one a number a number of submissions argued it was difficult for people living in the regions to have the same level of access to education as those live in major cities um the region universities Network commented there is a significant inequality in education attainment between the region Regional Australia and major cities Regional Australia is a generation behind in educational attendant compared to major cities and may W may take a generation or more to address this inequality so you know this theme is not U is not just coming from one area it's coming from right around the country uniting country sa when I what could be better uh in terms of support the first point immediate investigation in Education and Training opportunities across our region we have a lot of people who have to leave our communi toess access that sort of service policies and procedures that encourage investment from industry within our service area as well as provide greater career opportunities would be promoting greater wealth within our communities we've got ta and they do a range of courses but there enough not enough opportunities so once again if you educate people you need to have a pipeline of opportunity and without that pipeline of opportunity we're condemning people to in some cases in the Indigenous sector to almost a lifetime of inequality if they can't complete high school or if they can't there are no opportunities when they complete high school to go into an appren ship or a training ship then you know we really have failed those regions uh we take the vibrant city of w being a bit paral here and I apologize to those people I don't mention in the short time I have here today but any Senator will tell you they always take the opportunity to mention their home state first so the mayor mayor CLA mland of the wer city council observed we are a city with aging infrastructure both industry and Community assets we have pressure on the council's budget to balance FIS Financial sustainability against the need to upgrade assets to improve livability continued cough shifting from other levels of government plac a significant strain on our ability to ensure Financial sustainability into the future while managing and upgrading our aging infrastructure to become more desirable and living City a livable City we encourage increased funding allocations to upgrade upgrade Regional Community community assets something that is integral to our vision for our city a lot of our infrastructure is very old built in the 70s when the time that the town was booming and we'd certainly appre appreciate some more funding uh for those sort of upgrades and look this is a continual theme right around the country for many many communities education infrastructure opportunity and the like on I want to put on the uh on the record in this short time that I have is Mr David Ross director of the central land Council advocated government investment into infrastructure is one of the several recommendations to assist indigenous people to fill their potential the government needs to take urgent action to reverse these Trends I know better than most that this problem is complex however I believe there are clear steps that can be taken to narrow the gaps these include investing in the vital basic infrastructure in remote and very remote areas to improve opportunities for Aboriginal driven development on abigal land and sea including in roads water power telec Communications and access to health and education services now I met Mr Ross I think in the early 1970s when we were both truck drivers for John drink transport in Ellis Springs he knows what he's talking about he's lived that area all his life he's contributing in that area all his life and I humbly suggest that those uh um you know those who can make the decision that will impact in this area listen to his advice because uh it's coming coming from the right place so the couple of recommendations we made uh was the committee recommends that the Commonwealth government fundamentally reexamine its Regional infrastructure spending plan and make an expanded infrastructure program the basis of its stimulus plan for Australia's economic recovery from the impacts of the pandemic so use the opportunity the pandemic has C created and the funding of infrastructure properly in Regional Australia secondly in order to establish the most appr rate response in terms of regional investment the committee recommends the conol government undertake a series of Round Table consultations with Commonwealth departments and agencies state and local governments uh Regional associations and Community organizations so I think a very timely uh uh report tabled just after the debate on the castless welfare card because I know the debate there is widely held deeply felt there are various positions on it uh I think this points the way forward we have have to improve the infrastructure the education the training listen to the indigenous people who've been there for a long time and get some opportunities and I mean even just the infrastructure in uh Telly Health in remote communities would be a remarkable change people could get diagnosed over the internet you could remediate problems early and quickly so I commend the report to the Senate and seek leave to continue our Rems Senator Ro Rockman sorry that's all right to say thank you madam acting Deputy president I Rise to make a a very brief contribut contribution uh on this report following Senator Gallagher uh as as chair of the committee I am uh the deputy chair of the committee uh I will add my thanks to uh the Secretariat and all those who made submissions to the report and and I will pay tribute to uh the the role of Senator Gallagher uh in driving that inquiry and all the other Senators that participated in it uh obviously uh right across the chamber there are uh many uh members of this place who wish to see uh re Rural and Regional Australia advance and there is some additional comments from Coalition Senators noting some of the uh very very important things that this government is actually doing in this space uh in terms of things such as infrastructure and job creation and I'll know the presence in the chamber of of the minister who has been Central to driving some of those changes in ter terms of jobs programs um uh and the like uh I guess one of the frustrations of of 2020 has been that the plan of the committee was to get out into the regions much much more than we were able to now obviously in light of this year that is that is um the uh the least important thing that has has happened this year but it is uh a frustration for many of us who would have liked to have seen uh this place take its committee work out into the regions much more unfortunately this year hasn't allowed we all know why but uh it is an important report it is a very important uh policy issue and uh it is one that I certainly commend uh to all those uh out there listening to this to examine thank you do you seek to continue your remarks you my remarks thank you very much Senator W thank you madam acting Deputy president uh on behalf of the select select committee on the effectiveness of the Australian government's Northern Australia agenda I present an interim report of the committee and I move that the Senate take note of the report the question is that the report be noted all those in favor say would do you want to speak so you might start question afterward terrific um thank you madam acting Deputy president just in the time available I'll make a relatively short cont contribution um on this report so for those listening at home we the the Senate inquiry into the effectiveness of the Australian government's Northern Australia agenda uh commenced uh very early in this term and it was always intended to be a fairly long running inquiry to give the Senate an opportunity to review just exactly how the government's Northern Australia agenda is progressing uh what we've done today is table an interim report of the committee uh the intention is that the fin report of this committee will be tabled at the end of March next year um like every uh inquiry that's been conducted over this term this inquiry has of course been disrupted by Co 19 and particularly the limitations on travel that have been possible and that's been especially an issue for this inquiry given by its very nature it involves traveling and hearing from uh people in some of the most remote parts of this country that of course hasn't been possible as much as we would have liked to have achieved this year which is the reason for the extension of this inquiry into next year uh but not withstanding that today's interim report I think does make some important recommendations to the government about how it can uh improve the performance of probably its key funding mechanism for the Northern Australia agenda which is the Northern Australia infrastructure facility uh the naif I'll come back to that in a moment and what the has recommended for the naif shortly but I just also want to put on record my thanks to the other committee members uh Senator McDonald the deputy chair of the committee uh my colleagues from labor Senators McCarthy and Dodson uh Senator Roberts and Senator seaart as well uh again travel limitations have made it a little bit difficult for people to participate in all the hearings um but I do appreciate the efforts that everyone has put in and I do want to thank everyone as well for reaching a unanimous position in this interim report that's obviously not always possible um so I think we've handled ourselves very maturely uh and uh no doubt we can continue to do that over the course of this inquiry um can I also thank the uh hardworking sorry and Senator Dean Smith how could I forget Senator Smith thank you for reminding me we'll we'll um we'll see more of you when we get the uh committee over to Western Australia in the New Year Senator Smith and I'm very much looking forward to that um the uh yeah can I also thank the uh Secretariat who worked very hard uh over the course of this inquiry uh with the logistics and and of course the preparation of this report uh we do all very much appreciate your efforts and and your beavering away to get this report done uh behind the scenes um what we have achieved today uh is a number of hearings in Darwin Townsville Matt iser McKai and nullen booy in adland uh and over the last last few months particularly since Co hit we have might made a point of this inquiry continuing uh and have undertaken a number of hearings by teleconference so that we do keep it progressing and continue to hear uh from Witnesses uh as I say uh this what the decision we made was that the interim report should focus on the naif uh partly because um it is the only funding mechanism that is within the portfolio of Northern Australia partly because it has it is an it is a body that has in my view attracted quite a lot of deserved attention and and in some quarters criticism and also uh the government was itself conducting a review of the naif over the last few months and we thought it was important that the committee did bring down an interim report to provide some recommendations to government which they can hopefully listen to and act on uh when it comes time to legislating some changes to the na uh I do want to recognize that the Northern Australia minister uh Mr pit uh has already announced that there will be a number of changes made to the na which is very welcome from both the opposition's point of view and I think the committee as a whole um given the recommendations that we've made uh we obviously haven't seen the legislation yet uh but certainly what I've seen from the minister does look encouraging and it it does seem that the government recognizes there are some pretty significant changes that need to be made to the naif so that it does work effectively so that it does get money out the door uh and so that it does build the projects and create the jobs that it was intended to uh I think it's well known that I've been uh very strong critic of the naif up until now uh and as I made clear at the Northern Australia conference in uh rockampton last week my criticism is not of the officials of the naif or its board members I think it has lacked political Direction and political leadership uh and I am pleased to see some of these changes that the minister is now flagging um as I have said before I just just don't think it's acceptable that 5 years after this uh uh body was first announced um that we see only $218 million of its $5 billion budget having actually been released to fund projects that's less than 5 cents in the dollar released 5 years after this body was first announced now we of course hear from the government on a regular basis that the naif has approved funding of over $2 billion for projects and that's very good um but what they'd never want to accept and acknowledge is that the amount of money that's actually flowing out the door is considerably less than that $218 million uh and what that really means is not just in numerical terms uh but it really means that we've got billions of dollars of lost opportunities for Northern Australia which is particularly important now as we are in recession and as we're starting to recover from coid um again as I made clear in my speech to the Northern Australia conference last week um there are some incredible opportunities in Northern Australia as we recover from coid uh there's renewed interest in decentralization in people moving out of big cities particularly in the southern states which have uh borne the burden of Co 19 and its lockdowns uh I was in Darwin a couple of weeks ago and people are really excited about the fact that the population there is increasing for the first time in some time uh and you can actually feel a bit more energy in place like Darwin uh and optimism than we have seen for some time so it is important that the government takes this opportunity uh that we've been given through coid uh where people are thinking about things differently to really drive this Northern Australia agenda home and actually deliver on its expectations um what this report does is make a number of recommendations for how the naif can be improved and these recommendations go beyond the changes that the government has already flagged uh the report does acknowledge the changes to the naife that the government has flagged and congratulates them on doing so but we do think and when I say we the committee as a whole uh does think that there are some other amendments and changes to the knife that could be made uh just briefly running through those recommendations first of all uh it's to broaden the eligibility of the naif to allow uh for funding of smaller projects and broader a broader range of Industries one of the main pieces of feedback that I've received both through the inquiry and on separate work as the shadow minister is that um one of the problems with the naif is that up until now it has really focused on the funding of large projects in the tens of millions of dollars and hundreds of millions of dollars uh and while there while there are some projects of that scale uh kicking around in Northern Australia and seeking financing there's a lot more projects that are much smaller in nature uh but do need Finance uh through through this government facility and have found it very difficult to access that fun funding through the naife um so we are recommending in this report that the naife uh have a have a good look at its eligibility and its focus to make sure that it is paying enough attention and providing enough support to those smaller projects um we've also recommended that the government consider converting some of the Na's funds to Grants Equity stakes and guarantees um that of course would have fiscal implications for the government and that's why we have uh simply recommended that they consider doing so rather than outright recommending it um but again uh the evidence that the committee has received does suggest that uh converting some of these funds to Grants Equity stakes and guarantees would provide a better funding vehical for those small scale projects that I was talking about but also in particular projects that are being led by First Nations communities um I've said before that uh the given the proportion of uh the northern Australian Community who are from First Nations communities given the high levels of disadvantage we continue to see in First Nations communities given the fact that in the Northern Territory alone 50% of the land is Aboriginal owned um we have to make sure that uh the interests of First Nations people are at the center of the Northern Australia agenda and the nap has got a role to play in delivering that as well um there are other recommendations we've made in this report such as ensuring that naif na funded project s do a better job of buying locally sourcing labor locally so that we do really see that local spin-off out of naif projects um and we have continued to recommend that there be greater transparency and accountability from the naif in relation to things like its bonuses that it pays um all in all what we're saying in this report is the naif is a worthwhile institution that needs to get moving we hope this will happen and I seek leave to continue my remarks uh thank you Senator watt uh leave as granted before I C to to minister time has expired for consideration of items 15 being table in committee reports 16 documents and 17 further consideration reports we will now move to ministerial statements but before I do that I understand the minister has a government response to table I I do thank you uh I present the government's response to the report of the Parliamentary joint committee on the Australian commission for law enforcement Integrity on its inquiry into the examination of the annual report of the Integrity commissioner 2018 to9 and seek leave to have the document Incorporated into hand s leave is granted uh thank you uh are there any ministerial statements Minister thank I table documents relating to orders for the production of documents concerning Australian sport commission and Sport Australia legal advice and Australia's Sovereign naval ship building capacity Senator Farrell thank you uh acting Deputy president I seek to take note uh on the uh response there um to the interim report of the select committee on the administration of uh Sports grants you don't you don't need to seek leave so thank you um then um I've just received the uh a copy of the U uh The Minister's response um through Mr monetti who's the acting chair uh and um despite a decision of the uh Senate earlier this week when the report was handed the interim report I should say was handed to the uh Senate on the um shocking circumstances of what is now known as the sports RS Affair um the government continues to um refuse to come clean or act transparently in respect of this matter despite the fact that they've had ample opportunity to do so and despite the fact that the clear unequivocal will of the Senate is that they do so now I think it's important to go back in time a little bit and have a look at uh what um what's transpired here um it started out with the Australian National Audit office conducting a very thorough audit into the government's handling of the so-called Community Sports infrastructure grants program what we know as the sports RS program uh the auditor uh General told the Senate inquiry that his office had spent more than uh 3,800 hours of work on this inquiry and importantly um he found and I quote from the report uh there was no legal Authority evident to the ano under which the minister was able to approve uh the csig program Grant now I'll repeat that no legal Authority um now this uh inquiry has been going for some time now the government all along has thought that um under the cover of the pandemic they would uh Escape scrutiny for what they did uh with this uh Sports RS uh uh program but um can I tell you this Mr acting Deputy president they're not going to escape that inquiry the Australian people want to know some answers about what went on here more more particularly uh the sports Community wants to know what's G on here uh more particularly um still all of those um sporting organizations all of those volunteers uh who originally looked at the the uh criteria for the granting of these applications heaps and heaps and heaps of money uh that was supposed to go to sporting club all of those um uh volunteers who toiled away night after night thinking thinking that they were entering a legitimate process thinking that they that this this uh process the government had set up to distribute the sporting grants and we've of course got no problem with sporting organizations getting money but the government misled the Australian people misled all of these Volunteers in these uh sporting clubs into thinking that there was going to be a legitimate process for the distrib distribution of these funds that if you had a good project and that you scored well with sports Australia uh you were going to be rewarded with one of these grants but yeah that's what they thought Senator Chone but what did we find out nothing of the sort occurred in fact as each tranch of money was was uh was um handed out by the then Minister McKenzie the situation got worse and worse and worse fewer clubs with high scores were rewarded uh and the government handed this money over to their own marginal seats their own marginal seats or seats that they were trying to win the whole process was a fraud right from the start at no stage at no stage was there any legitimacy to this process and all of those hardworking volunteers now know that that's what happened here and you know why are we here today discussing this well um earlier in the year when sport Australia uh gave some evidence they came along they said to us look you tell us what documents you want and we'll hand hand them over we've got nothing to hide the government's got nothing to hide about this we want to explain what we've done they said that at the hearing one of the first hearings into this matter but what's happened we haven't got the documents despite the inquiry now going for nine months or so uh despite a decision earlier this week of the Senate making it very clear that um the Senate wants to see these documents uh we still haven't got the document and and this response by the government today uh or at least Sports Australia Today make it clear we're still not going to get it we're still not going to get it now as I said before the government thinks that they can hide from scrutiny over the pandemic that somehow um what they did throughout this process to um uh disrespect sporting clubs in this country in the way that they can handed out the funds they think the issues going going to go away well let me tell you the issue is not going to go away somebody is going to have to take responsibility for this U now I know Senator McKenzie has gone but it's very clear from what we' found out about her role in this process uh that she was just doing the bidding of the uh the Prime Minister the Prime Minister was giving the instructions as to exactly where these funds had to go so as to maximize the chances of the government being reelected that's what it was all about that was nothing to do with a fair distribution of sporting funds to uh Australian sporting clubs it had everything to everything to do Mr acting Deputy president uh with the reelection of this government now we're not going to leave it here we're not going to leave it here the government might think that they can hide uh from scrutiny by sending in letters like the one that they've uh given late on a Thursday afternoon uh to the Senate uh but we're not going to leave it there and we've got two very fine Senators on the job Senator Chisum and Senator green uh and they've got their teeth they've got their teeth into this uh and I can see I can see Senator cash smiling because she knows she knows that what I'm saying is true even Senator Brockman is smiling I can see he's he's got his head down for a change they know they know they know that the Australian people are going to find out what went on here now I think I know what went on here I think poor old Senator McKenzie simply did simply did what she was instructed to do by the Prime Minister and the prime minister's office to win the last election uh there was there was no accountability no transparency and they they like most most other people thought they were going to lose the election so it didn't really matter uh they were never going to have to be held responsible for the IR irresponsible way in which they distributed These funds um but those two senators I mentioned Senator Chism F very fine Senators senators from Queensland they're on the job and they've got their teeth into this issue and if the government thinks that some how by delaying this process they will escape scrutiny then they've got another think coming because day by day week by week month by month we will continue to pursue uh this government uh to get the truth out of what's G on here uh because at the end of the day um the government will have to explain why they so abuse us this grants process public money yeah it's public money they thought money well well they thought it was their own money that's that's what happened Senator Chone they thought this money was theirs they thought they could yes that's right Senator Pratt they thought they could hand this money out uh in such a way money no no wasn't wasn't their money no they treated it like it was a yes that's I couldn't have said a better set a Chone thank you um I hope you're going to make make a contribution to this debate um they they knew that this money was not theirs they're trying to hide but let me tell you there is no place to hide we're going to track track down what went on here and the Australian people are going to find out one day exactly what went on thank you Senator Farrell uh Senator green thank you uh I just want to um rise and make a contribution to to um this uh debate in regards to the ministerial um statement uh but particularly the letter that's been tabled today uh by the minister in regards to um the the refusal um of um the government uh via Sports Australia to comply with a request from the Senate uh to provide documents requested by the Senate uh inquiry into the sports grants um Saga uh if I can make clear to the Senate this is a a document um that uh relates to the legal Authority that the minister had to make decisions about these grants uh we have always questioned whether the minister even had the legal authority to make these decisions uh and it is a concern it is a concern that many legal uh submissions have been made to the committee that have questioned the legal Authority that the minister had the only basis that the public has for believing that the minister had legal authority to make these decisions is a piece of legal advice that the Attorney General is has a hold of but will not make public that is the only information that we have now I note I note that in the letter the uh chair uh the acting chair of sports Australia notes that there's a current legal proceeding on foot but I want to make clear to the Senate that the the members of this committee have gone about this in a very deliberate way understanding understanding that legal professional privilege isn't always grounds for a public interest immunity claim but when there's legal proceedings on foot we do need to be careful in those respects we have asked for this evidence in camera so we can at least understand what advice Sports Australia had what what understanding they had about The Minister's legal Authority we have asked for that in camera it has not been provided that's why the interim report put a recommendation to the Senate and the Senate supported that recommendation the Senate supported a recommendation to request this information because it is crucial for the public to understand how badly the government mismanaged their taxpayer funds when it came to making decisions about who received this money because we know there are so many circumstances in this in this Saga that the government is refusing to make public there are numerous numerous documents that the government has refused to make public not just to our inquiry there's the gateun report everyone is familiar with the gate report that's the report that the Prime Minister well he wasn't happy with the audit a general report wasn't happy with what that said so he went to get his own report from um Mr gin that report uh was completed and what do you know it said nothing nothing's wrong here nothing's been done um to UNT uh we don't need to worry about this matter anymore but that report has not been made public not a single member of the public or indeed a single member of the Senate or anyone on this committee has had the opportunity to read that report so we can understand what questions were asked what Witnesses were questioned what documents that report had access to and without that information the only thing that this committee or the all the Senate and the members of the public will have to determine is that the government is cover covering this up because otherwise you would release the information and make it public and why doesn't why is it a concern well we know that the government ran a parallel process the minister in conjunction with the prime minister's office there were 136 emails ran a parallel process to make recommendations about where this the These funds should go sports Australia had a Merit assessment process they scored applications people who have experience with sport understanding where these funds should go and assessing them on their Merit they were the ones that made the decision and when the list made its way over to The Minister's office well the Prime Minister intervene and said no no no we've got an election coming up we need to make sure that there's enough announcements in our marginal seats so we can go stand get a photo stand next to a big check and and make sure that this money is going to the people for their votes not the people who might need the money not the sporting clubs that have done the hard work to make sure that they had a really good application but the but they made sure that this money only went to the people whose votes they needed and that is not how the government should be handing out taxpayer funds there's another reason why the government doesn't want to let anyone know what the truth of this Scandal was and I and and um Senator Farrell is right we are not letting this go we are not letting this go because when we finally get these uh these documents they will show that the Prime Minister was intimately involved in this Scandal 136 emails went back and forth between the prime minister's office and The Minister's office they included several examples of the colorcoded spreadsheet and Chang es were requested by the prime minister's office multiple times to that spreadsheet because they were working with chq their Campaign Headquarters to make these changes it was a politicized process it shouldn't have been because nobody in the public none of these sporting clubs were told don't bother applying unless you live in one of our marginal seats that is what people need to know how was this process allowed to occur and I just want to draw the Senate's attention to one of the documents that we have received because I think it shines a light on why we know that this government is not going to provide any other documents why this do why this government is going to ignore a resolution of the Senate this is an email from the executive director of sports Partnerships in sports Australia it's an email on the 5th of December 2018 and it's one of the documents that we have actually managed to get through the process of estimates through the process of this inquiry and it goes to show that when we actually do get the documents they paint a very Grim picture for this government this email sent to The Minister's office and ceing the CEO of sports Australia refers to the changes that the minister has made made to the decisions in this program and it says we also recognize your comments that in making changes to the approved list that The Minister's office use a rating scale provided by Sports Australia as a re reference but the minister is advised that as the delegate she may need to defend the decisions at Senate estimates I.E if changes were made she could not state that she approved the recommended decisions in industry panel that followed due process where a rigorous transparent and defensible process took place Sports Australia tried to warn the minister that she shouldn't go down this road because she would end up having to answer questions about not following the recommendations of sports Australia we know that the government was warned we know that people in sports Australia good people in sports Australia had very grave concerns about this process and they raised those concerns with the minister they said to the minister hey wait a second you might not want to go down this track because if you do you'll be doing the wrong thing but they didn't care all they had in their sights was the election all they had in their sights was getting themselves reelected it was all about protecting their own jobs getting themselves back into the cushy jobs that they have and and not doing the right thing by the sporting clubs and the people who made these applications and the people in the public who expect better from this government so this letter today is not unexpected but it is unacceptable it is unacceptable that a committee of the Senate that the Senate itself is not being given the information it needs to understand what has gone wrong here and we know the reason that we we are not being given this information it's because the Prime Minister Scott Morrison was at the head of this Scandal and the more documents that we received because we're not giving up that the more that it will show that the Prime Minister led the sports RS Scandal and he let Minister McKenzie take the fall and we're not going to stop until we found it uh thank you Senator green I think Senator Chisum sorry Senator renck uh did have was was first up so Senator Chism thanks Mr acting Deputy president uh and what we know is that whilst Minister colbeck wasn't responsible for administering Sports RS uh what we've learned today is he is an accomplice in the cover up uh and the minister has had uh 12 months to be honest with the Australian people honest with this Parliament and actually come in and explain what has gone on and provide answers to those people those volunteers those and dads those people who give up so much of their time in good faith uh to apply through the the the process the guidelines that were put forward by sport Australia um put in the volunteer hours and we've heard from so many clubs this year about how many hours they dedicated to putting in a submission and then they were dted by this government all for political decisions but yet they don't have the actual good grace to come in and be upfront with those people who volunteered their time and tell them what's G on and admit that this was all about their reelection that was what their focus was on the whole time so it is absolutely outrageous that their political decision making U was Paramount uh through this program and the fact that they treat this Senate with contempt by not actually providing the legal advice today and I will come to that in more detail shortly but they Absolut Ely need to level with the Australian people they need to fund those clubs that they done it so we know those clubs that received a high score uh the ones that were judged as deserving by Sports Australia that this government DED we know who they are and the government should do the right thing and fund those clubs uh we've had a budget since this they still failed to do it in the budget but it's not too late so many of those clubs that came evidence uh that came and gave evidence to us uh they are still desperate to have these upgrades uh and the work that they do uh the work that they have done putting forward their submissions uh need to be rewarded as a result uh and it's the groups it's the councils uh it's the uh indigenous councils that we've heard from uh so many worthy places about encouraging young people to get involved in sport about giving uh indigenous people an opportunity in a place like wunda to play uh at a football ground with Club rooms and appropriate facilities we know that there's so much growth in women's sport in particular uh that is being neglected as a result so we've heard the stories about the women who have to change in the car or out the back of the club rooms clearly not appropriate uh and it is this government that's responsible for those things uh by not answering questions on this but not providing legal advice uh it's just a pattern of behavior that we've seen as they try and cover up what TR what really went on in this uh they won't answer questions about what was the involvement of the Prime Minister in his office we know that there was 136 emails between The Minister's office and the prime minister's office about this program we know that they won't even release to us the spreadsheets so we actually the committee has not seen the spreadsheets that the minister made their decision making on uh we haven't seen any of they won't release them to us uh we haven't seen the G's report uh we haven't seen uh the talking points that were prepared for Minister McKenzie's meeting with the Prime Minister and his office about extending this program uh as it got closer to the election as Senator Farrell said in his speech the political decision making got worse so in round one it was 40% ignored uh in round two it was 70% ignored by round three is the election was imminent it was 73% ignored that's how political the decision making got the closer the election got uh and we also have no idea who authorized the five additional projects that was granted funding after caretaker kicked in so caretaker applied and they still they still gave out five more grants in caretaker period and we're none the wiser about who was responsible for that so that is just outrageous that caretaker was in place five grants were approved and were none the wiser about who was responsible for granting those but let's get to the substance of today's legal advice uh and it was against the request of the Senate on the authority of the then Minister McKenzie to authorize grants as part of sports RS is just another example in a long Saga of the almp government lack of transparency and accountability the letter from Sports Australia Today claims that due to legal proceedings commenting on the 23rd of July this year that they are concerned that asc's the Australian Sports commissions interested may be adversely affected if the legal professional privilege applicable to the advice is prejudiced by the requirement to table this advice summary the asc's claim however doesn't explain why the minister made a pii claim on the 16th of July before any legal proceedings had been commenced and there was a failure of the minister to obviously come in here and address that issue specifically and this is even though the beachworth law law and Tennis Club a high scoring club with 78 of 100 so well above the identified threshold by the audit office of being eligible who asked for a $500,000 Grant they requested that Sports Australia review their decision on the 4th of March this year Sports Australia was still prepared to provide a confidential briefing of legal advice in in May to the committee Sports Historia again makes the claim that on the basis of Legal Professional privilege they should not be required to table the legal advice however Legal Professional privilege is not been accepted in the Senate as grounds for refusing to provide information or documents the Senate has rejected government claims that there is a long-standing practice of not disclosing legal advice legal advice to the federal government is often disclosed by the government itself as in the letter uh and the pii claim itself the disclosure of the information may materially affect the Commonwealth position in pending legal proceedings the committee recognized this at the time uh and said that we may we said it was accepted grounds um sorry the committee was not satisfied with that and that the correspondent explains the specific harm to the public interest that would result again there has been no explanation as to the risk of providing a confidential briefing to the committee in camera as the committee said we were happy to accept and further it needs to be stated we consider this information V information as vital evidence for the inquiry as it goes to the very legal foundations of the program and whether then Minister McKenzie even had the legal authority to be authorizing these grants the legal experts the committee has heard from have all cast out uh all have been unable to find the suggested legal Authority uh and then minister can claims to have had to make these grants uh and I went through some of these issues with the legal Authority uh we heard from Professor Lindell we heard from Professor Tumi uh experts in constitutional law about they could not identify the legal Authority uh that the minister had to be the decision maker in this process so it's not enough that it was in the guidelines that is irrelevant they had to identify the legal Authority and they were unable to do it so this is why we have have pursued this uh Sports Australia were originally happy to give us the summary in camera which we had agreed to but then it was Minister colbeck the one who claimed pii which is why we' brought it to the Senate and why the Senate voted for that in the interim report on Tuesday night so we will continue to pursue it but it's across a whole range of issues that we will continue to pursue and that's why the sports Ro inquiry will be going on into next year when we had an AED to finish it this year but the fact that the government won't cooperate makes it all the more necessary that we continue to pursue it so what are the 136 emails between The Minister's office and the prime minister's office discussing this scheme what is the content of those give us access to the spreadsheets so we can see which clubs missed out what scores they received uh so that we can actually talk to them and let them tell their story cuz some of the compelling evidence we've seen this year the most compelling evidence we've seen this year are those volunteers those moms and dads that I talked about that put in the work that have been dted by this government they deserve the opportunity to be heard they also deserve the opportunity for this government to do the right thing and fund those clubs that received the high score the legal Authority we will continue to pursue that because it puts the very basis of this program in doubt and the government haven't been able to provide assurances the gation report again another one that the government haven't released that actually goes to the very heart of why Minister McKenzie lost her job the talking points that were prepared for then Minister McKenzie for her meeting with the Prime Minister as they discussed future rounds of this program so what was in those talking points you know what led to the political decision making that we saw and who approved those five projects after caretaker had been put in a fundamental element of democracy that this government have not provided any answers for it all and there's five projects out there that were were that were given granted permission to with no Authority the Senate will now the question is that the Senate take note those who the question say I against no the eyes have it the Senate will now proceed to the consideration of General business Clark General business debate on the motion circulated by Pauline Hansen's One Nation Senator Roberts thank you Mr acting Deputy president the motion I moved is the opening paragraph in Robert godson's newspaper article yesterday I'll quote it again when China declared that Australia had been evil it suddenly became clear that the dispute between the two Nations is more deep-seated than a trade spat involving wine coal Timber Etc now as a servant to the people of Queensland and Australia who is involved in the governance of Australia I want to focus on got golson's meaty fourth paragraph quote from president X down there has been little respect for Australia for a long time and many in China believe we are a foolish country that makes mistakes at almost every turn led by defense end of quote he then details serious flaws in governance in three defense projects the submarine chimole as he calls it F-35 Joint Strike Fighter and Hunter frigs we are a foolish country obviously from this and the obvious point of his article is shoddy governments shoddy governments over many decades both liberal National and labor people in this country are feeling concerned about the seriously deteriorating state of our country we have lost our economic sovereignty we're losing our national sovereignty we're plunging towards catastrophe economically and dependent with a complete loss of security people are fed up and across many communities and industries are feeling dispirited hopeless confused aimless wary and concerned even fearful because most can sense our country's destruction and I mean right right around the country yet 100 years ago Australia was number one in the world in income per person and had the highest GDP gross domestic product per person there's a worse aspect Beyond economic demise though bullies like China prey on those perceived as being weak got lebson rightly says that due to poor and even stupid decisions we're rightly perceived as being weak in defense yet he barely scratches the full extent of the deterioration of our security because our produ Ive capacity has been dismantled and their Economic Security smashed destroyed and we are vulnerable now as a servant to the people of Queensland and Australia that is what I will discuss because like bullies in a schoolyard or in a workplace China prays on those it perceives as weak or foolish and by the way when I raise China I refer to the Chinese Communist party and not the millions of Australians of Chinese descent now in our country descendants of those who came during the gold rushers almost two centuries ago to those who immigrated recently the Chinese Communist party not only assesses other nations against China's values and standards the Chinese Communist party assesses our country against our values and from that it finds out does our government have courage does our government have integrity do the politicians in this country and this Parliament have the strength of character needed to lead a country now Australian values I've been thinking about this for some years now I've made a list of Australian values mateship Fair go support loyalty being fair inome telling the truth honesty fairness freedom freedom to live freedom of speech freedom of thought freedom of belief freedom of religion freedom of Faith freedom of interaction freedom of exchange democracy our flag our nation Family Care respect for people respect for Community respect for the law respect for the environment making sure government fulfills its three primary roles protecting life protecting property and protecting freedom and stays out of everything else our constitution we value our constitution especially competitive federalism and we value human progress and Australia has led that Improvement and progress in the last 150 years amazing progress in right across the world so let's assess governments against these values and their impact on our productive capacity productive capacity depends on many things but particularly energy costs the Primacy of energy ever decreasing cost of energy has led to 150 years of human progress but Australia has gone from the lowest electricity prices to the world's highest and yet we're now the world's largest exporter of energy gas and coal Chinese import a lot of our coal but their production of coal in their own country is eight times our total production not just our exports our total production eight times they make us look like small producers of coal they have the largest coal reserves in the world along with the United States they use our coal and they're building steel power plants out of our coal and they're building hundreds of cied power stations we legislate to use their wind wind turbines their solar panels we subsidize them it drives up the cost of our electricity and we pay them for their unreliables their solar and wind generators we pay pay them for the components for electric vehicles that we also subsidize and then we have Chinese compan compes affiliated with the Chinese Communist Party owning electricity networks in our major cities then we have the Queensland labor government stealing $1.5 billion dollar a year to the generators all of this destroys jobs destroys competitiveness and then taxpayers pay pay people quite often foreigners to come in and squat on the land just to get carbon dioxide credits it's called carbon dioxide farming but it takes good farmland and destroys it with noxious weeds and feral animals pests and then that has to be reclaimed at some later date who knows when then we have Angus Taylor the minister for energy a farmer he knows that the epca ACT is hurting him and even though I've had conversations with him he just Smiles rolls his eyes and just puts up with it he is a skeptic on climate change he is a skeptic that we're affecting the climate yet he's being slammed and he's now coming back into Parliament and driving up electricity prices Matt canavan Barnaby Joyce strong Skeptics in their beliefs Barnaby Joyce was the Deputy Prime Minister the Chinese know that they watch him they saw him come into cabinet and they saw him go for election in in New England when he moved out of the Senate into the lower house and Malcolm turble showered $400 million of taxpayer funds on unreliable wind power to get Mr Joyce elected and then Matt Canan and Barnaby Joyce were both in the cabinet and they suddenly became alarmist spouting the alarm due to our carbon dioxide so I've asked Matt Matt canovan in the Senate one day where's his evidence and he just slid away from me and now that he's out of cabinet and bar and Sen and Mr Joyce is out of cabinet all of a sudden there becoming a little bit skeptical again in their their actions in in their words but the Chinese Communist Party sees this and that tells them a lot about the lack of leadership in this country the Paris agreement the Chinese have their agreement with Paris agreement it says we will continue doing whatever we want continue growing our economy continue constructing our our our our country and developing our country and putting in place the infrastructure and then in 2030 we made consider something meanwhile this Parliament this building has legislated to destroy our economy to comply with Kyoto that's not an agreement that is stupidity and economic suicide and then the Chinese watch us the Chinese Communist Party watches us pay academics to tell lies about climate and to misrepresent The Climate science we even put some of them in charge in senior places in the csro and pay them $800,000 a year to destroy our country Dr Andrew Johnson went from head of the climate research agency uh Department in CSO to become head of Bureau of meteorology and un and under him and his predecessors the Bureau of meteorology has been shown to be concocting the data misrepresenting uh the temperatures we pay people like over Goldberg Ian chub past Chief scientists we pay them to destroy the the science misrepresent the science then we signed agreements in 1975 by whitlam that says we'll we'll comply with the Lima declaration to shut down our manufacturing and Export it and then the following year the liberal prime minister Fraser ratified the deal then in 1992 Paul King's labor government signed the Ria declaration which is about 24th 21st century Global governance then we had the Kyoto Protocol destroying our country stealing our Farmers property rights and now the Paris agreement exporting jobs shutting manufacturing and then the current prime minister has the tarity to say we will fiddle with the industrial relations system to bring back manufacturing how the hell can you bring back manufacturing with the highest electricity costs in the world and Manufacturing big component of manufacturing now the largest component usually is electricity how the hell can you do it with a tax system that favors multinational companies and lets them off scotf free how the hell can you do it with overregulation how the hell can you do it with with a lack of water how the hell can you do it with a lack of infrastructure the Chinese are watching this and they're helping us destroy our electricity sector and Export even more jobs because our prices for electricity are going up businesses are shutting and the jobs start up in in China we are now reversing the last 170 years of human progress reversing it because the key to human progress is decreasing prices of energy which raises productivity raises wealth raises the standard of living ended in this country 20 years ago 24 years ago we have seeded governance to the UN Lima Kyoto Rio Paris and many other agreements how does this comply with Aussie values how does it comply with being faired income and then worse the granddaddy who concocted this climate change rubbish is Mora strong or was Mora strong he concocted it when he took over when he created and then took over as head of the United Nations environmental program he pushed that starting in the 1970s and in the 1980s ramped it up in in 1988 formed the United Nations intergovernmental panel on climate change a fraudulent organization and liberal labor Nationals and the greens have fallen at all Maurice strong was a crook he was wanted by the police in America and died in Exile in China and who's the beneficiary of all this destruction of Western Civilization the Chinese government that's what the people in this chamber the people in the chamber across the hall there that's what they've done to this country by blindly following the UN dictates how does that comply with their values it doesn't it breaks our values what about water ownership destroyed separated water ownership from from property ownership what about the M darling Basin and the corruption that is Rife what about the the Farms Family Farms shutting down what about water projects what water projects that's it there aren't any and yet look at what amazing water projects the Chinese Communist party has put together to develop its country what about infrastructure hardly anything built no plan the north is exposed the Bradfield we see floods destroying Townsville destruction and waste of water flowing out the sea we see the state governments joining in labor party in Queensland Reef regulation shutting down agriculture vegetation protection legislation destroying agriculture fire breakes not being allowed destroying it when Farms Farms are Under Fire we put animals and fungus ahead of humans then the Queensland labor government puts the Communist CH the Chinese um company in charge of the electoral role then we've got the Queensland local Council corruption linked to the labor state government it extends well beyond ipwi and Paul pale it is systemic it is widespread we've got foreign banks that were deregulated under John Howard and we saw we saw the result of that through the ha Royal commission we see adani frustrated by both the liberal national government and the labor government in Queensland and the federal government that was weak and one man from India a booming economy a growing economy wanted to spend $7 billion in our country and he was thwarted for8 years that's a blight on us that not even the Chinese can miss that no one in the world can miss we go on and on and on and Senator Rex Patrick I give him credit for push for moving a motion to get an inquiry into the relationship between China and Australia five times sorry six times and I support him every time and both both the labor party and the liberal Nationals squashed it this is what the Chinese are seeing and yet Australians are wanting far more Australians are wanting leadership Australians are wanting security reassurance confidence leadership trust pride and freedom a restoration so we can be number one in the world again and what does it need it needs principal leadership based on values it needs disciplined leadership Based on data and facts instead of ideology paying off donors it needs honest leadership and needs strength of character the simple ability to say I'm wrong I'm sorry can you help me please explain we need Visionary policies and that is what will take us back to being number one thank you Brockman thank you Mr acting Deputy chair I uh I I Rise to speak uh to this debate but I do not the time so I'll keep my contribution very short to give others albeit a very short opportunity now I think it perhaps would be the understatement uh of the year and this is a year where we've had many serious issues to consider but it would be the understatement of the year to say that we are seeing a much more assertive uh an aggressively assertive China in the way it is dealing with the rest of the world but I think it is very important to make this point that Australia Australia's position Australia's uh standing up for its own position in the world its own sovereignty uh making Australia's decisions based on our national interest has not changed we are a trading Nation we are a nation that supports the flee free flow of Trades and goods according to International rules and norms and uh that is something that we expect to benefit All Nations and we we certainly hope that all nations commit to as well including China uh it is for China to explain itself and its actions we have always welcomed China's economic growth and trade has list lifted many people out of poverty right across the world right across the region we need to make sure that all nations in this world engage with each other in a way that is respectable to each country's sovereignty we support the peaceful development and prosperity of our region now clearly Australia is facing a number of trade issues uh in our relationship with China some of them very recent some of them dating back a number of years clearly the rhetoric has escalated in the last few weeks and months now the cumulative impact of these issues means that the perception is growing uh particularly following Ambassador Chung's remarks in April that there are other factors driving China's trade actions against Australia but Australia has not ended into a tit fortat we have been calm the Morrison government has been calm we have been consistent and we have been measured it is a matter for the Chinese authorities to explain plainly and clearly what is driving these concerning actions which are disrupting our bilateral trade now as I've said this is a very important matter we are uh the clock is ticking down I'm sure we'll have many more opportunities over the uh the week ahead and certainly into next year to discuss these matters further but I will leave my contribution there for now senat e thanks um thanks Mr acting Deputy president appreciate being given a few minutes at this juncture just to make some comments on uh behalf of the labor party and um uh I'll try too to finish in time to give uh Senator Patrick a few a few minutes on the face of it Senator Roberts's notice of motion is pretty anod really and labor we'll be supporting uh the proposition I did have some misgivings though that it would be the vehicle for the kind of um bicos language that uh that Senator Roberts is prone to giving and um and uh those misgivings prove to be well founded he did side an article um by Mr got libson yesterday that talked about uh people regarding uh Australia as foolish and while I don't accept that characterization uh Senator Roberts has made no small cont contribution himself uh to um The View that many countries across the region have about some of the darker recesses of Australian thinking uh in relation to the region uh and while he's free to speak his mind uh words have consequences uh and it didn't take too long there to move from uh views about uh the government of China to uh an alleged One World Government and uh across to the Bradfield scheme and the usual sort of rhetorical flourishes that um that uh Senator Roberts uh has about things that uh move from the re to the world of conspiracy theories very very quickly this is um as the resolution says uh a more deep-seated problem than a trade spat the language trade spat I think does uh an effort to diminish the seriousness of the uh economic issues and trade issues that confront the country uh Peabody Coal just announced today that uh it would be standing workers down and at its ensboro mine for 8 weeks uh very high quality uh metallurgical coal exported around the world uh that is a very serious issue in the hunter Valley coal and wine uh the resolution touches on Timber wine and coal thank you but lobsters sugar copper beef wheat and barley uh all of these important Regional Industries and important Regional uh employers uh many many tens of thousands of jobs uh rest upon uh those Industries and what I want to see is a more thorough thoughtful careful strategic debate within this Parliament over the course of 2021 and I want to see a more thoughtful strategic approach and a plan indeed from the Morrison government uh about how we're going to deal with not just the trade questions but about Australia's relationships across the region uh including uh our relationship uh with China the problem is that the Morrison government has failed to prepare Australia for the new realities in the region Mr Morrison has no plan to diversify Australia's export markets and no plan to deepen our relationships with the other countries in the region just today the Morrison government has put a bill through the Senate that confirms its solely responsible for foreign relations that means Mr Morrison and the minister need to show leadership and actually take responsibility instead of just using foreign policy as another vehicle for slogans and splashy headlines as a result uh Mr Morrison has made a bad situation worths uh the foreign policy and strategy is not just about events when significant events have occurred the labor party our leader Mr albanesi the leader here Senator Wong and our spokesperson on foreign policy have supported the government in a bipartisan way whether it's events like the disgraceful tweet from earlier this week the labor party has provided bipartisan support but of course strategy isn't about events strategies about having a clear view of what the national interest is a clear construction of what is in the interests of Australia and Australians and then Prosecuting a strategy that delivers a good outcome for the country in terms of our economy in terms of regional peace stability and economic growth across the region and of course a strategy that's consistent with Australia's values and the problem is that there has been a clear articulation of those positions across previous governments but there has been a sense of strategic drift and a lack of a policy approach from this government over the course of the last seven years I'll leave my remarks there Mr President Senator well it is 5:30 so I propose the Senate now adjourn sorry um sorry we need to put this do we need to put this motion I'll call look at the clerk um it being 5:30 we will move on but beforehand I'll put the motion because the debate has concluded so those in support of the motion say I contary no no the eyes have it all right division will be deferred until Monday when the Senate next sits now before the Senate moves to adjournment I understand Senator mcmah was going to seek leave to make a short statement Senator MCM yeah thank you um Mr President I seek leave to withdraw a question I asked um during CR cross chamber banter um interjections are always disorderly so I would like to seek leave to withdraw that you don't need to seek leave we'll take the comment as having been withdrawn not being here at the time um I will now propose that the the Senate do now adjourn Senator scar Mr President I uh riseing this adjournment speech to make uh a few short remarks in relation to a delightful event I attended on 26th November 2020 which was the opening of the Bertram Shore cross Bridge uh at uh within uh the jurisdiction of Somerset Regional Council the Australian government had com contributed over $600,000 to the uh rebuilding of this bridge the demolition of the existing Bridge construction of a new two-line bridge and minor changes to Road alignment and that funding of $66,500 under round three of the bridges renewal program was matched by the somerset Regional Council who contributed the sum of 618,000 469 now the major benefit of the uh renewal the rebuilding replacement of this bridge was that it will reduce trips by 6.5 km uh compared to the state highway in the local area improving safety and increasing flood immunity and vehicle traffic has been increasing on the route since the bridge was in completed and in fact during the opening process uh my spe my opening my speech uh contributed to the event to open the bridge was Dr out Dr Out Mr President uh from time to time by the great uh uh traffic that was uh going across the bridge the newly constructed Bridge so I'd like to convey the remarks or the substance of the remarks I made at the bridge opening and that included uh my congratulations to the somerset Regional Council led by the indefatigable mayor councilor Graham Leman who's one of the longest serving he might in fact be the longest serving mayor uh current mayor in Queensland or at least he's one of them and he's provided outstanding outstanding representation to the somerset region in conjunction with all of the counselors and what I said on the day um when I wasn't being drowned out by the increased traffic uh arising from the construction of this Great Bridge was that the federal government knows the federal government knows that any infrastructure which is uh which contributes to the cost of which is undertaken and executed by Somerset Regional Council the federal government knows that the summer Somerset Regional Council will make sure it's well costed well costed well planned and well executed and that was certainly the case with respect to this bridge and I'd like to pay tribute to all those Somerset Regional Council workers who worked on the bridge also to the SE volunteers from the local area who assisted with the opening ceremony now I should say I did not open the bridge I was delighted to witness the opening of the bridge by Mrs carel shawcross who was is the Widow of Mr Bertram shawcross and I must say that uh she did a wonderful job in terms of opening the bridge and uh I uh it was a great honor to be in her presence and also in the presence of some of her family members and i' I'd like to quote to you from an email R see from Jeff shawcross the son of carel who gave some uh gave an overview with respect to the contribution made by the shawcross family in that region and I quote the shawcross family has been within the district for a very long time we moved from the mount me area in the 1890s to Highwood Lane kilcoy then selected the property deur on New Country Creek in 1916 as part of the selection scrub had to be cleared and farming started the family of Bertram's Bertram sha cross cross's wife carel who opened the bridge the Ruckers owned W Glenn next door and this property was bought by Bert before they were married they then together bought further properties in this area including windy Valley so the family has long been associated with this area and this bridge and Jeff shawcross described it as I'm sure even the Roman road builders would be proud of this one and quite and I absolutely agree and he he told me a great anecdote about what happened before this two-lane Bridge was constructed when it was a on lane bridge the protocol was if you were coming from the town you were given right away because it was a big deal to go to the town so if you're coming from the town when it was a oneway bridge you were given right of way that was the protocol but Jeff did tell me did tell me that perhaps the real reason was if you're coming from town maybe you'd gone to the local pub and uh and maybe it was the wise thing to be given way to just one of the many greater sto stories of Australia which makes this country so great Senator seaward Mr President in the wake of the Year marked by bushfires and Corona virus the impact of the climate emergency on our health has never been more critical or in our face the World Health Organization has declared that climate change is the greatest threat to human health this century the Bureau of me meteorology has confirmed that under current Global pledges Australia will experience warming effects of 3.4 to 4.4 degrees of warming by the turn of the century this would fundamentally alter our very way of life the risks that climate change Pro poses to our health are getting worse every year as global temperatures rise extreme weather events like bush fires droughts Cyclones and floods are becoming more frequent and severe this is putting lives health and the well-being of the entire world population at risk we are already seeing the increasing effects of air pollution and the threats to food and water supply and security climate change is contributing contributing sorry contributing to an increased risk of infectious diseases C cardiovascular disease respiratory disease asthma allergies mental ill health psycho uh psychosocial impacts violence poor nutrition injury poisoning and mortality climate change is also worsening the conditions that led to the co 19 pandemic with environmental degradation and habitat loss responsible for the increased risks of uh xotic diseases like Corona virus in the absence of action climate change is predicted to lead to 85 deaths per 100,000 people globally per year by the end of the century more than are are currently killed by all infectious diseases across the globe the mja lanet countdown report released today highlighted that the 201920 bush fires resulted in in about 450 deaths due to direct injury and air pollution explo exposure the air pollution was so severe that it made the New South Wales annual average PM 2.5 concentration by high the far highest in the past 20 years climate change also poses sign serious risks to disruption of our health care supply chain damage to our health infrastructure and threats to the safety and quality of health care provided in our current trajectory um if it continues unchecked we Face ex existant exist exist we we Face threats to humanity sorry I'll abandon the attempt basically it's just threats to humanity while we have devoted much of 2020 to solving the coid 19 pandemic climate change continues we need to apply the same level of focus and intervention and concentration on climate change as we have rightly on the Corona virus Australia's Peak body of climate and health the climate and Health Alliance recently released a policy road map for a healthy regenerative and just future this road map has been endorsed by 29 leading Health groups so far including the Public Health Association of Australia consumers Health Forum of Australia and the Australian College of Nursing health organizations are recognizing this climate emergency they are doing the work and quite frankly the government should be doing much more in this space we need a comprehensive nationally coordinated response to climate change that also includes health and in fact puts it at its core right now we have the opportunity to protect our health from the devastating impacts of climate change but we don't have any time to waste we need to adjust our climate targets to net zero emissions by 2035 at the very latest otherwise it is going to be too late and we are going to suffer these consequences we need to end fossil fuel use for good this incl includes no new coal or oil or gas we need massive investment in Renewables in this country so that we can run on 100% renewable energy it's time to apply the same level of urgency to tackling this crisis as we have done to the coid 19 pandemic we need to make sure that we are integrating climate in across our across portfolio areas we need to make sure that we are addressing climate change from a health lens as well Senator Mullen uh thank you Mr President uh as we all know and as a number of speakers have spoken about uh this evening 2020 has been an incredibly difficult and trying year for we Australians we've contended with drought fires floods and now Co 19 it's been the year of the Aussie battler without doubt where our strong values of hard work perseverance and steadfastness in the face of adversity have certainly been put to the test it's also been a year in which Australians have stepped up to the plate and given generously with their time their money and volunteer hours to help out others in their Community a year in which charitable organizations have been working tirelessly to support those in n me so today I Rise Mr President to speak about the Australian Red Cross an organization whose work at times goes largely underreported but which has a profound impact on the lives of many Australians not since World War II has there been so much demand for Red Cross services staff and volunteers have been involved in three significant backtack long-term emergencies drought bushfires and now Co 19 from the 1st of July 2019 to the 30th of June this year the Australian Red Cross emergency services activated 4,789 volunteers and staff they helped 83,7 15 people across 63 events including the summer bushfires drought and coid 19 in one single year the drought that has Afflicted many areas around around Australia has seen our farmers and Regional communities face incredible adversity but they've not faced it alone the Red Cross and other charitable organizations have stepped up and helped out those in need in 2018 uh 2019 Red Cross launched an appeal for Aussie farmers who are battling severe drought and Australians stepped up and donated $1.5 million a total of 7,452 grand of up to $3,000 were distributed with the support of Partners like the CWA and Rural financial counselors and they've helped farmers and and and their families relieve Financial stress caused by the drought and then came the black summer bush fires fires that were on a scale never seen before in Australia tens of millions of hectares burnt 33 lives lost 3,000 houses burned down and millions of animals killed or dis placed the Red Cross and other Charities faced public pressure on several fronts public demands to get money to people quickly and claims that they were holding on to money a key part of disaster support and Recovery is getting funds to those affected as quickly as possible but that comes with the responsibility of ensuring the funds are managed properly and the money goes where it is supposed to go another key aspect of Disaster Recovery is uring that there are funds remaining to support people weeks and months after the disaster in the case of the black summer bush fires since June the Red Cross has had more than 1,739 people come forward seeking financial assistance for the first time months after the last fires were extinguished when it comes to providing grants in a disaster there are several phases immediate emergency grants rebuilding and long-term Rec recovery the Red Cross is one of the few Emergency Management organizations that operates in all three stages in preparedness in response and in recovery this is why funds should not be spent all at once during an emergency and this is why the Red Cross is still able to be out there helping people in the community now however just as many communities were starting to recover Along Came Co 19 and many Australians were Ed into economic hardship once again organizations like the Red Cross came to the for since April this year Federal Government funding of $13 million has been provided to Red Cross under the government's $200 million Community Support package so today I would like to thank the Australian Red Cross for everything they've done this year supporting those in need there are thousands of Australians Mr President around our a great country who have a roof over their head and food on the table thanks to the work of the Red Cross so I would ask all Australians during Christmas during this time of giving to remember the Red Cross to be generous and to make a donation thank you green thank you Mr President Mr President as the Morrison government continues to congratulate itself on a job well done and use slogans and advertising to try to convince the Australians that they are on top of our economic recovery the truth about our economy right now is that people are hurting and they are worried about the future the latest wage data shows that wages grew slower in the past 12 months than ever before now it has been a tough year but this data is off the back of years and years of stagnant wage growth under this government before the the pandemic even hit on top of low wage growth we know that we have an insecure work crisis in this country this pandemic highlighted this crisis and it has made it worse we've got used to insecure work we've almost come to accept it and the workers that we needed to get us through the pandemic were some of the worst insecure work examples that we have seen and that has imp impacted our health response we've heard on many occasions of aged care workers and security guards who had to have a second job because their first job was too insecure and didn't provide the security that they needed of a full-time job it's also impacted our economic response because it will take longer for our economy to recover if more jobs are insecure the government chose to exclude casual workers from jobkeeper and yet so many of the workers that were directly impacted by the shutdowns needed to get us through uh this pandemic were in highly casualized workforces people in the Arts and entertainment sector Hospitality workers retail workers all of these workers were already in casual and insecure work and yet the government chose to exclude casual workers from the jobkeeper scheme our economy cannot recover if Australians don't have good secure jobs and maybe some of those opposite don't understand what it's like to have a casual insecure job but can I tell you not knowing when your next shift is going to be impacts your entire life and inversely we know that a good secure job gives you the confidence to spend money in your local uh businesses in local shops in your community it gives you the confidence to pay for extra Health appointments to get checkups that you might need to plan for the future to save for a house to make sure that you've got a good dignified retirement you can't do those things if you don't know when your next shift is coming workers around the country this Christmas won't be having a very good Christmas they are not out there high-fiving about this government's so-called comeback it won't be a great Christmas this year for workers in the mining industry who are facing the prospect of becoming permanent casuals we know that casualization has been rough in the mining industry for years and this government has stood up and said they would do something about it they don't say it here while they're standing in the chamber but they say it when they're standing on the ground in central Queensland the member for Dawson Senator canavan often tells people from the mining industry that they will do something to fix casualization but when given the chance to do something about this the government is actually intervening in a high court case that would overturn a decision that stops mining companies from making work permanent casuals that is what the government is doing and we need to judge the government on its actions not what it says when it's standing in central Queensland it won't be a great Christmas for workers who work for BHB under their OS services Enterprise agreement they have had a win they had the EA overturned and thank goodness because this was a shoddy agreement to start with it was agreed with a couple of people in West in Australia nine people decided what sort of EA would apply to thousands of workers in central Queensland but this government has done nothing nothing to step in and stop that sort of thing from happening to stop casualization in the industry or to make sure that people have more secure work in these uh Industries it won't be a very good Christmas this year for workers in the meat and food processing industry they have been incredibly heart- hit by this pandemic I had the chance to meet many of them in Brisbane last week and I thank the Ami euu for for giving me the opportunity to listen directly to those workers and to understand what they're going through in their workplaces most recently at JBS dinmore they announced that 600 600 Australian workers have lost their jobs 600 workers who won't have a job this Christmas and when the government had the chance to extend job keeper to Industries like the meat workers industry to businesses like JBS they didn't take that chance Jos fredenberg refused to sign those jobs could have been saved if this government had stepped in and we know that quantis workers will not be having a very good Christmas this year because this week we found out that 2,000 ground crew jobs will be outsourced and that includes 50 jobs in cans in Regional Queensland where I live that doesn't mean Outsourcing doesn't mean that the work doesn't need to be done I mean we know that now it doesn't mean that the the job doesn't need to be done it just means that quantis is saying that we would prefer for that job to be done by someone who has a less L secure job a less secure job and this government has turned its back on Aviation workers they've had plenty of subsidies and grants and even jobkeeper paid to quantis the business itself has said that it will be back back in the black next year but these workers won't have a job they're having to bid for their jobs and they're having to compete for jobs with people on labor higher contracts casually employment insecure work that this is from the pandemic we need to learn the lessons that this pandemic has taught us and one of the things that the pandemic has shown us is that insecure work is damaging to the economy it's D damaging to the community and we need to make sure people have secure jobs because it's good for our economy all we have got from this government from its leadership right down to its back bench is more attacks on working people and more pushes to make sure that people have less secure work next week they'll be bringing IR legislation out publicly for the first time and we hear a lot from this government about everyone playing their part in this so-called team Australia recovery and they'll probably say things along the lines of you know what our economy and labor market needs is more flexibility but can I tell you that flexibility is often a vehicle for increasing insecurity it is the word that is used instead of insecurity but when the government says flexibility what they mean is insecurity I was shocked today shocked to hear Senator stoker a queenslander actually blame contous workers for not accepting more flexible working conditions leading to their own redundancies she blamed them for their own redundancies because they hadn't accepted more flexible working conditions every time the government says flexible what they mean is insecure an insecure work is bad for workers it is bad for families but it is also bad for our economy we have an opportunity at the end of this pandemic to make sure that more people are in Secure jobs but this government has shown through this pandemic that they are not willing to stand up for workers they are not willing to do the hard work to make sure that people have good working conditions and good secure jobs and that is very concerning because what it means is that our our economy and our recovery will take longer under this government and people will not have the jobs that they need this Christmas to feel secure to take care of their families and to plan for the future thank you Senator green the Senate stands adjourned and we'll meet at 10:00 a.m. on Monday the 7th of December home time | Australian Parliament Fan | UC6F5ZNp-AWBeA4j_PmqL8Rw | 2020-12-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 66,387 | 375,034 |
3_o4FXTMyPs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3_o4FXTMyPs | Injuries (animated storytime) | okay I ran a poll on Twitter and most of you wanted an injuries video over a school story's video which yeah that makes sense because people hate school and love hearing about me getting hurt which is good because all the school stories I have would cross over into another video I have planned for the future when I reach more people so injuries whoo most people injure themselves in their lifetime whether it's banging your toe on a wall or getting an arrow to the knee we all get injured well unless you're a sensible civilized person who consciously avoids danger at all times like many wounded one time I was on my trampoline and my dad and my two brothers and me were doing some sick tricks one person would do something and then the rest would attempt to do the same I say attempt because one of my brothers was little and I was not as strong and muscular as I am now shut up so my more active brother did a handstand and then he did a roll then my dad did the same then my youngest brother well he tried and then it came to my turn I put my hands down I lifted my legs up I fell on my head and crushed it into my chest with all my downward momentum plus I wasn't the skinniest person I thought I was dying or had broken my neck or both I went to the hospital as you do when you are dying but it turns out I was just winded yeah another time when I was five some kid in my class stabbed me with a pencil the lid bit snapped off in my hand but I didn't realize it at the time and the skin healed over and now I have a piece of pizza lid in my hand but a few years ago I went up to my dad I was like dad you need to dig this out of my skin so he got a needle and some tweezers and attempted to dig it out and let me just say it was pretty far into my skin so eventually we got to it and tweaked it out but only some of it came out and pretty much disintegrate it when we did so there's still over half of it in my hand okay my worst injury ever well I should probably know my worse as my most memorable injury I was about eight or nine years old and I got home and my dad was mowing the lawn and the place was set up like this the house was here the garage was here and there was a little opening on to the lawn I got out of the car walked to where I could see my dad mowing the lawn and I waved as you do but as I was waving a piece of sharp plastic shot out from under the lawn mower and hit me directly in my left eye I think it was my left eye was it my left eye shut up shut up it wasn't nose my left eye shut up and hit me directly in my left eye and all I can remember is dropping to the ground with my hand over my eye and my mom rushes over and I think my dad did as well they were like oh dang well your eyes bleeding we rush inside and take some photos as you do then drive to the hospital and I get checked out doctors put some yellow stuff in my eye and I leave and I didn't have to go on school camp which is good because I didn't want to go on school camp and I still have a scar on my left eye thanks for watching the video does Danny operating lawnmowers without full-body kevlar protection unless you want to get views would just just just don't stand alone Ollis okay you're thinking thanks for watching guys thanks for watching my video if you enjoyed the video please hit the like button and the subscribe button and if you want have done that and want to show extra support then follow my Twitter and donate to my patreon page and link in the description join my discord server if you want to chat to some people more people who like my videos or people who don't like my videos there's really a whole range of people and my discourse survey you should go check do them right now and yeah thanks for watching bye love you | Matopotato | UCsgpWZx0OcbAWZjuaLYjYuw | 2018-09-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 777 | 3,748 |
2iL23o-QIto | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2iL23o-QIto | Sourdough Waffles & Chili Dogs/Some Daily Life | okay this video is going to be kind of a m Podge on how this day went and there should be plenty of kid action going on for those of you who have asked for some more kiddo footage so here this morning I am making some sourdough waffles and it is the same way that I make the sourdough pancakes so it's around two cups of the starter or if you can see here that I am just dumping my starter out I know that I had about two to three cups of starter so I've just went ahead and dumped it all out I did go ahead and feed it the night before so I can make sure it was the thickness that we like and that it was nice and active because it helps it stay real fluffy and bubbly but you do not have to use active starter you can use discard so I'm going to add two tablespoons of sweetener we use sukin it is seriously the exact same as the pancakes I just put it in the waffle maker and then a teaspoon I have starter on my finger so I'm trying to keep it off of everything if you've ever worked with sourdough then you know that if starter gets anywhere and it dries it is kind of like dealing with concrete so I'm trying to keep it off of anything that I touch but then it was a teaspoon of baking soda and now I'm going to get some salt I just do a little sprinkle of salt sometimes I don't do it at all cuz I completely forget so if you don't do salt it's not a deal breaker just a little sprinkle of salt and then I'm going to do uh the recipe is a teaspoon of vanilla extract but I like to use the vanilla bean powder and so I'm only going to use half a teaspoon because the vanilla bean powder is stronger than the vanilla extract so I kind of eyeballed I'm still using my teaspoon here but I eyeballed half a teaspoon and we got a FedEx package they love getting the pack packages Brian even though he does have a office he has everything shipped to our house still and so just about every morning we get packages our neighbors probably think I'm a online huge online Shopper but it's really Briant stuff so then we're going to add two eggs it can be room temperature it can be out of the refrigerator whatever you like to do doesn't really matter and then on this one so that is like the base uh recipe there but on this one I did add because I had some homemade applesauce so I did add about a tablespoon there of applesauce a heaping tablespoon of applesauce and it just added a different flavor to it everybody really liked it so I am un you I am using a Danish dough whisk to whisk it up you can use a fork you can use a spatula you can use whatever you want but I use my Danish dough whisk for everything and you can see here the consistency starting to get really nice and fluffy really thick and so I have my iron all here already nice and hot so I'm going to pour that on there and I am not a professional at using my uh my waffle maker cuz it has like a ready light so you can tell when it's ready or not but I don't know when the ready lights on it's always still kind of sticky not really ready and so I don't know I'm just not I'm not good at my waffle maker I just lift it up like I did there and I check it and if it's not pulling apart then I take it out and then Leland and Wyatt like theirs uh they say crispy waffles so I do tend to overcook their waffles because they like them they like them nice and nice and crispy kind of hard but this one was a softer one so uh I'll split this one with Hannah and I'm going to make Leland's crispy one right now I'm here in the background I'm also going to try and get them to eat some scrambled eggs along with it sometimes I uh have a hard time getting them to eat anything else but the waffle so I do kind of dread when they ask for Waffle mornings but I'm making some some pancakes oh gosh no I'm making some scrambled eggs and they do actually end up eating the scrambled egg so it was it was a morning that kind of went nice I went ahead and I fed my sourdough got got it recharged I did half flour half water and then I'm going to cover it you always want to cover it with a breathable material and then secure it so you don't get any fruit flies in it why it's helping me with the laundry he likes to get everything off of their beds and then Lan likes to do Anna's bed okay so here I'm going out going to deal with the chickens and everybody has finally eaten gotten dressed we're probably around 10 10:30 here and uh they're going to play around while I can get some chicken duties done and then we actually it had been a while since we had some rain and it we had quite a few warm days so I am later on here going to work on getting everything nice and watered because we had gone probably two weeks or more Without Rain and we've been in the 70 and ' 80s so everything even though we're cooler in the evenings that's why I've been able to go a little longer without watering but things are starting to dry out so I do need to get some watering done and this is when we did watch Remy for Mom and Dad so no we did not get a dog but we're watching Remy for Mom and Dad and uh he and cie were just under the trampoline arguing so I had to break that up try and keep him with me they did really well my cats do not like dogs at all they will fight any dog that that comes in the yard but they actually did really well with Remy as long as I had him by me cie would kind of growl but she was okay and baby was actually pretty pretty good with him too and he's the one that really would just chase him off but I was really glad that we had an easy time and I am yes you water the green stocks from the very top and let it water itself but I did plant some seeds in it and so I wanted to go ahead and make sure I watered each one of those Pockets so to make sure that the seeds were nice and wet before they sprouted because um I planted let me think I did some beets radishes and carrots in the green stock and so I wanted to make sure I had those nice and uh and wet here I'm getting my gor GS down we did have a little Frost for two nights so my Vine died off and I'm just trying to collect all the gourds and we'll see if they dry out properly or not cuz they weren't quite ready but we'll see okay so here I am going to make it's actually my quick bread recipe my quick sandwich bread recipe but I am going to be doing hot dog buns because I'm going to do chili dogs for dinner and so I have two the two teaspoons of active dry yeast and then it's supposed to be a tablespoon of honey but if you can see there that was very much more than a tablespoon when I do my hamburger buns or my hot dog buns I do add more honey than normal because they like them sweeter kind of like a Hawaiian roll so I did add quite a bit of honey that's probably I would say maybe two tablespoons probably there and then one to two tablespoons of butter probably and so I'm measuring out I have my checking my water here it was a little warm but it it was okay it ended up working but I warmed up uh one and 1/3 cup of water and then I'm going to measure out well I'm going to get it stirred up yes to go ahead and warm up my yeast mix in that honey and I will be measuring out I do half of the iron corn and half of the allpurpose flour and so I did around two 245 G of iron corn and then probably 200 45 gram of allpurpose whenever I do my flour and I did uh just grind the iron corn this same morning so my iron corn was still pretty fresh and it does it it is it is a little bit different than if I grinded and had sat in the freezer for a little while but um I mean it's still good it's just whenever I mix it up it does tend to be a little more on the um the softer side the Sticky Side even though I do add a little bit of flour to it extra flour to it it it will be a little stickier too because of the honey but because it's fresh fresh fresh ground um it will need to set after I mix it for quite a while I think I mix it like 15 to 20 minutes and I will it will still be sticky so I take it off and it will be setting oh look I have H my alarm going off right now that I have bread in the oven but um it will be a little sticky and I will set it on the side and it when it's fresh fresh ground it takes that uh that flour a little more time to soak up the moisture so here it's still kind of sticky to the Bowl I'm going to I added about maybe a teaspoon or two of flour there that is the allpurpose flour that I added and so going to let it mix just a little bit more it is a little see kind of stick on the stickier side but it's okay I'm going to take it off I'm going to set it to the side I'm going to cover it and during that hour of rising it's all that fresh ground flour is also going to absorb more of that moisture so it does end up firming up a little bit more than uh when I first take it off of the dough hook okay so while that's Rising I am practicing jumping jacks with the boys because they do that at karate and if you can see here Lan's getting better at it but Wyatt was still struggling so so we were practicing Jumpy Jack and an thought that she would pitch in and do it too she does give up pretty quick at in a little bit when she realizes she can't do it quite like see right there I already gave up okay so now I'm going to form the hot dog buns and so I fold it over just like I do my sandwich bread and it's kind of like many versions of the sandwich bread and so when I get it out of the bowl I just pinch off a little portion enough to fill my hand and then I'm going to fold it over make make sure you have nice tension on the top a good form so uh it that tension will help it keep its form while it's rising and so I just form like basically little the way I same way I do my sandwich bread just little mini versions and then it ends up coming out like hot dog buns and honestly on this day like y'all are probably like oh I can't wait to see what this looks like I do forget to video everything put together them coming out the oven the um hot dog being put together with the chili like I forget to do all of that so I'm sorry but this is the process okay so here I have a pound of ground meat and I'm adding a little bit of salt I just sprinkle salt enough to cover it I don't know how much that would technically be and then I'm adding some garlic powder here you can use fresh garlic whatever you like um my kids don't like to see garlic so I do garlic powder a little bit of chili powder trying to think what all I ended up doing but we will find out together oh some cumin I was running out I needed to refill my container I do have I buy it in Bolt from Azure standard and so I do have a big jar of it I just need to refill my little one and this is onion powder and I'm going to go ahead get all that mixed up really good while it's on medium heat get it all browned up and mixed up real good together okay now I am going to put those hot dog buns in the oven at 350° and I bake them for between 15 and 20 minutes some I don't know some days it's a little different so I do I start with 15 and I check it and kind of watch it and sometimes I have to go up to to 20 but I think I'm pretty sure on this day I just stuck with the 15 okay I added some black beans there that I had uh precooked and froze like several months ago I had soaked and cooked some black beans and I had way too much so I ended up just jarring some and putting them in the freezer so this is some fermented Peppers all the peppers that we had left in the garden before we got this little Frost that we had and so I collected those and I chopped them all up seeds and everything and I stuck them in a jar to ferment and so I like to add a little bit of those whenever we have anything that's chili wise or taco wise um even nachos I like to add those so they're really good they were all very very spicy peppers especially keeping the seeds in but when you ferment it it actually makes them more mild so I was able to get away with putting that in the food and the boys didn't complain about it so I normally add some ketchup well I was completely out of ketchup so what I did was I got a small can of um tomato paste and normally I would would mix that in and then add a little bit of sucin it to add some sweetness but I ended up not adding sucin it on this day because when I tasted it you'll see I did double dip when I tasted it okay but I mean it was just feeding my family they'll be fine I wasn't sick or anything but when I tasted it it was actually really really really good I don't know if it was those um those fermented Peppers that had some kind of sweetness to them or change the flavor or something but I did not add any of the suc in it I thought it was really really really good and everybody ate all of it hope yall enjoyed the video and seeing the kids a little bit and we will see yall on the next video | Three Strands Homegrown | UC26xEztKpQ-dgWag7hthOVA | 2023-11-22 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,694 | 12,794 |
7tojd4sDy4Q | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tojd4sDy4Q | Throwing It Back to Some Old Heart of the Home Recipes | where we have been serving up uh wonderful homemade dishes since 1860 now I haven't been around since 1860 but I have been around for quite a few years and today I would love to welcome my cousin vonel Moser who has been making wonderful coconut cakes for our family for many many years today we're going to share our grandma Do's recipe with you which is a homemade cake with these ingredients and today we're going to share Von Seal's secret recipe which happens to be very simple and is a great way for today's busy Homemaker to make a wonderful dish that she could give as a gift or um take to a birthday party and her secret is frozen coconut the same secret that Grandma dos used so we would love to share this cake with you and now I'd like for my guest bonil Moser to explain her wonderful cake recipe to you simple wonderful and everyone will love it thank you Sherry I just make it by the Box recipe on the B and cook it I'll take a serrated knife slice it lengthwise make four layers instead of two and then the frosting is 12 oz of cool wh 12 oz of coconut 8 oz of sour cream a cut and a half of sugar okay the ingredients for our super fast great great cake are one box of white cake mix cook according to the directions on the box simple simple your frosting the secret to this recipe 16 oz of Cool Whip Tha 16 oz of frozen coconut remember only use frozen coconut 8 O of sour cream and 1 and 1/2 cup of sugar now the secret to this is mix the sour cream mix the sugar and mix the Cool Whip but mix it for about 5 minutes until the sugar is completely dissolved and completely smooth um and then you layer the coconut in with the frosting and there's your end result and I promise you you can you can take it to your mother-in-law and she will not know that you didn't work all day long to make this cake Granny's recipe was wonderful but this one easy simple and in half the time with half the ingredients and we'd love for you to share the cake with us now the best part of this show is sharing this wonderful cake with our friends and we are going to slice and celebrate this cake really brings is a reason to celebrate bring in your friends bring in your neighbors and watch them smile now you see the four layers this is a very simple simple way to make lots of folks happy I think it's time for me to sample this cake what do y'all think wonderful as always absolutely wonderful light and fresh and nobody knows it's not homemade hi welcome back to Harris Farm where I am thrilled to death to have my friend Mna Denon visiting Mna and I have been friends for longer than we care to discuss um 30 some odd years ago she used to eat in my mother's restaurant and had mother's famous meatloaf now tonight we're going to have my meatloaf um but we're also going to make what mother would have made mother didn't use a recipe didn't always use the same ingredients and my brother who thinks he never ate onions ate plenty of onions because mother put everything in the blender so we're going to show you how to feed your children without letting them know they're having onions they're having beets they're having salsa they're having anything you want to clean out of the refrigerator and put it in Mother's Meatloaf we're going to chop some loaf bread loaf bread now how old is this bread oh it's been the refrigerator about 2 weeks okay doesn't hurt it a bit it's been refrigerated we're going to cube we're going to cube it and we have two bottles of almost gone ketchup and we're going to add a little bit of water to it because mother would clean out the refrigerator that would be and never throw anything away okay okay now we're going to put this in the blender now I put the bread in first let's put some liquid in first and all of a sudden we have two empty ketchup bottles mother would be so proud of me she never wasted anything oh sandwiches were good we could not wait to leave the law office to go get them at lunchtime right I likeed mine with SL small onions mayonnaise and ketchup couldn't beat it I like M mayonnaise on one slice of the bread and ketchup and mustard on the other that sounds pretty good okay I can pour some more in okay okay A little bit of A1 Sauce okay and if I had some hind 57 I'd throw it in there but I didn't find any so how about one more egg one more egg and then we are going to chop up the onion that my brother doesn't eat but he's eating plenty of them in Mama's meatloaves that means three three eggs right okay now we're going to have to add a little bit of water to this and then Miss Mara is going to okay got it okay Miss Marna is going to put it on and puree it pure R you're right you're right I had to there you go we're going to mix ground chuck and ground beef and to that we're going to add the mixture I can't tell there's any onion in there can you I don't see the onion and I don't believe Roy will ever know and will not tell him now we're going to put it in the oven at 375 for about 45 to 55 minutes smells great smells oh it smells wonderful I can't wait to have a meatloaf sandwich thanks for stopping by Harris Farm hope you'll come back to see us next week see you thank you Miss Mna it was a I love you so hi folks welcome to Heart of the home we're at the home of Mike and Sandy Denson and I have my granddaughter Ansley Bruce visiting with me today and we're going to prepare a simple simple recipe re um I think Mike and Sandy are preparing for a barbecue for the 4th of July and I'm going to teach Ansley who will share this recipe with all her friends the easiest recipe you've ever done a friend of mine pet Massie shared this recipe with me four years ago and yesterday we named it ice cream sandwich Heaven because it is Heavenly light easy simple and 5 minutes how about that 5 minutes now the ingredients for this are ice cream sandwiches and we use the mini sandwiches and Pet's recipe was cool wh well because I couldn't remember that I adjusted and used marshmallow cream we're going to use both today and then um you complement this with pineapple strawberry wonderful wet nuts chocolate or butterscotch and if you make it and your family says I don't like pineapple just make it with the chocolate and butterscotch this is a recipe that you can improvise and you can if your children don't like strawberries take the strawberries out we've already unwrapped our mini sandwiches we're covering our layer of sandwiches with the marshmallow cream and then we are going to start putting some of the condiments on there we're going to start with pineapple and basically you just spread the pineapple on there there's your first flavor we have marshmallow and pineapple now we're going to cover the pineapple with Cool Whip and we bought fat-free Cool Whip I know that sounds crazy but you can't tell the dime's worth the difference in the taste and you do lose a few of those calories and we're going to add some strawberry to this and keep in mind if there's anything in this that your family doesn't like adjust it go to caramel go to Chocolate um do whatever you need to make sure your family's happy with it I even bought some um chocolate Cool Whip because I have some precious little granddaughters who love chocolate and I know that Miss Lily would love to have this with chocolate now we're going to drizzle some caramel over this and then with the caramel we will top off with chocolate and I think pette tells me she uses two full jars of nuts so I think we'll try that Miss anley what do you think of that this it look very good very good good I think it looks very good I think it's going to look better when we add a few cherries to it there you go Ice Cream Sandwich heaven and it is Heavenly you will enjoy it your family will enjoy it and you will make this over and over again remember simple easy took us about 5 minutes done deal okay Miss Ansley look easy simple and I'm going to dip you one up to enjoy oh my goodness looks like an ice cream sunday doesn't it yes oh goodness enjoy the 4th of July United We Stand wow I am so glad that we had those memories precious Merna Denon precious Von Moser I had Von seel's cake for years and years and years had no idea until we did heart of the home that that was not a made from scratch cake everybody showed up at our homecoming at church and everybody went straight for that cake because they knew it was the best thing in the house oh my gosh and Miss Mna did work for um the Landrum at the lawyer's office and she would come over there and get a meatloaf sandwich all the time Miss Freddy hamr would always come and get a roast beef sandwich and she'd have mustard on one piece of the bread mayonnaise on the other lettuce and tomato and salt and pepper and I can remember it like it was yesterday it's so crazy how these Precious Memories mean so much I want to read something out of Mike's book and this is this is so funny how we all have a gift and everybody says that I have the gift of cooking I deliver food to neighbors I deliver food to family when somebody um passes away or somebody's hurting or a birthday or whatever I deliver food it's one of the few things I can do without any problems no issues I can cook a little bit okay we all have a gift some animals in the wild have symbolic relationships that's when two animal species come together to form a mutual relationship ship that is beneficial to them both the zebra and the ostrich have that type relationship zebras have poor vision but a great sense of smell and hearing the ostrich has great vision but does not smell or hear well isn't that weird the two travel together to warm each other to warn each other of the impending danger each one of these animals benefit from the strength of the other it keeps him safe from Lions on the hunt the body of Christ is very similar all believers have god-given gifts to use for the benefit of others the Bible says each of you should use whatever gift you have received to serve others as faithful stewards of God's grace in various forms and that's 1 Peter 4:10 Paul said for just as each of us have one body with many members and these members do not all have the same function so in Christ we through many form one body and one member belongs to all the others Romans 12:45 each part each member plays is V is vital and only you can play it we are like the zebra and the ostrich we need each other boy you're not kidding you are not kidding um you know how much your prayers mean to me you know that um all of you who are with me through all the things that happened to us 13 years ago couldn't have made it without you absolutely could not have made it without you there's no way in the world that I could have sat there alone and handled what I did when I came back to television after Angela's death my producer said it's too soon you can't come back and I said no you don't understand I said I have to come back or I will never make it I have to come back I have to feel the warmth of the people who love me and I have to feel like I can give of something and last night I was watching Kennesaw State University is doing a um a visual of what suicide does and I was blown away by all the backpacks that are lining the Ballfield at kenas State University from suicides and I was just like wow wow I know what I've been through I know that I survived it I know that many of you are a part of why I survived it I know that what you did for me reaching out to me whether it was a call a letter let's go to lunch let's go drive somewhere and and see something different whatever you did it helped me through those those moments that I didn't think I would survive as I get on Facebook every day I see somebody who is facing what I faced and I always tell them the same thing the hurt will never go away but there will be a place of peace that you finally get to learn to live with this and so today as I look back to these beautiful women who made me stronger and who helped me I love being able to share that little bit of life that was fun it was happy um great things from from good people who shared my life and I remember so many special things about each of them so today again I'm going to say Reach Out pick up your phone call somebody say let's go to lunch let's take a beautiful drive up in the mountains it's not going to rain until tomorrow afternoon so get out and enjoy a little bit of what God has done for us it's all free doesn't cost us a penny well it does cost gas and that boy that's something else I'm spending $15 a day on gas and not going anywhere I don't have to go isn't that crazy but it is Everything Is Beautiful in the spring it all looks new it all looks fresh and bright so get out and enjoy it right now we're going to take you back to some of my favorite heart of the homes and this is when it first started we never did a retake on heart of the home we never started over we did it it was a 4minute segment we Zam bam it was done it was crazy I don't know how it all worked and how it was made so simple and so much fun but it truly was so let's share a little bit more of that today hi I'm Sherry Martin tonight on heart of the home we're going to do a really simple recipe my guest Johnson Collins said she's not crazy about tomatoes but I'm going to make a dish you might like you like pizza M yes so you've eaten Pizza on tomatoes and these have a few of the spices that pizza has and we're going to have mozzarella cheese so you might end up liking this and it's got garlic and you know our BD that films this for us it's got a horrible cold and we don't want to get her cold so we're going to stuff her full of garlic aren't we I think that's a good plan this is a really quick and simple recipe the ingredients are hunts Tomatoes we are using two cans of diced and one can of hole that we're going to actually cut in half uh mozzarella cheese a little bit of sugar a stick of butter salt pepper garlic salt a few bacon bits and Johnson garlic crisp garlic crisp and Johnson is is going to actually you're just going to break all those up in little pieces and we're going to add them to this we're going to bake it antioxidants from the tomatoes a few spices whole lot of garlic and it's going to be a quick and simple recipe okay Miss Johnson now your job is to crush all those little crisp that are left they're right into crushing okay Miss Johnson we've put two cans of the diced tomatoes in here and to that we're going to add a can of whole tomatoes and I told you this is simple it's going to get a little bit of sugar not much because the tomatoes are naturally sweet we're just going to sprinkle it with a little bit of sugar and we're going to add black pepper and little bit of garlic salt some onions this should be a good antioxidant recipe shouldn't it it should also keep everybody from getting a cold cut the butter up in just large chunks it will melt and make this even crispier with a garlic crisp because the butter and the crisp will melt together so we're going to add a few bacon bits to this and we're using the real bacon bits um you can fry your own or you can buy these that come in the package these are the real ones they're not those hard ones that come in the can now Miss Johnson is going to add the garlic crisp and we need these really really crushed up good have you guys since you can crush them a little bit more all right let's see how those did oh man that looks perfect see we're just going to sprinkle these on top which is going to add the flavor of the garlic and then it'll add the texture of the crunchiness and I'm going to cover this in mozzarella cheese and we're going to bake it okay here we go we're going to stick it in the oven 30 minutes at 3:25 there you go okay well Johnson it's ready we're going to pretend this is upside down pizza you weren't sure you'd like scallop Tomatoes but if we pretend the crust is on top there's the cheese the tomatoes are in the bottom antioxidants a lot of garlic good for you with a cold we're going to pretend it's pizza and we're going to try it it smells great doesn't it yes smells good it's going to be very hot I can assure you of that guys this was a simple recipe it was very inexpensive and we used my leftovers didn't we we got to use those leftovers um antioxidants look calcium it was easy it was fun byebye by bye welcome back folks tonight on heart of the home my special guest are Laura Johnson and Daren are going to help me with a very simple recipe that was submitted by Miss L wiswell from Jupiter Florida Lana and her mom watch US Weekly on streaming videos and she promised me this was a recipe that children would like to do so we're going to do this and it's going to teach us a little bit it's going to teach us a little bit about hot and cold so you ready guys yep you ready good okay let's start the ingredients for this item called eggs in a bag are eggs and any condiments you want I like salsa you like ham and you like cheese so we're going to combine our ingredients we're going to drop it in this freezer bag and in 13 minutes we're going to have an omelette isn't that wild we don't use a frying pan we don't use any butter and we're going to cook it in boiling water okay guys let's assemble our bags the first thing we're going to do is put your name on it so when the bags come out of the water you know what's yours okay okay allur how do you spell your name a l l u r a a l l l u u r a Aur okay when we put your ingredients in here you'll know this is yours when it comes out of the hot boiling water okay guys now we're going to put two eggs in each one and we're going to start with Miss Lura so miss Lura tell me what ingredients you want sweetheart do you want ham do you want cheese ham and cheese okay we're going to have ham and cheese and this is so neat and where did my Fork go Darion there you go my helper's Hiding my fork okay and remember guys this is your t time it and you boil this for 13 minutes Miss Aura here we go that work look just like gold it is gold isn't it it looks like gold it came from Cinderella's castle right okay arura you hang on to yours don't drop it hold on okay Johnson what do you want in your sweetheart ham and cheese ham and cheese and remember guys do two eggs I tested this last week on my growing boys who were racing go-karts and I thought three eggs would be good for them that didn't work it didn't get done in 13 minutes ham and cheese for Miss Johnson I think this is such a neat idea when they submitted it I thought well somebody's bumped their head you can't boil anything in a plastic bag but I've done it three times now and it's really neat Miss Johnson hang on to yours there you go hold it at the top okay Daran what do you want yours honey same kind same kind ham and cheese y'all aren't going to stray nobody wants bacon nope ham and cheese we're going to get it there you go two eggs remember two eggs you know last time Aur was here we made egg salad okay Darion there's yours now the trick is we're going to drop these in boiling water for 13 15 minutes okay okay I'm going to drop one in first and then I want y'all to follow me now drop your bags in there you go and in 13 minutes we'll have a perfect omelette I'm going to take these out of the water because I don't want the kids to get burned and it really is hot remember boiling water be very careful when you do this but it's been fine and I think the kids have enjoyed this one and it is something you can do for Mother's Day and not mess up the kitchen because look at that a perfect omelette and it didn't mess up the kitchen and there's no fat we use no butter no olive oil folks enjoy your family enjoy your friends thank you so much for coming back to see me and y'all promise you'll come back bye bye happy Mother's Day everybody see you again on heart of the home hi I'm Sher Martin and tonight on heart of the home my buddy Johnson Collins one of my favorite guests is here to help me celebrate what are we celebrating the Oney year anniversary the Oney year anniversary of heart of the home we've been on the Aira year we've had a lot fun we've done some simple recipes we've done some good recipes you helped with a deer recipe and tonight um we have a friend who's going to come by and bring us a special dessert while we're waiting on Miss Lucy Johnson and I are going to talk about something that I never forgot in the eth grade I had a really special teacher my homeade teacher Mrs masel km loved her absolutely loved her and she taught me some really simple things that I never forgot and I hope to teach you some simple things that you won't forget one of them is how to set a table you don't just grab a fork you do salad fork dinner Fork what is this fork for um how about an appetizer or a shrimp cocktail kind of looks like a baby Fork doesn't it yeah yeah yeah um Everybody um should learn to set the table correctly and today we're just going to talk a little bit about that and some of the things that you do need to learn because someday you may be entertaining the governor what do you think of that okay Miss Johnson now I'm going to take these apart you've seen how the table set do you think you can do it now if I remove them yes okay let's do this now you decide how you put them correctly back in place you know you can use linen na napkins too on our formal table we iron and use linen napkins that's not one of my favorite things because I usually get to iron the napkins but today we're going to use paper because we're using the Casual table in the breakfast room there you go now what's that fork this one it's a salad fork salad fork your dinner fork and do you know if we went to a really really foofoo restaurant we might have another Fork would that confuse you yes maybe and if we had soup we'd have a soup spoon and if we had iced tea we'd have another spoon this could get confusing guys now how old are you nine nine that could really confuse a nine-year-old you learned pretty quickly didn't you I think you pretty smart you going to go home and share this with Mom and Dad yeah good good yeah I think I hear our special dessert coming in the door it's time to celebrate there you go Johnson I promised you a cake for a celebration Our Friend Lucy voran just made us a wonderful simple dessert Lucy tell me about it it's a homemade angel food cake yes uh all you do is slice it in three layers just like you would uh you know regular cake and uh use a serrated knife because if you don't it will tear it okay okay and then all you do is take a 20 oz can of crushed pineapple an 8 oz Cool Whip and two instant puddings vanilla puddings and you don't do anything except mix th those three ingredients together if you put anything else in it it's going to be too gooey so that's all very simple that looks simple looks elegant looks like it's going to be light it is it's very going be light and you can you don't have to make a homemade cake you can go to the store and for what $1.99 buy an angel food cake show up at homecoming with this and somebody's going to think you've cooked all day garnish it with strawberries right whatever fruit is in season I think we're going to enjoy this thank you Lucy for stopping about to help us celebrate our one year anniversary you can also do the sides if you want to with another mix of CIP and pineapple anding right um and we love simple desserts this this is a good simple dessert we promised you a simple dessert for our oneyear anniversary thank you so much guys we'll be back hi I'm Sher Martin tonight on heart of the home I promised you a rich rich recipe and wow is it rich I've been eating this cake for about 30 something years you were 2 years old no cuz I'm only 29 uh oh uh oh well okay my daughter Angela was only two the first time I had this cake gosh does that make me or you old neither one okay neither one it is a rich recipe this was submitted by dorine Lee she's from kakei Illinois and she got the recipe from I think a Junior League cookbook there many many years ago rich rich rich chocolate cinnamon cake rich and good now I made my first one last week and Angela is going to grab the ingredients for you there are two cups of flour two cups of sugar one cup of butter A4 cup baking cocoa one cup water half a cup of Buttermilk one teaspoon of baking soda one teaspoon of cinnamon one teaspoon of vanilla extract two eggs and one teaspoon of salt now if y'all have been tuning in to Heart of the home we all know I'm not much at measuring now we're going to add we are actually measuring aren't we we measured today never measure well we're measuring today because this cake is pretty precise and we need to measure this okay Angela we have combined two cups of flour two cups of sugar we sifted that and now we're melting our cup of butter butter with our cocoa and our water we're going to let that melt good and then we're going to pour it over the dry ingredients and then we're going to add our butter milk and our cinnamon and our vanilla and our eggs and our soda tiny bit of soda tiny bit of salt it's going to be ready to bake this is a simple recipe using plain flour and the chocolate's already smelling so good oh man this chocolate smells great this is what makes this cake Rich butter and chocolate kind of like a man with a 401k and a state retirement out of town hobby oh my gosh that's rich that's rich now this is what a 10 by 15 pan it's a little bit larger than normal and that's the size pan that this recipe requires it's going to be in the oven for 30 minutes or until a toothpick put in comes out dry do not overbake it my first one I did overbake it so watch it closely now this rich rich recipe for our icing is Angela the amount of butter is one cup of butter one bag of 10 EG sugar four cup of cocoa four cup of cocoa um six tablespoons of milk a teaspoon of vanilla that's it bullet and saucepan that is it guys and it is so simple and you pour it over the cake hot man I think this deserves the rich and Powerful oo man it's good these walnuts came from Harris farm and they're big chunks of walnuts you can use pecans you can use walnuts I just happen to have a ton of walnuts we picked up out on the ground and shell oh wow yummy wow yummy just a hint of cinnamon and a whole lot of rich chocolate and what do you think of that I think that looks yummy enough to eat I think that look yummy I think Dorene had a good idea this was a great recipe guys Angela I promised you this was going to be rich and hotor I'm so glad you're here home from college I smell this all the way in Atlanta so I had to come uhuh okay good idea Tori there you go honey the third generation gets the cake three generations a great recipe bye-bye it's great | Cherie Martin | UCFM820fYwn7POv-EKTns7EQ | 2024-03-21 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 5,330 | 26,757 |
DGGIsEcpNaQ | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DGGIsEcpNaQ | Channeling ꞉꞉ Intro to our community on the ground and human colonies in space. | to start our colony of telepathic humans this is what changed everything there are some humans that have the ability to have telepathic communication with the aliens and they learned from that how to actually communicate with earthlings and how and why we do some of the things that we do and they found out that we're very very diverse cultures many many cultures they've discovered that their diversity isn't that bad because they have telepathy so they all start thinking pretty much the same way when it's all agreed upon you know what i mean if you have telepathy and you can know somebody's intent and know somebody's conversation and and what they believe in everything things become closer together they start you know the belief systems are closer the the social systems are closer it just makes sense that their belief everything will be a little bit more the same when they found out how diverse we were i mean every single person there's not two people that actually think alike i mean you may have some similarities in your thought patterns but when they actually started studying the thought patterns of humans they're going oh my this one thinks this way this one thinks this way this is the base for that thought this is the base for that thought in another person and they don't jive but they came up with the same answer and when they started realizing how diverse we were in our individuality that is when they started understanding humanity because they did not understand how diverse we were they didn't understand how one person could say the same thing as 14 other people and have 14 different meanings they are becoming more successful with communication now is because the thought patterns are being understood by those that are in the telepathic colony which is colony one and they're they're learning from the telepaths how to communicate with earth if you can understand why now that the human colonies that max proposed with the telepathic people has actually been the breakthrough for communication with earth in a greater way than it ever has before so now they have three colonies um with diversely different thoughts the third colony is an important one because that is where they're developing communication with earth in the sense of videotapes that kind of communication youtube kind of things that they want to be able to communicate with earth in the social media without causing excitement and craziness and all that stuff that is what colony 3 is doing there they have different individuals they have filmmakers from the from the earth who go there they won't say who but they have also aliens that are interested in doing that as well and they're coming together and they're recording hours and hours and hours a day but they want to make sure that it's usable material yes the colonies similar in spaceships and one isn't on another uh planet era that's in the pleiadian system uh the weather is being monitored by aliens because we're going through a very severe time in weather you may not realize it but if they would not be helping with the weather the weather would be three times as bad as it is they calm it down that much and even still with that it's still harsh are they trying to keep us from annihilating each other yes they're trying to keep well this is the closest that any earth civilization has been to to becoming part of the galaxy and we're entering a period of evolution for our species that will come within the next couple hundred years where a lot of people will become telepathic i don't know if anybody knows about how telepathy starts it starts with you know the energy chakras in your body it starts with the center the heart so that is why we are at the beginning of that evolution of telepathy this is the beginning of a new era for the world it is because you all now can walk into a room and and usually tell if somebody's good intention or bad intention and you won't even have to look at their face you don't have to look at their face and sometimes the face is deceiving but that is what i'm saying telepathy is coming to us it's going to take a couple hundred 150 200 years but this one 2012 that date december 21st 2012 was the beginning of what they called an ascension ascension of uh our vibration as a human as a community of people you see it starts it's very small but as it goes out it gets bigger and bigger and bigger and that's when it takes the people in that light we'll bring it in so and a lot of you may have experienced that where you wouldn't even have to mention something to someone and they'll already feel your vibration and say so how comes you're in such a good mood today or how comes you're a little different today right you've you experienced that that is your vibration going out when you start giving that away when you start giving that peace away then that's enlightenment think about that and though those who can find joy i think buddha said when you find joy you are enlightened and it and it's contagious and it's good and it's loving and joy is just part of that is part of the enlightenment when you find your joy your highest excitement in your world and when you find that and it starts coming out of you enlightenment keep it because we're all a net of a vibrational net of light and when that joy comes out we knit ourselves together as a community and then you net yourself together and that's going to be part of the community of the world is the net of light that goes around it and and if you're in a community with a lot of people that are netted together as light they bring you up if you're down and you bring them up if they're down what is the reason for the intercourse because we're closer to becoming part of a a citizen of the galaxy than we ever been before and so but what the uh greek for canarians say and that's the alliance that they have with the five different species there's five species and an alliance what they say is that this timeline will not pass that away did experiments that was a while back um they don't do that anymore at all they've uh they asked permission for to be for people to have a to go with them and they don't do any kind of experiments like that what do you think is the relationship of ongoing us or earthly political structures with this intercourse when they discuss first contact that's when it's that's when that becomes important because they don't want to be threatening to the to the world they don't want to be seen as coming to hurt anybody and that's why they're going to use the internet and youtube and things to prepare people ahead of time and also people like yourselves who understand and know that there are aliens out there that you to help others to calm down you know and it's not weird anymore and their intent from what i feel when they come through me is their intent is to educate who is ever here how to grow their vibration and be a higher vibrational person like lakesh he's very popular and took her the lyran she's very very uh loving to humans and pentium who is a yeagil and centiri santia okay you can see our videos on humancolony.org hugh cola first the first letter human colon abbreviated to hue color it's a unique word which we use now and on youtube it's very easy to find us and another channel uh first is quality tv and second is huge color chat it's been really amazing because our i think our yukolo h-u-c-o-l-o is the only um web channel that is actually birthing channelers and birthing galactic languages they even have galactic language gym you go in there and speak your language and see if someone can understand what you're saying and sometimes they can and some sometimes it's just practice here now we have a whole group of people speaking galactic languages and uh starting to channel they're they're they're all over the place down there um so three months it happened uh initially jim spoke several languages you heard lyran language is high so yeah it's goodbye they say that they speak this language for several years and they thought they go crazy and finally they find us and we can you know some of our people speak the same language and they can converse and there were amazing webinars on on record where nine people speak galactic languages together they converse in those languages and some of them can translate jim translates arcturian with without being without channeling i mean through when he channels he can speak many languages but even without channeling him can translate some thanks for coming i appreciate it much love | Hucolo TV / Channeling | UCj5wGWloHE8hKHPd5kqWsJQ | 2014-07-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,561 | 8,564 |
rZi86_ovB3Y | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZi86_ovB3Y | Bitcoin Q&A: The Scaling Rites of Passage | oh yeah so right now we know that Bitcoin has like the largest network effect so in the event of a contentious hard fork how likely is it that Bitcoin becomes obsolete as the main currency and other currencies take over like by far that's a very good question how likely is it that Bitcoin becomes obsolete I don't think it will become obsolete I think if it faces a contentious hard fork this is an example of things to come Bitcoin will be attacked it will be attacked through its mining it will be a tax through the network who will be attacked legally it will be attacked in every possible way if you don't think bitcoins going to be attacked you've misunderstood what this is about you don't go and poke a twenty trillion dollar industry and go hey we're going to disrupt you and then wait for it to rollover right this is offensive to a lot of governments and a lot of very very rich institutions and there are a lot of people who don't want to see Bitcoin succeed because it's decentralized and they're going to attack every aspect of it every aspect of Bitcoin will be attacked so if a fork happens we get to learn what happens when a fork attack occurs and we learn how to defend against fork attacks make no mistake anybody who walks into this thinking that a fork will be unopposed is going to very quickly discover that this will be a battle on all fronts day one we've achieved 51% we are now going to fork Bitcoin kind of seems like hey shipping date is here our work is done your problems are just about to begin my friend you launched a 51% attack that means you are seven blocks ahead every 24-hour period if you can sustain it but inevitably the two sides are going to attack each other they're going to attack each other on the network they're going to attack each other with denial of service they're going to attack each other with hash rate they're going to attack each other publicly privately anonymously and not in every possible way and immediately every bug in the software will get poked and then poked again and if you try to fix it you'd better write that code well because if you put another bug in that's gonna get poked too and then it becomes a battle about who has the best software development team and how quickly they can maintain that code and keep up time because that race is only seven blocks wide I don't think some of the people who are threatening to do of hard fork and 51% have thought clearly about the implications of what happens immediately afterwards this is not going to be an easy game it's going to actually allow Bitcoin to test all the possible attack scenarios nodes on networks on relay networks on hashing transaction malleability replay transactions and everything else what will come out of that probably a Bitcoin that's worth a lot less or in my view a technology that's worth a lot more because it's battle-hardened when it comes out of that it will have survived its first fork attack and we will know a lot more about what happens in highly contentious fork environments theorem taught us a lot but it didn't teach us much about a highly contentious fork the fork was initiated by the main development team which has more than 80% of the hash rate on their side the other thing to remember and I think this is important there's a lot of people who say if Bitcoin stumbles it's going to be overtaken by one of these other currencies it's very important to not mistake smooth sailing for good sailors right in order to have scaling problems you first need to have scale in order to have governance problems you need to have a controversy to govern over right and everything's hunky-dory combined and so you have twenty billion dollars on the table and then the Long Knives start getting sharpened since this is March we can use a reference beware the Ides of March right and you can then say oh it's not what it looks like it's not what it looked like you know don't pay attention to the stabbing really pay attention to the fact that we all came together to stab together that's the roman senate quote the point here is that what's happening in bitcoin now isn't unique to bitcoin if one of the other currencies gets to this scale and has to handle this many transactions they have a scaling problem which they're going to have to resolve there will be differences of opinion as to how to resolve that some approaches will lead to massive centralization and a takeover by miners some approaches will lead to failures in architecture and software these problems will repeat for every other currency these are the rites of passage you first have to grow up to face them right and so the big advantage that many of the other blockchains the currencies have is they can look at bitcoin watch what happens and learn these mistakes cheaply so that they don't have to repeat them expensively now how many of the block chains are actually doing that not many because for the most part they're too busy going where the best we're going to win next right and not paying attention to the fact that these exact same problems are going to exist in their own block chains there are no easy answers there are lots of very delicate design trade-offs in how you deploy trusts where and bitcoin is paving new ground it's carving a new path no one has gone here before pay attention we have a lot to learn this is a fantastic experiment but it's not easy it looks easy back there I like to remind people who was here when Bitcoin was in 2013 anyone here who used coin in 2013 yes a few people okay how much was the average fee zero right how many blocks were full zero how big was the block size problem zero how much of a governance problem did we have or danger of a contentious hard fork zero you look back at 2013 and you go easy days right what changed what changed was now there's 20 billion dollars at stake and the game gets serious right so it's easy to think that it will always be smooth sailing for the other cryptocurrency because they got everything right that's not going to be the case [Music] | aantonop | UCJWCJCWOxBYSi5DhCieLOLQ | 2017-03-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,122 | 6,056 |
-Ni5rZM-sQs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ni5rZM-sQs | San Lorenzo Valley Water District 5/7/20 | so he's Louie can't hear you he should be on now he's just muted and we're started to me you're on Steve okay welcome to the Board of Directors meeting for the San Luis Valley Water District let's go ahead and convene the meeting and Holly if you want to take the attendance you [Music] hi I'm sorry I don't see Lou Ferris on the meeting is he here Margaret okay great okay president Swan here director Henry here director foals your director Moran beer director Ferris here really thank you holy Recker there any additions or deletions to the agenda I have none I'm and I'll ask district counsel do you have any this is District Council I have none thank you this portion of the meeting is reserved for the public to ask any questions on items not currently on the agenda so you may speak on any subject you want that's not covered today you have [Music] three minutes to do so and and we'll be using that as the standard timepiece for all questions going forward even on the agenda items so they have three minutes to speak on anything and we will try to limit it so that you speak once on a topic and that's all we want to try and get through these four items it's a special meeting so we want to be efficient with our time and and move this along so that we can accomplish all four of these items and get back to our air-conditioned other rooms does anybody have any comments about something anything not on the agenda and I think it's CTV or the people watching forehand Aquarius correct okay not seeing any hands coming up then we'll move on to the existing items old business as it were one thing I'd like to do just to get it out of the way Rick I'd like to make a change and take the letter to Pacific Gas and Electric first and just so that it's done or not dusted so would you like to address that [Music] yes counsel Nichols does that require a motion or we just can move to that item it does not require a motion the board chair has the authority to change the order of the agenda okay so there'll be item 5d correspondence to PG&E regarding PGA's wildfire mitigation plan and tree removal the recommendation is that the board review the memo provide direction regarding the attached provides letter from PG&E regarding tree removal and PG&E wildfire mitigation plan at the February 20th 2020 environmental committee meeting during public comment request was made on behalf of the Valley Women's Club Environmental Committee and Friends of the San Lorenzo Valley Water to write a letter to PG&E addressing impact to the watershed by PG&E stree removal program a letter was drafted and booked to the board of directors on March 5th staff received direction to work with Nancy Macey of the valley Woman's Club to update the letter to reflect the district's more pacifically at the April 16 2020 board meeting director Foltz introduced a revised version of the letter included in this agenda pack after reviewing both letters the board decided to move forward the full submersion staff received direction to work with director folds director Moran and Nancy Macey to finalize the letter the final draft to see Exhibit A and a list of the recommended recipients Exhibit B arc attached and I'll turn it back over to the four Thank You Rick does does anybody on the board have any questions about the revised letter that Bob worked on with I forget who it was Nancy or is somebody else really meaty in our environmental program oh yeah barley right so does any board member have any I I do but I don't know how to you did fine let's just shout it out just okay let us know you're here what so what's your car I think this was a failure of proper procedure the original letter at the last meeting and I didn't realize I was approving for it to be written by another director but it was originally from the Environmental Committee it was written by a board member who was part of that committee who was written by a staff member who's part of that committee was also people from the public and from the committee that helped with it and I I won't vote I don't care if the new letter is the best letter ever written I don't think it was proper procedure and I'm gonna vote no thank you less any other let's see okay I can see a hand up Bob you have comment about the letter well I can I was just gonna say I could offer a to display the red lines if anybody needs to see that with respect to the procedure I may be very confused but I thought this was a letter that was introduced during public comment at an Environmental Committee meeting and was brought to the board for direction and given everything that's happened wasn't able to go back to the committee which is worse where it should have gone had we not been in this current situation and so at that point it's back to the board I am very confused about the process but my understanding the process is very different okay any other board member with any comments about the UM I'll chip in a little bit so um it was presented by a member of the Environmental Committee during public comment during a meeting a couple months ago and that's when it was first read and then it went to the board to be discussed and we've taken direction since then so that's my comment and the only other thing is I think director false and me and Nancy Macey work on it a little bit a while a week or so ago I was invited to that but I couldn't get my zoom connection working so I didn't participate in that but uh it's to the extent of de letter the letter addresses things that we are concerned about and you know there's many ways of expressing the same interests and I think it expresses those interests and I'm glad to see that we're you know requesting PG&E clean up its act a little bit and be conscious of what's going on here in the San Lorenzo Valley Thank You lewd you're the only one left other than myself do you have any questions about the letter you know I have no comment dad okay terrific thank you I think the letter is fine it it's exactly is what we ended up depressing it the whole last board meeting so I don't have an issue with it does the public wish to comment on this letter not seeing any hands then we're gonna bring it back and vote on this and so all I'd like to make a motion then that we what is it that we approve this letter as written by the team of individuals involved in writing it and and that we we sign it and send it on to everybody that's listed on the to list attached to the draft that we have on our agenda packets I'll second that motion thank you let's go for a vote Holly all right why Bob is it significant well it has to do with who to send the letter to and in what form so if you look at the second page there's a suggestion that separate letters would be sent rather than see seeing one or another and there's a list of folks here so one of the things that Nancy Carly and I discussed and we weren't we thought that this probably needed board specific board direction was which way to go and so I think we need to be very specific about what we would like staff to do relative to whether it's CCS or separate letters or what have you my you know I'm sort of diagnostic on it the way it's written it's kind of written towards PG&E so writing it to them with copies of these folks I think would be okay but you know it's really up to the board which which way we would want to go and I sorry to interrupt the thought but I wanted to make sure we were addressing this specific I don't know I got a feeling we're all pretty agnostic about the letter in Bob so let's just say that will direct that a unique copy let's see what you send one copy to PG&E and see see all these other people okay sounds good to me that's what emotion can I get a second again I'll second that again all right let's get a vote Holli president Swann yes director Henry no director foals yes director Moran yes drift Paris I'm sorry I didn't hear you oh you're muted I'm sorry I voted I thank you motion passes okay you respond so we're back on the agenda we'll go back to item 5a the unfunded liabilities it's recommended that the Board received the information and the presentation by staff there was no immediate action needed however staff recommends these issues continued to be discussed at committee level the district has been having more conversations around unfunded liabilities there are three main categories employee benefit liabilities deferred maintenance which is large capital projects large scale capital projects due to their past useful life all right would tanks age undersized pipelines etc there are smaller and routine projects paint coatings of existing tanks extending their useful life routine facility maintenance meter replacement etc some of these routinely occur in the annual budget such as the upcoming tank coatings knee replacement and paying with the required benefit liabilities for benefit liabilities are measured that the district can take to decrease these potential and save money for the future some of these deferred maintenance can also have a more detailed roadmap for future the finance manager has put together a PowerPoint and I will refer to the Finance Manager for reporting on this I'm Stephanie yeah just before you begin Stephanie I would really like to express my appreciation to the staff you particularly in a Rick and everybody else that invested time over the last couple of weeks in putting this together I know it took a tremendous amount of effort and it was not a scheduled item in our normal end of things but your efforts are very much appreciated by the entire Board of Directors so thank you very much and with that Stephanie if you've got a show to go or show to show feel free that's me we don't hear you are you muted unmuted little does that mean this is back into whatever one over to unfunded liabilities running around that house still down here oh there you are I heard the L okay can you hear me now yes ma'am okay my earbuds must not be working so I will work from my phone so unfunded employee benefit liabilities so what employee benefits are there essentially our district has to we have our pension liability many people are used to the idea of how retirement plans work we have two tiers 2% at 55 which is commonly referred to as the classic member and 2% at 62 which is called a pepra member and that's for anyone that enters the CalPERS system after January 1st 2013 for the first time the other employee benefit is referred to as open other post-employment benefits and the district offers a retiree medical benefit for employees that continue to use CalPERS medical plans after retirement and this is going to vary from when someone retired so so amount retires ten years ago depending on what the amount was in their contract at that time is what they is what they will be getting paid out at next slide so might as well just get the cat out of the bag so Gatsby 68 in Gatsby 75 essentially were the requirements to show your long-term obligation on your books as of our six 30 2019 financial audit the pension liability was at 3.8 million and the open liability was at one point one so the district had roughly five million dollars in unfunded employee benefit liabilities nextslide here's some of the key terms that you'll kind of see being used a lot of times in some of this stuff so the unfunded accrued liability it's pretty much the present value needed to pay the future calculated benefit a lot of this all gets put together from actuarial and actuarial use a lot of different assumptions to go into their projections them will be demographic such as mortality disability and retirement rates and then they also do economic assumptions for discount rates salary growth and inflation amortization base is essentially similar to a mortgage it's going to have the different amortization period how long it's getting spread out over and the different rate implied subsidy this relates to the vocab for the most part and this is where again more like an actuarial type of a thing where they it's like a blended rate for active employees we pay the same rate as the retirees would pay for their plan so because of that it's like the active employees are subsidizing the retiree premiums and that creates a liability that gatsby requires us to show on our books and then the net liability is just the difference between the liabilities and the asset next fine so as we said our opeth is about 1.1 million 60% of that is cash and 40% of that is that implied subsidy so when people are funding their trust if they have those created for this you wouldn't necessarily want to fund 100 percent because 40 percent of that is this implied subsidy which isn't something that you are technically paying out of currently our district only does pay-as-you-go method so we don't have any offsetting asset in 2018 the district did however create section 115 trust fund dedicated to pre funding the oak of liability essentially what it is is you're able to put your money into this trust and you're able to get better interest rate returns versus the district being able to invest our money not being restricted so the idea is you're earning interest in this trust that's going to help you build up that reserve to pay for these future obligations that you know that you have the nice part about these is you can get the money back so if we were to for example put fifty thousand into the trash if we spent twenty five thousand this year we'd be able to take twenty five thousand out of the trust or take twenty five thousand from the trust to pay towards the liability so on an annual basis if you have money sitting in that trust it will reduce this long-term net liability so this is something that we recommend the district start to fund next slide so the current Pedro method we have seven retired employees that do utilize the CalPERS medical we pay about twenty three thousand dollars per year and so the easiest way to go to start funding this would be a matching program that way you know we're paying 23,000 to the employees were paying 23,000 to the trust fund if the district ever got in a financial pinch and we needed some it we needed that yours money back we'd be able to easily submit a reimbursement for that amount of money and just to kind of put things in perspective if we were to sit here and put away 23 K at 5% the rate of return over 10 years would be about a 300 K balance so that would be covering about half of the cash liability so we could take a pause if there's board members or the public that have questions about up EV I'll leave it up to the chair for if we want to address questions right now for this specific OCAD portion or if we wanted to take all questions at the end well I think I'd like to take the questions at the unit I'd like to to not try to do a deep dive on this tonight I mean this is a lot of material that you put together and provided us with and I don't know if if any of the directors or even the public has had an opportunity to go through it in as much detail with respect to all of the outstanding liabilities or unfunded liabilities that are represented I would I would suggest them that we continue to go ahead and deal with questions at the end of the presentation sounds good and just to preface it for everyone like Rick said is specifically for this we're not looking for the board to take any action on the employee liabilities we wanted to get the information out there I'm assuming this will be going back to committee for actual recommendations at a later time to come back to the full board right I think it up there was was what was critical and I think you did a great job on that thank you okay so being we can go to the next slide that should try the next one one more there we go it's a little cutoff on here but in the package should be legible so now we'll go over the district's pension plan so most state and local retirement plans have a defined benefit plan which provides employees specific pension payments our pension system is through CalPERS we sit in their miscellaneous risk pool which simply means that we sit in a pool of money with a bunch of other agencies so it's a shared pool we kind of already went over the classic and pepra it shows that we have 16 active employees that are classic members 19 active employees that are pepra there's 27 employees retired that were classic and then that are pepra it shows what the employer and the employee contribution percentages are and the last line is the unfunded accrued liability from the actuarial report from June 30th 2018 so that is the more I put the most recent one that we have from that so this will be integrated in the next year's audit so the classic is sitting at 4.3 and the pepper is sitting at 38,000 the next slide I'll kind will start to explore why there's such a difference between the two okay next slide the brief pension history in the 1990s pension funds were over funded in 1999 Senate bill 400 granted billions of dollars in retroactive increases the pension benefits so everyone was sitting pretty with the dot-com boom and shortly after they pushed this legislative through it crashed so now the funds went from being over funded underfunded as it was starting to recover the 2008 stock market crash happened and things just got worse pepra went into effect January 1st 2013 so that was a pension reform act essentially pension funds would have I don't I probably would have gone completely under some sort of Reform Act didn't happened to get things level loaded again so this January occurred January 1st 2013 and it had a much different retirement age different things to have it is a less favorable package to employees versus the the classic members but it's what was needed to be able to help get pensions as a hold back to being in a little bit better state more recently CalPERS has continued to make more changes and some of their different assumptions and practices such as lowering the discount rate changing some of the years in their analyzation so anytime they do certain you know they do some of these there's a reaction so whenever they lower the discount rate everyone's liability goes up and so that's kind of pension funds we're doing good certain things happen and then not when it's kind of created the situation that most agencies are did now the next slide so this is a CalPERS chart and it's just kind of showing their historical funded status they have some of the key markers showing major things that happened and it just kind of helps show when it was over funded some of the different changes and stuff that happened where it's swung the opposite direction to where it is in such an unfunded state it has slowly started to recover but it obviously still is a long road ahead for not just CalPERS but pretty much all pension plans next slide some of the major changes that CalPERS made is their shortening the amortization period from 30 years to 20 years most of us can understand that relating to a home mortgage so instead of them advertising what we over 30 it's now over 20 they are also doing level dollar payments for the unfunded liability so agencies will have a higher initial payment but overall it'll reduce the interest cost and eliminate negative amortization potential and then they're eliminating some of their rate smoothing and ramp up and ramp downs that they used to do so whenever they would make certain assumption changes they would do a five-year rate smoothing which means you're impacted by it for many years so they've changed some of those different assumptions and all of these will start to show up in this next year's actuarial point next slide what is our district done in 2016 the district did a fresh start with CalPERS to amortize our then unfunded liability instead of being over 30 years over 15 and this saved our district well it's saving about eight hundred thousand dollars in interest expense the district also does the lump sum prepayment option each year we make the payment in July about every year and it's about three hundred thousand dollars where we have the option to prepay it instead of evenly over the next 12 months and it saves us about ten thousand dollars each year little footnote the district has multiple options to continue to lower the you al not only is there the unfunded balance we're charged 7% interest on it all from CalPERS next slide some of the options the district has to be able to do is to make additional one-time payment this gives the district the most freedom without being locked in for an example if the district chose to make fifty thousand payments each year over the next five years that would reduce our unfunded liability and it would save the district about six hundred thousand dollars in interest over a 20-year amortization period there's always the option to regress shorter and amortization periods similar to the Fresh Start that we did before you're locked in is the only downside in that and with CalPERS switching from the thirty down to the twenty essentially they're doing part of that work for us as well and then similar to the up EV the district could create a section 115 trust for pension fund it would work the same way you could earn interest on it it's nice that it stays being the district's money but it doesn't do anything as of right now for chipping away at the larger balance so this is something that would be good down the road for the district and then the last item some agencies go and take out a pension obligation bond to pay down their unfunded liability [Music] essentially you're taking on one debt to pay off another debt and you're just trying to hedge a better interest rate it's actually not recommended by the GSO a kind of for those reasons you'll see districts that are in a dire situation that may be forced to do something like that but it definitely would be more mean the district has better options than something like that next fine to summarize so having to show the future obligations is relatively new in the last couple years to all public agencies balance sheets so we're not alone the vast majority of agencies have a large liability that showed up on their balance sheet in these last couple years we will likely always have some liability on the books for example the implied subsidy portion from the OPA and then any changes in the market you know you could be up a little down a little one year we're not alone mostly all agencies are carrying these unfunded liabilities since everyone was impacted by more unfavorable market history in these last you know 20 years this isn't unique to CalPERS there's Cal stars there's been there's other nationwide pension plans that are all in a similar situation what's important is that agencies don't ignore it there are proactive ways to reduce the unfunded liability which benefits the fund overall and directly benefits our district by being able to reduce that 7% interest that were being charged next slide final thoughts it's obviously not a quick it's not a quick process it's going to take years of thought-out planning to gradually reduce the district's UAL planning and dedicating funds now we'll slowly start to help the district's financial future that ends my presentation and like I said is this was just more so getting the information out there making it so the board and the public can understand that unfunded employee benefit liabilities a little bit better and I'm assuming you know once we start up the committee's again this is something that we can go back to the committee level on and if the district or the committee wants to recommend something to the board we can always bring that back this is the type of thing that we can do an X budget amendment later on in the year if that's the route that the committee wants to go hey Thank You Stephanie correct did you want to go into the the tank aspects of the the tanks and infrastructure for unfunded liabilities work shall we take a pause and see if we have any questions for Stephanie on the with respect to the pension liabilities etc yeah we can we can go ahead and take questions on that you know the the water tank unfunded liability this is just the start of you know several sections in the operational end that the director operation has started to put together there's a lot more work to be done we wanted to bring what we had and start you know rolling it out to the board if you want to go ahead and take Stephanie's questions first and we do have the Director of Operations they can talk about the water tank unfunded liability right thank you yes so once again so I want to remind the other board members this is not a deep dive and any of this stuff right now so if you got questions make them pertinent and make them limited to the presentation and or any specific questions that you might have but we're not going to we're not going to drain this material it's it's well happy that we've got it and I think it needs a lot of time to review it and and digest before we're too - able to dive into it more greater detail but are there any comments or questions by any of the directors at this time first up I have some questions gorilla has blue Stephanie I have three questions for you if I may first of all do you know why or what the justification was for it percent bill 400 I was not even of age to vote I have I mean it was so I I mean it's hard for me to say like what I don't know what the political atmosphere was back then it was open my understanding from what I've read is it was over funded and everyone was floating on this dot-com bubble thinking that hey what a great way to give it back I know that the union's back then were pushing for that as well and that's all some of the stuff that went into pushing Senate bill 400 back there pushing it through back in the late 1990s okay thank you question number two the total liability for the unfunded liability is stands at just under five million dollars currently and I'm not a financial person so I'm gonna I'm gonna rephrase it and something that I can understand it sounds like back in two thousand 2017 CalPERS sent us a bill for five million dollars because of their monumental boneheaded decision to lower their projections is that right no it has nothing to do with CalPERS it was actually governmental Accounting Standards that required you never had to show what that future obligation that future cumulative obligation is on your books so it was accounting standards that changed that then said no you guys should be having to show this future liability on your book now so that was accounting changes to where everyone had these before that they've had them for years and years it just required us to put them onto our balance sheet that way and then shortly after that the Gatsby 75 which was the OBE came on he required us to put it on the books as well so I had nothing to do with CalPERS sending us a bill people could all you could always see what the actually what the liability was you know they put out these actuarial reports annually so the district had an unfunded liability for decades well now decades so it's accounting pronouncements not Cowper sending us a bill but we were paying on roughly 10% into the retirement fund for all employees going way back correct correct top of that we now oh you can call it an accounting change but to me it's a real bill that that's five million dollars above and beyond the ten percent that we're sending in every month for all of our employers going back here correct so essentially it's sitting here and it's taking the contributions that you're making now losses assumptions all these different things and projecting out over the next 20-30 years for what it is you're gonna have to be paying out and it's a difference between the press the difference between the projected assets and the projected liability that you're going to have well as I guess my point is I think somebody did a really bad job of trying to project you know what the actual cost of retirement was going to be because this unfunded liability just keeps going up enough so my final question is this what is the chance that we're going to have another round of unfunded liability it is that we're going to be you know we're required to pay down Agathe so that's why pepra that's why the 2013 pepra Pension Reform Act happened to stop these classic plan that were essentially paying out more than what the funds were realistically able to out earn an interest revenue so that's part of why you know when you look at the classic plan it's four point something million in that plan versus the pepra plan is only unfunded by about $38,000 so that Pension Reform Act kind of is partially to undo kind of what happened back with SB 400 to reset the pension plans so that they can still be viable so as the classic members retire out and more people are on pepra it will start to get a little bit more improved but I mean you're gonna have things like market volatility that are gonna always weigh in on that you know it's no different than people's private 401ks or different stuff like that I mean those were shed majorly as well in in you know these different crashes you talk about market volatility but the assumption that I see on that chart is that they're still assuming a return rate of 7% on their investments and I don't know anybody that's getting 7% today so why did it why it so it that tells me that down the road there's going to be another delta of unfunded liability added on because the difference between 7% and what people really are getting today which is you know today is something in the negative reason I mean it they'd have been lowering the discount rate they do it gradually they don't just do it you know they don't just go from eight and a half to seven it has been gradually getting lowered I believe they are talking about continuing to lower it which in turn is going to turn around and make our projected unfunded liability look worse [Music] till the the gradual lowering with the first time it was a half a percent and that was a quarter of a percent and then it's a half a percent we're still nowhere near reality in my mind assuming a return of 7% on in today's market I mean it's unfortunately all stepped-up you know we don't have control over this is the CalPERS people that manage the program right that set these values correct correct yeah any other questions many board member uh I see your blue hand up yeah thanks and 70 thanks for putting this together it's really good background information I'm looking forward to talking about in more detail in the budget committee just to follow up on on Lou's question but what is the 15 or 20 year return on investment that CalPERS is is getting that is sort of a long-term return on investment I don't think it's 7% but I I'm not sure what it is if it is ballpark its it is right around there I don't have it in front of me but over there long term and I mean and I guess that's the thing that they always you know these are long-term investments so while it may not be right now you know a couple you know over the last couple years I mean they actually had they were surpassing their the 7% I want to say this last year they reported it was six point eight that they got closing out I believe 2019 but long-term you know when you look at the long term of it it is roughly around me that motors done well I I mean I guess if you were to go back to the raging bull markets in the 80s and 90s perhaps but over the last 20 years I mean if it was only six point eight percent last year which was a pretty raging market I'm I'm concerned that even seven is is way too high and that this is something we're going to talk about in Budget Committee is what number we should be targeting at as a district I think in order to make sure that we're keeping our promises to our to our retired employees thanks Bob any other comments or questions from any board members no not for me thank you okay to the public then do you have any questions or comments about this aspect of the unfunded liability discussion three-two-one no okay Luther on Rick James president one this is District Council I see a few hands up in the attendee column yes oh I'm sorry okay who do we have in the attending okay so I study the names now we've got well at the top of my list is Larry Ford so Larry will recognize you for three minutes okay thank you this is Larry Ford I'm I'm wondering what has the staff been planning to do about these unfunded liabilities I mean it's it's not anything new you've been thinking about it and related to that I'm wondering what opportunities are there for grants from outside sources like government agencies and foundations and that sort of thing and then what opportunities are there to request maybe you know with a bunch of other water districts to have some kind of subsidy from the state or federal government and if there were some grant or subsidies available what is staff doing to prepare for getting some of those grants thank you um so similar to how it's you can't just go out and borrow money to pay this off I don't believe that there I am not aware of there ever being discussions of grants or subsidies from the government to pay off the pension liabilities the state does have a lot of their own if you look at the slide back in 2017 the state did take in a large six billion from the state to pay down the state's unfunded liability and so what that does is I mean if all agencies start to chip away at it I mean you put money in the stock market smartly you know the idea is that you'd be earning more money off of the returned you know we'd be getting a higher return so that's where the discussion kind of starts to come in I don't foresee there being any you know bailout type of thing where we'd be able to get grant money or money from the state for stuff like that but this is where the district you know we make we did the Fresh Start in 2016 and the district can make these one-time payments to slowly chip away at our district's unfunded liability and save that 7% each year on that you know that's where the example goes where I mean if we smartly choose to dedicate a plan towards this you know five one-time fifty thousand payments over the next five years save six hundred grand over a twenty year period that number can continue to grow if we end up having years where we have surplus money this is a good option for where some of it could be spent I mean obviously the district has other you know deferred maintenance and other capital projects that I should go towards but it would be smart to start to have a plan go towards me Thank You Stephanie next where they end up is looks like Gail mud [Music] you and we unmute Gail can you hear me now yes okay thank you Stephanie that was an excellent report even I could understand it even though I don't know much about finance I just want to sort of follow up on what you seem to be implying at the end of your response to Larry and if I understand it then we've established this 115 trust to pay down the unfunded liabilities for the medical benefits but so far we've not allocated any money for it and then the second part of my question is it also sounds like we've not budgeted this year or at any other time for these sort of one-time $50,000 payments to kind of the other part of the unfunded liabilities is that is that my understanding this correctly yes that's correct so one of the things that we were wanting to do with this budget process if we had it slated that we were gonna be talking about these unfunded employee benefit liabilities at the Budget and Finance Committee to hopefully get some money allocated during this budget given everything you know that kameez have been has been canceled I'm hoping that we can start it up again and then if that is the direction that the committee wants to go the board could vote to choose to allocate funds to some of these okay and if director Swann will just indulge me for a second more I guess I would like to jump off from that and advocate that I think we should restart the committee meetings I just I just think that the budget committee is gonna have a lot of things to do this year because of both the potential budget issues that might come if we have a recession and a lot of people who can't pay their bills but also to deal with this question I think engineering has some things that has to be done so I would encourage us to go back and do those meetings I think the especially the Finance Committee the the more people that are thinking about this probably the better thank you Thank You Gail and the last blue hand iced tea belongs to Beth Thomas yes you are recognized hi thank you it was a great presentation stephanie has a really complicated subject and I've had a lot of familiarity with CalPERS and with pepra in my work previously and I wanted to just say I happen to know that you're right I think CalPERS was estimating six point seven return on investment for 2018-19 and over 30 years they actually have had an eight point one percent return on investment and and I think pepper was important because and I was involved in the management of a large Union staff at the time employees really took on some of that debt burden in addition to what they were already paying the other thing that's interesting and I'm curious to know what happened in the water district during the 90s one of the one of the problems one of the practices that helped create this problem is that there were employer pension holidays because the because the because the pension was you know at a hundred and twenty-eight percent funding they gave a lot of employers pension holidays which means that while the employees were still paying for their percentage towards their retirement that the employers were not and I'm wondering if the water district if you know what the water districts practice was during that time and why maybe that's part of why the unfunded liability is also so hi that's an easy one I do not know what the district it back in our nineties okay were you born in the know now okay well that is that did contribute I think also that SB 400 which was CalPERS legislation actually also created some additional problems because they started funding some categories like police and fire got funded at three percent at fifty you know so a lot of that's been improved through pepra and hopefully it will continue that way but I think it's true that we're gonna see an even more difficult situation for the next foreseeable future given our current situation all right thank you thank you Beth any other questions or comments from anybody the public No okay now moving on 1 2 3 3 2 1 let's go into now was there was there an overview Rick that that James wanted to do with respect to the tank maintenance stuff that with the spreadsheets that he started or that we have so far any kind of [Music] comments are overview that you want to make James I have to unmute there yeah I'll let Jenna the Director of Operations give you an overview and discuss a little more of what you put together here James okay so this is very rough it's a start now you'll see in the estimated cost of painting and coding for the 14 welded steel tanks the costs are very similar all the way throughout I did get some costs from some neighboring districts that have done recent tank paintings and coatings um the difference is is that we don't know what is in our paintings of coding so that has a lot to do with the cost say if there's lead in the outside paint of the tank on the cost can go up a lot more for encapsulating or having to tent the whole project at sandblast so it's very hard to predict without having each one of these thoroughly gone through from a painting and coding specialist that has not been done another thing you'll see is that most of these tanks have not been coded since the installed installation here this has a lot to do with the deferred maintenance and the no money to do so I'm being told not to do so throughout all the years a lot of our tanks are I mean and it could a situation where when we do go to do these there will also need to be steel repairs done to some of these tanks before the paintings and coatings happen so they all have to some of the tanks are so pitted and worn at this point that now they're gonna have to go in and cut out sections and weld new steel in and whatever whatnot make repairs and some of the roofs and that kind of thing so that's gonna inflate the cost also more and that's another thing I mean you can't estimate that we don't know what the cost of that is until we're getting work it's looked at by a specialist and that has not been done now Blair tank and Brookdale tank we're on the little in the budget to be painted and recoated this year um we have no working on the RFP but it's been very difficult well we this is our first time doing so so we're trying to get an outline we're working with by pulling other districts cost and how they and their rfp's together and pulling them apart and trying to put our own together um it looks like that we put this back in the budget for the next fiscal year to actually get the paintings and coatings done as we're hoping to have the RFP done soon so this will be those are pushed back to next year and as I said in my operations department think that I did in March presentation that I did in March these I want to do two tanks a year I would like to see us do two takes a year for the next eight years and that would get us through all of our tanks and then I'm also looking into a maintenance program and so with the maintenance program after they're painted and coded if you go on a maintenance program the cost of the painting and coating is spread out through those next 15 to 20 years and you're not just paying out one lump sum after 15 to 20 years and during those 15 and 20 years they're coming out and touching up or making sure that these tanks are not in such bad shape that we have to do repairs again the next time we do pains and coating and the life of a steel tank is forever as long as they're maintained painted the code and kept up they will last forever oh I'll move down to alright let me take some questions if anybody has questions on the welded steel I was just wondering how long does it take to do an inspection and then how long does it take to do painting and coating the diving diving and cleaning inspections take about four to six hours per tank depending on the size of the tank we have one tank like our lion water treatment our lion tank the three million gallon one that actually takes almost eight hours it takes almost a full day to do that one tank because it's so large but they take about four to six hours normally per tank and I have a question to everybody at once and I can't hear ya just to finish off my second part of my question was painting and coding how long does that typically take start to finish paint coating to take up to two weeks okay right interject in here to on on the paintings and coatings on a couple these tanks one of the big concerns on the single tanks is that we have to keep customers in water and there's quite a bit of prep and work begun to move storage around and to continue keeping folks in water the the brookdale tank for one is a major hub and it'll be a significant project to keep folks in water while you're paying doing these painting encoders it's is that included in the cost that's referenced here as far as the two hundred to five hundred thousand dollars for painting and coating I don't think so that'll be done in-house that'll be a staff staff project but we are doing the inspections and cleaning paintings and coatings are different keep in mind we are on schedule with with underwater with wet inspections and vacuuming you know selten and and rust or whatever deposits out of the text that's any correct or wrong tape that is up to up to on schedule or those dates are also in this spreadsheet on the date of last inspection and we have had repairs done to some tanks underwater repairs to some of the coatings inside we have done touch-up painting to outside of some of the taste but it's not some of these tanks are and in the inspections are said with some of the pitting and deposits that are not on there they're gonna need repair okay and it's time to get on top when I actually Rick was first and then you Louis okay I don't know how to cut a deal with her - Louis go ahead laws you don't want it I have a simple question I see that big steel is 80 years old and you're saying it's gonna live forever yes definitely yes as long as that tank we continue to maintain that tank it will live forever Wow and there can always be I mean if it needs repairs we go and do repairs they can do steel repairs on steel tanks so the whole tank isn't just you know destroyed there'll be parts and pieces that are destroyed that'll be repaired and big steel has been modified and upgraded through the years we put when we first had big steel we bought it used some Lockheed it didn't have a roof on it we came in put a roof on it it has had paintings and coatings and then we came back and put stairs on I mean big steel has been maintaining it so it's a big over a million gallons thank you okay Rick okay uh thank you James I just want to echo some of what James said um I worked as a house painter for more years than I'd like to think and planned maintenance is what keeps costs down and to the degree that we're doing that and I hear that Rick is there is a schedule for periodic inspection that's the whole key is staying ahead of any major repairs so I'm glad to see that we're focused on this and it definitely needs to be a part of planned maintenance okay thank you Bob you have a question or comment you did you hang up you're still muted Bob yeah sorry my internet connection is a little unstable right now and am i coming through clearly enough yes yes Steve can you hear me yes hope we can hear you [Music] okay well buzzy see it hello hello yeah so sorry about that guys my internet connection went a little little Wiggy so am i coming through okay now yes great but James thanks very much for putting this together I know this represents a culmination of a lot of effort in your part and I think it's really great that were starting to really understand where we stand with tanks a lot of this tank maintenance is is way over way overdue for sure and your advocacy of making sure we take care of this is really appreciated I had one question about the inspections that are done are those inspections which I see that we've kept up on do those inspections include an examination of whether or not repairs are needed and where those repairs are needed in the tanks yes in doing like I said they we have done repairs like recently we did some repairs in Brookdale tank to the coatings and the outside paint and they do tell us they give us a very detailed dive video with audio and they point things out and all that and show us where the pitting is and whatever whatnot and we definitely try to combat it but it's not without doing the full painting and coating it's not combative a whole situation no perfectly understood thank you for that that's great information okay do we have any questions from the public for [Music] blue oh good blue I have two questions for James if I made sure career games looking at your list if I take the average estimated cost I come up with a figure of around ten million dollars and that's that obviously up a floor not a ceiling but does that sound about right dear [Music] actually I came up with I actually went through and did estimated totals for the whole total at the bottom of my spreadsheet it's not on the spreadsheet that I delivered and it came out to about 3.5 to 4.8 million is what I got well that's even better my second question is since what we loo-loo on somebody yes you're right because that's you're talking about the total over everything yep I am yeah okay yeah you're right but I'm just the welded steel would be three point five to four point eight million okay my second question is actually for all types of Tanks and that is if we if we find out when we do the inspection that there is repairs required and not just painting and coating if we get to a certain level of repairs I would assume that it would make more sense to replace than to repair and if that's true is there any thought given to if we have to replace the tank upsizing it I don't think that any of these tanks are so bad that it would be need to be fully replaced besides maybe one and that would be the Bear Creek Estates tank the 75,000 gallon one and that would also be a place to put a bigger tank if we ended up doing something like that but all these other tanks I mean I don't think it's bad enough to where we'd have to replace them I think repair and to go in do the repairs and paint and code them and then put them on a maintenance schedule that it's gonna be the cheapest cost to the district I'm gonna give if I can see if I can interject into Lou's question anytime Lou and for the full board they replace a mainline tank a pump is looked at for today's standards in the pump for flows fire flow storage we to upgrade and we upgrade wherever we can and wherever we have room but a good example is the Redwood Park tank the swim tank the new site is allowing us to put the state standard fire flow of 125,000 gallon tank in we always look at it and once the master plan is done we'll be able to run that much much quicker and I'm fundamentally we'll be able to run each one of those zones and do flow tests and so forth so the answered question we always look to upgrade one possible Thank You Lou do we have any questions from the public you okay the first I see is EJ Armstrong if we'll take EJ off there we go you and someone take him off me there we go how about right now there we go so far so good yes thank you for this presentation I really am interested in the tank issues having been involved in a number of issues involving tanks over the years my question is regarding thermal imagery has there been any attempt to do thermal imagery around the exterior surface of the tanks because not that can tell you a lot about what's going on with the steel good to know there has not you know the Fluke industries has some technology available to do that is very sophisticated and can really give a good analysis of the characteristics of the steel and indicate the points of failure and that could be costed out well in advance that's my question my hello thank you we will look into that great Thank You mr. Armstrong next mark Lee Martin let's take mark off mute you still owe me more or you're still on mute mark there there you go okay Arisa I appreciate the presentation on the capital facilities maintenance program Montagnes and I'm glad that they're keeping cost contained where needed and where it's advisable to spend money that approach its incremental other methods for looking at cost steel deformation or leakages through x-ray technology also used in the industry so they've been able to be something to look at but I think the Fluke industry model is excellent because it does look it does use photographic imagery based on heat sensing in various dimensions of the metal from the hole from various angles of the tank so used in metallurgy actually developed in the aerospace industry or weld certification anyway appreciate it I'm glad it's not ten million per year murder versus three million over the over the lifestyle life cycle of our existing tank inventory you're me yep thank you Mark yeah appreciate your input anybody else and the public have a question or comment for James no okay we served we took that pause James was there more you wanted to address yes so I wanted to go down to I want to go to the bottom of the spreadsheet now to go to the bolted steel tanks and talk just a little bit about these most of these are not that old obviously we'd have the spring tank that's kind of an old one but we don't have the data the Charlie tank and it's kind of an older one too but the other three are fairly fairly new um I'm not quite sure of the understanding on the painting and coatings on these yet what we have done though with the molten steel tank that we had at blue tank it was deemed failed I had a buckle in it from an earthquake in 89 and so when we what we did was a refurbish and replace and this on these bolts of steel tanks seems to be a lot cheaper than going with paintings and coatings to do a refurbish or replace the cost is not significant it cost us right around $250,000 we use the existing add we didn't have the new pad in we just haven't put some new pegs in around the pad to make it worth quake strength or up to standard but these are these have been a good thing for us these both the steel tanks and need a change in getting those inspected and the essent cost of inspections about the same and that's when we estimate that at a total of 1.3 if we have to refurbish a replace and then I will touch on the Redwood tanks obviously most of our redwood tapes now are in process of being replaced with six tanks that are going in out in one picot and then the swim tanks being changed to the Redwood Park tank site will eliminate those two as well and the Felton Heights tank is also in the process with the easements of stuff to be replaced as well the other that we have on there that are not in process they're technically in process because they're redwood tanks and they're noted to be taken out of our system but no plant suspects have been done on any of those other five tanks and the echo tanks are all at one site so that's why the cost of that is kind of it seems like replacing three tanks to cost more but it's one side it would end up being one or two redundant tanks to at the same site or a different site so that's where I came up with that constant these are just estimated costs that I came up the the felt Knights tank that's just in the process of being replaced is it being replaced with a significantly larger tank yes that tank is being replaced I do believe with a it'll be it'll be sized for that area 125,000 gallon tank to have fire flow and so forth oh it's a tank or any type of facility we try to bring it up to the engineering standards of today country and we're and that's another one that we don't have the the room at the existing site so we're just finishing up negotiating with a different property owner or a large enough site that's why that one is taking so long to do and we'll be coming to the board with a proposal in the next month to move ahead on that project and that tank is also funded from the lost acres community where he took over that community there's a payment that they will have to start making once we start making progress on that project that's partially person small part small part much of its funded but I know someone who's funded 75 grand that had been installed a few years ago would have been mostly funded there we go so that's my presentation on my spreadsheet and like I said it's very rough spreadsheet there's a lot of work to do still and we will keep adding to this there's a whole there's also three concrete tanks that I don't have on here and there's so multiple politics that I don't have on here poly tanks don't take much for maintenance besides inspection and cleaning um the big thing is is will say if they get hit a weathering lifespan they start to maybe crack or something like that that's the expected and to replace a poly tank is not a significant cost okay thank you James appreciated work James any any questions from any of the directors for your James on the this particular subject I got one go ahead Rick uh so James a few meetings ago you put up for bid some of those prep redwood salvaged redwood from one of the tanks did you ever did we ever get a sale on that or what happened there so what happened there is I had my whole big pack and everything all ready to go out and then we hit this covin thing and then they have to come out and look at it and stuff and it's behind locked gates of stuff well we didn't want we were told not to interact in public not to interact things so I asked the district manager if I should be moving ahead with that and we came to the conclusion that we shouldn't move ahead with that until this orders lift yes okay thank you great thank you Rick okay any uh any questions from the public and I see again from April April zilbert okay I hope I'm unmuted now you are April that was a very interesting presentation and I just have a question as a person who's kind of clueless about this when you need to replace a redwood tank do you replace it with a different material such as steel yes the majority time they replaced with steel we have replaced some of the redwood tapes with Polly tanks for because of difficult access or no project ready to go when the tank failed so we go in and there's some of these sites that have poly tanks or just temporarily put poly tanks in there when we took down the Redwood tanks that fail thank you that answers my question Thank You April I see Mark Lee go ahead mark yes following up on our discussion on maintenance on the tanks the larger capital that the projects are still it's a dynamic still and it's not set in stone we're still working on defying details on deadlines and budgets correct this is still evolving do you hear me I don't know if I have answer for that I would say yes to that question mark we are still James in the engineering department are still putting together the spec on on paintings and coatings we are incorporating a lot of inspection into the new painting coding specs pane coatings have changed a lot over the years especially with LED paints and so forth and the new coatings so that's what slow this process down this year is putting together that that new spec so and so we am we still have further chances down the road to comment as the public and rate payers here to look at the evolving maintenance deferred maintenance on those longer on the total tank population for the district correct you should be yeah the engineering committee would reviews specifications and and contracts and projects that would be done in the engineering committee okay thank you thank you mark any other questions from anyone in the public you need directors last shot three two one moving on okay Rick back to you for our next agenda item you muted ah there we go and you hear me now okay this will be item 5b the low income rate Assistance Program it's recommended to the board receive the information and we'll have a presentation by staff this is meant to be a guided discussion to help you present different options depending on the discussion the board may direct staff to proceed with developing a program of public water agencies rate revenues are subject to restrictions under proposition 218 and 26 that essentially prohibit utilizing those revenues to subside a rate assistance program the district has discussed using non rate revenues or a donation program to potentially fund a low income rate assistance like a Laura alehrer program the presentation will hopefully guide discussion around the most feasible option for our district at the April 16 2020 board directors meeting a local group calling itself friends of the SMB water submitted a proposal for board review and it's catched in your packet and at the April 16 2020 meeting and the board directed staff to bring the subject back to a special meeting for Duta for further discussion with that the Finance Manager will have a PowerPoint and we'll take that I'm Stephanie okay everyone hear me yep okay um so low income rated business program go to the next point so essentially we need to figure out what is the district's ultimate goal personally when we're talking about developing a plan like this I like to think about the viability of the plan but something like you know is something like this a plan if the district wants to have four years to come obviously pros and cons to everything so first idea is to create a long term program to give discount on bills monthly you know just for a monthly discount on a bill it would like me to be an internal ear and program is the plan to create a one-time relief for customers in need this could be an internal or an external ear and program do we want to create a temporary pilot program for the more immediate future until ad 401 is formulated and then if there's any other reasons that board members can think of that that may fit into that next slide he's going to run this program so depending on the type of program we pick is gonna start to point us in the direction of if you think it's going to be an internally staff ran program or an external [Music] internal there'll be different options constraints and cost that we can have if it's ran externally through a third party like a 501c3 that we partner up with some of the questions we weigh map may want to ask ourselves is how much controller input would we have in that situation and how important is that to the district this would obviously have a lesser impact on staff if customers are directed to go to a third party to get to get something so one of the things we'll want to weigh is pros and cons for an internally ran program versus an external ear and program next slide how is it going to be funded is it going to be district funded through non water rate revenues the district does have property taxes mobile lease revenue that would not have some of the same restrictions as our water rate revenue is the district's funding through customer donations to the district or a combination of the district could do their own donations as well is a district partnering with a third party for them to receive the donation and again similar situation to weigh the pros and cons of that one of the pros for if it was a 501c3 company is it would be able to be a tax-deductible donation versus if the district were to be the ones accepting donations it would not be and then some of the other pros and cons in this situation would be if it's a set amount versus an unknown so if the district were to be donating a fixed amount through some of our non water rate revenues we'd be able to set the actual dollar amount versus if it ran purely off of donation that can also get complicated because what if you don't have enough donations one month or one year and next time I asked Gina to put together a slide explaining ad 401 8401 was adopted in 2015 and required the State Water Resources Control Board to take the lead in developing lehre plan by 2018 they finally released the report just a couple months ago in 2020 she lists out some of the different highlights you know they acknowledge that local agencies are gonna have a hard time coming up with money on their own due to prop 218 and 26 constraint and they were reckless SWR CB was recommending that it be a statewide program recommend the 200% poverty level similar to what PG&E care program bases their stuff on discusses direct water bill credit renters water credit and crisis assistance recommends using state income tax and taxes on bottled water for funding the next step is for legislature to consider the recommendation since it involves creation of new fees it will take a two-thirds legislation legislative approval vote if it gets immediate traction maybe beginning as early as 2021 so and I mean that you know from a conversation Jean and I had that's been accelerated given the Cova pandemic we think that there may be a chance that they do look to accelerate this but either way we are talking about a year plus out and so that's kind of where my one of my previous slides is saying do we want to set something in stone now do you want to do a program with a B 401 coming down the pipeline it may be soon to where we are hold essentially what it is that we have to do we just don't know quite yet next slide and this is some of the things that I think will want to keep discussing I'm assuming this is going to be going to a committee as well internally ran program thoughts how much money each year fixed versus variable if it is a fixed amount that'll help us set the number of applicants allowed if funding is reduced how do you reduce the applicants enrolled what will it take to run the program internally probably a pretty high volume the first year as far as setting up an actual discount on a customer's bill for a monthly program that's relatively easy for us to do then there'd be ongoing annual renewals we strongly suggest that we piggyback off of the PG&E care program it is what a lot of other agencies do as well but overall well thought-out policy needs to be developed and then other smaller things by how have we do we want to advertise the program you know that again can be a discussion for for down the road for depending on what the board decides next slide stop on third party ran program it would like me needs to be a one-time relief it'd be pretty difficult to operate with a third party to get monthly bill discounts going it could run purely from customer donations it could be a combination of customer donations and district donations and then you run into the how important is program oversight by the district you know some of these places partner with you know United Way or different things like that and I kind of wonder what type of control they have my guess is you don't have a whole lot of control other than than partnering with them and being able to help designate unto them thirds like I said before a third pretty benefit it does encourage you know the tax deductible aspect of it nextslide what are other agencies doing Lyra programs or some sort of discounted rate programs it's most commonly found in cities and counties the majority of public water agencies such as ours you don't have mirror programs in place but some certainly do a lot of this all goes around that whole we can't use our water sewer rate revenue it would have to be an on rate revenue we do have some of those options other agencies may not which is why it's not as as common below are four examples of agency [Music] the Calaveras County Water has about 13,000 water customers their program allows 200 in the program with a $20 discount on their bimonthly bill so their program cost them about twenty four thousand dollars per year they keep it high level just stating that it's funded by non rate revenue Katella Valley has a hundred and nine thousand customers they administer it through a third party through donations and some funding from the district theirs is a one hundred dollar credit once per year option El Dorado Irrigation has about 41,000 customers their program is for sewer only they allow up to 1500 in the program with a twenty five dollar discount on a bi-monthly bill so that's a two hundred and twenty five thousand dollar program and from what I read they mapped out within a few months at their number of applicants also there's funded by non rate revenue as Valley recently started their pilot program they give a 30 percent discount on the basic meter fee and charge the flat near one rate to residential customers so a person using six thousand or less gallons of water they'd be getting about a $23 and forty two cent discount on their bimonthly bill they state that theirs is funded by their property tax revenue and when I spoke with them within the last couple weeks they had only four customers enrolled they do have it posted on their website but they don't proactively you know advertise it last slide so any final comment you know based on this discussion [Music] I'm assuming this is going to be going back to a committee I believe we have been discussing starting to MIDI them in June again but this kind of at least opens up the conversation for the board to discuss some of the different avenues that they think would be most feasible for our district Thank You Stephanie very well done okay any questions or comments or thoughts on the subject from the board members first Lu okay first of all I'd like to thank Stephanie and the Friends of s will be water as well as other ratepayers that have made their comments known about the subject on the the SOL vwd website it's been really helpful at least for me I support a Lyra program particularly a named one with a modest start and one that is legally viable and helps most deserving ratepayers but after having a discussion with Stephanie about about the financing in the particulars something came to my attention and that is that I was assuming that the property tax revenue we get which is a which is approximately a hundred thousand dollars a year is not a steady flow of Revenue there a few years ago they stopped the contribution for a while I believe it was because of some financial hardships with the library system but the bottom line is that that's not a guaranteed amount of money and given that and this is and since that would be the basic funding source because we can't use rate fare money I would hate to start a program and then have to stop it when we no longer had the property tax revenue so I'm recommending that we basically hit the pause button for six months and hopefully by then we'll be able to determine a clearer picture of our financial future and therefore what we can support in terms of the odd lira program you regula anybody else with the comment yes I do go right ahead Louis thank you saw your virtual blue hand I actually talked to our supervisor about a B 401 and he got back to me and he gave me the name of someone who's supposed to know all the information and he gave me a phone number which of course didn't work and so I called him back and left a message and today I found a message on my machine from his office and I'm gonna have to call them again because I it was too late to get ahold of anybody when I saw the messy so I'm hoping I can get some answers from the person he's directing me to the other thing is yeah property tax hike with us was on the long people board for a couple of years there we didn't get any property tax because of I have no idea I can't remember the reason I was also thinking maybe we need to do just kind of a test program say okay twenty-five thousand dollars two hundred and eight customers that'd be ten dollars a month or one hundred and twenty dollars for the year and see how that goes just do a test program don't just jump in and I I'm sure I'm not making some people really happy here I'm not against doing something for low income people but I want to do it smartly carefully and this has come up time and time again and there are issues about how it gets funded who gets the money to the rate pairs how much burden on staff it might be or did we go outside it's a big issue and I I would like to see this done I'm supportive but let's be true thanks Louis any other comments questions I mean I'll go oh go ahead thank you Steve so I fully support a program that helps people in need with their water bills and this is a program that is trying to do that so I'm fully supportive of that I want to make sure that the most needy are the ones that are helped and however whatever number of that is that we can afford but it's the most needy not first in line I'm not in favor of first-come first-serve approach to this and if it has to be modified from the care program I mean we've had a couple of issues with PG&E here most recently about their billing of us for the power outages and now with the environmental concerns got the Flyers and now we're going to use PG&E as a model so I'm a little reluctant to do that but I understand you know it's efficiencies perhaps and so one of the things about reaching out to people and it was there was a comment in there is I think this is why I wanted to support the Chatterbox that we just funded last meeting is these are this is what we need to do we need to go out and target the people that are most in need so I believe we can use this outreach component with the Chatterbox I'm in favor of doing this in here it's a first as I have a question that maybe Ricker Stephanie can answer is currently we have no cut-offs of water because of not paying bills so in effect we do have a low income assistance program working right now is cranked up let's go right ok so we can categorize it as that all right so I don't know how long we can continue doing that but as numbers come in that will make it clearer and for an analysis and as far as this you know this the state and you know this is not just a local problem it's a national problem and it's not a total state problem so I would hope that the state has said they're interested in doing this and they need to be pressured into doing this at the fastest pace we can help them do so I would like Lewis's approach to talking with the representative and if we need to do more of that we should do that that's basically where I stand thank you thank you any other thoughts from anybody if not I'll share mine so I I agree with I agree with all of you right now all the other directors that have spoken so far and I think it one of the I mean a low-cost assistants yeah that's that's fine I mean I certainly support that and I'm really curious to see that since the state has gone to the effort of this maybe 401 and it's at the point now where it's it's and maybe two years behind its schedule but at least now we're in a situation where it looks like they might actually do something with it sooner rather than later I would be inclined to let the state who's gonna be doing something with a mandate anyway in forcing us to adhere to it wait and see what they do and and then see what that would impact that's gonna have on us as you pointed out Riggs when we passed the resolution to not turn off anybody's water at the last meeting that pretty much is a little program to some extent so nobody none of the people that were impacted as as low-income or anybody that may have been recently affected by layoffs as a result of the the kovat crisis it doesn't seem like there's anything that we need to jump on immediately or take an immediate action other than what we already did at the last meeting so for that reason alone and the fact that 401 is in process to some extent I'm leaning towards Lou's suggestion let's do nothing for six months and watch it and also during that period will also see what additional impact our community is going to have with the result of delay us because I don't know where it is or how its impacted our 8,000 connections yet and if it's significant impact and that may cause us to rethink exactly what type of program and how we want to put it in place and manage it so those are my thoughts given where we are today with what we know about the the Kovach crisis etc any other comments from any director if not we'll go to the public and let the public comment so for all those 16 attendees we've got the first hand that went up that I saw was Tina too so Tina you are promoted to the top of the list thank you I'm also in support of her lira program I think it's a good idea however I also understand the unfunded liabilities and the other financial issues the district is going through so any lira program I feel like should be done responsibly with like fiscally responsible however I don't think that there should be a cap on like the number of residents that you allow to give applications to because then it does become a first-come first-serve I think that we should definitely target the lower-income individuals and that they will I don't want to say self select but the idea is that you'll you'll end up with a with a cap just based on income alone so I don't think that a cap on the number of applications is a good idea because I think it would exclude people who maybe move into the district who you know aren't familiar with the program the other thing I'd disagree with you about is that I don't think you should take a wait-and-see six month approach I think that the people who maybe can't pay their bill right now when that bill comes due or when you ever you decide that you're gonna start collecting for those then they're not gonna be able to pay it then either it'll could accumulate over months and I feel like if you send out a lifeline to some of these people now versus six months from now you're going to have a better response and I just think that that's it's unfair to wait on six funds for the people that need it now and yeah so that's that's my point okay Thank You Tina next with the comments from Lauren you're the next blue hand I see you Ram or at all it's Lawrence Larry Ford sorry oh okay sorry Here I am yeah I thought maybe there was somebody else there yeah um I want to thank all of you directors and staff we're working on this problem I think it's really it's a really important one and I appreciate that you're even interested just a couple of comments I think it's really important to focus on who really is needy that's come up before but clearly neediness is not is not necessarily limited to what their income level is and so I'm not sure how to resolve that problem but I think that's really what we're looking at is who are the people that are really hurting anyway and then I wanted to reiterate that my suggestion that the district staff focus on what kind of grants they can get they might not be able to get grants for a lyra program but they might be able to get grants for other projects which would offset other costs and make other funds available for things like this the problem that I see is I don't know who your grant writer is now it's a lot of work to do a lot of grant writing but I think that would be something that potentially could be really valuable to the district so but those are my suggestions thank you thank you Larry okay and next up James Mosier can you hear me yes thank you all again I'd like to reiterate what Larry said I really appreciate the board's interest and support for moving forward on this I just want to have I have a few clarifications in terms of the funding it's right that the you do have eight hundred and twenty-five thousand dollars in property tax that can be variable but this program could be funded out of other non operating ribbon and I believe that that won't be a problem long term you may have to move to some of the other account in terms of the delayed cut offs that the interested the that the district has done so far which I support strongly it doesn't really constitute in my mind a Lyra program for this reason you're simply delaying the cut-offs and delaying beneath a bill and at some point the district's going to have to say we've got to pay up and that's when the Lyra program would be kicking in some sort of Lyra program to be helping people it's not just the delay we're talking about it's talking about really helping folks the third thing is I am not at all I've looked at I've read the state report and the the looking at what the state is look thinking about in terms of doing a statewide Lyra program I've talked to our assembly person about it um it needs a two-thirds vote of the legislature this is a major major hurdle for anything getting out of the legislature as you know I don't think we should be waiting to see what the state does I think we should be taking the lead of other local agencies that realize that in the meantime as long as we have the means to do it that we need to be helping people we can anticipate in the next six months a year we're gonna have many rate payers that need this kind of help and I'm very sympathetic to what Rick Moran said about relying for auntie Jeanne for anything but in talking with our the water water board staff and in researching the other programs relying on the care program at PG&E it's a it's a it's a very straightforward thing but PGE does the Stafford determine who is available who's got the whose income matches us it would greatly reduce the staff time needed the Institute a program for us to rely on it if you try to do some other way of determining eligibility the staff class are gonna go way way up and the program you then end up spending a lot of money on staff time rather than on helping people so I those of us who made friends as him learns ovale water after looking at this carefully decided that was really the way to go um and I'm not sure if Cynthia Denzel was gonna be talking I'm not sure if she's on if she is I'm taking she can reinforce what I'm gonna say next which is but she has talked to I think the only 501c3 agency in the valley who I think would be viable for doing this and that's the belly churches United and in fact they have an informal program right now and there have been some donations to them specifically to help folks who were in need of emergency funds to avoid a cut off because of unexpected financial problem but they are have very limited staff they don't want to take on anything major on this it would take some discussion with them but there is there is some hope for that but that for those of us who have looked at this that is just one piece of the puzzle the more important piece is the Lyra program such as the ones that Stephanie described in other districts where there's a there's a discount the same as what PG&E does for low-income people PG&E rates they give a very significant discount and we're hoping that the district can move forward in this it does need a deliberate process I'm glad it can go to committee but I think you need to move on it now I like Lois's idea of a pilot program to get it just to get to figure out how to do it so that when people's needs really come forward in the next six months to a year we have something that's gonna really address this issue thank you thank you any other public comments and James I saw you thank you very much I'm I'm not ignoring you Cynthia Europe how do i James can you hear me now yes I want to thank all of you for your thoughtfulness about this I think all of the concerns raised are really valid and we all share those concerns I feel from talking to Stephanie I'd like to have more information from Stephanie about the need that she observes what the district sees how many people the kinds of issues that need to be addressed among ratepayers and it's difficult to do that without getting into privacy issues but I think that staff can guide us on where we should put our efforts and whether this is something that needs to be addressed immediately or can wait for a while and just what options they would prefer to see so I did talk to Lynn Robinson at Valley churches United and they have also had their operations interrupted by kovat because they have to be careful also about you know distancing from clients and that she told me that did slow down their ability to take applications so I think all of us everyone involved is trying to feel their way through this so we just need to maybe if the committee's can meet and it can be handled through the committee's to keep thinking about this working as Jim said towards mmm you know a more permanent program that would be helpful Thank You Cynthia any other comments from anybody Elena no coming up here Elaine fresco oh yes I just wanted to also confirm or low as the suggestion and and what Jim said about having a test program just to get it going and see how it works out sending it to committee I think is a good idea I don't agree with you Lou ferry's about waiting for California because well look it took them two years just to write a report and they have a lot of other things on their plate right now so I think just starting a small test program for us would be very valuable that's it Thank You Lane Beth you are next on the blue hand list that Thomas can you hear me hi hi thanks um yeah I am really interested in pursuing some kind of a program that will provide some relief for members of the community who who have economic difficulties my concern about having a temporary program you know trying it out is that I think that that will become very confusing to people who would need to take advantage of that program I can't imagine how you would say what we're gonna do this program and then all of a sudden have to pull the plug on it or something I think we'd have to think that one through but I do support the idea of having a program that would provide some help for people who need it thank you thank you next blue hand I see is Mark Dolson hi mom yep thanks I want to echo everyone's appreciation of the excellent work they're the staff and and the board have done on this and and I don't want to repeat everyone else so the only thing I'll add or reiterate is that you know I think as you continue to deliberate there's there's always the temptation in a difficult situation to just postpone your decision I I don't understand any really good basis for saying well let me just think about it in six months maybe I don't need to think about it at all I think you you have to make a decision and it's your decision but I think it's a it's just fooling yourself if you say well I support it and I'll think about it in the future figure out what you want to do that's my input okay thank you nobody else April Zilber I thank you again I'm so glad that the board is considering a lyric program and I do think it's important as other people have already said not to wait too long but to take it to committee now and start working on some of the questions that were brought up in the earlier presentation because exactly this is gonna happen people who still have work now are not gonna have work in a few months or people whose payment is in arrears and you you're not turning off their service but at some point in the future you're gonna say start paying us there does have to be something in place to help those people so I would really appreciate it if the board moves forward with exploring the options and committing to doing something sooner rather than taking a wait-and-see approach and a pilot program might be fine I don't have an opinion about whether it should be a pilot or not at this point thank you thank you the other public input it's not would you like to clarify your point yes thank you I obviously wasn't clear so let me clarify that I do not support waiting for the state I think that would be a mistake there's no telling when that might be resolved if ever what I do advocate waiting for is a stable revenue source and I'm hoping that in in state six months we will know whether or not our property tax revenue will continue to be stable or not because that's a big deal if we can't rely on those property tax money I don't know where we're gonna get the money to be able to support a program like this although we might eventually find it so it's really not a matter of waiting for the state it's a matter of making sure we have the - start something so that we don't start it and then stop it I think that would be a disaster so that that's a little clarification on and I do believe that it's reasonable to send this back to committee and further work on it not lose the time just not put the money in the budget so we're sure that it's a stable money sort thank you and one comment and one question so you know programs like this that are that are sort of rate support programs are really most effective at scale and one of the challenges I think that you know we face particularly where compared to a lot of the other ones that were examined is our really really small scale Scotts Valley of course has fundamentally different economic demographics and than we do and that also helps them with respect to the legislature in terms of getting to that scale because clearly a statewide program is the scale you know the the legislature the house is at seventy-five percent Democratic majority the Senate at seventy two point five percent both well above required two-thirds though to do this and certainly with the number of people who are losing jobs you know there's there's going to be an urgent need not just you know in our area but in Los Angeles and San Francisco and the other areas are much more heavily populated this is something that I hope the state legislature can look at and very quickly adopt something that said I'm certainly supportive of taking it to committee and let's dive into and you know in a more comprehensive fashion than we can do here one question for Gina legally Gina is there any way to target specifically those most in need or our programs like this really first-come first-serve to whatever caps are put on the program well I think it's not an either/or that's good but in terms of determining financial need I think the most significant difficulties are the ones that were identified which is the administrative burden of figuring out you know what constitutes financial need and then how to determine eligibility and that's where the state water board recommended relying on the PG&E cares information in order to make that determination so the district wouldn't have to so that and that aspect of the program doesn't have to be dependent on you know the number of people that the district can take or whether you know getting in is done on a first-come first-served basis or not they could be independent determinations but if but if we did decide to go down the PG Kerr's route we would really not be able to say we're going to target those most of need it would be whoever comes in with a PG&E care approval - whatever today so whatever got this any we put on the program that's right okay thank you terrific okay so what are we gonna do with this issue I have my hand up again oh I'm sorry you didn't paint it blue go right ahead Lois I just wanted to say the reason I suggested a pilot program is the very opposite reason of what Beth was saying I feel like if we just jump in and say hey this is what we're doing wow that then if it doesn't work people are gonna say gee you promised me X amount of dollars if we have a pilot program keep it small see how it goes that perhaps we would get a good idea of the best way to go forward and people wouldn't be necessarily expecting the money the other thing is I talked also to Anna s you are our congresswoman for our area and I said to her what what's gonna happen [Music] if people can't I said our water district is running just like it normally does but what if we don't get money she was saying well we're thinking next stimulus bill maybe help for facilities and I'm thinking yeah right I don't think a lot of people are getting the $1,200 they were promised but alone getting money to utilities but there's all kinds of ideas out there and I went out today and I saw more cars and people out that I've seen in two months and I'm hoping that maybe things are going to turn around by June item them hope springs eternal for me I think people are just pissed off at staying in their houses lost okay so yeah I have a couple of suggestions here we need to give the staff some suggestions or guidance as to what we would like them to do beam's yeah yeah I have a public on it who's talking Marc Marc Lee yeah I think you already commented mark what do you have do you have something significant - yeah it wasn't on earth wasn't on this topic at all pardon me I was not speaking on this topic at all okay sorry go ahead I am absolutely amazed at the creativity and the brilliance of the Friends of the Friends of the San Lorenzo Valley Water District putting that report together and leading the charge I get my hat off to you know James Moser Tina toe Cynthia Denzel Elaine fresco and Beth Thomas Mark Dolson in April ceremony for their they're good at research on this and I I I think just the opposite I think the board is being too conservative I think we should move forward with a program ASAP we have 30 million people unemployed the Cova virus is not going away in fact it's gonna get worse so I have a totally different thing people are not being able to afford this program our water rates or increasing 5% a year you have an existing budget of ten billion eight hundred and twenty seven thousand seven hundred fifty which is increasing the five percent in 2020 to 11 billion this only represents a subsidy of literally 1.7 percent I don't think we should even rely on property tax I think we should move forward and get this program initiated using the care model I don't know what soon everyone is worried about this is a drop in the bucket there are a lot of people that are struggling to pay their regular water bills as they go up five percent per year so I'm in favor of not slowing down the process but immediately taking a proposal before the district committee and getting a program initiated a zap and I think it's waiting for the assembly to come up with a strategic plan statewide is folly they're gonna drag their feet on this for years they after talking with Assemblyman mark stone he said this was Spain take another year or two do you implement so I would not rely on our state assembly we need to act individually and independently our own rapier and I don't think it's gonna be a difficult process to do I think we can use the care program that's already up and running and I do not think we should hesitate let's move forward thank you thank you Mark okay back to the the board for with respect to direction for the staff does anybody want to offer a suggestion at this point what I'm hearing for most of you that we were discussing this is the fact that we should probably put it into a committee or sent it to committee and let them study the details that have been provided by the the Friends of fill-in-the-blank organization and the research that Stephanie is done and compiled with with this and also the little more time will help us understand if the conditions of our own Valley a little bit more and the other impacts that we might see down the road I do think if we can get the committee's coming back in June that would be plenty of time one of the one of the suggestions I would have to the committee and to staff and currently would be since we are in the mode of not turning off people's water and we know that there are some people who probably will have a large balance set in three months or in six months from now that we develop some sort of a program to specifically address that condition which we know is likely to occur as well as or in conjunction with the whole Lera concept and per program going into committee and I assume it's Budget and Finance to be the appropriate committee to deal with this so what do you all think fellow directors I think that's a great idea thank you I agree too and we can I can work with the chair of the Finance Committee Miss Henry and put this together and get it agendize for that committee and we made once we get back and running in June we might even be able to have a second meeting to kind of catch up and to get these these important items through Ricks Padilla I liked everything you said there so I agree that it should go into the committee I support exactly what you said thank you terrific okay wonderful so we don't okay anybody else any other directory got a comment no okay so so that's the guidance Rick we don't need to vote on this right no we'll take it right back to committee and I'll meet with chair and Henry we can get this going and get it to wonderful let me have quick the Finance Manager do you want to add into that step that sound good to you I should I yeah I think I think taking it back to committee we can dive into it a little bit more and focus then on which type of route we can you know we can kind of lay it all out a little bit better right because you know we are monitoring our current accounts closely and and you know we're seeing you know positive with our rate payers paying their bills right now I know it's early and that'll give us a little bit more time to to prepare more information right okay moving on last item on the agenda tonight and Rick hey I see as the proposed rate increase this is a recommendation that the board review the information and staffs recommendation is to adopt a motion to proceed with the prior approved rate increased to take effect in 2020 you have some alternatives to freeze to stop the approved five percent rate increase from taking effect in 2020 the freezer stopped half of the approved five percent rate increase for two and a half percent taking effect in 2020 you could take no action staff does not recommend alternatives one and two because they would have significant long-term AVD negative impacts on the financial health of the district as briefly summarized in this map staff does not recommend alternative three because they final board decision regarding this issue is needed in conjunction with finalizing the fiscal year 2021 budget a little background according to the a B 401 final report recently released by the State Water Control Board drinking water is a basic basic human need expenditures to meet basic water needs are expected to continue to rise rapidly due to the need for water systems to replace aging infrastructure meet treatment standards diversity or diversify our supplies and maintain a well-trained workforce a number of factors explain the rising rates for water service three of which were relatively unique to to water among the basic service sectors first water has been historically underpriced compared to the true cost of service leading many water systems in California to underfund or foot off infrastructure maintenance replacement and other critical activities second increasing stringent water quality standards also require additional cost for treatment and operator training which further stress financial capabilities third percentage of federal support in total public infrastructure infrastructure spending for water utilities have fallen from 30 percent in the 1970s to less than 5% in 2015 in other words water systems must finance their own operations to a much greater extent than in the past in 2017 there was a study that found that the district's cost of water service would increase for proximately nine point seven million in 2016-17 to ten point six million and 2020 2021 in order to meet its revenue requirement the district undertook a proposition 218 process in 2017 and ultimately approved a water rate increase to be phased in gradually over five years the upcoming year for increase would be 5% going to affect with bills in November 20 2005 is also scheduled to be 5% taking effect in 2021 on an overview the attach rate schedule and scenarios project for the next five years of revenue and expenditures below summarize revenue that permanently would be lost to the district from stopping or freezing of a scheduled rate increase I do believe there is a income projections for rate increase attached to this memo the lost revenue would compound and be much greater over time frames longer than the next five years unless the district approves catch-up rate increases it continued when prior approved rate increases would help to ensure financial health for the district in the face of possible revenue losses due to koubek 19 anticipated losses and expenses related to wildfire risks and management compliance with strange and rated for requirements and the need to maintain aging infrastructure also these funds can be used to reduce other long term liabilities and/or future water infrastructure capital projects if just a little background this item was requested by Tara Swan to be put on the agenda and other directives is why it is on this agenda as well and with that I'll turn it back over to the chair Swan for questions there is a like said there is a spreadsheet there we do have the finance director still attending the meeting and she'd be more than happy to answer any questions or I could ask if she would like to add anything additional she could feel free to if anyone has any questions I'm more than happy to answer but essentially I think it's essentially showing the compounding of fact when a rate increase doesn't occur how quickly that can add up Thank You Stephanie ok blue hands are popping up Rick okay thank you I guess this is for Stephanie Stephanie could you give me maybe some specifics on what are the long term negative impacts on the financial health of the district if we don't do this some I just need some concrete examples of what you think those impacts are I mean it's for the least amount when it's 1.3 over five years that's 1.3 million dollars that could be used proactively to reduce our unfunded liabilities and have direct longer-term interests savings from our CalPERS pension like we were discussing it's being able to accelerate or fully fund some of the other deferred maintenance programs that we know we have on the horizon I mean pretty much every item that we talked about at this meeting so far all involved money and we pretty much are coming in with this fiscal year 2021 budget Wow we're coming in we're coming in breakeven which means if we wanted to go do some of these programs we really wouldn't be able to without taking out of reserves so I mean it it could be used for a lot of different things okay thank you daddy answers my question so I'm gonna share a comment then before I call on Bob number one I hate proposition 218 I think it's a license to steal and every time the water district is pulled that card out of the deck over the last ten years or so it's been extremely aggravating to me and a number of other ratepayers you know I I just I mean I'm in favor of one of the things and it just goes back to the platform that some of us ran on to get elected was stop giving away money which we've done a good job of that and to roll back or a attempt to roll back the rate increases which we haven't addressed at all until this potential opportunity I'm almost of a mind to say vote him down completely no rate increase and and force the district to live within its means you know within the budget it's got within the revenue its cut and to can seriously pursue those new revenue opportunities that that have been mandated at the beginning of this year so I'm just I I mean having being a realist also having been on the board now for a year and a half I see the realities in the expenses and realize that you know there are a lot of these unfunded mandates or liabilities that exist and there's operating expenses and there's a crappy infrastructure that it's been allowed to go on for far too long and so I hate the idea of pulling out a rate increase that's going to be used wisely but then again I'm not 100% sure about that either just my rambling thoughts on the subject of the rate increase because we haven't addressed it in the first year and I wanted to wait until we got a little better footing before bringing it up and talking about it again or addressing it but this is some thoughts right now I'll have more later Bob please share your thoughts and commerce with us but I wanted to talk a little bit about historical challenges that boards have faced in the past whenever there's been a prop 218 process certainly the last two for the most part all of the increased revenue has gone for increased operating expenses with with very little of that having been used to expand the amount of money that's available the margin that is the operating revenue minus the operating cost the margin available to deal with some of these very critical challenges we have and the unfunded and under funded liabilities aren't just the pensions and the OBE it's the tank maintenance it's the meters it's the a hundred and fifty million which is our guess of infrastructure that has to be replaced over 50 years which is three million a year it's the 30 years looking back that was not addressed in a sustainable and systematic fashion that we have to catch up on it's the Lyra program it's maintenance it's the the entire totality of what is in front of us and we have yet to put that all that we've got pieces of it now but we have yet to put that all together and so that's one side of the equation that is we debt we do definitely need to be putting more money towards oh I forgot about the reserves we do not have our reserves fully funded yet either so there's lots of places for money to go what I'm looking at with this year's proposed budget though and I'm not sure I understand the concept of flat I'm looking at a 733 thousand dollar increase in operating expenses over what we rest amay ting for this year coming in at and that was before you know the coronavirus really hit big time and an estimated 485 thousand dollars in revenue increase so that means that this revenue increase is going entirely to increase operating expenses which means that the margin that we're applying to these unfunded liabilities is shrinking it's actually going from 3.2 million again estimated actual for this year to 2.9 million this is exactly the bind that previous boards got into that you do this rate increase and operating expenses eat it all up and so there's not enough money available for for those really critical things so I hope that we're going to be able to keep making progress towards getting our hands around the unfunded liabilities and and you know I really like to continue working with staff on that but if we're not going to do that and we're gonna see this kind of operating expense increase just to run the district and the revenue not even covering that so that we can just stay in place then I'm not in favor of doing rate increases and I think that would have to be coupled with also saying we're gonna do a flat expense budget as well that is we're not going to go up ten percent in expenses and four percent in revenue we're gonna do flat on both I think the economic fallout from this shutdown is going to be a longer term that we expect the unemployment claims that have been filed in Santa Cruz County now again not just in our area in two weeks exceeded an entire month during the 2008 prices so we are definitely going to see a longer-term effect at this point I'm I'm not in favor of either the operating expense increase or the rate increase until such time is we have a very clear picture of unfunded liabilities multi-year process by which we're going to commit to the community how we're going to address those and a budget that reflects both in a very systematic and comprehensive fashion and we are not there yet think about any other director comments this time questions I'd like a tapetum words they'd Lou first of all - - James okay I put this item on the agenda and I can probably talk about this odd nauseam so James I'm going to give you authority to put me on the clock and stop me at five minutes okay moving right along I've been thinking about this a lot in the last week hello yes we are you okay I thought I lost you I've been thinking about this subject a lot in the last week and I vacillated back and forth basically all week and finally I step back took a deep breath and reduced it down to some simple axioms I thought about what I what I promised myself when I was appointed to the board a year ago and that was to follow some simple rules number one always have the best interests of the ratepayers in mind number two always listen to staff because after all they are the subject matter experts so towards that and then thirdly is to listen to all ratepayers because everybody has good ideas number one the interest of the ratepayers by my reckoning and correct me if I'm wrong the rate increase this year will be the seventh increase in the last eleven year and these have not been insignificant increases as I look at the the numbers from the California State Water Resources Board they say that the average water bill for California is increased by forty five percent between 2007 and 2015 well they don't live in Santa Renzo Valley my water bill and I have them right here if anybody would like to look at them in the last 11 years my my water rates have gone up by 345 percent in a vacuum that wouldn't be terrible the problem is all of my utility bills of gamma have gone up by a commensurate amount and that's slowly eating away at my fixed income in retirement to where I might have to move out of California in less than five years so I'm very attuned to the ratepayers in this valley and you know what other data points the first time we did the 218 process there was a thousand protests so the second time there was 2500 might we actually defeat the next rate increase you know considering that said that said Delta I don't know but I do believe that we're running into a rate payer induced I mean we're getting tired of rate increases because they never seem to end we never seem to give back to the people that keep this this district going and I think the ability the ability of rate payers in to absorb future increases is clearly diminishing at the same time I think I talked with Stephanie about the numbers and she makes a very compelling argument if we reduce the rate increase we effectively reduce it forever and and that is that that really gave me pause and and made me think that that maybe that's something that we can't do especially with what's going on with the economy right now so here's the last point and that's on the the other rate payers input there was a rate payer that that spent something to the board just yesterday that I thought had a pretty good suggestion her her idea was doing a temporary rollback Perseids free month for all rate payers that would be a one-time cost not a continuing cost and reduce our ability to raise money in the future and I think that's something that's that's worth considering to again think about what's in the best interest of the rate there but at the same time you know this is probably the worst time to think about forgoing a rate increase because I'm sure we're going to find out far too late in the future that it was something that we desperately needed so without having said all that I would I would suggest that we do some sort of rate increase similar to what that rate payer suggested as a one-time event and that's it that's my suggest Thank You Lou you know any other directors with a hankerin to make a comment me great okay well I decided I heard some comment about wasting money and I took a look back at what we have done what this new board and new district manager has done since December of 2018 one thing we have an engineering department it saves the district money we have a professional registered engineer and an assistant engineer to facilitate capital improvement projects in-house with considerable savings to the district we have a master plan that is being worked on and should be completed by the end of this year protec all right what if I can't even talk mainline replacements identifying deficiencies within the distribution system and long-range planning and financial forecasting we have eliminated the lawsuits that cost this district so much money and did nothing careful we've also reduced the attorney bills the probation tank the probation tank has been completed and upgraded from a hundred thousand gallon tank to a five hundred thousand gallon tank in addition to the that the district received a very prestigious award the American Public Works Association for environmental sensitive construction projects the swim tank the district move forward with purchasing an alternative project site for replacement of the swim tanks in Bend woman the alternative site has an estimated cost savings of about $500,000 in addition to the alternative site will allow us to put required amounts of storage to provide adequate fire flow fire management plan we have a fire management plan that we're moving forward with the district has procured a consultant to start the process and is moving forward as part of the process the consultant will be looking to apply for grants and lower costs to implement this program integrated pest management plan the district is moving it the district has developed a draft integrated yes you and we have also have a public Advisory Committee for facilities we have just voted to do a public outreach plan plan with chatterbox and we also just did a survey a customer survey we have a new website which is a DEA approved streamlining better search engines more information capital improvement section to give customers an update on construction thanks to staff we have a loan of 14 million five hundred thousand dollars much better than the USDA loan that WSC was putting forward and charging us a fortune fund for and one of the good things about the loan we got we got all the money up front and it's in the bank and it's earning some interest granted were paying interest but we're earning some interest on that and and that's helps we have prohibited the use of glyphosate in on district property the lion tank access road lion tank and the water treatment plant was damaged during heavy rainfall the cost to fix that is going to be tremendous in millions of dollars red we have FEMA but the district has to pay before you get FEMA money so and FEMA mone money is only out there for so long you get a date that they want you to be started we purchase nine generators - and they're in the process of being installed as we speak the surplus property mañana woods is as we speak is getting a commercial property appraisal the pipeline projects which well hollow Lions Sequoia California Drive that's all part of the five pipelines that are funded by the loan the revised ball Creek fish ladder it went from six inches to 12 inch steps cutting the cost in half uppers ine stream wood enhancement project which I believe was all paid by a grant has been finished I don't think we've been wasting money we've been proactive I believe the water district needs to continue to move forward not step backwards or stay in place I think we need to say what we want to do about this rate increase because the budget is due next month and I believe we need to say we're going ahead with the rate increase we don't have to approve it it's already been approved I get what Steve said I hate the 218 process also but it's almost impossible to stop a rate increase what if this last rate increase there was a huge huge push by people in the district standing outside with protest letters for people to sign bringing them in bringing but there were not enough in fact they were they didn't even try to verify that all the protest letters were legitimate because some of them were duplicates some of them people didn't live here they didn't bother with that because they're just it costs a lot of money and they fell well below the threshold hole to protest that's that's my look at this I think we need the rate increase and we need to go forward and if we get to September or even January and and things are not working people can't pay or whatever we can change and move the writing say hey we're gonna not do this right now or and we can modify the budget at that point the budget is not written in stone Mattson Thank You los any other comments from any other directors at this time no okay well we can go to the well if yeah well we'll just go to the public any of the anybody want to comment James and Mosier all right ahead Damir a mutant you know you're not muted right now okay great thank you I appreciate the opportunity of talking to the board about what I think is a critical issue I first don't want to agree with Louis that this board has made some good decisions in terms of cost savings the hiring of an engineering staff and getting rid of that horrible lawsuit both constituted good cost savings it's the way you do cost savings is you identify where you're spending is not optimum and you figure out how to do it more efficiently it's say as a former director of a non-profit I learned the hard way how to do cost cuts and the way you don't do pastas is to simply say okay we're going to cut $400 400 thousand dollars out of a budget that's been developed like this and it all has to be done in an emergency there is reasons why the budget operating budget is going up you're doing a lot of work you can look at this rate increase I mean you can look at the budget and you see somewhere around four hundred and forty thousand dollars of it going to increase cost for that loan the loan was really important the rate increase was it was the rationale for it was exactly she could get the loan so we could do the work that needs to be done I think the idea of saying to staff at this point you find however much it is three hundred and fifty thousand dollars of this budget and make a cut between now and June it is a recipe as Louis said for taking a step back we should go forward cuz you don't have to vote on this rate increase it's already been voted on it's already there we need that money we're so whole discussion at the beginning my gosh this district desperately needs to continue to fund that's part of the reason why the Friends of San Lorenzo Valley Water looked into the lira program because we were concerned about these rate increases and its impact on low-income people that's why the lira program is so important um as the state as the a report says we can it's gonna cost more that's what we're looking at think about climate change think about this kovat the cold right impact of the coal that all of this oh my gosh and those of us are going to afford the rate increase I am happy to pay a little bit more in order to make sure the state stays financially healthy so I strongly support the idea of simply going forward with the budget as proposed by the staff thank you thank you Tina you're up next I just wanted to reiterate mr. Mercer's comments that I also support the bolsa lira and the rate increase I think that it is imperative to the budget and as a rate payer I am willing to pay a little more in support of it right thank you very much next up Nancy Macey you [Music] you're still muted there you go yeah something got in the way of my marker sorry sorry okay thank you very much for the chance to talk on this issue I think it's imperative that you keep the rating increase you've got so many things coming up and we have so much fun determinant nature in the future because of a pandemic that it would you'd be shooting ourselves in the foot look at what your staff was done trust your staff they are very smart intelligent hard-working people who care about this district who care about their jobs and they've done a brilliant job in showing you why you need to keep this and the things that Rick was reading you know that was for the whole state of California that herbs a hoax I guess it was a whole United States right but anyway yeah we're we're right up there with everybody else and my husband and I are on limited income we're retired we're not out there you know having to make money and we're lucky in that respect we do have some income but you know how long can anybody count on that but we are willing and grateful for the opportunity to keep our water district healthy and I think close for her rundown of that very interesting series of accomplishments and go for it you guys don't be scared it'll work thank you okay thank you Peter go boom you yeah yeah hear me yes okay great I listen to all this very carefully I don't think I heard any director or staff member say you didn't need the money yeah on the rate increase right I heard somebody say you think it was Bob it was a campaign promise it might have been Steve I'm not sure that you ran on this well you ran on reducing unnecessary costs as Jim Moser said and you did that you got rid of the litigation you settled it under the rupture of attorneys fees and I think pretty much everybody including those of us who who ran you know we're against you guys in the campaign I think you did a good job of doing that and that was smart and you get rid of that but I again haven't heard anybody identify any cost that are in the budget that you think are unnecessary the rate increase as I understand it is gonna add an average of or add for the average user a dollar or two come on if people can't afford that then the leader program or you've already put a moratorium on it but it's not many many people are going to be in a different position if they have to pay a dollar or two more come on their water bill if you think that there's some costs that need to be cut that there are some xs+ in addition to what you've already gotten rid of and you get rid of the fact if you think there's some additional cost I think it's incumbent upon the people who incurred unnecessary costs to identify those costs staff has told you it as blue said trust the staff they're the ones who are doing this this is their job they're the professionals in this they've told you what they need if you think they're wrong then tell them where they're wrong don't look you don't need this line item you don't need this like that we don't need to repair all the infrastructure we don't need to maintain the infrastructure we'll let's let it all keep going down the drain or whatever it is but I get you guys or women whoever thinks you don't need the money identify what the expense you don't need staffs already told you they think they need all this they're not going to how can they identify something I don't think they need they think they need it all so again I think it's incumbent upon each of you who think that you don't need it to say why you're doing either by identifying cost beyond those you've already gotten rid of that that can safely be cut and maintained the district's mission of delivering safe reliable water in an affordable rate thank you thank you Peter anybody else Cinthia your hand is up can you hear me I would like to say that in my own neighborhood I see leaking pipes I see crumbling roads I really want infrastructure to be improved and it is not saving money if you let things deteriorate to the point where you pay much more I really appreciate director Henry's listing of all the things you have accomplished and to me that's the argument for continuing with the rate increase so that you guys can continue to fund infrastructure repairs thank you Thank You Gabriel your next book thank you I appreciate what Cynthia just said it dovetails perfectly into what I wanted to say and that is that we've had a low rainfall year so far and I'm really concerned about fire so it would be fabulous if we could keep moving forward with our tank repair and replacement and pipe repair and stuff so that there's enough water in case there is a fire in one of our neighborhoods so I I think we should stick with the rate increase the way it's already planned Thank You April gale thank you I also want to advocate proceeding with a five percent rate increase as planned I understand director falses concerned that our operating expenses are rising at rates greater than our revenues but then it's his responsibility to identify what are those expenses that he thinks we can get rid of also it doesn't make logical sense to say that because we are spending more than we're taking it in revenues we can't fund our our long term unfunded liabilities and then that's true but then simply say okay we're not going to raise the rates secondly not raising the rates as I brought this up last time is leaving money on the table there's a lot of people in the valley that can afford the average rate increase a month it's basically me going down to the raven and have one chai latte does not i'm happy to give that up and send the money to the water district instead and finally the point i want to make is the danger of not increasing the budget in one year stuff made the very important point that it has this compounding interest effect in that even if you stop it for one year you never can get that money back and you lose a lot of money down the road and so it's really important to go ahead as planned if you need to help people at the low end with some lira kind of project that that's fine but it would be a terrible mistake to not go ahead with the rate increase now and then we find ourselves five years down the road being five million dollars in the hole because of that thank you thank you Mark Dolson thank you I agree with so much of what's been said I'll try to say something a little bit different which is that it seems like you tell virtually all of us agree that the district has looming expenses and the more revenue that's available to meet those the better I think everyone agrees that the board and the staff have done a number of outstanding things to move in the direction of improved efficiency and cost savings and I think everyone agrees that we want to spend as little as possible whatever everyone shares that goal the the sticky point that I see is that I see two directors and I'm thinking of Bob and Steve right at the moment based on what you've said asserting that we we can magically achieve that goal by just imposing by Fiat a little bit on spending and that's that's a matter of faith I don't think I could shake your faith of that but I don't I don't think us that evidence base position that's all I'll say thank you Larry Ford thank you I I want to say that finally I remember when ten years ago or so the one of your predecessor boards made the decision not to go ahead with a rate increase and it was it was horrible because that you know we knew what the consequences of that was was gonna be we were gonna have a delay in you know the repairs of of infrastructure that was decaying and it just it was terrible from from my point of view a couple of dollars a month a dollar a month whatever it is that's perfectly affordable because I put it into the context of how long we've been waiting to catch up on on the deficit and now we're finally making a lot of progress as Louis described went on at great length and I'm really pleased about that and I'm really happy to pay for it thank you Thank You anybody else okay Elaine did you already talk on this matter if not please go ahead and begin speaking um hi yeah I'll make it short I just think that it would be very short-sighted to forego this rate increase I know that director folks mentioned a couple meetings ago about the optics of the rate increase and I just want to say I think that Louis Henry made a very good case that you already have very good optics and you and it it's not worth it to forgo this rate increase just for how it will look because it's so important and I actually did not really understand director false you are saying that our operating expenses are increasing and for that reason we shouldn't raise the rates and and and you're also pointing out that we have very a lot of unfunded liabilities I am NOT great in accounting but I don't understand that so obviously I am I'm very happy to pay this rate increase that's it thank you anybody else okay I think we've all going no mark make up your mind are you raising your hand or not okay no more hands all right coming back to the the board all right so I don't know if anybody has any comments in addition to what we've heard there's a lot they make emulsion you can I was just gonna say Lois before you make a motion if that's what you'd like to do we don't have to do anything right now so we don't have to vote the freezer stop it we don't have to we can take no action if we choose to or we can vote to get knock it down I would like to make a motion to keep the rate increase because we need to get this budget done and we need to have an answer none of those three things were staff was not saying we should do any of those three things and I agree with those who said we need to trust our staff and the reason we have a district manager is to give us information and we have a financial director I'd like to make a motion that we keep the rate increase and get the budget you Rick your hand is up oh yes I wanted to make a comment I'm quite willing to second that motion as long as I get an opportunity to make a comment about the subject of the budget all right I don't know let's ask Gina are we in order or are we stepping on our toes it's appropriate for director Moran to make a comment if he wishes prior to the second thing of motion thank you good right all right so here I am trying to put my head around all this a lot of this stuff is new to me in the regard if I never paid attention in my water bill when I was going to school or 15 years ago um but it has become something that's important to me now so when I hear that the water the price of water has been historically underpriced all right I'm gonna take that as an honest answer all right so that's part of maybe why other people have spoken about the the large percentage that our water bills have gone up in the last two years okay so if it's under price we're trying to catch up for you know past policy all right so water is a top priority with me so I would gladly find other ways to save money to make sure that I have safety liable water and I think Louis made a long and eloquent list of the things that this board is accomplished and all of those things require money and I haven't seen this board miss spend money I've seen them be real tight with money and I don't think they're being frivolous with any of the money that's being budgeted um [Music] the most one of the most important things about being on this board is for me is to being transparent so here we are we're talking about this a lot of people have chimed in it's a difficult situation to use this zoom technology but people are interested in doing this and we're talking about it upfront and being honest with each other and it's been pretty civil so I appreciate that so in that regard I'm willing to second Lois's motion okay we have a second and I'm just wondering do we even need this vote what's the purpose of it we already have if it's to keep the rate increase we already have the rate increase later Swan I think the purpose is that staff we're going the board seems to be going back and forth I don't want you know I guess for lack of a better term on the fence whether they're going to stop the rate increase or whether to let let the rate increase play out and staff needs to know so we can adjust the budget or work these numbers in the budget I don't want to go back and forth every board meeting or every finance meeting up to November and be on the fence on the rate increase and I think Stephanie I mean if you want to chime in on that will agree with me and I would like to put this on the pitch we're spending a considerable and do don't get me wrong it's a very very important issue we're spending a lot of time on and we're not making a decision I'd like to I'd like to put this to bed and move ahead it's difficult to put the budget yeah okay thank you Rick okay so we have a second you know I'd like to make a comment go ahead I think that Rick has made a very good point I think that's a good reason to proceed also I'd like to ask Gina point of order there's been a motion and has been a second don't we aren't we required to fulfill that vote yes there should be a vote take and I think the point that was being made was it was a broader one but you're absolutely right director Farris with a motion in a second the matter should be voted upon then let's call for the vote go ahead blowing okay excuse me Steve what is it groaning then right again probably could read back what the motion is thank you Louis Henry made a motion to keep the rate increase and get the budget done thank you okay presidents y-yes director Henry yes director false no beg your pardon no no director Moran yes director Faris no three yeses motion passes okay well thank you all very much for tuning in this the hour of this board meeting has now come to a close and we are adjourned you | CTV Santa Cruz County | UCH_hHwkXLnSvpBFG2fd12yA | 2020-05-11 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 24,981 | 132,362 |
HQtLRqqB-Kk | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQtLRqqB-Kk | Cuddle, A go AppEngine Demo - Andrew Gerrand | for this for this evening so my name is Andrew gerund and I work on go with rob and tonight I wanted to introduce an a small demo app called cuddle which is an app engine app written in go and go came to App Engine in the first of the second quarter of this year and in July we announced at Google i/o and in July 2011 we and opened it up to the public and was previously available to trusted testers only and at present all the major app engine API is is supported there's still a few of them that aren't that are still in there sort of primordial phase but they're we're going for one hundred percent support this year hopefully and so in this in this demo app I'm going to talk to you I'm going to introduce parts of the data store which is how to store structured data in with App Engine the channel API which which establishes a browser channel for pushing pushing messages from App Engine services to web clients and the memcache api api which is pretty much essential for writing anything scalable on the web these days so i said cuddle what is cuddle it's a cute name for a multi-user anonymous chat service so if you visit a URL like this one and i'll do this now showing my faith in our platform you get this screen and which is slightly off the screen but if i if i type in this box hello and it's optimized for mobile devices so it looks much better on a phone the idea is is that we can people can talk and you can see it it doesn't really matter who it is typically i could imagine a scenario where you're at a conference and you say hey guys the back channel for this talk is cuddle / through bar everyone goes there and says is an android terrible at giving talks he should give up and go home not really but this so when somebody the mechanics of this is that when somebody visits their URL cuddle / something it adds them to a room name / something so in this case G tug and then users can send messages to the room and then the service rebroadcasts messages to all the members currently present in that cuddle there's no persistent storage of messages they're purely ethereal so there's no backlog and there's no way to identify who has said what which is fine for a demo app and maybe it would become some kind of viral thing I'm accepting venture capital proposals you can see me afterwards so how does it work a little bit more technically so the path component can port o relates to a room record in the data store so room is the the name capital our room and so each participant in a room has an associated client record capital C and so when a user loads that URL our App Engine app queries the data store looks for a room with that name and if it doesn't exist it creates it and then it generates a random ID for that user for that session which would just be a random string of letters 40 characters long and then it creates a client record under that name as a child of the room record so the data store supports the notion of entities being related to each other and when you have a parent entity and a set of child entities that's considered an entity group and that becomes important when you start talking about data consistency but we won't actually encounter any of that in this session and then once they've joined the cuddle we create a browser channel for them with the channel API and that that channel is identified by a client ID and a special token and then we write the user interface which is just a blob of HTML CSS and JavaScript which if i go to my demo again you can see it looks something like that it's just got all of it in one big blob we write that out with the channel token so they can connect to the channel and the name of the group and the JavaScript us all the rest and so sending messages is simply a matter of sending and receiving is simply a matter of receiving messages via the browser channel and the JavaScript drawls into the page and a client post messages by hitting a handler a URL / post aha passing in the room name and the message body of themselves and so the server on receiving a message like that it looks up all clients who are children of G tug and then sends a message to all of those clients using the channel API everyone with me so far does that make sense it's a very very simple application but if you don't if this doesn't make sense that I want to clarify now okay so on the file system the anatomy of a guy application looks something like this you have the the route the a proof which is just some directory of whatever name in this case it's called cuddle you have an appt tamil file and so i forgot to ask the starboard who here has actually used App Engine before to build things okay that's cool so you've probably seen a nappy amor file before but it just contains the metadata that describes this application there's another cuddle directory and this time this is that this is the directory that contains the go code inside package cuddle and that's three files um some code to interact with the data store some code to provide the HTTP handlers and some code a very small amount of code to handle the naming of rooms and then finally we have that the route dot HTML which is a template file in the template format that Rob show demonstrated the lexer of for before and only use a small subset of the other lexus language of the template packages language but it does nonetheless so this is what the a piano file looks like it's very simple it just declares the application name which is cuddle demo its version one it uses the go runtime and it uses API version 2 which is the current version of the go runtime and this is bound to increase over time but the key difference between this and say a Python app is that our in a Python App you declare paths that correspond to certain handlers in your Python script or at least you can and whereas in go you simply define the URLs paths that correspond to go in general and then you let the go program itself handle the demultiplexing of requests to various HTTP handlers so in this in this case we're saying the regex dot star which is everything after / is going to be served by the Go app which is exactly what we want so go this is a example of a standalone go program so it's not an app engine program this is just a go program that serves an HTTP server on port 8080 that simply writes hello and then whatever the URL path is so if you go to slash david says hello comma Dave hi Dave and this hello function is an HTTP handler and all it does is write a string with F print to W which is the response and in the main function we register that function hello with the path / using this handle funk function from the HTTP package and then we call listen and serve to listen on port 8080 and run a web server but in App Engine it's much the same we use the HTTP package in the same way the key differences are is that instead of being in package main you're in a package of some other name in this case it's hello go App Engine apps provide their own package main which is just which means that you can't have your own one and so the other differences that we use an init function to register our HTTP handler with our with the hdb package in this sound alone go program we have package main but in our hollow package in our App Engine app we use an init function and these in it functions are run before main so that's how you do that it's very straightforward so our program cuddle has to http handlers it has a route handler and that handles the joining part where the client joins a cuddle and we add the client to the room and check for the room and then create the channel and then serve the HTML to the client and then we have the post handler which handles a request to post a message to a room and so the messages are returned to the user via the channel API so in our init function in our cuddle HTTP go we have to handle phone calls one to register route with everything after / and one to register post with flash post and so now driving straight into the code from the route handler the very first part of it which is here is it takes the name from the URL path component we slice off god it's so annoying we slice off the first / from the path because it will always begin with a slash something so if this was if you r dot URL dirt path was /g tug this slice operation makes it simply the string gtalk and we then pass name into a regular expression match so valid name is a regex object and match string matches the name string against that reg ex and so here in this separate code block this is the global variable valid name which I've created by calling reg reg ex must compile and it's simply a regex that matches all alphanumeric characters as well as dashes and so if it's not that name or if it's an empty name we'll get this if case which serves an HTTP error using this error helper function and we just say invalid help cuddle name until it's not found I'm so continuing with the route handler code we now want to call this get room function which is in the DB go file and it gets or creates a new room with that name and so this room is a value of type room which is a struct that has one field it has the room name and that's all we know about a room it just has a name and that's it this line here where we create the variable C it's an app engine context and to do any API calls in go in App Engine you need to provide them with a context that is based on the current request so this R refers to the are in the function arguments which is an HTTP request so we create a new app engine context from that request see and then we pass that into our get room function which uses it here to make an API call so this is the body of the get room function it's a pretty simple function it takes the App Engine context than a name and it returns two parameters now typically you would have this bit of code at the end of the line but I'm kind of constrained so I apologize for the sort of cramped pneus of some of these examples but at the top of this function i create a new room and there should be a columnar i apologize i created a new room with the name that was provided and and then I make a call to the datastore a get call and so I'm asking for a a room record with the key that I'm providing and storing the result in this room that I've created and you'll notice that I get the key by calling the method key on my room and that method is defined here it's a it's a method key on a pointed a room that returns a data store key and because often when I have a room I want to there's a few other examples where I need to get a key for room so I've made it a method on on the room type and all does is call the new key function to create a key for that room with that name and so in the back in the body of this function I make that get call and then I restore the stall the arrow return value in oh now if the ER value is that is the value from this data store package no such entity meaning that that room does not exist in the data store I want to put a new a new record for that room in the data store because the the definition of this function is that it fetches a room by name and if it can't it creates it right and so we execute a put and then stall the error value in and then I return the room and that error value so if there's an error has occurred the caller can handle that error value further upstream and it does as we see on this slide if if it doesn't if it fails we handle the error but can anybody tell me what's wrong with this and yeah so I've got a race condition who knows who doesn't know what a race condition is cool so essentially if I do a get and try and find a room with this key and then I don't find it and then another client comes in and is doing exactly the same thing they both don't see one one of them creates it and then the other one doesn't see it so what I need to do is instead do this in a transaction I'm so that I can have a consistent state and fortunately to do that in go it's really straightforward because go has just native support for functions as values so closures as values so you'll see the this is the core of my function here they get and the put statements I take that and I put that inside a new function definition FN so this is a variable FN which is a function that takes an app engine context and returns an error and inside this function all I do is do the get and the put and return the error value and then I can pass that function into this function finding transaction and so it just runs the contents of this it just runs this disclosure inside a datastore transact so it means that it means that I can't I can totally avoid that race and so data sort of running transaction returns an error and so here I'm returning the error return value of that and the room that I've just retrieved into this room variable so back to our HTTP handler now now that I have a room I want to add a client to that room which is this the person who's joining the room and I do this by calling the ad client method on room and I pass in a random ID which is a little function that just generates around am alphanumeric string of client ID Len characters long and I pass in the context as well and that returns a token and so this a decline will create a new client record and that's associated with that room so this is the ad client method and so the a decline takes an ID it creates a key that's a client with that ID and then it and most importantly this last field of new key is the parent key and so I pass in the room key as the parent key for this client and then when I issue the data store put putting this this new client variable I've created in as a datastore record when it is stored its key court describes itself as being a child of of the room and then I just it once all that success if it's not successful I return the error but if it is successful then I call I'm channel create which is accessing the channel API and creating a new browser channel that's associated with that client ID and and this channel to create it returns a string and an error and the string is the token we want to pass to the client and so finally in at the bottom of the route handler we've got our room and we've got our client in the room and we've got our token to set up the browser channel we create this data variable which is a structure containing a room in a token string there's just two string values and that is the room name and the token val value and then I call root temple that executes passing in w which is the HTTP response and data which is my template data and this riots this template that I've passed as a global variable it writes it out to the HTTP response and so you get something like this I showed you the court of the code from this before so the HTTP template looks like this it has an HTM the room name it has the the room name again this time in JavaScript form and the channel token and if we look at the the code that's actually generated you see that the G tag name is there in heading the gtalk name there is under room and this is the token that our channel API generates and so quickly back to the the template code itself in the JavaScript and I don't want to sort of dwell on the JavaScript very much but the JavaScript creates the browser channel using this function call others creating this new object passing in the token and then we call chandel open on that new object and set a non message handler that simply adds new messages to this log give every time a new message comes in on that channel and so this is this is a piece of infrastructure that's provided by the the App Engine channel API and it's a really flexible and nice way of just very easily setting up a back channel back to the client so does that there any questions about name of that so that's that's the entire thing end to end for actually joining a room and creating the browser channel and so now we're ready to and we're ready to receive messages and the final missing part of the puzzle is posting messages to the channel and so posting messages is basically just through first we have this post handler which you saw I registered with the HTTP package a while ago and we just get the room again using the same get room function that we had and then we call the send method to send this value so form value is a method on request that pulls get or post variables from an HTTP request so I want to pull the message get variable from our request and send that out to all of the clients who are participating in a room and so what is the what is this the send method look like it's quite straightforward we have at the top of it we have a query so we set up a client's slice which is like an array and we run this query against client records that have an ancestor that is apparent that is the room so we're looking for all of the client records that are children of the room and then we use the get all method to execute that query and then that's that stores all of the clients in the client slice and then we can iterate through the client slice and for each one of those we do a channel send call and we send identifying the channel by its client ID and send the message to that client so this iterates through and sends that message to every client that is currently connected by our channel if it encounters an error instead of returning the error to the user and telling them their post was unsuccessful instead I just call the error f method on the App Engine context and that actually writes an error message to the admin console in App Engine so I can log into the admin console and see if there's something wrong with the App Engine infrastructure or see if for some reason my messages aren't being sent correctly to clients but if a particular client doesn't receive a message that's not really an error that I should concern my end user with it's more of a programming issue so can anybody tell me something that might be not wrong but just bad about this what I'm doing here every time I'm sending a message i'm doing a datastore query I've just said what it is but yeah it's like totally inefficient to any time something like people sitting there chatting you don't want to just be querying for exactly the same data every time as long as nobody's joined this chat is the result of this query is always going to be the same so them enter the memcache the mem cache API so at the top of my function now I do this memcache get and i'm using the room named as the cache key because it's just the room names as good as anything and then I'm REE i'm getting the the participants of that room as a JSON blob out of memcache and if there's an error I return that error but if there's a cache miss meaning that this data isn't as either fallen out of memcache sure it wasn't there in the first place I want to do my data store query as before so I've just emitted those lines here for brevity but then once I've gotten that data from the data store i'll do a Jason set to set that memcache item so the next time this send method is called for this room that data will be found and we don't need to do the data store query again and then we send the messages just as we did before and and continue on and so there's one other piece of the casing puzzle that is left and that is anytime a new client enters the room we need to invalidate that cash record we need to delete it out of memcache because the client list its cache is no longer true don't no longer reflects the reality so after we've put the client into the data store in the ad client method we just do a simple call to memcache delete to delete em memcache record with that name and that just invalidates the cash and then we can go on to create a channel and so that's it that's the entire thing I've just yeah burned through that so the the entire code for this and the talk itself is all available at this URL so you're free to peruse at your leisure there's a couple of things that I omitted like the entire structure of the of the go files that you might find interesting ratifying and you get certainly a nice project hack on if you wanted to get started with something in the multi-user kind of interaction way like you could easily extend this to be some kind of game or something like a tic-tac-toe a board game or something but yeah the App Engine project for go is pretty well documented at this address again like Rob said there's the go lang website which has a huge amount of resources including tutorials and co walks and the go blog has a huge wealth of articles about go there's articles about profile and go programs if you're interested in performance there's articles about particular go idioms about error handling about using particular data structures and all these kinds of things so I thoroughly recommend if you're interested in go to check out the blog it's can't sell it enough it's really worth to you know but does anybody have any questions yes great grab the mic can you just explain that with the underscores were in the source code Andrew underscores sure so in places like this in go code you might see an underscore and in assignments and what that means is that data sorted put returns multiple return values data sort of put actually returns a key and an error value because it's possible to put what's known as an incomplete key that is a key that doesn't actually have a unique identifier in it and then once you put it in the data store it's actually filled out and becomes a complete key and you can use that to get data back out again so in this case I don't care about that key because I've already given it a complete key and I don't want to assign it to some temporary variable called like temp key or something instead I just want to throw the value away and so I use the underscore and the outer score is also kind of known as the right only variable and go and then one reason why this is really important aside from keeping your code nice and neat is that in go it's illegal to declare a variable that you don't then use so if I declared some temporary variable T I'll have to find some artificial way of using it or the compiler would complain to me about it so it's actually a really nice way of keeping it's an it's a nice rule because it means that you keep your go code very clean and don't leave remnants of things lying around but yea big fan of the underscore other questions I'm happy to answer any questions not just about this but about go in general yeah is there anything you wouldn't recommend use go for like any sort of application sure so one area which is a little bit wanting at the moment is there's no GUI tool kits like for native apps like not web apps that I really like I know there are bindings for things like gtk there are bindings for the windows whatever that's called I'm not a Windows programmer so i'm not sure but there are bindings for a few few different GUI tool kits but none of them are particularly idiomatically designed they all kind of are basically a thin shim on to a C API which is not a very fun way of writing go code and so when people say they want to write some rich GUI up I say it's probably better to write the fun part of it in go and then the UI part of it in either in the browser or use like an RPC connection to say I don't know whatever your favorite kind of languages for doing that kind of you I work but that's that's definitely the broadest it's one of the hardest things to design really well and so most you I kids talk it's aren't designed very well and even those that are not written for go so it doesn't sort of mesh as well as it could but goes really useful for a really broad range of things so that's a good question are there any questions from the chat did anybody see that no nobody's been watching oh you answer them in the chat stealing my thunder all right yeah I know I know that from just from playing with it a bit you can't have a function where you kind of a function and a variable with the same name if you caught you high you kind of name conflicts between as it methods and variables or variable instructs can you can you can you treat them can you treat them the same I don't remember kit like if you've got an ex does it doesn't matter if it's an exit is a method with no arguments or an exit is a variable of a struct can you call in the same there are a couple of things packed into that question I'm the first one is that it's illegal to declare two names at the same scope level and go so if you have in a function you can't declare the variable X twice at the same scope level if once you once you're sort of nested in a block you can shadow the outer X with your inner X but once you once you go to the package global level which is where we define things like global variables constants types and functions of course and methods which are just a type of function if you the example you're giving is so you have a type definition which has a struct with a field X and then also as a method with the name eggs you can't do that because they're both they both effectively exist at the same level and you address them in the same way if you have a struct foo dot X is either its field X or its method X so you can't have both yeah yeah but it has to be with convert AVI to be a call SFX open closed paren but you can't you can't with a method you can't take the you can't pass around a method because that would be carrying the the object that's associated associated with with the function and there's no carrying does an existing go that's a pretty sort of deep question which probably doesn't interest a lot of people but I'm happy to have incident does anybody have any other questions that it's fine for them to be those times types of questions I'm just reassuring people what's the performance of the Goa App Engine platform compared to personal Java I'm go David stop talking and listen to the question and therefore have some input to help me with with the answer the question was David works on go for App Engine that's why I bother him but the the question was what's the performance of the Go app engine run time compared to Python and Java and the answer is actually very good because go is a compiled language go apps tend to start up very fast so if your app comes under a lot of load it's very easy for the app engines app servers to fire up a whole lot of instances of your app and they start performing really really quickly pythons not too bad in this respect either it's not as fast as go but Java on the other hand a sizeable Java app can take a quite a long time on the order of minutes in some occasions to actually spin up and start serving effectively whereas go goes from basically zero to full throttle in under a second in most cases so that's really nice as far as code execution goes it's far and away the fastest language for App Engine at the moment java can compete with it on in some tasks but it absolutely blows python out of the water if you have anything cpu intensive to do and you want to do it on App Engine go is totally the language to do it in and in fact I would say if you have anything cpu intensive to do a full stop i think i was a pretty great language to do it in but yeah definitely applies to App Engine do you have anything you wanted to add to that or cool just wanted to make sure you were listening little other questions I was to give an example one of the things we one of the ad to early test programs what was it matter brought tiles to appspot com was this oh oh yeah you better fix it anyway it's a it's a server-side generated Mandelbrot example and it's but it's in the SDK you can check it out but it yeah it runs pretty fast oh yeah that too as well i think in and total disclaimer here I'm not on the App Engine team I don't know what the exact real story is but I believe we will be charging in a more fine-grain way for resource usage on App Engine and so I believe that go definitely has a big advantage in terms of CPU time and memory use / / Python and Java yeah but thanks for coming sure Joe a minute I can do one from scratch perhaps okay can you do something really really hard no yep sure okay I'll show a couple of things oh so I'll show you first I'll show you this what I meant to show you so this is all being generated and some data center somewhere in a long long way away from here so any sort of delay you see here is probably due to network latency also I'm over Wi-Fi so that Polly doesn't help but this is when we launched you know we've started pimping this this link out on Twitter and stuff and we had like a lot of people hammering it pretty hard and it was it was it was very nice to see how well it performed yep yeah yeah so we get we get stats on on how many of the tiles that were loaded were in memcache and how many were generated on the fly and you can see that oh if I read if I really the page there you go uh-huh so a bit over like one and a third of them were hits then or whatever sorry it's getting late so I'll show you I'll just quickly show you a run-through of hello world so the first thing I do is go to code google chrome calm / app engine / downloads of course you can just search for App Engine downloads and you'll get to the same place you go to the App Engine SDK for go and then you download the V whichever one matches your system and if you're looking there and wondering where Windows is that's a good question unfortunately we don't support App Engine for windows because go support for windows while it is there and it works it's not one hundred percent support in the same way that we support darwin linux and some of the other platforms but it is it is on the road map it is going to happen it's a matter of when and we hope one will be soon I can't make any timeline promises but the so I download that and it's already downloaded somewhere and unzip it to somewhere and then you get you get google app it you get a google app engine folder somewhere can't full screen them is that off the screen there you go okay so this is the contents there's a demos folder and it has a bunch of demo apps the hello world app is is in there under demos hello world it has an appt p.m. or file that looks very almost identical to the one that I showed you before well if you look at a Python one so if I if I say Python a p.m. or you'll see there's there's other directives so in Python you say script is home drop by and then it uses home drop by to serve that that particular path but in go and like I said at the start of the talk it's either handle by the running go up or it's not and so in this case it's just with a slash so my hello world program is in the HelloWorld directory so the path i'm in is demos hello world hello world and theirs hello world go which is in package hello world which is just a an init function which registers my handler with the HTTP package and the handler itself which says hello world and then to deploy this what i would do is go to the App Engine developer console and then see you can see my cuddle demo is there and then I would create a new app and I would call it hello world but of course that is taken so I have to call it something else but I'm not actually going to create one right now and I'm not actually going to update it but what I would do then is edit my a PM all to say whatever the name of that app I just created was as if he'll awards taken on color like Andrew hello Jade hug or something and put that there and then I would run the app CFG up data and there's all docs on how to do this as well in the getting started guide for App Engine I would just say update from this directory and it gets all the files together contacts the server asked me for my login credentials and because i use two-factor authentication which everybody should i need to create an app specific password for my app engine account and i'm not going to log into like my admin interface and show you what my passwords and all this kind of stuff so that's why i'm not going to log in and do it but otherwise i would type and rudy g which is my gmail email me hello and put in that one time password and then and then it would update to the server and then the service would go live and that would be it and it's that straightforward so that's hello world the other question was what happens if you want to have like multiple packages and things in a go program no so this is called hello world and there's a hello world directory inside it which has a hello world go package and so a package is like a unit of code and go it doesn't have to be called hello world it could be called anything I don't think they do have to be the same I think it's it's the convention is for them to be the same but they don't have to be yeah oh yeah oh yeah so sorry this is totally the best thing I could be demoing right so I can run the dev app server which anybody's done Python apps knows what the dev app server is I run the dev app server locally and that this is a virtual no a local instance of the the remote app server so when I visit this localhost link in my browser I see hello world and some unicode characters to make sure that unicode works and that's Korean this yep hey I'm not finished and so the really nice thing the really nice thing about this is when i go to demos hello world hello world and then edit that file so go as a compiled language as Rob mentioned it compile stir machine code and so when I loaded this page if i look at this log it says building go app running go app so when I ran unloaded that page it actually built and around the go program if I change the code in here the that dev app server will notice and will rebuild the code accordingly or so if I change this to say hello ji tug like that and then refresh it rebuilds Andrey execute it and serves the page so that gives you an idea of how quickly go builds as well so you get that very same fear thing that you get developing web apps in a scripting language in go for App Engine because we have this order magical recompilation system which is a really nice way of running go occurred and so that's that's a single package program but which is what I also demonstrated with cuddle before but if you want to have a package with multiple program up so a go app with multiple go packages and which is a very common thing to want to do I have say this app mustachioed which I demonstrated at Google i/o this is the route director at the Apple root of mustachio it has a number of directories in it it has the mustachioed directory which is the mustachioed main app code which is like the handlers and everything it has a resize package which has some image resizing code in it it has a free type go package which is a third party package that Nigel over there wrote for rendering text and i use it for drawing a mustache on an image and the go earth to package which is an OAuth implementation in go and so inside my inside those directories ears go code and the rear side what size one belongs to package resize the mustachioed one belongs to package mustachio and if i look at my mustachio / draw draw go you'll see it imports the freetype go package so this is this is a local dependency and these are these two here extra and image standard library packages and in my mustachios / HTTP package i have i import go off to and i also should be importing resize I don't know where that went oh yeah it's an outstanding a separate import so you import resize and that's the the image resizing code so the all of this go code when you run the dev app server or when you deploy to Google servers is all just boredom built into its packages and then linked into a single executable and then all of the various in its statements in it functions that that register HTTP handlers they all start before the main app begins and so you can have multiple different go apps that are all built into the same server as long as they don't clobber each other's HTTP paths they'll be fine so you can actually very easily in the same way you can with Python have multiple apps coexisting in the same logical app I'm sorry multiple logical apps coexisting in the same sort of physical app you can do the same thing with go with have multiple packages that are effectively multiple logical apps living in the same binary or the same go app does that answer your question yep yep so the rules for which files compile is being restricted all the time at the moment I think we exclude things it only looks for things that end in go and then we exclude things that end in underscore test go which are typically test files yeah so I'll get to that but we don't currently support an appt CFG ignore do we yeah oh okay and there is also a nappy Amal directory you can use to specify a path which has no go which which shouldn't be built and so the app builder won't crawl that path of you have a no build files directive directive in your app p animal as far as testing go has a really great testing framework called go test it lets you write tests that are really really simple and they're just written in go there's no cut metal language there it's all very lightweight and straightforward but part of the convention there is to use underscore test go files we want to bring the same thing to App Engine or at least something very close but it's on the road map it's not we've done done yet but there is so as far as testing goes we have the way we figured we'd make testing and go work really well is by making it really really easy to write tests and the simplest way of doing that is getting them to write them in go and the way testing works in go is we have this program called go test and i'll see if i can look at a simple one from the standard library so if we look at say the the zip package and where we have a this bunch of files if you ignore I just oops we have the go files and then we have these underscore test or go files and so when you build this package for production it just builds only the the dog Oh files not the test files but when you're on go test it actually builds all of those files together and then it provides a artificial main function that calls special functions so the special function in this case anything that begins with the word capital T test so this function test reader iterates over my range of reddit tests which is just more go data structures and then tests the actual code that is in zip package so I'm actually inside my zip package so i can access all the internals of the package as well as the external interface and so you can write tests that test all aspects of you of your code as if they're written in there right alongside the code itself but they don't get built into the final product but so yeah so that's that's that's essentially go test in a nutshell and that's a very long test so if you do test on short and it skips the really long ones and you'll see that all my tests pass which is nice but but yeah that's kind of an integral thing as part of the go philosophy to be really lightweight like that we do have a code coverage tool I think it's broken at the moment it used to work the things change in the compiler and everything and the linker and things kind of fall out of sync but it's definitely on the agenda to to make that work again soon so yeah it almost works on linux at the moment um i'll just quickly say a couple more things about where is it so no no no it's gone so in addition to go test we also have go doc which is like pie doc for documentation it pulls documentation right out of source code and that makes it very easy to keep your docs in your code in sync so if we look at if i'll just quickly show you in the if I do go talk archive / zip I'm you'll see there's all this documentation about the zip file package and so if I look at this thing for example the documentation for open the open method returns a blah blah blah blah if I actually look at the reader code and look for open you'll see that that is the actual comment on that on that function and going another step further if I go to a going to draw up / package / 5 / zip and go to open the same docs are all presenter there so it's all like totally consistent in that sense and so we we also have go install which is a remote package installation utility and it's also good for building packages locally without having to write make files which is always nice um we have a tool called go fix which is you can use to update go code between releases of go so we issue releases every one or two months and occasionally api's are changed and we have go fix which automatically rewrites your code to use the new AP is and so that you don't have to fumble around I'm changing things and a really nice side effect of that is that it enables us to make far-reaching API changes to make the api's better without having to burden people with the the the task of updating their courage and so we're not burdened with backward compatibility at this stage which is a nice thing there any big o something tools I'm forgetting oh yeah go format so if you run or go coach all go credits in the go repository is run through this tool called go font geo FMT and it formats go code to make it look pretty by some definition of pretty and it works really well it means nobody argues over white space it's very it's it eliminates all that myriad conversations or can you please put your brace on the next line that kind of thing it's just not an issue and working in a team environment it means that all go crowd looks the same and as a result go code tends to be very readable or at least more readable than a lot of code I've seen there is a there is a mocking framework that I believe might be open source soon there are some other open source testing tools that I haven't used them so I don't know but there is the if you go to the go package dashboard this lists packaged installations they're like external package installations and it also reports on their build status and there's also a projects page which lists is my administrative one with the admin interface showing how embarrassing oh no oh it's odd slug me out of everything oh forgot why I didn't do that you see the thing is changing google com google to come today you youtube com everything's all gone and i was signed into three accounts as well oh I got a Chinese one that's great okay oh and that's the corporate one go on yep that would have worked just as well anyway so that's the projects page it shows you there's a whole lot of stuff on there a lot of different things so definitely worth checking out if you're wondering so that's good i sported appspot.com or more easily accessible if you go to the package dashboard they're on girl under org what time is it a 23 anybody got it other questions yep database support we have what sort of database you like don't ask for Oracle first we don't have there's not an Oracle database driver there are my sequel postgres couch Demi other ones along those lines one really nice thing that we heard about so this is database related stuff redis sequel light all that kind of stuff but one really nice thing we heard about this one in particular MGO or mango is it's a MongoDB driver for for go written by geico Gustav Gustav Annie Meyer and this quote here is from one of the MongoDB guys one of the main guys and you're saying MGO might maybe well them be the most advanced MongoDB driver right now so yeah if you use MongoDB apparently you should be using go as well but you know that's that's a nice thing to know so it's not just that we have the support we also have quite rich support in areas of course it's not like uniformly rich though it's some little better better than others but it's definitely like way more mature than it was when we launched 18 months ago and it's really gratifying to see people building nice idiomatic interfaces to popular application but if somebody knows somebody oracle that doesn't hate google you could get them to write one sure if you wanted to get started contributing to go you would click on the contributing link that's a good place to start and then go to the contributing code page and where we have a small diatribe on how to get started with code review and the co-contribution process definitely better to get started writing your own stuff first it's a bit of a it's a like you go writing go code is different to writing code in other languages in that we don't have like the typical ideas of object hierarchies and inheritance and a lot of other things that you take for granted in other languages so it takes a little while for you to kind of unlearn a lot of these things and and start producing really idiomatic go code which is the kind of code that we put in the core project but it's the barrier to entry is really really low in terms of accessibility if you've got the code we'll take it it's licensed under a BSD license you still retain the copyright as one of the go or thurs but it's fairly distributable under the terms of that license and we have almost 200 non-google external contributors to date and a good 20 or of them would be active on a one-week kind of basis and we have two non-google committers as well so people who actually can commit code without us having well everything's code reviewed so that's a really great thing there's a high quality of code but they can actually commit code without us having to do it for them anybody else I just while I was saying about the community thing there's a great community of developers there's also a great community of go users and we have a very active mailing list called going nuts and an active IRC channel which you can see over there called go nuts it's more active in the United States and European daylight hours but it's still pretty active even in our time zone and if you have go questions taking it to either going nuts or to the IRC channel is a great way to get an answer that's accurate and quickly so yeah if you want to get into go definitely lean on those resources don't out searching the mailing list before posting is always a good idea they'll definitely say that but don't you know don't be afraid to post I guarantee you somebody much cheaper than you was probably posted before so you can't look too bad all right is anybody else have any questions cool well thanks everybody for coming I don't know if the Jeter guys have further things they want to talk about | GoogleFOSSSydney | UC9SzG8f9xlz8VquuO4fRZsg | 2011-08-30 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 9,167 | 46,527 |
9X4TNIyiXkY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9X4TNIyiXkY | Rhenium heptafluoride | Wikipedia audio article | rhenium hepta fluoride is the compound with the formula R f7 it is a yellow low melting solid and is the only thermally stable metal hepta fluoride it has a distorted pentagonal bipyramidal structure similar to if7 which was confirmed by Neutron diffraction at 1.5 K the structure is non rigid as evidenced by electron diffraction studies it can be prepared from the elements at 400 degrees Celsius to read +7 f2 to rf7 with fluoride donors such as CSF the rf8 - an ion is formed which has a square antiprism attic structure with antimony pentafluoride antimony 5 fluoride of fluoride acceptor the rf6 plus cation is formed references | wikipedia tts | UCqKZqRCjBaE6TBfi_JQc8ag | 2018-10-25 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 110 | 634 |
40COxDpCEjw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40COxDpCEjw | Bass Fishing Tips - Texas Rig | today I'm going to be talking about using some crawls this is the hoax fish crawl right here this one's in green pumpkin and how would how would would Rick is I have a regular straight um shank hook and I have it rigged on you don't really need those really expensive hooks where you need like tungsten any stuff like that I'm just using a straight regular lead hook or lead uh weight and you don't really need any of that super expensive stuff so that's going to save you a lot of money you can use tungsten if you want but that's just what I'm using for personal preference today so how would fish this bait you see him run with it just got a pretty good bite on this thing pulled it right off the hook um you can actually tell where the fish bit it if you guys are wondering what type of line I'm using I usually range from 10 to 15 lb if I'm going to use something like this like a crawl I'd range between 12 to 15 um right here I'm using 15 lb cagar fluorocarbon that's what I would highly recommend on any crawl bait if you're flipping some really thick cover with this type of bait maybe even 20 lb would be really great but personal preference I like 15 lb it's not too thick it's not going to break on you um it's just really great line in general especially for some crawls like this so if you're wondering what kind of places you really need to fish this crawl at you know tons of those bass when the sun CBS up they're going to get in a lot of that structure you know there's trees other vegetation there's grass there's all types of structure that those fish are going to get in this base going to be perfect especially when this bait's Texas Rig like this going to be perfect to flip in by that brush to flip in by those sticks to throw in that grass throw on the edge of the grass is going to be a perfect bait to get in between all that structure there are many ways you can work this bait it all depends on how those fish are going to be during the day you know those Fish can be really lethargic they can be really slow so you're going to be having to drag that bait on the bottom very very slow and then some days they're going to be a little bit aggressive where you're going to want to hop that bait kind of fast you're going to want to hop this bait right off the ground you're going to want to hop it a few times let it sink pump your Rod a few more times let it sink they're going to be aggressive they're going to want to eat it like that but then you're going to have those days where you want to throw your bait out there you want to let it sit you want to slowly drag it then there's also going to be those days where those fish are just so slow they're not wanting to chase after anything they're not wanting to be aggressive whatsoever you're going to want to throw that bait out there let it sit on the bottom for a little bit wait maybe 5 six seconds start to move a little bit more and then wait another 5 6 seconds it all depends on the day but there's tons of styles away there's tons of styles to work this bait if I had to use any Rod I would use either medium heavy or you can use a heavy power Rod this is a heavy power Rod this is a 73 heavy this is actually an Akuma TCS style rod on the re I have a Helios TCS reel and this is also by Akuma and this is a 71 to1 gear ratio reel that's really the gear ratio I would fade around with Rod 73 heavy you can also use a medium heavy but if you're going to flip and pitch and throw in some really thick cover I would definitely recommend a heavy even a extra heavy Rod to get this fish out of there I hope you guys enjoyed this video and got a few tips out of this video if you did and you want to see some more videos like this please hit that thumbs Thumbs Up Button definitely check out the hoax fish crawl and I'll catch you guys in the next video | KickinTheirBASSTV | UCq1McBIjys-xtjBpLskfa8Q | 2016-10-10 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 781 | 3,836 |
aPbXj6Vs7mI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPbXj6Vs7mI | World Catholic Association for Communication | Wikipedia audio article | si GN is official name world Catholic Association for communication is a Roman Catholic lay ecclesial movement for professionals in the communication media including press radio television cinema video media education internet and new technology it is a nonprofit organization with representation from over 100 countries it was formed in November 2001 by the merger of international Catholic Organization for cinema and audio-visual OCI see an international Catholic association for radio and television unda at its World Congress in Quebec in 2017 si GN is welcomed also former member organizations of the International Catholic Union of the press you see IP the word si GN is always in uppercase is a combination of the words sign and ignis Latin for fire it is not an acronym the Holy See has officially recognized si GN is as an International Association of the faithful and has included the world Catholic Association for communication also known as si GN is in its directory of international associations of the faithful published by the Pontifical Council for the laity before the dissolution of the Pontifical Council for Social Communications the governing body of si GN is included a representative of this Pontifical Council another Department of the Roman Curia Bo CIC unda and si GN is had also members and consulter Zin the Pontifical Council of Social Communications in June 2015 Pope Francis established a new Dyke a story of the Roman Curia with authority over all communications Offices of the Holy See and the Vatican City State including the Pontifical Council for Social Communications Holy See press office Vatican Internet service Vatican Radio Vatican Television Centre a servitor Romana vatican press it photographed service and vatican publishing house a representative of this new secretariat for communications as part of the governing body of si GN is si GN is has consultative status with UNESCO the Economic and Social Council of the United Nations in Geneva and New York City and the Council of Europe topic mission si GN is is a worldwide network working in media with the aim of alerting Christians to the importance of human communication in every culture and encouraging them to speak out in this sector si GN is which represents Catholic media in all the governmental and non-governmental organizations and institutions is committed to lobbying for policies to encourage communications that respect Christian values justice and human rights to involving media professionals in the dialogue on questions of professional ethics and to fostering ecumenical and interfaith cooperation in the media sector the mission of si GN is is to engage with media professionals and support Catholic communicators to help transform our culture's in the light of the gospel by promoting human dignity justice and reconciliation topic history the Catholic Church has a long history of engagement with the media of communications from the liturgy itself in manuscripts and print publishing in painting architecture and music but with the emergence and spread of new popular media in the latter half of the 19th century the church faced new challenges already in the 19th century Catholics considered the press and in the 20th century cinema and radio to be powerful modern popular media that could influence world views and moral values many Catholics including Pope Gregory the 16th and Pope Pius the 9th did not trust modernity and the popular media were no exception Gregory the sixteenth published in 1832 his encyclical murari vos on liberalism and religious and differed ISM that experience shows even from earliest times that cities renowned for wealth Dominion and glory perished as a result of this single evil namely a moderate freedom of opinion license of free speech and desire for novelty here we must include that harmful and never sufficiently denounced freedom to publish any writings whatever and disseminate them to the people which some dare to demand and promote with so great a clamor we are horrified to see what monstrous doctrines and prodigious errors are disseminated far and wide in countless books pamphlets and other writings which though small in weight are very great in malice in fact they blame them for the declining influence of religion in society modernity did not simply introduce technological and scientific innovations it enabled the dissemination of new ideologies based mostly on atheism and challenging the place of the church in society Pope Pius the ninth in 1864 condemned modernity liberalism and pestilential books pamphlets and newspapers however pope leo xiii wanted to build a bridge between the church and the modern world and started to promote Thomism the theology based on that of Thomas Aquinas in Anna temp to see if it might help to solve modern problems in 1888 leo xiii wrote that unconditional freedom of speech and publication could be tolerated later on in the 1920s pope pius xi encouraged the growth of catholic action professional catholics working and acting in the secular world including that of the modern media as a fruit of the contemporary catholic action you see IP was founded in Belgium in 1927 a year later the office Catholic Internacional du cinéma OCI C came into being in the Netherlands and the Bureau Catholic Internacional de radio diffusion bc ir in germany in 1946 bc ir became the International professional Catholic Association for radio and television under OSI I see onda and you see IP had similar objectives to bring together catholics already working as professionals in the media OC i see in the field of cinema unda in radio and television and you see IP in the press the interest of Catholics in the press and especially in the new media was understandable they saw the opportunities offered by the mass media to present their views and opinions on life and the world and so they naturally became involved in promoting education and values these professional Catholic lay associations working in the world of the professional media wanted to unite their efforts against the secularization of society and were thus working in the secular world on the one hand they were aware that the press and the new media of radio and cinema were contributing to secularization on the other hand they also believed that by engaging in these media and above all the secular media they could use them as a new means of evangelization efforts had to be made to evangelize the secular mass media or at least to insert the values of the gospel into them as a result of the merger of the Catholic media organizations Oh CIC and unda si GN is was founded in 2001 the archives of O CIC and under are located in the documentation and Research Center for religion culture and society co doc at the Catholic University of Louvain KU Leuven in 2014 the Vatican suggested that si GN is should also integrate the members of the former International Catholic Union of the press you see IP which a few years earlier had lost its recognition by the Holy See as an official Catholic organization at the si GN is World Congress of 2017 in Quebec several Catholic press associations former members of UCI P were welcomed among them cpa catholic press association of the united states and canada topic Catholics and cinema Catholics were involved in the new art of cinema from its inception in november 1895 the Catholic University of Louvain organized a screening of the agooo stand Lewis Lumiere films in April to May 1898 the Englishman William Kennedy Laurie Dixon of the american mutoscope and biography company cinematograph pope leo xiii in the gardens of the vatican it was the first time that a pope appeared before a film camera and blessed it and the spectators later when cinema became a regular and popular medium Catholics and above all the parish priests reacted in two ways condemning it are considering it as a tool of evangelization with worldwide influence on families and above all on young audiences in several countries worldwide priests started to use cinema as part of their apostolate among them there was the Jesuit priests known as abbe a Joseph joy in Switzerland before the arrival of cinema he projected images with a magic lantern for schoolchildren and from 1902 on he used cinema early film producers like pytheas found also inspiration in the Bible and in religions early 1907 an American film magazine published that from a modest beginning six or seven years earlier the films of The Passion of Jesus Christ became more and more popular every Lent and were among the most expensive productions in the whole film world it wrote also that in these years in the u.s. most films of The Passion were coming from France and Great Britain from 1910 on almost every Belgian city had its Catholic cinema called mostly family cinema or patria in these cinema halls educational as well as entertainment films were on the program and the selection and screening were controlled by the organizers mostly priests one of the Belgian pioneers was a be able bro II who was active in the Catholic Action movement and began to bring order to these Catholic initiatives by the 1920s he was convinced that it was necessary to inform the public of the moral value of films his aim was not to limit the action of Catholics to moral quotations he wanted a presence on all fronts that is why as early as 1921 he joined a group of Catholics who had founded a distribution agency under the name Bravo films he became one of the leading personalities as president of OSI I see in the 1930s in the field of cinema faux CIC itself was the result of international politics in 1919 the League of Nations was established in Geneva with the objective to prevent another world war by promoting a culture of peace and dialogue this was not only a matter of politicians and diplomats but also in a matter of the cultural world in 1922 a Technical Committee for culture the International Committee on intellectual cooperation CC was formed with personalities like Marie Curie Albert Einstein Gabriela Mistral and onry Bergson to shape the mind of the members of the League of Nations for example toward rectifying errors in textbooks which were alleged to be a mainspring of racial prejudices out of this committee came a permanent organization to study the development of cinema as a tool of Education only member states and international organizations were admitted to this organization in 1926 the International Union of Catholic women's leagues you ILFC since 1952 the world union of catholic women's organizations wuc wo urged catholics involved in cinema to build an international catholic cinema organization in order to have a say in the international film work of the League of Nations this led to the founding of Oh CIC in 1928 with its first secretary-general the French cannon Joseph Raymond who also became the secretary of the international educational cinematographic Institute ie CI of the League of Nations it was a way to counter the influence of those who had a negative attitude towards the Catholic world foe CIC developed a complex but largely positive approach to this new art it wanted to offer guidance to audiences and to discover and foster productions which promoted the same values as Christians did it wanted to inform lay Catholics and others in a professional way about the moral and artistic quality of films so that they could decide themselves if they would go and see a film or not it was the beginning of film education Oh CIC called for the creation of national organizations dealing with topics such as childhood families spirituality religion and cinema and film reviews an early form of media education it also expressed its intention to collaborate with the film industry one of its concerns was the promotion of good films both for education and entertainment this was one of the aspects put forward by the encyclical letter of pope pius xi on the motion picture vigilant akira published in 1936 the dominant perspective in this encyclical was cautious defensive and moralizing following the approach of the Legion of decency which had been founded by the US Catholic Church to launch a crusade against the abuses of the motion pictures after the Second World War the Vatican began to move closer to the approach taken by Oh CIC in the matters of cinema while undoh was much more involved in its development with specifically Catholic production for Catholic audiences Oh CIC soon realized that film production was beyond the funds and technical abilities of its members there were some hopes and flirtations with production in the early 1930s especially in the Netherlands but the members and leadership of Oh CIC saw that their work was in collaboration raishin in promoting exhibition distribution review and critical writing on cinema during Canon Jean Bernards presidency 1947 to 1972 the writing and reviews continued but the main development was the establishing of juries at International Film Festival's in collaboration with the directors and boards of the festival's beginning at the Brussels International Film Festival in 1947 and a year later at the Venice International Film Festival the O CIC jariya can began in 1952 this enabled o CIC to develop its criteria for its awards over these years one difficulty which emerged was a clash of perspectives on occasion with the decisions of the US Legion of decency which had been set up even with an oath of loyalty by the American bishops in 1934 the time of the enforcement of the Motion Picture code for all American film production in the 1950s the Americans indicated that some films which had 1o cic Awards were rated objectionable are condemned by the Legion and were concerned at this difference in moral perspective the philosophy behind the Legion of decency was not influential in Europe although the work of the Legion was acknowledged positively by pius xi in his encyclical letter vigilant akira 1936 then with changes in what could be portrayed on screen and how it could be portrayed fr Bernard had to face a controversy concerning the O CIC prize at the Venice Film Festival in 1968 which resulted in discussions with church authorities and the Vatican the jury gave its prize to Pier Paolo Pasolini avowed communist the winner of the 1964 award for his Gospel according to st. Matthew for his film Te'o Rama the controversy was inflamed by another spark when the Berlin Film Festival 1969 award went to John Schlesinger Oscar winner for Best Picture Midnight Cowboy this meant that after 40 years of activity Oh CIC was able to survive controversy articulate its aims and objectives and establish itself as what might be called a consciousness organization within the Catholic Church it did not set itself up as a censoring board which many assumes still when hearing that the Catholic Church has a cinema organization later some of its members nationally or regionally were part of the work of the Bishops Conference offering reviews classifications and advice which depended for its authority more on the bishops rather than Oh CIC preservation of film also became a concern the consequences for Oh CIC in terms of policy and power was that it could not be described as a sacristy organization later a six Inc description of how Oh CIC saw its scope as the president fr Peter Malone put forward at the audience with John Paul the second at the time of the merger of unda and O CIC and si GN is as both supporting Catholics who work in cinema and being a bridge between the Catholic Church and the professional world of cinema while explicitly religious films are appreciated Oh CIC came to realize that well made films grounded in humanity made the most impact a policy of seeing Christ in the marketplace the image of the marketplace was later embraced by John Paul the second referring to Paul's mixed hearing in the Athens marketplace the areopagus Acts of the Apostles 17 that media is that new era Pacus this policy has guided Oh see I see and the film work of s IGN is over the decades leading to the presence of O CIC juries at World Film Festival's national Oh see I see cinema Awards publications on the cinema of different nations especially from Africa movie reviews in publications and online promotion of particular films dialog with directors and film makers and offering advice on the release of films with particular Catholic inter stur controversies from The DaVinci Code to Antichrist from the 1930s on the Vatican began to have a closer interest in cinema with the letter of pius xi in 1936 vigilant akira the official teaching of the church on cinema was positive even though the document began with vigilant care amongst the ideas put forward by pius xi was one that would challenge philosophers and theologians that cinema teaches the majority of men and women more effectively than abstract reasoning number 23 just over 20 years later Pius the 12th issued the encyclical letter Miranda versus 1957 where he urged his readers to learn how to understand and appreciate how film works one might say that he is urging people to move on from being literate literacy to being visual to visual C number 57 though the terminology as this authors rather than the Pope's in 1971 a fuller document on communications and media following the Second Vatican Council and its declaration on social communications in termer if Iike 1963 spoke about the spirituality dimensions to be found in cinema commune yet progressí Oh 1971 knows 142 to 144 dialogue was a significant feature of the writings of Paul the sixth from his first encyclical ecclesiam tuam his church 1964 to Evangeline une t on D announcing the good news 1975 och Xperia T khals 1937 to 2001 the first publication newsletter 1937 to 1945 in March 1937 the first newsletter of O CIC was published in Brussels it was only in French it was mini a graft and produced in the office and the first issue counted five pages send by post to the members and other stakeholders although it was not in German the newsletter informations de la cick had all so a German title metal engine day internationales Cathal ition film burro when the war started in Belgium in May 1940 the publication didn't continue it was picked up in November 1944 by Felix more lioness less formations de los ik bulletin of the OSI IC office catholic international du cinéma international catholic office for film affairs continuation of the bulletin formerly published at six route reverse tear brussels only a few issues were published in the last came out in 1947 when the situation in Belgium had become normal in 1949 the International Film review English edition and review and tear Nationale du cinéma french edition was launched under the direction of andre rushkoff ski and published in Luxembourg later a Spanish edition was published in Madrid revista Internacional del cine containing not the same articles as in its French and English edition a German Edition began a Trier in 1951 this important illustrated publication directed after the departure of rushkoff ski by Pierre Dondre and then by the jesuit emmanuel Flippo in paris reached more than 170 issues in the first years it became worldwide and eye-opener for the professional film world and film journalists and film historians it gave a lot of attention to non American cinema European Asian Latin American in 1955 it published a special issue dedicated to film ology the at that time new way of approaching film analysis in 1948 the OCI see board members did meet the founder of film ology in Paris Gilbert Cohen say ah the film festival in Venice in 1973 through lack of funds Oh CIC reverted to its bulletin Oh CIC information published in French Spanish and English which had then existed already more than 20 years after an issue Xero published in July 1952 Oh CIC did launch at the end of that year for the second time informations of OSI I see the result of a decision taken at the general committee of OSI I see at its Madrid meeting there was obviously the International Film review but this was the magazine which was mostly directed to the secular film world and to make clear that Catholic professionals were contributing and developing in a positive way to the International film culture it needed a contact or an intern bulletin between the general secretariat and its members the national catholic film centers an information bulletin which was focused upon the life and activities of OCI see itself containing reports on the International and national meetings activities discussions ends on it was also published in French Spanish and French the aim was to bring together the activities of the members and the representation of the organization in the secular world such as UNESCO Council of Europe ECOSOC and the United Nations and the collaboration with the other international Catholic organizations such as Pax Christi or vise it was also me Mia graphed and produced in the office in 1979 the new Secretary General Robert molehunt started again a quarterly magazine called first Oh CIC info in different language versions French English and Spanish Illustrated and printed on the own printing machine offset press in Brussels first transforming the internal bulletin into an international periodical for internal and external use in 1988 it changed its name into cine media and gradually it became a trilingual international quarterly magazine it wanted to show the world Oh CIC activities of the General Secretariat and its members and reflections on cinema in the secular world of the need to have a new internal bulletin was felled and Oh CIC info did appear once more it existed till the and of 2001 the momento CIC merged with unda into si GN is General Secretariat location in 1928 Oh CIC was founded in the Dutch city den hog the first Secretary General was Reverend Raymond who got the Secretariat established in Paris in 1933 the Secretariat moved from Paris to Leuven Belgium where the new president bro II and the new Secretariat Bernard were two years later the staff moved to Brussels to the Rue traversée air this office was occupied from 1940 to 1944 and after the war it was the new Secretary General Yvonne de Hempton who integrated the Secretariat in her home at the Rue de lor may also in Brussels from 1946 to 1996 where it had to be abandoned due to ex procreation and the project of the government to demolish the building for a new construction which till 2018 was not done between 1996 and 2001 the Secretariat found a home in a Catholic school also in Brussels rucifee R where it got a whole wing of four floors and an enormous basement to its disposal General Assemblies World Congress of O CIC and its international study days 1928 LaHaye foundation of the International Catholic office for cinema 1929 Munich with the BCI our first International Congress General Assembly of Oh CIC 1933 Brussels with the Belgian Centre Catholic d'action cinematograph aji CCAC reorganization of the international organization with international study days 1938 Vienna cancelled because of the international political situation and sloughs of Austria by Nazi Germany Oh CIC was anti-nazi 1947 Brussels World Congress of Oh CIC with international study theme on Catholic action in cinema considered in the light of the teachings of the encyclical vigilant Akira 1950 Rome international study days on spiritual values in the film profession 1951 Luzerne international study days on Christian film critic 1952 Madrid international study days on film education 1953 Malta International study days on cinema and the missions 1954 cologne international study days on the morale classification of films 1955 Dublin international study days on the distribution and the influence of the moral classification of films 1957 havana world congress with international study days on the promotion of good films by film associations 1958 Paris international study days on the promotion of good films for a broad public 1960 Vienna International study days on cinema youth and the government 1962 Montreal World Congress with unda and international study days on creators of films and television productions 1964 Venice International study days on cinematographic exhibition and its function towards the audience 1966 Cuernavaca international study days at Ivan Illich is center C IDoc centro intercultural D document asean on the apostolate of cinema in the light of the Second Vatican Council 1967 Berlin international study days during the Berlin Film Festival with inter film the International Protestant organization for film on communication creation the sacred and cinema the visualization of the relations man and women in the film and the film Ferrand with children 1968 Bharath World Congress of Oh CIC with international study days on cinema at the service of evangelization 1971 GW ATT International and inter-confessional with interfilm meeting in Switzerland on short films and audio-visual programs at the service of the Christian message 1972 Deauville World Congress of Oh CIC with study days on cinema and the human development the name of Oh CIC has changed into international Catholic organization for cinema 1975 Petropolis World Congress of Oh CIC with international study days on cinema as a communication instrument between human beings 1977 Munich World Congress with international study days on cinema as a means of human promotion and the encounter between cultures 1980 Manilla World Congress of Oh CIC with international study days on cultural and social influence of foreign films 1983 Nairobi World Congress of Oh CIC with the common Oh CIC under international study days on communication and human promotion the challenges today with common study days with unda and the keynote speech of seán MacBride 1987 Quito World Congress of Oh CIC with the common under Oh see I see study days on Culture Media and gospel values with a keynote speech of the polish filmmaker Christophe Sanusi 1990 bang coupe World Congress of OC I see and under with study days on the new media age and it's challenge 1994 prague world congress of OC i see and under with study days on media and human dignity 1998 montreal world congress of OC i see and under with study days on creativity in the media sphere spiritual opportunity 2001 Rome World Congress of Oh CIC and unda murdering into si GN is topic Catholics and radio and television catholic radio producers had realized by the mid of the 1920s that radio had become like cinema an important means of spreading ideas and could therefore influence the views of millions and connect them to christian values already in December 1923 the radio world was waiting for the first international move of the churches to bring religion by means of radio to humanity this was put forward because in the Vatican the Pope was interested to spread the Christian message to all over the earth the company of ghuli Elmo Marconi was already involved in building a radio to transmit the voice of the Holy Father to almost every land it became a race against time because the Protestants had the same plans to be present in the world via the new invention which was the radio in the USA the first Catholic stations went on the air in 1925 in Canton Ohio Yakima Washington and East st. Louis that same year the Paulist fathers established WL WL their own radio station in new york the aim was acquainting the public with the Catholic viewpoint of current affairs quote dot fr Joseph max Orly Superior General specified this in saying that the station intended to be the official mouthpiece of everything Catholic we want especially to reach isolated communities where there is no Catholic Church quote dot all lasted only a few years that year the dominican FR lambert / quinn founded the catholic radio broadcasting company k ro in the netherlands as did the socialist association of works amateurs vara and a near later the liberal Protestant radio broadcasting company European Catholic broadcasters did meet for the first time in May 1927 in Cologne Germany while attending an international press exhibition organised by dr. Konrad Adenauer the mayor of the city they decided to gather again a year later to discuss the create a permanent International Organization for Catholics in radio this meant not only Catholic radio but also Catholics working in non Catholic radio stations in 1928 they did found the bureau Catholic International de radio diffusion be Cir in Cologne during their meeting in June of that year the name bi CR changed after the war into under the president of BC IR was fr / Qin th re director was Monsignor Bernard Marshall responsible for the Catholic radio in Germany and of the be Cir General Secretariat in Cologne II at its first International Congress 1929 in Munich bi CR drew attention to the importance of radio for religious cultural and social life it issued a blueprint for action decisions for Catholics and broadcasting it also established criteria for membership National Committee's representing Catholic individuals and groups professionally are passed orally engaged in broadcasting in that spirit BCI are invited Catholics to collaborate with radio companies private or public in making religious programs and to foster Christian values in 1930 BCI are established formal liaison with the geneva-based Union Internacional de radio diffusion BC IR was also asked to help in organizing Vatican radios first broadcast and to advise them in this new communication domain in the 1930s Catholic broadcasters worldwide had an optimistic view of the development of radio and later of the new medium of television it could transcend frontiers and bring peoples and cultures together it could be a means of exchanging cultural values a way of fostering mutual understanding radio was thought of as the means par excellence for reconciling people's fostering fellowship among nations and promoting peace like Oh CIC BC I are also developed different aspects of media education due to the arrival of the Nazis into power the BCI our General Secretariat moved in 1935 from Germany to Amsterdam fr / Quinn resigned and Monsignor Marshall became the new president and the Dutch Dominican fr John dito Oh P of the kr Oh became the new general secretary after world war ii and during the succeeding decades these principles found new expression in radio and television activities in 1946 bc ir changed its name to unda which is latin for wave its objectives were to help coordinate professional and apostolic activities of catholics in radio and television to promote collaboration among members through conferences publications information exchanges research to represent internationally the interests of members to help meet communications needs of members to help meet communications needs of the third world and to collaborate with non Catholic organizations having similar objectives in February 1958 for example participants from 12 countries came together in the second ever International Television Festival the first was the Prix Italia in the world organized in Monte Carlo by unda this TV festival was supported by Prince Rainier the third who inspired by this event created the festival de televisión de Monte Carlo three years later Ando was asked to give a prize at this festival and this tradition has carried on by si GN is from April 26 to 30 1954 Honda conducted an International Congress for radio TV specialists and professionals from 32 countries attended to talk about preaching via radio and television family and radio and television with Fr a Nellis and Ruo FM working for the BBC and so on at the end of the meeting the under General Assembly elected fr cours o P as president two months later unded did found the Department of Television which was a sub Secretariat directed in Paris by the Dominican Fr Raymond Picard Opie he started to develop a network of 80 TV specialists in 20 countries and published a monthly international Catholic TV review in February 1954 unda organized the first international Catholic Conference for television in Paris and had a theme the status of Catholic television and its place within national broadcasting systems due to conference the first Eurovision broadcasting could be worked out with the Eurovision officials at the European broadcast Union the Pope could give a message in Italian French German English and Dutch on Pentecost Sunday topic Christian television weeks in the 1969 the European members of unda and a Europe and WACC organized the first joint Christian television week at Monte Carlo television stations and networks from 16 countries submitted a total of 52 programmes for competition in three categories drama entertainment and news documentary participation worldwide it is done both unda and wacc but they take turns as chief organizer when unda is responsible it delegates the job to its european affiliates the idea is to be an ecumenical forum for fostering TV programs of high professional standard which reflect the vision of Christianity and values proper to men since then the event occurred every two years 1969 Monte Carlo 1971 baden-baden 1973 Salzburg 1975 Bryden 1977 Montreux 1979 Stockholm 1981 Amsterdam 1983 Dublin 1989 Hilversum 1995 buckston 1998 to lose you topic undisputable x' 1934 to 2001 the 1934 publication of the first BCI our bulletin represents a principal aim of the organization through its entire history to collect and diffuse information and documentation on broadcasting Catholics working in the church but above all in the secular world of broadcasting the organization first be Cir and then unda published in his monthly woollen a quarterly review or both news for and about the members coverage of major BCI are under events commentaries on official church events and pronouncements topis in broadcasting matters of professional technical or pastoral interest and announcements decisions of the organization's governing authorities in its history the publications were mostly in English and wrench but sometimes a number of editions were published in German and Spanish it aimed a readership which were not only its members and church related institutions but also the professional world listeners and viewers BCI our bulletin a quarterly published between 1934 to 1945 in French edited by Paul and rien speed of kr o the Netherlands undo bulletin published in 1948 in Freiburg Switzerland under documentation a quarterly review was launched in December 1976 in 1952 fr Raymond Picard published monthly international Catholic TV review topic General Assemblies of BC IR and on de 1928 cologne foundation of the Bureau Catholic Internacional de radio diffusion BC IR 1929 Munich together with Oh CIC 1936 Prague 1947 cry borg with the installation of the new general secretariat in freiburg and with the new name of under wave 1951 madrid 1953 cologne 1955 vienna the themes of the Assembly's study sessions the priest before the microphone broadcasting in the service of Education and liturgy and television 1957 Geneva 1960 Monte Carlo 1960 to Montreal the theme of the Assembly's study sessions broadcasting and basic education in Latin America and Africa 1965 Rome the theme of the Assembly's study sessions the Christian conscience and radio and television in a world characterized by change 1968 Munich 1971 New Orleans 1974 Dublin the theme of the Assembly's study sessions mass media has instruments for evangelization and human development 1977 Namur the theme of the assembiy study sessions the needs of our society and the response of mass media 1980 Manila the theme of the Assembly's study sessions the role of unda in a world of media 1983 Nairobi World Congress unda with the common under Oh CIC international study days on communication and human promotion the challenges today with common study days with unda and the keynote speech of seán MacBride 1987 Kido World Congress unda with the common under OC I see international study days on Culture Media and Gospel values 1990 bang coop World Congress of unda with the common you DNA Oh CIC international study days on the new media age and it's challenge 1994 Prague World Congress of under the common under OC I see international study days on media and human dignity 1998 Montreal World Congress of unda with the common under OC I see international study days on creativity in the media sphere spiritual opportunity 2001 Rome concluded with the merger with OC I see into si GN is topic Catholics and the press in the 19th century Catholic newspapers and magazines were founded in countries across the world the first Catholic diocesan paper in the US for example was the Catholic miscellany launched in Charleston South Carolina in 1822 and in 1842 the first Catholic newspaper ala propagate or Catholic in Louisiana was French before 1914 there were Catholic journalist associations in the United States CPA other publications were founded by religious orders and by lay Catholics with a desire to give a voice to the church in the public sphere notable examples are the tablet launched in Britain in 1840 by Frederick Lucas a convert to Catholicism the universe launched in Britain in 1860 by Archibald Dunn the Catholic press and Australian newspaper in Srilanka the layman john fernando founded the non artha pretty pious in Halle language Catholic weekly as a four-page broad sheet of church news and papal speeches in 1865 in 1886 more than two decades after it started Colombo archdiocese became the weeklies official owner it is one of the oldest Catholic newspapers in Asia the assumption is launched Lacroix as a daily newspaper in france in 1883 in 1910 the first Congress for Brazilian Catholic journalists found place and the Catholic National Press Agency o centro de boa imprensa which aim was to send quality articles to the many small Catholic journals and periodicals all over the country was organized before 1914 there were Catholic journalist associations in the United States CPA Belgium Italy France Germany and elsewhere in Asia Catholic newspapers appeared also in 1927 young lake athletes published the Catholic Times of Korea during Japanese colonial rule at the end of 1927 the International Bureau of Catholic Journalists later renamed the Federation of national of catholic journalists was founded in paris in 1928 the permanent Commission of Catholic publishers and directors of Catholic newspapers came into being in Cologne in Germany more and more Catholic newspapers were launched worldwide in the coming years as the Malaysian bishops did on the 5th of January 1935 with the still existing Malaya Catholic leader mcl published in Singapore in 1930 the first Universal Congress of Catholic journalists was organized in Brussels the International Bureau of Catholic journalists planned actions to train Catholic journalists to establish Catholic press agencies and to come up with ways to develop the Catholic press action in 1935 pius xi did set up a world exposition of the press in the vatican the heart of fascist Italy in which there was no press freedom that year it was decided to have formal statutes for the International Bureau of Catholic journalists in 1935 the two organizations the International Bureau of Catholic journalists and the permanent Commission of Catholic publishers and directors of Catholic newspapers federated into an international union of the Catholic press in Marseille these statutes were presented to the Vatican at the second International Congress of Catholic journalists in September 1936 in Rome that year count Giuseppe da Latorre of the AA servitor Romano became the president of the Association in 1937 the Dominican Fr Felix more Lyon linked with O CIC proposed an international newsletter of the film press to be established in Breda where the secretariat of the international union of the catholic press i UCP u CIP was based at the annual meeting of the directors of the i UCP in budapest in 1938 it was decided that the three universal congress of the catholic press would be held in Poland in September 1939 but it could not be held due to the outbreak of the second world war finally the Congress was held in Rome in 1950 with for the first time vice presidents from french-speaking Canada and the United States although the CPA became a member only in 1955 after the war the secretariat of the organization was transferred to Paris the 4th Congress was held in Paris in May 1954 on the theme the Catholic press in the world its mission its future with the participation of 250 journalists from 28 countries at the U CIP Congress in Vienna in 1957 with 400 participants from 32 countries it was stated that one of the aims of the Catholic press was to become a trusted source of information for non Catholics in 1963 pope john xxiii declared in his encyclical pacem in Terris peace on earth freedom of speech and publication to be a human right one of the significant congresses was the one held in 1965 in New York it was UCI peas 8th Congress held together with the 55th annual convention of the CPA and 800 journalists including 600 from the United States discussed the theme the truth in the search for freedom the discussions were about freedom in politics in art in the press and the relation between freedom and Authority freedom and civic rights and freedom and the international order afterwards the name was changed to international Catholic Union of the press you see IP at his 50th anniversary in 1977 the 12th World Congress of you see IP was held in Vienna bringing together 350 participants it was preceded by a meeting of about 50 delegates from so called third world countries a major theme was the new world order of information and communication nomic its 18th World Congress was held in Paris at UNESCO headquarters with some 1000 Catholic journalists from all over the world together among about 400 members of UC ip's young journalists network who had their own convention three days before the main World Congress Teresa ie Chui of Malaysia was elected as the first woman president was elected it was also the first Asian and first non-european president on the 19th of September 2001 a few days after the attack on the World Trade Center towers more than a thousand participants attended the 20th UCI P Congress at the University of Freiburg Switzerland to discuss the theme the media at the challenge of globalization Congress delegates issued a statement in which they condemned terrorism as well as all acts of violence against innocent victims they pleaded for dialogue reconciliation and peace the meeting of reporters editors and professors of journalism and communication aim to give the opportunity to understand and analyze globalization in both its positive and negative effects two days before the Congress the international meeting of young journalists a branch of UC IP was held despite the reluctance of the Vatican the UCI P adopted somewhat later new statutes that allow the reception of non-catholics due to administrative mismanagement of the elections of the board of UCI P of 2007 at the 22nd Congress in Sherbrooke Canada and other issues the Vatican withdrew recognition of UCI P as a Catholic Association following a formal statement made by the Vatican resulting from the serious management crisis the organization has been experiencing for years you CIP International Catholic press union was no longer able to use the adjective Catholic topic you see ip's periodicals in 1952 the first newsletter was sent out from the Paris General Secretariat of you CIP it was published in french as bulletin international de l'épée and in spanish later editions were also published in german and english between 1961 and 1972 of by material publication called journalist days catholics 65 issues were published by the UCI p secretary-general the french assumption is fr emile gebel 1908 to 1968 topic General Assemblies of you CIP 1930 Brussels Belgium first World Congress of the Catholic press 1936 Rome Italy second International Congress of Catholic journalists 1950 Rome Italy three nd you ICP World Congress 1954 Paris France fourth you ICP World Congress on the Catholic press in the world its mission and its future May 1957 Vienna Austria fifth you ICP World Congress 1960 Santander Spain sixth you ICP World Congress 1963 Rome Italy seventh you ICP World Congress 1965 New York USA eighth you ICP World Congress 1968 Berlin West Germany ninth you see IP World Congress 1971 Luxembourg 10th you see IP World Congress 1974 Buenos Aires Argentina 11th you see IP World Congress 1977 Vienna Austria 12th you see IP World Congress 1980 Rome Italy 13th you CIP World Congress 1983 dublin era 14th you CIP World Congress 1986 New Delhi India 15th you CIP World Congress 1989 Roop holding Germany 16th you CIP congress 1992 Campos do jordão Brazil 17th you CIP World Congress 1995 Graz Austria 18th you CIP World Congress 1998 Paris France 19th you CIP World Congress on the press a medium for tomorrow 2001 pry Borg Switzerland 20th you CIP World Congress on media and the challenge of globalization 2004 Bangkok Thailand 21 th you CIP World Congress on media challenges amidst cultural and religions pluralism for a new social order justice and peace 2007 Sherbrooke Canada you CIP World Congress on media and religion risk her opportunity 2010 Waga dugu burkina faso you CIP World Congress topic Catholics in radio television cinema and press working together from the 1960s unda and OC IC began to hold joint meetings and assemblies and incorporated work on the small and grassroots media that were then being developed after the under OC IC Congress in Manila in 1980 the first joint meeting of the boards of unda and OC IC was held in Washington in 1982 to study mutual relations a commission led by the American fr John Genie CSP suggested that the two organizations should merge but at the World Congress in Quito of 1987 the proposal was not accepted intense collaboration yes but no merger this decision was a paradox because a few days earlier the latin-american branches of the three Catholic organizations for the press cinema and radio and TV UCLA POC ICL and Al had created a joint Secretariat to cover all the media but the rest of the world did not follow them the 1980s saw the proliferation of video use soon followed by rapid developments in information technology and the growth of digital media and the internet between UC IP Honda and OSI I see there were always contacts as the offices of ossie IC and since the 1970s Korando were also in Belgium these contacts were easy and friendly all three organizations were represented on the board of the Catholic media council in Aachen Germany from 1977 to 1991 later the bonds became closer in the 1980s and 1990s see ip's president was the belgian luis meets 1937 to 2007 at the UCI P World Congress in Pattaya Thailand in 1996 mies appealed for closer ties with OSI IC and unda he said you see IP Oh see I see and under members could train Catholic journalists and work together in a way that reflected sincere faith and make Catholic mean quality since many members of unda and Oh CIC worked in several media and since media ministry was cross media the impetus for a combined Catholic association for audio-visual media grew ever stronger eventually leading to the merger of unda and OSI I see as si GN is on the 21st of November 2001 in Rome following the demise of UC IP in 2011 s IGN is opened up membership to Catholic journalists and at the si GN is World Congress of 2017 in Quebec several Catholic press associations former members of UCI P were welcomed into si GN is among them the CPA Catholic press Association of the United States and Canada topic Catholics and media education si GN is recognizes the power of the media and their influence in all aspects of individual community and social life media education is seen as a movement from a critical awareness of the languages and techniques of the media through analysis of the values they project and their influence on our lives towards a responsible participation in the use of media for the betterment of the person and society it is a way to enable the citizen to examine the process of media production media strategies media ownership the ways knowledge and meaning are made as well as media's immense power for empowerment the areas covered by si GN is in this perspective are very diverse advertising radio popular music film television video and internet the media educated person is able to create his or her own media statements to engage confidently with media producers and to exercise actively his or her rights as a democratic citizen so it is understandable that this work is one of the most important fields of action of si GN is the SI gnis media education project aims to bring together worldwide experiences and achievements in this field si GN is members want to come together to use financial material and human resources more effectively so that they can give a coherent response to the onslaught of national and global media on people and cultures across the world si GN is wants to build a world network of media educators and/or media education organizations something which doesn't yet exist the predecessors of si GN is unda and OC IC had a very long tradition in this field in the 1950s for example in 1954 the president of O CIC Mons jean-bernard from Luxembourg was one of those who with Eunice Co gave a decisive push which led to the foundation of the International Centre for films for children and young people CIF ej and a year later the belgian fr Leo lunders o P of o CIC became a founder of CIF EJ in the 1960s and 1970s the organization supported the planned any in Latin America and from 1987 to 2001 unde a widowed CIC produced its edge a communication magazine or in French edge of communication nouvelles you topic Catholics in the digital world from the 1970s on the digital world did start expanding worldwide also in the Catholic world the home computer meant that the digital world was entering fast into mass culture It was as if it absorbed the bits and digits of mass culture like a lightening fire the arrival of the first real digital camera in 1988 changed a lot even more when Photoshop shortly after came into being a year later the world wide web was invented and soon became accessible for the general public around 1995 Internet and the digital sound and images in all media and communications were introduced quickly mass culture became digital in 1997 the first social networking website 6° dot-com was launched nine years later Facebook entered the world social media became definitely part of the digital world and often attracts all the attention of the user day and night the digital evolution has entered into virtually every part of life and society from young children to adults and the elderly Catholic communicators were attentive to this evolution all this shapes a greater part of the world view and view of life of ever more people which implies ethical aspects the Vatican was also alert to this evolution the Pontifical Council for social communications P CSS published a series of documents on this topic such as ethics in advertising 1997 ethics in communications 2000 and ethics in internet 2001 during the discussion which led to this document on ethics in internet pope john paul ii supported the reflection of the peace ESS he felt the urgency to have a kind of guidance in this field in ethics in Internet he considered the digital as a great health to the churches pastors and faithful in facing the many challenges of the emerging media culture he wrote opportunities created by new technology by the process of globalization by deregulation and privatization of the media present new ethical and indeed spiritual challenges to those who work in social communications these challenges will be met effectively by those who accept that serving the human person building up a community grounded in solidarity justice and love and speaking the truth about human life and its final fulfillment in God were are and will remain at the heart of ethics in the media in ethics in Internet the ethical questions asked were multiple will it contribute to authentic human development and community building well the digital divide favors social and economic justice will it not be dominated by one commercial secular culture will it guarantee the freedom of expression and the exchange of ideas will it serve serious journalism Pope Francis in his message for the 48th world communications Day 2014 calls the faithful to become boldly citizens of the digital world which can be an environment rich in humanity a network not of wires but of people personal engagement is the basis of the trustworthiness of a communicator Christian witness thanks to the Internet can thereby reach the peripheries of human existence from 1980 on this was a reinforced tendency for OSI IC and unda BR Ferdinand Paz Wieck linked with OSI IC launched in 1981 his project to digitalize the Bible and to bring it in the digital new world for research the digital evolution or revolution had an indirect influence on the birth of si GN is in 1993 the General Secretariat of OSI I see with its Secretary General Robert molehunt introduced the email first with the missionary service of OC IC in Rome and then with the members worldwide the organization entered a new era of communication in the 1990s it was clear for unda Oh see I see and even you see IP that in the digital world the images and sounds television film music radio and journalism were dissolving the boundaries between the traditional media in 1996 Oh CIC organized at its fourth world video and multimedia forum in Cologne Germany a symposium on the computer and its global Empire the keynote was given by Derek dicker Cove his words on September 28 1996 in Cologne that the user of the Internet provides the content were prophetic Catholic communicators then asked him the question how will the technology use us at that time he couldn't give a clear answer but he drew attention to the possible ethical effects on the digital new world at the OCI sea under World Congress in Rome in 2001 at the birth of s IGN is a symposium seminar was given by webmasters in 2006 si GN is staff member Jim McDonald presented a paper to the EC IC in London linking media literacy and advocacy issues in 2008 a cover story on the changing media landscape which is the establishing of the digital world is published in s IGN is media 4's IGN is there is also the dimension of how the values of the gospel can be present and enhanced the digital age at the service for a better world for humankind at the SI gnis Quebec World Congress in June 2017 the board established a digital desk alongside the other desks cinema television radio media education journalism topic presidents and secretaries general of Oh CIC Honda you see IP and si GN is you topic you see IP Secretary General's and presidents 1927 to 2011 you see IP Secretary General's for the period 1927 to 2011 Joseph a George's France 1927 to 1940 hein Hoban the Netherlands 1935 to 1940 Jean Pierre du bois du May France 1950 to 1955 blooper Emil gabelle France 1955 to 1968 Lapierre Chevalier France 1974 to 1980 looper Bruno Holt's Switzerland 1984 to 1993 Joseph Tittel awfully India 1993 to 2011 you see IP president's for the period 1927 to 2011 grenade el forge Belgium 1927 to 1934 count Giuseppe dilatory Italy 1936 to 1960 Raimondo Manzini Italy 1960 to 1972 Luis Mears Belgium 1972 to 1981 sassman Austria 1980 to 1986 Gunther Meese Germany 1992 to 1998 Teresa EE Chui Malaysia 1998 to 2011 topic undersecretary generals and presidents 1928 to 2001 Under Secretary General's for the period 1928 to 2001 MGR Bernhard Marshall Germany 1928 to 1930 5p John Dido a the Netherlands 1935 to 1938 M Paul and rien speak the Netherlands 1938 to 1942 M Joseph deaning the Netherlands 1942 to 1950 M Francoise van Hoek Switzerland 1950 to 1952 P John dito up the Netherlands 1950 to 1953 P Bona Ventura Janssen up the Netherlands 1953 1954 fr Joseph newly Switzerland 1954 to 1971 fr John Stapleton UK 1971 to 1974 fr Jean de Soto's SJ Canada 1974 to 1981 fr Cole Murphy Ireland 1981 to 1994 fr Victor Sandridge India 1994 to 1998 fr Pierre Bellon j/sj Canada 1998 to 2001 under presidents for the period 1928 to 2001 P Lambert Henriques / Qin up the Netherlands 1928 to 1930 five MGR Bernhard Marshall Germany 1935 to 1938 fr John dito up the Netherlands 1938 to 1946 MGR F prosper Eenie Italy 1946 to 1948 P Johannes Benedict course up the Netherlands 1950 to 1960 to MGR Jacques Switzerland 1962 to 1968 fr Agnes Andrew OFM Scotland 1968 to 1980 P Anthony Scannell OFM cap USA 1980 to 1987 mr. Cheney wrong Monday and V change I Thailand 1987 to 1994 senior Angela and zukovsky MH sh USA 1994 to 2001 topic Oh see I see secretary generals and presidents 1928 to 2001 Oh CIC Secretary General's for the period 1928 to 2001 Rev Joseph Raymond France 1928 to 1933 fr jean-bernard Luxembourg 1935 to 1940 7fr Felix more Lyon Belgium 1944 1945 provisory Secretary General mrs. Evander Hempton Belgium 1947 to 1978 M Robert molehunt Belgium 1979 to 2000 - Oh see I see presidents for the period 1928 to 2001 dr. George Ernst Germany 1928 to 1933 can enable bro a Belgium 1933 to 1947 Rev jean-bernard Switzerland 1947 to 1972 Rev Lucien LaBelle Canada 1972 to 1980s our Ambrose I can Berger Opie Switzerland 1980 to 1990 fr Hank Hoekstra Oh Carm the Netherlands 1990 to 1998 fr Peter Malone MSC Australia 1998 to 2002 topic si GN is secretary generals and presidents 2001 si GN I asked presidents for the period 2001 fr Peter Malone MSC Australia 2001 to 2005 Amagi Loretha Sammy Malaysia 2005 to 2014 mas Davao Andujar Cuba 2014 to 2017 ms is Helen Osman USA 2017 si GN is Secretary General's for the period 2001 M Robert molehunt Belgium 2001 to 2005 M mark Ellen Switzerland 2006 2007 fr Bernardo suet Mozambique 2007 2008 ml veto de Souza Kenya 2008 to 2015 M Ricardo Y Anya's USA Argentina 2015 topic structure and activities of si GN is si GN is an international organization according to Swiss law has its General Secretariat in Brussels and a specialized technical office in Rome si GN is serviced Rome in 2015 si GN is chose Archbishop Oscar Romero as its patron because of his willingness to give his life rather than be silent in the face of justice Romero was canonized in October 2018 the organization's diverse programs cover different media communication fields and for each one a special department was founded called a desk it consists out of a president and a network of regional representatives each desk has a secretary who works with the General Secretariat in Brussels he or she is responsible for the coordination and the daily work of the desk the desks developed the different media communication fields promote the work of members in these fields and help coordinate meetings and training topic the cinema desk with the merger of OSI I see with unda into si GN is the presence in festivals of Catholic members of the organization not only continued but developed considerably it is one way of having contact with the professional world and also a way of bringing together in a jury professionals who are active in TV media education radio and film criticism bo CIC gave its very first prize to the Italian film viveur in pace by Luigi Zampa at the Brussels World Film Festival in 1947 the first award of si GN is went in 2002 to the Egyptian film by Magda Ahmed Ali Azhar al banna the secret of the young girl at the Milan African Film Festival in 2017 si GN is juries representing the national and international members of si GN is were in Venice san sebastian mar del plata buenos aires cavana Montevideo Milan Toulouse Washington Tehran Santo Domingo Zanzibar waha dugu religion today booze Ansan and Hong Kong si GN is has continued the ecumenical dialogue in cinema which started in 1974 at the Locarno Film Festival in 2017 si GN is representatives collaborated with members of the International interger CH organization for film si GN is continued also the ecumenical dialogue in cinema which started in 1974 at the Locarno Film Festival in 2017 si GN is representatives collaborate with members of the International Protestant Organization for film int ERF ILM in 17 international film festivals to award an ecumenical prize can Berlin Freiburg Oberhausen Locarno Kyiv Cottbus Leipzig Mannheim Heidelberg mantri yerevan Karlovy Vary zlin Lingle Saarbrucken and warsaw this policy of dialogue with other Christian churches was extended in 2002 to other religions in inter-religious juries the first interfaith jury was organized in Tehran in 2003 at the Fator Film Festival this jury comprises two jury members selected by SI gnis and one or two muslim jury members selected by the festival the jury has to consider for its award a new Iranian feature film the idea of jury representatives from different faiths was followed by the Brisbane Film Festival 2003 to 2009 9 2005 Dhaka Bangladesh 2006 and Leipzig since 2016 si GN is develops this dialogue according to the criteria of the Pontifical Council for Social Communications published in 1989 in which manipulation are based proselytism at times practiced in the media is incompatible with the ecumenical tasks and with the spirit of inter-religious cooperation and as the decisions of ecclesiastical authorities of firm topic the TV desk si GN is supports the production and distribution of quality TV programs throughout the world in organizing seminars that bring together TV producers programmers and channels searching for opportunities for co-production or collaboration si GN is also collaborates with the Catholic radio and television network CR TN it continues and develops the work of unda in the different TV festivals which started in the late 1950s in Monte Carlo in the following years under head juries at other international TV festivals like it Prix Italia and at the Golden Rose in Montreux in 2017 it gave prizes for the best of television in festivals at the International Television Festival of Monte Carlo at the Prix Italia and at the plural Plus festival every three years the si GN is European region Co organises with the WACC Europe a European television festival of religious programs hosted by different national public broadcasters the 2017 edition took place in Paris in June in November 2003 s IGN is held its first workshop for Catholic radio stations in eastern and southern Africa in Cape Town South Africa its aim was to encourage networking and collective strategic planning to enable Catholic radio stations on the continent to better face the challenges and opportunities arising in their regions si GN is was asked by these radios to concentrate its efforts within the existing ecclesiastical regional structures in Africa efforts were to be directed at strengthening local capacities within these existing structures rather than creating separate structures for networking radios in Africa to avoid duplication and unnecessary competition with existing church structures at the 2005 si GN is World Congress in lyon for the first time a selected international panel of national and international catholic radio networks as well as some major international catholic radio stations from all around the world were brought together in a consultative seminar for catholic radio networks you topic international s IG is TV desk seminars of Catholic TV producers the seminar is open to Catholic television stations channels institutions producers and production centers the aim is to build a network and to share capacities enable co-productions and build a professional community the first Secretary General of s IGN is Robert molehunt did initiate the TV seminars in 2003 with the first meeting in Cape Town 2003 Cape Town South Africa in conjunction with the sizing the television market and the si GN is board meeting 2004 Strasbourg France in conjunction with the si GN is board meeting 2005 Prague Czech Republic 2005 lyon france in conjunction with the si GN is world congress 2006 madrid spain in conjunction with the world congress of Catholic television an initiative of the Pontifical Council for Social Communications vatican 2007 bucharest romania in conjunction with the international festival on children's rights an initiative of both si GN is Romania and UNICEF 2008 buenos aires argentina 2009 chiang mai thailand in conjunction with the SI g and is world congress 2010 luxembourg 2011 Costa Rica with the theme new media new audiences and the challenges faced by Catholic producers 2013 Nero B Kenya with the theme media for development 2014 st. Petersburg Russia with the theme dialog of churches dialogue of cultures 2015 apparati de Brazil with the theme knowing your audience connecting to the periphery 2016 type of Taiwan with the theme imaging the church in media television and journalism 2018 dublin era with the theme beyond production marketing for maximum impact topic the radio desk si GN is supports the development of community radio and Catholic radio stations and promotes existing radio networks and associations radio is still an important medium si GN is is involved in Catholic and community radios all over the world and especially in Africa si GN is does not intend to establish its own Catholic radio networks rather si GN is seeks to reinforce existing networks and encourage interaction between networks to enhance the shared learning experience si GN is policy is one of subsidiarity and promoting professional collaboration si GN is services Rome provides technical consultation and equipment for radio stations especially in Africa it helps with training logistics and building networks for its members you topic the journalists desk since 2014 si GN is has been actively working to offer a space for former members of UC IP and other catholic journalists organizations in si GN is in some cases Catholic journalists are fully integrated into existing si GN is national structures as for example in Brazil are Hungary but the situation varies widely from country to country since 2014 si GN is has aimed to offer a place of exchange in solidarity for those Catholics working in all forms of journalism and publishing it aims to promote ethical professional journalism in the new multimedia era to build a global network for Catholic journalists working across different media in different regions to strengthen solidarity and personal ties among Catholic journalists through regular sharing of stories and information and to support freedom of expression and the rights of journalists the first international seminar for Catholic journalists and writers was organized by si GN is in Kuala Lumpur some 20 Catholic journalists came from Pakistan Korea the Philippines Vietnam Thailand Indonesia India Japan Cambodia Malaysia Sri Lanka Bangladesh and Singapore topic the media education desk in 2007 si GN is representatives from Asia Africa the Pacific Latin America North America and Europe initiated the s IGN is media education project Sigma aimed at setting up a global media education network and set out a si GN is charter on media education in 2008 regional meetings were held in Asia and Europe to ratify this charter and elaborate regional media education plans since 2014 the newly formed media education desk refocused its attention to develop and empower young communicators around the world in order to concretely reach its goal si GN is developed an intensive immersion and exposure communication program for young communicators the comm la vie communication laboratory since then participants from Asia Africa and North America have graduated from comm la B topic the digital desk the SI gnis desk is founded at the SI gnis Quebec World Congress in June 2017 si GN is explores how best this new technology can be harnessed to serve the common good and enhance the quality of communication for the majority of people one of Si gnis main objectives as to help reduce the digital divide between those countries closely connected to the global digital highways and those in the poorer regions of the world which are still struggling to connect to their own towns and villages for this si GN is services Rome provides an internet service via satellite that covers all of Africa the VSATs system you topic General Assemblies and World Congress's of si GN is every four years the assembly of delegates of si GN is has to meet face to face to elect or re-elect its president vice president's and to nominate the Secretary General this meeting brings together members of the Association from across the globe it contains also a series of workshops seminaries to share experiences keynote speeches of specialists in different fields of communication a film program a board meeting and other activities 2001 Rome Italy World Congress the merger of O CIC and unda into the new world Association si GN is 2005 Lyon France World Congress si GN is the theme peace through media 2009 Chiang Mai Thailand World Congress si GN is the theme media for a culture of peace children's rights tomorrow's promise 2013 fair out Lebanon World Congress si GN is foreseen but cancelled 2014 Rome Italy World Congress si GN is the theme media for a culture of peace creating images with the new generation 20-17 Quebec Canada World Congress s IGN is accepting the Catholic press agency CPA as member of si GN is guests of honor Martin Scorsese and Roth Demers 2021 Seoul South Korea World Congress s IGN is foreseen topic cygnus periodicals since 2002 in 2002's IGN is started with a multilingual Spanish English French quarterly magazine called si GN is media and has a website WWE at all issues of si GN is media from 2006 on can be consulted in their digital version on the si GN is website in February 2019 GN is started a new international multilingual try Mysterio film magazine cinema scene that cinema is still significant for the association and her mission to be present in the professional world cinema as art an expression of human creativity is a medium that influences cultures with values and worldviews since 1947 OC IC has been invited by international festivals to participate with juries si GN is a human achill and inter-religious to promote quality films that artistically translate values in its 72 years more than 2,000 films have been awarded or mentioned and most are now considered classics this new journal wants to mark the presence of si GN is in the world of the cinema but also to be an organ for its journalists critics and media educators working in more than 100 countries it wants to tie on in the tradition of the international cinema review the first issue was dedicated to honoring the 50th anniversary of FES PA Co the African Film Festival held in Wagga dugu cinema in Africa has always been a concern of OCI si si GN is since 1952 its member in Egypt promotes local cinema in the 1950s the OCI si missionary service in Rome used cinema for evangelization his director fr jean-marie Poitevin a Canadian kanu poor son film a la quas a day Schumann's de 1943 refused to make colonial propaganda since the independence of most African countries missionaries in senegal FR jean vast Congo fr Alexander vanden Heuvel and poet heaven in Rome have been working to decolonize the cinema-going and production it was part of their evangelization and meant humanizing the formerly colonized peoples who had been dehumanized by Western powers and their media they supported Africans to make their own images and tell their own stories not only for the public in Africa but also for the rest of the world in the 1960s vanden Heuvel proposed to Oh CIC to give us Mons sem beans man Dhabi his Grand Prix then the organization accepted the proposal of Professor Victor bocce to consider promoting African cinema as one of its priorities for the future at unda broadcasting of radio and television channels in Africa was also one of its priority concerns in 1973 Oh CIC installed its first jury at FES PA Co and the first prize went to Samba Sangha of saram elder or denouncing colonialism and its atrocities since then Oh CIC and now si GN is developed actions to promote not only African cinema in Africa but also elsewhere in the world the second issue of cinema presented at the zlín International Film Festival in May 2019 to celebrate the 20th anniversary of the ecumenical jury at the festival gave a focus on the child in the film and how OCI Si and si GN is dealt with this issue in its cinema activities since the beginning of cinema child in relation to cinema has been a concern of OCI si si GN is and was even one of the main reasons why o CIC was founded in 1928 Catholics organized educational sessions for children in their schools and parishes this experience has been recognized by the League of Nations after the war the festival's of cannon Venice had taken several initiatives on cinema for children in 1950 the Venice Film Festival invited Oh CIC to organize study days on the production and distribution of children's films in the following years OC isyes director of the children's film service P Leo lunders Opie worked with UNESCO to launch the International Film Center for children and youth CIF EJ in 1957 in which he stayed active for years his experiences were also shared with other organizations such as the International Catholic child Bureau or Bureau International catholique de L'enfance Pais between 1970 and 1987 and O CIC jury gave its award at the Children's Film Festival in he hone Spain known as the tsardom in Internacional de cine para la infancia while a Hooven two'd film education became one of the priorities of OCI si si GN is since the 1990s members of OCI si si GN is in Latin America were involved in unic EFS planned any plan Denis knows as the Film Festival diver Cheaney in Montevideo and linked cinema with media education such as cine mundo Chico in Argentina it also organized with its film critics juries in international festivals specializing in children's films such as Celine Lingle Chemnitz and also diver cheney since more than 70 years juries with OCI si si GN is members have always given great attention to films evoking the human condition of childhood in general film festivals such as can Berlin Buenos Aires Venice etc all issues of cinema can be consulted in their digital version on the si GN is website topic members 2017 topic s IGN is in Africa and in the Indian Ocean islands the members in Africa and in the Indian Ocean islands are topic si GN is in Asia the members of s IGN is in Asia our topic s IGN is in Europe and the Middle East the members of s IGN is in Europe and the Middle East are topic si GN is in Latin America and the Caribbean the members in Latin America and the Caribbean are topic s IGN is in North America the members in North America are topic si GN is in the Pacific the members of the Pacific are topic si GN is international members the group of international members are topic s IG and is associates the members associates are | wikipedia tts | UCmmkBTh8HaiycBZjOc8cVgw | 2019-06-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 12,778 | 75,320 |
6Q7gtbYlbBU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Q7gtbYlbBU | Jing Li (chemist) | Wikipedia audio article | Jinglei is a distinguished professor at Rutgers University she and her team are engaged in solid state in organic and inorganic organic hybrid materials research her current research focuses on designing and developing new materials for applications in the field of renewable and sustainable energy Li's research has resulted in 10 patents three pending and over 300 publications articles invited book chapters feature and review papers in high impact factor journals such as nature communications the Journal of the American Chemical Society Jack's and anger want chemi international edition she was one of the highly cited researchers by Thomson Reuters in both 2015 and 2016 topic education Lee completed her undergraduate studies in China and received her master's degree from the State University of New York at Albany she obtained her PhD degree in January 1990 at Cornell University under the supervision of Professor roald hoffmann the 1981 Nobel Prize laureate in chemistry she continued to work at Cornell as a postdoc for two years 1989 to 1991 with professor Francis DeSalvo before taking an academic position at Rutgers University topic professional career Lee joined the Rutgers faculty as an assistant professor in 1991 where she was promoted to associate professor in 1996 full professor in 1999 and distinguished professor in 2006 her current research group consists of nine graduate students to postdoc associates two visiting scientists for visiting graduate students and several undergraduate students Lee has received multi-million dollars in external research funds she has developed and taught seventeen different undergraduate and graduate courses since her first appointment with the university topic research professor Lee's interests and activities are primarily in the areas of solid-state inorganic and materials chemistry her current research focuses on the development of new and functional materials that are fundamentally important and relevant for clean and renewable energy applications these include our metal organic frameworks MOF for gas storage and separation carbon dioxide capture catalysis waste remediation and sensing these materials are made of a metal ion or metal cluster such as transition metals and organic ligands such as carboxylate groups and nitrogen containing molecules B inorganic organic hybrid semiconductors for photovoltaics and solid-state lighting these compounds consist of both inorganic and organic structure motifs they combine the good features of the two components resulting in enhanced and improved properties a possible application is to use these materials as phosphors for energy-efficient LEDs topic Jing Li has received numerous awards for her academic achievements including Lu Memorial Award Cornell University 1987 Howard Neil Wachter prize Cornell University 1989 wenting prize Cornell University 1989 Henry Rutgers research fellow Rutgers University 1991 to 1993 Henry Dreyfuss teacher-scholar the Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation 1994 to 1998 the Board of Trustees fellowship for scholarly excellence Rutgers University 1996 presidential faculty fellow National Science Foundation one nine nine five two thousand NSF Career Award National Science Foundation 1995 outstanding achievement award Chinese Association of Science and Technology US 2002 cheung-kong guest chair professor award the Ministry of Education China 2007 the clean energy education and empowerment c3e award the Department of Energy 2012 elected fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of science AAAS 2012 the Humboldt research award Humboldt prize Alexander von Humboldt Foundation 2013 Board of Trustees Award for Excellence in research Rutgers University 2013 fellow of the Royal Society of Chemistry RSC 2015 | wikipedia tts | UCGoNozP_2TZV5hVciGW1y6Q | 2019-06-06 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 558 | 3,784 |
wkzLZJHHsdc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wkzLZJHHsdc | Dancers React to B.I 비아이 - Keep me up Dance Practice Video | hey what's good y'all it's your boy down for the downstream friends we'll be back for another K-pop reaction and the boys back in the building it was popping all right listen y'all the road and Builder so this will be doing we're gonna do bi keep me up dance practice video y'all been saying this in the comments I appreciate y'all and listen get ready for the new season the bro is going to be doing the battles and choreography work with me we still gonna be doing K-pop that's not going but we got brand new playlist coming because of y'all y'all want to see battles y'all want to see different showcases y'all want to see award shows they are actually being worked on right now so appreciate y'all patience but let's get into this hit the like button you know I'm saying share yes yes and let's get to it so make sure the volume right here we go y'all know beyond be crazy like I ain't never seen him yes you have yeah waterfall yeah yeah a while ago yeah you saying them you saying you know yeah that was a while ago yeah so you're about to see him snap again oh say Studio yeah oh a different feel okay got straight to it [Music] good you're playing with the camera yeah they go again this isn't so so for me all right let me tatted on the right hey homie Inked Up I'm messing with it listen so good eye good eye but let me keep it honest with y'all did you notice the camera work this right now that that's a part of the choreography as well yeah you know because you see the body moving which is more so that's that next to Next Level you know saying everybody having a pose yeah and you know for a fact that like there's nothing wrong with that yeah but and everyone has been learning for like right now that has been trending for a couple years now is the the world of Afro from and we're not just saying afro but in specific areas of Africa when it comes to certain styles from Ghana from Nigeria from Kenya and more so everyone has been tapping into it so it's no surprise to me as a as a both of us as choreographers and teachers that we're seeing that movement like everyone has been taking those classes and want that in their music everybody honestly it is great that the movement is growing and you know it's touching more people [Music] you know it's touching multiple cultures like like for me it wants my heart to see it to to like hear people do hip-hop from other countries because that's what I grew up on because look at this field let's watch it again let's get to it right into it [Music] very Floyd you see that let's go what you got this right here okay get a little personal yes okay knock on cap I would if I was the choreographer I would have made him do more work on it like if y'all have y'all ever seen Usher You Remind Me yeah watch how he interacts with the with the women in there at the movement touched by Mario was another one I want to add a little bit more because he is dope for real for real Chris Brown Yo yeah another classic yeah because bi is dope like honestly yes a little more eye contact too especially on that right there yes if he would have had like his hand on his wall with more eye contact it would have been in like a a much stronger feel yeah and number one real quick for the people that don't understand this language this is not hating on the the artist or the choreographer this is showcasing perspectives of how we would approach it so please make sure you know what you're talking about first all right yeah much love to you because he's about to go off he got Tim's on Time come on look at that come on come on that transition was amazing um the whole setup [Music] um yeah the camera work is just it's almost like the camera yeah yeah that's what made the transition start by him moving the camera yeah to put them in a straight line and he moved back and they came back into for me it's crazy yo it gets Doper when you see more camera work really truly not just going back and forth no more but the following getting crazy with the game being a part of choreography that's that next level man I'm glad like like seeing like dance videos like this evolved yes because you get tired of seeing the same [ __ ] over and over again sometimes it does get boring it's not like it's not dope yeah it's just like okay what else what else and we're talking art so even y'all when y'all watch your favorite artists from any genre of music from our art you want to see that our perspective of it to grow more you know it's just like it's just it's just like the Fast and Furious movies I started watching them after five because because I'm like okay Car Chasers they're stealing something and somebody's after them you feel me let me see that boom boom wow interesting I like their footwork that's that listen nice [Music] okay so for me the energy one yes that that's the number one thing they went up this is the I think this is the second and third time that I watched the bi video and that the the the the choreographers and the artists the the movement in here been explosive the women has been killing it ain't no tangent about that prove me wrong let's go back prove me wrong go off go off go off I love it I love that [ __ ] go off that whole combo go off come on go off do you see this y'all ready for me to break it down let's break it down now honestly my favorite part was the pose I think I ain't gonna hold you this goes off because they they texture wasn't that hard and tough but he looked over yank boom and went right in boom boom that's my part that boom boom Oh yes playing with the levels of the same rhythm is nasty so let's talk about that time and he was watching that and that's what it makes you do yes yes that's that's that's connection yes you know that's energy that's feel I love all that [ __ ] yes come on [Music] I want him to see do more work I want to see more of his work tank got them all coming together yeah it's a little dark in the back but it's cool though I I wonder if that's because of the music video That's Coming yeah I wonder if they preparing for that and he cold that was real house right there foreign I like how can I say this I like how you know he doesn't need all the big spectacular moves you for me he just he just dances really really well it's like like I've seen plenty of people do choreography but they're just doing choreography they're not dancing you're like what I mean by that out like they're not putting themselves into it like like he's putting himself into this man yeah his like he he could dance like for real he could dance for real and the the one thing that's so interesting about the camera work that was like it's it's it's it's funny because it's like if if you are like this the whole time watching it it feels so busy because the way that the gimbal is working but if you stop and just watch you see how he's flowing with the song that is created that he you know what I'm saying that was written how he's singing it how he's rapping it he's flown with it and that's very consistent because I remember the first video watch of him that was the same thing it might feel like it's busy but it's not it's just it's just very well put together this [ __ ] is good yeah it's high energy but it flows yeah foreign he know his angles [Music] good transition I like I'm sorry I gotta go back to that transition it was simple but I really respected it it's the bounce man ah right got there and brought it right back to that concept [Music] okay interesting interesting did you see did you see that in the back sorry we're watching the back right now like look at the back look how he's posted up with the Timbs Boom turn into the formation oh did you did he uh did y'all hear that that was a nice edit yeah oh let's go let's go Tink Tink ah two three four tap tap tap go back go back go back this is very well put together hold on hold on [Music] let's go I love that [Music] keep me up they moving come on yeah with Tim's on let me know when you dance in some channels for real because you think it's easy yeah okay let me know when you dance at some Timbs is yeah and we're gonna bring it right back good job this is great it was great this is great this is that was great that was great that was great so here's my thoughts here's my thoughts on this so for me it's like uh it's like somebody just he he just did a normal like football perspective he threw a 75 yard touchdown and you wasn't surprised it was like good football you know what I'm saying it was just clean it was good it was so so good it was like now he just adding on to it it was just adding on it was just adding on to what he's about to do next so I wanted to see more like I'm at this place I'm at that place the bi where I just want to see more for real man yeah I ain't got no words because he's yeah good I don't want to give y'all a fake like oh my God I could not believe that just happened it's it's I can't do it it's like uh I just like watching the Denzel movie like yeah you know he can act yeah now turn take that take that DVD out I can't really see DVDs turn that movie off and put another one that's crazy don't want to use DVDs don't worry we've been through two areas one you know we lost the VHS some cassettes right yeah then we're going to DVDs and CDs yeah now we're done with CDs and now we about to be done with DVDs for real it's crazy you know but basically what we're trying to say is this Denzel Washington movie you know what's good just put on another one just put on another one we know Leonardo DiCaprio follow another movie don't tell me how great he is just put on another movie so we can continue to witness the greatness that's it so with that being said thank y'all so much let us know if you want us to do the music video also I would like to know personally what was your favorite part of this because y'all watch these and that's cool but I want to know what's your favorite part you know because I got mine excuse me we're trying to see y'all's perspectives you know what y'all see [Music] when y'all watch these videos yeah so what was your favorite part let me know let us know we'll be watching in the comments 100 all right y'all y'all take it easy peace | Donald Isom | UCYZnhmpJ1CtrrtBSKUkrYpA | 2022-11-29 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,024 | 10,244 |
zN-0yn5yRbg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zN-0yn5yRbg | The BANANA BLASTER is AMAZING! | hey guys what's going on i'm back with another call of duty mobile video and in today's video i'm going to be playing some ranked um with the mac 10 banana blaster i believe this is the same class i used last time in my mac 10 video and uh i completely forgot that this was a thing so this was this is the last gun in the battle pass that i completely forgot about um i mean it has a weird aesthetic but the iron sight is so much cleaner than the default one uh but yeah that's the build this is the class hope you guys enjoy see you guys in the next one all right nuketown russia domination someone's got the snoop dog skin domination all right gonna be using the banana blaster here i gotta say the skin itself is a bit strange but i do like i do like the fact that uh it has a pretty damn clean iron sight all right just want to throw that go this way okay shot me through the wall with an smg okay i didn't know that uh that gun could do that i got you dude we've taken the lead man how many bullets do you want a damn ah damn i should not challenge that one that was a bit too far all right let's put this down okay give me a second let's see if i can damn already blew my cover capturing bravo i didn't work no i'm being way too aggressive but it's too it's too much fun yeah i don't mind i don't mind dying there this is fun bye-bye oh didn't get him this one this guy's just too much fun to like rush with it's just because it shoots so damn fast and like medium range works pretty well but like there's a certain range it's just like ah i should not have taken that gunfight it just would not work i hear something kind of close to you like this guy like i'm not gonna challenge this guy's gotta are you there so oh no no no no ow what just hit me that's not good now should have kept it for next round but i was i was too greedy there damn yeah we got that three points like really fast all right that's fine i should be able to get another one maybe capture the object all right let's go and pull this out let's do right there all right give me one second i'm gonna kind of wait i'm gonna call in my streaks here all right it's gonna put this down mid let's put this down to clear some area and then i could push all right go go go you know damn i'm surprised no one's up here yeah i'm not having any luck with this uh reactor oh freaking teammate living hell out of here that's a dog have fun dude dude what's up people in swords i swear it's always the sword guys dude i love the fact that dogs have been nerfed like it's i think that health now is pretty damn good for how they have it now i love it oh so you can play that game yeah you want to go i went around damn i actually hit him yeah yeah try that again dude damn i'm just this map is not too good for that i guess or that i'm just not choosing the right spots i saw that guy hello oh that was fun i love the mac 10 honestly it's it's definitely has to be one of my favorite smgs now like look how tiny that freaking banana blaster is in my hand ah it's fun that's fun all right um hey yeah we're getting back up there nice 52 and five that's what i'm talking about all right let's go and hop into another one okay standoff hardpoint it's freaking oh my god that is a very colorful character oh you're gonna be glowing like you're gonna be standing out like look like everyone's again nice and like yeah and then wait there he is jeez looks like a freaking pinata all right right there jump what's up dude damn i'm surprised he's hitting those shots like i'm surprised hitting those shots because it's freaking hard to hit those like that head glitch area by the dumpster damn all right all right give credit where it's due definitely people spawning here so if i push out very dangerous might have been another guy down there could be wrong teammates okay give me one second people coming through here here's some from mid all right [Applause] ah freaking nades and mollies and freaking stuff oh god damn why don't you pop a molly right there that doesn't work yeah that that doesn't work damn that's a bad spot i'm gonna pop this i'll pop my uh goat chopper next all right all right there that should be at him hopefully in the back too all right i just heard someone like right next to me you just walk inside that's way too close that made dude people marty don't stop with marty dome damn did i hear people i just don't know where i'm coming from right there this is right here um i went next it's probably next where are you getting shot from oh i'm running out of ammo all right hold on change the point give me that one all right all right give me one second we're gonna pop that i'm gonna pop that yeah a lot of people say using the dog even though like the dog is not too good anymore nice shield nice shield you kind of trap me though oh boy they're gonna they're gonna climb up that or just go next yeah they're gonna go next nope i'm not even gonna attempt still out here nice and there you have it banana blaster it's it's too much fun man it's too much fun i think it looks so tiny and i can see type is still pretty damn good in this game all right keep talking about how we do 39-3 not bad all right thank you guys so much for watching and i will catch you guys in the next one | Bnatesgamer | UC5jNLQgk1bx3ifQmCG6CfWw | 2022-04-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,067 | 5,266 |
qpvcKz2BZio | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpvcKz2BZio | Angel Reader Laura Lyn visits 432 Abercorn Street in Savannah, Georgia | so i'm sitting here at 432 abercorn which is reported to be the most haunted house in savannah now we have done some research and have not been able to substantiate many of the stories that has been told there's many legends of very brutal murders of children uh a child that was supposed to been tied up and and died from exposure from the glass up the top of the window here but truly even though we have not been able to substantiate any of the stories and i i truly do not believe the stories that i heard there is an essence or an aura about this home that is very eerie when i walked up to the house i felt a almost like a feeling of doom or like danger and even sitting on the steps right now i feel like like a real extreme sadness almost the undertone of anger so there's something about this home and it might be because of the ley lines and that's here present and savannah uh part of the history with this coho square across the street from from this home it's reported to have slave burials there's so many layers to this city to the to the history of the city between revolutionary war and civil war and indian war there's so many different layers that perhaps there is something about this corner that holds a dark energy that is manifested itself into the home it certainly feels that way thank you i'm laura lynn you | Laura Lyn | UCVJA6zY0o2OOdSg_arIqpCw | 2013-11-21 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 257 | 1,333 |
eEvWG-7Kmww | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eEvWG-7Kmww | Shay Simkin ACII, Global Head of Cyber της Howden Athens Hilton | cyber insurance as you know is relatively a new product in the market even though I started selling cyber insurance or invented cyber insurance in 1997 still we look at the market that started only 2014 just so you get an understanding in 2014 the whole global premium for cyber was around half a billion dollars so it was a very small and minor product in the insurance industry I can tell you safely that in 2008 and 19 it will be around 6 billion dollars so it's definitely the fastest growing product in the insurance industry and since we realized today that most businesses are becoming digital even they may think that there are physical businesses but we are totally relying on computers insurances it's always been it's a risk transfer mechanism so we are not coming instead of risk avoidance risks acceptance and mitigation in the end of the day after you have done everything you want to transfer some of the risk to the insurance industry the industry now is waking up understanding that in the next 12 to 24 months everybody will have to have some kind of cyber insurance in their program and people are starting to understand and we want to understand what is cyber insurance how can it help how can it be built into my cyber security program what do I need in order to buy cyber insurance and that is what we concentrated today opening to people in Greece what is cyber insurance what to do around cyber insurance and I'm glad to say that from the couple of days that I've been here and meetings that I've done in Greece I am very optimistic about the Greek market I think the train may have rough left the station but it's in the first job so we can really make sure that the Greek businesses are are there to ensure this risk is cyber insurance risk for the insurance market in general so you have to bear in mind first of all that we are as I said before we are very new to to the insurance industry insurance was born three hundred years ago 350 years ago in the coffee shop Lloyd's coffee shop we are born as such in 2014 after a big event that happened in the United States so we are still learning we don't know a lot of things around what the product may be we know that right now there is relatively minor entry to the market but let's take for example there was a big event in 2017 which people may have heard about it was called North petia it was a state sponsored event from Russia against Ukraine the whole damage around North baton was about 10 billion dollars which is like two hurricanes yeah it could bring the prices up and everything but only 10 percent of it was insured so imagine now in one or two years where the market will have everybody will have cyber insurance we will have a cumulation problem we will have a lot of these things but we still are learning and changing as we go along we are accumulating data data is super important to us because people are still not sharing the data so when people have a cyber van there are still not sharing between them the events so they can know what happened and so it won't happen again so all in all we are we don't really know yet how the market would react we know that everybody is very eager to write cyber insurance there are around 200 companies around the world that are writing cyber insurance and so there is a lot of capacity around cyber insurance and the claims ratio maybe it's a it's a well kept secret between the insurance companies but it's around 65 to 70 percent so it's still relatively a very good business for the insurance industry your knowledge is globally companies taking cover for the cyber risk yes we are definitely you know when I started this in 97 if you stopped me in 97 and said that in 2009 they in 19 this will be the fastest growing product in the insurance industry I would have thought that you know I was dreaming but it's coming and they're from my global knowledge and I move around the world a lot and in different territories it's picking up faster than I ever thought [Music] | Nextdeal | UCSv3LuDpv2EpzH4f6u7uqSg | 2019-10-24 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 751 | 4,008 |
bOKzx6d72ik | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOKzx6d72ik | How to do a Side Lunge with Dumbbell Single Arm Row | begin Standing Tall with your feet close together hold it dumbbell or kettle bell in one hand and whatever side you're holding it on we're going to work to the opposite side first so make sure that you have space on the opposite side of your body to step out from here with your opposite foot step out into a big wide step letting your hips drive back and knee Bend only on this side other leg is straight sitting down into a side lunge in the bottom of this position we've got hips squared shoulders squared shoulders down and back and back is flat from here roll your arm weight coming up and elbow sliding past your waistline squeeze your shoulder blade in and down on this side lower down now drive through this foot to come back up to standing again step it out row lower down with control drive it up the breathing for this will be inhale exhale row inhale down exhale Hal press up because we've got a lot going on here be sure to maintain control over every part of this every step of the way and keep your core engaged it's also really important that you are not coming down with a rounded back so really drive your hips backward keep your chest tall and back flat | Heartmybody Fitness | UCH9eCeOdGCEzdcLT4_PgRMA | 2024-04-06 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 224 | 1,172 |
RVZbk3GEVSw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVZbk3GEVSw | Data Sharing, Part 1 of 3 - Request | hi hello my name is dr judy benign i'm an oncologist at nyu school of medicine hello dr judy benign i read your article about b cell functions it was very interesting i think that i could use the data for my work on pancreatic cancer i am not an oncologist i know but i think i could use the data for my work on pancreatic cancer oh so do you have the data everything you need to know is in the article no what i need is the data will you share your data i am not sure that will be possible but your work is in pubmed central and was funded by nih that is true and it was published in science which requires that you share your data i did publish in science then i am requesting your data can i have a copy of your data everything you need to know is in the article no i am not sure where my data is but surely you saved your data i did i saved it on a usb drive where is the usb drive it is in the box it is in the box at home i just moved but can i use your data there are many boxes well i forgot to label the boxes | NYU Health Sciences Library | UCChR3SPMhz1ul3M5C2XNpCw | 2012-05-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 220 | 1,018 |
drY4QXlfVeY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drY4QXlfVeY | The MOST Regretted Degrees (2021) | what's happening it's shane here and today we're going to be talking about the most regretted college majors right so these are college degrees that people go to university they spend all that time and money probably go 40 000 in debt in order to get the degree and then they regret it now of course there are going to be ones on this list there's going to be people down in the comments section that say i got this degree and it was the best thing that i ever did but overall on average these are the degrees that are the most regretted out of all of them and i'm basically going to be going over for you know the reasons at least in my opinion why that is and it's so difficult to do research on the right college degree for you because a lot of the time people have this preconceived notion in their head that a degree is going to lead to a job and that job is going to be a certain way but the reality is completely different but by the time they figure that out it's too late that's why i made this channel that's why i make all these educational videos for you guys and also i am getting amazing results from my college 101 course you can find it down in the description below i have a very limited time coupon on that it's probably the cheapest that it's ever going to be at this point so before we get into it make sure to gently tap the like button hit the subscribe button ring the notification bell and comment down below any thoughts comments criticisms etc that you have on the video and let's jump right in all right so number five on the list is going to be communications this was a zip recruiter survey and they found that 27 of people who got a communications degree really regretted it right and the biggest problem with communications very obvious it's just too general like there's so many different types of communicating you can communicate with someone over the phone you can give a speech to someone you can communicate via writing you can communicate via making youtube videos all of these different forms and mediums of communication are going to be completely different now if you became an expert on one of those things like starting a youtube channel making youtube videos hey you can make a living from that you can make a lot more than a living from that but the problem with communications is just too general hiring managers business owners are not going to know how you are going to add value to their company and so many of these people probably graduated and they weren't able to find a job and then they you know were stuck with all that student loan debt and that can be very disappointing next one on the list number four is going to be social sciences and law according to zip recruiter 29 of them regretted it and the reasons because it was too general impractical and it's hard to find a job without further study right so i've said this many times before um you know a lot of the social sciences and liberal arts degrees they are going to be very difficult for you to find a job in that field many people i would say most people end up graduating with a degree they can't find a job in anything that has anything remotely to do with the subject of the degree and so they either go back to grad school to get a master's or a doctorate which is very expensive it takes a lot of time or they just settle for a job that doesn't really have anything to do with what they originally wanted to do now i think that social sciences liberal arts teach you a lot of soft skills that can be very valuable formulating an argument critical thinking being able to give speeches being able to write a paper these are all things that are going to help you in many different facets of your life but when it comes to the financial side of things you really have to plan things out if you decide to get one of these degrees number three on the list is sadly going to be education 31 of people regretted getting an education degree and of course they would get an education degree in order to become a teacher now one of the positive things about getting these degrees is they have very very low unemployment rates so you are pretty much guaranteed to get a job but unfortunately the jobs don't tend to pay very well and they also tend to be very high stress and then there's limited job opportunities a lot of the time people will end up going back getting a master's even a doctorate sometimes because normal teachers just don't get paid all that much next one on the list number two is probably going to come as a surprise to many of you but that is biological and physical sciences 35 of people regretted this major now here's the thing about biological and physical sciences i've done many many videos on here about them when it comes to stem degrees science technology engineering mathematics science degrees are the weakest out of those by far you know technology engineering mathematics when it comes to the numbers at least the financials they are much more solid but with that being said science is still relatively good it's not bad but i think that people's perception of how good it is versus how it is in the real world is just completely off and so people end up being extremely disappointed when they get a biology degree a chemistry degree etc and they realize that you know the jobs that i'm looking at aren't going to pay me very well or in some cases i'm going to have to go back to school in order to get a master's or a doctorate just to be able to get a job and that's the truth for many of these science related degrees in order to get employed in the field if you're actually wanting to do the subject that you studied you're probably going to have to get a master's or a doctorate in many cases but if you do get a master's or a doctorate you're gonna be good to go so it's definitely kind of a double-edged swords there's some positives and some negatives there i think the reason so many people regretted this one in my opinion is just because of the fact that they didn't expect it next one on the list number one is going to be english and foreign languages the regret with this one was about 42 and to put that in perspective guys the least regretted degree was computer science and mathematics at about 12.7 so 42 versus 12 that's almost four times more people that regretted the degree and the main reasons for this is that it's impractical and there were limited job opportunities right so i remember you know by far the most controversial video on my channel which is the most useless degrees video got two over two million views now i remember i put uh you know language studies and stuff like that as one of the most useless types of degrees and i made a joke about how you can like get rosetta stone or you can just go and learn it on your own something along those lines but you know i understand i got a lot of flack in the comments for that you know people were saying oh no in order to be a trained translator you have to do this and that and blah blah well there you go okay the most regretted type of degree right so yes there is certain cases very specific cases where becoming a translator maybe going to college getting that degree would be worth it but for many many people out there they find that it isn't worth it because it's just impractical if you are going to get one of these types of degrees you know because you're passionate about it or something like that consider maybe double majoring in a different degree that might help you out uh something that's a little more practical something that is gonna be able to get your foot in the door when it comes to landing a job or maybe considering pursuing that subject on the side starting a youtube channel for instance would be an awesome side project that you could do but yeah i hope you guys enjoyed the video check out my other videos right here i made them just for you go ahead gently tap the like button hit that subscribe button ring the notification bell and comment down below any thoughts comments criticisms etc that you have on the video and i will see you guys next time [Music] | Shane Hummus | UCLKZ20yD2tNMBOkSDZo4FeQ | 2021-10-20 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,535 | 8,120 |
Ryfm3E180qc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ryfm3E180qc | BBMZANSI 2024: YOLANDA PUNISHED BY BIGGIE WITH NO TALKING HOUSEMATES CELEBRATE #yolandabbmzansi | youra when your mother visited you moved after Big Brother instructed housemates to freeze this is the second time you flaunted this instructions understood to show emotion in these circumstances moving from one part of the house to another as well as talking back and attempting to make physical contact with a visitor is in no way acceptable and this is a punishable offense yeah as a punishment Yolanda you will not be allowed to use your voice for a day meaning you will take a break from talking from this morning until Big Brother advises that your punishment is over Yolanda has finally gotten the punishment of dreams not her dream of the dream of the housemates so it the punishment is based on the reaction that she gave to her mother yesterday um her mother came to visit yesterday and she ran from where she was came and prostrated in front of her mom and she was trying to reach out to touch her mom's leg her mom had to move back and she was doing all sorts of fishal reactions expressions and everything a couple of you on my comment section have said it's a way of showing respect to Elders I kind of understand that however when Big Brother brought the instruction he said that while it is you know he understands that seeing a loved one in this type of situation can be quite um can excit emotions and all of that the fact that she ran from one point of the house to the other was Unbecoming and was deserving of punishment I want to see that way as well yes she can express respect and everything but she's not above um biggest instructions the rest of the housemates as well have respect for their parents but they didn't run from one end of the house to the other I am happy that she got this punishment at least we get to experience Yolanda being mute for a complete day guys I need you to see the response of the housemates in the next clip but before you do so please give the video a thumbs up okay thank you so much anyways let's move on to instruction at your own risk Big [Applause] Brother come and get your medal L mute mute mute I'm [Applause] forever what are you going to [Applause] do I said at the beginning that this is a dream come through for every single housemate in the house maybe even Mak as well Mak was not happy he was just looking and then at some point I think it was Willie or something that went someone that went to him and was like ah at least you'll be free for the next one then he was like ah it was like yes yes yes but you could just tell that he would not be fine because as much as he's always complaining about Yolanda talking too much he actually enjoys it if you look at him very well every single time she's disturbing he's always smiling even when he's complaining he's smiling he's doing it with a smile but for the rest of the housemates they are just so happy this was literally the first thing that that she wrote in response to the housemates celebrating that she got a punishment that was worth their while like literally worth their while by the way guys s's father just visited the house that video is going to come in next but I wanted you guys to also see um it's almost like the first official Act of business that Papa gust has done in the house the clip will come in and of course I'm going to come back and explain but let us dwell on Yolanda in a little while before we get on to the clip so the housemates literally chanted the most popular phrase that Yolanda has been doing has been saying in the house what she going to do about it and all of them just echoed nothing like it was it was the moment of moments guys this morning is already starting off on such an exciting Feit already um I cannot wait to see how Yolanda will be able to navigate the Waters of not being able to talk for a full day she's giving that slate so she can write on the mar board she's giving a mar as well whatever she has to say she has to write now she um big brother said she'll be allowed to speak during diary sessions but um and when she's solo practicing for the wager because of course wer is tomorrow she has to practice um so she would be given time and space to solo practice for the wager task but she would not be allowed to speak she would not be allowed to use her voice for the next one uh for the next 24 hours as you can see on the housemates faces they are enjoying every bit of moment of this punishment that Yanda is going through like I said let's get to The Business of Being HOH from Papa go I'll be back very shortly and easy to you know maintain things the way that they are we don't have to work like slaves every day cleaning up the house you know as long as we just maintain the cleanliness it's going to be an easier job for everybody every single day um one thing is please try not to leave food out in the kitchen or put it in the oven or in the microwave put it in the fridge if you want to eat it much later put it in the freezer you know you can always warm it up and stuff like that uh the reason we have we have a lot of flies in the house is cuz fruit gets left out and maybe it's just me I personally do not like FES Papa G has been I don't want to say slacking but he has been taking his time to actually you know people were expecting that um Papa goes becoming H they are going to he's going to like just hold the whole house to rans some and people are going to have a hard time you know um being under him his leadership as H but you know Fortune had turned the hand of you know activities and um larat got evicted so he's been literally using the last two days to um mourn lat's um departure and eviction and then of course yesterday his sister came and told him you came to this house alone play your game you know I am sad about Mama ghost leaving but play your game so this morning before the punishment brief was given to them he was in the um kitchen with some of the gents and they were talking about how the house is uncamp and what they can do to make sure that the house is clean especially now that they are fewer than they were before it would be a lot easier to know who is doing what and be able to keep the house in a way that is orderly and clean and neat and tidy so after that conversation of course the punishment brief came and he told everyone and then he was like okay since everyone is still here I might as well well use this opportunity to address the house and talk about how we can put ourselves together moving forward Papa ghost has always complained about um the house being untiy and how people keep food in the fridge for a long time even though they are not you know using it or food that they know that they are not going to go back and eat they just put it either inside the um fridge or inside the microwave and it's just sad you know he was even talking about how when mak's knes came um he he had to freeze so after the after he became freeze there was a fly patching on his food and when he got done he couldn't eat the food he had to throw it away so he was talking about how it is because of this type of you know untied behaviors that they not have flies in the house and it's making the whole Space uncomfortable for them to literally be in so he addressed the housemates I I like that he did and some of them were keeping straight face some of them didn't were quite indifferent but I'm sure that moving forward we're probably going to see a house that is more tidy than we've seen before I can't wait to see actually how things go in the house now that he's coming out of his shelf but then again we already halfway through the week so the pap ghost rain that we thought was going to be a dictatorship may not necessarily turn out to be that way and quite frankly these days he's just mellow he's just I think he's happy now that he has expressed his character and he has done what he has to do for the game and he's not about trying to prove himself anymore cuz in my mind I'm like he probably feels he has proven himself you know so he does not need to do too much so now he's just enjoying his stay enjoying himself and making sure that he keeps just being himself you know anyways the next video will be that of sa's Father's visit definitely look forward to it guys the man was cool he said quite a number of things to the to the ladies Z and Lima as well so I'll be back with that video very shortly make sure to subscribe turn on notification share your thoughts as well in the comment section like I said I will be back very shortly | XNaija | UC0LmEvzVkiitBV4Jhyv-zqA | 2024-03-13 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,681 | 8,488 |
GXp69fIpwBc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXp69fIpwBc | Empiricists: Locke, lecture 8 | okay hello um so um basically three things I want to talk about today one is judgments a lot called judgments it's kind of when other people call a communion um well maybe I should say rational no I think it just means opinion that's a judgment can be correct or but done correctly original um second is about uh how knowledge can be extended um and there's basically three ways knowledge can be extended it can be extended by reason it can be extended by instructions absolutely bye what was that nice [Music] well um and uh I have a third and I can put a question mark after it because we'll see what Watson Alpha but it is okay cannot be extended by faith and then the third thing as usual I don't know if I'll get to the first thing so it's starting Berkeley if I don't get to something I'm gonna finish um I want to talk about the three cases of knowledge of existence and I'll do my own existence and all the insistence of external things and knowledge of instances of God okay so I'll start with this one um breath so as I think I did I say this last night I must have said it right that a lot uses the term knowledge always involves um it always involves certainty because it's the perception of the agreement and disagreement they're in between our ideas and we can't be wrong about whether I ideas that we are disagree with each other um well we can't misperceive whether they agree disagree with each other that is if we perceive the two ideas agree with each other then they do agree with each other right so um [Music] so like things that we know right this is not judgment is opposed to knowledge the way a lot easier the things that we know are things that um they were certain in a very strong way our truth that it's not just that we don't have a reason to doubt those but that we do kind of somehow perceived that they're true and so they they must be true um and therefore given that very strict standard for accounts as knowledge there isn't very much knowledge right like most of the things could be ordinarily would say we know we're going to lock we don't really know um so you know Locke says like as I am sitting here writing this on this paper by myself I consider it very probable that other human beings exist but I don't know it because there's no one else I mean it's kind of weird when you think about it so he's he's writing I guess not that one I mean he says it's very very highly probable and probable enough to direct his conduct in every way but still I mean it's kind of interesting but the time when he's writing is the time when he's not sure there are any readers um but okay never mind that so um um so therefore lock says I mean since technology although it's great that we have it we don't have very much of it we also have this other faculty or um ascending to propositions in order to use them to guide our actions and this other faculty is called judgments so this is like not what Descartes means by judgment and not what God means by judgments I don't know exactly where this use of judgment comes from actually I don't know of anyone else other than lock it just this way but that doesn't mean there aren't other people it just means I don't know who they are but anyway so um so he's as I said he's using judgment to mean um basically what other people mean by opinion and sometimes Locke does call it opinion but the official term for it is judgments this is the definition this uh book 4 chapter 14 Section 3 on page 576. um The Faculty which God has given man to supply the want of clear and certain knowledge in cases where that cannot be had is judgments whereby the mind takes its ideas to agree or disagree or which is the same any proposition to be true or false without perceiving a demonstrative evidence in the proofs um so you know and therefore because of judgment basically means opinion lock makes the old uh platonic distinction between um knowledge and right opinionally in Block it's the distinction between knowledge and right judgment right so right judgments is when we do this and we turn out to be correct so we don't know that it's true but it is true um so um so you know like this is almost as good as this as Socrates and you know kind of decide um but uh uh but it's not as good as this because we don't have a demonstration to tie it down a big way right so it's like um not it doesn't have as much Social utility as knowledge I think is the way Locke understands whether that's the way Socrates understand that I don't know but anyway that so that I think that's the way log understands that so um so I think that explains why Locke although you know this is this is mostly what has to guide our actions correct um he's more interested in this he's more interested in knowledge because I think this is what he thinks is really the most valuable and you can get it um but um Locke says and this I think I've alluded this before um but this is where he says that and it's important always to keep it in mind that well I guess where he actually says it is the chapter on reason which is maybe that was chapter 14. what's the chapter title the reason no it's chapter 11. so 16 or 17. okay yeah chapter 17 is the chapter on reason block says you know um reason is the faculty we have arranging our ideas in the right order either for demonstration or or um like probable arguments right it's this reason has much to do in either one right so just as we reach knowledge by using reason to form correct demonstrations or at least that's one way to reach knowledge we reach um judgments yeah and now like you might also call this right judgment but that's not actually how a rock defines rights judgment nor is it how uh Socrates defines right opinion in an indepeno but you might say the the judgment that whether it's true or not is the right one for us to us to reach the conclusion that given our information is most rational for us to reach um uh reason is going to help us reach that kind of conclusion by telling us how to make probable connections um so I mean I guess what's important here is that um and Locke doesn't explain exactly how this well actually it does kind of explain at length in part that I didn't assign but um but but the explanation isn't that precise like exactly how this works what reason tells us to do when we have ideas that we don't receive agreement or disagreement between how how to judge whether it's probable that they agree or disagree um but um it's not like it's the fact that it's not knowledge but his merely opinion doesn't mean that we're just guessing or at least we shouldn't be right rather we should be weighing up the evidence and basically lock says you know we need to weigh uh what's been common in our own experience against uh what's been generally common in our own experience against what uh trustworthy Witnesses say about a particular incident um so uh so it's um the combination of a kind of induction based on my own experience and checking that against what other people say that um that's what reason tells us to do here and um we do that correctly then it's probable that we're right even though it's not certain um okay I think that's all I want to say about judgment are there questions about I mean that it's going to come up another it's already come up and it's going to come up again another contest but I think that's all there is to say about it on its own [Music] every time while I'm at it I'll turn off the join them or okay so now I'm going to talk about extension of knowledge um yeah first about thank you as I said there's three ways to do it um but um the other two kind of come back to the first one and the first one is to give your reason um so uh how do we improve our knowledge by reason um so like the main way is by demonstration and a demonstration works when we let's say the main way there's really two cases one is demonstration and the other one which in some ways it comes first is intuition right which I'm not sure I I think walk counts I mean this is the way first of all of extending your knowledge referring to learn intuition is when you have two ideas and just by considering them next to each other you can see their C because you're not really seeing right you can see their agreement of this agreement or disagree um and then and the reason I say like I emphasize this is a way of extending your knowledge you might think that like since these are kind of self-evident you kind of already know them so that's not true right according to lock you can't know something until you actually compare the ideas and before you know before you do that you have to you have to acquire the ideas if you don't already have the ideas you can't know it at all you have to apply the ideas and then you have to actually consider them next to each other next to each other right right at the same time I guess that means and then you can see there well but it needs more than just at the same time as you can see from the example I'm going to get them so I mean rather to call that a use of reason or not uh I don't know but it's part of the rational procedure of expanding your knowledge so like for example you know um if you have two right angles so traditionally this doesn't count as an angle like what we call 180 degrees and you can see why it doesn't have a vertex Rays so it's like a degenerate base of an animal but anyway so that so they always talk about if you write anything and in fact useless definition with the right angle is basically um when two lines meet them as the same angle on both sides that's the right animal so um so anyway if you have two right angles and then you draw some other lines here through this point and you you look at these three angles then it's intuitively certain that these three angles are equal to these two angles according to log and it's because I mean I guess maybe if I drew them separately it would be easier to understand like here's two right angles here's a straight line where I've drawn some other military lines it just happened these three angles are equal to these two angles and lock says you can know that intuitively because you can actually bring them together and compare them for example if I say it's more than the same time it's like you you in the case of ideas like this which are ideas of spatial figures this is literal you actually like somehow bring them on top of it okay and then it's intuitively certain that these two angles are equal to these three angles so demonstration though is when you have two ideas where uh you can't do that with them and so you can't tell intuitively whether they agree or dissipulate and this is where locks example that he comes back to it becomes back to other related examples too over and over that um theorem that the interior angles of the triangle are equal to two right angles right so if you add up these three angles it will be equal to adding up these two angles now and lock says you can't compare these directly right like no matter how you move and rotate this triangle you can't make these three angles sit against this line so a demonstration then is supposed to provide like intermediate steps where there's some angles you can compare these three two and then you compare those angles to these two and you know it's basically right so what you do is draw a line parallel to the base through the vertex but now this is the part I've been trying to understand for a long time how long actually supports the how long thinks we can demonstrate this but like I mean we know at least it's a theorem that this angle is equal to this angle it's those are parallel lines the question is does block make up intuitively certain or do they have to be more steps not sure this this by the way is pretty much the way Euclid through sentence that's like shifted around a little because it's basically the same group right and then we know this angle is equal to this angle so these three angles are intermediate because we can compare them to the three angles of the triangle but then we can compare these two right angles and that's the end of the demonstration yeah so again it's great and just take some sort of like a complicated thing and then breaks it down until it's intuitively like understandable well I mean it's not really breaking down that's going on here although that might be involved in some demonstrations concerns but it's it's just it's finding intermediate steps I get oh yes well you what you mean by breaking down but like like since we're breaking down the relationship between these two angles and these three angles into steps and at each step we have to have intuitive knowledge but we're not breaking down these angles right we're finding three other endings that we can put in between them so it writes and things of it as like the way the demonstration works is you know like what you want to demonstrate is that s is p but for that s is equal to P in this case right this is this is the second type of knowledge which the law calls the relation right it's not identity we're not proving that these three angles are the same as these two angles thank you for proving that they're equal to some they're they're similar to them when someone's better yeah so it's just like groups yeah it's proofs but I'm trying to explain how long thinks of proof works yeah right I mean it's somewhat because it's different the way we nowadays usually think about groups right so like he doesn't think of the proof as a bunch of I mean it's different from the way aristotelians think about true proofs too and he criticizes them we we don't he doesn't think of a group as a bunch of premises that you write down and then you have rules by which you can generate other propositions and then you get for the conclusion it's this is the conclusion and the problem is to find things to put in between to make it intuitive so you know you say like people that's two equals and we can fill in all these steps then the conclusion of the proof is that this equals that yeah I was confused because he talks about how each intermediate step requires not just requires but involves intuitive knowledge but right before that he talks about how it's not as certain events intuitive knowledge so I didn't understand why the certainty why why the uncertainty is created if there's intuitive steps that every step of the truth it's um it's a problem we'll see you actually using that to pass down on but it's but I mean I think I sort of understand what locks wedlock is is thinking this is I mean principle he says it's not as certain I mean that's weird because they're both absolutely certain so how can one be less certain than the other one but still I mean there's there but there's an issue here that there isn't in the in one step which is that you have to remember all the steps and what order they went and you know Locke thinks uh um as we'll see if remember when we get to knowledge of existence right lock says like just as I know of the existence present to existence of things by myself is so I know the path existence of things by my memory right so like memory is um as long as it lasts is as good as fast according to what um and in this case presumably we're not talking about sense memory is as good as intuition right but the problem is that memory tends to decay so as long as the memory is still there okay but as it decays and like I don't know that means you have a harder time recalling it or are you more easily you lose some of the details of it maybe as it decays so like at some point when you reach the end of a long cruise you may not be sure you remember all the steps or maybe hard to remember them and I think that's supposed to be the difference and I mean you can see why if it's just one step there's nothing to remember and so it hasn't started yet problem hasn't started yet but the whole thing is in front of you and there's nothing wrong number um and um and the point of this is to extend our knowledge so I mean maybe that sounds kind of obvious so I mean that is okay first of all this is a way we can extend our knowledge that part is kind of obvious it's possible to do this it's a way to extend your knowledge right like if you didn't know if those angles were the equals of those angles you could go through the proof and then you would know um um but it also seems like long thinks that um well there's a couple things first of all in his discussion he seems to assembly start out knowing what are the few ideas that you want to show that they agree or disagree we're just looking for the right intermediate ideas to do it um so uh uh there's a certain kind of process involved in the extension of knowledge that lock isn't talking about but also the other thing that I was going to say is that he seems to assume that this is the only use of demonstration um assume or it seems to think that there are no other uses of demonstration meaning that like if I already know something then searching for a demonstration of it is a waste of time because I already know um I mean it's possible that he doesn't say this I think maybe he would admit that if I find a shorter demonstration that would be good because it'd be easier to remember but he doesn't even say that um uh and yeah maybe he thinks that is not important because if you remember way back I don't know where this was but maybe it wasn't that way back maybe it was the beginning of book four and where he says you know I used to think he distinguishes between um uh when we know something by demonstration there's two cases one is that I can call up the whole demonstration whatever I need it the other is that I can remember that I had a demonstration but I can't remember all the stages of demonstration and log says I used to think that second case was inferior but now I realize that it's just as good because the way it works is this is where the reliability or not even subject to question about reliability of memory comes in I remember that I perceived at an agreement before those between those ideas in the past I don't remember the steps I used but I remembered I received it and I also know that if those ideas agreed in the past they still agree now because we're not talking about the type of thing that can change and therefore I still have a demonstration of whatever I wanted right and just perceived by a different path so anytime so like so like originally I wanted to know if these three angles are equal to these two angles and I was able to fill in these intermediate steps and become certain that they are now when all I have to do is remember that I was certain and add in the how to draw this on the intermediate diagram is not so clear that somehow I add in there the fact that if I was once certain it's then I could be certain now too and now I'm certain all right so anyway why was I saying that uh [Music] oh because I was saying so maybe he doesn't think it's important to find a demonstration that's shorter and easier once you've done done the demonstration once at least as long as your memory that you were certain less you don't need any demonstration uh I don't know How about if your memory goes away then you might be able to remember the steps in any case like I said he doesn't talk about that and he certainly doesn't talk about other purposes for finding a demonstration like trying to understand why something is true right like I know it's true but I don't know why so I want to find a proof that that doesn't make sense to him yeah um well something's intuitive is it's you know it's kind of inherently correct like you don't need to prove that it is right it's like it just makes sense well I mean yeah so the tune it means you know it just by inspecting doesn't use the word inspection but just by perceiving the two ideas you know for certain that they agree or disagree um so so according to to Locke a proof is not necessary and also for the reason I'm just saying a proof is pointless right if something is intuitively certain then you know it just by thinking about it and so looking you don't the purpose of proof is you know locks Locke actually says at the beginning of every proof the conclusion is in doubt otherwise there'll be no reason for approvement right so if you're certain about it right away then then a truth is like have no point yeah is it like impossible for something intuitive to be like wrong play what I'm what I'm asking is which if you have approved thank you well you know so I mean this is related to what you were asking also uh like and it's another thing that Hume is going to bring up in the same connection you know like Kim was gonna say like okay when a mathematician proves something do they say okay now I know it no they checked their proof you know they show it to other people and then they publish it and see if anyone has an objection or whatever right so um um it's not clear how luck can account for that I mean I think I know roughly how you would have counselor but I'm not sure you know like so first of all you would have to say something like it happens when you've thought about the words rather than the ideas right similar to we didn't talk about this but they didn't get to it but he says that confusion of ideas is always merely verbal right so like if I have two ideas and I'm I'm actually like I actually have those two ideas in my mind um there's no way I can confuse one or the other if they do foreign that is every perception of an idea is a perception of exactly what that idea is and not anything else so then why is it that we talk about having confused ideas instead because we have words where it's not where we haven't fully decided what idea they go with so I think he would say that I'm going to get to you and say I think he would say that that something like that happens when we make a mistake and approved probably that's also why he says that a proposition like all gold is yellow why this is trifling because if you know what these and assuming yellow is part of the definition of goal if you know what these ideas are then um then you don't add anything to the idea of gold that you already have in your mind by saying it's yellow you're already thinking we know right so this is as opposed to can't say that analytic judgment can form a can have a purpose of like clarification because Kant is following alignments and thinking we really do have ideas or concepts or whatever that are confused and we need to be clarified law is thinking that if we really have them they can't be confused and there's no need to clarify them and so a judgment like this is like again it's just playing with words basically yeah it was um there aren't supposed to be degrees inside being there may be some things more locked because you know as I was sitting there aren't really supposed to be degrees of certainty but then sometimes he says that some two things are certain and one's more certain than the other um but yeah as far as I can understand there there aren't um intuitive knowledge is absolutely you know like um yeah it's compared to perception but of course perception isn't that reliable like says perception right so it's better than perception um it's again I think it has to do with the with thought that there can't be anything hidden about an idea when it's in your mind you know like if it's in your mind it's there um and so if you perceive its connection to another idea um that was that connection is there and you know notice that these demonstrations these demonstrations are possible because we're talking about primary qualities in this necessary connections I said this before somehow this also demonstrations possible in ethics those demonstrations involve the existence of God as like as one of the intermediate ideas I believe um so yeah I don't know how that fits into what type of necessary connection is thing I think those demonstrate so so like what is the synthetic operatory element in ethics to use content terminology I think according to Locke it's not a proposition that we know but it's rather that affect the Pleasure and Pain has on our willing that somehow that's what allows non-trivial demonstrations in ethics and that is like certain and constant yes all right but anyway uh uh um I mean when it gives examples of demonstrating things in ethics and not very good they sound kind of trifling actually very like one example he gives is without property there is no fact or something like that um it sounds like that's about definitions uh I guess maybe like you have to understand under property like the law thank you right property is is the law that you can't interfere with someone else's rights um the law law is just an Administration then but I'm saying that like like that's because the question is when I demons when I demonstrate that without property there is no theft where does the existence of God and reward and Punishment and all that stuff come into it but if it doesn't it sounds like I'm just playing with definitions which again lock thinks is pointless although you know not everyone that would agree with them at that's pointless but he thinks that's pointless so you know so why is he giving without property it is about theft as an example so I was trying to say this Pro that it's that the like all that extra stuff is kind of hidden in the word property something like that I don't know never mind if that doesn't make sense to you forget about it um um right and you know I mean this is why he also criticizes the theory of the syllogism um which is that right the whole um like Machinery of Aristotelian logic where if you want to prove that s is p you would I mean so they agree that the conclusion they're usually thinking about identity they're not equality that's you know anyway so they agree with the conclusion has two terms and the two terms are what we're trying to connect and syllogism and you you know but the silicon and the silica importance doesn't involve an intermediate term but I think it's immediate term you know call it X so it writes are like the two parentheses the silicone are going to be S at X is p and the conclusion is going to be S is p right like um is [Music] prevention center Effectiveness but anyway right like if I want to show that all humans are mortal I can show like the premises might be all animals are Immortal all humans are animals therefore all humans are moral so lock says like all this extra stuff doesn't like help you extend your knowledge and it's an easier to write to write it like this what do you need all that extra stuff for but you know the truth is like I think um aristotelians like contemporary logicians whatever the other differences between them may be they're they're not studying it basically in order to prove things better they they're like once you take pill 9 you don't become able to prove things good it's they're studying it because they want to understand something about what proof is that's why residentialians are interested in silica um and again law kind of discounts that like the purpose you know Improvement is for extending your knowledge and not for like thinking about or using for anything else um okay so that's extension if you're valid by reason it's you know the main example she talks about our demonstration but every demonstration involves intuitive connections otherwise it's no good right like these this has to be intuitive and this has to be intuitive or there's no demonstration um so as I said the next one is instruction s and it basically has the same Parts as this um right that is it basically works the exact same way Locker talks about them together book four chapter eight section three and H5 40. oh instruction lies in something very different this is right after he talks about how pointless syllogisms are destruction lies in something very different and he that would enlarge his own or another's mind to truths he does not yet know must find out intermediate ideas and then lay them in such order one by another but the understanding may see the agreement or disagreement of those in question propositions that do this are instructive right so like so the way to not enlarge your knowledge by instruction is to have someone else find out this order for you and put it down in the right order and then you so this goes remember with his eye with his theory about the use of language right I you know like the teacher has the ideas in the right order this is harder of course right I mean it's like block says there's different levels of ability to prove something the highest level is when you find out the ideas yourself for the first time no one else has ever found intermediate ideas like this um the next level is that you're like able to remember and produce the idea that someone else has laid out and the lower level is just that you're able to follow when someone lays out an idea um and you know at least that good instruction first achieves although hopefully eventually you'll get to the next to the higher level of being able to reproduce it yourself but it's just like so I can get you to perceive the agreement that this agreement there is between the three interior angles of the triangle the two right angles by showing you the intermediate steps and then if you didn't know it before now you'll know this um and of course uh send some instruction involved demonstration and also instruction must involve intuition um and um I think uh walk agrees that you can also be instructed in intuitive truths that might seem like that might seem weird right like it's intuitive why do you need someone to instruct you but the point is that um again it's intuitive if you put the two ideas together and consider them together but if you've never done it you don't know and so um like um I can instruct you that these three angles are equal to these two animals um because even though supposedly as soon as you understand what these two figures are um you'll you know um you can tell that there's that equality um you know like infants and Savages and whatever I've never considered these papers someone has to tell them or they have to do it themselves right but if they don't do it themselves someone can tell them hey consider these two figures and then they'll see that they're even um and I think actually Locke talks about doing this this kind of intuitive I mean it's implicit in the idea that instruction works by demonstration right because again every step of the demonstration is intuitive I think block actually talks about this um uh instruction that only tells you something you can know by intuition this is back in book one I don't know how important this is but oh well um [Music] so it's a book one chapter 2 section 21 on page 68. but we have not yet done with a sentence of propositions at first hearing and understanding their terms just fit we first take notice that this instead of being a Mark that they are innate is a proof of the Contra since it supposes that several who understand and know other things are ignorant of these ignorant of these principles till they are proposed to them and one may be unacquainted with these truths till he hears them from others for this they were innate what need they be proposed in order to gaining ascent um et cetera Etc if so then the consequence will be that a man knows them better after he has been thus taught them than he did before once it will follow these principles may be more made more evident To Us by others teaching than Nature has made them by impression which will ill agree with the opinion of innate principles so right the point is that like our knowledge that it is impossible for the same thing both to be and not to be for example um can't be innates because like you know so what his opponents say is well it's innate in the sense that we are sent to it as soon as it's proposed to us and Locke says you're centered as soon as proposed to it that shows that someone taught it to you by proposing it and then you knew it better than you did before which will ill agree with the opinion of innate principle uh right so so that which is certainly an intuitive truth that is impossible for the same single to be and not to be um that type of thing lock is saying yes you need to be taught that because someone needs to propose it to you I mean or you may need to be taught it right I mean obviously again you could have figured it out by yourself or figure it out means like in the case of an intuitive through figuring it out is not a process you just have to decide to compare those two ideas yeah I guess I'm struggling to understand how instruction works we like sort of instill an intuitive idea in someone else because he you know like sort of examples of intuitive ideas the circle of not square or black and not white so like what's being added in the instructions is it like a new combination of intuitive things that the the people already knows there's not being a range such that they can you know what I just yeah I'm still here so like the identity and difference ones are going to be hard to catch because um because uh like all I have to do is kind of like while you're seeing something might remind you of something black I guess that they're not that they're different right but that still has to be done right like if you've never compared white and black you don't know for instance um so and like if you've never tasted a pineapple then you don't know that the taste of a pineapple was not black the last example is kind of weird right you don't know the taste of panel is not a tolerant maybe you somehow do know that because of the definition of tasty color which is which are weird animal but um so uh but anyway you don't know the taste of pineapple is not the case of a lemon if you've ever tasted a pineapple so like I can teach you the taste of a pineapple it was not looking at the lemon by giving you pineapple right but but it's easier to understand in a case like this right like you may never have thought of these ideas together you may never have thought of these ideas at all right like you know when Socrates teaches Nino and obviously there's like a huge question of that dialogue whether it's not produced in and all dialogue whether sovereignties is teaching or not teaching or whatever but when Socrates does what we would normally call teaching we know that the uh the Square on the diagonal is double the Square on the side right so that like [Music] um this square has no that's weird but this is where is twice the area of its Square like he does it by among other things is drawing or I mean first of all he tells the slave okay draw this now draw this now draw that right so he's introducing to have ideas and when it comes down to its sovereignties himself draws this line here right it's like before because he asked the slave what is the side of the double square on the slave that's what guessing he's in twice inside of the original one and a half times now the slave is able to Socrates is able to convince the slave but those don't work but the slave doesn't know what to say and then he says we'll consider this line so like once you consider that line it becomes I don't know if it's an intuitively certain or if there's a couple of steps inside in between but it becomes certain that right this square has four of these triangles and this square has two of them so foreign can teach you that all right um uh okay are there more questions about that because if not I'm going to talk about things not too exactly make it through the proof of the existence of God you know all right so I'm going to talk about faith this is interesting and weird so like when I wrote this as a third Source way of extending or not then put a question on um so faith is a way of gaining well at least we think it might be a way of gaining knowledge although it seems like in the end it turns out to be only probability [Music] but it works by something like instruction [Music] so this is book four chapter 18 section two on page 608 um faith is the ascent to any proposition not thus made out by the deductions of reason but upon the credit of the proposer as coming from God in some extraordinary way of communication this way of discovering truth to Men We call revelation um so it sounds like this right he said it doesn't proceed by the Productions of reason therefore it's neither this nor is it instruction in this sense but it's on the credit of the proposer is coming from God so right someone says um like uh well Locke says it should be something like this that you could demonstrate right like God told me that the interior angles of the triangle equal to right angles by the way I probably said this before that this you know the fact that law chooses this example over and over is something like being that has something to do with the weird status of the parallel thing I think this is um this has been known area problem in euclidean geometry and sure enough this is what once we have non-including geometry is like um and not including geometries the angles don't add up to right triangle on a sphere geometry have two right angles here on another angle there um anyway the other name why are they saying that at all because like maybe we would need God to tell us this is Flash okay anyway like [Music] um uh or it could be something that this would obviously be more usable something you couldn't know by demonstriction um like Lock's example is that there are um other finite spirits that are above us in the order of nature Angels basically right so lock says we can't see them so like we have no we can't we can't demonstrate their existence in any way we have no sense knowledge of them so how could we know they exist well God could tell us that would be an example of something you can learn from revelation but the thing that's weird about this is that um notice again the word Credit in there upon the credit that the proposer is coming from God so like What's Happening Here is that first of all pain is um I mean he's giving it a special theological definition but it basically just means trusting someone and of course primarily it means trusting God but if you're not the person who got the Revelation then there's another at least one other but probably many other um steps of trusting someone involved right because like um so these are the two cases that block calls original revelation and the traditional revelation so original Revelation is like here's the province and God by some extraordinary means it's extraordinary because the ordinary way God tells us things is through our reason but in this case God held the Prophet by extraordinary means it's not that some proposition is true and so why does the prophet now believe that the proposition is true because the prophet trusts God not to tell them to false things right so that's why I think they just like it just it means having faith in coming like trusting um that's the first case the second case is again is obviously well I guess it was obvious maybe not everyone would agree with this but uh but uh uh it's what we would think of as the more usual with those which is God tells the prophet but a certain prophetism is true and then the prophet tells me the proposition internal that's traditional revelation and of course normally there'll be lots and lots of steps right the prophet told someone who told someone else and told someone else and told someone else blah blah blah eventually he gets to me the issue in this simple anyways God told the Prophet The Prophet told tells me now I have I there's two trucks that I have to go on here right because I have to trust God to tell me the truth just the same way the prophet did his original Revelation but I also have to trust the prophet to tell me that God said now like why do I trust the prophet how do I decide whether to trust the product well I have to use my reason [Music] right as Locke says you can't tell me if I ask you why I should trust this product you can't tell me that's a matter of thing because I mean that is you could it's been similar to The Case of the freedom of the will thing maybe you could do it once but you can't always do it right because they would need an infinite number of profits saying that some Prophet told me to trust this Prophet because God told the second prophet for him so here's the second one God hold the second prophet that didn't Prophet is trustworthy this Prophet tells me that this Prophet right so obviously this is going to be a general solution so um so I can't this can't be a matter of Faith so that has to be either demonstration or probable arguments um and which is it going to be well like as Locke says this is book 4 chapter 18 section 4 on Page Six ten um or he has no greater an assurance than that of his senses that it is written in the book supposed written by Moses inspired but he has not so great and assurance that Moses wrote that book as if he had seen Moses write it so the Assurance of its being a revelation is less still than the Assurance of his senses still um this is something that took me a long time to reel still used to mean always the 17th century still means allergies so right what he's saying is the Assurance of it's being Revelation is less always than the Assurance of his senses um I saw Moses write the book um I still have to believe that Moses is telling me the truth when Moses said God told him he doesn't mention that in his passage but he does mention that other place and then it's clearly an issue and how do I know both well I mean I'm gonna have to say like in my experience Moses is a trustworthy guy other people have said he's trusted right these are the the regular ways we make probably checks um so that's why I said to begin with that first of all faith is not going to lead to knowledge in large sense right the most it's ever going to get at least certainly traditional Revolution is not going to get you any higher than probability um but um what about original Revolution now I mean this is less relevant because most people don't think they have original Revelation so um but still like to complete this you know discussion we need to talk about original Revelation can you get knowledge that well um the prophet has to know that it's God who's talking to us framing what is this extraordinary way like you you know see a burning switch and a voice comes out of it or you have a vision you know I don't know something happens and you have to decide whether God is the origin I mean we can suppose there's a demonstration although luck doesn't really provide this demonstration you know an even Descartes doesn't exactly provide a demonstration says something about it but we suppose that the demonstration that God would never lie to us suppose and that God can't be wrong about it so like those are the two ways someone could Lead You astray when they tell you something they could be wrong or they could be lying to you right so you might think okay there's no problem but but there is still a problem because actually locked up as two problems one problem is you have to be sure that God is talking to you and the other problem is you have to be sure that you understand correctly what God told them I guess the part that confusing me a little is it seems like being lied to would still be original revelation it's it's going to be the introduction of an idea from an external source that is is not I guess perceptive well but yeah but it wouldn't be a way of extending your knowledge here's the awareness right I mean if you were lied to and so like and so if you knew you know that this Revelation comes from a being that sometimes lied to that will sometimes lie to you then you you know you wouldn't so yeah I guess you could still call that rebel I mean I know that doesn't mean by Revelation Revelation means like revealing I don't know like lying is not really but but anyway the point is if it's going to be a way of examining your knowledge you have to you have to believe that the being the songs are truthful yeah um but it comes like in the form of a dream or yeah it could be a dream I mean uh uh you know I would that was basically I was saying the two Alternatives I was offering that either you know the physical or you know experience a physical Miracle or a constitute in a dream or a vision um but maybe there's other ways too but the point is whatever the way is number one it's going to have to communicate a proposition to so it has to have some kind of like talking aspect to it and uh and you have to um be sure what the source of that is and that you understand it from yeah wouldn't would traditional Revelations have to come before original Revelation because like it but the initial like knowledge would need to be like Realize by others in order for you to know that that is knowledge yourself [Music] are you saying that the prophet in order to be sure that it's God that's talking to them has to check with other people yeah um I don't think Locke is thinking that but like maybe loving us um um but uh yeah I don't think Vlog is thinking that but I mean because how would Lawton explain the increase in certainty that you get by talking with this person um I mean I guess if we're talking about a miracle you could ask other people if they saw it but but like anything like that is only going to be probability right like if in other words if it's I mean so first of all that wouldn't really be traditional Revelation coming before original Revelation that that it would be like yeah but somehow talking to other people is going to increase the profits um will attach more probability to this thing that they that they heard um but that will never get them to certain yeah so if if there is a way to get certainty from original Revelation that's not going to involve this okay so um but you know but but again I think Block's point exactly is that it never raises it rises to that level and that's why he says that um um even original Revelation can never so original Revelation law says can or could do things that traditional Revelation doesn't for example in traditional Revelation I can't if I had a new simple idea that you've never had I can't like if God caused a new simple idea in my mind that you've never had I can't transmit that to you you know which original Revelation that could happen but um but uh um but what even original Revelation can't do is um cause me to know something that goes against the dictates of my reasons right so like if a voice comes sit down from heaven and says you know two plus three equals four then I have to wait for myself like I mean it I think law acknowledges it may be very probable that's a Divine voice and I don't know exactly how that's established but I think like at least lock lock can freely give that away anyway right it may be I may be like entitled to think it's very probable if that's God that's on one side but on the other side two plus three is definitely not poor that's not probability that's certain so like however small the chance that either that voice is not God but I don't understand it properly it's still higher than the champ but two plus three equals four great so um so like so which basically I'm not saying the original Revelation also never Rises to the level of knowledge it's always just probability it might be very high probability but you can see the difference in that kind of case where there's supposedly a revelation of something that's contrary to reason now I mean one place this is heading as usual if you look in a book 4 chapter 18 section 5. come page 610 um the mind has so evident let's see for example the ideas of one body in one place do so clearly agree and the mind has so evident a perception of their agreements that we can never a sense to a proposition that affirms the same body to be in two distant places at once however it should pretend to the authority of a divine revelation since the evidence first that we deceive not ourselves in ascribing it to God secondly that we understand it right can never be so great as the evidence of our own intuitive knowledge whereby we discern it impossible for the same body to be in two places at once right so as usual he's not thinking about the Eucharist hey like um it doesn't matter how infallible you think of Poker or even like a voice comes down from happening tells you to the same body could be two places at once block says um that it's still more probable that uh you're a mistake that it's not really God or whatever because it's impossible for the same body to do both at once and supposedly that you know is an intuitive truth okay um but so that's one thing he has in mind but I think another thing has in mind is again remember that the the the um moral laws the Divine Law is supposed to be demonstrated right so like if a voice comes down from heaven and says um go kill those innocent people and take all their stuff says you can you say well it's highly probable that God is telling me to kill those innocent people and take all this stuff on the other hand it's certain that God doesn't want me to kill innocent people and take all this therefore Ray that wasn't God or you know whatever so um so they so that the other thing he's thinking is that um um this will prevent religion from trying to interfere with morale um presumably that's more important presumably Turlock that's more important than some issue about the youthless um uh maybe he doesn't emphasize it as much because it's like um because it you know like any respectable Anglican audience is gonna be like when you give them a Eucharistic example it's going to be like oh yeah right Revelation can never be contrary to Aretha so like that's very easy to accept but then you also like by the way convinced from the Revelation can't be contrary to ethics which is really more important um now I mean there's another issue here and so this what Hume is going to do with this and unfortunately we aren't going to read this part of you but insurance essay on miracles um he says that um so actually like Kim says that there might be something you could see that would cause you to believe that a miracle has occurred um I mean you know to understand what human means by that we have to get into the stuff we're going to read and hear him later about in one sense you can believe what you see ever right but um at least according to the ordinary ways we form opinions you know like if you see and Kim defines a miracle as a violation of the laws of nature that's for example not at all hospitals Miracle the nevermind so right so human finds a miracle is a violation of the laws of nature and so he says you know if you see it yourself then yeah you're going to believe it but suppose someone tells you there was a miracle so now he says well on the one hand we have the like very low probability that there's been a violation of the laws of nature in some sense that's like based on the way Hugh thinks we form judgments that's like the lowest possible probability right and on the other hand we have the probability that the person telling you this is lying or deceiving themselves out of analicism or enthusiasm or whatever um and Jim says that's not a low probability that happens all the time that's actually really high top ability and so he says that um you can like you can never be given testimony that will cause you to believe in a miracles that's his that's him's conclusion yeah I feel like that reasoning why is conventional Revelation like the probability that someone is crazy is way higher seeing percentage than being about that um right you mean in this simple case of traditional Revelation yeah where you're just judging this you know I mean this person doesn't come out of nowhere and claim to be a thought right I mean you know that's like that's not the story of the prophets of the Bible Well maybe sometimes it is but um but uh yeah I think but you know I mean even more so in the usual case of traditional Revelation right where you like where I mean you know that people copy down books I mean it's a tribute them and you know the interests and important views and whatever and you're like yeah that's those things are really likely miracle happened very unlikely you know so the question is the president is going to raise this does locked follow him and statically you know does he really think the traditional Revelation I mean that's certainly not what he says the law really think the traditional Revelation at least in many steps removed the way we are just doesn't you know um never gives much probability at all or does he think he has or is he not noticed hume's argument I mean that's possible but what he's saying is so close to it that it's a little hard to believe but you know or does he have some answer to it but I'm not sure what it would be those basically it's about possibilities I'm not sure which is right um okay that's all I want to say about Dave and so um I have 10 minutes to talk about relative existence better than zero sometimes having a few years um just I'm not sure which of the most important thing is what knowledge of existence means in general well I mean okay so remember way back when in book 2 chapter 7 Locke said existence and unity are two other ideas that are suggested to the understanding by every every object without an every idea Within when ideas are in my our minds we consider them as being actually there as well as we consider things to be actually without us which is that they exist or have existence so um right so every time I put it before every time I have any idea it comes comes in with the idea of existing you know so like here's the idea um so like every idea comes somehow together with the idea of existence in this existence this connection means that the idea exists and that it's object that it's right the idea I remember is the immediate object of my operation but that the median of the external object exists um but presumably this doesn't mean that everything that I have an idea of necessarily exists now um presumably I mean that is what Spinoza thinks right Spinoza thinks that every idea I have so every idea I have is an idea of it that Brian um attribute of thoughts and all of their objects exist so whenever I have an idea its object exists um by the way spinos Espinoza died in Amsterdam in 1677 launched arrived in Amsterdam in 1683. so there's like constantly speculation but I haven't it's hard I'm aware there's no like real strong evidence but there's possibly speculation that Locke might have you know probably like met people from Spinoza Circle I talked to them or something but anyway that's so that's not what lock is I mean he even Spinoza thinks that what what that that's true soups PCA attorney tactics right then like uh it's true when we look at all things as existing or not all simultaneously but it doesn't mean that the object of every one of my ideas exists now um and so I mean actually I think that's kind of like similar to what as I said before if this is a simple idea then um its object does exist or used to exist right because and again like how we know this is is never really never really resolved how we know this but we know this is like this is what makes lock and appearances we know that every single idea if it's not a sensation is a memory foreign can't make its own simple ideas so if I have a simple idea now I must have had it in the past as a sensation so its object existed then so in the case of sensible things right so there's three cases but I don't know if I'm going to get it all of them like external objects that is bodies missing from this list is other Minds as is missing from King of Hearts list in the united Pages although you can maybe gather some things about what lock thinks about that if you need Parable but you know number two is in Excel and number three is God so right Locke says that I have intuitive knowledge of my own existence I have demonstrative knowledge or can have demonstrative knowledge of God's existence and how do I know these of external objects well he says he calls it um sensitive knowledge and he says it's not so certain as intuition this is one of the cases where it's weird like what do you mean it's not so certain he says it's not so certain as Intuition or demonstration but it's certain enough to be called knowledge why he thinks it's not so certain um that is why is it different from this so how do I what is what's the source of my intuitive knowledge that I exist well like for example I'm wondering now whether I exist right or I'm doubting the other reasons qualifications discussing this um case brains away you know um so that means here's the operation of my mind that doubt and this operation is reflection it's immediate object is an idea the idea about maybe that's probably a complex idea but anyway so but you know um that is positively by the operation of doubt maybe that's not a company so this is just like knowledge and and from that I can move that the subject the substance in which doubt in here is the substance that carries out that operation exists this is just like if I say you know I'm looking at a snowball I have the idea of white [Music] um I conclude that the operation of um looking right um exists and therefore the result can be in which it adhere is the thing that looks white exists right these are like exactly parallel to each other so the question is why is one of them supposed to be more certain than the other um but I'm not sure but I think um it might have to do actually with the fact that we know some we know more about external objects than we know about ourselves we know more about them than we know about us so like that is um because like what's what I directly know here is there's something that can cause me to perceive the idea of what what I want to know is that there's a snowball but to know there's a snowball there means knowing something that has certain properties and causes me to perceive the idea of white there and um I know [Music] um I know some real properties that a snowball is supposed to have right it's supposed to be round and solid both of primary qualities so there's like um something I'm actually thinking of under one quality then attributing whiteness to it as well and I can be wrong about that right because you know it could be that this is a hologram of a snowball so it's not valid um whereas in the case of myself I don't know anything about myself except that on the subject of these operations so I can't be wrong right like I can't can't turn out it was just a hologram of myself because in that case I would be a Holier um so I I but I mean anyway this is the best I can do to try to explain this so so like the uncertainty in this it's not that Locke thinks it's uncertain block I think block thinks it's as certain that there's something white as but I expect but what's uncertain is whether something white is and but that's that's what I'm really trying to know whenever I know about external things and that's always less certain um or I mean I think it's put it differently it's like things are either certain or they're not but this one is a mixture of something certain with something that's not certain there's a particular idea that the computer is a certainty it's all right now but but I think that like what so I guess put it this way what I'm certain of is that there's something white there what I'm not certain of is that it's a snowball but when I see a snowball you know I have sensitive knowledge that there's a snowball there so that's not like pure unmixed certainty um I I you know that's the best I can do it doesn't fit the text very well so probably not and I don't have time to talk about the existence of God except I'll just say this is like it has some interesting features but it's not very Innovative um it's similar to traditional groups they just died I'll leave it back okay | Abraham Stone | UCgPflbWILJzwXdKvQ8wNODg | 2023-05-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 11,493 | 60,163 |
n817mMRB45A | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n817mMRB45A | John Stewart's Calculus Section 3.1 Q5 | all right we're back another video this time question five from section 3.1 of john stewart's calculus so uh for this one we have a constant so we need to remember the derivative of a constant is just zero we have a first degree polynomial and the derivative of the first degree polynomial is just one and finally we have a higher order polynomial which in order to find the derivative of you just move the power in front and you subtract one from it that's it so first we need to then the fourth step of course is to identify what we have in our question so we have a first degree point no no we'll do that one first because it's simple it's just one all right now we have a higher order point no no so we have to take the derivative of it we move the 75 down in front and we subtract 1 from 75 75 minus 1 is of course 74 and finally the derivative of a constant is 0. so putting that all together we have 75 x to the 74th power minus one plus zero the zero just drops off so you just have 75 x to the 74 minus one and that's it that's how we solve that problem if you like this video please consider liking subscribing as i'll be solving more problems from this textbook in the near future thank you and goodbye | Math Made Fun | UCFoq7lSRjP7cB8t61NKAn0Q | 2021-01-17 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 244 | 1,213 |
FWgeGCzlljY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FWgeGCzlljY | TTE Notti Addresses Snitch Allegations, Big Ak Exposes His Ex Girlfriend Homegirl | yo it's definitely Cloudchaser TV man we back up in this thing again you dig hey man we got some news to report man when it comes down to this whole Terence Gangster Williams on9 TV TT naughty you know they put out some paperwork you feel me and uh Gangster Williams he was pretty much on the podcast today right and um [ __ ] you know who came through right TT nauy he came through to address everything you feel me so um when it comes down to that situation we going to break it down live and direct like we always do you feel me we got a u few special guests in the building where we gonna have them chime in on this particular subject you feel me as well as man if y'all ain't heard about this this [ __ ] right here now this gonna be the one that's why we gonna do this one last the academics big AK man exposes his ex-girlfriend and then her hom girl comes out to expose him you feel me this the type of [ __ ] that's going on Gang live and direct you feel me so um y'all get in the comments y'all let me know what y'all think share this on Facebook and Twitter for us with a hashtag let them know what we talking about we got ganga Williams TT naughty We Got U academics you feel me we got Gangster Williams That's Terence ganga Williams bird man you feel me we going to get to that too as well as um DJ academics y'all heard what he been doing bro it seemed like he crashing out this weekend you hear me this going into 2024 so he going at Metro booming and we going to talk about that too as well so um again man y'all stay tuned let's get to it man let's get to the first piece of content you feel me when it comes down to it let's go all no C homie no c i damn TT slow down my boy slow down my boy slow down we need to know what's going on you feel me cuz this man put some allegations on you I was wondering when you was going to respond to it but they got you live and direct to answer you feel me that's what's up feel me shout out o TV man T ganger Williams went up there they been live for them in like four hours I think you feel me they' been talking about it let's get to it man give me that give me that bro because right now a lot of BS I my own you sayig I don't sit there I hand out nobody for doing everything do hold up hold up let me finish I my problem with and I I told straight up I don't like you but this what I have to say now when I get why he talking y'all why he talking I'mma hit it back because he talking fast as hell you hear me but I'mma hit it back just a little bit you know but um while he talking they pulling up that paperwork they pulling up that paperwork they want to know what's going on they letting them go they already told him slow down man slow down Jim let's get it man y'all know TT n let him know man I'mma drop the link in the uh chat y'all let him know we up here get the [ __ ] out you can y all you want Noom give me that give me that my own [ __ ] I don't sit up there you can'ts I came no hand out ask no for help doing everything do you came on my channel you came hold up hold up let me I my problem with and I you listen to video I told her straight up I still don't like you but this what I have to say now when I get stopped I'm 78 I was question with a Rob he said you are not you not you the or you get in to slow let slow his stop stop why is you speaking to the police D let's slow him down a little bit Yeah the video I told him straight up I don't like you this what I have to say now when I get sto I'm 78 I was going I was going for question with a WR he said you are not you do not you can follow us to the thing or you can get in our car [ __ ] you mean it's with chisty stop stop why is you speaking to the police without your lawyer I I'm a young [ __ ] I have no lawyer I don't care you got the right to remain silent anything you say can and won't be used against you to call law homeboy if you in the street you got to do the law hold on so I'm wrong I'm wrong if the law say hey can you come here for questioning the question hold up it don't matter if you go by yourself or with your lawyer you answer the question it do matter cuz if your lawyer standing there the lawyer ain't going to let them violate your rights and the lawyer can say he ain't answering that he ain't gonna say nothing about I end up going I end up going to State Jail yeah I end up going to State Jail cuz my my partner told him everything about yeah he P the gun on I went to stay jail for 18 months they d this man just said that he pulled the gun on him like damn I hope dude ain't come trying to come home off a pill my boy you know what I'm saying sometime people talk too fast you hear me real talk it don't matter if you go by yourself or with your lawyer you answer question it do matter because if your lawyer standing there the lawyer ain't gonna let them violate your rights and the lawyer can say heing that he ain't going to say nothing about absolutely going to State Jail yeah I end up going to State Jail cuz my my partner hold them everything about yeah he pull the gun on I went to St jail for 18 months they dropped you to death of a person that's what I did so if I told on myself I told on myself that's what it is so what TT TT let's go yeah I Ain no R I ain't no r i told on myself so what my [ __ ] I told on myself I myself2 this my [ __ ] [ __ ] I you don't run nothing you run your goddamn mouth now let me ask you damn he was letting that [ __ ] get no questions in right that [ __ ] TT Dy would let nobody get no questions in gang like real talk like think about it like this man literally going off he going off the media when it come to this [ __ ] you feel me and I'm listening I'm like yo let the man ask you the questions because then you can clear your name you feel me then this smut don't move on to a different place because now he addressing it so you know what it means right other bloggers gonna pick this up man they G to start posting it's gon to start the whole conversation and if it is a issue you feel me it is a discrepancy it's going to be called out you feel me so he should have just like so therefore he can always reference this particular situation like yo when they ask me this I answer this way you feel me so I don't know man what's up with this boy TT nauy man it's it's looking bad man he definitely on the rise and [ __ ] yo ghost what you think about this situation bro when it come to uh TT nauy I feel like this bro anytime a [ __ ] do all that fast talking trying to overt talk people and talk loud and think speaking loud or aggressively make you right or it's parallel with being correct I think you got something to hide I feel like it's definely more to his story I feel like he's sweating right now he look like he look like he nervous about something for sure he he up there like I know he drinking [ __ ] you know what I'm saying but like man they whatever said on this live must have triggered that [ __ ] you feel me he got him outside his body you know and Terence ganger Williams if y'all ain't seen that Terence gaser Williams basically expressed these thoughts earlier because he the one who put out the video of TT Nati saying that BG was a snitch I don't know if y'all heard that audio right let me get that together and [ __ ] for you hey ghost you heard that [ __ ] which Ario you talking about ch when TT nauy he said that uh BG was a snitch on the phone and [ __ ] oh yeah yeah yeah I heard that I heard that when he was um talking to that dude and he was referencing Terence Gangster Williams and BG like they both rats right yeah I heard that I heard that TT nauy and the crazy part is he was just threatening to release a phone call with with duberry about a month ago you feel me and somebody leaked this phone calltime you can't put that type of energy in this world gang I'm telling you cuz it's going to be ugly you feel me [ __ ] is crazy let me U Pull up this audio real quick for y'all so y'all can hear this [ __ ] Terence ganger Williams is literally that fathering do look this what he say got me I whatever damn you hear this [ __ ] he said I ain't even address this BG situation you feel me all this ganger Williams he said y'all all rats y'all all rats that's what people tripped out of like y'all seen he'll be going hard for BG or whatever he said that he was even BG salate you feel me like he was just buy he was just like [ __ ] they was in the same sale together gang he talking about how he know BG was on the phone with ti booy um Rick Ross um [ __ ] Bird Man how they even came about they situation even working on some of the [ __ ] that happened in the past he saying that he was there he was his Sate at the time right so now you see he come out he all around OG freeze like OG freeze need to get away from dude you know what I'm saying cuz me personally bro I'm going keep it a buck for you let me go stream for y'all right I'mma keep it a buck for y'all man me personally I think that nigga's a clucker you feel me like buddy already talking about he was doing [ __ ] boming Floyd for goddamn it 10 years his brain cells is fried gang they fried you feel me that [ __ ] TT nauy brain is fried and I see why he admitted to it you do some type of drug like that bro trust me it ain't going to be right ever again for you you feel me that's why we try to tell encourage the youth like man stay away from that [ __ ] stay away from these these different obstacles that you already seen the outcome from from these stupid ass [ __ ] like TT na you feel me do I think he a snitch I don't know yet gang I don't know if if he a snitch yet I ain't went over all the paperwork but me personally I do think he a goofy ass [ __ ] and I think he a clucker that [ __ ] still doing something I don't know what the [ __ ] he on budy ass be sweat M interview you know what I'm saying like the one uh he was on the one podcast they was like damn I seen you like I woke up later on you were still live and this and that like do you sleep you heard what that [ __ ] Kodak Black said right he tried that meth and he loved it Them [ __ ] be for days man I'mma keep it a buck for you let's get back to the content though let's see what they talking about hold on gang let's see what they talking about y mad on each other for on the de whatever ISO I don't how the [ __ ] you know this how hold on bro how you know you this how you I'm saying how like talk to me that [ __ ] crazy G that [ __ ] crazy but that's what we got going on when it comes to this tt90 situation and [ __ ] hold on let me see uh this [ __ ] wow hold on gang yo what's the word what's the word yo what's the word bigie all right all right this what gonna have to end up happening TT n might end up being the first dude is that one of these people they talking about gonna get pulled up on and that's where it's going to go to because the embarrassment that these dudes going through and and association with that yeah when you say something man I don't care if you on the internet on the phone or whatever be able to say that same thing in person when somebody talk to you facts be able to be able to be able to on it now and once they start you going to see it in the next three months somebody gonna pull up on one of the blogers whatever bro they gonna confront him and they gonna expose they gonna whoop their ass right there on tap watch and see yeah I think gonna be a blogger that like you know it's different Cloud Chasers and [ __ ] they do different things I think it's gonna be a blogger that specifically go Target other bloggers and call them out for they [ __ ] man and get them on camera I think that's coming soon I've been seeing it since early of this year but um I definitely think that that's was going to be you know something that's going to move the culture we GNA see what's but then but then TT block he said he had an interview at no jumper and told BG he gonna ride for him he gonna catch whack ass out there I think if I'm not mistaken he said he got an interview on the ninth you know what I'm saying so he about he gonna ride for B but he's calling him a snitch in the same tone these nigg doing anything for clay when they get talking about this is entertainment purposes that's dick ride that's clout Tason that's going to get your ass handed to you no fact they cause you saying entertainment that ain't entertaining talking about somebody snitching messing up somebody jacket like that them people gotta go back to they City bro and and you putting allegations like you putting people lives in je and their fam but the same [ __ ] they talking about these [ __ ] snitches this that the third I bet they wouldn't tell them to their face it's just wild to me how like this like how could [ __ ] just they automatically be like yeah this [ __ ] real and [ __ ] this the realest person and all that and they always fell them you know why they always fell him and I'mma tell them the secret how I be knowing that [ __ ] be faulty because they talk too [ __ ] much bro ain't no reason why you need to try to solidify yourself online if you one of them guys in these streets man that don't even make any sense to me sound like some sucker [ __ ] it sound like a [ __ ] trying to relive something you feel me that's all I be saying man but um we gonna get to it we gonna get to this other content where we at with it let me go to the um this academics man this academics in Metro booming gang academics and Metro booming like what's up with academics and Metro booming man about to tell y'all why they got some beef so as y'all see academics goes off on Metro booming good morning peace shred he said you a be ass [ __ ] don't like [ __ ] about me you a ho ass [ __ ] every time I violate you you basically ran and tuck your tail damn bro hold on bro now we got to make this make sense right let me let me put this up man we got to make this make sense gang so academics is saying that he violating Metro booming but how does that even work he saying you a [ __ ] ass [ __ ] I don't like [ __ ] about me you he say don't don't like [ __ ] about me right you a ho ass [ __ ] every time I violate you you basically ran it and tuck your tail so he talking about some online [ __ ] that that be the thing though he talking about some online [ __ ] now he don't know what type of time in Metro booming is in real life RL you [ __ ] watch too many g GTA RP videos you hear me this [ __ ] real life gang yo ghost how you feel about what I just said bro like he he don't he know the difference bro I'm trying to figure out D the man know the difference hi what's the word what's the word like do do the man know the difference though like when it come down to it bro like at the end of the day yeah you I think you got to come go back out and come back in and [ __ ] you got to go back out and come back in but yeah man so academic to me personally bro he crashing right now this weekend bro last I seen some people do some strange ass [ __ ] in the last two weeks gang I'm not gonna lie to you this is a crazy year man it all it had his ups and downs is bumps and turns all the way through 2023 man that's Jordan year man 23 man shout out to MJ man for real this Chicago [ __ ] [ __ ] academic's been having a hard ass [ __ ] last few days with this whole situation about him going to get exposed all 2024 you feel me so with that being said he tried to jump in front of some things and when he went and jumped in front of these things it still wasn't enough you know still wasn't enough yo ghost yo I can hear you now bro what's good with it bro man what up bro what up bro man this this this this this stuff with academics man this this looking real bad bro this looking real bad bro but but this basically this this basically like Karma bro this go back to like things me and you talked about behind the scenes for months now maybe even a year now like when academics first start feeling itself and he start like going real aggressively at rappers like talking down on rappers calling rappers broke and things like that you know like we knew that that would catch up to him and a lot of rappers wouldn't want to go to his platform what academics failed to realize bro is his platform is build off of content about rappers if rappers stop coming to your show you don't have a show bro you feel what I'm saying so now we learn that that's in fact true because Spotify cut him loose bro because he couldn't produce the content that they needed he couldn't produce the content um volume wise that they needed bro and had he not ruined some of those relationships by talking so down on these rappers he would have that content that he needed and he would have got his contract extended but unfortunately due to him running his mouth so much that contract got cancelled now that's one thing second thing let's go to this Metro booming [ __ ] bro just like you said bro how the [ __ ] do you violate a [ __ ] online bro like that shows you how much he's wrapped up in the internet thinking that the internet is actually real life bro you could never violate a [ __ ] on the internet and say he ran bro how the [ __ ] a [ __ ] ran from you on the internet bro that [ __ ] sound crazy to me bro I just really feel like a is crashing out bro and he's lost bro like like like he he's spiraling out of control at this point bro dealing with this this girl like she treating him like a sucker you know what I'm saying it's like at this point he likes to get treated that way bro he likes to be used bro he like those type of Ratchet females that want to take his money from him tear up his his relationships treat him like [ __ ] but yet you you talk about all these rappers and and clown them and say things about them bro but you let a female that ain't nowhere near your level treat you like like like you beneath her bro like this [ __ ] ain't adding up Chuck this [ __ ] ain't adding up bro then on top of that Chuck check this out bro this [ __ ] say this [ __ ] say the girl first off the first situation was this bro her friend she invites her friend to a home bro [ __ ] try to kick in acto kidnap him do all type of [ __ ] to him they trying to do all type of [ __ ] to him bro mind you all this happened off the strength of this girl bro he still go back and deal with her now if if you a [ __ ] that got any kind of sense bro regardless if the female had anything to do with that situation bro I'm still cutting you off just so I can protect myself bro this a crib that act talk about all the time that he has his mama in bro you have your mother here bro yo ghost what's good bro you can hear me yeah yeah yeah I can hear you bro like like like we into this [ __ ] bro this [ __ ] is crazy bro like how do academics keep going back to this chick Chu the chick the chick the chick set him up to be robbed and the chick stole 500k bro like this [ __ ] gotta be the biggest sucker ever yo yo yo can you hear me can you hear me yep yep yep you can hear me you can hear me yeah hell yeah man we had a um audio issue and [ __ ] man this [ __ ] crazy bet we back we back we back so like you saying though with this whole Metro booming situation bro if you go go again with that for me real quick bro like far like academic seem like he Tak on the street level you feel me well see this this my thing Chuck like my opinion on this is is parallel with yours bro it's exactly like yours bro you said something very important bro like how can academics say that he's violating somebody and that that Metro booming is running tucking his tail when you just talking about a [ __ ] on the internet bro we don't call talking about a [ __ ] on the internet a violation bro it's just what it is it's cutting dry you talking about a [ __ ] on the internet now if academic said these things to Metro Boomer in his face that's a different thing bro but that's something we've yet to see and I doubt we'll ever see that from academics because he don't be outside acting like this with [ __ ] bro he don't have this energy outside he not not letting his nuts hang when he go to these industry events talking crazy [ __ ] faces and [ __ ] bro that's not who he is bro but I think he's he's getting the internet and real life Mison screwed bro because how you feel like you violated a [ __ ] on the internet that ain't how it work at that a that ain't how it work at all you know what I'm saying that was that was definitely my point like yo bro what's to him he crashing out ever since he this this podcast came out like some of it at least where he dropping Snippets of this whole situation with his exgirl friend she trying to expose him you know what I'm saying it's getting there bro it's definitely getting there it's getting there on many levels where I ain't never seen academic talk like this [ __ ] online bro like why would he he be talking about rappers was talking like this online Am I Wrong y'all y'all get in the comments and let me know man share this live man we got about 60 people in the building man share this live let's get it out there gang hit the like button you feel me because we talking some real [ __ ] right now you dig real talk I can't believe this [ __ ] though like why would academics be saying you a [ __ ] ass [ __ ] don't like the [ __ ] don't like [ __ ] about me you a ho ass [ __ ] every time I violate you you basically ran and tuck your tail you basically you basically does that mean because he's acknowledging that this is internet [ __ ] he saying you basically what does that mean bro I don't know bro I I think that's some of his internet language bro like like like this [ __ ] really feels like Viola [ __ ] on the Internet is a violation bro no Act is not bro like I don't know who is in his ear bro allowing him to really get these false misconceptions about the internet in real life like being the same thing bro but it's not not when it come to [ __ ] like violating somebody bro to violate somebody bro you got to do this in person this is not something you can type this is not something you can speak you can't type that [ __ ] out gang right that remind me of them Clubhouse [ __ ] they be ra ra that [ __ ] remind me of the party line man in the 2000s but only difference is [ __ ] was really in their cities talking their [ __ ] so [ __ ] [ __ ] around get clapped you feel me these [ __ ] all around the world talking to a [ __ ] extra hard when you know he 3,000 miles away from you but when it's 100 miles away These [ __ ] be quiet and then they tuck they tail you feel me just like probably like this situation we know Metro booming from where Atlanta right well he he he originally from St Louis but you know he he grew his his to his stardom through in Atlanta you know what I'm saying okay so even then St Louis Atlanta and that [ __ ] in Jersey that that's a a long long stretch you feel me even if you come to that come that way and you act like that it's that like say Metro booming it looks like it's almost premeditated when he the one who started it you feel me but that's the type of [ __ ] that's going on in the culture right now man don't get tricked out of your position man [ __ ] need to stay in their Lane this goes for academics man your academics bro you up bro you know what I'm saying like some [ __ ] going to happen bro you must about to hit another level because why the [ __ ] is this coming out this this happened to a lot of them right some of us got to be more careful you feel me that's just how this [ __ ] happened me personally I never went through no [ __ ] like this where you know I'm saying the r word happened uh on my watch you feel me never ever you did but at the end of the day I know a whole lot of people around the country and it ain't like I'm sympathizing with [ __ ] I'm sympathizing with the whole situation this [ __ ] is [ __ ] up because right now like say shorty is really a victim dude dud got a loud ass voice a loud voice man you feel me his voice is very loud and we gonna get to that content right now man you know what I'm saying talk about the loud voice and what took place in this situation when it come to academics so let me pull up this academics hey CH let me say is too bro um we got to we got to really look at this and we really got to break this down to the to the to the to the to the smallest fraction bro and if we really look at this and break it all the way down bro academic's complete downfall is all centered around this one female bro all the problems that he's had in this last year have been all centered around this one female bro why would you keep going back to this bro and this woman is dragging down this Empire that you built on your own Brick by Brick by Brick bro makes no sense bro bro that don't make no sense at all none for sure we can't deny that feel me we can't deny that at all man let's get the likes up man I don't know how many likes we got in the building but let's get them joints up man get the likes up let me pull up this video building step for the cloud it's St for the cloud chaser TV dang this Chicago [ __ ] oh yeah don't forget to go um stop at the merch store bro we got some [ __ ] on there man for all you you know what I'm saying for your for your jeans and [ __ ] you feel me for the stack jeans for [ __ ] whatever you wear bro we got the shirts right now popping bro in the jackets you feel me go to um d o TCC do shop bro right now gang you know I'm saying a lot of products sold out right now you know I'm saying we appreciate the support but um we gonna go back live where everything gonna be restocked probably in the next uh couple of weeks so y'all stay tuned but if you haven't already go check that out so you can know what you want to buy you feel me salute I appreciate the support though let's get to it though let me see so let's get to what academic said then we going to get to what old girl said you feel me hold on one second gang cuz this this [ __ ] is wild though I ain't going to lie to you it's gonna get deep big see the link in the chat on streamyard we're about to get get get deep yeah 19 minutes let's get it years before it's like I won't call her a side tick because I don't even think she knew I was in no relationship like she was just a girl shorty comes over here I sent her Uber I went to Antonio Brown party type [ __ ] [ __ ] I went to the party [ __ ] I knew I was gonna get drunk I don't let nobody drive my cars [ __ ] my my cheapest car is $142,000 RS7 my cheapest car I got G wagons $200,000 I got a Lamborghini that $300,000 you hear this right let me let me make reference to this since we starting it that way right but let me make reference to this man so look so even though Crim nobody was charged nobody went to jail or whatever right but civil he still might be liable because you don't need the percentage I think in U criminal you need over 90% you know what I'm saying well at least over 70% you feel me trial a jury they going to be the Judgment right when it comes to this whole situation they didn't even file charges they they went away went away but I'mma give you a reference the game y'all just seen in the news with the game right the game just came out and it pretty much just said how he got another judgment with this same woman who alleged him a sexual assault right so it didn't go criminal but she still want seven million civil so academics he talking all this money [ __ ] right now again that's why I say some people be just be crashing out man it's def for the crashing out I thought his baby mama said that he only I mean not his baby mama but his ex-girlfriend said he only had 400,000 cash in there he was like yo what about my trust and like bro let them think that [ __ ] if that's what it is you think I only got 400,000 well I got 400,000 man you feel me but [ __ ] sometime man people talk too much on this internet I [ __ ] with academics man you feel me but this is like [ __ ] brother to brother I'm putting you up on game bro you should like like I know you be putting a lot of rappers on [ __ ] but you probably should have took your own advice in this situation bro silence let everything unfold some things got to unfold bro you don't got to be the first you don't got to be the one that like you know what let me get in front of it you it don't got to be that type of situation you feel me but [ __ ] it is what it is let's get to it though I got a [ __ ] um um rear um R8 that's also 300,000 bro like I don't have no like Acura like no disrespect to some people with Acura so I don't really let nobody drive my car because my cheapest car is like a really F car but I been I was working so hard at the time I was like that when Antonio Brown invited me to a party like he was a pool party he was in Jersey I'm like bro I needed to like onwi a bit I know sometimes y don't think that the streamer should take none out of me but it do like [ __ ] I gotta I gotta entertain y'all for six straight hours period then y'all just click me on and click me off y'all see add I might dip I who knows I gotta be on this [ __ ] trying to entertain so I was trying to just have some fun have my homies drive my car I say yo we're going to this party we go to the party once you get to the party my [ __ ] I start getting drunk yo I'm gonna tell you how crazy and how devious this [ __ ] gets because at first let me tell you how every criminal investigation go down my [ __ ] and like bro this is why I was trying to tell the stupid ass [ __ ] I'm like my [ __ ] like [ __ ] I'm really the victim in all of this [ __ ] like no no respect to the girl too you know I mean I guess she a victim you know she say you're victim but bro like I'm academics that's the by the way at the time that this [ __ ] happened that me too movement is popping bro they [ __ ] you know they don't even look at the other people they want to they want to lock me up they want to get me they're like [ __ ] all them [ __ ] what did I do so anyway here here's the thing that also kind of so anyway and this gonna [ __ ] y'all up the person so when I'm at the the party I see a random [ __ ] I swear I see a random [ __ ] the [ __ ] was like yo he he was some Italian he was like yo I don't know no academics what whatever y'all know I'm a drinker me and that [ __ ] was at the bar I was like [ __ ] I'm like [ __ ] you don't know nobody who could drink more than me gang he was like yo all right bet let's go shot for shot me and this dude went Shota shot like eight shots Chad you want to know who that [ __ ] was I found out later the detective told me the detective that investigated the same case that was his nephew me and his nephew the same day where they like remember remember the whole Police Department is thinking oh [ __ ] academics name is now in yo academics I'm going keep you real though what the [ __ ] does that even mean bro like I don't know if if ain't nobody said this yet gang I don't know I don't know if ain't nobody said this yet like but what does this mean bro keep it a buck bro like you saying that the same person that was there is a cousin nephew of a police officer wow amazing wow that's amazing y'all that's amazing you guys it's def for the cloud chaser TV that's amazing like what what does that mean though like why was it even relevant to this conversation bro but I get it academics is a good Storyteller he going to Captivate Captivate the audience you feel me let's get it yo anybody got something to say about that though bro like we got a few people online right now and [ __ ] like yo ghost how how you feel about it who's that Tyra Tyra how you feel about it yeah um well you know having had you know listened to this a few times uh and digging into it with you um you know you it just seems like every time I hear him speak first of all he is processing it with what the hell does his ego have to do and his cars and this and that have to do with what the ultimate story is about like he is shooting himself in the foot in that respect he was building up the case almost for a civil case if there was one to be going on and then he also mentioned something like he it sounds like there was criminal uh at least something that looked into it or something just the way he said that made it sound like somebody was looking into something um and then he did say I'm I'm not trying to be a victim here well I'm not the victim well the girl isn't too well she is too like so he did say you know sort of under his breath but he did Clearly say you know that she was a victim in the situation and then well uh you know obviously what else comes comes out in to this so just I'm a non-emotional standpoint what he's saying is he's already contradicting himself and and uh kind of throwing too much information on the fire that could shoot him in the foot um and other ways there's other situations that I have other investigation we want to see what's going with him even though really it's just some [ __ ] that happened to my house I had nothing I'm sleeping my name not only get cleared by my cameras thank God for the cameras my cameras clear my name it's also clear that at the party the [ __ ] I'm drinking with is the the the the nephew of the detective that's investigating the case they're like n that [ __ ] was definitely drunk as [ __ ] like they they basically carried him to the car like me and him was going shot for shot so anyway I have my homies drive my car I go like I literally get to the party I'm so drunk they're driving my [ __ ] I get drunk we are leaving the party I think we may stop it like Wendy's we get back to the crib what happened at the party though is that this girl was texting me she wanted to see me I sent her Uber she lived like two hours away [ __ ] by the time her car get even closer where I'm at [ __ ] I'm passed out I show up to my crib so my homies dropped me off the crib bro I Stumble up to my bedroom and I'm just sleeping [ __ ] I forgot what the [ __ ] happened six hours go by I get woken up by my homies I'm a little bit more so but like I bounce back real quick I never have a hangover that's a fact never have a hangover my homies with me I'm like yo bro yo lock the door we fa leave I'm like oh [ __ ] damn I'm knock for me I said what they said lock the door we F to leave I said all right bet cool they said oh and by the way remember that girl you like uber over here she in the other room on your guest like on the guest Wing what I ain't Uber no [ __ ] over here they're like [ __ ] remember you did the first thing I'm thinking about cuz I was at a party with AB there was like no disrespect to them girls that there there was just like some girls who they were definitely trying to choose but I was like these Chi do not look pretty type [ __ ] there was ratchets like no disrespect to they ever see this so I'm like oh my God I'm looking at my homies no [ __ ] way no way did I invite a [ __ ] like like crazy looking ugly chick to my crib first of all this hold on bro you already knew her Pride to you inviting her to the crib you ain't seen her multiple times sh like you said in the same audio how it was was before your girlfriend you let it be known because you know she did say she used to [ __ ] with you feel me allegedly she said that let's go like like y'all won't understand this this little point but it's like I'll invite somebody who's not from the state to my crib before I invite somebody that's around the state bro you no Jersey why would I invite you to my crib you probably got [ __ ] in Jersey [ __ ] if I fly you from Alaska [ __ ] like what's the chances you gonna have [ __ ] in Jersey you feel me like that's different right so you call same time so I'm like what any anyway they were like remember the other girl anyway they leave I lock my door so my two homies leave walk down I see shorty walk to my guest bedroom shorty naked like she's under cover like here the Shel blah BL I'm like oh [ __ ] what's going on I'm Waking I'm like y's good with you yo yo why you sleeping type [ __ ] I'm like damn so now I'm like I'm about to go down to the kitchen type [ __ ] yo come down here yo get dress do what you got to do Shorty comes down there was just like yo yeah I couldn't believe you were sleeping so I'm also like why didn't you wake me up so the whole time I'm like what y' do she was like nah we were just having fun we having fun ain't nothing happen we having fun blah blah blah blah anyway I go outside work because I had to you know this is night time I'm looking around I'm like yo something N I know my backyard ain't nothing really why [ __ ] look like it's been shorty gonna be on some [ __ ] like n nothing ain't happen she even said to me I promise you she said to me she said what you think I [ __ ] your friends and I was I really say but I was like and she was like hell no I ain't [ __ ] your friends [ __ ] like yo we was just all having fun your stupid ass was drunk and passed out all right bet [ __ ] cool this is now in the morning I gotta let my you know my real best friend Pluto you know this what y' I've gotten y I've lost so much trust in humans my only best friend is a dog I've lost so much trust in women my only person I trust is a dog I got I got my I got Pluto now I'm bringing my side like yo Pluto come on man run around do what you got to do man take a [ __ ] [ __ ] like now he's trained to take a [ __ ] outside but like no before you would be like yo what we out here for I'm like [ __ ] you out here take a [ __ ] go out there I'm like yo why the hell so that [ __ ] don't look right anyway I come back in and I'm looking through my window at the pool I said why this [ __ ] look a little weird also this is another thing that you know like I always tell these [ __ ] like like I rather not tell these stories man but I'mma always tell a story to the max where nobody could ever see I'm on any weird [ __ ] because like N I know look we gonna stop right there you know what I'm saying like this the thing you know what save academics let's put it out there you know what I'm saying while y'all listening to this it's camera footage academic went on record saying how you got cameras all over is crib everywhere everything is being with an outall is watched you feel me so they was able to pull the footage from this situation you dig and um them pulling the footage they I guess they decided not to file criminal charges because here's the thing if they had sex with this woman the DNA would be there so that's no question but it's like what was it consent you feel me was it consent that's the thing was he consent yo Big C what's good with it bro yo how you feel about this situation bro I know you was chiming in earlier like you know you you had some U good points when it came to uh this whole situation all right like you know a couple things for one when you get to a certain level certain point in life and certain maturity as a man just certain things you just don't do especially when you high-profile person and you're a person that got money you got something when you got something to lose you know if you that drunk this day and the third for one you shouldn't invited nobody at your house that late at night because you incapacitated they could have robbed them they could have robbed them dry you know what I'm saying they could have took everything whatever out the house or whatever the case is that's one thing then you got to partn them over all this that the third when you get to certain points man when you in this entertainment business everybody wants to lat on get on especially the dudes you got on the side because they want to be you and when he them cameras saved him Point Blank period because I just personally believe that like if it was something that was done he would have been seen during the course of it out there he he said Gary G blow job with two hands this that third all this other stuff and they was she did one she did the other they ran the Train on her and apparently the what he said was backed up vouched by the police department I don't care how popular he is out there this he's still a black man in a high fluent white neighborhood they would locked his ass smooth up as soon they saw something wrong regardless of whatever the case was this that thir if he did rape her whatever the case was he volunteered told her hey go get a rape kit or something he's removing himself far from the situation further for one he they in his house but he's getting his like look I ain't touched them I ain't touched the guy at all this that the third if there was something done that that was a rape or whatever if them guys would have raped her or whatever and the police and his he got his lawyer now you got the detectives and you got crime unit at this point it's a crime because they about get rape kits and all this that third if there was something was wrong at that point I without a sa out my mind the police department would have acted and did whatever they had to do with I mean because at that point he's volunteer he gave them hey here I'm not trying to hide nothing from her you know look hey y'all want the foot here go the pass Cod to the footage you know whatever y'all want cool I don't care what y'all want I ain't did [ __ ] and I'm Pro I'm working with y'all to prove that I so he cooperated with them to eliminate himself from that right and you even he cooperated because he you you see how he acknowledged the fact like yo I don't even got no friends them [ __ ] who talking about probably ain't his friends no more you feel me he like hot dog you gotta think about it prior to this point right here he worked and got to his point in the basement he was in the public first time we saw yeah first time we saw a was when he was on everyday struggle that's we really saw a face with you know okay this is him whatever the case is so and he got you know too much to lose so he know when he's at that point he's high profile so you know you got to do extra when you ain't got it you know what I'm saying so you gonna have to probably [ __ ] gon have to trick off he G you know baby I'm gonna fly you out this that he got do all that extra [ __ ] you know what I'm saying and just that on the Steelo who he is as a man but the fact that like if he didn't have them cameras man because like if he when like you said when this happened it was in the height of the me too movement they would have snatched his ass then hell yeah if he had them cameras it would have been over with but like like like I was saying earlier right it's like this bro this is 100% so if you got video now she not coherent you know what I'm saying they kind of can tell through the video not all the way but they can tell but if you do certain motions let's just say allegedly bending over or some [ __ ] um [ __ ] like he said two hands on the dick pause you feel me if if these things is going on for sure they looking at it like yo you must been a willing participant see the thing is these guys don't have actual footage so it's that word against hers or her word against theirs and it's whoever can prove to the jury what's going on if they decide to take it to trap now this is the problem right here this is the problem this same thing happened with who Tupac remember Tupac was in a hotel he was sleep in another room and the girl said Tupac rap me blah blah if Tupac would have had a camera it have been a whole different story at that point you see what I'm saying this is a year ago and she hasn't she didn't come out and just say she only came out because because he said something he brought it up y so and and as we talk about consent she says she woke up with him on top of her he had already done the dud by violating the you know physical bound allegedly and and he you know he's he's kind of all over the place of no I talked to her about the night before now I was up the night before I didn't even remember no not and and then found out the next day and I totally agree bigy like you you know he's reached a measure of stardom and notoriety he should you have to be careful he's saying he doesn't trust anybody because he he's looking over his shoulder and his dog's is only Solace but now he's got two dudes that he doesn't really know and this girl that he's been you know friends with for a couple years but they're all out there and he's too drunk to you know even he couldn't even you know help himself if something was going wrong so safety says that's not a bad or not a good decision but she was responding to this and um I just think in her statement you could hear it in her voice of um you know she didn't plan on coming out and just trying to go after him in the mean two time um she truly is uh I think she's torn up about this in a wi different way I think I think that she's embarrassed at this point because he did come out and say something so he you know he came out and said okay not only did she [ __ ] my friend she [ __ ] both of them and they ran a train on the outside and I got proof to show and prove this is what happened so if he would have came in that room like she said and got on top of her she would have told the police then oh for sure hey yo emo now hold on now now mind you now you know damn where the detective ask did you have sex with her he was like no don't you think they asked her too they had her in another room hey did he have sex did he touch you no he came and woke me up what y'all do we went in the kitchen and talk now everything they say if they went in the kitchen and talk out now he said he got cameras through his whole house the camera caught them in they talking no he said you see what I'm saying so he got that footage if I promise you it's worth like he said he got a $100,000 lawyer on retainer and he paid all that money for the video system he know it's worth every dollar dime of it because if there was really a for them that they had to break tape down the polic had to break that down and they apparently they didn't they after they conclusion was we don't see nothing that was wrong on act you didn't do nothing because you ain't on no tape doing nothing these dudes didn't doing nothing because she's out she was Bing over in front of them or whatever so they let them walk allegedly allegedly look look Miss Jade salute salute saying he was drunk and don't recall stuff makes it even worse that is true that's on his part you feel feel me but but he's relying on the cameras because apparently he got cameras all over his crib so he can see everything like every [ __ ] wall it's a camera or something that's pointed to it where he can see it's a outall you feel he confronted her with the tape because she kept lying to him but no but she was she was not coming after him she was she didn't yeah that's still his truth though because here's the thing if her friend or it's her old friend or whatever he met her and then they friends his girlfriend right so if his girlfriend is saying that she going to expose him and going to expose this particular situation I get it I don't think that he should have did it this way because he brought more attention to it no his whole his fault is this here this his fault pillar talking laying on that pillar talking to that bro who stole the half million from and all that that's where it come from what what did he say exactly when it come to the half a million like yeah he said he he was Wonder he went to count his money he realized he had like 400 Grand or something like that and so he just went uh just start recollecting trying to think back on what happened so he knows when her parents whatever came together her and she gave him her ring doar camera information and he saw her at home taking the money out like he said keep it in 50 Stacks taking it out you know boom boom boom on several occasions and he told her to bring the money back and she brought brought the money back then they that she confessed to it so he put too much trust in the wrong kind of woman if you on it off in three week they woman supposed to have that kind of access to him I mean he don't supposed to let her do what so he laying on that bed he in love with her he find out she's messing with this dude dude on the practice squad with the Jets and cash zapping dudes and all that he knew he a have [ __ ] but he lied to his s thought he did we got to keep it cleared up though like that's the current right that he's with right he ain't with her no more but that's who that chick is what say or whatever but this what [ __ ] got to realize this go for everybody listen everything when you thre with that woman that ain't never your woman it's just your turn bro that ain't your woman it's just your turn because I guarantee you in the next couple weeks a month go by y'all break up she going to have another dude it's his turn they going around here whipping women and beating them up nah bro that ain't player you got to take a hit bro you gonna take a hit that's part of the game and he laid there just told that woman too much how in the hell she know that Co to nine sa in his house you know what I'm saying his wife his his mama post a no n my mama don't know what I mean certain things people just don't supposed to know you don't give people all 100% access to you like that you know what I'm saying that's immature yo man sinful to page to create other Milli this right he got the leverage to you know take people that have a um react to this right real quick he said DJ academics has too much to learn so let's let's see what he say man you know what I'm saying these these this one of the guys from the man spere let's see what he say CU a lot of people in the comments they on social media like yo academics he a simp you feel me this would have never happened to him if he w a [ __ ] simp let's get to it man a vision take people that have ambition take people that have value who mean not only themselves good but the people around them good and put them kind of people around him and just create a circle of millionaires he has that kind of power to do that [ __ ] you dig but he just he just don't think big enough man because if he thought bigger he wouldn't be dealing with these SC Wags that he be dealing with man but with no further Ado let's get into this [ __ ] man bet oh facts hopefully I could um y can hear me I'm about I'm about to look at it I didn't even turn the lights on and [ __ ] like that I do got lights up in here but like I ain't about to turn it on I think this is fine okay so he he kind of like he talks a little bit about different random stuff he starts to really get into the story I believe around here let's get to it gang it's du for the cloud Chester TV the whole [ __ ] against me they got nothing to do with me I've been looking at her different from a while ago oh let let me say this though let me say this though also I don't know if y'all know this but we got that um trap little Ross content dropping tomorrow you feel me I'm G do the Trap little Ross content I was able to ask trap little Ross why the [ __ ] is he implicating all these people and [ __ ] he say he found it on the internet so what about them guys that he saying names that that wasn't on the internet you feel me so I got him the respond to it he actually I asked him the question he got mad about it we G we gonna get to it you gonna see he got a little mad about it Angry he like yo I'm doing Tay Savage [ __ ] oh Tay Savage said [ __ ] with me but now y'all see how that panned out right same situation right because I asked him about van and I asked him about drao you know I'm saying Draco feel me we gonna get to that tomorrow though so y'all stay tuned look for the notifications on that let's get back to the content because I'm a [ __ ] really at this at this juncture for this story I'm about to tell you I'm a victim nobody knows this story and even I got my assistant sitting over there she don't know the story this is facts but I never like I paid so much and I lost so much and I was the victim of this that when I seen a [ __ ] who's supposed to be with me trying to hold [ __ ] against me that got nothing to do with me BR I've been looking at her different from a while ago like y bro like are you serious so let me tell y'all what it is shorty really thinks that I care that much or I am so scared of her telling y'all this here's what she's gonna tell you n411 unspoken crime salute man salute y'all go check out both of them Pages man and 411 she in the chat go to her page as well as unspoken crime man real talk y'all gonna be surprised or here's what she thinks is the thing September of last year okay September was it September of last year is it September or October or it might have been November my bad I don't know September October and November of last year hey man y'all tripping man you mean to tell me it's 176 of y'all up in here but only 88 of y'all wiped your feet off at the door man off at the door when you step to A Pimp's domain man while we chop this game hit that like button man don't cost you nothing but a split second and a very minute uh spec of energy hit that like button I'm telling you the facts police raided my crib they kicked my door off my mama was at my crib see trick admic this this this is his first mistake in this live or his first big mistake in this live right now he just said that the police kicked his door in I don't know I could be wrong but I don't know about that being public until he made it public right and uh I think I skipped past that part but he was saying how nobody knew this even his assistant who works closely with him didn't know this information uh so it's pretty safe to say this what this hasn't been made public until now right see man you DJ academics and see this what I want y this this is the one of the biggest things I want y'all to take from this whole video right here with with academics going live right this what I want y'all to take away hey man even if you're not an academics especially if you're an academics and you got millions of followers millions of dollars all the [ __ ] especially for somebody like him but even on whatever level you're on everything is not supposed to be on the internet all of your business is not supposed to be on the internet not at all there are certain things that you keep to yourself it's certain things that you take to the Grave with you if you got to you know what I mean and if you just don't have nobody to talk with about you just keep it to yourself that's just like for instance right it's certain [ __ ] that I was only able to share with sinful to PE right it's certain things sin man he was the only person on planet Earth that I would be able to share certain [ __ ] with right but guess what now that he ain't here at least not in the physical form like like it's certain [ __ ] that nobody will ever know nobody not my mama not my dad not my S sisters and brothers like it's just certain [ __ ] that just ain't nobody gonna know especially not the internet and these are people that's close to me that I love nearly and dearly right but hey man you got to learn how to keep [ __ ] to yourself you know this is this is worse than and see people don't look at it like that but like you know how you know why they use the termin ology air your dirty laundry you know what I mean like why they they they they use the figure of speech airing your dirty laundry when it comes to you know sharing sensitive information with the public right just think about that figure of speech airing your dirty laundry just imagine setting your dirty laundry in front of your house right skid marks uh if you a female discharge stains uh you know blood whatever right and you just put that [ __ ] on display in front of your house it's going to make you look crazy right and if somebody did that unbeknownst to you and you find out you're going to be like damn you just going toir my dirty laundry like that that's why people use that figure of speech and this [ __ ] what he just did is worse than that you know what I mean like he'd have been better off if somebody put his skid mark ass draws in front of his house and took pictures of the [ __ ] he'd be better off with that like literally somebody airing his dirty laundry over this this is crazy ain't no way in the world that you a DJ academics and you letting the world know that that you uh had your door kicked in by the police yeah it is discretion man discretion is definitely involved in this particular situation shorty never came out they say allegedly this this incident took place over a year ago right over a year ago but guess what though it's out it's out family it is what it is it's out he put it out he's the first person to speak on it I get it get in front of it right but it's consequences behind everything man real [ __ ] and it's happened over a year ago like nobody was supposed to know that man why you do that and then even if this this chick that he talking about this Cheyenne chick I ain't even look at that part she got 11,000 followers like this chick's megaphone now sometimes granted because of the subject who you talking about you don't have to be big for something to go viral like it's people that's smaller than her that have made things go viral I understand that right but hey man this chick ain't nobody man this is nobody why you letting somebody like this hold something over your head and then look at her man she look like she in high school even though she not she looked like a child she look like she in high school man she looked like she walking down the street with a with a a backpack on and then bad enough she got a letterman jacket on in her profile picture like that make her look even more like a kid this look like somebody's High School daughter man and she a grown woman though that's the sad part this is a grown woman who look like somebody's High School ass kid like you have no business a DJ academics ain't got no and then especially after all the [ __ ] this chick done done which a lot of it is gonna be uh disclosed in this video but you ain't got no business messing with nobody like this and then you you on here on on your platform where you got on this one he got 600,000 followers she's actually like a really good girl like she's a this boy just said she's a really good girl hey man and it's you know you know what this remind me of and anybody who done been to jail especially if you older and you done been to jail or you know even if you older and you reflect back to when you was younger in jail and you seen other dudes that was like this I ain't never been this type of dude but you know how like in jail you see a young dude and it's like his first time in trouble and he meets somebody in in jail for the first time that's older and seem like they cool he meet the OG and seemed like it's cool like okay OG so this what happened right I was with my [ __ ] man I let my [ __ ] come through man and I fell asleep and then and he just running the hole he telling he just pouring his heart out to this OG that he just met not knowing that OG is Cutthroat OG don't give a damn about him OG gonna give him the wrong advice because OG is a old stupid [ __ ] as damn self you know he ain't got no business pour his heart out to OG but he just like trusting OG like they go way back that's what this remind me of you know he's the young stupid [ __ ] in jail and the OG is is the thousands of people in this live stream just listening to him damn then I you know I'm I'm some damn yo that was a hell of a breakdown right there you feel me that's wild he even gave the OG comparison you feel me we gonna get back to freeze hold on let's play live you know um what she had to say about academics let's get to it again damn so she took it down hold on man got booty showing up on the screen and [ __ ] godamn [ __ ] X Man X always got some [ __ ] going on family [ __ ] is ridiculous doing the live man you can't have booty just popping up on the screen like that you feel let's get to it I look crazy right now but I'm not going to stand here and let this man continue to lie about me that's not what happened academics you know that that's not what happened and for you to pretend that you didn't do anything for you to pretend that you didn't do anything I just went to your house and I'm just some thought like we didn't know each other for two years you tried to save yourself after your friends assaulted me whether or not you got drunk or not I know that when you woke up you were on top of me whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa y'all heard what she said she said that this man was on top of her so what never mind allegedly let's get to it I look crazy right now but I'm not going to stand here and let this man continue to lie about me that's not what happened academics you know that that's not what happened and for you to pretend that you didn't do anything for you to pretend that you didn't do anything that I just went to your house and I'm just some thought like we didn't know each other for two years you tried to save yourself after your friends assaulted me whether or not you got drunk or not I know that when you woke up you were on top of me too you raped me too and a test a rape kit was done you know what I'm going to come back with my own story this what you wanted and you're about to get it I've been quiet for way too long I look crazy right now but I'm not going to stand here and let this man continue to lie about me that's not what happened academics you know that that's not what happened and for you to pretend that you didn't do anything for you to pretend that you didn't do anything that I just went to your house and I'm just so some thought like we didn't know each other for two years you y'all heard that right yo St G what's the word gang what you what you gotta say that's wild boy I don't want to say too much but that's wild yeah she like bro you think that like here's the thing though bro like you being in entertaining entertainment business right got St G in the building you feel so like bro you think that he did a disservice to himself by revealing this [ __ ] cuz it's been over a year she never came out and said anything his girlfriend was threatening him saying that she gonna come out with some a whole lot of [ __ ] including this so he saying that he got in front of it you think that was a disservice to himself yeah he should have he should have just let him do let her do what to do but he got scared that what it sound like but you never know what happen F Li to I can't speak on be I don't know it's a real situation it's a real situation I hope he ain't did nothing like this no female though that's crazy yeah no word but let me break it down because like so what happened is is like he say he was drunk he invited her to the party she came to the party to his home and um his friends end up allegedly running a train on her she's calling it the r word you feel me they police came out there they did an investigation academics got cameras in this crib so they took the footage then they came back with a conclusion that what she saying with the r word didn't happen you feel me and even academics alluded to some things and I'm pretty sure that's probably the same things cuz he alluded to it I'm I'm pretty sure this is probably what they was saying when it came to the criminal investigation I guess she had two hands on the dick so if you got two hands on the Dick are you being the r word you feel me yeah it is what it is yeah it it live in this situation you know what I'm saying explaining it like that y you know what I'm saying but you know a female when she she feel like you know when she get her feelings you know she gonna pull out especially when you you come out like that like ain't nothing happen she know anything happen she gonna be in her feeling and she gonna pull it out into the world and now she mad so she gonna really pull it out to the world so this is a sticky situation yo but the whole it sound like the whole idea for the girl to go get the artwork uh kit done was academic so I'm like I'm thinking yo if you already seen the footage and you know what you knew like why would you tell get the artwork kit on your homies though that's a little weird to me too and I get that maybe he trying to you know me protect himself but like trying to protect himself and save himself you throw the homies under the bus like notice what he said this is clear he said this he said that's why I only trust [ __ ] that's why I don't got no more friends my dog is my friend so whatever he did in probably in that situation them same guys a his friends no more for sure but he always say that he gonna snitch on somebody he always say that if he if he ever in a tyght situation he always say sing you know he back so he kep he kept it real and a woman you know if she's got some sort of a drug in her system because that's where date rape drug comes in you know is that they can physically right now listen listen though listen we we don't like at the end of the day T we don't want to add extras on it ain't there because this is a serious situation you feel me like this is like he can this can end his career you feel me so we don't even want to Alle like certain things like we can't Alle that you feel me we can only go off of what came mou then we go from that and Edge you feel me so we can have these conversations when it come to it but we got to be clear though like that ain't what was said though you feel me she didn't say she got hit with a date rape drug or if she got was intoxicated off of some drug she like apparently from what he's saying so far she saying that she's going to expose it she was drunk you feel me he saying that he got V video footage so we G to go with that yo Shantel what's the word what's the word yo what up yo how how you feel about this situation you you know I'm saying you being a woman and [ __ ] then you know I'm saying you from New York I know New York Women is a little bit more aggressive than a lot of women in this country how you feel about this situation CU this is some East Coast [ __ ] I mean i f a video where it look like the camera was left on in the room or like his live stream was on I'm not sure but her screams did not sound consensual so I don't know what's the story behind the screams but if it's actually what it is it's [ __ ] up and but if she's lying and that was some other situation then you know that's fu yeah that scream you heard basically that's recent right so that's not really related with that case what that was was the current girlfriend that went to jail right after he yo y y you back good what happened to the law [ __ ] I don't even know bro what the [ __ ] they don't want this truth to go out there just some type of evidence that they man is cheating and then they confront him about it and they trying to press him press him press him for the truth hey man real [ __ ] man we don't do that [ __ ] we don't give a damn what what she done did once we find out what it is man but then I don't you know I'm I'm some pimping but beyond that man just on some real [ __ ] [ __ ] man like I don't know like I said I can't speak for everybody else but California man we don't we don't we don't be tripping off of females like that man not not not especially ones that ain't worth nothing like these chicks that he talking about they not worth nothing man like again why are you pressing this chick because now you gonna make her feel some type of way and then she's somebody who can't even afford a $200 Uber to your house so she stands to lose nothing but gain everything if she puts you in a compromising situation like she attempted to do so um basically what he's doing by trying to trying to uh squeeze her to tell the truth about something that he knows is irrefutably true because he got video footage of the [ __ ] he ain't doing nothing but playing with fire because this is a chick with nothing to lose now you making her feel some type of way you backing her into a corner when you should have just sent her on her way and you know as a result he end up gambling with his freedom that fortunately he didn't lose already I'm thinking like I know you lying now cuz you're admitting to first of all why would you even get naked for my [ __ ] if you came for me you don't know them whatever cool all right bet so I show her I'm like y bro you don't got to lie to me it's cool like I get it like we like this is the first time I seen her like in the year I said you don't gota even lie to me [ __ ] I even show I show her on my phone I said bro look right here she got another excuse she said oh nah so was a video of her naked in my pool bent over by the the deck and then one of my [ __ ] got his dick out like pause I'm sorry I'm got to give you all the details but I keep telling you somebody can't ever put dirt on my name without me telling the truth so I said bro like look at this right here she was like uh uh like she was like uh uh yeah he might took his dick out like I think he rub his dick on my [ __ ] but I never I'm like y bro you really lying to me right now makeup [ __ ] makeup [ __ ] makeup [ __ ] so um and and and this is probably first and foremost when I say slow ones in the back you know this this for Meek okay me I I I know I know you've been in the back of the class but bring your ass up here to the front today bring your ass up to the front today okay we're going we're going to bring you up to speed we're gonna bring you up to speed and we're gonna bring you up to speed with a few things okay you said I what what is this a hoax gotta be nah okay now by the way it is a h actually maybe not that stupid but um this clip is going viral okay by the way if everybody know I clearly said yesterday I've been wearing the same shirt for three days the keep it the bean shirt I've been wearing it for three days this was last night I come back from my studio so so look man so look this the thing right we gonna keep it a be man so we just got some uh footage that just came in man shout out to R sh T you know what I'm saying U we just got some more footage that just came man we going to keep it a be let's play this footage apparently this is allegely theight [Music] now I'mma keep it a buck with y'all right I ain't had sex with some females that's live screaming and [ __ ] but them screams sound weird that [ __ ] sound weird as hell what the [ __ ] was that man y'all get in the comments and let me know what y'all think man this [ __ ] getting ugly this is academic's house you going to see academics walk in this room now if this the same situation I don't know it's a ledge but this what they got out right now saying it is the same situation like I I get it she taking a big one or whatever right but bro I heard something bro I don't know exactly what I heard but it sounded very weird bro [Music] oh damn I just heard that though it said You [ __ ] me let me play that [Music] back [Music] y'all heard that right you [ __ ] me damn how the [ __ ] do did somebody get this footage though and he said that he was drunk and he was sleep what the [ __ ] [Music] so in the comments they saying this was a different night I'm going respect that and say maybe this was a different night but even then what the [ __ ] type of [ __ ] [ __ ] y'all got going on there over there bro like on some real [ __ ] bro like what type of [ __ ] y'all got going on over there G because the headlines read that you like Diddy or some [ __ ] like what the [ __ ] do y'all got going on over there man come on bro that [ __ ] sound weird I'mma keep it a buck what the [ __ ] was that man listen anything for some content yeah that was beyond content [ __ ] I didn't want that content to show up in my lap what the [ __ ] I would have never played it for you if it didn't show up in my lap you got to make it make sense my boy that's weird right there gang let's get to it though let's get to academic these text messages so look academics he about to respond to it on this live you feel me so we already gave what we thought about it let's see what academics got to say about it let me play that for y'all man we got it man we got it we got it back even the bright ones and also the chat [ __ ] uh I'm GNA just give you the fact because people are gonna make up [ __ ] make up [ __ ] make up [ __ ] so um and and and this is probably first and foremost when I say slow ones in the back you know this this for Meek Mill okay Meek Mill I know I know you've been in the back of the class but bring your ass up here to the front today bring your ass up to front today okay we're g we're gonna bring you up to speed we're gonna bring you up to speed and we're gonna bring you up to speed with a few things okay you said I what what is this a hoax gotta be nah okay now by the way it is a hoax actually maybe you're not that stupid but um this clip is going viral okay by the way if everybody know I I I clearly said yesterday I've been wearing the same shirt for three days to keep it a bean shirt I've been wearing it for three days this was last night I come back from my studio I done told my story I come back from my studio to my house there's cameras ripped out of my outside the inside of my house there's mad monitors broken there's M [ __ ] broken um I'm even talking to this individual like yo damn why do all this [ __ ] she gets her phone and she sees the blogs already started posting it and they're posting the clip where it says act girlfriend um stole 500k from him so you know she's not a public figure so she's like oh my God you ruined my whole like like I'm done now like nobody will ever that's all people are gonna know from me so she's she's drunk by the way this is a drunk woman she's screaming oh my God all that type of [ __ ] you know what I mean by the way at that time somebody hits me and say yo your stream accidentally started like it just started because the internet was out before I come down I cut the stream off that's it like there's random bums on here talking about I call my girlfriend smashing my uh my friend hold the [ __ ] up so he saying basically this [ __ ] came from he started his stream and then somebody was down there getting [ __ ] that wild and [ __ ] he's a wild boy man yo academics man you a wild boy my boy like this [ __ ] is getting Walky you feel me it's definitely getting Walky man y'all get in the comments and let me know bro this [ __ ] is getting Walky bro he said that he started his stream the internet was like going in and out so then it just H started then we heard that so they got this off of your live bro wow they've been sparing you apparently CU that mean that this [ __ ] must be a attack I don't know who you got beef with but this is definitely a attack because if this came out on your live and they spared you and they had this footage this whole time think about it academics is in my house you could probably even hear her hear her like what word she [Music] say okay all what drug do like allegedly what drugs do you give them bro huh yo academics what drugs do you give them bro like that to make a woman say that type of [ __ ] and go crazy like that sound like some schizophrenic [ __ ] I hope I said it right y'all I apologize you feel me but that's what it sound like to me that's what exactly what it sound like some some [ __ ] bro so is she diagnosed with that because I know if that was my girl and she doing [ __ ] like that I go and I got money at that I'm going send ass to the doctor she need to go get checked out that's a fact bro she need to go get checked out because something this is unusual behavior bro real talk you can't really explain this unless it comes with a diagnosis just keep it above okay okay so that came from that um again somebody who's drunk don't know what's going on or actually she do know what's going on but for her her her opinion on this whole thing is yeah this man just said somebody that's drunk that don't know what's going on bro you can't make this [ __ ] up okay okay so that came from that um again somebody who's drunk don't know what's going on or actually she do know what's going on but for her her her opinion on this whole thing is yeah I sent a picture of you to to a [ __ ] but I didn't post it on on on some public [ __ ] why did you have to go on your Twitch and talk about everything with me to the world like I look crazy now you feel me so whatever so that's that um I also really want to get to you I mean I'm not gonna because this not gonna really be no back and forth between me and nobody type [ __ ] you feel me it's definely back I also oh no I call Cap I call Cap gang I call Cap I call Cap it's definitely going to be a back and forth It's GNA be a back and forth [ __ ] this [ __ ] going into 2024 this is gonna be you you gonna have to live with this [ __ ] academics gonna have to live with this [ __ ] gang [ __ ] is crazy me and who's gonna understand what the [ __ ] I've been saying and realize I'm not coming on here like [ __ ] I would have never said none of that [ __ ] if I came on here to lie uh what I'll say is oh oh oh I wasn't even G I wasn't even gon to post these type of joints I wasn't even GNA post these type of joints but I see shorty who clearly was involved in that situation by the way short I didn't bring this up to make you look no way this was a this was a dealing between me and my girl or me and my ex-girl she just kept using that incident so I just cleared I just spoke on it and clear I didn't mean to make you look no type of way I haven't spoken on you you're right I just said what happened I ain't even say who you were you the one who just jumped out the Woodworks I never said who you were shorty okay and I'm not even y'all just said it bro y'all just said it in the comments like what happened he ain't said [ __ ] about sex about why shorty screaming in the background like that that's a fact bro like what's to it I get it it's a different situation that's cool bro we can say that this is a different situation let's be clear we can say that this is a different situation that's cool bro 100% that's cool why the [ __ ] is shorty saying what she saying like and screaming like that then allegedly I could have swar I heard her say you [ __ ] me what like who like for one who is this for two why is this happening under your watch for three why you walk in that room and act like it's nothing what the [ __ ] was that that's the first thing I'mma think in real time camera's on you g you gonna see my facial expression like what the [ __ ] hey yo what y'all got going on down there hey yo what's the word what the [ __ ] for real real maybe y'all see it differently I don't know man it is what it is but I for sure would have been like what the [ __ ] is this go play because he made a video not even gonna play the video you made but what I do want to show number one first and foremost if everything or anything you're saying is true a [ __ ] would have been charged nothing happened you feel me no case no nothing also I will say this these are things that the police and everybody else looked at their damn self you know unlike the that incident I will say this one was something that the police handled not social media it's crazy now that the police handled it nothing happened they said oh okay this wasn't [ __ ] now shorty is trying to and again I don't know how she just jumped into the mix but I'm gonna show you exactly and by the way I can't show certain [ __ ] like for example I sent her a video of of her at my pools side with two [ __ ] I said I was sleeping I can't show you that explicit photo I still got the image of that feel me I can't post it on here clearly but the police seen all this [ __ ] like these are they seen everything okay so these these are the messages we're going to go off like I'm not even going to play what shorty said because I'm not going to do this back and forth I'm going to show you text messages what the police said and you you're going to read these messages and remember what I said you're gonna read these messages and says and just say to yourself man this this sound like a was capping or man this sound like act did some [ __ ] oh this whatever you want to take from that you take from I was never gonna even post these [ __ ] you got these people like Sean Cloud Chase doing too much my [ __ ] okay this is the meage the cloud chasing bro is just a weird ass story my boy it's a weird ass story you feel me you got the facts you should put them out if you got the facts you should put them out I'm G tell you I can't post so on that day so the first me remember she got in the car she's leaving she got in the car she's leaving I'm ubering her back she says can you talk she calls my phone she calls my phone and she says yo hey um like I can't really believe that this happened blah blah she was like yo are you sure like yo what happened then so I'm like bro like I a going to lie you hav like I hate to say this cuz like I know she going to feel away but I'm only speaking facts I'm only speaking facts because because that's just is what it is I'm not trying to make her look no type of way bro I said there's a I said bro you were having sex with both of them at once I sent a screenshot a picture of her with the two dudes to her right this is what she said by way I can't post a picture of her and the two dudes clearly right like duh so I cropped it from there and I cropped her name out this is the messages that proceeded right after that by the way she's in a uber going home back from my crib remember like I started acting thisen to her after I confronted I'm like yo you [ __ ] two [ __ ] in my crib whatever whatever this is the messages now remember I don't know if y'all seen what video whatever she just put up does that video sounds like these messages like act you did something to me right I need remember in her video she says oh no she says an it wasn't just your friends it's you does these messages sound like academics did anything I'mma put it up on the screen this is the first message after I sent the picture this is her y'all know how text message work I'm sorry I'm terribly terribly sorry I said I don't know what you want me to say you w I suppose the reason why I said that is because when she was in my kitchen and I was telling her like yo I think you [ __ ] my [ __ ] she was like yo don't you like girls that be [ __ ] mad [ __ ] and I'm like bro you know like I looked at you and if she remembers this she know I'm not capping I said you know hell no she said don't you like girls to be [ __ ] mad [ __ ] that's what he saying she said allegedly I wonder where she got that from I know Selena pal at girls two different ways we have girls that we could possibly wife up they're good girls and horse like why y always think that a [ __ ] want a chick who [ __ ] everybody so that's why I was like yo I don't know what you want me to say LOL because I think she finally she when she says I'm sorry she's finally accepting it that she did have sex with the two dudes I said I don't know what you want me to say I said I guess you w I suppose whatever she said I never meant for all that to happen I listen does this sound like she saying acting nothing wrong I know you can never look at me the same this is what you're saying to me that's by the way this is not this is not cheyen this is not Cheyenne for every this is not cheyen this is some other [ __ ] she says look I know you can never you can't look at me the same he got a point though he got a point with them messages bro he got a point on that this dude sound like she ain't saying that AK did anything wrong okay she says I think I should talk to someone about this I say what you mean she says I feel really sad and I think I should talk to someone about it like a therapist or something okay let's see um let me see what's the next message give me a second a therapist or something hold on therapist something okay cool all right now this is another message okay here we go okay and then this is this is you know so I told I said yo you should get tested because we're talking into like in between All This and like on the phone and [ __ ] too I tell her yo you should go get tested like because like okay granted you didn't mean to whatever whatever but you had sex with two dudes unpr protected you should probably go get tested bro if I did some weird [ __ ] I'm not telling no girl to go get come on do like come on let's let's do the math all right anyway let me see damn so let me be clear bro me let me be clear from what I got on my screen right now and what I feel that I need to say right let's be clear gang so she say I know you can never look at me the same I think you should talk to someone about this he like who let me hold on let me remove myself he like what you mean brother right she said I really feel sad and I think you should talk to someone about it like a therapist or something now look man he he academics did admit that he's a [ __ ] simp he said that he was like like I get it see that's probably what's really [ __ ] her head up how not the fact that all this [ __ ] happened but it's the fact that he trying to act like he went into her like he saying he was into her I bet you that's where it stem from that's why she came out it ain't because of the factions on the table it's because academics is acting like oh yeah she just a th she just a thought whatever whatever whatever but even from this message the way she showing him this type of respect this is like he looked at her in a different light you feel me I definitely think that they trying to get academics to [ __ ] up out of here man 2024 they trying to get your ass my boy I don't know what you a did we ain't talked about the wrong [ __ ] one day huh [ __ ] um yeah let me download it again and then go like this and right here there we go okay so y read this message right okay then I then it happens and it says okay she says I'm hurt really bad it's unlike me to do this this is what she's saying it's unlike me to do this and I don't even know the other guy's name I was just laying there anyway like at this point I ain't gonna lie and this where I say I feel certain type of wrong for like because I'm mad at her I'm mad at her like yo you know me for like two years and big salute salute salute you Fu like I'm mad at her like I'm not really looking at it like oh maybe I'm thinking she's also playing games I'm like what you mean you don't remember doing it like nigg it's on camera what you mean you remember anyway so I say you call I guess she call she says I'm considering going in for a rap testing kit for us to figure this out because it's bits and pieces I remember and I'm still not okay right this what I say to her this what I literally say I said I'm done I'm done I ain't gonna lie to you family like I'm done I'm done right there with these messages right here if these messages are real ain't no [ __ ] r word victim gonna be seeing no [ __ ] like they saying in no messages man unless they confus it is a such thing you feel me mental health is is a reason a lot of our community is [ __ ] up you dig yo big n bro what's the word gang what the deal G what's going D what's up with it bro we live and Direct on YouTube bro like how you feel about this if y'all don't know big ant from Urban politicians and [ __ ] like how how you feel about this situation bro like from what you in gathered on looking around on the inter uh first thing is first man uh a man when he put himself in the in the situation it's his fault he put his self in this situation bro like when I say in this situation he put himself in there like bro why would you go to a female and tell a female two of my partners popped you wrong you need to get tested you so hurt and and and tender dick and out of pocket you basically telling her hey my two partners is dirty [ __ ] Ain't no other way around that bro so if you don't go to her you you really almost got these [ __ ] locked up his his lawyer pretty much told him that so it ain't even nothing else to really discuss whatever she saying whatever he's saying that would be settled with the police because from what he say they saw the camera so that'll be a police report like hey yeah [ __ ] they saw so ain't even really nothing to speculate she could come on internet and say whatever but guess what she's not on the internet if he don't go on YouTube and say that so [ __ ] need to know for everybody stop volunteering information stop volunteering unnecessary information because you mad or your feelings hurt ain't nothing good coming out of you volunteering information bro cuz this is all about his guy the girl he with he so discombobulated and don't know how to handle his business with females he came to the internet and told all type of stuff that we didn't need to know like let me try to jump out in front of it because he's still trying to play the game with his girl like oh you said you was going to expose me well I'll go to the Internet expose myself doing that tip fortat [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] and when you do that tip for Tat Dicky [ __ ] [ __ ] you never going to win any man [ __ ] talk to the young [ __ ] bro don't let no female have you in your B like that you got to be a man bro that [ __ ] is pathetic as a man and and [ __ ] take that [ __ ] how they want to take it bro only a real person a real man [ __ ] real [ __ ] real man gonna tell you you moving real weak if your partners don't tell you that you moving real weak them ain't your partners hey with regards to the point you made about these Partners bro am my understanding you correctly are you basically saying like act is in a way responsible for initiating that police report he's 100% uh responsible she don't go F the police report if he don't show her the video of them piping her down he shamed her she got a train ran on by his Partners voluntary train he got the video because he got cameras at his crib he asked her about it she lied he gets in his feelings and shows her the video well no look it's on camera whatever she then try to say well no I I didn't suck his dick oh okay I only sucked his dick and then oh he didn't put it in he just rubbed his dick on my [ __ ] so he wants her to tell him like oh they they [ __ ] me okay I ran the train and then what you can see she got the train ran on her what is there to talk to her that's crazy and like you said too him playing the game with the current girlfriend trying to let me beat you to a punch and in the process of that he probably defamed her put out some information that she didn't like like we would have never known about this girl and I don't know if you saw the last video she released saying like yo you lying you in fact you actually woke up on top of me so the fact that you weren't involved is actually cap and Chuck play that a little bit earlier but man this is this is this is nasty work friend I don't know girl like like I I don't want to say that he he did that to the girl CU she would have to prove no no she made that claim specifically in the latest video she put out yeah yeah I saw that and I'll be real with you she could be lying because you already lied about exactly she already lied about that try getting ran on her so I'm just like this right here you ain't trustworthy yourself you ain't credible but the police going to have it if it's that it ain't nothing to talk about like if if that the police got the video so if you on the video and them two [ __ ] running a train on you we don't need to hear no more that means them two [ __ ] is in the clear the only [ __ ] that could have did something to you hey hey big I I I want to ask you this question though and this this a good question you feel me like when it comes down to it so we seen what happened with the game he didn't get convicted on criminal charges that [ __ ] went away and then they came civil so like do you think that this woman has right to sue academics probably um get in his bag he been saying like he said his girl said he only had 400,000 he should have went with that he said no [ __ ] I got [ __ ] uh what he say trust bu stocks and buns and all this [ __ ] saying he got way more money you think they about to come out his money bro no do we know for certain that there was no um drugs involved that she might not have been drugged listen this is what it's no point in even asking that and this no disrespect homie but I'm just saying because there's a police report already academics say the police raided my house they even handcuffed that [ __ ] mama which is the [ __ ] that got bro the secondhand anger that I have to see any [ __ ] do that I don't give a [ __ ] who it is that [ __ ] makes me mad as a man that your mama is getting handcuffed because of a [ __ ] that [ __ ] disgusts me as a man bro I don't give a [ __ ] about the person I'm just saying as a man how mad I would be if the police put my mom in handcuffs by some [ __ ] with a raggedy [ __ ] that got a train ran on is it about the raggedy [ __ ] or is it about a [ __ ] being raggedy in his business though what you talking about academics the whole storyline I'm talking about the whole storyline the whole storyline at the end of the day the biggest thing is for me is that a [ __ ] M but but what I was getting at what you say uh uh CH no I was about to say like to like Rich what he was trying to I want you to CH in on that cuz I don't know if it went over your head for a second but like he saying like look we saying that's a ragly [ __ ] allegedly right she saying these type of things these acquis and [ __ ] it could be Money Motivated whatever the situation may be allegedly but we got to have accountability for academics he must be rly ass [ __ ] [ __ ] with a ragly ass [ __ ] right that's what I'm saying right there CH thank well no that that's that's the point that I'm making that my secondhand anger is for the M bro that's why I came I said earlier he brought this on himself it's all his fault that's what I started this off with I this is all his fault everything that's going on is his fault for sure I think you said that not only you Appo about the mother right the only reason the current girlfriend was able to find out about that and hold hold that over said she happened to be there when when he got raided right so to your point if he didn't put himself in that situation she would have never had this information can't blame anybody else but himself bro even if even if I got raided and we was at the crib if you want to go to the internet and tell them that tell them I don't give a [ __ ] we ain't do nothing to we clear we clear my [ __ ] he said the case got dropped I don't think he lying about the case getting dropped I think he telling the truth if that case was going on going y'all think we would have heard about that hey we should be able to find out about his business just like we find out about everybody El I've been telling y'all that the whole time bro no we have't one he put himself in there that girl gonna bring his ass all the way down everybody making a conclusion he better get rid of that goddamn girlfriend right I mean the fact that that girl disputes it now though it kind of forces him to Yo now you gotta produce the paperwork we got to see some sort of evidence and to answer we're gonna happen bro that video gonna come out watch listen if if the case got dropped to the laws we don't got to see [ __ ] no like I said like I said the whole time if it was really something that was really really on the wrong they white would have locked his ass up exactly they would got him right then bro not mind you we talking about over 15 months he the only [ __ ] with all this [ __ ] they got a video showing that Vindicated him so whatever it was that happened it might have been morally wrong or some [ __ ] like that but the police didn't say he did nothing wrong why didn't they feel the need to raid his house he already had an attorney this is confusing to me like no no no no no he got that t after they raided his Housey Tara I'm like you on a why are you raiding somebody unless there was an investigation of some criminality that was at this particular residence in the first place that's what a raid is about if it's Aug any type of intelligible evidence from when she filed her police report she said that he had a video that's why they rate to get the video they didn't have to rate it if he had an attorney he was he supposedly wasn't being charged so why not just ask him for this you know video like I don't understand what from what I heard I think that's how it played out he kind of um expanded on that he said once he got raid he got the attorney and they said yo this is what we want he was like yeah I decrypted it and gave him access to it understand he went and did the because she asked him do I need to go get he I'm just watching on TV she went and said they Tex him back and for she got the text message she was like and she confirmed that he was upstairs asleep on the text that he got the text message on the screen so you know they went through his phone if you ever go down the police department and [ __ ] bro they gonna go through every goddamn thing you got and she confirmed that he didn't know what was this that and third and he didn't know nothing about it she confirmed it the video confirmed it she asked him for the tape he told her but to be fair though we haven't seen that video and the latest video she just reled said that yo you actually woke up on top of it so this is why I'm saying it's going Force he say actually we got to see some proof no we don't you ain't gonna see nothing bro cause this is why the police department let his ass go and drop the case hey but we seen cases come back back [Music] too called a DA reject and then a DA will also repick up a case revisit a case as well so this case could possibly get Revisited This Ain't Gonna Do poss you say big bro people keep I don't know if people didn't listen to bro and see how she came he clearly said unless he is lying but I don't think he is he said they raided his house to get the video that makes sense she claims that I was raped in this house we doing an investigation du it's already been [ __ ] going down at this [ __ ] house I don't know if it was in that time frame of a bunch of [ __ ] whatever we running that [ __ ] house they kicked his doine kicked his doine handcuffed his mama that mean they came there for something we need your phone like homie on here just said we need phones and we need the camera surveillance footage he hands that over he said they went through everything they saw the video and they dropped the case because they saw it was consensual meaning you was engaging in this sexual act with these [ __ ] so them two [ __ ] is in the clear his two partners in the [ __ ] clear then him that knew what she said about him what went on with them two [ __ ] ain't got nothing to do with oh well you climbed on top of me D now who in the who got cleared because if they got if they didn't get cleared they would already be locked up and then she said she she got the stuff oh I got this I got that well why Them [ __ ] Ain't locked up then that's a fact why why they like if they on video raping you why they not lock but look though the thing years though this [ __ ] might play out civil you know what I'm saying through the Civil courts you feel me far suing academics he might be like bro he might be in a bad position then he was saying all this money he got and all that you feel me I get it but bro I'm telling you that was the wrong thing to do because we just the game I'mma tell you like this though I'mma tell you like this act them other [ __ ] they be losing them civil cases that's because they don't go to court he not settle he GNA pay his Lawry that bag which it it shouldn't go to civil court which he already got on retainer right bro [ __ ] don't be going listen bro then listen the thing with him is also he didn't say her name I don't think did he go on his live and say he never said her name never said her name that's a valid point we only know about mind you when he go to court you know the police is on his side cuz they already went through it come on see what I'm saying so you know what she didn't did basically she just got embarrassed and got caught up in what happened she embarrassed herself even more today you see what I'm saying that's more of what it is and that's why he kept asking her man and she kept denying the lie I didn't do nothing we had fun we kick it I didn't do nothing we fun we kick it now now you don't we don't even know if them tapes got full audio on them either she get G Gloria all r on the cas I a damn what i g say chitre hey huh hey ghost you trying to chime in on us yeah I just came back in what what what part y'all talking about now bro oh okay okay okay we'll get we'll get back to you in just a second bro cuz it's a whole lot Hey Hey Big Chuck yo salute y'all salute hey I just had a question did you see the text messages that um that that act showed a couple hours ago with her yeah we we just put that up on the screen that's what we was try okay okay for sure for sure okay we let let it play out you know what I'm saying we heard what was going on like the thing is though bro a lot of people in the comments they was like yo why he didn't admit that she was possibly having sex when she was screaming like that then it's some people like yo she was having a nervous breakdown allegedly allegedly right but the thing is bro them screams and I heard bro I played it back like four or five times he said you're [ __ ] me allegedly no he didn't say that this what happened what did he say he said hold on when he was filming last night she was at the house tearing his [ __ ] up he came home and caught her tearing his [ __ ] up so last night when he did the the confession thing in the studio he pulled up at the house she the one had tow his [ __ ] up when he got there that's what was going on he said that she hit the live and um she turned Hey Hey Hey Big C I'm glad you corrected me bro CA you know what I'm saying I like to be out there b yeah yeah so that was her [ __ ] his [ __ ] up that was her tearing his [ __ ] up in his house saidu and she went to jail her his his mama called the police that's what it was he walked in her his vandalizing his house oh but that kind more sense to the video to be honest like check this out bro y'all check this out go watch the video last night when he was in his Studio he said she probably in my house T my [ __ ] up right now actually made another video Big C clearing that up so that scream that we heard is a respon to her after you live and exposed her basically she saw you Ru my life and he never said her name so that just just to be clear that's the current girlfriend he's with that's that's in jail that's not the same girl right the accusation has to do with hey you know what's even crazi though hold on hold on you know what's even crazier like look put this together though right you know the person who posted that that whole situation that video and [ __ ] allegedly Meek Mills what came from Chu hold on Chu page bro hold on bro hold on yeah he he reposted it he reposted he Chu hold on Chu stop bro my partner Hood's on from Alabama that he the one that did it be reposted it yeah that's what we said that's what we said yeah that's what I look he still Meek Mill still posted it on his page we already know the situation when it comes to academics DJ academics and Meek Mills they've been having a back and forth for years you feel they supposed to be cool no hell no I never heard of that yes bro they look bro just because you squashing situation bro that don't mean that me and you cool bro this is why hold on been promoting a [ __ ] bro been promoting [ __ ] situations with a lot of [ __ ] that don't mean but you ain't promoting them hell but you're not going to promote the whole thing this the whole thing now Meek could have if if he posted that and he didn't if he came with that he might have said hey [ __ ] being cool with this [ __ ] now that could have been a thing or he could have said hey they trying to set him up I don't know what did he say in the cap so he said is he say much he said this RP or is this a skit question mark goel Meek Mill said Meek Mill reposted and he said this gotta be a hoax bro I know Meek in real life bro Meek trying to be funny bro like Chuck said bro just because they squash they beef don't mean they cool I really believe like academics and meek still both dislike each other but they just squashed whatever issues they hady exactly hold on hold on hold on hold on hold on now that this situation done came about Meek feel like this a chance for him to throw a slick shot and that's what he did and academics is responding academics is definitely about to go and Meek Mill about this [ __ ] Bro a is not liking this bro now hey hey to go back what y'all was talking about ear hold on hold on hold on big he just went at Metro booming we was talking about it hold on I'mma tell you something this how this go in this music game bro that [ __ ] got the biggest pull on marketing with them labor so and he I've heard from somebody in the couple of the building like he deliberately told F man I don't give a [ __ ] what y' I'm not [ __ ] with that [ __ ] and them [ __ ] know he got that juice cuz if he do it somebody else gonna post so hold hold on his version of getting his lick back because he a gonna be di the street so I'm GNA beat your ass on his market and [ __ ] I'm gonna make sure your [ __ ] crash that's his way of getting his Le back so y'all gonna fight in the street okay cool I'm get you on this [ __ ] computer and with that music [ __ ] up your money yeah but he he's losing his that [ __ ] that that [ __ ] that [ __ ] losing his momentum bro that [ __ ] is losing his momentum bro you see he that spoke about that on live last night no listen just last night he lost that Spotify deal because he couldn't produce as much content as they wanted for them to up his contract to renew his contract for another year bro and he hold on we talked about that earlier in this live bro me and Chuck spoke about this about a year ago when academic started feeling himself and started like dissing rappers as far as like feeling itself like speaking like I got more money than these rappers I don't like these rappers like he was really feeling himself but he not understanding bro your platform is built off of doing interviews with rappers bro [ __ ] want to see these interviews if rappers stop [ __ ] him today if all R hold on hold on see if rappers stopped [ __ ] with academics today and said none of us is going up there and doing interviews bro his [ __ ] will go all the way downhill bro that's wrong this is why he was already up there without interviews he was already up there without the interviews that's how without interviews bro he was not where he's at interviews bro he got him without the interviews matter fact intervie Che it out was nowhere near model this this is a model now in business where you g see how you know when the stock split it double down that [ __ ] going to double up watch just watch give him six months we got give him six months to see cuz he F to do when he started that Academy he F to had a he F to had a app his own it GNA be a whole Spotify his joint call The Academy he F to sign so many bloggers and [ __ ] to that [ __ ] bro he F to get so much ad money and [ __ ] the [ __ ] F to go crazy you know he sign Troy ass he believe he said he only putting up one million though I don't know you put hold on you put a million he got the infrastructure built out bro so he can sign 10 [ __ ] give him 100 Grand a piece up he sign [ __ ] for 50 what happen signing MAF H or something Troy have don't have a successful podcast yet bro don't but why hold on he's gonna turn them up because it gonna be more [ __ ] on his own guar see that's not guaranteed that's podcast not guaranteed to be successful on some real [ __ ] though bro like look look on some real [ __ ] tell people this all the time when it come to this right like when it come to this podcasting bro this [ __ ] is different I literally know like for example I'll give you the [ __ ] uh what's his name who was on academic show on um everyday struggle wayo feel me wayo he got some of the biggest guests on his podcast some of the dopest interviews bro you probably don't even know he even got a podcast after the everyday struggle let alone that his [ __ ] probably only hit 10,000 views this what I'm saying though it doesn't matter on the resources on okay I'm gon bring the biggest artist on my [ __ ] okay then what this [ __ ] got interviews with little Wayne all type of shito I know is different let me tell you something man listen one thing I know about you can see how his business model is from a business point that man did not turn that deal down unless he had a whole business seccession plan behind that for him to turn down whatever they gonna get for another year they like we G give a [ __ ] this give us something for him kind of weird though he had that whole thing with that Tana D no hold on hold on let me finish you m hold on one minute for him to turn that down say nope I'm not do this right here that man got a goddamn plan bro that's bulletproof they gonna make it jump up I'm telling you ain't no way hold on let's just like a woman if a woman leave a man she ain't gonna leave unless she got somewhere to go well let me let me let me break it down to y'all bro first off everybody can have their own opinion but the facts is bro academics didn't build his platform off of interviews thank you it is what it is you could talk about academics was in this game eight in 2013 hold on he was in this game for six years just started interacting with the rappers two years ago before the pandemic the only time he inter interacted with the rappers face to face really was on everyday struggle before that he wasn't interacting with no rappers he was keep it real though let's keep it real man when you start [ __ ] with them artist it gonna shoot you through the roof if you got I want I'm going through right now I see what's going on listen you ain't near in the same page zip code I'm not talking about will working with rappers shoot you through the roof of course it would but academic was already a top rap and hip hop media uh one of don't know talking about [ __ ] hey check this out correct me if I'm wrong this [ __ ] he gets probably five million a year from labels from promotion for sure from promoting this [ __ ] I don't know hold on listen listen listen I don't know a number and I don't I don't even care the number that's St money but these blog these labeles pay these [ __ ] thousands of dollars per post hell yeah what I'm saying I got like tons of anr and oscope I ain't even seen oscope rappers in I just so happened they a sign I don't know if that's because of me because they probably owe me some bread if that's the case right but um yeah bro like [ __ ] is watching what's going on in the culture like big and you definitely a part of the culture gang you know what I'm saying I'm just saying I'm just telling I'm just telling people what's real bro I'm in this [ __ ] I got phone calls I can make and I know what [ __ ] how this [ __ ] work these labels pay these [ __ ] directly thousands of dollars a post facts allegedly alleg all the blogs y'all see they get the big blogs that y'all follow they get paid thousands of dollars to post that artist and then the I seen the layout cuz I [ __ ] with the artist they send them [ __ ] spread I'm talking about a whole spreadsheet you get a spreadsheet on the feed so they might charge you 1,500 a post but they don't put your add on there they just put a hashtag and they say it's only gonna stay some of them be like oh it's only gonna stay up for a day but if you want to stay up permanent you got to pay 3500 or do you want to go to the story it's it's a thousand to go to the story type [ __ ] but the ra do shoot you through the roof though for sure so so I say that that that that's not that's not a what I'm just saying what academics was got popping off of hey wrong now mind you when before he started did the deal with Spotify and all that the man had over a million some followers already bro the man was already shooting through the Warr sh really blew him up the Warr sh I know that for sure 2014 but when you go and meet it with the artist you already got a fan base man you through the roof no that's that's not that's a fact of course but got have good music though you got me [ __ ] been saying my thing my thing is bro it's not even a debate his platform he was lit before he got to working with artist bro he just started doing the podcast like two years ago that's what all I said bro that's what I said hey ghost hey ghost didn't this podcast fail though bro it's it's it's supposed to now listen hereas like us up there bro like real talk like bro big ant bro he got it bro he got the whole sou bro and interviewed him listen but listen this is the thing I don't know about the whole s he got texes for sure but listen I don't got got the whole South G he got he got T so he a got the whole South [ __ ] let me tell you hold on let me tell you about no no no no no hold on hold on can't no [ __ ] tell me about me I don't got K let's go what I got is I got a following that [ __ ] with me from the whole country yes sir I'm not a I do I am a time because I'm from this ho when I open my mouth it's a time but my [ __ ] go outside of Texas [ __ ] in La [ __ ] with a [ __ ] [ __ ] Chicago Detroit New York all over this [ __ ] [ __ ] with me I because I don't just cover Texas [ __ ] exactly I've been traveling the whole [ __ ] country when when doing interviews was the thing I was in Detroit I was in Miami I was in Atlanta I was in LA three times a year I was doing this [ __ ] I was in Mobile Alabama I was in New Orleans so [ __ ] ain't just Texas I don't got Texas I never had Texas just Texas my [ __ ] scared L I'm from Memphis I got Memphis and I got the so so I say that to say this that the thing with academics podcast is he said himself he couldn't he couldn't keep the quality content going so he didn't want to put anything out he didn't want to just do anything he wanted the content to be quality that's why the deal didn't work out but let's be for real a lot of the artists not even doing interviews no more a lot of them they don't want to sit down and talk to nobody and I don't blame them it's all clickbait it's like [ __ ] I can control my own narrative while I go sit down with these [ __ ] and do interviews they want to clickbait my [ __ ] they want to ask me crazy questions and it's gonna get spun or however they want to spin it hey a let me you big one thing as long as as long as don't have to it is what it is as long as not at the level that they were dog I've been doing this [ __ ] Five Years [ __ ] I know the difference I've been outside when the artist was doing the interviews they don't do them like they used to bro you seeing more just regular random [ __ ] who don't rap doing interviews then you actually see rappers [ __ ] don't even be listening to the music no more like they used to hey now that part that part is true that part is true it's more like now this is what personalities and stuff that's what's gonna supplement that money from doing a deal with Spotify and stuff this man even have Pepsi commercial coke commercial but listen bro let's keep it bro see people keep talking about money that [ __ ] got money he don't need money to get his [ __ ] rolling he already got his own money he don't need to get no sponsors from nobody to get it rolling he got his own Studio he got his own paper he can afford to pay these [ __ ] out of pocket right now see people talking about oh this and this and that bro he can you have to take a risk every podcast is not guaranteed even if I get a deal and somebody give me some money to pay [ __ ] they still don't guarantee it it's a process so you you taking a risk regardless he can afford to take the risk he got the Brin and you know why he investing that money bro guess what the thing that he's really that he's getting that that what people want right now let me ask you this though he's hold on hold on he's getting the data because he know how many people that's watching male female that's what people are selling now people don't even know it data is the key if you got a 100,000 men the age 18 to 35 you sell that [ __ ] to companies so they can advertise that too that's what he's getting that's why he's signing people bro because there gonna be more people coming on you gonna have more and more and more data no no no got data data or not bro that's the wave right now exactly that's what it ain't about the data though with the it is about the data of course that's that's a giv bro they give you your data when you start your YouTube channel that's nothing new the wave right now is to have a bunch of podcast if you can that's the next level for him that's the next you got your podcast and have podcast under yours that's the he just trying to go to the next level it ain't that deep he trying to go to the next level hey what he said he said it on he said it on the live he said he trying to go to do the things like no jumper doing bro he said that bro like he definitely I didn't even see it but he he definitely trying to go to the next level but the thing about that bro just because you a good Entertainer a good podcaster don't mean you a good businessman like a [ __ ] got to make the right invest me personally I don't feel like like the Troy show should have been something he signed he should have signed something a better show than that for his first s bro that's how I feel he hey what's y'all thoughts on Rumble though I mean I would have thought if you giving them Spotify a logical jum beat you see [ __ ] like Aiden Ross and these other streamers and he's over there already on Rumble right they giv got a deal with Rumble bro man Rumble really is going to be the next version Empire wild yeah I can see that too I mean so more on that instead of no because Rumble don't have a algorithm they paying [ __ ] who got followings to try to get people over there to that platform and knowing academics as smart as he I think I the [ __ ] got a a damn Bachelor somewhat in mathematical science or some [ __ ] so he far from a damn dummy don't think that boy ain't got Parts in that [ __ ] but no listen bro the thing is with [ __ ] like Rumble them is startup like platforms that's why they don't have no Co for meaning he's not signed to rumble exclusively he just have to give them so much time I don't know if it's a week that's his business you know what I'm saying but he got a check from them already he streams he gonna go over there probably every once in a while stream strictly over there but then he gonna stream on YouTube because he know that's where the audience is at but I'mma go get Rumble what they want too and I'm trying to convince some of my platform to hey go [ __ ] with me on R so what r that's a startup platform they try to pay [ __ ] who got a following so they can get the audience over there nobody going and you know you getting some ownership if you smart bit man you ask for to stop because you know what it gonna do because you have bilding the actual building I can't call I can't call the future Rumble but with the other [ __ ] already in place twitch kick YouTube you know it gonna say bro come on you got to know it going to sell and you go over there and you got that much juice like act going over there with bro you go ask for some stock option I'm talking about him bro I'm talking about the [ __ ] platform bro like about the platform for him to go over there I'm just saying like hard of the deal bro he we he got a bag to go over there he made so it was good we know that so it ain't even nothing to discuss bro he over there he got a check over there and and and listen any podcast you start bro you taking a risk anybody have an opinion about any podcast academics G [ __ ] that he see already active on YouTube that's just what it is he he not g to come just sign the [ __ ] and then every [ __ ] that's active on YouTube Ain't G to sign so when he sign the [ __ ] he gonna sign the [ __ ] that he see been working consistently on their own whether we like the [ __ ] or not oh you already doing numbers you already got a follow his business model man we don't know how his man think he might want to start [ __ ] from the bottom up you never know how that man really think bro he just signed a [ __ ] I'm talk because [ __ ] question why he signed Troy Al Troy he said it out of his own mouth which I didn't even need him to say it I know why because Troy already been podcasting bro HEC he want somebody that that own their own stuff he just basically it's just a distribution exactly I put it on my channel tro was a rapper he just like he had plugs that's how look that ain't true bro he a he a bring him over there because he's a rapper he brought him over there he he brought them over there like a lot controversy tied to the niggaas so therefore whatever anything he said you still have people who have like a bias behind a lot of the [ __ ] that he done and all of that [ __ ] so his name been clickbait like I mean not just as a rapper but especially ever since that Irving Plaza [ __ ] like that nigga's name been click for the last seven years so once the nigg start like doing podcast and all that [ __ ] it makes sense for a [ __ ] like act to kind of like slide him in that you know I'm saying like just slide him in his don't bro don't he's always self marketing he been putting up his own money he got money he just said he gave him six figures too yeah but he ain't looking for a bag though CU clickbait don't mean you a good podcast either though I didn't say that I'm nobody nobody's tuning in nobody's tuning in to the facto show bro nobody was tuning in before he was with act bro and they still ain't tuning in now [ __ ] see this the thing if he would have did this with Troy Al before Troy Al took that stand maybe it would have been a good idea but now it was not a good idea bro that that that wasn't a good that wasn't a good deal on on at part that was a good deal on Troy part but stands reason to do nothing like no I can't say that they and Troy got the potential not not not for a podcast bro not for a podcast we G hold on this how we'll find out we gotta give some mon you gotta put some time on that [ __ ] is too much of a rapper he too hard to to even play in certain field I ain't GNA count I ain't count no [ __ ] out I ain't count no [ __ ] out and this sh who been consistent whether [ __ ] been consistent hold on hold on listen listen listen I'm not count nobody out who is consistent and got a something somebody who gonna help him push his [ __ ] in the game because that's what it takes in this game consistency dedication and then a [ __ ] who got the tools and the resources who gonna help you push your [ __ ] and you marketable yeah whether you marketable or not if you a [ __ ] that's going to get up and go get it and show up for work no matter how a [ __ ] opinion about you no matter whatever it is in the world real [ __ ] if you get up and you coming to work which he was already doing and then hey I'mma give you a distribution deal and I want my [ __ ] to win because you want my [ __ ] so I'm GNA do what I got to do to make so [ __ ] know where you at and make sure hey [ __ ] we we doing the risk we going for what the game is about so you can't count the [ __ ] out at all you can't count nothing out because anything is possible what I'm saying with academics making having his first signing and we know where he trying to go like kind of like the no jumper type of um model or whatever because he got the other the other podcast too the chat [ __ ] podcast them is homeboys from the chat and [ __ ] like shout out IR am facts facts part of that podcast but um I I just I just feel like he could have made a better better a more sound decision on who he signed as his first podcasters bro that's what I'm saying person that comes to mind G yeah long as he balanced it out I think it'll be a good thing if he if he get if he got like like Gil and wallow they balance each other out if he get somebody else balance out bro over there like this [ __ ] gonna work I'm tell somebody else he just sign who was a good signing for him a Gizzy a Gizzy go good with academics bro yeah good a good real good investment that was a great investment bro yeah and Gizzy G see they gonna help each other bro you know what I'm saying like together yeah good though andzy real animated and uh and he built something pretty cool at that kitchen table hey [ __ ] see you know what going on that mean that mean you tapped in long as I been tapped in he made something from that goam goam Pepsi with that goddamn Pepsi and Miss barber in the background come on bro that's how he gonna go get that corporate money he gonna have seven different eight different avenues that he got I got all these shows signed to me it makes sense for online gambling watch the first sponsor he gonna be a gambling company this the thing though see the Pepsis and PR Sprites and the coks and things like that and the bigger corporations and stuff like that with these type of allegations coming out this can this can this can ruin him for getting them type of sponsorships bro it can bro it just depends on how far this goes bro how far these allegations go I heard correct I heard some I heard somebody mention that the lady the Gloria lady the lawyer lady to be getting all them sexual assault cases she involved in this now Noah no you can't say not yet they ain't say nothing about it but get involved get involved he got a problem because she a dog bro but but this the the the the the big thing that like I say the fork in the road with that is just steal that tape and the police said it was n that happened that's the big thing that's messing that up so if that wouldn't happen it looking favorable but like if I'm this what he have to do to really clear clear if he say I'm gonna put a TI against you he take her ass to court he got my money he got my money to fight in court with that's see that you got to have money go to war and she going to go to war with it they got he got a check man so that'll make if he go see if he do that he' be the first person that really went you know what we gonna fight this [ __ ] out I'm gonna run your ass out the courtroom at that point then you know say he because everybody else settle everybody get [ __ ] it I want to do a cut a che hey I'mma be real with y'all I really feel like this this whole situation is bigger than what meets I like this is kind of like a diddy situation I like behind the scenes has made people mad bro just like Diddy did with the um with the with the with the um with the delion [ __ ] bro that's why all this coming out from Diddy because of the problems he was having with the deli man he got mad F that he he calling folk pre and [ __ ] know what the [ __ ] who they pul a switch on him but they came out that's what's going on with academics right now bro this a calculated bro this is not something that just popped up bro this a culated made it come back around on hold it yo but this is self-inflicted though buto the [ __ ] went live trying to play chest with his current girlfriend and he should have got rid of that girl when she start all that drinking and all exactly he should have got rid of that [ __ ] from the gate got of her bro she is gonna be the downfall of that [ __ ] bro one everything up for you bro go ask Adam see I don't think it's outside forces bro I think it's just him making goofy mistakes bro I'mma tell you something now one thing he did do that's coming back and B he got two PR start this is the I feel like this is the classic case or whatever when a nerd s or whatever like in the hot seat to be like that [ __ ] for once and you just start diving into all this [ __ ] you start punching above your weight when it come to dealing with other [ __ ] to dealing with [ __ ] and the way you moving you not even accustom to moving like that you understand because it's a lot of [ __ ] that was like wrong with the whole situation right he drunk he Technic to Uber to the crib she get there he passed out so that mean that the [ __ ] just let her put himself in that situation though bro but this is what I'm saying I'm not disputing that this is what I'm saying like the whole lineup is just crazy like everybody involved is like moving goofy as hell and now you got a bunch of people like what it sounds like is you got a bunch of people who did some [ __ ] and then now they embarrassed and so everybody trying to spin a narrative or whatever to make themselves look clean you understand what I'm saying like this some recent [ __ ] that happened within a year too bro this ain't no [ __ ] that happened in the 90s or the 80s bro right that's exactly what they trying to do that's why academics even came forward with the [ __ ] he the one put it out there everybody he put and then it's like this though when you have the type of receip because I ain't gonna lie like I went through a range of of different feelings and all kind of [ __ ] or whatever as I'm listening to the story and [ __ ] especially like before Big C cleared up that whole thing with the screaming in the background cuz I'm listening to that [ __ ] like [ __ ] that's crazy like you know I mean I done been in some wild so this [ __ ] get a train r on her and cry victim like come on man I'm from Memphis and this [ __ ] on the stage that from m n been [ __ ] know what time it is bro that ain't no [ __ ] victim Bro [ __ ] you mean p on no ho man but but so so look my point is like this she came there right he's passed out willingly willingly willingly bro yeah listen but list [ __ ] comeing to my house 3 4 in the morning man what the [ __ ] let me drive it home let me drive home like I got got there right the [ __ ] is passed out that means that one of his [ __ ] let her in now as a female my [ __ ] if the [ __ ] if you get there and you like yo where suck to sh the [ __ ] who invited you or if you know that you doing a link at that time in the morning 4 in the morning or some [ __ ] and you show up and it's a bunch of other [ __ ] there as a female I'mma think that you gonna be a little you know like your spider sens is gonna start tingling you understand what I'm saying like now once the [ __ ] not there and then all of that [ __ ] happened right she didn't like popped off with the homies and all of this other [ __ ] or whatever now she leaving the whole Tech now once you put the text message up that [ __ ] just put a whole another spin on [ __ ] like shorty did some [ __ ] she was embarrassed ran thech especi she realiz it was receip you know what's up bro you know what's up bro they ran she feel B about it she get not the deal you heard like when I when I used to be on the road with my artist I to tell them nigas straight up this how this [ __ ] going ain't nobody [ __ ] on the road bro we a that's sound like a skinny pimp lady be story you heard back on Hollywood back in the day my [ __ ] like come on man what about Lady B bro you [ __ ] I know what I'm talking about you heard that's like a skinny pimp Lady B [ __ ] yeah bro I tell [ __ ] bro stood I said bro ain't no [ __ ] on the road this is why bro man don't bring nobody to your room ain't know none of that c these [ __ ] will line your ass up see [ __ ] don't even know when you if you on like a seven City tour right and you stand on the road bro you can't leave the money who where you where you GNA leave your money I'm leave my money in the hotel room they come right in the hotel rooms bro them people downstairs letting them in all kind of [ __ ] cuz bro you cannot have no mother I want two rooms I always give me another room at a hotel cu the one you book for me I ain't going in that one I'm gonna be in a whole another room and see it's it's the same thing like you gotta look at Academia as the talent he is the talent most girls be like I can't get the talent I'm get the next thing to him cuz they trying to get in man you can't take this [ __ ] for granted why [ __ ] be wondering how the Go Pro when they go bro bro you ain't got no discipline if you ain't got no discipline as a man bro you gonna fall for [ __ ] see everybody want to be real [ __ ] instead of real they too eager man for the no more man pushing 100,000 man you the mother G get you g get bamed up with these folk bro you can't play the game like that no more and [ __ ] ain't taking the responsibility so now women seeing that man that b got she got a me she got she got what think they they thinking about it but Big C they know who to do it to though Square gonna fall for a real [ __ ] ain't gonna fall for no dumb [ __ ] like that bro I know you ain't I know I'm not and they cut from the car we cut from ain't going for that [ __ ] [ __ ] you got a train man on you and you went home broke this happened to me last year year for L all of a sudden just and I knew it was the devil bro all of a sudden man it's just women just come out the [ __ ] Woodwork and I'm lowkey just women everywhere you go a woman oh you look to oh this that bro you you gotta look at the writing on the wall like bro something ain't right about this you got to feel that room out you gotta feel if a person show you something bro you better believe they more of what they going be in what you see Yo Big C what they say heard back in the day TR uh we ran train on that [ __ ] to we ran a train on that [ __ ] come on I'm a Memphis [ __ ] bro man [ __ ] been running trains on the ho from E they had a whole big pun them [ __ ] had that whole TR [ __ ] the problem though list that [ __ ] came from Memphis bro it call running a train bro a no problem you feel me like it's not about if who ran a train on who or whatever the case may be that's not not the the situation situation is was it consent you feel me so you know I know certain things is trigger words that's why I say the r word you know what I'm saying salute to everybody that's um chiming in giving us their thoughts rather you in the comments or you actually on the panel man salute get this out to everybody on social media platforms X formally known as Twitter uh Instagram send it to your friends Facebook man share that [ __ ] man with a hashtag share everything with a hashtag they get it they want they want that F man and see the ex girl the girlfriend she just got mad for the fact that she like don't nobody know who I am he just won't show her off you know what I'm saying that's that see man that jocking for position [ __ ] bro that that divide and conquer [ __ ] bro that [ __ ] is that [ __ ] so deep that to get want to go looking for that 15 seconds of Fame they get it from their mama you heard they G get it even in the worst way though they gonna get it man for real they gota watch out for all that and then like and not to bring race in but you got to put race in it bro Ain't No Way in the world you gonna go he in a a predominantly white area in New Jersey and a woman coming and say that you raped they they raped her name they trying to lock a [ __ ] up on God that's my that's my thing right that's what happen when you [ __ ] the liberal states bro you can't do that [ __ ] down south or somewhere else on that type of time bro these get hold a leeway bro you got I tell the Poli right now man you was at my house bro and that man stole my chain and stole $1,000 off my drug they gonna lock your ass up before they find out what happened they going to bring you for no question they going lock your ass up for theft immediately then we going to find out what happened that's just how Memphis play they going to do that bro so if you got that much Fame and that much notarizing that kind of money yeah they immedately gonna lock you up but I think I think academics got his karma from exploiting them babies in sh when they was getting killed all them years ago bro that that's how that's my opinion you know what I'm saying it could be that I don't feel sorry for that dude he not he not cut from our C off from our culture bro he not you got know how to deal you got to know how to deal with women level you go to it's a different level of woman it's a different level of woman every level you got to act like I was always told man act like You' been there before act like You' been there man act like act you gotta act like you used to them bad bro treat them just like the ones you treat you know what I'm saying for a two for 20 at alab treat the same somewh you know I mean that was the thing I was saying before like the [ __ ] how much [ __ ] you think how many [ __ ] how many [ __ ] you think academic was getting before he was academic thank you thank youti the [ __ ] ain't got enough practice in the field to even be moving like you understand what I'm saying like first of all you gotta be pulling up to your house bro I don't know how everybody else move but the hotels is for the hoes man like you understand what I'm saying like that [ __ ] that [ __ ] in Lamar by them hotels and all that [ __ ] man man like if you got any s you got some money you supposed to have another spot bro any [ __ ] know this where you lay your head at I don't know ifas [ __ ] was in there kind of crazy because he ain't even and then it's like this though the type of [ __ ] academic is like he's scary bro so for them [ __ ] to be in his house like that like when he fall asleep it's like them [ __ ] F I don't even see no you know I'm saying like [ __ ] proba some corny [ __ ] too for nigg the Train on ho man come on man s man man n to 2K to the hoes man you know what I'm saying the price of went down to $40 my [ __ ] nigg they play enough they was play enough they brought their own [ __ ] to the house turn that [ __ ] out man been a free fest in that [ __ ] you heard N Them [ __ ] should have brought their own bro he was touching the he felt he felt a CT type of way quing theoz he used to no [ __ ] he used to no [ __ ] like that bro he a built for that that's what I'm saying for he thought he had so much juice that the [ __ ] came for them they I [ __ ] anybody appla that [ __ ] you can't knock the hustle but he a goofy for that he a come for my culture bro I for that [ __ ] bro just like I said he thought that was his bro they W your bro your turn Let It Go dog that ain't your ho dog let me get broke off and then jump off you heard what the [ __ ] say that my ho that's your ho too that my ho that's our [ __ ] old 0 [ __ ] get put on game I bet he thought [ __ ] like my L manig around me they can't [ __ ] over there [ __ ] the why he sleep got the whole bit over on the pool dickin good he got mad he say how he how they were doging the B [ __ ] hold this how he really got mad the [ __ ] he K can't come to the house no man heit on yo this [ __ ] crazy but um we about to get up off here man salute appreciate everybody that came through man salute man this [ __ ] is crazy from all of it man tte naughty academics his girlfriend friend his girlfriend man the list goes on man let's get to it man Terence ganger Williams come on man salute though appreciate y'all coming through man Steph for the Cloudchaser TV it's du for the Cloudchaser TV Jank | DEATH OF THE CLOUT CHASER | UC3e8QmerD0ZnLyyTpBXtr7Q | 2023-12-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 28,561 | 146,806 |
ADUfP8uOlyo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADUfP8uOlyo | splits flips loops #smart35 freestyle flight training #fpv #fpvfreestyle #fpvdrone | [Applause] I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when the lights shine I'll be there when the S I'll be make you s I'll be there I'll be [Music] there [Music] over there looking at me like scar baby come on over here I won't now you've got all that mystery locked inside you got see do you want to stay on the I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleep night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when the lights go shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be there make you [Music] feel [Music] I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when lights so shine I'll be there in the S I'll be there make you [Music] feel [Music] you over there looking at me like a scar baby come on over here I won't bu it youve got all that mystery locked inside you g SE do you want to stay on my I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleepless night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be back I'll be back I'll be there when the lights go shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be there I'll be I'll [Music] be I'll be there I'll be [Music] there I'll be I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when the lights shine I'll be there when the S I'll be there make you feel I'll be there I'll be there [Music] I over there looking at me like a scar baby come on over here I won't bu you got all that mystery locked inside you got see do you want to stay on my I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleepless night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when the lights go shine I'll be there in the sleep night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll [Music] be I'll be there when the sh I'll be there see I'll [Music] be I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when the lights are shine I'll be there when the S I'll be there make you s I'll be there I'll be [Music] there [Music] over there look at every like scar baby come on over by now you got all that mystery locked inside you g SE do you want to stay on my side I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleep night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when the lights go shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be make you feel I'll be I'll [Music] I'll be see I'll [Music] be over there looking at me like scared baby come on over here I by now You' got all that mystery locked inside you g SE do you want to stay on my I'll be there when the lights don't shine I'll be there in the sleepless night I'll be there make you feel all right I'll be there I'll be there I'll be there when the lights go shine I'll be there in the sleepest night I'll be make you feel I'll be I'll [Applause] [Music] oh | tgi360fpv | UCvnrMFE3mqUtnTr2rY15WBA | 2024-04-07 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 680 | 3,278 |
ZBRX5EpNfbc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBRX5EpNfbc | Halfpenny Bridge, Newtown, Powys | this is the hay nybridge the latest of succession of foot bridges that have crossed the seven at this point linking the town center over there with what still known as the canal area over here canal is long gone of course but at one time it was a very busy area the canal arrived in Newtown in 1819 and linked the town with a national canal network and then about 40 years later by the canal to large steam woollen mills were built the commercial mills and the Cambrian mills and they were very successful and they were successful because of the ideas of one man whose name is still recorded on the building over there pryce-jones Christ Jones started out as a Draper's assistant in Newtown and then got his own business which was very successful and then with the opening of the railway in 1861 he spotted an opportunity to grow his business even bigger why not sell stuff by mail send it on the railway parcels on the railway and he claimed to have invented the mail order business the Sears Roebuck in America have got different ideas about that nevertheless price Jones's mail order was very successful so successful in fact that he moved his business from the town center into those large buildings over there the Royal Welsh where happen for a while is very successful but in the end other businesses caught on and undercut pryce-jones and it declined but the very last vestige of mail order in Utah was with the closure of shop direct in 2011 | Global-Rural Project | UCyjZAvA9CSwBdnjfqPOSnVQ | 2015-06-22 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 265 | 1,449 |
19C7ex_VtBc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19C7ex_VtBc | Joy Coghill on Vancouver during WWII and Alan Barlow (Part 7 of 9) | I want to go right back I want to talk about early Vancouver yes I want to talk about your very beginning I'm interested because you were a teenager here in Vancouver during the second World War I was in vacui from from Glasgow from Scotland so you spent the War years here in Vancouver uh yes we came in the second year of the war my mother and I what was Vancouver like in 1942 43 44 45 when you said that I thought of the first play I did here was for the Vancouver Little Theater and it was Bundy pulls of strings and it was broad Scottish I had a broads Scottish accent at the time so I got this part of this this little girl in in this in Bundy puls of strings and the opening night was Pearl Harbor and there was blackout here and the thing was did we go would anyone turn up because there were no lights for driving across and you couldn't turn the lights the car lights on but you know we got in the car we got in somebody's car and we went over to the East end where the Vancouver Little Theater was and everybody was there the cast was there and the audience was there and they'd come from Victoria to see it and and and we did it when you say what was it like full of I remember that I just remember that I I I did this I had was taking elocution again as I did in Glasgow from a Anne Mossman here and her brother was playing the lead in Bounty puls the strings and I was playing this and and so there was no difference it was um I mean they expected this Coast to be bombed and in terms of Navy personel or food shortages or none of that or Well we'd come from Scotland where we you know we were and when we crossed Canada um we thought we came back to Canada because my father's pensions came from Canada he was in the Canadian Army and he was a a minister of the United Church and those two pensions are what we lived on and uh so my mother decided for two reasons one the monetary reason but also there if she stayed in Scotland her life was done she was a widow she wear a black armband the rest of her life and that her life was over so she wasn't going to have that happen so she came back to Canada where they had been happiest and and she had a sister in Vancouver so we crossed the country as we crossed the country the Sterling area closed behind us we never saw any of the pensions or any of my the savings uh until the war was over well long after the war was over when you say Sterling area you mean the pound ster Sterling yeah Pearl more pounds left Britain Therefore your P come right and and the pensions went into Scotland and stayed there and uh so we arrived in Vancouver on the seven uh pounds that we were allowed each managed to get across the country and here and then my mother went to work as a nurse for some somebody somebody's office and I had a paper route and we managed it was it was harder than if we'd stayed where we were and was it blackouts yeah and my mother knew all about that you see well not the way we had in Scotland but but she knew that and she became part of the what was it called VIP van it was it was the people who would tell the people what to do when we were bombed and she knew cuz she'd been on the street in in Glasgow so she knew what to do you had it it it when I remember reading what I had to do you had to you had to take when if there was a bomb there you had you had to take a a blanket or a sheet like this and approach the bomb and threw it over the bomb shovel sand on it wouldn't have done any good but we didn't have any bombs anyway Vancouver and the Japanese Canadian population Pearl Harbor what did you as a young Norwegian Canadian how how did you see that well we didn't we didn't know uh I was in I was at Kitana high school and uh one day we went to school and there were empty seats nobody told us what had happened it was ages before we knew that it was because we never thought of them as being Japanese they were people we went to school with and they were taken into the interior you know and we learned about that much later when everybody else did V Day what happened in V day and uh I was going to an elocution person and and I remember think I can see exactly where I was I was walking towards the house where I went for my lesson and I remember thinking today is so important that I'm amazed that the color of the sky hasn't changed and the color of the earth hasn't changed you know like first time you cross a border a major border into um France or Switzerland or something you you expect the Earth to change color I remember thinking that that there should be some phenomenal sight that says the world has changed that's all I remember is just that one thing and just point of curiosity what about Hiroshima and Nagasaki were you aware of the the end of the Japanese war the war in Japan and the atom bomb or was that just part of a teenager's periphery no no no that no that was our that was our um 911 the opposite of like 911 for was Dreadful thing Dreadful thing and how would you I don't know where I was for that though I don't remember where I was and I don't remember who I talked to about it but I know we did I know it was Dreadful way but the word was some we dropped an atom bomb or a major new weapon or the Americans did it's typically Canadian I think to say well it wasn't us that did it wasn't me with Canadian uranium from sasat yes exactly very hard no I don't I don't remember I remember keeping my feet on the road I was on the thrilling road I was on as far as the theater and going to summer school of the theater and going classes at UBC and stuff and keeping myself there not safe exactly but where' you go you go you go deeper and you go to what you know is good but um no I don't have the same you obviously have much clearer memory well it was you know I was well I wasn't born at the time but you weren't born but but in thinking about it and thinking if i' had been there yeah yeah what impact would that made on know see we didn't know things the way we do now instantly we didn't know till long after really um and do you remember anything about the again total pure personal curiosity here as as the japanes jaese Canad Japanese Canadians returned from the internment camps back to Vancouver was would one be aware of any of that living in Vancouver at the time in very personal terms they were our friends they you know and they went and and the the terrible impact for me was much later when I realized that their art had just been wiped out I mean I found do you remember Alan Barlo I remember Alan Marlo finding um a fabulous he he he would he could cross a street in Montreal and pass a shop and get a vibration of something that was in that shop and get off on the next stop and go back and say uh show me that W that you've got in the W window what do you think it is and it would turn out to be a medieval letter from a medieval alphabet you know and he found some ja Japanese work that had been taken and sold and appeared in Montreal in somebody's shop he had a an Exquisite thing and was aching achingly sad about it but he was looking after it was a very fragile thing was a a woman playing pipe Alan Barlo just is was a designer right a theater designer I do want to point out just because you're sitting here the other one other piece of Brilliance in that year of theater school that you ran that I was in one of the other most fruitful excises was you chose Alan Barlo a designer to direct a seconde exercise of country wife no I can't remember was a restoration and you had him as a designer direct us acting students and what he gave me as a designer he opened the door in the 18th century for me not through a history point of you but through Aesthetics and I blessed you for the rest of my life because his his uh combination of Aesthetics in terms of costume of hair of makeup of of snuff of this of that opened a period to me that could not have been open any other way and he was keeping me alive through your Greek exercise because we were talking he was incredible on the Greeks he would say when it came to chorus the the the basis of chorus was hysteria that you had to Tap The Well of Hysteria in order to get a chorus piece there um I remember him using the word and being startled and I know now that you're bringing it up that he was there for me when I first went there and that he was feeding me uh we were talking about doing I think he was the one that encouraged me to do it yeah great man dear man marvelous artist | Canada's Theatre Museum | UCVVjtORYr4scMKyLzrx4RfA | 2011-06-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,724 | 8,487 |
FDa-FLdy_mA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDa-FLdy_mA | Burton Dassett | Maria La Chica | UK Scrap Addicts | [Music] hello everyone it's Maria with you today and thank you so much for joining me on another video for UK scrap addict's so this month's theme is to use one single six by four photo and as you can see I just cut my photo from like an a4 piece of of paper basically I don't print photos and on your usual way of sending them to print I have an a4 printer at home and what I do I just copy my photos into a word document and from there I just print them so by doing that I can resize them and basically print as many as I want in in one sheet of a4 the downside of that is that I don't normally pay much attention at the size so I don't know if I fir to say four or 3x3 I don't know so this photo was one of the ones that resembled more of the size so I measured there with my ruler and then I trimmed it a bit and as you can see I also then mat it on a white piece of cardstock because I like my photos to have a white edge so now as you can see I've just cut those little white flowers they are from a quite an old pack buyer or was the lady's name the lady who does some project life who Hey Dude hey D yeah hey do swap is it I think that's her name yeah hey D swap so she did she had that this LASIK at flowers and I've been saving this for quite a long time and and I decided that it was time to use them now I've also taken a bit of acrylic white paint and drawn like her as you can see they're like a little square because the coloring in my foot is quite brown and and the wood background it's also quite dark and brown so by putting this white frame with the pain de gives a bit more contrast and just as I was going to glue down my photo I noticed you know what this needs a tiny extra so maybe some papers and these two just happen to be on my desk from earlier in the month during a national scrapbooking day and I decided to just cup a couple of pieces and and use it I'm just gluing my flowers I'm not using just normal wet glue nothing just no more PVA because he's going tucked under the photo anyway so it's not going to go anywhere and I will also be fussy cutting these flowers nothing special just so I'm speeding up a bit normal because there's nothing to see here just fussy cutting and it this technique is something I've done a few times now in the past them I've done like a big floral background and then layered smaller flowers on top and I quite really like how this comes out I will be using foam to bring a tiny bit of dimension to some of the flowers so yeah this is the basis of my layout and from now on I'm just gonna be doing the title and the journaling and a few embellishments so what can I tell you this photo it's a it's quite funny though because it's my kids with the cousin and I've done quite a few layouts of them and I've run out of titles like I've done the three amigos I've done like all kind of titles relating to three of them and but this one I just wanted to just go for the name of the place and as you can see here I'm really struggling to find alphas where I've got all the letters for the title and and I go through all my alphas and I thought I had enough for these ones but I didn't so I end up going to to my faithful these black alphas I've had like three or four packs of these ones but now and really love them they're not super special but they it is a nice font and so I don't mind using them a lot in my in my layouts so the title is Burton dassit which is where the photo was taken and a place near my in-laws where we go quite often and we fly kites and stuff live and the kids love it there because they are allowed to run up and down the hill and this day however was very very windy that's why the three kids are just against their world trying to be sheltered from the wind as you can see now I'm adding a tiny bit of glue to the to the office and it's something that really really does my heading when something is supposed to be self-adhesive or to have already glue and and then that glue is absolutely rubbish I have gone through my albums recently I was looking at them with my daughter and I noticed a few offers here and there that had just fallen off to the bottom of the page protector ID oh I hate it so from when I'm when I realized that from then on I am always adding an extra bit of glue to today to the office unless I know that the officer I'm using our this the sticky is quite good but for this once I knew I had to add a tiny bit more so as you can see I'm adding my journaling I'm telling you the story I just told you about of going to Burton that's it and it was windy and all of that but we had a good day a day at the end and now I'm just looking for a little label or attack or something like that yeah I go for this one's for the date and I know the date because it was Mother's Day this year and which happened to be my my mother-in-law's birthday so we went up to see them and just a couple of finishing touches I'm gonna add a couple of these enameled shapes I only had one blue so I only did that little bit rather than haven't done another cluster on the other side and a few the sequence and that is it thank you for joining me guys I hope you have enjoyed this video and I hope you'll join me again on UK scrap addicts on Facebook and YouTube on Instagram cheers bye [Music] you | UK Scrap Addicts | UCd20e8drYh_JbDFGclRnDkw | 2018-06-01 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,102 | 5,285 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.