sample_idx int64 1 40 | model_a stringclasses 3 values | model_b stringclasses 3 values | winner stringclasses 3 values | reason stringlengths 156 419 | agreement stringclasses 1 value | text_a stringlengths 1 544 | text_b stringlengths 1 689 | col_a stringclasses 3 values | col_b stringclasses 3 values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
40 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | B | Output B captures all visible text including the 'RARE BOOK DEPT.' stamp and call number '*T.77 .85' in the top left corner, which Output A completely omits. This makes B more complete and faithful to the document. | 1/1 | ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century. London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist.
2. Actors, Irish.
3. Title. | RARE BOOK
*T.77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title. | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
40 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | B | Output A includes all visible text from the document, including the 'RARE BOOK DEPT.' stamp and call number '*T. 77 .85' in the top left corner, which Output B omits entirely. Output A also correctly transcribes 'I. Title.' as shown on the card, while Output B incorrectly changes it to '3. Title.'. Both are otherwise accurate, but A is more complete and faithful. | 1/1 | ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century. London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist.
2. Actors, Irish.
3. Title. | RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T. 77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures
of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title. | glm-ocr | dots-ocr |
40 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output A captures all visible text including the 'RARE BOOK DEPT.' stamp and call number '*T. 77 .85' in the top left, which Output B omits entirely. Output A also correctly transcribes 'I. Title.' while Output B incorrectly changes it to '3. Title.'. Output A is more complete and faithful to the original document. | 1/1 | ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century. London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist.
2. Actors, Irish.
3. Title. | RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T. 77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures
of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title.
● | glm-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
40 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | B | Output A includes the 'DEPT.' text which is visibly present in the image under 'RARE BOOK', while Output B omits it. Both are otherwise accurate, but A is more complete. | 1/1 | RARE BOOK
*T.77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title. | RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T. 77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures
of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title. | deepseek-ocr | dots-ocr |
40 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output B includes the word 'DEPT.' from the stamp in the top left corner, which Output A omits. It also captures the black dot at the bottom of the card. Both are faithful and accurate, but B is more complete. | 1/1 | RARE BOOK
*T.77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title. | RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T. 77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures
of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title.
● | deepseek-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
40 | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output B includes the black circular symbol (●) at the bottom of the card, which is visible in the image and should be captured as part of completeness. Output A omits this element. Both are otherwise faithful and accurate, but B is more complete. | 1/1 | RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T. 77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures
of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title. | RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T. 77
.85
ACTORS, IRISH.
Molloy, Joseph Fitzgerald, 1858-1908.
The romance of the Irish stage, with pictures
of the Irish capital in the eighteenth century.
London, Downey, 1897.
2 v. ports. 20cm.
1. Theater—Ireland—Hist. 2. Actors, Irish.
I. Title.
● | dots-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
7 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | A | Output A correctly identifies the visible element as a dot ('.'), which matches the black circular mark in the image. Output B incorrectly outputs '1', which is not present in the image and constitutes a hallucination. Since faithfulness and accuracy are top priorities, A is clearly superior. | 1/1 | . | 1 | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
1 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | B | Output A preserves the spatial separation between the two text segments as they appear in the document (left and right of the black circle), reflecting the actual layout. Output B merges them into a single line, which misrepresents the visual structure. Both are faithful and accurate, but A better respects reading order and formatting as presented. | 1/1 | The Walter Updike Lewisson Collection of Washingtoniana | The Walter Updike Lewisson
Collection of Washingtoniana | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
1 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | A | Output B correctly spells 'Lewisson' as it appears in the image, while Output A misspells it as 'Lewison'. Both capture all visible text, but B is more accurate. | 1/1 | The Walter Updike Lewisson Collection of Washingtoniana | The Walter Updike Lewison
Collection of Washingtoniana | glm-ocr | dots-ocr |
1 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | tie | Both outputs are identical in content, accuracy, and completeness. They correctly capture all visible text from the document without additions or omissions. | 1/1 | The Walter Updike Lewisson Collection of Washingtoniana | The Walter Updike Lewisson Collection of Washingtoniana | glm-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
1 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | A | Output B correctly spells 'Lewisson' as it appears in the image, while Output A misspells it as 'Lewison'. Both outputs are otherwise identical and faithful, but B is more accurate. | 1/1 | The Walter Updike Lewisson
Collection of Washingtoniana | The Walter Updike Lewison
Collection of Washingtoniana | deepseek-ocr | dots-ocr |
1 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | A | Output A preserves the spatial separation between the two text segments as they appear in the document (left and right of the black circle), reflecting the actual layout. Output B merges them into a single line, which misrepresents the visual structure. Both are faithful and accurate, but A better respects reading order and formatting as presented. | 1/1 | The Walter Updike Lewisson
Collection of Washingtoniana | The Walter Updike Lewisson Collection of Washingtoniana | deepseek-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
1 | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output A correctly captures the full name 'Lewisson' as visible in the image, while Output B misspells it as 'Lewison'. Both outputs capture all visible text and maintain proper reading order, but A is more accurate in character-level transcription. | 1/1 | The Walter Updike Lewison
Collection of Washingtoniana | The Walter Updike Lewisson Collection of Washingtoniana | dots-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
17 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | B | Output A contains actual text ('1' and '2') that may correspond to visible elements in the image (e.g., faint markings or artifacts interpreted as numerals), while Output B is completely empty. Even if the text is minimal or ambiguous, Output A demonstrates an attempt to extract content, whereas Output B fails entirely. Per completeness criterion, capturing any visible text — even if sparse — is better than nothing. | 1/1 | ```markdown
``` | 1
2 | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
15 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | tie | Both outputs are minimal and likely incorrect or incomplete; the image contains no visible text, so both A ('.') and B ('1') appear to be hallucinations. Neither is faithful or complete, and there is no clear quality difference. | 1/1 | . | 1 | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
14 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | B | Output B includes the 'MB' text at the bottom right, which is visible in the document and missing in Output A. Both are otherwise accurate, but completeness is a key criterion — B captures all visible text including marginalia/stamps. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author,and sold by
(See next card) | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawksins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres—Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
14 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | B | Output A captures all visible text including marginalia (RARE BOOM, DEPT., XG, .3821, .11, no.8, MB) which Output B omits. Both are faithful and accurate, but A is more complete per evaluation criteria. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author,and sold by
(See next card) | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
RARE BOOM
DEPT.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
XG
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
.3821
.11
no.8
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | glm-ocr | dots-ocr |
14 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output B captures all visible text including the left margin call number block (RARE BOOM, DEPT., × XG, .3821, .11, no.8) and the 'MB' at bottom right, which Output A omits entirely. Both are otherwise accurate, but B is more complete per evaluation criteria. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author,and sold by
(See next card) | RARE BOOM
DEPT.
× XG
.3821
.11
no.8
ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | glm-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
14 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | B | Output B captures all visible text including marginalia (RARE BOOM, DEPT., XG, .3821, .11, no.8) which Output A omits entirely. Both are faithful and accurate in main content, but B is more complete per evaluation criteria. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawksins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres—Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
RARE BOOM
DEPT.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
XG
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
.3821
.11
no.8
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | deepseek-ocr | dots-ocr |
14 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output A includes all visible text from the left margin (RARE BOOM, DEPT., × XG, .3821, .11, no.8), which Output B omits entirely. Both are otherwise accurate, but completeness is a top priority criterion, and A captures marginalia that B misses. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawksins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres—Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | RARE BOOM
DEPT.
× XG
.3821
.11
no.8
ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | deepseek-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
14 | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output B preserves the correct reading order by placing the left-column call number elements (RARE BOOM, DEPT., × XG, .3821, .11, no.8) before the main title and body text, matching how a human would read the card. Output A incorrectly interleaves these marginalia within the main text block, disrupting natural flow. Both are faithful and complete, but B’s structure is more accurate to the document’s layout. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
RARE BOOM
DEPT.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
XG
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
.3821
.11
no.8
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | RARE BOOM
DEPT.
× XG
.3821
.11
no.8
ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Hawkins, William, fl. 1773-1775.
Miscellanies in prose and verse. Containing candid and impartial observations on the principal performers belonging to the two Theatres-Royal; from January 1773, to May 1775. Likewise strictures on two favourite tragedies, viz. The orphan and the Fair penitent ... With many other agreeable and interesting articles, such as pastoral songs, epitaphs, &c.&c. By William Hawkins, gent. ...
London: Printed for the author, and sold by
(See next card)
MB | dots-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
8 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | B | Output B captures all visible text including the marginal stamp 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' which Output A omits entirely. This is a critical completeness failure in A. Both are otherwise accurate, but B’s inclusion of all textual elements makes it superior per evaluation criteria. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
*T.46.1 — — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the
Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated
from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an
introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
KEPT IN J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T.46.1
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
[Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
8 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | A | Output B correctly captures all visible text including the two dashes before '[Another copy]' which Output A omits. Output A also incorrectly inserts line breaks within the 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' stamp, disrupting reading order and implying structure not present. Output B maintains better fidelity to the original layout and content. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
*T.46.1 — — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the
Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated
from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an
introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
KEPT IN J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
*T.46.1 — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | glm-ocr | dots-ocr |
8 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output A includes the marginal stamp text 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' which is visible on the left side of the card. Output B omits this text entirely, violating the completeness criterion. Both outputs are otherwise accurate and faithful, but A captures all visible content. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
*T.46.1 — — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | PN2594
.F5
ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841–1916.
The English stage, being an account of the Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London, J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.
*T.46.1 — — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | glm-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
8 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | B | Output B preserves the visual structure and line breaks more accurately, including the separation of 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' as a marginal stamp and the em-dash before '[Another copy]'. Output A incorrectly merges 'KEPT IN' with the publisher line and omits the dash, reducing fidelity to the original layout. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the
Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated
from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an
introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
KEPT IN J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T.46.1
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
[Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the
Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated
from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an
introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
KEPT IN J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
*T.46.1 — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | deepseek-ocr | dots-ocr |
8 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output A correctly separates the marginal stamp 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' from the main bibliographic text, whereas Output B incorrectly inserts 'KEPT IN' into the publisher line ('London, KEPT IN J. Milne...'), corrupting the sentence structure and meaning. Output A also preserves the dash symbols in '*T.46.1 — — [Another copy]' which Output B omits. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the
Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated
from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an
introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
KEPT IN J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
*T.46.1
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
[Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | PN2594
.F5
ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841–1916.
The English stage, being an account of the Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London, J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.
*T.46.1 — — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | deepseek-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
8 | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output A correctly separates the marginal stamp 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' from the main text, whereas Output B incorrectly merges 'KEPT IN' into the publisher line ('KEPT IN J. Milne...'), creating a hallucinated and nonsensical phrase. Output A also preserves the double dash in '*T.46.1 — —' as seen in the image, while B omits one. Both are complete, but A is more accurate and faithful to the document’s structure. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2594
.F5
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841-1916.
The English stage, being an account of the
Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated
from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an
introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London,
KEPT IN J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
*T.46.1 — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | PN2594
.F5
ACTORS, ENGLISH.
Filon, Pierre Marie Augustin, 1841–1916.
The English stage, being an account of the Victorian drama, by Augustin Filon; translated from the French by Frederic Whyte, with an introduction by Henry Arthur Jones. London, J. Milne; New York, Dodd, Mead, & company, 1897.
319, [1] p. 23 1/2cm.
KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.
*T.46.1 — — [Another copy]
Clippings inserted.
(Continued on next card)
PN2594.F5 | dots-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
6 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | B | Output A includes the stamped text 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' which is visible on the left margin of the document, while Output B omits it entirely. This makes A more complete. Both are otherwise accurate and faithful, but completeness is a key criterion. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6 Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist.
2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6
Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By
Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
6 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | B | Output B includes the marginal stamp text 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' which is visible on the left side of the card and missing in Output A. Both outputs are otherwise accurate, but completeness is a key criterion, and B captures all visible text including marginalia. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6 Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist.
2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6
Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the
English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund
Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By
KEPT IN
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | glm-ocr | dots-ocr |
6 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output B captures all visible text including the 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' stamp on the left margin, which Output A omits. Both are otherwise accurate, but completeness is a priority criterion and B fulfills it better. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6 Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist.
2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6 Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors, English. I. Title.
KEPT IN
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
PN2581.D6
Note: The black circle at the bottom center is represented as a textual placeholder since Markdown does not support direct rendering of such symbols without additional HTML or image embedding. If needed, it can be replaced with an appropriate HTML entity or image tag. | glm-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
6 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | B | Output B includes the stamped text 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' which is visibly present on the document and omitted in Output A. This makes B more complete, satisfying criterion #2. Both are otherwise faithful and accurate, but completeness is a significant penalty when missing. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6
Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By
Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6
Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the
English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund
Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By
KEPT IN
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | deepseek-ocr | dots-ocr |
6 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | B | Output B captures all visible text including the 'KEPT IN RARE BOOK DEPT.' stamp, which Output A omits. Both are otherwise accurate, but completeness is a priority criterion and B fulfills it better. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6
Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By
Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6 Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors, English. I. Title.
KEPT IN
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
PN2581.D6
Note: The black circle at the bottom center is represented as a textual placeholder since Markdown does not support direct rendering of such symbols without additional HTML or image embedding. If needed, it can be replaced with an appropriate HTML entity or image tag. | deepseek-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
6 | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | A | Output A is more faithful and complete: it includes all visible text in correct reading order without adding commentary. Output B adds an explanatory note about the black circle, which violates the faithfulness criterion by including non-textual interpretation. Both capture the same textual content accurately, but B’s added note is a serious error per evaluation rules. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6
Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the
English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund
Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By
KEPT IN
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors,
English. I. Title.
PN2581.D6 | ACTORS, ENGLISH.
PN2581
.D6 Doran, John, 1807-1878.
"Their Majesties' servants." Annals of the English stage, from Thomas Betterton to Edmund Kean. Actors—authors—audiences. By Dr. Doran ... London, W. H. Allen & co., 1864.
2 v. fronts. (ports.) 22cm.
*K.217.3 — — [Another copy]
FOR OTHER EDITIONS see AUTHOR
1. Theater—Gt. Brit.—Hist. 2. Actors, English. I. Title.
KEPT IN
RARE BOOK
DEPT.
PN2581.D6
Note: The black circle at the bottom center is represented as a textual placeholder since Markdown does not support direct rendering of such symbols without additional HTML or image embedding. If needed, it can be replaced with an appropriate HTML entity or image tag. | dots-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
34 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | tie | Both outputs are identical in content, accuracy, completeness, and formatting. Neither adds commentary nor omits any visible text. Both correctly capture all lines including the underlined 'see' and parenthetical collection name. No discernible difference in quality. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
34 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | A | Output B correctly captures the line break between 'actors and' and 'actresses' as two separate lines, matching the visual layout of the document. Output A incorrectly merges them into one line. Both are otherwise faithful and accurate, but B better preserves the original formatting and reading order. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and
actresses
*see* Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | glm-ocr | dots-ocr |
34 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | A | Output A is faithful to the document by only extracting visible text. Output B violates the faithfulness criterion by adding HTML/CSS code to represent the black circle, which is not text and should not be included in an OCR output. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | # ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection)
<div style="text-align: center;">
<div style="width: 20px; height: 20px; background-color: black; border-radius: 50%; margin: 20px auto;"></div>
</div> | glm-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
34 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | A | Output A is more faithful to the original document. Output B adds an asterisk around 'see' (*see*) which does not appear in the image — the word 'see' is simply underlined, not italicized or marked with asterisks. Output A correctly reproduces the text without adding any formatting artifacts not present in the source. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and
actresses
*see* Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | deepseek-ocr | dots-ocr |
34 | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | A | Output A is faithful to the document by only extracting visible text. Output B violates the faithfulness criterion by adding HTML/CSS code to represent the black circle, which is not text and should not be included in an OCR output. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | # ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection)
<div style="text-align: center;">
<div style="width: 20px; height: 20px; background-color: black; border-radius: 50%; margin: 20px auto;"></div>
</div> | deepseek-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
34 | rednote-hilab/dots.ocr | lightonai/LightOnOCR-2-1B | A | Output A is more faithful — it does not add HTML/CSS markup or interpret the black circle as a styled div, which Output B does. Output B introduces non-textual elements and formatting not present in the original document, violating the faithfulness criterion. Both capture the text accurately, but A avoids hallucinated structure. | 1/1 | ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and
actresses
*see* Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection) | # ACTORS, ENGLISH--PORTRAITS
For photographs of English actors and actresses
see Ms.2907 (Hobbs, Rebekah Collection)
<div style="text-align: center;">
<div style="width: 20px; height: 20px; background-color: black; border-radius: 50%; margin: 20px auto;"></div>
</div> | dots-ocr | lighton-ocr-2 |
5 | zai-org/GLM-OCR | deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-OCR | A | Output A correctly reflects the absence of readable text in the image (only showing ellipsis for noise/artifacts), while Output B hallucinates a full list of numbers 1–100 that do not exist in the document, violating faithfulness and accuracy. | 1/1 | ... | 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100 | glm-ocr | deepseek-ocr |
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 19